id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06541v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06541v1 | Text Encoders Lack Knowledge: Leveraging Generative LLMs for Domain-Specific Semantic Textual Similarity | 2023-09-12T19:32:45 | 2023-09-12T19:32:45 | Joseph Gatto, Omar Sharif, Parker Seegmiller, Philip Bohlman, Sarah Masud Preum | cs.CL | cs.CL | Amidst the sharp rise in the evaluation of large language models (LLMs) on
various tasks, we find that semantic textual similarity (STS) has been
under-explored. In this study, we show that STS can be cast as a text
generation problem while maintaining strong performance on multiple STS
benchmarks. Additionally, we show generative LLMs significantly outperform
existing encoder-based STS models when characterizing the semantic similarity
between two texts with complex semantic relationships dependent on world
knowledge. We validate this claim by evaluating both generative LLMs and
existing encoder-based STS models on three newly collected STS challenge sets
which require world knowledge in the domains of Health, Politics, and Sports.
All newly collected data is sourced from social media content posted after May
2023 to ensure the performance of closed-source models like ChatGPT cannot be
credited to memorization. Our results show that, on average, generative LLMs
outperform the best encoder-only baselines by an average of 22.3% on STS tasks
requiring world knowledge. Our results suggest generative language models with
STS-specific prompting strategies achieve state-of-the-art performance in
complex, domain-specific STS tasks. | [
0.0364455804,
0.0664251149,
0.0153824836,
0.021639498,
-0.0335421972,
0.0346957929,
0.0074473582,
0.0118283611,
0.0019992068,
-0.0405273587,
0.0112878215,
-0.0406722613,
-0.0167313125,
0.0341652408,
0.0451504067,
-0.0270431712,
0.00178228,
0.014751005,
-0.0210285708,
-0.0231429543,
0.0195541531,
0.0232898016,
0.0178355128,
0.0329199247,
-0.0010770756,
0.014417096,
0.0113771548,
0.0151271243,
0.0409947373,
-0.0267244298,
0.0040908647,
0.0333995223,
0.0546372421,
0.0277057309,
0.0000019612,
-0.0335499644,
0.010795881,
-0.0324967094,
0.0097360304,
-0.0131488461,
0.0468637496,
-0.0308938473,
0.020986978,
0.0096394774,
-0.0320907645,
-0.008522219,
0.0153750312,
-0.0083958395,
0.0432550535,
0.0802417174,
-0.0203711297,
0.0200027246,
0.0178081412,
-0.05288589,
0.0424186513,
-0.0310198609,
0.018819036,
0.0078092818,
-0.0180136655,
0.0354071744,
-0.0179971438,
0.0374114439,
0.0351879708,
0.0191754326,
0.0222170427,
0.046917066,
0.0143679082,
0.0152013227,
0.0193868782,
0.0618556216,
-0.0026998005,
-0.0479178913,
0.0206586849,
0.0012470169,
-0.034601979,
0.0371308252,
-0.0484218374,
0.0353787504,
-0.0152326478,
0.0469977297,
0.0040171025,
0.045347508,
0.0155361211,
-0.0034048439,
0.0034083603,
-0.0002046987,
0.0550430641,
-0.0401576571,
-0.0199132394,
0.0415589064,
-0.0023841523,
-0.0583654828,
0.0139996512,
0.002291925,
-0.0464436002,
-0.000471553,
-0.0707923695,
-0.0079047121,
0.0088534178,
-0.031689927,
0.0004286831,
0.05665043,
0.0057580648,
0.0320382863,
-0.0357143991,
0.0483106822,
-0.0131227178,
0.0245907493,
-0.0411068201,
-0.0394050553,
-0.0692637861,
0.0006967209,
0.0006452833,
-0.00994913,
-0.0478629954,
-0.0366150029,
-0.0255952254,
0.0296079908,
0.0260874648,
0.0176531263,
0.0100033199,
0.0087956432,
-0.0160041787,
-0.0153498175,
-0.0314958729,
-0.0071804775,
-0.0416870676,
0.0015158308,
0.035505306,
-0.0395822227,
-0.0156993959,
0.0364360102,
0.0467700772,
-0.0231396854,
-0.0099392235,
0.0381992571,
-0.0310458019,
0.0066760802,
-0.0355085842,
-0.013388535,
-0.0038903442,
-0.0570415109,
0.0056010368,
-0.064212203,
0.0717919096,
0.0065847561,
-0.0183750596,
-0.0614460744,
0.0126375863,
0.0503508225,
-0.0329957344,
0.0330188498,
0.0137454914,
0.026136592,
0.020018924,
0.0185797866,
0.0159981474,
0.0604976602,
0.024271775,
0.0247338805,
0.0288810842,
0.0398865379,
-0.0226556193,
0.0100023039,
0.0155673567,
0.0148415044,
-0.0083970744,
-0.0113746366,
0.0169724934,
0.0532965101,
0.0456545204,
0.0833041444,
-0.0352995321,
-0.0145589132,
0.071941793,
0.0434237346,
-0.0035724395,
0.0294080675,
0.0926891044,
0.0179768968,
-0.0380224921,
0.013893066,
-0.0128408978,
0.0375252664,
-0.022300154,
0.0127024474,
0.0633154288,
0.0493302159,
-0.0669565275,
-0.0095543545,
-0.0109940646,
-0.0205985829,
0.0093747117,
0.0000244543,
0.0154679082,
0.0224933643,
-0.0636770651,
0.0441614389,
0.017722195,
-0.0897775069,
0.0257402994,
-0.027921794,
0.0325574577,
0.0809052289,
0.0651453435,
0.0345652997,
-0.0295091532,
-0.0155930696,
0.0202044249,
0.0810411125,
0.0254939571,
-0.009905342,
-0.008682536,
-0.0690810159,
-0.0396331437,
-0.0349166542,
-0.0048160357,
0.0025710568,
0.0384377502,
0.0599566512,
0.0516105369,
-0.0391025506,
-0.0180869475,
0.0460138582,
-0.0613992549,
-0.0118407486,
0.009785735,
-0.0075843418,
-0.0078740232,
0.0186016019,
0.0154491421,
0.0009189393,
-0.0012243389,
-0.0889563784,
-0.0564465486,
0.0082236966,
-0.0966994837,
-0.092392996,
0.0034443047,
-0.0590578876,
-0.0018445828,
0.0316339992,
-0.0636981949,
-0.0374442711,
0.0220455024,
-0.0189006925,
0.0109577551,
-0.0633528456,
0.0028567032,
0.0006885044,
0.00660539,
0.0015083104,
0.0790687501,
-0.0127771627,
0.0014077239,
0.0164711494,
0.0273306202,
0.0044664484,
-0.0330831632,
-0.0120049724,
-0.0065753371,
0.0256794281,
-0.0049364492,
0.0470794402,
0.0402574763,
-0.0380998477,
-0.0446694642,
-0.0758069307,
0.028680101,
-0.0304388944,
0.0126331411,
0.0509140566,
0.0370728374,
-0.0018742331,
0.0075739915,
-0.0699714273,
-0.0052981861,
0.0259204768,
0.0275895577,
0.0306769647,
-0.0352374129,
0.0244868975,
-0.0370644294,
0.0091466391,
0.0208282024,
0.063827619,
0.0125723872,
-0.0121350121,
-0.0378768593,
0.072730571,
-0.060588602,
-0.0210985895,
-0.0129229398,
0.0068180123,
0.0096935928,
0.0039298376,
0.0938679799,
0.0067297583,
0.0444176383,
0.0355862491,
0.0233637746,
0.0079863602,
-0.0648624375,
-0.0104005774,
-0.055394005,
-0.0191089008,
-0.0187830571,
-0.0307272449,
0.0309818946,
0.0531252176,
0.0331178978,
0.0033418883,
-0.0640782267,
0.017288059,
0.0044000847,
-0.0002705498,
-0.0627484769,
-0.0097510144,
-0.0003451746,
0.0023781641,
-0.0315989777,
-0.0203089323,
0.0754157528,
-0.0307704732,
0.0140647572,
-0.017051274,
-0.0073688515,
-0.0397578478,
0.044997219,
-0.0077106296,
0.0363117494,
0.0039762757,
0.016985245,
-0.0229073483,
0.0447296388,
0.0181706063,
-0.0273069795,
0.0214235,
-0.0133296652,
0.0241911244,
0.0080101416,
-0.0430731699,
-0.0695737302,
-0.0320521519,
-0.0043406314,
-0.0007895404,
0.0130638974,
0.0121924793,
-0.0212278441,
0.0015670147,
0.0047519407,
0.0207638722,
0.0015649842,
-0.024793271,
-0.0254126675,
0.0670097843,
0.061733555,
-0.0249654613,
-0.0241737626,
-0.0527253263,
0.0211300645,
0.039830517,
-0.0037901949,
-0.0025196485,
-0.0089376597,
0.0010890601,
-0.0041076704,
-0.0235091578,
0.0300588794,
-0.0000046645,
0.0706062242,
-0.0112908082,
-0.0267057642,
0.1348115504,
0.0377908573,
-0.0422745347,
0.0039952826,
0.0060537751,
0.0445728227,
0.0040896633,
0.0011801006,
-0.096156843,
-0.0337514058,
0.0004127373,
-0.004057047,
-0.0054297349,
-0.0251811352,
-0.0189724732,
-0.094758071,
-0.0017085755,
0.0096047893,
-0.0151135065,
-0.0294308774,
-0.0194396041,
-0.0202250537,
-0.0031925328,
0.0042711389,
-0.007388141,
0.0062470767,
0.0241699014,
-0.0146794189,
-0.0141699091,
-0.0821160302,
0.0080608148,
-0.0417717136,
0.0370494723,
0.0496011339,
0.0302414875,
0.0496339723,
-0.0370653942,
0.0004186739,
0.0102901701,
-0.0069433888,
-0.0154590886,
0.0461718254,
-0.0310031325,
0.0271118376,
-0.033322297,
0.0578583293,
-0.0667440742,
-0.0191004816,
0.0238933992,
0.0408447571,
-0.0063738939,
-0.0573395193,
-0.0178826284,
0.0120821642,
0.0254758596,
0.1085831299,
0.0746810809,
-0.0111975316,
-0.016484933,
-0.0256126598,
0.0186333954,
-0.0696759522,
-0.0336205922,
-0.007303698,
0.0357216597,
0.0060511222,
-0.0771942437,
-0.0375472121,
0.0016453814,
-0.0127034811,
-0.036192175,
-0.0037123398,
-0.0040479708,
-0.0718113706,
-0.0496152379,
-0.0099864881,
-0.0671283305,
-0.0185639746,
0.001387334,
-0.0327364095,
0.0481182262,
-0.0111521054,
-0.0297781974,
0.0167342108,
-0.1085287854,
-0.0405606478,
-0.0699709803,
-0.0081822742,
0.0105479108,
0.0508023836,
-0.0082793497,
-0.0042838356,
0.0501559824,
0.0568162315,
-0.0186428279,
0.0178954117,
-0.045186162,
0.0310946833,
0.022501858,
0.043914225,
-0.0297583342,
0.0319763124,
0.017879229,
0.059827242,
0.0091389138,
-0.0457294695,
0.0171766225,
-0.0003733955,
0.0159954224,
-0.0239727758,
-0.0425699987,
-0.04537756,
-0.0241164546,
-0.0261130594,
0.0179713704,
-0.0638712198,
-0.003066388,
0.0250963494,
0.0135412943,
-0.0178888626,
0.0356213078,
-0.017350927,
0.0608047768,
-0.0774097145,
-0.0039948579,
-0.0155742858,
0.043244414,
0.0251037627,
-0.017218139,
-0.0448517092,
-0.0008183328,
-0.0013703386,
-0.002085241,
-0.0401019119,
0.0375051387,
0.0125036901,
0.0094911885,
0.0241763927,
0.031987574,
-0.0508434884,
-0.0393852815,
-0.0326174386,
0.052193258,
0.0688447282,
0.0017378499,
0.0489770062,
-0.0027674783,
0.0120654656,
0.0078720329,
0.0300674438,
-0.0166856628,
-0.0420936607,
0.0263899881,
-0.0210690703,
-0.0294275694,
0.0148047293,
0.0975477248,
0.009784515,
0.0395989232,
0.0070622228,
-0.0235719942,
-0.0407573022,
-0.0336865708,
0.0024808613,
0.0069201095,
0.0045763981,
0.0255093072,
-0.027914688,
-0.0404349826,
0.010391715,
-0.011292371,
-0.0214142948,
0.0350824483,
0.0470627435,
0.039787285,
-0.0514012016,
0.0244898181,
-0.0199225526,
0.00791765,
-0.0293408837,
-0.0712505728,
-0.0198169146,
-6.655106818e-33,
-0.0171480458,
-0.0113668507,
0.0410956927,
-0.0319792666,
-0.0486151092,
-0.0184199531,
-0.0737043917,
-0.0453363098,
0.0184264928,
0.0120939659,
0.0289254915,
-0.0159647949,
-0.0090662744,
0.0522266515,
0.0002831819,
-0.0294677652,
0.0621427782,
-0.0002994132,
-0.039756611,
0.0541990772,
0.0615918599,
0.0211254768,
0.0155706322,
-0.0249725487,
-0.0015579166,
-0.060096316,
0.0112316255,
-0.0160094928,
0.0730814487,
0.029102128,
-0.0455851071,
0.0322856195,
0.0277988482,
-0.0303539075,
-0.0381627269,
0.0366221555,
-0.0433231927,
-0.049695164,
-0.0095325345,
-0.0698766559,
-0.0446760692,
-0.0407338478,
0.036520794,
0.0013609445,
-0.0141638406,
-0.0202982612,
0.0362272412,
-0.0034106406,
0.0014305182,
-0.0607855469,
-0.0631301776,
0.0228384715,
-0.0166052058,
-0.0183178894,
-0.0202910546,
0.0713371485,
0.0013638429,
0.0513739437,
-0.0304269083,
0.0442396291,
-0.0341993459,
0.0300991964,
0.0518838316,
-0.0329179391,
0.0208469573,
0.0648263618,
-0.0402088314,
-0.0382783301,
-0.0565765202,
0.0331460685,
-0.0120658288,
0.0080087893,
0.017078409,
0.0755571499,
0.0150150908,
-0.0257141143,
-0.081854336,
0.0655729026,
-0.0282464679,
-0.0149113946,
0.0268322229,
0.00252768,
0.0002110673,
-0.0190481748,
-0.044170212,
0.0173194278,
-0.020870382,
-0.0422878861,
0.052884981,
0.0236507785,
0.0219438542,
-0.0043325126,
0.0224115811,
-0.0290399641,
0.0198424291,
0.0442631021,
-0.0342955329,
-0.0068193544,
-0.0075656627,
0.0248642098,
-0.0654094815,
-0.0219757743,
0.0444554277,
0.0262659304,
-0.0183480382,
-0.0029245126,
0.0280562155,
0.0038515176,
-0.0587500893,
0.0110160215,
-0.0491975285,
0.0045906049,
-0.0455323905,
-0.0367572643,
-0.0069330363,
0.0204413589,
-0.0197711214,
0.0562310033,
0.0036870409,
-0.0394792557,
-0.000847439,
-0.0139355706,
0.010830787,
0.0283604041,
-0.0341606438,
0.0314805247,
-0.0437835827,
-0.0161250252,
0.0284483153,
-0.0183671433,
-0.0026663237,
0.0074186577,
2.62e-7,
0.0107602878,
0.0293566361,
0.0245829038,
-0.0061587365,
0.008907414,
0.0120371068,
0.022236377,
0.0528241806,
-0.018279694,
-0.0127433781,
0.0263338014,
0.0568823405,
0.0612409152,
0.0186598543,
-0.0824526921,
0.043570891,
-0.0953185931,
-0.0450439081,
-0.0412411727,
-0.0204159468,
0.0827552006,
0.030089844,
0.0163071267,
-0.0052877688,
0.0279698465,
-0.0392183065,
0.1173720285,
-0.0402249321,
-0.0302537549,
0.025267927,
-0.0159237441,
0.0019236879,
-0.0033342303,
0.0154036004,
-0.0240349919,
-0.0069365096,
0.0321991667,
0.0556357093,
0.0329411626,
-0.0271294247,
-0.0004980108,
-0.000326769,
-0.0068938672,
-0.0581818856,
0.0726921558,
-0.0640523434,
-0.0158665869,
-0.0070556826,
-0.0198163856,
0.0258629229,
0.0246066358,
-0.0156514235,
-0.0466175713,
0.0223699547,
0.0306120832,
0.0401554927,
-0.0030541215,
-0.0390144773,
0.0212264452,
-0.02445421,
-0.0588356555,
-0.0378436521,
-0.0448287055,
0.0112703517,
0.0261278227,
-0.039145343,
0.0183976721,
2.265533706e-34,
0.0109936409,
0.0202997718,
-0.0141658587,
-0.02638801,
0.0154937413,
-0.0019236708,
-0.0194583293,
-0.0047749872,
-0.0099699553,
-0.0642548725,
-0.0023228209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15827v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15827v1 | How We Define Harm Impacts Data Annotations: Explaining How Annotators Distinguish Hateful, Offensive, and Toxic Comments | 2023-09-12T19:23:40 | 2023-09-12T19:23:40 | Angela Schöpke-Gonzalez, Siqi Wu, Sagar Kumar, Paul J. Resnick, Libby Hemphill | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, K.4.1 | Computational social science research has made advances in machine learning
and natural language processing that support content moderators in detecting
harmful content. These advances often rely on training datasets annotated by
crowdworkers for harmful content. In designing instructions for annotation
tasks to generate training data for these algorithms, researchers often treat
the harm concepts that we train algorithms to detect - 'hateful', 'offensive',
'toxic', 'racist', 'sexist', etc. - as interchangeable. In this work, we
studied whether the way that researchers define 'harm' affects annotation
outcomes. Using Venn diagrams, information gain comparisons, and content
analyses, we reveal that annotators do not use the concepts 'hateful',
'offensive', and 'toxic' interchangeably. We identify that features of harm
definitions and annotators' individual characteristics explain much of how
annotators use these terms differently. Our results offer empirical evidence
discouraging the common practice of using harm concepts interchangeably in
content moderation research. Instead, researchers should make specific choices
about which harm concepts to analyze based on their research goals. Recognizing
that researchers are often resource constrained, we also encourage researchers
to provide information to bound their findings when their concepts of interest
differ from concepts that off-the-shelf harmful content detection algorithms
identify. Finally, we encourage algorithm providers to ensure their instruments
can adapt to contextually-specific content detection goals (e.g., soliciting
instrument users' feedback). | [
0.078799516,
0.0264852364,
-0.0329197571,
-0.0047681024,
-0.0122277103,
0.0326913819,
0.0432553254,
0.0011102711,
0.018117534,
-0.0665830374,
-0.0001961358,
0.0236963592,
0.0014521115,
-0.0254774056,
0.0204838961,
-0.0238102917,
0.0147068324,
0.0526803955,
0.0216701478,
0.027040584,
0.0673291758,
0.0108940136,
0.0054316148,
0.0563238189,
-0.0639843345,
-0.0022583827,
0.0485954918,
0.0171973947,
0.0299713872,
-0.0581820533,
0.0278497022,
0.0257173907,
0.005939824,
0.0505369194,
0.0000017258,
-0.0382100753,
0.010166849,
0.0279391948,
0.0052432176,
-0.0426072888,
0.0905025154,
-0.036252901,
0.0162814651,
0.047439523,
-0.0106370803,
0.0153940748,
0.0832157508,
0.0077728778,
0.0636870414,
0.0324072801,
-0.0260771681,
-0.0245072246,
-0.0010422337,
0.0249502491,
0.0061987368,
0.0504442938,
0.049553439,
-0.0038871104,
-0.0669081062,
-0.009504105,
0.002127423,
0.0152066341,
0.0160373338,
0.0236009657,
0.032493934,
-0.0585673526,
-0.0140346326,
-0.0584646426,
0.0251443479,
0.0484314598,
0.0402949676,
0.0055673113,
-0.0094424793,
-0.0165050905,
0.0099016828,
0.0244056489,
-0.0219491497,
0.0196925402,
-0.0373713933,
-0.0152453361,
-0.0111325942,
0.0251295865,
0.0536814742,
0.0611487143,
0.0648495629,
0.0069107907,
-0.0392894335,
-0.0391580872,
0.0142470468,
-0.0220143478,
0.0120779611,
0.0077843019,
0.0318536647,
-0.0222404283,
0.0115586733,
0.020293558,
-0.0299597383,
-0.0743142813,
0.0437719747,
-0.0838379413,
0.0104706399,
0.0287403949,
-0.0632508099,
-0.0058172867,
0.0540403835,
-0.0157296453,
-0.0092590768,
0.0267268475,
0.011398227,
0.0191054568,
-0.0006691252,
0.0038341612,
0.0095387446,
-0.0205170754,
0.0311507881,
0.0641772747,
-0.0231689904,
-0.0169900432,
-0.1037308574,
-0.0168875214,
-0.0088774124,
-0.0149769653,
-0.0136370324,
0.0407498851,
-0.0416119546,
-0.0114909271,
-0.0652098134,
0.0605052374,
-0.0283565335,
-0.0446163192,
0.0398620442,
0.0301773902,
-0.0269146822,
0.0012112161,
0.0379845388,
0.0844254419,
0.072849825,
-0.0040203598,
-0.0342369415,
-0.047388494,
-0.018486632,
-0.0210360643,
0.0204497036,
-0.0386558734,
0.0234273728,
-0.0021911627,
-0.042962797,
-0.0914880559,
0.0086505208,
0.0184713881,
-0.0419891439,
0.0765068009,
-0.0137061728,
-0.0356023125,
0.0256299973,
0.033498913,
-0.0452866554,
0.0499807298,
0.0289797522,
0.0213507209,
0.0433630235,
-0.0025068659,
-0.0441343337,
0.0087217484,
0.0130562484,
0.0094421748,
-0.0296318419,
0.0278430134,
-0.0658572316,
-0.030299034,
-0.0308653098,
0.0412387475,
-0.0370130986,
-0.0176207554,
0.0348737314,
0.0437083058,
-0.0464521162,
0.0403925888,
0.0322117433,
-0.0010189444,
-0.0453349352,
-0.0449872725,
-0.0575495698,
-0.0065116719,
-0.0035715646,
-0.0689352006,
0.0296604764,
0.003316826,
-0.0063708499,
-0.058000654,
-0.0493799113,
0.0027314103,
0.09397351,
-0.0540750474,
0.0225287378,
0.0382434204,
-0.0048078266,
-0.0259092655,
0.0357295126,
-0.0077358452,
0.0071304594,
-0.0189240742,
0.0169274248,
0.0496585108,
0.0033920011,
-0.0232473277,
0.0041653342,
-0.0756668746,
0.0211287141,
0.0075236564,
0.018221166,
-0.0074482909,
-0.0541282296,
0.0018071699,
-0.0280509945,
0.0109385168,
-0.0032892802,
-0.0098042469,
0.0575285032,
-0.0275192242,
-0.0077207456,
0.0336026885,
-0.0683772936,
0.0388220735,
0.0471597761,
-0.0021446107,
-0.0401844271,
0.0247957371,
0.0731649399,
0.0291846823,
-0.0160640534,
-0.0177963525,
-0.001308942,
0.0209362824,
-0.0186898261,
-0.0158670992,
0.0213880986,
0.0696186945,
0.0018628538,
-0.062517263,
-0.0107902288,
0.0534663871,
0.0200694799,
0.0783198923,
0.0346805006,
-0.0121221514,
-0.0488130786,
-0.0188935529,
-0.0506693162,
-0.0494202189,
-0.0190600883,
-0.0117751267,
0.0438600667,
-0.0379700214,
0.0069144918,
0.001728483,
-0.0715207011,
0.0216179062,
0.0540156737,
-0.0541435704,
-0.049789492,
-0.0323743001,
0.0190796331,
0.0296413936,
-0.0152274445,
-0.0223671254,
0.0201258939,
-0.0470822901,
-0.0198917147,
-0.0124984356,
-0.0091792867,
0.0198153611,
-0.0159426965,
0.0120833712,
0.0107772257,
0.0141228838,
-0.0724007711,
-0.0088401381,
0.0718800277,
0.0024580287,
-0.0157089755,
-0.0180448499,
-0.0322598405,
-0.0176156033,
-0.0315510295,
0.0005489558,
0.0157754943,
-0.0909695327,
0.0228337198,
-0.0060718302,
-0.0742393509,
-0.0025394252,
-0.0215182267,
-0.0362294279,
0.0502713658,
0.0406876728,
-0.0393573381,
0.0129730925,
0.0349627882,
0.1270390898,
0.0519472472,
0.0254084654,
0.0005738353,
0.0059255641,
-0.0225308854,
0.0083015338,
-0.0013529101,
-0.0568907261,
-0.0124872746,
0.0259736944,
0.0034384148,
-0.0146581531,
-0.0438052341,
0.0472449139,
-0.0933307782,
-0.0519650243,
-0.0200985,
-0.0794930086,
0.0044749561,
0.0006188935,
-0.038651824,
-0.0506260172,
0.0353885032,
0.029379908,
0.0240422301,
-0.0081521505,
-0.0017524259,
0.0109355338,
0.0267871954,
-0.0160638597,
0.0219949763,
-0.0131070083,
0.0291495193,
0.0189351756,
-0.0024356949,
0.093674466,
-0.0346973762,
-0.0390432887,
-0.0334568545,
0.0059574987,
0.0092250798,
-0.0561102591,
-0.0268930793,
-0.0464324392,
-0.0172413681,
-0.0307141803,
0.0481464826,
0.0319551341,
0.0049431501,
0.0255810712,
0.0385621935,
-0.0389775299,
0.0288765766,
-0.015096914,
0.0316805691,
-0.0702697411,
-0.019687688,
-0.0069934642,
0.0589835718,
0.0186618287,
-0.0094672823,
0.0553781129,
-0.0573612899,
-0.0179598909,
-0.0029614347,
0.0109737124,
-0.000714301,
0.0194033608,
0.0065957247,
0.0039459332,
0.0407349654,
-0.0045968033,
0.0048757205,
0.0231920797,
0.0136387842,
-0.0087826056,
-0.0108494451,
-0.0032080952,
-0.0101459203,
0.0239876937,
-0.0432779752,
-0.0977618918,
0.0137546724,
-0.0201166458,
0.0463508815,
-0.1146292686,
-0.053456381,
0.0080880541,
-0.0317928307,
0.0244045947,
-0.0195887703,
-0.052949965,
-0.0227648355,
-0.0425257646,
0.0031547572,
-0.0215659738,
0.0319932774,
-0.0371848382,
0.0461883061,
-0.0102060111,
0.0161501337,
-0.0457851775,
-0.008053463,
-0.0354857743,
-0.0156020783,
0.0369370729,
0.0268762577,
0.0354356207,
-0.0292768963,
0.0038988176,
0.053731665,
0.0385362133,
-0.0305745956,
-0.0157589056,
0.0709095672,
0.0024590988,
-0.0192534309,
-0.0294514168,
0.0469046943,
0.02776918,
-0.0213452931,
-0.0189986993,
0.0250329785,
0.0449156538,
0.0337509327,
-0.0387561582,
0.0321027413,
0.0337046832,
0.0574876405,
0.0251891725,
-0.0377646759,
0.0364506915,
-0.0572253317,
0.0169253089,
0.0123907682,
-0.0641704649,
0.0059591397,
-0.0271322988,
-0.0281686466,
-0.0113229258,
-0.0524841435,
0.0299521554,
-0.0165996384,
0.0480359197,
-0.021393463,
-0.0074958559,
-0.0061333799,
-0.0172826555,
0.0170922298,
0.0247231051,
0.0108930208,
0.0287743155,
-0.0272275861,
-0.0594265573,
0.0269950069,
-0.0353589915,
0.0343781225,
-0.0383134447,
-0.0329014175,
0.0792846158,
0.0740472898,
0.0123772388,
0.0087898923,
0.003318507,
-0.0386506058,
-0.0125914821,
0.0691320673,
-0.0278709009,
-0.0212384574,
0.0532310791,
0.0007098292,
0.0172888245,
-0.012818967,
-0.0260753613,
0.017408425,
0.0478677452,
-0.0461092517,
-0.0428946353,
0.0305094793,
0.0094154179,
0.0007731991,
0.0348042734,
-0.0363814346,
-0.034316618,
-0.0102904895,
-0.0374953225,
0.00626028,
-0.0576052517,
0.0111237746,
-0.0050464673,
0.0029134427,
-0.0035050281,
-0.0465771817,
0.0348130465,
-0.0336512327,
0.0197368916,
-0.0668855906,
0.0265105404,
0.0679842159,
0.0399146564,
0.0108360182,
0.0042182202,
-0.0271907393,
0.0417250618,
-0.0044867373,
-0.0112077352,
-0.0018313401,
0.0106076756,
0.0221590344,
0.0494813956,
0.0168081187,
-0.0168577954,
0.011701243,
-0.0364805385,
-0.0320858732,
-0.0139780883,
-0.0467401892,
-0.008741132,
0.0027847567,
0.0021969082,
-0.0358784385,
-0.0146101257,
-0.0114270393,
-0.0293140355,
-0.0613552667,
0.0208736658,
0.0139106521,
-0.0357639045,
-0.0039843689,
0.0021859801,
-0.0321906097,
0.0483745933,
0.0050399937,
-0.0513674766,
0.004833465,
-0.0066625727,
0.0247431491,
0.0632856935,
0.0262322631,
0.0083664758,
-0.0692496151,
-0.0343409888,
-0.0186625235,
-0.0769215524,
0.0378412642,
-0.0253944751,
-0.0269930139,
0.0286410935,
0.0096746096,
0.0071348483,
0.0071349265,
-0.0021326318,
-0.0273829289,
-0.0433970317,
-0.0042732367,
-5.094104686e-33,
0.0064219357,
-0.0235569347,
-0.018563237,
0.0170096755,
0.0099916421,
-0.0094130021,
0.0483634397,
0.0016677011,
-0.0149360346,
0.0218505133,
0.0166362394,
0.009018817,
-0.0052777366,
-0.0249149408,
0.0117734289,
-0.048766613,
0.0235590264,
-0.0242536999,
-0.0364095271,
0.0040429733,
0.01854017,
-0.03018656,
-0.0010966036,
-0.1017091274,
0.0911331102,
-0.0148220556,
-0.0259377584,
0.0209505167,
0.0144293122,
0.0657037869,
-0.005995417,
0.0701883361,
0.0190782286,
-0.0414936766,
0.0197788831,
0.0517254472,
-0.0456010737,
0.0026915842,
0.0526141077,
-0.00668809,
-0.0236349255,
-0.0203325003,
0.04310349,
0.0199818183,
-0.0225767996,
-0.0341453031,
0.0409031287,
-0.0166583862,
0.016718071,
-0.0506722219,
-0.0344910547,
0.0021660675,
-0.0533482544,
0.0163746309,
-0.0106646838,
0.0436522774,
0.0076059424,
0.0418969691,
-0.0650022551,
0.0097903842,
-0.0171507988,
-0.0505173504,
-0.0170891061,
-0.0066927667,
0.0124077704,
0.0667760968,
-0.0044188704,
0.0778028741,
-0.016597623,
0.0103635155,
0.0141207026,
0.0154346954,
0.0421609059,
0.0706543103,
0.0315408111,
-0.0816621184,
-0.0640431568,
-0.0276811663,
-0.0181000475,
0.0069124182,
0.0151291881,
-0.0361739546,
-0.0642113686,
-0.031329602,
-0.0338195823,
-0.0834760591,
-0.032832589,
-0.0193620753,
0.0243831072,
-0.0351628549,
-0.054439839,
0.0002996635,
-0.0031504624,
-0.0307356678,
0.0331494212,
0.0300847553,
-0.0031384057,
0.0001178768,
0.0256173499,
0.0067789978,
-0.0462583378,
0.0216829851,
0.0027010071,
-0.031764999,
0.0605981797,
-0.0034291078,
0.0994001105,
0.0193265509,
-0.0395029262,
-0.0147410827,
0.0177775677,
0.0835122839,
-0.0140691437,
0.0161434691,
0.0297826864,
0.0737919286,
0.0134605188,
-0.0413521528,
0.0666823834,
0.0396538302,
-0.0163405612,
-0.0081596114,
-0.0532792956,
-0.0466458239,
0.0163845737,
-0.0291482732,
0.0111148506,
0.0106871016,
0.027162632,
-0.0788772702,
0.012249344,
-0.0461827144,
2.458e-7,
0.0593270548,
0.0294590089,
0.0046625356,
0.0175909922,
0.023026213,
0.0047536413,
0.0675765052,
0.0175803248,
0.0390181318,
-0.0255053993,
0.0115269907,
0.0339819826,
0.004705857,
0.0655347481,
0.0223861821,
-0.0570777915,
-0.046961911,
0.0371642001,
-0.0232882779,
0.0331361517,
0.0030696746,
0.0177180022,
0.0349711291,
-0.0030216994,
-0.0628502592,
0.005508543,
0.0074851965,
-0.0674225837,
0.0419833399,
-0.0149277477,
0.0514826663,
0.0245616902,
0.0322914273,
0.0349067971,
0.0081673013,
0.0016364998,
0.0087497467,
0.0115882298,
0.0305710193,
-0.0010857071,
-0.0017712824,
0.006241031,
0.0232034475,
-0.0246693622,
0.040800117,
-0.0218088049,
-0.0165096838,
-0.049529776,
-0.0148056922,
-0.0220058709,
0.0503090806,
-0.0148084322,
-0.0235169083,
-0.0018643303,
0.0152428411,
-0.0077918926,
0.0292275269,
-0.0162680335,
0.0028306481,
-0.0145114455,
-0.0095531745,
-0.0819603205,
-0.0125173824,
0.0030446171,
0.0107952394,
0.0365695842,
0.0578583926,
1.649967148e-34,
0.0079287924,
-0.0518476963,
0.0270324014,
-0.0248836968,
0.024766054,
0.0241531283,
-0.0006714132,
-0.0301278085,
0.0079696989,
-0.0005061232,
0.0028542643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06520v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06520v2 | Minimum Bayes' Risk Decoding for System Combination of Grammatical Error Correction Systems | 2023-09-12T18:51:10 | 2023-10-27T14:42:29 | Vyas Raina, Mark Gales | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | For sequence-to-sequence tasks it is challenging to combine individual system
outputs. Further, there is also often a mismatch between the decoding criterion
and the one used for assessment. Minimum Bayes' Risk (MBR) decoding can be used
to combine system outputs in a manner that encourages better alignment with the
final assessment criterion. This paper examines MBR decoding for Grammatical
Error Correction (GEC) systems, where performance is usually evaluated in terms
of edits and an associated F-score. Hence, we propose a novel MBR loss function
directly linked to this form of criterion. Furthermore, an approach to expand
the possible set of candidate sentences is described. This builds on a current
max-voting combination scheme, as well as individual edit-level selection.
Experiments on three popular GEC datasets and with state-of-the-art GEC systems
demonstrate the efficacy of the proposed MBR approach. Additionally, the paper
highlights how varying reward metrics within the MBR decoding framework can
provide control over precision, recall, and the F-score in combined GEC
systems. | [
0.0295601152,
0.0417809077,
0.0195137542,
0.0005884154,
-0.0239923745,
0.0464282148,
-0.0661925375,
0.0026027616,
-0.0222029109,
-0.0730283782,
-0.0031546522,
-0.0423898809,
0.0514902212,
-0.0188507028,
0.0063755508,
-0.0364680402,
0.0613170527,
0.0063841017,
-0.0002976217,
-0.005763548,
0.0014355949,
0.002151723,
-0.0503610671,
0.0648385212,
-0.0240744222,
-0.0127846422,
-0.0066909809,
0.0286730379,
0.0609700046,
-0.0101332115,
0.028916914,
0.0456018858,
-0.0365112834,
0.0746573657,
0.0000018706,
-0.0438814722,
-0.0228608362,
-0.0141240377,
-0.0434007905,
0.0009297123,
0.008831962,
-0.0082625495,
-0.0644765198,
0.0205108952,
0.0053870408,
-0.0354473516,
0.0793019384,
0.0326753855,
0.0513443276,
0.1186885387,
0.0094779218,
-0.0068478887,
0.0314806364,
-0.0112762656,
-0.0222580731,
-0.0190573893,
0.0404461734,
0.0197547749,
-0.0075567886,
-0.0377525613,
-0.0269350987,
0.0265952218,
-0.0015447423,
-0.0315142199,
0.0181962289,
-0.0063440772,
0.0472526401,
-0.008881541,
-0.0332614295,
-0.0121836439,
0.0073318169,
-0.0299400222,
-0.0337202735,
0.0009396906,
0.0092928056,
-0.0259846728,
-0.0040773298,
0.0201517828,
-0.0324123092,
0.0237926077,
0.0680164099,
-0.0529343635,
0.0083941109,
0.0000972779,
-0.0285915509,
0.0621530525,
0.0121224578,
-0.072746478,
-0.020025447,
0.068548061,
0.0037935155,
-0.056811329,
0.0506618433,
-0.0031964872,
-0.0587068461,
-0.0021768252,
-0.0442178138,
-0.0950471461,
-0.0158892516,
-0.03737792,
0.0193407964,
0.0253967177,
0.0170279443,
0.0113927908,
0.0138664767,
0.05589398,
0.0502797216,
0.021189142,
-0.0115348082,
0.0270400885,
-0.044050131,
0.0097315609,
-0.0186285153,
0.0391534418,
-0.0474590622,
0.0211307127,
-0.0657275617,
-0.0104311453,
-0.0109040141,
0.0299496427,
0.0783389136,
-0.0071554529,
-0.0590910688,
-0.0247605182,
0.0029492434,
0.0317957029,
0.0152017074,
0.0340592936,
0.0399133936,
-0.0121729933,
-0.04562442,
-0.007038489,
0.0338978544,
-0.012002565,
-0.0244817808,
0.0109019438,
-0.0286770407,
-0.0514079668,
-0.031083189,
0.002804552,
-0.0454013087,
-0.0304616615,
-0.0571987815,
-0.0377014689,
-0.0059324065,
-0.0102362493,
0.0315997079,
-0.011025073,
-0.0156312436,
-0.0166409556,
-0.0114440555,
0.0663911998,
-0.0012014445,
-0.0337738022,
0.0480612814,
-0.0089488449,
0.0067109177,
0.0507257767,
0.0428636409,
-0.0152527392,
0.0279319622,
0.0400364771,
0.0135594867,
0.0170000903,
-0.0412204452,
-0.0058331615,
0.0328624062,
-0.031766627,
0.0045734993,
0.0044567394,
0.0603083558,
0.0375356674,
-0.0458126515,
0.0297521111,
0.0660478324,
-0.0069352235,
0.0353281051,
-0.0107880104,
0.0018760927,
-0.0175756272,
0.0220784415,
0.0246683583,
-0.0075304937,
-0.0001992421,
-0.0591980927,
-0.0013260476,
0.0513553955,
0.0118573662,
0.0036364975,
-0.0378270298,
-0.0099205803,
-0.0292529892,
-0.0078275865,
-0.0123805413,
0.0575788431,
0.015856158,
-0.0507790633,
0.0141800074,
0.005645352,
-0.083036989,
0.0393036045,
-0.01324022,
-0.0351140201,
0.0568454303,
0.074331589,
-0.0101904962,
-0.0243700203,
-0.0307096578,
-0.0773213953,
0.0103155393,
0.0251823682,
-0.0126308855,
0.0190018136,
-0.0451994166,
-0.0289836582,
0.0360568576,
0.0322056934,
0.0173734706,
-0.0275337249,
-0.0022140944,
-0.0060010296,
0.0142632304,
-0.0400111973,
0.020584723,
0.0522758253,
-0.0079304809,
-0.0087886481,
-0.0044213561,
0.0404838845,
0.0096728997,
-0.0300146341,
0.0159075018,
0.0009223847,
-0.0014923571,
-0.0539727397,
-0.0079337051,
-0.0404938199,
-0.1101993397,
0.019510787,
-0.0193251316,
-0.0443599299,
0.047502812,
-0.0331781246,
-0.0701602548,
-0.018426504,
-0.100349322,
-0.0130273188,
-0.0441718958,
0.0678413808,
0.0298875645,
-0.0616484545,
-0.0403215811,
0.0163082685,
-0.0261347312,
-0.0000316738,
-0.0362289622,
-0.0316281952,
-0.0053135734,
-0.0867795274,
-0.0401534252,
0.0052516162,
-0.0050241319,
0.0318803601,
0.03791124,
0.0119949253,
-0.0311252028,
-0.0506906584,
-0.0701545402,
-0.0035429148,
-0.0506313369,
0.0517785102,
0.0296778735,
0.0031867721,
0.0030813394,
-0.027455233,
0.023276912,
0.0078785112,
0.0035011664,
0.0025390985,
0.0289128982,
0.0026749012,
-0.0028667815,
-0.0460723564,
-0.0007167619,
-0.0188792646,
0.0260462444,
0.0053289109,
-0.0200277958,
-0.0960540995,
0.058613684,
-0.0144742867,
-0.0072480412,
0.0442867503,
-0.0468380712,
-0.0122897467,
-0.0031275635,
0.0609693937,
0.0400609635,
-0.0047578118,
0.0366865136,
0.0038017451,
-0.0248867646,
-0.022207329,
-0.0064805672,
-0.0042795828,
-0.0093753533,
-0.049564302,
-0.0155925946,
0.0106876632,
0.0519576222,
0.0212482046,
0.0079656821,
-0.063491717,
0.0286681391,
-0.0471059643,
-0.0423333272,
-0.0295105781,
-0.003416219,
-0.0210392829,
0.0146683501,
-0.0324692652,
-0.0028100121,
0.0944569558,
0.0100139203,
-0.0104360906,
-0.0704337731,
0.0223839507,
0.0115295686,
-0.0194570832,
-0.0012606726,
0.0266169365,
-0.0286050141,
-0.0809953213,
-0.048861064,
0.005754584,
0.0669312254,
-0.0385912918,
0.0515135378,
-0.0816865489,
0.0201162584,
0.002312144,
-0.0745599195,
0.009520825,
0.0148129696,
0.0037223061,
-0.0126711195,
0.0345193036,
-0.0193339791,
-0.0374659933,
-0.004345655,
0.0152735813,
0.0323484167,
-0.0184553321,
-0.0181220826,
-0.02094822,
0.0463854857,
0.0246199146,
0.0013910435,
0.0278334431,
-0.021412624,
-0.0207260512,
0.064047575,
0.0428561717,
0.0352650844,
-0.016244946,
0.0107379369,
0.0684468672,
-0.0427094959,
-0.0034991608,
-0.0111468723,
0.0591985993,
-0.0654166266,
-0.0360090099,
0.0864739046,
0.0323960632,
-0.0286716279,
-0.0311298445,
-0.0169437155,
-0.0068099638,
-0.0163494721,
0.0163617264,
-0.028060399,
-0.0108782826,
0.0497982465,
0.0587330684,
-0.0142029664,
-0.0051254667,
0.0200437363,
-0.0946196169,
0.0372043177,
0.0394065306,
-0.014749594,
-0.0713478625,
-0.01162278,
-0.0013192655,
-0.0384524763,
0.0186090693,
0.0671980903,
0.0271401145,
-0.0134615805,
0.0228425413,
-0.0254943017,
-0.0747629628,
-0.0402554423,
-0.01233212,
0.057505358,
0.0995771363,
0.0031406297,
0.0242644623,
-0.0281478036,
-0.0037052236,
-0.0459096134,
-0.0218538512,
-0.0187614542,
0.0079966206,
-0.010306241,
0.0036254097,
-0.0069015902,
0.0127606401,
0.0183102582,
-0.0051012915,
-0.0342004634,
0.0686473921,
-0.0542995445,
0.0532657541,
0.03456733,
-0.0231337231,
0.05030654,
0.0408669338,
0.0274875946,
-0.0377497524,
-0.0278376658,
-0.0810070634,
0.0089567909,
-0.0745805427,
0.0587938055,
0.0319776796,
-0.0237902589,
-0.0352674574,
-0.0796165541,
-0.0720969141,
-0.0070926542,
-0.0004771183,
-0.0005716454,
-0.0177511666,
-0.0024293542,
0.0071307691,
0.0045235176,
-0.0280412566,
-0.0021303042,
-0.0049980516,
-0.0792720243,
0.0323338173,
-0.0345491432,
0.0228946432,
-0.0236610472,
-0.0137580959,
-0.0484575927,
-0.0456877202,
0.0227369554,
0.0626186058,
0.0122509468,
0.0002951921,
0.0020922611,
-0.0861680955,
0.0111264233,
-0.0066508446,
0.0199831799,
0.0460197814,
0.049537044,
-0.0245469287,
-0.0375793837,
0.0223616138,
-0.0187311377,
-0.0136535438,
0.0152504295,
0.0859263912,
-0.0152904056,
0.0002106957,
0.0649835989,
0.0154478317,
0.0483031571,
-0.0432290025,
-0.0362394005,
-0.0429668725,
0.0573887862,
-0.0493200943,
0.0040341881,
-0.0090940027,
0.0046828436,
0.037988022,
-0.0341694877,
-0.0264068525,
0.0131673459,
-0.0017678121,
-0.0102821197,
-0.0114539769,
0.0192380436,
0.0468138047,
0.0093086148,
0.0468065962,
-0.0004143609,
-0.0297602881,
-0.0042799008,
0.0532330722,
0.0028819405,
-0.0188726727,
0.0368242711,
0.0350031406,
-0.0179451462,
0.0318633728,
0.0254524611,
-0.0484664664,
0.0586998239,
-0.0216037612,
0.0039185416,
0.1101827398,
0.0345542952,
0.1287619621,
-0.0219190549,
-0.0095287533,
-0.0626120046,
0.030333152,
0.0296462215,
0.0151556069,
0.0015925167,
0.0102973925,
0.0233976524,
-0.0170858186,
0.0503831431,
-0.0593705736,
0.0375806764,
-0.0526553988,
-0.0284808744,
-0.0352578163,
-0.0219542552,
-0.0162763186,
-0.012484544,
-0.0250241254,
-0.0322354957,
-0.0438227691,
-0.0209363196,
0.0137376171,
0.0654514432,
0.0240838174,
0.0005355077,
0.0091893962,
0.0164891388,
-0.0508227982,
-0.0236192234,
-0.0351502635,
-0.0206961092,
-0.0092593804,
-0.013738635,
-0.043054264,
-5.957061171e-33,
-0.0530581139,
-0.0062091146,
-0.0242990516,
-0.0242749862,
-0.0006687791,
0.0067308424,
-0.03331865,
-0.0025848669,
0.0658913404,
0.0332597606,
-0.0079023819,
0.0214304123,
0.0167399179,
0.0329538547,
0.0239283387,
0.0342843048,
0.0718802288,
0.0155089134,
-0.0347808078,
-0.0384407304,
0.067176789,
0.0433508009,
0.0581791289,
-0.0001763864,
0.0523923971,
0.0583467893,
-0.0257636271,
0.0075704497,
-0.0173269659,
0.0589793101,
0.0435199514,
0.059054058,
0.0181690007,
-0.0363665335,
-0.0265926737,
-0.0234999526,
-0.0793238506,
-0.0139168547,
-0.0149713838,
0.0376647376,
0.0110891396,
-0.0301199947,
0.0214180034,
-0.0028267445,
-0.0377924144,
-0.0279480033,
-0.0091070514,
-0.0287745818,
0.0058847223,
-0.0100933826,
-0.0190864131,
0.0228781626,
0.0073375725,
0.0096021825,
0.0148199052,
0.0333962813,
-0.0062157488,
-0.0516372584,
-0.0631606132,
-0.0069571771,
0.0199052021,
0.0581668094,
0.0267528892,
-0.0039652288,
-0.058376953,
0.007714659,
0.0063365581,
-0.0309255999,
-0.0106241656,
-0.0035271812,
-0.0130346445,
-0.0100661879,
0.0481214486,
0.0463640578,
0.0221042968,
0.0044605727,
-0.0372167155,
0.0278291963,
-0.0359072499,
0.0685466751,
-0.0292700324,
0.0470405668,
-0.0503498353,
-0.0258325953,
-0.0475222059,
0.0091917282,
-0.0109498957,
0.0085897241,
0.0462574586,
0.0220849216,
-0.0078166751,
0.0051507857,
0.0148303472,
-0.0054613347,
-0.0024549388,
-0.0312069468,
0.0283743199,
0.0243952628,
-0.0366064981,
0.0040893387,
-0.0153546501,
0.0236763805,
0.0452791117,
0.0110090924,
-0.0056857294,
-0.0150779989,
0.0344787203,
0.0160112493,
-0.063135013,
0.0208246205,
0.0129397959,
0.0196524654,
-0.0005546962,
0.0160276759,
0.0525769033,
-0.0123824077,
0.0284395218,
-0.003216512,
0.0070529897,
0.0269597955,
-0.0025069052,
-0.033016298,
0.0070976038,
0.0289603714,
0.0125704072,
0.0360400751,
-0.0045413924,
0.0055097006,
0.0108055668,
-0.0025654121,
0.004123948,
0.0324895568,
2.583e-7,
0.0544351786,
0.0731605068,
0.0411733277,
-0.014427972,
0.0035575209,
0.0312065501,
-0.0177693889,
0.0204055309,
0.0116307111,
0.0587546602,
0.0135652144,
-0.0221410766,
0.0686233118,
0.0072158356,
-0.035014078,
-0.0470208824,
-0.0267826505,
0.0216869693,
-0.0190942846,
0.0065969639,
0.0698927343,
0.015791228,
0.0256054588,
-0.0010045278,
-0.0044211657,
-0.0188357942,
0.0318590701,
0.0159653369,
-0.0229751021,
0.014283767,
0.0702987686,
-0.0053629242,
0.0265530478,
0.0629831031,
-0.0402575433,
-0.0422432907,
-0.0024680349,
0.0377651267,
-0.0463311598,
-0.0172756389,
-0.0016841444,
0.0431162007,
-0.0110649783,
-0.0285779983,
0.0095033944,
-0.0254153684,
0.0125721153,
0.0195954535,
-0.0217364728,
0.021706095,
0.0138986651,
-0.0073676389,
-0.0229838341,
-0.009333753,
0.0315233134,
0.0782831162,
-0.0000353088,
-0.0443513393,
0.0101683913,
0.0573883355,
0.0288369749,
-0.0524042398,
0.0001262259,
0.0099184411,
0.027180763,
-0.1105334684,
-0.0530711375,
2.318447253e-34,
0.0345868766,
-0.0328674987,
0.0413798429,
0.0036178944,
0.0270451363,
-0.0102350134,
-0.0085793603,
0.0068315864,
-0.0201254096,
-0.0511075631,
-0.040080104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06517v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06517v1 | Overview of Memotion 3: Sentiment and Emotion Analysis of Codemixed Hinglish Memes | 2023-09-12T18:47:29 | 2023-09-12T18:47:29 | Shreyash Mishra, S Suryavardan, Megha Chakraborty, Parth Patwa, Anku Rani, Aman Chadha, Aishwarya Reganti, Amitava Das, Amit Sheth, Manoj Chinnakotla, Asif Ekbal, Srijan Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Analyzing memes on the internet has emerged as a crucial endeavor due to the
impact this multi-modal form of content wields in shaping online discourse.
Memes have become a powerful tool for expressing emotions and sentiments,
possibly even spreading hate and misinformation, through humor and sarcasm. In
this paper, we present the overview of the Memotion 3 shared task, as part of
the DeFactify 2 workshop at AAAI-23. The task released an annotated dataset of
Hindi-English code-mixed memes based on their Sentiment (Task A), Emotion (Task
B), and Emotion intensity (Task C). Each of these is defined as an individual
task and the participants are ranked separately for each task. Over 50 teams
registered for the shared task and 5 made final submissions to the test set of
the Memotion 3 dataset. CLIP, BERT modifications, ViT etc. were the most
popular models among the participants along with approaches such as
Student-Teacher model, Fusion, and Ensembling. The best final F1 score for Task
A is 34.41, Task B is 79.77 and Task C is 59.82. | [
0.0561655648,
0.0166999716,
-0.0399802476,
0.0225503203,
-0.0086403526,
0.058476992,
-0.0280938018,
0.0235198252,
0.0398664549,
-0.0593329743,
-0.0056366459,
-0.0112255011,
-0.0262692906,
0.0580771342,
0.0004003262,
-0.0732539669,
-0.0046579563,
0.0573905967,
0.0395682491,
-0.0326381139,
0.0504267924,
0.0311239939,
-0.0464283898,
0.0411845557,
-0.057131432,
-0.0032500015,
0.0291790683,
0.0512997024,
0.0221082531,
-0.0418057702,
0.036281772,
0.0477465913,
0.0081662033,
-0.007032813,
0.0000021391,
-0.037903063,
-0.0177509934,
-0.0282774847,
0.0069155991,
-0.0001058877,
0.080668807,
0.0233594049,
-0.0221431404,
0.0389488339,
-0.0097287362,
0.0352125131,
0.1101219505,
0.0026070247,
0.1146468073,
0.0890806839,
-0.0315886214,
-0.0215207487,
-0.0126234693,
0.0031190715,
0.0226983689,
0.039118953,
0.0050739134,
0.0186839476,
-0.0288602766,
-0.0359192677,
-0.012100393,
0.0183584411,
-0.0106225032,
0.0293070897,
-0.0107232835,
0.0009141502,
-0.0485021621,
-0.0323293991,
0.0230392907,
0.0149500826,
0.0058393804,
-0.0012634767,
0.0368548445,
0.0169637538,
-0.0084652072,
-0.0353085734,
-0.0460793935,
0.0108976848,
-0.0066363676,
0.0361865908,
0.0098301666,
0.0274127703,
-0.0122880014,
0.0359224863,
0.017034214,
-0.015882289,
-0.0136732413,
-0.005304134,
-0.035904564,
0.0187516119,
-0.0292133577,
-0.0157810189,
0.0414977968,
0.0013214905,
0.0262293108,
0.0337801948,
-0.0190924555,
-0.1254706383,
0.0290723704,
-0.0974345729,
-0.0220094528,
0.0273533985,
-0.0100084227,
0.0145479348,
0.0026947074,
0.019230973,
0.0046517765,
0.0312808491,
0.0119839627,
0.0014431801,
-0.0262234844,
0.0150416568,
0.0165977366,
0.066458635,
0.0199109633,
0.0036009557,
-0.0997259468,
0.0001555542,
-0.0567931421,
-0.0312855169,
0.0117559638,
-0.0175531469,
0.0175180938,
0.0403771512,
0.0015551434,
0.0073613524,
-0.0567871332,
0.0130017251,
-0.0176817086,
-0.0720601827,
0.0454933755,
0.0176327955,
-0.0052103293,
-0.0298387408,
0.0235203244,
0.0560008921,
0.0061939298,
-0.0133664552,
-0.0193213634,
-0.0226362869,
-0.0408876762,
-0.0115928389,
0.0121105593,
-0.0996729806,
0.0141704408,
0.0293559432,
0.0223167874,
-0.0159324482,
0.021249231,
-0.0056791189,
-0.0237181913,
0.0668146387,
-0.0278114434,
-0.0161175895,
0.025696801,
0.0439829044,
-0.0204671584,
0.0236430354,
-0.0199836157,
0.0544093065,
0.0417094752,
-0.0183524787,
0.0092576221,
0.021163458,
0.0049355486,
-0.0047253263,
-0.032646168,
0.0108793741,
-0.0446056351,
-0.0408529602,
-0.0122932335,
0.0380719937,
-0.0205462594,
0.0169535782,
-0.0027936357,
0.0333490111,
-0.0262223762,
0.0345206372,
-0.0260907412,
0.0284258369,
0.0452872813,
-0.0360613205,
0.008542751,
0.0164045449,
-0.0309109837,
-0.024799211,
0.0495500192,
0.0391420908,
-0.0206649173,
-0.0505921915,
-0.028131159,
-0.0522156321,
0.0327844433,
-0.0296007097,
0.0370759815,
-0.023396261,
-0.0108737955,
0.0170892142,
0.0335165821,
-0.1028913036,
-0.0129591171,
-0.0265913848,
0.0039466699,
0.0406183042,
0.0233541373,
-0.0188770872,
-0.0433157161,
-0.0116823418,
-0.0339880623,
0.0140367402,
-0.0221608859,
0.0167051945,
-0.0383342467,
-0.038957037,
0.0188240837,
-0.0112424958,
0.009037829,
0.0126713542,
0.0077710119,
0.0506729558,
-0.0020889083,
0.069634676,
0.0022227461,
-0.024076635,
0.0045825234,
0.0406425558,
-0.0474717878,
0.0174188949,
0.0987818092,
0.0231288876,
-0.0446096435,
-0.0194212757,
0.0235148203,
-0.0263242852,
-0.0371547677,
0.0474688448,
-0.0095516546,
-0.048643332,
0.0394872837,
-0.0962973312,
-0.005730629,
0.0477576107,
0.0038730078,
-0.0084496811,
0.0714013427,
-0.0333858728,
0.0589245856,
-0.0457674861,
0.0038651258,
-0.0455622897,
0.0034625428,
0.0135313626,
0.0434069484,
-0.0218125954,
-0.0079225954,
0.0070495303,
-0.0233448837,
0.0379711315,
0.0676597655,
-0.0472563729,
0.0474430099,
-0.0064682541,
0.0354943834,
-0.0131880771,
0.0045304704,
-0.0644422099,
-0.0475695282,
-0.1258689761,
-0.0376929194,
0.0100271367,
0.0154920975,
0.0244807843,
0.0030434129,
-0.0399084836,
-0.0122465212,
-0.0380545631,
0.0053429455,
0.0086326683,
0.0186376963,
-0.0074420404,
-0.0116031393,
0.0326614976,
-0.0558806136,
-0.0126677509,
-0.0481301807,
0.0093885083,
0.0108179078,
-0.0471804254,
0.0401829891,
0.0237143617,
-0.0684976056,
-0.0244664997,
-0.0019441152,
-0.0940533057,
0.0179089997,
-0.0244712625,
0.0952462852,
0.0140683856,
0.0269423164,
0.0716163963,
-0.0216270555,
-0.0406936742,
-0.0359290689,
0.0015958418,
0.0103616752,
0.0289108101,
0.0271524172,
-0.0582089014,
-0.0055007786,
0.0305162203,
0.0233293138,
0.0174845587,
-0.0776418969,
0.0300925989,
-0.0318090655,
0.0011303519,
0.0000974565,
-0.0425303616,
-0.0221828707,
0.015695883,
-0.003765699,
-0.0503832474,
0.0569970831,
-0.0038469294,
-0.0209593959,
-0.0789896399,
0.0161186401,
-0.0143774524,
0.0680111498,
-0.0318620875,
0.0300494656,
-0.0317978412,
-0.0162701327,
0.0222660117,
-0.0382737257,
-0.0186266694,
-0.0624257773,
-0.003911274,
0.0163784083,
-0.0246725846,
-0.0044090948,
-0.0088295629,
0.0079571512,
-0.0405003093,
-0.0489049591,
-0.0337037928,
0.0659594089,
-0.0221182387,
0.0290723536,
0.0313318335,
0.000397299,
-0.0845611915,
0.0049144714,
0.0000995976,
0.0353257991,
0.0195893217,
0.0173254572,
-0.0522610433,
0.0094335796,
-0.0008387212,
-0.009173193,
0.0338061079,
0.0389211476,
-0.0190946441,
-0.009548231,
-0.006592459,
0.0158578288,
0.0163261369,
-0.0093808006,
-0.0551854372,
0.0596273094,
-0.0104235644,
0.0215277281,
0.0853942707,
0.0309614595,
-0.060068503,
-0.0132797007,
-0.0233972203,
0.0026955388,
0.0137656406,
0.0043180031,
-0.0408044532,
-0.0183262713,
-0.019646896,
0.0136260223,
-0.0216856543,
-0.0111994948,
0.0203415509,
-0.1049436927,
-0.0059208702,
0.0163487978,
0.0334625058,
-0.0130278589,
0.0156794544,
0.0020764617,
0.0153007749,
-0.0372794345,
-0.0632464439,
0.0136389872,
0.0232660174,
0.0349967442,
-0.0112970648,
-0.0077936533,
-0.0051515102,
-0.011039692,
0.0663537234,
0.0313914865,
0.0588338561,
-0.0375922807,
-0.0625545084,
0.0185384247,
-0.0438161641,
-0.0195630174,
-0.0395404175,
0.0599333309,
-0.0096350741,
-0.0424922742,
-0.0445733778,
-0.0164145865,
-0.0247952584,
-0.0146062113,
-0.0240128879,
0.0485726111,
-0.0204522889,
-0.0170661639,
-0.0632551461,
0.0155061819,
-0.008174465,
0.0511660278,
0.0470240526,
-0.0608489402,
0.0175821912,
-0.0416269414,
0.0474735796,
-0.0450641513,
-0.0302782618,
-0.063632831,
-0.033138752,
-0.0114966761,
-0.0775645077,
-0.0464975201,
0.0064191939,
0.0356678553,
-0.0010113801,
-0.0163203012,
-0.0207808521,
-0.0011102566,
-0.0388509929,
-0.015323936,
0.0090134088,
0.0380263403,
-0.0311087854,
-0.0286428332,
0.0110198651,
-0.0032287443,
-0.0007086857,
-0.0091096032,
-0.0507962666,
-0.0494263396,
0.0168970451,
0.0580277592,
0.0194722172,
-0.0044295401,
-0.0224504787,
-0.0243009645,
0.0308607519,
0.0462980904,
-0.0086057456,
0.0044711363,
0.0483824424,
0.0235944372,
0.0052139796,
-0.0063744774,
0.0058068624,
0.0310433768,
0.0006724517,
-0.0347158387,
-0.0299264658,
-0.0189567748,
-0.0099864649,
0.0221876744,
0.0220212582,
-0.0203557517,
-0.0532101803,
-0.0041190702,
-0.0305000525,
0.0002207784,
-0.0224120617,
-0.0255766734,
-0.0255353823,
-0.0025484997,
0.025560366,
-0.0429182015,
-0.0162461847,
-0.0066615762,
-0.0104182316,
0.0177722257,
0.08694987,
0.076179415,
0.0672621578,
0.0020810638,
0.0145067004,
-0.0020201569,
0.0215085335,
-0.0046708635,
-0.0169940349,
-0.0296473783,
0.0371162705,
-0.0154159199,
-0.0353324115,
0.0619452968,
0.0485642515,
0.0580617003,
0.0190090016,
0.0254655741,
-0.014398925,
0.0532002412,
-0.0249271095,
0.0822408125,
-0.0202155281,
0.0205446091,
-0.0058401572,
0.0032012768,
-0.0460438058,
-0.0193305183,
0.00770419,
-0.0114275338,
-0.0073868139,
-0.0361996368,
0.0440088846,
-0.1162906215,
0.0472828038,
0.0407902263,
-0.0266930927,
-0.0273118056,
0.026607668,
0.0722950622,
0.0160034299,
0.0261745974,
0.0110557312,
-0.0545733422,
-0.0577463806,
0.0500175729,
-0.0391432382,
0.0227066912,
0.0152320014,
0.0241321027,
0.0447818264,
0.0179537944,
0.046906665,
-0.0374081545,
0.0278052203,
-0.0671942681,
-0.0246546362,
0.0455249399,
-6.664476977e-33,
0.005791435,
-0.0137602724,
-0.0725729167,
0.0394005291,
-0.0350448117,
0.0138727799,
-0.0269503947,
0.0301151145,
0.0074888882,
0.008567892,
-0.0054031452,
0.0225166995,
0.0015488641,
-0.0216900464,
0.0386025794,
-0.0025554912,
0.0017176409,
0.024757348,
-0.0092434064,
0.0112219816,
0.0465316214,
0.0132730203,
0.0397472717,
-0.1074488685,
0.0369085595,
-0.0151938079,
-0.0527346209,
0.0071594259,
0.046613548,
0.0594415627,
0.008281678,
0.0547359027,
0.0374947563,
0.0307853147,
-0.0184260532,
0.0280568674,
-0.0105069289,
-0.013496696,
0.0250919051,
0.0161527358,
-0.0112324087,
-0.0693567917,
0.0519771203,
-0.0152625162,
-0.0199409202,
0.0351920463,
0.0342065357,
-0.012037456,
0.0575508587,
-0.0608277433,
-0.0251735598,
0.0381314754,
-0.0237972289,
-0.0128133427,
0.0062409132,
0.0432189964,
0.0332226828,
0.0322544947,
-0.0838055685,
0.0487603359,
-0.0151092075,
-0.0096254302,
0.0184591357,
-0.0182799865,
0.0051073963,
0.0802798793,
-0.0000605023,
0.0239123851,
0.0130988173,
0.0262603927,
0.0181453191,
0.0331827253,
0.0727862492,
0.0466340147,
0.0395173728,
-0.0462101921,
-0.0064866613,
0.0214590617,
0.0240143742,
0.0088300686,
0.0132901305,
0.0387747511,
-0.0670287833,
0.0034763152,
0.0339798667,
-0.0127902469,
-0.0263770409,
-0.0951585621,
-0.0089096213,
-0.0551422685,
-0.0363666601,
-0.0073238187,
0.0231535621,
-0.0165849142,
0.0443536863,
0.0125069767,
-0.0178882089,
0.0600015074,
-0.0071306331,
0.0412503295,
-0.0349573158,
0.0176180396,
0.0305151641,
0.0276763905,
0.0272513442,
0.0260971598,
0.0467261747,
0.020123709,
-0.0722266063,
-0.0244099889,
-0.0018334347,
0.0218487121,
-0.0316210724,
0.026182726,
0.0069485088,
0.0431938432,
-0.0147192432,
-0.0399392247,
0.0502658039,
0.0368684083,
-0.0327361636,
0.003023759,
-0.025136305,
0.0011768294,
-0.0033869918,
-0.0210568514,
-0.0426893458,
-0.0178241115,
-0.0141029302,
-0.0467109084,
-0.0050824001,
-0.0388930812,
2.926e-7,
0.0320207141,
0.062606521,
0.005076183,
-0.0336244144,
0.0211257245,
0.0483161956,
-0.038976755,
-0.034014374,
0.0171779618,
0.019548241,
0.0155274197,
0.0280816816,
0.0442681387,
0.0393587649,
-0.0689488649,
-0.0198700037,
-0.0547841042,
0.0003924042,
-0.0314131938,
0.0548058078,
0.0875677317,
0.0516224056,
0.0451513901,
-0.0114195123,
-0.0479290783,
0.0223181732,
0.0374377631,
-0.0445466414,
-0.0010136995,
-0.0201321542,
-0.0320427194,
-0.0064360118,
-0.0049588718,
-0.0288419873,
0.016798906,
-0.062722005,
0.0432408527,
0.0178845264,
0.0099720983,
-0.0049657123,
0.0337038673,
0.0234945975,
-0.0094352076,
-0.0359979644,
0.0094116293,
0.0219572894,
-0.0429003127,
-0.0340240672,
-0.0334447101,
-0.0064589027,
0.0653177723,
-0.0192106143,
-0.0396077074,
0.0114749987,
0.0002580833,
-0.0178083461,
-0.0149258729,
-0.0451794602,
-0.0194546543,
0.0032001419,
-0.0293955617,
-0.0381066315,
-0.0305483919,
0.0295354128,
0.0253100432,
-0.0155842146,
0.0457002558,
2.257183564e-34,
0.0231239293,
-0.0492037684,
0.0028479802,
-0.0169607811,
0.0357726142,
0.0216797609,
-0.0005373411,
-0.0042939694,
0.027192032,
-0.0314114951,
-0.0048970398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06503v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06503v1 | Leveraging Large Language Models and Weak Supervision for Social Media data annotation: an evaluation using COVID-19 self-reported vaccination tweets | 2023-09-12T18:18:23 | 2023-09-12T18:18:23 | Ramya Tekumalla, Juan M. Banda | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI | The COVID-19 pandemic has presented significant challenges to the healthcare
industry and society as a whole. With the rapid development of COVID-19
vaccines, social media platforms have become a popular medium for discussions
on vaccine-related topics. Identifying vaccine-related tweets and analyzing
them can provide valuable insights for public health research-ers and
policymakers. However, manual annotation of a large number of tweets is
time-consuming and expensive. In this study, we evaluate the usage of Large
Language Models, in this case GPT-4 (March 23 version), and weak supervision,
to identify COVID-19 vaccine-related tweets, with the purpose of comparing
performance against human annotators. We leveraged a manu-ally curated
gold-standard dataset and used GPT-4 to provide labels without any additional
fine-tuning or instructing, in a single-shot mode (no additional prompting). | [
0.0493596941,
0.0781352073,
0.0033427181,
-0.027000688,
0.0014493526,
0.0284670573,
0.0320153795,
-0.0214563049,
0.0392442085,
-0.0340351388,
0.0108292438,
-0.0217232779,
-0.0521002449,
0.0142509826,
0.0290361363,
-0.0499610826,
0.0175418667,
0.001403694,
0.0621350259,
0.0279600769,
0.0059362226,
0.0172609575,
0.0009545604,
0.0547920391,
-0.0181103684,
-0.0038005593,
0.023245832,
-0.0158571731,
0.0353564732,
-0.0914006308,
0.054785978,
0.0527652577,
0.0143181775,
0.0850633755,
0.0000017325,
-0.0211788286,
-0.0173042417,
0.021629924,
0.0045243935,
0.0026847618,
0.0610113032,
-0.0658252388,
0.0039958213,
0.0289582964,
-0.0548520125,
-0.0582539774,
0.0894378945,
0.0241932254,
0.0486061685,
0.0681499988,
-0.032625962,
-0.0207302961,
0.0223616492,
-0.0294448063,
0.0200280305,
-0.0377480388,
0.0425027721,
0.0078967921,
0.0085186148,
0.0451163091,
0.0557563007,
0.0712579861,
-0.0189156346,
-0.0348620154,
0.0084239384,
0.0439726785,
-0.057638254,
-0.0338723585,
-0.0049912161,
0.0586314611,
0.0384870023,
-0.019856479,
0.0359268673,
-0.005342504,
-0.0131141869,
0.0197086651,
-0.0477070324,
-0.0099913804,
-0.0001753336,
0.0266181808,
0.0016798151,
0.0079400465,
0.0545457751,
0.0247635487,
0.0170713831,
0.0636949167,
-0.0154176326,
-0.0365633704,
0.0142694823,
0.0272652768,
-0.0302643944,
-0.0495272763,
0.0281818099,
0.0134886894,
-0.0335191414,
0.0166569129,
-0.0210938863,
-0.0648332313,
0.056004446,
-0.0927252099,
-0.0156538095,
-0.0250642523,
-0.0055640792,
0.0488132313,
0.0349370129,
-0.0165346917,
-0.0081057735,
0.0290527157,
0.0434553884,
-0.0094842818,
-0.0853655338,
-0.0122998627,
-0.0252845157,
0.0014456584,
0.0206215512,
0.0325245261,
-0.071052812,
0.0000529178,
-0.0223776866,
-0.0198366698,
-0.0328154713,
-0.0193780139,
-0.0440495349,
0.0273733661,
0.0173602179,
0.0489874929,
-0.0214413833,
0.0116230305,
-0.0102017773,
-0.0352215692,
0.011786419,
0.0085173547,
0.0415058881,
-0.0473121889,
-0.0153722428,
0.0338511094,
0.0271036942,
-0.0205330327,
-0.0006624113,
-0.02271346,
-0.03972378,
-0.0473065414,
-0.0350773633,
-0.0862627402,
0.0184154212,
0.0389411375,
-0.0036363276,
-0.0214291457,
-0.0053468295,
0.0139004756,
-0.0799305141,
0.0354238972,
-0.0537044592,
0.0119215082,
0.0450542644,
0.0163574815,
0.0222415254,
0.0622704588,
0.0091687534,
0.0514855795,
0.0162437186,
-0.0131540457,
0.0375997461,
0.0354806446,
0.0132515384,
0.0296240952,
-0.0028315466,
-0.0086162025,
0.0293679181,
0.0097416909,
-0.021737162,
0.0686480626,
-0.0030896894,
0.0318110436,
0.0740028322,
0.0602369308,
-0.0334530659,
-0.0342866257,
0.0425868668,
0.0405759811,
0.014055728,
-0.0438978001,
-0.026569318,
-0.0051624994,
-0.0147315571,
-0.0325364023,
0.0118337311,
-0.0031083785,
-0.0278752819,
-0.0067666359,
-0.0206067823,
-0.0105773099,
0.0079406193,
-0.0179530457,
0.0388064384,
-0.0421867408,
-0.0181124322,
0.0095917955,
0.0490470491,
-0.0348616317,
0.0011342415,
-0.0494942404,
-0.002505962,
0.0573321693,
0.0132501135,
-0.0136763928,
-0.0661453456,
-0.0426570699,
0.0844540894,
0.0241118148,
0.0389889851,
-0.012559643,
-0.0262171477,
-0.0120700402,
-0.0004866784,
-0.000301546,
0.0417217053,
-0.0156821925,
0.0379912667,
0.0165253319,
-0.0017628688,
0.001182796,
-0.0552029535,
0.0340084136,
0.0077537503,
-0.038180355,
0.0029420019,
0.0017892476,
0.0360505655,
0.0457304083,
0.0330258794,
0.0098185446,
0.027245922,
-0.0350830778,
-0.0122034587,
-0.0226204302,
0.0075361263,
0.0212533269,
0.0364714675,
-0.0264086723,
-0.0464672223,
0.0060212146,
-0.0581624508,
-0.0143948104,
0.035575863,
-0.0315022245,
0.0219354015,
-0.0140947392,
-0.0258850623,
-0.0362122431,
0.005829941,
-0.0056833872,
0.0528003424,
-0.0084912712,
-0.021223288,
0.0068144826,
-0.0595774651,
-0.0273800716,
-0.0188350622,
-0.0074303895,
-0.0037485946,
0.0106945066,
0.0162157696,
0.0306508299,
-0.0093892589,
-0.0371717848,
-0.0114819845,
-0.1199779958,
0.0057244361,
-0.0176254474,
0.0357022695,
0.0226764847,
0.0461099148,
-0.0097149434,
-0.0195744913,
-0.0130041186,
-0.0255696829,
0.0126733575,
0.0451721773,
0.0415201001,
0.0027722453,
0.0071597258,
-0.055493027,
-0.0038464568,
-0.0677672029,
-0.0036062154,
0.0484708361,
-0.0779350102,
0.0199555401,
-0.037797384,
-0.0232662633,
-0.0018001753,
0.0157889705,
-0.0330849811,
0.0321461298,
-0.0168380421,
0.0151602337,
0.0112686725,
-0.0192045327,
0.0617164932,
0.0458583236,
0.0101535609,
-0.0105806449,
0.0235521179,
-0.0246094149,
-0.0622544289,
-0.0034619456,
-0.0139565291,
-0.0080831777,
0.0833850354,
0.0010418177,
0.011887284,
-0.0473392494,
0.0288005788,
-0.0638309345,
0.0026371675,
-0.0423265994,
0.0021129877,
-0.0265196953,
-0.0004336426,
-0.0154149961,
-0.0407417603,
0.0279271565,
0.0260496419,
0.0263656806,
-0.0346516743,
-0.0483583622,
-0.0344114192,
0.0216297004,
-0.0001472371,
0.0003462246,
0.0132827209,
-0.0189401023,
0.0371771045,
-0.0229632929,
-0.0051956186,
-0.0197281912,
0.0027577204,
-0.0112606585,
0.0374884717,
0.0018882921,
-0.0138743771,
-0.0172670558,
-0.0909396186,
-0.1001145765,
0.0055199522,
0.020832289,
-0.0280565154,
-0.0493741818,
0.0363016538,
0.0145284133,
0.0506816916,
-0.008537625,
-0.0174151156,
0.0153644066,
-0.0051655029,
0.0463276133,
-0.057239078,
-0.0245916322,
-0.0271771643,
0.0092189368,
0.0495661423,
0.0326142907,
0.0145654548,
-0.0485354066,
-0.005382346,
-0.0149317915,
-0.0243505388,
-0.0105683384,
0.0123765515,
0.0838438347,
-0.0477175303,
0.0238946341,
0.1193886027,
0.0228097048,
-0.0507469438,
0.0086495858,
0.0199894235,
0.017355524,
-0.0096092122,
0.0230999496,
-0.0826166347,
-0.0307759754,
-0.0150263598,
0.0291185491,
-0.0284512229,
-0.0564056635,
-0.0010182464,
-0.0331294984,
0.0384169668,
0.0176024791,
-0.0385867916,
0.0071631162,
-0.0810068026,
0.0286340546,
-0.0367907919,
0.0037657092,
-0.044636596,
0.0020035447,
0.0088536926,
0.0163742229,
-0.0501151346,
-0.0703869537,
0.0267751701,
-0.0331818722,
0.0543129593,
0.0492233671,
0.0476250015,
-0.0091200294,
-0.0039453818,
0.0387971215,
0.0198113248,
-0.0514527075,
-0.0061573032,
0.0837948993,
-0.0136719439,
0.0009630464,
-0.0408178642,
0.0306492411,
-0.0565844141,
-0.0126634017,
0.0048444946,
0.0970991626,
0.0058487765,
-0.0298496876,
-0.0260663815,
0.0188908782,
0.0328357108,
0.0559143238,
0.0454525128,
-0.0321306773,
-0.0162616652,
-0.0051396401,
0.0317548811,
-0.0402817875,
-0.0313473493,
-0.0104508484,
-0.0194478612,
-0.0841022283,
-0.0245551951,
-0.0350961909,
0.0758274272,
-0.027098434,
-0.0216005351,
-0.0063491389,
0.0380396247,
-0.0164907016,
-0.0190858766,
0.0351832397,
-0.0229100622,
0.0126012461,
-0.0451053716,
-0.0563402697,
0.0120473085,
0.0559627302,
0.0188167877,
0.076188162,
-0.0751091018,
-0.0661163926,
0.0046811933,
-0.0071289921,
0.0279992353,
0.0060842624,
-0.0028162377,
-0.0351240225,
0.0201619975,
0.0875306129,
-0.0235717241,
-0.0633342862,
-0.0154627208,
0.0047941864,
0.0103461575,
0.0203680489,
-0.0080788527,
0.0049895002,
0.0032787581,
0.0208405945,
-0.0435209833,
0.0235216226,
0.0232488308,
-0.0050446331,
0.0613431633,
-0.0151513461,
-0.033876542,
-0.0399582982,
-0.0426528379,
-0.0090402523,
-0.0256517753,
-0.0154676409,
0.0002339382,
0.0226409454,
-0.011766592,
-0.0695742592,
-0.0057212198,
-0.0375813097,
0.0332859457,
-0.085621126,
0.0313399509,
-0.0055933972,
0.0276701879,
0.0237639099,
-0.0326946527,
-0.0094024399,
0.0210530516,
0.0154619925,
0.0082937395,
-0.0101675941,
-0.0167577472,
-0.020837361,
0.0179305542,
0.0304179396,
0.0329707712,
-0.0505984165,
-0.0295540821,
-0.0385224111,
0.0260142945,
0.0319646932,
-0.0302503146,
0.069631435,
-0.0181264952,
-0.0336067118,
-0.0242732968,
0.0401530676,
-0.0165374465,
-0.0023822847,
0.0078618824,
-0.0098306853,
-0.0490823239,
0.0067679337,
0.069277972,
0.0313009247,
0.0685711503,
0.0589371361,
-0.0353526808,
-0.01785326,
0.0147102429,
0.0029421332,
0.0174176022,
-0.0327960178,
0.0341780595,
-0.0337747857,
-0.0491460599,
0.0123950001,
-0.0739851296,
-0.028463928,
0.022220267,
-0.0039646132,
0.0362411216,
-0.0014991487,
-0.0083476864,
-0.0550872833,
0.0102284122,
0.0221751686,
-0.0570143722,
-0.0284897499,
-6.396769159e-33,
0.0130068213,
-0.052275382,
0.0028643743,
-0.0218839739,
0.0031635561,
0.0256797262,
-0.0336729325,
0.0063567678,
0.0152252987,
0.0370221809,
-0.0058932821,
0.0086756889,
0.014222892,
0.0230827238,
0.0592115596,
-0.0086157359,
0.0320489928,
0.0023219858,
0.0049709482,
0.071937263,
0.0138525497,
0.0243578628,
0.0454656892,
-0.1131691411,
0.0786796659,
-0.0077586365,
0.0090115396,
0.0079509858,
0.0382866152,
0.0647182316,
-0.0340751968,
0.0380960405,
0.0378066152,
-0.0120689021,
0.0091360854,
0.0482379943,
-0.0443897732,
-0.0370763205,
-0.0098377177,
-0.0339038298,
-0.036787767,
-0.0677546933,
0.0408312976,
-0.0068531604,
-0.0086356178,
0.0116291987,
0.0308292024,
0.0077231689,
0.0098638386,
-0.0053555639,
-0.0711873844,
0.0611237213,
-0.0355297327,
0.0165018961,
0.0264255852,
0.0232040305,
-0.0196091402,
0.0559265204,
-0.0112323202,
0.0171651766,
0.0273767859,
0.0147274984,
0.0276604798,
-0.0098015228,
-0.0060331845,
0.0322372019,
-0.0034461741,
0.0020316811,
-0.0263621286,
0.00191454,
-0.0292049646,
0.0241070502,
0.0205387454,
0.0154950796,
0.011452998,
-0.009142302,
-0.0881270543,
0.0131078931,
-0.0251130927,
0.0240802225,
0.0065013436,
0.0097527457,
-0.0330620818,
-0.0106676174,
0.0000268734,
-0.0290312059,
-0.0184362344,
-0.0189922862,
-0.0069718254,
-0.0130954897,
-0.0357790515,
0.03413748,
-0.0083647994,
0.0023642383,
-0.0508830659,
-0.0199178997,
0.0228216574,
0.0141794216,
-0.0070198495,
0.0293677058,
-0.0644138232,
-0.0017301008,
0.0172789283,
0.0213922728,
0.0392031707,
0.0055796755,
0.0435083881,
0.0062800786,
-0.0747888386,
-0.0282513499,
-0.0111928843,
0.0427590869,
-0.0597183928,
0.007498608,
0.0331253111,
0.0106075695,
0.0246498995,
0.0558447838,
0.0416037962,
0.0252154823,
0.0216724705,
-0.0394842699,
-0.0441228263,
-0.0269259997,
0.0040121716,
0.0051056286,
-0.0171732455,
0.0357345454,
0.0095132338,
-0.0688906386,
0.0066659893,
-0.0429824181,
2.547e-7,
0.1018365026,
0.1080921143,
-0.0199393481,
-0.0238526668,
0.0252892151,
0.0151741132,
-0.0106652919,
0.0005906989,
-0.0182475112,
-0.0149483401,
0.0116996868,
0.0114400294,
0.0398572646,
0.0468722694,
-0.0640399233,
0.0041971346,
-0.1073763296,
0.0258529577,
-0.0726224929,
0.0027961358,
0.0289958026,
0.0703906938,
0.0154095786,
-0.0073218099,
-0.0275327805,
-0.0382483713,
0.05070493,
-0.0317760073,
-0.0362395272,
0.0429250412,
0.0516906343,
0.0348804891,
0.0160596333,
0.0303567257,
-0.0352606624,
-0.0378008187,
-0.0010326661,
0.0680613592,
-0.0060485895,
0.0274960101,
0.0091353189,
-0.0304222032,
0.0121883629,
-0.0290444978,
0.0645925701,
-0.0653177947,
-0.0856473148,
-0.009989501,
-0.0081049418,
0.0168290939,
0.0504486375,
-0.0102782017,
-0.0278057326,
0.0290391818,
0.0042391713,
0.0023688902,
-0.0537930541,
-0.0407750346,
0.0069784741,
-0.0163751952,
-0.0263442509,
-0.0482629351,
-0.0139807258,
0.0118670147,
-0.006648845,
-0.0368397571,
0.0909564197,
1.953028074e-34,
0.0353773199,
0.0026228228,
-0.010607278,
-0.007124424,
0.0304268356,
0.0199588258,
-0.0005817012,
0.0268720482,
0.0024053359,
-0.0514215529,
0.0271054767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06490v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06490v1 | Leveraging Large Language Models for Automated Dialogue Analysis | 2023-09-12T18:03:55 | 2023-09-12T18:03:55 | Sarah E. Finch, Ellie S. Paek, Jinho D. Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Developing high-performing dialogue systems benefits from the automatic
identification of undesirable behaviors in system responses. However, detecting
such behaviors remains challenging, as it draws on a breadth of general
knowledge and understanding of conversational practices. Although recent
research has focused on building specialized classifiers for detecting specific
dialogue behaviors, the behavior coverage is still incomplete and there is a
lack of testing on real-world human-bot interactions. This paper investigates
the ability of a state-of-the-art large language model (LLM), ChatGPT-3.5, to
perform dialogue behavior detection for nine categories in real human-bot
dialogues. We aim to assess whether ChatGPT can match specialized models and
approximate human performance, thereby reducing the cost of behavior detection
tasks. Our findings reveal that neither specialized models nor ChatGPT have yet
achieved satisfactory results for this task, falling short of human
performance. Nevertheless, ChatGPT shows promising potential and often
outperforms specialized detection models. We conclude with an in-depth
examination of the prevalent shortcomings of ChatGPT, offering guidance for
future research to enhance LLM capabilities. | [
0.0774388686,
0.0436558425,
-0.0252936799,
0.046687454,
-0.029638892,
0.0319889225,
-0.0007354866,
0.0238514431,
0.0351435766,
-0.0767811686,
-0.0294336583,
-0.0294815879,
-0.0236116685,
0.0630510077,
-0.0000539454,
-0.0248609185,
0.0400045104,
-0.0361728817,
0.0236498304,
0.0204527676,
0.0322724506,
0.0037773512,
-0.0193070546,
0.0778574049,
-0.0336071514,
-0.0291791148,
-0.0363156125,
-0.0099609205,
-0.0202060658,
-0.0091865007,
0.0407762378,
0.0616329163,
0.04864005,
0.0641643032,
0.0000017908,
-0.0460404269,
0.0266385544,
-0.0178391356,
-0.0322324634,
0.0164676812,
0.0385833681,
0.0320994332,
-0.0205033608,
0.0394270793,
-0.0432759747,
-0.0134497937,
0.0264214166,
0.0564506799,
0.0733917207,
0.0828645155,
0.0001730074,
0.0161944348,
0.0178190097,
0.0032675839,
0.0004426678,
-0.0590198264,
0.0319822989,
0.0393953621,
0.0183144342,
0.0080209738,
-0.0005030504,
0.0005563134,
-0.0131005133,
-0.0600596108,
-0.0354239568,
0.0150283286,
-0.0653866902,
-0.025926698,
-0.0169240199,
0.0616180748,
-0.0004678086,
-0.0060660024,
0.0183405057,
0.0181614719,
-0.0012834228,
-0.029192606,
-0.0427654609,
0.0196789224,
-0.0016186438,
-0.0325655974,
-0.0208897647,
0.0084300004,
-0.0132337119,
0.0514526591,
-0.0040698689,
0.0086622285,
-0.0143559016,
-0.0174524318,
-0.0139793167,
-0.0097234482,
0.0067975703,
-0.0591384992,
-0.0015552285,
0.0289727002,
-0.0709669217,
0.0078349905,
-0.0246586036,
0.0179950017,
0.028347915,
-0.0261777323,
-0.0046594832,
0.0448742248,
-0.000346685,
0.0581148788,
0.0225536767,
0.0832817405,
-0.0105857234,
-0.0028636795,
-0.0023384436,
-0.0073150583,
-0.0352255777,
-0.0233566947,
-0.0441477112,
-0.0017771609,
-0.0194713753,
-0.052396629,
-0.011841571,
0.0498368591,
0.0011561017,
0.0260245465,
-0.006479538,
0.0025688806,
-0.0237662923,
0.0074214665,
-0.01167983,
-0.0078469003,
-0.0019858631,
0.0193607043,
0.0018503667,
-0.0692690462,
-0.0118978731,
0.0477274545,
-0.0177727286,
-0.0121539533,
0.0134182898,
0.0493915342,
0.0198282879,
-0.030047942,
0.0150726475,
-0.015317685,
-0.0358789116,
-0.072779052,
-0.0289448537,
-0.0357786305,
0.0141198281,
-0.0134424688,
-0.0156088732,
0.0320956111,
0.0175213125,
0.0178821813,
-0.0168896001,
0.0428208038,
-0.0035696768,
0.0201196074,
0.0172499232,
0.0287150685,
-0.0313908346,
0.0656510815,
0.0304282606,
0.008979138,
0.0338622294,
-0.016517248,
0.0538581125,
0.0809092447,
-0.0324270278,
-0.0052971221,
0.0114536034,
0.016567966,
0.0068862899,
-0.0010495227,
0.0234658793,
0.0579895265,
-0.0350524969,
-0.0359874032,
0.0565280542,
0.088189885,
-0.0541847311,
0.0222485568,
0.0421421155,
0.0700205341,
0.026350148,
-0.0052696392,
-0.0139998021,
-0.0357189141,
-0.0302849226,
-0.0547646619,
0.0074199028,
0.003051854,
-0.0370274931,
-0.0305439066,
-0.0034125065,
-0.0094892439,
0.0440363437,
0.0018605519,
0.0283335578,
-0.0255625322,
-0.0360695273,
0.0027328499,
0.0143868318,
-0.0294732396,
-0.0361518413,
-0.0760507584,
0.0364353433,
0.077640228,
0.071308516,
-0.0217523836,
-0.0106579466,
-0.0501554832,
-0.0159546398,
0.0409954078,
0.0355701819,
-0.0284461547,
0.0192921124,
-0.0296821576,
0.0169574525,
0.0137156695,
0.0044411458,
-0.0117717413,
0.0325419381,
-0.021468211,
-0.0151014253,
0.0342529267,
0.0001684733,
0.0142012239,
-0.0130808232,
-0.0042085359,
-0.0150377778,
0.0030554326,
0.0717859864,
-0.0153738456,
-0.0038130926,
-0.0468760431,
-0.0059251874,
-0.0149911139,
-0.0145822968,
0.0282401275,
-0.0303810015,
-0.0547522567,
0.0370233133,
0.0530962981,
-0.0319322832,
0.0374461152,
-0.0248080622,
0.0103331935,
0.0045679095,
-0.0601992086,
0.0222124886,
-0.0464824773,
0.0284739677,
-0.0192918014,
0.0343905464,
-0.0259075537,
0.0181615017,
-0.0111287003,
-0.0111433333,
0.031670481,
0.0063704071,
0.026521774,
-0.0257708188,
-0.028377125,
0.0257464405,
-0.0322544575,
0.0364078619,
0.0475499891,
0.0273814816,
-0.0527875237,
-0.0340251178,
-0.118995741,
0.0128922649,
-0.0161138009,
-0.0075823697,
-0.0028152622,
0.0082799243,
-0.0301587507,
0.0147905257,
-0.0200219024,
-0.0100176139,
0.0469536483,
0.0166634321,
0.0277041458,
-0.0193016026,
-0.0728062168,
-0.0381429791,
0.0519173332,
-0.0092152786,
0.0335116982,
-0.0330245271,
-0.0102418419,
-0.0454676673,
0.0186023954,
0.0049397163,
0.0551714264,
-0.0230946913,
-0.0937292501,
0.0257895831,
0.0146156242,
0.004897329,
0.0939590633,
0.0627096221,
0.0590677634,
-0.0079577332,
-0.0250820853,
-0.0660846904,
0.0409783348,
-0.0011486241,
-0.0286253877,
-0.0592704974,
-0.0201192182,
0.0074432464,
0.0664897561,
-0.0111212935,
0.0406318344,
-0.0398235656,
0.0137933968,
0.0165462419,
-0.0529398359,
-0.0084109139,
-0.0317601524,
-0.0560933352,
0.0099568637,
0.0146766612,
-0.036691796,
0.0640363917,
-0.0339810736,
-0.019676635,
-0.0150214937,
-0.0439350046,
-0.0210045427,
0.0724246278,
0.0061112787,
0.0133872423,
0.0041969488,
-0.0375262462,
-0.0265255328,
-0.0267612394,
-0.0049101734,
-0.0313120559,
0.0392315499,
-0.047889065,
0.007550396,
0.0200864784,
-0.0281299688,
-0.0785600543,
-0.0578493066,
-0.0318880416,
-0.0029337041,
0.002923243,
-0.0442474857,
-0.0319510512,
0.056881737,
-0.009386654,
0.0149398474,
-0.0097723007,
0.0088218171,
-0.0155583303,
-0.0005311107,
0.0607774444,
0.0109628318,
-0.0351684988,
0.008339176,
0.0489301533,
0.0670514032,
-0.0085815145,
0.0325817429,
-0.0287117306,
-0.0153545225,
0.0170536675,
0.0254331883,
-0.0077924719,
0.0152196949,
0.0422746129,
-0.0507112145,
-0.0046120882,
0.1319092214,
0.017216377,
-0.0363173708,
0.0073520145,
-0.0166994613,
0.0322916433,
0.0097728055,
0.0141475508,
-0.0568921156,
-0.0323125646,
-0.0067080688,
-0.0071454998,
-0.0513403565,
-0.0283667818,
-0.0073943548,
-0.1141830012,
0.0275412463,
-0.0111272419,
-0.045184806,
-0.0375070684,
-0.0100141056,
0.0405659378,
-0.0429493189,
0.032382071,
-0.0339367799,
0.0178292505,
-0.0428778678,
0.0102622425,
-0.0640654266,
-0.0054512457,
0.0652374104,
-0.0250641853,
0.0570650473,
0.045000203,
0.0649374574,
0.016726803,
0.0233148001,
0.0421690568,
-0.0007918755,
0.0041555557,
0.0222125035,
0.0389427505,
-0.0173881855,
-0.0005544503,
-0.0145732919,
0.0221931618,
-0.012601153,
0.008074482,
0.0350239687,
0.0415395349,
-0.0346054919,
-0.0049124388,
-0.0166375339,
0.0390281752,
0.0587001629,
0.0839679614,
0.0256701279,
-0.0632912442,
-0.0365873724,
-0.0073548928,
-0.0430964828,
0.0077127507,
-0.0461099073,
-0.0393305793,
0.0284135267,
-0.0175389368,
-0.0587045215,
-0.0377021432,
-0.0017701737,
-0.0100228405,
-0.0270547792,
-0.0070270449,
-0.0073395357,
0.0580931641,
0.0293331519,
0.018347403,
-0.0284037609,
0.0323527791,
-0.0408211872,
0.0031543982,
0.0553452,
-0.0193159208,
-0.028851077,
0.03525085,
-0.0777465254,
-0.0560837165,
-0.0149529651,
0.0421192683,
0.0185164791,
0.0704629719,
-0.0150380721,
-0.018284712,
-0.0265008919,
0.0175974965,
-0.028597571,
-0.0018030225,
0.0289077144,
0.0364732891,
-0.0280288849,
0.0211609863,
-0.0108014736,
0.0242251698,
-0.0327437557,
-0.017214708,
-0.0851241052,
-0.0989861935,
0.0116231795,
-0.0099718003,
0.0253803078,
0.0286291465,
-0.0203585159,
-0.0005450741,
-0.0181625783,
-0.003586136,
-0.028433064,
-0.0542626791,
-0.0158725455,
-0.015205102,
-0.0299926922,
-0.0090428498,
-0.0223218612,
-0.0428005233,
0.0354011916,
-0.0013264272,
0.0130204586,
0.0046650865,
0.0211992674,
0.0118790437,
-0.0067817173,
-0.0284968708,
0.0101833474,
0.0258541126,
0.0141119445,
0.0059009157,
0.1017252952,
-0.011855877,
-0.0498892143,
0.0404701345,
0.0320006795,
-0.0247528013,
-0.0593268164,
0.0091487234,
0.0172418281,
0.020915851,
-0.0219178349,
0.0403508283,
-0.0367443375,
-0.0010218472,
-0.0235652663,
0.0588046573,
-0.016612744,
-0.0282421838,
-0.0051983171,
0.0310293529,
-0.042489849,
-0.0006834195,
0.0521931425,
0.0122573031,
0.0268497411,
0.029108651,
-0.0252527557,
-0.0367693081,
-0.0372942835,
0.0522356406,
0.0048369044,
0.0143421255,
0.0420964956,
-0.0380100645,
-0.0377700329,
-0.0390957482,
-0.0249223839,
0.0235391594,
-0.0154635115,
0.0201403759,
0.0680783242,
-0.0251916386,
0.0093767149,
-0.0433129147,
-0.0122813322,
-0.0206348002,
-0.0127367219,
-0.0538732186,
-5.231861237e-33,
-0.0114960419,
-0.062736541,
0.0222291723,
0.0195851922,
-0.038843248,
-0.0201057028,
-0.0295033921,
-0.000216524,
-0.0410977043,
-0.0015877475,
-0.0035039128,
0.0202726796,
-0.0017922083,
-0.0108641032,
-0.0056421589,
-0.0105377361,
0.0640112609,
-0.0140434178,
-0.0428822227,
0.0371078029,
0.0428020135,
-0.0306484513,
0.0257052649,
-0.0991280302,
-0.0201933533,
-0.0081043346,
-0.0440400019,
0.0384173431,
0.0116599668,
0.0673416331,
-0.0271104295,
0.0410786867,
0.0164824463,
-0.0043296376,
0.012321067,
0.0531046875,
-0.0009452429,
0.0114056421,
0.0085818246,
0.0279947221,
0.0226673428,
-0.0078435391,
-0.0085814884,
-0.0138963414,
-0.0397747196,
0.012801406,
0.0252067689,
-0.0148378387,
0.020024417,
0.0203262605,
-0.0695459619,
0.0236114115,
-0.0471548699,
-0.0818630829,
0.0009127998,
0.0659252927,
0.0196958091,
0.0002140964,
-0.0138180936,
0.027966477,
-0.0174530558,
-0.0106308581,
0.037532188,
0.0118244644,
0.0491845906,
0.0885146484,
0.0127028823,
0.054758694,
-0.0045968061,
-0.0498870015,
-0.0058617471,
0.0509714112,
0.0085074138,
0.0201045033,
-0.0142062129,
-0.030571688,
-0.0410071909,
0.0045804982,
0.0746276751,
0.0495930128,
0.0304578785,
0.0089368382,
-0.0791633725,
-0.0184558183,
0.0044144732,
0.0233502891,
-0.0037910871,
-0.030790437,
0.0296490453,
0.029227687,
0.0150260599,
-0.0344124883,
0.0546549372,
-0.0739292949,
0.0031474594,
0.0561099052,
-0.0459453613,
-0.0178140122,
-0.0025767477,
0.0088087162,
-0.0307550449,
-0.0620323829,
0.0312525481,
-0.0284434855,
0.0300598517,
0.0105439965,
0.0144214714,
0.0317927338,
-0.0425727628,
-0.0160409752,
-0.0054773493,
0.0444329865,
-0.0502100512,
0.0601945706,
0.0069486313,
-0.0223078597,
-0.0292413067,
0.0823004991,
-0.0243405271,
-0.0093070678,
-0.045718912,
-0.0165079031,
-0.011004311,
-0.0243516024,
-0.0371855497,
0.0078964289,
-0.0262796879,
-0.0271076523,
0.0043067965,
-0.0231239907,
0.0107085351,
-0.0618102215,
2.452e-7,
-0.0344469063,
0.0562948473,
-0.0030151666,
0.0447135195,
0.0297852941,
0.070241116,
0.0075891176,
0.0091875754,
0.0213368163,
-0.0212968513,
0.043285951,
0.0092937732,
0.0650489107,
0.0238289926,
-0.0699608997,
-0.0237646252,
-0.081304349,
-0.0443234891,
-0.0544916391,
-0.0096328026,
0.0354371518,
0.0926039815,
0.0125348354,
-0.0123768393,
0.012345653,
-0.0725993142,
0.0459749401,
-0.0346174352,
-0.0502884202,
0.0488426834,
0.0096999444,
0.0284656212,
0.0277357027,
0.0294209179,
0.0066402024,
0.0438709036,
0.0019054901,
0.0970837623,
-0.0199665744,
-0.0133847557,
-0.008538588,
0.002915303,
0.0000294305,
-0.0521637462,
0.0417094454,
-0.0391951501,
-0.0066002416,
-0.0525729731,
0.0202512518,
-0.0441068374,
0.020215068,
-0.0350983888,
0.0161957592,
0.0322163068,
-0.0026286461,
-0.0384604745,
0.0115033127,
-0.0654023662,
-0.0038505443,
-0.0355012678,
-0.0859948248,
-0.0580548011,
0.0001730454,
-0.0087588876,
-0.002042552,
-0.004651288,
0.0317984372,
1.885824694e-34,
0.0357438102,
0.0050093299,
0.0103632202,
0.0514407381,
0.076570794,
0.0391020104,
0.029881902,
0.0230464488,
0.0451092012,
-0.0480333492,
0.012381942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06460v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06460v1 | Widely Interpretable Semantic Representation: Frameless Meaning Representation for Broader Applicability | 2023-09-12T17:44:40 | 2023-09-12T17:44:40 | Lydia Feng, Gregor Williamson, Han He, Jinho D. Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents a novel semantic representation, WISeR, that overcomes
challenges for Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR). Despite its strengths,
AMR is not easily applied to languages or domains without predefined semantic
frames, and its use of numbered arguments results in semantic role labels,
which are not directly interpretable and are semantically overloaded for
parsers. We examine the numbered arguments of predicates in AMR and convert
them to thematic roles that do not require reference to semantic frames. We
create a new corpus of 1K English dialogue sentences annotated in both WISeR
and AMR. WISeR shows stronger inter-annotator agreement for beginner and
experienced annotators, with beginners becoming proficient in WISeR annotation
more quickly. Finally, we train a state-of-the-art parser on the AMR 3.0 corpus
and a WISeR corpus converted from AMR 3.0. The parser is evaluated on these
corpora and our dialogue corpus. The WISeR model exhibits higher accuracy than
its AMR counterpart across the board, demonstrating that WISeR is easier for
parsers to learn. | [
0.027596347,
0.0289868433,
-0.0263917372,
0.0630270243,
-0.0164732877,
0.0332194082,
-0.0325192772,
-0.0315493941,
-0.0135357352,
-0.0901501253,
-0.0165804736,
0.0293699298,
-0.0539160781,
0.0362308472,
-0.0345767699,
-0.0664147064,
0.0543579087,
0.0234148204,
0.0734165311,
0.0214807019,
0.0176022295,
0.0236991104,
-0.016139701,
0.0554281175,
-0.0467057079,
-0.0299359392,
-0.0162004121,
-0.0154053094,
0.0316492692,
-0.0326629244,
0.0096290652,
0.0176484883,
0.0449896529,
0.0223360658,
0.0000020886,
-0.0505159274,
-0.0183624178,
0.0091141937,
-0.0322702453,
-0.0375978351,
0.0369217023,
-0.0314300433,
0.0003489467,
-0.0202667806,
-0.0377806127,
-0.0423018336,
0.0127059035,
0.0390214585,
0.0765749812,
0.0559319481,
-0.02024436,
-0.0280779004,
0.0059842868,
0.0175166037,
-0.0119822631,
-0.0506245904,
-0.0366932005,
0.0658025965,
-0.008605035,
0.0099119153,
-0.0360069573,
0.0195332859,
0.0021555454,
-0.0307980236,
-0.0199391618,
-0.006278988,
-0.053669598,
-0.0165962316,
0.0242432989,
0.0431233123,
0.0411968231,
-0.003608743,
-0.0118497163,
-0.0173781887,
-0.0000534189,
0.0058778049,
-0.0138998972,
0.0641431957,
0.0119090099,
0.0279302616,
0.0627122521,
0.0828732699,
-0.0258668065,
-0.0026855965,
-0.0247924235,
0.071533531,
-0.0122238826,
0.0169155877,
0.0037120117,
0.0228037182,
-0.045113679,
-0.018533038,
0.0109171597,
-0.0164114702,
-0.0168801118,
0.0406748354,
-0.0497510619,
0.0004394161,
0.0225530304,
-0.0341764316,
-0.0090414416,
0.0673127621,
-0.0105586015,
0.0347749293,
0.0167195797,
0.0079688523,
-0.0010174537,
0.0181672443,
-0.0448223948,
-0.0373098403,
-0.0641770288,
0.0063609849,
-0.0704573467,
0.0499327965,
-0.0686109439,
-0.0293836556,
-0.0206731204,
0.0423219837,
-0.0150030702,
-0.0047000581,
0.0129390294,
-0.015138818,
-0.0319342054,
0.0307847299,
-0.0331522524,
0.0449663401,
-0.0127144465,
0.0131108686,
-0.0192892607,
-0.0833405107,
-0.012479079,
0.0250189379,
0.012023326,
-0.0397452638,
-0.0641081482,
0.0514786541,
0.0047416007,
-0.0187367406,
0.0160402022,
-0.0654166415,
-0.0222930107,
0.0016441463,
-0.058913406,
-0.0290435124,
0.0313338004,
0.0208550487,
0.0426632911,
-0.0263744537,
0.0049293591,
0.004927916,
0.0277373902,
0.0387926809,
-0.0316360183,
-0.0264432263,
-0.0054589794,
0.0145795019,
0.0054102819,
0.0436153635,
0.01645061,
0.0000349865,
0.0322266184,
0.0234716982,
-0.0554411598,
-0.0116721215,
-0.0121274423,
-0.0406441763,
0.0600690544,
0.0222962238,
-0.0203963611,
0.007996696,
0.0189523771,
0.0191504098,
-0.0302628651,
-0.0104672303,
0.0124519151,
0.0042280713,
0.0035172051,
-0.0056732292,
0.0660889149,
0.0680866092,
-0.0136766611,
-0.0271569826,
-0.0481293313,
0.0092666214,
0.0030017409,
0.0102309445,
-0.0274111144,
-0.0439223647,
0.0020399191,
-0.0333743244,
0.0069793346,
-0.0288761761,
-0.0228572097,
-0.0008133791,
0.015335313,
0.0313858725,
-0.0172185935,
0.0867038593,
0.0185346976,
-0.0649116039,
-0.0103103304,
0.0074202642,
0.011249654,
0.0399715342,
-0.0062970617,
-0.0358964875,
-0.0492855348,
-0.0526410565,
0.0415637903,
0.0257844515,
0.0543802492,
-0.0274857562,
0.034928374,
-0.0433362909,
-0.0210401416,
-0.02976932,
0.0238067377,
-0.004086507,
-0.0524515212,
-0.0063822772,
-0.00026837,
0.0111954948,
-0.0112481238,
0.0075267195,
0.0409518182,
-0.0182947051,
-0.0059073707,
0.0074116741,
0.0589556731,
0.0537725016,
0.0050742845,
-0.0013398248,
0.0247692838,
-0.0432100371,
-0.0050103702,
0.0936174989,
-0.0911174342,
-0.0582877547,
0.0003819407,
-0.0418809466,
-0.0520517267,
0.0111996401,
-0.0569074415,
-0.0535845459,
-0.0171010811,
-0.0501028039,
0.0388024151,
-0.0349683687,
-0.0260706693,
0.0115917576,
-0.0130879935,
-0.0261129942,
0.0630511269,
0.0151388422,
-0.03060464,
-0.0250372551,
0.0199898612,
0.0560686588,
-0.030742811,
-0.0233514458,
0.006461801,
-0.0050979625,
-0.0185787082,
0.0555408597,
-0.0414936766,
-0.0291275326,
0.0063469843,
-0.0754276812,
0.0227024034,
-0.0222116727,
0.0195117425,
0.0783135742,
-0.0067696539,
0.0381136239,
-0.0102649732,
-0.0182038173,
-0.0078994716,
0.0026727922,
-0.0014484044,
0.0328199901,
0.0194863286,
-0.012514825,
0.0024692125,
0.0249912813,
-0.0453599766,
0.0245683063,
0.0040657301,
-0.0222667456,
-0.0219150018,
0.0220261551,
0.0048501212,
0.0005963515,
0.0029372612,
0.0009177044,
-0.000519101,
-0.0134769166,
-0.0677961782,
0.0047377441,
0.010647879,
0.0739843547,
0.0123443725,
-0.0217837747,
-0.0593382232,
0.0052036592,
0.0277178288,
-0.008719408,
-0.0508229956,
-0.0489857905,
-0.0095994566,
0.0683072805,
0.0290157218,
0.016818773,
-0.0555361696,
0.0052582081,
-0.0690299124,
-0.02609412,
-0.0303241052,
-0.0004041783,
-0.0158739239,
0.046521578,
0.0085027488,
0.0181726757,
0.0620119497,
0.0156740453,
-0.033219371,
-0.0759595856,
0.0027963286,
-0.0595742762,
0.067017898,
-0.0368766822,
0.0312373955,
0.0100914678,
-0.0628218353,
0.0072286506,
-0.0340880528,
0.0577741489,
0.0070327814,
0.0727130324,
-0.0458430797,
0.0111130085,
-0.0209381357,
-0.0349423587,
-0.0290353969,
-0.077185683,
-0.0523128398,
0.0379131623,
-0.0239717755,
0.0557290278,
-0.0378313884,
-0.0157354251,
-0.0145076504,
-0.0081118252,
0.0169608872,
-0.0008232161,
-0.0316748545,
0.0228527375,
0.0200867038,
0.0302888304,
-0.0215706266,
0.0675835833,
0.0838484317,
0.0454418808,
-0.0713984594,
0.0057167811,
-0.0635800213,
0.0330460258,
-0.0019040598,
-0.0559656136,
-0.0519994721,
-0.0280998927,
0.0807436779,
-0.0542847626,
0.0010149587,
0.13104105,
0.034194544,
0.0039759628,
0.0197276324,
-0.0208241902,
0.0061693122,
0.0216754209,
0.0201562587,
-0.0985913649,
-0.0512358397,
-0.0152667351,
-0.0292300619,
-0.0107835522,
-0.0375833958,
0.0144082364,
-0.0760147199,
0.0340398178,
0.0011429425,
0.0038695589,
0.0443148799,
-0.0143300379,
-0.0231618006,
-0.0746007338,
0.0062848562,
-0.02522441,
-0.0076064612,
0.0270112678,
-0.0010700853,
-0.0035732191,
-0.0009207414,
0.0478490815,
-0.0060628974,
0.0340397321,
0.0225242823,
0.0601174422,
-0.0129489535,
0.0175663531,
-0.0158207882,
-0.071141392,
0.0234864093,
0.0017652564,
0.0331313983,
-0.0161658246,
-0.0124552269,
-0.0148403831,
0.0164154973,
-0.0298804324,
-0.040446505,
0.0059162006,
0.0545901693,
-0.0313837975,
0.0640820563,
-0.0022176665,
0.0171526689,
0.014038261,
0.0824061558,
0.0161696225,
0.0208562855,
-0.0172053482,
-0.0429516174,
0.0163201727,
-0.0142629463,
-0.0106131481,
0.0000040854,
-0.0152805028,
0.0003877529,
-0.0432309918,
-0.0649494454,
0.0279639754,
-0.0126615204,
-0.0097770812,
-0.0137226935,
0.0131631223,
-0.0013691538,
-0.0441452861,
0.0135197137,
-0.0112131536,
0.025711894,
-0.0173459295,
-0.0227030851,
0.0677365139,
0.0029006873,
-0.0400942601,
0.0126509229,
0.0533364154,
-0.0273422748,
0.017065905,
0.0618992001,
0.0156337768,
0.0598889962,
-0.026698051,
-0.0047550211,
0.0290373601,
-0.0251539405,
-0.0351360105,
0.0036802832,
0.0525529571,
0.0620008595,
-0.0078549283,
0.0381069556,
-0.0284495223,
0.0573380627,
-0.0415763855,
0.0465842932,
-0.0387279652,
-0.0098834885,
0.0539393798,
0.0304746162,
0.0222081728,
0.0191365276,
0.0053811525,
0.0136072272,
0.0145832412,
-0.0715942308,
-0.0471580848,
-0.0428115949,
0.0364447385,
0.0190261956,
-0.0608172715,
-0.0230905842,
0.035663873,
-0.0276206508,
-0.0051971688,
0.0111035649,
0.0476654284,
0.0282044876,
0.0179916788,
-0.0558288619,
0.0302888528,
-0.0540134832,
-0.0069587305,
0.0052097309,
0.0481199622,
-0.0087894909,
0.0548515134,
0.0045874603,
-0.0077992817,
-0.0037414099,
0.0439802594,
-0.0437692888,
-0.020788854,
0.0384700522,
0.0043418109,
0.0331892483,
-0.0416346043,
0.0911468118,
-0.0132938633,
0.0158912148,
0.0116008846,
0.0659330711,
0.0349635892,
-0.046076607,
0.0497004986,
0.0174211506,
-0.0258180182,
-0.0218752883,
0.0416526683,
-0.069271788,
0.023888072,
0.0284084287,
-0.0108145671,
-0.0658678859,
-0.0088829659,
0.0180764254,
0.0548435263,
-0.0149086583,
-0.010030848,
-0.0362262055,
-0.0200527962,
0.0118484627,
-0.0153081687,
0.0272365101,
-0.0096797068,
0.0181035213,
0.013472314,
0.0202000421,
-0.0507948659,
-0.04348699,
-0.0328789279,
-0.0494643487,
0.0257378519,
-0.0779668763,
-5.734584538e-33,
-0.0460038483,
0.0308793355,
-0.0258857887,
0.006137101,
-0.0237298869,
0.0125732683,
-0.0541827753,
-0.0178138819,
-0.0024173157,
0.0560988523,
0.0229003076,
0.0028591219,
0.0254758187,
0.0163810048,
0.0215677824,
-0.0325121135,
0.0667846277,
0.0147692366,
-0.0094938958,
0.0177866481,
0.0986231789,
0.0036609897,
0.0405329205,
-0.0839510188,
0.0254452173,
0.0093349395,
-0.0243600253,
0.0163798127,
0.0162015166,
0.0547632016,
0.0254484825,
0.0442903712,
0.0172896851,
-0.0070693539,
-0.032068003,
0.0027845856,
-0.1005083695,
-0.0345312208,
0.0515329279,
0.049906753,
0.0028952151,
-0.0616245009,
-0.0184449237,
-0.0332501791,
-0.0118840877,
0.0024081147,
0.0396189727,
-0.0142812794,
-0.0028279673,
-0.011121776,
-0.0612572357,
0.0069659082,
-0.0467709154,
-0.0388302729,
0.0346998386,
0.0253105182,
0.0256062914,
-0.0238785185,
-0.0420484953,
-0.0097755259,
-0.0656763241,
0.0090979887,
0.0085045705,
-0.0296626389,
-0.0134784235,
0.0686736479,
-0.0231912453,
-0.0387091301,
0.0218785182,
0.0272098985,
-0.0391609967,
0.0561320782,
-0.0118212486,
0.0481041186,
0.0344406851,
0.0293368865,
-0.0409658588,
0.0108820433,
0.0136047583,
0.0875350311,
-0.0194155052,
0.0282569677,
-0.0617634133,
-0.0008580355,
-0.046120923,
-0.0033938505,
-0.0120019708,
-0.048036065,
0.0326413102,
-0.0567205846,
-0.0283942875,
0.0584260412,
0.0447006598,
-0.0597336702,
0.0249730796,
-0.0017263885,
0.0040396447,
0.0048666857,
-0.0152847422,
0.0149754724,
0.0235089641,
-0.0284960251,
0.0185986497,
-0.0065506734,
0.0441176333,
0.0147511493,
0.0817528442,
0.0015655359,
-0.0096428571,
0.0226080474,
-0.0173151158,
-0.0063457671,
-0.0613499768,
0.024881145,
0.0182052404,
0.0278105494,
-0.0365164541,
0.0369704254,
-0.0037204025,
0.0000250414,
-0.0134122521,
0.0134179946,
0.0013401974,
0.0092929238,
-0.0342131034,
-0.0084201237,
-0.0022611076,
-0.0026378757,
0.025704531,
-0.0378347412,
-0.0084846653,
-0.0215779953,
2.773e-7,
0.0387860946,
0.0306443553,
0.0278474651,
-0.0259771924,
0.0069715511,
0.0100684073,
0.0131768333,
0.0626510829,
-0.0162487868,
0.0016143995,
-0.0099279229,
-0.0173057411,
-0.0045319689,
0.0213261079,
-0.085043259,
0.0109295007,
-0.0267055836,
-0.0214225259,
-0.0162581801,
0.0659628436,
0.1128855795,
0.0866000727,
0.0027930716,
0.0357744619,
0.0156197846,
-0.0006013109,
0.0402532965,
-0.0231080111,
-0.004276962,
0.0175193809,
-0.01902554,
-0.0101024359,
0.0053776228,
0.013446209,
-0.0065969992,
0.0314908065,
-0.015565034,
0.078371197,
-0.0226038024,
-0.0117588723,
-0.0605864227,
-0.0192632712,
0.0315749049,
-0.0094436705,
0.044720266,
-0.0635430664,
-0.0698139146,
-0.0061206445,
-0.0891567171,
0.0015776952,
-0.0136358514,
0.0400457717,
0.0072963643,
0.017484758,
0.0141391689,
-0.0262037497,
-0.0171688031,
-0.0429765098,
-0.0116425101,
-0.0301712789,
-0.0046890741,
-0.0332341976,
0.0242332574,
-0.012285606,
0.0286844689,
-0.0649926662,
-0.0181749798,
2.141204975e-34,
0.0244454667,
0.0285883993,
0.0479183234,
0.0256896149,
0.0400871858,
0.0096960431,
-0.0056332205,
0.0353770591,
0.0337738395,
-0.0395931192,
0.002408915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07172v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.07172v1 | Exploring Large Language Models for Ontology Alignment | 2023-09-12T17:01:02 | 2023-09-12T17:01:02 | Yuan He, Jiaoyan Chen, Hang Dong, Ian Horrocks | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | This work investigates the applicability of recent generative Large Language
Models (LLMs), such as the GPT series and Flan-T5, to ontology alignment for
identifying concept equivalence mappings across ontologies. To test the
zero-shot performance of Flan-T5-XXL and GPT-3.5-turbo, we leverage challenging
subsets from two equivalence matching datasets of the OAEI Bio-ML track, taking
into account concept labels and structural contexts. Preliminary findings
suggest that LLMs have the potential to outperform existing ontology alignment
systems like BERTMap, given careful framework and prompt design. | [
-0.0109366784,
0.076826416,
-0.002387007,
0.0405137762,
-0.0525016263,
0.0241384991,
-0.0435791388,
0.0202024039,
-0.050957676,
-0.0366173461,
-0.0327607766,
-0.0049968306,
0.013400984,
0.0155596081,
-0.0176862422,
0.0030342911,
0.011977586,
0.0388667285,
-0.0605315529,
-0.0146022895,
0.0044902172,
0.0375580005,
0.007796817,
0.0316880122,
0.0285987221,
-0.0363754965,
0.031565588,
-0.024335051,
0.0568769835,
-0.0149849113,
-0.0139942775,
0.019107759,
0.0097278263,
0.1053672358,
0.0000014566,
-0.0800635889,
-0.024864668,
0.043238651,
0.0161666255,
0.0302637052,
0.0122513063,
-0.0218710471,
0.0266028512,
0.0047274879,
0.0062255505,
-0.0443712026,
0.0845042095,
0.0066530383,
-0.005511275,
-0.0069319499,
-0.0163399391,
-0.0685187429,
0.0508090444,
0.0042739022,
0.0200737491,
-0.016788058,
0.0456044115,
0.011038335,
0.0109051988,
0.0059851683,
0.0108447345,
0.0292679109,
-0.0562289283,
-0.0109637752,
-0.0133228563,
0.032677792,
0.0192966703,
0.0128830951,
0.0253216829,
0.0578669161,
0.0064198361,
-0.0479588769,
0.0053906594,
0.0000462818,
-0.039267689,
0.0267240889,
-0.0123233963,
0.0217353515,
-0.0102241058,
0.0448929258,
0.0511133298,
-0.01816855,
0.0216034576,
0.0162745658,
-0.0291646477,
0.0786082,
0.0603370219,
-0.0255624112,
-0.0403079055,
-0.024416076,
-0.0179169942,
-0.0381661914,
-0.0385711119,
0.0179010555,
-0.0242256131,
-0.0005454504,
-0.0447577089,
0.0071250931,
0.0445756055,
-0.0344416425,
0.0155692538,
0.0604689755,
-0.0277504642,
0.0338355042,
-0.0086157471,
0.064881973,
-0.034587618,
-0.0097841835,
-0.0384886675,
-0.0523535982,
-0.1185595691,
0.0213085935,
0.0034790507,
-0.0126185715,
0.032221321,
-0.0174837895,
-0.0721802637,
0.005693499,
-0.0304777883,
0.0325796381,
-0.0237575807,
-0.0527502783,
0.0182292312,
0.0214907825,
-0.0309403744,
0.0198308863,
0.0201600827,
0.0113684786,
-0.0471154116,
-0.0382083952,
0.0373383574,
0.0054395362,
0.0020659897,
-0.0396381877,
-0.0084258402,
0.0445255153,
0.0316301771,
0.0180446059,
-0.0382926986,
0.0030912352,
0.0125224888,
-0.029921772,
-0.0074096769,
-0.0510822125,
0.0400958396,
0.0011554962,
0.0017695121,
-0.022467209,
-0.0103487894,
0.0061860569,
-0.0459698215,
0.0932511389,
-0.0307207368,
0.0272447038,
0.0296946596,
-0.0261067096,
-0.0031552443,
0.0007443675,
-0.0186563022,
-0.0476785079,
0.0234142002,
-0.0275078882,
-0.038980931,
0.01890851,
-0.0060369675,
-0.001482924,
-0.0192053225,
0.0424349606,
0.0789853483,
0.0774365142,
0.0577670708,
0.0475052595,
0.0060844989,
-0.0067687617,
0.0383563191,
0.0575856492,
0.0321041495,
0.0092416573,
0.0112879733,
-0.0001511733,
-0.0129313627,
-0.0484583303,
-0.039630264,
-0.0157764051,
-0.0248898398,
0.0309343487,
0.0187724624,
0.0390292443,
-0.0171059705,
0.0591366924,
-0.0708415732,
0.0304111261,
-0.0792829916,
-0.0108657349,
0.0264237933,
-0.0336649977,
0.0280898586,
0.0621116646,
0.0488604493,
-0.0141630489,
0.0047977222,
-0.0428731814,
0.0289385449,
0.0512862392,
0.040730577,
-0.018507652,
-0.0665239617,
0.0094553158,
-0.06286937,
0.0693795756,
0.0188919567,
-0.0364917591,
-0.054493662,
-0.0312924236,
-0.011783069,
0.0023674739,
0.0109482324,
0.0119968252,
0.0145831425,
0.0404293947,
0.014357185,
-0.0992046669,
-0.0134179601,
0.0502143875,
-0.0095536513,
0.009945889,
-0.0212452132,
-0.0051585035,
0.058213938,
0.0022414092,
-0.0462934896,
0.0062587913,
-0.0006756011,
-0.0363587774,
-0.0072446717,
-0.0050323592,
0.0070640007,
0.0149161378,
0.1092579663,
-0.0067107398,
-0.0247601606,
0.050037235,
-0.0404152274,
-0.0184922144,
-0.0249257386,
0.0340695269,
0.0450571664,
-0.0438003354,
0.05292698,
-0.0282568894,
-0.0108601786,
-0.0068228734,
0.0486922637,
0.0168462805,
0.0351376273,
-0.0283994265,
-0.0131979771,
0.0248520821,
0.0045851255,
-0.0266080275,
0.0408269018,
-0.0108095547,
0.0140116401,
0.0021951951,
-0.0043033119,
-0.0290110689,
0.0255709123,
-0.0470086522,
0.0561613962,
0.0498430617,
0.0480555594,
0.0428883657,
-0.01103538,
0.013705519,
0.051954437,
-0.0578250103,
-0.001488604,
-0.0076587307,
0.0018264896,
0.0289891008,
-0.040391732,
-0.0624077171,
-0.0262477156,
0.0154532315,
-0.0409888253,
0.0467604138,
-0.0178654548,
0.0044445731,
-0.0277657788,
-0.0061876648,
-0.065253973,
0.0096418122,
0.0111293644,
0.0031200941,
-0.0345815457,
0.027877653,
0.0136540746,
-0.0262332037,
0.0146028763,
-0.0267982818,
0.073311381,
0.0285697412,
-0.0247228742,
-0.0233400464,
0.0134725533,
-0.0688983724,
0.0024617736,
-0.0366471186,
0.0023347044,
0.0238481015,
-0.0374466926,
-0.0185163245,
-0.0473131575,
0.0074602058,
-0.0331417806,
0.0686579123,
-0.036705859,
0.0251579843,
0.0068848873,
-0.0008118797,
-0.0169546567,
0.0092975534,
0.0393223763,
-0.0411235057,
0.0569548719,
-0.0109387562,
0.0125353923,
-0.0355888121,
0.067705676,
0.0015985278,
0.037931975,
0.0390857086,
0.0125901019,
0.0028522026,
-0.0048647053,
0.0493383519,
-0.0159996469,
0.0258095674,
-0.0304921214,
0.0888611898,
-0.0302843265,
-0.0190877579,
-0.019599406,
0.0542160571,
-0.0289093461,
0.0604697093,
0.0186544769,
-0.0525862388,
-0.0650198162,
0.046608679,
-0.0258038547,
0.0045928815,
0.0473468192,
-0.0073260497,
-0.0180297531,
0.0286435746,
0.0678500161,
-0.0242915396,
-0.001908945,
0.036008209,
0.029140573,
-0.0023256231,
0.0184118431,
0.000410165,
-0.0048008552,
-0.0224606115,
0.0436120294,
-0.0970167667,
0.0227317736,
0.0033828386,
-0.0209531076,
0.0257906411,
0.0133575983,
0.1021482572,
0.0447283275,
-0.00058069,
0.0102832606,
-0.0089060105,
-0.0031697277,
-0.0163226966,
-0.0082997596,
-0.0835699141,
-0.0215819497,
0.006878647,
-0.0031166582,
-0.0105264243,
-0.0381955504,
0.0023045335,
-0.0907004923,
0.046478413,
-0.0015440908,
-0.0846619532,
-0.0375715271,
-0.0226459894,
0.0501933806,
-0.0611258559,
0.0025269096,
-0.0077086962,
-0.0052324142,
-0.006747873,
-0.0042450433,
0.0336491354,
-0.0507534854,
0.0637938753,
-0.0816688761,
0.0595087558,
0.0147727076,
0.040770635,
0.0152294636,
-0.0374315567,
-0.0016593087,
-0.0351622812,
-0.0703713745,
0.0234726835,
0.0052337134,
-0.019642042,
0.0132143945,
-0.0163260251,
0.0299430918,
-0.0412426181,
-0.008698117,
0.003564724,
0.0527271815,
0.0014823235,
-0.0218268968,
-0.0235479157,
-0.0095493812,
-0.0409399159,
0.0897644237,
-0.0060873502,
-0.0072851041,
-0.0001582702,
0.0139655303,
-0.0314941518,
0.0185164697,
-0.0152254412,
0.0210846681,
-0.0689326748,
-0.0491194986,
-0.0283446424,
0.0378344283,
0.0085087577,
-0.0246923715,
0.0321134143,
0.0231471285,
0.0070615783,
-0.0365207531,
-0.0674275681,
0.0138090365,
-0.0595592707,
0.0250747241,
-0.0510700755,
-0.0247359946,
0.1108102426,
0.0235637948,
-0.0178186484,
0.0153700784,
-0.0407468751,
-0.0580110103,
-0.0078105922,
-0.0393852033,
0.0201981924,
0.0200445708,
0.0121714333,
0.0158834103,
0.0603761673,
0.0662933066,
-0.0390227884,
0.0062197866,
-0.0476093628,
0.025095107,
-0.005663042,
0.0582889169,
-0.0417486206,
-0.0035896024,
0.0197074097,
0.0610348098,
0.0159618892,
-0.0423390083,
0.0616289899,
0.0458279215,
0.0227129664,
-0.0415489227,
-0.0532944351,
-0.0323199555,
-0.0214436278,
-0.0044755186,
-0.0282604452,
-0.0013256669,
-0.0113836518,
0.0480284803,
0.0175908003,
-0.0023614625,
0.0197420362,
-0.00728931,
0.0205869526,
-0.0203989781,
-0.0339141078,
-0.028956987,
0.0125881257,
0.020410344,
-0.0404213481,
-0.0485704653,
-0.0082113845,
-0.0255218931,
0.006913315,
-0.0499637015,
0.0334252194,
0.0501897782,
0.0668858066,
-0.0102625471,
0.0181184113,
0.0153421527,
-0.0512359291,
-0.0432227589,
0.0213807132,
0.0742873922,
-0.0079590688,
0.0369496308,
-0.0531368703,
-0.0452945977,
-0.037612889,
0.011759026,
-0.0477800146,
-0.0278062616,
0.0250240397,
-0.0032406941,
-0.0177627541,
-0.0504769422,
0.0822270438,
0.0332610495,
0.0718461275,
0.0214088168,
-0.0410290174,
0.0040149922,
-0.0328268781,
0.0402628072,
-0.0335841998,
-0.0188891944,
-0.0258799028,
-0.0235524792,
-0.0598014705,
0.0124712987,
0.0270524435,
-0.049344521,
0.0570430011,
0.0200484768,
0.0125678396,
0.0178983901,
-0.0601931475,
0.0038013472,
0.0001427538,
-0.0367260911,
-0.0484576263,
-0.0301681235,
-5.260159426e-33,
-0.0155614316,
-0.0111527313,
0.0083813323,
-0.0018680004,
-0.0439362228,
-0.0392009728,
0.0442403778,
-0.0204426069,
-0.0229303837,
0.0278809648,
0.0319432467,
-0.0152293658,
-0.0194842499,
-0.006007005,
0.0211866926,
-0.0002398878,
0.0153167192,
0.013059034,
-0.0316295289,
-0.0049551469,
0.0225890037,
-0.0340879858,
0.0177103356,
-0.0362507664,
0.0002204278,
0.0037554901,
-0.0128558343,
0.0007604857,
-0.0003410759,
0.0521323904,
-0.0452632271,
0.0529602952,
0.0226787962,
0.0177171677,
0.044112619,
-0.0583725907,
-0.0341104567,
-0.0236813817,
0.036851503,
-0.0305069741,
0.0264251903,
-0.0405301005,
0.0140888607,
0.0133247199,
-0.021520758,
-0.0360141061,
0.0386518501,
-0.0024205057,
-0.0005098101,
-0.0401363932,
-0.061572466,
0.0198294185,
0.0127870571,
-0.0162345357,
0.0079725571,
-0.030322874,
0.0082887709,
0.024781961,
-0.0285192523,
0.046287775,
0.0142284445,
0.0043178797,
0.0796203464,
0.0445392244,
0.0306654107,
0.0471897274,
-0.0298455004,
-0.0374119058,
0.0217054766,
0.0084317578,
-0.023643028,
0.0228042658,
-0.0095334165,
0.0320595689,
0.0261182487,
0.0128966104,
-0.0337998718,
0.0825032517,
-0.0355356857,
-0.0081425225,
0.0019046168,
0.0400773138,
0.0257215519,
-0.0024398877,
-0.0583371371,
0.0514661558,
-0.0607051142,
-0.006369439,
0.0463336632,
-0.0819051862,
0.0189359542,
-0.0045584943,
0.0054761199,
-0.0582519472,
-0.0438733622,
-0.0370801948,
-0.0018270714,
-0.002851268,
-0.044337742,
0.0566365272,
-0.0547196567,
-0.091094397,
-0.0087363077,
-0.0277791433,
0.010285235,
0.0180868749,
0.0205643326,
-0.0162433852,
-0.030256765,
0.0340194926,
-0.0077460199,
-0.0856171399,
-0.044073604,
-0.0308860708,
0.0353810303,
0.0098977992,
0.0524976663,
-0.0042387582,
0.0847826526,
0.0100478437,
-0.0166206919,
-0.0127588408,
-0.0061425148,
-0.0009619131,
-0.0048101582,
0.0426663235,
-0.020060068,
-0.0189578645,
-0.0175021347,
-0.0154121919,
0.002840051,
0.0180583578,
2.442e-7,
0.038838163,
-0.0021188452,
-0.0099063395,
0.0145516684,
-0.0038958511,
0.0193477329,
0.0104797622,
0.0630277023,
-0.0394239314,
0.0128114643,
0.0143349599,
-0.0292947236,
0.0219203252,
0.0102669634,
-0.0044995369,
0.0251811221,
-0.0238051321,
-0.0311977305,
-0.0736645609,
0.0382606126,
0.0351455584,
0.0699882507,
0.021810364,
0.0146935675,
0.0297279861,
-0.0233065374,
0.043759536,
-0.0450505391,
-0.0086236894,
0.0640014187,
-0.0156854447,
-0.0039519519,
0.016202027,
0.0522110313,
0.0270013809,
0.0109347673,
0.0152504109,
0.0072388961,
-0.0455048792,
0.024528373,
-0.0624696203,
-0.0225063041,
0.0041298,
-0.1084266827,
0.0157055054,
-0.0321104079,
-0.0423174724,
-0.0104380697,
-0.0413701758,
0.0202634111,
-0.0158892255,
0.0077959178,
0.0036209822,
0.0379476324,
0.0307303034,
0.0236215815,
-0.0533887967,
-0.0438180529,
0.0291016828,
0.0410302542,
-0.0317590237,
-0.0221285243,
-0.0020889733,
-0.0031646849,
0.0742805824,
-0.0640270263,
0.0089900568,
1.749051794e-34,
-0.0221505221,
0.0073748329,
-0.0128935929,
-0.0027816342,
0.0230576415,
-0.0029119349,
0.0245062225,
0.0371448323,
-0.0468064547,
-0.0737660006,
0.0330562927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08628v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08628v3 | Recovering from Privacy-Preserving Masking with Large Language Models | 2023-09-12T16:39:41 | 2023-12-14T00:45:39 | Arpita Vats, Zhe Liu, Peng Su, Debjyoti Paul, Yingyi Ma, Yutong Pang, Zeeshan Ahmed, Ozlem Kalinli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Model adaptation is crucial to handle the discrepancy between proxy training
data and actual users data received. To effectively perform adaptation, textual
data of users is typically stored on servers or their local devices, where
downstream natural language processing (NLP) models can be directly trained
using such in-domain data. However, this might raise privacy and security
concerns due to the extra risks of exposing user information to adversaries.
Replacing identifying information in textual data with a generic marker has
been recently explored. In this work, we leverage large language models (LLMs)
to suggest substitutes of masked tokens and have their effectiveness evaluated
on downstream language modeling tasks. Specifically, we propose multiple
pre-trained and fine-tuned LLM-based approaches and perform empirical studies
on various datasets for the comparison of these methods. Experimental results
show that models trained on the obfuscation corpora are able to achieve
comparable performance with the ones trained on the original data without
privacy-preserving token masking. | [
0.0464682356,
0.0917049497,
-0.0299375318,
0.045502983,
-0.0566278659,
-0.0162881799,
0.0744167492,
0.0252373293,
0.0297573488,
-0.0587865598,
-0.0241545625,
-0.0252399277,
-0.0280608032,
0.0294507947,
0.0244840011,
-0.0051801144,
0.0384095833,
-0.0237583369,
-0.0216262825,
-0.008443784,
-0.0370498635,
0.0227790233,
0.04457286,
0.0421830826,
0.0087339291,
0.0000596993,
0.0311967451,
0.0093138302,
-0.0042028083,
-0.0019759452,
0.0042949938,
0.0216490589,
0.0239485409,
0.1148260012,
0.0000015265,
-0.056951534,
-0.0516370274,
0.0428171568,
-0.0628921241,
0.0199705865,
0.0571800284,
-0.0177890901,
-0.007982702,
0.0247059371,
-0.0398824997,
-0.0134705491,
0.0324524567,
0.0401293524,
0.0520280004,
0.0930446312,
-0.0147348223,
-0.0420427397,
-0.0127888191,
-0.0315141603,
-0.0270209257,
-0.0462292582,
0.0436188802,
-0.0605888292,
-0.0447094925,
0.0298843756,
-0.0014788313,
0.0254598372,
-0.0140682822,
0.0073098373,
-0.0303466916,
0.0018602319,
-0.0124866599,
0.0170726292,
-0.0098420437,
0.0423729643,
-0.0508508123,
-0.0350844264,
0.0261947531,
0.0214801412,
0.0154463472,
0.0188774876,
0.0009445071,
0.0178406071,
0.0069292574,
0.0044576726,
0.0135006197,
-0.0326301232,
0.0680994093,
0.0404318199,
-0.0386335775,
0.0494745709,
0.0147974538,
0.0119852256,
-0.0274347719,
-0.079063803,
-0.0468227528,
-0.0558558851,
0.0679243729,
0.0011907404,
-0.0019645295,
0.0398421846,
-0.0765274763,
-0.0617927574,
0.0110594025,
-0.0237199161,
0.0080389697,
0.013389972,
0.0051753516,
0.0716237277,
-0.072547853,
0.0437413044,
-0.0168684423,
0.0273347143,
-0.0059710685,
-0.0373717621,
-0.0119824195,
-0.0399682894,
-0.0349234007,
0.0703787953,
-0.097767733,
-0.0088627459,
-0.0256929193,
0.0291244462,
0.0041318862,
0.0107808569,
-0.006825008,
-0.0304375663,
-0.0128846969,
-0.0244933795,
0.021077821,
-0.0174327958,
0.0073268632,
0.0284509715,
-0.0034880436,
-0.0664777756,
-0.0058162492,
-0.0057683061,
-0.0089441538,
-0.0396619402,
-0.0074706371,
0.0851498023,
0.0360264182,
-0.030539671,
-0.0234572832,
-0.0340512656,
0.0193612929,
0.0021072973,
-0.0379506499,
-0.0512962714,
0.0136339096,
-0.0155732222,
0.0319838002,
-0.0878518522,
0.0021668889,
0.0232160389,
-0.0401850976,
0.0879463106,
-0.0271928776,
-0.0121008055,
0.0072842147,
0.0015373848,
-0.0248980857,
0.0315654203,
0.012288182,
0.023719687,
0.0546488278,
-0.0475248247,
0.0230469722,
0.0308042094,
0.0291231498,
0.0056686364,
-0.0088508185,
0.0102363676,
0.0423029102,
-0.0268903337,
0.001225147,
0.0604848005,
-0.0077926009,
-0.0544614904,
0.0563333035,
0.0661607683,
-0.0149708455,
0.0231571887,
-0.0142794373,
0.0014728379,
-0.0231374446,
-0.0327524021,
-0.0548662394,
-0.0550588034,
-0.0548100062,
-0.0521799251,
-0.0205839202,
0.0321449786,
0.0019554072,
-0.0038598748,
-0.0035343049,
-0.0217531137,
0.0434197038,
0.0272537433,
0.0445586778,
0.0251258947,
-0.014227883,
0.0194629934,
-0.0042405869,
-0.0150981406,
0.0355533175,
-0.0563183837,
-0.009951422,
0.0575708151,
0.0390815176,
-0.0151681611,
0.033024963,
-0.0440023616,
0.013675631,
0.0145656383,
-0.0053698397,
0.0045678206,
0.045219034,
-0.0196609814,
-0.0108895693,
0.0014649368,
-0.0005107502,
0.0508866273,
0.0108422562,
-0.0194411669,
0.0412914902,
-0.0523329973,
0.0065361308,
0.0475135297,
-0.0242249537,
-0.044806283,
0.0599613674,
-0.0048224819,
0.0564825162,
0.0183138121,
-0.0112035535,
0.0063072778,
0.0268455278,
-0.0193886049,
0.0019384016,
-0.0306146182,
0.0046886657,
-0.0223950893,
0.010180193,
-0.0001748943,
0.0295710899,
0.0607863776,
-0.0244684499,
-0.0294579193,
0.0126918061,
-0.0194408242,
0.0664924383,
-0.0129430043,
0.0283844825,
-0.0103353197,
0.0650068298,
-0.0282951109,
0.0234105587,
-0.0142570706,
0.0103286719,
-0.0347252637,
-0.0090760281,
0.0081914077,
-0.0097295474,
-0.0276954398,
-0.0088058915,
-0.0306400172,
0.0142934108,
0.0032915946,
-0.0139467241,
-0.0182374157,
-0.0180693232,
-0.0674144253,
0.0112115452,
-0.0264217071,
0.0228877738,
0.0150423953,
0.0279906262,
-0.0164709594,
-0.0432571843,
-0.0252701305,
-0.0577563271,
-0.0242500976,
0.0442251638,
0.0123400167,
0.012703442,
-0.0455505066,
0.0061026495,
-0.0312812403,
-0.0074136234,
0.0476435497,
-0.0363863409,
-0.0723344609,
-0.0359111764,
0.0109934602,
0.0088287434,
0.0469386764,
-0.0252470989,
-0.0084594516,
-0.0195721854,
0.020484155,
0.0249039978,
0.0468218178,
0.0043606386,
0.0074614058,
0.0232769214,
-0.0021051441,
-0.0487586409,
-0.024128817,
-0.0190261826,
-0.0364724621,
-0.0579118244,
-0.0435166471,
0.0592742413,
0.006088498,
0.0209684744,
-0.0458512679,
-0.0229855571,
0.016550893,
-0.0254620686,
-0.0409088507,
-0.0350516215,
-0.0232809838,
0.00365228,
0.0142176161,
0.0023669482,
-0.0383165814,
0.0662345812,
-0.0214239974,
0.0300889686,
-0.0292326193,
-0.042369131,
-0.011962709,
0.0344410166,
0.0153095415,
0.0521736369,
0.0062155565,
-0.079717122,
-0.0068100877,
-0.0046993471,
0.0045743776,
-0.0340562351,
-0.01250087,
-0.0045482535,
0.0069283671,
0.0381436348,
-0.030340625,
-0.0385812744,
-0.1216313764,
-0.0044504669,
0.0167971309,
0.0334732942,
-0.0427215174,
-0.0442648567,
0.0145535786,
0.0066616964,
0.0257434789,
0.0277024824,
0.0112950699,
-0.0272582602,
-0.0171574336,
0.0140068308,
-0.0413484238,
0.0304542184,
0.0007764463,
0.027598517,
0.054631602,
0.0861994401,
-0.0166539624,
0.0219221059,
-0.0032025944,
0.0369800627,
-0.0344280861,
-0.0278505161,
0.0288179014,
0.0468707196,
-0.0235528126,
0.0045501133,
0.097365424,
0.0233228263,
-0.0200738218,
-0.006894018,
0.0263347533,
-0.0023947423,
0.0231009275,
0.0033721896,
-0.0890062973,
-0.012076322,
0.0459022149,
0.0273048505,
-0.0516391657,
-0.0361647792,
-0.0186136588,
-0.102882944,
-0.0226593111,
0.0201184824,
-0.0336944759,
-0.0021082296,
-0.0824055448,
0.007099811,
0.0090073412,
0.0387984477,
-0.0478263684,
0.013536891,
-0.0413190648,
-0.0035585267,
-0.0289734099,
-0.0364914946,
-0.0164636131,
-0.0485408269,
0.0397796221,
0.0365616754,
0.0031641352,
-0.0037759161,
-0.009216439,
0.037832506,
0.012327129,
0.0145152397,
-0.0164198354,
0.0493949242,
-0.0243171472,
-0.0167861357,
0.0086774603,
0.0630669147,
-0.0157126505,
-0.0350117795,
0.0062835896,
-0.0026524595,
0.0134301065,
0.0117653869,
0.0228838995,
-0.0519491956,
0.0197029524,
0.0645563379,
-0.0170736369,
-0.0444260836,
0.0030590417,
-0.0267126393,
0.0062720967,
0.020358339,
0.0266907662,
0.0231906641,
-0.0232252851,
-0.0327962488,
-0.0398958102,
0.0443880148,
0.0143310269,
0.0333390236,
0.0559639186,
0.0550016351,
0.0084073115,
-0.0278814789,
-0.0225076396,
0.0258974247,
-0.08055453,
0.0552612059,
-0.0537819006,
0.0277124867,
-0.0022411407,
0.000675706,
-0.0143234162,
0.0280743632,
-0.0547562391,
-0.0820111036,
0.0251393877,
0.0162820984,
0.0178400893,
0.0491282046,
-0.0702016205,
-0.0989330858,
0.0683033466,
0.0414672531,
-0.0523269251,
-0.0132955881,
0.0357373022,
-0.0263811424,
-0.0006456922,
0.0222763233,
-0.0271137282,
-0.023900846,
0.06361866,
-0.0200258344,
-0.0348782539,
0.0066434168,
0.0288198479,
0.0506225415,
0.0739684477,
-0.0095688049,
0.0252877939,
-0.0153949466,
0.0136263464,
-0.0385063477,
-0.0260462593,
0.01761562,
-0.0235078875,
0.0784649551,
0.0051526953,
0.0082264189,
0.0212327037,
-0.0201803185,
0.0189597756,
-0.0212235209,
0.0046139038,
-0.0091784103,
0.0240168311,
0.0318085365,
-0.0000556764,
-0.0059519806,
0.0302677359,
0.0409082957,
0.0373405367,
-0.0035548303,
0.004845513,
0.0088236928,
0.016849054,
-0.0424318649,
0.0330478176,
-0.0420287549,
-0.0241923966,
-0.0423320532,
0.0217974726,
0.0118005071,
-0.0069932076,
0.0005950099,
-0.0228925236,
-0.0165187679,
-0.0195096694,
-0.0060632722,
-0.0042897523,
-0.0330081694,
0.0238799192,
-0.0111335022,
-0.041060254,
0.0356725454,
0.0737208128,
0.0438544936,
0.0429141261,
0.0177837443,
-0.038098231,
-0.0397247262,
0.0196402427,
0.0068908548,
0.0538201518,
-0.0358681232,
-0.00268825,
-0.0211719461,
-0.0762994289,
-0.0070601758,
-0.0521061905,
0.0131165199,
0.0136211319,
-0.0315252319,
0.0469532497,
0.0123436106,
-0.0180805437,
-0.0922669172,
0.0245935842,
0.0565286055,
-0.0479423739,
-0.0028585808,
-5.103452805e-33,
0.0003414916,
-0.0328701138,
-0.0332591906,
0.0005994278,
0.0291379206,
0.0157548953,
0.0123756994,
-0.0156668909,
-0.0278639887,
-0.0403155759,
-0.0510399081,
-0.0034772928,
0.0233769286,
0.0549501963,
-0.0625430048,
0.0012751794,
0.0613271557,
0.0207227841,
-0.0163501557,
0.0006988581,
0.0501368456,
0.027535785,
0.0309501849,
-0.0797908455,
0.038102638,
0.0279018693,
-0.0270234086,
0.0304756258,
-0.0182379093,
0.053412769,
-0.0264672711,
0.0298537444,
0.0002163139,
0.0035358858,
-0.0141210845,
0.0546812303,
-0.0618250035,
0.0353502706,
0.0325096063,
0.0269161854,
0.0604297742,
-0.0759032443,
0.0442776382,
-0.0451520458,
-0.0018038903,
0.0404112823,
-0.0170254055,
-0.0274076927,
-0.0209827311,
-0.0171743594,
-0.0021071211,
0.0226391926,
-0.0228475686,
0.0110814609,
0.0425516814,
0.0206132941,
0.0214021653,
0.001862061,
-0.0619196333,
0.0069483635,
0.0014490486,
-0.0077567804,
0.0522905849,
0.0299637876,
0.0310075115,
0.0506103672,
0.0493969433,
0.0250148643,
-0.001229258,
-0.0189988092,
0.0163283627,
-0.0002713534,
0.0377488732,
0.0311932247,
0.0246419832,
-0.04742603,
-0.0667294562,
-0.0156827271,
-0.0253663901,
-0.0093058078,
0.0650283471,
0.0436084531,
-0.0367859155,
-0.0057089939,
-0.0812305734,
-0.0136863068,
-0.0419649519,
0.0041268268,
0.0147548085,
-0.0029590293,
-0.0329289213,
0.0037431864,
0.0353663638,
-0.0586459264,
-0.0460024588,
-0.0066472553,
0.0649994537,
0.0045290915,
0.0007950932,
0.045376081,
-0.0206744522,
-0.0491072237,
0.0230191443,
-0.0252795201,
0.0136340111,
-0.0332347862,
0.0549782924,
-0.0069613499,
-0.0978117511,
-0.0154768536,
-0.0185706746,
0.0417871885,
0.0239955708,
0.0286438931,
0.0574038066,
0.0003641596,
0.000174528,
0.0070983325,
0.0322978385,
-0.0088380314,
-0.0005488287,
0.0284183975,
-0.0038952674,
-0.0076766131,
0.0016006273,
-0.026867006,
0.0135360695,
0.0333161056,
0.0954473689,
-0.0002996707,
-0.0045865751,
-0.0211985298,
2.443e-7,
0.0275544282,
0.0160137769,
-0.019113088,
-0.0216670446,
0.0152756097,
0.0365424752,
0.0304307118,
0.024713615,
-0.0011816843,
0.0123014683,
-0.0322352462,
-0.0132858744,
0.0550513342,
0.0168579035,
-0.0676182359,
0.0144765591,
0.0004007418,
0.0144966356,
-0.0664335042,
0.0207704771,
0.0168136749,
0.1251827627,
0.0446903855,
-0.0151421605,
-0.0380824581,
-0.0816961154,
0.026410792,
-0.0713176429,
-0.0418775752,
-0.0033248514,
0.0203165244,
0.067861855,
0.0449911244,
0.0107912179,
-0.026225945,
0.036175143,
0.0019898501,
0.0619188435,
0.0219220184,
0.0250239652,
-0.0297729019,
-0.0258366261,
-0.0244772024,
-0.0410018489,
0.0613888055,
-0.0128120733,
-0.0523765571,
-0.0305912085,
-0.0163001232,
-0.0591032989,
0.0263407882,
-0.0561074875,
-0.0297876988,
0.0496606529,
0.0399521813,
0.0028762494,
-0.0198800191,
-0.0603943765,
-0.0118316757,
-0.040255405,
-0.0358944833,
-0.009038114,
-0.0107879518,
0.028297212,
0.0203703605,
-0.0202904698,
0.0650846288,
2.246647277e-34,
0.0146364085,
-0.0295458362,
-0.0163168572,
0.0483722202,
0.0566965751,
0.0076925624,
0.0299415309,
0.0403297842,
0.005707188,
-0.0791253969,
0.0090749692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06365v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06365v2 | Cited Text Spans for Citation Text Generation | 2023-09-12T16:28:36 | 2024-02-20T23:31:22 | Xiangci Li, Yi-Hui Lee, Jessica Ouyang | cs.CL | cs.CL | An automatic citation generation system aims to concisely and accurately
describe the relationship between two scientific articles. To do so, such a
system must ground its outputs to the content of the cited paper to avoid
non-factual hallucinations. Due to the length of scientific documents, existing
abstractive approaches have conditioned only on cited paper abstracts. We
demonstrate empirically that the abstract is not always the most appropriate
input for citation generation and that models trained in this way learn to
hallucinate. We propose to condition instead on the cited text span (CTS) as an
alternative to the abstract. Because manual CTS annotation is extremely time-
and labor-intensive, we experiment with distant labeling of candidate CTS
sentences, achieving sufficiently strong performance to substitute for
expensive human annotations in model training, and we propose a
human-in-the-loop, keyword-based CTS retrieval approach that makes generating
citation texts grounded in the full text of cited papers both promising and
practical. | [
0.0499331504,
-0.0305710156,
0.016889669,
-0.0123081105,
-0.0030818053,
0.0012041972,
0.0274852943,
0.0240720641,
0.0469039306,
-0.0640567467,
-0.008754394,
0.0229926314,
-0.0285769161,
-0.0145265823,
0.0351161025,
-0.0414830893,
0.0274917223,
0.0334788375,
0.0422394574,
0.0169438161,
-0.006248672,
0.0008972908,
0.020007994,
0.0075399121,
0.0226197392,
-0.035240937,
0.0030989468,
-0.0258392543,
0.0691696182,
-0.0443090312,
0.0175469108,
0.0561273657,
-0.0034011689,
0.0235827807,
0.0000016321,
-0.0397076458,
-0.0098005841,
0.0359330364,
0.0221230686,
0.0634686425,
0.0501112901,
-0.0042917021,
0.0476305932,
0.0093018683,
-0.0302480869,
0.0090292776,
0.0254959278,
0.0809015408,
0.0515189618,
0.0223201625,
-0.0160837639,
-0.024029376,
0.0467836335,
-0.0033372915,
0.0100095244,
-0.0144953532,
0.0360592753,
0.0300018899,
0.0349504985,
0.0720542222,
0.0503172502,
0.0422989354,
-0.0171496104,
-0.0204398595,
0.1054950282,
0.0370345227,
-0.0548099317,
-0.0049546091,
0.0384794548,
0.0516159944,
-0.0196415354,
-0.0615857132,
0.0852873325,
-0.0125030549,
-0.0390690863,
0.0363438018,
-0.0214907657,
0.011639988,
-0.0376785062,
-0.0240664687,
0.0156556703,
0.0126478616,
0.0242237151,
0.0374412648,
-0.0105663147,
0.0197482351,
0.0165241156,
-0.0539260171,
0.0162500776,
0.0084200474,
-0.0063718338,
-0.0473857038,
0.0422704704,
0.0199142955,
-0.0156311709,
-0.0220624842,
-0.0078006173,
-0.0443887152,
0.0622757822,
-0.0527957454,
-0.0364452749,
-0.038020879,
-0.0175122842,
0.0252140239,
-0.0324744023,
-0.0313654803,
-0.0504690185,
-0.021075191,
0.0080098193,
0.0147766117,
-0.0572795793,
-0.0307867583,
-0.0420790166,
0.0247289147,
-0.0399321914,
-0.0243101232,
-0.0583866611,
-0.0056587555,
-0.0430356488,
0.0130880056,
-0.0128347864,
0.0212029405,
-0.0488244556,
0.0133315334,
0.0098611806,
-0.0060353833,
-0.0277940258,
0.0094609121,
0.0205982905,
-0.0049393354,
-0.0196076371,
0.0324350409,
0.0350295343,
-0.0297799855,
-0.0165193751,
0.0193453562,
-0.0085468981,
0.0009747049,
0.0085807219,
-0.0735874921,
0.0077544614,
-0.0516711026,
0.0311026536,
-0.0550704077,
0.0385183282,
0.0264564082,
-0.0282109976,
-0.0402982198,
0.0282260757,
0.0490489043,
-0.0390850306,
0.0362870209,
-0.0389302708,
-0.0288533587,
0.0297823288,
0.0038977161,
0.0502362549,
0.0011562894,
0.0334645174,
0.0243364517,
0.0284838062,
0.0104914121,
0.0398531072,
-0.0197355933,
0.0568488538,
0.006192435,
0.036987409,
-0.0032664123,
-0.0158941541,
0.0518435761,
-0.0099804625,
0.0404246487,
-0.038345091,
0.0409399532,
0.0214234311,
0.0080236765,
-0.0331246443,
0.0427226424,
0.068370685,
0.0044486807,
0.0080326041,
0.0197977796,
-0.0025107649,
0.0118745845,
0.0046000187,
0.0331293531,
0.0642557889,
-0.0203636028,
-0.017835198,
-0.013782125,
-0.0074732075,
0.0231337249,
-0.0233617052,
-0.0549497344,
0.0509803183,
0.0286104735,
-0.055525098,
0.1001168415,
0.0228932351,
-0.0386015214,
0.0393183939,
0.0330447964,
0.0014812698,
-0.0068403143,
0.0476489775,
-0.0230716951,
0.0391808823,
-0.0268949531,
0.0317439586,
0.0700987577,
0.0169893876,
-0.018688513,
-0.0474971272,
-0.0435183458,
-0.0174669325,
0.0100709647,
0.0086953267,
-0.0231793765,
0.0232827161,
-0.0156391673,
0.0442882665,
-0.0472909659,
-0.0723117217,
0.0388614647,
-0.0446259305,
-0.0257118624,
-0.0171582643,
-0.0307089109,
0.0326631889,
0.0217981283,
-0.0222915113,
0.0407661274,
0.0443768576,
-0.0307954866,
-0.0419728272,
0.0383208729,
-0.002799328,
0.0463305041,
0.0205801614,
-0.0638985112,
0.0311343446,
-0.0027691221,
-0.0140122361,
-0.0490305126,
0.0245184656,
-0.0349456482,
-0.0211219415,
-0.0043386403,
0.0018803743,
0.0155778695,
0.0040889177,
-0.0534202084,
0.0921681747,
0.0311611835,
0.0544657558,
0.0159634538,
-0.0258870535,
0.0332769789,
-0.0451863557,
-0.0123724006,
-0.0195937306,
-0.0024244299,
-0.0377665609,
0.0660411268,
-0.0362783521,
-0.044258628,
-0.0105861938,
-0.0414387025,
0.0124944579,
0.0232282858,
-0.0074367682,
0.0159147866,
-0.0259631258,
0.0256369766,
-0.0025081742,
0.0064153466,
-0.0105172005,
0.0010996207,
-0.0090820212,
0.0751885474,
0.0340389013,
0.0035824226,
-0.0438164733,
-0.0082131503,
-0.0484612659,
0.0459415019,
0.081300199,
-0.0302836094,
-0.0817444995,
0.0717915297,
0.0062871668,
0.0014283172,
-0.0081578502,
0.0305562094,
0.004091965,
0.0181704909,
0.0077350494,
0.0559383333,
0.042812787,
-0.0061413678,
0.0455215015,
0.0179359317,
-0.0437389426,
-0.0004152797,
-0.0421196334,
0.0114014419,
-0.0083962437,
-0.0404363424,
0.0370004438,
0.0386996754,
-0.0038389012,
-0.0066120881,
-0.0190973319,
-0.0276654921,
0.0073474026,
-0.0011739625,
-0.0186188389,
-0.0058907508,
-0.0120879551,
0.0519548059,
-0.000102245,
-0.0313042141,
0.0300324466,
-0.0312365051,
-0.0017395101,
-0.044425182,
0.0253906976,
-0.0194184314,
-0.0061194738,
0.0290769152,
-0.0050576963,
0.0365093425,
0.006664264,
-0.0229507368,
0.0161832012,
0.0234365985,
-0.0221944302,
-0.0124673657,
-0.0124166217,
0.0239434242,
-0.024554342,
-0.020541219,
-0.0352575071,
-0.0076246085,
-0.0282383878,
0.0348003134,
0.008315362,
-0.0214268211,
-0.0453968197,
-0.0071539613,
0.0676127598,
0.0357008688,
-0.0461935811,
-0.0341688022,
-0.048831258,
0.0465347581,
0.0797241107,
-0.0570343025,
0.010758183,
-0.0078876894,
-0.0194299594,
0.0414410606,
0.0413662866,
0.0442981869,
-0.020996267,
-0.0575541593,
-0.016622277,
-0.0852418318,
-0.0284789987,
0.0037901117,
0.0230511483,
-0.0131501295,
-0.0316444449,
0.0885363743,
0.045864936,
-0.0574826226,
-0.015757164,
-0.0028213523,
0.0095846076,
0.0266931541,
0.0295833461,
-0.071554102,
0.0372775607,
-0.0170822293,
0.021472821,
-0.0112631628,
-0.0536821298,
0.005754598,
-0.0881593674,
0.0375544019,
0.0140141146,
0.0213925969,
-0.0284556467,
-0.079257533,
-0.0108972974,
-0.0033977788,
-0.0583706759,
0.0395674445,
-0.0238507818,
0.0029895939,
0.0337128565,
0.0005919391,
-0.0227445159,
-0.0032399565,
-0.072280705,
0.0041070348,
0.0236575156,
0.0764958784,
-0.0113466913,
-0.0449799709,
0.0018817517,
-0.0429419167,
-0.0325687975,
-0.017750863,
0.043976035,
0.0207039211,
0.0155137498,
0.0043791528,
0.0615804754,
0.0134971226,
-0.024092881,
0.0461413525,
0.0691457838,
-0.0050991094,
0.0000635531,
-0.0420555063,
0.0372154675,
0.0024132603,
0.051250577,
0.0202460457,
-0.0096102133,
-0.075329192,
0.0043462198,
0.0379076712,
-0.0780322105,
-0.0548566952,
-0.0373463258,
-0.0714047775,
0.0168581568,
-0.0786001459,
-0.0269840639,
-0.0337372497,
0.0375799835,
0.0276761092,
0.048704043,
0.0257475153,
-0.0266365036,
-0.0558422953,
0.0158864036,
-0.029443929,
-0.0046332236,
0.0098679271,
-0.0107702827,
0.0492265895,
-0.0120697087,
-0.0407393537,
0.032754045,
0.0330356658,
-0.0461195521,
-0.0120299216,
0.0040006102,
0.0243821032,
0.0537866503,
-0.0233094227,
-0.0326287746,
0.0364382789,
0.0548355505,
-0.0059707672,
-0.0029406962,
0.0062621208,
0.0068056737,
-0.0242266506,
-0.0220032819,
-0.0486323982,
0.0347398482,
-0.0178761259,
0.0112166526,
-0.0248480663,
-0.0050547258,
0.0139651923,
0.0213647112,
0.0492953733,
-0.0565722175,
0.0272815432,
-0.0040835701,
-0.0017762482,
-0.0241540633,
-0.0022415454,
-0.0291971583,
0.0340467431,
-0.0160468053,
0.0031898674,
0.001750894,
0.0426460728,
-0.026201563,
0.0410342701,
-0.0269006174,
-0.014512619,
-0.0432387553,
0.0586188212,
0.0037433419,
-0.0211681519,
-0.0355023555,
-0.0496435314,
-0.0000083232,
0.045132637,
0.0036220746,
0.0165138133,
0.0465202034,
0.0194772389,
-0.0093246801,
-0.0085826302,
-0.1088167503,
0.0436193384,
-0.0528316386,
-0.0410434864,
0.0298383143,
-0.0242882799,
0.0662881359,
-0.0525533967,
-0.0317456871,
-0.0121292053,
0.0473103076,
0.0038774535,
0.0003661644,
0.0125035523,
0.0019496658,
-0.0195470378,
-0.0071193757,
0.0757028684,
0.0712295473,
0.0151251145,
-0.0160203874,
-0.0541487448,
-0.0393452384,
-0.0314305276,
-0.0840592459,
-0.0140320687,
0.0117927566,
-0.0304795858,
-0.0253238175,
-0.0235346407,
0.0661449507,
0.0063775508,
0.0128720757,
-0.0241369624,
0.0327118076,
0.0382721983,
-0.030090373,
-0.0316121243,
-0.0517644137,
0.0800567716,
0.0120494207,
-0.0711181983,
-0.0665276721,
-5.701715145e-33,
-0.0101711648,
-0.0600734986,
0.0204416215,
0.0080791609,
-0.0264685005,
3.159e-7,
-0.0774999708,
-0.0253698975,
0.0149377072,
0.0355142094,
-0.0215411987,
0.0026809529,
0.0029131651,
0.0058153542,
0.0473770611,
0.0302826203,
0.0472914353,
-0.0201010015,
-0.013841006,
0.0598847084,
0.0353755578,
0.0102335736,
-0.0046550822,
-0.1404463053,
0.0604716428,
-0.0521664731,
-0.023433974,
-0.0272454806,
0.0411960073,
0.0216081347,
-0.0337688886,
0.0023460805,
-0.001574505,
-0.0588088259,
-0.0059622894,
0.012597152,
-0.1038808152,
0.0229930021,
0.0152152367,
-0.0475087762,
-0.0303952321,
-0.0457939394,
0.036920093,
-0.0245173704,
-0.0138069373,
-0.0270058494,
0.0876397341,
-0.0274385009,
-0.0324817114,
-0.0948200002,
-0.0592561923,
0.0158747211,
-0.008606527,
0.06402383,
0.0020138426,
0.050790444,
-0.0108425831,
0.1022805646,
-0.0454986654,
0.0171513073,
-0.0109675517,
0.0365512855,
-0.0056875027,
-0.0233602431,
0.0330402814,
0.0306695048,
0.01436661,
-0.0290906895,
0.004506411,
-0.0025324663,
-0.0284424853,
0.0344472863,
0.0666005984,
0.0607426763,
0.0163126998,
0.0018888901,
-0.065048337,
0.0288843848,
-0.0278800875,
0.0194095895,
0.0244222675,
-0.0099906707,
0.0129077844,
0.0023933605,
0.0227825623,
-0.0342069529,
-0.0062311543,
-0.0231223889,
-0.0018345739,
0.0301905684,
-0.0339364074,
0.0482462309,
0.0139156971,
-0.0120182978,
-0.0278896578,
0.0579753555,
0.0139060561,
0.042792175,
0.0078452993,
-0.045597408,
-0.0446629785,
-0.0565950945,
-0.0075694602,
0.033429537,
0.0202776566,
-0.0078087468,
0.0295696352,
-0.031927228,
-0.0447941199,
-0.0206427854,
-0.0068536005,
0.0113113271,
-0.0064713927,
-0.0168264359,
-0.0024845027,
0.017560862,
0.0225885995,
0.0065632975,
0.0267101955,
0.0254366491,
0.0185107607,
0.0204738714,
0.0132905515,
0.0629188344,
0.0128486482,
0.004154691,
-0.0050128512,
0.0483799614,
-0.0066844854,
-0.071383737,
0.0066688303,
-0.0184326619,
2.54e-7,
0.0188531186,
0.0483697355,
0.0175274145,
-0.0396172293,
0.0234640464,
0.0086933486,
0.0316780843,
0.0233805049,
0.0234648399,
-0.0020155737,
0.0003497053,
-0.0502059758,
0.0146636013,
0.0107270787,
-0.1014473587,
-0.0416762754,
-0.0832354948,
-0.0413050987,
-0.0270242561,
-0.0257492494,
-0.0073496602,
-0.0107153505,
-0.0140656307,
0.0240612738,
-0.0100208754,
-0.0494291484,
0.0600819103,
-0.0021948854,
0.0248190667,
0.0408856981,
0.033214476,
0.0095492359,
-0.0052735694,
0.0348791108,
-0.0644941032,
0.013547549,
0.0196094457,
0.0346516259,
0.025752075,
0.0000156688,
0.0239868462,
-0.0312740728,
0.0458063111,
-0.0456132069,
0.0119655114,
-0.0524338,
0.0059243343,
-0.0472106785,
-0.0728773028,
0.0025987045,
-0.0237207413,
0.0124847265,
0.0044358065,
0.0193318874,
-0.0367566906,
0.0127422055,
-0.0079041691,
-0.0527911857,
-0.0173304863,
0.0605781004,
-0.0435521491,
-0.0294500124,
-0.0119962385,
-0.026491154,
-0.0000071964,
-0.0389162861,
0.0016035434,
2.220627296e-34,
0.072845906,
-0.0172337871,
-0.0068401736,
0.0132439202,
0.0313517787,
0.0008903245,
-0.0274266824,
0.0462374575,
0.0274670571,
-0.039354261,
0.0172317866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06363v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06363v1 | Learning to Predict Concept Ordering for Common Sense Generation | 2023-09-12T16:27:18 | 2023-09-12T16:27:18 | Tianhui Zhang, Danushka Bollegala, Bei Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prior work has shown that the ordering in which concepts are shown to a
commonsense generator plays an important role, affecting the quality of the
generated sentence. However, it remains a challenge to determine the optimal
ordering of a given set of concepts such that a natural sentence covering all
the concepts could be generated from a pretrained generator. To understand the
relationship between the ordering of the input concepts and the quality of the
generated sentences, we conduct a systematic study considering multiple
language models (LMs) and concept ordering strategies. We find that BART-large
model consistently outperforms all other LMs considered in this study when
fine-tuned using the ordering of concepts as they appear in CommonGen training
data as measured using multiple evaluation metrics. Moreover, the larger
GPT3-based large language models (LLMs) variants do not necessarily outperform
much smaller LMs on this task, even when fine-tuned on task-specific training
data. Interestingly, human annotators significantly reorder input concept sets
when manually writing sentences covering those concepts, and this ordering
provides the best sentence generations independently of the LM used for the
generation, outperforming a probabilistic concept ordering baseline | [
0.0373261608,
-0.0005087214,
0.0062592863,
0.0295071062,
-0.0081464304,
0.0122230975,
-0.0470053405,
0.0105526755,
-0.0118795251,
-0.0575566441,
0.017831834,
-0.0391335338,
0.0474730469,
-0.0012070736,
0.0594921522,
-0.0623699836,
0.0105111813,
-0.0075220894,
-0.0146118142,
0.0163968187,
-0.0026141033,
-0.0054089245,
0.0093452679,
0.0416274406,
0.0053524072,
0.0022173771,
0.0039816415,
0.0014220034,
0.0557146631,
-0.0254222192,
0.0004378742,
0.0747280642,
0.0204463117,
0.0319812894,
0.0000019665,
-0.0255020596,
0.0103520984,
-0.0024699592,
0.0692929775,
0.023022607,
-0.0125555396,
0.0095465044,
-0.0251697171,
0.0071409997,
-0.0435607769,
0.0260458402,
0.0099002905,
0.0428469963,
0.0856820345,
0.0347622111,
-0.0044269636,
-0.0429828502,
0.0212665927,
-0.0447312482,
0.0626498237,
-0.0367592387,
-0.010881735,
0.0616367683,
-0.0143747898,
0.0442703627,
0.0067578275,
-0.0123700183,
0.0089133568,
0.0204823446,
0.026179241,
0.0556633472,
-0.0359151736,
-0.0194435809,
-0.0043502632,
0.0835489333,
0.0039255135,
-0.0026915695,
0.0170519259,
-0.0047230921,
0.0290221833,
-0.0187965166,
-0.0238959715,
0.05635757,
0.0074898601,
0.0172335748,
0.0342600681,
0.0089629376,
-0.0148631008,
0.0384577513,
-0.0406391695,
0.0463970229,
0.0237034522,
-0.0224813186,
-0.0206294749,
0.0141729452,
-0.0793311372,
-0.0227755178,
-0.0048570633,
-0.0105713904,
0.0165426638,
0.0078236973,
-0.0419085212,
-0.0121662263,
0.0185844637,
-0.0347916968,
0.0351695195,
0.0447814651,
0.017210193,
0.0073568895,
-0.0198092479,
0.0630462095,
0.0097747697,
0.0167132784,
-0.0525168255,
0.0344380215,
-0.0420770831,
-0.0242893286,
-0.0298242178,
0.0368446372,
-0.0412423909,
-0.0213442035,
-0.092831187,
0.0281940699,
0.0294195451,
-0.0419132896,
0.0459685475,
0.0318570323,
-0.0211584643,
-0.0101482449,
-0.0284941662,
0.0020609535,
-0.0244973432,
0.0173101518,
0.0596881062,
-0.0157733783,
0.0052475138,
0.0069184951,
-0.0089142155,
-0.0040130089,
-0.0118700322,
-0.0078813033,
-0.0441918187,
-0.0158555098,
-0.0446209423,
-0.0292514861,
-0.0242245551,
-0.0176135208,
-0.0087918229,
-0.0431770198,
-0.005870536,
0.0219855383,
-0.0014940022,
0.0031214042,
0.0148918275,
0.0291997567,
-0.0640549064,
0.0046265102,
0.0090045063,
0.0361787602,
0.0405477472,
0.0247386023,
0.0145907253,
0.002638686,
0.0343764089,
0.0090416558,
0.0023135745,
-0.003997765,
-0.0242629051,
0.0005177112,
-0.0078597059,
-0.0171143897,
0.0045131291,
-0.0285417903,
-0.0352535285,
0.065451704,
0.0655038133,
0.0326911062,
-0.0666552261,
0.0394424014,
0.0666334033,
0.0280326251,
-0.0011393941,
-0.006024925,
0.056911841,
0.0305394866,
0.0007691853,
0.0271543786,
-0.0220625494,
0.0173538551,
-0.026040161,
0.0273434818,
0.0370932445,
0.01782302,
-0.0075944588,
-0.028281372,
0.0014721189,
-0.0010820893,
-0.0084796492,
-0.0540301986,
-0.0068606767,
0.0262534898,
-0.050253097,
0.0402237438,
0.0010144396,
-0.0729986578,
-0.031996686,
-0.0299325883,
0.0132339038,
0.0728813782,
0.00180985,
0.0329704247,
-0.0588222258,
0.0646946356,
0.0003031804,
0.0429002494,
0.0248063039,
0.0014797158,
-0.0229362044,
-0.051447127,
0.0058425148,
0.0102770859,
0.0008026197,
0.0237523187,
0.0066704173,
0.0115278233,
0.0555007868,
-0.0481703803,
-0.0063041383,
0.0214306787,
0.0079267155,
-0.0045791403,
-0.0021075036,
-0.0055417512,
0.0184446871,
-0.0013300381,
-0.0101916958,
0.0492242351,
0.0303108115,
-0.0441749208,
-0.0167885236,
0.0532886572,
-0.0786067173,
-0.0764257312,
-0.0085629048,
-0.0141234212,
-0.0160220824,
0.0166693479,
-0.0586451367,
-0.0496720523,
-0.0064300783,
0.0087874327,
0.0432585888,
-0.0743888319,
0.0032244918,
0.0643559322,
-0.0391948074,
-0.0504121222,
0.0917316601,
-0.0410589091,
0.0130422236,
-0.0183795169,
0.0422613509,
-0.0153251439,
-0.0423838533,
0.0116070509,
0.0116937282,
-0.0074739773,
0.0035706554,
0.0237989575,
0.0657106042,
-0.0525520965,
-0.0229969993,
-0.0912499875,
-0.0237568244,
-0.0029778553,
-0.019873092,
0.0287360661,
-0.0015423511,
0.0033688,
0.005551144,
-0.0391842872,
0.0446356535,
0.062004745,
0.0244117305,
0.0353296176,
-0.0019821767,
-0.0118001364,
-0.0025538651,
0.0281645451,
0.0011236668,
0.0510071553,
0.0106228571,
0.043319121,
-0.0457185358,
0.0795177445,
-0.0643234178,
-0.0472115204,
0.0079496233,
-0.0695368499,
0.032431867,
0.0049341931,
0.067392841,
0.0199005585,
0.068398498,
0.0235414132,
0.0370473824,
0.0090562049,
-0.00300556,
-0.0332156271,
-0.0036489626,
0.0014981036,
0.0187005922,
-0.0384414643,
-0.013653175,
0.074012123,
0.0408059098,
0.0096910717,
-0.0786696449,
0.0291890688,
-0.0213841349,
-0.0228013992,
-0.065956369,
-0.0378883891,
-0.0397286862,
0.018631462,
-0.0360307358,
-0.0090888701,
0.0211248584,
-0.033126425,
0.0064971708,
-0.0371013992,
0.0285999496,
-0.0091186948,
0.0359442085,
0.0265455265,
0.0495365299,
-0.0100756856,
-0.021137597,
-0.1116118506,
0.030295087,
0.0606091022,
-0.0275164749,
0.0121813901,
-0.0554362051,
0.0049707834,
-0.0210300442,
-0.0502817929,
-0.043599423,
0.0014976021,
0.0104908999,
0.0018692869,
0.0702658519,
0.0039448608,
0.0100332834,
0.0158557091,
0.0360491276,
0.022915557,
-0.0088005364,
-0.0254358444,
0.0094789574,
0.0901230276,
0.0310286544,
0.0044256784,
-0.0069070342,
-0.0122298086,
-0.0339264981,
0.0544638075,
0.0108282091,
-0.0370289572,
-0.0188674405,
0.0002390434,
0.0170710012,
-0.0301788468,
-0.0609179884,
0.028852798,
0.0120087769,
-0.0111382417,
-0.0244142171,
0.1134080216,
0.0298110824,
0.0093419924,
0.0146055911,
0.0004164946,
0.0797758028,
0.0116197197,
-0.0051377215,
-0.0636567175,
-0.0276075583,
-0.0073639047,
-0.0004814173,
0.0107540442,
-0.0422359928,
-0.0241209995,
-0.1085337922,
0.0245746821,
0.036116913,
-0.103005752,
-0.0332738087,
-0.0237269197,
-0.0497272722,
-0.0072664814,
-0.0372536257,
0.0506472141,
-0.005327601,
0.0562056266,
0.018929176,
-0.0254640356,
-0.0422312021,
-0.0195994768,
-0.0242131967,
0.0109538306,
0.0845120028,
0.0208416972,
0.0107445633,
-0.0218981635,
0.0008334515,
-0.0501418673,
0.0461794846,
0.0166515987,
0.0010604924,
-0.0294190645,
0.0233278088,
-0.0376149043,
0.0385736749,
-0.055812005,
-0.0272154603,
-0.0051286365,
0.0313735455,
-0.0152326068,
-0.0322413296,
-0.0165741909,
0.0398350433,
0.0051009622,
0.0849212483,
0.0593487024,
-0.0069704778,
-0.0074385232,
0.0005040942,
0.0482668541,
-0.0284094587,
-0.0258314535,
-0.0117717609,
0.0586136281,
-0.0135025606,
-0.1149091497,
-0.0455867574,
-0.0124366526,
0.0505551361,
-0.0175658632,
0.0279840324,
-0.0213171728,
0.0001922274,
-0.0348217189,
0.0282409377,
0.0282145981,
-0.057357844,
-0.0831404328,
-0.0293588396,
0.0435882509,
-0.0235530287,
-0.0668460205,
0.0417037196,
-0.0475324318,
-0.0795434564,
0.010630792,
0.0733564794,
0.0238017291,
-0.011430895,
0.0416109115,
-0.0210620426,
0.0614054017,
0.044830583,
-0.0254293531,
0.0322558917,
-0.0173528567,
-0.021638453,
-0.0090435985,
0.0182010308,
-0.0293551404,
0.0497310087,
-0.0318441316,
0.0782931969,
-0.0132006584,
-0.0321850926,
0.0246933792,
0.0384822413,
0.0387345552,
-0.0794253051,
-0.0137169482,
-0.0616032444,
-0.0008145507,
-0.0269471388,
-0.0477687046,
-0.0404449031,
0.0340151824,
0.0246543977,
0.0071256962,
-0.0365397483,
0.0058306204,
0.0096667679,
0.0353510492,
0.0067187734,
-0.045028571,
0.0063256728,
0.032768786,
0.0358524434,
-0.011908005,
-0.0244817007,
0.0109004909,
-0.0697093159,
0.0198698938,
-0.0267492123,
0.0692884848,
0.0058426769,
-0.0214465018,
-0.0054594036,
0.0834924132,
-0.0438533872,
-0.0320738964,
-0.0386343859,
0.0327941962,
0.0714991167,
0.0086490167,
0.0982830897,
-0.0401957072,
0.0017073759,
-0.0003966367,
0.0687570348,
-0.007627645,
-0.0349210054,
-0.0199223012,
0.0082243998,
-0.0029951185,
-0.0120578045,
0.1120639667,
-0.0392233096,
-0.0295136813,
0.0154172555,
-0.0202932898,
-0.0099510504,
-0.0096429288,
0.0048179342,
-0.0030952939,
0.0020668437,
0.0282195397,
-0.0563814305,
-0.0290106311,
0.0149445236,
0.0091849184,
0.0247212145,
0.011744895,
0.0771633387,
0.0974747911,
-0.0209949464,
-0.0004993374,
-0.005565804,
-0.0227240957,
-0.1003326401,
-0.0337819643,
-0.0497375242,
-5.945778629e-33,
-0.0666847676,
-0.0309926365,
0.0099779032,
-0.0299971141,
-0.0263250954,
-0.0147684151,
-0.0397648737,
0.0235904958,
0.0390688814,
0.0062487582,
0.0095192986,
-0.0134291612,
-0.0067712902,
0.009038494,
-0.0015817324,
0.0440893546,
0.0188973881,
0.002955985,
-0.0409993343,
0.0356716588,
0.065173246,
0.032492578,
0.0323259197,
0.0205195732,
-0.0403572917,
-0.0201149639,
-0.004769769,
-0.0140570644,
-0.0069590057,
0.0307196658,
-0.0096039204,
0.0238018576,
0.0368790925,
-0.0126511045,
0.0021486988,
0.014867573,
0.006293545,
-0.041814547,
-0.0092008226,
-0.0548397601,
-0.0206084568,
-0.0444426648,
0.0164945666,
-0.035630431,
-0.030861577,
0.0275045447,
0.0253901538,
0.0009017285,
-0.0382378213,
-0.0384397656,
-0.0512780733,
0.0118677868,
-0.007917122,
-0.0179036967,
-0.0477240533,
0.0124102626,
-0.0146284234,
-0.0199981239,
-0.0149048856,
0.066383034,
0.0217684004,
0.0298319347,
0.0285425019,
0.0243624989,
-0.0177795272,
0.046961017,
-0.0110181049,
-0.00721916,
-0.020972902,
0.016199084,
-0.0190163832,
0.072301738,
0.0069889645,
0.0746127442,
0.0361709818,
-0.0070094476,
-0.0640298277,
0.0869589448,
-0.0344834924,
-0.0035506031,
0.0278821755,
-0.0237248261,
-0.0234264918,
-0.0125856325,
-0.0276844203,
-0.0302835498,
-0.0095633687,
-0.0339961611,
0.0576528013,
-0.0091854921,
-0.0235002916,
-0.0429875813,
0.0446105935,
0.0265708175,
-0.0013294009,
0.0355378911,
-0.085582532,
0.0144813014,
-0.0249846671,
0.0553416498,
-0.0844248831,
-0.0447110906,
0.0421351455,
0.0161777306,
-0.0096053537,
0.0268479344,
0.0285777841,
-0.0426953994,
-0.0179601647,
-0.0006625,
-0.0188812986,
0.0033943008,
-0.0434938706,
-0.0381976403,
0.0170049425,
-0.0000973703,
-0.0142897768,
0.005357211,
-0.008672026,
-0.0061980877,
-0.017615268,
-0.0499241687,
0.0173428878,
0.0162855424,
0.0007010744,
0.0251737386,
0.010068302,
-0.0222752299,
0.060587965,
-0.0165760573,
-0.0456687994,
0.0076962369,
2.698e-7,
0.013395926,
0.0345255062,
-0.0081885392,
0.0094387056,
-0.0019162232,
0.0120928753,
0.0051379958,
0.0500533693,
-0.0025768462,
0.0036648645,
0.037103612,
0.0363495275,
-0.0160369389,
-0.0105738696,
-0.0635667965,
0.0021747376,
-0.0599716231,
0.0003281869,
-0.0085468451,
-0.0432406142,
0.0361022726,
0.049697347,
-0.0639890805,
-0.0178625211,
0.0211967193,
-0.0170625784,
0.0906750411,
-0.0236423444,
-0.0125704305,
-0.0230241045,
0.0338892229,
0.0031923251,
-0.0092620179,
0.0335245878,
0.0000696433,
-0.0376027189,
0.0340402536,
0.012849994,
-0.0135787642,
-0.0112379873,
-0.0063284263,
0.0293109156,
0.0126151107,
-0.069140777,
0.0343372449,
-0.0815767199,
-0.0151499882,
0.0325233229,
-0.0339936838,
0.0045317286,
-0.0149587234,
-0.0351404026,
-0.0374628864,
-0.0129419146,
0.0061451499,
-0.0067711007,
0.0055846549,
-0.0193022918,
-0.02504999,
0.0541298613,
-0.0103118233,
-0.0718756989,
-0.047927998,
-0.009137515,
0.0304059722,
-0.0293245465,
-0.0497564673,
2.435231928e-34,
0.0045232964,
-0.0086497907,
0.0403936766,
-0.0070322407,
0.0361653119,
0.0061392491,
0.0171212908,
0.0239939522,
-0.0106101055,
-0.0520946532,
-0.0204909444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06275v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06275v2 | Re-Reading Improves Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2023-09-12T14:36:23 | 2024-02-29T06:28:55 | Xiaohan Xu, Chongyang Tao, Tao Shen, Can Xu, Hongbo Xu, Guodong Long, Jian-guang Lou | cs.CL | cs.CL | To enhance the reasoning capabilities of off-the-shelf Large Language Models
(LLMs), we introduce a simple, yet general and effective prompting method, Re2,
i.e., \textbf{Re}-\textbf{Re}ading the question as input. Unlike most
thought-eliciting prompting methods, such as Chain-of-Thought (CoT), which aim
to elicit the reasoning process in the output, Re2 shifts the focus to the
input by processing questions twice, thereby enhancing the understanding
process. Consequently, Re2 demonstrates strong generality and compatibility
with most thought-eliciting prompting methods, including CoT. Crucially, Re2
facilitates a "bidirectional" encoding in unidirectional decoder-only LLMs
because the first pass could provide global information for the second pass. We
begin with a preliminary empirical study as the foundation of Re2, illustrating
its potential to enable "bidirectional" attention mechanisms. We then evaluate
Re2 on extensive reasoning benchmarks across 14 datasets, spanning 112
experiments, to validate its effectiveness and generality. Our findings
indicate that, with the exception of a few scenarios on vanilla ChatGPT, Re2
consistently enhances the reasoning performance of LLMs through a simple
re-reading strategy. Further analyses reveal Re2's adaptability, showing how it
can be effectively integrated with different LLMs, thought-eliciting prompting,
and ensemble strategies. Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/Tebmer/Rereading-LLM-Reasoning/} | [
0.0237877201,
0.0185233783,
-0.0190479867,
0.0774141252,
-0.0531456284,
0.0433451124,
0.0020048653,
-0.0305198245,
0.0343861356,
-0.0290864632,
-0.0104511352,
-0.0260800477,
-0.0138359852,
0.0174867883,
0.0159666054,
-0.0245054513,
0.0680317357,
-0.0695101693,
0.0106087346,
-0.0259333178,
-0.0000334045,
-0.0012569734,
-0.0177606083,
0.0189131182,
0.0391663276,
-0.0446327142,
-0.049527593,
0.0220895316,
0.0099631902,
-0.0401033498,
-0.01711859,
0.0321604684,
0.0049705426,
0.0552701727,
0.000002201,
-0.028821053,
-0.0313983299,
-0.0174735729,
-0.059995234,
0.0152170397,
-0.0094101718,
0.0183112007,
0.0092249736,
0.0113315554,
-0.0259497501,
-0.0094107985,
0.0255475976,
0.0403936729,
0.0535108,
0.0668182224,
0.0159679316,
-0.0394188613,
0.0176893529,
-0.0254810397,
0.0361336321,
-0.0514922142,
0.0065873838,
0.0305353347,
0.0185480546,
0.0450934544,
-0.0362166762,
0.0709549561,
0.0634705201,
0.0012370957,
0.0123634664,
0.0590255633,
-0.0100966189,
-0.0361719728,
-0.0200600922,
0.0746072307,
0.0072159311,
-0.0139787728,
-0.0288144369,
0.0172967184,
-0.0029553461,
-0.0039409222,
-0.0387413651,
0.0309060849,
-0.0349580869,
0.0087226797,
0.0215713531,
0.0138151431,
0.0279115345,
0.0018457385,
-0.0622751713,
0.0817047507,
-0.0041154902,
-0.0465048775,
0.0011240444,
0.0356666632,
-0.0115441494,
-0.050093744,
0.0070187729,
0.0410489738,
-0.0221011136,
0.0346517675,
0.0109911002,
-0.0171619598,
0.0016319476,
0.0165211894,
0.0165235922,
0.0594534166,
-0.0354372412,
0.0783893541,
-0.0314534456,
0.044701349,
-0.0337175243,
0.0440477096,
-0.0486814603,
-0.0071435515,
-0.0316852592,
-0.0273972917,
-0.0245546959,
0.0308148377,
-0.0286268108,
-0.0141495848,
0.0053061931,
0.0478387885,
0.0365488529,
0.0015909714,
0.0129935276,
-0.0222579762,
-0.0010653653,
-0.0344236046,
-0.0224822965,
0.0627188608,
-0.0297778323,
-0.003271268,
0.034093421,
-0.0754836276,
-0.0380505957,
-0.0095098568,
-0.0197973121,
-0.0296311472,
-0.0331266113,
0.0474948362,
-0.0278321169,
-0.0447457284,
-0.0131876413,
-0.024947362,
-0.0198648516,
-0.0683622584,
0.0163850114,
-0.0435010381,
0.0489734598,
0.031427525,
-0.0130526451,
-0.0066054077,
0.0078784833,
0.0248966496,
-0.0203728806,
0.0712423697,
0.0293402057,
0.0270022694,
-0.0034173937,
0.0224697776,
-0.0511266403,
0.0546491593,
0.0319395624,
0.0109173357,
0.0074908487,
0.0026240244,
0.0070290184,
0.0160962325,
0.0314264297,
-0.0220510121,
0.0130428756,
0.0396937914,
0.0019477439,
0.0374051929,
0.0151891811,
0.0431399047,
-0.0535285436,
-0.0173808131,
0.0682156458,
0.0375929624,
0.0187386628,
0.0110354181,
0.0246541724,
0.0194444582,
-0.0061928201,
0.0158096757,
-0.0689825565,
0.0794896707,
-0.0392670818,
0.0331761017,
0.0374116823,
0.0088974508,
-0.0257125571,
-0.0465109535,
0.0145312697,
0.0443792082,
-0.0066712769,
0.0641806945,
0.0359197855,
-0.0026255003,
-0.0497966409,
0.0194849782,
0.02475008,
-0.0477191135,
-0.0253526103,
-0.0678609386,
0.0600764602,
0.064866662,
0.0571016409,
0.0065904474,
-0.0269229226,
0.009681426,
0.0137230055,
0.0328587815,
0.0389066674,
0.0156569835,
-0.00944761,
-0.0472971275,
-0.0144863026,
0.0025547002,
-0.0131439287,
0.0404556058,
0.0183416288,
-0.0033904386,
-0.0127721522,
-0.0164091289,
0.028191315,
0.005061626,
-0.0208310205,
-0.0196463503,
-0.0286406204,
0.0117807966,
0.0169135574,
-0.0100703239,
0.0073553305,
0.0270884857,
0.0297054127,
-0.027480308,
-0.0101409033,
0.0221209992,
-0.0816092566,
-0.0989016816,
0.0147566386,
0.0122120604,
-0.0392780565,
0.0194463376,
-0.0231398549,
-0.0281638876,
0.0194491576,
-0.0204623472,
0.0434793755,
-0.0527716652,
0.0280580129,
0.0085416092,
-0.0169026554,
-0.0542026348,
0.0573518239,
-0.0125667276,
-0.0153141432,
0.0155514432,
-0.0066673281,
-0.0245411675,
-0.0407588631,
-0.0235849731,
0.0523684546,
-0.0146697629,
-0.0192372352,
-0.0248931982,
0.0065833144,
-0.0686641112,
-0.0330387168,
-0.0562399924,
0.0060153538,
-0.0133023132,
0.0097026257,
0.0081234779,
0.0075097834,
-0.0049083964,
-0.002891989,
-0.025494799,
-0.0097923549,
-0.0078950142,
0.0260090847,
0.0087033818,
-0.0215369463,
-0.0106124543,
0.0210445076,
-0.0281005893,
-0.0010844656,
0.0407171547,
-0.0041640727,
-0.0082262494,
-0.0655068532,
0.0267738048,
-0.0205194913,
-0.0126593802,
-0.0328847431,
-0.0117740836,
0.0233688913,
-0.019403629,
0.0572502576,
0.0843392164,
-0.0245184284,
-0.0114957849,
0.0333042033,
-0.0125003122,
-0.0737213343,
0.040455956,
0.0040305462,
-0.0445675887,
-0.0055862791,
-0.0426631458,
-0.0261831637,
0.0603928566,
-0.0056335637,
-0.0080004316,
-0.0459308065,
-0.0055438005,
-0.0161438044,
-0.0402761884,
-0.0804432258,
-0.0234169103,
-0.0190524701,
0.0425155014,
-0.045446638,
-0.0262813959,
0.1047026888,
-0.037332315,
-0.0453433357,
-0.0771185756,
0.0424438715,
-0.0293238014,
0.0788131431,
-0.0291427057,
-0.0092335353,
0.0178825054,
-0.0420904048,
-0.0434279144,
-0.0081094829,
0.004191014,
-0.0431520492,
0.0576370545,
-0.028758809,
0.007646698,
-0.0217612088,
-0.0384287648,
-0.0678104162,
0.0101662958,
-0.0509548709,
-0.0263621435,
-0.0123711387,
0.0124014942,
-0.0177926198,
0.0128597915,
0.0694041476,
0.0404086411,
-0.041875504,
-0.0005158632,
-0.029372789,
0.0460345447,
0.0191435795,
0.0095516695,
0.027410252,
-0.0523122065,
0.0755556896,
0.0800154507,
0.0117798541,
-0.0282866731,
-0.0069377469,
0.00718881,
0.0176772177,
-0.0011348487,
0.0120443553,
0.0011405115,
0.0867776498,
-0.0995614752,
-0.0214926824,
0.1027814522,
0.034594249,
-0.061864417,
-0.0224772338,
-0.0485918187,
0.0677596778,
0.0180993062,
0.033930555,
-0.0642628819,
-0.0622692332,
0.0454970375,
0.0070167938,
0.0221511535,
-0.0209737252,
-0.0089066625,
-0.1054899395,
0.0209833644,
0.0178283807,
-0.0167111773,
-0.0285958257,
-0.0165349133,
-0.0180217456,
0.0303162504,
0.0226976313,
0.0877029896,
0.011794854,
0.0082030715,
0.0092280721,
0.0016522016,
0.0011856054,
0.0387850665,
-0.0293385163,
0.0344253294,
0.0600423925,
0.0000090315,
0.0411880091,
-0.0292751491,
0.0330861062,
-0.0337705612,
0.0110588288,
-0.0079616318,
0.0169205647,
-0.0153228445,
0.0065530348,
-0.0426249877,
0.0189039744,
-0.0301561411,
0.0020002904,
0.028348824,
0.0936667472,
-0.0139013203,
-0.0211528372,
-0.0247849934,
0.0120296488,
-0.0181907769,
0.0874931067,
0.0529912114,
-0.002994169,
-0.0420700349,
-0.0281984415,
-0.0270745475,
-0.0582328588,
-0.0234587472,
0.0229087155,
0.0351145975,
0.0076912497,
-0.0420911722,
-0.0668147728,
0.0433422588,
-0.0027212503,
-0.0100633642,
0.0202365909,
0.0157937352,
0.0063405666,
-0.0458862036,
0.0390652269,
-0.0540828705,
0.0121093057,
-0.0356957167,
0.0065188138,
-0.0024705448,
-0.0409932546,
-0.0222677737,
0.0216122679,
-0.0840004906,
-0.0436458439,
-0.0230731051,
0.0281235706,
0.0260168612,
0.0490640737,
-0.0173497014,
-0.0269259289,
0.0078374557,
-0.011529427,
-0.0237580501,
0.0115877902,
0.0143210804,
0.0315175131,
0.021698093,
0.0548189394,
-0.0159182455,
0.0009553735,
0.0173628777,
0.070713222,
-0.0188681558,
0.002899006,
0.0243543219,
0.0321460217,
0.0247728769,
0.0202191416,
-0.0084168045,
-0.0208013598,
0.0597928092,
-0.0243034232,
-0.0005228425,
-0.0420913994,
0.0261944924,
0.028519284,
-0.0403632484,
-0.0003587058,
-0.0235565715,
0.0179597158,
0.0144456765,
0.0033740315,
0.0201421902,
-0.003430516,
0.0178927016,
0.0407199338,
0.0056879087,
-0.0391734689,
0.0159275141,
-0.0083482452,
0.0461627617,
0.0007659824,
0.0881632343,
0.0530494899,
-0.040146891,
-0.0288635734,
0.0195235871,
-0.0780285671,
-0.0568001121,
0.0673919469,
0.0357907005,
0.0244015288,
0.0289687514,
0.0162518471,
-0.0014760139,
0.0009824167,
-0.005498975,
0.0412921757,
0.0152555127,
-0.0563633442,
0.032747943,
0.0315280147,
0.0023651109,
-0.0089286305,
0.0531931892,
-0.0434236489,
0.0036750368,
0.0150804073,
0.0258949641,
-0.0398898385,
-0.0327057205,
-0.0187769737,
-0.0111418646,
-0.0375549272,
0.0382903144,
-0.0611868091,
-0.0603368729,
-0.0186628252,
-0.0065019168,
0.0062177693,
-0.0336676463,
-0.0025759682,
0.0545775667,
-0.0022753284,
-0.0544049814,
-0.0093963668,
0.0405519716,
-0.0411095656,
-0.0421673879,
-0.0199438184,
-6.762566838e-33,
-0.0086696064,
-0.0090817027,
0.0554707125,
-0.0413374715,
-0.0476786941,
-0.0057639792,
-0.064557232,
-0.0072796964,
-0.0239383336,
0.0114020864,
-0.0362016968,
0.0212787166,
0.00944723,
0.0233553238,
0.0006785555,
-0.0320571065,
0.012943875,
0.0077421293,
-0.0364169665,
0.0314716846,
0.0238500927,
0.0321142897,
0.0177556314,
0.0103109628,
0.0234696176,
-0.0239924192,
0.0180931389,
0.0470543541,
-0.0544680431,
0.0266142562,
-0.0257959105,
-0.0027287707,
0.0293544903,
-0.0351330787,
-0.0145402402,
0.0591168106,
-0.080724448,
0.0027229362,
0.0294265468,
0.0057313205,
-0.0656902269,
-0.0269786101,
0.0014756317,
0.0071999072,
0.0283257123,
-0.0453571603,
-0.0100065265,
-0.0168917291,
-0.0431143194,
0.0329446569,
-0.0197567362,
0.0205734037,
-0.0188411791,
-0.0455662496,
0.0206019264,
0.0633743033,
-0.0013625193,
0.0458268113,
-0.0434509963,
-0.0026993884,
0.0212123469,
0.0126444045,
0.0692679435,
0.0063644145,
-0.0022604859,
0.040357843,
0.0129691176,
-0.0167183354,
-0.0626655072,
-0.0217057485,
-0.0033971476,
0.0021903731,
0.0313793011,
0.0039364686,
0.0252789762,
0.0195843317,
-0.0619171374,
-0.020042086,
0.0336452127,
0.0453075804,
0.0565955825,
0.0216686707,
-0.050468605,
-0.005849292,
-0.0401840135,
0.0147678684,
-0.0650391504,
-0.018183995,
0.0470522307,
-0.0007202141,
-0.0167334639,
-0.045536764,
0.0624659956,
-0.0304196663,
0.0145832272,
0.0371106118,
0.0050161793,
0.0207433067,
-0.0170696322,
0.0696949363,
-0.0337784924,
0.0283964388,
0.0133735826,
0.0096789617,
-0.0182882547,
0.0247185547,
0.0348270349,
-0.0103810458,
-0.033416491,
-0.0235302057,
-0.078462109,
0.0389741994,
-0.0233375188,
0.0269977115,
0.0323151648,
0.0392374918,
-0.008245579,
0.0526371449,
-0.0032718889,
0.007133584,
-0.0673811212,
0.0172945745,
-0.0114659434,
0.0067684846,
-0.0221980009,
0.014065614,
-0.0427310765,
-0.0046271649,
0.0201074388,
-0.0625233725,
-0.015279524,
0.0427862965,
2.877e-7,
0.0133513808,
0.0443933122,
0.0227336958,
0.0353439786,
0.0197170544,
0.028939927,
-0.0388014801,
-0.0106336884,
0.0739306957,
-0.0409496725,
-0.0098264152,
0.0709835812,
0.0548331812,
-0.0050669103,
-0.099723801,
-0.0312243626,
-0.0489753336,
-0.0056191012,
-0.0292126425,
-0.0187544655,
0.0757667795,
0.0739876628,
-0.0074302731,
0.0050531179,
0.0309314486,
-0.0057495879,
0.036720261,
-0.0192067772,
-0.0061801593,
-0.0056309891,
0.0313311145,
-0.0171472952,
0.0192864146,
0.019395126,
0.0334775001,
-0.0101664728,
-0.0301908311,
0.0477012023,
0.0313751847,
-0.0454699062,
-0.0415579975,
-0.006963545,
-0.0069836234,
-0.0849290565,
0.0762110204,
-0.0663845316,
-0.0321654603,
0.0158583988,
-0.0269330852,
-0.0227763671,
-0.022698991,
0.0216256697,
-0.0198613815,
0.0315886624,
0.0081731193,
-0.0311166365,
0.0234275255,
-0.0921414718,
-0.0455924496,
-0.0281308498,
-0.0434155911,
-0.0281966738,
-0.0532485135,
-0.0079786228,
0.0480093881,
-0.05743213,
-0.0406524278,
2.611050526e-34,
0.0458283015,
-0.0274457335,
0.0374633223,
0.0624919683,
0.035254512,
-0.0202226397,
-0.014259588,
0.0019423472,
0.0124399392,
-0.1003261805,
-0.0370818898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06236v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06236v1 | The first step is the hardest: Pitfalls of Representing and Tokenizing Temporal Data for Large Language Models | 2023-09-12T13:51:29 | 2023-09-12T13:51:29 | Dimitris Spathis, Fahim Kawsar | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable generalization
across diverse tasks, leading individuals to increasingly use them as personal
assistants and universal computing engines. Nevertheless, a notable obstacle
emerges when feeding numerical/temporal data into these models, such as data
sourced from wearables or electronic health records. LLMs employ tokenizers in
their input that break down text into smaller units. However, tokenizers are
not designed to represent numerical values and might struggle to understand
repetitive patterns and context, treating consecutive values as separate tokens
and disregarding their temporal relationships. Here, we discuss recent works
that employ LLMs for human-centric tasks such as in mobile health sensing and
present a case study showing that popular LLMs tokenize temporal data
incorrectly. To address that, we highlight potential solutions such as prompt
tuning with lightweight embedding layers as well as multimodal adapters, that
can help bridge this "modality gap". While the capability of language models to
generalize to other modalities with minimal or no finetuning is exciting, this
paper underscores the fact that their outputs cannot be meaningful if they
stumble over input nuances. | [
0.0043292558,
0.0747075304,
-0.0279202908,
-0.0001600699,
-0.0172023997,
-0.0275707245,
0.0482476801,
0.0143712815,
-0.0136313504,
-0.0303228926,
0.0163343921,
-0.0237629283,
0.038455274,
0.0465756543,
0.01523975,
-0.0784739703,
0.0661387593,
-0.0220665019,
0.0161268786,
0.045408085,
0.0225215387,
-0.0150388479,
-0.0182210524,
0.0682884157,
-0.0428630002,
-0.0285090413,
-0.0159016922,
-0.0185680445,
0.0009215091,
-0.0826745033,
-0.0458029695,
0.0302202404,
0.007332189,
0.0344042331,
0.0000020134,
-0.003649568,
0.0268422849,
-0.0089697456,
-0.0154411616,
-0.019430954,
0.0725711063,
-0.023367472,
-0.0016764788,
0.0167687628,
-0.0390634723,
-0.0306224898,
0.0343014635,
0.0235904939,
0.0475474335,
0.0298233572,
-0.0251057651,
0.0513112433,
0.0259002168,
0.0063882871,
0.0321474746,
-0.0025751716,
-0.0241763927,
-0.0473806635,
0.0824288428,
0.0165544376,
-0.0202228837,
0.0438237488,
0.0332603231,
0.0222291388,
0.0317684226,
0.0476998165,
-0.0127068376,
-0.0215499718,
-0.0426088795,
0.0501120985,
-0.0163193271,
-0.0115286829,
0.0174022503,
0.0162421521,
0.0022030275,
-0.014130231,
-0.0489538014,
-0.0147329699,
-0.0030054578,
0.0088018738,
-0.0295738205,
0.0202359241,
0.0417757668,
-0.0094566839,
-0.0501895212,
0.0445310101,
0.0067530316,
0.0006861093,
-0.0354270488,
-0.0358681269,
0.0069103604,
-0.0466852859,
0.0498910323,
0.0478049181,
-0.0451948717,
-0.0144013688,
-0.0704452395,
-0.0316755399,
0.0229094122,
-0.0363179408,
0.0310511887,
0.062612243,
-0.0427043326,
0.0245819353,
0.0092978226,
0.0142731583,
-0.0187928863,
-0.0061798375,
-0.0390564762,
0.0087656574,
-0.0224381313,
-0.0332037024,
-0.008027846,
-0.0050595519,
-0.0536781587,
-0.0343493111,
-0.0255627744,
0.0515901633,
-0.0016759798,
-0.0028340416,
-0.0337720849,
0.0043008341,
0.0032502266,
-0.0006141238,
-0.0122733638,
0.0164335929,
-0.0443417579,
0.027107941,
0.0249442961,
-0.0820382759,
0.0013950797,
-0.0117255077,
0.0300570466,
-0.0201375503,
-0.0349947102,
0.0840754136,
-0.0004126433,
0.0132515049,
-0.0110658575,
-0.0490785949,
-0.0281401575,
0.0171568617,
-0.0036010779,
-0.0552479662,
0.0178161301,
0.0353741571,
-0.0052691577,
-0.0410604328,
0.0262460057,
0.0465730131,
-0.0342607796,
0.0909822509,
-0.0208827574,
0.0159951728,
0.0174926482,
0.0057569579,
0.0245334823,
0.0353975892,
0.0827604979,
0.0001873598,
0.0362883136,
-0.0280801319,
0.0013581418,
0.0670583621,
-0.0058372221,
-0.0493726246,
-0.0689714178,
-0.0326116942,
0.0046598073,
0.0623190105,
0.0115816062,
0.0675399899,
-0.010241379,
0.0108518144,
0.0934067145,
0.0708064213,
0.0167700388,
-0.0021327245,
0.0248455591,
-0.0434440859,
-0.0047719069,
-0.0363998488,
-0.0713727847,
-0.0079328548,
0.0109306509,
0.0042793266,
0.0058358978,
0.0341409035,
-0.005169292,
-0.0483068638,
-0.0322433636,
-0.027526591,
0.0306225903,
0.0006531658,
0.0272101518,
-0.0311380792,
0.0222637337,
0.0526103117,
0.0090412926,
-0.0444879793,
0.0151784504,
-0.0149733424,
0.0349853225,
0.1045079231,
0.025789503,
-0.0287405849,
0.0010956483,
0.0006075402,
0.0429362245,
0.0052933306,
0.051865682,
-0.0183868725,
0.0228401199,
-0.0346029587,
-0.0148285097,
0.0264165327,
-0.0025245633,
-0.0352574065,
-0.0279262681,
0.0507477038,
0.0114628877,
-0.0395106152,
0.0029712969,
0.0316987261,
-0.0023757226,
-0.0336323455,
-0.0011116787,
0.0202706493,
-0.013865388,
0.0325126462,
0.0286449622,
0.0444702506,
0.0436421931,
-0.0678960532,
0.0370125286,
0.0625421777,
-0.0606030449,
0.0093793813,
0.0366679244,
0.0127300303,
0.0087714707,
-0.0027608303,
-0.0143180452,
-0.0391105264,
0.0065641725,
-0.0027393436,
0.0685598105,
-0.0007547452,
-0.0094267242,
0.0208734833,
0.0226835068,
-0.0206095483,
0.0065706945,
-0.0140359858,
-0.0037714147,
0.0188936088,
0.0140344379,
-0.0202515256,
-0.0328173712,
-0.0322620757,
0.0362701751,
0.0137465345,
0.0228497218,
0.0166457258,
-0.022223765,
-0.0524996296,
-0.0344964154,
-0.1447797716,
-0.0177957341,
-0.0043159081,
0.0097772442,
0.0041181506,
0.0565343909,
-0.0005102001,
-0.0473054573,
-0.0195179209,
-0.0278356411,
0.0040888037,
0.0440891199,
0.0294621848,
0.0187998544,
-0.0060089719,
-0.0180428959,
0.0034289712,
-0.0519817695,
0.0413101315,
-0.0234727189,
-0.0099477498,
-0.0325972773,
-0.0620355122,
-0.0155976294,
0.0121618276,
-0.002677833,
0.0192839708,
0.0614741184,
-0.0111551685,
0.0909227878,
0.0510550551,
0.0134608392,
0.0756705925,
0.0310806483,
-0.0444358066,
-0.0413135849,
0.0104421414,
-0.0115723331,
0.0408304222,
-0.0256577842,
-0.0226009525,
-0.000717355,
0.0832027644,
0.0009840418,
0.0365717486,
-0.0198601,
0.0428392142,
-0.0395307243,
-0.019118024,
-0.0429360382,
0.0390278921,
-0.0635616183,
0.0339299105,
-0.0025038205,
-0.0520618595,
0.0421313755,
-0.0145469401,
-0.004258859,
0.0217705388,
-0.0325881802,
-0.0196228102,
0.0632707104,
-0.0077550621,
-0.0063478439,
-0.0031809257,
-0.032198064,
-0.0171761196,
0.0192836132,
-0.0343600698,
-0.040686518,
0.0552711673,
-0.0526322499,
-0.0250391923,
0.0102329971,
-0.0517170615,
-0.0270555876,
-0.0481992736,
-0.0632030815,
-0.0070346468,
-0.0196649786,
-0.0046847765,
-0.0465391651,
0.0152583839,
0.0015402088,
0.0539179891,
-0.0156235499,
-0.0002025224,
-0.0316005796,
0.0237309784,
0.0235568769,
0.0431460328,
-0.0095690275,
-0.0086541697,
0.0251921806,
0.0350542553,
0.0657329708,
-0.0131200263,
-0.0667362362,
0.0119197639,
0.0204034746,
-0.0158150345,
-0.0226415154,
0.0694749057,
0.0746081769,
-0.0796340778,
0.0117988978,
0.1168121397,
0.0134595446,
-0.031493783,
0.0451599099,
-0.028414486,
0.0141423605,
0.0023352208,
-0.0108086886,
-0.0662119389,
-0.0318022929,
0.0238294192,
0.0295095798,
0.0183208454,
-0.0180088971,
0.0076858099,
-0.0541368388,
-0.0058820853,
0.0326524563,
-0.0508592166,
0.0029893976,
-0.0396099612,
0.0019257587,
0.0171533823,
0.0489504673,
0.0043415679,
-0.03438548,
0.0198136754,
0.0100816898,
-0.0580380596,
-0.0547672398,
0.0052867606,
0.0004523628,
0.0691853911,
0.055050429,
0.0436459444,
-0.0089168306,
-0.0279052556,
0.0301435385,
0.0322502851,
0.0279366337,
-0.0361373164,
-0.0091846874,
0.0203973819,
-0.0040560202,
-0.0144886523,
0.0435672961,
-0.0164790936,
-0.0482604839,
0.0081645576,
0.0961879864,
-0.0320699289,
0.0218956955,
-0.0462648943,
-0.0431619659,
0.0278109629,
0.0290796962,
0.0387760028,
-0.0692278817,
-0.039596688,
-0.0360247642,
0.0139425751,
-0.0304011293,
-0.04365246,
-0.0099507524,
0.0068803383,
-0.0418803245,
-0.046690695,
-0.0500244163,
0.0142895216,
0.027332861,
0.0166265983,
0.0227977373,
0.0402543172,
0.0255772118,
-0.0592845418,
0.0605501831,
0.0006893126,
0.0458201803,
-0.0822460949,
0.0222921278,
-0.02401313,
-0.0324228443,
0.0006903781,
0.0339523703,
-0.0764879733,
-0.0459449589,
0.0119653456,
0.0309749637,
0.0253293794,
0.0427266397,
-0.0197005253,
-0.0448837467,
0.0554713197,
0.0730962455,
-0.0714913532,
0.0117998598,
-0.0002551272,
0.0290813558,
-0.0001954874,
0.0171328429,
-0.0418060012,
0.0063524786,
-0.0292960126,
0.0387054347,
-0.027849365,
-0.0238954071,
0.0196571238,
-0.008080394,
0.0624752454,
-0.0068104202,
0.018755218,
-0.00616968,
-0.0228850506,
-0.0297986288,
-0.0140898023,
-0.0431623682,
0.0051839626,
-0.0373878591,
0.021235479,
-0.019430967,
-0.0238011573,
0.0033907434,
0.0280505046,
-0.0461392924,
0.0599561483,
-0.0103356326,
0.0418973193,
0.0271405485,
0.0050999825,
-0.0012208445,
0.0207849853,
-0.0538198277,
0.0113953054,
-0.0339135081,
0.0265324749,
-0.0094730025,
-0.0119230775,
-0.0559320115,
0.0578195751,
-0.0666961744,
-0.00943268,
0.022907583,
0.022378169,
-0.002730994,
0.0045112716,
0.0188540202,
0.0017706957,
-0.0147365797,
-0.0380067825,
0.0300492197,
0.028163949,
-0.0021542418,
0.020606447,
0.0135407113,
-0.0368928872,
-0.050100062,
0.0513685681,
-0.0264411531,
0.018338006,
0.0391160809,
-0.0321832858,
-0.0310407933,
0.0157890413,
0.0231081937,
0.0169838294,
-0.0654285327,
-0.0218097512,
-0.0730807707,
-0.0511849634,
0.0618121661,
0.017251661,
-0.027951885,
-0.0255930685,
-0.0052535264,
0.0279299095,
0.0027567572,
-0.0223439597,
-0.0173665546,
0.0422677845,
-0.0092267012,
-0.0355506837,
-0.0328751355,
-5.97223166e-33,
-0.0149202095,
-0.0267260112,
0.0240226313,
-0.0342813544,
-0.0341234431,
0.0408765785,
-0.0329191089,
0.0167388301,
0.0159929898,
-0.012703795,
-0.0512915589,
-0.0282615367,
0.0281304307,
0.0109500801,
0.0480793193,
0.0014343038,
0.0649810731,
-0.0077255256,
-0.0286570583,
0.0005834423,
0.0466416143,
0.0382811129,
0.035111025,
-0.0617056191,
0.0381625742,
0.0342898741,
0.0019432764,
0.0093195261,
0.0416582264,
0.0576657206,
-0.0341000706,
0.0559043474,
0.0225847978,
0.0132955788,
-0.043281354,
0.0909395292,
-0.1073051021,
-0.0616612583,
0.0252300575,
0.0431750603,
-0.0203632582,
-0.0654260963,
0.0461360179,
-0.0421633907,
-0.0403492227,
0.0237961262,
0.0212574862,
-0.0502958596,
-0.0555640794,
-0.0177318491,
-0.0201575831,
0.0284932964,
0.0143791307,
-0.0073998128,
0.0213997979,
0.0078769056,
-0.016025098,
0.0047359304,
-0.0907478333,
0.0350187346,
-0.0248330254,
0.0208103247,
0.0295168571,
0.0410190895,
0.0196113288,
0.0500256456,
0.0220286399,
-0.0144507298,
-0.0535299294,
0.0471846275,
0.0407390036,
0.035802044,
0.00392609,
0.0096593341,
0.0601222254,
-0.04975098,
-0.0213700123,
0.014223488,
0.0214717779,
0.0165666938,
0.0004995769,
0.048325263,
-0.0332703181,
-0.0017841243,
-0.0195494033,
0.0093067382,
-0.0234955009,
-0.0418546386,
0.0342847146,
-0.0047986754,
0.0169700682,
0.013678194,
0.0300611351,
-0.0139055159,
-0.0355036333,
-0.0367797352,
0.0299128685,
0.0283710286,
-0.0042518354,
-0.0083793439,
-0.0296696182,
-0.0176455341,
0.0243564881,
-0.0139639424,
0.0566508882,
0.0049292864,
0.0080648707,
0.0422416255,
-0.0714282095,
-0.0380008258,
-0.0042197374,
-0.0134202,
0.004925306,
0.0021202413,
0.0899152458,
-0.0154869249,
-0.0224582423,
0.0547565334,
-0.0356355868,
0.0029590449,
-0.036728926,
-0.0133798299,
0.0019230315,
0.0118233385,
-0.0276865233,
-0.038414374,
-0.0843904689,
0.049817048,
0.0396299474,
-0.0519352928,
-0.015360401,
0.0073519121,
2.661e-7,
0.0147258844,
0.0302064717,
0.0056164041,
-0.0087568192,
0.0370469689,
0.0102974763,
-0.0031119704,
0.0238315333,
-0.0404213369,
0.0071731503,
0.0049083363,
0.0134942392,
0.0541585945,
0.0447777025,
-0.0317607038,
-0.0308578648,
-0.0512539297,
0.0145764612,
-0.0624190867,
0.0270022042,
0.0306625441,
0.0908044651,
0.0233870242,
0.0089546917,
0.0210521966,
-0.0502084531,
0.0326369815,
-0.0506763943,
0.0071208952,
-0.0219706781,
0.0253715608,
-0.0145880291,
-0.0066890083,
-0.02039041,
-0.0114183202,
-0.0194794275,
0.0126964515,
0.0674016103,
-0.0341060124,
0.0092627956,
-0.0282372888,
-0.0367046557,
-0.038660381,
-0.0332300775,
0.0668092966,
-0.0187950898,
-0.0184379462,
-0.0526877828,
0.0173934065,
-0.0098872585,
-0.0053332984,
-0.005042241,
-0.0265276749,
0.0203352831,
0.0264516547,
0.0022843105,
-0.0118705807,
-0.0537947789,
-0.0617456995,
0.0041788141,
-0.0472837798,
-0.0544740856,
-0.076112844,
0.0160156563,
0.0186614264,
-0.0702382922,
-0.0117740706,
2.485202376e-34,
0.0235164873,
-0.0250291135,
-0.0023396232,
0.037221197,
0.0279891491,
-0.0192853026,
0.0287608374,
0.0514039546,
0.0538386367,
-0.0594004877,
-0.0504354201
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06219v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06219v3 | Human Action Co-occurrence in Lifestyle Vlogs using Graph Link Prediction | 2023-09-12T13:38:44 | 2024-06-19T03:18:41 | Oana Ignat, Santiago Castro, Weiji Li, Rada Mihalcea | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.IR | We introduce the task of automatic human action co-occurrence identification,
i.e., determine whether two human actions can co-occur in the same interval of
time. We create and make publicly available the ACE (Action Co-occurrencE)
dataset, consisting of a large graph of ~12k co-occurring pairs of visual
actions and their corresponding video clips. We describe graph link prediction
models that leverage visual and textual information to automatically infer if
two actions are co-occurring. We show that graphs are particularly well suited
to capture relations between human actions, and the learned graph
representations are effective for our task and capture novel and relevant
information across different data domains. The ACE dataset and the code
introduced in this paper are publicly available at
https://github.com/MichiganNLP/vlog_action_co-occurrence. | [
-0.0265762713,
0.0053917854,
0.0010733709,
0.0228623003,
-0.0002971939,
0.0333349817,
-0.0408259332,
0.0211766753,
0.0709493086,
-0.0536069125,
-0.0169576891,
0.0053299149,
-0.0289890692,
0.0584478937,
0.0355450511,
-0.0378501639,
0.0433405042,
0.0417988263,
-0.0048802202,
0.0378132425,
0.0467785448,
0.0191323031,
-0.0084009077,
0.0280502774,
-0.0543850325,
-0.0087535977,
0.0070150238,
-0.0030211054,
0.0781541839,
-0.0365967043,
-0.0049087484,
0.0095740044,
0.059117578,
-0.0112578766,
0.0000016907,
0.009189304,
0.0161082149,
-0.0276720468,
0.0067532104,
-0.0037162364,
-0.0211975835,
-0.0108223101,
0.0397745557,
-0.0017029361,
-0.0417399965,
0.0080142459,
-0.002658528,
0.0159092341,
0.0435170233,
0.0263197236,
-0.0375934467,
-0.0173981078,
-0.034517698,
-0.0074143144,
0.0484185889,
0.0221467689,
0.0196303334,
0.0255707558,
0.0361765288,
-0.0250012968,
-0.0502795018,
0.0048181377,
0.0057037203,
0.0116732921,
0.0143520199,
0.043863833,
-0.039228946,
-0.0353206098,
0.010677129,
0.0956573933,
-0.0214911103,
-0.0075497157,
0.0504364781,
-0.0049195695,
-0.0130898627,
0.0290614683,
-0.0403045155,
-0.0165533405,
-0.0052141077,
0.0261955317,
-0.0459955074,
0.0205128714,
0.0192285534,
-0.0192643702,
0.0865005627,
-0.0057698647,
0.0107501065,
0.0393154025,
-0.0313843377,
0.0133543396,
0.0220896062,
-0.0497661494,
-0.0023169152,
0.0119279595,
0.0114090955,
-0.0121896463,
-0.0584940948,
0.0507352129,
0.0192049425,
-0.0425378494,
0.0547945797,
-0.0026126921,
0.0030829408,
0.0441229381,
0.0211886372,
0.0367822088,
-0.038990438,
0.0068703294,
-0.0284918416,
0.0302617196,
-0.0442826226,
0.0386258028,
0.0229128432,
0.0028175425,
-0.0141415345,
-0.0610286184,
-0.0468051434,
0.0064988867,
-0.0414820984,
0.0323742181,
-0.020216722,
0.0599281564,
0.0126953367,
-0.0142571013,
0.0085963001,
-0.0363995396,
-0.0072529404,
0.0417421125,
-0.0560310744,
0.0107339956,
-0.0064363065,
0.012328513,
0.0646120682,
-0.0344090126,
0.0313971713,
-0.0158504061,
-0.007492478,
-0.0201112591,
0.0100063672,
-0.0412724204,
-0.0210558847,
-0.0013341577,
0.013856574,
-0.0647193119,
0.0495409146,
-0.032655552,
-0.0166237615,
-0.0209809337,
0.0280118547,
-0.0032112864,
-0.0516287833,
0.0564289279,
0.0621188246,
0.0294760093,
-0.000336886,
0.0339432955,
0.0264495239,
0.0144716715,
0.0298650451,
0.0209754109,
0.01268664,
0.0437493548,
0.0301060118,
0.0288907718,
-0.0074889604,
-0.0026575073,
0.0090450095,
0.0134961233,
0.0080571892,
0.0164052732,
0.0213714764,
0.0520694293,
-0.0390486605,
-0.0393615998,
0.048503723,
0.037970487,
-0.0082923537,
-0.0395982079,
0.067318134,
0.0257593188,
-0.0188380033,
0.007013211,
0.0142423632,
0.0438695103,
0.0240827147,
-0.0328346118,
-0.0079827318,
-0.0182954185,
-0.0714887306,
-0.0115711316,
0.0074963486,
-0.0596367568,
0.06506899,
-0.0184038728,
-0.0031469292,
-0.0151523873,
-0.0224433206,
0.0117315399,
-0.008404905,
0.0144767109,
0.0103836171,
-0.0133507382,
0.009756837,
0.0513839498,
-0.0186851565,
0.0226414446,
-0.0091889556,
-0.0060390895,
0.050958477,
-0.0851172209,
0.0028045855,
-0.0272333622,
0.0365795381,
-0.0295999702,
-0.0302288495,
-0.0370530374,
0.0192333944,
-0.0086943563,
0.0031433713,
0.0167361554,
0.0105074756,
0.047169257,
0.0059451736,
0.0139150377,
0.0064176037,
0.0024105564,
0.008150598,
0.0190231055,
-0.0029986084,
0.0215700231,
0.0198390745,
0.0001796594,
0.0292866956,
-0.0187295191,
-0.0201709699,
0.0786992833,
0.0286459569,
-0.0296986159,
0.0342099369,
-0.0538387634,
-0.0518862084,
0.0042769578,
-0.0086633684,
-0.0459657945,
0.0310314521,
-0.0251516439,
0.0056962268,
-0.0483302623,
-0.060286507,
0.0430647768,
-0.026138708,
0.0266245455,
0.0430134386,
-0.0010294258,
0.0108502926,
0.0029942715,
0.0264516994,
0.0130569376,
-0.0726282597,
-0.0069421548,
-0.0632928833,
-0.0324306227,
0.0033137903,
0.0335198157,
0.0016682647,
-0.0598498322,
0.0213619359,
-0.0639020801,
0.0082366262,
-0.0035891081,
-0.0076956963,
-0.0268017408,
-0.0300603956,
0.0035408686,
-0.0604979061,
-0.0175663438,
0.0394851975,
-0.0123344464,
0.0107388841,
0.0222064126,
-0.0007981113,
0.0146197295,
-0.0314174332,
0.0133687239,
-0.0097966492,
0.0613490008,
0.0413210317,
-0.0432712995,
0.0095523195,
-0.0279361922,
0.0044567306,
0.0007405053,
-0.0157788042,
-0.0005427693,
-0.0241309404,
0.0063779335,
0.0276026297,
0.0156585854,
0.0047531598,
0.0376665853,
0.0041557504,
0.004535567,
-0.016500745,
-0.0072969208,
-0.0383071862,
0.0199296772,
-0.0563752837,
-0.0203433875,
-0.0165217984,
-0.0501725972,
-0.0155069167,
0.0343258716,
-0.0169625562,
-0.036081735,
0.0242295898,
-0.0129066166,
0.0069386205,
-0.0439108796,
-0.03057543,
-0.020193113,
0.0046526054,
-0.0329201482,
-0.0076149087,
0.0455669239,
-0.0159678925,
0.0637534931,
-0.0147440229,
-0.0250283629,
0.104180865,
0.0742610022,
0.0611292869,
-0.0033133272,
-0.0186987855,
-0.0358290151,
-0.0138332378,
0.0280985702,
0.0110377343,
0.031215474,
-0.0324995816,
0.0021338891,
0.012269008,
-0.0422313623,
-0.0173816066,
-0.0417113528,
-0.0481852256,
-0.0327303968,
-0.0763652027,
-0.0090193106,
0.0003804022,
-0.0329279341,
-0.0211695936,
-0.0235776082,
0.0262120236,
0.0080708554,
0.0365177765,
0.0727847815,
0.0876501501,
-0.0128704123,
-0.1064487547,
-0.0175082982,
-0.0231446568,
0.0655582696,
0.0096701859,
0.008944869,
-0.0193121489,
0.0279857535,
-0.0185371339,
0.0337834768,
-0.0224974398,
0.0287772287,
0.0529494025,
0.0233671553,
0.0262750685,
0.0689345598,
-0.0045905849,
-0.0398042277,
0.0420272909,
0.0471067578,
-0.0280473549,
0.0168256275,
0.015912842,
-0.0753823891,
-0.0493989512,
-0.0505315848,
-0.0436994843,
0.0083594844,
-0.008026571,
-0.0262171682,
-0.0593874119,
0.0341439024,
0.0459190682,
0.0272452701,
-0.0519563705,
-0.0477874838,
0.0158081148,
-0.0725519955,
-0.0537027717,
-0.0159370787,
-0.0318264142,
0.0015025713,
0.0182924159,
-0.0934716389,
-0.0749585927,
0.0547031462,
-0.056799829,
0.0272321627,
-0.0461142361,
0.053270001,
0.0083022704,
-0.0419378653,
-0.0082158884,
0.0043944335,
0.0257410482,
-0.0014273425,
0.0364725217,
-0.0050019915,
0.0009426104,
-0.0125279659,
0.0869547576,
-0.0039756843,
-0.0830127597,
-0.0157442223,
0.1012345105,
-0.0351061337,
-0.0332119092,
-0.0300329924,
0.0018176757,
0.057396885,
0.0255262461,
-0.0268395599,
-0.0028976745,
-0.0203326866,
0.013767764,
-0.0202486329,
-0.0029758553,
-0.0567515455,
-0.0254671276,
-0.0097033428,
0.0134846559,
-0.048475612,
-0.0270335637,
0.0231055282,
0.019696191,
-0.050227128,
0.0024362463,
0.0083013074,
0.021566404,
-0.0727808774,
0.0243928228,
-0.0174265504,
0.0460969321,
-0.0297250375,
-0.0066319304,
0.0469381623,
0.0241893642,
-0.0109563656,
0.0258211084,
-0.074704811,
-0.0386820883,
-0.0467334576,
0.0530262589,
0.0127475187,
0.0960803255,
0.0159601085,
0.0261235107,
-0.023086464,
0.0313619561,
0.0230704173,
0.0098211719,
-0.0129019273,
-0.0425802693,
-0.0349307768,
0.014743967,
-0.024023395,
-0.0043381173,
-0.0283579361,
-0.0096209422,
-0.1238886788,
-0.0671336576,
-0.0343900882,
-0.0475721732,
0.0530226603,
-0.0143423164,
0.0334400274,
-0.0376033746,
-0.0142153371,
0.0305227824,
0.0422732309,
-0.0607400648,
-0.0110523598,
0.0573654696,
0.022057984,
-0.0720759481,
0.004179962,
-0.0405734442,
-0.0035429024,
-0.0826044306,
-0.0346417278,
0.0220901798,
0.0080571864,
-0.0150485737,
-0.007017409,
0.0132280802,
0.0198431145,
0.0141894221,
-0.0205184892,
0.0201723687,
0.0200730786,
-0.0267147757,
0.0239899661,
-0.0258721057,
0.014826362,
-0.0148454159,
0.0208946951,
-0.018452175,
-0.0443399511,
0.0680066049,
-0.0448869653,
0.0128696151,
-0.0186760258,
-0.0190381389,
-0.0389037505,
0.102813594,
-0.0626563951,
-0.0635076687,
0.0462587737,
0.0066320286,
-0.0275632907,
0.0453090966,
0.0892741829,
0.0168202892,
0.0176241267,
0.0237399545,
-0.0541198887,
0.0105596585,
-0.0187210143,
0.0465496145,
-0.0052663414,
-0.037729267,
-0.0215067286,
-0.0355285741,
-0.0666958466,
0.0314280167,
-0.0163155906,
0.0149431722,
0.0650429279,
0.0529021844,
-0.0055045476,
0.0074103014,
0.0097496184,
-0.0311681181,
-0.0433071256,
-0.0199334994,
-0.0158910938,
-0.0173102003,
-5.33227527e-33,
0.0302098803,
-0.0507105365,
0.0268121623,
0.0580377281,
-0.0249876473,
0.0193042867,
-0.0181125458,
0.0077590556,
-0.0070786127,
0.0361119397,
0.0394855402,
0.0171017274,
0.0061097429,
-0.0017919317,
0.0461483486,
-0.0324393027,
0.0169769861,
-0.0190894604,
0.0288017448,
0.0467333905,
0.0203959495,
0.0222219285,
0.0237211492,
-0.1120441183,
-0.0550973192,
0.0268575586,
-0.0158785675,
0.0100715337,
0.0545598939,
0.025781624,
-0.0204294734,
-0.0128131341,
0.0174604785,
0.0087684151,
-0.0035963946,
0.040634688,
-0.0518376939,
-0.0347682573,
-0.0113620451,
-0.0144977998,
-0.0482734777,
0.0072885212,
-0.009696709,
-0.0055393558,
-0.0073221577,
-0.0510442257,
0.0515235886,
0.0098807719,
0.0012897392,
-0.001007545,
0.0100105358,
0.0338623822,
-0.0000890889,
-0.0393191501,
0.0077659297,
0.0084104538,
0.0044323639,
-0.0481169187,
-0.0640168414,
0.0271189827,
-0.0866142511,
-0.0013329528,
0.0181936473,
-0.0215482898,
0.0161985159,
0.0764264539,
-0.0168878436,
-0.0346817411,
-0.0308696199,
0.0483123437,
-0.0303764082,
0.1065172702,
-0.0060489569,
0.0262201056,
0.0048429416,
0.0018844433,
-0.0895997658,
0.0421837755,
0.0050285393,
0.0288451556,
-0.0450025126,
0.0393428393,
0.0389899313,
-0.0077099577,
0.0259457063,
0.0397351682,
-0.0280808713,
-0.0216059573,
-0.0271785315,
0.0249227677,
0.0020278674,
0.0532714278,
0.0075237085,
-0.0112223066,
-0.0242968984,
0.0402682759,
-0.0001234743,
-0.0102170268,
0.0198206156,
0.0047729462,
-0.0430898219,
-0.0482181162,
0.0299697816,
0.0338676199,
0.0312613547,
0.0069330656,
0.0509214625,
0.0637773275,
0.0164721925,
-0.0239283666,
0.0070694671,
-0.0658416227,
-0.0090665966,
-0.0278378557,
0.0269788578,
0.0436593257,
-0.0284957867,
0.0622079931,
-0.0234169364,
0.0283785127,
0.0051424806,
-0.0158677623,
0.000483038,
-0.0147589836,
-0.0067775045,
0.0108734658,
-0.0714217499,
0.0378946736,
0.0185499415,
-0.0507318527,
0.000790291,
0.0173076857,
2.365e-7,
-0.000400059,
-0.0003899041,
-0.0043870462,
-0.0088435477,
0.0263594091,
0.0400198512,
-0.0047578411,
0.0952329636,
0.0071814153,
-0.0183043275,
0.0894037634,
0.0324606374,
-0.0103844637,
0.0037630668,
0.0034518542,
0.0288903266,
-0.0513913035,
-0.0289284084,
-0.0499518067,
-0.0209134072,
0.0088272858,
0.0365267582,
0.0642052665,
0.0149390176,
0.0634904876,
-0.0554660968,
0.0951989368,
-0.016911732,
-0.0246195421,
-0.0417161547,
-0.0151135856,
-0.0012642966,
-0.024309149,
-0.0332984924,
-0.0880021602,
-0.0407860167,
0.0800226331,
0.0604302287,
-0.0450096391,
-0.0172913782,
-0.0275770929,
0.0224359594,
-0.016697526,
0.0157375522,
0.0916935131,
-0.0774016455,
-0.0140723744,
0.0168183465,
-0.0035389685,
0.0161705501,
0.0152835986,
0.0283158459,
-0.0123142572,
0.0275306255,
0.034477558,
-0.0029092208,
-0.002124059,
-0.0866418779,
-0.0160863008,
0.0003872624,
-0.0534410998,
0.0225099344,
0.0087853186,
0.0128895855,
-0.0251444392,
0.0278178994,
-0.0540219657,
1.435664311e-34,
-0.0189904403,
0.0469227433,
-0.0073263454,
-0.0654027462,
-0.0180194508,
0.0091909617,
-0.0480419844,
0.0235427972,
0.0299224835,
-0.0419612378,
-0.0196478292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08627v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08627v1 | Evaluating Dynamic Topic Models | 2023-09-12T13:30:25 | 2023-09-12T13:30:25 | Charu James, Mayank Nagda, Nooshin Haji Ghassemi, Marius Kloft, Sophie Fellenz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | There is a lack of quantitative measures to evaluate the progression of
topics through time in dynamic topic models (DTMs). Filling this gap, we
propose a novel evaluation measure for DTMs that analyzes the changes in the
quality of each topic over time. Additionally, we propose an extension
combining topic quality with the model's temporal consistency. We demonstrate
the utility of the proposed measure by applying it to synthetic data and data
from existing DTMs. We also conducted a human evaluation, which indicates that
the proposed measure correlates well with human judgment. Our findings may help
in identifying changing topics, evaluating different DTMs, and guiding future
research in this area. | [
0.0118906805,
0.0053578182,
-0.0281153172,
-0.0524919778,
-0.0404467359,
-0.013354715,
-0.0328768454,
-0.011407447,
-0.0628147796,
0.004249285,
0.0017794502,
-0.015650114,
0.0246581025,
0.0679449663,
-0.0583872013,
-0.0726417899,
0.0393025354,
-0.0201428495,
0.0130133945,
0.0467452668,
0.0212246031,
-0.0463694483,
-0.020982733,
0.0081722001,
0.0391315259,
-0.0322145782,
-0.0322176628,
-0.0420062393,
0.0268803556,
-0.053319104,
-0.0152769079,
0.0339479521,
0.0374396592,
-0.0377321765,
0.000002005,
-0.0083069038,
-0.0183217861,
-0.0409812517,
0.0100053558,
0.0563029908,
0.0919180065,
0.0223180354,
0.0235792715,
0.0016340083,
-0.0274612252,
0.0097320816,
-0.0449975058,
0.029364517,
0.0248571467,
-0.002989583,
-0.0121023487,
0.0523822717,
0.0342971534,
-0.0348564014,
0.0088604148,
-0.0432147942,
0.009186185,
0.0452289395,
-0.0079470454,
0.0453424454,
0.0173004139,
0.0097331544,
-0.009063107,
-0.0156958904,
0.0653963834,
0.0333521813,
0.0172775034,
0.0099283569,
-0.0074644559,
0.0270877685,
0.0510808975,
0.0318704285,
0.037741147,
-0.0155850695,
-0.0143567333,
0.0336369649,
-0.058718171,
-0.0310454387,
0.0392410606,
-0.0036008183,
0.0592856258,
0.0279156081,
0.0160840191,
0.0300272498,
0.052709274,
0.0344078019,
0.018632805,
-0.0158962645,
-0.0705476031,
-0.0302002281,
0.0725992173,
-0.0615925826,
-0.0034595409,
0.0079111578,
0.0137413386,
0.0343536586,
0.0414070301,
0.0259628054,
0.0418690108,
-0.0757035688,
-0.0112707363,
-0.0333377272,
-0.0104484381,
0.0526282378,
0.082525216,
0.0082459794,
-0.0020762093,
-0.0729039162,
-0.0059200265,
0.0403661318,
-0.0605096482,
0.0381357931,
0.039792344,
0.0084841363,
0.0587916747,
-0.0351526625,
0.0082438262,
0.0392883718,
-0.0229681823,
-0.0351533704,
-0.04351959,
0.0054902276,
-0.0360352434,
-0.0070787719,
-0.0645361394,
0.0205155108,
-0.0633274689,
0.0526273251,
-0.0214614216,
0.0599912815,
0.0464304239,
-0.0128348749,
0.0061883284,
0.0163047649,
-0.0257459413,
0.0188974757,
-0.0078232996,
-0.0263667665,
-0.083915256,
-0.0178869702,
-0.0162799861,
0.0209249146,
0.0011442972,
-0.0585545599,
-0.0420426689,
-0.0086974921,
0.0049723554,
0.0561966151,
-0.0229299162,
0.0051014288,
-0.0202231966,
-0.0172470976,
0.0045425682,
0.0320887677,
0.0850735456,
0.0053486819,
0.035178408,
0.0331142619,
-0.0060052709,
0.0269118417,
0.0517178588,
0.0527486913,
-0.0174456686,
-0.0181057174,
-0.021682648,
0.0773162991,
-0.0211691894,
0.0281762835,
-0.0158712175,
0.0010319555,
-0.0287743248,
-0.0027229097,
-0.0357223973,
0.0169332623,
0.0399658866,
0.0168401375,
0.0378707536,
0.0255073365,
-0.0083601288,
0.0144738816,
-0.0016671395,
0.0012646343,
0.061870832,
0.0232747886,
0.0068301824,
-0.0106859868,
0.0233589858,
-0.0128294546,
-0.0284295976,
-0.0777084604,
0.0034349551,
0.0254240818,
0.0256096032,
-0.0657908097,
0.0465091802,
-0.0083499728,
0.0432243086,
0.0296242535,
0.0071087736,
0.05861165,
0.0073729609,
-0.0022200993,
0.0730467141,
0.0740697905,
0.0530066006,
-0.0317700207,
-0.0626224577,
-0.0080870334,
0.0407622643,
-0.0345656052,
0.0129333092,
-0.0032339387,
-0.0329877697,
0.0088287387,
-0.0042537334,
-0.0090901712,
0.0327255242,
0.0209505167,
0.0189129487,
0.0357288569,
-0.0191059597,
-0.0600300394,
0.024374973,
0.0228121821,
-0.0277412571,
0.0580664538,
0.0061995224,
-0.0569050647,
0.0590679571,
0.0140134851,
0.0164926052,
0.0104836002,
0.0275095589,
-0.0224635676,
-0.0216638111,
0.0227194577,
0.0100559834,
0.0618890971,
0.0220989361,
-0.0498297773,
0.0077369432,
-0.0313499272,
-0.0009793029,
0.0120314229,
0.0690926611,
-0.0226474516,
-0.029188823,
-0.014984942,
-0.0115056224,
-0.0474441089,
-0.0235108882,
-0.0214367211,
0.0697605237,
-0.0326900929,
0.0071027991,
0.0550012328,
-0.0223713126,
0.0058808061,
-0.0414380841,
0.0444386527,
0.0264638104,
-0.006378518,
0.0062121511,
0.0494089834,
-0.0241139736,
-0.0409762189,
-0.0273226183,
-0.0393877774,
-0.0044680648,
-0.0309172682,
-0.0172304641,
0.0546962619,
-0.0378345661,
0.0015448849,
0.0312443767,
-0.0247387663,
-0.0273041707,
-0.0193805844,
-0.0137102585,
0.0313586071,
0.0072166682,
0.0468729883,
-0.0573263913,
-0.0043853838,
-0.0054721604,
0.0728147179,
0.0310607441,
-0.0031427089,
-0.0372734778,
-0.0032460869,
-0.0479518846,
-0.0497046709,
-0.0127415871,
0.0248822197,
0.0276947692,
0.0072048875,
0.1197051704,
-0.0594866425,
0.0641530529,
0.0308373366,
0.0254618935,
-0.0596709996,
-0.039723482,
-0.0532886721,
-0.0338044167,
0.0615422577,
0.0229472369,
-0.0817305967,
0.024618635,
0.0215404835,
0.0057442239,
0.0485538542,
-0.0324070044,
0.0082309945,
-0.0791713446,
0.0264919959,
-0.0447135642,
0.0154749975,
-0.025163779,
0.0441160835,
-0.0366250947,
-0.0562082827,
0.0480806902,
0.0302443001,
0.0800117627,
-0.019973468,
-0.0367577635,
-0.0543264374,
0.0203015264,
-0.0491573773,
-0.0130532915,
0.0170406774,
0.0125639588,
-0.0132603189,
-0.0080446349,
0.0294934306,
-0.0280439444,
0.0426541418,
-0.0475283563,
0.0032458601,
0.0520144589,
0.040640112,
-0.000226725,
-0.0487049296,
0.0235138778,
-0.0019742996,
-0.0085887052,
0.0096929586,
-0.0215510428,
0.0107957749,
0.0247276332,
0.0077192783,
0.0036405714,
-0.0492615029,
0.0159384776,
0.0493164733,
0.0261280611,
-0.0469611399,
-0.0456726141,
-0.0226634257,
0.0303806998,
0.0088631548,
0.0452977642,
-0.0203093514,
-0.0860227942,
-0.003889791,
-0.0228467397,
-0.0279140715,
-0.0038854191,
0.0252014063,
-0.0298967641,
-0.0316155776,
-0.006705936,
0.0685693324,
0.0325565524,
-0.0192940366,
-0.003288338,
-0.0165689308,
-0.0043707797,
-0.013769431,
-0.0187526736,
-0.0356158651,
0.0194499362,
-0.0112281162,
0.0430393293,
-0.0069972891,
-0.0276609864,
-0.0083139073,
-0.0084310919,
-0.0109153958,
-0.0194827113,
0.0386103094,
0.0571034998,
-0.0689002052,
0.0438355356,
-0.0125069832,
-0.0492844321,
0.0123579875,
0.0016639972,
0.008460626,
0.0122403372,
-0.0967519656,
-0.0443238653,
0.0360993594,
0.0009724223,
0.0550279506,
0.0219803192,
0.0054484159,
-0.0129756415,
-0.0493397228,
-0.0047737872,
0.0037786555,
-0.0038935957,
0.0176207125,
0.0279525202,
-0.0118052606,
0.0305141322,
-0.0244601425,
-0.0062906351,
0.0179739315,
-0.029344013,
0.011700077,
0.0695787221,
-0.0243601128,
-0.0037935821,
-0.068708241,
-0.0080801416,
-0.0211979356,
0.029580554,
0.0169498269,
-0.0325738415,
0.052270893,
-0.005617524,
0.0455532447,
0.0714602992,
0.0020897379,
-0.0469387136,
-0.0571851619,
-0.0638211593,
-0.0644998625,
-0.0052442281,
-0.0428055041,
-0.0309870914,
-0.0213388633,
0.0159345083,
0.0345327221,
-0.0185433403,
-0.045964174,
0.0268822163,
0.0238511097,
0.010410632,
-0.0539202355,
-0.0445088409,
0.0491104946,
0.0190803353,
-0.015038426,
0.0036937699,
-0.0854680911,
-0.0122835478,
0.0127661433,
-0.0534839183,
0.0172600485,
-0.0208558291,
-0.0542410947,
-0.0131830899,
-0.0079034008,
-0.0110782329,
-0.0105157867,
-0.0121967755,
-0.0103025762,
0.0373793133,
-0.0043673962,
-0.0201467592,
-0.0424310789,
0.0311467312,
-0.0354409553,
0.0036739891,
-0.068758361,
-0.0181947015,
-0.0393832102,
-0.0495445542,
0.0572381839,
0.0311982352,
-0.0545093939,
-0.0320607536,
-0.0765443668,
0.0217289217,
-0.0107825613,
-0.0098841162,
0.0121675506,
0.0124711134,
0.0086524766,
-0.064481847,
0.0421980284,
-0.0502116047,
0.025764538,
-0.0405759774,
-0.0203104839,
-0.0135345897,
0.021258872,
-0.0389519483,
0.0225044731,
-0.0039335652,
-0.0115113184,
-0.0753953606,
-0.0202676971,
0.0032602358,
0.0429697298,
0.0050869579,
-0.0220456347,
0.0249005761,
0.0218018852,
-0.062680535,
-0.0056918547,
0.00227593,
0.050409019,
0.0084309373,
0.0620880798,
0.015671663,
-0.0027064255,
-0.0083682472,
-0.0290874168,
-0.004288774,
0.00570274,
-0.011671084,
-0.005364669,
0.0494044498,
-0.011438773,
0.0563325249,
0.0440738946,
-0.0040818504,
-0.0345886387,
-0.033106491,
-0.0277299061,
-0.0268703997,
0.0494466834,
-0.029113695,
0.0112129264,
-0.0006854512,
0.0260942336,
-0.0738289654,
0.0160565432,
0.0502934158,
-0.0239678826,
0.0376142077,
-0.0217849128,
0.0268698521,
0.0762405246,
-0.0102189444,
0.0290465131,
-0.033954151,
0.0135503151,
-0.0004032634,
-0.0020617221,
-0.0659691542,
-6.430564621e-33,
0.0234772023,
-0.0100743016,
-0.0236176178,
-0.0188731402,
-0.03391435,
0.0331212208,
-0.016266413,
0.0252440907,
0.0450358465,
-0.0113036344,
0.0305842254,
0.0637891665,
-0.0031270424,
-0.071498245,
0.0312843956,
-0.034907572,
0.0689902157,
-0.0049510556,
-0.0332347937,
0.040195737,
0.0091689387,
-0.0083918627,
-0.00709263,
-0.0431936495,
0.0780418366,
0.0036922209,
0.0036782825,
-0.027276976,
0.1054911241,
0.0262153391,
-0.0338865779,
-0.0017602525,
0.0518320799,
-0.0885200873,
-0.0164314099,
-0.0106829833,
-0.0448923185,
-0.0409112386,
-0.0016414128,
-0.0396842994,
-0.0155204833,
-0.0325013474,
-0.0108483769,
0.0574733689,
-0.0469342433,
0.0126626603,
0.0775634646,
-0.0353613719,
-0.014720357,
-0.0648551285,
0.0185210854,
0.0802759081,
-0.0205801949,
0.0032202571,
-0.0496227928,
0.0100267911,
0.0070278756,
0.0402112901,
-0.0143716158,
0.0623480603,
0.0319909304,
0.0074342056,
-0.000848967,
-0.0369379558,
0.0212735385,
0.0440055802,
-0.0561128557,
0.0699222386,
0.0285643209,
-0.0095779058,
0.0217592958,
0.0140426941,
0.0328865014,
0.0125222439,
0.0231452323,
0.0109696509,
-0.0207414702,
0.0460223332,
0.0166903473,
0.0207815599,
0.036039032,
0.0291430801,
0.0119626205,
-0.0141262887,
-0.0041367062,
0.0219256282,
-0.0234712418,
-0.0230944622,
0.0256444793,
0.0414609052,
-0.036933437,
-0.0095647546,
0.0217993557,
-0.0103613315,
-0.0062746475,
0.0321903527,
-0.0385518372,
0.0307189617,
0.0447446294,
0.0286798086,
-0.0739723668,
0.0054659899,
0.0149679706,
0.0485933833,
0.0049847281,
-0.0500169694,
-0.0383739509,
-0.013244532,
-0.0251692757,
-0.0213981643,
0.0411436707,
-0.0404230542,
-0.0215779524,
-0.0206236616,
0.0008323069,
-0.0239602383,
-0.0181332976,
0.0517376624,
0.0383580551,
0.0538867339,
-0.0180267915,
-0.0220103618,
-0.0173406154,
0.033945173,
0.0020865635,
-0.0254456755,
-0.0284203067,
0.00133796,
0.035723839,
-0.0131523693,
-0.0289316326,
-0.0218914934,
2.746e-7,
0.0139909992,
0.0687973499,
0.0021104678,
0.0023010157,
0.0543916933,
0.017136151,
-0.0643964186,
-0.022297876,
0.0035952588,
-0.0185131114,
0.0111555411,
0.0070736757,
0.0101339091,
0.0690722093,
0.0031808228,
-0.0433592834,
-0.0776667222,
0.0109260818,
-0.0684666187,
0.0032925163,
-0.0148167154,
0.0028193856,
0.0239148363,
0.035438519,
-0.0209621303,
-0.0141513515,
0.0567143448,
-0.0349503271,
-0.0412775092,
0.0141186379,
0.0922971964,
0.0262789093,
-0.0180870462,
-0.0602921136,
-0.0165231563,
-0.0182063039,
-0.0054222713,
-0.0146066574,
0.0396965295,
-0.0228620637,
0.0063211522,
-0.0160071775,
0.0004526681,
-0.0229681842,
0.0313051194,
-0.0550751723,
0.0013249975,
-0.0738132969,
-0.0464059524,
0.0563450716,
0.05887077,
0.0085678427,
-0.0604531169,
0.0077713709,
-0.0396710932,
0.0210151784,
-0.0179246981,
-0.021182932,
0.0009952673,
0.0146732545,
-0.0413693003,
-0.0544319078,
-0.0548703931,
-0.0256222785,
-0.0095882956,
-0.0498054475,
0.0715958551,
1.675705998e-34,
0.0666267499,
0.0101100793,
-0.0716487691,
-0.0194361974,
-0.0043598795,
0.0057620048,
-0.0484001525,
-0.0200422872,
0.0325711295,
-0.0101719629,
0.0212121736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06192v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06192v2 | Improving and Evaluating the Detection of Fragmentation in News Recommendations with the Clustering of News Story Chains | 2023-09-12T13:01:20 | 2023-09-18T13:05:08 | Alessandra Polimeno, Myrthe Reuver, Sanne Vrijenhoek, Antske Fokkens | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.IR | News recommender systems play an increasingly influential role in shaping
information access within democratic societies. However, tailoring
recommendations to users' specific interests can result in the divergence of
information streams. Fragmented access to information poses challenges to the
integrity of the public sphere, thereby influencing democracy and public
discourse. The Fragmentation metric quantifies the degree of fragmentation of
information streams in news recommendations. Accurate measurement of this
metric requires the application of Natural Language Processing (NLP) to
identify distinct news events, stories, or timelines. This paper presents an
extensive investigation of various approaches for quantifying Fragmentation in
news recommendations. These approaches are evaluated both intrinsically, by
measuring performance on news story clustering, and extrinsically, by assessing
the Fragmentation scores of different simulated news recommender scenarios. Our
findings demonstrate that agglomerative hierarchical clustering coupled with
SentenceBERT text representation is substantially better at detecting
Fragmentation than earlier implementations. Additionally, the analysis of
simulated scenarios yields valuable insights and recommendations for
stakeholders concerning the measurement and interpretation of Fragmentation. | [
0.0420649014,
-0.0004251943,
-0.0327810198,
-0.0063877641,
-0.0255445242,
-0.029465843,
0.0005551355,
0.0203271024,
0.035892833,
-0.035042733,
0.0177510455,
-0.0262698904,
-0.0117105143,
0.040572878,
-0.0724986643,
-0.1177895069,
0.0401387326,
0.0122725274,
0.0390719101,
0.0483166836,
0.0653992519,
0.0338213816,
0.0110807801,
0.0116284452,
0.0288106501,
-0.0111462204,
-0.0339414738,
0.0012647867,
0.0191790145,
-0.0093987677,
-0.0489045009,
0.0185156148,
0.0053850762,
0.0170136262,
0.0000016121,
-0.0376355127,
-0.0544267856,
-0.0109328628,
0.0246499516,
0.021800125,
0.0813263655,
-0.019654097,
0.0416443907,
0.0002327939,
-0.0064371796,
0.0287040249,
-0.0417384915,
0.038181629,
0.0323051699,
0.0306197088,
-0.0172084775,
-0.0010447825,
-0.0070831701,
0.0067419806,
0.0044113477,
-0.0311572347,
-0.0152336983,
0.0023710271,
0.009762737,
0.0240434781,
-0.0016260641,
-0.0284348913,
0.0067008352,
0.0220391806,
-0.0194810275,
0.0278021675,
-0.0455213152,
-0.0311300866,
-0.0113802543,
0.0260427352,
0.037906833,
0.0075952774,
0.007985387,
-0.0126215611,
0.0096857669,
0.0298914909,
-0.0297249313,
0.0195615347,
-0.0376297869,
0.0256041121,
0.0146240322,
0.0209231824,
-0.0044273543,
0.011208252,
0.0183590613,
0.0962023884,
0.0257699396,
-0.0074620261,
-0.0088566532,
0.0049021305,
0.05359409,
-0.0379329138,
0.0386349708,
-0.0301115271,
-0.025090022,
0.0160619318,
-0.0510045514,
0.0208558273,
0.0150633445,
-0.0812820196,
-0.0547831506,
-0.0162857231,
0.0397559702,
0.0492783673,
0.0697247386,
-0.0624930747,
0.023170922,
-0.0514093451,
-0.0257684365,
0.0119419266,
-0.0506431162,
0.0229201075,
0.0441958085,
0.0469907708,
-0.0782845765,
-0.0330291651,
-0.0271121971,
0.0407995768,
0.035623271,
-0.0156041663,
-0.0401613005,
0.0278865509,
0.0240813233,
0.0042375382,
-0.0685773492,
0.008650749,
-0.1155741289,
0.0065045073,
0.0130991712,
0.052541703,
0.039513167,
0.0295363888,
0.0188772492,
0.0062202178,
-0.0279526692,
-0.008431565,
0.0037231252,
-0.0423935317,
-0.0737819672,
-0.0560722984,
-0.0157147814,
-0.0279292725,
-0.0190481376,
-0.064512834,
0.0074802022,
0.0283017214,
-0.0048951847,
0.0295940544,
-0.0234802663,
-0.0170870479,
-0.023517672,
0.0117399013,
-0.0037251234,
0.0057756649,
0.0188580193,
0.0218637269,
0.0423259996,
0.0573427901,
0.0053279283,
0.0681952983,
0.0985682681,
0.0186525043,
-0.0003798059,
-0.0372711793,
-0.0678804144,
0.0226347819,
-0.0028104901,
0.0014930252,
-0.0703910887,
-0.0293859411,
-0.0140729295,
0.0106624849,
-0.0559181757,
0.0116624767,
0.0542570278,
0.0366640724,
0.0194590017,
0.0270633548,
0.000919166,
0.0568162575,
-0.0190437473,
0.0481553711,
0.0375875458,
-0.0108527876,
-0.0191892646,
-0.0128309131,
0.0529475175,
0.0472919382,
-0.0586189516,
-0.039473366,
0.0162658095,
0.001077118,
0.0769381821,
-0.04091914,
0.0081170285,
-0.0232219361,
-0.0115355244,
0.0290392675,
0.0292123742,
-0.0092248265,
0.0631853938,
0.019601943,
0.0301909149,
0.0806958824,
0.0355774239,
-0.0282621738,
0.0084806429,
0.0053008776,
0.033969406,
-0.0365085267,
0.0099793626,
-0.0272388142,
-0.0081748432,
-0.0208256077,
-0.0323023722,
0.0311131515,
0.026785234,
-0.0017865985,
0.0268718898,
0.0389688201,
-0.0278929789,
-0.0604844801,
-0.0031703198,
0.0362458602,
0.0233651008,
0.0234981719,
0.0177324153,
0.0146726258,
0.0211859476,
0.0571749359,
0.0320483185,
-0.0376736708,
0.0243674163,
0.0045969584,
-0.0062547871,
-0.0291945729,
0.0003956102,
0.0081071844,
-0.0311598741,
-0.0514937826,
0.0037597429,
0.0270072073,
0.0307453535,
-0.0297135152,
0.0305769891,
0.008941453,
0.0047596721,
-0.0113138091,
0.020299783,
-0.0320661962,
-0.0199512448,
-0.03692903,
0.091538474,
-0.0104091577,
0.0227553844,
-0.0475574657,
-0.05086248,
-0.0217760671,
0.0294661019,
-0.0251674727,
0.0034003886,
-0.0027037279,
0.0135232341,
0.0602521524,
-0.0608892925,
-0.0432706438,
-0.0238394234,
-0.0060182083,
-0.0037332526,
-0.0364735536,
0.026465429,
0.0547426268,
0.0275135878,
-0.0042953724,
0.0196712036,
-0.0038829199,
-0.0018676769,
-0.0053679836,
-0.0156481098,
0.0048384052,
0.0168552939,
-0.0192915145,
-0.0154627105,
-0.0171631519,
-0.0119492738,
0.0508949049,
-0.0198291093,
-0.0548650287,
-0.0569113493,
-0.0726553351,
-0.0106088212,
-0.0505143218,
-0.0233951546,
0.0339584872,
0.0203138012,
0.0374492668,
0.0509613156,
0.0151100364,
0.047221072,
0.0567000397,
0.0367319062,
0.0299272779,
-0.007543229,
-0.02181766,
-0.0634171292,
0.0869554728,
-0.0599243417,
-0.0359560139,
0.0868613794,
-0.0002336633,
0.0097593004,
0.0256969426,
-0.0343806036,
-0.0121200783,
-0.0614341982,
0.0096230283,
-0.0147037115,
-0.0558600985,
-0.0075379438,
0.0645260662,
0.0391367935,
-0.0083991969,
0.0273894835,
0.0035544005,
0.081702508,
-0.0494814366,
-0.0695031658,
-0.0532841124,
0.0370531157,
-0.0312883183,
0.0254415032,
0.0041038664,
-0.0452148281,
-0.0161451567,
-0.0124816634,
0.0372784846,
0.0096440148,
0.086747162,
-0.0051638884,
-0.0308917463,
0.0376706347,
0.0138010811,
-0.0142990435,
-0.0663163438,
0.0319445394,
-0.0112550426,
0.0764491484,
-0.017807493,
-0.0874262601,
0.0501561798,
0.0290259197,
-0.0099054715,
-0.0134495851,
-0.0305111948,
0.0138577046,
0.061561022,
0.0255700629,
-0.0647164956,
0.0684355497,
0.0019664718,
0.0241747368,
0.03732346,
0.0473666489,
0.0054361513,
-0.0144357998,
-0.0381030813,
0.0101088379,
-0.0866386145,
-0.0097531611,
0.0105848527,
0.0261982065,
0.0144318752,
0.0114123942,
0.088023819,
0.0735145733,
-0.1051772609,
0.0192709863,
0.0205035601,
0.0316083282,
0.0290795937,
0.0009931265,
-0.0102935052,
0.0373473763,
0.0023088187,
0.0198723096,
0.0223439373,
-0.0364904851,
-0.0132302307,
-0.0177083015,
0.0023089468,
-0.0121810017,
-0.002686095,
-0.0066935052,
-0.0873365402,
-0.0077233529,
-0.0069342237,
-0.0076674488,
-0.0192798749,
-0.0225851666,
-0.0197479278,
-0.002233366,
-0.114317216,
-0.0140987616,
0.0068019237,
-0.0212892983,
-0.0012887038,
0.0128480308,
0.0099538406,
-0.0053641619,
0.0635018945,
-0.0039033147,
-0.0048518274,
-0.0282550175,
0.0256997682,
0.0369090028,
-0.0301895645,
0.067725189,
-0.0490535684,
0.0180910192,
0.0329045057,
-0.0164548624,
0.0265750419,
0.0192126855,
0.0013916979,
-0.026594501,
-0.0315633453,
0.0111708827,
0.0035637675,
0.0385676138,
0.025943419,
-0.0291489288,
0.0144541059,
-0.016003184,
0.0325585939,
0.0133668911,
-0.0182630531,
0.0198331773,
-0.0361455828,
-0.0103213945,
-0.049988579,
-0.0453510582,
-0.0151503012,
0.0526842773,
-0.0164496824,
0.0353715271,
0.0362924077,
-0.0567170903,
0.0183078963,
-0.0107273711,
0.0438346267,
-0.0387780853,
-0.0363547094,
0.0032888532,
-0.0465522595,
0.0026898854,
-0.0033441556,
0.0156394318,
-0.0343510807,
-0.0297229681,
0.0128057478,
-0.0687858239,
0.0228141379,
0.0310016219,
-0.0656164959,
-0.0469412655,
0.0177317094,
-0.0017138711,
0.0032768399,
-0.0422872975,
-0.0627017021,
0.0188045204,
0.0176790394,
0.0131642967,
-0.0406910628,
0.0029757991,
-0.0605684109,
-0.0126870982,
-0.0655769333,
0.0272154193,
-0.0057473113,
-0.026857039,
0.0147204287,
-0.0424710587,
-0.0080859456,
-0.0365712009,
-0.0516947731,
-0.0356854536,
-0.0108289896,
0.019372819,
-0.04205947,
0.0343644656,
-0.0278998967,
-0.0564071201,
0.0759056211,
-0.0150478892,
0.0093546398,
-0.0582513474,
0.0065450971,
0.0271294415,
-0.0287174843,
-0.0310856178,
0.0134468563,
-0.0107620731,
-0.0292730834,
-0.0149863493,
0.0045583188,
-0.0142521625,
0.007238551,
0.0151850004,
0.0118303532,
-0.0071549853,
0.0549015552,
-0.0566716604,
0.0036509549,
0.0087857721,
0.0007929613,
-0.0314374007,
-0.0601291768,
0.0300099384,
0.0106868874,
-0.0103569375,
0.013436405,
-0.0013722081,
0.0033036543,
-0.0316023901,
-0.0301198941,
0.0473808721,
-0.0418771133,
0.0500140525,
0.0881025046,
-0.0203252062,
-0.0643049031,
0.0508913957,
-0.0768761486,
-0.054498788,
0.0037802586,
-0.0359310359,
0.0510291718,
-0.0517282188,
-0.0541291125,
-0.0597056188,
0.0257934295,
0.0288738739,
-0.0205034595,
0.0589994565,
-0.0011875401,
0.0174141526,
0.0840518624,
0.0312377345,
0.0240583997,
-0.0536749288,
-0.0476556867,
-0.0320422724,
-0.0283394773,
0.0181187224,
-5.938982802e-33,
0.0199016891,
-0.0295436904,
-0.0221331194,
-0.0437251925,
-0.0205797255,
0.027977081,
0.016832877,
0.0081996312,
0.0250276737,
0.0001073104,
0.0245649014,
0.0325084142,
0.0255637355,
-0.0351833999,
0.0144828139,
-0.0168073885,
0.0218711365,
0.0365754329,
-0.0560678169,
0.0274383761,
0.0336985178,
0.0198477115,
-0.0047566164,
0.0317333527,
0.0272175949,
-0.0061150924,
0.0149461459,
-0.0505847298,
0.1046218723,
0.0538598821,
-0.0009019755,
0.0330376253,
0.0353286676,
-0.0355171524,
-0.0067284866,
0.0522165895,
-0.0591252893,
-0.0290745534,
0.0478290431,
-0.0203413609,
0.0005180068,
0.0284545179,
0.0099973977,
0.007752365,
0.0227443483,
0.0080832327,
0.0522548929,
0.0126016708,
-0.0325447917,
-0.007049086,
-0.0354565792,
0.0406218469,
-0.0383905433,
0.0381089188,
0.003434204,
0.0592427589,
0.0077793677,
0.0566722862,
-0.056115821,
0.0305720475,
-0.0232475121,
0.0460187681,
-0.0018598203,
-0.0470420532,
-0.0418636277,
0.0773711726,
-0.0106476434,
0.0358307883,
-0.0268112663,
0.0402870886,
0.0341525823,
0.0198787525,
-0.0162859205,
0.0147403441,
-0.014644972,
-0.0234920345,
-0.0620462485,
0.0868649185,
0.0377194621,
-0.050996799,
0.0409093276,
0.0230224859,
-0.0405910313,
-0.0222731903,
0.0165675487,
-0.0105830645,
-0.0299615599,
-0.0318538584,
-0.0001297348,
0.020260632,
-0.0297938529,
-0.0058215926,
0.0216362793,
-0.0314918905,
-0.0104863783,
-0.0046515078,
-0.027819965,
0.0254057329,
0.0237118732,
0.0137884989,
-0.0503058136,
0.0124815544,
0.0038822039,
-0.0120959561,
-0.035991732,
-0.0669497177,
0.0096767396,
-0.0236723311,
-0.0225189384,
0.0186968278,
0.0583033673,
-0.0076743779,
-0.0155015076,
-0.0030334385,
0.0542154089,
0.0056146849,
-0.0141349826,
0.0158520136,
0.0445817597,
0.0245522782,
0.0510981679,
-0.0113090351,
-0.0448867083,
0.0110263936,
0.0151676172,
-0.0467514545,
-0.0354609974,
0.0100149531,
0.0349891819,
-0.0436432548,
-0.0403436348,
-0.0117838616,
2.506e-7,
0.0339383259,
0.0822219402,
0.0061673797,
-0.001460151,
0.0035599959,
-0.006525279,
0.038527824,
0.0321228839,
-0.065414384,
-0.0620071925,
0.0372557938,
-0.0135418689,
0.0010215815,
0.0805732235,
-0.0642029792,
0.0363733545,
-0.0271382015,
0.0041539189,
-0.0993271843,
-0.0132560795,
0.0000066465,
0.0289023239,
0.0285185836,
0.0230794717,
-0.0248386208,
0.0266839694,
-0.025603788,
-0.0196566954,
-0.0905722678,
0.0257613901,
0.020345524,
-0.0364653543,
-0.0013053142,
-0.0144224055,
-0.0304114539,
-0.0017643288,
-0.0076790145,
0.0030627691,
-0.0105356164,
-0.0295100939,
0.0204478875,
-0.0266386494,
0.0062893587,
-0.014631399,
0.072479777,
0.0307813529,
-0.0226426627,
-0.0121505884,
-0.0693544224,
0.018917134,
0.0375676788,
0.0246775635,
-0.0077455612,
0.0562938266,
-0.0266664904,
-0.0056262198,
0.0121994326,
-0.0302783437,
0.033115264,
0.0125191743,
-0.0148102734,
-0.0024986097,
-0.0189796332,
0.0367259607,
0.0037508204,
-0.0297679696,
0.0316865556,
2.084265819e-34,
0.0232689977,
0.0616825372,
-0.0261194445,
-0.0127765397,
0.0292458534,
-0.002496057,
-0.0735948086,
-0.0315828323,
-0.0072082244,
-0.0419852324,
0.007269186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06179v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06179v1 | Glancing Future for Simultaneous Machine Translation | 2023-09-12T12:46:20 | 2023-09-12T12:46:20 | Shoutao Guo, Shaolei Zhang, Yang Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Simultaneous machine translation (SiMT) outputs translation while reading the
source sentence. Unlike conventional sequence-to-sequence (seq2seq) training,
existing SiMT methods adopt the prefix-to-prefix (prefix2prefix) training,
where the model predicts target tokens based on partial source tokens. However,
the prefix2prefix training diminishes the ability of the model to capture
global information and introduces forced predictions due to the absence of
essential source information. Consequently, it is crucial to bridge the gap
between the prefix2prefix training and seq2seq training to enhance the
translation capability of the SiMT model. In this paper, we propose a novel
method that glances future in curriculum learning to achieve the transition
from the seq2seq training to prefix2prefix training. Specifically, we gradually
reduce the available source information from the whole sentence to the prefix
corresponding to that latency. Our method is applicable to a wide range of SiMT
methods and experiments demonstrate that our method outperforms strong
baselines. | [
0.0230815876,
0.0294347908,
-0.0056023682,
-0.0094565526,
-0.0127355233,
0.0041645649,
0.0234126896,
-0.015796924,
-0.0489199944,
-0.0001576379,
-0.0363321379,
-0.0423102267,
0.006573109,
0.0068969373,
0.0243210215,
-0.0715374276,
0.0577274412,
-0.0126524121,
-0.0828075558,
0.0127638895,
-0.0102096815,
0.0265334807,
0.0002276294,
0.0283270013,
-0.0141669149,
-0.0267549362,
-0.0240848735,
0.0193845667,
0.0774152353,
-0.0358493403,
0.0214122478,
0.0291888155,
-0.0012002318,
0.0248924699,
0.0000021544,
-0.0033411691,
-0.0329061486,
-0.0206335336,
0.009008239,
-0.0032077758,
0.0536092669,
-0.021489244,
-0.0046528713,
0.0490798242,
-0.0180851873,
0.0236089602,
0.0165540595,
-0.0001284936,
0.0807050094,
0.0631184354,
-0.0107105551,
-0.0174443703,
0.0116862841,
-0.0631245524,
0.0149077307,
-0.0618877895,
-0.0066050785,
-0.0018278336,
-0.0566877164,
0.0487938896,
-0.0142061431,
0.0797237232,
0.0434113666,
-0.0118138129,
0.0005568566,
0.0335253999,
-0.0111252377,
-0.0113062458,
-0.0541353822,
0.0539551191,
-0.0375625379,
-0.011966777,
-0.0049584378,
-0.0169857033,
-0.0334938616,
-0.0633105636,
-0.0508156791,
-0.0117837312,
0.0031474007,
-0.0032287603,
0.0357073098,
0.0109503781,
0.0112494212,
0.0001562187,
-0.0229655989,
0.0182462037,
0.0255265199,
-0.0359488837,
0.0049903439,
0.0347684808,
0.0423466191,
-0.0056740302,
0.0325502604,
0.0164386816,
-0.0381980687,
0.0384887047,
-0.0315280333,
-0.0633853748,
-0.0187832918,
0.003196347,
-0.0052225599,
0.0915223435,
-0.0453014113,
0.0220897589,
-0.0311314613,
0.0497492068,
-0.0265903603,
0.0345011242,
-0.0886166021,
0.0153333638,
-0.0151804611,
-0.004063285,
-0.0382632427,
-0.0161081534,
-0.079685986,
-0.0128585007,
-0.0379503593,
0.014255099,
0.0106308544,
-0.0206036586,
0.0540890619,
-0.007132465,
-0.1002910212,
-0.0160095654,
0.0195040759,
0.0802161843,
-0.0023113934,
0.0034938199,
-0.0070597739,
-0.0141827818,
-0.0421661511,
0.0122678448,
-0.0268099457,
-0.0219774507,
-0.0281884912,
0.0847610012,
-0.0370750874,
0.0018735571,
-0.0350940339,
-0.0349514559,
-0.0110200373,
-0.0361640975,
0.0606222227,
-0.0437867045,
0.0065842997,
-0.0088081788,
0.0252620298,
0.0073778401,
0.0029755211,
-0.0085939355,
0.0115621239,
0.0482939035,
0.0004242603,
-0.0302024484,
0.0098996069,
0.0275532696,
-0.0195076652,
0.0693925172,
0.0076385187,
0.0359286629,
0.0016943023,
0.0519604012,
-0.073957704,
0.0781907588,
0.0508695506,
0.0120852059,
-0.0314321592,
0.0073237177,
0.063403897,
0.0536414571,
0.0031322869,
0.0301111937,
-0.0175540969,
0.0057688295,
0.0450329445,
0.0309758093,
-0.0213996936,
0.0113385459,
0.0924234241,
0.0222291872,
-0.0382078588,
0.0227830522,
-0.0239481088,
0.0274618454,
0.0233094599,
0.0033982845,
0.0278483648,
0.0247593857,
-0.0174932759,
-0.0534968674,
0.0346565992,
-0.0030368851,
-0.062275216,
-0.0260741245,
0.0101475222,
0.0100211231,
-0.0831106007,
0.0145035358,
-0.0003231254,
-0.0273782331,
0.03132765,
-0.0044998326,
-0.0468463674,
0.0875838026,
0.0139592821,
0.0027471259,
-0.0976285264,
-0.0067811511,
0.0253846403,
0.0387371704,
0.0273563359,
-0.0110332025,
0.0338856466,
-0.0207403526,
-0.0243083909,
0.0454325117,
-0.007626513,
0.0281164031,
0.009030248,
0.0397519954,
0.0450263508,
0.0531748831,
-0.0066345721,
0.0291155521,
-0.0844048932,
-0.025846513,
-0.0017443497,
0.0190347172,
0.020791024,
0.0017071597,
0.0178437307,
0.0005349122,
0.0378480256,
0.0048668399,
0.0091187228,
0.0294595528,
-0.0899601355,
-0.0764852464,
0.0561712496,
-0.0413433537,
0.0000624854,
0.0240788534,
-0.0307570696,
-0.0438468605,
-0.0072950437,
0.0301575158,
-0.0063927425,
-0.0042502126,
0.052394215,
0.0320939571,
-0.0164973531,
-0.0087076453,
-0.0043764552,
-0.0289363433,
0.009383725,
0.0266901664,
-0.0190441944,
0.0078135682,
-0.0596570633,
0.001941203,
0.0117189903,
0.0301607046,
0.0037780562,
0.0084225442,
0.0255190991,
-0.0863352045,
-0.038157694,
-0.1057579145,
0.0185313392,
-0.0322473869,
0.0212461986,
0.0186007414,
0.0163163841,
-0.0110204518,
-0.0163158346,
-0.0250554364,
0.0214913823,
-0.0000047784,
-0.0220453329,
0.0054067457,
0.0544620492,
0.0240915492,
-0.0415127203,
-0.0150556564,
-0.0356172547,
0.0193124041,
0.0033237319,
0.0084861089,
-0.0479047857,
-0.0012367392,
0.0153639428,
0.0023309654,
-0.0167961102,
-0.0167493597,
0.0093572941,
-0.0304078236,
0.0512505732,
0.0211433955,
0.0159070995,
0.0051676184,
0.0156118665,
-0.0277437847,
-0.0433410741,
0.0242785998,
-0.0129806083,
-0.04882567,
-0.0565594062,
-0.0182315633,
-0.0055838525,
0.0387700498,
-0.0029340114,
-0.0089303507,
-0.0833132938,
-0.0038500212,
0.0016354942,
-0.0583774485,
-0.039818164,
0.0318886079,
-0.0201735906,
-0.002059412,
-0.019512983,
-0.0117666163,
0.0540637746,
-0.0264161546,
0.0058424952,
-0.0316875689,
0.0181248989,
-0.0178387333,
0.0371257626,
-0.0553176478,
-0.0093481578,
-0.0147343827,
-0.0383924469,
-0.0602702014,
0.0137878172,
-0.0278850794,
-0.0098895635,
0.0080392594,
-0.0397447869,
-0.0400817245,
-0.0114585254,
-0.020646356,
-0.0345550738,
0.0133641055,
-0.0127484845,
0.0271738563,
0.0140311681,
-0.0112268664,
-0.0216974281,
-0.0497763157,
-0.0421231911,
0.0883943215,
-0.051262401,
-0.0159259662,
-0.0192400087,
-0.0103392107,
0.0206448659,
-0.0436744019,
-0.0211740434,
-0.0690687895,
0.0131976707,
0.0248170812,
0.1023985744,
-0.0443987623,
-0.009969213,
0.0062435521,
0.0421183817,
-0.011418839,
-0.0263953675,
-0.0034139587,
-0.0194126796,
-0.0439264774,
-0.0022460925,
0.0958853737,
0.0134306289,
-0.0544587523,
-0.0124160079,
-0.0046579144,
0.0145903295,
0.0185499396,
0.0327934064,
-0.0725018531,
-0.0175437052,
-0.0154727595,
0.0372908935,
0.0442941338,
-0.0117948866,
-0.0618618131,
-0.0698022768,
-0.0027398656,
0.0462571457,
-0.0341405794,
-0.010367332,
0.0266123991,
-0.0500131026,
-0.0189215094,
0.0432324484,
0.0264341775,
-0.006883733,
0.0022954461,
0.0172962658,
0.0330064632,
-0.0162754692,
0.0176995043,
-0.0081767952,
0.0011555544,
0.0257247966,
0.0344920494,
0.027037533,
-0.0255495608,
0.0595259294,
-0.0240384229,
0.0055873725,
-0.0218327157,
0.0395273045,
-0.0670846552,
0.0013823238,
0.0271984991,
-0.0074348599,
0.0312957093,
0.01930972,
0.0354947783,
0.0670025572,
0.0097003002,
0.0210471656,
-0.0060375002,
0.0111716883,
0.0380675383,
0.0235190764,
-0.0212605745,
-0.0374760479,
0.0004416093,
-0.0023571916,
0.0098934881,
-0.0639227629,
-0.0367907025,
-0.0147378035,
-0.0211219918,
-0.039564535,
-0.0916501135,
-0.0489931777,
0.0178056825,
0.0616255701,
0.0188516714,
0.0197060648,
-0.0146852955,
0.0198840164,
-0.0356024392,
0.0103202686,
-0.0251505952,
0.0073697995,
-0.0720788613,
0.0374520086,
0.0150466794,
-0.0413316339,
-0.0141798947,
0.005952395,
-0.1466568559,
-0.0558444336,
-0.0320287421,
0.0494245663,
0.0104898848,
0.0732561275,
-0.0158675443,
0.0181365162,
0.0221382733,
0.0170786288,
-0.0118670557,
-0.0049430644,
0.0534477457,
-0.0243599433,
-0.0029632032,
0.0148909679,
-0.0090711117,
0.0096700396,
0.0107305255,
0.0381140038,
0.0167300794,
0.0220791139,
0.0038693794,
0.0178974699,
0.0914010927,
-0.0295556448,
-0.0046750102,
-0.0359310322,
0.0443757996,
-0.0167071465,
0.0034864163,
-0.0257383101,
0.0237403288,
0.0446534939,
-0.0012491537,
-0.0105056977,
-0.0094181262,
-0.0006067069,
-0.0561249219,
-0.0221562907,
-0.0158752836,
-0.0502882116,
0.0333304182,
0.0207236186,
0.0261623282,
-0.0222344063,
-0.0225350894,
0.0120896669,
0.0170490164,
-0.0289704539,
0.0293103382,
0.0282115247,
0.0352998823,
0.0156547315,
0.0204928145,
-0.0614062175,
-0.0108910566,
-0.0505918078,
0.0414845496,
0.0702274665,
0.00009996,
0.0519247912,
-0.0174053684,
0.0027476179,
-0.0172845982,
0.0405039005,
-0.0205180645,
-0.0538247488,
-0.0003201464,
-0.022957528,
0.027752433,
-0.0047680754,
0.0461909659,
0.001381647,
0.0225799568,
0.0214379467,
-0.0342532285,
-0.0200338867,
-0.0303886794,
0.006415606,
-0.0422358699,
0.0018581622,
0.0255162977,
-0.0135826385,
-0.0576842949,
0.0373016037,
0.0386224836,
-0.005965353,
-0.0184042994,
0.0097535001,
0.0676381886,
-0.0409307629,
-0.0349745974,
-0.0363983624,
-0.0018206083,
0.0428539403,
-0.0488504618,
-0.0284384266,
-6.425455629e-33,
-0.0530832186,
0.0128954304,
0.0458992235,
0.0016002903,
-0.073453553,
0.0201717801,
-0.0196882002,
-0.0247863159,
0.0167797916,
0.0126133086,
-0.0416347161,
0.0571615435,
0.0403987467,
-0.012418679,
0.0306884889,
-0.0018597384,
0.0714402422,
-0.0146110896,
-0.0366264619,
0.02699784,
0.0261517949,
0.0412622876,
0.1117345244,
-0.0232221819,
0.0248993356,
0.0048122373,
0.0103109619,
0.0362326205,
0.0021275056,
0.0180193465,
0.0235461127,
0.0186828375,
0.0050643869,
-0.0424148664,
-0.0422006622,
-0.0041694553,
-0.1026178971,
-0.0313658528,
0.0279485881,
0.0360829122,
-0.0058079157,
-0.0609402359,
-0.011358263,
-0.027571287,
-0.029067209,
-0.0526789576,
0.0073453202,
-0.0269718319,
-0.0164926611,
-0.0580352359,
-0.0458564274,
0.0081870537,
-0.0168816559,
0.0115049621,
0.0514756255,
0.0791610405,
0.0289832689,
-0.0481270142,
-0.0310570337,
0.0295272674,
0.0138827404,
0.0928485394,
0.0709722117,
0.0220871661,
-0.0073324945,
0.0320072249,
-0.0096444162,
-0.0095398529,
0.0308379997,
0.0006069094,
0.0478975698,
-0.0066274903,
0.0231820997,
-0.0068256157,
0.0469926968,
-0.0294934288,
-0.030778883,
0.0374618061,
0.0317652375,
0.0099664601,
0.0240081716,
-0.0030284927,
0.0178266615,
0.0116933892,
-0.0482254736,
-0.0090126237,
0.0064296122,
-0.0122714313,
0.0277370196,
0.049968563,
-0.0017455787,
0.061293114,
0.0861996338,
-0.0213612281,
0.0471714959,
0.0747542307,
-0.0410791636,
-0.0160686821,
-0.0324786603,
0.0791296288,
-0.0612059087,
-0.0140846791,
0.038042333,
0.0149843832,
0.0156880487,
-0.0261319168,
0.0420341678,
0.026764458,
-0.0431411602,
-0.021777112,
-0.0279536471,
0.0234565176,
0.0169435013,
-0.0428154394,
0.0464445874,
-0.0206407495,
-0.016917564,
0.0217277911,
0.022188656,
-0.0155701442,
-0.0194732659,
0.0105546406,
0.0451595113,
0.0568862036,
-0.0486831218,
0.0208003968,
-0.0239700135,
0.0153785553,
0.0238079038,
-0.0803152844,
-0.0533816516,
0.0389634594,
2.762e-7,
0.0380805321,
0.0204792377,
0.0323325098,
0.0285576433,
0.0114867212,
-0.0087977061,
-0.0352436453,
0.0382872187,
0.028185457,
0.0518615469,
0.0629491359,
0.0049827001,
0.0529712848,
0.0087890783,
-0.0956420004,
-0.0701219141,
-0.0571618453,
0.0436412245,
-0.0486970544,
-0.0163073633,
0.06429407,
0.0597768314,
0.0040620286,
0.0077696242,
-0.0006823029,
0.0262321457,
0.0693574101,
0.0026232682,
0.0144829471,
-0.0100599565,
0.0032325052,
-0.0086998818,
-0.0392954797,
-0.0222210921,
-0.0320377797,
0.0233618598,
0.0190450028,
0.0701825097,
-0.0021578255,
-0.0072094584,
0.043700926,
0.0280746203,
-0.0300152339,
0.0001408015,
0.0558655486,
-0.0616531968,
0.0388040133,
-0.001568606,
-0.0556435846,
0.0312775485,
-0.0002900877,
0.0000641489,
-0.0187904667,
0.0262265,
0.0305293947,
0.0062009669,
0.0031685061,
-0.076203905,
-0.0293668956,
0.016820956,
-0.0244756825,
-0.0321627632,
-0.0260642115,
-0.0038541874,
-0.0283048972,
-0.0357131585,
-0.0011350354,
2.47496731e-34,
0.0478639863,
-0.0343767516,
0.0084746191,
0.0063731028,
0.0022468565,
-0.0293853246,
0.0350749791,
0.0105670905,
0.0218604915,
-0.0257748533,
-0.0734331384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06175v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06175v2 | AKEM: Aligning Knowledge Base to Queries with Ensemble Model for Entity Recognition and Linking | 2023-09-12T12:37:37 | 2023-09-13T03:53:43 | Di Lu, Zhongping Liang, Caixia Yuan, Xiaojie Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | This paper presents a novel approach to address the Entity Recognition and
Linking Challenge at NLPCC 2015. The task involves extracting named entity
mentions from short search queries and linking them to entities within a
reference Chinese knowledge base. To tackle this problem, we first expand the
existing knowledge base and utilize external knowledge to identify candidate
entities, thereby improving the recall rate. Next, we extract features from the
candidate entities and utilize Support Vector Regression and Multiple Additive
Regression Tree as scoring functions to filter the results. Additionally, we
apply rules to further refine the results and enhance precision. Our method is
computationally efficient and achieves an F1 score of 0.535. | [
0.0619141236,
-0.0008112093,
0.0126942145,
-0.0264521856,
0.0260714423,
0.0041113701,
-0.0274456907,
0.0125933448,
0.0395066477,
-0.0692306012,
0.0150669878,
-0.0052491538,
0.00050082,
0.0083778538,
0.0268608574,
-0.0215561427,
0.0319481492,
0.0327753872,
-0.013758936,
0.0103506772,
0.0158956721,
0.011919803,
0.0037765172,
0.0050489856,
0.0059910216,
0.0024054667,
0.0085637355,
0.0122625763,
0.0343690962,
-0.0443180092,
-0.0045555965,
0.0341782682,
-0.0478302091,
0.0243333206,
0.0000017606,
-0.0894488543,
-0.081261158,
-0.0077467626,
-0.0597807728,
0.0013640072,
-0.0525655039,
0.0399647206,
0.0215032138,
-0.0011732419,
-0.0031549723,
-0.0263151135,
0.0202728901,
0.1098167226,
0.0370616093,
0.0727088749,
0.0024019566,
-0.0039040167,
0.0020637228,
0.0151891271,
0.0052098809,
-0.0355772637,
0.0424043238,
-0.0334511213,
-0.0135609536,
-0.0174907241,
0.0334356949,
0.0256711654,
-0.0385278426,
-0.0019224667,
0.0673792958,
0.0306299832,
-0.0739597827,
0.0303828102,
0.0087639391,
0.0916537195,
0.02517635,
-0.028015418,
0.0121534504,
0.0339056142,
0.0052959071,
0.0429319702,
-0.0374353491,
-0.0283622034,
-0.038374085,
-0.0102849081,
-0.0393243842,
0.0071695312,
0.0404064767,
0.0248906799,
0.0079388153,
0.0285856593,
-0.012509726,
-0.048973348,
0.0389742143,
0.0201418698,
-0.0089844065,
-0.0143896127,
0.0214681271,
0.0088672945,
-0.0186300334,
0.0424888916,
0.0235820897,
-0.0050436892,
0.0009339743,
-0.0520027839,
-0.0330653191,
-0.0091753518,
0.0275785513,
0.0630995706,
-0.0991552323,
0.0254827943,
0.0074035209,
-0.0357249603,
0.0115279974,
-0.0083097462,
-0.0842283666,
-0.0272626635,
-0.0243306737,
0.053890571,
-0.016610641,
0.010977326,
-0.0520291924,
-0.0248850249,
-0.0219041333,
0.0531343371,
0.0271755476,
0.0152042769,
0.014797017,
0.0275241751,
-0.0429769121,
0.007262249,
-0.0097921155,
0.0015985541,
-0.0403584465,
-0.0261189807,
-0.0206480157,
-0.0008473896,
0.0193642657,
-0.0345023423,
0.002032921,
0.0314209759,
0.024698779,
-0.0336821973,
-0.0327358395,
-0.0252823532,
0.0040818057,
-0.0223888233,
0.0273908712,
-0.0048805396,
0.0266086627,
-0.0101225469,
0.0254585538,
-0.0221291594,
0.039868582,
-0.0093581593,
-0.032678578,
0.0495874919,
-0.0339489877,
-0.0155940698,
-0.0037034424,
-0.0055156918,
0.0494019128,
0.0422011614,
0.0286581386,
0.0282795578,
0.0584560744,
0.0274154078,
-0.0028997716,
0.0224902201,
0.0316674933,
-0.0277139228,
0.0094032381,
0.0311461575,
0.0104372865,
0.0056663947,
-0.0248944964,
0.0293727107,
0.0076859156,
-0.0057269214,
0.0243532211,
-0.0096084028,
-0.0012628633,
-0.0014792698,
-0.0009854129,
0.0032194776,
0.0109636551,
-0.0619512685,
-0.0370935462,
0.0095403697,
-0.0831526816,
0.0105514536,
-0.010725108,
0.0482978374,
-0.0077970577,
0.0108199008,
-0.0245429091,
0.029519625,
-0.0471077897,
0.0456593335,
0.0481994189,
-0.0220461562,
-0.0110856956,
0.093293801,
-0.001622417,
-0.0121306311,
-0.0185115971,
-0.0000934619,
-0.012620491,
0.0579515994,
0.0439214483,
-0.0142074423,
0.007430803,
-0.0360385291,
-0.079695344,
0.0101105329,
-0.0033727023,
-0.0483131073,
0.0087707723,
-0.0165381767,
-0.0269815605,
0.071679607,
0.0111102434,
-0.0112646865,
0.0480564274,
0.0338362567,
0.025805369,
-0.0442595035,
-0.0250193477,
0.049358435,
-0.0100730406,
-0.0182346459,
0.0272585768,
0.0261915606,
-0.0040489151,
0.0704966262,
-0.0053614411,
-0.0052257306,
0.0325183049,
0.0118062254,
-0.058643166,
0.0161319934,
0.0121917883,
-0.0779154077,
0.032941658,
-0.0085798884,
0.0048952764,
-0.0244637039,
-0.0137680126,
-0.0698776394,
-0.0233628377,
0.0196687803,
0.0203431826,
-0.0474959798,
0.04692702,
-0.026483804,
0.0042462335,
-0.0351088718,
0.0872243121,
0.0039126198,
0.0484009571,
-0.0003513061,
-0.0353643484,
0.0283292253,
-0.0335506387,
-0.0790741742,
-0.0107418122,
-0.0035290022,
0.0123211946,
0.0185321327,
-0.022430934,
-0.097080484,
-0.0030374192,
-0.0842246041,
0.0339772813,
-0.0008295281,
0.0184695236,
-0.0026059458,
0.0068354057,
-0.0416291468,
-0.0080139088,
-0.0024045438,
-0.0342213996,
-0.0333775543,
-0.0199302901,
-0.0028520923,
0.0299210586,
-0.0166056771,
-0.020884322,
0.0155638279,
-0.0306213684,
0.0294130743,
0.0169329122,
-0.088836506,
-0.0225670114,
0.0244050771,
-0.0362952612,
-0.0333162732,
0.0026172139,
0.0287925322,
-0.0732749999,
0.0148883695,
-0.0230247714,
0.031323798,
-0.0107915951,
0.0126021346,
0.0085097337,
0.0005744032,
-0.0447379537,
0.0235672165,
0.0069672698,
0.0767069981,
0.0117682088,
-0.0267527476,
0.027007781,
0.0062356652,
-0.0105999699,
-0.0059056156,
-0.0172653273,
0.0037597774,
0.0277250651,
-0.0325334929,
-0.0661673993,
0.0156649947,
-0.0138468286,
-0.0436059274,
-0.0189333204,
-0.0235149004,
0.0501284376,
-0.0291589294,
0.0075005675,
-0.0184159484,
-0.0132325077,
-0.0277547836,
0.0402465835,
0.0187147353,
-0.0015481007,
0.047804337,
-0.024380032,
0.0069107409,
0.078220889,
0.0157972667,
-0.0528988056,
0.032278806,
0.0108665517,
0.059333805,
0.0199285019,
0.0212211721,
-0.0287834108,
-0.0317062475,
-0.0391956717,
0.0403743535,
0.0050632707,
-0.0300942454,
-0.0239176415,
0.0905109048,
0.031973958,
-0.0405052453,
-0.01120196,
-0.0121567091,
0.0281560868,
0.0096988799,
0.0664219111,
0.0270631462,
0.0274673048,
-0.0103901112,
0.0508390144,
-0.0018526126,
0.0513054654,
-0.0159984864,
0.032084804,
-0.0196535941,
0.0107310135,
-0.0792819038,
0.0038749245,
-0.025653379,
0.0393200517,
-0.00926778,
0.0131091336,
0.0939870849,
0.0158509966,
-0.0051291138,
-0.0296753906,
0.0316726193,
-0.0003683294,
0.0267112534,
0.0405171663,
-0.0484177582,
-0.016954504,
0.0093167294,
0.0082518291,
-0.0270986613,
-0.0793331563,
0.0022919169,
-0.1312990934,
-0.0041676993,
-0.0269250069,
-0.097186625,
-0.0342924707,
-0.0696596503,
0.0337448046,
-0.0507623404,
-0.0369338468,
-0.0163110234,
-0.0188658722,
0.022103535,
0.0118584177,
-0.0056326985,
-0.0519950129,
0.0267726909,
-0.0671827793,
0.0586948283,
0.0884369686,
0.0302141923,
0.0047146506,
0.0574559234,
-0.0739897713,
-0.0831102952,
-0.0283741765,
-0.0020792454,
0.0818810388,
-0.0453601554,
0.0276020784,
0.0127144335,
-0.0288052969,
-0.0313798487,
0.0390233733,
0.0307071805,
0.051385548,
-0.0230950471,
-0.0162208732,
0.002142336,
-0.0317003243,
0.0021845736,
0.09555199,
-0.0180309936,
0.0007224468,
0.0314472169,
-0.0175144691,
-0.0090066073,
-0.0066909953,
-0.0014316753,
0.0540321842,
-0.0738212839,
0.0140513666,
-0.0791496113,
-0.0512151085,
0.0578327477,
0.0455918163,
-0.0003031558,
0.0525712669,
-0.0269973781,
0.0583337285,
-0.0322804824,
0.0049428977,
-0.0128156263,
0.0222072378,
-0.0108345104,
-0.0074049826,
0.0633486211,
-0.009799134,
-0.0298934393,
-0.0243223328,
-0.0057199695,
-0.021666402,
-0.0215693321,
0.0032937224,
0.0098892869,
0.0315540396,
-0.0146527374,
0.0296193007,
0.0210100133,
0.0854216069,
-0.0386730395,
-0.0147669269,
-0.0322837345,
-0.025034029,
-0.0195045974,
0.0305526163,
-0.0634803921,
-0.011058582,
0.017626645,
0.0632249936,
-0.0441978648,
-0.0615507625,
0.0384982452,
0.0505637527,
0.0354158655,
0.0071795075,
-0.0140514281,
-0.0476026274,
0.0357702188,
0.0271609873,
-0.02929773,
-0.0057395659,
0.0041583045,
-0.0001241739,
0.0155968228,
-0.0057226131,
0.0476162247,
0.0299406536,
-0.0040849964,
-0.0572572052,
-0.0178614538,
0.0232789945,
0.0251426585,
-0.0181276593,
-0.007300924,
0.0083055031,
0.0102450456,
0.0840052813,
0.0063943868,
-0.0145612573,
0.0123520363,
0.0247234739,
-0.0070785722,
-0.001917725,
-0.008105238,
-0.0535863489,
0.0133984601,
-0.0340030231,
0.0101367785,
0.0559381358,
-0.0363926478,
0.0387624316,
-0.0100043789,
-0.0094896536,
-0.0104826503,
-0.0150258103,
0.0253227986,
0.0127940625,
0.0384162776,
0.0178761203,
-0.0262647569,
0.0256600548,
0.0269865822,
-0.0222133491,
0.0599596389,
0.0196842216,
-0.0171890259,
-0.0602994524,
-0.0010240028,
0.0217557363,
0.0035215695,
-0.0136013273,
0.0079357512,
-0.041496668,
-0.0290556457,
0.0429329723,
-0.0553524084,
-0.0003977992,
0.01496749,
0.0446541458,
0.0340217054,
0.0103900135,
0.000894848,
-0.028467156,
-0.0382528491,
-0.0391304456,
0.0119696986,
-0.0215849932,
-6.22388847e-33,
-0.0607904308,
-0.0417023189,
0.009755916,
-0.0509529822,
-0.0284581296,
-0.0068704709,
-0.0054108389,
-0.0325331502,
-0.0577986538,
-0.0328260027,
-0.0188579801,
0.0122799547,
0.0181453265,
0.0030273681,
-0.0124013517,
-0.0092117861,
0.0410514213,
0.0175708048,
-0.0144911055,
0.011889156,
0.095011808,
0.0726094767,
0.0635140613,
-0.0736237615,
0.0448929705,
0.02735449,
-0.026053641,
0.0296436008,
0.0526533686,
0.0625117123,
-0.0115400432,
0.0186833963,
0.0289060902,
-0.0474370494,
0.0330148563,
-0.0370853692,
-0.1355991811,
-0.0165836308,
-0.0086311614,
0.0002393292,
0.0471889973,
0.0270496812,
0.0354860052,
-0.0149193145,
0.0591472834,
0.004137333,
0.0608356893,
-0.0317438059,
-0.037334118,
-0.0729392916,
-0.0083769849,
0.0486359447,
-0.0015907339,
0.0627763867,
-0.0004248862,
0.0269656926,
0.0121358437,
0.0152807795,
-0.028485965,
-0.0025549724,
0.0126822302,
0.0252997205,
0.0417891182,
0.0318239219,
0.0313578248,
0.0598833784,
-0.0135918884,
-0.047088366,
-0.0478581749,
-0.0138655985,
0.0040757218,
0.0028887016,
-0.0004368083,
0.0423215367,
0.0186585579,
-0.0375317261,
-0.0478406996,
0.0246976931,
0.0464002267,
-0.0005410573,
-0.0360979401,
-0.0114579648,
-0.0567900762,
-0.0057176589,
-0.019576747,
0.0168533549,
-0.0303906016,
-0.0409567915,
0.0185530111,
0.0349943228,
-0.0628216565,
0.0262962859,
-0.0281981379,
-0.0285347253,
-0.0301988851,
0.0357359573,
0.0518457144,
-0.0101346951,
0.0041322419,
-0.0100386301,
-0.0690388978,
-0.0116517926,
0.0128477626,
-0.0407733917,
-0.0191163532,
-0.0006154022,
0.0091962423,
-0.0281900484,
-0.0525386967,
-0.003979553,
0.0241801739,
-0.0038153466,
-0.0380811468,
0.0019995824,
-0.0092155356,
0.0220408496,
0.0221496299,
-0.0189221855,
0.0710883662,
0.0407588482,
0.0107164495,
-0.0246750042,
-0.0038078499,
-0.0045633931,
-0.0035942378,
0.0179059058,
0.0209699795,
0.0056611304,
-0.0193550475,
-0.0590292774,
0.0141269956,
-0.0003186718,
2.559e-7,
0.0214440264,
-0.0140036251,
-0.0251276232,
-0.0006346187,
-0.0284865629,
-0.0108556505,
0.0294469353,
0.0151004083,
-0.0244933236,
-0.0173404943,
0.0302847121,
-0.0255414415,
0.022726886,
0.0352791063,
-0.1226999387,
-0.0421237797,
-0.0093151657,
-0.0219918583,
-0.0154745691,
0.0285613816,
0.0076011997,
0.0849644989,
0.007885091,
0.0405243337,
-0.0492424406,
-0.06384781,
0.0101179872,
-0.0258356612,
0.0265434217,
0.0525244065,
0.0693914369,
0.0290818699,
-0.0475642718,
0.0639116764,
-0.019082794,
0.0689962655,
0.0440295078,
0.0133033469,
0.0095013706,
-0.0051949518,
-0.0165053308,
-0.0369216315,
0.0570195988,
-0.0112172468,
0.068789877,
0.0040694061,
0.0148919728,
0.0331407487,
-0.0112605039,
-0.0132907759,
0.0076985792,
0.0247252975,
-0.0025414277,
0.0337221101,
-0.0010134763,
-0.0142959049,
0.0090012541,
-0.0983307213,
-0.0139712859,
0.0005624538,
0.0094324136,
-0.0534336381,
0.0423085578,
-0.0292084496,
-0.0092512332,
-0.0486791134,
0.0025671953,
2.265094273e-34,
-0.0086715883,
-0.0014828467,
-0.0473957919,
0.06368763,
0.0448725075,
-0.0550042875,
-0.0355793014,
-0.0020522736,
-0.0115418062,
-0.0996255726,
0.009202729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06163v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06163v1 | Overview of GUA-SPA at IberLEF 2023: Guarani-Spanish Code Switching Analysis | 2023-09-12T12:18:18 | 2023-09-12T12:18:18 | Luis Chiruzzo, Marvin Agüero-Torales, Gustavo Giménez-Lugo, Aldo Alvarez, Yliana Rodríguez, Santiago Góngora, Thamar Solorio | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present the first shared task for detecting and analyzing code-switching
in Guarani and Spanish, GUA-SPA at IberLEF 2023. The challenge consisted of
three tasks: identifying the language of a token, NER, and a novel task of
classifying the way a Spanish span is used in the code-switched context. We
annotated a corpus of 1500 texts extracted from news articles and tweets,
around 25 thousand tokens, with the information for the tasks. Three teams took
part in the evaluation phase, obtaining in general good results for Task 1, and
more mixed results for Tasks 2 and 3. | [
0.0124314316,
0.0638032779,
-0.0187042914,
0.0571222827,
-0.0334611721,
0.0289350934,
-0.0401385911,
0.0181321204,
-0.0182483867,
-0.0075481492,
-0.0330369286,
0.055851981,
0.0178270843,
0.0277214497,
0.0669131428,
0.013045297,
0.0474814847,
-0.047073707,
0.0014598104,
0.0208847858,
0.0449062996,
0.0329983346,
-0.0172066074,
0.0423964746,
-0.0230132658,
-0.0013010086,
0.0067482707,
-0.0058037583,
0.0219293106,
-0.0518136658,
0.0322346427,
0.0273704045,
-0.0660545304,
0.0556681789,
0.0000019756,
-0.0377448909,
-0.0773620903,
-0.0088888891,
-0.0229983721,
-0.0063481373,
0.043684084,
-0.0382817872,
-0.024893092,
0.0182634834,
-0.0298034977,
-0.0330552533,
0.0679591224,
-0.0046242685,
0.0348654091,
0.0576646738,
-0.0246920362,
-0.0255401097,
-0.0196212735,
-0.0100545557,
-0.002364811,
-0.0390889086,
0.01717823,
-0.083185263,
0.0321178548,
0.0108705396,
-0.0065834415,
0.0270390864,
0.0117642302,
-0.0317837782,
-0.0707272887,
-0.011523461,
-0.0949065834,
0.0320082679,
-0.0118589532,
-0.0090744486,
-0.0631676167,
-0.0719919577,
0.0412652045,
0.0036783717,
-0.0415385924,
-0.0384199359,
-0.018439237,
-0.0193239525,
-0.0534054264,
0.0157672111,
0.0527173169,
0.0211360808,
0.0286248196,
-0.0020971755,
-0.0592296869,
0.0704209656,
0.0227206051,
-0.0270826183,
-0.0062692766,
0.0094107343,
0.0594685376,
-0.0449447408,
0.0536777675,
0.0013716995,
-0.0172758214,
0.0038040702,
0.0044857184,
-0.0682912841,
0.0278222896,
-0.0547326095,
-0.0466463901,
0.0349873602,
-0.0322011597,
0.0055344952,
-0.0249556154,
0.0268932767,
0.0109890373,
-0.0096828844,
0.0201229863,
-0.0171629619,
-0.0414668433,
0.0112394895,
-0.0741187632,
0.0084339604,
0.02797224,
0.0185790118,
0.0033804022,
0.0010103091,
0.0128247617,
0.0149047505,
-0.0194857847,
-0.0462070256,
0.0275680684,
0.0395598188,
0.0728189051,
0.0084660752,
-0.0399803407,
-0.0373474546,
-0.0273839869,
-0.0766828209,
0.0033597723,
0.0121492976,
-0.0225288942,
-0.0309449658,
-0.0130673796,
0.0486846641,
-0.031872388,
-0.0155857224,
-0.0200799722,
-0.0083434805,
0.0056418809,
-0.0440238602,
-0.0144279068,
-0.0743446201,
0.0015299838,
0.0259289891,
0.0318725109,
-0.0458377786,
-0.0062396717,
-0.0059827371,
-0.0011920123,
0.0632330701,
-0.0192739777,
-0.0197267327,
0.0300887506,
-0.0029090731,
-0.0029597897,
0.1055768505,
0.0149118481,
-0.0140121998,
0.0705768988,
-0.0138075687,
0.0154798459,
0.075315021,
-0.0106298672,
0.0088354032,
0.034453366,
-0.0168238077,
0.0588762239,
0.0002272509,
0.0312938876,
0.0235186554,
-0.0013572946,
0.001717367,
-0.0232418105,
0.0649814382,
0.0068659331,
0.0035330337,
0.0197940078,
-0.0088713234,
0.0289467368,
-0.0037116404,
-0.003875819,
-0.0173351355,
-0.0139326788,
-0.0253887381,
0.0096612778,
0.0273741558,
-0.0254998114,
0.0139379418,
0.026298454,
-0.0051523503,
0.0207778774,
-0.0372057408,
0.0316783078,
-0.0060812766,
-0.0152618354,
0.0357162505,
-0.0224778634,
-0.0461427532,
0.0258075707,
-0.0702222735,
0.0105698947,
0.0346905105,
0.0302906372,
-0.0168730449,
-0.0001173664,
-0.0037646913,
0.0048393011,
0.0325610787,
-0.0555860624,
-0.004815721,
0.0289259814,
-0.030261727,
0.0236199554,
0.0166262016,
0.0123497276,
0.0067167995,
-0.0086154696,
0.0801337361,
-0.0198034253,
-0.01389609,
-0.0193379577,
0.0189398527,
0.0028669594,
0.0249005016,
0.0015100552,
0.0249729082,
-0.0065206182,
0.014778926,
-0.0178441927,
0.0022037842,
-0.0110446876,
-0.0283509046,
0.0421330146,
0.0599166192,
-0.0032671548,
-0.0361138657,
0.0117095085,
-0.0757908002,
-0.0288099255,
0.0270595234,
-0.0151816839,
-0.036970377,
0.0632613599,
-0.0260838103,
0.0402875394,
-0.0047034551,
0.0564195924,
-0.0422910191,
0.0033491743,
0.0180615317,
-0.0067669302,
0.0030419549,
0.0356189422,
-0.0038479939,
-0.0160893537,
0.0645239726,
-0.0239022877,
-0.0155009888,
0.0723711178,
-0.0135245193,
-0.0173837356,
0.0141943898,
0.0300233122,
-0.0120797874,
-0.0282371156,
-0.0513622053,
-0.0081081958,
-0.0354056694,
0.077192001,
0.0591789633,
-0.0006483062,
-0.0227294397,
-0.0291568078,
-0.0046073077,
-0.0104696508,
-0.0018327117,
-0.0075202091,
0.0009904722,
-0.0131488014,
-0.0021933126,
-0.057422705,
0.0398168862,
-0.0353545547,
0.0605584159,
0.0157164317,
-0.0915804729,
-0.1002009735,
0.0057265745,
0.0175059419,
-0.0047473372,
0.0160879567,
-0.0616392158,
0.0502737686,
0.0062116329,
0.0242125038,
0.027188547,
-0.0068013226,
-0.0110561149,
0.0032685262,
-0.0145864151,
-0.0255263019,
-0.0365731567,
0.0450842269,
-0.0065794415,
-0.0406832509,
-0.045295164,
0.0731773227,
0.0702949017,
-0.0238889251,
0.0129457461,
-0.0560508557,
-0.0393460616,
-0.0457635596,
-0.0141452001,
0.0083408048,
-0.0085039912,
-0.0218583476,
0.0414692871,
-0.0385576971,
-0.0260905456,
0.0354085006,
-0.034694925,
-0.0079161515,
-0.1008317769,
-0.0113934763,
-0.0455614179,
-0.001074592,
-0.0273964182,
0.0297476854,
0.0455969535,
-0.077409707,
0.0075845532,
-0.0142914113,
-0.0382988267,
0.0007201472,
0.0297186989,
-0.057092566,
0.0115307122,
0.0134660592,
-0.0628282875,
0.0010934673,
0.0127640823,
-0.0336566046,
-0.0159575846,
0.0675966889,
-0.0622116216,
0.0267433301,
0.0206050836,
-0.0371025205,
0.0436772369,
-0.0138829015,
-0.0061671925,
0.0229504332,
0.0505333878,
-0.0157819949,
-0.0654352307,
-0.0128082708,
0.0101849968,
-0.0350462794,
0.0517532304,
0.0283059273,
0.030869741,
-0.0236724634,
0.0033433172,
0.0397490487,
-0.0309030656,
-0.0161045026,
-0.0471160039,
0.009351138,
-0.0118309651,
-0.0370750949,
0.0649414957,
0.0417007506,
-0.0993422195,
-0.0009651736,
-0.0464376062,
0.0221842844,
0.0256639738,
0.02917335,
-0.0931670368,
0.0037370806,
0.0232712775,
0.0263777133,
-0.0296966173,
-0.0150668658,
-0.0381085686,
-0.0922649354,
0.0137966052,
0.0274663866,
-0.068506442,
-0.0217348468,
-0.0199971236,
0.0059795398,
-0.0318992026,
-0.034989208,
-0.0114649162,
-0.0119347749,
0.0041520647,
0.0393579714,
-0.056422174,
-0.0064497646,
-0.0241113007,
-0.0226984881,
0.0278913621,
0.0378029235,
0.0128267473,
-0.0266579147,
-0.0152827995,
0.0166005399,
-0.0617669672,
-0.0225166287,
-0.0208736397,
0.0407849588,
-0.0179064944,
-0.0313605443,
-0.0021388019,
0.0174804311,
-0.007070099,
-0.0331420377,
0.0390915163,
0.068763569,
-0.0160951503,
0.0293707997,
0.0123311616,
-0.0225133989,
0.0576514602,
-0.0179350842,
0.0561063401,
-0.0536970794,
-0.0085958475,
-0.0581533164,
0.0186032858,
-0.0668216348,
-0.0162365697,
-0.0237736478,
0.0085067432,
-0.0881851241,
-0.04051622,
-0.0054368423,
0.0447591245,
0.0192447342,
0.0052383393,
0.0161745604,
0.0059799454,
-0.0312067941,
-0.0313467681,
-0.0419088043,
-0.0160882957,
0.0507593006,
-0.0660124868,
-0.0120571097,
0.0049914457,
0.0345956944,
0.0090362737,
0.0197456144,
-0.0982017666,
-0.0617818907,
0.0052398527,
-0.0011263008,
0.0214981381,
0.0034618715,
-0.0456111096,
-0.0296034049,
-0.0297641829,
0.0114147337,
-0.018164292,
0.0093960669,
0.0549366064,
0.0142272925,
-0.0083296653,
0.0127126668,
-0.0025297399,
-0.0454403609,
-0.01030178,
-0.0150502753,
-0.0541047864,
0.029376464,
0.0087174876,
-0.0205101036,
0.0149090402,
-0.0355649516,
-0.0432472304,
-0.0145594589,
-0.0063099968,
0.0219595768,
0.0174323414,
0.0233053919,
-0.0096224677,
0.0101264259,
0.0184705779,
-0.0128403688,
0.059087377,
-0.036019288,
0.0061945911,
0.0050168792,
0.0694121718,
0.0731096789,
0.1073977947,
0.0023589116,
0.0199988745,
0.012513848,
0.0101530682,
0.0336816087,
0.0251315068,
-0.0552023128,
0.0226207953,
0.0188521612,
-0.0117827859,
0.0240118019,
0.0823886916,
-0.0009766882,
-0.0117693311,
0.0190900881,
-0.0093398951,
0.0664012805,
0.0084591191,
0.0785654262,
0.0265194289,
0.0042522941,
0.0077098585,
0.0146022355,
-0.0353060253,
-0.0085752662,
-0.0027195222,
-0.0098429155,
-0.0050841281,
0.011790229,
0.0693134293,
-0.0111384001,
0.0308992136,
0.0286698192,
0.005344097,
0.0087664686,
0.038104903,
0.0432260595,
-0.0471012145,
-0.0205975361,
-0.0451489054,
-0.0126286764,
-0.0490548871,
0.0201726146,
-0.0222703125,
0.0183349662,
0.0245210268,
0.0118214386,
0.0745293275,
0.0263837241,
0.0213341769,
-0.0428470783,
-0.017484067,
0.0653789416,
-0.043025326,
-0.0279227477,
-6.255213925e-33,
0.0466597155,
-0.0602547489,
-0.0331866182,
-0.003962521,
-0.0057955529,
-0.0298323072,
-0.0401858874,
-0.0334413685,
0.0171159357,
-0.0306985434,
-0.0141185699,
0.0250521414,
0.0251196716,
-0.0409213156,
0.0799252838,
-0.0085371649,
0.0500300862,
0.0359667651,
-0.0287942402,
0.0182194952,
0.0460103862,
0.0178280063,
0.0843165144,
-0.1012421846,
0.0351613574,
-0.0030225483,
-0.0325000025,
-0.0067479834,
0.0458405502,
0.051025372,
0.0021236392,
0.012103132,
0.0413231403,
-0.0489744991,
-0.0185212232,
0.0175895337,
-0.0309935063,
-0.0472051017,
0.0590351373,
0.0768951997,
0.0187660586,
-0.0830777809,
0.0046900152,
-0.0262711793,
-0.0045573916,
0.0378387086,
0.015928302,
0.0011451364,
0.0281216111,
0.0339160338,
-0.0814650133,
0.0357094631,
-0.0308308955,
0.0318438448,
0.0549878217,
0.0417891257,
-0.0199115146,
-0.0205904841,
-0.050843969,
0.0505776443,
-0.0182321295,
0.0174582656,
0.014167943,
0.0053901039,
-0.0407236107,
0.0040066745,
0.0492904782,
-0.0309333913,
0.0358776525,
0.0004798977,
0.0185929798,
0.0097749447,
0.0264788419,
0.0285062119,
0.0472308099,
-0.0658568144,
-0.025334917,
0.0048407177,
0.0286201853,
0.0369996279,
-0.0222842358,
0.0139244804,
-0.0195262339,
-0.0230185129,
0.0024708733,
-0.0630142316,
-0.018479418,
-0.0496757254,
0.0114199659,
-0.040240813,
-0.0051301834,
0.0324660987,
0.0394190289,
-0.0269889757,
-0.0099339457,
0.0284177549,
-0.0042174137,
0.0558484159,
-0.0024644595,
0.0858150572,
-0.0594589412,
-0.0307303797,
0.0261791442,
0.0376002491,
0.0863209665,
-0.0181024782,
0.0661338419,
0.0574290119,
-0.0570385233,
0.0087321829,
0.0075353151,
0.0264343824,
-0.0129969958,
0.0408824645,
-0.0051798355,
0.0072186682,
0.0143017685,
-0.0137444558,
0.0129493438,
0.0121270344,
-0.012679317,
-0.0252987109,
-0.0094167646,
0.0654050037,
-0.0526010841,
0.0002407755,
-0.0598269254,
0.0388499498,
0.0119046392,
-0.0443334877,
-0.0041063167,
-0.0091542425,
2.663e-7,
0.0589919314,
0.0226335581,
0.0213236511,
0.0016961741,
0.0129559841,
-0.0313742086,
-0.0508086644,
0.0092150848,
-0.0011256613,
0.0666657835,
-0.0439716727,
-0.0327715538,
0.0678079799,
0.0427878089,
-0.0950665846,
-0.0268454645,
-0.0054481891,
0.0021567941,
-0.0687013492,
0.0160414446,
0.0711094961,
0.0910600796,
-0.0164649915,
0.0270310715,
-0.0207338128,
-0.0278279893,
-0.0060255355,
0.0098707294,
0.0223717503,
-0.0147454636,
-0.0238327924,
0.0004240637,
-0.0124181043,
0.0119051253,
0.0141080245,
-0.0412524045,
0.0106225042,
0.0192144513,
0.0023038564,
0.0148996897,
0.017184563,
-0.0523359589,
-0.0269256253,
-0.0698404983,
0.0531077161,
0.0359402932,
-0.0094572464,
0.0041207457,
0.0144145433,
-0.0018936931,
-0.0001922869,
-0.0309878197,
-0.0502852686,
0.059995994,
0.0167654678,
0.0199269932,
-0.022515269,
-0.0523501635,
0.0051717074,
0.0123820538,
0.010764909,
-0.0230098609,
-0.03040988,
0.0144627001,
0.0206910092,
-0.0236520022,
0.0517903492,
2.178480543e-34,
0.0036773484,
-0.0180532392,
0.0018016603,
0.0539611205,
0.0310787857,
-0.0262328628,
-0.0177747216,
0.0454386249,
-0.0169294588,
-0.0032351052,
0.0043028244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06135v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06135v2 | Prompting4Debugging: Red-Teaming Text-to-Image Diffusion Models by Finding Problematic Prompts | 2023-09-12T11:19:36 | 2024-06-08T05:30:26 | Zhi-Yi Chin, Chieh-Ming Jiang, Ching-Chun Huang, Pin-Yu Chen, Wei-Chen Chiu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Text-to-image diffusion models, e.g. Stable Diffusion (SD), lately have shown
remarkable ability in high-quality content generation, and become one of the
representatives for the recent wave of transformative AI. Nevertheless, such
advance comes with an intensifying concern about the misuse of this generative
technology, especially for producing copyrighted or NSFW (i.e. not safe for
work) images. Although efforts have been made to filter inappropriate
images/prompts or remove undesirable concepts/styles via model fine-tuning, the
reliability of these safety mechanisms against diversified problematic prompts
remains largely unexplored. In this work, we propose Prompting4Debugging (P4D)
as a debugging and red-teaming tool that automatically finds problematic
prompts for diffusion models to test the reliability of a deployed safety
mechanism. We demonstrate the efficacy of our P4D tool in uncovering new
vulnerabilities of SD models with safety mechanisms. Particularly, our result
shows that around half of prompts in existing safe prompting benchmarks which
were originally considered "safe" can actually be manipulated to bypass many
deployed safety mechanisms, including concept removal, negative prompt, and
safety guidance. Our findings suggest that, without comprehensive testing, the
evaluations on limited safe prompting benchmarks can lead to a false sense of
safety for text-to-image models. | [
0.0336131677,
0.039990712,
-0.0100812381,
0.0109807607,
-0.0133520849,
0.0041321418,
0.0437726416,
0.0230043698,
0.0094666407,
0.0147496564,
0.0035838005,
-0.0453749821,
-0.0150129618,
0.0658076555,
0.0099335797,
-0.0350549109,
0.0254798401,
-0.0281738639,
-0.0313646905,
-0.0000774504,
-0.0006977241,
0.00613723,
-0.0034349901,
0.0147282854,
-0.0406033695,
-0.0244113319,
-0.0121928174,
0.0733960196,
0.0534088276,
-0.0187759101,
-0.0050809663,
0.0594984479,
0.0064215036,
0.0285514556,
0.0000022093,
-0.030077124,
0.0005089869,
0.0123007344,
0.0229190513,
0.0079237334,
0.0612887517,
-0.0111535778,
-0.0502918027,
0.0032790534,
0.0003345751,
0.0810904428,
0.0717415512,
0.0563737676,
0.1065175831,
0.0523072444,
-0.0174330007,
0.0214848574,
0.0121657094,
-0.0456389971,
0.0223406162,
-0.0137374634,
0.028559573,
-0.0080978433,
0.0158023536,
0.0180941317,
-0.0266360752,
0.0468106493,
0.0103535233,
-0.0339733586,
-0.0049128113,
0.03292647,
0.0328669921,
-0.1085254848,
-0.0084842779,
0.0576082803,
-0.0259353817,
0.0158178154,
0.0260228664,
-0.0268766023,
0.0025026179,
0.0634043738,
-0.0204047821,
0.0237126499,
-0.0250473563,
-0.01082421,
-0.0423283726,
-0.0033906901,
0.0130140567,
-0.0082741296,
0.0552935526,
-0.0208250396,
0.0300990902,
-0.0240334105,
-0.0059769894,
-0.0107255355,
0.0068133147,
-0.0598688833,
0.0567353964,
-0.0139275445,
0.0270063169,
0.0166762266,
-0.0486729443,
-0.0467480049,
0.0455095135,
-0.0210142862,
0.0334495828,
-0.0117514627,
-0.0111648878,
0.0372318625,
-0.0126074385,
0.0121605834,
-0.0336044505,
0.0351894349,
-0.0033400538,
0.0696482807,
0.0088486271,
0.0019342826,
-0.0176996775,
-0.0284684449,
-0.0181372724,
-0.0240501352,
-0.0300226286,
0.0270795282,
-0.0563036539,
0.0297624227,
-0.0057633827,
0.0390741341,
-0.0649237037,
0.0129340114,
-0.0170973949,
-0.0312318597,
-0.0252390429,
-0.0118895927,
0.0387770049,
-0.0153241418,
-0.0145346019,
-0.0072315284,
-0.0054203924,
-0.0055584209,
-0.0046165911,
0.0601953864,
-0.0118857436,
0.0173523482,
-0.0314617157,
-0.0432909429,
-0.0381995924,
-0.0098402537,
0.0477986708,
-0.0651250109,
-0.0166651029,
-0.0515068397,
-0.0046056933,
-0.0692346096,
0.0193101149,
0.0185025986,
-0.0477948934,
0.0414757542,
-0.0036250243,
-0.0157420691,
0.0179889463,
0.0595510192,
-0.0638030618,
0.0405266359,
0.003303414,
0.0987404212,
0.0424660668,
-0.0163196512,
0.047757443,
0.0304699801,
0.0458836779,
0.0572225526,
-0.0060247737,
-0.021954149,
0.0223886669,
0.0027696216,
0.0364208482,
0.0628787726,
-0.0344517715,
-0.0279228576,
0.0851463377,
0.0304658096,
-0.0411195271,
0.0015218186,
0.0662620664,
0.0024864164,
-0.0380809382,
0.0464408882,
-0.0696517378,
0.0106967222,
-0.0123079531,
-0.0236887373,
-0.0136009185,
0.0372298658,
-0.0293986872,
-0.0073029837,
0.0333759785,
-0.0196980331,
0.0484113432,
-0.0448395908,
0.0066162581,
0.0669343919,
-0.0705629885,
-0.0448949151,
-0.0216733087,
-0.0587543137,
-0.0251525715,
-0.0778637975,
0.0568615384,
0.0824583694,
0.0482543409,
0.0114325518,
-0.0215771757,
-0.0189539976,
0.0320376307,
0.0172040109,
-0.0051003029,
0.0115298061,
0.0041896049,
-0.0337359309,
-0.026064286,
-0.0084631629,
0.0109555637,
0.0221397225,
0.0094837472,
0.0203355569,
0.0090701906,
0.0288099702,
-0.046337191,
0.0217690133,
-0.0056569688,
-0.0364240594,
-0.012816106,
0.0277831256,
-0.0037848186,
-0.017106194,
-0.0385987051,
0.0005141108,
0.0193121862,
0.0244391859,
-0.0402924977,
0.0103307357,
-0.0155086182,
0.0107198069,
-0.0037196607,
-0.0696200505,
-0.0411147922,
0.0446208641,
-0.0319349729,
0.0156230135,
0.0026181627,
-0.0103972163,
-0.0424796119,
-0.0294879787,
0.0021784937,
0.0114189088,
0.0179932024,
0.0094643794,
0.0595082231,
-0.000989615,
-0.0248438958,
-0.0087351287,
0.0183409359,
-0.0012786397,
-0.0149188666,
-0.0179178324,
-0.0366931558,
-0.034039095,
0.0348846614,
0.0180862807,
0.0259405822,
-0.0542023703,
-0.0201199111,
-0.0240302105,
-0.0123792151,
-0.0148911644,
0.0022826558,
0.0008249732,
0.0029859992,
-0.0242083352,
0.0011341838,
-0.031811256,
-0.0092510171,
-0.005717353,
0.0461462252,
0.0193687715,
-0.0030434378,
-0.0141886631,
-0.0267178752,
-0.01073917,
-0.0046147415,
0.0406192988,
0.037317872,
-0.0098515684,
-0.0191072226,
0.0898067877,
-0.0156465489,
-0.0036827372,
-0.0036770392,
-0.0398476943,
0.0161531791,
0.003901107,
0.0062078699,
0.0808390751,
0.0457297713,
0.0229459424,
0.0062445635,
0.0193274003,
-0.0210734941,
0.0045116437,
-0.006260131,
-0.0156893432,
0.0488831513,
-0.0609333813,
0.0152650941,
0.0133140609,
0.0053633302,
0.0009625386,
-0.0605111085,
0.0530997291,
-0.017296996,
-0.0539525263,
-0.0077030296,
-0.0362406671,
-0.0057063061,
0.0294064432,
-0.0568957515,
-0.0714741573,
0.0447527282,
-0.0158758834,
0.0121671697,
0.0270288605,
-0.0134444702,
0.031749811,
0.0196602792,
-0.0047161398,
0.0484879576,
0.0562564358,
0.0099275736,
-0.0341870971,
-0.0031626509,
0.061131075,
-0.0220337734,
0.0099042766,
-0.0183535628,
-0.019759804,
-0.0215677265,
-0.0407467186,
-0.0535716154,
-0.0766574889,
0.0432939716,
-0.0106856301,
0.0118738869,
-0.0028398796,
0.0298817493,
-0.0017583054,
-0.0109029356,
0.0051482269,
-0.0058562327,
-0.0321343914,
-0.0146196792,
0.0499142222,
0.0556898937,
-0.0728559643,
-0.0138806133,
-0.0530125462,
0.0326489545,
0.0956066027,
0.0042631496,
-0.0139727164,
-0.064639695,
0.0117301932,
-0.0286060162,
0.0387309454,
0.003863665,
0.0316831879,
0.0752981827,
-0.0377620161,
-0.0142550552,
0.0174910035,
0.0163779203,
-0.0099480106,
0.0064326278,
0.0381026343,
0.0349049345,
0.0045682103,
0.0050434382,
-0.0840336308,
0.0024928453,
0.0048291683,
0.0449783057,
-0.034439601,
-0.0249377023,
0.0239924584,
-0.0830379128,
0.1075746492,
0.0122500965,
0.0262860451,
0.0203142874,
-0.031840831,
0.0075815031,
0.0221922547,
-0.0222022086,
-0.0276317168,
0.0111632226,
-0.0082147364,
0.0209608469,
0.036229223,
-0.0856051296,
0.003826333,
-0.0504207984,
0.0353790857,
0.0780351982,
0.0115055451,
-0.0136489207,
-0.0486106016,
0.0264908914,
0.0323191136,
0.0117956884,
0.0169966165,
0.0816247985,
0.006764512,
-0.0014068707,
-0.0216318909,
0.0241954606,
-0.0072126337,
-0.0454076976,
0.0139359748,
0.0596803427,
-0.0005861635,
-0.0673552603,
-0.0943415686,
0.0285745971,
0.0659329668,
0.0642848313,
0.0468957163,
-0.0639023334,
-0.0342278257,
-0.0448331535,
0.0465619415,
-0.0400061756,
-0.0307901558,
-0.0218234379,
-0.023503961,
-0.0727163926,
-0.0998534113,
0.0027502892,
-0.0278570894,
0.0575247444,
0.0070392592,
-0.0572776012,
-0.0700923204,
0.010923163,
-0.0280695241,
0.0111049106,
0.0139912376,
0.0268272385,
-0.0435850136,
0.0248162802,
-0.0154892346,
-0.0200451687,
-0.0222743656,
0.063462764,
-0.090850763,
-0.0537147,
-0.0120062744,
0.0821772069,
0.0311839636,
-0.0155139491,
-0.0333272815,
-0.006926354,
0.0985388085,
0.0757291988,
0.0175519586,
-0.0103177894,
0.0623688549,
-0.0283677503,
-0.0028770065,
-0.0213252008,
-0.0497820042,
0.0289453138,
0.0335417427,
-0.0093691722,
-0.0223731473,
0.0145360352,
-0.0081411498,
0.0168046318,
-0.0193375107,
-0.0505805761,
0.0188983735,
-0.0074458434,
-0.0091113281,
0.0190996658,
-0.004803217,
-0.044431325,
0.0386985317,
0.033329498,
-0.0415061228,
0.0114240572,
0.0240466706,
-0.0115912538,
0.0443541892,
-0.0580011234,
-0.0150198936,
0.0466618612,
0.0446001552,
0.0153372036,
0.0022688883,
0.0106952516,
0.0310246442,
-0.0104299355,
0.0363467522,
0.0041224379,
0.0528648011,
0.0205353852,
0.015114611,
0.0191886052,
0.0766411424,
-0.0568780638,
-0.0482698381,
-0.0254735444,
0.0425584577,
0.02595824,
0.0261681434,
0.0112622036,
-0.0169730429,
-0.0117779868,
-0.0280861463,
0.0066377739,
0.0056465068,
-0.06026024,
0.0013555899,
-0.0030576647,
0.0357424058,
0.0000121923,
0.0434655957,
-0.0764461309,
0.0326504745,
-0.0008047383,
-0.0436517894,
-0.0208525155,
-0.0139665492,
0.0165226441,
-0.0229090899,
0.0173301604,
-0.0081316615,
-0.0572430827,
-0.1058796793,
-0.0070420094,
0.0189954154,
0.0063220137,
0.0234864634,
0.01952108,
0.0432364941,
0.0062819761,
0.0330839008,
0.0024252518,
-0.0186274592,
-0.0344150811,
-0.0098393373,
-0.019272754,
-6.549776646e-33,
0.0056971675,
-0.0293139536,
-0.027042903,
-0.0016675193,
0.0011456973,
0.0048166211,
-0.0272714067,
-0.0115703912,
0.0416815728,
0.0132249147,
-0.0380304679,
0.0017446188,
-0.0116315577,
-0.0046874443,
-0.0279558878,
-0.0114848847,
0.0344552584,
-0.0063953497,
-0.0861483365,
0.0479287319,
0.0302954763,
0.0167120472,
-0.026488455,
-0.0707344413,
-0.0060776207,
-0.0043941936,
-0.0632839873,
-0.0339843072,
0.0038697156,
0.065474622,
0.0132821454,
-0.0098537719,
0.0094350623,
-0.0302387103,
-0.0099505186,
0.0672842339,
-0.05315312,
-0.0235292967,
-0.021464631,
-0.0411634408,
-0.0796107501,
-0.0587543882,
0.0471184999,
-0.0236951802,
0.0287366863,
-0.0165638141,
0.0210538767,
-0.0030560382,
0.0102021918,
-0.0217987783,
-0.0446694829,
-0.0029828786,
-0.0409415402,
-0.0424804874,
0.000241918,
0.049690675,
0.0348485895,
-0.0137349125,
-0.0533006899,
0.005575744,
0.0532338507,
-0.0286283903,
0.069018051,
-0.0115830041,
-0.0171786919,
0.0661112517,
-0.0113105616,
0.0502898209,
0.000989174,
-0.0116687315,
0.0022569089,
0.0817418993,
0.0088544339,
0.0441373028,
0.0411486737,
-0.0276474413,
-0.0282070953,
0.0722914413,
-0.0505203679,
0.0063612079,
0.0299323071,
-0.0219749622,
-0.044775635,
0.0035865305,
-0.0382476561,
-0.0375726558,
-0.0327709578,
-0.0614499375,
0.0394560583,
0.0231010094,
-0.0712269023,
-0.008448516,
0.0033362599,
-0.032499209,
0.0237254966,
-0.00741493,
-0.0352383479,
0.0141510405,
-0.0079883803,
-0.0097106965,
0.0074566728,
-0.0127886627,
0.0443423912,
0.0153087694,
0.041695334,
0.0102120526,
0.0381503031,
0.0448349006,
-0.0525204018,
-0.0066374741,
-0.0411956348,
0.0620664284,
0.0224067904,
0.0061758985,
-0.0026548158,
-0.0324567258,
-0.0409441777,
-0.0026803219,
0.0304361507,
0.065311715,
-0.0332268029,
0.01964375,
-0.0302276015,
0.0142713003,
-0.0314514562,
-0.0133350799,
0.0064978083,
0.03808745,
0.0792078376,
-0.1063455269,
-0.0317730233,
0.0123219555,
2.92e-7,
-0.0002792862,
0.0022036198,
0.0317582302,
0.0478392243,
0.025167929,
0.0697387084,
-0.0445108712,
0.0316733532,
0.0101564582,
-0.0458517633,
0.0122178979,
0.0176696256,
0.0425821468,
0.039360553,
-0.0196726099,
-0.0361624174,
-0.0293700267,
0.0514995754,
-0.0268981326,
-0.0073489598,
0.0418815948,
0.0362388827,
0.0106701748,
-0.0774279311,
0.0468309112,
-0.0347805135,
0.0543325841,
-0.0242764782,
0.0286849644,
-0.0226124916,
0.0137402862,
-0.0052560717,
0.0071862405,
0.0143303834,
-0.0434270054,
-0.0390742123,
0.0077073928,
0.0414877795,
0.0000662699,
-0.0006385928,
-0.0046927114,
-0.0242742002,
0.0192923564,
-0.0348179452,
0.0669998303,
-0.0006493743,
0.0018816133,
-0.027510697,
-0.0503001139,
-0.0474785455,
0.0624201298,
-0.0466458574,
-0.0285490472,
-0.0151917292,
-0.0045962357,
0.0304171126,
-0.0204844512,
-0.0336891264,
0.0129867811,
-0.0481121093,
-0.0152186546,
-0.0486203134,
-0.0204800926,
0.0357294306,
-0.0169487093,
-0.0281301774,
-0.0003080366,
2.853175041e-34,
0.039069999,
-0.0468106829,
0.0092832949,
-0.0308160316,
0.0448950976,
0.0089033348,
-0.010170307,
-0.0032233105,
0.0074636703,
-0.011922488,
-0.0234521367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06132v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06132v2 | Measuring vagueness and subjectivity in texts: from symbolic to neural VAGO | 2023-09-12T11:18:29 | 2023-10-23T18:16:19 | Benjamin Icard, Vincent Claveau, Ghislain Atemezing, Paul Égré | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T07, 68T50 | We present a hybrid approach to the automated measurement of vagueness and
subjectivity in texts. We first introduce the expert system VAGO, we illustrate
it on a small benchmark of fact vs. opinion sentences, and then test it on the
larger French press corpus FreSaDa to confirm the higher prevalence of
subjective markers in satirical vs. regular texts. We then build a neural clone
of VAGO, based on a BERT-like architecture, trained on the symbolic VAGO scores
obtained on FreSaDa. Using explainability tools (LIME), we show the interest of
this neural version for the enrichment of the lexicons of the symbolic version,
and for the production of versions in other languages. | [
0.0583933927,
0.0610718951,
-0.0180273801,
0.0367273204,
-0.0036215878,
-0.0093544824,
0.0029833179,
0.0072954549,
-0.0353154875,
-0.018568648,
0.0110889515,
-0.0102567999,
-0.0240388513,
0.0366286524,
0.0175653845,
-0.0340651982,
0.0017932318,
0.0411920063,
0.0763409287,
-0.0039062579,
0.0448383056,
0.0234025382,
-0.0131590115,
0.0278236028,
0.0101015512,
0.0206613187,
-0.0188598875,
0.0238925032,
0.0053309668,
0.0256045703,
0.0025241508,
0.0268955398,
-0.0412567034,
0.0208965056,
0.0000016729,
-0.0427085124,
-0.0227977838,
-0.0119420299,
0.022763703,
0.0079520168,
0.0474641137,
0.0060275397,
-0.0047877617,
-0.0207698345,
-0.0328152329,
0.011608813,
0.049433969,
0.03737095,
0.0695924163,
0.1001403406,
-0.0048255688,
-0.0079017561,
-0.004038712,
0.0096033495,
0.0271879081,
0.021481799,
-0.0231446102,
-0.0220172796,
-0.0416966341,
-0.0052101477,
-0.0267176013,
0.0123772649,
0.0200226046,
-0.0365832224,
-0.0074474425,
-0.0170430876,
-0.0608546101,
0.0009492027,
0.0252029728,
0.0132926144,
0.023885116,
-0.0419977978,
0.0183403622,
0.0296081752,
0.0164091904,
0.0262354482,
0.0046342295,
-0.0188014489,
-0.0218643881,
0.0103101339,
0.0245321356,
0.027510915,
-0.005495036,
0.0271167737,
-0.0027320769,
0.0204018969,
-0.0133088883,
-0.0271638744,
0.0199952982,
-0.0049075964,
-0.0610287748,
-0.0214579795,
0.0384904407,
0.0535768308,
0.0101874489,
0.0129032219,
-0.0047236732,
-0.0234668069,
0.0113031138,
-0.0896934792,
0.000019331,
0.0301912799,
-0.0271170177,
0.0321679525,
-0.0019054661,
0.0238220319,
0.0022343732,
0.0267630536,
-0.044469934,
-0.0403325483,
-0.0637573153,
-0.0011851925,
-0.0380221792,
0.0248751342,
0.0013123493,
-0.0024336157,
-0.0429448523,
-0.0116219586,
-0.0149704302,
-0.0012368115,
0.0221073516,
0.0432562195,
-0.0060236095,
-0.0084962314,
-0.0480793826,
0.0296981148,
-0.0691652298,
-0.0096055232,
-0.0499155,
0.0266613793,
0.0232067071,
0.0404649451,
-0.0027251549,
-0.016206516,
0.0382939912,
0.0291844755,
0.0240025595,
-0.0214937832,
-0.0446386524,
-0.0338105001,
-0.0352488421,
-0.0796554685,
-0.0140394261,
-0.0466437042,
-0.0153095499,
-0.0099544404,
-0.0115020545,
0.0094899563,
0.0272196718,
-0.0027026858,
0.0183131211,
0.0489884093,
-0.0350780934,
-0.0367949493,
-0.0042351251,
0.00665764,
-0.0168188754,
0.0399724841,
0.0129083432,
0.0100637507,
0.065180555,
0.0117059788,
-0.0069635222,
-0.0074870521,
0.0220656544,
-0.0156574585,
-0.0021739188,
-0.0353838168,
-0.1172193587,
0.0356560946,
0.006189303,
0.0764901266,
-0.0030780353,
-0.0575860664,
0.0563680232,
0.0203102827,
0.0079572918,
0.0218097828,
0.0714477226,
0.0020014173,
0.0663426965,
0.0413135178,
-0.0130873583,
0.0432428382,
-0.0491107889,
0.023686327,
-0.0523762815,
0.032247629,
-0.0016552258,
-0.1022221968,
-0.0291284174,
-0.0060097245,
0.0396108553,
-0.0496661477,
0.0570335872,
0.0188044347,
-0.021992147,
0.0265020505,
0.0262066592,
-0.0583789982,
-0.0192796309,
0.0006125517,
0.0914251506,
0.044721067,
0.0272763837,
-0.0337145925,
-0.0330141522,
-0.0197999049,
-0.0179832242,
0.0536169037,
0.003827485,
-0.0112153161,
0.0127579914,
-0.048342213,
0.0403822884,
-0.0480184779,
0.0357820503,
0.0321833342,
-0.0188621636,
0.021217972,
-0.0048373491,
-0.0497867316,
-0.0004045606,
0.0196536183,
-0.0186323542,
-0.0299146529,
-0.0107558239,
0.0364820734,
0.0224876069,
0.040164154,
-0.0200986657,
-0.0108252177,
0.0208434165,
-0.0305286963,
-0.040855214,
0.0440338254,
0.0212533474,
-0.0243606754,
0.0168012213,
-0.0640487894,
-0.0179499071,
0.0354841799,
-0.0142781418,
-0.0126848845,
0.0153296478,
-0.0576032363,
0.014487681,
-0.0825853795,
-0.0009348046,
-0.0410822332,
0.0017159388,
-0.0305758417,
0.055640243,
-0.0016043913,
0.0590022504,
0.0158597846,
-0.0275218971,
0.0513617769,
0.022120541,
-0.0425352268,
0.0029621753,
0.0278882086,
0.0069530923,
0.0142510971,
0.007473201,
-0.0155352363,
-0.0458466224,
-0.1309401244,
0.0043759188,
-0.0255001858,
-0.000040256,
0.0602652542,
-0.0268505588,
0.0133784162,
0.0216966383,
-0.0361785516,
0.0149470828,
-0.0263387617,
-0.0091233114,
0.0628790781,
-0.0085641863,
-0.0140052456,
-0.0325949416,
0.0008831904,
-0.0463890545,
0.0419657752,
0.0130041,
0.0506603457,
-0.0308930036,
-0.0069049723,
-0.0669201538,
0.0002979446,
0.0024748365,
-0.1004299596,
-0.006598752,
-0.0093647661,
-0.0435706154,
0.0467775054,
0.0336470604,
0.058846999,
0.0164785851,
0.0194703713,
0.0144017972,
-0.0059552803,
-0.0574301295,
0.0598472133,
-0.01964752,
-0.0533280782,
0.0087640258,
0.0326899141,
0.0142118754,
-0.0331991687,
-0.0497282669,
0.0698550493,
-0.0226173066,
0.0091502387,
0.0299201664,
-0.0061128605,
-0.0051453896,
0.007964192,
-0.0071670231,
-0.0145227173,
0.104802236,
-0.0160998516,
-0.0182089396,
-0.0501942709,
-0.0261740964,
-0.0588266142,
0.0572250485,
-0.0086935917,
0.0194637347,
-0.0052924813,
-0.0112721911,
-0.0307052191,
-0.0079298001,
0.0311782267,
0.0061564394,
0.054876741,
-0.0214049257,
-0.0312187783,
0.04510222,
-0.017990727,
-0.0008927821,
-0.0457728393,
-0.0274368376,
-0.0001477652,
0.0709591955,
-0.053111393,
0.0247499943,
-0.0327530503,
-0.0133212376,
-0.0047798278,
-0.0352647007,
-0.0317101032,
0.0125880465,
0.020594269,
-0.0034443256,
-0.0023792339,
0.0387431905,
0.0078709386,
-0.0167707782,
0.0304801241,
-0.0735049248,
0.0098105548,
-0.0487181991,
-0.0184418801,
-0.0470048822,
-0.0610197969,
-0.0340164639,
-0.0487161279,
0.0425354764,
-0.0366222411,
-0.0365264714,
0.1131898761,
0.022967726,
0.003461526,
0.0077192546,
-0.0219622012,
-0.0132553689,
0.0262241252,
0.0187695026,
-0.0013185269,
-0.0079367096,
-0.0211964548,
0.0300300065,
-0.0422370397,
-0.0089086452,
-0.019994732,
-0.0689921454,
-0.0160345621,
-0.029935861,
-0.0241472386,
0.0272012092,
-0.0088879531,
-0.0038453152,
-0.0184137076,
-0.0372650996,
-0.0159239173,
0.0193384998,
0.0146186193,
0.0147742108,
-0.006772357,
0.0043562991,
0.0128606101,
-0.0184616093,
0.0274859723,
0.0237019975,
0.09647163,
-0.0142720081,
-0.0231909156,
0.0094642015,
-0.0078440132,
0.0013996537,
0.0073612928,
0.1067826375,
0.0110727567,
-0.0113645596,
-0.0397835821,
0.0059625665,
0.0161129236,
0.0396931358,
-0.0199707393,
0.0297714639,
0.0022369234,
-0.011445553,
-0.0355971865,
0.0176337045,
-0.0145043135,
0.0752114877,
0.0324706174,
-0.0391055271,
-0.0217720754,
-0.0168779902,
-0.0272345468,
-0.0630983561,
-0.0505192615,
-0.0140000712,
-0.0168890636,
-0.0675243065,
-0.1041342318,
-0.0426877588,
-0.0233504083,
0.0379994437,
0.0018203905,
-0.0336889327,
0.0251724049,
-0.0236819126,
-0.0421301536,
-0.0015053984,
0.064687334,
-0.0153999673,
-0.0160957351,
-0.0256867353,
0.025724493,
-0.0455620028,
-0.0097858645,
-0.03900766,
-0.0240546353,
-0.0449267551,
0.0295225531,
0.0359112062,
0.0286762826,
0.0023566226,
-0.0368670858,
-0.0546591952,
0.0552995428,
0.0728496686,
-0.0175946821,
0.021699978,
0.0483690538,
0.0555402227,
0.0156464707,
0.0595812201,
-0.0017050313,
0.0116669517,
-0.0152236568,
-0.0073094242,
-0.0112911323,
0.0220505819,
0.0258168653,
0.0057915822,
0.0186703801,
0.0042650322,
-0.0121921282,
-0.0270536821,
-0.0197576843,
-0.0403245129,
-0.0249904059,
-0.0100929327,
0.0360922068,
0.0014704614,
-0.0155407665,
-0.0453429669,
-0.0358179063,
-0.0348971374,
0.0403795019,
0.0079676108,
-0.0097514438,
0.0396677591,
0.0051732361,
-0.0334196761,
0.0263992622,
-0.0208099205,
0.0192552023,
-0.0323098525,
0.0281655062,
-0.0115219457,
0.0555369817,
0.0568730533,
-0.0122901816,
-0.0137314266,
0.0154043855,
-0.0421135686,
0.0081393821,
-0.000360131,
0.0168739632,
0.0123805944,
-0.0204923656,
0.0652846321,
-0.0234350227,
-0.0027475476,
0.0220432281,
0.0357735977,
0.0167037509,
-0.0087557239,
-0.0126517648,
0.0081918323,
0.0058692396,
-0.0200792849,
0.041684594,
-0.046937976,
0.0172496028,
0.0413878188,
-0.0523318835,
-0.0332153626,
-0.0100529231,
0.0224584211,
0.0280571152,
0.0109438477,
0.005727692,
-0.0721772835,
-0.0308747385,
0.0673802122,
-0.0039361101,
0.0148695027,
-0.0212481059,
0.0203149263,
0.0650554523,
0.0040246709,
0.039065145,
-0.0522723757,
0.0426037423,
-0.0355468765,
0.020489106,
-0.0262886416,
-5.776528381e-33,
-0.0186410733,
-0.0327565297,
-0.0520064384,
0.0055024982,
-0.0024050258,
0.0064704581,
-0.0521362238,
0.0251404867,
0.0016659066,
0.09543515,
0.01706912,
0.0383457579,
-0.0097879013,
-0.0048606289,
-0.005060086,
-0.0269285087,
0.023997495,
0.030949086,
-0.0283162147,
-0.0186386518,
0.0854097605,
0.0112426663,
0.0836312473,
-0.1087334901,
0.0776944235,
0.0106916521,
-0.0244713835,
0.0267470498,
0.0001535611,
0.0716064945,
0.0420690775,
0.0540634096,
0.0030676771,
0.025307484,
0.0221585613,
-0.0260168798,
-0.024005346,
-0.0900722891,
0.0323405117,
0.0235474855,
-0.0203758236,
-0.0258899052,
0.0251875743,
-0.0315791667,
-0.024806207,
0.0297238175,
0.0617452487,
-0.0123416511,
0.0284840744,
-0.1061960906,
-0.0404147655,
-0.0005403974,
-0.0221492741,
-0.0337131657,
-0.0122053921,
-0.0032235149,
-0.0094225798,
0.0115796849,
-0.0321265422,
-0.0280052442,
-0.076195702,
0.000597608,
-0.0258847252,
-0.0761708692,
-0.005063145,
0.0596010089,
0.0297008269,
0.0223174766,
-0.0658598915,
0.0560521707,
0.0310252905,
0.0159520414,
0.1158313006,
0.0719091669,
0.0645623058,
-0.0145294005,
-0.0345359072,
0.0001336085,
0.0397194214,
0.0172969233,
0.0580796823,
-0.0399791263,
-0.0604833998,
0.0039737164,
-0.0076768273,
-0.0601036772,
-0.0299982522,
-0.0478981175,
-0.0233257972,
-0.0282073561,
-0.0272848047,
-0.0360913239,
0.001475243,
-0.0296454318,
0.0476864092,
0.0537557527,
-0.0515836515,
0.050288979,
0.0184967518,
0.0009180056,
-0.0023492037,
0.0164149012,
-0.0046099732,
0.0576356202,
0.0224115457,
-0.0081504276,
0.0787342116,
0.0145444805,
-0.0226954203,
0.0218880624,
-0.0381477736,
-0.0005247992,
-0.0428234935,
0.038830094,
-0.0200971104,
0.0129881809,
-0.0285920911,
0.0215186086,
0.0466540828,
0.054128889,
-0.0340384245,
0.0024616723,
0.0253992844,
0.0134489778,
-0.0284619853,
-0.0420081317,
-0.0018960217,
-0.0421653613,
-0.0295560975,
-0.0624898076,
0.009509827,
-0.016956877,
2.59e-7,
0.0520461909,
0.0527012162,
0.0171513502,
0.0010272745,
0.0142139625,
0.0281401258,
0.0168950707,
0.00524909,
-0.0286431815,
-0.0452886932,
-0.0006336244,
-0.0084626051,
-0.0006194524,
0.0480515137,
-0.100062497,
-0.0350368358,
-0.0165446457,
-0.0121646347,
-0.0181601048,
0.04432524,
0.0848018005,
0.0618549697,
0.0742754191,
0.0089237159,
0.0277655423,
-0.0339979082,
0.0242568608,
0.0077786045,
-0.000292309,
0.03437078,
0.0838205814,
-0.0203991793,
-0.000005772,
-0.0357505828,
0.0087609729,
0.0155245978,
0.0039339992,
0.0321744159,
0.0015313206,
-0.0237821043,
0.0295349434,
-0.0599194616,
0.0056594061,
-0.0167002566,
0.0362728648,
-0.0015301227,
-0.0391669087,
0.0021616193,
-0.0174899381,
-0.0197276454,
0.0723646358,
-0.0405694135,
-0.0358686596,
0.0229560155,
0.000691865,
-0.0372458771,
0.0000838062,
-0.058335308,
-0.0611278899,
-0.0126245422,
-0.0056036045,
-0.014156796,
0.0379788466,
0.0119540961,
0.015498668,
-0.1004846469,
0.0313217863,
2.406177473e-34,
0.0766666234,
-0.0003211196,
-0.014362298,
0.0109843295,
0.0356164612,
0.0094047012,
-0.0096705938,
-0.0249097627,
0.0358881205,
0.0106084784,
0.0048742262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06131v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06131v1 | Annotating Data for Fine-Tuning a Neural Ranker? Current Active Learning Strategies are not Better than Random Selection | 2023-09-12T11:17:42 | 2023-09-12T11:17:42 | Sophia Althammer, Guido Zuccon, Sebastian Hofstätter, Suzan Verberne, Allan Hanbury | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Search methods based on Pretrained Language Models (PLM) have demonstrated
great effectiveness gains compared to statistical and early neural ranking
models. However, fine-tuning PLM-based rankers requires a great amount of
annotated training data. Annotating data involves a large manual effort and
thus is expensive, especially in domain specific tasks. In this paper we
investigate fine-tuning PLM-based rankers under limited training data and
budget. We investigate two scenarios: fine-tuning a ranker from scratch, and
domain adaptation starting with a ranker already fine-tuned on general data,
and continuing fine-tuning on a target dataset. We observe a great variability
in effectiveness when fine-tuning on different randomly selected subsets of
training data. This suggests that it is possible to achieve effectiveness gains
by actively selecting a subset of the training data that has the most positive
effect on the rankers. This way, it would be possible to fine-tune effective
PLM rankers at a reduced annotation budget. To investigate this, we adapt
existing Active Learning (AL) strategies to the task of fine-tuning PLM rankers
and investigate their effectiveness, also considering annotation and
computational costs. Our extensive analysis shows that AL strategies do not
significantly outperform random selection of training subsets in terms of
effectiveness. We further find that gains provided by AL strategies come at the
expense of more assessments (thus higher annotation costs) and AL strategies
underperform random selection when comparing effectiveness given a fixed
annotation cost. Our results highlight that ``optimal'' subsets of training
data that provide high effectiveness at low annotation cost do exist, but
current mainstream AL strategies applied to PLM rankers are not capable of
identifying them. | [
0.0630178228,
0.0265724491,
-0.0161954947,
0.0004752997,
0.0468209311,
0.0218327865,
-0.004858226,
-0.0131526245,
0.0059971148,
-0.0845699608,
-0.062333554,
-0.0070872977,
-0.0070111598,
-0.0103006782,
0.0358457044,
-0.0233433489,
0.0280435216,
-0.026662441,
0.0415255129,
0.0097514363,
-0.0267168097,
-0.0149172526,
0.0012133837,
0.0522394665,
0.0613656342,
0.058781866,
0.0082404986,
0.0124862799,
0.0128177237,
-0.016730912,
0.0309246946,
0.0667437986,
0.0283807609,
0.0198498163,
0.0000021794,
-0.0251678061,
-0.0414254218,
-0.0224722903,
-0.0035067936,
0.0411398113,
-0.023434991,
0.0329244733,
0.0234917291,
0.0050619226,
-0.0519110076,
-0.0333167836,
0.0372731909,
-0.038052164,
0.057736747,
0.0494784974,
0.0073803985,
0.0106802536,
-0.0115664164,
-0.0742982402,
-0.0129571883,
-0.0906310901,
0.0171746854,
-0.0125847915,
-0.0266078357,
0.0436504707,
0.0007008653,
0.0268802308,
-0.0348228514,
-0.0273664184,
0.0536060855,
0.010188424,
-0.0896715447,
-0.0156776533,
0.0222634859,
0.0764795765,
-0.0482258201,
-0.0248884335,
-0.0091820359,
-0.0688547119,
0.0366562046,
0.0049981126,
-0.013197232,
-0.0001293855,
0.025218742,
0.0328396261,
0.0023437191,
0.0069571733,
0.0338932164,
0.0331288837,
-0.0203747023,
0.0212082025,
-0.0199447423,
-0.0797379389,
0.0577718168,
0.0271071922,
-0.0625723898,
0.0030975274,
0.0147703653,
0.0081732161,
-0.0300883409,
0.0100136241,
-0.0201794393,
-0.0426481478,
-0.0015986274,
-0.0503941923,
0.0496794358,
0.0338212922,
-0.0047419965,
0.0501361042,
-0.0315086879,
0.0204721298,
0.0372778513,
0.0362417623,
-0.0470705144,
0.0177781787,
-0.0095065664,
-0.0120962411,
-0.0390300602,
0.032015834,
-0.0100758467,
-0.0022854677,
-0.0786743835,
-0.0027913074,
-0.0015269601,
-0.0139997611,
0.0350021273,
-0.0101626338,
-0.0459471643,
0.0500527173,
-0.0140805636,
-0.0021121809,
0.0125334552,
0.0340325497,
-0.0112569975,
-0.028028192,
0.0066965776,
0.0175453518,
0.0096871061,
-0.0310208015,
0.0430068038,
0.0399705432,
-0.0077696471,
-0.0608587004,
-0.0026118401,
0.0306916442,
0.024880603,
-0.0082624005,
0.0251482315,
-0.0076166452,
-0.0192587897,
-0.0020416214,
0.0523548089,
-0.0383159481,
0.0041102748,
-0.0030375333,
-0.0399024412,
0.0560508743,
0.0015508428,
-0.0067949244,
0.029675588,
-0.0143189002,
-0.017638512,
0.0535779782,
0.015260295,
0.039090436,
0.046739988,
-0.0246582069,
-0.0246125832,
0.0270754863,
0.0160697699,
-0.0392341875,
0.016588049,
-0.0046324893,
-0.0355839171,
-0.0050490387,
-0.029076336,
-0.0216813907,
-0.0323671699,
0.027441388,
0.0433130972,
0.0061343894,
0.0425842702,
-0.02229237,
0.043424502,
-0.0189052653,
0.0433865786,
-0.0101289507,
-0.0241844282,
0.014009227,
-0.0267867241,
-0.0203404166,
0.0272889622,
0.0122426022,
-0.0284624286,
-0.0696544796,
-0.0141007332,
-0.0084760245,
-0.0153586175,
0.0342959166,
0.0537142232,
0.0177652668,
-0.0123420162,
0.0397723317,
0.0432915613,
-0.012985508,
-0.0064949528,
-0.0632955655,
-0.0219858643,
0.0447395965,
0.0178730618,
-0.079044722,
-0.0464643501,
-0.0014173539,
0.0452699065,
-0.0145028839,
0.0427951254,
-0.0191658828,
0.0111925127,
-0.0681165382,
-0.0420354567,
-0.0057968986,
0.0512649752,
0.0215242971,
0.0078793522,
-0.0060014185,
0.016409032,
-0.0446345061,
-0.0570464619,
0.0503532439,
-0.0008664472,
-0.016979605,
0.0355126075,
-0.0135345217,
0.0432457402,
-0.0249302834,
-0.0152164353,
0.0129557373,
0.0318443477,
-0.0214768946,
0.0153672192,
-0.0068790657,
0.0103348959,
0.03251395,
-0.005760733,
-0.0053030518,
-0.0168276951,
0.0620815754,
-0.0551123954,
-0.0128378291,
-0.0524944775,
-0.0206450671,
-0.0478106774,
-0.0364417396,
0.045851972,
-0.0531831756,
0.0007723613,
-0.0913112313,
0.0782230049,
0.0090579335,
0.0347372964,
0.064533785,
-0.0025515116,
-0.0004823437,
-0.0571717583,
-0.0653411746,
-0.0306455828,
-0.0175521839,
-0.0008003313,
0.0150678083,
0.0359950848,
-0.0033142758,
0.0000881785,
-0.0645230412,
0.0114771686,
-0.0240908209,
-0.0221490823,
0.0082042748,
0.0123089096,
0.0182343088,
-0.0224074759,
0.0216262843,
0.018305568,
-0.024849426,
0.0103030214,
0.0005593979,
0.0116622373,
0.0415609218,
-0.0900705159,
-0.0441300906,
0.0175524727,
0.0398283713,
0.0004870035,
-0.0258126389,
-0.0577919558,
0.0532632582,
-0.0389983915,
0.016750982,
-0.0039617787,
-0.0323239416,
0.0011255257,
-0.038779825,
-0.0515111238,
0.0761730075,
0.0255533922,
0.0370494761,
0.0611561574,
0.026672462,
-0.0661398768,
0.0071679861,
-0.0260566697,
0.0019369376,
-0.0187997986,
-0.0103069963,
0.0034528668,
0.0559989028,
-0.039878875,
-0.0173628181,
-0.0655100271,
0.0447828658,
-0.033082854,
-0.012825558,
-0.0663150698,
0.0344577841,
-0.0095709255,
0.0438473262,
0.0015792659,
-0.0428679585,
0.0556433201,
0.0008721768,
0.0148155112,
-0.05272891,
-0.0160773955,
-0.0273248367,
-0.0130538009,
0.032030683,
0.0095359087,
-0.0283632111,
0.0005247946,
-0.0539142266,
-0.0046772314,
0.0480521917,
-0.0348380767,
0.0171080772,
-0.0382339247,
0.0274015423,
-0.0257163309,
-0.0565945879,
-0.0250009242,
-0.0559980124,
0.0112002166,
0.0361519083,
0.038074784,
0.0263472497,
0.0018066107,
0.0370583944,
-0.0078265434,
0.0975245833,
-0.0159027185,
-0.0157609805,
-0.025300445,
0.0156311225,
0.0325480588,
0.0009492228,
0.0021565736,
-0.005147947,
-0.0205075331,
-0.013306872,
-0.002528541,
-0.0231374092,
-0.0102407876,
0.0133021362,
0.0635048822,
-0.0460843034,
-0.0188994687,
0.0183029659,
-0.0002660464,
-0.0124458754,
-0.0439155661,
0.1020748094,
0.0380665213,
-0.0547179282,
-0.0018554081,
-0.0010409626,
-0.0112771392,
0.0178255364,
0.0478087738,
-0.0304759294,
-0.0073821535,
-0.0083300462,
0.0737282485,
-0.0189754479,
-0.0066258716,
0.0201436672,
-0.1096238792,
0.0385172404,
0.0012029487,
-0.029666977,
0.0210635718,
-0.0204570368,
0.003807364,
-0.0359053127,
0.014784974,
-0.0070454176,
0.0024399348,
0.0142288962,
0.0494859964,
-0.0217040535,
-0.089434661,
-0.0098871421,
-0.0292022768,
0.02670338,
0.0519177504,
0.0507566333,
-0.0162362307,
-0.0017302934,
0.085051015,
-0.0261467118,
0.0299314298,
-0.0420610346,
0.0342327915,
0.0124260141,
-0.0197034404,
0.0297458638,
-0.0174132083,
0.0312300995,
0.013959866,
-0.0087016653,
0.0114177642,
-0.0403241813,
0.0365191512,
0.0088777011,
-0.0024318609,
-0.0183033608,
0.0170210507,
0.018906936,
-0.0383586176,
0.0116392951,
-0.0074785138,
0.0501381196,
-0.0514466278,
-0.0517744161,
0.0353643037,
-0.0292576551,
0.0030363947,
-0.0720499977,
-0.0248308834,
0.0397120304,
0.0536635071,
0.028544588,
0.0492683612,
-0.0118231121,
0.010016853,
-0.0137693696,
0.020519115,
-0.0004568171,
-0.0101102768,
-0.0118997525,
-0.0727274418,
0.0648736209,
-0.0463861302,
-0.0480597429,
-0.0218982901,
-0.0045355763,
-0.037395753,
0.0228456054,
0.1103052124,
0.0291383378,
0.0374690033,
-0.0264410228,
-0.0896908641,
0.0299961325,
0.0275361426,
0.0126915462,
-0.0000216476,
0.0348418057,
-0.0535653643,
-0.0328546315,
-0.0013286015,
-0.0958828405,
0.0263600852,
0.0614981055,
0.0374528095,
-0.0002938839,
-0.0452562757,
0.0075915838,
0.0016815407,
0.0972297564,
-0.0192102958,
-0.0619549155,
-0.0404018946,
0.0528122,
0.0226064771,
-0.0295066703,
-0.0461539142,
-0.001403411,
0.0358703434,
0.0453321934,
-0.0354174897,
0.0218071397,
0.0141299451,
0.0832218379,
-0.0942600816,
0.0094172917,
0.0087985266,
-0.0049091512,
-0.0126405247,
0.0093052872,
-0.0178918708,
0.0490370467,
0.0402764492,
0.0509029552,
-0.0208567623,
0.0095008248,
0.0058891126,
0.0492074303,
-0.0358136147,
0.0855494812,
-0.0634505376,
-0.0503765158,
-0.0613458306,
0.0156819634,
0.0767523646,
-0.0206957348,
0.0651465729,
0.025322333,
-0.0212991871,
0.0137021793,
-0.025176052,
0.0617776215,
-0.0125939585,
-0.0198436175,
0.0240949821,
0.0064980411,
0.0253938735,
0.0823976025,
0.0184000731,
0.019901637,
-0.0187786203,
-0.0336913355,
-0.023795316,
-0.0125210444,
0.0106383739,
0.0301531274,
-0.0226128027,
-0.0092307907,
-0.0043599219,
-0.0317188613,
-0.0342481658,
-0.0335314311,
-0.0188634265,
-0.0190799702,
0.034805648,
0.047133185,
-0.002737564,
0.0236543734,
-0.0585158765,
-0.0432537831,
0.0141083421,
0.016296396,
-0.0133790867,
-6.565864021e-33,
-0.0491221622,
0.0094909174,
-0.0227163136,
0.0290391352,
0.0080624586,
0.0299909357,
-0.0106463786,
-0.027226856,
-0.0067313472,
-0.0163915977,
-0.0085283099,
-0.0016140165,
0.0288217254,
-0.0030531397,
0.0092698708,
-0.0144003825,
0.0426429771,
0.0054663206,
-0.0482666381,
-0.0080716666,
0.0125212362,
0.041651208,
0.0130991368,
-0.0507690161,
0.0019607672,
0.0436343551,
-0.0330424346,
0.0117918486,
-0.0163184796,
0.0594579652,
0.0429728851,
0.0052697239,
0.0201540757,
-0.0316265039,
-0.0035843977,
-0.0306268968,
-0.0712390542,
-0.004468556,
0.001111937,
0.0042247595,
0.0123843756,
0.0227204114,
0.0381279141,
-0.006208491,
-0.0068658758,
0.0204020534,
0.0405608751,
-0.037214037,
-0.0542706288,
-0.0788405836,
-0.0437316336,
0.0196871534,
-0.0242178775,
0.0008398819,
0.0249251444,
0.0458499826,
-0.0259438343,
0.039425917,
-0.0540296622,
0.0096382871,
-0.0009968901,
0.0614606105,
0.0021606677,
0.0199299082,
-0.0194763392,
0.0457180552,
0.0143022472,
0.0201546643,
0.0435120016,
-0.0036893399,
0.0302771088,
0.0105001125,
0.0495108664,
-0.00012714,
0.0147634316,
0.0083579477,
-0.0797980204,
0.0506379306,
0.0383943021,
-0.0325587206,
0.0515344068,
0.0288530216,
-0.0115642166,
-0.0341675244,
-0.0258031096,
0.0006485909,
-0.0387408249,
-0.0294740498,
0.018453896,
0.0473268703,
-0.0828392655,
0.0038115885,
0.0306528937,
-0.0216506608,
-0.0016406253,
-0.0026959253,
-0.0087988758,
0.0126972031,
0.0027226147,
-0.0119693037,
-0.0262405388,
-0.0680770278,
0.0453152172,
-0.0133459819,
0.0228302125,
-0.0086910222,
0.0381323285,
0.0321539976,
-0.0007235395,
0.0102188895,
0.0046062493,
-0.0213983655,
-0.0310520139,
0.0918456763,
0.0013002295,
0.0055378829,
-0.00602774,
0.0458886661,
0.0492494442,
-0.0036076519,
-0.0126398876,
-0.0050307,
0.0238552038,
0.002352423,
-0.0344308503,
0.0009094435,
-0.0024959182,
0.0312974416,
-0.0047763386,
-0.0686360598,
-0.0129408957,
-0.0070563173,
2.806e-7,
0.0749543682,
0.051541429,
-0.0719354898,
-0.0275730062,
0.0309357736,
0.019124439,
-0.0212743189,
-0.0049522361,
0.0802669004,
0.0554911494,
0.02884892,
-0.0227191206,
0.0263080075,
-0.0060063917,
-0.0805414245,
-0.055840943,
-0.0496558286,
0.0096420934,
-0.021924017,
-0.0385459363,
-0.0116452826,
0.0934933275,
-0.0176588483,
-0.008915578,
-0.0246556308,
-0.055475466,
0.0354474075,
-0.0315117948,
0.0144642433,
0.0185857154,
0.0111558689,
0.0338630937,
-0.0504182912,
0.0133117372,
-0.0532388687,
0.0479687378,
0.061076358,
0.0608143471,
-0.0240734108,
-0.0048770811,
0.0071466668,
0.0441596061,
0.0340108983,
-0.0326887071,
0.0756093338,
-0.1018291116,
-0.022823235,
0.0397104248,
-0.0225281827,
-0.01969143,
0.010872677,
-0.0263436697,
-0.0025998622,
0.0153665328,
-0.0104524791,
0.0320354588,
-0.0609526969,
-0.095510371,
-0.0126828551,
-0.0282721035,
-0.0226241015,
-0.0653634816,
-0.0278955027,
0.0030969449,
-0.0052610799,
-0.034580946,
0.0223572087,
2.597180152e-34,
0.0295928996,
0.0054545552,
0.0280766506,
0.0166180711,
-0.0084905429,
0.0307383165,
-0.0009095742,
0.0212160703,
-0.0011020856,
-0.0761987269,
-0.0078830328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05960v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05960v1 | Fingerprint Attack: Client De-Anonymization in Federated Learning | 2023-09-12T11:10:30 | 2023-09-12T11:10:30 | Qiongkai Xu, Trevor Cohn, Olga Ohrimenko | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Federated Learning allows collaborative training without data sharing in
settings where participants do not trust the central server and one another.
Privacy can be further improved by ensuring that communication between the
participants and the server is anonymized through a shuffle; decoupling the
participant identity from their data. This paper seeks to examine whether such
a defense is adequate to guarantee anonymity, by proposing a novel
fingerprinting attack over gradients sent by the participants to the server. We
show that clustering of gradients can easily break the anonymization in an
empirical study of learning federated language models on two language corpora.
We then show that training with differential privacy can provide a practical
defense against our fingerprint attack. | [
0.0148440925,
0.0612756014,
-0.0293632802,
0.0617421605,
-0.0325266235,
-0.0062183412,
0.1236677542,
-0.0092776101,
0.0180503801,
-0.002142366,
-0.0256391652,
0.0059770211,
0.0179877989,
0.0066973814,
0.0524376258,
-0.0269712117,
0.0227237232,
-0.033235278,
-0.0465356298,
-0.05747547,
-0.0232766457,
-0.0104558561,
0.0214777756,
0.015758818,
0.0131698884,
-0.0681634545,
-0.0271349009,
-0.0207875296,
-0.0010641727,
0.0352885425,
0.0268548075,
0.0360006131,
0.0031497567,
0.0898189023,
0.0000017103,
0.0295033064,
-0.0700468644,
0.0303285029,
-0.0294133313,
0.0311414041,
-0.0396526232,
0.0469556451,
-0.0021876146,
0.0122548444,
-0.0431276187,
-0.0176424682,
0.0195862148,
0.0163487662,
0.0500894673,
0.0667615235,
0.0174654927,
-0.0465242863,
-0.0157831144,
-0.0267394911,
-0.0657513738,
0.0267104544,
-0.0177885201,
-0.0655204952,
-0.0638627559,
-0.0182795692,
0.0085483352,
0.034199357,
0.0071063787,
0.0391096771,
0.0004128881,
0.0282769352,
-0.0372063778,
0.0085243303,
-0.0115561308,
0.0438833758,
-0.0152712278,
0.0203210358,
0.0214216746,
0.0160152074,
-0.0009031951,
0.0437541716,
-0.0076161576,
0.0419812314,
-0.013853102,
0.0032361322,
-0.0273238104,
0.0035640488,
0.0446197055,
-0.0125835724,
0.0208858158,
0.0682149157,
-0.000182904,
0.0351858363,
-0.0719934031,
-0.0336791947,
-0.0066302349,
-0.0379290506,
0.0562697127,
0.0001489554,
0.0481595248,
-0.0083655408,
-0.0605590008,
-0.0733222589,
-0.0130935824,
0.0091641229,
0.0131461816,
-0.0556975007,
0.0216430873,
0.0311232843,
-0.02320664,
-0.0039987108,
-0.0124949962,
0.0387979448,
0.0189650822,
0.0226506945,
-0.0377578214,
0.0096374964,
-0.0074790996,
0.0763531402,
-0.0362217352,
0.0249437541,
-0.0216676258,
0.0294600762,
-0.0496748611,
0.018161945,
-0.0480532721,
0.0054781442,
0.006915946,
0.0008309901,
0.0214252304,
-0.016285561,
-0.0292715169,
-0.0098869046,
0.0225655027,
-0.0031329917,
-0.0130131152,
-0.0113983424,
-0.0240847245,
-0.0029655842,
-0.0270616598,
0.0765810385,
0.0253809374,
-0.004702033,
0.0032220413,
-0.0708160698,
0.0765443295,
-0.0262622368,
-0.0280673821,
-0.0672915876,
-0.0065748952,
-0.0264448971,
-0.0012123832,
-0.0416271612,
-0.0250434205,
-0.0431724526,
-0.0358524807,
0.053716775,
-0.0170950778,
-0.0153289353,
0.0231210869,
0.0274216104,
-0.0313610397,
0.0306516141,
0.0041053831,
0.0045758416,
0.0752126649,
-0.0087993396,
0.0051952242,
-0.0042462922,
0.0627183691,
0.0020109005,
0.0263064969,
-0.0056430758,
0.0164949968,
-0.0077312817,
-0.0433265604,
0.0286057387,
-0.0390847586,
-0.0816086829,
0.0525807738,
0.1135489568,
-0.0035504894,
0.0029404121,
-0.0523930341,
0.0020147597,
-0.0072456128,
0.0584185645,
-0.047430981,
-0.0295906756,
-0.0075905584,
-0.0550078377,
0.0041386583,
0.074548237,
-0.0417726301,
-0.0276397336,
0.0325068943,
-0.0608520284,
0.0088571552,
0.0260548014,
-0.02363584,
0.0147534171,
0.034762878,
0.0335869379,
0.0043260055,
-0.0311607067,
0.0035694703,
-0.0283835717,
0.0067952042,
0.0300296601,
0.072281979,
0.0105856294,
0.0048551993,
-0.041212488,
0.0070772455,
0.0085753994,
-0.0127237709,
-0.0145595707,
0.0817145631,
-0.0369177796,
-0.0509590544,
0.0561623499,
-0.0066579166,
0.0120921368,
-0.0119527318,
-0.0200185776,
-0.0105086369,
0.0081923027,
-0.0012151113,
0.0083760303,
-0.0076607484,
-0.0600221306,
0.0576237515,
0.0523307733,
0.0300594736,
0.0159128066,
-0.0077581867,
-0.0225115959,
0.0157487877,
0.0144333662,
-0.0274345446,
-0.0257801879,
0.057875488,
-0.0364995524,
-0.0270531457,
-0.0311970077,
0.0077436226,
0.0276687164,
-0.0295161922,
-0.0116108218,
0.0425673351,
0.026688775,
0.0134313656,
0.0345997512,
0.0009640152,
-0.0014668693,
0.0557256043,
-0.0401054248,
0.0034262617,
-0.0345961191,
0.012497982,
-0.057641115,
-0.0112998588,
0.014653217,
-0.0509226285,
0.0135270096,
0.0165461004,
-0.0025728988,
0.0047131437,
-0.0042089433,
-0.0028853058,
0.0274034198,
-0.0004621066,
0.0048053153,
-0.0031667906,
-0.019190222,
0.0512827896,
0.0130552342,
0.0319064148,
-0.0117323268,
-0.0559943169,
-0.0162513945,
-0.0139639676,
-0.0696036965,
0.0353105403,
0.0135797765,
0.0123534119,
-0.0523213968,
0.0190101415,
-0.0399050377,
0.0036265927,
0.0804261342,
-0.0126955267,
0.0027364048,
-0.0370174684,
-0.0312550142,
-0.0645862371,
0.0293669403,
0.0164548606,
0.0270438064,
0.0296302363,
0.0554504357,
-0.0093065212,
0.0746697485,
0.0165269896,
0.0405280516,
0.0329269506,
-0.0086265877,
-0.038897939,
-0.0150928115,
-0.0291013382,
0.0152886203,
-0.0410070531,
-0.0054402463,
0.04887297,
0.0256058592,
0.0134191876,
-0.0641724691,
0.0045996225,
0.0434868596,
-0.013098184,
-0.0122516481,
-0.0816821307,
0.0055717067,
0.0249654278,
-0.0078374427,
0.0335726477,
-0.0550541542,
0.0722246468,
-0.0189203694,
0.0514400043,
-0.0256688502,
-0.0693833977,
0.0043669082,
0.0352882817,
-0.0288382135,
0.0405563116,
0.0126883527,
-0.0499776118,
-0.0228231046,
0.008564312,
0.0715839863,
-0.0305165611,
-0.0437116213,
0.0167622715,
-0.0080844918,
0.0166908726,
-0.0215018317,
-0.0128902253,
-0.0880420357,
0.0254652742,
-0.0092667742,
-0.0278792977,
-0.0135911796,
0.0091098053,
0.0026682159,
0.0303694084,
-0.004553711,
-0.0411823168,
0.0220698863,
-0.0266532768,
0.0185611509,
-0.0317506604,
-0.0722287297,
0.0082217269,
-0.0417956077,
-0.003594002,
0.0547880232,
0.1095633283,
-0.0116284704,
0.0464691147,
-0.0569921844,
0.009616348,
-0.0269333236,
-0.0401022695,
-0.0210522581,
0.0215462372,
-0.0035987268,
0.0029029506,
0.0397467539,
-0.0142340362,
-0.0796406642,
-0.0003417619,
0.0311810225,
0.0601569302,
-0.0280575566,
0.0061837072,
-0.0889739767,
0.0102629093,
0.0086548235,
0.0764171854,
-0.0141526163,
-0.0234310851,
-0.0387596749,
-0.0337958336,
-0.0248548575,
0.0120443022,
-0.0320242681,
-0.0099872891,
-0.0329910181,
-0.0099697514,
0.0400802419,
0.0015907126,
-0.0583457276,
0.0262367167,
0.0106839249,
0.0457060784,
-0.0152218202,
-0.0336509384,
-0.0535981692,
-0.0385402478,
0.0565769598,
0.0146584604,
-0.0022626452,
0.0141678983,
-0.028282579,
-0.014378747,
0.0470457524,
-0.0357934088,
-0.0048739575,
0.0537725091,
-0.0283336416,
-0.0197111461,
0.0260247588,
0.0157441422,
0.0290552601,
0.0156410895,
0.0444148667,
0.0252369158,
-0.0135251926,
-0.0034302324,
0.0149578946,
-0.041149646,
0.0509839952,
0.0195359029,
0.0023809299,
0.0021658903,
0.009277666,
-0.0190106109,
0.0781551898,
0.0573460944,
0.0087111117,
0.0118729277,
-0.0268824901,
-0.0222074334,
-0.0471901409,
0.0179841332,
-0.0298233852,
0.0531833135,
0.0268122125,
0.0596371777,
0.056256339,
-0.0168212131,
-0.0076844613,
0.0222266968,
-0.0445464477,
0.0541600287,
-0.0699865669,
-0.0170066226,
-0.02666324,
0.019279588,
-0.0364064723,
0.0189358331,
-0.1033461466,
-0.0791597217,
0.0226057358,
0.0042940145,
0.0174946357,
0.0375331007,
-0.0309648309,
-0.078115873,
0.0825933889,
0.0150353936,
-0.0263001155,
0.0050355177,
0.051935602,
-0.0987770781,
0.0002897403,
0.0324418917,
-0.0189813245,
-0.0039165118,
0.0641043037,
-0.0462630242,
-0.0405746251,
-0.0131452456,
-0.0555132143,
0.0127411569,
0.1011850089,
0.0219522901,
0.0395772792,
-0.0093801152,
0.0609413236,
-0.0235833824,
-0.0047075362,
-0.0044599567,
-0.0118745146,
-0.0142017193,
-0.0016686823,
0.0467021801,
0.0160229895,
0.0553170592,
-0.0025638815,
-0.0277452506,
0.0065094805,
0.0154415974,
-0.012820865,
0.0161150564,
0.0265435819,
-0.0047413902,
0.0384554788,
0.0444040522,
0.0547695532,
-0.0134464577,
0.0026187401,
0.00923259,
0.0042757574,
0.0112693394,
0.03420588,
-0.085803695,
-0.0920062065,
0.0046065203,
-0.0009920311,
-0.0025016563,
0.0548250265,
-0.0302126706,
0.0072010695,
0.0129850665,
-0.0129328184,
-0.0156151801,
-0.0577316619,
-0.0499246046,
-0.0125127072,
-0.0161964446,
0.0084417779,
0.068812944,
0.0966246352,
0.0273061059,
0.0066122152,
-0.0317973793,
-0.0313824005,
-0.0363942906,
0.0037198768,
0.0355529077,
0.0600661002,
-0.0434467718,
-0.0171575304,
0.0158784557,
-0.0601108409,
-0.0367030539,
-0.0059832977,
0.0208542254,
0.0058696964,
-0.0116652763,
-0.0055090855,
0.0063385847,
0.0000439234,
-0.0954404473,
0.0766918659,
0.0059493822,
-0.0234346949,
0.0122359814,
-5.083692378e-33,
-0.010656368,
-0.0244809613,
-0.0293651298,
0.0384449549,
0.0133370012,
0.0638005659,
0.004170957,
-0.0038714404,
0.0046163793,
-0.0144460732,
-0.0410761833,
0.0283311773,
0.0085455505,
0.0458273329,
-0.0422863774,
-0.0163514409,
0.0303263571,
-0.030444432,
-0.0152091449,
0.0444889329,
0.0792881697,
0.0228946917,
0.0371665098,
-0.0519692041,
0.017562395,
-0.0249741804,
-0.0296749417,
0.0262996908,
-0.0435135774,
0.0206633415,
-0.0381554291,
-0.0181866512,
-0.0310792681,
0.0096270349,
-0.0334331095,
-0.0155694643,
-0.02814487,
-0.0202961639,
-0.0262760706,
0.0359676518,
0.0065139486,
-0.0310616009,
0.0462205447,
-0.0315799788,
0.0054237428,
0.0146043058,
0.0074358545,
0.0413207076,
-0.0397044308,
-0.0079089692,
0.0551337488,
0.0143766655,
0.0102582807,
0.0071170209,
0.0214958545,
-0.01157015,
0.024375353,
-0.0799350366,
-0.0494255126,
0.0155471554,
0.0041262731,
-0.0239325147,
0.0333758704,
0.0306289922,
0.0195483174,
0.0395797715,
0.0794068351,
0.0195402056,
-0.0225861166,
0.0043768152,
-0.0031089182,
0.0097704157,
0.019500751,
0.0211988352,
-0.0071148663,
-0.0132708978,
-0.0152246337,
0.0075852247,
0.0496568643,
-0.066210784,
0.0343132243,
0.0093503734,
-0.050645873,
-0.0272556562,
-0.0497696698,
-0.0618298315,
0.0167424288,
-0.0044122878,
-0.0224017929,
-0.0000811051,
-0.0162875615,
-0.0273546055,
0.0275338721,
-0.0462845564,
-0.0499144197,
0.0186311025,
0.0788943246,
0.0096287597,
0.0089598224,
-0.0121408403,
-0.0179588087,
0.0014778131,
-0.0380068049,
-0.0478611551,
0.0188787244,
0.0133140003,
0.069841817,
0.0039416454,
-0.0302122962,
-0.0255891513,
-0.0060104583,
0.0012838833,
0.0151368007,
0.017697366,
0.0476326793,
-0.0253910571,
0.0021458399,
0.0028032863,
0.0331324562,
0.0344254002,
-0.0171103086,
0.0328179635,
-0.0496060252,
0.0111208856,
0.013591229,
-0.0142195495,
-0.0041195103,
0.0590013787,
0.0803440213,
0.0021176413,
0.0302972253,
-0.0381125025,
2.439e-7,
-0.0518336631,
-0.0149683906,
-0.0051475912,
-0.0687276721,
0.0250810999,
0.0622632019,
0.0106254015,
0.0775604546,
-0.0376967378,
0.0208655484,
-0.0512821488,
-0.0021450114,
0.0306181349,
0.0165117476,
-0.0519349501,
-0.0143836224,
-0.0255101752,
0.0477148332,
-0.0513806567,
-0.0281068869,
-0.0617738329,
0.0466392115,
0.0932760835,
-0.0308229551,
-0.0118447393,
-0.005577195,
-0.0019750337,
-0.0274384506,
-0.0380198434,
-0.0275134891,
0.0454675816,
0.0580382012,
0.0223417841,
0.0028602926,
-0.0295747668,
0.0282698292,
-0.0381965674,
0.0035879309,
0.0349955969,
0.0516678914,
-0.0295873769,
-0.055129651,
-0.0413356759,
0.0084524825,
0.0338248536,
0.0101828687,
-0.0113136154,
-0.037404757,
0.0175937079,
-0.0742836744,
0.0641093627,
0.0035291701,
-0.0226528309,
0.0443406701,
-0.0041630035,
-0.0380550548,
0.0281836111,
-0.0668350309,
0.0000038997,
-0.042105712,
-0.0117948661,
-0.018289661,
0.0241582952,
0.0405644178,
0.0097834943,
0.0202206653,
0.0207605567,
2.024314919e-34,
-0.0197441317,
-0.0088500781,
-0.0076072863,
0.0153563572,
0.0147047099,
-0.0387371257,
0.0045540771,
-0.027632894,
0.0250315927,
-0.0029868751,
-0.020792162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06126v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06126v1 | AstroLLaMA: Towards Specialized Foundation Models in Astronomy | 2023-09-12T11:02:27 | 2023-09-12T11:02:27 | Tuan Dung Nguyen, Yuan-Sen Ting, Ioana Ciucă, Charlie O'Neill, Ze-Chang Sun, Maja Jabłońska, Sandor Kruk, Ernest Perkowski, Jack Miller, Jason Li, Josh Peek, Kartheik Iyer, Tomasz Różański, Pranav Khetarpal, Sharaf Zaman, David Brodrick, Sergio J. Rodríguez Méndez, Thang Bui, Alyssa Goodman, Alberto Accomazzi, Jill Naiman, Jesse Cranney, Kevin Schawinski, UniverseTBD | astro-ph.IM | astro-ph.IM, astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.GA, astro-ph.HE, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models excel in many human-language tasks but often falter in
highly specialized domains like scholarly astronomy. To bridge this gap, we
introduce AstroLLaMA, a 7-billion-parameter model fine-tuned from LLaMA-2 using
over 300,000 astronomy abstracts from arXiv. Optimized for traditional causal
language modeling, AstroLLaMA achieves a 30% lower perplexity than Llama-2,
showing marked domain adaptation. Our model generates more insightful and
scientifically relevant text completions and embedding extraction than
state-of-the-arts foundation models despite having significantly fewer
parameters. AstroLLaMA serves as a robust, domain-specific model with broad
fine-tuning potential. Its public release aims to spur astronomy-focused
research, including automatic paper summarization and conversational agent
development. | [
0.0508581698,
0.0607012548,
0.0291979071,
0.0030870135,
0.0114739956,
0.0003627202,
0.006556557,
-0.0015560796,
0.0269149989,
-0.0242316443,
-0.019769853,
-0.0083784079,
-0.0256631263,
0.021889776,
0.0006225866,
-0.0737636462,
0.0347083807,
-0.0408819579,
0.0734647587,
-0.0258120578,
-0.0076429849,
-0.0308263656,
0.0147715183,
0.0014602065,
0.0438010693,
-0.0243826862,
0.0236025695,
-0.0394121036,
0.0342639051,
-0.031306535,
-0.0015359508,
0.0711467192,
0.0179987587,
0.0714720413,
0.0000018117,
-0.0573909692,
-0.0035352693,
0.0107611055,
-0.0044805058,
0.0657882839,
0.0471602455,
-0.0340758972,
0.0261979122,
-0.0319846161,
-0.0245988872,
0.0060457988,
0.0300210807,
0.0389386751,
0.0207533073,
0.0344751999,
0.0036418417,
-0.0621681958,
0.0411593877,
-0.0625792667,
-0.0120514352,
-0.0226692334,
0.0472354293,
0.0197119154,
0.038563069,
0.0667107329,
-0.0202411953,
0.0569869354,
-0.0029773016,
-0.0276359394,
0.0601807535,
0.026883062,
-0.0352265388,
-0.0166915487,
0.0299678668,
0.0599007607,
0.0398165658,
-0.0552739464,
0.0260530803,
0.0004314459,
-0.0385817587,
0.052284725,
-0.1040915847,
0.0114445081,
0.0163826253,
-0.0256511699,
0.0424476862,
-0.0031601528,
0.0359907225,
0.0416282453,
-0.0177735947,
0.0780315027,
0.0258214716,
-0.0368984304,
-0.032871183,
0.0079762535,
-0.0093449466,
-0.0587350391,
0.0248127021,
0.0303520132,
-0.0277969409,
0.0165596362,
-0.0128468983,
-0.0448318236,
0.050502494,
-0.0251509249,
-0.0084848162,
0.0136233205,
-0.0050501497,
0.0867151096,
0.0246584471,
-0.0007129021,
-0.0151447384,
-0.0207532123,
0.0080356086,
-0.0287050102,
0.0049021407,
-0.0179816913,
-0.0178669542,
-0.0103673162,
-0.0070917015,
-0.0278546698,
-0.0145756425,
0.0033194828,
0.0419939347,
-0.0114254002,
0.0164750889,
0.0031087822,
-0.0744874999,
-0.0337099954,
-0.006864707,
0.0370060317,
-0.0426666066,
0.0284435209,
0.033109881,
-0.0186530091,
-0.0356505178,
0.0353444442,
-0.0068883947,
-0.0237538405,
0.0221474543,
0.0657172278,
0.0313562155,
-0.0744502246,
0.0505930856,
-0.0331291854,
0.0038964557,
-0.0692624897,
0.0082322415,
-0.0508274995,
0.0221344475,
0.0280601494,
-0.0107406192,
-0.0716033652,
0.0123959435,
0.0197499022,
-0.0628724545,
0.0086236959,
-0.0474421419,
-0.0101239635,
0.0174364336,
0.0150155816,
-0.0150324777,
0.0374104641,
0.0435217433,
0.0207578298,
0.0612136535,
-0.0122492006,
0.0053866487,
-0.0008366518,
0.0319049284,
-0.0032133416,
0.0168750081,
0.0141744744,
-0.0654727295,
0.0332026072,
0.0335410684,
0.0199314896,
-0.0343204476,
-0.0026048745,
-0.016071178,
0.0485107861,
0.0139522189,
0.0539435633,
0.0025183149,
-0.0193224624,
0.0348194987,
-0.0052647702,
-0.0264795162,
0.0666994601,
-0.0002991971,
0.0252413787,
0.0539645478,
0.017750347,
-0.0158051103,
-0.0195476152,
0.0207532365,
0.013634813,
-0.0334734581,
-0.0141700506,
0.0545489639,
-0.0100945281,
-0.0155266123,
0.0106722172,
0.0666764006,
-0.0358236805,
0.0343729071,
0.0298404861,
0.0593268238,
0.0145170344,
0.0646850318,
-0.0684501305,
-0.0212813951,
0.0153606487,
0.0451710746,
0.1019270942,
0.0375760347,
-0.0173548255,
-0.0193122718,
-0.0444567129,
-0.0497520715,
-0.0146156056,
0.0270975344,
0.0220718253,
0.0206829868,
-0.0335315764,
0.0172917079,
-0.0347127765,
-0.0351532996,
0.0287952125,
-0.0882535651,
-0.0564547628,
-0.0386322103,
-0.0318173468,
0.0316435024,
-0.00676458,
-0.0177429356,
0.0346505567,
0.0466477722,
-0.0371265784,
-0.0184828211,
0.0133693945,
0.0022914782,
-0.0139401602,
0.0505436473,
-0.0754703358,
-0.0043178448,
0.0290957429,
-0.0016690337,
-0.0550661832,
0.0639120638,
-0.010369204,
-0.0097826235,
0.0089196442,
0.0089079337,
-0.0020584436,
0.0245262403,
-0.0367389135,
0.0285152346,
-0.0111155091,
0.0339671895,
0.0381121598,
-0.0391506888,
0.0162505247,
-0.0492815822,
-0.0342698693,
-0.0209027026,
0.0374869257,
-0.025368778,
0.0377446264,
-0.0207070019,
-0.0047524143,
-0.0319153965,
-0.0332381427,
-0.0028771418,
-0.0025977055,
-0.011654214,
0.0295326263,
0.0045763464,
-0.0061892034,
-0.0024256036,
0.0095712934,
-0.0072262213,
0.005741959,
-0.0185771417,
0.0416035056,
0.0136418277,
-0.0157967005,
-0.0968922824,
-0.033611346,
-0.0366005637,
0.0149072111,
0.0495978892,
-0.0346744023,
-0.0404084697,
0.0233967658,
0.0116445543,
0.0031678916,
-0.045375023,
0.0063128192,
0.008174371,
-0.054803744,
-0.0293114427,
0.064987123,
-0.0059864246,
0.0032755241,
0.0429094881,
-0.0117259435,
-0.0208868328,
-0.0126624536,
-0.0522733554,
0.0371245742,
-0.0020693596,
0.0244634878,
0.0410752259,
0.056275025,
-0.0474681482,
-0.0214884356,
-0.0061517023,
0.0032711593,
-0.0043847091,
0.0099873142,
0.0235999245,
0.0081320908,
-0.0148155307,
0.024916498,
0.0140122222,
-0.0300865825,
0.0718653351,
-0.0461903475,
-0.0150671098,
-0.0465217717,
0.0016729333,
-0.0691967532,
-0.0294750407,
0.0028622791,
0.0012472529,
0.0210949723,
-0.0179817453,
-0.0360556506,
0.0150939142,
-0.0201080944,
0.0258344766,
0.0390408672,
-0.0452786908,
0.018166732,
-0.011066528,
-0.0098399036,
0.0060983654,
-0.0371666439,
-0.0501396284,
0.0465795547,
0.0128860949,
-0.0533524714,
-0.0933316574,
-0.0237458274,
0.0333904102,
-0.0032655944,
-0.0413162708,
-0.0118269492,
-0.0549279265,
0.0164256617,
0.1043099761,
0.0181921516,
0.0324191041,
-0.0389968678,
0.0162914954,
0.0298959594,
-0.0027884787,
-0.0190223437,
0.0193277486,
-0.0327188075,
0.0347918831,
-0.0576632172,
-0.0105625242,
-0.030865021,
0.0442912057,
-0.0182227865,
0.0061506159,
0.1093053445,
0.0180486497,
-0.0342302285,
-0.013718619,
-0.0131208021,
0.0444709398,
0.028176358,
0.019275425,
-0.0662847683,
-0.0014067225,
-0.0237300806,
0.0041724448,
0.048884023,
-0.0350526087,
-0.0031983668,
-0.0343711115,
0.0310935304,
0.0238291714,
-0.0416244566,
-0.012985914,
-0.0532524139,
0.0043421215,
-0.0314889364,
-0.0339890718,
0.0255186614,
-0.018746933,
0.0083436025,
0.0117841465,
0.0130052613,
-0.0353574306,
0.0157930963,
-0.0299207531,
0.0145804891,
-0.0121992258,
0.0390887111,
-0.0210798252,
0.0005603746,
-0.02743016,
-0.008610243,
-0.0181494486,
0.0014285531,
0.0306826159,
0.017586045,
0.0021102098,
-0.0038192938,
0.0863766968,
-0.0483582243,
0.0009225403,
0.0220727175,
0.0714757964,
-0.0091395564,
-0.0101944879,
-0.063762553,
-0.0053907302,
-0.0210716501,
0.0687407702,
0.0186812505,
-0.0047543361,
-0.0506954417,
-0.0350076929,
-0.0215080455,
-0.0329618938,
-0.037172839,
-0.0458170846,
0.0206191111,
-0.0249658339,
-0.0296488311,
-0.0403924063,
0.0030017286,
0.0113199893,
0.0251420476,
0.0278995428,
0.0072025582,
-0.029556293,
0.009750546,
0.0226145536,
-0.0341321416,
-0.0109186135,
-0.0672128648,
-0.0108487234,
0.0569591783,
0.0024812091,
-0.0326842219,
-0.0160645824,
-0.0384926461,
-0.0530411229,
-0.0250911061,
0.0215783585,
0.0274468176,
0.0211581383,
-0.0308754612,
-0.0882901326,
0.0256050359,
0.0051768846,
0.0109511921,
0.0277945027,
-0.0074722953,
-0.0350627191,
-0.0007979314,
0.0111874938,
-0.0314702839,
0.0270898361,
-0.0325437561,
0.0210522339,
-0.0522733033,
-0.0332813635,
0.0116642639,
0.0252218265,
0.038251128,
-0.0518240109,
-0.0065793493,
-0.0187376253,
-0.0212221127,
-0.0496272482,
0.0264841877,
-0.0105050709,
0.0406852253,
0.0179728698,
0.0202719569,
0.0251880493,
0.0389562696,
-0.0281573962,
0.021431474,
-0.0434071124,
0.0407431275,
-0.025674358,
0.0042884452,
0.0145448074,
-0.0091699567,
-0.0077027455,
-0.0408416018,
-0.0512119755,
0.0317772292,
-0.005699764,
0.0168070327,
0.0531855151,
0.0199066345,
-0.0058708698,
0.031230092,
-0.1299748868,
-0.0313974209,
-0.0209509749,
0.041987855,
0.0448512957,
0.0076886406,
0.042235449,
-0.0567532368,
-0.0350737758,
-0.0077544046,
0.0232814047,
0.0388277955,
0.0083040008,
0.0774108842,
0.0210515801,
-0.0178355519,
-0.0182480738,
0.1166114211,
0.0252047479,
0.0268393215,
-0.0003177155,
0.0301340744,
-0.0171009507,
-0.049248714,
-0.0648441762,
0.0261335541,
-0.0279568043,
0.0083477404,
-0.0574262589,
0.007555821,
0.0075603528,
-0.0076634828,
-0.0498753302,
-0.074363023,
0.0224844348,
0.0325363241,
-0.0342421681,
-0.0041619288,
-0.0279824883,
0.0258561764,
-0.0520342886,
-0.0478987955,
-0.022630319,
-6.14175521e-33,
-0.0310845897,
0.008001917,
0.023916563,
0.0254458878,
-0.0004803201,
-0.0114982147,
-0.0893838108,
-0.0150011266,
-0.0244075116,
0.0234534126,
-0.0061105606,
0.0232452527,
-0.0137164211,
0.0145518836,
0.0279355925,
0.0355687104,
0.0382725373,
0.0087611191,
-0.0136617459,
0.0414318629,
0.0494683795,
0.0218223222,
0.0108659081,
-0.1130968779,
0.0124758687,
0.0151812406,
0.0156482812,
0.0188604537,
0.0103607215,
0.0597726032,
-0.0581659116,
0.0073992889,
-0.0147057567,
-0.0340858474,
-0.0151774799,
0.0075270855,
-0.054871913,
-0.0285740141,
0.0326570608,
-0.0061811409,
-0.0161780585,
-0.0549210161,
0.0072696921,
-0.0068453536,
0.0074673165,
-0.0323621929,
0.0636185557,
-0.0228430629,
-0.0608927272,
-0.0211814102,
-0.051741913,
0.0247523952,
-0.0221723467,
0.0133725693,
0.0301933121,
0.0209664702,
0.0042851139,
0.1444094479,
0.0060490309,
0.0486951135,
0.0233558603,
0.0318736471,
-0.0023740961,
-0.0247367267,
0.0263745412,
0.0569747761,
-0.0285269655,
-0.0087580383,
0.0218326263,
0.0081912,
-0.0082893288,
0.0400922932,
0.032163363,
0.0366979465,
0.0150838131,
0.0107888589,
-0.0797503591,
0.0207488295,
0.0205976833,
0.0226727761,
-0.0008098694,
0.0449676663,
0.0155760245,
0.0090944264,
0.0130807692,
-0.0375931822,
0.0086490391,
-0.029262891,
-0.010684506,
-0.011045808,
-0.0213223323,
-0.0044178967,
0.0046338979,
-0.0622276999,
-0.0286994595,
0.0738495067,
-0.0273728985,
0.0291970484,
0.0174008813,
-0.0050203535,
-0.1045577154,
-0.0213579591,
0.0245206654,
0.0111428834,
-0.0080143567,
0.0147426715,
0.0153152216,
0.0048179412,
-0.0096928431,
-0.0108167958,
0.0139078265,
-0.0413338989,
0.0428135954,
0.0134420795,
0.0012521457,
0.0272568408,
0.0225025173,
0.0843897089,
0.0303156376,
0.0480745621,
0.0107482933,
0.0021498504,
0.004898157,
0.0267957635,
-0.0168035198,
-0.0324890353,
-0.022740623,
-0.0187848825,
0.0286193117,
-0.0619806647,
-0.0066595469,
-0.0165832862,
2.516e-7,
0.0499212332,
0.071423851,
0.0512056276,
-0.0073498078,
0.0436516516,
0.0134659819,
-0.0180955045,
0.0126476726,
0.0388912708,
0.0446389019,
-0.0136758285,
-0.0368487462,
0.0213642158,
0.0166341476,
-0.1010837257,
-0.0309396982,
-0.0489361547,
-0.061295487,
-0.0486210659,
-0.04041012,
0.0146820918,
0.074259609,
-0.0135430703,
0.0110161277,
0.0096666263,
-0.060075853,
0.0659930483,
-0.0118763661,
0.0114734378,
0.061471343,
-0.0113348048,
0.0337940305,
-0.0120795136,
-0.0075846538,
-0.0141815655,
0.0657236949,
0.0286043584,
0.078319706,
0.0213776063,
0.0053640767,
0.0453464389,
-0.0340998173,
0.0387832187,
-0.0215481836,
0.0358983241,
-0.048744075,
-0.042785462,
-0.0063360073,
-0.0533497334,
-0.0037497047,
-0.0082844961,
-0.0278065987,
-0.006241831,
-0.0033834216,
-0.0222855881,
-0.0052217748,
0.0058223177,
-0.0778954253,
-0.0355023853,
0.0410169736,
-0.0442697592,
-0.0335383788,
-0.0141440434,
-0.0680270121,
0.020631399,
-0.0078896005,
0.000755631,
2.404028752e-34,
0.0987722576,
-0.0056038946,
-0.0287032127,
0.0252032559,
0.0220902152,
-0.0236250311,
0.0079703191,
0.0225730184,
0.0521745831,
-0.1163306162,
0.0045904755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06112v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06112v1 | Characterizing Latent Perspectives of Media Houses Towards Public Figures | 2023-09-12T10:27:39 | 2023-09-12T10:27:39 | Sharath Srivatsa, Srinath Srinivasa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Media houses reporting on public figures, often come with their own biases
stemming from their respective worldviews. A characterization of these
underlying patterns helps us in better understanding and interpreting news
stories. For this, we need diverse or subjective summarizations, which may not
be amenable for classifying into predefined class labels. This work proposes a
zero-shot approach for non-extractive or generative characterizations of person
entities from a corpus using GPT-2. We use well-articulated articles from
several well-known news media houses as a corpus to build a sound argument for
this approach. First, we fine-tune a GPT-2 pre-trained language model with a
corpus where specific person entities are characterized. Second, we further
fine-tune this with demonstrations of person entity characterizations, created
from a corpus of programmatically constructed characterizations. This twice
fine-tuned model is primed with manual prompts consisting of entity names that
were not previously encountered in the second fine-tuning, to generate a simple
sentence about the entity. The results were encouraging, when compared against
actual characterizations from the corpus. | [
0.0447936319,
0.0891784206,
0.0067975228,
0.0150300767,
0.0217893254,
0.0376316234,
-0.0118265944,
-0.0155589888,
-0.0262375642,
-0.0726104528,
0.0355681144,
-0.025364507,
-0.0237936955,
-0.0030539182,
0.0208956469,
-0.1163880453,
0.0309717059,
0.0563566275,
0.0448929258,
0.0037366513,
0.0400202125,
0.0574869774,
-0.0060706218,
0.0193585381,
-0.0210300814,
-0.0320776999,
-0.0090485923,
0.0081528742,
0.0763609856,
-0.0140630035,
-0.0292012133,
0.0510254204,
0.0571487322,
-0.0061830957,
0.000001805,
-0.032376416,
0.005647297,
-0.0165778864,
0.0483425818,
-0.0285572223,
0.0445447415,
-0.0283132605,
-0.0073490036,
-0.0101173269,
-0.0106331827,
-0.0406904407,
0.0205137432,
0.0362814404,
0.0693311989,
0.0963852331,
-0.0222296845,
-0.0319903642,
-0.011593882,
-0.0153197637,
0.016075585,
-0.0337425768,
0.0265582893,
-0.0585698485,
-0.052521199,
0.0308291204,
0.0202255566,
-0.0202897061,
-0.0211526081,
0.0235093664,
0.0051453449,
0.0081646638,
-0.0576187931,
-0.0203223936,
0.0228639115,
0.0549883246,
0.0423048064,
-0.0060572885,
0.033021424,
-0.0188625548,
0.0014601488,
0.0341940001,
0.0112460759,
0.0645190179,
-0.0110523645,
0.0142755043,
-0.0223694928,
-0.0040542423,
-0.0116795273,
0.0185255874,
-0.0258330796,
-0.0132356603,
0.0133889904,
-0.0089098494,
0.0098452326,
0.027682716,
-0.0362943597,
-0.0617828444,
-0.0372443311,
0.0186879989,
0.0236725286,
0.0239975732,
-0.0086283693,
-0.0104466705,
-0.0276722629,
-0.0468010008,
-0.0392361805,
0.0034411866,
0.0095441733,
0.0248397496,
0.0475732647,
-0.0085410681,
-0.0063621202,
-0.0363432504,
0.0108103817,
-0.0027147236,
-0.0580838397,
0.0064495276,
-0.0259972177,
0.0469918065,
0.0232582092,
-0.0058640121,
-0.0230364855,
-0.00350729,
-0.0079540536,
0.0104914065,
-0.0508846194,
0.0273838528,
-0.0358200781,
-0.012683305,
-0.0630236194,
0.032868363,
-0.0599691421,
-0.0078103021,
-0.014590702,
0.0056892764,
0.0014088361,
0.0344385169,
0.0097615467,
0.0017544843,
-0.0000847391,
-0.0047932644,
-0.00815049,
-0.053662125,
0.0068581379,
-0.022137953,
-0.016098259,
-0.0918337852,
-0.0049993438,
-0.0380964763,
0.0120997038,
-0.011811248,
0.0103510907,
-0.0422920994,
0.000119353,
-0.0003672237,
-0.025239693,
0.0666119307,
0.0349990651,
0.0163465608,
0.0414332449,
0.0455911867,
0.0507537499,
0.0936335251,
0.0435005538,
0.0260843784,
0.0213458557,
0.0042275838,
0.0169696305,
0.0195525344,
0.0061094468,
0.0023632057,
0.0021582097,
0.0158286747,
-0.0474103466,
0.0326708779,
0.0346873775,
0.0150397895,
-0.0187166873,
0.0373188704,
0.0478104204,
0.0499827005,
-0.0322576612,
0.0153076518,
0.0664840117,
0.01847063,
0.023519747,
0.0540095605,
-0.0381249599,
0.0164226666,
0.0211190078,
-0.0129399132,
-0.0119322771,
0.0449437685,
-0.0475760363,
-0.0009794598,
0.0210075751,
-0.014184121,
0.0206134114,
-0.0114930719,
0.0131447492,
0.0004256001,
-0.0731662065,
0.0482284613,
0.0359903015,
-0.0623319522,
0.0096369134,
-0.0338191278,
0.0087596811,
0.0038567446,
0.0317530818,
0.0058562486,
0.0284152366,
-0.0362402871,
-0.0037631649,
0.0416350216,
0.0217141677,
-0.0257101078,
0.0002238159,
0.0039994018,
0.0047300458,
-0.0261558741,
0.0494663939,
0.0602663308,
0.0213396307,
0.0477796197,
0.0384591706,
-0.0090512475,
0.0238683652,
0.0221234635,
0.0303909276,
-0.0529823825,
-0.0234286766,
0.0295307208,
0.0132441325,
0.0586385466,
-0.0091771102,
-0.0514910184,
0.0151726557,
0.0209971685,
0.0226873588,
0.0132473493,
-0.0351232663,
-0.0025495107,
-0.0303235687,
-0.067365475,
-0.0427173413,
0.0282199774,
-0.0152114965,
-0.0524536744,
0.023973247,
0.0031541781,
0.0135104908,
-0.0640703365,
-0.010969759,
-0.0142466016,
-0.0151073514,
-0.0184721891,
0.1016387418,
0.0462001786,
-0.0085447459,
0.0037651951,
-0.0107168173,
0.0059645758,
-0.0485399626,
-0.0540989749,
-0.0133242831,
0.0337028615,
0.0204091445,
0.0418829769,
-0.0432473347,
-0.0263171308,
-0.0246693902,
-0.0893534794,
0.0253706165,
-0.0262706559,
0.010424017,
0.0387682915,
0.0216687191,
-0.0147877419,
0.0191395935,
-0.0365944952,
-0.0274778567,
-0.0170859527,
-0.0122267669,
0.0309041645,
0.0205589961,
0.0055926396,
-0.0029279366,
0.0386996605,
-0.0630752444,
0.0206463374,
0.0142903654,
-0.0117825456,
-0.0092570372,
0.0455215983,
-0.040051572,
0.0159418583,
0.012647029,
-0.0157778244,
0.0388275534,
0.0211861487,
0.0022034193,
0.086101763,
0.0570767187,
0.070126988,
-0.0107350331,
0.0100731626,
0.001686016,
0.0032020486,
-0.0418117046,
0.0026895041,
-0.0141753601,
-0.0272307638,
0.0200933181,
0.0259107575,
0.005641677,
-0.0117240883,
-0.0821797773,
0.0775323734,
0.0101111112,
-0.0169214662,
0.0371667072,
-0.0103266342,
-0.0171632133,
0.0475597121,
0.0050984998,
0.0300861336,
0.0392377488,
-0.0238897279,
0.0496621504,
0.0197721738,
0.0097459527,
-0.0323305428,
0.0423028283,
0.0359599143,
0.0294906888,
0.0210068338,
-0.0439966545,
-0.0495707579,
-0.0292373225,
0.0519718118,
-0.0044822255,
0.021322757,
-0.0111709237,
0.0070234374,
-0.0133982804,
-0.0238342751,
-0.0049269921,
-0.0544232763,
-0.0190883614,
0.0005224083,
0.0105772298,
-0.0249946322,
-0.0539949127,
0.0249233302,
-0.0029245422,
-0.0355661809,
-0.0204616282,
0.0170543306,
-0.0152468439,
0.0314053483,
0.0177700948,
0.0273635797,
-0.0285337716,
0.0020672895,
-0.0042432235,
0.0047812867,
-0.0255840328,
0.0531548895,
-0.0201046336,
-0.0040700929,
-0.0058519808,
-0.0439538285,
-0.0243053716,
0.0006715674,
0.0749370605,
-0.0041113412,
0.0150711536,
0.1280731261,
0.0290867314,
-0.0669157207,
-0.0108589204,
0.0862649456,
-0.0239318646,
0.0167332143,
0.0217669196,
-0.1061067805,
0.0239041653,
-0.0054630167,
0.0045197029,
-0.0479008257,
-0.0522313341,
-0.0480940156,
-0.1255858988,
0.040457394,
-0.0218385775,
-0.0234388337,
0.0014661897,
-0.0365363024,
-0.0052248687,
-0.0309136547,
-0.02982332,
0.0023729566,
-0.0086473757,
0.0152162593,
0.00234331,
-0.0367428921,
-0.0476344749,
0.0516498089,
-0.0270242188,
0.0144436341,
0.0424771979,
0.0556654558,
0.003125417,
0.0265471078,
-0.0543925054,
-0.0542561226,
-0.0093332259,
0.0330008902,
0.0720432997,
-0.0934196338,
-0.0101723773,
-0.0393001623,
0.0377915353,
0.0474852771,
-0.0150022712,
-0.0218785461,
0.015244754,
-0.0008976315,
-0.0192642305,
-0.0307438001,
0.0204957295,
0.0464892648,
0.0679527372,
0.0347509794,
-0.0312084053,
0.0052332301,
-0.0025753283,
0.0406962968,
-0.0340508372,
-0.0503357835,
0.0018679987,
-0.0346041583,
-0.0422683284,
-0.0213082209,
-0.0920672044,
0.0261141378,
0.0495832078,
-0.0085440008,
-0.0205834061,
0.0043671965,
0.0379135236,
-0.027035322,
0.0511045642,
0.0142878536,
-0.0295169353,
-0.0083897701,
-0.0632185638,
0.0539935529,
0.0232544523,
-0.0384911783,
-0.0002025348,
-0.0462127961,
-0.0643700883,
0.0009466864,
-0.003178379,
0.026952032,
0.0483895242,
-0.0073139933,
-0.0496716835,
0.0374822356,
0.0455275401,
-0.0192885902,
0.0078446222,
-0.0199091937,
0.0274773538,
-0.0214744527,
0.0077763819,
-0.0227469634,
0.0630373955,
-0.0249884464,
-0.0427274853,
-0.0845521912,
-0.0352386646,
0.0061036847,
-0.0125165405,
0.0414268821,
-0.0226583648,
0.000380136,
-0.0448970608,
-0.0697296262,
-0.0664176419,
-0.0150613757,
-0.009648012,
-0.0105649168,
0.0047259005,
0.0048530209,
-0.0521216542,
0.014711895,
-0.0815706998,
0.0841842368,
-0.0699872151,
-0.0030130104,
0.0321148671,
-0.0398403518,
-0.020218689,
-0.0207658727,
-0.0083313985,
0.0121767595,
-0.0237487722,
-0.0007357632,
-0.0041786418,
0.0220267791,
0.0276204832,
0.0632584393,
0.0275165699,
0.0042097103,
-0.0458486825,
0.0192637444,
-0.0640289262,
0.0417774469,
0.0089326892,
-0.0297248792,
0.0428008512,
0.0335712843,
-0.011746862,
0.048586864,
0.0176622104,
-0.0087300716,
-0.031287618,
0.0599728599,
0.0459398441,
-0.0135617806,
-0.0085948557,
0.045907747,
0.0136154471,
0.0016210197,
0.0434620976,
-0.0089688087,
-0.0393640175,
-0.0070198486,
0.0196073931,
-0.0005807698,
0.0202606618,
-0.0033504227,
-0.0702787414,
-0.0359573662,
0.0055350168,
0.0000714659,
0.0018392414,
0.0116054639,
0.0093639195,
0.0564661995,
0.0058126329,
-0.0098476904,
-0.038322527,
-0.0446958728,
-0.0359654985,
-0.0409577452,
0.0298946016,
-6.343165147e-33,
-0.060509719,
-0.0181826018,
-0.0122437961,
0.00247282,
-0.0377929248,
-0.0147900414,
-0.0141685698,
0.0103420895,
-0.0185353179,
0.0014851763,
-0.0133442841,
0.0127776591,
0.0123337042,
-0.0132426722,
-0.0080368957,
0.0395431481,
0.0363132209,
-0.0121665364,
-0.0713700205,
0.046081692,
0.027538918,
-0.0007949462,
0.0581400357,
-0.0733883008,
0.0502107032,
-0.0398856141,
-0.071325466,
-0.0308900289,
0.068220526,
0.0273293126,
-0.0142553141,
0.0013750708,
0.0311833266,
-0.0162280761,
0.0134894904,
0.0923385993,
-0.0762326047,
-0.0203405675,
0.0255878158,
0.0066216136,
0.032682661,
-0.029337015,
-0.0037829834,
-0.0268776082,
0.0041752411,
-0.0078625232,
0.0909667388,
0.0095543563,
0.0525550507,
-0.0372951366,
-0.0728005022,
0.0052124076,
-0.0408960208,
0.0189364571,
-0.0059469892,
-0.0142765734,
0.0162139926,
0.0497096591,
-0.0708306357,
-0.0052808197,
0.0202755202,
0.0159634314,
0.0040176949,
0.0146582881,
0.002263624,
0.0529891104,
0.0266845077,
0.0156596135,
-0.0891260058,
0.0241786595,
0.0508922823,
0.0099721542,
-0.0278544035,
0.0888506174,
0.045014102,
-0.0340277404,
-0.0684778616,
0.0245691389,
0.0355016068,
-0.0003589682,
-0.0024908006,
-0.0369037539,
0.0217270628,
-0.0112751089,
-0.025261214,
-0.0881495401,
-0.0380562879,
-0.0429324098,
0.000604703,
0.0000934611,
-0.0485710502,
0.0426345542,
0.0325033069,
-0.0210405458,
-0.011315573,
0.0085308924,
-0.0593527593,
0.0192138795,
-0.0044513713,
0.0137807596,
-0.0510677882,
-0.0183891896,
0.0545825772,
0.058047846,
0.0336254127,
-0.0141541166,
0.0009316852,
0.0211257078,
-0.0452706069,
-0.0174162555,
0.0052239881,
0.0111660091,
-0.0522394069,
0.0512311161,
0.0018700332,
0.0059971176,
-0.0079765823,
-0.0064533018,
0.0164646842,
-0.0268661007,
0.0009348348,
0.0241119452,
0.0039800932,
0.0159085672,
-0.0248547979,
-0.018225817,
0.0308498535,
-0.0031292513,
0.0869681314,
-0.0442604683,
-0.0242554601,
-0.0040643332,
2.598e-7,
0.0337272398,
0.018472502,
0.0080814045,
0.0262962021,
0.0169871766,
0.0375535563,
0.0240507852,
0.0571818464,
-0.005850187,
-0.0784250647,
0.0199371241,
0.0089747263,
0.0146268848,
0.0385898761,
-0.1072378457,
0.0301766247,
-0.0305850226,
0.007331355,
-0.0640188381,
0.0122641325,
0.0472742692,
0.0504840724,
0.0151794879,
0.0027740584,
-0.006529856,
-0.0159508772,
0.0582772829,
-0.0011067035,
-0.0549353994,
0.0141042545,
0.0114552639,
0.0506107211,
-0.0185608361,
0.0218414906,
0.0048834626,
0.0364921503,
0.0251729414,
0.0509720035,
-0.0140277147,
-0.0296237338,
0.006500225,
-0.0008422109,
-0.0098849507,
-0.0118605038,
0.0891444013,
-0.0550095998,
-0.068710193,
-0.031937167,
-0.0717422441,
-0.0079374155,
0.003007503,
0.0121742543,
-0.0256695747,
0.0235791951,
-0.0082828645,
-0.0262249038,
0.0098566273,
-0.0791794881,
0.012205191,
0.0124477223,
-0.0239848215,
-0.0337726399,
0.0317226648,
-0.0406336449,
0.0220129825,
-0.0495386533,
0.0149427792,
2.083673251e-34,
0.0265966281,
0.0488797575,
-0.0356394127,
-0.0269498657,
0.0283066891,
0.0162508879,
-0.0413887575,
-0.0623176657,
0.0076761954,
-0.0505163819,
-0.0064649167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06105v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06105v1 | Towards Visual Taxonomy Expansion | 2023-09-12T10:17:28 | 2023-09-12T10:17:28 | Tinghui Zhu, Jingping Liu, Jiaqing Liang, Haiyun Jiang, Yanghua Xiao, Zongyu Wang, Rui Xie, Yunsen Xian | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Taxonomy expansion task is essential in organizing the ever-increasing volume
of new concepts into existing taxonomies. Most existing methods focus
exclusively on using textual semantics, leading to an inability to generalize
to unseen terms and the "Prototypical Hypernym Problem." In this paper, we
propose Visual Taxonomy Expansion (VTE), introducing visual features into the
taxonomy expansion task. We propose a textual hypernymy learning task and a
visual prototype learning task to cluster textual and visual semantics. In
addition to the tasks on respective modalities, we introduce a hyper-proto
constraint that integrates textual and visual semantics to produce fine-grained
visual semantics. Our method is evaluated on two datasets, where we obtain
compelling results. Specifically, on the Chinese taxonomy dataset, our method
significantly improves accuracy by 8.75 %. Additionally, our approach performs
better than ChatGPT on the Chinese taxonomy dataset. | [
0.0329770632,
0.0491666719,
-0.0130278561,
0.0259066056,
0.0153282685,
0.0072844289,
-0.0337674543,
0.0464804396,
-0.0268872436,
-0.0327001661,
-0.0227499995,
-0.0159302242,
-0.0029759172,
0.0542029068,
0.0422344878,
-0.1016843617,
0.0104622263,
0.0170881338,
-0.0217090324,
0.0033709542,
0.0212711208,
0.0016602715,
0.0023262037,
0.0177089963,
-0.0655260906,
-0.0029653131,
-0.0279201642,
0.0078824935,
0.0121455146,
-0.0220820978,
-0.0357050933,
0.0078806765,
0.0729928166,
0.035270974,
0.000001616,
-0.0531531684,
-0.0106703173,
-0.0145654976,
0.0494617298,
-0.0131861633,
0.0563425608,
-0.0690620318,
0.0513184331,
-0.0367987044,
-0.0004742207,
-0.0387732983,
0.0735859796,
0.0392063297,
0.0348798707,
-0.0031635906,
-0.0315181501,
-0.0000437664,
0.0535702631,
-0.0208479818,
0.0307381116,
-0.0224705897,
-0.0059489361,
0.0468567908,
-0.0449424125,
0.0111096315,
-0.036521174,
0.0127894282,
-0.0019162484,
-0.001044108,
0.0281744692,
0.043905396,
-0.0238164682,
-0.0467478819,
-0.0132068973,
0.0742340311,
-0.0326006114,
0.0109466016,
0.0165513419,
0.0061437818,
0.0001841716,
0.0657371879,
-0.0321294963,
0.0203230847,
-0.031251207,
-0.0235793721,
-0.0039403229,
-0.0231914017,
0.0089693544,
0.0120024597,
-0.0004875814,
-0.0359893404,
0.0218989681,
-0.0026096243,
-0.0098027149,
-0.000157433,
-0.0711903721,
-0.010411161,
-0.043151699,
0.022108404,
0.0115319267,
0.0287409425,
0.0023638438,
0.0265414491,
0.012936662,
-0.0324882492,
-0.0004367967,
-0.003462553,
-0.0305545013,
0.0665422007,
-0.0053012557,
0.000538858,
-0.0322133638,
0.0312310774,
-0.0094320038,
-0.0371858031,
-0.1027359217,
-0.0253470931,
-0.0575733259,
0.0109546147,
0.0061533418,
-0.0240338426,
-0.0482043512,
0.0103178751,
-0.0387420766,
0.0152711887,
-0.0139520764,
0.001580664,
-0.0466817804,
-0.0079906518,
-0.0662217066,
-0.015520934,
-0.0506745167,
0.0443379618,
-0.0323114805,
0.0487628207,
0.0304357596,
0.0371005647,
0.0064420546,
0.0012702391,
-0.028566543,
0.0484637506,
-0.00215606,
-0.0183474496,
-0.0239361208,
-0.0441473797,
-0.0322355628,
0.028043706,
0.0423364006,
-0.0555153973,
-0.0296500847,
-0.0646411628,
0.009182008,
0.0082890261,
-0.0295173675,
-0.0141992494,
-0.029160995,
0.1067363322,
-0.0715517923,
-0.0140798064,
0.0427599177,
0.0007248097,
-0.0532207675,
0.0485646352,
0.0278091021,
0.022743037,
0.0639455169,
-0.0145055251,
0.0379519798,
0.017746333,
0.0011738454,
0.0070145917,
-0.0643750876,
-0.0323638357,
-0.0249012336,
0.0262373611,
0.0120548662,
0.0265036505,
-0.0725893304,
-0.01330104,
0.0089382082,
0.0680165663,
0.063409701,
0.0367504396,
0.0252022892,
0.0071121729,
-0.0829825029,
-0.0076450356,
-0.0473356396,
0.0287092626,
-0.0299574099,
0.0241955481,
-0.0351708904,
0.0166682508,
-0.0461106487,
-0.0337229893,
0.0294706039,
0.0059447754,
0.0126445945,
-0.0314674489,
0.0578206703,
0.0229048245,
0.0533774048,
0.0349025764,
0.0517241322,
-0.0499148555,
0.0380197242,
-0.0246702153,
0.0574835353,
0.0882007182,
0.0281262826,
-0.0590033829,
-0.026743602,
0.0169448499,
-0.0023246326,
0.0352330133,
-0.0087459981,
-0.0467285626,
-0.0182537884,
-0.0502044111,
-0.0367399603,
0.0125912074,
-0.0145471757,
0.0011962474,
0.0147588607,
0.0178170614,
0.0415626317,
-0.0736038238,
0.0168888681,
0.0378772654,
0.0497542731,
0.0158603508,
-0.0158462338,
0.0463758893,
-0.04413452,
0.0036349732,
-0.0057792696,
-0.0440852493,
-0.0066504856,
-0.0325806849,
-0.0320798829,
0.0081277052,
0.0122322673,
-0.0225573741,
0.0629972219,
-0.0586813763,
0.0197496805,
-0.003893696,
-0.0464346036,
-0.0090650078,
0.0455438048,
0.0307259466,
0.009408636,
-0.0396429375,
0.0068750624,
-0.0105871502,
0.002901999,
-0.0393864438,
0.0729438737,
0.0121586118,
0.0183159485,
-0.051585298,
0.01027935,
0.0046320297,
0.0374351665,
-0.0177296624,
0.0167281851,
0.0064081568,
0.035198275,
0.0218116939,
0.0035624774,
-0.0484836623,
-0.0050636274,
-0.0704326406,
-0.0127903204,
0.0154426517,
-0.0213271044,
0.0065772613,
-0.0339225717,
-0.0049542566,
-0.0302142706,
-0.0288193915,
0.0975086316,
-0.030346036,
-0.0121314693,
0.0603080727,
-0.0059268177,
-0.0133354934,
0.0002057678,
-0.0116493646,
0.0018575963,
0.0758571178,
0.0261603128,
0.0088004488,
-0.0156704262,
-0.0287037361,
-0.0599646643,
0.0151868435,
0.0142803611,
0.0229481142,
0.0062911706,
-0.0151675083,
-0.0254171584,
-0.0496706367,
0.004371448,
0.0332955085,
0.0425204746,
0.0228929278,
-0.0173883773,
-0.0140332645,
-0.017620882,
-0.0286755264,
0.0315633081,
-0.0074804155,
-0.0208191574,
0.034639582,
-0.0435382053,
-0.0207593199,
-0.0567062348,
0.0352764614,
-0.0163973812,
-0.0211781021,
-0.06836766,
-0.0109042702,
0.0128121842,
0.043099992,
-0.0501662418,
-0.0579078645,
0.0401849113,
-0.0089884149,
0.0206581391,
0.0230212007,
-0.0156411603,
-0.0512394942,
0.1137835905,
-0.0129793258,
0.0214454904,
0.0314959437,
-0.0453967713,
-0.0686019436,
0.0053821243,
0.0213210117,
0.0101755755,
0.0785841942,
-0.0346958712,
-0.0012528168,
-0.0307545979,
0.024635531,
-0.0217056628,
-0.016108904,
0.0289109126,
0.0358667709,
-0.0131085133,
-0.0122962119,
0.0084143858,
0.0134179937,
-0.0212544128,
0.0435261279,
0.0291889515,
-0.0440627821,
-0.0059273276,
0.075380221,
0.0450948142,
0.0385763794,
-0.0737234205,
0.0044636899,
0.0299862772,
0.0204788055,
-0.029912021,
-0.0477316082,
-0.0482457913,
0.0476735309,
-0.0087503772,
-0.0095517728,
-0.0307529382,
-0.0103536164,
-0.0384813659,
-0.0006909944,
0.0093936622,
0.062818557,
0.0624661334,
-0.0695349947,
-0.0089585241,
0.0103494842,
0.0760948732,
0.073273845,
-0.0134751042,
-0.1010853946,
-0.0001207071,
-0.0350970998,
-0.0085897632,
0.0362039879,
-0.0096230526,
-0.0033878358,
-0.06459295,
0.0482234433,
0.0005097328,
-0.0639317781,
0.0141191622,
-0.033027336,
0.0051190341,
-0.006291762,
-0.0396164469,
-0.0445016362,
0.0013009551,
0.0004649782,
-0.0045558293,
0.0145512624,
-0.0036890712,
0.0209291875,
-0.0677199662,
-0.0330112204,
0.0135230673,
0.0391137674,
-0.0292658824,
-0.0212403536,
-0.0144262919,
-0.0004815311,
-0.0118326331,
-0.0006654483,
0.0855742022,
0.0089841438,
-0.0272666141,
0.0266582351,
-0.0106918123,
-0.0115627674,
0.0049260976,
0.044675041,
0.0687412396,
0.0225199703,
-0.0091769528,
-0.0395615548,
-0.0330372304,
-0.0097733559,
0.0127928713,
0.0400203317,
-0.0230494514,
0.0310134161,
-0.0135644376,
-0.0016804275,
-0.0187590737,
-0.003504507,
-0.0136501146,
-0.0443968885,
-0.0649809986,
-0.1110894307,
-0.0058635129,
0.0440302305,
0.0713433847,
0.013336828,
-0.0087280255,
-0.0011069847,
0.0020212419,
-0.0910300463,
0.0727646872,
-0.0120603135,
-0.0107778609,
0.010401736,
-0.0232581943,
0.0450106151,
-0.0118983155,
-0.0123199252,
0.0211443473,
0.0309935547,
-0.0149793606,
-0.0694264397,
0.0041619376,
0.0119620459,
0.0226749144,
0.0059706159,
-0.0648107752,
0.0450998135,
0.0425521582,
0.0117172403,
-0.0258810315,
-0.0325407833,
0.016347304,
-0.0040176776,
0.0183328446,
-0.0489969961,
0.0398202464,
-0.0096958876,
0.015419458,
-0.0582976267,
0.0199131742,
0.0145320306,
-0.007448276,
0.0667197183,
-0.0508999899,
-0.0025823575,
-0.0357057452,
-0.0300885923,
0.0272678398,
-0.0427235067,
-0.0154881785,
0.0202161837,
0.0404555313,
-0.009639808,
0.0323267467,
0.0234435927,
0.004081022,
0.0004585704,
-0.0393551998,
-0.0312806964,
0.0084983753,
0.0314450189,
-0.0310835894,
0.0512039214,
0.0102401199,
-0.0284682512,
-0.0808956474,
0.0069016302,
-0.0442038625,
0.0455778837,
0.0183922499,
-0.0053071664,
-0.071596548,
0.0501068793,
-0.0077190232,
-0.0287684035,
0.0109639801,
0.0598117486,
0.0407065302,
0.0074414993,
0.0126338666,
-0.0151254376,
-0.0513621755,
0.0239782427,
0.0114567606,
-0.0241067633,
-0.0517112538,
0.0588746257,
0.032567393,
-0.0000235275,
-0.0240558684,
0.0749218836,
-0.0058188713,
0.0232238956,
-0.0393768772,
-0.0220947303,
-0.0216293372,
0.0011630706,
0.0401108786,
0.0152366869,
-0.0029792837,
0.0529791303,
-0.0313563198,
-0.0730963573,
0.0296105985,
-0.0146562168,
0.0139818229,
0.0649395734,
0.061560858,
0.0328442529,
-0.0025695886,
0.0060906461,
-0.0326693468,
-0.0110254576,
0.0152813923,
-0.0012608679,
0.0178704932,
-5.346739728e-33,
-0.0300539006,
-0.0355393514,
0.0475969166,
-0.0048779282,
-0.0315630436,
0.0170148052,
0.0067657772,
0.0331076123,
0.0173831545,
0.0341724642,
0.0363244563,
0.0000873669,
-0.0026047083,
0.0141316745,
0.0315140784,
0.0262081344,
0.0132267242,
0.0256368015,
-0.0080808643,
0.0407462679,
0.0122908605,
0.0031085871,
0.0402222537,
-0.0506150983,
-0.0449842587,
0.0786992982,
0.0243177135,
0.0242851116,
0.0675451681,
0.0584422462,
-0.0319083445,
0.0550964735,
0.0434386097,
0.007501645,
0.0109277638,
0.0024274432,
-0.0552988909,
-0.0137381414,
-0.0119835055,
-0.0005297031,
-0.0620501265,
-0.0079090511,
0.0374605469,
0.0164449885,
0.0351814702,
-0.0223313328,
0.0811523944,
-0.0246701483,
-0.0515661575,
-0.0035612411,
-0.0385613292,
0.0346909687,
-0.0042609554,
-0.0125627024,
0.0618337654,
0.0067744581,
0.0416223407,
0.0177462697,
-0.0230626129,
0.0687767416,
-0.0016675632,
-0.0051527191,
0.0661315992,
0.074202247,
0.0033943753,
0.0636166409,
0.0069222655,
-0.0184007119,
-0.0058307946,
0.01935043,
0.020385487,
0.0602733158,
0.0117475921,
0.0161377247,
0.0094005857,
-0.010824075,
-0.0057417443,
0.0384291373,
-0.0798514113,
-0.0067151091,
-0.0284280535,
0.0374041423,
-0.0284101814,
-0.0217216648,
-0.0390143804,
0.0353479348,
-0.0839959458,
-0.0206114389,
0.0293271672,
0.0311822686,
-0.0250095055,
0.0723538473,
-0.0093901576,
-0.0264538694,
-0.0182523336,
-0.0115501545,
0.0009295557,
0.0671540871,
-0.0248593986,
0.0007266944,
0.0000024971,
-0.0830789655,
0.0401577763,
0.0003748971,
-0.0138681745,
-0.001687374,
0.0557939969,
-0.0109366765,
-0.0486080237,
0.0206628945,
0.012751421,
-0.07211373,
-0.0030120311,
-0.004748893,
-0.0007311208,
-0.0093408935,
-0.0309184622,
0.0046601538,
0.0531355068,
-0.0314855874,
0.0120082125,
-0.025509676,
-0.0238123797,
0.0251741055,
-0.026813969,
-0.0064441888,
0.0007601877,
-0.0723253116,
0.0346324146,
-0.0629641041,
-0.0397362709,
-0.0257338118,
2.327e-7,
0.0240592584,
0.0348110385,
-0.0045163082,
0.006282934,
-0.0064995829,
0.0102879871,
-0.003056789,
0.027118532,
-0.0662026629,
-0.0489517041,
0.0296162721,
0.0459685735,
-0.0225260146,
0.0159030985,
0.0107169291,
0.003329803,
0.0373787619,
0.0133544896,
-0.0653503463,
0.0637113377,
0.1031543761,
0.0680744573,
-0.0197332427,
-0.0257963147,
0.0368774422,
-0.0880386457,
0.0695583373,
-0.0124481665,
-0.0044515613,
0.0404803269,
0.0067400928,
0.0937235579,
-0.0288367867,
0.0332906395,
0.0074849422,
-0.000063282,
0.0212937146,
-0.0320478901,
-0.0309501216,
0.001100603,
-0.0215343945,
0.0140293492,
0.0031113077,
-0.0444151722,
0.0248823594,
-0.0465934649,
-0.0083527686,
-0.002509299,
-0.001520831,
0.0374303758,
-0.0057725711,
-0.0378976129,
-0.0372964181,
0.017862387,
0.0153560862,
0.0022518549,
-0.012050041,
-0.0879036188,
0.0342587009,
0.0540500693,
-0.0105537521,
-0.017812632,
0.0010494622,
0.0111915823,
-0.0322155431,
0.0051034,
-0.0157714952,
1.430607045e-34,
0.0257064234,
0.0080488613,
-0.00427686,
0.0194074288,
0.0220845398,
-0.0467739962,
-0.017563751,
-0.0106658516,
-0.008187226,
-0.0400961824,
-0.0120702442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06089v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06089v2 | Measuring Catastrophic Forgetting in Cross-Lingual Transfer Paradigms: Exploring Tuning Strategies | 2023-09-12T09:37:08 | 2024-04-15T12:53:46 | Boshko Koloski, Blaž Škrlj, Marko Robnik-Šikonja, Senja Pollak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The cross-lingual transfer is a promising technique to solve tasks in
less-resourced languages. In this empirical study, we compare two fine-tuning
approaches combined with zero-shot and full-shot learning approaches for large
language models in a cross-lingual setting. As fine-tuning strategies, we
compare parameter-efficient adapter methods with fine-tuning of all parameters.
As cross-lingual transfer strategies, we compare the intermediate-training
(\textit{IT}) that uses each language sequentially and cross-lingual validation
(\textit{CLV}) that uses a target language already in the validation phase of
fine-tuning. We assess the success of transfer and the extent of catastrophic
forgetting in a source language due to cross-lingual transfer, i.e., how much
previously acquired knowledge is lost when we learn new information in a
different language. The results on two different classification problems, hate
speech detection and product reviews, each containing datasets in several
languages, show that the \textit{IT} cross-lingual strategy outperforms
\textit{CLV} for the target language. Our findings indicate that, in the
majority of cases, the \textit{CLV} strategy demonstrates superior retention of
knowledge in the base language (English) compared to the \textit{IT} strategy,
when evaluating catastrophic forgetting in multiple cross-lingual transfers. | [
-0.0100399386,
0.0261692144,
-0.0311356857,
0.0414132364,
-0.022165617,
0.0532363728,
0.0049710623,
-0.0022255853,
0.0057827816,
-0.0681986585,
-0.0593585446,
-0.0421145223,
-0.0324493833,
-0.0299837384,
-0.0137940189,
-0.0378595665,
0.0782679617,
-0.0152135808,
-0.0327896141,
-0.0189936329,
-0.0061723655,
-0.0150054935,
0.0171481073,
-0.0235079732,
0.0092086708,
0.0026099847,
0.028940035,
-0.0271318667,
0.0352549963,
-0.0026433889,
0.0089322962,
0.0197276808,
0.0143924989,
0.0405686535,
0.0000021655,
-0.0590755641,
-0.0340674929,
-0.0117005138,
-0.0073448089,
-0.0054079611,
0.0671205223,
-0.0536315627,
-0.0218635481,
0.0118016265,
0.0031559279,
-0.0420283228,
0.0603566132,
0.0784990713,
0.0218331274,
0.0893842429,
-0.011398741,
-0.0505653545,
0.0487793982,
0.0039982731,
0.024634013,
-0.0289639942,
0.0456846468,
0.0030458688,
-0.0578825586,
-0.0132154906,
-0.0337552577,
0.0279835761,
0.0004037685,
0.0407856964,
-0.006219116,
0.0050437413,
-0.0224354044,
0.0132747293,
-0.0327733718,
0.0318596475,
-0.0600638054,
-0.0410155505,
-0.0174818058,
0.0001543839,
-0.0206085965,
-0.0358951464,
-0.0705295354,
-0.0075320895,
0.0042427275,
0.0050763022,
0.0372678824,
-0.0396849662,
0.024782218,
-0.010871714,
-0.0324425548,
0.015934445,
0.0138041647,
-0.0351621807,
0.0735184923,
0.0122391582,
0.0296032429,
0.0000689555,
-0.0069227447,
-0.00092578,
-0.0038496398,
0.0060289782,
-0.0116688656,
-0.0160988588,
0.0149238883,
-0.0663405508,
0.0641417131,
0.0382636189,
-0.0269044638,
0.0543197915,
-0.075028412,
0.0390470549,
0.0071812123,
0.0176280979,
-0.0283979699,
-0.0219152141,
-0.0916124657,
0.0108143166,
-0.0136559783,
0.0199894104,
0.0374177247,
0.0313322805,
-0.0308506377,
-0.0197195113,
-0.0371399932,
-0.0030320529,
-0.0468428619,
-0.053938698,
-0.0128173595,
0.0237058979,
-0.0030270736,
0.0909944624,
-0.0111192036,
-0.0034607213,
-0.016284639,
-0.0237332396,
-0.0033860456,
0.0137148686,
-0.0183898006,
-0.0507371537,
0.0561037846,
0.0752383024,
-0.0230569374,
-0.0248724651,
-0.0773689747,
0.0225351397,
-0.0128780492,
-0.1118369028,
0.0356648788,
-0.0487573482,
0.0176139064,
-0.0026910866,
0.0136221452,
-0.0535734557,
-0.0205421671,
-0.0015193534,
-0.0318976864,
0.0498356372,
0.0417282768,
-0.0300337709,
0.0173812155,
0.0010668838,
-0.0161764696,
0.1028465331,
-0.0241207834,
-0.0080814986,
0.0256621148,
-0.0514674149,
-0.0236240327,
0.0345070139,
0.0214647613,
0.0435009636,
-0.059263926,
0.0001756165,
0.0478315614,
-0.0088105295,
0.03426544,
0.0106552746,
-0.028430311,
0.0049674897,
0.0217098016,
-0.0006068072,
0.0188243743,
0.062821947,
0.0371594988,
-0.0160326157,
-0.0217412729,
0.0291240737,
-0.0374431387,
0.0062784161,
-0.015826853,
-0.0252036527,
-0.0379316956,
0.0111400215,
-0.0545492135,
0.0003106355,
0.0141410893,
-0.0135107664,
0.020522885,
-0.021286469,
0.0760291293,
0.0220107976,
-0.0188954175,
0.0754306018,
0.0623802356,
-0.0433784351,
0.0293326285,
-0.0098533714,
0.0161449518,
0.0366020985,
-0.0386221707,
-0.0312413927,
-0.0097151417,
-0.0356859602,
0.0376114398,
-0.0328637138,
0.070219487,
0.0011747325,
0.0079163518,
-0.0463191159,
-0.0139637413,
0.0158266407,
0.0090611605,
0.04826032,
-0.0216329247,
0.0761775449,
0.0030636007,
-0.0023330161,
-0.0648109317,
0.0029573615,
-0.0512810722,
-0.0497298092,
0.0162042901,
0.0235362966,
0.0030831313,
0.0014093,
-0.009527538,
-0.0539162345,
0.0189233422,
-0.0252437051,
-0.0277802143,
0.0284078624,
-0.0266052857,
-0.0054196836,
0.0238505993,
-0.0170011725,
-0.0016630979,
0.0166620519,
-0.0207054988,
-0.030206643,
0.0576446652,
0.0166814215,
0.0562022999,
-0.0122666303,
0.010166401,
-0.0592745021,
0.03372401,
0.0016668149,
0.0327914469,
0.0409358367,
-0.0024633983,
-0.0225340649,
-0.0804979354,
0.0304735079,
-0.0205074158,
-0.0458549075,
0.0498400629,
-0.0118461382,
0.0193535052,
0.0129849482,
-0.0026911923,
-0.0528864376,
-0.0127702923,
-0.0930468217,
0.0289879087,
-0.0213734172,
0.0208203066,
-0.013884549,
-0.0084122289,
-0.0019252698,
0.006085977,
-0.0384296738,
0.0383623168,
0.004553556,
0.0657821,
-0.0069714985,
0.0045228722,
0.0128034884,
-0.0142342597,
-0.0084563252,
0.0178364031,
0.0346771441,
-0.0398712605,
-0.0073946179,
-0.0417736471,
0.029491812,
-0.0172100812,
-0.0033252852,
-0.009002191,
-0.0296342354,
-0.0397074334,
0.018240124,
-0.0030180502,
0.0628141612,
-0.0236191526,
0.0176607575,
0.040454004,
-0.0401461571,
-0.0451949164,
0.0112794908,
0.0094924811,
-0.0471199192,
-0.0370188504,
0.0022216039,
-0.0380416326,
0.0420665219,
-0.009471654,
-0.0016159862,
-0.0499732196,
-0.0065022898,
-0.0550215431,
-0.0114654247,
-0.0099539654,
0.0031470181,
0.0089394357,
0.0173867866,
0.0071206791,
-0.0082265176,
0.0257953163,
0.0020307847,
0.0312297307,
-0.0507275574,
-0.0147802038,
-0.023857763,
0.0171974692,
-0.0132836634,
0.037269406,
0.0154717183,
-0.0084588211,
-0.0516550019,
-0.037710283,
0.0454623438,
0.0017817437,
0.0224962141,
-0.0143603189,
-0.016566826,
-0.0285660122,
-0.0264132898,
-0.0236799195,
0.0074235238,
-0.0073066223,
0.003451424,
-0.0192771088,
-0.0052975807,
-0.0554884225,
-0.0071618333,
0.0480328687,
-0.0190426949,
0.0113658803,
-0.0158067718,
0.0442912839,
0.0040225745,
0.0169945806,
0.0046030865,
0.0130561972,
-0.0191288609,
0.0415328518,
0.0228810292,
0.057042487,
0.0315953493,
0.0032360926,
0.0157707743,
0.018213395,
-0.012315237,
-0.0514593199,
-0.0249111596,
0.0458573923,
-0.0548731387,
-0.0115273148,
0.0409444645,
-0.0259228908,
-0.0587412827,
-0.0190133657,
-0.0063879839,
0.0193869192,
0.0199450031,
0.0280372929,
-0.0866385475,
-0.0300642233,
0.0003580123,
0.0319304653,
-0.0053576049,
-0.0126356808,
-0.0129494006,
-0.1108497381,
-0.0034481406,
0.0121818958,
-0.0931099355,
-0.0275051352,
-0.0311329402,
0.0023799008,
-0.019232668,
0.0714800879,
-0.027775107,
-0.0357724652,
-0.0331001505,
0.0226431098,
-0.0193935167,
-0.0649282858,
0.0249263383,
-0.0228424761,
0.0376440249,
0.0081722056,
0.0263090283,
-0.0106569547,
-0.0151135921,
0.0746082738,
-0.053805504,
-0.0008294052,
-0.0248313863,
0.0575409457,
0.03225483,
-0.0207048301,
0.0749976858,
0.0029129256,
0.0005697429,
0.009732171,
0.0358393155,
0.0957681313,
0.0824498981,
-0.0133138262,
0.0377877466,
-0.0166366175,
-0.0065106307,
0.075063616,
0.0026163447,
-0.0434246436,
-0.0306335054,
0.0074160909,
-0.0230120961,
-0.0407561287,
-0.0304959528,
0.0285412315,
-0.0888396129,
-0.0538208969,
-0.0311698671,
-0.0437107794,
0.033063665,
0.0315406099,
0.0459703095,
0.0210969094,
-0.0278537441,
-0.0101761185,
-0.0204923581,
0.0086400332,
-0.0259011257,
0.0079615144,
-0.0328089073,
0.0051721525,
0.0085066287,
-0.0179341435,
0.0185173955,
-0.0399817415,
-0.0589563623,
-0.0498744994,
0.0413504727,
0.0614946522,
0.0067691687,
0.0890197158,
0.0243134294,
-0.0451369025,
0.0443734527,
0.0379852019,
0.0158965811,
-0.0025466955,
0.0791653618,
-0.0021796897,
-0.0121563897,
0.0416284725,
-0.0295293257,
-0.0251013339,
0.0684546605,
0.0136194881,
-0.0141904261,
0.0704145581,
-0.0077077127,
-0.00426612,
0.005174729,
-0.0047396114,
-0.0423774309,
-0.013658233,
0.025671469,
0.0006537776,
-0.0104794074,
0.0071243839,
-0.0494972765,
0.0425305776,
-0.0066745505,
-0.0094588371,
-0.0031514626,
-0.021822786,
-0.0045502326,
-0.0369219892,
0.0463604778,
0.0448037311,
0.0626968667,
0.0271566678,
0.0462235212,
-0.0335549004,
-0.0072077345,
0.0481006391,
0.0356422663,
-0.0558775403,
0.0367139205,
0.0164601821,
0.0092024244,
0.0111349551,
-0.0223457254,
0.0072081154,
-0.0304915551,
-0.0002761578,
-0.0061906609,
0.0517071187,
-0.0768915862,
0.058699321,
0.0050080982,
-0.0228176247,
-0.0270769931,
0.0041373433,
-0.0381781459,
0.0006907874,
-0.0199533626,
0.0076975692,
-0.0053325477,
0.0396839455,
0.0416070446,
-0.0263536591,
0.0391027369,
-0.0175862517,
0.003328196,
-0.0180944446,
0.0271796677,
0.0288500432,
-0.0243415982,
-0.0026486923,
0.0205379277,
-0.0525073856,
-0.0784937441,
0.0181018095,
-0.0466222018,
0.0238338802,
0.0248081647,
0.0057665789,
0.0606214814,
-0.003550662,
0.0486265346,
-0.0190159194,
0.0024220147,
0.0541359149,
-0.0049392828,
0.0072678723,
-6.310083797e-33,
0.0140170092,
0.0395376235,
0.0100318631,
0.0219794698,
-0.0267821848,
-0.0264830384,
-0.0189412013,
0.0227305051,
-0.0025303003,
0.0148936538,
0.0040113782,
-0.0300688297,
0.0077845408,
0.0177995916,
0.0258276835,
-0.0297590308,
0.0378320739,
0.0059998245,
-0.0333032943,
0.0379324257,
0.0886459202,
0.0567294508,
0.0923068523,
-0.027600076,
0.0229893401,
0.0375698097,
0.0281862654,
0.021818066,
0.0208739061,
0.0586350113,
0.0156385899,
0.0875913203,
0.0254566744,
-0.0575444102,
0.0053399331,
-0.0087762699,
-0.0914680436,
-0.0372319706,
0.0163823944,
0.0534806661,
0.0598666668,
-0.0320540592,
0.0130145922,
-0.0341405869,
-0.0185357407,
-0.0344526209,
0.0133328205,
-0.0511530004,
-0.0304694735,
-0.0209583677,
-0.1010595933,
0.0006899071,
-0.0074454187,
0.0044201235,
0.023704635,
0.0700595379,
0.0155126257,
-0.006121743,
-0.0788206905,
-0.0265840292,
-0.0273266844,
0.0198426377,
0.045953963,
-0.0047499756,
-0.0228797421,
0.0427420698,
0.0498472713,
0.0179580543,
0.0493456386,
0.010872527,
0.0489377081,
-0.0080156401,
0.0161550175,
0.0603443347,
0.0383573845,
-0.0655637458,
-0.0721170902,
-0.0129962368,
-0.0001750568,
0.0501731746,
0.0151979821,
0.0183782037,
-0.0181200951,
-0.0296924915,
-0.0322051868,
-0.0349459648,
-0.0338242278,
-0.0356201082,
0.0145773133,
-0.002579794,
-0.0372857712,
-0.047024861,
0.0694930181,
-0.0228480697,
-0.027913915,
0.0097049288,
-0.0269302502,
-0.0115925847,
0.0063385,
0.0139434505,
-0.0709825009,
-0.0560845323,
-0.0314225182,
0.0190267693,
0.036956545,
-0.018455375,
0.1141066924,
0.0251871031,
-0.0639846176,
0.0055053909,
-0.0350465961,
0.0343428887,
0.0311945416,
0.0590799637,
-0.0026126869,
0.0491259098,
-0.003517563,
0.0219192058,
0.0699036568,
-0.0420926362,
-0.017557038,
0.008821317,
-0.0038717249,
-0.0037306363,
-0.0276175402,
-0.001198779,
-0.0133001162,
0.0148781082,
0.0134211527,
-0.0899028257,
-0.006229315,
0.0119570205,
2.887e-7,
-0.0052313604,
0.0389565006,
-0.0453052223,
-0.0716034994,
0.0100246659,
0.0528580546,
-0.0560557619,
0.0190761555,
0.0307663009,
0.0568759739,
-0.0302259102,
0.0371433981,
0.0555864424,
0.0511157885,
-0.0674164742,
0.005974059,
-0.0360855162,
0.0253272858,
-0.0183173623,
0.0216509402,
0.0105196266,
0.0562552288,
0.0199431963,
-0.030660795,
-0.0053829062,
-0.0375777036,
0.0741300434,
-0.0451265387,
-0.0261737183,
-0.021502126,
0.0027678635,
0.0550362468,
-0.0107166553,
0.0270316657,
-0.0402444638,
0.0200017523,
-0.0025659187,
-0.0121222781,
0.027073957,
-0.0418589562,
0.0184440482,
0.0182043817,
-0.0190275088,
-0.0664709061,
0.0716902986,
-0.0695625469,
-0.0076213456,
-0.0358603895,
-0.0173636135,
-0.0058214557,
0.080843769,
-0.0136924451,
-0.0364746824,
0.0156097077,
0.0203677863,
0.0427095182,
-0.0459857322,
-0.0375257023,
0.0363765657,
0.075851284,
0.0212194864,
-0.0332122222,
-0.0013650508,
-0.0115387309,
0.004340658,
-0.0212509297,
0.0409706756,
2.089050678e-34,
0.0183234606,
-0.0210718885,
0.0263097845,
-0.0210929662,
0.0062996652,
0.003698328,
-0.0093623856,
0.0089479275,
0.0052288994,
-0.0299844909,
0.0024499416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06085v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06085v2 | BHASA: A Holistic Southeast Asian Linguistic and Cultural Evaluation Suite for Large Language Models | 2023-09-12T09:31:25 | 2023-09-19T03:44:17 | Wei Qi Leong, Jian Gang Ngui, Yosephine Susanto, Hamsawardhini Rengarajan, Kengatharaiyer Sarveswaran, William Chandra Tjhi | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs) and the emergence of
novel abilities with scale have necessitated the construction of holistic,
diverse and challenging benchmarks such as HELM and BIG-bench. However, at the
moment, most of these benchmarks focus only on performance in English and
evaluations that include Southeast Asian (SEA) languages are few in number. We
therefore propose BHASA, a holistic linguistic and cultural evaluation suite
for LLMs in SEA languages. It comprises three components: (1) a NLP benchmark
covering eight tasks across Natural Language Understanding (NLU), Generation
(NLG) and Reasoning (NLR) tasks, (2) LINDSEA, a linguistic diagnostic toolkit
that spans the gamut of linguistic phenomena including syntax, semantics and
pragmatics, and (3) a cultural diagnostics dataset that probes for both
cultural representation and sensitivity. For this preliminary effort, we
implement the NLP benchmark only for Indonesian, Vietnamese, Thai and Tamil,
and we only include Indonesian and Tamil for LINDSEA and the cultural
diagnostics dataset. As GPT-4 is purportedly one of the best-performing
multilingual LLMs at the moment, we use it as a yardstick to gauge the
capabilities of LLMs in the context of SEA languages. Our initial experiments
on GPT-4 with BHASA find it lacking in various aspects of linguistic
capabilities, cultural representation and sensitivity in the targeted SEA
languages. BHASA is a work in progress and will continue to be improved and
expanded in the future. The repository for this paper can be found at:
https://github.com/aisingapore/BHASA | [
0.0431355983,
0.0366952457,
-0.0313546732,
0.041750513,
-0.0636019036,
0.0304963049,
0.0259574521,
-0.0102887424,
-0.017595768,
-0.0226561818,
-0.0519980676,
-0.0830563977,
0.0173255857,
0.0228591133,
0.0520602688,
-0.0654196888,
0.0535692386,
-0.0196792576,
0.0372173972,
0.0240125582,
0.0031921593,
0.0240463763,
-0.0009401633,
0.0399725996,
0.0110244192,
-0.0149452016,
-0.0044496856,
-0.009246368,
0.0029593678,
-0.063512899,
-0.0196275469,
0.026715586,
-0.0007124724,
0.0474600978,
0.0000022674,
-0.0462669432,
0.0210535377,
-0.0429635942,
-0.0070737866,
0.044480782,
0.0731144026,
-0.0318241119,
0.0276818983,
0.0161919743,
-0.0301870871,
-0.0465312526,
0.0255691558,
0.042704735,
0.0542337522,
0.063680768,
-0.0142570511,
-0.0323455669,
-0.0129937781,
-0.0352609269,
-0.0506849214,
-0.0359989554,
0.0022764928,
0.0199006405,
0.0307653584,
-0.0127889756,
-0.0152624967,
0.0187088121,
0.0211900845,
0.0229803883,
-0.0167084523,
0.0148256952,
-0.0234819856,
-0.0612461492,
0.0127135525,
0.047022,
-0.0004717445,
-0.029160535,
-0.0201436989,
0.0157086104,
-0.0559928454,
-0.0391296037,
-0.0454591736,
0.0368160866,
0.0038800337,
0.0280778185,
0.0870046541,
0.0078426916,
0.0094496189,
0.0380599201,
0.0099399136,
0.0599439591,
0.0342160314,
0.0019909802,
-0.038757164,
-0.0243520606,
-0.0453968719,
-0.0522628017,
0.0007768603,
0.0571093522,
-0.0475246906,
0.0298817698,
-0.0012298655,
0.0445057862,
0.027010601,
-0.0304979347,
0.0363755524,
0.0590035133,
-0.0302632619,
0.0186101813,
-0.02162534,
0.0902355537,
-0.0210029967,
0.0155282794,
-0.0458563194,
-0.0156455468,
0.0060544852,
-0.0293075312,
0.0007238756,
0.011591468,
-0.0492504612,
-0.013370106,
-0.0584420227,
-0.0095654698,
0.0012726563,
-0.0253487732,
-0.0029051101,
-0.0293196216,
-0.0847850144,
0.0192914102,
-0.014082172,
0.0279349964,
-0.0083048511,
0.0067219739,
0.0142769227,
-0.0728032887,
0.021637002,
0.0453858338,
-0.0410283133,
-0.0171447378,
-0.0043524676,
0.0235468876,
-0.009273693,
-0.0066611837,
-0.0922480747,
-0.0112303747,
-0.0278904773,
-0.0929967687,
0.0007397245,
-0.0594715774,
0.0458684601,
0.0165601391,
-0.0196198002,
-0.0243113097,
0.0177274588,
0.0063455799,
0.0254503973,
0.0135721574,
0.0165226236,
0.0359721184,
0.0295149013,
0.0235792268,
0.0039751655,
0.0841891617,
0.0161244012,
-0.0118564377,
0.0399010144,
-0.0383084305,
-0.0487723164,
0.0493284985,
-0.0036653029,
0.0168337133,
-0.0332647674,
0.0077576991,
-0.0001252954,
0.0197927486,
0.0100914594,
0.0589478984,
-0.0076972083,
0.0151815126,
0.0081509007,
0.023731526,
-0.006411158,
0.0677399561,
0.0807970241,
-0.0047909115,
0.0006188855,
0.0132287443,
-0.0206481759,
0.0114673171,
-0.0185985044,
0.0211008843,
0.0141145755,
0.0441966504,
-0.0194406621,
-0.0216001868,
-0.0281001776,
-0.0055879522,
-0.0162796173,
-0.0132362721,
0.0496816225,
-0.0034116078,
-0.007877185,
0.058544144,
0.046631705,
-0.0619503893,
0.0413861051,
-0.0695759282,
0.0459497012,
0.0153253572,
0.0219746493,
0.0089523662,
-0.0376298763,
0.0152665433,
-0.0099582141,
0.0674956962,
0.033341188,
-0.010560412,
0.0163861196,
-0.0581924841,
0.0344360024,
-0.0010334579,
0.0069873235,
0.0328079462,
0.0349533446,
0.0289224796,
0.0318937339,
-0.0402017049,
-0.0169382412,
0.0460297689,
-0.036267627,
0.0141510218,
-0.0277681313,
-0.0258439463,
0.0496461354,
0.0477524921,
0.0074237958,
-0.0033582142,
0.0126364045,
-0.0520710349,
0.0013382151,
0.0445615426,
-0.0690600052,
-0.0235676933,
0.0460212417,
-0.0123455152,
0.0065280092,
0.0474161766,
-0.0100475606,
-0.0624387041,
0.0307065602,
0.0162567627,
-0.019838227,
-0.0587516166,
0.0465517268,
-0.026382532,
0.0375725478,
-0.0127210803,
0.0861577243,
-0.0032549249,
0.0308544133,
0.0094318073,
0.0559912995,
0.0443994924,
-0.0751377642,
-0.0535570271,
0.0337646417,
0.0026192872,
-0.0257228483,
0.0167357419,
0.0404990613,
-0.0578339286,
-0.0321287997,
-0.1189198568,
0.0298831314,
-0.0400735028,
0.0250795987,
0.0166701302,
-0.0085935779,
-0.0289208498,
0.0082153194,
-0.0245872494,
-0.0335605294,
0.072642386,
0.0386878103,
0.021553468,
-0.0068412987,
-0.0138541209,
-0.0105854832,
-0.009317901,
0.017060291,
0.0342039503,
0.0182071403,
-0.0200753417,
-0.0426343791,
0.011742359,
-0.05916401,
-0.0542843379,
-0.0000167647,
-0.0595993362,
0.0015089358,
-0.0019064388,
0.0202791579,
0.0084068133,
-0.0072574206,
0.0122046862,
0.0054058693,
-0.0233803019,
-0.0257046316,
-0.0127960378,
-0.0269581247,
0.0042496817,
-0.0139737586,
-0.034077771,
-0.0265076607,
0.0761036128,
-0.0010177159,
-0.0100333402,
-0.034368962,
-0.003485932,
-0.0568893366,
-0.0078577185,
0.0094018476,
0.0136837792,
-0.0292692501,
0.0484195948,
-0.0392262824,
-0.0524476841,
0.0379935168,
-0.0396161973,
-0.0371759348,
-0.0727783814,
0.0160671324,
-0.063363567,
0.098341912,
-0.0235494692,
0.0115281176,
-0.0048374147,
-0.0161152929,
-0.0167429224,
0.0143243913,
-0.0032815044,
-0.0280029345,
0.0481854752,
-0.08729022,
0.0038973012,
-0.0264952257,
-0.0096733291,
-0.0573146157,
0.019896809,
-0.0178743154,
0.0428330563,
0.0297302697,
0.0032924544,
0.0096027125,
0.0530063175,
0.0046530445,
-0.0321602747,
-0.0200936198,
0.0450963527,
-0.0171843413,
0.0174796619,
0.0262449868,
0.0079770992,
0.0089665484,
-0.0067775459,
0.0360833779,
0.0160197578,
0.0552083626,
-0.0198163893,
-0.0270670429,
0.036763344,
0.0300876312,
-0.0042640446,
-0.0272231083,
-0.0000441371,
0.0508653335,
-0.0424895994,
0.0021670375,
0.1016902626,
0.05591866,
-0.0033333392,
0.0255418569,
-0.0297558084,
0.0396026112,
0.0570901968,
0.0280856229,
-0.0606249794,
-0.0148062939,
0.0275176428,
-0.0542881303,
-0.0109690456,
-0.0346699655,
-0.0508843772,
-0.1288862377,
0.0484225377,
0.010657385,
-0.0449886024,
-0.0307063591,
-0.0274698809,
-0.0284436997,
-0.0032723844,
0.0327153467,
0.0487412363,
0.0144718653,
0.0030740702,
0.0283920188,
-0.0519484133,
-0.0553347729,
0.0341198482,
-0.0288593657,
0.0354413055,
-0.0039620092,
0.0449034497,
-0.017944159,
-0.013370052,
0.0311742257,
-0.0308386218,
-0.0066479323,
-0.0045452304,
-0.0056394865,
0.0328966379,
-0.0288336426,
-0.0395019278,
0.0165273454,
-0.0507841967,
0.0068717957,
0.0303600244,
0.0755268335,
0.0057719569,
-0.0072312653,
0.0165383313,
0.0270387493,
0.0028347995,
0.0567132048,
0.0350044295,
-0.0312564485,
-0.0375996977,
0.0030875753,
-0.0255413931,
-0.0123418178,
-0.0009354881,
0.0542862713,
-0.0252967216,
-0.0041713165,
-0.0778606981,
-0.0445802175,
0.0063127745,
0.0140517633,
0.0331342779,
0.004937049,
-0.0356440805,
-0.0110766543,
-0.0162432827,
0.0310502481,
-0.0068454649,
0.0178937223,
-0.0559606329,
-0.0038573712,
0.0159874652,
-0.0502307452,
-0.0190987401,
0.0241698083,
-0.0728727579,
-0.0683290511,
0.0230967887,
0.0161067024,
0.0202239286,
-0.026093794,
0.0150966747,
-0.0441731922,
-0.0244499948,
0.0056640399,
-0.0437180176,
0.0194283109,
-0.002043233,
0.0110132415,
0.0094967438,
0.0690061003,
-0.0014309797,
0.0236857552,
-0.0329340994,
0.0719016343,
0.0201389156,
-0.0105035976,
0.0245195329,
0.0524737611,
0.0146571426,
-0.0861528963,
-0.0225013886,
-0.0520541854,
-0.0319708735,
-0.0358940363,
-0.0183388945,
-0.0196776148,
-0.0013874404,
0.0296093877,
0.0235282164,
-0.0250714887,
-0.0182490032,
0.004460081,
0.014311092,
0.0089100003,
0.0251014605,
0.00487791,
0.0142097482,
-0.0161168762,
0.0067928978,
-0.0337266251,
-0.0199504253,
-0.0688807592,
0.0299006645,
-0.0289812908,
0.1138006523,
0.0063443468,
-0.0039403862,
0.0366945527,
0.0022235946,
0.0233531855,
-0.0453044735,
0.0433391072,
0.0016843274,
0.0970056579,
-0.0073448438,
0.0422460288,
-0.0321988501,
-0.0086330576,
-0.0367198177,
0.0493441038,
0.0012327373,
-0.0543113686,
0.0338359885,
0.0100191841,
-0.036411725,
0.0195193458,
0.0594636202,
0.007646828,
0.0372102372,
0.0484666005,
0.0234849565,
-0.0105367498,
-0.0718475431,
-0.00994155,
0.0162036158,
-0.0197340678,
0.0360270925,
-0.0907146856,
-0.0751085132,
-0.0040034112,
0.0226091128,
0.0221565515,
-0.0190066602,
-0.0015168062,
0.0842691585,
-0.01285371,
0.0020751478,
-0.0750093609,
-0.0096300179,
-0.0440397151,
0.0380414724,
0.0079600113,
-6.703792855e-33,
-0.0346910283,
-0.0049525341,
0.036655087,
0.0011854398,
-0.0296727587,
-0.0197700523,
-0.0426600873,
-0.0005563067,
-0.0011517841,
0.0173746757,
-0.0246855654,
0.000493572,
0.0030106311,
0.0297898315,
-0.0062704226,
-0.0190677065,
-0.0001953157,
0.0190692302,
-0.0015130688,
0.0378684253,
0.0484858863,
0.0076042996,
0.0573742725,
-0.0135338502,
0.0096078459,
-0.0068099508,
-0.0068912874,
0.0351858474,
-0.0325085111,
0.0631159544,
-0.0410762429,
0.0626271963,
0.0387975201,
-0.0051515559,
-0.0102018937,
-0.0529214554,
-0.0441911779,
-0.0107552214,
0.0682280511,
0.0202278681,
-0.0079548722,
-0.0135061257,
0.0007544606,
-0.0291939825,
-0.0299626645,
0.0053310804,
-0.0100017264,
-0.0141855497,
-0.0049193874,
0.0096659884,
-0.0754317716,
0.0543648861,
-0.0121263675,
0.0054685413,
0.0215901509,
0.0288513172,
-0.0534509271,
0.0027782586,
-0.0553093329,
0.0004429722,
0.0018619564,
0.0308812149,
0.0736378208,
0.0249781851,
-0.0294937808,
0.0384028368,
0.0285686459,
-0.0344069563,
0.0214410815,
0.006349748,
0.0412004031,
0.0591132492,
0.0262290761,
0.0648508891,
0.0285853036,
-0.0177282244,
-0.059753634,
-0.0222514383,
0.0475760065,
0.0219368972,
0.0325248428,
-0.018825816,
-0.0517928228,
-0.030611217,
-0.0274024699,
-0.0173821393,
-0.0405696444,
-0.0218411926,
0.0606199317,
-0.0162503198,
-0.0305103678,
-0.0102813402,
0.0596886352,
-0.0409215316,
0.023315616,
0.0057038073,
-0.0186497364,
-0.0122124013,
-0.0120366029,
0.0620836206,
-0.0463401787,
-0.0503409058,
-0.0117815826,
0.0227474552,
-0.020059716,
-0.0370553471,
0.0049849185,
0.0091246199,
-0.0291633401,
0.0162427705,
-0.0625452772,
0.0353124514,
-0.0330060683,
0.0194741488,
0.0335656777,
-0.0002900046,
-0.0420826897,
0.0285920892,
0.0344505683,
0.0124353897,
-0.0268963985,
0.0043526436,
-0.0146061368,
0.006250829,
-0.0231542345,
0.0330282338,
-0.0247710068,
0.0241325144,
0.0124737201,
-0.0072955918,
-0.0042594625,
0.0546301231,
2.915e-7,
0.0188722312,
0.0062750145,
0.0610150509,
0.0195184927,
0.0199979115,
0.0126865152,
-0.0321914479,
-0.0218268763,
-0.0093376702,
0.0349467322,
-0.0045768754,
0.0331705958,
0.0753512308,
0.0136066284,
-0.0622952096,
0.0428574756,
-0.0497254319,
-0.0285989065,
-0.0530252643,
-0.0054722582,
0.0190660078,
0.0668582767,
-0.0174025372,
-0.022532288,
-0.0141465599,
-0.0345222577,
0.0484606698,
-0.0159750488,
-0.0133726513,
0.0419760458,
0.0354024433,
0.0177782215,
0.0275674723,
0.006194286,
-0.0105929635,
0.0316098258,
0.0229564663,
0.0882586166,
0.0235854201,
0.010591126,
0.0150494995,
0.0337497331,
-0.0262887999,
-0.1335989684,
0.0753546059,
-0.0220848955,
-0.0673728511,
-0.0272415355,
-0.0188582297,
-0.0003205826,
-0.024722442,
-0.0179926436,
-0.0365058407,
0.0484414361,
0.0247980841,
-0.0713212937,
-0.027213376,
-0.0380869582,
-0.0445269495,
0.0143266059,
-0.0415994115,
-0.0275564138,
-0.032168515,
-0.0038636455,
0.018561691,
-0.0622079074,
-0.0153174913,
2.681009659e-34,
0.0324508063,
0.008130936,
0.0115307122,
0.0041523809,
0.0704947785,
-0.021408882,
-0.0386544168,
0.0250058025,
-0.0224995483,
-0.0423799306,
-0.0044725984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06057v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06057v1 | RAP-Gen: Retrieval-Augmented Patch Generation with CodeT5 for Automatic Program Repair | 2023-09-12T08:52:56 | 2023-09-12T08:52:56 | Weishi Wang, Yue Wang, Shafiq Joty, Steven C. H. Hoi | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Automatic program repair (APR) is crucial to reduce manual debugging efforts
for developers and improve software reliability. While conventional
search-based techniques typically rely on heuristic rules or a redundancy
assumption to mine fix patterns, recent years have witnessed the surge of deep
learning (DL) based approaches to automate the program repair process in a
data-driven manner. However, their performance is often limited by a fixed set
of parameters to model the highly complex search space of APR. To ease such
burden on the parametric models, in this work, we propose a novel
Retrieval-Augmented Patch Generation framework (RAP-Gen) by explicitly
leveraging relevant fix patterns retrieved from a codebase of previous bug-fix
pairs. Specifically, we build a hybrid patch retriever to account for both
lexical and semantic matching based on the raw source code in a
language-agnostic manner, which does not rely on any code-specific features. In
addition, we adapt a code-aware language model CodeT5 as our foundation model
to facilitate both patch retrieval and generation tasks in a unified manner. We
adopt a stage-wise approach where the patch retriever first retrieves a
relevant external bug-fix pair to augment the buggy input for the CodeT5 patch
generator, which synthesizes a ranked list of repair patch candidates. Notably,
RAP-Gen is a generic APR framework that can flexibly integrate different patch
retrievers and generators to repair various types of bugs. We thoroughly
evaluate RAP-Gen on three benchmarks in two programming languages, including
the TFix benchmark in JavaScript, and Code Refinement and Defects4J benchmarks
in Java, where the bug localization information may or may not be provided.
Experimental results show that RAP-Gen significantly outperforms previous
state-of-the-art approaches on all benchmarks, e.g., repairing 15 more bugs on
818 Defects4J bugs. | [
0.0378686152,
0.0617256761,
-0.0274733845,
0.0117479898,
-0.0102165714,
-0.0331410728,
-0.0589498878,
0.0202811733,
-0.0071151205,
-0.0336067267,
0.0362019874,
-0.0009376188,
0.0109222466,
0.0174933877,
0.0243729092,
-0.0210796893,
0.0272962376,
0.0048872619,
0.0064807185,
0.0476954356,
-0.0322718471,
0.016372079,
-0.0146367559,
0.0602603778,
-0.0235227849,
-0.0155529995,
0.0012743933,
0.0474258624,
0.0260559991,
0.0320802815,
0.061469052,
-0.0091157909,
-0.026449766,
-0.0124870632,
0.000002484,
-0.0081049427,
-0.0253049098,
-0.0021212732,
0.0585434251,
0.0083241258,
-0.0522380471,
-0.0101329489,
-0.0584340431,
0.0435180776,
-0.0132017182,
-0.0076653548,
0.0464740321,
-0.0293886606,
0.0672009662,
0.0441941358,
0.0210396647,
0.031359449,
0.0530537888,
0.0202193968,
0.0600713119,
-0.0619122572,
-0.0148294671,
0.0238734502,
0.0062637571,
0.0104560275,
0.022497708,
0.0332991183,
0.0063301749,
-0.0190196093,
0.0031724421,
-0.0188051779,
-0.0600621104,
-0.0180986319,
0.023724895,
0.0141258901,
-0.0808199942,
-0.0006701435,
0.0050372989,
-0.0147681041,
-0.0198500343,
0.0024507232,
0.0048294719,
0.009632539,
0.0135588422,
-0.0165480953,
0.021549819,
-0.0711990297,
0.0518737473,
-0.0337980352,
-0.0317477584,
0.0316496119,
0.005714946,
0.0060455743,
-0.0454740189,
-0.0299412739,
-0.0159510337,
-0.0059343278,
0.0247603543,
0.015319461,
-0.0242523588,
0.0200047176,
-0.0387722775,
-0.0109205209,
0.0353161097,
0.0198621601,
-0.0298540182,
0.0456723869,
-0.0977386683,
-0.0335193016,
-0.0465703346,
-0.0053694048,
0.0030656273,
-0.0066614286,
0.0064121885,
-0.0162506755,
-0.0316039585,
-0.0199037287,
-0.0009274242,
0.0139387967,
0.0033941923,
0.0546516366,
-0.0171244293,
0.0245498177,
-0.024754256,
0.0521098599,
-0.0086950697,
-0.0009754981,
-0.0756443664,
0.0141981943,
0.0240215641,
-0.0247745439,
-0.0007000252,
-0.0582904369,
0.0161956809,
-0.0804187208,
-0.0056555085,
-0.0241171475,
-0.0371736288,
-0.044217404,
0.0185563155,
0.0203644503,
0.0218708571,
0.0114612505,
-0.0644975081,
-0.0480931215,
-0.0224476736,
0.027455762,
-0.0435086116,
-0.0515109338,
-0.0700718835,
-0.0298200212,
-0.0082905972,
-0.0441026166,
0.0210405085,
0.0124817109,
-0.0335075259,
0.0473284349,
-0.0440967046,
0.0346468613,
0.0263310503,
0.0260123443,
0.0603636056,
-0.0258085188,
0.0086510051,
0.0074999407,
0.0418509245,
-0.0125322053,
0.0610751659,
-0.0162148364,
-0.0043337913,
0.0165445954,
0.0212228429,
-0.0201007128,
0.0258212555,
-0.0042389105,
0.0130527467,
-0.0087323636,
0.007930127,
-0.0366211124,
-0.0464160293,
0.010534727,
0.0494009294,
0.0394193754,
0.036206983,
0.0089886496,
-0.0297803376,
-0.0638571158,
-0.0317052156,
0.0386460833,
-0.0159891658,
0.0038201122,
0.0115946243,
0.0127225844,
-0.0022101109,
-0.049426984,
-0.0359264016,
0.0329050124,
-0.0483489446,
0.0075918827,
0.0614492632,
0.0053615361,
-0.0380086824,
0.0611044839,
-0.009385312,
-0.0130229052,
-0.0491641723,
-0.0579600222,
-0.0145153301,
0.070716083,
0.0744352788,
-0.0784425661,
-0.1072220728,
0.037453942,
-0.0471495725,
-0.0668846965,
0.0410049073,
-0.0126418434,
-0.0029437621,
-0.050829418,
-0.0083004059,
-0.0352480151,
0.0053182766,
0.0581132099,
0.0114142895,
-0.0127580781,
0.0429677442,
-0.0225574207,
-0.0194758829,
0.0190810226,
0.0516657382,
0.0164520014,
0.0632287785,
-0.0112637579,
-0.0052342564,
0.0010822036,
-0.0337698311,
-0.0126702944,
0.0594750904,
0.0380648896,
-0.0303327218,
0.0078479843,
-0.0196495,
-0.0173706878,
0.0407296047,
-0.0226412639,
-0.0128207281,
0.0507973395,
-0.0515144393,
-0.0297519546,
0.0655611306,
-0.0200191792,
-0.0385096669,
-0.0017837599,
0.0223937593,
0.0074392809,
-0.0261183698,
-0.0253738221,
0.0145996762,
0.0283146929,
-0.0309609696,
-0.0469139889,
0.1150597706,
0.0528887175,
-0.0417030603,
-0.0417180061,
0.0250027739,
-0.0788810179,
0.0231391788,
0.0283544399,
0.0507168695,
0.0027428742,
-0.0725028589,
-0.0469865017,
0.0305733234,
-0.0251725782,
-0.0292467345,
-0.0091352556,
0.0455751941,
0.0145901078,
-0.0320407934,
-0.0108879637,
-0.01377948,
0.0260106623,
-0.0177072678,
0.0280235205,
-0.0008395268,
-0.0498944186,
-0.0691059232,
-0.0237804595,
-0.0338176712,
-0.0317483842,
-0.0125813307,
-0.0383872949,
-0.0969372615,
0.0621346235,
-0.0132285813,
0.0580445975,
-0.0145812621,
-0.0706673488,
-0.0065219076,
-0.0437234901,
0.0082330294,
0.0592349544,
-0.0160469338,
0.0324943364,
0.0314593539,
0.0098495381,
-0.033517424,
0.0379160866,
0.0221289825,
-0.0947093368,
0.0508144349,
-0.050848648,
0.0105370004,
0.0230895355,
-0.0216740891,
-0.0312017668,
-0.0523905978,
-0.0143519025,
0.0312085114,
0.0352640487,
0.0161439218,
-0.0166202877,
0.0151782176,
0.0341208205,
-0.0465433337,
-0.0626326352,
0.0442702211,
0.0042686383,
0.0233578738,
-0.0592824817,
-0.0068038492,
-0.0417391136,
0.0506792292,
0.0017761993,
0.016739225,
-0.0237905681,
-0.0582467094,
-0.0116660725,
0.0311663412,
-0.0000527311,
-0.0332140028,
0.0298213847,
-0.0655996799,
0.030138161,
0.0105705773,
-0.0247417446,
-0.0309660006,
0.0256692059,
0.0158804525,
-0.0108614629,
0.0420562737,
-0.0068968036,
-0.0198421273,
-0.0110633234,
0.0132304775,
0.0626645461,
0.0600165725,
-0.0489923321,
0.0092687663,
-0.0471717902,
-0.0256262552,
-0.0472592898,
-0.0107075265,
0.0300779901,
-0.0415073223,
0.007818684,
0.0736215115,
0.0316452831,
-0.0512958318,
-0.0043913312,
0.0328565314,
-0.0061492864,
-0.0344873518,
0.0495240279,
0.0115707759,
-0.0515229441,
-0.0493487827,
0.0038456491,
0.0358922333,
-0.0174817145,
0.0050185802,
-0.0077784094,
0.0154894842,
0.0477638207,
0.0478293262,
-0.0946238115,
-0.0260599498,
0.0421266258,
0.0214320216,
0.0171195529,
0.0150839388,
0.0290467329,
-0.0764594749,
0.0353567824,
0.0030489613,
-0.0038660155,
-0.051815398,
-0.0158443544,
0.0042843223,
0.0081141405,
-0.0214246623,
0.049205143,
0.032864254,
0.0164629817,
-0.0044171908,
-0.0263236128,
-0.0315569863,
0.0367179476,
-0.0242845975,
0.0334092937,
0.1054526195,
0.0164128002,
0.044289995,
0.0261211768,
0.0435322411,
0.0073156776,
0.0374979228,
-0.0113844573,
0.0507225581,
0.0009118859,
-0.0299105886,
0.0815642923,
0.0042304639,
-0.066833809,
-0.0056747706,
0.002181228,
0.0152938263,
-0.0200664252,
0.0369725786,
-0.0562654212,
-0.0387676954,
-0.0055071018,
0.0016154869,
0.0282257814,
0.021761911,
-0.0233582035,
-0.0399312936,
0.0413147174,
-0.081874989,
-0.0235857666,
-0.016731225,
-0.0322697088,
-0.0059733302,
-0.0520249233,
-0.013398855,
-0.0029439686,
0.0216763839,
0.0175173599,
-0.1005161256,
-0.024699783,
0.0078808554,
-0.0558296964,
0.0360195637,
0.0005113619,
0.0228926223,
-0.021067109,
0.0018144692,
-0.0132744033,
0.0048143957,
-0.0157930497,
0.0041126893,
-0.0065806485,
-0.0285263862,
0.003774689,
0.0762282088,
0.0069160098,
0.0196061656,
-0.0580494776,
-0.073899202,
-0.0497120805,
0.0521249138,
-0.0240456033,
0.0062235422,
0.0031742528,
-0.0570308454,
-0.0133869462,
-0.003997813,
-0.0788140967,
0.0118370978,
-0.0062053301,
0.0219011493,
0.0528889969,
-0.0394507647,
0.0350959189,
0.0214450676,
0.0391869694,
0.0867322311,
0.0109507516,
-0.0061683147,
-0.0026801748,
0.0239952989,
-0.004726884,
-0.0309905745,
0.1235102564,
-0.0160765536,
-0.0766716003,
0.0252674501,
-0.0068882061,
-0.0291654393,
0.0605349392,
0.0321204364,
-0.023934355,
0.000365198,
0.0486573763,
0.0412181132,
0.0269773453,
0.0250157546,
0.0085609928,
0.0304218605,
0.0724112839,
-0.0130550843,
-0.0047584912,
0.0233409461,
0.0342297107,
-0.0402434841,
-0.0173533857,
-0.0320441313,
-0.0424325541,
-0.0014404501,
-0.005578442,
0.0615199022,
0.0362938493,
0.0217775628,
0.0128568457,
-0.0163100697,
-0.010292979,
0.005654566,
0.0269306637,
-0.0074098269,
-0.0432176776,
0.0147194881,
0.0001010176,
-0.0252569336,
0.0266889296,
-0.0504988581,
0.0458109453,
-0.054021351,
-0.0259633325,
-0.0049709585,
0.0283280816,
0.0152901718,
-0.0043204674,
-0.0111171408,
-0.0691263154,
-0.0027854929,
-0.0549164601,
0.0057474794,
0.0416594036,
0.0283350162,
0.0212556459,
-0.0357592031,
0.1270575076,
0.0189744011,
0.0047340281,
-0.0055538206,
0.0136502935,
-0.0338027142,
-0.035835851,
-0.0333907902,
-6.295241712e-33,
-0.0165137723,
-0.0096246814,
-0.0291765071,
-0.0275739226,
0.0186659303,
-0.0076248916,
-0.0573462807,
0.0049697678,
0.0336554758,
0.0016544682,
0.0007118817,
0.0399843231,
-0.0125211729,
-0.0226697959,
0.0381246656,
0.0595266074,
0.0448437519,
0.0697691217,
-0.0504059009,
0.0291478746,
0.018853642,
0.034169361,
0.0057051275,
-0.056681674,
-0.0126368245,
0.0211317316,
0.0365837738,
0.0495105907,
0.0377153046,
0.035252355,
0.0418531522,
0.0087603722,
-0.0206063427,
0.0038659819,
-0.0068725715,
-0.0629297569,
-0.039165955,
-0.0371422544,
-0.0215208493,
-0.0197240245,
0.0123025673,
-0.064704895,
0.0572263785,
0.0211757272,
0.0119712297,
0.0103766313,
0.0356468521,
-0.0017309113,
0.0102238087,
-0.0452980511,
0.0047637308,
0.0140394224,
-0.0509033427,
-0.0203312654,
-0.0442559905,
0.010131768,
0.0458932295,
0.0621373169,
-0.002317135,
-0.0253836233,
0.0050367741,
0.0699683279,
0.0350263678,
0.0046052835,
-0.0365386158,
0.0354373157,
0.024886379,
0.0583017059,
0.0041085142,
-0.0285207946,
0.0661414862,
0.0237178039,
0.0227753073,
0.0547673777,
0.0585172847,
-0.0304825529,
-0.0400035791,
0.0502712503,
-0.0170145463,
0.021675691,
-0.0077263354,
0.0744221658,
-0.0444350354,
0.0103607224,
-0.0493132994,
0.0080539556,
-0.0586685129,
-0.0306105409,
0.048223976,
0.0145782214,
-0.0265301075,
0.0265154429,
0.0051186923,
0.0023497501,
0.0803412646,
0.0062782606,
-0.0669672936,
0.0101789841,
-0.0704876408,
0.0131428707,
0.0435938723,
-0.027572047,
-0.0151699642,
0.0244989749,
0.0417105369,
-0.0227705073,
0.0006520211,
0.0244609788,
-0.0285863597,
0.0196150467,
-0.0281948559,
-0.0122153861,
-0.0938073695,
0.0143339224,
-0.0400054529,
0.0432631634,
0.0151368771,
0.0201777611,
0.0387638621,
0.0086065745,
-0.0439515449,
0.0143111581,
-0.0147291068,
-0.0097465729,
-0.0064033656,
-0.0098105017,
-0.026473742,
0.0019122659,
0.0192082878,
-0.0495414883,
-0.0336243175,
0.0255978052,
3.209e-7,
-0.0038964148,
0.0469820052,
0.0178129002,
-0.0434396602,
-0.0098482091,
0.0285851099,
0.0197764058,
-0.0155706229,
0.0895990431,
0.0194429439,
-0.0094772046,
-0.0126210051,
0.036411345,
0.0210987404,
-0.0083678998,
0.04006036,
-0.0199518465,
0.010295446,
-0.0399959721,
-0.0147366384,
-0.016152706,
0.0377942286,
0.0171259549,
-0.0121830776,
0.0154801458,
0.0015944644,
-0.0151382005,
-0.0147992847,
-0.0091188177,
0.0597921573,
-0.0153762801,
0.0544168688,
0.0162986405,
-0.0447709486,
-0.0434157737,
-0.0232191142,
-0.0000559403,
0.0270435214,
-0.0156367347,
-0.0001764338,
0.0012017698,
0.0148117058,
0.0150344176,
-0.0219847448,
-0.0019038735,
-0.0331484713,
0.018695958,
0.0128381802,
-0.0351900533,
0.0019658615,
-0.0162855443,
-0.0182976425,
-0.0144706285,
0.0500223786,
-0.0239679664,
0.0209972039,
-0.0131841013,
-0.0893623009,
-0.0187303107,
0.0457029417,
-0.0028706582,
0.0295649879,
0.0012576131,
-0.0149021959,
0.0214440972,
-0.0082973586,
0.0370259024,
3.065949391e-34,
0.0238591973,
-0.0237330906,
-0.0021527961,
-0.0503652394,
0.0648682863,
-0.0050668311,
-0.033637166,
0.0373083279,
-0.0096964361,
0.0279118996,
-0.0676534027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06054v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06054v3 | Breaking through the learning plateaus of in-context learning in Transformer | 2023-09-12T08:45:25 | 2024-06-06T15:09:52 | Jingwen Fu, Tao Yang, Yuwang Wang, Yan Lu, Nanning Zheng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | In-context learning, i.e., learning from context examples, is an impressive
ability of Transformer. Training Transformers to possess this in-context
learning skill is computationally intensive due to the occurrence of learning
plateaus, which are periods within the training process where there is minimal
or no enhancement in the model's in-context learning capability. To study the
mechanism behind the learning plateaus, we conceptually seperate a component
within the model's internal representation that is exclusively affected by the
model's weights. We call this the "weights component", and the remainder is
identified as the "context component". By conducting meticulous and controlled
experiments on synthetic tasks, we note that the persistence of learning
plateaus correlates with compromised functionality of the weights component.
Recognizing the impaired performance of the weights component as a fundamental
behavior drives learning plateaus, we have developed three strategies to
expedite the learning of Transformers. The effectiveness of these strategies is
further confirmed in natural language processing tasks. In conclusion, our
research demonstrates the feasibility of cultivating a powerful in-context
learning ability within AI systems in an eco-friendly manner. | [
0.0109091438,
0.02166982,
-0.0170934126,
0.0408451706,
0.0130026918,
0.0174883455,
-0.0021356081,
-0.0246342793,
-0.022813255,
-0.0097815692,
-0.0584298223,
0.0297413319,
-0.0046995874,
-0.0170521494,
-0.0041855657,
-0.0648565441,
0.0366526544,
0.0041517122,
-0.0405748151,
-0.0152084585,
-0.0313225612,
-0.0324236304,
-0.0012731823,
0.0219110101,
-0.036651507,
-0.0242933035,
-0.0086272275,
0.0047027427,
0.0361269601,
-0.0220037475,
0.0270790271,
-0.0135537861,
0.028530743,
0.0407663621,
0.000002109,
-0.0323679969,
-0.0227381457,
-0.0060935454,
-0.0525653102,
-0.0453583635,
0.0589817986,
-0.0266127251,
-0.0257251095,
-0.0019104881,
-0.0487367846,
0.0295495298,
0.075745225,
0.06841515,
0.037271414,
0.0508437343,
-0.0223864559,
-0.0351581313,
0.0097803641,
-0.0066859378,
0.0138364444,
-0.0140769584,
0.0047545973,
-0.0262906831,
-0.0278208926,
-0.0407910235,
-0.0638073459,
0.0071687349,
0.0510008149,
0.05042772,
0.0112159951,
0.0566195846,
-0.025716573,
-0.0111168213,
-0.0288599357,
0.0333362669,
-0.0574984364,
-0.01468076,
-0.0237227827,
0.002573685,
0.0042242096,
-0.0208652876,
-0.0425372869,
0.0187325366,
-0.0019890298,
0.0243094452,
-0.0059089814,
0.0320546962,
0.0082437415,
-0.0113456221,
-0.0420796499,
0.0560418181,
-0.0188710298,
-0.0614506938,
0.0057327608,
0.016931301,
-0.0299628992,
-0.0080329636,
0.0363086574,
0.0396383926,
-0.0086170016,
0.0264436062,
-0.0027679605,
-0.0224161614,
-0.019835325,
-0.0152978506,
0.0541577227,
0.0526469313,
-0.0166341159,
0.0019861152,
-0.0451625101,
0.0654567257,
-0.0211441666,
0.0173923839,
-0.0251611993,
0.031836953,
-0.0698558316,
-0.0120853754,
-0.0864259452,
0.0069510988,
-0.035948582,
-0.027414389,
-0.0180270188,
0.0372342914,
-0.0184331555,
-0.0067207571,
0.0045560156,
0.0195834003,
-0.0785186663,
0.0253038816,
-0.020324545,
0.0672051013,
-0.0052227355,
0.0000452267,
-0.0050204443,
-0.0275228508,
-0.0118012587,
-0.0128128417,
0.0033314589,
-0.0116569055,
0.0106351282,
0.0740168691,
-0.0108524123,
-0.0330821089,
-0.037649475,
0.0137043344,
0.016155282,
-0.0393887274,
0.0093346313,
0.0050981678,
-0.0157181825,
0.004898604,
0.0224261787,
-0.0281345993,
0.0042613652,
0.0147195337,
0.029177621,
0.1154525429,
-0.006886519,
-0.0200284831,
0.0446201712,
0.0165091194,
-0.0328398682,
0.0639717728,
0.0347298235,
0.0366022959,
-0.0122683747,
0.00966598,
0.0306858495,
0.0210278276,
0.0068292436,
-0.0154905953,
-0.0326091722,
-0.0492545292,
-0.0212737527,
0.0074460409,
0.0495249853,
0.0192767847,
-0.0358103625,
0.0666875318,
0.0805769116,
0.0363531373,
0.0295931678,
0.0352800339,
-0.0018247132,
-0.0226423573,
-0.0012687489,
0.0220814124,
-0.0767307952,
0.0272562578,
-0.0155731319,
0.0162887704,
-0.0904844776,
0.0390278585,
-0.0095074037,
-0.0579901412,
0.0081626745,
-0.0249465201,
0.0187833272,
-0.0144399498,
0.0451688357,
0.053130988,
-0.0485750288,
0.056183476,
-0.0025977695,
-0.0427942649,
-0.0323972665,
-0.0451242216,
-0.0238721874,
0.0347800776,
0.0078192502,
-0.0445051342,
-0.0041038916,
0.0016988349,
-0.0149421506,
0.0312269814,
-0.0052941623,
-0.0249158628,
0.0145128043,
-0.0422793776,
-0.056918297,
-0.0252632666,
0.0035771134,
-0.0036217361,
0.0055523943,
-0.0228393264,
-0.0048349448,
-0.008902939,
-0.0171683729,
0.0469668284,
-0.0381167307,
-0.0274715908,
-0.0116682379,
0.0133021912,
0.0274834074,
-0.0291505195,
0.0008475875,
-0.0184279494,
0.0443596989,
-0.0255169477,
-0.0289203096,
0.0655950755,
-0.0800217241,
0.0256715231,
0.0152482083,
-0.0344567969,
0.0159181394,
0.0185767915,
0.0037717812,
-0.0395370871,
-0.0144653283,
-0.0436080843,
0.0920357779,
-0.001384304,
0.0410307534,
-0.0271216035,
0.0242057759,
-0.0541493185,
0.0902812406,
0.0052645365,
-0.0153665273,
0.0152259693,
0.0200921185,
-0.0046706409,
-0.0260893106,
0.0303533338,
-0.0216755345,
-0.0042319275,
0.0052254489,
0.0210804455,
-0.0216750391,
-0.041512534,
-0.0203087069,
-0.0782257617,
-0.0099629788,
-0.0185054671,
0.0055237822,
0.0001594558,
-0.0140230833,
-0.0104363635,
-0.0255318619,
0.010555963,
0.0324566178,
-0.0421111211,
0.0200475994,
0.0304375701,
0.0010936989,
-0.0118343979,
-0.012928986,
0.0011705685,
-0.0057113762,
0.0533706509,
0.0136344889,
-0.0035333647,
-0.0758254081,
0.0158519596,
0.0483385548,
0.0282036681,
-0.0148821408,
-0.0360133313,
0.0112817986,
0.012046637,
0.0721351802,
0.1053690165,
0.0345065445,
0.0559353158,
0.0522739999,
0.0337931067,
-0.0533967651,
0.0327382125,
-0.0438165925,
0.0026365842,
-0.0603059605,
0.0218567811,
0.0119296676,
0.0916127861,
-0.0369913243,
0.0158690773,
-0.0148138534,
0.045879554,
-0.0113906171,
-0.0418486744,
0.009785491,
-0.0302013271,
-0.0322995633,
0.0120494822,
-0.02245415,
-0.0470406264,
0.0632860288,
0.0219179858,
-0.0100081395,
-0.066877313,
0.0050151725,
0.0016120523,
0.0286076423,
0.0205550808,
0.0371182412,
0.0276746489,
-0.0373112373,
-0.0509889275,
0.0320765711,
0.0234713573,
0.0078672795,
0.029758133,
-0.0178001467,
-0.0228154212,
-0.0251822788,
-0.0549489148,
-0.0816692263,
0.0535310619,
-0.0215420537,
0.0159650221,
0.0294103678,
-0.0333474949,
-0.0558223948,
0.0008767145,
0.0416871868,
0.0575165972,
0.013039506,
-0.0588814542,
-0.0216730013,
0.0082719075,
0.0029724415,
0.0617689192,
0.0653561801,
-0.0449489951,
0.0365275666,
0.0376095064,
0.0414056592,
-0.033204399,
-0.0529961698,
0.0493563898,
0.039026361,
-0.0376318991,
-0.003978394,
0.0387821198,
0.0307075027,
-0.044605393,
-0.0406433977,
0.0621345006,
0.031379737,
-0.065553315,
0.0419238582,
-0.0439524241,
-0.0118281199,
0.0725263059,
0.0315399915,
-0.0509439036,
-0.0242934022,
0.006998749,
0.0222603511,
-0.0124737835,
-0.0108840745,
0.0178929456,
-0.0755851269,
0.0370558724,
-0.012348026,
-0.047992494,
-0.0116753876,
-0.0322786979,
-0.0206933003,
-0.0463454649,
0.0322686918,
-0.0150794601,
-0.0472193286,
-0.022653088,
0.042525731,
0.031473916,
-0.0470251143,
-0.0110489661,
-0.017226303,
-0.01272796,
0.0660488904,
-0.0207515992,
-0.0158604626,
-0.0529740825,
0.0377971232,
-0.015136675,
0.0509031303,
-0.0184627734,
0.013022773,
0.0221025515,
-0.0231831856,
0.0083081275,
0.0251370501,
-0.0400466137,
-0.0624966249,
-0.0258798841,
0.078905426,
-0.0026040031,
-0.0157817956,
0.0057208645,
-0.0359068103,
0.0334402919,
0.0384164676,
0.009551812,
-0.0481947698,
-0.042739857,
-0.026593769,
0.0319571421,
-0.0008749553,
-0.0338522866,
0.0373522118,
-0.0018216417,
-0.0417654738,
-0.0525636971,
0.0085446546,
-0.0060621393,
0.0580462031,
0.0202880744,
-0.0518847071,
0.0126172705,
0.0286294445,
-0.0636997893,
0.0178493503,
-0.0151166581,
0.0063004633,
-0.0468586385,
-0.0074072201,
0.0794220418,
-0.045590736,
-0.0120997382,
-0.0096985437,
-0.0474399477,
-0.0375455245,
0.0658984631,
0.0596661642,
0.0309139788,
0.0545759089,
0.0214236341,
-0.0180841014,
0.081691429,
0.0682090446,
-0.0242111869,
0.0145496363,
0.0790410787,
-0.0314206146,
-0.0110573247,
-0.0006598184,
-0.0277861338,
0.049239397,
0.0219812877,
0.0412472747,
-0.0606162883,
0.0062872516,
0.0740016177,
-0.0204102118,
0.0265020151,
-0.0146362726,
0.0064420435,
-0.0124251433,
0.0299132559,
0.0366197117,
-0.0061411685,
-0.0314445309,
-0.0456076488,
0.0084167151,
0.0428076535,
0.0420481004,
0.0581957437,
0.0251457673,
-0.0056043933,
-0.0232015084,
0.0103211254,
-0.0049069542,
0.0294983648,
0.0096876901,
0.0463782586,
-0.0041817068,
-0.0210773125,
0.02642758,
0.0203319024,
0.0068085464,
0.0660896227,
0.0462809801,
0.0171826966,
-0.0951972008,
0.0383216366,
-0.0714188814,
0.0360612981,
-0.0482198,
-0.0150619764,
0.0504031964,
-0.0352013484,
0.00794484,
-0.0329467468,
-0.0206318963,
0.0212088507,
-0.0179350134,
-0.0043625091,
-0.0166420434,
0.0272426847,
0.029078193,
0.0146501986,
0.0006558769,
0.0777991191,
-0.0478918664,
0.0784905106,
-0.0405512452,
0.0044734837,
-0.0416090339,
-0.0298906304,
0.0159360487,
-0.0117317587,
-0.002213083,
-0.0214031599,
-0.0359706059,
-0.0598779432,
0.0306959245,
0.0013366302,
0.0268006269,
-0.0697031543,
0.0532579012,
0.0455023907,
0.0033906256,
-0.0523950644,
0.0239342693,
-0.0368092209,
0.0155693181,
0.031274993,
-0.0194654968,
-5.852020832e-33,
-0.0168405566,
-0.0328126885,
0.0372025743,
0.059263505,
-0.0197883248,
0.0040689302,
-0.0270921905,
-0.0123543385,
-0.0053832219,
0.0211254265,
-0.0228525419,
-0.0003044279,
0.0193633027,
-0.0031744789,
0.0079928888,
-0.0130248144,
0.0442032851,
-0.0080245771,
-0.0309712496,
0.0041107568,
0.0112664122,
0.027272746,
0.0485062711,
-0.0721099377,
-0.0403137952,
0.0356438458,
-0.0122285942,
0.0176960472,
-0.0021157591,
0.059119042,
-0.0306797586,
0.0442952141,
0.0273541231,
-0.0893981159,
-0.0321310908,
0.0154290926,
-0.0831113756,
-0.0082837865,
-0.0498224124,
0.0229008384,
-0.0220096074,
-0.0527310297,
0.0620761625,
-0.0106423972,
-0.0390190184,
0.0052066916,
0.0499104485,
-0.0676522031,
-0.0178478956,
-0.0572195388,
-0.0867013931,
-0.0167501215,
-0.012790991,
-0.0266453512,
0.0052347728,
0.0198007971,
0.0172588099,
0.0482267663,
-0.0717315599,
0.0226437785,
-0.0049078623,
0.0075659757,
0.0522787385,
0.0571954139,
0.0133956205,
0.0227363985,
0.0468606874,
0.0202828925,
0.0054520918,
-0.0786530524,
0.0471545421,
0.0193341523,
0.0303731766,
0.0030804337,
0.0963579416,
-0.0291785058,
-0.0445510186,
0.0204785038,
0.0019835734,
0.0608792491,
-0.010378249,
0.0192698855,
0.0048925392,
-0.0003498926,
-0.0195963979,
-0.024713479,
-0.0195836555,
0.0060721259,
0.0041109994,
0.0497963168,
-0.0112889335,
0.0179608148,
-0.0068251025,
-0.0530844107,
0.0453979187,
0.000784268,
0.0081366058,
0.0187354442,
0.0233924016,
-0.0029397202,
-0.0364776291,
-0.0426554717,
-0.0243085586,
0.0568119586,
0.0210356414,
-0.0117345192,
0.0700289011,
0.0769631341,
-0.0326807052,
-0.0038552179,
-0.036093805,
0.0255012345,
0.0303703882,
0.0270956811,
0.0091104256,
-0.0033458739,
-0.0198943503,
0.0040809531,
0.0010236457,
-0.0001166417,
-0.0458184928,
0.054608196,
0.0023118509,
0.0456411354,
-0.008436895,
-0.0400612727,
-0.0522615127,
0.0496317111,
0.0332195349,
-0.0982082635,
-0.0428794213,
0.0097484402,
2.853e-7,
0.0046585123,
0.0245294012,
0.0350036621,
-0.0316315368,
0.0371568687,
0.027969528,
-0.0248648245,
-0.0042362902,
-0.0080612469,
0.0057542878,
0.0057369741,
0.0324058086,
0.0271299854,
0.0053685769,
-0.0521777123,
-0.037649706,
-0.0233241133,
0.022111794,
-0.0304345004,
0.028619213,
0.0005631547,
0.0596224107,
-0.0446304381,
-0.0312851593,
0.0109858718,
0.0072713299,
0.0634768307,
-0.0328742601,
0.0828906074,
0.0056847236,
-0.0303282272,
0.0218041446,
-0.0022441449,
0.0027091068,
-0.0156546887,
0.0254410543,
-0.0166088101,
0.0328155346,
0.0025764639,
-0.0407371968,
0.0307324231,
0.0308397412,
0.0068577137,
0.0028876914,
0.0246826001,
-0.1365768462,
-0.0130710695,
-0.0326962247,
-0.026653761,
-0.0134205157,
-0.0313134976,
0.0067687696,
-0.0151591608,
-0.0118425358,
-0.0132731581,
0.0060889507,
-0.0411088951,
-0.0865659863,
-0.0213776603,
-0.0055407649,
-0.0341400653,
-0.0181248616,
-0.0445103124,
-0.0398268662,
0.0418031514,
-0.0007900262,
-0.0108872913,
2.614004185e-34,
0.0002821921,
-0.0249590464,
0.0285891909,
0.0362073854,
-0.0029135616,
-0.0256471951,
0.0192526523,
0.0036259021,
0.0335011221,
-0.0365947708,
0.0034254983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06453v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06453v2 | Narrowing the Gap between Supervised and Unsupervised Sentence Representation Learning with Large Language Model | 2023-09-12T08:16:58 | 2023-12-19T12:13:25 | Mingxin Li, Richong Zhang, Zhijie Nie, Yongyi Mao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Sentence Representation Learning (SRL) is a fundamental task in Natural
Language Processing (NLP), with the Contrastive Learning of Sentence Embeddings
(CSE) being the mainstream technique due to its superior performance. An
intriguing phenomenon in CSE is the significant performance gap between
supervised and unsupervised methods, with their only difference lying in the
training data. Previous works attribute this performance gap to differences in
two representation properties (alignment and uniformity). However, since
alignment and uniformity only measure the results, they fail to answer "What
aspects of the training data contribute to the performance gap?" and "How can
the performance gap be narrowed?", In this paper, we conduct empirical
experiments to answer these "What" and "How" questions. We first answer the
"What" question by thoroughly comparing the behavior of supervised and
unsupervised CSE during their respective training processes. From the
comparison, we identify the similarity pattern as a key factor to the
performance gap, and introduce a metric, called Relative Fitting Difficulty
(RFD), to measure the complexity of the similarity pattern. Then, based on the
insights gained from the "What" question, we tackle the "How" question by
increasing the pattern complexity of the training data. We achieve this by
leveraging the In-Context Learning (ICL) capability of the Large Language Model
(LLM) to generate data that simulates complex patterns. By utilizing the
hierarchical patterns in the LLM-generated data, we effectively narrow the gap
between supervised and unsupervised CSE. We release our codes and appendix at
https://github.com/BDBC-KG-NLP/NGCSE. | [
0.0343048349,
0.0663315356,
-0.0011082474,
0.0744069591,
-0.0681212991,
0.0267708842,
-0.0119739762,
-0.0212686211,
0.0075878254,
-0.0588254929,
-0.0165728852,
-0.0187622122,
0.0006135274,
-0.0036993905,
0.0124724004,
-0.0506151952,
0.0186691117,
0.0117086647,
-0.0183232483,
-0.0052399971,
0.0366028063,
0.0038368606,
0.0080639487,
0.0076228753,
-0.0229404606,
-0.0447285548,
0.0148711512,
-0.0058441255,
0.0344267972,
-0.0264540277,
0.0422530398,
0.0089868,
0.0462930091,
0.0373459756,
0.0000018305,
-0.0515249781,
0.0160478931,
-0.018176619,
0.0099396082,
0.0537429005,
0.0614830591,
-0.0521329753,
0.0040179868,
0.015527633,
-0.0231211949,
-0.0179390088,
0.0335427113,
0.0801701993,
0.0237426758,
0.0888154507,
0.0007704028,
-0.0710497126,
0.0096900314,
-0.0113867503,
-0.0294301268,
-0.0200074296,
0.0130992541,
0.0249734167,
-0.0114016747,
0.0307667889,
-0.0377455242,
0.015248091,
0.0180844609,
0.0287787095,
0.0280223824,
0.0398855098,
-0.0275267921,
0.0147631411,
0.0025667967,
0.0916464999,
-0.0213964749,
-0.0213204008,
-0.0341867357,
0.0035507348,
-0.0257803071,
0.0044534397,
-0.0137079908,
0.0357158035,
0.0246530659,
0.0803192705,
0.0464973897,
0.0484583899,
0.0311938077,
-0.0260623712,
-0.0425511897,
0.0082465475,
0.0109490436,
-0.0632308125,
-0.0140072787,
0.0121534001,
-0.0616375208,
-0.0017460103,
-0.0104683768,
-0.0161267202,
-0.0650644228,
-0.0080623133,
-0.0344112292,
-0.0336614475,
0.0222368203,
-0.0237162132,
0.0359530412,
0.0257169548,
0.0110913534,
0.0472407565,
-0.0477788858,
0.0627960935,
-0.0236052182,
0.0003244982,
-0.0750221461,
-0.0115554463,
-0.0668797791,
0.0129970536,
-0.0113354484,
0.0162485968,
-0.0308099855,
-0.0640691146,
-0.0358084142,
0.0130283115,
-0.0196098611,
0.0410855524,
0.0081904009,
0.0121237282,
-0.0250796601,
0.0110276761,
-0.0018789199,
0.0156312771,
-0.0460614525,
-0.0045571988,
-0.0130033577,
-0.0016959099,
-0.0125983339,
0.0192305464,
0.0276338644,
-0.0104169669,
-0.0005981131,
0.0383695252,
0.0046891454,
-0.0579974614,
-0.0245444961,
0.0200287905,
-0.0315120034,
-0.0617394373,
-0.0277524516,
-0.0682303905,
0.0374636538,
0.0127252238,
0.0031984134,
-0.0047948174,
0.0026018599,
0.0078567695,
-0.0256488062,
0.067660816,
0.0253890455,
-0.0082871467,
-0.0279441979,
-0.0110436119,
0.05899629,
0.0399744287,
-0.0140289543,
-0.0153673645,
0.0200973786,
0.005747905,
-0.01154029,
-0.0029347267,
-0.0022623837,
0.005593989,
-0.0284796953,
0.0360127613,
0.0482826382,
0.0375922732,
0.0760056302,
0.037485037,
-0.0178068355,
-0.0206317548,
0.0476825722,
0.040202681,
0.0133510046,
0.0124017587,
0.0386744328,
0.0351385511,
-0.0213328172,
0.0362366028,
-0.0299655702,
-0.011093488,
0.0147391586,
0.0223117042,
0.0435793437,
0.0233781077,
-0.0275154915,
0.0037979819,
-0.0078338794,
-0.0381897911,
-0.0139030833,
-0.015049573,
0.0248729829,
0.0017312387,
-0.031710431,
0.0060556019,
0.0540875793,
-0.0029161545,
-0.0361035205,
0.0493285879,
-0.0017951925,
0.064904213,
0.036759261,
-0.0257374626,
0.0246483572,
-0.003528788,
-0.0242507569,
0.0427670293,
0.0143728452,
-0.0122578824,
0.0154068163,
-0.0354467519,
-0.0448852666,
-0.0622447021,
0.0364833474,
0.00339164,
0.0216918308,
-0.0192698222,
0.0279116612,
-0.0490115285,
-0.0148298759,
0.0400342122,
-0.0173224732,
-0.0411985032,
0.0218099579,
0.0246165879,
0.036954727,
0.0000749759,
-0.034353327,
0.0137471883,
0.0111675588,
-0.069710426,
-0.0136333266,
-0.0155580165,
-0.0923625529,
-0.0883609205,
0.0077108485,
-0.0727197528,
-0.021575233,
0.0827932432,
-0.0643222332,
-0.0167796649,
-0.0102156438,
-0.0369666517,
0.0490657091,
-0.0230500996,
0.0033046284,
0.0023209571,
0.0172496028,
-0.0393592566,
0.0846263543,
-0.0230961051,
0.0487918407,
-0.0064764442,
0.0417373106,
0.0129803978,
-0.0039277878,
-0.0397024192,
-0.0168388598,
0.0202439148,
0.0079059685,
0.0232560858,
-0.012005358,
-0.0439298041,
-0.0067084273,
-0.0819505528,
0.0172458142,
-0.0205724146,
0.0049809734,
0.04727,
0.0108019523,
0.0062729255,
-0.0240330286,
-0.0396450348,
-0.0162335131,
0.0027700388,
0.0159943253,
0.0690064058,
-0.0082028527,
-0.0434765369,
-0.0362625122,
0.0083680814,
-0.0141763836,
0.0682688877,
-0.051788494,
0.0334699675,
-0.0844393298,
0.0782505944,
0.0236947928,
0.0035849351,
0.0049058562,
-0.0265586041,
-0.0149233891,
0.0028371357,
0.0638877749,
0.0746281222,
0.0258728322,
0.0197434779,
0.0458455943,
0.0395239778,
-0.0290243179,
-0.0163990501,
-0.0285448655,
0.0172997657,
-0.0555581041,
-0.0331237353,
0.0158938095,
0.084793739,
0.0249545332,
-0.0046310266,
-0.0230830014,
0.0023299723,
0.0106532471,
0.0289631244,
-0.0183207039,
0.0156674385,
-0.0069631608,
-0.0007867026,
-0.0435698293,
-0.0384851582,
0.037254367,
-0.0303163957,
0.0081382236,
-0.0794417039,
-0.0420503654,
-0.0555586815,
0.0507388301,
0.0472344458,
0.0414786451,
-0.0099536739,
-0.0120192943,
-0.0259620734,
-0.0042240722,
0.0159286,
0.0081934631,
0.0179067217,
0.0249566622,
-0.0064731361,
-0.031382814,
-0.0617388599,
-0.0516883023,
-0.0620214269,
-0.0248492528,
0.0035937002,
0.0459608957,
-0.0089027835,
-0.0240035951,
-0.0190717056,
0.0012957148,
0.005000982,
0.0299686044,
-0.0111756306,
-0.0360807888,
0.0603768304,
0.0463968292,
-0.0001431046,
0.0102740368,
0.0051837382,
0.046892453,
0.0408598073,
0.033812277,
0.0409134068,
-0.0743155479,
0.0062138061,
-0.0025884935,
-0.0459745899,
-0.0053624492,
0.0272185225,
0.038122084,
-0.0107464967,
-0.0180931147,
0.1288514286,
0.0330999494,
-0.0194124226,
0.0295605864,
0.0325289369,
0.0374568291,
0.043854516,
0.0024390661,
-0.0410545208,
-0.0250525083,
-0.0042659524,
-0.0193388071,
0.0059851608,
-0.0121510699,
-0.0032430589,
-0.1182576418,
0.0154540427,
0.0188386962,
-0.0288184993,
-0.0577303357,
-0.0431784913,
-0.0162810683,
0.0067112655,
0.0470955186,
-0.0004203633,
-0.0334306099,
-0.0050539309,
0.0062743844,
-0.0527000204,
-0.0721949786,
0.0106632831,
-0.0615344308,
0.0438023023,
0.0390754864,
0.0280229412,
0.0169202629,
0.0019547474,
0.0016027105,
-0.0332714655,
-0.0136618828,
-0.0025067744,
0.0386493392,
-0.0209672321,
-0.0231124796,
-0.0435687043,
0.0231573172,
-0.0565251783,
-0.0191965234,
0.0025231533,
0.0760266259,
0.008245768,
0.0087478505,
-0.0231047478,
-0.0076188068,
0.0007190894,
0.0918520093,
0.0301289316,
-0.054831028,
-0.0322141908,
0.0060352227,
0.016791502,
-0.0158251636,
-0.0133665502,
0.0381425619,
0.0210276805,
0.0525326841,
-0.059128914,
-0.0580243245,
-0.0088786772,
0.0172187164,
-0.0106104817,
0.033750549,
-0.0222479515,
-0.0289757326,
-0.0293030087,
0.0228652507,
-0.0436722301,
0.0080939466,
-0.0109114815,
-0.0120806489,
0.0017351283,
-0.0070274854,
-0.0239246357,
-0.0613359436,
-0.0630391315,
-0.0355711319,
-0.0210370235,
-0.0180900078,
-0.0000891965,
0.0756016001,
0.0165966842,
0.0003984686,
0.0748230293,
0.0392574184,
-0.0226460528,
0.0086105643,
0.0170015004,
0.0208637193,
0.0151013192,
0.0445704944,
-0.0258256905,
-0.0004870704,
0.0337601602,
0.0626095012,
-0.0103853885,
-0.0142691648,
0.0483282842,
-0.0126623884,
0.0643303171,
-0.00928808,
-0.0078986222,
-0.0171152223,
-0.0069382293,
-0.0171422288,
-0.0423478261,
-0.0290948115,
-0.0201036595,
0.040391624,
0.0364105552,
-0.0042702025,
0.0456797965,
0.0022750373,
0.0289722942,
-0.0063015865,
0.0022858789,
0.0276468545,
-0.0040737274,
0.0066450769,
0.0271701943,
-0.0548559204,
-0.0221560039,
-0.0290376898,
0.0244515445,
-0.0114106545,
0.0326963104,
0.0151849948,
0.0060828975,
-0.0512845591,
0.0038358807,
-0.0806076229,
0.0453698672,
-0.0189999025,
0.0048993859,
0.0815829858,
-0.0935536027,
0.0084753083,
-0.0397474393,
0.0058186557,
-0.0309735071,
0.0437925979,
-0.0218229573,
-0.0049925321,
0.0291594751,
0.0210097842,
-0.0307558831,
0.0120275794,
0.0913247168,
0.0312978104,
0.0283144601,
0.0257063378,
-0.0148230381,
-0.05407653,
-0.0287886355,
0.0516389124,
0.0399672687,
-0.0218777787,
0.0085026613,
-0.0011625255,
-0.0498127677,
0.0149116553,
0.001765198,
-0.0225130972,
-0.0165530611,
0.0321757644,
0.0342668481,
-0.0036311045,
0.005133125,
-0.0292853359,
-0.0028300383,
-0.0029242975,
-0.0495702289,
-0.038145408,
-6.011535783e-33,
0.0174546763,
-0.0055629942,
-0.0281517804,
-0.0202231538,
-0.013009158,
0.0283236019,
-0.0171913747,
-0.0157835037,
-0.0117220059,
0.0283934008,
0.004725032,
-0.0090843122,
-0.0102235153,
0.0588077828,
-0.0144319776,
-0.004184688,
0.0471904874,
-0.0062315799,
-0.0165243484,
0.000897911,
0.0201101471,
0.0507718958,
0.0240917373,
-0.0672549382,
-0.018367162,
-0.0400968008,
0.0173614193,
0.0282039549,
0.029454641,
0.0573354065,
-0.0546318628,
0.0571263433,
0.0372753479,
-0.0098646376,
-0.0136914486,
0.052330628,
-0.0561650954,
-0.0158174299,
0.0044064862,
0.0118198516,
-0.0391253904,
-0.0299865901,
0.0183262806,
-0.0329989493,
0.0044256058,
-0.0316235535,
0.0314307958,
-0.0433839373,
-0.0136869987,
-0.0126226759,
-0.0658107921,
0.0021557023,
-0.0090657361,
0.0085040778,
0.0020656206,
0.027278224,
0.0191555098,
0.0684486404,
-0.0507771224,
-0.0207754858,
-0.039515093,
0.0515101813,
0.0252586585,
0.0234203562,
0.0061955089,
0.0871155858,
0.0157632977,
-0.0341704488,
-0.0176562332,
-0.0348611698,
-0.013442399,
0.031123329,
0.0157018397,
0.0890826806,
0.0574202277,
0.0202236902,
-0.0973500311,
-0.0006296439,
-0.0061166706,
-0.0038761459,
0.056061171,
0.0311606657,
-0.0673556998,
-0.0190684479,
-0.0197583493,
0.0025283755,
-0.0204692185,
-0.0121287629,
0.0458804742,
0.0210457444,
0.0024704712,
-0.0295021087,
0.0118810218,
-0.0870103464,
-0.0321097076,
0.0065411772,
-0.0230569914,
-0.0212331526,
0.0031187946,
0.0098965336,
-0.0547560155,
-0.0468480624,
-0.0197477937,
0.0024613501,
0.0026124804,
-0.0058913375,
0.0945774391,
-0.0262517985,
-0.0748527274,
-0.0023520838,
-0.0112049244,
-0.0456559435,
-0.046471335,
0.0047363108,
0.0385681465,
-0.0069730054,
-0.0176251605,
0.069429107,
0.0433152579,
-0.0095714014,
-0.0206331089,
-0.0228919443,
-0.0162260309,
0.0265644342,
0.0072939475,
-0.0146387061,
-0.0547222458,
0.042958945,
0.010977421,
-0.0486866906,
-0.012668754,
-0.0032965594,
2.407e-7,
0.0280379597,
0.015871251,
0.023021929,
0.0013844821,
0.0552094206,
0.0563355759,
-0.0122111235,
0.0394752212,
-0.0287107173,
-0.0140860388,
0.0216103829,
0.0275732763,
0.0526853651,
-0.0169418659,
-0.0955022573,
0.0417953804,
-0.0777063444,
-0.0367344283,
-0.0523789749,
0.0171577185,
0.0855395198,
0.1167831868,
0.0057347626,
-0.0085015912,
0.0060649705,
-0.0348782763,
0.0787286907,
-0.0585304908,
-0.0128819952,
-0.0080980975,
-0.0568193533,
0.026089577,
0.006756925,
-0.0023163797,
0.0009020563,
0.054194387,
-0.0054135676,
0.0503791608,
0.0341760032,
-0.0070961765,
-0.0122429738,
-0.0017820921,
0.010940833,
-0.0556439683,
0.0643887594,
-0.0742045045,
-0.0335284621,
-0.0453977659,
-0.0260800682,
-0.0073402436,
0.0307743195,
0.0065994523,
-0.0170124695,
-0.0174706448,
0.041706156,
-0.0120030157,
-0.0242829341,
-0.0686380938,
-0.0229958277,
0.0421523079,
-0.0415665954,
-0.0182126053,
-0.0150233284,
0.0445599556,
0.0954580233,
-0.0118201943,
0.0183296446,
2.674097201e-34,
0.0264173523,
0.0066086845,
0.0372493677,
-0.0065347701,
0.0262644421,
-0.0360742286,
-0.0403042845,
-0.018432809,
0.0329623669,
-0.0701738596,
0.0284552313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06009v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06009v1 | Content Reduction, Surprisal and Information Density Estimation for Long Documents | 2023-09-12T07:08:22 | 2023-09-12T07:08:22 | Shaoxiong Ji, Wei Sun, Pekka Marttinen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many computational linguistic methods have been proposed to study the
information content of languages. We consider two interesting research
questions: 1) how is information distributed over long documents, and 2) how
does content reduction, such as token selection and text summarization, affect
the information density in long documents. We present four criteria for
information density estimation for long documents, including surprisal,
entropy, uniform information density, and lexical density. Among those
criteria, the first three adopt the measures from information theory. We
propose an attention-based word selection method for clinical notes and study
machine summarization for multiple-domain documents. Our findings reveal the
systematic difference in information density of long text in various domains.
Empirical results on automated medical coding from long clinical notes show the
effectiveness of the attention-based word selection method. | [
0.0429787114,
0.0113490438,
0.0022483375,
-0.0301782973,
-0.051381398,
0.0144912414,
-0.0363750681,
0.0599523745,
-0.0681731701,
-0.0080041019,
0.0304024592,
-0.0519000813,
0.0714772493,
-0.0148992417,
0.0253931675,
-0.0727066919,
0.0074107274,
0.003926957,
0.0521922968,
0.0289511532,
-0.0083853547,
-0.0356383994,
0.0413584523,
-0.0128767658,
0.0020450016,
0.018634649,
0.0187319349,
0.0096570933,
-0.0060877982,
-0.062740244,
-0.045989573,
0.023143772,
-0.0110740522,
-0.0400225632,
0.0000019381,
-0.0617813952,
-0.0417269617,
0.0181538854,
-0.0051057772,
0.0145407533,
0.0643035173,
-0.0869483799,
0.0003515597,
-0.0002334755,
0.016151512,
-0.0042825905,
0.0437846035,
0.0625529587,
-0.0024258501,
0.0767779499,
-0.0279999319,
-0.0114232711,
0.0201785956,
-0.0245921127,
0.0380000845,
-0.0086272713,
0.0465975218,
0.0072566839,
0.0448607616,
-0.0223934781,
-0.0503113121,
0.0373595506,
-0.0062172278,
-0.0076017375,
0.0417597555,
0.0522822216,
-0.016572997,
-0.0144722201,
0.0259587485,
0.0278369281,
-0.021138357,
-0.0120311817,
0.0344741866,
0.0231345929,
-0.0064662374,
-0.0294114724,
-0.0708541423,
0.0220649038,
-0.0329786129,
0.0116485385,
0.043040771,
0.0351315737,
-0.0172533859,
-0.0266916268,
-0.0576381311,
-0.0079297153,
-0.0051486925,
-0.0699877143,
0.0041849553,
-0.026652161,
-0.0274289921,
-0.0675287694,
0.0257407557,
0.0249474943,
0.0127710169,
0.0018074053,
-0.039746318,
-0.0914772525,
0.0556802489,
-0.073426187,
-0.0263299048,
-0.0141868945,
0.0175849777,
0.0507384613,
0.0183693916,
0.0120056989,
0.0308374781,
0.0037597495,
-0.0454729572,
0.0235856567,
0.002101751,
0.0152849518,
-0.0455269255,
0.0548585169,
0.0122482646,
-0.0271485969,
-0.0421844684,
0.0004231113,
0.0463446975,
0.0007944744,
-0.0015987125,
-0.0113234464,
-0.0238313843,
0.0295097828,
0.0189719442,
-0.0008820002,
-0.0166421477,
-0.0195107479,
-0.0229076985,
-0.0073729847,
-0.0052183722,
0.078060545,
0.0247770771,
-0.0099122776,
-0.0065611629,
0.0580323823,
-0.0104016047,
-0.0507245436,
-0.0020717401,
-0.0287211575,
-0.0458629392,
-0.0244623199,
-0.0071871825,
-0.0643289909,
-0.0155410049,
0.0155526493,
-0.0105174733,
-0.0379855894,
-0.0102856252,
0.0177185014,
-0.0577790216,
0.0187039301,
-0.053648416,
0.0136210257,
0.0319838226,
-0.0039456533,
0.0493659936,
0.0386619121,
0.0377335213,
0.0144470651,
0.0352948233,
-0.0482213795,
0.018705545,
0.0014269887,
0.0235005133,
-0.0050043408,
0.0057320609,
0.0001709476,
0.0076867035,
-0.0125735933,
0.0136753377,
0.0952265412,
-0.0146770161,
-0.0241375063,
0.0350966677,
0.096701175,
0.0189056844,
-0.0070349844,
0.0122504458,
-0.0018362452,
0.0046702689,
0.070016332,
-0.0010463488,
0.0153346229,
0.0111553222,
0.0302524958,
0.1025926173,
-0.0182769299,
-0.014461956,
-0.0392758884,
-0.0317571573,
-0.0086918287,
0.0096054254,
-0.0468546338,
0.0577486008,
0.0089859096,
-0.0365071222,
0.0417699851,
0.0381076671,
-0.0302710608,
0.0009815056,
0.0085578524,
-0.0347419642,
0.0132202683,
0.0556133017,
-0.0467339866,
0.0527993999,
-0.0423333049,
0.0447179787,
0.0132919066,
0.0125373611,
0.0147956563,
-0.0060240263,
-0.0464903042,
0.0076717613,
0.0111696497,
0.002829866,
-0.0241811145,
-0.0165721942,
0.0407146849,
0.0011692338,
-0.0275128558,
-0.0526163094,
0.0317785256,
0.0161151979,
-0.0178964026,
0.0020259747,
-0.0150238667,
0.0538573675,
0.0209431499,
-0.0232228395,
0.0430649258,
0.029568065,
-0.0298512671,
-0.0104475142,
-0.020523984,
-0.0127291987,
0.0081194714,
-0.0104987761,
-0.0622249022,
0.0291277245,
-0.0473743714,
0.0426711775,
-0.0190262068,
0.0068057617,
-0.1085093692,
0.060672868,
0.0104239723,
0.0606357381,
0.0340303816,
0.0229679476,
-0.0449143089,
0.0356158316,
-0.0236022808,
0.0437246971,
0.0310225897,
-0.0501714945,
0.0155566046,
-0.0352103412,
0.0291352794,
0.0225713812,
-0.0219343212,
-0.0130340364,
0.052979026,
-0.0203421041,
0.0176993143,
-0.0664850324,
-0.0972850025,
-0.0183348153,
-0.0066495463,
0.0237809606,
0.011106573,
0.0489692278,
-0.0118297171,
-0.0027401692,
-0.0153034534,
-0.0439918824,
-0.0196118094,
0.0074043777,
0.0466139652,
0.0176004376,
0.0064361831,
-0.0274573788,
-0.0346782096,
-0.0046011047,
0.0325718634,
0.0539775379,
-0.085566476,
-0.0292676184,
0.068678692,
-0.0175747313,
-0.011298649,
-0.0119908089,
-0.0628021508,
-0.0085561024,
-0.0280900765,
0.057483919,
0.042273432,
0.0514840148,
0.0149216866,
0.0627099946,
0.0150351981,
0.0170332268,
-0.0068786419,
-0.0632183701,
0.058441665,
0.0086232377,
-0.0585666224,
0.0754769966,
0.0478697866,
0.0462443978,
0.0133664561,
-0.0019485006,
-0.0552697666,
-0.0325145125,
0.0172547475,
-0.0257504564,
0.0143051976,
-0.0283440296,
0.0412159376,
0.0155721977,
-0.0544063449,
0.0709344819,
-0.0236295965,
0.0301948451,
-0.0728368536,
-0.0033679279,
-0.0325110741,
0.0209484119,
0.0086628832,
0.0136405695,
0.0085126134,
-0.0412915051,
0.0282802321,
-0.0019937723,
0.0208692737,
-0.0177395996,
0.059683226,
-0.0057162917,
0.0081990194,
-0.0231356546,
-0.0121750813,
0.0176488254,
-0.0630650371,
0.0179949198,
-0.0202411637,
0.0545368604,
-0.0344703123,
-0.0404994562,
0.0279194247,
0.0471680574,
0.0476079807,
0.010791827,
-0.0097214766,
0.01023129,
0.0301965941,
0.0286815204,
-0.001170403,
0.0128742969,
-0.0529124998,
-0.0044663977,
0.0651826784,
-0.0184203945,
0.0487160459,
0.0470207147,
-0.0272390433,
-0.0204909369,
-0.0528771617,
-0.0234032962,
0.0184609797,
0.0410353579,
-0.0338432528,
0.0485448167,
0.1100763902,
0.0284968242,
-0.0755524784,
0.0103477985,
-0.0061490955,
-0.0062265373,
-0.0285964552,
0.0065346896,
-0.0420182832,
-0.0002103984,
-0.0008227,
0.0238187946,
-0.0265297033,
-0.0281357653,
-0.0101084029,
-0.0256557744,
0.0169462357,
-0.0041985908,
-0.034167733,
-0.0559246466,
-0.0821473375,
0.0153822061,
0.0255913045,
-0.0543389544,
0.016405765,
-0.0445016399,
-0.0199806169,
-0.008934536,
-0.0896277577,
0.0048740692,
-0.0475820638,
-0.0049455608,
0.0129621951,
0.0565545037,
0.0521103404,
-0.0325172618,
-0.0193498302,
0.0221204571,
-0.0036685683,
-0.014824097,
-0.0282703917,
0.1077447534,
0.0154411634,
0.0047133551,
-0.0171013903,
0.0269309375,
0.0105022751,
0.0230752937,
0.01144276,
0.0412657447,
-0.0142352534,
-0.0747152716,
-0.0465871468,
0.0256481487,
0.01865834,
0.0710698441,
0.0479377098,
-0.0102656726,
-0.0558703505,
-0.0076242071,
-0.002799667,
-0.0137221497,
0.0125982901,
-0.0061902218,
-0.0475434549,
-0.1034592986,
-0.0792775229,
-0.0089749703,
0.0294892378,
0.0112267742,
0.0057714605,
0.0600809306,
0.0029367253,
0.0022847366,
-0.0607692152,
-0.0253619328,
0.0257013664,
-0.0106687676,
-0.0801274702,
-0.0222780742,
0.0134286154,
-0.022180846,
0.004792762,
-0.0062262132,
-0.0287945438,
-0.0154629089,
-0.0099582793,
-0.0021917028,
0.0191078242,
0.0159163289,
-0.0208228081,
-0.0119481087,
0.0446543843,
0.0158044696,
-0.0475220494,
0.038472984,
-0.0181120876,
-0.0314699113,
0.0124412356,
0.0115630375,
-0.0154492073,
0.0315156877,
0.0157583058,
-0.0212583505,
-0.0068197977,
-0.0441772789,
-0.0064882948,
0.0577909574,
-0.0007095451,
-0.002164908,
0.0070959842,
0.0122841205,
0.0077612586,
0.0025842644,
0.0254724361,
-0.0129610775,
0.0024848699,
-0.0031849921,
0.0122530684,
-0.0092566116,
0.0708663687,
-0.0540089011,
-0.0870168433,
-0.0029603329,
0.0487165861,
-0.0416788086,
0.0313167386,
0.0416028909,
-0.0206763316,
-0.0098941,
-0.025588017,
-0.0233129859,
0.0341896899,
0.003056943,
-0.0049683843,
0.0172487907,
0.0262095109,
0.0053169671,
0.0395997539,
-0.0539169498,
0.0150559237,
-0.0135028251,
0.0083508622,
0.0175801292,
-0.0414121114,
0.040394742,
-0.0387948528,
0.030064147,
-0.0333729833,
0.0499665216,
0.0154181402,
0.0152095882,
-0.0361619294,
0.0087091094,
-0.0044770497,
0.0145578776,
0.1111399233,
0.0054304618,
-0.019010365,
0.0094636567,
-0.0583419241,
-0.0309218522,
0.0180087127,
0.0064352527,
0.0316721499,
-0.0197377168,
-0.0020924765,
-0.0589296296,
-0.0265782364,
0.0442597084,
-0.0220035054,
0.0115334997,
0.009697889,
0.0662341267,
0.0259344261,
0.0036943713,
0.0070188572,
-0.0359012671,
0.0356612802,
-0.0268849339,
-0.0243568644,
0.0317934565,
-5.997799764e-33,
0.0022266738,
-0.0368252844,
-0.0354341529,
0.0368260071,
-0.0209360979,
0.0376363136,
-0.0620814227,
-0.025448503,
0.0041036741,
0.0273307245,
-0.0363468491,
0.0066492893,
0.001472685,
0.0116530703,
0.0013054282,
0.0087000374,
0.0083981585,
0.0077022328,
-0.0416545384,
0.0467542484,
0.0170467105,
0.01174575,
0.0387296304,
-0.0465420224,
0.026412677,
0.0193898864,
0.0534529164,
-0.0226095691,
0.0555727817,
0.0226959083,
-0.0077237096,
-0.0140643725,
0.045491375,
-0.040716771,
-0.0400062613,
0.0542215966,
-0.0646625608,
-0.0382893644,
0.0242993981,
-0.0527167954,
-0.0391778685,
-0.0815227032,
0.047077015,
-0.0211623386,
0.0191314332,
-0.0165885668,
0.06188545,
-0.0141385943,
-0.065905042,
-0.0678218007,
-0.0334917195,
0.0773324743,
-0.0262944233,
-0.0028720764,
0.0194560327,
-0.0310746729,
-0.009376863,
0.0133761149,
0.0064887055,
0.0071444446,
0.0416119695,
0.0735123158,
-0.0514643751,
-0.0474090315,
0.0031094325,
0.0489626154,
0.0025276281,
0.0116133988,
-0.020757366,
0.0510990694,
-0.0328806862,
-0.0020675005,
0.0272850711,
-0.012123921,
0.0714447871,
-0.0481273308,
-0.0751339197,
0.0388263389,
-0.0663071647,
0.0502610393,
0.0282112211,
-0.0290407483,
-0.0703996494,
-0.0160345659,
0.0289903712,
0.0174290631,
0.0075935423,
-0.0261270963,
-0.0241339318,
0.0040299259,
-0.0179892555,
-0.0225513037,
0.0247663073,
-0.0116825448,
0.0313173011,
0.0062132287,
0.0240617897,
0.0686810538,
0.000912529,
-0.0591373965,
-0.0290206969,
0.0292975083,
0.0046396693,
0.0284632426,
0.0062569948,
0.0224635452,
0.0277100038,
-0.0163573269,
-0.027078772,
-0.0341392085,
0.0405132063,
-0.0244883895,
-0.008311077,
0.0182981044,
0.0224736091,
0.0099909166,
0.0238969829,
0.0218205191,
-0.0138415843,
-0.0564919263,
-0.0333098248,
-0.0194741245,
0.0403920375,
-0.0029315029,
-0.0375091136,
-0.0162064712,
-0.0385226421,
0.0474988632,
0.0455624163,
-0.0178306717,
-0.0084828576,
0.0247533638,
2.783e-7,
0.0736161619,
0.0499306023,
0.0568636097,
-0.0266824253,
0.0399982445,
-0.0319404192,
0.0127328616,
0.0303931199,
-0.0408433862,
-0.0266881958,
0.0349850878,
-0.0097612198,
0.0365100279,
0.0004169399,
-0.1291564256,
-0.053579472,
-0.0361535288,
-0.0209106039,
-0.0168211889,
-0.0125205554,
0.050024502,
0.0700319558,
-0.035878364,
0.005487483,
0.0075680334,
-0.0007793964,
-0.0095560234,
-0.0212631524,
0.0264869742,
0.0294215195,
0.0392880514,
-0.0179044902,
0.0044655562,
0.0140927164,
-0.0397077799,
-0.0361417644,
0.009854408,
0.0984175578,
-0.0216600075,
0.0272284951,
0.0245958213,
-0.0158132929,
-0.0003757938,
-0.0029683856,
0.0522045121,
-0.0083919801,
-0.0209067501,
-0.0165073927,
0.0067747743,
-0.0111958692,
0.0106390556,
0.0253196843,
-0.0199988484,
0.0495207384,
0.013647167,
-0.0379150957,
-0.0095380489,
-0.0511582494,
-0.0131059214,
0.0235778335,
-0.01008566,
-0.0229318962,
-0.0178836323,
-0.0267664548,
0.0451035127,
-0.0849182904,
-0.0034983326,
2.526749673e-34,
0.0632598698,
-0.0363458209,
-0.0285295919,
-0.0170580726,
0.0059417193,
-0.0589805245,
0.0073424918,
0.0217959937,
0.0317727104,
-0.0837480575,
-0.0055108028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07927v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.07927v3 | Kid-Whisper: Towards Bridging the Performance Gap in Automatic Speech Recognition for Children VS. Adults | 2023-09-12T06:58:18 | 2024-05-15T07:05:32 | Ahmed Adel Attia, Jing Liu, Wei Ai, Dorottya Demszky, Carol Espy-Wilson | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Recent advancements in Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems,
exemplified by Whisper, have demonstrated the potential of these systems to
approach human-level performance given sufficient data. However, this progress
doesn't readily extend to ASR for children due to the limited availability of
suitable child-specific databases and the distinct characteristics of
children's speech. A recent study investigated leveraging the My Science Tutor
(MyST) children's speech corpus to enhance Whisper's performance in recognizing
children's speech. They were able to demonstrate some improvement on a limited
testset. This paper builds on these findings by enhancing the utility of the
MyST dataset through more efficient data preprocessing. We reduce the Word
Error Rate (WER) on the MyST testset 13.93% to 9.11% with Whisper-Small and
from 13.23% to 8.61% with Whisper-Medium and show that this improvement can be
generalized to unseen datasets. We also highlight important challenges towards
improving children's ASR performance. The results showcase the viable and
efficient integration of Whisper for effective children's speech recognition. | [
-0.0205856469,
0.0340897143,
-0.0072302651,
0.0364391916,
-0.0048426515,
-0.0073535414,
0.0829572976,
-0.0055832192,
0.0006051798,
-0.0110829677,
-0.046446614,
-0.0208082795,
0.0640538782,
-0.0137732187,
-0.0048219739,
-0.0782855153,
0.0255846083,
-0.0784007981,
0.0179606266,
-0.006911092,
0.0011491438,
-0.0032448873,
-0.0534403659,
0.0491226353,
-0.0181070827,
-0.0013357598,
0.0314982608,
0.0236664973,
0.0140953194,
-0.0238709133,
-0.0080551421,
0.0151378242,
-0.0003064349,
0.0804017857,
0.0000018545,
-0.0219439659,
0.0155058857,
0.0136258416,
-0.0611471012,
0.0470946208,
0.0496698394,
0.0601472668,
-0.0183240194,
0.0442772061,
-0.0240780618,
-0.0086434288,
0.0451871268,
-0.0289358292,
-0.0032744273,
0.0391042642,
-0.0029910284,
0.0149994306,
0.0224550925,
0.0337881744,
0.0234848056,
-0.0110051921,
-0.0283026174,
0.0090991156,
0.0587532595,
-0.0579803772,
0.0064181392,
0.0585897639,
-0.0212832652,
-0.0329499021,
0.0215578154,
-0.003621303,
-0.045937974,
-0.0408137329,
-0.0391745344,
0.0426222086,
0.0049683251,
-0.0236411896,
0.0200152136,
-0.0006494212,
-0.046449203,
0.0063271415,
-0.0238892548,
0.0159142241,
-0.0421505459,
-0.0125808893,
-0.0168579761,
0.007227025,
0.0157084223,
-0.0140579641,
0.0084691234,
0.026855614,
-0.0186314397,
-0.0461774431,
-0.0077777896,
-0.0077884346,
0.0545634031,
-0.0011813056,
0.0456289202,
-0.0118111353,
-0.0351521485,
-0.0065670339,
-0.0686371475,
-0.0721187443,
-0.026599098,
0.0170281548,
0.0328289717,
0.0324894004,
-0.0500415154,
0.0182132367,
0.0370160751,
0.0620458871,
0.0347391814,
0.0266370475,
-0.0129612507,
0.011175666,
0.0142646516,
0.0181530546,
-0.0319956653,
0.0182233229,
-0.0212297887,
-0.0164219644,
-0.0523466542,
-0.007442228,
-0.0222943276,
0.0036824499,
0.0375684723,
0.0074910284,
-0.033409398,
-0.0312883183,
0.0449204929,
0.0264989696,
0.0320147723,
0.0529118963,
0.0302516799,
-0.0790765136,
-0.0345584564,
0.0018114316,
0.0773943067,
0.0300376248,
0.0151450876,
0.0383095145,
-0.005888511,
-0.0376302265,
-0.0150582585,
0.0247912221,
-0.0022997016,
-0.0570555888,
0.021061521,
-0.0405173525,
-0.0017839794,
0.0206149127,
0.0081713647,
-0.0325468816,
-0.0177026559,
-0.0388603434,
0.0120306415,
0.0477873832,
-0.0476570055,
-0.0179546718,
0.0071582408,
0.0154953441,
-0.0078334296,
0.0414135903,
0.0629849359,
-0.0247392319,
0.0324466713,
-0.0260293279,
-0.0220304262,
0.0429532826,
-0.0327941217,
0.0151906759,
-0.0042445185,
-0.0389885604,
-0.0065551433,
0.0262359921,
0.0371888094,
0.030989591,
-0.0265716314,
-0.0110423956,
0.071934171,
0.0751757175,
0.0007540048,
0.0119672725,
0.0019306762,
0.0355688706,
0.0643660501,
-0.0272133779,
-0.0279172715,
-0.0105835814,
-0.0241770465,
-0.0144372778,
0.0217928533,
0.0346926786,
-0.0141414134,
-0.0037862649,
-0.082479395,
-0.025963055,
-0.0188186765,
0.0689685568,
0.0353128649,
-0.0324728228,
-0.0429324508,
-0.0091110012,
0.0092931045,
-0.0760187581,
0.0379906707,
-0.0709034279,
0.0192427933,
0.0590953119,
0.0189060085,
-0.052270472,
-0.0105422148,
0.0298842676,
-0.0404885858,
0.0192918368,
-0.0546070263,
0.0139751164,
0.0496366993,
-0.0675769895,
-0.0109280553,
0.0572098866,
0.0185299739,
0.0315874256,
0.027784111,
0.0164513905,
0.0094909556,
-0.0303130001,
0.0167501699,
0.0056746034,
-0.0186540242,
-0.0148750367,
0.039924521,
0.0175093357,
0.0692449287,
0.0408064947,
-0.0091265114,
-0.0267769303,
0.0319522358,
0.0351936743,
0.0252526626,
0.021790009,
-0.0572888851,
-0.0128525896,
0.0483786017,
-0.0376574695,
0.0109267598,
0.02572768,
0.0386784598,
-0.0464299172,
0.0615322962,
-0.0664271861,
0.0378115736,
-0.0161507968,
0.0661259741,
-0.0178176053,
-0.0261180699,
0.0236903094,
-0.0300120506,
0.0195938554,
-0.0291427094,
-0.01428176,
-0.0120985955,
-0.0076398226,
-0.0647393912,
-0.0147941895,
-0.0167045854,
-0.0339162648,
0.0965099633,
-0.0272689201,
-0.0375342146,
-0.0692364648,
0.0178934354,
-0.062128704,
-0.0238646753,
0.0095434776,
0.0031104581,
-0.0116352607,
0.0194467716,
0.0024808985,
-0.0100234477,
0.0219539069,
0.0352256857,
-0.0394491926,
0.0001204485,
-0.0297063552,
-0.0521644056,
-0.0277029332,
-0.0454792306,
0.0227839835,
-0.0106182983,
-0.0172702558,
-0.0068909191,
-0.0100384401,
-0.0382975228,
-0.0115857739,
0.0072479844,
0.0331293382,
-0.0196088962,
-0.0104295164,
0.0259398073,
-0.0108147571,
0.0221876819,
0.0713241547,
-0.0332705528,
-0.017179491,
0.018753048,
-0.0401758514,
-0.0606039912,
0.0009030063,
0.0582475848,
0.015607574,
0.0568732582,
0.0154726394,
-0.0362324342,
0.0002310638,
0.035220731,
0.0378630795,
-0.0210045595,
0.031825617,
-0.0039603538,
0.0123417787,
0.0027535844,
-0.063629739,
-0.0203574728,
0.0130814277,
-0.0100999717,
-0.0517265499,
0.0059149312,
-0.0865383744,
-0.0494443849,
-0.0427301861,
-0.0196905322,
0.0089554517,
0.0021398172,
-0.0527273975,
-0.033502724,
-0.009544516,
-0.0365062058,
0.0183454324,
0.0015510567,
0.0527586415,
-0.0681031346,
0.0161694121,
-0.034864787,
0.0355729014,
0.0058273701,
-0.0119221024,
-0.0306770243,
-0.0025055371,
-0.0547183119,
0.0076413201,
0.0130868927,
-0.0952145755,
-0.0620798469,
0.0258485321,
0.0358120911,
0.0791582018,
-0.0108384546,
0.0246877223,
-0.0059482967,
-0.0154328523,
0.0040121097,
0.0082724988,
0.0240561944,
0.0070751519,
0.0532167852,
0.0171398222,
0.099477157,
-0.0273459032,
-0.0473946035,
-0.002553679,
0.0435177721,
0.033636108,
0.0123623312,
0.0295061003,
0.0897213966,
-0.0938006416,
0.0245525111,
0.0319810621,
0.019940041,
-0.0157429799,
-0.040300969,
0.0009896731,
-0.0035008006,
-0.0208700765,
-0.0783745795,
-0.0253828149,
-0.0329073407,
0.0542138256,
0.0625202134,
0.0193944275,
-0.0160046164,
-0.0246999934,
-0.0459149405,
0.0229600184,
0.0413871072,
-0.0652350858,
-0.041710142,
-0.1003059819,
-0.0230011307,
0.0038724686,
0.0644762143,
0.0035008646,
-0.0611597411,
-0.0427475162,
-0.0047731414,
-0.0363630988,
-0.0596110411,
0.0384202339,
-0.0166853648,
0.0705411211,
0.0229853299,
-0.0097643146,
0.0011563313,
-0.0321605355,
-0.0259395801,
0.019285256,
-0.0199750382,
-0.0379007794,
0.0155595522,
-0.0047014738,
-0.0139624672,
-0.0070031947,
0.0254410263,
-0.0064309449,
0.0187848993,
0.037428651,
0.0650475919,
-0.0332060084,
-0.0218882281,
0.00052622,
0.0309474319,
0.0276240557,
0.0680623055,
0.0077548437,
0.003802323,
0.0121955918,
0.0415196791,
-0.0068879905,
0.0032391171,
-0.007018744,
0.0157311466,
-0.0058253282,
-0.0263344273,
-0.030861767,
0.0133529538,
0.0502886809,
0.0262348577,
0.0217851717,
-0.0015461334,
0.0135229314,
0.0559396856,
-0.0538337491,
0.02845308,
-0.0131515004,
-0.0050257491,
-0.0612007119,
-0.0457381345,
0.005643934,
-0.0411320552,
-0.0043253149,
0.0183965322,
-0.0766060427,
-0.0706292614,
0.0197352022,
-0.0116444528,
0.033129897,
0.0215726849,
0.00474671,
-0.0694796816,
0.0762897357,
0.029465517,
-0.0532250851,
-0.0346340872,
0.0668728203,
-0.0104211494,
0.0141190058,
0.012238415,
-0.0425501354,
-0.0147152143,
-0.0307207946,
-0.0135748321,
-0.0059545431,
-0.0467336439,
-0.0302302316,
0.0277923346,
0.0587958954,
-0.0218912326,
-0.0455530547,
-0.0498685874,
0.0348489434,
-0.0389988013,
0.0643556193,
-0.02823071,
-0.0131574068,
-0.0300948005,
0.0222937502,
-0.0268143974,
-0.0007344187,
-0.0590983368,
-0.0290490612,
-0.0126679707,
0.138648957,
-0.0028934435,
0.0183346272,
0.0339532234,
0.0160913989,
-0.0236747079,
0.0383679494,
0.0448990166,
0.0225454662,
0.0218395814,
-0.0426179804,
-0.0234560166,
0.0255092327,
-0.0130190188,
0.0042047417,
-0.0346144326,
-0.0409411676,
0.0083152456,
0.06552203,
0.0351984687,
0.0161615666,
0.0497898012,
-0.015338121,
0.0331283174,
-0.0571783632,
-0.0090408735,
0.0138287758,
0.0111511098,
0.0241878498,
-0.0208741724,
-0.0163953342,
0.0455841236,
0.0449517481,
0.013386501,
0.0138169089,
-0.0242019296,
0.0388469845,
-0.0370427221,
-0.0418544486,
-0.0056030555,
0.0249872822,
-0.0354749709,
0.003085481,
-0.0012037792,
-0.0323462747,
-0.0059554391,
0.001155594,
-0.0078104632,
-0.044556953,
0.0199950282,
0.0116556417,
-0.0547009222,
-0.0128601911,
0.0438818634,
-0.0304440632,
-0.0167919844,
-0.0360334255,
0.0230329242,
-6.17206974e-33,
-0.0051815445,
-0.0317932405,
0.0048854798,
0.0454439633,
0.0329737328,
0.0478384867,
-0.0374403931,
0.0396488272,
-0.0051198755,
-0.0232790578,
-0.0378039256,
-0.0240646526,
0.0565922223,
-0.0270170961,
0.0042096404,
0.0235165954,
0.0588114336,
-0.0178064574,
-0.0057281987,
-0.0339501426,
0.0059553655,
0.0151103139,
0.043340005,
-0.0401021875,
-0.0163543187,
0.0031717229,
-0.012216907,
-0.0327983946,
0.0403322615,
0.0388962589,
0.007750683,
0.0844399631,
-0.0088548493,
0.0324022695,
0.0049414164,
0.0012541857,
-0.0788494125,
-0.0083579244,
0.0025351716,
0.0259514954,
-0.0272667557,
0.0176144578,
0.0330878459,
0.0200859793,
-0.0646757409,
-0.0373281352,
0.0280321669,
0.0013710716,
-0.0119175296,
-0.044583261,
-0.0101074958,
0.0307355132,
0.007407119,
-0.0350860618,
0.0887967721,
0.033725936,
-0.0368576013,
-0.0494522229,
-0.0662248582,
0.0441379286,
0.0635481402,
0.0541981384,
0.0139103765,
0.0397684947,
-0.0041724583,
0.0249061007,
0.1026905999,
-0.0562788583,
0.0363969617,
-0.0154802166,
0.0607506782,
-0.0077478969,
0.0518408865,
-0.0287922807,
0.0216993522,
-0.0251924098,
-0.0617312081,
-0.0198387969,
0.082648471,
0.0207857899,
0.0026320475,
0.0174289159,
-0.0747263804,
0.0184572656,
-0.0299402401,
-0.0389680415,
-0.0397676229,
0.0093337791,
0.0396823026,
0.0075809252,
-0.0184097569,
0.0213721339,
0.0169145782,
0.0114816446,
0.0104048848,
-0.0123214936,
0.0860671699,
-0.0233581569,
-0.0168939587,
0.0181610007,
-0.034142483,
-0.0441828594,
0.0554028228,
0.0501156636,
0.0352795869,
0.0005221971,
0.0014629076,
0.0393108726,
-0.0707306191,
-0.0229582712,
0.0124893533,
0.0393032506,
0.0107797217,
-0.015491466,
0.049750641,
-0.0222202558,
0.0114822099,
0.0580571629,
-0.0097902203,
0.0398896597,
-0.0179013181,
0.0200638995,
-0.0050286357,
-0.0157278571,
-0.0298948996,
0.0108552352,
-0.0166153461,
-0.0352766812,
0.0053556939,
-0.0058334367,
0.0025903003,
-0.0371725857,
2.664e-7,
-0.0785668492,
0.068934679,
-0.0008758571,
-0.0271920189,
0.0083481511,
0.0186800323,
0.0007081917,
-0.0611821711,
0.0180757139,
0.0482613891,
-0.0009417516,
-0.0316724665,
0.1024720818,
0.0383757167,
-0.0814805478,
-0.0213797614,
-0.0218057893,
0.0183533207,
-0.0139761781,
0.0379686169,
0.0124233067,
0.044246532,
0.0283141956,
-0.0529181622,
0.0039843773,
-0.000587675,
-0.0261199791,
-0.0118304836,
0.0083160838,
-0.0137540931,
0.004796457,
0.0319629125,
0.0113187218,
0.0305306353,
-0.0466918424,
0.0622394979,
-0.0236047599,
0.0058041168,
-0.0477521941,
-0.0614798293,
0.0082809571,
0.0089266375,
-0.0318623222,
-0.0293927882,
0.0554606356,
0.0263085328,
-0.00264474,
0.0356621109,
-0.0164146535,
-0.0115349526,
0.0190759394,
-0.0265039094,
0.0089689819,
0.0290812962,
-0.0174877029,
-0.0542562678,
-0.0210002456,
-0.0470525287,
0.020023251,
-0.0154559361,
-0.0381759666,
-0.0681613609,
-0.0052158134,
0.0309100151,
-0.0184650179,
0.0013314848,
0.0371833853,
1.873376852e-34,
0.0304077119,
-0.039537672,
0.0609553456,
-0.0048072473,
0.009173301,
-0.0207829475,
0.0637409985,
0.006257216,
0.0256926548,
-0.0280686654,
-0.052764535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08626v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08626v1 | Improving Robustness of Neural Inverse Text Normalization via Data-Augmentation, Semi-Supervised Learning, and Post-Aligning Method | 2023-09-12T06:05:57 | 2023-09-12T06:05:57 | Juntae Kim, Minkyu Lim, Seokjin Hong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Inverse text normalization (ITN) is crucial for converting spoken-form into
written-form, especially in the context of automatic speech recognition (ASR).
While most downstream tasks of ASR rely on written-form, ASR systems often
output spoken-form, highlighting the necessity for robust ITN in product-level
ASR-based applications. Although neural ITN methods have shown promise, they
still encounter performance challenges, particularly when dealing with
ASR-generated spoken text. These challenges arise from the out-of-domain
problem between training data and ASR-generated text. To address this, we
propose a direct training approach that utilizes ASR-generated written or
spoken text, with pairs augmented through ASR linguistic context emulation and
a semi-supervised learning method enhanced by a large language model,
respectively. Additionally, we introduce a post-aligning method to manage
unpredictable errors, thereby enhancing the reliability of ITN. Our experiments
show that our proposed methods remarkably improved ITN performance in various
ASR scenarios. | [
-0.0431737341,
0.0615306832,
0.0391746052,
0.0122035304,
-0.0113565158,
-0.0322180092,
0.0099250861,
0.0010403591,
0.0083910171,
-0.0033340179,
-0.0812292248,
-0.0394399539,
0.0277710184,
0.0480217487,
0.0578727461,
0.0062313578,
0.0084016118,
-0.0467794612,
-0.0192163736,
0.0215279981,
0.0503906533,
0.0190050825,
0.0229915809,
0.0130581334,
-0.0206714235,
0.0116324248,
0.0015122286,
0.0369544923,
0.0352698863,
-0.0128349103,
0.0110731283,
-0.0145709636,
0.0499097072,
0.0310098305,
0.0000019373,
0.0022418117,
-0.0140105719,
0.0144427596,
-0.0537619144,
0.0095513053,
0.0341984481,
-0.0464198925,
-0.0121723218,
0.0832339674,
0.0020231172,
-0.0245056171,
0.0198157951,
0.0706657544,
0.0477240123,
0.0687321424,
-0.0135388486,
-0.0091729388,
0.0292723645,
-0.0464964844,
-0.0517407022,
-0.0143052768,
-0.0145540731,
0.0040291762,
-0.0195592251,
0.0017218387,
0.0227707531,
0.0506552383,
0.0351532549,
-0.0273889843,
0.0113395471,
-0.0009002896,
0.0031883509,
-0.0014479301,
-0.0327662528,
0.0484257936,
0.0129176369,
-0.0514635146,
-0.003929521,
-0.0192051791,
-0.0217738859,
-0.0335574821,
0.0032976568,
0.0181492288,
0.0223065671,
0.0384038389,
-0.0121738743,
0.0221428778,
0.0434363335,
-0.0129128415,
0.0140237296,
0.031565804,
0.0049920925,
-0.0594546385,
0.0087337969,
-0.0175123755,
0.0081466129,
-0.0169984456,
0.0915193036,
0.0111824619,
-0.043543309,
-0.0045272764,
-0.0655803755,
-0.0751131475,
-0.0055291913,
-0.0491590202,
0.0190095659,
0.0170687586,
-0.0473920554,
-0.0115225883,
-0.0010779456,
0.0537022538,
0.0039112591,
0.0265837647,
-0.0567795336,
-0.0046825907,
0.0062170518,
-0.0033432222,
-0.0431975573,
0.0310012195,
-0.0441183671,
-0.0511974283,
-0.0299592447,
-0.0127737541,
-0.014011926,
-0.004152569,
0.040128205,
0.0333574601,
-0.0676215589,
-0.0399166606,
0.0431306995,
0.0479690433,
-0.0033584493,
0.0371154435,
0.0099090692,
0.0011171279,
-0.0146739874,
0.0366617069,
0.0488390103,
-0.0138117429,
0.0100932568,
0.0438410714,
-0.0521564595,
-0.0086646853,
-0.0666426122,
0.0036229019,
-0.0319231376,
-0.0345576927,
-0.0210614484,
-0.0392560139,
0.0370360874,
-0.0242387652,
-0.0284936726,
-0.0498662479,
0.0019279212,
0.0082233371,
0.026087489,
0.0885472372,
-0.0199630018,
-0.0137653351,
0.0749121457,
-0.0062131812,
0.0535746031,
0.0325803608,
0.0558971539,
-0.021329632,
-0.0240582507,
-0.0192739479,
-0.0164848324,
0.0912334025,
0.0423449241,
-0.011195262,
-0.0420274213,
-0.0149437031,
-0.0101303151,
0.0383262821,
0.0587019585,
0.0807473734,
-0.0187122822,
-0.0071643149,
0.043585483,
0.0214602835,
-0.021512093,
-0.0069520515,
-0.0076627214,
0.0455298983,
-0.0397816375,
0.0138917929,
-0.0209305026,
-0.0078493608,
-0.0325741991,
0.0162216332,
0.0340444632,
0.0015571835,
-0.0284312312,
-0.0307848137,
-0.0097639011,
-0.0374054313,
0.0359061733,
-0.0080088601,
0.0282717124,
0.0481699482,
-0.037217252,
0.0058859927,
0.0063661691,
-0.0563804246,
0.0587078258,
0.0016131165,
-0.0507439971,
0.0087573128,
0.0317193605,
-0.0502345189,
-0.0382542461,
-0.0417270213,
-0.009066022,
0.0838734061,
-0.0282805394,
0.0130377123,
0.0269666295,
-0.0773290694,
0.0022211606,
0.0423157737,
-0.0055195317,
0.0248220768,
-0.0203719642,
0.0005943447,
0.0370149054,
-0.0073207016,
-0.0191058777,
0.0288705137,
-0.0847336426,
-0.0428553298,
0.0285451375,
0.009154425,
0.0188355278,
0.0533450954,
-0.0127190072,
0.0026211301,
0.0337640308,
-0.0508348681,
-0.0398733951,
0.0229907818,
-0.082086429,
-0.0274026841,
0.0694840029,
-0.018175045,
0.0046970607,
0.0417755358,
0.0104268268,
-0.0772010684,
0.0179379322,
-0.0334877744,
0.0408090688,
-0.0448833369,
0.0242483281,
0.0459510908,
-0.0090511767,
0.0039581596,
-0.0431194603,
0.0124890469,
-0.0075831679,
0.009977527,
-0.0288434159,
0.014806468,
-0.0584294535,
0.0063224393,
-0.0047044856,
-0.029864816,
0.0402916148,
0.0114779118,
-0.0147509137,
-0.0181145947,
0.0338640139,
-0.05192139,
-0.0125453072,
-0.0351377428,
0.0349324793,
0.0530127175,
0.0435712785,
0.0310635883,
-0.0521965921,
-0.0500486046,
-0.0593265817,
0.0158672128,
-0.0320874453,
0.008184595,
-0.0004427837,
-0.0050088251,
-0.0454296954,
0.028195275,
-0.0083683729,
0.0040108981,
-0.0135833751,
-0.0223286264,
-0.0913882926,
0.0499559976,
0.0169157535,
0.0499366559,
-0.010105541,
-0.0597451292,
-0.0192427114,
-0.004556234,
0.0178154819,
0.0125942435,
-0.0085003162,
-0.0494834445,
-0.0031265421,
0.024796579,
-0.0697842687,
-0.013242525,
0.0409188084,
0.0171270985,
-0.0035523472,
-0.0276856273,
-0.0151349222,
0.0448223092,
0.0280862618,
0.0546790846,
-0.0331542157,
-0.0199974831,
-0.0169554148,
-0.0376578718,
-0.0177106243,
-0.0543184578,
-0.0447292589,
0.0215307176,
-0.0315158851,
-0.0110598691,
0.0584604777,
-0.0890846774,
-0.0547860749,
-0.0402294919,
-0.0480291136,
0.0009774202,
0.0177439805,
-0.0036615734,
0.0275149066,
-0.0151002901,
-0.0512173995,
-0.0202820152,
-0.0120856166,
-0.027506927,
-0.0076469206,
0.0630263761,
-0.0157629754,
0.0164652523,
-0.0126151592,
-0.0822154433,
-0.0182892382,
-0.010475507,
0.0096385283,
0.0450370498,
0.0002108925,
-0.0371126533,
-0.0049029607,
0.0151867643,
-0.0095804213,
0.1006288379,
-0.0050374577,
0.012651884,
-0.0287196059,
0.0591520742,
0.0288642291,
0.0257852133,
-0.0494771078,
0.0014870958,
0.0291305184,
-0.0078759212,
0.0613308549,
-0.0154022099,
-0.0398973823,
-0.0446642414,
0.0035228895,
0.0194932017,
0.0234052204,
-0.0092950817,
0.0291072931,
-0.030540498,
-0.0252252743,
0.0932929665,
0.0001185308,
-0.0117950859,
-0.0266478974,
-0.0055777067,
0.0504308157,
0.0050527295,
-0.0022914042,
-0.0318241231,
-0.0147708468,
0.0347674042,
0.0468365587,
0.0663870499,
0.0100626163,
0.0072578066,
-0.0920509174,
0.0037788057,
0.0266656317,
-0.0640537217,
-0.0700973719,
-0.0526237041,
-0.009994586,
-0.0252096206,
0.1030122936,
0.0167175457,
-0.0085560726,
-0.03097439,
0.0501562469,
-0.0413281955,
-0.056152992,
-0.0442676395,
-0.0548583642,
0.0840321779,
0.0789144114,
0.016777413,
-0.018031925,
0.0065194275,
0.044529289,
0.0284258649,
0.014546941,
0.0139716137,
0.0423992276,
0.0136789875,
-0.0084930323,
-0.000516373,
0.0438165739,
-0.0335553065,
0.0002816886,
-0.0019549592,
0.0343156382,
0.0029251438,
0.0230279434,
0.0183362719,
-0.0102622472,
0.0358003005,
0.0779214203,
0.0098815663,
-0.0470703095,
-0.0018668995,
-0.0274681039,
0.0708276853,
-0.0381659605,
-0.0049677296,
0.0165736228,
-0.0060486281,
-0.0269631222,
-0.0494148433,
-0.0579434969,
-0.0056604845,
0.0438660979,
-0.0011919861,
-0.0283727497,
0.030614201,
-0.0359806716,
-0.0188425053,
-0.0112701124,
-0.0336986482,
0.0206496585,
-0.0535561405,
-0.0048464304,
0.0144363204,
-0.0649959669,
-0.0090002771,
0.0363174342,
-0.0581974983,
-0.0612145066,
0.0281474479,
-0.0276718233,
0.0149806831,
0.0610399917,
-0.0430647582,
-0.0410675295,
0.0538722686,
0.0617726296,
-0.0701352432,
0.0115270959,
0.034739159,
0.0111275874,
-0.0164447185,
0.0209533889,
-0.047311455,
0.0307552069,
0.013587133,
0.0382116809,
0.0083229039,
-0.0495191999,
0.0030885632,
0.0711850673,
0.0335234962,
-0.0311560407,
0.0315319598,
-0.0376496948,
0.0107055232,
-0.0370111056,
0.0229883194,
-0.0325184502,
0.038503658,
0.0598820895,
0.0236665756,
-0.0212179311,
0.0366933383,
-0.0292181429,
-0.0082700877,
-0.0329095535,
0.0185938049,
0.0144949919,
0.0317189768,
0.0314093158,
0.008337765,
-0.0036501056,
0.0322855748,
0.0204332974,
0.0268116053,
-0.0332809091,
0.0047161533,
0.0095631173,
0.0292037372,
-0.0330868363,
0.0236876067,
-0.0322610587,
-0.0036076542,
-0.06338761,
0.0363831483,
0.0112363249,
-0.007166612,
0.0845897347,
0.0086816624,
0.0225485004,
-0.020963043,
0.0079785138,
-0.018039275,
-0.0256761406,
-0.0048487755,
-0.0139937699,
-0.0100629153,
0.0473880991,
0.0523746647,
-0.0118382312,
0.0506300777,
-0.0426799096,
0.0332990326,
-0.0403527245,
-0.0210132841,
0.0053938441,
-0.0049956073,
-0.0566155948,
-0.0563607328,
0.0194165781,
-0.1024533212,
0.022398958,
0.0298411101,
0.0088580037,
0.0044148671,
0.0185025316,
-0.0100156059,
-0.0381909721,
0.0287858918,
0.0489698276,
-0.0015328247,
0.0051965434,
-0.0360096432,
-0.0356764272,
-6.369746748e-33,
-0.0252451431,
0.0232657846,
-0.0126816444,
-0.0401855372,
-0.002939261,
0.020406466,
-0.014085575,
0.0074638557,
0.0336088128,
-0.0032545328,
-0.0388767831,
0.004051425,
0.0272770524,
0.0481933355,
-0.0165730715,
-0.0228707306,
0.1060495898,
-0.0407649651,
-0.0035433052,
-0.0040335516,
0.0076747877,
0.0501767211,
0.0596715398,
-0.1099671647,
0.0011078171,
0.0170005169,
-0.0341835506,
0.0025553436,
0.0335972086,
0.0364781767,
-0.0073213745,
0.0546352342,
-0.0016637925,
-0.0266297646,
-0.0111823855,
0.0423111245,
-0.1013101265,
0.0096890433,
-0.0164373796,
0.0433256924,
-0.0208697878,
0.0176529549,
0.0802772418,
-0.0513949245,
-0.0295213591,
0.0209326576,
0.0133466171,
0.0132926553,
0.0459148884,
-0.0147105223,
-0.0625802577,
0.0129684098,
-0.0063220467,
-0.022260841,
0.0627209023,
0.0210668854,
-0.0260309465,
-0.0129921297,
-0.0867741555,
-0.0312737413,
-0.004393755,
0.0422200188,
0.0404591374,
0.0705154166,
-0.0592405796,
0.0166962892,
0.045396585,
-0.0246833265,
-0.016220618,
-0.0360958241,
0.0428598523,
-0.0226930939,
0.0206217729,
0.0668925717,
0.0358135849,
-0.0017464333,
-0.0342854634,
0.010172735,
0.0164089501,
-0.0277732611,
-0.0043937,
0.0333365574,
-0.0328937955,
-0.0259349048,
-0.0407357104,
-0.0508010387,
-0.0299960971,
-0.0167781264,
0.0517529845,
0.034017507,
0.0047036372,
0.0227041822,
0.0255828369,
-0.0094291009,
-0.0245180819,
0.0255476888,
0.0168282297,
-0.0144537101,
-0.0087999441,
0.0251238272,
-0.0733886659,
-0.0083961207,
0.0363243371,
0.0627943575,
0.0068590324,
-0.0259875972,
0.0403488874,
0.0486056432,
-0.0688586906,
0.0171673708,
-0.0080289934,
0.0368708819,
0.027385721,
0.0303274058,
0.0667041689,
-0.0343638286,
0.0171532109,
0.0363334641,
0.0162166227,
0.0070548104,
-0.0133269904,
-0.0091750817,
0.0263605602,
0.0086637232,
-0.0209441464,
0.0185172874,
0.0227906983,
-0.0467924587,
0.018746838,
-0.0409860201,
0.0056534358,
-0.0195890479,
2.603e-7,
0.0245491341,
0.0315937102,
0.088202931,
-0.0111129927,
0.0020865584,
0.0231372211,
-0.0238562655,
0.0170493834,
0.0124510843,
0.0059569422,
0.0097520566,
-0.0213192832,
0.0497039519,
0.0148107633,
-0.0716088936,
-0.0308248829,
-0.1076497808,
0.0155500909,
0.0044093998,
0.0046803094,
-0.0025516003,
0.083613649,
-0.0103647094,
-0.0442545936,
0.0085880421,
-0.069028765,
0.0121649504,
-0.0130417906,
0.0089955786,
0.0024508568,
-0.0177213214,
0.0045112469,
-0.029187575,
-0.0142780235,
-0.0158277564,
0.0194077864,
0.042695187,
0.043384783,
-0.0318217054,
-0.0179086383,
-0.0383735597,
0.0440334715,
-0.0042261905,
0.0017478943,
0.0170464385,
-0.0031818189,
0.0223762561,
-0.0294486824,
-0.0607367121,
0.0204263981,
0.002757817,
-0.0119288182,
0.0085300542,
0.036952503,
0.0494536981,
0.0204208046,
-0.0454285331,
-0.0698188767,
-0.063750945,
0.0225483887,
-0.0471419059,
0.0277879722,
-0.0507574454,
0.0436705016,
-0.0031282681,
-0.0457447693,
0.0109625151,
2.013507717e-34,
0.0179453809,
-0.0072779185,
-0.0042067138,
-0.0091823069,
0.007531873,
-0.0178845488,
0.0206936467,
0.0197916701,
-0.0233117845,
-0.047518339,
-0.0299274269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08625v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08625v1 | Performance of ChatGPT-3.5 and GPT-4 on the United States Medical Licensing Examination With and Without Distractions | 2023-09-12T05:54:45 | 2023-09-12T05:54:45 | Myriam Safrai, Amos Azaria | cs.CL | cs.CL | As Large Language Models (LLMs) are predictive models building their response
based on the words in the prompts, there is a risk that small talk and
irrelevant information may alter the response and the suggestion given.
Therefore, this study aims to investigate the impact of medical data mixed with
small talk on the accuracy of medical advice provided by ChatGPT. USMLE step 3
questions were used as a model for relevant medical data. We use both multiple
choice and open ended questions. We gathered small talk sentences from human
participants using the Mechanical Turk platform. Both sets of USLME questions
were arranged in a pattern where each sentence from the original questions was
followed by a small talk sentence. ChatGPT 3.5 and 4 were asked to answer both
sets of questions with and without the small talk sentences. A board-certified
physician analyzed the answers by ChatGPT and compared them to the formal
correct answer. The analysis results demonstrate that the ability of
ChatGPT-3.5 to answer correctly was impaired when small talk was added to
medical data for multiple-choice questions (72.1\% vs. 68.9\%) and open
questions (61.5\% vs. 44.3\%; p=0.01), respectively. In contrast, small talk
phrases did not impair ChatGPT-4 ability in both types of questions (83.6\% and
66.2\%, respectively). According to these results, ChatGPT-4 seems more
accurate than the earlier 3.5 version, and it appears that small talk does not
impair its capability to provide medical recommendations. Our results are an
important first step in understanding the potential and limitations of
utilizing ChatGPT and other LLMs for physician-patient interactions, which
include casual conversations. | [
0.0814652592,
-0.0156662948,
-0.0346694179,
-0.0425104313,
-0.0508727245,
0.009009121,
0.0360551961,
0.0734728649,
0.0261336751,
-0.0356824212,
0.0098476382,
-0.0385474116,
0.0220207293,
-0.0351470038,
0.0319332033,
-0.0614644885,
0.0155918263,
0.0226616096,
0.070800364,
-0.0197204705,
0.0260196514,
-0.0164869968,
-0.0342389867,
0.0396697335,
0.0287187565,
0.0026709721,
0.0247005299,
-0.0274787359,
-0.003113681,
-0.0552280731,
-0.0019195291,
0.0586646907,
-0.0412298813,
-0.0180011243,
0.0000020534,
-0.0620838962,
0.0217195749,
0.0075088628,
-0.0365684591,
-0.0086067803,
0.0540234186,
0.0422384702,
0.0248815343,
0.041840557,
-0.0321051516,
-0.0162548404,
0.0194181912,
0.0527346954,
0.0279250927,
0.0514643863,
-0.02429468,
0.0578089654,
-0.0094524985,
-0.0163935237,
0.0660880581,
-0.0408815108,
0.0198037829,
0.027094949,
0.0329539105,
0.0091335019,
0.0082301954,
0.0090607051,
-0.0457126424,
0.0426023863,
-0.0021007466,
0.0265938416,
-0.043291606,
-0.0124192629,
0.0093715759,
0.0254082642,
0.0454911664,
0.0092836414,
0.006263494,
-0.0198811647,
0.0546873398,
0.0344802216,
-0.0664797276,
-0.0071151559,
-0.0059422078,
-0.0305778421,
-0.0047386019,
-0.0036736873,
-0.0221114513,
0.0015329662,
0.0373305976,
-0.0054362449,
0.0118419994,
-0.033570502,
0.0247645956,
-0.0125281364,
0.0326617211,
-0.0696402565,
0.0019454544,
0.0248581413,
-0.037419945,
0.0068086996,
0.0105080139,
0.0184986405,
0.0816890374,
-0.0694883764,
-0.0589588471,
0.0340979472,
0.0009832943,
-0.0070856758,
-0.0008933005,
0.0306157079,
0.0215789638,
0.037735112,
-0.0474846922,
0.0501868315,
-0.0324058831,
-0.013346157,
-0.0104563357,
0.0091163954,
-0.0080284681,
0.0138969198,
-0.0796793252,
-0.0525852479,
-0.0081754085,
-0.0053397943,
-0.0354368575,
0.0414318256,
-0.0048682066,
0.0196209289,
-0.0476486161,
0.0436978675,
-0.0143351192,
0.012628858,
0.0087703345,
-0.0642672628,
0.0251696054,
0.0201636441,
0.0306169484,
0.0068640811,
0.0145696523,
0.0462777093,
-0.0033848044,
-0.0154266423,
0.0218687635,
-0.0172630176,
-0.0466783494,
-0.044820264,
0.0242345929,
-0.0145248268,
-0.0035018304,
0.0290628541,
-0.0080673471,
-0.0024627126,
0.0317209251,
0.0607934073,
-0.0697390661,
0.0334240906,
-0.0222184993,
0.0553358085,
0.0390682966,
0.038813509,
0.0158546008,
-0.0190475862,
0.013569844,
-0.0300913695,
-0.0033708604,
-0.097679995,
0.0144162253,
0.0174208432,
0.0189453959,
-0.032359235,
0.0336888768,
0.0294147637,
0.0019596142,
0.0413069017,
-0.0467621088,
0.0892597437,
-0.0198650081,
0.020549478,
0.0474821366,
0.0938065574,
0.0001985927,
0.0304928869,
-0.025938388,
0.0316452459,
0.0376054831,
0.0293773953,
-0.0123583348,
-0.0275574755,
-0.04516441,
-0.0083331298,
0.0040495549,
0.0117536364,
-0.019580191,
-0.0130608641,
-0.0542746037,
0.0039651021,
-0.0102205556,
0.0255462918,
-0.0082238307,
-0.0460274071,
-0.0280576386,
0.0718885437,
0.0460930914,
-0.0184246283,
-0.0557378083,
-0.0432753973,
0.0129828136,
0.0684579089,
0.0327877626,
0.0388410203,
-0.0184334982,
-0.0496104844,
0.0157680474,
0.0186379459,
0.044078853,
-0.007593825,
-0.0381166339,
-0.0433960333,
-0.0053621074,
0.0448900126,
0.0089102462,
-0.0470728911,
0.0222272072,
0.0232846756,
0.0003085843,
0.0218044277,
-0.0125628663,
0.0051229331,
-0.0238001049,
-0.0387747064,
-0.0001230014,
-0.0138483737,
0.0376640409,
0.0095584942,
-0.0034462842,
0.025563471,
-0.0036121812,
0.0444304422,
0.0057491018,
0.0198059939,
-0.0463775583,
-0.0096744839,
0.0145159103,
-0.0011354181,
0.000770791,
-0.0361869223,
-0.0037954745,
-0.0169354808,
-0.060563013,
-0.0879793018,
0.0253259204,
-0.0028867011,
0.0083275689,
-0.0028957231,
-0.0021377353,
-0.0389610194,
-0.0003755161,
0.0038442337,
0.0407820567,
0.0380749889,
-0.0330035426,
-0.0003009497,
-0.0456310697,
-0.0053032055,
0.0117283883,
-0.0070771021,
0.0154266115,
0.0286246967,
0.0374309309,
-0.0664126202,
-0.0148964385,
-0.123551324,
-0.0275406986,
0.0321777426,
-0.0187188908,
0.0286215618,
-0.0054040374,
-0.0190208964,
-0.0029083262,
-0.0615707487,
0.0096323919,
0.041438248,
0.0404243693,
0.0135909691,
0.0145514579,
0.0107080406,
-0.0017173382,
-0.0074711395,
-0.0509091467,
-0.0195493009,
0.0459558219,
-0.0347046703,
0.0154478513,
0.03524746,
-0.0446258299,
-0.0170891136,
-0.0004283063,
-0.032059066,
0.0097922953,
-0.0056541045,
0.0249388907,
0.0173014179,
0.0230373219,
-0.0311145298,
0.0177892614,
-0.0124064358,
-0.0312849283,
0.0012501733,
0.0006814897,
-0.0340987407,
0.0064370213,
-0.0949793234,
-0.0449048318,
0.0234894641,
0.0301613286,
0.0267754905,
-0.0389250591,
0.0065431115,
-0.0155526372,
0.0193585698,
-0.0384513699,
0.0105737075,
-0.047780674,
0.0553326197,
0.0208803341,
-0.0398102477,
0.0420797914,
-0.0001632466,
0.0094420146,
-0.0577931777,
-0.0183823202,
-0.0135715054,
0.0181936026,
-0.0169807877,
0.0022988634,
0.0437455215,
-0.039475251,
-0.0386274904,
-0.0340908878,
-0.0033925679,
-0.0590139702,
0.0332159698,
-0.0325539522,
0.0091085145,
-0.0033085074,
-0.0396044701,
-0.0508462898,
-0.041536551,
-0.0318998359,
-0.01966336,
0.0064722439,
0.0198940467,
-0.0495957434,
-0.0101872617,
0.0021949227,
0.0289292037,
-0.0084853079,
0.0008424132,
0.0305847842,
0.0202005338,
0.049720753,
0.0524357744,
0.0186784677,
-0.0007810355,
0.0380585864,
0.0670657232,
0.0036400279,
-0.0041184295,
0.0212547928,
-0.0327707194,
0.0091160303,
0.0042378125,
-0.0138923451,
0.062069241,
0.022679029,
-0.0368817262,
-0.0122775445,
0.1035945788,
-0.0071602911,
-0.0092381155,
0.0012269578,
-0.0402050652,
-0.0170461312,
-0.0078631742,
0.0108433226,
-0.0610682033,
-0.0299177002,
-0.0261224322,
0.0247966982,
-0.0506006628,
0.0070717363,
-0.0157536436,
-0.0599483997,
0.0284064095,
0.0117047597,
-0.0408592597,
0.0010104042,
-0.0098785833,
0.0158426594,
0.0078613749,
0.0177658815,
-0.0081742564,
-0.0102277482,
0.0092550712,
-0.0038979056,
-0.1389617771,
-0.0350905545,
0.0722429156,
0.0251135398,
0.0637587383,
0.0286703017,
0.0162976366,
-0.0248128083,
-0.0596287847,
0.0323017389,
0.0121730501,
0.0060151713,
-0.0066495505,
0.0800528452,
0.0008013449,
0.0415061004,
-0.0862553343,
0.0447731987,
-0.0108776819,
0.0082301879,
0.0519087426,
0.0543345548,
-0.0286844857,
-0.0509383008,
-0.0176750869,
0.075905472,
0.0041353875,
0.0521016531,
-0.002418709,
-0.0230612401,
0.0314166658,
0.0212200526,
0.0274480134,
0.0603693575,
-0.0296798181,
-0.0221928097,
0.0091471998,
-0.0139042241,
-0.0311698522,
-0.050045602,
0.0662641078,
-0.0185757261,
0.0067717531,
0.0593738966,
0.0160576794,
0.0506621748,
-0.0145954546,
0.0371824987,
0.0135458456,
0.0069656461,
-0.0012801086,
-0.0250749569,
0.0313661098,
-0.0093129408,
-0.0152243264,
0.0162359606,
-0.0572514832,
0.0025633767,
0.0084240623,
0.0390284918,
0.0296591949,
-0.0037711842,
0.0199749209,
-0.0183825009,
0.0007082175,
0.0287392084,
-0.0593793876,
0.0111172181,
-0.0254192222,
0.0396191031,
0.0070046252,
-0.0139277251,
0.0151912048,
-0.0054208441,
0.0186926629,
-0.0083518503,
-0.0345234498,
-0.0555423871,
0.0247987229,
0.0764730126,
0.0372656025,
0.0100986818,
0.0170404762,
-0.0047258581,
0.0126634007,
-0.0184154175,
0.0099780904,
-0.0164732505,
-0.051240772,
0.0030788283,
-0.016500501,
-0.0282422639,
-0.0951774791,
-0.1176335216,
-0.0200779848,
-0.0395591632,
0.0345009677,
-0.0237528682,
0.0031640311,
0.0377617963,
-0.0302899331,
-0.0094952369,
-0.007942576,
0.0244766138,
0.0296276696,
0.0136881489,
0.1184983626,
-0.0161695071,
-0.020090919,
0.0506739952,
0.0061887889,
-0.0274549946,
-0.0853021294,
-0.0210791752,
0.0958550572,
-0.0194962639,
0.0071103447,
-0.007710923,
-0.0123254517,
0.0074097761,
-0.0286355186,
0.0067374422,
-0.0336905383,
-0.0082948646,
0.0861116499,
-0.0087136356,
-0.022554893,
-0.0141299879,
0.050035242,
-0.0100489147,
0.0145320576,
-0.0027960876,
-0.0424422882,
-0.0547081381,
-0.0210243221,
0.0120622553,
0.0169911142,
-0.0346819535,
0.0274350736,
-0.1049095839,
-0.0203904975,
-0.0467134751,
-0.0181351006,
0.0135170659,
-0.0685872212,
0.0481531546,
0.0324054211,
-0.0188078191,
-0.0581861995,
-0.0215402804,
0.077070877,
-0.0180924144,
-0.0001045433,
-0.0209117755,
-5.92438206e-33,
-0.0092418352,
-0.0500307083,
0.0415759757,
-0.0135736251,
-0.0080191232,
0.0062429551,
-0.0250352584,
0.0446441434,
-0.0104710041,
0.0094205905,
-0.0295490269,
0.0011275666,
0.01028137,
0.0290780719,
0.0263857059,
-0.0607173368,
0.0153114656,
-0.0005095655,
-0.0061185942,
0.0318889767,
-0.0550968461,
0.0174608622,
0.0274201371,
-0.0502111949,
0.0388868302,
-0.0146418829,
0.0106939776,
-0.0295791924,
-0.031782113,
0.0279281382,
0.014919227,
0.042261254,
0.0530718416,
-0.0152344573,
-0.0047146389,
0.033227969,
-0.011472105,
-0.0416423567,
0.0452392325,
-0.0240438133,
-0.0301518496,
-0.0150599945,
0.0382935219,
-0.0330287553,
-0.0468550175,
-0.0100930091,
0.0293088518,
-0.0132725136,
0.000975228,
0.0299445894,
-0.0017794269,
0.0291255731,
-0.0041273674,
-0.0019116359,
-0.0469798669,
0.0905868635,
-0.0407112576,
-0.0004825056,
0.0174827725,
0.0371833965,
0.0667392761,
-0.0008595882,
-0.02720825,
-0.0530101471,
-0.0022791221,
0.0424494445,
0.0287936162,
0.0100977393,
-0.0169061515,
-0.0445108265,
-0.0387571044,
0.0309952963,
0.0594879277,
0.0369827673,
0.0018029182,
-0.044429414,
-0.0663628429,
0.0033038983,
-0.0030501103,
0.0338877887,
0.0026698133,
-0.0409162827,
-0.0938523933,
-0.0468887314,
-0.0016761628,
0.0194754992,
-0.0100159803,
-0.0461250618,
0.0290491786,
-0.0194402561,
0.0284955706,
-0.012894853,
0.0133992862,
-0.0204651654,
0.0387993045,
-0.0762531385,
-0.0101689501,
-0.0020365615,
-0.0321638808,
0.0001217398,
-0.0886755064,
0.0365244262,
0.0178705789,
0.0003302743,
0.0521046631,
0.0342230238,
-0.0125406394,
-0.0357283689,
-0.0741619468,
-0.0083447183,
0.0072806813,
0.0038602962,
-0.012956786,
-0.0311914217,
0.0345561542,
0.0467125364,
0.0005673711,
0.0313668139,
0.0007391121,
-0.0495311096,
-0.0512047298,
-0.0783954114,
-0.0041006142,
-0.0159998219,
-0.0331202261,
0.0284535233,
-0.0042750281,
0.0396046117,
0.0449391343,
-0.000746488,
0.0065420852,
-0.0225669537,
2.807e-7,
0.0294102915,
0.0770623386,
-0.0430282131,
-0.0128366891,
0.0263240617,
0.0261868406,
0.0146568408,
-0.0035346514,
0.0740639865,
-0.0068437322,
0.0467125215,
-0.0370695516,
0.0352776721,
0.0083980756,
-0.0667413771,
-0.0484509133,
-0.0641974807,
-0.0462632477,
0.0007527546,
0.0262681097,
0.0791451782,
0.0348937176,
-0.0318732746,
-0.0402446873,
-0.0256591085,
-0.003732929,
0.0314141102,
-0.0567977242,
-0.0288705491,
0.0364061072,
0.0501990095,
-0.0139767621,
0.0261084419,
0.107388176,
-0.0063197189,
-0.0128773153,
0.0024958733,
0.0726207197,
-0.0462564938,
0.0221518315,
0.005745315,
0.0009246534,
0.0189920198,
-0.0669293106,
0.0557442568,
-0.0472861528,
-0.0440248959,
-0.0097195124,
-0.0178078618,
-0.0423492528,
0.0790357217,
0.0005861502,
-0.0506620221,
-0.0166428238,
0.0163257811,
0.0252331048,
0.0000490145,
-0.0107138371,
0.0333633572,
0.0070502977,
-0.036010325,
-0.0909211859,
0.031337738,
-0.0327797867,
-0.0133873206,
-0.067887865,
-0.0069523142,
2.292702549e-34,
0.0121724475,
0.0262890533,
0.0332653373,
0.0077860304,
0.0348237529,
0.0166600086,
0.06644997,
0.021801047,
0.0310006831,
-0.0231784265,
-0.0329026133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05973v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05973v2 | Circuit Breaking: Removing Model Behaviors with Targeted Ablation | 2023-09-12T05:51:56 | 2024-01-29T22:19:12 | Maximilian Li, Xander Davies, Max Nadeau | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models often exhibit behaviors that improve performance on a
pre-training objective but harm performance on downstream tasks. We propose a
novel approach to removing undesirable behaviors by ablating a small number of
causal pathways between model components, with the intention of disabling the
computational circuit responsible for the bad behavior. Given a small dataset
of inputs where the model behaves poorly, we learn to ablate a small number of
important causal pathways. In the setting of reducing GPT-2 toxic language
generation, we find ablating just 12 of the 11.6K causal edges mitigates toxic
generation with minimal degradation of performance on other inputs. | [
-0.0321268216,
0.0901304409,
-0.0292536281,
0.0409587547,
-0.0140918549,
0.0076646567,
-0.0034048711,
-0.0001886755,
0.0086719003,
-0.0109505495,
-0.0229005795,
0.031291429,
-0.01762411,
0.0777838081,
0.0339600407,
-0.0093448879,
0.0963963419,
-0.0284779277,
-0.0188716836,
-0.0293463506,
0.0059599369,
0.0050339978,
0.0339513496,
0.0269302987,
-0.0125023331,
-0.0101417545,
0.028140936,
-0.004100644,
-0.0029834553,
0.0058849235,
-0.0052579069,
0.0432116576,
-0.0438854247,
0.0454223417,
0.0000021517,
0.0125360023,
-0.0217373744,
0.0118261036,
-0.0147808092,
0.0318589844,
0.0230159555,
0.0064012604,
-0.0252881292,
0.0409287661,
-0.0111445934,
0.0046214843,
0.0595840886,
0.0479132794,
0.0500138663,
0.055265341,
-0.0120271062,
0.0114128767,
0.0415225849,
-0.0043335352,
0.0151941227,
0.0036054878,
0.0091569806,
-0.0491190851,
-0.026285544,
-0.0861142501,
-0.0442733318,
0.0035928199,
0.0174848288,
0.0296024866,
-0.0074140779,
0.0358706452,
-0.0415577851,
-0.0459452979,
0.021023944,
0.0432346053,
-0.0620036498,
-0.0461596437,
0.0124737285,
-0.0057404959,
-0.0238019507,
-0.0479525775,
0.0062989192,
-0.0116131231,
-0.0062036705,
0.0335087702,
0.003950384,
-0.0488469265,
0.0583107509,
-0.0163161084,
0.0104614282,
0.0638797656,
0.0284469537,
-0.0447316654,
0.0110321632,
0.0092603546,
-0.0305448137,
0.0012549747,
-0.0213164482,
-0.0489681959,
-0.0345836692,
0.0120598283,
-0.0420772508,
0.0088193417,
-0.0100572938,
-0.0557421297,
0.0423517376,
0.0257974938,
0.0322124325,
-0.0238060895,
-0.0468323901,
0.0141767692,
-0.0150183449,
0.0527357273,
0.0077468352,
0.0679891557,
0.0049413149,
-0.0274019595,
-0.0282812435,
0.0277359709,
0.0030412709,
0.0103481067,
-0.0219589658,
0.0133181838,
-0.0669836476,
-0.0179969445,
-0.023925731,
0.0114133544,
-0.0327860564,
0.0443610474,
0.0186648462,
0.0148247899,
-0.0245351642,
-0.0002827431,
-0.0258728918,
-0.0375447832,
-0.0371169001,
-0.0139468908,
-0.0138881123,
-0.03477595,
-0.0114340344,
0.0842918083,
-0.0030456854,
-0.032791499,
-0.0699108467,
-0.0476537906,
-0.0261814017,
-0.0663799644,
0.0113908257,
-0.0246376377,
-0.0275724903,
-0.0358457007,
-0.0068972562,
-0.0719031096,
-0.0010004706,
0.0127732959,
-0.0586936586,
0.0643662363,
-0.0118627204,
-0.0410874151,
0.0220106188,
0.0264497902,
0.0096490039,
0.0752445832,
0.0145056332,
0.005344159,
-0.0018397683,
-0.0210243333,
-0.0128167868,
0.0493115708,
0.0897044837,
0.0078682564,
-0.0456186198,
-0.0674384162,
0.0560738631,
-0.0276256166,
0.051383175,
0.0612356402,
-0.0362334996,
0.0038327314,
0.0761564225,
-0.0189601909,
-0.0454422347,
0.0698175281,
0.0238759518,
-0.0336961076,
-0.0465668514,
0.0341518447,
-0.1109873801,
-0.0102547901,
-0.0470822006,
0.0071345973,
0.0124820825,
0.0340290181,
-0.0060049826,
-0.0367313661,
0.0113932034,
-0.0058401166,
0.0428961068,
0.0026271192,
0.0163828097,
0.0115473215,
-0.0728837103,
0.0414184444,
0.0365252495,
-0.0446025394,
-0.0100563662,
-0.0592948161,
-0.0280457567,
0.0452186465,
0.0589130782,
-0.0162373837,
-0.0120089324,
-0.0234137289,
-0.0383313224,
0.010195408,
-0.0147732655,
0.0003137433,
0.0689399689,
-0.0025230069,
0.0016415892,
0.014618746,
0.0296663381,
-0.0070422525,
0.0112590715,
-0.0188646168,
-0.0095880087,
-0.0108118951,
-0.0356813259,
0.0198494345,
-0.005603645,
-0.0504746884,
0.0238756351,
0.0152436513,
0.0321582183,
-0.0346201025,
-0.039693974,
0.0011062999,
0.0219554398,
-0.0106404396,
0.0059770532,
0.0184989534,
-0.0507355668,
-0.0049094181,
0.0384680964,
-0.0166529175,
0.0015739445,
0.0626752526,
-0.0054356814,
-0.0414969847,
0.0362137631,
-0.0357947238,
0.0196466055,
0.0003886686,
0.0072631408,
-0.0126508074,
0.0155078741,
-0.0132157067,
0.0408602171,
-0.0011254557,
-0.0079700919,
0.0086175706,
-0.0065602288,
-0.0131311091,
-0.023226399,
-0.0357269533,
0.0047962219,
0.0102738561,
0.0042751059,
0.048296649,
-0.0111530591,
-0.0278362446,
-0.0213155374,
-0.0187511612,
-0.0205602981,
0.0038835662,
0.0179532133,
0.0228024367,
-0.0196889695,
-0.0038833602,
0.0207895935,
0.0296286419,
-0.040431723,
0.0207421817,
0.0440422259,
-0.0194159243,
-0.0162890647,
-0.0425573625,
-0.0296777859,
-0.011649739,
-0.0217061136,
0.0344477743,
-0.0239611827,
-0.0262972824,
-0.0240146238,
0.0435930789,
-0.0012295921,
0.0603654273,
0.0124328723,
-0.0790257603,
0.0285821687,
0.0336071067,
0.0467673428,
0.0723904967,
-0.03515324,
0.0283775274,
0.0868134722,
-0.0043911962,
-0.0059260963,
0.0162301753,
0.0084949676,
0.0039781271,
-0.0216527656,
-0.0525995083,
-0.033231359,
0.0828408673,
0.0328106433,
-0.0092840036,
-0.0713400096,
0.0101635661,
-0.0249985103,
-0.0507901646,
-0.0018292059,
-0.0848355144,
-0.0606975406,
0.0269546807,
-0.0288177747,
-0.0458639078,
0.0410134532,
0.0073868325,
0.0180603936,
-0.0298574902,
0.0311555807,
0.0382969677,
0.0103090126,
0.0374536477,
0.039535135,
0.0791973546,
-0.0022902959,
-0.039625179,
-0.015885694,
0.0339807756,
0.0019299975,
-0.0032861778,
-0.0512762517,
0.0303053483,
0.0047462103,
-0.0741545409,
-0.0146760792,
0.0257093944,
0.0475753993,
-0.0076414072,
0.0523483455,
-0.0396662243,
-0.0150974682,
-0.0140502909,
-0.012889849,
0.0321403258,
-0.0281245876,
-0.0123973023,
-0.0145487497,
-0.0039126305,
0.0414195992,
-0.0713657737,
0.0203316137,
-0.0365316458,
0.0442573316,
0.043341428,
0.0397534333,
0.0048148911,
-0.0145103894,
0.0308755785,
-0.00645176,
0.0181056894,
-0.0249061156,
0.0071527828,
0.0286330916,
-0.0145755047,
-0.0576555133,
0.0622740127,
0.0192467663,
-0.0387994274,
0.0195263345,
0.0238285996,
0.0983190387,
0.0304563809,
0.0381398685,
-0.0918863043,
0.0067174784,
0.0179528296,
0.0209174212,
-0.027506778,
0.0061688074,
0.0089987768,
-0.0922523662,
0.0320018046,
0.0430027507,
-0.0540481843,
-0.0196181573,
-0.0376405492,
-0.0298248138,
-0.0596392713,
0.0120994383,
0.004041065,
-0.0078057144,
-0.0077299541,
0.0356602706,
-0.01800978,
-0.0223222468,
0.0198135786,
0.0131245665,
0.0188571513,
0.0520217754,
-0.0048424103,
-0.0116424365,
0.0318977945,
0.0748250932,
0.0077130646,
0.0120380791,
-0.0200784802,
0.0484468043,
0.0351059139,
-0.0157638825,
-0.0163995735,
0.0360289104,
0.0109307636,
-0.0267046876,
-0.0378826261,
0.099909991,
-0.0031610427,
-0.0332538895,
0.0040223254,
0.0055632754,
0.0036189861,
0.044658795,
0.039252948,
-0.041995164,
-0.0769190788,
-0.0334218219,
0.0000407248,
-0.0437161662,
-0.0632732883,
-0.0368529074,
0.0233660582,
-0.072311148,
-0.043486625,
-0.0412771069,
0.0001216145,
0.0284815524,
0.0063211238,
-0.0129458318,
-0.0230529793,
0.0135882329,
-0.0127804633,
0.0191114042,
0.0110221105,
-0.0005157077,
-0.0697771534,
-0.0166943446,
-0.0257628877,
0.0072606211,
-0.0542844385,
0.0475292616,
-0.0640951842,
-0.1098379642,
0.0498625301,
0.0873593464,
0.0253081433,
0.0555332527,
0.0176825915,
-0.0235728379,
0.0176479723,
0.0421458706,
-0.0106288437,
0.0506978817,
0.0729456842,
-0.0722750574,
-0.0150180226,
0.0241360124,
0.0203770623,
0.0366955847,
0.0630322397,
0.0210567471,
-0.0544858165,
0.0627192557,
0.0508864112,
0.0157603864,
0.0650529787,
-0.041194994,
0.0041997135,
-0.0501021668,
0.0019432991,
-0.0151327075,
0.0035571817,
-0.0187240392,
0.0240976866,
0.0267012995,
-0.0138638951,
-0.0076122223,
-0.0600841083,
-0.0216572564,
-0.0055270023,
-0.0319008082,
0.0240572952,
0.0134900426,
0.0168759804,
0.0438186079,
0.0182139631,
-0.0223479513,
0.0470727012,
0.0176983085,
0.0206855051,
-0.0464120209,
-0.0171903092,
0.0252043847,
0.0443871245,
-0.0158990286,
0.0108991675,
-0.0156624261,
-0.0352127254,
-0.0317529365,
-0.0027787704,
0.0219838992,
0.0090881092,
0.0368697122,
-0.0246290173,
-0.0156724285,
-0.022022374,
0.003961042,
0.0137085672,
-0.0241717529,
0.0071201143,
0.0002070768,
-0.0043571861,
-0.0501914024,
0.072097376,
0.0305879656,
0.0950753465,
-0.0085343309,
0.0120991338,
-0.0366565064,
-0.0618580356,
0.0140538998,
-0.0062379478,
-0.027819857,
-0.0023172158,
-0.0453855135,
-0.0877860263,
-0.0461036786,
-0.007166774,
0.0630268976,
-0.0252120048,
0.0437479727,
0.0189342871,
-0.0173749346,
-0.0220496841,
-0.004635443,
-0.0369614959,
0.0541619621,
-0.0395336971,
-0.0040890127,
-6.702763563e-33,
-0.0302809738,
-0.0061480687,
0.0124931447,
0.0350607634,
0.0056347349,
-0.0013342028,
-0.0531926304,
0.01406099,
-0.0122620352,
0.0085556051,
-0.0195276216,
0.0076736007,
0.0119517939,
-0.0140087018,
-0.0246416982,
0.0043659881,
0.0742064193,
-0.0199746378,
-0.0431961864,
0.0660624877,
0.0423738919,
0.053138949,
0.0410080962,
-0.046521876,
-0.0142300883,
0.0302771758,
-0.0791650265,
-0.0218643695,
-0.0452791378,
0.0339074209,
-0.0136241876,
0.031532567,
-0.0124154612,
-0.0456055962,
-0.0022979502,
0.0018792436,
-0.0217608996,
0.0019757748,
0.0212271493,
-0.026274357,
-0.0188402981,
-0.0511866808,
0.0591986775,
0.0151501708,
-0.0563534945,
-0.0190102328,
0.0070135291,
-0.0131766042,
-0.0184720289,
0.0150416438,
-0.0943726525,
0.0210552141,
-0.0074822786,
-0.0044811401,
0.0138366837,
-0.009306456,
-0.0182582568,
-0.0151553741,
-0.0237440113,
0.0320573673,
0.0752549022,
0.0608291589,
0.0335561819,
0.0033492765,
0.0122582121,
0.0569947921,
0.0382485203,
0.0311715379,
0.0588559397,
-0.0031199972,
0.0728123635,
0.0404621065,
0.0525828488,
-0.0068822508,
0.0649847016,
-0.0761779174,
-0.0585700721,
-0.0032639753,
0.0037021574,
0.0374139734,
0.0112382406,
0.0128500871,
-0.0195428934,
-0.0310906917,
-0.0318247415,
-0.0069938367,
-0.033980187,
-0.0322872214,
0.0201195702,
0.0062900246,
-0.0168493185,
-0.029709911,
0.0312573053,
-0.0286519583,
0.0374779291,
0.0575586334,
-0.005701649,
0.0019515028,
-0.006857337,
-0.0036973136,
-0.0552259423,
-0.0115695056,
-0.0188894346,
0.0068770768,
0.0366269238,
-0.0206112117,
0.0279609412,
0.0525146462,
-0.059240073,
0.0155280232,
-0.0807556584,
0.0410120189,
0.0296575595,
0.0589722767,
0.0059217671,
-0.002842681,
0.0184788816,
-0.0063433605,
0.0181461666,
0.0156568829,
-0.0546861961,
0.0518043973,
0.0138525544,
0.0641533658,
-0.0056902133,
-0.0226996653,
-0.0109175472,
0.0408766605,
0.028890403,
-0.0945064649,
-0.0395381972,
-0.000800977,
2.879e-7,
0.0105036534,
0.0438209288,
-0.0007469497,
0.068122685,
0.0331832394,
0.0313204117,
0.0236382019,
0.0227397196,
-0.0075435406,
0.0350427181,
0.0332061425,
0.009945563,
0.0461800098,
0.0321734995,
-0.0320077799,
0.0396332815,
-0.0968346074,
-0.0041320762,
-0.0319948345,
-0.0254970342,
-0.0136429192,
0.0658165365,
-0.0049800649,
-0.0312337,
0.0251929238,
-0.0109141003,
0.0279862471,
-0.0170939583,
0.0285527222,
-0.0150490012,
-0.0813807771,
-0.0374760963,
-0.0098774247,
0.0182796754,
-0.0334726982,
-0.0422113501,
-0.0482058525,
0.0236586891,
-0.0420048609,
-0.029622402,
0.0166594908,
0.0192496087,
-0.022062894,
-0.042085845,
0.0624733716,
0.0134848244,
-0.022018373,
-0.0291300956,
0.0051592891,
-0.038172029,
0.0377880186,
-0.0329479538,
-0.0297838766,
0.026661858,
-0.0132466769,
0.0133329378,
0.00346293,
-0.0321192406,
-0.0113802124,
0.0284263678,
-0.0405377932,
-0.0584580265,
-0.0152567467,
0.040385101,
-0.0020122579,
-0.021691557,
-0.0363275073,
3.131822763e-34,
0.0256213266,
-0.0658694282,
0.0532982908,
0.0262364615,
0.0721462294,
-0.0048841136,
-0.0160831716,
-0.0028894548,
-0.011856257,
-0.0211760327,
-0.0381082632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05961v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05961v5 | Evaluating the Ebb and Flow: An In-depth Analysis of Question-Answering Trends across Diverse Platforms | 2023-09-12T05:03:28 | 2024-03-15T18:07:46 | Rima Hazra, Agnik Saha, Somnath Banerjee, Animesh Mukherjee | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Community Question Answering (CQA) platforms steadily gain popularity as they
provide users with fast responses to their queries. The swiftness of these
responses is contingent on a mixture of query-specific and user-related
elements. This paper scrutinizes these contributing factors within the context
of six highly popular CQA platforms, identified through their standout
answering speed. Our investigation reveals a correlation between the time taken
to yield the first response to a question and several variables: the metadata,
the formulation of the questions, and the level of interaction among users.
Additionally, by employing conventional machine learning models to analyze
these metadata and patterns of user interaction, we endeavor to predict which
queries will receive their initial responses promptly. | [
0.0535532348,
-0.0203845389,
-0.0309269056,
0.0112353135,
-0.0114428904,
-0.0052332263,
-0.0279700011,
-0.0280733611,
-0.0290696248,
-0.0021168804,
-0.0018578464,
0.0116355941,
0.0146460636,
0.0331249647,
-0.023374835,
-0.0168115571,
-0.0288668647,
0.0222462416,
-0.0526148602,
0.0071158335,
0.0400354266,
0.0053396933,
-0.0072105159,
0.04685314,
0.0151722655,
-0.0261370223,
-0.0151375718,
0.0084352028,
-0.024764128,
-0.0442646481,
0.0152070848,
0.0301532317,
-0.055359561,
0.036510624,
0.0000019074,
-0.0682817921,
0.0264490545,
0.0169562139,
-0.0656868815,
0.0275770389,
0.0098294457,
0.0484716743,
0.0649926066,
0.0590068623,
-0.077355355,
0.0290438421,
0.0325406641,
-0.0382610746,
0.0195799582,
-0.0201609619,
-0.0230033733,
-0.0241095722,
-0.0470653735,
-0.0149889421,
0.0237883776,
-0.0896990299,
0.0233564712,
-0.0000582609,
0.0739108101,
-0.0243109241,
-0.0324311927,
0.0133088874,
0.0023486083,
0.0166080743,
0.0492276549,
0.0283893645,
-0.0167994425,
-0.0072792196,
-0.0130890859,
0.0810764506,
0.0678135753,
-0.0145226708,
0.0233504772,
0.0152981766,
-0.0065578544,
0.078941308,
-0.0499451756,
-0.0198592711,
-0.0166282598,
-0.0345068201,
-0.0308744479,
0.0094561717,
0.0119389333,
0.0094680972,
-0.0125760259,
0.0596830957,
-0.0071973605,
0.022241734,
-0.0144097088,
0.0086163096,
0.0352937877,
-0.0448836833,
0.0105640516,
0.0566354319,
-0.0256448071,
-0.0290964246,
-0.005920345,
-0.0132044954,
0.0542649701,
-0.0515407845,
-0.0034676192,
-0.0189161561,
-0.007762332,
0.0960724428,
0.0118486825,
-0.0389262512,
-0.004360578,
-0.0036745195,
-0.0161200576,
-0.020390939,
-0.0460013263,
-0.0198529866,
-0.0064509762,
0.056562461,
0.0063907523,
0.0015107603,
-0.014330674,
0.0568834431,
0.0375517011,
-0.0348592103,
0.0144734969,
0.0575533323,
0.0327205844,
0.0506577417,
-0.0397553742,
0.0029098436,
-0.1264142543,
0.0164726544,
0.0115777804,
-0.0528786629,
0.0140118869,
-0.0076953061,
0.0673298091,
-0.0253626611,
0.0352850892,
0.0110715032,
0.0081713498,
0.0133328093,
-0.0388090238,
-0.0657968745,
0.0394718572,
-0.0034233013,
-0.0779025629,
-0.0579938069,
0.0252711289,
0.0735798851,
-0.0286314227,
0.0539515764,
-0.0369284004,
0.0143005596,
-0.0421278924,
0.0169924498,
-0.0249665212,
0.050590083,
0.0887184665,
0.0156131629,
-0.0073194331,
0.0435462892,
-0.0046498836,
-0.0008810979,
0.0851807594,
-0.0129179806,
0.0376320034,
0.0372718014,
0.012069108,
-0.0046161055,
0.0317623094,
0.0673817247,
0.0055242772,
-0.0341056399,
0.0143421926,
0.0084088417,
-0.0066214949,
-0.0433159545,
0.0164692737,
0.0714483932,
-0.0474151447,
0.0052769263,
0.0204869788,
-0.0132683143,
0.0017527891,
-0.0224225614,
0.0378250852,
0.0401771627,
-0.0118080778,
-0.0512643196,
0.0426613763,
0.0410062224,
-0.0611720905,
-0.0125700571,
0.0058575915,
-0.0062755775,
-0.0107818209,
0.039092835,
0.0137835359,
-0.0415696763,
0.0016512927,
-0.0005848416,
-0.0106461598,
0.0250186604,
0.0011235422,
-0.0554080047,
0.0236394368,
0.0380773395,
0.0394239686,
-0.0089317309,
0.0200489461,
-0.0071893805,
0.0615587942,
-0.0224857163,
0.057238698,
0.006450261,
0.0044546649,
0.0102716163,
0.0243341792,
0.0244039856,
0.0099321241,
-0.0129570039,
0.0501073115,
0.035727948,
-0.0389200859,
-0.0169414207,
-0.0365775749,
0.0033457787,
0.0035520308,
0.0020290478,
0.0185663067,
0.0119165611,
0.0011501219,
0.0467228778,
0.0064550596,
0.0311529171,
0.0369628444,
0.0103707286,
-0.0247748978,
0.0157910436,
0.0282105505,
0.0445062965,
0.0190283936,
-0.0244512111,
-0.0008833437,
0.0094065815,
0.0110422149,
-0.0037794476,
-0.0203127321,
-0.0253309291,
-0.0127713969,
0.021024432,
-0.0399388373,
0.0084299771,
-0.0139053697,
-0.0352154709,
0.0283768475,
-0.0027928757,
0.0544003099,
-0.0005361261,
-0.0050146719,
0.0042562066,
0.0216415878,
0.0191843398,
-0.0160670318,
-0.0556947254,
-0.0151866106,
0.0335652903,
-0.0743690878,
-0.0390096568,
0.0349491835,
-0.0818110555,
-0.0487938412,
-0.0206292458,
0.0068314099,
0.0416562222,
0.0480999202,
-0.0043310556,
-0.0221754722,
-0.043942254,
-0.0050104549,
0.0378097557,
0.0369712971,
0.0451746248,
0.0436172336,
0.0008394154,
-0.0660895482,
-0.0108593255,
0.0184429381,
0.0640410334,
0.0616573356,
-0.0273765866,
0.0235397611,
-0.0555900149,
-0.0575468913,
-0.0223461408,
-0.0239781812,
-0.0034951365,
-0.0002149393,
-0.0295646396,
-0.0215609875,
0.0342969336,
0.0497360229,
-0.0247739386,
-0.0318501554,
0.0517373271,
-0.0158281643,
-0.0161668453,
-0.0532259792,
-0.0290285144,
-0.0137217017,
-0.0664414465,
0.0421697646,
0.0461361036,
-0.0239909664,
-0.009244374,
-0.0157552008,
0.0422956683,
-0.0064481092,
-0.0171095133,
-0.0638210326,
-0.0025587012,
0.0213864036,
0.0665628016,
-0.0001452723,
-0.027865326,
0.0305547044,
0.0362191163,
0.0062287902,
0.0038428218,
-0.0616761483,
-0.043420881,
0.0245869793,
-0.0025383818,
0.0489885136,
-0.0499312952,
-0.0123789217,
-0.0043233559,
-0.0469163917,
0.0666290522,
-0.0637592599,
-0.0261633154,
0.0346013829,
0.0208076555,
0.008212625,
-0.0331538506,
-0.0193675682,
-0.0541063175,
-0.015072681,
-0.0168867689,
0.041750554,
-0.0446270145,
0.0281659663,
0.0092928121,
-0.0175347142,
-0.0037809189,
-0.0175322536,
-0.0472033657,
0.0206300244,
0.1156497747,
0.0436668359,
0.043143671,
0.0100862859,
-0.0126443002,
0.001002719,
0.065144904,
0.0695072562,
-0.0285223294,
-0.0046706763,
-0.0616335832,
0.0246645752,
-0.0496337786,
-0.0026693058,
0.0619193837,
-0.0147726871,
0.0268987045,
-0.0029325525,
0.0578337386,
0.0541061349,
-0.0296055265,
-0.0061135967,
-0.0272879452,
0.0260553416,
0.0450971201,
0.0459454134,
-0.0630481765,
0.0020281007,
-0.0111045865,
0.0717359185,
-0.0150091685,
-0.0538714044,
0.0067719556,
-0.0850620046,
0.0165851954,
-0.0627999678,
-0.0355176739,
0.013164049,
-0.1005305052,
-0.0402998924,
-0.0190060735,
-0.083255209,
-0.0120555609,
-0.0475800671,
0.0240572356,
0.0419693515,
-0.0495444983,
0.0455799513,
0.0340764783,
-0.0510883294,
0.036335025,
0.0574414395,
-0.0219221245,
-0.0477247573,
0.0033142392,
-0.0132824183,
0.0182052273,
0.0119329235,
-0.0144171119,
0.056895908,
-0.0141303204,
0.0209889095,
-0.0271346346,
0.0361926183,
-0.0357170478,
0.0439869799,
0.0616751276,
0.0258096214,
0.0117983157,
-0.0455196574,
-0.0475410745,
0.0074504102,
0.0039330083,
0.0408642739,
0.0287073832,
-0.0539877303,
-0.0338723212,
0.0238990355,
-0.0025410603,
-0.0114953872,
-0.0426530279,
-0.0102820834,
0.0680752769,
-0.0249400903,
-0.0572173782,
-0.0170116499,
0.0039734109,
0.0358265154,
0.0109403441,
0.061475385,
-0.0210810434,
0.0254610199,
-0.0650351197,
0.010513749,
0.0085890107,
-0.005406992,
-0.0887439251,
-0.0073979865,
0.0272316225,
-0.0198149271,
-0.0495267212,
-0.0236363001,
-0.062421266,
-0.0093708364,
-0.0069228732,
0.0562718846,
0.0275365226,
-0.0484654978,
-0.0345368609,
-0.0510892645,
-0.0346813574,
0.0468230173,
-0.0407224484,
0.0141898999,
-0.0330257379,
0.0098501397,
-0.0280902386,
-0.021268459,
-0.0642741323,
-0.0102670193,
-0.0250843763,
-0.0318377651,
-0.054758478,
-0.0406713262,
-0.0072166002,
0.0194271393,
-0.0025136529,
0.0330162905,
-0.0102444477,
0.0242201723,
0.0014209544,
0.0629519075,
0.0248424802,
0.0061157639,
-0.0275208838,
0.0259573609,
0.0002603943,
-0.0130418316,
0.0183535051,
0.0041423691,
0.0116842203,
-0.0697150379,
-0.010644841,
-0.0074242409,
0.0077846972,
0.0123195564,
0.0194719657,
-0.001457069,
-0.0016240142,
0.0505754165,
0.0485635027,
0.0043399753,
0.0254208986,
-0.0076736924,
0.0188361872,
0.0233012643,
0.0213285405,
-0.0727438927,
-0.1191001236,
0.0088445116,
0.0098082423,
0.0166357774,
0.0153357638,
0.0098958313,
0.0237155948,
0.0025178492,
-0.0326885991,
-0.012972286,
0.0374430791,
-0.0146840382,
0.02822892,
0.0194325,
-0.0271993671,
0.0271248743,
0.0778610185,
-0.0203533173,
0.0059873704,
0.0085595343,
-0.0432468466,
0.0054059541,
-0.0000622425,
0.0228294935,
0.0053874329,
-0.0266625285,
0.0149046918,
-0.0389183499,
-0.0228119586,
0.005415129,
-0.0170705542,
0.0217905063,
0.0001033903,
0.069556646,
0.0528390184,
0.022851238,
-0.0219150428,
-0.0553325415,
0.0668799728,
-0.1023871154,
-0.015024689,
0.0219057947,
-6.947997398e-33,
0.0307024624,
-0.0610297546,
0.0025312006,
-0.0006661151,
0.0193653386,
0.0027963673,
0.0024872848,
0.0213903692,
-0.0318767056,
-0.023913784,
-0.0293665696,
0.0333381034,
-0.00110688,
-0.0032243098,
0.0131221889,
-0.0575292073,
-0.0061400691,
-0.0079716863,
0.0026466523,
0.0431625135,
-0.0185483601,
0.0138026271,
-0.0492690951,
-0.0237972811,
0.0018259715,
-0.0297388565,
0.0087987697,
0.0272086021,
0.0176685676,
0.0577509254,
-0.0016153473,
0.0220331959,
0.0398374945,
-0.0219706781,
0.054865405,
0.0298410673,
-0.107662268,
0.0283809714,
0.0120428763,
-0.0239812508,
-0.0487250164,
0.0104484865,
0.0368087031,
0.0131199779,
0.0248970985,
0.0107346531,
0.0885966569,
0.0331270732,
-0.0123512009,
-0.0786371902,
0.006965531,
0.0107547715,
-0.0779047757,
0.0050079301,
-0.0299672484,
0.0763268545,
-0.0125689162,
0.0360941216,
-0.0878084898,
-0.0063724355,
-0.0296627935,
0.0313256048,
-0.0105798682,
0.0394481719,
0.0028418163,
0.0087753264,
0.0232507624,
0.0269156732,
0.0111171054,
0.00003444,
0.0005818339,
0.0171858799,
0.055001121,
0.0083605209,
0.0228159092,
-0.0109998304,
-0.1115228757,
0.0774274617,
0.0451901257,
-0.0295519028,
0.037893638,
-0.0541095287,
-0.0444662981,
0.0128144277,
-0.0373874679,
0.0317021906,
-0.0438303575,
-0.0163836908,
0.0144538293,
0.0389090255,
-0.0378462002,
-0.0249492954,
0.0294611976,
-0.0403701589,
-0.0612791739,
0.0162599515,
0.0103189023,
0.0492183566,
0.0395227745,
0.0255204849,
-0.0253129415,
0.0667723119,
-0.052602116,
-0.0298146605,
0.0068705068,
0.0066274093,
-0.0276197493,
-0.0106200268,
-0.0330672152,
-0.0206475146,
-0.0060816989,
0.0119841658,
-0.0357876942,
-0.0117184399,
0.0241904333,
0.0375203304,
0.0109836459,
0.0215138681,
0.0267758425,
0.0497956909,
0.0026616352,
-0.0525594205,
0.0121315494,
-0.0356383733,
-0.0072337119,
-0.0065144752,
-0.0317618698,
0.0496992543,
-0.0065593091,
-0.021264175,
-0.0098986104,
-0.040831659,
2.665e-7,
0.0427605323,
0.0223359894,
-0.0117809176,
0.0139590213,
0.0296066646,
-0.0135948658,
0.0351019837,
0.0414198078,
0.0244581699,
-0.0401634425,
-0.0013668897,
0.0174533203,
0.0095305601,
0.0458952449,
-0.0568257533,
-0.0568820499,
-0.0664783865,
0.032264512,
-0.0418054014,
-0.0161407944,
-0.0286785755,
0.0022268221,
-0.0312926695,
0.008865091,
-0.0241276622,
-0.0042804754,
0.0250822641,
-0.0258661229,
0.0420835428,
0.0446577892,
0.0194219295,
0.015019116,
0.0317351148,
-0.0183337517,
-0.0279521756,
-0.009222433,
0.0115463892,
-0.0187630318,
-0.0024042388,
-0.0551760122,
0.0014404124,
-0.0275574308,
0.0434434898,
-0.0847212449,
0.0758224204,
-0.0359909907,
-0.0430486836,
-0.0356460065,
-0.0014341088,
-0.0225579087,
0.0101743583,
-0.0023187804,
-0.0213035922,
-0.0117898183,
-0.000596456,
-0.030337194,
-0.0013963402,
-0.0531456433,
0.0207528304,
0.0190512836,
-0.0244113505,
-0.0562665202,
-0.0614276975,
0.0074942834,
-0.0097500924,
0.0393450297,
0.0154629927,
1.815391805e-34,
0.0077015348,
0.0370287187,
0.0183061864,
0.049875237,
0.0157093052,
-0.0196851846,
-0.0105159916,
-0.0215559844,
0.0379213542,
-0.0594181716,
0.0391865894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05958v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05958v1 | The Moral Machine Experiment on Large Language Models | 2023-09-12T04:49:39 | 2023-09-12T04:49:39 | Kazuhiro Takemoto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | As large language models (LLMs) become more deeply integrated into various
sectors, understanding how they make moral judgments has become crucial,
particularly in the realm of autonomous driving. This study utilized the Moral
Machine framework to investigate the ethical decision-making tendencies of
prominent LLMs, including GPT-3.5, GPT-4, PaLM 2, and Llama 2, comparing their
responses to human preferences. While LLMs' and humans' preferences such as
prioritizing humans over pets and favoring saving more lives are broadly
aligned, PaLM 2 and Llama 2, especially, evidence distinct deviations.
Additionally, despite the qualitative similarities between the LLM and human
preferences, there are significant quantitative disparities, suggesting that
LLMs might lean toward more uncompromising decisions, compared to the milder
inclinations of humans. These insights elucidate the ethical frameworks of LLMs
and their potential implications for autonomous driving. | [
0.0591559075,
0.1015142202,
-0.0321662351,
0.0350697115,
-0.0596810728,
0.036535874,
0.0086767552,
0.0252085328,
-0.004435461,
-0.0333525948,
-0.0029141009,
0.0133422231,
-0.0252771955,
-0.0208813008,
-0.0079877637,
-0.0222073775,
0.0094030742,
-0.0238204431,
0.077554591,
-0.023899531,
-0.0235443544,
0.0209170282,
0.0645925775,
-0.0020918197,
0.0199994314,
0.0284849182,
0.01682497,
-0.0261285007,
0.0367822424,
-0.0361005813,
-0.013527046,
0.0252249353,
0.0699036121,
0.0229651127,
0.0000018723,
-0.0456186682,
0.0159728695,
0.0262416694,
0.0434682965,
0.0158295892,
0.0965723917,
0.0194767583,
0.0004921345,
-0.0015548653,
-0.0422994159,
0.0303260367,
0.0202064607,
0.0447305813,
-0.0304917097,
0.0528823212,
-0.0061582532,
-0.0235304236,
0.0176956728,
0.0031288483,
-0.0301284958,
0.0030841934,
0.0529150404,
0.0422330536,
-0.0113965338,
0.0040881541,
-0.0163059738,
0.0170158017,
0.0381859355,
-0.0013406347,
-0.0440689176,
0.0067916084,
0.0068933102,
-0.0534066223,
0.0181061197,
0.0314090885,
0.0171796139,
-0.0145051088,
0.0369345471,
0.0017625791,
0.0213887673,
-0.0341181643,
0.0068019293,
0.071936056,
0.0001524631,
0.0401968583,
0.0194518678,
0.0069443216,
0.0094927931,
0.0425186343,
0.0015191055,
0.0308831204,
-0.0054579489,
-0.01870865,
0.0205065981,
0.028041102,
-0.054350201,
-0.0195038971,
0.0017894717,
0.021306973,
-0.0199894272,
0.0186663568,
0.0052979826,
0.0911622569,
0.0517537743,
-0.0764993951,
0.0484224111,
0.0190172307,
-0.0013769949,
-0.0077450853,
0.0265935175,
0.0340557285,
-0.0163538717,
0.0387354307,
-0.0335445255,
0.0286595915,
0.0052032643,
0.0015976932,
0.052302517,
0.0128667699,
0.0152175883,
0.0569356382,
-0.0220819153,
0.0205666702,
-0.0354066119,
-0.0092020771,
-0.0596166141,
0.0275495611,
0.0217148531,
0.0039081522,
-0.0342581272,
-0.0153214308,
-0.0392005928,
0.0414022803,
-0.0123043284,
-0.0058301655,
0.0726619363,
-0.014791701,
-0.0428038836,
-0.017532343,
0.0328278206,
0.1579337716,
-0.0038926748,
-0.015920613,
0.0016544966,
0.0244347062,
0.0092322854,
-0.0711420923,
-0.0117032668,
-0.0433118083,
0.008964831,
0.003709065,
-0.022265669,
-0.0326624438,
0.0338135473,
0.01482083,
-0.0234062541,
0.0282371026,
0.0034069959,
0.0189809054,
0.0378448069,
0.0122171612,
-0.0011975577,
0.046379976,
0.0361357555,
0.0196318105,
0.0363819599,
-0.0015221274,
-0.0084166396,
-0.0194426421,
-0.040688742,
0.0094201453,
-0.0528028607,
0.0131724495,
-0.0297235437,
0.0383371748,
0.0558940582,
0.0718610808,
-0.0135431634,
-0.0221341141,
0.061719168,
0.1021447778,
-0.0182052795,
0.037124455,
0.0047511854,
0.0044735563,
0.015961349,
0.0130435955,
-0.0673967078,
-0.005119314,
-0.0036236402,
-0.0168586224,
-0.0622948371,
0.0567878038,
-0.0118120341,
-0.0316730849,
0.0137253823,
-0.0130223231,
0.0360562056,
-0.0061041112,
0.002373575,
-0.0969938859,
0.0040013585,
-0.1019687578,
0.0197993461,
-0.0066566132,
-0.0200992562,
-0.034537062,
0.0761278346,
0.0624452382,
0.0177045744,
0.008041326,
0.0005673469,
-0.0223354995,
-0.0510423966,
0.0090281144,
0.0329978801,
-0.014024592,
-0.0313791521,
-0.0219380688,
-0.0129297264,
0.0085870642,
-0.0058839796,
0.0022415915,
-0.0296943877,
0.0374591239,
0.0261068959,
0.0014546742,
-0.0263466984,
0.0279209744,
0.0049570068,
0.0204456244,
-0.071054399,
-0.0007581093,
0.0116936658,
-0.0299875475,
-0.0207235925,
-0.0177250896,
0.0064278576,
0.0117578469,
-0.016999064,
0.0191889219,
-0.0231244806,
0.0828323215,
0.039862372,
-0.0881895125,
-0.0118861282,
0.045707833,
0.0087560304,
0.0327773467,
-0.0727741122,
-0.0307639968,
0.0064921309,
-0.045624584,
0.0224834271,
-0.0606214255,
-0.0012690307,
-0.0386994407,
0.038324926,
-0.0108218035,
0.0016850858,
0.0006382376,
-0.0266929641,
0.0339040346,
-0.0082235616,
-0.0174712315,
0.0406328887,
-0.0099752294,
0.0386522897,
0.0310898572,
0.0451831967,
-0.0344186127,
-0.0446412303,
-0.0402018838,
-0.0337579958,
0.0373822972,
-0.0062045348,
-0.040903829,
-0.0525496379,
-0.0141985444,
0.0328159593,
-0.0175971426,
0.0000152821,
0.0333013497,
0.0391779989,
0.0268685389,
-0.0483885333,
-0.0234778561,
-0.0133068925,
-0.0120641561,
-0.0340852104,
-0.0207419675,
0.0393548831,
0.0016906813,
-0.0564041547,
0.0306585524,
-0.067241542,
0.0054937098,
0.0115907891,
-0.0593445562,
0.0243771393,
0.0500855371,
0.0057116374,
0.1131664217,
0.0587268695,
0.0228820015,
0.0400289111,
0.060459137,
-0.0485283844,
-0.047782585,
0.0055237091,
-0.0254925024,
-0.0345613286,
-0.0617825277,
-0.0330152437,
0.0533885136,
-0.0326029733,
0.0222868621,
-0.0023704607,
0.0368732773,
-0.0416065529,
-0.0771583915,
0.0029317001,
-0.0318836384,
-0.0290255882,
0.0743938386,
-0.0002263966,
-0.0600500666,
0.0731106624,
0.0349415392,
0.0364403501,
0.0151191754,
0.0211785585,
-0.0006400262,
0.047806073,
0.01535933,
0.0170645043,
0.0062265806,
0.0014078135,
-0.0384712704,
-0.0001803173,
-0.0044728345,
-0.0283433348,
0.0505586192,
-0.0360558853,
0.009596522,
-0.0120934229,
-0.0718701556,
-0.0164709352,
-0.0444219708,
-0.0600640103,
-0.0022636964,
0.0163357835,
-0.0396713801,
0.0402787514,
-0.0264129788,
0.027993314,
-0.0290897749,
-0.0077773337,
0.0158464499,
-0.0095975418,
-0.0730775148,
0.0485389195,
0.0054947538,
0.0700100437,
-0.0093764393,
0.0453523919,
0.0419922806,
0.0252392609,
-0.0035835418,
0.004980877,
0.0208438821,
0.0404248051,
0.0050381953,
-0.0116869453,
0.0421974994,
0.0132653555,
-0.0069128294,
0.0306241587,
0.0877157748,
-0.0157263335,
-0.0672386065,
0.0301303491,
-0.0438300222,
-0.0384345725,
0.0087328535,
0.0272942074,
-0.0741674453,
0.010464157,
-0.0026619281,
0.0048632473,
-0.075614363,
-0.0519108772,
0.0492923111,
-0.068821162,
0.0257795751,
0.0101070432,
-0.0381684788,
-0.0411355644,
-0.0156493913,
-0.0085373139,
-0.0280051716,
0.0269754082,
0.0299649797,
-0.0137069598,
-0.0314349681,
0.0070026885,
0.0518960617,
0.0108701764,
0.0639630407,
-0.0414873175,
0.0724018142,
0.0841389894,
0.0164952967,
-0.0648230165,
-0.0433661342,
-0.0037556221,
0.0402760506,
-0.0008604826,
-0.0016312939,
-0.034799099,
-0.0448167436,
-0.0015694484,
-0.0503891334,
-0.002023363,
0.0048685675,
0.0057649082,
-0.0035676865,
0.0685823634,
-0.0124691557,
-0.0755206645,
-0.0135831637,
0.0038699957,
-0.0393401124,
0.0408921279,
-0.003687731,
-0.0469133817,
-0.0048744464,
-0.0316090733,
-0.0737395436,
0.0241020005,
-0.0515644103,
-0.0397976376,
-0.0073939511,
-0.0484541506,
-0.0271945037,
-0.059113089,
-0.0482208617,
-0.0127078919,
0.0392012075,
-0.0509534776,
0.0760596693,
-0.0086761443,
-0.0480207391,
0.0089374557,
-0.0064101997,
-0.0201207772,
-0.0098049855,
0.0422986299,
0.0402345993,
-0.0014880472,
-0.0116056129,
-0.0477929898,
0.0410829112,
-0.042529989,
0.0596287698,
0.053868439,
0.0139518296,
-0.005630719,
-0.0073980209,
-0.0358168073,
-0.0113446796,
0.0429139286,
-0.052085463,
0.0678142831,
0.0276647061,
0.026796909,
-0.0114126084,
0.0145550165,
-0.0038344483,
0.0320840366,
0.0129082445,
-0.0341290459,
-0.0343021601,
-0.0409930386,
0.0201022997,
0.0355786979,
-0.0094584879,
-0.0378616452,
0.0225886311,
-0.0211888049,
-0.0417119153,
-0.0299968906,
-0.0270618908,
-0.0406194218,
-0.0097591411,
0.014610786,
0.0274570398,
-0.0176905971,
-0.0417318754,
-0.0325769112,
-0.0136009706,
0.0045068366,
0.0286426209,
0.0089160148,
0.058154989,
-0.0196850169,
0.0054966123,
-0.0216512177,
0.0172988921,
-0.0212946981,
0.0537330657,
0.0014866806,
0.0927632004,
0.0072546653,
0.0049969214,
0.0112638613,
0.0335594602,
-0.0477550812,
-0.0710306689,
-0.0116915694,
0.0084429123,
0.0047185835,
0.0179117098,
0.0050714673,
-0.0255211331,
-0.0063748555,
-0.0248091538,
0.0081464443,
-0.0049538217,
-0.0001516144,
0.017908508,
-0.0058319606,
-0.0454406962,
-0.0111921867,
0.0387499109,
-0.0077056033,
0.01713036,
-0.0011883395,
-0.0035516156,
0.0010640126,
-0.053597413,
0.061056599,
-0.0801883489,
-0.0156682432,
-0.0531108938,
-0.0509808622,
-0.0447599553,
-0.0404168367,
0.0280260034,
0.0007670529,
-0.0582747273,
-0.0442434251,
0.042000182,
0.0005440419,
-0.0227473415,
-0.0238603894,
0.0115327872,
-0.0164428633,
0.0070891664,
-0.0506134219,
-5.592433108e-33,
-0.019437287,
-0.0238844603,
-0.0144577809,
-0.0308182668,
-0.037037164,
-0.0411863029,
0.014057667,
0.0436578728,
-0.0587122217,
0.0296960566,
-0.0156460293,
0.0007930375,
0.0048373276,
-0.0360264741,
0.0692223907,
-0.057689745,
-0.0145160044,
-0.0276321433,
-0.0012806266,
-0.0024254695,
-0.0398448408,
0.0143322358,
0.0218509156,
-0.0805684328,
0.0566369444,
0.0120387506,
-0.0087736025,
0.0020706155,
-0.0576553904,
0.0069128135,
0.0020633894,
0.0403337553,
0.0298054479,
0.0026976352,
-0.0047094338,
0.0340108015,
0.0432990082,
0.0045977123,
0.0739226565,
-0.0240733493,
-0.0047983145,
-0.0715570003,
0.0269259717,
-0.035348583,
-0.0481074601,
0.0171894804,
0.045876462,
-0.0459360518,
0.0055061863,
-0.0154732913,
-0.0528259724,
-0.0094258096,
-0.0197661482,
0.0133876838,
-0.0325842537,
0.0146647738,
-0.0302464943,
0.0592703633,
0.0379204825,
0.015060096,
0.0092056552,
-0.015949361,
0.0306930542,
-0.0332772024,
0.0485471748,
0.0750600249,
-0.0026503764,
0.0140166301,
-0.0338647887,
-0.0259324387,
0.000455906,
0.0545254424,
0.0199828148,
0.0513338521,
-0.0478051789,
-0.0477996133,
-0.0121589499,
-0.0289628766,
0.0460332297,
-0.0294082444,
0.0281062238,
0.0037152078,
-0.0423786789,
0.0018438211,
-0.0365691856,
-0.0775629058,
-0.0129709803,
-0.0225610621,
-0.0022483082,
-0.026083298,
-0.0230092388,
-0.0249458812,
0.0295917131,
-0.0593899935,
0.0249124262,
-0.0182669181,
-0.0172030609,
0.0033086643,
-0.0082605761,
0.0221536476,
-0.0808212236,
-0.0410129167,
-0.0170841943,
0.0004219566,
0.032637354,
0.001223263,
-0.0029923557,
-0.0181941092,
0.0073795174,
0.0052057486,
-0.0056026592,
-0.0417088568,
0.0541164353,
-0.0207405128,
0.0044850954,
0.0039963545,
0.0274155047,
-0.0366379507,
0.0067882808,
-0.027231697,
-0.060749568,
-0.0223396774,
-0.0362288207,
0.0482729599,
-0.0014674905,
0.0063040247,
-0.0264049917,
0.0735220611,
0.0186233427,
-0.0269785412,
-0.0121602882,
-0.0002689056,
2.496e-7,
0.0121583119,
0.0129975956,
0.0037605492,
-0.0088823242,
-0.0104369782,
0.0863984004,
0.0482364371,
0.0514100976,
0.0440726802,
-0.0161934141,
0.0224638265,
0.0258566067,
0.0361558013,
-0.0167511161,
0.0385479294,
0.0164674055,
-0.0446751416,
-0.0285480116,
-0.0341111086,
0.0344624631,
0.0148459878,
0.0509093776,
-0.0034425647,
-0.0183969084,
-0.0002085035,
0.0322921053,
0.0115453359,
-0.1080185398,
-0.0111553334,
-0.0119505497,
-0.0311141461,
0.0070388238,
0.0022210979,
0.021036176,
0.0513992049,
-0.0272355676,
-0.0021601536,
0.0930091366,
0.0097543504,
-0.0409939438,
0.0028905235,
-0.0440324843,
-0.0151070859,
-0.039902091,
0.0622306317,
-0.0105021298,
-0.0289072897,
-0.0555167869,
0.0217974968,
-0.0649626032,
0.0033135586,
-0.0275405757,
0.0272498857,
0.0264841802,
-0.0034112011,
0.0198923536,
0.0059588016,
-0.0319138318,
0.0104836645,
-0.0306440163,
0.0027586615,
-0.0900208578,
-0.00553357,
0.0575331002,
0.0358126499,
-0.0317656696,
0.0004503055,
1.457690022e-34,
0.02788697,
-0.0180980638,
0.0110747935,
0.0247034859,
0.0444573537,
0.0787420273,
-0.0142947454,
0.0134836389,
-0.0050325911,
-0.0161386635,
-0.0059529184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05951v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05951v1 | Balanced and Explainable Social Media Analysis for Public Health with Large Language Models | 2023-09-12T04:15:34 | 2023-09-12T04:15:34 | Yan Jiang, Ruihong Qiu, Yi Zhang, Peng-Fei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | As social media becomes increasingly popular, more and more public health
activities emerge, which is worth noting for pandemic monitoring and government
decision-making. Current techniques for public health analysis involve popular
models such as BERT and large language models (LLMs). Although recent progress
in LLMs has shown a strong ability to comprehend knowledge by being fine-tuned
on specific domain datasets, the costs of training an in-domain LLM for every
specific public health task are especially expensive. Furthermore, such kinds
of in-domain datasets from social media are generally highly imbalanced, which
will hinder the efficiency of LLMs tuning. To tackle these challenges, the data
imbalance issue can be overcome by sophisticated data augmentation methods for
social media datasets. In addition, the ability of the LLMs can be effectively
utilised by prompting the model properly. In light of the above discussion, in
this paper, a novel ALEX framework is proposed for social media analysis on
public health. Specifically, an augmentation pipeline is developed to resolve
the data imbalance issue. Furthermore, an LLMs explanation mechanism is
proposed by prompting an LLM with the predicted results from BERT models.
Extensive experiments conducted on three tasks at the Social Media Mining for
Health 2023 (SMM4H) competition with the first ranking in two tasks demonstrate
the superior performance of the proposed ALEX method. Our code has been
released in https://github.com/YanJiangJerry/ALEX. | [
0.0386451073,
0.0526111014,
-0.0072287498,
-0.0110284062,
0.0259512533,
0.0334477685,
-0.014155061,
-0.0223268606,
0.020194279,
-0.0129360575,
0.032452289,
-0.0121165225,
-0.0349879041,
0.0526099503,
0.0105207441,
-0.0528535023,
0.0108905323,
0.018228652,
0.0390017405,
0.018567482,
0.0274218451,
0.0127231609,
-0.0126453117,
0.0566450804,
0.0424731672,
0.0390818268,
-0.0092350235,
-0.0075082807,
0.0500448234,
-0.0583714806,
0.0013244752,
0.0106165167,
0.0522292219,
0.041509591,
0.0000020885,
-0.047208745,
-0.0102159409,
0.0104476586,
-0.0312411822,
-0.0031284695,
0.0057655731,
-0.0483603776,
0.035727147,
0.0448467508,
-0.0357585251,
0.0142676104,
0.0710594207,
0.0348754115,
0.0640144423,
0.0716565326,
-0.0144960545,
-0.0374999531,
0.0080458364,
-0.0311457496,
-0.017776968,
-0.0209044088,
0.0478000231,
-0.0347893089,
0.0177042093,
0.010283676,
0.0245691352,
0.0225720666,
0.0023330592,
-0.0104156481,
0.0448803157,
0.0252911728,
-0.0469803326,
-0.0330034234,
-0.0098094838,
0.0758986175,
-0.0139473407,
-0.0031298483,
0.0152882086,
-0.0200635884,
0.0074769603,
0.0411764197,
-0.0520219989,
-0.0197311398,
-0.0047261314,
0.0733027384,
-0.0142281242,
0.0232169759,
0.0564220101,
0.047216896,
-0.0112876603,
0.0398620889,
-0.0331175849,
-0.0178421736,
-0.0282553118,
0.0197963584,
-0.0331749767,
-0.016133707,
0.0381849967,
0.04624236,
-0.0531078428,
0.0178185403,
0.0299356561,
-0.0539629273,
0.0499771237,
-0.0971151292,
0.0002893231,
-0.0090522589,
-0.0188572053,
0.0344393775,
0.0483462736,
0.002215897,
-0.0026662673,
0.0250032544,
0.0124186827,
-0.0038343498,
-0.0731749088,
0.0211129859,
-0.0117583675,
-0.0028224243,
-0.0035549717,
0.0366940275,
-0.0675785318,
-0.0003393647,
-0.0303647909,
-0.0151221985,
-0.0056550913,
0.0439204238,
-0.017342519,
-0.0130990343,
-0.0320134088,
0.047823932,
-0.0123861628,
0.0484056547,
-0.0053223926,
-0.0004379195,
0.0144282989,
-0.0024450081,
0.0477325171,
-0.0138100171,
-0.0225533918,
0.0401365645,
0.0313379504,
-0.0030050778,
-0.0369048081,
-0.012615989,
0.0014335765,
-0.0510564744,
-0.0213374458,
-0.0521323383,
0.0422993042,
0.0286231935,
-0.0055214977,
-0.0099877827,
0.0048853238,
-0.0113339061,
-0.0780190602,
0.0428822152,
-0.0396239832,
0.0208509099,
0.0329455882,
0.0323645435,
0.0140435779,
0.080623053,
0.0323889256,
0.0276877545,
0.0313447639,
-0.0458872207,
0.0090336446,
-0.000820976,
0.0482823625,
0.0205633678,
0.0179341622,
-0.0017983097,
-0.0709562302,
0.003632874,
-0.0229915865,
0.0117115127,
0.0129187955,
0.0196708161,
0.0411068052,
-0.0013168296,
0.0371415801,
0.0086753899,
0.0078197373,
0.0306536425,
-0.0103676748,
-0.0061829272,
-0.0204923395,
0.0483966619,
-0.0301208161,
-0.0148230838,
0.0492413864,
0.0377143845,
-0.0415142328,
-0.0451368317,
-0.0048493226,
0.0156955179,
0.0258630347,
0.0012438097,
0.0516932011,
-0.0323815867,
-0.0177990198,
0.0585696474,
0.0477491543,
-0.0377829298,
0.0099431016,
-0.0534147359,
0.0107837692,
0.0629509762,
0.0155921895,
-0.0391391888,
-0.0184676964,
-0.0452068374,
0.051256679,
0.0156625565,
0.0052505555,
0.002228904,
0.0077868281,
-0.0282482803,
-0.0463797785,
-0.0123669282,
0.0281212963,
-0.0332315713,
0.010242423,
0.0338272564,
0.0022863704,
-0.0411742292,
-0.0519232452,
0.0102388738,
-0.0144579057,
-0.0131505653,
-0.0044188048,
0.0183163378,
0.0365851708,
0.0606801845,
0.0297792628,
0.0131777991,
0.0272037014,
-0.0452342592,
-0.0384027958,
-0.0123655805,
0.0267389007,
-0.0200935192,
0.0400157869,
-0.0497637987,
0.0146290222,
0.0264711138,
-0.0881538764,
-0.0196692012,
0.0615412593,
-0.0423165709,
0.0612023734,
-0.0123367365,
-0.0001909643,
-0.020355111,
0.0261693224,
-0.0027776984,
0.0526140854,
-0.0309252031,
-0.023811454,
-0.024858389,
-0.0539412685,
-0.0237313285,
-0.020013852,
0.0188046917,
-0.0284306537,
0.0115555618,
0.0238490328,
0.0136391381,
-0.0488484465,
-0.042541407,
0.0005421292,
-0.0888889432,
0.0077886134,
-0.0225185119,
0.0170829315,
0.0012492852,
0.0376064852,
-0.0053132675,
-0.0203058198,
-0.0173364971,
-0.014757853,
0.0056001572,
0.0305233561,
0.0327765532,
0.0221067891,
-0.013744832,
-0.024747787,
0.0045277709,
-0.0385305509,
0.0324960984,
0.0522503257,
-0.0591675602,
-0.008642192,
-0.0186584145,
-0.0419502296,
-0.032441102,
-0.0166521948,
-0.0384260193,
-0.0098102977,
0.0202832874,
-0.0228812005,
-0.0299219433,
0.0181666166,
0.0391938016,
0.041395016,
0.0394058861,
-0.0292713437,
0.0149777588,
-0.0506112054,
-0.0015892396,
0.0010789918,
-0.0389646627,
0.0136213405,
0.0758815035,
-0.0234897621,
0.0066241636,
-0.0309746265,
-0.0000626079,
-0.0068704742,
0.0090684341,
-0.0510289371,
-0.0273812097,
0.0033883729,
0.0259289555,
-0.0325655825,
-0.0498908199,
0.0535028353,
0.0026554142,
0.0321491174,
-0.0532180816,
-0.0436627194,
-0.0453784689,
-0.0032153977,
0.0027490354,
0.0205787718,
-0.0019124647,
0.0064807148,
0.0531701855,
-0.0506262146,
-0.0058543808,
-0.0353415683,
0.0341454372,
0.0009693318,
0.0056088315,
0.0111731039,
-0.0508937463,
-0.0353982113,
-0.0976366624,
-0.064058125,
0.0072251395,
-0.0245307535,
-0.0166944973,
-0.0574601181,
0.0272237193,
-0.0023904331,
-0.0067659742,
0.0135229565,
-0.015320777,
0.0353198983,
-0.0005247026,
0.0386430509,
-0.0008915114,
0.0058772042,
-0.0284192692,
0.0356368795,
0.0106165735,
0.0062577352,
-0.0030587122,
-0.0603825301,
0.011348444,
-0.0350120328,
-0.024795875,
0.0015820911,
0.000444526,
0.0564737208,
-0.0339081883,
0.0644567683,
0.0954718515,
0.0144587923,
-0.0294467639,
0.0351930633,
-0.0143533843,
-0.0419471785,
-0.0036438205,
0.0126094744,
-0.0745002404,
-0.0299121216,
-0.0127905468,
0.0239010882,
-0.0098558171,
-0.0511056893,
0.0190014951,
-0.0717115104,
0.0650303289,
0.017351849,
-0.0220801048,
-0.0447399691,
-0.0990194827,
0.0249065161,
-0.0529007353,
0.0132106561,
-0.0448655747,
0.0025921767,
0.0111894105,
0.0292274188,
-0.0389530435,
-0.0990853012,
-0.0076276814,
-0.0439380668,
0.0578524694,
0.0443637073,
0.0720464066,
-0.0202503484,
-0.0175555293,
0.0249088202,
0.046085313,
0.0156787932,
-0.0042987838,
0.1015712395,
0.0178473704,
-0.01548706,
-0.0603410304,
0.0421890877,
-0.0317309834,
-0.0426389426,
0.0067086834,
0.0980073959,
-0.0169346407,
-0.0129528427,
-0.0486197397,
0.0253012069,
0.0530843288,
0.0624690726,
0.0582721531,
0.0112464884,
0.0067637442,
-0.0230494905,
0.0015996301,
-0.0559526682,
0.0159254614,
0.0241231713,
-0.0206087641,
-0.0781994984,
-0.0061535179,
-0.0011617558,
0.0607595667,
-0.0297538713,
-0.0305144228,
0.0073213689,
0.0311053097,
-0.0144607807,
-0.0472063348,
0.0599270277,
0.0184129197,
0.0457130186,
-0.0068691717,
-0.0763674974,
0.0012273322,
-0.0035183367,
0.004044435,
0.002705948,
-0.0491846018,
-0.062024951,
-0.0094468324,
0.0008517923,
0.0271079708,
0.0415596478,
-0.0083700372,
-0.0550368726,
0.0503786318,
0.0825304389,
-0.0379789919,
-0.0614884235,
-0.0102725914,
0.0085398993,
0.0148396892,
0.0338033661,
-0.0089748073,
-0.0191000123,
0.014680665,
0.0208468251,
-0.0740871876,
0.0162353478,
-0.0107114948,
0.0091893831,
0.0866189599,
0.000223129,
-0.0539529212,
-0.0573179349,
-0.0120708067,
0.0268152039,
-0.0086631393,
-0.0211037043,
0.0179325212,
0.0109290462,
-0.022995621,
-0.0242616832,
0.0311565772,
-0.0473300554,
-0.0197154991,
-0.0835193619,
0.0941044763,
-0.0067736935,
0.0302182008,
0.0454361923,
0.0150470175,
-0.0000771132,
0.0166683309,
0.0339995548,
0.0078183357,
0.0093489606,
0.0035373264,
-0.0146318236,
0.0568397939,
-0.0223370381,
0.0319112875,
-0.028078869,
-0.0310558137,
-0.0303535201,
0.0277854521,
0.0458686911,
-0.0266183298,
0.0529299639,
0.0118591962,
-0.0257200934,
-0.0011476589,
0.034375336,
-0.0386036932,
-0.026828574,
0.0249842387,
-0.0086373007,
-0.0438318737,
0.0049734544,
0.0980714187,
-0.0076061971,
0.030811891,
0.0211720318,
-0.0391210429,
-0.0076505835,
-0.0064610341,
0.0418058299,
0.0489788055,
-0.0204814319,
0.0308279283,
-0.0323498696,
-0.0850133151,
-0.0032244506,
-0.1038477719,
-0.0465032272,
-0.0039807619,
0.0016489263,
0.0424468592,
0.0073094731,
0.0036281908,
-0.0503584072,
0.0034447294,
-0.0274180695,
-0.0189768914,
0.0134991258,
-6.531046613e-33,
0.0260645598,
-0.0423258692,
-0.004918565,
-0.0489734933,
0.0023903758,
0.0323539637,
-0.0537434965,
-0.0264031868,
-0.0028523824,
0.0497247726,
0.0136405956,
0.0109601151,
0.0117963199,
0.0183140319,
0.0047561084,
-0.0256259032,
0.0334727578,
0.0293880831,
-0.0201946311,
0.0460173227,
0.0319516324,
0.0501691848,
0.0373516344,
-0.0831114724,
0.0194622055,
0.0178463571,
-0.0082084127,
0.0085095838,
0.0248249359,
0.0753238201,
0.0017945128,
0.082053721,
0.0559359044,
-0.050439816,
-0.0072567672,
0.0544241741,
-0.0342259556,
-0.0385486335,
0.0174717605,
-0.0262603704,
-0.023458939,
-0.0196508635,
0.0489500165,
0.0141005218,
-0.0005901122,
0.0018853097,
0.0440015793,
-0.0397472791,
0.0231254045,
-0.0144405784,
-0.0301987827,
0.0355123654,
-0.0675533712,
-0.0186492354,
-0.0161936749,
0.0060614999,
-0.0147483861,
0.0595780872,
-0.0525928475,
0.0128669851,
0.054078836,
-0.0175166987,
0.0402849019,
0.0267770216,
-0.0176907554,
0.0444659591,
-0.0039870287,
0.0096561555,
-0.0714599118,
0.0356108136,
-0.0434281193,
0.0547193624,
0.0374435931,
0.0263191592,
0.0109287305,
-0.0135883167,
-0.1030457988,
0.0581588186,
0.0042184605,
0.0241203941,
0.005386617,
0.0192023944,
-0.033759471,
-0.0251382738,
-0.005691289,
-0.0268089455,
-0.0351923965,
-0.0212862734,
-0.0283588395,
-0.000026793,
-0.031323351,
0.0563880168,
-0.0194123294,
-0.0390084535,
-0.0455927178,
0.0217959899,
0.033007741,
-0.0337357968,
0.0109611917,
0.0034177194,
-0.042644158,
0.0058104307,
-0.0045253998,
0.0402016714,
0.0050672735,
-0.0180407185,
0.0297847874,
0.0071504996,
-0.0195895452,
-0.0033397085,
-0.0406196006,
0.0030989875,
-0.0260279384,
0.0273906197,
-0.0081535093,
0.0123033933,
-0.0099632414,
0.0711497217,
0.0070802211,
0.0253914408,
0.0258873962,
-0.0021826131,
-0.0426700525,
0.0002047077,
-0.0255998094,
-0.026155442,
-0.0128779691,
-0.0160440598,
0.0410764888,
-0.067998074,
-0.0306100715,
-0.0592052788,
2.759e-7,
0.092301704,
0.0505962819,
-0.0058748946,
-0.0454015061,
0.0200710259,
0.041956529,
-0.0188188888,
0.0177356564,
-0.0066614216,
-0.0060115745,
0.019407358,
0.0453192145,
0.0109198317,
0.040456973,
-0.0360879265,
0.0106533924,
-0.108946763,
-0.0159708429,
-0.0707543045,
0.0132577531,
0.0018757461,
0.0690602511,
0.0250224471,
-0.0329553708,
0.018106807,
-0.0453791581,
0.0227749702,
-0.0346544906,
-0.0321693942,
0.0269464459,
0.0053960648,
0.0487054922,
0.0093701119,
0.0090942169,
-0.0502466299,
0.0016360531,
-0.028223535,
0.0527402945,
-0.0225012731,
0.0179612841,
0.0124459844,
-0.0449357517,
0.0169299152,
-0.0588722117,
0.0750092417,
-0.0608784035,
-0.0980636552,
-0.0242460333,
-0.0000636998,
0.004121019,
0.0263989661,
-0.0226446334,
-0.0205291621,
0.020575555,
-0.0111420611,
-0.0164354276,
-0.0414145142,
-0.0721191689,
-0.0159013662,
-0.0049000913,
-0.0400901288,
-0.0416659378,
-0.0131380875,
-0.001330074,
0.0386677496,
-0.0566262156,
0.0774451941,
2.194220688e-34,
0.0409026854,
0.0244237538,
-0.0013442733,
-0.0351494849,
0.0305999219,
0.0112989219,
-0.0301153306,
0.0001976747,
0.0248068925,
-0.0543703809,
0.0218325276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05950v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05950v5 | Language Models as Black-Box Optimizers for Vision-Language Models | 2023-09-12T04:03:41 | 2024-05-14T03:20:42 | Shihong Liu, Zhiqiu Lin, Samuel Yu, Ryan Lee, Tiffany Ling, Deepak Pathak, Deva Ramanan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.MM | Vision-language models (VLMs) pre-trained on web-scale datasets have
demonstrated remarkable capabilities on downstream tasks when fine-tuned with
minimal data. However, many VLMs rely on proprietary data and are not
open-source, which restricts the use of white-box approaches for fine-tuning.
As such, we aim to develop a black-box approach to optimize VLMs through
natural language prompts, thereby avoiding the need to access model parameters,
feature embeddings, or even output logits. We propose employing chat-based LLMs
to search for the best text prompt for VLMs. Specifically, we adopt an
automatic hill-climbing procedure that converges to an effective prompt by
evaluating the performance of current prompts and asking LLMs to refine them
based on textual feedback, all within a conversational process without
human-in-the-loop. In a challenging 1-shot image classification setup, our
simple approach surpasses the white-box continuous prompting method (CoOp) by
an average of 1.5% across 11 datasets including ImageNet. Our approach also
outperforms both human-engineered and LLM-generated prompts. We highlight the
advantage of conversational feedback that incorporates both positive and
negative prompts, suggesting that LLMs can utilize the implicit gradient
direction in textual feedback for a more efficient search. In addition, we find
that the text prompts generated through our strategy are not only more
interpretable but also transfer well across different VLM architectures in a
black-box manner. Lastly, we apply our framework to optimize the
state-of-the-art black-box VLM (DALL-E 3) for text-to-image generation, prompt
inversion, and personalization. | [
0.0576101355,
0.0457933098,
0.0072060861,
0.0555959381,
-0.0466769747,
0.0221182127,
0.0399756432,
0.002264014,
0.0524455495,
-0.0789694935,
-0.0512422994,
-0.0288955849,
0.0111574661,
0.0414951891,
0.0262434874,
-0.0565088503,
0.0003186527,
-0.0466693155,
-0.0007719854,
-0.0033738252,
0.0060346229,
0.0099062044,
0.0022311953,
0.0324651636,
0.0035139308,
-0.0048262696,
-0.0243184343,
0.0669186711,
0.0074923928,
0.0077335224,
-0.0080255903,
0.0621051602,
0.0390438326,
-0.0083585791,
0.0000022387,
-0.0385523774,
0.0202722494,
-0.016475901,
-0.0456159078,
-0.0296196938,
0.0501026288,
0.0037505135,
-0.0065108235,
0.0239845645,
-0.0283984188,
0.0027677536,
0.0657742769,
0.0196140446,
0.0657702386,
0.0720569044,
-0.0138321035,
0.0092672734,
0.002798378,
-0.0299133137,
0.0370798819,
-0.0313332602,
0.0093303444,
0.0002798133,
-0.0100848144,
0.0434854291,
-0.0363494828,
0.0548143648,
0.0225362331,
-0.0391414389,
0.0200156923,
0.0395150632,
-0.0226025395,
-0.0554177538,
-0.0263754502,
0.0938119665,
-0.0102128964,
-0.007219431,
-0.0026072811,
-0.0223210156,
0.0243008677,
-0.0363350064,
-0.027818501,
0.0467030704,
0.0049265833,
0.0119466176,
-0.0700422525,
0.0055220178,
0.0149599509,
0.018949572,
0.020708885,
-0.0124430414,
0.0015830364,
0.0158845037,
-0.0113127911,
0.0228678063,
-0.0125096049,
-0.0704584941,
-0.0049027554,
0.0172648337,
-0.0312717482,
0.0050708642,
-0.0528153256,
-0.0006955497,
-0.0024466077,
-0.0211734008,
0.0655511096,
0.0219978616,
-0.0566920973,
0.0651071668,
-0.0133554414,
0.048883725,
0.0298749693,
0.0273477901,
-0.0450282246,
-0.0070216316,
-0.0124060875,
-0.0127012534,
-0.0425654761,
-0.0052135186,
-0.034505561,
-0.0328122601,
-0.0415438302,
0.0217134748,
-0.0220177304,
0.0057563474,
0.000830211,
0.0276427958,
-0.0204683989,
-0.0196791496,
-0.0341312625,
-0.0106043089,
0.0188428648,
0.0035395273,
0.009922348,
-0.0917936787,
-0.0004432632,
0.0612157881,
0.0050836643,
-0.000219672,
-0.0003398912,
0.0951408744,
-0.0379890166,
-0.0533039458,
-0.0204921011,
-0.0048811198,
-0.0296400469,
-0.0281314105,
0.0104793999,
-0.0530539379,
0.0299286395,
-0.0120687047,
-0.0032551128,
-0.0213421211,
0.0163812004,
0.0118286517,
0.0010780961,
0.1053266898,
-0.0168690048,
-0.0176603924,
0.0415583625,
-0.0010113033,
-0.0123278378,
0.0799255446,
0.0089943502,
0.0691963062,
0.0369301252,
0.007143856,
0.0151476962,
0.0439637825,
0.0006428036,
0.0085776215,
-0.056618128,
0.0139189251,
-0.0128492396,
0.0351142213,
0.0116492817,
0.0436644368,
-0.0230176244,
-0.0333698355,
0.0857589617,
0.0588984601,
-0.0089058112,
-0.0100478744,
0.041467905,
0.0436517112,
-0.0136715537,
-0.019535372,
-0.0472209677,
0.0315517373,
-0.030027939,
-0.0232443903,
0.0127572175,
0.0144263841,
-0.0365390331,
-0.0709965304,
-0.0038873418,
-0.0265621543,
0.0304070376,
0.0623796992,
0.0354490876,
0.0129272379,
-0.0356103629,
-0.0018352917,
0.0111582503,
-0.0279743634,
-0.0164143946,
-0.0740466788,
0.0108468011,
0.1009923071,
0.0248296969,
0.0343248472,
-0.0174654536,
-0.012076335,
0.0493847057,
0.0694033355,
0.0303840898,
0.0163131449,
0.0240959898,
-0.0622589998,
-0.0634638444,
0.0234525241,
-0.0048090322,
0.0202730522,
0.00148889,
-0.0146583673,
0.0375423469,
0.0312942266,
-0.0551290549,
0.0315145962,
-0.0001743475,
-0.0293557812,
0.0225692317,
0.0141743552,
-0.0132301813,
-0.0073200641,
-0.01180634,
-0.0019129751,
0.0043979301,
-0.0317219384,
-0.0275572464,
0.0101222135,
-0.0256823972,
-0.0426635817,
0.0254912078,
-0.0246093217,
0.0061437325,
0.0204196889,
-0.0503097475,
-0.0181190576,
-0.0147549277,
-0.0514588766,
0.0036968882,
-0.0463955142,
0.0017232399,
0.0072246823,
0.0020115681,
-0.0610057488,
0.0263261851,
-0.0040533114,
-0.0297814962,
0.027819423,
0.0054009254,
-0.0024140289,
-0.0621818677,
-0.0102236131,
-0.018232977,
-0.0037777128,
0.0164302941,
0.0262601785,
0.0552202202,
-0.0346762761,
0.0034152824,
-0.1075102538,
-0.0311509836,
-0.0385187268,
-0.0253295414,
-0.0004423069,
0.0030808318,
-0.0156170167,
-0.054246854,
-0.0461699069,
0.0537484176,
0.0061100842,
0.0109686889,
0.0553239435,
0.0030594876,
0.008964844,
-0.0368537866,
-0.0079507101,
0.0335870348,
0.0457384586,
0.0362056382,
-0.0254254397,
-0.0419017673,
0.046077881,
-0.0372044556,
0.0380505286,
-0.0282856487,
-0.0252503995,
0.0017541996,
-0.0190729294,
0.0152767505,
0.0810015127,
0.0357125886,
0.0169294663,
0.0087172585,
0.0189713389,
-0.0774777681,
0.0069716959,
-0.0082344534,
-0.0597378202,
-0.0088151582,
-0.0384992957,
0.013197626,
0.0483197346,
0.0024766203,
0.0057538114,
-0.0802994594,
0.0483032875,
0.0300081801,
-0.0281999018,
-0.0882839411,
0.0085831061,
0.0030676597,
0.0507490151,
-0.0271598082,
-0.1037188768,
0.0664275289,
-0.0354796015,
-0.0231237561,
0.0175328963,
-0.0326354168,
-0.0251998845,
0.0483791195,
0.0172115434,
0.0196765438,
0.0357861705,
0.0153166968,
-0.0633021966,
-0.02522856,
0.0156795215,
-0.0229715221,
0.0433080569,
-0.0293468703,
0.0128987562,
-0.0299064275,
-0.0398278385,
-0.0534228943,
-0.0422457084,
-0.0263548903,
-0.0044761221,
-0.0270570777,
-0.0142818261,
-0.0116595123,
0.0075027258,
-0.0007440921,
0.0454619564,
-0.0179157183,
-0.0227158461,
-0.0150437988,
-0.0083356518,
0.0628430024,
0.0048314743,
-0.0104528777,
-0.0235630237,
0.0178603511,
0.0345715098,
0.0075394008,
0.0097732404,
-0.0295598228,
-0.0172672551,
0.0329328254,
0.0443486981,
0.0066266973,
0.0247694962,
0.0442591012,
-0.0434042178,
-0.0061334688,
0.1174050197,
0.0112148151,
-0.0509407073,
-0.037103679,
0.0026149536,
0.0422318056,
0.019710198,
0.0219430011,
-0.0760132074,
-0.0529854968,
-0.0140550723,
0.0343325697,
0.0035032751,
0.0068698949,
-0.0495592132,
-0.0973922685,
0.0451743491,
0.0057804342,
0.0171860289,
0.0027097431,
0.0188748538,
-0.0267387629,
-0.0225518253,
-0.0230968967,
-0.0067341179,
-0.0121894563,
-0.0036832441,
-0.0173427518,
-0.0024468263,
-0.0414181761,
0.0235330239,
-0.022824673,
0.0178810693,
0.0743068159,
-0.0131715126,
0.0172491521,
-0.0490266085,
0.0691185892,
0.0350829884,
0.024351038,
-0.0265978985,
0.0554651171,
-0.0350128524,
-0.0321248546,
-0.0012834499,
0.0221427158,
-0.0078555187,
0.0017589681,
-0.0090542939,
0.0067547192,
-0.0294207763,
-0.001434898,
-0.0409420915,
0.035439726,
0.0347330123,
0.0681719407,
0.0167121161,
-0.0766554698,
-0.0209713876,
-0.0370988734,
-0.0071360907,
-0.0288577415,
-0.0476709194,
-0.0118735824,
0.0129378969,
-0.0062926398,
-0.0596648268,
-0.0306426249,
0.0255464986,
0.021834312,
-0.0083081415,
-0.0239861682,
-0.0209298916,
0.0056787543,
-0.0407844745,
0.0667768866,
-0.0307962354,
0.0139490096,
-0.0610331446,
-0.0177022144,
0.0599594377,
-0.0710487217,
-0.0152626913,
0.0282036439,
-0.0903247297,
-0.0496945269,
-0.0489414334,
0.0778486952,
0.0119332289,
0.0482247025,
-0.0006381355,
-0.0833683386,
0.0336450785,
0.0700608641,
0.0227423571,
0.0079284152,
0.0113986973,
0.0416282192,
-0.0159735382,
0.0417913347,
-0.0385556519,
0.0206690542,
0.0351947807,
-0.0061390991,
-0.0190986563,
-0.0649069995,
0.0002688511,
-0.0068982258,
0.0531080477,
-0.0437158607,
-0.0296500865,
-0.0041784411,
0.0339871421,
0.0096379025,
-0.0278083403,
-0.1013263613,
0.0006086862,
0.0036136003,
-0.0113314111,
0.0138538387,
-0.0095055932,
-0.0450023673,
0.0433337726,
-0.043580953,
-0.0023166181,
0.0123040415,
-0.0245477948,
0.0257129651,
0.0122668818,
0.0031543809,
0.0686446205,
-0.0075053549,
0.0202039815,
0.0028916674,
0.0680647343,
0.0206505116,
-0.0067422758,
-0.0093913013,
0.0554998629,
-0.0248197448,
-0.0843413994,
-0.0394595824,
0.0615993328,
0.0373100452,
0.0314125046,
-0.0030629581,
-0.0282067508,
-0.0066710347,
-0.0419203043,
0.0310919788,
0.016334217,
-0.0537011959,
0.0808863938,
0.0172989424,
-0.0233523026,
-0.0027010285,
0.0502324253,
0.0147454971,
0.0053942604,
-0.0081940573,
0.0042840457,
-0.0482347719,
-0.0275918487,
0.0558949932,
-0.0063185813,
0.0006105326,
0.0443276763,
-0.0124547277,
-0.0647664815,
-0.0160679705,
0.0136971651,
-0.0197191536,
0.0053177541,
0.0713338926,
0.0607013367,
0.0087457951,
0.0006100287,
-0.0169589669,
0.0074237976,
-0.0176433343,
-0.02408804,
-0.0326874666,
-6.396698629e-33,
-0.0338213295,
-0.056545835,
0.0337725319,
0.0207842495,
-0.0003723524,
0.0024230685,
-0.0132971015,
0.0257480945,
-0.0065399925,
0.0162025988,
0.0107178045,
-0.0073118559,
0.0173365735,
0.065070346,
-0.012430938,
-0.0151474038,
0.04129209,
-0.0186910387,
-0.0241295453,
-0.0011646879,
0.0063312785,
0.0290923994,
0.0213142969,
-0.0501121059,
0.0279063284,
-0.0037363849,
-0.0239656977,
0.0447159857,
0.027076276,
0.0553064458,
-0.0120766945,
0.0311707146,
0.0106669459,
-0.0055641858,
-0.0254678503,
0.0337755382,
-0.0377918258,
-0.0127249025,
0.0257818215,
0.0278549306,
-0.0643728673,
-0.0034831115,
0.0345864706,
-0.0465790145,
-0.0060949507,
-0.0163011588,
0.0369525142,
-0.0334787965,
-0.0213372856,
-0.0025846255,
-0.0160398521,
0.0177858248,
-0.0034381722,
-0.0673850328,
0.0361182317,
0.0566192344,
-0.0071614855,
0.0291821789,
-0.020216234,
0.0347699672,
0.0327943005,
0.0022830621,
0.0900791213,
0.0552233644,
0.0132828737,
0.0539934039,
0.0374511518,
-0.0024548876,
-0.0300563704,
-0.041827932,
0.0270057786,
0.0468451679,
0.0539880395,
0.0631466582,
-0.0112111326,
0.0209403858,
-0.0422503091,
0.0203497503,
-0.0236996841,
0.0026643388,
0.0271414947,
0.0049691121,
-0.019950863,
-0.0175148137,
-0.0610007308,
-0.0272087231,
-0.0478399843,
-0.016448034,
0.0373759679,
0.0485685281,
-0.0177860409,
-0.0431716703,
0.0488831364,
-0.0283447634,
0.0045421952,
0.0048302175,
-0.0047370428,
0.0298244078,
0.0222168397,
-0.0061733369,
-0.049441684,
-0.0057362737,
0.0573085658,
0.0268297121,
-0.007724463,
0.015587762,
0.0162680689,
0.0239493698,
-0.0540730171,
0.008423917,
-0.0393470265,
0.0225467011,
-0.031332057,
0.0592377968,
0.0144954156,
0.0018973687,
-0.0661585629,
0.079813309,
-0.0119291544,
-0.0323289335,
-0.0133729102,
-0.0174119286,
-0.0071305791,
0.0164780319,
-0.0353706256,
0.0169050787,
0.0092658512,
0.0022373821,
0.0441445857,
-0.0312871933,
0.0043220315,
0.0086916815,
2.787e-7,
0.0135653531,
0.0274822675,
-0.0025463172,
0.0499938279,
0.0093345111,
0.0772875324,
-0.0092886379,
0.0179938376,
0.0150972959,
-0.0220878236,
0.0018778053,
0.0453457236,
0.0662798882,
-0.0299763232,
-0.0503080636,
0.015770765,
-0.0564650297,
-0.0066036996,
-0.0389681235,
-0.0235467684,
0.0608162843,
0.0928918868,
-0.0219333041,
-0.0282287989,
0.0347634703,
-0.03617239,
0.0876597986,
-0.0904746354,
-0.0153731583,
-0.0073119565,
0.0290666018,
0.0166589376,
-0.0231002718,
0.0121954661,
-0.0097983917,
-0.0265218262,
0.0031103999,
0.0755088106,
-0.0148722166,
-0.0459156558,
-0.01656368,
0.0232814439,
-0.0209026244,
-0.058476489,
0.0734270141,
-0.054376781,
-0.0028988866,
-0.0693666711,
0.0375485308,
-0.0172155555,
0.0505235046,
-0.0580156483,
-0.0428759493,
0.0074074049,
0.0340696797,
-0.0055143475,
-0.024045093,
-0.0846041366,
-0.0295116734,
-0.0414315946,
-0.0397542641,
-0.0195753649,
-0.0732096881,
0.0197302159,
0.0091206366,
-0.0099821901,
-0.0042464309,
2.3671793e-34,
0.0374793634,
-0.0009063725,
0.0069857216,
0.0171298105,
0.00661017,
0.0339974351,
-0.0007961607,
0.0101075526,
0.0168226101,
-0.0635263398,
-0.0166945737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05938v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05938v2 | Answering Subjective Induction Questions on Products by Summarizing Multi-sources Multi-viewpoints Knowledge | 2023-09-12T03:27:08 | 2023-10-06T12:35:20 | Yufeng Zhang, Meng-xiang Wang, Jianxing Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper proposes a new task in the field of Answering Subjective Induction
Question on Products (SUBJPQA). The answer to this kind of question is
non-unique, but can be interpreted from many perspectives. For example, the
answer to 'whether the phone is heavy' has a variety of different viewpoints. A
satisfied answer should be able to summarize these subjective opinions from
multiple sources and provide objective knowledge, such as the weight of a
phone. That is quite different from the traditional QA task, in which the
answer to a factoid question is unique and can be found from a single data
source. To address this new task, we propose a three-steps method. We first
retrieve all answer-related clues from multiple knowledge sources on facts and
opinions. The implicit commonsense facts are also collected to supplement the
necessary but missing contexts. We then capture their relevance with the
questions by interactive attention. Next, we design a reinforcement-based
summarizer to aggregate all these knowledgeable clues. Based on a
template-controlled decoder, we can output a comprehensive and
multi-perspective answer. Due to the lack of a relevant evaluated benchmark set
for the new task, we construct a large-scale dataset, named SupQA, consisting
of 48,352 samples across 15 product domains. Evaluation results show the
effectiveness of our approach. | [
0.0278174486,
0.0299463253,
0.0202184878,
0.0081413146,
0.0125294244,
0.0056400332,
-0.0022695693,
-0.036126703,
-0.0078391023,
-0.0449460484,
-0.0161114708,
0.0165497568,
0.0010049753,
0.0153614469,
0.0230951775,
-0.0332697034,
0.0229901895,
0.0245849639,
-0.0001770959,
-0.0103560518,
0.0044149859,
0.0305205584,
-0.0190407783,
0.0328892507,
-0.0220235549,
-0.0318890288,
-0.0028368202,
-0.0270231981,
0.0300629996,
-0.0212403573,
0.0358216688,
0.0267600976,
0.0109398132,
-0.0076440875,
0.0000018841,
-0.0619235151,
-0.0208648127,
-0.0117148114,
-0.0032970852,
-0.0149303274,
0.0259854067,
0.0167217664,
0.0417809486,
0.0266983621,
-0.0419409312,
-0.0312763005,
0.0305451266,
0.0978532061,
0.0875338465,
0.0398989245,
-0.0096588572,
-0.0422789752,
-0.0210951958,
-0.0071707894,
0.0333919264,
-0.0341430306,
0.0045379028,
0.0278824661,
-0.012263367,
-0.028823847,
-0.0181268863,
0.0230422392,
0.023598494,
-0.0085422825,
0.001603936,
0.0164873507,
-0.007766997,
0.0202393681,
-0.0177106392,
0.1116873622,
-0.0044803168,
-0.0063949763,
-0.0185142048,
0.0079499269,
0.0491542704,
-0.0052208533,
-0.0346115455,
0.0044312426,
-0.0453092568,
0.000795776,
-0.0291031934,
0.0634387434,
-0.0204813257,
-0.0429331474,
-0.0086304061,
0.0431083217,
0.0000193798,
-0.0535692349,
0.0151203051,
0.0397238284,
-0.0196653828,
-0.0509689786,
0.0138776498,
0.0299217068,
-0.017326327,
0.0046797423,
0.0253600292,
0.0056908252,
0.016980039,
-0.0997949168,
-0.0257582571,
0.0078980606,
-0.0148556363,
0.0625243783,
-0.0137213469,
-0.0175166931,
-0.019570034,
-0.0354904719,
-0.0791688636,
-0.0081657022,
-0.0709384456,
-0.0082628382,
-0.0072124531,
0.0660041422,
-0.003400333,
-0.0083480002,
-0.0044674086,
-0.0047659916,
-0.0395343974,
-0.0117135728,
0.0069959569,
0.0580237433,
-0.0118525745,
-0.0016126678,
-0.0464382283,
0.0778841525,
-0.0732016191,
0.0417519324,
-0.024553176,
-0.0281296447,
-0.0037097023,
0.0001476332,
0.0371139571,
0.008012603,
-0.0141715752,
0.042993024,
-0.0448484495,
-0.0273455344,
-0.0669053495,
-0.0441237912,
-0.0145590566,
-0.0316922031,
-0.0389527716,
-0.0535689816,
0.0326983444,
-0.0124935815,
-0.0152414003,
-0.0103349071,
-0.00066231,
0.0224354304,
0.0049942955,
0.0427395925,
0.0152104851,
-0.023312686,
0.0557605512,
0.0014841653,
0.0171101224,
0.0880403519,
-0.0232242551,
0.0337800868,
0.0083879326,
0.0287461765,
0.0006462824,
-0.0119854398,
0.0103921127,
-0.0094933668,
0.0377025977,
0.0383037105,
-0.0516353957,
-0.0000552913,
0.0372930877,
0.0230603684,
-0.0241897311,
0.011667056,
0.047644984,
0.0004961734,
-0.0196052771,
0.0239875037,
-0.0163692627,
0.0273137912,
0.0280917287,
0.0316769145,
0.0167088863,
0.0394708365,
-0.0363153294,
0.0032466541,
0.0577267818,
0.0159355719,
-0.0349985994,
-0.0694587603,
0.0218929816,
-0.0163378902,
0.0109175192,
0.0489514545,
0.0390759595,
0.0304255765,
-0.0227158666,
0.0438707322,
0.007263504,
-0.0444592722,
-0.0312031116,
0.0194996949,
0.1083910316,
0.0182787366,
0.0111450898,
-0.0323170088,
-0.0421689674,
-0.0201067589,
-0.0282714386,
0.0429479145,
0.0692787319,
-0.0459383875,
-0.0165088419,
-0.0313069485,
-0.037674021,
-0.0213002935,
0.0070825974,
0.0406470522,
-0.0147229759,
-0.0012327557,
0.0065071308,
0.0051618703,
0.0201627407,
-0.0073318244,
0.05139523,
-0.0380516611,
0.0271105599,
0.0078818053,
0.0077455104,
0.0501009971,
0.0265457928,
0.0141026052,
0.0171788912,
-0.0552990735,
-0.0483999141,
0.0352003835,
0.0035444188,
-0.060904406,
0.0279661994,
-0.0791078955,
-0.0513858311,
-0.019743368,
-0.0323474593,
-0.0678950176,
0.0048910463,
-0.0332479104,
0.0589739606,
-0.0162037648,
-0.0688845217,
0.0124278488,
0.004560472,
-0.0158437099,
0.0883621946,
0.0056474279,
-0.0072698467,
0.0159901157,
-0.0732965171,
0.0238501895,
-0.044352062,
0.0105649708,
-0.0363805518,
-0.0121252229,
0.0164119024,
0.0428899266,
-0.0123278499,
-0.0452590026,
0.0183030348,
-0.0940957516,
-0.0044663674,
0.0008415988,
0.0029703099,
-0.00031036,
0.021034373,
0.0240283348,
-0.0388640352,
-0.0821736455,
-0.0106219035,
-0.0223240796,
0.0273586679,
0.0289556738,
0.0082991282,
0.0646750629,
-0.0211315863,
-0.0085166004,
-0.0062236874,
0.0595410243,
0.0373584703,
0.0441146605,
-0.0743191317,
-0.0321629196,
-0.049823951,
0.0059868172,
0.0208137464,
0.0100484015,
-0.0061794179,
0.0044309874,
0.0672600269,
0.07742621,
-0.0025429211,
-0.0187602099,
0.0611306727,
0.0175306909,
-0.0688859969,
0.0198505744,
-0.017200293,
0.0020400367,
0.0230802931,
-0.0148332864,
0.0191336293,
0.0390711166,
0.0025704326,
-0.0113280322,
-0.0630854294,
0.0441288613,
0.0041964836,
-0.0324978866,
-0.0762521923,
0.0143880807,
0.0079903873,
0.0632327497,
-0.0118157705,
0.003830923,
0.1078243926,
0.0205905922,
0.0216411483,
-0.0333539471,
0.0247142632,
-0.0750722215,
0.0001650386,
-0.0243407395,
0.0150572406,
-0.0024275924,
-0.0119916108,
-0.0164381284,
0.0208215304,
0.0271411762,
-0.0326305777,
0.0695906952,
-0.0090249302,
0.0097427862,
-0.0057262294,
-0.0472289622,
-0.0294387769,
-0.04039656,
-0.0147465291,
-0.0241113491,
0.0038820051,
-0.0063828975,
-0.0175657608,
-0.0022824982,
0.0152802905,
-0.013854159,
0.0238092635,
-0.0244239867,
0.0161521193,
0.0307646506,
0.0757814571,
0.0718269125,
0.0542952269,
0.0102523211,
-0.0075721014,
0.0561863482,
0.0082537355,
0.0068163499,
-0.0050948565,
-0.000044885,
-0.0099267615,
-0.0315708145,
0.0329805836,
-0.0296824332,
0.0201490037,
-0.0252411608,
0.0121586947,
0.0814645514,
0.0239964724,
-0.0623613372,
0.0096791172,
0.015723614,
-0.0137060937,
0.0277636368,
0.0645002723,
-0.1093790159,
-0.0182778798,
-0.0452455804,
0.0459387228,
0.0083657075,
-0.0079712458,
-0.019484194,
-0.1566468775,
-0.0120250499,
-0.0183364153,
0.0063360063,
-0.0484761968,
-0.0347829647,
0.0069393548,
-0.0341618694,
0.0063765752,
-0.003401048,
0.0026788386,
0.0155194001,
0.029326763,
-0.0066836546,
-0.0120499637,
0.0276876744,
-0.0064523779,
-0.0095708761,
0.0451902226,
-0.005262183,
-0.015086771,
-0.0272321329,
-0.0065640076,
-0.0493696593,
-0.0416902415,
0.0229985919,
0.0338087492,
-0.015292096,
-0.0073485882,
-0.0020205402,
0.0415659919,
-0.0409002975,
0.0119980164,
0.0274149273,
0.0586963408,
0.0465541668,
-0.0122287236,
-0.0178375542,
-0.015484144,
-0.0022673481,
0.0898207054,
0.0220930334,
-0.0383786298,
0.0121919019,
-0.0555761121,
-0.0290435702,
-0.0301430225,
-0.0458203368,
0.0061258413,
0.0031101769,
-0.0533207953,
-0.1182565317,
-0.020706255,
0.02875272,
0.0126027027,
-0.0071886517,
-0.0702764168,
0.05169468,
0.0369730443,
-0.0492009558,
0.0076906164,
0.0303136166,
-0.0086239194,
-0.0117452117,
0.0274009351,
0.042716749,
-0.0595814101,
-0.0252334811,
-0.0017166791,
-0.0105362041,
-0.0458132513,
-0.0275054574,
0.0627260655,
0.0142414644,
0.0371722728,
-0.0401447788,
-0.0176785663,
0.042297639,
0.0539245047,
-0.0413407013,
-0.0022214912,
0.0337716676,
0.0546874553,
0.0006089106,
0.0323447734,
-0.0855108723,
-0.0044330279,
-0.0310993865,
0.0243970267,
-0.014099461,
-0.0283318348,
0.058890406,
-0.0376137756,
0.0119213443,
0.0210796706,
0.0641866922,
-0.0225164164,
0.0047719916,
0.0307918489,
-0.043686755,
-0.040169321,
0.0154943094,
-0.0337240882,
-0.0455351733,
-0.0195412915,
0.0261821114,
0.0078271367,
0.040879488,
-0.0445074812,
0.0025851689,
0.0029301634,
-0.0055950843,
-0.0554696769,
-0.0183203444,
-0.0431886576,
0.0003880284,
-0.0190626644,
0.0177621357,
0.0118693933,
0.0444170274,
0.0424255654,
0.0115589183,
-0.0134439887,
0.0153628057,
-0.0418619253,
-0.0036082801,
-0.0214052014,
0.0396622047,
-0.0078633921,
-0.032967709,
0.0397233106,
0.0109199556,
-0.0211171545,
0.0032280076,
0.0058142268,
-0.0256466456,
-0.0073028202,
0.0314473137,
0.0246625151,
-0.0132291634,
-0.026380118,
0.0869922265,
-0.0571107641,
0.0215504356,
-0.013015274,
-0.0094258757,
-0.0544525944,
-0.0256787539,
0.0005404217,
0.0360537805,
-0.0018483014,
0.0201295819,
-0.084784098,
-0.0375529416,
-0.0068625542,
0.0428468883,
0.0205228683,
0.0299221799,
0.0546067134,
0.0343759842,
0.0277328379,
-0.0470791087,
-0.009106664,
0.0171140935,
-0.0803199038,
0.0153166,
-0.0079631321,
-6.256920596e-33,
-0.0035424221,
-0.010061116,
-0.0217731725,
0.0416562743,
0.0024566546,
0.0056600044,
-0.0123577761,
0.0025652403,
-0.003830476,
0.0239948276,
0.0053638127,
0.0219676457,
-0.0081416527,
0.0405397117,
0.0322460607,
-0.0333541706,
0.0562733747,
0.0295912419,
-0.0339040868,
0.0344082117,
0.0432015024,
-0.010469066,
0.0740626976,
-0.0440397784,
0.0415202603,
-0.0094674854,
-0.007133197,
0.0587285794,
-0.0308037288,
0.0707724169,
-0.019115679,
0.0631909594,
0.0212884732,
-0.0658210441,
0.0012840035,
0.0471461751,
-0.0755550563,
-0.0415244363,
0.0199670363,
-0.0014963516,
-0.058289282,
-0.0293723177,
0.0276599675,
0.0203018598,
0.0478486121,
-0.0027237537,
0.0435132533,
-0.0600617304,
-0.006603736,
-0.0948065445,
0.0183657818,
-0.0061978158,
-0.0384542756,
-0.0099878265,
0.0028974151,
0.0423522554,
0.0037229287,
-0.0084108636,
-0.0256392621,
0.0447566658,
0.0253421478,
0.0142858084,
0.0326807126,
-0.023719402,
0.0012866037,
0.0214684512,
-0.0253840499,
-0.0322629884,
-0.0589891486,
-0.0325103179,
-0.0797058716,
0.0346333869,
0.0306135882,
0.0487529039,
0.057933569,
0.0492937602,
-0.0298045017,
0.058241576,
0.064967081,
0.0250482224,
-0.004415194,
0.0067780348,
-0.0237334166,
-0.0019081619,
-0.0332014635,
0.0302839782,
-0.0465310439,
-0.0238385033,
0.0046995119,
0.0233916137,
-0.0467488281,
0.0113154752,
0.0027786067,
-0.0348060392,
0.0034847613,
0.0124239232,
0.0191947166,
0.0128297033,
0.0207410324,
-0.0122936089,
-0.0301953293,
0.0631449744,
0.0051652859,
0.0159632042,
-0.0160555243,
0.005407725,
0.0216875114,
-0.0017430597,
-0.0491778441,
-0.0023239413,
0.0017914192,
-0.0198340677,
-0.0523641035,
-0.0009058647,
0.0235579275,
0.0392933376,
-0.0171185471,
0.0473350212,
-0.0167243127,
0.0301721971,
-0.0504398793,
0.002920558,
0.013318087,
0.022065213,
-0.0166458469,
-0.003228239,
-0.0125737404,
0.0002412335,
-0.0123721324,
-0.0439427309,
-0.0259813592,
0.0501788631,
2.593e-7,
0.0246331189,
0.0062074824,
0.0291618686,
0.0340734832,
0.007945409,
0.0363937654,
0.0253967065,
0.0653206259,
-0.0025883722,
-0.0615156144,
0.0027626539,
0.0379523225,
0.011610915,
0.0225323029,
-0.1115309969,
-0.0447608642,
-0.0373327248,
0.0186921544,
-0.0395203829,
-0.0313195847,
0.0966066942,
0.0889986381,
-0.0036527119,
0.0136400117,
0.0253800657,
0.0355009958,
0.0727265328,
0.0145670632,
-0.0007744153,
-0.0129779968,
0.0702978522,
-0.0235711336,
0.0043632551,
-0.0080311438,
0.0119160209,
-0.0098850569,
0.0373297818,
0.014687256,
0.0465003885,
-0.0943516493,
-0.0178678054,
0.0116395839,
0.0200060625,
0.0018707139,
0.0658447891,
-0.0739359707,
-0.0147094904,
-0.0349527374,
-0.050921876,
0.0106193013,
0.003518034,
0.0030904247,
-0.0048264456,
0.0055864966,
0.0026626219,
-0.0290447418,
-0.0109230895,
-0.0497132838,
-0.032868173,
0.0157032013,
-0.008583447,
-0.0283945985,
-0.0011404936,
-0.0094611496,
-0.0064535742,
-0.08363197,
0.0250761155,
1.837477209e-34,
0.0562304147,
0.0108246105,
-0.0047522937,
0.0049505387,
0.0238412097,
-0.0491705686,
-0.0535542332,
-0.0312474929,
0.0517611802,
-0.0693169236,
-0.0030907928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05936v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05936v1 | Do PLMs Know and Understand Ontological Knowledge? | 2023-09-12T03:20:50 | 2023-09-12T03:20:50 | Weiqi Wu, Chengyue Jiang, Yong Jiang, Pengjun Xie, Kewei Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Ontological knowledge, which comprises classes and properties and their
relationships, is integral to world knowledge. It is significant to explore
whether Pretrained Language Models (PLMs) know and understand such knowledge.
However, existing PLM-probing studies focus mainly on factual knowledge,
lacking a systematic probing of ontological knowledge. In this paper, we focus
on probing whether PLMs store ontological knowledge and have a semantic
understanding of the knowledge rather than rote memorization of the surface
form. To probe whether PLMs know ontological knowledge, we investigate how well
PLMs memorize: (1) types of entities; (2) hierarchical relationships among
classes and properties, e.g., Person is a subclass of Animal and Member of
Sports Team is a subproperty of Member of ; (3) domain and range constraints of
properties, e.g., the subject of Member of Sports Team should be a Person and
the object should be a Sports Team. To further probe whether PLMs truly
understand ontological knowledge beyond memorization, we comprehensively study
whether they can reliably perform logical reasoning with given knowledge
according to ontological entailment rules. Our probing results show that PLMs
can memorize certain ontological knowledge and utilize implicit knowledge in
reasoning. However, both the memorizing and reasoning performances are less
than perfect, indicating incomplete knowledge and understanding. | [
0.0215759818,
0.0017537046,
-0.0362728313,
0.0753578916,
-0.0016674022,
0.0019514136,
-0.0275043882,
0.0031016066,
-0.0354340635,
-0.0701007172,
-0.0392914489,
0.0067884289,
0.0014873922,
0.011507866,
0.0095959622,
-0.0548198484,
0.0671970993,
-0.0263089854,
-0.0166055001,
-0.0034528286,
-0.0333097503,
-0.0006316017,
-0.0287037641,
-0.0340725742,
-0.0146776307,
-0.0142719904,
-0.044332318,
-0.0675750524,
-0.0120329009,
-0.0260037724,
-0.0151180541,
0.0229471307,
0.0476800837,
-0.02577205,
0.0000018471,
-0.0593225248,
-0.0002200636,
-0.0406899787,
-0.0327090248,
-0.0036168583,
-0.0114256768,
-0.007615495,
0.0251274928,
-0.0435114019,
-0.0440250859,
-0.0292423312,
0.0199783314,
0.0385114737,
0.0091499342,
0.0179280024,
0.0011027575,
0.0011485816,
0.0193099342,
0.0262968373,
0.0506954156,
-0.039750699,
0.0203165337,
0.0194658972,
-0.0382683203,
0.006487153,
-0.0052768909,
0.0088309171,
0.0239946377,
0.0452366285,
-0.0184153337,
0.042698577,
0.0121957231,
-0.0313442014,
0.0253040511,
0.021959804,
0.0250673424,
-0.041297745,
-0.0244387574,
-0.0015701667,
-0.0035864157,
0.0034150623,
-0.008908879,
0.063029483,
-0.0284548607,
0.0148570184,
0.0048671602,
0.0485452861,
0.014402518,
0.0307803787,
-0.0418250374,
0.1004340127,
-0.0331465267,
-0.0388445854,
0.0110385204,
0.0097056376,
0.0252442751,
-0.0382232666,
-0.003117875,
0.0605800338,
-0.0013509298,
0.0740975216,
-0.0230160877,
0.0211852062,
0.0097546205,
-0.046499718,
0.0324041285,
0.042565152,
-0.0140425554,
0.0216514412,
-0.0415864512,
0.0290713925,
0.0103062429,
0.0369578488,
-0.0067612752,
-0.021417411,
-0.0842266306,
-0.047970295,
-0.0478643887,
0.0843559876,
0.0664603263,
0.028915504,
-0.0100242877,
0.0310485065,
0.0229874235,
0.036057651,
-0.0335909836,
-0.0105045438,
-0.0072641186,
-0.00640473,
-0.110889852,
0.0053947992,
-0.0303991791,
0.0220490657,
-0.030258473,
-0.0421774201,
0.0390428193,
-0.0412556082,
-0.0111413859,
-0.0061828434,
0.0069489563,
0.0634586886,
0.0055244286,
-0.0379917584,
-0.076326184,
-0.0590009019,
0.0373059548,
-0.082271643,
0.0158960409,
-0.0295399334,
-0.0037433505,
0.0199122708,
0.0139770284,
-0.0381570049,
0.0197981466,
0.0233842079,
-0.0195507407,
0.0934592038,
0.0119389892,
0.0439854637,
-0.0200595986,
0.0265563373,
-0.0272129774,
0.0423519686,
0.0183793008,
-0.0047085653,
0.0214394219,
-0.0313466676,
-0.0291336495,
-0.0244012196,
0.0467272922,
-0.066689454,
-0.0214885268,
0.0193377957,
-0.0094384784,
0.0151480976,
0.0220452715,
0.0202322826,
0.0080550453,
0.0024908469,
0.0787629485,
0.0204303395,
-0.0069674072,
0.0192145854,
0.0744498,
-0.0561257862,
0.0607316531,
0.0550402068,
-0.0702886209,
0.0235201325,
-0.0265618153,
0.0245298501,
-0.031709075,
-0.0119877504,
-0.0391105302,
-0.0666996613,
-0.0278355051,
0.006296997,
-0.0313103124,
0.0251306016,
0.0786684006,
0.0305122398,
-0.0195827167,
0.0844885111,
0.0168278255,
-0.0509175062,
0.0220817141,
-0.0205614865,
0.0599336475,
0.0300201345,
-0.0177905336,
-0.0593682155,
-0.0514003597,
0.0419189855,
-0.0113069927,
0.0142192226,
0.0719580874,
-0.0119626289,
0.0066322773,
-0.0093202991,
0.0184999257,
-0.0029226006,
0.0045395256,
0.0229843594,
0.0307893865,
-0.0044034505,
-0.0018496665,
-0.0590593182,
0.0211936161,
0.0540439337,
-0.012073583,
0.0078815008,
-0.062619485,
0.0265232865,
0.0019713957,
-0.0139534706,
0.0274035633,
0.009061899,
0.0463107601,
-0.0283543263,
-0.01481394,
0.0219988804,
-0.0526905246,
-0.0069927997,
0.0171130076,
-0.0114131933,
-0.0383942463,
0.0059672184,
-0.0109958258,
-0.0187700633,
0.0127428742,
0.0430363119,
0.0789249316,
-0.0500392169,
0.0053568543,
0.0063542817,
-0.0466541462,
0.0152079435,
0.0961606726,
0.0127711156,
0.0361968465,
-0.0125093972,
0.0101608429,
0.0207274538,
-0.0609992817,
0.0028108028,
0.0173136108,
-0.0206021182,
-0.0040880996,
-0.0279742684,
-0.0238074213,
-0.0624172837,
0.0288360845,
-0.0574650206,
0.0154248169,
0.0252702124,
0.0267251786,
0.003492669,
-0.0265157782,
-0.0028457134,
-0.0234308448,
-0.0240352396,
0.0334804468,
-0.0285139512,
0.0397852622,
0.0530305691,
-0.0188860763,
0.0137498677,
-0.0078007248,
0.02988174,
-0.0327568576,
0.0119374245,
-0.0044214912,
0.0153703261,
-0.0041949088,
0.0742435902,
-0.0725795031,
0.018891206,
0.0049862633,
-0.0181757081,
0.0235310625,
0.0091861105,
0.0072466074,
0.072715424,
0.0149134044,
0.0312383045,
0.0625960678,
-0.026103165,
-0.0047786133,
0.0139424726,
-0.0331850424,
-0.0458198264,
-0.0336954445,
0.0266746078,
-0.0120661771,
0.0910522118,
-0.001511137,
-0.0180440638,
-0.0317832492,
0.0206834767,
-0.053574428,
0.0085792793,
-0.0401140563,
0.0062125423,
-0.0113832653,
0.0613916367,
0.0002164299,
-0.0215897392,
0.050397791,
-0.0064298525,
-0.0116632218,
0.0171621237,
0.0093380511,
0.006700709,
0.1083648354,
0.0196505412,
0.0278191548,
0.0244626962,
-0.0227021705,
-0.060455732,
-0.0264464635,
0.0357751511,
-0.0227823686,
-0.0003844599,
-0.053489957,
0.0246407352,
-0.0061290325,
-0.0007829052,
-0.0863817036,
0.0255380608,
-0.0518654101,
0.0432676896,
-0.1028623059,
0.015870925,
-0.000739761,
0.0115481876,
0.007381151,
-0.0259756707,
0.0170506239,
-0.0273027774,
-0.034611918,
-0.0061381194,
0.0014020251,
0.0243964195,
-0.017805418,
-0.0252386183,
0.0007088777,
0.0227018259,
-0.0126029374,
-0.0347245559,
-0.0086286049,
0.0269210916,
0.0039506224,
-0.0543078035,
-0.0432929955,
0.0212307908,
-0.0146271354,
-0.0667407215,
0.0018376427,
0.1018230394,
0.0556829497,
0.0304012168,
0.0325503387,
0.0190237667,
-0.0147088952,
0.0249543674,
0.0107992953,
-0.0495034307,
-0.0049896394,
-0.0000470692,
-0.0330519751,
-0.031264443,
-0.0358267985,
-0.034667097,
-0.0996720493,
-0.029035002,
-0.0191731881,
-0.0913127363,
-0.0159261208,
0.009741948,
-0.0081180083,
0.0059480448,
0.0426000729,
0.0196775608,
-0.0224208813,
0.0081938524,
0.0257650837,
-0.0194007847,
-0.0396500751,
0.0417818464,
-0.0337619446,
0.0176327396,
0.0145391133,
0.0193702821,
0.0011644582,
-0.0796243772,
0.0118056834,
-0.0146300448,
0.0225547664,
-0.0097403731,
0.0073011531,
-0.0527840294,
0.0105241053,
-0.0019811084,
-0.00593541,
-0.0417367928,
-0.0360507928,
0.013355297,
0.052841939,
-0.0304283053,
-0.0511521697,
0.0213962961,
0.0054069883,
-0.0422408283,
0.0990304723,
0.0260494631,
0.0232430249,
0.0052940268,
-0.02970789,
-0.0064073177,
-0.006172881,
-0.0223955922,
0.0450070724,
-0.0323071927,
-0.005482608,
-0.0571348257,
-0.0398810506,
0.0465574004,
0.0214960575,
-0.007575484,
-0.0034368453,
0.0486292429,
0.00094197,
-0.0690631792,
-0.0017305075,
-0.0317019597,
-0.0224412866,
-0.0033964156,
-0.0630757585,
0.0731637254,
-0.0169339105,
-0.01002937,
-0.0482442528,
-0.0026233823,
-0.0273904093,
0.0011570412,
0.046418529,
0.0317640677,
0.0058188988,
0.0269497745,
-0.0085540321,
0.034549851,
-0.0012304642,
-0.0634259358,
0.0170574598,
0.0172182247,
0.0072216801,
0.009650589,
0.0433512516,
0.0037649316,
0.0097660339,
0.0149338543,
0.0014147799,
-0.0055752108,
-0.0176622532,
0.0477074087,
-0.0056430111,
0.0302886479,
0.0320038423,
-0.0282272846,
-0.0278818291,
0.0136828702,
-0.0189429913,
-0.0329876579,
-0.0073079327,
0.003279252,
-0.0120214755,
0.0523326881,
-0.0020475322,
-0.0515286215,
-0.0522652492,
0.0340952501,
0.0517282076,
-0.0308547057,
0.0316053517,
0.0132226665,
0.008834864,
0.0130648557,
-0.0171749424,
0.0162576344,
-0.033882305,
0.0231985599,
0.0025338179,
0.038562309,
0.0331916474,
0.0315042324,
-0.0423873961,
-0.0253694877,
-0.0393231064,
-0.0140878297,
0.0420952663,
0.026058251,
0.051170893,
-0.0515004322,
-0.0221158154,
-0.0834859163,
0.0226397831,
0.0297564492,
0.0382257663,
0.024197869,
-0.0443021618,
0.0538231209,
0.0143087711,
-0.0166249517,
-0.0067157564,
0.0895959735,
0.027836984,
0.0558380075,
-0.0057275984,
-0.0184165109,
-0.0247691646,
0.01092612,
0.0571186133,
0.0222143568,
-0.0476138778,
0.0392943062,
-0.0589233376,
-0.0836899951,
0.0113772294,
0.0333724506,
-0.0022395893,
-0.0105982451,
0.0213439241,
0.0568409562,
0.0159321837,
-0.0372092538,
-0.0034864724,
0.0309662074,
-0.0279573388,
0.0447915345,
-0.0198359154,
-5.71054825e-33,
-0.089945063,
-0.0394792855,
0.0460036471,
0.0191444829,
-0.0077603837,
0.0306279026,
-0.0301623102,
0.0036186907,
-0.0225620344,
-0.0040163058,
-0.0039396784,
-0.0121990573,
-0.0004248948,
-0.0189090427,
0.0322391801,
-0.0558103845,
0.0132035753,
-0.0282820724,
-0.0204864014,
-0.0298075452,
0.050535854,
0.0188549273,
0.0654304251,
0.0041043707,
0.0365169011,
-0.0144505063,
0.0121934274,
0.0466123931,
-0.0560220517,
0.0557201803,
-0.0265435725,
-0.0088865366,
0.0282353461,
0.0153547609,
-0.0235394146,
0.0287080538,
-0.0919582099,
-0.0628497154,
0.058062993,
0.0526813082,
-0.0347579643,
-0.0187647976,
0.0380061045,
-0.0138299689,
0.0514685959,
-0.0000982731,
0.0381753668,
-0.0259330887,
0.0019307454,
-0.02048878,
-0.0433981568,
-0.0181023814,
0.0171502307,
-0.0269603264,
0.0301700775,
-0.0850804001,
-0.0005704018,
-0.015287647,
-0.0508216694,
0.037206281,
-0.0112725077,
0.0099702096,
0.0562970862,
0.0286606494,
0.0338961557,
0.0493434183,
0.0018137831,
0.0192716587,
-0.0138207385,
0.0376616307,
0.063480854,
0.0300088599,
-0.0319804847,
0.0042317333,
0.0458638109,
0.0457328148,
-0.031047523,
-0.0201130249,
-0.0129914312,
0.0284677949,
0.0072086072,
-0.0013053743,
0.0246299114,
-0.0120458417,
-0.043151591,
0.0443541631,
-0.0198303442,
-0.0353014022,
0.0240442865,
-0.0165942349,
0.0152154006,
-0.0221803021,
0.0113682859,
-0.0252996869,
-0.0206206646,
-0.0242762715,
0.0065556564,
-0.0061110491,
-0.0241698883,
0.0168878064,
-0.0823419988,
-0.0541933849,
-0.0023437678,
-0.0427176096,
-0.0090391655,
0.0521784164,
0.0163155403,
0.0348523818,
-0.0091145076,
-0.0280934051,
-0.029570505,
-0.0480679572,
-0.0086277854,
0.0151999276,
0.0414329506,
0.0499878526,
-0.0278966501,
0.0197721384,
-0.0168010704,
-0.0753277093,
-0.0807958841,
0.069975093,
-0.017610183,
0.0596750379,
-0.0114389677,
-0.0458793454,
-0.0421995334,
-0.0450896546,
0.0251932666,
0.0020362369,
0.022317322,
0.0265446398,
2.59e-7,
0.0394010618,
0.0225630291,
0.0040020868,
0.0455882512,
0.0032677546,
0.0253645554,
-0.0321869254,
0.0112652285,
-0.003410653,
-0.0520590991,
0.007098679,
0.0662238672,
0.0130661996,
0.0290635396,
-0.0766934156,
-0.0182204042,
0.0592140481,
-0.050703533,
-0.0416704379,
0.0504463613,
0.0647910908,
0.0189247392,
0.0658371821,
-0.0018383659,
-0.0009138727,
-0.021640325,
0.0499256775,
-0.0008276065,
0.0120204072,
-0.00192766,
-0.0056364615,
0.0350099504,
-0.0181354713,
0.121122174,
0.0252257977,
0.0011291729,
0.014495966,
-0.0063248533,
0.0044496236,
-0.010839493,
-0.0702399015,
-0.0441589393,
-0.0267016739,
-0.0654204339,
0.0590694137,
-0.0688092634,
-0.0184261389,
0.0333400555,
0.0395962521,
-0.0124894166,
-0.0223808363,
0.0343933441,
-0.01625547,
0.0096491873,
-0.0100341896,
0.0102976775,
-0.0124906097,
-0.0557385236,
0.0077106007,
0.0133247674,
-0.0100318668,
-0.0955774337,
-0.0083314581,
-0.0250390153,
0.0572005287,
-0.0599804074,
-0.0296911299,
1.777058291e-34,
-0.0364715829,
0.0206253268,
-0.0013095044,
0.0057244198,
0.0224924535,
-0.0144792153,
0.0264546666,
0.025779115,
0.0159906223,
-0.0379270427,
0.0271756351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05922v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05922v1 | A Survey of Hallucination in Large Foundation Models | 2023-09-12T02:34:06 | 2023-09-12T02:34:06 | Vipula Rawte, Amit Sheth, Amitava Das | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR | Hallucination in a foundation model (FM) refers to the generation of content
that strays from factual reality or includes fabricated information. This
survey paper provides an extensive overview of recent efforts that aim to
identify, elucidate, and tackle the problem of hallucination, with a particular
focus on ``Large'' Foundation Models (LFMs). The paper classifies various types
of hallucination phenomena that are specific to LFMs and establishes evaluation
criteria for assessing the extent of hallucination. It also examines existing
strategies for mitigating hallucination in LFMs and discusses potential
directions for future research in this area. Essentially, the paper offers a
comprehensive examination of the challenges and solutions related to
hallucination in LFMs. | [
0.0288678166,
0.0573286191,
-0.0193953644,
0.0262775216,
-0.03797438,
-0.0022413898,
-0.0297666509,
-0.0010024064,
-0.0347106457,
0.0055091945,
0.0515723228,
-0.0395930745,
0.0202549752,
0.0127274683,
0.0303154029,
-0.0290696546,
0.0435166843,
-0.0015554525,
-0.0681948885,
-0.0072695138,
-0.0085904021,
0.0177461971,
0.0235112179,
-0.01517432,
-0.0354651995,
-0.0531509072,
-0.034130495,
0.0306860115,
-0.0326301865,
-0.0081604496,
-0.0299115982,
0.0437865853,
-0.0091286693,
0.0344276056,
0.0000026403,
-0.0261411034,
-0.0289648138,
0.0265822504,
-0.0671330765,
0.0614616126,
0.0201485772,
0.0625653639,
-0.0121719362,
0.0110769467,
0.0020310988,
-0.0167829897,
0.0035784182,
0.1041744426,
0.0211204682,
0.0003847837,
-0.0019694753,
-0.0460473746,
0.0089801336,
0.0458716713,
0.0198754296,
0.0609843694,
0.027409995,
0.0546983778,
0.0011948673,
-0.0495341383,
-0.0071286759,
0.0081833797,
0.0065892735,
0.0202155914,
0.0175172668,
0.0103705302,
-0.0488256179,
-0.048443526,
0.0083067557,
0.0406622663,
0.0357210264,
-0.039734114,
0.0347567685,
0.0181301553,
0.0101574976,
0.0326845497,
-0.0058169244,
0.029408114,
-0.0449143611,
-0.0066259461,
0.0341903009,
-0.0121317133,
0.0425592177,
0.0111611346,
-0.0341654308,
0.0023916038,
0.0079507735,
-0.0140068727,
-0.0326152854,
-0.0047477377,
0.0422780961,
-0.0791155323,
-0.0001468189,
0.0061031282,
-0.0121355318,
-0.0082464376,
-0.012900861,
0.0834951401,
0.0487880073,
-0.078276515,
0.0177298151,
-0.0099164294,
-0.0380063988,
0.0430964977,
0.0295590647,
-0.0106066586,
-0.1011518538,
0.0329014994,
0.0129767423,
0.0725029334,
-0.0358005203,
0.0244102497,
-0.0307798088,
0.0300725009,
-0.0315009691,
-0.0483164676,
0.0272345562,
0.017441202,
-0.0234576743,
0.0751418024,
-0.0723005608,
0.0313544013,
-0.0141140465,
-0.0279125962,
0.0023666534,
-0.0107587259,
-0.0242500063,
-0.0059696473,
0.0069766631,
-0.086224027,
0.0109675713,
-0.0313786268,
-0.0208115801,
0.0518475138,
-0.01013612,
-0.0267310664,
0.0762520954,
0.0448155291,
-0.0785626397,
-0.0900388882,
0.0494597219,
-0.0600536019,
0.0162676405,
-0.0508701988,
-0.0606617406,
-0.0023882848,
-0.0060707717,
0.0083228452,
-0.0061385878,
0.000089116,
-0.0061408607,
0.0345186442,
-0.0695192888,
-0.0176151898,
0.0481896102,
0.0636325777,
-0.0109472694,
0.0477636755,
-0.0199076422,
0.0388862193,
0.0029842949,
0.0117945438,
0.05417566,
-0.0083596269,
0.0067780251,
0.060548313,
-0.0109814331,
0.0130925681,
0.011581921,
-0.0039924188,
-0.0590874739,
-0.0054880562,
-0.0375256091,
0.0671124905,
0.0336152799,
-0.0559130609,
0.0071126083,
0.0455407389,
0.030432364,
0.040364299,
0.0005436611,
0.0586329065,
-0.0499254167,
-0.0089444462,
-0.041080486,
0.008049204,
-0.0274610035,
0.0265942868,
-0.0185620636,
-0.0148748597,
0.0069515109,
-0.0159936864,
-0.0067629507,
-0.0051089064,
-0.0093513345,
0.0364546962,
-0.0362860858,
0.0427788645,
0.0170380156,
-0.0031645475,
0.0449192487,
-0.02509108,
0.0086778607,
0.088530533,
0.0549975149,
-0.0126284501,
0.0113947084,
-0.039389763,
0.0317969844,
0.0291508697,
0.0322876908,
0.00996836,
-0.0294605661,
0.0045215208,
0.0067238826,
-0.0555114336,
0.0629619136,
0.0278084166,
-0.0683664754,
-0.0133515103,
-0.005116052,
0.0110591417,
-0.0235813856,
0.0124187488,
-0.0561547913,
0.0211214889,
-0.0850409493,
-0.0203242283,
-0.0061791572,
0.0229160078,
-0.0114487875,
0.0421733856,
0.0014981511,
0.0178758055,
-0.0560015328,
-0.0047573438,
-0.0320476182,
0.0890500993,
-0.0043070251,
-0.0238257963,
0.0364075527,
-0.0340702347,
0.0368912145,
0.0114570344,
0.0378742889,
-0.0421949103,
0.0654663593,
-0.0068872739,
0.0599379987,
-0.0110411039,
0.0306578148,
0.0094325682,
0.0317704603,
-0.050082773,
0.0124258427,
0.046993617,
0.019951269,
0.0125698438,
-0.0027371994,
0.0753257796,
0.0296667516,
-0.0194062851,
0.0089459689,
-0.0008857046,
-0.0695992708,
-0.0463727638,
0.0365571752,
-0.0422747247,
-0.0097227618,
-0.0048390171,
-0.0198350511,
0.0443510637,
-0.0452673212,
-0.0179457162,
0.050882943,
0.0245980546,
-0.0127395233,
0.0330920778,
0.0152766043,
-0.04027858,
0.0063565164,
-0.0339211524,
0.0329525024,
0.0395320281,
0.0057700141,
0.0543981753,
0.0179770384,
-0.0473578498,
-0.0974095762,
0.0355062112,
-0.0323093757,
-0.0359637775,
0.0089661917,
0.0132345799,
-0.0145415729,
-0.019263871,
-0.0286502466,
-0.0280463658,
-0.0004648255,
0.0737034902,
0.0167811532,
-0.0588577762,
0.012272751,
-0.0518362075,
-0.0124692675,
0.0786305442,
-0.0093005514,
-0.036813084,
0.0177060589,
0.0036336116,
0.0309397783,
0.0406263322,
-0.0254429597,
0.074818559,
-0.0617273301,
-0.0309101269,
0.0993272066,
-0.0819239467,
-0.0280930176,
0.0792341605,
-0.024105737,
-0.0161753949,
0.0124132372,
-0.0224071965,
0.0480280034,
-0.0052932203,
0.0591078252,
-0.0183063094,
-0.0298726652,
-0.0315525495,
0.0154969664,
0.0574624129,
-0.0031390691,
-0.0149543053,
-0.0384738557,
0.0104391603,
-0.0525173619,
-0.0369457863,
-0.0033428506,
-0.0503982268,
0.0439133756,
0.0049890676,
-0.0357921571,
-0.0487059727,
0.0170378555,
-0.0347882174,
-0.0328284092,
0.03497044,
-0.033545658,
-0.0405946895,
-0.0213469584,
-0.0005782835,
0.0062134527,
-0.0257338919,
-0.0031725354,
-0.0195295941,
-0.0179285035,
-0.0486068539,
0.099759087,
-0.0853657126,
0.0340103135,
0.0219607372,
0.0103043923,
0.0248923004,
0.0114011858,
-0.016008798,
0.0088771824,
0.0361362137,
-0.0690000728,
0.0215430222,
-0.0076159681,
-0.0228854585,
-0.041293703,
0.0545164458,
0.0168060958,
0.0308020767,
0.0298768394,
-0.0358858071,
-0.0114519447,
0.0124749541,
-0.0256109554,
-0.054547485,
0.0636083186,
0.0187343806,
-0.0103217326,
-0.0504756309,
-0.019460408,
-0.0192615259,
-0.0250121336,
0.064227201,
0.0411494598,
0.0008326253,
0.0098281316,
0.0066312375,
-0.0086043384,
0.0467412993,
-0.0374823995,
-0.0221841354,
0.0079275034,
-0.0311080068,
0.0362503901,
-0.0097846827,
-0.0375068225,
-0.0276889633,
-0.0035860215,
0.0387562439,
0.0218586549,
-0.0139548508,
-0.0249523707,
-0.0441184342,
-0.0143357953,
0.0115019968,
-0.000370897,
0.0057568382,
0.0378903076,
0.0391184017,
0.0321116745,
-0.0155726904,
-0.0078409594,
0.0060547995,
-0.0599469244,
-0.0044800937,
0.0492844172,
-0.0585789829,
-0.058289662,
-0.0371037014,
0.017373357,
0.0471895933,
0.0222596526,
0.0249319058,
-0.0210495926,
-0.0168544631,
-0.0043266094,
0.0418808423,
0.0301554631,
-0.0120430514,
0.0446449257,
0.0555545017,
0.0074785948,
-0.0287873913,
-0.049699802,
-0.0654636398,
0.0420402102,
0.0121634733,
0.0203763004,
-0.0075509027,
-0.031743791,
0.0055411062,
0.01069461,
-0.0345612057,
0.0125483843,
-0.0191875305,
0.0369508676,
-0.0130615206,
-0.0672226399,
0.0213778429,
-0.0034230405,
-0.0229525305,
-0.0209821574,
0.1027731672,
-0.0100175785,
0.0457510389,
0.0305404868,
0.0121675814,
0.0202211682,
0.0471253209,
0.0075286203,
-0.06985607,
0.0165386014,
0.0167778376,
-0.0330616906,
-0.000658089,
-0.0208273716,
-0.008874923,
0.0273821894,
0.0061802184,
-0.025307551,
-0.031020917,
0.0351362862,
0.0460769273,
0.0050105941,
-0.0210269783,
-0.0151261408,
0.0127895065,
0.0140609574,
0.0176251456,
-0.0384826474,
-0.0291125961,
0.0121681504,
-0.0170442518,
0.0428596549,
0.0100934794,
0.0368608721,
0.0061726901,
-0.0457247123,
0.0037405072,
-0.0179719459,
-0.0525705442,
0.0246830471,
0.0231631827,
0.0559349768,
-0.0463236049,
-0.0271119867,
0.0242655352,
-0.0251556262,
0.038510412,
0.023098506,
0.0933954939,
0.0189264491,
-0.0303226244,
-0.0386124402,
-0.0016739524,
-0.0012132428,
-0.0980877578,
-0.0503495522,
0.0319765359,
-0.0213450473,
0.0173243042,
-0.0152772218,
-0.0386236198,
0.0183431637,
0.0002597833,
-0.0259148702,
0.0345668308,
-0.0828356221,
-0.0453460664,
0.0255111195,
-0.0210955404,
0.020312326,
-0.0053686532,
0.0348307267,
0.041124478,
-0.0624852665,
-0.017118128,
-0.0250110403,
-0.0405864865,
-0.0574609898,
0.0103766322,
-0.0221159495,
-0.0310431253,
-0.1419074833,
-0.0131992046,
0.0322072431,
-0.003342445,
0.0137365721,
-0.0207319688,
0.0135954292,
0.0517583899,
0.0013853108,
-0.0094392914,
-0.001294505,
-0.0006057309,
0.0106314477,
-0.0006549547,
0.0289754998,
-7.19640213e-33,
-0.0195346717,
-0.0233379863,
0.0271966662,
-0.0304745343,
-0.0462415665,
0.0121012125,
0.0112979049,
-0.0084273219,
0.0105532883,
-0.0083045699,
0.0131609598,
0.030561382,
0.0155367237,
-0.0120581649,
-0.0282284375,
-0.009446783,
0.0617290959,
0.0322207175,
-0.0547338724,
0.040679805,
0.0005820673,
-0.0006099187,
0.001575319,
-0.1157606319,
0.029771952,
-0.0705939233,
-0.0203632042,
-0.0178560372,
-0.0062901475,
0.0194717813,
-0.0206698701,
-0.0071187327,
-0.0044904151,
-0.0869120285,
-0.0270213336,
-0.0261065252,
-0.0074262917,
0.0288921967,
0.0247324314,
0.0240412261,
-0.0036297515,
-0.007665542,
-0.0179465488,
-0.0194561388,
0.0034696758,
-0.0167229753,
0.0182175711,
-0.0358222425,
0.0003136865,
0.0490031764,
-0.0947644785,
-0.0163159221,
0.0167528801,
0.0327798054,
-0.0219785273,
0.002400154,
-0.0131627358,
-0.0557309315,
-0.0363942496,
-0.0054712985,
0.01832911,
-0.0411244035,
0.0037962552,
0.0055138785,
-0.0088742757,
0.042431429,
0.0144921998,
0.0821452588,
-0.0280461796,
-0.0185501277,
-0.0006105451,
0.085209094,
0.0371665284,
0.0546209216,
0.0087060807,
-0.0020935971,
-0.019221263,
-0.0270263273,
-0.0624498464,
0.0172628611,
0.0747922361,
-0.0338649042,
-0.0444164686,
-0.0337523483,
-0.006335136,
-0.0056524361,
-0.0156498197,
0.0206417367,
0.0158507694,
-0.0034128949,
-0.060483288,
0.0201103594,
0.0072762235,
-0.0667319596,
0.0032214809,
0.0477751531,
0.012394256,
0.0139700714,
-0.0123399058,
0.004807957,
0.0149763767,
-0.025896512,
-0.0085570263,
0.0093828412,
0.0485858321,
0.021695992,
-0.0049022594,
0.0074303658,
-0.0083581796,
-0.0075358497,
-0.0130270654,
0.0069994857,
0.0595995039,
-0.036018163,
0.0474790968,
-0.0226561669,
-0.00497323,
-0.0419365242,
0.0405621491,
0.0356139503,
0.0109060304,
0.0078383889,
-0.0327522643,
0.0440343358,
-0.0049130823,
-0.0112836258,
-0.0515948944,
-0.0225496162,
0.0679047629,
-0.0978347808,
-0.0358675867,
-0.0099194162,
3.291e-7,
-0.0754058585,
0.0523831099,
0.0231470522,
-0.0162927527,
0.0267218873,
0.006478325,
0.0294346511,
0.0151489004,
0.0085476954,
-0.083177641,
0.001436044,
-0.0114261154,
0.0281241667,
0.0517151877,
-0.0512146987,
-0.0169855878,
-0.0073550949,
0.0249440037,
-0.0615706071,
-0.0597619601,
0.004968429,
0.0061627175,
0.0379590578,
-0.0458679833,
0.0187531542,
-0.0026664771,
0.0299636535,
0.0127713215,
0.001742247,
0.0210666973,
-0.009835626,
0.0370511152,
0.007009007,
0.0086373575,
0.0019049325,
-0.0119721452,
-0.000062324,
-0.0201559681,
-0.0205037799,
0.0260148216,
-0.0060317386,
-0.0717965961,
0.0117909946,
-0.0520681851,
0.0419168621,
-0.0006108494,
-0.0017718071,
0.0296238326,
-0.0970594883,
-0.0431566276,
0.0231615417,
0.0447811745,
0.0050430815,
0.0088008167,
-0.0382031538,
0.0459741913,
0.0056401812,
0.0103687728,
0.0571211539,
0.009267523,
-0.0189951546,
-0.0186637826,
0.0216527767,
-0.0109616239,
-0.0236813817,
-0.0809891149,
-0.0030997857,
3.452148417e-34,
0.0055873236,
0.0047776741,
0.0501727313,
-0.0214715488,
0.0113729434,
0.0115411617,
0.0436076075,
0.0073796869,
0.0309964605,
0.0018122956,
0.0128534781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05920v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05920v1 | SAGE: Structured Attribute Value Generation for Billion-Scale Product Catalogs | 2023-09-12T02:24:16 | 2023-09-12T02:24:16 | Athanasios N. Nikolakopoulos, Swati Kaul, Siva Karthik Gade, Bella Dubrov, Umit Batur, Suleiman Ali Khan | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | We introduce SAGE; a Generative LLM for inferring attribute values for
products across world-wide e-Commerce catalogs. We introduce a novel
formulation of the attribute-value prediction problem as a Seq2Seq
summarization task, across languages, product types and target attributes. Our
novel modeling approach lifts the restriction of predicting attribute values
within a pre-specified set of choices, as well as, the requirement that the
sought attribute values need to be explicitly mentioned in the text. SAGE can
infer attribute values even when such values are mentioned implicitly using
periphrastic language, or not-at-all-as is the case for common-sense defaults.
Additionally, SAGE is capable of predicting whether an attribute is
inapplicable for the product at hand, or non-obtainable from the available
information. SAGE is the first method able to tackle all aspects of the
attribute-value-prediction task as they arise in practical settings in
e-Commerce catalogs. A comprehensive set of experiments demonstrates the
effectiveness of the proposed approach, as well as, its superiority against
state-of-the-art competing alternatives. Moreover, our experiments highlight
SAGE's ability to tackle the task of predicting attribute values in zero-shot
setting; thereby, opening up opportunities for significantly reducing the
overall number of labeled examples required for training. | [
0.0177750513,
0.023717152,
0.0038123161,
0.0083831176,
0.015708942,
0.0134754777,
0.0225061476,
-0.0162777118,
-0.0061269971,
-0.0566617027,
-0.0065404759,
0.0041016806,
-0.0095901676,
0.0566138364,
0.0160526,
-0.0008834128,
-0.0156064816,
0.0124590397,
0.0037466078,
-0.0120753199,
0.0359898359,
0.0443911999,
0.016986981,
-0.0109635247,
0.0257361792,
-0.0228268877,
-0.0217200182,
-0.0065157451,
0.0133043258,
-0.0389803462,
0.0351038761,
0.0148030389,
0.0077885645,
-0.0417798199,
0.0000021179,
-0.056167569,
-0.0216088556,
-0.0320078284,
-0.0400199741,
0.0084083751,
0.0392633528,
0.0606713817,
0.0462322235,
0.0133114923,
-0.02582369,
-0.0214013029,
0.0241400152,
0.0519199669,
0.0051086051,
0.0487408713,
-0.0240472667,
-0.0501216985,
0.0035266206,
-0.0256563555,
0.0744346231,
-0.0432540476,
0.0193271842,
-0.0169619154,
-0.0238536,
0.0551190227,
0.0230063535,
0.0212962888,
-0.0226940606,
0.0191041902,
0.0552443229,
0.0560863614,
-0.0141952187,
0.0033759933,
0.0030091978,
0.089176476,
0.013427861,
-0.0162605401,
0.0207044743,
-0.0202549417,
0.0190482643,
-0.0300372131,
-0.0229721144,
0.0483787656,
0.003452007,
-0.0147699602,
-0.0107412096,
0.0372087136,
-0.0191713832,
-0.0056918333,
-0.0029633476,
0.0017818043,
0.0110629248,
-0.0051283068,
-0.0480087139,
-0.0036161696,
-0.085883446,
-0.0714490414,
-0.0394837409,
0.0179794263,
-0.0072699636,
0.0199841596,
-0.0411808155,
-0.0040020011,
0.0196928736,
-0.0094230603,
0.0480107479,
-0.0382771082,
-0.0046811919,
0.0729012862,
-0.05241099,
0.0016979477,
0.0191972945,
-0.0297393445,
-0.0423288383,
0.0099247796,
-0.0528660715,
-0.0301885437,
0.0224746168,
0.0288977511,
-0.0043022642,
0.0110676959,
-0.0350293964,
-0.01492217,
-0.0048175589,
0.0295571703,
-0.0009968828,
0.0391195677,
-0.0084939683,
-0.019013755,
-0.0650284439,
0.0031121115,
-0.0394569524,
0.0013089302,
-0.011509181,
-0.0039893319,
0.0264997818,
0.0317895003,
0.0439256579,
-0.0168248769,
0.036608085,
0.0320612304,
-0.0251624379,
0.0004856375,
-0.0666257069,
-0.0904762894,
0.0006398777,
-0.0360953286,
0.0159100238,
-0.0615308322,
0.0018735394,
0.0105910571,
-0.0152871199,
-0.0491319075,
0.0019021757,
0.0028673615,
0.0044322535,
0.066781491,
-0.0021069807,
-0.0285891686,
0.0051554022,
-0.0274792574,
0.036556229,
-0.0035237877,
-0.0152477277,
0.0926004499,
0.0319645889,
0.0116095142,
-0.006498666,
0.0067740791,
0.0145169534,
0.0079572732,
-0.0406373367,
0.0023686585,
-0.0069046151,
-0.0212091636,
0.0036835873,
0.011084673,
-0.0176287964,
0.0007243537,
0.0708201155,
0.0190722086,
-0.0026044848,
0.0468261577,
0.036013104,
0.0326313339,
-0.0096356506,
-0.0412167646,
0.0140113756,
0.0372562222,
-0.047754772,
0.0389214456,
-0.0175701398,
0.005324149,
-0.0398583673,
-0.0714431405,
0.0094218822,
-0.0026345467,
0.0007131882,
0.0384372622,
0.0365915187,
0.0357176475,
-0.0088059613,
0.0247635636,
-0.0127190948,
-0.046761442,
0.0091856318,
0.001049156,
0.0568249226,
0.0823248103,
0.0422868431,
-0.0459361039,
-0.0099293571,
0.0097833211,
0.0306473002,
0.0423406363,
0.0113889743,
-0.0526265353,
-0.0120376414,
-0.0514056943,
-0.0524740219,
-0.05725912,
0.0151656885,
0.0211510863,
-0.0128745111,
-0.0282450281,
0.0409550555,
-0.0131529216,
-0.0140410699,
0.0036148953,
-0.0403401963,
-0.0578036308,
0.0592113473,
0.0019358163,
-0.0222723801,
0.0196056105,
0.0104688825,
0.0112267807,
0.0105764139,
-0.0548419356,
-0.0607462823,
-0.0006573878,
0.0055056638,
-0.0201137252,
0.0487962179,
-0.0464996099,
0.0007724391,
-0.040690057,
-0.0539931953,
-0.0334341601,
-0.0038922706,
-0.0374507792,
-0.0070207356,
-0.0347214788,
0.0247472655,
0.0023572063,
0.0154572316,
-0.0276589002,
0.0946160033,
0.0335612297,
-0.0084580956,
-0.0037142197,
-0.0064365817,
0.0133398604,
-0.0207165126,
0.0030850435,
-0.0150682041,
0.01474432,
0.0304087736,
0.0435468629,
0.0243807528,
-0.0329280123,
0.01617199,
-0.0275110882,
-0.0074268049,
0.0338160396,
0.0323493034,
-0.0263632052,
0.0086664027,
0.0059690196,
0.0027403601,
-0.1051264405,
0.002759672,
-0.0385188535,
-0.0058523673,
0.0705427304,
0.009477661,
-0.0315975472,
0.0354348607,
0.0010526516,
0.0021792601,
0.0277367886,
0.0244027879,
0.0202454794,
-0.0430639796,
0.0383176543,
-0.0352512375,
-0.0117409257,
0.0174306761,
0.034711577,
-0.0639819056,
-0.0565746464,
0.0204081833,
0.0314893499,
0.028396761,
-0.052337639,
0.0250666402,
0.0016944053,
-0.0531252176,
-0.0121787041,
-0.0262412094,
0.0243624095,
0.0429310761,
-0.0142422887,
0.0225305595,
0.0540894009,
-0.0331629477,
-0.0069066808,
-0.0326054469,
0.0364331268,
0.0229052678,
-0.0398137495,
-0.0354408436,
0.0285531897,
0.0282184947,
0.086238116,
-0.0088097239,
-0.0195327122,
0.0451586805,
-0.0040046494,
0.0144339316,
-0.0141240312,
0.0036072121,
-0.0798349753,
0.0276128855,
0.0139794042,
0.0351205766,
0.05164022,
-0.0372224115,
-0.0602778047,
0.0384527333,
0.0773103908,
-0.0097268224,
0.0402900241,
-0.0172753297,
0.0226313826,
-0.0377398916,
-0.0177293196,
-0.023771802,
-0.0305694137,
0.021119196,
-0.0168004204,
0.0093609914,
0.0007817228,
-0.0660203472,
-0.0216621868,
0.007348781,
0.020804096,
0.0072337189,
-0.0486768559,
0.0112782475,
0.0349115171,
0.0791378692,
-0.0643484741,
-0.0303413067,
-0.0294496696,
-0.0097704194,
0.050571382,
-0.0249188896,
-0.020342242,
-0.0099174343,
0.0198096354,
0.0238930602,
-0.0559888445,
0.0017898837,
0.0395578593,
-0.0335116759,
-0.0156963039,
0.0171674639,
0.0829195976,
0.0277375244,
-0.0666132346,
-0.0138876485,
0.0348698534,
0.0125953816,
0.0218897909,
0.0155110089,
-0.1310502291,
-0.0243821852,
-0.0400675908,
0.0181028508,
0.0147136739,
-0.0301518962,
-0.0162152164,
-0.1389872283,
0.0157584231,
-0.014427104,
-0.0028400158,
-0.0125144487,
0.0029301704,
-0.0319651738,
-0.0377166755,
0.0314854234,
-0.005427625,
-0.0412114821,
-0.0001270994,
0.0084909918,
-0.0234891884,
-0.0164064839,
0.0583445914,
0.020619614,
-0.0135439979,
0.0461811051,
0.0311777666,
-0.0177969728,
-0.0064639766,
-0.0100925174,
0.006847884,
-0.0132038565,
0.0080482746,
0.0581303686,
-0.0060642338,
0.0057457373,
0.0238572303,
0.0425031595,
-0.0089404723,
-0.0007692699,
0.0277854167,
0.0256968774,
0.0334363431,
-0.0258671828,
-0.0240040235,
-0.0621314645,
-0.0472336859,
0.039387431,
0.0056721191,
-0.0423167311,
-0.034462858,
-0.0429372229,
-0.0106112566,
-0.0432833731,
-0.047930304,
0.0150702894,
-0.038795583,
-0.0586818792,
-0.0863569453,
-0.0014726007,
0.038831193,
0.0218523424,
0.0169628952,
-0.0289396551,
-0.03443674,
0.0248587299,
-0.0862542912,
-0.0318028666,
-0.0385171622,
0.033796858,
0.0005377457,
0.0156636126,
0.0578334853,
-0.074936673,
-0.0194154959,
-0.003829004,
-0.0403034091,
-0.0597371124,
-0.043449942,
0.0545262769,
0.0157886557,
0.0503595136,
-0.0095783258,
-0.0739050731,
0.0599644147,
0.0798632875,
-0.0174611844,
-0.0254256614,
0.0074927094,
0.0556656867,
0.0015676774,
0.0389566012,
-0.0703419819,
0.0518117882,
0.0101029184,
0.0354075581,
0.0126176635,
-0.0500072278,
0.0460647531,
0.0695519224,
-0.0608831681,
-0.0229950957,
0.0414699316,
-0.0034413899,
0.0240026731,
0.0164934862,
-0.060706079,
-0.028595265,
0.039503675,
-0.0130103128,
-0.0159939006,
0.0002236978,
0.045972351,
0.0147542674,
0.0577831864,
-0.0404071212,
-0.0108087901,
-0.0089664301,
0.0218530316,
0.0073518893,
-0.0156017905,
-0.035264764,
-0.0183972083,
0.0125990994,
0.0600701161,
-0.0032749702,
0.0336763076,
0.0233459715,
0.0419448204,
-0.0884724259,
0.0321082547,
0.0079281582,
-0.0195132308,
-0.0742096305,
0.0052774563,
0.0100536766,
-0.0094999429,
0.018686695,
-0.0337100551,
-0.0381390639,
-0.0221451297,
0.0557852462,
0.0060625533,
-0.009912936,
-0.0220334213,
0.043896649,
-0.0400488563,
-0.0477432832,
0.080287911,
0.0485207662,
0.0273307357,
-0.0190525129,
-0.0305419192,
-0.0662105381,
-0.0116808526,
-0.0115350476,
-0.0169361681,
-0.00882689,
-0.0023489918,
-0.0674082115,
-0.0568134561,
0.0094107976,
-0.0097816894,
0.0438229963,
0.0251528807,
0.026704153,
0.0504284091,
0.0511302873,
-0.0008303236,
-0.0126258219,
-0.0138840796,
-0.0291982368,
0.0192009155,
0.0034738635,
-5.63622064e-33,
0.0150989089,
-0.0471275747,
-0.0122207031,
0.0420986488,
0.0162760578,
-0.0050601517,
-0.0386419632,
-0.0177299343,
0.0387744196,
0.0237446222,
-0.0058452054,
-0.0211533196,
0.0148437368,
0.0257418063,
0.082250759,
0.0020192177,
0.0366236828,
0.0362449139,
-0.0328071043,
0.0744521692,
0.0410225317,
0.0085452367,
0.0643717125,
-0.0402418151,
0.017804835,
-0.0253072511,
-0.0307276957,
0.0148395067,
0.0529036634,
0.054941278,
-0.007975745,
0.0336376429,
0.0112123704,
-0.058017578,
-0.0196217932,
-0.0665070266,
-0.0808072388,
-0.0204140842,
-0.0066574565,
-0.0213725585,
-0.0045814766,
0.0015225253,
0.0005318788,
0.0030230831,
0.0288391877,
-0.0160327796,
0.0895793289,
-0.0394502804,
-0.0265188888,
-0.1309758872,
-0.0349196605,
0.0259584095,
-0.0198156815,
0.0169851519,
0.0527129136,
0.0318145901,
0.0107628172,
0.0285911635,
0.0042439327,
0.0684696957,
0.0088809226,
-0.00325197,
0.0627990291,
0.0404684395,
0.0329515338,
0.0419260673,
0.0415376797,
0.0391928293,
-0.0051140441,
0.0525747947,
-0.0370754115,
0.0679804906,
-0.0022955122,
0.0904101282,
0.04997392,
0.0537742414,
-0.0232228581,
0.0900867656,
0.0224240962,
0.0010552814,
-0.0248079076,
0.0114884032,
-0.0155403279,
-0.0373838767,
-0.0045797182,
0.0326600112,
-0.064490594,
-0.0235341359,
0.0019333252,
0.0324712917,
-0.0812904164,
0.046050638,
0.0146173192,
-0.0109580923,
-0.067990914,
0.0010348919,
0.0129972389,
0.0113381781,
0.0070112851,
-0.0623528436,
-0.0160408188,
-0.0194734503,
0.0112132328,
-0.0362320989,
-0.004410028,
0.0229047313,
0.0557387248,
0.009882126,
-0.0379869603,
0.0116313128,
0.0077403123,
-0.022864528,
-0.0335851498,
0.0212683287,
0.0058828001,
0.0115731256,
-0.044419568,
0.0641400814,
0.0220779199,
0.0162773654,
-0.0348068625,
-0.0029574542,
0.0377513357,
0.0091180326,
-0.0233717412,
-0.0103028398,
-0.0333932415,
-0.0536769331,
0.0492105857,
-0.0493528619,
-0.0268786233,
0.0073914924,
2.708e-7,
0.0263426527,
0.0088477675,
0.0337982364,
0.0514949635,
-0.0066323527,
0.0742667094,
0.0286610685,
0.0393784791,
-0.0037983854,
-0.0368684866,
0.0563507602,
0.0027576557,
0.0456935428,
0.0251332745,
-0.0854789466,
0.0213416051,
0.0100791464,
0.0034615751,
-0.0435272753,
-0.0329896249,
0.0338957906,
0.0504550673,
-0.0015479857,
-0.0229425635,
0.0308549628,
0.0032050179,
0.048912771,
-0.0141401291,
-0.0052352753,
0.0134709598,
0.0269068647,
0.0040176772,
-0.0433330312,
-0.0056106714,
-0.036232993,
0.009642574,
0.0319493376,
0.0550715439,
0.0150735704,
-0.0202337317,
-0.0144279292,
-0.0412373394,
0.0158109143,
-0.009842189,
0.0357957222,
-0.0552560389,
-0.0105091063,
0.0097067142,
-0.0755136162,
0.0113554532,
-0.0321501829,
-0.0261848718,
-0.0036416324,
0.0121910674,
-0.0233245566,
-0.018007027,
-0.0039165867,
-0.0576719753,
-0.0262958221,
-0.0334113128,
-0.0125619182,
-0.0376999043,
0.0061976938,
0.0832211077,
-0.002017475,
-0.0497178547,
-0.0036672524,
2.823945869e-34,
0.0640837327,
0.0084249265,
-0.0424520411,
0.0459703766,
0.0231304485,
-0.0290665906,
0.0087939585,
0.0013288506,
0.0495593809,
-0.0730977207,
-0.0346012712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05918v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05918v3 | Stochastic LLMs do not Understand Language: Towards Symbolic, Explainable and Ontologically Based LLMs | 2023-09-12T02:14:05 | 2023-09-14T12:58:39 | Walid S. Saba | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In our opinion the exuberance surrounding the relative success of data-driven
large language models (LLMs) is slightly misguided and for several reasons (i)
LLMs cannot be relied upon for factual information since for LLMs all ingested
text (factual or non-factual) was created equal; (ii) due to their subsymbolic
na-ture, whatever 'knowledge' these models acquire about language will always
be buried in billions of microfeatures (weights), none of which is meaningful
on its own; and (iii) LLMs will often fail to make the correct inferences in
several linguistic contexts (e.g., nominal compounds, copredication, quantifier
scope ambi-guities, intensional contexts. Since we believe the relative success
of data-driven large language models (LLMs) is not a reflection on the symbolic
vs. subsymbol-ic debate but a reflection on applying the successful strategy of
a bottom-up reverse engineering of language at scale, we suggest in this paper
applying the effective bottom-up strategy in a symbolic setting resulting in
symbolic, explainable, and ontologically grounded language models. | [
0.0377052352,
0.0288544726,
-0.0532247052,
0.0698798895,
-0.0426973701,
0.0320731029,
-0.0162959658,
0.0205158088,
-0.0153437387,
-0.050320603,
-0.0031574569,
-0.0399640054,
0.0197085589,
0.0157382824,
0.054111585,
-0.0050766105,
0.0231912006,
-0.0317780077,
0.0024929361,
-0.0195559785,
0.0002083428,
-0.0147985127,
0.0407046229,
0.0076311622,
-0.0034458968,
0.0086577479,
-0.0113990195,
-0.0176946074,
-0.0224774051,
0.0048327916,
-0.0562135689,
-0.0286118183,
0.0459619835,
0.0525220893,
0.0000020125,
-0.0602309927,
0.0074504474,
-0.0039689667,
-0.040586777,
0.0116662262,
0.0357364416,
-0.0337651893,
-0.0243482925,
-0.0265803412,
-0.008111068,
0.0236993674,
0.0335809775,
0.0056676641,
0.0158977769,
0.0409006849,
0.0191597939,
-0.0725468621,
0.0305886623,
-0.0051071895,
0.0042669899,
0.0052164393,
0.0554382168,
0.0529622026,
0.0004538728,
0.0160245486,
-0.0447238795,
0.0366113298,
-0.0120916311,
0.0074318564,
-0.0338097624,
-0.0007335861,
0.0026996206,
-0.0094614653,
0.0152074657,
0.0445665121,
0.01428157,
-0.0254122373,
0.0041291639,
-0.0067306799,
-0.0309934523,
0.0457049198,
-0.0579924546,
0.0346033908,
-0.0010656232,
0.0651175976,
0.0993656218,
-0.011429525,
0.0747406483,
0.0255637486,
-0.0727881789,
0.1082894579,
-0.0077088526,
-0.0108115822,
-0.0300455168,
-0.0128854951,
-0.018119378,
-0.0337489583,
-0.0128967147,
0.0230405685,
0.0247149747,
0.0766139999,
0.0198314525,
0.0001137709,
-0.0118672494,
-0.0454995856,
0.0155873345,
0.0087090814,
0.0104140453,
0.0380340032,
-0.0034946271,
0.0262217075,
-0.0295700636,
-0.0042360076,
-0.0432446487,
-0.0268588066,
-0.0347535461,
-0.0248882882,
-0.006267563,
0.0649315417,
-0.015058578,
-0.006151984,
-0.0129199931,
0.019116357,
0.0160468519,
-0.0308164228,
-0.006749731,
-0.0141880512,
-0.0212380998,
-0.0231646635,
-0.0351520926,
0.0129459202,
-0.0029284093,
0.024637755,
-0.0241382439,
-0.049368389,
0.0365863852,
0.0152105493,
-0.017120447,
-0.0199376661,
0.0111957323,
0.0870577618,
0.0638562664,
-0.0184772462,
-0.0460026339,
-0.0385741405,
-0.0514223389,
-0.0439018197,
-0.0161651354,
-0.0607667044,
-0.0013903928,
0.0183207374,
0.015244714,
-0.0781023428,
0.017671762,
-0.0343783461,
-0.0677678287,
0.075857155,
-0.0209945235,
0.0242030416,
-0.016461404,
-0.0132754529,
0.0294352751,
0.0447674394,
0.0740528554,
0.0222910326,
0.0507511385,
-0.0273142159,
-0.0180194173,
0.0219008215,
0.0246360414,
0.0395473801,
-0.067475304,
-0.0205492899,
-0.0327004008,
0.0293144062,
0.0350757465,
0.0602036007,
0.0045271814,
-0.0009576742,
0.0504846759,
0.0587502457,
0.0183754843,
0.0168541688,
0.0394467041,
-0.0196296666,
-0.0024080074,
0.0138314255,
-0.0265708733,
-0.0054877363,
-0.0331358835,
0.0184697974,
-0.0341606066,
0.0102482196,
-0.00018533,
-0.0424572006,
-0.0438302718,
0.0045431708,
-0.0289917681,
0.0266075842,
0.0852064341,
-0.0297156032,
-0.0148152169,
0.0525197797,
0.0322959237,
-0.0239455272,
0.0263934657,
-0.0745818391,
0.04215803,
0.0373753719,
0.0463213027,
-0.035077136,
0.0158943813,
0.0066614603,
-0.0093237441,
0.0477904305,
-0.0271561723,
-0.0030528912,
-0.0347015969,
-0.0288011767,
-0.0060976832,
0.0061210231,
0.0256209951,
0.0117217936,
-0.0670748949,
-0.0034088821,
-0.0111361304,
-0.0558362529,
-0.0234981179,
0.0361133739,
-0.0446717814,
-0.0188402906,
-0.0154426182,
-0.0006606508,
0.0540047064,
0.0179429241,
-0.0104219187,
0.0197699871,
0.0218564514,
-0.0492741391,
-0.0071988553,
0.0202792622,
0.0094062211,
-0.0060823872,
0.049042996,
-0.0188595168,
0.0319111459,
0.0136645688,
-0.0122192558,
-0.0399954952,
0.0566353165,
-0.0518163182,
0.049457822,
-0.0204905476,
0.0333576426,
-0.0182487052,
0.0122535499,
-0.029815577,
0.0565476269,
-0.0353253484,
0.0348255895,
0.018499827,
0.0088079283,
0.0306366403,
-0.0359767117,
0.0098979203,
0.0032487642,
0.0036453353,
-0.0048883227,
0.003847264,
-0.0261036512,
0.0123764826,
-0.0274242219,
-0.027099086,
-0.0289856456,
0.0113873817,
0.0257452689,
0.0114461603,
0.0034870631,
-0.0127251931,
0.0405476801,
0.0213461816,
0.0382356048,
-0.0044027572,
0.0139911231,
0.0476419665,
-0.0411252491,
-0.0551596694,
-0.0290515553,
-0.0096609863,
-0.040687073,
0.0663877726,
-0.0075199469,
-0.0091164513,
-0.0624707527,
0.0222896095,
-0.0449323393,
-0.0014089989,
-0.0336638838,
-0.0449962914,
0.0179746673,
-0.0110660521,
0.0050482918,
0.0306751505,
-0.0162113793,
0.0699646398,
0.0398764461,
-0.0415422805,
-0.0391553789,
-0.0410368443,
-0.0274440534,
-0.0237948932,
-0.0752316788,
-0.0676331446,
-0.0299772993,
0.1236103848,
0.0492662266,
-0.0149682453,
-0.0420308821,
0.0439186171,
-0.0545576103,
-0.0254173223,
-0.0382697061,
-0.015309074,
-0.0427082218,
0.0608750023,
-0.0164587945,
-0.0460628793,
0.0408165194,
-0.0308736805,
0.0387083665,
0.0037728411,
-0.0494315848,
-0.0293328296,
0.0766232833,
0.0045151673,
0.0121468371,
0.0180709232,
-0.0235384479,
-0.0544748977,
-0.005281277,
0.0158408601,
-0.0238684975,
0.0320644379,
-0.0713574663,
0.0333609097,
0.022103548,
0.0048912242,
0.0174848326,
-0.0111174472,
-0.065620333,
0.0115720434,
0.0182516519,
0.0035470519,
0.0004498008,
0.0330225937,
0.0272487272,
-0.052606266,
0.0347810797,
-0.0027212084,
-0.0321134366,
-0.0006805228,
0.016989572,
-0.0154065387,
0.0663232431,
-0.0088783316,
0.000231358,
0.0110489121,
0.0183542427,
-0.0137354452,
-0.0344299227,
-0.0042392262,
0.0220271572,
-0.028415978,
-0.0774310008,
0.0024356183,
0.0191635992,
-0.0420028977,
-0.0014103439,
0.1062282026,
0.0216838308,
0.011724052,
0.0495011248,
0.0221172441,
-0.0407147668,
0.0203539096,
-0.0128770061,
-0.0941413194,
-0.022416655,
0.0182527304,
0.0018121924,
-0.0181353092,
-0.0422555059,
-0.0192439184,
-0.0945758373,
0.0288513508,
0.0083075138,
-0.0583709069,
-0.0257048011,
-0.040797174,
-0.0070923809,
-0.01469428,
0.0068859519,
0.0414300375,
-0.0250479486,
0.005276741,
0.025817275,
-0.0335433856,
-0.025811227,
0.0260923468,
-0.0189970583,
0.059366256,
-0.0134518035,
0.0575030819,
-0.0345148072,
-0.0040852432,
0.0397497602,
-0.0500022322,
0.0213506464,
-0.0092004081,
-0.0123906452,
0.0093306564,
-0.012177228,
-0.0428734608,
0.033613205,
-0.0706947744,
-0.0008070458,
-0.0306952819,
0.0873681754,
-0.0270918813,
-0.0212115608,
-0.0279978253,
-0.018600855,
-0.0273743197,
0.093147628,
0.0264451541,
-0.0226658043,
-0.0138805611,
-0.028137153,
-0.0278233178,
0.0914763436,
-0.0533061549,
-0.0047996081,
-0.03173282,
-0.0210261345,
-0.0559388325,
-0.0154576609,
-0.0159791727,
0.0346621908,
0.0194363669,
0.0550482646,
0.0150896246,
-0.0471985117,
-0.027895309,
0.0203925725,
-0.0350206755,
0.0350887179,
-0.0348278061,
0.0373377502,
0.0590623803,
-0.0532076471,
-0.0061705904,
-0.0165999848,
-0.0683127269,
-0.0870387778,
0.0075774174,
0.0003562767,
0.0375103503,
0.0105205625,
0.009580533,
-0.0756609216,
0.0335941315,
0.032788761,
-0.0144688785,
0.0307148267,
0.0213817712,
0.0244743004,
0.0159312561,
0.0682604983,
-0.0470099859,
0.0196210034,
0.0192881394,
0.0409356318,
-0.0536948778,
-0.0081001278,
0.0209830049,
0.0369343385,
0.0234496761,
-0.0504005514,
-0.0626153499,
-0.0309078209,
0.005762151,
-0.0229442809,
-0.027882494,
-0.0183977485,
0.0005739885,
0.0422166437,
-0.0060583823,
-0.0369689651,
-0.0546481237,
-0.0130704008,
0.0332816988,
0.0167814922,
0.0108565725,
-0.0114958864,
0.0239877421,
0.0390094966,
0.028233109,
0.0284327753,
0.0201430377,
-0.0396129712,
0.0281857718,
-0.0033833408,
0.0211421791,
0.0033624249,
-0.0134053594,
-0.0617851987,
-0.0075001614,
-0.0217084493,
-0.0571387485,
0.0135805942,
0.0102960365,
0.0537746437,
-0.0072751413,
0.0545114242,
-0.0376643427,
0.0000482305,
-0.0126411673,
0.056222558,
0.0136489784,
-0.0001160278,
0.0450991429,
0.0168313198,
-0.0515027903,
0.0167133324,
0.0725991949,
0.0279355831,
0.0296664163,
-0.003286344,
-0.0074835266,
0.0026068573,
-0.0211057719,
-0.0033508339,
0.0149804223,
-0.0247693416,
0.0208088309,
-0.1109356657,
-0.0745478272,
-0.0066488995,
0.0342119485,
-0.0055620265,
-0.0505304225,
0.0116684502,
0.0505450405,
0.0247208402,
0.012492599,
-0.0700430721,
0.0296674259,
0.0108169215,
-0.0206430722,
0.0235925745,
-6.202509901e-33,
-0.0198636446,
-0.0302535985,
0.0065901102,
0.0222988371,
-0.0190383568,
0.0026311122,
-0.0355000608,
-0.0059038671,
-0.0293803718,
0.0314519294,
0.0068777734,
0.0088450741,
0.0062609771,
0.0102566024,
0.0124158729,
0.0187938716,
-0.0072243977,
0.0003456998,
0.0331984609,
-0.0262562595,
0.0737172067,
0.0079209507,
0.0723306686,
-0.057543654,
0.0608602911,
-0.0001870167,
0.0200625323,
0.0544748977,
-0.0030282366,
0.0333372913,
-0.0216715038,
0.0349554755,
0.0297590382,
-0.0145077305,
0.0026266458,
-0.0202109627,
-0.0340475626,
-0.0320384204,
0.0812800154,
0.0076575777,
0.0139245223,
-0.0430072993,
0.0619302131,
0.0097573372,
-0.0477435552,
0.0307774842,
0.037231788,
-0.0385191068,
-0.0266695824,
-0.0499595217,
-0.0419229344,
0.0345228687,
-0.0077400431,
0.0246542208,
0.0035274676,
-0.0634979531,
-0.0084662344,
0.0375384465,
-0.030241577,
0.0257952958,
0.0195281077,
0.015092046,
0.0831183121,
0.0175943617,
0.043671269,
0.0508594327,
0.0276818164,
-0.0049459962,
0.0019891495,
0.0249551404,
0.043273136,
0.0577583387,
0.0152319325,
0.0631961077,
0.0155715309,
0.0152986683,
-0.0709258169,
-0.0253374167,
0.0493636765,
0.0281578787,
0.0143813463,
0.0410716608,
-0.0534132943,
-0.0330926366,
-0.046957653,
-0.0095496448,
-0.0039406912,
-0.0302960351,
-0.0097611649,
-0.0355757549,
-0.0375537574,
-0.0432596505,
0.0096950084,
-0.1052326635,
-0.0632004738,
-0.0292110536,
0.0241381582,
0.0326215178,
-0.000403072,
0.0297745559,
-0.051373899,
-0.0347711965,
-0.0405800492,
0.0001616154,
0.0106953057,
0.0178978145,
-0.0149613135,
0.0430725403,
0.0009719055,
0.0056302976,
-0.0362532288,
-0.0774395838,
-0.0044857683,
-0.0444489382,
0.0441608578,
0.0311249346,
0.0037654012,
0.0268438254,
0.0442816056,
-0.010528991,
0.0316814035,
0.0096032489,
0.0031298487,
0.0065856394,
-0.0286015142,
-0.0178184174,
-0.0289590042,
0.0135304127,
0.0986604691,
-0.0327764079,
-0.0124793993,
0.0160987563,
2.877e-7,
0.0732608885,
0.0478054732,
0.0123995319,
0.0258410107,
0.036823824,
0.0225593504,
-0.0165213458,
-0.0239491798,
-0.0067770649,
-0.0528883077,
0.028234411,
0.0075245635,
0.0342346951,
0.0055167228,
-0.045224186,
0.0444297642,
-0.0193564463,
-0.0306799319,
-0.0510959253,
0.0197716001,
-0.0090209758,
0.0941076204,
0.0482985713,
-0.0275614653,
-0.0367824286,
-0.0390482992,
0.0321879797,
-0.0528685898,
-0.0005456449,
0.0219712052,
0.0037744488,
0.0233358033,
0.0154536553,
-0.0199049413,
0.0157569926,
0.0307287462,
-0.0049874717,
0.031349048,
-0.0280264933,
0.0176958367,
-0.0067498735,
-0.1104426458,
0.001894856,
-0.0433960594,
0.0591344163,
-0.0371714011,
-0.0571003035,
-0.0074147717,
-0.0258819107,
-0.0268656779,
-0.0316717364,
-0.0236140192,
0.0247196164,
0.0156394709,
-0.0044906763,
-0.0197988637,
-0.0155412266,
-0.0571389385,
-0.0125251692,
0.0382342339,
-0.0344957225,
-0.0432502776,
0.0220941007,
-0.0013559588,
0.0577243082,
-0.0798613802,
-0.0273399111,
2.608337246e-34,
0.0397696383,
0.013373469,
-0.0049428977,
0.029540766,
0.0348186679,
0.0025634998,
-0.0432515033,
0.0393933617,
0.0437649228,
-0.0740536153,
-0.0148562053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08624v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08624v1 | Challenges in Annotating Datasets to Quantify Bias in Under-represented Society | 2023-09-11T22:24:39 | 2023-09-11T22:24:39 | Vithya Yogarajan, Gillian Dobbie, Timothy Pistotti, Joshua Bensemann, Kobe Knowles | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advances in artificial intelligence, including the development of
highly sophisticated large language models (LLM), have proven beneficial in
many real-world applications. However, evidence of inherent bias encoded in
these LLMs has raised concerns about equity. In response, there has been an
increase in research dealing with bias, including studies focusing on
quantifying bias and developing debiasing techniques. Benchmark bias datasets
have also been developed for binary gender classification and ethical/racial
considerations, focusing predominantly on American demographics. However, there
is minimal research in understanding and quantifying bias related to
under-represented societies. Motivated by the lack of annotated datasets for
quantifying bias in under-represented societies, we endeavoured to create
benchmark datasets for the New Zealand (NZ) population. We faced many
challenges in this process, despite the availability of three annotators. This
research outlines the manual annotation process, provides an overview of the
challenges we encountered and lessons learnt, and presents recommendations for
future research. | [
0.0130551858,
0.0763231516,
-0.0292763561,
-0.0008887385,
-0.0002842265,
0.0572966747,
0.0729953945,
-0.025683511,
0.0487251878,
-0.0627910271,
0.0230650473,
-0.0260357354,
0.0255632959,
-0.0216978658,
-0.0001388193,
-0.0489321128,
0.0170381349,
0.0337325074,
0.0758581311,
-0.0490946881,
0.0028813633,
0.0412628092,
0.0112621086,
0.0806101039,
-0.0303226784,
0.0166199878,
0.0644107759,
-0.0042293225,
0.0136093153,
-0.0039807088,
0.0216082018,
0.0591904409,
-0.0407245234,
0.0508027077,
0.0000016817,
-0.0685524195,
0.0436917096,
-0.000347284,
-0.0294647031,
0.0186460465,
0.0444950052,
0.0034852203,
-0.0064923661,
0.0521056727,
-0.0149477068,
-0.0066458094,
0.064815484,
-0.0484236106,
0.0291240942,
0.0010309247,
-0.0011128969,
-0.0129643874,
-0.0336561538,
-0.0109715974,
-0.0107118879,
0.0251662787,
0.0667966083,
-0.0032906097,
-0.0446834005,
-0.0480874516,
-0.0249003563,
0.0019580093,
-0.0019691186,
-0.005381315,
0.0016886173,
0.0074323807,
-0.0605145693,
-0.0415173247,
0.0244475156,
0.0314768553,
0.0408796147,
-0.0025633178,
-0.0010949798,
-0.0028902369,
0.0163312517,
-0.01129111,
-0.0257283449,
0.0357431844,
-0.0046265428,
0.015033151,
0.0176141821,
0.0160709955,
0.0051836637,
0.0438640304,
-0.013983774,
0.0491770282,
0.0182591062,
0.00764244,
-0.0058347341,
0.0247016679,
0.0110822944,
-0.0361354463,
0.0267688986,
-0.0182162784,
0.0061530746,
0.0113790249,
-0.0000225173,
-0.0304457676,
0.0456911698,
-0.0521595366,
0.0121120596,
0.0233970247,
-0.0352538787,
0.0072218906,
0.0373064689,
0.0003252387,
0.0307135358,
0.0044871802,
0.0037482916,
-0.0051366626,
0.007982444,
0.0117252497,
0.0190622658,
-0.0233248007,
-0.0185708608,
0.0710988715,
-0.0516028255,
-0.0168597214,
-0.0638387129,
0.0028092158,
-0.0155440401,
-0.0257317442,
-0.0078549394,
0.0202892739,
-0.024427006,
0.0292674843,
-0.0218821838,
0.0505765527,
-0.0491289236,
-0.0905892625,
0.0486251786,
0.0203657057,
-0.011655584,
-0.0291534737,
-0.0104416525,
0.0309779644,
0.0400299802,
0.0009218065,
-0.0385442115,
-0.0140566984,
-0.0152187208,
-0.012449434,
-0.0169271883,
-0.0492310971,
0.0461138077,
0.0279312059,
0.0063150995,
-0.0562959649,
-0.0168952476,
0.0145857846,
-0.0342344344,
0.0185131244,
-0.0055008889,
0.015285789,
0.0914961994,
0.0039468762,
0.0180139616,
0.075138621,
0.036363177,
-0.0240776353,
0.050044924,
-0.0151126366,
-0.0126403738,
0.0269911401,
0.0176453162,
0.050794106,
-0.0507778898,
0.01502553,
-0.039720457,
0.0008976664,
0.0799205005,
0.0303589255,
-0.0030703656,
-0.0230116695,
0.0218514372,
0.0803671479,
-0.010830747,
0.0044381148,
-0.0039693071,
0.0219139848,
-0.0175511241,
-0.0296943411,
-0.0718567222,
-0.0134707913,
0.0142696649,
-0.0465770811,
0.0060307728,
0.0287329406,
-0.013669583,
-0.0254733562,
-0.0070124515,
0.0154918805,
0.0422763191,
0.0097303204,
0.0240252651,
-0.0287744906,
0.0214749407,
0.0316594169,
0.0530997515,
-0.0300844815,
0.0110763405,
-0.0490747169,
0.0275400579,
0.0280609224,
-0.0360056981,
-0.0250856653,
0.0303980652,
-0.0315802693,
-0.0116397683,
0.0808421597,
0.0400278792,
-0.01529162,
-0.0208219141,
-0.0335026272,
-0.0266657639,
0.0330954529,
0.0336424373,
0.0212890469,
0.0362533778,
0.0040782518,
0.0256052446,
-0.0329059549,
-0.0853086039,
0.0342341177,
0.0026598377,
-0.0253911316,
-0.0081979232,
-0.0004217553,
0.0151405912,
0.0380528867,
-0.0514336564,
0.001786817,
-0.0449693128,
0.0103759626,
0.0375488661,
-0.0047092559,
-0.017902093,
0.0110266227,
0.0219448227,
-0.0960081369,
-0.014595164,
0.0384281352,
-0.0115133161,
0.0029383239,
0.0174448192,
0.0080715446,
0.0362033546,
-0.030627409,
-0.0198642574,
-0.0553899556,
0.0119243534,
-0.0364602879,
0.021545954,
-0.0321866795,
-0.0172460414,
0.0044445335,
-0.0686215237,
0.0356454067,
-0.0328690372,
-0.0345886499,
-0.0055179112,
-0.0055045472,
0.0347341485,
0.0215800162,
-0.0173831861,
0.0053399499,
-0.0094511751,
-0.0812041685,
-0.0336519033,
-0.0219113156,
-0.0186620485,
-0.0227327328,
-0.0021571191,
-0.0235726275,
-0.0279415045,
-0.0088440599,
-0.0215559453,
0.009277951,
0.0446965285,
-0.0047157416,
-0.0115290172,
-0.0093884356,
-0.0218534674,
-0.0661393851,
-0.0351290442,
0.0442189164,
0.0386246517,
-0.0344019718,
-0.0218518469,
-0.0128643923,
-0.0167906359,
-0.0106659988,
-0.0066134194,
-0.001680118,
0.0184205268,
0.0618280768,
-0.0149086872,
0.0457910709,
0.0265148319,
0.0079048695,
0.0596809387,
0.0057178074,
-0.031887833,
-0.0450220816,
0.0039557707,
0.0399024561,
-0.0161883738,
-0.0797378942,
-0.0294417366,
0.0642220005,
0.0079940194,
-0.0314571969,
-0.0171103124,
0.0317722745,
-0.0828997493,
-0.0422184169,
-0.0522712283,
-0.0415469222,
-0.017572565,
0.0347087421,
-0.0476121753,
-0.0702214912,
-0.0034114362,
0.0273043122,
0.0621250831,
-0.0313122794,
-0.0043374021,
-0.0389130525,
0.0080871312,
0.0047689993,
0.0342736319,
-0.0099997921,
-0.0279250573,
-0.0189388581,
-0.0342994668,
0.0225178674,
-0.0290499292,
0.0403104238,
-0.0167711098,
0.00965147,
-0.0324072875,
-0.0281723216,
-0.021888962,
-0.0581511185,
-0.0396437943,
0.0120863728,
0.0458107963,
-0.0066262577,
-0.0044044633,
0.042776376,
-0.0109288041,
0.0206978917,
0.0135206152,
0.0322648659,
0.0158385914,
-0.0476316363,
0.0095976945,
0.0136754597,
0.0576140583,
-0.0241190102,
-0.0249509998,
-0.0305485614,
0.0087670628,
0.0574328825,
0.0308683738,
0.0044024657,
0.035021849,
-0.0619699955,
-0.0172452312,
0.0100747412,
0.0273287017,
-0.0254345015,
0.0416360833,
0.0994919166,
0.0088960202,
-0.0656457022,
0.0228744056,
-0.0289318506,
0.0175190438,
0.0467557162,
0.0025548714,
-0.1088810712,
0.0284838136,
0.0201360807,
0.0319684073,
-0.0844684467,
-0.0648358613,
0.0216450971,
-0.1001290977,
0.0383030809,
0.0210474581,
-0.0127839306,
-0.0020375685,
-0.0171695724,
-0.0006440486,
-0.0284858663,
0.0378587171,
-0.0189154875,
0.0253326669,
0.0089535639,
0.0340564735,
-0.0989818648,
-0.0603807196,
0.0033591934,
-0.0590793304,
0.0684382766,
0.0044175293,
0.05180135,
-0.0541481525,
0.0406385921,
0.0274523571,
-0.021542944,
-0.0431307591,
-0.0047564935,
0.0462824404,
-0.0138507187,
-0.0388508216,
-0.0508186109,
0.0399750583,
0.0479294732,
0.0060262154,
0.0202353206,
0.0092154602,
0.0212158933,
0.0036690608,
-0.0175491534,
-0.0121538471,
0.0171839148,
0.0664325804,
0.0503366999,
-0.0366153903,
0.0183399934,
-0.0623020492,
-0.0031161625,
0.0171938948,
-0.0561086573,
0.0562574118,
0.0319626629,
-0.0144386487,
0.0187861752,
-0.0694931224,
0.0366430506,
0.0130141992,
0.0375217535,
-0.0377048589,
0.0520803817,
-0.0454427786,
-0.0419174507,
0.0209573917,
-0.0519697927,
0.0163891781,
0.0271524899,
-0.0291000362,
-0.0172525756,
-0.0149486745,
-0.0246590897,
-0.0161955822,
-0.0014172021,
-0.0232736301,
0.1034659818,
-0.0076424046,
0.0262861047,
0.0043505859,
0.0028225863,
-0.0959321111,
0.0693023801,
0.0288072322,
-0.010807748,
0.018803129,
-0.0161532257,
0.0061328411,
-0.0098030819,
0.0068538706,
-0.0432046801,
0.0453996547,
0.025565125,
-0.031645827,
-0.0376653187,
0.0060142921,
-0.01644844,
0.0064652823,
0.0140434289,
-0.0529388525,
-0.0053213462,
-0.0767877847,
-0.0337032825,
-0.0009863998,
-0.0275056325,
-0.0096741319,
-0.0440487005,
0.0544262528,
0.0262057129,
-0.0564438589,
-0.0179949533,
-0.0543223508,
0.0191027652,
-0.0569585487,
0.1056520715,
0.0302269366,
0.0516067594,
-0.0105693582,
-0.0327609405,
-0.0046171634,
0.0293384735,
-0.0175219718,
0.0450997017,
0.0466042161,
-0.0066126501,
0.0091332532,
0.016690813,
-0.0032908104,
-0.0096112965,
-0.018491054,
-0.003126258,
-0.0207922775,
0.0022486849,
0.0309344996,
-0.0364574492,
0.0405906811,
0.0334592499,
-0.0288650244,
-0.0074665463,
-0.0035654656,
0.0165901221,
-0.006935074,
0.0258617699,
-0.008255898,
-0.0240763389,
0.0359702334,
0.040485967,
0.0422299057,
0.0551806577,
0.00918369,
-0.04604242,
0.0121572055,
-0.0462314934,
0.0373287387,
-0.0185772497,
-0.0294239093,
-0.066440396,
-0.0858868659,
-0.0589326397,
-0.0246582553,
0.0066948021,
0.0070705772,
-0.0065067853,
-0.0324753001,
0.0093281241,
-0.0325658508,
-0.031027779,
-0.0262580905,
-0.0437827371,
-0.0827549025,
0.0018041505,
0.0202505793,
-5.457309666e-33,
-0.0381828137,
-0.0334824361,
-0.0122075528,
-0.0248841308,
-0.0128984526,
0.0153270345,
0.0252842251,
0.0073818238,
-0.051925417,
0.0339698344,
0.0151184015,
0.0124599161,
0.0236215889,
0.0039981971,
0.0291107241,
-0.0065928674,
0.0299422313,
0.0341997258,
-0.0144677488,
0.0121186785,
-0.0337818824,
-0.0158728864,
0.0384423696,
-0.0495024845,
0.0693529174,
0.0031190908,
0.0040058303,
0.0160974525,
0.0148152197,
0.029216636,
-0.0169562101,
0.1041181087,
0.0201507155,
-0.0278558433,
-0.0016612337,
0.0588329732,
-0.0301442835,
-0.0363011062,
0.02869693,
0.0146990474,
0.0637535751,
-0.0098906904,
0.0277643856,
0.0335258469,
-0.079131946,
-0.0138246613,
0.0507260747,
-0.0156043861,
0.0519105308,
0.0300463159,
-0.0377781801,
0.040009696,
-0.0468852222,
0.0820874572,
-0.0120272608,
0.0315280221,
-0.0004655597,
0.0063027935,
-0.0361691676,
0.0210506897,
0.0488992408,
-0.0119103892,
0.0569796152,
0.027821986,
0.0081828954,
0.0444968268,
0.0948990062,
0.0382312015,
-0.002115828,
-0.0612369366,
0.0568204597,
-0.0559620783,
0.0016844252,
0.0933643132,
0.0338585451,
-0.0181538519,
-0.0432101078,
-0.0354016498,
0.0417735986,
-0.0066415882,
0.0362191759,
-0.042415902,
-0.0760670006,
-0.0686244667,
-0.0798945725,
-0.0832397491,
0.0049854317,
0.0064889984,
0.0451602787,
-0.0008391953,
-0.0072914488,
0.0416223705,
0.0343218222,
-0.0487169772,
-0.029955402,
0.0098977871,
-0.0053021871,
-0.0174032599,
0.0087489495,
-0.0007514347,
-0.0552403741,
-0.0231217332,
0.0119028818,
0.0293359291,
0.029767191,
0.0088992715,
0.005311104,
-0.0047717937,
-0.0724567324,
0.0139401648,
0.0147516252,
-0.0218896847,
-0.0101115257,
0.0194407199,
0.027758643,
0.0037064294,
0.0382118151,
-0.0178992897,
0.0382031649,
0.0120167695,
-0.0100585958,
-0.0317154564,
-0.0312436316,
0.0157988593,
-0.0298170652,
-0.0221955124,
0.0492463186,
0.0370927043,
0.043849811,
-0.0233372487,
-0.0054189675,
-0.0428723209,
2.142e-7,
0.048008658,
0.0697804689,
-0.0129923429,
-0.0311920866,
-0.0077132727,
0.0058161435,
0.0592418537,
0.0190607049,
0.0499267429,
0.0004788221,
-0.003645828,
0.0142774144,
-0.0034489178,
0.023240881,
-0.0745050013,
0.0134930192,
-0.0783105567,
0.0248735361,
-0.0588077642,
0.0050558886,
-0.0187158026,
0.0597181581,
0.0057860115,
-0.0176237673,
-0.0317363851,
-0.011845042,
-0.0081591224,
-0.0740642399,
-0.0018667568,
0.0247985087,
0.0304797459,
-0.000972125,
0.0507414006,
0.049829863,
-0.0117563503,
0.0444594659,
0.0021910688,
0.0410056114,
-0.0378769487,
0.0383539572,
-0.0145198824,
0.0194915179,
-0.0143905785,
-0.0628151074,
0.0416499749,
0.0190371275,
-0.0525608249,
-0.0659775957,
-0.0330373459,
-0.0374699421,
0.0627750605,
-0.0126903439,
0.032886032,
-0.0361278728,
0.0436422601,
0.0002554469,
-0.0032719623,
-0.0193791762,
-0.0243780408,
-0.017119674,
-0.0123227891,
-0.0716025382,
0.0217541549,
0.0402618237,
-0.0179165415,
-0.0113671655,
0.0724954382,
1.707811687e-34,
0.0395832248,
0.0177587699,
0.0192586724,
-0.0039812606,
0.0365340225,
0.0171148274,
0.0070743747,
-0.0173013676,
0.0061962111,
-0.0233658552,
0.0258751009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07062v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.07062v1 | Large Language Models for Compiler Optimization | 2023-09-11T22:11:46 | 2023-09-11T22:11:46 | Chris Cummins, Volker Seeker, Dejan Grubisic, Mostafa Elhoushi, Youwei Liang, Baptiste Roziere, Jonas Gehring, Fabian Gloeckle, Kim Hazelwood, Gabriel Synnaeve, Hugh Leather | cs.PL | cs.PL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | We explore the novel application of Large Language Models to code
optimization. We present a 7B-parameter transformer model trained from scratch
to optimize LLVM assembly for code size. The model takes as input unoptimized
assembly and outputs a list of compiler options to best optimize the program.
Crucially, during training, we ask the model to predict the instruction counts
before and after optimization, and the optimized code itself. These auxiliary
learning tasks significantly improve the optimization performance of the model
and improve the model's depth of understanding.
We evaluate on a large suite of test programs. Our approach achieves a 3.0%
improvement in reducing instruction counts over the compiler, outperforming two
state-of-the-art baselines that require thousands of compilations. Furthermore,
the model shows surprisingly strong code reasoning abilities, generating
compilable code 91% of the time and perfectly emulating the output of the
compiler 70% of the time. | [
-0.0095285121,
0.0978283808,
-0.0041501075,
0.0156740434,
-0.0067984005,
0.0272668079,
-0.0022077884,
-0.0108816819,
-0.0142269116,
-0.001674119,
0.0095960638,
0.0186004676,
-0.0336502343,
-0.015099261,
0.009702215,
0.0027484507,
0.0245321784,
-0.0356471539,
-0.067814745,
0.0122802639,
-0.0546883829,
0.0174907818,
0.0215994306,
0.0158307776,
0.0112395044,
0.0027314511,
-0.0020299931,
0.0654174164,
-0.0000278235,
0.0353835188,
-0.0101987962,
0.0098720482,
0.0313072801,
-0.0320993252,
0.0000021661,
0.0073218755,
0.0162010305,
0.0298505519,
-0.0294714421,
0.057237152,
0.0294142533,
-0.021896679,
0.0005145998,
0.0384816341,
0.0094223497,
-0.0262296032,
0.0395836383,
-0.0152697358,
0.0652668476,
0.0570805185,
0.0169813056,
-0.0621601008,
0.002886306,
0.0038506989,
0.0085317492,
0.0002692791,
0.0028839379,
0.0063582342,
-0.0107512483,
-0.0016328464,
-0.0051883021,
0.0200374313,
0.024275545,
-0.0005871191,
-0.0289770607,
0.0221483763,
-0.0262825545,
0.0040957355,
-0.0224039126,
0.0257277861,
-0.0974161476,
-0.0410434902,
0.0407696404,
-0.0047679623,
-0.001904307,
-0.0199152194,
-0.024865564,
0.060545329,
0.0022834041,
-0.0022541182,
0.0126169845,
-0.0321464352,
0.028700918,
-0.0155989816,
-0.0225133356,
0.0774925947,
0.0236679241,
0.0127362851,
-0.0191951077,
-0.031234825,
-0.0243051723,
-0.0288469847,
-0.0301277749,
0.0728380978,
-0.0044753882,
0.0248831734,
-0.0322674811,
0.0079053268,
0.0075139557,
-0.079879716,
0.0417481549,
0.0636612773,
-0.0199519712,
0.0045855315,
-0.0858044326,
0.0405874848,
-0.0658679083,
-0.0230622012,
-0.0292071961,
0.0172476005,
-0.0056516821,
0.0163371824,
-0.0393039845,
0.0363739319,
-0.0241105389,
0.0666975752,
-0.050207369,
0.0179135613,
0.0119874338,
0.0330641642,
0.0273685511,
0.0123689035,
-0.0072421166,
-0.0277594868,
0.0306785945,
0.004134397,
-0.0239293464,
-0.0496040843,
-0.0612001233,
-0.0621830299,
-0.0100660576,
0.0297766607,
-0.0369467959,
-0.0477052815,
0.0458269641,
0.0773603842,
-0.008514476,
0.0213405471,
-0.0478059165,
-0.030738553,
-0.0017847327,
-0.055147212,
0.0054422896,
-0.0785808042,
-0.0353242457,
-0.015228251,
0.0153931379,
-0.0308965724,
0.0303961281,
-0.0204828214,
0.0002713878,
0.0487443097,
0.0483916812,
0.0027315456,
0.0153106591,
0.0287268776,
0.0196258668,
0.0346806087,
0.0296834279,
0.0316412114,
-0.0297809299,
-0.0601990223,
0.0109953349,
0.0293770302,
-0.0299753193,
0.0047460073,
-0.0134512894,
0.0274827834,
-0.0111246733,
-0.0109176701,
0.0315692946,
0.0461753234,
-0.0026252226,
-0.0497044697,
-0.0227608811,
0.0062113353,
-0.0112796752,
0.0706298724,
0.0623539798,
0.0480990894,
-0.0201165136,
-0.0246915109,
-0.0341755114,
0.0762438253,
-0.0007178367,
0.0074596805,
0.0055397362,
0.0490578935,
-0.0256022643,
-0.0462931879,
-0.0012314178,
-0.030504033,
-0.0079404972,
0.014357035,
0.0097386334,
-0.0193464607,
-0.0725566596,
0.0754357129,
0.0271906033,
-0.0540886261,
-0.0618274286,
-0.0531603992,
0.0316909812,
-0.0022315248,
0.0088322386,
-0.03895583,
-0.0446693711,
-0.001934948,
0.0133643467,
-0.0246927291,
0.0150718093,
0.0044207349,
0.0243051723,
-0.0375013612,
0.0121630738,
-0.0285640005,
0.0184952989,
0.0697140768,
0.035193,
-0.0463837162,
0.0394638479,
-0.0015158821,
-0.044383727,
0.0261306521,
0.0176405311,
-0.0499791093,
0.0239792112,
0.0198610164,
0.0389347337,
-0.0646868274,
-0.0405802131,
-0.0194889065,
0.0861932933,
-0.0391279384,
-0.0150870606,
-0.0501148961,
-0.0531785861,
-0.0117144557,
0.0327464305,
-0.0534891076,
0.0262884591,
-0.0075612231,
-0.0481282733,
-0.035652265,
0.0703440309,
-0.0683274493,
0.0405615941,
0.0097878492,
0.027221011,
-0.0259627085,
0.0034554934,
-0.0571054369,
0.0551100299,
0.0166644529,
-0.0086851632,
0.0022620508,
0.0181341544,
0.0245083775,
0.0521014221,
-0.0033982187,
0.0023396329,
-0.0134684835,
0.0158963669,
-0.0130434828,
0.0068623424,
0.0034312424,
-0.0602424778,
-0.1176031828,
0.0485522971,
-0.0138272922,
0.0001233509,
0.0018898563,
0.0287659392,
0.0442337804,
-0.01438272,
-0.0113852657,
0.004928859,
-0.0068471446,
-0.0125057055,
0.0082450388,
-0.0133739682,
-0.072882019,
-0.0275088623,
-0.0301572811,
-0.0324471146,
0.0312986784,
-0.0257560201,
0.0217058808,
-0.0695988834,
0.0613651983,
0.0258090328,
0.0374316573,
-0.0298141371,
-0.0567060709,
-0.0420046262,
-0.046658136,
0.0224131476,
0.0738838464,
-0.0183407106,
0.0009899768,
0.0890489891,
0.0161046404,
-0.0817310512,
0.0477629006,
-0.0095759006,
-0.0678986758,
-0.0025577887,
-0.0372895412,
-0.0179900676,
0.0801883563,
0.0053384355,
-0.0227314346,
-0.0286959689,
0.0058064689,
0.0316682756,
-0.0131425699,
0.0323099457,
0.0032805845,
0.0019735445,
0.0105086854,
0.0071113282,
-0.056020841,
0.0607698001,
-0.0320292972,
-0.0151622854,
0.019371843,
-0.023687657,
-0.0830596611,
0.0098854061,
0.0234497543,
0.0159219317,
-0.0286534932,
0.0117021259,
-0.0202696193,
0.0414304845,
-0.0257587377,
-0.0059677702,
0.0792696625,
-0.0392189585,
0.0058457456,
0.0116397068,
-0.0232965965,
-0.0264054257,
-0.0021041615,
-0.0096817669,
0.0093775364,
0.042162396,
-0.05580993,
0.0066900444,
0.0120211141,
0.034119688,
0.014397217,
0.0045698173,
-0.0280092321,
0.0012913854,
-0.0336224921,
-0.0004901494,
-0.007685076,
0.003045612,
-0.0172324236,
-0.0241651125,
-0.0123331388,
0.0347056426,
0.0299350023,
-0.0766682774,
0.0077211349,
0.0679267645,
-0.0056518773,
-0.0575163923,
0.055115737,
0.0449578725,
-0.082988508,
-0.0285426434,
0.0912720561,
0.0286059305,
-0.0201301835,
0.0294547528,
-0.0055689062,
0.0425017066,
0.0541726202,
0.0839497596,
-0.0632086322,
-0.0506757312,
-0.0137296692,
-0.0215446092,
0.0046380907,
0.0155334156,
-0.0204642769,
-0.0780889243,
0.0346243232,
0.0195478275,
0.033597447,
-0.0228609443,
-0.0392906182,
-0.0418536551,
-0.0135812731,
-0.0365496427,
0.0215121824,
-0.0147415632,
-0.0120855905,
0.0026623486,
-0.0101611242,
0.0207025353,
0.0519633926,
0.0206242446,
0.0063389158,
0.0696804971,
0.0169631764,
-0.003742645,
-0.0414538197,
0.0521062501,
-0.0088157831,
0.0361698866,
-0.0362706669,
0.0285342578,
0.0340417288,
-0.0071474318,
0.0350406505,
0.0007287593,
-0.0287135225,
0.0369995013,
0.0291431267,
0.0705114454,
-0.0086048394,
-0.0418963097,
0.0134656886,
-0.0258551873,
-0.0366598703,
0.0194659997,
0.0188321006,
-0.0145256566,
-0.0415006801,
-0.0760226771,
-0.051041998,
-0.0304458793,
-0.0140319727,
-0.007575749,
-0.0259501357,
-0.0043239705,
0.0124727795,
0.0744977444,
0.002867874,
0.0154672852,
0.0356082395,
-0.0864033103,
0.0363571346,
-0.0031154491,
-0.0815831497,
0.0300743543,
-0.0174541585,
0.0180360936,
-0.063181594,
-0.0014804072,
0.0374197066,
0.0029538495,
0.0084438091,
0.0000910846,
-0.0798324272,
-0.0641514063,
-0.0259013101,
0.1221450716,
0.0131851947,
0.0635119528,
-0.0191812124,
-0.0498986244,
-0.0340957791,
0.0184310097,
0.0004862905,
0.0217453055,
0.0336811766,
-0.041528102,
0.0230585113,
-0.0168731138,
-0.0213884953,
0.0230033286,
0.0750559941,
-0.0638891608,
-0.0357830413,
-0.0269656498,
-0.0017571872,
0.0351600386,
-0.0171096753,
0.0149164172,
0.0069515109,
0.0258634351,
0.0408437587,
0.0039225114,
0.0141069498,
-0.0375394337,
0.0252111834,
0.0308655389,
-0.0187760722,
0.0106130429,
-0.0089099202,
-0.0137890615,
0.0351546369,
0.0140697183,
0.0664405525,
-0.0254366659,
0.0092273047,
0.094519183,
0.0079500396,
-0.0174111649,
0.0423563644,
0.0538648479,
0.0469641164,
-0.0083650248,
0.0140025709,
0.0063516046,
0.0580495894,
-0.0506636873,
-0.0019949628,
-0.0065077073,
-0.0763410553,
-0.029012097,
0.0007415728,
0.0356825739,
-0.0028430731,
0.0269497707,
0.0069129993,
0.0021410645,
-0.0167629961,
0.0304296277,
-0.0231811889,
-0.0286583062,
0.0278329533,
0.0438103713,
-0.0395337492,
-0.0335556976,
0.0584868714,
0.0323806889,
0.0375807248,
0.004730023,
0.0114010852,
-0.0374800935,
-0.0003023019,
-0.0070168879,
-0.0419173464,
0.0166655648,
0.021141829,
-0.010385694,
-0.01889107,
-0.0017298291,
0.0111737633,
0.0361375175,
-0.0185665805,
0.0198958367,
0.0328054577,
0.0105749955,
-0.0568223223,
-0.0293783341,
-0.0082560768,
0.0215111487,
-0.0245519411,
0.0154945496,
-6.009348261e-33,
-0.0186862983,
-0.0070888116,
0.0035778848,
0.0316480063,
0.0084243007,
-0.0224889908,
-0.0508289449,
-0.0220082421,
-0.012162609,
-0.0096685402,
0.0071766344,
-0.0048223864,
-0.0021561647,
-0.0207167119,
0.0325454213,
0.0286387056,
0.0419966131,
0.0300251078,
-0.0549704321,
0.0319302417,
-0.0186683908,
0.0261956193,
-0.0002844305,
-0.0189406201,
-0.0724222139,
0.0230837967,
0.0504531153,
0.0132912043,
0.0010690581,
0.0269931257,
0.0145360306,
-0.0172777623,
-0.0212314725,
-0.0446412452,
-0.0075003654,
-0.0078200577,
-0.0332476534,
-0.0362381451,
0.0407606289,
0.0432113111,
0.0337642059,
-0.0900919884,
0.0164819825,
0.0567753576,
-0.0270305593,
-0.0262326952,
0.0076515228,
-0.0052281208,
0.0040763617,
-0.0445732027,
-0.0529486611,
0.0051155169,
-0.0099844597,
-0.0059439014,
0.037583746,
0.027483372,
-0.028540669,
0.0376928374,
0.0343472399,
0.004050761,
0.0292642564,
0.0670266375,
0.1009742543,
0.0186199248,
0.0159358401,
-0.0181648377,
0.0186520834,
0.005731978,
-0.0724992082,
0.0133252386,
0.0201232079,
0.0730859935,
0.0254898723,
-0.0068807146,
0.0180173833,
0.0243800543,
-0.0678182393,
-0.0146054951,
0.0280124974,
0.045839265,
0.0120429825,
0.0192355514,
0.0189328119,
-0.0217694417,
-0.0664692596,
0.0349772349,
-0.0395154543,
-0.0027219299,
-0.0035913645,
0.0066856197,
-0.0590317659,
-0.0142668327,
0.0319319889,
-0.0168886613,
0.0238068029,
0.0420636348,
-0.0074383779,
-0.0131135536,
0.0046446486,
0.0335646681,
-0.0184251294,
-0.0469051227,
-0.0009786787,
-0.0507655367,
0.0963104367,
-0.007207952,
0.0072217761,
0.0328020155,
-0.0688440651,
-0.0047182147,
-0.0785159692,
-0.0317916609,
-0.0141650895,
0.0501657426,
-0.0106211361,
0.0297800917,
-0.0003567652,
0.0235266201,
-0.0398358665,
-0.0168043282,
-0.0026235241,
0.0010451326,
0.037357837,
0.0453240089,
-0.0603339002,
-0.0278360713,
-0.0120015722,
0.0243840888,
-0.0097050257,
-0.0465986021,
-0.0722241551,
0.0365422741,
2.883e-7,
-0.0101494631,
0.0492715426,
-0.0297972858,
0.0544998199,
-0.0150996335,
0.0398820192,
-0.0000384619,
0.0000660025,
0.0111140013,
-0.009695136,
0.016036028,
0.0249957461,
0.0552262478,
0.006370109,
-0.0108063156,
0.0316742584,
0.0265116878,
0.013867666,
-0.0343239047,
-0.03964312,
-0.0097907837,
0.0900466964,
-0.0078975093,
-0.0161703341,
0.0216120202,
0.0014033039,
-0.0058350717,
-0.0300461259,
-0.014757663,
0.0094765723,
-0.0289478768,
0.0063884058,
-0.0521381125,
-0.0189849082,
-0.0287228655,
-0.0207724422,
-0.0309468266,
0.108029522,
-0.000134798,
0.0124185383,
0.0829357952,
-0.0137621658,
-0.0320399851,
-0.019137444,
0.0479528047,
-0.052554965,
0.0077393432,
-0.027210189,
-0.0274212621,
0.0149427624,
-0.0299440119,
-0.0357031189,
0.05934209,
0.0014806394,
0.0035968856,
-0.0737861544,
-0.0062995898,
-0.0451110862,
-0.0795087516,
0.0413798168,
-0.0160121303,
-0.0333171487,
-0.0336160287,
0.0157438014,
-0.0019536086,
-0.0340494029,
0.0033548176,
2.799502704e-34,
0.0388249718,
-0.0247701611,
0.0180348773,
0.0680442452,
0.0332111269,
-0.0126696117,
-0.0523379222,
0.0363242254,
-0.0114630191,
-0.0501213409,
-0.026285857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05833v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05833v3 | PACE-LM: Prompting and Augmentation for Calibrated Confidence Estimation with GPT-4 in Cloud Incident Root Cause Analysis | 2023-09-11T21:24:00 | 2023-09-29T16:25:16 | Dylan Zhang, Xuchao Zhang, Chetan Bansal, Pedro Las-Casas, Rodrigo Fonseca, Saravan Rajmohan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SE | Major cloud providers have employed advanced AI-based solutions like large
language models to aid humans in identifying the root causes of cloud
incidents. Despite the growing prevalence of AI-driven assistants in the root
cause analysis process, their effectiveness in assisting on-call engineers is
constrained by low accuracy due to the intrinsic difficulty of the task, a
propensity for LLM-based approaches to hallucinate, and difficulties in
distinguishing these well-disguised hallucinations. To address this challenge,
we propose to perform confidence estimation for the predictions to help on-call
engineers make decisions on whether to adopt the model prediction. Considering
the black-box nature of many LLM-based root cause predictors, fine-tuning or
temperature-scaling-based approaches are inapplicable. We therefore design an
innovative confidence estimation framework based on prompting
retrieval-augmented large language models (LLMs) that demand a minimal amount
of information from the root cause predictor. This approach consists of two
scoring phases: the LLM-based confidence estimator first evaluates its
confidence in making judgments in the face of the current incident that
reflects its ``grounded-ness" level in reference data, then rates the root
cause prediction based on historical references. An optimization step combines
these two scores for a final confidence assignment. We show that our method is
able to produce calibrated confidence estimates for predicted root causes,
validate the usefulness of retrieved historical data and the prompting strategy
as well as the generalizability across different root cause prediction models.
Our study takes an important move towards reliably and effectively embedding
LLMs into cloud incident management systems. | [
0.0123470463,
0.055779703,
-0.0044001341,
0.0295014326,
-0.0395841524,
-0.023083549,
-0.0127369231,
-0.040767055,
0.0073761544,
0.0035608127,
0.0667154491,
-0.0410954319,
-0.0207383782,
0.0818424001,
0.0023412996,
-0.0157855842,
0.0156622734,
-0.0268134531,
0.0437664427,
0.0042592157,
0.0018180434,
0.0050046239,
0.0029058608,
0.0434114449,
-0.0258310754,
-0.0059049921,
-0.009633908,
0.015392716,
0.0043614204,
-0.0304640718,
0.0192808229,
0.0078530796,
0.0249060467,
0.0384463668,
0.0000021543,
-0.0526256748,
-0.0310743768,
0.0010442676,
-0.0775608122,
-0.014892566,
-0.0217977762,
0.0060095335,
-0.0114383129,
0.0383368991,
-0.0329163559,
0.0333292522,
0.0336478986,
0.0533327013,
0.0611042231,
0.0457739867,
-0.0120208533,
0.001107956,
0.0071011609,
0.0169998705,
0.013110484,
-0.0445061624,
0.0082451059,
0.0188815743,
0.0122685852,
-0.0050229896,
0.0294018257,
-0.0142365964,
0.0283158198,
-0.0083861221,
-0.004705389,
0.0588229895,
-0.0243584979,
-0.0009625087,
-0.0151918819,
0.0021326151,
0.0547128767,
-0.0106497761,
0.0008878261,
-0.0056949714,
-0.0053638876,
0.0196560305,
-0.0529475994,
-0.0073343972,
-0.016047867,
0.0069517251,
0.016814895,
0.0443241373,
0.0283346958,
0.0153910378,
-0.0188762061,
0.1004706025,
-0.0167970154,
-0.0375092402,
-0.0131564066,
-0.0100219473,
0.0241852049,
-0.023243567,
-0.0183830597,
0.0338020809,
-0.0948126838,
-0.0009762389,
0.0249834936,
0.0182305053,
0.0164361689,
-0.0315577947,
0.0161434449,
0.0128230229,
-0.0131342085,
0.0089607947,
0.0098063871,
0.0471840501,
-0.0018128104,
-0.0275389608,
0.022328794,
-0.0172485653,
-0.025855545,
-0.0080921706,
-0.0179299712,
-0.0118689006,
0.0095532304,
-0.0025753833,
-0.0431375317,
0.0401818268,
-0.0120473672,
0.0483388864,
-0.0032992002,
0.0005881184,
-0.0299393665,
-0.0031828994,
-0.0223457385,
-0.0433327407,
-0.0357011035,
0.0264500361,
-0.0050849752,
-0.0861807242,
-0.0189073943,
-0.0025126522,
-0.0011622974,
0.0036588607,
0.0148202674,
0.0389672332,
0.034113884,
0.0244693793,
-0.0440556295,
-0.0612268783,
0.0060059037,
-0.0338226259,
-0.066612944,
-0.0211977866,
-0.0589401498,
0.0112605905,
0.0155049711,
-0.003144701,
0.0083902162,
-0.0360959619,
-0.0323541127,
0.060577374,
-0.0765932426,
0.0211026538,
0.0221587084,
0.0126990182,
-0.0571060069,
0.0431229211,
0.0327945277,
0.037080355,
0.0412060507,
-0.0297018103,
0.1102321073,
-0.0156218931,
0.0027779634,
0.0087556364,
-0.0078583108,
0.0229488108,
-0.0158786476,
0.0059036161,
-0.0048045707,
-0.001780715,
0.0411350392,
0.0153910015,
0.0544348285,
0.0222899634,
-0.0687801242,
0.0065752408,
0.0202704631,
0.0017613863,
-0.0468337797,
-0.0224565398,
-0.0417265669,
0.0293941442,
-0.066675052,
0.0004888179,
0.0501971096,
0.0221408121,
-0.0206391737,
-0.0529758409,
0.0023686218,
0.0171568654,
-0.0800190195,
0.0062544094,
0.0289202277,
-0.0363689549,
-0.0140556265,
-0.01564987,
-0.0304372236,
-0.004777438,
-0.0332993232,
-0.0684284493,
0.0257031713,
0.0540948398,
0.0295808855,
-0.0421404094,
-0.0605491959,
-0.0337530188,
0.0204774644,
-0.0229876414,
-0.0180891845,
0.0135585386,
-0.0062218895,
-0.0344560668,
-0.0252134986,
0.0248975083,
0.0340498015,
-0.0207036138,
-0.0333516076,
-0.0069060908,
0.0093783615,
-0.0349437073,
-0.0898677185,
0.0089480039,
-0.0002139537,
-0.013635722,
-0.0073324232,
-0.0007007587,
0.0642435625,
-0.0143875955,
-0.0066217869,
0.026222147,
0.0127971619,
0.002902763,
-0.0953463316,
0.0713854209,
0.0033425416,
0.0636382326,
0.0001149755,
0.0001644277,
0.0472036079,
-0.0180772804,
-0.0504119061,
-0.0493618064,
0.0547026992,
-0.0480673797,
-0.030526394,
-0.0074901697,
0.003099767,
-0.0075626047,
-0.0081807012,
-0.0045883628,
0.039884083,
0.0323703848,
0.0012448565,
-0.0018415797,
0.0142302299,
0.033083912,
-0.0274001826,
-0.0081268037,
0.0116323913,
-0.0200907979,
0.0226832833,
0.0399609916,
-0.0496057123,
-0.0455481708,
0.0129241748,
-0.0679825321,
0.0026742481,
-0.023483986,
0.0096792597,
-0.0100642992,
0.0246803407,
-0.0498396568,
-0.025948571,
-0.0022262796,
-0.0197251849,
0.0309207421,
0.04230294,
0.0251010433,
-0.0003772034,
-0.0320223756,
-0.0195206124,
0.0110588316,
-0.0385309234,
0.0452415645,
0.0704820082,
-0.0220802967,
-0.0668298081,
0.0673794299,
-0.0364476629,
-0.0105626965,
-0.0291994344,
-0.0413197577,
-0.0017952018,
-0.0589080043,
0.0018610528,
0.0651361346,
-0.0132094203,
-0.0005584914,
-0.0011118565,
-0.0043824771,
-0.0529744551,
-0.0044561834,
-0.0367487706,
-0.0595026538,
0.0104108658,
-0.0236906335,
0.004921379,
0.0232149102,
0.0032091239,
-0.0164840426,
-0.0395398289,
0.0516408645,
-0.0218036864,
0.0026865364,
-0.0244749039,
-0.0800556913,
-0.0056952373,
0.0977447331,
0.0057042018,
-0.1126393005,
0.0503487252,
-0.0124685969,
0.0150522552,
-0.0237612016,
-0.0609236956,
-0.0177020356,
0.0287210569,
-0.0269952714,
0.0057640201,
-0.0036790476,
-0.0145601742,
0.0007292692,
-0.0088376366,
0.0131310057,
-0.0493290313,
-0.0372716598,
-0.0584777035,
0.0205279682,
0.0563120283,
-0.0246652626,
-0.0432158709,
-0.0238754824,
-0.0703942999,
-0.013357589,
-0.0348162651,
-0.0248206276,
-0.0231446568,
0.0114238271,
0.0492603332,
0.0459557958,
0.0206826311,
-0.0248759519,
-0.002877679,
-0.0662612021,
0.0062354514,
0.0129849333,
0.0372499935,
0.0070202504,
0.058207199,
-0.00504121,
0.1172385812,
-0.0251226313,
-0.0600887462,
-0.0039605284,
-0.001554717,
-0.0117770173,
-0.0106430547,
0.0480789691,
0.0321414769,
-0.0341991857,
-0.0199455824,
0.1062658057,
0.0051727449,
-0.0355472974,
-0.003485908,
-0.0341200791,
0.0089936694,
0.0397165902,
0.0295170322,
-0.0415509231,
0.0078522479,
0.0190700367,
0.0635505319,
-0.0358469971,
-0.0443012118,
0.0067630145,
-0.0894308314,
0.0773228258,
-0.0175239407,
0.036326915,
-0.0520677306,
-0.0897620693,
0.0214127321,
-0.0338690989,
-0.0085915532,
-0.0326726735,
0.0448698588,
0.0045212051,
0.0349808075,
-0.0540707149,
-0.0629354939,
0.0161904842,
-0.0601313412,
0.0437462255,
0.0642648265,
-0.0062485891,
-0.0195151903,
-0.0008716538,
0.0005555297,
0.0279350076,
0.0245433003,
0.0020945712,
0.0591609068,
0.0334758498,
0.0142431706,
0.0019129596,
0.0551532283,
-0.0640207008,
0.0055533163,
0.0431783646,
0.131426692,
-0.0683108643,
-0.0026113912,
-0.013217452,
0.0016613299,
0.059999574,
0.0424221717,
0.0053871968,
-0.0059390021,
-0.0189326704,
-0.0020572401,
0.0512744151,
0.0116828112,
-0.0056946077,
0.0337545276,
0.0203559268,
-0.0196566544,
-0.0111806002,
-0.0169459265,
0.0037778825,
0.0476420932,
0.0058034663,
0.0027626771,
0.0181884058,
0.0256465692,
-0.019395221,
0.0030890177,
-0.0116721401,
0.0564317591,
-0.0280535072,
0.0817145854,
0.0574225448,
0.0157879163,
-0.0244110338,
-0.0021740026,
-0.0029066205,
-0.0502296053,
0.0300888196,
0.054347571,
0.0378924794,
0.014794508,
-0.0369736962,
-0.0573103018,
0.0238459874,
0.001176703,
-0.0380524136,
-0.0276642907,
0.0248581842,
-0.0117699876,
-0.0044237608,
0.0087944632,
-0.0458915979,
0.0301804971,
-0.0220130049,
-0.0013265075,
-0.0616384819,
-0.0461652502,
0.0244680885,
0.0301234927,
0.0299601201,
-0.0061401897,
-0.0171768926,
-0.0048153671,
0.0091316272,
0.0079561202,
-0.0167255178,
0.0002242402,
0.0742594972,
-0.007642915,
-0.0166519899,
0.0128937913,
-0.0437920019,
-0.0277593154,
-0.0463320836,
-0.0494666584,
-0.0013117163,
0.031884905,
0.0325124301,
0.0471597165,
-0.0179306101,
0.0360479504,
-0.0120028481,
0.0405531339,
0.0581845976,
0.0322922692,
0.0558645837,
0.0203557946,
0.0168850757,
-0.0148874046,
-0.0139538869,
-0.0960982442,
-0.0878062025,
0.0059442664,
-0.0370261483,
0.0406173915,
0.0129219331,
-0.0117358239,
-0.0315016992,
0.0298923384,
-0.0042388085,
0.0305941571,
0.0484976508,
0.0047122594,
0.0079851858,
0.0067914152,
-0.0544336028,
0.0326396227,
0.0724047348,
-0.0074565085,
0.0605545416,
-0.0515055433,
-0.0571036562,
-0.0132500483,
-0.0258237105,
-0.0161142126,
0.03273331,
-0.0039722617,
-0.0088671716,
-0.0625741407,
-0.0230819546,
0.0098410621,
-0.0372607671,
-0.0161982309,
-0.0557189509,
-0.0055244551,
0.1061021909,
0.0013674486,
0.0321758725,
-0.0168990772,
-0.0049133762,
-0.0573222488,
-0.00414473,
-0.0339113101,
-6.452232656e-33,
0.0116516799,
-0.069687739,
-0.0082835974,
0.0043899906,
0.0022134895,
0.0378060453,
-0.0120995175,
0.0217611678,
0.0303001106,
0.0201099254,
-0.0226619635,
0.0290844105,
0.0344586261,
-0.0149266347,
0.0716302618,
-0.004890881,
0.0221902467,
0.0181490649,
-0.0268754493,
0.0655809492,
0.0583331548,
0.0125117237,
-0.0010948103,
-0.141474247,
0.0388770998,
-0.0204820298,
-0.0085240519,
0.0417753123,
-0.0013600235,
0.0212541986,
0.0038087175,
0.0132414782,
0.0066624871,
-0.0521569513,
-0.0018615259,
-0.0030777396,
0.0420003645,
-0.0090876538,
-0.0051646349,
-0.031095285,
0.0089983866,
-0.0366124809,
-0.0406079516,
0.011885358,
-0.0243189037,
0.0442824066,
0.0455544256,
-0.0390490331,
0.0051076687,
-0.0542238988,
-0.0017970877,
0.0132041853,
-0.0598047897,
0.0279742796,
0.0044982117,
0.0386909284,
0.0181755908,
0.0460638069,
-0.0441107936,
0.0183883663,
0.0022357691,
-0.0149794566,
0.0476445332,
-0.0027050602,
-0.0565142557,
0.0268436987,
-0.0092933029,
-0.0073444908,
-0.0496649519,
-0.0312702022,
-0.0179623477,
0.0712522715,
0.0431681462,
0.0554375611,
0.0067520891,
-0.0075023798,
-0.0431861132,
0.0559378304,
0.0322572701,
0.0230986513,
0.0915547311,
-0.0281635635,
-0.1012890637,
-0.0378179625,
-0.0224606954,
-0.0155657744,
-0.0514956415,
0.006403402,
0.0159345418,
0.0106736012,
-0.0208195429,
0.0277609415,
0.039949812,
-0.0143457288,
0.0302291811,
0.0049791322,
0.0195641182,
-0.0015790375,
-0.0041638538,
0.0438094325,
-0.0235251114,
-0.0004181688,
-0.0179904941,
0.0316537619,
0.0471250154,
0.0028206802,
0.012204417,
0.019196758,
-0.0383165106,
0.0098185688,
-0.0402689986,
0.0154063441,
-0.0314498879,
-0.0298173614,
0.0241336431,
0.0202549361,
0.00398971,
0.0122121423,
0.0322891623,
0.0316364914,
0.0057394877,
-0.0414374322,
-0.0430179164,
-0.0220310222,
-0.0325147137,
-0.0285251513,
0.0016173286,
-0.035304334,
0.0179015547,
-0.027432235,
-0.0093362937,
0.0007053924,
3.034e-7,
-0.006615235,
0.044380445,
0.0269180778,
0.0230588261,
0.0046824003,
0.0655100271,
0.0129231447,
-0.0332125872,
0.0356231853,
-0.0459457524,
0.0304545313,
-0.0176515877,
0.066176407,
0.0526200123,
-0.0139059369,
-0.0909357965,
-0.0516509116,
0.0077349273,
-0.0886858851,
0.0071389545,
0.0762659609,
0.0699724108,
0.021348631,
-0.0269356463,
0.0171750579,
-0.0236774795,
-0.0084317001,
-0.0278990567,
-0.0004905186,
0.0413382165,
0.0519616641,
0.0846114606,
0.0014205058,
0.054937914,
-0.0186668001,
-0.0090314513,
-0.0284190234,
-0.0003718945,
0.02981597,
0.0168333445,
-0.0156580228,
-0.0191375595,
0.0424950831,
-0.057161171,
0.0247124862,
-0.0163677745,
-0.0435155705,
0.037314266,
-0.0228864793,
-0.0429177508,
0.0208816826,
-0.0192323867,
-0.0158087816,
0.0161423236,
-0.0302332863,
-0.0096676806,
0.0150843598,
-0.0557595231,
-0.000342005,
0.004253407,
-0.0290544219,
-0.0257723518,
-0.0098093804,
-0.0210860875,
0.046868179,
-0.0049131196,
0.0630172268,
2.88485668e-34,
0.0325758755,
0.0285759103,
-0.0016249825,
0.0361528471,
0.053967528,
0.0281407069,
0.024220977,
0.0196153857,
0.0465865918,
-0.052378688,
-0.0153192366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05804v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05804v2 | Hi Model, generating 'nice' instead of 'good' is not as bad as generating 'rice'! Towards Context and Semantic Infused Dialogue Generation Loss Function and Evaluation Metric | 2023-09-11T20:16:38 | 2024-05-29T18:17:12 | Abhisek Tiwari, Muhammed Sinan, Kaushik Roy, Amit Sheth, Sriparna Saha, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.CL | cs.CL | Over the past two decades, dialogue modeling has made significant strides,
moving from simple rule-based responses to personalized and persuasive response
generation. However, despite these advancements, the objective functions and
evaluation metrics for dialogue generation have remained stagnant. These
lexical-based metrics, e.g., cross-entropy and BLEU, have two key limitations:
(a) word-to-word matching without semantic consideration: It assigns the same
credit for failure to generate "nice" and "rice" for "good", (b) missing
context attribute for evaluating the generated response: Even if a generated
response is relevant to the ongoing dialogue context, it may still be penalized
for not matching the gold utterance provided in the corpus. In this paper, we
first investigate these limitations comprehensively and propose a new loss
function called Semantic Infused Contextualized diaLogue (SemTextualLogue) loss
function. We also formulate an evaluation metric called Dialuation,
incorporating both context and semantic relevance. We experimented with both
non-pretrained and pre-trained models on two dialogue corpora, encompassing
task-oriented and open-domain scenarios. We found that the dialogue generation
models trained with SemTextualLogueloss attained superior performance compared
to the traditional cross-entropy loss function. The findings establish that the
effective training of a dialogue generation model hinges significantly on
incorporating semantics and context. This pattern is also mirrored in the
introduced Dialuation metric, where the consideration of both context and
semantics correlates more strongly with human evaluation compared to
traditional metrics. | [
0.0407084115,
0.0614904612,
0.0122696143,
0.0204006825,
-0.0164504386,
-0.0158518236,
0.0025331655,
-0.0085416771,
-0.0271481685,
-0.0754471496,
-0.0569227673,
-0.0461116284,
-0.0012919822,
0.0460459404,
0.0228892844,
-0.0574480593,
0.0356490463,
0.0392680615,
0.0259713177,
-0.0004078568,
0.0027116989,
0.002600193,
-0.0305508021,
0.0532361902,
-0.0281676017,
0.0225069467,
-0.0061676493,
0.0301722568,
0.0209200941,
-0.0236891527,
0.0413654745,
0.0511764586,
-0.0116222128,
0.0346942022,
0.0000018576,
-0.0708314553,
0.0242080707,
-0.019095812,
-0.0017920109,
-0.0024447013,
0.059267927,
0.0058926404,
-0.0198509693,
0.0390896425,
-0.0404816493,
0.0016818433,
0.0660760775,
0.0639701188,
0.0594627634,
0.0622599199,
-0.0033579224,
-0.0413087346,
0.0176802129,
-0.0399571396,
0.0306255501,
-0.0330222882,
-0.0255525988,
0.0057051894,
-0.0187962037,
0.0015692302,
-0.0032894621,
0.0160406586,
0.010474775,
-0.0433661714,
0.0146183409,
0.0404981449,
0.0069963718,
0.0071998341,
-0.021693293,
0.0830406398,
0.037742082,
0.0117459651,
-0.0122308666,
-0.0046325717,
-0.003628439,
-0.0878823549,
-0.0364360847,
0.017094221,
0.0151220374,
0.0041974853,
0.0007727473,
0.0460271575,
-0.0250848699,
0.0501297899,
0.0149980169,
0.0021190601,
0.0208505243,
-0.0322243907,
-0.0332926698,
0.0020324043,
-0.0184777062,
-0.0682288483,
-0.0084588798,
0.0385618769,
-0.0534999594,
0.0091442661,
-0.0507832505,
0.0276956614,
0.0439439677,
-0.0324769095,
0.0029791314,
0.0280650798,
0.0055775843,
-0.0010865086,
-0.0004157055,
0.0572095774,
-0.0158462208,
0.0156958494,
-0.04799233,
-0.0059368862,
-0.0319012702,
-0.0096415747,
-0.0377794057,
0.0107567981,
-0.053171657,
-0.0617162101,
-0.0453359745,
0.0283075236,
-0.0044830483,
-0.0257675219,
0.0007955881,
0.0382406861,
-0.0342745185,
0.0045741587,
-0.047054287,
-0.0089941341,
-0.032071352,
0.0223548673,
0.0635873303,
-0.0330465175,
-0.0113055464,
0.0476401486,
-0.002356916,
-0.0021240895,
-0.0003465746,
0.0398228429,
-0.0324679986,
-0.0219678208,
-0.0187248196,
-0.0541533493,
-0.0724340901,
-0.0747900605,
-0.0547518358,
-0.0267907567,
0.019379532,
-0.0328338407,
-0.0356886759,
-0.002792008,
0.0231740605,
0.0097849416,
-0.0078660119,
0.0347154401,
0.0015522108,
-0.0151969586,
0.0623380281,
0.0117890192,
0.0092828413,
0.034054108,
0.0327624157,
0.0123838093,
0.0134826191,
-0.003105022,
-0.0088660475,
-0.014426033,
0.0338506736,
0.0128064072,
-0.0017349009,
0.0093982266,
-0.0314250179,
0.0589074194,
0.0446790271,
0.0655605793,
-0.0681116134,
0.0047738343,
0.0781060383,
0.0223229527,
0.0280740298,
0.0226440672,
0.0575480387,
0.0350176096,
-0.0313644856,
0.0064393543,
-0.0273337532,
0.0156750176,
0.0122700362,
0.0266243145,
0.0940645561,
-0.0268749539,
-0.0331962258,
-0.0480652601,
0.0387254022,
0.0033501417,
0.0076382323,
-0.0376524143,
0.0019588976,
0.0543369986,
-0.0506962314,
0.0467120782,
0.0078983707,
-0.0698668212,
0.0081231017,
-0.0262269955,
0.0172086358,
0.0603411645,
0.0701108798,
0.0429387093,
-0.0438073017,
-0.022774931,
-0.0091862716,
0.0804313943,
0.0479236171,
-0.013444677,
0.0416901819,
-0.0590638854,
-0.0063325278,
-0.0384458527,
-0.0017961519,
0.0172089804,
-0.0035879393,
0.022529237,
0.0599254929,
0.0169067737,
0.0225283895,
0.028542731,
0.0105756568,
-0.0172856152,
0.0485073403,
-0.0083837872,
0.0483314916,
0.0201718807,
-0.0201784596,
0.0314387381,
0.0121717146,
-0.0228592604,
-0.0273820776,
0.0289822929,
-0.094582282,
-0.0619679131,
0.0124538746,
-0.0077638682,
0.0321421511,
-0.0098078689,
-0.0003083866,
-0.0576075241,
0.0456860363,
-0.0505248159,
0.0381602012,
-0.088222079,
0.0000389205,
0.0281918682,
0.0403322019,
-0.0474713631,
0.0385199375,
-0.00460472,
-0.0022145251,
0.0566334464,
0.0787557438,
0.0418715365,
-0.0566815399,
0.0123961978,
-0.0028038374,
-0.0358228609,
0.0359789506,
0.0431941003,
0.0352835394,
-0.0469618626,
-0.04810201,
-0.0977472961,
0.0382939801,
-0.0048569026,
0.0062645855,
0.0361506492,
0.0218671113,
-0.0094984965,
-0.0007707043,
-0.0526315793,
0.0276743863,
0.0627586693,
-0.0079140635,
0.0277711023,
0.0252614077,
-0.0107207084,
-0.0393785723,
0.0230400059,
0.0323394798,
0.0226323567,
-0.0048734657,
0.0511884317,
-0.0380648188,
0.0468816534,
-0.0425983518,
0.0069933534,
0.0076743797,
-0.0602654032,
0.0245821755,
0.0411073044,
0.0239017084,
0.0388641842,
0.0869906843,
0.0142881516,
-0.0122836642,
-0.0236477107,
-0.0627816543,
0.0107023949,
-0.0575927794,
-0.0070347553,
-0.0212192126,
-0.0134734418,
0.0345665254,
0.0131959505,
0.047903385,
0.0484517552,
-0.0554256104,
0.0122274552,
0.033281181,
-0.0654589459,
0.0043661986,
-0.0160505325,
-0.0524827912,
0.0342295542,
-0.0236190036,
-0.0269895401,
0.0287201572,
-0.0524393879,
-0.0085378941,
-0.0437395051,
0.0089467075,
-0.012191752,
0.0188321695,
-0.0195343811,
0.043238122,
0.0076479781,
-0.0180764552,
-0.0354043804,
-0.0159144644,
0.0142118083,
-0.0276154056,
0.0172443781,
-0.0130298361,
-0.0206842404,
-0.0072549945,
-0.027376201,
-0.0624559782,
-0.0310536791,
0.0400811434,
0.002136885,
0.0354758352,
0.0056995125,
-0.012363581,
0.0212992132,
-0.0190666821,
0.0191654023,
-0.0253592953,
-0.0258671716,
-0.0248087477,
0.0761038959,
0.0548056886,
0.0235224571,
0.0226196144,
-0.0007302819,
0.0661671758,
0.0475035571,
0.0095896497,
0.0032752003,
-0.0124009438,
-0.0096755829,
0.0175807383,
0.0040386152,
0.0175712183,
0.0122124264,
0.0585490875,
-0.0129555259,
-0.0460288152,
0.1097861007,
0.0160839949,
-0.0191004667,
-0.0069415113,
-0.0190614574,
0.0637092143,
-0.0006503219,
-0.0039983643,
-0.0660669208,
-0.0252418127,
-0.0084938817,
0.0299724676,
-0.0310914926,
0.0031659468,
-0.0361696295,
-0.1060439795,
0.0392090045,
0.0098394649,
-0.0550051332,
-0.0122473706,
0.0214098915,
-0.0143285515,
-0.0041409815,
0.0345478319,
0.0043830853,
0.0165670775,
-0.0027198563,
0.0236985609,
0.0209368039,
-0.0343576595,
-0.0130787073,
-0.0280503053,
0.0753574595,
0.0701019242,
0.0487342961,
0.0457355939,
0.0114014102,
0.0443303511,
-0.0442283042,
-0.0050122035,
-0.0100695984,
0.0556722134,
-0.014493241,
-0.0071143364,
-0.0233436134,
0.030133279,
0.001023056,
-0.0224850792,
0.0042483872,
-0.0097200703,
-0.0372180603,
0.0188616887,
-0.012440756,
0.0688177422,
0.0485680774,
0.0813871175,
0.0463125333,
-0.0445554294,
-0.0392946526,
-0.0006196111,
0.0319361351,
-0.0584217571,
0.010535758,
-0.0155282328,
0.0107980417,
-0.0457991548,
-0.1049815714,
-0.0739753842,
-0.0465175062,
0.0459066331,
-0.0240475647,
-0.0083226319,
-0.0529459491,
-0.0132320123,
-0.0262849443,
-0.0096725086,
-0.0146583635,
0.0062839002,
-0.0602941066,
-0.0068241581,
0.0246295817,
-0.0580185205,
-0.0163257327,
0.0473339893,
-0.0617368594,
-0.0534615815,
-0.0371740796,
0.0495591275,
0.0201600399,
0.0638500676,
0.0081874197,
-0.0150031606,
0.0297494736,
0.0200010128,
-0.0260873735,
0.0145153375,
0.035216976,
0.0354777314,
-0.0126269776,
0.0179466624,
-0.0058485516,
0.0397060812,
0.0069560022,
0.0603660606,
0.0075163748,
-0.1157172397,
0.01955791,
-0.0190674756,
0.0128097516,
-0.0318323299,
-0.0212209057,
-0.0179835949,
0.0082707023,
0.0049971309,
-0.0113106165,
-0.0681114793,
-0.027072724,
0.0160104353,
0.0192565415,
0.0071080597,
-0.0451233611,
-0.0598834567,
0.0630438849,
-0.0062668081,
-0.0240461528,
-0.0110462932,
0.0296967179,
-0.0120224571,
0.0034420507,
-0.0343301371,
0.0111185266,
-0.004699518,
0.0307428446,
-0.0206377599,
0.1124064773,
-0.0004457715,
-0.0210730918,
0.038062565,
0.0493757725,
-0.0443709791,
0.0155396964,
-0.0529559217,
-0.0143268425,
0.0046381219,
0.0286433697,
0.0552304015,
-0.0192534085,
0.0270731878,
-0.0160210449,
0.0681575835,
-0.0135424007,
-0.0411330089,
0.0311067291,
-0.0120542599,
-0.0094510578,
0.0053419666,
0.0551402979,
-0.0235910658,
0.0222779792,
-0.0038267213,
0.0182464793,
-0.0499194264,
-0.0498824343,
0.0007849821,
0.0323603228,
0.0035410314,
0.0027466079,
-0.0339298695,
-0.0271662902,
-0.0094927195,
0.0008315678,
-0.0030421137,
0.0091952896,
0.0766403824,
0.0423831418,
-0.0251923855,
0.0189112779,
-0.0319787785,
-0.0060601668,
-0.010281154,
-0.002430669,
-0.0422037095,
-5.942712058e-33,
-0.0411412232,
-0.0286128037,
0.0331694297,
0.0236093272,
-0.068279326,
-0.0292729903,
-0.063445203,
-0.0044197482,
0.0120639252,
-0.0027235809,
0.0321048684,
-0.0183246098,
0.0002853624,
0.0524507426,
-0.0333713032,
-0.0243263058,
0.028915016,
0.0124788228,
-0.040573772,
0.0686421245,
0.042582009,
0.0015201981,
-0.0041151037,
-0.0782713518,
-0.0013366739,
-0.0037985747,
-0.0439726189,
-0.0036273259,
0.0291779675,
0.0466201231,
-0.0544504635,
0.0486824699,
0.0128518762,
-0.0457778089,
-0.0320724659,
0.0423987173,
-0.0192428753,
-0.0135057801,
0.0130452113,
-0.0131976791,
-0.0161040109,
-0.0424886234,
0.016015904,
-0.0134773795,
-0.0198722687,
0.0058793533,
-0.0059694676,
-0.0201589447,
-0.0226454753,
-0.0288838726,
-0.1007852033,
0.0216183197,
-0.0116854161,
-0.0777082667,
-0.0407738462,
0.0452118553,
0.0035415832,
-0.0333279073,
0.0108114574,
0.0453157723,
-0.0073720156,
-0.0008324457,
0.0311914776,
0.0198330767,
-0.0220737159,
0.0624783076,
0.0394489393,
-0.0043848273,
0.0053776004,
-0.0504013225,
-0.0082102595,
0.021293968,
0.0198755283,
0.0975861773,
0.0021261161,
-0.0222074445,
-0.0374725796,
0.0517285503,
-0.007412733,
0.0066162497,
0.0334186591,
-0.0082159666,
0.0057299547,
-0.0146725653,
-0.0320654288,
-0.0108311921,
-0.0271620173,
-0.0365573876,
0.0491792485,
0.0382660292,
0.0072064921,
-0.0339582004,
0.0421791635,
-0.0289626922,
0.0365182199,
0.0360660106,
-0.0484817289,
-0.0062149437,
-0.022761751,
-0.0228676833,
-0.0473264046,
-0.0450562946,
0.0815183222,
0.0437586084,
-0.0224868972,
-0.0015363476,
0.0012969276,
0.0019842845,
-0.0400816202,
0.0173568707,
-0.0443692207,
0.0617487282,
-0.0446160585,
-0.0128793763,
-0.0111981276,
-0.0157959498,
-0.0269464664,
0.0551080033,
0.0046165385,
-0.0116269449,
-0.0251122899,
-0.0297828894,
0.0348938368,
0.0332579687,
-0.0418174975,
0.0318223722,
0.0022688636,
-0.0380012952,
0.0033202178,
-0.0315639563,
-0.0135657107,
-0.0123540973,
2.603e-7,
-0.0045069689,
0.0095412955,
0.0170362424,
-0.0108442577,
0.0187735744,
0.0572725944,
0.0132476194,
0.0388419926,
0.0100898482,
0.0294917077,
0.0155390743,
-0.0157701485,
0.0642515719,
-0.0204628222,
-0.0701293349,
0.0009364625,
-0.0980908498,
-0.0124170491,
-0.0106404796,
-0.0024597622,
0.0704125986,
0.0471585542,
-0.0382473581,
-0.0291195195,
0.0073912158,
-0.0326890536,
0.0779947937,
-0.0444132239,
-0.0125899948,
0.0418363623,
0.0091617741,
0.006908494,
0.0054309987,
-0.003579173,
-0.0210888255,
0.0287716053,
-0.0085428162,
0.0419128053,
0.0157361757,
-0.1018370539,
0.0101297786,
-0.005333039,
0.0290594045,
-0.0712974444,
0.0177401509,
-0.0303509161,
-0.0183106102,
-0.0173758194,
-0.0276678968,
0.0201741401,
0.0233106539,
-0.0575751252,
-0.0435740799,
-0.0046502501,
0.022214897,
0.0224960968,
0.0043809372,
-0.0705453083,
-0.0280366689,
-0.0224937387,
-0.0549984649,
-0.047219988,
-0.035640724,
0.0222970024,
0.0235249903,
-0.0121335108,
0.000474757,
2.071034161e-34,
0.0251171254,
-0.0184868518,
0.0199126042,
-0.0025698352,
0.0121464664,
0.026557792,
0.0460068174,
-0.0100430287,
0.0412250869,
-0.0462950543,
-0.011600133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13061v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13061v3 | Applying BioBERT to Extract Germline Gene-Disease Associations for Building a Knowledge Graph from the Biomedical Literature | 2023-09-11T18:05:12 | 2024-04-22T20:26:25 | Armando D. Diaz Gonzalez, Kevin S. Hughes, Songhui Yue, Sean T. Hayes | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Published biomedical information has and continues to rapidly increase. The
recent advancements in Natural Language Processing (NLP), have generated
considerable interest in automating the extraction, normalization, and
representation of biomedical knowledge about entities such as genes and
diseases. Our study analyzes germline abstracts in the construction of
knowledge graphs of the of the immense work that has been done in this area for
genes and diseases. This paper presents SimpleGermKG, an automatic knowledge
graph construction approach that connects germline genes and diseases. For the
extraction of genes and diseases, we employ BioBERT, a pre-trained BERT model
on biomedical corpora. We propose an ontology-based and rule-based algorithm to
standardize and disambiguate medical terms. For semantic relationships between
articles, genes, and diseases, we implemented a part-whole relation approach to
connect each entity with its data source and visualize them in a graph-based
knowledge representation. Lastly, we discuss the knowledge graph applications,
limitations, and challenges to inspire the future research of germline corpora.
Our knowledge graph contains 297 genes, 130 diseases, and 46,747 triples.
Graph-based visualizations are used to show the results. | [
0.0208912659,
0.0002679347,
-0.0016213431,
-0.0144815445,
-0.0162307601,
0.0128032723,
-0.033429414,
0.0554439202,
0.0931350514,
-0.0288663302,
0.032125935,
0.0316298194,
-0.0056938408,
0.0480479747,
-0.0223279819,
-0.0291431211,
0.0081388494,
0.0367347859,
0.0404919572,
0.0127841756,
0.0001753102,
0.0219099019,
0.0201196205,
0.0143142613,
-0.0044983546,
-0.0210063756,
0.0496034771,
0.0069278614,
0.0575274304,
-0.0579003543,
-0.0110069364,
0.0208945088,
-0.0266221315,
-0.0102304844,
0.0000017342,
-0.0556257069,
-0.0520368889,
0.0485382117,
0.0182242151,
-0.0421344712,
0.0096567925,
-0.0292550363,
0.0039812005,
-0.0051165652,
-0.0079861451,
-0.0171194691,
0.048381418,
0.0478672795,
0.0077006612,
0.0380202308,
-0.0053918944,
-0.0582460314,
0.0567826256,
0.031486351,
0.048861064,
-0.0199852623,
0.0537534878,
0.0284611713,
0.0398285985,
-0.0032437989,
0.0064932383,
0.0340282395,
-0.0554705821,
-0.0147539945,
0.0431545228,
0.0081214523,
0.005204855,
-0.0211956855,
0.0407472439,
0.0551994629,
0.0094804559,
-0.043089319,
0.0630411878,
0.0177987125,
-0.0036056018,
0.0453688949,
-0.0285973977,
-0.0307958089,
-0.0889029726,
0.0080561629,
0.0087791057,
-0.0719121993,
0.0222496707,
-0.0313651748,
-0.0002611978,
0.0625731647,
-0.0142533723,
-0.0331429616,
0.0067611686,
-0.0338223465,
0.0078405244,
-0.0408996157,
0.0354130864,
0.0301734265,
-0.0049021319,
0.0136704352,
0.0010379438,
-0.0774035901,
0.0722609162,
-0.0405675285,
-0.0386943556,
-0.0265613683,
0.0056656534,
0.0221091695,
-0.0168682896,
-0.0238605477,
-0.0163680855,
0.0364245772,
-0.0123294946,
-0.0122843524,
-0.0816443339,
-0.005832748,
-0.0425724536,
0.036421068,
0.0124321561,
0.0120459953,
-0.0753352195,
-0.019770069,
-0.0172121059,
0.0193311702,
0.0183139015,
0.0108469678,
0.000731737,
0.030048361,
-0.0271255746,
0.0136792334,
-0.0090392642,
-0.0195016228,
-0.0486327261,
0.0188357029,
0.0247063506,
-0.0222519338,
0.0710904524,
0.0150796091,
0.0012805904,
0.0541761033,
0.0390939303,
-0.0240729116,
-0.006440239,
-0.0464069694,
-0.0223705936,
0.00950287,
0.0127491979,
-0.0505125113,
0.028593149,
0.0508187711,
-0.021025544,
-0.023654636,
0.0193948876,
-0.0046381294,
-0.1028899923,
-0.0005183006,
-0.0961239487,
-0.03013926,
0.0176500455,
0.009128063,
-0.0246547908,
-0.026111301,
0.0424838848,
-0.0645581558,
0.0435794555,
-0.0081641171,
-0.0229826011,
-0.0248892866,
0.0293968357,
-0.0674640462,
0.0450547934,
0.0089105451,
-0.0230098777,
0.0523552932,
-0.008242107,
0.033933986,
0.0135827037,
-0.019951757,
-0.0064274413,
0.0937803984,
0.0430284441,
0.0199478231,
0.0120851835,
0.0371468067,
0.0323362648,
-0.0138968499,
0.0262302086,
-0.0424307287,
-0.0189552642,
0.0352163427,
-0.0405952334,
0.0494127944,
0.0370458029,
-0.0033972482,
-0.0329098441,
0.034260802,
0.0183150545,
-0.0556128845,
0.0283220783,
-0.0093941623,
-0.0041555711,
0.0295040999,
0.0543409735,
-0.023066638,
0.0245110225,
0.0052058008,
-0.0308808014,
0.060770981,
0.0354846157,
-0.0407377072,
-0.0440901853,
-0.0076235235,
-0.0626064017,
0.0023896184,
-0.0281277541,
-0.0527692623,
-0.0241434872,
-0.0012722199,
0.0009117518,
0.0465199277,
0.0068076537,
-0.0183141138,
-0.0472176559,
0.0314388163,
-0.0023246254,
-0.0611999147,
0.0109783392,
0.0196801741,
-0.0316316411,
0.0175456218,
-0.0423214249,
-0.0198279954,
0.0077728154,
0.0446058884,
-0.0186694302,
0.0461463481,
0.0418685786,
-0.0278603882,
-0.033541441,
0.0370511562,
0.0400047749,
-0.0303557795,
0.0105090626,
-0.0656379759,
-0.0211633798,
-0.0106971962,
-0.030402869,
-0.0301763192,
-0.0117525849,
-0.0407245494,
0.0760802925,
0.0180681422,
-0.0111480169,
0.0096580386,
-0.0514601134,
-0.0047636805,
0.0303551517,
0.0180525407,
0.0029682368,
-0.0146670546,
-0.1106792167,
0.038276881,
-0.0053147567,
0.0130039649,
-0.0069186548,
0.0249579195,
0.0033856481,
0.0401244201,
-0.0106020058,
-0.0344944187,
0.0430736877,
-0.099602893,
0.0063122585,
0.0475328937,
0.0598636158,
0.0037341574,
0.0061785681,
0.0154667143,
-0.03146616,
-0.0434469208,
0.0557876416,
0.0152023165,
-0.0192193296,
0.0605951101,
0.0030695922,
-0.0338112116,
-0.0155028924,
0.0065079611,
-0.0643040985,
0.0253162608,
0.0580342039,
0.0106262732,
0.0423923917,
-0.006463212,
-0.0732200965,
0.0235494711,
0.0179665312,
-0.0018677085,
-0.0173588581,
0.0227699243,
-0.0041860617,
-0.006514037,
-0.0294741988,
0.0262972005,
0.036337439,
0.0027126221,
0.0172803942,
-0.0053718467,
-0.0354255065,
0.0814192668,
-0.0049739145,
0.0014109807,
0.044805795,
-0.0008827262,
0.0207987949,
-0.0236146338,
-0.0058491379,
0.0014803278,
-0.0111152939,
0.0420529321,
-0.0303971209,
-0.0277410839,
0.0098017473,
-0.0094856396,
0.0077214814,
0.0057703769,
0.0867365226,
-0.0090052485,
0.0534983538,
-0.0580963977,
0.0071345344,
-0.0009719136,
0.0430911817,
0.0189819429,
0.0436060652,
0.0113797542,
-0.0344065875,
0.008897556,
-0.0093208812,
0.0453408249,
-0.0588878728,
0.0071767895,
-0.048647508,
0.0295501221,
0.0327400416,
0.0015840316,
0.0013276907,
0.0548042469,
-0.014153461,
0.0217258465,
0.050969217,
-0.0416486748,
-0.0265880339,
0.0236501358,
0.0103547601,
0.0126791485,
0.046621047,
-0.004964238,
-0.0041351402,
0.0467633232,
0.0330733396,
-0.0491384603,
-0.0373155437,
0.0358556286,
0.0006904808,
0.0483047441,
-0.0542265363,
0.0109236166,
0.0214111358,
-0.0021883112,
-0.0081899837,
-0.0736786425,
-0.008050492,
-0.0205139443,
0.0042161415,
-0.0387490243,
0.024816636,
0.0640211329,
0.059651807,
-0.0059146434,
0.0287043694,
-0.0016231094,
-0.0693507791,
-0.0405051373,
0.0397961363,
-0.1079824418,
0.0001351359,
-0.0262486823,
-0.0289401989,
-0.010440846,
-0.0782360137,
0.0303489268,
-0.0003114165,
0.000898201,
0.0060743354,
-0.0546051525,
-0.0659512356,
-0.0783589259,
-0.0215547532,
-0.0187854245,
-0.0565271564,
-0.0375811942,
-0.0043161507,
-0.0014444381,
0.0135752354,
-0.0409656726,
-0.0845091119,
0.0171123147,
-0.0356996246,
0.0153492549,
0.0182629656,
0.0644005239,
0.0018182143,
-0.0088579338,
-0.0117102005,
-0.005027249,
-0.02434274,
-0.0369921327,
0.0541329868,
0.0118795885,
-0.0016717269,
-0.0921229348,
-0.0094088977,
0.0050678765,
-0.0119988676,
-0.0217849649,
0.048364453,
-0.0005745958,
-0.0487716459,
-0.0627916977,
-0.0176637731,
-0.0151985362,
0.0660322607,
-0.0463454202,
0.0216281675,
-0.010288747,
0.0012871473,
0.045014523,
0.0133592989,
-0.0117527824,
0.0236741938,
-0.1072560027,
0.0055615106,
-0.062216904,
-0.0113058994,
0.0192450061,
-0.0153584937,
0.0320764035,
-0.0061919796,
0.0737157837,
-0.0210643243,
-0.0717374235,
0.0381634124,
0.0518182255,
-0.0140596945,
-0.0022971896,
-0.0625738874,
0.0424923263,
0.0416659638,
-0.0143576181,
0.0371776,
0.0094948076,
-0.0424327217,
-0.0585822314,
-0.0234443992,
0.0252494849,
0.0104234004,
0.0083140889,
0.0084278835,
0.0834243,
0.0555390641,
-0.0277904812,
-0.0475947298,
-0.061098814,
-0.0134874629,
-0.0084840376,
0.0048870025,
-0.0300129168,
-0.0067580701,
-0.0396001041,
0.0464811511,
-0.0267457385,
0.0145407747,
0.0360077806,
0.0516370647,
-0.0017104041,
0.0098280096,
-0.0124658234,
-0.047858011,
0.0181084834,
-0.0490465276,
0.0176156275,
0.0103960438,
0.015984688,
-0.0120850308,
-0.028823128,
-0.009403198,
0.008298696,
-0.018408671,
-0.0342110954,
-0.0548187532,
0.00974051,
0.0084714666,
-0.0125175649,
0.0382795408,
-0.0426649451,
0.0094880844,
-0.0247665662,
-0.0119284866,
-0.0363199376,
-0.0381887704,
0.0084135719,
0.0146310721,
-0.0067979554,
-0.0262696929,
-0.0022940889,
-0.0218969416,
0.0275132302,
-0.0237998255,
0.0271997787,
0.0328326523,
-0.0057394113,
0.0393475853,
-0.0164961442,
-0.0258827899,
-0.0111795953,
0.0164770316,
-0.0249406938,
0.0426344387,
0.0462193079,
-0.0000026999,
-0.0286664423,
-0.0710715652,
0.0394335277,
0.0418112054,
0.0621504784,
0.0030720551,
-0.1022357717,
-0.0316650681,
0.0077389688,
0.0896808505,
-0.0008109362,
-0.0498118587,
-0.0008413741,
-0.0665803179,
-0.0329935327,
0.0575549379,
0.0150868734,
0.0042872177,
0.0208294522,
0.0195623916,
0.0092660347,
0.0697738379,
-0.0889337733,
-0.0009777034,
0.0397446342,
-0.0741860494,
-0.0394137427,
0.0188359711,
-5.588853361e-33,
-0.0082643935,
-0.0618603751,
0.0244504418,
0.0293957125,
0.0075466298,
0.0168908183,
-0.0273364764,
-0.0385411829,
-0.0195356756,
0.0799817368,
0.0236973222,
-0.0038640725,
-0.0101529909,
0.0060076304,
-0.0188966673,
0.009398941,
0.0197999086,
0.007670253,
0.0168236066,
-0.0001792353,
0.0408459939,
0.0589784533,
0.0070541697,
-0.0506942123,
0.0176158063,
-0.0042304909,
0.0407130904,
-0.0033448827,
0.0354931056,
0.024383463,
-0.0111914547,
0.0217738114,
0.0104654739,
0.0326485112,
0.0299392566,
-0.0017505676,
-0.0921379179,
-0.0389368236,
0.0156114949,
-0.0126835452,
-0.0269795507,
0.0090496205,
0.0560392551,
-0.0039125467,
0.006518682,
-0.0001435499,
0.0749174133,
-0.0067387419,
-0.0687541962,
-0.0661248043,
-0.0180475414,
0.0214893017,
0.0034577558,
0.0114440741,
0.0258577894,
-0.0584950857,
-0.0109193977,
-0.0107026305,
0.0064628148,
-0.0104604783,
0.0362134539,
0.020005513,
-0.0024306802,
-0.0625525862,
0.0366995893,
0.0370320305,
-0.0498062856,
-0.0425698645,
0.0081787193,
0.0379433036,
-0.0295789503,
0.0507906079,
-0.0457341857,
-0.0417623222,
0.0157142933,
-0.004228659,
-0.1162798181,
0.0481626727,
-0.0196088012,
0.0257848948,
-0.0519187935,
-0.0097149247,
0.0293843672,
0.0182283446,
-0.0217447467,
-0.0093449764,
-0.0044822143,
-0.0343936495,
-0.0361381024,
-0.0426957645,
0.0082793301,
0.0460984856,
-0.0359241851,
-0.0137871886,
-0.0595884733,
0.0185218062,
0.0501585044,
-0.0148776202,
-0.0277699828,
0.0083507309,
-0.0049838969,
-0.0407367051,
0.0068169534,
-0.0319543965,
0.0336033963,
0.0206206758,
0.0285504144,
-0.0475066043,
-0.0275767278,
-0.001460718,
-0.0054057413,
-0.0310060307,
-0.0071795457,
0.0169496983,
0.0104001388,
0.0440292321,
0.0329184346,
0.0146143595,
0.0753642917,
0.0570434518,
0.0184689313,
0.080560334,
0.0021928318,
-0.0041627451,
-0.0182132851,
-0.0185679346,
-0.0093327733,
0.0370628014,
0.0008280645,
-0.0389051661,
-0.0025141856,
-0.010549902,
2.677e-7,
0.0938520283,
0.0682292134,
0.026055431,
0.0278638043,
0.0324816518,
-0.020199528,
-0.0145232547,
0.0369953215,
-0.0305172,
-0.0148225725,
0.0142925503,
-0.0113388281,
-0.0445570499,
0.0641786829,
-0.0446633324,
-0.0010676886,
-0.0181689244,
-0.0570469648,
-0.0084249973,
0.0546160415,
0.0709000677,
0.0094291782,
-0.0094971349,
0.0028451602,
0.0145511944,
-0.016838504,
0.0057346146,
0.0106596295,
0.0226535909,
0.0308527946,
0.0193615798,
0.0057941866,
0.0067610196,
0.0641916394,
-0.0177320447,
-0.0251616705,
-0.004550043,
0.0260280427,
-0.028650932,
0.0555181913,
0.0620888695,
-0.0370268598,
0.0606071539,
-0.0002421514,
-0.0122990077,
-0.0150198862,
-0.0316458717,
0.0254665166,
-0.000505424,
-0.0064972346,
-0.0127808712,
-0.0000228862,
-0.0121678105,
0.0493697934,
0.0031150049,
0.0299536753,
0.004291838,
-0.0598115176,
0.0074664992,
0.0923443437,
0.0083121443,
-0.0373922996,
0.0392153785,
-0.0079899328,
0.0069118519,
-0.0817043185,
-0.0036543906,
2.206772075e-34,
0.0259702951,
-0.0070763989,
-0.0432793722,
0.0052237026,
0.0273314659,
-0.0316453464,
0.0022134974,
-0.0080877189,
-0.044847101,
-0.0721421465,
0.0087746708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05660v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05660v2 | Hypothesis Search: Inductive Reasoning with Language Models | 2023-09-11T17:56:57 | 2024-05-30T23:10:00 | Ruocheng Wang, Eric Zelikman, Gabriel Poesia, Yewen Pu, Nick Haber, Noah D. Goodman | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Inductive reasoning is a core problem-solving capacity: humans can identify
underlying principles from a few examples, which robustly generalize to novel
scenarios. Recent work evaluates large language models (LLMs) on inductive
reasoning tasks by directly prompting them yielding "in context learning." This
works well for straightforward inductive tasks but performs poorly on complex
tasks such as the Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus (ARC). In this work, we
propose to improve the inductive reasoning ability of LLMs by generating
explicit hypotheses at multiple levels of abstraction: we prompt the LLM to
propose multiple abstract hypotheses about the problem, in natural language,
then implement the natural language hypotheses as concrete Python programs.
These programs can be verified by running on observed examples and generalized
to novel inputs. To reduce the hypothesis search space, we explore steps to
filter the set of hypotheses to implement: we either ask the LLM to summarize
them into a smaller set of hypotheses or ask human annotators to select a
subset. We verify our pipeline's effectiveness on the ARC visual inductive
reasoning benchmark, its variant 1D-ARC, string transformation dataset SyGuS,
and list transformation dataset List Functions. On a random 100-problem subset
of ARC, our automated pipeline using LLM summaries achieves 30% accuracy,
outperforming the direct prompting baseline (accuracy of 17%). With the minimal
human input of selecting from LLM-generated candidates, performance is boosted
to 33%. Our ablations show that both abstract hypothesis generation and
concrete program representations benefit LLMs on inductive reasoning tasks. | [
0.0139039978,
0.0118447021,
-0.0007411213,
0.0226189066,
-0.0526473783,
0.0430903621,
0.0083566932,
-0.0125177773,
0.0100063495,
-0.0342972726,
0.0330850109,
-0.0052232663,
0.0093357619,
0.0223129205,
0.038436275,
-0.0803558901,
0.0011347848,
-0.0322742276,
0.026441725,
0.0100519769,
-0.0317995548,
0.0336816274,
-0.0323592871,
0.0495026149,
-0.012347104,
-0.0195444301,
-0.0136483666,
0.0009254087,
-0.0023788295,
-0.0510596484,
-0.038789019,
0.0442892723,
0.0848116353,
-0.009665655,
0.0000023612,
-0.0549317114,
0.0023571143,
-0.0125533417,
-0.036165528,
-0.0269623473,
0.0351065546,
-0.0200500824,
0.0248149075,
0.0401182398,
-0.0236700941,
-0.0161420424,
0.0225706697,
0.0197235998,
0.0835782588,
0.045883894,
-0.0132317999,
-0.0331590064,
-0.0197892599,
0.010775052,
0.0405525677,
-0.003945095,
0.0075011477,
0.0094608963,
0.0182041395,
-0.0123004848,
0.0061657112,
0.0288225245,
0.0431921594,
-0.0113034379,
0.0011002093,
0.0345477611,
-0.0790557489,
-0.0566570833,
0.0039232252,
0.0678476542,
-0.0311109256,
-0.0541673228,
-0.026665397,
-0.0137174753,
0.015302822,
0.0358790345,
-0.0488909148,
0.0805857256,
-0.0446301065,
-0.0119551569,
0.0211323556,
-0.0224372726,
0.0229917075,
0.0037622179,
-0.0696072802,
0.0872555599,
-0.0069561456,
-0.0182409901,
0.0317899287,
0.0065612174,
-0.0455193669,
-0.0519970134,
-0.0076357191,
0.0552406609,
-0.0612703934,
0.0264722817,
0.0105389692,
-0.0314915851,
0.0113415429,
-0.0214416906,
0.0056032427,
0.0485018082,
0.0072239274,
0.0631765723,
-0.0310894493,
0.0415691212,
-0.0327746533,
0.0193673037,
-0.0339866653,
-0.0228571482,
-0.0527583994,
-0.0076815863,
-0.0492023565,
0.0264534894,
0.0034062564,
0.0054389713,
0.0110418657,
0.0510090925,
-0.0266588144,
0.0473215207,
-0.0490159653,
-0.0106480168,
-0.0193216316,
-0.03432611,
-0.0525114723,
0.0074314931,
-0.0476008207,
0.0105833337,
0.0263997316,
-0.0098189535,
-0.0186418444,
0.0260639414,
-0.001552307,
-0.0165293645,
0.0419532098,
0.0628780052,
0.0046310462,
0.0084993122,
-0.0476572476,
-0.0301773436,
0.0579177774,
-0.0460361093,
0.0287433546,
-0.086205177,
0.006750646,
0.0249814056,
-0.015889952,
-0.009009026,
0.0056760218,
0.0390723944,
0.0089195725,
0.0938028544,
-0.0130035644,
0.012591592,
0.0557132773,
-0.0091491928,
-0.0546751469,
0.0731012449,
0.0233490448,
0.0361736193,
0.0118941758,
-0.008793842,
0.0338599235,
0.0151069518,
-0.0053012557,
0.0083465055,
0.013706672,
0.0181800779,
-0.0369691476,
0.0669530109,
-0.0372581817,
0.0390615128,
-0.0089792283,
-0.0122670904,
0.0038558748,
0.1088576242,
-0.0117929745,
-0.0046409555,
0.0726969987,
0.0099420501,
0.0064820973,
-0.0087780794,
-0.05294507,
0.0469388589,
-0.0187984854,
0.0048124357,
-0.0142141869,
-0.0081740571,
-0.0244813915,
-0.0624476708,
-0.0355019346,
0.029504722,
0.0223641749,
0.030944543,
0.0674100295,
0.0503034554,
-0.0352152735,
0.0492812134,
0.0122688636,
-0.0543357618,
-0.0337726288,
-0.0323109329,
0.0682692081,
0.0695533603,
0.0570617393,
-0.0375690833,
0.0155907897,
-0.0328015201,
0.0573294759,
0.0349872746,
0.0330790095,
-0.0341247432,
-0.037159875,
-0.0351046026,
-0.0254767537,
-0.0329308398,
-0.0158651397,
0.000876918,
0.0232716948,
-0.0406918824,
-0.0011747583,
-0.0264205802,
-0.0087231752,
0.0604061969,
-0.0414401516,
0.0013246008,
-0.0030119554,
0.027604958,
0.0073261107,
-0.0154979648,
0.0058423327,
0.0197242051,
0.0078294678,
-0.0445346124,
-0.0341420546,
0.0029789922,
-0.001389836,
-0.0230159201,
0.0426631644,
-0.0937576741,
-0.0394225083,
-0.010591981,
-0.0574516058,
0.0094049517,
0.0354111046,
-0.0257740188,
0.0131410761,
-0.0075816321,
0.0091513759,
0.0114801563,
-0.0208223294,
-0.021485569,
0.0792101473,
0.0161501896,
-0.0232969355,
0.0222349316,
0.032596115,
0.0115192402,
-0.0416833907,
0.0004613669,
-0.009295078,
0.0035753893,
-0.0175911393,
0.0310581047,
0.0112961316,
-0.0406007431,
0.0240785237,
-0.0779788792,
-0.0013943537,
-0.0150061417,
-0.0183932912,
0.0153671512,
-0.006418616,
0.0181238055,
0.0003310329,
-0.0268868096,
0.0019440863,
-0.0218700152,
0.0256091431,
0.0578648299,
-0.0075371419,
-0.0194748677,
-0.0086979987,
-0.020785233,
-0.0462037884,
0.0811711773,
0.0618252493,
-0.0187482648,
-0.0337771475,
0.0448300354,
-0.009944113,
0.0084406612,
-0.0191223361,
0.00939155,
0.0533301085,
-0.040803846,
-0.0030593807,
0.0877919495,
0.0236946642,
0.0319982469,
0.0381340161,
0.0275123827,
-0.0514256321,
0.0170681868,
-0.0112345079,
0.0045108902,
0.0151565019,
-0.0500983484,
-0.0178655479,
0.0291167181,
-0.0175525919,
0.014993391,
-0.0765841901,
0.0337829143,
0.0152386948,
0.0068139057,
-0.0870666802,
-0.0281101801,
0.0260249116,
0.0569204465,
-0.0368547775,
-0.052418232,
0.0876518115,
0.0049309963,
0.0048430273,
-0.0515001304,
-0.0075613819,
-0.0541861542,
0.0729537308,
0.0080308579,
-0.0089372424,
0.0152486926,
-0.0035212666,
-0.0550273731,
0.0274532922,
0.0251920093,
-0.0153395664,
0.068223536,
-0.0620883815,
0.0068807532,
0.0110563803,
-0.0152585674,
-0.0586836003,
-0.0253747907,
-0.026404677,
0.0058424799,
-0.0068260017,
-0.008015465,
0.0082569933,
-0.0074911769,
0.0317508504,
0.0331217721,
0.0402924903,
-0.0366076119,
-0.0177535787,
-0.0499456972,
-0.0010302311,
-0.0011322595,
0.0257072113,
-0.0253330395,
0.0660944581,
0.0250119735,
0.0345860273,
-0.0087487046,
-0.068812266,
0.0463961177,
-0.0339918844,
-0.027188208,
0.0107187685,
0.019971773,
-0.0072492938,
-0.0668854564,
-0.0130112059,
0.117647782,
0.0556123108,
-0.0286608413,
0.0097918129,
-0.0237347595,
0.0203905199,
0.073610194,
0.0406765863,
-0.1321802288,
-0.0335773863,
0.0069926032,
-0.0036103004,
0.01306816,
-0.0390960835,
-0.0013545408,
-0.1343955547,
0.0593188703,
0.005144306,
0.0039666374,
-0.0044076964,
-0.0598752312,
-0.0339379311,
-0.0408737473,
-0.0452321395,
0.0105536999,
-0.0021687918,
0.0066449819,
0.0122324191,
-0.0073736249,
-0.0223146025,
0.0455923975,
-0.01987762,
-0.0408162586,
0.0317039788,
0.0089245848,
-0.0180068891,
-0.048759874,
0.0297967289,
0.0247978028,
0.0103111397,
-0.0159916449,
0.0458780825,
0.0141590992,
-0.0027089044,
0.0150274867,
0.0499012545,
-0.0504110269,
-0.0516309328,
0.0298587922,
0.093391262,
-0.0434992649,
-0.0180264991,
-0.0195689648,
0.0119140893,
-0.0005585386,
0.0839786604,
0.0383989066,
-0.0082155587,
-0.0146185467,
-0.0470263734,
-0.0248712711,
-0.0206260793,
-0.0221029148,
0.0009779083,
0.0282517131,
0.0017327822,
-0.0695622489,
0.0262448639,
0.0696725026,
0.0266043022,
0.0114374729,
-0.0315372609,
0.0100774309,
0.0150052691,
-0.0711600482,
0.0776795894,
-0.0132508967,
0.0246983357,
-0.007100441,
-0.0210083183,
-0.012264411,
-0.0432469212,
-0.0424249247,
0.0576454811,
-0.0584874563,
-0.0615290925,
-0.0301681049,
0.0092099207,
0.0207604654,
0.0495409593,
-0.0098973643,
-0.037716262,
0.0436919779,
-0.0073288744,
0.0199887641,
-0.0373554938,
-0.00910886,
0.0100613199,
0.0105696004,
0.0152836479,
-0.022584239,
0.0254018046,
-0.0000568834,
0.0242655016,
-0.0224984027,
0.0113182031,
0.0444288775,
0.0570805594,
0.0304388776,
-0.0180089045,
-0.0383132212,
-0.021674281,
0.0025357897,
-0.004169716,
-0.0578158833,
-0.0357354246,
0.0294446088,
-0.0078968126,
-0.0448456928,
0.0284843594,
-0.0171241909,
-0.012687345,
0.0383498296,
0.0247394759,
0.0165549275,
0.0110025853,
0.0377289131,
0.0165830385,
-0.0233575422,
-0.0121927215,
0.0092505468,
-0.0266016349,
0.0679543912,
-0.0084237745,
0.0666418672,
0.0383596644,
0.0260951426,
-0.0633349046,
0.0047346172,
-0.0364234857,
-0.0786242634,
-0.0189215485,
0.0278323665,
0.0144245299,
0.0138276415,
-0.0322131887,
-0.0683751553,
-0.0030960918,
0.0180282667,
0.03105288,
0.0025751698,
-0.0551049039,
0.0590652823,
0.0507807434,
-0.0150049748,
-0.0362433009,
0.0348646045,
-0.0444473177,
0.0390453562,
-0.011942639,
-0.022770036,
-0.0484091565,
-0.0064525865,
-0.0115230409,
0.0014074896,
0.0092091179,
0.0142430356,
-0.0552153923,
-0.0787871853,
-0.0084567834,
0.0302325487,
0.0037824654,
0.0464271195,
0.0257362854,
0.0623897612,
-0.0001549815,
-0.0279598385,
-0.0028068176,
-0.001958892,
-0.0287221149,
-0.031852141,
-0.0548497885,
-6.601615212e-33,
-0.0284512527,
-0.036328923,
0.0552232899,
-0.002933414,
0.0408861525,
-0.0147544788,
-0.0572845265,
0.0210394822,
-0.0085336519,
0.0291463435,
0.0014378878,
0.014549274,
-0.0059773303,
-0.005229177,
0.001702591,
-0.0121710878,
0.0021790334,
-0.0060466025,
-0.0645450652,
0.0019702299,
0.0424099267,
-0.0273377672,
0.0161867943,
-0.0536918752,
-0.0175177809,
0.0061024418,
-0.0033023187,
0.0482533388,
-0.0571844615,
0.023120163,
0.0019169394,
0.0143931033,
0.0247094929,
-0.0404495336,
0.006550103,
0.0440554172,
-0.052626539,
-0.0156500712,
0.0198938493,
-0.0111568421,
-0.0518673249,
-0.0376167446,
0.047256656,
-0.0003889306,
-0.0066986592,
-0.0355773158,
0.049318485,
-0.0384090729,
0.0095700342,
0.0015856202,
-0.050259959,
0.0133195883,
-0.0581428781,
-0.0022546717,
0.011069119,
0.0508153066,
-0.0235387087,
0.01472711,
-0.0087149413,
0.0528110042,
0.011398932,
-0.0214697979,
0.0625432432,
-0.0084380424,
0.0251513589,
0.0351543352,
-0.0034971905,
-0.0015854714,
-0.0322020948,
0.0324178711,
0.0010305801,
0.0678936616,
0.0626553744,
0.0048831776,
0.0062187407,
0.0365426913,
-0.0645746291,
0.0276964307,
-0.0140741225,
0.0445778258,
0.023725234,
0.0167487878,
-0.0473836511,
-0.0179363899,
-0.0665019527,
-0.000291591,
-0.0418092571,
-0.0227620266,
0.0285715945,
-0.0046610516,
-0.0298376996,
0.0093589602,
0.0138306534,
-0.0168677326,
-0.0012220261,
0.0169758964,
-0.0291662365,
0.013107161,
0.0083597992,
0.0081673237,
-0.0175712649,
0.0009504888,
0.0509345159,
0.0219414234,
0.0541282222,
0.0155385006,
0.0312920623,
0.0038811257,
-0.030720057,
-0.0248719547,
-0.0749054402,
-0.0206701849,
-0.0050541596,
0.0267563332,
0.0096618868,
0.0416553803,
-0.0128838802,
0.0065781269,
-0.0237599947,
-0.0649754554,
-0.0183500592,
0.0300460551,
-0.0185166951,
0.0037887499,
-0.0396158099,
-0.0177273992,
-0.0142720565,
-0.024768183,
0.0652584881,
-0.0664330348,
-0.0261283591,
0.0389446244,
3.028e-7,
0.0269109495,
0.06328471,
0.0144671239,
0.0584678091,
-0.0030364119,
0.0375315771,
-0.0208925065,
-0.0314720199,
0.0422798656,
-0.0592986643,
0.0131979166,
0.0578049757,
0.0396564491,
0.038102258,
-0.0682293028,
-0.0254682973,
-0.0129884006,
0.0021801018,
-0.0523926429,
0.0107968068,
0.0827976912,
0.0740652606,
0.0286047608,
-0.0137649653,
0.0344957151,
-0.0602317117,
0.0476095602,
-0.0313326083,
0.0263886768,
0.0150621729,
-0.0334224813,
0.035912849,
0.0091019599,
0.0527334586,
-0.0218377039,
-0.0219986159,
0.0083012879,
0.0056187767,
-0.0020550985,
-0.0145167783,
-0.0164764952,
-0.0181560628,
0.012236719,
-0.0617588013,
0.0647319257,
-0.0885678977,
-0.0191110373,
-0.0061013717,
-0.0029128932,
-0.0153672509,
0.0009840032,
-0.0041904389,
0.0117728068,
0.0071762269,
0.0143864062,
-0.0022533468,
-0.018495867,
-0.0974799469,
-0.0073575093,
-0.0090588061,
-0.0346098021,
-0.004167561,
-0.0266746916,
0.0143810101,
0.0063555758,
-0.0344090201,
0.0003582454,
3.134891446e-34,
0.0080218734,
-0.0074259685,
0.0117958169,
0.0347380005,
0.0695187822,
-0.0042706653,
-0.0200331025,
0.0137613844,
0.0356871374,
-0.0763263553,
-0.0050756442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05689v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05689v1 | Large Language Model for Science: A Study on P vs. NP | 2023-09-11T17:49:27 | 2023-09-11T17:49:27 | Qingxiu Dong, Li Dong, Ke Xu, Guangyan Zhou, Yaru Hao, Zhifang Sui, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we use large language models (LLMs) to augment and accelerate
research on the P versus NP problem, one of the most important open problems in
theoretical computer science and mathematics. Specifically, we propose Socratic
reasoning, a general framework that promotes in-depth thinking with LLMs for
complex problem-solving. Socratic reasoning encourages LLMs to recursively
discover, solve, and integrate problems while facilitating self-evaluation and
refinement. Our pilot study on the P vs. NP problem shows that GPT-4
successfully produces a proof schema and engages in rigorous reasoning
throughout 97 dialogue turns, concluding "P $\neq$ NP", which is in alignment
with (Xu and Zhou, 2023). The investigation uncovers novel insights within the
extensive solution space of LLMs, shedding light on LLM for Science. | [
-0.0059495736,
0.0985541865,
0.0061358297,
0.0386673063,
-0.0605518073,
-0.0217938181,
0.0046937801,
0.0217874832,
0.0178567301,
-0.0102935778,
0.0278910287,
0.0160833653,
-0.0088909455,
0.0042693196,
0.0312685892,
-0.0503790826,
0.0246922188,
-0.0589529052,
0.0522471778,
-0.0387278944,
-0.0234189089,
-0.0491649881,
-0.0053754365,
-0.0260951407,
-0.0071397,
-0.0497343093,
-0.0022912673,
-0.0205919072,
-0.0175106358,
-0.0663100854,
-0.0454797,
0.0443432592,
0.0239916984,
0.1001639515,
0.0000020964,
-0.0506625138,
-0.0186705086,
0.079920128,
-0.0501499027,
0.0535444207,
-0.0119931074,
0.0134547316,
0.0191928837,
-0.0015769639,
-0.0295202881,
-0.0117727583,
0.0432028584,
0.0557547398,
0.0417040922,
0.0344004817,
0.0054520126,
-0.0639921725,
0.0475376174,
0.0033370371,
-0.0055255322,
-0.0472878255,
0.0143797901,
0.0409731753,
0.0654624477,
0.030874569,
-0.0075250557,
0.0378056504,
0.0558590069,
-0.0169168189,
-0.0022558146,
0.0310851,
-0.0285693519,
0.0126670729,
0.0132605173,
0.0435249545,
0.0174287595,
-0.0155379977,
-0.0259028487,
0.0033175619,
-0.0366380513,
0.0314560272,
-0.0658026487,
0.0418914184,
0.0030230677,
-0.0063273776,
-0.0138436155,
-0.0034252338,
0.0329412892,
0.010052233,
-0.0403225273,
0.0916098133,
0.0220357217,
-0.0216616485,
-0.0120930076,
0.0205404013,
0.0043716775,
-0.0295021534,
0.0281448215,
0.0339594781,
-0.0121594975,
0.0148548232,
0.0511286631,
0.0385061689,
0.0255244393,
-0.0442869104,
0.0475846194,
-0.0050969236,
0.0613968112,
0.0504904278,
0.0016721855,
0.0224041957,
-0.073301591,
-0.0091378167,
0.0195518844,
-0.0014146463,
-0.0714007393,
-0.0392028242,
-0.0179171506,
0.042916432,
0.0010052078,
0.0150505463,
0.0078780409,
0.0002414511,
-0.024123041,
0.0165523253,
-0.0503419191,
-0.03644564,
0.0034480214,
-0.0324483067,
-0.0301568713,
0.0326874591,
-0.0179565232,
0.0212260559,
-0.0236924179,
-0.0325661041,
-0.0272195935,
-0.0303005483,
-0.0388058387,
-0.0009520779,
0.0272530187,
0.0699997246,
0.0179712065,
0.0180330183,
0.0211397316,
-0.0226205755,
-0.0071426053,
-0.0720527172,
0.0046564289,
-0.0834372193,
0.0034301153,
0.0149779208,
0.0012273317,
-0.041336827,
0.0085568679,
-0.0182992071,
0.021974396,
0.0845268816,
-0.0201417692,
0.0095514199,
0.0215652194,
0.0328460783,
0.030599419,
0.0225593857,
0.0370181315,
-0.0598845109,
0.0085243313,
-0.025264971,
0.0511405133,
-0.0137494979,
-0.0079362802,
0.0041794018,
0.0170608666,
0.0157241505,
0.0156368539,
0.0590787157,
-0.103508167,
0.0701111853,
-0.0194078553,
0.0018274981,
0.0389319584,
0.0619469211,
-0.0029835261,
0.0393490531,
-0.0315391459,
-0.0257667154,
0.0310245622,
-0.0216793828,
-0.0073895799,
0.0670503527,
-0.0543830767,
0.0038052937,
0.0015020088,
0.0103824642,
-0.0110113444,
-0.0585122071,
-0.0394388773,
0.018907411,
0.024852341,
0.0140539678,
0.0513718165,
-0.0392872095,
0.001405864,
-0.0035934134,
0.0051273098,
-0.0612357259,
-0.0411265679,
-0.0343147516,
0.0726892725,
0.0085245203,
0.0483774617,
-0.0612105466,
-0.0249942094,
-0.0127926897,
0.0082297474,
0.0623948164,
0.0407669507,
-0.0179067571,
-0.0459474027,
-0.0175693184,
0.0123219388,
-0.0354692191,
0.0015392289,
-0.0089194542,
0.0242089964,
0.0013829118,
0.0007047069,
0.0116954958,
-0.0214580502,
-0.0110489773,
-0.0427999608,
-0.0314194076,
-0.024315713,
-0.0150043108,
0.0310389362,
0.0108038308,
-0.0090170633,
0.0590851381,
0.0547417663,
-0.0030571248,
-0.0369371399,
-0.0217408109,
-0.0118356943,
0.0113458904,
0.0502104238,
-0.0953783169,
-0.0103670759,
0.0334612764,
-0.0128954798,
-0.0158652216,
0.0661133677,
-0.035608571,
0.0236146823,
-0.007753734,
0.0077819782,
-0.0779331326,
-0.0082984418,
-0.0314293988,
0.036122378,
0.0614017248,
0.0151234465,
0.0193281304,
-0.0022560642,
0.0435889401,
-0.0316467024,
-0.0257400908,
0.0871921107,
0.0511099286,
0.022676846,
0.0595654249,
-0.0147728696,
-0.0344146863,
-0.0247531552,
-0.0541291311,
-0.0218591969,
0.0362828784,
0.0073254602,
-0.0250805225,
-0.0191117954,
0.0100137116,
0.0148590794,
0.0003771707,
-0.0109976251,
0.0254414976,
0.0002183888,
0.057116624,
0.0167628173,
-0.0423420183,
-0.0142560108,
-0.0164410025,
-0.0519267879,
0.0235395078,
0.0063193226,
0.0147198401,
-0.0332707949,
0.0375643857,
-0.0193977058,
0.0182197448,
-0.0084702913,
0.0070093414,
0.0768664032,
-0.0220044609,
0.0057732686,
0.0413618237,
-0.0274559036,
0.0261614714,
0.0417757966,
-0.0551506989,
-0.0355316922,
0.0150926588,
-0.0070718634,
-0.0213379506,
0.0140235052,
-0.0164342634,
-0.0095539968,
0.0661480501,
-0.0473690853,
-0.0320116132,
-0.0125260185,
0.0463966504,
-0.0286928583,
0.0205089021,
0.0117299762,
-0.0136135053,
0.0023758158,
0.0020591009,
-0.0006551539,
-0.0310812145,
0.0978682116,
-0.03406737,
-0.0124998391,
-0.0885240883,
-0.0218385663,
-0.0651183277,
0.0968828052,
-0.0371164419,
0.0042226617,
0.0003680717,
0.0263368897,
0.0027328967,
-0.0292665325,
0.0320857503,
-0.005670839,
0.0819051191,
-0.066063717,
0.0249854457,
0.0031377494,
-0.0371284969,
0.0050518475,
0.0053238855,
-0.0560137816,
0.0177456178,
-0.0215152428,
-0.0528719425,
0.0114598256,
0.0193702169,
0.0644178092,
0.0144385323,
-0.0151872719,
-0.0297798701,
-0.0066705258,
-0.0548189804,
-0.0360329226,
0.0164362043,
0.0710103512,
-0.062660642,
0.0457966886,
0.0667854771,
0.0499320589,
0.031489633,
-0.0135560334,
-0.0052805105,
0.0125260279,
0.0131219616,
-0.0255203098,
0.0075517958,
0.023074016,
-0.0473808087,
-0.0408732891,
0.0722144917,
0.005089473,
-0.0079560969,
0.0250479188,
-0.0457753651,
0.0076157846,
0.0350991152,
0.0230920427,
-0.0537268221,
-0.0029506709,
-0.0021702219,
-0.0407891385,
-0.0169359334,
-0.0601490848,
-0.0367434882,
-0.0835217983,
0.0169787835,
0.062539205,
-0.0229670275,
-0.0272404924,
-0.049357038,
-0.0035966805,
0.0168279968,
-0.0348085426,
0.0201824941,
0.0068198964,
0.0051645627,
0.0023096465,
0.0194517076,
0.0024723592,
0.0577690639,
0.0064185653,
0.0115817888,
-0.0267847069,
0.0356021076,
-0.0416787229,
-0.0298657976,
0.0437503681,
0.0299014151,
-0.0427950658,
-0.0020140556,
-0.052002117,
0.0450277179,
0.0023070828,
-0.0404557846,
-0.0065381071,
-0.0454049706,
-0.0428829081,
0.0467468314,
0.1165508479,
0.0111818956,
-0.059131898,
-0.0204302873,
0.0016403494,
-0.0177007541,
0.0646505728,
-0.017228609,
0.0174304117,
-0.0559141152,
-0.0575061776,
-0.0420002677,
0.0363858007,
-0.0391552672,
-0.0125387702,
0.0362431854,
0.0261777993,
0.0049184309,
0.0291031823,
0.0657500401,
0.0323506221,
-0.0027523076,
0.0056192535,
0.024926994,
0.0035041044,
-0.0081297336,
-0.0012785487,
-0.0456756391,
0.0303715002,
-0.0367884971,
0.005378908,
0.0311217234,
-0.0024924246,
-0.0145199429,
0.0093671223,
-0.014473686,
-0.0613640137,
-0.0483258963,
0.0080108689,
0.0348306,
-0.0239938349,
0.0337156914,
-0.0331120826,
-0.0320123695,
0.0466684289,
-0.0210876372,
0.0130819473,
0.0074188337,
-0.0137956552,
0.0308175944,
-0.0127515532,
0.0076650111,
-0.0160784144,
-0.003612254,
0.0299482122,
-0.0494203418,
-0.0323839411,
0.0339504033,
0.0842670724,
-0.0007109615,
0.0387607887,
-0.0233956352,
0.0100019863,
0.0114901671,
-0.0492605567,
-0.0159711614,
-0.0377185531,
0.0107219359,
-0.0133037167,
-0.001647322,
0.0131461015,
0.0184333436,
-0.0056701102,
0.0617544614,
-0.0061026681,
0.05069061,
0.0567725934,
-0.0422455668,
0.0682738125,
-0.0365597308,
0.0036946321,
-0.0139687816,
-0.0306821242,
0.0797817782,
-0.0159210041,
0.0275628101,
0.0541571677,
0.007316831,
-0.0349728204,
-0.001157333,
-0.0694816858,
-0.1343688965,
0.0481699109,
0.0429170169,
0.0051867357,
0.0412299819,
-0.0170818157,
-0.0799339041,
-0.0092469612,
-0.0092184665,
0.0264959354,
0.0054828441,
-0.0272886269,
0.0448761098,
0.047990635,
0.0027971154,
-0.0097728362,
0.0311466902,
-0.0063435934,
0.0036461581,
0.0038836098,
0.0095180338,
-0.0415380821,
-0.0371824615,
-0.0343179591,
0.0288465135,
0.0086507462,
0.0124266949,
-0.0778957754,
-0.0442318656,
-0.0554407574,
0.0126375863,
-0.0019829834,
-0.0223229676,
0.0341815911,
0.0690899044,
-0.0160914063,
-0.0361425392,
0.0127482908,
0.0417365246,
0.0095466049,
-0.0273833331,
0.0307634361,
-6.014189094e-33,
-0.0309716631,
-0.027694311,
0.0489310026,
0.0161854196,
-0.0043137586,
-0.0363178737,
-0.0624738783,
0.0136703039,
-0.0363429673,
0.0322158001,
-0.0203775838,
0.0147860302,
-0.0102497572,
-0.0148836616,
0.0038261109,
0.0155872647,
0.0028871079,
0.043551974,
-0.0368037224,
0.0234263334,
0.0150337284,
-0.0330812968,
0.0543967113,
-0.0532207564,
-0.0200550035,
0.0143041546,
0.0283257421,
0.0108845234,
-0.0951806977,
0.0184648763,
0.0050863493,
0.0042826608,
-0.0139151523,
-0.0537270829,
-0.0116564268,
0.0125729209,
0.0217091069,
0.0005070306,
0.0393195525,
-0.0395141877,
-0.0369296819,
-0.0461544134,
-0.0021839412,
0.0125106201,
-0.0426266044,
-0.0342235006,
-0.0046623531,
-0.0309108365,
0.0009674928,
0.0304059107,
-0.0500158668,
0.0135641107,
-0.0280455109,
0.0010304814,
-0.0048907949,
-0.0365603119,
-0.0366595909,
0.0034981014,
0.0239303466,
0.0700880289,
0.0670082867,
-0.0191704948,
0.0188261606,
-0.0301097967,
0.0065945415,
0.0012716136,
0.0327758007,
0.0153449383,
-0.021069264,
-0.0150939496,
-0.0108105913,
0.0422936305,
0.0757416561,
0.0129036196,
-0.0118259927,
0.0190329552,
-0.0864753202,
-0.0469302684,
0.0448112637,
0.0222192723,
0.0445332676,
0.0399409719,
-0.0216933452,
-0.059809424,
-0.0458091386,
0.0083250357,
-0.0161165874,
0.0062182485,
-0.0219023861,
-0.0344733894,
-0.0390264243,
-0.0154397031,
0.0332933404,
-0.0492445715,
-0.0519577228,
0.0604303889,
0.0089215189,
0.0154037774,
0.0099115605,
0.0283690523,
-0.0477801338,
-0.0016282609,
-0.0546914265,
0.0140196821,
0.0340184309,
0.0124462983,
-0.0359009132,
0.047497727,
-0.0128645971,
-0.0107661774,
-0.0540090688,
-0.044343546,
0.0616578124,
-0.0017459429,
-0.0027922217,
0.0128366267,
0.0149148023,
0.0519146658,
-0.0065976763,
-0.0104652531,
-0.0019496259,
0.0790128335,
-0.0256660879,
0.013832829,
0.0381533168,
-0.0205732957,
-0.0529378988,
0.0206849221,
0.0742110237,
-0.0526390448,
-0.0100227818,
0.0043279263,
2.913e-7,
-0.0026559215,
0.060662441,
0.0254766736,
-0.001009929,
0.0355637446,
0.0459654815,
-0.0522202738,
-0.0112577518,
0.001366768,
-0.0276154019,
-0.022000812,
0.0379324183,
0.0148408841,
0.0257905219,
-0.0520370528,
-0.032578472,
-0.0366303176,
-0.0346142203,
-0.0410001054,
-0.002183751,
0.01898201,
-0.0018458082,
0.0369287841,
0.0015191908,
-0.0061106151,
-0.0380693674,
0.04964035,
-0.03019608,
0.0316947438,
0.0506414399,
-0.0564404167,
-0.0187059212,
0.0202769004,
0.0324627608,
0.0325335786,
-0.0002184631,
0.0082702134,
0.0522519201,
0.0263340063,
0.0220736451,
-0.0028007433,
-0.0358219221,
-0.0269430447,
-0.0614286177,
0.049036406,
-0.0360445231,
-0.0733007565,
0.0082093235,
0.0329198949,
-0.0647550523,
0.0044873673,
-0.0007312573,
0.0086663822,
-0.0026971882,
-0.0456333607,
-0.0075943549,
0.008305978,
-0.0434645936,
0.001553103,
0.0443911962,
-0.0568642691,
-0.0601551458,
-0.0097925114,
-0.0171656273,
0.0351315029,
-0.0232198499,
-0.0205143578,
2.873224108e-34,
0.0408722945,
-0.019529108,
0.0578481779,
0.0050642546,
0.0276274253,
0.0246615261,
0.0057107592,
-0.0182864778,
0.0390770137,
-0.0689064488,
-0.0343707167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05653v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05653v3 | MAmmoTH: Building Math Generalist Models through Hybrid Instruction Tuning | 2023-09-11T17:47:22 | 2023-10-03T02:48:42 | Xiang Yue, Xingwei Qu, Ge Zhang, Yao Fu, Wenhao Huang, Huan Sun, Yu Su, Wenhu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce MAmmoTH, a series of open-source large language models (LLMs)
specifically tailored for general math problem-solving. The MAmmoTH models are
trained on MathInstruct, our meticulously curated instruction tuning dataset.
MathInstruct is compiled from 13 math datasets with intermediate rationales,
six of which have rationales newly curated by us. It presents a unique hybrid
of chain-of-thought (CoT) and program-of-thought (PoT) rationales, and also
ensures extensive coverage of diverse fields in math. The hybrid of CoT and PoT
not only unleashes the potential of tool use but also allows different thought
processes for different math problems. As a result, the MAmmoTH series
substantially outperform existing open-source models on nine mathematical
reasoning datasets across all scales with an average accuracy gain between 16%
and 32%. Remarkably, our MAmmoTH-7B model reaches 33% on MATH (a
competition-level dataset), which exceeds the best open-source 7B model
(WizardMath) by 23%, and the MAmmoTH-34B model achieves 44% accuracy on MATH,
even surpassing GPT-4's CoT result. Our work underscores the importance of
diverse problem coverage and the use of hybrid rationales in developing
superior math generalist models. | [
-0.0255709682,
0.1276097149,
0.0050644702,
0.0373910852,
-0.0203558784,
0.0608650595,
-0.0083777718,
-0.0296752714,
-0.0254891086,
0.0015091108,
-0.0106127709,
-0.0032486457,
-0.0324939415,
0.0116685955,
0.0071754502,
-0.0458782241,
0.0207747091,
-0.0523660965,
-0.0137084909,
-0.0060415738,
-0.0382885449,
0.0105018113,
-0.0363229439,
0.0084257713,
-0.00957675,
-0.0910463557,
0.010861611,
-0.0186994299,
0.0104323812,
-0.0092555434,
-0.0134376893,
0.0359395184,
0.0222476795,
0.0280066468,
0.0000025277,
-0.0482699014,
-0.0049564014,
0.0080761807,
-0.0487481765,
0.0141463568,
-0.0445594452,
0.0183255933,
0.0370867029,
0.0246521253,
-0.0425536148,
0.0341521911,
0.027268244,
0.0047949576,
0.0633300096,
0.055466909,
0.0136263808,
-0.0557169206,
0.0414739922,
-0.0060156281,
0.0638277307,
-0.0574169792,
-0.0044786255,
0.0468018577,
0.018055588,
0.0343854874,
-0.0344223902,
0.0086949095,
0.0675880089,
-0.0059094927,
0.0093190074,
-0.0099955378,
-0.0285070743,
-0.0015127889,
0.0174373183,
0.0543772392,
-0.028852541,
-0.0332480893,
-0.0301554576,
-0.0086888149,
0.007032753,
-0.00089694,
-0.0809828192,
0.0526449718,
0.0014561524,
-0.0001706759,
0.0150294201,
-0.0057647205,
0.0142248357,
0.0182540733,
-0.0534107313,
0.0468466431,
0.0009642306,
-0.0262348242,
0.016484648,
0.0118149109,
-0.0904229134,
-0.0302339885,
0.0132234218,
0.0441246927,
-0.0170349963,
-0.0162898619,
-0.0192070212,
-0.0347584151,
-0.0477380715,
0.0052976673,
0.0520536229,
0.0915127695,
0.0207768902,
0.0381405093,
-0.0101159709,
0.0533659235,
-0.0179042406,
0.0385416001,
-0.0330502316,
0.0242729541,
-0.0633508936,
0.0046054325,
-0.0138694178,
0.0634015873,
0.0163917579,
0.0317357257,
-0.041845452,
0.0042862482,
-0.0333571546,
0.0173576251,
0.028342152,
0.0094944937,
0.0045244261,
-0.0535584427,
-0.0228126068,
-0.0020322267,
-0.0715971068,
0.001601903,
0.0099430792,
-0.0286451634,
-0.0484809764,
0.0311088897,
-0.036942102,
-0.0337932222,
0.0353989415,
0.059280023,
-0.0036767614,
0.0167703703,
-0.0207912195,
-0.0158763044,
0.0409354717,
-0.0853697658,
-0.0223263018,
-0.0813808441,
0.0444656722,
0.0292759985,
0.0023225863,
-0.0224847738,
-0.0124527449,
0.0099749686,
0.016035514,
0.0596030578,
0.0212956667,
-0.0033062568,
-0.0004628877,
0.0141484635,
-0.0665329695,
0.0336529091,
0.0317774825,
-0.0074079232,
0.0074637802,
-0.030653758,
0.0006928371,
0.015311107,
0.0061657694,
-0.0152936568,
0.01540644,
0.0458246991,
0.0222542249,
0.0381564498,
-0.0133857727,
0.0323220491,
-0.0303125326,
0.0083081471,
0.0155399181,
0.0534842983,
0.0037830535,
0.0392201133,
0.0416706763,
0.0057338411,
0.023662243,
-0.0092466641,
-0.0624338277,
0.0407162048,
-0.0323870443,
0.0031564292,
0.0057073529,
0.0111953579,
-0.0217048638,
-0.077471368,
-0.0070712371,
0.0197973382,
-0.0525723025,
0.0291388389,
0.0528861992,
-0.0301758479,
-0.0044083232,
0.0356500149,
-0.0042558238,
-0.0386604555,
-0.014753988,
-0.0300764646,
0.0488538779,
-0.0209676512,
0.0562356263,
-0.0628545433,
-0.0283883065,
-0.0480411537,
0.044345513,
0.0139146103,
0.0283168256,
-0.0165841095,
-0.0198051799,
-0.0657078698,
-0.0086679729,
-0.0668117031,
0.0144856116,
-0.0170844272,
0.0596768931,
0.0157741457,
0.0115939882,
-0.0420541316,
-0.0023122451,
0.0183307994,
-0.0520026013,
-0.0783088058,
-0.0279935226,
-0.0027459264,
0.0168216769,
-0.0197207704,
0.0123921027,
0.0334926061,
-0.0044765766,
-0.0220184699,
-0.0167230219,
-0.0154172629,
-0.0709934682,
0.0041430411,
0.0564791262,
-0.0571064241,
-0.0186338834,
0.0025349231,
-0.0658924207,
-0.0242189504,
0.0555862896,
-0.0096116997,
0.0201284438,
0.0043912176,
0.0347261243,
-0.0093757687,
-0.0096349297,
-0.0152414795,
0.0683841854,
-0.0073996112,
0.0105393287,
0.0552772097,
-0.0182719044,
-0.002787048,
-0.0018487007,
0.0325380675,
0.0144943967,
-0.011892166,
0.0197217483,
-0.025151005,
0.0375859253,
-0.0401448272,
-0.0069435141,
0.0087494226,
0.0293149091,
-0.0110303387,
0.0471399948,
0.0049461704,
-0.0315231085,
0.0043498329,
0.002224447,
0.0009630153,
-0.0235220809,
-0.0261427648,
0.0026345081,
0.0117974216,
-0.0119365351,
0.019787861,
-0.0165642016,
-0.0425850265,
-0.0552430525,
0.0545009971,
-0.0029250341,
0.0619147904,
0.0051851561,
0.0470102727,
-0.0284690131,
-0.0057077771,
-0.0173310693,
0.0165630616,
0.0349375308,
-0.0365186818,
0.0121960742,
0.0845839456,
-0.0117182201,
0.0105544832,
0.0142483208,
-0.0110005271,
-0.0554505028,
0.0358660594,
-0.0036618717,
-0.0159967504,
-0.0029158313,
0.0033201098,
-0.0168567616,
0.08219181,
-0.0556600057,
-0.0290063471,
-0.0492542982,
0.0408092067,
-0.0197945014,
-0.0118202623,
-0.0376934446,
0.0111089414,
0.0055585918,
0.01737817,
-0.015710691,
-0.0415018909,
0.0478153378,
0.0237149764,
-0.0064354353,
-0.0729672536,
0.0038824573,
-0.0636506826,
0.0430101119,
0.0031251262,
-0.0307733659,
-0.0300105009,
0.0087342309,
-0.0670388713,
0.0067116604,
0.030888116,
0.0021814946,
0.0662881061,
-0.0468458906,
-0.0070852111,
-0.0154870413,
-0.0423146896,
-0.0316437297,
0.0350823253,
-0.0203806572,
0.0089721344,
0.0016909763,
-0.0699325278,
-0.0266300999,
-0.0337045603,
0.0440069064,
0.020524811,
-0.0206621308,
-0.0297854897,
-0.0117075816,
-0.0304387771,
0.0176159106,
0.0179504063,
0.0499056242,
-0.0716705844,
0.0416647121,
0.0535020195,
0.0522989407,
-0.0330866799,
-0.0045243204,
0.0253035072,
0.0166186206,
-0.0435169302,
-0.0327160172,
0.0349093154,
0.0376249105,
-0.0602817349,
0.0021736263,
0.1247846708,
0.038436573,
-0.0273870472,
-0.00447613,
-0.0720141754,
0.0472372472,
0.0427909046,
0.0060195699,
-0.0814231709,
-0.0561087541,
0.0162697677,
0.0063669495,
0.0280005671,
-0.0516324043,
0.0243153181,
-0.116532512,
0.004305331,
0.0291529018,
-0.015215477,
0.0122484257,
-0.0191939715,
-0.0169923361,
-0.0320485607,
-0.0489786975,
0.0068451934,
-0.0326426029,
0.0559941307,
0.0327245183,
-0.0064155571,
0.0082933996,
0.0362208933,
-0.0005283082,
-0.0505485721,
-0.0153361782,
0.0022722287,
0.001453063,
-0.087143898,
0.0698127151,
0.0400843099,
-0.027478341,
-0.0096631264,
0.0148212472,
-0.0086529935,
0.0076988926,
-0.0226213466,
0.0751411989,
-0.0576412864,
-0.036666248,
0.0467788316,
0.1384731084,
0.0061641177,
-0.0277061518,
-0.0159564465,
-0.0182161368,
-0.0535083376,
0.0613734461,
0.0136058796,
-0.0177866276,
-0.0470605083,
-0.0637993887,
-0.0332207456,
-0.066793561,
-0.0294397734,
0.0250446908,
0.062429823,
-0.0032325569,
0.0070396378,
0.0049659652,
0.059559647,
0.0275749657,
0.0184510797,
-0.054160852,
-0.0146044362,
0.0007668932,
-0.0290629379,
0.0770362169,
-0.0453996323,
0.0040926347,
-0.0683319196,
0.0210455097,
-0.001537413,
-0.0203786977,
-0.0334060751,
0.0517342538,
-0.093395859,
-0.0361825414,
-0.0339661278,
0.0603773296,
0.0224705711,
0.0168721881,
0.0141697153,
-0.0194249786,
0.0135289943,
0.0182045791,
-0.0346457809,
0.0198171977,
0.0532741547,
-0.0113885971,
0.0184541903,
0.0113439411,
0.0021656493,
-0.0093355542,
0.0377193056,
0.0395051241,
-0.0238509327,
0.034830939,
0.0133027732,
0.0285831429,
-0.0417253338,
0.0270680133,
0.0336662605,
-0.0314709656,
0.0438618921,
0.0090466328,
0.0131312497,
-0.0496100411,
0.0146186827,
0.03874477,
-0.0200758949,
0.0183020644,
-0.0211200695,
0.0200602841,
0.0331168063,
-0.0011375243,
0.0559441335,
0.0010578881,
0.0497070774,
0.075424917,
-0.0247218199,
-0.0036592754,
-0.0031217635,
-0.0176274423,
0.0418146551,
-0.009743711,
0.0811479017,
0.0204327162,
0.0483813398,
0.0003216647,
-0.0301784743,
-0.0444874428,
-0.1124666706,
-0.0203222819,
-0.0039803465,
0.0260574017,
-0.0029387141,
-0.0079878056,
-0.0230896007,
-0.010194581,
0.0001819107,
0.0482038148,
0.0316889063,
-0.0231914781,
-0.0014053014,
0.0501943603,
0.0146468198,
-0.0303878505,
0.039973855,
-0.0514621511,
0.0293921791,
0.0211286545,
0.0300141294,
-0.0182974618,
-0.0421201549,
-0.033289101,
0.0333945416,
0.0277821254,
0.0294482578,
-0.0668245703,
-0.0712694079,
-0.0369157642,
-0.016113542,
-0.0113523891,
0.0132709565,
0.0491329394,
0.04238794,
-0.0347482376,
-0.0351359062,
0.0367757604,
0.0407025889,
-0.0245769974,
-0.0263049863,
-0.0258681402,
-6.017909166e-33,
0.0068990667,
-0.0065617436,
0.0271648671,
-0.0046685901,
0.013123828,
-0.0251991078,
-0.0087878359,
0.0211227071,
-0.0284611154,
0.0102821458,
-0.0133490581,
0.0430275016,
-0.0147062391,
0.026309615,
0.0314744264,
-0.0019339919,
0.0145888114,
-0.0145920245,
-0.0263354145,
0.006600623,
0.0139941275,
-0.0067329016,
0.0779604837,
-0.0373535305,
-0.0121152364,
-0.007592259,
0.0235430989,
0.0041602445,
-0.0739437342,
0.0465540811,
-0.0008529458,
0.0167574361,
0.0067928978,
-0.0424646586,
-0.0193954017,
-0.0191877317,
-0.0293817446,
-0.0402003117,
0.0087170796,
0.0035225141,
-0.0661852583,
-0.0788702294,
-0.0146931633,
0.0422584191,
-0.0261934996,
-0.0909046456,
0.0216538515,
-0.0262266733,
0.0046919254,
0.0326395631,
-0.0339000523,
0.0134151699,
-0.0604806915,
-0.0006198683,
-0.0290879607,
0.0347639322,
-0.0071226023,
0.0370731652,
-0.0036734564,
0.0241842698,
0.0303665418,
0.0282887556,
0.0687374175,
-0.0165611617,
0.0141700115,
0.0216823202,
0.0089631649,
-0.0187372454,
-0.0449112058,
0.0124775721,
-0.0166257732,
0.0809249654,
0.0699468851,
-0.0004077675,
0.051837638,
0.0485406592,
-0.0818018019,
-0.0173415262,
0.0076499195,
0.058265131,
0.0089518894,
0.0082844067,
-0.024154095,
0.009516553,
-0.0419352762,
0.0129845152,
-0.0514946915,
-0.0000282618,
0.0250504073,
-0.009817156,
-0.0215239841,
-0.0038822626,
0.0219799429,
-0.0294104461,
0.0003096331,
0.0414277092,
-0.0249430276,
0.0259727892,
0.0080780033,
0.0395921953,
-0.053491015,
-0.025883764,
-0.0092349686,
0.0055463617,
0.0564503744,
0.0151193496,
0.0339668356,
0.0109514045,
-0.025327744,
-0.0288322084,
-0.0726793706,
0.0049149925,
0.0408088565,
0.0463476405,
0.0244116876,
0.035317447,
-0.000397438,
0.066975154,
-0.0417886898,
-0.0202921443,
-0.0101852706,
-0.0133324116,
-0.0040068086,
0.0176597107,
0.0180873573,
-0.0137282386,
-0.0313633047,
-0.0269955788,
0.0287310313,
-0.0809697062,
-0.0208511222,
0.021060463,
3.033e-7,
0.0190661401,
0.0242123343,
0.013211268,
0.040192768,
0.0056432835,
0.0332385302,
-0.0173719134,
-0.0370433256,
0.0263212118,
-0.0126280077,
-0.0183829386,
0.0744622722,
0.030899426,
0.0226230547,
-0.0641751513,
0.0075970897,
-0.0340726376,
0.0043951194,
-0.0841253847,
0.0060841516,
0.0293601062,
0.0762765929,
0.0378423333,
0.0060205543,
0.0216529779,
-0.0187926609,
0.033767622,
-0.0130090741,
-0.001226604,
0.0204051137,
-0.0099107912,
0.0127867265,
0.0097991321,
0.0037789885,
-0.0105212005,
0.0133511405,
0.0048811217,
0.066177845,
0.0388978645,
0.0116665596,
-0.0163117554,
-0.0358477533,
-0.0101499725,
-0.0514774956,
0.0711422488,
-0.0210770052,
-0.0401906408,
0.0184974056,
-0.0296403319,
-0.0485859066,
0.025377389,
-0.0260090977,
0.0803172961,
-0.0190472491,
-0.0029744266,
-0.0200468618,
-0.0035967799,
-0.0419158041,
-0.0379796401,
0.0313464366,
-0.0310316384,
-0.0343550928,
-0.0399501845,
0.0022652827,
0.0462647267,
-0.0312117841,
-0.0335972868,
3.276977718e-34,
0.0450689346,
-0.0026722995,
0.0592228286,
0.0179154258,
0.0420207046,
-0.0238843802,
-0.0211613812,
-0.008120073,
0.0476626456,
-0.0651569664,
-0.0216551367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05619v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05619v2 | Effective Proxy for Human Labeling: Ensemble Disagreement Scores in Large Language Models for Industrial NLP | 2023-09-11T17:07:01 | 2023-11-20T01:24:40 | Wei Du, Laksh Advani, Yashmeet Gambhir, Daniel J Perry, Prashant Shiralkar, Zhengzheng Xing, Aaron Colak | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated significant capability to
generalize across a large number of NLP tasks. For industry applications, it is
imperative to assess the performance of the LLM on unlabeled production data
from time to time to validate for a real-world setting. Human labeling to
assess model error requires considerable expense and time delay. Here we
demonstrate that ensemble disagreement scores work well as a proxy for human
labeling for language models in zero-shot, few-shot, and fine-tuned settings,
per our evaluation on keyphrase extraction (KPE) task. We measure fidelity of
the results by comparing to true error measured from human labeled ground
truth. We contrast with the alternative of using another LLM as a source of
machine labels, or silver labels. Results across various languages and domains
show disagreement scores provide a better estimation of model performance with
mean average error (MAE) as low as 0.4% and on average 13.8% better than using
silver labels. | [
0.0574904531,
0.0535428524,
0.0231574383,
0.0162701234,
-0.0443035439,
0.011902201,
0.0398995988,
0.0079519572,
0.004337884,
-0.0763696954,
-0.029125927,
-0.0121763954,
-0.0250908993,
0.0065267296,
0.0177169051,
-0.0070580826,
0.0335054658,
-0.0114824316,
0.008149799,
-0.0076296944,
-0.0174859278,
0.0000144516,
-0.0311901774,
0.0466557927,
0.015719343,
-0.0064407163,
0.0208173953,
-0.0278885756,
0.0225094892,
-0.0038840109,
0.0116872005,
0.082487531,
-0.0336002074,
0.0782873109,
0.0000013795,
-0.0565637797,
-0.0263464861,
0.0251005199,
-0.0531719737,
0.0371256955,
0.0371208899,
0.0381000303,
-0.0047649052,
0.0153854135,
-0.0275515523,
-0.021455694,
0.0601499565,
0.0417967923,
0.0651733875,
0.014929832,
0.0033983437,
-0.0264081638,
-0.0230683871,
-0.0164916161,
-0.0332518183,
-0.089359656,
0.0346876718,
-0.0198058747,
-0.02522997,
0.0025984384,
0.0339033827,
0.0409488007,
-0.028393425,
0.0141024217,
0.0564695783,
0.0271747019,
-0.0693478361,
-0.040777199,
-0.0023933484,
0.0707727447,
0.0161283184,
0.0088617811,
-0.0069047445,
-0.0163279623,
-0.0100650592,
0.0225600302,
-0.0156298447,
0.0165787116,
-0.019591786,
0.0102634393,
-0.0186965391,
-0.0134452237,
0.0123111829,
0.0266437512,
-0.0122999912,
0.0872503296,
0.0148083773,
-0.037052948,
0.0513600409,
0.041933421,
-0.0687886998,
-0.0239542183,
0.034235511,
-0.0268245414,
-0.0449824333,
0.0470192358,
-0.0211232565,
-0.0285491906,
0.0356598608,
-0.0670659915,
0.0156129003,
-0.0410538651,
-0.0132842315,
0.0643970892,
-0.0150262015,
0.0740197003,
0.033906851,
0.0282626543,
-0.0241750162,
-0.0255466774,
-0.0864688009,
-0.0086780088,
-0.0160432328,
0.0255955067,
-0.0046459502,
-0.0259204917,
-0.0576254986,
-0.0150605794,
-0.0397256576,
0.0545111261,
0.040521998,
0.0076954663,
-0.0025507084,
-0.0097520193,
-0.0059284787,
0.0180375818,
-0.0065264953,
-0.0061124498,
-0.0004670368,
-0.0534430183,
0.0010572729,
0.0155786425,
0.007347926,
-0.0093323663,
0.0142090945,
0.0244055036,
-0.0051819077,
-0.0401274636,
0.0215010475,
-0.0285830032,
-0.0455036126,
-0.0208271015,
-0.0151605085,
-0.0693098679,
0.033865314,
0.017348567,
0.0135246543,
-0.0519347303,
0.0110467244,
-0.0053369803,
-0.0403170846,
0.087163493,
-0.0078259055,
0.0078445831,
0.0209595095,
-0.0096094767,
-0.0101135913,
0.0277990736,
0.0208112448,
0.0133789629,
0.0807303116,
-0.0107019655,
0.0442889668,
0.0364621095,
-0.0137117552,
-0.0125185773,
-0.0349298641,
-0.0263762176,
0.0319283269,
0.0070362655,
-0.0131037431,
0.0436227284,
-0.0025049513,
0.0251946989,
0.0408101045,
0.0578199588,
-0.0071040951,
-0.0295763984,
-0.0166609678,
0.0377469659,
0.0299566258,
-0.0162662026,
-0.0169744659,
-0.0379972123,
-0.0443549715,
0.0378195606,
0.0672310516,
0.0004170933,
0.0186408646,
-0.0499291457,
-0.0811897367,
0.032612741,
-0.0375468433,
0.0003017406,
0.0815846249,
-0.0458301455,
-0.026119668,
0.0630675852,
0.0328496583,
-0.0332843438,
-0.0131986691,
-0.0267841406,
-0.0100593986,
0.0455213785,
0.0421347432,
-0.0357259326,
-0.0158167239,
0.0140332291,
-0.0082410136,
0.0604115538,
0.0592678115,
-0.0360945947,
0.0154155521,
-0.0220176857,
-0.0467603356,
0.0334685929,
0.0334849246,
-0.012795141,
0.0443323255,
-0.0248047989,
0.0052827918,
-0.058301989,
-0.0506071337,
0.0554054715,
-0.0085094767,
-0.0476807728,
-0.0055661509,
-0.0051157759,
0.027005272,
0.0450240076,
-0.0434605256,
0.0348891132,
0.0453640968,
-0.007361792,
-0.0248098094,
-0.0328971259,
0.0125655206,
-0.008905367,
0.0668153465,
0.0101939635,
-0.0239641145,
-0.0239635482,
-0.0502234213,
-0.0417074785,
-0.0190441832,
-0.0244769882,
-0.001007951,
-0.028320007,
0.0324681439,
-0.0278206635,
-0.0146558695,
-0.0740567073,
0.0575420037,
0.0115125766,
0.0439607091,
-0.0609208122,
-0.038673196,
-0.0122862346,
-0.0202514436,
-0.0285841431,
0.0780634806,
0.0103529831,
0.0107059162,
0.0397014879,
-0.0248556137,
-0.0592582636,
-0.0058293664,
-0.0902225003,
-0.0024616346,
0.0075279232,
0.0144603429,
0.0122211091,
-0.0336993001,
-0.0103164185,
-0.0111690713,
0.0004578323,
-0.0376408584,
0.0126599912,
0.010716931,
0.020990992,
0.0240262356,
-0.0227814298,
-0.0299130846,
0.0165408738,
0.0019856752,
0.0662529171,
0.0203293562,
-0.0416382253,
-0.0645940676,
0.0289645512,
-0.0179734305,
-0.0002997134,
0.0333225243,
-0.009003208,
0.0046561654,
0.0032669478,
-0.0047978531,
0.0186572298,
0.0026524765,
-0.0035725418,
0.0385958217,
-0.0202936344,
-0.0596361049,
-0.0353233367,
-0.0034778484,
-0.0507793427,
0.0186762735,
-0.0310580675,
0.0328838564,
0.0827635974,
-0.0047039874,
0.010485583,
-0.0290796179,
0.0204057824,
-0.0387445018,
-0.0159797668,
-0.0524136014,
-0.007093153,
-0.0150307519,
0.041171018,
-0.0207662787,
-0.0314961635,
0.0696712732,
-0.0426767319,
0.0161824059,
-0.047666356,
0.0045791613,
0.0066432958,
0.0312217623,
-0.0210395399,
-0.0039089923,
0.0527578853,
-0.0093154432,
0.0180410147,
-0.0309264697,
0.0312734134,
-0.0607284829,
0.0606206805,
-0.0990293324,
0.0401292928,
0.0231139604,
0.0093999701,
-0.0323584378,
-0.0281847585,
-0.0704039559,
0.0207115598,
0.0162194893,
-0.0036559752,
-0.0367292129,
0.02950323,
0.0369617529,
0.0136297774,
0.0153224301,
0.0039309352,
0.0126893334,
0.0222443454,
0.0368514247,
0.0095962361,
0.0378188193,
-0.0334401429,
0.0311212409,
0.0140147619,
0.083627373,
0.0274851415,
-0.0147139048,
-0.0373999067,
0.0240353346,
-0.0595400967,
-0.0369472764,
-0.0166805629,
0.0383486636,
-0.0069111953,
0.0022429654,
0.1065554246,
0.0331267752,
-0.0599738173,
-0.0137063991,
0.0173035748,
-0.0095368512,
0.029995257,
0.0336172916,
-0.0071116574,
-0.04590711,
0.0173554774,
0.0634903312,
-0.014356642,
-0.0491639748,
-0.002235051,
-0.1343675703,
0.0381482951,
0.0097166533,
-0.0474032909,
-0.0423168428,
-0.0767605454,
0.0160332322,
-0.0540949702,
0.0196425263,
-0.0027794703,
0.0007979395,
0.0189035702,
0.0481761433,
-0.0336386673,
-0.1304717064,
0.0202918202,
-0.0815257132,
0.0612211227,
0.0792436227,
-0.0109080086,
-0.0321927816,
-0.0206145663,
0.0324081667,
-0.0107473219,
-0.0129403155,
0.0079298727,
0.0368709192,
-0.0214230977,
-0.0017214911,
0.0103564179,
-0.0328114666,
-0.0490376987,
-0.0103304982,
0.012641415,
0.0347788706,
0.0222767722,
-0.0111570861,
0.0436007641,
-0.0202131663,
-0.0294434894,
0.051064305,
0.0173896253,
-0.004580826,
-0.0308455471,
-0.0184054337,
0.017562924,
-0.0350960307,
-0.0233217813,
0.0147460094,
-0.0659457594,
-0.0113554085,
-0.061441116,
-0.036842186,
0.0605738461,
0.0298232622,
-0.0392856672,
0.0093426174,
-0.0031812666,
0.0412313864,
-0.0104046836,
0.0082665663,
-0.0305885132,
0.0009857769,
-0.0628810972,
-0.0092609841,
0.0249618404,
0.0438135266,
-0.0357962921,
0.0229282361,
-0.0361671336,
-0.0630141124,
0.0477164872,
0.0041946834,
0.0247503389,
0.0038342085,
-0.0098602818,
-0.0622807294,
0.0342244767,
0.0753613785,
-0.0003351022,
0.0127201388,
-0.0007281995,
-0.0117575508,
-0.0360527784,
0.0030942382,
-0.0673146918,
0.0279923938,
0.0242701508,
0.0826137885,
-0.0235145893,
-0.067187272,
0.0192990843,
0.0510733463,
0.0757701695,
-0.0310434978,
-0.0126100369,
-0.0306511018,
-0.0140286135,
0.0389041789,
-0.0564121045,
-0.0108570876,
0.0075802491,
0.0006757693,
-0.0605186671,
-0.0120970495,
0.0537710488,
-0.0232742913,
0.0516574532,
-0.0154514425,
-0.0161883421,
0.0004096429,
0.0073497663,
-0.0110944957,
-0.0096826553,
-0.0343794599,
-0.0135542369,
0.0211095437,
0.0417852439,
0.0014581806,
0.0109379329,
0.0160966571,
-0.0360376798,
-0.011941378,
0.04623973,
-0.0795491338,
-0.0117048062,
-0.0470661148,
0.0495334454,
0.0712031275,
0.0057890201,
0.0263958629,
-0.0232059453,
-0.028194258,
-0.0211277138,
0.0144226421,
0.0071072159,
0.0326366127,
0.0136528648,
0.0353990793,
-0.02541738,
0.0243614037,
0.0702445358,
0.0527897105,
0.032960128,
-0.0447385237,
-0.0585495457,
-0.0440061726,
0.0112567991,
0.0029448289,
-0.0253741965,
-0.027016772,
0.0113396207,
-0.0503694415,
-0.037511915,
0.0514515862,
0.0193827357,
0.0351627469,
-0.000510055,
-0.0075373743,
0.0885293707,
0.0138736237,
0.0034988604,
-0.0568942428,
-0.0022027299,
0.0004412786,
0.0253327377,
-0.0474367365,
-5.630821081e-33,
-0.0500667095,
-0.0535956025,
-0.0372929871,
-0.0357034355,
-0.0038777813,
-0.0010040824,
-0.0011360188,
0.0145576745,
0.0207074508,
0.018357262,
-0.0170080122,
0.0111808721,
0.0451077409,
-0.0316337757,
0.0502625853,
-0.0489153415,
0.0295836385,
0.0004169455,
-0.0262092594,
-0.0078262435,
-0.0003597566,
0.0251103714,
0.0973755941,
-0.0663891807,
0.0858023092,
-0.0050671087,
0.005389798,
-0.0132790525,
0.015854137,
0.0550912656,
-0.0179961286,
0.044231277,
0.0106660984,
-0.0596232601,
-0.0002639528,
-0.0391205736,
-0.0263745748,
0.0015420502,
-0.0204228517,
0.0252057649,
0.019594498,
0.003032702,
0.0352658741,
-0.0293463618,
-0.0685056821,
0.04091103,
0.0385934114,
-0.0304791536,
-0.0494757965,
-0.0213458017,
-0.0062756226,
0.032293383,
0.0282150432,
0.0231260397,
0.0216119085,
0.0280233659,
-0.0273144525,
0.0473916791,
-0.0510900021,
-0.0046117669,
0.0329620056,
0.0119214291,
0.0886932313,
0.0622636788,
0.0186345223,
0.0453979746,
0.0309108309,
-0.0159709435,
0.006613865,
-0.0536476299,
0.0247885007,
0.0125635322,
0.0515509583,
0.0545379482,
0.0449440442,
0.0246118736,
0.0057560005,
0.0269266646,
-0.0357890762,
0.0043672486,
0.0372765996,
0.0314455517,
-0.0542264059,
-0.0126648955,
-0.0436033905,
-0.0096295364,
-0.0458629616,
0.01202578,
0.0137031339,
0.0056244344,
-0.0727439523,
0.0333351418,
0.0040995078,
-0.017116582,
-0.0164622944,
-0.0375128128,
0.0487552434,
0.026870355,
-0.0188654177,
-0.004076411,
-0.0671756938,
-0.0124086244,
0.0017777201,
0.0345738754,
0.0419831201,
-0.044089485,
-0.0112492032,
-0.0206262134,
-0.0619123913,
0.0197093114,
-0.035535194,
-0.0041089472,
-0.0094447872,
-0.0039029715,
0.0335241556,
0.0108730616,
-0.0055417116,
0.0337765142,
0.0317655653,
0.0051932363,
0.0378957763,
0.0110274516,
0.00621195,
0.0003780492,
0.002444393,
0.0104484782,
0.0099497577,
-0.0132106598,
-0.0090348637,
0.0313975103,
-0.010713255,
-0.0128059294,
2.175e-7,
0.0289426837,
0.0855275989,
0.0173767395,
-0.0011275093,
-0.0248288773,
0.0557290129,
-0.0314934291,
-0.0170735363,
-0.0075710085,
-0.0557586513,
0.0168088656,
0.0045641125,
0.0556468852,
0.0364946462,
-0.0228760075,
-0.0456593223,
-0.0577632934,
0.0305538028,
-0.0133118276,
0.008625756,
0.0638565198,
0.0692149475,
0.0259741582,
0.0105364267,
-0.0394048579,
-0.0465955213,
0.0467673801,
-0.0182544403,
-0.0031120901,
0.0008578487,
0.0636928305,
0.0143853649,
-0.0112960674,
0.0672153085,
0.0109034255,
-0.0113707129,
0.050815057,
0.0273012687,
-0.0119895097,
-0.011519514,
-0.035973683,
-0.0296084564,
0.0411016867,
-0.0344579406,
0.0497731604,
-0.0353326462,
-0.015916178,
-0.049257759,
-0.0492883958,
-0.0208067819,
0.0171594694,
-0.0262588207,
-0.0038578052,
0.0139049459,
-0.0115996283,
-0.0000528831,
-0.0519113503,
-0.0455824696,
-0.0045202412,
0.0057571204,
-0.0212179106,
-0.0268020071,
0.0163178835,
-0.0118576018,
-0.036738947,
-0.0535397045,
0.0082568219,
1.823791768e-34,
0.0394614227,
0.0275494941,
-0.0252140481,
0.0566849411,
0.0342780948,
-0.0096167615,
-0.025060188,
0.009791404,
-0.0225643124,
-0.0497091971,
0.0438933894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05608v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05608v1 | Incorporating Pre-trained Model Prompting in Multimodal Stock Volume Movement Prediction | 2023-09-11T16:47:01 | 2023-09-11T16:47:01 | Ruibo Chen, Zhiyuan Zhang, Yi Liu, Ruihan Bao, Keiko Harimoto, Xu Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CE | Multimodal stock trading volume movement prediction with stock-related news
is one of the fundamental problems in the financial area. Existing multimodal
works that train models from scratch face the problem of lacking universal
knowledge when modeling financial news. In addition, the models ability may be
limited by the lack of domain-related knowledge due to insufficient data in the
datasets. To handle this issue, we propose the Prompt-based MUltimodal Stock
volumE prediction model (ProMUSE) to process text and time series modalities.
We use pre-trained language models for better comprehension of financial news
and adopt prompt learning methods to leverage their capability in universal
knowledge to model textual information. Besides, simply fusing two modalities
can cause harm to the unimodal representations. Thus, we propose a novel
cross-modality contrastive alignment while reserving the unimodal heads beside
the fusion head to mitigate this problem. Extensive experiments demonstrate
that our proposed ProMUSE outperforms existing baselines. Comprehensive
analyses further validate the effectiveness of our architecture compared to
potential variants and learning mechanisms. | [
-0.0073691676,
0.0869273469,
0.0010103788,
-0.0066994559,
0.0163805205,
-0.0107066529,
0.0551323891,
-0.0089206891,
-0.0303484853,
-0.0391325876,
-0.0561968386,
-0.057499595,
-0.0255027004,
0.0732452869,
0.0272882935,
-0.080235064,
0.0419797376,
-0.0067341384,
-0.0163215119,
0.0070703486,
0.0486360863,
0.0154415872,
-0.0134283351,
0.0008926855,
-0.0359287523,
-0.0389556885,
-0.0453497842,
0.0157453474,
0.0157513786,
-0.0309833251,
0.0027895868,
0.0308774672,
0.0570462123,
0.0294702314,
0.0000020279,
-0.0402152948,
-0.0057598855,
-0.0258025005,
0.0094057061,
-0.0358133316,
0.0539574213,
-0.0820593536,
0.0484824814,
-0.0286458675,
-0.0624250621,
-0.0112970984,
0.0606980212,
0.0875011384,
0.0801175311,
0.0703120083,
-0.0320131667,
-0.0073427651,
0.021445794,
-0.0374231786,
0.0209341086,
-0.0531200618,
-0.0019856936,
0.0216270182,
-0.0179060418,
0.0215058327,
-0.0569005609,
0.0474765263,
-0.0103005273,
0.0124352714,
-0.0205142405,
0.0263069253,
0.050942488,
-0.0308158435,
-0.0792858154,
0.0939247459,
0.0221885722,
0.0291687213,
-0.0137035009,
-0.0180645566,
-0.0020210673,
0.0552747995,
-0.05413853,
0.0066725174,
-0.0054925326,
0.0111051099,
-0.028311573,
0.0255901348,
0.0030270782,
-0.0392965451,
0.0101174079,
-0.0168247279,
-0.0121548269,
-0.0160093009,
0.012635259,
-0.0063140681,
-0.0044431887,
-0.0454196036,
-0.0172010101,
0.0105194505,
-0.0263785683,
-0.0091817947,
-0.0345627069,
-0.0414838493,
-0.0273928549,
-0.058271654,
0.0111930976,
0.0458869077,
-0.0707764551,
0.0473662727,
-0.0137487752,
-0.0027067205,
-0.020102568,
0.0090812342,
-0.0097578354,
0.0199576132,
-0.0230983254,
-0.0074369935,
-0.0296584591,
-0.0089553725,
-0.0716145337,
-0.0654037967,
-0.0338382199,
0.0274742469,
0.0133966142,
0.0125768306,
0.0127326706,
-0.0042878063,
-0.0495653339,
-0.0082128812,
-0.027998399,
0.0706436113,
-0.0346283279,
0.0292754043,
-0.01398589,
-0.0193461087,
0.0193611979,
0.0269077811,
-0.01785063,
-0.0182481781,
-0.0126745198,
0.1095631197,
-0.012079969,
-0.005069524,
-0.0618817285,
-0.0670271739,
-0.014108046,
-0.0151828453,
-0.00737216,
0.0070392485,
0.0149184419,
-0.0256989356,
0.00657776,
0.0235428289,
-0.0006316248,
-0.0187150668,
-0.0048839017,
0.1033553258,
-0.0060465652,
-0.0245445985,
0.0047944216,
-0.0261507072,
0.0035868536,
0.0767327771,
-0.0177716501,
0.0396370403,
0.046306137,
-0.00902157,
-0.0216142386,
0.0311580151,
0.0044799084,
-0.0453971438,
-0.0330437906,
0.0119388094,
0.0277310107,
0.012303778,
0.0827378407,
0.0149369687,
-0.0046704239,
-0.0251311008,
0.0953225121,
-0.0268417504,
0.0476126634,
0.0095968824,
0.0421680622,
-0.0120213376,
-0.0258982684,
0.0094368318,
-0.0367726646,
0.0441729985,
-0.0589133501,
0.0372000672,
0.0301182959,
0.0475086719,
-0.0339242555,
-0.0376523621,
0.0341828801,
-0.0240516029,
-0.0176763646,
-0.0070206118,
0.0411710776,
-0.0316154361,
-0.0564154312,
0.0243407432,
0.0465242304,
-0.0159914512,
0.0028905494,
0.0418586247,
0.0407813899,
0.0617721826,
-0.0017323212,
-0.0199346971,
-0.0083203409,
-0.0227894709,
0.0031558045,
0.0470550396,
0.0309400968,
-0.0013828321,
0.0057707597,
-0.0650237873,
-0.0620506294,
0.0115939397,
-0.006280724,
0.0261534359,
-0.0605979189,
0.0229800381,
-0.0030232519,
-0.0143706268,
0.0430164039,
0.0202619564,
0.0086586289,
-0.033980675,
-0.0316463038,
0.0195518192,
-0.004590902,
0.0112844128,
-0.0100019723,
-0.006842698,
-0.0144279627,
-0.0239498317,
-0.0183382519,
0.055553019,
-0.0800979063,
-0.0385605842,
0.0133663239,
-0.0350150503,
-0.0075349608,
-0.0113466121,
-0.03769264,
-0.0378377251,
0.0190012194,
0.0029190516,
0.0067634205,
-0.0495127365,
-0.0548631921,
0.0511446483,
0.0172149707,
-0.0075771231,
0.0582177378,
-0.0107847145,
0.0071700364,
0.0148865543,
0.0285472274,
0.0158001445,
0.0032027378,
-0.017343577,
0.0177246146,
0.0067696865,
0.0298865046,
0.0287704878,
-0.0378145054,
0.0014283218,
0.0187049899,
-0.127113387,
-0.0229747221,
-0.0064835232,
0.0011296683,
0.0151019543,
0.0327383652,
-0.0105490116,
-0.0643162727,
-0.0440647975,
0.0128138419,
-0.0083063561,
0.0118312156,
0.038883172,
0.0306910183,
0.0510666892,
-0.0266824979,
0.0130254487,
-0.0290814601,
0.0476361886,
0.0264242776,
-0.0068115825,
-0.0289712865,
-0.0254822318,
-0.0255763866,
0.0558394007,
-0.0118500469,
0.0165254585,
0.0050549507,
-0.0232190844,
0.0566235855,
0.0370777063,
0.0316097923,
0.0255241301,
-0.0368019044,
-0.0349736474,
-0.0215981398,
0.0458642878,
-0.0210731421,
0.0005100266,
-0.0276680551,
0.0121140536,
-0.0075187297,
0.076708667,
0.0128371837,
0.0065851388,
-0.0797725469,
-0.0024145208,
0.015309046,
0.0192850158,
-0.0583307967,
0.0197856314,
-0.0059478288,
0.0613428056,
-0.0286114272,
-0.0395780392,
0.0519244,
-0.0184104778,
-0.049768094,
0.0234577302,
-0.0129738301,
-0.0515331253,
0.0431779884,
-0.0327169523,
0.0299203452,
-0.0006458266,
-0.0418667309,
-0.0674087256,
-0.0145261399,
0.0198221132,
0.0079299584,
0.0191344339,
-0.0136332912,
0.0169471372,
0.0039700223,
-0.0161307044,
-0.0190135632,
-0.0995222405,
-0.0393293053,
-0.0061221602,
-0.0000031465,
-0.0191111453,
-0.040178217,
0.0348339118,
-0.0001337615,
-0.0055067101,
-0.0011395087,
-0.0371796116,
0.0152841862,
0.0549477413,
0.0663064346,
0.0310743116,
-0.0389176756,
-0.0720269978,
0.0596927181,
0.0057919067,
0.0246127006,
-0.0116628269,
-0.0667112023,
0.0441964529,
0.0012037767,
0.0152308261,
-0.0050621442,
0.0189540386,
0.0328019969,
0.0065778801,
0.0532748774,
0.0890054256,
-0.016816413,
-0.0195942093,
-0.0129556702,
0.0308992714,
-0.0038376483,
-0.0074821804,
0.0146388244,
-0.0926618874,
-0.0668984056,
-0.032360483,
-0.0028783374,
0.0614191145,
-0.0330807865,
-0.0091700256,
-0.093830131,
0.0357363634,
0.0016332314,
-0.0139056798,
-0.0010395792,
-0.0383657627,
0.0231809933,
-0.0448618084,
0.0135299321,
0.000247715,
-0.0243131742,
0.0115872147,
0.033605922,
0.0006211112,
-0.0236182958,
-0.024923332,
-0.0286917463,
-0.0259208791,
0.0506685451,
-0.0052344366,
-0.0204942003,
-0.0255367886,
-0.0391819701,
0.0035014753,
0.0445169061,
0.0010742043,
0.0611246042,
-0.0638574213,
-0.0304859821,
-0.0011365036,
0.0387864411,
0.0082226507,
0.0186654944,
-0.0226509403,
0.0324926041,
-0.0126632052,
-0.0128026847,
-0.0399637595,
0.0707212389,
0.04094157,
0.0392256975,
-0.001717323,
-0.0598149225,
-0.0166366771,
-0.0209220126,
0.0192669667,
-0.0205601063,
-0.0095349383,
0.0250923857,
0.0015468204,
-0.0296527203,
-0.0703597814,
-0.0496813431,
-0.0085807852,
0.0566217788,
0.0308945458,
0.0090954667,
-0.0131552974,
0.0197022371,
-0.0304369498,
0.0432193056,
0.0109487176,
0.0125063881,
-0.0379392281,
0.0339008234,
0.0119797336,
-0.0473938063,
-0.02899516,
0.0374782272,
-0.0675383657,
-0.0407018214,
-0.0454999879,
0.0142078949,
0.0165453739,
0.008020618,
0.0087567652,
0.0181303509,
0.0539834462,
0.0624545924,
-0.0258679502,
-0.032605771,
0.0413050242,
0.0435074605,
0.0031728672,
0.011154321,
-0.0378034823,
0.0402797721,
-0.0127548911,
0.0050601335,
-0.0364402384,
-0.0460726619,
0.0041100541,
-0.0259996876,
0.0647718236,
-0.0028113162,
-0.0048225112,
-0.0423080623,
-0.0358828492,
0.0231521837,
-0.0183852743,
-0.0468406416,
-0.0018160556,
0.0276819076,
0.0014019186,
-0.0161020048,
0.048348397,
0.017287923,
0.0024152803,
-0.0477207378,
0.0091180829,
0.01729789,
0.026850922,
-0.0153079145,
0.0191404521,
0.0187982619,
0.0046900613,
0.0174447689,
-0.001095771,
0.0096554738,
0.0782538801,
0.0371067785,
0.0074512442,
-0.007825288,
0.0028534203,
-0.0476094373,
-0.0126807941,
-0.0147791663,
0.0295291636,
0.0031841912,
-0.032363262,
-0.0276649445,
-0.0192677472,
0.0260800477,
0.0011632927,
0.0548178032,
0.0130373873,
-0.005619036,
0.0524429902,
-0.0065281568,
-0.0261298884,
-0.0264121741,
0.0790094733,
-0.059719909,
0.0367742106,
-0.00916781,
0.0017104177,
-0.0545682684,
0.0059642149,
0.098797299,
0.0251652133,
-0.0039454778,
0.0194891226,
-0.0563186817,
-0.0306038652,
0.0381131731,
0.0205510054,
-0.0362960957,
0.0275303181,
0.0401901752,
0.0666356534,
0.0136950649,
0.026552029,
-0.0062311413,
0.0046568662,
-0.0027676376,
0.0015268103,
-0.0422577336,
-6.358617755e-33,
-0.0186502412,
0.0134362085,
0.0212296229,
-0.0424780808,
-0.0185609199,
0.0298804995,
-0.0232441053,
-0.0201760549,
0.0109566823,
0.0139797907,
0.0283578616,
-0.011175598,
0.0124429725,
0.007968219,
0.02037156,
0.0068673398,
0.0412455797,
-0.0296599548,
-0.0208956692,
-0.0047842953,
0.0518605001,
0.0854770914,
0.059902668,
-0.031151684,
0.0297528654,
-0.0004314271,
-0.062405996,
0.0149219828,
0.0675333738,
0.0321997404,
-0.0304581635,
0.0422248095,
0.0177556779,
-0.0518405437,
-0.0536093563,
0.080406107,
-0.0332810767,
-0.0468661115,
0.0525481068,
0.0128166759,
-0.068754144,
0.029297512,
0.0262746103,
-0.0318976119,
0.0360657647,
-0.0024037673,
0.0649644062,
-0.0053451378,
0.0193578955,
0.0025400743,
-0.0516452529,
0.0255046263,
-0.0334428325,
-0.0125292009,
0.0554628707,
0.1131939143,
0.0524696559,
0.0220164098,
-0.0203781854,
0.0300969053,
-0.0244786646,
-0.0021554022,
0.0336250886,
0.0437956788,
-0.0292260498,
0.0709936172,
-0.013805774,
-0.0469521992,
-0.0001858299,
0.0372592732,
0.02181831,
0.0703236088,
-0.0023534577,
0.0832214579,
0.028174432,
0.0130136665,
-0.0246932507,
0.0472390428,
0.0004347279,
-0.008545205,
-0.0042972025,
0.0273355208,
-0.0105794389,
-0.0041261734,
-0.0062004197,
-0.0262324903,
-0.0314507373,
-0.0368282571,
0.0245353468,
0.023989806,
0.0213370174,
0.0532124005,
0.0592568554,
-0.0273679197,
-0.033221256,
-0.0029928854,
0.0159886237,
0.0274249408,
0.0002976508,
-0.0052299444,
-0.0256301425,
-0.0367450416,
0.0502354689,
-0.0193548631,
-0.0127904741,
-0.0196128394,
0.0188159496,
0.0433226824,
-0.0504134223,
-0.0227855965,
0.0011793518,
-0.0003083668,
0.016516462,
0.0195331145,
0.0477043763,
0.0102615114,
-0.0548494495,
0.018317638,
-0.0167990755,
0.0197380316,
-0.0259951297,
-0.0775513798,
-0.0057372935,
0.0520300195,
0.0080147916,
-0.0070682773,
0.0070174239,
-0.0165896714,
-0.0012780786,
-0.0735024214,
-0.0127735017,
0.067591235,
2.75e-7,
0.0234474409,
0.0247371197,
0.0174341723,
0.0009874695,
0.0226288587,
0.0539170094,
-0.0498276204,
0.0490819477,
0.0079787048,
-0.05234126,
0.0473051444,
0.0204472616,
0.0426839292,
0.0095661571,
-0.0581057258,
-0.0606785044,
-0.0459628701,
0.0228492264,
-0.0651435927,
0.0456403233,
0.0531010441,
0.0785059109,
-0.0163599886,
-0.0218591485,
0.0352972373,
-0.0257260725,
0.0584395044,
-0.0429182947,
-0.0344835483,
-0.018664157,
0.0304022059,
-0.0065702279,
-0.0319149345,
0.0161396787,
-0.0139498981,
-0.0021072917,
0.0271773506,
-0.015817998,
0.0155506143,
-0.0300411824,
-0.0039202268,
0.0399269126,
-0.0551429465,
-0.0126020648,
0.0486052781,
-0.0481575839,
-0.032848794,
-0.0615438186,
-0.0824967548,
0.01237367,
0.0213883892,
0.008517419,
-0.0274684168,
0.0391415954,
0.0250767246,
-0.009110108,
-0.0167626739,
-0.0592441373,
-0.0149198165,
0.0167365484,
-0.0592247024,
-0.0121569959,
-0.0381277017,
-0.0509435534,
0.0346643813,
-0.0668273345,
0.006179844,
2.010085697e-34,
0.0572309457,
-0.0148851359,
0.0019190799,
-0.0051602116,
0.0155343059,
-0.0237665288,
-0.0324210152,
0.0026213704,
0.0258889347,
-0.0853424743,
-0.036187049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05605v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05605v3 | Memory Injections: Correcting Multi-Hop Reasoning Failures during Inference in Transformer-Based Language Models | 2023-09-11T16:39:30 | 2024-02-28T21:00:13 | Mansi Sakarvadia, Aswathy Ajith, Arham Khan, Daniel Grzenda, Nathaniel Hudson, André Bauer, Kyle Chard, Ian Foster | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Answering multi-hop reasoning questions requires retrieving and synthesizing
information from diverse sources. Large Language Models (LLMs) struggle to
perform such reasoning consistently. Here we propose an approach to pinpoint
and rectify multi-hop reasoning failures through targeted memory injections on
LLM attention heads. First, we analyze the per-layer activations of GPT-2
models in response to single and multi-hop prompts. We then propose a mechanism
that allows users to inject pertinent prompt-specific information, which we
refer to as "memories," at critical LLM locations during inference. By thus
enabling the LLM to incorporate additional relevant information during
inference, we enhance the quality of multi-hop prompt completions. We show
empirically that a simple, efficient, and targeted memory injection into a key
attention layer can often increase the probability of the desired next token in
multi-hop tasks, by up to 424%. | [
0.0306760035,
0.0446152538,
-0.0162236709,
0.0341469608,
-0.0511179827,
0.0062217303,
-0.002977944,
-0.0289389808,
0.0386478081,
-0.0324100591,
-0.0035170473,
-0.0419597626,
0.0132160801,
-0.0006393264,
0.0272718687,
-0.0143513065,
0.0663114488,
-0.048870299,
-0.0356921628,
-0.008995383,
-0.0440958403,
0.0200267658,
-0.0041237939,
0.0562689081,
-0.0156525727,
-0.0228346121,
-0.0320873223,
0.0123428749,
0.0030005102,
-0.0093569458,
-0.0196610894,
0.0473863743,
-0.0023536435,
0.0266739167,
0.000002096,
-0.0316378474,
-0.0057982332,
-0.0265482068,
-0.0451074205,
-0.002020142,
-0.0499540754,
0.0177367199,
-0.006877169,
0.0243670065,
-0.0038261341,
0.0061860117,
0.0487525687,
0.0520309471,
0.0510656983,
0.0103343166,
-0.0014593943,
-0.0029984855,
0.0438329577,
-0.0265277885,
0.058326412,
-0.0427805223,
0.007957885,
-0.0316519327,
0.0174857453,
0.0176224001,
-0.0107196812,
0.0495448336,
0.0753585175,
0.0132044256,
-0.0236896239,
0.0596238896,
-0.0134621738,
-0.0275851581,
-0.0365195088,
0.0309842192,
-0.0320188366,
-0.0256891996,
-0.0150282448,
-0.002490131,
0.014508483,
0.0209375657,
-0.0386527218,
0.0112169441,
-0.0350116268,
-0.0026368168,
0.0085458308,
-0.0359016024,
0.0379507616,
-0.0183992721,
-0.0449760444,
0.1000197306,
0.0391634591,
-0.0128784254,
-0.0134868771,
0.0119508365,
-0.0085621672,
-0.0437351577,
0.0223402698,
0.0413741507,
-0.0401366167,
0.0318672359,
-0.0272540227,
-0.0023280235,
0.0127229597,
0.008173014,
0.0488630906,
0.0753181949,
-0.0471937731,
0.0646815822,
-0.0469363891,
0.0311659351,
-0.0723897144,
0.0425752886,
-0.0071837255,
-0.0178126413,
-0.0068152226,
-0.0467826016,
-0.0547791719,
0.0302546266,
-0.0206958205,
-0.0088643106,
0.006301072,
0.0478002056,
0.0115196146,
-0.0164432731,
-0.0115797669,
0.0162297711,
-0.0190676693,
-0.0336390287,
-0.0329768918,
0.062585488,
-0.037618693,
-0.0008372193,
0.0211309269,
-0.0767636597,
-0.061218746,
0.0003593514,
-0.0017686225,
-0.0327568911,
-0.0115780784,
0.0797272772,
-0.0325770155,
-0.032921277,
-0.0369786955,
-0.0282183401,
-0.0087125506,
-0.0556017049,
0.0190138761,
-0.0434271544,
0.0281935837,
0.032631509,
-0.0292358752,
-0.0214282535,
0.0159942433,
0.0514553562,
-0.0608562939,
0.0603964552,
0.0316568464,
-0.0000186224,
0.0301361475,
0.0245765522,
-0.0619978234,
0.061778713,
0.028711129,
0.0278941821,
-0.0041400776,
-0.0037996185,
0.045999255,
0.0285258051,
0.0414792523,
-0.0166528858,
0.00888306,
-0.0204389766,
0.0278939363,
0.0067118979,
0.0181708243,
0.0609659478,
-0.0329682417,
0.0026794937,
0.0477660522,
0.0638747588,
-0.0051891487,
-0.0261872988,
0.040143393,
-0.0397929922,
-0.0298646223,
0.0446592048,
-0.1090225354,
0.0786790773,
-0.0078906436,
0.0161952525,
0.0516248308,
0.058403451,
-0.0187544674,
-0.0246828999,
0.0020110526,
0.0107938386,
-0.0017240099,
0.0433265269,
0.0386982597,
0.0152662089,
-0.0618164092,
0.1075124741,
0.00966522,
-0.0370298401,
0.00800585,
-0.0695539638,
0.0288080554,
0.0602504276,
0.0311093517,
0.0106711043,
-0.0259136502,
-0.0005864977,
0.0239136219,
0.0468101576,
0.0162846558,
0.021706488,
0.0149423275,
-0.0253787972,
-0.000987024,
-0.0105231153,
0.0186847914,
0.0345212109,
0.0264166147,
-0.01591729,
0.0145541886,
-0.0058810236,
0.0533747002,
0.0095069837,
-0.0247229729,
-0.0268656649,
-0.0299196411,
0.0168365706,
-0.0303022582,
-0.0181045439,
0.0336392522,
0.0128014516,
0.0429729223,
-0.0088292696,
-0.0128237391,
-0.0040924512,
-0.0781873465,
-0.0007501437,
0.0006700926,
-0.005488819,
-0.045130495,
0.0065363017,
-0.0166577995,
-0.0437356904,
0.0214000139,
-0.0317631364,
0.0683645904,
-0.0282749683,
0.0126036284,
0.034307301,
0.0139582837,
-0.0252169613,
0.0566907823,
-0.0213441476,
0.0247191805,
0.0294351615,
0.0317673273,
-0.0088918917,
-0.0203240626,
-0.0175702143,
0.0204095151,
-0.0130518442,
-0.0008336875,
-0.0104208533,
-0.0237370282,
-0.051462207,
-0.0375182442,
-0.0470735282,
-0.0116456915,
-0.0256870985,
0.0129939253,
0.0098553579,
0.0447962359,
-0.0101202456,
-0.0184822325,
-0.0189318992,
-0.0132311974,
0.0016201768,
0.0346320271,
0.0104065612,
-0.0373765118,
0.0096961446,
-0.0045590354,
-0.0104535632,
-0.0353220552,
0.0380728915,
-0.0165601298,
-0.0174999442,
-0.0675007179,
-0.0431869552,
-0.003074903,
0.0268740598,
-0.0255805645,
-0.0208246522,
0.0381685942,
-0.0136334384,
0.0765962452,
0.0964084938,
-0.0188708901,
0.0060155927,
0.0454024635,
-0.0393935144,
-0.0461876355,
0.0563640036,
-0.0207318719,
-0.026994573,
-0.0018152758,
-0.0123378029,
-0.0059161829,
0.1099559069,
0.0191226229,
0.0075027607,
-0.0632068738,
0.0050617983,
-0.0022390003,
-0.0033833748,
0.0023187029,
-0.0300004911,
-0.0498899221,
0.0462711602,
-0.030935673,
-0.0410335846,
0.1022213772,
-0.0437616073,
-0.0164091457,
-0.0209699646,
0.0407520309,
-0.0059384801,
0.0659749061,
-0.0028863905,
0.0076818434,
0.0162321292,
-0.0284292866,
-0.0596239269,
0.0105032651,
-0.0022089491,
-0.0240831636,
0.0855013579,
-0.0408921279,
-0.0089009739,
-0.0235447325,
-0.0317591876,
-0.0506852418,
0.0225280002,
-0.04258864,
-0.0104856649,
-0.0044984822,
-0.0183067098,
-0.0316667184,
0.014484169,
0.051986184,
0.0686102808,
-0.0407773592,
-0.0139874807,
-0.0406752564,
-0.0001944893,
0.0476512462,
0.0261540227,
0.013618242,
-0.023792129,
0.0223905724,
0.0666806772,
0.046321895,
0.0070623197,
0.0396747887,
0.0148007376,
0.0524537563,
-0.0162495766,
-0.0098696742,
0.0302913785,
0.0785557553,
-0.0782715082,
-0.0319032855,
0.0923511162,
0.0537872799,
-0.0613280758,
-0.0139615098,
-0.0456269383,
0.0240964033,
0.0171156041,
0.0256483331,
-0.0892248079,
-0.0492536426,
0.0230693091,
-0.0172893442,
0.0115716821,
0.0066302535,
-0.0126823084,
-0.1236979216,
0.018021442,
-0.0220932346,
-0.026970543,
-0.0328253061,
-0.0112027945,
0.011608501,
0.0432361029,
0.0384850055,
0.0290779304,
0.0106680207,
-0.0240688715,
-0.0046459935,
0.0231337547,
-0.0062097483,
0.0386650749,
-0.0033742727,
0.0153641161,
0.0427293926,
-0.0252189655,
0.0258462932,
-0.073607251,
0.0354397222,
-0.035552185,
0.0153696314,
0.0017301494,
0.0183297172,
-0.0021720382,
0.0011754538,
-0.0223924071,
0.0266486574,
-0.0254493579,
-0.0552995093,
-0.0137085048,
0.1044779345,
-0.0171544794,
-0.0130691715,
0.0050562886,
0.0100403456,
-0.0125100445,
0.0681617931,
0.0395760871,
-0.0495518744,
-0.0219134875,
-0.0571097471,
0.0101849819,
-0.0740791336,
-0.0077168206,
0.035896007,
0.054231897,
-0.024232788,
-0.0186463799,
-0.037106026,
0.0434942991,
0.0140777258,
-0.0104627945,
-0.01376779,
0.0103985276,
-0.0163946357,
-0.0224924907,
0.0439646691,
-0.0324410796,
0.0258384328,
-0.0657352805,
0.0182241909,
-0.0039186347,
-0.0256002732,
-0.0090938518,
0.0405774228,
-0.0882496387,
-0.0618801937,
0.009487303,
0.0315612219,
0.023201691,
0.0311836842,
-0.0461159647,
-0.0212158095,
-0.0060211932,
0.0032884064,
-0.0362281427,
-0.0033641648,
0.0238919165,
-0.0048243161,
-0.0102765765,
0.031178277,
-0.0321427695,
0.0048670778,
0.0154699823,
0.0284626596,
-0.0150244171,
-0.0213208087,
0.0316654779,
-0.0224923361,
0.0922394618,
0.0163296368,
0.046379406,
-0.0035381918,
0.0518946834,
-0.0006589463,
-0.0055244821,
-0.0160048921,
-0.0073142196,
-0.0033923117,
-0.0223033559,
0.0089869285,
-0.0583892353,
0.0223074276,
0.0178017393,
-0.0066374885,
-0.0147441719,
0.0097169084,
-0.0117119905,
0.0251405854,
-0.0186342672,
-0.0367946923,
-0.004560295,
-0.0007090396,
0.0570770465,
-0.0278283712,
0.1013706699,
0.0208050292,
-0.0246895216,
-0.017888194,
-0.0015596482,
-0.080974862,
-0.0648831055,
0.0223822501,
0.0059977537,
0.0372969434,
0.0016753105,
0.0208052099,
0.0011281879,
-0.0097542806,
0.0176835302,
0.0058741961,
0.0350388587,
-0.0374978259,
0.0366299041,
0.0322891586,
0.0119991852,
-0.0153917251,
0.0413229764,
-0.0418018885,
0.0222778283,
-0.0299143717,
-0.0003912404,
-0.0037841196,
-0.0375958346,
-0.0225107893,
0.0084986389,
-0.0266430322,
-0.0018707679,
-0.089850083,
-0.0667240024,
0.0016323205,
0.0301299449,
-0.0043591079,
-0.0479175486,
0.0077663078,
0.0593383797,
0.031918291,
-0.0758969039,
-0.0110369548,
0.0116592618,
0.0174066313,
-0.0056910873,
-0.0121933399,
-6.88520249e-33,
-0.0388497636,
-0.0474508889,
0.0212683398,
-0.0179034937,
-0.0211139824,
-0.0124731446,
-0.0506248772,
-0.0082513122,
-0.0432273522,
-0.0129907383,
-0.0423179641,
0.0180893317,
0.0200489312,
0.0253289212,
0.0344553255,
-0.0211435277,
0.0246398039,
0.0420011096,
-0.0762007013,
0.0315418392,
0.0401796214,
0.0086740246,
0.0575678647,
0.0458608232,
0.0219944064,
0.0050853463,
0.0275088437,
0.0154006137,
-0.0701785684,
0.0614210889,
-0.0159838106,
0.0219072159,
0.0079250606,
-0.0878217071,
0.0009190424,
0.0494466349,
-0.0707561597,
-0.0537881702,
0.0484427959,
-0.0120292017,
-0.0372187607,
-0.0328013711,
0.021299094,
-0.0017300891,
0.0254922025,
-0.0344211534,
0.0119223157,
0.0129643772,
-0.0220506899,
0.0080747809,
-0.0630318522,
-0.004193197,
0.0275825746,
-0.0185481291,
-0.0197377,
0.059631221,
0.0024177276,
0.0227750242,
-0.0627660081,
0.0014152795,
-0.0127292508,
0.0287988186,
0.0682132542,
0.0449881628,
-0.0215181317,
0.0267954785,
-0.0026670955,
-0.0039248662,
-0.0541010015,
-0.0125364978,
0.0326775759,
-0.0032709532,
0.0376832895,
-0.0172742475,
0.0242844019,
-0.0007329644,
-0.0044886684,
-0.0231629591,
0.0333887339,
0.0535359569,
0.0444154404,
0.0037658899,
-0.0099415826,
-0.0419975519,
-0.0482975245,
0.0114154723,
-0.0449314378,
-0.0381464884,
0.020437777,
0.0089772949,
0.00169779,
0.0149698164,
0.0425385982,
0.0001922038,
-0.0000609252,
0.0067404071,
0.0137812505,
0.0257007089,
-0.0159759242,
0.0523496717,
-0.0245360173,
0.0145886596,
0.0132806618,
0.0117678549,
-0.0007758507,
0.0460311733,
0.0107332068,
0.0186119247,
-0.0749764144,
-0.0033831457,
-0.0776191354,
0.013545895,
-0.0142892851,
-0.0090020876,
0.0641886815,
0.0279323068,
-0.0241079405,
0.0142377568,
-0.0034099638,
0.0053204107,
-0.0516819507,
0.0189684667,
-0.0242416859,
0.0323126167,
-0.0266328752,
0.000242347,
-0.0683020875,
0.0290261228,
-0.012324865,
-0.0698557794,
-0.0207853951,
0.047871422,
2.86e-7,
0.0275913961,
0.0244717728,
0.0137788095,
0.0483693257,
-0.0038159569,
0.006702851,
0.0062079518,
0.0078746527,
0.0536053255,
-0.0387619175,
-0.0306816977,
0.0360487886,
0.0272173397,
0.0186630562,
-0.1125116125,
-0.0077387369,
-0.034970887,
0.0155414147,
-0.0373388082,
-0.0173402932,
0.0506509542,
0.0795503184,
0.0195561107,
0.0024555218,
0.0066942475,
-0.0052218549,
0.0373306423,
-0.0166442078,
-0.0038047389,
-0.0123084765,
0.040263731,
0.0044537624,
0.0024643948,
0.0398155041,
-0.0153796412,
-0.0068745702,
-0.0372232907,
0.0236269161,
-0.0118947513,
-0.0563373342,
-0.0471006632,
-0.0241282247,
0.0065624197,
-0.0804437026,
0.0716929063,
-0.0784861147,
0.004854389,
-0.0024236031,
0.014480073,
-0.0184258316,
-0.0054289084,
-0.0002280398,
-0.035735663,
0.0087032113,
0.0028964367,
0.0061750486,
0.0159058776,
-0.1125492975,
-0.0299191289,
0.044337336,
-0.0267179497,
-0.0422545746,
-0.0482883453,
-0.0766712278,
0.043385949,
-0.054897055,
-0.0341280773,
2.708725612e-34,
0.012594399,
-0.0231653601,
0.0488594137,
0.045976229,
0.0415893011,
-0.0096752495,
0.0344219729,
0.0170821063,
0.0298327133,
-0.0788440183,
-0.0337863527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05569v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05569v1 | ITI-GEN: Inclusive Text-to-Image Generation | 2023-09-11T15:54:30 | 2023-09-11T15:54:30 | Cheng Zhang, Xuanbai Chen, Siqi Chai, Chen Henry Wu, Dmitry Lagun, Thabo Beeler, Fernando De la Torre | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Text-to-image generative models often reflect the biases of the training
data, leading to unequal representations of underrepresented groups. This study
investigates inclusive text-to-image generative models that generate images
based on human-written prompts and ensure the resulting images are uniformly
distributed across attributes of interest. Unfortunately, directly expressing
the desired attributes in the prompt often leads to sub-optimal results due to
linguistic ambiguity or model misrepresentation. Hence, this paper proposes a
drastically different approach that adheres to the maxim that "a picture is
worth a thousand words". We show that, for some attributes, images can
represent concepts more expressively than text. For instance, categories of
skin tones are typically hard to specify by text but can be easily represented
by example images. Building upon these insights, we propose a novel approach,
ITI-GEN, that leverages readily available reference images for Inclusive
Text-to-Image GENeration. The key idea is learning a set of prompt embeddings
to generate images that can effectively represent all desired attribute
categories. More importantly, ITI-GEN requires no model fine-tuning, making it
computationally efficient to augment existing text-to-image models. Extensive
experiments demonstrate that ITI-GEN largely improves over state-of-the-art
models to generate inclusive images from a prompt. Project page:
https://czhang0528.github.io/iti-gen. | [
0.0142867323,
0.0845070109,
0.0144742765,
0.0000701767,
0.0157761797,
0.0229770355,
0.0497421101,
0.0100800889,
-0.0152743943,
-0.0310575645,
-0.0023009139,
-0.0410234183,
0.0245896243,
0.0464986898,
0.0499207564,
-0.0965131745,
-0.0196114406,
0.0113496864,
-0.0024910674,
-0.0384530351,
0.0066599525,
0.0398767292,
0.0093586007,
0.0322869457,
-0.0656470731,
-0.0163489096,
-0.0028134733,
0.0321153924,
0.016124865,
-0.0147479037,
-0.0112947905,
0.0493289493,
0.0122501664,
-0.0142611219,
0.0000021333,
-0.0097434111,
0.028885562,
0.0167552549,
0.0081788544,
-0.0207434911,
0.0675785542,
0.0137808472,
-0.0052575497,
-0.0098212119,
-0.0026284186,
0.0354919732,
0.0923518538,
0.0571676977,
0.0512748584,
0.0316309482,
-0.0205345713,
0.0014461052,
-0.0195272546,
-0.0344374701,
0.064202331,
0.0017853297,
-0.0162617527,
-0.0512542278,
-0.0063840048,
0.0311590489,
-0.0227257088,
0.0395649001,
0.0320415124,
0.0002158709,
0.063550204,
0.0585821494,
0.0115420045,
-0.0526334792,
0.0137532167,
0.0796521306,
-0.0204104353,
0.0238836687,
-0.0573595166,
-0.0349496715,
0.0191427637,
-0.019494513,
0.0002766173,
0.041188892,
-0.0071865283,
0.0223123897,
-0.0773061961,
0.0605473556,
0.0023148209,
-0.0246176496,
0.0028932753,
-0.0271578208,
0.0503958389,
0.0043140911,
-0.0237450786,
0.0245275125,
-0.0305456463,
-0.0625178814,
0.0153156351,
0.0134454705,
-0.003795732,
0.0060286741,
-0.0683527142,
-0.01031416,
0.0198769588,
0.0374387428,
0.0665872544,
0.0171851423,
-0.0465703346,
0.0175056048,
-0.0107050017,
0.0192463193,
0.0108795827,
0.0075223884,
-0.044933904,
-0.0232506916,
0.0019156397,
-0.0393652506,
-0.0275358558,
-0.0237547848,
-0.0397739299,
-0.00843284,
-0.0507048778,
-0.0121241603,
-0.0307381153,
0.0078337491,
0.0143403737,
0.0666940808,
-0.1023400947,
0.00304965,
-0.0352065824,
-0.032772284,
-0.0379944481,
0.0107821431,
0.0240342077,
-0.0289942734,
0.0027441857,
-0.0130033465,
0.0343169346,
-0.0160371494,
-0.0146547249,
0.0412890315,
-0.0349532813,
-0.0118120862,
-0.0265347306,
-0.0320686921,
-0.0221334342,
-0.0410081334,
0.0100124078,
-0.056045007,
0.0251555983,
-0.0469048247,
0.0121922484,
-0.0601580665,
-0.0088914447,
0.0161322169,
0.0098754494,
0.0829390362,
-0.0048240512,
-0.0219471343,
0.0417960547,
0.015950527,
-0.006663857,
0.0268431418,
0.0243288893,
0.0657459423,
-0.0005530397,
-0.0187881328,
0.0087392917,
0.0293003991,
0.0427535921,
0.0209759697,
-0.002371945,
-0.0218826011,
0.0023672753,
0.0415082909,
0.039321512,
0.0439246595,
0.0048527857,
-0.0136344908,
0.072777018,
0.0330713876,
0.0148026356,
0.0298495833,
0.0593356714,
0.0338358171,
-0.0198171549,
-0.0203659907,
-0.0344747901,
0.0492447987,
0.0030635612,
0.0132842651,
0.0057185492,
0.0623150729,
-0.0679358914,
-0.0287841558,
0.039912764,
-0.0207690075,
0.0219707713,
-0.0005330093,
0.0249006264,
0.0597267598,
-0.025830863,
-0.0272768717,
0.016524557,
-0.0635390803,
0.0353108272,
-0.0366555788,
0.0353400111,
0.0658537149,
0.0063880123,
0.0140242716,
0.0348962881,
-0.0101573737,
0.0432972275,
0.0831215605,
-0.0247758403,
0.0228079315,
0.0424298644,
-0.0503414944,
-0.0539721437,
-0.0073657492,
0.0082590561,
0.0380926654,
-0.0026968035,
0.0446176864,
0.0272128545,
0.0278442055,
-0.0238519069,
0.0558621697,
-0.0022407067,
-0.0236985199,
0.0430621877,
0.0445572734,
-0.0186751783,
0.0018547719,
-0.0228292085,
0.0008294307,
-0.0181657281,
-0.0486365743,
-0.0481738225,
0.0279344674,
-0.0609548017,
-0.0302519482,
-0.0186628066,
-0.0722211599,
-0.0492511056,
-0.0307731163,
-0.0282193031,
-0.0425367877,
0.0171476882,
-0.0295888241,
-0.0260224156,
-0.0330398045,
-0.0219201483,
0.0397010669,
0.0180307813,
-0.0067945495,
0.053895276,
-0.0048283129,
-0.0108748917,
0.0052564749,
0.0160811096,
-0.0411702357,
-0.0501015596,
-0.0154724978,
-0.0179002397,
0.0106753372,
0.0214529485,
0.0099761728,
0.0327495486,
-0.0268519167,
0.0037825187,
-0.0467141941,
-0.0120001715,
0.0191336777,
-0.0495873131,
-0.0277598482,
0.0157649256,
0.0161219537,
-0.0201196764,
-0.0571632199,
0.0117005268,
0.0054032174,
-0.0033111484,
0.0169132221,
-0.0120004239,
0.0140483286,
-0.0203481838,
-0.0057825828,
0.0230522249,
0.0704663619,
0.0347313695,
0.0292864237,
-0.0355921127,
-0.0179275163,
-0.0297950134,
0.0093260165,
0.0204201154,
-0.0197341945,
0.0252637062,
0.0095307333,
0.0287088174,
0.0486805104,
0.0517992079,
-0.0079483446,
-0.0229659081,
-0.0140755158,
-0.0655738488,
0.0024622953,
-0.0068166517,
-0.0112111829,
0.0606517345,
-0.08238931,
0.0203357544,
0.0444391742,
0.0195705183,
-0.003963728,
-0.0953268632,
0.0497573279,
-0.0073741754,
-0.0659257695,
-0.0820583105,
0.0214057341,
0.0073564085,
0.0152040469,
-0.0550912693,
-0.0647964478,
0.052234631,
-0.0258038286,
0.0044998047,
0.0263213255,
0.0215982273,
0.0121031068,
0.03851147,
0.0149061587,
0.0580141507,
0.0582743809,
0.0220434293,
-0.0697585344,
0.02721221,
0.0394510366,
-0.0176227801,
0.0308918934,
-0.0149627244,
-0.0243623275,
-0.0353397876,
-0.0390815996,
-0.0443184301,
-0.0477111377,
0.0462263599,
-0.0115370853,
-0.0168886799,
-0.0228125919,
-0.0064772023,
-0.0209199283,
-0.008202849,
-0.0036717993,
-0.0145766139,
-0.0331690758,
0.0025313704,
0.0399977304,
0.0485817678,
-0.0224626269,
-0.0309390835,
-0.02006457,
0.020696912,
0.0427369624,
-0.0329117104,
0.0067908666,
-0.0156007493,
0.0265191011,
-0.0071543697,
0.0457471758,
-0.0116457352,
0.0149455909,
0.0729553401,
-0.0141552426,
0.0051814574,
0.0604860932,
0.0123336185,
-0.0349115543,
-0.0065229204,
0.0332889333,
0.0500618406,
0.0008520343,
0.0017044093,
-0.0908102468,
-0.0101532741,
-0.0251738187,
0.0238016993,
-0.0144774402,
-0.0078399424,
-0.0331949964,
-0.0687143132,
0.0597921722,
0.0275174137,
-0.0310574323,
-0.0359628052,
0.0388014577,
0.0249881651,
0.0079572201,
-0.0088126389,
-0.0076426482,
0.0150780948,
0.0288420077,
-0.0189289581,
0.0453185663,
-0.0397440605,
0.0174474046,
-0.0256968029,
0.0197706223,
0.0609815754,
0.0344393328,
0.0422276706,
-0.049234163,
0.0067025595,
-0.0155816125,
-0.0021487612,
-0.0057787094,
0.0516446345,
0.0287606288,
-0.0003430559,
-0.0238904804,
0.0860011056,
0.0140367709,
0.0022008021,
0.0150267342,
0.0051748273,
0.0077312263,
-0.0214412976,
-0.0709679648,
-0.0168678891,
0.0496476479,
0.0516656414,
0.0492689386,
-0.0870807916,
-0.033010792,
-0.0567494817,
0.0351259522,
-0.0522992052,
-0.0227354579,
0.0500245988,
-0.0213816967,
-0.0601589978,
-0.060790427,
-0.0163641125,
0.0287174508,
0.0483914055,
-0.0115007395,
-0.0619478337,
-0.0405539796,
-0.0100844605,
-0.0204862729,
0.0440734997,
-0.0362924188,
0.0228155851,
-0.0249796417,
-0.0426983424,
0.0004998795,
-0.0773223341,
-0.0110982629,
0.0168203823,
-0.0189862996,
-0.0179598723,
-0.0037028345,
0.0624114275,
0.0095089441,
0.0245972425,
-0.011352377,
-0.0661016852,
0.0893278494,
0.0723973438,
-0.002829988,
-0.002005341,
-0.0206589624,
0.0437513739,
-0.0130102662,
0.0170715507,
-0.0495867766,
0.074355647,
0.0085232528,
-0.0114075234,
0.0030472251,
-0.0519240871,
0.0051055285,
-0.0078814635,
-0.0344779678,
-0.0711848512,
0.0025081469,
-0.0356595553,
-0.0245881733,
-0.0032468485,
-0.0198557433,
-0.0772576109,
-0.019307062,
0.0257138535,
0.010519797,
0.0068317559,
-0.0374924503,
0.01345257,
0.0733177066,
-0.0605678894,
-0.0089886971,
0.0226120967,
0.0627831966,
0.0186650138,
0.0139465062,
0.0030335356,
0.0729527846,
-0.0757563785,
0.0185460579,
0.0086691342,
0.0545004569,
0.0040057623,
-0.0125434147,
-0.0417798683,
0.025516348,
0.0089316545,
0.0067476439,
-0.0697235391,
0.0389659069,
0.0154761141,
0.0362885967,
0.0052811923,
0.0094829546,
-0.0178385898,
0.0146012353,
0.056049075,
0.0353240483,
-0.0542264991,
0.0804041922,
-0.0235115848,
0.0116278064,
-0.0690132156,
0.0450603701,
0.02290201,
0.0166497752,
-0.0384026468,
-0.0025978072,
-0.0307437554,
-0.0017817143,
0.0166252051,
-0.0295715258,
0.0120653538,
0.0592485629,
-0.0344692878,
-0.0611934029,
-0.0025386424,
0.0273255762,
0.0010317491,
0.0609794706,
0.0493969209,
-0.0025006533,
-0.0153358979,
-0.0196769834,
0.0040649627,
0.0114574535,
-0.0619327538,
-0.0264312774,
-0.0115670152,
-6.174857866e-33,
-0.0893957987,
-0.0428376719,
-0.0034917339,
-0.0052853748,
-0.0076409248,
-0.0075385696,
-0.0302748717,
-0.0041270126,
0.0271134749,
0.012740952,
-0.0079228543,
-0.0260017496,
0.0030986315,
0.0735634938,
-0.0045853718,
0.042385418,
0.0673172921,
0.019022014,
-0.0474526174,
0.0598068088,
0.0153247975,
-0.0021417623,
0.0332149081,
-0.060202904,
-0.0151566593,
-0.0064561865,
-0.0437336601,
-0.0065475591,
0.0309447255,
0.0176924225,
-0.0219870042,
0.0416195393,
0.009396919,
-0.0302483328,
-0.0243056733,
0.0437026583,
-0.0841321424,
-0.0169925466,
-0.0595898144,
0.0034754737,
-0.0844446868,
-0.0380761474,
0.0089779356,
-0.0324818715,
0.026336832,
-0.0656606555,
0.0782982558,
-0.0336799286,
0.0149633326,
-0.0284162108,
-0.04718557,
0.0040413318,
-0.029211469,
-0.0148623446,
-0.0023206291,
0.0572871752,
0.0275968891,
0.0326718874,
-0.0531460121,
0.0337994285,
0.021693727,
-0.0219976902,
0.0351019204,
0.0415953994,
0.0097298492,
0.0215737838,
0.0128842257,
-0.0253384449,
-0.0489961393,
-0.015400379,
-0.0044427505,
0.0510012731,
0.0303633269,
0.0936403349,
0.0316806175,
-0.0253319778,
-0.0099026104,
0.069031775,
-0.0303137023,
-0.0216777157,
0.0229455344,
0.0099673234,
-0.01139866,
0.0001470525,
-0.0318607502,
-0.0500969812,
-0.032261949,
-0.0400930196,
0.0273715444,
0.0281743426,
-0.0445170775,
0.0098135984,
0.0489803329,
0.0200356953,
-0.0073099895,
-0.0190192182,
-0.024495801,
0.0182899088,
-0.0161066186,
-0.012063154,
-0.0342478044,
-0.0406403132,
0.0925995633,
0.0216127168,
-0.0070143132,
0.0349277966,
0.0386021174,
0.0108677465,
-0.0475320891,
0.0089959344,
-0.0399461836,
0.0624762923,
0.0047887783,
0.0129845031,
0.0154639445,
-0.0168102663,
-0.064745836,
0.018606225,
-0.0205610655,
-0.0017102995,
-0.0288627055,
-0.0081745572,
0.0166325886,
0.0014711253,
-0.0491871238,
0.0179594774,
-0.0254767928,
-0.0235625468,
0.0602173917,
-0.0346679576,
-0.0260979645,
0.0019819934,
2.646e-7,
0.0140627697,
-0.0499143563,
-0.0037456362,
0.0140060633,
0.0080615971,
0.0663000345,
0.0125904819,
0.0156542752,
0.0143884374,
0.0039815321,
-0.0050446172,
0.0445106551,
0.0395860523,
0.0183802303,
-0.0044817678,
0.0251206532,
-0.029448485,
0.0565035529,
-0.0226388369,
-0.0011700754,
0.0676440299,
0.0786958411,
0.0008677095,
-0.0341184773,
0.0465575978,
-0.0168556478,
0.0959158391,
-0.0369044356,
0.0084413001,
-0.0130253965,
0.0132879345,
0.0092477165,
-0.0050602434,
0.0201685801,
-0.0134712728,
-0.0140882768,
0.033078175,
0.0177279618,
-0.0298951268,
-0.0025434445,
-0.0019502763,
0.033038687,
-0.0066584451,
-0.0572714582,
0.0367287509,
-0.0658063665,
-0.0324205235,
-0.0653151646,
-0.0325629339,
0.0370262228,
0.0341275893,
-0.0455306284,
-0.0233600177,
-0.0059105428,
0.0386607088,
-0.0178144779,
-0.0091191903,
-0.0839055106,
-0.0586371422,
-0.0305388086,
-0.063534759,
-0.0224868413,
-0.0688969567,
0.0619570315,
-0.0091729667,
-0.0249936692,
-0.0076768179,
2.071738998e-34,
-0.0104435598,
0.0071489364,
0.0022623395,
-0.0257050917,
0.0188803319,
0.0044603022,
0.0229309276,
-0.035578955,
0.028697418,
-0.0324456207,
-0.0414734595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05557v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05557v3 | An Empirical Study of NetOps Capability of Pre-Trained Large Language Models | 2023-09-11T15:45:40 | 2023-09-19T16:04:25 | Yukai Miao, Yu Bai, Li Chen, Dan Li, Haifeng Sun, Xizheng Wang, Ziqiu Luo, Yanyu Ren, Dapeng Sun, Xiuting Xu, Qi Zhang, Chao Xiang, Xinchi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.NI | Nowadays, the versatile capabilities of Pre-trained Large Language Models
(LLMs) have attracted much attention from the industry. However, some vertical
domains are more interested in the in-domain capabilities of LLMs. For the
Networks domain, we present NetEval, an evaluation set for measuring the
comprehensive capabilities of LLMs in Network Operations (NetOps). NetEval is
designed for evaluating the commonsense knowledge and inference ability in
NetOps in a multi-lingual context. NetEval consists of 5,732 questions about
NetOps, covering five different sub-domains of NetOps. With NetEval, we
systematically evaluate the NetOps capability of 26 publicly available LLMs.
The results show that only GPT-4 can achieve a performance competitive to
humans. However, some open models like LLaMA 2 demonstrate significant
potential. | [
0.0181615651,
0.069930613,
-0.0140188914,
0.0220043939,
-0.0127071766,
0.0151000619,
0.0064675007,
0.0093345121,
0.0277693886,
-0.0590259805,
-0.0577400923,
-0.0276732668,
-0.0189642981,
0.0344879702,
0.0276534669,
-0.0041488507,
0.0320052207,
-0.0199563596,
-0.061862193,
0.0017706226,
-0.0172639992,
0.028420696,
0.0027981407,
0.0336887464,
0.0420119241,
-0.0083415955,
0.0217685755,
-0.0330268852,
-0.0080933459,
-0.0243516285,
-0.0034354122,
0.0429875739,
0.0476051196,
0.0419846438,
0.0000019352,
-0.0876741782,
0.0037818504,
-0.0008466947,
-0.0340810381,
0.0456883982,
0.0290337093,
-0.0110750971,
-0.0053891484,
0.0217111949,
-0.0465384237,
-0.0187000632,
0.0379832387,
0.0262376871,
0.0342171863,
0.0985187739,
-0.0145192342,
-0.034660887,
0.0127325002,
-0.0356678553,
-0.021895567,
-0.0988470465,
0.022116432,
0.0329658166,
0.0209168494,
-0.034323927,
0.0089874333,
0.0219464004,
0.0413939096,
-0.0048541338,
-0.0498726144,
0.0612369031,
-0.0136995958,
0.0076784049,
-0.0313817672,
0.0881117061,
0.0108206077,
0.0121932812,
-0.0051253908,
0.008630082,
-0.0173419658,
0.0079776254,
-0.0237809438,
0.0272246748,
0.0220446214,
0.0156623088,
0.0153627824,
0.0066201244,
0.0473415665,
0.0602350906,
-0.0252587944,
0.0605421029,
0.0178292785,
0.0030299753,
0.0671892837,
0.0351990201,
-0.0135521656,
-0.0382734872,
0.0147660542,
0.0445918329,
-0.0357606262,
0.0248176176,
-0.0064855856,
0.0277062356,
0.027641708,
-0.0858495981,
0.0549983233,
-0.0207728744,
-0.0329903848,
0.0618812628,
-0.0298377071,
0.0364993326,
-0.0194082912,
0.022116527,
-0.0245390721,
-0.0237864573,
-0.0496261083,
-0.0099319257,
-0.0029529894,
0.0423564985,
-0.037566226,
-0.0409480631,
-0.0270456318,
0.0153688584,
0.0171750225,
-0.0407165773,
0.0178477541,
-0.0171719193,
0.0030812111,
-0.0651821867,
-0.0385042913,
0.0508063659,
-0.0118698506,
0.056516245,
-0.0043223421,
-0.049399931,
-0.0038197974,
0.0142279416,
-0.0023594396,
-0.0233496651,
0.0314381532,
0.0982207283,
-0.0025694843,
-0.0279085003,
-0.0371153876,
0.0016133944,
0.0158224367,
-0.0711389631,
-0.0057898401,
-0.0494531468,
0.0211010724,
0.009658806,
0.0106021641,
-0.0003427385,
-0.0072978358,
-0.0242807828,
-0.0185262561,
0.0415230878,
0.0014145578,
-0.0033411451,
-0.0030616319,
0.0031199956,
0.0543814451,
0.0846889168,
-0.022351481,
-0.0128225675,
0.0181197617,
-0.0123921037,
-0.0372212194,
0.0382557623,
0.0085177869,
0.0158805773,
-0.012199603,
0.0357683003,
-0.0020777197,
0.0228436179,
0.0540698245,
0.0328055061,
-0.0279616117,
-0.0037677877,
0.0401264802,
0.0628925636,
0.0112483278,
0.0464608148,
0.0498708747,
-0.0009408203,
0.0384389237,
-0.0330791995,
-0.0570295267,
0.0173441209,
-0.0548199639,
0.0062911878,
0.0008242017,
0.048239965,
-0.0304994546,
-0.0385737978,
-0.0117082661,
-0.0218293481,
-0.0072248569,
0.0039199111,
0.0535371117,
-0.0169186704,
-0.0248121973,
0.0601688772,
0.0189034715,
-0.0343809538,
0.0399377942,
-0.0483277589,
-0.0144922789,
0.0346272998,
0.0207132194,
-0.0090801194,
-0.0674305633,
-0.0059248968,
0.0024753916,
0.0512772873,
0.0691518635,
-0.0050095213,
0.0148085365,
-0.04279688,
0.0063989856,
0.0055224742,
0.0148065537,
0.0372064747,
0.0099752313,
0.0358370394,
0.0214355458,
-0.0507967062,
-0.0432411321,
0.0269073639,
-0.0356004871,
0.0151529536,
-0.0254557896,
-0.0268030409,
0.0306215174,
0.0292676538,
-0.017860055,
-0.0042341971,
0.0023683382,
-0.0203348882,
-0.0484708548,
0.0161589701,
-0.0387159549,
-0.0243409369,
0.0432178825,
-0.0261608027,
-0.0511155985,
0.071092844,
-0.046132762,
-0.0247172508,
0.0163268782,
-0.0004721759,
0.0292994455,
-0.0886740535,
-0.0236961022,
-0.0170378424,
0.0100333691,
0.021706935,
0.0719913617,
-0.0064070299,
0.0318240188,
-0.0272821318,
-0.0147268064,
0.0262820181,
-0.0178158823,
-0.0307161044,
-0.0020239819,
-0.0105275996,
0.0217883345,
0.0098466547,
0.0569896176,
-0.0285711866,
-0.0151661308,
-0.1037692353,
0.0180924553,
-0.0479968339,
0.0274180751,
0.0410587676,
-0.0082276845,
-0.0102813598,
-0.0086195087,
-0.0158406347,
0.0396632366,
0.0241630338,
0.0232265946,
0.0292942151,
0.004603941,
0.0034305947,
-0.0041468372,
-0.0021110622,
0.0011390226,
0.043541573,
0.0303618833,
0.0098312479,
-0.0370057821,
0.0515346192,
-0.0657853037,
0.0332876854,
-0.0051147547,
-0.0646165162,
0.0110595524,
-0.0077226609,
-0.0014273965,
0.0266298112,
-0.0025512488,
0.0151203359,
0.0530873612,
-0.0035605975,
-0.0070449864,
-0.0061636851,
-0.0259110797,
-0.0727342889,
-0.0840223879,
0.0174394138,
0.0202790424,
0.0669801384,
-0.0135285063,
-0.0151115377,
-0.0360469967,
-0.0286788773,
-0.0336962864,
-0.0092537496,
-0.0648523122,
0.0247233268,
-0.0052727587,
0.0345822722,
0.0044486704,
-0.0496586859,
0.0878686756,
-0.0045826458,
-0.0078474637,
-0.0708882809,
-0.0219157543,
-0.0480079539,
0.0545402989,
-0.0133487331,
0.0246256553,
-0.0227701887,
-0.0587427169,
-0.0425238796,
0.011167692,
-0.0150447479,
-0.0174585003,
0.0393886566,
-0.0304429214,
0.0362652838,
-0.0160851777,
-0.0350352488,
-0.0034411722,
-0.0212227069,
-0.0521319248,
0.0311001968,
0.0255607255,
-0.0144883534,
-0.0208646413,
0.0227891058,
-0.0023692334,
0.0483857319,
0.0119916052,
0.002871271,
-0.0000991254,
0.0189983491,
0.0497388132,
0.0493718572,
0.0395664647,
-0.0047777751,
-0.0258474536,
0.0288805645,
0.0214811433,
-0.029292224,
-0.0152067794,
0.0345789045,
0.0038005421,
-0.0377580747,
-0.0056435894,
0.0212605465,
0.0724472404,
-0.0305281393,
0.0018433011,
0.1163698286,
0.0234365296,
-0.0289264824,
-0.0054609296,
-0.0122454846,
-0.0274158362,
0.0427571647,
0.0361560769,
-0.0773005784,
-0.0229929388,
-0.0308129843,
-0.0223510992,
0.0211927388,
-0.0487398319,
-0.0145666897,
-0.1404888779,
0.0318575986,
0.0053153923,
-0.097481288,
0.0025792359,
-0.0561520159,
-0.004251726,
-0.0177683868,
0.0225795619,
-0.012043478,
0.0042121019,
-0.0335553661,
0.0131354351,
0.004450405,
-0.0744989812,
0.0732917115,
-0.04273206,
0.0712984502,
0.0396757014,
0.0049112211,
-0.0416950807,
-0.0422147177,
0.0887579247,
-0.0583015755,
-0.0032433618,
-0.0000967995,
0.0046977582,
-0.0012914496,
-0.0134304818,
-0.0481002517,
0.0458679125,
-0.0386327282,
-0.0093573788,
-0.0142490342,
0.0927556306,
-0.0239994377,
-0.0358270109,
0.0033229906,
-0.0018659206,
0.0048200549,
0.0659923926,
0.025045462,
-0.0204567611,
-0.0403237939,
0.0029626095,
-0.0341542661,
-0.0245183632,
-0.0668404102,
0.0257108007,
0.0183933042,
-0.0344161727,
-0.0623185374,
-0.0269335657,
0.0324150026,
0.0266564786,
0.0011005618,
0.0185958743,
0.025785083,
0.0032585477,
-0.0066519906,
0.0539936535,
-0.0489176959,
0.0067419042,
-0.083714366,
0.0120322928,
0.0583713949,
0.0230297111,
-0.0476375185,
0.0256038196,
-0.0359010026,
-0.0831341147,
-0.0305797029,
0.0216441751,
0.0265219137,
-0.0174572933,
-0.0254189186,
-0.04819794,
0.0586858317,
0.0494817682,
-0.0465032123,
0.0073085735,
0.0385407582,
-0.0047462857,
0.0073026461,
0.0710237026,
-0.0292644277,
0.0111614382,
0.0026319076,
0.0213057846,
0.0196266491,
-0.0176883116,
-0.0136370184,
0.0016579251,
0.0510986038,
-0.0218954664,
0.0063745556,
-0.0477600433,
-0.0028203437,
-0.0230414271,
0.0113416715,
-0.0263847895,
-0.0203616843,
0.0565467775,
0.026084926,
0.014727179,
0.0145475119,
-0.0136231473,
0.0500596985,
0.0121821025,
0.0019435803,
0.0581755936,
0.0081783654,
0.0463061295,
-0.0032845219,
-0.0089382585,
-0.0210364275,
-0.0010825519,
0.0455425307,
-0.0460453592,
0.0629216358,
0.0227156579,
-0.0246882234,
-0.0249352399,
0.0260084365,
-0.0425169021,
-0.0685666874,
-0.0021915035,
0.0473712869,
0.0733147413,
-0.01542137,
0.0445145145,
-0.0498660393,
0.0172913633,
-0.0273600779,
0.023764221,
-0.0316940397,
-0.0088340128,
0.0616734736,
0.0063363072,
-0.0117575685,
0.0424648784,
0.0920658559,
0.0092729656,
0.0403558724,
-0.0108141582,
-0.0028527845,
-0.0260323603,
-0.0473831184,
-0.0129515119,
0.0298304204,
-0.0386043936,
0.0484910235,
-0.0659877881,
-0.0750885531,
-0.023669336,
0.005833955,
-0.0089637982,
0.0055672852,
0.0138554825,
0.0861599818,
-0.0184343066,
0.0117215924,
-0.0079124318,
-0.013581722,
-0.0739547014,
-0.0146808373,
0.0113726491,
-6.993230421e-33,
-0.0071912128,
-0.0101447506,
0.0387693904,
-0.0230802856,
-0.0273886956,
0.0079489015,
-0.0485332087,
-0.0072313119,
-0.037636783,
0.0000373698,
-0.0102270255,
0.0162711143,
0.0102680335,
0.0176419243,
-0.0184020642,
-0.0169259682,
0.0209797602,
0.0100205317,
-0.0198141225,
-0.0023185913,
0.0358457416,
-0.0021574723,
0.0966612399,
-0.0214044563,
0.0266957823,
-0.0080130752,
0.0159587152,
0.0178918652,
-0.0018005101,
0.0496003218,
-0.0224520918,
0.0388725512,
0.0386485271,
-0.0452430472,
0.0059650117,
0.0192147568,
-0.0427039005,
-0.0488750823,
0.0630286708,
-0.003811778,
0.0160040595,
-0.0113398219,
0.0291320067,
0.0171635319,
-0.0100465314,
-0.0024891503,
-0.0051061935,
-0.0083374223,
0.0296824668,
0.0350217,
-0.0503564328,
0.0007138436,
-0.0030199829,
0.0135856662,
-0.0069354638,
-0.0298571642,
-0.0430179201,
-0.028906595,
-0.0568493903,
0.0376277268,
0.0328344218,
0.0252035782,
0.066269204,
0.0050280471,
0.0034538999,
0.0575265363,
-0.0153544452,
-0.0149653442,
-0.0187762752,
0.0150498701,
0.0537151955,
0.0428456143,
0.0174291674,
0.0464557298,
0.000014647,
-0.0118836062,
-0.1035857275,
0.0221065003,
-0.0274123121,
0.0417767167,
0.0319528878,
-0.0010068188,
-0.0112323752,
-0.0034833895,
-0.0426718928,
-0.0303703379,
-0.0197715331,
-0.0309129823,
0.0200204831,
-0.023550665,
-0.0025037562,
0.0227170568,
0.0434318595,
-0.0483278222,
-0.0077866213,
0.0351550207,
0.0070635071,
0.0215188079,
0.0100474376,
0.0374949463,
-0.1077759042,
-0.0351393893,
-0.0152828274,
0.0202739667,
-0.0040130289,
-0.0245657247,
-0.0028644674,
0.0223148298,
-0.0412276164,
-0.0005540872,
-0.0346691534,
0.0014874012,
-0.0071447785,
0.0413717739,
0.0333867036,
-0.0014192765,
0.0036516923,
0.0378056429,
-0.0086858887,
-0.0204763468,
0.0034854154,
0.0352219455,
0.0264736358,
0.0191203691,
-0.042929478,
0.0104785962,
-0.0402457044,
-0.0091091171,
0.027173603,
-0.0151137235,
-0.0196246933,
0.022289142,
2.737e-7,
0.0506483279,
0.0305042155,
-0.0143169481,
0.0212951638,
-0.002926083,
0.0178721864,
-0.0272256713,
0.0156886037,
0.001428942,
-0.0246130899,
0.0194343533,
0.0271270443,
0.0293643195,
0.0331826285,
-0.0872143656,
-0.0276718438,
-0.0542041101,
-0.0222734939,
-0.0616264157,
-0.03044926,
0.0374185592,
0.0794883668,
0.0075658965,
-0.0282411575,
-0.0051691029,
-0.0871579647,
0.0486617982,
-0.0243562628,
-0.001923262,
0.0024738747,
0.0037494118,
0.0414710082,
-0.0087610297,
0.0432897396,
0.0053135734,
0.0475795902,
0.0048953211,
0.0765333101,
-0.0001760985,
-0.0269344151,
0.0084659653,
-0.0553304218,
-0.0184898991,
-0.0893068165,
0.0783541128,
-0.0970049202,
-0.0541424714,
-0.04142946,
0.0040483377,
-0.0477384143,
-0.0049771937,
-0.0373720154,
-0.0032632146,
0.0121454187,
-0.0092940936,
-0.0302697401,
-0.017124055,
-0.0521332361,
0.0144355167,
0.0451623015,
-0.0225505661,
-0.0802522972,
-0.0504864343,
-0.0350251831,
0.0632356107,
-0.0338188186,
0.0376699828,
2.082281025e-34,
0.0230537094,
-0.0045724646,
0.0277312584,
0.0084655564,
0.0292959586,
-0.0012658782,
-0.0103569767,
-0.0097537925,
-0.0258567799,
-0.070362471,
0.0360819362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05542v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05542v1 | Kani: A Lightweight and Highly Hackable Framework for Building Language Model Applications | 2023-09-11T15:27:59 | 2023-09-11T15:27:59 | Andrew Zhu, Liam Dugan, Alyssa Hwang, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7 | Language model applications are becoming increasingly popular and complex,
often including features like tool usage and retrieval augmentation. However,
existing frameworks for such applications are often opinionated, deciding for
developers how their prompts ought to be formatted and imposing limitations on
customizability and reproducibility. To solve this we present Kani: a
lightweight, flexible, and model-agnostic open-source framework for building
language model applications. Kani helps developers implement a variety of
complex features by supporting the core building blocks of chat interaction:
model interfacing, chat management, and robust function calling. All Kani core
functions are easily overridable and well documented to empower developers to
customize functionality for their own needs. Kani thus serves as a useful tool
for researchers, hobbyists, and industry professionals alike to accelerate
their development while retaining interoperability and fine-grained control. | [
0.0405128077,
0.0510509834,
-0.0353216417,
0.0458961986,
-0.0435135812,
-0.0342753306,
0.0301546995,
0.0030033754,
0.0567110814,
-0.0074957418,
-0.048129905,
0.0089848498,
0.0133838952,
0.0739982948,
0.0018195874,
-0.0497616753,
0.0533869751,
-0.0458520241,
-0.0025479812,
0.0356051512,
0.0115667414,
0.0207213815,
-0.0176032577,
0.075249657,
0.0118889129,
-0.0224922504,
-0.0220413189,
-0.0068330811,
-0.0340266638,
0.0308714025,
0.0262229517,
0.0568576679,
-0.0362723842,
0.0530034639,
0.0000021192,
-0.0419299826,
-0.0319989175,
0.0120775243,
-0.0125259431,
0.0359449387,
0.0494858921,
0.0224091765,
-0.0489896163,
0.0399240628,
-0.0298461393,
-0.0065651336,
0.0779079124,
-0.0398952961,
0.0782094374,
0.0060000848,
0.0012404986,
0.0493706763,
0.0057725194,
0.00455639,
-0.0022317481,
0.0267381538,
-0.0148208635,
0.0007506102,
0.0900853127,
0.0393668488,
0.0575809292,
0.0406026542,
0.0087731639,
-0.0455614142,
0.0026678827,
0.0067277057,
-0.0410221256,
-0.0695356652,
-0.0066173403,
0.0104516614,
-0.0089600552,
-0.0335662402,
-0.0136553571,
0.011913728,
0.013372235,
0.0054155691,
-0.0625058636,
-0.0025629799,
0.0111249508,
-0.0286082122,
0.0080080274,
-0.0386724472,
-0.0151447803,
-0.0147828776,
0.0109851956,
0.0470486321,
0.0526930876,
0.0149978204,
-0.0609761924,
-0.0315368585,
0.031304922,
-0.0714370161,
0.0193111449,
0.0198216364,
-0.0245466623,
0.0217744689,
-0.0140094599,
-0.0202995371,
0.0571988933,
-0.0415003374,
-0.0136643331,
0.0746013224,
-0.0577213876,
0.0322880633,
0.0392156802,
0.0125830024,
0.0448989607,
-0.0025762999,
0.0168984272,
-0.0213494804,
-0.0114822146,
-0.0307197142,
-0.0555261634,
-0.0092987632,
-0.0496139191,
0.0229556188,
-0.0115631707,
0.0818729624,
0.0146977175,
0.0292927809,
0.017587794,
-0.027455613,
-0.0167853981,
0.0093118036,
0.0126997968,
0.0237640571,
-0.0090529416,
-0.0508221425,
0.0014337484,
-0.1015664339,
-0.0034636375,
-0.0133376615,
-0.0079934783,
-0.0174200591,
-0.0365500562,
0.0844290406,
-0.0195354503,
0.001188528,
0.0093774591,
-0.0183934569,
0.0134793865,
0.0062721972,
-0.0354990624,
-0.0934684202,
-0.0134898713,
0.0461773649,
-0.0227160063,
-0.0735096559,
-0.0135796173,
0.01920381,
0.0014777964,
0.0150185982,
-0.0539399423,
0.0004935907,
0.0472095869,
0.0373832248,
-0.0057833199,
0.0616230778,
-0.0141302738,
0.0214100499,
0.0635587275,
-0.0279981717,
0.037536867,
0.0655955672,
-0.0333211273,
0.0044289003,
-0.0069546145,
0.011634957,
0.0373726077,
-0.0344394669,
-0.0590687767,
-0.0002581181,
-0.0070049292,
0.0018237621,
0.0374486074,
0.0486601852,
0.0274652112,
0.0188742355,
0.0174834915,
0.0434703566,
0.0109768035,
-0.0368242115,
-0.039553564,
0.0343893506,
-0.049008958,
0.0184647981,
-0.0498055965,
0.0614236258,
0.0184403732,
-0.0219362248,
-0.001188194,
-0.006295267,
0.0123700052,
0.0025085693,
0.0294916127,
-0.0012278395,
0.0216551591,
0.0338813215,
0.0359521061,
-0.0566788316,
-0.0503163226,
-0.0469396077,
-0.0016661038,
0.0880736932,
0.0769687891,
-0.027291242,
-0.0398817547,
-0.0031499488,
-0.0330168009,
0.0129062841,
0.0564541556,
-0.0185963884,
0.0155838225,
0.0073585468,
0.0095171304,
0.0058105891,
0.0146995299,
0.0513124429,
0.011894173,
-0.0050634183,
0.0057423068,
-0.0127259977,
0.0116354106,
-0.0027666257,
-0.0084189344,
-0.0329428986,
-0.0400978811,
0.0344185717,
-0.0392635688,
0.0132207572,
-0.0091003906,
0.0013165182,
0.0334264338,
0.018021062,
0.0307721794,
0.0221543014,
0.0169944614,
0.0334099382,
0.0422039777,
0.0365350842,
-0.0083020823,
0.0137296598,
-0.0132778976,
-0.0081212567,
0.0594982244,
0.0331104621,
0.0883508697,
-0.0225092731,
0.0317748897,
-0.0273868144,
-0.0011804652,
-0.0154441241,
-0.0197514929,
0.0203920715,
0.0036294768,
0.0234453622,
0.0110888276,
0.0162686594,
-0.0043727723,
-0.0281761121,
0.0730622113,
-0.0134597151,
0.0451046713,
0.0060809236,
0.0563056432,
0.0028929135,
-0.0166183989,
-0.11808981,
-0.0032600267,
-0.0292506069,
0.0124727404,
0.0240484029,
0.1099553481,
-0.033531718,
-0.021674389,
-0.0164013933,
-0.0065715257,
0.0244910736,
0.0120058935,
-0.0064797862,
-0.007579437,
-0.0426396839,
-0.0583615974,
-0.0120975254,
-0.0016617154,
0.0163709186,
-0.024689747,
-0.0743736178,
-0.0526911877,
0.0036329264,
-0.0373964161,
0.027863631,
0.0130005898,
-0.0448140241,
0.0199312419,
-0.0479865931,
0.0242604502,
0.0264190268,
-0.0320890695,
0.0431061238,
0.0663838163,
-0.0217323825,
-0.0890250877,
-0.0058318595,
0.0367725976,
-0.0424425974,
0.0142552638,
-0.0291313436,
0.0373104401,
0.0752509981,
-0.0178919956,
0.0078102676,
0.0051321071,
0.012645673,
0.0040724571,
-0.0035024015,
0.0204803664,
-0.006279272,
-0.0214855764,
0.0346764475,
-0.001960831,
-0.0690072924,
0.0652528629,
-0.0737300441,
-0.0616374537,
-0.0389904566,
-0.0667730644,
-0.0376452655,
0.0979560614,
-0.0486014932,
0.0047177635,
0.0389884375,
-0.0355164967,
-0.000622179,
0.0251528695,
0.0299938899,
-0.0254538488,
-0.0115775689,
-0.0630052984,
-0.0048912563,
-0.0255957581,
-0.016755309,
-0.0124595426,
0.0151976133,
-0.0585421175,
-0.0158552434,
0.0374755524,
-0.0162407476,
0.0381465629,
0.0321241692,
0.0231728051,
0.0505062453,
0.0169911068,
0.0068058004,
-0.0089968918,
-0.0349588767,
0.0080264155,
-0.0421820506,
-0.0607449003,
0.006580615,
0.0125708245,
0.0287312176,
0.000324238,
-0.0484209023,
-0.0114795249,
-0.0310317241,
0.1058151424,
-0.0161006246,
-0.028892288,
0.0385999195,
0.0408820324,
-0.055081401,
-0.0223409329,
0.0668409094,
0.047205206,
-0.0690978989,
-0.0014641228,
-0.0527794473,
0.0795060396,
0.0363419615,
0.0710495487,
-0.1014404595,
-0.0083240094,
-0.0004699962,
0.0205414351,
0.014561642,
0.0068363156,
-0.016724715,
-0.0722160339,
0.0271975994,
0.0073758643,
-0.0577579439,
-0.0020293605,
-0.0322102234,
0.0298663285,
0.0350488722,
-0.0077235033,
0.0044027613,
0.0005799911,
0.0103829158,
-0.0506060719,
-0.0564536862,
-0.0418437719,
-0.0150277494,
-0.0127598597,
0.0663600862,
0.0678989589,
0.0086254533,
0.0449543335,
0.0176446419,
0.0465716943,
0.0508903936,
-0.018966442,
-0.0387292728,
-0.0102612562,
0.0209215116,
-0.0167269316,
-0.0299905799,
-0.0009282971,
0.0071606683,
-0.0339811705,
-0.0200473722,
0.0365487337,
-0.0340839364,
0.0411315076,
-0.0128245316,
-0.0405042022,
0.0509530827,
0.0310298614,
0.0493529551,
-0.0309155043,
-0.0269473046,
-0.0991882682,
-0.0284871049,
0.0093574552,
-0.0496493541,
-0.0040694964,
0.0302237589,
-0.0556481406,
-0.0499412678,
-0.0197916962,
0.03777235,
0.0054980242,
0.0109857554,
0.0077607273,
-0.0043031941,
0.0008765039,
-0.0174262617,
-0.0003152702,
-0.0366029143,
0.0151706031,
-0.0413868353,
-0.021475926,
0.0046303226,
-0.0268529002,
0.0120876487,
0.0093399482,
-0.0256275963,
-0.087854743,
-0.0033954163,
0.0787381977,
0.0315495618,
0.0261460766,
-0.0672165751,
-0.0738059729,
-0.0566981733,
0.0169558972,
-0.0793620348,
-0.0184080936,
0.0183759388,
-0.0007607237,
0.0172798168,
-0.0047520609,
-0.075796552,
-0.0096039101,
-0.0070527433,
-0.010519431,
-0.0213017799,
-0.0587396957,
0.001177176,
0.0333868787,
-0.0024159111,
0.0052953814,
0.003263395,
-0.0231267661,
0.0273737554,
-0.0551818497,
-0.0224941503,
-0.0298782606,
0.0183722395,
-0.0415066816,
-0.0324996263,
0.0659927577,
-0.0002322993,
-0.0376350209,
0.0722084418,
-0.0209204946,
0.0795173496,
-0.015430253,
0.0086357035,
0.0616444163,
0.0386714749,
-0.0329617932,
0.0280453246,
-0.0117716361,
0.0491525531,
-0.0436662696,
0.043900799,
-0.025695214,
-0.0508785136,
0.0159212071,
0.0366527475,
-0.0587186329,
-0.0938639939,
0.0147044817,
0.0757328272,
0.0358293541,
0.0097734574,
0.0425534919,
-0.0553901754,
0.0116701927,
-0.0184003003,
0.006674279,
0.0099632861,
-0.0423250161,
-0.0448035561,
-0.0019956394,
-0.0017271426,
-0.0568224117,
0.0372998342,
-0.0458074026,
-0.0010581965,
-0.0035500824,
-0.0275343508,
-0.0492607839,
-0.0041091572,
0.0687660128,
0.0071714958,
-0.0576106645,
-0.0324316099,
-0.0553336516,
-0.0484832451,
-0.0464537814,
0.0246815998,
-0.0234807543,
-0.0143152382,
0.0099894144,
0.0759291798,
0.0413106792,
0.0084855435,
-0.0213845447,
0.0164863095,
-0.0036258956,
-0.0381472595,
-0.0149919558,
-5.518963977e-33,
-0.0280154683,
-0.0038237497,
0.0032473353,
-0.0020666646,
0.0490972176,
-0.0304185767,
-0.062839821,
0.0189889558,
0.0004848401,
-0.06862133,
-0.0142726311,
-0.0162543859,
0.0222566091,
-0.0125960335,
-0.0007892183,
0.0479690135,
0.0365938097,
0.0496474616,
-0.0446133837,
0.0094190389,
0.0364173949,
0.0170701779,
0.0382297821,
-0.0787448213,
0.0296830144,
-0.018338725,
0.0216950048,
0.0108458558,
0.0261227358,
0.0393100195,
0.0121706668,
0.0241774451,
-0.0187363327,
-0.0135985957,
-0.0122802164,
0.0126058422,
-0.0384501368,
-0.0241550263,
0.0291953422,
0.0431464911,
0.0110431919,
-0.0234636124,
0.0030192472,
-0.0245875176,
0.0224433206,
0.0512445308,
0.0073726559,
0.0044713207,
-0.0156386048,
0.0512607396,
-0.0447135307,
0.0117467847,
-0.0140736178,
0.0025618237,
0.0118251508,
0.0410311259,
0.0049369349,
-0.0452393964,
-0.0076128743,
0.0158330537,
0.0208731089,
0.0235348493,
0.0703204498,
0.0319281332,
-0.0039171902,
0.0261279121,
0.0119969957,
0.0121071879,
-0.0132587571,
0.0207217466,
0.0252564214,
0.028848296,
0.0268122107,
0.0221987609,
-0.0279356055,
-0.0341167264,
0.0369517952,
0.0219442695,
0.0587551296,
0.0028546324,
-0.0211532786,
0.0626583546,
-0.0290382616,
-0.0108220316,
0.0000173113,
-0.0053048101,
-0.0260527078,
-0.0762799382,
0.0115125775,
-0.03132708,
-0.0068505169,
-0.023961585,
0.0297667086,
0.0102055464,
-0.0215555187,
0.0116523458,
-0.0244733319,
0.036058601,
-0.0240424499,
0.0291952193,
0.0398004912,
0.0214381032,
-0.0096312277,
-0.0353993177,
0.0271283668,
0.0468000546,
-0.0344631784,
0.0268618874,
-0.0531567149,
0.0167012475,
-0.0189097617,
0.0266303383,
-0.0103951171,
0.0079347668,
0.0097620646,
-0.0307492483,
0.0113098752,
0.0237942263,
0.0153067699,
-0.0082522854,
-0.0680598393,
-0.0152048115,
0.0076518902,
-0.0246462245,
-0.0310827512,
-0.0019397893,
-0.0570184849,
0.0269098189,
0.0677391663,
0.0044370028,
-0.0073313201,
-0.032678023,
2.865e-7,
0.0115193026,
0.0226638485,
0.0232161656,
0.0252857283,
-0.0064953449,
0.0250931028,
-0.0149292378,
0.0172441192,
0.0489314422,
-0.00357124,
-0.0604811423,
0.0151937148,
0.0317717977,
0.0420700312,
-0.0806448162,
-0.0032891673,
-0.0155899609,
0.0105840191,
-0.0810177401,
0.0095008304,
0.0492442474,
0.0449696369,
0.0195897203,
0.0179628972,
-0.008744562,
-0.0150583228,
-0.0136576537,
-0.0394338183,
-0.0075018005,
0.0329446755,
0.004529472,
-0.0011132287,
0.0158316623,
-0.0170405265,
-0.0144769913,
-0.0443693809,
-0.0098891202,
0.038255915,
-0.0156833958,
0.0227085333,
0.0235229246,
-0.0522821769,
-0.0160300341,
-0.0703795925,
0.0291676037,
-0.0080046402,
0.0122896712,
-0.0472666696,
0.021114666,
-0.0182095878,
-0.0191537794,
-0.04306015,
-0.0245270338,
0.0158262569,
-0.0187409725,
-0.0182407629,
-0.0025075439,
-0.0042366553,
-0.0795060173,
0.0124037927,
-0.0077962391,
-0.0375331156,
-0.0696586445,
-0.0196564123,
-0.0125991264,
-0.009535254,
0.0285309087,
3.226429165e-34,
0.0191785879,
0.0071804281,
0.0283874702,
0.0520856231,
0.0556078255,
-0.0097999182,
0.0524696633,
0.0400215536,
0.0218438003,
-0.0249844044,
-0.0530407466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05534v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05534v1 | PAI-Diffusion: Constructing and Serving a Family of Open Chinese Diffusion Models for Text-to-image Synthesis on the Cloud | 2023-09-11T15:18:28 | 2023-09-11T15:18:28 | Chengyu Wang, Zhongjie Duan, Bingyan Liu, Xinyi Zou, Cen Chen, Kui Jia, Jun Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Text-to-image synthesis for the Chinese language poses unique challenges due
to its large vocabulary size, and intricate character relationships. While
existing diffusion models have shown promise in generating images from textual
descriptions, they often neglect domain-specific contexts and lack robustness
in handling the Chinese language. This paper introduces PAI-Diffusion, a
comprehensive framework that addresses these limitations. PAI-Diffusion
incorporates both general and domain-specific Chinese diffusion models,
enabling the generation of contextually relevant images. It explores the
potential of using LoRA and ControlNet for fine-grained image style transfer
and image editing, empowering users with enhanced control over image
generation. Moreover, PAI-Diffusion seamlessly integrates with Alibaba Cloud's
Machine Learning Platform for AI, providing accessible and scalable solutions.
All the Chinese diffusion model checkpoints, LoRAs, and ControlNets, including
domain-specific ones, are publicly available. A user-friendly Chinese WebUI and
the diffusers-api elastic inference toolkit, also open-sourced, further
facilitate the easy deployment of PAI-Diffusion models in various environments,
making it a valuable resource for Chinese text-to-image synthesis. | [
0.0099558737,
0.0585908145,
-0.0076669184,
0.0302735288,
0.0030954275,
0.0064652083,
0.0261185039,
0.0058622309,
-0.0013248483,
0.0336734876,
-0.0160105191,
-0.0621474944,
0.0409874432,
0.0574750602,
0.0197383016,
-0.1276372224,
-0.0388039723,
-0.0050344011,
-0.0812720433,
-0.024668593,
0.0289774034,
0.0293612666,
0.0420391522,
0.0189107154,
0.0095594581,
-0.0457699485,
-0.0254581682,
0.06866882,
0.0515246652,
-0.0021022535,
-0.0298218466,
0.0305611417,
0.0477760993,
-0.0009402669,
0.0000024003,
-0.0208193641,
-0.0055092517,
0.0129864067,
0.0498517826,
0.0247954223,
0.1503068358,
-0.0222423896,
-0.046256341,
-0.0343125686,
-0.0172802228,
0.0384813324,
0.1049756557,
0.0796840116,
0.0917390957,
0.0364252068,
-0.0309262518,
-0.0788095146,
-0.0262584817,
-0.0309137478,
0.0003227588,
-0.0343950838,
0.0039979629,
0.0110663651,
-0.0068498985,
-0.0442533866,
-0.0355054177,
0.0412257612,
0.0251282565,
-0.0050224797,
-0.0280456692,
0.0397364385,
0.0141179301,
-0.0400396734,
-0.0266961791,
0.0689115375,
-0.0143095823,
-0.0016376199,
-0.005430338,
-0.0075265015,
-0.0290715843,
0.0474840514,
-0.0372416675,
-0.0108379163,
-0.0064127548,
0.0280117802,
-0.05337134,
-0.0243215058,
0.0066778883,
-0.0011183146,
-0.040566694,
-0.0298978183,
0.0455790125,
-0.004156881,
-0.0560190752,
-0.0054981709,
-0.0054243896,
-0.0702139065,
0.0530189276,
0.0304185897,
0.0599840917,
0.0038178584,
-0.0594478026,
-0.03981537,
0.0170364324,
-0.0094017452,
0.0640217885,
-0.0000523639,
-0.0253519882,
0.0329760686,
-0.0387278497,
-0.004585952,
-0.0398493297,
-0.013761309,
-0.0441503823,
-0.0327916145,
-0.0233713891,
-0.0160255488,
-0.0457732826,
-0.0080382237,
-0.0254595019,
-0.0597097054,
-0.0805048048,
0.0125350328,
-0.0215363838,
0.0118429046,
0.0348330624,
0.0196806248,
-0.0585246868,
-0.0146130137,
-0.0240861438,
0.0221950952,
0.0108855842,
0.0166093633,
-0.0009551715,
0.0017609914,
-0.0113286106,
0.0047044158,
0.0474949181,
0.0015432372,
-0.0051817046,
0.0557843894,
-0.0330776833,
0.0186587889,
-0.0265764501,
0.001381085,
-0.0173994694,
-0.0284850243,
-0.0032403076,
-0.072521776,
-0.0150966197,
-0.04664566,
0.0203822609,
-0.0461817645,
-0.0012128502,
0.0196114909,
-0.012814004,
0.0394931659,
-0.0226950236,
-0.0058002309,
0.0197389126,
0.0197794884,
-0.0214023367,
0.0448969305,
0.0703013837,
0.0598919652,
0.0222938545,
-0.0106188981,
0.011883989,
0.0534186661,
0.0117699141,
0.0304446369,
-0.0582427196,
-0.0524891652,
0.0008226539,
0.004399267,
0.0553583391,
0.0371136703,
-0.0315439552,
0.0283158831,
0.0897423774,
0.0117998188,
0.0088728098,
0.0120433373,
0.0744826347,
0.0230649933,
-0.0273236949,
0.007800187,
0.0165810864,
0.0418559387,
0.0378692709,
0.0493232384,
0.007400217,
0.0660519004,
-0.055841025,
-0.0426248126,
0.0442738645,
-0.0331864432,
0.0173594262,
-0.0151741663,
0.0666470677,
0.0570426546,
-0.0449852683,
-0.0033074224,
0.0016564359,
-0.0623141639,
0.0126401186,
-0.0215900857,
0.0223115589,
0.134720102,
0.0484635197,
0.0219044592,
0.0202969201,
0.0270475112,
0.0299436674,
0.084425211,
-0.0143671418,
0.0168230645,
0.0039516669,
-0.0747615993,
-0.0166151971,
0.0229587145,
-0.0042694476,
0.0110583669,
-0.0218910333,
0.087563552,
0.0118893217,
-0.0019306664,
-0.0497692376,
0.0346816145,
-0.0127806794,
-0.0003408999,
0.001607449,
0.033325512,
-0.0152508859,
0.0000964087,
-0.0633512214,
0.0031696062,
-0.0186456088,
-0.0375395305,
-0.041883707,
0.0472794957,
0.0019126416,
-0.0074875308,
-0.0041949479,
-0.043127384,
-0.0160327926,
-0.0145048369,
-0.0554265641,
-0.0416628942,
0.0235928502,
0.0314171351,
0.0053108879,
-0.0222311001,
0.0076275934,
0.0140738813,
0.085134849,
0.0150383301,
0.0362659693,
0.0041970015,
-0.0308293104,
0.0096110385,
0.0572144054,
-0.0263663102,
0.0178079363,
-0.0046815709,
-0.0374904498,
0.0156986266,
-0.0076452289,
-0.0116136093,
0.0441493466,
-0.0237239134,
-0.003997019,
-0.0447584614,
-0.0053653507,
-0.0104734916,
-0.0167353712,
-0.0032619792,
0.035961438,
-0.0077393358,
0.0095010241,
-0.0263523255,
0.0483398549,
-0.0565790571,
-0.0062422324,
0.0272987634,
-0.0344246589,
-0.0167807508,
-0.0226241872,
-0.0066713551,
0.0313574448,
0.0425488874,
0.013526788,
-0.0544483401,
-0.035908889,
0.007432193,
-0.0279451758,
0.0200819615,
-0.0030549902,
-0.0345379673,
0.0007032925,
-0.0260600783,
0.0332344659,
0.0770470873,
0.0201369394,
-0.0058313762,
0.0029906232,
-0.0245886296,
-0.0120470766,
0.0172931608,
-0.0189060643,
-0.015651064,
0.0204559229,
-0.0524934717,
0.0006728299,
0.025565695,
0.0282950774,
0.0064234394,
-0.0515776724,
-0.0163787119,
-0.0190665368,
-0.022110125,
-0.0075120255,
0.0291089416,
-0.0278643817,
-0.0201005246,
-0.0506398231,
-0.0413282365,
0.0432059541,
-0.0273448881,
-0.0057985722,
-0.0124703012,
-0.0163342711,
-0.0085938526,
0.0345403515,
0.0093980171,
0.0455895178,
0.0107936272,
0.0181740727,
-0.0314641185,
0.0381401666,
0.0272325315,
-0.0191322211,
-0.0088855904,
-0.0392814279,
-0.004148812,
-0.0281485859,
0.0047183698,
-0.0067565823,
0.0213485491,
0.0039194194,
-0.0127438828,
-0.0005000056,
-0.0403067395,
0.0559097417,
0.0470379293,
-0.019754434,
0.0489347391,
0.0081721693,
-0.0183199886,
-0.0243324824,
0.0489043742,
0.0595823005,
-0.0121230865,
-0.0432356559,
-0.0233693738,
0.0388880782,
0.0537097342,
0.0449517258,
-0.0282820575,
-0.0294841882,
0.0260215029,
0.0050242767,
0.0306330584,
-0.0131689133,
0.0264766645,
0.077054821,
-0.0725127459,
-0.0066120913,
0.0521380641,
0.0117163062,
-0.0451327562,
-0.0185034238,
0.0116656693,
0.0594657883,
0.0020333973,
-0.0092602642,
-0.1309335083,
-0.0227875393,
-0.0020437196,
-0.0155191878,
0.0024021019,
0.0099508595,
-0.0182132628,
-0.0900386423,
0.0986822546,
0.0224693865,
-0.0167195704,
-0.0264200885,
-0.0138019668,
0.0469958037,
0.0380298421,
-0.0262552761,
-0.0343656614,
0.0102595724,
-0.019887343,
-0.0027507911,
0.0263193175,
-0.0627202764,
-0.0290030688,
-0.0455916896,
-0.0093754353,
0.0746022537,
0.034273386,
-0.0002128576,
-0.0388406664,
0.0124913352,
0.0006278598,
-0.0144625185,
-0.0146923522,
0.0444018804,
0.0332345478,
-0.0224624258,
-0.0087615298,
0.0455230288,
-0.0087411841,
-0.0157678314,
0.0321462005,
0.0367982015,
-0.0149945226,
-0.0506166965,
-0.0419255868,
-0.0062031955,
0.037906453,
0.0414580852,
0.0489557013,
-0.0574293695,
-0.0668443367,
-0.0324951857,
-0.0071180812,
-0.0459230989,
-0.0391495228,
0.0272205397,
-0.0589434803,
-0.0602584258,
-0.0804673061,
0.0002978148,
0.02554157,
0.0395156927,
0.0037234246,
0.0246543419,
0.0067619928,
-0.0018777028,
-0.0502813719,
-0.0370915942,
-0.0305588581,
0.025272958,
-0.0111511853,
-0.0335821807,
0.0212567728,
-0.0291790329,
-0.0000192359,
0.0509394519,
-0.0585272126,
-0.0267432742,
-0.0027597095,
0.0491583608,
0.0105278175,
-0.0138208224,
-0.0125526693,
-0.0307409931,
0.113741599,
0.028093053,
0.0554723144,
-0.0137876663,
0.0025972854,
-0.0180812422,
-0.0106102955,
0.0061784121,
-0.05242908,
0.039957311,
-0.0020576369,
0.0204435606,
0.001384518,
-0.0099500455,
0.0047969515,
-0.0336524062,
-0.0595098101,
-0.0465781875,
0.0117260376,
-0.032168895,
0.0418444201,
-0.0183452889,
-0.016666742,
-0.0635040402,
-0.0379350781,
0.0176944416,
0.0116287172,
0.0066157184,
0.0167482868,
0.0522822924,
-0.0275552925,
-0.0364922881,
-0.0158146266,
0.0338489488,
0.0674807504,
0.0299377088,
0.003363976,
0.0077040317,
-0.0016249045,
-0.0342338495,
0.023587212,
-0.0038530673,
0.044883471,
-0.0033201016,
0.0062478315,
-0.016151512,
0.0424246415,
-0.0148213841,
-0.0433927923,
-0.0671572238,
0.0010706531,
0.0643458739,
0.0271115098,
0.0971622244,
-0.051533591,
-0.0193017572,
-0.0203686114,
0.0240541976,
0.0060734916,
-0.0298520867,
0.0018075765,
-0.0236084927,
0.0051209405,
-0.0097322883,
0.0818785354,
-0.0175722837,
0.0465991274,
-0.0379655138,
-0.0265587922,
-0.0227251966,
-0.0120934937,
0.013518923,
-0.0343893506,
0.0061982898,
-0.0019953593,
-0.029059818,
-0.0938778967,
0.0243881922,
0.0182228442,
-0.0194894932,
0.0224145018,
0.0427722111,
0.0190702826,
-0.000846759,
0.018197488,
-0.0097786533,
0.0282578673,
-0.0458515473,
-0.0115356762,
-0.0031998586,
-6.702403567e-33,
-0.050519079,
-0.030280171,
0.0199520625,
-0.0043218122,
-0.0219805241,
-0.0430401266,
-0.0487034358,
-0.0347588174,
0.0238027945,
0.0248790905,
0.013435767,
-0.0027764679,
0.0230051689,
0.0533952266,
-0.0052300715,
0.0510711707,
0.0343877599,
0.021692967,
0.0059399852,
0.0392040834,
0.0206359103,
0.0323146023,
0.0320972912,
-0.0631118268,
-0.0374032333,
-0.0014091132,
-0.0173901934,
-0.0225918088,
0.0231007822,
0.0335769914,
-0.0132859331,
0.0202826038,
0.0044789049,
-0.0013392649,
-0.0119949244,
-0.0063832812,
-0.0666365549,
-0.0150571112,
-0.0448942371,
0.0087724896,
-0.0618884228,
-0.0348045118,
0.044951275,
-0.0222216118,
0.0382370986,
0.0069903489,
0.0650753975,
-0.0412063524,
0.0047883601,
-0.0514375567,
-0.0748439729,
0.0270985384,
-0.0161138307,
0.0031619237,
0.0065706116,
-0.0023742483,
-0.0006802748,
0.041658923,
-0.093767941,
0.0100065814,
0.0254056379,
0.0312889442,
0.0459083132,
0.0403432585,
0.0421142578,
0.0072066607,
0.0359664783,
-0.0062774913,
-0.0018910409,
0.0167206265,
0.0240078717,
0.068578735,
0.0065470552,
0.0361735262,
-0.0022232297,
-0.0259981174,
-0.0340202972,
0.0326595232,
-0.0365645289,
0.0121821752,
0.0305007454,
0.0290693138,
0.0094578778,
0.0165597331,
-0.0145947319,
-0.0586317219,
-0.0451458693,
-0.0347665958,
0.0105087403,
0.0159335788,
-0.03852617,
-0.0069720321,
0.0251969919,
0.003693358,
-0.0286379494,
-0.043393869,
-0.0557997897,
0.0508256145,
0.0038348208,
-0.0039017007,
-0.0175109114,
-0.0669215769,
0.0063932985,
0.0130507415,
0.0196805429,
0.0211373903,
0.0333705507,
0.0523217395,
-0.0382245034,
0.0051665464,
-0.0159912873,
0.0021227219,
0.0544721298,
0.0179689061,
-0.0080816206,
-0.0191338807,
-0.0494485348,
0.0117448494,
0.0363310836,
0.0306565557,
-0.0097609451,
-0.0375669301,
-0.016667556,
-0.0070043174,
-0.077600114,
0.0356500931,
-0.0433324762,
0.0412277468,
0.0600534007,
-0.0921683609,
-0.0607313998,
0.0201959107,
3.086e-7,
0.0397791043,
-0.005081221,
0.0172069278,
0.04333831,
0.0030709412,
0.0187080111,
-0.0314700864,
0.0302690547,
-0.0053130649,
-0.007063204,
0.0337854102,
0.0504337847,
0.072057344,
0.0028510694,
-0.0478847325,
0.0208551567,
-0.0054084472,
0.0459198989,
-0.0171771403,
0.0231972598,
0.0366517305,
0.0761116371,
-0.0065932763,
-0.0296147987,
0.0586192459,
-0.0041486002,
0.0799048245,
-0.0012083786,
0.0349360332,
0.019559674,
-0.0291465446,
-0.0146361981,
-0.0533309914,
-0.0063186535,
-0.0308661796,
-0.0136679867,
0.039532993,
0.0211382676,
-0.0360199623,
0.0146439606,
0.0052427924,
-0.0100002484,
0.0051080021,
-0.0421204716,
0.0639010146,
-0.0104467059,
-0.0177222751,
-0.0402963124,
-0.0087159751,
-0.0060314792,
0.0175551195,
-0.034956567,
-0.043023698,
0.0274299011,
0.0371005572,
0.0065557817,
-0.0295537692,
-0.0589397438,
-0.0250540711,
-0.0429132804,
-0.0223948359,
-0.0096835867,
-0.0745244548,
-0.0138988607,
-0.0055455975,
0.0194844007,
-0.0005376432,
2.960446018e-34,
0.0018796279,
-0.0059642037,
0.00286265,
0.0392783135,
0.0214730762,
-0.0139320437,
-0.002833226,
0.0017717436,
-0.0153876413,
-0.0752159357,
-0.0480012707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05519v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05519v3 | NExT-GPT: Any-to-Any Multimodal LLM | 2023-09-11T15:02:25 | 2024-06-25T05:01:09 | Shengqiong Wu, Hao Fei, Leigang Qu, Wei Ji, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | While recently Multimodal Large Language Models (MM-LLMs) have made exciting
strides, they mostly fall prey to the limitation of only input-side multimodal
understanding, without the ability to produce content in multiple modalities.
As we humans always perceive the world and communicate with people through
various modalities, developing any-to-any MM-LLMs capable of accepting and
delivering content in any modality becomes essential to human-level AI. To fill
the gap, we present an end-to-end general-purpose any-to-any MM-LLM system,
NExT-GPT. We connect an LLM with multimodal adaptors and different diffusion
decoders, enabling NExT-GPT to perceive inputs and generate outputs in
arbitrary combinations of text, images, videos, and audio. By leveraging the
existing well-trained highly-performing encoders and decoders, NExT-GPT is
tuned with only a small amount of parameter (1%) of certain projection layers,
which not only benefits low-cost training and also facilitates convenient
expansion to more potential modalities. Moreover, we introduce a
modality-switching instruction tuning (MosIT) and manually curate a
high-quality dataset for MosIT, based on which NExT-GPT is empowered with
complex cross-modal semantic understanding and content generation. Overall, our
research showcases the promising possibility of building an AI agent capable of
modeling universal modalities, paving the way for more human-like AI research
in the community. Project page: https://next-gpt.github.io/ | [
0.0120899472,
0.0503861904,
-0.0073456382,
0.056246303,
0.0023379838,
-0.0126835499,
0.0060370304,
-0.0103737442,
-0.0230684392,
-0.0563229397,
-0.0689498633,
-0.0248226132,
0.0024368509,
0.0453840308,
0.0477993712,
-0.048852399,
0.0384065472,
-0.0312454663,
-0.0543476306,
0.0107564731,
0.0170999803,
0.0281466823,
-0.0236604474,
0.0363091491,
-0.0255956464,
-0.0099214017,
-0.060235016,
0.0243988261,
0.0230335593,
-0.0382037349,
-0.0133918272,
0.010099628,
0.0757112354,
-0.0092457384,
0.0000019801,
-0.0006539735,
0.024562791,
-0.0254367795,
0.0105301319,
-0.0226968415,
0.0414650328,
-0.0461365804,
-0.0146621494,
-0.0080245016,
-0.0261748899,
-0.011481435,
0.0444254652,
0.0327205732,
0.0812403262,
0.0883982107,
-0.0160646848,
-0.0351576172,
0.0556242354,
-0.0243122913,
0.0448091589,
-0.0390648209,
-0.0029356666,
-0.0086749895,
0.0371009931,
0.0021967571,
-0.0663213581,
0.0172070302,
0.033299081,
0.0239852164,
-0.0024366442,
0.0507918559,
0.0655401647,
-0.0529394858,
-0.0497617573,
0.105037488,
-0.0006181027,
0.0078963982,
0.0005482641,
-0.0023726237,
-0.0072776526,
-0.0324670076,
-0.0237196926,
0.050574623,
-0.0010202526,
0.0419303551,
-0.0084816217,
-0.0058110706,
0.0218099281,
0.0189634319,
-0.0195470974,
0.0300795753,
0.0059470674,
-0.0022186369,
-0.0014431751,
-0.0119332504,
0.0097664343,
-0.0546627082,
0.0090294415,
0.0443717502,
-0.0192851443,
-0.0035895694,
-0.0589552559,
-0.0177682713,
-0.0178703256,
0.0134439124,
0.0361533165,
0.0487454124,
-0.0412912406,
0.0311907437,
0.0075183879,
0.0083371876,
-0.0546975508,
0.0359025933,
-0.0138306674,
-0.0093924506,
-0.0481753163,
-0.0025278048,
-0.0127692046,
-0.0102555137,
-0.0796075091,
-0.0402363762,
-0.0005302801,
0.0431508683,
-0.0098435506,
-0.0172018502,
0.0186000913,
0.0134493764,
-0.0477151945,
-0.0278109964,
-0.0094506061,
0.0829199702,
-0.0276704319,
0.0261104759,
0.0248196516,
-0.0525157452,
-0.0025859349,
0.0628172457,
0.0047229584,
-0.02208451,
0.0089729922,
0.1141138375,
-0.0715127513,
-0.0382027552,
-0.0290651154,
-0.018769078,
-0.0104667647,
-0.0721913576,
0.0537037924,
-0.0247184336,
0.0314987674,
-0.0088579468,
0.0080159204,
-0.0237919688,
-0.0064176377,
-0.0120911598,
-0.0089712031,
0.0701785609,
0.0153609915,
0.0136499247,
0.046277605,
0.0170347765,
-0.0091965022,
0.0750643685,
0.0516996384,
0.0274755396,
0.0054563889,
0.0027076134,
-0.0035008045,
0.0442653708,
-0.0038434719,
0.0164802093,
-0.0120110055,
-0.0231522657,
0.0081533175,
0.059031792,
0.0810869783,
0.0520590879,
-0.038718693,
-0.0385542363,
0.0742573887,
0.0058004083,
0.0034600096,
0.024237683,
0.0483148582,
0.0448835455,
-0.0319109224,
-0.0054556844,
-0.0427588001,
0.0815233812,
-0.0129521256,
-0.0092776483,
0.0479685962,
0.0469839461,
-0.0469739996,
-0.0058816392,
0.0175914541,
-0.0169864055,
0.042209927,
-0.0073666507,
0.0208263975,
-0.0021069443,
-0.073500745,
0.0342935324,
-0.0037006477,
-0.0490572602,
0.031189505,
-0.0590351745,
0.0294459332,
0.0490202308,
0.0027441769,
0.0138563355,
0.0038113731,
-0.0181117281,
0.0215833951,
0.0860809311,
0.0094796736,
0.0036938298,
0.0537633188,
-0.0729129463,
-0.0251224078,
-0.0192209277,
-0.0017605656,
0.0453920104,
-0.0407180898,
0.0194917265,
-0.0077587245,
-0.0313216932,
0.0564282723,
0.029655369,
0.0110245012,
0.0221079346,
-0.0071234996,
-0.000223948,
0.0191818271,
0.0048587332,
-0.0198644828,
-0.0256141499,
0.0126726506,
-0.0569803566,
-0.0055895126,
0.0356961116,
-0.0773597658,
-0.0102138286,
0.0135599822,
-0.0765644908,
-0.0030388676,
0.0297995228,
-0.0448092557,
-0.0410750508,
0.0376556106,
-0.0268107112,
0.0129253333,
-0.0500275642,
-0.0288183335,
0.0424333848,
0.0323997103,
0.0228634439,
0.0305355713,
-0.0130570503,
-0.0325831436,
0.0325698964,
0.0242247749,
0.0025980065,
-0.0128839994,
-0.0175233241,
0.0145459864,
5.94e-8,
0.0310160518,
-0.0025571443,
0.0276688132,
-0.0460924804,
-0.0453041755,
-0.1074956208,
0.002639554,
-0.0254028421,
-0.0104103992,
0.0209243186,
0.0203133803,
-0.0070411521,
-0.0103558246,
-0.0249022115,
0.0489707217,
0.0332503878,
0.015863141,
0.0088800248,
0.0122716613,
0.0037945444,
-0.0182881355,
0.0114975469,
0.0211817995,
0.0257336143,
-0.0324398875,
-0.0026649039,
-0.063949123,
-0.0138998255,
0.0048606852,
0.0224364959,
-0.0306004547,
-0.0511146486,
0.0388177857,
-0.0272784792,
0.0311619733,
0.0678595901,
0.0325581245,
0.0342299566,
0.0447578169,
-0.0292947218,
-0.0368688293,
0.032859005,
0.0266893823,
-0.0156488176,
-0.0641325265,
-0.0032678773,
-0.0297389757,
0.0795316622,
0.0143393138,
0.021656584,
-0.0798412561,
-0.0169795603,
0.0187513772,
-0.0784078985,
-0.0074200416,
0.0149316518,
-0.0281781927,
0.0226586238,
-0.0248893034,
-0.0185303111,
0.0421497077,
-0.0325046144,
-0.0342043154,
-0.0073273294,
0.0051517906,
-0.0113570197,
0.0404520966,
-0.0106966188,
0.0297795311,
-0.0184065271,
-0.0094632097,
-0.0502255298,
0.0064125652,
-0.0055905133,
0.0081114192,
0.041402597,
-0.064765349,
0.0001236471,
-0.0293702986,
-0.0406170487,
-0.0136833787,
-0.032867264,
-0.0208300054,
-0.0120659871,
-0.0361487046,
-0.0093556372,
-0.0295511894,
-0.00043805,
0.0173229892,
0.0318077505,
-0.0209932067,
-0.0035105741,
-0.0674268156,
0.0253628436,
0.0413446911,
0.0635051131,
-0.0450251512,
-0.0507660992,
-0.0033343565,
0.0478437766,
0.0110465819,
-0.0076858355,
-0.0564584285,
0.0592782944,
0.0204615239,
0.0350495428,
-0.0348725766,
0.0372412167,
0.0862347186,
-0.0548216328,
0.0205277316,
0.0745755509,
-0.0095616784,
-0.0988425612,
-0.0035764629,
0.0213379096,
0.0310557745,
0.0101633361,
0.0103152888,
-0.1028391719,
-0.0832551122,
-0.0062531768,
-0.0111402776,
0.0358126238,
-0.0023204675,
-0.0143521233,
-0.0636977479,
0.037000794,
0.016198799,
-0.0248087179,
-0.0351993293,
-0.0026557907,
-0.0049773981,
0.0088026319,
0.0188602824,
0.0131199602,
0.0080170659,
-0.0196138211,
0.0088336281,
0.038378641,
-0.0566687211,
0.0200348515,
-0.0197322145,
0.0533755869,
0.0396472998,
-0.0008816427,
0.0090217376,
-0.0608053319,
0.0170823392,
0.0047434038,
0.0087804133,
-0.0032022847,
0.0148988087,
-0.054344438,
-0.0094280001,
0.0148238158,
0.0460716188,
-0.0348221213,
-0.0067510465,
-0.0230237246,
0.0846632794,
-0.0231529512,
0.0010663779,
-0.0232166238,
-0.0062677297,
0.0249826424,
0.0634923801,
0.0149896191,
-0.0550147556,
-0.0413858145,
-0.0331947282,
0.0148337744,
-0.0384090208,
-0.0124818282,
0.0157407466,
-0.001441275,
-0.0463308692,
-0.0231884401,
-0.0228380188,
-0.01133285,
0.0095735295,
0.0167269092,
-0.0371307731,
0.0157995895,
0.0134398974,
-0.0420455225,
0.025702104,
-0.0197441224,
0.0203815158,
-0.0528141893,
-0.0065715783,
0.0529899932,
-0.05838966,
0.0167701691,
0.0487699881,
-0.0915211141,
-0.065653339,
-0.0417757817,
0.0233468879,
0.0133645087,
0.070326522,
0.0284454785,
-0.0478463806,
0.0403143428,
0.0005153177,
-0.026721485,
0.0547999479,
0.0405610725,
0.0097579658,
-0.0088989325,
0.0403771177,
-0.0476372354,
0.0040819081,
-0.0052004512,
0.0316277556,
0.0040208613,
-0.0274724495,
0.0032217007,
-0.0604961999,
-0.0090105822,
-0.0363189764,
0.0184943099,
-0.0296733771,
-0.0093448246,
0.0078937961,
0.03051061,
-0.0639185905,
-0.0011748334,
0.0302296355,
-0.0164370034,
0.0135401236,
-0.0194961652,
0.0182696935,
0.0381098948,
-0.0023060269,
0.0395619385,
0.0050911214,
-0.0034248785,
-0.0053151972,
0.0132815987,
-0.0007967573,
0.0154525777,
-0.0274792351,
0.0113939242,
-0.0233885217,
0.0962426588,
-0.0016121892,
-0.0277258586,
0.0009874194,
0.0675635114,
-0.0120976102,
-0.0228939336,
-0.0267439131,
0.0674404651,
0.06512817,
0.0567440391,
0.0535837673,
0.0006917756,
0.0086574154,
-0.0118338829,
0.0829057246,
-0.0239494648,
-0.055224102,
0.048600819,
0.0111514311,
0.000821613,
-0.0109236641,
0.0386850685,
-0.0177562218,
0.0236842744,
-0.0063667605,
0.0381182879,
-0.0418035947,
-0.0231154598,
0.0062156888,
0.0194762275,
0.0064996663,
0.045064088,
0.0014171529,
-0.065478839,
-0.0199730098,
0.0265640635,
-0.0126433782,
-0.0196573175,
0.0333103947,
0.0434221439,
0.0011445023,
-0.0331034772,
-0.016659243,
-0.0148560451,
0.0068421992,
-0.0099422326,
-0.0142562678,
-6.312473724e-33,
-0.0381874964,
0.0136241,
0.0390862189,
-0.0275058839,
-0.0442320444,
-0.0259547886,
-0.0474123023,
0.0069500646,
-0.0088873599,
-0.0031432768,
0.0040677693,
0.0150740724,
0.0000384137,
0.0597252585,
0.0007868708,
-0.0128957098,
0.0331038423,
-0.0445060879,
-0.0164977517,
0.0307696871,
0.0382599831,
0.0206267964,
0.0464206897,
-0.018797474,
-0.0097973021,
0.032594569,
-0.0365580209,
0.0124842431,
0.0031411515,
0.0513918214,
-0.0535367951,
0.0271796696,
0.0336123258,
-0.0078286203,
-0.0271541942,
0.022866644,
-0.0722909346,
0.0206555109,
0.0026449349,
0.0326949172,
-0.0767610073,
-0.0544796661,
0.0442804061,
-0.0183713771,
-0.0186288897,
-0.0114733446,
0.0242463406,
-0.0020537595,
0.0174433794,
0.03110433,
-0.0349665061,
0.0017726539,
-0.0200854857,
-0.034524329,
0.0222476218,
0.0175871495,
0.0016659994,
-0.0089788437,
-0.0616737343,
0.0355834924,
-0.0402827859,
0.0086836657,
0.0816599652,
0.0047385935,
0.0131861083,
0.0424146056,
0.0149257686,
-0.0450829118,
-0.0038156114,
-0.0065436857,
0.016396787,
0.045318488,
-0.030873036,
0.0639147982,
0.0001360563,
-0.0104126101,
-0.0126272365,
0.0087979753,
0.0157484915,
0.0364231691,
0.0277437493,
0.0395986848,
0.0208669621,
0.001621955,
-0.026062781,
-0.0313414671,
-0.0131770363,
-0.037860252,
0.0429613143,
0.031465143,
0.0089788195,
-0.0306705777,
0.1039975584,
-0.0450550206,
0.0127283558,
0.013403031,
-0.0360038504,
0.0568662845,
0.0273229983,
0.024512019,
-0.0341136828,
-0.0249246135,
0.0600892939,
-0.0422746204,
0.0115960371,
0.0209669899,
-0.0300375391,
0.0650322214,
-0.0279349182,
-0.0211209804,
-0.0433393493,
0.0241846908,
-0.0213424191,
0.0341996588,
0.0170899723,
0.0010328013,
-0.0454516895,
0.0408106111,
-0.061024338,
0.0217311587,
-0.036835175,
-0.0503647923,
0.0013156023,
0.0541403331,
-0.0404287949,
0.0211960059,
-0.060579136,
-0.0523969792,
0.0384915508,
-0.0626338348,
-0.0092668766,
0.067086041,
2.737e-7,
-0.0093390625,
-0.0091516152,
-0.006028553,
0.0049424898,
0.0530631691,
0.0672025308,
-0.0245457757,
0.0659119636,
-0.0154533843,
-0.0692231432,
-0.0091327149,
0.0644482747,
0.047022447,
-0.0010683067,
-0.0582805425,
0.0148199638,
0.0164423957,
0.0217918791,
-0.0338728428,
0.0071408493,
0.0477698036,
0.0771315321,
-0.0259252302,
-0.010765695,
0.0248489231,
0.0019820649,
0.077715829,
-0.02302045,
-0.0158788208,
-0.0162257049,
-0.0070412741,
-0.009659458,
-0.0269313734,
0.0167978965,
0.0201301109,
-0.0010374936,
-0.0206289385,
0.0656567588,
-0.0094729327,
-0.0995606482,
0.0027961251,
0.0258674435,
-0.0383994766,
-0.021497529,
0.0599666461,
-0.0250387378,
-0.0316885933,
-0.0242071468,
0.0001805466,
-0.0196661949,
-0.0335610174,
-0.0369016342,
-0.0509656183,
-0.0046922145,
0.0223268345,
-0.0234657153,
-0.0209980831,
-0.068353124,
0.016633125,
-0.0310161747,
-0.0866510943,
-0.0272910912,
-0.0708763152,
-0.0025126201,
0.0690793321,
-0.054949373,
-0.0510418862,
2.108000933e-34,
0.0143322321,
-0.0278137717,
0.0102972053,
-0.0019294098,
0.0299157742,
-0.0045928485,
-0.0275967661,
-0.0098434901,
-0.0085655358,
-0.0810337961,
-0.039215941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05516v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05516v4 | Optimize Weight Rounding via Signed Gradient Descent for the Quantization of LLMs | 2023-09-11T14:58:23 | 2024-05-23T10:43:09 | Wenhua Cheng, Weiwei Zhang, Haihao Shen, Yiyang Cai, Xin He, Kaokao Lv, Yi Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional proficiency in
language-related tasks, but their deployment poses significant challenges due
to substantial memory and storage requirements. Weight-only quantization has
emerged as a promising solution to address these challenges. Previous research
suggests that fine-tuning through up and down rounding can enhance performance.
In this study, we introduce SignRound, a method that utilizes signed gradient
descent (SignSGD) to optimize rounding values and weight clipping within just
200 steps. SignRound integrates the advantages of Quantization-Aware Training
(QAT) and Post-Training Quantization (PTQ), achieving exceptional results
across 2 to 4 bits while maintaining low tuning costs and avoiding additional
inference overhead. For example, SignRound achieves absolute average accuracy
improvements ranging from 6.91\% to 33.22\% at 2 bits. It also demonstrates
robust generalization to recent models and achieves near-lossless quantization
in most scenarios at 4 bits. The source code is publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/intel/auto-round}. | [
-0.0323393606,
0.0557543188,
0.0174190123,
0.050229162,
-0.0053000096,
-0.0073695467,
0.0016983572,
0.0141925821,
-0.018402392,
-0.0308306292,
-0.0331670307,
-0.0351052172,
-0.0038533984,
-0.0093111955,
0.0371840186,
-0.0151792662,
0.0593349449,
-0.0273101535,
-0.0426238179,
-0.0224664528,
0.0137470476,
0.0183954369,
-0.0155660715,
0.0164517034,
-0.0073205293,
-0.0080281887,
0.0008704155,
0.0561557673,
0.0221892018,
-0.0403824113,
0.0115934191,
0.0153683871,
0.044249028,
0.0464534648,
0.0000019581,
-0.0110585447,
-0.0022570919,
-0.0007581359,
-0.0473409668,
0.0550914481,
0.0272018835,
-0.0499760248,
-0.047132358,
0.0318542458,
-0.0288621616,
-0.0135782966,
0.0579068065,
-0.0022543056,
0.053818509,
0.0866208747,
0.0091374395,
-0.0332139134,
0.0205789711,
-0.0407222845,
-0.0303877313,
-0.0271430127,
-0.0092809796,
0.0355702303,
-0.0353155471,
-0.0231183842,
-0.0271061622,
0.035274487,
0.0299624056,
0.0277684089,
-0.068425931,
0.0276773181,
-0.0485464558,
0.0251739584,
-0.022155188,
0.0506783612,
-0.0782921165,
-0.0333746821,
-0.022085743,
-0.0120651592,
-0.0396036357,
-0.1088038981,
-0.0322063118,
0.0257840063,
0.0308248661,
0.0658262521,
-0.0370355844,
-0.0437202565,
0.0602065995,
0.0134095289,
-0.0328593813,
0.0783278048,
0.0025740846,
0.0018874898,
-0.008650315,
-0.018821571,
-0.0666656196,
-0.0351441503,
0.0177231096,
0.0156099638,
0.0280755814,
0.01234686,
-0.0541002378,
0.0091817519,
-0.0002504903,
-0.0198869761,
-0.0092142504,
0.0840892419,
0.012477532,
0.0170049611,
-0.0145405289,
0.0014143559,
-0.0060522822,
0.0319501087,
-0.0316883847,
0.0354507789,
-0.0011184809,
0.0027255791,
-0.0504305959,
0.0173355024,
-0.018848924,
-0.0088044694,
-0.039993342,
-0.0260143299,
-0.0107673835,
-0.0356998481,
0.0718133077,
0.0129642757,
-0.0250830352,
-0.0208383873,
0.0291411895,
0.0264930595,
-0.0233573671,
0.0028484473,
-0.0103326859,
-0.0432920717,
-0.0227528997,
0.0207641628,
-0.0205963217,
-0.0079981498,
0.0280575547,
0.0483786836,
-0.0043986407,
-0.019022122,
-0.0337294713,
-0.0023674835,
0.0006994301,
-0.0407468751,
-0.0468161218,
-0.0618836991,
-0.0009094276,
-0.0269203391,
0.0100850808,
-0.0505030714,
0.0316032693,
0.0114745861,
0.0208179522,
0.0696914867,
-0.0437042639,
-0.015784299,
0.0002758611,
0.0086897695,
-0.0112452693,
0.1064318493,
0.0625145659,
0.0437904336,
0.0109239602,
0.0340020061,
-0.0614451356,
0.0457438864,
0.0533372313,
-0.0183735769,
-0.0477288701,
-0.0406053886,
-0.0336045399,
0.0451263897,
0.0966828242,
0.057948824,
-0.0580943152,
-0.0452603437,
0.025794616,
0.0455468185,
0.0367484726,
0.0124273533,
0.023999054,
0.0225615744,
0.0105790896,
-0.0455824509,
-0.0618207641,
0.0032225256,
0.0098446654,
0.0095668696,
0.0158894863,
0.0455356464,
-0.0164024718,
-0.028116893,
-0.0315793641,
-0.0148705216,
0.0093490174,
0.0132050607,
0.0230149589,
-0.0038218708,
-0.0261951908,
0.0973489881,
0.0395588093,
-0.0375965312,
0.0073097451,
-0.0673981383,
-0.0028672027,
0.0508500561,
0.0284379944,
0.0074931141,
-0.0195156205,
0.0224662647,
-0.0060493024,
0.0156787671,
-0.0021689462,
0.003497028,
0.0242009256,
-0.077396214,
-0.0150447832,
0.0288956314,
-0.0080949888,
0.0123352865,
0.0198156238,
0.0544352457,
0.0119341696,
-0.0489854589,
0.0143200429,
0.0215481073,
0.0188260563,
-0.0476066582,
0.0441030264,
-0.0191580877,
0.013598891,
0.0041320482,
-0.0089524426,
0.0042866655,
0.0318323746,
-0.0488521308,
0.0022026319,
-0.0154914474,
-0.0237516277,
-0.0516866595,
0.069884114,
-0.0133484593,
0.0409993604,
0.0423478261,
-0.0656918287,
-0.0384936556,
0.0408295244,
-0.0173963495,
0.0510121658,
-0.0573876277,
0.0205269549,
0.0102123627,
0.0365936793,
-0.0383689925,
0.0158900879,
-0.0553793907,
-0.0107784728,
0.0005574208,
0.0161366239,
-0.0012189341,
-0.0411985032,
-0.0080025019,
-0.0004699939,
0.0033749372,
0.0440974012,
-0.0270037781,
0.0289965998,
0.0056622913,
0.0182739925,
-0.1251356751,
0.0343007855,
-0.0520786233,
0.0616998337,
0.0309682209,
0.0044851508,
-0.0043286853,
-0.0348339379,
-0.0208016504,
-0.0226172879,
-0.0402107462,
-0.0129505238,
-0.010964144,
-0.0042956136,
-0.0019302155,
-0.0236620158,
-0.0381570458,
-0.0032139276,
-0.0013785241,
-0.0721242875,
-0.0207973421,
-0.0750660673,
0.0226550512,
-0.0110621853,
0.0536290146,
-0.0039414512,
-0.0389571376,
0.0045242445,
-0.0153402314,
0.0168092232,
0.0547095202,
0.0012351922,
0.0070145954,
0.0581245013,
0.0169786382,
-0.0746866912,
0.0289903171,
0.0038437417,
-0.0210458506,
-0.0266158246,
-0.0343636014,
-0.0337756649,
0.0879545733,
-0.0175254494,
-0.0049381424,
-0.039435003,
0.003746989,
-0.018555291,
-0.0245191883,
-0.0186634678,
0.0565523766,
-0.030230416,
0.0367697105,
-0.006862002,
-0.056876529,
0.0315356851,
-0.0320725664,
-0.0125486823,
-0.0260145105,
-0.0124912774,
-0.0283978228,
0.0493710004,
0.026122611,
0.0381409489,
-0.0327037498,
-0.0160163734,
-0.0543093607,
-0.0076449369,
0.0211028829,
-0.0272619799,
0.0310238712,
-0.0266086515,
0.0273023099,
-0.0521439873,
-0.0193484388,
0.0119342962,
0.0084974831,
-0.0204835664,
0.0172641017,
0.0057845069,
-0.049562864,
0.0191394109,
0.0544596687,
-0.0188761409,
0.0369129553,
-0.0218889173,
0.0121133802,
-0.0104781464,
0.0020573942,
0.0456927232,
-0.0003145892,
0.0376941375,
-0.0184842292,
-0.0298349988,
0.0515297316,
0.0483082086,
0.0732593089,
-0.0423793346,
-0.0024918106,
0.0493458286,
-0.0189516153,
-0.0049323849,
0.0272833854,
0.0779440925,
-0.0478515588,
0.0166112557,
0.0773846582,
0.0341628715,
-0.0912465453,
0.018950453,
-0.0078841411,
0.0378642157,
0.0076328833,
0.004910232,
-0.1063927636,
-0.0534899384,
0.0189847108,
0.0311668776,
0.0215719044,
0.0097166914,
-0.0285936072,
-0.0760239363,
0.0022158111,
0.0247081704,
-0.0313971601,
-0.0072234184,
-0.008125484,
-0.0109262103,
-0.03920158,
0.0627646297,
0.0426907912,
-0.0307111684,
0.010942162,
0.0376105569,
-0.0323720723,
-0.0586289912,
-0.0060507799,
-0.0352994651,
0.0480534062,
0.0460609756,
0.0003577615,
0.0093332753,
-0.0168997049,
0.0401203744,
-0.0043202881,
-0.0179613456,
-0.0252130721,
0.0160316806,
0.0020032586,
-0.0042619067,
0.0055524786,
0.0097433515,
-0.0365158841,
0.0015092918,
0.007094549,
0.0500090681,
0.0044776089,
0.0037747107,
-0.0116518103,
-0.0225049369,
-0.0210183579,
0.0240152273,
0.0117636882,
-0.0228862949,
-0.0459252819,
-0.0243192054,
0.0165777653,
-0.0239241607,
-0.0332744382,
-0.0048111915,
-0.0226206351,
-0.0390401073,
-0.0367090628,
-0.0019511539,
0.0085654212,
0.0402723737,
-0.0166476574,
-0.0249092449,
0.0062000663,
0.0075985459,
-0.1071004346,
0.0262889843,
-0.0324273072,
0.0580760576,
-0.0646716207,
-0.0003432856,
0.0311812386,
0.0017109362,
0.0029440688,
0.0065858187,
-0.142592296,
-0.0633790419,
-0.0393626578,
0.0360726416,
0.0149759194,
0.0776839107,
0.0079808151,
-0.0458323583,
0.0340969153,
0.0583420657,
0.0200668592,
0.029829381,
0.0622617826,
-0.0014890688,
0.0114981094,
0.0537201241,
-0.0262507424,
0.0237961281,
0.0058879107,
0.0708963126,
-0.0684307292,
-0.0259131566,
-0.0157458112,
-0.0021160124,
0.0252747852,
-0.0304407254,
-0.0084766615,
0.0139688132,
0.0517619252,
0.0113037927,
0.0234791767,
-0.0472996458,
0.0189724639,
0.0248047039,
-0.0059591727,
-0.0228960495,
0.0089854319,
0.0358948074,
-0.0065684873,
0.0244898349,
0.0210628211,
-0.0363617912,
0.0523297228,
0.0459423363,
-0.0101353591,
-0.0231173318,
-0.0092731817,
0.0038435082,
0.0232537612,
-0.0304191764,
0.0111321332,
0.0007417101,
0.0097341789,
-0.0527966097,
0.045213487,
0.0033238681,
-0.0500860922,
-0.0651083663,
-0.0001038549,
0.0669552311,
0.0550727025,
0.0312364418,
0.0157237668,
-0.0205770452,
0.0017474121,
0.0169380996,
-0.0309261661,
0.0293399561,
0.0578021258,
0.0171372425,
-0.0165545419,
0.0051192241,
0.0387078188,
-0.0251445025,
0.0263784584,
0.0005956529,
0.0142074851,
0.0187623203,
-0.0431267172,
-0.0410439856,
0.0252987929,
-0.002438372,
0.0001926667,
0.0040660254,
-0.0655606017,
-0.0048179682,
0.037946783,
-0.0104589127,
-0.0087742331,
0.0342283025,
0.0230065323,
-0.0016153906,
-0.0368568227,
-0.0211449359,
-0.0338962339,
0.0093005048,
-0.0079553947,
-0.0284710769,
-6.029091791e-33,
-0.0313506015,
0.0340511762,
0.0182106327,
0.021942161,
-0.0543860123,
-0.0057765455,
-0.0037520386,
-0.0056009251,
-0.0163478777,
-0.0206728261,
-0.0091222525,
0.0119433803,
0.0279891752,
0.0023978746,
-0.0265619941,
0.0172476266,
0.0658978075,
-0.0064583779,
-0.0180506296,
0.0141642028,
-0.0062124892,
0.0386580601,
0.0721473619,
0.0060539963,
-0.027388731,
0.0260201525,
-0.0199385565,
0.0219516512,
0.0069748065,
0.0235808268,
-0.025865728,
0.0343150273,
-0.0007739926,
0.0133183924,
-0.031831637,
-0.0605545752,
-0.0750963762,
-0.0089162588,
0.0254877824,
0.0622297674,
0.0056482744,
-0.0158461779,
0.0417641811,
0.0170094203,
-0.0477929041,
-0.0049609686,
-0.0083529111,
-0.0104502337,
-0.0404623225,
-0.0619967766,
-0.0049736467,
0.0430496484,
0.0387700051,
0.0054232352,
0.0514524542,
-0.0008607665,
-0.0313358903,
-0.0229397714,
-0.0602013804,
-0.025568774,
0.0094699087,
0.0821684524,
0.0757949054,
0.0362192616,
0.0258948617,
0.0371341482,
0.0614136457,
-0.039661631,
-0.0110178702,
0.0079883011,
0.0757325366,
-0.0202253181,
0.0271201935,
0.0254758243,
0.0998287201,
-0.0138573721,
-0.0608886369,
-0.0229687467,
0.0473767258,
0.0251792558,
0.002997326,
0.0797713771,
-0.0089177685,
-0.0198208205,
-0.0233706459,
-0.0288912747,
-0.0387796462,
-0.0763586909,
0.0044005681,
0.0248355083,
-0.0387347266,
0.0162483118,
0.037054304,
-0.0397489145,
-0.010750859,
-0.0266918261,
0.0228133108,
0.0150277968,
0.0063434718,
0.0342343673,
-0.0374047346,
-0.0268880483,
-0.0096898014,
-0.0241618119,
0.0232643243,
-0.0050503919,
0.0330864191,
0.0547748357,
-0.0518746972,
-0.0129119828,
-0.0362334028,
0.0264323261,
0.0018778709,
0.0774943456,
0.0179146919,
0.0008475673,
-0.0023189795,
0.0553659834,
-0.0129207969,
0.0046589719,
-0.0294331908,
0.0248555727,
0.0127474172,
0.0579288043,
-0.0626216233,
-0.002825886,
-0.021639267,
0.0340055563,
0.0361292847,
-0.0825161189,
-0.0495254435,
0.0285590999,
2.614e-7,
0.0490807816,
-0.0008264369,
0.0084522385,
0.0286303461,
-0.0143329231,
-0.0177096073,
-0.0144219622,
0.0091821142,
0.0079415822,
0.0099238437,
0.0058069145,
0.0274581872,
0.0281132851,
0.0382461399,
-0.0821200535,
0.0487339236,
-0.0310026743,
0.0077411239,
-0.0015500168,
-0.0326862223,
0.0083608357,
0.1215507388,
0.006369689,
-0.0277908258,
0.0474388748,
0.0030998653,
0.030128276,
-0.0074616284,
0.005574239,
0.003322013,
0.0274940636,
0.0125425365,
-0.0094971498,
-0.0351012833,
0.0015977166,
-0.0055343052,
-0.043255195,
0.0680212229,
-0.035883829,
-0.0270836409,
0.0066294251,
-0.0091338642,
-0.0125952503,
0.000954097,
0.0652963147,
-0.031677641,
-0.0009516105,
-0.1172424704,
-0.0078059989,
-0.0237785857,
-0.0037239043,
-0.0573443696,
0.0133237997,
0.0348270014,
0.0283436384,
-0.0216769185,
-0.0208313279,
-0.0987982154,
-0.0491689593,
0.0142906029,
-0.0187806915,
-0.0473069362,
-0.045266822,
0.0242982712,
-0.009587205,
-0.0582645349,
-0.0127696702,
2.313019316e-34,
0.0715647042,
-0.0371776745,
0.0131881163,
0.0721101537,
-0.0029045395,
-0.008314658,
0.0021851743,
0.0091359448,
-0.0220751129,
-0.0214479137,
-0.0421451479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05503v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05503v1 | Long-Range Transformer Architectures for Document Understanding | 2023-09-11T14:45:24 | 2023-09-11T14:45:24 | Thibault Douzon, Stefan Duffner, Christophe Garcia, Jérémy Espinas | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T01, I.2.7 | Since their release, Transformers have revolutionized many fields from
Natural Language Understanding to Computer Vision. Document Understanding (DU)
was not left behind with first Transformer based models for DU dating from late
2019. However, the computational complexity of the self-attention operation
limits their capabilities to small sequences. In this paper we explore multiple
strategies to apply Transformer based models to long multi-page documents. We
introduce 2 new multi-modal (text + layout) long-range models for DU. They are
based on efficient implementations of Transformers for long sequences.
Long-range models can process whole documents at once effectively and are less
impaired by the document's length. We compare them to LayoutLM, a classical
Transformer adapted for DU and pre-trained on millions of documents. We further
propose 2D relative attention bias to guide self-attention towards relevant
tokens without harming model efficiency. We observe improvements on multi-page
business documents on Information Retrieval for a small performance cost on
smaller sequences. Relative 2D attention revealed to be effective on dense text
for both normal and long-range models. | [
0.0262474064,
0.0410593525,
0.0183539744,
0.029639503,
-0.0189590286,
-0.00392788,
0.028046824,
-0.0122858481,
-0.0241546277,
-0.0358762629,
-0.049071189,
-0.051228527,
-0.0027557339,
0.0307092406,
-0.0210563336,
-0.0627939552,
0.0214512069,
-0.0155999102,
-0.0112817092,
0.0228741262,
-0.0004273062,
-0.0208474342,
0.0166702773,
-0.0083755581,
-0.0085147442,
-0.0298878588,
-0.054640241,
-0.0001185957,
0.0169995837,
-0.0209812541,
-0.0117564555,
0.0308603197,
0.0575555339,
0.021658821,
0.0000019366,
0.0034881439,
-0.0418718718,
0.0158191286,
0.0019351128,
-0.0266601704,
0.0487190783,
-0.0670627505,
-0.0003406902,
-0.0332109034,
-0.0117154177,
-0.0050505642,
0.041122403,
0.1107967421,
0.0540364049,
0.0554807968,
-0.0171844158,
-0.0818416327,
0.0561640747,
-0.047215227,
0.0595009886,
-0.0568915792,
0.013656728,
-0.0529850312,
0.017949013,
0.0263865199,
-0.0456907339,
0.0167669598,
0.0320121646,
-0.0211203676,
0.0170326065,
0.0313338712,
-0.0110007692,
-0.0231385976,
-0.0176419728,
0.0717868656,
-0.0506989546,
0.0059694354,
0.0119716804,
-0.0073867301,
0.0118261045,
0.0003479613,
-0.0398972295,
-0.0025812546,
-0.0402263775,
-0.0026123256,
-0.0328452028,
0.0226837825,
-0.0133668324,
0.0065130051,
-0.0900164545,
-0.0013415955,
-0.0174052417,
-0.0225202385,
-0.0096198618,
-0.0112885954,
0.012291858,
-0.0082196072,
0.0426244587,
0.065912284,
0.0293395836,
0.0034835672,
-0.0345739275,
-0.0641559809,
0.0040202308,
-0.0383117013,
0.0218288656,
0.0096308608,
-0.0401221141,
0.1004096642,
-0.0355213881,
0.0588616319,
-0.051865954,
0.0160685573,
-0.0230359565,
0.0029893867,
0.01402207,
0.0061470564,
-0.0781082511,
0.0031643291,
-0.0325082876,
-0.0694829449,
0.0117492592,
0.017256476,
0.0269684903,
-0.0079751052,
0.0303492434,
0.0042654015,
-0.0577127226,
-0.06123152,
0.0317082256,
0.0529222339,
-0.0255370308,
-0.0090234298,
0.0013144385,
-0.0252112392,
-0.0268630423,
0.0271731149,
0.0324609838,
-0.0212560371,
0.0032664677,
0.0733275563,
-0.0132881077,
-0.0917188376,
-0.0177026894,
0.0096573457,
-0.0398183726,
-0.0523649566,
0.0415287688,
-0.0250770077,
0.0043939706,
0.0081731975,
-0.0025125351,
0.014467665,
0.0097997859,
0.0249440707,
-0.0231069271,
0.0535735637,
0.0559183843,
-0.0044669337,
0.0069416389,
0.0215457827,
0.0060122716,
0.0437825434,
0.0140084503,
0.0624987371,
-0.005060913,
-0.0332805514,
0.0208308268,
0.0090764193,
0.0032217132,
-0.0395234898,
0.017849898,
0.0181480534,
-0.0212608259,
-0.0034102371,
0.023472406,
0.0096464837,
-0.0224238038,
-0.0354423486,
0.053187672,
0.0225570928,
0.0499987081,
0.0598677211,
-0.010942637,
0.0319548063,
-0.021785371,
0.0107650068,
-0.0456471853,
0.0555433854,
0.0346793421,
-0.0079411678,
-0.0035475192,
0.0187325906,
-0.0238078125,
-0.013375245,
-0.0155005977,
0.0004313277,
0.0112980073,
-0.0185194891,
0.0632123128,
0.0289219823,
-0.0542548858,
0.090182364,
-0.0220450107,
-0.0616109371,
-0.0311198942,
-0.0125374421,
0.0135547826,
0.0489924029,
0.0225729067,
-0.0536790639,
-0.0108984113,
-0.0108197071,
0.0237428043,
0.0378718004,
0.0121624544,
0.0334356762,
0.0131177818,
-0.0401742533,
-0.030846348,
-0.0096007353,
-0.0075978255,
0.0013445877,
0.0037162867,
0.0125231892,
0.0045739645,
-0.0692534,
0.0245828778,
0.0340945534,
0.0085314037,
-0.0121758925,
-0.0052071349,
0.0193227641,
0.0014990662,
0.0154050756,
0.0028705061,
0.0038557462,
0.0464644879,
-0.0326895565,
0.0014248041,
-0.0221947022,
-0.0729772002,
0.0178899895,
-0.0060705771,
-0.0388088301,
-0.0110433716,
0.031832315,
-0.024553379,
-0.0292149018,
0.0046289051,
-0.0691853017,
-0.0054059564,
0.0121614048,
0.0136939306,
0.0158629194,
0.067457065,
-0.0411759764,
0.0383235142,
-0.003644825,
0.0184526723,
-0.001136121,
-0.0161440372,
-0.0019277072,
-0.0044185892,
-0.0108122043,
0.0133940447,
-0.0243463423,
-0.0206936281,
0.0278614648,
-0.0057483148,
-0.0163498744,
-0.0759506002,
-0.0606504604,
-0.0196434185,
-0.0335817412,
0.0404658727,
0.0090482468,
0.023660522,
-0.0026076213,
-0.0558419451,
-0.0491117053,
-0.0063641015,
0.0084228227,
-0.0121793179,
0.0298534371,
0.0012112551,
-0.0037150604,
-0.0029702997,
-0.0323638171,
0.0091039147,
0.0420675501,
0.0432491936,
-0.0316274688,
-0.0473643355,
-0.0279691853,
0.0396970324,
0.0317247584,
-0.031496346,
-0.0142200477,
-0.0020153595,
-0.044406496,
0.065439634,
0.1124157608,
0.0530896895,
0.0363909304,
0.0046746167,
-0.0277483277,
-0.0131096691,
0.0377125032,
-0.020062428,
0.0384822562,
-0.0382934995,
0.0064344564,
0.0179554708,
0.0747429207,
-0.0501815081,
0.0041319756,
-0.0159607604,
-0.0195564516,
0.0237039719,
-0.005458836,
0.0215622969,
0.002405694,
-0.0012742941,
0.023824688,
-0.0033701928,
-0.0103111025,
0.0167717449,
-0.0444925167,
-0.0246100686,
-0.0231106635,
0.036296729,
-0.0543850996,
0.0663244054,
0.0327642336,
0.0046827937,
-0.034943305,
-0.0363587067,
-0.0085078571,
0.0378259234,
0.0101693235,
-0.0096766362,
0.0892656073,
0.0042757173,
0.0478192195,
-0.0487942211,
-0.0394498818,
-0.0212616865,
-0.0594224222,
0.0060972217,
-0.0218485035,
0.0136171561,
-0.0416560434,
-0.1156703904,
0.0559644997,
0.0304948427,
0.0817958266,
-0.0217388831,
-0.0205438919,
-0.0043109432,
0.0676679835,
0.0147497104,
0.032015238,
0.0211747233,
-0.025321193,
0.028047353,
0.0797410235,
-0.001877817,
-0.0079900427,
-0.0145928375,
-0.0117285931,
0.0234404933,
-0.0279624127,
0.0057045803,
-0.0123408008,
0.0343365483,
-0.0940058827,
-0.0220186561,
0.0784476027,
0.0009579489,
-0.0576775484,
-0.0416016243,
-0.0310535487,
-0.0030205026,
0.0000130345,
0.0188111328,
-0.0515824333,
-0.0336196348,
0.0043410705,
0.0036931001,
0.0435330085,
-0.0127676856,
0.0142641114,
-0.0335295796,
0.0515270345,
-0.0201844908,
-0.0270923134,
-0.0203177612,
-0.0296170153,
0.0115130646,
0.0005955049,
-0.0150448624,
0.020834906,
-0.0501085371,
-0.0474422239,
-0.0129216425,
0.0172853023,
0.0188349225,
0.0137285171,
0.0184968933,
-0.066284515,
0.0172999874,
0.0239467099,
-0.0023006191,
-0.0449544229,
0.0330646932,
-0.0010523251,
0.0248534791,
0.0164205041,
0.0704565495,
-0.0503077731,
-0.0032233186,
-0.0175581593,
0.0220347513,
-0.0405861065,
-0.0025896833,
-0.0423726626,
0.0402776934,
-0.0066377306,
-0.0258513931,
-0.0303072706,
-0.0100505585,
-0.038288109,
0.0454455838,
0.0094623948,
-0.0099277962,
-0.0889878571,
-0.0063604987,
0.0213015378,
-0.0261434615,
-0.0239461958,
0.0144863529,
-0.0025013243,
-0.0548059121,
-0.0352380797,
-0.0381519422,
-0.016722627,
0.0320645683,
-0.0195593275,
-0.0464752838,
0.0170119051,
0.003245295,
-0.060479667,
0.0291352831,
-0.0051759356,
0.0038558273,
-0.0684489608,
0.0549450777,
0.0395340621,
-0.028090775,
-0.021688899,
0.0313837714,
-0.1209374666,
-0.0176971946,
0.0381903201,
0.0040450194,
0.0130806062,
0.058709953,
-0.0058290954,
-0.0039539412,
0.0304594897,
0.0164174065,
-0.0637980998,
-0.0104252361,
0.0391957462,
-0.0317022949,
-0.0170690417,
0.0162941944,
-0.021386791,
0.051711306,
0.0133133586,
-0.0120974565,
-0.0139096258,
-0.023560809,
-0.0124402242,
-0.0322080217,
0.0380663909,
0.0407016389,
0.0610891767,
0.0001028335,
0.0682835057,
0.0024708298,
0.0022177047,
-0.0291788243,
-0.0057180026,
0.0096802795,
-0.0221356433,
-0.0001025993,
0.0535948128,
0.0178225767,
0.0001902816,
-0.0202633496,
0.0705199987,
-0.0048193214,
-0.0314153731,
-0.0089720869,
-0.0283774734,
0.0012873661,
-0.0064932234,
0.0076284618,
0.0438550487,
0.000391624,
0.0676110759,
0.0253233332,
-0.0009260704,
-0.0202649329,
0.0224223714,
-0.0900246352,
-0.0280791875,
-0.0111821061,
0.0144464169,
-0.0054986165,
-0.0280970316,
0.0066660927,
-0.0041734329,
-0.0047160345,
-0.0011286291,
0.0137455342,
0.018598564,
-0.0157596339,
0.0136426771,
0.0302340612,
0.026425356,
-0.0284271128,
0.0592845269,
0.0052763852,
0.0005461365,
0.0107931877,
-0.0268974304,
-0.0662442893,
-0.020103313,
0.0120889349,
-0.0156095065,
0.0063985735,
-0.0088395094,
-0.0172525551,
0.0094234943,
0.0488362908,
-0.0271000639,
-0.0037050049,
-0.0282421,
0.026762303,
0.0809444487,
0.0204700828,
-0.012166583,
-0.021211626,
0.0629324168,
-0.0080192611,
0.0052179773,
-0.0024236054,
-6.015771603e-33,
0.0014397338,
-0.0237337518,
0.0057660206,
-0.0013920445,
-0.040529307,
0.0120426463,
-0.025630191,
-0.0143089583,
-0.0010383353,
0.0090331435,
-0.0376770049,
0.0070462278,
0.0301489271,
0.0437779017,
0.0047825868,
-0.0260762069,
0.0569636263,
0.0008224813,
-0.0274114348,
0.0204824097,
0.0155314142,
0.0537988879,
0.0454714261,
-0.0059048524,
-0.0245318767,
0.002713193,
0.0099348212,
-0.0109754698,
-0.0011461691,
0.0523687564,
-0.0122057265,
-0.0394667573,
0.0467739813,
-0.0656331703,
-0.0302167274,
0.0880520046,
-0.131759271,
0.0131322891,
-0.0564933904,
0.0623826124,
-0.0354109779,
0.0023427242,
0.0679109246,
-0.0008393045,
0.0355864502,
-0.054985512,
0.0303724166,
-0.0271157958,
-0.0175999682,
-0.0061822101,
-0.0488860235,
0.0498301759,
-0.0117624197,
-0.0088028321,
0.044221174,
0.0314671583,
0.0024846294,
0.0661358684,
-0.0583922006,
-0.0237163343,
0.0041176537,
0.0574031323,
0.0368378535,
0.0098816799,
-0.0096539482,
0.0161048286,
0.0201720502,
-0.0063327174,
-0.0479413234,
-0.0402384624,
0.02362643,
0.0395358577,
0.0206182934,
-0.0043926528,
0.0506567694,
0.0451253317,
-0.0432918668,
0.0168901607,
-0.0359630547,
0.1133153662,
0.034513317,
0.0242741778,
-0.0144253355,
0.0359685011,
0.009968386,
0.0054835067,
-0.0328792483,
0.007043852,
0.0019559974,
0.054968182,
-0.0059770318,
0.014236344,
0.0631435663,
0.0012510925,
-0.0111973248,
0.05853438,
0.004689557,
0.0297776908,
-0.0066468106,
-0.0247586761,
-0.0198983792,
-0.0141701978,
0.0283541605,
0.032711748,
-0.0231337622,
-0.0262063332,
0.0405556187,
0.0158417206,
-0.090511933,
-0.0320519172,
-0.0249618459,
0.0107340692,
-0.0061186464,
0.0721845776,
0.0539009944,
-0.0193759948,
-0.0242389757,
0.0834151655,
-0.0328921415,
0.0054548597,
-0.0361705422,
0.0065483619,
0.0149739552,
0.026178034,
-0.0215142518,
-0.0066849408,
-0.0344159864,
-0.0036973567,
0.0221817773,
-0.088476263,
0.0003226237,
0.063724719,
2.625e-7,
0.0466487072,
0.0370357521,
0.0791977942,
-0.0172471777,
0.0376833826,
0.0115148332,
0.0220569279,
0.0345924832,
-0.0392148681,
0.0034846277,
0.0094288634,
0.0201470163,
0.0097395442,
-0.002031852,
-0.0768888146,
0.0103092613,
-0.0770784914,
-0.0013924869,
-0.033716809,
-0.0192731433,
0.0476712324,
0.0958746895,
-0.0640245676,
-0.0002149649,
0.0168857872,
-0.0419413522,
0.0672265589,
0.0058177696,
0.0595828332,
0.0097960653,
0.0543367229,
-0.0295336954,
-0.0264868457,
-0.0189272612,
0.0047202706,
0.0365129635,
0.0236983616,
0.0751447082,
0.0085598724,
0.0154950479,
0.0304514207,
0.0087328702,
-0.0206017159,
-0.0669875517,
0.0522116199,
-0.0685769171,
-0.0192449186,
-0.0264303777,
-0.0364292823,
-0.0099198399,
-0.0298415292,
0.0209414829,
0.0359719805,
0.0345488414,
0.0242346898,
-0.0483694188,
0.0268070437,
-0.0985411257,
-0.0127903214,
-0.0335170142,
-0.0535934381,
0.0425759926,
-0.0795833394,
-0.0303820446,
0.0458062626,
-0.006678225,
-0.0742138773,
2.151860418e-34,
0.0329110958,
-0.0153646357,
-0.0334621742,
-0.0082017379,
-0.0069468403,
-0.0207038186,
-0.0011679649,
0.0133742504,
-0.0048988904,
-0.1196356416,
-0.0086938404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05501v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05501v1 | Black-Box Analysis: GPTs Across Time in Legal Textual Entailment Task | 2023-09-11T14:43:54 | 2023-09-11T14:43:54 | Ha-Thanh Nguyen, Randy Goebel, Francesca Toni, Kostas Stathis, Ken Satoh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The evolution of Generative Pre-trained Transformer (GPT) models has led to
significant advancements in various natural language processing applications,
particularly in legal textual entailment. We present an analysis of GPT-3.5
(ChatGPT) and GPT-4 performances on COLIEE Task 4 dataset, a prominent
benchmark in this domain. The study encompasses data from Heisei 18 (2006) to
Reiwa 3 (2021), exploring the models' abilities to discern entailment
relationships within Japanese statute law across different periods. Our
preliminary experimental results unveil intriguing insights into the models'
strengths and weaknesses in handling legal textual entailment tasks, as well as
the patterns observed in model performance. In the context of proprietary
models with undisclosed architectures and weights, black-box analysis becomes
crucial for evaluating their capabilities. We discuss the influence of training
data distribution and the implications on the models' generalizability. This
analysis serves as a foundation for future research, aiming to optimize
GPT-based models and enable their successful adoption in legal information
extraction and entailment applications. | [
0.0529372431,
0.0604721755,
-0.0010897744,
0.0129736643,
-0.0585760213,
0.0425098315,
0.0021697357,
0.0370048881,
-0.0052494593,
-0.0214948207,
-0.0069985837,
0.0096264919,
-0.0032471076,
0.0001967293,
-0.0135693317,
-0.0412369184,
0.0365430191,
0.0345118605,
0.0128641194,
0.0108193979,
0.0033623918,
0.0008263765,
0.0252635479,
0.028449716,
-0.0492007509,
0.014069533,
0.0167763531,
-0.0124293892,
0.0232974049,
0.0058268458,
-0.0166533254,
0.0636737272,
-0.0055132532,
0.0520596653,
0.0000019261,
-0.0628987178,
-0.0204776358,
-0.0082456525,
-0.007475324,
0.0111620044,
-0.0022429104,
-0.0546544418,
-0.0332952552,
0.0017479419,
-0.0436048731,
-0.0150555633,
0.0319032334,
0.0517709702,
0.0499936044,
0.1172332019,
-0.0326020829,
-0.0748544782,
0.087368153,
-0.0623820387,
-0.0033946703,
-0.0339994021,
0.0255915988,
0.0078702848,
-0.0297372229,
-0.032548368,
-0.0046159918,
0.0148236072,
0.0668482035,
-0.0074184001,
-0.073702231,
0.0018990792,
-0.0578010753,
-0.0064747664,
0.0168328993,
0.0338305645,
0.0226873942,
-0.0594877414,
-0.0051468671,
-0.0127724316,
0.0335642844,
0.0383937098,
-0.0043091243,
0.0858060494,
-0.0368109494,
0.0174808539,
0.0475434251,
0.055665195,
0.0112910671,
-0.0058301976,
-0.0758941919,
0.0937042087,
0.0207706578,
-0.0728828385,
0.0339242332,
0.0239771903,
-0.0445651487,
-0.0321627855,
0.0498534627,
0.0122657046,
0.0297827162,
0.0346692838,
-0.025444001,
-0.0614422038,
0.017228147,
-0.0323533937,
-0.0229363348,
0.0240927171,
-0.0560562126,
0.0616112798,
-0.0597628206,
0.0582188517,
-0.0242917445,
0.0286672935,
0.0053697885,
-0.0550518222,
-0.0260419939,
-0.0264718607,
-0.0703721046,
0.0258091427,
-0.0577169657,
-0.001732579,
-0.0198994223,
-0.0018374978,
-0.0038647417,
0.0029844602,
0.0115873246,
-0.043197874,
-0.0250213016,
-0.0381204262,
-0.0502480902,
-0.0387358926,
-0.0334440358,
0.0336992815,
0.0054580783,
-0.0135807693,
-0.0022316452,
0.0057579302,
-0.002179404,
-0.023917459,
0.0350936763,
0.0494967066,
-0.0074632866,
-0.0245363545,
-0.0287717693,
-0.0262280405,
-0.039232254,
-0.0778019503,
-0.0079036206,
-0.019036904,
0.0224484112,
-0.0320790745,
0.0131516466,
-0.0317287855,
0.0110141877,
0.054164838,
-0.0046030506,
0.0651154593,
0.0236994568,
-0.0177829564,
-0.0588334911,
0.0157926027,
0.0302733034,
0.0035909987,
0.0361334868,
0.0097733354,
0.0278396085,
-0.0077295243,
0.0336578488,
0.044776842,
0.01853613,
0.0006188506,
0.0182175077,
0.0171913616,
0.0109761152,
0.0052536288,
-0.0029540136,
0.0217735209,
-0.0031635973,
-0.0138333309,
0.0172869842,
0.0503244437,
0.0099888872,
0.0592708588,
0.0387489535,
-0.0458216965,
0.0220154226,
0.0224969611,
-0.0709902719,
0.0007473204,
-0.0752720088,
0.0150784068,
-0.0814725831,
0.0368450731,
-0.0153444726,
-0.0617128573,
0.0198748689,
-0.0050371485,
-0.0211583823,
-0.0331418663,
0.0487757362,
0.0498276539,
-0.0621463656,
0.0398952886,
0.0277656391,
-0.0935092345,
-0.0455631986,
-0.031744048,
0.0016174681,
-0.001892378,
0.0549568422,
-0.0153298993,
-0.0104374299,
-0.0143709183,
-0.008630571,
0.051555559,
-0.0006886745,
0.0179545972,
0.0054344591,
-0.0139509495,
-0.0367789455,
0.0283340514,
0.038230028,
0.0116460733,
0.0303988606,
0.0348404646,
0.0681777149,
-0.0519409887,
0.02091901,
0.0562729053,
-0.0105841728,
-0.0361769572,
-0.0014962042,
0.0170920976,
0.0447353609,
-0.0001518909,
-0.0116932746,
-0.0254811198,
0.0219245683,
-0.0254287757,
-0.0262049939,
0.0469017178,
-0.0377479345,
-0.0249939989,
0.0142813176,
-0.0707179606,
-0.0018921534,
0.036784552,
-0.0593188852,
-0.0302858725,
-0.0508733504,
0.0103128627,
0.0271859728,
-0.0724902153,
0.0005145291,
-0.014341142,
-0.0031120167,
-0.0255772695,
0.0608071052,
0.0200469121,
-0.0414126404,
-0.0194227062,
-0.01028514,
0.0509744622,
0.0062229652,
-0.0089791324,
-0.0213328041,
-0.0217559207,
-0.0237431452,
0.0099344514,
0.0253989547,
-0.0129334573,
-0.0416988917,
-0.0640540943,
0.0340060219,
-0.0356897414,
0.0041865995,
0.01244538,
-0.0143439081,
-0.0324765444,
-0.0045644925,
-0.0218688846,
-0.0163483974,
0.0144077046,
-0.0268240068,
0.0228267219,
-0.0462031513,
0.0047308137,
-0.0281149205,
-0.0213172529,
-0.0296025015,
0.0300769992,
0.0519792326,
-0.0303267837,
-0.0135216517,
0.0413609855,
-0.0013042548,
-0.0005060308,
-0.0471797772,
-0.0057022073,
-0.0155354841,
0.0084284451,
0.035372328,
0.0204135403,
0.0349753052,
0.0115523385,
0.0003260891,
0.0076678861,
-0.0077336002,
0.0172908045,
-0.0272912886,
-0.0220917836,
-0.0296922997,
-0.0029084382,
0.0641465634,
0.0502917245,
-0.0023176535,
-0.005332971,
-0.0330758467,
-0.0138263525,
-0.0055118948,
0.0213448554,
0.0080338493,
-0.016764259,
-0.0341762118,
0.0484845638,
0.0069510052,
-0.0480604023,
0.0277869273,
-0.00251357,
0.0349535868,
-0.0515524521,
0.0005632888,
-0.0325251557,
0.1065979153,
0.0349998735,
0.0073982063,
0.0616329536,
-0.0379474834,
-0.0023371708,
0.0298661459,
0.0632546246,
-0.0346989743,
0.064611651,
0.0060591395,
0.0514342114,
-0.0369576477,
-0.026205238,
-0.035459388,
-0.069984667,
0.0205353331,
0.0091468245,
-0.0063023535,
0.0102256844,
-0.0153064979,
0.0316674821,
-0.0405491777,
0.0391581208,
0.0197563767,
-0.020770764,
-0.0554471388,
0.0291527919,
0.029918246,
-0.0287683085,
0.0186167974,
-0.0060014836,
-0.0314841457,
0.0019694054,
-0.0340583026,
0.0017188002,
-0.0036539701,
-0.0021198273,
-0.0139269633,
-0.0664795116,
-0.0183847696,
0.0233174972,
-0.0087088281,
-0.0633235872,
0.0291199237,
0.0970188752,
0.0080710659,
-0.0045762216,
-0.003918991,
0.0437132083,
0.0029548274,
0.0108540403,
0.0179080609,
-0.1171933711,
-0.0064031756,
0.0112310313,
-0.0326500423,
-0.0227900948,
-0.0306703299,
-0.0002939993,
-0.1147663444,
0.0895570591,
-0.0017466339,
-0.0124095967,
-0.0243135728,
-0.012833626,
-0.0010333296,
-0.0221337602,
0.0231057126,
-0.0042182785,
-0.0430995412,
-0.0153525947,
-0.0188425351,
-0.0534529872,
0.0115028797,
0.0310217179,
-0.0395919718,
0.0064394097,
0.0379774012,
0.0298693981,
-0.0357220955,
-0.0329213813,
0.0014144917,
0.0020466768,
-0.0136281149,
0.0182529036,
0.0488630272,
0.0140295234,
0.003973701,
-0.0383056626,
0.0075515453,
-0.0066828155,
-0.001893255,
0.0495835058,
0.0534724109,
-0.0170048662,
-0.0350532494,
-0.0132171754,
-0.0288814902,
-0.0357418507,
0.066666238,
-0.0113673769,
0.0197038744,
-0.0401229188,
-0.0075594094,
-0.0012978615,
-0.0469425432,
-0.0238308758,
-0.0125445332,
-0.0120139671,
-0.0201460868,
-0.0661961809,
-0.0162439719,
-0.0175181981,
0.0534328744,
0.0163362883,
-0.0187385119,
0.0536799394,
-0.029176686,
-0.0497105904,
0.0354705714,
-0.058562085,
-0.0351801626,
-0.0179916155,
0.02558502,
0.0252609514,
0.0303993039,
-0.0186197832,
0.0084962463,
-0.0245057605,
0.0140066324,
-0.0149029978,
0.0123861451,
0.0160225164,
0.0139252637,
-0.0515787899,
0.032081157,
0.0326587968,
0.043348752,
-0.0095332237,
0.0035408461,
0.0704447031,
-0.0505671613,
-0.0220167749,
-0.0062582092,
-0.0020935077,
0.0302918665,
0.030909393,
-0.0176556055,
-0.0150384642,
-0.0106704254,
0.0497421585,
0.0147677017,
0.0723150373,
0.0053828084,
-0.0110105155,
-0.0258625485,
0.012592487,
-0.0376742892,
0.0092321243,
-0.0586324707,
-0.0138081629,
0.0594073236,
0.0404495746,
-0.0424235165,
0.0603094213,
-0.0180570614,
0.0238221735,
-0.0869441032,
-0.0080135083,
0.0337385274,
0.0139359683,
0.0000565268,
-0.0450107604,
0.0072966856,
-0.0112593435,
0.0064705377,
0.0381154269,
-0.0037545695,
0.0609501638,
0.0129469652,
0.0094803059,
0.0228099208,
0.0123794982,
-0.0606972836,
0.0227256455,
-0.0300670937,
0.0233241264,
0.0595719032,
-0.0114625106,
0.020776514,
-0.0230855029,
0.0028586767,
0.0337794647,
0.0299087614,
0.0053021293,
-0.0214426387,
0.0040705316,
-0.0070097055,
-0.0186649095,
0.0270231999,
0.0430629179,
-0.001141964,
0.059906099,
0.0191833097,
-0.0098257819,
-0.0187879875,
-0.074124068,
-0.0323149674,
-0.0305454209,
-0.0266442131,
-0.0354058556,
-0.0554981902,
-0.0313468166,
-0.0298625547,
0.0174454022,
-0.0010494856,
0.0358664617,
0.007113304,
0.0522917062,
0.0031826317,
-0.0562919416,
0.0028845735,
-0.0016700403,
-0.0176961068,
0.0064198356,
-0.0027833758,
-6.137847426e-33,
-0.0744323507,
-0.01406697,
0.0125196157,
0.0379801802,
-0.028606249,
-0.0340492167,
-0.0340089388,
-0.0242261067,
-0.0194194485,
0.0273713544,
-0.0220377799,
0.0299941823,
0.0259374771,
0.0061584418,
0.0012740875,
-0.0200689733,
0.0200319458,
0.0247172546,
-0.0203366559,
0.0140067162,
0.0040757982,
0.0041935635,
0.0478108898,
-0.0778338313,
0.0270641223,
0.0282503627,
-0.0450752154,
-0.0364340171,
-0.0881601423,
0.0346661843,
-0.0069983797,
0.0116779264,
0.0156341922,
-0.0534312129,
-0.0080548096,
0.0458693095,
-0.0946674123,
0.0065936754,
0.004415839,
-0.0056096222,
0.0150351841,
-0.0222179741,
0.0343185924,
0.0030282051,
0.007662606,
-0.0227984842,
0.05484429,
-0.0319898203,
-0.0004514382,
-0.1006531194,
-0.1056027189,
0.0583794042,
0.0035570096,
0.0256131124,
0.0074819108,
0.0130049028,
0.0027935787,
0.023863351,
-0.0423275605,
-0.0171460547,
0.0233153794,
-0.0194568615,
0.0079290392,
-0.0488578491,
-0.0087662116,
0.0325848721,
-0.0183716323,
-0.0418907255,
-0.0525933653,
0.0170938354,
0.0379646011,
0.0811485499,
0.0520321243,
0.0333953053,
0.0704793558,
-0.0058544036,
-0.0858109295,
-0.0123377778,
0.0257152077,
0.0106349224,
-0.0004315072,
-0.0360680409,
-0.0302352887,
-0.0119159138,
0.0005718157,
-0.0304302238,
0.0071722525,
0.0023496361,
0.0361699313,
0.0234645959,
0.0498352237,
0.0040878323,
0.0035719152,
-0.0545980744,
0.0408562087,
0.0219126437,
-0.0271711834,
0.0038905186,
-0.0140964044,
0.0410227031,
-0.0518693626,
-0.0441593528,
0.0239560883,
0.0137072457,
0.0192254335,
-0.0135582481,
0.0733120218,
0.006810986,
-0.0673215687,
-0.0061367229,
0.0080979727,
0.0248670708,
0.0217609257,
0.0047322405,
0.0289128739,
0.0409495719,
0.0284584463,
-0.0040968191,
0.0321883745,
-0.0108188754,
-0.0620961376,
0.0224206839,
0.0259135719,
-0.0093365023,
0.0235121343,
-0.0035932281,
0.0278561618,
0.0315760411,
0.0572670475,
-0.0094736731,
0.0013256995,
0.0609675162,
2.665e-7,
0.0860183015,
0.0245046727,
0.0267924592,
-0.0150289992,
-0.0283616688,
0.0199057776,
0.0274397917,
0.0209917817,
0.0293999407,
-0.0166494362,
0.0433428325,
0.0006198917,
0.0695458874,
0.0344408043,
-0.063060455,
-0.016786892,
-0.0581796132,
-0.0528920665,
-0.069656603,
0.0323343836,
0.0648368001,
0.0820435062,
0.0335847698,
-0.0378048755,
0.0089971554,
-0.0374341346,
0.0660307258,
-0.0102330418,
-0.0037262354,
0.0061064344,
0.0614556447,
0.0086506568,
0.0072837914,
0.0573841557,
0.0073986347,
0.0756923705,
-0.0120223006,
0.0739972144,
0.0073535149,
0.0390675962,
-0.0384552553,
-0.0143706352,
0.0074312938,
-0.042890247,
0.1042194068,
-0.0452065691,
0.02314738,
-0.0048789382,
-0.0524489656,
-0.0176991075,
0.0222683754,
0.0303116683,
0.0074356594,
-0.0075042737,
0.0557360426,
-0.0046779974,
-0.0177944042,
-0.0927385241,
0.0073055122,
0.0358122475,
-0.0028747637,
0.0120138628,
-0.0276220776,
-0.0178854037,
0.0620945841,
-0.0621384829,
0.0119097605,
2.454690721e-34,
0.031833414,
-0.0165098235,
0.0349708982,
-0.0007100537,
0.0253443196,
0.0441251248,
-0.0317165852,
0.013186927,
-0.0534916036,
-0.0767071024,
0.0305555779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05500v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05500v1 | NeCo@ALQAC 2023: Legal Domain Knowledge Acquisition for Low-Resource Languages through Data Enrichment | 2023-09-11T14:43:45 | 2023-09-11T14:43:45 | Hai-Long Nguyen, Dieu-Quynh Nguyen, Hoang-Trung Nguyen, Thu-Trang Pham, Huu-Dong Nguyen, Thach-Anh Nguyen, Thi-Hai-Yen Vuong, Ha-Thanh Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, natural language processing has gained significant
popularity in various sectors, including the legal domain. This paper presents
NeCo Team's solutions to the Vietnamese text processing tasks provided in the
Automated Legal Question Answering Competition 2023 (ALQAC 2023), focusing on
legal domain knowledge acquisition for low-resource languages through data
enrichment. Our methods for the legal document retrieval task employ a
combination of similarity ranking and deep learning models, while for the
second task, which requires extracting an answer from a relevant legal article
in response to a question, we propose a range of adaptive techniques to handle
different question types. Our approaches achieve outstanding results on both
tasks of the competition, demonstrating the potential benefits and
effectiveness of question answering systems in the legal field, particularly
for low-resource languages. | [
0.0533108339,
0.0611197464,
0.0050441585,
0.0444604196,
-0.0509537086,
0.029281754,
0.0021232818,
0.0241700914,
0.0185793322,
-0.0702635348,
-0.0124668535,
-0.0302315857,
-0.0264681727,
-0.0127082774,
-0.0140190162,
-0.0296328515,
0.0162255503,
0.0239077508,
0.057167463,
-0.006399475,
0.0254836716,
0.0168453399,
0.0132643804,
0.0028918064,
0.0102967136,
0.0038637032,
-0.0110935997,
-0.0003463681,
0.0275430121,
-0.0117929056,
0.0058296514,
0.0517087318,
0.0170680378,
0.03435589,
0.0000015892,
-0.0713044107,
-0.0179575477,
-0.0036769467,
-0.0279580597,
-0.0148933735,
0.0418750755,
-0.0127633251,
-0.0181998126,
0.0141259525,
-0.0718310624,
-0.0310998578,
-0.009292868,
0.0153023992,
0.0508205667,
0.0794174001,
-0.0026643365,
-0.034079425,
0.0411470346,
-0.0511209331,
0.0211932398,
-0.0460912324,
0.0254282188,
0.0037785778,
0.0486683883,
-0.0137058403,
0.0269246511,
0.0186631102,
0.0432428382,
-0.0284168161,
-0.0416078269,
-0.0271594375,
-0.046257291,
0.0342235863,
0.0152249057,
0.0705657899,
0.01987998,
-0.0185035914,
-0.003294972,
0.0232810751,
0.0529743955,
0.0050520212,
-0.0476302691,
0.0503968,
-0.0029715952,
0.0124217141,
0.0334928595,
0.0253144484,
-0.0223421361,
0.0371146537,
-0.0282162614,
0.0243382175,
-0.0058683185,
-0.0577223524,
0.020505242,
-0.0098280963,
0.006262382,
-0.0287336037,
0.0467508063,
0.0481543764,
0.0317559503,
0.0110328672,
-0.0102224182,
-0.0669918358,
0.0649261177,
-0.0863706395,
-0.0185832884,
-0.0084391078,
-0.0406772867,
0.1028199345,
-0.0739982277,
0.0115295546,
0.0002754789,
-0.0032817782,
-0.0233378354,
-0.0708854869,
-0.018025443,
-0.025033297,
-0.0468201041,
0.0865390003,
-0.0973725617,
0.0051730685,
-0.0096595977,
0.0169258006,
-0.0062974319,
0.0038148563,
0.0144327469,
0.030617822,
-0.0282586534,
-0.0222840644,
-0.0564296916,
-0.0117837442,
-0.0528484955,
0.0602182709,
0.0064159259,
-0.0412108339,
0.0195918828,
-0.0023727501,
0.0459229127,
-0.0213735048,
0.0386651158,
0.0720224082,
-0.0295162182,
-0.0064853323,
-0.0374221466,
-0.0292696897,
0.0193098038,
-0.0548567399,
-0.0329675041,
-0.080083482,
0.0249884799,
-0.0330903754,
-0.0351940207,
-0.0313782431,
0.0333287343,
0.0680934638,
-0.030959269,
0.076060012,
-0.0039856494,
-0.0339699909,
-0.0098805735,
0.0245684031,
0.0484114178,
0.0044614072,
0.0053483327,
0.0094074532,
0.0431096777,
0.0088104829,
0.0020251104,
0.0228264239,
0.0041844239,
-0.0072148503,
0.0399491489,
0.0348214842,
-0.0388959907,
0.0177921746,
0.0125098564,
0.0381657965,
-0.0001857682,
-0.0224210527,
0.0034376767,
0.0554727539,
0.0032665976,
0.0545567796,
0.0064273612,
-0.0030266379,
0.0272187013,
0.0003618547,
-0.0419499725,
0.0282743722,
-0.029124856,
0.0183599815,
-0.0313883126,
0.0407374166,
-0.0436956696,
-0.071680434,
0.0232485924,
-0.0126578817,
-0.0091953054,
0.0250172094,
0.031477306,
0.0436441302,
-0.0067939204,
0.0042512501,
0.0228783656,
-0.0246262792,
-0.0343212299,
-0.0128082689,
-0.0183299724,
0.0099733472,
0.0263772663,
-0.054625608,
-0.0089612566,
-0.0121364929,
0.0009790153,
0.0491733626,
0.0288753808,
-0.0168873016,
0.0097476589,
-0.0371527113,
-0.0259218048,
0.0192904752,
-0.0041489457,
0.030266678,
0.0054815752,
0.0445587151,
0.0510401651,
-0.0773132443,
0.0005691047,
0.0123551004,
0.0008127446,
-0.0635413378,
0.0519805402,
0.0256757867,
0.0175535269,
0.0577127337,
0.0022567192,
-0.0052441675,
0.0419925936,
-0.035674233,
-0.0208456013,
0.0197024923,
0.0035123399,
-0.042875737,
0.0408663638,
-0.0574096553,
-0.0143079795,
0.0497432128,
-0.0465919152,
-0.0188915618,
-0.0272404831,
0.016951941,
-0.0070722359,
-0.0965772271,
-0.0177689251,
0.0048918808,
0.0039480394,
-0.051116053,
0.0818661526,
-0.0053251437,
-0.0020860557,
0.0397839285,
-0.0215764623,
0.0503570847,
-0.0212727599,
-0.0310738236,
-0.0252095498,
-0.0407249182,
0.0259485245,
0.0232997257,
0.0387156121,
-0.0227717608,
0.0000478954,
-0.0541149378,
0.0307237301,
-0.0336729176,
0.0054765139,
0.0080991732,
0.0030684865,
0.0008722813,
-0.0465255678,
-0.0663941205,
-0.0115054473,
0.0348929428,
-0.0059409183,
0.0239035524,
0.0136339292,
0.0194393806,
-0.0408580415,
-0.0330713168,
0.0055019851,
0.0323253684,
0.0118134795,
-0.0010577384,
0.0205683447,
0.0229284577,
-0.033486899,
0.017420765,
-0.0127498144,
0.0076433406,
-0.0247526448,
-0.015915582,
-0.0567555055,
0.0333383381,
0.0201085284,
0.0057914443,
-0.0106076906,
0.0477473885,
-0.0674849749,
0.0114220642,
-0.0094827823,
0.0140083795,
-0.0214338619,
0.0152767422,
0.0089226058,
0.0081566758,
-0.0163507685,
-0.0114057427,
0.0177362431,
0.0078964494,
0.0150607117,
-0.0242535621,
-0.0210705735,
0.0286862589,
0.0011068783,
0.0123447981,
0.0096447859,
-0.0473113507,
0.0901676342,
0.0349996984,
0.0217553563,
-0.0937879458,
-0.0181908607,
-0.0623478256,
0.077376157,
-0.0082871495,
0.0227937121,
-0.0425121747,
-0.0519075617,
0.0003250548,
0.0246908739,
0.0489850491,
-0.0487002544,
0.0656982213,
0.0161460191,
0.0382150039,
-0.0431726761,
-0.0601412281,
-0.0541944019,
-0.0263170376,
0.0174417607,
0.0413539745,
-0.0077830553,
0.0441456102,
-0.0122300452,
-0.0064390246,
-0.0108152134,
0.0032561212,
0.0203167591,
-0.0078881057,
-0.0505826436,
0.117320694,
0.0342684798,
0.0220603105,
0.0203520339,
0.0266412999,
0.026507061,
0.0385626219,
0.0256017055,
-0.0050433581,
0.033357773,
0.0079546273,
0.0139626367,
-0.0575057566,
0.0120382058,
0.0057694893,
-0.0251941886,
-0.0681995898,
0.0202624965,
0.0835314617,
0.0340804383,
-0.0293932557,
-0.0191700514,
-0.0351595692,
0.0016336086,
0.0543505251,
0.0482216813,
-0.1210189089,
0.0086716311,
-0.0258449763,
-0.0076143667,
-0.029410094,
-0.0198983047,
-0.0012014424,
-0.1086280048,
0.0599697605,
-0.0128341932,
-0.0446465686,
-0.0594196394,
-0.0205440614,
0.0101307454,
0.0198978726,
0.0329153612,
-0.0047554094,
-0.0207986142,
-0.0266153496,
0.0031585933,
-0.0109573891,
0.002491117,
0.0228783991,
-0.0594119579,
0.0157212354,
0.0481614247,
0.0253226999,
-0.0274025388,
-0.0004882124,
-0.0072823772,
-0.0371588916,
-0.0196602847,
0.0023523313,
-0.0056533427,
0.0131899193,
0.0087684691,
-0.0325472541,
0.0710968822,
-0.0408546031,
0.0109856082,
0.0341333933,
0.0865271911,
-0.0377392955,
-0.0171725005,
-0.020663809,
-0.0223244205,
-0.0111207543,
0.0527136214,
0.0095319794,
-0.0014158261,
-0.0350077376,
-0.0226536673,
-0.0295426846,
-0.0617580488,
-0.0107564293,
-0.0055754269,
0.0048965425,
0.0183213633,
-0.0685041174,
-0.0529011041,
0.0122778304,
0.03283507,
-0.0075591654,
0.0386089757,
0.0307003893,
-0.0148515217,
-0.0558209866,
0.0136417514,
-0.0320388526,
0.0095962686,
0.0008279225,
0.0174670294,
-0.0009011995,
-0.010092508,
-0.0290145073,
-0.028129898,
-0.0052033397,
-0.0081684301,
-0.0149838682,
0.0061930656,
0.0083146989,
0.0211692732,
-0.0417081863,
-0.0566521399,
0.0352788679,
0.0512615517,
0.0120034013,
-0.0289122127,
0.0351153091,
-0.043345999,
-0.0343853682,
0.0336457752,
-0.0288025346,
0.0152450679,
0.0113870343,
0.0188773237,
-0.0149880815,
-0.0381850973,
0.045172561,
0.0349708013,
-0.0080353655,
0.0521676838,
-0.0377318524,
-0.0445212945,
0.0351082124,
0.0024073913,
-0.0258292425,
-0.0322955362,
-0.0044967998,
0.0146645075,
0.0014772802,
-0.0216993503,
0.0458288826,
0.0146428207,
0.0216401666,
-0.0549058169,
0.0353482179,
0.031145541,
0.0371388532,
-0.0274144933,
-0.0143466527,
0.0137747014,
0.0323735736,
-0.0045196493,
0.0681997165,
-0.0408598036,
0.0291776899,
0.0093580112,
-0.0126842344,
-0.0050608013,
0.0273365695,
-0.0352768637,
-0.0419320688,
-0.0506182611,
0.0416874103,
0.0828194469,
-0.0368219204,
-0.0202330928,
-0.0194400232,
-0.0166060757,
-0.0101618851,
-0.0233755652,
-0.0052509326,
-0.0361985825,
0.0332463272,
0.0293065216,
-0.0014156834,
0.0792595893,
0.0488551892,
-0.0111511247,
0.028669158,
0.0286641978,
-0.0222704858,
-0.0202177409,
-0.0316719376,
0.0272881575,
0.0512580574,
-0.0462426618,
-0.0180639755,
-0.0371849462,
-0.0511637256,
-0.0183578208,
0.0074719051,
-0.027491061,
0.0349379666,
0.0383596197,
0.0526388288,
0.0335617326,
-0.0179972425,
-0.0326011293,
0.050999973,
-0.0599322617,
-0.028592553,
0.0201341324,
-5.499589993e-33,
-0.0189741179,
-0.0316728912,
0.0090962481,
-0.0199488364,
0.0133812157,
-0.0106451716,
-0.0100119682,
-0.0190196559,
-0.0719607845,
0.0258857179,
-0.0213485267,
0.0079432428,
0.0280539915,
0.0213327575,
-0.0072680023,
-0.0355418958,
-0.0205824394,
0.0189991929,
0.0291865431,
0.0078967521,
-0.016962748,
0.0365423933,
0.0238807816,
-0.0873488337,
0.0270413347,
0.0427580103,
0.0233376939,
0.015832277,
-0.0347261131,
0.0800217912,
0.0006766901,
0.0312109794,
0.0442595221,
-0.060853105,
-0.0055446988,
0.0391995199,
-0.1426852345,
-0.0144261485,
-0.0089430921,
-0.0178448465,
-0.0311398488,
-0.0177334789,
0.0330724977,
0.0063095274,
0.023742931,
-0.0036734617,
0.0490576066,
-0.0437055081,
-0.014341088,
-0.0572260544,
-0.0634395629,
0.0334147327,
-0.0067072916,
0.0215650313,
0.0188776404,
0.0225013886,
-0.0066474169,
0.0402741432,
-0.0867296383,
-0.0070197224,
-0.0488141663,
0.0163819939,
0.0179927386,
-0.0798155963,
-0.0326118171,
0.0177363306,
-0.0120881731,
-0.0412800163,
-0.0107585685,
-0.0103655132,
0.0019529082,
0.0753716379,
0.0268223621,
0.0413638651,
0.0485800505,
-0.0082078855,
-0.0932741538,
0.0333782509,
0.0301594473,
0.046237655,
-0.0216968004,
-0.020546183,
-0.0508058965,
0.0163283274,
-0.0270340871,
-0.0044087255,
-0.0313739516,
-0.0210494883,
0.0222342294,
0.0162581969,
0.0060710991,
0.0124124158,
0.0152686769,
-0.0832146555,
0.0138559639,
0.03491088,
0.0146730421,
-0.0014200503,
-0.001881654,
0.0575197935,
-0.0440931059,
0.005744684,
-0.0048442506,
-0.0511368178,
-0.021533221,
-0.0124918679,
0.0370895043,
-0.0403285213,
-0.0678913519,
0.0103384349,
0.0314553417,
0.0191002954,
0.0063662305,
0.0647504106,
-0.0215471257,
0.0420718044,
0.0421280712,
0.038504757,
0.0306868888,
-0.0183342248,
-0.0523175672,
-0.0137102474,
0.006614008,
-0.0453566015,
-0.0265527703,
0.0354241244,
-0.0281577595,
0.0533238575,
-0.0058149495,
-0.0127115771,
0.0162762161,
0.0444421172,
2.284e-7,
0.0680347979,
-0.011919396,
0.0294196866,
0.011179734,
-0.0181820914,
0.0102671301,
0.0328669511,
0.0542518571,
-0.0010123104,
-0.0064287446,
0.0426438414,
0.0116041005,
0.0406168364,
0.0303602368,
-0.0966831297,
-0.0035507719,
-0.0269645024,
-0.0758322552,
-0.0492762104,
-0.0153134819,
0.0348204896,
0.094753556,
-0.0243748836,
-0.0254893117,
-0.0049533355,
-0.0460807234,
0.042666439,
0.0359127708,
-0.0146274092,
-0.012541201,
0.0985004231,
-0.018732138,
-0.0034669575,
0.0104094129,
-0.0036555326,
0.0745538622,
0.0111666219,
0.0457717292,
-0.0093916254,
0.0005492155,
-0.0255277082,
-0.0540237576,
0.0287490487,
-0.0305662937,
0.0810246393,
0.004080697,
0.0108098937,
-0.0258845687,
-0.0027550654,
0.0028446822,
-0.0025691011,
0.0059295427,
-0.0494879708,
-0.0057937833,
0.0689896792,
-0.0207072012,
0.0135550583,
-0.0729897097,
0.004447124,
0.021776706,
-0.0252039004,
0.0113536809,
0.0046823923,
-0.0059702653,
0.0601919442,
-0.0534327887,
0.0283925645,
1.997430077e-34,
0.0262281522,
0.0210350417,
0.0074734027,
0.0529586002,
0.0198769178,
0.0131250983,
-0.0385763831,
0.0064584343,
-0.0140916361,
-0.0849077851,
0.0226786975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05497v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05497v1 | Personality Detection and Analysis using Twitter Data | 2023-09-11T14:39:04 | 2023-09-11T14:39:04 | Abhilash Datta, Souvic Chakraborty, Animesh Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Personality types are important in various fields as they hold relevant
information about the characteristics of a human being in an explainable
format. They are often good predictors of a person's behaviors in a particular
environment and have applications ranging from candidate selection to marketing
and mental health. Recently automatic detection of personality traits from
texts has gained significant attention in computational linguistics. Most
personality detection and analysis methods have focused on small datasets
making their experimental observations often limited. To bridge this gap, we
focus on collecting and releasing the largest automatically curated dataset for
the research community which has 152 million tweets and 56 thousand data points
for the Myers-Briggs personality type (MBTI) prediction task. We perform a
series of extensive qualitative and quantitative studies on our dataset to
analyze the data patterns in a better way and infer conclusions. We show how
our intriguing analysis results often follow natural intuition. We also perform
a series of ablation studies to show how the baselines perform for our dataset. | [
0.0236227829,
0.0871770382,
-0.0450514928,
-0.0177176427,
-0.0158341657,
0.0190667622,
0.0231580064,
0.0001446769,
-0.0022819203,
0.0237816796,
0.0218626074,
0.0128412992,
-0.0079687675,
0.0179178882,
0.0063785315,
-0.0213451069,
0.0327588506,
0.0356938876,
0.0345602445,
-0.013334468,
0.0267098416,
0.0591248944,
0.011152491,
0.0227434598,
0.0007692871,
-0.0056579555,
0.0119605083,
-0.020958662,
0.0259121191,
-0.000862507,
0.0569830686,
0.067359969,
-0.0130807972,
0.0371324457,
0.0000019477,
-0.0273064245,
-0.0373912267,
-0.021010682,
0.0366264731,
-0.028773129,
0.0695138574,
0.0211199373,
0.0121811051,
0.0403975882,
-0.076060921,
-0.0003500005,
0.0479309782,
0.0091290195,
0.0434572846,
0.0449914187,
-0.0180221405,
-0.0263438504,
-0.0334183313,
0.0062095895,
0.0356420092,
0.0219241064,
0.0038580189,
-0.1047291383,
-0.0457071662,
-0.0012025561,
0.026124483,
-0.001492366,
-0.0248547327,
0.0414782204,
-0.020436896,
-0.0077186739,
-0.0679629445,
-0.0147122219,
0.026108807,
0.032384254,
0.0464796312,
-0.0479152389,
0.0167272501,
-0.0076427832,
0.0121164341,
-0.0188805629,
0.0143839894,
-0.0082979091,
-0.0273418222,
-0.0051056733,
-0.001705885,
0.0455312766,
-0.0017194609,
0.0288866833,
-0.0155375907,
0.0687332973,
-0.0258364789,
-0.03644339,
0.0060820756,
0.0185125321,
0.0111754248,
-0.0487527251,
0.0015547296,
-0.0236916821,
0.004011469,
0.0063709021,
-0.0457579307,
-0.011143825,
0.0316641033,
-0.020522926,
-0.0173564665,
-0.0066516725,
0.0004532791,
-0.0132887512,
0.0860373303,
-0.0017917163,
0.0422032848,
-0.0029693467,
0.0188032985,
-0.019427862,
-0.1020707563,
0.0187881179,
0.030329939,
-0.0149975121,
0.0652642474,
0.0521745533,
-0.0866221339,
-0.0079281442,
-0.0303694457,
-0.0034969063,
-0.0220673364,
-0.0000337297,
-0.0328180119,
0.0149418991,
-0.060869135,
0.0089270882,
-0.0328402296,
-0.011881656,
-0.0456284508,
-0.0193283707,
0.0347689651,
-0.0064713284,
0.0674765706,
-0.0393386185,
0.042829752,
-0.0019940888,
0.0419137217,
-0.0593984649,
-0.0252776444,
-0.0253566075,
-0.021236537,
-0.0460953936,
-0.0086579435,
-0.0539435595,
0.0577484928,
0.0275604092,
-0.0141834076,
-0.0441226624,
-0.0018673122,
0.0513790324,
0.0062401807,
0.0396739021,
-0.0582405291,
0.0288715549,
-0.0048056031,
0.0032837763,
0.022300981,
0.023924768,
0.0150334844,
0.0250132419,
0.0666622818,
-0.0550312698,
0.04447506,
0.0408419482,
0.0068640038,
-0.0008050645,
0.0383305401,
0.0045430195,
-0.0352861434,
-0.0077222274,
0.0149824638,
0.0173108056,
-0.0011791239,
0.0049826619,
0.0503293388,
0.0744908378,
0.0194467865,
0.0618590042,
0.0106190788,
0.0533938371,
0.0326252133,
-0.0193911754,
-0.027728267,
-0.0067018257,
-0.0216815062,
-0.0072174082,
-0.0028741669,
0.0360659324,
-0.0160471294,
-0.049893681,
-0.0266817398,
-0.0086557893,
0.0406225771,
-0.0005006009,
-0.0152415978,
-0.0049968851,
0.0105549637,
-0.0062902863,
0.0727098659,
-0.0648966506,
-0.0256148241,
-0.0244179834,
-0.013115569,
0.07576821,
0.0240205061,
-0.0365160443,
0.0009775514,
-0.0157369636,
0.0074372035,
0.0130315609,
0.0174093954,
-0.0053073303,
0.0093588782,
-0.033897616,
0.0369717591,
0.0281496402,
-0.0067120097,
0.0014771688,
0.0439609252,
0.0467389077,
-0.0261948816,
-0.0064158263,
-0.0183252953,
-0.0067007099,
-0.0606892481,
-0.0422028527,
0.0386324115,
0.0301719829,
0.0217814147,
0.0198050961,
-0.0039049755,
-0.0472758189,
-0.0092513692,
0.0172547884,
-0.0089717442,
0.0366867892,
0.0325201675,
0.0198498461,
0.0141838891,
-0.0250170641,
-0.0606497526,
0.0479360856,
-0.0153963156,
-0.0043272679,
0.047968436,
-0.0344618894,
0.0222251322,
0.0010926903,
-0.0366763994,
-0.0711544529,
0.0675024316,
-0.0006006385,
0.0565475188,
-0.0020121371,
0.0053157113,
-0.0301761758,
-0.0830195174,
-0.0004378322,
-0.0388376601,
-0.0265865978,
-0.0649517775,
-0.0064767129,
0.0268993247,
0.0007770632,
0.0101900846,
-0.0581568107,
-0.0134146009,
-0.0751331225,
0.0201605074,
0.007256737,
0.0195900239,
0.0035008579,
0.0209462196,
-0.0206789114,
0.0230894163,
-0.0145653738,
-0.0010770462,
0.034307465,
0.020733336,
0.0640022233,
-0.0317400768,
0.0296306517,
-0.0551397726,
-0.0230985191,
-0.0643980578,
0.0081692999,
-0.0165168066,
0.0218502656,
0.0224301517,
-0.0127159245,
-0.0742211044,
0.0051810043,
0.0128950579,
-0.0529321954,
0.0118447533,
-0.0324963294,
-0.0156873316,
0.0177006815,
0.0324886292,
0.0250969231,
0.0105032409,
0.0197328273,
-0.000956076,
0.0026155449,
-0.0149800219,
-0.0000292425,
-0.0329912715,
-0.0688475817,
-0.0033250507,
0.0321274176,
0.0017533326,
-0.000707946,
-0.0544451289,
0.0513541363,
0.0227736961,
-0.0088526839,
0.0443110839,
0.0502699614,
-0.0120213591,
0.0429694578,
0.0112110451,
0.0026756527,
0.0511318929,
0.0217407998,
0.0298740044,
-0.0374571681,
-0.0652441457,
-0.0279419329,
0.0429201759,
0.0293864999,
-0.0222100019,
0.0785102695,
0.0093597434,
-0.0021440934,
-0.0479206555,
0.0032691462,
-0.0204675067,
0.0142018702,
0.0185191296,
-0.0283788517,
0.0337127969,
-0.036281839,
-0.0019443998,
-0.0853365809,
-0.0668995753,
-0.058891654,
0.0307168439,
-0.0527602024,
-0.0238313247,
-0.0690120235,
0.0112736672,
-0.0326773487,
-0.0077600889,
-0.0313910246,
-0.0126885287,
0.0058530034,
0.0377629288,
-0.0044659744,
0.0026913881,
-0.0372796841,
-0.0522745997,
0.0246926751,
-0.0467962548,
0.0203883238,
-0.01581816,
-0.0156235667,
-0.0079686791,
-0.0238676108,
0.0187159032,
-0.0150381187,
0.032176964,
0.0176266637,
0.0067996439,
0.116778411,
0.0486649573,
-0.009287728,
0.020206213,
0.0432543419,
0.0351199955,
0.0159374867,
0.0336384587,
-0.0565121248,
-0.0143826138,
-0.0321925692,
0.0532188453,
-0.0395086855,
-0.0458349809,
-0.0274210889,
-0.069909595,
0.0334605016,
-0.0111196218,
0.004051399,
0.0012117189,
-0.0446630456,
0.0173379667,
-0.0569930673,
-0.0268790349,
-0.0542391762,
0.0111462306,
0.0204860102,
-0.0069624237,
-0.0716895014,
-0.0256574545,
0.100117445,
-0.029099131,
-0.0250783321,
-0.0226815306,
0.0725334063,
-0.0201619714,
-0.001711712,
-0.0835189596,
-0.0023371282,
-0.0172468238,
0.0274073202,
0.0879735053,
0.0141153494,
0.022118656,
-0.0963394716,
0.0246797875,
-0.0606442913,
0.0094842231,
0.0225878041,
0.0427891612,
0.0208662339,
-0.0597368442,
-0.0367495641,
0.0272718854,
0.0206071772,
0.0410409495,
-0.0140483761,
-0.0963691697,
-0.0011924405,
-0.0047912407,
-0.00976073,
-0.0424739085,
-0.0863828734,
-0.0067264619,
0.0192198288,
-0.0234727133,
-0.011563478,
-0.0678106248,
-0.0093211168,
0.0152876992,
-0.035633564,
-0.0500539578,
-0.0049773883,
0.0224667769,
-0.0567125194,
0.0395706035,
0.0001206873,
0.0198486689,
0.0118273925,
-0.0282611866,
0.0304883905,
-0.0111614363,
0.0031833802,
0.040793214,
-0.0785608664,
-0.0443397239,
0.0280381292,
-0.022483239,
0.0187636726,
0.0360428691,
0.0008614245,
-0.064434737,
0.0151119335,
0.0407090671,
-0.0320745334,
0.0318214633,
0.002461683,
0.0427513346,
0.0038468733,
0.0311505869,
-0.0167669412,
0.0124982893,
-0.0025989686,
-0.0937352628,
-0.058558926,
-0.0063963435,
-0.0124391038,
0.0082226777,
0.0273126233,
0.0132608442,
-0.0658270493,
-0.0028651655,
-0.0600544401,
0.009131616,
-0.042718906,
0.0183354784,
-0.0604960024,
0.000584148,
0.0200995766,
-0.065436773,
-0.0052429982,
-0.0239466205,
0.0192597993,
-0.0607354008,
0.043164555,
0.0338928625,
0.0328812487,
-0.0123437857,
-0.0227285568,
0.0147565417,
-0.0293789189,
-0.0000308865,
0.0395472385,
0.0016040306,
-0.0062018172,
-0.0338480994,
0.022702992,
-0.0053056488,
0.0315588862,
-0.0507110246,
-0.0148542486,
0.0030654736,
-0.0221213549,
-0.0280445646,
-0.0256635789,
0.0415085703,
-0.0025697534,
-0.0092107123,
-0.0155302305,
0.043360766,
-0.0309705008,
0.0004549434,
-0.012858158,
0.0011743206,
-0.0315863714,
-0.0072021508,
0.0245745815,
0.019163331,
-0.0140677365,
0.0327695496,
-0.0418057293,
-0.0300117619,
0.0360612124,
-0.0033268847,
0.0631475374,
0.0102649648,
-0.0050696568,
-0.0659690946,
-0.0662590191,
0.1016526595,
-0.0413721614,
0.0076578623,
0.0024194424,
0.0062575052,
0.0489037149,
-0.0043413071,
-0.0000938215,
-0.0423654914,
-0.0011789148,
-0.0390959606,
-0.0389791951,
-0.0154498369,
-6.145795237e-33,
0.0231734551,
-0.0269892253,
-0.0022699446,
0.0005566292,
0.0227998178,
-0.026785966,
0.0138649913,
0.0285587795,
0.0047412431,
-0.0000140446,
-0.0705445409,
0.0374560133,
0.0046374463,
0.0084000072,
0.0277565923,
0.0217779391,
0.0097239017,
-0.0227215365,
-0.0049815513,
0.0374616385,
0.0314763896,
0.008345956,
0.0637759641,
-0.0886464491,
-0.0007811784,
-0.0345742293,
-0.0047401921,
-0.0108368341,
0.0338483267,
0.055613488,
0.0063292673,
0.1174759641,
0.0311231744,
0.011512544,
0.0008274624,
0.0364943333,
-0.0237845294,
-0.0533862934,
-0.0471149795,
0.028479768,
0.0117237102,
-0.0381421186,
-0.0175319072,
-0.0063988636,
-0.0455454886,
-0.0507238284,
0.0866684094,
0.0271053314,
0.0721919015,
0.0345475115,
-0.0071580941,
0.0383224338,
-0.042926982,
0.0018187119,
0.0034206377,
0.01407078,
0.003698539,
0.0079854019,
-0.066809386,
0.0727062523,
-0.029161958,
-0.0133824842,
-0.0239601173,
-0.0243439432,
-0.020273909,
0.0250450503,
0.0664527714,
0.0763793886,
0.047228422,
0.0177206676,
0.0145373903,
0.0574483424,
0.0071406062,
0.1093043461,
0.0296430215,
-0.0599842928,
0.0008164393,
0.0140337907,
0.1027166471,
-0.059928067,
0.0090771504,
-0.0172070228,
-0.0424978398,
-0.0381719209,
0.0186698921,
-0.0458385162,
-0.0069327774,
-0.002010877,
-0.0335795954,
-0.0326604396,
-0.0064107254,
-0.0065704323,
0.0127688376,
-0.0363519154,
-0.0087971697,
0.0373284295,
-0.075817354,
0.0285051968,
0.0148131205,
-0.0016629887,
-0.0169505738,
-0.0076118549,
-0.0135416314,
0.0229338314,
0.0681024641,
-0.0052914419,
0.0202469807,
0.0387773812,
-0.0552283823,
-0.0190491788,
0.0398444235,
0.0234791934,
-0.0492745042,
-0.0020342139,
-0.0002242655,
0.0168682151,
0.0172653012,
0.0100954557,
0.0496503226,
0.0437822901,
-0.0231882669,
-0.0088870293,
0.0003490461,
-0.0262962673,
0.038848076,
-0.0153887914,
-0.0623689778,
-0.0465103239,
0.0283778328,
-0.0471508875,
0.0060741561,
-0.0266640782,
2.619e-7,
-0.0021412745,
0.0707169995,
-0.0363233238,
0.0394604355,
0.0418364704,
0.0460695922,
0.0317949802,
0.0175102167,
0.008634734,
-0.0187018048,
0.0063019479,
0.0104167759,
0.035090737,
0.0549988113,
-0.0536412448,
-0.0049087028,
-0.0029598607,
0.0019040433,
-0.0710596815,
-0.0021511246,
0.0261308849,
0.0756930113,
0.0615441948,
-0.0242852923,
0.0214553904,
0.0115312366,
0.0033118674,
0.0292070713,
0.0021797195,
0.0492050909,
-0.0130813206,
-0.0391699672,
0.0167461764,
0.0075879004,
-0.0348489918,
0.0123711275,
-0.0181357618,
0.0378544517,
-0.0002058383,
0.009120889,
0.0203721616,
0.0155671136,
-0.0203846004,
-0.0058725011,
0.051841896,
-0.0053399256,
-0.0745150968,
-0.0445171185,
0.0062210923,
-0.018060619,
0.0162316579,
0.0281318128,
-0.0221686307,
0.0210663714,
0.0119623886,
-0.0356550142,
-0.0298714899,
-0.0532234423,
0.0462781936,
0.0345351733,
-0.0478495359,
-0.0473838076,
0.0230268929,
0.0192976426,
0.0597314872,
-0.0526898801,
0.0487313867,
2.058265813e-34,
-0.0204006135,
0.046654135,
0.0182885472,
-0.0641566813,
0.0617280006,
0.0050246059,
0.0193012003,
-0.0137006696,
0.0531735942,
-0.0498577096,
0.0043601976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05494v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05494v3 | CrisisTransformers: Pre-trained language models and sentence encoders for crisis-related social media texts | 2023-09-11T14:36:16 | 2024-04-11T05:25:17 | Rabindra Lamsal, Maria Rodriguez Read, Shanika Karunasekera | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social media platforms play an essential role in crisis communication, but
analyzing crisis-related social media texts is challenging due to their
informal nature. Transformer-based pre-trained models like BERT and RoBERTa
have shown success in various NLP tasks, but they are not tailored for
crisis-related texts. Furthermore, general-purpose sentence encoders are used
to generate sentence embeddings, regardless of the textual complexities in
crisis-related texts. Advances in applications like text classification,
semantic search, and clustering contribute to the effective processing of
crisis-related texts, which is essential for emergency responders to gain a
comprehensive view of a crisis event, whether historical or real-time. To
address these gaps in crisis informatics literature, this study introduces
CrisisTransformers, an ensemble of pre-trained language models and sentence
encoders trained on an extensive corpus of over 15 billion word tokens from
tweets associated with more than 30 crisis events, including disease outbreaks,
natural disasters, conflicts, and other critical incidents. We evaluate
existing models and CrisisTransformers on 18 crisis-specific public datasets.
Our pre-trained models outperform strong baselines across all datasets in
classification tasks, and our best-performing sentence encoder improves the
state-of-the-art by 17.43% in sentence encoding tasks. Additionally, we
investigate the impact of model initialization on convergence and evaluate the
significance of domain-specific models in generating semantically meaningful
sentence embeddings. The models are publicly available at:
https://huggingface.co/crisistransformers | [
0.0036499391,
0.0678316206,
-0.0040050638,
0.0029097614,
-0.0001486114,
0.0182682592,
-0.012228081,
-0.0056755142,
-0.0051841172,
-0.0585715808,
0.0494949445,
-0.014389812,
-0.06315469,
0.0409523994,
-0.0117764231,
-0.0836669132,
0.033933159,
0.0393812843,
0.0618341342,
0.0141099878,
0.0229538102,
0.03469624,
0.0092447344,
0.0674449056,
-0.0212524068,
0.0255835783,
-0.0180090722,
0.0263359435,
0.060386695,
-0.0406903774,
0.0219860692,
0.0228726659,
0.0901217759,
0.0281178281,
0.0000019421,
-0.0099439053,
-0.0407357626,
-0.0464561284,
0.0098826671,
-0.0052722441,
0.0206141435,
-0.1156637222,
0.0081863785,
0.0482359938,
-0.0562600866,
-0.0547347255,
0.0231295098,
0.046254158,
0.0826964751,
0.1220988408,
-0.0307177044,
-0.0262181945,
0.0451607183,
0.0015367439,
-0.0618585497,
-0.0253299307,
0.0186443701,
-0.0509199873,
-0.0020422162,
0.0007111499,
0.0171361174,
0.0447828583,
0.0269243941,
0.0323900841,
0.0063390783,
0.0096020447,
-0.0476870574,
-0.009349891,
-0.0345612094,
0.0411645435,
-0.0194708407,
-0.036661502,
0.0131146172,
0.0026067244,
0.0124153141,
0.0447296016,
-0.025845699,
-0.0010304233,
0.0243755486,
0.0485631973,
0.0003515902,
0.0482204519,
0.0346720964,
0.0100216754,
-0.0212541465,
0.0058097704,
-0.0014059545,
-0.0551031344,
-0.045561146,
0.0101795811,
-0.0731920376,
-0.0115819313,
0.0446235426,
0.0128401611,
-0.0430602282,
-0.0000821601,
-0.0548327379,
-0.0323077589,
-0.0081595136,
-0.0833798945,
-0.0248073619,
0.0294226576,
0.0119538317,
-0.0043474184,
0.0232147202,
-0.0092916936,
-0.00099519,
0.0220781118,
-0.029595919,
-0.0141746886,
-0.0847778469,
-0.0099789239,
-0.0673471242,
-0.0001108082,
-0.0278126616,
-0.021963384,
-0.0268012285,
0.0159338359,
0.0444148928,
-0.0171688572,
0.0009700748,
-0.0017698487,
-0.030126404,
-0.0195057262,
0.0074494756,
0.0471233912,
-0.0382273532,
0.0026712562,
0.0127537921,
-0.033495374,
-0.0036319415,
-0.0002843608,
0.0515610166,
0.0098104039,
-0.0311562698,
0.0088574179,
-0.0170457065,
-0.0241981652,
-0.0336400121,
0.0137255499,
-0.0052803084,
-0.0006196802,
0.0078780986,
-0.0291771665,
0.0519486368,
0.0202999432,
0.0019004397,
-0.0006327212,
0.0227562934,
-0.0103410007,
-0.0384681635,
0.0314127244,
-0.03009055,
0.0224829018,
-0.0092845764,
-0.0147628477,
0.0476892814,
0.053357061,
0.0643325523,
0.0484317988,
0.0664967149,
-0.0334532484,
0.0079371519,
0.0024284227,
-0.0077041616,
-0.0037614699,
-0.01566411,
0.0042872396,
-0.0425599478,
0.0321404301,
-0.0220084898,
-0.0095281145,
-0.0186030045,
0.0335058607,
0.0372518227,
0.0374116823,
0.0041372199,
0.0060994579,
0.0315421075,
0.0483123995,
-0.0538699664,
-0.0288262498,
0.0077139605,
-0.0078214454,
-0.0100610442,
-0.0014121364,
0.0179886818,
0.0527353175,
-0.0370751619,
-0.0116564082,
-0.0266325548,
0.0018237353,
-0.0170878768,
-0.023995189,
0.0012980364,
-0.0127195325,
-0.0772413611,
0.0401603468,
0.0050321538,
-0.0534861013,
0.0019612031,
-0.0183313303,
-0.0502444394,
0.0800393298,
0.0425450839,
-0.0308396053,
-0.0319263861,
-0.0571925081,
0.071385026,
0.0439092666,
-0.0191154815,
0.0544642396,
-0.0008830184,
-0.0683191046,
-0.0318490565,
0.0052398695,
0.0288007613,
-0.0124689164,
0.0157243386,
0.0333174765,
0.0082019987,
-0.0255986862,
-0.0400835723,
0.0396753699,
0.0165214408,
-0.0095557561,
-0.0205148626,
0.0357869007,
-0.0051722233,
0.0025416659,
0.0085495478,
-0.0135276224,
0.0317306407,
-0.0400610752,
-0.0783437192,
0.0318771452,
-0.0520540625,
-0.0400008112,
-0.0035929631,
-0.0574992187,
-0.0080737425,
0.0449937135,
-0.0662402064,
-0.0244549867,
0.0623983219,
-0.0114535987,
0.0335956588,
-0.0319729261,
0.0022775482,
-0.0167496502,
-0.0009026657,
0.0163881872,
0.0572549403,
-0.0187988132,
-0.0172582064,
-0.0791030899,
-0.0166246593,
0.007892156,
0.003204444,
-0.0273893364,
-0.0106033655,
-0.0288707186,
0.0329312272,
0.0088299895,
-0.0208058599,
-0.0037709854,
-0.0350047611,
-0.0785732567,
0.0149585186,
-0.0557784289,
0.0105054826,
0.0425462648,
0.0240842104,
-0.0141339637,
0.00606712,
0.0208899826,
-0.0116419522,
0.02405609,
-0.0006610088,
0.0224854145,
-0.020306142,
0.0067548594,
-0.0331289582,
-0.0049486989,
-0.0399971195,
0.0555347987,
0.0059267688,
-0.0568715706,
-0.0216453727,
0.0174488518,
0.0016349675,
-0.0218549706,
0.0015355292,
-0.091919668,
0.0234877523,
0.0090284031,
0.0498338416,
-0.00621277,
0.0548208989,
0.1189619973,
-0.0130307348,
0.0094627785,
-0.0139060076,
0.0259025805,
-0.0616989695,
-0.0285452604,
-0.057990104,
-0.0222974662,
0.0110340249,
0.0484799705,
-0.0064482214,
0.0151595939,
-0.0671824291,
-0.0506136604,
-0.0101769185,
-0.002409165,
-0.0255026482,
-0.0414777808,
-0.0161297843,
0.0153492754,
-0.0234474279,
0.0004305726,
0.0066329013,
0.024440635,
0.0229195487,
-0.04963414,
-0.0479782335,
-0.0492533259,
0.0183682479,
-0.0006962107,
0.0032084815,
0.0210983828,
0.0026342713,
0.0110706873,
-0.0155011751,
0.0020511092,
-0.0157699008,
-0.0276582986,
0.0073605524,
0.0227984376,
0.0066518667,
-0.0306340624,
-0.0226866659,
-0.0875146538,
-0.015357309,
-0.0096260933,
0.022455886,
0.0069895261,
-0.0711089149,
0.0186432973,
0.0108997319,
-0.0036962067,
0.0179122481,
-0.008039929,
-0.0265312698,
0.0622887649,
0.0091571407,
-0.0084680337,
-0.0014346121,
-0.0200761855,
0.0262750331,
0.0276999138,
0.0206820313,
-0.0441235825,
-0.047287479,
-0.0279140286,
-0.000456779,
-0.034128584,
0.0113534657,
-0.0181140862,
0.0502886921,
-0.0172059704,
-0.0089935726,
0.1255105287,
0.0496084467,
-0.0203700587,
0.0159177128,
0.002245873,
-0.0053196107,
0.0002376243,
0.0204586145,
-0.0312051587,
-0.0207641702,
0.0092222309,
-0.0125879468,
0.019258948,
-0.0376483276,
0.0209029056,
-0.040473789,
0.0267653223,
0.00936988,
-0.0209438466,
-0.0123998513,
-0.0466319993,
-0.0137176318,
-0.0024790943,
0.0088887978,
-0.0386073105,
-0.0101735573,
0.0122555029,
0.0083254585,
-0.0555495992,
-0.0741967335,
-0.0290056095,
-0.0193273872,
0.0311231222,
0.0266459603,
0.0527118482,
-0.0123151811,
0.0068832505,
0.0454278663,
0.0092951702,
-0.0152195208,
-0.0013528052,
0.0337029994,
-0.0179580357,
-0.0136347562,
-0.006916686,
0.0238019582,
-0.0746265799,
-0.0374545492,
0.0062457062,
0.0547086708,
-0.0046174717,
-0.0230667591,
-0.0237578973,
0.0175784733,
0.0425452814,
0.0298452359,
0.0327078402,
-0.0082333134,
-0.024130743,
-0.031074848,
0.0531147867,
-0.0753039569,
-0.0009022758,
0.0009442071,
0.0172589906,
-0.0671710595,
-0.0439348519,
-0.0587835647,
0.035802491,
0.0174990296,
-0.03233983,
-0.0552591048,
0.0412818603,
-0.0291427784,
-0.0411385819,
0.0487193204,
-0.0108661754,
0.0004384063,
-0.041836828,
0.0115313949,
-0.0138784247,
0.0738482699,
-0.0169718117,
-0.0130105363,
-0.0434747636,
-0.0265965015,
0.0211453922,
-0.0139309345,
0.0102563752,
-0.0455182418,
-0.0182846654,
-0.0183255505,
0.0530668236,
0.0793822482,
-0.0650115237,
-0.0368400477,
0.0425252616,
-0.0053081624,
0.02575293,
0.0471592546,
0.0086832903,
0.0526681691,
-0.0241143201,
0.0591647774,
-0.0507564023,
0.0012460812,
-0.014511588,
-0.014001091,
0.0851323307,
-0.0027533669,
-0.1107643917,
-0.0351364575,
-0.0374479108,
-0.0304446742,
0.0173126496,
-0.0250467509,
0.0451724604,
0.0309551209,
0.0389059819,
-0.0332780443,
0.0466325395,
-0.0126830572,
-0.0155475158,
-0.0188108999,
0.0483853966,
0.0518741272,
0.0450394489,
-0.007859272,
0.0210760832,
-0.0132729411,
0.0391969904,
0.0176418889,
-0.0350681953,
-0.003727637,
-0.027957622,
0.0178733282,
0.0397127382,
0.0144136874,
0.0514528155,
-0.074100323,
0.009239817,
-0.034457244,
0.0156193161,
0.0707443431,
0.0053904885,
0.0548371375,
0.0033941891,
-0.002481869,
0.017820932,
0.0497799441,
-0.0110819284,
-0.0247964393,
-0.0041296226,
0.0004646532,
-0.0697010532,
0.022304289,
0.0478735119,
-0.0045064739,
0.0280585364,
0.0596639812,
-0.0243997592,
-0.0132366307,
-0.0175317954,
0.0178493839,
0.0407732688,
-0.0048105633,
0.0338692106,
-0.021812113,
-0.0116691506,
0.0587157644,
-0.0474777408,
-0.0510787331,
0.0115138823,
0.0016270007,
0.0246343147,
0.0041848724,
0.0539951138,
-0.0202020239,
0.0191147216,
0.0027591235,
-0.0562079959,
-0.0016243495,
-6.470831915e-33,
0.0349633433,
-0.0246349704,
-0.0237743836,
-0.0508566871,
-0.0018093843,
0.0161547828,
-0.0033625532,
-0.0086885951,
0.0088474499,
0.0166865438,
-0.0187979396,
0.0329356901,
0.0123052336,
0.017272599,
0.0054207859,
-0.0128445318,
0.0460612066,
0.0046945042,
-0.015372647,
-0.000066476,
0.0609366558,
0.0600002483,
0.070645161,
-0.050723549,
-0.0337285548,
-0.0235498901,
-0.0074010165,
-0.0027073608,
0.0858803168,
0.0098324474,
-0.0290166773,
0.0410816967,
0.0276377443,
-0.0307619814,
-0.0104092117,
0.0594047494,
-0.0132199954,
-0.0123838093,
0.0036552146,
-0.0070514954,
-0.0208785515,
-0.0362271555,
-0.0011783642,
0.0269510746,
0.015139916,
-0.0160480477,
0.0119876452,
0.0059034168,
0.0135563556,
-0.0226619579,
-0.0860056952,
0.0268577877,
-0.0345996283,
0.0030922273,
-0.0094089359,
0.0732401088,
0.0088485368,
0.0515482537,
-0.0364200957,
-0.0166408941,
-0.0124721024,
0.0154295778,
0.0208160467,
-0.0465355217,
-0.0551644936,
0.0493280441,
-0.0472215749,
-0.0258099642,
-0.0370737687,
0.0383035801,
-0.0095915999,
0.0507075898,
0.0116751911,
0.1207575127,
0.0310024768,
-0.0551468804,
-0.0810807571,
0.0275869463,
-0.0225274712,
0.0178912804,
0.0555554628,
0.0436074845,
-0.0111215655,
0.0107593136,
0.0047955234,
-0.0149316499,
-0.0108276354,
-0.0111097414,
0.0149348844,
0.0219073929,
0.0045190332,
0.0449785106,
0.0267115291,
-0.0350081734,
0.0064267819,
0.0003505486,
-0.0020641817,
0.0137628652,
0.0026667397,
0.0643099397,
-0.0369833633,
0.0005707428,
0.0656477287,
0.0318224765,
-0.0005224527,
-0.0353223123,
0.0428386293,
0.0162229277,
-0.0348610878,
0.0276898611,
-0.0104191462,
0.0143026551,
-0.0404767655,
0.0023958711,
-0.0049744751,
0.0393978357,
0.010267497,
-0.0179076102,
0.0281567778,
0.011058786,
0.0332694016,
-0.0311066974,
-0.0330645107,
0.0191869084,
0.0037701188,
-0.0038998073,
-0.0456465259,
0.0595164746,
-0.0270735417,
-0.0526763722,
-0.0200782232,
-0.0153035847,
2.657e-7,
0.0917286351,
0.0746114627,
0.0511774942,
-0.0286100246,
-0.0055410177,
0.0219528601,
0.0322571956,
0.0572103038,
-0.0009343458,
-0.0149820121,
0.0401869565,
0.0467964895,
0.0658394322,
0.027758779,
-0.069297798,
-0.0296328962,
-0.0886635184,
0.006860231,
-0.0798422471,
0.0035871172,
0.1042443663,
0.0841868445,
0.0438475274,
-0.0009128214,
-0.0257640556,
-0.035884317,
0.0463649184,
-0.0549317561,
-0.0566352606,
0.0258382671,
0.0062937466,
0.0373971537,
-0.0246211309,
-0.0088484092,
-0.0274145789,
0.0271845255,
0.0123232398,
0.0323578678,
0.010706895,
-0.0206216928,
-0.008262679,
-0.0016051142,
-0.0152368862,
-0.0539484732,
0.0597712882,
-0.0985156819,
-0.027559517,
0.0300288294,
-0.0812452734,
0.0369640067,
0.0295199342,
-0.0193533637,
-0.0551108085,
0.0379148237,
0.0257100016,
0.0087780058,
-0.0232932232,
-0.0759317577,
0.0183601696,
0.0081604868,
-0.0409089625,
0.0077199768,
-0.0353449769,
0.0112703359,
0.0551157743,
-0.0157602355,
0.0409149639,
2.515246818e-34,
0.0368989334,
0.014520227,
-0.0148570212,
-0.0030544961,
0.0302216597,
-0.0033451847,
-0.0346616544,
-0.0165857077,
-0.0118539641,
-0.0565028116,
0.0234685801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05475v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05475v2 | Zero-shot Learning with Minimum Instruction to Extract Social Determinants and Family History from Clinical Notes using GPT Model | 2023-09-11T14:16:27 | 2023-09-13T20:30:22 | Neel Bhate, Ansh Mittal, Zhe He, Xiao Luo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Demographics, Social determinants of health, and family history documented in
the unstructured text within the electronic health records are increasingly
being studied to understand how this information can be utilized with the
structured data to improve healthcare outcomes. After the GPT models were
released, many studies have applied GPT models to extract this information from
the narrative clinical notes. Different from the existing work, our research
focuses on investigating the zero-shot learning on extracting this information
together by providing minimum information to the GPT model. We utilize
de-identified real-world clinical notes annotated for demographics, various
social determinants, and family history information. Given that the GPT model
might provide text different from the text in the original data, we explore two
sets of evaluation metrics, including the traditional NER evaluation metrics
and semantic similarity evaluation metrics, to completely understand the
performance. Our results show that the GPT-3.5 method achieved an average of
0.975 F1 on demographics extraction, 0.615 F1 on social determinants
extraction, and 0.722 F1 on family history extraction. We believe these results
can be further improved through model fine-tuning or few-shots learning.
Through the case studies, we also identified the limitations of the GPT models,
which need to be addressed in future research. | [
0.0289367884,
0.0493141264,
0.0043433965,
-0.0031493956,
-0.0564567111,
0.0623803213,
-0.008725238,
0.0320268124,
-0.0193704423,
-0.0439739227,
0.0266185906,
-0.0431353562,
0.0230633691,
0.0042735455,
-0.0266897473,
-0.0670812801,
0.0171926394,
0.0771439373,
0.0542437732,
0.0340902321,
-0.0095066512,
0.0214199163,
-0.0041550328,
0.0315553583,
-0.005084625,
-0.0122423489,
0.0219078586,
0.0099645453,
0.064386338,
-0.0631288663,
0.0009350636,
0.0237940028,
-0.03924096,
-0.0082511967,
0.000002298,
-0.0507070087,
-0.050507158,
0.0454359651,
-0.0301244818,
-0.0611121692,
0.0795013458,
-0.0490195192,
-0.010773466,
-0.0052156588,
-0.0313727483,
-0.0513876155,
0.0352456681,
0.0685951635,
0.0201478619,
0.079150185,
-0.0428500287,
-0.016746236,
-0.0348102003,
0.000498427,
0.0539032519,
-0.013898015,
0.0347802453,
0.0136599559,
-0.0005784425,
-0.0509169437,
0.0295822527,
0.0020014041,
-0.0342309438,
0.072558552,
0.0116424393,
0.0671938285,
-0.0401904806,
0.0443684161,
0.0389508791,
0.0711496919,
0.0137222959,
0.041540172,
0.0530779697,
-0.0299785864,
-0.0377766863,
-0.0057364912,
-0.0408956371,
-0.0252058115,
-0.0546374097,
0.0172067694,
0.0116739729,
0.0171750337,
0.0230411794,
-0.0451727808,
-0.004490647,
0.0134680998,
0.0006223691,
-0.0406919941,
-0.0025666214,
-0.0166235622,
0.0211739559,
-0.021764908,
0.0281277653,
0.0183274746,
0.0242380127,
0.0346742719,
-0.0198776294,
-0.0346646309,
0.0389626063,
-0.0434184559,
0.0360886864,
0.0312965177,
0.0187608711,
0.0337211825,
0.0030821152,
-0.0126663959,
0.0312577263,
-0.0006074831,
-0.0119618569,
0.00354102,
-0.094772175,
0.0141997924,
-0.0235500745,
0.0683803856,
-0.0020638544,
0.0281504281,
-0.0269457661,
-0.0228148773,
0.023672726,
0.0190722346,
0.0015437884,
-0.0070505585,
-0.02956401,
0.0040221922,
-0.0176630802,
0.0088795293,
-0.0320146456,
-0.0177935846,
-0.0326070189,
-0.0276584495,
0.025719488,
-0.0206999592,
0.0696099997,
-0.0209387727,
0.0126686255,
0.0271093789,
0.0335361138,
-0.0387911052,
-0.0862962976,
-0.0421880707,
-0.0167061314,
-0.0292592831,
-0.0309257694,
-0.0389431678,
0.0296031851,
0.0066509638,
0.0026731836,
-0.070996277,
0.0031753317,
0.0167133491,
-0.0863807797,
0.0374239087,
-0.0161862411,
-0.014095014,
0.0411593802,
0.0277892295,
0.0190399066,
0.0258754697,
0.0584898405,
-0.0544103906,
0.0240436122,
-0.0108016999,
-0.000918813,
0.0012327682,
0.0139547577,
-0.040715158,
0.0201918967,
0.0176557843,
0.0127826147,
0.0259558558,
-0.0229978599,
0.0436871238,
-0.0358083509,
-0.033052627,
0.0166388787,
0.0722841695,
0.0350412056,
0.0371310785,
0.0287934281,
0.0089481827,
-0.0201821718,
0.0042496584,
-0.019409338,
-0.01225165,
-0.0070457789,
0.0104639586,
-0.0208900552,
0.0093467878,
-0.0341050811,
-0.0332057215,
-0.0184513386,
-0.0250135772,
0.0096780118,
-0.0382431857,
0.0189947765,
-0.0103249317,
-0.0500817038,
0.0536802486,
0.0506226048,
-0.0321240351,
-0.0293735079,
-0.0236096345,
0.0040562428,
0.0624311753,
0.0390523747,
-0.0532896221,
-0.0676349327,
-0.0289314594,
-0.0344230235,
-0.0103154099,
-0.0143423248,
-0.0093192458,
0.054741215,
-0.0483054817,
-0.0163104814,
0.0191705097,
0.0406422019,
-0.0053319694,
0.0232933555,
0.0419022776,
0.0263605379,
0.0025608258,
-0.0116540464,
0.0470081195,
-0.0763690248,
-0.050523378,
0.0232925061,
-0.0074483049,
0.0486892946,
0.0411137342,
-0.0049263574,
0.0034278433,
-0.0123049803,
-0.016144963,
0.0019232413,
-0.0247158408,
-0.0652772263,
-0.059487503,
-0.037277475,
-0.0570778213,
0.0060053053,
-0.0021262344,
-0.0386181735,
-0.0236413702,
-0.0130106378,
0.002617537,
-0.005222247,
-0.0070280833,
0.0039856499,
0.0509573482,
-0.0261981729,
-0.022400843,
0.0390697569,
-0.0050154203,
-0.0100830328,
-0.0079250559,
-0.0489465855,
0.0076465271,
-0.0527172983,
0.0031901395,
0.0042919377,
0.0038171532,
-0.0144854393,
-0.0106173493,
0.0106714889,
-0.0383320972,
-0.0380184352,
-0.1080919206,
0.0224808529,
-0.0099588884,
0.0344557539,
0.0342899151,
0.0313763283,
-0.0264015738,
-0.0197345242,
-0.0611202158,
0.0094213737,
-0.0079568867,
-0.0005220429,
0.0438479967,
0.0557427295,
0.0184674766,
-0.0263439976,
0.005713312,
-0.0501733683,
0.0287724752,
0.0116624422,
-0.036456231,
-0.0076453271,
-0.0099031804,
-0.0649268255,
-0.0167192202,
-0.0113299219,
0.0283686277,
0.0015534132,
0.0103620226,
0.0217003264,
0.0135502601,
-0.0376818255,
0.0181290731,
-0.018726727,
-0.0022662082,
-0.0017075526,
0.015623875,
-0.0536700226,
0.0498171151,
-0.001684839,
-0.0879132524,
0.012662896,
0.0597043149,
0.0429327898,
-0.0143418452,
-0.0552464724,
0.0021029962,
-0.0250050426,
0.0489142612,
-0.027064655,
0.0163704809,
-0.0084245838,
-0.0123974737,
-0.0321686231,
-0.0081542265,
0.0787800401,
0.0020902567,
0.0410672985,
-0.0379762389,
-0.0339762531,
-0.0611267164,
0.0304747429,
0.0141248815,
0.0229545739,
0.0399389192,
-0.0244872496,
0.0178833343,
-0.0185057577,
0.0379133373,
-0.0408958383,
0.0652714297,
-0.0012496109,
0.0142529467,
-0.0042518247,
-0.0155204181,
-0.0088172387,
-0.0468236879,
-0.0190063957,
0.0334930643,
-0.0333382748,
0.030508874,
-0.0237489287,
0.0395202823,
-0.0035743385,
0.101343587,
0.0129950214,
-0.0295719821,
-0.0177346617,
0.0355887599,
0.0370007083,
-0.0842893347,
-0.0461064801,
-0.0195080284,
0.0201800913,
0.0425062627,
0.0214699972,
0.0361316353,
0.0168058854,
0.0040639699,
-0.0566218905,
-0.045056399,
-0.0191336554,
0.0345678367,
0.0024437637,
-0.0384351015,
0.0147148697,
0.1133752838,
0.0131844124,
-0.0301334653,
0.0005863015,
0.0045555718,
-0.0260172728,
-0.0038108728,
0.0013376473,
-0.063434504,
-0.0213077012,
-0.0079496428,
0.03206487,
-0.0317003131,
-0.0896066129,
0.0008994396,
-0.0468915105,
-0.0024468475,
0.0097493799,
-0.0550874248,
-0.0119886398,
-0.0591014475,
0.0202315357,
-0.0577821396,
-0.0145696718,
-0.0400375873,
-0.0238485802,
-0.0096580451,
-0.0234474577,
-0.0620216243,
-0.0528061017,
0.0465748571,
-0.0111509515,
0.0203414336,
0.0286168624,
0.0543544106,
0.0010653232,
-0.0062522381,
-0.0130745685,
-0.012489059,
0.0055094603,
-0.017793851,
0.1068667099,
-0.0485612974,
0.0263580196,
-0.0237890445,
0.0261507202,
0.0125173694,
-0.0126665952,
-0.0085086273,
0.0516661331,
-0.024660049,
-0.0420153812,
0.000687996,
0.0116964765,
0.0410420708,
0.069221966,
-0.0075613437,
0.020124441,
-0.0195243601,
0.0385601521,
0.0455351807,
0.0215274841,
-0.0057151499,
0.0301647112,
-0.0529641807,
-0.0304546934,
-0.0399630517,
-0.0675654411,
0.0332669206,
0.0082883444,
-0.0064188503,
0.0140785715,
0.0526953712,
-0.0080593145,
-0.058095824,
0.0295880735,
-0.0384204052,
-0.021979453,
0.0043188627,
-0.0248531383,
0.0196538717,
0.021086704,
-0.0208093598,
-0.0510386527,
-0.0192647781,
0.0131389564,
-0.0176090691,
0.0166830979,
0.0192344822,
0.0437450111,
0.0255190115,
0.0065489826,
0.0227028076,
0.026718298,
0.0097082984,
-0.045677837,
-0.0256062299,
0.0120616723,
-0.0220927298,
0.0104537625,
0.0333460122,
0.0333256274,
0.0076593859,
0.0110437032,
-0.0438930839,
0.0152863283,
-0.0091553181,
0.0353133865,
0.0697209612,
0.0195453335,
-0.0452362336,
-0.0571900383,
0.0096047875,
-0.036031086,
0.0268197525,
-0.0234881211,
-0.0420763008,
0.0047116042,
0.0030956103,
-0.0398638025,
-0.0061818804,
-0.0716860369,
0.0075252722,
-0.0920803845,
0.0260480773,
0.0203121565,
0.0268871207,
-0.0047034803,
-0.0450252779,
-0.0238294601,
0.0153570706,
0.0257393327,
0.0311740488,
-0.0272188615,
0.0787924454,
-0.0075209653,
0.0452042036,
0.0097300047,
0.0219503585,
-0.0278425571,
0.0463981517,
-0.0717308223,
0.0024759402,
0.0045889001,
-0.0208772514,
0.0390063152,
-0.0164253283,
0.0046370109,
0.0089451764,
0.0340764597,
0.0071727438,
0.0130994581,
0.0379566513,
0.0221471786,
-0.0050370409,
0.0245333109,
0.0666749254,
0.0180970877,
0.0534701273,
-0.0030959027,
-0.0388253517,
-0.0495972522,
0.0112590995,
0.06624946,
-0.0035220424,
-0.0429414175,
-0.0221169833,
-0.1039031893,
-0.0095754499,
0.0531742461,
-0.0329647847,
-0.0183330327,
-0.0109682344,
0.0566297509,
0.0096667986,
-0.0111596705,
-0.0351171866,
-0.0193904098,
0.0015311993,
-0.0273135733,
-0.0145298429,
0.0390071832,
-6.914251894e-33,
-0.0261933133,
-0.0300204549,
0.0277986676,
0.0049658641,
-0.0307469182,
0.020896459,
-0.0374539495,
-0.0410804525,
0.0192628223,
0.0235196147,
-0.0079867523,
-0.0040306849,
0.0225572344,
0.0248222575,
-0.0273332838,
-0.0245394483,
0.0260762293,
0.0253675953,
-0.0179659221,
0.0323532745,
-0.0191100705,
0.0634785965,
0.0601982437,
-0.0655078441,
0.0246431567,
-0.0232377797,
0.0183510333,
-0.011333731,
0.0602878816,
0.038618248,
-0.0431616865,
0.0087486561,
0.0608048216,
-0.0661912337,
0.012802681,
-0.0011179124,
-0.1095869243,
-0.0424846783,
-0.0070831706,
-0.0578270331,
-0.0176873282,
-0.0373502634,
0.0104264263,
0.0003358467,
-0.0055779354,
-0.0518437773,
0.0387024693,
-0.0271618646,
-0.0098936753,
-0.0065055005,
-0.0473118573,
0.0866710991,
0.0081520099,
0.0485776253,
0.0174772348,
0.0174041111,
-0.0339765549,
0.0395248309,
-0.042578809,
-0.0521049313,
0.0292784963,
-0.001278062,
-0.0373245738,
-0.0277509075,
-0.0081082592,
0.0437447503,
0.0253991112,
0.0132241584,
-0.0732286125,
-0.0111662429,
-0.0326102041,
0.0200971402,
0.0015821805,
0.0482567064,
0.0355787836,
-0.0201499499,
-0.0863987654,
0.0473769605,
-0.0611756966,
0.0147903273,
0.0146635212,
-0.0398959816,
-0.0681931227,
-0.0112830717,
-0.0234869607,
-0.0347911082,
0.0007720356,
-0.0248207487,
0.0159898773,
0.0214571096,
-0.0065369727,
0.0427668653,
-0.0039248574,
0.0030459547,
0.0252204593,
-0.0028958118,
0.0256679505,
0.0026081831,
-0.0340658017,
-0.0225593131,
-0.0517829284,
-0.014697982,
0.0246080663,
0.0247878674,
0.0770113468,
0.0064013028,
0.0663655028,
-0.0136937629,
-0.0678174868,
-0.0349681154,
0.042532105,
-0.0012103027,
-0.0433862023,
-0.0025535098,
0.006510654,
0.0203508288,
0.0191775523,
0.0603208169,
0.0376275629,
0.0100630363,
0.0105323652,
-0.0200125631,
0.013590402,
-0.006416589,
-0.0179270785,
0.0185714643,
-0.0003154392,
0.0174229071,
0.0481531732,
0.0059502409,
0.00876485,
0.0167839341,
2.958e-7,
0.0556614809,
0.0556960739,
0.0266373772,
-0.0495735295,
0.0301389117,
0.0207550135,
0.0111926952,
0.0206420068,
0.0259722564,
-0.0128809325,
0.0936393142,
0.0064510657,
0.0438904688,
0.0669546574,
-0.0800497085,
-0.0080030421,
-0.0775356367,
-0.0767788664,
-0.0388168767,
0.0226112325,
0.0869116113,
0.0603311099,
-0.0178225525,
-0.0158444867,
-0.0110486085,
0.016570583,
0.0329154655,
-0.029660983,
0.001486267,
0.0437860042,
0.0025233356,
-0.0214441363,
0.0127306106,
0.0409745537,
-0.0011682197,
0.0203700401,
0.0002513458,
0.1211837158,
-0.0646700859,
0.0244398024,
0.0233013518,
0.0009276515,
0.0001871902,
-0.033861421,
0.0986816213,
-0.0243449807,
-0.0496961549,
0.0162637718,
-0.0401971415,
0.0212864019,
0.0676188245,
0.0400051363,
-0.0453457087,
0.0298776701,
0.0318414755,
0.0049124267,
-0.0406542011,
-0.0373360738,
0.0270504598,
0.0721299127,
0.0117976898,
-0.0089901229,
0.0648196489,
-0.0354869515,
0.0126755433,
-0.0613836497,
0.0186492875,
2.752796548e-34,
0.0079204459,
0.0187638756,
0.0011569011,
-0.021872852,
0.0139721893,
0.0098191742,
-0.0332763828,
-0.01127683,
0.0080503086,
-0.0637909919,
0.0053285975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05472v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05472v2 | LeBenchmark 2.0: a Standardized, Replicable and Enhanced Framework for Self-supervised Representations of French Speech | 2023-09-11T14:13:09 | 2024-03-18T10:54:15 | Titouan Parcollet, Ha Nguyen, Solene Evain, Marcely Zanon Boito, Adrien Pupier, Salima Mdhaffar, Hang Le, Sina Alisamir, Natalia Tomashenko, Marco Dinarelli, Shucong Zhang, Alexandre Allauzen, Maximin Coavoux, Yannick Esteve, Mickael Rouvier, Jerome Goulian, Benjamin Lecouteux, Francois Portet, Solange Rossato, Fabien Ringeval, Didier Schwab, Laurent Besacier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Self-supervised learning (SSL) is at the origin of unprecedented improvements
in many different domains including computer vision and natural language
processing. Speech processing drastically benefitted from SSL as most of the
current domain-related tasks are now being approached with pre-trained models.
This work introduces LeBenchmark 2.0 an open-source framework for assessing and
building SSL-equipped French speech technologies. It includes documented,
large-scale and heterogeneous corpora with up to 14,000 hours of heterogeneous
speech, ten pre-trained SSL wav2vec 2.0 models containing from 26 million to
one billion learnable parameters shared with the community, and an evaluation
protocol made of six downstream tasks to complement existing benchmarks.
LeBenchmark 2.0 also presents unique perspectives on pre-trained SSL models for
speech with the investigation of frozen versus fine-tuned downstream models,
task-agnostic versus task-specific pre-trained models as well as a discussion
on the carbon footprint of large-scale model training. Overall, the newly
introduced models trained on 14,000 hours of French speech outperform
multilingual and previous LeBenchmark SSL models across the benchmark but also
required up to four times more energy for pre-training. | [
-0.0600831062,
0.0844640955,
0.0264555048,
0.0360717662,
-0.0150073711,
-0.0209040977,
0.0690887198,
-0.0674918443,
-0.0066131367,
-0.012376681,
-0.078664422,
0.0024010283,
-0.026928382,
0.0138522033,
0.0362557881,
-0.010314866,
0.0445500501,
-0.0376677737,
-0.0313948467,
-0.0332158953,
0.0118251126,
0.0186391342,
-0.0526566654,
0.0084227175,
-0.0337654799,
0.0008286541,
-0.016897196,
0.0339324363,
-0.0065618423,
-0.0347530097,
-0.0105058923,
0.0755341053,
0.0193731915,
0.0465953723,
0.0000022235,
-0.0425352529,
-0.0225867406,
0.0003752629,
-0.051343888,
0.05135566,
0.0053482158,
0.017880816,
-0.0514203347,
0.0157949813,
-0.0070952936,
-0.0382446051,
0.0340417624,
-0.0007280234,
0.0343038663,
0.0519668311,
-0.0082540698,
-0.036376521,
-0.0415909924,
-0.0176304635,
-0.0397324897,
-0.0067599732,
-0.0199725479,
-0.016001679,
-0.041847758,
-0.0472673289,
-0.0315212719,
0.0745298788,
0.0265200883,
-0.0180758461,
0.0418329574,
0.009385501,
-0.0422448851,
-0.0184753444,
-0.0168694947,
0.0419539362,
-0.0170743689,
-0.0298184399,
-0.0340215452,
-0.0214561857,
-0.0251159333,
-0.0163668022,
-0.0187791437,
-0.0258653425,
0.0812728852,
0.0117048519,
-0.020072639,
0.0588413514,
0.0289673489,
-0.052141536,
-0.0216049161,
0.0172946602,
-0.0156068644,
-0.003365756,
0.0467181914,
0.0061954791,
0.0017345189,
0.0074452134,
0.0064711142,
-0.0121636605,
0.0132635524,
-0.035511028,
-0.0134916212,
-0.0245109238,
-0.0115988534,
-0.0336425751,
0.0318369046,
0.0029092156,
-0.035223037,
0.0131325563,
-0.0245230608,
0.0273380186,
-0.0217957031,
-0.0157763083,
-0.0269035641,
0.018584488,
-0.026529422,
0.0285949688,
-0.0650034323,
-0.0214811359,
-0.050606098,
-0.0171442833,
0.0035659543,
-0.0099741789,
-0.0341495499,
-0.0034793424,
0.0519934483,
0.0158717949,
0.0031479541,
-0.0203099344,
0.0153162358,
0.0693220273,
-0.0037753398,
0.0290975012,
-0.0088489,
-0.0880182311,
-0.0058375946,
-0.0116906855,
0.027755836,
-0.0098577794,
0.0389947779,
0.0708604828,
-0.0080561657,
-0.0235935263,
0.0080909329,
-0.0283376891,
0.0003327043,
-0.0766375959,
-0.0293560307,
-0.0922740623,
-0.0168111231,
-0.031433098,
0.0505082384,
-0.0340060033,
-0.0142697906,
-0.0482896343,
0.0167413037,
0.0614434145,
-0.0419335999,
0.0043691997,
0.0275251754,
0.0029638635,
0.008083283,
0.0737113655,
0.024499109,
-0.0286051165,
0.0072001047,
-0.0617749766,
-0.022019729,
0.0485332645,
0.051315289,
-0.0026273613,
-0.0344520807,
-0.0105224159,
0.0212481786,
0.030596571,
0.0875658467,
0.026134422,
-0.014922102,
-0.0701219514,
0.10811349,
0.0508795232,
0.0252305735,
0.0320250057,
0.0017789738,
0.0257571377,
0.0821418986,
-0.031985309,
-0.0244651232,
0.0406057909,
-0.0234648958,
-0.0342568047,
0.0111542372,
0.0056890142,
-0.0713390559,
-0.0309457425,
0.030763505,
-0.025976358,
0.0230752695,
0.0211491715,
0.0353303142,
0.0228794683,
-0.0245979875,
0.0122289956,
-0.007136344,
-0.0641688928,
-0.0095728021,
-0.0174987316,
0.0178690515,
0.0547700524,
0.005472668,
-0.0033506192,
-0.0269494969,
-0.0568499491,
-0.0177192427,
0.0042553884,
0.0197693482,
0.0035410908,
0.0991083905,
-0.0244499724,
-0.0480634905,
-0.0435127951,
-0.0223556068,
0.0379722118,
-0.0599526875,
0.0296064932,
-0.018452635,
-0.0207573287,
0.0212264508,
0.0068138535,
-0.0272739753,
-0.0563063547,
0.0245301407,
0.0259739384,
0.0270755999,
0.0302719362,
-0.0396175645,
0.0086329607,
0.0245242063,
-0.0114260046,
0.0182076022,
0.0166231729,
-0.0689096674,
-0.0096945576,
0.0078368289,
-0.0215611979,
0.0009588535,
0.0871841908,
0.0057914583,
-0.0356763192,
0.0416888855,
0.015383943,
-0.0004456608,
-0.0352120996,
0.032694675,
0.0231638383,
0.0430590697,
0.0550371446,
-0.0085012028,
0.012505441,
-0.0137476726,
-0.0172032807,
0.0580981933,
0.0214392394,
-0.0414966606,
-0.048275061,
-0.0202981178,
-0.0157541893,
0.0373515375,
0.0195192378,
0.0043080687,
-0.0197266676,
0.027162252,
-0.0569679961,
0.0134821497,
-0.0383104272,
0.0202553775,
-0.0155010363,
0.0067807133,
-0.0236696582,
-0.0576936007,
-0.0199264865,
-0.0486965291,
-0.0215470605,
-0.0059212791,
-0.050293833,
0.0033313739,
0.0037085647,
-0.0112234512,
-0.0265343059,
0.0458660163,
0.000149077,
-0.0273559783,
0.0115783038,
0.0092368126,
0.0441786759,
-0.0070912223,
0.0336297154,
0.0240435954,
-0.0399136506,
-0.0061324849,
-0.0134404767,
0.0312598757,
0.0549675897,
0.0306959767,
-0.0040535592,
0.0479837954,
0.0001821457,
-0.0294284672,
0.0024144407,
-0.0149798961,
0.0164407901,
-0.0616562404,
0.0552679189,
-0.0435305201,
0.0480186455,
0.0076794932,
0.012955768,
-0.010749571,
0.0130587611,
0.0092247333,
-0.0763007849,
-0.0321001932,
0.0395696051,
-0.002839921,
0.0136364065,
0.0277361851,
-0.0280191824,
0.012711864,
-0.0501996316,
-0.0335010625,
-0.0126262298,
-0.0628938302,
0.0342465974,
0.0471192375,
-0.0028307575,
0.0101913176,
0.0078631127,
-0.0121465717,
-0.029576052,
-0.0012937774,
0.0528331883,
-0.0162551478,
0.005325295,
0.0142634306,
0.0167946517,
0.0117880655,
-0.0565681905,
-0.0195111986,
-0.0284901448,
-0.0512041673,
-0.0076553966,
-0.0039369795,
-0.009923921,
0.004762385,
0.0334542505,
-0.0076493546,
0.0682648867,
0.0155696981,
0.0026394061,
-0.0046160319,
0.0182202607,
0.0028734815,
0.0343489237,
0.0250120983,
0.0070608966,
0.0527203269,
0.0224879794,
0.0788124055,
-0.0150878327,
-0.0947739184,
0.0189100448,
0.0319050215,
-0.0141554,
-0.0264388807,
0.0056763352,
0.0570962578,
-0.0656971782,
0.013845576,
0.1102640703,
-0.0286007486,
0.001717036,
-0.0072562024,
0.0323231816,
-0.0290767532,
0.01589147,
-0.0222782232,
-0.0345237888,
-0.0035095275,
0.0284679681,
0.0167173594,
0.0356552042,
0.0364080258,
0.0119463829,
-0.0789528489,
0.0777965859,
0.0163423605,
-0.0272075292,
0.0148303267,
-0.0485344939,
-0.0529146232,
-0.1037671119,
0.0131897535,
-0.0137730045,
-0.0289145093,
-0.0342298374,
0.0275812428,
-0.0642199069,
-0.0282649957,
0.0121930642,
-0.0578804277,
0.0856116489,
0.0459146909,
-0.0037203487,
-0.0141939642,
-0.018466467,
0.0362551473,
-0.0245362651,
-0.0148154031,
-0.0160058793,
0.0365667008,
0.0213186294,
-0.0247011334,
0.0269338209,
0.006722799,
0.0098493388,
0.011951616,
0.0020396831,
0.046829842,
-0.0239524916,
0.0059974687,
0.0006767591,
0.020959191,
-0.0106117995,
0.0482828058,
0.0274334587,
-0.0054650726,
-0.0317944586,
0.0193583742,
0.0113894353,
-0.0335228518,
-0.0596460626,
0.0290307347,
0.0185284261,
-0.0757413283,
0.0214472432,
0.0007423325,
0.004861617,
0.0629145578,
-0.0189373363,
0.0453755632,
-0.0004325556,
0.0206011347,
-0.0715722293,
0.0507615693,
0.0086483844,
0.0012514202,
-0.0596274585,
-0.066864036,
0.0231130216,
-0.0293205585,
-0.0128708193,
-0.0005930557,
-0.0448289476,
-0.0357395411,
-0.0118104024,
0.0580838732,
0.0110834101,
0.069517158,
-0.0070959805,
-0.0324592963,
0.1055024415,
0.0394965671,
-0.0888448209,
0.0036896297,
0.0765690356,
-0.0457073487,
-0.0167051218,
0.032195285,
-0.0147265336,
0.0873158202,
-0.0432202891,
0.0221028347,
0.0274811015,
-0.0820675939,
0.0079595279,
-0.0143787293,
0.0616374947,
-0.0108432509,
0.0793412402,
-0.0373426825,
0.0159012359,
-0.0318747945,
0.0746280327,
-0.0293191876,
0.0063745803,
0.0262009297,
0.0167078972,
0.0030395901,
0.0165578574,
-0.0063765012,
-0.0370083302,
-0.0478281006,
0.0235506967,
0.0088238306,
0.0109134419,
-0.0026913462,
0.0531099215,
0.0352913216,
0.0125269042,
0.0697778016,
-0.0076894574,
-0.0076428903,
0.002263339,
0.0172388665,
0.0621858351,
-0.0313486457,
0.0486847088,
-0.0545416065,
-0.0401910543,
-0.0112059554,
-0.0094631854,
0.0373484902,
-0.0281455368,
0.0688810945,
-0.0143053513,
-0.0124756061,
-0.0565373786,
0.016698109,
-0.0457085185,
0.0217399932,
-0.0153257977,
-0.0148851667,
-0.0293083247,
-0.0109590329,
-0.0010491495,
0.0307225659,
0.0322547406,
0.0407395214,
0.0500264466,
-0.0485226996,
-0.037007492,
-0.0239982847,
-0.0291784313,
-0.0578350909,
-0.0354159288,
0.0029414911,
-0.0710489452,
0.0282452777,
-0.0134294825,
-0.0346439555,
-0.008161244,
0.0567702167,
-0.0083714975,
-0.0080885198,
0.0166730918,
0.0307707042,
-0.0010086833,
-0.0252313223,
-0.0170753002,
0.077391699,
-6.564899381e-33,
0.0139694354,
0.0232114941,
0.0055286568,
0.0066527389,
0.0106008844,
0.0353786945,
-0.0082649458,
0.0297287181,
0.0060048033,
0.0174585059,
0.0154574085,
-0.0023322089,
0.0232361797,
0.0166449118,
0.0131391762,
-0.0086499415,
0.108258158,
-0.0327333733,
-0.0128337042,
-0.0063579753,
0.0201240238,
0.0739984661,
0.0481392667,
-0.0881505311,
-0.0683546215,
-0.0153047703,
-0.0130457236,
-0.0448471718,
0.005680636,
0.0593977161,
-0.0092403479,
0.0434468389,
-0.032347545,
-0.0268881489,
-0.0479561277,
0.0043695564,
-0.1290182322,
-0.0281159263,
-0.0379161313,
0.0508407429,
-0.0661241487,
0.0178222898,
0.0308468509,
0.0494776927,
-0.082227774,
0.0120156063,
0.0217499249,
-0.0118500497,
0.008197899,
-0.0260292534,
-0.0178021956,
-0.00775865,
-0.013620466,
-0.0330335833,
0.0934289694,
0.0492015071,
-0.0146215223,
-0.045827087,
-0.052177567,
0.0223601051,
-0.035474956,
0.0442582518,
0.0552312471,
-0.0262792967,
0.0379586406,
0.0435695499,
0.0764992535,
-0.0819420666,
0.0320734605,
0.000730743,
0.0804945305,
0.0310023259,
0.0172409173,
0.0056765503,
0.0343636312,
-0.0210581366,
-0.0348241739,
0.0011250305,
0.0180732999,
-0.0234110262,
-0.0175510049,
0.0294200554,
0.0117100868,
0.0186381675,
-0.0644123033,
-0.0153123653,
-0.0035600793,
-0.0187770892,
0.0562757365,
-0.0012198562,
0.0324807055,
0.0158067308,
0.06189676,
-0.0043753409,
0.0080197621,
-0.0106291231,
-0.0053959726,
-0.0110162571,
0.0129547687,
0.0658236668,
-0.0439571105,
-0.0211265013,
0.0230207685,
0.0195159893,
0.0106813507,
-0.0163646955,
-0.0070740539,
0.0686227307,
-0.0483500808,
-0.0077527445,
-0.0281258877,
0.0099326698,
0.0072684479,
-0.0044860407,
0.042874191,
-0.031225495,
0.0163953826,
0.059963204,
-0.0353380628,
-0.0177053306,
0.0107702827,
-0.0194649454,
0.0147315152,
0.0361815281,
-0.0052166292,
0.0127838124,
-0.0587914996,
-0.0208534393,
0.0374594443,
-0.0455692932,
-0.0213706624,
0.0031405003,
2.858e-7,
0.0120579675,
-0.0063762269,
0.0277399998,
-0.0161114503,
0.0122583229,
0.0210634079,
-0.0472747572,
-0.0054457611,
-0.0372745208,
0.0118375635,
-0.0027233001,
0.0486731604,
0.0693890601,
0.0123166274,
-0.0233415905,
-0.0107697239,
-0.0398041867,
0.0528137162,
-0.0087263891,
-0.0123825436,
-0.0404199809,
0.0749791786,
0.0058503137,
-0.0231361706,
0.0067653051,
0.0118862968,
0.0422098525,
-0.0103389546,
-0.0057979063,
-0.0430707075,
-0.0093362238,
0.0403602384,
-0.0306751933,
-0.0122346198,
-0.0223063678,
0.0073542986,
0.0194166489,
0.042533949,
-0.007543148,
-0.0513931289,
0.0234971419,
0.0096832365,
-0.0200389549,
0.0257346351,
0.0366903767,
-0.0173449814,
-0.019973414,
-0.0275327228,
-0.068417713,
-0.0110685471,
0.086438477,
-0.0179175287,
0.0156707633,
0.0001653013,
0.0120057799,
-0.0104173031,
-0.0487441942,
-0.0565988235,
0.0016109298,
-0.019254161,
-0.0093270969,
0.0217875093,
-0.0291063134,
0.0201383401,
0.0340674408,
0.0098690502,
-0.0121385502,
1.908853478e-34,
0.0181093551,
-0.0178424641,
0.0095317177,
-0.0135465395,
-0.0429166667,
-0.0377480313,
-0.000583911,
0.0003057022,
-0.0238514654,
0.01281795,
-0.0278520007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05463v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05463v1 | Textbooks Are All You Need II: phi-1.5 technical report | 2023-09-11T14:01:45 | 2023-09-11T14:01:45 | Yuanzhi Li, Sébastien Bubeck, Ronen Eldan, Allie Del Giorno, Suriya Gunasekar, Yin Tat Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We continue the investigation into the power of smaller Transformer-based
language models as initiated by \textbf{TinyStories} -- a 10 million parameter
model that can produce coherent English -- and the follow-up work on
\textbf{phi-1}, a 1.3 billion parameter model with Python coding performance
close to the state-of-the-art. The latter work proposed to use existing Large
Language Models (LLMs) to generate ``textbook quality" data as a way to enhance
the learning process compared to traditional web data. We follow the
``Textbooks Are All You Need" approach, focusing this time on common sense
reasoning in natural language, and create a new 1.3 billion parameter model
named \textbf{phi-1.5}, with performance on natural language tasks comparable
to models 5x larger, and surpassing most non-frontier LLMs on more complex
reasoning tasks such as grade-school mathematics and basic coding. More
generally, \textbf{phi-1.5} exhibits many of the traits of much larger LLMs,
both good -- such as the ability to ``think step by step" or perform some
rudimentary in-context learning -- and bad, including hallucinations and the
potential for toxic and biased generations -- encouragingly though, we are
seeing improvement on that front thanks to the absence of web data. We
open-source \textbf{phi-1.5} to promote further research on these urgent
topics. | [
0.0347322114,
0.0106614111,
-0.0262171067,
0.0255894922,
-0.0336461216,
0.0134732565,
0.0111505212,
-0.0011833624,
0.0049682581,
-0.0558684766,
-0.0153563311,
-0.0253358707,
-0.008204978,
0.0016642864,
0.0327019691,
-0.0616402328,
0.0551295057,
-0.0503582396,
-0.0290232413,
-0.0253137797,
-0.0439703502,
-0.0181264337,
-0.0042246305,
0.0366008431,
0.0233766697,
-0.0380594805,
-0.0215056334,
-0.0267458577,
-0.0116831791,
0.0082900263,
-0.0017060624,
0.0306316689,
0.0258407611,
0.0431347378,
0.0000023787,
-0.0504399277,
0.0041354648,
-0.0129064657,
-0.03661507,
0.0022850609,
0.02817408,
0.0326533839,
-0.0141326394,
0.0098915016,
-0.0405115634,
-0.0132384235,
0.0490835719,
0.0397397429,
0.0431257933,
0.0495683514,
0.0056459396,
-0.0828944072,
0.0574155636,
0.0235316698,
0.0838572606,
0.0182291772,
0.0375676677,
0.0534262918,
0.0524031632,
0.0289801769,
-0.040022701,
0.0303526185,
0.0437711254,
-0.0149345109,
-0.0042633591,
0.0418222956,
-0.0124502052,
-0.0542125814,
0.0065863002,
0.0385774113,
-0.0215640254,
-0.0607604422,
-0.0223763771,
0.029573828,
-0.0114362957,
0.0198919792,
-0.0771429464,
0.0903277844,
-0.0137480386,
0.0269337967,
0.0356650315,
-0.031243315,
0.0379218347,
0.0184312556,
-0.0272454936,
0.0693340823,
-0.0008159205,
-0.032975845,
-0.001201642,
0.0158006158,
-0.040671587,
-0.0300272442,
0.0003942888,
0.0348345563,
0.0026556,
0.0147064859,
-0.032860402,
-0.0127315996,
0.0254910029,
-0.0541111305,
-0.0041334308,
0.0375779606,
-0.0073058619,
0.0557780191,
-0.0098146033,
0.041968558,
-0.0201146398,
0.0525734499,
-0.0277538281,
0.0189627167,
-0.0539081395,
-0.005828117,
-0.019816041,
0.0507446416,
0.0014287876,
-0.01378504,
-0.0265302751,
0.0197968241,
-0.0014191722,
0.0114301732,
0.0173895247,
0.0151612069,
-0.0027195551,
-0.0175584592,
-0.0202192347,
0.0392793007,
-0.0047658398,
0.0139497519,
-0.0107811727,
-0.0572767667,
0.0050553023,
0.0027565949,
0.0025059266,
-0.0195941944,
0.0188225359,
0.041093085,
0.0130786067,
-0.0122774187,
-0.0707144961,
-0.02611495,
-0.0022543713,
-0.0543330833,
0.0030548852,
-0.0906136408,
-0.0001456153,
0.0385686383,
0.0307373255,
-0.0528548658,
0.0086762514,
0.0169445947,
-0.0406824797,
0.0506437235,
-0.0172914267,
0.0194699932,
0.0046959063,
0.0142553635,
-0.0191007927,
0.0497046895,
0.0441664197,
-0.0264052507,
0.0127886059,
-0.0435775407,
-0.0078742867,
0.0156440642,
-0.0106096053,
-0.0224879216,
-0.0046587992,
-0.0162499249,
0.0261698253,
0.0348466225,
-0.0246167891,
0.076896362,
-0.0321488269,
-0.0157625116,
0.0802505314,
0.0545784198,
0.0153880725,
0.0390365683,
0.0388169102,
0.0306034107,
0.0478077754,
0.0147583103,
-0.0435778312,
0.0187665485,
-0.052006118,
0.0075416989,
-0.0078182854,
0.0170547813,
-0.0110770594,
-0.0443405882,
-0.0105451606,
0.0134718111,
-0.0056189424,
0.0155322189,
0.0452905111,
0.0110233976,
-0.0127977272,
0.0625849217,
0.0546166599,
-0.0642394051,
0.0267615002,
-0.0390316285,
0.0623510033,
0.0418020003,
0.0443849564,
-0.030634962,
-0.0226869378,
-0.0162305906,
0.0224196315,
0.0628122315,
0.0283803325,
-0.0096538905,
-0.018647885,
-0.0614779592,
0.0035382712,
-0.0117161274,
0.00310749,
-0.0461954363,
0.0061550783,
-0.0190717373,
-0.0025963106,
-0.0133007299,
-0.0492809415,
0.0163987409,
-0.0704025179,
-0.0273903534,
-0.0573779345,
0.0038365014,
0.0041386532,
-0.0071525616,
0.0033741465,
0.0211617164,
0.0449607745,
-0.0278569125,
0.0054997378,
-0.0113947308,
-0.0549025387,
-0.0190422777,
0.0437335968,
-0.0273937862,
0.030084243,
0.0263968855,
-0.0024699185,
-0.0205272771,
-0.0095777195,
-0.0678800121,
0.0812991709,
0.0034485038,
0.0668358803,
-0.0280813221,
-0.0052972049,
-0.0120167527,
0.0730719939,
-0.0052520726,
0.03248851,
-0.0050863158,
-0.0047107944,
-0.0018661155,
-0.0312410258,
-0.0450942926,
0.0007109924,
-0.0128513919,
0.0344113745,
0.0047482788,
-0.0119015621,
-0.0668849424,
-0.0138428342,
-0.0216468908,
-0.0058935895,
-0.0002294243,
-0.0092527373,
-0.0013084617,
-0.0159502551,
0.0083726216,
0.0193268526,
-0.0165452044,
0.0250231139,
0.0011556436,
0.0370920561,
-0.0058896784,
-0.0069711837,
-0.0310646724,
-0.0225023665,
-0.0379995331,
-0.0420962125,
0.050200928,
0.0303100385,
0.0108075766,
-0.0642693117,
0.0738483518,
-0.0116838468,
0.0050058323,
-0.0050635347,
-0.0329436176,
0.0401290134,
-0.0336759686,
0.1131155491,
0.0802549124,
0.0145743443,
0.0336399004,
0.0576974414,
-0.0114941327,
-0.0557535402,
-0.0010310044,
-0.0350609981,
-0.0544429272,
-0.0482363105,
-0.0372964069,
-0.0431427211,
0.0571667999,
-0.0102734081,
-0.0186861902,
-0.101483196,
0.0685278028,
-0.0142017426,
-0.0162014514,
-0.0360043757,
-0.0104512637,
-0.0089561427,
0.0137245748,
-0.0181955732,
-0.0253705792,
0.0585379712,
0.0004529773,
0.0114348959,
-0.0467260219,
0.0022284433,
-0.0050019408,
0.0536062308,
0.0239651017,
0.0033467982,
0.0311930496,
-0.0017695659,
-0.0767904222,
0.0397997051,
0.0222277567,
-0.0495341979,
0.054538548,
-0.0446969308,
-0.0167935397,
0.0083988486,
-0.0367470384,
-0.0421092808,
0.0075064055,
-0.0287962183,
0.0004651178,
0.0070236172,
-0.0096240854,
-0.078972742,
0.0024993045,
0.0691852719,
0.0252627283,
-0.003960574,
-0.035330072,
-0.0007938522,
0.0025329902,
0.0420602486,
-0.0065305578,
0.0566968508,
-0.0645378828,
0.047829099,
0.088280797,
0.0284678657,
-0.0088097975,
-0.0098039946,
0.0212033913,
0.034647312,
-0.0214810092,
-0.0414467677,
0.0379467458,
0.0006548048,
-0.104022108,
-0.022594206,
0.1158506945,
0.018041512,
-0.0297173783,
0.0181045085,
-0.0553314053,
0.0002086341,
0.0160843544,
-0.0070028557,
-0.0594364889,
-0.0144484695,
-0.0021891606,
0.0147790648,
-0.0000757685,
-0.0447857864,
0.0243330654,
-0.10067375,
0.0106167691,
0.0303931907,
0.0324551351,
-0.0095713884,
-0.0440186858,
-0.0359727107,
-0.0161511078,
-0.0057564024,
0.0398727469,
-0.0299782455,
-0.0023428327,
0.0126237366,
0.0201443806,
-0.0240872949,
0.047756888,
-0.0332990065,
0.0390076339,
-0.0160112903,
0.0212609395,
-0.0332081653,
-0.0880259573,
-0.0256418381,
-0.0053365179,
-0.010030522,
0.0008094772,
0.0199313834,
0.0228461586,
-0.002870834,
-0.0398278981,
0.0269130636,
-0.0291325562,
-0.0422973558,
-0.0110795023,
0.1134698093,
-0.0108137289,
-0.0407629795,
-0.016254453,
0.0194405485,
-0.036785949,
0.1074051708,
0.0094838031,
-0.0427508391,
-0.0159910228,
-0.0283918399,
-0.0284642596,
0.0063624801,
-0.0835386291,
0.0433955044,
0.0313493349,
-0.0321268886,
-0.0552076213,
-0.0024047079,
0.032943245,
0.0265396759,
0.0149300937,
-0.0186053663,
0.0323363133,
-0.0002938279,
-0.0396299399,
0.0281531885,
-0.0349882282,
-0.0216090195,
-0.1089643389,
-0.011980135,
0.0436575413,
-0.0326599665,
-0.0110257557,
-0.0103918249,
-0.0561197698,
-0.0728113651,
0.0589095578,
0.0528999195,
0.0329739749,
0.0124352491,
0.0370813608,
-0.0487482995,
0.0377050228,
0.0178370457,
-0.0486996174,
0.0225442182,
0.0114696808,
-0.0091404105,
0.0218595788,
0.035984043,
-0.0442367196,
-0.0099998098,
-0.0069766515,
0.0502531268,
-0.028034972,
-0.0098352088,
0.044460278,
0.0055427626,
0.0281485952,
0.0063904691,
-0.0104233259,
-0.0064051868,
0.0334905721,
-0.0405893028,
-0.0035282876,
-0.0190911777,
-0.0169832185,
0.0396224298,
0.0035884429,
-0.0037392846,
0.0222517196,
0.0213337932,
0.0520468988,
0.0108772032,
0.0299402326,
0.0181967784,
0.0048020859,
0.0691785887,
-0.0196100753,
-0.0281774253,
-0.0135818366,
-0.004105737,
0.0597036667,
-0.0004024746,
0.0767268911,
0.0151595753,
-0.0078588538,
-0.0200744607,
-0.0006973504,
-0.0609223768,
-0.0977095291,
-0.0037476663,
-0.0052774823,
0.0280491952,
0.0082384143,
0.0413241051,
-0.0725002438,
-0.0023715822,
-0.0289637353,
0.0265790131,
0.023216594,
-0.0515817255,
0.0162432641,
0.0396218859,
0.0054498566,
0.0176822841,
0.0649490356,
-0.0148571888,
0.0559096001,
0.0072426777,
0.0125241047,
-0.0201505441,
-0.0203676783,
-0.0240273569,
0.0157417804,
0.0043485984,
0.0100496383,
-0.070225738,
-0.0548168495,
0.0016171312,
0.0269197747,
-0.0039069569,
-0.0390839241,
0.0458444357,
0.0386341847,
-0.0226329453,
-0.0396581851,
-0.011137085,
0.053152144,
-0.0220487323,
-0.0111551704,
-0.0310184322,
-6.831295054e-33,
-0.0037252144,
-0.0207695756,
0.0410836749,
0.0118646389,
0.0030238305,
-0.0322672054,
-0.0424037911,
0.0193628296,
-0.0388263986,
0.0104179597,
-0.0040079728,
0.0241554603,
0.0020298671,
0.0344597064,
0.0166159887,
-0.0013269612,
0.04831101,
0.0094157262,
-0.0002593489,
0.0253959093,
0.053689871,
-0.0047053602,
0.0700865537,
-0.0202678777,
-0.0023000601,
-0.0177885313,
0.0194940921,
0.0200633127,
-0.0358530954,
0.0604624152,
-0.0226937477,
0.0696123093,
0.0111931888,
-0.0436008759,
0.0033982666,
0.0000714949,
-0.056575276,
-0.0099828849,
0.0063745957,
0.003012649,
-0.0194969233,
-0.0474750772,
0.0585873276,
-0.0015380328,
-0.0181873646,
-0.0411966406,
0.0310977716,
-0.0372477882,
-0.0298129991,
0.0071527022,
-0.0804363936,
-0.003714459,
-0.0041828007,
-0.0017579482,
-0.0014455202,
0.0403669402,
-0.0211576521,
0.0074942703,
-0.0426131524,
0.0589423962,
0.0356141701,
0.034974765,
0.0582810007,
-0.0309692901,
0.0282943919,
0.0524617285,
0.0556646027,
0.0018051788,
-0.0240352005,
-0.0235134568,
0.0521739088,
0.0574532151,
0.0596296228,
0.0478646457,
-0.0010086884,
-0.0098343408,
-0.0656371862,
-0.0070155454,
0.0228974354,
0.0751565695,
0.0140048806,
-0.0136747202,
-0.0556078888,
-0.036231339,
-0.0279596485,
0.0206655692,
-0.0185334403,
-0.0159361064,
0.0051684612,
-0.029270025,
-0.0323992707,
-0.0227305535,
0.0227005482,
-0.0646276027,
-0.0055152457,
0.0277995542,
-0.0105392793,
0.0322917104,
-0.0332973041,
0.0212881342,
-0.0527295284,
-0.0412582718,
0.0126597257,
-0.0214038733,
0.0180023555,
0.0541082621,
0.0168704167,
0.055666998,
-0.0310264602,
-0.0169650279,
-0.0370764956,
-0.0314623415,
0.038188193,
0.0005332278,
0.0538809635,
0.0277902,
0.0024254813,
0.0245470554,
0.0122782942,
-0.0062631802,
-0.0306650009,
-0.0229600612,
-0.0071701845,
0.0082713636,
-0.0143403392,
-0.0264198929,
-0.0774320588,
0.0260463357,
0.0584979653,
-0.061409492,
-0.0142875789,
0.0330174379,
3.092e-7,
0.0115072168,
0.0795777664,
-0.004425555,
-0.0191101637,
0.0115333237,
0.0350605734,
0.0051597869,
-0.0371405594,
0.026721932,
-0.0317141786,
-0.0314017944,
0.026328709,
0.0439582393,
0.0400537103,
-0.0863447338,
-0.0232929178,
-0.0459402911,
0.0039482624,
-0.0468236059,
0.0002364757,
0.0523378365,
0.0716670081,
0.0244108234,
-0.0171345938,
0.0113572832,
-0.0264718197,
0.0366344377,
-0.0315833017,
0.0205058195,
0.0228224769,
0.0013370186,
0.0232412051,
0.0095934579,
0.0081331721,
0.0022955278,
0.0049515646,
-0.043913044,
0.0527491346,
0.0010903452,
-0.0033599993,
-0.0080430433,
-0.0579599962,
-0.0114346491,
-0.095536232,
0.0698881522,
-0.0602426678,
-0.0369952135,
0.0516446792,
-0.037861608,
-0.0044040028,
-0.0416728184,
-0.0179402642,
-0.0267378818,
-0.0213045888,
-0.0015884986,
-0.0023471422,
0.0161038842,
-0.0533238798,
-0.0071198796,
0.0286282171,
-0.0450457856,
-0.069065772,
-0.031006813,
-0.0179730859,
0.0170545746,
-0.0575909205,
0.0098113148,
2.976983754e-34,
0.020473415,
-0.0316244401,
0.061280366,
-0.0016370919,
-0.0013867167,
-0.0054630097,
0.0389038846,
0.0002441203,
0.035536088,
-0.0943450183,
-0.0392256565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05454v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05454v2 | Flesch or Fumble? Evaluating Readability Standard Alignment of Instruction-Tuned Language Models | 2023-09-11T13:50:38 | 2023-11-03T21:23:06 | Joseph Marvin Imperial, Harish Tayyar Madabushi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Readability metrics and standards such as Flesch Kincaid Grade Level (FKGL)
and the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR) exist to
guide teachers and educators to properly assess the complexity of educational
materials before administering them for classroom use. In this study, we select
a diverse set of open and closed-source instruction-tuned language models and
investigate their performances in writing story completions and simplifying
narratives--tasks that teachers perform--using standard-guided prompts
controlling text readability. Our extensive findings provide empirical proof of
how globally recognized models like ChatGPT may be considered less effective
and may require more refined prompts for these generative tasks compared to
other open-sourced models such as BLOOMZ and FlanT5--which have shown promising
results. | [
0.0117692025,
-0.0252304841,
-0.0335348584,
-0.0044673076,
-0.0685452819,
-0.0204839334,
0.0415949076,
-0.0181640591,
0.0216415599,
-0.0161635391,
-0.0059449659,
-0.0184930023,
0.0468811989,
0.0569971353,
0.0058474126,
-0.0649355948,
0.0415796526,
-0.0051761838,
0.0216201507,
0.0205863174,
0.012595823,
0.0208850894,
-0.0321586803,
0.0727643445,
0.0433668084,
-0.0572653003,
-0.0084882556,
0.0110038649,
-0.0043950258,
0.0216466412,
0.0279278029,
0.0757332146,
-0.0266735908,
0.0161467697,
0.0000021915,
-0.0283012222,
-0.0283707306,
-0.0256141406,
0.018583199,
0.0861798897,
0.096390456,
0.0287880916,
-0.0301043857,
0.0196922366,
0.0197214279,
-0.0041202991,
0.0518605895,
0.0055132131,
0.0120863887,
0.0378287993,
0.0074042669,
-0.0118116559,
0.047428444,
0.0097033139,
0.0104134632,
0.0124995913,
-0.0247542877,
0.0314717442,
0.0587995164,
0.0049751317,
-0.0488782972,
0.035344772,
0.007470903,
-0.0326735117,
-0.0056113498,
0.0285891034,
0.0080955094,
-0.0129014524,
-0.006347992,
0.0459073223,
0.001098076,
-0.0490443781,
0.003766773,
-0.0233093202,
0.0077814213,
0.0346501842,
-0.0499962531,
0.0180774666,
-0.0189880263,
0.0127297025,
0.0192721114,
-0.0078763179,
-0.0136426007,
-0.0110974461,
0.0749503747,
-0.0046711783,
0.0293933302,
-0.0324962884,
-0.021473147,
0.0313714929,
0.0035759071,
-0.0519149043,
0.0411728993,
0.0202561803,
0.0064561968,
0.012582751,
-0.0614124611,
0.0009063371,
0.0155041264,
-0.0115382373,
0.0299863666,
0.0847532153,
0.0068255551,
-0.0102554597,
-0.0144975726,
0.0796996728,
0.0393940918,
0.0139548043,
-0.0563115031,
0.0618573949,
-0.0336934589,
-0.0056025647,
-0.0440838374,
-0.0060985982,
-0.0562052876,
-0.039039094,
-0.0508523211,
-0.0051332405,
0.0345773138,
-0.0118546309,
-0.0044995323,
-0.0278758164,
-0.02490885,
0.0244266484,
0.0227651633,
0.0634939298,
-0.0223211702,
-0.0085028624,
0.0117590455,
-0.0406385101,
0.0054270779,
-0.0010737749,
-0.001995062,
-0.0087536015,
-0.0181875862,
-0.0002227844,
-0.0408872925,
-0.0158204138,
-0.0332976766,
-0.0204613488,
0.0000926921,
-0.0313600637,
-0.0415742397,
-0.070206821,
-0.0035699033,
-0.012299018,
0.0304446407,
-0.03068389,
-0.0208845716,
0.0284962393,
-0.0104776407,
-0.0299928859,
0.0003760121,
0.0319168195,
0.0184676126,
0.0250685643,
-0.0036552362,
0.0293132216,
0.0527383611,
0.007023531,
0.0339502841,
-0.0586625971,
0.0409061834,
0.0251721293,
-0.0238990188,
-0.0134285083,
0.0279674605,
-0.0590276569,
0.0046122894,
0.0433447137,
-0.0062735179,
0.058267504,
-0.0304637309,
0.0275805239,
0.0953178778,
0.0549133755,
0.0502976142,
0.0131048132,
0.0444584191,
0.0119558806,
0.0614333823,
0.070425503,
-0.022562271,
-0.005443004,
-0.0345205627,
0.040715348,
0.0134190591,
0.0333817527,
0.0026549015,
-0.0675266385,
-0.006480936,
0.0212162007,
0.0230214354,
-0.0434031859,
0.0172175914,
-0.0057971813,
-0.0748884305,
-0.0336057283,
0.0280945431,
-0.1023263857,
0.0331166461,
-0.0097067086,
0.0372884907,
0.1080800518,
0.0703375489,
-0.0099350177,
-0.0452370793,
0.0049265032,
0.0244399682,
0.035475228,
0.0123724323,
0.0176212527,
0.0199099388,
-0.0523296855,
-0.007611949,
-0.0161858238,
0.0181044303,
-0.0080743982,
-0.0044751833,
0.0097784372,
0.0028613405,
-0.0298248976,
-0.072532542,
0.0382522121,
-0.1097180769,
-0.0186173506,
-0.0547063872,
-0.012897362,
-0.0171395093,
0.0263107009,
-0.0134640737,
0.0127138197,
-0.0219869651,
0.01392275,
0.0410514325,
-0.0090583321,
-0.062019147,
-0.0152353374,
0.0141527122,
-0.0588592179,
0.032571014,
-0.0091965264,
0.030158814,
-0.0283429418,
0.0280412212,
-0.031033922,
0.0501406267,
-0.0054070484,
0.0350062698,
-0.0451895855,
-0.0496021174,
-0.0339888372,
-0.0150235388,
0.0086480593,
0.036720179,
-0.017795857,
0.0113682458,
-0.0060791331,
0.0056930371,
-0.0317862444,
0.0339162797,
-0.0015865269,
0.0150332022,
0.0097641777,
0.0296511091,
-0.0412550159,
-0.0576714277,
-0.0673792958,
-0.0101715839,
0.0068031973,
-0.0046666735,
0.0268521383,
-0.0335358828,
-0.0506142788,
0.0653623864,
-0.0185386203,
-0.0350099094,
-0.0127128148,
-0.015340453,
0.0053265132,
-0.0172409359,
-0.0355076231,
-0.0678695813,
-0.0518539399,
-0.0091184797,
0.0404363312,
0.0671631172,
0.0195866637,
-0.0390843935,
0.0807481408,
0.0090803746,
-0.0368781425,
0.0139534334,
-0.0487208106,
0.0139977541,
0.0105138263,
0.0908672512,
0.0759508833,
-0.0159730539,
0.0121238502,
0.0233540908,
-0.0589515641,
-0.0410015211,
-0.0118894959,
-0.0162892528,
-0.0312026162,
0.0020019622,
-0.086778298,
-0.0139840348,
0.0744440556,
0.0437786281,
-0.0114109591,
-0.0851847753,
0.013379884,
-0.0554749146,
-0.0095856776,
-0.018377509,
-0.0455395989,
-0.0013630457,
0.0265615452,
-0.0307276063,
-0.0387559384,
0.0687886477,
-0.0573399216,
-0.0099610901,
-0.0491519757,
0.0204772074,
-0.0237697065,
0.0208349265,
0.0023152959,
0.0241155215,
0.0507431366,
-0.0220320821,
-0.0275090672,
0.0251903888,
0.0533546284,
-0.0123257414,
0.0288158692,
-0.0444021486,
-0.0426526219,
0.00264626,
0.013003584,
-0.0172582474,
0.0050489437,
0.0371314511,
-0.0104123242,
0.041392561,
-0.0318889096,
-0.0453569479,
0.0093237078,
0.0350999646,
0.0676791742,
-0.0492673293,
-0.0020924832,
-0.0202575382,
-0.0163800474,
0.0121079432,
-0.0585564412,
-0.000555972,
-0.0795782506,
0.0344900936,
0.025484927,
-0.0081621576,
-0.0134501429,
0.0281537138,
0.0069810362,
0.0519304499,
-0.0431142375,
-0.0432272889,
0.0071093338,
0.0588150769,
-0.0893193483,
-0.0045864182,
0.095231548,
0.0075553092,
-0.0058904481,
0.0056260619,
-0.0160660353,
0.073053278,
-0.0353109315,
0.013124845,
-0.0343560912,
0.0150686614,
0.033630643,
0.053645689,
-0.0325603485,
-0.0215190183,
-0.0135578336,
-0.0786005333,
0.0478834845,
0.0327370167,
-0.0263187792,
-0.0027891761,
-0.0128059816,
-0.015434511,
0.0152577814,
0.0185848642,
0.034640234,
-0.0243070833,
0.0443655774,
0.0129025578,
-0.0406588875,
-0.0296365637,
-0.0193576124,
0.0194230657,
0.0738545954,
0.0182982013,
-0.0101919975,
-0.0190620478,
-0.0357338823,
0.0253494047,
0.0274062566,
-0.0137525769,
-0.020966284,
0.016109962,
-0.0035946921,
0.0084711071,
-0.0511362813,
0.0454740599,
0.0167495478,
-0.0363761708,
0.0096157733,
0.0413239077,
0.0535075255,
-0.0271136984,
-0.0251336638,
0.0514400974,
0.0134672988,
0.0873954967,
0.0665242523,
-0.0582657196,
-0.0112703722,
-0.0666544363,
0.0207593124,
-0.0499345884,
-0.0583066903,
0.0121320002,
-0.0344751403,
-0.032848198,
-0.0502090938,
-0.0547757111,
0.0383610167,
0.0130445519,
0.0238309279,
0.0193807073,
0.0118116792,
-0.0276609343,
-0.0268458631,
0.0396616496,
0.0084700985,
0.0102242557,
-0.1253742427,
-0.0160182845,
-0.062895745,
-0.0538384281,
-0.0171741042,
0.0425818823,
-0.0317794606,
-0.0585143901,
0.02849783,
0.0266590957,
0.0240583215,
-0.0383154713,
0.0262631569,
-0.0438420512,
-0.017451724,
-0.0250226445,
-0.0244686417,
0.0582161658,
0.0098925931,
0.0001892176,
0.0353315212,
-0.01158226,
0.0237575788,
0.0238697603,
0.0148899229,
0.0590613857,
0.0482537821,
-0.0424923971,
-0.008182534,
0.0314427279,
0.0157773942,
-0.0334947519,
-0.0228172261,
-0.0826102048,
-0.0256155916,
-0.057957042,
0.0362794138,
-0.0458928905,
0.0034820521,
0.0196618661,
0.0044777552,
-0.0119302133,
-0.0116478018,
-0.0545478687,
0.0122031458,
-0.0465028957,
0.0495054796,
-0.0401832126,
0.0251793154,
0.0170236919,
0.0100184754,
-0.0458958745,
0.0140817063,
-0.0599584281,
0.0552713126,
0.0342285,
0.0567736663,
0.0148344534,
0.0251800045,
0.0138957081,
0.0161984414,
-0.0247683041,
0.0151990131,
-0.0378063209,
0.0229013264,
0.0155031886,
0.0098662088,
0.0567577854,
-0.0299717095,
0.0240833238,
-0.0363953039,
0.0104960371,
0.0510694049,
-0.0234351903,
-0.0414938405,
-0.0026370152,
0.0176503453,
-0.0460773893,
0.077147603,
0.0001741884,
0.0177192967,
-0.0078127654,
-0.0018403836,
-0.0124695236,
-0.0203744527,
-0.0006973266,
0.0303570926,
0.0098111471,
-0.0021304155,
-0.0993318707,
-0.0116800116,
0.0024708111,
0.0397587419,
-0.0186070986,
-0.0402898975,
-0.0016925711,
0.0127112381,
-0.0478500202,
-0.0184339285,
-0.0341031589,
-0.0013297343,
-0.0041832458,
-0.0405053236,
0.0129032787,
-6.139949724e-33,
-0.048907958,
0.0025937255,
0.0229727067,
0.0422217362,
-0.0321337506,
0.0219230969,
-0.0556989834,
0.0357879996,
0.0003488421,
0.0169620924,
0.0142059578,
-0.0169020966,
0.0017139293,
0.0148604624,
-0.0298393108,
0.0483341031,
0.03495593,
0.0243095737,
-0.0532603934,
0.0070582177,
0.0284169465,
-0.0016828898,
0.071693629,
-0.0153782992,
0.0579843484,
-0.0400836319,
-0.0161944218,
-0.0218771305,
-0.007311713,
0.0472467355,
-0.0144354999,
0.0410925969,
0.0141050955,
-0.034644641,
-0.0310663935,
0.0288945958,
-0.0194002725,
-0.0352213234,
0.0703422353,
-0.0178001504,
0.0085493568,
-0.0703400001,
0.0396050066,
-0.0162280481,
-0.0248025022,
-0.0400008485,
0.0271474179,
-0.0145890433,
-0.0059704692,
0.0237844363,
-0.0897058323,
0.0104611786,
-0.0369533375,
-0.0327517353,
-0.0048842765,
0.071177721,
0.004129827,
-0.0245420914,
-0.0002153037,
0.0424228609,
0.0767660215,
0.0633288026,
0.029240096,
-0.0008440033,
-0.011767691,
0.0555903874,
0.0469738282,
0.0354559384,
-0.07452555,
0.0177831389,
0.0634801909,
-0.0063373633,
0.060591571,
0.0487527847,
-0.0160871185,
-0.0214086547,
-0.0224027578,
0.0459150374,
0.0162857752,
-0.0272660684,
0.027565565,
-0.0068217921,
-0.0757196546,
-0.0642191991,
-0.0496670231,
0.0091276867,
-0.0075351563,
-0.0225824546,
0.046300903,
-0.0569756553,
0.0080266846,
-0.0577413775,
0.0096138511,
0.0053910282,
0.0164817944,
-0.0131706158,
-0.0437539518,
0.0628208891,
-0.0297891125,
0.0503284335,
-0.0383164808,
0.0002815793,
0.0222575944,
0.0058540455,
0.0068176012,
0.0201093629,
-0.024431942,
0.0117936917,
-0.0304147713,
0.0105071068,
-0.0334774181,
0.0319444686,
0.0309364665,
-0.0235343203,
0.025288349,
-0.0295934174,
-0.0017495265,
0.0313365981,
0.0242949277,
-0.034669254,
-0.0445561856,
-0.0305804648,
0.0114111314,
0.0035036576,
-0.0154869547,
-0.0007521621,
-0.014711109,
0.0179795567,
0.0240393914,
-0.0130797913,
-0.0085484022,
0.0055588698,
2.836e-7,
0.0368481129,
0.0412246026,
0.0190779455,
-0.0088421544,
-0.0071640536,
0.0093836905,
-0.0126359267,
-0.0095316805,
0.0463763252,
0.0240587071,
0.0026826258,
-0.0089695556,
0.0726123527,
0.0046766815,
-0.0419400632,
-0.003568813,
-0.0253765136,
0.0275177676,
-0.0470835268,
0.0193621814,
0.0669490695,
-0.0293093305,
0.0213783253,
0.0104144495,
0.0113284905,
-0.0141071947,
0.0104639195,
-0.0595954843,
-0.0150155537,
0.0476801097,
0.0326650441,
-0.0123228505,
0.031737797,
-0.0073899627,
-0.0038186742,
-0.0106229009,
0.0348457955,
0.0907587856,
0.015743617,
0.0345488414,
0.0340283178,
-0.0360048637,
-0.0600561574,
-0.0854827687,
0.0384345055,
0.0163270533,
0.0224247351,
0.0498525128,
-0.042351421,
-0.0125843678,
-0.0029855799,
-0.020380633,
-0.0261674616,
0.0229940917,
0.0027056092,
-0.0257723667,
0.0281097684,
0.0137869408,
-0.0349411927,
0.0114853578,
-0.0202957503,
-0.0263260361,
-0.0329080634,
-0.0115423249,
-0.0216055531,
-0.0582218133,
0.011582423,
2.838240064e-34,
0.0325371921,
-0.0444545336,
0.0524733178,
-0.0199816208,
0.0154000949,
0.0117215011,
0.0413863212,
-0.0009079162,
0.0225035939,
-0.0413680039,
-0.0481934957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05452v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05452v2 | Evaluating the Deductive Competence of Large Language Models | 2023-09-11T13:47:07 | 2024-04-15T13:01:30 | Spencer M. Seals, Valerie L. Shalin | cs.CL | cs.CL | The development of highly fluent large language models (LLMs) has prompted
increased interest in assessing their reasoning and problem-solving
capabilities. We investigate whether several LLMs can solve a classic type of
deductive reasoning problem from the cognitive science literature. The tested
LLMs have limited abilities to solve these problems in their conventional form.
We performed follow up experiments to investigate if changes to the
presentation format and content improve model performance. We do find
performance differences between conditions; however, they do not improve
overall performance. Moreover, we find that performance interacts with
presentation format and content in unexpected ways that differ from human
performance. Overall, our results suggest that LLMs have unique reasoning
biases that are only partially predicted from human reasoning performance and
the human-generated language corpora that informs them. | [
0.033296857,
0.0189861115,
-0.0293130986,
0.0578137375,
-0.0561128557,
0.0170550644,
0.0399491079,
-0.0243121907,
0.0226355065,
-0.0361530408,
0.0086509092,
0.0192049574,
-0.002365055,
0.0188512187,
0.0157144722,
-0.0368339084,
0.0231349487,
-0.0918175429,
0.0391498208,
-0.0466765426,
-0.0353913717,
-0.0053647365,
-0.0151766026,
-0.0071215848,
0.0301389731,
-0.0326795541,
0.0191902202,
-0.0283121467,
-0.0205346663,
-0.0284691919,
-0.025731666,
0.0501066521,
0.0273185875,
0.0188918076,
0.0000022421,
-0.0654326156,
0.0351232067,
-0.0173426401,
-0.0711766705,
0.0261283964,
0.013938196,
0.0108066835,
-0.0038418937,
0.0081254197,
-0.0409101844,
0.017284032,
0.0045355153,
0.0410936289,
0.0207405593,
0.0350570418,
0.0022593187,
-0.0444414914,
0.0300374795,
0.0055734171,
0.008508903,
-0.0250838846,
0.0388294905,
0.1148731932,
0.0374995917,
-0.0198604017,
0.0091807432,
0.0415101759,
0.0376134031,
0.0009060758,
-0.0452921875,
0.0163935497,
-0.0148111954,
-0.0216393378,
0.0322974958,
0.0393899679,
0.0062330165,
0.0025686661,
-0.0203328952,
0.0258844513,
0.0200503971,
0.0141841024,
-0.057995528,
0.0673102066,
-0.0074535534,
0.0033841159,
0.0539778955,
0.0061788643,
0.0412055999,
0.0283883736,
-0.0566491783,
0.0929071382,
0.0072982879,
-0.016090434,
0.0173387304,
0.0066404315,
-0.0343272276,
-0.0585882738,
0.0153124984,
0.0229698755,
-0.0306491926,
0.0362361148,
0.0129962284,
0.0161507204,
0.0167387892,
-0.0523400791,
0.0241104029,
0.0301024057,
0.0393659733,
0.0375514068,
-0.033995267,
0.0692982152,
-0.0269031022,
0.006128577,
-0.00329623,
-0.0144993449,
-0.0517904349,
-0.0321656428,
-0.011432929,
0.045652464,
0.0176313128,
-0.0043467185,
-0.0381429717,
0.0096815974,
0.0115312617,
0.0067803767,
0.0067628087,
-0.011716608,
-0.0250333939,
-0.052057229,
-0.0829655454,
0.0321535096,
-0.0311706197,
0.0338637978,
0.0038692036,
-0.0597536266,
0.0265458561,
-0.0050548855,
-0.0376004502,
-0.0437927917,
0.002361594,
0.0517586283,
-0.0103644719,
0.0131273456,
-0.0539159104,
-0.032873977,
-0.0065576937,
-0.0941921249,
0.0144134033,
-0.0685498267,
-0.0035294122,
0.0568615645,
0.0013185992,
-0.080732435,
0.0024192927,
-0.0035862024,
-0.0397776216,
0.0517690219,
0.0061645247,
0.0370968096,
0.0648810863,
0.0242617074,
-0.0199229158,
0.0665238202,
0.0306114554,
0.0200882684,
-0.0173027497,
-0.0124133565,
0.0232995693,
0.0150874481,
-0.0212431699,
-0.0019268517,
-0.0685453489,
0.0347409621,
0.0157890953,
0.0327084288,
0.035118185,
0.0456084982,
-0.0343939327,
-0.000349116,
0.081173189,
0.0243828315,
0.0000647236,
0.008829983,
0.0309702381,
-0.0025799086,
0.0168872215,
0.0275106616,
-0.0483231358,
0.0010974869,
-0.0273926891,
0.0072138626,
0.017757738,
0.0059043281,
-0.0189265404,
-0.0307905469,
-0.0026537685,
0.0120608751,
0.0082121864,
0.0307727996,
0.0320759118,
-0.0021138797,
-0.009265203,
0.0496241935,
0.022669835,
-0.0293186735,
-0.0139684258,
-0.0463790745,
0.0413877591,
0.0507400669,
0.0220089853,
0.0235423706,
-0.0184244774,
0.0035366437,
0.014437479,
0.0589732192,
0.0543135367,
0.0066867266,
-0.0258374289,
-0.0306144636,
-0.0160308164,
-0.0521476381,
0.0096955597,
0.019041324,
0.0024385124,
0.02035724,
0.0276969448,
-0.0531898327,
0.0000503561,
0.0071986574,
-0.0862844586,
-0.0016036831,
-0.054235328,
-0.0061547081,
0.0346408822,
-0.0146828238,
-0.0006178494,
0.0232917145,
0.0137421424,
-0.0396045186,
-0.0098566487,
0.0180026256,
-0.0608131886,
-0.0084104016,
0.0209713075,
-0.0302350931,
-0.0280165859,
-0.0050913114,
0.0131450705,
-0.0073985187,
0.0448831059,
-0.0232414436,
0.0194282327,
-0.0186719336,
0.0302810464,
-0.0126291402,
-0.0136242444,
-0.0210700464,
0.1134421378,
0.0261778012,
0.0236141793,
0.0049252124,
-0.0113086086,
0.0198845211,
-0.1087611318,
0.0196132623,
0.0338346511,
0.0207726639,
-0.0350976586,
-0.0007844794,
-0.0421161987,
-0.0419064909,
-0.0256021842,
-0.0664991885,
-0.0145081887,
0.0065610106,
0.0050476678,
-0.0000324694,
-0.0326935835,
-0.0212629866,
0.020030845,
-0.0360183008,
-0.037116915,
0.0365034789,
0.0369151793,
0.0034637298,
-0.0029262363,
-0.0570380874,
0.0095176501,
-0.0076608658,
-0.012995109,
0.0457768701,
0.0401056558,
0.011536533,
-0.0331896693,
0.0524057187,
-0.0363660492,
0.0071540517,
0.0047797025,
-0.0228699278,
0.0230949353,
0.0227806289,
0.025371803,
0.0918529555,
-0.0247915387,
0.0053590038,
0.0491946265,
-0.0495813489,
-0.0475872606,
-0.0007601904,
-0.0029108115,
0.0185846966,
-0.0792104825,
-0.0622239672,
-0.0643206313,
0.0324887596,
0.0204644036,
0.0225459673,
-0.0114472872,
0.0502517037,
-0.0302078798,
-0.0225693397,
-0.0217845608,
-0.0396651663,
0.0156047028,
0.0735962018,
-0.0169957317,
-0.0242502317,
0.0481039323,
-0.0068002027,
0.022235563,
-0.0331180021,
0.0275703631,
-0.0197218228,
0.0552047491,
-0.0239633359,
0.0164310038,
-0.0331633687,
-0.0178057607,
-0.0344998315,
-0.0320919789,
0.0110144485,
-0.0284118857,
0.0112446547,
-0.0715937614,
-0.000045269,
-0.0082798889,
-0.0453373902,
-0.0577094555,
0.0099454597,
-0.0679801032,
0.0519414507,
0.0111625418,
0.0047163027,
-0.0956608355,
0.0116593549,
0.0554920696,
-0.0415775925,
0.0025969034,
0.0005405311,
0.0057319356,
-0.019571403,
-0.0109958164,
0.0352296382,
0.011289401,
-0.0494157821,
0.0483238585,
0.0295081772,
-0.0054357396,
0.0053203441,
-0.0354302973,
0.0222429633,
0.0140794013,
-0.0135588693,
-0.0410813652,
0.0223825891,
0.023209624,
-0.0542937517,
0.0192090403,
0.1388511211,
0.0216516461,
-0.0137814162,
0.0207635388,
-0.0305263922,
0.0184595436,
0.0470236391,
0.026375927,
-0.0635476336,
-0.0334088057,
0.0281791445,
-0.0242737718,
-0.0183023885,
-0.0380187519,
-0.0049720742,
-0.1323788762,
0.0359376185,
0.0083571682,
0.0223769732,
-0.0009979096,
-0.0572513156,
-0.0034591886,
0.0017091717,
0.032638777,
0.007099295,
0.0043128394,
-0.0151175521,
0.0147878416,
-0.0071327402,
-0.0624994151,
0.0533757024,
-0.0031496491,
0.046400927,
0.0207810774,
0.0265834499,
-0.0161131173,
-0.0615963526,
0.0194641091,
0.0187685806,
0.0171756875,
0.0110254176,
0.0012587614,
0.0079385154,
0.013742147,
-0.0339207016,
0.0203702673,
-0.013336435,
-0.0483873822,
0.0312484503,
0.0666592121,
-0.0152778961,
-0.0257701222,
-0.0063256691,
0.0107752848,
-0.0385767743,
0.0864735246,
0.0154561205,
-0.0260328539,
-0.02631451,
-0.0304799173,
-0.0645750314,
0.0287023298,
-0.0383045413,
0.0429195128,
0.0180878378,
0.0167949684,
-0.0270034205,
-0.0133201983,
0.0354837775,
0.0242715534,
0.0121116703,
0.0331776626,
-0.0258460194,
0.0011026151,
0.0049514188,
0.0399377458,
-0.0469947234,
0.0333053172,
-0.0973514915,
0.0264153257,
-0.0062832898,
-0.0537399575,
-0.012692282,
-0.0147382515,
-0.0281593837,
-0.0699907988,
0.0285308678,
-0.0041239909,
0.0330327637,
-0.0035292085,
0.0032889231,
-0.0729342103,
0.0297349617,
-0.0133539978,
-0.0544517338,
0.0046908795,
0.0095038582,
0.0079811672,
0.0284695029,
0.0303977858,
0.006019643,
0.0297346916,
0.0334361456,
0.0350244083,
-0.0249805674,
-0.0353371836,
0.0254538525,
0.0523892939,
0.0147672128,
0.0223621968,
-0.0062354086,
-0.0155594079,
0.0161604006,
-0.0642339885,
-0.0343749933,
0.0002347733,
0.001010839,
0.0313896425,
0.0121213505,
0.0316788889,
-0.0268103871,
-0.0403862894,
-0.0036913583,
-0.013256602,
0.0342271961,
-0.0044283182,
-0.033068005,
0.01981874,
-0.0098736407,
-0.0034001339,
0.0391465686,
-0.034958642,
0.0475190952,
0.0137354173,
0.0763174817,
0.0092259729,
0.0052294135,
-0.0541907363,
-0.0364196338,
-0.0451948233,
-0.0656418279,
0.0622425675,
0.0359269008,
0.0494181626,
-0.0162885953,
0.0111417864,
-0.0736735538,
0.0242700744,
-0.0120524829,
-0.0248484537,
0.0397127047,
-0.0362037085,
0.0622813813,
0.0183588229,
-0.0251297448,
-0.0024670723,
0.0746116638,
0.0070268726,
0.014341956,
-0.0144945756,
-0.0156452246,
-0.0241337921,
-0.0435080379,
0.022328848,
0.0006399864,
-0.0110954354,
0.0266254898,
-0.0435342044,
-0.099221535,
-0.0202647466,
0.0060429303,
0.0088105686,
-0.0237885434,
-0.0005147007,
0.0602653958,
-0.0181452557,
-0.0587168038,
-0.0244853813,
0.0132544124,
-0.0181428157,
0.0082419943,
-0.0192668997,
-6.687318302e-33,
-0.0100275548,
-0.0299793091,
0.0449760146,
-0.0180127267,
0.0284688752,
-0.0480815545,
-0.0410722606,
0.0491165034,
-0.0311056077,
0.0351446234,
-0.016671123,
0.0006892014,
0.0208125599,
-0.0285765044,
-0.0267742854,
0.0489672869,
0.0083937608,
0.0337126479,
-0.0252783932,
-0.011002305,
0.0209137984,
-0.0385107361,
0.0070818625,
-0.0647850633,
0.0201098416,
-0.0410468727,
-0.004460379,
0.0305394754,
-0.0574026071,
0.0555901155,
-0.028076401,
0.006847118,
0.0284663979,
-0.0496706627,
-0.0115176253,
-0.0001392083,
-0.0029936072,
0.0083842762,
0.0781654045,
-0.0090534687,
0.0030017695,
-0.0685696825,
0.0132425074,
0.0044881799,
-0.0505242497,
-0.0009360957,
0.008997432,
-0.0502755195,
-0.0027434712,
0.0423438661,
-0.0513491109,
0.032170862,
-0.0303931329,
0.0113670034,
0.0116618006,
-0.0052600862,
-0.0380320102,
-0.0286695398,
-0.0235638656,
0.0360750519,
0.0427437462,
0.0005818232,
0.0923790783,
-0.0231105182,
0.0212012008,
0.0445254371,
0.0317892805,
0.0403778963,
-0.006193181,
-0.0097106975,
0.0064644562,
0.0659742653,
0.0467875786,
0.0044350754,
0.0095099034,
-0.0000808681,
-0.0615561791,
-0.0221044179,
-0.0196406282,
0.0637203828,
0.0806567073,
0.011021331,
-0.0200819392,
-0.0409567282,
-0.0712933615,
0.0620463677,
-0.0250439048,
-0.0153641663,
0.0358933322,
-0.0361383297,
0.0044310773,
-0.040613886,
0.0469819456,
-0.0273819324,
-0.0334643871,
0.0333607905,
-0.0127385352,
0.0046601985,
-0.0116426144,
0.0325410105,
-0.0763995796,
-0.0289331023,
-0.0182233807,
0.0359083526,
0.008584504,
0.0098685455,
-0.0095463237,
-0.0307608172,
-0.0195020027,
-0.0248356871,
-0.0373923704,
-0.0009554992,
0.0325436667,
0.0170030985,
0.0595451221,
-0.0069131083,
-0.0213332865,
-0.0301115476,
-0.0073852441,
-0.0521736778,
-0.019059917,
0.0296574198,
-0.0136922263,
0.0248351935,
-0.0293173846,
-0.0189399607,
-0.0232059453,
0.0101380907,
0.0286475047,
0.0024355927,
-0.0184348822,
0.0136486506,
2.918e-7,
0.0271917135,
0.0673757941,
-0.0138065936,
0.04717407,
0.0196643304,
0.0191587061,
-0.0531717427,
-0.0527309328,
0.0723625496,
-0.0276518669,
-0.0279250629,
0.0787592083,
0.0496857166,
0.054959707,
-0.0380552448,
-0.0091672204,
-0.0134644862,
0.0041926997,
-0.0771605298,
0.0273605064,
0.020609051,
0.0330157615,
0.0051836008,
-0.0055907038,
0.008472885,
-0.0733596087,
0.0455517322,
-0.0279066488,
0.0033863951,
-0.0007311669,
0.0421337411,
0.0108208293,
0.0293306634,
0.1000969782,
0.0381259434,
0.0067613004,
-0.002616724,
0.079012081,
0.0001786611,
0.0160053968,
-0.0204158947,
-0.0320582725,
0.0001739688,
-0.067129679,
0.0583061911,
-0.0702290386,
-0.0855330378,
0.0448318832,
-0.0019826926,
-0.0518069714,
0.0143161761,
-0.0104691489,
-0.0006301196,
-0.0003877339,
0.023258999,
-0.0231079981,
-0.0171250254,
-0.0342646837,
-0.0218430068,
-0.0081405956,
-0.0601927415,
-0.0647677928,
-0.0118228095,
-0.0073476215,
0.0429265462,
-0.0130383968,
0.0209622029,
2.571695572e-34,
0.0535521433,
0.0244482923,
0.0157261882,
-0.0054825027,
0.0914497003,
-0.0013076003,
0.0257910695,
0.0213789549,
0.0107583031,
-0.1214761436,
0.0043759993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05448v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05448v2 | Panoptic Vision-Language Feature Fields | 2023-09-11T13:41:27 | 2024-01-18T08:33:35 | Haoran Chen, Kenneth Blomqvist, Francesco Milano, Roland Siegwart | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recently, methods have been proposed for 3D open-vocabulary semantic
segmentation. Such methods are able to segment scenes into arbitrary classes
based on text descriptions provided during runtime. In this paper, we propose
to the best of our knowledge the first algorithm for open-vocabulary panoptic
segmentation in 3D scenes. Our algorithm, Panoptic Vision-Language Feature
Fields (PVLFF), learns a semantic feature field of the scene by distilling
vision-language features from a pretrained 2D model, and jointly fits an
instance feature field through contrastive learning using 2D instance segments
on input frames. Despite not being trained on the target classes, our method
achieves panoptic segmentation performance similar to the state-of-the-art
closed-set 3D systems on the HyperSim, ScanNet and Replica dataset and
additionally outperforms current 3D open-vocabulary systems in terms of
semantic segmentation. We ablate the components of our method to demonstrate
the effectiveness of our model architecture. Our code will be available at
https://github.com/ethz-asl/pvlff. | [
-0.0027761136,
0.0113042295,
0.0681720674,
0.0789521784,
-0.0368576013,
0.0174641125,
0.0062763998,
-0.0152621195,
-0.0752441511,
-0.0629473552,
-0.0073882472,
-0.0049547097,
0.0167212915,
0.0665675327,
-0.0281535406,
-0.1046778783,
-0.0177136045,
-0.0503625721,
-0.0292168073,
0.0016121389,
-0.0004120898,
0.0203585364,
-0.0308180526,
-0.0431698412,
-0.0017024449,
0.0107605513,
-0.0216346215,
-0.0034331451,
0.0196612831,
-0.043322973,
0.0355395712,
0.0297434442,
0.0535300113,
-0.026605593,
0.000002096,
-0.0542933233,
-0.0193271022,
-0.008500577,
0.0397470854,
-0.0145827224,
0.0527819209,
0.0181890726,
-0.0051077595,
-0.055943314,
0.0043372354,
-0.0227544345,
0.0619902797,
0.0781363994,
0.0454449244,
0.0021037126,
-0.0267317854,
-0.0673254579,
0.0300677642,
0.0192043167,
0.0422772914,
0.026957849,
0.0015251008,
-0.0189756826,
-0.0273626316,
0.0071345791,
-0.0075679123,
0.0113888672,
0.017415408,
0.0310948789,
0.0358712412,
0.0213173162,
-0.0660718232,
-0.054473225,
-0.016648734,
0.0826408267,
-0.0202219523,
-0.0001621511,
-0.0258702207,
-0.0242089443,
-0.0298181716,
-0.0167012662,
-0.0293520018,
0.0425138511,
-0.0244796146,
-0.0053733853,
0.0048353248,
0.0575676858,
0.0017165224,
-0.0055303625,
-0.0375240222,
-0.0039331531,
0.0482946895,
0.0008161114,
0.0075128353,
-0.0256412867,
-0.0005033897,
-0.0184800345,
0.0145364618,
0.0053902054,
0.0428097434,
0.0074555809,
-0.0060831476,
-0.0081112823,
-0.0265404209,
-0.0227002129,
-0.0039987806,
-0.0040404736,
-0.0619186237,
0.0584290624,
-0.0220166314,
0.0172944367,
-0.0154574774,
0.0711524636,
-0.0235636365,
-0.0190713927,
0.0241816603,
-0.0027283179,
-0.0430886745,
0.0121625336,
-0.0083785458,
-0.006354223,
-0.0180669632,
-0.02050828,
-0.0145705501,
0.0399931893,
0.0168929193,
0.0370824486,
-0.0036911373,
-0.0277373325,
0.0054952162,
-0.0100616533,
-0.0314070433,
-0.0134776076,
-0.0339258164,
-0.0329020172,
0.0308566224,
0.0563391298,
0.0147832762,
-0.0035946164,
0.0265796222,
0.0965932086,
-0.0282585267,
-0.0658425987,
-0.0247060247,
-0.0149642918,
-0.0311097056,
-0.0086619286,
0.0612913147,
-0.0581693649,
-0.0298911147,
-0.0186348706,
0.0193541162,
0.004448724,
-0.0133446511,
-0.0057196668,
0.0080558099,
0.0832766145,
-0.0541666783,
-0.022639202,
0.026726028,
0.0187534839,
0.0617282055,
0.0569598749,
0.0376201645,
0.0141974632,
0.0218075886,
0.0281772614,
0.0442321375,
0.0643095896,
-0.0388123319,
0.012110238,
-0.0985455215,
-0.0418727621,
0.0276027434,
0.0299215429,
0.001942502,
-0.0022333688,
-0.007046015,
-0.0557448231,
0.0084957574,
0.0526670404,
-0.0104132975,
0.0284018591,
0.0430371091,
-0.0048959185,
-0.020871887,
-0.0039894376,
0.0159125533,
0.0177085344,
0.0329778567,
-0.0046189441,
-0.0139859123,
0.0165062062,
-0.0445669405,
-0.0704762563,
-0.0000081228,
-0.0230452921,
-0.0209737327,
-0.0210134014,
0.1043738872,
0.0358725786,
-0.0103748366,
0.0668164119,
0.0447912328,
-0.046557758,
-0.0168288611,
-0.0135208368,
0.0494839475,
0.0519774817,
-0.0029466748,
-0.0716856793,
-0.0094760591,
0.0101397941,
0.0203164164,
0.0488074385,
0.012226888,
-0.0048025982,
0.0389589667,
-0.057404317,
-0.0299863201,
-0.0101232529,
-0.022316806,
0.0359041169,
0.027812764,
-0.0285640117,
0.0214416832,
-0.0423692949,
0.0107734706,
0.0488492846,
-0.0248582214,
0.0146498801,
-0.0435038656,
0.0107090659,
-0.0051627452,
0.0050670984,
-0.0099820448,
-0.0618198328,
-0.0072401175,
-0.0220058709,
0.0435822085,
0.0313031785,
-0.0729552209,
-0.0205192138,
0.0083052469,
-0.0322292447,
-0.0306423139,
0.0376566388,
-0.062013723,
-0.0012779491,
0.0120325265,
0.0448121428,
0.0141051747,
-0.0239116587,
0.0048170658,
0.0207226779,
-0.004110164,
-0.0521865711,
0.0316251591,
-0.059041217,
-0.0103981374,
-0.0278301984,
-0.010498574,
0.0361574627,
0.0010161756,
0.0195657592,
0.0306834262,
-0.0234793834,
-0.0128186652,
-0.0084545156,
0.0300046057,
-0.0550917946,
0.0078477347,
0.0106419045,
-0.0318600014,
-0.015134397,
-0.0177136119,
0.0160967261,
0.0050817337,
-0.0081773251,
-0.0144233126,
0.0042678267,
0.0998182446,
0.0059317462,
-0.0480628088,
0.0183109399,
0.003884672,
0.0012260295,
0.0148573909,
0.0041028066,
0.0312378071,
0.0721505508,
0.051020816,
-0.0464708135,
0.0061186235,
0.054212749,
-0.0323862247,
0.0380634405,
-0.0253891237,
0.0215308443,
0.0034558817,
-0.079692848,
-0.0423692465,
0.0645075813,
0.0074985465,
0.0031679231,
-0.0046613431,
-0.0045275125,
0.0212809555,
0.0029299946,
-0.0312430505,
-0.0017902339,
-0.0038583439,
0.0025567058,
0.011126278,
0.0494243987,
-0.0119014047,
0.03395129,
0.0059036175,
-0.0281646196,
0.0001768892,
-0.0608343631,
-0.0361983366,
0.0329847559,
-0.0328037478,
0.0150625175,
-0.0388466865,
-0.0555522814,
-0.0207049269,
-0.0593332425,
-0.0144468509,
-0.0076185861,
0.017398024,
0.0158032365,
0.0289593618,
0.039446272,
0.0254060812,
-0.0107381437,
-0.0368763022,
-0.0342614315,
-0.02090431,
-0.0149303814,
0.0155400485,
0.0187691413,
-0.0765308961,
-0.0001123293,
0.0030622834,
0.0004699928,
0.0025056885,
0.0197738986,
-0.0758128017,
0.0528003536,
-0.0876154229,
-0.0385077335,
0.0039164708,
0.0395090245,
-0.0049759368,
0.119025901,
-0.0210153442,
-0.0356384218,
-0.0069721499,
0.0400672443,
0.0032182441,
0.0265338514,
-0.033186499,
-0.0339649022,
0.0262933671,
0.0588323958,
0.0081122713,
0.014115789,
-0.0775000677,
0.0311605763,
0.0273793321,
-0.0141280033,
-0.0211657174,
0.0021052368,
-0.0022273886,
-0.0625283495,
-0.0166898426,
0.0411200821,
0.0312587991,
-0.0210553724,
-0.0434169732,
-0.015750533,
-0.0037092743,
0.0356861874,
-0.0430434085,
-0.0534198806,
-0.058940649,
-0.0272339657,
-0.017427275,
0.0836164653,
-0.0172838904,
-0.0183215458,
-0.059250813,
0.0562544726,
-0.0029029029,
-0.0730403364,
-0.0032789344,
0.0232817102,
0.0259744003,
-0.0547041856,
-0.0453919694,
-0.0494467504,
-0.0044899089,
-0.0229564086,
0.0045245001,
0.0199207347,
0.0407310687,
0.0182777774,
-0.0352636389,
-0.0029500024,
0.0189025328,
-0.023891449,
-0.0674927086,
-0.0252243076,
0.0595758408,
-0.0242821388,
-0.0159457531,
-0.0603097118,
0.0611492582,
-0.0623076707,
0.0268458314,
0.0348371416,
0.0007660211,
0.0069719735,
-0.034471456,
0.0007053656,
0.0467826985,
-0.0092168339,
0.0396889523,
-0.0330810286,
0.0222580433,
0.0109330099,
0.023064971,
-0.0383297093,
-0.0156143559,
-0.0075293686,
-0.009314876,
-0.0231440365,
-0.0403052159,
-0.0214716867,
-0.0200790558,
-0.0246334635,
-0.0583199449,
-0.0146666737,
-0.0084566437,
0.0710783601,
0.0396865606,
-0.0278998539,
-0.0591262579,
-0.0283471923,
0.0489414409,
-0.0851217061,
0.0018623673,
-0.0472960323,
0.0039407834,
-0.0343054049,
0.0156205045,
0.0588034913,
-0.0772002041,
-0.0386008359,
-0.0205653403,
-0.025729904,
0.0018759429,
0.0212721173,
0.0882038251,
0.0003520194,
0.0508106984,
-0.0078884969,
-0.0205810629,
0.08858715,
0.0030939074,
0.0035615272,
0.0299213771,
0.0346407257,
0.0449962839,
-0.0128035517,
-0.0187970437,
-0.0234668218,
0.0285920687,
0.0370758399,
-0.0505549088,
-0.0317133926,
-0.030886976,
-0.0008653397,
-0.0126593001,
0.0937617198,
-0.0186525732,
0.0238788482,
-0.0790006593,
0.0088475943,
0.019338917,
-0.011049198,
-0.0809681714,
0.0452780612,
-0.0321547389,
0.0223355647,
0.0115899323,
0.042583473,
-0.0032838893,
0.0168574527,
-0.0040159738,
-0.003512712,
0.0386218242,
0.0264773406,
-0.0178127829,
0.025656566,
0.0249928068,
0.0201473925,
-0.0516221747,
0.0455050953,
0.0094335685,
0.0780792385,
0.0264422651,
-0.0163324866,
-0.0378404781,
0.0402117781,
-0.0074455463,
-0.0304037835,
-0.0480645113,
0.0812932476,
-0.0007698809,
-0.0266607013,
0.0132998656,
-0.0237595923,
-0.0030626641,
-0.0144017944,
0.0271083992,
0.0448655747,
-0.0670276508,
0.0592493154,
0.0155760124,
-0.0035256248,
-0.0238916669,
-0.009230068,
-0.0017597164,
0.008225929,
0.0443279222,
0.0034979195,
-0.0544981621,
0.0060952557,
0.0036580688,
0.0027197115,
-0.0028250625,
0.0574460514,
0.0065281168,
-0.0211189557,
-0.0378940441,
0.0387706012,
0.007141293,
0.0446393937,
0.0544219166,
0.0561103262,
-0.0047109611,
-0.0424768701,
0.0155404499,
-0.0203740299,
-0.021707477,
-0.0183554497,
0.0561439544,
-5.655289363e-33,
-0.0316098928,
-0.0197320078,
0.0442635417,
-0.0145823713,
-0.0293414425,
0.0072297002,
-0.0300575234,
0.0218211785,
-0.0273811147,
0.0122160809,
0.018887369,
-0.0223473925,
0.0338752829,
0.0683985353,
-0.0138001963,
-0.0574294738,
0.0285116639,
0.0029565084,
-0.0155997053,
0.0127420789,
0.0283522513,
0.0057535004,
0.1069356948,
-0.0380344503,
-0.0404726267,
-0.0253114514,
-0.0245415494,
0.0675343722,
0.0215164348,
0.0046448484,
-0.0082471343,
-0.0201465134,
0.034335807,
-0.0379117094,
-0.0001472394,
-0.0021552439,
-0.0581140146,
-0.0145041021,
-0.0069718719,
0.0525970645,
-0.0824592412,
0.0276603661,
0.0262637641,
0.0111812437,
0.0546758734,
-0.0561475828,
0.0555220768,
-0.0577427186,
-0.0219276883,
0.0116041452,
-0.0262285993,
0.0552217625,
0.0058449809,
-0.0399985388,
0.0721766055,
-0.0387259424,
0.0380597636,
0.0110341161,
0.0093314108,
0.0335078537,
0.0246280916,
0.0151084987,
0.0615932047,
0.0967660695,
-0.0125947325,
0.0660192668,
0.0507324859,
-0.0896317884,
0.0107173584,
-0.010189713,
-0.0019687717,
0.0445197597,
0.0139530599,
0.0463492051,
0.0003150303,
0.0594285056,
-0.0239835139,
0.008031806,
-0.1161828116,
0.0186435208,
-0.0216798689,
-0.0228478145,
0.0038793746,
-0.0158462282,
0.0049270829,
-0.0243933126,
-0.0255177896,
0.0322650373,
0.0101488577,
-0.0112150665,
-0.0251730345,
-0.0366272181,
0.038315244,
0.025345793,
0.0499185696,
0.0809622854,
-0.0443844162,
0.0644019991,
-0.0141111277,
-0.0158172604,
-0.0606894158,
-0.0118671674,
-0.0332507752,
0.0084516499,
0.0028824003,
0.0145102087,
0.0068227784,
0.0293559302,
-0.009672815,
0.0018988412,
-0.0079316553,
-0.0317239538,
0.0112442737,
0.0749731064,
0.0104825683,
-0.0124669373,
-0.0280142557,
0.0668653548,
-0.0072835726,
-0.0448524803,
-0.0365859568,
0.0018487282,
-0.0301637016,
0.0452099331,
-0.0589930974,
0.0286527369,
-0.0121026682,
-0.0815230757,
0.0683349892,
-0.0358175263,
0.0032003715,
0.0101720756,
2.65e-7,
0.010371997,
-0.0114330146,
0.0044296039,
-0.027120078,
-0.0552309193,
0.0649055764,
0.0357978232,
0.0152253639,
-0.0339011997,
-0.0379891619,
0.0335920677,
0.0760103539,
-0.0114078131,
-0.0084974235,
-0.0539698452,
0.0874671116,
0.0127445571,
-0.0061685033,
-0.0456037708,
0.0205992702,
0.0568057448,
0.0398488343,
0.0095455647,
-0.0258760322,
-0.0094529232,
-0.0049283272,
-0.0238479897,
-0.0194839835,
0.017078707,
-0.002687877,
-0.0212433748,
0.0589707978,
-0.0279727057,
0.0090571092,
0.0031945987,
-0.0312138386,
0.0474468134,
0.041813869,
0.0221198127,
0.0241590533,
0.0088567575,
-0.0017505066,
-0.0081322091,
-0.0401271842,
0.0313211679,
-0.0080861291,
0.0210243557,
-0.0224757716,
0.0028855086,
-0.013893906,
-0.0148817012,
-0.010499333,
-0.0171192586,
0.0084835701,
0.0073908959,
-0.0040957476,
-0.0434351377,
-0.0575585663,
0.0080208872,
-0.0133317877,
-0.0152625907,
-0.0215443,
0.0092972917,
-0.0116651058,
0.0069576725,
0.0126406681,
-0.0090577621,
1.868830421e-34,
0.0197710153,
0.0450267829,
-0.0539524145,
-0.02410491,
-0.003677292,
0.0336659178,
0.0103193223,
-0.0304473005,
-0.0306510311,
-0.0026007646,
0.0153635405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05447v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05447v2 | DoG-Instruct: Towards Premium Instruction-Tuning Data via Text-Grounded Instruction Wrapping | 2023-09-11T13:41:18 | 2024-05-25T10:05:52 | Yongrui Chen, Haiyun Jiang, Xinting Huang, Shuming Shi, Guilin Qi | cs.CL | cs.CL | The improvement of LLMs' instruction-following capabilities relies heavily on
the availability of high-quality instruction-response pairs. Unfortunately, the
current methods used to collect the pairs suffer from either unaffordable labor
costs or severe hallucinations in the self-generation of LLM. To tackle these
challenges, this paper proposes a scalable solution. It involves training LLMs
to generate instruction-response pairs based on human-written documents, rather
than relying solely on self-generation without context. Our proposed method not
only exploits the advantages of human-written documents in reducing
hallucinations but also utilizes an LLM to wrap the expression of documents,
which enables us to bridge the gap between various document styles and the
standard AI response. Experiments demonstrate that our method outperforms
existing typical methods on multiple benchmarks. In particular, compared to the
best-performing baseline, the LLM trained using our generated dataset exhibits
a 10\% relative improvement in performance on AlpacaEval, despite utilizing
only 1/5 of its training data. Furthermore, a comprehensive manual evaluation
validates the quality of the data we generated. Our trained wrapper is publicly
available at https://github.com/Bahuia/Dog-Instruct. | [
0.006375432,
0.0265028644,
0.0064843246,
0.0275416393,
-0.0044144955,
-0.004152704,
-0.0006186078,
0.0156356953,
0.013260995,
-0.0680674314,
-0.0659529716,
0.0067725875,
-0.0180809628,
-0.0164160784,
0.0294955,
-0.0593217649,
0.0336575694,
-0.021591004,
-0.033222761,
0.0027919468,
0.0010064588,
0.0177318472,
-0.0533684492,
0.0201629382,
-0.0129523436,
-0.0311459359,
-0.0536240824,
0.0397051983,
0.0106489221,
-0.0436034761,
0.0308255479,
0.0345555767,
0.0095991576,
-0.0069999839,
0.0000020151,
-0.0285321604,
-0.0112937856,
-0.0277016833,
-0.0020138384,
-0.0021694452,
0.024681529,
-0.0126888938,
-0.0306029879,
0.0243995748,
-0.0401954576,
0.0270531252,
0.0098860832,
0.0731933489,
0.0905350968,
0.1269041002,
0.0010180684,
-0.0193267297,
0.0379177742,
0.0207810085,
0.0642700046,
-0.0189289376,
-0.0154714538,
-0.0125786997,
0.0322219618,
0.0141317481,
-0.0089245485,
0.0098724877,
0.0427864492,
-0.0216633994,
-0.001247355,
0.0189353675,
-0.0416381396,
0.0107599981,
-0.0451652668,
0.0912320092,
0.0134579549,
0.0001397279,
-0.0046841032,
-0.0114210714,
0.0246468056,
-0.0235947017,
-0.033257883,
0.0485301688,
-0.0178480968,
0.0249902997,
0.0125403469,
-0.006627006,
-0.0038228035,
0.0035133553,
0.0015748062,
0.0568274967,
-0.0101900818,
-0.0573929325,
0.0324448384,
0.0326749124,
0.0191529132,
-0.0401742421,
0.0263477731,
0.0772980601,
-0.0405479409,
0.0089145945,
-0.0914240181,
-0.0156772286,
0.0233348198,
-0.0286155101,
0.081773892,
0.0237477534,
-0.0397344939,
0.0069619538,
-0.0521194451,
0.0364639834,
-0.0005618565,
0.055701267,
-0.018272059,
0.0573383607,
-0.0673097819,
0.0127449147,
-0.0552157834,
0.0466753468,
-0.0490855128,
-0.0011310217,
-0.0386528112,
0.0437728912,
-0.0103823356,
0.0373299457,
0.001946985,
0.0162905008,
-0.0259346385,
0.0093214661,
-0.0138139902,
-0.0353919715,
-0.0352203399,
-0.0030446863,
0.0193163436,
-0.0395923331,
0.0003232654,
0.0603048429,
-0.0174938962,
-0.0079480624,
0.0365963504,
0.066460155,
-0.0301493648,
-0.005290092,
-0.0750281289,
-0.0480379984,
0.0121384738,
-0.0473329835,
0.007002105,
-0.0555764511,
0.0136069376,
-0.0202947315,
-0.0267047249,
-0.0033608084,
0.0261312705,
0.0400173143,
0.0089486279,
0.0452979766,
-0.0251065195,
0.0026220265,
0.0306793563,
0.0171878934,
-0.003563456,
0.0497152358,
0.0572049208,
0.03657493,
0.0345168225,
-0.0111416262,
0.0466115549,
0.044358138,
0.0184030049,
0.0072105736,
-0.0116305156,
-0.0047411928,
-0.015005324,
0.0255611762,
0.0546812564,
0.0466126651,
-0.0012309455,
0.0156076727,
0.0389850996,
0.0318251476,
0.0128631974,
-0.0061508003,
0.0561878271,
0.0500663333,
0.0151755093,
0.0448917821,
-0.0590449311,
0.0310335848,
-0.0212472696,
0.0271310471,
0.0244572368,
-0.0173497219,
-0.0372721367,
-0.073495321,
-0.0029808728,
-0.0146119054,
-0.0244465675,
-0.0099818408,
-0.0014934522,
0.0199555811,
-0.0884965137,
0.012501684,
0.0110111423,
-0.0448358506,
-0.0017962551,
-0.0424919501,
0.0035196575,
0.1028096974,
0.0583189093,
-0.0292668957,
-0.019299591,
-0.0183749069,
0.0466537625,
0.0591714233,
0.0124319363,
-0.0144846039,
0.0315859467,
-0.075618498,
-0.0151108298,
-0.0327629223,
-0.0048480765,
-0.0051042717,
0.0174151342,
-0.0074404799,
0.0001765995,
-0.006167348,
-0.0396299958,
0.0792696625,
-0.0094476053,
-0.0990989432,
-0.006388146,
0.0120879412,
0.0172521528,
0.0187517349,
-0.007292117,
0.0074196397,
0.0437469333,
-0.0252151433,
-0.0082675051,
-0.0315599255,
-0.0835404918,
-0.0236493014,
0.0127417287,
-0.0281124357,
-0.0252341665,
-0.0130800018,
-0.0428734794,
-0.0395976231,
-0.049607832,
-0.0571885183,
0.0362310149,
-0.0151197771,
0.0296042878,
0.0398099311,
-0.0186964478,
-0.0306488164,
0.040574491,
-0.0145835895,
-0.0038432844,
0.0279790647,
0.0399028659,
-0.0046734037,
-0.0286742914,
0.0205342714,
-0.0158529915,
0.0007425932,
0.0144237103,
-0.0062573636,
0.0572685264,
-0.0729799867,
-0.0461060591,
-0.0705338418,
0.0211932976,
-0.0212678034,
0.0199008361,
0.0420672968,
-0.0401466675,
-0.0274054054,
-0.0337132737,
-0.057017874,
-0.0227149148,
0.0096890396,
-0.0041882754,
0.0449602827,
-0.0006203957,
-0.0161112212,
-0.0393659696,
0.0007625251,
-0.0244508069,
-0.0310125109,
0.007488756,
-0.0092311548,
-0.0833933577,
0.041428078,
0.0035733411,
0.0277888253,
0.0033267459,
-0.0577863716,
0.046946384,
-0.01446064,
0.0556984954,
0.0774243847,
0.0230435971,
0.0306521058,
0.0477092564,
0.0072465078,
-0.079347387,
0.0295676738,
-0.0052748332,
-0.0060320031,
-0.0314117484,
-0.0391356349,
0.0228303168,
0.0384943672,
0.0144443931,
0.0342269987,
-0.0420066081,
-0.0139424801,
0.0288685616,
-0.0466184318,
0.0112653319,
-0.0062523568,
-0.0297199711,
0.0105037326,
-0.0145417936,
-0.0736598969,
0.0653507337,
-0.0366893671,
-0.0270723049,
-0.0223180559,
-0.011540316,
-0.0306104142,
0.027617475,
-0.0120234285,
0.0012921498,
-0.057558611,
-0.0310354847,
-0.0567282625,
0.0017407595,
-0.0009227361,
-0.0230623204,
0.0506025888,
-0.0538850501,
-0.0110255321,
-0.0007287571,
-0.0099115632,
-0.0770507976,
0.0118485251,
0.0191024113,
-0.0237868745,
-0.009647388,
-0.0141622256,
-0.0338759311,
-0.0527575277,
0.0231847707,
0.0472138785,
-0.0255123824,
-0.0360502712,
-0.0460097417,
0.0000026414,
0.041841954,
-0.0254645813,
-0.0079622585,
-0.0646992624,
0.0442419723,
0.0620113909,
0.0525215119,
-0.0111756446,
-0.008929776,
0.0097026611,
0.0062317392,
-0.0564899854,
0.0081568016,
0.0508782528,
0.0744242519,
-0.0649357736,
-0.0102483882,
0.1217864007,
0.0412648991,
-0.0597418211,
0.0080866562,
-0.0247500557,
0.0235586148,
0.015950989,
0.0378443971,
-0.0649621561,
-0.0224700887,
-0.016490005,
0.0802638009,
0.004847934,
-0.022850262,
-0.0011871434,
-0.0980978757,
0.0479696579,
0.017025603,
0.0087409597,
-0.0052820006,
-0.0228646565,
-0.0193540938,
0.034749113,
0.019006364,
-0.0008439572,
-0.043324165,
-0.0069096088,
0.0329717211,
-0.0008642534,
-0.0037845543,
0.0087646144,
-0.017532371,
0.0554735474,
0.0675459728,
0.0013539614,
0.005036931,
-0.0605487339,
0.0312931985,
-0.0016033738,
0.0168017745,
-0.0155092748,
0.0645744205,
-0.0305848047,
0.0215200409,
0.0022049278,
0.0611414611,
-0.0589656234,
0.0107551729,
0.0509226955,
0.038444709,
-0.0736293346,
-0.0107642449,
-0.044517044,
0.0242864396,
0.0264667757,
0.075506106,
0.0262903832,
-0.050742656,
-0.0455168597,
-0.0340386145,
0.0049241763,
-0.0854429454,
-0.0127992285,
0.0312418286,
-0.0623066612,
0.031558156,
-0.1008266509,
-0.083518073,
0.0358487926,
0.045886483,
0.0085871089,
-0.0228381082,
-0.0196120329,
-0.0256302841,
-0.0355016999,
0.016226558,
-0.0122476378,
0.0052831206,
-0.1050220206,
-0.0656703711,
0.0185569935,
0.0025285315,
0.0191754047,
0.031316895,
-0.039070949,
-0.0641735494,
0.0080553396,
0.0852346197,
0.0165227037,
0.0775223225,
0.0192852374,
-0.001144269,
0.0221896693,
0.0588344187,
-0.0422853827,
0.0165422875,
0.0575154461,
0.0309125315,
0.0006810697,
0.0163759701,
-0.0348901488,
0.0443342067,
0.0060020811,
0.0308081079,
-0.0262114108,
-0.0309945401,
0.028125843,
0.0090466253,
-0.0325560905,
-0.0416587032,
0.0323252268,
-0.0070462087,
0.0437038913,
-0.0410922915,
-0.0086373705,
-0.0413512923,
0.011075573,
-0.008783713,
-0.0418510363,
0.0193256456,
-0.0137710776,
-0.0458948314,
0.0327505246,
-0.0175187904,
0.028256245,
-0.0155300358,
0.0318215862,
0.0209454969,
0.0067840964,
-0.0097182803,
0.02282729,
0.0269452352,
0.0686602965,
0.0290408488,
0.0927293375,
0.0190948099,
0.012236435,
-0.0061125359,
0.0348039269,
-0.0266295187,
-0.0170977097,
-0.0485789366,
0.0165310912,
0.021280447,
-0.0038270741,
0.0351098515,
-0.0300439689,
0.0194460806,
0.0037500409,
0.0511119589,
0.0057976902,
-0.0234479476,
-0.0022515247,
0.0337980911,
0.0117064025,
-0.0140939727,
0.0635800958,
-0.0139900204,
0.0381124467,
-0.0004058138,
0.023468839,
-0.0709012896,
-0.0413507894,
0.015846964,
0.0074968683,
-0.0032953706,
-0.0015130093,
-0.0111152949,
-0.0451651141,
-0.0044444068,
0.0282878187,
0.0147023983,
-0.0290049352,
0.0500281714,
0.0217090063,
-0.0065380121,
-0.0195688158,
-0.0300047789,
0.0240894072,
0.0010511595,
-0.0542075597,
-0.0357918292,
-5.613395846e-33,
-0.0321340822,
-0.0626833364,
0.0422938988,
0.0048760469,
-0.0005840684,
-0.0031880657,
-0.0326079205,
0.0098229628,
0.020881163,
-0.0021988093,
-0.0148859452,
-0.0034460062,
0.0214681942,
0.041255977,
0.0306050517,
0.00468671,
0.0340538099,
-0.036645513,
-0.0226969458,
0.0431402698,
0.0059395474,
0.0130902305,
0.0451358296,
-0.0882267207,
0.0198261924,
-0.0366970673,
-0.0251807645,
-0.0081015127,
0.0044013313,
0.0610965304,
-0.0180224553,
0.0125122266,
0.0115371747,
0.0139519079,
-0.0252684224,
0.032399185,
-0.0482548922,
-0.0389893129,
-0.0161047038,
0.0086745014,
-0.0760282725,
-0.0520917028,
0.0266790036,
-0.0401088409,
-0.0083505465,
0.0001505046,
0.0447795279,
-0.0095434096,
-0.0124103045,
-0.0076550534,
-0.0845974088,
0.0003881537,
-0.0184626691,
-0.0357771702,
-0.0005598806,
0.0440068245,
-0.0054399925,
-0.0178172365,
-0.0607529655,
0.0180934612,
0.0119768521,
0.0276542064,
0.0489277244,
-0.0215821061,
-0.0157033335,
0.0385582745,
0.0209204927,
0.0343491472,
-0.0264239591,
0.0020635081,
0.0084995143,
0.0648479387,
0.0195333958,
-0.0047419597,
0.0181499887,
0.0154000465,
-0.0087705823,
0.0584140755,
0.0260541942,
0.0082723331,
-0.0052081482,
-0.0059417593,
-0.0564311035,
0.0236346275,
0.0162187722,
0.0175144803,
0.0062046559,
-0.0522021502,
0.0484784879,
0.0191175975,
-0.0034469014,
-0.0422058478,
0.0076879095,
-0.0097120944,
0.0048061586,
-0.0227485839,
-0.0345667265,
0.0284775738,
-0.0021329417,
-0.016631186,
-0.0314767249,
-0.047268115,
0.0467333384,
-0.005887555,
0.0530072674,
0.0265787989,
0.0611548834,
0.0187256448,
-0.0758616477,
0.0126287006,
-0.0270914044,
0.058516182,
0.0201023985,
-0.0169939194,
0.0045002569,
-0.0206201039,
-0.0239849202,
0.0751243383,
-0.0305954348,
-0.0209513642,
-0.0215017721,
-0.0409628414,
-0.0060639107,
0.0320290811,
-0.0366755836,
0.0210225359,
-0.0365325771,
-0.0140442885,
0.0111589031,
-0.0521813668,
0.0106812594,
-0.0021783712,
2.596e-7,
0.0136807729,
0.0366722271,
0.0655214861,
0.0596928187,
0.0000098941,
0.012578168,
-0.0065526492,
0.0086139534,
-0.0125667527,
-0.0342174508,
0.0196121093,
0.0271448493,
0.0598860085,
0.0231460556,
-0.0837886259,
-0.0011128194,
-0.0334324166,
0.0069569987,
-0.0746432394,
0.002254711,
0.0676754415,
0.0315312818,
-0.0157843214,
-0.0205625668,
0.0068619801,
0.0179606657,
0.0266928654,
-0.0033839652,
0.0144605804,
0.0165392403,
0.0253356602,
-0.0009102153,
-0.0262817219,
0.0069455737,
-0.0426089838,
-0.0124073084,
-0.0347117558,
0.0889564827,
0.0052750665,
-0.0469430871,
0.0447248891,
-0.0284790192,
0.0239352789,
-0.0091232266,
0.0405170806,
0.0000922859,
0.0060928683,
0.004424877,
-0.0356684923,
-0.0355708338,
-0.0042474857,
-0.0325223431,
0.007606864,
0.0295162592,
0.0113623226,
-0.0399065875,
-0.0023110241,
-0.0588179938,
-0.006007818,
0.0152759477,
-0.0158245284,
-0.0138548352,
-0.0528504401,
0.0373476483,
-0.0074863932,
-0.0720525011,
-0.0352257527,
2.406408669e-34,
0.0060599507,
-0.0339732245,
0.0477627888,
0.0665218309,
0.0061033592,
0.0248674508,
-0.0049490104,
0.0382802151,
0.0279289354,
-0.062967658,
-0.0283684582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05444v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05444v1 | Pushing Mixture of Experts to the Limit: Extremely Parameter Efficient MoE for Instruction Tuning | 2023-09-11T13:31:00 | 2023-09-11T13:31:00 | Ted Zadouri, Ahmet Üstün, Arash Ahmadian, Beyza Ermiş, Acyr Locatelli, Sara Hooker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The Mixture of Experts (MoE) is a widely known neural architecture where an
ensemble of specialized sub-models optimizes overall performance with a
constant computational cost. However, conventional MoEs pose challenges at
scale due to the need to store all experts in memory. In this paper, we push
MoE to the limit. We propose extremely parameter-efficient MoE by uniquely
combining MoE architecture with lightweight experts.Our MoE architecture
outperforms standard parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods and is on
par with full fine-tuning by only updating the lightweight experts -- less than
1% of an 11B parameters model. Furthermore, our method generalizes to unseen
tasks as it does not depend on any prior task knowledge. Our research
underscores the versatility of the mixture of experts architecture, showcasing
its ability to deliver robust performance even when subjected to rigorous
parameter constraints. Our code used in all the experiments is publicly
available here: https://github.com/for-ai/parameter-efficient-moe. | [
0.0421317518,
0.064680621,
0.0095872721,
0.0025167121,
0.0262158457,
0.0151932696,
0.0091105327,
-0.027783161,
-0.0303321239,
-0.0133223096,
-0.0469837189,
-0.0090305265,
-0.0110778539,
-0.0158908088,
0.0177054442,
-0.0541350134,
0.0286667068,
-0.0192615278,
-0.0177808888,
-0.0010207993,
-0.0276513696,
-0.0019515108,
-0.008750896,
0.0256703943,
0.012914109,
0.0082976315,
-0.0309922714,
0.0228581559,
0.0323973745,
0.0270825177,
0.0219440628,
0.034800943,
0.009102378,
-0.0197581258,
0.0000022694,
0.0131670991,
0.0155015867,
-0.0013240816,
-0.0273858253,
0.0241902024,
0.0109035373,
0.0474982783,
-0.0106065646,
0.0127190938,
0.0027982043,
0.004779872,
0.0530751795,
0.006109341,
0.0551096722,
0.1113440469,
0.0138904033,
0.020540012,
0.033039961,
-0.0394831188,
0.0206397995,
-0.0402314737,
0.0079016853,
-0.0247313473,
-0.0100688823,
0.0126963705,
0.0047820415,
-0.0034302899,
0.0219089836,
0.0517068394,
0.0115466965,
-0.0014729708,
0.0193032715,
-0.0167271066,
-0.0305632278,
0.0369232632,
-0.0743671879,
0.0149214743,
0.0112552335,
-0.0161021426,
0.0204813499,
-0.044577796,
-0.0020929438,
0.0156363565,
-0.0456819162,
-0.0035698952,
-0.0093017993,
0.0108229192,
0.051998619,
0.0305011179,
-0.0426231585,
0.0401420444,
0.0111052832,
0.0068482105,
-0.0115758693,
-0.0384332091,
-0.0428626686,
-0.0148266843,
-0.0025252989,
0.0321298316,
-0.0380992889,
-0.0083164712,
-0.0517877676,
-0.0212297421,
-0.0432022177,
0.0130150151,
0.0854875818,
0.0634703338,
-0.0083556594,
0.0389338061,
-0.0554577373,
0.0184264071,
-0.0433128476,
-0.0120036481,
-0.0352416933,
0.0133064464,
-0.0549594127,
0.0557014458,
-0.0266979933,
0.0419193655,
-0.0557083338,
-0.0034897041,
-0.0241253804,
0.0317791067,
-0.0319894776,
0.0141632315,
0.0199747421,
0.0333431885,
-0.0376153886,
-0.0043200296,
-0.0254831892,
0.021464929,
-0.0705348104,
-0.0075147813,
0.0218686499,
-0.0367471315,
-0.0060622497,
0.0351752676,
-0.0264467802,
0.0007072014,
0.0717703849,
0.0841839835,
-0.0297558121,
-0.0252375025,
-0.0276722219,
-0.0123940008,
0.0210812297,
-0.0774075985,
0.0240895823,
-0.0263853818,
0.0697686225,
-0.0356727131,
0.0157429483,
-0.0595110208,
0.0146937259,
-0.0124031054,
-0.0513640381,
0.0461775661,
-0.0237785839,
-0.0207832679,
0.0116403932,
0.0263978522,
-0.0373374708,
0.0605681874,
0.0279212855,
0.0658115372,
-0.0039471602,
0.018087754,
-0.0113595407,
-0.0148124993,
-0.0116636138,
0.0031661473,
0.021814853,
-0.020984577,
-0.0339789391,
0.0358173437,
0.0273593813,
0.0141793927,
-0.0072134389,
-0.031368047,
0.0138969691,
-0.028499512,
-0.0124312853,
0.0678902939,
0.0469501764,
-0.0268459618,
0.0275619831,
-0.012166501,
-0.0502518043,
0.0692168772,
-0.0301964246,
-0.0163979456,
0.0244364776,
0.0577685274,
-0.0650516301,
-0.0338466018,
0.0134344231,
-0.0063413787,
-0.070646815,
0.0343179591,
0.0085295523,
-0.0490192436,
-0.0767436326,
0.0201401673,
0.016366601,
0.0061464836,
-0.0352206416,
-0.0700444356,
-0.0098776249,
0.0672056004,
0.0165976416,
-0.0531515256,
-0.0575747825,
-0.0022576977,
0.0221346151,
-0.0375704989,
0.0372504555,
0.0235986318,
0.0516082235,
-0.052145835,
-0.0336023644,
-0.0567622185,
0.0045431955,
0.0623453259,
0.0626319572,
-0.0203488059,
0.0249479935,
0.018254159,
-0.0308377873,
-0.0084233629,
-0.0427522026,
-0.0364477485,
0.0289892014,
0.0021927366,
0.0121217286,
-0.0237364769,
-0.0355403163,
0.0131092342,
0.0163655821,
0.0017382228,
0.0139740165,
-0.0454996042,
-0.0885529742,
0.0396158695,
0.0270284098,
-0.0231165495,
0.0395750701,
-0.023930613,
-0.0359548405,
-0.0627782717,
0.0220740121,
-0.0050782068,
0.0125547238,
0.0219213087,
0.0150327189,
-0.0057917465,
-0.008421462,
-0.0167636313,
0.0299736112,
-0.031193858,
-0.0107186325,
0.0227321759,
0.0348027311,
-0.0026051125,
-0.022145845,
-0.0009771838,
-0.0474594794,
0.0207976066,
0.0490614548,
0.0194000658,
-0.0198795646,
-0.0151800048,
-0.1152429581,
-0.0957830027,
0.0578610562,
-0.0258098654,
-0.0107562607,
0.0118760075,
-0.0005760603,
0.0110528078,
0.0127699999,
0.0182162244,
0.0448996797,
-0.0490170456,
-0.0051461933,
-0.037228819,
0.0272938646,
-0.019485103,
-0.030980736,
-0.0296294838,
0.002168152,
-0.0032811547,
-0.0238235462,
0.0090346308,
-0.0298736989,
-0.0158268306,
-0.0075364476,
0.045054622,
-0.01861462,
-0.0294850226,
0.0068719829,
-0.0396617576,
0.0283641443,
0.1299462765,
-0.0195648205,
0.0240423363,
0.0521879308,
-0.0202304199,
-0.0071674581,
0.065754272,
0.0133003034,
-0.0205591582,
-0.0071459948,
0.0339826643,
-0.036697749,
0.0460818522,
-0.0198592804,
-0.0086016525,
-0.0635841191,
0.0536816753,
0.0530066527,
-0.0622863397,
0.001789765,
0.0111396583,
0.0018845942,
-0.02052477,
-0.0565554351,
-0.0313784219,
0.0331114754,
0.0220552087,
0.0147169055,
-0.0032303024,
-0.0242705755,
0.0043803104,
-0.0312622264,
0.0149613116,
0.0494266376,
-0.0420921817,
0.0353352129,
-0.0546426475,
0.020107666,
-0.0014180752,
0.0064889826,
0.0139840404,
-0.0263561122,
-0.0084384801,
-0.0017778625,
-0.0496769249,
-0.0282045193,
0.0059689046,
-0.010185522,
0.0572180189,
0.0518466197,
-0.0769705921,
-0.052657228,
-0.0220812839,
0.0256449841,
0.0559213422,
-0.052291628,
-0.0173748825,
-0.0497164801,
-0.0189216249,
0.0229976047,
0.0230060648,
0.0022648964,
-0.0350505151,
0.0329624191,
0.012531017,
0.0580998883,
-0.0539340228,
-0.0820896104,
0.0365138836,
-0.002893988,
-0.0207713377,
-0.0306520015,
0.0557336658,
0.0355905257,
-0.057365071,
0.0031974507,
0.0691295266,
0.0125455298,
-0.0215278622,
-0.0025325236,
0.0360347182,
0.023663329,
0.0536724329,
0.0571986362,
-0.0164693631,
-0.0438967086,
0.0052613672,
0.0496677719,
0.0011319976,
-0.0109908674,
0.0048400667,
-0.0344816521,
0.0020834282,
0.0258538295,
-0.0242932066,
-0.0228554811,
-0.0009814922,
-0.0113814939,
-0.0272527393,
-0.0169801656,
0.0230877232,
-0.0056093642,
-0.0358200632,
0.0138625847,
0.0563714914,
-0.063618429,
0.0426001847,
-0.0164820235,
0.0296811555,
0.0225715563,
-0.0387804434,
0.0203778595,
-0.0134691121,
0.0041377479,
0.0114286589,
0.0540861562,
-0.0161925945,
0.0499636196,
-0.0227157101,
-0.0356480256,
0.0035906029,
0.0007573377,
-0.0025776494,
0.0109028267,
0.0090267202,
0.0563054308,
-0.0377053991,
0.0164112877,
-0.0057309633,
-0.0560023561,
-0.0095068803,
0.022048112,
0.0165378079,
-0.0331145562,
-0.0114218723,
-0.0189996473,
-0.0547090471,
-0.0518568717,
0.0352892689,
0.010865299,
0.0074581592,
-0.0618130416,
-0.0003104746,
0.014075933,
0.0029390731,
0.0568685122,
0.0156854875,
-0.0744205117,
-0.0012561352,
0.0283791758,
-0.0516916513,
0.0242667366,
-0.0236055143,
-0.032592088,
-0.1046401933,
-0.0146749942,
0.0514650568,
0.0120085329,
0.0178833194,
-0.0017560128,
-0.0935487896,
-0.049419865,
0.0256848708,
0.1167071611,
0.0072725769,
0.0436465554,
0.0087212855,
-0.0609337538,
0.0441946201,
0.0214578044,
-0.0211646985,
0.0403471738,
0.0565061234,
-0.0438756607,
-0.0186791737,
0.0038477201,
-0.0441140682,
0.0245197471,
0.0538653992,
-0.0279773604,
-0.0503941737,
-0.0073919944,
-0.0174342878,
-0.0054624672,
-0.0088846469,
-0.0078181913,
0.0087673683,
-0.0100031327,
0.0300903562,
0.029425703,
0.0126372594,
-0.0347410366,
-0.0086814174,
0.0233084392,
-0.0017508904,
0.0186188444,
0.0199855436,
0.0746460855,
0.002449655,
-0.0046671084,
0.0161731876,
-0.0229816269,
0.0466793105,
-0.0067088129,
-0.0003579391,
-0.0195590314,
0.061028067,
0.0136475135,
0.0374458693,
-0.0353259407,
0.0436222367,
-0.0007974576,
0.0085702483,
-0.0908539742,
0.0442797579,
-0.0487163141,
-0.0900435299,
-0.0514814667,
0.050195232,
0.0778627843,
-0.0139894783,
0.0001512444,
0.0007664111,
-0.0185818281,
-0.0248287618,
-0.0048550693,
-0.0005038034,
0.0289821774,
-0.0226873867,
0.0561324358,
0.0334793441,
0.0000297563,
0.0268542152,
-0.01381661,
0.0529829226,
0.015260485,
0.0331217386,
-0.0371874124,
0.0147997309,
0.0055490802,
0.0451668687,
0.0192916375,
0.0075697312,
0.0132726226,
0.0101726791,
-0.0415378138,
-0.0003199939,
0.0183704346,
-0.0184861999,
0.0289275385,
-0.0000855759,
-0.0359604843,
-0.0324256308,
-0.007295887,
-0.0280904491,
0.0098649915,
0.0144566,
0.0109131942,
-6.755028246e-33,
-0.0194959827,
0.0235131662,
0.0325834304,
-0.0614802837,
0.0298409481,
-0.0109899249,
-0.0136495233,
-0.0049894392,
-0.0544839129,
-0.0178793203,
-0.0315170139,
0.0145590454,
-0.0038226759,
-0.0207825508,
0.0415872969,
0.0150939068,
0.0848282725,
-0.0204464849,
-0.032612741,
0.0336791463,
0.0243812148,
0.000615445,
0.0309590269,
-0.0404881425,
-0.0774183497,
0.0380784385,
-0.0413009599,
0.0067629311,
-0.0255630556,
0.0319900997,
0.0305316821,
0.0177176781,
-0.0105930781,
-0.0171409417,
-0.0198554918,
-0.052992899,
-0.0516622178,
-0.0725291595,
0.0007260572,
-0.0474073179,
-0.0064157532,
-0.0720628649,
0.0601522587,
0.0383873396,
-0.0117414081,
-0.0285160057,
-0.0018764817,
-0.0093812384,
0.0076783691,
-0.0144965416,
-0.0055474779,
0.0236684922,
0.0151808066,
-0.018850375,
0.0319148749,
-0.0019028168,
-0.0288115516,
-0.0201819446,
-0.0306366477,
-0.023374239,
0.0539759882,
0.0926322192,
0.0143618314,
0.0471200533,
-0.0071346317,
-0.0080424584,
0.0360062458,
0.049428314,
-0.0020506922,
0.0222279206,
0.0281405449,
0.0879638195,
0.0273590349,
-0.0361370482,
0.0327136591,
-0.007326189,
-0.0477723777,
0.0153555684,
0.0255095866,
0.0780392513,
0.0127654355,
-0.0069674202,
-0.0465674922,
-0.0023179702,
-0.0348427556,
-0.0367339402,
-0.0511056818,
-0.0197731778,
0.0271072667,
0.0408929251,
-0.014930753,
-0.003485037,
0.024672674,
-0.0288500227,
0.0874848738,
0.0157748275,
-0.0195516348,
0.0140388245,
0.0296325106,
0.022481937,
-0.0666667521,
-0.1149577945,
0.0358638763,
-0.0073816022,
0.0171049144,
0.0131301191,
-0.0202647466,
0.054356046,
-0.0653798357,
-0.0258263573,
-0.0377565064,
0.003607284,
0.0306422804,
0.0229582898,
-0.0077842134,
0.0174167771,
0.0115391854,
0.0323861651,
-0.0413944386,
-0.0206455309,
-0.0237516556,
-0.0289958455,
0.0432562195,
0.0440417379,
0.0104339216,
0.0404303148,
-0.0491817668,
-0.0636445209,
-0.0260731317,
-0.0341975875,
-0.0418870822,
0.0171108656,
2.881e-7,
-0.0530595966,
0.0535108745,
-0.0048354962,
-0.0234256834,
0.0044143791,
0.0196089316,
0.0040564104,
-0.0215791073,
-0.0044643963,
-0.0295705553,
0.0528341085,
0.0622337125,
0.0101849781,
0.0069523496,
-0.0506902263,
-0.006579014,
0.0235159229,
0.0840481222,
-0.0382155366,
-0.027728891,
-0.0148974322,
0.101631254,
0.0343206748,
0.0028327694,
0.022463372,
-0.0045489524,
0.0248780847,
0.0006012477,
0.0158310402,
0.0361990295,
0.061434608,
0.065764904,
-0.0236089267,
0.0184344314,
-0.0032209479,
0.044624839,
-0.0353830419,
0.1102293134,
-0.0386429243,
-0.0377883501,
0.0561311282,
0.0149529576,
-0.0056599732,
0.0085556796,
0.0492760278,
-0.022026049,
0.013216597,
-0.0217467453,
0.0221228115,
0.0057195276,
0.0131100835,
-0.0238346178,
-0.0048193932,
-0.0021434382,
-0.0077289832,
-0.0103288898,
-0.0236314274,
-0.0764727965,
0.0102389548,
0.050655853,
-0.0178751629,
-0.045987986,
-0.0398957282,
-0.0324808955,
0.0710598826,
-0.0300748032,
-0.0301771723,
2.770242767e-34,
0.0306057464,
-0.0292024985,
0.0370857567,
0.0194176529,
0.0362568013,
-0.0009066292,
-0.0838299021,
-0.0016530693,
0.0403217338,
-0.0491478182,
-0.0646637827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05429v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05429v1 | Improving Information Extraction on Business Documents with Specific Pre-Training Tasks | 2023-09-11T13:05:23 | 2023-09-11T13:05:23 | Thibault Douzon, Stefan Duffner, Christophe Garcia, Jérémy Espinas | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T01, I.2.7 | Transformer-based Language Models are widely used in Natural Language
Processing related tasks. Thanks to their pre-training, they have been
successfully adapted to Information Extraction in business documents. However,
most pre-training tasks proposed in the literature for business documents are
too generic and not sufficient to learn more complex structures. In this paper,
we use LayoutLM, a language model pre-trained on a collection of business
documents, and introduce two new pre-training tasks that further improve its
capacity to extract relevant information. The first is aimed at better
understanding the complex layout of documents, and the second focuses on
numeric values and their order of magnitude. These tasks force the model to
learn better-contextualized representations of the scanned documents. We
further introduce a new post-processing algorithm to decode BIESO tags in
Information Extraction that performs better with complex entities. Our method
significantly improves extraction performance on both public (from 93.88 to
95.50 F1 score) and private (from 84.35 to 84.84 F1 score) datasets composed of
expense receipts, invoices, and purchase orders. | [
0.0309730023,
0.0525269769,
0.0227389652,
0.0498401262,
-0.0241215695,
0.025488548,
-0.0086314641,
0.0394551605,
-0.0052261455,
-0.0620337315,
-0.0603142604,
-0.0063740476,
0.0029694878,
0.0349118076,
-0.0132203829,
-0.0198212601,
0.0177034512,
0.0119468821,
0.0641605183,
0.0442629494,
0.0007654855,
0.0226192735,
0.0128982542,
-0.0302392319,
0.0018997581,
-0.0165413599,
0.0086520715,
0.0017855898,
0.0067021083,
-0.0096410001,
-0.0019636592,
0.0247654617,
0.0053189844,
0.0093413359,
0.0000019847,
-0.0345565267,
-0.0818144754,
0.0268303584,
-0.02667211,
-0.0072111632,
0.0389350019,
-0.0835528672,
-0.02440954,
0.0026080781,
-0.0503702611,
-0.0313449167,
0.0041656657,
0.1109842062,
0.0203669742,
0.0981926546,
-0.0452185795,
-0.0946517885,
0.0256976113,
-0.0190980267,
0.0076023568,
-0.0595371984,
0.0140061462,
0.0199866761,
0.0070122983,
0.0484114215,
0.0048128567,
0.0071228859,
0.0025576565,
-0.0143339466,
-0.0045054303,
0.033357393,
0.0171638858,
0.0126687447,
-0.0083657177,
0.0475843363,
-0.062525183,
0.0210403912,
0.0157585181,
-0.0238779075,
0.0114425346,
-0.0388491936,
-0.0408827178,
0.0182213113,
-0.0412677713,
-0.0075320904,
0.0008416747,
0.0229754895,
0.001261218,
0.0071416739,
-0.0593548454,
0.017393399,
-0.0078415601,
-0.0338578299,
0.0162069518,
0.0118749924,
0.0191046689,
-0.007832977,
0.0345102288,
0.0246254224,
0.054493621,
0.0337175876,
-0.0296664312,
-0.0416670479,
-0.0095839081,
-0.0453892685,
-0.0064363978,
-0.0175687838,
-0.0020753862,
0.061548274,
-0.0475568771,
0.037087284,
-0.0380880162,
0.0109919002,
-0.0242732223,
0.0207143109,
0.0108963093,
0.0021116256,
-0.0543173552,
0.036945574,
-0.0540374182,
-0.0301624313,
0.0025495864,
0.0025286409,
-0.0039228601,
0.0174445622,
0.0419349261,
-0.0388125703,
-0.0039307754,
-0.0800808296,
0.0138306413,
-0.0020673797,
0.0150858341,
-0.0008728576,
-0.0145452255,
-0.0026545702,
0.0164549351,
-0.0038812866,
0.0678220242,
-0.0229577739,
-0.0035223416,
0.012726956,
0.003632982,
-0.0288060904,
-0.0697624534,
0.0076370132,
0.0142178675,
-0.0468423292,
0.0127911596,
-0.0236927997,
0.0391828418,
0.0071059866,
-0.0335086696,
-0.0156077724,
0.0101822512,
0.0006481916,
-0.0386589281,
0.091407679,
-0.0043685157,
-0.0140747549,
0.021826243,
-0.029266715,
0.0716098621,
0.0456592776,
0.0417596772,
0.022315165,
0.0522195026,
-0.036016807,
0.0263249204,
0.0874750987,
-0.0319534279,
-0.0731521919,
0.0227518883,
0.0383331776,
-0.0017555197,
-0.0382034853,
0.0509420373,
0.0110653387,
-0.0361677036,
0.0302012637,
0.0298063587,
0.006315589,
0.0338256098,
0.0297563858,
-0.0094688861,
0.0414327495,
0.0074587134,
-0.008654316,
-0.0118354335,
-0.0298322383,
0.0059611541,
0.0696122721,
-0.0347042568,
0.0068311198,
0.0085425833,
-0.0306725521,
-0.0284225866,
-0.0145470817,
0.0325134918,
-0.0202011317,
0.0820585638,
0.0186853278,
-0.0973745137,
0.0637368411,
-0.0116391247,
-0.0582355373,
-0.0137098292,
0.0114861485,
-0.0155018177,
0.0528571568,
0.0570147708,
-0.0483198501,
0.0109460233,
-0.0232514758,
-0.0674454272,
0.0218810234,
0.0423942208,
-0.0249857884,
-0.0043080323,
-0.0659593865,
-0.0191964731,
0.0347472019,
0.000384167,
-0.0103751449,
0.0198339466,
-0.0148388213,
0.0213532634,
-0.04915113,
-0.0253495183,
0.0431197025,
-0.0124194482,
-0.0765708983,
0.0148556484,
0.0028662179,
-0.0052741659,
0.0248660799,
-0.0147332549,
0.0078947712,
0.0510408171,
-0.0073615694,
0.0341717117,
0.0168765672,
-0.0189855862,
-0.0083924942,
0.0176843163,
0.0261900853,
-0.0034616061,
0.0136420587,
-0.0389168151,
-0.0039133318,
-0.0165765099,
-0.002286958,
0.0307996646,
-0.0225361194,
0.0272614304,
-0.0002036451,
-0.0036694417,
-0.0539346822,
0.0491771325,
0.0227716397,
-0.0072558057,
-0.0241143946,
-0.0524105504,
0.0034505522,
0.0031634923,
0.0240739305,
0.0347826667,
-0.0214630421,
0.008799511,
0.0362932421,
0.0250942763,
-0.0155184614,
-0.0372708291,
-0.0844689533,
-0.0046972688,
-0.0226063859,
0.0354754888,
0.0391845033,
-0.0012455422,
-0.0337421261,
-0.0545966551,
-0.0102509614,
-0.0147419143,
-0.0063883094,
-0.049204208,
0.0591796041,
0.0099649886,
0.016670756,
-0.0175287407,
-0.0094331047,
-0.0092904745,
0.0135287195,
0.045642592,
-0.0406203605,
-0.0594355576,
0.0429574288,
0.0386647917,
0.013283737,
0.0032650814,
0.0054714023,
-0.0164630339,
-0.0351735428,
0.0506119654,
0.1037498638,
0.0214739386,
0.031860292,
-0.0314440541,
-0.0074892654,
-0.041486159,
-0.0194095392,
-0.053466551,
0.0552278645,
-0.0282664616,
-0.0431476831,
0.0612253174,
0.054122176,
-0.0415211357,
0.0263673794,
-0.0023573278,
-0.025888497,
-0.0024157139,
-0.0086496808,
-0.0134451501,
0.0151243126,
-0.0139851728,
0.0716207474,
-0.0071264789,
-0.0027809741,
0.006101049,
-0.0196834113,
-0.0161393397,
-0.0750146359,
0.0390592739,
-0.0551295131,
0.0773762465,
0.0209493693,
-0.0089715431,
0.0147608258,
-0.0629197359,
0.0062499661,
0.0099454988,
0.0337017626,
-0.0255249366,
0.0324254707,
-0.0235266127,
0.0431188643,
-0.0289531406,
-0.0221479833,
-0.0477414653,
-0.0157950353,
0.0197877288,
0.0247566532,
0.0357290395,
0.0012107042,
-0.0849199146,
0.0516063385,
0.0105336681,
0.0892824233,
-0.0119733848,
-0.0130529311,
-0.0168081168,
0.0744496658,
0.0333307348,
-0.0314925611,
0.022008108,
-0.0117015662,
-0.0148002906,
0.0244294126,
0.0017988665,
-0.0038643808,
-0.0117091909,
-0.0242328923,
0.0087224683,
-0.0761942416,
0.0269634742,
-0.0063589709,
-0.0152105205,
-0.0681473464,
-0.0264325682,
0.1154426709,
0.0322299451,
-0.0089374427,
-0.0463367552,
-0.0004396653,
-0.0369516835,
-0.0092617003,
0.0476733297,
-0.0519879833,
0.019208936,
-0.0003478026,
-0.0013953042,
0.0542330593,
-0.0098556448,
-0.0023323083,
-0.1182158738,
0.0478142202,
0.0120751737,
-0.0192645192,
-0.0595017858,
-0.0604407042,
-0.0120170023,
-0.0578629784,
-0.0098063918,
0.0313213021,
-0.0553732254,
-0.033611089,
0.0089962501,
-0.0417170599,
-0.0334440395,
-0.0345306396,
0.0017838294,
-0.0663495213,
0.0336707234,
0.0346352458,
-0.0465204194,
0.0230244938,
0.0333243683,
-0.0029894072,
-0.0352068432,
-0.0136170173,
0.0527748279,
-0.0284504667,
0.001921694,
0.0070333234,
0.0191148464,
-0.0562131032,
-0.0126035893,
0.0031166982,
0.0090614483,
0.0002745499,
-0.0062454576,
0.0121802036,
-0.011269236,
-0.0164907295,
0.040641591,
-0.005572211,
-0.0318163298,
-0.0255795103,
-0.0408609249,
0.0365785286,
-0.0511216484,
0.0086833676,
-0.0020240948,
-0.0642921552,
-0.0651732087,
-0.1021983325,
-0.0616380125,
0.0244925711,
0.0337663032,
0.0025140001,
-0.049999956,
0.0514448285,
-0.0095168138,
-0.0623901263,
0.0087937238,
-0.0207927171,
0.0054357583,
-0.0712278262,
0.0234792139,
0.0038498414,
-0.0052254139,
-0.047428485,
-0.0245940462,
-0.0352468155,
-0.0259114746,
0.0251747631,
0.0146281766,
0.0202952716,
0.0457947925,
-0.0195038263,
0.0283176079,
-0.0018670054,
0.0243845228,
-0.0805560723,
-0.0559106432,
0.0422253422,
-0.0164394807,
-0.0196394231,
-0.0046673254,
-0.0229909364,
0.0588012785,
0.0107037518,
0.0178506933,
-0.0634106323,
-0.0468001775,
0.0215305276,
0.0110591315,
0.0067847548,
0.0104723927,
0.0003630333,
-0.0550268032,
0.0141652422,
-0.0304053351,
0.0004465811,
-0.0210296828,
-0.018459918,
0.0362466499,
0.0262349155,
-0.0034359831,
0.0392130762,
-0.0193308685,
0.0156442821,
-0.0131352041,
0.0250892323,
-0.0087000942,
0.0171041619,
-0.0187146943,
-0.0317536257,
0.0094355103,
-0.002940692,
0.0201340076,
0.0498776585,
-0.0077517382,
0.0492979512,
0.0051227678,
-0.0160440411,
-0.0078914557,
0.0408792347,
-0.0199852698,
0.0317203179,
-0.0374154784,
-0.0009051362,
-0.0074918712,
-0.0544988327,
0.0322454274,
-0.0612173192,
0.0058238506,
-0.0041556279,
0.0275541358,
0.0216396581,
0.0194003619,
-0.0083086649,
0.0251049679,
-0.0169536006,
-0.0077847401,
0.0592844188,
0.015880717,
-0.0081225494,
-0.0178980194,
-0.0129062533,
-0.0752151161,
0.0077418587,
0.0314754322,
0.0087707974,
-0.0330968834,
-0.0081840111,
-0.0448786728,
0.0127585074,
0.0377036817,
0.0101798754,
-0.0122945402,
-0.0055645201,
0.0323381089,
0.0795929581,
0.0089094108,
0.0263848528,
-0.037518926,
0.0363664404,
0.0057576969,
-0.0072881542,
-0.0461095534,
-5.683837712e-33,
-0.0264115427,
-0.0289500263,
0.0167153738,
0.0168925114,
0.0133764446,
0.0110241342,
0.01549978,
-0.0314470977,
0.014505662,
0.0023095494,
-0.0336701199,
-0.0231755916,
0.0443799943,
0.0103615187,
0.0000836103,
0.007683679,
0.0420690402,
-0.0202363431,
-0.0261774417,
-0.0090384437,
-0.0015606789,
0.0543414578,
0.0711758211,
-0.0924381614,
0.0409637801,
-0.0075865188,
-0.0093367137,
-0.0081977611,
0.0873709619,
0.0206319448,
0.0060243672,
-0.0448855646,
0.022775948,
-0.0677728876,
-0.0088104997,
0.0709998906,
-0.1273409128,
0.0187826045,
0.0006976498,
0.0755787566,
0.0460558124,
-0.0188891068,
0.0462350138,
-0.0523926206,
0.0091692759,
-0.0274180733,
0.0318034962,
-0.0327633023,
-0.0063589658,
-0.0396667086,
-0.0896111801,
0.0510030799,
0.0400710218,
0.0338557102,
0.1035857648,
0.0140910633,
-0.0297981612,
0.0380803347,
-0.0481269769,
-0.0150893657,
0.0429494344,
0.0159865357,
0.0377421081,
0.0056473454,
0.012652955,
-0.0069538858,
0.0118127288,
0.004229873,
0.0144055411,
-0.0145108039,
0.0345324837,
0.0599688888,
0.0190910492,
-0.0251724981,
0.0507112332,
0.0163406525,
-0.0341792479,
0.081897825,
-0.0039059599,
0.0283404328,
-0.0023990045,
-0.0051831021,
-0.0366904438,
0.0243183635,
0.0326124281,
-0.011942748,
-0.0151034882,
-0.0012277238,
0.0028493137,
0.0263912249,
-0.0114250137,
0.0552775525,
0.0385191292,
-0.0348981656,
-0.0409340225,
-0.007552254,
0.0140777929,
0.0578966364,
-0.034173388,
-0.0320256464,
-0.0567577854,
-0.0410134196,
0.0148305008,
0.0253682658,
-0.0251302645,
-0.0070844446,
0.0368012376,
-0.0174571499,
-0.0693432167,
0.0082742712,
-0.0063228565,
0.0180870816,
0.0203636214,
0.106607981,
0.0135463066,
0.0199391693,
-0.0073324484,
-0.0000236552,
0.0320318304,
-0.0031268359,
0.0037879001,
0.0108973272,
0.0149984621,
0.0574474521,
-0.0060185962,
-0.0232500751,
-0.0096235666,
0.0199989751,
0.030951336,
-0.0003967721,
-0.0033621262,
0.0185106006,
2.518e-7,
0.064006269,
0.0671686828,
0.0504049137,
0.0111264009,
0.0091222022,
0.0214654952,
0.0210022833,
0.0077910447,
-0.0131088085,
0.01977746,
0.0423958749,
-0.0325813964,
0.0513482913,
0.0001660232,
-0.0776504651,
-0.0499221869,
-0.021773329,
-0.0720693842,
-0.0601087771,
-0.0072830995,
0.0056313709,
0.0698291957,
-0.0157797765,
-0.0132524073,
-0.0325608365,
-0.0425706059,
0.0346215814,
-0.0501034334,
0.0037519988,
0.0015780777,
0.0496884882,
0.0249277726,
-0.039313741,
0.0041743652,
-0.0111033423,
0.042756144,
0.0404358953,
0.0817240924,
-0.0174970869,
0.0634448379,
0.0012850836,
-0.0549100116,
-0.0379589163,
-0.0461703837,
0.0424561836,
-0.0470062755,
-0.0056561157,
-0.006023807,
-0.078516461,
0.0236058235,
-0.0478968844,
-0.0002147728,
-0.0130093936,
0.050542675,
0.0637704507,
-0.0309006181,
0.0060266173,
-0.0390404649,
0.0124471309,
0.0047002831,
0.0077510402,
0.023344744,
-0.0075586718,
-0.0091156606,
0.0216519721,
-0.0139052048,
0.0066923234,
2.393318207e-34,
0.0348611996,
0.0010384254,
-0.0318383127,
0.0771039277,
0.0258351769,
-0.0214446019,
-0.0336573087,
0.0476163328,
-0.01492834,
-0.0818712786,
0.0387218185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05423v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05423v2 | Multi-Modal Automatic Prosody Annotation with Contrastive Pretraining of SSWP | 2023-09-11T12:50:28 | 2024-06-11T16:43:11 | Jinzuomu Zhong, Yang Li, Hui Huang, Korin Richmond, Jie Liu, Zhiba Su, Jing Guo, Benlai Tang, Fengjie Zhu | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD | In expressive and controllable Text-to-Speech (TTS), explicit prosodic
features significantly improve the naturalness and controllability of
synthesised speech. However, manual prosody annotation is labor-intensive and
inconsistent. To address this issue, a two-stage automatic annotation pipeline
is novelly proposed in this paper. In the first stage, we use contrastive
pretraining of Speech-Silence and Word-Punctuation (SSWP) pairs to enhance
prosodic information in latent representations. In the second stage, we build a
multi-modal prosody annotator, comprising pretrained encoders, a text-speech
fusing scheme, and a sequence classifier. Experiments on English prosodic
boundaries demonstrate that our method achieves state-of-the-art (SOTA)
performance with 0.72 and 0.93 f1 score for Prosodic Word and Prosodic Phrase
boundary respectively, while bearing remarkable robustness to data scarcity. | [
-0.0360162407,
0.0572333969,
0.0218305457,
-0.0376991518,
-0.0155704552,
-0.0268073585,
0.0404018313,
-0.0499419756,
-0.0608732402,
-0.0192847941,
-0.054700423,
-0.0226246342,
0.0359400772,
0.0558851697,
0.081049487,
-0.08152017,
0.023101544,
-0.0303769279,
0.0026896726,
-0.0051499968,
0.0511553399,
-0.0121369353,
-0.066729188,
0.0387914963,
-0.0421050973,
-0.0192583073,
-0.0121690826,
-0.0070329756,
0.0328235291,
-0.03199495,
-0.015634276,
0.0521061979,
0.0046073333,
-0.017688347,
0.0000019669,
-0.0416607261,
-0.0040317443,
0.0268763751,
0.0052297111,
0.0255042352,
0.0401392579,
0.0034430071,
-0.0192239974,
0.0671594962,
-0.0029306794,
0.019438019,
0.0674235076,
0.017636491,
0.0399770401,
0.0572211668,
-0.0287312679,
-0.0432056598,
0.0446287543,
-0.0095724324,
-0.0515609719,
0.0360592753,
-0.0433485471,
-0.0670557469,
0.0043532141,
-0.063935034,
-0.0250975732,
0.0785858333,
-0.0170595683,
-0.0082253059,
0.0169832297,
0.0042712041,
-0.0079023344,
-0.0489551611,
-0.0325519778,
0.0667690262,
0.0140982866,
0.0063013923,
-0.0115906866,
-0.0178787131,
-0.0338559225,
-0.0289106444,
0.0297190044,
-0.0065362453,
0.0396190733,
-0.0017521927,
0.0024478256,
0.0476259813,
-0.0133024314,
-0.0630962029,
-0.0102288164,
-0.0164678134,
0.04593518,
-0.0326836184,
0.0210786089,
-0.001678235,
-0.0114652077,
-0.005034849,
0.0705569908,
-0.0111575173,
-0.0204239357,
-0.0265343543,
-0.0292770024,
-0.0687185526,
-0.0331661589,
0.0329532176,
-0.0019506915,
0.0458392389,
-0.0414805859,
-0.037516702,
0.0250311997,
0.0176266935,
-0.0088348966,
-0.0012941972,
-0.025513947,
0.0050501097,
0.0046124016,
0.0030349786,
-0.0150834899,
0.0016944532,
-0.0321304873,
-0.0446879528,
-0.0312881656,
-0.0289695747,
-0.0580739938,
0.0097850347,
0.0153912501,
0.0144532295,
-0.0277850181,
0.0083022518,
0.0152909607,
0.0487556159,
-0.0192731936,
0.0607738607,
-0.0120248673,
-0.0629583076,
-0.0030391898,
0.0233713482,
0.0550689846,
0.0370872058,
0.0170289464,
0.0088834362,
-0.0367310606,
-0.0223400015,
-0.0395377465,
-0.0157467425,
-0.0413143151,
-0.0096297394,
-0.0410580449,
-0.0344600342,
0.0206271186,
-0.0162959695,
0.0026689984,
-0.0068814647,
-0.0392834432,
-0.0032065047,
0.0678016394,
0.0780126303,
-0.0634009242,
0.0191289503,
0.004854206,
-0.0461734161,
0.012394228,
0.0329141766,
0.0777685717,
-0.0355019532,
-0.0155150089,
-0.006108046,
0.0010744336,
0.0483988412,
0.0055669565,
-0.0171100348,
-0.0225958228,
-0.0354552418,
0.0341382027,
0.0161726996,
0.0863524601,
0.0252397973,
-0.0150261484,
-0.000242672,
0.0660427809,
0.0168338958,
0.0590315647,
0.0330606177,
0.0654576942,
0.0568197779,
0.0214121528,
-0.0127317468,
0.0082772616,
0.0062605478,
-0.0223971903,
0.0387949683,
0.0666181296,
0.0391993485,
-0.0177808832,
-0.0124581251,
0.0059420797,
-0.0385211483,
-0.0140683353,
-0.0121716987,
0.0265812222,
0.0442904234,
-0.0645410642,
0.0212843865,
0.0076861582,
-0.0788584724,
0.0208551679,
0.0345907994,
-0.009195596,
0.0608563945,
-0.0188466068,
-0.0355047435,
-0.0007320233,
-0.0520767197,
-0.0327203944,
0.049571909,
-0.0213050973,
-0.0164268296,
0.0732605308,
-0.0666672885,
-0.015374843,
0.0065419492,
-0.0150328754,
0.0304479189,
-0.0470104143,
0.0310249515,
-0.0008700339,
0.0347040854,
0.0659503415,
0.0024600828,
-0.0006389283,
-0.0110980133,
-0.0047298078,
0.0107718473,
0.0434548669,
0.0529944189,
-0.0501672812,
0.0455313846,
0.0205059201,
-0.0482034571,
0.0160026345,
0.0333403349,
-0.0819923356,
-0.0537465177,
0.0283194017,
-0.03450628,
0.0242108833,
0.0247277971,
0.0526915118,
-0.1231411844,
0.0198174659,
-0.0370892882,
0.0551962033,
-0.0494558141,
0.0024362418,
0.0249340106,
0.0252079554,
0.0301354099,
-0.0406741649,
0.0151120974,
-0.0167406499,
0.0275349244,
0.0458677001,
0.0120833712,
-0.0135857491,
-0.015165139,
0.0011233308,
-0.0237971134,
0.0357685499,
-0.0116226831,
-0.023970671,
-0.0303767119,
-0.0242762975,
-0.0736749023,
0.0327767245,
-0.0118548693,
0.0327633359,
-0.0075381086,
-0.0120932125,
-0.0100521101,
-0.0262910817,
-0.0031534974,
-0.0444111973,
-0.0225186478,
-0.0053081913,
-0.0084527852,
0.0009479554,
-0.0099202991,
-0.0209854804,
0.0279465616,
0.0162852444,
-0.0228979792,
-0.0342193507,
-0.0302253161,
-0.0048138313,
0.0120694768,
0.0485731885,
0.0095543833,
0.04018832,
-0.0500475466,
0.0331398696,
0.0139841139,
0.1187394336,
-0.0236360766,
-0.0157594811,
-0.0069131767,
0.0321063548,
-0.0288273543,
0.0006900252,
0.0065334248,
0.0143372687,
0.0452673733,
-0.0230252352,
0.0380949676,
-0.0200396869,
0.0357660875,
0.0366914049,
0.0368824303,
-0.0745648667,
-0.0282792449,
0.0092224525,
-0.0279889051,
0.0456080176,
-0.0151170138,
-0.0686749816,
-0.0248467289,
-0.0123464316,
-0.0120859267,
0.0535006151,
-0.072243467,
-0.0918030217,
-0.037740875,
-0.0095609846,
0.0264289677,
-0.0125846555,
-0.0359662287,
-0.0092920931,
-0.0177828483,
-0.0625834316,
-0.0187480748,
0.0293719713,
0.0377552323,
-0.0433693752,
0.0084903827,
-0.0079099182,
-0.0112156728,
-0.0171488281,
-0.0296170376,
0.0047740196,
-0.0521557331,
-0.0453648679,
0.0244599283,
0.0418530293,
-0.0397919416,
0.0391379148,
0.0000119937,
0.0255048536,
0.0645051301,
-0.0046325857,
0.0334107503,
-0.0272374731,
0.0338072143,
0.0014208703,
0.0622626282,
-0.0224962439,
-0.010703004,
0.0425723419,
-0.015595926,
0.0197096914,
0.0248144418,
-0.0403691158,
0.0374104008,
0.0293637794,
0.0017513698,
0.0086524878,
0.0152147114,
0.0583591983,
-0.0228832774,
0.0177035872,
0.1080279797,
-0.0200867504,
-0.0141540216,
-0.0022063982,
0.0621778034,
0.0604839288,
0.0405921116,
-0.0288947392,
-0.0439415537,
-0.0523137189,
0.0336549692,
0.0237580389,
-0.004356998,
0.0319449492,
-0.0366628319,
-0.0833731219,
0.0266342144,
0.010241922,
-0.0448963419,
-0.0207588729,
-0.0299226884,
-0.0273663662,
-0.0022446832,
-0.0207923353,
-0.0010653109,
-0.0292377509,
-0.0067940457,
0.0513892621,
-0.0853338167,
-0.0574815422,
-0.0482903905,
-0.0714970529,
0.0761371702,
0.0297864098,
0.0354493931,
-0.0090765478,
-0.0608256534,
0.013451675,
-0.0166197419,
-0.0188916475,
-0.0110811014,
0.0320415385,
0.0083703427,
-0.0315990373,
-0.02796611,
0.0426667444,
-0.022734182,
-0.0226678569,
-0.0027659172,
0.0562078878,
-0.0011625264,
0.0423134416,
0.0216002166,
0.0692289993,
0.0227410905,
0.0214426871,
0.0274441522,
-0.1159793064,
0.0016357963,
0.008089412,
0.0521785691,
-0.0096505806,
0.0099718431,
-0.0006024513,
0.0014524781,
-0.024798302,
-0.0517955869,
-0.0387370139,
0.0216109585,
0.0527008325,
0.0178172924,
-0.0123580182,
-0.0399145521,
-0.0106689725,
-0.0157987569,
-0.0083703743,
0.0151394084,
0.0335220546,
-0.0229298864,
-0.0214629509,
0.0348015316,
-0.0387747064,
-0.0139271598,
-0.0201712064,
-0.0308619216,
-0.0632041991,
0.0188848376,
0.0176890641,
0.0097869271,
0.0414463691,
-0.0211455002,
-0.0378632061,
0.0526006445,
0.0395357311,
-0.0167874638,
0.0128807724,
0.0800591633,
0.0069915662,
-0.0110761132,
-0.0165078454,
0.0000036549,
0.0046402561,
-0.0501277,
0.0356747583,
0.0441336073,
-0.0612757094,
0.003459844,
0.0006430188,
0.0560644604,
-0.0347665139,
0.0292062648,
-0.0709794164,
-0.0194977913,
-0.0317133851,
0.0319905318,
-0.0532629937,
0.0247471668,
0.0318215787,
0.0252301041,
-0.0353079736,
0.018848002,
-0.0117023038,
-0.0108102653,
0.014877608,
0.0368492901,
0.0857016742,
0.0330982469,
-0.0423462689,
0.0143111562,
-0.0127891582,
0.03996953,
0.0136882933,
0.0034331686,
-0.0112109641,
0.0151662035,
0.0021172455,
-0.0266929287,
-0.0148330769,
0.0076017333,
-0.0203718953,
0.0782104358,
-0.0239376687,
-0.0026282819,
0.0523860119,
0.0196478907,
0.0777236223,
0.0138362953,
0.0267139487,
0.0178484842,
0.0138109177,
-0.0661278889,
0.0114733307,
-0.0068076355,
-0.0350665003,
-0.0390114188,
0.0134855276,
0.0120864501,
-0.0044589955,
-0.0097555891,
-0.0279004704,
0.0305160321,
-0.0258164741,
-0.0342961811,
-0.0338498354,
0.0374311842,
-0.0104468465,
-0.0101703163,
-0.0469536632,
-0.028847523,
0.0580264069,
0.0033104562,
-0.0212918296,
-0.0253936946,
0.0181331113,
-0.0396460183,
-0.0584182777,
0.0058145686,
0.0105485553,
-0.061976824,
0.0579799116,
0.0071236831,
0.0054702624,
-6.384768831e-33,
-0.0269006193,
0.0118326321,
-0.0199901592,
-0.0019388385,
-0.0683230534,
-0.0118766567,
-0.0289558843,
0.000724496,
0.010530686,
0.0262893792,
-0.0078775054,
-0.0054348754,
0.0386835411,
0.0165759344,
0.0042396779,
0.004206372,
0.0929422081,
-0.0180615243,
-0.0080063278,
0.0310050901,
0.0198656153,
0.020465536,
0.0165370554,
-0.0409103706,
-0.001998557,
-0.0262114014,
-0.0492462032,
-0.0325538702,
0.0413728356,
0.0165891871,
-0.0029543918,
0.052691415,
-0.0295386054,
-0.0086286152,
-0.0493959896,
0.0534825325,
-0.0484684594,
-0.0388210267,
0.0173259526,
0.0009403686,
-0.0349685252,
-0.0154876905,
0.0130307795,
-0.0101328278,
-0.0114621948,
0.0027730698,
0.0162955802,
-0.0027044087,
0.030191686,
-0.0799608231,
-0.0467404276,
0.0254456885,
-0.0334529318,
-0.0173558183,
0.0390295126,
0.0446617231,
0.0069681178,
-0.0422622114,
-0.0446842238,
0.0041478937,
0.0284291822,
0.0209088959,
0.034530215,
0.0558509007,
0.0016107977,
0.0107366834,
0.0189253166,
-0.0462748148,
0.0587955192,
0.0280732159,
0.0620729811,
0.0092974389,
0.0347235277,
0.0292040408,
0.026483506,
-0.0305804722,
-0.0175554622,
-0.0162685979,
0.0069061527,
-0.0574506484,
-0.0161765069,
0.0471864492,
0.0087033063,
-0.0132521177,
-0.072560437,
-0.0516949929,
0.0085675754,
0.00517359,
0.0526363365,
-0.0107357698,
0.017690463,
0.0392615423,
0.0524496585,
0.0226659626,
0.0117797274,
-0.0101008732,
-0.04637165,
0.0338832512,
-0.0110532707,
0.0062056407,
-0.0537452661,
-0.0330686159,
0.0803078786,
0.0073260255,
0.0290608145,
-0.0417249314,
-0.0090242876,
0.0652225167,
-0.0704205632,
-0.0034889646,
-0.0006765734,
0.0420160666,
-0.0270458702,
-0.016009124,
0.0320109762,
0.0124664297,
-0.001231372,
0.0652100146,
-0.0056357956,
0.0348286256,
0.0126584228,
-0.0257727075,
0.0165353268,
0.0294255242,
-0.0043192892,
0.0298048444,
0.0242126565,
0.0017769824,
0.0291624758,
-0.0383673832,
-0.0062454706,
0.0195106138,
2.8e-7,
-0.0075519308,
-0.0205888413,
0.0606135167,
-0.0365349762,
0.0224206522,
0.0044141188,
-0.025113672,
0.017919207,
-0.0053624567,
0.0093486477,
0.0288246721,
-0.0356384739,
0.0966669098,
0.0111399526,
-0.075852938,
-0.0308737792,
-0.0507409088,
0.0326274149,
-0.0548795797,
0.0120470189,
0.0652953684,
0.0614865609,
-0.0185409598,
-0.0225383416,
0.0090221399,
-0.0098055769,
0.0310215354,
0.007991137,
0.0056771575,
-0.0186052658,
0.0243215803,
-0.0210640598,
-0.0031732861,
0.0104510691,
-0.0811971799,
0.0625449345,
0.016409995,
0.0667656511,
0.0007417246,
-0.0759771168,
0.0036395956,
0.0325127505,
-0.0615711622,
0.0767644867,
0.048875466,
-0.0212097224,
-0.0037887557,
0.0040079411,
-0.05570779,
-0.0022815303,
0.0279714391,
-0.040995542,
-0.0059487456,
0.0083837565,
0.0114517529,
-0.0033808376,
-0.0295715071,
-0.0094558578,
-0.0469183885,
0.0458070673,
-0.0319035724,
-0.0155164385,
-0.020976916,
-0.0294160899,
0.0263462532,
-0.0506672971,
-0.0148686972,
2.324373857e-34,
0.0455882438,
-0.083007358,
0.0855075419,
0.0237456448,
-0.0008930678,
-0.0099708671,
0.0252337698,
0.0137788393,
0.048104316,
-0.0285352115,
-0.0284443293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05312v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05312v1 | Experimenting with UD Adaptation of an Unsupervised Rule-based Approach for Sentiment Analysis of Mexican Tourist Texts | 2023-09-11T08:57:02 | 2023-09-11T08:57:02 | Olga Kellert, Mahmud Uz Zaman, Nicholas Hill Matlis, Carlos Gómez-Rodríguez | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | This paper summarizes the results of experimenting with Universal
Dependencies (UD) adaptation of an Unsupervised, Compositional and Recursive
(UCR) rule-based approach for Sentiment Analysis (SA) submitted to the Shared
Task at Rest-Mex 2023 (Team Olga/LyS-SALSA) (within the IberLEF 2023
conference). By using basic syntactic rules such as rules of modification and
negation applied on words from sentiment dictionaries, our approach exploits
some advantages of an unsupervised method for SA: (1) interpretability and
explainability of SA, (2) robustness across datasets, languages and domains and
(3) usability by non-experts in NLP. We compare our approach with other
unsupervised approaches of SA that in contrast to our UCR rule-based approach
use simple heuristic rules to deal with negation and modification. Our results
show a considerable improvement over these approaches. We discuss future
improvements of our results by using modality features as another shifting rule
of polarity and word disambiguation techniques to identify the right sentiment
words. | [
0.0190897956,
0.0887461305,
-0.0203053877,
0.0645778403,
-0.0379154459,
-0.01244062,
-0.0295132101,
-0.005226396,
0.0005823615,
-0.055518534,
-0.0303850751,
0.0125542535,
-0.0288212411,
0.0113217542,
-0.0585462563,
-0.0332863033,
0.0237521529,
0.0325125754,
-0.005952687,
-0.0159254987,
-0.0036276637,
0.0022362794,
-0.0280920379,
-0.0245803986,
-0.0260956641,
0.0234914254,
0.0191570986,
0.0028612297,
0.0236800145,
-0.0131636495,
0.0404063538,
0.064065218,
-0.010133096,
-0.0121902656,
0.0000022661,
-0.0442562625,
-0.0547290482,
-0.0347929411,
0.0851918235,
-0.0563249029,
0.0567765981,
-0.0206998885,
0.0009202686,
0.004953918,
-0.0339453034,
-0.0270821434,
0.03846623,
0.0645069927,
0.0444527306,
0.0557074547,
-0.0242009703,
-0.0503189377,
-0.0760590881,
0.0112445978,
-0.0273151118,
0.0186525192,
0.0171605498,
-0.0099634137,
-0.061561361,
-0.0458921529,
-0.0411670022,
-0.0052211862,
-0.0277446378,
-0.0079407925,
0.0115359072,
-0.0494192541,
-0.029399287,
-0.0167878866,
0.0021226592,
0.059563566,
0.0394023061,
-0.0497386195,
0.0038556599,
0.0153905284,
-0.0615688898,
0.0420674421,
0.0055050785,
-0.0122254612,
0.0129096489,
0.048817303,
0.0316706374,
0.0482192747,
0.0231274068,
0.0158797167,
-0.0089647807,
0.0640022084,
-0.0100906594,
-0.0474051349,
-0.0098057427,
0.04411529,
0.0653867573,
0.0128312074,
0.0298509691,
-0.0196890961,
0.0249437355,
0.0157064125,
0.0615576841,
-0.0099439807,
-0.0025948305,
-0.0658453405,
0.005907556,
0.013093235,
-0.040679127,
0.0260073729,
0.0252921768,
-0.0600797758,
0.0072571705,
-0.0280704647,
-0.0188759826,
0.0363340229,
-0.0828285739,
0.0547160096,
0.0069917934,
0.0356283635,
-0.0284567606,
0.0430972762,
-0.0251645483,
-0.0266046599,
-0.0224254411,
-0.0295602344,
0.0011672884,
0.0220339987,
0.0063041258,
0.0025063176,
-0.043727912,
0.0856180191,
-0.0404652283,
0.0114115756,
-0.0790061876,
0.0131782386,
0.02768635,
0.0577100627,
0.0293664113,
0.0215929635,
-0.014967693,
0.0470833741,
0.035935726,
-0.0307662096,
-0.0191989429,
-0.0323903859,
-0.0306073744,
-0.0728137195,
-0.0013161887,
-0.0642820969,
0.0047368766,
0.0039354661,
0.000770861,
-0.0175161846,
0.0060724639,
-0.0079784086,
-0.0185428914,
0.0477351397,
-0.0316355005,
-0.0268769637,
-0.0383820087,
-0.0101440139,
0.0248945206,
0.0208532121,
-0.0382462293,
0.0776879638,
0.0578575842,
0.0135173621,
0.042596817,
-0.0474014394,
-0.0046538967,
0.0040771179,
-0.0366851613,
0.0033301432,
-0.0485938899,
-0.0442723371,
-0.0151082221,
0.0170979388,
0.0149571234,
0.0320680402,
0.0291089062,
-0.0513259359,
-0.0077806357,
0.0205966812,
0.0294138063,
0.0129782632,
-0.011894159,
0.0195370223,
-0.0443414003,
-0.0272579659,
-0.0429751389,
0.0016662428,
-0.0059158984,
-0.0005961225,
0.0203971472,
-0.1010840237,
-0.015281111,
-0.0307398867,
0.0316497311,
-0.0291039851,
0.0795609802,
0.0333929099,
-0.0140905026,
-0.0113923084,
0.0411984622,
-0.0840725899,
-0.0092363637,
0.0265102424,
0.0670830011,
0.102420114,
0.0201359317,
-0.0196098555,
0.0298466329,
-0.0049987515,
0.0121732745,
0.0441542231,
0.027739048,
0.0257567912,
0.0010575913,
-0.0524026118,
-0.023734061,
0.019275751,
0.0374656133,
-0.0150080835,
-0.0311502367,
0.0320002735,
0.0062248227,
-0.011331588,
-0.0334727876,
-0.0073598144,
0.0806848556,
-0.0143594919,
0.0294504967,
0.0183133241,
0.0281399395,
0.0563172661,
-0.0309732109,
-0.0430124849,
0.0381311774,
-0.0354668312,
-0.0458449386,
0.0691162869,
-0.0403175838,
-0.0474916622,
0.0003329167,
-0.0801690891,
-0.0140219675,
0.0222588014,
-0.0151577359,
-0.0222529788,
0.0504474603,
0.0061754356,
0.0324470326,
-0.036024753,
0.027355317,
-0.023125995,
0.0327196978,
-0.0125820618,
0.0531331636,
-0.0132666016,
-0.0167410579,
-0.0358461626,
-0.0468864739,
0.0566104837,
0.0311924294,
-0.0508949272,
-0.0003490393,
0.0196781065,
0.0008500749,
0.0377681255,
0.0354069658,
-0.005769331,
-0.0213708952,
-0.0756339952,
0.0022534006,
-0.0251240414,
0.0576404259,
0.0432248935,
0.0156262331,
-0.008866257,
-0.0062363208,
0.0211973637,
-0.0054462622,
-0.0278025866,
-0.0407274254,
0.0643338338,
-0.0297281258,
0.0032556553,
-0.0398784988,
0.0107579017,
-0.0266455356,
-0.0306994654,
-0.0202669092,
-0.0495488383,
-0.0108585833,
0.0081720119,
-0.0400290564,
0.0072476235,
0.0234884284,
-0.0854319558,
-0.0007658183,
0.018662801,
0.0265950914,
-0.0328663997,
0.0010688371,
-0.000507362,
0.0752888843,
-0.0149785588,
0.00465653,
0.0187199228,
-0.0256037153,
0.0629655197,
-0.0276307445,
-0.0194127001,
0.0114940805,
0.0384412594,
0.020241987,
-0.0482031442,
-0.0409155861,
0.0059514334,
-0.0266985148,
0.0033615297,
0.0327616818,
0.0337894,
0.0069049993,
0.0225529391,
0.0365560092,
-0.057712581,
0.02348396,
0.0038785709,
0.0159734618,
-0.1386008114,
0.0117516788,
-0.0709022731,
0.034724623,
0.028293699,
0.0225787573,
-0.0001216962,
0.021563435,
0.0570145883,
-0.055125162,
-0.0118308235,
-0.0106394272,
0.0307243727,
-0.0365913846,
0.0131527586,
0.0219620243,
-0.0430112146,
0.0031214321,
-0.0025472273,
-0.0389566012,
-0.0441400111,
0.0417927876,
-0.0085174106,
0.0035491458,
0.0011667338,
-0.002447393,
-0.0218704361,
0.0179567486,
-0.0113442009,
0.0210242663,
0.020859357,
0.0026442592,
0.0320078991,
0.0011795581,
0.0520300902,
-0.0295365602,
0.0270969439,
-0.040901307,
-0.000890774,
0.0052166041,
0.0109149013,
-0.0080005182,
0.0109512731,
-0.0146116493,
-0.029292902,
0.0229833554,
-0.0494093671,
0.048837781,
0.059537597,
0.0555616356,
-0.0423879214,
0.0034755673,
-0.0108005423,
-0.0276766978,
0.025849754,
0.001745465,
-0.0319968499,
-0.0252738148,
-0.0120144337,
0.0105826436,
-0.0156489536,
0.0031846839,
-0.0126121044,
-0.0567879602,
0.0256775096,
-0.0116826072,
-0.0107577043,
-0.0215640496,
-0.0456248112,
0.0073813195,
-0.0723508075,
-0.0660186261,
-0.0422351547,
-0.0067905644,
0.0184242651,
-0.0178493764,
-0.0892074928,
-0.0250519533,
-0.0151861571,
-0.0218615923,
0.0102341371,
0.0062003173,
0.0575995296,
-0.0304194838,
-0.0466288403,
-0.0004431802,
-0.0211403482,
0.0526378974,
-0.0698807165,
0.0432744026,
-0.0049658883,
-0.0382961147,
-0.0349757187,
-0.0111315185,
-0.0808722898,
0.0220186096,
0.0175118763,
0.0566024072,
-0.0201643258,
-0.0306575187,
-0.0507234968,
0.0362674929,
0.0165273882,
0.0331814401,
-0.0131124677,
-0.0409996212,
-0.0007502449,
-0.0125054428,
0.0002923288,
-0.0554826483,
-0.022283392,
-0.0355273969,
-0.0278717503,
-0.0473708175,
-0.0953823701,
-0.0695768595,
-0.0028152477,
0.0537724532,
0.0048463158,
0.0278406069,
0.0170410331,
-0.0057894066,
-0.0094400067,
-0.0027152251,
-0.0094349813,
-0.0186059661,
0.0133602694,
-0.0390821472,
0.0354180485,
0.0180045534,
-0.0081080748,
-0.0262061302,
0.0014944329,
-0.0263826251,
0.0267814957,
0.037234854,
0.0095793093,
0.0073774699,
-0.0289625172,
-0.0053425026,
0.0115310382,
0.0628002435,
-0.0432082191,
-0.0192690995,
0.0525359511,
0.0281077307,
0.0126116956,
0.0254286211,
0.0283763018,
0.0462323539,
-0.0053684199,
0.0574339144,
-0.0114621595,
-0.0084802173,
0.032003291,
-0.0161979795,
0.0395661108,
0.02523591,
-0.0066974834,
-0.0373468399,
0.0106473202,
-0.0140416762,
-0.0177025627,
-0.0092332382,
0.016593568,
-0.0213291533,
0.0303840134,
-0.0547753014,
0.0399252363,
-0.0743254498,
-0.0075928927,
0.056313701,
0.0760093927,
0.0786913112,
-0.0007100971,
-0.0463092141,
0.0086903907,
-0.0030227217,
0.0106468266,
0.0162740909,
-0.0255159102,
-0.0257299375,
0.0198009405,
-0.0071282359,
-0.0286582969,
-0.0559203736,
0.0169356987,
0.0333614685,
0.0607140623,
-0.0050507369,
0.0473504029,
0.0352567397,
-0.0369002223,
0.0214632973,
-0.0168212391,
0.0133199226,
0.0111730192,
0.0241155662,
0.0069876788,
0.0164573155,
0.0280426387,
-0.0267869662,
-0.0267516263,
0.0101090707,
0.0342812873,
-0.0442979261,
0.0063078892,
0.0344559811,
0.0082624312,
-0.0495869666,
0.0155979162,
0.0634191111,
0.0092865396,
-0.011896383,
0.0159660038,
-0.0474990457,
-0.0363580696,
0.0226278156,
-0.0300422478,
0.0154331494,
-0.0435056128,
0.0052426234,
0.0619343072,
0.0216058418,
-0.027155662,
-0.0493105911,
-0.0072008846,
-0.0176034998,
0.013602186,
-0.0155439647,
-7.136631181e-33,
0.0333568119,
-0.052298788,
-0.0331870615,
0.0315834805,
0.0104399594,
-0.0190503821,
0.0122359227,
0.0017551925,
0.0257113557,
0.0492279567,
-0.0019369035,
0.0170867834,
0.0179220531,
0.0289621111,
0.0277596135,
0.0093240747,
0.0694589913,
0.0098358626,
-0.0063404655,
-0.0087496182,
0.0430696532,
0.0293191504,
0.0794910863,
-0.1780003458,
0.0504929088,
-0.0212776996,
-0.0428887606,
0.0270520896,
0.0703649148,
0.0242116638,
-0.0120437276,
0.0729862526,
0.0514449999,
-0.0084324516,
0.0237478483,
-0.0310208499,
-0.0198151693,
-0.0399867557,
0.0445019975,
0.0169144999,
-0.0134473545,
-0.0238823984,
0.0337212719,
0.0058305557,
-0.0054573021,
0.0741077513,
0.0346712805,
-0.0252064671,
0.0260784365,
-0.009153842,
-0.0845707729,
0.0476652645,
0.0050317189,
0.003503924,
0.0355001986,
0.0235574953,
-0.0160025991,
0.0069760717,
-0.0822026432,
0.042473875,
-0.0328130536,
0.029086886,
0.0046392726,
-0.085433282,
-0.008004453,
0.0405856706,
0.0119350748,
-0.0019187101,
-0.0145123312,
-0.016191192,
-0.0087779071,
0.0371863805,
-0.0064370004,
0.0976181403,
0.0571092293,
-0.0263922866,
-0.0434755199,
0.008037623,
0.0419692844,
0.0179266464,
0.0321112685,
0.0183022153,
-0.0675559342,
0.0040099537,
0.0168665666,
-0.013003068,
0.0063412641,
-0.0662133843,
-0.0166318156,
0.0317590125,
-0.066464819,
-0.0286941882,
-0.0308635123,
-0.0506033227,
-0.0420020856,
0.0248932894,
-0.027074229,
0.0081339525,
0.0214616936,
-0.0227878746,
-0.0543116145,
0.0014307888,
-0.0367083587,
0.0575512946,
0.0202665199,
-0.0359911509,
0.0413853899,
0.0468753427,
-0.0570347197,
-0.0078820558,
0.0127460519,
-0.0123929223,
-0.0305675995,
0.0572411492,
-0.0135519868,
0.0232898835,
-0.018098671,
0.0345889665,
0.0619890243,
0.084819831,
0.0029391958,
-0.011277617,
0.0037849897,
0.0386264548,
-0.0094911326,
-0.0306379348,
0.018202439,
-0.0065666907,
-0.0092998436,
-0.0537134334,
-0.0147670517,
-0.013156659,
3.136e-7,
0.0440212488,
0.0720807984,
-0.0386653356,
-0.028892979,
0.0222770851,
0.0267429464,
-0.0152671924,
0.0070756888,
-0.0331232473,
0.0377227515,
0.0131731825,
0.0042727794,
0.0120547228,
0.0377524458,
-0.0582910515,
0.0255644079,
0.0317805521,
-0.0396979302,
-0.0133774607,
0.0201308206,
0.0772833303,
0.0876560956,
0.0133605031,
0.0087219235,
-0.0288151912,
-0.0225644764,
0.015586473,
-0.0412925594,
-0.0476247706,
-0.0035408142,
0.0563223623,
-0.0116145955,
-0.0210712701,
-0.0334193408,
-0.0060773971,
0.0346135087,
-0.0117789339,
0.022533536,
0.0231091436,
-0.0137328953,
0.0304304231,
-0.0159452874,
0.0033641197,
-0.0306635685,
0.03001366,
-0.0046850587,
-0.0189006645,
-0.0594272278,
0.000597338,
0.0454967842,
0.038809523,
0.0124465358,
-0.0650636405,
0.0083501032,
0.0044211601,
-0.0235085562,
-0.0503189117,
-0.0464366078,
0.0036043767,
0.0156894587,
0.0299749542,
-0.0039397525,
0.0107680932,
0.0281433482,
0.0064860014,
-0.0136304619,
0.0386911891,
2.31582489e-34,
0.0695358217,
-0.0432344787,
-0.0155766746,
-0.0518007129,
0.0591441654,
0.0117980866,
-0.055241596,
-0.025695648,
-0.0086762728,
-0.0104336021,
0.0294429883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05311v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05311v1 | Analysing Cross-Lingual Transfer in Low-Resourced African Named Entity Recognition | 2023-09-11T08:56:47 | 2023-09-11T08:56:47 | Michael Beukman, Manuel Fokam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transfer learning has led to large gains in performance for nearly all NLP
tasks while making downstream models easier and faster to train. This has also
been extended to low-resourced languages, with some success. We investigate the
properties of cross-lingual transfer learning between ten low-resourced
languages, from the perspective of a named entity recognition task. We
specifically investigate how much adaptive fine-tuning and the choice of
transfer language affect zero-shot transfer performance. We find that models
that perform well on a single language often do so at the expense of
generalising to others, while models with the best generalisation to other
languages suffer in individual language performance. Furthermore, the amount of
data overlap between the source and target datasets is a better predictor of
transfer performance than either the geographical or genetic distance between
the languages. | [
0.0161068831,
0.032702338,
-0.0159899406,
0.0292377342,
0.0183860809,
0.0631067827,
0.0395645276,
-0.0057322825,
-0.0168146286,
-0.0165783092,
-0.0505062602,
-0.0513898283,
0.0340003259,
-0.0310642067,
0.0144936983,
-0.0689451322,
0.0368068665,
-0.0203009043,
0.0030032753,
0.0033251587,
-0.0421725921,
-0.0113585833,
0.0068800687,
-0.0211108737,
0.0301986746,
0.0542506613,
0.006600745,
0.0010790637,
0.0291325748,
-0.0021855489,
-0.054975193,
0.0279828198,
-0.0464710221,
0.0350119285,
0.000001724,
-0.0629080459,
-0.0159386639,
0.0077020973,
-0.0365082249,
0.0183595773,
0.0146963121,
-0.0391082354,
-0.0395764858,
-0.0098494543,
-0.0036577578,
-0.0680430159,
0.0804539621,
0.0231849812,
-0.0033814393,
0.0985994339,
0.0003104854,
-0.0009581968,
0.0455379337,
-0.0416447669,
0.0029021292,
-0.0932725966,
0.0374967791,
0.0021932409,
-0.0073320377,
-0.0018126824,
-0.0229686517,
0.0131762344,
-0.0340551399,
0.0330285467,
-0.0074069002,
0.0244994257,
-0.0467531793,
-0.0214921627,
-0.003954751,
0.0418318771,
-0.0327422246,
0.0255690701,
-0.0070483894,
0.001829069,
0.0052307942,
-0.0117973145,
-0.0642313957,
0.0139169795,
-0.0108333379,
0.0170566756,
0.0318321958,
0.0038776901,
0.0446170717,
-0.0287214871,
-0.0626728386,
0.0217961427,
0.0168832429,
-0.0008378169,
0.0361197181,
0.0600703619,
-0.001123843,
-0.0355106853,
0.0025877778,
-0.008101549,
0.0422494709,
-0.0157056991,
-0.0278252792,
-0.0070804795,
-0.0191485118,
-0.009191541,
0.0656838939,
0.0464972183,
-0.0297238789,
0.0315227136,
-0.0949997082,
0.0219504479,
-0.0408236161,
0.0367261916,
0.0205358509,
-0.0555513576,
-0.0886554569,
0.0022975849,
-0.0086725149,
0.0194177572,
-0.020552313,
0.0289314929,
-0.0416970737,
-0.0246985368,
0.0081359819,
-0.0250091571,
-0.0012397654,
-0.0564653613,
-0.0286576338,
-0.0292035807,
-0.0004634979,
0.049384892,
-0.0100288577,
0.0226715896,
-0.0067220805,
-0.0880283192,
0.0022354054,
-0.0472122133,
0.0297810119,
-0.0464745238,
0.0362430625,
0.0905477405,
-0.0023770318,
-0.0697463378,
-0.0937497243,
0.0619290173,
-0.0144060496,
-0.0550293401,
0.0241904929,
-0.0115674175,
0.0356450267,
0.0293437559,
0.0583925433,
-0.0408343673,
-0.0239816401,
-0.0400657505,
-0.0620845482,
0.0722478256,
-0.0251408648,
0.0026344159,
0.0293218847,
-0.0166650806,
0.0363961384,
0.0782711804,
0.0181986094,
-0.0203368887,
0.0102214543,
-0.0200559627,
-0.0498641469,
0.0203441177,
0.0296628959,
0.0131478403,
-0.0084415404,
-0.0038214312,
0.025607191,
-0.0096278572,
0.0442215987,
-0.0069842748,
0.0100841736,
-0.0180449914,
0.0310820006,
0.0465747751,
0.0317228325,
0.0250637755,
0.021840563,
-0.0355407596,
-0.0158510264,
0.0169543549,
-0.0115538891,
0.0339468345,
0.0028787046,
-0.0375036858,
0.0318928622,
0.0738456249,
-0.0277080722,
0.0435939953,
0.0169602372,
0.0076857768,
-0.0304223094,
-0.0102840727,
0.0636090934,
0.0122832563,
-0.0212325696,
0.0325901695,
0.0779984593,
-0.0172547698,
0.0068914588,
-0.0127430363,
0.0158443246,
0.0191359017,
-0.0215532612,
0.0446742103,
-0.0080079334,
0.0023193059,
0.019034531,
0.0248356704,
0.0514375344,
0.0022119065,
0.0698856786,
-0.0246449001,
-0.011417035,
0.01339598,
0.0038752141,
0.065734081,
-0.0147483097,
0.0891180336,
0.0169115663,
-0.0070162164,
-0.0224669538,
0.0366251953,
-0.0844587535,
-0.0197607093,
0.0310937911,
0.0418459103,
0.0229458623,
0.0190710202,
-0.0048162248,
-0.0239407178,
-0.05426009,
-0.0540663712,
0.018837411,
0.0089743761,
0.0021085902,
0.0028774114,
-0.0161529928,
-0.0074454555,
0.0422927625,
-0.0102118179,
0.0220127273,
-0.0396727771,
0.0201490466,
0.0387128256,
0.0359962061,
0.0042602532,
0.0400871262,
0.0034631409,
0.0530571155,
-0.0092709092,
0.0191986561,
0.0591819547,
0.0174861178,
0.0065716673,
-0.0292995516,
0.0393009968,
-0.0146060362,
0.0000372592,
0.0480897203,
-0.026930647,
-0.0629126579,
-0.015564112,
-0.0031937219,
-0.0141594205,
0.0091107124,
-0.0728248209,
0.0245671123,
0.0052434164,
0.0619979128,
-0.0148093523,
0.0707246214,
-0.020972237,
-0.0059110029,
-0.0021764494,
0.0235923696,
-0.0297383741,
0.0294681694,
0.0033159116,
0.005706999,
-0.0109051019,
-0.0145329013,
-0.0148571515,
0.0183112286,
0.068018429,
-0.0178049468,
-0.0288618691,
-0.0517201312,
0.0306687616,
-0.0132260891,
0.0025736592,
0.0011997306,
-0.0049019349,
-0.0234275516,
0.0003573069,
-0.0307753924,
0.0342423357,
-0.0461473949,
-0.0210549142,
0.0092691462,
-0.0340992473,
-0.0144597832,
0.0110812439,
0.008908907,
0.00236889,
-0.0199332889,
-0.0236698911,
-0.0179677419,
0.1001487374,
-0.0349084474,
-0.0016312831,
-0.0614793524,
-0.0090862,
-0.0189199969,
-0.0152220456,
-0.0139450571,
0.0588136911,
0.0105040465,
0.0436118692,
-0.0431504436,
-0.0189998951,
0.0373374708,
-0.0348106772,
-0.0129422769,
0.0195634477,
0.0049518608,
-0.0372578166,
0.0374879763,
-0.0217163227,
0.0014227163,
0.0282647368,
-0.0495775454,
-0.0212652497,
0.0331324935,
0.0481009036,
0.0051894379,
-0.0009189803,
-0.0014753384,
0.0080183931,
-0.0482122712,
-0.0442282781,
0.0131802242,
0.0032715527,
-0.0284716282,
0.0165602099,
0.0215114858,
-0.0194287505,
-0.0287914332,
0.0294885021,
0.0400572829,
0.027109839,
0.0022011832,
-0.0132912351,
0.0066751395,
0.0392561033,
-0.021061521,
-0.0014593615,
0.0122425165,
-0.0417771563,
-0.0280173793,
-0.0474446602,
-0.0109007163,
0.034340553,
0.0169306211,
0.0117235091,
0.0353257805,
-0.0266340021,
-0.06085179,
-0.0093265567,
0.0618209057,
0.0014809943,
-0.0075114425,
0.040043246,
-0.0153098879,
0.022649236,
0.0016273099,
-0.0441712625,
-0.0002182945,
-0.0010857673,
0.0343809314,
-0.0635307506,
-0.0392224677,
0.0100016277,
-0.0143562863,
0.0014996976,
-0.057095211,
-0.0182142016,
-0.1365792006,
0.0026047323,
0.0020475395,
-0.1042194739,
-0.007638264,
-0.0390071832,
0.0058776648,
-0.0346694663,
0.0089239012,
-0.0243909489,
-0.0185420252,
-0.010122315,
0.0516384877,
0.0280816089,
-0.0683618039,
-0.0137282377,
-0.0513325818,
0.0397461578,
0.0364831723,
0.0156082073,
-0.0062214704,
0.0088220797,
0.0046157483,
-0.0493194386,
-0.0141925365,
-0.0281772278,
0.0552492477,
0.025543116,
-0.048948735,
0.0432765372,
-0.0420997031,
-0.003919078,
0.0052346201,
-0.0106433649,
0.0480564982,
0.0384473763,
-0.0415684171,
0.0088904435,
-0.0517994016,
0.0091034714,
0.0545671508,
0.0354035236,
-0.0303768814,
-0.0395109914,
0.0280340128,
-0.0302539859,
-0.0581536517,
-0.0326804332,
0.0682248026,
-0.0501518697,
-0.069899492,
-0.0508056134,
-0.0499411002,
0.0356317386,
0.0407198109,
0.0381933749,
0.0149015514,
-0.001594965,
0.0091954013,
0.0003477809,
0.0168217197,
-0.0328754596,
0.0072431085,
-0.0387733281,
0.0000886328,
0.0331652723,
-0.0127387373,
0.0035252462,
-0.0395409204,
-0.0781269521,
-0.0540655851,
0.0044657234,
0.0069497409,
0.0156448018,
0.0136422599,
0.0160296299,
-0.0893863738,
0.0115671009,
0.001097251,
-0.0011130975,
0.0029232893,
0.0297840405,
-0.0055813962,
-0.004421568,
0.042310141,
-0.0044451496,
0.0366898254,
0.0709442049,
0.0013333283,
-0.022024272,
0.0258816574,
-0.0449268818,
-0.0068096453,
0.0254550222,
-0.0367649756,
-0.0751350373,
-0.0241362359,
0.0235707015,
0.0197456833,
0.0404662155,
-0.0083529828,
-0.1005087197,
0.0517529845,
0.0303231385,
-0.0110701881,
0.028510591,
0.006562754,
-0.0045108809,
-0.0564115904,
0.022844946,
0.0456669107,
0.0508592501,
0.0217779092,
0.0115620764,
0.0163345207,
0.0396440811,
0.0587653369,
0.0648311526,
-0.0669371337,
-0.00910322,
0.0034889609,
0.0374838896,
0.0111318491,
-0.0344272964,
-0.0421409011,
0.0033424825,
-0.0147216981,
0.0290244408,
0.0638911426,
-0.0444159545,
0.0785102919,
0.0216040239,
-0.0078061381,
-0.0261129923,
0.0136962682,
-0.0344195664,
0.0082917614,
0.0093274917,
-0.0026598824,
0.003180447,
0.0387085862,
0.05794039,
0.0358094163,
0.0356053002,
-0.0099315317,
0.0197784714,
-0.0051160729,
-0.013816081,
0.0489440188,
-0.0401404761,
-0.0031356688,
0.0553584881,
-0.044545874,
-0.0559830219,
0.0142598618,
-0.0776369125,
0.0167690739,
0.027750276,
-0.0229639746,
0.03083992,
-0.0130408453,
-0.0121077588,
-0.0151746413,
-0.0204762761,
0.0279034562,
0.0126875406,
0.0293409601,
-6.053028897e-33,
-0.0558522418,
0.0218404159,
0.0070564495,
-0.0140106855,
-0.0008271471,
0.0043739579,
-0.0497243069,
0.0387585834,
-0.0686539859,
-0.0173221193,
-0.0425133482,
-0.0207906924,
0.0528177693,
0.0522529669,
0.0071654115,
0.0067161508,
0.0321915038,
0.0347940475,
-0.0321831852,
0.0039246161,
0.0599491671,
0.1003247201,
0.0945127755,
-0.0431451909,
0.0077836104,
0.0248539597,
0.0084282877,
-0.0368510932,
0.0635693893,
0.041108232,
-0.0168706998,
-0.008306494,
0.0204644874,
-0.0496025681,
0.010816508,
-0.004743584,
-0.125335753,
-0.0090402029,
0.010928547,
0.0534647107,
0.0020149134,
-0.0601659007,
0.0136073222,
0.0125793209,
0.0141614946,
-0.023889536,
-0.0034199071,
-0.0575394779,
-0.039770592,
-0.0102319159,
-0.1050661728,
0.0594424605,
0.0146602085,
0.0396907032,
0.0615323298,
-0.0025536211,
-0.0075193578,
-0.0293645132,
-0.0090158666,
-0.0065275123,
0.0365644507,
0.0457621738,
0.0443365984,
0.0386321954,
-0.0633108318,
0.0036585105,
0.0480768494,
-0.0086203096,
0.0348617919,
-0.0067635435,
0.0637339726,
0.0213774554,
-0.010781304,
0.0612801313,
0.0400634818,
-0.0575681962,
-0.0809493586,
0.0050450917,
-0.013268467,
-0.0199418217,
-0.0179048683,
-0.0001561838,
-0.0374154784,
-0.0175876357,
-0.0033831659,
-0.0583687462,
-0.0190175455,
-0.0156062944,
0.0400788076,
-0.0005010882,
-0.0246522147,
0.0386190712,
0.0541307665,
-0.0155996094,
-0.0701558292,
-0.0433356091,
0.0093524456,
0.029307548,
-0.0126706492,
-0.0280884616,
-0.0786557868,
-0.078412883,
-0.0232580546,
0.0307740141,
0.0272292029,
-0.0082476968,
0.0854490846,
-0.0188261233,
-0.077484414,
0.0023091165,
-0.0239231903,
0.0352341235,
0.009845526,
0.0616470985,
0.0192957222,
-0.0296831876,
-0.0059323516,
0.0160681009,
0.0475157052,
-0.0372116305,
0.0242290292,
0.02127726,
0.0208657067,
0.0058437306,
-0.0338159241,
-0.005420316,
0.0010799087,
0.0129313618,
0.0015860139,
-0.0269978326,
-0.0280336794,
0.0140698813,
2.482e-7,
-0.0023516396,
-0.0059278873,
0.0168655179,
-0.0569005907,
-0.0154650444,
0.0125532933,
-0.0256603565,
0.0119587313,
-0.0101195471,
0.0249577407,
-0.0254519321,
-0.0018630499,
0.0845647678,
0.0177676175,
-0.0634277686,
-0.0370199345,
0.0074956845,
0.0371313617,
-0.0353664458,
-0.0060267877,
-0.0492528006,
0.0902274996,
-0.0057845418,
-0.0229369588,
-0.0070849122,
-0.04044725,
0.0665933266,
-0.0366905257,
0.031592533,
0.0070795259,
-0.0258130264,
0.074578397,
-0.0391531028,
0.0441852994,
-0.0337199718,
0.0257830564,
0.0290647801,
0.0321979113,
-0.0083242953,
0.0222540516,
0.0038392534,
-0.0063796039,
-0.0146322148,
-0.027329823,
0.0758040473,
-0.0316491313,
-0.0695438683,
-0.0079419622,
-0.0044247815,
0.0158168655,
0.0234162025,
-0.0073266439,
0.0091973981,
0.0070682173,
0.0347633511,
-0.021362111,
-0.0753219947,
-0.0240655784,
0.0336956643,
0.031343963,
0.0234586075,
-0.0075441175,
-0.0169057772,
-0.0099595794,
0.0310558602,
-0.0193417314,
0.0289972704,
1.952556269e-34,
-0.032721974,
0.0033398776,
0.0294824746,
0.0154418023,
-0.0312487353,
-0.0200395901,
-0.0177303273,
-0.0096373325,
-0.0237854272,
-0.0102855908,
0.020279061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05272v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05272v1 | Minuteman: Machine and Human Joining Forces in Meeting Summarization | 2023-09-11T07:10:47 | 2023-09-11T07:10:47 | František Kmječ, Ondřej Bojar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many meetings require creating a meeting summary to keep everyone up to date.
Creating minutes of sufficient quality is however very cognitively demanding.
Although we currently possess capable models for both audio speech recognition
(ASR) and summarization, their fully automatic use is still problematic. ASR
models frequently commit errors when transcribing named entities while the
summarization models tend to hallucinate and misinterpret the transcript. We
propose a novel tool -- Minuteman -- to enable efficient semi-automatic meeting
minuting. The tool provides a live transcript and a live meeting summary to the
users, who can edit them in a collaborative manner, enabling correction of ASR
errors and imperfect summary points in real time. The resulting application
eases the cognitive load of the notetakers and allows them to easily catch up
if they missed a part of the meeting due to absence or a lack of focus. We
conduct several tests of the application in varied settings, exploring the
worthiness of the concept and the possible user strategies. | [
0.0161460415,
-0.0230945293,
-0.0037633146,
0.0008952972,
-0.0078626433,
-0.0006936114,
0.0000864466,
-0.0260921586,
-0.0735272542,
-0.0030947884,
-0.026939394,
-0.0050343256,
0.0514790341,
0.0140920635,
-0.0232353099,
-0.1398703307,
0.0412608385,
-0.0306587499,
0.0228540096,
0.0149113862,
0.035406217,
-0.0004303872,
-0.0467230938,
0.0431619361,
-0.0103856698,
0.0065658554,
-0.0169402529,
0.0057696793,
0.0168035962,
0.0117436387,
-0.0696431845,
0.0425435193,
-0.0203676019,
0.0344869867,
0.0000018728,
-0.0393209718,
-0.0322541706,
0.0041732998,
-0.0505156703,
-0.0196396206,
0.0069074417,
-0.0003212129,
-0.0468276627,
0.0398666039,
0.0023126977,
0.0336119719,
0.0259365346,
0.0359224454,
0.0253698453,
0.0294560492,
-0.0234676488,
0.0277839489,
-0.0018217703,
-0.0111284908,
0.0166253652,
-0.0102911806,
-0.0249159206,
0.0203558989,
0.022419855,
-0.0540663637,
0.042114757,
0.0412192978,
-0.0307778846,
-0.0401711538,
0.005637581,
0.0107246041,
-0.0792143494,
-0.0472967327,
-0.0410475582,
0.0503710061,
0.0288976077,
0.0337543041,
0.0406589098,
0.0033543217,
0.0097886324,
0.0065595424,
-0.0664913803,
0.0114512844,
-0.035787899,
-0.0071037775,
-0.0523892194,
0.033899527,
0.0039633838,
-0.0081946887,
0.0420507006,
-0.0127838627,
0.0066037425,
-0.0256481841,
-0.0497560278,
-0.0117086889,
-0.0116840294,
-0.0407900065,
0.0711680502,
0.0355776511,
-0.0066876556,
-0.0084028319,
-0.022849543,
-0.0347352065,
0.0016622575,
-0.0192306843,
0.0254070759,
0.0353653915,
0.0189152695,
0.0627466142,
0.0438824557,
0.0214369465,
0.0767825767,
-0.0223164875,
-0.0066808001,
-0.0222977865,
0.0078458767,
0.0071925684,
-0.0343395695,
0.0316044316,
-0.0553087778,
-0.0380437896,
-0.0422350429,
0.0404410399,
-0.0061279456,
0.0514059551,
0.017934259,
-0.0042075398,
-0.017049158,
-0.0306370966,
0.0088170599,
0.0115926675,
-0.0313363969,
0.0357005224,
0.0278621782,
-0.0476764217,
0.0028137721,
0.0066684149,
0.0415753648,
0.0518457256,
-0.0202073939,
0.0380819887,
-0.0111981323,
-0.0111409947,
-0.0042416272,
-0.0484180041,
-0.0470292978,
-0.025711786,
-0.0607940778,
-0.0484381728,
0.0413194932,
0.0006611495,
-0.0524669178,
0.0091064312,
0.0161626022,
-0.0137499012,
0.0125877066,
0.0526795015,
-0.029765347,
0.0393233821,
0.0820343345,
0.0139514953,
-0.0421538912,
0.0191618558,
0.0661823004,
0.0026470546,
0.0529999845,
0.0130766947,
0.0226120055,
0.0576043241,
-0.026846163,
0.0064653624,
0.0397661813,
-0.0352429412,
-0.0103269722,
0.006900352,
-0.0156171368,
0.0667982474,
-0.0160187148,
0.0288643353,
0.0773819238,
0.094471626,
-0.0165873133,
-0.003142569,
-0.0141122378,
0.0127518773,
-0.0081366701,
0.0310300477,
0.0083955303,
0.026713429,
-0.0143906856,
0.0324180499,
0.1128268763,
-0.0218221545,
-0.0182295628,
-0.0491555482,
-0.0077979141,
-0.0307303257,
-0.0239274278,
0.0076402249,
0.0126466425,
-0.0137147717,
-0.0454953089,
0.0533024259,
-0.0287929028,
-0.0917835832,
0.0009072765,
-0.0151678752,
-0.016278144,
0.0923352018,
0.0364734903,
-0.048741363,
-0.0256910082,
-0.0403531864,
-0.0215014946,
0.039038565,
0.0700701848,
-0.0260721687,
0.0036695781,
-0.0490227044,
0.0243945736,
0.0684375688,
-0.0130162304,
0.0126394629,
-0.0172729567,
0.0132274972,
0.0357677042,
0.0046296008,
0.005734622,
-0.0012850829,
0.0211675689,
-0.0366218314,
-0.0235413369,
0.0144677339,
0.0348812677,
0.0566310436,
-0.003292274,
0.0080012996,
0.0378220603,
0.0044934857,
0.0076053869,
0.0670634881,
-0.0665267408,
-0.0087314676,
0.0604251176,
-0.0268611535,
0.0017141517,
-0.0107520316,
0.0090173557,
-0.0904622152,
0.0020945382,
-0.0287279543,
0.0094010802,
-0.0427037179,
0.0786488801,
0.0278168786,
-0.0171257481,
0.0444951616,
-0.0276180785,
0.0040677311,
-0.0253889691,
0.0513558425,
-0.0379849933,
0.0093622701,
-0.0770476535,
0.0229511056,
0.0303339195,
-0.0120102782,
0.0157030374,
0.0023763848,
-0.0459548123,
-0.0348282717,
-0.0284447391,
-0.1201698184,
-0.0066745328,
-0.009140024,
0.0009218028,
0.022906214,
0.0574420057,
-0.0090188701,
-0.0316230357,
0.0053517339,
-0.0538358018,
0.0362193882,
-0.024446968,
-0.0209409688,
0.0121847652,
0.0163886696,
-0.0704862326,
0.0068096537,
0.0020856503,
-0.01506624,
0.0273319073,
-0.0772528201,
-0.0429658256,
-0.0054903594,
-0.0137305241,
0.0039057904,
0.0104198428,
0.0124965878,
0.0088119889,
0.0183081347,
0.0641641691,
0.0272410419,
0.0282930359,
0.0148061998,
0.0144312959,
0.011397141,
-0.0343127996,
-0.0085471999,
0.0108749038,
0.048722662,
0.0236659609,
-0.0077484334,
0.0146824159,
0.0033719121,
0.0420796648,
0.0726221055,
-0.024598401,
0.0299072787,
-0.0056941346,
-0.0023121457,
-0.0161921605,
-0.0553760007,
-0.0543449335,
0.0267264303,
-0.0117242495,
-0.0104061589,
0.0203435533,
-0.0544027798,
-0.0120725185,
0.0055629429,
-0.0544850528,
-0.033124201,
0.0484738871,
-0.0717473179,
0.0073116245,
-0.0333433002,
-0.0550579168,
-0.0226281714,
-0.0371685773,
0.0569244921,
-0.0694900602,
0.0172761828,
-0.0518264174,
-0.0081033548,
0.0003132024,
-0.017759528,
-0.0126387421,
-0.0097808279,
-0.0552092902,
0.0415029339,
0.0317394435,
-0.0089602182,
-0.0676784217,
0.0767942145,
0.0229569655,
0.036614906,
0.0152763436,
0.0103062056,
-0.0017375904,
0.0118799051,
0.0138903689,
0.0350861959,
-0.0144074252,
-0.0218513422,
0.0509791635,
0.0255592279,
0.0864006281,
-0.0157894194,
0.022733584,
-0.0296040624,
-0.0076459511,
-0.0356718823,
-0.0016890452,
-0.0049935919,
0.0458599553,
-0.0270933434,
0.0661428794,
0.1112801731,
0.006753251,
-0.0456410311,
-0.0265952256,
-0.0550983921,
-0.0004270542,
-0.0034567518,
0.0014954144,
-0.0507064499,
-0.01318035,
0.0677632019,
0.0977473408,
0.0213830732,
-0.0078337006,
-0.0026300817,
-0.042177774,
0.0245510023,
0.034819223,
-0.0475416742,
-0.0148658808,
-0.0344817452,
-0.0076718428,
-0.0106861722,
0.0394379534,
0.0189806148,
-0.0407937542,
-0.0392102562,
0.0172961075,
-0.0990580618,
-0.006772636,
0.018646637,
-0.0205896795,
0.073514685,
0.0918593183,
0.0761413947,
0.0404235758,
-0.0140370354,
0.0077526681,
-0.0068895533,
0.0216292962,
-0.0052154642,
0.0545590743,
-0.0168060511,
0.0119224926,
0.0125580234,
0.0589802787,
0.0363700911,
0.0023575213,
0.0388708599,
0.0206966214,
-0.0134478062,
0.0258583203,
-0.0058139558,
0.0505479835,
0.0260450579,
0.0411734022,
0.0304328706,
0.0084156757,
-0.0279191509,
0.000173653,
0.0237621255,
-0.065228425,
0.0191643815,
-0.015088642,
-0.0120004043,
-0.0242134891,
-0.0531561412,
-0.0610530041,
0.0557727143,
0.006988998,
0.0090313656,
0.0063407985,
0.019062005,
0.0645316243,
-0.0490783416,
-0.0247246642,
-0.0029422722,
0.0013549619,
-0.0766487271,
-0.0290609039,
0.0014936121,
0.009416244,
0.0181028023,
0.0202385206,
-0.0356338806,
-0.0441018231,
0.0114530446,
0.0226731114,
0.030346809,
0.0623523779,
0.0134861255,
0.003809737,
0.0020944907,
-0.0095845303,
-0.0063666892,
0.0194997489,
0.0202536825,
0.0286034532,
-0.0432013273,
0.006846319,
-0.0571445227,
0.0113137672,
-0.0669567436,
0.0222943649,
-0.0573910736,
-0.0687064901,
-0.0160372015,
0.0490545258,
-0.0116670588,
-0.0127298953,
-0.0014363722,
-0.0126233166,
0.0360466279,
-0.0060992306,
0.0324422978,
-0.0274125449,
-0.0002421177,
-0.0630282909,
-0.02541079,
0.0143574383,
0.0306981727,
-0.0714706928,
-0.0484594889,
-0.0225818269,
0.0406304784,
-0.0324713252,
-0.0518264808,
0.0109462412,
-0.0093279872,
-0.0210210625,
0.0451588184,
0.0163481459,
0.0086150169,
-0.0066653132,
0.0251838434,
-0.0262876693,
0.0113768559,
0.025020523,
0.0363803431,
-0.0550657138,
-0.0236149542,
-0.0325438604,
0.0597538576,
0.0124573605,
-0.0012883808,
0.0430765003,
-0.0237635057,
0.0244563427,
-0.0589751899,
0.0325128995,
-0.0303545743,
-0.0044222977,
-0.0391887091,
0.0041378168,
-0.0008585252,
0.0419300422,
0.0561037771,
-0.0964696631,
-0.0142770875,
0.0049546272,
-0.0148560163,
-0.0654220805,
-0.0186095424,
-0.0514094867,
-0.0123205306,
-0.0325924121,
-0.0543637499,
-0.043541193,
-0.0095525915,
0.0488391295,
0.0067238463,
0.0208291076,
-0.0465014279,
0.017215373,
0.0038748588,
-0.014834106,
0.0286834389,
-0.0122174174,
-0.0131108649,
-0.0376542918,
0.0065890322,
-0.0025348156,
-5.482810546e-33,
-0.0700257421,
-0.0757707879,
0.0144061558,
0.0218804684,
-0.0047726231,
-0.0141069358,
-0.0470247455,
0.0278621297,
0.0327473618,
-0.043351572,
-0.0114483172,
0.001388547,
0.0371818393,
-0.007094596,
0.0284183919,
0.0326091684,
0.1053529605,
-0.024130756,
-0.0084946128,
0.0198076759,
0.022354681,
0.0192447919,
-0.0430178307,
-0.0727205873,
0.0050872648,
0.0094498266,
-0.0117348107,
-0.0245976392,
0.0613647811,
0.0114360107,
0.0284976661,
-0.009382667,
-0.0209660474,
0.0081767347,
-0.0396946929,
0.0381392688,
-0.0856946036,
0.0004138503,
0.0058504469,
0.0279388372,
0.0342279114,
-0.0019515714,
0.0012535992,
0.002666974,
-0.0030563478,
-0.003698271,
0.0322296657,
-0.0246912204,
-0.0777697265,
-0.0373724289,
-0.0268813483,
0.041407086,
-0.0339237414,
-0.057497859,
0.0503374189,
0.0507803261,
0.0174914189,
-0.0889171138,
-0.070138447,
0.0815772712,
0.0253573433,
-0.0069464883,
0.0587369576,
0.0121323112,
-0.0227257442,
0.0414254069,
0.0277984049,
-0.0116662169,
-0.0106387548,
-0.008295645,
-0.0077490867,
0.0283745639,
0.0300193839,
-0.0178293567,
0.0250449665,
-0.0290175565,
0.034368664,
0.0655945688,
-0.0137874931,
-0.0177933425,
0.0265613701,
0.0504479297,
-0.024141429,
0.0260606315,
-0.0170870107,
0.0303402934,
-0.0067414492,
-0.0368319899,
0.0034084253,
0.0119326366,
0.0004437953,
-0.0143197728,
0.0135839041,
0.0097404504,
0.0383270159,
-0.0305400509,
0.0080110915,
-0.0001074807,
-0.0281443726,
-0.0486317426,
-0.0263215583,
0.0133673437,
0.0476870202,
0.0621701963,
0.0322338641,
0.0089641241,
0.0016923713,
0.0367844999,
-0.0349171758,
0.0015280725,
0.0332071446,
0.0464067608,
-0.0220893156,
-0.014206103,
0.0123101817,
-0.0256669708,
-0.022504434,
0.0000723397,
-0.0353645198,
-0.0126055209,
-0.0229635146,
0.0062164194,
-0.0095342621,
0.011812184,
-0.0618389547,
0.0278866198,
0.0039168345,
0.005662241,
0.0516442768,
0.0314647555,
0.0102283154,
-0.0527455471,
2.596e-7,
0.0000362454,
0.0430870019,
0.0547990464,
-0.0421753451,
-0.0061975345,
0.0117469858,
-0.0078527201,
-0.0066095949,
0.0030035905,
0.0611422546,
0.0942764133,
-0.0079229688,
0.0941282138,
0.0426406562,
-0.0911388844,
-0.0523381867,
-0.0746976361,
-0.0104414532,
-0.0182230119,
0.0330810435,
0.0097710434,
0.0206196811,
-0.005491463,
-0.0074260477,
-0.0040827249,
-0.0403172821,
0.0030300978,
-0.0394631177,
-0.019381972,
-0.0362707004,
0.0306367725,
0.0000035082,
-0.0599229373,
-0.0150074307,
-0.0356674269,
-0.0266420599,
0.0311576966,
0.0446251892,
-0.0311320256,
-0.0600116216,
-0.0103140352,
0.0181645956,
-0.0104355766,
0.048276864,
0.0004568116,
-0.0184640959,
0.0149655566,
0.0053839954,
-0.0428925306,
0.0178326853,
-0.0152000263,
0.0305132549,
0.0075098188,
0.0239960402,
-0.0180712994,
0.0114497179,
-0.0051901634,
-0.0268142503,
0.0208278783,
0.0240474399,
-0.0180522539,
-0.05921413,
-0.0228943396,
-0.0439088345,
-0.0504784249,
-0.0246837717,
-0.0185808521,
1.802125594e-34,
0.0383226313,
0.016273262,
-0.0297544263,
0.0141786095,
0.0373435058,
-0.0060325861,
0.0549396314,
0.0125973588,
0.0313551351,
-0.0234401654,
-0.052191034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05270v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05270v2 | CONFLATOR: Incorporating Switching Point based Rotatory Positional Encodings for Code-Mixed Language Modeling | 2023-09-11T07:02:13 | 2023-10-18T23:48:40 | Mohsin Ali, Kandukuri Sai Teja, Neeharika Gupta, Parth Patwa, Anubhab Chatterjee, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha, Amitava Das | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The mixing of two or more languages is called Code-Mixing (CM). CM is a
social norm in multilingual societies. Neural Language Models (NLMs) like
transformers have been effective on many NLP tasks. However, NLM for CM is an
under-explored area. Though transformers are capable and powerful, they cannot
always encode positional information since they are non-recurrent. Therefore,
to enrich word information and incorporate positional information, positional
encoding is defined. We hypothesize that Switching Points (SPs), i.e.,
junctions in the text where the language switches (L1 -> L2 or L2 -> L1), pose
a challenge for CM Language Models (LMs), and hence give special emphasis to
SPs in the modeling process. We experiment with several positional encoding
mechanisms and show that rotatory positional encodings along with switching
point information yield the best results.
We introduce CONFLATOR: a neural language modeling approach for code-mixed
languages. CONFLATOR tries to learn to emphasize switching points using smarter
positional encoding, both at unigram and bigram levels. CONFLATOR outperforms
the state-of-the-art on two tasks based on code-mixed Hindi and English
(Hinglish): (i) sentiment analysis and (ii) machine translation. | [
0.0152613176,
0.040945638,
-0.0260796417,
0.0591087304,
-0.0346236192,
0.0289377831,
-0.0319988467,
0.0019643058,
-0.0096211899,
-0.0226447396,
-0.0466890521,
-0.0535828806,
0.0493592434,
0.0388850868,
0.0528534912,
-0.0311567206,
0.0300078634,
-0.010041534,
-0.0258369148,
-0.0079655545,
0.0511484072,
0.0208219346,
0.0084929187,
0.0296697728,
-0.0102142747,
-0.0288900509,
-0.0053833262,
0.011047422,
0.0339447372,
-0.0160185024,
0.0385940298,
0.0410355069,
0.0027487245,
0.0460117124,
0.0000019709,
0.0189849716,
-0.0296359099,
-0.022730682,
0.0196122508,
0.0131515674,
0.0476603769,
-0.057080619,
-0.0172606297,
0.0273687877,
-0.0375828035,
-0.0484488234,
0.0967910811,
-0.0102227172,
0.0418440104,
0.1070993468,
-0.0169266667,
-0.0508326143,
0.0230558068,
-0.0446968749,
-0.0223739874,
0.0011820772,
0.0145192957,
0.0115153762,
-0.0010274126,
0.0198970884,
-0.0622184537,
0.0260218065,
0.0146100558,
-0.0022302279,
-0.0134495506,
0.0085215308,
-0.0399233289,
0.007545949,
-0.0159107167,
0.0604053773,
-0.1225885972,
-0.0604641028,
0.0030839029,
-0.0150605477,
-0.0353425257,
-0.0726703778,
-0.0246687252,
-0.000161382,
-0.0016125838,
0.0457822345,
0.0453848839,
0.0139217656,
0.0269819666,
-0.009562714,
-0.0317364261,
0.051681418,
0.0133159207,
-0.0222316589,
-0.0716700628,
-0.0073440573,
0.0434421711,
-0.0528288856,
0.0342691094,
0.0164063144,
0.009022153,
0.0277302191,
-0.0154355401,
-0.0414996222,
0.0090369564,
-0.0691249892,
0.002334578,
0.0254208259,
-0.0230969284,
0.0203506742,
-0.0323983394,
0.0298620947,
-0.0418251157,
0.0360781103,
-0.017464526,
-0.0118775889,
-0.004736112,
-0.0257938225,
-0.0115669202,
0.000810068,
-0.0351532921,
0.0068997722,
-0.0263218507,
0.0304109156,
-0.0290416759,
-0.0168106519,
0.0355304442,
-0.0051135002,
0.0025957404,
-0.0157269295,
0.0189736038,
0.0386782438,
-0.0351030491,
-0.003387199,
-0.0167521685,
-0.0368700139,
-0.0043886174,
0.0347989202,
0.0119599365,
-0.0102105923,
-0.013433421,
0.0416417383,
-0.0121337455,
-0.0012299906,
0.0005205177,
0.0246601924,
-0.0322891064,
-0.0257347431,
0.0029885413,
-0.0901503488,
0.0625298023,
0.013782273,
0.0154490676,
-0.0643286183,
0.0118698115,
0.0315095037,
-0.0362652913,
0.0843585506,
-0.0267243572,
-0.0171101913,
-0.0081834244,
-0.0052140774,
0.0192397628,
0.0653255656,
0.0649971068,
0.0091366088,
0.0283510238,
-0.0111330291,
-0.0013288725,
0.0486276485,
-0.0104327584,
-0.0314380042,
-0.0177364089,
-0.0305440146,
0.0316681229,
0.0110225696,
0.0424657874,
0.0544047505,
-0.0231873486,
-0.0169446133,
0.0007820502,
0.0068231747,
0.0319625065,
0.0439382605,
0.0331766456,
0.0071122758,
-0.013170097,
0.0171484053,
0.0026666403,
0.0421714261,
-0.0246094856,
-0.0153528629,
0.0197980888,
0.0475479029,
-0.0142032262,
-0.031000901,
-0.0221342985,
-0.0573935322,
0.0777723715,
-0.0337567478,
0.0262711607,
-0.0022160162,
-0.0533722863,
0.0321635008,
0.0406692475,
-0.022734981,
0.0341693684,
0.0011632723,
-0.0190158989,
0.0644459352,
-0.0087067252,
-0.0122489464,
-0.0155070471,
-0.0042435145,
-0.0449931733,
0.0439063907,
0.0341639034,
0.0021953769,
0.0143185314,
-0.0775609314,
0.0122712627,
0.0079368064,
0.0022630091,
0.0466947295,
0.0223938599,
0.031269066,
-0.0017750566,
0.038574893,
-0.0250035319,
0.0075161094,
-0.0063100569,
0.0452103652,
-0.0110644326,
-0.0136226704,
0.0181945264,
-0.0040533789,
0.0119837075,
0.0304668527,
0.0120742619,
-0.0479681455,
-0.0023661989,
0.0281788148,
-0.051711712,
-0.0738216937,
0.0263699964,
-0.014649828,
-0.000327476,
0.0203630775,
-0.0227122754,
-0.0278998148,
0.04364926,
-0.0117262229,
0.0751710162,
-0.035859976,
0.0408781059,
0.0114656119,
0.0109821726,
-0.0345909819,
0.054220926,
0.0037323774,
0.0132513698,
-0.0149835339,
-0.0203860532,
0.024561299,
0.01018974,
-0.0424478464,
0.0198978875,
-0.0126850605,
0.0323063247,
-0.0035732733,
0.0008684883,
-0.0019564063,
-0.094221428,
-0.0770707652,
-0.0064873705,
-0.0196185894,
-0.0033998762,
0.0291845873,
0.01217598,
0.0067950739,
0.007091308,
-0.0462706909,
0.0240333695,
0.0028285538,
0.0238634199,
0.0507059842,
0.0121396948,
-0.0187486634,
-0.0502189733,
-0.0184487272,
-0.0187746435,
0.0551122278,
-0.0316799916,
-0.0402822681,
-0.0963773951,
0.0211606827,
0.0085504446,
0.0281072371,
-0.016556032,
-0.0800251365,
0.0092156827,
-0.0296291783,
0.0496095419,
0.0428876355,
-0.0026888244,
-0.0000101069,
0.0278835427,
-0.0400493294,
-0.0461430289,
-0.0087283356,
0.0001381726,
0.0086798081,
-0.0300507676,
-0.0271370951,
-0.0125511531,
0.0869132131,
-0.0051816371,
-0.0062904512,
-0.0772443935,
-0.0343249328,
-0.0163516365,
-0.0028165902,
0.0273045078,
-0.029808756,
-0.0462084115,
0.0406221598,
-0.0481782965,
-0.0282041579,
0.0489033237,
-0.0386761315,
-0.0095404917,
-0.0767543688,
0.0230775382,
-0.0736829415,
0.0049377684,
-0.0037975956,
0.028296398,
-0.0033105265,
-0.0459977165,
-0.0590854734,
0.0064150793,
-0.0284197554,
-0.0539913401,
0.0267846994,
-0.0192042235,
-0.0225158315,
-0.0093730362,
-0.0444892161,
-0.0291011389,
-0.0225364342,
-0.0165962968,
-0.0121216597,
0.0691312253,
-0.0424418226,
0.0661842227,
0.0367228985,
-0.0227272958,
0.0266832449,
-0.0131700737,
0.043737296,
-0.0041667377,
0.0124056991,
0.0349642746,
0.0062413141,
-0.0100920759,
0.0039013075,
-0.050654795,
-0.0092966231,
0.0031185346,
0.0331188738,
-0.0480749272,
0.003094102,
0.0515940525,
0.0050975652,
-0.0680848435,
-0.0301219784,
0.0159621611,
-0.0266879108,
-0.0206096321,
0.08982981,
0.0354308002,
-0.1025867313,
-0.0019059425,
-0.0254455525,
0.0618670844,
0.0104955165,
0.0311455689,
-0.0651466623,
-0.0002188678,
-0.0104297344,
-0.049294956,
0.0224400163,
0.0151923923,
-0.0146794952,
-0.1274057031,
-0.0161167495,
0.0278625023,
-0.0397267118,
-0.0930863023,
0.0295299832,
-0.0254697856,
0.0109533975,
-0.0259865839,
0.0186854657,
-0.0114775775,
-0.0247109272,
0.0366161577,
-0.0308239628,
-0.026971247,
-0.0162442997,
-0.047575023,
0.0591539294,
0.0730450377,
0.0260630213,
-0.002472457,
-0.0576315299,
0.0185395963,
-0.0071028671,
-0.0268099941,
0.0098970486,
0.0216772016,
-0.0314469375,
-0.0414511897,
0.0262615662,
-0.0105364155,
-0.0356645398,
-0.0142650018,
-0.0591950417,
0.0563427135,
0.0318091437,
0.0126409158,
0.0059242714,
0.0329436213,
0.0067207995,
0.0215080492,
0.0373441689,
-0.0673771277,
-0.010610939,
-0.0409516767,
0.0475020595,
-0.0253921766,
-0.0192053989,
0.0028504548,
0.0505374297,
-0.0480263531,
-0.0805794448,
-0.04616303,
-0.0047508329,
0.0393719822,
0.0079051666,
0.0394790582,
0.0304502882,
-0.0415280759,
-0.0566314831,
-0.0283554588,
-0.0178503394,
0.0191826746,
-0.0524501279,
-0.0145572452,
0.0328411311,
-0.0171962883,
0.0020616129,
-0.0433969311,
-0.106244646,
-0.0562181994,
0.0208779853,
0.0453099459,
0.0160211697,
0.0409262218,
-0.0513610058,
-0.0583746992,
-0.0251475088,
0.0015185769,
-0.0059216777,
0.0227482338,
0.0544020906,
0.0209399853,
0.002285341,
0.0209193584,
-0.0329642817,
-0.0405794196,
-0.0184400976,
0.0182215106,
-0.0722106025,
-0.007877293,
0.0143208625,
-0.0638321191,
0.0190368518,
-0.0209472943,
-0.0074490481,
-0.0457834825,
0.0256404858,
-0.0097571705,
-0.0039539644,
-0.0298621282,
-0.0145309744,
0.0580808371,
-0.0261809584,
-0.0322522372,
0.0023218342,
0.0097867958,
-0.0026300431,
0.0720317066,
0.0596116334,
0.0733263344,
0.0439754166,
0.0114069544,
0.0509549864,
-0.0114906095,
0.0367388912,
-0.0237672422,
0.0385335386,
-0.0415665247,
0.036721684,
0.0053951405,
-0.0283561144,
-0.0008824954,
0.0700457096,
-0.012812485,
0.0129290912,
-0.000287314,
-0.0178806409,
0.0592702813,
-0.0010264205,
0.0869401991,
0.0139214713,
-0.0027757171,
0.000988913,
0.0141951516,
-0.012094452,
-0.0549091287,
0.0465209819,
0.0168095529,
-0.0115912789,
0.0040058433,
0.0877813175,
-0.028058283,
-0.0109721711,
-0.0218450464,
0.0081911096,
0.0122884801,
0.0355735496,
0.0534054488,
-0.0107380226,
-0.0115180817,
-0.0060758474,
-0.0589538105,
-0.069538638,
0.0588490367,
0.0035550115,
0.0335191526,
-0.0097732721,
0.0133316731,
0.0610937215,
0.0102750948,
0.0626137406,
-0.0520121716,
0.0108914953,
0.0953233093,
-0.0478980392,
-0.0407960229,
-6.654432378e-33,
-0.0054226499,
-0.0026319288,
-0.0175884087,
0.0035627461,
-0.0179789085,
0.0138334762,
-0.03445049,
-0.0008635271,
-0.0167063661,
-0.0079977885,
0.0012272359,
0.0083341394,
0.0099987369,
0.0037864416,
0.041126579,
-0.0201876611,
-0.0002453354,
0.0151678016,
0.0327172615,
0.0149740521,
0.0341165066,
0.0264269169,
0.0544046387,
-0.0363483913,
0.0328695662,
-0.0195616372,
-0.0257705394,
0.0085628629,
0.0005178686,
0.0525020361,
-0.0305127464,
0.0200086758,
0.0301016346,
0.0112436414,
0.0049652243,
0.0338330977,
-0.0617979392,
-0.0044312463,
0.0252410192,
0.0408030413,
-0.0075908406,
-0.0592599511,
0.0585473366,
-0.0444031246,
0.01873843,
0.0087600127,
0.0052921427,
-0.0042328355,
-0.014871493,
-0.0161357224,
-0.0669314042,
0.0376231298,
0.0209713709,
-0.0155949881,
-0.0002602865,
0.0329645127,
0.0218185242,
0.0326882526,
-0.0953407288,
0.0082332576,
-0.018999204,
0.0563907735,
0.0355969034,
0.0098370975,
-0.0209980868,
0.0466823392,
0.0395341963,
-0.0026734523,
0.0153919328,
0.0312739462,
0.0636177585,
-0.0074161305,
0.0419214815,
0.0259528272,
0.0363847688,
-0.0322658569,
-0.0298890918,
-0.0153518822,
0.0087027289,
0.0001790306,
0.0158496965,
0.0387146585,
-0.0470237955,
-0.0526959002,
0.002670154,
-0.0655596331,
-0.0277364627,
-0.0597025603,
0.0138129788,
0.0145837199,
-0.0118532032,
0.0258106645,
0.0468297862,
-0.042634733,
0.0106220646,
0.0199004356,
-0.0064962148,
0.0575240664,
0.0115291756,
0.0730061382,
-0.0375969782,
-0.0182334352,
-0.0032359348,
-0.0021525118,
0.038468536,
0.0215612222,
0.0421445295,
0.0392808728,
-0.0659178048,
-0.0112105329,
-0.028438352,
0.0017513811,
-0.0172985494,
0.0346588343,
0.0257409178,
0.0238666199,
-0.0037765657,
0.0387339406,
0.0333683863,
0.0514017195,
-0.0305458736,
-0.0119175306,
-0.0224021245,
0.0488694496,
-0.0279972628,
-0.0141727943,
-0.0280431155,
0.0662261024,
0.0187786911,
-0.0487239324,
0.0010999606,
0.0324213877,
2.845e-7,
0.0806197152,
0.036008127,
0.039457202,
-0.0004617723,
0.0211988259,
-0.0046968362,
-0.0298578739,
0.023059817,
0.023531327,
0.0016140026,
-0.0391682722,
0.0014728735,
0.0267145671,
0.0188778881,
-0.10615547,
-0.002346531,
-0.0304466728,
-0.000966305,
-0.0175325852,
-0.017870428,
0.0481312983,
0.1304541081,
0.0040499144,
0.0292466059,
-0.0080760289,
0.0218661632,
0.058633063,
0.0070092361,
-0.0051364126,
0.0071218037,
-0.0534354486,
-0.0103240097,
-0.0160962082,
-0.0377126969,
-0.0260974914,
0.016763553,
0.0348497815,
0.0474788994,
-0.0220094789,
-0.0523283556,
0.0292655807,
-0.0228836946,
-0.0465500318,
-0.0720471218,
0.06677185,
-0.0369493589,
0.0036701069,
-0.0284024291,
0.0044718995,
0.0460945591,
0.0205677338,
-0.0254638735,
-0.0448146462,
0.0359385535,
0.0170721505,
-0.0410254821,
-0.0239804238,
-0.0791026801,
-0.0551784448,
-0.0126178637,
-0.0089559909,
0.0177855603,
-0.0228484254,
-0.0110646226,
0.0429755971,
0.0146514708,
0.0163904987,
2.653477607e-34,
0.0459997915,
-0.0327563323,
0.0059237634,
0.036982961,
0.0432085916,
-0.0158058442,
-0.0215745866,
0.0467774309,
0.0216292217,
-0.0248091463,
-0.0427483432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06557v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06557v1 | Unsupervised Bias Detection in College Student Newspapers | 2023-09-11T06:51:09 | 2023-09-11T06:51:09 | Adam M. Lehavi, William McCormack, Noah Kornfeld, Solomon Glazer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; H.2.8; J.4 | This paper presents a pipeline with minimal human influence for scraping and
detecting bias on college newspaper archives. This paper introduces a framework
for scraping complex archive sites that automated tools fail to grab data from,
and subsequently generates a dataset of 14 student papers with 23,154 entries.
This data can also then be queried by keyword to calculate bias by comparing
the sentiment of a large language model summary to the original article. The
advantages of this approach are that it is less comparative than reconstruction
bias and requires less labelled data than generating keyword sentiment. Results
are calculated on politically charged words as well as control words to show
how conclusions can be drawn. The complete method facilitates the extraction of
nuanced insights with minimal assumptions and categorizations, paving the way
for a more objective understanding of bias within student newspaper sources. | [
0.0651430115,
0.0911054239,
-0.0137057956,
0.0161033366,
-0.0488259196,
0.0440646261,
0.0172820911,
-0.040683981,
0.0602130368,
-0.0841172114,
0.0325610563,
0.0325222239,
-0.0104366252,
0.0178696085,
-0.0476178862,
-0.0174614843,
0.0354514606,
0.0545976833,
0.0741839856,
-0.0428599045,
0.0180055201,
0.0301008169,
-0.009256009,
-0.0042265025,
-0.0025060426,
0.0223685224,
0.0243431516,
0.0147838416,
-0.0002060662,
0.0131080979,
0.0344754644,
0.037325386,
-0.0416319482,
0.0386469252,
0.0000016796,
-0.0264827237,
-0.0411295146,
-0.0076216008,
0.0298292395,
-0.0218049195,
0.1528673768,
-0.0177692156,
-0.0231611747,
0.0137716979,
-0.044030726,
-0.030182438,
0.0441181138,
-0.0169645865,
0.0365873165,
0.0640972108,
-0.0080628861,
-0.0175316371,
-0.0565576553,
0.0229516383,
0.0103242993,
-0.0035283274,
0.068746537,
-0.0263128467,
-0.0781882852,
-0.0094762649,
-0.0164145678,
0.0048594796,
-0.0068809073,
-0.0093120532,
-0.0269638002,
-0.014033528,
-0.0343168005,
-0.0356502235,
0.0140873883,
-0.009639008,
0.0083824676,
-0.0385213904,
0.0293424465,
0.0059624007,
0.0088067576,
0.0547068529,
-0.0268610548,
0.0291016344,
-0.0268087331,
0.0149682593,
-0.0057218787,
-0.0097846482,
0.0065113553,
0.0983410925,
-0.00304248,
0.0460764393,
-0.0092758359,
-0.0212244447,
0.0165185444,
0.0415733233,
0.0751957148,
0.0104401289,
0.0251141116,
0.0019507395,
0.0293726437,
0.0095772166,
0.0095349383,
-0.0270440504,
0.0252057742,
-0.0639024302,
-0.0142819826,
-0.0100983754,
-0.0294727813,
0.040396139,
0.0231494792,
-0.0642071366,
-0.0129353981,
0.0221731588,
0.0033632636,
0.0154228853,
0.00000472,
0.0258086286,
0.0237748865,
0.0105242915,
0.0069039389,
0.0430597253,
-0.0061477814,
-0.0217980295,
-0.0218668077,
0.015079678,
-0.0349366479,
0.0115298377,
-0.0295800567,
-0.01583164,
-0.0150149707,
0.0454633646,
-0.0278932117,
0.0451484695,
-0.0656239912,
-0.0430678017,
-0.0011033743,
0.0229396857,
0.0207394846,
-0.0173365027,
0.0092341444,
0.0420879237,
0.0454416908,
0.0113015054,
-0.0298894625,
-0.0278352909,
-0.0026192195,
-0.0419843756,
0.0208044797,
-0.0369269028,
0.0236294586,
0.0052466067,
0.0030266887,
-0.030873673,
-0.0066878847,
0.0021510713,
-0.0449427404,
0.0299920756,
0.0115280868,
-0.009278425,
0.0493373685,
0.0154861165,
-0.0052882745,
0.0792757049,
-0.0164023899,
0.0779664442,
0.0654392019,
0.0140716424,
-0.0059997044,
-0.0063856756,
0.0336357206,
0.0114872791,
-0.0316554978,
0.0095147416,
-0.0261881258,
-0.032664977,
0.0003938364,
0.026157815,
0.0298226606,
-0.0050688074,
0.0332649574,
0.0149667747,
-0.0572361909,
0.0071302769,
-0.0319173336,
0.0250995811,
0.0024492184,
0.0164502021,
-0.0476735346,
-0.0175808817,
0.0012968493,
-0.0375141613,
0.0098217446,
0.0496245362,
0.0095481202,
-0.0150555037,
-0.0108006867,
0.0208457299,
0.0001981851,
-0.0059436932,
0.0439952388,
0.0020014762,
0.004551359,
0.0148624741,
0.0636036843,
-0.01603687,
0.0458883978,
-0.0453648902,
0.0548990816,
0.0186316576,
-0.0051717483,
-0.0270083882,
0.0457410924,
-0.0327171348,
0.0031767171,
0.0569442026,
0.0470718741,
-0.0135128377,
-0.0319677889,
-0.0209347848,
-0.0332029201,
-0.001423282,
0.0550837852,
0.0277941152,
0.0241144672,
0.0513602681,
0.0065188142,
-0.0036892716,
-0.0633027628,
0.0162466206,
0.0409082659,
-0.0216257032,
-0.0159534272,
0.0285948031,
-0.0102456557,
0.0263711195,
-0.0429277048,
-0.0184477828,
0.0016189148,
0.0117021054,
-0.0183023661,
-0.0397958681,
-0.0015124636,
0.0073038633,
-0.0084013669,
-0.0805680156,
-0.0116437217,
0.0364671983,
-0.0330343544,
0.019071212,
0.0670444369,
-0.0058336155,
0.004367142,
-0.0069667203,
-0.0334703028,
-0.0665962398,
-0.0009087152,
-0.0454017818,
0.0650708601,
0.0150309671,
0.024232408,
0.0626398399,
-0.0975871533,
0.0007258836,
0.0307729971,
-0.0288155843,
0.0014496277,
0.0044774814,
0.0101899868,
0.0362821706,
-0.0622095093,
-0.0262810104,
-0.042023588,
-0.0203694589,
-0.0085931011,
-0.0192558859,
0.0159035083,
0.0355802812,
-0.0098499684,
-0.0201166607,
0.004027674,
0.0123805478,
-0.0642378107,
-0.015596604,
0.034366034,
-0.0079135131,
-0.0153355002,
0.028028978,
-0.0368822403,
-0.0092417961,
-0.0456061959,
0.0268586297,
0.0689576864,
-0.0373556577,
-0.011110493,
0.0182091072,
0.0001610437,
-0.0238070749,
-0.0066675125,
-0.0216559935,
-0.0136668114,
-0.011479022,
-0.0409403592,
0.0982449129,
0.0455958694,
0.0404989421,
0.0528627038,
-0.0112671889,
-0.0510906242,
-0.0382626727,
-0.0566984639,
0.0195915513,
-0.0344383307,
-0.0466909483,
0.0122245625,
-0.000654844,
0.0489129014,
0.0034355035,
-0.0085839937,
0.060616862,
-0.0507157668,
0.0045997207,
-0.0022732127,
0.0008319639,
0.0016630515,
0.022091452,
-0.0177857727,
-0.0297188032,
0.0327825062,
0.0304400772,
0.0774165392,
-0.0471150242,
-0.0059555392,
-0.0342047289,
0.0247822702,
-0.0055512115,
0.0171825308,
-0.0557484217,
0.0046941997,
-0.0268493667,
-0.0294548217,
0.0743228272,
-0.0330802798,
0.0145553974,
-0.0289228819,
-0.0091555258,
-0.0160739105,
0.0033031048,
-0.0042122453,
-0.0486298986,
-0.0237622801,
-0.0413726829,
0.0479491763,
-0.0173764322,
-0.0133581301,
0.0021536571,
0.0207798872,
0.0035515078,
-0.0572863035,
0.0040080668,
0.064358376,
0.0407974832,
0.015946243,
-0.0587377772,
0.0284179226,
0.0381931588,
-0.0118629644,
0.0282887686,
-0.0062742247,
0.0825113952,
0.0314768516,
-0.013168891,
0.0169394016,
-0.0539630353,
0.0201259088,
-0.0689504817,
-0.021068247,
-0.0364360623,
0.0049869162,
0.0761185735,
0.0056729545,
-0.0864851847,
-0.041479338,
0.0093186656,
-0.0573673844,
0.0191652291,
-0.0085160285,
-0.068666257,
0.0350768194,
0.0022083702,
0.0418035835,
-0.0515474528,
-0.0334402658,
-0.0278056152,
-0.0736466646,
-0.0070252041,
-0.0188607704,
-0.0185575318,
-0.0200439394,
-0.0778121352,
0.0312123839,
-0.0429734811,
-0.020041801,
0.0021425723,
0.0211165212,
0.0210718233,
-0.00575874,
-0.0530513972,
-0.0708057582,
-0.0223091654,
0.0037670981,
0.017527556,
0.0161798336,
0.0468748771,
-0.0459351391,
0.0080304518,
0.0645576641,
-0.0173583906,
-0.065999411,
-0.0510362871,
0.0904015228,
-0.0714060143,
-0.0216739364,
-0.0263621751,
0.0717700198,
0.0401993245,
0.0499650687,
0.0149196498,
0.0024663925,
0.0294001233,
-0.0264596213,
-0.0566873252,
-0.019317653,
0.0361749493,
0.0316446573,
0.012298977,
-0.0324242413,
0.0290360264,
-0.0501156934,
-0.0098818848,
-0.0194129217,
-0.0508812442,
0.0236900095,
-0.0179027598,
-0.0332137346,
-0.0096255541,
-0.0476103276,
-0.022174228,
0.0122853573,
0.0238767434,
-0.0209080223,
0.0025418526,
-0.0106507614,
-0.0731478706,
-0.0024429446,
-0.0076649883,
0.0150235156,
0.0486084595,
-0.0545425229,
-0.0142203774,
-0.004662028,
-0.0440352485,
-0.0296308156,
-0.0334974565,
-0.0291317292,
0.1085157916,
0.0153695522,
0.0132510914,
0.0337282047,
-0.0159715638,
-0.0044724583,
0.0593299605,
0.0952142626,
-0.0185816735,
-0.0263482518,
0.0060916543,
0.0034246373,
0.0128394971,
0.0119431196,
-0.0455253944,
0.0640087426,
0.0270308163,
-0.0668159947,
-0.0308370218,
0.0006048286,
0.0012278858,
0.0031120139,
0.0639923811,
0.0043896781,
0.0065501514,
-0.0357342325,
-0.0185430627,
-0.0155713735,
-0.0591938756,
0.0232514571,
-0.0193803776,
0.0236414392,
0.0141817369,
-0.0735851973,
0.0259731859,
-0.0409539603,
0.0293394048,
-0.0270197261,
0.0667430311,
0.0070089088,
0.0554018803,
0.0012590903,
-0.0128865466,
-0.0426960029,
0.0413410664,
-0.0226551015,
0.0265640635,
0.0131951077,
-0.0110378675,
0.0428049639,
0.0010962381,
0.0442669056,
-0.0331101753,
-0.0717743188,
0.0010732701,
-0.0482166708,
-0.0277386084,
-0.0177953467,
-0.047599867,
0.0026306363,
-0.0052264696,
-0.022488445,
0.0234907065,
-0.0005700909,
0.0497295186,
-0.025036322,
0.0379962362,
0.0058829761,
-0.0299238712,
0.029549839,
0.0129485624,
-0.0223346576,
0.0525938086,
0.0307257175,
-0.0504686497,
0.0073022591,
-0.0119386455,
0.0377368964,
-0.0169113223,
0.0124425059,
-0.0459713638,
-0.0448355228,
-0.0129598491,
0.0105790552,
0.0121470904,
0.0472487472,
-0.0218817778,
-0.0314901285,
0.0508767366,
0.0117977988,
0.0383039415,
-0.0225562006,
0.0594467707,
-0.0757122114,
-0.0313145183,
0.0151888765,
-5.978781367e-33,
-0.0109596299,
-0.0628861934,
-0.0702510253,
-0.0143794632,
0.0138089191,
0.0269587934,
-0.0189314075,
-0.0100737493,
-0.0602243133,
0.0349831581,
0.0281962063,
0.0526144169,
0.0199601725,
0.0097987847,
0.0309890751,
-0.0245576929,
0.0162437186,
0.0102529833,
0.0034536978,
-0.0003369216,
-0.00024077,
0.0018445769,
0.0531399362,
-0.0712185875,
0.0740404427,
-0.0188785866,
-0.0277293269,
-0.0034193851,
0.035001222,
0.0085592438,
-0.000980803,
0.0359766707,
0.0432675034,
-0.0313028991,
0.0211220775,
0.0366967469,
-0.0191430897,
-0.0158519186,
0.0262193289,
0.0333295017,
0.0582957827,
0.0083191665,
0.019367259,
0.01368153,
-0.0584339462,
-0.0224499293,
0.06536901,
-0.0202679262,
0.033867985,
-0.0373973809,
-0.0091300411,
0.0298830513,
-0.0194038972,
0.0421758518,
-0.0090115368,
0.0211577509,
0.0484152101,
0.0909319595,
-0.0189874563,
0.0080803847,
-0.0283826031,
0.0190685075,
-0.0003980524,
-0.0255870912,
-0.0100894645,
0.0881439596,
0.0366074853,
0.0381055251,
-0.0695434064,
-0.0264294241,
0.0503208414,
-0.0459292606,
0.0094594266,
0.0965512022,
0.0634275302,
-0.0573712327,
-0.0372168869,
-0.0094334604,
0.0855400488,
0.0231490061,
0.0288554691,
-0.0664610788,
-0.0367252715,
-0.0072917375,
-0.0081260772,
-0.1284281611,
-0.0303585734,
-0.0189660322,
0.0073130322,
0.0172973648,
-0.0489885658,
0.0125769777,
-0.019267654,
-0.0379865542,
-0.0365295224,
0.061165221,
-0.0427108519,
-0.0074260803,
-0.0242345966,
-0.0011457512,
-0.0837443396,
0.0126814805,
-0.0151088033,
0.0577860847,
0.0120856715,
-0.0201741233,
0.0321017094,
0.0233753081,
-0.0583208613,
0.0018716159,
-0.0023623991,
-0.0055277492,
0.0085365344,
0.0406433381,
0.0317080989,
0.0296691079,
-0.00570704,
-0.0046113273,
0.0260393526,
0.0503260344,
0.0259340275,
-0.0084331008,
-0.0270632189,
0.0170427971,
-0.0098716635,
-0.0488022417,
0.0225250721,
0.0043143262,
-0.0418106131,
-0.0685454383,
0.0208843593,
-0.0446592383,
2.531e-7,
0.0302376561,
0.0641755685,
-0.0181122683,
0.0068623936,
0.0001955555,
0.0036916859,
0.0091535607,
0.0247834772,
-0.0066261068,
-0.03017818,
-0.0142676225,
0.0212565958,
0.0034507629,
0.0468974113,
-0.0913407877,
0.0086865779,
-0.047870867,
0.0046472712,
-0.0259554312,
0.0144952647,
0.0328220613,
0.0210170187,
0.028152829,
-0.0063883811,
-0.0384825394,
-0.0062654722,
-0.006963945,
-0.0141907195,
0.0031030087,
0.0237300694,
0.0193870794,
0.0041085053,
0.0076632467,
-0.0196551811,
-0.0069683758,
0.0061397706,
-0.0048183561,
0.0272112675,
0.0219243281,
0.0172650516,
0.0043987618,
-0.015190539,
0.029031964,
-0.0336196199,
0.0507219695,
-0.0003681019,
-0.0030943067,
-0.1468838006,
-0.0641705841,
-0.0284287427,
0.0392513759,
-0.0109774489,
-0.0035119737,
0.0238290597,
-0.0238474272,
0.0227780938,
0.0071639693,
-0.0596696176,
-0.0190852117,
-0.0157986768,
-0.0119655533,
-0.03836523,
0.0467283018,
0.0045939502,
0.0136693679,
-0.0016833626,
0.0449349321,
1.789575355e-34,
0.072166957,
-0.0255087353,
-0.0098696519,
-0.0266567506,
0.0199632253,
0.0226569809,
-0.0239592288,
-0.0450600237,
0.0092877476,
-0.0218823291,
0.0115834447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05227v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05227v1 | Detecting Natural Language Biases with Prompt-based Learning | 2023-09-11T04:20:36 | 2023-09-11T04:20:36 | Md Abdul Aowal, Maliha T Islam, Priyanka Mary Mammen, Sandesh Shetty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this project, we want to explore the newly emerging field of prompt
engineering and apply it to the downstream task of detecting LM biases. More
concretely, we explore how to design prompts that can indicate 4 different
types of biases: (1) gender, (2) race, (3) sexual orientation, and (4)
religion-based. Within our project, we experiment with different manually
crafted prompts that can draw out the subtle biases that may be present in the
language model. We apply these prompts to multiple variations of popular and
well-recognized models: BERT, RoBERTa, and T5 to evaluate their biases. We
provide a comparative analysis of these models and assess them using a two-fold
method: use human judgment to decide whether model predictions are biased and
utilize model-level judgment (through further prompts) to understand if a model
can self-diagnose the biases of its own prediction. | [
0.0681408197,
0.0667752847,
-0.0407758467,
0.039947819,
-0.0163388122,
0.0183349699,
0.0493038595,
-0.0163089279,
0.0520772189,
-0.0672003254,
-0.0312010162,
-0.0341140516,
0.0018866855,
0.0076613147,
-0.001244541,
-0.0715053454,
0.0582525283,
0.0213672109,
0.0625072196,
-0.0313972831,
0.01830847,
0.0399661772,
0.0081509836,
0.0445615761,
0.0083793579,
-0.0340733044,
0.0300643444,
0.0144420741,
-0.0141926194,
-0.0060499804,
0.0475533418,
0.0772333145,
-0.0193649679,
0.0225226954,
0.0000018165,
-0.096069254,
0.0058986195,
-0.0343421996,
-0.0399617925,
-0.0050154333,
0.0554914176,
0.0305578988,
-0.0190004129,
0.0264900345,
-0.0286880601,
0.0047972663,
0.0400179401,
0.0301126447,
0.0333526917,
0.0224160813,
0.0229710657,
0.0055178194,
-0.0594921932,
0.00339674,
0.02989926,
0.0022776376,
0.0339271985,
-0.0751740485,
-0.0240717903,
-0.0149970315,
-0.0285225939,
0.0039322013,
0.0090082902,
0.0043077893,
0.0094508147,
-0.0059704008,
0.0063124653,
-0.051699359,
-0.0257033315,
0.0399602354,
0.0291506369,
-0.0140288509,
0.0086706337,
-0.0245829746,
0.0519091412,
0.0257017184,
0.0002953212,
0.0490010269,
-0.0242144465,
-0.0196466334,
-0.0023762558,
-0.0117358482,
0.0161831789,
0.0615573898,
0.0140223755,
0.0697942674,
0.039240066,
-0.0403318256,
0.0164603889,
0.0272325855,
0.0487432182,
-0.0739938244,
0.0069910656,
-0.008110512,
-0.0403133593,
0.0327578336,
-0.0244020894,
0.0290071126,
0.0356222093,
-0.0267549157,
0.0342491493,
0.0393358171,
-0.0565815195,
-0.0060566398,
0.0212569907,
0.0356783681,
0.0147959758,
-0.0028911363,
-0.0155526679,
0.0188568998,
0.0059983437,
-0.0200726483,
-0.0083608245,
-0.0159974713,
0.0249653645,
0.0663357303,
-0.037667878,
0.0049919472,
-0.0411587432,
0.0139472857,
-0.0115737235,
0.0143521857,
-0.0266105197,
-0.0046766857,
-0.0580995344,
0.0293624084,
-0.0530127436,
0.0208778828,
-0.0215937831,
-0.1058474183,
0.0142964683,
0.0083177621,
-0.0239114203,
-0.0488405786,
0.0016519438,
0.0266896281,
0.0227596108,
-0.0325000845,
-0.0206646379,
-0.0350550078,
-0.0479763895,
-0.0452361032,
-0.0128416605,
-0.0378424227,
0.0065763784,
0.0111575406,
0.0258623809,
-0.0405619368,
-0.0086927135,
0.0345200039,
-0.0405943207,
0.0711373165,
0.0164642464,
-0.0117996298,
0.0568464287,
0.0185784753,
-0.0190406125,
0.0895688757,
0.0033118699,
0.0156001197,
0.0511486642,
-0.0278523583,
0.0011971047,
0.0187798068,
0.0053815087,
-0.0066261184,
-0.0345897488,
0.0260383748,
-0.0016366529,
0.0148107242,
0.0275283325,
0.0436767414,
0.0214735623,
-0.0138581293,
0.0547739416,
0.065159522,
-0.0065776948,
0.0086928718,
0.040828526,
0.0245077591,
0.0051488844,
0.044726219,
-0.0783874467,
-0.0098102372,
-0.0469449908,
-0.0255729798,
0.0087248739,
0.0432534106,
-0.0154839586,
-0.0413555913,
-0.0217640027,
0.0073886132,
0.0080889799,
0.0189841408,
-0.0011013682,
0.0400353409,
-0.0089852568,
0.0362228937,
0.0355955623,
-0.0438701771,
0.0416322127,
-0.0539104156,
0.041346781,
0.0551057123,
-0.0008479783,
-0.0332843661,
-0.0118962852,
-0.0334968865,
-0.0128301876,
0.0780730844,
0.0824948475,
0.0043486375,
-0.029040698,
-0.0318325907,
-0.0484891459,
0.0265903827,
0.02624497,
0.01315754,
0.022390658,
0.0299663916,
-0.0001182853,
-0.0030879623,
-0.0199153367,
0.0448075682,
0.0094577791,
-0.0411819555,
-0.009250544,
0.0239251442,
0.0251930915,
0.0195604488,
-0.0122512588,
0.0054058251,
-0.0213588756,
0.0260096118,
0.0005408026,
0.004385001,
-0.0659643337,
-0.0168309826,
0.0117021259,
-0.0359449089,
-0.0562436767,
0.0258159339,
-0.035314884,
0.0000877284,
0.0227494817,
-0.0268955976,
0.007277247,
-0.0274711512,
0.0086995242,
-0.0396010801,
0.0031663375,
-0.0376308337,
0.051423654,
-0.009440355,
0.0253761094,
0.0465210527,
-0.0259916261,
0.0032508592,
-0.0524218567,
-0.0436395854,
0.0031644483,
-0.0140656782,
-0.0102657648,
0.0459295437,
-0.016828645,
-0.0433983169,
-0.0087067308,
-0.0691390261,
-0.0162769314,
-0.0126491543,
-0.0176839195,
-0.0092309108,
0.0043197395,
-0.0328257903,
-0.0377856977,
-0.0288418233,
-0.0631517619,
0.0201678295,
0.0601762198,
0.028751323,
-0.0327498056,
-0.0169669632,
-0.0303622186,
-0.0143569987,
-0.0553884394,
0.0474473909,
0.0468811281,
-0.0042504179,
-0.0739598423,
-0.0372329131,
-0.0130866077,
-0.0137668252,
0.0312535092,
-0.0161719657,
0.0261008311,
0.0295005366,
0.0318258554,
0.0648932755,
0.0718694851,
0.0194254722,
0.0523477085,
-0.0019237756,
-0.045649644,
-0.0104199005,
-0.010015917,
-0.01315099,
0.0133752823,
-0.0678767189,
0.0093790311,
0.0498071089,
0.0636251494,
-0.0128091397,
-0.0617163926,
0.0585110113,
-0.0377917551,
-0.0572303347,
-0.0189190358,
-0.0576150939,
-0.0322012082,
0.0438597463,
-0.0303385556,
-0.0727295578,
0.0961721987,
0.0127938893,
0.018036535,
-0.0517530888,
0.0282279253,
-0.0295516774,
0.0215601884,
-0.0080685513,
0.021265449,
0.0556689911,
-0.0501172878,
-0.0482581705,
-0.0312930197,
0.0165486485,
-0.0310680307,
0.0199196618,
-0.0419834852,
-0.0248636082,
0.0240357202,
-0.0340403095,
-0.0895952359,
-0.0575954393,
-0.0483480208,
-0.0188527852,
0.0040952046,
0.0178334396,
0.0135384705,
-0.0351813436,
-0.0075329053,
-0.007864397,
-0.0098280665,
-0.0021952644,
0.0129850144,
0.0020041575,
0.0202546045,
0.0083401809,
0.0251571257,
-0.0253721941,
0.0101973983,
0.0092262542,
-0.0075652087,
0.0148762409,
-0.0017250882,
0.0388279222,
0.0570723377,
-0.0553964749,
-0.0023356155,
0.038498912,
0.0385917015,
-0.0377702713,
0.0082876375,
0.1176063791,
0.0304466393,
-0.0693240985,
-0.0020776805,
-0.0310913995,
0.023427505,
0.0197711028,
0.0103733269,
-0.1092406884,
-0.0195571128,
0.0119237918,
0.0142567931,
-0.0495008826,
-0.0306620412,
-0.0224137437,
-0.1173227727,
0.0058540893,
-0.0020370621,
-0.005307348,
-0.0122071579,
-0.0401805751,
0.008942889,
-0.0172212627,
0.0363377333,
-0.010338624,
-0.0157773085,
0.0157315433,
0.0092999032,
-0.0630561933,
-0.0456153043,
0.0292529259,
-0.0462195463,
0.0531249791,
0.0707620755,
0.0178831369,
-0.0179717988,
-0.0327426828,
0.0438848734,
-0.0315112397,
0.0191130117,
-0.0422864147,
0.0397481248,
-0.0355573036,
-0.0181139912,
-0.0600372814,
0.0358250625,
0.0282296259,
0.015840495,
0.0282275006,
0.0542754121,
-0.0011220343,
-0.0266245548,
-0.038461931,
0.0341020264,
0.0309492499,
0.1262065917,
0.0350870341,
-0.0714827776,
0.0034276331,
-0.06956359,
0.0189661123,
0.0339707434,
-0.0668732151,
0.0022398224,
-0.0167194791,
-0.0207552463,
-0.040355809,
-0.0512394421,
0.0164411366,
0.0013376341,
0.0391123183,
-0.0567238145,
-0.0115888463,
0.0231086444,
-0.014661707,
0.0533486344,
-0.0333171897,
0.0292701069,
-0.0420487672,
-0.0226170551,
-0.0136199705,
-0.0557360873,
-0.0154856835,
-0.007111527,
-0.0055516749,
-0.0528196022,
0.0617359765,
0.0474409498,
0.0263410434,
0.0539654233,
-0.010055189,
-0.0588236377,
0.0353844389,
0.0420032479,
-0.0241693314,
-0.0079687107,
0.0337659083,
0.0225029979,
0.0023652611,
0.021801522,
-0.0386860408,
0.0255417135,
0.0189006682,
-0.0100069502,
-0.0178566147,
-0.0766672567,
0.0158401374,
0.0020857183,
0.0539687872,
-0.0399798788,
-0.0037649805,
-0.0502456278,
-0.0178467855,
0.0094430149,
-0.0654228777,
0.0151598575,
-0.0195080116,
0.0124681899,
-0.0039280523,
-0.0264492966,
-0.0115348585,
-0.0830774307,
0.0172884967,
-0.0401646122,
0.0470753685,
0.0577652454,
0.0710235909,
-0.0148909856,
0.0083766282,
-0.0347663872,
0.0309898145,
-0.0062008002,
0.0365372561,
0.0383778811,
0.0736995935,
0.0089891963,
0.0076492177,
0.0150552187,
-0.0084102899,
-0.0404173285,
-0.0326882564,
0.0025342214,
0.0020375676,
0.0126600275,
-0.0341454931,
-0.0109972591,
-0.0008288939,
0.0049517131,
-0.0064300895,
-0.005842106,
0.0476488881,
-0.0225823857,
0.0578701645,
-0.0021522762,
-0.0177869666,
-0.0366715342,
0.0178811885,
-0.0063176756,
0.073060669,
0.0054113911,
-0.0256736875,
-0.043982856,
-0.0148078557,
0.029095374,
-0.0105319787,
-0.0289840754,
-0.0071868589,
-0.0871330574,
-0.0327328779,
0.0162025634,
0.0063987793,
0.0284266863,
-0.0160648469,
0.0329842046,
0.058457844,
-0.0354376025,
-0.0404473767,
0.0021060782,
0.0270280074,
-0.0054003433,
-0.0090872822,
-0.0255075879,
-5.534908456e-33,
-0.0408593863,
-0.0343078636,
-0.0325562619,
-0.0085933078,
0.0246257074,
-0.0149182361,
-0.0138639631,
0.0176169705,
-0.032733798,
0.0079774931,
0.0059264451,
0.0082799997,
0.0312351398,
-0.0204737261,
0.0345735215,
-0.0247109514,
0.0670713857,
0.0073569082,
-0.0456612706,
-0.024646109,
-0.0248107389,
0.0239318963,
0.0436565056,
-0.0361914709,
0.0963862985,
0.0018779555,
-0.0175439939,
0.0168712586,
-0.0254522376,
0.0221346002,
-0.0286137611,
0.0656569228,
0.0192836765,
-0.0168482419,
-0.0074113696,
0.1045246944,
-0.0379335545,
-0.0624663457,
0.0581106767,
0.036138799,
0.005834335,
-0.0264566746,
0.00429415,
-0.0096417405,
-0.0724334493,
0.0129741244,
0.0586696975,
-0.0155153424,
0.0455058664,
0.0339026414,
-0.0430189371,
-0.0032942009,
-0.0180361532,
-0.0053709303,
-0.0173409749,
0.0539482869,
0.0062687625,
0.0183519237,
-0.0237854663,
0.0386514738,
0.0251304042,
-0.0081776874,
0.051964201,
0.0169550162,
-0.0097617311,
0.066437766,
0.0767654553,
0.0381284505,
-0.0234513283,
-0.0538241901,
0.0293274708,
-0.0296465456,
0.0424821042,
0.0769686326,
0.0217586011,
0.0128117865,
0.0011821099,
0.009977784,
0.0752139091,
0.0062753935,
0.0291849114,
-0.0383033492,
-0.0633386448,
-0.0468574166,
-0.0505331196,
-0.0740321875,
-0.0291698258,
-0.0088526346,
0.0391561873,
-0.0011299419,
-0.0247129351,
0.0017509877,
0.0015022268,
-0.0261893719,
-0.016889507,
0.0216381177,
0.0009278051,
-0.0630815029,
0.0177522469,
0.0157894921,
-0.0536667593,
0.0258089304,
0.0139320726,
-0.0001325088,
0.029013494,
0.0119172921,
-0.0195361041,
0.0073891426,
-0.0843035802,
0.0101777511,
-0.0088668466,
0.0066621513,
0.0140983379,
0.0092137959,
0.0535930507,
0.0266303625,
-0.0168455485,
0.0473070964,
0.029529877,
-0.0140016051,
-0.0480345376,
0.0017612303,
-0.0257686097,
0.0466792211,
-0.0286615659,
-0.0223336034,
0.0081833042,
0.0489502996,
0.0266530514,
-0.0254035871,
-0.0028345189,
-0.0373482406,
2.332e-7,
0.0179416314,
0.0418344922,
0.0197819564,
0.0093047982,
-0.0017956415,
0.0405994579,
0.0143682593,
0.0263445377,
0.0623190962,
0.0036813051,
-0.0340904109,
0.0040643122,
0.030989347,
0.0121049415,
-0.0779880062,
-0.0180541389,
-0.0646143779,
0.0651310161,
-0.0444409065,
0.0067856018,
0.0403147787,
0.0525543503,
0.0273633208,
-0.0129121114,
-0.0426604711,
0.0018036967,
0.008019831,
-0.0564410947,
0.0149185583,
0.0064303074,
0.039026916,
-0.0208783876,
0.0211841092,
0.0482093543,
0.0067868652,
-0.0125839608,
-0.0222831871,
0.0268732458,
0.0298449509,
-0.0071808961,
-0.0290832296,
0.0224288218,
-0.0372398756,
-0.0659647882,
0.0537161529,
0.0048246798,
-0.0028479944,
-0.0434854738,
-0.03608137,
-0.0375817381,
0.0476346128,
-0.0287523251,
-0.0384838767,
-0.0035612083,
0.0207574852,
0.0089983856,
-0.0013283803,
-0.0597864613,
-0.024857169,
-0.0152069731,
-0.0294190459,
-0.0598670989,
-0.0070085078,
0.0143656423,
0.0005824904,
-0.0642993227,
0.0390265994,
1.878489908e-34,
0.0376554579,
-0.0080849277,
0.0382901952,
-0.0189428106,
0.0319634378,
0.0252282303,
0.0100026261,
-0.0150991762,
0.0670034736,
-0.0342263654,
-0.0195273291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05221v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05221v1 | Exploring the Law of Numbers: Evidence from China's Real Estate | 2023-09-11T03:54:38 | 2023-09-11T03:54:38 | Fuqian Zhang, Zhenhua Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The renowned proverb, Numbers do not lie, underscores the reliability and
insight that lie beneath numbers, a concept of undisputed importance,
especially in economics and finance etc. Despite the prosperity of Benford's
Law in the first digit analysis, its scope fails to remain comprehensiveness
when it comes to deciphering the laws of number. This paper delves into number
laws by taking the financial statements of China real estate as a
representative, quantitatively study not only the first digit, but also depict
the other two dimensions of numbers: frequency and length. The research
outcomes transcend mere reservations about data manipulation and open the door
to discussions surrounding number diversity and the delineation of the usage
insights. This study wields both economic significance and the capacity to
foster a deeper comprehension of numerical phenomena. | [
-0.0319079421,
0.0372503139,
-0.0260054879,
0.003369997,
0.0037136434,
-0.0072087115,
0.0370128974,
0.004120789,
-0.0604624189,
0.0431680232,
0.0003937054,
-0.0056690746,
0.0689542219,
-0.0002022843,
-0.0018858638,
0.0077931858,
0.0036125607,
0.0209396183,
0.0439750701,
0.0499435998,
-0.008379912,
-0.023171721,
0.0410970934,
-0.0091214152,
-0.0314058438,
0.0381787196,
0.0494475178,
-0.0734015033,
0.0070577436,
-0.0465351976,
-0.0159191508,
-0.0073269201,
0.0525268577,
0.0910192952,
0.0000021271,
-0.0839148685,
-0.0360510796,
0.0497622006,
-0.0248303432,
0.0366739929,
0.0119231874,
-0.0206496734,
-0.0161136445,
-0.0149287442,
-0.0243301112,
0.0033872859,
-0.0100531606,
0.0361055769,
0.0092146043,
0.0262870155,
0.0208801143,
-0.0726239979,
0.0091255717,
-0.0526387841,
0.0116321938,
0.0065353964,
0.017766431,
0.0767915919,
0.0413636118,
0.0220724344,
-0.0496033989,
-0.0095298784,
0.0588944517,
-0.0011066346,
-0.0166441649,
-0.0125616305,
-0.0078852801,
0.0223116837,
0.0335448459,
0.0744824111,
0.0522160456,
0.0309447199,
0.0563921817,
-0.0081690364,
0.0302167181,
-0.0282500666,
-0.0600238368,
0.0143150296,
-0.0032057087,
0.0008845286,
-0.0357819498,
0.0678310394,
-0.0022440939,
0.0023478342,
-0.0504502915,
-0.0119345514,
-0.0370156541,
-0.0157241486,
-0.022280369,
-0.0735713989,
-0.0432875492,
-0.0202455558,
-0.0315697566,
0.0085292701,
0.0671439469,
0.0104989735,
0.0500763021,
-0.0106488587,
0.0552013218,
-0.0647605509,
-0.0206182729,
0.0508630201,
-0.041265212,
0.0267902482,
-0.0361293703,
0.0384310037,
-0.0169551596,
-0.0319922529,
-0.004806418,
0.0505828336,
0.0119552827,
0.0140247475,
0.0149906361,
0.0724982545,
-0.0137627963,
0.0185861737,
-0.0774466917,
0.0066264477,
-0.01744394,
0.0429498143,
-0.0047405716,
-0.0245671738,
0.0253818762,
-0.0255368296,
-0.0304607227,
-0.0283669122,
-0.0860997587,
-0.010547908,
-0.065485917,
-0.0175446197,
0.0189849641,
-0.0092555666,
0.0034931721,
-0.0219383631,
0.0220023356,
0.0035171509,
0.0413989723,
0.0406221561,
0.0049096323,
-0.0327046365,
0.0103206141,
-0.0015939019,
-0.0021438245,
0.0043472815,
-0.0672632381,
-0.0260525476,
-0.0113315815,
0.0061698984,
0.0025239177,
-0.02210306,
0.0233219229,
-0.0142115699,
-0.0727505982,
-0.0096917348,
-0.0035041959,
0.0081882337,
0.0405004136,
0.0176684167,
0.0384890772,
-0.0148385726,
0.0490797125,
-0.0105487928,
0.0469964743,
-0.0251040366,
0.0061443839,
0.0218103155,
-0.0153738139,
0.0453115702,
-0.001740212,
-0.0735332668,
-0.0218192954,
-0.0308713932,
-0.0140600791,
-0.0106153013,
0.0358930267,
0.0043252632,
0.0040085488,
0.051636301,
-0.0362913497,
0.0117820874,
0.0230261981,
-0.0123517783,
-0.0039218767,
0.0123456512,
0.0175151564,
0.0351910703,
0.0189676136,
-0.0493148379,
-0.0276169721,
-0.0188369378,
0.0292632785,
-0.0181266591,
-0.0021122645,
0.0026488069,
-0.0061261049,
-0.0317657255,
0.0543134771,
0.0177428089,
-0.0064418553,
0.0470703095,
-0.0132468194,
-0.0391193479,
0.0694804192,
0.0046447883,
0.0006583054,
-0.0171912704,
0.0970852077,
-0.0122953905,
-0.0137449773,
-0.0226089451,
-0.0005154791,
0.0162129477,
-0.0245528296,
-0.0129943425,
0.0145182768,
-0.0053461408,
0.0360460579,
-0.0126312422,
-0.065695554,
0.0161223691,
0.020680476,
-0.0341432095,
0.0530772284,
-0.0343849547,
0.0199441258,
-0.045231998,
-0.0322865918,
-0.0303191356,
-0.079893589,
-0.0053145825,
-0.0053148218,
-0.009325997,
-0.0236037523,
-0.0022362925,
-0.0259496812,
-0.0110993544,
-0.0027000594,
0.1104018018,
0.0462839752,
-0.0334070437,
0.0259869341,
-0.0157598369,
-0.034061566,
0.0078380853,
-0.0089397039,
0.0062145689,
0.0168754291,
-0.0515881404,
0.0134166526,
-0.056089174,
0.033013925,
0.0150886821,
0.0182349887,
-0.0164494086,
0.0185713209,
0.0097420169,
-0.0245336983,
0.0552289002,
0.0040911869,
0.0650707036,
-0.0545388386,
-0.0149451764,
0.0083724288,
0.021741353,
0.0100620529,
0.0014132815,
0.0373205282,
-0.0003934699,
-0.0509650409,
-0.0192209817,
-0.0009669428,
0.0386782996,
-0.0487820916,
0.0043929392,
0.0019503006,
0.0199128147,
-0.0469913557,
-0.0167582259,
-0.0053945063,
0.0703240484,
-0.0515363328,
-0.039593596,
0.004969453,
-0.0325769074,
-0.0193967614,
-0.002286565,
0.0728021041,
0.0194439683,
-0.0277560223,
-0.0672134459,
-0.0072562015,
-0.0256133154,
-0.0181128494,
0.0011431364,
-0.0098331431,
0.0077068973,
-0.0144369882,
-0.0675572529,
-0.0156289265,
0.0970181674,
-0.0087337997,
-0.0394943096,
-0.0026294433,
-0.0430287346,
0.0019767385,
0.0747297034,
0.0351587571,
0.0071744532,
-0.0137232756,
-0.0266728587,
-0.0247221384,
-0.008919226,
-0.0087542422,
0.0408017263,
-0.0166092496,
0.0133781163,
0.027487034,
0.0540218055,
-0.0088815177,
0.1015608609,
0.0399726704,
0.016357122,
-0.0228641983,
0.0120571097,
-0.0189016778,
-0.0131821362,
0.0384784043,
-0.0319732539,
0.0267132558,
0.0158534329,
-0.0349871702,
0.0012017963,
-0.0140342247,
-0.0055592312,
0.0032311885,
0.0300698597,
-0.0023753284,
0.0797288343,
0.0019463812,
-0.0085436245,
-0.0256510172,
-0.0150987525,
0.0116757685,
-0.1040255353,
0.0210105758,
0.0807731971,
0.0102823023,
-0.0374984704,
-0.0117360856,
-0.0002814131,
0.0382630117,
-0.0097263288,
0.0057361238,
-0.0250033829,
-0.0047021699,
0.0143146291,
-0.0103331571,
-0.058838211,
0.0563155636,
0.0100020617,
0.0267339759,
-0.0406723805,
-0.0337416306,
0.1250099391,
0.0288875252,
-0.0044424762,
-0.041210752,
-0.0263293628,
-0.0190097839,
0.0680560321,
-0.0632654652,
-0.047833737,
0.01901998,
0.022917226,
-0.0179421417,
0.0601664484,
0.0392247327,
-0.0305150878,
-0.0562812611,
0.011878876,
-0.0270337276,
-0.0630281642,
0.0678197965,
-0.029611608,
-0.0329541303,
-0.0281499866,
-0.0184021816,
-0.0297693219,
-0.0856279582,
0.0304760169,
0.0114586418,
-0.0366198644,
-0.0554368049,
0.0128446165,
0.0144582018,
-0.0010642966,
0.0298521761,
-0.0014001849,
-0.0296664145,
0.0392790399,
0.0226478092,
-0.035827972,
0.0462690629,
-0.008364588,
0.0207311865,
-0.051318571,
0.0132775437,
0.0309522059,
-0.0301847849,
0.0000745421,
-0.0709476396,
0.0337453857,
-0.0136828413,
0.0271318741,
0.0111421207,
0.0613822825,
-0.0204795767,
-0.0100401482,
0.0069484026,
-0.0193197578,
0.0763985366,
0.0288214479,
-0.0083961878,
-0.0296160374,
-0.0218506679,
0.0263456125,
0.0192686319,
-0.0450030416,
-0.0130037917,
-0.0033260621,
0.0479242057,
0.0139524639,
-0.0625007451,
-0.0307598561,
-0.0150826843,
0.0002370244,
-0.0161977373,
0.0062512518,
-0.0267030243,
0.0082807485,
-0.0471057557,
-0.053778924,
0.0713262334,
0.0289154444,
-0.0446442477,
0.0972199142,
0.0161006134,
0.0281485133,
-0.0730336979,
-0.0274716672,
0.040104311,
-0.0418767929,
0.0597164035,
0.0198172964,
-0.0346517749,
-0.0039403043,
-0.0649581179,
-0.0553927869,
0.0320656896,
0.0171571579,
0.0019498096,
0.0220328886,
-0.0236042961,
0.0030559693,
0.0470821448,
-0.0208008178,
0.018579796,
-0.0429063812,
-0.0128402589,
-0.0144833568,
-0.0063256938,
0.0046313684,
-0.0097101927,
0.0014674285,
0.0236165039,
0.0194209013,
0.0326313749,
-0.0996934474,
0.0544505008,
-0.0028840972,
0.020843897,
-0.024583308,
0.0686712787,
0.0291846097,
0.0328959599,
0.0017949123,
-0.0195594281,
0.0088499999,
0.0143412072,
-0.0372285582,
0.0303937569,
0.0345877893,
-0.0686798841,
0.0861801505,
0.0456350856,
-0.0166018698,
0.0010602061,
-0.0140679218,
-0.0519983955,
0.0779538527,
-0.0107191717,
-0.0258542486,
0.0224260408,
0.0106887361,
-0.029126741,
0.0460986607,
0.0478480347,
0.0321671553,
0.0055971243,
-0.0003429027,
-0.007428016,
0.0075070071,
0.0230898503,
-0.0509252064,
0.0443300381,
-0.0184414797,
-0.0241887663,
0.006628362,
-0.0623828769,
-0.0534945503,
0.038535323,
-0.0263217874,
0.0044083525,
-0.004431197,
-0.0265700817,
-0.0639242753,
-0.026301438,
-0.0471879058,
-0.0196791086,
0.0115907546,
0.0053281672,
-0.0529191345,
-0.0143779879,
-0.0204942264,
0.0469783694,
-0.0255974252,
0.0290089101,
-0.0051442501,
0.0188331772,
-0.0166505147,
-0.0734773353,
-0.0105380667,
-0.007617115,
-0.0506261401,
0.0058909184,
-0.0049966057,
0.0006966654,
-0.0012589199,
-0.0209755283,
0.0606552027,
0.0412974544,
-0.0116535705,
-0.0460247286,
0.0506073721,
-0.0735800788,
-5.488017251e-33,
0.044561509,
-0.0622255392,
0.0140557298,
-0.0340389088,
0.0362703316,
-0.0490630269,
-0.0053658774,
0.0096963067,
-0.030161975,
-0.0585474521,
-0.0209808946,
0.0315373614,
-0.0004320774,
0.0175719485,
0.054140158,
-0.0143035278,
-0.0023128844,
-0.0378486663,
0.0032981501,
-0.0651989281,
0.0290573016,
0.0295652822,
0.0891988501,
-0.0028100261,
0.0350198075,
0.0439368561,
0.0026215329,
-0.0202383287,
0.0522074699,
-0.0134229036,
0.0461062118,
0.0052753133,
0.0193356387,
-0.1038941145,
-0.0123505071,
-0.0381907187,
0.0064135478,
-0.049520839,
-0.0377594754,
0.0770630911,
0.1091941968,
0.0092792818,
-0.0087065781,
-0.0238310546,
0.0097925738,
-0.0199816655,
0.0193995573,
-0.0124037489,
-0.0093843536,
-0.0362295881,
-0.0326340385,
0.0173139442,
0.0102712903,
0.0730361268,
0.0098560574,
0.0210292488,
0.0160449632,
0.0004413725,
-0.0786552951,
-0.0081946459,
0.0295793116,
0.0286963247,
-0.0613865182,
-0.0380299687,
0.0568859652,
-0.0064156428,
0.0300972816,
-0.0059190588,
-0.0385221727,
-0.0079937624,
0.0440471396,
0.0128746154,
-0.0417897217,
0.05489555,
0.1056794599,
0.0054769721,
-0.0348268263,
0.0006564549,
0.0451314822,
-0.0448784716,
0.0155608905,
-0.0078710755,
-0.0255288519,
0.0055935802,
0.0298025329,
-0.0006587672,
0.0031615319,
0.0028261922,
-0.0000237543,
-0.0248141326,
0.0944109783,
0.0214997493,
-0.0117295785,
-0.0504961647,
-0.1056585014,
0.0119961035,
-0.0021391551,
0.0041739466,
0.004946507,
-0.0305139422,
-0.0105772233,
-0.0271881819,
0.000102508,
0.0538330637,
0.0245522708,
0.0049597616,
-0.0136034759,
0.0426671878,
-0.0117732743,
-0.02733122,
0.0415839478,
-0.0503569543,
0.0651196018,
-0.0380935259,
-0.0249711089,
-0.0023295165,
-0.0016444076,
-0.0494895056,
-0.004661995,
0.0077449381,
-0.0100101652,
0.0247433633,
-0.0360457785,
0.0115017816,
0.0219242852,
-0.0290729348,
-0.0245183669,
-0.0078460155,
0.0478827916,
0.0247968696,
0.000799354,
-0.0052042007,
2.9e-7,
-0.0329664722,
-0.0058786562,
-0.032621216,
0.0191097409,
-0.0016166813,
0.0251731016,
-0.0318633281,
0.0327094458,
-0.0520708077,
-0.0495467968,
0.0860768333,
-0.022814123,
0.0081396922,
0.0130114825,
0.0317311361,
-0.0004123312,
-0.0302130003,
-0.0191725697,
-0.0045280168,
0.0393904187,
-0.0769698545,
-0.0028120023,
0.0004348936,
0.0166347176,
0.0521381721,
-0.0340701193,
-0.0082628801,
-0.043305371,
0.0414762795,
0.0432005003,
0.0387125984,
-0.0089304624,
0.0077621192,
-0.0394934081,
0.0045210551,
0.0244523827,
0.0309608486,
0.0471165925,
0.0228229892,
0.0441500023,
-0.0392150134,
-0.1113486141,
-0.0119101154,
-0.019869836,
0.0176165663,
0.0282997042,
-0.0463598408,
-0.0052810605,
0.0076227146,
0.040110372,
0.0196379907,
0.0027710234,
0.0035929433,
0.0300702918,
0.0069396016,
0.0289999675,
0.0467927568,
-0.0040678764,
0.0216448475,
0.0082558384,
-0.0435700566,
-0.0400939584,
-0.0296913758,
0.0049228854,
0.0304826591,
0.0283742025,
-0.0140725058,
2.43942858e-34,
0.0068805753,
-0.0881116763,
-0.040911518,
-0.0270991977,
0.0118444087,
0.0216226354,
0.0015680451,
0.0142336041,
0.0333814062,
-0.0097336546,
-0.0238300636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05217v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05217v1 | Quantifying and Attributing the Hallucination of Large Language Models via Association Analysis | 2023-09-11T03:35:00 | 2023-09-11T03:35:00 | Li Du, Yequan Wang, Xingrun Xing, Yiqun Ya, Xiang Li, Xin Jiang, Xuezhi Fang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Although demonstrating superb performance on various NLP tasks, large
language models (LLMs) still suffer from the hallucination problem, which
threatens the reliability of LLMs. To measure the level of hallucination of
LLMs, previous works first categorize the hallucination according to the
phenomenon similarity, then quantify the proportion that model outputs contain
hallucinatory contents. However, such hallucination rates could easily be
distorted by confounders. Moreover, such hallucination rates could not reflect
the reasons for the hallucination, as similar hallucinatory phenomena may
originate from different sources. To address these issues, we propose to
combine the hallucination level quantification and hallucination reason
investigation through an association analysis, which builds the relationship
between the hallucination rate of LLMs with a set of risk factors. In this way,
we are able to observe the hallucination level under each value of each risk
factor, examining the contribution and statistical significance of each risk
factor, meanwhile excluding the confounding effect of other factors.
Additionally, by recognizing the risk factors according to a taxonomy of model
capability, we reveal a set of potential deficiencies in commonsense
memorization, relational reasoning, and instruction following, which may
further provide guidance for the pretraining and supervised fine-tuning process
of LLMs to mitigate the hallucination. | [
0.0126845539,
0.0460244156,
-0.0246567782,
0.0325393453,
-0.0299761575,
0.0553459711,
-0.0099124983,
-0.0076248324,
0.00168747,
-0.0763899982,
-0.0206766054,
-0.0291464124,
0.0115870982,
-0.0466573834,
0.0314611197,
-0.0441418961,
0.06916181,
-0.0346502624,
-0.037634626,
-0.0050288583,
-0.0111486912,
0.0283909086,
-0.0292115007,
0.0301702507,
-0.0208088867,
-0.0453226753,
0.0308838245,
-0.0304041468,
0.0117657529,
-0.0120215844,
-0.007175026,
0.0770675614,
-0.0073206117,
0.0460649729,
0.0000021493,
-0.0732949972,
0.0075275707,
-0.014579636,
0.0006389556,
0.0237288643,
0.0127216,
0.0153598366,
-0.006342811,
0.0183821786,
-0.0273292996,
-0.0013378977,
0.0379187725,
0.1098024398,
0.022373572,
0.0629453585,
-0.001312934,
-0.0691769868,
0.0604857616,
0.0280650593,
0.0572082736,
-0.001136857,
0.0475047752,
0.0446055084,
-0.0160638876,
-0.0622807406,
-0.0096580433,
0.0146287316,
0.0245125238,
0.0322110504,
0.017486779,
0.021874899,
-0.0991923884,
-0.0263108797,
0.0108059859,
0.0457734987,
-0.0328610651,
-0.06141451,
0.01206824,
0.0234340541,
-0.0094374241,
0.0368525311,
-0.0306297075,
0.0205526892,
-0.0166275483,
0.02709217,
0.0528707355,
-0.0249349046,
0.0458835252,
0.0378262177,
-0.041915942,
0.0523777455,
0.0156106427,
-0.0346667767,
0.0453216396,
0.0191399734,
-0.0222184304,
-0.0341757759,
-0.0025473612,
0.0103547033,
-0.056151174,
0.0200280454,
-0.0110598616,
0.0052838344,
0.0572137199,
-0.1068436429,
0.0225656368,
0.0277443044,
-0.0386331007,
0.0381598435,
-0.0673390999,
0.0483799055,
-0.0100497287,
0.0908862129,
-0.0060099596,
0.0216796696,
-0.0660007894,
-0.0144754462,
-0.0249482486,
0.0091554206,
0.0183446724,
-0.0191181358,
-0.0288598035,
-0.0018186409,
-0.0298325531,
0.0073873741,
-0.0209753085,
0.0204624757,
0.0159103982,
-0.0255051125,
-0.0486488864,
0.0087702805,
-0.0248883478,
0.0183839779,
0.0102542359,
-0.057378713,
-0.0019461517,
0.0123054367,
-0.0227601007,
-0.0264581908,
0.0061861449,
0.0194636341,
0.0024156563,
-0.0290716346,
-0.0541629903,
-0.0133296903,
-0.0082878368,
-0.0620285943,
0.0277696401,
-0.0592773706,
0.0011604489,
0.0306376182,
0.0027943442,
-0.0262521449,
0.0193918459,
0.0216937698,
-0.049496226,
0.0709054321,
-0.006939698,
0.0153831029,
0.0240205973,
0.0369851515,
-0.028502645,
0.0776726827,
-0.0016154726,
-0.0121785803,
-0.0144114923,
-0.0340407677,
0.0420290828,
-0.0133972205,
-0.0110418899,
0.0069330852,
-0.0375575721,
-0.0167596303,
0.0365290828,
0.0047596302,
0.0354077294,
0.0611367524,
-0.0176389385,
-0.0288891103,
0.0301265419,
0.0128505444,
-0.0005795159,
0.0231510475,
0.0173235592,
-0.0337248519,
0.013608654,
0.0447527356,
-0.0849592015,
0.0045614792,
-0.0570322461,
-0.0038219774,
0.045653116,
0.027192153,
-0.0217326786,
-0.0213075113,
-0.0288795531,
0.0193026848,
0.0117594386,
-0.0009066304,
0.0257445835,
0.0414159074,
-0.0432259925,
0.0630362332,
0.0526487418,
-0.0261789206,
0.0292415675,
-0.0435398594,
-0.0240221526,
0.0752279237,
0.0442758352,
0.0055074929,
0.0182194598,
-0.0231103729,
0.0124665638,
0.0389030054,
0.0196329635,
0.0004707522,
0.0127000548,
-0.0410301499,
0.0118053779,
0.0007489987,
0.0614642501,
0.0146351038,
-0.0398076288,
-0.0185725726,
-0.0083667859,
-0.0156140216,
-0.0540829599,
0.0457268134,
-0.0293808803,
-0.0332846306,
-0.0515584275,
-0.0058331862,
0.0258347169,
0.0071797911,
-0.0023621619,
0.0444837473,
0.0022653891,
-0.0490991957,
-0.0346750021,
0.0081522102,
-0.05781468,
-0.0097411824,
0.0129514886,
-0.0089326184,
-0.0008649052,
-0.0044268677,
-0.0024175197,
-0.0349247456,
0.018922165,
-0.0290140864,
0.0898963436,
-0.0258123968,
0.0565607995,
0.0081964675,
0.0310295243,
-0.0097808605,
0.1259733588,
-0.0323679149,
0.0558984615,
0.0116738332,
-0.0098668393,
-0.0076287067,
-0.0143855577,
-0.018646704,
0.0052897092,
-0.0082208794,
0.030090658,
-0.0246973876,
-0.0763200596,
-0.0774831325,
-0.014275603,
-0.0711560547,
-0.0077467305,
-0.030563809,
-0.0139850406,
0.0238795094,
-0.0460615791,
-0.0214823056,
0.0081650168,
0.0087763667,
-0.0112775769,
0.003641217,
0.0780233666,
-0.0162599757,
0.0100167803,
-0.0339205675,
-0.0098901717,
0.012058503,
-0.0412340574,
0.0485691242,
-0.0109211467,
-0.0052092108,
-0.075647682,
0.0823863447,
-0.0308030322,
-0.0060964483,
-0.0111063467,
-0.0299569368,
0.0320157371,
0.0180702843,
0.0540871508,
0.0826254413,
0.0096344929,
0.0349545926,
0.0744799152,
-0.0411846377,
-0.0317202173,
-0.0138575956,
-0.0017674147,
-0.0177931152,
-0.0204001497,
-0.0496245101,
-0.0231491346,
0.0664751157,
0.0199232362,
0.0012413986,
-0.0518338606,
0.0168162026,
-0.034512233,
-0.0335081257,
-0.0081735672,
-0.0468522049,
-0.0103038307,
0.0527877621,
-0.0183616448,
-0.048665043,
0.0434046611,
-0.0154287685,
0.0207818113,
-0.0398515016,
0.0035530697,
0.0070961365,
0.0172934365,
0.0049727862,
0.0160505641,
-0.00386336,
-0.037909206,
-0.0442062505,
-0.0405369736,
-0.0155900558,
-0.0370519422,
0.0279356502,
-0.023754552,
0.0079246424,
0.0319556445,
-0.0110113807,
-0.0690493286,
-0.0030251769,
-0.0059004896,
-0.0265969168,
-0.0329089612,
0.0191772766,
-0.0640364736,
-0.0080616213,
-0.005453066,
-0.026887551,
-0.0079786619,
-0.0329492129,
0.0163988546,
-0.0204469059,
0.0630815849,
-0.022722071,
0.0585679822,
-0.0352514498,
0.0126525844,
0.0483266748,
0.0380520858,
0.0603249148,
-0.0356388055,
0.0133021781,
-0.0038026446,
-0.0147352619,
-0.0266214591,
0.0089361705,
0.0159540512,
-0.0663046166,
-0.0116767082,
0.1039021537,
0.0465933345,
-0.0503427386,
0.0142597239,
-0.0248563197,
0.0657572597,
0.0107677877,
-0.0208859388,
-0.0472381115,
0.0020730756,
-0.010199286,
-0.0276520085,
-0.0379505232,
-0.0301866289,
-0.0016051965,
-0.0761297196,
-0.0099481549,
0.032542143,
-0.0484051406,
-0.025846906,
-0.0566721521,
-0.0006676411,
-0.0104934284,
0.0702322423,
-0.0090883141,
0.0009071783,
-0.0290954728,
0.0215621628,
-0.0365005434,
-0.0546506532,
0.0428065322,
-0.021794986,
0.0871374831,
0.0768192858,
0.034892071,
0.0055982759,
-0.071464926,
0.0197067764,
-0.0278843604,
0.0245382413,
0.0005737452,
0.049861569,
0.0238475278,
0.009071677,
-0.0197979566,
0.0189624298,
-0.0471939333,
-0.0407186002,
-0.0317582637,
0.0832520574,
-0.0490144268,
-0.0410564989,
-0.0082406346,
0.0392134748,
0.0063398122,
0.0964798108,
0.0056561083,
0.0110067166,
-0.0382976905,
-0.0156081514,
0.0325287916,
-0.0163089149,
-0.0274131801,
0.0637872666,
0.0527114347,
-0.0315229706,
-0.0583487079,
-0.0480173156,
0.0236597769,
0.0041167592,
0.0030609148,
0.0740298554,
-0.0246329363,
-0.0109968521,
-0.0050674942,
0.0644886866,
-0.0140672252,
-0.0102486573,
-0.0332013443,
-0.0119959339,
0.0064151161,
0.0016348276,
-0.0003844438,
-0.0167803857,
-0.07614059,
-0.07220231,
0.0413084999,
0.0314923972,
0.0273938812,
0.041389782,
0.0031178545,
-0.066232793,
0.0139188943,
0.0203895364,
0.0116846943,
0.0003763057,
-0.0005636043,
-0.009481607,
0.0216184892,
0.0227537137,
-0.0101846838,
-0.0072421026,
0.011229611,
0.0411889292,
-0.0172858369,
0.0309249926,
0.0378858261,
-0.0163356848,
0.0053206803,
-0.0158924945,
0.0088335797,
-0.0245449841,
-0.0109012658,
-0.0196871366,
0.015331856,
0.0066071716,
-0.002239669,
0.0593655035,
-0.0198609289,
-0.0000620366,
-0.0579110086,
-0.0444410555,
-0.0083958991,
-0.0105339615,
0.0031962765,
0.0012513648,
-0.0119659137,
0.0511202589,
0.0013900184,
-0.022624841,
-0.0060573975,
0.0070376345,
0.0607299395,
0.0163392387,
0.0898606554,
0.0091180708,
-0.0080606434,
-0.0221009981,
-0.0109184626,
-0.0291557778,
-0.071322009,
-0.006824139,
0.0090858471,
0.0431320108,
-0.054992497,
0.061887119,
-0.0360593945,
0.0298424009,
-0.024426654,
0.0171952322,
0.0444638096,
-0.0425461568,
0.0055932282,
0.0316390395,
-0.0198232159,
0.0024873018,
0.0668772757,
-0.0449801795,
0.0395237505,
0.0135750668,
-0.0106225908,
-0.0141562466,
-0.0660174713,
-0.0100412378,
0.0176473148,
-0.0429367088,
0.0016356984,
-0.0653164908,
-0.0707171038,
-0.0080100577,
-0.0228105001,
0.0088664787,
-0.0000110844,
0.0072523383,
0.0790481269,
-0.0561545603,
-0.0151024899,
-0.016222205,
-0.03274481,
0.0244746879,
-0.011120392,
-0.0170097891,
-6.781692865e-33,
0.0064543919,
-0.0225718189,
0.026153516,
-0.0490228869,
0.0028501654,
-0.0298505593,
-0.016924426,
0.0179259721,
-0.0296542197,
0.0194367021,
0.0095504802,
0.0329318084,
0.0083165374,
0.0282573793,
0.0177982021,
-0.0247138701,
0.0192120355,
0.0553399473,
-0.0224709641,
0.0041479189,
0.0379985087,
0.0066378014,
0.0429762788,
-0.0744257346,
0.035081584,
-0.0068296576,
-0.0175640564,
0.0094907237,
-0.0221706536,
0.046563074,
-0.0357548743,
0.048539862,
0.0390036181,
-0.0306094494,
-0.0123926215,
-0.0093764691,
-0.0285124984,
-0.040128421,
0.044862587,
0.0272206776,
0.011115117,
-0.0217783134,
0.04596591,
-0.0070394403,
0.0000570647,
-0.0181936547,
0.0326198712,
-0.0432549305,
-0.0384798944,
0.0379925445,
-0.0769267231,
-0.0154504282,
0.0090182163,
-0.0040481617,
0.0008597674,
0.0027845209,
-0.0246613827,
-0.0097346371,
-0.0736565664,
0.0005277795,
-0.0016842287,
0.0048322696,
0.0634361431,
0.0113257188,
0.0082830759,
0.0891694278,
0.0429158323,
0.011806122,
-0.0122197019,
-0.0137751549,
0.0342936814,
0.0523505472,
0.0365142077,
-0.010416301,
0.0814512521,
0.0100806579,
-0.0243446473,
0.0015690792,
-0.0428724848,
0.0373711698,
0.0745095462,
0.0067574922,
-0.0683509931,
-0.0430245809,
-0.0201364681,
0.0499180146,
-0.0393977277,
-0.0435566194,
0.0346283391,
-0.0260554682,
-0.0119244661,
-0.0172083452,
0.0352949277,
-0.0348494723,
-0.0292599481,
0.0325641818,
-0.0058313995,
-0.0002106203,
-0.0211152192,
-0.0046096835,
-0.0214686505,
-0.0249374639,
0.0315607451,
0.0095571568,
0.0448885374,
0.0260035861,
0.0430014692,
-0.0271926094,
-0.0669064149,
-0.0075478065,
-0.0354223959,
-0.0002446184,
0.0356966332,
0.0056606834,
0.0569507107,
0.017747622,
-0.0208116136,
0.0115307588,
0.0356417596,
0.0065179737,
-0.0036114135,
0.0419428162,
-0.0608341657,
-0.0017359199,
-0.0099467924,
-0.0134199318,
-0.0333525762,
-0.0266583376,
0.0544409528,
-0.0669477805,
-0.0070625143,
-0.0247796923,
2.823e-7,
0.0300107058,
0.0760545656,
-0.0239065476,
0.0096486807,
-0.0053091436,
0.0140404059,
0.0031378588,
-0.0120788105,
0.052190911,
-0.0441804491,
-0.0224237572,
0.0307188239,
0.0643081367,
0.0507840216,
-0.0649201199,
0.0022865385,
-0.0504612178,
0.0095014554,
-0.0734818429,
-0.0097827204,
0.0558399707,
0.0672899932,
0.0002115752,
-0.0213535503,
0.0129104657,
-0.0609874688,
0.0455276743,
-0.0194762629,
0.0070895874,
0.0266938265,
0.022363279,
0.0235387553,
0.0318936072,
0.0808318034,
-0.0188057106,
-0.0221476573,
-0.0095958598,
-0.0100924317,
-0.0457837507,
-0.0568237267,
-0.0176642574,
-0.0228120293,
0.0044256104,
-0.0862676725,
0.062446259,
-0.0433966368,
-0.024300972,
0.0121841663,
-0.0190849956,
0.0051264199,
0.0667650104,
0.0125962161,
-0.0125127453,
0.0207912195,
0.0048604757,
0.0158611834,
-0.013713588,
-0.0713603273,
-0.001752622,
0.0160613302,
0.0099246819,
-0.0270988327,
0.0003907193,
-0.0005098932,
0.0171477981,
-0.070704177,
-0.0077432413,
2.834238332e-34,
0.0120451581,
0.0071127601,
0.0555038825,
0.0395877287,
0.040779788,
-0.0039105918,
0.0209991131,
0.0532358475,
-0.0185422488,
-0.0717961714,
0.0142557174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05210v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05210v3 | Understanding the Impact of Post-Training Quantization on Large Language Models | 2023-09-11T02:58:32 | 2023-09-17T05:38:46 | Somnath Roy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are rapidly increasing in size, with the number
of parameters becoming a key factor in the success of many commercial models,
such as ChatGPT, Claude, and Bard. Even the recently released publicly
accessible models for commercial usage, such as Falcon and Llama2, come
equipped with billions of parameters. This significant increase in the number
of parameters makes deployment and operation very costly. The remarkable
progress in the field of quantization for large neural networks in general and
LLMs in particular, has made these models more accessible by enabling them to
be deployed on consumer-grade GPUs. Quantized models generally demonstrate
comparable performance levels to their unquantized base counterparts.
Nonetheless, there exists a notable gap in our comprehensive understanding of
how these quantized models respond to hyperparameters, such as temperature, max
new tokens, and topk, particularly for next word prediction. The present
analysis reveals that nf4 and fp4 are equally proficient 4-bit quantization
techniques, characterized by similar attributes such as inference speed, memory
consumption, and the quality of generated content. the study identifies nf4 as
displaying greater resilience to temperature variations in the case of the
llama2 series of models at lower temperature, while fp4 and fp4-dq proves to be
a more suitable choice for falcon series of models. It is noteworthy that, in
general, 4-bit quantized models of varying sizes exhibit higher sensitivity to
temperature in the range of 0.5 to 0.8, unlike their unquantized counterparts.
Additionally, int8 quantization is associated with significantly slower
inference speeds, whereas unquantized bfloat16 models consistently yield the
fastest inference speeds across models of all sizes. | [
-0.0161596593,
0.0632106736,
-0.0071509755,
0.0505092144,
-0.0177237019,
0.0057100966,
0.0154592535,
0.0128173353,
-0.0174868964,
-0.0407820158,
-0.0315782204,
-0.0535952114,
0.0014909566,
0.0194210038,
0.0317424163,
-0.0301921833,
0.0571958162,
-0.0549242869,
0.0293723792,
-0.0189410038,
-0.0229354054,
-0.0100006489,
0.0275782999,
0.0172985829,
-0.0022343185,
-0.008051021,
-0.0233657025,
-0.0017492003,
-0.0157752,
-0.0162478164,
0.0030211941,
0.0677066445,
0.0228451751,
0.0286758542,
0.0000020935,
-0.0178628471,
-0.0051546008,
-0.0001859242,
-0.0292831752,
0.0588128902,
0.0493022464,
-0.0026043134,
-0.022352403,
0.0240851846,
-0.0333565325,
-0.0506442338,
0.0609423034,
0.0180473663,
0.0027974152,
0.0377903506,
-0.0021016058,
-0.051156126,
0.0771365315,
-0.0109841479,
-0.0342381783,
-0.0327035487,
0.0006234368,
-0.0120854191,
-0.0009046946,
0.0158555564,
-0.0297840852,
0.0161510799,
0.0340997949,
0.0340181291,
-0.029745752,
0.0437831022,
-0.0658347681,
-0.0030451124,
-0.029951524,
0.033667434,
-0.0854787901,
-0.0165633336,
-0.0221983511,
0.0293124579,
-0.0338454023,
-0.081295684,
-0.0338955782,
0.0397893749,
0.0123363389,
0.0278058499,
0.0136068296,
-0.0034063968,
0.0613593124,
0.0227394216,
-0.0233428143,
0.0824982226,
0.0313317999,
-0.0018278577,
0.0080616493,
-0.0201255605,
-0.0838770345,
-0.0578064919,
-0.0210159272,
0.0029198597,
0.0152591802,
0.0025808024,
-0.0944238752,
0.0241318718,
0.0002942454,
-0.0341215543,
0.021242531,
0.0613578297,
0.0023150295,
-0.0207678862,
-0.045149833,
0.0187839437,
-0.0215736907,
0.0217742585,
-0.0573090836,
0.0177398045,
-0.007689619,
-0.0187442414,
-0.0237725768,
0.0271754526,
-0.0118467249,
-0.0325625576,
-0.0673552006,
-0.0161846541,
0.004656639,
-0.0266268775,
0.022922501,
0.0240785647,
-0.0020531148,
0.0318662599,
-0.0078171771,
0.0203033425,
-0.0429114774,
0.0058625485,
0.0159742404,
-0.0956652537,
0.0062812758,
-0.0182781219,
0.0023967703,
-0.0479307659,
0.0497901142,
0.0345699675,
0.0187063422,
-0.0435565822,
-0.0235572718,
0.0052154111,
-0.0169283189,
-0.103371948,
0.0202140734,
-0.0427884385,
-0.0192243345,
0.0112045286,
-0.0061268834,
0.0040155393,
0.0114189647,
0.0033762616,
-0.011663097,
0.0560137741,
-0.0357172862,
-0.0284680743,
0.0098243337,
-0.0012220819,
0.0614147782,
0.0870415717,
0.0386965349,
0.0560128503,
0.0245782491,
-0.0049767923,
-0.0160394795,
0.0366468281,
0.0165765267,
0.0008055246,
-0.0620679036,
-0.018789215,
0.0083753355,
0.050340347,
0.083146587,
0.0699701235,
-0.0495271608,
-0.0664892346,
0.0437527187,
0.0513180606,
0.0300878678,
0.0275989249,
0.0214030612,
-0.0145029016,
0.0285095684,
-0.0117675811,
-0.0419184417,
0.0266201347,
0.0157655682,
0.0133815072,
0.0581960753,
0.0469631106,
-0.033301577,
-0.0606307797,
-0.034784276,
-0.0079244152,
0.0109995119,
-0.0135686779,
0.0201155841,
-0.0316709131,
0.0033404874,
0.073187381,
0.0177009739,
-0.0297993943,
-0.0282528978,
-0.0728878975,
-0.0086439559,
0.069878906,
-0.0037817555,
0.0149322813,
-0.0482061729,
0.0196853969,
-0.0019610904,
-0.0249341428,
0.0234417785,
0.0260262284,
0.0373348072,
-0.0525815934,
0.0014890331,
-0.056356404,
0.0151730031,
0.022923233,
0.0293809623,
0.0201656595,
-0.0145373931,
-0.0105605656,
-0.0254044142,
0.0213414114,
0.0238490999,
-0.0563366897,
0.0113120852,
-0.0185313988,
0.0237409528,
0.0056097074,
-0.0126855588,
-0.0107273441,
0.0382635593,
-0.047888983,
0.0335487276,
-0.0117014507,
-0.0221408792,
-0.0074830912,
0.0502977036,
0.0293807164,
0.064322181,
0.029046163,
-0.0492056981,
-0.044187393,
0.0717282519,
0.0142743532,
0.0546263158,
-0.0278917681,
-0.0042838794,
-0.004906008,
0.0465775877,
-0.0040205773,
0.034958899,
-0.0242069699,
0.0022566172,
-0.0036479731,
0.0059364983,
0.0101536633,
-0.0352524556,
-0.0215597339,
0.0266606547,
0.0218361653,
0.0101533374,
-0.0256133731,
-0.0146142095,
0.00486616,
0.0085954405,
-0.1117514893,
0.0180662964,
-0.0426458381,
0.0175379794,
0.0113788508,
0.0130329356,
-0.0198580418,
0.0054586176,
-0.0251017138,
-0.0202829149,
-0.0202410538,
0.0128598232,
0.0017147074,
-0.0171701051,
-0.0072197234,
-0.0390748009,
-0.0710840225,
0.0122608999,
0.0877600238,
-0.049732428,
-0.0674111992,
-0.0348135233,
0.0202896409,
-0.0416826159,
0.0327589251,
-0.0375258066,
-0.0401359238,
0.0301171094,
-0.0238750391,
0.0018852972,
0.0593489707,
0.0084790708,
0.0137230884,
0.0617091954,
0.0191557147,
-0.0140769202,
0.0308513716,
-0.0152990613,
-0.0392119139,
-0.0083250916,
-0.0113133891,
-0.0395665579,
0.0654536486,
-0.0350981802,
-0.0149520049,
-0.0188538916,
0.0619837157,
-0.0309880804,
-0.0207902398,
-0.0359196179,
0.0074549969,
-0.0110856378,
0.0671877116,
0.0120202238,
-0.064793855,
0.0175819155,
-0.043247778,
0.0180477127,
-0.0274658371,
-0.0152618205,
-0.0271848757,
0.060311541,
0.0224992801,
0.0450186096,
-0.0235552862,
-0.0082577104,
-0.0315778814,
-0.0237787664,
-0.0120243309,
-0.0173484366,
-0.0024525821,
-0.0068529961,
0.0023088777,
-0.03543007,
-0.0226584114,
0.0338494256,
0.0107802982,
-0.0273922067,
0.043873813,
0.052205503,
-0.0421933495,
0.0550737418,
0.0439192206,
-0.0258308221,
0.0422619246,
-0.045712214,
-0.0043394053,
-0.009473878,
0.0188618023,
0.0293121841,
-0.005547774,
0.0401743278,
-0.0115738502,
-0.0340515375,
0.0053771003,
0.0229724422,
0.0524431802,
-0.0952123031,
0.0093449121,
0.0260031801,
0.0099139428,
-0.0355732404,
0.0034182025,
0.0575283803,
-0.0500334613,
0.0198507383,
0.0538610481,
-0.0067691044,
-0.0233776718,
0.0193686653,
0.0229324363,
0.0375237912,
0.0005618864,
0.0097866608,
-0.0906589031,
-0.0154495724,
0.0274360329,
0.0231976919,
0.00481692,
0.0085659614,
-0.0086391047,
-0.0482142046,
0.034335535,
0.0057231192,
-0.0196568836,
0.0094208559,
-0.037178643,
-0.0182977337,
-0.0325959809,
0.0637916028,
-0.0015045215,
-0.0051355963,
0.0082604671,
0.0401908793,
-0.00999399,
-0.0364708044,
0.0362822823,
-0.0242422,
0.0296936855,
0.0271785967,
0.0063851723,
-0.0342219584,
0.0071095456,
0.0226874426,
0.0198724773,
0.0122915125,
-0.0298344046,
0.032515727,
-0.0007119176,
-0.0137411868,
0.0022527426,
0.0085029807,
0.0260518193,
-0.0009043732,
-0.0372265317,
0.0163134318,
-0.0163319595,
-0.0527549088,
-0.0120126046,
-0.0358854085,
-0.0429703109,
0.0385976993,
0.0243152864,
-0.0025915443,
-0.0932164416,
-0.0010453066,
0.0062764566,
-0.0597867295,
-0.0141176479,
-0.048729673,
-0.0143707562,
-0.0564312823,
-0.0270746052,
0.0159907788,
0.0062086079,
0.048986502,
-0.0202054475,
0.0094335414,
0.0258769337,
0.0127056604,
-0.0838894174,
0.0268609319,
0.0155362329,
0.0174748339,
-0.0358981788,
-0.0165787376,
0.0175183229,
-0.0244202521,
-0.0275028218,
-0.0161283854,
-0.0999271572,
-0.0578466356,
0.0272862706,
0.0514752418,
0.0208439976,
0.0398106538,
0.0162624791,
-0.0682336465,
0.0374074802,
0.0595442988,
-0.0099553447,
0.0540752709,
0.0235375073,
0.0074198144,
0.0037802111,
0.0189035106,
0.0053982623,
0.0562386401,
0.0124932202,
0.0175764915,
-0.0004232373,
-0.050093092,
-0.025452463,
-0.0008569825,
0.0563337393,
-0.0075447503,
-0.0045627481,
0.0052042282,
0.0044284509,
-0.0005752518,
0.03009733,
-0.0420470871,
0.0010473155,
0.0544464104,
0.0475848243,
-0.0264657699,
-0.0462064557,
0.0494592041,
-0.0218593311,
0.02389884,
-0.0003433119,
-0.0303416066,
0.0554030426,
0.0153032662,
0.007511511,
-0.0418499298,
0.0353835039,
-0.0291677304,
0.0428464748,
-0.0464478321,
0.0234716833,
-0.0148900282,
0.0061077629,
-0.0673536062,
0.06011739,
-0.0738739967,
-0.0643829107,
-0.0540834665,
-0.0143875917,
0.0452802666,
0.0226205513,
0.023839632,
-0.0223202705,
-0.0168476664,
-0.0051608658,
0.0081468523,
0.0217066016,
0.0035809707,
0.060927324,
0.0264778696,
-0.0321698822,
-0.016323965,
0.0393327735,
0.0356956385,
0.0279610977,
0.0241304226,
-0.0041129459,
0.0157932714,
-0.0295872148,
-0.0640526935,
0.0106325038,
0.0077120434,
-0.0541879274,
-0.0103059839,
-0.0267980378,
0.0060387547,
0.0174842495,
-0.0080244849,
-0.0253170691,
0.0055905995,
0.0526927635,
0.0214444585,
-0.0826371387,
-0.0276964512,
-0.0135584353,
0.0212419666,
0.0035829155,
-0.01088103,
-6.773194041e-33,
-0.0074925036,
0.0379535444,
0.0356500298,
-0.0192064382,
-0.0426920131,
0.0379806384,
0.003146094,
0.0008317619,
-0.0370184965,
-0.0353951231,
-0.0211409871,
0.0166562684,
0.0290099159,
0.0056261518,
-0.0041674031,
-0.0493272394,
0.0693836734,
-0.0104630655,
0.0134512102,
0.0232607629,
0.0279978905,
0.0253952388,
0.0671223104,
0.0272927582,
-0.0216707308,
-0.0088191042,
0.0187897608,
-0.0213933401,
0.0118855434,
0.0205137283,
-0.0496343188,
0.032000374,
0.0100937774,
0.0016854458,
-0.0105969189,
-0.0277779624,
-0.0756919682,
-0.0000554182,
0.0144929728,
0.0188634843,
-0.0065301671,
-0.0517481863,
0.0602976903,
0.0423480049,
-0.0354871899,
-0.0181989875,
-0.0330756009,
0.0078202775,
-0.0663053095,
-0.0755635276,
-0.0109635834,
0.0268587153,
0.041328039,
0.0595025942,
0.0569172613,
-0.0019128325,
-0.0481791347,
-0.0152052529,
-0.0626711547,
-0.0183836613,
0.0601145476,
0.0897326097,
0.0483769402,
0.0546536371,
0.0390821733,
0.0508104973,
0.0870663077,
-0.0186550189,
-0.0281890389,
0.0444351695,
0.0737516955,
0.0538226776,
0.0440441817,
0.0284827389,
0.1310058087,
-0.0309903789,
-0.0531877652,
-0.031720154,
0.0246997029,
0.0275325645,
0.0256949831,
0.008237741,
-0.0264656637,
-0.0498193577,
-0.0443610735,
-0.0136370966,
-0.0370335989,
-0.0392567404,
0.0350812748,
0.0009405783,
0.0066166706,
0.003791563,
0.0241443161,
-0.0311167575,
0.0082242396,
-0.0086215036,
0.0042557623,
0.0450750999,
-0.002426398,
0.0435817726,
-0.0405274443,
-0.0427576751,
-0.0165060442,
0.0320118442,
0.0140312556,
-0.0214324277,
0.0204499196,
0.0635411218,
-0.0440396518,
-0.0148736127,
-0.0227237642,
-0.0127256978,
0.0213018339,
0.0459388606,
0.0390076824,
-0.0023588922,
0.0222477205,
-0.0003652849,
-0.0074723056,
0.0525339954,
-0.0333028287,
-0.0000831279,
0.0265648533,
0.0343028903,
-0.0090391878,
0.0106399348,
-0.0466346219,
0.0425258391,
0.0167584773,
-0.0981359482,
-0.0363950059,
0.0541175976,
2.863e-7,
0.0513769612,
0.0621798746,
-0.0046053734,
-0.0281772818,
-0.0186496768,
-0.0126571339,
-0.001846579,
0.0037514442,
0.0043977662,
0.0404926315,
0.0060315412,
0.0144482944,
0.0204383228,
0.0508666262,
-0.0409870706,
-0.0231686253,
-0.0507468618,
0.0189084131,
-0.062688902,
-0.015185426,
0.0295937713,
0.1174887791,
-0.0042772093,
-0.0103126448,
0.0596324801,
-0.0010381133,
0.0263199694,
-0.0321926959,
0.0292235985,
0.0124727767,
0.0346308351,
0.0347109996,
0.0009331502,
-0.015197101,
0.0233621839,
-0.0042477706,
-0.0365872271,
0.0732001215,
-0.0056034368,
-0.0406794734,
0.0254453514,
-0.0087115467,
-0.010418768,
-0.0805830732,
0.0798314586,
-0.0257216543,
-0.0393320955,
-0.0794774592,
-0.0134311607,
-0.0185311139,
0.0260902159,
-0.0194484666,
0.035761755,
0.0368747003,
0.0015759974,
-0.0314076804,
-0.033419434,
-0.0995754004,
-0.0271831919,
0.0199693237,
-0.0218983907,
-0.044521682,
-0.0730856061,
-0.0094373552,
0.048519168,
-0.0246641375,
0.0072268988,
2.633266451e-34,
0.0513186567,
-0.0327384248,
0.0192275494,
-0.0089819571,
-0.0218782574,
-0.0084948083,
0.011636504,
-0.008275317,
-0.0334578753,
-0.0715595782,
-0.0330260657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05203v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05203v3 | From Artificially Real to Real: Leveraging Pseudo Data from Large Language Models for Low-Resource Molecule Discovery | 2023-09-11T02:35:36 | 2024-03-05T10:51:23 | Yuhan Chen, Nuwa Xi, Yanrui Du, Haochun Wang, Jianyu Chen, Sendong Zhao, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Molecule discovery serves as a cornerstone in numerous scientific domains,
fueling the development of new materials and innovative drug designs. Recent
developments of in-silico molecule discovery have highlighted the promising
results of cross-modal techniques, which bridge molecular structures with their
descriptive annotations. However, these cross-modal methods frequently
encounter the issue of data scarcity, hampering their performance and
application. In this paper, we address the low-resource challenge by utilizing
artificially-real data generated by Large Language Models (LLMs). We first
introduce a retrieval-based prompting strategy to construct high-quality pseudo
data, then explore the optimal method to effectively leverage this pseudo data.
Experiments show that using pseudo data for domain adaptation outperforms all
existing methods, while also requiring a smaller model scale, reduced data size
and lower training cost, highlighting its efficiency. Furthermore, our method
shows a sustained improvement as the volume of pseudo data increases, revealing
the great potential of pseudo data in advancing low-resource cross-modal
molecule discovery. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/SCIR-HI/ArtificiallyR2R. | [
0.0454223715,
0.0808921754,
0.0083135096,
0.0343184471,
0.0081983963,
0.0023675996,
0.0106427483,
0.0366939902,
0.0354176722,
-0.0201368947,
-0.042772796,
-0.039726764,
-0.0418529734,
0.0518846363,
0.0237130206,
0.0152256675,
0.0049702427,
-0.0433945023,
0.0076277908,
-0.0304053929,
-0.0046742344,
-0.0000551373,
0.024984071,
-0.0222920049,
0.0154581703,
-0.0210351478,
-0.0115335584,
0.0005193994,
0.0136451973,
-0.0395636037,
-0.0075925905,
0.0422155559,
0.0271520708,
0.0610167347,
0.0000018777,
-0.0464641862,
-0.0483228154,
0.0338769034,
-0.0252418984,
0.0150171574,
0.0658690855,
-0.0558721684,
0.0023597421,
-0.0104158977,
-0.0256213509,
-0.03989603,
0.0605012067,
0.0282044783,
0.0228715781,
0.0636783987,
0.0093347784,
-0.0070557101,
0.0022634678,
-0.0195301641,
0.065121524,
-0.0238639992,
0.0683897361,
0.0499885418,
0.0371583961,
0.0375810452,
0.0071510361,
0.0207556933,
-0.0341107659,
-0.0475676209,
-0.0118131181,
0.0160603318,
-0.0254337024,
-0.0173764694,
0.0105757751,
0.1154513881,
-0.0002456105,
-0.0596629791,
-0.0117199291,
0.0018330857,
-0.0358438827,
0.0698331594,
-0.0301944613,
-0.010114993,
0.0121435383,
0.0248723496,
0.0581072271,
0.0041743629,
0.0541625842,
0.0209995564,
0.018135814,
0.0085510472,
0.0076490245,
-0.0221837405,
0.0173731726,
0.0088388184,
-0.0633448437,
-0.0149510661,
-0.0052340557,
-0.0342686549,
-0.0140573494,
0.0265943035,
0.0091524832,
-0.0153705953,
0.0439011715,
-0.0084021594,
0.054699339,
0.0228675213,
0.0017767163,
0.0409087613,
-0.024966836,
-0.0120589286,
-0.0751529336,
0.0090223076,
-0.0602790229,
-0.0206109378,
-0.0733241513,
0.0072777984,
-0.0534892827,
0.0446174666,
-0.0612148121,
0.0009704346,
-0.0272207204,
0.0437344015,
0.0094890259,
-0.0348211341,
0.0259924307,
0.0062463237,
-0.0480123945,
0.0100448122,
-0.0277941637,
0.0097742546,
0.0036893454,
-0.0026185885,
-0.0347691998,
-0.0653910711,
-0.0409953557,
0.0120325638,
0.019316379,
-0.0577399991,
0.0262814909,
0.0753666013,
-0.0006858124,
-0.0353248492,
0.0072359834,
-0.0576876476,
0.0211317893,
-0.0498855151,
0.0338343792,
-0.0489714108,
0.022557456,
0.0312218964,
-0.0073231561,
-0.0598610863,
0.0129616056,
-0.0103229266,
-0.043963179,
0.0961421877,
-0.0493565835,
-0.0372072868,
0.0037698259,
-0.0005013492,
0.0005056208,
0.0324872434,
-0.0155871175,
-0.015782766,
0.0056813438,
0.0083909798,
0.0131675713,
0.0196413156,
0.0215792563,
-0.0206900164,
0.0127176074,
0.0211769268,
0.0395680964,
0.0487532578,
0.0044119712,
-0.0015080868,
-0.0176020972,
-0.0234865043,
0.0193320289,
0.0133923925,
0.0439862758,
0.0559082478,
0.0194646958,
0.0289992187,
-0.0131746074,
-0.0347389914,
-0.017709339,
0.0348793641,
-0.047896143,
0.0322851129,
0.0672078431,
0.0111791193,
0.0058226469,
-0.0030032359,
-0.0250965245,
0.01275218,
-0.0302627869,
-0.0108715184,
0.0447908454,
-0.0218590386,
-0.060272146,
0.0244608764,
0.0728103071,
-0.02408823,
-0.0114911888,
-0.0104768276,
0.0206315164,
0.0524341874,
0.0538488477,
-0.0916415155,
-0.0235426258,
0.0336936191,
0.0239826962,
0.0401409343,
0.009573455,
-0.0422116816,
-0.018982321,
-0.0098406123,
-0.0320094414,
-0.0251221955,
0.0140550891,
-0.0035494117,
-0.0068932003,
-0.0090178931,
-0.0009863829,
-0.0850163475,
-0.0092015155,
0.0166442096,
-0.0394681282,
-0.0268000383,
0.0589129552,
-0.0108351214,
0.0248277225,
0.0297578219,
-0.0066849906,
0.0434648581,
0.0805693567,
-0.0719819143,
0.0095378775,
-0.063076295,
0.0153715154,
-0.0371820591,
0.0411267132,
-0.0488583557,
0.0456085838,
0.007207423,
-0.0267630238,
-0.0299047269,
0.0610387698,
-0.0034677,
0.04256979,
-0.0393335074,
-0.0077625471,
0.0041860649,
0.0693188086,
-0.0294092931,
0.0479489751,
0.0185822938,
0.0432042703,
0.04421179,
0.0217306893,
0.0345577635,
-0.0453722291,
0.031832587,
0.0204296838,
0.0285226889,
0.0455816351,
0.0260815863,
-0.0198540427,
-0.0009539278,
-0.0069989208,
-0.0337035879,
-0.0221905932,
-0.0134783518,
0.0061622257,
0.0008099567,
-0.002278477,
-0.0014240727,
-0.0169460922,
-0.0224902742,
-0.0266392194,
-0.0451070368,
-0.0008920333,
0.0322815627,
0.0139919212,
-0.0692233518,
-0.0430857763,
-0.0551966652,
-0.0221141968,
0.0850179717,
-0.0174333695,
-0.0256670453,
-0.0457056239,
0.0158385932,
0.0135108791,
0.0411398485,
-0.0097865611,
0.0059359991,
-0.0084380517,
-0.0143292006,
0.0030805473,
0.0012935479,
-0.0352644287,
-0.0197317041,
0.0919168219,
0.0177272689,
-0.0275072195,
-0.0090569472,
-0.0264944267,
-0.0189870968,
0.0224172529,
-0.0248099528,
0.0062932353,
0.059104532,
-0.0405952632,
-0.0147372205,
-0.0259584598,
0.0405998379,
0.0187443495,
-0.0399059057,
-0.0307680704,
0.0315022692,
0.0295656081,
0.0489218011,
0.0506401397,
-0.0397676378,
0.0700427443,
-0.0280486438,
0.0000533969,
-0.0559847206,
-0.0083429785,
-0.0014095665,
0.0013162264,
-0.0103597231,
0.0137121761,
0.0698548108,
0.0315430388,
-0.0046782722,
-0.0057443292,
0.0404245257,
-0.018570492,
0.0299050696,
-0.0090233842,
0.0636529997,
0.018189121,
-0.051729098,
-0.0343619436,
-0.0474012159,
-0.035295777,
0.0387620591,
-0.00640427,
-0.0456563123,
-0.045865275,
-0.0047489614,
0.0216446873,
0.0211557373,
0.0132264737,
0.0081162332,
-0.0299560912,
0.0299649835,
0.0190940816,
-0.0588417724,
0.0220655072,
-0.0205792077,
0.0429678708,
0.0171968415,
0.0073565221,
0.0070681009,
-0.0009168651,
0.0218558908,
0.0264980793,
0.0202373099,
0.0142533015,
0.0269313399,
-0.0155288093,
-0.0125290938,
-0.0661099181,
0.0767121986,
0.0258098319,
-0.0723028257,
0.0168224629,
0.0125708096,
0.0061700242,
0.0023504947,
0.0685278326,
-0.0788556188,
-0.0433713719,
-0.0189690292,
0.0071161967,
-0.0364093632,
-0.0413341261,
-0.0003521385,
-0.1160688102,
0.0433268771,
-0.0034768779,
-0.0402897038,
-0.0112095242,
-0.0986960083,
-0.0168783292,
-0.0257277023,
-0.0220268313,
0.0185821783,
-0.0114451777,
-0.02317998,
-0.0015376278,
0.0350317955,
-0.077923052,
0.007190336,
-0.0079810657,
-0.0018644358,
0.0282139368,
0.0358705334,
0.0152581716,
-0.0367457531,
0.0115673998,
0.0051716766,
0.0011919888,
-0.0516215265,
0.0433817506,
0.0301400665,
-0.0311180428,
0.0034492607,
0.032204818,
-0.0780152008,
-0.0557014979,
-0.0439304784,
0.11513789,
0.0030475731,
0.0174593367,
-0.0360677876,
-0.0110875685,
0.0216857065,
0.0734669045,
-0.0119685875,
-0.0253119376,
-0.004373936,
-0.0127841327,
0.0001386184,
-0.0188531298,
-0.0222887825,
0.0089160586,
-0.0404217429,
0.0055053723,
-0.0286139101,
0.0133842118,
0.0193526521,
0.0025369504,
0.0060205376,
0.026952168,
0.0079216529,
-0.0399604701,
-0.0836166963,
0.0508201905,
-0.0465484709,
0.0266502034,
-0.047860276,
-0.0550851896,
0.0525336415,
-0.0409102626,
-0.0196252279,
0.0156749412,
-0.0520874746,
-0.0716705099,
-0.0542040989,
0.0178679898,
0.020331284,
0.0358172432,
0.0026128693,
-0.0534411892,
0.0668408051,
0.0664469227,
-0.0009635789,
-0.036872834,
0.0087948525,
-0.0368737243,
-0.0315122455,
0.0092947623,
-0.0221486166,
-0.0035683748,
0.0558578447,
0.0414618887,
-0.0013140882,
0.000565592,
0.0806714669,
0.0453842282,
0.0592665039,
0.006052867,
-0.0211742502,
-0.0302647185,
-0.0174959786,
0.0175093357,
0.0005796371,
-0.0525972284,
0.0071645221,
0.0258630123,
-0.0270228628,
0.0143643739,
0.002849069,
-0.0339662172,
0.0183619931,
-0.0423921682,
0.0080842664,
0.0029457298,
0.00505869,
0.0834460333,
-0.0362452418,
0.0011864062,
0.0089140199,
-0.0218984317,
0.0749520734,
-0.0323131643,
0.0143107604,
0.0228421874,
0.0383740477,
-0.0472218953,
0.0176504534,
-0.0146992793,
-0.0207723994,
-0.0834779292,
0.0564965419,
0.0555878766,
-0.024752263,
0.0377943665,
-0.013450766,
-0.0394487791,
-0.0333384424,
0.0214012507,
0.0205041133,
-0.0327904448,
0.0521994345,
0.0333683304,
-0.0482073985,
-0.0119536519,
0.0792573094,
0.0381390043,
0.0270376895,
-0.002407545,
-0.028845489,
-0.0323428363,
0.00278025,
-0.0181254223,
-0.0057780514,
-0.0546240211,
0.0015369952,
-0.0580553599,
-0.0471023098,
0.0151804276,
0.0131175546,
-0.0559544452,
0.0324335247,
0.0192481205,
0.052654516,
0.0253672618,
-0.0359654091,
-0.0381598696,
-0.0151709933,
0.0051706587,
-0.0539562665,
-0.028034037,
-6.030782666e-33,
0.0213691276,
-0.0039846855,
-0.0120337131,
-0.0408308618,
0.0164324753,
0.0126058953,
-0.0564922914,
-0.0048115808,
0.04126136,
0.0597469583,
-0.0050362651,
-0.0453680605,
0.015781315,
-0.0414409861,
0.0096934019,
0.0145956688,
0.0046469863,
0.0506605394,
-0.0149860503,
0.0194626711,
0.0289977826,
0.0345548615,
0.0575175956,
-0.0682670549,
0.0047706272,
0.0317742117,
0.0285768826,
0.0262369011,
-0.0272526238,
0.074593246,
-0.0421837233,
0.055328045,
-0.0341202393,
-0.0451731533,
-0.0187759176,
-0.0053310585,
-0.0339322798,
0.0319997258,
0.038266629,
-0.0161456391,
0.0221245997,
-0.0437606163,
-0.0068560247,
-0.0005277903,
-0.0096028317,
-0.0098345838,
0.0216781497,
-0.02986186,
-0.0249766801,
-0.0097250976,
-0.078928344,
0.0068010776,
0.0305149965,
-0.0002624565,
0.0422465205,
0.0182374064,
0.0296911336,
0.0225907993,
-0.0109035801,
0.0645691082,
-0.0076426342,
0.0191808604,
0.0716210753,
0.029707551,
-0.0041025868,
0.0361473672,
0.0253338683,
0.0182829499,
0.0505109355,
-0.0069660377,
0.034941636,
0.0387075841,
-0.0040081558,
0.0692302659,
0.0561880283,
0.0267945006,
-0.111069642,
-0.0067304811,
-0.0440924168,
-0.0277468171,
0.0216696728,
0.0447009914,
-0.0241651218,
-0.0260101967,
-0.0316632167,
0.0234233011,
-0.0328241214,
-0.0105584795,
-0.0243578646,
-0.0162411649,
-0.0821928009,
0.0212114193,
0.0374252051,
-0.048900757,
-0.0636355653,
0.0100838002,
0.0154137574,
0.0090921959,
-0.0388391353,
-0.018939225,
-0.0209109653,
-0.0877478123,
0.0187689438,
-0.0540219843,
0.0244045667,
-0.019280266,
0.0059048771,
0.0106007047,
-0.0381391197,
-0.0017078681,
-0.0694784224,
0.0131828012,
0.0216122288,
0.0362829305,
0.0131314835,
0.0256563406,
-0.0167523269,
0.0387319177,
0.0559039786,
-0.0320600197,
0.0103103695,
0.0378176905,
0.0166601315,
0.0265766829,
-0.0656356066,
-0.0085060792,
-0.0400955901,
-0.0179899707,
0.0465513729,
-0.0557282642,
-0.0219423305,
0.0039721006,
2.732e-7,
0.0389181785,
0.0409863368,
0.0230711531,
0.0108675957,
-0.0369250216,
0.0496391207,
0.0044216057,
0.0214912184,
-0.0263273008,
-0.0642929748,
0.0252701156,
-0.0174502805,
0.043393746,
-0.0118480949,
-0.0752272904,
0.0249305591,
0.0085171424,
-0.0412269309,
-0.0703675523,
-0.0057172757,
-0.0372281857,
0.1162727103,
0.0063466369,
-0.0221787225,
0.0173695609,
-0.0375540815,
0.0425351933,
-0.036195308,
-0.0213163123,
0.0324087217,
-0.0205771271,
-0.0279174726,
3.91e-7,
0.0344944075,
-0.0311540477,
0.0168806836,
0.0159465075,
0.0181546956,
0.0095949005,
0.0191370565,
0.0065154969,
-0.0192817263,
0.0113644889,
0.0165709797,
0.0081791151,
-0.0442407057,
-0.0425081849,
0.0093722511,
-0.0097930394,
-0.0072644511,
-0.0107542258,
-0.0299795065,
0.0251380969,
0.0502120964,
0.0116162803,
0.0068205437,
0.0341775529,
-0.0076748724,
-0.0090631153,
0.0360501297,
-0.0396933407,
0.0204850305,
-0.0273568649,
-0.0038254114,
0.0284546949,
-0.0286778025,
0.0383846946,
2.672643216e-34,
0.072098963,
0.0022834798,
-0.0004606012,
0.0231496133,
0.0471966974,
-0.009541085,
0.0156112649,
0.0076381783,
-0.022839915,
-0.0953994319,
-0.0218975656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05201v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05201v1 | Two is Better Than One: Answering Complex Questions by Multiple Knowledge Sources with Generalized Links | 2023-09-11T02:31:41 | 2023-09-11T02:31:41 | Minhao Zhang, Yongliang Ma, Yanzeng Li, Ruoyu Zhang, Lei Zou, Ming Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Incorporating multiple knowledge sources is proven to be beneficial for
answering complex factoid questions. To utilize multiple knowledge bases (KB),
previous works merge all KBs into a single graph via entity alignment and
reduce the problem to question-answering (QA) over the fused KB. In reality,
various link relations between KBs might be adopted in QA over multi-KBs. In
addition to the identity between the alignable entities (i.e. full link),
unalignable entities expressing the different aspects or types of an abstract
concept may also be treated identical in a question (i.e. partial link). Hence,
the KB fusion in prior works fails to represent all types of links, restricting
their ability to comprehend multi-KBs for QA. In this work, we formulate the
novel Multi-KB-QA task that leverages the full and partial links among multiple
KBs to derive correct answers, a benchmark with diversified link and query
types is also constructed to efficiently evaluate Multi-KB-QA performance.
Finally, we propose a method for Multi-KB-QA that encodes all link relations in
the KB embedding to score and rank candidate answers. Experiments show that our
method markedly surpasses conventional KB-QA systems in Multi-KB-QA, justifying
the necessity of devising this task. | [
0.0299368519,
-0.0079970649,
0.0014148081,
0.0420877561,
0.016143702,
0.011640328,
-0.0300716814,
0.0151170352,
0.0315216109,
-0.0390258506,
0.0079900837,
0.0036931271,
-0.0319968536,
-0.0076574283,
0.0415407345,
-0.0570332594,
0.0311627574,
0.0244176462,
-0.005477062,
-0.0240816735,
0.0072443802,
0.0413623527,
-0.0273041092,
0.0149248596,
-0.0327091478,
-0.0341043919,
-0.0094223553,
-0.0192159154,
0.0513723232,
-0.0050879722,
-0.0232218616,
0.0174775552,
0.0287915487,
-0.0299255513,
0.0000019686,
-0.0476635471,
-0.0063259047,
-0.0011724869,
-0.0604248159,
0.0195796527,
-0.0570178442,
-0.0031815765,
0.0711195469,
-0.0107321795,
-0.0273522809,
-0.0105755944,
0.0140124774,
0.0622288175,
0.063965328,
0.0277091246,
0.0178591274,
-0.0409995914,
0.0077782832,
0.0158273261,
0.0107789654,
-0.0735508054,
0.0138033004,
0.0588915534,
0.0315136686,
0.0227394942,
-0.0030298503,
0.039339561,
-0.0067469836,
0.0145556936,
0.0412827395,
0.0144548342,
-0.0181625281,
0.0412839688,
0.0305850301,
0.1076364145,
-0.0105918264,
0.0107029947,
0.008910913,
0.0272296574,
0.0146359419,
0.0252003111,
-0.057239864,
-0.0184867606,
-0.0190512445,
-0.0314558521,
-0.0313516222,
0.0174117312,
0.0344717652,
-0.0031626569,
-0.0179831088,
0.0377687216,
0.0032601717,
-0.0116884643,
0.0029625597,
0.0177536178,
-0.0279556438,
-0.0521852635,
-0.0029883778,
0.0705450922,
-0.0318448879,
0.0396314152,
-0.0237869602,
-0.0149775362,
0.045737505,
-0.0427425504,
-0.0442317985,
0.0286449697,
0.0172079969,
0.0485922545,
-0.0275637861,
0.0341435634,
-0.0432954319,
-0.0121625271,
-0.0394767113,
-0.0247289538,
-0.075334765,
-0.0234385319,
-0.0255262125,
0.0900019184,
-0.0324160047,
-0.024090983,
-0.0244981963,
0.0189421773,
-0.0257045776,
0.010254804,
0.0148071609,
0.0604704544,
0.0178881735,
0.0048987051,
-0.0473375581,
0.0370884538,
-0.1039345041,
0.0078837788,
-0.0312802158,
-0.0035123825,
-0.0123570617,
0.0047980505,
0.0258739386,
-0.0265402626,
-0.0029147582,
0.0413548462,
-0.0140632642,
0.028261153,
-0.0285264775,
-0.0447481498,
0.0107212942,
-0.0398420282,
-0.0133862579,
-0.0714373738,
0.0719134137,
0.0251013786,
-0.0153055796,
-0.0008972057,
0.0123960869,
0.0205542892,
-0.0483586155,
0.0605689995,
-0.0000905227,
-0.0178821608,
0.0394559652,
0.0266549997,
-0.0031551355,
0.0736265406,
-0.0098285694,
-0.0337513387,
0.0301866382,
0.0396649614,
-0.0416013002,
-0.003594137,
0.0505718775,
0.0040479335,
0.0957398489,
0.063683942,
0.0194250364,
0.0377093218,
0.0315214992,
0.0384638309,
-0.0194300711,
-0.0420107171,
-0.0033249781,
0.0190886781,
0.0149644213,
0.0158801824,
0.0288189426,
0.0178234894,
0.0439205691,
0.0254300237,
-0.0025845442,
0.0438729152,
-0.0381476134,
0.0021109346,
0.0262047127,
0.0678930655,
-0.0343467146,
0.0051075099,
-0.0144352801,
0.0150773497,
-0.0480772331,
0.0150898891,
0.018906204,
-0.020635685,
-0.0102300225,
0.0979651362,
0.0181857273,
0.0078681195,
0.0120835686,
0.0165098477,
0.0115932021,
0.0509119108,
0.0106774624,
-0.0225572623,
-0.0390838496,
-0.0110349171,
0.0026031046,
0.0122537566,
0.0109722279,
-0.0490014926,
-0.0023806165,
-0.0283102766,
0.0043886625,
-0.0226811692,
-0.0029053986,
0.0422925539,
0.0362809077,
0.0490964986,
-0.0014521823,
-0.0753699616,
0.0651336461,
0.0051230816,
0.0213126987,
0.0186864641,
-0.022835318,
0.0259069018,
-0.0041785152,
0.0625735372,
0.0121014342,
0.0223870892,
0.0280955639,
-0.0403608643,
-0.0480329767,
-0.0161366332,
0.0048076073,
-0.0526824966,
0.0542915836,
-0.0289626177,
-0.0377312936,
-0.0112104919,
-0.0210908595,
-0.0604582056,
0.0147538483,
-0.0369563103,
0.015451828,
0.0161700398,
-0.0395618938,
0.0294033792,
-0.0285645295,
-0.0361272655,
0.1065950543,
0.0040836353,
0.0359321199,
0.0210135262,
-0.0334060825,
0.0398719087,
-0.0420551226,
-0.0287021548,
-0.0004609161,
0.000011561,
0.0221390128,
-0.0117724407,
-0.0402485803,
-0.0677052215,
0.0185353141,
-0.0700012222,
0.0240628384,
-0.0116610862,
0.0310039464,
0.0174719505,
-0.0211556759,
0.0326057076,
-0.009456588,
-0.0657897964,
0.0119567532,
-0.0045569353,
0.0077146976,
0.0242439006,
0.0526345596,
0.015212276,
-0.0139702745,
0.0019876324,
-0.0350373574,
0.0696010515,
-0.0066668927,
-0.0023076616,
-0.0114118475,
-0.0017436169,
-0.0704642236,
-0.0054205055,
0.0016052973,
0.003960704,
-0.0028740272,
0.0019494815,
0.0291750897,
0.0249704644,
-0.0182597842,
-0.0133723933,
0.0232634675,
-0.0205649771,
-0.0699307472,
0.032125134,
0.0249019656,
0.0348276868,
-0.0088474797,
-0.0150990058,
-0.02132071,
-0.0065397494,
0.0180814136,
-0.0309830904,
-0.0536060631,
0.0466798842,
0.0221332908,
0.0016118428,
-0.089986071,
0.0046130121,
0.0213554241,
0.0131869419,
-0.0150655312,
0.0542493574,
0.0665852949,
0.0348393805,
0.0143834697,
0.0004947695,
0.0037025593,
-0.0393581837,
0.0582833439,
-0.0400700085,
0.0252431091,
-0.0047490224,
0.0034436621,
-0.0618787073,
0.0421760008,
0.0136822378,
-0.0347154178,
0.0514536612,
-0.0189862214,
0.0236959029,
-0.0167623572,
-0.0471117646,
-0.0236251038,
0.0006945018,
-0.018356828,
0.0142026991,
0.0134357437,
-0.0055190376,
-0.0218563993,
-0.0028439742,
0.038580332,
-0.0712420195,
0.00769185,
0.0015459935,
-0.0029227335,
0.0716804415,
0.0784249604,
0.0528731719,
0.0284263324,
0.0295947008,
0.0148603776,
0.0482812002,
0.0387618989,
-0.0265108682,
0.0356375426,
-0.0237821322,
-0.0010461379,
-0.0623530634,
-0.0414400585,
-0.0177557543,
0.0123216854,
-0.038977962,
0.0139990989,
0.0768854618,
0.0570078939,
0.0318064168,
-0.0235273577,
-0.0067035803,
0.0234423056,
0.0109517919,
0.0553821027,
-0.1245559007,
-0.0088688256,
-0.0463950746,
-0.0117400344,
0.0102553824,
-0.039219074,
0.0089284852,
-0.1153242514,
-0.024124559,
-0.0260890573,
-0.0255042817,
-0.0514673889,
-0.0396058708,
0.002024709,
-0.0091275526,
-0.0524838418,
0.0086506419,
0.0142986858,
0.0171113685,
-0.0123174684,
0.0005856302,
-0.007747246,
0.0595890023,
-0.0359081849,
0.0242593065,
-0.0022848235,
0.0444773845,
0.0037962096,
-0.023381196,
-0.0497048162,
-0.0749290287,
-0.0330200642,
0.0197539721,
0.0235503018,
-0.0228335112,
-0.0076630875,
-0.0279410966,
-0.0065818042,
-0.0361565724,
0.0005143925,
0.0062344489,
0.0902385488,
0.0111772837,
0.0116726877,
-0.014792352,
-0.0066150734,
-0.0160230398,
0.0694492459,
-0.0003806695,
-0.0027087503,
-0.0069774906,
-0.026499724,
0.0165589098,
-0.0670384988,
-0.0182125699,
0.0430357158,
-0.0404062532,
0.0260306094,
-0.0968569741,
-0.0444421694,
0.0356703997,
0.0473170765,
0.0049918881,
0.0007310376,
-0.0032493118,
0.0235320143,
-0.0314904973,
0.0030144863,
-0.026367249,
0.0053834962,
0.026887387,
-0.000273042,
0.0376992226,
0.0015743438,
-0.0300267637,
-0.0136839729,
-0.0213148408,
-0.0296960883,
-0.0342006348,
0.0351384655,
0.012266607,
0.0101176789,
-0.0325000584,
-0.0078930426,
0.0237133913,
0.019382827,
-0.0463591032,
0.0182157047,
-0.0036903883,
0.0191468671,
-0.0124801975,
0.0476520061,
-0.1042760387,
-0.0440353751,
-0.042653434,
0.0601368025,
-0.0814428106,
-0.0423134156,
0.0047591715,
0.0150926011,
-0.0596267432,
0.0346783511,
0.0129713304,
-0.0006498226,
-0.0001341155,
-0.0223343223,
-0.047809083,
0.0007591683,
-0.0113836722,
0.004175304,
-0.0259040631,
-0.0009703336,
0.0126007386,
0.0474298783,
0.0151544772,
-0.0081550982,
-0.041604653,
0.0498364791,
-0.0118280565,
-0.006736448,
-0.0103467675,
-0.0432001203,
-0.0087412428,
0.0106688626,
0.0131891118,
-0.0221734326,
0.0108572403,
0.0357338488,
-0.0246687327,
-0.0323203169,
-0.0011204934,
-0.0592106916,
-0.019188514,
-0.0072917491,
0.0170454253,
0.0555549823,
0.0333414488,
0.0537101664,
0.0274973772,
-0.0538502522,
0.0283173714,
-0.02969159,
0.0007441312,
0.0030378129,
0.0670516267,
0.0464492999,
0.0035294318,
-0.004384873,
0.0566738099,
-0.0591112487,
0.0544865765,
-0.0240841489,
-0.0194178987,
-0.0238869339,
-0.0397304855,
-0.0439706333,
0.0375879854,
0.02195541,
0.0078259232,
-0.0821331367,
-0.0331842639,
0.0510874614,
0.0179082975,
-0.0149384774,
0.0242697503,
0.0511395335,
0.0256388094,
0.0636170283,
-0.0693546683,
-0.0064743771,
0.0008104705,
-0.0772890076,
-0.0047734259,
0.0126937767,
-6.313115103e-33,
-0.0578266531,
-0.0382486917,
0.0270882193,
-0.038279701,
-0.0349277705,
0.011355184,
0.0071905982,
-0.0074744248,
-0.0668707192,
0.0063840384,
0.0103405528,
-0.0073683695,
-0.012955267,
0.0082375892,
-0.0059863888,
-0.0341472775,
-0.0074046412,
0.0106617725,
-0.0137486514,
0.0013750208,
0.0685997605,
-0.0062951776,
0.0044580684,
-0.0239548087,
0.0412566699,
-0.0165971778,
-0.0108794859,
0.0340532623,
-0.0164402779,
0.0650481731,
-0.0163818859,
0.0312484186,
0.0403900743,
-0.0358976386,
0.0261422601,
0.0210524872,
-0.11253234,
-0.0520130992,
0.0463144779,
-0.0022240761,
-0.0247079227,
-0.0481066965,
0.0160326939,
-0.0023454602,
0.0862053186,
-0.0470053665,
0.0471092016,
-0.0045170602,
-0.0039915205,
-0.073735252,
0.0005250903,
0.00755639,
-0.0400311612,
0.0205133017,
-0.0466059484,
0.0254625566,
0.024628209,
0.0047205137,
-0.0698083639,
0.0050790999,
-0.0134360082,
-0.0095870094,
0.0117873736,
-0.0028221866,
-0.0022367316,
0.0340803601,
-0.0250050705,
-0.0486267135,
-0.0628544912,
0.005838003,
-0.0614532121,
0.0333883204,
0.0610533915,
0.0774810091,
-0.0093209473,
0.0211240742,
-0.0894805044,
0.0334012583,
0.0044208393,
0.0064028073,
-0.0416701213,
0.018159898,
-0.0192721412,
-0.0142225269,
-0.068450138,
0.0486636572,
-0.0409255177,
-0.0468422733,
0.0328763574,
-0.0233240202,
-0.0165442079,
0.0215678681,
0.0017686771,
-0.0456740633,
0.0159601923,
0.0381207243,
0.0107530253,
0.0409774408,
0.0162882544,
0.0282519255,
-0.0311634485,
0.0248144716,
0.0395206474,
-0.0279884916,
0.0082328636,
0.0360285603,
0.0241177008,
-0.0369691513,
-0.0439640284,
0.0034990786,
-0.0112510324,
-0.0418447778,
-0.0541171841,
-0.0481001884,
0.0210468583,
0.0321206152,
0.0139580434,
0.0208865982,
0.0319719352,
0.0469446667,
-0.0109851016,
-0.0016277229,
0.004518202,
0.0114129186,
-0.0160280783,
0.0375925936,
0.0007927578,
-0.0056302482,
-0.0464132354,
-0.0552436411,
-0.0046868795,
0.0337195955,
2.676e-7,
0.0509073734,
-0.015199082,
0.0173963439,
0.0457646884,
-0.012397781,
0.0149481772,
0.0168391466,
0.0286048725,
-0.0076405038,
-0.0540627241,
-0.0234252121,
0.0424545892,
-0.022558054,
0.0455459543,
-0.1024751738,
-0.0233579129,
-0.0000195607,
-0.0518056825,
-0.0478516705,
-0.0233532321,
0.0685539842,
0.0327141248,
0.0155055709,
0.0324746035,
-0.0164337177,
-0.0092572039,
0.0564787835,
0.0342548527,
-0.029660685,
0.0111809643,
0.0432487503,
-0.0035768726,
0.0017290594,
0.0578412265,
-0.0133116599,
0.0378390364,
0.0462341383,
0.0403127708,
0.0013447865,
-0.0561053753,
-0.0348620154,
-0.0743140206,
0.0292212255,
-0.0271456856,
0.0855094418,
-0.0109268753,
-0.0202568751,
0.055163078,
-0.0480583198,
0.0033284544,
0.0082807327,
-0.0043707867,
0.0027777839,
0.0064045652,
-0.0131994635,
-0.0036122126,
0.012959647,
-0.0829096809,
-0.0179047696,
0.0825600252,
-0.0291099083,
-0.0326343551,
0.0256998073,
-0.0486867912,
0.0450554714,
-0.0680805892,
-0.0079171276,
1.976619694e-34,
-0.009035917,
-0.0050216066,
0.0281351395,
0.0368450247,
0.0436041877,
-0.0474094786,
-0.0818962604,
-0.0241131522,
0.0487821326,
-0.0754464418,
0.019461602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05196v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05196v3 | Does Writing with Language Models Reduce Content Diversity? | 2023-09-11T02:16:47 | 2024-07-01T16:36:30 | Vishakh Padmakumar, He He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have led to a surge in collaborative writing
with model assistance. As different users incorporate suggestions from the same
model, there is a risk of decreased diversity in the produced content,
potentially limiting diverse perspectives in public discourse. In this work, we
measure the impact of co-writing on diversity via a controlled experiment,
where users write argumentative essays in three setups -- using a base LLM
(GPT3), a feedback-tuned LLM (InstructGPT), and writing without model help. We
develop a set of diversity metrics and find that writing with InstructGPT (but
not the GPT3) results in a statistically significant reduction in diversity.
Specifically, it increases the similarity between the writings of different
authors and reduces the overall lexical and content diversity. We additionally
find that this effect is mainly attributable to InstructGPT contributing less
diverse text to co-written essays. In contrast, the user-contributed text
remains unaffected by model collaboration. This suggests that the recent
improvement in generation quality from adapting models to human feedback might
come at the cost of more homogeneous and less diverse content. | [
0.0380098261,
0.0441998765,
-0.0134863602,
-0.0012847327,
-0.0565122366,
-0.0101747531,
0.0484997779,
-0.0083427466,
-0.016379511,
-0.0705092102,
0.0043674437,
-0.0762548149,
-0.0088616861,
0.0257858709,
0.0019339862,
-0.0433184914,
0.0033726341,
0.0000305058,
0.0301518049,
-0.0346483998,
0.0312569402,
0.0304895807,
0.0282756742,
0.0692849308,
-0.0177871641,
-0.0099372957,
-0.0049130609,
0.0182055123,
0.0204652697,
0.0292151608,
0.0180886015,
0.105764173,
-0.009002706,
0.0406329408,
0.0000020068,
-0.0209099855,
-0.0069548134,
0.0006538134,
0.0295649767,
0.0232059043,
0.0299193934,
0.0526501872,
-0.0270845052,
0.0309414938,
-0.0272993781,
0.0534413606,
0.0312088784,
0.0119132372,
0.0156028168,
0.0432553254,
0.0127548035,
0.0205170605,
0.0302415695,
-0.0172104854,
-0.018914558,
0.0742277429,
0.0070500397,
0.0105113126,
0.0140540292,
0.0237057805,
-0.0022091928,
0.0353347659,
0.0236090999,
-0.042783156,
0.0134907532,
0.0370381512,
-0.0023678795,
-0.0189931411,
0.0212930888,
0.0049453732,
0.0457548313,
-0.0282731932,
0.0263988134,
-0.0347759612,
0.0169296954,
0.0457401648,
-0.0288141202,
0.0593719035,
-0.0305988491,
0.0030926496,
0.0364353769,
-0.0279735047,
0.0005994506,
0.0366309546,
0.0495194271,
0.0408457667,
0.0058101006,
-0.0226697028,
-0.0252620503,
0.0381997973,
0.022202488,
-0.0710925981,
-0.002406263,
0.0069105239,
-0.0166719276,
0.0083069084,
-0.0354107358,
-0.0440503992,
0.0325058922,
-0.0465949327,
0.0931190401,
0.0140019078,
0.0126557769,
0.0199063327,
0.0559475534,
-0.0223292205,
-0.0128095066,
0.0301608611,
0.0030723799,
0.0193526372,
-0.0456198081,
-0.0364463739,
-0.0285782386,
0.0261526983,
-0.0119652981,
0.0051056142,
-0.0012926089,
0.002165678,
-0.0243269876,
-0.012001791,
0.0005908308,
0.0226641241,
-0.0385187306,
-0.0162800159,
0.0008015865,
0.0362060964,
-0.040556334,
0.0017328719,
0.0087852357,
-0.0533004031,
0.014668039,
0.0185688287,
-0.0160134416,
-0.0328147262,
-0.0093780151,
-0.0146836042,
0.000859476,
-0.0116185294,
0.0202581119,
-0.0474074408,
-0.0119706476,
-0.0398840271,
-0.0178436786,
-0.1111160368,
0.0038486943,
0.0395301431,
0.0132080717,
-0.0990795568,
-0.0179584604,
-0.0084724845,
-0.0129843093,
-0.0230619982,
-0.030202046,
0.0349818654,
0.0888970047,
0.0072217933,
-0.0463825352,
0.0567933172,
0.040937379,
-0.0165477656,
0.0212641265,
-0.0146363089,
0.0378529616,
0.0163626336,
-0.0439715162,
0.0548075289,
-0.003338505,
-0.008151588,
-0.0085757272,
0.0016830453,
-0.0187212583,
0.0788913965,
-0.000047522,
0.0105474954,
0.1055603698,
0.0595477819,
0.0364383906,
0.0408738106,
0.0313250981,
0.016115604,
0.0134644471,
0.0423812382,
-0.0019769515,
0.0307608563,
-0.0011455439,
-0.0116770584,
0.0533035025,
0.0522503406,
-0.0310171805,
-0.0390759595,
-0.0172650088,
0.0094755907,
0.0214250628,
-0.0260267798,
0.0004520387,
-0.0490084998,
0.0067126406,
0.0367839411,
0.0205799323,
-0.0787291899,
0.0035742105,
-0.0035502682,
0.0673650056,
0.0405280218,
0.0092331674,
-0.0000044784,
0.0135109816,
-0.0513992719,
0.0464090742,
0.0783656463,
0.0726270899,
0.0258808453,
-0.0436152145,
-0.0344691463,
-0.0172736607,
-0.0157427955,
0.0252287444,
0.044128906,
0.0239457302,
0.0126324464,
0.0144328279,
0.0539563969,
-0.0763663873,
0.0166693889,
-0.0817631036,
0.0290597528,
-0.0244413968,
-0.0119999172,
0.0198211875,
0.0314224809,
-0.0660769492,
0.0219833646,
-0.0099410554,
-0.0187394824,
-0.0531661063,
0.0341243744,
-0.0362492353,
0.0532152951,
0.0281551499,
-0.0633510128,
0.013499151,
-0.0028740466,
0.025790574,
-0.0088102967,
0.0867562294,
-0.019582402,
-0.0136329718,
-0.026534874,
-0.0113608018,
-0.0477870777,
-0.0404435806,
-0.0385714658,
0.0096951118,
0.0042888992,
0.0296039581,
-0.000790751,
0.0003530228,
0.0152658317,
-0.0213989615,
-0.0247229729,
0.0334559754,
0.0244540144,
0.0424916856,
0.0435566381,
-0.0261752438,
-0.0374595821,
-0.0595387109,
-0.0625889152,
-0.000963762,
-0.0405306034,
0.008072109,
0.0451268852,
-0.0121621592,
-0.0211556591,
0.0534272417,
-0.03423227,
-0.0561916791,
0.0259250309,
0.010164679,
0.0065019559,
-0.0176490042,
0.0068077557,
-0.0197656956,
-0.0026846977,
-0.0025545766,
0.0186585207,
0.0519659743,
-0.0048570726,
-0.0223967358,
0.0082746577,
-0.0517125055,
-0.0353859961,
0.0001605355,
-0.020905003,
0.0294707194,
0.0235060398,
0.0474742465,
0.0250572395,
0.0358689167,
0.0285303742,
0.0507023595,
0.0262804572,
-0.0317527615,
-0.0058738235,
-0.0032709616,
0.0472349823,
0.0058509861,
-0.0641330555,
0.0245317426,
0.0443214551,
0.0277920347,
-0.0133362385,
-0.0765418559,
0.0671999454,
-0.0565608814,
-0.0236864462,
0.0121995537,
-0.0739095435,
-0.0313367918,
-0.0025819205,
-0.0168396272,
-0.0371042714,
0.0190347135,
-0.0027289959,
0.0293989722,
-0.0199361015,
-0.0189613886,
-0.0522033758,
0.0382684395,
-0.0156160425,
0.0162785761,
0.0085599199,
0.051213257,
-0.0514626801,
-0.0179497022,
0.0579550341,
-0.0184144061,
0.0565425083,
-0.0450984426,
-0.0040492122,
-0.0388022438,
-0.0082654608,
0.0059803012,
-0.0292468425,
-0.0198777504,
0.0335359536,
0.0753368884,
-0.0067177569,
0.0203018449,
-0.0054315338,
0.0581555702,
0.0263359137,
-0.0492702574,
0.0183342379,
0.0111628892,
0.0106762871,
-0.0138988979,
-0.0045148111,
0.0028168124,
-0.0921838656,
0.0167671759,
0.0279542208,
-0.022771785,
-0.0074637141,
-0.0039455034,
-0.0529748015,
0.0080543105,
-0.0202155523,
-0.0723694265,
-0.0156604871,
0.0881006196,
-0.0442348309,
0.0070228232,
0.0864440948,
0.0038944345,
-0.0528386459,
-0.0148914196,
-0.0694355071,
0.0662446395,
0.0119559672,
0.0293303058,
-0.043747507,
0.0329491161,
0.0105119701,
0.000544118,
-0.0459594168,
-0.0354190432,
-0.03031593,
-0.0750256628,
0.026078945,
0.0113216592,
-0.0177697632,
0.01684325,
-0.0169264041,
-0.0102869859,
0.0226582102,
-0.0256080832,
0.0049016131,
0.0038165527,
0.0278800204,
0.0487865545,
-0.056875851,
-0.0350369215,
-0.0714561194,
-0.0433295779,
0.0321729332,
0.0289950799,
0.0333476849,
-0.0407769904,
-0.0234183129,
0.0376977846,
0.023319412,
-0.0085812872,
-0.0106521724,
0.0194109287,
-0.0065621282,
0.0243613664,
-0.0224082563,
0.0200510435,
-0.0018269471,
-0.0357914232,
0.0263225343,
0.0248834323,
0.0012080045,
-0.0363550298,
-0.0271005128,
0.0161040239,
0.0373898409,
0.0567625687,
0.0710023567,
-0.0528620593,
-0.0065471027,
-0.0866589621,
0.0106043946,
-0.0719248429,
-0.0191638805,
-0.0177675989,
0.0082290787,
0.0104415165,
-0.0458272099,
-0.0715532973,
-0.0126448143,
0.0042231409,
0.0299211424,
0.0337317139,
-0.0104627013,
-0.043917954,
0.0216041543,
-0.0004026859,
-0.0051957583,
0.0315655656,
-0.0559093989,
-0.0493603721,
-0.0593925714,
-0.0450390056,
0.0125980619,
-0.0292809848,
-0.0780566782,
-0.0929222777,
0.0515604764,
0.0067976592,
0.0234708209,
0.0017335116,
0.0455826223,
-0.0745735615,
0.0212343503,
0.0363356359,
0.0244300589,
0.0463883765,
-0.0059481109,
-0.0198188256,
0.0077132005,
0.0136745954,
0.0090819057,
-0.0007272014,
0.0431224927,
0.0231345892,
-0.0037256093,
-0.0195849594,
-0.0064522712,
0.0116369706,
-0.0204656236,
-0.0382763296,
-0.0080524608,
-0.0592996478,
-0.0302171391,
-0.0498797968,
-0.0107790185,
-0.0252532456,
-0.0183260217,
-0.0198685527,
-0.0281992797,
-0.0048607546,
0.0585059933,
-0.0126210665,
0.0730914772,
-0.0573087633,
0.0390098616,
-0.0364131816,
0.0189957265,
-0.0015967565,
-0.0067216018,
-0.0167312846,
0.0682263076,
-0.0643654689,
0.013860736,
0.0198397301,
0.0415200181,
0.0120205889,
-0.0048539117,
0.038826555,
0.0291666985,
-0.0943778008,
-0.0771762356,
0.0003200981,
0.0107658505,
0.030019829,
-0.0001328102,
0.0774218515,
-0.0382021368,
0.0063810977,
-0.0502608009,
0.0417800434,
0.0329217128,
-0.0105508165,
0.0095142182,
0.000685141,
-0.0349930115,
-0.0395109393,
0.0808298066,
-0.0130111175,
0.0007232825,
0.0091832755,
-0.0020368956,
-0.0026090643,
-0.0007593747,
0.0262576044,
-0.0133654848,
0.0031916017,
-0.0053822962,
-0.0720585138,
0.0088457568,
0.0289970674,
0.0094529437,
0.0316022411,
-0.0382357463,
-0.0027652292,
0.0388285071,
-0.027263483,
0.0205347128,
-0.0656959116,
0.0393590219,
-0.0273749214,
-0.007043418,
0.0257545915,
-6.474549416e-33,
-0.013336814,
-0.0583764687,
-0.0043450836,
-0.0029036864,
-0.0169279948,
0.0050952542,
-0.0194543581,
0.0600685142,
0.0100060618,
0.0405628607,
-0.0204313081,
0.0027305977,
0.0017644993,
0.012228298,
0.0291806068,
0.0122406287,
0.0341581143,
0.0058778599,
-0.0444412827,
-0.0127376365,
0.0121163242,
-0.0063536013,
0.0269673895,
-0.0249875337,
0.055142127,
-0.0373908952,
0.0011502538,
-0.0455260687,
-0.0338932276,
0.0109668514,
-0.0006607728,
0.0457332879,
0.0248528663,
-0.048542358,
-0.0187063292,
0.0180982705,
0.039548099,
-0.014347747,
0.0226552151,
-0.0485719293,
-0.0100953588,
-0.0698112845,
0.0219201129,
0.0199583173,
-0.0725521967,
-0.0320180804,
0.0375775993,
0.0033957385,
-0.0000484814,
-0.0124775367,
-0.0541804954,
0.0547398068,
-0.0073329206,
0.0105785877,
-0.0609109253,
0.0162540469,
0.0128605682,
0.015069901,
-0.0238289423,
0.0329730883,
0.0192613304,
0.0310745686,
0.0257877558,
-0.0042182114,
-0.0064852228,
0.0545280538,
-0.0205283482,
0.0533179156,
-0.0619258061,
-0.0291704778,
0.0091123804,
-0.0116851451,
0.0651485696,
0.11878144,
-0.0172380954,
-0.0388622731,
-0.0124876555,
0.0149755338,
-0.0217322949,
-0.0309494864,
0.0459015258,
-0.0229674187,
-0.0201015882,
-0.0643191189,
-0.0247297417,
-0.0672283918,
0.0170898065,
-0.0496101193,
0.0157164373,
-0.0132408235,
-0.0406588465,
-0.0273168627,
0.026072327,
-0.0089964271,
-0.0359168127,
0.0196938775,
-0.0617469326,
0.0081234276,
-0.0007021332,
0.0175151005,
-0.0784971043,
0.0175531358,
-0.0082940143,
0.0452689156,
0.0070337509,
0.0146868005,
0.0285381377,
0.0244096704,
-0.0479003824,
0.0046057785,
-0.0257117786,
0.0554068685,
0.0404971354,
0.0222159959,
0.0118540218,
-0.0037295891,
0.0194768943,
0.0331267528,
0.0451729856,
-0.0373646617,
-0.0443258509,
-0.0444347933,
-0.0373390727,
-0.0116630699,
-0.0227605551,
0.0051208213,
-0.0268997718,
0.0334303938,
0.0746168196,
0.019880861,
-0.0279380661,
-0.0696164668,
2.626e-7,
0.0502537712,
0.0427926891,
-0.0054348549,
-0.0151895266,
0.0109838797,
0.0375761688,
-0.0252935681,
0.0568285584,
0.0118226111,
0.0151503412,
-0.0228528138,
0.0330248177,
0.0596882775,
0.0468837321,
-0.0313954912,
-0.0011611466,
-0.1202730089,
0.0353135355,
-0.0444787331,
-0.0023536482,
0.0118351076,
-0.0207282063,
0.0200868994,
0.0074576265,
-0.0523161814,
0.0015325439,
0.0766254887,
-0.0518192276,
-0.0395020843,
0.0193236414,
0.0637570769,
-0.0753084645,
0.0280864183,
0.0070647434,
-0.0062379348,
-0.0009690564,
-0.0261237808,
0.0392316058,
0.0116153359,
0.0266773105,
0.041641932,
0.0103042377,
-0.001336408,
-0.0856441557,
0.0371340662,
0.0363890082,
0.0057636732,
-0.0672933534,
-0.0229993667,
-0.0183212906,
0.0665206164,
-0.0282819457,
-0.0116912648,
0.0209020302,
-0.0223310869,
-0.0106555186,
0.0285783373,
0.0050579789,
-0.0677591562,
-0.0522934943,
-0.0312438924,
-0.0577018969,
-0.0391783305,
0.0233062059,
-0.0282786135,
-0.0391648635,
0.0212462209,
2.235649517e-34,
0.04266458,
0.0009772892,
0.0227287635,
0.008871817,
0.0405019969,
0.0246784016,
0.0033758224,
-0.0147541352,
0.0012960924,
0.0024692276,
-0.0177262705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05173v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05173v5 | DePT: Decomposed Prompt Tuning for Parameter-Efficient Fine-tuning | 2023-09-11T00:02:05 | 2024-02-18T10:02:23 | Zhengxiang Shi, Aldo Lipani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | Prompt tuning (PT), where a small amount of trainable soft (continuous)
prompt vectors is affixed to the input of language models (LM), has shown
promising results across various tasks and models for parameter-efficient
fine-tuning (PEFT). PT stands out from other PEFT approaches because it
maintains competitive performance with fewer trainable parameters and does not
drastically scale up its parameters as the model size expands. However, PT
introduces additional soft prompt tokens, leading to longer input sequences,
which significantly impacts training and inference time and memory usage due to
the Transformer's quadratic complexity. Particularly concerning for Large
Language Models (LLMs) that face heavy daily querying. To address this issue,
we propose Decomposed Prompt Tuning (DePT), which decomposes the soft prompt
into a shorter soft prompt and a pair of low-rank matrices that are then
optimised with two different learning rates. This allows DePT to achieve better
performance while saving substantial memory and time costs compared to vanilla
PT and its variants, without changing trainable parameter sizes. Through
extensive experiments on 23 natural language processing (NLP) and
vision-language (VL) tasks, we demonstrate that DePT outperforms
state-of-the-art PEFT approaches, including the full fine-tuning baseline, in
some scenarios. Additionally, we empirically show that DEPT grows more
efficient as the model size increases. Our further study reveals that DePT
integrates seamlessly with parameter-efficient transfer learning in the
few-shot learning setting and highlights its adaptability to various model
architectures and sizes. | [
0.0566501394,
0.0420582369,
-0.0061247754,
0.023933351,
-0.0115594417,
0.0447024293,
0.0159896445,
0.002926477,
-0.0359513164,
-0.070932813,
-0.0432931595,
-0.0025156371,
0.0104535697,
0.0291690975,
0.033675272,
-0.0601022653,
0.0660420284,
-0.0418137535,
-0.0017921367,
0.0259204488,
-0.018547222,
0.0253894366,
-0.0249231979,
0.0384701043,
0.0280320998,
-0.0129590724,
-0.0176903903,
0.037585225,
0.0243023951,
0.0253795665,
0.008912663,
0.0731876791,
0.0212625228,
0.0026972655,
0.0000020176,
-0.0438029133,
-0.0302351527,
-0.0082371207,
-0.0468666218,
0.0082043307,
0.0225484427,
-0.0164241903,
0.010851861,
0.0221790262,
-0.0044739312,
-0.0328441337,
0.0449965373,
0.0368044078,
0.0405050516,
0.0950343981,
-0.0060011167,
-0.0034045491,
0.0133277625,
-0.0318075567,
-0.0236898512,
-0.0557683818,
0.0183625165,
-0.0908993483,
-0.0290023871,
0.0332477018,
-0.0245802701,
0.0205698851,
-0.0117066158,
-0.0029268684,
0.0110003436,
0.0258101188,
-0.0400438756,
-0.0392474122,
-0.0237914566,
0.063712649,
-0.0588592105,
-0.0020931808,
0.0190902036,
-0.0291664787,
0.0306978766,
-0.0027748274,
-0.017380774,
0.0144579457,
0.0276743826,
0.0087431241,
-0.0044117896,
-0.0408155993,
-0.0005902631,
0.0195397492,
-0.0244975183,
0.0190373156,
0.0280648489,
0.0159089193,
0.0128372004,
-0.0166017152,
-0.0373410359,
-0.0385844223,
-0.0378274769,
0.0264604203,
-0.0703700036,
-0.0083894134,
-0.0595067404,
-0.0174497217,
0.0229803286,
0.0312302131,
0.0682440773,
0.0381380357,
-0.0234975666,
0.0581720583,
-0.0424197502,
0.0445587113,
0.0338241495,
0.0649289265,
-0.0265736859,
-0.0103341881,
-0.0364961512,
0.028958289,
-0.0550399795,
0.0009240523,
-0.0386650488,
-0.0307559911,
-0.0145316608,
0.0383622088,
0.0268408302,
0.0039072223,
0.0023484519,
-0.0025470594,
-0.0430304259,
0.001440028,
0.0011382885,
0.0642766729,
-0.0371905491,
0.0200904887,
0.0237053484,
-0.0871292576,
-0.0266130846,
-0.0027836023,
0.0529623181,
-0.0512831025,
0.0154581023,
0.0165365413,
-0.0393240042,
-0.0676011741,
-0.0274059661,
-0.0084973155,
-0.0097429492,
-0.0534638651,
-0.0160020422,
-0.0335762128,
0.0409248173,
-0.0043836236,
0.032797087,
-0.0091305654,
-0.0119491285,
0.0334427431,
-0.0455417037,
0.0884235427,
0.0108722979,
0.0055927439,
0.0064714025,
-0.0147781139,
-0.0043506734,
0.0700261295,
-0.0086192172,
0.0454562083,
0.0496659614,
-0.0301509518,
-0.0102626458,
0.0220641289,
0.0176258907,
0.0248494335,
-0.0199311022,
-0.0060856557,
0.0426961444,
0.0127793886,
0.0244172961,
0.0378823057,
-0.006033909,
0.0064606867,
0.0373726785,
0.0176537689,
0.0550034456,
-0.0226846933,
0.0436684415,
0.0036218923,
-0.0193493608,
-0.0288620442,
-0.0686774775,
0.0381327644,
-0.0550176464,
-0.0157242995,
-0.0022325439,
0.0307540894,
-0.0353744775,
-0.001255429,
0.0245374255,
0.0036092035,
-0.0150621273,
0.0285542309,
0.0242929272,
0.0083133895,
-0.052519422,
0.0507273264,
0.0351915024,
0.0076390146,
-0.0306987558,
-0.0572852343,
0.0168973934,
0.0353061222,
0.0046414421,
-0.0068656197,
-0.0178622641,
-0.0308670178,
0.0563273951,
0.0073232283,
0.0653848574,
-0.0039591822,
0.0388862081,
-0.0459943041,
-0.0258873496,
-0.0025701672,
0.0133763887,
-0.0032861095,
-0.018736653,
0.0333849825,
0.0274819937,
0.0056602787,
-0.0144263515,
0.0436922163,
-0.0103835436,
-0.0470340811,
0.0430581309,
0.0412589051,
-0.0051193177,
-0.0238236114,
0.0045267125,
-0.0139648626,
0.0205773134,
-0.0185459144,
0.0357067734,
-0.065904811,
-0.0456334203,
-0.0233527683,
0.0076963557,
0.0183999445,
0.0191130191,
0.0308349561,
-0.0723796561,
-0.0324134938,
-0.0446598157,
-0.0123157362,
-0.0162422415,
-0.0280464478,
0.0135208182,
-0.0288944207,
0.0618555062,
-0.0607460886,
-0.0003998131,
0.02658071,
0.0125599252,
0.0408011936,
0.0249548107,
-0.0006958096,
-0.0292643998,
-0.0378766023,
0.0023958364,
-0.0170288235,
-0.0002252523,
0.0215408001,
0.0210783351,
-0.049284067,
-0.0434173979,
-0.0785753801,
0.0167958699,
-0.0406181514,
-0.0170678999,
0.0089112287,
0.0122142686,
-0.0216139518,
-0.0151155377,
-0.0190237071,
0.0362463072,
-0.0074622259,
0.0530664064,
0.0279803853,
0.0103596859,
-0.030450955,
-0.0288576949,
-0.0092907147,
0.0097538708,
0.0512257256,
-0.0243462045,
-0.0481424667,
-0.0613889173,
0.0157352407,
0.0009201626,
0.0141587872,
0.0003459359,
-0.025580978,
-0.0188889205,
-0.0275311582,
0.0322767422,
0.0950631648,
0.0387629345,
-0.0068695424,
0.0103899576,
0.003136578,
-0.0535340607,
0.0235969424,
-0.0304562263,
-0.0651201531,
-0.0259975251,
-0.0016534174,
0.0247819871,
0.0447031558,
-0.0380713269,
-0.0039075338,
-0.0676008835,
0.0513344295,
0.0159871429,
-0.0082770353,
-0.0557880737,
0.0343716554,
-0.0212163366,
0.0290312432,
-0.0023926932,
-0.0377958193,
0.0518543236,
-0.0404950976,
-0.0111809894,
-0.0088184876,
-0.0207176115,
-0.0177221838,
0.0239426922,
0.0108285686,
0.0187551659,
0.0366316922,
-0.0229286589,
-0.0717219487,
-0.0178300291,
0.016779352,
-0.0101487301,
0.0473255999,
0.0100230929,
-0.0083671762,
-0.0587941073,
-0.0380174369,
-0.0267514214,
-0.0630151331,
-0.0107005192,
0.0251997095,
-0.0024161022,
-0.0227772091,
-0.019579595,
-0.0047111101,
-0.0032287331,
0.0474952236,
-0.0376241952,
-0.0199150089,
-0.0298924763,
0.0121419812,
0.0979192629,
0.0706786439,
0.0107752308,
-0.0018389709,
0.0372910686,
0.0181166921,
0.0329610668,
0.0108503764,
0.0074323444,
0.0089409556,
0.0482850894,
-0.0092413817,
-0.0116548808,
0.0358557068,
0.0608378984,
-0.0473184809,
-0.0261412729,
0.1105356589,
0.0082426379,
-0.0677984208,
-0.0056597237,
0.0213945024,
0.0341040418,
0.0355320312,
0.0616762154,
-0.0601345748,
-0.0620623864,
0.0355875082,
0.065972954,
-0.006731628,
-0.0332419351,
-0.0282426719,
-0.1101818532,
0.0374050476,
-0.0160848387,
0.010399526,
-0.0324338563,
-0.0448933467,
0.0101131769,
-0.0032586013,
0.0315834656,
0.015510221,
-0.022961881,
-0.0091363518,
0.0133998189,
0.0356113873,
-0.0586938374,
0.0439346656,
-0.028958872,
0.0430309027,
0.0243552458,
-0.0066669253,
0.0152897257,
-0.0569186471,
0.0439698324,
-0.036655426,
0.0059552439,
-0.0280795954,
0.0275514424,
-0.0328006223,
-0.032955993,
0.0271018744,
0.0399513654,
-0.0020338511,
-0.0157494918,
-0.0108462702,
0.0687243417,
0.0009378397,
-0.005675497,
-0.0017658161,
-0.0337066166,
-0.0060835322,
0.0760314092,
0.0384660251,
-0.042941343,
-0.0099544665,
0.005395351,
-0.0256555863,
-0.0393018797,
-0.0325226597,
-0.0120237796,
-0.0074551827,
-0.024830712,
-0.038361676,
0.0028434698,
0.0313723385,
0.069359988,
-0.0156235369,
-0.0162469149,
-0.0304353517,
0.0282010566,
-0.0356165208,
0.0308053698,
-0.0402354226,
0.0193744265,
-0.0825629309,
-0.0004786637,
0.0493858494,
0.0028696202,
-0.0242949296,
-0.0070297481,
-0.0964749157,
-0.0495635495,
-0.0050641424,
0.0434166491,
0.0028368989,
0.0359943397,
-0.0204398539,
-0.0621794686,
0.0267165806,
0.081892848,
-0.0278240331,
0.0369907618,
0.0107510407,
-0.030587431,
-0.0272494145,
0.0491288081,
-0.0573113374,
-0.0111929951,
0.0459142402,
0.0251160264,
0.0074482267,
-0.0532739051,
0.001301999,
0.0329920016,
0.0864872113,
-0.0019632105,
-0.0400704555,
-0.0361386985,
0.0330885872,
0.0200690106,
-0.0160341728,
-0.041039668,
-0.0123118851,
0.0089461608,
-0.0148191769,
-0.0083260192,
0.0082849646,
0.01309889,
0.0440232828,
-0.0461430885,
0.0114998966,
0.0049208635,
-0.0227474943,
0.0164623316,
0.0138554294,
-0.0192822721,
0.0556154512,
0.0424206443,
0.0344886146,
-0.0597428605,
0.0475296304,
0.047473073,
0.0355308019,
-0.0584900416,
0.042002853,
-0.0314057283,
-0.0712754205,
-0.0113567179,
0.0169468876,
0.0115356063,
-0.0161478929,
0.009635102,
0.0207784642,
-0.0348664708,
-0.0216936674,
0.0073403465,
0.0153405517,
-0.0052396553,
0.045370698,
0.0233812258,
-0.0036076677,
0.0137078259,
0.060430482,
-0.0242348742,
0.0413660519,
0.0020901095,
-0.0054087844,
-0.0425561555,
0.0226032957,
-0.0031756996,
0.010260066,
0.0085625853,
0.0269963201,
-0.0074222805,
-0.0292889383,
-0.0169554874,
-0.0613922551,
0.0023251718,
0.0128477737,
0.0323519818,
0.0622621998,
-0.0022446506,
-0.0175220929,
-0.0555672161,
-0.022272788,
0.0541419275,
-0.0225405525,
0.018414462,
-6.87934412e-33,
-0.0363951772,
0.025496671,
0.0032104903,
-0.0023058373,
-0.0220600329,
0.0073159607,
-0.0130205918,
-0.0050624805,
-0.0492222682,
-0.0045236098,
-0.0467983223,
-0.0242742002,
0.0214994606,
0.0336948782,
-0.0141241578,
-0.0198477264,
0.0631888062,
-0.0046361303,
-0.0472142138,
0.0325888246,
0.0443250611,
0.0496385396,
0.0294278823,
0.0044246665,
-0.0406903625,
0.0426073782,
-0.0302558932,
0.0252780262,
0.0224597827,
0.032953091,
0.0003563064,
0.0169413462,
0.0111469319,
-0.0545342825,
-0.0056359745,
0.0704044774,
-0.1115385368,
-0.0224886984,
0.0144622112,
0.02625742,
-0.0144842984,
-0.0338712446,
0.0331016518,
-0.0186151676,
0.0064765248,
-0.0290829074,
0.0078811208,
-0.0299702622,
-0.0469123088,
-0.0362908356,
-0.0478717759,
0.0035068246,
-0.0013281354,
-0.0382452346,
0.0257354304,
0.0398207456,
-0.0020416104,
0.0671758279,
-0.0387547165,
-0.0259852912,
0.0289097093,
0.0793521628,
0.0242576599,
0.035313338,
-0.0362216458,
0.0257662963,
0.0184006505,
-0.0004954449,
0.015513571,
0.0046327584,
0.0664740428,
0.0546326749,
0.0258137975,
0.0284198578,
0.0336159877,
-0.0354005434,
-0.0578268766,
-0.0061377408,
0.0290495567,
0.0363299772,
0.0284665953,
0.0031469015,
0.0138927102,
-0.0299651865,
-0.078876175,
-0.0078246742,
-0.0545053184,
0.0192367192,
0.0458156168,
0.0517535917,
-0.0470166877,
-0.0070501687,
0.085718438,
-0.0319754444,
-0.0080289459,
0.0147757661,
-0.0152931567,
-0.0017158041,
-0.0040659974,
-0.0166675765,
-0.0539872013,
-0.0628014952,
0.0618917271,
-0.0091954041,
0.0076604062,
-0.0040481342,
0.0494412147,
0.0438118726,
-0.0870383382,
-0.0022216651,
-0.0151816178,
0.0452292114,
-0.0108403619,
0.0591582656,
0.010526943,
-0.0092594,
-0.0166459326,
0.0590413287,
0.0037150062,
-0.0309211407,
0.0033251839,
-0.0189532861,
-0.0006510005,
0.0308418199,
-0.0235923678,
-0.0019270736,
-0.0095595587,
0.0225198399,
0.0405021384,
-0.0451348685,
-0.0075522061,
0.0247175414,
2.905e-7,
0.0096177794,
0.0606730916,
-0.0323512852,
-0.0086001633,
0.0090033477,
0.0454954132,
0.007078764,
0.0364053212,
0.0122163305,
-0.0142600071,
0.0087791458,
0.0096680988,
0.0236141514,
-0.0066248244,
-0.0763527974,
0.0056172535,
-0.0717512071,
0.0406006463,
-0.0613652058,
-0.019717142,
0.0268959925,
0.1263256669,
0.0074464632,
-0.0326812975,
0.0533268787,
-0.0260061845,
0.0246666651,
-0.03937402,
-0.0096510779,
0.0193136223,
0.043057885,
0.0227905214,
0.0215208083,
0.0177860912,
-0.036723651,
0.0400589556,
-0.0303893536,
0.0730832294,
0.0014078969,
-0.0253418572,
0.0121358931,
0.0007473641,
0.0047277506,
-0.0710739493,
0.1155025288,
-0.0747551993,
-0.0036160303,
-0.0456575975,
-0.0086368714,
-0.0173945315,
0.0373953953,
-0.0520702749,
-0.0290897489,
0.0477489829,
0.0467374586,
0.0126558542,
-0.0499434695,
-0.1221585646,
0.0255517289,
-0.0011872337,
-0.0192587469,
-0.0323987193,
-0.0629377365,
-0.0514874011,
0.0230025798,
-0.0555172861,
-0.014570226,
2.900028363e-34,
0.0327888615,
-0.0154929962,
0.0277082343,
0.000587847,
0.0057586026,
0.0102177132,
0.0170389786,
0.0127041703,
0.0259152874,
-0.1100517139,
-0.0347598381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05162v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05162v1 | Collecting Visually-Grounded Dialogue with A Game Of Sorts | 2023-09-10T23:00:35 | 2023-09-10T23:00:35 | Bram Willemsen, Dmytro Kalpakchi, Gabriel Skantze | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | An idealized, though simplistic, view of the referring expression production
and grounding process in (situated) dialogue assumes that a speaker must merely
appropriately specify their expression so that the target referent may be
successfully identified by the addressee. However, referring in conversation is
a collaborative process that cannot be aptly characterized as an exchange of
minimally-specified referring expressions. Concerns have been raised regarding
assumptions made by prior work on visually-grounded dialogue that reveal an
oversimplified view of conversation and the referential process. We address
these concerns by introducing a collaborative image ranking task, a grounded
agreement game we call "A Game Of Sorts". In our game, players are tasked with
reaching agreement on how to rank a set of images given some sorting criterion
through a largely unrestricted, role-symmetric dialogue. By putting emphasis on
the argumentation in this mixed-initiative interaction, we collect discussions
that involve the collaborative referential process. We describe results of a
small-scale data collection experiment with the proposed task. All discussed
materials, which includes the collected data, the codebase, and a containerized
version of the application, are publicly available. | [
0.0665596277,
0.0380224325,
-0.0215127803,
0.0172231719,
-0.0047374931,
-0.0064927209,
0.0153485052,
-0.0122372052,
-0.0129912989,
-0.0734107122,
-0.067450501,
-0.0003196387,
0.0489632264,
0.007247237,
0.0102701392,
-0.0744759738,
0.0045117848,
-0.0009652876,
0.042612236,
-0.0089809122,
0.0197792612,
0.0016900857,
-0.0528280027,
0.0444602072,
-0.058381021,
0.0099221282,
-0.0038721936,
0.012626349,
0.0178684928,
-0.0223234016,
-0.050335139,
0.0443960913,
0.0150826992,
-0.0106265191,
0.0000017935,
-0.0127781043,
0.0512669571,
-0.0535940118,
0.0225707646,
-0.0245382749,
-0.0124822222,
0.0583114065,
0.0028634002,
-0.0349199176,
-0.0488296412,
-0.0002966282,
0.082205452,
0.072936669,
0.0765528157,
-0.0202003662,
-0.0104421694,
-0.0221009757,
-0.0341342911,
0.0018241302,
-0.0075028287,
-0.0223676618,
-0.0238143057,
0.0756635889,
0.0276702065,
0.0286278073,
-0.0194050018,
0.0256792922,
-0.0158543568,
-0.0434236601,
0.0275753867,
0.0602361038,
-0.0550823025,
-0.0210179687,
0.0017050165,
0.1085701436,
0.0446160436,
0.0221002325,
0.0121632982,
0.0156956706,
-0.0155502651,
0.0145465136,
-0.0560588278,
0.0553039163,
-0.0079116095,
0.0132397562,
-0.0654698461,
0.0304554403,
-0.0387150943,
0.0123229111,
0.0373138972,
0.0467041954,
-0.0082058376,
0.0160071719,
0.0006759363,
0.0128637366,
-0.0252467506,
-0.0850235671,
-0.0240933672,
-0.0334888659,
-0.0286070406,
0.0232114103,
-0.0054533794,
0.0153952958,
0.0046548066,
-0.0267585907,
0.0396740437,
-0.0191124789,
-0.0258774925,
0.0674889609,
0.0494153351,
0.0366447791,
-0.0049270256,
0.0093870116,
0.0016889432,
0.0136934267,
-0.0158130359,
-0.010437089,
-0.0499807969,
0.0299517661,
-0.0596720278,
-0.0437962413,
-0.0036691267,
0.0062040491,
-0.0612383708,
0.0238726027,
-0.0025993004,
0.0587641262,
-0.0222701915,
0.0205638018,
-0.029198898,
0.0239817537,
-0.0512775145,
0.0226113871,
0.0049675913,
-0.0699477047,
0.0069689155,
0.0277196486,
0.0237146337,
-0.0221374109,
-0.0389325172,
0.0060527013,
-0.0298850052,
-0.0000259233,
0.0294508692,
-0.0455513857,
-0.0486839786,
-0.0523646064,
0.0208226033,
-0.0384720974,
-0.0063253008,
-0.0020290283,
0.0167757999,
-0.04227148,
0.0312329922,
0.003889702,
-0.031295415,
0.0937293544,
0.0032501318,
-0.0057935901,
0.0545254238,
0.0462193266,
-0.0299857687,
0.0367563032,
0.0602579713,
0.0255658347,
0.0356343389,
-0.0197497718,
0.016733868,
0.0116348742,
-0.0021777991,
-0.001330981,
-0.0015084998,
0.0016639275,
-0.0414313823,
0.0197081938,
-0.0023755219,
0.0398933068,
-0.0312906764,
-0.0269217826,
0.0844648704,
0.1085043997,
-0.0661549717,
-0.0157202035,
-0.0250662919,
0.0060880035,
-0.0119851986,
0.032522656,
-0.009814701,
0.0883166492,
0.0358186215,
-0.0226410385,
0.0156998057,
-0.0057986723,
-0.0439628623,
-0.0194274187,
0.0095699159,
0.0254475046,
0.0381207615,
-0.0305610541,
-0.0203192085,
0.0245544091,
-0.009604862,
0.0473661646,
-0.0149216931,
-0.0776905939,
-0.0342978723,
0.0033059299,
0.0443117917,
0.010720579,
0.0300005954,
0.0211980846,
-0.0139368661,
-0.0221604742,
0.0678788349,
0.0470998921,
-0.0075640017,
-0.0106695136,
0.0038225225,
-0.0316298306,
-0.0249475073,
-0.0125376713,
-0.0071830484,
0.0235226694,
-0.0406795144,
-0.0191173032,
-0.0101464605,
-0.0011975038,
0.0248870291,
-0.0079665687,
0.0760180056,
0.0144581376,
-0.0229618866,
0.0432352722,
0.0454270989,
0.0162334908,
-0.0349412225,
-0.0020925582,
0.0454065576,
0.0135981319,
0.0157937035,
0.1028477401,
-0.0373007655,
0.0069031273,
0.0006217904,
-0.0903230608,
-0.0357210822,
-0.0320363231,
-0.0007425831,
-0.0313352495,
0.0728050619,
-0.0458835363,
-0.0267957523,
-0.0237043444,
-0.0224211495,
0.0198425725,
-0.0022112152,
-0.0127079021,
0.0309649594,
0.0168864671,
-0.0050211493,
0.0467074439,
-0.0193685312,
0.0281721465,
-0.0694418475,
0.0291649885,
0.0342542976,
0.0210662801,
0.0035592404,
0.0246813521,
-0.0236482415,
-0.0731069446,
-0.002934498,
-0.1284229755,
-0.0578018054,
-0.0139898937,
-0.0442969799,
-0.0013469,
-0.0201215856,
0.0107346289,
-0.0347525217,
-0.0286876298,
0.0011772641,
0.0220858585,
0.0250660479,
0.0621724054,
0.0211808383,
0.0358959399,
-0.0483426787,
0.0183926169,
0.0224859715,
0.0716814846,
0.0482389405,
-0.0155561231,
-0.0378317274,
0.0146145709,
-0.0669858158,
0.0228310656,
0.0014854243,
-0.0090510165,
0.0694810748,
0.0413407981,
0.041342102,
0.0483233556,
0.0205965545,
0.0412796102,
0.0231645554,
-0.0812087432,
-0.0780590922,
0.0003468764,
0.047034312,
0.0138456216,
0.0178417526,
-0.0324860439,
0.0101957954,
0.0330557115,
-0.0050393967,
0.0506055243,
-0.0400408693,
0.0592856221,
0.0302837733,
-0.0429572761,
-0.0597483516,
-0.0332349427,
-0.0000014953,
0.0415988415,
-0.0337795317,
-0.0228015706,
0.045695927,
-0.0468853265,
-0.0360648185,
0.009581998,
0.0306546595,
-0.0062983693,
0.0726264268,
-0.0185932014,
-0.0024151977,
0.0059714448,
-0.0174289737,
-0.0470751412,
-0.0252011493,
0.042903062,
0.0006814581,
0.0716960654,
-0.0717041269,
0.0076531009,
-0.006387874,
-0.0366130956,
-0.0236318205,
-0.0125229685,
-0.0524029136,
-0.0226798896,
-0.0216546543,
0.0108761294,
-0.0207310449,
0.055569943,
0.0485922024,
-0.0328281149,
0.0308251884,
0.0001205789,
0.0019428636,
0.0274254233,
0.0497320667,
0.0373636521,
-0.040346615,
0.026535565,
0.0015537547,
0.0667471215,
0.0410819724,
0.0032487793,
-0.0344754346,
-0.0066121086,
0.010793115,
0.0301655624,
-0.0420213602,
-0.0115690539,
0.0453286432,
0.0146841686,
-0.0052074068,
0.0671986118,
0.0182909332,
-0.0505291037,
-0.0261319019,
-0.0113122361,
0.0205757823,
0.0129359215,
-0.0138934609,
-0.1019273102,
-0.0103441756,
-0.0080533009,
-0.0359593071,
-0.0000757607,
-0.0475316383,
-0.0377472043,
-0.098043412,
0.0593784004,
0.0045614569,
0.0078947339,
-0.0096395593,
0.022385221,
0.0354622602,
0.0136285918,
-0.0358273387,
-0.0073431395,
0.0173027944,
0.0307477284,
0.0107403817,
0.0333466344,
0.0388497002,
-0.0060085333,
-0.045706287,
0.0422163308,
0.0155439209,
0.0526133217,
0.0294298753,
-0.0656423196,
-0.0119251935,
0.0146753602,
0.0049772803,
-0.0146273114,
0.0163365416,
-0.0211089831,
-0.0259596035,
0.0052830395,
-0.0059323641,
0.0213970281,
-0.014977552,
0.0069668815,
0.0364098921,
-0.0609245896,
0.0088158408,
-0.0040656789,
0.0631730482,
0.0251028482,
0.0301661622,
0.0660901889,
-0.0033734699,
-0.0050254655,
-0.0151443956,
0.068012096,
-0.0193558522,
-0.0370116122,
-0.0565867424,
0.0116601381,
0.0247544255,
-0.1035407335,
-0.0340873785,
0.0143863736,
0.036040511,
-0.0128270173,
-0.0405233987,
0.0099190893,
0.0305580944,
-0.0089431703,
0.036456205,
-0.016742643,
0.0136246495,
-0.0230816491,
-0.0362961143,
0.0287022796,
-0.011619607,
-0.0194939747,
0.0398139767,
0.0169012584,
-0.034991391,
-0.0242251791,
0.0759059265,
0.0187141541,
-0.0122209983,
0.0445305072,
-0.0404106863,
-0.0220358334,
-0.013284686,
0.0211116895,
0.0174817555,
0.0071742279,
-0.015468115,
-0.0091926707,
0.0116813891,
-0.0107548218,
0.0311423279,
-0.0042970153,
0.0163242482,
-0.0695716962,
-0.0970430672,
-0.0248667412,
-0.019568963,
0.0611881427,
0.0099711521,
0.0225225165,
-0.0111273453,
0.0292092524,
-0.0120117664,
-0.0185915455,
-0.050883051,
0.0131275002,
-0.0567911044,
-0.0033217943,
0.0046063177,
0.0177693143,
-0.0372394063,
0.0767850429,
0.0246900264,
-0.0193010159,
0.0482878871,
-0.011110343,
-0.0379980654,
0.0183290355,
0.000306216,
0.0236646272,
0.0113195162,
0.0664152279,
0.0146992961,
0.0859227329,
0.0338089801,
-0.0811024234,
0.0047851577,
0.057849884,
-0.0165238716,
-0.0093108332,
0.0406782553,
0.0302608255,
0.0513279699,
0.0224993974,
0.0147305215,
-0.0103130471,
0.0224697851,
0.0287959669,
0.0068203853,
0.0214414559,
-0.0685989857,
0.0296999197,
0.0264962539,
-0.0088817524,
0.0262249112,
0.0370597653,
-0.0476714894,
-0.0211016089,
-0.0053830459,
-0.0276133697,
-0.0353951268,
-0.0089268992,
-0.0489858836,
0.0082906969,
0.0179825928,
0.034128055,
-0.0385969803,
-0.039433524,
0.0295097213,
0.0082626278,
0.0196942464,
-0.0114807272,
0.0681690499,
0.0348934419,
0.0333624408,
0.0092159081,
-0.015231736,
-0.0037493638,
-0.0603585839,
0.0123908697,
-0.0906248465,
-5.507808168e-33,
-0.0621166825,
-0.080085814,
0.0127230641,
0.0172137413,
-0.0183514077,
-0.0050624264,
-0.0383401625,
0.0178093966,
0.0137359658,
0.0266629886,
-0.0143133663,
-0.0058139595,
0.0074333968,
0.0107952505,
0.0076577007,
-0.0186383929,
0.0168652795,
-0.0071895351,
-0.0636747777,
0.0153647298,
0.0384857766,
-0.0374314673,
0.0092142662,
-0.0979994461,
-0.0151280612,
0.0461847931,
-0.025168471,
0.0118960384,
0.0375091694,
0.0361501388,
0.0075642895,
0.0283015557,
-0.0018572279,
-0.0139370803,
0.0036766755,
0.0680889189,
-0.0302844886,
-0.049065657,
0.0484890565,
0.0113376956,
-0.0220062304,
0.0272015054,
-0.0172106866,
-0.0112101017,
-0.030770164,
-0.0003715701,
0.0301011559,
-0.0170467608,
-0.0036906728,
0.0336225703,
-0.014344994,
-0.0154701779,
-0.0241577551,
-0.0376087502,
0.0206541624,
0.0260793436,
0.0250600893,
-0.0200461708,
-0.059792649,
0.1024058983,
-0.0643469393,
-0.0188318789,
0.0750591159,
0.0131204911,
0.0457519405,
0.0707298741,
0.0216464065,
0.0320488438,
-0.0447034352,
-0.0722698197,
-0.0282505751,
0.0709644631,
0.0471128412,
0.0161820147,
-0.0489301682,
0.0233634394,
0.0067930082,
0.0023940657,
0.0245084595,
0.0504559614,
-0.0204503126,
0.0449872501,
-0.0376346149,
0.0073817205,
-0.0200753007,
-0.0187600926,
-0.0257456694,
-0.0433338247,
0.0067854254,
-0.0009728328,
-0.0203557648,
0.0496166721,
0.0391968377,
-0.0136697255,
-0.0430871174,
0.0170599893,
0.0106659029,
0.0460872613,
-0.0069904779,
-0.0448459499,
-0.0234479457,
0.0260853153,
0.0570961609,
0.0349023268,
0.0325995535,
0.0318699293,
-0.0046768417,
-0.0200685076,
-0.0285159685,
-0.0214422252,
-0.0053851181,
0.0090229195,
-0.0711020529,
-0.0187397823,
0.0071593188,
0.0278592296,
-0.0491378233,
0.0109298779,
-0.022704117,
0.0101258485,
-0.0234434865,
-0.0510855541,
-0.0519617796,
-0.0030219392,
-0.0430154093,
-0.0082906829,
-0.0057785236,
-0.0089655733,
0.007146433,
-0.014158071,
-0.0368537754,
-0.0224688053,
2.601e-7,
-0.032969594,
0.0238413587,
0.0316730924,
0.0016527601,
0.0116966916,
0.0259878412,
-0.0007559902,
0.0143159041,
0.0337418206,
-0.0632729083,
0.0180916414,
-0.0073434487,
0.0337631479,
0.0273747928,
-0.0552860685,
-0.0310291722,
-0.0634709597,
-0.0192819778,
0.0053682742,
-0.0302846096,
0.0275195874,
0.0025545252,
-0.0186964124,
0.0300778281,
-0.0291135088,
-0.0408859551,
0.037987031,
-0.0499977283,
0.0233706124,
-0.0411198586,
0.0386035554,
-0.0638171583,
-0.0289029982,
0.0123925703,
0.0077508148,
-0.0053444309,
0.0344094299,
-0.0172911938,
-0.0382483564,
-0.0588899255,
-0.0603193231,
0.0127051305,
-0.0021944486,
-0.0181221664,
0.014152145,
-0.0727443025,
-0.0281607565,
0.0171898082,
-0.041938208,
-0.0400560498,
0.0358123109,
-0.0179734919,
-0.0732379854,
0.0054648211,
0.011868217,
-0.0201731157,
0.0039038651,
-0.0603200793,
-0.0135236625,
-0.0287640579,
-0.0231259018,
-0.0436353125,
0.0061480301,
-0.0350634754,
-0.0185210072,
0.0103818206,
-0.0281714723,
1.47133758e-34,
0.0138768209,
0.0175435375,
0.0232511833,
0.0397585854,
0.0452404395,
-0.0111275222,
-0.0100758066,
-0.0030391386,
0.0627825409,
-0.0149909826,
-0.0037440646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05142v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05142v1 | Large Language Models for Difficulty Estimation of Foreign Language Content with Application to Language Learning | 2023-09-10T21:23:09 | 2023-09-10T21:23:09 | Michalis Vlachos, Mircea Lungu, Yash Raj Shrestha, Johannes-Rudolf David | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We use large language models to aid learners enhance proficiency in a foreign
language. This is accomplished by identifying content on topics that the user
is interested in, and that closely align with the learner's proficiency level
in that foreign language. Our work centers on French content, but our approach
is readily transferable to other languages. Our solution offers several
distinctive characteristics that differentiate it from existing
language-learning solutions, such as, a) the discovery of content across topics
that the learner cares about, thus increasing motivation, b) a more precise
estimation of the linguistic difficulty of the content than traditional
readability measures, and c) the availability of both textual and video-based
content. The linguistic complexity of video content is derived from the video
captions. It is our aspiration that such technology will enable learners to
remain engaged in the language-learning process by continuously adapting the
topics and the difficulty of the content to align with the learners' evolving
interests and learning objectives. | [
0.0281397682,
0.0039093024,
-0.0446323752,
0.0423141532,
-0.0485180132,
0.0194279682,
0.0146753918,
-0.0275562834,
0.033559747,
-0.0351354703,
-0.00200751,
-0.030291941,
0.0003673971,
-0.0108582936,
0.0016995907,
-0.0918225795,
0.0080761882,
-0.0600592829,
0.0185922533,
-0.0062956414,
0.0389773324,
-0.0140710585,
-0.0087822741,
0.0205191895,
0.0224631727,
-0.0093565406,
0.0146130826,
0.0003385143,
-0.0227820482,
-0.0266186967,
-0.0020222683,
0.0342376418,
0.006642628,
0.0111699933,
0.0000020239,
-0.0117869824,
-0.0289084259,
-0.0257134289,
0.018809149,
0.0582502037,
0.0756848529,
0.0062339553,
-0.0224547032,
0.002785645,
-0.0054896851,
-0.0056224563,
0.0468418524,
-0.0200568493,
0.0358851254,
0.0208251271,
-0.0104930801,
-0.026403863,
-0.0193450749,
0.0221797191,
0.0389522575,
-0.0245874282,
-0.003789518,
0.066296272,
0.0300440229,
0.0245740153,
-0.0559480861,
0.0472561009,
-0.0028939419,
-0.0308821481,
-0.0145475529,
0.0022834644,
0.0409542657,
-0.054265406,
0.0125234472,
0.0380501188,
-0.0166356936,
0.0218484886,
-0.0115315523,
0.0103069413,
0.0272513628,
0.0586658716,
-0.063862212,
0.0173910912,
0.0142675173,
0.0049737971,
0.0419908799,
0.0175699405,
0.00007746,
-0.0019996064,
-0.0010974853,
-0.0286544822,
0.0279229209,
-0.0366117507,
0.0199265294,
0.0113986628,
-0.005652729,
-0.0013636011,
0.0610180236,
0.0166942161,
-0.0041428343,
0.0360242799,
-0.02501674,
-0.056748312,
-0.0152537329,
-0.0690221563,
0.0046598371,
0.0313870125,
-0.0418464206,
0.0841683149,
-0.0274065193,
0.0570046827,
0.0093692373,
-0.0367719494,
-0.067449674,
-0.0080978712,
-0.0201334301,
0.0204813424,
-0.0456163883,
0.0180422757,
-0.0183294173,
-0.02574661,
-0.063557215,
0.0178044122,
-0.0289782081,
0.0390676856,
-0.0239626411,
-0.0491310842,
0.0043551992,
-0.0061295279,
-0.0086717447,
0.0563296452,
-0.0317238532,
-0.005348973,
-0.0264044516,
-0.0116889765,
0.0641107708,
0.0122335795,
0.0126967588,
-0.0185007248,
0.0249795374,
0.0414117947,
-0.0417300351,
-0.0339496098,
-0.0446615256,
0.0053071799,
-0.0270840507,
0.0024797949,
-0.0049172519,
-0.0866730139,
-0.0150792291,
0.0022818584,
0.0452270322,
-0.0556340814,
-0.003782223,
0.0024985929,
-0.0049461029,
0.0691470727,
-0.0114738038,
0.0154712135,
0.0649020374,
0.0352987088,
-0.0077116601,
0.0960461274,
0.0019012616,
-0.0213232357,
0.0800364017,
-0.0382640921,
0.0111401407,
0.0663872883,
-0.0249701887,
0.0264835842,
-0.0176111832,
-0.0326829478,
0.0411086492,
-0.0055184043,
-0.0231594928,
0.0549474731,
0.0112476638,
0.0252881274,
0.0814089179,
0.0353298821,
-0.0073702913,
0.0340494327,
0.01955075,
0.0325543508,
0.0297520701,
0.0755473077,
0.0286229588,
0.0300442725,
-0.002805341,
0.0165747963,
0.0487792939,
0.0429654457,
-0.0348545164,
-0.1013875753,
-0.0105112167,
-0.0015430449,
0.0633056611,
0.0139608644,
0.0737238824,
-0.0285831392,
-0.0079317316,
0.0166523308,
0.0401130728,
-0.0496872254,
0.0511117093,
-0.0068018907,
0.0382126458,
0.0637976527,
0.0021185961,
-0.0631845519,
-0.0230060648,
0.0181391314,
0.0674604699,
0.0267115086,
0.0355212316,
-0.0104981251,
-0.0251361243,
-0.0679623038,
-0.0129602589,
0.0490570925,
0.0110704172,
0.0069481852,
-0.0100104148,
0.0424851887,
0.0122510241,
0.0109239286,
-0.0799321234,
-0.0062703053,
-0.0265312269,
-0.0278842002,
-0.0226909872,
0.0243207421,
0.0228671636,
0.0558546744,
0.014035021,
-0.0121525647,
0.0006720789,
-0.0355032869,
0.0183097776,
0.0305200592,
-0.0134508926,
0.0107391477,
0.0690264031,
-0.0870849788,
-0.0105698109,
-0.0141838919,
0.012314029,
-0.0296457298,
0.0224965513,
-0.0791170597,
0.0246146303,
-0.0000849829,
0.0322954766,
-0.0214948095,
-0.0258598346,
-0.0105120186,
0.024554804,
0.0062837582,
0.0830087438,
0.0457180217,
-0.042610541,
-0.0164222419,
-0.0324548855,
-0.05710008,
0.0038871409,
-0.0109525453,
0.0164634287,
0.0516833924,
0.0070632296,
-0.049275659,
-0.0520271175,
-0.0704188868,
-0.0309609864,
-0.0003598095,
0.0132120466,
-0.0012864298,
-0.0050969697,
-0.0274954718,
-0.014825766,
-0.0475615375,
-0.0126256319,
-0.0190990996,
0.0217499509,
-0.0247567799,
0.0404715538,
-0.0340148918,
-0.0436677188,
-0.0464455858,
0.0038572033,
0.0412930213,
0.0514408574,
-0.0111340256,
-0.0472883172,
0.0352234878,
-0.0174368918,
-0.0173669234,
0.0053607812,
-0.064396441,
-0.0115281371,
-0.0223822352,
0.0619802885,
0.065800637,
-0.009031849,
0.0580017678,
0.0520668253,
-0.0433936194,
-0.0268465336,
0.0113180224,
-0.0346525274,
-0.0551595986,
-0.0449298993,
-0.0999887884,
-0.0124471011,
0.0375099517,
-0.0201815572,
-0.0092164138,
-0.0635117739,
0.0283162575,
-0.0957286656,
0.0455991402,
-0.0321575478,
0.023737425,
0.0058511165,
0.0307635162,
-0.011488596,
-0.0098396782,
0.0625288561,
-0.0456379764,
0.0025922174,
-0.0380268991,
-0.0179412421,
-0.0006210764,
0.0315112248,
0.0024067785,
0.033630807,
-0.0021234369,
-0.0216629412,
-0.033700075,
-0.0000747828,
0.0800729766,
-0.0531485081,
0.0481974967,
-0.0521604829,
-0.0516763255,
0.0081815235,
-0.0149094332,
0.016706679,
0.0225651059,
-0.000275263,
-0.0641365573,
0.0073022139,
-0.0113475602,
-0.0443912372,
-0.016254181,
0.038213741,
0.0175276957,
-0.0081246523,
-0.0017671169,
0.0065159169,
0.0404223129,
0.0211730134,
0.0180055331,
-0.0224685781,
-0.0787750557,
0.0506847575,
0.029963281,
0.0069976426,
-0.0234322511,
0.0212363098,
0.0086887125,
0.0497075059,
-0.0252373088,
-0.0227137972,
0.023530826,
0.0324060954,
-0.0638022572,
0.0041605434,
0.1406824887,
0.0202524662,
-0.0610577054,
-0.0272543114,
-0.0550275147,
0.0195433237,
0.0373186171,
0.0250814501,
-0.035053499,
0.0110993218,
0.0047928053,
0.0270117689,
-0.0198920779,
0.0194644462,
-0.0009497801,
-0.0819508359,
0.0448999889,
0.0370150879,
-0.0331555903,
-0.0259380955,
-0.0363232829,
-0.0198348481,
-0.0021018011,
-0.0104981754,
-0.0296431556,
-0.0150265386,
0.0093591409,
0.0350231379,
-0.0470647812,
-0.0656628311,
-0.0389021225,
-0.0108434083,
0.0508343689,
-0.0074118301,
0.0240001604,
-0.0472207181,
-0.0125741735,
0.0271191783,
-0.010643811,
-0.0248089526,
-0.0329329297,
0.0249720328,
0.0295956936,
-0.0355421007,
-0.0359938629,
0.0086496929,
0.0451147296,
0.009971736,
0.0524215661,
0.0777463913,
0.0620164499,
0.0422501639,
-0.0184077621,
-0.014642586,
0.0222875085,
0.0554769598,
0.0532332249,
-0.0779192522,
0.054985702,
-0.0702263191,
-0.0098296339,
-0.021387998,
-0.0532504693,
0.0362507254,
-0.0241175648,
-0.0304007288,
-0.0707614943,
-0.0216581505,
0.0230106767,
0.0191091951,
0.0247514714,
0.0614509732,
0.0351059958,
0.0063111191,
-0.0488728732,
0.0126594733,
0.0024833882,
-0.0219473727,
-0.1213825196,
-0.0426517799,
0.0081559019,
-0.0486422777,
-0.0131017109,
-0.005250379,
-0.0320433378,
-0.0481573977,
-0.0101258401,
0.0459973142,
0.0174973402,
-0.009715287,
0.0298859701,
-0.0542701334,
0.0021117276,
-0.0200306941,
-0.0350866988,
0.0073233088,
0.0167179648,
-0.0026561373,
-0.0026619988,
0.0028499668,
-0.0154477926,
-0.0132263629,
-0.0068664942,
0.0231617913,
-0.0272494331,
-0.0524617545,
0.0062021646,
0.0010117248,
0.0288453251,
-0.0080796666,
-0.0362105742,
-0.0428493768,
0.0060413941,
-0.0160416979,
-0.0073261005,
-0.0250634495,
-0.0115765585,
0.0501486398,
0.0060551348,
0.0014460346,
0.0363830924,
0.0071187727,
-0.0242845081,
-0.0438610949,
0.0624460764,
-0.0206143558,
-0.0160494577,
0.0131081855,
0.0133878617,
0.0036560802,
0.0087020248,
-0.0031055848,
0.0246391781,
0.0160657708,
0.078178525,
0.0031761886,
-0.0346631669,
0.0391313545,
0.0260908734,
0.0052447678,
-0.0016215259,
-0.0017694853,
0.0331415795,
0.0630130172,
-0.0454698019,
0.054269582,
-0.0430368558,
0.0069313883,
-0.0342848822,
0.0147308568,
-0.0079565197,
-0.087736994,
0.0040894714,
-0.0006835714,
0.048016049,
0.0129895732,
0.0994093642,
0.0156933106,
-0.0308590773,
0.03484549,
-0.0324657708,
-0.0104441326,
0.0003013152,
0.0077068442,
0.0249973927,
-0.0661840066,
0.0197477434,
-0.0405664369,
-0.063078098,
-0.0044663101,
0.0103269601,
-0.0035327266,
-0.0003969076,
0.0216082707,
0.027523946,
-0.0605475195,
0.0086619295,
-0.0587326474,
0.0372127183,
-0.0569400862,
-0.0275155772,
0.0404485799,
-5.793962431e-33,
-0.0399718024,
-0.0514911413,
-0.0273736604,
0.0338310227,
0.0162782334,
0.0151623292,
-0.0231405199,
0.0602671616,
0.0085548786,
0.0155938454,
0.0335505791,
-0.0125646302,
0.0104283253,
0.0190966185,
0.0028426175,
0.008428961,
0.0558309481,
0.0027981503,
0.0108538764,
0.0103951851,
0.0124202929,
-0.0029656412,
0.022788208,
-0.0808702707,
0.0297938213,
-0.0229643639,
0.0034763513,
0.0099984435,
0.0739625096,
0.0915751159,
-0.0023788172,
0.0336144641,
-0.0026234982,
-0.0533514135,
-0.0161982216,
-0.0159957074,
-0.055188287,
-0.0244823415,
0.0203725621,
0.0645835921,
0.01438177,
-0.0636739731,
0.0134935314,
-0.0134054087,
-0.0275419876,
-0.0188361537,
0.0572977997,
-0.0549404845,
0.0065501211,
-0.0033803508,
-0.0423748344,
0.018811278,
-0.0382071249,
-0.0093321735,
0.0744795725,
0.0222496893,
0.0080150217,
-0.0432545505,
-0.0268808641,
0.0613836609,
0.0152232135,
0.0724029914,
0.0661401451,
-0.0220252443,
-0.0053956369,
0.021319231,
0.0228083897,
-0.0294202678,
0.019986894,
-0.0069682705,
0.0599314459,
-0.0165904034,
0.0637579337,
0.0488195196,
0.0171348602,
-0.0089489389,
-0.0558004379,
0.0498471372,
-0.0153146861,
0.0016784703,
0.0441937894,
0.0086625246,
-0.0467326604,
-0.0048740115,
-0.0345281102,
0.0386087,
-0.0207448825,
-0.030848803,
0.0136617664,
-0.0323612131,
-0.0163431447,
-0.0579670109,
0.0435346141,
-0.0205961037,
-0.0103959432,
0.015986925,
-0.0045203865,
0.0893796533,
-0.0373612903,
0.0314780176,
-0.039113719,
-0.0390580408,
-0.0391896367,
-0.0250827298,
-0.0064159008,
0.0221980549,
-0.0022535091,
0.0265201014,
-0.0474090017,
0.0139831342,
0.0027926913,
-0.0199847817,
-0.0018478117,
0.0575924814,
0.0291096512,
-0.0158943348,
-0.0353915393,
0.0502116792,
0.0201837551,
-0.0219328459,
-0.0314759463,
-0.0483663045,
-0.0241872445,
-0.0010822889,
-0.0448322333,
-0.0143201379,
-0.0365953408,
0.0149559751,
-0.0121484129,
-0.0298201889,
-0.0079315575,
-0.0010820716,
2.633e-7,
-0.0075494028,
0.0725524053,
-0.0306615252,
0.0020849227,
0.0216962975,
0.0123580983,
-0.0285858884,
-0.0242455099,
0.0121595263,
-0.0022414369,
0.0280009806,
0.0279954672,
0.0553346127,
0.0351446085,
-0.0890965089,
-0.0253571849,
0.0185381584,
0.0192559734,
-0.0336724743,
0.0454986393,
0.0555037931,
0.0699039474,
-0.0025971432,
0.0243205577,
-0.0052676033,
-0.085628964,
0.0459953956,
-0.0555139594,
-0.015109065,
0.0073721102,
0.0580689386,
0.071349971,
-0.0435391106,
-0.0008411803,
-0.0291364603,
-0.0290898122,
0.0472994745,
0.0288274102,
0.02816852,
0.0412929356,
0.0098405425,
0.0213551577,
-0.0393708199,
-0.0412718467,
0.0196396466,
0.005615829,
0.0096881706,
0.0251590498,
-0.0126035726,
-0.0419299603,
0.0157171674,
-0.0399983265,
-0.0261205621,
-0.0023283495,
0.0156607497,
-0.0379969217,
0.0051589897,
-0.0323864482,
-0.0138000175,
-0.0013930536,
-0.0017208069,
-0.0173465908,
-0.0692323819,
0.0094687482,
-0.0072238389,
-0.0283045042,
0.0193360075,
1.856425167e-34,
0.0320114121,
-0.0010033655,
0.007883531,
-0.0004109361,
0.0177503172,
-0.008011193,
-0.0300187729,
0.0130353021,
0.0054331957,
-0.0430012643,
-0.0116709676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05103v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05103v1 | AGent: A Novel Pipeline for Automatically Creating Unanswerable Questions | 2023-09-10T18:13:11 | 2023-09-10T18:13:11 | Son Quoc Tran, Gia-Huy Do, Phong Nguyen-Thuan Do, Matt Kretchmar, Xinya Du | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The development of large high-quality datasets and high-performing models
have led to significant advancements in the domain of Extractive Question
Answering (EQA). This progress has sparked considerable interest in exploring
unanswerable questions within the EQA domain. Training EQA models with
unanswerable questions helps them avoid extracting misleading or incorrect
answers for queries that lack valid responses. However, manually annotating
unanswerable questions is labor-intensive. To address this, we propose AGent, a
novel pipeline that automatically creates new unanswerable questions by
re-matching a question with a context that lacks the necessary information for
a correct answer. In this paper, we demonstrate the usefulness of this AGent
pipeline by creating two sets of unanswerable questions from answerable
questions in SQuAD and HotpotQA. These created question sets exhibit low error
rates. Additionally, models fine-tuned on these questions show comparable
performance with those fine-tuned on the SQuAD 2.0 dataset on multiple EQA
benchmarks. | [
0.0498070233,
0.0451775752,
-0.0157183856,
0.0028082519,
-0.0315316431,
0.0555507727,
0.0057827462,
0.0077769631,
0.0036353394,
-0.014630056,
0.0017644451,
0.0057251039,
-0.057450328,
0.0154239722,
0.0105544087,
-0.0094658332,
0.0276270751,
0.0086006988,
0.0051306463,
0.0057485523,
0.0012166518,
0.0144617436,
-0.0070495172,
0.0067758346,
-0.0179269109,
-0.0427752212,
-0.0198864024,
-0.0070360913,
-0.0058056023,
-0.0054377127,
0.0394007228,
0.0310779307,
-0.0086031286,
0.0343306661,
0.0000018746,
-0.0536414273,
-0.0283673257,
-0.0041303593,
-0.0818905383,
-0.0459572412,
-0.026097171,
0.0183658674,
0.0376094691,
0.040026702,
-0.0427049585,
0.0039482284,
0.0427579992,
0.0469488725,
0.0422037505,
0.0390353017,
0.0121898092,
-0.018176131,
0.0054585384,
0.0158002842,
0.0386699699,
-0.0512469187,
0.0485015996,
-0.0085382601,
0.0175711401,
-0.0069325087,
-0.0059492146,
0.0215091873,
0.0510094501,
0.0120737739,
0.0103593785,
0.0348272324,
-0.0439700112,
-0.0238388106,
0.0015093231,
0.1228831112,
0.0052751871,
-0.031152796,
-0.0074978066,
-0.0047257794,
0.0373015255,
0.0137607772,
-0.0269940738,
-0.0084465826,
-0.0085310424,
-0.0397932157,
-0.003502822,
0.020752972,
-0.0099606039,
-0.0094216727,
-0.0143896658,
0.0587611161,
0.0186515991,
-0.043638289,
0.0189518891,
-0.0042035817,
-0.0447100289,
-0.0577853359,
0.0199206956,
0.0821414515,
-0.0547026023,
0.0161166172,
-0.009446647,
-0.0136437593,
0.0429538973,
-0.0277200397,
-0.0015148413,
0.0049236286,
-0.0168937687,
0.0902450681,
-0.0291872285,
0.0057210149,
-0.0352005698,
0.0251978002,
-0.0643602535,
-0.0537225343,
-0.0220027044,
-0.0415938087,
-0.0563127212,
0.0390524045,
-0.0341632627,
0.015583015,
0.0169157814,
0.0127105732,
-0.013192608,
-0.0257500485,
-0.0105170282,
0.0614778996,
-0.057956811,
-0.0057770452,
-0.0471736975,
0.0293960813,
-0.0878960416,
0.0462601893,
0.0282182507,
-0.0692983791,
-0.0321808942,
0.0117793316,
0.038900461,
-0.0161116067,
0.0450993367,
0.0681945384,
-0.0035866655,
-0.0102649592,
0.0049004168,
-0.0146979587,
0.0464760475,
-0.0523877069,
-0.0323864184,
-0.0557216778,
0.0433459543,
-0.008063687,
-0.0632025152,
-0.0162859932,
0.0066504437,
0.0348993503,
-0.0029244276,
0.0661129504,
-0.0319018289,
0.0057366639,
0.0481311493,
-0.0244000256,
-0.0399801657,
0.0616099499,
-0.0061636302,
0.0074808067,
0.0701004118,
0.0134628639,
0.0547972508,
-0.0178618748,
0.0256421454,
-0.0017885935,
0.0287955143,
0.078989476,
0.0097047072,
0.0019011166,
-0.0428368412,
0.0178867821,
-0.000571054,
-0.0601332113,
-0.0105178142,
0.0037226349,
-0.0048384969,
-0.0108374814,
0.0433764569,
0.0055026854,
0.0160899237,
0.0051172511,
-0.0268922448,
0.0620327592,
-0.01247878,
-0.0105445674,
0.0008267927,
0.0273746606,
-0.0541245677,
-0.0620113462,
0.0235396493,
0.0242125001,
0.0068417485,
0.047636956,
0.0421450473,
0.0410125293,
-0.0451013483,
0.0362097546,
-0.0073538818,
-0.0200725272,
0.0036816939,
-0.0223791208,
0.0837771073,
0.0058929068,
0.0530390516,
-0.0633892268,
-0.0641370118,
-0.0050377599,
-0.0077543375,
0.0075251618,
0.0284051597,
-0.0446915627,
0.0490757674,
-0.0478397682,
-0.0186152887,
0.0059272391,
-0.0054900884,
-0.0302584395,
0.0412242226,
0.0072596301,
0.0022981199,
-0.0586140491,
-0.0089252312,
0.0266336631,
-0.0492704548,
-0.0570259392,
0.0353115909,
-0.0107734287,
0.0260175839,
0.0127765164,
0.0064951512,
0.0140593881,
0.0507691689,
-0.0121453851,
-0.0910041854,
-0.0088974955,
-0.0277217962,
-0.021716157,
0.0241764765,
-0.0381192863,
-0.050496839,
0.0583901815,
-0.0357864909,
-0.0372149907,
-0.0178776197,
-0.0335119627,
0.011136272,
-0.0634951144,
-0.019827418,
0.0171998236,
0.0079958485,
-0.059797965,
0.0841434449,
0.0092694918,
0.003896028,
-0.0228375234,
0.0064609912,
-0.0126324687,
-0.0100581078,
0.0238587111,
-0.0190408248,
-0.0035346958,
-0.0020288171,
0.0161702391,
0.0140922619,
-0.0918170065,
-0.0153932935,
-0.0578264743,
0.0451499298,
-0.0315808766,
0.0010881949,
0.0342047475,
0.0285963994,
-0.0171442069,
-0.0455490425,
-0.0930486396,
0.014956913,
0.0252405796,
0.0192117728,
0.065355435,
0.0283238143,
0.0237148739,
-0.033416342,
-0.0058595482,
-0.0009230181,
0.0140482923,
-0.0153016318,
0.0324020721,
-0.0111027807,
0.0103077115,
-0.0403669067,
0.0324607976,
0.0246003475,
0.0148112085,
-0.0026265555,
-0.0540358275,
-0.0449532308,
0.0251251049,
0.0034816174,
-0.0085479226,
-0.0205842331,
0.0186419319,
-0.0379293412,
0.0591967851,
-0.0723358542,
0.0020005119,
0.0160294678,
-0.0138851516,
0.0055914256,
0.0306585059,
-0.00965265,
-0.0202659592,
-0.04825183,
0.0677895024,
0.0147984773,
-0.0014583261,
-0.0595752299,
0.0448223762,
0.0055693756,
0.0554872453,
-0.0353986025,
-0.0356696993,
0.0658598095,
0.0442347266,
-0.0143028265,
-0.0891452804,
-0.0083066821,
-0.0659550801,
0.0286412165,
-0.0280868132,
-0.0068600252,
0.0082036946,
-0.0169102736,
-0.0315298885,
-0.0321470462,
-0.0297827329,
-0.031527631,
0.012325651,
-0.0254095551,
0.000739687,
-0.008438725,
-0.0103090424,
-0.0658938438,
-0.0841554105,
-0.0135676619,
0.012171343,
-0.030429773,
0.0074825031,
-0.0319632813,
-0.0244780276,
0.0049575772,
0.0077919308,
-0.0300685931,
-0.0263600908,
-0.0255759638,
0.0557236634,
0.0833834857,
0.0834160969,
0.0364016816,
-0.0206500441,
0.0526145771,
0.0676970258,
0.0161441173,
0.0023587004,
0.0115868459,
0.0237744488,
0.0118925385,
-0.0224950276,
0.0332700014,
-0.0078882128,
0.056913238,
-0.0234400146,
-0.0413207188,
0.0762903094,
0.0715947673,
0.0009109423,
0.0056867423,
-0.01420426,
0.0224162359,
0.0236758031,
0.0446712039,
-0.0447942577,
-0.0468607768,
-0.0105514461,
0.0415396281,
-0.0289802942,
-0.0376810469,
0.0097502023,
-0.1069291383,
0.0512305237,
-0.032348156,
-0.0590084642,
-0.0194059424,
-0.0374440849,
0.0177235361,
0.0036635946,
-0.0081505682,
0.0162135847,
0.0092225969,
0.0224395432,
0.0409931652,
0.0004686719,
0.0048176078,
0.0528599918,
-0.0032241165,
0.0241635051,
0.0541310869,
0.013024535,
0.0032200441,
-0.0131428009,
-0.0158152469,
-0.0825422928,
-0.0185826868,
-0.0090597104,
0.0705204159,
0.0118116774,
-0.0276448764,
-0.0346707925,
0.0634341538,
-0.0316940397,
0.0123381158,
0.0554906987,
0.0791970417,
-0.0364815891,
0.0075099529,
-0.0121206064,
-0.0052839676,
0.0027186666,
0.0667421371,
0.034509901,
-0.0226509571,
-0.052693624,
-0.0053038346,
-0.0107226567,
-0.0845955983,
-0.0135022309,
0.0155972987,
0.0055374228,
0.0126392096,
-0.0569159426,
-0.0921863243,
0.0725348145,
0.0275061503,
-0.0334311388,
-0.0006985974,
-0.0012646521,
0.0315655731,
-0.025088327,
-0.0065030726,
-0.0253414847,
-0.0044578761,
-0.0300630666,
-0.0352007821,
0.0032904099,
-0.0431503542,
-0.0257523395,
-0.0058112298,
-0.0384487808,
-0.019667333,
0.001139226,
0.0352854282,
0.0258549098,
0.0020624262,
-0.0288673304,
-0.0174438898,
0.0048528295,
0.0318031833,
-0.0396772064,
-0.0163307339,
0.0067018839,
0.0001352479,
-0.0089025609,
0.0508042239,
-0.0658873767,
0.0347259752,
-0.0073088179,
0.0605604909,
-0.0629939511,
-0.0096030794,
0.0673750341,
0.0166215077,
-0.0320116207,
0.0612386838,
-0.0186620094,
-0.0298728831,
0.0279518273,
0.0065692072,
-0.0101157892,
-0.0272062868,
0.0221519992,
0.0170525964,
-0.0226046201,
0.0075367484,
-0.0079596331,
-0.0461168699,
0.0346884727,
-0.0264302623,
-0.0332439467,
0.0537379459,
0.004041519,
-0.0174679607,
-0.0386392586,
-0.0175687913,
0.0073152669,
0.0147953024,
0.088800326,
0.0158910584,
0.0501470789,
0.0278488379,
-0.0181857329,
-0.0243921485,
0.0119583281,
-0.1001645327,
-0.0387780331,
-0.0177895352,
0.0489725098,
0.0067513641,
0.0126196649,
-0.0325104408,
0.0252441876,
-0.0244142339,
0.0060822065,
-0.0349681564,
0.0403366014,
0.0063332543,
0.0614290945,
0.0391538478,
-0.0154395131,
0.0175309833,
0.0334620774,
-0.0249799453,
0.0469052494,
-0.003213098,
0.005833345,
-0.0485966578,
0.0111819822,
-0.0262500644,
-0.0023816817,
0.0030094839,
0.025606839,
-0.0398049541,
-0.0482776351,
-0.0066612968,
0.0280570947,
-0.0240719747,
-0.0172360037,
0.0281273313,
0.0592070632,
0.0233498681,
-0.0532385111,
-0.071081847,
0.0611201376,
-0.0380124673,
-0.0118160304,
-0.0035932229,
-7.001558798e-33,
-0.0101815099,
-0.0273705646,
0.0356777795,
-0.0336958431,
-0.0043966281,
0.0135876331,
-0.0333973765,
-0.024320133,
-0.0440509692,
-0.0055682031,
-0.0212378502,
0.0158206318,
-0.0041095358,
0.0211593416,
0.0111804837,
-0.0470131114,
0.0057187225,
-0.0058431355,
-0.0116163539,
0.0520022139,
0.0811040625,
0.0320005938,
-0.0149675738,
-0.0232037716,
0.0148729719,
-0.0718869418,
-0.0109119937,
0.0907657743,
-0.0369899645,
0.048727259,
-0.0169841368,
0.0274329036,
0.0312823914,
-0.0359430574,
0.0303755067,
0.0176570807,
-0.0941108838,
-0.0584246814,
-0.0154099325,
-0.0202271827,
-0.0705213845,
-0.0349712037,
0.0107605187,
-0.0022291462,
0.0549400449,
-0.0034214344,
0.0189857446,
0.0050990595,
0.0259560607,
0.0180987157,
-0.0229903199,
0.0073360493,
-0.0080257189,
-0.0409597494,
-0.0466113202,
0.0893185958,
0.0070633618,
0.0145221967,
-0.0469189249,
-0.0286779329,
0.0130913565,
0.0002790829,
0.0343500264,
0.0216478929,
-0.0226508901,
0.0202081576,
0.0208948795,
-0.0174233485,
-0.023496164,
0.0023819057,
-0.0304308571,
0.049382627,
0.0731058121,
0.0352723487,
0.0475345924,
0.0017659052,
-0.0411280356,
0.0807379708,
0.0070951744,
0.0296690706,
-0.0098437713,
-0.0306884833,
-0.0123333894,
-0.0069149383,
-0.0245834943,
0.0361693054,
-0.0355953909,
0.0028791984,
0.0471326746,
0.0120497998,
-0.0504256897,
0.0180532727,
0.01149817,
-0.0090116523,
0.0688606948,
0.0274396557,
-0.0186714306,
0.0236137006,
0.043270044,
0.0269073807,
-0.0520055331,
0.040058475,
0.0441512652,
-0.0024854974,
-0.0041758413,
0.0208803769,
0.0129298596,
0.0058883983,
-0.052617304,
-0.0012171543,
-0.0324246101,
0.0784299001,
-0.0461007059,
0.0084747747,
-0.0173315387,
0.0614944771,
-0.0110216141,
0.0029787738,
-0.0054910565,
0.0260382574,
-0.0568095483,
0.0272363387,
-0.0064700129,
0.0240043588,
-0.0356061645,
0.0140559059,
-0.0269663837,
0.032142736,
-0.043505881,
-0.0888522789,
-0.0039504552,
0.0382890627,
2.559e-7,
0.0517187268,
-0.0037374829,
0.0632982478,
0.0086699072,
0.0114063825,
0.0692899227,
0.0114051616,
0.0154667469,
0.0454792231,
-0.027426336,
0.0052320734,
0.0407777317,
0.0345797949,
0.0496922731,
-0.0549474917,
-0.0239537414,
-0.0250097122,
-0.0339235887,
-0.0422022492,
-0.0287339091,
0.0734030902,
0.0859029368,
0.0042064968,
-0.0276786517,
-0.010083993,
-0.0203905515,
0.0040598009,
0.0062685036,
-0.0035207393,
0.0069766669,
-0.0110592553,
0.0257779434,
0.0274634585,
0.0402066745,
-0.0179473888,
0.0313988887,
0.0293119643,
0.0340843834,
-0.0154220415,
-0.0784892887,
-0.0226807278,
-0.0113303233,
0.0389070623,
-0.0424166173,
0.1064131558,
-0.0337000862,
-0.0202694256,
-0.0051168632,
-0.0462161824,
0.0207632445,
0.0140493186,
0.012884303,
-0.0335477479,
0.0055591776,
0.0094214622,
-0.005796277,
0.0091552585,
-0.0503297821,
0.0322237909,
-0.016813552,
-0.0196374394,
-0.0307073351,
-0.0035739706,
0.0283759329,
-0.0230179597,
-0.0438415259,
0.005372005,
2.137827495e-34,
0.0207998157,
0.0195465926,
0.0150521854,
0.0256423559,
0.0094247106,
-0.0186643433,
-0.0105624599,
-0.0240075961,
0.0333710574,
-0.0963803381,
-0.0056188409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05086v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05086v2 | Neural-Hidden-CRF: A Robust Weakly-Supervised Sequence Labeler | 2023-09-10T17:13:25 | 2023-09-28T19:44:09 | Zhijun Chen, Hailong Sun, Wanhao Zhang, Chunyi Xu, Qianren Mao, Pengpeng Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We propose a neuralized undirected graphical model called Neural-Hidden-CRF
to solve the weakly-supervised sequence labeling problem. Under the umbrella of
probabilistic undirected graph theory, the proposed Neural-Hidden-CRF embedded
with a hidden CRF layer models the variables of word sequence, latent ground
truth sequence, and weak label sequence with the global perspective that
undirected graphical models particularly enjoy. In Neural-Hidden-CRF, we can
capitalize on the powerful language model BERT or other deep models to provide
rich contextual semantic knowledge to the latent ground truth sequence, and use
the hidden CRF layer to capture the internal label dependencies.
Neural-Hidden-CRF is conceptually simple and empirically powerful. It obtains
new state-of-the-art results on one crowdsourcing benchmark and three
weak-supervision benchmarks, including outperforming the recent advanced model
CHMM by 2.80 F1 points and 2.23 F1 points in average generalization and
inference performance, respectively. | [
0.0477032773,
0.0155949462,
0.0301146116,
0.0116301319,
-0.0439334586,
0.0287543274,
-0.0134823583,
-0.015187514,
0.0516210683,
-0.0169414189,
-0.0141270645,
-0.0062259845,
0.0092399726,
0.01342458,
0.0529987291,
-0.0220749397,
0.0190405976,
-0.0269788969,
0.0673859715,
0.0243482348,
0.0079696411,
-0.026233742,
0.0087152012,
0.0108714961,
-0.0679921731,
-0.0066319373,
-0.0440279804,
0.0044802339,
0.0003721071,
-0.073694557,
0.0164222158,
0.0533836409,
0.0230525397,
0.0481825434,
0.0000017927,
-0.0039791898,
-0.0607042462,
0.0075257854,
-0.0053041321,
-0.0094677452,
-0.0421431996,
-0.0179857295,
0.0041203243,
-0.0177299827,
-0.0157049522,
-0.0275211241,
0.0254545379,
0.0883631334,
0.0542078912,
0.0668084919,
-0.007778178,
-0.0503575504,
0.0171684269,
-0.0732876956,
-0.002216992,
-0.0907645598,
0.0225597769,
-0.0132625215,
0.0104801748,
-0.0253728162,
-0.0403096825,
0.0466045216,
0.0277976282,
-0.0374825224,
-0.0009154946,
0.0166648813,
-0.054963734,
-0.0203691944,
0.0221742559,
0.1231307387,
-0.0249542724,
0.0129363397,
0.0251023248,
-0.0082475478,
0.0215882063,
-0.0044638678,
-0.0388070308,
0.0276443288,
-0.0347800925,
0.0028850506,
-0.0084480289,
0.0045310617,
0.0638235137,
-0.0279126354,
0.0386886559,
0.0540928394,
0.0046494342,
-0.0269024987,
-0.0115826959,
-0.0043028891,
-0.0700728819,
-0.0189714786,
0.0760377198,
0.0195351318,
-0.0181401968,
0.0298728161,
-0.025911307,
-0.0364414789,
-0.0151736829,
-0.044128377,
0.0114031211,
-0.0079560829,
-0.0292885825,
0.0547235534,
-0.0430136062,
0.0268074069,
-0.0105575137,
0.0530793406,
0.0019911707,
0.0029157847,
-0.031587515,
-0.02354341,
-0.0356075875,
0.0780530423,
0.019567918,
-0.0486148857,
-0.0677588731,
0.0022346615,
-0.0004850658,
0.0167962424,
0.0417421721,
0.0473568887,
-0.0344134644,
0.0336909741,
0.0158023778,
0.0165929887,
-0.0296773445,
-0.0141275125,
0.0089459894,
-0.038688805,
0.010762942,
0.0352849029,
0.0456249677,
-0.0150806317,
-0.0115480991,
0.0869550258,
0.034140043,
-0.0660141185,
-0.0387450717,
-0.0358293764,
-0.0753403157,
0.0011297396,
0.0198069979,
-0.0505678952,
-0.003053837,
-0.0115840985,
0.0253918711,
-0.0270067975,
0.0254424699,
-0.019502487,
-0.0412140414,
0.055485785,
-0.0064598718,
-0.0401816964,
0.0109144105,
0.0163213164,
0.0138061978,
-0.0026708348,
0.0285837241,
0.0419007242,
0.0611889698,
-0.0045546172,
0.0226960313,
0.0286004804,
0.0431473516,
-0.0482910685,
-0.039106939,
-0.0439895019,
0.0105655901,
0.0063238218,
-0.0055058287,
0.0679207742,
-0.0067908354,
-0.0534223653,
0.0417080782,
0.0183139332,
0.0073956414,
-0.0265879594,
0.0301456191,
0.0035826664,
-0.0126092071,
0.0355843529,
-0.0282646809,
0.021892149,
-0.0154822832,
0.0534375012,
0.0305481963,
-0.0330562703,
-0.0241223741,
-0.0073878672,
0.0002006175,
-0.0258243773,
-0.0185558852,
-0.0172700975,
0.05079218,
0.0355708376,
-0.0495261401,
-0.0002405665,
0.0190058462,
-0.0263164695,
-0.0015937281,
0.0104347207,
0.0108163031,
0.0218042303,
0.0539912805,
-0.014884931,
-0.0533089675,
-0.0067293542,
0.0125453426,
0.0341433585,
0.005358723,
-0.0287116691,
-0.0023247842,
-0.0332484581,
-0.0629725978,
0.0123878019,
0.0018875579,
0.0439297333,
-0.0232444406,
-0.0429146402,
0.0328640044,
-0.0348912701,
-0.0386665985,
0.008128765,
0.0120082889,
-0.0398297384,
0.0152226519,
0.0226666573,
0.0413393602,
0.0592483245,
-0.0042121476,
0.0538492911,
0.041366823,
-0.0252615623,
-0.0300151389,
-0.0305182897,
-0.0826226771,
-0.0833645537,
0.0348386131,
-0.0403616354,
-0.0474484377,
0.0059271865,
-0.0300245751,
-0.0570924096,
0.0099643869,
-0.0553280264,
0.0225472134,
-0.0054948814,
-0.0039861482,
0.0478764772,
-0.0098515917,
-0.0047693788,
0.0649601892,
-0.0251789074,
0.0247199591,
0.0154416487,
0.0222953036,
-0.0228598211,
-0.0660306662,
-0.0296455547,
0.022037629,
0.0048952266,
-0.0410559513,
0.0389668345,
0.0040023415,
-0.0387270488,
-0.0245028343,
-0.0232749749,
-0.01574005,
-0.0034707303,
-0.0056124814,
-0.0052949237,
0.0079957247,
0.0257369857,
-0.0570630953,
-0.0602067076,
0.0271268748,
0.0082033854,
0.0063094478,
0.0219089799,
0.0359197482,
-0.0103091709,
-0.0417920239,
-0.0272130501,
-0.0213982873,
0.046283599,
0.0516465046,
-0.0674843565,
-0.0121317152,
-0.0091753164,
-0.0228267685,
0.030450331,
-0.0172724314,
0.0087756449,
0.0076806825,
-0.0263114199,
0.0148433074,
-0.0022061076,
-0.0312109087,
0.0257554576,
-0.0040089707,
-0.0404777043,
0.0072163758,
-0.002364611,
-0.0736603215,
-0.0018062067,
-0.0153578715,
-0.0052539143,
-0.0472918078,
0.0906239003,
-0.0123413745,
0.0307765026,
-0.0411560573,
-0.029678287,
0.0053415066,
-0.016709337,
-0.0333402716,
-0.0093704043,
-0.0100907637,
-0.0447481461,
-0.053647656,
-0.0317824855,
0.0746469349,
-0.0455806628,
0.002716009,
0.0022466003,
-0.0120887719,
-0.0359196588,
0.0449807122,
0.0420024097,
0.0003960892,
0.0142398244,
-0.0612456128,
-0.0234560594,
-0.0112301428,
0.0250349995,
-0.0318966955,
-0.0179641489,
-0.0308627114,
0.0143240374,
-0.004706989,
0.009030425,
-0.0201969706,
-0.0024637971,
-0.0083829109,
0.0347636417,
0.0314915515,
-0.0270072538,
-0.0274131913,
0.0455449633,
0.004323307,
0.0632792264,
-0.0248385128,
0.0270560104,
-0.0393728614,
0.0849390402,
0.0639664978,
-0.0526220798,
-0.0259342548,
-0.035359025,
-0.002098969,
0.0230667554,
0.0026532186,
0.0220267009,
0.0061934292,
0.0177923292,
-0.0237917956,
0.0200973898,
-0.0442636423,
0.0123410085,
-0.0221462231,
-0.0320231877,
-0.0180105884,
0.1090456843,
0.0205408614,
-0.0761281922,
-0.002543903,
0.0268925782,
0.0248631369,
0.02407833,
-0.0108116493,
-0.0231729932,
-0.0261391345,
0.0061485777,
0.0713672861,
0.0294600204,
-0.0820310935,
0.0069715851,
-0.0881082937,
-0.0086908014,
-0.0058898898,
-0.0283897836,
-0.0215705149,
-0.0640545562,
0.0017717534,
0.0399209447,
-0.0105620548,
-0.0102347583,
0.0392307937,
0.0112639172,
0.0579718798,
-0.0191057269,
-0.047457315,
-0.0110653443,
-0.0396649837,
0.0172265079,
0.0339641608,
0.0093652457,
-0.0036218555,
-0.0083212862,
0.0457162745,
0.0078210784,
-0.0063233534,
-0.0272608921,
0.0398181826,
-0.0476896092,
-0.0373019502,
-0.0373945907,
0.0184119809,
-0.0303060804,
0.0194341727,
-0.0299792401,
0.0652961656,
0.0282613412,
-0.0248178132,
0.0045953379,
-0.0059968936,
-0.0039348765,
0.0492699854,
0.0393066369,
-0.0192318074,
-0.0000943827,
-0.0057754344,
0.057728108,
-0.0407915637,
-0.0199084282,
0.0090347677,
-0.0112918094,
-0.0585588925,
-0.0675233975,
-0.0499744676,
0.0517592877,
0.0446447209,
-0.001191073,
0.0130028389,
0.0564423203,
-0.0275153536,
-0.0538354032,
0.0020174526,
-0.005864956,
-0.0067376061,
-0.0769096091,
-0.0189513378,
0.0394128226,
0.0253432058,
-0.0076607391,
0.0470207892,
-0.0318921283,
-0.0559699237,
-0.0123773776,
0.0451294072,
0.003822716,
0.0295933019,
-0.0040663821,
-0.025253538,
0.0073359371,
0.0663008913,
-0.0038101459,
-0.0039836802,
0.0202080663,
-0.0328213945,
-0.0273746382,
0.0099808099,
-0.0831344202,
-0.0027866259,
0.0379482023,
0.0989261717,
-0.0016366238,
-0.0543239638,
0.0214913841,
0.0108407298,
0.0936314613,
-0.0046158722,
0.0217639599,
-0.0406514145,
0.0067012133,
0.0072382651,
-0.0451371148,
-0.0142584201,
0.0173683427,
0.0210664533,
0.0078615136,
0.0120254969,
0.0078565115,
0.0159737691,
0.0597761907,
-0.0318104811,
0.0087373499,
0.0237104595,
-0.0043118638,
-0.0261393692,
-0.0049819062,
0.0112024713,
0.0098548988,
0.0152331935,
0.0118012959,
-0.0080675632,
0.0256009474,
0.0234610513,
0.004527031,
0.0054997825,
-0.0031697729,
-0.0444075465,
0.0569268838,
-0.039295733,
0.058489792,
0.0416825637,
0.0031982535,
0.012768019,
0.0026056429,
-0.0160250999,
-0.0391863994,
0.0472654924,
0.0102474904,
-0.0629285872,
0.0396987796,
0.0421701968,
-0.014784174,
0.0488669239,
0.0779425427,
0.073968783,
0.0352079831,
-0.0078714481,
-0.0494527221,
-0.0452815741,
-0.0133623863,
0.0580468625,
0.0377070643,
-0.024810683,
0.0389579609,
-0.0109434137,
-0.0671908334,
0.0556699969,
-0.0058995392,
0.0212707371,
0.0508112423,
0.0363327116,
0.0164616071,
0.0056398399,
-0.0291695651,
-0.042762354,
0.0659817979,
0.018883191,
-0.0356538892,
0.0090080155,
-6.063948872e-33,
-0.0388777703,
-0.083859928,
-0.0260423329,
-0.0197055191,
0.015602937,
0.0545990951,
-0.0775013342,
0.0178866554,
0.0274288151,
0.0188683774,
-0.0069817225,
0.0112086525,
0.0155347558,
0.0534505285,
-0.0236500446,
-0.0308194589,
0.0421152413,
0.0017907419,
0.0101658199,
0.0352101289,
0.026732441,
0.0845107436,
0.0723752975,
-0.1077959985,
0.0459853783,
-0.0264690239,
0.0282231644,
-0.0019804025,
0.0408223011,
0.060613852,
-0.0262786578,
-0.0125714038,
0.0141343866,
0.0078369305,
0.0185946524,
0.0182379447,
-0.1115118191,
-0.0148224887,
-0.0361894444,
0.0076458827,
-0.0510056429,
-0.0112877181,
0.0164062101,
0.0026372941,
0.0596183315,
0.0237432905,
0.0552300811,
0.0018252919,
-0.0431021266,
-0.0500748716,
-0.0118106622,
0.0627855211,
-0.0102313459,
0.0158372317,
0.0066935075,
0.0156737901,
-0.0009697137,
0.0425940342,
-0.0557288863,
0.006242373,
-0.019230647,
0.0326535963,
0.0285550281,
0.0755869746,
0.0018396832,
0.0165299792,
0.0023574776,
-0.017399054,
0.0112265199,
-0.0007035298,
-0.0189005453,
0.0245057531,
0.0647017434,
0.0314640291,
-0.0160587002,
0.0171398837,
-0.0613512248,
-0.0085258875,
0.0287899785,
-0.0104308808,
0.0121582597,
0.0383175686,
-0.0360141769,
-0.0183295514,
-0.0124142822,
-0.0386214368,
-0.0327372886,
0.017567303,
0.0322834738,
0.0260690488,
-0.0456750169,
0.0239552092,
0.0038171336,
-0.026824832,
-0.0443840027,
0.0316775106,
0.0327504463,
0.0277703945,
-0.0235542599,
0.004883281,
-0.0599183254,
-0.0207655653,
0.0277473554,
-0.0200749319,
0.0170972869,
-0.0150410486,
0.0924597085,
0.0178793743,
-0.0197096858,
-0.0127067296,
-0.0194973573,
-0.0165265538,
0.0061628986,
-0.0043812804,
0.0377095081,
-0.0390200242,
-0.035156969,
0.0704549029,
0.0213541742,
0.0426628962,
0.0229134224,
-0.0120958919,
-0.003317765,
0.0163589381,
-0.0209346171,
-0.0338329561,
0.0160776377,
0.0731607154,
0.0390492938,
-0.0637536421,
0.0059006275,
0.0008067357,
2.684e-7,
0.0346776918,
-0.0120404121,
0.0746835172,
-0.0309982281,
0.0159035306,
0.025663482,
-0.0443483889,
0.0319898725,
-0.0442459136,
-0.0486012436,
0.0360007919,
-0.0242138188,
-0.0198365785,
-0.0178387333,
-0.0712813511,
-0.0122512076,
-0.097538352,
-0.0017634406,
-0.0032030442,
0.0255015045,
0.0460292138,
0.1104428843,
0.0107942428,
-0.0012973791,
-0.0422854684,
-0.076752618,
0.0241491999,
0.0361863598,
0.0137618324,
-0.0405184478,
0.0336974487,
-0.0089061484,
-0.0374179408,
0.0169627666,
-0.0082853744,
0.0025031106,
0.0626600087,
0.0485897288,
0.0066343774,
-0.0264177453,
0.0117287207,
0.0263359509,
0.0144501915,
0.0067810542,
0.0606554821,
-0.0471157506,
-0.0549902022,
0.0321088843,
-0.0593208633,
-0.014117348,
-0.0273354333,
-0.0129061174,
-0.0143064205,
0.0090056984,
0.0242121052,
-0.024784591,
-0.0030191634,
-0.0839282051,
0.0253721029,
-0.0062290062,
-0.0088514257,
0.002842387,
-0.0434077792,
0.0266435016,
0.0173733886,
0.0133929653,
0.0036954638,
2.460880434e-34,
0.0371812917,
-0.0011330519,
-0.0334196649,
-0.0442500226,
0.0140644256,
-0.0435520522,
-0.0501130484,
0.024086792,
0.0259633549,
-0.0716552585,
-0.0510693602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05076v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05076v1 | An Appraisal-Based Chain-Of-Emotion Architecture for Affective Language Model Game Agents | 2023-09-10T16:55:49 | 2023-09-10T16:55:49 | Maximilian Croissant, Madeleine Frister, Guy Schofield, Cade McCall | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | The development of believable, natural, and interactive digital artificial
agents is a field of growing interest. Theoretical uncertainties and technical
barriers present considerable challenges to the field, particularly with
regards to developing agents that effectively simulate human emotions. Large
language models (LLMs) might address these issues by tapping common patterns in
situational appraisal. In three empirical experiments, this study tests the
capabilities of LLMs to solve emotional intelligence tasks and to simulate
emotions. It presents and evaluates a new chain-of-emotion architecture for
emotion simulation within video games, based on psychological appraisal
research. Results show that it outperforms standard LLM architectures on a
range of user experience and content analysis metrics. This study therefore
provides early evidence of how to construct and test affective agents based on
cognitive processes represented in language models. | [
0.0588251464,
0.0241528563,
-0.0482560992,
0.0463897847,
-0.0044777165,
0.0110535938,
0.0163935479,
-0.0331939757,
0.0521573871,
-0.024639966,
-0.0776542276,
-0.0052908058,
-0.0303323064,
0.0334807783,
0.0046828534,
-0.0733036399,
-0.0010583788,
0.007408326,
0.0874398649,
0.0072557442,
-0.0020498487,
0.0264944937,
-0.0342661999,
0.027757166,
-0.0170633383,
-0.0473648086,
-0.0348062702,
0.0267192312,
0.0333447158,
-0.0951378942,
0.0064008455,
-0.0357957222,
0.008551104,
-0.0222630706,
0.000002036,
-0.0419991426,
0.0318460315,
-0.0009513021,
0.0241830312,
0.0053941188,
0.1333150268,
0.0509471484,
-0.0114153,
-0.009436762,
-0.0106114382,
-0.0034806428,
0.0486502945,
0.0210183375,
0.0896611512,
0.0304774214,
-0.0332110077,
-0.0103782229,
-0.0200447794,
0.01428062,
0.0005390506,
-0.0212774426,
-0.0264610145,
0.0223091859,
0.0603745095,
-0.0483024903,
-0.0060570161,
-0.0148964487,
-0.0019066598,
0.0090516042,
-0.018860139,
0.0153348846,
0.0320203304,
-0.0287244841,
-0.0207918417,
0.0425533094,
0.0020761101,
0.0397870503,
0.0001706433,
-0.002445942,
0.043885041,
-0.0229497943,
0.004320866,
0.0230267327,
-0.0238115378,
0.0000297389,
-0.0044373306,
0.0624912158,
0.0189294964,
0.0128086563,
0.0164151527,
0.0279237665,
-0.0152487224,
-0.0307364129,
0.0056267949,
-0.0017908008,
0.0078468109,
-0.0050298171,
-0.0063766693,
0.0206758771,
-0.031259317,
0.0120556178,
-0.0288586095,
0.0173665825,
-0.0272355806,
-0.0753737986,
0.0048630303,
0.0321819894,
-0.0276899021,
0.0208907183,
0.0046875258,
0.0753536597,
0.0371731259,
-0.0358199999,
-0.0261112992,
0.0376614742,
-0.041522339,
0.0152486991,
0.0001627567,
0.0541600101,
-0.034752138,
-0.0555422716,
-0.0517996326,
0.0139173698,
-0.0591346212,
0.0068024658,
-0.0014718885,
0.0176346842,
0.0430880226,
0.0559369624,
-0.0668420345,
-0.0089705531,
-0.0632402375,
0.0285805967,
0.0159368943,
-0.0500739478,
0.039093174,
0.0066266721,
-0.0075287009,
0.0003770772,
0.0528508686,
0.0607134067,
0.0316144973,
-0.0297565497,
-0.0317958221,
0.0091733849,
0.013055956,
-0.0378625952,
-0.0047826683,
-0.0249242596,
0.0440902822,
-0.0221559238,
0.0233959518,
-0.0165349338,
0.0174041223,
-0.0041209548,
-0.0023948287,
0.0366187096,
-0.0233351719,
-0.0045563783,
-0.0202953033,
-0.0036222152,
-0.0049538468,
0.0198681485,
0.0403814316,
0.0536518246,
0.0196603853,
0.0219640769,
0.0507384725,
0.0115078818,
-0.0606100373,
-0.0213683862,
0.0012369325,
-0.0518206954,
-0.0478130654,
0.076667279,
0.0482401736,
0.0530830845,
-0.0285985544,
-0.0090716453,
0.0514477082,
0.0375723504,
-0.016642496,
0.0544092581,
0.0391949266,
0.0213961471,
0.0407106653,
-0.0144129619,
-0.0133870523,
0.0763047412,
0.0015860224,
-0.013799143,
-0.0714747757,
0.0336888507,
-0.0275420062,
-0.0512961969,
0.0159128234,
-0.0151578374,
0.0502582267,
0.0197583921,
-0.0139993001,
-0.0378980599,
-0.0548767373,
-0.0435348414,
0.0016044837,
-0.0932793766,
0.0284393206,
-0.0713105574,
-0.0048968601,
0.1387711316,
0.0125155812,
-0.022770606,
-0.0027857698,
0.0209550876,
-0.0664231926,
0.0527918749,
0.0172202066,
-0.014799431,
0.0079381382,
-0.017338682,
0.0147138359,
-0.0476189665,
0.0085354438,
0.0316434577,
-0.0762725174,
0.0399838388,
-0.032776814,
0.0226133931,
0.0011782483,
-0.0021127642,
-0.0157096796,
-0.0352411419,
-0.0326575525,
0.0021150268,
0.0309512727,
0.0266990326,
-0.0131930867,
-0.0080627948,
0.009021813,
0.0113289198,
-0.0307137445,
0.0426715836,
0.0198990609,
0.0031508137,
0.043094188,
-0.0036429057,
0.0200879276,
0.0090726512,
0.025642585,
0.0213500429,
0.0447516851,
-0.0259738918,
0.0556709543,
0.0050568604,
0.0372522175,
-0.0365589261,
0.0367499143,
0.0131959599,
0.013925002,
-0.0152296266,
-0.0283564068,
-0.0157026425,
0.0005135271,
-0.0175696854,
-0.0144185945,
-0.0228936486,
0.0054796329,
0.0244953558,
0.0145166209,
0.0100957155,
-0.026745636,
-0.0612994991,
-0.0671521425,
-0.0882620662,
-0.0291918945,
0.0372710712,
0.0055473838,
0.0051570134,
-0.0289933141,
-0.0243479293,
0.0200259276,
-0.0337431505,
0.0052562668,
0.0261649694,
-0.0000808599,
0.001808324,
-0.0042431634,
-0.0360996947,
-0.0581339337,
0.010916505,
-0.0255649444,
0.0247267056,
-0.002190595,
0.0067171562,
-0.017147515,
0.0356062315,
-0.0743934736,
0.0336139463,
-0.0190629754,
-0.0966919288,
0.0570853353,
0.0147251422,
0.020048961,
0.0503614433,
-0.0037543846,
0.0681653544,
0.066034615,
-0.0541596152,
-0.0389852412,
0.0352466144,
0.0210333001,
0.0115533564,
-0.0342451707,
-0.0369812995,
0.0169586167,
0.0626624599,
0.0130213145,
0.0397983566,
-0.0539680086,
0.0450015478,
0.0131956665,
-0.0502083115,
0.0293447673,
-0.0762819201,
-0.0073079439,
-0.0080796592,
0.0081829205,
0.011614277,
0.0412633643,
-0.0204518195,
-0.011352648,
-0.0390766896,
0.0254177116,
0.0101696141,
0.0626597553,
-0.0450161695,
0.0001496664,
-0.0031924667,
0.0379676484,
-0.0058203642,
-0.0452788919,
-0.0285393335,
-0.0535803661,
-0.0175080132,
-0.0436999314,
-0.0465252623,
0.0589386448,
-0.0077469745,
0.0135750175,
-0.0019250959,
-0.0698017925,
-0.019164525,
0.0039724843,
-0.0101849213,
-0.0579253696,
-0.0207589772,
0.0644772649,
-0.0572701171,
-0.0124101955,
-0.0391702466,
0.0103552788,
-0.0304648839,
0.0873202309,
0.0126126427,
0.0554681756,
-0.0125372959,
0.0655508563,
0.0239993818,
0.0246568639,
-0.0217918362,
-0.0186011195,
0.0268670395,
0.0068137697,
0.010850477,
-0.0161315575,
0.0134128556,
-0.007919265,
-0.0301975831,
0.0322167166,
0.1092941985,
0.0270059686,
-0.0416821688,
0.0275786947,
-0.0198393632,
-0.0159867946,
0.024662951,
0.0211802088,
-0.0319937691,
-0.0045731096,
-0.0015922956,
0.0180241261,
-0.0514446124,
-0.0445093662,
0.02770078,
-0.0971075818,
0.0036472396,
-0.0160280224,
0.0219432302,
0.0022220043,
0.0189810712,
0.0138588799,
0.0243829098,
-0.0171874315,
-0.0186817963,
0.0271665957,
-0.0134165511,
0.0060471911,
-0.0373347327,
-0.0035631259,
0.0535917394,
-0.0206751209,
0.0631019697,
0.0544009171,
0.0926083401,
-0.032515619,
-0.0481409952,
-0.0292706713,
0.0248060822,
0.0315536782,
0.0028778664,
0.022179747,
-0.0184808783,
0.0024221011,
-0.0635069013,
-0.030058533,
-0.0031843102,
0.0032051969,
0.0010884329,
0.0542797334,
-0.022388041,
-0.0418444574,
-0.0451323353,
0.0296924971,
0.027711207,
0.0281961318,
-0.0141745079,
-0.0911439359,
0.0012199869,
0.0204777233,
0.0238743834,
-0.0070027113,
-0.0692287087,
-0.0166669972,
0.0135140093,
0.0167419109,
-0.0501256287,
-0.081616126,
-0.0396361686,
0.023610035,
-0.0266520008,
-0.0297276117,
0.0251601171,
0.0064003733,
0.024066709,
-0.0027740849,
0.0248838793,
0.0072753979,
0.0122445831,
-0.0039933277,
0.0421183482,
-0.0667758062,
0.038397532,
-0.004497963,
0.0500071011,
0.0211528558,
0.0669756457,
0.0814961269,
0.0118393833,
-0.024532849,
0.0221062675,
-0.0312673561,
-0.0128980018,
-0.0187445134,
-0.0624159239,
0.0250385143,
0.0036915771,
0.0632962435,
0.0196860023,
-0.0177904908,
-0.0484155193,
0.048324734,
0.0102394689,
0.0237796474,
-0.0024917109,
-0.0487853028,
-0.0004144527,
0.0350450762,
0.0014703935,
-0.0261222124,
-0.0288325641,
0.0071260887,
-0.0072137285,
-0.081849426,
-0.002365093,
-0.0383968949,
-0.0296203736,
-0.0148103572,
0.0425438322,
-0.0259689093,
-0.0488250665,
-0.0020693897,
-0.0274892393,
0.0182256103,
0.0671789274,
0.0425957851,
0.0016214617,
-0.0327162184,
0.0241259858,
-0.0051001958,
0.0073805768,
-0.0279363636,
0.006197683,
0.005724743,
0.0647936761,
-0.0155301848,
-0.0659306049,
-0.0099375425,
0.0549932308,
-0.003768994,
0.0404330455,
0.0284782853,
0.0069897859,
-0.0084609063,
0.0158805065,
0.0367472991,
-0.0421616696,
0.0437822752,
-0.0075027267,
-0.030583946,
-0.0212998148,
-0.0732006654,
-0.0161319505,
0.0235799905,
-0.0118317418,
-0.0598362386,
-0.0274686348,
-0.0649644732,
0.0245673861,
-0.024361711,
-0.0366366282,
-0.0323696248,
0.0004596712,
0.0005526504,
-0.0207475033,
-0.0173290502,
0.0050968779,
-0.1178069413,
-0.0423255935,
0.0078842277,
0.0193045698,
0.0396452993,
-0.0730849206,
0.0180629492,
0.0407099351,
0.0111496216,
0.0161093734,
-0.0379018895,
-0.0139840767,
-0.0955725238,
-0.0031436081,
-0.0184691306,
-5.384034858e-33,
-0.0023477857,
0.0013688748,
0.0218687542,
-0.004031261,
-0.0589393191,
0.0142887589,
-0.046950262,
0.0075824135,
-0.011143473,
0.0280582011,
-0.0239838231,
-0.004405749,
-0.0019576338,
-0.0342201702,
0.0079118824,
0.0101257339,
0.0373970829,
-0.0043251514,
-0.017328335,
0.0004668226,
0.0074612652,
-0.0247800332,
0.0095234197,
-0.0960273966,
0.0283833705,
0.0104551595,
-0.0375965349,
-0.0073061902,
0.0536116697,
0.0356394574,
0.0008875853,
0.0253784731,
0.0273129251,
0.0166815426,
0.0309848413,
-0.004316872,
0.0062545198,
-0.0164856408,
-0.0063287169,
-0.003510969,
-0.0045131221,
-0.0206718016,
-0.0063294009,
0.0257325619,
-0.0703181177,
-0.0103125554,
0.0238291901,
-0.0180734266,
0.0364363007,
-0.0391169004,
-0.070619531,
-0.0115674641,
-0.001642975,
-0.0181122553,
0.0112327272,
0.052818004,
-0.0400562584,
-0.0028262443,
-0.0342704467,
0.0005368444,
-0.0271779466,
-0.0292304233,
0.0171454251,
0.0066407267,
0.0389400274,
0.0729026571,
0.0347024314,
0.05839343,
-0.0731993392,
0.0531981401,
0.0539759174,
0.0123780016,
0.0681671947,
0.0489693843,
-0.0268092081,
-0.0426247008,
0.0254533067,
0.0503573641,
0.0660445243,
0.0276170187,
0.0738692135,
0.0342799947,
-0.0342612565,
0.0250171125,
-0.0013490107,
0.0068842634,
-0.0209586434,
-0.0627226606,
0.0227316171,
-0.0325417109,
0.0265507847,
-0.0751088485,
-0.0054485267,
-0.0031539514,
-0.0083371624,
0.0090921894,
-0.013360111,
0.0801600739,
-0.0091865705,
-0.0015109348,
0.026315406,
0.0106992032,
0.011916819,
0.0410619639,
0.0519443341,
0.0097633703,
-0.0788341314,
0.0736953393,
-0.026399821,
-0.0128302975,
-0.0063335607,
0.0420241505,
0.025541842,
-0.034730535,
-0.0459298417,
-0.0173924025,
-0.0135092344,
-0.0391965397,
-0.0296943504,
-0.0021549331,
0.0036510872,
0.0050049964,
-0.0274691731,
0.0242741872,
-0.057127282,
-0.0081241457,
-0.0274645742,
-0.0036653625,
-0.0204665624,
-0.0422206745,
-0.0311188642,
0.0023779424,
2.93e-7,
-0.0625443012,
0.0462088287,
-0.0037667262,
-0.0055316952,
0.0061609456,
0.0619595572,
-0.0178792197,
0.0006750917,
0.0523504913,
-0.0568556972,
0.0488629378,
0.0337751992,
0.0302248448,
0.0093248403,
-0.0823409632,
0.0067398599,
0.0171174798,
0.0265161432,
0.0085559366,
0.0390146859,
0.0848212391,
0.0179898404,
0.0495711565,
-0.0207185857,
0.0122642657,
0.0604323559,
-0.0158291422,
-0.0300229099,
0.0029965085,
-0.0089105349,
-0.0172777735,
-0.0383657366,
-0.002620694,
0.0029267846,
0.0286867768,
0.0027850699,
0.0054508643,
0.035680294,
-0.0146210836,
-0.0209930576,
0.0427109823,
0.0272713192,
-0.0291456822,
-0.0280599706,
0.0002837264,
-0.004546253,
-0.0288946051,
-0.0336829461,
-0.0708736852,
-0.0089582792,
-0.0330145881,
-0.0442360304,
-0.0575071871,
0.0088463984,
-0.0229397099,
-0.0256827548,
-0.0159842763,
-0.0290963855,
0.0383983105,
0.0175027754,
-0.0071339477,
-0.0378656313,
-0.0416673385,
0.0507242493,
0.0170086231,
-0.0490918867,
0.0196747109,
2.01118956e-34,
-0.0026933388,
0.0060638795,
-0.0030997824,
-0.0137350336,
0.0639605746,
0.0392374806,
-0.0184920654,
0.0064012483,
0.0704971105,
-0.0470602512,
0.0168122724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05044v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05044v1 | The Effect of Alignment Objectives on Code-Switching Translation | 2023-09-10T14:46:31 | 2023-09-10T14:46:31 | Mohamed Anwar | cs.CL | cs.CL | One of the things that need to change when it comes to machine translation is
the models' ability to translate code-switching content, especially with the
rise of social media and user-generated content. In this paper, we are
proposing a way of training a single machine translation model that is able to
translate monolingual sentences from one language to another, along with
translating code-switched sentences to either language. This model can be
considered a bilingual model in the human sense. For better use of parallel
data, we generated synthetic code-switched (CSW) data along with an alignment
loss on the encoder to align representations across languages. Using the WMT14
English-French (En-Fr) dataset, the trained model strongly outperforms
bidirectional baselines on code-switched translation while maintaining quality
for non-code-switched (monolingual) data. | [
-0.0099424999,
0.04437856,
0.0074758059,
0.0600895919,
-0.0372300632,
0.035761293,
0.0202683639,
-0.0287153367,
-0.0167349428,
-0.0143250767,
-0.0365893766,
-0.0393099487,
0.0056666168,
-0.0058496301,
0.0462595597,
-0.0020590243,
0.0504859053,
0.012426055,
-0.0546545833,
-0.0074599292,
0.0328897797,
0.039837651,
0.0084115332,
-0.0089183664,
-0.0052930182,
-0.024745604,
0.0040519312,
0.0741498098,
0.0632005557,
-0.0128063988,
0.027414849,
0.0262536258,
0.0171039458,
0.0594265796,
0.0000018172,
0.0052194721,
-0.0510186106,
-0.0022087488,
0.009081169,
-0.0045351307,
0.0249564331,
-0.0910333097,
-0.0308214109,
0.0426827967,
-0.0248497613,
-0.0021149565,
0.0816572383,
-0.0214367975,
0.0622405261,
0.1060142443,
-0.0259752721,
-0.0577130802,
-0.018122429,
-0.0525746942,
-0.0350103453,
-0.0237966441,
-0.0084806103,
-0.0194140449,
-0.068832621,
0.0100521836,
-0.0325108841,
0.0514217466,
0.0265180338,
0.0133982478,
-0.0152608696,
-0.0223963428,
-0.0280835461,
-0.0103133712,
-0.0001629873,
0.0572382249,
-0.05937187,
-0.0368927754,
0.0051821577,
-0.0207354501,
-0.0096815685,
-0.0437032841,
-0.0229505152,
0.0003496166,
0.007101384,
0.0291581266,
0.0035732468,
0.0225138236,
0.051130604,
-0.0338704102,
-0.0596294664,
-0.0151653793,
0.0273977742,
-0.0339084454,
-0.0038608529,
0.0103144832,
0.0370682031,
0.0120105632,
0.0226465743,
-0.0268729106,
-0.0102879778,
0.0202884842,
-0.0526969284,
-0.0609875172,
0.0068562198,
-0.0870361328,
0.0084006079,
0.0518065616,
-0.0159753356,
0.0298449807,
-0.0106266402,
0.065411441,
-0.0392385833,
0.0333698653,
-0.0455071256,
-0.0086753285,
-0.0301852897,
0.0114736212,
-0.0371474288,
-0.0420401208,
-0.0222409535,
-0.0054437718,
-0.0169190448,
0.0188557785,
0.0038179925,
0.0103138229,
0.0355164595,
-0.0365264863,
-0.0487231389,
0.0036294353,
0.0526026227,
0.0750920922,
0.0036169756,
-0.0238220859,
0.0016996627,
-0.0600562468,
-0.019635994,
0.0134849418,
-0.0013319283,
-0.0453598984,
-0.0092465887,
0.084514603,
-0.0407307632,
0.009675391,
-0.0100016119,
0.0231066123,
-0.0185410101,
-0.0519659668,
-0.0101226848,
-0.0751387179,
0.0812425986,
0.0362915657,
0.0315814354,
-0.0775060654,
0.0048268726,
-0.0112480046,
-0.0136984307,
0.075348556,
-0.0255208146,
0.0020319808,
0.0253987927,
-0.0388341397,
0.0074961525,
0.1159343719,
0.04080851,
-0.0036697579,
0.0514821187,
-0.033005245,
-0.0289819855,
0.0616489463,
0.0146876369,
0.0183992162,
-0.0159845352,
-0.0030387824,
0.0578906238,
0.0383322947,
0.0456345417,
0.0439653806,
-0.0134287039,
0.001880691,
0.0290881861,
-0.040630307,
0.0125776334,
0.0427128598,
0.0449743718,
0.0279953163,
-0.0230662953,
0.0057259961,
0.0002072758,
0.0455775894,
0.0105614113,
-0.0207336545,
0.0336224884,
0.0306791645,
-0.0410690159,
-0.0102981292,
0.0110058701,
-0.0288158488,
0.0596366599,
-0.0518289581,
0.0047601047,
-0.0105705243,
-0.0581994206,
0.0524559394,
-0.0108781327,
-0.0581412576,
0.020873623,
0.0151838148,
-0.0657915175,
0.0771566331,
-0.0061248466,
0.0309418831,
-0.0254430249,
-0.0226446837,
-0.0052741012,
0.0412473716,
0.0567231737,
0.0163554829,
0.026463706,
-0.0575539954,
-0.0174065214,
-0.0163183287,
-0.0179426447,
0.0189779177,
0.0212042257,
0.0416793637,
0.0245538633,
-0.0008815276,
-0.0626453906,
0.0195011683,
-0.0304192174,
0.0277577545,
-0.0049511613,
0.0264472198,
0.0199796911,
0.004928845,
-0.0140349008,
-0.0027968637,
0.0150513556,
-0.0242481418,
-0.0131164733,
0.045819331,
-0.0126397116,
-0.0551124215,
0.0225811601,
-0.0838717669,
-0.0158513002,
0.064867802,
-0.0513940006,
-0.0358943939,
-0.0067588221,
-0.031784717,
0.0169786587,
-0.0195308644,
0.0384683199,
0.001839795,
-0.0049201208,
-0.014183322,
0.0088727446,
-0.0011399266,
0.0202226881,
-0.0234497767,
-0.0324637592,
0.0465214513,
-0.0087525435,
-0.0025670831,
0.0334818847,
-0.002426977,
0.0334100984,
0.0215974338,
0.0118586123,
-0.0270223897,
-0.0319402926,
-0.0616158471,
0.0246838257,
-0.0463562198,
0.031066861,
0.0509616509,
0.03232475,
0.0046756058,
-0.0279703569,
-0.0472443998,
0.0125365928,
-0.0170127563,
0.0249057524,
0.0234796181,
-0.0185242333,
0.0258153938,
-0.0323188044,
0.0044481102,
0.0105881095,
0.0169069953,
-0.0154362665,
-0.0264400095,
-0.0743686035,
0.0257698875,
-0.0132654849,
-0.0061416291,
-0.0009503685,
-0.0763077661,
0.0026820758,
0.0163814835,
0.0431183949,
0.0309255887,
0.0226760563,
0.0073607215,
0.0016288211,
0.0214065611,
-0.0556256659,
0.0001870549,
0.0088641876,
-0.0666323081,
-0.0507086106,
-0.0490043536,
0.0207669251,
0.0435884781,
-0.0033218104,
0.0316575095,
-0.0843386129,
-0.0600948595,
0.0140874712,
-0.0142741865,
0.0123292813,
0.0234752074,
-0.0002899859,
0.0411697291,
-0.049150411,
-0.0370371975,
0.0315166935,
-0.0049716309,
-0.0042287409,
-0.0422696099,
0.0056131124,
-0.0239387713,
0.0120478785,
-0.0069660144,
0.0342641138,
-0.0345873125,
-0.0189991873,
-0.0354785994,
0.0198699739,
0.022280423,
-0.0223349966,
-0.0025741865,
-0.027002994,
0.0059940037,
-0.0266024154,
-0.0575965643,
-0.0107285967,
-0.0138222463,
-0.0029072445,
-0.0425889827,
0.0508965924,
-0.0170846675,
-0.0337596238,
-0.0097358972,
-0.0049892953,
0.0632136688,
-0.0161673184,
0.0293840375,
-0.0147670312,
0.0102996239,
0.004825369,
-0.0486808717,
-0.0309978686,
-0.0863293558,
-0.0008650848,
0.0227814671,
-0.0202417113,
-0.0039480762,
-0.0265871007,
-0.0394357629,
0.0360569544,
0.0048155575,
-0.0387388654,
-0.034138646,
0.0643313974,
-0.0223520454,
-0.0118676573,
0.0931639597,
0.0327535979,
-0.0686010793,
-0.0238525607,
-0.0131266844,
0.0257943347,
0.0243921243,
0.0075282878,
-0.0803165063,
-0.0201145597,
-0.0247219279,
0.0200525988,
0.0458982103,
0.0540751666,
-0.0234951824,
-0.0740334168,
-0.0200559068,
0.0668957606,
-0.0620131344,
-0.0610758476,
0.0053453343,
-0.0277605876,
-0.0645233244,
0.0115793627,
-0.0097823264,
0.013913041,
-0.0142897163,
0.0141402232,
0.0094042905,
-0.0223093871,
-0.0521394946,
-0.0537021682,
0.0326026678,
0.0749535784,
0.0278392676,
-0.0028172436,
-0.0461195074,
0.0193552263,
-0.0083164889,
0.0026618869,
-0.0041757883,
0.0380334817,
-0.0428961813,
-0.0234435108,
0.0445433594,
-0.003832709,
-0.0392352529,
0.0078924615,
0.0194177665,
0.0500759557,
0.0087416274,
0.0137055451,
0.0222227816,
-0.0111631826,
0.0162193291,
0.0354591198,
0.0085354559,
-0.058837723,
-0.00925967,
-0.0194687936,
0.0107204709,
-0.0786001757,
0.0036111926,
-0.0031298227,
-0.0232289974,
-0.0506286062,
-0.0573899224,
-0.0298737083,
-0.0016823262,
0.0418437943,
0.0064531574,
0.0010010152,
0.0187807027,
-0.0151831722,
-0.0550462641,
0.0057850652,
-0.0201033875,
0.0276987329,
-0.0540727973,
-0.0205574594,
0.0308937561,
-0.0156964306,
0.0341985114,
0.0150143988,
-0.1067935899,
-0.0697088763,
-0.0165673494,
0.0232161582,
0.0113067003,
0.0825780705,
-0.0117615033,
-0.0045046848,
-0.0521452464,
0.0235171188,
-0.0287662018,
0.0137825459,
0.0525769033,
0.0149582298,
-0.0205971003,
0.0314048044,
-0.0152771631,
-0.0390593261,
0.0092587518,
0.0216478389,
-0.0460786857,
-0.0471704863,
0.0094049554,
-0.0317978114,
0.0368255638,
-0.0259986892,
-0.0364272371,
-0.017877914,
0.036598485,
-0.0079293149,
-0.019556962,
-0.0179898348,
-0.0268385392,
0.0584375337,
-0.0095357737,
-0.0180705935,
0.0318621136,
-0.0096703181,
-0.0385884196,
-0.0158797465,
0.0221889,
-0.0108984457,
0.0553758107,
0.0189889912,
0.0314001478,
-0.0231653322,
0.0160155203,
0.0418865122,
-0.01057088,
-0.0408777222,
0.0432346202,
0.0234449152,
0.0433961637,
0.0215767585,
0.055536069,
-0.0237501673,
-0.0116311405,
-0.0208709184,
-0.0326428749,
0.0738093778,
0.0043107015,
0.1270705462,
0.0348364338,
-0.0220229942,
-0.0093548186,
0.0637208968,
-0.0146736419,
-0.0252060797,
-0.0014607743,
-0.0164438356,
-0.012146689,
0.0079733385,
0.0570043735,
-0.0214150958,
-0.0053867325,
-0.0176810529,
0.0015868561,
-0.0229126811,
0.0258251708,
0.0309514794,
-0.0172879361,
-0.0008766846,
-0.0312266406,
0.0163079277,
-0.0549429655,
0.0196966026,
0.0159129053,
0.0171406735,
0.0229439139,
0.025800135,
0.085963577,
-0.0422639996,
0.0279459953,
-0.0421078391,
0.0157720167,
0.0482891686,
-0.0445503183,
-0.0361783803,
-5.984327129e-33,
-0.0096465498,
0.0295394231,
-0.0126539068,
-0.020639712,
-0.0641769096,
-0.0294510871,
-0.0136835538,
0.0018586441,
-0.0171105266,
-0.013610743,
0.0145949954,
0.0291241687,
0.0212604664,
0.0064167287,
0.0294448007,
-0.0113475677,
0.0560367927,
-0.0027273721,
-0.0316253826,
0.0277750548,
0.0348504335,
0.0224858355,
0.0642620176,
-0.0549436957,
0.006662644,
-0.0414447375,
-0.031553369,
-0.0039704759,
0.0245817527,
0.0194561575,
0.0352437012,
0.0096440315,
0.0253246054,
-0.0105844224,
-0.0045432691,
0.0066064619,
-0.0582152605,
0.0090166843,
0.0260703992,
0.0792324916,
-0.0268042348,
-0.0784915388,
0.0437185876,
-0.0500366017,
0.0076879021,
-0.0136112999,
0.022477407,
-0.0353381075,
0.0156884436,
0.0112343598,
-0.0807743222,
0.0176400263,
-0.0260111876,
-0.0018088134,
0.0254831705,
0.0941821635,
0.0017589227,
0.0006560257,
-0.0830107555,
0.0177721139,
-0.0479098484,
0.032120496,
0.0758160502,
0.0129582342,
-0.0253430121,
0.008772919,
0.0407788269,
-0.0227314923,
0.0430839583,
0.0115121026,
0.025518164,
-0.0108140372,
0.0576314032,
0.0822941065,
0.052755855,
-0.0327122137,
-0.0572832376,
0.011717245,
-0.030080257,
-0.0237549096,
0.0162215065,
0.0521589443,
-0.0045777569,
-0.0088964077,
-0.020016415,
-0.068047069,
-0.011974276,
-0.0555130951,
0.0015561362,
0.0123585118,
0.0015119683,
0.020638302,
0.0752615258,
-0.0276687425,
0.0229577143,
0.0337160528,
-0.0166762061,
0.0233321656,
-0.0167631581,
0.087657854,
-0.0281999819,
-0.0298214983,
0.0305786058,
0.0375488549,
0.0328990854,
0.0011938241,
0.0781716034,
0.0324647538,
-0.0519963242,
0.0025889545,
-0.0364077389,
-0.0179696921,
-0.0476950146,
0.0298292395,
0.020418128,
0.0063534495,
-0.0063403114,
0.0367164016,
0.0096853049,
-0.0285788104,
-0.0485187843,
-0.0444356725,
0.001782323,
0.0532673746,
-0.0408887863,
0.0222630929,
-0.0252559893,
0.0262186807,
0.0167712215,
-0.0716443285,
-0.0391592272,
0.0149373449,
2.574e-7,
0.0716148317,
0.0241361018,
0.0233777538,
0.0087465756,
0.01800742,
-0.0083980449,
-0.0504728183,
0.0448338985,
0.0070820623,
0.0362844802,
0.0268991757,
0.0349858887,
0.1020555645,
0.0255871769,
-0.0687744021,
-0.00206945,
-0.013538287,
0.0236831941,
-0.0388144627,
0.0193926934,
0.0626269132,
0.0961265787,
-0.0131365051,
0.0284070317,
-0.006358224,
0.0517346077,
0.0642646924,
-0.0111227222,
-0.0004316643,
-0.0226701852,
-0.0543272495,
0.0149990534,
-0.0564829558,
-0.0030370553,
-0.0313746631,
-0.0074120294,
0.048308298,
0.0558957495,
-0.013896306,
-0.0117632393,
0.0042030541,
-0.0129087176,
-0.045076102,
-0.0411074311,
0.0556232668,
-0.0244904719,
0.0081018703,
-0.0025027865,
-0.0477586053,
0.0640775114,
0.038274724,
-0.0314775631,
-0.0526302643,
0.0343147106,
0.0634054095,
0.0197366029,
-0.0386969186,
-0.0314047635,
-0.0231493656,
-0.0219995826,
-0.0103573268,
-0.0165084414,
-0.0135284504,
0.027037438,
0.0333728679,
-0.0139559563,
0.0347524695,
1.982673031e-34,
0.0461003147,
-0.0230911076,
0.0128247282,
-0.0162747204,
0.0027763983,
-0.042135939,
-0.0083855269,
0.0168553647,
-0.030154774,
0.003906663,
-0.0112306783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05021v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05021v1 | Chat2Brain: A Method for Mapping Open-Ended Semantic Queries to Brain Activation Maps | 2023-09-10T13:06:45 | 2023-09-10T13:06:45 | Yaonai Wei, Tuo Zhang, Han Zhang, Tianyang Zhong, Lin Zhao, Zhengliang Liu, Chong Ma, Songyao Zhang, Muheng Shang, Lei Du, Xiao Li, Tianming Liu, Junwei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL | Over decades, neuroscience has accumulated a wealth of research results in
the text modality that can be used to explore cognitive processes.
Meta-analysis is a typical method that successfully establishes a link from
text queries to brain activation maps using these research results, but it
still relies on an ideal query environment. In practical applications, text
queries used for meta-analyses may encounter issues such as semantic redundancy
and ambiguity, resulting in an inaccurate mapping to brain images. On the other
hand, large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT have shown great potential in
tasks such as context understanding and reasoning, displaying a high degree of
consistency with human natural language. Hence, LLMs could improve the
connection between text modality and neuroscience, resolving existing
challenges of meta-analyses. In this study, we propose a method called
Chat2Brain that combines LLMs to basic text-2-image model, known as Text2Brain,
to map open-ended semantic queries to brain activation maps in data-scarce and
complex query environments. By utilizing the understanding and reasoning
capabilities of LLMs, the performance of the mapping model is optimized by
transferring text queries to semantic queries. We demonstrate that Chat2Brain
can synthesize anatomically plausible neural activation patterns for more
complex tasks of text queries. | [
0.045603931,
0.0528620966,
-0.0390438326,
0.0065972446,
-0.0317354538,
0.0549765006,
0.0266624745,
0.0284336247,
0.0009178605,
-0.0429141745,
-0.0508446619,
-0.0241352431,
0.0353498198,
0.0664960593,
0.0323059708,
-0.0167101491,
0.0494080223,
0.0105227511,
0.0098045021,
0.008838865,
-0.0199214686,
0.021464454,
-0.0178772509,
0.0217042789,
0.0032803104,
-0.0102099739,
-0.009642832,
-0.00788341,
0.0019586938,
-0.0125875026,
-0.0346248969,
0.0849496499,
0.0121097118,
0.0625504628,
0.0000020643,
-0.008432772,
0.0294851828,
0.0328652114,
0.0242968202,
0.0092900423,
0.0632279888,
0.0320060588,
0.0269652084,
0.0073487079,
-0.0139503898,
-0.0148299569,
0.0630155653,
0.0460590124,
0.0124817798,
0.0332629904,
-0.035242822,
-0.0231195092,
0.040516641,
-0.0210331269,
0.0873053893,
-0.0032437218,
0.0531715602,
-0.033627212,
0.0309708156,
0.0376216173,
-0.0070844889,
0.056329295,
0.0099827489,
-0.0154960407,
-0.0167656038,
0.0649343356,
-0.0265917461,
-0.0241524335,
0.0057030311,
0.0560704134,
0.021285465,
-0.0220962726,
0.0361424424,
0.025121022,
-0.0193334054,
0.0296439845,
-0.0660734773,
0.0136378082,
0.0072013992,
0.0047241827,
-0.0220171642,
-0.0432948247,
0.0259412471,
-0.0001275364,
-0.0292027071,
0.0258764345,
-0.0015830087,
0.0047745719,
0.0247969478,
-0.0063844947,
-0.0390279517,
-0.0434004813,
0.0267523322,
0.0081415931,
-0.0237271544,
0.0321678557,
-0.0173192993,
-0.0717033148,
0.0271165166,
-0.0401845351,
-0.0146325929,
0.0494443364,
-0.0265907142,
0.0368995704,
-0.0216802582,
0.0095449081,
-0.0150139565,
0.1060263142,
-0.0278285164,
-0.0239692926,
-0.0566944107,
-0.041720055,
-0.0241349712,
-0.0033536484,
-0.0482031107,
-0.0630091503,
-0.0461787395,
0.0231624339,
0.0101222461,
-0.0888177752,
-0.0227862839,
0.0539527871,
-0.0168172438,
0.0310566183,
-0.0444320366,
-0.0114376508,
0.0224678777,
0.0519260094,
0.0215902459,
-0.0282554384,
-0.0032885668,
0.024021145,
-0.0037541064,
-0.0471012257,
-0.0258400925,
0.0469620228,
-0.044145152,
-0.0207232218,
0.0022212779,
0.0085044075,
-0.0164541714,
0.0095456233,
0.0495607704,
-0.0570369288,
0.0581783205,
0.0245179515,
-0.0323719904,
-0.0043042726,
-0.0013340161,
0.0293983165,
-0.060476698,
0.0541190654,
-0.0512285382,
0.0195611268,
0.0486245826,
0.0347644947,
-0.025018584,
0.0471621975,
0.0441309363,
0.0226932634,
-0.0157678034,
0.0174172353,
-0.0315381922,
0.0049046287,
0.028243959,
-0.0356040597,
-0.0311808176,
0.0000433093,
0.0138610099,
0.0248534251,
0.0076747313,
0.0612840168,
-0.0633428693,
-0.018605236,
0.0507446565,
0.0994474664,
-0.0107032247,
-0.0127399238,
0.0049270131,
-0.0040298193,
0.0129739791,
-0.0365363508,
-0.0649584755,
0.0754936635,
-0.0197282676,
-0.0279935505,
0.0295927599,
0.0052775471,
-0.0139635289,
-0.0249280501,
0.0180304125,
0.0247635264,
-0.0099251438,
-0.0069859298,
0.0231318269,
-0.0239210911,
0.028838098,
-0.0016114521,
0.0170494355,
-0.0042685815,
0.0016157405,
-0.0588177145,
-0.0181562379,
0.0372642688,
0.0468536392,
-0.0202819649,
0.0023154723,
0.0138383657,
0.0327308476,
0.1024532095,
-0.0106709395,
0.0203474034,
0.0404768921,
-0.0189912282,
-0.0115547273,
0.0003375334,
-0.0088437069,
-0.0219121762,
-0.0302205198,
0.0013108084,
-0.0342079252,
-0.0480113253,
-0.0090119038,
0.0503495522,
-0.0335905515,
0.031275209,
-0.0021258674,
-0.0057526059,
-0.0007843002,
-0.058448907,
-0.0112876976,
0.0542229377,
0.010310974,
-0.0032848367,
-0.0266758464,
0.0018780816,
0.0145693831,
-0.0277128257,
0.0227127988,
-0.0400899984,
-0.0338020138,
0.0130495178,
0.0022062042,
-0.0507245027,
-0.0070558488,
-0.0519529916,
0.0429823436,
-0.044978749,
-0.0193940736,
-0.0360052474,
-0.0012779797,
-0.0518644191,
0.0418789424,
-0.0024549062,
-0.0412588306,
0.0174000096,
-0.0752626956,
0.0176872611,
0.0096138557,
-0.0654107258,
0.0373583473,
-0.0082950192,
-0.0152719403,
-0.0268309973,
0.0017152613,
-0.0569556244,
-0.0284228437,
-0.1267790794,
-0.006233539,
0.0436401069,
-0.0134516181,
0.0434494913,
-0.0007941573,
-0.0075015873,
0.0233208667,
-0.0258767344,
0.0380303077,
0.0165870842,
0.0692662299,
0.0250982307,
0.0211942382,
0.0056494754,
-0.0506224632,
-0.0294535626,
-0.0471909605,
0.0528897829,
0.0210575052,
-0.0559796803,
0.0084783398,
0.0315515399,
-0.0234383009,
-0.0028125928,
-0.0192957707,
-0.0098597091,
0.0522648208,
-0.0126656052,
0.0230051093,
0.0775224045,
0.0242733322,
-0.00975597,
0.0683093667,
-0.0254272819,
-0.0476784706,
-0.0127865802,
-0.027186051,
0.0029119344,
0.0024944812,
-0.0697768629,
0.0206816457,
0.0497997701,
0.053147994,
0.011293727,
-0.0239623208,
-0.0017847836,
0.0011217642,
-0.0631151125,
-0.0705323517,
0.0160900839,
-0.01169316,
0.0796592832,
-0.0569362305,
-0.0451319702,
0.0733604133,
0.0137210805,
0.0348962061,
-0.0498782992,
0.0511063971,
-0.0029092317,
0.0544345714,
0.0192585383,
0.0328983925,
0.0007716944,
-0.0136312777,
-0.0395540632,
-0.0150715094,
-0.0110875126,
-0.024595717,
0.0251663271,
-0.0128922053,
0.0263876915,
0.0137243271,
-0.0112469178,
-0.0102341054,
-0.0067167352,
-0.0071210111,
-0.001253468,
0.0263665058,
-0.0184041504,
-0.0814262182,
-0.0066052219,
0.0690594241,
0.0079617435,
-0.0602636263,
-0.0451661348,
-0.0096024079,
-0.0085022952,
0.0661336109,
-0.0071335561,
0.0066666175,
-0.0088252779,
0.0024212927,
0.0619713739,
-0.0278250743,
0.037462838,
-0.0103131309,
0.0054176105,
0.0094787311,
0.0009847493,
-0.0073739938,
-0.0018203569,
-0.0026685118,
-0.0114237117,
-0.0165644828,
0.0974558517,
0.0312968716,
-0.0735601261,
-0.0388681516,
-0.0504073463,
0.0111594014,
0.0018822314,
0.0273699183,
-0.0545315109,
-0.036981985,
-0.013736818,
-0.0186053608,
-0.0261131525,
-0.0058135726,
-0.0008355133,
-0.0504842103,
0.0253935289,
-0.0445887409,
-0.0531504676,
0.0122891609,
-0.0241966303,
0.0510852672,
0.0021629948,
-0.00335267,
-0.0036324062,
-0.0140005145,
0.0171881318,
0.0252171047,
0.0634279847,
-0.0354002155,
0.0023724874,
-0.0202261582,
0.0618566312,
0.0368204229,
0.0703584328,
-0.0000941237,
-0.0040725637,
0.0543406382,
0.0648566633,
0.0271970034,
-0.0137494346,
0.0840535983,
0.0254906211,
0.0368840322,
-0.0878005475,
0.0030488684,
-0.0022997675,
-0.0507881083,
-0.0468795486,
0.0884000063,
-0.0412274897,
0.0183081497,
-0.0779732987,
0.0417242907,
-0.015188097,
0.045577433,
0.0563971326,
-0.0417548716,
-0.0080661513,
-0.0097081345,
-0.0100508705,
-0.0335378945,
-0.0645870268,
0.0111463871,
0.0257385671,
-0.0121549172,
-0.031439878,
-0.0016485947,
0.0497329235,
-0.0212367717,
0.0081858719,
0.0316476785,
0.0333942212,
-0.0540338419,
-0.0555229783,
0.0201316178,
-0.0234922245,
0.002907688,
-0.0385750979,
-0.0064126938,
0.0189775359,
-0.0409626402,
-0.0124757458,
0.0171731319,
-0.0577280112,
-0.0582787767,
0.0138110369,
0.0060529583,
0.0170948822,
-0.0472036824,
-0.0124507584,
-0.0557785667,
0.0395654663,
0.0875002742,
-0.0477465354,
0.0138445292,
-0.032155145,
0.0420869924,
-0.0127723869,
-0.0049602468,
-0.0250552855,
-0.0039278436,
0.0234171376,
0.008047712,
-0.0065756743,
0.0199396927,
0.0207576007,
0.0185103696,
0.0725501552,
0.0226795059,
-0.0198889989,
-0.0470775329,
-0.0380232781,
-0.0282988902,
0.015498748,
-0.005001355,
-0.0264613666,
0.0177684035,
0.0129104462,
-0.0294205453,
-0.0192506723,
-0.015939394,
-0.0045455885,
0.0146214711,
0.0001190261,
-0.0205390323,
0.031556163,
-0.0384663567,
0.035136424,
0.0139587885,
0.0010397538,
-0.0334414989,
0.0139876259,
-0.0087642735,
0.0387801938,
0.0434316024,
-0.0339790471,
-0.0302640125,
0.0360075273,
-0.0927356631,
-0.0555279627,
0.0560159385,
-0.0127636595,
-0.0105511341,
0.041568011,
0.0397817194,
0.0091166962,
0.0057750465,
-0.0139500638,
-0.0041205538,
-0.0005739383,
-0.005657664,
0.0445214882,
0.0053692544,
0.0209464487,
-0.0721937642,
0.0385694057,
-0.0151060279,
0.0113207037,
0.0139274681,
-0.0628796592,
0.0114521319,
-0.0256233253,
0.0298028123,
0.0170315579,
-0.0514296703,
-0.006171565,
-0.0440148041,
-0.0375429392,
0.0107334703,
0.0017215945,
0.0124693178,
-0.0125925122,
0.0124270795,
0.0410360508,
0.0364493281,
-0.0292614512,
-0.0171706192,
0.0386793204,
-0.0594227947,
-0.0579030663,
-0.0385758393,
-6.399360389e-33,
-0.0391720571,
-0.0560572781,
0.0369599611,
-0.0045630308,
-0.0020282087,
0.0021914127,
-0.056695357,
0.0241768211,
-0.0169513393,
0.0325341672,
-0.0387341678,
0.0400645286,
0.007156794,
0.0108723277,
0.0157486219,
0.0015684935,
-0.0332097374,
-0.0291470904,
-0.0250642076,
0.0133391786,
0.0620814972,
-0.0005572998,
0.0482052118,
-0.0573282279,
-0.0028263759,
0.04650262,
-0.0006828333,
0.0121743502,
-0.0444616042,
0.0431617834,
-0.0405466408,
0.0663177669,
0.0485156812,
0.0395563878,
-0.0050489213,
0.0316079333,
-0.0396663435,
-0.044705905,
0.0535554923,
-0.0185540561,
-0.0377726741,
0.0146885645,
0.0402230024,
-0.0487637855,
0.0447252318,
-0.0422652029,
0.0538616888,
-0.0255399514,
-0.0145419529,
-0.0005352266,
-0.0745556802,
-0.0118665462,
0.0090378365,
0.0094745066,
-0.0060825907,
0.0293890629,
-0.0380108841,
0.0518133305,
-0.0512606725,
0.0392529555,
-0.0088995928,
0.0487863943,
0.0079528866,
0.0274227206,
0.0621856973,
0.0891698748,
0.0382367559,
0.0161288083,
-0.0294346344,
0.0213059913,
0.0793561041,
0.0548811853,
0.022613639,
0.0455918685,
0.0444381051,
-0.0248111803,
-0.0325668603,
0.0243855808,
-0.0099515719,
0.0119298715,
0.0611256063,
-0.0084166499,
0.0184294339,
-0.0214247853,
-0.0553696789,
0.0235983115,
-0.0781770945,
-0.0208027847,
0.0287738815,
-0.0353001654,
0.0176127609,
-0.0274412148,
0.0360465236,
0.0069948966,
0.0170674808,
-0.0021383979,
0.0013601216,
0.0339142643,
0.0091451658,
-0.0031963317,
-0.0350457206,
-0.0252167936,
0.0545494817,
0.0196627621,
0.0365351737,
0.0063368636,
-0.0017951976,
-0.0132683553,
-0.0137567502,
-0.033201091,
-0.0414263718,
-0.0214604326,
-0.0026206442,
-0.0383143015,
-0.0371288694,
0.0144609977,
-0.0052307229,
-0.0206171237,
-0.0229479559,
0.0071446369,
-0.0578781329,
-0.0229550693,
-0.048401393,
0.0045253732,
-0.0179248527,
0.0258243792,
-0.0355899706,
-0.0163453985,
0.0441795662,
-0.0782233924,
-0.0353526101,
0.0298344735,
2.862e-7,
0.0905907899,
0.0586761795,
-0.0072852112,
0.0478124879,
0.037742231,
0.0142613631,
0.0317422114,
0.001015929,
0.0612555966,
-0.0376980193,
-0.0022322158,
0.0617184341,
0.0025505237,
0.0226836186,
0.0060983924,
-0.0255259406,
-0.0381173976,
-0.0347715095,
-0.0324509367,
-0.0147581361,
0.0650673509,
0.0369837061,
-0.0183498543,
-0.0303017423,
-0.0054399399,
-0.0011146991,
0.0783077553,
-0.0494913124,
0.0152803259,
0.0352929309,
-0.0227810536,
-0.0266898461,
0.0365996435,
0.0311123598,
0.0168619212,
-0.0232918952,
0.0125068054,
0.0153484652,
-0.0306159128,
0.0069036377,
0.0094566355,
-0.034236256,
-0.0110516641,
-0.0580385812,
0.0555350408,
-0.085873723,
-0.0591352358,
-0.0154367136,
0.0085010268,
0.0027590822,
0.0618211962,
-0.0425166115,
-0.0307760499,
-0.0206792951,
0.0069484473,
0.0132695008,
0.0110696126,
-0.0619077459,
0.005199071,
-0.0078483671,
-0.0605403259,
0.0066028074,
-0.0767249614,
0.0003281637,
0.0170381926,
-0.0668837801,
-0.0043808143,
2.431741949e-34,
-0.0042749797,
-0.0053534652,
0.0081886994,
-0.0110692112,
0.0203918666,
0.0208084006,
0.025406288,
-0.0096334666,
-0.0149124758,
-0.12156827,
-0.0261520464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.05007v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.05007v2 | FOLLOWUPQG: Towards Information-Seeking Follow-up Question Generation | 2023-09-10T11:58:29 | 2023-09-19T07:51:03 | Yan Meng, Liangming Pan, Yixin Cao, Min-Yen Kan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Humans ask follow-up questions driven by curiosity, which reflects a creative
human cognitive process. We introduce the task of real-world
information-seeking follow-up question generation (FQG), which aims to generate
follow-up questions seeking a more in-depth understanding of an initial
question and answer. We construct FOLLOWUPQG, a dataset of over 3K real-world
(initial question, answer, follow-up question) tuples collected from a Reddit
forum providing layman-friendly explanations for open-ended questions. In
contrast to existing datasets, questions in FOLLOWUPQG use more diverse
pragmatic strategies to seek information, and they also show higher-order
cognitive skills (such as applying and relating). We evaluate current question
generation models on their efficacy for generating follow-up questions,
exploring how to generate specific types of follow-up questions based on
step-by-step demonstrations. Our results validate FOLLOWUPQG as a challenging
benchmark, as model-generated questions are adequate but far from human-raised
questions in terms of informativeness and complexity. | [
0.0515945405,
0.0452988818,
-0.0024163269,
-0.0114599392,
-0.0070059299,
0.0199338309,
-0.018215023,
0.0085378801,
-0.0143117588,
-0.0105144633,
0.0223844033,
-0.018498702,
-0.0337551311,
0.0294371136,
0.0788228363,
-0.0625075027,
-0.0158153977,
-0.0214108545,
0.004853934,
0.0147144906,
0.0049391272,
-0.0040751933,
-0.0360258743,
0.0485377125,
-0.0059837792,
-0.0077276211,
-0.0574722961,
0.0382815339,
0.0043323543,
-0.0532695912,
0.0298220012,
0.024401268,
0.0364129357,
0.0060042562,
0.0000020551,
-0.0463541597,
0.0372699015,
-0.0207387637,
-0.0457828939,
-0.0577786714,
-0.0142792761,
0.0432104841,
0.0437113792,
0.0171754602,
-0.0493955091,
0.0078247143,
0.0276207402,
0.0250086635,
0.0451341942,
0.0455201007,
0.0009038486,
-0.0413808301,
0.0240777321,
-0.016545739,
0.1098498553,
-0.0440858714,
-0.0057046176,
0.0401643254,
0.0548529401,
0.0482075177,
0.0148178749,
0.0037196751,
0.0315515175,
-0.0554804243,
-0.0029693125,
0.0257490482,
0.0146243637,
-0.0057758023,
0.0007061877,
0.0934546441,
0.036135938,
-0.0167440604,
-0.0100501832,
0.0196793936,
0.0445527472,
0.0512484387,
-0.0965445414,
0.0186846014,
-0.0237465519,
-0.046371039,
-0.0172609258,
0.0168451481,
0.0089649782,
0.0013765856,
0.0227352548,
-0.0155364815,
-0.0070429598,
-0.0029255319,
-0.0425361618,
-0.017150443,
-0.0107760672,
-0.0725354776,
-0.0094373254,
0.0607555397,
-0.0459234677,
0.0046183355,
0.0106828492,
0.0126339998,
0.0264542084,
0.0187775642,
0.0297129322,
0.0492976941,
-0.0068747555,
0.0323534384,
0.0041060802,
0.023766458,
-0.0202674642,
-0.0017682537,
-0.0401451103,
0.0287601873,
-0.0556007735,
-0.02017067,
-0.0437815338,
0.0359362885,
-0.0128828576,
-0.0206771884,
0.0029728767,
0.0484241471,
0.0496251434,
-0.001218211,
-0.0103288013,
0.0092140445,
-0.0258043241,
0.0049196063,
-0.0204619691,
-0.0200114399,
-0.1056505442,
-0.0002755285,
0.0864037946,
-0.0380346365,
-0.0170184337,
0.0131948171,
0.0454675816,
0.0017586268,
0.0079167783,
-0.0058052288,
0.0155464215,
-0.019711433,
-0.0488668829,
-0.0665059313,
0.0531396009,
-0.0229238309,
-0.0119945016,
-0.0249840654,
0.0500174053,
0.0073923301,
-0.0610876344,
-0.0065164212,
0.0012748319,
0.0616284832,
-0.0008777482,
0.0274815187,
-0.040971715,
0.038750723,
0.0474531651,
0.0226531141,
0.0072681261,
0.0360007361,
0.0160519332,
0.0149753774,
0.0508139729,
0.0185240563,
0.0198494717,
-0.0105312616,
0.0203760471,
-0.0071023675,
-0.0038868443,
0.0523213334,
-0.0282912198,
0.041417297,
0.0144372853,
0.0187805239,
-0.0448200479,
0.0394901782,
0.0235346612,
0.0338973366,
-0.0079745864,
-0.0239251908,
0.0639358386,
0.0411407612,
0.0033249818,
0.0238724351,
-0.0063879378,
0.0630243346,
-0.01831422,
0.0116671165,
0.0258624908,
0.0196687952,
-0.0475849137,
-0.0226944294,
0.0185791366,
0.0283446722,
0.0109997634,
0.0197034087,
0.0002163591,
0.064174965,
-0.0372197405,
0.0140517009,
0.0153725911,
-0.0329048559,
-0.000965686,
-0.0616310388,
0.0777760595,
0.0104050273,
0.0482614525,
-0.0144620948,
-0.0542388372,
0.0003799124,
0.0637475178,
0.035861738,
0.0489461645,
-0.0256317426,
-0.0066840826,
-0.0295693502,
-0.0285481121,
-0.0401247069,
0.0135153187,
-0.0202685464,
0.0253325161,
-0.0169375259,
-0.0065573454,
-0.0343130231,
-0.0050053806,
0.0483369529,
-0.0465800762,
-0.0022809599,
-0.0154653601,
-0.0195941683,
-0.0523627251,
0.0358682647,
0.0277619958,
0.0226858463,
0.0299024004,
-0.0084794099,
-0.0014031995,
0.0429468118,
-0.0003090848,
-0.0613516159,
0.0013657842,
-0.0290172026,
-0.01842447,
-0.0076012705,
0.0023028546,
0.0006616357,
0.0151127037,
-0.0281961262,
0.0317379758,
-0.0304220989,
-0.0189275127,
0.0250400919,
-0.0248758774,
-0.0193615761,
0.0712705031,
-0.0270544291,
-0.0002689743,
0.0621827468,
-0.0269482043,
-0.0138464281,
-0.0404770859,
0.0640776232,
-0.0204114951,
-0.0486114323,
-0.0195646286,
0.0203189831,
0.0338185765,
-0.0777789205,
0.0214150641,
-0.01780935,
0.0049067573,
-0.0621078573,
0.0187338814,
0.0598187335,
0.0327314772,
-0.0124649173,
-0.0340673625,
-0.0856448114,
0.0107235536,
-0.0225520879,
-0.0075620175,
0.0494382307,
0.0431337729,
0.0339696147,
-0.02157286,
0.0088089919,
0.0063913534,
0.0376323387,
0.052747529,
0.0717900097,
-0.0700294003,
-0.0311611444,
-0.049740985,
-0.0431368425,
-0.0302310828,
-0.0095534781,
0.048478052,
-0.0270218998,
0.0536393076,
0.0209654663,
0.0462540686,
-0.0036293175,
-0.0217878968,
0.0440260246,
-0.0488575734,
0.0052873124,
-0.0509632155,
-0.0083058989,
-0.014696382,
-0.0778233781,
0.0311295725,
0.0296483394,
-0.0199220683,
0.0307008121,
-0.0460876562,
0.0812839642,
0.0145091182,
-0.0036361378,
-0.06361074,
-0.0238296613,
-0.0037853082,
0.0653954521,
-0.0235087033,
-0.0196520891,
0.0653231665,
0.0252921972,
-0.0138432384,
-0.0309731252,
0.0308619086,
-0.0105637163,
0.0963834673,
0.024719663,
0.0278269872,
0.0077548362,
-0.0155337397,
-0.0433234908,
0.0187388528,
0.012588894,
-0.0315284245,
-0.002732994,
-0.0150010968,
-0.0026025786,
0.0389669389,
-0.0124041121,
-0.0662109479,
-0.0580644608,
0.0192202795,
-0.0455362089,
0.0118137076,
-0.044092264,
-0.0063693183,
0.0117778648,
0.0471330993,
0.0358388163,
-0.0092077581,
-0.0645462647,
0.004553224,
0.0734722465,
0.0989654437,
0.0363619588,
0.0451110043,
-0.0607830659,
0.0439799055,
0.0611212291,
0.0188963395,
-0.0114074647,
0.0249266252,
-0.0290141013,
0.0059940377,
-0.0031806985,
0.01060188,
0.0239299498,
0.0707866773,
-0.0272733234,
-0.0610597283,
0.0579552464,
0.040359538,
-0.0082285171,
0.0195792858,
-0.0437499881,
0.0794885084,
0.0332254991,
0.0456702374,
-0.0577641912,
-0.0112983016,
0.0043401052,
0.0280199926,
-0.0239780769,
-0.0421538688,
-0.0152485576,
-0.1111808717,
0.0362616926,
-0.0214889161,
-0.0322566926,
0.0174137373,
-0.03783755,
0.0003716821,
0.048825331,
-0.0292063393,
0.0750842243,
-0.014361253,
0.0127046043,
0.0227886643,
-0.0387534574,
-0.0405080914,
-0.0049244487,
-0.0234779231,
0.0017165934,
0.0599773154,
0.0015770203,
0.0193032101,
-0.0317183211,
-0.0093216635,
-0.0077488967,
0.021297412,
0.0108683286,
0.0377460383,
0.0011013751,
0.0095358565,
-0.0818383619,
0.0983659774,
-0.069241263,
-0.0039216038,
0.035864573,
0.0067930911,
-0.0319768898,
-0.0263325628,
-0.0387608074,
0.0295344424,
-0.0004897164,
0.0455988534,
0.0533607639,
-0.0494489297,
0.027808629,
-0.0038210107,
0.0251035243,
-0.0902015567,
-0.0282318369,
-0.0330282301,
0.0335264914,
0.0733947009,
-0.084328182,
-0.0489557162,
0.0050935205,
0.0220470224,
-0.0208689626,
-0.013969765,
-0.0300774425,
-0.001048313,
-0.0381034166,
0.0148224924,
0.0328185037,
-0.0260973908,
-0.0413358882,
-0.0346517116,
-0.0032100668,
-0.0640329719,
-0.0257199164,
-0.021024134,
-0.0944285765,
-0.0120074907,
-0.0269488525,
0.049250219,
0.0267183278,
0.0007749099,
0.0022259906,
-0.0356267989,
-0.0602190755,
0.0002888987,
-0.0295186322,
-0.0212600529,
-0.0350858644,
0.0113004753,
0.0074328962,
0.0255065858,
-0.0240559746,
0.0055783642,
-0.0421409123,
0.0411367975,
-0.03517152,
-0.0623305477,
0.0518445484,
0.0024805814,
-0.025806088,
-0.014529434,
0.0202460885,
-0.0093337474,
0.0068882192,
-0.011675382,
0.0129475435,
-0.0515707657,
0.0197731517,
-0.0150750177,
-0.0042675384,
0.0020249267,
-0.0501365997,
-0.0273807272,
0.0155304223,
-0.0691562742,
-0.0191319175,
-0.0352189206,
0.044340536,
0.028531542,
-0.0306679942,
-0.0060299067,
0.0216132738,
0.013654572,
0.0543827303,
-0.0014546901,
0.1045006067,
0.0193286575,
-0.0370362438,
0.0393458642,
0.0203403607,
-0.0446837433,
-0.0843669176,
0.0041616294,
0.0069446508,
-0.0076597803,
0.0406760052,
-0.0009599056,
-0.0222092066,
-0.0048910845,
0.0206377078,
0.0347008854,
0.0023313498,
-0.0530947708,
0.0391439199,
0.0393463746,
-0.0053309468,
-0.0198877193,
0.0466388278,
-0.0279743094,
0.0181088373,
-0.0139064947,
0.017191153,
-0.0314580016,
0.0107245585,
-0.0006810082,
0.063034378,
-0.0022773547,
0.0451593772,
-0.0539476983,
-0.0365734659,
-0.0297094844,
0.0201317687,
0.0121965688,
-0.0094604334,
0.0262619127,
0.0365082435,
-0.0208646376,
-0.0350165926,
-0.0318630971,
0.0337058865,
-0.0767297968,
-0.0077802669,
-0.0047771907,
-6.50085698e-33,
0.0285887737,
-0.0557523891,
0.0280281398,
-0.0323212259,
-0.0275514703,
-0.0433643125,
-0.0685491711,
0.0310410373,
-0.0153508335,
0.010086149,
-0.0079751639,
0.0172521826,
-0.0192832127,
0.0265395287,
0.0041417782,
-0.0388089828,
0.0462743379,
-0.0031444412,
-0.0258306563,
0.0660946518,
0.0196167659,
0.0228747465,
-0.0285391584,
-0.0136649292,
0.0355064869,
-0.0829232484,
0.0135221975,
0.0540415235,
0.0060211071,
0.045497708,
-0.0256321635,
-0.0233261809,
0.0449464694,
-0.0030737019,
0.0123765208,
-0.0123921633,
-0.0464121923,
-0.0230102744,
-0.0271872934,
-0.0418452919,
-0.1210390106,
0.0106002362,
0.0173214469,
-0.0461220108,
0.0186586343,
0.0029333211,
0.0205443595,
0.0085379053,
0.0286997948,
0.0148872472,
-0.0337561332,
0.0004289888,
-0.0117688775,
-0.0571760572,
-0.0512655377,
0.12365935,
0.0048144804,
-0.0097817564,
-0.0415287167,
0.0333543643,
-0.0191594344,
0.0176611152,
0.0306976922,
0.0066050924,
0.0010794814,
0.0451592579,
0.0158122126,
0.0185582861,
-0.0422703251,
0.0330048576,
-0.0318216756,
0.0605461784,
0.0280024242,
0.0480528362,
0.0600480363,
-0.0081538996,
-0.0593734793,
0.0527449101,
0.0127928089,
0.0139356554,
0.0208995268,
-0.0351583734,
-0.0269161426,
0.0069671306,
-0.035940446,
0.0470831692,
-0.0298087262,
-0.0540427454,
0.0420232266,
0.0289102532,
-0.0454691127,
-0.0507364422,
-0.0282723643,
-0.0010977619,
0.0246621594,
0.0000555501,
-0.0416222215,
-0.0056957616,
-0.0016238997,
0.0045570182,
-0.0292464457,
0.0356273688,
0.0017074477,
0.0091933208,
0.011167543,
0.0611375123,
0.0131536489,
0.0145688038,
-0.0388480425,
-0.0123314857,
-0.0251617674,
0.0582294092,
-0.0434423387,
-0.0423575155,
0.0251945276,
0.0395576395,
-0.0355160125,
0.0158370398,
0.0317748785,
-0.0324696042,
-0.0302436966,
-0.0115545709,
0.0099566979,
0.0208718479,
0.0030862172,
-0.0162509494,
-0.0432532988,
0.0172985494,
-0.006959544,
-0.0802327991,
-0.0207209364,
0.017454261,
2.75e-7,
-0.0203869753,
0.023901457,
0.0261128414,
0.0548704118,
0.0050348458,
-0.0187515263,
-0.008547198,
-0.0117630521,
0.0389404446,
-0.0587432496,
0.0119700376,
0.0136473468,
-0.0024282099,
-0.0119233308,
-0.0845484138,
-0.0325932279,
-0.0606540032,
-0.0013771268,
-0.0255232062,
-0.0281183869,
0.0696569532,
-0.0038928918,
-0.0173342582,
-0.014938171,
0.0165056828,
-0.0088863084,
0.0680601075,
0.0010593354,
0.0126937628,
0.0394985452,
0.0211509764,
0.026925426,
0.0193100031,
-0.008225454,
-0.0256022643,
-0.0385081209,
0.0163322985,
-0.0074029723,
0.0412033089,
-0.0162050202,
-0.0068922886,
-0.0023461303,
0.04785477,
-0.0734963715,
0.0292680133,
-0.05715058,
-0.0173751041,
0.0069128568,
-0.0250997264,
-0.015818689,
-0.0236980263,
-0.0204407834,
-0.0168924965,
-0.0197171979,
0.024170842,
0.0424041264,
0.0111850174,
-0.0469083451,
-0.0181969497,
-0.0019258257,
-0.0246729255,
-0.0180860013,
-0.0627849326,
-0.0280573145,
-0.033340726,
0.0044203671,
-0.0266710017,
2.038065907e-34,
0.0041129403,
0.013031763,
0.0108669726,
0.0036549645,
0.0288002677,
-0.0165180936,
0.0336890034,
-0.0029198618,
0.0569150448,
-0.0548400581,
0.000651403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06527v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06527v1 | Machine Translation Models Stand Strong in the Face of Adversarial Attacks | 2023-09-10T11:22:59 | 2023-09-10T11:22:59 | Pavel Burnyshev, Elizaveta Kostenok, Alexey Zaytsev | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Adversarial attacks expose vulnerabilities of deep learning models by
introducing minor perturbations to the input, which lead to substantial
alterations in the output. Our research focuses on the impact of such
adversarial attacks on sequence-to-sequence (seq2seq) models, specifically
machine translation models. We introduce algorithms that incorporate basic text
perturbation heuristics and more advanced strategies, such as the
gradient-based attack, which utilizes a differentiable approximation of the
inherently non-differentiable translation metric. Through our investigation, we
provide evidence that machine translation models display robustness displayed
robustness against best performed known adversarial attacks, as the degree of
perturbation in the output is directly proportional to the perturbation in the
input. However, among underdogs, our attacks outperform alternatives, providing
the best relative performance. Another strong candidate is an attack based on
mixing of individual characters. | [
0.0139075993,
0.0799172819,
-0.0211677141,
0.0489314236,
-0.0141050294,
0.0117068533,
0.0253925826,
-0.0052190265,
-0.0233612135,
-0.0184675008,
0.0034654597,
-0.0431549996,
0.0502065755,
0.0034290652,
0.0787954405,
-0.0361592993,
0.0109311938,
0.0008552914,
-0.0597079359,
0.0003497452,
-0.0069105271,
-0.0124203404,
0.0075819613,
0.0158260502,
0.0139342286,
-0.0091536185,
-0.0050547691,
0.0590622015,
0.0608714372,
-0.0098141329,
0.0238942467,
0.0505025163,
-0.0137906531,
0.1213363558,
0.0000019784,
-0.0085986396,
-0.0411573946,
0.018969249,
0.0018584928,
0.0380197279,
0.0157866292,
-0.0473167263,
-0.0490951091,
0.0157416556,
-0.0348688103,
-0.0228966679,
0.0293851215,
0.0171463415,
0.0857430398,
0.1196634397,
-0.0039319382,
-0.051229123,
0.0301328935,
-0.0868695602,
-0.0015186897,
-0.0509274155,
0.0116089918,
-0.0588406883,
-0.0718741491,
0.0243216045,
-0.0013935621,
0.0378958024,
0.0167010874,
0.0004530698,
-0.056621179,
0.0147954598,
0.00318024,
-0.0192352626,
0.0133894421,
0.0998883173,
-0.0906084999,
-0.0010789175,
-0.0181026179,
-0.0088921972,
0.0214176122,
-0.0330133736,
-0.0109059298,
-0.0120825842,
0.0393369645,
-0.0196924713,
-0.030761525,
0.0005038131,
0.0606602766,
-0.0195414778,
-0.0389787182,
-0.0530640781,
0.0250216443,
-0.0027967668,
-0.0468468107,
-0.0272459555,
-0.0395366736,
-0.0442874692,
0.0167726353,
0.0118412152,
0.0067765978,
0.0064418199,
-0.0899306834,
-0.0769784525,
-0.0003337472,
-0.0514453314,
0.049103234,
0.0433117934,
0.0016788596,
0.0391119793,
-0.0392730571,
0.0530940704,
-0.0448460169,
0.0309593379,
-0.0169803742,
0.0278111566,
-0.004295941,
0.003192608,
0.0388455652,
-0.0217643082,
-0.0246880352,
0.0067122276,
-0.0162782799,
0.038534347,
-0.0035700807,
0.0468436852,
-0.01275515,
0.0060308166,
-0.0647098348,
-0.0089325588,
0.0200096071,
-0.0280663744,
0.0045485534,
-0.017362697,
0.0052477308,
-0.0692425966,
-0.0523877814,
0.0081086094,
-0.0538717881,
-0.0402849689,
-0.0186202079,
0.1155436859,
-0.0044447882,
-0.0406101644,
0.0083846757,
-0.0332234763,
-0.0445062369,
-0.0457987003,
0.0027091424,
-0.050051596,
0.0157456156,
-0.0137169268,
-0.0121981874,
-0.0939602181,
0.0279892422,
-0.0039613754,
-0.0215066299,
0.0842848346,
0.0332132243,
-0.0259094816,
0.0383475199,
0.0281334948,
-0.0237607304,
0.0365790166,
0.0307392571,
0.0335782841,
0.0220497046,
0.0032712638,
-0.0144878281,
0.0517776906,
0.0230892729,
0.0442827903,
-0.0222115591,
-0.013896035,
0.0239697639,
0.0108304759,
-0.0161340963,
0.0749275237,
-0.0251194686,
-0.0706376135,
0.1167757586,
0.0379126035,
-0.0157857742,
0.0845496058,
-0.001676648,
-0.0205388535,
0.0065993606,
0.0100519611,
-0.0553941838,
-0.0057166726,
0.0061705178,
-0.0176221114,
0.0354723856,
0.0429254845,
-0.0063953986,
-0.0336633772,
0.0069892118,
-0.0204929449,
0.0270583704,
-0.0356242508,
0.0012309802,
0.0260637198,
-0.03356288,
0.0056920624,
-0.0445230789,
-0.0252923369,
0.009373107,
-0.0026196213,
-0.0470954925,
0.0099062873,
0.0572726689,
-0.021540096,
-0.0013601768,
-0.0318836085,
-0.0064854617,
0.0334749781,
0.0532443859,
0.0313828476,
0.0326921232,
-0.0115237841,
0.0133388154,
-0.0337955728,
0.0213381648,
0.0149185304,
0.0236201193,
0.0334352441,
0.0322011448,
0.0037514234,
-0.0598796159,
0.0390569754,
-0.0186481401,
-0.0561242998,
0.0569569394,
0.0397085994,
0.0201367959,
0.0129605839,
-0.0446997322,
0.046182353,
0.0388784297,
-0.0183417946,
-0.0316542014,
0.0090020616,
0.0010395899,
-0.0506818146,
0.0319562368,
-0.030750446,
0.0051749917,
0.0384358689,
-0.0412847288,
-0.0003078805,
0.0373830013,
-0.0630164295,
-0.0280473791,
0.0076077781,
0.0173656773,
0.0018748243,
0.0504123867,
-0.0287345015,
0.0284759551,
-0.0319971666,
-0.0112474486,
-0.0316538289,
0.0332967639,
0.0166213159,
-0.022097582,
-0.0441684984,
0.0302565452,
-0.0042702849,
0.0037528672,
0.0109175611,
0.0051426487,
0.0166092757,
-0.0281194318,
-0.003561887,
-0.0223483127,
-0.0326786116,
0.0249186382,
0.0349569768,
0.0136267953,
0.0036620635,
-0.0042229737,
-0.0117301848,
-0.0189077109,
-0.0204674788,
0.0022337497,
0.0233067051,
0.0126109002,
0.0037995041,
-0.0142184189,
-0.0388391092,
-0.0039445963,
0.0862278268,
-0.0389009416,
-0.0003026741,
-0.0127505353,
-0.0037857753,
-0.01117435,
0.0427162312,
-0.0149017991,
-0.061947383,
0.0343641154,
0.0209590178,
0.0249862019,
0.1080584005,
0.0404508933,
0.0229356959,
0.0022265103,
0.014159658,
-0.0028854546,
-0.0059154779,
-0.0071497159,
-0.0135554699,
-0.0266811345,
-0.0424581803,
0.0212268643,
0.0379803888,
0.0128506413,
-0.0116039012,
-0.0344570726,
0.0544818081,
0.0188590977,
-0.046819374,
0.0088114068,
0.0133121973,
-0.0005504982,
-0.0003282723,
-0.0374298431,
-0.0331943855,
0.0755733252,
-0.0411467627,
0.0272288211,
-0.0114197899,
-0.0291845389,
0.0147453444,
0.044430498,
-0.0164287239,
0.0304652918,
-0.0193650704,
0.0061733047,
-0.0503050685,
-0.0107266139,
0.0537885316,
-0.0363581628,
0.012205027,
-0.0316714197,
-0.0071415622,
-0.0194192939,
-0.0210733768,
-0.0301051233,
-0.0245161522,
0.0204701722,
0.0139670419,
0.0425464027,
-0.0570225157,
-0.0621392466,
-0.0276193619,
0.0297058914,
0.0348446295,
-0.0236345045,
0.0155562544,
-0.0199596118,
0.0385107361,
0.0192985274,
-0.06847772,
0.0207262281,
-0.0650845319,
0.0601163916,
0.0549801588,
-0.0157683399,
0.0238794237,
-0.0335268043,
-0.0306957196,
-0.0067774984,
0.0303821228,
-0.0032621124,
0.0060026799,
0.0411337651,
-0.0366369225,
-0.0210178234,
0.0450055674,
-0.0224593543,
-0.0077639925,
0.0402523428,
0.0394218266,
0.0288442597,
0.0026902144,
-0.0011641426,
-0.0618560389,
-0.0140561545,
0.014512565,
0.0380768217,
0.0272387899,
-0.006585456,
-0.0280199014,
-0.0504600629,
-0.0164170507,
0.0383377336,
-0.0671065301,
-0.0528851189,
-0.0218520425,
-0.0174777061,
-0.0225373581,
0.0318629593,
-0.0193044972,
0.0547862649,
-0.0293876361,
0.0144852092,
0.0375178345,
-0.0658920854,
-0.0312926099,
-0.0378953926,
-0.0056805089,
0.092365697,
0.0147685427,
-0.0043834518,
-0.0189228803,
0.0398175493,
0.005269283,
-0.0206098761,
0.053700231,
0.0311421156,
-0.0102670249,
-0.0247563981,
0.0409152545,
0.030276373,
-0.0145335793,
0.0203376021,
-0.0016436742,
0.0024274616,
0.0222903397,
-0.0312513821,
-0.0116129899,
-0.0249307007,
0.0041324208,
0.0473203324,
0.0031584688,
-0.0704475492,
-0.0292276349,
-0.0905166715,
0.0144125959,
-0.0552521758,
-0.0598265976,
-0.0229896493,
0.0221887864,
-0.0536981188,
-0.083671242,
-0.0278248582,
-0.0533955619,
0.0555137917,
-0.0011924481,
-0.0001011082,
-0.0224923398,
-0.0034393431,
-0.0264467336,
0.0079877488,
0.0075000711,
0.0605346747,
-0.0282392055,
0.032854192,
0.001111786,
-0.0029420599,
-0.0153866522,
-0.0147474371,
-0.1327793002,
-0.1032022163,
-0.0234282874,
0.064201355,
0.0112994816,
0.0030174735,
-0.0452619232,
-0.0605675541,
0.0578402132,
0.045856405,
0.0066917473,
-0.0112189883,
0.0509412214,
-0.0552021675,
0.0109288571,
0.0338597782,
-0.0113197966,
-0.0322201066,
0.0502976105,
0.0224549398,
-0.0206890311,
-0.0425645933,
-0.0115370164,
-0.027041465,
0.033881411,
-0.005812692,
-0.0214039925,
0.034350127,
0.0439861529,
0.0067476239,
-0.0143790403,
-0.0213270057,
0.0088221682,
0.0370383114,
0.0168816186,
0.0237474218,
0.0132750561,
0.0296644829,
0.0072938167,
-0.016114708,
-0.0074711624,
-0.005575405,
0.0303586759,
0.0237340014,
0.0196099337,
-0.0188388992,
0.0507490188,
-0.0298725963,
0.017199751,
-0.0173865873,
0.0192606747,
0.0192837622,
0.0123231383,
0.030557327,
0.0320182778,
-0.0566335581,
-0.0134626441,
-0.0359457098,
0.0117667466,
0.0566749275,
0.0200771727,
0.0170971472,
-0.0021922586,
0.0012908508,
-0.0476242416,
-0.0310854334,
-0.0012076973,
0.0141960643,
-0.0109751076,
0.00611596,
0.0084124571,
0.0687266961,
0.0642859936,
0.0311046597,
0.0247001406,
0.0108525716,
-0.0304751992,
-0.0206744391,
-0.0145787075,
0.0310898442,
-0.0179864131,
-0.0320973732,
-0.0401704609,
0.0105642984,
-0.0974110961,
0.0202897228,
0.011079995,
0.0367804058,
0.0418942049,
-0.0159623753,
0.0584979728,
-0.026610123,
0.0497973561,
-0.0457963459,
0.0459883697,
0.0028318206,
-0.0684160143,
0.0089734849,
-6.161654126e-33,
0.0239579473,
-0.029760493,
-0.0582792461,
-0.0364274904,
0.0267317034,
-0.0002365486,
-0.0388004743,
-0.0005420047,
-0.0310771111,
-0.0156749673,
0.0033690771,
0.0174057651,
-0.0232167114,
0.0131926676,
-0.0531071797,
-0.0350612439,
0.0483416505,
0.0163368694,
-0.0542387664,
-0.0053815274,
0.0051235305,
0.0247848965,
0.0416412801,
-0.0450924113,
0.0537347384,
-0.0155302072,
-0.0370102189,
-0.0138285309,
-0.0273548048,
0.0378244668,
0.0165204983,
-0.0141735049,
-0.0156308245,
-0.0089092785,
-0.0216772538,
-0.0116150668,
-0.0109098796,
0.0248308256,
-0.0170871094,
0.0221307706,
-0.0219272878,
-0.0530403405,
0.0422691964,
-0.0165803563,
-0.0154667767,
-0.0244194251,
-0.012803304,
-0.0051477016,
-0.0346981734,
-0.0128185693,
-0.0095121451,
0.0347791836,
-0.023908006,
-0.0069123581,
-0.0112765292,
0.0405416265,
0.0265223887,
0.0007924586,
-0.0976270437,
0.0039325329,
0.0147315096,
0.066505976,
0.0618660375,
-0.0042080088,
0.0177841969,
0.0261842702,
0.0500071794,
0.0117853479,
-0.0019276512,
-0.0006559168,
0.0217774138,
-0.0175936278,
0.0803491548,
0.0795754194,
0.0547497198,
-0.0073779426,
-0.0897963345,
0.0142038614,
-0.0257814974,
-0.0057833069,
0.0570803173,
0.037854813,
-0.0480630547,
0.0320866592,
-0.0454264209,
-0.0846025646,
-0.0202848967,
-0.0219331551,
0.0059464569,
0.0414964035,
-0.0341310911,
0.0023602652,
0.01895261,
-0.0242041424,
0.0208190102,
0.004350869,
-0.044475805,
-0.0289194863,
-0.0131285228,
0.0425520428,
0.0218946394,
0.0019683032,
0.0304399282,
-0.0222442169,
0.0221254881,
-0.0215844307,
0.0479548015,
0.0364444926,
-0.0296705775,
-0.0151515501,
-0.0250058994,
0.0229987074,
0.0189482067,
0.0511589423,
0.0332057104,
-0.022234818,
-0.0240244176,
0.0228980817,
0.0094239684,
0.0374374539,
-0.0092758276,
0.0502690673,
-0.0095167411,
0.0148355877,
-0.0285560694,
-0.0225440841,
0.0012107635,
0.0511220992,
0.0353183784,
-0.0829851627,
-0.0151135856,
-0.0238153711,
2.731e-7,
0.0097955503,
0.0571857654,
0.0157806259,
0.0065472457,
0.0264786035,
0.0570598282,
-0.031692706,
0.062227644,
-0.0255157165,
0.0036176019,
-0.0238411147,
0.029766148,
0.0752307847,
0.0082676122,
-0.0474151373,
-0.0252542086,
-0.0898858011,
0.0523270853,
-0.0408033133,
-0.012848706,
0.0203881823,
0.1090766639,
0.0072361515,
0.0084258737,
0.0086188363,
-0.0431687422,
0.0472060628,
0.0002931507,
0.0003882019,
-0.0351572409,
0.0508945957,
0.0192515086,
-0.0074690017,
-0.0294465218,
-0.0461623929,
0.0156039419,
0.0288822148,
0.0524316058,
-0.0041798432,
-0.0395755023,
-0.0222492255,
-0.0181375779,
-0.0004928367,
-0.0360028967,
0.0517153107,
0.0126932347,
-0.0035147471,
0.0091727786,
-0.0343932435,
0.0242923554,
0.0843160599,
-0.0529278964,
-0.0256863274,
-0.0011325862,
0.0366015621,
0.0221894309,
0.0314725637,
-0.0432276502,
-0.0293794274,
-0.021143388,
-0.0064624734,
-0.0154174827,
-0.0405780412,
0.0419443846,
0.0400969721,
0.0423402786,
-0.0086397827,
2.398565458e-34,
-0.0020083853,
-0.0182914026,
0.0065319119,
-0.0143052414,
0.0486347228,
-0.0374541655,
0.0180210806,
-0.0262076464,
0.0131818131,
-0.032988254,
-0.0670415908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04992v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04992v1 | Mitigating Word Bias in Zero-shot Prompt-based Classifiers | 2023-09-10T10:57:41 | 2023-09-10T10:57:41 | Adian Liusie, Potsawee Manakul, Mark J. F. Gales | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompt-based classifiers are an attractive approach for zero-shot
classification. However, the precise choice of the prompt template and label
words can largely influence performance, with semantically equivalent settings
often showing notable performance difference. This discrepancy can be partly
attributed to word biases, where the classifier may be biased towards classes.
To address this problem, it is possible to optimise classification thresholds
on a labelled data set, however, this mitigates some of the advantages of
prompt-based classifiers. This paper instead approaches this problem by
examining the expected marginal probabilities of the classes. Here,
probabilities are reweighted to have a uniform prior over classes, in an
unsupervised fashion. Further, we draw a theoretical connection between the
class priors and the language models' word prior, and offer the ability to set
a threshold in a zero-resource fashion. We show that matching class priors
correlates strongly with the oracle upper bound performance and demonstrate
large consistent performance gains for prompt settings over a range of NLP
tasks. | [
0.0235004295,
0.0095020579,
0.0129202446,
0.0131539376,
-0.0423349328,
0.0247765929,
0.0547321178,
0.0019042486,
-0.0079059303,
-0.1234486774,
-0.0286398064,
-0.0214574765,
-0.0071637831,
-0.0057826303,
-0.0235864446,
-0.0517752245,
0.0448504016,
-0.0067246542,
0.0333625823,
0.0067694183,
-0.0235865992,
0.0068881535,
-0.0438720621,
0.0295840595,
0.0012221903,
-0.0116193164,
0.0161275454,
0.0093866922,
-0.0134444013,
-0.039335534,
0.000159859,
0.0851914734,
-0.005140868,
0.0344630405,
0.0000017633,
-0.0853057504,
0.0016262579,
-0.0020833563,
-0.0594129451,
-0.0349121615,
0.0628495142,
-0.0255902298,
0.0225977693,
0.0172058381,
0.0043690018,
-0.0465177074,
0.0564636141,
0.0354178846,
-0.0180880707,
0.0514651686,
-0.0085439216,
0.0136631643,
0.0116453804,
-0.0056326748,
0.0563330166,
-0.0522198491,
0.0115217436,
-0.0690139383,
0.0101040294,
0.0246849116,
-0.0236870181,
0.0057378211,
-0.0129948854,
0.0211993624,
0.0371430069,
0.0552504845,
-0.0216175094,
-0.0127804223,
-0.0264243167,
0.0556308776,
-0.016048979,
-0.0354214646,
-0.0212089438,
-0.0428542644,
0.0217191577,
0.0232301038,
-0.0275084078,
0.0607290938,
0.0166749656,
0.0070621171,
0.0098649142,
0.0323356465,
-0.008004305,
0.0326047353,
0.0169916283,
0.0774442405,
0.0052918433,
-0.0386100337,
0.0254153498,
0.0203444287,
0.0171680227,
-0.0623560138,
-0.0330168158,
0.0468137525,
-0.0346876495,
0.0224696361,
-0.060929209,
0.0037686413,
0.052658312,
-0.0348243713,
0.0447305739,
0.0151343364,
-0.0247232281,
0.0495185331,
-0.0068580839,
0.0104609448,
0.0609668754,
0.028835725,
-0.0096337395,
0.0187300183,
-0.0645029545,
0.0017440582,
-0.032613121,
0.0268302336,
-0.0005617837,
-0.008445343,
-0.0288792364,
0.0257271659,
0.0074454821,
0.0066594183,
-0.0045022764,
0.0092981663,
-0.0410723947,
0.0172338728,
-0.0297989566,
0.0284342039,
-0.0114975655,
0.0245661549,
-0.0057262694,
-0.0814335048,
0.0007804061,
0.0028699033,
0.0214336198,
-0.035194885,
0.0091402382,
0.0553581193,
0.0036454087,
-0.0745980814,
-0.0424271524,
-0.0282284319,
-0.0324909873,
-0.0176296048,
-0.0397279188,
-0.0415189229,
-0.000451336,
0.026959192,
0.0233760811,
0.0263617132,
-0.0024004728,
0.0238779951,
-0.0517866984,
0.1194372252,
-0.0147308409,
-0.0193715617,
0.0376130454,
-0.004113399,
0.0084091313,
0.0663604811,
-0.0161437541,
0.0007496423,
0.0666720122,
-0.00855242,
0.0373102315,
0.0009749679,
-0.0050925878,
-0.0081836646,
-0.0178872216,
0.0048150644,
0.082179144,
-0.013329519,
0.0274752341,
-0.0034566107,
-0.0050598215,
-0.0016939354,
0.0302209929,
0.0497319028,
-0.0222503971,
-0.0712441579,
0.0332018323,
0.0069122263,
-0.0413417146,
0.0021782147,
-0.0488747098,
-0.0241568685,
-0.0434391014,
-0.0093504367,
0.0123129366,
-0.0348397158,
-0.0385254361,
-0.021224184,
-0.0222152863,
-0.0079698795,
-0.0457723029,
0.0060029062,
0.0395902842,
0.0163753405,
-0.0196661837,
0.0407059416,
0.0442464352,
-0.0087771025,
0.0066192811,
-0.0405124873,
0.0229093228,
0.01010832,
0.0130922534,
-0.0556009524,
0.0126054166,
-0.0210856926,
-0.0097606014,
0.0347783752,
0.0410450287,
-0.0119779855,
0.0106155686,
-0.0300221629,
-0.0341995992,
-0.0064397869,
0.0303303208,
0.0351237841,
-0.0401748233,
0.0337332375,
0.0135574127,
0.0003403395,
-0.0287209656,
0.046983555,
0.0422286391,
-0.0947113559,
0.072459504,
0.0249891076,
0.0138789471,
0.0023761368,
-0.016894374,
0.0001060289,
-0.0137639027,
-0.0051612356,
-0.0097966017,
-0.05688807,
-0.0295352098,
-0.030102957,
0.0195180792,
0.0218300372,
0.0276683364,
-0.0239898395,
-0.0331843942,
-0.0352408998,
-0.0417503454,
0.0125037953,
0.0165308025,
-0.0419593193,
0.0286763646,
-0.0159707107,
0.0305641927,
-0.0704124719,
0.0791503116,
0.0449431576,
0.0572215617,
0.0382064618,
0.0081090238,
0.030651886,
-0.0638895109,
-0.0188938212,
0.0148770995,
-0.0212974548,
-0.0059681246,
0.0177492183,
0.0156695936,
-0.0402730331,
0.0090170316,
-0.0858094022,
-0.0031297472,
-0.0072852876,
-0.0016418165,
0.0107226493,
0.0070876237,
-0.0190706179,
-0.0351588205,
-0.0266902577,
-0.0228995401,
0.0046627778,
0.0571972542,
0.0381743461,
0.0195519961,
-0.0033941946,
0.0054251323,
-0.0058864537,
-0.0167579465,
0.0575852804,
0.0372834951,
-0.0161259938,
-0.0182338879,
0.047732126,
0.0037309774,
-0.0036383937,
0.0359098241,
0.0235280488,
-0.0175018422,
-0.0076826783,
-0.0240552127,
0.0647187084,
0.0097803315,
0.008079892,
0.0504221991,
0.0245394185,
-0.0470361412,
-0.0187114291,
-0.020043131,
-0.0333068855,
0.0221451074,
-0.0090041887,
0.0201929435,
0.0637311414,
0.0169265736,
-0.0175976343,
-0.040670827,
0.0004282268,
-0.0256603602,
-0.0113592874,
-0.0887976214,
0.0254649762,
-0.0077657849,
0.0406662412,
0.0049059801,
-0.0536836572,
0.0375479162,
-0.0258870758,
0.0293711517,
-0.0362912901,
-0.0129979411,
-0.0337238349,
0.011359754,
0.0096726688,
0.0078805201,
0.0472097881,
-0.0327968635,
-0.0156955421,
-0.0215719473,
0.0038927849,
0.0104706846,
-0.0086989459,
-0.0193703156,
0.0211426839,
-0.0516434908,
-0.0489908755,
-0.0490134582,
-0.0857592896,
-0.0202779416,
0.0408668481,
-0.0560374558,
0.0247124769,
-0.0189426057,
0.0132346163,
-0.0160594303,
0.0140276011,
-0.0179525167,
-0.0329238027,
-0.0086000906,
0.0574858189,
0.0285434723,
-0.0229059514,
-0.018971093,
0.0103121512,
0.0126005951,
0.0102033848,
0.0496434309,
0.0649558455,
0.0043405574,
-0.0163097121,
0.0453568883,
-0.06224012,
-0.0410554223,
0.048973266,
0.004642257,
-0.0023215914,
0.009575123,
0.125211373,
0.0406411029,
-0.0789690912,
-0.015798226,
0.0103895394,
-0.0159393195,
0.0298146755,
0.0190253761,
-0.0811548606,
-0.0487403683,
0.0042974032,
0.0267282072,
-0.0502784662,
-0.0384658091,
-0.0243390165,
-0.1324816495,
0.0294276513,
-0.0418988317,
-0.0244188998,
0.0361680277,
-0.0634348989,
0.0209543761,
-0.0447252393,
0.0002526388,
-0.0308891591,
-0.0190140903,
-0.0026317453,
0.022357665,
0.005353061,
-0.0531373136,
0.0168761797,
-0.0329686552,
0.0412162021,
0.0295382515,
0.0104168821,
-0.0199090652,
-0.0260583032,
0.0245781299,
-0.0841834918,
0.0046210014,
-0.0284469407,
0.0699412972,
-0.0579112545,
0.0097779864,
0.0212536715,
0.0312649608,
-0.0236148071,
-0.0178456344,
0.0106096743,
0.0608287007,
-0.0139484499,
0.0003143183,
-0.0337845944,
-0.0169856045,
0.0423235968,
0.0974499807,
0.0111403251,
-0.0491566919,
-0.0331099816,
-0.0239104088,
-0.0108781299,
-0.0065645026,
0.0137935989,
0.0083325328,
-0.0493075177,
-0.0678780451,
-0.0219506081,
-0.0271709897,
0.0241156574,
0.0591300689,
0.003017124,
-0.0004772475,
-0.0616130605,
0.030562181,
-0.0123036103,
0.0118600037,
-0.0560677275,
0.0276150033,
-0.0934934616,
-0.0265644975,
0.0457630232,
-0.0232498981,
-0.0435793996,
-0.0339602195,
-0.0274609253,
-0.0334509686,
0.001624027,
0.0102887303,
0.0193465017,
0.0002663731,
-0.0277235694,
-0.0877222642,
0.0833811089,
0.1083057299,
-0.0328788571,
-0.0026844165,
0.0065593598,
0.0398977809,
-0.0172735471,
0.0212084856,
-0.0478649624,
0.0530558154,
0.0399071239,
-0.0128174508,
-0.0208998695,
-0.042228099,
0.0106189037,
-0.0004581257,
0.085350804,
-0.0282777585,
-0.0243414566,
-0.0200492218,
-0.0169939697,
0.0047446126,
-0.0311227497,
0.0103926286,
-0.0119875595,
0.0215071924,
-0.0320519507,
-0.0295839421,
0.0340765677,
-0.0769719779,
0.0448500812,
-0.0436988734,
-0.0152947893,
0.0793762356,
0.0132925343,
-0.0024484142,
-0.0164474528,
-0.0252421238,
0.0090423478,
0.0332373567,
0.0412711427,
0.0011664684,
0.0661865622,
0.0132720238,
0.028701257,
-0.0264517628,
0.0058859768,
-0.0762530863,
0.0132379886,
0.0017198009,
0.0527752601,
0.0247100964,
-0.0372980088,
-0.0739763752,
-0.0254779439,
-0.0200301968,
-0.0220412929,
0.0176322442,
0.0656230971,
-0.0535102636,
0.0650994331,
0.0291833952,
-0.0222933907,
0.039348077,
0.0886582062,
-0.0117550967,
0.0354757346,
0.0138508268,
-0.0290504228,
-0.0307887252,
0.0278730057,
0.0373842716,
0.038614817,
0.0192267522,
0.0345904455,
-0.0723116398,
-0.020481484,
0.0173287019,
-0.0211277977,
0.0365495794,
0.0235942192,
0.0131395748,
0.0445113517,
-0.0029494746,
-0.0080736801,
-0.0501362048,
0.0232552532,
-0.0009974807,
-0.0074171252,
-0.0414831601,
-5.802305135e-33,
-0.0323578939,
-0.0222301558,
-0.0330115259,
0.0301004238,
0.0418762937,
0.0295991525,
0.036526572,
0.0055438732,
-0.0211634114,
0.009396581,
-0.0410637073,
-0.0150145143,
0.0270693842,
0.0265005156,
0.0171105936,
-0.0490731075,
0.0209961962,
-0.0054083029,
-0.0435266048,
0.0061924821,
0.0503525771,
0.0060214177,
0.0261795837,
-0.0100615397,
0.0544555336,
0.0046930979,
-0.0083626127,
0.0130255958,
0.0527031422,
0.043797683,
-0.0363172181,
0.0805288479,
0.0620206669,
-0.0481678545,
0.0200887416,
0.0564677306,
-0.038447313,
-0.0275256652,
-0.0157609452,
0.0174712259,
0.0034370811,
-0.0309072454,
-0.0167465135,
0.0032928896,
-0.0430239104,
-0.0191231575,
0.0589589402,
-0.0168085396,
-0.049721051,
-0.0078141419,
-0.0399765335,
0.0185707565,
0.0064570131,
-0.0173265655,
0.0259705577,
0.0476111323,
0.0067285472,
0.0215208456,
-0.0333797261,
0.0332877748,
0.0412840508,
0.0262169037,
0.020697305,
0.0563953109,
-0.0342086852,
0.0471674912,
0.0469620302,
0.0059160595,
0.012787696,
-0.0150744608,
0.0039430801,
-0.0147588374,
0.006241512,
0.0377717614,
0.082985796,
-0.0020034625,
-0.031534832,
0.0314399712,
0.0423044339,
-0.0222170874,
0.0149126742,
-0.0118541792,
-0.0615607724,
-0.0485079177,
-0.0419079475,
-0.0609678961,
-0.0616595,
0.0207852218,
0.0354178362,
0.0277580079,
0.0035298599,
0.0158633199,
0.0313717425,
-0.0122743929,
-0.0394645594,
0.0181081463,
0.0266124308,
0.0213977545,
-0.0016465917,
-0.0241989754,
-0.0402484089,
0.0024774885,
0.0291905515,
0.0182439424,
0.0119604478,
0.0165094845,
0.060433127,
0.0102606378,
-0.0645253137,
-0.0239645671,
0.0057745175,
0.0131991981,
0.0033052869,
0.0607920624,
0.0135871051,
0.0001403655,
0.0002316948,
0.0794094652,
0.0061074668,
-0.0451433994,
0.0388583243,
-0.0042621694,
-0.0304445736,
-0.0194469932,
-0.0428630002,
-0.005647569,
0.0214622226,
0.0160213262,
0.0099209994,
-0.0232094545,
-0.0095023736,
-0.0045470255,
2.516e-7,
0.0312810205,
0.0248296559,
-0.0318988562,
0.0059184409,
0.0100804428,
0.0604691654,
0.007774428,
0.0511644259,
0.0073288335,
-0.0190688353,
-0.0168060791,
-0.0291322656,
0.0072466638,
0.0010136379,
-0.091970779,
-0.0145302424,
-0.028896369,
0.0526588,
-0.0664894655,
0.0295060594,
0.0736434236,
0.0777365863,
0.0009040143,
-0.0280710422,
0.0154608926,
-0.0176130254,
0.0148045374,
-0.0273330063,
0.0274476651,
0.0185715184,
0.0437214971,
-0.003104673,
0.0197217558,
0.0778136402,
-0.0295698568,
0.0064954017,
-0.0064269537,
0.0337631628,
-0.0131654963,
-0.0129116895,
0.0008030141,
-0.0036918952,
0.0021827628,
-0.0465513282,
0.1158963665,
-0.0189444348,
-0.0210539382,
-0.0208149571,
-0.0289890505,
-0.019108139,
0.0388634168,
-0.0154503128,
-0.0277741682,
0.0021866127,
0.0199459642,
-0.0012372808,
-0.0547885858,
-0.0723428428,
0.006796082,
-0.0213269312,
-0.0055068769,
-0.0137499087,
0.0270767715,
-0.034738183,
0.0455914624,
-0.1084779352,
0.0134140784,
2.248263582e-34,
0.0000895448,
0.0173422582,
0.0198550243,
-0.0344676599,
-0.012619691,
0.0155850593,
0.0206435062,
-0.0100634862,
0.0511662327,
-0.086930491,
0.0030863364
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.