id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04979v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04979v1 | Retrieval-Augmented Meta Learning for Low-Resource Text Classification | 2023-09-10T10:05:03 | 2023-09-10T10:05:03 | Rongsheng Li, Yangning Li, Yinghui Li, Chaiyut Luoyiching, Hai-Tao Zheng, Nannan Zhou, Hanjing Su | cs.CL | cs.CL | Meta learning have achieved promising performance in low-resource text
classification which aims to identify target classes with knowledge transferred
from source classes with sets of small tasks named episodes. However, due to
the limited training data in the meta-learning scenario and the inherent
properties of parameterized neural networks, poor generalization performance
has become a pressing problem that needs to be addressed. To deal with this
issue, we propose a meta-learning based method called Retrieval-Augmented Meta
Learning(RAML). It not only uses parameterization for inference but also
retrieves non-parametric knowledge from an external corpus to make inferences,
which greatly alleviates the problem of poor generalization performance caused
by the lack of diverse training data in meta-learning. This method differs from
previous models that solely rely on parameters, as it explicitly emphasizes the
importance of non-parametric knowledge, aiming to strike a balance between
parameterized neural networks and non-parametric knowledge. The model is
required to determine which knowledge to access and utilize during inference.
Additionally, our multi-view passages fusion network module can effectively and
efficiently integrate the retrieved information into low-resource
classification task. The extensive experiments demonstrate that RAML
significantly outperforms current SOTA low-resource text classification models. | [
0.0348184034,
0.0055352403,
0.0157670677,
-0.0100613581,
0.0059961877,
0.0049767154,
0.0020307016,
-0.0119306576,
-0.0386028551,
-0.0490782522,
-0.0556460433,
0.0372369513,
0.0163847581,
-0.0105281686,
-0.0546570085,
-0.0566032082,
0.0347732864,
0.0382202938,
0.022075044,
0.0258510914,
-0.0018791568,
-0.0075610667,
0.0352284983,
0.018094128,
0.0420786738,
-0.0083116749,
-0.0080176508,
0.0078431908,
0.051818952,
0.0100903148,
0.0406728797,
0.0080901887,
0.0179664548,
0.0471105129,
0.0000019696,
-0.0253281184,
-0.0251467433,
0.0000432431,
-0.0374212749,
-0.0187680144,
0.0823902935,
0.024257319,
0.0285019036,
0.000490694,
-0.0120185809,
-0.0569925122,
0.029678151,
0.0673477203,
0.0382420309,
0.0561826006,
-0.0082686683,
-0.0067018638,
0.0029852821,
-0.0290967319,
0.0572732687,
0.0102408715,
0.0167153385,
-0.0752742067,
0.0279716998,
0.0223136842,
0.0362598859,
0.0536558554,
0.0140572414,
0.0374413952,
-0.0215237532,
0.0371793285,
-0.0493544899,
0.042346824,
0.0106967026,
0.0470557995,
-0.0235631224,
-0.0519865341,
-0.0260645337,
-0.0031886355,
0.0439638197,
0.0612366721,
-0.0301662851,
0.000606329,
-0.0259728264,
-0.0089482339,
-0.0348350443,
0.0632796884,
0.0312680639,
0.007538755,
-0.009705537,
-0.0028645659,
-0.0172969401,
-0.0279806145,
-0.0021815917,
-0.0278782956,
-0.0612062775,
0.0410185866,
-0.0218094327,
0.0092903404,
0.0652355403,
0.0059407484,
-0.0271767341,
-0.0638573542,
0.0284503344,
-0.0631098226,
0.0401589386,
0.0106367813,
-0.0154490629,
0.0396452509,
-0.0297617223,
-0.0344471708,
-0.0015526519,
0.0270034894,
-0.0346266255,
-0.0261988454,
-0.0904297456,
-0.00473664,
-0.0369378217,
0.0866045207,
-0.0084512234,
0.0357625671,
-0.0436255373,
0.0000752111,
0.0107081374,
-0.001092042,
0.0284864921,
0.0097126858,
-0.0226532128,
-0.0232893247,
-0.0130404159,
0.0216605589,
-0.0184299145,
0.0317025594,
-0.0157439634,
-0.0186125543,
0.0035334092,
0.0088815996,
0.0200653076,
-0.0315329544,
0.0398021601,
0.0122120026,
-0.0080762152,
-0.0825248435,
-0.0930417106,
-0.0088447407,
-0.0343251452,
-0.0590346158,
0.0150062405,
-0.0299276784,
-0.0003567929,
-0.013045405,
-0.0224992931,
0.0248460304,
-0.003788159,
0.0522124171,
-0.0241346285,
0.0525885485,
-0.0205262024,
-0.0537128188,
0.0476797633,
0.0339234285,
-0.0143946167,
0.0632738471,
0.020302223,
0.0433309488,
0.0117319589,
0.022161724,
0.0126266778,
-0.0265075043,
0.041338183,
0.0195866115,
-0.0000608397,
-0.0275423527,
0.0201436039,
-0.0424476899,
-0.0050691967,
0.0024458691,
-0.0427125357,
-0.0257511772,
0.0300424956,
0.0247225221,
0.0024087885,
0.0171122123,
0.0252717976,
-0.000162558,
0.0139855091,
-0.0017166327,
-0.0059502786,
0.0412674993,
-0.0315941572,
-0.0297521856,
0.0035345424,
0.0189298876,
-0.067088306,
-0.0542895384,
0.0361086056,
-0.0307950079,
-0.0507364571,
0.0201048162,
0.0707121789,
0.0140591888,
0.0023690779,
0.0170281529,
0.0404192731,
-0.0435946733,
-0.0119443471,
-0.0164551567,
-0.0139704337,
0.0071980236,
0.0489000566,
-0.1029612496,
-0.0020178298,
-0.0372871123,
0.0462508835,
0.0090682562,
0.0210313257,
-0.0138791502,
0.0135780405,
-0.0511627346,
0.0026957747,
-0.0134844342,
0.0197059456,
0.0618964694,
-0.0327517353,
-0.0134433312,
0.0367489457,
-0.072479926,
-0.0242901929,
0.0282627642,
-0.016834937,
-0.0290411562,
0.0245137252,
0.033406727,
0.0015439872,
0.0107040983,
-0.0212042015,
0.0032722231,
0.0205185432,
-0.0661907196,
-0.0202981867,
0.0288733169,
-0.0308603812,
-0.0549607538,
0.0145144667,
-0.0144692846,
0.0171076246,
0.0212289691,
-0.0249606483,
-0.0704013705,
0.0335196368,
0.0122639658,
0.0618684404,
-0.0667698011,
-0.025573764,
0.01278897,
0.0066367299,
-0.0613702387,
0.0474451929,
0.0040193903,
0.0558941737,
0.0121458452,
-0.0640891418,
0.0883403867,
0.0076311706,
-0.0435415842,
0.0255803,
-0.0393111296,
0.0421938933,
0.0378105715,
-0.0274347123,
-0.0068061776,
-0.0346165262,
-0.0701818839,
-0.0226401594,
-0.0126611236,
-0.0096843997,
-0.0128373029,
0.0210188217,
0.0086385198,
-0.0362216905,
-0.0076243449,
0.0189519692,
-0.0344161205,
0.0236013774,
0.0259750038,
0.0477149859,
0.0425450131,
-0.0190657973,
-0.0209464021,
0.0089263823,
0.0807156116,
-0.0013932426,
0.0072900066,
-0.003597897,
-0.039279867,
0.0020221742,
0.0297200903,
-0.039009437,
-0.0285003372,
-0.0250546522,
-0.0609961413,
-0.0235676542,
0.0264163204,
-0.0063031595,
-0.0693275481,
0.0473871082,
0.0518588163,
-0.0830713287,
0.027402116,
-0.0021701148,
-0.0115138991,
-0.0030699098,
0.0119781801,
-0.0152026722,
0.0368969105,
-0.0082968306,
-0.015160122,
-0.0638439506,
0.0144168036,
0.0258434899,
-0.0040833037,
-0.0530833565,
0.0287441574,
0.0054585487,
-0.0255116355,
-0.0368771851,
-0.0274864696,
0.0599344634,
-0.0021054661,
-0.0177002139,
-0.0292049665,
-0.0287147313,
-0.0402618013,
0.0110832918,
-0.0232899059,
0.0359183066,
0.0194963608,
-0.0089787738,
-0.0524864309,
-0.0347308256,
0.0398348458,
-0.0174424332,
0.06151025,
0.0026812109,
0.0395547487,
-0.0641466901,
-0.0484127365,
-0.0520545729,
-0.0334491469,
0.0255256444,
0.009902684,
-0.0399341732,
0.0161499772,
-0.081160523,
-0.0070928675,
0.0393981859,
0.0777829438,
-0.0258577131,
-0.0446227826,
0.0116735306,
0.0419601277,
0.0012939629,
-0.0028011214,
-0.0504683629,
0.0000772583,
0.036232885,
0.0374822989,
0.0255115554,
-0.0039714035,
-0.0528549664,
-0.0120015042,
0.0114433113,
-0.0350016616,
0.0180933531,
0.0103363032,
-0.0250803307,
-0.060568288,
-0.0112315267,
0.0858238786,
0.0315894969,
-0.0937390998,
-0.0617812648,
-0.0382677019,
0.0132652447,
0.0252480358,
0.0328691863,
0.0135417869,
-0.0181096159,
-0.0160082616,
0.0532994643,
0.0093183033,
-0.018043017,
-0.0143946642,
-0.0710459575,
0.0151871108,
0.0039317352,
-0.0163393095,
-0.0495517105,
-0.0462582745,
0.0036903929,
0.0094353836,
-0.0401844941,
-0.011039611,
-0.0309304371,
-0.0194735639,
0.0262149572,
0.0127860615,
-0.0139387771,
0.0008724508,
0.0032650384,
-0.0009254038,
-0.0213546958,
0.0158150084,
-0.0304517113,
0.004648325,
0.0701877996,
-0.0433979928,
-0.0043082386,
-0.0106914621,
0.0984872431,
-0.0313169211,
0.0222956482,
0.0280180816,
0.0041403174,
-0.0411610305,
-0.0497638658,
-0.0095653944,
0.0567098781,
-0.0289591886,
0.0101613505,
-0.0628510714,
-0.0346777998,
0.0064155152,
0.041470021,
-0.0019204488,
-0.0444150865,
-0.0120253135,
0.0190942083,
-0.01325671,
-0.0255404729,
0.0300377198,
0.0774587244,
0.035938289,
-0.033509478,
-0.0311495308,
-0.0363918059,
-0.0468194708,
0.0662880987,
-0.0036490813,
0.0495308228,
0.0077421092,
0.0046755164,
-0.0623257831,
-0.0003727778,
-0.0436131656,
-0.0259981416,
-0.0282773282,
0.0324818343,
0.0778341666,
-0.0818314627,
-0.0108281681,
-0.0296489112,
-0.0190683044,
-0.0137010552,
-0.0224333238,
0.0380399004,
0.0132518429,
0.0273640305,
-0.0012706897,
-0.0265878104,
0.0879706964,
0.0573014505,
0.0252580792,
-0.0186125375,
0.0743469819,
0.0179350488,
-0.0609339699,
0.014605972,
-0.0293852277,
0.0268772803,
0.0206080656,
-0.0664323345,
-0.0499714091,
0.0222343542,
0.019696014,
-0.0138897244,
0.0584331714,
0.0108295996,
-0.0319974236,
-0.0783602744,
0.0014335575,
0.0356724672,
-0.0038778393,
-0.0240039751,
0.0034332999,
0.0342795178,
-0.0224306844,
0.0026082944,
0.0230971128,
0.0001389267,
0.040704079,
0.0193371829,
0.0108532151,
0.0095521435,
0.049110949,
-0.0285500214,
0.021322906,
-0.0383780375,
0.0230253693,
0.0192630626,
0.0064879563,
-0.0510038547,
0.0408935808,
0.0213175304,
-0.0058293408,
-0.0488222577,
0.0316599943,
-0.0686641708,
0.0495128073,
-0.029470196,
0.0024981925,
0.0325370133,
0.01840581,
-0.0176145975,
-0.018800851,
-0.0239546336,
-0.0498935096,
0.0111391516,
-0.0043992363,
0.0276960637,
0.0014382994,
0.0126585448,
-0.012778041,
0.0367006212,
0.0663868412,
0.0073944316,
0.0303098187,
0.0100780204,
-0.0195245296,
-0.0584529936,
-0.0132896444,
-0.012012884,
0.0557430051,
-0.014002814,
0.0151900928,
-0.0452135652,
-0.0016543356,
0.0605006777,
-0.0280601699,
-0.0249378961,
0.0122190984,
0.0242117308,
0.036426466,
0.012651803,
-0.0095850294,
-0.0356737487,
-0.0044810115,
0.001936418,
0.0217304621,
0.0028404966,
-6.026226523e-33,
-0.0150521146,
0.0073481426,
0.0245313812,
-0.018276196,
0.0045859781,
0.0175093673,
0.0144188954,
-0.0113056162,
-0.0395242684,
-0.0042571584,
-0.0084947608,
0.0027730779,
0.0002640091,
0.0399678424,
0.0092787743,
-0.0025038973,
0.0418474562,
0.0148753459,
-0.0180526935,
0.02205915,
0.0890885666,
0.0403027758,
0.0300474707,
-0.07326103,
-0.0163623057,
0.0214723777,
0.0005551922,
-0.015179662,
0.0074384045,
0.0268556513,
0.0114076175,
0.080288358,
0.0440424159,
0.0071084988,
0.010801781,
0.0520542078,
-0.0850045905,
-0.0917622894,
-0.0143592013,
-0.0351724066,
0.0097418781,
-0.0559069142,
0.0121044479,
0.0058720582,
0.0409679562,
-0.0394128226,
0.0726523548,
-0.028250901,
-0.0414465778,
-0.0160306264,
-0.0036133018,
0.0326730534,
0.0229416657,
0.0001690196,
0.0213163458,
0.0532557555,
0.0220345128,
0.023160575,
-0.0614564009,
0.0041324552,
-0.0355499424,
0.0521523692,
-0.0368203558,
0.021780178,
-0.0157565847,
0.0428176969,
0.0034404029,
0.0550351292,
0.0431400314,
-0.0084765851,
0.0439005531,
0.019703256,
-0.0048708925,
0.0981783867,
0.0341096595,
-0.01590183,
-0.0675065741,
0.0395524763,
0.0121549508,
0.0607275367,
0.0159042496,
-0.0111224465,
-0.0605625212,
-0.0148816928,
-0.0395734087,
-0.0727519915,
-0.0358120613,
0.0163343512,
0.0079684714,
0.0668283999,
0.0150665874,
-0.0002485105,
0.0436831824,
-0.0290787667,
0.0266501736,
0.0684945211,
-0.0100942701,
0.0303610563,
0.0170608833,
-0.0104248766,
-0.067362532,
-0.0190974399,
0.0338150375,
0.0009133658,
-0.0124381837,
0.003056928,
0.0896522254,
0.0313665979,
-0.0538902357,
-0.0152657423,
0.0047704643,
-0.00366082,
-0.0026647369,
0.0286020543,
-0.0042992975,
0.047222469,
-0.000920042,
0.0458489433,
-0.0120296814,
0.0012311032,
0.0015386572,
-0.0315733738,
0.018860653,
-0.0075606033,
0.0225485824,
0.0341847129,
-0.0063935821,
0.0040489198,
0.0654247999,
-0.0540080182,
0.0345758982,
0.0226972494,
2.769e-7,
0.0390258357,
0.0074488511,
0.0267185867,
-0.0324888118,
0.0162898377,
0.0423116945,
-0.0168239642,
0.0217360295,
0.0191792753,
0.0049361046,
0.0394749567,
0.0121729933,
0.0396349542,
0.0458957925,
-0.0753021017,
-0.0388406888,
-0.0390518866,
-0.016477434,
-0.0151853198,
-0.0204358418,
0.031087812,
0.0714954212,
0.0320346691,
-0.0209065378,
0.0029153086,
-0.0582943074,
0.0811983198,
-0.0212134756,
-0.0139363604,
0.0236077607,
0.0309473146,
0.0570958816,
-0.0280978587,
-0.0023021128,
-0.0084326249,
0.0233635325,
0.0111824349,
0.0389117785,
-0.0135706849,
-0.0638638958,
0.0236714333,
0.019444894,
-0.0006700358,
0.0223319698,
0.0726493746,
-0.0921531543,
0.0008089026,
0.0154462773,
-0.0202412456,
0.0155340964,
0.0331628807,
0.0206791777,
-0.0119222952,
0.0102073615,
-0.0120664798,
-0.0071836277,
-0.0324786231,
-0.1210404262,
-0.0134545118,
0.0405909829,
-0.0335909128,
-0.0319982879,
-0.0314504206,
-0.0258951746,
0.0656565502,
-0.1127929986,
0.0354890935,
2.233478756e-34,
0.0151821468,
-0.0348667465,
-0.0147722922,
-0.0686072558,
-0.0438746028,
-0.0288219266,
-0.0500771441,
-0.0222828202,
0.0428173617,
-0.0548650324,
0.0154234348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04977v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04977v1 | RGAT: A Deeper Look into Syntactic Dependency Information for Coreference Resolution | 2023-09-10T09:46:38 | 2023-09-10T09:46:38 | Yuan Meng, Xuhao Pan, Jun Chang, Yue Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 14J60 (Primary) 14F05, 14J26 (Secondary) | Although syntactic information is beneficial for many NLP tasks, combining it
with contextual information between words to solve the coreference resolution
problem needs to be further explored. In this paper, we propose an end-to-end
parser that combines pre-trained BERT with a Syntactic Relation Graph Attention
Network (RGAT) to take a deeper look into the role of syntactic dependency
information for the coreference resolution task. In particular, the RGAT model
is first proposed, then used to understand the syntactic dependency graph and
learn better task-specific syntactic embeddings. An integrated architecture
incorporating BERT embeddings and syntactic embeddings is constructed to
generate blending representations for the downstream task. Our experiments on a
public Gendered Ambiguous Pronouns (GAP) dataset show that with the supervision
learning of the syntactic dependency graph and without fine-tuning the entire
BERT, we increased the F1-score of the previous best model (RGCN-with-BERT)
from 80.3% to 82.5%, compared to the F1-score by single BERT embeddings from
78.5% to 82.5%. Experimental results on another public dataset - OntoNotes 5.0
demonstrate that the performance of the model is also improved by incorporating
syntactic dependency information learned from RGAT. | [
0.0551833585,
-0.0085501838,
0.0210817717,
0.0396016277,
-0.0188632682,
0.0009617066,
-0.0398129113,
-0.027363997,
0.0570337288,
-0.0276710317,
-0.0006176108,
0.0073234965,
-0.021339884,
-0.0278471932,
0.0105983112,
-0.0516418926,
0.0410349742,
0.0523002632,
0.0087915249,
-0.0083447471,
0.0173277576,
0.0185623784,
0.0189765319,
0.0249536503,
-0.0532891303,
-0.0328671038,
0.0061360081,
0.0360654816,
0.0290183332,
0.0245826542,
0.0438965224,
0.0423166603,
-0.0010281826,
0.0199412759,
0.0000017087,
-0.0693586543,
-0.0259716008,
-0.0012931257,
-0.0239235945,
-0.0033306486,
-0.0291503351,
0.0195385646,
-0.0002800816,
0.0201903712,
-0.0080423532,
-0.0197642576,
0.0275199246,
0.0713069811,
0.076199919,
0.0363081023,
-0.0095850918,
-0.0333376117,
0.0037840568,
-0.0355405249,
-0.0486267097,
-0.056841366,
0.0021485854,
-0.0048236093,
-0.0204689149,
-0.0155902412,
-0.0209365338,
0.0215866938,
0.0396058336,
-0.0033068494,
0.0423528738,
0.0303934868,
-0.0785288587,
-0.0032607031,
0.0172536299,
0.0970160067,
0.0037052641,
0.0110034831,
0.0144005828,
0.0190171804,
-0.0159591325,
-0.0182710737,
0.004163343,
-0.0279372241,
-0.0398996137,
0.0114967991,
0.0171516016,
-0.0307822563,
-0.0012997896,
0.0214448068,
-0.0437431745,
0.0924481824,
0.0077362871,
-0.0180992242,
0.0683766231,
0.0273012668,
-0.0748750642,
-0.0539514869,
0.0811001807,
0.0125717064,
-0.0289286338,
0.026094364,
-0.0511795282,
-0.0070347027,
-0.0038178521,
-0.0808071494,
0.0031709764,
0.0339810178,
-0.0443995744,
0.0344770886,
-0.0575009547,
0.05557473,
-0.0439049676,
0.0308187753,
-0.0239501726,
-0.0493274368,
-0.0583615154,
0.0075891586,
-0.0869805291,
0.0494805388,
-0.0422475673,
-0.0279530361,
-0.0445139483,
-0.0047682505,
-0.0027620248,
0.0153077673,
0.0430549085,
0.022542879,
-0.0429686569,
-0.0063418299,
0.0016527278,
0.0580602735,
-0.0556899682,
-0.0210895054,
-0.0376606882,
-0.018294666,
-0.0250780657,
-0.0064281337,
0.0452577136,
-0.0450344048,
-0.0134467101,
0.0139692696,
0.0200135559,
-0.0340215228,
-0.0084190005,
-0.0220193975,
-0.0537048094,
-0.0327173658,
-0.0274844971,
-0.0523123331,
0.0179872941,
0.0172128249,
0.0083066849,
-0.0300709531,
0.0479002744,
0.0234162156,
-0.0303297136,
0.0566434041,
0.0447418652,
-0.0342984982,
0.0257081967,
-0.0178614557,
-0.002595911,
0.0670030341,
0.032648325,
-0.0032791959,
-0.0077416645,
0.0431869365,
-0.0621466823,
0.0111424513,
0.0522457659,
0.0134057207,
0.026457021,
0.0118148914,
-0.0584965348,
0.0340036526,
0.0460280254,
0.0661978796,
-0.0025454641,
-0.0475426875,
0.0018627595,
0.0142323431,
-0.0025109733,
0.0079125576,
0.0061863633,
0.0240668729,
0.00330614,
0.0695569888,
-0.0499080606,
0.0149825746,
0.0114260782,
-0.0062525743,
0.0197175611,
0.0020340909,
-0.0058790916,
0.0014667131,
-0.0062092994,
0.0070816651,
-0.0157241095,
-0.0223501436,
0.0336949304,
0.0431182384,
-0.0746287704,
0.0593542606,
0.0184435379,
-0.0373493396,
0.0007869543,
0.0112316413,
-0.0431139395,
0.0220406204,
0.0369151346,
-0.0308720749,
-0.0917296857,
-0.0078439107,
0.0070436238,
0.0092845019,
0.020920001,
-0.0147526339,
0.0349860303,
-0.0482484326,
-0.0221970491,
0.0108534247,
0.0014972306,
0.0451274477,
0.0243060384,
-0.0305177402,
0.0305918418,
-0.0198822394,
-0.0056782197,
0.018641239,
0.0159873422,
0.0097007379,
0.020187255,
0.045104906,
0.036374677,
0.0357333571,
-0.0067011788,
0.0015352091,
0.0104742609,
-0.0367394164,
-0.019282205,
0.0257020127,
-0.0692136809,
-0.0592952892,
0.0068745157,
-0.0599964745,
-0.0703086406,
0.0099693844,
-0.0354688764,
-0.0549950004,
-0.0064084618,
-0.0641574264,
0.0872552618,
-0.0211091675,
-0.0106581571,
0.0520274602,
0.0023653226,
-0.0224657226,
0.0783885419,
-0.0198644307,
0.0170304235,
0.0339492932,
0.0161695015,
0.0283090509,
-0.0499263294,
-0.0105532343,
-0.0182150714,
-0.0042092903,
-0.0184883513,
0.0312352926,
-0.0004758743,
-0.0650359243,
-0.0253008697,
-0.0676621944,
-0.002579212,
-0.0173452515,
0.0303379036,
0.0315305293,
0.0265769511,
0.0148585886,
-0.0301511139,
0.0185626093,
0.0000989598,
0.0091180364,
-0.0034497699,
0.035172116,
0.0463799983,
-0.0081072683,
-0.0573650487,
-0.0193673577,
-0.0515625477,
0.0218325779,
0.0139669105,
-0.0461752936,
0.0122624012,
0.0215078648,
-0.003046094,
0.0470419228,
0.0220399983,
-0.0425789133,
-0.0144276852,
-0.0035046157,
0.0717759579,
0.0546436831,
-0.0334502868,
0.0125571042,
-0.0100871623,
-0.0901870877,
-0.061047323,
0.0576208979,
0.0096366741,
-0.0261904299,
-0.0135187004,
-0.0010250369,
0.0153726973,
0.0535652637,
0.0077461922,
-0.0243138727,
-0.0645644069,
-0.0141231287,
-0.033608567,
-0.0135401962,
0.0404020585,
-0.0215471406,
-0.0399031304,
-0.0171344224,
-0.0859751403,
0.0305909775,
0.0962335318,
-0.0100017088,
-0.033061292,
-0.051530771,
0.0521839038,
-0.0409873836,
0.0545645319,
0.0006813215,
0.0163471326,
0.0617591366,
-0.1194871664,
-0.0293155555,
-0.0055053933,
0.0221477952,
-0.0095771607,
0.0356778614,
-0.0262737293,
0.0355939344,
-0.0011174594,
-0.0053005284,
-0.0500862375,
0.0070511037,
-0.032175988,
-0.0106194625,
-0.0003015579,
-0.0041843369,
0.0310763922,
-0.0210163593,
-0.0058178026,
0.0260166842,
0.008859152,
0.0034061612,
-0.048457548,
0.0521517284,
-0.0166405905,
0.0131335054,
-0.0069752308,
-0.0097700236,
-0.0024220149,
0.0194453262,
0.0552367754,
-0.0195132606,
-0.0133130653,
-0.0082064951,
0.0132874819,
-0.0578776337,
-0.0400052853,
-0.0439415723,
0.0552405268,
-0.0616733469,
-0.0209477618,
0.1009796858,
0.0528791584,
-0.000862279,
-0.0309584029,
-0.0021711518,
0.0185156167,
0.0242142063,
0.0207988378,
-0.026289966,
-0.0253469329,
0.0292951223,
-0.0251685902,
0.0275768079,
-0.0575524084,
-0.0082306033,
-0.1002220213,
0.0059390771,
-0.0218632054,
-0.0256104842,
-0.0613536648,
-0.0062600044,
0.0436620489,
-0.0027316303,
0.0091549009,
-0.0172617417,
-0.0062235207,
0.0124572115,
-0.0068283789,
-0.0201647561,
0.0075016785,
0.0321804807,
-0.0673169121,
0.0110865394,
0.0682438612,
0.0743263215,
0.0126314498,
0.0555882491,
0.0459342189,
-0.0498869792,
-0.0263239648,
-0.0401871875,
0.0437681749,
-0.0146392006,
-0.0193489101,
-0.0250723846,
0.0192288663,
0.011116514,
0.0232200194,
-0.0280494727,
0.0292278286,
0.0285328384,
0.027324263,
0.0240680687,
0.0157274809,
-0.0065108971,
0.0517950617,
0.0400889367,
-0.0049122609,
-0.0484350398,
-0.0218557939,
0.0531218983,
-0.0658153519,
-0.0000317087,
0.0151455998,
-0.0253689867,
0.013787264,
-0.0539574437,
-0.0582489371,
0.0479336604,
-0.0031880944,
0.0169390347,
-0.0394402482,
0.0450545438,
0.0005644607,
-0.0308136791,
0.0204382222,
-0.015512282,
0.0229849778,
-0.0517728887,
0.0201576222,
0.0537261888,
0.0525090955,
-0.0134487953,
0.0564489663,
-0.0012892386,
-0.0350093134,
0.010294144,
0.0233859643,
0.0093431044,
0.0440259576,
-0.0895436034,
-0.0283966493,
-0.0103451116,
0.0140019963,
-0.0336502865,
0.0135643641,
0.0691112578,
0.0230080113,
0.0047663972,
0.0633158833,
-0.0305141769,
-0.0062559349,
-0.0111705633,
0.0584922396,
-0.0176583119,
-0.0817213431,
0.0438901968,
0.0032242204,
0.0042645973,
-0.0016377942,
0.0712883025,
-0.0503369868,
0.0482301079,
-0.0086368946,
-0.001438472,
-0.0128872283,
0.0026042443,
0.0154258376,
-0.0001514706,
0.0123664634,
0.0128308209,
-0.0121760005,
0.0343957804,
-0.010293006,
0.007001224,
0.0485459603,
-0.027490532,
0.0127122849,
-0.0136370463,
-0.0150934542,
-0.0508353077,
0.0284841303,
0.0200559124,
-0.0217368919,
0.0244655088,
0.0152431987,
-0.0399460793,
0.002282596,
-0.0422932729,
-0.0366679728,
0.0222960077,
-0.0455446467,
-0.0014607979,
0.0719033554,
-0.0301570855,
0.0868304372,
-0.0144994492,
-0.016341228,
-0.0051616142,
-0.0017532026,
-0.0330094695,
0.0079734121,
-0.0009005285,
0.0131523507,
0.0307717174,
0.0296683256,
0.0409784056,
0.029636696,
0.0452342518,
-0.0004497595,
-0.0107488027,
-0.0548967831,
-0.045229625,
-0.0336537957,
-0.0015190818,
-0.013971692,
0.0409006849,
-0.0334358625,
-0.0457966924,
0.0654854625,
-0.0326890722,
-0.0086509576,
0.0067780083,
0.0351714119,
-0.0031122379,
0.0247006882,
-0.0540747233,
-0.0061208992,
0.0384373851,
0.044022087,
-0.0344624631,
-0.0227120146,
-5.877246206e-33,
-0.0908513591,
-0.0247733053,
-0.0365039259,
-0.0087026767,
-0.0375546217,
0.0329705738,
-0.0690460503,
-0.0150793809,
-0.0221019015,
0.0333984196,
-0.0261906199,
0.0379829928,
0.0092828646,
0.0361062847,
-0.0125099225,
-0.0228724629,
0.0599099249,
0.0375276729,
0.0125869894,
-0.0120177139,
0.0300997291,
0.055921711,
0.0723998472,
-0.0666773096,
0.0289779473,
0.022436006,
-0.0130194984,
0.0410704724,
0.0025051401,
0.0414503664,
0.0098059019,
0.0430832505,
-0.0065733823,
-0.0125780022,
-0.0092125311,
0.0525505394,
-0.1698212475,
-0.0466573797,
0.014832384,
0.0250597745,
-0.0165105797,
-0.0153411208,
0.0448597148,
-0.0110789882,
0.0672367439,
-0.0144174322,
0.0449405722,
-0.0033157426,
0.0119006503,
-0.0104685519,
-0.0461988077,
0.0298103932,
0.0001889808,
-0.0347457305,
0.0169769712,
0.033722911,
0.009422604,
-0.0174879748,
-0.0431109741,
-0.0329620503,
-0.0608831905,
0.0229523107,
-0.0355096459,
0.0373203829,
-0.0068783374,
0.0160002783,
-0.0277795754,
-0.0429461263,
-0.0272740182,
-0.0307149552,
0.0010337913,
0.0303031635,
-0.0175357666,
0.027599737,
-0.027114084,
0.0411920175,
-0.0451059639,
-0.0114146853,
0.0563936606,
0.0636904463,
-0.0169840641,
-0.0026111633,
-0.0237938166,
-0.027310688,
-0.0297121201,
-0.0401873775,
-0.0262819529,
-0.0250783768,
0.0052523892,
-0.0139395706,
-0.0269085038,
0.0261640344,
0.0143860895,
-0.0437441543,
-0.0327442996,
0.0088405497,
0.0380640104,
0.0211252887,
0.019259965,
0.0705486238,
-0.050659053,
0.0059196758,
0.0116387149,
0.0022195422,
0.0019870833,
-0.0138408672,
0.0482030027,
-0.0293253679,
-0.0455616228,
-0.0040654698,
-0.0545091406,
0.0143295219,
-0.0743496716,
0.0349057876,
0.041266337,
0.0291099325,
-0.0084548835,
0.0543689243,
0.0428539403,
0.0595892183,
-0.0615681075,
-0.0135508021,
0.0150067834,
0.0543829724,
0.0129999947,
-0.0179281235,
0.0016487342,
0.0494639017,
-0.0098057929,
-0.0253710635,
-0.0237216577,
-0.0104512153,
2.538e-7,
0.0473537147,
0.0267858244,
0.1110388711,
-0.0102041522,
-0.0167342257,
-0.0082287043,
0.0091500059,
0.0524638481,
0.009983113,
-0.0605886988,
-0.0105218478,
0.0120730735,
-0.0005140315,
0.0126409857,
-0.0924574584,
-0.0020377927,
-0.0306295641,
-0.0234069824,
-0.0166885108,
0.0058632977,
0.0242541656,
0.0758260116,
0.0673701614,
0.0270674694,
-0.0411899649,
0.0060939947,
0.0354965515,
0.0219708513,
-0.0194247421,
0.0268148035,
-0.0121887233,
0.0163880475,
-0.0206627063,
0.0310965776,
0.0056635747,
0.0238618869,
0.0404726602,
0.0512747951,
0.006063018,
-0.0372306667,
-0.018199686,
-0.0095394682,
0.0163297616,
-0.0034006878,
0.0514040999,
-0.0769106299,
-0.0065310793,
-0.0074224388,
-0.0332825109,
0.0219606049,
-0.0001587412,
0.0126060154,
-0.0246740058,
0.0275153816,
0.0048488146,
-0.0150463227,
-0.0236610379,
-0.0784318969,
-0.036976859,
0.0454039685,
-0.0135973748,
-0.0120549928,
0.0074273143,
-0.021584725,
-0.0088963937,
-0.0273654964,
-0.0058222925,
2.244693936e-34,
0.0074981716,
0.0085583869,
0.0273144022,
0.0248777196,
0.0178970657,
-0.0183357913,
-0.0610814355,
0.0132852662,
0.0315832607,
-0.0030366017,
-0.0011359282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04971v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04971v1 | Prompt Learning With Knowledge Memorizing Prototypes For Generalized Few-Shot Intent Detection | 2023-09-10T09:16:38 | 2023-09-10T09:16:38 | Chaiyut Luoyiching, Yangning Li, Yinghui Li, Rongsheng Li, Hai-Tao Zheng, Nannan Zhou, Hanjing Su | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generalized Few-Shot Intent Detection (GFSID) is challenging and realistic
because it needs to categorize both seen and novel intents simultaneously.
Previous GFSID methods rely on the episodic learning paradigm, which makes it
hard to extend to a generalized setup as they do not explicitly learn the
classification of seen categories and the knowledge of seen intents. To address
the dilemma, we propose to convert the GFSID task into the class incremental
learning paradigm. Specifically, we propose a two-stage learning framework,
which sequentially learns the knowledge of different intents in various periods
via prompt learning. And then we exploit prototypes for categorizing both seen
and novel intents. Furthermore, to achieve the transfer knowledge of intents in
different stages, for different scenarios we design two knowledge preservation
methods which close to realistic applications. Extensive experiments and
detailed analyses on two widely used datasets show that our framework based on
the class incremental learning paradigm achieves promising performance. | [
0.0276589338,
0.0521401353,
-0.0152710183,
0.0001294665,
-0.0343048647,
0.0426061861,
0.0187292974,
0.0139558446,
0.0389621817,
-0.0560180508,
0.009607912,
-0.0178809687,
-0.0256166514,
0.0308421049,
-0.033518251,
-0.0142828366,
0.072306633,
-0.0166986044,
0.0458499119,
0.0456146859,
0.027702596,
0.0011332951,
-0.0137794297,
0.0161921158,
-0.0485722944,
-0.022819275,
-0.0599430092,
-0.0129093677,
0.0264507588,
-0.0564586371,
0.0280005075,
0.0581511967,
0.0579525493,
0.0214613061,
0.0000020117,
-0.0742438361,
-0.0239276942,
-0.0408316925,
-0.0801379085,
-0.0360503867,
0.0208944641,
-0.0129900258,
0.014708044,
-0.0081179347,
-0.0321138203,
-0.0312004779,
0.0031403182,
0.0346671902,
0.0224564783,
0.0276429337,
-0.0164242014,
-0.0474481769,
0.0312935933,
-0.0166363623,
0.0705149099,
-0.0549211241,
0.0297511388,
-0.0365773328,
-0.0552088693,
0.0081848903,
0.0016400159,
0.0097895218,
0.0041124495,
-0.0065620528,
0.0215265695,
0.0053515066,
0.0213960707,
-0.0129303634,
-0.040816199,
0.0216579624,
-0.0301593859,
0.0029555308,
-0.0112255644,
-0.0364808254,
-0.0070381714,
-0.0644723326,
-0.0087214913,
-0.0071991938,
-0.0414274819,
-0.0197687931,
-0.0029755961,
0.0080110282,
-0.0207956806,
0.0221743379,
-0.0182379168,
-0.028880205,
-0.0037041081,
0.0008043771,
0.0176732447,
-0.0271309558,
0.0167393461,
-0.0194104612,
-0.0054873633,
0.0712182745,
-0.0428650752,
0.0255443566,
-0.0357722305,
0.0133610107,
0.047443904,
0.0063850768,
0.0216882098,
0.0255677085,
-0.0127189886,
0.0880690813,
-0.0140427649,
0.0295148361,
0.0469715185,
-0.0002960993,
-0.0628242865,
0.0207326375,
-0.1018555611,
0.0007265696,
-0.0758232921,
0.0518311113,
0.0256271977,
-0.0035372046,
-0.0189068969,
0.0379534811,
0.0211186148,
0.0055556986,
-0.0382469036,
-0.0225082915,
-0.0173026491,
0.0439115055,
0.0168760698,
0.0052118548,
-0.0194636621,
0.0574396662,
0.0105364947,
-0.0320577174,
-0.0357826017,
0.0073563247,
0.0167030394,
0.0057349387,
0.0023354732,
0.0049056862,
-0.0345546715,
-0.0858839154,
-0.0623771548,
-0.0212009121,
-0.0162249468,
0.0063218269,
-0.0381826162,
-0.026275564,
0.0194248427,
-0.0283376332,
-0.0117967268,
0.0038402195,
-0.0061491835,
0.0005672479,
0.0054131378,
0.0900460482,
0.0100988476,
-0.0052954573,
-0.0113332551,
0.0433456153,
-0.0377831534,
0.0564009286,
-0.0367566533,
0.0315625183,
0.0115128029,
0.0194563176,
0.0410698205,
0.001073572,
0.0215682201,
0.0237034094,
0.0251367968,
0.0112812417,
0.0558882542,
0.0077959984,
-0.0129722711,
-0.0289541427,
-0.0190342925,
-0.0117811179,
0.0511626452,
0.0187585838,
0.0119183911,
-0.050816901,
0.0319801867,
0.0365078747,
-0.0055347788,
-0.0060406863,
-0.0159138087,
0.0146105913,
-0.0455440544,
-0.0573489144,
-0.0891890675,
-0.0012498992,
-0.0575252287,
-0.0101178456,
0.0346720368,
-0.0303194951,
-0.0139182564,
-0.0076816198,
0.0381994806,
0.034151189,
-0.0139243845,
0.0162241906,
-0.0034771462,
0.0033435645,
-0.0416330546,
-0.0687268451,
0.0736459568,
0.0278886966,
-0.0091327569,
-0.0569729879,
-0.0545507744,
-0.0419422016,
0.0020852198,
-0.0210879929,
0.0065962235,
-0.0391043536,
0.0872726515,
-0.0196732711,
-0.0384234078,
0.0045157489,
0.0060749198,
-0.0031019731,
-0.0358924493,
0.0257032271,
-0.0001856328,
-0.0050261938,
0.0472089238,
0.034283977,
0.0301101729,
-0.02670018,
0.0080211358,
0.0346095487,
0.0085352315,
-0.0086666597,
0.0436766036,
-0.0427299216,
0.0187716596,
-0.0231072772,
0.0034398122,
0.0201708507,
-0.031140767,
-0.0804851949,
-0.0053233872,
0.0729095116,
-0.0550559647,
-0.0506006293,
-0.0365080535,
-0.0172815155,
-0.0438499823,
0.0076392442,
0.0096875858,
-0.076060228,
-0.0074181072,
-0.0111433156,
-0.0040292358,
-0.0124838995,
0.0529376417,
-0.000580718,
-0.0204658173,
0.0631914511,
-0.0474467799,
0.0346756242,
-0.003227893,
0.020463204,
-0.0104320934,
-0.0455885269,
-0.0165668502,
0.0088901091,
0.0436524935,
-0.0693890452,
0.0025973693,
-0.0460699648,
0.0068462333,
-0.023068931,
-0.0229390096,
-0.0263270941,
0.0134468023,
0.0007357884,
-0.0266824532,
0.0025981278,
0.0446298234,
-0.0382501855,
0.0241594035,
0.0112710362,
0.0204213336,
-0.0101962099,
0.0186577085,
0.0582902245,
0.0093656927,
0.0246649552,
-0.0101779476,
-0.0212873407,
-0.0546967871,
0.0128817288,
0.006571258,
-0.0000639429,
-0.0135555994,
-0.0190672185,
0.0266605131,
-0.021972483,
-0.0028911829,
0.0452567376,
0.0232074056,
0.0184041765,
-0.010034821,
-0.0240733288,
-0.0388758667,
0.026293695,
-0.018107323,
-0.0183286816,
-0.017967103,
0.0171341393,
0.009220616,
0.0403779782,
-0.0033681581,
0.0049269125,
-0.0329839848,
-0.0146949962,
0.0139472084,
-0.0589295067,
-0.1240351945,
0.0199557189,
-0.0180045031,
-0.0179270618,
0.0110351983,
-0.0323311575,
0.0562735498,
0.0346285664,
-0.0024813435,
-0.0243864357,
-0.0206937343,
0.002130012,
0.085846208,
0.0019700595,
0.0276052281,
0.0340328366,
-0.0409203954,
-0.0310547203,
-0.0298510008,
-0.0194010325,
0.0136905788,
0.0423836075,
-0.0089642098,
-0.0132006519,
-0.022878781,
-0.0216301326,
-0.0777267441,
-0.0975625217,
0.0125651583,
0.0102425357,
-0.0723169893,
0.0228554588,
0.0020564434,
0.0120442118,
-0.0039695399,
0.0502036363,
0.0121466015,
-0.0412583649,
-0.0149276173,
0.0583807752,
0.0194873046,
-0.0338829383,
-0.049223993,
0.0209396929,
0.0742623433,
0.0781976581,
0.0173936076,
-0.0016177025,
-0.0043662325,
0.0309256371,
0.0103626931,
-0.0077365479,
-0.0113200434,
0.0197038837,
0.0497906916,
-0.0035020944,
-0.0024769474,
0.0781033188,
0.0388925448,
-0.0505796969,
-0.0034709114,
-0.001166939,
-0.0058768555,
0.0291906185,
0.0048026349,
-0.0569909364,
-0.0561537147,
-0.0130472137,
0.0113053415,
-0.0237241648,
-0.0124524077,
-0.0220641661,
-0.0777974725,
0.0151592186,
-0.0044638515,
-0.0784961581,
0.0331620723,
-0.0401524007,
0.0054289699,
0.0275856182,
-0.0270991027,
0.0219891295,
0.018868383,
-0.0485928692,
-0.007814927,
-0.0169743951,
-0.007702366,
0.0363806263,
-0.0148030994,
0.0484961085,
-0.0060914615,
0.0150301522,
0.0252822693,
-0.0233533178,
-0.0035694507,
-0.102642782,
0.034384612,
-0.015317969,
0.0276712216,
-0.0274215844,
0.0214323495,
0.0066646142,
0.0372365601,
-0.0357655436,
-0.0912014246,
0.0436928868,
0.051233612,
-0.0408381335,
-0.0036398387,
-0.0260219369,
-0.0463052802,
0.0848791003,
0.0831148997,
-0.0018139323,
-0.055462528,
0.0301544648,
0.010097865,
-0.0068738852,
-0.0298675913,
0.0513558686,
0.0239732061,
-0.0179207325,
-0.000302195,
-0.0188206621,
-0.0419780277,
0.0267086215,
0.0176506285,
0.0006488286,
0.0200197659,
-0.0246607624,
0.0124960709,
-0.0517190509,
-0.0469223484,
0.0006323072,
0.0251618605,
-0.0052478858,
-0.0425373428,
0.0348240174,
-0.0420783721,
-0.0088521242,
-0.0247179028,
-0.0675438941,
0.0060802191,
0.003723118,
0.052793622,
0.0098292343,
0.0630410016,
-0.0279963743,
0.0269449595,
0.0444407091,
0.0297342092,
0.0367987864,
0.0173137039,
0.047853563,
0.0298793484,
-0.0268195551,
0.0153386053,
-0.0386891216,
0.0290070791,
0.036557585,
-0.0352245346,
-0.0867903978,
-0.0124691995,
0.0528676994,
-0.0105781816,
0.0562753044,
-0.0054228376,
-0.0057919621,
-0.005485977,
0.0503413826,
0.0291862488,
0.0019151389,
-0.0295577012,
-0.0107865473,
0.0132683069,
0.0005623706,
-0.0201637633,
0.0125168152,
0.0000221036,
-0.0180773064,
-0.0388361514,
-0.0328648649,
0.0363546573,
0.0123835392,
-0.0067678764,
0.0076302895,
-0.0462694429,
0.0523889624,
-0.0185270216,
-0.0032231533,
-0.002307249,
0.1206757873,
0.0345039144,
-0.0054025645,
-0.0079568727,
0.0487712398,
-0.0074479152,
-0.0138120549,
0.0117848311,
0.0151722264,
0.020933209,
0.0065352526,
-0.0511912741,
-0.0080822352,
0.0137183825,
-0.0145798521,
0.0635330677,
-0.0201018583,
-0.0782725066,
0.0034981784,
0.0086514587,
-0.0034607698,
0.0361002907,
0.0527075715,
-0.1016923636,
0.0618437864,
0.006004435,
0.0339033008,
-0.0587917306,
0.0422365032,
0.0846274123,
0.0144732026,
0.0004052842,
0.0104401857,
-0.0081739547,
-0.00070136,
0.0241273846,
-0.0593197942,
0.0276773535,
0.0517864041,
0.0507615022,
0.0337597504,
-0.0163986497,
-0.0529883131,
-0.0119212503,
-0.0237260088,
-0.0367267318,
0.0216905344,
0.0052563576,
-5.867788619e-33,
-0.0015999695,
0.034222547,
0.0125600277,
-0.0045770463,
0.0057767066,
0.0323624201,
-0.0200956613,
-0.036086835,
0.0099176718,
-0.0041781901,
-0.0002317524,
0.029037524,
0.0057412898,
0.0124381008,
0.03539465,
-0.0411564037,
0.0352781452,
0.0018731176,
-0.0020930334,
0.0376382694,
0.0759484172,
0.0387496315,
0.0295400694,
-0.0263255425,
-0.0486867055,
0.029618131,
-0.0590744317,
0.0560934432,
-0.00885987,
0.0659980401,
-0.0173217654,
0.0214063171,
0.0432184562,
-0.0263961051,
-0.0185192749,
0.0296811722,
-0.0701761171,
-0.0322278664,
-0.0370106734,
0.0213195011,
-0.0572516285,
-0.0175895561,
-0.0357541591,
-0.02369662,
0.0205271021,
-0.0034662695,
0.0026089496,
-0.0271325,
-0.0235015061,
-0.0217806082,
-0.0340312794,
-0.0050885044,
0.0009662115,
-0.0241934936,
-0.0112818591,
0.0132458173,
0.0219813623,
-0.0376410186,
-0.0646835864,
0.011753004,
-0.0455390438,
0.0033408003,
-0.0284247007,
0.0251119416,
-0.0060863383,
0.0855650231,
0.0343367085,
-0.0319969878,
0.0112899588,
0.006145901,
-0.0178118479,
0.0487215184,
0.0211614724,
0.0300170742,
0.0494810604,
-0.0510597415,
-0.0464825779,
0.0109102447,
0.0644528568,
0.0368829928,
0.0101786451,
0.0222510677,
0.0005872725,
0.0098188091,
-0.0201750845,
0.0044620982,
-0.0421122275,
0.0129542286,
0.0471553765,
0.0737189576,
-0.0231634956,
-0.0203637909,
0.0681234002,
-0.0058103236,
0.0313586369,
0.0309592951,
-0.0198850092,
0.0331683047,
0.0101225236,
0.0309430733,
-0.0664537698,
-0.0555692837,
0.0627731234,
-0.0114731798,
0.02295449,
0.0312579311,
0.0749941841,
0.0631071553,
-0.0265094638,
-0.0174609944,
-0.0009886537,
0.0274059623,
-0.0138176493,
0.0013673166,
0.0209886972,
0.0179202352,
-0.0350303352,
0.0645279586,
0.0093314806,
-0.0534015745,
-0.0326054767,
0.0087690428,
0.0162648074,
0.0019040483,
-0.0059564509,
-0.0257452093,
0.0029288281,
-0.0557356663,
-0.002600224,
-0.0563867986,
0.0171355475,
0.019282233,
2.726e-7,
-0.0264138281,
-0.0080807954,
-0.0133904982,
0.0168762226,
0.0486931615,
0.0572303534,
-0.0215297397,
0.0725813508,
-0.0017144051,
-0.0076039843,
0.0542821363,
0.0003412239,
0.0014972757,
-0.0008372791,
-0.0799810141,
0.0030873371,
0.0376162864,
-0.0102552036,
-0.0739936009,
0.0504443422,
0.0979803428,
0.0848402828,
0.0374776721,
-0.0420460664,
0.0529753566,
-0.050174281,
0.0561178029,
0.0197905302,
0.0348676108,
-0.0078689288,
0.0307077225,
0.0061940867,
0.0064822426,
0.0782882124,
-0.0245471876,
-0.0382308327,
-0.0567107424,
0.0307438057,
-0.0136027364,
-0.034821678,
-0.0398517027,
0.0525782146,
0.0175057407,
-0.0426533036,
0.0980689302,
-0.0646570325,
-0.0210117511,
0.0236874856,
-0.0207332559,
-0.0260878094,
-0.0074951272,
0.0573346429,
-0.0007507787,
0.0117914686,
0.0064228382,
0.0417709276,
-0.0490351394,
-0.0982425809,
0.0247745309,
-0.0254671481,
-0.01563292,
-0.0276592188,
-0.0033670552,
0.008588721,
0.0361215323,
-0.1061043963,
-0.0203762185,
2.027428601e-34,
-0.011019066,
-0.030482715,
0.0311543625,
0.0282635726,
-0.0402583182,
-0.0041065761,
-0.0239839144,
0.0076002278,
0.0398845598,
-0.0372191295,
0.0034763322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04965v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04965v2 | Prefix-diffusion: A Lightweight Diffusion Model for Diverse Image Captioning | 2023-09-10T08:55:24 | 2023-10-17T01:30:57 | Guisheng Liu, Yi Li, Zhengcong Fei, Haiyan Fu, Xiangyang Luo, Yanqing Guo | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | While impressive performance has been achieved in image captioning, the
limited diversity of the generated captions and the large parameter scale
remain major barriers to the real-word application of these systems. In this
work, we propose a lightweight image captioning network in combination with
continuous diffusion, called Prefix-diffusion. To achieve diversity, we design
an efficient method that injects prefix image embeddings into the denoising
process of the diffusion model. In order to reduce trainable parameters, we
employ a pre-trained model to extract image features and further design an
extra mapping network. Prefix-diffusion is able to generate diverse captions
with relatively less parameters, while maintaining the fluency and relevance of
the captions benefiting from the generative capabilities of the diffusion
model. Our work paves the way for scaling up diffusion models for image
captioning, and achieves promising performance compared with recent approaches. | [
0.0178875327,
0.0353275873,
0.0090964446,
0.0250692312,
0.0402144007,
-0.0024993599,
0.005497063,
0.0041431817,
0.0148943225,
-0.0100199161,
0.0026736069,
-0.05277263,
-0.0165435113,
0.0696911067,
0.0104651479,
-0.0888580903,
0.0363578424,
-0.0281213671,
-0.033313781,
-0.0233868603,
0.0150520951,
0.0008300011,
0.0220322851,
0.0194286294,
-0.0254087467,
0.0055530118,
-0.0109509034,
0.0135472957,
0.013557449,
-0.0230468232,
-0.0151061863,
0.072658807,
0.102577664,
-0.0266718604,
0.0000019731,
0.0347289443,
0.0142011335,
0.0250582509,
0.0191707965,
-0.0023449876,
0.0462827459,
0.0086853784,
0.0229970831,
-0.0040373579,
-0.0128130401,
-0.0044619334,
0.0924717188,
0.0409357212,
0.0839459375,
0.0411650576,
-0.0275865775,
-0.0706747323,
0.0044543366,
-0.0698859841,
0.0320798084,
-0.0139691094,
-0.0254750121,
0.063564837,
0.0006164194,
0.0028043461,
-0.041927509,
0.0405945331,
0.0096370783,
-0.0110773509,
0.0583936945,
0.0697644353,
0.0531025827,
-0.0251195971,
-0.022480173,
0.1023044437,
-0.0153420568,
0.0530886054,
-0.0160876792,
0.0012959235,
-0.0058957357,
-0.0173161235,
-0.0553725362,
-0.0095381821,
0.0568558089,
0.0238875709,
-0.0687858909,
0.0470159799,
0.0330730826,
0.0026905157,
-0.0111928238,
-0.03943865,
0.0287648104,
0.0148797408,
-0.0516962856,
-0.0037337753,
-0.0291759633,
-0.0411714688,
0.0209550392,
-0.0016636689,
0.0098034078,
0.0217360742,
-0.0449739881,
-0.055394154,
0.0017257322,
-0.0274514928,
-0.0116895158,
-0.0079705901,
0.0068943417,
0.0688692033,
-0.005460347,
-0.0357360728,
-0.0191075429,
-0.0081809247,
-0.060394302,
0.0137282563,
-0.0309587531,
-0.0143676996,
-0.0355284587,
0.0716256872,
-0.047884509,
-0.071279861,
-0.0582420006,
0.0015072526,
-0.0296188295,
-0.0211984739,
0.0316787362,
0.0825712979,
-0.0327948481,
-0.0137947649,
-0.0075865244,
0.0241203122,
-0.0261584111,
-0.0098090312,
0.0255461447,
0.0228887163,
-0.0229665935,
0.0223339405,
0.0288738403,
-0.0261524543,
-0.0064585255,
0.0466461331,
-0.0373592526,
-0.0125083486,
-0.0005645089,
-0.0257469807,
-0.0254889764,
-0.0076584956,
0.0109342718,
-0.0770391375,
0.0195729621,
-0.0249800906,
0.0040715598,
-0.0590576418,
0.0272487458,
0.0105385426,
-0.0380879864,
0.0916490033,
-0.0292929411,
-0.0121947965,
0.0284073651,
0.043223571,
-0.0015419089,
0.0634665787,
0.0302332733,
0.0373976305,
0.0323047116,
0.0027544003,
-0.0009372192,
0.0217371173,
0.0322823413,
0.037110623,
-0.0048263171,
-0.0233753007,
-0.0042198906,
0.0338962264,
0.0686065331,
0.0661083609,
-0.0516259409,
-0.0046738293,
0.0876705274,
0.0541668497,
-0.0362129696,
0.024814507,
0.0517735109,
0.0279810335,
-0.0399848148,
0.0013991111,
-0.0003091415,
0.0405164659,
0.054507643,
-0.0055402135,
0.0431387238,
0.0342366137,
-0.0666393489,
-0.0330249593,
0.024234226,
-0.0197396092,
0.0621442646,
-0.0281438939,
0.0142440284,
0.0127436323,
-0.0557302684,
0.0774856359,
-0.0029040293,
-0.0401615985,
-0.0103141312,
-0.0272536725,
0.0157462526,
0.0687685087,
0.0334879309,
0.0172122139,
-0.0304544512,
-0.0221270751,
0.0409801602,
0.03381522,
0.0222658552,
0.0217341464,
0.0134584811,
-0.0638998225,
-0.0374302417,
0.0123975417,
0.019254772,
0.0295483861,
-0.0154231023,
0.0358261317,
0.0397485346,
0.005648823,
-0.0645241514,
0.018113289,
0.0028001487,
-0.0450280644,
0.015844794,
0.0032669751,
-0.0085061537,
0.0176915489,
-0.0436411686,
0.0121836644,
-0.0104525257,
-0.0198399834,
-0.0471065193,
0.0375394113,
-0.0647851825,
-0.0437642932,
0.0093839085,
-0.0908838734,
-0.0257051345,
0.014710729,
-0.0434934422,
-0.0343157686,
0.0342750214,
-0.0231646169,
-0.0120340502,
-0.0795631036,
-0.0239687357,
0.0327113084,
0.0523890518,
0.0204099473,
0.0606865212,
-0.0341856517,
-0.0296547972,
0.0170221888,
0.0184200779,
-0.0230681654,
-0.0110012237,
-0.0645829141,
-0.0334900729,
0.0160148181,
0.0207003728,
-0.0140189696,
0.0248984508,
-0.0319312513,
0.0070613874,
-0.109725222,
-0.0060584527,
-0.0092264935,
-0.0620621145,
0.0005214249,
0.0307863727,
0.0323963463,
-0.0199068524,
-0.0361747928,
-0.0070513627,
-0.0015085555,
0.0298772026,
0.0300645456,
0.0119329961,
-0.0229801908,
-0.0353641957,
-0.0028750214,
0.0425883122,
0.0575976484,
-0.0095038507,
-0.0085370708,
-0.0011805753,
-0.0247104503,
-0.0071654418,
0.0042631566,
-0.0115895113,
-0.0107536977,
-0.017617926,
0.0033013127,
0.0254853908,
-0.0038944278,
0.0454617105,
0.0563600957,
0.0038098928,
-0.0138973277,
-0.0096934829,
0.0162833612,
-0.0200259704,
0.0064176181,
0.0362920351,
-0.039894782,
-0.0316058882,
0.0208640732,
-0.0199299883,
0.0104188034,
-0.0784669518,
0.0017002061,
-0.0026292182,
-0.0824316442,
-0.0599743016,
-0.0006616513,
-0.0292526018,
-0.0306921545,
-0.0648015365,
-0.0492969751,
0.0393115431,
-0.0082523851,
-0.0161363594,
-0.0184054617,
-0.0182473082,
0.0042377864,
0.0528879799,
-0.0335573964,
0.0413534194,
0.0189072564,
0.0081524523,
-0.0082838982,
-0.03005879,
-0.0030911507,
-0.0257764198,
0.0658552274,
-0.0284141563,
0.0046317792,
-0.0155793242,
0.0033122119,
-0.0197791159,
-0.0510813706,
0.0233489573,
0.0020745089,
-0.0017855258,
-0.0089549245,
0.0191297755,
0.0434110202,
0.0017816277,
0.0375625379,
0.0090291258,
0.0144478986,
-0.0070647444,
0.0692217201,
0.0499753281,
0.0248164795,
-0.037970107,
-0.0379962996,
0.0368886702,
0.0196644813,
-0.0224994645,
-0.0407918468,
-0.0712289363,
-0.0005987795,
-0.0231912863,
0.0126043102,
-0.0037038776,
0.0193843003,
0.0801386908,
-0.0361250788,
-0.0059026964,
0.0865062028,
-0.0009380511,
-0.0460132621,
-0.0074435985,
0.0465728492,
0.0730832964,
0.0206178688,
-0.0171733908,
-0.0650828928,
-0.0415669084,
-0.0311875772,
-0.0184412953,
0.0380838551,
0.0177067891,
-0.0481408834,
-0.0744723603,
0.0661981925,
0.0351127237,
-0.010200873,
-0.0172663163,
0.0125160711,
-0.0325889178,
0.0314226635,
0.0043416042,
-0.055687122,
0.0191832408,
0.005526776,
0.0214428697,
0.025680013,
-0.0889853537,
-0.0062893238,
-0.0577176623,
0.0240973327,
0.0153581174,
0.0129067572,
-0.0209833011,
-0.0556424111,
0.0124094533,
0.0139264017,
-0.0130119892,
-0.005987037,
0.0671989843,
0.0028051932,
-0.0341841839,
0.0147658382,
-0.0088310782,
-0.0396926366,
-0.0060253651,
-0.0303756334,
0.0567287318,
-0.0092431763,
0.0085656485,
-0.0693981573,
0.0262726955,
0.0623012967,
0.0562000014,
0.0344482809,
-0.0375590287,
-0.0041655786,
-0.0025094647,
0.0009617508,
-0.0302346796,
-0.0516176522,
-0.0181875955,
-0.0203344431,
-0.0620216131,
-0.0871487409,
-0.016100686,
0.0149407145,
0.0492396802,
0.0263345335,
0.022649372,
-0.0074618761,
0.0102427388,
-0.0360270403,
0.0604595877,
-0.0350510217,
-0.0005271998,
-0.0249031466,
-0.0089555783,
0.0418068282,
0.0040238178,
-0.0315441191,
0.0550897866,
-0.0882456079,
-0.0259256195,
-0.0347889252,
0.0579654351,
0.0126057193,
0.0291100033,
-0.0098522594,
-0.0335492007,
0.0535040088,
0.0148709407,
0.0747173578,
-0.0011802992,
0.0425269566,
-0.051718697,
-0.0105274646,
0.0170319136,
-0.0298906919,
0.0353204235,
-0.0437232554,
0.0219679363,
-0.0379995592,
0.0248253569,
-0.0241064355,
-0.0633862391,
-0.0016920494,
-0.0416783504,
0.0445494801,
-0.0442006402,
-0.0102095539,
0.0021137076,
-0.0138419541,
-0.0588425212,
0.0048486716,
0.0335536301,
0.0468927324,
-0.0188667029,
-0.0170949753,
0.0199943539,
0.0068757534,
0.01534265,
-0.0252159815,
0.006264165,
-0.0251297504,
-0.0097786551,
0.0124772787,
-0.0224718042,
-0.0032068009,
-0.0359120443,
-0.0118639367,
-0.0078250626,
-0.0063857022,
-0.0037098064,
-0.0133798774,
-0.0416997895,
0.0259316899,
-0.0106474515,
-0.0226708129,
-0.0658677444,
0.0362177491,
0.0595003627,
0.0020093236,
0.0221327469,
0.0089380071,
-0.0139058884,
-0.0079469597,
-0.0124796797,
-0.0310669392,
-0.0147709418,
0.059130881,
0.0134908147,
0.0088615324,
0.0176059008,
0.0502960198,
-0.043505501,
0.0237761661,
-0.0105833979,
-0.0219855085,
-0.0122806095,
-0.0172878709,
-0.0049767089,
0.0231648758,
0.0027855649,
0.063351512,
-0.0203067437,
-0.08061032,
0.01252707,
-0.008084463,
-0.0162364449,
0.0586444177,
0.0853709653,
0.015426483,
0.0216418989,
0.0393387191,
-0.0086712223,
0.0007104602,
-0.0213983078,
0.0113251228,
0.0090642124,
-6.568081297e-33,
-0.0506155416,
-0.0215672031,
0.0044779466,
-0.0755581409,
-0.0550549664,
0.00074757,
-0.0490174107,
0.0383488573,
-0.0088198604,
0.0227721352,
0.0049980069,
0.0106264707,
0.0133285569,
0.0469084866,
-0.0006280883,
0.027624147,
0.0543948412,
-0.0053617163,
0.0170525219,
0.0159964878,
-0.0020943806,
0.0078277038,
0.0222579613,
-0.0385933258,
-0.0042305719,
-0.0087260604,
-0.022106871,
0.0165275689,
0.0824917406,
0.0217892956,
-0.0416798964,
0.0316905789,
0.0018122026,
-0.02456039,
-0.0542335808,
-0.0007903836,
-0.0536177382,
-0.0296221748,
0.0437435769,
-0.0135537293,
-0.027741937,
-0.0272861514,
0.0234870221,
-0.0170977712,
0.0199829172,
-0.0062860423,
0.0588419922,
-0.0064747278,
0.0001378578,
-0.0101682544,
-0.0330327228,
0.0418721698,
-0.0193546694,
-0.0094214045,
0.0002589256,
-0.0222921111,
0.0155714992,
0.0242684204,
-0.0368729047,
0.0104455091,
0.0233940296,
0.0388031676,
0.0392341092,
0.0362061486,
0.0072849644,
0.052589152,
-0.0128641138,
0.009750261,
-0.0064453171,
0.0131579805,
0.0101639088,
0.0646091178,
0.0407678522,
0.0211000815,
0.0616951585,
-0.0034669798,
-0.0175148491,
0.0134858359,
-0.0868577287,
-0.0019392766,
0.0368978493,
0.0224050898,
0.0170203168,
0.0190155134,
-0.0503376387,
-0.0193620436,
-0.0082887057,
-0.0629613847,
0.0171433724,
0.0469294153,
-0.0390220508,
0.0548321679,
0.0684032962,
-0.0180964116,
0.0017344174,
-0.0178079195,
0.0135093508,
0.0217595045,
0.0085940072,
-0.0021599829,
0.0031125925,
-0.0667949095,
0.038474746,
0.0259341151,
-0.0084640952,
0.0114786942,
0.0322855935,
0.0224639084,
-0.0350917093,
-0.013119611,
-0.028007729,
-0.0014879927,
-0.047818061,
0.0287192371,
0.0199230257,
0.0238067023,
-0.0694829673,
0.0252181217,
-0.0201270003,
0.0420580283,
0.0011027043,
-0.0284302551,
0.0033033963,
0.0365420543,
-0.0232645255,
0.0270225778,
-0.0221813247,
-0.0047706347,
0.065190807,
-0.0718272552,
-0.0492768548,
0.0296557434,
2.715e-7,
0.001453695,
0.0150221521,
0.0204282347,
0.0182438213,
0.0121992091,
0.0263293367,
-0.0268759318,
0.0324364863,
-0.0398619361,
-0.0738163069,
0.056373179,
0.0518627577,
0.002725156,
-0.0212126561,
-0.0502772219,
-0.0054214243,
-0.0449573658,
0.0345751904,
-0.0155759798,
-0.0330160968,
0.0216726921,
0.1175582185,
0.0174187627,
-0.0101733953,
0.0141578792,
-0.055584088,
0.0872478634,
-0.0149353379,
0.0140446238,
-0.0126546798,
0.0083000241,
0.0255407356,
-0.0399808325,
-0.0094182203,
-0.0375527889,
0.0111446176,
0.0868175402,
0.0490382351,
-0.0370520987,
-0.0291886851,
-0.0166077483,
0.0275213774,
-0.0101540498,
-0.0048225899,
0.0539574623,
-0.0473771244,
-0.0100887865,
-0.0738700256,
-0.0363702774,
0.0089779152,
0.0588421561,
-0.0437554121,
-0.0462137796,
0.0054526543,
0.0313090459,
-0.0038921037,
-0.0297608804,
-0.1044150665,
0.0069140429,
-0.0119461864,
-0.0745168626,
-0.0343485624,
-0.0736775473,
-0.0407171026,
0.0366023108,
0.0339474939,
0.0025893692,
2.043714019e-34,
0.0905773267,
-0.014038139,
-0.0016382419,
0.0239905864,
0.004314499,
0.0006040214,
-0.0129933478,
-0.0363528132,
0.0351538658,
-0.0502398722,
-0.0210802723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04951v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04951v2 | Multi-document Summarization: A Comparative Evaluation | 2023-09-10T07:43:42 | 2023-09-12T04:19:49 | Kushan Hewapathirana, Nisansa de Silva, C. D. Athuraliya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper is aimed at evaluating state-of-the-art models for Multi-document
Summarization (MDS) on different types of datasets in various domains and
investigating the limitations of existing models to determine future research
directions. To address this gap, we conducted an extensive literature review to
identify state-of-the-art models and datasets. We analyzed the performance of
PRIMERA and PEGASUS models on BigSurvey-MDS and MS$^2$ datasets, which posed
unique challenges due to their varied domains. Our findings show that the
General-Purpose Pre-trained Model LED outperforms PRIMERA and PEGASUS on the
MS$^2$ dataset. We used the ROUGE score as a performance metric to evaluate the
identified models on different datasets. Our study provides valuable insights
into the models' strengths and weaknesses, as well as their applicability in
different domains. This work serves as a reference for future MDS research and
contributes to the development of accurate and robust models which can be
utilized on demanding datasets with academically and/or scientifically complex
data as well as generalized, relatively simple datasets. | [
0.0320025608,
0.0206339583,
0.0537192002,
-0.0176493507,
-0.0128865037,
0.0006474211,
-0.0186244845,
-0.0163857993,
-0.0169635657,
-0.0730500966,
-0.0246383827,
0.0008473774,
0.0201669112,
-0.0140937641,
-0.0090539176,
-0.0787233189,
0.0080327271,
-0.0180088319,
-0.0117917378,
0.0068744589,
0.0230649263,
0.0108576668,
0.0136916991,
0.0321761146,
-0.0058231191,
-0.007767342,
0.0219670348,
0.0040472392,
0.0492863357,
-0.0146816792,
0.0348265171,
-0.0103261732,
0.0502315238,
-0.0012718909,
0.0000020517,
-0.0528593957,
-0.0477433205,
0.0109455977,
0.0187293049,
0.0320229009,
0.0401176326,
-0.0673226565,
0.0535834171,
-0.0147440005,
-0.0090372162,
0.0308782551,
-0.0252457205,
0.04042124,
0.0693533346,
0.0329689607,
-0.0261920691,
-0.0695822537,
0.0498832874,
-0.025133647,
-0.0374789052,
-0.0494111031,
0.0192432273,
0.0463720411,
0.0082633076,
-0.0120076602,
-0.0085883392,
0.0198071152,
-0.0217360649,
0.0121659767,
-0.0304377507,
0.0106201293,
-0.0229952727,
-0.025766721,
-0.0016016966,
0.0842288882,
-0.0252624694,
0.0515458733,
0.0243417006,
0.001700495,
-0.0103936484,
0.0140141621,
-0.0937277675,
0.0371172279,
-0.006497025,
0.0139262807,
0.0013160739,
0.0507548675,
-0.0234042648,
0.0451188572,
-0.0267080329,
-0.0152060883,
-0.0092249028,
-0.0107398713,
-0.015806552,
0.0076014707,
-0.0328598544,
-0.023897605,
0.0248993617,
0.0342719369,
2.588e-7,
0.0066258088,
-0.0665570647,
-0.0829386562,
0.0607527941,
-0.0053422847,
0.0168352164,
-0.0240517575,
0.037665423,
0.0481820926,
-0.0358181186,
0.0069394773,
-0.0018845751,
0.0303462241,
-0.0246206038,
-0.0358928144,
-0.0167729873,
0.002042616,
-0.0101189716,
0.0555016436,
-0.0120224003,
-0.0388956778,
-0.0172272827,
0.0027660499,
0.0012580079,
-0.014510992,
-0.0223029107,
-0.0082630962,
0.0209327769,
-0.0138907069,
0.0177704766,
0.0403770916,
0.0001342614,
-0.0329781249,
0.0471985191,
-0.0008612288,
0.0000440284,
0.025191525,
0.0151191428,
0.0213363767,
0.0323325172,
0.0175847616,
-0.0205084011,
-0.0642274916,
0.014158411,
-0.0442516208,
-0.015252931,
-0.0721557513,
0.0141242919,
-0.0633543134,
-0.0012802875,
0.0054534245,
0.003961314,
-0.0028930204,
0.0043991385,
0.0004274845,
-0.0615419596,
0.0129070869,
-0.0124329291,
0.0166110508,
0.0698092952,
0.0295130666,
0.0108937109,
0.0558614992,
0.039575506,
0.0276268627,
0.0558652692,
0.0381428488,
-0.0032406426,
0.0199521855,
0.0024287866,
0.0071974606,
0.0488584563,
0.004230205,
-0.0193658061,
0.0007311717,
0.0250443891,
0.0418283939,
-0.0493467376,
0.0175293311,
0.0331814438,
0.0539212823,
-0.0052941381,
-0.003788217,
0.035524644,
0.0225566197,
0.0562429093,
0.0409426615,
0.0464036204,
0.0172424559,
-0.0167237595,
0.0865412056,
0.0940017328,
0.0407908671,
-0.0238253083,
-0.0521312803,
0.0085043097,
-0.0368602201,
-0.0151781728,
0.0141223222,
0.0688248649,
-0.004840896,
-0.0680103526,
0.0197531525,
-0.0079277428,
-0.0458510667,
0.0156183178,
-0.029327387,
-0.0059893904,
0.0123732928,
0.0537833944,
-0.0631906018,
-0.0374721438,
-0.0208731387,
0.0134451492,
0.0088047357,
0.0570234843,
-0.0018132803,
0.0042640213,
-0.0665800497,
-0.0293562729,
-0.0408859663,
-0.0139662065,
-0.0107336761,
-0.0183150005,
-0.0179471839,
0.0384032913,
0.033761315,
-0.0770244449,
0.0367868096,
-0.0188627541,
0.0126752211,
-0.0354036279,
-0.0327110365,
0.0158561561,
0.0273491163,
-0.0168966409,
0.0291096754,
0.0426619761,
-0.0069381972,
0.0105145145,
-0.0376491211,
-0.0509490669,
-0.0180019718,
0.0119490512,
-0.0574605614,
-0.010712414,
0.0674973726,
-0.0203965269,
-0.0502058938,
0.0036962782,
-0.0277672727,
-0.0374995321,
-0.0203271061,
0.0230516363,
0.030926168,
0.025469346,
-0.0283667613,
0.0391386561,
-0.0072949175,
0.020072924,
0.0538558327,
-0.0318034664,
0.001206434,
-0.0047153933,
-0.0162404738,
-0.0170676801,
0.0031192992,
0.0076236618,
0.0469226725,
0.0298757982,
-0.0122762108,
-0.0146557018,
-0.0919647291,
-0.0003501157,
-0.0086525269,
-0.0161094796,
0.0209783353,
0.0395396762,
-0.0021750741,
-0.0239365473,
-0.0131188249,
-0.034243349,
0.0190827977,
0.013204827,
0.0391533263,
-0.0026084518,
0.06389305,
-0.0599086322,
-0.0388737693,
-0.0038910985,
0.0584561303,
0.012412712,
-0.0148248989,
0.0307993367,
0.0087075206,
-0.0360699967,
-0.0609791353,
0.0019791005,
0.04338957,
0.0021372407,
-0.0307929255,
0.0665368587,
0.0371311083,
0.0602677576,
0.0180841293,
0.0172577221,
0.0038970488,
-0.034415938,
-0.0025138224,
-0.0338017456,
0.0510676838,
0.0089521762,
-0.0201763678,
0.0506078973,
0.0473980531,
0.0203149151,
-0.0041666613,
-0.0018052727,
0.0125055909,
-0.0035421054,
-0.0139575088,
-0.039970208,
-0.0069869976,
0.0150087383,
0.0148968985,
-0.0091752699,
0.0004652224,
0.0419128612,
-0.0144678243,
0.0133117549,
-0.0667829141,
0.0073750541,
-0.0805778354,
0.0320836715,
0.0214400422,
0.0253797844,
-0.0286443196,
0.0207656324,
-0.0216566529,
-0.0201708302,
0.0204288177,
-0.0113606807,
0.0807587877,
-0.0458146594,
0.024347784,
-0.0365824923,
0.0190569758,
0.0342864394,
-0.0379199013,
-0.0181399509,
0.0077612731,
0.0321738347,
0.0356330611,
-0.0565411672,
0.0374720134,
0.0202751663,
0.1026084721,
-0.0399024375,
-0.0505167767,
0.0099606263,
0.0759509951,
0.0721063912,
-0.0112384204,
0.0236010328,
-0.0778531879,
0.0075581521,
0.014829509,
0.013706971,
-0.0213919356,
0.0291665029,
-0.0134628098,
-0.0172046032,
-0.0784927532,
0.0146752009,
-0.047435455,
0.0530163348,
-0.027902605,
0.0257488694,
0.0736427829,
0.0200493112,
-0.0141676012,
-0.0306136068,
0.0045887656,
0.0215079654,
-0.0062063448,
-0.0309956819,
-0.0372314416,
-0.0196721051,
-0.026102433,
0.0088467207,
0.0402112529,
-0.0204028115,
-0.0058647739,
-0.0234611742,
0.0150917601,
0.0048274053,
-0.0823364258,
-0.0099439891,
-0.0207541343,
0.0212904885,
-0.0240937043,
-0.0022365008,
-0.0001666333,
-0.0460448451,
-0.0111840451,
0.002526057,
-0.0972990245,
-0.0107400967,
-0.0281226076,
-0.0171753727,
-0.0514696948,
0.052522622,
0.0224376079,
-0.0051987101,
0.0592174977,
0.0327059776,
-0.0117896749,
-0.0102906246,
0.0034900918,
0.0645590425,
-0.030243881,
0.0262488201,
-0.0302241426,
0.0475988574,
0.0076494771,
0.022039704,
0.0449317172,
-0.0005644514,
-0.0007810704,
-0.0406874977,
-0.0873557627,
0.01792139,
-0.0656529516,
0.0465876944,
0.0286756605,
-0.0282111112,
-0.0401469134,
-0.0213898495,
-0.009242557,
-0.0500587672,
-0.0186813474,
-0.0077314386,
-0.0363544486,
-0.030347446,
-0.0611482821,
-0.0495893769,
0.0400476828,
-0.0408616066,
-0.0393193103,
-0.0125471549,
-0.0356330313,
0.0220603328,
-0.0208870489,
0.0017950663,
0.0110156769,
-0.0261563603,
-0.0498230606,
0.0001439078,
0.0757388994,
-0.0217697714,
-0.0412482955,
0.008420052,
-0.0659193546,
-0.0061722388,
-0.0315235667,
0.0505432151,
0.0159732886,
0.0436279997,
0.0255007222,
0.0039264238,
0.0725084469,
0.0164502058,
-0.0000250456,
-0.0036215778,
0.021046171,
0.0200991314,
-0.0369829722,
-0.0082041239,
-0.06011042,
0.0622170828,
-0.0628445074,
0.0409015045,
-0.0181280524,
-0.0353943072,
-0.0112768607,
0.0351051763,
0.0161125753,
-0.0178101566,
-0.0057074046,
-0.0372577496,
-0.0434630997,
-0.0118256109,
-0.0021593343,
-0.0284469239,
0.0560102165,
-0.0113499928,
0.0104898233,
-0.0242876057,
0.0505351983,
0.0289314725,
0.024687361,
-0.0518500954,
0.0104522118,
-0.017730128,
-0.0185941942,
-0.0454502851,
-0.0207005329,
-0.0671789497,
-0.0178922117,
-0.0484697223,
-0.0434995331,
-0.0020695669,
0.0004835063,
0.0229403246,
0.0196830016,
0.027738329,
0.0418947116,
-0.0921648666,
0.0233496111,
-0.0824952573,
-0.0045986092,
0.0369642787,
-0.0046122978,
0.1040791646,
0.0076113679,
-0.0262385737,
-0.0326614492,
0.0219357517,
0.0556543469,
0.0362190232,
-0.0298133548,
0.0148146059,
0.0247282069,
0.0268667284,
0.1022035405,
-0.0399135016,
-0.0003309176,
0.0025254518,
-0.0221248977,
-0.0524497107,
-0.0274189003,
-0.0167577602,
0.0373383425,
0.0209102631,
-0.0360541418,
-0.0371923409,
0.0253958572,
0.0525706559,
0.0000714522,
-0.0056305341,
-0.01214178,
0.0367086604,
0.0343028307,
0.0136084091,
0.0195882898,
-0.0700188056,
-0.0404378735,
-0.0191887543,
0.0018955877,
0.0118561536,
-5.605330118e-33,
-0.0227529258,
-0.0085447207,
-0.0420157537,
0.0205799211,
-0.0412901305,
0.0054943599,
-0.0587412082,
-0.0626110509,
-0.0003530508,
-0.0244520362,
-0.0059013111,
-0.0218638144,
0.0038610878,
0.0482749827,
0.0284452327,
0.0441294163,
0.0232958421,
-0.0139013994,
-0.0376975611,
0.0409416147,
0.0266706403,
0.0154879047,
0.0356482193,
-0.0327085145,
0.026940994,
-0.0315489247,
-0.0373396091,
-0.0696638003,
0.0260354374,
0.0424096659,
-0.0038636753,
-0.0003545815,
0.052397076,
-0.0154822264,
-0.0612048097,
0.0113068018,
-0.0572736114,
-0.0177373942,
-0.01645712,
-0.0440226123,
-0.0646658912,
-0.0384236686,
0.0394685715,
-0.0228438117,
0.0439513773,
-0.0667556599,
0.0970204324,
-0.0341869369,
-0.034102574,
-0.1023414433,
-0.0203636736,
0.0342215262,
-0.0521365106,
-0.0278187152,
0.0313084833,
0.0822524279,
-0.0172002092,
0.0501652099,
-0.0161551274,
0.073484771,
0.0354540758,
0.0100310845,
0.0401466824,
0.0173714235,
0.0298914816,
0.0423179157,
-0.0066384948,
-0.0318044648,
0.0149677061,
0.0016450727,
0.0134400604,
0.0177937187,
0.0120097976,
0.0034205313,
0.0042618588,
0.0590868182,
-0.0614858195,
0.0985352024,
-0.0139961066,
-0.0222933497,
0.0359356664,
-0.0104165347,
0.0294582862,
0.021219451,
-0.0078371912,
0.0217505135,
0.0091702845,
0.0139092738,
-0.024630554,
0.0287881661,
-0.0554996021,
0.0230184309,
0.0244698469,
-0.0178017002,
0.0041511576,
0.0188642293,
-0.0167498235,
0.0455876403,
0.0106412387,
-0.0338283516,
-0.043642085,
0.0338660069,
0.0400698557,
0.0028033548,
-0.0099568963,
-0.0149369128,
0.0445016697,
0.0042078951,
-0.0221045576,
-0.0147127956,
0.0315618403,
-0.0009089535,
-0.0329577625,
0.0319072939,
-0.0277236588,
-0.039631363,
-0.0038613835,
0.0530648604,
0.0007742856,
-0.0103129651,
-0.0039765332,
-0.0132293366,
0.0332028009,
0.0238336697,
-0.0148307187,
0.0352999382,
-0.0121426983,
-0.0354821309,
0.0312403403,
-0.0229129232,
-0.0181086659,
0.0183476042,
2.44e-7,
0.0791309774,
0.0352155827,
0.0640194863,
-0.0021944572,
0.0004584833,
0.0146847591,
-0.0134657202,
0.0246790461,
-0.0061937589,
0.0532874241,
0.0547167473,
0.0137075959,
0.0527160279,
0.0139693739,
-0.0743867457,
-0.0316459984,
-0.0750146583,
-0.0429101512,
-0.0414628386,
-0.042732805,
0.0482166484,
0.0478114486,
-0.0327239372,
-0.0031496645,
-0.036483936,
0.0116323512,
0.0489578173,
-0.0242194403,
-0.0236086603,
0.0399085283,
0.0594688505,
0.0215545688,
-0.048907727,
-0.023494808,
0.0083337314,
0.0066252695,
0.1056544259,
0.048952926,
0.012098982,
-0.0015746334,
0.0483138449,
-0.0031999941,
0.0457684584,
0.0026032864,
0.0415867232,
-0.059872169,
-0.002268221,
-0.0223588273,
-0.0439322442,
0.0232839901,
0.0055866577,
-0.0067565809,
-0.0520551503,
0.0674135163,
-0.022754116,
-0.0123916389,
0.0234337579,
-0.0572069101,
-0.0073727006,
0.0455052778,
0.0102107115,
-0.0154860886,
0.0031934734,
-0.0306707695,
0.0086592836,
-0.0527851097,
-0.0523329526,
2.279646985e-34,
0.0970794037,
-0.0340048671,
-0.0561924912,
-0.0148600759,
0.0081522567,
-0.0466181375,
-0.0581532679,
-0.0273618624,
-0.0274881814,
-0.0933304727,
-0.0063316561
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04940v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04940v1 | What's Hard in English RST Parsing? Predictive Models for Error Analysis | 2023-09-10T06:10:03 | 2023-09-10T06:10:03 | Yang Janet Liu, Tatsuya Aoyama, Amir Zeldes | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite recent advances in Natural Language Processing (NLP), hierarchical
discourse parsing in the framework of Rhetorical Structure Theory remains
challenging, and our understanding of the reasons for this are as yet limited.
In this paper, we examine and model some of the factors associated with parsing
difficulties in previous work: the existence of implicit discourse relations,
challenges in identifying long-distance relations, out-of-vocabulary items, and
more. In order to assess the relative importance of these variables, we also
release two annotated English test-sets with explicit correct and distracting
discourse markers associated with gold standard RST relations. Our results show
that as in shallow discourse parsing, the explicit/implicit distinction plays a
role, but that long-distance dependencies are the main challenge, while lack of
lexical overlap is less of a problem, at least for in-domain parsing. Our final
model is able to predict where errors will occur with an accuracy of 76.3% for
the bottom-up parser and 76.6% for the top-down parser. | [
0.0267053004,
0.0098239947,
-0.0247414205,
0.0418075845,
-0.0303604752,
0.0010955584,
-0.032140743,
0.0204617344,
-0.0027459094,
-0.0936234817,
-0.0028530301,
-0.0050375285,
0.038014248,
-0.0265304297,
-0.0259584617,
-0.0449789688,
0.0506761968,
-0.012285498,
0.0421695746,
0.0069174967,
0.0246143937,
0.0094757555,
0.0007075275,
0.0038342839,
-0.0427712761,
-0.0626412407,
-0.0019546025,
0.0045526111,
0.001897341,
-0.0826530755,
0.0767280534,
0.0380057134,
-0.0011889549,
0.0108135268,
0.0000018655,
-0.0285528246,
-0.0108163152,
-0.0007661842,
0.0026499024,
0.0362090878,
0.0380743071,
0.004308416,
-0.0158588234,
0.0082795452,
-0.0268259775,
-0.0124773057,
0.0127101913,
0.0864420384,
0.0443742163,
0.0561191179,
-0.0284655374,
-0.0119859539,
0.0217112843,
0.0111683244,
-0.0676311702,
-0.0239096191,
0.0123354755,
0.0087971836,
0.0013063597,
0.0306760315,
-0.0135755818,
0.0029023688,
-0.0031324835,
-0.0020045796,
-0.0567787513,
0.0148410117,
-0.0039935252,
-0.0086584892,
0.0048856423,
0.0044552251,
0.0763763264,
-0.0113559226,
-0.0053846953,
0.0055885185,
-0.0106060803,
0.0223208759,
-0.0070859175,
0.0379403606,
-0.069352828,
0.0306591056,
0.0626949593,
-0.0332174189,
-0.0376489237,
0.0004576701,
0.0442575216,
0.0862084851,
-0.0042092567,
-0.0652082264,
-0.0141443852,
0.0553813353,
-0.0324405245,
-0.0482912697,
0.0161157493,
-0.031028511,
-0.0614401326,
0.0166494213,
-0.0146609815,
-0.0376040488,
0.0195371173,
-0.0560618341,
0.0112690665,
0.0204509255,
-0.0100812754,
-0.0120936614,
0.0218062885,
0.0663161427,
0.0040131113,
-0.0384235196,
-0.0168879144,
0.0272931233,
-0.0364821218,
-0.0687196329,
-0.0548049547,
0.0482827798,
-0.0706408918,
-0.0019119807,
-0.0324498639,
-0.0304244608,
-0.0062723202,
-0.0155108823,
0.0093839895,
0.0136402268,
-0.0746201873,
0.0513246693,
-0.047782056,
0.0316816941,
-0.0345064737,
0.0277811009,
-0.0353334807,
-0.0096930787,
-0.0045129284,
0.0248382129,
0.0090928478,
-0.0311328378,
-0.0703323036,
0.0249014255,
-0.0111514935,
0.0301777367,
-0.0027872899,
-0.0465215631,
-0.0453964882,
-0.0228923336,
0.0159876794,
-0.0250566565,
-0.0311456304,
0.0183408298,
0.0429822952,
-0.0119905295,
0.0141066592,
0.0282185823,
-0.03320821,
0.0247100014,
0.0173539091,
0.0238538161,
-0.0218453165,
-0.0078775603,
0.0098051857,
0.0518935546,
0.0369183011,
-0.0660133064,
0.0401749201,
-0.0030003772,
-0.0419704281,
0.0076199854,
-0.0395027958,
-0.0329533666,
-0.0188679509,
0.0129213566,
-0.035116449,
-0.007214494,
0.0376745202,
0.0473208278,
-0.025442455,
0.0145223308,
0.0011103402,
0.0568044148,
-0.0210343339,
0.0242350549,
0.0554615706,
0.0351525098,
0.0381611325,
0.0578487255,
-0.0139947515,
-0.0720892102,
0.0079884352,
0.0103612123,
-0.0615976788,
-0.0118403332,
0.02001567,
-0.0346247368,
-0.0410425663,
0.0299750287,
0.0051496602,
-0.0564463995,
0.0087558255,
0.01901903,
-0.0376510099,
0.0347281508,
0.0190479327,
-0.0518542305,
-0.0085256649,
-0.0046034176,
-0.0312590003,
0.0338460952,
0.0063084722,
-0.0322628617,
0.0045268708,
0.0010814293,
0.0253758878,
0.0753597915,
0.0138479387,
-0.0194170121,
-0.0174637772,
0.0136698764,
-0.0029349988,
-0.0110572325,
0.0463691354,
-0.0043767532,
-0.0192145407,
-0.0140337311,
-0.0255120136,
-0.005347454,
-0.0148166539,
-0.0035519761,
-0.0163862668,
0.0119756013,
-0.0242788643,
-0.0064287307,
0.0542149134,
0.0259713493,
-0.0117058437,
0.0270850416,
-0.0162751954,
-0.024920458,
0.0121415574,
0.0269045644,
-0.0553523786,
-0.0150419427,
0.0081649879,
-0.0406388193,
-0.0547292568,
0.0193864964,
0.0120706325,
-0.0296181273,
0.0289930999,
-0.0626490191,
0.0487139411,
0.0017264008,
0.0181681644,
0.0094126258,
-0.0259209312,
-0.0339380167,
0.0753745288,
0.0301604681,
0.0439627208,
-0.0032981085,
-0.0673725531,
0.0099530807,
-0.0211827289,
-0.0097015882,
-0.0163984112,
-0.017062759,
-0.0316392556,
0.0343082137,
0.0078941211,
-0.0728996396,
-0.0118890954,
-0.0768461525,
-0.0201129671,
-0.0107041653,
0.0617895015,
0.035500247,
-0.025037095,
-0.0130071128,
0.0035251498,
0.039214287,
-0.0241515357,
-0.0082719354,
0.0173412021,
0.0684705079,
-0.0303153526,
0.0069617168,
-0.0382537805,
-0.0083740233,
-0.0949398354,
0.0148142045,
-0.0015297586,
-0.0340405628,
-0.0376512371,
0.0547838509,
-0.0113465628,
0.0171396378,
0.0255584866,
-0.0631767288,
0.0270113479,
0.0342283174,
0.1109781489,
0.0339615531,
-0.0027604729,
0.0342042074,
-0.0100346478,
-0.077907294,
-0.0268191826,
0.033880122,
0.0096120732,
-0.0013614814,
-0.0474360883,
-0.0101234373,
-0.0145581784,
0.098960191,
0.0317106061,
0.0154528348,
-0.03388552,
0.0277618878,
-0.0678837076,
-0.0023611132,
0.0378573462,
-0.0523842126,
-0.0115549695,
0.0301834773,
-0.0317567661,
0.0297941975,
0.0443667956,
-0.0306691155,
-0.0155821647,
-0.0581546687,
0.0235681906,
0.0010417396,
0.0361844152,
0.009898901,
-0.0194827132,
0.0480668135,
-0.1026821882,
0.0035519681,
-0.0441621132,
0.0634629726,
0.0165985841,
0.0736291185,
-0.064450331,
0.0143678524,
-0.0160768218,
-0.063637197,
-0.0032198115,
-0.037146356,
-0.0176415686,
0.0229701996,
-0.0436294563,
0.0022581217,
0.0278806239,
0.0119132148,
-0.0115236687,
0.0259248298,
-0.0282332022,
-0.0112662036,
-0.0299169663,
0.0408305302,
0.0196683072,
0.0042056642,
0.0128921075,
0.0204911307,
0.0500897095,
0.0407529138,
-0.0066386503,
0.0074988203,
-0.0245173033,
0.0086548794,
-0.0002820058,
-0.0361392349,
-0.0866680741,
-0.0130778318,
0.0871957913,
-0.0519880466,
-0.0510213487,
0.1076684073,
0.0287816264,
0.0214176197,
0.0231944229,
-0.0483042337,
0.0241171345,
0.0333412327,
-0.0030964501,
-0.019710036,
0.0150265377,
0.0333316028,
-0.0154201519,
-0.038650874,
-0.0616841055,
0.0227383859,
-0.1094759256,
0.0453346968,
-0.0180744175,
-0.0204386059,
0.024176335,
0.0008922128,
0.0051324372,
0.0315229744,
0.0356847271,
0.0122646187,
-0.0625562146,
0.0221750811,
0.0259321965,
-0.0820381492,
0.0059644594,
0.019463243,
-0.0210433118,
-0.0207218844,
-0.0076550595,
0.0598475039,
-0.017343279,
0.0282545257,
0.0337240994,
-0.050636176,
0.0202933364,
-0.0345397703,
-0.0245955084,
0.0260624625,
0.0005161276,
-0.0557710305,
-0.0023356166,
-0.0361686014,
-0.0032784101,
0.0168792233,
0.0722267628,
-0.0146898134,
-0.0014100826,
0.0019904869,
0.0214196909,
-0.0013927884,
0.0360830426,
0.013374446,
0.0233819205,
-0.0632052794,
-0.0339241326,
0.0405975543,
-0.0138058113,
-0.0110810064,
0.0185415912,
-0.0222322233,
0.0157779213,
-0.0558709055,
-0.0794893801,
-0.0045454553,
0.0001228636,
0.0003326383,
0.0042935647,
0.0345071591,
-0.0029644528,
-0.0124101331,
-0.0052019134,
0.0119923651,
-0.011032749,
0.0038625002,
0.0275851209,
0.0676911548,
0.0185528751,
-0.0404209122,
-0.0495151468,
0.0063998648,
-0.0390458964,
0.0385788903,
-0.0040451218,
0.0155086042,
0.0289332252,
-0.01133148,
-0.0221680012,
-0.0129592922,
-0.0017771435,
-0.0650503486,
0.0545698851,
0.0421340764,
0.033695668,
0.0027394455,
0.0321803652,
-0.0073805833,
0.0197522752,
-0.0355579183,
0.0488477908,
-0.0095413905,
0.0117796427,
0.0417594463,
0.0170625634,
0.0735531375,
0.0186197739,
-0.0018299387,
-0.0321346633,
0.0014385978,
-0.089699842,
-0.0537706278,
-0.0212778132,
0.0058178608,
-0.0164041985,
0.01004312,
-0.0602283143,
-0.0257183015,
-0.0516583696,
0.0634543896,
-0.0097342273,
0.0305392388,
0.089515835,
0.0125677073,
-0.015987277,
-0.0125823654,
-0.0177739635,
-0.0324234404,
-0.002192531,
0.0533142351,
-0.0051025669,
0.0578099899,
-0.004391544,
0.0090170726,
0.0117019415,
-0.0304230191,
-0.0227486715,
0.0206952542,
0.0150424521,
-0.0321381204,
0.0227520578,
-0.0495835766,
0.1116347536,
-0.0319403075,
0.0265143253,
-0.0167633276,
0.0371622443,
0.0183145553,
-0.0244706646,
0.0469666012,
0.0215446372,
-0.0191915836,
-0.0123395696,
0.065928176,
0.0157490578,
-0.0012506205,
0.0492889099,
-0.0268485676,
-0.0287390873,
-0.0797495767,
-0.0077751293,
-0.0061416943,
0.0103594186,
-0.0098471614,
-0.0352520235,
-0.0389150269,
0.0410470814,
-0.0092103798,
0.0136897359,
-0.0414205454,
-0.0248794798,
0.0672174096,
0.001623717,
-0.0634487197,
-0.0313714147,
-0.0094006686,
-0.0332446508,
-0.0037617846,
-0.0636298284,
-6.039871441e-33,
-0.0762173608,
-0.0534038469,
0.0169844106,
0.0317617506,
-0.0519592762,
0.0706429332,
-0.0749029368,
0.0340249129,
0.0266657714,
0.0599648803,
-0.0374736711,
0.0319366939,
0.0258266013,
0.0271649696,
0.074031502,
-0.0046482924,
0.0563503131,
-0.0101221194,
0.0100295171,
-0.0384560041,
0.0486976653,
-0.005097209,
0.0763754919,
-0.0275452267,
0.034792196,
-0.0007012071,
-0.009621907,
0.0412911773,
-0.0119239213,
0.0315596797,
0.0103765018,
0.0349061452,
0.0491393059,
0.022580225,
0.0025643113,
0.0402778648,
-0.1212219,
-0.0689483806,
0.0760378987,
0.0091958977,
-0.0134002585,
-0.0103897834,
0.0386548713,
0.0057574357,
-0.0201083198,
-0.0083113676,
0.0428638831,
0.0045791073,
0.0435837507,
-0.0033400743,
-0.0780340359,
0.0146751469,
-0.0155733097,
0.0375234522,
0.0179757439,
0.040677987,
0.0296607446,
-0.0281825829,
-0.0375654325,
-0.0018984181,
-0.0632623807,
0.0464099385,
-0.0036101541,
-0.0299062897,
-0.0135985203,
0.0541013964,
-0.0235419981,
0.0131061738,
0.0281901732,
0.0285357591,
0.0043411511,
0.0130139524,
-0.0085246079,
0.0053360555,
-0.0091099469,
0.0493280254,
-0.0389421955,
-0.0573113598,
0.0266545285,
0.0845495388,
-0.0379363783,
-0.0126067931,
-0.0507713184,
-0.0401555076,
-0.0171811022,
-0.0206759572,
0.0041573565,
-0.0299654715,
0.0232475605,
-0.0269023553,
0.0284195524,
0.0069783265,
0.0117909191,
-0.0045962748,
-0.0346821696,
-0.0363060534,
0.0029259534,
0.0172623005,
-0.0175165329,
0.0425782725,
0.0043888842,
-0.0424688235,
-0.0337491073,
0.0328138843,
0.038057182,
0.013804785,
-0.0101647992,
-0.0178193133,
-0.0553011894,
0.0019659121,
0.0149738798,
0.0188971255,
-0.0692290962,
0.0599337779,
0.0477689207,
0.0245316811,
0.0088709984,
0.0656055063,
0.0209465157,
-0.0137808472,
-0.0278607924,
0.0171338264,
-0.0184461586,
0.0080662947,
0.015023197,
-0.0257029943,
-0.0022569189,
-0.0010748518,
0.0383767374,
-0.0068202098,
-0.0218935348,
-0.0070468802,
2.581e-7,
0.0145789571,
0.0727092251,
0.0487633385,
0.0101965191,
0.0250810161,
0.0001653938,
0.0398667492,
0.0329801328,
0.0211210512,
0.0155850388,
-0.0208633691,
-0.0370767601,
0.0329151005,
0.0586927794,
-0.0878581628,
-0.0566196963,
-0.0878161713,
-0.0237405989,
-0.0230640415,
0.03502395,
0.0658951998,
0.000045052,
-0.023684185,
0.0387661085,
-0.064850226,
-0.0244302545,
0.0065961815,
-0.0053036232,
-0.0115750637,
0.0530373678,
-0.048003003,
-0.0151859764,
0.0404314324,
0.0547321923,
0.003938959,
0.0106382566,
0.022826774,
0.0432196893,
-0.0060802461,
0.0061673252,
-0.0235481113,
0.0115808928,
0.0101368194,
-0.0077142562,
0.0052894484,
-0.0646349043,
-0.0278339386,
0.0168170948,
-0.0410962887,
-0.0165191628,
-0.0277456101,
0.0241827089,
-0.0014005534,
0.0034047528,
0.005346084,
0.0087640826,
-0.0177419484,
-0.0305556282,
-0.0081261322,
0.0474738292,
-0.0029996466,
-0.0417357683,
0.0308573451,
0.0233886801,
0.0047126822,
-0.0332555026,
-0.0166986976,
2.13423512e-34,
0.0434905589,
-0.0140922554,
0.0673822761,
0.0270416643,
0.0550176911,
0.0249459855,
0.0203498155,
0.0461557209,
0.0041989959,
-0.055579301,
-0.005492996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04919v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04919v1 | Unsupervised Chunking with Hierarchical RNN | 2023-09-10T02:55:12 | 2023-09-10T02:55:12 | Zijun Wu, Anup Anand Deshmukh, Yongkang Wu, Jimmy Lin, Lili Mou | cs.CL | cs.CL | In Natural Language Processing (NLP), predicting linguistic structures, such
as parsing and chunking, has mostly relied on manual annotations of syntactic
structures. This paper introduces an unsupervised approach to chunking, a
syntactic task that involves grouping words in a non-hierarchical manner. We
present a two-layer Hierarchical Recurrent Neural Network (HRNN) designed to
model word-to-chunk and chunk-to-sentence compositions. Our approach involves a
two-stage training process: pretraining with an unsupervised parser and
finetuning on downstream NLP tasks. Experiments on the CoNLL-2000 dataset
reveal a notable improvement over existing unsupervised methods, enhancing
phrase F1 score by up to 6 percentage points. Further, finetuning with
downstream tasks results in an additional performance improvement.
Interestingly, we observe that the emergence of the chunking structure is
transient during the neural model's downstream-task training. This study
contributes to the advancement of unsupervised syntactic structure discovery
and opens avenues for further research in linguistic theory. | [
0.0218326673,
0.0423394777,
0.0071095866,
0.0135436365,
-0.0421915948,
-0.0117898406,
0.0033681963,
-0.0355123989,
-0.0212049223,
-0.0552303493,
-0.0023844333,
-0.0398795195,
0.0067110462,
0.028533645,
0.0366004147,
-0.0941555351,
0.0336546861,
-0.0124539584,
0.0015308,
0.0435730889,
0.0294611268,
0.0076270238,
-0.0094997538,
0.0205899458,
-0.0137628289,
-0.0333917402,
-0.0062485556,
0.0107230227,
-0.0194382854,
-0.0216176864,
0.0263485927,
0.0170644429,
-0.0125990165,
0.0252083521,
0.00000177,
-0.0435349569,
-0.010997002,
0.0038026234,
-0.00814729,
-0.0082284724,
0.0447351523,
-0.0256635826,
-0.0208394192,
0.0149275521,
-0.0323390104,
0.0032804299,
-0.0043445644,
0.0771069601,
0.0521810427,
0.0711875036,
-0.0008509983,
-0.0638347343,
0.0314068086,
-0.0265553277,
-0.0185556989,
0.0039927959,
-0.002456249,
-0.0386082344,
-0.034252964,
-0.0049653728,
-0.0411729291,
-0.0101549923,
0.0318529643,
0.000380431,
0.0137546426,
0.0242320821,
-0.0600918718,
-0.0073662749,
-0.0093900906,
0.0372318812,
-0.0613062717,
-0.016137857,
0.0377217047,
-0.012478034,
-0.0362363569,
-0.039706897,
-0.0175746512,
0.0596909076,
0.0028151826,
0.0276647154,
0.0318984091,
-0.0048160311,
0.0167286266,
0.0172691457,
0.0054043205,
0.0812826902,
0.0007757664,
-0.0473922975,
-0.0049263146,
0.0111812055,
0.0165312979,
-0.0587893538,
0.0068844142,
0.0311003961,
-0.0184710305,
0.0223409813,
-0.0258165449,
-0.014323513,
0.0095324637,
-0.0292996801,
0.0036560127,
0.015963953,
-0.0217052139,
0.0116009591,
-0.0026183499,
-0.0079619205,
-0.0149381366,
-0.0104309255,
-0.0279996973,
0.0341321118,
-0.0825426057,
-0.0230925623,
-0.0291556027,
0.0385600962,
-0.0750641301,
-0.0322156288,
-0.0407960266,
-0.0280793924,
0.0056061461,
-0.0377088189,
0.0225351676,
0.0317553915,
-0.044673942,
0.0395678207,
-0.0296996832,
0.0283280145,
-0.0435213409,
-0.0053103226,
0.0446602255,
-0.0388285331,
-0.0259264596,
0.0470877662,
0.0207774881,
-0.006538962,
-0.0186205935,
0.0239044279,
-0.0224448107,
-0.0095662093,
-0.0529529117,
-0.0637060702,
-0.0273701008,
-0.0465436205,
0.0403182916,
-0.0689403266,
0.0453527831,
-0.0651450902,
-0.0244203545,
0.0174811464,
0.0001770434,
0.0441515185,
-0.0253856368,
0.060275346,
-0.0167921092,
-0.0300388094,
-0.0013480417,
-0.0121526727,
0.0413336121,
0.0358330011,
0.0592062362,
0.0593778826,
0.0354796946,
0.0157418307,
0.0133794248,
0.0147804301,
-0.0218975898,
-0.0693794712,
-0.0541091152,
-0.0275388006,
-0.0577404685,
0.0071780914,
0.03115898,
0.0469987467,
0.0047735954,
0.035484571,
0.0147091355,
0.0500650555,
0.0358942151,
0.0572005548,
0.0676778555,
0.0472071543,
-0.0277498309,
0.0541410297,
-0.0386994705,
-0.0060043093,
0.0185573269,
0.0373427346,
0.012327618,
0.0159387477,
-0.0147652458,
-0.0185023602,
-0.0194511041,
-0.0054233009,
-0.0076221032,
-0.0525613837,
0.0508883633,
0.0673714206,
-0.0394593291,
0.0058615734,
0.0234283879,
-0.0489922762,
0.0432459712,
0.026349457,
0.0009423965,
0.0669342577,
0.0319754481,
-0.020164812,
0.0024836776,
-0.0087256515,
-0.0087675499,
0.0558103062,
-0.0199085977,
-0.0221523475,
0.0355668552,
-0.0465266444,
0.0075158309,
-0.0012971415,
0.0140063902,
-0.0114179729,
-0.0344562083,
-0.0261677317,
0.0149669228,
0.0041836975,
-0.0321332477,
0.0681633651,
0.0085520046,
-0.002401239,
0.0373763964,
0.0159882698,
0.0264886133,
0.0059645814,
-0.0067090201,
0.0220884997,
0.0189646445,
-0.0455374792,
-0.0220306311,
-0.0175208654,
-0.0625406429,
-0.1057634577,
-0.0004052816,
-0.046251066,
0.0120412381,
0.0107589597,
-0.0358046554,
-0.0550977364,
0.0192545205,
-0.028890647,
0.03339931,
-0.0344748013,
0.0021601282,
0.0384325981,
0.0161402021,
-0.0178618934,
0.0602064021,
-0.0198007002,
0.007930859,
-0.0554617308,
-0.0427231193,
-0.0076811532,
-0.0356754474,
-0.0281293746,
0.0265766494,
-0.0390270315,
-0.0433230661,
-0.0048133866,
-0.0032862858,
-0.0693321824,
-0.013117576,
-0.0162264667,
0.0367250741,
-0.014665178,
0.0405865796,
0.0043844022,
-0.0243768599,
0.0109057296,
-0.0384244695,
-0.037379954,
-0.0366910174,
0.0010441245,
0.0203028228,
0.0860586911,
-0.0076431343,
-0.0225575697,
-0.0423743427,
-0.0379062183,
-0.0589317456,
0.0289226007,
-0.0185986105,
-0.0610827841,
-0.0257315971,
0.0122110182,
0.005254271,
0.0020791495,
0.0043719523,
-0.0575086586,
-0.0037348571,
0.001632135,
0.0878555104,
0.074593775,
0.0218989141,
0.0115414821,
0.033718273,
-0.0024697417,
0.0347084664,
0.0287884604,
-0.0296018012,
0.0452163592,
0.030666478,
-0.0043750368,
0.0367038436,
0.1019869223,
0.0104334177,
0.0025872842,
-0.0063663302,
0.0018818792,
-0.0556588806,
-0.0110835182,
0.0018011264,
-0.0244726483,
-0.0472808443,
0.0243214313,
-0.0389145352,
-0.0229169652,
0.0227314308,
-0.0298625119,
-0.0240462106,
-0.0509321019,
-0.0135203879,
-0.0402099378,
0.0558342487,
0.0451335274,
-0.021297995,
0.0209613964,
-0.0742094815,
-0.0202221666,
0.0063690348,
0.0022158488,
0.0152785135,
0.0283138137,
-0.0321313404,
-0.0393360592,
-0.0274699554,
-0.0209434591,
-0.0105481828,
-0.0434743762,
0.0216986556,
0.0062889368,
0.0372825302,
0.0078763608,
-0.0108727794,
-0.0067038289,
0.0052508675,
0.0523454472,
-0.0496553183,
0.0157572273,
-0.0335672721,
0.0653108507,
0.0398498587,
0.033725284,
0.0323822945,
-0.019728316,
0.0382029302,
0.0275496412,
0.0457137898,
0.0333655514,
-0.0372649059,
0.0197311584,
-0.0095028998,
-0.0413523205,
-0.0064928588,
0.0216473192,
0.0378475115,
-0.0975302011,
-0.0096806455,
0.1097473949,
0.0291669928,
-0.0142361093,
0.0100217126,
0.0244660676,
0.0172486492,
0.0172693301,
0.0064751413,
-0.0530414879,
-0.0283897035,
0.0131390737,
0.0112747541,
0.0075350809,
-0.061762251,
0.003201378,
-0.0979602933,
0.0400171801,
-0.0250966903,
-0.0199572835,
0.03596697,
0.0111135691,
-0.0509936549,
-0.0037377004,
-0.016125204,
-0.0090579782,
-0.058807008,
-0.0011938704,
0.0378626436,
-0.1392698586,
-0.018916307,
-0.008281176,
-0.0800162107,
0.0101314671,
0.0723585486,
0.0412024632,
-0.0278121475,
0.0167264771,
0.0278976765,
-0.0424798094,
0.0074919639,
0.0246914886,
0.0528440326,
-0.0197496619,
-0.0092404587,
-0.0328084417,
0.0250524729,
-0.0440509059,
-0.012910841,
-0.0152263222,
0.031230716,
0.0149639919,
-0.0314872749,
-0.0062542772,
0.0483322404,
-0.0108832177,
0.078970097,
0.0150203295,
-0.0341237374,
-0.0515843891,
-0.0075619617,
0.0227467995,
-0.0657945797,
0.0173353422,
0.0393612981,
-0.0265025161,
0.0131706465,
-0.1125648692,
-0.0868187174,
0.0423872769,
0.021334907,
0.0075702788,
0.019684311,
0.025150355,
-0.0012204357,
-0.0295345914,
0.0144140925,
0.0072143003,
-0.0131378807,
-0.0494000204,
-0.0258204639,
0.0181901529,
0.0117754964,
-0.0190813281,
0.0081585757,
-0.0699458197,
-0.0232317112,
0.0378660262,
0.0272904951,
0.0089143217,
0.04540601,
-0.0241487436,
-0.0361809917,
0.0142596327,
0.02739623,
-0.068537645,
0.0112478705,
0.0072830385,
0.0217617489,
0.0039020835,
0.0256167818,
-0.0174464248,
0.0289593358,
-0.0007189742,
0.0447497182,
0.0035296257,
0.0195967797,
0.019495856,
-0.0271442048,
0.0692554638,
-0.0179281104,
0.0223389454,
-0.0535705201,
0.0093483925,
-0.0051986068,
-0.0037308652,
-0.0478651859,
0.0286000296,
0.04387559,
0.0166654736,
-0.0145854289,
0.0676138401,
0.0240182076,
0.0096591162,
0.0128687881,
0.0086382376,
0.0152649898,
0.0122674732,
-0.0412612297,
0.0491016433,
-0.0242663585,
-0.0219447594,
-0.034817338,
0.0469641201,
-0.0188063439,
0.0493857004,
0.0410844684,
0.0094311358,
-0.0491335578,
0.0357321016,
-0.0434325784,
0.0637730807,
-0.0371079147,
-0.049752418,
0.0356562138,
-0.0665272251,
0.0375043526,
-0.0031131806,
0.0123307342,
-0.0273114741,
0.0189254899,
-0.0349327177,
-0.0217228197,
0.0115190409,
0.0280914903,
-0.0704601854,
-0.0379835814,
0.0763251483,
0.0583331361,
-0.0162541065,
0.0569274984,
0.0314506963,
-0.0162257683,
0.0050589172,
0.001600887,
0.0501554199,
-0.0187504757,
-0.0183352344,
-0.0206619278,
-0.0109269032,
-0.0049655349,
0.0279529169,
0.0273053925,
-0.0072511528,
0.0495422222,
0.0356155187,
-0.0059812837,
-0.0460059568,
-0.0334649272,
-0.032849364,
0.0335237347,
-0.0003626499,
-0.0193513501,
-5.747297877e-33,
-0.0223039612,
-0.0242239442,
-0.014919105,
0.047027532,
-0.0376255438,
-0.007892767,
-0.0478329509,
-0.0189304315,
0.0172615405,
0.0305160172,
-0.0161509272,
-0.0060441541,
0.025871167,
0.076849632,
0.0637592152,
-0.0211674012,
0.0719388872,
-0.0277061686,
-0.0118953455,
-0.0032962016,
0.0238265749,
0.0584281646,
0.056680344,
0.0368563533,
-0.0216289144,
-0.0339474678,
0.0125178099,
0.0438836664,
0.0250008889,
0.0450218543,
-0.0295467004,
-0.0059029376,
0.0599671826,
-0.0222928897,
-0.0376309454,
0.0600282624,
-0.1111785695,
-0.0301423613,
0.0059628822,
0.0109183434,
-0.0822766349,
-0.0033855713,
0.0566757731,
-0.0056626238,
0.0293785278,
-0.0160121322,
0.0442129374,
-0.0078772539,
-0.0202211197,
-0.034220878,
-0.077367872,
0.0107022524,
0.0068964679,
-0.0294056907,
0.0215095431,
0.0107843485,
0.0244689081,
0.0099276593,
-0.0815137923,
-0.0219122786,
-0.0217393339,
0.0747551024,
0.0177492164,
0.0231000409,
-0.0126862871,
0.0793118104,
0.0475800522,
0.027549427,
-0.0346382894,
0.0164717324,
0.0322831944,
0.0452231728,
0.0133895362,
-0.0086597288,
0.0912668481,
0.0026907872,
-0.0312085692,
0.0128890509,
0.0360278636,
0.0343800895,
-0.0338790305,
0.0117780315,
-0.0170212127,
-0.0248583108,
0.0161773916,
-0.0093798265,
-0.011475319,
-0.016431015,
0.0360766351,
0.0273738671,
0.0261198748,
0.0501425415,
0.0244707353,
-0.0155827664,
0.0398480147,
-0.0399655476,
0.0119041847,
0.0233298559,
0.008650599,
0.0080738105,
-0.0802612454,
0.0066524008,
0.0003911863,
0.0050588143,
-0.0089776367,
0.0152375139,
0.0506062843,
0.0085752187,
-0.0597308949,
0.0305387545,
-0.0172024053,
0.0096951323,
-0.0194036067,
0.0525936633,
0.0408351943,
0.0187402032,
-0.0165514424,
0.0840121433,
0.0053212652,
-0.0113519905,
-0.0223173723,
0.0337575302,
-0.0050378474,
0.0323107466,
-0.0027068218,
-0.048475977,
-0.0045117568,
-0.0132584535,
0.0504668914,
-0.0547403358,
0.0051008775,
0.0318286382,
2.511e-7,
0.0099132853,
0.0629167929,
0.1054628566,
-0.0479424521,
0.036740724,
0.0026844572,
-0.0161092635,
0.0387080163,
-0.0524342358,
-0.0056013567,
-0.0206131395,
-0.0413917229,
0.0374834649,
0.0096212504,
-0.1273732632,
0.0337443426,
-0.0695307478,
-0.0295132585,
-0.044687666,
-0.0409270003,
0.0436508209,
0.1025691926,
0.0036213426,
-0.0025340854,
-0.0280097481,
-0.017437309,
0.01538633,
0.0284106676,
-0.0301018786,
0.0245000795,
-0.037930917,
0.0227825213,
-0.0295369495,
0.0059693535,
-0.0443499498,
0.0396898948,
0.0076351585,
0.0408131368,
0.0191368237,
-0.0079060197,
0.0291633811,
-0.0051516094,
-0.001906871,
-0.0066753863,
0.0291788746,
-0.0716750398,
-0.0153597966,
0.016024556,
-0.0174651071,
0.0318109691,
-0.0264322981,
0.0164231267,
0.0080193058,
0.0267319307,
0.0207665414,
-0.0091917654,
-0.0137965512,
-0.0610589385,
-0.0178501494,
0.039069891,
-0.0412748232,
0.0216991436,
-0.0343430974,
-0.0179210305,
0.0345666669,
-0.0618635714,
-0.0349983759,
2.26095961e-34,
0.0001973624,
-0.0056573856,
0.0086670434,
0.0335833281,
0.0422800295,
-0.0140707903,
-0.0408025309,
0.0274510197,
-0.0046106786,
-0.0334230624,
0.0022493945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.11508v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.11508v1 | Towards LLM-based Autograding for Short Textual Answers | 2023-09-09T22:25:56 | 2023-09-09T22:25:56 | Johannes Schneider, Bernd Schenk, Christina Niklaus, Michaelis Vlachos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Grading of exams is an important, labor intensive, subjective, repetitive and
frequently challenging task. The feasibility of autograding textual responses
has greatly increased thanks to the availability of large language models
(LLMs) such as ChatGPT and because of the substantial influx of data brought
about by digitalization. However, entrusting AI models with decision-making
roles raises ethical considerations, mainly stemming from potential biases and
issues related to generating false information. Thus, in this manuscript we
provide an evaluation of a large language model for the purpose of autograding,
while also highlighting how LLMs can support educators in validating their
grading procedures. Our evaluation is targeted towards automatic short textual
answers grading (ASAG), spanning various languages and examinations from two
distinct courses. Our findings suggest that while "out-of-the-box" LLMs provide
a valuable tool to provide a complementary perspective, their readiness for
independent automated grading remains a work in progress, necessitating human
oversight. | [
0.0482766889,
0.0046452982,
-0.0364966504,
0.0250841007,
-0.0594086722,
-0.0024757625,
-0.0002613061,
0.0167295057,
0.0455860607,
-0.0790802985,
0.0080901394,
-0.0067472165,
-0.0226821825,
0.019357102,
0.0130470917,
-0.0182074308,
0.0130691146,
-0.0281927213,
0.0101705259,
-0.0220028348,
0.0052831522,
0.0083575724,
0.0125791905,
0.0102598704,
0.010054783,
-0.0096030384,
-0.0215940215,
-0.0500673763,
-0.0130269229,
0.0188039728,
0.0307582114,
0.0834828541,
-0.0312005654,
0.0235871747,
0.0000019111,
-0.0558823608,
0.0220014229,
-0.0013455278,
-0.0276344419,
0.0452684052,
0.0361761451,
0.059674494,
-0.0061382763,
0.0240100566,
-0.0736085325,
-0.0028196222,
0.0204117876,
-0.0061751152,
0.0806488022,
0.065627344,
0.0232602302,
0.0069586891,
0.0456472896,
0.0112510938,
0.0134022404,
-0.0222088024,
0.0393278301,
0.0375376157,
0.0141294347,
0.0458388142,
-0.0277507324,
0.0289975256,
0.0216631014,
-0.0423285626,
0.006441494,
-0.0164269377,
-0.022842722,
0.014754924,
0.0153963277,
0.0370654911,
-0.0008103132,
-0.0279366542,
-0.0047206711,
-0.0087066488,
0.0341515206,
0.0083612185,
-0.0531560965,
0.0330752693,
-0.0176781267,
0.0020808349,
0.0281354561,
-0.041414652,
-0.0115594734,
0.0504542552,
0.0190808792,
0.019812474,
0.0069384426,
-0.0355458446,
-0.0164455585,
0.019603502,
0.0169400368,
-0.0661073104,
0.0219943281,
0.0869963467,
-0.0109036099,
0.0149068423,
-0.0044161305,
-0.0188995134,
0.0563750975,
-0.0454767607,
0.0227303244,
0.0122669879,
0.0035132882,
0.0054311156,
-0.0328308903,
0.0862827301,
0.0464409553,
0.0299172997,
-0.0592426583,
0.0069157127,
-0.0106542511,
-0.0046959142,
0.0025755363,
0.0428086296,
-0.0084016072,
0.0568612367,
-0.067978099,
-0.0169930737,
-0.0643800274,
0.0404911414,
0.0206285976,
0.0096830111,
-0.003798953,
0.0183958299,
-0.0487429872,
0.0277944952,
-0.0175014716,
0.0106039289,
-0.0129099386,
-0.0113945743,
0.0186563432,
0.0106904097,
0.0072219423,
0.0191177763,
0.0416418836,
0.0795889497,
-0.0020026106,
0.0108790407,
-0.0120723415,
-0.0479190275,
-0.0168316476,
-0.059104871,
-0.0148148136,
-0.0771499947,
-0.0021415474,
0.0058672982,
-0.0177947935,
-0.0127591668,
0.0087284641,
0.054656148,
-0.0068654949,
0.0162591506,
0.0126134399,
0.006902406,
0.0312909745,
0.0225233752,
0.0009211301,
0.0201190691,
0.0546948686,
0.0402877107,
0.0579142682,
-0.0621162914,
0.07288789,
0.0525585748,
0.0003842006,
0.0062006428,
0.0240086615,
0.0108157825,
0.0008964937,
-0.0043907198,
-0.0227646101,
0.0601036958,
0.0258882549,
-0.0138737513,
0.0357399508,
0.0630133003,
-0.0061889095,
0.0382252149,
0.0151917804,
-0.0056650904,
0.0463533476,
0.0508873202,
-0.059464585,
0.0063424022,
-0.0465234034,
-0.0020417699,
-0.0018091225,
0.0365635306,
0.0120082526,
-0.102596283,
0.0022152083,
-0.0119065009,
0.0024463376,
0.0532176904,
0.0320380814,
-0.0070425668,
-0.0036598551,
-0.0341283455,
0.0287562571,
-0.0565185025,
0.0501871109,
-0.0778314248,
0.0474631228,
0.0717304498,
0.062995933,
-0.0423135161,
-0.025876306,
-0.0222438537,
0.0067009199,
0.0242651962,
0.0331915282,
-0.0526621379,
-0.0470560826,
-0.0414539687,
-0.0223715473,
0.0210207552,
-0.0208798032,
-0.0077929581,
-0.0038256787,
0.0040722489,
0.0077382559,
-0.020993365,
-0.0895872712,
0.0282122362,
-0.0202795304,
-0.0685723945,
-0.0015617859,
-0.0050782654,
0.0001891915,
0.0261859037,
-0.0028686775,
0.024082724,
0.0174957253,
0.0008515082,
-0.0408815667,
-0.0903941691,
-0.0275665186,
0.0027330946,
0.0675797462,
-0.0303981658,
-0.0120307542,
0.005434107,
-0.0586576201,
-0.0364273936,
-0.0061331852,
-0.0229711141,
-0.0193067975,
-0.011944958,
0.0210123472,
-0.0247008465,
-0.0545073785,
-0.063659288,
0.0215694346,
0.0288217049,
0.0523784384,
0.0058001066,
-0.0039738473,
0.035605751,
-0.0036212567,
-0.0446030572,
0.0035942881,
0.0112876007,
0.0380341858,
0.0519857779,
0.0392328724,
-0.0438588187,
-0.0411607325,
-0.0729166791,
-0.0165320132,
0.0133104092,
0.0283404849,
0.0169415027,
-0.0313807875,
-0.0073435614,
0.0065145902,
-0.0859213322,
-0.0159100201,
0.0526317544,
-0.0042350716,
0.0206679665,
-0.012616273,
0.0108846258,
-0.0532894842,
-0.0234050583,
-0.0485904925,
0.0005845706,
0.0647076443,
0.0007993385,
-0.0572376736,
0.0553675257,
-0.015879821,
0.0169424117,
0.0203111097,
-0.0599560179,
-0.0100375023,
-0.0118580423,
0.0174443815,
0.0641943812,
0.0217556879,
-0.0274559036,
0.0652827844,
-0.020822566,
-0.0776720792,
-0.0053336979,
-0.0079622278,
-0.0214443244,
-0.0302366428,
-0.0668947101,
-0.027015781,
0.0157528967,
0.0232292749,
-0.0549692065,
-0.0373344533,
0.0276893415,
-0.0554483943,
0.0020246205,
-0.0217629485,
-0.0518842712,
-0.0094382316,
0.0382482745,
0.0046890583,
-0.0505874828,
0.1022370681,
-0.0216375813,
0.0268325154,
-0.03448008,
0.014279779,
-0.0434815548,
0.047190275,
0.0050445371,
-0.0014524838,
-0.0234792847,
0.0193489771,
-0.0479009561,
-0.0097290147,
0.0337653309,
-0.0940047726,
0.0565099232,
-0.0565969832,
-0.0153262783,
-0.0017098644,
-0.0280263927,
-0.0315894298,
-0.0042468072,
0.0070510437,
0.0206688419,
-0.0352237932,
0.0104298005,
0.0042193732,
-0.0279483739,
-0.0005487779,
-0.004461173,
-0.0581483208,
-0.0101333717,
-0.0002377221,
0.0259987749,
0.0360296257,
-0.0248376038,
0.0180111118,
-0.001468992,
0.0574939288,
0.068258971,
0.0412827581,
0.017573189,
0.0232952479,
-0.0090383943,
0.038526468,
-0.0695179403,
-0.0031722076,
0.023742348,
0.0157955047,
-0.0844125524,
-0.0053897463,
0.1075453535,
0.01440694,
-0.0507279374,
-0.0209881775,
-0.0388627909,
-0.0456532128,
-0.0005893646,
0.0449463725,
-0.0942965373,
0.0000512397,
-0.0119622005,
0.0536456406,
-0.0472128689,
-0.0367538854,
0.0095729977,
-0.0991257131,
0.0449861921,
0.021416435,
-0.0057079205,
-0.0155243995,
-0.0324444138,
-0.0117371436,
-0.0182016566,
0.0029649343,
0.0036154962,
-0.0101130186,
0.0085802721,
0.0356343314,
-0.0618464686,
0.025228139,
0.0692917258,
-0.02704015,
0.0516321734,
0.0339531563,
0.0171865039,
-0.0369349793,
-0.0292290598,
0.0468447246,
-0.036563091,
-0.0200972464,
-0.0169817563,
0.0301235095,
-0.0002214614,
0.0107564833,
-0.0369995609,
0.016137965,
-0.0043670088,
0.0081798341,
0.0866895393,
0.1145322993,
-0.0177050214,
-0.0330632925,
-0.0421300754,
-0.0107297525,
-0.0158309732,
0.065870136,
0.0231540408,
-0.0700770393,
-0.0333061218,
-0.0615366735,
-0.0172133408,
-0.0244739596,
-0.0547854453,
0.0080503486,
-0.0290872045,
0.0113933189,
-0.0487891138,
-0.0825097114,
0.0527037233,
-0.0394520834,
0.0265802294,
0.0115086501,
0.006732062,
-0.018796524,
-0.0160323828,
0.0057523143,
-0.0302917622,
0.0313816965,
-0.0440872461,
-0.0017991284,
0.0087836031,
-0.018466251,
0.0026293166,
0.0184116419,
-0.0446951874,
-0.0447976962,
0.0226815101,
0.0737160072,
0.0176271498,
0.0105670132,
-0.0088630002,
-0.0333633348,
0.0339336284,
-0.0273734797,
-0.0033754467,
0.0136051113,
0.0080111083,
-0.0023369621,
-0.0089337369,
0.0018763144,
-0.0243006609,
0.0309574082,
0.0509272702,
0.0168214627,
-0.0132389106,
-0.0661854967,
0.0361563079,
0.0676000118,
-0.0236837883,
-0.0022751619,
-0.0109858131,
-0.0121984072,
0.0060995976,
-0.0148212099,
-0.047010202,
-0.0034929782,
-0.0050951918,
0.0238139909,
-0.0222672541,
-0.007453768,
0.0004596183,
-0.0529060289,
0.0187385865,
-0.0409886315,
0.0671130419,
0.0173674189,
0.0347959734,
0.0118996352,
-0.021397844,
-0.0302730277,
-0.0134303467,
0.0134066967,
0.0461467393,
-0.0101194996,
0.0554282703,
-0.0143556139,
0.0008430564,
0.0328827649,
0.0181670506,
-0.0478889868,
-0.0024750738,
-0.0369912758,
0.0350720994,
0.0160709228,
0.023429649,
0.0357419625,
-0.0014038413,
0.0057027545,
-0.0286874548,
-0.0099715972,
0.0165622588,
-0.0150116002,
0.0240812358,
0.0152831087,
0.0179304723,
0.019601712,
0.0506196693,
-0.0273846984,
0.0418108441,
-0.0050507332,
-0.0365524814,
-0.0140733141,
-0.0533442833,
0.0077851764,
-0.0122912684,
0.0143073685,
-0.0395336561,
-0.0416216366,
-0.063357994,
-0.0053483243,
0.0580050647,
0.0248085391,
-0.0369433574,
0.0044214916,
0.0450058542,
0.0069830958,
-0.008924976,
-0.0594231598,
0.0562012158,
0.0003079012,
-0.0338450111,
-0.0304139722,
-5.407129281e-33,
-0.0054374207,
-0.0580596812,
0.0263573043,
0.0628404021,
-0.0022160902,
0.0021752664,
0.0041916985,
0.0070115477,
-0.0188465472,
0.0137571646,
-0.028394578,
0.010849149,
-0.0084107807,
0.0243749823,
0.061384473,
-0.0150882499,
0.0197946988,
-0.0194967259,
-0.0139765302,
0.0388217121,
-0.0233833566,
-0.0287371837,
0.0658240318,
-0.0497902222,
0.0922508314,
-0.0200649388,
-0.0121354247,
0.0018416705,
-0.0717656985,
0.0706725419,
-0.0042069401,
0.0750438273,
0.0438050553,
-0.0107096592,
-0.0000355132,
0.0364865921,
-0.0530263893,
-0.0585042834,
0.0178455357,
0.0019332333,
-0.0152580542,
-0.0502064675,
0.0464717597,
-0.0152037581,
-0.0721599013,
-0.0032993529,
0.0524250604,
-0.0481163971,
0.0049634418,
-0.0334002674,
-0.0311436336,
0.0148565853,
-0.0249853451,
-0.0126841767,
-0.014719693,
0.0650491267,
-0.000058685,
-0.0194683578,
-0.003011195,
0.0339034609,
0.0539074205,
0.0350967459,
0.0433386788,
-0.0188762285,
-0.0405613445,
0.0321646705,
0.0230916776,
0.0147008365,
-0.0223390069,
-0.0449686088,
-0.0016371016,
-0.0062881289,
0.1314265877,
0.0483968072,
0.0023341761,
0.0049544624,
-0.0760331154,
0.0623022392,
0.0595054403,
0.0460709594,
-0.0100365095,
-0.0786122084,
-0.041790273,
-0.0354487225,
-0.059152998,
-0.0145781804,
-0.0325916186,
-0.0193314478,
0.0312441252,
-0.0490040332,
0.0129071884,
-0.0217470098,
-0.0002766059,
-0.0603292696,
-0.0177776404,
-0.0106557868,
0.0231026355,
0.0339282528,
-0.010508813,
0.0156171303,
-0.0022149952,
0.0304177143,
0.0091884891,
-0.0429198854,
0.0103877755,
0.0051411008,
0.0070884484,
0.0038538638,
-0.0459747016,
-0.0102990204,
-0.0075924597,
0.0055714156,
0.0494178496,
-0.0015825655,
0.0010771345,
0.0243995246,
0.0203302037,
0.0397638194,
0.0055509312,
0.0199071094,
-0.0277479347,
-0.0381286927,
0.0295730568,
-0.004582583,
-0.0327515155,
-0.0024176254,
-0.038812831,
0.0397783443,
-0.0250612404,
-0.0275496785,
0.0154836271,
0.0200852044,
2.497e-7,
0.0745651126,
0.0610223301,
0.0035728116,
-0.010692697,
-0.01424029,
0.0118195508,
-0.0009039859,
-0.0055585126,
0.0595471598,
0.0249439087,
0.0224905945,
0.0055160709,
0.0304676946,
0.0390127897,
-0.0565714464,
-0.0147690736,
-0.0191800259,
-0.0463029593,
-0.0331138484,
0.0483630113,
0.0830126479,
0.0299959499,
0.0235284381,
-0.0173032004,
-0.0582114942,
-0.0302341152,
0.0076661971,
-0.0212813113,
-0.0232199375,
0.0443562046,
0.0574440621,
-0.0261540487,
0.0445180163,
0.0544652045,
-0.0041465685,
-0.0239235535,
-0.0015342736,
0.0579402186,
-0.0045341393,
0.0119181545,
0.0186890513,
-0.0535098054,
0.0349476784,
-0.0361952931,
0.0616819561,
0.0094374195,
0.0166128464,
-0.0552135818,
-0.024086317,
-0.0478052236,
0.0281711314,
-0.0268725883,
-0.0237420686,
0.0315359458,
0.0142727494,
0.0106163695,
0.0039579445,
-0.0335933343,
-0.0102777146,
0.0133656543,
-0.0086716572,
-0.0519078299,
-0.0140830791,
0.0016141619,
-0.0131406123,
-0.0830360129,
0.0221471414,
2.338075942e-34,
0.0415310487,
-0.0387463942,
0.0271512289,
-0.0014258687,
0.0182992257,
0.0469692983,
0.0185354482,
0.0353637338,
0.0201452877,
-0.0778777525,
-0.0409765877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04862v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04862v1 | Distributional Data Augmentation Methods for Low Resource Language | 2023-09-09T19:01:59 | 2023-09-09T19:01:59 | Mosleh Mahamud, Zed Lee, Isak Samsten | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text augmentation is a technique for constructing synthetic data from an
under-resourced corpus to improve predictive performance. Synthetic data
generation is common in numerous domains. However, recently text augmentation
has emerged in natural language processing (NLP) to improve downstream tasks.
One of the current state-of-the-art text augmentation techniques is easy data
augmentation (EDA), which augments the training data by injecting and replacing
synonyms and randomly permuting sentences. One major obstacle with EDA is the
need for versatile and complete synonym dictionaries, which cannot be easily
found in low-resource languages. To improve the utility of EDA, we propose two
extensions, easy distributional data augmentation (EDDA) and type specific
similar word replacement (TSSR), which uses semantic word context information
and part-of-speech tags for word replacement and augmentation. In an extensive
empirical evaluation, we show the utility of the proposed methods, measured by
F1 score, on two representative datasets in Swedish as an example of a
low-resource language. With the proposed methods, we show that augmented data
improve classification performances in low-resource settings. | [
0.0467135459,
0.0540752001,
0.0057495018,
0.0157939866,
-0.0487956852,
-0.0161211621,
-0.0304032248,
-0.0031122651,
-0.0163823366,
-0.0628250614,
0.0009120075,
-0.0081369048,
0.0367467403,
0.0193750784,
0.0336745605,
-0.0411475152,
0.0568962842,
0.0425783172,
-0.0553827994,
-0.0185723361,
-0.0076940004,
0.0042702602,
0.0248010214,
-0.0133613832,
-0.0120203532,
0.0408410206,
-0.0139281312,
0.0123574343,
0.0382355973,
0.0132367807,
0.0095578274,
0.0485667214,
0.0126360524,
0.0420384929,
0.0000018226,
-0.0662765503,
-0.0192177445,
-0.0043176776,
-0.036037486,
0.0256680418,
0.0979878604,
-0.0365251265,
0.0017246949,
0.0359487943,
-0.0128466208,
-0.0449128151,
0.0427005664,
0.0311393235,
0.0269929972,
0.0730493069,
-0.0223001633,
-0.0513191298,
0.0244138371,
-0.0313425995,
0.0159635134,
0.0146783264,
0.0469899811,
0.0099177258,
0.0207510814,
0.0372492298,
-0.048804462,
0.0342412181,
0.0131688556,
0.0099544218,
0.085202232,
0.0284696072,
-0.0497961268,
-0.0059556286,
0.011152084,
0.0526590273,
-0.0303081758,
-0.0443081632,
-0.0293510053,
-0.0178505126,
-0.0077354489,
0.0219719335,
0.0119187878,
-0.0525903851,
0.0277162138,
0.0388513803,
0.0465157852,
-0.0165819898,
0.0224736631,
0.0185385644,
-0.026391454,
0.0206291862,
0.0359867327,
-0.039250508,
0.0120213311,
0.0025934842,
-0.0102980528,
-0.04566513,
-0.0557189994,
-0.008979084,
-0.0060885516,
0.0188954547,
-0.0883343294,
-0.0911969543,
0.0596641377,
-0.0465673134,
-0.0151367513,
0.0032532311,
-0.0111277904,
0.0228942689,
-0.0424882583,
-0.0366478972,
0.0227296446,
0.012919927,
-0.0437016115,
-0.0312065594,
-0.0236705616,
0.0337742008,
-0.0268062428,
0.0163636748,
-0.0718534216,
-0.0211176239,
-0.0804357156,
0.0202086251,
0.0033879478,
-0.0138863716,
0.0206509158,
0.003254459,
-0.0281678066,
0.0243750904,
-0.0413245745,
-0.0097837774,
0.0031581407,
0.0393390357,
-0.0426476635,
-0.0411895886,
0.0212646592,
-0.0026662941,
0.064909175,
-0.0310843792,
0.0414709486,
0.0142969396,
-0.0065976731,
-0.0778795928,
-0.0523802415,
0.0240912698,
0.0034389566,
-0.0380668752,
-0.0667964965,
-0.0692445785,
0.033888638,
-0.0067384602,
-0.0181361921,
-0.0006482047,
0.0331298932,
-0.0002701224,
-0.0268665589,
0.0997620896,
-0.0976700634,
0.0133118602,
-0.0071914243,
-0.0346997119,
0.0083732493,
0.033960741,
0.0093531404,
-0.0085643381,
0.0389882885,
0.0060376646,
0.010107832,
0.0248097498,
0.0097227432,
0.0278648939,
-0.022765452,
-0.0236973427,
-0.040654581,
0.009146098,
0.0489199311,
0.0370370857,
-0.0081245219,
0.0186162405,
0.032731384,
-0.0284698047,
0.0394026078,
-0.0024592299,
0.0262101237,
0.0417819284,
-0.0463179871,
-0.035990715,
-0.0396413617,
-0.0155542968,
0.0380144492,
0.0290271193,
0.0377210788,
0.0280482601,
-0.0028282453,
-0.0387477465,
0.010940765,
-0.0315751098,
0.0805008635,
-0.0024793216,
0.0546648689,
0.0365032479,
-0.011553444,
0.0230327435,
0.0386961177,
-0.0072123748,
0.0288118031,
-0.0300029628,
-0.0403789431,
0.0696740299,
0.0530074127,
-0.0128531959,
-0.0285308082,
-0.0266498253,
-0.0016180167,
0.0243747458,
0.0102492506,
0.0008101817,
-0.0058321794,
-0.0497304872,
-0.0124621112,
-0.0115458081,
0.0153153343,
0.0244940408,
0.0673862025,
0.0437014624,
0.0185419675,
-0.0769399032,
-0.0485423394,
0.0189389344,
-0.0093793375,
-0.0222999267,
0.055757422,
0.0139811086,
-0.0011214655,
0.0379485339,
-0.0101748919,
0.0131133376,
0.0152619565,
-0.042441152,
-0.0725122094,
0.0147288451,
0.0395207591,
-0.0682223141,
0.0168488584,
-0.0299897753,
-0.0348897167,
0.0468033142,
-0.0472291969,
-0.0286369883,
0.017092634,
-0.0389729701,
0.0684171841,
-0.0500731878,
0.0012845974,
0.0130243003,
0.0698430315,
-0.017241383,
0.0804985464,
-0.0026778111,
0.0473710336,
-0.0168805569,
0.0542503893,
0.0290364083,
0.0184319336,
-0.0245594345,
-0.0340853967,
-0.034467116,
0.0340467803,
0.0165003035,
-0.0219632275,
-0.037376903,
0.0009348445,
-0.0736411512,
0.0053261551,
-0.0091471132,
0.0181570761,
0.0248525031,
0.056958925,
-0.0137110231,
-0.0143133402,
-0.031003546,
0.0095870849,
0.0096801324,
0.0274033006,
0.0230002869,
-0.0030128555,
-0.0406654589,
-0.0138327852,
0.010880528,
0.0285345372,
0.0107585965,
-0.0096732052,
-0.0453528874,
-0.0089240205,
0.0463783182,
-0.0173793659,
0.0466444157,
-0.010681293,
-0.0367459878,
-0.0524378084,
0.030488072,
0.0517690554,
-0.0100561855,
0.017755175,
-0.0501067825,
0.029984558,
0.0215843413,
-0.0359741412,
-0.0145485466,
-0.042141296,
-0.0366540998,
-0.0280292593,
-0.0385325849,
-0.0130010452,
-0.0132237775,
0.0289068148,
-0.0419458598,
0.0016518072,
-0.0156068439,
0.0045737978,
-0.0084322793,
-0.043770168,
0.008678644,
-0.0192258544,
0.0257877987,
-0.0150201749,
-0.0352505706,
0.0552539229,
0.0012717861,
0.0036598006,
-0.0910615027,
-0.0745889097,
-0.0271881018,
0.0248474423,
-0.0097159622,
0.0295355804,
-0.0727010667,
-0.0007911918,
-0.0096894829,
-0.0107656773,
0.0243602656,
-0.017723348,
0.0299547613,
-0.0046122484,
0.0050329007,
-0.0005034614,
-0.028841408,
-0.0511555299,
-0.0984214172,
0.0165219121,
-0.0154049685,
0.0378517173,
-0.0407641493,
-0.0291782953,
-0.0285500083,
-0.0114861941,
0.0516546667,
0.0087092333,
-0.0107606761,
-0.0273324866,
0.0277046878,
0.0386393666,
0.0097327325,
-0.0250322055,
0.0276901126,
-0.0259464588,
0.0074789743,
0.0104369773,
-0.0155626228,
-0.0141916024,
-0.018145103,
0.0029229077,
-0.0093364138,
0.0016797144,
-0.0110207275,
0.0080129234,
-0.0066322675,
0.0137398941,
0.0664978549,
0.0276868735,
0.0107784104,
0.0149186263,
-0.0311862845,
0.0329798274,
0.0417232886,
0.0295287147,
-0.0958218724,
-0.0218727123,
0.009701387,
0.0109680453,
-0.0293742586,
-0.0191990677,
-0.0049769916,
-0.1282695681,
0.0184112955,
-0.0260272659,
-0.0368703045,
-0.0390897356,
-0.0535320938,
0.0175650343,
-0.0223623514,
-0.0185552239,
-0.0458851308,
0.0190633219,
0.0037003614,
-0.0044497242,
0.013588828,
-0.1014541462,
-0.0026134611,
-0.0337452255,
0.0449789055,
0.0163225029,
0.0202358831,
-0.0282043889,
-0.042038776,
0.0548018813,
-0.0323223025,
-0.0283448324,
0.0218736213,
0.0582185127,
-0.0240721088,
-0.0088216569,
0.0022278631,
0.0527796187,
-0.0013071697,
-0.035099268,
-0.0122767212,
0.0597081445,
0.0200335216,
0.0195792429,
-0.0145382136,
-0.0207262971,
0.0654066652,
0.053714972,
0.0208363533,
-0.0176654197,
0.0053644478,
0.0332810245,
-0.0132537195,
-0.0007371243,
0.0789095238,
0.0383732952,
-0.0375609994,
-0.0618738569,
-0.0676538274,
-0.0578092337,
0.0329682343,
0.0031016476,
0.0226212926,
0.0629517809,
-0.0491250828,
-0.0417395793,
-0.0838832408,
0.0023177061,
0.0128657725,
0.0441678613,
0.0284069944,
-0.0279112291,
0.010254343,
-0.0031446547,
-0.0118341176,
-0.017006522,
-0.0216104779,
-0.0687204227,
0.0196981523,
-0.0083748596,
0.0148823727,
0.0684418082,
-0.0272478517,
-0.0150303477,
0.0382279642,
0.1089837775,
-0.0056229811,
0.03528006,
0.01837302,
-0.0078170178,
0.0284330063,
0.016251659,
-0.0125214383,
0.0149342325,
0.0126943933,
0.0123199783,
-0.0072001484,
-0.0155942449,
0.008512333,
0.0264157876,
0.0533439405,
-0.0760747269,
0.0016175217,
-0.0340622291,
0.0171188638,
-0.0071450719,
-0.0272834189,
-0.00508215,
-0.0248375181,
0.0305770617,
0.0209052209,
-0.0146270776,
0.0351802669,
-0.0561761595,
0.0428138487,
0.0312343016,
-0.0009854874,
0.008808923,
-0.0345462225,
0.0361945331,
0.0297635235,
0.0009142164,
-0.0197400842,
0.0267432388,
0.0266011897,
-0.0270382557,
-0.0143015385,
0.0207144152,
-0.0378164053,
-0.0306060053,
0.0306757744,
-0.0402694568,
0.0155334221,
-0.0415281951,
0.022535203,
0.0213517491,
-0.0241308678,
0.0237786714,
-0.0429887138,
-0.025733538,
-0.0069804951,
0.0235335771,
-0.0459757932,
-0.0337128639,
0.0153938476,
-0.0030471978,
-0.0448571853,
0.0371072143,
0.02395913,
-0.0369293056,
0.053895317,
-0.0383156762,
0.0005832466,
-0.0249357857,
-0.0024144449,
0.0433615744,
0.0458790176,
-0.0081526879,
-0.0001804121,
-0.0701932833,
-0.0852501169,
0.0088125085,
0.0249054041,
-0.0298813656,
0.027833892,
0.0414479561,
0.0348839872,
0.0229483917,
0.0411421806,
-0.0581511669,
0.0083232252,
0.0306472052,
-0.0526312441,
0.0169080254,
-5.9825345e-33,
0.0120724523,
0.0071221101,
0.0030081377,
-0.060053274,
-0.0166982338,
0.0271062516,
0.0155144148,
-0.0176780466,
0.0112492424,
0.040012192,
-0.0132809458,
-0.0010242912,
0.0248544384,
0.0343738347,
-0.01709239,
-0.0051000696,
0.0303060096,
0.0408822335,
0.0023252687,
-0.0217678007,
0.0375057571,
0.0394964926,
0.0760475993,
-0.0563006289,
0.0216512699,
0.0166770443,
0.0038374832,
0.0070405807,
0.0613964908,
0.0023666108,
-0.0130420392,
0.0848199502,
0.0163973887,
-0.0295589585,
0.0139872776,
0.0347162262,
-0.0755203441,
-0.0392457135,
0.0389833041,
-0.0062930062,
-0.0341910943,
0.01511708,
0.0406810939,
-0.0271291398,
0.0049325163,
0.0280889533,
0.029450627,
-0.0333905779,
-0.0123356404,
0.0041287923,
-0.0731259659,
0.0452341214,
0.0435360335,
0.0104037141,
-0.0239325855,
0.0179965962,
0.0126775196,
-0.0208680499,
-0.0739473701,
0.0264392421,
0.0159119144,
0.0090500675,
0.019774219,
0.003442968,
-0.0043998426,
0.0576165281,
0.0323950462,
-0.0039970852,
-0.0091813309,
0.0085828975,
0.0388529748,
0.012010389,
0.0099924328,
0.1109769046,
0.0608374625,
-0.0289000049,
-0.0456074737,
0.0582285263,
-0.0092827957,
-0.0169606935,
-0.0005175595,
-0.0106989183,
-0.0831046477,
-0.0511519127,
-0.0377368517,
0.0226233117,
-0.0233774129,
-0.047928948,
0.0317468904,
0.0218552351,
-0.0243639927,
0.0332170166,
-0.0061841505,
-0.0513235256,
-0.0374253094,
-0.0068692844,
-0.0120005123,
0.0234357007,
-0.0069316579,
-0.0234790798,
-0.0146539714,
-0.0391496681,
0.0214122012,
0.0568061955,
-0.0191617291,
0.0055079595,
0.0403601788,
0.0118887369,
-0.0848866329,
0.0451837853,
-0.0054713706,
0.0085984217,
-0.0489308052,
-0.0130714057,
0.0178347807,
0.053296674,
-0.0099416422,
0.0104631996,
0.0700581744,
0.0510256514,
-0.0030592685,
0.0065427613,
0.0087280395,
0.0297241211,
0.0113015827,
0.0119079575,
-0.0258497037,
0.0005974406,
0.0332768895,
-0.0613986403,
0.0187870562,
-0.0363342017,
2.805e-7,
0.0564833246,
0.0280993059,
-0.0044922247,
-0.0447010025,
-0.0188215375,
0.0178274959,
0.0264019165,
0.0411517844,
-0.0267851856,
-0.0171890538,
0.0335210562,
-0.0129750101,
-0.0100136762,
-0.0026351884,
-0.0934660956,
-0.0039260527,
-0.052876018,
-0.0380917639,
-0.0528959446,
-0.0087594334,
0.0619893596,
0.1352317035,
0.0654350519,
-0.0453391746,
-0.0167278983,
-0.0294517521,
0.014523807,
-0.0046009268,
-0.0531546399,
0.0026560896,
0.0256787892,
0.0454922505,
0.0412222855,
0.0163738038,
-0.0595122539,
0.034043774,
0.0063049616,
0.0082578138,
-0.0317846797,
0.0284667648,
-0.0121668875,
-0.0040573417,
-0.0370715,
-0.0463184267,
0.0559488498,
-0.0602958463,
-0.0236981157,
-0.0224656127,
-0.0377015695,
0.0763821304,
0.05278676,
-0.0448046885,
-0.0555279143,
0.001735546,
0.0457691364,
0.0205006972,
-0.0677707866,
-0.0656290501,
0.0076334719,
0.0318358727,
-0.009647293,
-0.0499423333,
-0.0237452351,
0.0455004238,
0.0434599556,
-0.0257383119,
0.0310528986,
2.388709443e-34,
0.0461412668,
0.0392982736,
-0.0189691037,
-0.0332595594,
-0.0007605046,
-0.0183492023,
0.0372841433,
0.0339014903,
-0.0090419604,
-0.0341089033,
0.0063201175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04858v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04858v1 | Reverse-Engineering Decoding Strategies Given Blackbox Access to a Language Generation System | 2023-09-09T18:19:47 | 2023-09-09T18:19:47 | Daphne Ippolito, Nicholas Carlini, Katherine Lee, Milad Nasr, Yun William Yu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | Neural language models are increasingly deployed into APIs and websites that
allow a user to pass in a prompt and receive generated text. Many of these
systems do not reveal generation parameters. In this paper, we present methods
to reverse-engineer the decoding method used to generate text (i.e., top-$k$ or
nucleus sampling). Our ability to discover which decoding strategy was used has
implications for detecting generated text. Additionally, the process of
discovering the decoding strategy can reveal biases caused by selecting
decoding settings which severely truncate a model's predicted distributions. We
perform our attack on several families of open-source language models, as well
as on production systems (e.g., ChatGPT). | [
0.0099351415,
0.0998125896,
-0.0186066497,
0.0740100369,
-0.0270019174,
0.0085782008,
-0.0213596616,
0.0327900164,
-0.0245395266,
0.0015305671,
-0.0007812114,
-0.0158629846,
0.0330054983,
0.0603292771,
0.0475332327,
0.0413696952,
-0.0016444335,
-0.0142631494,
-0.0179485772,
0.0093349768,
-0.0417102911,
0.0269527603,
0.0305209253,
0.0797529891,
0.0383799374,
-0.0186974555,
-0.0193270948,
0.0410551205,
-0.0215793829,
-0.0096197156,
0.0118401088,
0.0382909216,
-0.0191522799,
0.0617738515,
0.0000017157,
0.0167069379,
-0.0227295347,
-0.016387593,
-0.0659834743,
0.0498520471,
0.0599844232,
-0.0181191247,
-0.0414345525,
0.0289652813,
-0.0109915594,
-0.0168579277,
0.0677716061,
0.0097418875,
0.0326649584,
0.0452933758,
0.0265889224,
0.0053518051,
0.0237679388,
0.0010263487,
-0.0332421511,
-0.0168948136,
0.0001511334,
-0.0346889459,
-0.0329998024,
0.0107756173,
-0.0000384539,
0.008889134,
0.0217595268,
0.0063057607,
-0.0638912842,
0.0232587438,
-0.0283135176,
-0.0451014936,
-0.0119795725,
0.0472704135,
-0.0301454458,
-0.0319825262,
0.0336958319,
0.0200100113,
0.0000735674,
-0.0355157666,
0.0087519428,
0.0407797955,
-0.0305774175,
0.0184093192,
0.0190613028,
-0.0130017363,
0.0167334639,
-0.0143176625,
-0.0138749089,
0.0464247912,
0.019591732,
0.0003562809,
-0.0127672693,
-0.0053488445,
0.0487145446,
-0.04370334,
0.0411050841,
0.0042556925,
0.0248126443,
0.0092943721,
-0.0224627312,
-0.0500631109,
0.0168912411,
-0.0253095515,
0.0532730184,
0.0505337678,
-0.0050451602,
-0.0247600842,
-0.0320093818,
0.0198277328,
-0.0162151158,
0.0165538993,
-0.0110235345,
0.0444901586,
0.0167626012,
-0.0312829092,
-0.0274305157,
-0.0200734846,
-0.0332326032,
-0.013119637,
-0.006404018,
0.0084350621,
0.0659843981,
-0.0199995507,
-0.0039809905,
0.0246172491,
-0.0708152577,
-0.0038825555,
0.0316003114,
0.0100103226,
-0.0119497199,
-0.0510256737,
0.0230307262,
-0.1028734222,
-0.0297540855,
0.0097414963,
-0.0179148,
0.0105757657,
-0.0070128767,
0.0572239161,
-0.0194298718,
0.0221145265,
-0.0477188006,
-0.0692488626,
-0.0279818121,
-0.0150884688,
0.0192386601,
-0.0716275871,
-0.0186121911,
-0.0099323299,
-0.0257859323,
-0.0548692942,
0.0103213275,
0.021647647,
-0.0479104184,
0.0530775376,
-0.0237110592,
-0.02195042,
0.0237033386,
0.0067150132,
0.0123081747,
0.090257518,
0.0053979275,
0.0676137954,
0.013325531,
-0.0137649542,
0.0245511606,
0.0558476262,
0.0598932877,
0.0068310304,
-0.0543211512,
-0.0670795813,
0.004587044,
0.0096874349,
0.0579609312,
0.0343062058,
-0.0399406068,
-0.036896497,
0.0491075478,
0.0711616203,
-0.0088498453,
0.0359729901,
0.0503780358,
-0.0052518169,
0.0027836477,
0.0386034511,
-0.0197982825,
-0.0048322808,
-0.0531945378,
0.0197910238,
0.0094094072,
0.0666671842,
0.0016350967,
-0.0182507373,
0.0211490095,
-0.0382021517,
-0.0047839209,
-0.0321722478,
0.0543134734,
0.0522657409,
-0.0305312164,
0.0179147106,
0.0465144664,
-0.035211321,
0.033598315,
-0.0848579928,
-0.001653245,
0.0564681999,
0.0676562265,
0.0212794244,
0.0138090877,
0.006771089,
-0.0512321368,
0.0779120997,
-0.0247897506,
-0.0037621595,
0.0215578899,
-0.0505556241,
-0.0158313606,
0.0216245633,
0.042406112,
0.0645295233,
-0.0138210878,
0.0022199077,
0.0275065824,
-0.0531752966,
-0.0371452197,
0.0289834999,
-0.0529502258,
-0.035103824,
0.0207958557,
-0.0082556261,
0.005928563,
0.0066831489,
-0.0254107807,
0.0397573784,
0.0225090552,
-0.0281135291,
0.0044364249,
0.0056365747,
-0.0194715206,
-0.0720142275,
0.008075227,
-0.0269844923,
0.0098735578,
0.0458444059,
-0.0107826833,
-0.0128375776,
0.089517422,
-0.0346840955,
0.048240941,
-0.0478693321,
0.0024272809,
0.0050491914,
0.012172441,
-0.0247780606,
0.0477341413,
-0.0272409469,
0.0076487646,
0.0189817101,
-0.0202508476,
0.0081332177,
-0.0462219864,
0.0008714868,
0.0314479135,
-0.054567378,
0.0022530118,
0.0029069942,
0.0267582629,
-0.0038517914,
-0.0244251303,
-0.0503998138,
-0.0103319613,
-0.0494344123,
0.0319105536,
0.0421912856,
0.0085554235,
-0.0119847534,
-0.0384370126,
-0.0282457918,
0.0052814474,
-0.0002779654,
0.0033120047,
-0.0017685671,
0.012717857,
-0.0156764109,
-0.0202927906,
-0.0291102082,
-0.012284915,
0.077050209,
-0.0172648542,
0.0026195499,
-0.0860393718,
0.0271948706,
0.0059515722,
0.0130664315,
0.0087903282,
-0.086412847,
0.0250901822,
-0.0265723579,
-0.0089073023,
0.0722609311,
0.0028776126,
0.0345185213,
0.0101522487,
0.0148429973,
-0.0608826242,
-0.0263482407,
-0.01442004,
-0.0318983197,
-0.0303109549,
-0.0944627747,
0.0172118861,
0.1244926378,
0.0446313471,
0.0067519764,
-0.0644306988,
0.042553965,
-0.022598369,
-0.0349041484,
-0.030509131,
0.028410105,
-0.0377744995,
0.0678703114,
-0.012142498,
-0.055513557,
0.0476512387,
-0.0497312583,
-0.002869409,
-0.0316889994,
-0.0063115959,
0.0151934531,
0.0367401503,
0.0028651666,
0.0543458126,
0.0517934822,
-0.0610636324,
-0.0011482616,
0.0469514728,
0.0053688595,
-0.0405590571,
-0.0144378366,
-0.0444614589,
-0.0201399326,
-0.0093085319,
-0.0250560734,
-0.0302067176,
-0.0131813576,
0.0137868868,
-0.0233858265,
0.0400637425,
-0.0295570772,
0.0175159816,
-0.0109617542,
-0.0152088692,
0.0533853099,
-0.0225854199,
-0.0054803342,
-0.0321695916,
0.0178807043,
0.0456751436,
-0.0516712181,
0.0364691615,
-0.0435163863,
-0.039876692,
0.0520885102,
0.0425812937,
0.0713117272,
-0.0161302835,
-0.0050972719,
0.0324743502,
0.0286540594,
0.0146430293,
0.0604376793,
-0.0037837517,
-0.035936486,
-0.028037427,
0.0692381263,
0.0179471634,
-0.0650173724,
0.0148209352,
0.0045435941,
0.0409297943,
-0.0017333336,
0.0238519441,
-0.0414650775,
0.0028644102,
0.0118567869,
0.0751819909,
-0.0256000385,
-0.0172987245,
-0.0175519884,
-0.130071789,
0.0306605026,
0.0334647074,
-0.0528844297,
-0.0174742714,
0.0082050832,
-0.0404764339,
-0.0016874737,
0.0339483917,
0.0259820968,
0.0375365019,
0.0242548157,
0.0114546642,
-0.0287660677,
-0.0593947135,
-0.0348627083,
-0.0316527523,
0.0762517154,
0.1000502557,
0.0184706412,
0.0198484976,
0.0276495349,
0.0183549337,
-0.0215160791,
0.0171178579,
-0.0055074315,
0.0593535937,
0.0236265212,
-0.026276812,
0.0113927666,
0.0408403762,
-0.0767977238,
0.0193392336,
-0.0431699939,
0.006837002,
-0.0171735305,
-0.0248664878,
0.0294620115,
0.0059513967,
0.0564354286,
0.0527595729,
0.0510153398,
-0.0419181809,
-0.0405122377,
-0.0788827613,
0.046282053,
-0.0693152845,
-0.0409459434,
0.0262271687,
0.0436369628,
-0.0724557117,
-0.1031001136,
-0.0071557425,
0.0023475932,
0.0233888254,
0.029749833,
-0.0056037796,
0.0332059674,
-0.0399927273,
-0.0305031259,
-0.0137545941,
-0.0218560956,
-0.0399961844,
-0.0608519949,
-0.0265234355,
0.0021623273,
-0.0422786325,
-0.0114993053,
0.0207786392,
-0.0617319196,
-0.06924887,
0.0057319356,
0.0579045787,
0.0236429498,
0.0371527746,
-0.0407488905,
-0.0559891351,
0.0413138457,
0.0598929189,
-0.0230554938,
0.0115220221,
0.0208471119,
-0.0106847659,
-0.0269878563,
0.0372250602,
-0.0343639404,
0.0096491715,
0.0390788876,
0.0000600833,
-0.0225449502,
0.0177424233,
0.0313415378,
0.0036700806,
0.0404451154,
-0.0608638972,
-0.0122285802,
-0.0140296621,
-0.0050817635,
-0.0249346923,
0.0275692455,
-0.0432457589,
-0.00568577,
0.0466906913,
-0.0244222805,
0.0301842093,
-0.0207055826,
0.0116424989,
0.0521077737,
-0.0248582345,
-0.0015181181,
0.0314893574,
0.0355284587,
0.0496443175,
-0.0065109534,
-0.0071927062,
0.0441880375,
-0.0231758114,
0.0759981796,
-0.0187670458,
0.0360061862,
0.0173619986,
0.0039088195,
0.002616165,
0.0452489741,
-0.0345568061,
-0.0461084098,
-0.0406530015,
-0.003664328,
0.0324456319,
0.0151202194,
0.049286548,
-0.0227310006,
0.0111087197,
-0.0313115679,
0.0183158889,
0.0125163747,
-0.0172608122,
-0.030149579,
-0.0189484917,
-0.0269675553,
-0.0198500659,
0.0953142717,
0.0336044431,
0.0531398505,
-0.0183162838,
-0.0029891666,
-0.017513806,
-0.0126491394,
-0.0289925858,
0.0006681852,
-0.0395973586,
0.0070869676,
-0.032016065,
-0.0605328605,
-0.0355188549,
0.0249783117,
0.0254818648,
-0.0067957044,
-0.004983231,
0.042281054,
-0.0120475544,
0.0043494524,
-0.0500594117,
0.0154205188,
-0.048013296,
-0.0249691997,
-0.0223395973,
-6.079023852e-33,
-0.0100484733,
-0.0215811506,
-0.033649344,
0.0013948719,
0.0328509659,
-0.0011760395,
-0.0576522127,
-0.0176614318,
0.0022559052,
-0.0190430153,
-0.0197867118,
0.0031951477,
0.0249487162,
0.0307053123,
-0.0129216854,
-0.0023183064,
0.0385344662,
-0.0347721875,
-0.0558815822,
0.0437708423,
0.0661796629,
0.0406050868,
0.0537460968,
-0.0357045755,
-0.0060668662,
-0.0001373711,
0.0089193517,
-0.0009258186,
-0.0144671006,
0.0560064912,
-0.0169369038,
0.0002231119,
0.0081831813,
-0.0510483831,
-0.0276903622,
0.0099737952,
-0.0367826335,
0.0074384883,
-0.0033771056,
0.0286713485,
-0.020272404,
-0.0460904166,
0.0323083587,
-0.0240193401,
-0.0195278693,
0.0103587098,
-0.0084931133,
-0.0100954995,
-0.0207975991,
-0.034412723,
-0.0436767377,
-0.0014135131,
-0.0107885199,
-0.0094309729,
0.0280523598,
0.024843419,
-0.0156829599,
-0.0124039436,
-0.0146676889,
0.0198490676,
0.044188831,
0.0384256169,
0.087711826,
0.0614727922,
-0.0004200339,
0.0542893894,
0.0341186449,
-0.0081137456,
-0.0354941338,
-0.0026727447,
0.0581332594,
0.0183990803,
0.0246018823,
0.0039896751,
0.0472562648,
-0.0416526049,
-0.0003433724,
0.0181495342,
0.0493379384,
-0.0305110924,
0.060578011,
-0.0119443722,
-0.0264119059,
-0.0405577384,
-0.0467816964,
-0.1033369899,
-0.0367486998,
-0.0316836238,
0.0396475084,
0.0236177463,
-0.056207139,
-0.0626551583,
0.0467948057,
-0.0794819072,
0.0333078615,
0.0266372878,
-0.030665921,
0.0252996776,
-0.0080845151,
-0.0018947126,
-0.0052578105,
-0.0084875776,
0.0121118575,
-0.0132058999,
0.0308453031,
0.0263523255,
-0.0020630884,
0.0114909988,
-0.0120702563,
0.0258410517,
-0.0498532988,
0.0325935036,
0.0544154495,
0.0280499514,
0.0496098511,
-0.0483838879,
-0.0060678194,
-0.0337721929,
0.0175038055,
0.0578802675,
-0.0255799163,
-0.0117385145,
0.0223522168,
0.022689933,
-0.0430895612,
-0.0166005492,
-0.0179540962,
0.0239442717,
0.0536502078,
0.0074070836,
-0.0118008275,
0.0299023725,
2.418e-7,
0.0306489654,
0.0306445155,
0.056182012,
0.0065908753,
0.0355492532,
0.0314468667,
-0.0107586561,
0.026437236,
-0.0013217056,
-0.0548790172,
-0.0465193614,
-0.0220470112,
0.0742380172,
0.0175622422,
-0.0865450501,
0.0213045292,
-0.0442652293,
0.0221729483,
-0.0658543333,
-0.020843694,
0.0215828121,
0.065769501,
-0.0558690354,
-0.0393467844,
0.0564668179,
-0.0301739033,
0.011690096,
-0.008407128,
-0.006544413,
0.0220216978,
0.0054125455,
0.0224397536,
0.0067859115,
-0.002949974,
-0.039442338,
-0.0460696034,
-0.0299780276,
0.047724247,
-0.0027028741,
-0.0190356709,
-0.0003115048,
-0.0227434002,
0.0085010082,
-0.0207497291,
0.0268374421,
0.0178491343,
-0.01489102,
-0.0319210403,
0.0359039567,
-0.0669155866,
-0.0162006784,
-0.0888492092,
0.0230223481,
0.0346012041,
-0.0178363118,
0.008456544,
0.0177456141,
-0.0307389144,
-0.040963091,
-0.0288403518,
-0.0351050086,
-0.048527211,
-0.0537853613,
0.0098246625,
0.0239150245,
-0.0310493093,
0.0167610534,
2.494793905e-34,
-0.0005249984,
-0.0061947536,
0.0107171163,
0.0165350754,
0.0286419131,
-0.0001275615,
0.0647543296,
0.042557504,
-0.0212399103,
-0.0448831953,
-0.0341176651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04849v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04849v2 | Speech Emotion Recognition with Distilled Prosodic and Linguistic Affect Representations | 2023-09-09T17:30:35 | 2024-03-14T21:46:37 | Debaditya Shome, Ali Etemad | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We propose EmoDistill, a novel speech emotion recognition (SER) framework
that leverages cross-modal knowledge distillation during training to learn
strong linguistic and prosodic representations of emotion from speech. During
inference, our method only uses a stream of speech signals to perform unimodal
SER thus reducing computation overhead and avoiding run-time transcription and
prosodic feature extraction errors. During training, our method distills
information at both embedding and logit levels from a pair of pre-trained
Prosodic and Linguistic teachers that are fine-tuned for SER. Experiments on
the IEMOCAP benchmark demonstrate that our method outperforms other unimodal
and multimodal techniques by a considerable margin, and achieves
state-of-the-art performance of 77.49% unweighted accuracy and 78.91% weighted
accuracy. Detailed ablation studies demonstrate the impact of each component of
our method. | [
-0.0533119589,
0.0737030283,
0.0048519899,
0.0017461523,
0.0079475418,
0.014342756,
0.011726399,
-0.0669316873,
-0.0093794586,
-0.0363010652,
-0.0704226419,
0.0111700231,
-0.0096136574,
0.0173951201,
-0.0032298206,
-0.067391336,
0.0011688957,
0.0140944095,
0.0540715009,
-0.0124811456,
0.0578613691,
0.0200817157,
-0.0775177255,
0.0138923898,
-0.0398058854,
-0.012044712,
-0.064908497,
0.0227115452,
0.0336658247,
-0.0237914566,
0.0154452017,
0.0280937217,
0.0406224839,
0.0059600808,
0.0000021585,
0.007535676,
-0.0083357655,
-0.0130525837,
-0.0161955785,
0.0183738284,
0.0681334287,
-0.0052283313,
-0.0131734768,
0.0157352928,
0.0044340417,
-0.03290236,
0.0472945198,
0.0309679527,
0.0674077496,
0.0305000581,
-0.0179870799,
0.0114074294,
-0.0186566506,
-0.0139390603,
-0.0294740442,
0.0297165532,
-0.0201034471,
0.0012661151,
0.0097371312,
-0.0717784539,
-0.0553217568,
0.0223718584,
-0.0076171276,
0.0087672248,
0.0041726036,
-0.0017713199,
-0.0471412614,
-0.0214306302,
-0.044930011,
0.0865781978,
0.0347435623,
0.0169298183,
0.0014091793,
0.0022552744,
0.0000489769,
-0.0327210017,
0.0023667293,
-0.0197078083,
0.0273043383,
0.0245264061,
-0.0245339423,
0.0424405746,
0.0007269085,
-0.0153400516,
-0.0029269615,
-0.0066284859,
-0.0159201752,
0.0107454462,
0.0448829643,
-0.0331578441,
-0.0231473073,
0.0269532446,
-0.0005450647,
-0.0341806412,
0.036168389,
-0.0318851545,
-0.0382380448,
-0.024336271,
-0.038511686,
0.0262006801,
-0.0208628494,
0.0444128104,
-0.0566761233,
0.0354361087,
0.0107964203,
-0.0009653564,
0.0058173509,
-0.0203078464,
-0.0159757826,
-0.0090663107,
-0.0680723935,
0.0377184078,
0.0086628897,
0.024528712,
-0.0360705256,
-0.0488799363,
-0.056411624,
-0.0269971173,
-0.0373831205,
-0.0181800611,
-0.0034682604,
0.00934311,
0.0097305262,
0.0138228796,
0.0051961658,
0.0778641254,
-0.0154239945,
0.046164602,
0.006686131,
-0.0455148667,
0.0098599279,
0.0016636862,
0.0292505585,
0.0067070657,
0.0484845713,
0.0246934909,
-0.0135199381,
-0.0457063317,
-0.0444164723,
-0.0168766677,
-0.0431510769,
-0.0513067767,
0.0382640511,
-0.0434742458,
0.0437434614,
-0.017210871,
0.0146654239,
-0.052496098,
0.0064757932,
-0.0721965656,
0.0085974121,
0.0770467371,
-0.01416854,
-0.0040281885,
-0.0152664557,
0.0116715347,
0.0007987977,
0.0394083597,
0.0332355723,
0.0351366512,
0.0062303455,
-0.0297239367,
-0.0369717181,
0.004298917,
0.0166927408,
-0.0194015708,
-0.0092715081,
-0.0454237238,
-0.0153276417,
0.0061734356,
0.0886002481,
0.0367723368,
-0.0231642313,
-0.0212095194,
0.073655434,
0.0179200117,
0.0052150665,
0.0299660489,
-0.0245065,
0.0386288874,
0.0079534231,
-0.0520379208,
-0.039507512,
0.0303475726,
0.0097227283,
-0.0170869902,
0.0703390166,
0.0340408571,
-0.0231649913,
-0.0099400571,
0.0105269933,
-0.0379851982,
-0.0056606582,
0.0521357022,
0.0378168151,
-0.0347303636,
-0.0134618813,
0.046726495,
0.0261243265,
-0.0598296374,
-0.0070921155,
0.02314003,
-0.0247137435,
0.0569391362,
-0.0178257022,
-0.0622226298,
-0.0074141407,
-0.0367535427,
0.0217268448,
0.0112033775,
0.0066134678,
-0.0070126052,
0.0889014751,
-0.0749906451,
-0.0207292363,
-0.0222436544,
-0.0079390435,
0.0459817983,
-0.028955847,
0.0671355724,
-0.0176262576,
-0.0444004908,
0.0723278001,
-0.0147297848,
0.0109322648,
-0.0682063028,
-0.0300699733,
0.0280667711,
0.0329136997,
0.0016882085,
-0.0396101139,
-0.0238873959,
0.0481879488,
-0.0241603423,
-0.0081350226,
0.0267075151,
-0.0352712236,
-0.0502335951,
0.0625125691,
-0.058094319,
0.0345728472,
0.0198443104,
-0.0114701623,
-0.0406400822,
0.0828720778,
0.0075475238,
0.0707504898,
-0.0386040173,
-0.0210209657,
0.0056092432,
0.046381332,
0.0482695922,
-0.0267810151,
-0.0067207059,
-0.0535882823,
0.0076120221,
0.0001254657,
-0.0080328723,
0.012796673,
-0.0891966596,
0.0388343185,
0.0144590382,
0.0115543026,
-0.032427825,
-0.0164286662,
-0.0360341556,
-0.0478868,
-0.1188717186,
-0.0008382868,
-0.0030568193,
-0.0105831157,
-0.0214924831,
0.0239436422,
-0.028534377,
-0.0141803809,
-0.0117661348,
-0.0109163756,
0.0002027724,
-0.0024651808,
-0.0458385572,
-0.008676514,
0.0048143463,
-0.0236574877,
0.017012259,
-0.0059092399,
-0.0106459009,
-0.0828252286,
0.0306194872,
0.0210498832,
-0.0136138182,
-0.0215652213,
0.0489457063,
-0.017295137,
-0.0403164253,
0.0125382701,
-0.0040501319,
0.0023327225,
0.0082541015,
-0.0416731685,
0.0540857799,
0.0242352523,
-0.0405243188,
-0.0477381386,
0.0653469488,
0.0093854647,
0.0605639927,
-0.0186414048,
0.0287078712,
-0.0968433544,
0.0337741598,
0.0179389417,
0.0232982617,
-0.015615277,
-0.0264229681,
0.0459558368,
-0.0619914271,
0.0031197204,
0.003298803,
-0.0060243844,
-0.0488064662,
0.0120016886,
-0.0298049673,
0.0276995096,
-0.0206505824,
-0.0678973868,
-0.0573794171,
-0.0124477837,
0.0150011247,
0.0568945855,
-0.077709727,
-0.0030119815,
0.0036818613,
0.0132193984,
-0.0031981294,
-0.0263231844,
-0.0182022881,
-0.0664230958,
0.0037169449,
-0.0165598541,
-0.0406797901,
0.0232608486,
-0.0459123924,
-0.0188356675,
-0.0549777672,
-0.0492668748,
0.0090872627,
-0.0079015298,
-0.0106934486,
-0.0050661708,
-0.0326909162,
0.0476316437,
-0.0412039496,
0.0281341579,
0.00274642,
-0.0044182185,
0.0464062095,
0.0101887928,
0.0433851965,
0.0177358035,
0.0200654138,
0.0607425794,
0.0319143496,
0.0691493377,
0.0081696678,
-0.0319817998,
0.0729967728,
0.0060227765,
0.0394510515,
-0.0241230968,
-0.0218152851,
0.038126573,
-0.0238494053,
0.0714235455,
0.0928212404,
0.0203286856,
-0.0232467744,
0.00270725,
0.0106272064,
0.0453466475,
0.0171432607,
-0.0053425897,
-0.0410485752,
-0.086932458,
0.0212976616,
0.053488981,
0.0161204431,
-0.0043589259,
0.0068299803,
-0.0635290071,
-0.0002655406,
0.0142760882,
0.0261049792,
-0.0429228358,
-0.0325153172,
0.0104711279,
-0.0112838699,
-0.0253197663,
-0.0218739118,
0.0032639301,
-0.0129626626,
0.0484350473,
-0.0341225937,
-0.0584172197,
0.026953714,
-0.0283505283,
0.0387102775,
-0.0011938013,
0.0703302994,
-0.0105756838,
-0.0536558442,
-0.0267463923,
-0.0159319825,
-0.0121445423,
-0.0235616006,
0.0375891328,
-0.0146716181,
-0.0309567209,
0.0012442154,
0.0467362218,
-0.0491473414,
0.0204656031,
0.0054643978,
0.0966316909,
-0.0292893182,
-0.0108060781,
-0.0063575581,
0.028475143,
0.0440134145,
0.0264477339,
0.020408066,
-0.0420218743,
-0.0425728969,
0.0087726368,
0.0074134548,
0.0405238457,
-0.0024186436,
0.0142930234,
0.0238408744,
-0.0138762435,
-0.0198172852,
-0.0685181543,
0.0174048506,
0.0405452512,
-0.0048920093,
-0.0297761597,
-0.0181885883,
0.0220188107,
-0.0661599115,
0.049269136,
0.0451807119,
0.0202425364,
0.0105173104,
-0.0111685954,
0.0338911898,
0.0033485934,
-0.0010885206,
0.0231513306,
-0.0342968479,
-0.0805135816,
0.0250691567,
0.0121287862,
0.0084803645,
0.0238496885,
0.0131750256,
-0.001323841,
0.0717496201,
0.0209012534,
-0.003078599,
0.0220608693,
0.0825321078,
-0.0223921686,
-0.0053820568,
-0.0155799445,
-0.0104439482,
0.0402913168,
0.0000835227,
0.0099246409,
0.0270269811,
-0.0196285695,
-0.0167095326,
0.0175153334,
0.0662747547,
0.0190292168,
-0.0264674854,
-0.0254524183,
-0.0099380696,
0.0168506708,
0.0681383535,
-0.0513115637,
-0.0040763556,
-0.0057040793,
0.0360001512,
-0.0364483111,
0.0059853513,
0.042666804,
-0.0458615646,
-0.0017876234,
0.0747333467,
0.0396760888,
0.0118979393,
-0.0154080773,
0.0235033333,
0.0128124785,
0.0584700555,
0.0259496886,
-0.0119278636,
-0.0300267301,
0.0351045504,
-0.0137142325,
-0.0393738225,
-0.0265538115,
0.0352065228,
-0.0028784287,
0.0360226855,
-0.0138108516,
0.0377199687,
0.0303908568,
-0.0176383313,
0.0359151848,
-0.036762666,
0.0427588001,
-0.0051289028,
0.0271587986,
-0.0537185147,
0.0328794569,
0.0193832126,
-0.001219929,
-0.0308591016,
0.0073397299,
0.0049424581,
-0.0284818485,
0.0712464452,
-0.0275844131,
0.0454037152,
-0.0683020353,
-0.0348417982,
0.0914968625,
0.0008376968,
-0.0065367152,
0.0197226219,
-0.040748585,
-0.0408223681,
0.0427219011,
-0.021837268,
-0.0332071632,
-0.0526403785,
0.0315128304,
0.0113957124,
-0.0281557813,
0.0336471722,
0.001892727,
-0.0296312384,
-0.0245936271,
-0.0171356387,
0.0387970507,
-6.224086835e-33,
-0.0012425524,
0.0423301086,
-0.0360556021,
-0.0035115078,
-0.0619291216,
0.0464813672,
0.0090375999,
0.0347424783,
0.0097821224,
0.025487816,
-0.0214962177,
0.0254312381,
0.0128965108,
0.001859965,
0.0086981542,
-0.0184057616,
0.0386941582,
-0.0219601914,
0.0089019192,
0.0349151604,
0.0432466604,
0.0758746937,
0.0397101827,
-0.0904641375,
-0.0109545514,
0.0331722535,
-0.0222422816,
-0.0673263371,
0.0611130707,
0.020089563,
-0.0215407908,
0.0484323241,
-0.0327209719,
-0.0060938178,
-0.0208246317,
0.0076928502,
-0.0608212128,
0.0016190812,
-0.009989975,
-0.005585948,
-0.0336534046,
-0.0178601407,
0.016250262,
0.0359103382,
-0.0209724829,
-0.0220477246,
0.0097018667,
-0.0110905468,
0.0219862144,
-0.0397722013,
0.0046226867,
0.0134853916,
-0.0449822694,
-0.0456901081,
0.0641205013,
0.0243582036,
0.0247865207,
-0.0017822031,
-0.0532497764,
-0.0091181574,
-0.0249581262,
0.0126810279,
0.0102724861,
-0.003733906,
0.0119831022,
0.1012222618,
0.0262841694,
-0.0823786259,
0.0367028341,
0.0324799456,
0.066409491,
0.0658547506,
-0.0092465198,
0.0628405064,
0.0233543385,
-0.0170876589,
-0.0170061383,
0.0278642159,
0.0726077259,
0.0008978816,
0.017333677,
0.0224072728,
-0.0057111233,
0.0129373595,
-0.0271274522,
-0.0421658531,
0.0148808062,
-0.0114666875,
0.0444259569,
-0.00885785,
0.0106742075,
-0.0038723208,
0.0267615058,
-0.0055268928,
0.0020249244,
0.0382910967,
0.005202177,
0.0347954705,
0.0031057019,
0.0180877876,
-0.0367696285,
-0.0333281532,
0.0649984106,
0.0010134542,
0.0446489789,
-0.0272991508,
-0.0306974873,
0.0649291053,
-0.0410245098,
-0.0177913252,
-0.0155284619,
0.0641682371,
-0.0196452774,
0.0159608088,
0.0017719732,
0.0082846191,
0.0023757324,
-0.0438497886,
0.0075474987,
0.0595372133,
-0.0062066126,
-0.0517536066,
0.0335102789,
0.0416800119,
-0.0511890166,
-0.0115590841,
0.0119168796,
-0.0735929012,
-0.0288441535,
-0.0362857133,
0.0062575857,
0.0208224431,
2.994e-7,
-0.0288263559,
-0.0004642828,
0.024342889,
-0.0720145553,
0.0527237058,
0.0414691754,
-0.0362306982,
0.026432652,
0.0271073431,
-0.0615084507,
0.0527102426,
0.0294405222,
0.0969595835,
0.0258137714,
-0.1005712375,
-0.034076672,
0.0054224338,
0.0028957713,
-0.005920832,
-0.0082951225,
0.0595485792,
0.0816802606,
0.0299722292,
-0.0063065155,
0.0172571,
0.0240138005,
0.0234410763,
-0.0147081912,
0.015154466,
-0.0461872257,
0.0022163903,
-0.0564344041,
-0.0398736782,
-0.0096347816,
-0.0144599639,
0.0370615199,
-0.0034898664,
0.0561280437,
0.009252768,
-0.1105734408,
0.0104846265,
0.0466234908,
-0.0429399237,
0.0319961868,
0.0450790301,
-0.0298812483,
-0.0214545187,
-0.0215562079,
-0.0563086234,
-0.0076719061,
0.0495525263,
-0.0238061361,
-0.0517533235,
0.0132829444,
-0.0197504535,
-0.0705950782,
-0.0399906486,
-0.0653125346,
0.0093191201,
0.0535473377,
-0.0541249514,
-0.0470823422,
-0.014273528,
-0.01064076,
0.0485240482,
-0.0330305248,
-0.0327033699,
2.224494719e-34,
-0.0037969134,
-0.0256321449,
0.0171473622,
-0.003275183,
0.0040901806,
-0.0158320758,
-0.0498418286,
-0.0503689162,
0.0449800342,
-0.0456477217,
-0.011100458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04842v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04842v2 | Leveraging Large Language Models for Exploiting ASR Uncertainty | 2023-09-09T17:02:33 | 2023-09-12T16:46:26 | Pranay Dighe, Yi Su, Shangshang Zheng, Yunshu Liu, Vineet Garg, Xiaochuan Niu, Ahmed Tewfik | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.SD, eess.AS | While large language models excel in a variety of natural language processing
(NLP) tasks, to perform well on spoken language understanding (SLU) tasks, they
must either rely on off-the-shelf automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems
for transcription, or be equipped with an in-built speech modality. This work
focuses on the former scenario, where LLM's accuracy on SLU tasks is
constrained by the accuracy of a fixed ASR system on the spoken input.
Specifically, we tackle speech-intent classification task, where a high
word-error-rate can limit the LLM's ability to understand the spoken intent.
Instead of chasing a high accuracy by designing complex or specialized
architectures regardless of deployment costs, we seek to answer how far we can
go without substantially changing the underlying ASR and LLM, which can
potentially be shared by multiple unrelated tasks. To this end, we propose
prompting the LLM with an n-best list of ASR hypotheses instead of only the
error-prone 1-best hypothesis. We explore prompt-engineering to explain the
concept of n-best lists to the LLM; followed by the finetuning of Low-Rank
Adapters on the downstream tasks. Our approach using n-best lists proves to be
effective on a device-directed speech detection task as well as on a keyword
spotting task, where systems using n-best list prompts outperform those using
1-best ASR hypothesis; thus paving the way for an efficient method to exploit
ASR uncertainty via LLMs for speech-based applications. | [
0.0289330687,
0.0338196084,
0.0102801528,
0.0502388962,
-0.0077016107,
0.0057186838,
0.0386579931,
-0.0337299965,
0.0545025282,
-0.0688992515,
-0.0303055886,
-0.0604150705,
0.021479439,
0.010758251,
-0.0045239413,
0.0187989064,
0.0515643507,
-0.0878276229,
-0.0008617625,
-0.0082413489,
-0.0128681008,
0.016406009,
-0.0188944042,
0.0256097354,
0.0233817361,
0.0311094578,
-0.0215538796,
0.0369618498,
0.0031144333,
-0.0247255005,
-0.0231515635,
-0.0037249483,
0.04128097,
0.0487849824,
0.0000019174,
-0.0339089334,
-0.0467734635,
0.0129939355,
-0.1069771945,
-0.0110258702,
0.0181961078,
-0.0126448032,
-0.0228354502,
0.0359894782,
0.025064135,
0.0179620497,
0.0530928969,
0.0189424548,
0.0015695998,
0.0642044172,
0.0150025059,
-0.0016452941,
0.0248230025,
-0.0356479324,
-0.0094214007,
-0.0671128184,
-0.0085095968,
-0.08192835,
0.0450525135,
0.0020511255,
-0.0046585654,
0.0384123772,
-0.0158245862,
0.0171489958,
0.0112680662,
-0.0023901914,
0.0166743752,
-0.0362555832,
-0.0657959804,
0.0252047144,
-0.0253536403,
-0.0161759816,
0.0275908262,
-0.0164389238,
-0.0358993672,
-0.0177152604,
0.0153047126,
0.0381602906,
-0.0343914963,
0.0035808682,
0.0315367803,
-0.0125258807,
0.0491819605,
0.0426451601,
-0.050105121,
0.0594183467,
0.0066728555,
-0.0022970547,
-0.0104226796,
-0.016001422,
0.0029658005,
-0.0492539071,
0.0234459098,
0.026212981,
-0.0962978303,
0.0393603668,
-0.0139976479,
-0.0094668036,
-0.000657753,
-0.021064138,
0.0284919236,
0.0522188358,
-0.0338675305,
0.0338335857,
-0.0028725693,
0.0564072542,
-0.0039433534,
-0.0091715967,
-0.0400297306,
-0.0032652628,
0.0029775822,
0.005543577,
-0.0207666364,
0.0359116979,
-0.0574881583,
-0.058770068,
-0.0123601789,
0.0429056957,
0.0216505062,
0.0283330735,
0.006134389,
-0.0286315382,
-0.0360922851,
-0.0365751609,
0.0054091271,
0.0267335121,
0.0330517478,
0.041368898,
-0.0017941991,
-0.0713486597,
-0.0070916479,
0.007032244,
0.0436803699,
-0.0162252299,
0.0166715439,
0.0530452393,
-0.0063142171,
-0.0800758302,
-0.0162919499,
0.0259958114,
-0.0249178819,
-0.0377609096,
-0.0273057986,
-0.0324038714,
0.0200216342,
0.0268785208,
0.0224753749,
-0.0298178736,
0.0412534103,
-0.0035768466,
-0.0057357601,
0.1030802354,
0.0040561776,
0.002464467,
0.0084652845,
-0.0115509275,
-0.0120084202,
0.0554609075,
0.0374338143,
0.0230102222,
0.0259113871,
-0.0228451621,
-0.0169653203,
0.021482002,
-0.0427314788,
-0.0192522462,
-0.0006024839,
0.0004178558,
-0.0129566379,
0.0279740021,
-0.0037825278,
0.0662863404,
0.003585699,
0.0143866641,
0.0529204533,
0.0527277067,
-0.0038509544,
-0.0154461339,
-0.0024861987,
0.0201335456,
-0.0356443599,
-0.0150957499,
-0.0551123023,
0.0014903739,
-0.0329933986,
-0.0037771496,
0.0333418027,
0.0419893302,
-0.0090611288,
-0.0380141474,
-0.0514143556,
-0.022268299,
-0.0281606279,
0.0908469707,
0.0505668819,
-0.0362737104,
-0.038822487,
0.0324774347,
-0.0259453226,
-0.0471879058,
0.0116240112,
-0.072752431,
0.0477120019,
0.0618631653,
0.025841862,
-0.0576874353,
-0.0443551466,
-0.0175673198,
-0.0317784399,
0.039579697,
0.0205220189,
0.0145313358,
0.046817299,
-0.0438965224,
0.0008141895,
0.0491068363,
0.0069196555,
0.061342869,
-0.0383504443,
-0.0225787908,
0.0011395797,
-0.0330600366,
-0.0012114954,
0.005617395,
0.0225563068,
-0.0227086097,
0.0472277589,
0.0134638688,
0.0665082633,
0.0082715191,
-0.0265437029,
-0.0106424065,
0.0385000482,
-0.0444222279,
0.0015567604,
-0.000584398,
-0.0484229885,
-0.0093253506,
0.0342998952,
0.0091496697,
-0.0186228231,
0.0448598266,
-0.0180513691,
-0.0744027346,
-0.0181026831,
-0.0485230498,
0.0375807099,
-0.0256299824,
0.0391553193,
0.0443589687,
0.0241115689,
-0.0059547904,
0.0214283746,
0.0387845859,
0.0248906985,
0.0640851036,
-0.0081271958,
0.0091429064,
-0.0412542708,
-0.0463763252,
0.0207721256,
-0.0153676858,
0.0000630992,
0.0070055616,
-0.0194476098,
-0.0079558948,
-0.0304869246,
-0.0886585787,
0.0028840001,
-0.0449964218,
0.005348077,
-0.0160457604,
0.039082583,
0.021960523,
-0.0354722366,
-0.0095792878,
-0.0194563419,
-0.0009968028,
0.0102346018,
-0.0267888959,
0.0126557117,
-0.0514365546,
-0.0149056865,
0.0086913463,
0.0099762194,
0.0067760185,
0.0004896455,
-0.0218696836,
-0.0910575911,
-0.0118627138,
0.008768389,
0.0453330018,
-0.0220696945,
-0.0131511576,
0.0073858406,
-0.0238770768,
0.0100264363,
0.0721143037,
0.0208162423,
-0.0010753312,
0.0389105789,
-0.0089925546,
-0.0484775193,
0.0212086737,
0.0226410702,
-0.0151483286,
-0.025044648,
0.0154583538,
-0.0305294488,
0.0366045311,
0.0205075759,
0.0187854972,
-0.0322605856,
-0.0427511744,
0.0093081156,
-0.0481690317,
-0.058840543,
-0.0356588252,
-0.0385305136,
0.0551736429,
0.0109422896,
-0.0257004686,
0.039941173,
-0.0862521231,
-0.0298816413,
-0.0395982675,
-0.0476918854,
-0.0219643023,
0.0206768159,
0.0128266271,
0.0142031666,
0.019465914,
-0.0388394669,
-0.015129149,
0.02189794,
-0.00433244,
-0.0657841861,
0.0874733254,
-0.0678767487,
0.0412643068,
-0.0376636498,
-0.0571779124,
-0.0441775285,
-0.0404339544,
-0.0642037392,
0.0016722081,
-0.0050611719,
-0.0268169492,
-0.0010156346,
0.0422192737,
0.0158720613,
0.0729874596,
0.0241771918,
0.0113864597,
-0.0469469875,
0.0392954946,
0.0420623384,
0.0488760993,
0.0384127907,
0.0241248887,
0.0532193035,
0.0128066791,
0.060915865,
-0.0075328667,
-0.0277137645,
0.0179435462,
0.081031777,
-0.0135155953,
-0.0316733904,
0.0666592717,
0.0796221048,
-0.0531847626,
-0.0166014303,
0.1189022735,
0.0098644849,
-0.0181170609,
-0.0263356771,
0.0210743267,
0.007340956,
0.0338461436,
-0.0048331139,
-0.0454658344,
-0.0474703014,
0.0585185625,
0.03883994,
-0.0303453803,
0.0184748471,
-0.0280142762,
-0.0818481594,
0.0565661266,
0.0029322712,
-0.0127271023,
-0.0149848098,
-0.0326871946,
0.0042078537,
-0.0120044285,
0.0609252937,
0.0098785236,
-0.0011834856,
-0.0435240045,
0.025588667,
-0.0513353981,
-0.0517604537,
0.0262415297,
0.0221857484,
0.0992948338,
0.0313761681,
-0.0069704973,
-0.0195608828,
-0.0330750495,
0.0222069826,
-0.0489991903,
0.0357834212,
-0.0289791655,
-0.0270090811,
0.0085836248,
-0.015816858,
0.0340319127,
0.0153664062,
-0.0298027564,
-0.0101682274,
-0.0053906594,
0.0520302653,
-0.0475224033,
0.0299285445,
0.0255162884,
-0.0322947726,
0.010282808,
0.0678307563,
-0.001303056,
-0.027786294,
-0.0113606872,
-0.0227329638,
-0.005448353,
-0.0134122968,
0.0067978078,
0.0095752021,
-0.0212378278,
-0.0161252841,
0.0058836215,
-0.0001562295,
0.0135924909,
0.0154578732,
0.0188685711,
0.0457522869,
0.0015988003,
0.0373215824,
-0.0104361866,
0.0078829052,
-0.0037428434,
0.0422262214,
-0.0756019279,
0.0185568687,
0.0428184383,
-0.0722115412,
-0.020368373,
0.0411597826,
-0.0407296829,
-0.0706918538,
0.0111498553,
0.0079136491,
0.0306984652,
0.0199806355,
-0.050940115,
-0.0507864244,
0.0241376162,
0.0470753349,
-0.0082772505,
0.0218544491,
0.0520508066,
0.0166176334,
-0.0310007203,
0.0436525345,
-0.0635148957,
0.0187651012,
0.00129781,
0.0131655056,
-0.0357213728,
-0.0881109089,
0.0010411589,
0.0478534028,
0.0772597864,
-0.0548927188,
-0.0241519008,
-0.016493775,
0.0588946342,
0.0302318856,
0.0163400955,
-0.0183972679,
-0.0198463816,
0.0139642851,
-0.0216718502,
-0.0187178534,
0.0228342731,
0.0002595725,
0.0024013231,
-0.0391809903,
0.0677559674,
0.0189900547,
-0.034840133,
0.0389048867,
-0.0134824561,
-0.0426077917,
0.055883076,
0.042910438,
0.0369403437,
-0.0069812909,
0.0449275784,
-0.0110616665,
-0.0234339572,
-0.0141136795,
0.0406719483,
-0.0871048495,
-0.1029785275,
0.0071250661,
0.0751019642,
0.0303004887,
-0.0091975266,
0.0156579893,
-0.0032777225,
0.0052649388,
-0.0579375215,
0.0452286936,
0.0066207396,
-0.0126822395,
0.06328585,
0.0286245532,
-0.0095244944,
0.0094731832,
0.0253600217,
-0.0162952337,
0.0428972468,
0.016411595,
0.0060175546,
-0.0753835738,
-0.0433456227,
-0.0146864168,
0.0043798964,
-0.0261432454,
-0.0023676932,
-0.0238353666,
-0.0716656893,
0.045206707,
-0.0223011766,
0.0326350033,
-0.0651311204,
-0.0264863726,
0.0332254991,
-0.0132629359,
0.0190027133,
-0.0158210173,
-0.0251314733,
-0.0347991325,
-0.0095463069,
0.0154836578,
-6.414587449e-33,
-0.0277185645,
0.0195037629,
0.0006732227,
-0.0328314491,
0.0103042489,
0.0536681786,
-0.0087440852,
0.0091742929,
-0.0204488095,
-0.0556808598,
-0.0516892858,
-0.0016974,
0.0389101617,
0.0162144322,
-0.0054031746,
-0.0219443925,
0.0893231854,
0.00029612,
-0.0059793699,
-0.0325673111,
0.0372783616,
0.0187912844,
0.0128882816,
-0.0179601554,
-0.0175868217,
0.0239834916,
-0.0092165405,
0.0034323526,
-0.022896193,
0.0396150164,
-0.0070030419,
0.046123594,
0.0162237063,
-0.0458991826,
-0.0096120769,
0.0455104336,
-0.0857605934,
0.0059154429,
0.0308100786,
0.0401434861,
0.0156658702,
-0.0031936327,
0.0325863473,
0.0109301833,
-0.0183075201,
0.0080821654,
-0.0144116739,
-0.016751023,
-0.0406474732,
-0.0095915841,
0.0211592466,
0.0335767865,
-0.0001764622,
-0.0374999866,
0.0772051215,
0.0251179338,
-0.0093175611,
-0.0089255404,
-0.0562035628,
-0.0001301296,
0.0005823536,
0.0542440265,
0.0457571447,
0.0447543412,
-0.0420823246,
0.0279965382,
0.0071559004,
-0.0652813762,
0.0168118365,
-0.0346976668,
-0.0098012621,
0.0431333259,
-0.0115634128,
0.0467424653,
0.0298173651,
-0.0250255149,
-0.0293442551,
-0.0182642974,
0.0544428751,
0.0017549052,
0.0579274856,
0.05196153,
-0.0566571467,
-0.00685838,
-0.0570997857,
-0.0097942529,
-0.0586191788,
0.0240805373,
0.0588213503,
0.0517822392,
-0.0295366049,
0.0013568691,
0.0525638461,
-0.0102159102,
0.0043575284,
0.0180449262,
0.0509847589,
-0.0044670864,
0.0128989154,
0.0568296425,
-0.0464329384,
-0.0179274324,
0.0145228133,
0.010860906,
-0.0105989072,
-0.0381878279,
-0.0185031425,
0.0711746812,
-0.071378015,
-0.0033721121,
-0.0295899082,
0.0254686177,
-0.0351371318,
0.0224650018,
0.0560608767,
-0.0286922902,
-0.0116614839,
0.047199402,
-0.0579694323,
-0.0117470408,
-0.0158468951,
0.0085358657,
-0.0200024638,
0.0047276495,
-0.0558227375,
-0.0059211436,
0.0219150484,
-0.0101553211,
0.0198268835,
-0.0190351401,
-0.0000926336,
0.0105123511,
2.859e-7,
-0.0233559962,
0.0118154604,
-0.0048528751,
0.0063254051,
0.0201373491,
0.0432037674,
-0.002753054,
0.0015711765,
-0.0072463048,
-0.0204168484,
0.0086671785,
0.0108824773,
0.0485737026,
0.0114867948,
-0.0679014102,
-0.0135415811,
-0.001935316,
0.0538343526,
-0.0140206916,
0.0009750355,
0.0621953756,
0.1224976927,
-0.031518545,
-0.035434939,
0.0047632148,
-0.043395251,
0.0077253319,
-0.042383384,
0.0265681949,
-0.0153812151,
0.01656661,
-0.0049708434,
-0.0085244635,
0.0521348529,
0.0138063878,
0.0214980114,
-0.0232691225,
0.0629595071,
-0.0124200331,
-0.0365161002,
-0.0222956985,
0.0288673863,
-0.0015505602,
-0.0516942851,
0.0752712563,
0.024037268,
-0.0137046436,
-0.0717037544,
-0.0058049597,
-0.0279996525,
-0.026326742,
0.0096797319,
0.0236928649,
0.0070825848,
-0.0062250672,
-0.0401052386,
-0.0317652375,
-0.0907393768,
-0.005483273,
-0.0091942484,
-0.0600208044,
-0.0269957799,
-0.0636867806,
-0.0001306343,
0.044099845,
-0.0759425312,
-0.0286116581,
2.319424842e-34,
0.0382260866,
-0.024653675,
-0.0198337361,
0.05947854,
0.026648527,
-0.0204108842,
-0.0181962214,
0.0245667566,
0.0327404179,
-0.0889577866,
-0.0262827128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04827v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04827v1 | Neurons in Large Language Models: Dead, N-gram, Positional | 2023-09-09T15:51:36 | 2023-09-09T15:51:36 | Elena Voita, Javier Ferrando, Christoforos Nalmpantis | cs.CL | cs.CL | We analyze a family of large language models in such a lightweight manner
that can be done on a single GPU. Specifically, we focus on the OPT family of
models ranging from 125m to 66b parameters and rely only on whether an FFN
neuron is activated or not. First, we find that the early part of the network
is sparse and represents many discrete features. Here, many neurons (more than
70% in some layers of the 66b model) are "dead", i.e. they never activate on a
large collection of diverse data. At the same time, many of the alive neurons
are reserved for discrete features and act as token and n-gram detectors.
Interestingly, their corresponding FFN updates not only promote next token
candidates as could be expected, but also explicitly focus on removing the
information about triggering them tokens, i.e., current input. To the best of
our knowledge, this is the first example of mechanisms specialized at removing
(rather than adding) information from the residual stream. With scale, models
become more sparse in a sense that they have more dead neurons and token
detectors. Finally, some neurons are positional: them being activated or not
depends largely (or solely) on position and less so (or not at all) on textual
data. We find that smaller models have sets of neurons acting as position range
indicators while larger models operate in a less explicit manner. | [
0.0167886764,
0.0552422367,
-0.007140473,
0.0606016815,
-0.0314247645,
0.0136285909,
0.0278331824,
-0.001822375,
-0.0309680421,
-0.0227554552,
-0.0093923286,
-0.0427183881,
0.0346693881,
0.0481126606,
0.0367733687,
0.011963414,
0.052734457,
-0.0210216343,
-0.0165303107,
-0.0293230023,
0.0085252533,
0.0175850093,
-0.0031233036,
0.0357036926,
-0.0261344295,
0.0015456915,
-0.0365831889,
-0.0191271584,
-0.037844196,
0.0282915086,
-0.013371204,
0.0088679828,
0.0106676016,
0.0953849107,
0.0000020296,
-0.0149528068,
0.0456782468,
-0.0212926157,
-0.0435141735,
0.0532606542,
0.0135389436,
-0.0061700838,
-0.0432627238,
-0.0115924934,
-0.0100789741,
-0.0555513501,
0.0396536775,
0.0231982898,
0.004238226,
0.06767793,
-0.0053812615,
-0.0357379355,
0.0732328445,
-0.0270613059,
0.0016714196,
0.0021959546,
0.0381977893,
-0.0683638304,
0.000300289,
-0.0171603542,
-0.0393020622,
0.0588880591,
0.0504693091,
-0.0087604309,
-0.0047970652,
0.0668253303,
-0.0047163023,
-0.0419832505,
0.0302909333,
-0.0257286392,
-0.0710910186,
-0.0273019075,
0.0328010172,
-0.0197099652,
-0.0021619734,
-0.0459251702,
-0.0370082781,
0.0166207757,
0.032376118,
0.0279479865,
0.0144879101,
-0.0589583069,
0.0659260228,
0.010775635,
-0.028080957,
0.0382290296,
0.0293979496,
0.0060618515,
-0.036215771,
0.0219248366,
-0.0604136623,
-0.0492339171,
0.0243587662,
0.0080215801,
-0.0245489813,
0.0150264669,
-0.0410962626,
-0.0373508371,
-0.0008350011,
-0.0665671825,
0.0469655395,
0.0374514088,
-0.0152962077,
0.0251878817,
-0.0492153428,
-0.0158721246,
-0.0111250728,
-0.0111917472,
-0.0119348085,
0.0163765941,
0.0054920949,
-0.0564648695,
-0.0181724373,
0.059279874,
-0.004938202,
-0.0408298261,
-0.014765949,
0.010367088,
-0.0200076103,
-0.0150381494,
-0.0255443584,
0.0354975574,
-0.0288423765,
0.0051771682,
0.0106610525,
0.045105353,
-0.0243270993,
0.0348146595,
0.0102087343,
-0.0584990643,
-0.0136881294,
0.012260342,
0.0238922723,
-0.0238540005,
0.0265851207,
0.0324295089,
0.0047084023,
-0.0182584226,
-0.0391617864,
0.0217346381,
-0.0284392107,
-0.0269663371,
-0.0257877372,
-0.0559651516,
-0.0079978621,
0.0213721264,
0.0010807734,
-0.023816064,
0.0197623707,
0.0392457806,
-0.0368902646,
0.0393520519,
-0.0268266462,
0.0179269072,
0.0249039289,
-0.0379308239,
0.0427115858,
0.0775476173,
0.0292175468,
0.0476903431,
0.0434534512,
0.0076367278,
-0.0164215155,
0.039102748,
0.0246518869,
0.0204414409,
-0.0530271493,
-0.0710881054,
-0.0106334565,
0.0392879434,
0.0519389734,
0.0464148633,
-0.0334077179,
-0.054911036,
0.059634164,
0.0761703998,
-0.0225005671,
0.0462341458,
0.0462907739,
-0.015738653,
-0.0057693832,
0.0325035192,
-0.0391586013,
0.0076159444,
0.0004246313,
0.0153369326,
0.0189904366,
0.0204348788,
-0.0156044811,
-0.0259867944,
0.002004558,
0.0044979695,
0.0029278956,
-0.0209251698,
0.0561119579,
0.0115390699,
-0.0197732262,
0.0295238253,
0.0158628039,
-0.0082608759,
-0.0015341303,
-0.0605753623,
0.0197788421,
0.030056702,
0.0311132111,
-0.0393431522,
-0.0404153354,
0.0328072682,
-0.0076440717,
0.0371637419,
0.0042789811,
0.0236062519,
0.0474155061,
-0.0429109223,
0.0261764731,
0.0102998149,
0.0399872176,
0.0249673259,
-0.0036930437,
-0.0158318393,
-0.0159513243,
0.0056191669,
-0.0398851372,
0.0310713723,
-0.0125542851,
0.0093523422,
0.0265045669,
-0.0057390695,
-0.0140921548,
0.0059825266,
0.0009427161,
0.0229402166,
0.0461352207,
-0.0430690795,
0.033050511,
-0.0178200826,
-0.0658922493,
0.0107705835,
0.0561521761,
0.0603244863,
0.0044249608,
0.0548159629,
-0.0194870271,
-0.0294344965,
0.0278457813,
-0.0556398146,
0.0510460213,
-0.0304537378,
-0.0146848429,
0.0038361612,
0.0293787085,
0.0144524314,
0.0499526933,
-0.0011393816,
0.0275741257,
-0.0047831861,
-0.0098839002,
0.0289067086,
-0.0639515892,
-0.0407204367,
0.0042616255,
-0.0244979132,
0.0016157021,
0.003973742,
-0.0378132574,
0.0054008951,
0.0100088594,
-0.1182931513,
-0.0060627526,
-0.0150742261,
0.0026664077,
0.0281094089,
0.0204498898,
0.0184335448,
-0.0128589896,
-0.0101984832,
0.0718810633,
0.0176984333,
0.0324125215,
0.0415696241,
0.0077291364,
-0.0180295389,
-0.0481932051,
-0.0622789748,
0.0013714246,
0.0739728361,
-0.0153896976,
-0.0744910613,
-0.0356417075,
0.0331695639,
0.0077913324,
0.0581012517,
0.0135504603,
-0.0499603637,
-0.0007862551,
-0.0428041741,
-0.0299702194,
0.0634663627,
-0.0155560439,
0.0525780953,
0.0099488171,
-0.0095071299,
-0.0174967013,
-0.0048651835,
-0.0532344468,
0.0374679975,
-0.0682761818,
0.0300287381,
-0.0258996356,
0.0955356956,
0.0117597952,
-0.0339527838,
-0.0218927525,
0.0044942629,
-0.0411464497,
-0.0387075394,
-0.0475218818,
-0.0130675249,
-0.0352351628,
0.0175870489,
-0.0231542327,
-0.0514238104,
0.0233126562,
-0.013837086,
-0.0022925651,
-0.0017963519,
-0.0213098992,
-0.0283119511,
0.054255642,
0.0542692579,
0.0198041406,
-0.0097002191,
-0.0264378134,
-0.0528006889,
0.0134629738,
-0.045727782,
-0.0060961298,
0.0233949218,
-0.0251046307,
0.0100047793,
-0.0153018665,
-0.0349642374,
-0.008493728,
-0.0339276828,
-0.0187953729,
0.0385212861,
0.0128902011,
-0.0415997691,
-0.0201254822,
-0.0042112241,
-0.0224530231,
0.0872688666,
-0.0167447794,
0.0054263468,
-0.0382250212,
0.0449087173,
0.0349337645,
0.0452215038,
0.0192726385,
-0.0357030183,
-0.0193338953,
0.0584606342,
-0.0091943741,
0.0312987939,
-0.0790295899,
0.0043981913,
0.0338522904,
-0.0061123534,
-0.0137924189,
-0.0266098715,
0.0404056832,
-0.0648579821,
-0.0301660504,
0.0799294561,
0.0068105939,
-0.0639117509,
-0.000963832,
0.0379876718,
0.0528514609,
0.0078734364,
0.0166438892,
-0.0425107814,
-0.0013308777,
0.0355448052,
-0.0098906523,
0.0129164793,
0.0165985245,
0.0177115984,
-0.0979930162,
0.0329629108,
-0.0064185802,
-0.0099209808,
0.0013646148,
0.018709572,
0.0030867683,
-0.0052656336,
0.0003387756,
0.0051279282,
0.0150156301,
-0.0035282539,
0.026882099,
0.0241299383,
-0.0144704571,
-0.003051738,
-0.0273614768,
0.0500028059,
0.0462657474,
0.0347813927,
-0.0291613378,
-0.0364648104,
0.0708929673,
-0.0161497481,
0.0183634367,
0.0103449365,
0.0422557481,
0.021123914,
-0.011132977,
-0.020404987,
0.0241949596,
-0.041394528,
-0.0268504303,
-0.0626133457,
0.0226823259,
-0.0171882752,
-0.0258078054,
-0.0155885173,
-0.0069149337,
-0.0296221357,
0.0335253812,
0.0358726159,
-0.0792687982,
-0.0443044864,
-0.0461241491,
0.00665067,
-0.0211619716,
-0.0428071432,
-0.0432947315,
0.027086053,
-0.0615715757,
-0.034882091,
0.0108357575,
0.0299387872,
0.0499770194,
0.0192850418,
-0.0061815297,
-0.0064399261,
-0.0420310646,
-0.0357403383,
0.0264577977,
0.0022146909,
0.0406656526,
-0.0645225942,
-0.0014656708,
0.0369422808,
-0.0334882401,
-0.0429318286,
-0.0205642395,
-0.1117878035,
-0.0465678535,
0.0514170788,
-0.0217409953,
0.0291533936,
0.0074276496,
-0.0482026823,
-0.0784103721,
0.0445001237,
0.0815041512,
-0.0455125794,
0.0790385082,
0.0003082885,
-0.0656922907,
-0.0190961342,
0.0383026674,
0.0130876312,
-0.0079924548,
0.0457927547,
0.0276359208,
-0.0088574523,
0.0254699253,
0.0186445527,
-0.0253006388,
0.0822665989,
0.0194777343,
0.0172135998,
-0.0514286794,
0.009330119,
0.04589504,
0.0153391315,
-0.0463092402,
-0.02555543,
0.0585165024,
0.0445859395,
-0.0174766853,
-0.0100677684,
0.0973073095,
0.0095544299,
-0.0005700567,
-0.0466788448,
0.0270120688,
-0.0445606112,
0.0207490474,
0.0125229033,
-0.0260016788,
0.0512149408,
-0.0287915394,
0.0225817151,
-0.0461001731,
0.0254929811,
0.0325497501,
-0.0274129249,
-0.0670399144,
0.0313582532,
-0.0763844699,
-0.0542373769,
-0.0357063599,
0.0255342312,
0.0591449812,
-0.0260460619,
0.0149459653,
-0.0269025657,
-0.0383089297,
-0.0279389061,
-0.017545037,
0.0195600223,
0.0043720505,
0.0034475352,
0.0399316847,
-0.0128258318,
0.003012863,
0.0334833898,
0.0343142152,
0.0400799923,
0.0126161622,
0.0058762114,
0.0194751136,
-0.0137441661,
-0.0023996576,
0.0250129029,
-0.0343081951,
0.0100187343,
-0.0288046636,
-0.0758246109,
-0.0108421193,
0.0153840603,
-0.0025890274,
-0.0417328402,
0.0189892538,
0.039071314,
0.0288042128,
0.01984578,
-0.0244849697,
0.0500969924,
0.0250358842,
-0.0494516119,
-0.0326473713,
-6.398618358e-33,
-0.0130217541,
-0.0040930565,
-0.0001668036,
-0.0114097884,
-0.0112810945,
0.0240468439,
-0.0313314125,
0.006536325,
-0.0112404656,
0.033311829,
-0.029617846,
0.0158740617,
0.0124338297,
0.0260683801,
0.0016299841,
-0.0208826642,
0.0468306057,
-0.0327975564,
0.0170264393,
0.0150049711,
0.0486568473,
0.0310094357,
0.0417663381,
-0.0115444027,
-0.0144466739,
0.0049865176,
0.0037302789,
0.0153235225,
-0.0656251088,
0.032220684,
-0.0740355477,
0.0317946151,
0.0135466075,
-0.0253552161,
-0.0262042005,
0.0028791784,
-0.0811853707,
-0.0253899414,
0.0333174877,
0.0371016823,
-0.0348833203,
-0.0271065757,
0.0796525255,
0.0145229604,
-0.029923575,
0.024084812,
0.012865223,
-0.0164256375,
-0.0528412238,
-0.0247103777,
-0.0514115356,
0.028598018,
0.0154294251,
0.0030093142,
0.0394304246,
-0.0570649356,
-0.0138071598,
-0.0171398073,
-0.0541134626,
-0.0136805847,
0.0002922553,
0.1083153412,
0.0090910969,
0.0301962551,
0.0210949611,
0.0729930624,
0.083185263,
0.013452284,
-0.0410513282,
0.0372646153,
0.0556297712,
0.0098430607,
0.0387052149,
-0.0210701432,
0.0717598125,
-0.0614222065,
-0.0249627829,
-0.0536566302,
-0.0065775835,
0.0467049032,
0.0700282976,
0.0334199257,
0.0117159709,
-0.043295119,
-0.0114710117,
-0.0618168116,
-0.0461114869,
-0.0022915774,
0.0162710901,
0.020380795,
-0.0234103743,
0.0062737484,
0.003119709,
-0.038951043,
-0.0174974762,
0.0158765558,
0.0110284314,
0.0389540456,
0.0236176252,
-0.005382373,
-0.0145248221,
-0.0055247517,
-0.0292202383,
0.0113369497,
0.0141356783,
0.0122237355,
0.0150328418,
0.0729938075,
-0.0450448878,
-0.0144120622,
-0.0409776904,
-0.0195749328,
0.02542888,
0.0930328444,
0.0420461595,
0.0047599021,
0.0049066306,
0.023655273,
-0.0076918807,
0.0204607435,
-0.0369491354,
0.029857222,
-0.0021374275,
0.0244642328,
-0.0508514531,
-0.0218245797,
-0.0633060634,
0.0525939912,
0.0359472483,
-0.0750229135,
-0.0199407749,
0.0426054485,
2.858e-7,
0.0201654863,
0.0110857747,
0.0251960531,
-0.0395568311,
0.0706631243,
0.0283148587,
-0.024736248,
0.0109255593,
0.0126061719,
0.0017197024,
-0.0042170142,
-0.0189210437,
0.0262264628,
0.0139099779,
-0.1081889644,
0.0222732704,
-0.0500009172,
0.0321660675,
-0.0499719381,
-0.0027791774,
-0.0604404137,
0.1386838555,
0.0144446697,
-0.0260026269,
0.0478835627,
-0.0484424457,
0.0093931528,
-0.0109177036,
0.0027611672,
-0.0231497716,
0.0309882592,
-0.0124441134,
-0.0062777712,
-0.0305269305,
0.0158908833,
0.0267295539,
0.0146825472,
0.0652524754,
-0.0125751477,
0.012711836,
-0.0046538641,
-0.0235002786,
-0.001648233,
-0.0568450429,
0.0449998528,
-0.0085465591,
-0.0402088426,
-0.0644330308,
0.0412342437,
-0.0105517153,
-0.0218215305,
-0.021516297,
0.0023547988,
-0.00753575,
0.0112565337,
-0.0406280868,
-0.0376139246,
-0.0702564418,
-0.0255142022,
-0.0082857814,
-0.0602008961,
-0.0518611036,
-0.0775179043,
0.0295452271,
0.0513305999,
-0.0294093508,
-0.0343526192,
2.735137041e-34,
0.0423556343,
-0.0008294785,
-0.0086628133,
0.0325094871,
0.0087664258,
-0.0177481789,
0.0405490696,
0.0106981918,
-0.0120408712,
-0.0707393363,
-0.0373416655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04823v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04823v2 | FaNS: a Facet-based Narrative Similarity Metric | 2023-09-09T15:29:24 | 2024-03-02T14:46:27 | Mousumi Akter, Shubhra Kanti Karmaker Santu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Similar Narrative Retrieval is a crucial task since narratives are essential
for explaining and understanding events, and multiple related narratives often
help to create a holistic view of the event of interest. To accurately identify
semantically similar narratives, this paper proposes a novel narrative
similarity metric called Facet-based Narrative Similarity (FaNS), based on the
classic 5W1H facets (Who, What, When, Where, Why, and How), which are extracted
by leveraging the state-of-the-art Large Language Models (LLMs). Unlike
existing similarity metrics that only focus on overall lexical/semantic match,
FaNS provides a more granular matching along six different facets independently
and then combines them. To evaluate FaNS, we created a comprehensive dataset by
collecting narratives from AllSides, a third-party news portal. Experimental
results demonstrate that the FaNS metric exhibits a higher correlation (37\%
higher) than traditional text similarity metrics that directly measure the
lexical/semantic match between narratives, demonstrating its effectiveness in
comparing the finer details between a pair of narratives. | [
0.0314523429,
0.0094908476,
-0.0369744003,
0.0243123434,
-0.0699778423,
0.0065040733,
0.004223248,
0.0074020913,
0.0262181833,
-0.0213349238,
0.0114030968,
-0.048476655,
0.0017910779,
0.0433074087,
-0.0354937613,
-0.021230353,
0.004346129,
0.0315351263,
0.0134513946,
0.0189959425,
0.0443636402,
0.0778567716,
0.0415047407,
0.0279782824,
0.0099012069,
-0.0061303875,
0.0268087015,
0.0131103313,
0.0338029787,
-0.0373467505,
0.0151360314,
-0.0145075107,
0.0533660725,
0.0443104431,
0.0000018753,
-0.0450869612,
-0.0271962583,
-0.0117649585,
0.0235554222,
0.017248271,
0.0669308677,
0.0033900817,
0.0453435965,
0.006122475,
0.0042076013,
-0.0574263111,
0.0028606676,
0.0850249082,
0.0364472978,
0.0560182668,
-0.0302649233,
-0.0432158299,
-0.0095448233,
0.0106774746,
0.0157595538,
-0.0229305979,
0.004071177,
0.0140130008,
-0.0097734798,
-0.0180497523,
0.0177435186,
0.0163724478,
-0.0207573976,
0.0183872581,
-0.0448812731,
0.0539616048,
-0.0216300841,
0.0277285706,
0.0149678569,
0.0449981242,
0.0110400794,
-0.0763591751,
0.0307197608,
-0.0060080234,
-0.0355632007,
0.0512208082,
-0.0872141793,
0.028440712,
-0.0333168469,
0.0218359567,
0.0288236625,
0.0224112105,
0.0151098724,
0.011299286,
0.0390288383,
0.0196955614,
0.0461757444,
-0.0039704451,
-0.070179686,
-0.0244020242,
0.008522938,
-0.0375081114,
0.008686332,
0.0166818593,
0.0015160918,
-0.0108533511,
-0.026564924,
0.0421414115,
0.0160500277,
-0.1061737537,
0.01895128,
0.0188424028,
-0.0181278437,
0.0780804083,
-0.0280475076,
0.0105080325,
0.0110422764,
-0.0277480334,
-0.0415537618,
-0.0058658011,
-0.0512033999,
0.0197750293,
-0.0033744106,
0.0279426426,
-0.0190200061,
-0.0324163102,
0.0278478973,
-0.0011374392,
0.0197870992,
-0.0114885988,
0.0066364901,
-0.0046368507,
0.0042272252,
-0.0414373986,
-0.022445688,
0.0373680294,
-0.0668734312,
0.0200662054,
-0.0376253054,
-0.0069424775,
-0.0096905064,
0.0108207623,
0.0314222872,
-0.0139105301,
-0.0038163145,
0.0100789126,
0.0081340866,
-0.0142984111,
-0.0843865946,
-0.0518632978,
0.0033066592,
-0.0348611958,
-0.0334263444,
-0.0678870827,
0.0492733493,
-0.0002498109,
0.0081240712,
-0.0125050228,
-0.0034330478,
0.0275912043,
-0.0306535531,
0.0174118374,
0.0140100606,
0.0218805429,
0.0454297997,
0.0169912931,
0.0451727882,
0.0090188123,
0.0182560086,
0.0524074323,
0.0921930745,
0.0258757062,
-0.0015442003,
-0.0010337766,
-0.0321832187,
0.0407094695,
0.0003710187,
0.0218934938,
0.0086191008,
0.0517422259,
0.0219595674,
0.026638642,
-0.0691868067,
-0.0296863522,
0.0910644084,
0.0763527155,
0.0258036871,
-0.0118379174,
0.0632657856,
0.037204396,
-0.0125005031,
0.0040630931,
0.0248835236,
0.0025249524,
-0.0073868055,
-0.0099101542,
0.0499984026,
0.0370739475,
-0.0365453102,
0.0347225368,
-0.0072782892,
-0.0080780592,
-0.0241215322,
-0.0080214618,
-0.0051161079,
-0.0252562538,
-0.030906029,
0.001049931,
0.0586213917,
-0.0824312046,
0.0308965854,
-0.0098503856,
0.0612073988,
0.0625548512,
0.0661831349,
-0.0069594211,
-0.0282712094,
-0.017177172,
0.0068603978,
-0.0250681993,
0.0540489927,
-0.0113863898,
-0.0168801378,
-0.0300294831,
-0.0017507676,
-0.0035162817,
-0.0002928039,
0.0084927715,
0.0085886596,
0.0189063661,
0.015230176,
-0.0309394486,
-0.0341788381,
0.0291844625,
-0.0407054797,
0.011883961,
-0.0119402595,
0.0012125946,
-0.00141157,
0.0278700124,
-0.0000556169,
-0.0034548535,
0.0187782217,
-0.0410904624,
-0.0667442679,
0.0368671827,
-0.0347714312,
-0.0418921895,
0.0232545473,
-0.0295195952,
0.0337753482,
-0.0120173208,
0.0140257087,
-0.0273589492,
0.0265751686,
-0.0054124598,
0.016307136,
-0.0474487133,
0.0401842743,
-0.0327329971,
-0.02710885,
-0.0519284084,
0.096376203,
0.0304490179,
0.0500349626,
-0.0634100512,
-0.0420313664,
0.0201261993,
0.0049048117,
-0.0226372983,
0.035282094,
0.0240083467,
0.014398111,
0.0583778247,
-0.0625020415,
-0.0299154799,
-0.0514844842,
-0.1008802801,
0.0621125065,
-0.0051427134,
0.0019076422,
0.0471143425,
0.02386887,
-0.0354444943,
0.0279758908,
-0.0477408767,
-0.0240865834,
0.0049967105,
0.0122817336,
-0.013429109,
0.0171529446,
-0.0001518705,
-0.0575058609,
-0.0059899553,
-0.0294068772,
0.0793835074,
0.0007938062,
0.0166648701,
-0.0416376404,
0.0028522913,
-0.0336671993,
-0.0074300226,
-0.0375588201,
0.0314178504,
-0.0078771571,
-0.0422520861,
0.0191883501,
0.0346140862,
0.0232282057,
-0.0078996718,
0.0126566952,
-0.0346561968,
-0.0440641716,
-0.0110953823,
-0.0568458065,
-0.0057362653,
-0.0320824236,
-0.0394873843,
0.0142650977,
-0.0143666435,
0.0333823822,
0.0070214244,
-0.0627945289,
0.0166716073,
0.0011794022,
0.0444478579,
0.0104978466,
-0.0373254083,
-0.0019690658,
0.0208170898,
-0.0192246288,
-0.010724159,
0.0534611642,
-0.0677228495,
0.061176572,
-0.001585473,
-0.0346259475,
-0.0842925757,
0.0904884115,
-0.0104018226,
0.0296683554,
-0.0078589572,
-0.0177245047,
0.0282983594,
0.0076361187,
0.0618006736,
-0.0409488045,
0.0330304839,
-0.0065944828,
0.0055466401,
0.0323548913,
-0.0195784084,
-0.0054558804,
-0.0630134344,
-0.0146631887,
-0.0223132931,
-0.0093118893,
-0.026074985,
-0.0478479266,
0.0254401509,
0.0235779416,
0.0229568072,
-0.0223597959,
-0.010649005,
-0.0003106134,
0.0472936369,
0.0485031083,
-0.0163205881,
-0.0207856968,
-0.0179930069,
0.033302553,
0.0080778133,
0.0253813323,
0.0084523233,
0.0126224542,
-0.0170942638,
0.0278180782,
-0.0553160049,
-0.0239656288,
-0.0214324668,
0.0294556171,
-0.0477765389,
0.0126631819,
0.1261909902,
0.0275723077,
-0.0572065115,
-0.0068227747,
-0.0144747449,
0.0110539617,
0.0380710699,
-0.0085246768,
-0.0214171223,
-0.0003458425,
0.0161422584,
0.0201284084,
0.0163166448,
-0.0528675951,
-0.0203924533,
-0.0617452636,
0.0225775782,
0.009550414,
0.0104498668,
-0.036616575,
-0.0564561002,
0.0209606625,
-0.0169165451,
-0.0200305805,
0.0200239439,
-0.0442265086,
-0.0038046411,
-0.0517609343,
-0.0048206737,
0.0015194411,
0.0576763675,
-0.0760308206,
0.023423072,
0.0160188377,
0.037569914,
0.014531387,
0.0109196482,
-0.0602194071,
-0.0008501554,
-0.0300314762,
0.0190492477,
0.0748888552,
-0.0538576916,
0.0149886683,
-0.0375976339,
0.0560718253,
0.0226310883,
-0.031359192,
0.0157888923,
0.0315487757,
0.001415359,
-0.0467565805,
-0.0186658893,
-0.0005836831,
-0.0182690322,
0.0949843973,
0.0436083004,
-0.0001195924,
0.002255694,
0.0231116191,
0.0318025351,
-0.010475372,
-0.0929359198,
-0.0032387767,
-0.0056362743,
-0.02439983,
-0.0453740247,
-0.0423494764,
-0.0104110343,
0.0186344888,
0.0050502443,
0.0400441438,
0.0254569929,
-0.0452433303,
-0.0610620975,
0.0215688013,
-0.0431565046,
0.0397148244,
0.0199521836,
0.0526428372,
0.0664796233,
-0.0375234671,
-0.0081456034,
-0.0184871908,
-0.0621016361,
-0.0238401443,
-0.0317577198,
-0.0755659118,
0.0056909309,
0.0377148874,
0.0015632686,
-0.0478175096,
-0.0001213832,
0.0098586082,
-0.02894249,
-0.0013957329,
-0.0587094873,
0.0140205259,
-0.0074058967,
0.0189607907,
-0.0320754573,
0.0031900974,
-0.020638993,
0.0490139946,
0.0034725666,
-0.018352259,
0.0387865044,
0.0110938214,
0.0267510861,
-0.0101327291,
-0.0181344114,
-0.0790452212,
-0.0520255417,
-0.0241819546,
0.0052408106,
-0.0113328146,
0.0092393868,
0.0198243074,
0.0041071093,
-0.0443558544,
0.0101387231,
-0.0300577059,
0.0393930972,
-0.0800108686,
-0.007975325,
-0.0039073667,
-0.0000420917,
-0.0461897217,
-0.0074094841,
-0.0357785672,
0.0014983676,
-0.0113972072,
0.0210022535,
-0.0521648377,
0.0108449934,
0.016756244,
0.0140974522,
0.0014856966,
0.034723945,
-0.0513550006,
-0.0573770665,
-0.0305473655,
-0.0075205029,
0.0614954866,
-0.0619805343,
0.0525874384,
-0.006196917,
-0.0075364262,
-0.0217234902,
-0.0291683935,
-0.0006575405,
-0.0048542456,
-0.0241621621,
0.0382584035,
-0.0358831473,
0.0648676232,
0.0657408237,
-0.0044589927,
0.0600215346,
0.029553771,
-0.0709947869,
0.0063270647,
-0.0496442951,
0.0283385683,
0.0695428103,
-0.0148544526,
-0.0375658683,
-0.0693479404,
0.0088303825,
0.0345459357,
-0.0150913605,
-0.0199040435,
0.0069309855,
-0.0050242278,
0.0709639788,
0.0031186321,
-0.0039649536,
-0.0515170135,
0.00116588,
-0.0248119812,
-0.0065804129,
-0.0232996196,
-6.104143799e-33,
-0.0074489401,
0.0112049822,
0.0002651895,
0.0320438594,
-0.1121136621,
0.0277791079,
-0.0103305792,
-0.0195932183,
-0.0084035266,
0.0306939818,
0.0417111591,
0.0106535498,
-0.0018811997,
-0.016136026,
-0.0025759381,
-0.0084744962,
0.0228246599,
0.0275199655,
-0.0471892022,
0.0597291328,
0.0395092145,
0.0040942463,
0.0230935328,
-0.0813095048,
0.0069855941,
-0.0172626767,
0.0135343214,
-0.002297404,
0.0639983267,
0.0338727646,
0.0038365091,
0.0450014025,
0.0483737364,
-0.0082602547,
-0.012629888,
0.0012247483,
-0.0241330788,
-0.0211445633,
0.0650674999,
-0.0489980243,
0.0402109362,
-0.0302905664,
0.0310157631,
0.0062090987,
-0.0100252256,
-0.0332667492,
0.0579237826,
-0.0102640223,
-0.0151583953,
-0.0212909635,
-0.0379720703,
0.0384121314,
-0.0245322846,
-0.0079030013,
-0.0163854416,
0.0165088307,
0.0296544731,
0.0821942911,
-0.0453173071,
0.0476057641,
-0.057552062,
0.0573860295,
-0.0138865849,
-0.0315374173,
0.0021199647,
0.1068524569,
0.029196348,
-0.0160688721,
-0.0812815279,
0.0385312177,
0.0121756904,
0.0139080063,
0.0214273464,
0.0787134022,
-0.0320603698,
-0.0263067037,
-0.0518329293,
0.0689906105,
-0.0085550053,
0.0114624063,
0.048175402,
0.0162770525,
-0.0316833258,
-0.0128522264,
-0.0504134595,
0.001880639,
-0.0411554016,
0.0073058866,
0.0192664135,
-0.0131247882,
0.0092514157,
0.0091785518,
0.0315876938,
-0.0284790415,
0.0265621096,
0.0448399521,
-0.0470302366,
0.0103324838,
-0.0086620655,
0.0570022836,
-0.0258766059,
-0.0076328102,
0.0010786898,
-0.0039911503,
0.0147614973,
-0.0314482078,
0.0215009078,
0.005173062,
-0.0580598563,
0.0089523606,
0.0076712109,
-0.0800279975,
-0.0562073328,
-0.0404780395,
0.0122533925,
0.0311512984,
0.0203076843,
-0.0009862239,
0.0432594754,
-0.0197060071,
-0.0199749954,
-0.0986345559,
-0.0078208968,
-0.011559654,
0.0284884349,
0.0239512511,
-0.0223587677,
-0.0140248258,
0.0319226831,
-0.0135401189,
-0.0230125301,
0.0080237705,
2.609e-7,
0.0025602542,
0.026958609,
0.010807097,
0.0023017609,
-0.0138529632,
0.0563934706,
0.0093108686,
0.0424774513,
-0.0016745421,
-0.013198019,
0.0236649886,
0.0461593606,
0.0266278889,
0.0382914022,
-0.0396984108,
0.0452565588,
-0.0910007358,
-0.0590340719,
-0.0965217128,
-0.0275640097,
0.0941288546,
0.0221250691,
0.0571526177,
0.0031494938,
0.0196762476,
-0.0462922901,
0.0448539853,
-0.0338855572,
-0.073890321,
0.0715750679,
-0.0416744426,
0.0040341876,
-0.0355635174,
-0.0356599726,
0.0035944742,
0.033542037,
0.0515332296,
0.0299031939,
-0.0211120676,
-0.0130731361,
-0.0141393663,
-0.0542741828,
-0.0113502275,
-0.0635450035,
0.0679825097,
0.0122996448,
-0.0017849526,
-0.0449195616,
-0.0151734306,
0.0222744122,
0.0346839987,
0.018103499,
-0.0465355068,
0.060533911,
0.019041134,
0.0086069824,
-0.0035389999,
-0.071119234,
0.0168552008,
0.0231512226,
-0.0334127657,
-0.0036960479,
-0.0030016615,
0.0213717315,
0.0015871953,
-0.0187317934,
0.0687421113,
2.433012264e-34,
0.0218262374,
0.0429018326,
-0.0083196955,
-0.0076020048,
0.0596145801,
0.0115199499,
-0.0423641801,
0.0085326089,
-0.0076194541,
-0.0775831714,
-0.004693713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04790v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04790v1 | MMHQA-ICL: Multimodal In-context Learning for Hybrid Question Answering over Text, Tables and Images | 2023-09-09T13:35:01 | 2023-09-09T13:35:01 | Weihao Liu, Fangyu Lei, Tongxu Luo, Jiahe Lei, Shizhu He, Jun Zhao, Kang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the real world, knowledge often exists in a multimodal and heterogeneous
form. Addressing the task of question answering with hybrid data types,
including text, tables, and images, is a challenging task (MMHQA). Recently,
with the rise of large language models (LLM), in-context learning (ICL) has
become the most popular way to solve QA problems. We propose MMHQA-ICL
framework for addressing this problems, which includes stronger heterogeneous
data retriever and an image caption module. Most importantly, we propose a
Type-specific In-context Learning Strategy for MMHQA, enabling LLMs to leverage
their powerful performance in this task. We are the first to use end-to-end LLM
prompting method for this task. Experimental results demonstrate that our
framework outperforms all baselines and methods trained on the full dataset,
achieving state-of-the-art results under the few-shot setting on the
MultimodalQA dataset. | [
0.0088595916,
0.052267421,
0.0119586708,
0.0586334951,
-0.0098619023,
0.0279302057,
0.0007590927,
-0.0018521204,
0.0072803763,
-0.080376029,
-0.0638369918,
-0.0392014384,
-0.0459157154,
0.0291980784,
0.0440485552,
-0.0084635681,
0.0446356013,
-0.0288528707,
-0.0260668509,
0.004000654,
0.0323101841,
0.0143111572,
-0.009494124,
0.0227669273,
-0.0250249002,
-0.0454511717,
-0.0319306627,
0.0153974388,
-0.0139441052,
-0.0140302153,
0.0361721665,
0.0576729476,
0.0653644875,
0.013613618,
0.0000018295,
-0.0093701575,
-0.026341537,
0.00911377,
0.0040362901,
-0.0391459502,
0.020125851,
-0.0221614074,
0.031758748,
-0.0087971976,
-0.0670110509,
0.0147461835,
0.0270002466,
0.0461061709,
0.0687738359,
0.0630599931,
-0.0138796605,
-0.0063928133,
-0.0026314429,
-0.0043816688,
0.0354582928,
-0.0437649041,
-0.0071630692,
0.039920833,
0.0293650571,
0.0140653821,
-0.0102462862,
0.0687410757,
0.0232449584,
0.026028458,
-0.0161812603,
0.0318010151,
-0.0207919516,
0.0151807247,
-0.0232990533,
0.1338800043,
0.0094615994,
0.0193707347,
-0.0080079101,
0.0183213912,
0.0044833282,
-0.007544125,
-0.0618406683,
0.0315493494,
-0.0113206627,
-0.0202679895,
-0.0577666946,
0.0003786813,
-0.0113292178,
0.0052159545,
-0.0209357888,
-0.0067671477,
0.0012899665,
-0.0126201902,
-0.0101609668,
-0.0172264483,
-0.0559810847,
-0.0333705172,
-0.0366866291,
0.0584932007,
-0.0341111049,
0.0132326344,
0.0007744399,
-0.0484562479,
0.0434183441,
-0.0479854271,
0.0099243196,
0.0245727915,
-0.0477930941,
0.0527890958,
-0.0049762819,
0.0039033568,
-0.0369818471,
0.0075361752,
-0.0240589119,
-0.0440024361,
-0.0523344427,
-0.014293937,
-0.0395866781,
0.0254369434,
-0.0596739799,
-0.0503699854,
0.0014924516,
0.0374105908,
-0.012806247,
0.0189330149,
0.0042412332,
0.0381276645,
-0.0372309871,
0.0071704481,
-0.0238628481,
0.0509740598,
-0.0277482495,
0.0116733266,
-0.0012682115,
-0.0403419212,
-0.0062058903,
0.0021131709,
0.0369191356,
-0.0351836942,
0.0231442582,
0.0845225379,
-0.0758185983,
-0.0400021039,
-0.0221982393,
-0.0253910851,
-0.0130790947,
-0.0653254986,
0.0199033413,
-0.0652264506,
0.0462366492,
0.0031869225,
-0.0131464321,
-0.005867722,
0.0069939988,
0.0580655485,
0.0069181421,
0.0874418989,
0.0169371311,
-0.025201818,
0.0480632782,
0.0063251122,
-0.0221026447,
0.1221610904,
-0.0004157877,
-0.0030699964,
0.0485451967,
0.0191701576,
0.018708583,
0.0519861728,
0.0368777029,
0.0258310828,
-0.0216805544,
0.0491166897,
0.0466530025,
0.0049683498,
0.0203417633,
0.0299633406,
-0.0202182122,
0.0056400876,
0.0398760065,
0.025435375,
-0.0084265722,
0.0118779056,
0.0044652955,
0.0031479532,
0.0082061281,
-0.013739299,
-0.0373732299,
0.0762268677,
-0.0233825445,
0.0148829008,
0.0372423194,
0.0331012718,
-0.0408872105,
-0.0132141793,
0.0031379184,
0.0012599829,
-0.0172991585,
0.0483652428,
0.0421251468,
0.0420543812,
-0.0536922179,
0.0197032262,
-0.0014171916,
-0.0102215903,
-0.0402522497,
-0.004672077,
0.0368008576,
0.0274215825,
0.0098170619,
-0.0593588315,
-0.019882869,
-0.0328203216,
0.0372281633,
0.0339851342,
-0.0424401835,
-0.0305145904,
0.0265298579,
-0.039853029,
-0.0191600379,
-0.012084174,
-0.0031851998,
-0.0154732158,
0.0268814676,
0.0257699061,
0.0157413967,
-0.0480209105,
0.0278248023,
0.0049878741,
0.0218701139,
-0.011611375,
-0.0118646175,
0.034478683,
-0.0050680391,
0.008354472,
-0.0136347748,
0.0032340493,
0.021941971,
-0.045835752,
-0.0326516628,
-0.0016912202,
-0.0327881053,
-0.0777073652,
0.0393324569,
-0.030544769,
-0.0307341386,
-0.0340471789,
-0.0546796396,
-0.0193487518,
-0.0037026138,
-0.0320516936,
0.004990241,
-0.0630305633,
-0.053287223,
0.042308595,
0.0125167714,
-0.0381089002,
0.0635939464,
-0.002678432,
-0.0099950004,
0.0373745263,
-0.0409059785,
0.005449478,
-0.0223394148,
0.0047967001,
0.014718581,
0.0005453845,
0.0527710095,
-0.0074070478,
0.0422833227,
-0.0547040142,
-0.0031906883,
-0.1311101466,
0.0005179611,
-0.0339126922,
-0.0149357105,
0.0269050431,
0.0310287289,
0.0036801479,
-0.0448274203,
-0.053402774,
-0.0053696241,
0.0264039151,
0.0425696447,
0.0518410839,
0.0318552889,
0.0258750208,
-0.0380423069,
-0.0157018136,
-0.0047965753,
0.1017163694,
-0.0498674884,
-0.0159515291,
0.0068574455,
-0.0473191217,
-0.0315445513,
0.0426086038,
-0.0140774753,
-0.0056599788,
0.0002740245,
-0.0365704298,
0.0323447734,
0.0478765368,
-0.0035616537,
-0.0097664762,
-0.0127074048,
0.0030512735,
-0.0610727817,
0.0360947251,
0.0259866826,
-0.0240518693,
0.028395772,
-0.0252476055,
0.0124274008,
0.0061969706,
-0.022916181,
-0.0009524725,
-0.0232003629,
0.0424818546,
0.0296662115,
-0.0108875679,
-0.0913655236,
0.0711023882,
0.0198858529,
0.0241013393,
-0.0218550768,
-0.0110602295,
0.0236376077,
-0.0074303071,
-0.0164894089,
-0.0145716062,
-0.015284732,
-0.0677944645,
0.0624940284,
-0.0125662582,
0.0250263065,
-0.0164470263,
-0.0088510113,
-0.0495879613,
-0.018632656,
0.0003308364,
-0.0195550267,
0.0905046463,
-0.0087589817,
0.0401344784,
-0.0305721592,
-0.0510366932,
-0.0194066167,
-0.031759236,
-0.0287156776,
0.0055339388,
-0.0724509358,
0.007881863,
0.0241796318,
-0.0130813289,
0.0357239991,
0.0233665165,
-0.0212759562,
-0.020668475,
-0.0273467526,
0.1023468748,
0.0779995024,
0.0390941016,
-0.0525885671,
-0.0325927548,
0.0281930268,
0.0548737273,
0.014680706,
-0.0355169326,
-0.0373853631,
0.0252716653,
0.0152459648,
0.0257698763,
0.0073670754,
0.0327031091,
0.0435938872,
-0.0496955514,
0.0040666657,
0.0632227883,
0.0137524921,
-0.052438356,
-0.0261436496,
-0.0036078112,
0.0337863155,
0.0438138172,
0.0374667607,
-0.127919212,
-0.0819016993,
-0.0307567194,
-0.0062967497,
0.0274110772,
-0.0042768661,
0.0003083574,
-0.0772879496,
0.0243364051,
-0.0392885581,
-0.0987910032,
-0.0671167001,
-0.0080195498,
-0.0057276082,
0.0129556861,
0.0318620875,
0.0151503114,
-0.0344217531,
0.004855772,
0.0128658814,
0.0393141508,
-0.0412306115,
0.0147362882,
-0.0572841242,
-0.005516754,
0.0393284149,
-0.0024990535,
-0.0159805305,
-0.0334469639,
0.0226353388,
-0.0095256586,
-0.0051719416,
-0.0011868591,
0.0468046032,
-0.0404845104,
-0.0231106337,
-0.0092464602,
0.0388949402,
-0.0201972239,
-0.0091418643,
0.0152142253,
0.0691185445,
-0.0088381004,
0.0212359764,
-0.0299067218,
-0.0139698396,
0.035128016,
0.0535095297,
0.0103735393,
-0.0268780384,
-0.0497752056,
-0.0191351455,
-0.0336576067,
-0.0315156467,
0.0222541559,
0.0363928713,
-0.0047516618,
0.032736592,
-0.0602616929,
-0.0102852192,
0.046329096,
0.0460079424,
-0.018434424,
-0.0040582391,
-0.0302941445,
0.0370473154,
-0.0741861463,
0.0509782061,
-0.0457745641,
0.0215139054,
-0.0377752446,
-0.0013513428,
0.033556141,
-0.0437149256,
-0.0171335656,
0.0408676453,
-0.0861047432,
-0.0226619802,
-0.0624849759,
0.0464378521,
0.0058444045,
0.039969407,
0.0452514663,
-0.0300140996,
0.0304309018,
0.0333612226,
-0.0245592315,
-0.0067116334,
0.0243512671,
0.0276827961,
-0.010938568,
0.0357274897,
-0.0718093812,
-0.0253441054,
-0.0173864905,
0.049685929,
-0.0109355543,
0.0036946351,
0.0192834102,
-0.0115453843,
-0.0427790098,
0.0192465764,
-0.0158191454,
-0.0154933408,
0.0215814374,
-0.0017214086,
-0.0520648696,
-0.0491114371,
0.025469685,
-0.0218574945,
-0.0333212242,
-0.0013074244,
-0.0004434447,
0.018919345,
0.0624830276,
-0.0151557289,
0.0105626788,
0.0430673882,
-0.0382042006,
0.005152449,
-0.0251375325,
-0.0111505119,
0.010159241,
0.001328962,
0.044702515,
-0.0300399717,
0.0845304951,
0.0338066481,
-0.047089532,
-0.068592988,
0.0332955867,
-0.027593853,
-0.0327148475,
-0.0223534219,
0.041793026,
0.0674140081,
0.0133697717,
-0.0066946647,
0.0131188752,
-0.0310038961,
0.0130609609,
0.0213003475,
0.0142304469,
-0.0087409467,
0.0799557567,
0.016873762,
0.0017989812,
0.0095036244,
0.0749502555,
-0.0121589638,
0.0164036304,
0.0129095502,
-0.0027262964,
-0.035509266,
0.0034799131,
0.0452717096,
0.0159881134,
-0.0049168165,
0.0195521414,
-0.0123838605,
-0.065913327,
0.0168096926,
0.0035302129,
-0.0827190876,
0.0270485971,
0.0479242355,
0.0583079606,
0.0817695186,
-0.0446114689,
-0.02665486,
0.0280121993,
0.0112172822,
-0.0021205212,
-0.0040538078,
-6.259591172e-33,
-0.0201271642,
-0.0298250448,
0.0346185118,
-0.0703473166,
-0.0007710815,
0.0128956791,
-0.0156854484,
-0.0107265841,
-0.0138257341,
-0.0147248004,
-0.0101385536,
-0.0013162042,
0.002879071,
0.0558099039,
0.0065739807,
-0.0358283967,
-0.0081740571,
-0.0167773962,
0.0011092504,
-0.0023468989,
0.0219637509,
0.0241916273,
0.043041449,
0.0094911968,
0.0128008071,
0.0068305116,
-0.0065587475,
0.0274495035,
-0.0083328122,
0.0547740348,
-0.0604157224,
0.0312604122,
0.0323860273,
-0.0403460339,
-0.0092278952,
0.053781379,
-0.1097458974,
-0.0068668248,
0.0120372707,
0.0168717094,
-0.0523428731,
-0.0198118594,
0.008382963,
-0.0478630811,
0.0350089632,
-0.0389488079,
0.0387456901,
0.0052884375,
0.00641206,
-0.0338895358,
-0.0261347461,
0.0072542657,
-0.0349861458,
0.0103437472,
-0.0012179322,
0.082940869,
0.0270754844,
0.0305761546,
-0.0680959672,
-0.0095162615,
-0.037457563,
0.0016138788,
0.053216774,
0.0273191165,
0.0051116934,
0.023285795,
0.0137527604,
0.0110439314,
-0.0421481431,
-0.0256588217,
-0.0066471277,
0.0513058864,
0.0182692576,
0.0710948482,
0.035399083,
0.0336111262,
-0.0477307029,
0.0345576443,
-0.0167474691,
0.0254596043,
-0.0078186654,
-0.0052452432,
0.0005161206,
0.007406339,
-0.0353251398,
0.0329819843,
-0.0380648188,
-0.0120082805,
0.0405797064,
0.0108218156,
0.02800918,
0.0169421751,
0.0674214289,
-0.0392977186,
-0.0304829217,
0.0368423462,
-0.0077110212,
0.0336264856,
0.0216022581,
0.0437732302,
-0.0013287761,
-0.0025093078,
0.0411015563,
-0.0171703007,
0.0157036968,
0.0124279326,
0.0535096377,
0.0150635205,
-0.0760878399,
-0.0088376254,
-0.0429599471,
0.0346336029,
-0.0331300013,
0.0352241397,
-0.0080805868,
0.015560938,
-0.0424480475,
0.0303142518,
-0.0147829568,
-0.0054757246,
-0.0208664089,
-0.0474075787,
-0.0097251385,
0.0054067327,
-0.010434458,
0.0331854224,
-0.0617945828,
0.0065687601,
-0.0114091011,
-0.0677061602,
0.0054709339,
0.0540668629,
2.472e-7,
0.0632034987,
0.0034137263,
0.021699613,
0.0458471738,
0.0129071241,
0.0367495269,
-0.0299865901,
0.0244979169,
0.0107333446,
-0.0293184705,
0.0179829355,
0.0363956951,
0.029377969,
0.0331004187,
-0.0426716655,
-0.0256272219,
-0.0497868732,
-0.0244729239,
-0.0694293752,
-0.0040860455,
0.0344744474,
0.0842611045,
-0.0484933481,
-0.0190761164,
-0.0060185171,
-0.0379608087,
0.0861812085,
-0.0145249721,
-0.0014076489,
-0.0074892244,
0.0178697836,
0.0035647429,
0.0275154542,
0.0216378458,
0.0008540483,
0.0074845655,
0.0503954142,
0.0386342034,
-0.0018215233,
-0.0580788255,
-0.0262512397,
-0.001625767,
0.0098588308,
-0.06095488,
0.1172358021,
-0.0464572906,
-0.0154738463,
-0.0300682615,
-0.0314910747,
-0.0216222312,
0.021773085,
-0.0186028741,
-0.0395382084,
0.0407910496,
0.0462954715,
-0.0228034612,
-0.0041526002,
-0.0702537298,
-0.0067757387,
0.0287043341,
-0.032797385,
-0.0110368775,
-0.0221682265,
-0.018144602,
0.0146613438,
-0.0566833839,
-0.0276994407,
2.116118731e-34,
0.0485465862,
-0.0087714419,
0.0365279205,
0.0782034844,
0.016616974,
-0.0268445071,
-0.0232698787,
-0.0334163867,
0.0254224632,
-0.080120191,
-0.0078396043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04766v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04766v4 | SeaEval for Multilingual Foundation Models: From Cross-Lingual Alignment to Cultural Reasoning | 2023-09-09T11:42:22 | 2024-04-01T03:26:26 | Bin Wang, Zhengyuan Liu, Xin Huang, Fangkai Jiao, Yang Ding, AiTi Aw, Nancy F. Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present SeaEval, a benchmark for multilingual foundation models. In
addition to characterizing how these models understand and reason with natural
language, we also investigate how well they comprehend cultural practices,
nuances, and values. Alongside standard accuracy metrics, we investigate the
brittleness of foundation models in the dimensions of semantics and
multilinguality. Our analyses span both open-sourced and closed models, leading
to empirical results across classic NLP tasks, reasoning, and cultural
comprehension. Key findings indicate (1) Most models exhibit varied behavior
when given paraphrased instructions. (2) Many models still suffer from exposure
bias (e.g., positional bias, majority label bias). (3) For questions rooted in
factual, scientific, and commonsense knowledge, consistent responses are
expected across multilingual queries that are semantically equivalent. Yet,
most models surprisingly demonstrate inconsistent performance on these queries.
(4) Multilingually-trained models have not attained "balanced multilingual"
capabilities. Our endeavors underscore the need for more generalizable semantic
representations and enhanced multilingual contextualization. SeaEval can serve
as a launchpad for more thorough investigations and evaluations for
multilingual and multicultural scenarios. | [
0.0190478899,
0.068828769,
-0.0162235647,
0.0619945712,
-0.052718062,
0.0149123408,
0.0288800485,
-0.0419045724,
-0.0263177156,
-0.0343662351,
-0.0443285927,
-0.0452446453,
-0.0086187981,
-0.025347203,
0.0046863453,
-0.0283778124,
0.043854624,
0.0110048605,
-0.0021641573,
-0.0228959005,
0.0082849935,
0.0534633361,
0.0104686404,
0.0379598625,
-0.0025869729,
-0.0364486501,
0.0051510064,
-0.0069857999,
0.0325336196,
-0.0151748573,
-0.0020549374,
0.0336265527,
0.0157351214,
0.0350341946,
0.0000020385,
-0.0519960523,
-0.0059403949,
-0.0000741858,
-0.0001640468,
-0.0057328236,
0.0526463017,
-0.0519932881,
0.0112500424,
-0.0259387698,
-0.0436242744,
-0.0013122883,
0.0316839851,
0.0586362742,
0.037068408,
0.0334618799,
0.0043319948,
-0.0611616932,
-0.0191344135,
-0.0185284801,
-0.0313692056,
-0.0419849791,
0.0076986742,
0.0400721431,
-0.0269630011,
0.0195365753,
-0.0428481512,
0.0440156087,
0.0419391952,
0.0155658368,
-0.0372325331,
0.0099742869,
-0.0452811457,
-0.0604474843,
0.0211695731,
0.0766908675,
0.0131804692,
-0.0272682011,
-0.0080913361,
0.018214969,
-0.029067317,
-0.0193285104,
-0.0407813117,
0.0745504275,
-0.0095296064,
-0.001730263,
0.0495733023,
0.0065167272,
0.0363093056,
0.046370849,
0.0097307637,
0.0945365578,
0.0036000083,
-0.007313557,
0.0077970307,
0.0114363506,
-0.0023665535,
-0.0404802412,
-0.0072832294,
0.0034840584,
-0.0363346301,
0.0378625169,
-0.0299823023,
0.0087865619,
0.0493688323,
-0.0513282008,
-0.013252411,
0.0644608662,
-0.0489674658,
0.0656070486,
-0.0036817305,
0.0356839299,
-0.0548201688,
0.0540507697,
-0.0052894028,
-0.0512508713,
-0.0311341882,
-0.0073466366,
0.0187489092,
0.0181551836,
-0.0316325948,
0.0102263475,
-0.0276335068,
-0.0057998695,
-0.0105901258,
0.0010475338,
-0.0263193827,
-0.0233803429,
-0.0219171271,
0.0126011977,
-0.0323336534,
0.0705923364,
-0.0621968582,
0.0052394234,
-0.0112331118,
-0.0833447948,
0.0001960497,
-0.0120231099,
-0.0533958673,
-0.0520284288,
0.021329375,
0.0231557786,
0.0062665753,
-0.0043545249,
-0.0454612933,
-0.0190412216,
0.0017817806,
-0.0629780293,
-0.0011112776,
-0.0556400418,
0.0657665133,
0.0193502903,
0.0073078149,
-0.0516166799,
0.0176333878,
0.0442704819,
-0.0306135137,
0.0459995829,
0.0458130389,
0.0005352061,
0.0142080123,
0.0094070127,
-0.0059168376,
0.0878882781,
-0.0214215443,
-0.0260052253,
0.0757370219,
-0.0005435768,
-0.0975864157,
0.016102992,
0.0286315419,
0.004029437,
-0.0002153497,
0.0550087653,
0.0163783021,
0.0210467521,
0.0245324187,
0.034461312,
-0.0264833178,
-0.0343804955,
0.0364386812,
0.040674068,
-0.0195684303,
0.0253829323,
0.0437391847,
-0.0220486689,
-0.0221188162,
0.0030582966,
-0.0732985362,
0.0146899028,
0.001561899,
0.0014492701,
-0.0107871909,
0.0882617533,
-0.0372059457,
-0.0263650995,
-0.0059582018,
-0.0052217557,
-0.0021578914,
0.0264166687,
0.0248235371,
-0.0031239295,
0.0100389235,
0.0752139241,
0.0497531854,
-0.0524058379,
0.0026820644,
0.0058992142,
0.0239260886,
0.0055780746,
0.0009965375,
-0.016016908,
-0.0149697075,
-0.0081371386,
0.0391331501,
0.0425156206,
0.0591349229,
-0.0107280323,
0.052412834,
-0.037852671,
-0.0123249581,
-0.0406092294,
-0.0012119898,
0.029023828,
0.0205259807,
0.0397391468,
-0.0024954446,
-0.0623051897,
-0.0258354843,
0.0343659706,
-0.0584199689,
0.0069025885,
-0.0367562026,
0.0133811738,
0.0103694899,
0.0410521254,
0.0084023345,
-0.001156864,
0.023838751,
-0.0379142649,
-0.0179191772,
0.0210049525,
-0.062847279,
-0.0376950316,
0.0598114282,
-0.0377618112,
-0.0352500454,
0.0108474242,
-0.0335291252,
-0.0299727619,
-0.0009785591,
0.0294681098,
-0.0105277803,
-0.0436539501,
-0.0156343654,
-0.02804658,
0.0193578228,
-0.0181255676,
0.0755318999,
-0.0152659547,
0.0250393078,
0.0039901235,
-0.028319044,
0.0707296357,
-0.0363351367,
-0.0321395919,
0.0423069932,
-0.0095922314,
-0.024463119,
0.0387235358,
0.0262250565,
-0.0328914076,
0.0305318404,
-0.0985223278,
0.0114167053,
-0.0343819447,
-0.0217926782,
0.031703651,
0.0121947704,
0.0080328044,
-0.0197202172,
-0.0644683093,
-0.0373735763,
0.0188378375,
0.0394521914,
0.0365250334,
-0.0089278184,
0.0259373989,
-0.005791659,
-0.0296588819,
-0.0248772539,
0.0487981699,
-0.0235896055,
0.0125521021,
-0.0142552368,
-0.0321389847,
-0.0669551343,
-0.0144392569,
-0.0236232821,
0.0056102029,
-0.0053206524,
0.0211937781,
-0.0087328656,
0.0717500001,
-0.0113224667,
0.0090787578,
0.0374371819,
0.0276691876,
-0.0580063164,
0.0199888162,
0.0041832859,
0.0296251941,
-0.0238998663,
-0.0358951092,
-0.0253560636,
0.0623449907,
0.0083060944,
-0.0018173165,
-0.0573678762,
0.0011970617,
-0.0380269065,
-0.0405072495,
-0.0335718766,
0.0130599411,
0.0126425,
0.0588270612,
-0.0520358905,
0.0033482581,
0.0783657804,
-0.0026714709,
-0.0062731472,
-0.0574787706,
0.0060248133,
-0.0524295643,
0.050251998,
-0.0401849784,
0.0530728623,
0.0027107305,
-0.0001483817,
-0.0556704216,
-0.0304773301,
0.0437362939,
-0.0149021409,
0.0647866651,
-0.0236605685,
-0.0206864346,
-0.0236350168,
-0.0544347689,
-0.0400870107,
-0.0348467864,
-0.0286129154,
0.0414358228,
-0.0273322817,
0.0100107184,
-0.0500634462,
-0.0206036493,
0.0634363964,
-0.0195591394,
-0.0121780187,
0.0178660173,
-0.0052676741,
-0.0135307182,
0.0578773804,
0.0192453768,
0.0431249551,
-0.0108390916,
0.0383877493,
0.0224824883,
0.0494638793,
-0.0267732739,
0.0183686707,
0.0058198785,
0.0288343113,
0.0082877455,
-0.0525106899,
-0.0374547318,
0.0756381899,
-0.0170595702,
0.0129798539,
0.0879799649,
0.016723888,
-0.0008843521,
0.0040683611,
-0.0658616871,
0.0278372634,
0.0407218561,
0.0123495813,
-0.0952127799,
-0.0248362869,
-0.0018256443,
-0.029400574,
0.0235948153,
-0.0202555023,
-0.0130305244,
-0.1159942299,
0.000752455,
-0.009466242,
-0.0759239718,
-0.0196727272,
-0.0375716276,
-0.0190032981,
-0.0412424356,
0.0382733829,
-0.007319984,
0.0233504716,
-0.007042828,
0.0018059304,
0.0154677313,
-0.0629794151,
0.0553585924,
-0.0324499793,
-0.002293963,
0.0221739765,
0.0691834539,
0.0055264668,
-0.0582414865,
0.0190883186,
-0.0308104735,
-0.0060555679,
-0.0147860385,
0.0122022815,
0.0024123157,
-0.0188560709,
0.0019172854,
0.0270586926,
-0.0336547941,
-0.007590475,
0.0011670054,
0.0808895975,
0.0270390864,
0.0058149314,
-0.0246893466,
0.0163125414,
-0.0047843163,
0.0925467163,
-0.0068682483,
-0.018417459,
-0.0300200302,
-0.0122205205,
-0.0215244014,
-0.0189610068,
-0.0629757717,
0.0447233729,
-0.025386041,
-0.0114701074,
-0.0333788656,
-0.0821071267,
-0.0046508438,
0.0275982935,
0.0258883201,
-0.0180363599,
-0.0222849548,
-0.0068750917,
-0.0096305441,
0.0499128662,
-0.0401074961,
0.0431253128,
-0.0147143938,
0.035424348,
0.0022978059,
-0.05014579,
-0.0243316535,
-0.0081979483,
-0.0303170551,
-0.0590755641,
0.005695086,
0.0536688119,
0.0140908817,
0.021099396,
-0.0137390792,
-0.010264039,
-0.017231049,
-0.0176136773,
-0.032724794,
0.0042841169,
0.0322147347,
-0.0129187051,
0.0012719863,
0.0538235046,
-0.0272843745,
0.0208389908,
0.006853974,
0.0732308403,
-0.0201574098,
-0.0056123529,
0.043857038,
0.0115532791,
0.0129765291,
-0.0095068784,
-0.0260323994,
-0.0303907916,
0.0050359084,
-0.0078264577,
-0.0450653657,
0.0046407725,
0.0033120827,
0.0434965454,
-0.0179775339,
0.0131048914,
0.0067394213,
-0.0044696177,
0.0159274358,
-0.0074433708,
-0.0024968616,
0.0589149781,
0.0334668607,
-0.0324161798,
0.023284262,
-0.0309434142,
0.0273633879,
-0.0165839568,
0.0609174073,
-0.0297820736,
0.0840439945,
0.0300694536,
-0.0148160998,
0.0368576497,
-0.0115496032,
-0.0460931063,
-0.0409711376,
0.0515246093,
-0.0239961054,
0.0607826337,
-0.0529475175,
0.0457865,
0.0121898064,
-0.0356989242,
-0.0168868322,
0.0338892341,
0.0428537205,
-0.0506142005,
0.0640501231,
0.010974206,
-0.0087543763,
0.005703981,
0.0523054041,
-0.0269015934,
0.0311620384,
0.0065694689,
-0.0033243257,
-0.0130161652,
-0.0359469056,
0.012064605,
0.0242208671,
-0.0268194359,
0.004819606,
-0.0981965661,
-0.0506173186,
0.025274314,
0.0064107059,
-0.0112980492,
-0.0114969816,
0.0096536521,
0.1134964675,
0.0104184663,
-0.0248671491,
-0.0423028283,
0.003220239,
-0.049350474,
0.0216243062,
-0.0118257711,
-6.179239521e-33,
-0.0163483061,
0.0185725335,
0.0083947722,
-0.0384004824,
-0.0165011939,
0.002311345,
-0.0354130864,
-0.0025847293,
-0.1020417735,
0.0221415777,
-0.0098395105,
0.0224880222,
0.0103787063,
0.0044963169,
0.0149188181,
-0.0297542829,
0.0031506801,
0.0215430353,
-0.0243874416,
-0.0035927929,
0.053034734,
0.0224862993,
0.078349933,
-0.0823963284,
0.0535650179,
-0.0035504145,
0.0283256881,
0.0178661868,
-0.011743648,
0.062704213,
-0.0218757242,
0.0414383486,
0.0342795178,
-0.0340141766,
0.0106845386,
-0.0190385077,
-0.1031119674,
-0.030858621,
0.0780901313,
0.0398182198,
-0.0284628123,
-0.0315658003,
-0.0004018808,
-0.0139200781,
0.0120255668,
-0.0200353805,
0.048193261,
-0.0356510133,
-0.0050637182,
0.0138691943,
-0.0641791523,
0.0196195394,
-0.002208465,
0.0223462619,
-0.0194738638,
0.0922101364,
-0.0096016712,
0.0559977181,
-0.0486849807,
0.0090297181,
-0.040906284,
0.0008502073,
0.074916482,
-0.0108985817,
0.0018331045,
0.0514005944,
-0.0028130861,
0.0188391004,
0.0026595576,
-0.0261258781,
0.0185748395,
0.0325001329,
0.0024480794,
0.1406609565,
-0.0016768345,
0.0438675247,
-0.1053228751,
-0.0081835119,
0.0272003114,
0.0320598371,
0.0152566507,
-0.0173080731,
-0.0099367537,
0.002462398,
-0.0723731145,
-0.0236047413,
-0.0297630187,
-0.015893532,
0.0429698974,
-0.021381218,
-0.0199385807,
0.0290944036,
0.0436390862,
-0.0352003016,
-0.0243834481,
0.0551466122,
0.0124364281,
-0.0420847572,
0.021065563,
0.061513681,
-0.0584153645,
-0.0045629218,
-0.0368427336,
-0.0109640071,
0.0238207709,
0.0264027286,
0.0678998381,
-0.0091482187,
-0.0270687696,
-0.0137259392,
-0.0391266979,
-0.004388669,
-0.0518564656,
0.0140904263,
0.038680084,
0.0408212394,
-0.0181234088,
0.0359695666,
0.0623187125,
0.0043051783,
-0.0249203444,
-0.0502357222,
0.0046611447,
0.0390153863,
-0.0248658583,
-0.0095045213,
-0.0308948085,
0.0278039724,
-0.0007432378,
-0.0566259697,
-0.0134955961,
0.0280578751,
2.652e-7,
0.0555481315,
0.0074702231,
0.0000834959,
0.0135816662,
-0.0040392745,
0.0347791649,
-0.0294097271,
0.0233057253,
-0.0139084393,
-0.0533784777,
-0.0246551987,
0.0488961302,
0.0528080687,
0.0363880061,
-0.0768300146,
0.014454524,
-0.0413184091,
0.0073391013,
-0.055322703,
0.0141206319,
-0.0028105804,
0.0886752605,
0.0005963098,
-0.0088850707,
-0.0202938057,
-0.0070566977,
0.0725730211,
-0.0249645505,
-0.0208170488,
-0.0186349209,
-0.0121260779,
-0.0051053334,
0.0053914948,
0.0240543168,
-0.0041107708,
0.0336144939,
0.0409433357,
0.0541804098,
-0.0064688581,
-0.0270672124,
-0.0172762237,
-0.0319786295,
-0.0282504857,
-0.1136459485,
0.0726616606,
0.0236253403,
-0.0479256585,
-0.0091273021,
-0.0249188989,
0.015609758,
0.0600168556,
0.0048440518,
-0.0273299962,
-0.0035950372,
0.0262460839,
-0.0162554551,
-0.0072104055,
-0.046059873,
-0.0417942852,
-0.0005058384,
0.0069356668,
-0.0326234587,
0.0154222688,
-0.0298829041,
0.0189732313,
-0.0348650254,
-0.0242458656,
2.217759044e-34,
0.0178673733,
0.003256236,
0.0187361371,
0.0037125503,
0.045796562,
-0.0363798514,
-0.0133963963,
-0.0092036715,
0.0149320131,
-0.0221268795,
0.0046031699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04739v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04739v2 | Data Augmentation for Conversational AI | 2023-09-09T09:56:35 | 2024-03-02T23:14:47 | Heydar Soudani, Evangelos Kanoulas, Faegheh Hasibi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Advancements in conversational systems have revolutionized information
access, surpassing the limitations of single queries. However, developing
dialogue systems requires a large amount of training data, which is a challenge
in low-resource domains and languages. Traditional data collection methods like
crowd-sourcing are labor-intensive and time-consuming, making them ineffective
in this context. Data augmentation (DA) is an affective approach to alleviate
the data scarcity problem in conversational systems. This tutorial provides a
comprehensive and up-to-date overview of DA approaches in the context of
conversational systems. It highlights recent advances in conversation
augmentation, open domain and task-oriented conversation generation, and
different paradigms of evaluating these models. We also discuss current
challenges and future directions in order to help researchers and practitioners
to further advance the field in this area. | [
0.0293896925,
0.0664533973,
-0.0308440197,
0.0267567094,
-0.0011180234,
0.0016988241,
0.0044438113,
-0.0406645462,
0.0189445671,
-0.0345983133,
-0.0416839346,
-0.0207368582,
-0.0118729807,
0.0784852579,
0.019933898,
-0.066733472,
0.0093294987,
-0.0097482884,
0.0193599947,
0.0136076268,
0.0249340478,
-0.0088319518,
-0.0329222865,
0.0457545109,
-0.014358419,
0.0059974566,
-0.0665302351,
0.0056156348,
0.0351008549,
-0.0386813395,
0.0134118004,
0.0192623828,
0.0436969064,
0.026136985,
0.0000018871,
-0.0217046551,
0.0058548469,
-0.0289588664,
-0.0445973538,
-0.0535051152,
0.0227089413,
-0.021646129,
0.0116162645,
0.0197100658,
-0.063710317,
-0.0274877064,
0.0620913617,
0.041906286,
0.0676970258,
0.0903750286,
-0.019736249,
0.0150378123,
0.0303278975,
-0.0113896541,
0.0292210355,
-0.0130658047,
-0.0057398821,
0.0084832525,
0.0470852554,
0.0161349084,
-0.0105255572,
0.0066667809,
0.0254609101,
-0.0240412951,
0.0440025628,
0.0141202966,
-0.0170902777,
-0.0164159443,
-0.0337607972,
0.0972884968,
0.0657779723,
0.0058493433,
-0.0153834922,
0.0022653521,
0.0408723764,
-0.05529809,
-0.0659089386,
0.0089773424,
0.019599719,
0.0174931902,
-0.0291171093,
0.0473906286,
-0.0073096002,
0.0243060719,
0.0114702536,
0.0272313152,
-0.0310253687,
-0.0351047516,
-0.0192399155,
0.0145013733,
-0.002468158,
-0.0722983479,
-0.0046877223,
0.0275885221,
-0.0546852276,
0.0214320198,
-0.0607140772,
-0.0482474566,
-0.0064764596,
0.0004987014,
-0.0027842848,
0.0373412706,
-0.0457845181,
-0.0015958922,
0.0513948686,
0.0201678798,
-0.001670223,
-0.043701794,
-0.0228460226,
-0.0314408503,
-0.0017436079,
0.0136291515,
-0.0448953658,
0.0158627219,
-0.0836490318,
-0.0346528441,
-0.0358637273,
0.0574806444,
-0.0271167066,
0.0049283938,
0.006122814,
0.0418186113,
-0.0432462841,
0.0085154371,
-0.0137114292,
0.0045278859,
-0.0379905514,
0.0317618847,
0.0614840686,
-0.0940547213,
-0.0165745113,
0.0399043486,
0.0324184,
-0.0122098792,
-0.0159745403,
0.0437298976,
-0.0164493918,
-0.0374245718,
-0.0322833583,
-0.0191982687,
-0.0246072691,
-0.0667242706,
-0.004597662,
-0.012018282,
0.0436275676,
-0.0284833051,
-0.0155247599,
-0.0248805955,
0.0168688986,
0.0058821221,
0.0046548932,
0.0422788523,
-0.0621065982,
-0.006366034,
0.0276212245,
0.0108474968,
-0.0174678341,
0.0714885145,
0.053860344,
0.0436063297,
0.0412669927,
0.0126903439,
0.0297678467,
-0.0027443198,
0.0280724317,
-0.0154115492,
0.0257837921,
0.0219247676,
-0.0489856824,
0.0502528585,
0.0140602095,
0.0469411947,
-0.0525452383,
0.007325477,
0.0519301631,
-0.0089557162,
-0.0169984996,
0.0043898923,
0.0221737009,
0.0321341045,
0.0028001247,
-0.0042935191,
-0.0172744859,
0.0536921099,
-0.0037075849,
-0.0076270108,
0.0491559431,
-0.001173183,
-0.0373415798,
-0.0639277548,
0.0216464885,
-0.0252234526,
0.0480806865,
0.0311187636,
0.0138391359,
0.0170240216,
-0.024600314,
-0.0278243646,
0.0004580663,
-0.0787435547,
-0.0093267011,
-0.0127748828,
-0.001609594,
0.0581700727,
0.0502505787,
-0.0230401065,
-0.0693560466,
-0.0179680046,
0.0307663474,
0.0573696941,
0.0337713696,
-0.0291863177,
0.0390844233,
-0.080371663,
0.0034108132,
-0.037628483,
-0.0075407922,
0.0166185014,
0.0071473774,
0.0147550413,
0.0290596317,
0.0094128586,
-0.0148023656,
-0.0042342488,
-0.04289883,
-0.0265868623,
0.0378157981,
0.0124386912,
0.0101920357,
0.0478559136,
0.0127809308,
-0.0129314736,
0.0317666195,
0.0004601601,
-0.0169027559,
0.0674042851,
-0.0277150963,
-0.0379862227,
0.0134622995,
-0.0217509884,
0.0140717588,
0.0177807491,
-0.023671994,
-0.0746864155,
0.0510462485,
-0.080798924,
0.0320645161,
-0.0525101274,
0.0196991097,
0.036989484,
0.0445330068,
0.0182011891,
0.0235408489,
0.0211617406,
-0.0408541448,
0.0279201604,
0.0303215347,
0.0145641407,
-0.08706256,
0.0083053652,
-0.006019685,
0.0075503434,
0.0020300427,
0.0150591442,
-0.0262408648,
-0.0906346291,
0.0031986996,
-0.1359597296,
0.0129962051,
0.0049179979,
-0.0096285678,
-0.0201453846,
0.0469157584,
-0.0102234911,
-0.0261584576,
-0.0855856612,
0.0156294033,
0.0666244552,
-0.0013989076,
0.0400136299,
0.0420733429,
0.004739265,
-0.050724633,
0.0474497192,
0.0469894297,
0.0023899805,
0.0069741006,
-0.0265820958,
-0.0234457925,
0.0272648763,
-0.047897879,
0.069495745,
-0.0280614924,
-0.0399767384,
0.0186977126,
0.0064728977,
0.0282920767,
0.0379529558,
0.0317628197,
0.0336117297,
-0.0080884993,
-0.0399051681,
-0.0472254269,
0.05233353,
-0.0176470391,
0.0404551029,
-0.0109025175,
-0.0088008,
0.0191581398,
0.0123923421,
-0.0137241874,
0.0255652517,
-0.0342813395,
0.0243678205,
0.0312550813,
-0.0537352934,
0.0150726307,
-0.023780141,
-0.0348593071,
0.0202313401,
-0.0209639464,
-0.0434571877,
0.0650310218,
-0.0149191571,
-0.0419538207,
-0.0476299524,
-0.0124527961,
-0.0367245004,
0.0416748412,
-0.0168759525,
0.0044888607,
0.0062881671,
0.0044693369,
-0.001832124,
0.0249517653,
-0.0300812982,
-0.0462756269,
0.0228214059,
-0.0327886641,
-0.0250752326,
0.0331289209,
-0.0729833692,
-0.0734986961,
-0.0016124577,
-0.0325299725,
-0.0222656541,
0.035415981,
-0.0493347161,
-0.0228224657,
-0.0283942074,
0.0131029533,
0.025593996,
-0.0228880625,
-0.0058498001,
-0.0273089986,
0.020409666,
0.0714755058,
0.0590959266,
0.0131901633,
-0.0154301589,
0.0471002012,
0.0142803937,
0.0486637056,
-0.036355827,
-0.0191476513,
-0.0062391069,
0.0228324477,
0.0258754157,
-0.0126091791,
-0.0130619304,
0.054435879,
-0.0181555152,
-0.0222055987,
0.1002650484,
0.0207214523,
-0.0159199387,
0.0071514235,
-0.0219787471,
0.0053954315,
-0.0112344008,
0.015063758,
-0.0908776894,
-0.0384910069,
0.0086284447,
0.0428474285,
-0.0479372293,
-0.0506982878,
-0.0286387783,
-0.1113872826,
0.0502643548,
0.0006851849,
-0.0465793349,
-0.0223796014,
0.0125296982,
0.0287820604,
-0.005141011,
0.0149124628,
-0.0431826301,
0.0248211045,
0.0091514401,
0.0314524584,
0.0306363069,
-0.0443387292,
-0.0427125953,
-0.0114059402,
0.09210857,
0.0529738665,
0.0828791186,
0.0415603705,
-0.015926877,
-0.0027809134,
0.0370891504,
0.0083826175,
0.0114962952,
0.0650747269,
-0.0212266408,
-0.0173584595,
-0.0164518859,
0.0653533489,
-0.0132379839,
-0.0014699649,
0.0291223917,
0.0282078516,
-0.0752151906,
0.0329631828,
-0.008032402,
0.0284875482,
0.0711619481,
0.0652128756,
0.0236485079,
-0.0423940122,
0.0101141315,
0.0008888019,
0.0125785619,
-0.0748242438,
0.0405093953,
-0.0052433615,
0.0246432479,
-0.0204346552,
-0.0922293365,
-0.0747015849,
0.0359934159,
0.0219855048,
-0.0310920086,
-0.024191726,
-0.0013749674,
0.002085726,
-0.0131208729,
0.0146786412,
-0.024673678,
-0.0126956971,
-0.0371601544,
-0.0631199703,
-0.0117386878,
-0.0914736837,
0.0127041303,
0.0323936231,
-0.0892138705,
-0.0556798093,
-0.0044518365,
0.0587756038,
0.023733519,
0.0500900261,
0.0034457394,
-0.0440150201,
-0.0223266091,
0.0557583272,
-0.0595199354,
0.0065058377,
0.0469159074,
0.0288789123,
0.0012154856,
0.036310453,
-0.0158656966,
0.0291214343,
-0.0108839041,
-0.0098804105,
-0.0260389298,
-0.0572824106,
0.007702346,
0.0189059209,
0.0361200199,
-0.0020453725,
-0.0249452256,
-0.0267998427,
0.0100588733,
-0.0621992238,
-0.0186590645,
-0.0865598395,
-0.0014830655,
-0.0292692743,
0.0246075597,
0.0143843386,
-0.019626569,
-0.0351194404,
-0.0087010171,
-0.0482384376,
-0.0042767324,
0.0209547114,
-0.0077253953,
0.0196148828,
0.0048846514,
-0.0008981727,
0.0357023552,
0.0084909238,
0.0335668474,
0.009075176,
0.0568661243,
0.0204942115,
-0.0437290445,
0.0313695744,
0.0525903441,
-0.0744338557,
-0.0133659532,
0.0008776916,
0.0576253496,
-0.0036508751,
0.0113253742,
0.0602004193,
-0.0468995087,
0.0483058468,
-0.0004982027,
0.0282352269,
-0.0052898317,
-0.0498856939,
-0.0041223895,
0.0064914273,
-0.0397273563,
0.0266597122,
0.0526514724,
-0.0386823379,
0.0521164387,
-0.0370756872,
0.0102228923,
-0.0476172939,
-0.0300725084,
0.0126352049,
0.0265711453,
0.0012413493,
0.0351673886,
-0.0335347094,
-0.0314204432,
-0.0277897567,
-0.0077996007,
-0.0223225132,
-0.0286517441,
0.0405120105,
0.0202771574,
-0.030574996,
0.020317765,
-0.0405868776,
0.0179660097,
-0.0559970662,
-0.0152316084,
-0.0062899757,
-5.562770243e-33,
-0.0166617166,
-0.0133453058,
0.0178643763,
-0.0044421502,
-0.0698763207,
-0.0005815799,
-0.0590395965,
0.0046472917,
-0.0087745348,
-0.0015692215,
-0.0082843909,
0.026118869,
0.0048370757,
0.0676936507,
-0.0218242072,
-0.0143448524,
0.0469707474,
0.000707845,
-0.006845335,
0.0579752699,
0.049638398,
0.0033141421,
-0.0134890191,
-0.0832041502,
0.0573228188,
-0.033644978,
-0.0275250021,
0.032095857,
0.0615697801,
0.0387493633,
-0.0029033681,
0.0325724296,
0.0068249921,
-0.0354839861,
-0.0201236308,
0.0203480441,
-0.0305321105,
-0.0087555153,
0.0160645656,
0.0093311304,
-0.0574360602,
-0.0172656234,
-0.0011248642,
-0.0065369122,
0.0118976897,
0.0567640774,
-0.0253595356,
-0.0472791903,
0.0205418579,
0.0155265434,
-0.0516090579,
0.0076944497,
-0.0313045681,
-0.0702353343,
0.0216939226,
0.1035512462,
0.0277193878,
-0.02744749,
-0.0237368848,
0.0586707778,
0.0223559588,
-0.0421338044,
0.0514268279,
0.0210060496,
0.0054269419,
0.0486868396,
0.0303382147,
0.0154746445,
-0.0308732502,
0.0447270274,
-0.0206816252,
0.0516458377,
0.0151359821,
0.0593628883,
-0.0043733176,
-0.0108526163,
0.009250747,
0.0494138747,
0.0211453978,
-0.0107551878,
-0.0142660392,
0.0065084193,
-0.0489655547,
0.0013732319,
0.0118939551,
0.0162845887,
0.0000771623,
-0.0387160704,
0.0273690876,
0.0388357714,
-0.0123513024,
-0.0008302621,
0.0117883179,
-0.0368339792,
0.0452763811,
0.0403151363,
-0.0318848006,
0.0194546785,
-0.0221159365,
-0.0296824574,
-0.0336120576,
-0.0286570787,
0.0966423303,
0.0434134081,
0.0051646931,
0.02875573,
0.0099183135,
0.0141080935,
-0.0071498365,
0.0180089101,
-0.0396693945,
0.1001034454,
-0.0260464381,
0.026029354,
-0.0010912416,
0.0261716079,
-0.0425088294,
0.0597419292,
0.0070292535,
0.0292135421,
-0.0476257391,
-0.0598322302,
0.0104937442,
-0.01483854,
-0.0382569171,
0.0055714571,
0.010816047,
-0.0575978197,
-0.0005008542,
-0.0265659392,
-0.0005799255,
-0.022031175,
2.641e-7,
-0.0494311787,
0.0050043599,
0.0358325765,
0.0063806972,
0.0110508353,
0.0482194461,
0.0058139963,
0.0263232123,
0.0236656833,
-0.0164561607,
0.0292708762,
0.0252260845,
0.0625567287,
-0.0010966798,
-0.0818832666,
-0.0487568527,
-0.0339971334,
-0.0337891281,
-0.0130222281,
0.002382485,
0.0559581034,
0.0568330288,
0.0275076069,
-0.0058150915,
0.032903377,
0.0109678498,
0.0318898931,
-0.0292087384,
-0.0320511684,
0.0253185015,
0.031376984,
0.0226711258,
-0.0322888717,
-0.0152237704,
-0.0226791892,
0.0459729247,
0.0001064424,
0.0119761536,
0.0311829466,
-0.0512041412,
0.010626059,
0.0336031243,
0.0096026631,
-0.0244752113,
0.0500571579,
-0.0311486181,
-0.0314959176,
-0.0068425755,
0.0081580523,
0.0018921744,
-0.0009840218,
-0.037845619,
-0.0372243486,
0.0013821959,
0.0160709452,
-0.0218694657,
0.0118888989,
-0.0620240383,
0.0032467064,
-0.0336307772,
-0.0757962391,
-0.0671102554,
-0.0383075736,
-0.0008056471,
-0.0127880927,
-0.0265730973,
-0.008450768,
1.859508659e-34,
0.0298172925,
0.0065934034,
0.0066871583,
0.0198537651,
0.0239206813,
-0.0036265403,
0.0031297156,
-0.016961012,
0.0519584939,
-0.0640233383,
-0.0134797804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04734v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04734v1 | Towards Better Multi-modal Keyphrase Generation via Visual Entity Enhancement and Multi-granularity Image Noise Filtering | 2023-09-09T09:41:36 | 2023-09-09T09:41:36 | Yifan Dong, Suhang Wu, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou, Xiaoli Wang, Jianxin Lin, Jinsong Su | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM | Multi-modal keyphrase generation aims to produce a set of keyphrases that
represent the core points of the input text-image pair. In this regard,
dominant methods mainly focus on multi-modal fusion for keyphrase generation.
Nevertheless, there are still two main drawbacks: 1) only a limited number of
sources, such as image captions, can be utilized to provide auxiliary
information. However, they may not be sufficient for the subsequent keyphrase
generation. 2) the input text and image are often not perfectly matched, and
thus the image may introduce noise into the model. To address these
limitations, in this paper, we propose a novel multi-modal keyphrase generation
model, which not only enriches the model input with external knowledge, but
also effectively filters image noise. First, we introduce external visual
entities of the image as the supplementary input to the model, which benefits
the cross-modal semantic alignment for keyphrase generation. Second, we
simultaneously calculate an image-text matching score and image region-text
correlation scores to perform multi-granularity image noise filtering.
Particularly, we introduce the correlation scores between image regions and
ground-truth keyphrases to refine the calculation of the previously-mentioned
correlation scores. To demonstrate the effectiveness of our model, we conduct
several groups of experiments on the benchmark dataset.
Experimental results and in-depth analyses show that our model achieves the
state-of-the-art performance. Our code is available on
https://github.com/DeepLearnXMU/MM-MKP. | [
0.0410117581,
0.0599273555,
0.0257669855,
0.0174432825,
-0.0243239235,
-0.0161939915,
-0.0172033533,
0.0377214551,
0.0045115296,
-0.057897035,
-0.0109723303,
0.015578527,
-0.016596524,
0.0531654656,
0.0378301479,
-0.0775216222,
0.0211579688,
-0.0346808843,
-0.0326671563,
-0.0100487918,
0.019192012,
0.0283221453,
-0.0027191965,
0.0589686297,
-0.0246691126,
0.0092658745,
-0.0242644157,
0.0129465507,
0.0232695024,
-0.0206366926,
-0.0329820551,
0.0338987969,
0.0183487535,
-0.0033553075,
0.0000018309,
-0.0268826243,
-0.0041729254,
0.0055850144,
0.0557111762,
-0.0181706138,
0.0675709024,
-0.0190623868,
0.0246236157,
-0.0080248071,
-0.0233295225,
0.0276734289,
0.0814835057,
0.0711340159,
0.0714567155,
0.0174389966,
-0.0487011075,
-0.0359310061,
0.0142379189,
-0.0266199429,
0.0213911328,
-0.0671645626,
0.0057090195,
-0.0110023404,
-0.0423018262,
0.0351483114,
-0.0209174193,
0.0419650041,
-0.0119278254,
0.0024022809,
0.064592801,
0.0439677127,
-0.0043470059,
-0.0546898507,
-0.0366551355,
0.0938802734,
-0.0223035291,
0.0242650416,
-0.0035159001,
-0.0357517786,
0.0143464105,
0.0472021289,
-0.0359227397,
-0.0030309914,
0.0065922081,
0.0118958093,
-0.0700324401,
-0.0159987323,
0.0006689396,
0.0263396632,
0.0044988822,
-0.0663224459,
0.0671189725,
-0.0107926745,
-0.0258744769,
0.0190039277,
-0.0642808378,
-0.0672641471,
0.0055504539,
0.0319805555,
0.019787835,
0.017114209,
-0.0730273351,
-0.0164377522,
0.0484818369,
-0.0801130384,
-0.0143558159,
-0.0151514774,
-0.0364019312,
0.0680726469,
-0.0421801209,
0.0218161512,
-0.0299616773,
0.0420014337,
-0.0309133977,
-0.0340125374,
-0.0294645149,
-0.0063828384,
-0.0032061536,
0.036718078,
0.0116797155,
-0.0628707781,
-0.056684494,
0.0083245477,
0.029688349,
0.0184143633,
0.0131709762,
0.0403821655,
-0.0325196125,
-0.0242067873,
-0.0166297741,
-0.0225606281,
-0.0214256477,
0.0303508714,
-0.0021863179,
0.0112250159,
0.0105107781,
0.0152876377,
0.0505526587,
-0.0133413319,
0.0234417524,
0.0400134884,
-0.0621224642,
-0.0200422108,
-0.0026754716,
-0.0882837474,
-0.0615409054,
0.007235467,
0.0191644114,
-0.0408216231,
0.0199763067,
-0.0224763136,
-0.0087489691,
-0.020322429,
0.0214955434,
0.0267647281,
-0.0764703676,
0.1038496122,
-0.0251712818,
-0.0069152787,
0.0129913129,
0.025005376,
0.010890007,
0.0379205048,
0.0338790007,
0.0574645698,
0.0544099472,
0.0038266538,
0.0047561438,
0.0321573913,
0.0272558965,
0.0149732241,
-0.0143879922,
-0.0233498383,
-0.0307242051,
0.014204354,
0.0086930189,
0.0357036404,
-0.0337204076,
0.0404594913,
0.073621437,
0.0377947986,
0.0091422265,
0.0234563779,
-0.0082561476,
0.0191982631,
-0.031868659,
0.0024412128,
-0.0023010876,
0.0239473637,
-0.0175703783,
0.0520911925,
0.0650645718,
0.0633255467,
-0.0165270083,
-0.0341241844,
0.0181805808,
0.0066982298,
0.0016232883,
-0.0221421048,
0.0489631183,
0.0021832166,
-0.0702653155,
0.0895598754,
-0.0076732608,
-0.0494115837,
-0.0107698096,
-0.028714655,
-0.0030579111,
0.0417586379,
0.0532618873,
0.0258810706,
-0.0289416984,
0.0186951924,
0.0091177719,
0.0714875087,
-0.0368006825,
0.0129633211,
-0.0024645361,
-0.0890359282,
-0.0955133289,
-0.0200170632,
-0.0196457002,
-0.027755212,
0.0021130007,
0.0262230374,
0.0538958013,
-0.0032914991,
0.0429191962,
0.0313951112,
0.0565230958,
0.0174329691,
-0.0244227797,
0.0175696779,
-0.0131911403,
0.0100002224,
-0.007197103,
0.0178810004,
0.0131164258,
-0.010575749,
0.0106792422,
0.0313708223,
-0.0125355786,
0.0144624868,
0.0323487036,
-0.0534985214,
0.0113758119,
-0.0145757748,
-0.0055590738,
-0.0527515151,
0.0088920202,
-0.0185263269,
0.0163766276,
-0.0604952164,
-0.0025786082,
0.0128373085,
0.0485404693,
-0.0225536618,
0.0673711672,
-0.0266281068,
-0.019505607,
-0.0116668316,
-0.0116517898,
0.0098683853,
0.0266645551,
-0.003859787,
0.0063288761,
-0.0090431953,
0.0172021277,
0.0372414775,
0.0196250509,
-0.0417393669,
-0.0323124342,
-0.0906000882,
-0.0311026741,
0.023937365,
-0.0534807704,
0.011735878,
0.0233901143,
0.0226657372,
-0.0390624516,
-0.0288439281,
0.0213597454,
0.0049192822,
0.0055070161,
0.0246159993,
0.0217056032,
-0.0059889904,
-0.0118651018,
0.0269316137,
0.0253647249,
0.0585784018,
0.0394659787,
-0.0447818339,
-0.0026718001,
0.0439044535,
-0.0150618022,
-0.0089590186,
0.0153635526,
-0.0302961282,
0.0250482056,
-0.0074970755,
0.0659851283,
-0.0191621464,
0.0462586954,
-0.0435489081,
-0.0007571897,
-0.0504720584,
-0.0419960171,
0.0039420146,
0.0018231537,
-0.0290452484,
0.0145124886,
-0.0311524961,
-0.000994956,
0.0104271201,
-0.0026862202,
0.0179345626,
-0.0803336054,
0.0277638659,
0.0382349193,
-0.0619688332,
-0.0654666871,
0.0158927348,
-0.0016845948,
0.0086700963,
-0.0606201589,
-0.0271417759,
0.0247102603,
-0.0378597267,
0.0114922505,
-0.006412548,
0.0142002925,
0.0072759432,
0.0562014654,
-0.016620269,
0.0250312742,
0.035672117,
0.0074319635,
-0.0383351259,
-0.0421328209,
0.0166947972,
-0.0387219712,
0.0895400792,
-0.0453286618,
0.0134763168,
0.007119617,
-0.007472544,
-0.0366801806,
-0.0519123971,
-0.0054938439,
-0.0316652171,
0.0029758471,
-0.0203869622,
0.0277572386,
0.0230580363,
0.0193833485,
-0.0164343119,
0.0097823888,
-0.0239116158,
-0.014932611,
0.0734443963,
0.0840006769,
0.024148874,
-0.054310143,
-0.0202787146,
-0.0059526991,
0.0507190339,
0.0561227351,
-0.0216070823,
-0.0070200614,
0.0162830669,
0.024098495,
0.0346073359,
-0.0103178127,
0.0132226562,
0.059627369,
0.0054586967,
0.0096978787,
0.0603699982,
0.0096436488,
-0.037445683,
-0.0283621941,
0.0105860149,
0.0115519967,
-0.0095646726,
-0.0077178497,
-0.0358788557,
-0.0441619307,
-0.0134504065,
-0.0269630644,
-0.002745694,
0.0113778096,
-0.0405873172,
-0.0728925541,
0.0308525451,
0.0115550673,
-0.0086328834,
-0.0361250974,
-0.0046980241,
-0.0188815985,
-0.0160462651,
-0.006928016,
-0.0457456037,
-0.0136384545,
-0.0022996669,
-0.0100144772,
0.0249806698,
-0.0622802861,
-0.0154990889,
-0.0789203718,
-0.0036835666,
0.044034604,
0.0490039289,
-0.019629268,
-0.0449982993,
-0.0044191289,
0.0207063835,
0.0012943562,
0.0274564438,
0.0301293917,
-0.0184685159,
-0.0391084552,
0.0008425921,
0.0087209148,
-0.000094381,
-0.0292204209,
0.0087296134,
0.0032554099,
0.0049920473,
0.0368705206,
-0.0513891838,
0.0160547961,
-0.0069086081,
0.0382832214,
0.012675833,
-0.0200109798,
0.0023149031,
-0.0067384215,
0.0321704857,
-0.0894748569,
-0.0404051431,
-0.0233556665,
-0.046314802,
0.0159080178,
-0.0704162642,
-0.0434067845,
0.0400667936,
0.0184129793,
-0.0209281072,
0.0308564361,
-0.0377274938,
0.0200133193,
-0.0556548201,
0.0137909772,
-0.0291462541,
-0.0064337207,
0.0076849032,
0.0127165075,
0.0397746786,
-0.0418115221,
-0.037782155,
0.0445158072,
-0.0655675307,
-0.0153884497,
-0.0117603717,
0.0459488295,
0.0045037367,
0.015551745,
0.001196045,
-0.038264703,
0.0739611834,
0.0469098911,
-0.0156350434,
-0.0190339535,
0.0088161603,
-0.0094571617,
-0.0268683434,
0.0084153432,
-0.0674061999,
-0.0113163088,
-0.0032325527,
0.0458846651,
-0.0481651239,
-0.0787544101,
0.0083954008,
-0.0005103309,
0.0201565754,
-0.0650522336,
0.0103639131,
-0.046612855,
-0.0028000602,
0.0173534919,
-0.0245054159,
-0.0536229983,
0.0229427945,
0.0103856726,
-0.0305045564,
0.0090020522,
0.0294242352,
-0.0273843016,
0.0197481383,
-0.0212314092,
-0.0389830619,
0.010139592,
0.0174750984,
-0.0047442787,
-0.0119567914,
0.0045680767,
0.0131405871,
-0.0115236705,
-0.021236198,
-0.0235211682,
0.0281028468,
0.0041402089,
-0.0459604785,
-0.0463472381,
0.0836804733,
-0.0229657069,
0.0149291158,
-0.0972514823,
0.0177220237,
0.0846266076,
0.0184371118,
0.0233861785,
-0.0059209224,
-0.0415940024,
0.0187815148,
0.0387174524,
-0.0003229106,
-0.0091888057,
0.026111668,
-0.0057590841,
0.002645178,
0.0027370481,
0.0927451923,
-0.0116086304,
0.0471670665,
-0.0141730541,
-0.0183389205,
-0.0459302254,
0.0034600827,
0.0505178347,
0.0280838925,
-0.004402861,
0.0310039967,
0.0042754943,
-0.0436635502,
0.0566328168,
-0.0055491948,
-0.0182598252,
0.0471832342,
0.0449462272,
0.0580911301,
-0.0048260665,
0.0054591377,
-0.0332185961,
-0.0174565129,
-0.0018513039,
0.0077750478,
-0.0012357853,
-5.988490583e-33,
-0.0291963071,
-0.0406388454,
0.0248346385,
-0.0119249364,
-0.0136312917,
0.020539023,
-0.0059408047,
-0.0020405839,
-0.0001932456,
-0.0072292592,
0.0212479979,
-0.0103797987,
0.0214163195,
0.0197509322,
0.0238845218,
0.0051665166,
0.0486476831,
0.001760166,
0.020712411,
0.0350433029,
-0.0038920434,
0.0115059409,
0.0589360334,
-0.0475031137,
0.0129729826,
-0.0017012052,
-0.0606989935,
-0.0354790017,
0.0599323511,
0.0778393075,
-0.0200020354,
0.0397740975,
0.0038046127,
-0.0300272591,
-0.0318287723,
-0.0101186531,
-0.0061712214,
-0.0198815651,
-0.0011560813,
-0.0149469785,
-0.0541448072,
-0.0439908579,
0.046370063,
-0.0308003984,
0.0133512001,
-0.0138540203,
0.066938594,
-0.0277949758,
-0.0168368351,
-0.0329719186,
-0.0072430014,
0.0195305068,
-0.0080124084,
-0.026753759,
0.017942246,
-0.0065777102,
0.0492300652,
0.0371948704,
-0.027110273,
0.0686657503,
0.0368740857,
0.0123129804,
0.0649483576,
0.06460125,
-0.0107379258,
0.0602331236,
-0.003342734,
-0.0609870069,
-0.0151432995,
0.0204694439,
0.0237198807,
0.0997199267,
0.0375106521,
0.12615107,
0.0134655368,
0.0404728688,
-0.01567089,
0.0769343376,
-0.063648127,
0.0214926172,
0.0132096494,
0.0202898551,
0.00368215,
0.0394310392,
-0.0575150028,
0.0053416891,
-0.06811364,
-0.0252333693,
0.007950454,
0.0662479624,
-0.0777865872,
0.0632835254,
0.0426129662,
-0.0046316795,
0.0032023226,
0.0029149742,
0.0011033526,
0.0340776257,
-0.0086658318,
-0.0187948737,
-0.0173292011,
-0.0435727946,
0.0951149985,
0.0021396633,
-0.0024035827,
0.0083345678,
-0.024787128,
-0.0150296614,
-0.0405285247,
-0.0025457791,
-0.012896114,
-0.0132974833,
-0.0211166758,
-0.0298605375,
0.0264374483,
-0.0042502363,
-0.0667647496,
0.0028633429,
0.0208878517,
0.0308551937,
0.0236966852,
-0.0558071993,
0.0217260588,
0.0377008058,
0.0149577083,
0.042077411,
-0.0350492448,
-0.101192072,
0.0285490416,
-0.0294876508,
-0.05073772,
0.0110099968,
2.516e-7,
0.0125528397,
0.0240036063,
0.0411207527,
0.008349427,
-0.047487624,
0.0646605492,
-0.0027748891,
0.0275370218,
-0.0319769531,
-0.0651174337,
0.0289642438,
0.0397225358,
0.0153846508,
-0.0072087105,
-0.008270422,
0.0140314475,
-0.0493504852,
0.0310535245,
-0.0283115711,
0.0089754984,
0.0832705498,
0.0639192536,
-0.0196054205,
-0.0320276655,
0.0187265109,
-0.0581288561,
0.0781763792,
-0.0287177321,
-0.0502718911,
0.0143870823,
0.0098809712,
0.0341814235,
-0.0403328426,
0.0420017131,
-0.0179205947,
-0.0383972526,
0.0996608362,
-0.0012854434,
-0.0125204735,
-0.0550130047,
-0.0529190525,
0.011938354,
-0.0032404605,
-0.0325432643,
0.0655823126,
-0.0270893611,
-0.0099015981,
-0.0654913411,
-0.0412705615,
0.058555413,
0.0143376198,
-0.0412307717,
-0.072853826,
-0.0046973764,
0.020756036,
0.0299153719,
-0.0384136662,
-0.0754916668,
-0.0124545693,
-0.0198109206,
-0.0258292984,
0.0147206839,
-0.0614667237,
-0.0579893515,
0.0490956381,
-0.0587416328,
-0.0106882323,
1.789753171e-34,
0.0207986012,
-0.020328356,
-0.0025252451,
0.0154124023,
0.015855778,
-0.0127031505,
-0.0319656208,
-0.016384678,
-0.0289921071,
-0.0343227237,
-0.0153498827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04725v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04725v1 | EPA: Easy Prompt Augmentation on Large Language Models via Multiple Sources and Multiple Targets | 2023-09-09T09:03:50 | 2023-09-09T09:03:50 | Hongyuan Lu, Wai Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown promising performance on various NLP
tasks via task prompting. And their performance can be further improved by
appending task demonstrations to the head of the prompt. And usually, a better
performance can be achieved with more demonstrations. However, asking the users
to write the demonstrations can be cumbersome. As a simple yet cost-effective
workaround, this paper proposes a novel method called EPA (\textbf{E}asy
\textbf{P}rompt \textbf{A}ugmentation)\footnote{While this paper considers
augmenting prompts via demonstrations, we name it EPA as the name EDA is
already taken by a well-known NLP method \citep{wei-zou-2019-eda}.} that
effectively minimizes user efforts in writing demonstrations while improving
the model performance at the same time. EPA achieves these goals by
automatically augmenting the demonstrations with multiple sources/targets,
where each of them paraphrases each other. This is well motivated as augmenting
data via paraphrasing effectively improves neural language models. EPA thus
employs paraphrasing as an augmentation method for in-context learning.
Extensive experiments indicate that EPA effectively improves both NLU and NLG
tasks, covering from natural language inference to machine translation in
translating tens of languages.\footnote{Code and data will be released upon
publication.} | [
0.0303645432,
0.0504454784,
-0.0008381669,
0.0326109454,
-0.0446259081,
-0.0019362181,
0.0303498879,
-0.0096890545,
-0.0098499684,
-0.0420816205,
-0.032817211,
-0.0075017619,
0.0045353449,
-0.0204325914,
0.0675477535,
-0.0838581622,
0.0344909057,
-0.0488022231,
-0.022217242,
-0.0049069412,
0.0023487606,
0.0174474679,
-0.0232694242,
0.0443085916,
0.0193287469,
-0.004573978,
-0.0371001177,
0.0095620556,
0.0112778237,
-0.0235200394,
-0.0017709081,
0.0382850319,
0.0098080188,
0.0082812123,
0.0000022342,
-0.039047353,
-0.0260516945,
-0.0048864968,
-0.0674712658,
0.044854641,
0.0707387775,
-0.0175826661,
0.0227035936,
0.0209825877,
-0.0401940159,
-0.0346203782,
0.0294275973,
0.046298489,
0.0945069343,
0.0592847839,
0.0107792411,
0.0011342815,
-0.0089690937,
-0.0589562282,
0.0107750185,
-0.0140604982,
0.0183873922,
-0.050061956,
0.0566192903,
0.0421996005,
0.0086957822,
0.0479561128,
0.0480036885,
0.0002040839,
-0.0080666775,
0.0222501028,
-0.016493408,
-0.0185564477,
-0.0321766175,
0.0760351643,
0.0068221926,
-0.0247036405,
-0.0069248728,
-0.0114043411,
0.0212461092,
0.0230434258,
-0.0760577992,
0.0355824791,
0.0128752142,
0.0071737431,
0.0057882303,
0.012396019,
0.0276869889,
0.0305816755,
0.0042869984,
0.0562746711,
0.0227376204,
-0.0254267361,
-0.00769844,
0.0119497599,
-0.0305316281,
-0.0570254177,
-0.0012254954,
0.0288323667,
-0.0488579795,
0.0210244898,
-0.0684709921,
-0.0736590624,
0.0229783915,
0.007215505,
0.0810533091,
0.0339699239,
-0.008361252,
0.0441029146,
-0.0372065715,
0.0521905385,
-0.0326395705,
0.04942232,
-0.0597685911,
0.0057647489,
-0.0190547034,
0.0107806567,
-0.0717493221,
0.0293719992,
-0.0507089719,
-0.0231122561,
-0.0503975824,
0.0275343843,
-0.0104703056,
0.010037329,
0.0065786615,
-0.0038295125,
-0.0574668236,
0.0125294812,
0.0142544629,
0.0189923719,
-0.0566769391,
0.0150235733,
0.0200325828,
-0.0587425567,
-0.0611654185,
0.0029032864,
0.0234839413,
-0.0303931683,
-0.0026398171,
0.0821522474,
0.005248684,
-0.0634464845,
-0.0196406562,
-0.0145185003,
-0.0299493056,
-0.0385640189,
-0.0044378429,
-0.0708256364,
0.062574096,
-0.0296263304,
-0.0146040656,
-0.0398682728,
0.0121155474,
0.0426795669,
-0.0219422039,
0.0736977682,
-0.0226978511,
0.0036679234,
0.0133947395,
-0.0041327407,
-0.0721652061,
0.0489275903,
0.0325811543,
0.0149123129,
0.039457798,
0.0398538895,
0.0060025752,
0.0378362052,
0.0459850654,
0.0432338119,
-0.0080657834,
-0.0198742542,
0.023003418,
0.036750026,
0.0158495344,
0.0481536724,
-0.0441461354,
0.0390020572,
0.052668035,
0.022261139,
-0.0242596455,
-0.0248157158,
0.062998049,
0.0107250782,
0.0237654541,
0.0061544366,
-0.0435403809,
-0.0063369074,
0.0003582014,
0.0323960595,
0.0329980925,
0.0230228752,
-0.0226461608,
-0.0370474048,
0.0136740506,
-0.0214130841,
0.0231060591,
0.0328497738,
0.0256141201,
0.0529407449,
-0.0343568735,
0.0281665046,
0.0424574465,
-0.0556674302,
0.0131850243,
-0.0440120921,
0.0316719487,
0.0497981124,
0.03274443,
-0.0282036811,
-0.0318004042,
-0.0408238098,
0.0433864258,
0.0231640432,
0.0215831175,
-0.0237313472,
0.0098879253,
-0.0316615812,
-0.0171450283,
-0.0543236248,
0.0176565554,
0.0029041176,
0.0574022159,
-0.0020050642,
0.0302145556,
-0.020878043,
-0.0449635983,
0.0475407541,
-0.0592744797,
-0.0266009048,
0.0175730716,
0.0237662718,
0.001420865,
0.0404081307,
0.0046472419,
0.0097221928,
0.0237384066,
-0.0463542305,
-0.0041286913,
0.0214864835,
-0.0373850465,
-0.0675341189,
0.0384365954,
0.0031680071,
-0.015511414,
0.0134765748,
-0.0447024219,
-0.0503107794,
-0.0420584008,
-0.0321555696,
0.0467328876,
-0.0295399223,
0.0468867309,
-0.0000772719,
0.0016551106,
-0.029985331,
0.0480208844,
0.011419286,
0.0177005939,
0.0843317136,
0.0206887554,
0.0076270881,
-0.0394039601,
-0.0262556989,
-0.0140711721,
0.0405527875,
0.0080714328,
0.0031718789,
0.0158521999,
-0.039417766,
-0.0030725745,
-0.0977629796,
0.0230964329,
-0.0244639777,
0.0054073972,
0.0380930379,
0.0402483977,
-0.0222332235,
-0.0416954681,
0.0007750691,
-0.0582001247,
-0.0119759515,
0.0108663095,
0.0393082909,
0.0413320884,
-0.0104243988,
-0.0234880541,
0.0056876568,
0.0049347016,
0.0624093488,
0.0181847364,
-0.0411677733,
-0.0770040229,
0.0144269327,
0.023168074,
0.0243603252,
-0.0085754758,
-0.0004025945,
-0.0087730912,
-0.0069803144,
0.0587979257,
0.0729730576,
-0.0057699517,
0.0075442418,
0.0309238024,
0.0238836315,
-0.0703397989,
0.0100687612,
-0.0108701112,
-0.0027587912,
0.008280443,
-0.0298925936,
0.0224597398,
0.0245422348,
0.0099469218,
-0.0203410927,
-0.04252946,
0.0185905881,
-0.0190207642,
-0.017640369,
-0.0217307322,
-0.060084112,
-0.0485699512,
-0.0044858926,
-0.0300092306,
-0.0451110676,
0.0885793865,
-0.0786487907,
-0.0238697771,
-0.049311392,
-0.0144246174,
-0.0259945914,
0.0380451158,
-0.0009265933,
0.0265138783,
-0.0017195184,
-0.0246197768,
-0.0361557789,
0.0232842602,
0.0014562247,
-0.0058728368,
0.0635155365,
-0.0736259967,
0.0048963134,
0.0069182254,
-0.0648648366,
-0.0584970564,
-0.0671585649,
-0.0074880458,
0.0110518811,
-0.0436592177,
-0.015383401,
-0.0226949863,
-0.0451907665,
0.0534738749,
0.0789003149,
-0.0414845236,
0.0048018778,
-0.053737767,
-0.0035840387,
0.0629942641,
0.042154856,
-0.0153327184,
-0.0642847046,
-0.0028872862,
0.0227941796,
0.0688107312,
0.0040173344,
-0.0272089429,
-0.0249157436,
0.0135938767,
-0.048621282,
-0.0178240053,
0.0000828307,
0.0617830344,
-0.0529511161,
0.0072783013,
0.1066652387,
0.0082990509,
-0.0354059264,
0.0217272416,
0.0023890329,
0.0338675231,
0.0029558833,
0.0390433371,
-0.070824191,
-0.0340692885,
0.0168686267,
0.0543081611,
0.0406952538,
-0.0025423483,
-0.0212588441,
-0.1450937837,
0.0313731767,
0.0030583653,
-0.0377028137,
-0.026834337,
-0.0230307411,
0.0256518628,
0.0142669743,
0.0513061509,
-0.0025502304,
-0.0143521624,
0.0308232941,
0.018755706,
0.0277363099,
-0.0846192539,
-0.0271691103,
-0.0669372678,
0.0426150821,
0.0334077552,
0.0041661756,
0.0079477383,
-0.0269057415,
0.0192307215,
-0.0067592529,
-0.006619819,
0.0046971124,
0.0520928502,
-0.012017821,
-0.0178811997,
0.0168169402,
0.0585077554,
0.0008792973,
-0.0122431535,
0.0304197781,
0.0577617437,
-0.000905667,
0.0319966897,
0.0181962643,
-0.0201375913,
0.030540986,
0.0588486567,
0.0389737189,
-0.0519067384,
0.0026037053,
-0.0207399335,
-0.0441767983,
-0.0633007959,
-0.0135293268,
0.0265498105,
-0.0310423039,
0.0022910307,
-0.0899311081,
-0.0484116748,
0.0424851887,
0.0701432675,
0.0305139646,
0.037362352,
-0.02420846,
-0.014374448,
-0.0032927506,
0.0394087508,
-0.0373215415,
0.0352448784,
-0.0246605109,
-0.0303200707,
0.034522064,
-0.0234800428,
-0.0117791826,
0.0184199773,
-0.0812792256,
-0.0635564104,
-0.0155799109,
0.0622886755,
0.0163133442,
0.0721450448,
-0.0334874131,
-0.0306797531,
0.0386141092,
0.0347891562,
-0.0302480124,
0.0256818254,
0.0176434331,
0.016447736,
-0.0105891107,
0.0404032096,
-0.0265548509,
-0.0154537363,
0.0155796632,
0.0474406332,
-0.0106795421,
-0.0488134474,
0.0307445657,
0.039965231,
0.0418535396,
-0.0396306626,
-0.0233907104,
-0.0368110016,
0.0376775526,
-0.0116661862,
-0.0334925614,
-0.0503238253,
0.0374421701,
0.0007461585,
-0.0075583109,
0.0138893342,
-0.0203829743,
0.0074095493,
0.0040133372,
-0.0559676625,
0.0101231812,
-0.0009381907,
-0.013040497,
0.0118974848,
0.0217292476,
-0.0231304597,
0.0044389409,
-0.0275914092,
0.0197660644,
-0.0447249487,
0.0427069515,
0.0570086874,
-0.0351536348,
-0.0306119993,
0.0574104823,
-0.0724679828,
-0.0190343801,
-0.0059393728,
0.0706414729,
0.0531903952,
-0.0125853186,
0.0679008067,
-0.0327620283,
-0.0117303971,
0.0157554522,
0.0416532457,
-0.0107946778,
-0.0365715288,
0.0289152749,
0.0037041283,
0.0146599086,
0.0214471314,
0.0651480556,
-0.0184313115,
0.0499370024,
0.0093782693,
0.0362464562,
-0.0522333309,
-0.0588024482,
0.0115799457,
0.0142963286,
-0.0399013385,
0.0045235213,
-0.0033501654,
-0.0441297255,
-0.0074884114,
0.0157800186,
-0.0466630906,
-0.0354398377,
0.057927493,
0.0386651605,
-0.0265969038,
-0.0233588405,
-0.0401738994,
0.0147863794,
0.0289586131,
-0.0241848845,
-0.0291825645,
-6.433433562e-33,
-0.0259563662,
-0.0041527324,
0.0100331819,
-0.019003734,
-0.0393427536,
-0.006133907,
-0.0312534198,
-0.0009162025,
-0.0090755932,
-0.017143853,
-0.0389456525,
-0.003820345,
0.0296889357,
0.0282251872,
0.0120652188,
-0.0219092425,
0.0497517847,
-0.0105504626,
-0.0369172208,
0.0230265018,
-0.0129526807,
0.0339169651,
0.0488614589,
-0.0557875484,
0.0588553362,
-0.0098985452,
-0.0271479022,
-0.0079588154,
-0.0156566594,
0.0290033445,
-0.0089813741,
0.0273821205,
-0.001418273,
-0.0511434823,
-0.0343074091,
0.0282064341,
-0.0694976375,
-0.0117121236,
0.0405915082,
0.0191579852,
-0.0903594792,
-0.0323703252,
0.0307582077,
-0.035136316,
0.0372637473,
0.0469274744,
0.0075250724,
-0.033385504,
-0.0129732853,
0.0408950746,
-0.0362596959,
-0.0019660234,
0.0314374603,
-0.0069668177,
0.0076073296,
0.0572618842,
-0.0105594415,
-0.0079121739,
-0.0505432971,
0.0092378706,
0.0355505683,
0.0367988236,
0.0382661112,
0.0031776337,
-0.0117265061,
0.0398635492,
-0.0327399187,
-0.0260808803,
-0.0196649823,
-0.0173665285,
0.0186669491,
0.0153190633,
0.0337301418,
0.0309199523,
0.0067545422,
0.0382348709,
-0.0208319295,
0.0266434215,
0.0630375445,
-0.0044163014,
0.0394318588,
-0.0125361318,
-0.041173283,
-0.0261164717,
-0.0318284072,
0.017453324,
-0.0176478028,
-0.0513246767,
0.0480919406,
0.0402558781,
-0.0450994484,
-0.0006586358,
0.0122868996,
-0.0234344918,
-0.0265814941,
0.0019862892,
-0.0180685315,
0.0359322876,
-0.0170606915,
0.0051131728,
-0.0339735523,
-0.032961823,
0.0112610292,
0.0304376967,
0.021711804,
-0.0009158892,
0.0547394082,
0.0292500928,
-0.0741357431,
0.0433554351,
-0.0276812017,
0.0347698294,
0.0192512721,
-0.0237330236,
0.0489626974,
0.0242854636,
-0.0158232525,
0.0439132079,
0.0265724715,
-0.0435700156,
-0.018979298,
0.0141961398,
0.0136354174,
0.0167779941,
-0.0370538794,
0.0107238181,
-0.0198033601,
0.0470014252,
-0.0174213536,
-0.0466447249,
-0.0105902655,
-0.0144797098,
2.92e-7,
0.0414000973,
0.0132925268,
0.0308382064,
0.0456013195,
-0.0212393738,
0.0081343567,
-0.0202135853,
0.0040770732,
-0.0113022579,
-0.0058521018,
0.0124989646,
0.0313109942,
0.0465917066,
-0.0239556972,
-0.1518866122,
-0.0477957055,
-0.0468033217,
0.0245440993,
-0.0571926311,
-0.0208196044,
0.0408248752,
0.107496053,
0.0268456992,
0.0032122168,
-0.0223988369,
-0.0408221483,
0.0574680604,
-0.013265525,
-0.0033554819,
0.0147921955,
0.0074503073,
0.0086322157,
-0.0239454079,
0.0279941466,
-0.0027684278,
0.0264054295,
0.0240911674,
0.0595936812,
0.0235621333,
0.0279475264,
-0.0014015666,
-0.0184522383,
0.0013297667,
-0.0543770082,
0.068638742,
-0.0539235733,
0.0096415933,
-0.012048075,
0.0088440776,
-0.0065828911,
-0.0003888801,
-0.0316014588,
-0.0267403349,
0.0114175463,
0.0242841039,
-0.0131110633,
-0.0365459956,
-0.0768101588,
-0.038493488,
-0.0086146751,
-0.039520517,
-0.0294198878,
-0.0219724085,
-0.0079525169,
-0.0041945353,
-0.0919338316,
-0.0066301529,
2.974835033e-34,
0.0255879369,
-0.0038853264,
0.0389720313,
0.0349490643,
0.0112490077,
-0.0097346492,
0.0179233775,
-0.001265388,
0.0249235425,
-0.0542459227,
-0.0556809157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04716v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04716v1 | Toward Reproducing Network Research Results Using Large Language Models | 2023-09-09T08:07:54 | 2023-09-09T08:07:54 | Qiao Xiang, Yuling Lin, Mingjun Fang, Bang Huang, Siyong Huang, Ridi Wen, Franck Le, Linghe Kong, Jiwu Shu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Reproducing research results in the networking community is important for
both academia and industry. The current best practice typically resorts to
three approaches: (1) looking for publicly available prototypes; (2) contacting
the authors to get a private prototype; and (3) manually implementing a
prototype following the description of the publication. However, most published
network research does not have public prototypes and private prototypes are
hard to get. As such, most reproducing efforts are spent on manual
implementation based on the publications, which is both time and labor
consuming and error-prone. In this paper, we boldly propose reproducing network
research results using the emerging large language models (LLMs). In
particular, we first prove its feasibility with a small-scale experiment, in
which four students with essential networking knowledge each reproduces a
different networking system published in prominent conferences and journals by
prompt engineering ChatGPT. We report the experiment's observations and lessons
and discuss future open research questions of this proposal. This work raises
no ethical issue. | [
0.0177602042,
0.0532275327,
-0.0167548265,
0.0333861038,
-0.0924273208,
-0.0574428774,
0.0656379014,
0.0243026372,
0.0171070956,
-0.0291840453,
0.0080008218,
0.0076578083,
-0.0083638765,
0.0704174712,
0.0282084141,
0.0186404549,
-0.0077940891,
0.0057613053,
-0.0536952578,
0.0023507066,
0.0216273461,
0.0065085823,
0.0430884138,
0.0256474297,
0.0527103394,
-0.0029468539,
-0.0212715268,
-0.0134668518,
-0.0338312276,
-0.0056340182,
0.0308214687,
0.0486420169,
0.014777218,
0.0446009226,
0.00000188,
-0.0425882563,
-0.032147862,
0.064457044,
-0.0197496712,
0.0696069077,
0.0324809663,
0.0087073883,
-0.0164520945,
0.0272339974,
-0.0098809525,
-0.0028984859,
0.0469468124,
0.0016604254,
0.0079001626,
0.0006014461,
0.0093882931,
-0.018202031,
0.0003158467,
-0.0005103662,
-0.0298813935,
-0.0037559092,
0.0305899736,
0.0542588122,
0.060170155,
0.0506355837,
0.0086058183,
-0.0292320065,
0.0135665722,
-0.0296621248,
0.0026627362,
0.0424292572,
-0.0335937291,
-0.0095107732,
-0.0220476501,
0.0246561933,
0.0338830464,
-0.0508210994,
0.0597788095,
0.0294625703,
-0.0443870015,
0.0401023924,
-0.0466440916,
-0.0160839222,
0.0345897079,
-0.0048702694,
-0.0670402572,
-0.0108467499,
0.0087715331,
0.0150779746,
0.0148049416,
0.0477466807,
0.0199209806,
-0.015196776,
-0.0578045882,
0.0026451112,
0.0487757586,
-0.0226434134,
0.0546440743,
-0.0120811081,
0.021894902,
-0.0134694101,
0.0336865373,
0.0116093792,
0.0576279573,
-0.0006470696,
0.015436179,
-0.029357627,
0.0102106277,
0.0296884328,
-0.0152795548,
-0.0049675726,
-0.0813468099,
0.0276129674,
0.002930921,
0.0264055878,
-0.0551550277,
-0.0003748797,
0.0058928072,
0.0481304154,
-0.0129315313,
-0.0136653483,
-0.0306778941,
0.0411824919,
-0.0009896889,
0.0448926538,
-0.052589871,
-0.0215815119,
-0.0097406935,
-0.0211297516,
0.0147741931,
-0.0030482251,
0.03854784,
0.0143626975,
-0.0047320309,
-0.0364413001,
0.0125747267,
0.0034485834,
-0.0071709519,
0.013531914,
0.0033086464,
0.1108043566,
0.0084171426,
0.0098131914,
0.0416079499,
-0.068055056,
0.0335132778,
-0.0045760814,
-0.0330596454,
-0.1047899053,
0.0020995634,
0.0391178876,
0.009779457,
0.00242972,
-0.0370565839,
-0.0720993206,
-0.0095894886,
0.0352329165,
-0.0251207873,
0.0240791161,
0.0130154686,
0.00654377,
0.0224819966,
-0.0136938663,
-0.0032423981,
0.0205510929,
0.0455910861,
-0.0155377556,
0.0214717761,
0.0392237045,
0.0345342234,
0.015523579,
-0.0118611865,
0.0125817172,
0.0856289938,
0.0159144606,
-0.0579961948,
0.0796266496,
-0.0400860049,
0.0244362336,
0.0430134758,
0.0610617064,
0.0419954881,
0.0052466141,
-0.0239662603,
0.0611231253,
-0.0006670745,
-0.0429468751,
-0.0397595651,
0.0129146529,
0.0093323058,
0.0011595257,
0.0320299678,
0.0296762791,
-0.0055022519,
0.0257154591,
0.0099096755,
-0.0148418192,
-0.0100917453,
-0.00195231,
0.051996246,
-0.0014753875,
-0.0250002313,
0.0138700604,
0.0202580336,
-0.0265706647,
0.0084633008,
-0.0489576794,
0.01439403,
0.0425056331,
0.0946009532,
-0.0032355126,
0.0548762754,
-0.0009281543,
0.0084544756,
0.007161397,
0.0654249415,
-0.0123337889,
-0.0706192926,
-0.0182882082,
-0.0032091588,
0.0467185341,
0.0089486148,
-0.0058893333,
0.0178617276,
0.0017997485,
-0.0225916114,
-0.0513977148,
-0.0780302733,
-0.0203158092,
-0.06470263,
0.0552845113,
-0.0516219363,
-0.0198844057,
0.0445704795,
0.0226333905,
-0.0331929773,
-0.0012124828,
0.0190671254,
0.0050958218,
-0.0356058888,
-0.0283449646,
0.0457418896,
0.0720199198,
0.0021384151,
-0.0902041793,
0.0251357965,
0.0677172244,
-0.0409456082,
0.0075994153,
0.0607817806,
0.003656344,
0.050202094,
0.0287656244,
0.0009729975,
-0.0531258807,
-0.0131683946,
-0.0024224925,
-0.0339084677,
0.0487716049,
0.0287012346,
-0.0248881429,
-0.0174458884,
0.0320899338,
-0.0322696231,
-0.006137915,
0.0294692796,
-0.0113873398,
0.0613419116,
0.0249850452,
-0.0022411635,
-0.0103674978,
-0.0338431485,
-0.0414701067,
0.0109162899,
-0.0087876897,
0.049510058,
0.0684238076,
0.0218865275,
0.0047924966,
-0.0136704054,
-0.0081213731,
0.0336582735,
0.0021768317,
0.0015485991,
0.0354288965,
-0.0107824709,
-0.0772683844,
-0.0509803034,
-0.0625861809,
-0.0045462707,
0.0771971643,
0.0295445099,
-0.0152991628,
-0.0666833967,
0.0225785952,
-0.0371750109,
-0.0297812205,
-0.0133414492,
-0.0435303822,
0.029556185,
0.0191482995,
-0.0212692581,
-0.0170754325,
-0.0053131161,
0.0006090052,
0.0221275687,
0.0198902525,
-0.0943317711,
-0.0318288691,
-0.0542309359,
-0.0449893288,
-0.0371977948,
-0.0565833561,
0.0259627402,
0.0190380942,
-0.0147618633,
-0.022440929,
0.0064430968,
-0.0215569846,
0.0006280345,
0.0382031575,
-0.046913594,
-0.0326005891,
0.0041248603,
0.0368826725,
0.0161605459,
-0.0304758474,
0.039619606,
-0.0512604713,
-0.0020624991,
-0.0507918671,
-0.0483380482,
-0.0324599668,
0.0614292361,
-0.0080912849,
0.032754235,
-0.0340083241,
-0.0007736215,
-0.0190349501,
-0.0031539788,
0.0224156734,
-0.052278813,
-0.0062961839,
-0.0079202913,
0.014801668,
-0.0356609896,
-0.0226757266,
-0.0032312833,
-0.0190005619,
-0.0241972078,
-0.0023249805,
0.0396769531,
0.0105457744,
-0.0077130133,
0.0723254532,
0.0608991906,
0.0405426584,
0.02798458,
0.0013635566,
-0.0121171214,
-0.008659441,
-0.0051364531,
-0.0420792177,
0.0351015404,
0.0264681596,
-0.0128120901,
0.0566505194,
0.0255376212,
0.0251586959,
-0.0243139658,
-0.0235979371,
0.0264878049,
-0.0346728079,
-0.0011512815,
0.0372086279,
0.0307402331,
-0.0133820074,
-0.0039506219,
0.0341247283,
0.0144176045,
-0.095824644,
0.0049176728,
-0.0096072555,
0.0262000449,
0.0146537395,
0.0438313298,
-0.1003451347,
0.0494240746,
-0.011035311,
0.03118423,
-0.0096572591,
-0.0245880932,
0.002096016,
-0.0754396245,
0.0585356429,
0.0258727185,
-0.0438055061,
0.0228973608,
-0.1000719145,
0.0151659111,
0.0163262021,
0.0266095679,
0.0228899624,
0.038767349,
-0.0250277556,
0.0080658188,
-0.0524764806,
-0.1013488322,
0.0315759592,
0.0077892635,
0.0872749314,
-0.0343115069,
-0.0057860506,
-0.0375019424,
0.0027409613,
0.0408421904,
0.0146110253,
-0.0373199135,
0.0143321659,
-0.0263294764,
0.0493003614,
-0.0260975212,
-0.0475205854,
0.0146664223,
-0.0409986079,
-0.0127569623,
-0.0043849605,
0.0481351279,
-0.0148638217,
-0.0391122699,
-0.0418038107,
-0.0204750653,
0.0345835127,
0.0302624051,
-0.0068868743,
-0.0357872061,
-0.0324599966,
-0.0238241702,
-0.0299974289,
0.0351214334,
-0.0644464344,
-0.0381104909,
-0.0022820728,
0.0258829836,
-0.0140610095,
0.0303933192,
0.0215905774,
0.0158505309,
0.0331089199,
-0.0056796949,
0.064121455,
-0.0420624055,
-0.0125763929,
-0.0168288276,
-0.0488227978,
0.0033984578,
-0.0692648888,
0.0188972745,
0.0388875529,
-0.0089883823,
-0.0300104506,
-0.0080135837,
-0.0423078239,
-0.0802318081,
0.0155116338,
0.0118721332,
0.0361793637,
0.0195118878,
-0.0262636021,
-0.0406820811,
-0.0244420208,
0.0337414183,
-0.0140367746,
0.0131229963,
-0.0143130766,
-0.0486666746,
-0.0195421763,
-0.0302303657,
-0.0830048844,
0.029976733,
0.0395989753,
-0.0272385962,
-0.020831611,
-0.0632288679,
0.0267865844,
0.0638801232,
-0.0121921478,
0.0027584585,
0.0113595724,
0.0160145219,
-0.006821041,
-0.0103639383,
-0.0045611784,
-0.0108590247,
-0.0618740171,
-0.0028032653,
0.0076106642,
0.0620366894,
0.0367752425,
0.0063749617,
0.0502155274,
-0.0096344519,
0.035287831,
-0.0195745993,
-0.0149736684,
0.0791650712,
-0.0096365763,
-0.0346037373,
-0.0179462377,
-0.024390338,
0.0772345066,
-0.0344501361,
-0.0294797886,
0.0131260799,
-0.0392753147,
-0.0094532846,
0.0400096625,
-0.0430602022,
-0.065791443,
0.0051174061,
0.0447064117,
0.016259579,
0.0970954522,
0.0067357593,
-0.0730869696,
0.0200001393,
-0.0640799105,
0.0275304355,
-0.0397532247,
-0.0148193669,
0.0312060714,
0.0093931453,
0.0093379291,
0.0398209058,
0.0199762844,
0.0416634195,
-0.042165786,
-0.0060789734,
-0.0221306756,
-0.0180853717,
-0.0147126261,
0.0360754728,
0.0036985609,
-0.0579308532,
-0.0664134324,
-0.0176897123,
-0.0242353883,
-0.0200370569,
0.0131737804,
0.0380055234,
-0.037903782,
-0.004420076,
0.0663122833,
0.033621639,
0.0257300008,
-0.0139234615,
0.0094333645,
-0.0197339356,
-0.0423351303,
0.0440439172,
-6.159388728e-33,
0.0608510487,
-0.0356472135,
0.0174533743,
-0.0068430337,
0.0043300563,
0.0188507959,
-0.0370162614,
-0.0319075994,
-0.0129481554,
-0.0028099609,
-0.0067983945,
0.009226582,
0.0309682861,
0.0074333502,
0.0194838382,
0.0325234048,
0.0333440118,
-0.008417001,
-0.0373998731,
0.0269725043,
0.0019718611,
-0.0159237348,
-0.0058309687,
-0.0534657463,
0.0246537905,
-0.0889796168,
0.0142222112,
0.0033049753,
0.0051069316,
0.0509549156,
0.0040374245,
0.0280960221,
-0.0099952361,
-0.0507797785,
-0.0181296039,
-0.0138651188,
-0.0263093226,
0.0573105849,
0.0149142994,
-0.0005466082,
-0.0043228292,
0.0314089619,
0.0115656005,
-0.0175233968,
-0.0391255021,
0.014720954,
-0.0232217126,
0.0453685895,
-0.0457925461,
0.0621881224,
-0.0003114761,
-0.0354467183,
-0.0075540752,
0.0635650754,
0.0195607189,
-0.0725461468,
-0.0303451251,
-0.0315011255,
-0.0373103507,
0.038241297,
-0.0182663035,
-0.0140598482,
0.0236593504,
-0.0160058308,
-0.0233169552,
0.0038197408,
0.0017585757,
0.0444877744,
0.0324075706,
-0.0116632292,
0.0138347028,
0.0352259241,
0.0496292226,
0.0526362993,
-0.0557910651,
-0.0176528972,
-0.0326246135,
-0.0296784826,
0.0162136164,
-0.0408418365,
0.0462268665,
0.0256357193,
-0.0097650327,
-0.0469000228,
-0.0044198968,
-0.0108788041,
-0.0156717729,
-0.0549377613,
-0.017170066,
0.0072442777,
-0.0298173409,
0.0191045217,
0.0484099239,
-0.0496511273,
-0.0739125684,
0.0176451728,
0.0293345787,
0.054668434,
-0.0056746942,
0.0043207537,
-0.0806859285,
-0.0144135375,
-0.0487185679,
0.0290450975,
-0.0029169226,
0.0051772348,
0.0093806861,
0.02111426,
-0.0405970216,
0.0514100567,
-0.020913044,
0.0050488156,
-0.0002223915,
-0.0521658659,
0.0182015374,
0.0011311814,
0.0610839725,
-0.0106125204,
0.0133937923,
-0.0206148382,
-0.0066043702,
0.0497765243,
-0.0362629257,
0.0270632431,
-0.0159802418,
0.0108936587,
-0.0731095225,
0.1009071246,
0.0746093541,
0.0255369358,
-0.0102968514,
-0.0324430689,
2.793e-7,
0.006466778,
0.0185910501,
0.0225807186,
0.0219528731,
0.0550885424,
-0.0084474934,
-0.0039339373,
0.0619764775,
0.0301698931,
-0.0021717602,
-0.0235995948,
-0.0067678182,
0.0253868978,
0.0056354431,
-0.0887479484,
-0.0098117692,
-0.0994976163,
-0.0010910546,
-0.0502657965,
-0.0369316973,
0.0217614006,
0.0058465335,
0.0253047179,
0.034464065,
-0.0171555001,
-0.044732485,
-0.0040390175,
-0.0241062175,
-0.0140384352,
0.0484709144,
-0.0017066875,
0.0302248523,
-0.0054868823,
0.0220553763,
-0.0208400916,
-0.0544876233,
-0.0327855609,
0.0151171843,
0.0370195024,
0.0657965392,
-0.0196084064,
-0.085203737,
-0.0230310876,
-0.0531913228,
-0.014168757,
-0.0464981049,
-0.0498572849,
0.0169235356,
-0.0133939721,
-0.1103310287,
-0.0054456801,
0.0091708861,
0.0386955217,
0.0038523332,
-0.0545155741,
0.001949588,
-0.0110251456,
-0.0308498293,
0.0182656534,
0.0010390955,
-0.0060665938,
-0.1062500402,
-0.0024293782,
-0.0071884384,
0.0524090119,
0.004764548,
0.0637657568,
2.354365263e-34,
0.0341695882,
0.0503128171,
0.0491825826,
0.0434375033,
0.000891227,
-0.0084983604,
0.0342954174,
-0.0064277127,
0.0032418242,
-0.0254305582,
-0.0213049501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04704v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04704v1 | Analysis of Disinformation and Fake News Detection Using Fine-Tuned Large Language Model | 2023-09-09T07:10:19 | 2023-09-09T07:10:19 | Bohdan M. Pavlyshenko | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.IR, cs.LG | The paper considers the possibility of fine-tuning Llama 2 large language
model (LLM) for the disinformation analysis and fake news detection. For
fine-tuning, the PEFT/LoRA based approach was used. In the study, the model was
fine-tuned for the following tasks: analysing a text on revealing
disinformation and propaganda narratives, fact checking, fake news detection,
manipulation analytics, extracting named entities with their sentiments. The
obtained results show that the fine-tuned Llama 2 model can perform a deep
analysis of texts and reveal complex styles and narratives. Extracted
sentiments for named entities can be considered as predictive features in
supervised machine learning models. | [
0.0711978301,
0.0120796524,
-0.0278620496,
0.0819362402,
-0.0532992594,
0.0303656217,
0.0021114408,
0.0059634871,
0.0250360034,
-0.0401978232,
-0.0167748295,
-0.0599849224,
0.0261813942,
0.055711329,
0.0299759563,
-0.0094956364,
0.0442712419,
0.0120008029,
0.0740625635,
-0.0224057101,
0.0399296544,
0.0364820585,
0.0118298065,
0.0053511239,
0.0110229757,
-0.0050103096,
0.0211008415,
-0.0050588138,
0.036402896,
0.0013684341,
0.0074690869,
0.0070017716,
0.0102456892,
0.0701028854,
0.0000017993,
-0.0213887636,
-0.0206699725,
-0.009667295,
0.0001953326,
0.0089449026,
0.1092083678,
-0.0199271347,
-0.03915428,
0.0320988223,
-0.0138187921,
-0.0299687516,
0.0162556246,
0.1006408036,
0.0767664611,
0.1266713738,
-0.0057533314,
-0.0628739893,
0.041571185,
-0.0168033596,
-0.0093070613,
-0.0082444949,
0.075406611,
-0.0334640816,
-0.0310776588,
0.0413958952,
0.017482996,
-0.0191774387,
-0.0009442252,
-0.0235267952,
-0.0335399434,
-0.0211676937,
-0.0189093128,
-0.0377826095,
0.0243814588,
0.0552015752,
-0.0506672673,
-0.0456117392,
0.0220854133,
-0.0165870041,
-0.0196688138,
0.0191160776,
0.0075468649,
0.0292120147,
-0.0262385476,
0.039254535,
0.0778919682,
-0.0492474139,
0.0237947553,
0.0440276265,
-0.0009262688,
0.0472280271,
-0.0075395475,
-0.0079659633,
0.0255997181,
-0.0307811443,
-0.0188043434,
-0.04759771,
0.0277572125,
0.0053290958,
0.0158348959,
0.0188587811,
-0.056411773,
-0.0075205453,
0.0329642408,
-0.1213639602,
-0.0107315099,
0.0102447281,
-0.0088608013,
0.0149951382,
-0.0146605382,
0.0084194364,
-0.0266641509,
0.0063485992,
-0.0321828648,
-0.0171640404,
0.000238818,
0.0023695983,
-0.000057438,
0.0615416989,
-0.0303369667,
-0.008678156,
-0.0609843917,
-0.0347189792,
-0.005534071,
0.0240271837,
-0.0220887233,
-0.0189937949,
0.0010473678,
-0.0011502139,
-0.0333268493,
0.0554279201,
-0.0012183154,
0.0505225845,
-0.041874364,
-0.0359612666,
0.0192246344,
0.0438993573,
-0.0293921959,
0.0030374392,
0.0222764034,
0.0078573236,
0.0126606431,
-0.0298242643,
-0.0669538453,
-0.0251760762,
-0.0155032268,
-0.0812679306,
0.0162806623,
-0.0674482584,
-0.0282545779,
-0.0397213921,
-0.0061816438,
-0.0283181928,
0.00273214,
0.0337641016,
-0.0531541556,
0.0341071524,
-0.0051380293,
-0.0101895211,
0.0870042667,
0.0244347788,
0.0728246719,
0.0808319747,
0.0191676095,
0.1220493093,
0.0424508266,
0.0151379136,
0.0003675826,
0.0396168269,
0.0105381459,
0.0232934728,
-0.0335107706,
-0.0065775807,
-0.0219162423,
-0.0339851417,
0.0175543446,
0.0371400788,
0.0043079541,
-0.0236316267,
0.062373668,
-0.0200611483,
0.0198263712,
0.0122892121,
0.0352430306,
0.0211092867,
0.0324979611,
0.0105989818,
-0.015230109,
0.0201859511,
-0.0399699733,
-0.0257013757,
0.0118686957,
0.054473538,
-0.0190333556,
-0.0132924682,
0.0079294872,
-0.0089269476,
-0.0332683697,
-0.0234324932,
-0.0011961327,
-0.0019945672,
-0.0550035164,
0.0212847982,
0.060725823,
0.0078858314,
-0.0081094736,
-0.0775038674,
0.0511295497,
0.0297878236,
0.0095773283,
-0.0041709673,
0.0090450374,
-0.0603933781,
-0.0064352965,
0.0410393737,
0.0106945774,
-0.0142085226,
-0.0619722605,
-0.0044888305,
-0.010497977,
-0.0526561402,
0.0231331084,
0.0047971657,
-0.018972734,
0.0359561704,
0.011924156,
-0.0209240895,
-0.0460900776,
0.0282931924,
0.0240805335,
0.0045874845,
-0.003259331,
0.0345864706,
0.0222121123,
0.0333225802,
-0.0121519482,
-0.0301905423,
0.057912536,
-0.0252578426,
-0.027297141,
-0.06611076,
0.0131916525,
-0.0275024604,
0.0071871467,
-0.0268354733,
0.0133757275,
0.0620495863,
-0.0245322939,
0.0139272073,
0.0059272586,
-0.0456284434,
-0.0054426198,
-0.0485371873,
0.0036575673,
-0.0550832972,
0.0332452394,
0.0021730787,
0.0704947412,
-0.0502321236,
0.0089170458,
-0.0199066736,
-0.0009898059,
0.0007232628,
0.0175417438,
-0.0312568322,
0.0336888172,
0.0304035228,
0.0027591228,
0.0215734653,
-0.0013433631,
0.007091858,
-0.0625510588,
-0.0301904883,
-0.0000560881,
-0.0318401717,
-0.0004503895,
0.0320756771,
-0.026129799,
-0.0163996182,
0.0458288826,
-0.0518942662,
-0.0102108,
-0.020032974,
0.0131202377,
0.0169013981,
-0.0186104532,
-0.0427802764,
-0.0106183067,
0.0407141522,
-0.0144082438,
0.0246295277,
0.0318825357,
-0.0582214147,
-0.02964315,
0.0438535772,
-0.0359777138,
-0.0002296541,
-0.0419606268,
-0.0518047623,
-0.0156876836,
0.0096471095,
0.0125534041,
0.0505508929,
0.0195954721,
0.0627290681,
0.027699545,
0.0451730117,
0.0231136382,
-0.040545702,
-0.0328596421,
0.0301023312,
-0.0353487208,
-0.0485471003,
0.0040108473,
0.0347043686,
0.0377730802,
0.0008109422,
0.0228367448,
0.0224299785,
-0.0258475784,
-0.004623068,
0.0829050317,
-0.046208825,
0.0060359109,
-0.0191041958,
-0.0194350146,
-0.0425220355,
0.0763279572,
-0.0424151011,
0.0462919883,
-0.0331686176,
-0.0495742969,
-0.0376904979,
-0.0219554044,
-0.0064823106,
0.0267865844,
-0.0128182983,
-0.0205757096,
0.0131260017,
-0.0264047924,
0.0227119755,
-0.0311010908,
0.019648036,
-0.0275385175,
0.0256466661,
0.0302323364,
0.0053256825,
-0.0483700521,
-0.1030271873,
-0.013100734,
-0.0067155426,
0.0154198967,
-0.0263185222,
-0.0570901595,
-0.0112405606,
0.0072630113,
-0.0026683321,
-0.0251770876,
0.0308542717,
-0.0039676903,
0.0318961516,
0.0605720505,
-0.0271692034,
0.0664125755,
-0.0372531712,
0.0038963803,
0.0126688685,
-0.0559460893,
0.0218371917,
-0.0138980979,
-0.012276737,
0.0025758839,
-0.0247531105,
-0.0164404791,
-0.0089523867,
-0.005165216,
-0.0581084341,
0.0246018637,
0.0968709067,
0.0126634073,
-0.0156475194,
-0.0079584252,
0.0276440643,
-0.0298963971,
0.0155950282,
-0.0016245886,
-0.052495677,
-0.0014213335,
0.0038113499,
-0.0202558469,
-0.0475210212,
-0.0196399298,
-0.0137682641,
-0.1029680446,
0.0073487666,
-0.0058550388,
0.0094577176,
-0.0722281709,
-0.0665720925,
-0.0069859875,
0.0122620929,
0.0133992862,
-0.005187091,
0.0066304277,
-0.0221433081,
-0.0137548074,
-0.0120982267,
-0.0469166301,
0.0009293348,
0.0092193978,
0.0460764207,
0.0524848364,
0.0651911944,
-0.0505330414,
-0.0139783043,
0.001870784,
-0.0101110777,
-0.0291543659,
-0.0070388434,
0.0478140526,
-0.0369029492,
-0.0368313901,
-0.0305724274,
0.0650277734,
0.0286028236,
0.0453390889,
-0.0267417487,
0.0283347871,
-0.0003682869,
-0.0812979564,
0.0067333183,
0.0217546076,
0.0256767254,
0.0456954129,
0.0074379728,
-0.0183902383,
0.0043052831,
-0.0199248251,
-0.0331790447,
0.0266892109,
-0.0431660339,
0.0290677473,
0.0084598558,
-0.0006972458,
-0.0398560651,
-0.0120880017,
0.0099177212,
0.0047214865,
-0.0148783755,
0.0653277487,
0.0198182482,
-0.0162108839,
-0.0205024369,
-0.0122716567,
-0.0216978323,
0.0773524567,
0.0004319416,
-0.0027904517,
0.0391509496,
-0.0117385425,
-0.0029904058,
0.0070123789,
-0.0886997059,
-0.0534717888,
0.0179541875,
0.0182598606,
0.0110144317,
-0.0007578648,
-0.0008204851,
-0.0732269883,
0.0648325086,
0.0459165387,
-0.0543183126,
0.0397248082,
-0.0078420974,
0.0238560382,
0.037093997,
0.0310561042,
0.0063314741,
0.0541129299,
0.0383707806,
-0.0368327871,
-0.0285752397,
-0.0391135998,
0.0136692729,
0.055401329,
0.0314647444,
-0.0056985393,
-0.017940037,
-0.0621390194,
0.0005184653,
-0.0110982191,
-0.0138667338,
0.0063896291,
0.0163063779,
0.0314972997,
-0.0124083692,
-0.0275237244,
0.0040997691,
-0.0344066098,
-0.0118667567,
-0.0206560958,
0.0452736057,
-0.0137999449,
0.0431106128,
0.0275764391,
0.008466078,
-0.0282140374,
-0.0087305782,
0.0191134382,
0.0187608171,
0.0027865912,
-0.0045157345,
0.0131640648,
-0.0172515716,
-0.0160823185,
-0.0126538221,
0.0329529382,
-0.0000079698,
-0.0374710411,
0.0537247472,
0.0391868241,
-0.0140339043,
0.0130063845,
0.0168631673,
0.0040868474,
-0.0019968054,
-0.0000702848,
-0.0017213773,
-0.0278303139,
0.0302168168,
-0.0038516587,
-0.0508110896,
0.0166688655,
0.0302989837,
0.0293341093,
0.0268540271,
0.0498298369,
-0.0130698839,
-0.0294555537,
-0.0100242682,
0.0259406585,
0.0270866305,
-0.0139414649,
0.0066380971,
-0.0695835277,
-0.0527298339,
0.0431395173,
-0.0426061302,
0.0045929551,
-0.0083302911,
0.0074113426,
0.0622548126,
-0.00087181,
0.0489311777,
-0.0636601821,
-0.0227475036,
0.004371129,
-0.0248314552,
0.0448993519,
-6.30203313e-33,
-0.0059395446,
-0.0642622635,
-0.0218064673,
0.0222789366,
-0.0367012434,
0.015202078,
0.0052768849,
-0.0310871638,
-0.0608336627,
0.0613819696,
0.0461360365,
0.0332715884,
-0.0066213347,
-0.0034902287,
-0.0885237232,
0.01078026,
0.0432824045,
0.00599337,
-0.0109085785,
0.0007953911,
0.0708466247,
0.007169947,
0.0259013232,
-0.0528020486,
0.0394059084,
-0.0284155495,
-0.0670649782,
0.0236708559,
-0.0182497539,
0.0396111533,
-0.0171386115,
0.0731657818,
0.0358909518,
-0.0539504215,
0.0295895189,
0.0453084446,
-0.0009966821,
-0.0384541601,
0.0407579951,
-0.0148300873,
0.045837976,
-0.0114271035,
0.0620504208,
0.0146539761,
0.0000065411,
0.0450455211,
0.0468365401,
-0.0205140915,
-0.0027617617,
-0.0064388704,
-0.0592635274,
0.0098976977,
0.0048805918,
0.0228604469,
-0.005760646,
-0.0004853487,
0.0204313379,
0.0261347368,
-0.0811787024,
0.0036242283,
-0.0028365587,
0.0268893726,
-0.0161323063,
-0.0309193097,
-0.0347946025,
0.0793501064,
0.0099366819,
0.0165324546,
-0.0554911941,
0.0371974744,
0.027526442,
0.0217756443,
0.0193356834,
0.0858121291,
-0.0176566932,
-0.0875918269,
-0.1194497347,
0.0149513558,
0.050011456,
0.0212513991,
0.0173928384,
-0.0481635146,
-0.0336855389,
-0.0091147739,
-0.0412778631,
0.0031906373,
-0.0395436287,
0.0020428582,
-0.012879408,
0.0233217347,
-0.0417817198,
0.0305707715,
-0.0097930841,
-0.0714228004,
0.002972065,
0.0362898894,
-0.0724453926,
0.0263075568,
-0.0056500644,
0.03736265,
-0.0734429881,
-0.0412342586,
0.0024368674,
-0.0258020405,
0.0027026213,
-0.023542922,
0.034277156,
0.0119853597,
-0.0851867199,
0.0078055277,
-0.0051967236,
0.0198416077,
0.0377977788,
0.0338187367,
0.0081752623,
-0.0168594457,
-0.02200054,
0.0154142771,
-0.0178993922,
0.0248850398,
0.0125625758,
0.0191049445,
-0.0125359353,
0.0296257176,
-0.0424776822,
-0.0085197361,
-0.003275298,
0.028874293,
0.0148518067,
-0.0851373971,
-0.0003371878,
-0.019321885,
2.676e-7,
-0.0020125117,
0.0682008564,
-0.0441344045,
0.013537785,
0.0051798061,
0.0600464046,
0.0217108447,
0.0192959607,
-0.0192246921,
-0.0641667768,
-0.0269210432,
0.0063156746,
-0.0062647955,
0.032031551,
-0.0879089311,
0.0658795983,
-0.0155662103,
-0.0253883544,
-0.043913316,
-0.0199459568,
-0.0113818031,
0.1051327363,
0.0444283672,
-0.0453127995,
-0.025248833,
-0.0053163758,
0.0488714539,
0.0416493081,
-0.0508169197,
0.0464428887,
0.0217151847,
-0.010060817,
-0.0144691579,
0.0117418915,
-0.0063332613,
0.0509143881,
-0.0112557644,
0.0616721213,
-0.0016825721,
0.0074546672,
0.0083257221,
-0.053360194,
-0.0074589169,
-0.0489758477,
0.0901945457,
-0.0102963215,
-0.0569999553,
-0.0839379206,
-0.0215802006,
0.0007849386,
0.0370564982,
-0.0452482291,
0.0104352618,
0.0449015424,
-0.0164273474,
-0.0258050356,
0.0084112985,
-0.0300323833,
0.020209305,
0.0050665238,
-0.0267474614,
-0.015732972,
-0.0091788359,
-0.0233952478,
0.050845921,
-0.016978018,
0.0808762461,
2.209859814e-34,
0.0539087169,
-0.0428782664,
-0.0288196821,
-0.0063931993,
0.0281280093,
0.0301231015,
-0.0342534445,
0.007349757,
-0.0201513264,
-0.0561521836,
0.0072729052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04695v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04695v2 | Code-Style In-Context Learning for Knowledge-Based Question Answering | 2023-09-09T06:27:00 | 2024-01-05T09:54:03 | Zhijie Nie, Richong Zhang, Zhongyuan Wang, Xudong Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Current methods for Knowledge-Based Question Answering (KBQA) usually rely on
complex training techniques and model frameworks, leading to many limitations
in practical applications. Recently, the emergence of In-Context Learning (ICL)
capabilities in Large Language Models (LLMs) provides a simple and
training-free semantic parsing paradigm for KBQA: Given a small number of
questions and their labeled logical forms as demo examples, LLMs can understand
the task intent and generate the logic form for a new question. However,
current powerful LLMs have little exposure to logic forms during pre-training,
resulting in a high format error rate. To solve this problem, we propose a
code-style in-context learning method for KBQA, which converts the generation
process of unfamiliar logical form into the more familiar code generation
process for LLMs. Experimental results on three mainstream datasets show that
our method dramatically mitigated the formatting error problem in generating
logic forms while realizing a new SOTA on WebQSP, GrailQA, and GraphQ under the
few-shot setting. The code and supplementary files are released at
https://github.com/Arthurizijar/KB-Coder . | [
0.0086823357,
0.0238052979,
0.0047233757,
0.0336498804,
-0.0121400524,
0.0356531255,
-0.0080123544,
-0.0264320206,
0.035386689,
-0.0632764027,
-0.0130652366,
0.0349889956,
-0.0604695454,
0.066500105,
0.0431328453,
0.0107156383,
0.0549244545,
-0.0090293018,
0.0070127151,
0.0078136083,
0.0141414953,
0.0344872624,
0.0157609098,
0.008432542,
-0.0316845328,
-0.0785066113,
-0.0150663396,
0.0241635498,
-0.0048404406,
-0.0414942876,
0.0379862525,
0.023976,
0.0279201735,
-0.0021701637,
0.0000019637,
-0.0559710823,
-0.0306583699,
0.0139062768,
-0.0454851687,
-0.0115239341,
-0.0102082761,
-0.0137530128,
0.0157344285,
0.0311596859,
-0.0747626796,
-0.0098640602,
0.0334991068,
0.000384133,
0.0793362036,
0.0699398667,
0.0024904911,
-0.0305200648,
0.0091241682,
-0.0093439287,
0.0182998441,
-0.0669575706,
0.0181560554,
0.0334104262,
0.0112983743,
-0.0113310572,
-0.009665261,
0.0185008496,
0.0378998443,
0.0162439384,
-0.0020456628,
0.0195554011,
-0.0570490025,
0.0245245192,
-0.0117951389,
0.0926566795,
0.0018560616,
-0.0556935035,
0.0112003777,
0.0132608917,
0.0053069126,
-0.031841781,
-0.0327350907,
0.0302073956,
-0.018972991,
0.0026931011,
0.0163158253,
-0.003184983,
0.0155414455,
0.0052014729,
-0.0297960788,
0.0735464096,
0.0031045456,
-0.0467823632,
0.0073155393,
0.0022405065,
-0.0535218678,
-0.0438435711,
-0.0387215801,
0.0584360622,
-0.0574828163,
0.0123614492,
-0.0447224006,
0.0035043424,
0.0226362236,
-0.0255795773,
0.004655248,
0.0450944938,
0.0247001182,
0.0506500155,
-0.0295409244,
0.0512831844,
0.0067754202,
0.0143540446,
-0.0668464452,
-0.032742694,
-0.0550928563,
-0.03335426,
-0.0617123693,
0.0522476323,
-0.0545742773,
-0.0232468117,
0.0027712919,
0.0883450285,
-0.0121794837,
0.027891472,
0.0007382399,
0.0093039358,
-0.0124146417,
-0.0078587048,
-0.015598299,
0.0324002281,
-0.0328848101,
-0.0086304871,
0.0052046119,
-0.0388137065,
-0.0257295184,
0.0095416866,
0.014141175,
-0.0378476121,
0.0136954552,
0.0063897511,
-0.0041134572,
0.0063567795,
-0.0412815027,
-0.0426189341,
0.0068818717,
-0.0195664205,
-0.0221222006,
-0.0846642926,
0.0009720996,
0.0068636569,
-0.0227852035,
-0.0479265824,
-0.0006913675,
0.0481483489,
0.0172927361,
0.0716466084,
-0.0436165445,
-0.0147197172,
0.0215947405,
-0.0076227696,
-0.026831843,
0.0800046846,
0.0007268422,
-0.0363606252,
0.0123083359,
0.0081594316,
-0.019897515,
0.026634559,
0.0474706367,
0.0193256568,
-0.028045278,
0.0593329705,
0.0437198132,
-0.0037473582,
0.0577029586,
0.0160009339,
-0.026240766,
0.0209668949,
0.0030246382,
-0.0028460247,
0.0199424922,
0.0156114548,
0.021809319,
0.0249016359,
-0.0085646771,
-0.0393880084,
-0.057481017,
0.0137742534,
-0.0193153862,
0.0323150456,
-0.0253757201,
0.0017020075,
-0.0315951891,
-0.0206669904,
0.0134071801,
0.0010912557,
-0.0107285902,
0.0475353152,
0.0118258744,
0.0555674993,
-0.033972837,
0.0696219876,
0.0108692721,
0.0000336418,
-0.0153926099,
-0.0421119407,
0.0564957112,
0.0212166049,
0.0237741359,
-0.052400209,
-0.0567756779,
-0.0146441497,
0.0250908118,
0.0034904662,
-0.0104325162,
-0.033605393,
-0.0131997503,
-0.0333120674,
0.0098300073,
-0.0540884398,
-0.0119157685,
-0.0414688624,
0.0316574834,
0.0067752884,
0.0199833494,
-0.0325630456,
0.0393638536,
0.0164110865,
-0.0147974659,
-0.0047658407,
0.006240671,
-0.0053779618,
0.0395960137,
0.0006639616,
0.0070272149,
0.0274606794,
0.0121078612,
-0.0298151709,
-0.0186024997,
-0.0039411727,
-0.0507397838,
-0.12919873,
0.0565115102,
0.0062632659,
-0.0244282261,
-0.0194998812,
-0.079010576,
-0.0305748377,
-0.0086498698,
-0.0358290486,
0.0468441173,
-0.0639391169,
-0.0677149296,
0.053982541,
-0.0432253629,
-0.0746328011,
0.0922093168,
0.0231781583,
0.0010413709,
0.0020795618,
0.0555275455,
-0.0155226374,
-0.0160007272,
0.0213133059,
-0.018717153,
-0.0279815178,
-0.0043831975,
-0.0274052192,
0.0363004878,
-0.07129848,
-0.0062087355,
-0.1142509952,
0.0255114008,
-0.0301069971,
0.0226136222,
0.0585869402,
0.0387550108,
0.002582917,
-0.0306108799,
-0.0688276067,
-0.0094384486,
0.0217616502,
0.0135024292,
0.0353541374,
0.0109659061,
-0.0207838956,
-0.0135427434,
-0.0136278346,
-0.0336945541,
0.0548094995,
-0.0089084608,
0.0428461768,
-0.0481822118,
0.0197864119,
-0.0288478639,
0.0341587402,
-0.0068542752,
-0.0061750901,
-0.0068779881,
-0.0311599933,
0.0174653195,
0.0714740604,
-0.0114115272,
-0.0207087416,
0.0239879843,
-0.0112357838,
-0.0472879484,
0.0623387434,
0.0003945347,
-0.028085677,
-0.0319926403,
0.0127678234,
0.0236828439,
0.0158490166,
-0.0057709119,
-0.0103954868,
-0.0485409312,
0.0344441421,
0.0164520666,
-0.0041468013,
-0.0435212515,
0.0134597095,
0.0037075162,
0.0356913693,
-0.0208938047,
-0.001630927,
0.0618248619,
0.0216996204,
-0.0440413728,
-0.0736380443,
0.0058049806,
-0.0675163269,
0.0606557168,
-0.0102834562,
0.0092317462,
0.0158508625,
-0.0441715531,
-0.0457462296,
-0.028799111,
0.000636025,
-0.0168949701,
0.041268006,
-0.043288555,
0.0479488932,
0.0025943518,
-0.0320224576,
-0.0567861833,
-0.0183669794,
-0.0496686511,
0.0351018608,
-0.0638261959,
0.0455611423,
0.0412969664,
-0.0057725348,
-0.0049113752,
0.0226659011,
0.0174907539,
-0.0202363878,
-0.0447068997,
0.0410619676,
0.070520021,
0.0304298159,
-0.002845739,
0.0227073245,
0.0389563553,
0.0508255549,
0.0152612673,
0.0150211174,
-0.010360321,
0.0134858768,
0.0156306773,
-0.0187022295,
-0.0156423915,
0.0363564342,
0.0619107522,
-0.0572493821,
-0.0303553771,
0.1336193383,
0.0386588536,
-0.0033719251,
-0.0052674119,
-0.0193071608,
0.0382168368,
0.0558398589,
0.0432706587,
-0.0973672047,
-0.0619688369,
0.0063926792,
0.026262328,
0.0114438133,
-0.022959806,
0.0146391112,
-0.1159307063,
0.0205865372,
0.0025083495,
-0.0649915263,
-0.0461242869,
-0.0373777524,
-0.0226734988,
-0.0221030377,
-0.0041885469,
0.036502853,
-0.041621618,
0.0432412662,
-0.0071486272,
0.0012029575,
0.001660842,
0.0511861257,
-0.0372293629,
0.0025386605,
0.0998534635,
-0.0068580937,
-0.0027006315,
-0.0085042678,
0.0084148049,
-0.0367360786,
-0.0054124487,
-0.0456771851,
-0.0031333247,
-0.0094573312,
-0.0174231268,
-0.0215058718,
0.0612306222,
-0.0742084756,
-0.0305245612,
0.0580973849,
0.063861087,
-0.0170361083,
0.0017217638,
0.0042128908,
-0.0244246349,
0.0121142352,
0.0680714324,
0.0291536208,
0.0077380096,
-0.0543794632,
-0.0447571613,
0.0212015416,
-0.0336099453,
0.0063518058,
0.0410774536,
0.0216389447,
0.0260951854,
-0.0762730315,
-0.033070609,
0.0642794371,
0.0509414673,
-0.0362743028,
-0.0074861208,
0.0463776588,
0.0084220022,
-0.0556664467,
0.0087435152,
-0.0455586538,
0.0102363043,
-0.0239968747,
0.0052001346,
0.0341054648,
-0.0068117632,
-0.0405962095,
0.0040131384,
-0.0603294261,
-0.0234722774,
-0.0276186932,
0.0389526561,
0.0108172521,
0.0543357469,
-0.033810582,
0.0160048287,
0.0178818144,
0.0087264068,
-0.0277431421,
0.0102681648,
0.0261605959,
0.0093223387,
0.0035826133,
0.0409781262,
-0.0638336167,
-0.0167453941,
0.009064557,
0.0635505244,
-0.0660061985,
0.0254169144,
0.0535372011,
0.0040415064,
-0.0326587744,
0.0300715119,
-0.0172796082,
0.009451326,
0.021525342,
-0.0203614198,
-0.0397572145,
-0.0601745173,
0.0080022691,
0.0018020555,
-0.05021156,
0.035198871,
-0.0017038177,
-0.0196328089,
0.054262206,
-0.0037990739,
0.0076828715,
0.0559526049,
0.00925384,
0.052967079,
-0.038271118,
-0.0385659188,
-0.0093171038,
0.0006034265,
0.0382635407,
-0.0199434161,
0.0521394834,
0.0412394702,
-0.0047309524,
-0.0374303125,
-0.0072511933,
-0.050334502,
-0.052863989,
0.014642383,
0.0062585929,
0.0617748015,
0.0258485936,
0.0186549295,
-0.0077465265,
-0.0231954455,
-0.0254399013,
0.0320390016,
0.021507157,
-0.0409144051,
0.0619119555,
0.0275314599,
-0.0181389451,
-0.0489439294,
0.1096069515,
0.0027643992,
0.0656852052,
-0.0052674222,
-0.0081158932,
-0.0423262529,
-0.0261899568,
0.0173348617,
0.0544532575,
0.0005512765,
0.0183189474,
-0.0167293698,
-0.0714573041,
0.0270955171,
-0.0183329675,
-0.030956028,
0.0031943584,
0.0595017709,
0.0584191009,
0.0488292947,
-0.0709760934,
-0.0096376957,
0.0417751446,
0.0027069063,
-0.0578474365,
-0.0245435555,
-5.987192764e-33,
-0.0043750345,
-0.0063506886,
0.0475686938,
-0.009175675,
-0.0131097166,
-0.0152963456,
-0.0455672853,
-0.0397085287,
-0.0199987516,
-0.0306616873,
0.016997382,
0.0143951904,
-0.0077082859,
0.0602838472,
-0.0079386234,
-0.0449480824,
0.006981316,
0.0065005645,
0.0076582036,
0.0194002241,
-0.0154953767,
0.0389460139,
0.0094708223,
0.0104399631,
-0.0174346287,
-0.0110002002,
-0.0085010249,
0.0496409424,
-0.02944321,
0.0496865734,
0.0036360126,
0.0043089534,
0.0252548251,
-0.0299825743,
-0.0057728579,
0.0365128219,
-0.0828968063,
-0.022560671,
0.0345557518,
-0.0018236428,
-0.0149842566,
-0.0420266688,
0.0324030928,
-0.0168154091,
0.0491881743,
-0.0357219502,
0.0033330168,
-0.0162340067,
-0.0043012341,
-0.0569047704,
-0.036948625,
0.017901063,
-0.0254821125,
-0.0185895432,
-0.040662121,
0.0265930407,
0.0061843642,
0.0272470471,
-0.0426817983,
-0.020720657,
-0.0310158748,
0.0393052101,
0.0280097704,
0.0355298109,
0.0166402087,
0.0043434552,
-0.0017644123,
-0.0321248025,
-0.018479662,
0.0403676741,
-0.0040902309,
0.0350935608,
0.0067129303,
0.0584059618,
0.0241625961,
0.0274033416,
-0.1199124381,
0.0006899805,
-0.0257187244,
0.0458375588,
-0.0180033688,
0.0115079181,
-0.0199952014,
-0.0145003181,
-0.0448935553,
0.0450271927,
-0.0295753181,
-0.0086513869,
0.0505500026,
-0.001219238,
0.011782201,
0.0083835963,
0.005329919,
-0.053157866,
0.0182995796,
0.0483427122,
0.0017790649,
0.0170360077,
0.0021744759,
0.0495788008,
-0.0251472816,
0.0044518625,
0.0257418454,
-0.0122806244,
0.0110298889,
0.0100367256,
0.0401248075,
0.0155437784,
-0.0548795089,
0.0047685388,
-0.0362597629,
0.0301176198,
-0.0141723612,
0.022655597,
0.0180369336,
0.0461211428,
0.0073605045,
-0.0000765875,
-0.014312217,
-0.0318379924,
-0.0299679916,
-0.0146308718,
0.0037806209,
0.020473389,
-0.0441323482,
-0.0217910912,
-0.0270291008,
0.02272496,
-0.0238133688,
-0.0183058809,
-0.0116245179,
0.0259200856,
2.622e-7,
0.0624813288,
0.0181472413,
0.0057895957,
0.0753228143,
0.0326074995,
0.0395718217,
0.0256977342,
0.0376733243,
0.0384940729,
-0.0182534512,
-0.0018669453,
0.0402792133,
0.00844137,
0.0354820825,
-0.0866337717,
0.0221567247,
-0.0198603421,
-0.0467152297,
-0.0425228663,
0.0173806548,
0.0779287666,
0.0937597752,
-0.0103435321,
-0.0064779418,
0.0209294893,
-0.0535925925,
0.0298670325,
0.0380653702,
0.012708189,
0.0128311189,
-0.0573679097,
-0.0188715849,
0.0066541736,
0.0475466996,
0.0018438163,
-0.0025145886,
-0.0056911679,
0.0765821934,
-0.0134092327,
-0.0120736752,
-0.0308442023,
-0.0214019082,
0.0417734198,
-0.0850909427,
0.1101165712,
-0.0460352376,
0.008283373,
-0.0096933264,
-0.0377354734,
-0.0339098871,
-0.0273304973,
-0.0080091134,
-0.0071511921,
0.0192915946,
0.0254166126,
-0.0208661407,
0.0150674423,
-0.0396787189,
-0.025120439,
0.0235746987,
-0.0173174143,
-0.0355274342,
-0.0208253656,
0.0244740508,
0.0390666947,
-0.025794087,
0.0333647616,
2.648463848e-34,
0.0101105673,
0.0027243793,
0.0305674132,
0.0700324997,
0.0293442812,
-0.0005905808,
-0.0278853159,
0.0011758662,
0.0320069008,
-0.0900944322,
-0.0030172118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04679v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04679v2 | Embedding structure matters: Comparing methods to adapt multilingual vocabularies to new languages | 2023-09-09T04:27:18 | 2023-10-26T21:26:16 | C. M. Downey, Terra Blevins, Nora Goldfine, Shane Steinert-Threlkeld | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained multilingual language models underpin a large portion of modern
NLP tools outside of English. A strong baseline for specializing these models
for specific languages is Language-Adaptive Pre-Training (LAPT). However,
retaining a large cross-lingual vocabulary and embedding matrix comes at
considerable excess computational cost during adaptation. In this study, we
propose several simple techniques to replace a cross-lingual vocabulary with a
compact, language-specific one. Namely, we address strategies for
re-initializing the token embedding matrix after vocabulary specialization. We
then provide a systematic experimental comparison of our techniques, in
addition to the recently-proposed Focus method. We demonstrate that: 1)
Embedding-replacement techniques in the monolingual transfer literature are
inadequate for adapting multilingual models. 2) Replacing cross-lingual
vocabularies with smaller specialized ones provides an efficient method to
improve performance in low-resource languages. 3) Simple embedding
re-initialization techniques based on script-wise sub-distributions rival
techniques such as Focus, which rely on similarity scores obtained from an
auxiliary model. | [
0.009200383,
0.0358327702,
0.0043479973,
0.0408943817,
-0.0254273806,
0.0025983006,
-0.009866111,
0.0031114507,
-0.0199988633,
-0.0489396863,
-0.0394023955,
-0.0372201726,
-0.028721083,
0.000877945,
0.0538737178,
-0.021800071,
0.0581866279,
-0.0226260033,
-0.0371842459,
-0.0093932524,
-0.0028235638,
0.0028699616,
0.0242021102,
0.0087208282,
-0.0286176056,
-0.0006980824,
0.0212263279,
0.0140413744,
0.0071638539,
-0.0035711876,
-0.0195337962,
0.0433203317,
0.0281042289,
-0.0067540379,
0.00000176,
-0.0391337052,
-0.0348159187,
-0.0169419739,
0.0416272022,
0.0243393201,
0.0778359547,
-0.0433693714,
0.0099509722,
0.0243160184,
-0.0045558889,
-0.0655223802,
0.0606911778,
0.000813616,
0.0136674717,
0.0614006519,
-0.0344215073,
-0.018049581,
0.000471181,
-0.0231736396,
-0.0419456884,
-0.0530275032,
0.0116639435,
-0.0047211987,
-0.0363086648,
0.0013616969,
-0.0405262709,
0.0283682998,
-0.040649958,
0.0050483146,
0.0401515253,
0.0171809103,
-0.0404435545,
0.0015721568,
-0.0125561887,
0.0464392602,
-0.0733016431,
-0.0438663289,
-0.0205395333,
0.0258102342,
0.0065358141,
0.0227475986,
-0.0525318906,
-0.0143739795,
0.0513843745,
0.0158693381,
0.0664821565,
-0.029706426,
0.0433227643,
-0.0065961028,
-0.0603341721,
0.0497846939,
0.0770114288,
-0.0251251496,
0.0258345567,
0.0177018121,
-0.0124153867,
-0.0341509879,
0.023576824,
-0.0042397543,
0.023125561,
0.030382162,
-0.0450989045,
-0.0382543877,
-0.004628411,
-0.0408708677,
0.0401798226,
0.0462382026,
-0.0276256576,
0.0461911894,
-0.0812311694,
0.0150515586,
-0.0201476812,
0.01943353,
-0.0510977991,
-0.0303296037,
-0.0301088151,
-0.0005330424,
-0.0584931634,
0.0237713121,
-0.0091161663,
-0.0104130311,
-0.0033023036,
0.0511302017,
0.0013358609,
-0.0183617547,
-0.0069132159,
-0.0362758115,
-0.0075822072,
0.0053162859,
0.011308495,
0.0415499508,
-0.0530623756,
-0.0119572412,
-0.0487610474,
-0.023555886,
-0.0324585848,
0.0331425816,
0.0196268559,
-0.0321046785,
0.0192414336,
0.0604705028,
-0.0208056979,
-0.054175131,
-0.0355364718,
0.0562863424,
-0.0088408794,
-0.0204620007,
0.0279212836,
-0.0773574337,
0.0476785302,
0.0052242568,
0.0277485251,
-0.026753176,
-0.0116035501,
0.009535159,
-0.064706631,
0.0901979282,
-0.0031509018,
0.0075653661,
-0.0197945256,
-0.0465916246,
0.030236166,
0.0715364516,
-0.0338396244,
-0.0188611001,
0.0855277181,
-0.0329160914,
-0.0347911082,
0.0451915227,
0.0202573519,
0.0411172919,
-0.041235283,
-0.0129170902,
0.0273832753,
0.0101775555,
0.0453760736,
0.0174342971,
-0.0344483554,
0.0110919541,
0.0005556633,
0.0897939876,
0.0087870546,
0.0205159299,
0.0621146895,
-0.0412311554,
-0.0451098122,
-0.000044885,
-0.0226372983,
-0.0114976279,
-0.0034422332,
-0.0067948494,
0.0275970474,
0.053740643,
-0.0476907082,
0.0228149295,
-0.0218908209,
-0.0342046097,
0.0205930788,
-0.0538066886,
0.0529414937,
0.0275658462,
-0.0307148118,
0.0745034367,
0.0598682612,
-0.0429639444,
0.0307956096,
-0.0097407997,
-0.0213363003,
0.0292471629,
0.0248800628,
-0.0234359168,
-0.0376938358,
0.0198130663,
0.0252433717,
0.0060991067,
0.0553826094,
-0.0284792613,
0.0217793752,
-0.0605785474,
0.0194530375,
-0.0166892596,
0.0048052897,
0.0762815252,
-0.0157376826,
0.0211507995,
0.0125044882,
-0.0802560374,
-0.0077428208,
0.0358890295,
-0.0651127994,
-0.0124147227,
0.0304530263,
0.0039105834,
0.0223736949,
0.0345078446,
-0.0095076114,
-0.0061323261,
0.0387557186,
-0.0488656759,
0.0090817707,
0.0034507548,
-0.0590396114,
-0.0577380024,
0.0562035814,
-0.0144193145,
0.0264252629,
0.023970997,
-0.0211299676,
-0.0293576457,
0.0411529541,
0.0243802089,
0.0765041038,
-0.0451498628,
0.0455943681,
-0.0166987274,
0.0479592383,
-0.0354337953,
0.0219786875,
0.01984917,
0.0204030592,
-0.0037388671,
-0.0142017072,
0.0379812047,
-0.0100052133,
-0.0400451869,
0.062609829,
-0.0224963687,
0.0127730472,
0.0131276073,
0.0123300944,
-0.0164468233,
-0.0084454091,
-0.1059800312,
0.0157735161,
-0.034741547,
0.0121263759,
0.028272165,
0.0257175751,
-0.0011714991,
-0.014115124,
-0.0411057211,
0.000877424,
-0.0141642876,
0.0444183424,
0.0099453209,
-0.0187512003,
0.00794004,
-0.0268670972,
-0.0143320458,
0.0155707747,
0.0737854913,
-0.0597144775,
-0.0079492647,
-0.0382625312,
0.0089891441,
-0.0294652618,
0.0215325616,
-0.0037485387,
-0.0207102541,
-0.0313631296,
-0.0040002954,
0.0763121694,
0.0059236479,
-0.0278293062,
0.010823559,
0.0482428968,
-0.0194968209,
-0.02040134,
-0.0091631124,
0.0104083484,
-0.0222762767,
-0.0507701747,
-0.0238676816,
0.0084587596,
0.0461903811,
-0.0342489518,
-0.0264627431,
-0.0690261275,
-0.030071957,
-0.0368784219,
-0.0240441784,
-0.0123028252,
0.011113218,
-0.0257833675,
0.0093153315,
0.0069495961,
0.0074625565,
0.0310543515,
-0.0328620113,
-0.0059044007,
-0.0730527937,
-0.018468095,
-0.0393312983,
0.0126221683,
0.0043616183,
0.01600595,
-0.0374662541,
-0.0286944415,
-0.034296941,
0.0067494316,
-0.0105846832,
-0.0057794615,
0.0515238829,
-0.0064350697,
-0.0003161646,
-0.0055753882,
-0.0172566362,
-0.0170013681,
-0.0497533567,
0.0012244531,
0.0265751053,
0.0314193256,
0.0072322423,
-0.0229084957,
0.0329553075,
0.0042578964,
0.0563785471,
0.010302823,
0.017749995,
-0.0039015738,
0.0438313857,
0.0192204006,
-0.0117905447,
-0.0116047636,
-0.0171017293,
0.0230587833,
-0.0032172562,
0.034728352,
-0.0566480383,
-0.0103994291,
0.0189111661,
0.079981856,
-0.0423045941,
-0.0397067554,
-0.0296639353,
0.045446489,
0.0399466529,
-0.0276271645,
0.0840382129,
0.0208846387,
-0.0648195148,
0.0120274518,
-0.0289439578,
0.0542054661,
0.0372288227,
0.0299545005,
-0.0581118315,
-0.0075793066,
0.0111281956,
-0.002592721,
0.0596624576,
-0.0190155003,
-0.0198960826,
-0.1162617654,
-0.0168260392,
0.0106916353,
-0.0696449429,
-0.0168770216,
-0.0491316356,
0.0041446858,
-0.0279002804,
0.0250322092,
-0.0248275902,
-0.0228304807,
-0.0044834143,
0.0110379988,
0.0000543171,
-0.0410978161,
-0.0069705034,
-0.0423735306,
0.0335944742,
0.0021978379,
0.0238540061,
-0.0384084582,
0.0262412131,
0.0469617471,
-0.0180304181,
-0.0254591573,
-0.0194117762,
0.0436431877,
-0.0250615459,
-0.0103817517,
0.0595753081,
-0.019900253,
-0.0458671302,
-0.0354438648,
0.0010574985,
0.0812008679,
0.05168809,
-0.0062749679,
0.0020157748,
-0.0277313944,
-0.0008204826,
0.0582675412,
0.0112189548,
-0.0603980012,
0.0077701472,
0.0144420359,
0.0156410821,
-0.0201126616,
-0.0063103256,
-0.0014531179,
-0.0316931121,
-0.0295258425,
-0.083732076,
-0.0435485654,
0.0345298089,
0.0593815222,
0.0221187808,
0.0237250142,
-0.0481974557,
-0.026661085,
-0.0182227716,
0.012343701,
-0.027639145,
-0.0258775447,
-0.0474427529,
0.0024269209,
0.020802604,
-0.0031214957,
-0.0002385192,
-0.0566186942,
-0.0090414612,
-0.0510058142,
0.002495216,
0.0282926075,
0.0061386107,
0.0397400595,
-0.0208073817,
-0.0285069384,
0.0481348969,
-0.0251448341,
-0.0152410027,
0.0212160163,
0.0442887023,
-0.0138804382,
-0.0025731083,
0.0550526269,
-0.0297735911,
0.0098424181,
0.0086576939,
0.0724694878,
0.0091917748,
-0.0551308878,
0.006913438,
0.0277392007,
0.0278662387,
-0.033130344,
-0.0022709919,
-0.0606976449,
0.0154716801,
-0.0477058664,
-0.0064177318,
-0.0179553274,
-0.0094936686,
0.0445129909,
-0.0045048189,
-0.0089941239,
0.0009281185,
-0.0312279705,
0.0443091691,
0.0059736012,
-0.0044826795,
0.0201696716,
0.0053097177,
0.0146482037,
0.0420053601,
-0.0220397599,
-0.0451043583,
-0.0115216821,
0.0097724563,
-0.0949172303,
-0.0265933033,
-0.0058097136,
-0.0266344566,
-0.0210786276,
0.034017574,
-0.0133974403,
-0.0103677344,
-0.0078638848,
0.0320748612,
0.0647125244,
-0.0839519501,
0.0836861953,
-0.0125044398,
-0.0272210408,
-0.0164172631,
-0.001428618,
-0.0001582332,
-0.0084910933,
0.0201716088,
0.0040744659,
-0.0287211593,
0.0220598504,
0.0593493283,
0.0129457563,
0.0169772003,
-0.0147466501,
-0.0014159668,
-0.0104877651,
0.0144956978,
0.0582147613,
0.0368455946,
-0.01943288,
0.0305471923,
-0.0459344797,
-0.0864387527,
0.0028674817,
-0.0299443249,
-0.0449970141,
0.0336811431,
0.0277642068,
0.08982566,
0.0075401557,
0.040362522,
-0.0419835038,
0.0118954051,
0.0465296358,
-0.0519785061,
0.0356910639,
-6.183635135e-33,
-0.0216193758,
0.0258908793,
-0.0152646853,
-0.0264943056,
-0.0054090857,
-0.0019212797,
-0.0093620066,
0.0039181947,
-0.0353804417,
0.0112954415,
-0.0375486687,
-0.0236902963,
0.0145817241,
0.020861065,
-0.0094866902,
0.0272835344,
0.0168865155,
0.0302367434,
-0.0030085614,
-0.0002981324,
0.0628486425,
0.0616878606,
0.1324983388,
-0.0278077498,
0.0022609285,
0.0140410997,
0.0437411517,
0.0080881156,
0.0800342038,
0.0242495816,
-0.0107114464,
0.0331680104,
0.0340585597,
-0.0202992745,
0.0028732617,
-0.0141610485,
-0.0668468103,
-0.0623723976,
0.064996399,
0.0179656763,
-0.0180990584,
-0.0338677689,
-0.0100362012,
-0.0347257964,
0.0200061407,
-0.0021785598,
0.0232310165,
-0.0099817319,
-0.041046001,
0.0250372887,
-0.104978539,
0.0334791616,
0.0195182431,
0.0255064331,
0.0561573394,
0.0346804932,
0.0072621051,
0.0070242886,
-0.017727701,
0.0077195028,
-0.0359131545,
0.0363378599,
0.0541496128,
0.0134359626,
-0.0301784147,
0.0480207838,
0.0128063727,
-0.008241686,
0.0581693314,
-0.019181814,
0.0341922753,
-0.0087611908,
-0.0005487273,
0.0471793637,
0.0227555856,
-0.0325055793,
-0.064091675,
0.0066345087,
-0.004988614,
0.0310487393,
0.0321509056,
0.0272040162,
0.008483476,
-0.0333989672,
-0.0579988919,
-0.0271426309,
-0.0227194559,
-0.0725198016,
0.0371537432,
-0.0131689487,
-0.0258135609,
0.027762223,
0.0535519384,
-0.0301476121,
-0.0269198492,
0.0328411646,
-0.0091737304,
0.0142047973,
-0.0236418694,
0.0498583801,
-0.0469645634,
-0.0660250634,
-0.0124715753,
-0.0441182517,
0.021787066,
-0.009489865,
0.057916861,
0.0070295809,
-0.0766887963,
-0.0168264657,
-0.0211785287,
-0.0302153267,
-0.0165243745,
0.0586220473,
0.0118830781,
0.0347665325,
0.0010138596,
0.049170021,
0.1020604149,
-0.0278562456,
-0.0061780014,
-0.0384091586,
0.0249073971,
0.0240671337,
-0.0264776815,
0.0110725043,
-0.0209465344,
0.0321585275,
0.036380291,
-0.0453008227,
-0.023572078,
-0.0180057399,
2.622e-7,
0.0718972236,
0.0422728918,
-0.01122058,
-0.0623703226,
-0.0042236135,
-0.0016385824,
-0.0422826484,
0.0645833313,
0.0058867787,
0.0070316358,
0.0122817187,
0.0181745626,
0.0112669729,
0.0259122793,
-0.0841142833,
-0.0013539757,
-0.034304589,
0.0256987009,
-0.0128204757,
0.0009492802,
0.0015084067,
0.1249132678,
0.0037407544,
-0.0021003089,
-0.0451711267,
-0.0608654246,
0.070893161,
-0.0502154939,
-0.0448804535,
0.0218722261,
0.0021571368,
0.0330867283,
-0.0085422061,
0.0080373967,
-0.0532804504,
0.0471570455,
0.0700288564,
0.0450435616,
-0.0273260865,
-0.004737318,
0.0254343301,
-0.0063989926,
-0.0081775729,
-0.0556398556,
0.0573149063,
-0.0105586397,
-0.0343084522,
-0.0404646732,
-0.0289624557,
0.058582738,
0.0400182158,
-0.025460368,
-0.0489125699,
0.0442355908,
0.0665943921,
0.0483363755,
-0.0660159364,
-0.0547648743,
0.0151219144,
0.0659156814,
0.0041264924,
-0.0178444907,
0.0024569125,
-0.0481552966,
0.033482831,
-0.019351583,
0.04653522,
2.447322989e-34,
0.0381572619,
0.00937213,
0.0277649947,
0.0316761024,
0.0190463029,
-0.0597229786,
0.0184548534,
0.0485334918,
-0.0112344055,
-0.0654444173,
0.00058946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04663v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04663v2 | FIAT: Fusing learning paradigms with Instruction-Accelerated Tuning | 2023-09-09T02:43:48 | 2023-09-12T14:34:03 | Xinyi Wang, John Wieting, Jonathan H. Clark | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Learning paradigms for large language models (LLMs) currently tend to fall
within either in-context learning (ICL) or full fine-tuning. Each of these
comes with their own trade-offs based on available data, model size, compute
cost, ease-of-use, and final quality with neither solution performing well
across-the-board. In this article, we first describe ICL and fine-tuning
paradigms in a way that highlights their natural connections. Based on these
connections, we propose a new learning paradigm called FIAT that fuses the best
of these paradigms together, enabling prompt-engineered instructions and
chain-of-thought reasoning with the very largest models while also using
similar methods to perform parameter updates on a modestly-sized LLM with
parameter-efficient tuning. We evaluate FIAT's effectiveness on a variety of
multilingual tasks and observe that FIAT performs better than both ICL and
fine-tuning at scales ranging from 100-10,000 training examples. We hope that
FIAT provides a practical way of harnessing the full potential of LLMs without
needing to make a hard choice between learning paradigms. | [
0.0175328553,
0.0801164508,
-0.0065899636,
0.0273483582,
-0.029084513,
0.0569774322,
0.0208095722,
-0.0242661908,
-0.0011101684,
-0.0556138121,
-0.0548826791,
-0.028591508,
-0.0142316874,
0.0130133573,
0.0165210273,
-0.0405239426,
0.0552966557,
-0.078602694,
-0.0222303104,
-0.0110915964,
-0.0115185576,
0.0218572747,
-0.0113262944,
0.0233755838,
0.0095130103,
-0.0260309428,
-0.0115796141,
0.0194084421,
0.0076143346,
0.0128362915,
0.0133348601,
0.0494764186,
0.0507790782,
0.0635690242,
0.000002203,
-0.0389889367,
-0.013391844,
0.0044012074,
-0.0240371954,
0.0285811555,
0.0180396587,
-0.0081000859,
-0.0350877158,
0.0196989384,
-0.0301751513,
-0.0125305075,
0.0446961559,
0.015259319,
0.0519262664,
0.0977874324,
0.0046712435,
-0.0507981814,
0.0174862053,
-0.028808726,
-0.0145565635,
-0.0587084703,
0.0260951277,
-0.0262518954,
0.0031007228,
0.0283748042,
-0.004381727,
0.0384071991,
0.053373903,
0.0122528551,
-0.0355058424,
0.038956061,
-0.0205874015,
-0.0059632016,
-0.0409216173,
0.0543410294,
-0.0258227773,
-0.0209071562,
-0.0105103226,
0.0079746237,
-0.0043061101,
-0.0310183819,
-0.0349413082,
0.04030196,
-0.0139077539,
0.0199825577,
0.024826549,
-0.0358683504,
0.0449520163,
0.0162773971,
-0.0680735707,
0.0485607721,
0.0119287586,
-0.0168284252,
0.0205089319,
-0.0100322599,
-0.0349699184,
-0.0422296226,
-0.0282508619,
0.0452327505,
-0.072204113,
0.0182765555,
-0.0240884982,
-0.0040565566,
0.0203126092,
-0.0293232892,
0.0675060153,
0.0505450405,
-0.0223730579,
0.0631179437,
-0.0525910072,
0.0221362039,
-0.0249758773,
0.0211550705,
-0.040499609,
0.0025875142,
-0.0542211048,
0.0273477789,
-0.0427048057,
-0.0032505784,
-0.0542456284,
-0.0007671556,
-0.0228626523,
0.0507877246,
-0.0068576722,
0.0312171094,
-0.005218673,
-0.0223574918,
-0.0108928876,
-0.0290212166,
-0.0058724764,
0.0465798378,
-0.0500684269,
0.0043222611,
0.0112177078,
-0.0389315337,
-0.0123315724,
0.0069627487,
-0.0266927108,
-0.0196641274,
0.050103955,
0.0597044267,
-0.0327564888,
-0.020130273,
-0.0461927503,
-0.0110120019,
0.0049923821,
-0.1108372882,
-0.0084457863,
-0.0773052871,
0.0292126946,
0.0137025667,
-0.0033656724,
-0.03359681,
0.0221274812,
0.0155759156,
-0.0228168052,
0.0735347569,
0.0065468531,
0.0070180008,
-0.0046161846,
-0.0006614004,
-0.0307990294,
0.0761339515,
-0.0112077352,
0.0032353038,
0.0193579905,
0.0207644477,
-0.0144742299,
0.0417121425,
0.0163992252,
0.0468307287,
-0.0279751755,
0.014380021,
0.060281232,
0.0157238599,
-0.0010104988,
0.0486606844,
-0.0073379334,
0.006216886,
0.0352829583,
-0.0116313351,
0.0138115631,
0.0127743343,
0.0599859133,
-0.0037581839,
0.0001091195,
-0.0083986511,
-0.0696207359,
0.0214077588,
-0.0409886502,
0.0144751137,
0.0101764109,
0.0393016562,
-0.0383875854,
-0.0537540428,
-0.0259270929,
-0.0030356634,
0.0027691363,
0.0532158837,
0.0569251589,
0.0194915067,
-0.0387979485,
-0.0113708349,
0.0522273034,
0.0053826356,
-0.0469703972,
-0.0599044152,
0.0115756756,
0.0482547507,
0.0229739528,
-0.0323037095,
-0.0386980437,
-0.0238072183,
0.071702987,
0.0291306414,
0.0302180648,
-0.0080836881,
-0.0182994325,
-0.0643537641,
-0.0119831664,
-0.0226152129,
-0.0040635453,
0.0315896794,
0.0542932637,
0.0075678509,
-0.0063707954,
0.0087060817,
-0.0432777256,
0.0279427599,
-0.0382254682,
-0.0429815687,
0.0122763524,
0.035220895,
0.008116005,
-0.0242342129,
-0.0149617307,
0.0117078787,
0.0190314092,
-0.0264735445,
-0.0027516133,
-0.0218097996,
-0.0624704324,
-0.0039312178,
0.0244449228,
0.0346645787,
-0.0217374004,
-0.038388852,
-0.0525286905,
-0.0270715263,
-0.0034047884,
-0.0128280064,
0.0526312366,
-0.0463144816,
0.0132018924,
-0.0143670728,
0.0219623502,
-0.0491949059,
0.0650235042,
-0.0169069935,
-0.0095330542,
0.0711947531,
0.0587457791,
-0.0040628863,
-0.0126182595,
-0.0270878673,
0.0173702519,
0.0054221898,
0.0239138696,
-0.007720008,
0.0244845562,
-0.0241937079,
-0.038860172,
-0.0899210125,
0.0268929694,
-0.0406864658,
-0.0027578061,
0.0047144149,
0.0044472273,
-0.0116987489,
-0.0229582768,
-0.0050466964,
-0.0018599285,
-0.0022236675,
0.0571024343,
0.0041210363,
0.0245944876,
-0.0229175668,
-0.0173096042,
-0.0185387935,
-0.0205630586,
0.029444987,
-0.0216652229,
0.0128301,
-0.0783044025,
0.0065148058,
-0.0304964855,
0.0612148233,
-0.0258419048,
-0.013010486,
0.0265947413,
-0.0420994386,
0.0600072667,
0.0905790478,
-0.0170381162,
0.0284511894,
0.0512839667,
-0.0036742564,
-0.0427185632,
0.0545419008,
-0.017292954,
-0.0585996546,
-0.0309617911,
0.0093551166,
-0.0211870968,
0.0740212053,
-0.0415157415,
-0.0263795927,
-0.0488262437,
0.030502487,
-0.0004497032,
-0.0254651867,
-0.0447562374,
0.0008424582,
0.012999272,
0.0193867702,
-0.0158084594,
-0.0558936521,
0.1013108343,
0.0011918545,
-0.0024982318,
-0.0561606474,
-0.0290588196,
-0.0525207669,
0.0412334763,
-0.0051974999,
0.0218669139,
0.0062456583,
-0.0031661559,
-0.0576254576,
0.0006138866,
-0.0006918795,
-0.0062542125,
0.0626101121,
-0.0648278221,
-0.006387217,
-0.0054167439,
-0.0807294399,
-0.0530937836,
-0.0065358505,
-0.0189336594,
0.0296612531,
0.0139981452,
-0.0556083135,
-0.0322520025,
-0.0085125705,
0.0282448921,
0.0480429344,
-0.010911827,
-0.0145960702,
-0.0363280885,
-0.0066981292,
0.0376306772,
-0.0014421918,
0.027995985,
-0.052371446,
0.0466412939,
0.0430401862,
0.0753094554,
-0.0455988534,
-0.0403672867,
0.0242945813,
0.0386431254,
-0.0232209805,
-0.0028791418,
0.0215409156,
0.0426523499,
-0.081613645,
-0.0359446555,
0.1311168671,
0.0309553687,
-0.0744271949,
-0.0034630552,
-0.0089820074,
0.0541669615,
0.0462601073,
0.076380983,
-0.08304061,
-0.0536305793,
0.0194804855,
0.0112717766,
0.0017142158,
-0.0238359533,
-0.0055330945,
-0.0941614956,
0.0380060449,
0.0079257991,
-0.0465679057,
-0.0162895676,
-0.056083221,
-0.018415099,
0.0288026351,
0.0054663219,
0.0225202516,
-0.0278557986,
-0.0106884493,
0.0065530553,
0.0498034842,
-0.0273317713,
0.0568397008,
-0.028186908,
0.0263340697,
0.0436973684,
-0.0177495796,
0.0381826125,
-0.0576562919,
0.0541002229,
-0.0094476454,
0.0271276291,
-0.0366730429,
-0.0063173887,
-0.010384243,
-0.0328183956,
0.0072277207,
0.0542322882,
-0.0146223539,
-0.0091280434,
0.0111721009,
0.0963269919,
-0.0082510132,
0.0118241878,
-0.0033438799,
-0.0347252339,
0.0179714337,
0.0434767567,
0.0103557957,
-0.0457465127,
-0.0337604769,
-0.0356565155,
-0.049306374,
-0.0284194592,
-0.0129912654,
0.0182635188,
-0.0137404976,
-0.0128190946,
-0.0407038927,
-0.0143347448,
0.0319743529,
0.0508302003,
0.0151647143,
-0.0072783828,
-0.005726119,
0.0044642645,
-0.0516999811,
0.0266223829,
-0.0474427417,
0.0309949517,
-0.0871095881,
-0.0328740925,
0.0326190144,
-0.0030462085,
-0.0060152328,
0.0406613126,
-0.0697890818,
-0.0769271106,
-0.016034862,
0.0616195686,
0.0162901804,
0.0882199928,
-0.0064693871,
-0.0290297884,
0.032911934,
0.0007766046,
0.008547659,
0.0195147861,
0.0315433517,
-0.0038629079,
0.0196386166,
0.048466403,
-0.0395304896,
0.0040281988,
0.0266343281,
0.0368407182,
-0.0489411987,
0.0137179252,
0.0291390512,
-0.0258594565,
0.0200026352,
-0.0244911872,
-0.0294972174,
-0.014957699,
0.0438636467,
-0.0009961985,
-0.0328331478,
-0.0344308503,
0.0064826719,
0.0052839927,
-0.0163888671,
0.0186545141,
-0.0049079554,
0.0442481115,
0.024733793,
-0.0066609229,
0.0163865443,
0.0022809217,
0.0156725012,
0.0590366498,
0.014405435,
-0.0201969016,
0.0565644093,
0.0349440537,
0.0620580651,
-0.044052951,
0.0972819179,
0.0393368937,
0.0006927663,
-0.0567086935,
0.0183579046,
-0.0565114506,
-0.0747476369,
-0.0046393648,
0.0300754532,
0.065488264,
-0.0065729972,
0.0220090356,
-0.0372255296,
-0.0445968285,
-0.0213451926,
0.0143536199,
0.0011102747,
-0.0382693335,
0.0064821141,
0.0380466022,
0.0033955842,
0.0188509189,
0.058801055,
-0.0152978422,
0.0528745614,
0.0167805348,
0.0069309417,
-0.0409899615,
-0.0389600061,
-0.009504253,
0.0152093396,
0.0058496958,
0.0201149881,
-0.0522299595,
-0.0632811561,
-0.034175463,
0.0152821429,
-0.0393313989,
-0.0115197459,
0.0375827141,
0.0526200905,
-0.0026829985,
-0.0193374343,
-0.0298077669,
0.0215091966,
0.0110912044,
-0.0432338119,
-0.0019196948,
-6.446331674e-33,
-0.0160466935,
0.0044074468,
0.0557863675,
-0.0158858001,
-0.0111668101,
-0.003828784,
-0.0232542325,
-0.0079905437,
-0.0158068873,
0.0138308583,
-0.0190790761,
-0.0150087737,
0.0069245752,
0.0196556095,
0.0124032721,
0.0026083577,
0.0349779204,
0.0026214491,
-0.0108145624,
0.0306370072,
0.0566771701,
0.0188250076,
0.0376369059,
-0.0060059652,
-0.0043069236,
0.0134077147,
0.0014487363,
0.0650165379,
-0.0474472307,
0.0406901613,
-0.0094816471,
0.0281563271,
-0.0053437194,
-0.0423351973,
-0.0090122605,
0.0021134536,
-0.0720532537,
-0.0080405409,
0.0285791941,
0.0136093441,
-0.0269965101,
-0.0423245914,
0.021835085,
-0.0033432795,
-0.0058902605,
-0.0225077569,
0.0039222236,
-0.0256883111,
-0.016831072,
0.0068135909,
-0.0848882124,
0.0142455613,
0.0060945144,
-0.0351790041,
0.0200983994,
0.0265400112,
-0.0010815535,
0.0029176301,
-0.0503172241,
-0.0006170897,
0.0109116985,
0.0567953847,
0.0829783231,
0.036184594,
0.0042318227,
0.0189659093,
0.0341855325,
0.0039658644,
-0.0242123548,
0.007617271,
0.0255016498,
0.0527038574,
0.0150937345,
0.0237971544,
-0.0049958965,
0.0067354767,
-0.0863787606,
-0.0065191016,
0.045297768,
0.0602142215,
0.0159412716,
0.0104652895,
-0.0369498469,
-0.0312075168,
-0.0619735047,
0.0069494164,
-0.0507794395,
-0.000386913,
0.0368979983,
0.028811885,
-0.0297803972,
-0.017724989,
0.0411962345,
-0.0292286612,
-0.0347277671,
0.0236698464,
-0.0168619733,
0.0099975066,
0.0089742709,
0.0472591333,
-0.0547280237,
-0.0352956355,
-0.0011084286,
-0.0088501386,
0.0068279216,
-0.0113535672,
0.0578034669,
0.0450173654,
-0.0684766546,
0.0078687798,
-0.0632916838,
0.0427182913,
0.0079955813,
0.0290721525,
0.0217894018,
0.0199223571,
0.0094681606,
0.0611292124,
-0.0050575556,
-0.0369000062,
-0.0237960182,
-0.0190941598,
-0.0098285452,
0.0295633692,
-0.0157722663,
0.0121660633,
-0.0499582067,
0.0161635522,
0.0101856412,
-0.0755966604,
-0.0079253353,
0.0406547002,
2.804e-7,
0.0042166105,
0.0583714992,
0.013639437,
0.021098977,
0.0161413848,
0.0528755672,
-0.0233830996,
-0.0081500495,
0.0293035358,
0.0172535703,
-0.0080080051,
0.0813239589,
0.0400085896,
0.0160287544,
-0.0918238834,
0.0084006451,
-0.0410501547,
0.0292478502,
-0.0732690915,
-0.0096983751,
0.0032316311,
0.0953571573,
0.0033746806,
-0.0148485098,
0.040740367,
0.0047443919,
0.0661217198,
-0.0173314381,
-0.0154967941,
0.0208813269,
-0.0362554751,
0.0325748399,
-0.0097714234,
0.0209252723,
-0.0164846778,
0.0262676124,
-0.0409852453,
0.0867687166,
0.0152366813,
-0.0301281586,
0.0204302389,
-0.0267827008,
-0.012943699,
-0.0686852932,
0.091997765,
-0.0633540601,
-0.0060617984,
-0.0338361487,
0.0250431504,
-0.0237470791,
0.0146400677,
-0.0340980701,
-0.0263155904,
0.0395927206,
0.0155772045,
-0.0184933003,
-0.0148842316,
-0.0761473402,
-0.0339114591,
0.0214477014,
-0.0210737586,
-0.0345915556,
-0.0576174408,
0.0091643911,
0.0218270384,
-0.0522643216,
0.000729632,
2.950007077e-34,
0.0450030454,
-0.0247249696,
0.0392066725,
0.0519451238,
0.0198910534,
-0.0170385838,
-0.0335942991,
0.024774069,
0.0344909206,
-0.0904540867,
-0.0248773154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04662v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04662v1 | MADLAD-400: A Multilingual And Document-Level Large Audited Dataset | 2023-09-09T02:34:01 | 2023-09-09T02:34:01 | Sneha Kudugunta, Isaac Caswell, Biao Zhang, Xavier Garcia, Christopher A. Choquette-Choo, Katherine Lee, Derrick Xin, Aditya Kusupati, Romi Stella, Ankur Bapna, Orhan Firat | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We introduce MADLAD-400, a manually audited, general domain 3T token
monolingual dataset based on CommonCrawl, spanning 419 languages. We discuss
the limitations revealed by self-auditing MADLAD-400, and the role data
auditing had in the dataset creation process. We then train and release a
10.7B-parameter multilingual machine translation model on 250 billion tokens
covering over 450 languages using publicly available data, and find that it is
competitive with models that are significantly larger, and report the results
on different domains. In addition, we train a 8B-parameter language model, and
assess the results on few-shot translation. We make the baseline models
available to the research community. | [
0.036456991,
0.0788053945,
0.0183165763,
0.0544787869,
-0.063027963,
0.0143987471,
0.0520579927,
0.007524895,
-0.0372694209,
-0.0303353034,
-0.0325964615,
-0.0162989143,
-0.0020325482,
0.031632401,
0.0575721897,
-0.0073654577,
0.0436141714,
-0.0345822833,
-0.0024663946,
0.0130361896,
0.0010244047,
0.0325279348,
0.0311455503,
0.0462457575,
-0.0339618549,
-0.0193187967,
-0.0095345899,
0.0163593534,
0.0106692538,
0.0022441067,
-0.0298930164,
0.0504351594,
0.0236804392,
0.1016578004,
0.0000020714,
-0.0647238865,
-0.0620142706,
0.034819223,
-0.009690172,
0.0504155569,
0.0440715775,
-0.0498657748,
-0.000920433,
0.0143193286,
-0.0040855268,
-0.0321311876,
0.0264986362,
0.038442269,
0.0562760271,
0.0849279389,
-0.0225552209,
-0.0651133284,
-0.0082020639,
-0.0509178452,
-0.0242412686,
-0.0752586871,
0.0031072129,
-0.0118451398,
-0.0388616398,
0.0352871045,
-0.0102241263,
0.0210040752,
0.0195831303,
-0.0364546776,
-0.0018164864,
-0.0238685794,
-0.0820763558,
-0.017474642,
-0.0150337527,
0.0409760177,
-0.0360692739,
-0.0324454419,
0.0195083097,
0.0026441645,
0.0023089163,
-0.0304821674,
-0.0208589565,
0.0237364247,
-0.0218229759,
-0.0060470621,
0.0194057766,
0.0016363835,
0.0380350612,
-0.0078581376,
-0.042864766,
-0.0171276759,
0.0372134633,
-0.0422242917,
-0.0166041106,
-0.0018495918,
0.0074765682,
-0.0294618383,
0.0383296497,
-0.0284183975,
-0.0036878539,
-0.01571564,
-0.0487703085,
-0.0269231573,
0.0498187318,
-0.0158507209,
-0.005735999,
0.0375007167,
-0.0478654094,
0.0751584321,
-0.0337764211,
0.067833595,
-0.0183393881,
0.0600539856,
-0.0395211764,
-0.0283185579,
-0.0205842126,
0.0260603167,
-0.0454905964,
0.0166597813,
-0.0294382907,
0.0104264151,
-0.050308764,
0.0216983967,
0.0154883964,
0.0476128496,
0.0269113202,
-0.045984827,
-0.004435508,
-0.0531634279,
0.0131342914,
0.0083912089,
-0.0294794254,
-0.0116123976,
0.0041145608,
-0.0448316038,
-0.0237895157,
0.0058997353,
-0.0005531813,
-0.0308864601,
-0.0043830676,
0.1331636906,
0.0100330366,
-0.037823271,
0.0132048726,
-0.0633536577,
-0.0309279226,
-0.0394461192,
-0.0090598194,
-0.0808210522,
0.0546948574,
0.0067726951,
0.0237134304,
-0.0065218173,
-0.023942817,
0.000147509,
-0.0283580571,
0.0642346665,
-0.0230915342,
-0.0085903434,
-0.0300238393,
-0.0340581723,
-0.0082516111,
0.0347096138,
0.0016654117,
0.0303354114,
0.0771785825,
-0.0046514389,
0.0114093339,
0.0485462844,
0.0294833798,
0.0190566536,
0.0154371485,
0.0327895917,
0.0294415206,
0.0060354532,
-0.0004388339,
0.0631035492,
-0.0372503102,
-0.0119414264,
0.0464040935,
0.0650508031,
-0.0162064284,
0.0032068158,
0.0126776798,
-0.0278484877,
0.0094612921,
-0.0311689805,
-0.0393827111,
-0.0143906763,
0.0563698187,
-0.01449499,
0.0522321127,
0.0211989991,
-0.013959772,
-0.0165911037,
-0.0141540077,
-0.0185423438,
-0.0335845798,
-0.0318763964,
0.0575584136,
0.0007865023,
-0.0413051248,
0.0060300664,
-0.0148658641,
-0.0524759293,
0.0016317127,
-0.0475077964,
0.0272602756,
0.0633591264,
0.0673096329,
-0.0067546368,
-0.0074145896,
-0.0565729104,
0.0558683462,
0.0548681989,
0.0751675144,
-0.0047507775,
0.0412520804,
-0.0414055362,
-0.0303367451,
0.0096707009,
0.0321945287,
0.0518374071,
-0.0156606734,
0.0327062458,
0.0246948414,
-0.0722663179,
-0.0448427349,
0.0320872664,
0.0087940963,
-0.0239630975,
0.025807878,
0.0062899156,
0.0328437127,
0.0486025438,
-0.0191942696,
0.0237597469,
0.0192467924,
0.0068430877,
0.0055249226,
0.0188507084,
0.0257993434,
0.0189183336,
0.0179184247,
-0.0515929237,
-0.0238812342,
-0.0013734954,
-0.0559038371,
-0.0422363579,
0.0042721773,
0.0037547755,
0.0418880582,
-0.0323319398,
0.0423372015,
-0.0171849821,
0.0021180192,
-0.0137289576,
-0.0001816556,
-0.006316463,
-0.0135049801,
-0.0082665626,
-0.0231222361,
0.0573506281,
-0.0109053366,
-0.015783919,
0.0094870673,
-0.0223651771,
0.032743372,
0.0448114537,
0.053804446,
-0.0162540283,
-0.0305822659,
-0.0465093032,
-0.0238320567,
-0.036232803,
0.0341785029,
0.0387103222,
0.0258643758,
0.0188716147,
-0.0019714991,
-0.0018636369,
-0.0648855194,
-0.0122075817,
0.0141620478,
0.0181239303,
-0.0336780138,
-0.0226701479,
-0.0201366823,
-0.0127121564,
0.0020167856,
0.0531596653,
0.0205315314,
-0.0312187877,
-0.0369313546,
-0.0044334047,
-0.0167549811,
-0.0300396588,
-0.0031521046,
-0.0248472709,
0.0182879474,
-0.0235667899,
0.0294115245,
0.0303785279,
-0.0311361905,
0.0042513707,
-0.0072835535,
-0.0344770253,
-0.0669134185,
-0.0194776077,
0.0122764464,
-0.0244326741,
0.013496777,
-0.007341831,
0.0634443015,
0.0161583144,
0.005321037,
-0.0054742699,
-0.0577723198,
0.0017403008,
-0.0054459707,
-0.0105189476,
-0.0362949185,
0.0047272141,
-0.0022305415,
0.0279279817,
-0.0033973185,
-0.0542027913,
0.0633834302,
-0.0473336354,
0.0149049237,
-0.0151903825,
0.0108312173,
-0.0311516337,
0.052409105,
-0.0195199363,
0.0267431103,
-0.0437316336,
-0.0251896251,
0.0287087671,
-0.0009391734,
0.0219998751,
-0.0035605861,
0.0221379884,
-0.0437644534,
0.0211327579,
-0.0192453433,
-0.0194769502,
-0.012944757,
-0.0068719219,
-0.0275900438,
-0.0101367738,
0.0137270531,
-0.0278695561,
-0.0496197827,
0.0239234194,
-0.0066031627,
0.0876576528,
-0.0202559028,
-0.0096324701,
-0.0023107119,
-0.010475303,
-0.0115191573,
-0.0582799278,
0.0109020891,
-0.0619091578,
0.0130081596,
0.0284378231,
0.0512787104,
-0.0089239627,
0.0085395826,
-0.0239864122,
-0.0044960026,
-0.0017274193,
0.0194612313,
-0.0209947024,
0.0177508425,
-0.0468388088,
-0.0179293193,
0.1116363034,
0.0230830163,
-0.0544784144,
-0.0141249886,
-0.0240777135,
-0.0304262396,
0.0003804326,
0.0169369318,
-0.1230583712,
-0.0298307575,
0.0208111331,
0.0462124497,
0.0272771586,
-0.0128844585,
-0.009324206,
-0.0719129145,
0.0382141024,
0.0389324874,
-0.072243534,
-0.0780054107,
-0.0253884885,
-0.066919595,
-0.0540981665,
0.0452837907,
0.0040887152,
0.0379994847,
-0.0264954325,
0.0020852147,
0.0016372462,
-0.0211369973,
0.0262870602,
-0.0810192302,
0.0236145332,
0.0501068011,
0.0267315451,
-0.0004635046,
-0.0293333344,
0.065459162,
0.0078428658,
-0.0297617167,
-0.0057239779,
0.0133881569,
-0.0141938794,
-0.0331601985,
0.0358267017,
0.0488343909,
-0.0553824641,
0.0067812423,
0.0413390659,
0.0577128269,
0.0055966843,
0.0089942049,
0.0064429869,
-0.0468862839,
-0.0323174782,
0.0494982228,
-0.0043185214,
-0.0335332006,
-0.025985498,
-0.0269461405,
-0.0428293757,
-0.0963552371,
0.0306590814,
-0.0083772475,
-0.0488756523,
-0.0443171449,
-0.0727928206,
-0.0246736836,
0.0055626081,
0.0696393028,
0.0186255928,
0.012495799,
0.018907398,
-0.0329683609,
-0.0023101396,
0.0432415828,
-0.080311887,
0.0472010858,
-0.1009080932,
0.0429659374,
-0.0031249265,
0.0229618624,
-0.0259445943,
0.0670405775,
-0.0738809854,
-0.0672335252,
-0.0085371593,
0.0354135484,
0.0292902216,
0.0351013727,
-0.0610406101,
-0.018778434,
0.0206503626,
0.011575086,
-0.0341249518,
-0.0624405518,
0.0262170807,
-0.0175121259,
-0.0211856756,
0.0240220726,
-0.0443364158,
-0.0296363216,
0.0224149767,
-0.0107768113,
0.011878456,
0.0056886799,
0.0340331048,
0.0286584273,
0.0306145474,
-0.0088513084,
-0.0005690783,
-0.0457153358,
0.0113259461,
-0.0371674225,
-0.021431949,
-0.0324607678,
0.0019495336,
0.0459105074,
-0.0260894615,
-0.0025904761,
0.0015753487,
-0.0184835121,
0.0113190822,
-0.0113491686,
-0.018561814,
-0.0207493566,
0.0641148686,
0.0206653196,
-0.0422031879,
-0.0156676471,
0.0173765738,
-0.0285239518,
0.0151724666,
-0.0482342802,
0.0250618439,
0.0069976123,
0.0455994233,
0.0221728254,
0.0617027357,
-0.0316057056,
0.0209749769,
-0.0070549822,
0.0161273219,
0.0578181744,
0.0171903223,
0.074783802,
-0.0254469868,
-0.0040891999,
-0.0262280442,
0.0667961612,
0.0289956443,
0.0049644825,
-0.0232056994,
0.0054241498,
-0.0330457948,
0.0338079296,
0.0832073316,
0.0090784458,
0.0026273318,
-0.0012425656,
-0.0269527808,
-0.0275518503,
0.0009808203,
0.0318014286,
-0.0309034232,
-0.0283532552,
-0.0599147454,
-0.0402324386,
-0.0515522547,
-0.0006202563,
0.0207783505,
0.0184389446,
0.0484327339,
-0.0244103707,
0.112423569,
0.0032719988,
0.0149426004,
-0.0354252756,
0.0081295362,
0.0214641728,
-0.0377395712,
-0.0185786225,
-5.992997135e-33,
0.0186202582,
-0.0256021284,
-0.0080751739,
-0.0356037542,
0.0072239321,
0.0176765993,
-0.0111744273,
-0.0503128469,
0.0119576314,
0.0119206849,
-0.015176204,
0.0058766464,
0.040211983,
0.00729628,
0.0384720005,
0.0053521483,
0.0573560968,
0.0158670526,
-0.0184526145,
0.0229122844,
0.0482405722,
-0.0005375561,
0.0810779482,
-0.0422029272,
0.080979757,
0.0039035836,
-0.0482010841,
0.0003749983,
-0.0111463591,
0.0415278524,
0.0073706601,
-0.0181255173,
0.01174343,
-0.0217226706,
-0.0288938917,
-0.0253623594,
-0.0736070648,
0.0112889102,
0.0236776341,
0.0628599897,
0.0261598881,
-0.0631813183,
0.0354579911,
-0.0315452367,
-0.0210285243,
0.0293987766,
-0.0034903071,
0.0014744512,
-0.0489073656,
-0.0520193726,
-0.0601055659,
0.0411531329,
-0.016584672,
0.009907308,
0.0182481986,
0.0616234541,
-0.0053671347,
-0.0038522938,
-0.0610444807,
0.0432832129,
-0.0176995359,
-0.0155291529,
0.0482417941,
-0.0244198088,
-0.0163305253,
0.0096458318,
0.0185332093,
0.0106259063,
0.0482350476,
0.0560122393,
0.0079539921,
0.025034219,
0.0547922589,
0.063491106,
0.0066768439,
-0.0356335565,
-0.0342970677,
0.0545631535,
-0.0089258673,
0.0293096229,
0.0543895774,
-0.0070638461,
-0.0301224981,
0.0137631372,
-0.0202466436,
-0.0525452383,
-0.0454842858,
0.0140384976,
0.0323628709,
0.0368334837,
-0.0335292518,
-0.0099973045,
0.0558593906,
-0.0347444005,
-0.0330859125,
0.0150772883,
-0.0172048546,
-0.0010169296,
-0.0347074531,
0.0424129777,
-0.0186374728,
-0.0532475598,
0.0321289785,
0.0182405859,
0.0227961335,
-0.0296816751,
0.0514802076,
0.011781943,
-0.0820915997,
0.0242317002,
-0.0205313172,
0.0012231533,
-0.0165770035,
0.0276860278,
0.0439090282,
-0.013818494,
0.0035532292,
0.0089096734,
0.0239301287,
-0.0176254995,
-0.0033864572,
0.0297082514,
0.0034197972,
0.0385131091,
-0.0155977635,
0.001868884,
-0.0289192479,
-0.030259477,
0.0775581077,
-0.0188738126,
-0.0145748584,
0.0034713165,
2.682e-7,
0.0158902369,
0.0506837107,
0.0321767293,
-0.0227843579,
0.0151778217,
0.0257960763,
-0.0243581478,
0.0586676486,
-0.0363245644,
0.0489706285,
-0.0060656616,
-0.036538139,
0.0867268816,
0.0288168266,
-0.0831746906,
0.0016665986,
-0.0766261518,
0.0309755225,
-0.0899914801,
0.0060361484,
0.0096761892,
0.1220159829,
0.0067519508,
-0.011311207,
-0.0036504781,
-0.0750330165,
0.033607237,
0.0030178977,
-0.0705576465,
-0.0324070565,
0.0561056063,
0.0337096676,
-0.0056596547,
0.0161824431,
-0.0175522119,
0.0165404473,
0.0325149819,
0.0825253054,
0.0232763812,
0.0346297957,
-0.005111564,
-0.0693938285,
-0.0086555183,
-0.031912148,
0.0671658665,
0.0210795812,
0.0050376891,
-0.0110355224,
-0.0015497471,
0.0155492499,
0.0511461794,
-0.0068424684,
-0.0291345641,
0.0523640327,
0.0327879936,
-0.0032763625,
-0.0104169985,
-0.0401496887,
-0.0069930945,
-0.029090194,
-0.0020772908,
-0.0185654145,
-0.0216531977,
0.0162227917,
0.010093811,
-0.0411127768,
0.0153869065,
2.60416516e-34,
0.0745106265,
-0.0538415797,
0.0165028796,
-0.0265784319,
0.0537232421,
-0.0185461529,
0.0020198231,
0.0169654004,
-0.0165268201,
-0.0217455309,
-0.0135819921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04658v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04658v2 | Exploring Large Language Models for Communication Games: An Empirical Study on Werewolf | 2023-09-09T01:56:40 | 2024-05-11T07:08:16 | Yuzhuang Xu, Shuo Wang, Peng Li, Fuwen Luo, Xiaolong Wang, Weidong Liu, Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Communication games, which we refer to as incomplete information games that
heavily depend on natural language communication, hold significant research
value in fields such as economics, social science, and artificial intelligence.
In this work, we explore the problem of how to engage large language models
(LLMs) in communication games, and in response, propose a tuning-free
framework. Our approach keeps LLMs frozen, and relies on the retrieval and
reflection on past communications and experiences for improvement. An empirical
study on the representative and widely-studied communication game,
``Werewolf'', demonstrates that our framework can effectively play Werewolf
game without tuning the parameters of the LLMs. More importantly, strategic
behaviors begin to emerge in our experiments, suggesting that it will be a
fruitful journey to engage LLMs in communication games and associated domains. | [
0.1023883522,
0.0707269013,
-0.047876928,
0.056731768,
-0.0498008206,
-0.0200124085,
-0.0316919461,
0.0369790085,
-0.0024708766,
-0.057121098,
-0.0339951105,
-0.0261112638,
0.028323954,
0.0200079922,
0.0214261729,
-0.0214678422,
0.0061657298,
-0.0242719427,
0.039605543,
-0.0192687269,
-0.0173223913,
-0.0473909155,
0.0094431117,
0.0332728662,
-0.0032907007,
0.0162375737,
-0.0408366919,
0.005767697,
-0.0027064574,
-0.0072487486,
-0.0204471741,
0.0034846326,
0.0309436601,
0.0282727145,
0.0000018763,
-0.0521860458,
0.0042895344,
-0.0259626154,
-0.0023632799,
-0.0106641604,
0.0654342994,
0.0013890294,
0.0091458624,
-0.0004264955,
-0.0497027449,
-0.0232952144,
0.0705824718,
0.0126321958,
0.0596409552,
0.0958325788,
0.0106852083,
-0.0206984598,
0.0150298513,
-0.0324600972,
-0.0034519588,
-0.0688194856,
0.0391413458,
0.0061115348,
0.0137128066,
0.0282509848,
-0.036163535,
0.034318056,
-0.0141584016,
-0.0113659129,
-0.0495853946,
0.0457129925,
-0.0014837517,
-0.0038100146,
-0.0242023673,
0.0256524906,
0.0235348977,
-0.021045953,
0.0264554247,
-0.0140825249,
0.0111751966,
0.013803022,
-0.0475201085,
0.0338879786,
0.032905072,
0.0076770359,
-0.0085131219,
0.0271603223,
0.0639940947,
0.0195118021,
0.0161024667,
0.0902602598,
-0.0273556877,
-0.0220598448,
-0.0296633411,
-0.0012825007,
0.0021612355,
-0.0813256279,
-0.044004377,
0.0566289127,
-0.0525391661,
0.0376872048,
-0.0087565687,
0.0204582904,
0.0250328127,
-0.0356321335,
0.0106963757,
-0.0045681838,
0.0508279167,
0.0591069385,
0.0573399439,
0.0143728582,
0.001581581,
-0.0236215368,
0.0118031139,
-0.0101979338,
-0.0419046097,
-0.0499316752,
-0.0333372876,
0.0276598539,
-0.0046765069,
-0.0258559491,
0.026312083,
0.0061653475,
-0.0232292693,
0.0573300421,
-0.0184779596,
0.0042456975,
-0.0418512374,
-0.0144957071,
-0.0361195467,
0.0213250108,
-0.039897386,
0.01595442,
0.0118071614,
-0.0740149617,
-0.0051010698,
-0.0224927124,
-0.0134121487,
-0.0250776783,
0.012959321,
0.0946213678,
0.0117219985,
-0.0078572566,
0.010475724,
-0.0026609362,
-0.0120530985,
-0.0861555338,
-0.0241091065,
-0.0440985411,
0.0272898488,
0.010025518,
0.022747606,
-0.0432813615,
-0.0028600157,
-0.0185692254,
-0.0489434935,
0.0844998136,
0.028580714,
0.0255726911,
0.0085737947,
0.0186768528,
0.0434706248,
0.1129727662,
0.0569539815,
0.0214742199,
0.0437585749,
0.0085111195,
0.0039865179,
0.0525073223,
0.0070127435,
0.0281948037,
-0.0106790951,
-0.0099856723,
-0.0154798143,
0.0428466611,
-0.0272355378,
0.0306476876,
-0.037214186,
-0.0281271636,
0.0716582984,
0.0333375968,
0.0168047212,
0.0525875874,
0.0264015999,
0.0225563552,
-0.043397449,
0.0255201068,
0.0095607387,
-0.0092189768,
-0.0442645997,
0.0000564996,
0.0221213549,
-0.0275463834,
-0.0240355842,
-0.0302342959,
0.0101634134,
-0.0184864439,
0.0700620934,
0.0471429676,
0.0337283239,
-0.0096147256,
-0.0313135646,
0.0315220281,
0.0438836217,
-0.011188685,
0.0087292837,
-0.0393874571,
0.0138843227,
0.0476059876,
0.0770530626,
-0.0375894532,
0.0247576255,
-0.0045431918,
-0.0005599718,
0.059148591,
0.0698500127,
0.0023835725,
0.0007608959,
-0.0273543522,
-0.0008075068,
-0.0366155654,
0.0195044689,
0.0354429111,
-0.0107181631,
0.0277691968,
-0.0233483296,
0.0028199453,
-0.0026783012,
-0.0023701044,
-0.000438077,
-0.0407462865,
-0.0380082652,
-0.01531721,
0.0567234866,
-0.0157419704,
-0.0347078517,
0.0227445047,
0.0421915166,
-0.021094976,
-0.0352203473,
-0.0038130865,
0.0213946551,
0.0158144142,
0.0169884562,
-0.0167970043,
-0.0002763433,
0.0092222728,
0.0024763832,
-0.0049566273,
0.0649346262,
-0.0286857989,
0.1119485125,
-0.0012106848,
0.0031801956,
-0.052723743,
-0.0196203925,
-0.0306754187,
0.0313364826,
0.0180280358,
0.0236135386,
-0.0343519971,
-0.038537398,
-0.0180596039,
-0.0561093017,
0.0255343765,
0.0494486354,
0.0092922188,
0.0093589406,
0.0811765119,
-0.0031258194,
-0.0176875424,
-0.0791499615,
-0.0841510072,
-0.0052446672,
-0.0015478737,
-0.0016895516,
0.0015916654,
-0.0069752121,
-0.0140424985,
0.0435458496,
-0.016816264,
0.0036881955,
0.0324884057,
0.0333882049,
0.0333787687,
0.0602251999,
-0.0288558379,
-0.0246833749,
-0.0095847538,
-0.0197857786,
0.064675279,
0.0093556484,
-0.0099939555,
-0.0757692754,
0.0086753489,
-0.0571210757,
0.0372316092,
-0.0495356694,
-0.0459938943,
0.0269513652,
-0.0120458528,
0.0422650576,
0.0340202376,
0.025834417,
0.0699505806,
0.0487008542,
-0.0442105234,
-0.061163798,
0.0239793528,
-0.0530848131,
-0.0528467782,
-0.1089350656,
-0.0493236184,
0.0369268246,
0.0671099052,
-0.0139748249,
-0.004062837,
-0.0366248079,
0.0475537926,
-0.0058113909,
-0.0543010347,
-0.0370148867,
-0.0288640298,
-0.0121013485,
0.0195598323,
-0.0011527407,
-0.0094336141,
0.0732687488,
-0.0138067827,
0.0097370045,
0.0021599971,
0.0238414891,
-0.027037859,
0.1036563441,
0.0022494411,
0.0025933711,
0.0213611145,
-0.0117693692,
-0.0351382308,
-0.0670569763,
0.0682459027,
-0.0397241749,
0.0126063116,
-0.0003121539,
0.0262332186,
0.0221943203,
-0.0424489826,
-0.0111719072,
-0.0452593938,
-0.0679104403,
-0.0086726751,
0.0482632853,
-0.015069114,
-0.0963926837,
0.0124136861,
0.0509686209,
-0.0320578851,
0.0136390366,
-0.0159173515,
-0.0208159741,
0.0154154915,
0.0517058149,
-0.0025762776,
0.0342856869,
-0.0440589935,
-0.000607174,
0.0282545015,
-0.0136141544,
-0.0055641797,
0.0241920967,
-0.0221558418,
0.0377494246,
-0.0312278979,
-0.0039368956,
0.0380281322,
0.014717116,
-0.0224976204,
-0.0343961045,
0.0677923635,
0.031238379,
-0.0130743049,
0.0284858104,
-0.0258124955,
0.0599374957,
-0.0079480633,
0.020318618,
-0.0820144936,
-0.0275189672,
0.0130122956,
-0.0249044765,
-0.0289925262,
-0.025263723,
-0.0222350452,
-0.1242592558,
-0.0108237565,
0.0281083547,
-0.0109618818,
-0.0137252659,
-0.0096706636,
-0.0232884977,
-0.0211440865,
-0.0137066282,
-0.0005005674,
-0.0016857848,
-0.0163351502,
-0.0215319749,
0.0064759441,
-0.0013244537,
-0.0051443563,
-0.0193246789,
0.0648759604,
0.0462048799,
0.0571788885,
-0.013159479,
-0.0187556576,
0.0112390239,
-0.0031199965,
-0.0276443679,
-0.003692351,
-0.0048895143,
-0.0181109644,
0.0051614703,
0.0103196194,
-0.0308624897,
0.025532078,
-0.0100841299,
0.01112267,
0.0178416763,
-0.0178271905,
-0.0871949494,
0.0415658392,
0.0015443348,
0.0488732122,
0.0854807273,
0.0113656018,
-0.0519871414,
-0.0039855917,
-0.0416770093,
-0.0130920401,
0.0205887817,
-0.0967489854,
-0.0395866521,
0.0682875365,
-0.0222045425,
-0.0428178124,
-0.0479490422,
-0.0264473967,
-0.0062969592,
0.0102513889,
0.0299805589,
0.016331505,
0.0313875824,
0.0010190103,
-0.0037149475,
-0.050527636,
-0.0105023244,
-0.0211376082,
-0.0221400484,
0.0201593768,
-0.0596154183,
-0.0165282488,
0.0403851196,
-0.0722879469,
-0.0736072138,
-0.0148147754,
0.042442292,
0.0299881175,
0.0268583335,
0.0015375456,
-0.0628529117,
-0.012337625,
0.0547864586,
-0.0187525321,
0.0300467126,
0.023178827,
0.0067208777,
0.0351559147,
0.0521938987,
-0.0409423634,
-0.0123763029,
0.0276458934,
0.0763113052,
-0.026578879,
-0.027083477,
0.0283725839,
-0.027779527,
0.0068851272,
-0.013652158,
-0.0626031756,
0.0221665427,
0.0144678643,
-0.0321577527,
-0.0348510221,
-0.015472508,
-0.0348656215,
-0.0197616704,
0.024500601,
0.020198267,
0.0047970423,
-0.0242665764,
0.0310713053,
0.0162898842,
0.00984642,
0.0400987528,
-0.0024688568,
0.0461053587,
-0.0090156905,
0.0290333331,
0.0454058275,
-0.0002162236,
0.0323663168,
0.0367907807,
0.0122023774,
0.0668104738,
-0.0624531992,
-0.0047106287,
-0.0004493922,
-0.0122617381,
-0.0756029263,
0.0561634749,
0.0300620627,
0.0647850484,
0.0239336267,
0.0297872964,
-0.0518505536,
-0.007742092,
-0.006059349,
-0.0212068819,
0.002091869,
-0.0892672315,
0.018041702,
0.0310437474,
-0.0526888892,
0.0380092002,
0.055656556,
0.0341163017,
0.0329888463,
-0.0110087832,
0.0129377656,
-0.0007477492,
-0.0165358987,
-0.0016257151,
0.0223340914,
-0.0212264005,
0.0243090875,
-0.0723183975,
-0.0437007397,
-0.0247701686,
0.0328456722,
-0.0021642863,
0.0016321208,
0.0174524318,
0.0217282064,
0.0009298014,
0.0077800388,
-0.0510840304,
0.0575631522,
-0.007758318,
-0.0285338629,
-0.0082255704,
-6.593289039e-33,
-0.0003083622,
-0.0372686721,
0.0336125158,
0.0008974058,
-0.0160370413,
-0.0198363811,
-0.0440960117,
0.0149416123,
-0.0169468708,
0.000944516,
0.0063338163,
-0.014726826,
0.0156309176,
0.0000277634,
0.001741623,
-0.0270473473,
0.0175478794,
0.0183154643,
-0.0527031124,
0.002665963,
-0.00624181,
-0.0106281238,
0.0413833447,
-0.0368190594,
0.0227573849,
-0.0094249342,
-0.040222276,
0.0538133308,
0.0119411815,
0.0165523849,
0.0140924491,
0.0114211747,
0.0077503165,
-0.0442762785,
0.0082251132,
0.0382384099,
-0.0231866762,
-0.015857581,
0.0623349622,
-0.0176523905,
0.004081056,
-0.0223406572,
0.0282936264,
-0.0048916573,
-0.0254178941,
0.0265917946,
0.0078902487,
-0.0278192051,
-0.0176817551,
0.0152254375,
-0.0385769755,
-0.0042744679,
-0.0422992818,
0.0031459064,
0.0041816514,
0.0131300921,
0.0127671482,
0.0251498707,
-0.0455964208,
0.0846703202,
0.0356919654,
0.0196124557,
0.0369404666,
0.0287473574,
0.0634926185,
0.0714181662,
-0.0069241147,
0.0268382281,
-0.035823632,
-0.0494075716,
0.0261063371,
0.0044199121,
0.02349158,
0.0235844534,
-0.0435836129,
-0.0443334393,
-0.072658807,
-0.0356967226,
0.0670439377,
0.0219445303,
0.023596378,
0.0332689397,
-0.0405019894,
-0.0342989378,
-0.0387416631,
-0.0196703896,
-0.0155601902,
-0.0608334243,
0.0115552275,
0.0306753553,
-0.0092354799,
0.0099696349,
0.0325807966,
-0.0635284409,
-0.0931949988,
0.0136108939,
0.0152793154,
0.0241193157,
-0.0077367527,
-0.0180034395,
-0.0290519614,
-0.0279884804,
-0.0106334193,
-0.009466758,
-0.00265818,
0.0057598236,
-0.0103346892,
0.0176173095,
-0.0387541689,
-0.0092980154,
-0.0067929658,
0.024981292,
0.0078426115,
-0.0657618716,
0.0353142843,
0.0061345715,
-0.0041907071,
0.0043513933,
0.025062589,
-0.036804039,
-0.0198484007,
0.0402661972,
-0.0366288722,
0.0121545596,
-0.01373496,
0.0011654423,
-0.0550716296,
0.0411189422,
0.0262966212,
-0.0128454622,
-0.0284331497,
-0.0617364496,
2.751e-7,
-0.0007521783,
0.0672637969,
-0.0366484411,
0.0319419838,
0.0344481096,
0.048795972,
-0.0545921735,
0.0168772787,
0.0111044897,
-0.0559734665,
0.0207248852,
0.066199556,
0.026687596,
0.0101984357,
-0.1031780541,
0.0279119294,
-0.088039577,
-0.0357906856,
-0.0414885059,
-0.0284977369,
-0.0112581849,
0.0639531985,
0.0633379295,
0.0413352363,
-0.0202517305,
-0.0508514158,
0.0557023697,
-0.0783583671,
-0.0180898439,
0.0471972935,
-0.0048059104,
0.0059942091,
0.0007117669,
-0.0306708813,
0.0066420888,
0.0269341674,
-0.0432786644,
0.0379805528,
0.0099321054,
-0.0332945883,
-0.0372097008,
0.0046057622,
-0.0257284548,
-0.0490626656,
0.0363179818,
-0.0587724559,
-0.0657101572,
-0.0265484508,
0.0284880288,
-0.0287910178,
-0.0153150605,
-0.0206359159,
-0.0402593091,
0.0032883128,
-0.0083021643,
0.0315731019,
0.0303708985,
-0.0324715003,
-0.0182304364,
0.0143621964,
-0.0478649884,
-0.0567483269,
-0.0277453978,
0.0003274453,
-0.0115348613,
-0.0539369844,
0.017019704,
2.182079347e-34,
0.0544170029,
0.0001840332,
-0.007093179,
0.0127636213,
0.0591890477,
0.0181120764,
-0.0169633478,
0.0189149287,
0.0655098259,
-0.0473249257,
-0.0048709833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04646v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04646v1 | Efficient Finetuning Large Language Models For Vietnamese Chatbot | 2023-09-09T00:11:53 | 2023-09-09T00:11:53 | Vu-Thuan Doan, Quoc-Truong Truong, Duc-Vu Nguyen, Vinh-Tiep Nguyen, Thuy-Ngan Nguyen Luu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs), such as GPT-4, PaLM, and LLaMa, have been shown
to achieve remarkable performance across a variety of natural language tasks.
Recent advancements in instruction tuning bring LLMs with ability in following
user's instructions and producing human-like responses. However, the high costs
associated with training and implementing LLMs pose challenges to academic
research. Furthermore, the availability of pretrained LLMs and instruction-tune
datasets for Vietnamese language is limited. To tackle these concerns, we
leverage large-scale instruction-following datasets from open-source projects,
namely Alpaca, GPT4All, and Chat-Doctor, which cover general domain and
specific medical domain. To the best of our knowledge, these are the first
instructional dataset for Vietnamese. Subsequently, we utilize
parameter-efficient tuning through Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) on two open LLMs:
Bloomz (Multilingual) and GPTJ-6B (Vietnamese), resulting four models:
Bloomz-Chat, Bloomz-Doctor, GPTJ-Chat, GPTJ-Doctor.Finally, we assess the
effectiveness of our methodology on a per-sample basis, taking into
consideration the helpfulness, relevance, accuracy, level of detail in their
responses. This evaluation process entails the utilization of GPT-4 as an
automated scoring mechanism. Despite utilizing a low-cost setup, our method
demonstrates about 20-30\% improvement over the original models in our
evaluation tasks. | [
0.0591384098,
0.0247775521,
-0.0217513759,
0.0092441542,
-0.0086313225,
0.0279414058,
0.0013338836,
0.0002089094,
0.0511324219,
-0.0453868285,
-0.068575114,
-0.0282750744,
-0.0025875093,
-0.0002562005,
0.0018391288,
-0.0719416961,
0.035067495,
-0.0058880993,
-0.0030888731,
-0.0079218792,
0.020228155,
0.0113013461,
-0.0523651503,
0.0711555332,
0.0486043282,
-0.0055158837,
-0.025912419,
0.0267004259,
0.017634701,
-0.0424077176,
0.0127246967,
0.0530623794,
-0.0087554259,
0.0196647868,
0.00000215,
-0.0236912258,
-0.0091356467,
-0.014215216,
-0.0236119572,
-0.002814716,
0.0686983913,
-0.0246981829,
-0.0172784813,
0.0470503531,
-0.0268337354,
-0.0308846962,
0.0540675484,
0.0216468237,
0.0912867785,
0.0811401382,
0.0072787949,
-0.0003909375,
0.0110434256,
-0.0128611876,
-0.0073716305,
-0.0572850443,
0.0134930518,
0.0218292009,
0.0518098883,
-0.006885733,
-0.0538926795,
0.0287720524,
0.0144003024,
-0.0068972558,
0.0108377906,
0.0129308784,
-0.0628357753,
-0.0054719495,
-0.0152996369,
0.0962868854,
-0.0094520124,
0.0098650558,
-0.0147945629,
0.0180943459,
0.0136450445,
-0.0258589089,
-0.0535937808,
-0.0238590986,
0.0235768482,
-0.0068059708,
0.0098776929,
-0.0356116779,
0.0005416554,
0.0258178134,
-0.0015087118,
-0.0183450542,
0.0146227358,
-0.0356889591,
0.007454922,
-0.0058069699,
-0.0282715186,
-0.0239344332,
0.0270054415,
0.0599123575,
-0.0510274284,
0.0280563291,
-0.0301184542,
0.0111275809,
0.0333634801,
-0.0457004905,
0.0278351828,
0.0775972977,
-0.0220364127,
0.0299332123,
-0.0083964281,
0.0695364475,
0.0072778799,
0.0413909778,
-0.0547491945,
0.0083285533,
-0.0743139237,
0.0087292138,
-0.0478646532,
0.0292614587,
-0.0230630394,
-0.0101111308,
-0.07434953,
0.0222603064,
0.0022304424,
-0.0211308058,
0.0302372258,
-0.0110092945,
-0.0729145631,
-0.0007291368,
-0.0234831832,
0.0365776345,
-0.0171848983,
0.0341519229,
0.0058735269,
-0.0961652622,
0.0055892006,
0.0156835858,
0.0121727418,
-0.0211198237,
0.0376570933,
0.0596102402,
-0.0177161507,
-0.0319042131,
0.003268274,
0.0315840282,
-0.0146767227,
-0.0639716387,
-0.0028067525,
-0.0479978994,
0.034231212,
-0.0003940621,
0.0509255938,
0.0048751971,
-0.0093682176,
0.0173455738,
-0.0336838961,
0.063489154,
0.0021740631,
0.0315329097,
0.0289861131,
0.0088189626,
-0.0096363835,
0.0515713394,
0.0303011853,
-0.0042173197,
0.0068385643,
-0.0722973347,
-0.0063949898,
0.0254864767,
-0.0202766918,
-0.0071733035,
0.0435791165,
0.0270158667,
0.002120272,
0.0636523068,
0.0067010103,
0.0501750372,
-0.0357359275,
0.0000754856,
0.0697435811,
0.0443302356,
0.0223668274,
0.0076877559,
0.056614656,
-0.0022033094,
0.0451437533,
-0.0010330593,
-0.0616972521,
0.0137651227,
-0.0423615128,
-0.0022760418,
0.0132449884,
0.0250233151,
-0.0543963499,
-0.0544004031,
-0.0021262737,
-0.0192673653,
0.0194225907,
0.0035941016,
0.0453201607,
-0.0001416422,
-0.0365707725,
-0.0004918277,
0.059989389,
-0.0165895466,
-0.0132430382,
-0.0692939907,
-0.0203255937,
0.0800494924,
0.0413011275,
-0.0197989494,
-0.0424291193,
-0.0089390436,
0.0285025351,
0.0333394781,
0.0561765134,
-0.0175055563,
0.0305278003,
-0.0622336157,
0.0044582011,
0.0335378125,
-0.003605824,
0.0332411155,
0.0307064243,
0.0285012964,
-0.0262097362,
-0.0003640769,
-0.0496765338,
0.0423160456,
-0.04090482,
-0.0353657007,
-0.0037274889,
-0.0052732024,
0.0665497407,
0.0198889561,
0.0086579546,
-0.0153487464,
0.0218187552,
-0.0131859872,
0.0373005867,
-0.0183594767,
-0.0370509624,
-0.038764827,
0.0328045599,
-0.023529673,
-0.0163821857,
0.0660274848,
-0.0344109908,
-0.0349323414,
0.0063592731,
-0.0426043123,
0.0183374994,
-0.0409234464,
0.0417724922,
-0.0110273743,
0.0369209126,
-0.0106813712,
0.0261337254,
0.0030539737,
0.0230491981,
0.0562151894,
0.0024194617,
-0.0116987582,
-0.0687280968,
-0.0165057369,
0.0391841941,
-0.0049594254,
0.0354308747,
-0.0024742659,
0.0715760514,
-0.0503343642,
-0.0572137795,
-0.1315817088,
0.0296714976,
-0.0194059871,
0.0120485546,
0.0263460036,
-0.007014622,
-0.0234018024,
-0.0397604331,
-0.03511988,
0.0134533029,
0.022695303,
0.0220473967,
0.0098324539,
0.0170031581,
-0.0376540236,
-0.0622565895,
-0.0010990301,
0.0241832305,
-0.0291164964,
-0.0095510809,
-0.0033201524,
-0.0382797569,
0.004862356,
-0.030447755,
0.0075074933,
-0.0093667386,
-0.1019752398,
0.0143586481,
0.0018232574,
0.0277497414,
0.0784104094,
0.0243083779,
0.0382935442,
0.0216421876,
0.0214375705,
-0.0574035868,
0.0193733107,
-0.0284089409,
-0.0672708899,
-0.0483700521,
-0.0370780192,
-0.0320594348,
0.0673174858,
-0.0005886612,
0.024077937,
-0.105247274,
-0.0275262501,
0.0030488931,
-0.0141555173,
-0.0153580932,
0.0505481362,
-0.0362753607,
-0.0184579007,
-0.0077862553,
-0.0522319339,
0.0970006362,
-0.0244974699,
-0.022376975,
-0.0689844787,
-0.0309510436,
-0.0209963098,
0.0214450937,
-0.000831559,
0.022217514,
-0.0207973905,
-0.0242045447,
-0.0316102095,
0.0587739013,
0.0105687091,
-0.071898669,
0.0320547782,
-0.0305822305,
-0.0091872588,
-0.0071592494,
-0.0391041972,
-0.0310119055,
-0.0323172249,
-0.0274084453,
0.0118346252,
0.0214368422,
0.0015763195,
-0.0448280536,
0.0217201002,
0.0197085962,
0.0287827291,
-0.000680249,
0.0009513878,
-0.0288436338,
-0.0161278583,
0.0413934849,
0.0226601157,
-0.0062407674,
-0.0237102825,
0.0699789971,
0.0046777483,
0.0229693353,
0.001490759,
-0.0040592132,
0.0067691281,
0.0312333424,
0.0021918416,
0.0029599692,
0.0280589722,
0.0557400137,
-0.0380003974,
0.0014743786,
0.1194308475,
-0.0029349979,
-0.0404215865,
0.0133656729,
-0.0242800545,
0.024065841,
0.0099678859,
0.0471092947,
-0.0576067418,
-0.032729134,
0.0062538139,
0.0433289111,
-0.0207347013,
0.0023554584,
-0.0041355002,
-0.1255354732,
0.0228117686,
0.0100898091,
-0.071139276,
-0.0603724457,
-0.0399641804,
0.0140262684,
-0.0254652146,
0.048380997,
0.0066921981,
-0.0183632225,
-0.01778627,
0.0178887788,
-0.0339449905,
-0.0714371502,
0.0613855496,
-0.008272592,
0.0905596018,
0.0468991809,
0.0485052317,
0.0062311664,
-0.0052007632,
0.0214843936,
-0.0144089116,
-0.0012873639,
-0.0015555262,
0.0406824797,
-0.0115464218,
-0.0152408136,
-0.0127925109,
0.0339093469,
-0.0175287221,
0.0307645481,
0.0157746524,
0.0648674071,
-0.0136999972,
0.0071852691,
0.0159968212,
0.0385730416,
0.0013176372,
0.0585973151,
0.0258561075,
-0.0534383655,
-0.0118526584,
-0.0227581281,
-0.0108975759,
0.0052355984,
-0.03202812,
0.0392849371,
-0.0864175037,
0.0051472131,
-0.0795099363,
-0.0559760854,
0.0500876121,
0.0236308705,
0.0179009233,
0.0251628421,
-0.0101806698,
0.0318010375,
0.0345717818,
0.0449071974,
-0.0320552401,
0.0074075209,
-0.0801859796,
-0.0608190186,
0.0284115225,
-0.071127139,
0.0148890065,
0.0118457861,
-0.0086111361,
-0.0436515957,
0.0203373171,
0.0607862882,
0.0192725286,
0.03489035,
-0.0079192119,
-0.0640897453,
-0.0322304331,
0.0426422656,
-0.0171991941,
-0.0056712902,
0.0328337066,
0.025124805,
-0.027437605,
0.0337837189,
-0.0328718685,
0.0337042026,
-0.0127924001,
0.0306171067,
-0.0154608367,
-0.050215207,
0.0146001652,
0.0464345105,
0.0221227743,
-0.0138539616,
-0.0359297581,
-0.020018464,
0.0423070453,
-0.0290547851,
0.0033261429,
-0.0382515751,
-0.0408646092,
0.02870005,
-0.0135004167,
-0.0178135131,
-0.0227748305,
-0.0201120544,
-0.0065609016,
-0.0277304258,
0.0149216484,
-0.0003474763,
0.0189095214,
0.0194716752,
0.011213162,
-0.0303585455,
-0.0157127064,
0.015598177,
0.0239212215,
-0.0073236781,
0.0969288275,
-0.007942941,
-0.004814866,
0.0244622417,
0.0506316572,
-0.0296967477,
-0.0564560369,
-0.0308807809,
0.0416642465,
0.0510846861,
0.022043379,
0.0740375742,
-0.0240963809,
0.0033154464,
-0.039239157,
0.0315472446,
-0.015721688,
0.0003816166,
0.0298805367,
0.0153806126,
0.0080623478,
0.0140541298,
0.0701228157,
0.0179081298,
0.06381955,
-0.0027588671,
0.0023157934,
-0.0397428498,
-0.0193883516,
0.0196150709,
0.0285457093,
-0.033186499,
0.0016524933,
-0.0252940916,
-0.0546313748,
-0.0476369523,
0.0002739066,
-0.0151582984,
-0.0309397485,
0.0350915268,
0.0262195691,
-0.0257813595,
-0.0080989935,
-0.059074793,
-0.0084982449,
-0.0418258198,
0.0145226615,
0.0387169607,
-6.615560249e-33,
-0.0553636402,
0.0082464013,
0.0313729085,
-0.0068159658,
-0.0191877577,
-0.0101272278,
-0.0271317903,
0.0093996972,
-0.0477117151,
-0.0053144917,
-0.0168472696,
-0.0002490503,
0.0270875487,
0.0153248236,
0.0049256426,
-0.0209075417,
0.0203161612,
0.0010933233,
-0.0284766722,
0.0394393317,
-0.0088363765,
0.0226447079,
0.0409195572,
-0.058802411,
0.009187012,
-0.0072957771,
0.0053653428,
-0.0024478454,
-0.0201325249,
0.0707087666,
-0.0244374126,
0.0441055074,
0.0338316597,
-0.0120016495,
-0.0128815677,
-0.0119617786,
-0.0850605592,
-0.0106616188,
0.0221679788,
0.028169129,
-0.0381834693,
-0.0361426622,
0.0160826556,
-0.033792723,
-0.0352157392,
-0.0126171866,
0.0019189625,
-0.0657273009,
0.0143279685,
0.0376177058,
-0.0526834875,
0.0166004281,
-0.0155379251,
-0.0715457052,
-0.0219996125,
0.0585930347,
-0.0378543958,
0.0287227295,
-0.0216434337,
0.0228897016,
0.0180726536,
0.0286926478,
0.0438610241,
-0.0011053035,
0.0183129013,
0.0378758982,
0.028320957,
-0.0180719271,
0.030493075,
-0.0344169773,
0.0067545888,
0.0326587819,
0.0448165946,
0.0429357104,
0.0285926182,
-0.0173907131,
-0.0685175285,
0.0213658437,
0.0207686722,
0.0240709037,
0.0196457021,
0.0105079161,
-0.0621082112,
0.0025625101,
-0.0112189464,
0.0157495625,
-0.0155573655,
-0.0671782866,
0.0436921418,
0.0308047906,
-0.0186966024,
-0.0294670295,
0.055745203,
-0.0476898402,
0.0303582139,
-0.0305159688,
-0.0309725851,
0.0227424614,
-0.0245623179,
0.0137103824,
-0.0671305507,
-0.0553453341,
0.0458727218,
-0.0360157788,
0.0307653509,
0.0067970851,
0.011494753,
0.0227013826,
-0.0528936647,
0.0136439772,
-0.022833664,
0.0250317417,
-0.0158047117,
0.0349687263,
0.0073246281,
0.004217078,
-0.0164483413,
0.0786037892,
-0.0023423031,
-0.0000461543,
-0.0419335663,
-0.0468058363,
-0.0019068655,
-0.0197728109,
-0.0599491633,
0.0365419351,
-0.047927238,
0.022287881,
-0.0090015316,
-0.0352402404,
-0.0171165764,
0.0013092454,
2.91e-7,
0.0333107337,
0.0470756628,
0.007684873,
-0.0063414816,
0.0169768259,
0.0063865073,
-0.0343798772,
0.0192323811,
0.0255172625,
0.0096357996,
0.0277661458,
0.0314448066,
0.0830763355,
-0.0081763733,
-0.0801514909,
-0.038732104,
-0.0690949038,
-0.0146150207,
-0.0373235643,
-0.0289468542,
0.0387591273,
0.1061853841,
-0.0446388535,
-0.0033394843,
-0.0009902269,
-0.0318136103,
0.0570678525,
-0.0272336174,
-0.0320805162,
0.0399484523,
0.0461481549,
0.0228178091,
-0.0047594304,
0.0049109398,
0.0068722498,
0.0181328841,
0.0165253151,
0.1123939157,
-0.0189971868,
0.0032332318,
0.0404938534,
0.0175342914,
-0.0155302342,
-0.0569807813,
0.0680740923,
-0.042892769,
-0.0419585146,
-0.0001200449,
-0.0055159172,
-0.0107753044,
0.0453855135,
-0.0498794951,
-0.0354183242,
0.0480403043,
0.0271831062,
-0.0169587098,
-0.032228291,
-0.0317173861,
0.0029284304,
-0.0041403729,
-0.0466771238,
-0.084590897,
-0.0084616784,
-0.0268517137,
-0.0021084191,
-0.0645524561,
0.0181006584,
2.244344732e-34,
0.0164936204,
-0.0050519905,
0.0410172939,
0.0171220154,
0.0338482186,
-0.013474633,
0.0174977705,
0.0244985856,
0.0267720185,
-0.0865959674,
-0.0109436661
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04635v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04635v1 | Can NLP Models 'Identify', 'Distinguish', and 'Justify' Questions that Don't have a Definitive Answer? | 2023-09-08T23:12:03 | 2023-09-08T23:12:03 | Ayushi Agarwal, Nisarg Patel, Neeraj Varshney, Mihir Parmar, Pavan Mallina, Aryan Bhavin Shah, Srihari Raju Sangaraju, Tirth Patel, Nihar Thakkar, Chitta Baral | cs.CL | cs.CL | Though state-of-the-art (SOTA) NLP systems have achieved remarkable
performance on a variety of language understanding tasks, they primarily focus
on questions that have a correct and a definitive answer. However, in
real-world applications, users often ask questions that don't have a definitive
answer. Incorrectly answering such questions certainly hampers a system's
reliability and trustworthiness. Can SOTA models accurately identify such
questions and provide a reasonable response?
To investigate the above question, we introduce QnotA, a dataset consisting
of five different categories of questions that don't have definitive answers.
Furthermore, for each QnotA instance, we also provide a corresponding QA
instance i.e. an alternate question that ''can be'' answered. With this data,
we formulate three evaluation tasks that test a system's ability to 'identify',
'distinguish', and 'justify' QnotA questions. Through comprehensive
experiments, we show that even SOTA models including GPT-3 and Flan T5 do not
fare well on these tasks and lack considerably behind the human performance
baseline. We conduct a thorough analysis which further leads to several
interesting findings. Overall, we believe our work and findings will encourage
and facilitate further research in this important area and help develop more
robust models. | [
0.0873442814,
0.0470751263,
-0.0207795892,
0.0356398225,
-0.042556867,
0.0270143673,
0.0028555396,
-0.0038846941,
0.0102462191,
-0.0379358642,
0.0059688799,
-0.0356802866,
-0.0246619917,
0.016276652,
0.0019318664,
-0.0491302684,
0.0382963568,
0.0084803086,
0.0205200892,
0.0046571023,
0.0270883124,
0.0142359948,
-0.01938501,
0.0288575217,
0.0159011744,
-0.0373992585,
-0.0258160774,
-0.0136711681,
-0.0263938978,
-0.0185994618,
0.0406875014,
0.0621016212,
-0.0218026508,
0.0487470627,
0.0000017963,
-0.0549251288,
-0.0151327094,
-0.0227309912,
-0.0544344522,
-0.0145093827,
-0.0022430308,
0.0151767172,
0.0447936878,
0.0471438095,
-0.0456754602,
-0.0128951315,
0.0516914427,
0.0700466409,
0.0677470565,
0.0396717042,
0.0052920934,
-0.0164006855,
0.0046258564,
0.0225439016,
0.0182453133,
-0.076417245,
0.0104814628,
-0.0046805623,
-0.0207750034,
-0.0009118637,
-0.0151249524,
0.0246581379,
0.0356655084,
0.0131705813,
-0.0138341142,
0.0115042245,
-0.0543088838,
-0.0478573889,
-0.03434572,
0.0838248506,
-0.0023467415,
-0.0690368935,
-0.0124967899,
0.0003908109,
-0.0005084578,
0.0338328406,
-0.0188508723,
0.0033211226,
-0.0270937197,
-0.0432611443,
0.025985688,
0.0175339282,
0.0108148986,
0.0126948385,
0.0169668086,
0.1065032631,
-0.0042013996,
-0.058551427,
0.0278181136,
0.0021046593,
-0.0609753504,
-0.0442432575,
0.0403984897,
0.0514691845,
-0.0231816024,
0.0344068818,
0.0211201459,
0.0296746194,
0.0414608046,
-0.019093886,
0.0042552333,
0.0424412638,
-0.0337734893,
0.0603779294,
-0.0062500737,
0.0304903165,
-0.0005652069,
0.0032592101,
-0.0369370505,
-0.0306706131,
-0.0492016748,
-0.0368768573,
-0.0249913074,
0.0501837097,
-0.0415298603,
0.0142044211,
-0.0279819816,
0.0170020796,
-0.0017604043,
0.0343049429,
0.0147271901,
0.0506105199,
-0.0303821079,
-0.0080021918,
-0.0884895176,
0.0273603536,
-0.0601542778,
0.0440519974,
-0.0060344036,
-0.0740849748,
0.0051992144,
0.0056882636,
0.0099793859,
-0.0150808794,
0.013999803,
0.0386565737,
0.0350138769,
-0.03277326,
-0.0191892479,
-0.0205585528,
-0.0005474168,
-0.0718252659,
-0.01270115,
-0.031467244,
0.0127485413,
0.0425450988,
-0.0051343371,
-0.0014670672,
-0.0090415282,
0.0414504744,
0.0160247777,
0.1091552228,
-0.0123195695,
0.0497981496,
0.0323007256,
-0.007256174,
-0.027102232,
0.050850857,
-0.0000677641,
0.0045068683,
0.0722094402,
-0.0326723494,
0.0711143762,
-0.017222859,
-0.0019448703,
-0.0162848607,
0.0293178596,
0.0683582127,
-0.0391305611,
0.0203243252,
-0.02796847,
0.0661916509,
0.0042243726,
-0.0609462373,
0.0709360838,
0.0847888812,
-0.0300839618,
-0.0093026599,
0.0455715396,
-0.003716015,
0.0231497623,
0.0416400209,
-0.035743501,
0.0021130238,
-0.0420440845,
0.0100217136,
-0.0151854828,
-0.0120856101,
-0.0364495963,
-0.0635501817,
-0.0569918118,
0.0066633024,
0.0089195631,
0.0398250856,
0.0133529259,
-0.0088784844,
-0.021220861,
0.0333450884,
-0.0240804553,
-0.0261045545,
0.0090072276,
-0.0637691393,
0.0982805118,
-0.0036824069,
0.0438488647,
-0.0463250466,
-0.0345059894,
-0.015932288,
-0.01799348,
0.0291525368,
0.0881802365,
-0.0248141922,
0.0186978076,
-0.0221577045,
0.0187316351,
0.0322009772,
0.0224484764,
-0.0077623739,
0.0250067078,
-0.0096354922,
0.0007138692,
-0.0858158469,
-0.0182689205,
0.0401502848,
0.000287249,
-0.0120251337,
-0.0071199909,
0.0067186616,
0.0322199464,
0.0133176045,
0.0322772935,
0.0165963899,
0.0185689032,
0.0094777672,
-0.0350417532,
-0.021806214,
-0.024401458,
0.0060528689,
0.0074510844,
0.0016572354,
-0.0498378277,
0.071128428,
-0.0359021313,
-0.0422518328,
0.0071901642,
-0.0251504276,
-0.0057294182,
-0.0621563084,
-0.0027969393,
0.0053879828,
-0.0047211228,
-0.0593617186,
0.0618026219,
0.0018308252,
0.0479236431,
-0.0459059887,
-0.0083757434,
0.0306406952,
-0.0258973185,
-0.0461294204,
-0.0056013339,
-0.0089127282,
0.0137572307,
0.0298502725,
-0.006742137,
-0.0885796249,
-0.0034480004,
-0.0682283938,
0.0250734612,
-0.0275646988,
0.0224641524,
0.0588236153,
-0.0121601932,
-0.012967688,
-0.0247144438,
-0.0656376481,
0.0244523585,
0.0274028219,
0.0344803408,
0.0707912073,
-0.0110555915,
0.0179584641,
-0.0529764816,
-0.0050458307,
-0.0242087599,
0.008359462,
0.0020611607,
0.0008635431,
-0.0473141037,
0.0237502195,
-0.0288466103,
0.0132392133,
0.0305276178,
-0.0041039223,
0.0053727482,
0.0128106773,
-0.0285520256,
0.0505219549,
0.0071390532,
0.0089766858,
0.0113184517,
0.0286126081,
-0.0485785604,
0.0304335691,
-0.0583309717,
-0.0580765307,
0.0130741987,
-0.0192257632,
0.0175133795,
0.0471857861,
0.0289869849,
-0.0136635443,
-0.0756635144,
0.0374799743,
-0.0398175456,
0.0095368866,
-0.0490233935,
-0.0140379136,
0.0017141416,
0.094137311,
-0.0144586721,
-0.0395477712,
0.0981287807,
0.0090679992,
-0.0187225621,
-0.0630741641,
-0.0177554768,
-0.0529409833,
0.0685196817,
-0.0114940722,
0.003705075,
0.0628625751,
-0.0504787043,
-0.0181842539,
-0.0475570224,
-0.0137096485,
-0.0440159328,
0.0519441701,
-0.0330156237,
-0.0149105145,
-0.0005618403,
-0.0373390764,
-0.059520144,
-0.0538288243,
-0.018094942,
-0.0073100501,
-0.0290740151,
0.0079307146,
-0.0006077216,
0.0079647815,
0.0022920726,
0.0293128733,
-0.0370092653,
-0.0274746418,
-0.0335746817,
0.0653596669,
0.0624971688,
0.0385408513,
0.0765882358,
0.0050776028,
0.0221987721,
0.0353767425,
0.0254598297,
-0.0006640957,
-0.0059486269,
0.0165708717,
0.0308902115,
-0.0362356156,
-0.0022491491,
0.0362467505,
0.0639606789,
-0.0347000696,
-0.0383782908,
0.0860363469,
0.0648008436,
-0.0046480335,
-0.0074669365,
-0.0419748984,
0.0012898335,
0.0249286219,
0.0293200202,
-0.0440779477,
-0.0378969125,
0.0007124154,
0.0409523211,
-0.0419911556,
-0.0000767396,
-0.0242110435,
-0.1011431292,
0.029310666,
-0.0442197323,
-0.0230656937,
-0.0213587694,
-0.0592189394,
0.0004222771,
-0.0295695793,
0.0586821325,
0.0105999876,
0.0051664039,
0.0218386538,
0.0260550641,
-0.0403995216,
-0.0304721482,
0.0451535136,
-0.0061439597,
0.0418532565,
0.043775171,
0.0309121758,
-0.0239748191,
-0.0499962047,
-0.0093166633,
-0.0809506401,
-0.0250429958,
-0.0158190653,
0.0522208624,
0.0391502678,
0.0060818186,
-0.0223003644,
0.0292228293,
-0.058052253,
0.0178222302,
0.0370492265,
0.0599557161,
-0.0211998541,
-0.0367887728,
0.0036695637,
-0.0152548617,
-0.020528866,
0.0863376558,
0.0539980084,
-0.015747264,
-0.0724967197,
-0.0237100609,
0.0027603828,
-0.0328572877,
-0.0343756452,
-0.0089208502,
0.034230981,
0.0104428604,
-0.06687022,
-0.0816425607,
0.0183499232,
0.0140060904,
0.0045468505,
0.0041023563,
0.0245140716,
0.0149959931,
-0.0107762385,
0.0164447278,
-0.0171768554,
-0.0092522036,
-0.0353453383,
0.0276641846,
0.0236902907,
-0.046007663,
-0.0122221755,
-0.0170525797,
-0.0276990905,
-0.022743009,
0.0049946909,
-0.0032271752,
0.0421277508,
-0.0385614112,
-0.0441679731,
-0.0599367246,
-0.0296671335,
0.0114616156,
-0.0255306419,
-0.0343469456,
0.0120917466,
0.0032237626,
-0.0152777852,
0.0479229055,
-0.010264135,
0.0193959232,
0.0024961808,
0.0270899199,
-0.0595344789,
0.0009178079,
0.0702947527,
0.0405042991,
0.0356706157,
0.0391718149,
0.0143551882,
-0.0159787182,
-0.0120140603,
0.025774993,
-0.0128679844,
0.001454403,
-0.0035321829,
0.0214291234,
-0.0249930657,
-0.0352657288,
-0.0492017455,
-0.0662901327,
0.045373898,
-0.0211734157,
-0.0471231006,
0.0571687818,
0.0142339598,
-0.0349841677,
-0.0166052692,
-0.0344851539,
-0.0139908278,
0.0168425236,
0.0794878826,
0.0394645743,
0.0723254234,
0.0026072462,
-0.0037426446,
0.0061229854,
-0.0107137226,
-0.0725243166,
-0.0485474542,
0.0078335796,
0.0148469331,
0.0259262007,
-0.0101363556,
0.0056918743,
-0.0031880459,
-0.0080396198,
-0.0083499951,
-0.0136807533,
0.0446735583,
-0.0101748379,
0.0559382364,
0.0297308657,
-0.0199460257,
0.0048875981,
0.0214928724,
-0.0253974795,
0.0367470682,
-0.0086614741,
-0.0419640578,
-0.0269855093,
-0.0046484545,
-0.0187696777,
0.0076895524,
-0.0227815118,
0.053961549,
-0.0735486746,
-0.0665072426,
0.0106109995,
0.0094596259,
0.0335808657,
-0.0104145212,
-0.0075346534,
0.0698728785,
0.0225504227,
-0.0305872578,
-0.0590439439,
0.0030445037,
-0.0281035621,
0.0090024741,
-0.0664314628,
-6.487852339e-33,
0.0031212552,
-0.0503060482,
0.0045945016,
-0.0324626267,
0.0389987007,
0.0170758814,
-0.0302900169,
0.0061379541,
-0.0532240048,
-0.0071259961,
-0.0336132683,
0.0178003963,
0.0067296536,
0.0065901908,
0.0162183363,
-0.0476996824,
0.007240592,
0.0022150618,
-0.0240648855,
0.0116438409,
0.0516363345,
-0.0220271423,
0.0140364869,
-0.0307321958,
0.0629463345,
-0.0163297746,
-0.000927214,
0.0479232036,
-0.0607917011,
0.0562899299,
-0.0394628495,
0.0634529814,
0.0427624546,
-0.0309101436,
0.0520359613,
0.0020859477,
-0.0467319787,
-0.0456271879,
0.0567680486,
-0.0000405039,
-0.0552976914,
0.0207692068,
0.0400351323,
-0.0173796806,
0.0079223644,
0.0230925083,
0.0214675702,
-0.0037668247,
0.0352597907,
-0.0057506813,
-0.0221240502,
0.0004592827,
-0.0143398941,
-0.0223959014,
-0.0175487865,
0.0890770033,
-0.0321379267,
0.013269023,
-0.0662834048,
-0.0094992947,
-0.0013673855,
0.0190747771,
0.0502504483,
-0.0408219807,
-0.0486731902,
0.0274577476,
0.0148970261,
-0.0213475488,
-0.0086020632,
-0.0175320264,
-0.0211977623,
0.0108746514,
0.0983097106,
0.0464503579,
0.0538173877,
-0.0036007436,
-0.0456463732,
0.0222163089,
0.0164639652,
0.036225494,
0.0381921344,
-0.0209938362,
-0.0841846094,
0.0072140866,
-0.0755926818,
0.0023632329,
-0.0807015672,
-0.0163422264,
0.0725341961,
-0.0073464229,
-0.0176216774,
0.0016884116,
-0.0109866932,
-0.0254029986,
0.0138636148,
-0.0180801116,
-0.0080822362,
-0.0116425902,
0.032979127,
0.0693462342,
-0.034306176,
0.0118888943,
-0.022874875,
-0.0028457011,
0.0041684941,
-0.0013130791,
0.0378639065,
0.0036304512,
-0.0430882871,
0.0083863884,
-0.0237183757,
0.0458335169,
-0.0317875557,
0.0014738627,
0.0417818055,
0.043229688,
-0.0315328017,
0.0379643179,
0.0087602902,
0.0048581832,
-0.0627373308,
0.0053736768,
-0.0205797181,
0.0196172856,
-0.0423414186,
-0.008035901,
0.0036050722,
0.0242152605,
-0.051633466,
-0.0354442187,
0.0030623188,
0.0190700237,
2.503e-7,
0.0374348573,
0.0260109883,
0.0248607397,
0.009208383,
0.0064815567,
0.051873941,
0.005240595,
0.0246409606,
0.0504397191,
-0.0416045524,
-0.0302508604,
-0.0201194417,
0.0179924686,
0.0324980877,
-0.0283635389,
-0.0063936403,
-0.0152700357,
0.008856697,
-0.0275228936,
0.0351256952,
0.0863815099,
0.080249913,
0.0237424485,
0.0017366573,
-0.0303984247,
-0.0109157702,
0.0169543661,
0.0027153157,
-0.0156815406,
0.0143302763,
0.0650048107,
0.0303443614,
0.0359793082,
0.0694034025,
0.0177211389,
0.00221532,
0.0098637687,
0.0297564194,
-0.005453317,
-0.068381615,
-0.03484248,
-0.0127252471,
0.0274968278,
-0.1038263142,
0.0835377499,
-0.0381598696,
-0.0521649197,
0.0232489649,
-0.0186876599,
-0.0115265446,
0.0095318528,
-0.0120575828,
-0.0185937732,
-0.0058886581,
-0.0086483648,
-0.0030365884,
-0.0036475549,
-0.0578012168,
-0.0058158413,
0.0140917981,
0.0090114009,
-0.0060238526,
-0.0143058226,
0.007515131,
0.0127429832,
-0.0853494108,
-0.0037828058,
2.071279132e-34,
0.0211495422,
0.0161665026,
0.0201965291,
0.0136529785,
0.030955432,
0.0294105932,
-0.0086367885,
-0.0234114416,
0.0182059351,
-0.0278158709,
0.0048811128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04607v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04607v1 | Linking Symptom Inventories using Semantic Textual Similarity | 2023-09-08T21:50:10 | 2023-09-08T21:50:10 | Eamonn Kennedy, Shashank Vadlamani, Hannah M Lindsey, Kelly S Peterson, Kristen Dams OConnor, Kenton Murray, Ronak Agarwal, Houshang H Amiri, Raeda K Andersen, Talin Babikian, David A Baron, Erin D Bigler, Karen Caeyenberghs, Lisa Delano-Wood, Seth G Disner, Ekaterina Dobryakova, Blessen C Eapen, Rachel M Edelstein, Carrie Esopenko, Helen M Genova, Elbert Geuze, Naomi J Goodrich-Hunsaker, Jordan Grafman, Asta K Haberg, Cooper B Hodges, Kristen R Hoskinson, Elizabeth S Hovenden, Andrei Irimia, Neda Jahanshad, Ruchira M Jha, Finian Keleher, Kimbra Kenney, Inga K Koerte, Spencer W Liebel, Abigail Livny, Marianne Lovstad, Sarah L Martindale, Jeffrey E Max, Andrew R Mayer, Timothy B Meier, Deleene S Menefee, Abdalla Z Mohamed, Stefania Mondello, Martin M Monti, Rajendra A Morey, Virginia Newcombe, Mary R Newsome, Alexander Olsen, Nicholas J Pastorek, Mary Jo Pugh, Adeel Razi, Jacob E Resch, Jared A Rowland, Kelly Russell, Nicholas P Ryan, Randall S Scheibel, Adam T Schmidt, Gershon Spitz, Jaclyn A Stephens, Assaf Tal, Leah D Talbert, Maria Carmela Tartaglia, Brian A Taylor, Sophia I Thomopoulos, Maya Troyanskaya, Eve M Valera, Harm Jan van der Horn, John D Van Horn, Ragini Verma, Benjamin SC Wade, Willian SC Walker, Ashley L Ware, J Kent Werner Jr, Keith Owen Yeates, Ross D Zafonte, Michael M Zeineh, Brandon Zielinski, Paul M Thompson, Frank G Hillary, David F Tate, Elisabeth A Wilde, Emily L Dennis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | An extensive library of symptom inventories has been developed over time to
measure clinical symptoms, but this variety has led to several long standing
issues. Most notably, results drawn from different settings and studies are not
comparable, which limits reproducibility. Here, we present an artificial
intelligence (AI) approach using semantic textual similarity (STS) to link
symptoms and scores across previously incongruous symptom inventories. We
tested the ability of four pre-trained STS models to screen thousands of
symptom description pairs for related content - a challenging task typically
requiring expert panels. Models were tasked to predict symptom severity across
four different inventories for 6,607 participants drawn from 16 international
data sources. The STS approach achieved 74.8% accuracy across five tasks,
outperforming other models tested. This work suggests that incorporating
contextual, semantic information can assist expert decision-making processes,
yielding gains for both general and disease-specific clinical assessment. | [
0.0245030243,
0.014865038,
-0.0164013691,
-0.0343978107,
-0.017503405,
0.0228409898,
0.0060274135,
0.0393986739,
0.0538595654,
-0.0350585692,
0.0016944092,
0.0365823582,
-0.0183013901,
0.0166255254,
-0.0226677489,
-0.0486974791,
0.0065966519,
0.0575817898,
0.0208525993,
0.016488133,
-0.0008497044,
0.0435801111,
-0.0244228113,
0.0310422517,
-0.0100749386,
-0.0082185082,
0.0692316294,
-0.0103463689,
0.0663583353,
-0.0769702941,
-0.0249346457,
0.0236676577,
-0.0224181265,
-0.0412640758,
0.0000019936,
-0.0603196099,
-0.0303080007,
0.0151657276,
0.0175179876,
-0.0373769328,
0.0517264195,
-0.0038634865,
0.0403696969,
0.0194773506,
-0.0353647545,
-0.0240464509,
0.0333776362,
0.0598787479,
0.0340239778,
0.0319212191,
-0.0529514402,
-0.0019400814,
-0.0121930018,
0.0241082124,
0.0146065457,
-0.0148505978,
0.0262909159,
0.0138943959,
0.047051616,
-0.0288169235,
0.0109194666,
0.031967707,
-0.0055920659,
0.079667531,
-0.0110369585,
0.0717786551,
-0.012337015,
-0.0031108579,
0.0276127458,
0.0701196566,
0.0079997769,
-0.025606839,
0.0268392414,
-0.0126508633,
0.0061682933,
0.0550771132,
-0.0068984358,
-0.0222788732,
-0.0325665101,
0.0383324772,
0.0498680919,
0.0481589288,
0.0246268623,
-0.0189763755,
0.0039023396,
0.0378368609,
-0.0058397637,
-0.0467283539,
0.0219677091,
-0.0212573092,
-0.0320835561,
-0.0684266016,
0.0253159013,
-0.005846594,
-0.064686507,
0.0146395853,
-0.0065472471,
-0.037203975,
0.05593995,
-0.0510085784,
-0.0003733651,
0.0451538712,
-0.0031412533,
0.0024816534,
-0.0116018858,
-0.0260104407,
0.0136505533,
0.0231656265,
-0.0673761442,
-0.0274075978,
-0.0734809935,
0.0056780628,
-0.0396247022,
0.0222271979,
0.013586198,
-0.0358443782,
-0.0521166213,
-0.0076971599,
-0.0263977442,
-0.0084916465,
0.0023771713,
0.0288857948,
0.0362880826,
0.0432423949,
-0.0254966021,
-0.023622917,
-0.059383627,
0.0292948894,
0.0002809099,
0.0031251102,
0.0486831516,
-0.0035055808,
0.0128555847,
-0.0067568924,
0.044422023,
0.0163557529,
0.023162676,
0.0097302133,
-0.0200110786,
-0.0458139442,
-0.0288769901,
0.0141671617,
-0.0642460883,
-0.065555647,
0.0452160388,
0.0358535573,
0.0044612074,
-0.046038527,
-0.0080941888,
0.0347587205,
-0.0572722368,
0.0451401807,
-0.0303612594,
0.0292734429,
0.0093077952,
0.015657844,
0.0207253508,
-0.0353582315,
0.0179586187,
0.0083864713,
0.0271866303,
0.002257118,
0.0155461282,
-0.0276519265,
0.0157194324,
-0.0187794454,
0.0184996221,
-0.0173706897,
0.0046867728,
0.051207535,
-0.0550748557,
0.0656512901,
0.002327045,
-0.0076009408,
0.0287466813,
0.0800546184,
0.0508599915,
0.0379956551,
0.0142907519,
-0.0063700378,
-0.0212875362,
-0.0138931982,
-0.0088489912,
-0.0104268389,
-0.0463730805,
-0.0129179237,
0.0402068272,
0.0050296383,
-0.041753266,
-0.0647152141,
-0.0685599819,
0.0020771371,
-0.0195857957,
0.0116696116,
-0.0080835335,
-0.0199907403,
0.0124332123,
0.0116580958,
0.0571693294,
-0.0336164832,
-0.0416798294,
-0.0032969359,
-0.0023012953,
0.0856877044,
0.0051439437,
-0.0429007821,
-0.0125902891,
0.0163631383,
0.0107445912,
-0.0438680872,
0.0305828974,
-0.014841266,
-0.0168841537,
-0.0084822578,
-0.0017765278,
0.0406198874,
-0.0074631311,
-0.0307789501,
-0.0577416047,
0.0154707544,
-0.0110031869,
-0.0402563773,
-0.0351109058,
0.0670634806,
-0.030409703,
-0.0099322181,
0.0035942316,
-0.0015494024,
0.068543233,
0.0248277653,
0.0057206647,
0.0306021273,
0.0092943963,
-0.0581350699,
-0.0897376016,
0.0399199128,
-0.0421126187,
-0.0166179016,
-0.0014126842,
-0.0248392392,
0.0476379804,
-0.0060982285,
-0.049226705,
-0.0195603464,
0.0208707768,
-0.0443297066,
0.0097029246,
0.014581956,
-0.0240284018,
0.0204127803,
0.0114402203,
-0.0328850038,
0.0378609486,
-0.0148097584,
0.0148439119,
-0.0205695573,
-0.0356510058,
-0.0089703659,
-0.0179462302,
-0.0390367359,
-0.0373111814,
0.0080290986,
-0.0099512357,
-0.0223271903,
-0.0369878449,
0.0085488176,
-0.0174734779,
-0.1488579363,
0.0030944746,
0.0335992202,
-0.0093788272,
0.0161907058,
0.0080702174,
-0.0243033636,
-0.0118806018,
-0.0612199865,
0.0019501377,
0.0385798588,
0.0258128606,
0.0319991559,
0.0270285159,
0.0027221495,
-0.0796703845,
-0.0106382929,
-0.0749133751,
0.0326338075,
0.0565290004,
-0.0225514863,
-0.0212330669,
0.0182672851,
-0.0710054263,
0.0082757706,
0.0312176179,
0.0199292265,
-0.0391399935,
-0.0090468433,
-0.0012743589,
0.0103755714,
0.0069130813,
0.0244387798,
0.06760782,
0.01713432,
-0.067159228,
0.0048024757,
-0.0534896813,
0.009774969,
-0.0113988677,
-0.0572307222,
0.0406727754,
0.048840683,
0.0566659272,
-0.0057975352,
-0.0318041258,
0.0334808677,
-0.0196251497,
0.0371761285,
-0.0288135502,
-0.0156268273,
0.0316661261,
0.0304955617,
-0.0101715662,
-0.0397638306,
0.0779359788,
-0.0166650899,
0.0611308478,
-0.0880396515,
-0.0202343576,
-0.0232470725,
0.0055593099,
0.0124545833,
0.0355137028,
-0.0062686722,
0.0478960127,
0.017605694,
0.009386166,
0.0309468973,
-0.0309010558,
0.0382427908,
-0.0219923332,
0.0082441783,
0.0317380279,
-0.0368219092,
-0.0334895141,
-0.028338436,
-0.0276750084,
0.0180951692,
-0.002876017,
0.0218641665,
-0.0754080638,
0.0155395325,
-0.0065171733,
0.0214627665,
0.0559951253,
-0.038852606,
0.0300661698,
-0.0043610581,
0.0234697536,
-0.0280517749,
0.0322220139,
-0.0130528323,
0.029683847,
0.0346820392,
-0.0188400559,
0.0243591499,
0.0120215937,
0.001274407,
-0.0387493186,
-0.0605277307,
-0.0122070918,
0.0226404574,
-0.0554893762,
-0.0188927967,
0.0088639716,
0.1257115006,
0.0553633459,
-0.0430719852,
0.024063902,
-0.0558277331,
-0.0054593924,
0.0085245483,
-0.0151596889,
-0.0443690158,
-0.0428966917,
-0.0271592159,
0.0169888679,
-0.0394071788,
-0.0259906854,
0.0189797599,
0.002859755,
-0.0237786602,
-0.0326429158,
-0.0461187288,
-0.0190152247,
-0.0159155056,
0.008573846,
-0.0072733709,
-0.0384807624,
-0.0595694594,
-0.0004626072,
0.026970882,
0.0072469739,
-0.0887698159,
-0.0252074748,
0.0561785996,
-0.0490695126,
0.0455602407,
0.0309533682,
0.0773130879,
0.015223708,
-0.0299595874,
-0.0304537695,
-0.0288326684,
0.0168337878,
0.0062540136,
0.0776217803,
-0.0101664858,
0.0427270941,
-0.0614810139,
0.0441223569,
-0.0523950309,
-0.0086806435,
0.0256261081,
0.0994480848,
-0.0273040384,
-0.0327677354,
-0.0413074456,
0.0437654182,
0.0142547796,
0.0593767315,
-0.0070958501,
0.0137635767,
-0.0028125111,
0.0720958412,
0.024015598,
0.0167758428,
-0.0203453004,
0.0376810245,
-0.0142136822,
-0.0204692185,
-0.0886627734,
-0.0562827624,
0.0220005363,
-0.0420164093,
0.0080119781,
-0.013226944,
-0.018023273,
-0.0149342278,
-0.0736865103,
0.0183195081,
0.048684068,
0.0327125862,
0.0112811094,
0.0053564454,
0.0516428463,
0.0177912917,
-0.0279168654,
0.0043278448,
-0.0403649844,
0.0120697161,
-0.0007978798,
-0.012801026,
0.0096112723,
-0.0113455299,
-0.0049098921,
0.009345782,
0.0290088318,
0.012941164,
-0.0411516689,
-0.0022885313,
-0.0149818733,
0.0307688564,
0.0231400952,
0.0220168326,
-0.0289449468,
0.0726335272,
0.0158266202,
0.0023857995,
0.0108232442,
-0.0108094728,
0.0528808124,
0.0091294078,
-0.0049366779,
0.0124710845,
-0.025569994,
-0.0250726882,
-0.0404077023,
0.0187122803,
-0.0096448585,
0.0110949986,
-0.0052332231,
-0.0128568681,
0.0150443232,
-0.0272398386,
0.0319809653,
-0.0465640984,
-0.0103544313,
-0.0588849038,
0.0239600707,
0.0135272909,
0.0244323928,
-0.0156357549,
-0.0199746806,
0.0089597013,
-0.0106744915,
-0.0102391783,
-0.007101885,
-0.0259056929,
0.0505486205,
0.0114497887,
0.041551739,
0.00227152,
0.0530953445,
-0.0156720355,
-0.0746896267,
-0.0211753324,
-0.0337827094,
0.0268590655,
-0.0206270441,
0.0338558592,
-0.0182499737,
0.0191725735,
-0.0079301167,
-0.0533023775,
-0.0261506103,
0.0009937523,
0.0265223794,
-0.0124091683,
-0.0032613098,
-0.0236624274,
0.0508403927,
-0.0490941405,
0.0168945696,
0.0259537213,
-0.0762007833,
-0.0018631173,
-0.0273865554,
0.0219286568,
0.0389845558,
-0.064879559,
-0.0297147594,
-0.0677925646,
-0.0266609062,
0.0398477614,
-0.0227374658,
-0.0096759899,
0.0161563456,
0.0509784631,
0.0290466864,
-0.0096406648,
0.0036561689,
-0.0023044911,
-0.0096897893,
-0.0557296537,
-0.020731369,
-0.0326514654,
-5.13936379e-33,
-0.0069274646,
-0.0132116862,
0.0146892723,
0.0078484919,
0.03773183,
0.0144529557,
-0.0269026496,
-0.0245814119,
-0.0058129798,
0.0443283617,
0.0318489112,
0.0171492901,
-0.0048151216,
0.0289844088,
0.0272744372,
-0.0353375077,
0.0349176936,
0.0247367453,
-0.0233463142,
0.0231016316,
0.0270787347,
-0.0015038962,
0.0103031537,
-0.1008647755,
-0.0005786911,
-0.010240959,
0.0239035357,
-0.0217729602,
0.0469225049,
0.0525423847,
-0.0179486051,
0.0689052567,
0.0672985911,
0.0271929037,
-0.0075379731,
0.0188814085,
-0.0494716913,
-0.0585921071,
-0.0038707338,
-0.0819961801,
-0.0140386932,
0.0273600277,
0.0433034077,
-0.0060225558,
-0.0044048177,
-0.0097075617,
0.0850883946,
-0.0382109322,
0.016632108,
-0.068836458,
-0.0447043926,
0.0248873811,
0.0034852403,
0.0310157258,
-0.0260979496,
0.0868934989,
-0.0432042666,
0.0541005246,
-0.0139327459,
-0.0042641875,
-0.0258978866,
0.0032273494,
0.0211174171,
-0.0655829981,
-0.0094913291,
0.0586388223,
0.0212307833,
-0.0715204403,
-0.0526229106,
0.0331169888,
-0.0122241965,
-0.0016632435,
0.0569637381,
0.0427832939,
0.0364886932,
-0.0189066771,
-0.0644697696,
0.0514518581,
-0.055288218,
0.0108379433,
0.0515878536,
-0.0045267632,
-0.0394939557,
-0.0276306141,
-0.0423312001,
0.0439366065,
-0.0529943109,
-0.0360795259,
0.0556856096,
-0.0281958058,
0.0239417851,
0.0016134052,
-0.0086504091,
-0.0037495315,
-0.002731551,
-0.013630609,
0.0347503424,
0.0036345867,
-0.0232553743,
0.0089201359,
-0.0536325946,
-0.0213664938,
0.0162225962,
-0.0023699992,
0.073539719,
0.0135774817,
0.0265722498,
-0.0719651952,
-0.0370996147,
-0.0231690519,
0.0369172841,
-0.0233399943,
-0.0089494912,
0.0124806501,
-0.0091027347,
0.0425607823,
0.005480967,
0.0279968828,
0.0242762119,
-0.0110978978,
-0.0571213849,
-0.0512320958,
-0.0159611683,
-0.0330524445,
-0.0093940105,
-0.0057786056,
-0.0486430414,
-0.0181682874,
0.0362944268,
-0.0543015376,
0.0056780521,
0.0023513814,
2.672e-7,
0.092236951,
0.0440455601,
-0.0138027733,
-0.0624656528,
-0.0087917447,
-0.0020524326,
0.0630766973,
0.0462119244,
0.0102639608,
0.0204719584,
0.0623946078,
0.0134021463,
-0.0063635856,
0.0893641114,
0.0068208622,
-0.0189315658,
-0.0617878065,
-0.0559695102,
-0.0351262353,
-0.0202606153,
0.1161739901,
0.0662937537,
0.0014444182,
-0.024061285,
0.0474150926,
-0.0174730215,
0.0120898969,
-0.0516144,
0.0244773254,
0.0372927785,
-0.0039088186,
-0.0163494572,
0.0177657343,
0.0890940949,
-0.011990115,
-0.0123116272,
0.0289237369,
-0.0253458992,
-0.0300486553,
0.0019600168,
-0.0103483964,
-0.0283301175,
0.0101930238,
-0.0494263284,
0.064377211,
-0.0745552406,
-0.0069151749,
0.0279801395,
-0.0091002434,
0.0041902335,
0.0407691002,
0.0149996998,
-0.0311995279,
0.0551046468,
0.0350699015,
0.0547314696,
0.002894128,
-0.0864225328,
-0.0099439332,
0.0443634689,
-0.035556417,
-0.0138733629,
0.0268924795,
-0.019298654,
0.0186202899,
-0.0769961998,
0.0117249181,
2.47589439e-34,
-0.0070526903,
0.0621552654,
-0.010245461,
-0.0201576985,
0.0354481563,
0.0201149844,
-0.0161177292,
0.0107694939,
0.0287003312,
-0.0892681107,
-0.0006860573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04564v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04564v1 | When Less is More: Investigating Data Pruning for Pretraining LLMs at Scale | 2023-09-08T19:34:05 | 2023-09-08T19:34:05 | Max Marion, Ahmet Üstün, Luiza Pozzobon, Alex Wang, Marzieh Fadaee, Sara Hooker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large volumes of text data have contributed significantly to the development
of large language models (LLMs) in recent years. This data is typically
acquired by scraping the internet, leading to pretraining datasets comprised of
noisy web text. To date, efforts to prune these datasets down to a higher
quality subset have relied on hand-crafted heuristics encoded as rule-based
filters. In this work, we take a wider view and explore scalable estimates of
data quality that can be used to systematically measure the quality of
pretraining data. We perform a rigorous comparison at scale of the simple data
quality estimator of perplexity, as well as more sophisticated and
computationally intensive estimates of the Error L2-Norm and memorization.
These metrics are used to rank and prune pretraining corpora, and we
subsequently compare LLMs trained on these pruned datasets. Surprisingly, we
find that the simple technique of perplexity outperforms our more
computationally expensive scoring methods. We improve over our no-pruning
baseline while training on as little as 30% of the original training dataset.
Our work sets the foundation for unexplored strategies in automatically
curating high quality corpora and suggests the majority of pretraining data can
be removed while retaining performance. | [
0.0199809186,
0.095481284,
-0.0016707185,
0.0444379486,
-0.0179007575,
0.0284560658,
-0.0052771028,
0.0421832353,
-0.0006827759,
-0.0470063873,
-0.0554667264,
-0.0766241923,
-0.0053695254,
-0.0320605859,
0.013349656,
-0.0126075651,
0.0341455378,
-0.0352664106,
-0.033564169,
-0.011788412,
0.0134413932,
-0.0015895697,
0.0284451507,
0.0063100643,
0.0104896855,
0.0154085495,
0.0378251076,
0.0095056072,
-0.0251930002,
-0.0435281619,
0.022625003,
0.0587947592,
0.0032066219,
0.0316464342,
0.0000020292,
-0.0500451103,
-0.009390478,
-0.01579847,
-0.0187292956,
0.0636330545,
0.0433011539,
0.0075736316,
-0.021888148,
0.0281700976,
-0.0284131393,
-0.0268618744,
0.0311790835,
0.0221879538,
0.0718718022,
0.0944878384,
0.0063288501,
-0.0140881334,
0.0230902676,
-0.0263667591,
0.0032530536,
-0.0303183459,
0.0388830416,
0.0110067651,
-0.0413699746,
-0.004574114,
-0.0297864601,
0.0216347184,
0.0029927164,
0.0248502512,
0.0044579622,
0.0172680207,
-0.0188887529,
-0.0278378744,
0.0150378449,
0.0909726843,
-0.0363186784,
-0.0437262766,
0.0039580083,
-0.0028990405,
-0.020668447,
-0.0027951836,
-0.0162223,
0.021799095,
0.0119217979,
0.0525785126,
-0.017067099,
-0.0281876456,
0.0684472248,
0.0279962402,
-0.0581571683,
0.0139798597,
0.0102722626,
-0.0504200049,
0.0305063073,
0.0194061026,
-0.0081840884,
-0.0248534288,
-0.0005015981,
0.0030052068,
-0.0224982873,
0.0168485045,
-0.062748827,
-0.0209161099,
0.0161982626,
-0.014738434,
0.0438588001,
0.0087879468,
0.000851718,
0.0496307425,
-0.0139912227,
0.0100832228,
0.0279673841,
0.0501659773,
-0.0630461127,
0.0084534436,
-0.0267626047,
0.0241915602,
-0.0226615686,
0.0408360437,
0.0154020488,
0.0012160938,
-0.0364537165,
-0.0010142118,
-0.0039554578,
0.0079297647,
0.01374989,
-0.0286719035,
-0.0132150715,
-0.0025303613,
-0.0182183571,
-0.015914863,
-0.0012172114,
0.025623465,
-0.0063733743,
-0.0584546663,
-0.0177714378,
0.0188422278,
0.016903678,
-0.0303439051,
0.0447448716,
0.0563898161,
-0.0027851202,
-0.0673244968,
-0.0606624112,
0.0102381362,
-0.0046936069,
-0.047812324,
-0.0170480534,
-0.0578615442,
0.0176602397,
-0.0175027344,
0.0261677559,
-0.0626297072,
0.000503384,
0.0200506505,
-0.0328393467,
0.0649798512,
-0.0554283597,
0.0368504487,
-0.0328563191,
-0.0088773351,
0.0011373962,
0.0683410689,
0.0385083668,
-0.0055689318,
0.0709221438,
-0.0245242063,
0.0119157098,
0.0390639119,
0.0427093394,
0.0321259052,
-0.0054880157,
-0.0143802734,
0.005997669,
-0.000327515,
0.0371696204,
0.0660607591,
-0.0453339443,
-0.0035719813,
0.0870830342,
0.0492438823,
0.0444870628,
0.0263487604,
0.0135605764,
0.0219515674,
0.0236463882,
0.0264397133,
-0.0472748913,
-0.0411603972,
-0.0263729207,
-0.0071041328,
0.0387934223,
0.0453416668,
-0.0456378907,
-0.0671179146,
-0.0177790839,
-0.0228415541,
0.0245422404,
0.0088484446,
0.0545390211,
0.0009860807,
-0.0423483998,
0.04281158,
0.0401450284,
-0.0717717409,
0.0422087051,
-0.0355270281,
0.028777888,
0.0664299205,
0.0565970503,
-0.0173545722,
0.0044593373,
0.0000927818,
0.0579532124,
-0.0107210008,
0.0303212609,
-0.0073050149,
0.0493416041,
-0.0897769555,
-0.0383956544,
0.0255193356,
0.0226307083,
-0.0094910823,
0.0187588204,
-0.0050072283,
0.0361230038,
-0.0648550615,
-0.0812537447,
0.0580374077,
-0.0274450071,
-0.0368084125,
0.0242892541,
0.0075489837,
0.0429249816,
-0.0018958758,
-0.0405147411,
0.0015468386,
0.040502537,
-0.0287064109,
0.0342215821,
-0.0322193168,
-0.0375857241,
-0.0236646347,
0.0589924529,
-0.0274782293,
-0.0054283799,
0.0756090358,
-0.0457948968,
-0.0234379228,
-0.0347189792,
-0.0476202369,
0.0395627357,
-0.0760988221,
0.035975676,
-0.0082674082,
0.0338563286,
-0.0314611085,
0.0249866564,
-0.0134407822,
0.0402215756,
0.00004318,
-0.0327877626,
0.0266834851,
-0.032471735,
-0.0592792369,
-0.0060679619,
-0.0238265097,
0.0535809919,
0.0166563746,
0.0406738035,
-0.0501119308,
-0.0140736047,
-0.0598758906,
-0.0127641773,
-0.0423427522,
0.019583853,
0.0051594065,
-0.0131905032,
-0.0143977813,
-0.0180256441,
-0.0277880765,
-0.0318321623,
0.0153706968,
0.0169434156,
0.0385759026,
-0.0156096024,
-0.0244762097,
-0.0275713671,
-0.0325197317,
0.0233184043,
0.0416062213,
-0.0197243616,
-0.0044273715,
-0.0485056601,
0.0808593705,
-0.039400164,
0.0049748085,
0.0034755699,
-0.0597971082,
-0.0081090648,
-0.0127600078,
-0.0210706443,
0.0380467325,
0.0064628902,
0.0058161905,
0.0714168176,
0.0073819896,
-0.0464764163,
-0.019784512,
-0.0208493024,
-0.008617742,
-0.0395910516,
-0.0267362967,
0.0242678486,
0.0315016769,
-0.0184866041,
-0.0209230017,
-0.0425170995,
0.0171239208,
-0.0160714965,
-0.0120529681,
-0.034642417,
0.0228672661,
-0.0172465444,
0.0534651317,
-0.0259364955,
-0.0797030702,
0.0565584712,
-0.0377411246,
0.0235168878,
-0.0363847166,
-0.014467679,
-0.0103093106,
0.0181109142,
0.0156288482,
0.0243090354,
-0.0261030365,
-0.01329087,
-0.0514125749,
-0.0160261299,
0.0422024839,
-0.0540853217,
0.0516174175,
-0.0534112044,
0.0280326046,
0.0082016895,
-0.0405224562,
-0.0375110544,
-0.0345166549,
-0.0131470347,
-0.0381894335,
0.0158974938,
-0.0038729997,
-0.0125791421,
0.0036060007,
0.0163501166,
0.0390505977,
0.0225274339,
0.0123421317,
0.0065440778,
0.0231088772,
0.0184626523,
0.0057798573,
0.0307741258,
-0.0448448658,
0.020910928,
0.0522521734,
0.0448293202,
0.0007550479,
0.0013625853,
0.0136859575,
0.0530697368,
-0.010530822,
-0.0091753891,
0.0203058589,
0.0415267646,
-0.0250150375,
-0.0164165087,
0.1168970019,
0.010873572,
-0.0383390114,
0.0109263472,
0.0506987311,
0.0381700732,
0.0086107207,
-0.0064848079,
-0.0739264041,
-0.0250690747,
0.0167466626,
0.0327981673,
0.0129468711,
-0.0313356332,
-0.0165975858,
-0.1207049564,
0.0261186883,
0.0296087191,
-0.0379525721,
-0.0202048812,
-0.059660852,
-0.0007706215,
-0.0439107642,
0.0288066305,
0.010678852,
-0.0137153938,
0.0073988009,
0.0225180238,
-0.050056994,
-0.1004651487,
-0.0031813195,
-0.0361361988,
0.046204824,
0.0385460556,
0.0289236382,
-0.0032515589,
-0.0605164841,
0.0575139076,
-0.0331084616,
-0.0326925851,
-0.0242427532,
0.0796079487,
-0.0124771688,
-0.0216049142,
0.0077617723,
0.0158259664,
-0.0231740624,
0.000003771,
-0.0021043762,
0.0459575914,
-0.0065929638,
-0.0094138058,
0.0253161099,
-0.022072861,
-0.0155237028,
0.0909283087,
0.0376960598,
-0.0448217802,
0.003946851,
-0.0144252218,
0.0196217168,
-0.0557682849,
-0.0148736145,
0.0464987718,
-0.0443574302,
-0.0219686646,
-0.0706523582,
-0.0487579443,
0.0218864568,
0.034566775,
-0.0002036254,
0.0121193714,
-0.003996172,
0.0069559147,
-0.02434095,
0.0367169566,
-0.0584007502,
0.0096209282,
-0.0815969706,
-0.0110262558,
0.008314603,
-0.0006203131,
-0.01400562,
-0.0223252513,
-0.0704426169,
-0.0464868098,
0.0054878923,
0.0574710518,
0.0240269583,
0.0559094511,
0.006023353,
-0.0507256575,
0.063632898,
0.0472186208,
-0.0435842611,
0.0270765424,
0.0599935092,
-0.0306397416,
0.0137412567,
0.0513393618,
-0.0486910343,
0.010942868,
0.0388243906,
0.0269550532,
-0.0191859528,
-0.0005485113,
0.0218462553,
0.0543291382,
0.0390408523,
-0.030857956,
-0.0191059466,
-0.0420837514,
0.0360296294,
0.0128829423,
-0.0092653157,
-0.0524053574,
0.0178326461,
0.0492113866,
0.0085793389,
-0.0329714343,
0.0247466732,
-0.0247789063,
0.0435094386,
-0.0316896103,
-0.000630485,
-0.0229940321,
-0.0054532336,
0.046236638,
0.0012688739,
-0.0030448514,
0.0040566749,
0.0126942834,
0.0076834401,
-0.0011802242,
-0.0191267766,
0.0065831803,
0.0252475012,
-0.0242715422,
0.0648333207,
-0.0674075037,
-0.0439082496,
-0.0444146171,
-0.0126965595,
0.071892105,
-0.0406489708,
0.053221561,
-0.0061016968,
-0.0062563918,
-0.0484051444,
0.0006405294,
-0.0017799697,
0.0155171957,
-0.0006928913,
0.0052590352,
-0.0303196702,
0.0220451783,
0.1109780967,
-0.0198998824,
0.0412175655,
-0.0001303408,
-0.0087249167,
-0.0391381755,
-0.0158569571,
0.0187681336,
0.0419270806,
-0.0354833156,
-0.032127995,
-0.0340166502,
-0.1008103341,
-0.0021384216,
0.0018601306,
-0.0113438545,
-0.0053614853,
0.0251718555,
0.0580635853,
-0.0178877618,
0.0713514015,
-0.0291638598,
-0.0546184294,
0.0040151617,
-0.0345078222,
-0.0010625498,
-6.611001535e-33,
0.0254422054,
-0.0074487329,
-0.0098066479,
-0.0031359198,
-0.0140742576,
0.014733457,
-0.006163212,
-0.0152305039,
-0.0284836814,
-0.0040951814,
-0.0180560146,
0.0061740093,
0.0136592258,
0.0395952053,
-0.0452775359,
-0.0193620641,
0.0418218039,
-0.0153103564,
-0.0421962962,
-0.0021848106,
-0.0060277665,
0.0479979776,
0.0576283336,
-0.0455009677,
-0.0087882169,
0.020816559,
-0.0268211085,
0.0174746942,
0.0177753549,
0.0555926673,
-0.0122404424,
0.0602480136,
0.0264108349,
-0.0041387812,
-0.0264664404,
-0.0168889742,
-0.0556345694,
-0.0285616647,
-0.0003993699,
-0.00584818,
0.013053555,
-0.0089406054,
0.0498559512,
-0.0198261924,
-0.0386969969,
0.024634039,
0.0184387136,
-0.0302574392,
-0.0600375943,
-0.0235243868,
0.0037771075,
0.046908427,
-0.0072723106,
-0.0259796586,
0.0291432068,
0.0052948939,
-0.0102877142,
0.0542668626,
-0.0601085164,
0.0471799932,
0.0311271697,
0.0484363921,
0.0498918891,
0.000917244,
0.0137574263,
0.0783526525,
0.0303257722,
-0.0042968723,
0.0244670063,
-0.0105935689,
0.0624607392,
0.0231646262,
0.028956024,
0.0565031953,
0.0517124161,
-0.048738353,
-0.0919204652,
0.0431544743,
-0.0238265228,
0.0352181345,
-0.0192928333,
0.0141938208,
-0.0286041088,
-0.0269933883,
-0.0441144779,
-0.010399254,
-0.0269949809,
-0.0240414646,
0.0258386303,
0.0241982639,
-0.0496244915,
-0.0404230542,
0.0067108991,
-0.058200743,
-0.0479295403,
0.0071467678,
-0.0233318377,
-0.0100005371,
0.00734055,
-0.0010039359,
-0.0433722921,
-0.0405493081,
0.0031446517,
-0.0131798415,
0.0028018139,
-0.021874316,
0.0515320227,
0.0268627089,
-0.0742902532,
0.0150476098,
-0.03337707,
-0.00429891,
0.0334479585,
0.039529793,
0.0392557569,
0.009771524,
0.0082749417,
0.0465811193,
0.0340857431,
-0.0048646652,
-0.0262738261,
-0.0235608201,
0.0176874604,
0.0259821806,
-0.0028374095,
-0.027699478,
-0.0242528152,
0.0023062157,
0.0566582344,
-0.0525743142,
-0.0041056341,
-0.0073522488,
2.726e-7,
0.0366240479,
0.0477905907,
-0.0136605371,
0.0062868339,
-0.0184436087,
0.0155605394,
-0.0447448604,
-0.0018567776,
-0.0253842957,
-0.0044033462,
0.0258826893,
0.0284366105,
0.0793044791,
0.0335855372,
-0.0870986506,
-0.0086467434,
-0.0660278574,
-0.0103927068,
-0.0221114084,
0.0013250074,
0.0262081157,
0.1320613027,
0.0105583575,
-0.0411266759,
0.0107983137,
-0.0770964921,
0.0528958365,
-0.0775604621,
-0.016488472,
0.0198943373,
0.0676809177,
0.0124659771,
-0.0009792108,
0.0073196436,
-0.0535822995,
0.0185508542,
0.0050438554,
0.058158502,
0.0071951984,
-0.0102398703,
-0.0124062514,
-0.0101221772,
-0.0013497343,
-0.0453185365,
0.0763864815,
-0.0009938166,
0.0010231992,
0.0002615109,
-0.0250446834,
-0.0433286391,
0.0527291223,
-0.0360072963,
-0.0377179906,
0.0236856528,
0.0301789213,
0.0010411763,
-0.0041382047,
-0.060962934,
0.0060166782,
-0.0257025007,
-0.0103206579,
-0.0876791477,
-0.0210979208,
-0.0168214254,
0.0474083498,
-0.0492077023,
0.036105562,
2.566816811e-34,
0.0741242319,
-0.0410805382,
0.0341480896,
0.0265037175,
0.0162770748,
-0.0057950215,
0.0389665179,
-0.0141453659,
-0.027522184,
-0.082877785,
0.0232393686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04561v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04561v2 | Four Ways to Improve Verbo-visual Fusion for Dense 3D Visual Grounding | 2023-09-08T19:27:01 | 2024-07-03T14:01:52 | Ozan Unal, Christos Sakaridis, Suman Saha, Luc Van Gool | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | 3D visual grounding is the task of localizing the object in a 3D scene which
is referred by a description in natural language. With a wide range of
applications ranging from autonomous indoor robotics to AR/VR, the task has
recently risen in popularity. A common formulation to tackle 3D visual
grounding is grounding-by-detection, where localization is done via bounding
boxes. However, for real-life applications that require physical interactions,
a bounding box insufficiently describes the geometry of an object. We therefore
tackle the problem of dense 3D visual grounding, i.e. referral-based 3D
instance segmentation. We propose a dense 3D grounding network ConcreteNet,
featuring four novel stand-alone modules that aim to improve grounding
performance for challenging repetitive instances, i.e. instances with
distractors of the same semantic class. First, we introduce a bottom-up
attentive fusion module that aims to disambiguate inter-instance relational
cues, next, we construct a contrastive training scheme to induce separation in
the latent space, we then resolve view-dependent utterances via a learned
global camera token, and finally we employ multi-view ensembling to improve
referred mask quality. ConcreteNet ranks 1st on the challenging ScanRefer
online benchmark and has won the ICCV 3rd Workshop on Language for 3D Scenes
"3D Object Localization" challenge. | [
0.021982342,
0.0156356115,
0.0682064295,
0.0389601141,
-0.0095349476,
-0.0156082455,
0.0016702717,
-0.0551484376,
-0.0205121879,
-0.050683815,
-0.0341212451,
0.0371471867,
0.0231701639,
0.0367991962,
0.0200072583,
-0.0475069731,
0.0128200473,
-0.0215094313,
-0.0614832006,
0.0002212604,
0.0056488169,
0.0080928467,
-0.0340061262,
0.0049625197,
-0.0365819037,
0.0086100474,
0.0156390481,
0.0241173599,
0.0528670438,
-0.0576957352,
0.0352794155,
0.015956156,
0.0435193032,
-0.0261530541,
0.0000018746,
-0.0183395464,
-0.0305423122,
-0.0040314631,
0.0092133842,
-0.0373601504,
-0.0496079549,
-0.0317124352,
0.0103434445,
0.0154432934,
-0.024465397,
0.0042949864,
0.057383582,
0.0824749395,
0.0648820028,
0.0055419113,
-0.0309206955,
0.0025684743,
0.0150649101,
-0.0169421863,
0.0171886627,
-0.0208406411,
0.0063222642,
0.053927701,
-0.0342308171,
0.0018343331,
-0.0178871881,
0.0268696081,
0.0458215661,
0.026897179,
0.0751118585,
0.0517414398,
-0.0514425412,
-0.0115126194,
-0.0263748206,
0.0762588382,
-0.0306676589,
-0.0038420493,
-0.0123319076,
0.0220852252,
0.0130318683,
-0.0398848765,
0.0076684938,
0.0280211661,
-0.0280181821,
-0.0131020546,
-0.0409658775,
0.0541585833,
-0.0165308472,
0.0030858847,
-0.0601058975,
-0.0144191151,
0.0155688487,
0.0360949188,
0.0076631429,
0.0376367085,
-0.0319860689,
-0.0644233599,
0.0309440345,
-0.0091608213,
-0.0176259857,
-0.0107402001,
-0.0316067412,
0.0077998289,
-0.0538088866,
-0.0226516295,
-0.0027662427,
0.0178293251,
-0.0659095421,
0.0749780089,
-0.0423691235,
0.0464058444,
-0.0474013761,
0.0425337963,
-0.0056531564,
-0.0062882015,
0.0038582846,
0.0301780254,
-0.0751656294,
0.0288539249,
-0.0457700267,
-0.0540380031,
0.0020340087,
-0.0303813852,
-0.0347084813,
-0.0127388602,
-0.0388333909,
0.0717845634,
-0.0342042968,
-0.0079155555,
0.0077562938,
0.0182717294,
-0.0214578118,
0.019971827,
-0.0413501449,
-0.0559854619,
-0.0148074282,
0.0502985492,
0.0044516684,
-0.0350545198,
0.0151995877,
0.0561976954,
-0.0405377224,
-0.0740695149,
0.0112567805,
-0.0186219644,
-0.0351183452,
-0.0195370167,
0.0555981658,
-0.0520134382,
-0.003958106,
-0.0245121568,
0.0072237328,
-0.0647680908,
0.0253586005,
-0.0148503873,
0.0151811019,
0.0857463926,
-0.0239103977,
-0.0617781766,
0.017295463,
0.0254970621,
0.023491038,
0.0182354618,
0.0154792527,
0.0197417047,
-0.0117734708,
0.032962922,
0.0288707353,
0.0212125275,
0.0098412083,
0.0177362915,
-0.0693814382,
-0.0186783448,
-0.0168997813,
0.0147355646,
-0.0099117663,
0.0253605749,
-0.0247486979,
-0.0193940569,
0.0246602278,
-0.0011188325,
-0.1085232124,
-0.0226434413,
0.0292088371,
-0.033540573,
-0.0272750985,
-0.0014343346,
-0.0541034415,
0.0483084805,
0.0122061362,
-0.0343165323,
-0.0147509715,
0.0295477137,
-0.0232193768,
-0.0561829805,
0.0015055678,
0.0139468974,
0.0306782424,
-0.0053648348,
0.0680869371,
0.0491895936,
-0.0330441892,
0.0684057623,
-0.0092884107,
-0.02616941,
-0.0218942463,
0.0340977721,
0.0137593923,
-0.0132338954,
0.0026316226,
-0.0040750569,
-0.0611176454,
-0.0022418201,
0.0488019325,
0.0611061938,
-0.0256187245,
-0.0119219637,
0.0571395233,
-0.0222932715,
-0.0520567968,
0.0019263405,
-0.0159920622,
0.0520426929,
0.0732532889,
-0.0137772774,
0.0403034799,
-0.066112332,
0.0708470419,
0.0438782834,
0.0059271911,
0.0239404496,
-0.066417627,
0.022224525,
0.0279202778,
0.0182540957,
-0.0022019844,
-0.016825065,
0.0192160886,
-0.0523836501,
0.0157413296,
0.0404778495,
-0.0657060966,
-0.0069947331,
0.0160297267,
-0.0541040488,
-0.0254452955,
0.0115044713,
-0.0277267769,
-0.0191807505,
0.0199383814,
-0.0028795667,
0.0346728787,
0.0238968879,
-0.0291667655,
0.0504554398,
0.0154127479,
-0.0415937081,
0.0501934774,
-0.054688748,
-0.0098235961,
0.0024427969,
-0.0126952305,
0.0360071585,
0.0127983987,
0.017212918,
-0.0274790321,
-0.0094918879,
-0.0259756148,
0.0233251546,
0.0061658914,
-0.0493896008,
0.0249034856,
0.0087838229,
-0.0205037389,
-0.0232103933,
-0.0129264714,
-0.0184124038,
-0.0127178356,
0.0174577292,
-0.0617741868,
-0.0091042537,
0.0170278959,
0.0003457164,
-0.001094787,
0.0030769599,
0.0078848582,
-0.0432205349,
-0.0351186506,
0.0254597478,
0.0127471881,
0.0102764498,
0.0443613753,
-0.0794194639,
-0.0314357728,
0.0314867795,
-0.0471997038,
0.0659877732,
-0.031863682,
0.0174702145,
0.0148177212,
-0.0469643883,
0.0534884632,
0.0963452458,
-0.0568627529,
0.0211062282,
0.0028754908,
0.0085892603,
-0.0245133489,
0.0012544449,
0.0098177195,
-0.0199514925,
-0.005684617,
0.0281889774,
0.0047351946,
0.0112354849,
-0.0155254146,
0.0098276623,
-0.0324648507,
0.0152090946,
0.0045245318,
-0.0635551363,
-0.049428273,
0.0199455898,
0.0127516938,
0.0096283443,
-0.0609715618,
-0.0269007999,
-0.0015766408,
-0.0421120301,
-0.016342625,
0.0084989509,
-0.0059831254,
0.0205995068,
0.0104771284,
0.0454751551,
0.0149922678,
-0.0120457392,
-0.0422228985,
-0.031482596,
-0.0486482196,
-0.0251482595,
0.057487268,
0.0464979373,
-0.0635716319,
0.0339711271,
0.0053301449,
-0.0390799977,
-0.0098677529,
0.0355601273,
-0.0530078076,
0.0263279155,
-0.0504059456,
-0.0130626466,
-0.0271091908,
0.0226331763,
0.0192332342,
0.0883694589,
0.0050513004,
-0.0329703577,
-0.0312717631,
0.0157049522,
-0.0198874231,
0.0429378934,
-0.001744685,
-0.0035108717,
-0.0251656789,
0.0838127509,
0.0225239322,
-0.0034395575,
-0.0805468038,
0.0373626761,
0.0179500189,
0.0441777632,
-0.0054209544,
-0.0139983688,
0.0411313437,
-0.0305939224,
-0.0590485036,
0.0275432039,
0.0093967738,
-0.0123523697,
-0.030250188,
0.0044614389,
0.0164970737,
0.0534745008,
-0.0305904038,
-0.0112325698,
-0.0445996821,
0.0040886872,
-0.0238459613,
0.0989794284,
-0.0120464861,
0.0134778889,
-0.0852839574,
0.0208477359,
0.0050008944,
-0.0510792695,
-0.088277109,
0.0206992123,
0.0488324538,
-0.0264778491,
-0.0305275619,
-0.0233627465,
-0.0174460318,
0.000615787,
0.0173034109,
0.049269028,
0.0317556672,
-0.0041915854,
-0.0588804223,
-0.0302340463,
0.0227774996,
0.0122134015,
-0.0129763661,
-0.0406269953,
0.0402092412,
0.0054343315,
-0.0057136379,
-0.0167031419,
0.0390417911,
-0.0521142818,
-0.0105137434,
0.0416962318,
0.0231595375,
-0.0172918011,
-0.0473070443,
-0.0498855449,
0.0051292446,
-0.0222549047,
0.0653238893,
-0.0262429547,
0.0281160977,
0.0152828228,
0.0330526829,
-0.0193266496,
0.0182455424,
-0.007160211,
0.0132278735,
0.0309287515,
-0.0106199859,
0.00881657,
-0.0144294724,
-0.0659984797,
-0.0308600757,
-0.0564828776,
0.0046766051,
0.0860485509,
0.0413482711,
0.0115336543,
-0.0469668694,
0.0143547961,
0.0266949553,
-0.0396959335,
0.0433129519,
-0.0289989728,
0.0180526674,
-0.0383223109,
0.0810841992,
0.0373972282,
-0.0424928702,
-0.0333023816,
0.0264743101,
-0.0114634782,
-0.0033317679,
-0.0116259232,
0.0498869047,
0.0086986907,
0.0810495466,
-0.0042228838,
0.0418294147,
0.0082420111,
-0.0171025563,
0.0202946905,
0.0617884248,
0.0260493606,
0.0040887529,
-0.0224139784,
-0.0213362798,
-0.0631955191,
0.0503584072,
0.039267417,
-0.0398731977,
-0.0497978479,
-0.0144572891,
0.0067331372,
-0.0317724757,
0.0747953802,
0.0033247829,
0.0704719275,
-0.0579418465,
-0.0006659796,
0.0130182318,
-0.0038013372,
-0.1014632285,
0.0561668649,
-0.0215323213,
0.0239257645,
0.0202036351,
0.0339512192,
0.0355684347,
0.0831046477,
-0.0074546533,
-0.0561273657,
0.0244756583,
-0.0427016132,
-0.0077839615,
0.0128461095,
0.0022583792,
0.030540755,
-0.0214949418,
0.0570949391,
-0.0257789027,
0.0369437076,
0.0690046623,
-0.0219805744,
-0.0451736115,
0.0562831908,
0.0049117221,
-0.0127934096,
-0.0354867689,
0.0329398923,
0.0413142815,
-0.0037422704,
0.0522374474,
-0.0219288301,
-0.0106589682,
0.0190505423,
0.0297818426,
0.0410771035,
-0.045606982,
0.0367475711,
0.0146156913,
-0.0101672783,
0.0001491427,
-0.0021080049,
0.0235008895,
0.0166100971,
0.0341920368,
-0.0007933937,
-0.0462079383,
0.004653729,
0.005543957,
0.0200451054,
0.0220011193,
0.0710926503,
0.0110530062,
-0.0552663878,
-0.0306362081,
0.0524588116,
-0.0483459793,
0.0267101154,
0.054669477,
0.03510461,
0.0374710299,
-0.060399957,
0.0209603347,
-0.0486156456,
0.0006886715,
-0.0143018002,
0.0348441936,
-5.470898013e-33,
-0.050228864,
-0.0500360951,
0.0039517293,
-0.0310328715,
-0.0135938991,
0.0287468079,
-0.0375453122,
0.0176482089,
-0.0211671721,
0.0369853191,
0.0130412988,
0.01778307,
0.0191874616,
0.0248984452,
-0.020645991,
-0.0165763218,
0.0578440912,
0.0350542031,
0.0013655847,
-0.0032464154,
0.0158584844,
0.0036214215,
0.0849746391,
-0.0821325406,
-0.0237585176,
0.017787965,
-0.033595603,
0.054583475,
-0.0099250311,
0.0045951791,
-0.0101129198,
-0.043964874,
-0.0066982312,
-0.0441016853,
-0.0194645971,
0.0046301885,
-0.1338999271,
-0.006674659,
-0.0136255324,
0.0443650149,
-0.0510052778,
0.0238747522,
0.0328123048,
-0.0167855378,
0.0391145386,
-0.036626175,
0.0240498744,
-0.0303836856,
-0.0299308486,
-0.0271677114,
-0.0191051215,
0.0057639759,
-0.0079671526,
-0.0718257725,
0.0130079305,
-0.0155891217,
0.0523302108,
-0.0011349852,
-0.0626004636,
-0.0164786279,
-0.0648005307,
0.0378468558,
0.0437329039,
0.0580322631,
-0.0295728315,
0.0789193884,
0.0212926026,
-0.0563376062,
0.0052121892,
-0.0216446165,
0.0049198596,
0.059781339,
0.0440128371,
0.015278711,
0.0296482649,
0.0533944108,
-0.0359961726,
0.0043229461,
-0.0951145589,
0.0830799118,
-0.0056230342,
0.002085146,
-0.020816179,
-0.0082801394,
0.0270594563,
-0.0472685806,
-0.0052252263,
0.026637461,
0.049345281,
0.0343886502,
-0.0407436229,
-0.0117372777,
0.0489480086,
0.0077083991,
0.0303471945,
0.081486173,
0.005236594,
0.0529799275,
-0.0077704145,
-0.0047288365,
-0.0505239964,
-0.0063067805,
-0.0038681256,
0.0065552439,
0.0190181565,
0.0031741478,
0.0137719736,
-0.0002176969,
-0.0157469697,
0.0021001287,
-0.0372615568,
0.0310728736,
-0.0049516726,
0.071036458,
0.0559746139,
0.014905354,
-0.0099622561,
0.038276054,
-0.0091756731,
-0.0361229926,
-0.0060352837,
0.0098141748,
-0.0303558819,
0.0496759899,
-0.0262017064,
-0.0136214206,
-0.0497900061,
-0.0426946916,
0.0750879794,
-0.0661611408,
-0.0265602209,
0.0072268066,
2.664e-7,
-0.0049223579,
0.0039037908,
0.0537023768,
-0.0030905441,
-0.0434401557,
0.0475310944,
0.0461294167,
0.0691303462,
-0.0185513701,
-0.048843693,
-0.0148590365,
0.0546169281,
-0.0198751595,
0.0095395278,
-0.0706225932,
0.0270692352,
-0.0290190596,
-0.0252749864,
-0.0330215022,
-0.0054406216,
0.019526815,
0.0470457077,
-0.0196226612,
-0.0048582987,
0.0004678534,
-0.0414151326,
-0.027454013,
0.0004927701,
0.0310447775,
-0.0011250445,
0.0386347324,
0.0477421172,
-0.0206376091,
-0.001723873,
0.0125499777,
-0.002054824,
0.0710592568,
0.0102143809,
-0.0347833373,
-0.0018486436,
-0.0248211995,
0.0053153541,
-0.0024725387,
0.0052655418,
0.0397217982,
-0.0507775359,
0.0306131039,
0.0113038206,
-0.0369521305,
-0.0215254277,
-0.0037964964,
0.0292039104,
-0.027593378,
-0.0158797689,
0.0159196556,
0.0078923292,
-0.0478320606,
-0.070198454,
-0.0247968938,
0.0082223583,
-0.0062927194,
0.0004611978,
0.0425397865,
-0.060828425,
-0.0118871275,
-0.0115975281,
-0.0830658227,
1.864574649e-34,
0.0197707862,
0.0199732799,
0.0063186963,
0.018674789,
0.0245507006,
0.006613296,
-0.0380056053,
-0.0153375594,
-0.0312194172,
-0.0045280815,
0.0087119034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04550v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04550v3 | Retrieving Evidence from EHRs with LLMs: Possibilities and Challenges | 2023-09-08T18:44:47 | 2024-06-10T20:11:42 | Hiba Ahsan, Denis Jered McInerney, Jisoo Kim, Christopher Potter, Geoffrey Young, Silvio Amir, Byron C. Wallace | cs.CL | cs.CL | Unstructured data in Electronic Health Records (EHRs) often contains critical
information -- complementary to imaging -- that could inform radiologists'
diagnoses. But the large volume of notes often associated with patients
together with time constraints renders manually identifying relevant evidence
practically infeasible. In this work we propose and evaluate a zero-shot
strategy for using LLMs as a mechanism to efficiently retrieve and summarize
unstructured evidence in patient EHR relevant to a given query. Our method
entails tasking an LLM to infer whether a patient has, or is at risk of, a
particular condition on the basis of associated notes; if so, we ask the model
to summarize the supporting evidence. Under expert evaluation, we find that
this LLM-based approach provides outputs consistently preferred to a pre-LLM
information retrieval baseline. Manual evaluation is expensive, so we also
propose and validate a method using an LLM to evaluate (other) LLM outputs for
this task, allowing us to scale up evaluation. Our findings indicate the
promise of LLMs as interfaces to EHR, but also highlight the outstanding
challenge posed by "hallucinations". In this setting, however, we show that
model confidence in outputs strongly correlates with faithful summaries,
offering a practical means to limit confabulations. | [
-0.0018784298,
0.0692985356,
0.0167561267,
-0.0327921472,
-0.0287859011,
0.0544779524,
-0.0412144065,
0.0527961142,
-0.0064086844,
0.010783338,
0.0235453974,
-0.0352014974,
-0.006938444,
0.0269747451,
-0.0137489792,
-0.0425410382,
0.0247628894,
0.0047234381,
0.0475020409,
0.0121382298,
-0.0405629128,
-0.0284722559,
-0.0149610499,
0.0235876273,
0.0096242297,
0.0176188368,
-0.0111478185,
0.0391617976,
0.0202470589,
-0.0624363571,
-0.0429943874,
0.0056201299,
-0.0138672236,
-0.0077828583,
0.0000020066,
-0.0618259981,
-0.0560963415,
0.0225656871,
-0.0518983081,
-0.0707520396,
0.0286134742,
-0.0168709662,
0.021389652,
0.0053805276,
-0.0226455107,
-0.0260453932,
0.0164185129,
0.0507999174,
0.0274114329,
0.0578077622,
-0.0214435272,
0.0506626554,
0.0259271041,
-0.0200133454,
0.0675735548,
-0.0066357451,
0.0437661484,
-0.0055650384,
0.0383491926,
-0.0155486092,
0.0433653183,
0.0524588078,
-0.0015182028,
0.0500555784,
0.0034828878,
0.0498872958,
-0.0117448699,
0.0181861427,
-0.0057718251,
0.0307732243,
0.0262782443,
0.019089086,
0.0529324673,
-0.0075374669,
-0.022955576,
0.0491070077,
-0.0357871056,
0.0272113793,
-0.052021116,
-0.0059991758,
0.0028463963,
0.02540127,
0.0361170061,
-0.0118886279,
-0.0452586487,
0.0169940386,
0.0005918187,
-0.0316162258,
0.0511852354,
0.0189624131,
0.0460329838,
-0.0762029812,
0.0068900404,
0.0548944548,
-0.0419589542,
-0.0041498891,
0.024222767,
0.0260507669,
0.1038885862,
-0.0176446903,
0.0399515703,
-0.0006535659,
-0.0179130584,
0.0559828356,
0.0118119353,
-0.0579180829,
-0.0630135909,
0.0545677692,
-0.0308197383,
0.0102218697,
-0.0339909345,
-0.0028717401,
0.0189521685,
0.0394833498,
0.0292333402,
0.0104066916,
-0.0545087606,
0.0037909772,
0.0056386795,
0.0420610905,
0.0082612652,
0.0328729153,
-0.0158998426,
0.0062002726,
-0.062468417,
-0.0030635272,
0.0163226742,
0.0035479637,
0.0067358613,
-0.0202408452,
0.0146047557,
0.0364404097,
0.0105680013,
0.0107349642,
0.0326701775,
0.0514169559,
0.0353526436,
-0.0225820243,
-0.0176158138,
-0.0698282048,
-0.0352556482,
-0.0372881107,
0.0247104373,
-0.0728680566,
0.0057618436,
0.0176432319,
-0.0182323288,
-0.045948837,
0.0073188622,
-0.0065703844,
-0.031203527,
0.0499119759,
-0.0790465102,
-0.011037793,
0.0318412334,
0.0292705745,
-0.0289480556,
0.0196232665,
0.012247703,
0.0036865629,
0.0001190623,
0.0039158571,
0.0510575026,
0.0049195737,
0.0059734341,
-0.0116079152,
-0.0090703266,
0.0154197728,
-0.0142061142,
0.022651542,
-0.0532572195,
0.0429714285,
-0.0025805852,
0.0015784373,
0.0393562131,
0.047104951,
0.0450077355,
-0.0398457944,
-0.0140173733,
-0.0447572209,
-0.0207617674,
0.0187337548,
-0.0113042826,
0.0395181403,
-0.0071822903,
0.0207797643,
0.0383292921,
-0.0277397409,
-0.0455594622,
-0.0797756761,
-0.0539353415,
0.0130050341,
-0.0267498493,
0.0223604031,
0.0476570241,
-0.0410978608,
-0.0079863695,
0.0297985505,
0.049790848,
-0.0028244765,
-0.0483236127,
-0.0678637773,
-0.0135473227,
0.0608888045,
0.0370868817,
-0.0562639162,
-0.0379639752,
-0.0235421788,
0.0053503742,
-0.015890792,
-0.0166568086,
0.0044530951,
0.0280407574,
-0.011388029,
-0.0504770651,
0.0262018852,
0.0347099304,
-0.0300507825,
-0.0290046725,
-0.01656463,
-0.0263328478,
-0.0667391792,
-0.045023445,
0.0215605199,
-0.0439616181,
-0.0048001404,
0.0240044966,
0.0124810981,
0.0457093529,
0.0161460191,
-0.0220301729,
0.0481572673,
0.0583734922,
-0.0156606939,
-0.0536063537,
-0.0112587782,
0.0124848606,
0.0144017478,
0.012843376,
-0.0456872471,
-0.0005155444,
-0.0862878785,
-0.0265418272,
-0.0417113118,
-0.0593743138,
-0.0612058118,
0.0052898773,
-0.0176897887,
0.0054653324,
0.0590920188,
-0.0290404446,
-0.0282841418,
0.0320747867,
-0.0400658771,
-0.0223291982,
0.0193121321,
-0.0655050203,
0.0254773814,
-0.0722757876,
-0.0152843222,
0.0011769428,
0.0169357285,
0.0152415857,
0.004737271,
-0.0164825972,
-0.0357299298,
-0.0295563806,
-0.0962600559,
0.0052989065,
0.0068482901,
0.0323666856,
0.0007867868,
-0.0056654159,
-0.0229942929,
-0.0171073899,
-0.0317956991,
-0.0292193964,
0.0436691493,
0.0389541239,
0.0611866601,
0.043348588,
-0.0270725414,
-0.0174098872,
-0.0201888829,
-0.0245333333,
0.0192582849,
0.0140032973,
-0.0337903909,
-0.0088308575,
-0.0095808888,
-0.0376057252,
-0.0227416921,
-0.0012989929,
0.0304366276,
0.0174362976,
-0.0646771416,
-0.0247889981,
0.049587395,
-0.0194485653,
-0.0003093341,
0.0496309958,
-0.0241536144,
-0.0445429459,
-0.001761262,
-0.057502538,
-0.0033207228,
0.0501104183,
-0.054988198,
0.0285764802,
0.0152291013,
0.0136457486,
0.0212840047,
-0.021520026,
0.0173671748,
0.0229814965,
-0.0186946578,
-0.0478737056,
0.0267322119,
-0.0069310828,
0.0765650794,
-0.0078705894,
-0.0511492155,
0.0781273916,
-0.0113266241,
0.0766800269,
0.0127419373,
-0.0349751785,
-0.0390661396,
-0.0034233078,
-0.0162842479,
0.0177021828,
0.023911152,
0.0152533781,
0.0170616377,
-0.0240707248,
0.0132822003,
-0.0672893226,
0.0371899121,
-0.0246019904,
0.0462589674,
0.033030916,
-0.0056173233,
-0.0339531079,
0.0122948494,
-0.0088383807,
0.003721948,
-0.0573954359,
0.0384109579,
-0.0833200812,
0.0045934943,
-0.0004958164,
0.0339777209,
0.0195268523,
-0.03154248,
0.0139659112,
0.013621402,
0.0084644193,
-0.0285423808,
0.0169127546,
-0.0487776436,
0.0248952508,
0.0929993242,
-0.0082811713,
0.0412325449,
-0.0231986865,
0.0166317467,
-0.0296428781,
-0.0246773437,
-0.0006270465,
0.0377099961,
0.0042839781,
-0.0174030904,
0.0077374806,
0.0796150863,
0.0278332941,
-0.066074498,
-0.0143393027,
-0.0171444733,
-0.0185005162,
-0.0213736575,
0.0048723402,
-0.048719734,
-0.0027667489,
-0.0078909788,
0.0488223545,
-0.033012826,
-0.0612410903,
0.0233396199,
-0.0135441488,
0.0739558786,
-0.0179128684,
-0.0010992952,
-0.0040315874,
-0.0684905052,
0.0233177003,
-0.0238754209,
-0.022917252,
-0.0134178614,
-0.0073823626,
-0.0365142301,
0.0061542303,
-0.0473484844,
-0.0326250158,
0.0111441482,
-0.0355685465,
0.0195326861,
0.0342206992,
0.0262604076,
-0.0312636942,
-0.0740840286,
-0.0256428253,
0.0345380343,
0.0336434804,
-0.0178883933,
0.0985743925,
0.0072164787,
0.0238645822,
-0.0511180833,
0.0167039149,
-0.0112806745,
-0.0027031626,
0.009304367,
0.0754484087,
-0.0730214715,
-0.0110793188,
-0.0596714094,
-0.0013556188,
0.0307086185,
0.0463573374,
-0.0083860345,
0.0107855918,
-0.0263857674,
0.0326492079,
0.0475801155,
0.0291645974,
0.00071124,
0.0527301952,
-0.0370215699,
0.0069009275,
-0.0539122745,
-0.0258438438,
0.0135538448,
0.0213544481,
-0.01835371,
0.0100569353,
0.0087652477,
-0.0128015224,
-0.078736566,
0.0316771753,
0.0152688492,
0.0008192598,
-0.0385363773,
0.0000413007,
0.0400569513,
-0.0012249872,
0.0135196112,
-0.0070475568,
-0.0482607521,
-0.0094044013,
-0.0137246083,
0.0613789074,
0.0356732532,
-0.0079235444,
0.0084295943,
-0.0154795628,
0.0507322326,
0.0403762944,
-0.0102006178,
-0.0211808477,
0.0089475997,
0.0016688695,
-0.0442005843,
-0.0157452114,
-0.0182159133,
0.0413543694,
0.0133732622,
-0.0035812235,
-0.0566761754,
-0.0565685555,
0.0234552212,
0.0576445237,
0.0703871623,
-0.0168578643,
-0.0296217091,
0.0032434117,
0.0178949274,
-0.0299831275,
0.0201226063,
-0.0131432768,
0.0087697124,
-0.0265841428,
-0.0283794962,
0.0138189038,
0.0307680573,
-0.0559284352,
-0.0300572701,
-0.0704162046,
0.005749186,
-0.0165047757,
-0.0485799871,
0.0201332103,
-0.0345005803,
-0.0113189388,
0.0213291552,
0.0269919652,
0.0465728156,
0.0334320031,
0.0434472077,
0.0016615673,
0.0444714613,
-0.0146695888,
0.0279604085,
-0.0656367987,
-0.069169417,
-0.0132879512,
0.0161641613,
0.0334826335,
0.0321537927,
0.022182975,
-0.0407456085,
0.0168467946,
-0.035296794,
0.0125527922,
0.0290241707,
0.0568643883,
0.0410583951,
0.0236833245,
-0.0119687309,
-0.0083098048,
0.061691843,
-0.0166832879,
0.0341174006,
-0.0267095473,
-0.049824819,
-0.0535967164,
-0.0431003124,
0.021516284,
0.0006244938,
-0.0347923376,
-0.0395036601,
-0.068415761,
-0.0134769501,
0.061134886,
0.0196103267,
-0.0340326019,
-0.0142730772,
0.0196151212,
0.0429361686,
0.0121524977,
0.021309657,
0.0068116733,
0.0020566904,
-0.0243549384,
0.0056211548,
0.0327358507,
-6.581816214e-33,
0.009277124,
-0.0519606322,
0.0090134414,
-0.0172350351,
0.043707855,
0.0284585096,
-0.0318552181,
0.0017178935,
0.0529434383,
0.0050926073,
-0.0255866274,
0.001723137,
0.0207911972,
0.009581103,
0.0334726796,
-0.0199123863,
0.0129604759,
0.0174601376,
-0.0218983609,
-0.0071496954,
0.0042701475,
0.0062664347,
0.0088092759,
-0.1150096506,
0.0290232822,
0.0395651832,
-0.0098771974,
0.0232929718,
-0.0340653807,
0.0376533531,
-0.034789782,
0.0207702573,
0.0130866887,
-0.0343676843,
-0.0182466302,
-0.0052391454,
-0.070563294,
-0.0281906724,
-0.01273135,
-0.055277288,
-0.0269499421,
-0.019272821,
0.0449597389,
0.0009168717,
-0.0123930406,
-0.0249289144,
0.0147057455,
-0.0321907625,
-0.0351801701,
-0.0697931796,
0.0377468839,
0.0782201141,
-0.0012341962,
0.0244338177,
0.0032707141,
0.0056277383,
-0.0269758701,
0.0130863972,
-0.0514550097,
0.0149741434,
0.0418873131,
-0.0199963618,
0.0119584966,
-0.0468810648,
-0.0192386955,
0.0890859589,
0.0422309227,
-0.018515788,
-0.085179247,
0.007398048,
-0.0470425077,
0.0489035062,
0.0174242817,
0.0259103328,
0.0691613555,
0.0213072691,
-0.0889688283,
0.0801632553,
-0.0569158755,
0.0678032562,
0.0537571833,
-0.0143809235,
-0.0649011731,
-0.0080403611,
-0.009790007,
-0.0017360987,
-0.0256847814,
-0.0304018222,
0.0157651342,
0.028885765,
-0.0027117068,
0.0302597638,
0.0103687188,
0.0158915557,
0.0198399052,
-0.0402236655,
0.0638351366,
-0.0218253303,
-0.0325378142,
-0.0225600712,
-0.0030179836,
-0.0146053201,
0.0417117588,
0.0076937145,
0.0381839983,
0.0193078369,
0.0145468889,
-0.0292505119,
-0.0660267025,
-0.0076328153,
0.0227401834,
0.0181729048,
-0.0295212269,
-0.0278580803,
0.0617796108,
0.0007085754,
-0.0004115008,
0.0775067806,
-0.0183486864,
0.0251804087,
-0.0329511315,
-0.0117302639,
-0.0073852101,
0.0128560141,
-0.0026739743,
-0.0074509396,
-0.0141439233,
-0.0340031758,
0.0361829437,
-0.0083070733,
-0.0023536156,
0.0422963351,
2.933e-7,
0.0801105276,
0.0305974018,
0.0525955744,
0.0034849702,
0.0134703955,
0.0100915888,
-0.0206341539,
-0.0193581544,
0.0414971635,
-0.08122769,
0.0658604875,
0.0345736034,
0.0430410691,
0.073297672,
-0.0391057804,
-0.0717725828,
-0.0416619703,
-0.0112547725,
-0.0223125685,
-0.0069263135,
0.0975147486,
0.0183830317,
-0.0457039885,
-0.0514821,
-0.0031435341,
0.0058255238,
0.0401635505,
-0.053363353,
0.0304796062,
-0.0190230161,
0.0687626079,
-0.0119659612,
0.022329703,
0.0698967129,
-0.0025667967,
-0.0259499643,
-0.0222180858,
0.083614178,
-0.043840304,
-0.0092697022,
0.0127607463,
-0.0157601275,
0.0511263907,
-0.0015811371,
0.0710290298,
-0.0483257174,
-0.0341992006,
0.0203748383,
-0.0408195667,
-0.0084709767,
0.0832052603,
-0.0023484083,
-0.0223795976,
0.0276088174,
0.0024094114,
0.0479864739,
-0.0198975764,
-0.0577458628,
0.0103053264,
0.0483566634,
-0.0079799742,
-0.0304452144,
0.0622831434,
-0.0097227907,
-0.0247223731,
-0.1192986742,
-0.017691223,
2.591659691e-34,
0.0392189398,
0.0401754044,
-0.0252968352,
0.0176155195,
0.0143691888,
0.0006385334,
0.0001196689,
-0.0049144537,
0.0283444095,
-0.0989663303,
-0.012231118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04461v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04461v2 | Measuring and Improving Chain-of-Thought Reasoning in Vision-Language Models | 2023-09-08T17:49:44 | 2024-03-19T21:48:59 | Yangyi Chen, Karan Sikka, Michael Cogswell, Heng Ji, Ajay Divakaran | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Vision-language models (VLMs) have recently demonstrated strong efficacy as
visual assistants that can parse natural queries about the visual content and
generate human-like outputs. In this work, we explore the ability of these
models to demonstrate human-like reasoning based on the perceived information.
To address a crucial concern regarding the extent to which their reasoning
capabilities are fully consistent and grounded, we also measure the reasoning
consistency of these models. We achieve this by proposing a chain-of-thought
(CoT) based consistency measure. However, such an evaluation requires a
benchmark that encompasses both high-level inference and detailed reasoning
chains, which is costly. We tackle this challenge by proposing a
LLM-Human-in-the-Loop pipeline, which notably reduces cost while simultaneously
ensuring the generation of a high-quality dataset. Based on this pipeline and
the existing coarse-grained annotated dataset, we build the CURE benchmark to
measure both the zero-shot reasoning performance and consistency of VLMs. We
evaluate existing state-of-the-art VLMs, and find that even the best-performing
model is unable to demonstrate strong visual reasoning capabilities and
consistency, indicating that substantial efforts are required to enable VLMs to
perform visual reasoning as systematically and consistently as humans. As an
early step, we propose a two-stage training framework aimed at improving both
the reasoning performance and consistency of VLMs. The first stage involves
employing supervised fine-tuning of VLMs using step-by-step reasoning samples
automatically generated by LLMs. In the second stage, we further augment the
training process by incorporating feedback provided by LLMs to produce
reasoning chains that are highly consistent and grounded. We empirically
highlight the effectiveness of our framework in both reasoning performance and
consistency. | [
0.0382966958,
0.0528380238,
0.0021010577,
0.0579418167,
-0.048168648,
0.0368500128,
-0.0001405756,
-0.0093371365,
0.0225897152,
-0.0428410135,
-0.0115514155,
-0.0021158187,
0.0183707867,
0.0333126895,
0.021751428,
-0.0735975057,
0.0270308293,
-0.0378442965,
-0.0169836711,
0.0331087671,
0.0009900187,
0.0131884385,
-0.0038869018,
0.0444960035,
-0.0118269296,
-0.0357463323,
-0.0045504542,
0.0177325495,
0.0373338871,
-0.0279889796,
-0.0311817285,
0.0194668155,
0.0585566461,
0.0005733077,
0.0000021592,
-0.0395316519,
0.0275283623,
0.0105746817,
-0.02034197,
-0.0149793057,
-0.0390059501,
-0.0320424996,
0.0178396981,
0.0068942853,
-0.0266055111,
0.0149864731,
0.0231981725,
0.0263301358,
0.0777831078,
0.0232351962,
-0.0123967435,
-0.0171934348,
0.0116975633,
-0.0121034496,
0.0304495394,
-0.0501315445,
0.0085983761,
0.0332157239,
0.0146503821,
-0.0122544002,
-0.0200113431,
0.0291057434,
0.0420840941,
-0.0266133621,
-0.0144048855,
0.0353222862,
-0.0477588326,
-0.0604576468,
-0.0104673794,
0.071124807,
-0.0263233688,
-0.0197980646,
-0.0062972973,
-0.0102167716,
-0.0085194958,
-0.0090841502,
-0.0292316377,
0.0424592569,
-0.0337693207,
0.0182321183,
-0.0498231761,
-0.0054055783,
0.0184767488,
0.0238877628,
-0.019449003,
0.0378397144,
-0.0297010783,
0.0111876056,
0.0239455216,
0.0349988714,
-0.0258798208,
-0.054454267,
-0.0304474179,
0.039615877,
-0.0181344561,
0.0133561939,
-0.0191976242,
0.022217093,
-0.0169369299,
-0.0244266558,
0.0586364307,
0.0368164778,
-0.0556593463,
0.0757233724,
-0.052665785,
0.0722695515,
-0.0106586097,
0.0582557321,
-0.0050692684,
-0.0393181145,
-0.0521218479,
0.0120414542,
-0.0063013495,
0.0019588515,
-0.0165862832,
-0.0286557283,
-0.0106203631,
0.0095904563,
-0.0212957188,
0.04027142,
0.0159158614,
0.0354479514,
0.0196935181,
-0.0431833938,
-0.0813245103,
0.0228746329,
-0.0216921046,
0.0254863538,
0.0025257119,
-0.0554596223,
0.002695547,
0.0242340397,
-0.0022374585,
-0.0038927482,
0.0079913111,
0.052550789,
-0.030657161,
-0.014158275,
-0.0505949222,
-0.0206802916,
0.0043041287,
-0.0676487461,
0.0223189443,
-0.057799466,
0.0256380681,
0.0080973534,
-0.014356019,
-0.0187725499,
0.0037111605,
0.0273746215,
-0.0430083945,
0.0993165448,
-0.0417611934,
0.0081234667,
-0.0118274894,
0.0106943632,
-0.024975894,
0.0511327125,
0.0441659912,
0.0537496395,
0.0148237832,
0.0239550341,
0.0138972187,
0.0041403328,
-0.0149775911,
-0.0199670736,
-0.0619495921,
0.0215019304,
-0.0472215526,
0.0289479997,
0.0017444593,
0.0566018187,
-0.0098718526,
-0.0399231762,
0.0556843504,
0.0529240295,
0.0134090884,
-0.0342340432,
0.0757258236,
-0.0051764254,
0.0103386519,
-0.0023559842,
-0.070114255,
0.0662447065,
0.0098953303,
-0.0045371735,
-0.0202108249,
0.008661096,
-0.0235077664,
-0.0668935403,
-0.0360141322,
0.0142882587,
-0.0032318167,
0.0308927335,
0.042871464,
0.0025479922,
-0.0263846479,
0.0071858,
0.0144655304,
-0.0291899852,
-0.0200808812,
-0.0535954498,
0.0437465683,
0.0710723624,
0.0404074416,
0.0256610885,
-0.0074343821,
0.0101127401,
0.0390118659,
0.0283316094,
-0.0034026126,
0.0075764339,
0.0113584027,
-0.0435318276,
-0.0521428697,
-0.0034708565,
0.0003237919,
0.0028067562,
0.0135845114,
-0.0340776406,
0.0080631599,
-0.0538187064,
-0.007805849,
0.0420052372,
0.0269075036,
0.0244130418,
-0.0308769085,
0.0309487917,
-0.0037698247,
-0.0197278224,
0.0029846535,
-0.0012110837,
0.0017778887,
-0.0153086903,
0.0100385053,
0.0192551892,
-0.0247629546,
-0.0052497233,
0.0262231287,
-0.0681913346,
-0.0472239144,
0.0151716629,
-0.0581865795,
-0.0036678687,
0.005884239,
-0.0191436354,
-0.0385880508,
-0.0642906427,
-0.0168019626,
0.025978215,
-0.0071731065,
-0.0086784307,
0.0795327052,
-0.045019269,
-0.0210509896,
0.0161557235,
0.0096341521,
0.0323953964,
-0.0338797383,
0.0279379804,
-0.0113180261,
-0.0074550933,
0.0009065708,
-0.0180849936,
0.0068358653,
-0.0483591668,
0.0082626706,
-0.0684497952,
-0.0317621157,
-0.0144113898,
-0.015743196,
-0.0118630519,
-0.0407713242,
-0.0014030468,
-0.0335486941,
-0.0021093157,
0.0396711156,
0.0066522546,
-0.0006242212,
0.057769224,
-0.0129676098,
0.0105316294,
-0.0184667595,
0.0093894033,
-0.0072241197,
0.0514945462,
0.0308977123,
-0.0343288444,
-0.0196152925,
-0.001590026,
-0.0620754994,
0.043941319,
-0.0230738316,
-0.0075140828,
0.054470282,
-0.018735921,
-0.0002777552,
0.1084234118,
0.0052082757,
0.0120353866,
0.0277256742,
0.0127797658,
-0.0322193764,
0.0111833764,
0.0066378359,
-0.0224737804,
-0.0061935056,
-0.0176346172,
-0.0348818451,
0.032739792,
-0.0188110359,
0.0170527305,
-0.0782921761,
0.0442495532,
0.0205795001,
-0.0364053883,
-0.0678869188,
0.0040447148,
0.0135064991,
0.0759296194,
-0.0575416982,
-0.0750077069,
0.0706587508,
-0.0378363691,
0.0136910537,
0.0337080024,
0.0027240266,
-0.0373575799,
0.081041418,
0.0218114294,
-0.0101520931,
-0.0128680933,
0.0380663164,
-0.0673025995,
-0.0232075397,
0.0285262987,
-0.0060324939,
0.0570950881,
-0.0825740546,
0.0245015044,
-0.0246474259,
-0.0194404833,
-0.0585682839,
0.028607456,
-0.078776665,
0.0105379205,
-0.0690621287,
-0.0092468578,
-0.0092073074,
0.0172275454,
0.0398904532,
0.0241159238,
0.0231094807,
-0.0238681249,
-0.0243350454,
0.0046150135,
0.0555581897,
0.0245181341,
0.0101324506,
-0.0210539699,
0.031034153,
0.0550895892,
0.0055489852,
0.0023561507,
-0.0687089562,
0.0466141216,
-0.0159748439,
0.0570683554,
0.021805957,
0.0479906984,
0.0316746421,
-0.0682854354,
-0.0043932288,
0.0918811858,
0.0248963069,
-0.0210098457,
-0.0089809811,
0.0035335843,
0.0175358597,
0.0502775237,
0.0210278761,
-0.0823168457,
-0.0657535419,
0.0100699095,
0.0007472754,
0.0109035904,
-0.0391875729,
-0.0300034024,
-0.0932743922,
0.0838099197,
-0.0246579554,
0.0314180367,
-0.0337534361,
-0.0052532218,
0.0078544086,
-0.0072097522,
-0.0300611239,
-0.0042838608,
0.0147767803,
0.0168709382,
-0.0005272687,
0.0182900317,
-0.0164396167,
0.0627426133,
-0.0631581619,
-0.0089740073,
0.0565123037,
0.0014930699,
0.0437917784,
-0.1137337685,
0.0258305129,
-0.009786848,
0.0272537898,
-0.0058057094,
0.0513426252,
-0.0349177904,
-0.0416841656,
-0.0024742775,
0.0357713439,
-0.0165347084,
-0.0199413616,
-0.0208411869,
0.0519189648,
-0.0313426182,
-0.0257457215,
-0.0432361402,
0.0103286272,
-0.0496334508,
0.0614302382,
0.0316054858,
-0.0111957006,
-0.0426718704,
-0.0172796194,
-0.039322421,
-0.0401799418,
-0.0473950058,
0.0199330132,
0.041873727,
0.0183233749,
-0.0580444857,
-0.0227898099,
0.0268881619,
0.0597581714,
-0.0375533029,
-0.0414715372,
0.0080192611,
0.018142255,
-0.0557385087,
0.0776809156,
-0.0386329256,
0.0401731022,
-0.0307436604,
0.0231331978,
0.0069075031,
-0.0499082133,
-0.0261736587,
0.0245784596,
-0.0825415552,
-0.0238126796,
-0.0540179871,
0.0815629587,
0.024462482,
0.0471033901,
0.0057245605,
-0.0270117223,
-0.0151094589,
0.0424452499,
0.017436862,
0.014037502,
-0.0006143767,
0.000773502,
0.01079698,
0.0387592129,
-0.0303202122,
0.0235757437,
0.0234609302,
0.0225406457,
-0.0199256148,
-0.0135071976,
0.0341671109,
-0.0018109229,
0.0455357283,
-0.0027082886,
-0.0054176864,
-0.0049079424,
0.0240358207,
0.0052201734,
-0.0258526448,
-0.0882880837,
0.0142066516,
0.0058058081,
0.0156827047,
0.0074953781,
-0.0335602798,
-0.0049614026,
0.0223630369,
-0.0274930131,
-0.0522167645,
0.0167526472,
0.012293132,
-0.0181737393,
-0.0020671824,
-0.0051370198,
0.0081578903,
-0.0388544276,
0.0534003116,
0.0146696046,
0.0790546834,
0.0545654558,
-0.0040610065,
-0.025719393,
0.0180963967,
-0.0612307265,
-0.0609800518,
0.0001603993,
0.034096349,
0.0371851511,
0.0086781327,
-0.0140458038,
-0.0293101035,
-0.0058939252,
-0.0055813249,
0.0357233919,
0.0149550419,
-0.0311267972,
0.049928207,
0.0401438698,
0.0059162243,
-0.0321713276,
0.0356565863,
0.0122101409,
0.0150150191,
-0.029533444,
-0.020719979,
-0.0300447121,
-0.040118672,
-0.0151485298,
-0.0087855291,
0.01499019,
0.0391170532,
-0.0575212687,
-0.0905265883,
-0.0066576866,
0.0533785,
0.0225565527,
0.0341441557,
0.0302942395,
0.0674155131,
0.0246242825,
-0.0205130558,
0.0163950771,
-0.0474731401,
-0.0104358429,
-0.0022893345,
-0.021216657,
-6.49532334e-33,
-0.0051172138,
-0.0450235978,
0.0590217225,
0.0026311514,
0.0057767895,
0.013953072,
-0.0449837297,
-0.0170973279,
-0.0483637936,
0.0350809284,
0.0113800485,
0.0115092387,
-0.0008666283,
0.017915586,
-0.0085062683,
-0.0205825083,
0.003918462,
0.0161640048,
-0.0237974543,
-0.0340639018,
0.0127255125,
-0.0111752171,
0.0202177707,
-0.0474648252,
-0.0205114409,
0.0301037561,
-0.0162695684,
0.0590074249,
-0.0203287937,
0.0584837943,
-0.0026071146,
-0.0161565114,
0.0353794843,
0.0095977345,
-0.012040088,
-0.0026235501,
-0.0808707476,
-0.0090794908,
0.0407746136,
0.0053617726,
-0.1129407138,
0.0219785776,
0.0388166569,
0.0082553132,
-0.0018014151,
-0.0581161864,
0.0414024033,
-0.0272908155,
-0.001105252,
0.0088765956,
-0.0047091725,
0.0114317797,
-0.0039056453,
-0.0474613234,
0.0389566496,
0.026087435,
0.0037746108,
0.0532843061,
-0.0419911742,
-0.0002046457,
-0.0096877525,
-0.0137063563,
0.1175126284,
0.0100029288,
-0.0012181503,
0.070786804,
0.0123916911,
-0.028081445,
-0.0790113434,
-0.0047663995,
0.0106744105,
0.0798489302,
0.0778859034,
0.0315449908,
-0.0032188382,
0.0527885184,
-0.0740924254,
0.019882936,
-0.053875301,
0.1023076326,
-0.004428362,
0.0168471038,
0.0006730277,
0.0092100771,
-0.0509047247,
-0.041030746,
-0.0544166677,
0.0126318773,
0.0503692254,
0.0216672737,
-0.0231972802,
0.0186945237,
0.0344407409,
-0.0245037172,
0.012034527,
0.0036149207,
-0.0237758849,
0.033512257,
0.0329909697,
0.0180727467,
-0.0501705557,
0.0209587757,
0.0570648387,
0.0389314853,
0.0095160063,
0.0010088821,
0.0456024557,
-0.0082059111,
-0.0085243611,
-0.0074906442,
-0.0721208528,
0.01635045,
-0.0354368947,
0.0207163244,
0.0385996625,
0.0289505236,
-0.0584509298,
0.0439025648,
-0.0373282693,
-0.0378145128,
-0.0163046401,
0.018862702,
-0.0016878097,
0.0241479669,
-0.0227451622,
-0.0025263063,
-0.0346103869,
-0.0331217349,
0.028489776,
-0.0493082739,
-0.0014221626,
0.0651320741,
2.753e-7,
0.0084592765,
0.033060994,
0.0257185604,
0.0336349085,
0.004540862,
0.0543027073,
-0.0166385118,
-0.0083007803,
0.0199487098,
-0.1149650589,
-0.0116737382,
0.0791921094,
0.0517121628,
0.0062398165,
-0.0102377776,
0.03420588,
-0.0354405493,
-0.0420790426,
-0.0425012484,
-0.0043033045,
0.0659486875,
0.0472147726,
-0.0004668203,
-0.0317912363,
0.0696370006,
-0.0383037999,
0.0573240556,
-0.0217637941,
0.0200754348,
-0.0461337455,
0.013210413,
0.0049254857,
0.0036274407,
0.0398177467,
-0.0048131458,
-0.0268774293,
0.0267754029,
0.0241901334,
-0.0140907755,
-0.012542123,
-0.0494128801,
-0.0001620851,
0.0091430442,
-0.0713695213,
0.0919967517,
-0.0508008488,
0.007182254,
-0.0012326555,
-0.0122985812,
0.0050883153,
0.0130154267,
0.0111221848,
-0.023379093,
0.0202431008,
0.0332582183,
-0.0178808011,
-0.0326122828,
-0.0811495632,
-0.0358112603,
-0.0430118777,
-0.0307223964,
0.0003487362,
-0.0635284111,
-0.0049781227,
0.0389108472,
-0.0117386319,
-0.0764499679,
2.3163945e-34,
0.0126208263,
-0.0123951668,
0.0305998065,
-0.0150425965,
0.0379682481,
-0.000639318,
-0.0300804097,
0.0038029442,
-0.0016022796,
-0.0622350164,
-0.0033060219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04389v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04389v2 | CSPRD: A Financial Policy Retrieval Dataset for Chinese Stock Market | 2023-09-08T15:40:54 | 2023-09-11T05:19:16 | Jinyuan Wang, Hai Zhao, Zhong Wang, Zeyang Zhu, Jinhao Xie, Yong Yu, Yongjian Fei, Yue Huang, Dawei Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CE | In recent years, great advances in pre-trained language models (PLMs) have
sparked considerable research focus and achieved promising performance on the
approach of dense passage retrieval, which aims at retrieving relative passages
from massive corpus with given questions. However, most of existing datasets
mainly benchmark the models with factoid queries of general commonsense, while
specialised fields such as finance and economics remain unexplored due to the
deficiency of large-scale and high-quality datasets with expert annotations. In
this work, we propose a new task, policy retrieval, by introducing the Chinese
Stock Policy Retrieval Dataset (CSPRD), which provides 700+ prospectus passages
labeled by experienced experts with relevant articles from 10k+ entries in our
collected Chinese policy corpus. Experiments on lexical, embedding and
fine-tuned bi-encoder models show the effectiveness of our proposed CSPRD yet
also suggests ample potential for improvement. Our best performing baseline
achieves 56.1% MRR@10, 28.5% NDCG@10, 37.5% Recall@10 and 80.6% Precision@10 on
dev set. | [
0.0337828547,
0.0554865524,
-0.0007383705,
0.0073337951,
0.0313644521,
-0.0096440697,
0.0324825794,
0.045973435,
0.0342307314,
-0.0240515955,
-0.0157773178,
-0.0663116053,
-0.0556247942,
0.0414729379,
0.0149285952,
-0.0412655771,
0.0503992587,
0.0161896776,
0.0800593495,
-0.0103345774,
0.040253967,
0.0142955724,
0.0426802039,
0.0290150363,
0.0121398903,
0.0278420039,
-0.0190151557,
-0.0129932407,
0.0203241985,
-0.022214679,
0.0379966833,
0.0146981152,
0.0774912313,
0.0052763675,
0.0000016416,
-0.0367741175,
-0.0379921533,
-0.0046548271,
0.0090887854,
0.0100453664,
0.0236331522,
-0.0431197621,
0.0642089099,
0.0061070956,
-0.0543891527,
0.0207122192,
0.0319740772,
0.0711840466,
0.0916155055,
0.0990827158,
-0.004608986,
-0.0417553596,
-0.0035164685,
-0.0898590013,
0.0204440095,
-0.0942550749,
0.0421468206,
0.0106554022,
-0.0227635,
0.0441337153,
-0.0104920929,
0.0308479518,
0.0033184588,
0.0144968526,
-0.0097802319,
-0.0119176926,
0.0043224203,
0.003448863,
-0.011735538,
0.0700824931,
0.0177089628,
0.0272810943,
0.0262672957,
-0.0203896966,
-0.0224551074,
0.053284131,
-0.0365717746,
0.0170692615,
0.0047298283,
0.0313490331,
0.0059701344,
-0.0088064969,
0.0115417764,
-0.0022124373,
-0.0585358478,
-0.0084535787,
-0.0324448608,
-0.060736414,
0.0443205982,
0.0046839421,
0.0149160912,
-0.0007466548,
0.029501196,
-0.0120119909,
0.0176214967,
-0.0079112388,
-0.0080014626,
-0.0157338232,
-0.0037946207,
-0.059722133,
-0.014075838,
0.0352178812,
-0.0162463672,
0.0661143661,
-0.0169217605,
0.0099022007,
0.0154210851,
0.0159401465,
-0.0153666073,
0.0139998533,
-0.0352038816,
-0.0242706072,
-0.0762512907,
0.069337301,
-0.0469724983,
-0.0476832874,
-0.0469091535,
-0.0330743454,
-0.0202919226,
0.0303740017,
0.0169991218,
-0.0128655322,
-0.0485498533,
-0.0228562597,
-0.0476561487,
0.0077513829,
-0.0519159064,
0.0102246776,
-0.0056270519,
0.0260184202,
-0.0018079196,
0.0044280468,
0.0070842677,
-0.0174057391,
0.0126727,
0.017409008,
0.0070837229,
-0.0639928058,
-0.0270610861,
-0.0411719792,
0.0007254816,
0.0065927091,
-0.0228844248,
-0.0116228694,
0.0212849434,
-0.0659884438,
-0.0037689121,
-0.0429038964,
0.0279491805,
0.0117889391,
-0.0454535149,
0.0631264225,
0.0338021293,
-0.0572778285,
-0.0349063575,
0.0003927705,
0.0680441856,
0.0736810863,
-0.0079200035,
0.0239075776,
0.082771197,
0.0355539918,
-0.0071953777,
0.0040182383,
0.0319516137,
-0.0290568192,
0.0265597552,
0.0441927761,
0.0105253505,
-0.013880725,
0.040115349,
-0.0014953999,
-0.0218360275,
-0.0337837823,
0.0231456514,
0.0347030498,
0.0202375874,
-0.0110480264,
-0.0024459739,
0.0285543799,
0.0080452496,
-0.016131334,
0.0181897637,
-0.0173493829,
-0.0002088839,
0.0421372764,
0.0464375839,
0.0080107087,
-0.029513916,
-0.0410737656,
0.0124496212,
0.0209511891,
-0.0323969834,
0.0229475703,
0.0505009443,
-0.040877331,
-0.0622221753,
0.070530355,
0.0186153911,
-0.0302367546,
0.0014414967,
0.0241061561,
0.0227797944,
0.0510480553,
0.0292880181,
-0.0604896955,
0.0207592994,
-0.0145580163,
-0.0150740081,
0.0477678627,
0.0461996496,
-0.0173796099,
-0.0265571587,
-0.0681657717,
-0.0265221205,
0.0014443503,
0.0427291393,
0.0319915786,
0.0159787368,
0.0156369545,
0.0179282147,
-0.0203561801,
0.0214677323,
0.023376381,
-0.0035076765,
-0.0300368536,
0.0071105189,
-0.0136526637,
-0.0006056105,
0.046579767,
-0.0397205353,
-0.0134063717,
0.002214103,
-0.0295847282,
-0.034774866,
-0.0021647087,
-0.0606948845,
-0.0121848239,
0.011728853,
-0.0229142606,
0.0008343626,
0.0170407947,
-0.0498603657,
-0.03823746,
-0.0533694401,
0.0182246603,
0.0007337471,
-0.0757931545,
-0.0503056906,
0.0034797429,
0.0100474898,
-0.033081945,
0.0529146828,
-0.0221084002,
0.0334675238,
0.0021165544,
0.0198310297,
0.0317148119,
-0.054804977,
-0.0232006218,
0.018298544,
-0.0143905999,
0.0400984958,
0.0664545968,
-0.0133032249,
0.0088645751,
-0.0151160583,
-0.0447165519,
0.0073711942,
-0.0237442199,
0.0052213129,
-0.0170775615,
-0.0058182566,
-0.0057706703,
-0.0330312662,
-0.0308580752,
-0.0157114584,
-0.0534191467,
-0.0081829308,
0.0301222689,
0.0143195856,
0.0093667358,
-0.0431536511,
-0.0093180556,
-0.0035612539,
-0.0204681326,
0.0032657187,
-0.0047877114,
0.0010372959,
0.0248623416,
0.0097723817,
-0.0028341054,
-0.0373928733,
0.0246860646,
0.0006719014,
-0.0381372795,
0.0004817542,
0.0540310182,
0.0199085567,
0.0750776231,
-0.0168294013,
-0.0150387483,
-0.0518571809,
0.0398865789,
-0.0271208845,
-0.0134670902,
-0.0132171195,
0.0245896727,
0.0350772701,
0.0376041085,
-0.0058021424,
0.0006033067,
-0.0792398006,
-0.0045576459,
-0.0077973423,
0.0264347903,
-0.0744858161,
0.0365150012,
-0.0178414099,
0.0471225269,
-0.0126438923,
-0.0264707692,
0.0604213029,
-0.0129645467,
-0.0246497653,
-0.0257044807,
-0.0378827639,
-0.0605391972,
0.0619556084,
-0.0261535905,
0.0082527408,
-0.0327651165,
-0.0439584106,
-0.0164145529,
0.0085900482,
0.0371909551,
-0.0466284156,
0.0001489543,
-0.0164836347,
0.0770051554,
-0.0128488326,
-0.042924244,
-0.0032582064,
-0.0913034976,
-0.0154110836,
0.0269210134,
0.0535112731,
-0.0431363955,
-0.0195098892,
0.0658619478,
-0.0338825956,
0.0114781549,
0.0335420258,
-0.0164268352,
0.0156663936,
0.0138234496,
0.0558958948,
0.0158457514,
-0.0218573995,
-0.007007583,
0.0240977574,
0.0291669015,
0.0178331826,
-0.0079392632,
0.0154274013,
0.0013369931,
0.0036358421,
-0.0736163259,
0.0397558697,
0.0102111362,
0.0049266391,
-0.052641619,
-0.0312419236,
0.0771551207,
0.0234636683,
0.0103267329,
-0.017798977,
0.0457119234,
-0.0064808587,
-0.0065361629,
0.0241667405,
-0.1227382123,
-0.0036618281,
0.0084574763,
0.0197392032,
0.0285613444,
-0.051292032,
0.0011385545,
-0.128422901,
0.026334703,
-0.0136856129,
0.0031987368,
-0.0866905749,
-0.0602352992,
-0.0182241853,
-0.0383443236,
0.0036743165,
0.0223819185,
-0.0156283658,
0.0160698593,
-0.0045226198,
-0.018946033,
-0.0091481935,
-0.004490905,
-0.0218499638,
-0.0244934782,
0.02911699,
-0.0046410509,
0.0060344776,
0.0355746448,
-0.0394611731,
-0.0514270626,
-0.0276935119,
0.0002369455,
0.0441676565,
-0.0535092652,
-0.0403213575,
0.0120931529,
0.0391376838,
-0.0282330122,
0.0206887983,
-0.0133665055,
-0.020074416,
-0.0457827039,
-0.0290115643,
-0.0141438525,
0.0511716045,
-0.0111093707,
0.0799549073,
0.0132251419,
-0.0000936846,
-0.0108758518,
-0.0399605036,
0.0179497022,
-0.0673808903,
-0.0440712199,
0.0012293764,
-0.0284053162,
0.0456863232,
-0.0812253132,
-0.0719786659,
0.010250425,
0.053918086,
-0.0130331311,
0.0006359051,
0.0695263371,
-0.0028623138,
-0.0155148515,
0.0134164197,
-0.0474241264,
-0.0245392509,
-0.03461992,
-0.0228939448,
0.012867745,
0.0338450111,
-0.0600738488,
0.0116520766,
-0.0190772805,
-0.0330377482,
-0.0107706441,
-0.0011917397,
0.0090552811,
0.000779738,
-0.0393378399,
0.0504013561,
0.108014144,
0.0754432157,
-0.0533289686,
-0.0366574787,
0.0410363525,
0.0178382974,
-0.0167229474,
0.0272784773,
-0.0370079093,
-0.0118218055,
-0.0272858962,
0.0665208027,
-0.0309841596,
-0.0293719135,
0.0033428075,
0.0047456236,
0.0495041981,
0.0467445329,
-0.0036766869,
-0.0762533769,
0.0116084274,
-0.0011992182,
-0.0010540589,
-0.0230048653,
-0.0106448382,
0.0444730297,
-0.0624887049,
-0.0331852324,
0.0825809538,
0.0069413525,
0.0242839754,
-0.0130950361,
-0.0050253766,
-0.0145516982,
0.0203090645,
0.0010516626,
0.0022187242,
-0.001374885,
0.0241263956,
0.032477472,
0.0304260161,
-0.000997904,
0.0120438877,
0.0295861177,
-0.0030278107,
0.0160508789,
-0.0367070436,
-0.0491929241,
-0.0144691244,
-0.0210581757,
0.0478009805,
0.0464643873,
-0.0562056452,
-0.0197884981,
-0.0452289768,
-0.0020744822,
0.0023560023,
0.01565779,
0.0024603715,
-0.0061017368,
0.0192914251,
0.0046165534,
-0.0551357269,
0.0051274518,
0.0972088054,
0.010342462,
0.0328424089,
0.0188189838,
-0.0283583906,
-0.0145299947,
-0.0479322709,
0.0628655031,
0.0382223837,
-0.0047892435,
0.0018367457,
-0.0498592593,
-0.0188828018,
0.0026600412,
-0.0048916759,
-0.0409522243,
0.0396528505,
0.0229260307,
0.0610341541,
0.0037882649,
0.042113129,
-0.0116549553,
-0.0015556111,
-0.0255578198,
-0.004851588,
-0.0633685216,
-5.622753516e-33,
-0.0356336534,
0.001809004,
0.0288427472,
-0.0517496616,
0.0154658835,
-0.0197678152,
-0.0187252648,
-0.0342582092,
-0.012394201,
0.0221121125,
0.0150805544,
0.0148868766,
0.0069886399,
0.0389849506,
-0.0022847785,
-0.0086672548,
0.0528181121,
0.0133791836,
-0.0058414489,
-0.0050509241,
0.061016608,
0.0838057473,
0.0414099395,
-0.0181389228,
0.0505188257,
0.009350731,
0.0005962538,
-0.0064945873,
0.0437149666,
0.0430996157,
0.0139186531,
0.0585502684,
0.0220693015,
-0.0801347643,
-0.0161485691,
0.022904858,
-0.06796702,
-0.0649268776,
-0.0086226221,
0.0159550998,
0.0429406464,
0.023966942,
0.0400305688,
-0.0141877597,
0.0549332015,
-0.0031740856,
0.0323936939,
0.0056752656,
0.0095844045,
-0.0589375086,
-0.0257495381,
0.0341924541,
-0.0098247882,
0.0414062887,
0.026342649,
0.0569899976,
0.0384766534,
0.0600651242,
-0.0398475304,
-0.0136650065,
-0.0406574681,
0.0503468886,
-0.0286592171,
-0.0236298144,
-0.0065740217,
0.0412765853,
-0.0510994568,
-0.0100057637,
-0.0063465862,
0.0132801281,
0.033345703,
0.0362823829,
-0.0091669466,
0.0715619996,
0.040858347,
-0.0208180994,
-0.0489757061,
0.0615882948,
0.0145541597,
0.0300883371,
0.0241605137,
0.0322159678,
-0.0229722317,
-0.0188463181,
-0.0322990902,
0.0074146376,
-0.0099657234,
-0.0116040073,
0.0308405962,
0.0526929423,
0.0005441443,
0.0460285284,
0.0328433253,
-0.0493179262,
-0.0523924902,
-0.0017367797,
-0.0026689954,
-0.0315196067,
-0.0006526522,
0.030473439,
-0.0475401208,
-0.0630215704,
0.0063024303,
-0.026717566,
-0.0597953424,
-0.0523075871,
0.0116725676,
-0.0335652158,
-0.0658649355,
-0.0123192389,
0.01851294,
-0.0152752437,
0.0109703876,
0.0515360124,
-0.0113395918,
0.0559934191,
0.0220428742,
0.0469987653,
0.0073929881,
0.0278515536,
-0.0136137903,
-0.0551372617,
-0.0010235131,
0.0170985945,
0.0186250098,
0.0303320829,
-0.0104261031,
0.0414366797,
0.0110651609,
-0.0335042253,
-0.0024943138,
0.0390667878,
2.323e-7,
0.0492114127,
0.0387705863,
0.0218320061,
0.0039327447,
-0.0352492593,
0.0237356313,
-0.0306059103,
0.0453739874,
-0.0329689011,
-0.0235289298,
0.0543757603,
0.0149019053,
0.0378931575,
-0.012365968,
-0.1258223802,
-0.0407684892,
-0.0593520813,
-0.0014932734,
-0.072318092,
0.0215632301,
0.0091128303,
0.0830695331,
0.0143228015,
0.008123924,
0.018076662,
-0.0815405324,
0.0583831295,
-0.0294584446,
-0.0453905873,
0.0260890815,
0.0344382823,
0.0531492569,
-0.0171328299,
-0.0084636742,
-0.0147528313,
0.0505660847,
0.0079714134,
0.0777576044,
0.0515992343,
-0.040596243,
-0.0210023317,
-0.007121555,
-0.0337988026,
-0.0105184829,
0.0510255471,
-0.0527883507,
-0.0169742126,
-0.0055441335,
-0.0706474632,
-0.0056874445,
0.0414684005,
0.0195908006,
-0.0158806592,
0.0321155712,
0.01844237,
0.0149717163,
0.045491755,
-0.0731242225,
0.0309054423,
0.0133028692,
-0.0325332582,
0.0094420426,
-0.0045072325,
-0.0040543666,
-0.0179437492,
-0.0395779535,
0.0249419995,
2.076951581e-34,
0.0507222861,
-0.0311262719,
-0.0402936786,
0.0078159319,
0.0775627643,
-0.0088115782,
-0.0256502721,
0.0327178501,
-0.0142101543,
-0.1063827649,
0.000549937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04372v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04372v2 | MoEController: Instruction-based Arbitrary Image Manipulation with Mixture-of-Expert Controllers | 2023-09-08T15:06:05 | 2024-03-30T05:05:52 | Sijia Li, Chen Chen, Haonan Lu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Diffusion-model-based text-guided image generation has recently made
astounding progress, producing fascinating results in open-domain image
manipulation tasks. Few models, however, currently have complete zero-shot
capabilities for both global and local image editing due to the complexity and
diversity of image manipulation tasks. In this work, we propose a method with a
mixture-of-expert (MOE) controllers to align the text-guided capacity of
diffusion models with different kinds of human instructions, enabling our model
to handle various open-domain image manipulation tasks with natural language
instructions. First, we use large language models (ChatGPT) and conditional
image synthesis models (ControlNet) to generate a large number of global image
transfer dataset in addition to the instruction-based local image editing
dataset. Then, using an MOE technique and task-specific adaptation training on
a large-scale dataset, our conditional diffusion model can edit images globally
and locally. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our approach performs
surprisingly well on various image manipulation tasks when dealing with
open-domain images and arbitrary human instructions. Please refer to our
project page: [https://oppo-mente-lab.github.io/moe_controller/] | [
0.0382979177,
0.049575191,
0.00291632,
0.0307953451,
-0.0186369643,
0.0115485378,
0.0509000346,
0.0163498838,
0.0114542376,
-0.0255808942,
-0.0550134741,
-0.016404422,
-0.0197464507,
-0.0226107072,
0.0191272777,
-0.0851320997,
0.0001919681,
-0.0322768949,
-0.0451088808,
-0.0017624383,
-0.003696779,
-0.0064103631,
-0.0143849114,
0.0119647337,
-0.0288528763,
0.0044066506,
-0.0330663882,
0.0518832169,
0.0291029643,
0.035979744,
-0.0183187481,
0.0912777781,
0.0550429374,
0.0119328704,
0.0000020356,
-0.0057865372,
0.0214215145,
0.0122420127,
0.0424460173,
-0.0248318613,
0.0906089619,
-0.0044372445,
-0.0563890375,
-0.0332696736,
-0.00852664,
0.0333731361,
0.0782904923,
0.0666671395,
0.1074826196,
0.0881129429,
-0.011695643,
-0.0303055029,
-0.0136031359,
-0.0117941974,
0.051122874,
-0.0119768288,
0.0358923078,
0.0466896594,
0.0404814705,
0.01610763,
-0.0530761294,
0.0464902781,
0.029861683,
-0.0302066617,
0.0130247464,
0.0338001736,
0.0505428724,
-0.0416608416,
-0.0357524268,
0.0536266044,
-0.067910336,
0.0354000628,
0.0006520454,
-0.0014601804,
0.017648885,
0.067492716,
-0.0351207294,
0.0125548933,
0.0022128648,
-0.002160551,
-0.0841128826,
-0.0333447009,
-0.0072120414,
-0.0080617033,
-0.0174940415,
0.0168933757,
0.0244985837,
0.0119072031,
-0.0242968518,
-0.0002236031,
-0.0221806057,
-0.0666188896,
0.043311622,
0.0262635443,
-0.0159466341,
-0.0068673347,
-0.0749015957,
-0.0602894314,
-0.02881095,
-0.0298437309,
0.0387530588,
0.024006376,
-0.0083683236,
0.0533279814,
-0.0231788661,
0.0405543186,
-0.0488650128,
0.029460635,
-0.0328572802,
0.0023459408,
-0.0773702636,
0.0118382173,
-0.0339541696,
-0.0203965064,
-0.0853260532,
-0.0090117967,
-0.0607264712,
0.012162229,
-0.0213157348,
0.0064787944,
0.020677736,
0.0237082615,
-0.0531748198,
-0.0442785136,
-0.0573242344,
0.0180279762,
-0.0009155947,
0.0404103585,
0.0304005947,
0.0016795472,
-0.0292774756,
0.0309893973,
0.0312624946,
-0.0224632714,
-0.006175688,
0.0993932262,
-0.0987768769,
0.0143099986,
-0.0225568432,
0.0070243874,
0.0104122562,
-0.0331254005,
0.0332107991,
-0.0595769472,
0.0259577967,
-0.0247360896,
-0.0118691232,
-0.079311125,
0.0033907138,
0.0187311135,
-0.0396594889,
0.0437338836,
-0.0167680085,
-0.000261799,
0.0723672062,
0.0209416635,
-0.0675991625,
0.0256180335,
0.0165443011,
0.0375775099,
0.0006532623,
0.0079705333,
0.0394005552,
0.0467352122,
-0.0268150084,
-0.0013133762,
-0.0147848856,
-0.0145681771,
0.0054242802,
0.0173007734,
0.0757671446,
0.0244129077,
-0.0621277764,
0.0150513491,
0.0727674589,
0.0261692237,
-0.0114191677,
0.0283969734,
0.0767164454,
0.0368977897,
-0.0036650153,
0.0086589511,
-0.0338745415,
0.0559373535,
0.0055528935,
-0.0023233013,
0.0041331621,
0.0042194868,
-0.0461467952,
-0.0293850172,
0.0330390222,
-0.0069788508,
-0.0022952345,
-0.0293819066,
0.0412408188,
0.0310333259,
-0.050180763,
-0.0541423187,
-0.0050232885,
-0.0541569963,
-0.018043777,
-0.0507254042,
-0.014474229,
0.0639050305,
0.0071887271,
-0.0025258774,
-0.0051364386,
-0.0152849797,
0.0225130524,
0.0506435335,
-0.007982919,
0.0290467981,
-0.0028386624,
-0.034989167,
-0.0376380943,
-0.0183255412,
0.0097489757,
0.0394742191,
0.0139973108,
0.0070934771,
0.0027729112,
0.0136770541,
-0.0369769856,
0.0365065783,
-0.0278269537,
-0.0281118881,
0.0194539931,
0.0133714499,
-0.0058548437,
-0.012634756,
-0.0579090789,
-0.0060553798,
-0.0306594726,
0.0121914186,
-0.0384365879,
-0.0260362495,
-0.0246916786,
-0.0157800373,
-0.0229973476,
-0.0602349117,
-0.0366870724,
-0.0439105816,
-0.0336123928,
-0.0417936966,
0.003727677,
0.0354413316,
-0.0141079044,
-0.0221619681,
-0.0026563369,
0.0337924212,
-0.0041433228,
0.0049690022,
0.0543737449,
-0.0119060446,
-0.0264983214,
0.0625689551,
0.0388495587,
-0.0269681439,
-0.0254477467,
-0.0067393724,
-0.0606081188,
0.0178298056,
0.0173642375,
0.0071691489,
0.0519577302,
-0.0448430516,
-0.0508574918,
-0.0681048259,
-0.0092792232,
-0.0175290331,
-0.0215061288,
0.031337373,
0.0190620609,
-0.0216804892,
-0.0061424468,
0.0067266333,
0.03281096,
-0.0421154238,
-0.0200591777,
0.0212410726,
0.0062826066,
0.0139354886,
-0.0603137985,
0.0153346136,
0.0315619633,
-0.001683711,
0.0309749097,
-0.0145177525,
-0.0290654544,
0.0459620208,
-0.0186985694,
0.0542822331,
-0.0157631747,
-0.0328743756,
-0.0004117485,
-0.0129304891,
0.0547720194,
0.0866509527,
-0.0212776288,
0.0239238068,
0.0074653332,
-0.025982637,
-0.0076843272,
0.0311773531,
-0.0012194777,
-0.0148447799,
-0.0147071956,
0.0049438234,
-0.0062492704,
0.0623759478,
0.0249258336,
-0.0013152061,
-0.0676712692,
0.0039548543,
-0.0152692907,
-0.0561437309,
-0.0135087091,
0.0245552268,
-0.0179368705,
-0.0357793234,
-0.0919979587,
-0.0569704585,
0.0355439223,
0.0121702366,
-0.0196967889,
0.017052561,
-0.0323123559,
0.0279247705,
0.0099346302,
0.0195040125,
0.0353484936,
-0.0016858983,
0.0141195944,
-0.070713304,
0.0038409941,
0.0373663083,
0.0206667036,
-0.0231564958,
-0.086740613,
0.0171600506,
-0.0333308503,
0.0067191115,
-0.0081606926,
0.0060423971,
0.0218994506,
-0.0003425935,
0.0267234072,
-0.0613318533,
-0.0198812783,
-0.0093437238,
0.0521630198,
0.0538120642,
-0.0072441837,
-0.0292851161,
-0.0357159227,
0.0132827982,
0.0304210931,
0.0211701877,
-0.1091803908,
-0.0370691828,
0.018457124,
0.045228567,
0.0286378115,
-0.0603843667,
-0.0466988981,
0.0486576818,
-0.0415295586,
0.0042650402,
0.0037921511,
0.0404572934,
0.115558967,
-0.0479018837,
0.0084321359,
0.0638902038,
0.0217307471,
-0.015934201,
-0.0337311514,
0.0288318209,
0.0118718967,
0.0180500373,
0.0395710245,
-0.0772731453,
-0.0360988528,
-0.0203031972,
-0.0234607365,
0.0215452965,
-0.0177367292,
-0.0376875401,
-0.0473308116,
0.0704605654,
0.0313895419,
-0.0278045759,
-0.0208202619,
0.007968056,
0.0365860388,
-0.0044588703,
-0.0473393202,
0.0016340341,
0.01168059,
-0.0020702577,
-0.0018428623,
0.0689633563,
-0.0567551777,
-0.0167767946,
-0.0064805169,
0.0017626663,
0.0573451743,
-0.013899982,
0.0011597244,
-0.0137380818,
0.0302582607,
0.068500787,
0.0251978207,
-0.0068591842,
0.0469085947,
0.0093925949,
-0.00615675,
-0.0055728285,
0.054268565,
0.0211845823,
-0.0202482082,
-0.0036879969,
0.0665496886,
0.0006939669,
-0.0295666549,
-0.0319535658,
-0.0564429723,
0.0470522158,
0.0082605658,
-0.0029749835,
-0.051575359,
-0.0438208245,
-0.04678002,
-0.0467173457,
-0.0300174505,
-0.0400451347,
-0.0029625327,
-0.0384062678,
-0.0636745095,
-0.0533062518,
0.0187203456,
0.077977933,
0.0430825762,
0.0100732315,
-0.0276336558,
0.0350626521,
0.0209439043,
-0.0098995175,
0.0176104028,
-0.0372556783,
0.0030277364,
-0.0621941984,
-0.0426007137,
0.0377938412,
0.0027498286,
-0.0054856697,
0.004701864,
-0.0432098284,
-0.0601765662,
-0.0448723473,
0.0844481289,
0.0076733739,
0.0237803441,
0.0014282905,
-0.0698595271,
0.0635379404,
0.0279061012,
-0.0224310327,
0.011669673,
0.0350689515,
-0.002666581,
-0.0100920238,
0.0168485641,
-0.0431661308,
0.0399583466,
0.038655214,
-0.0155668696,
-0.029133128,
0.0180879254,
-0.0039841281,
-0.0494514555,
-0.0084923124,
-0.01964988,
0.0635944977,
-0.0619583651,
-0.0039124279,
-0.0171037521,
0.0000470915,
-0.0902403444,
-0.005147934,
0.0130580794,
0.0077047013,
0.0207115468,
-0.0062049692,
0.0166030247,
0.0044006798,
-0.0272898339,
-0.0101711052,
-0.0156112136,
0.025412662,
0.0365049839,
0.0351580605,
0.019141797,
0.0111244209,
-0.0097180884,
0.0332394131,
0.0103892507,
0.0835922956,
0.0259310864,
0.0096849706,
-0.0169867929,
0.0121579031,
-0.0416201092,
-0.0412021726,
-0.0363191254,
0.0681737959,
0.0728419125,
0.0013526622,
0.0353822038,
-0.0333020426,
-0.0073049953,
-0.0237092804,
0.0669428408,
0.0140015772,
0.006719864,
0.0150790932,
-0.0007294058,
0.0497626476,
0.0001294714,
0.0658671185,
-0.0330847576,
0.0204027332,
-0.0259606298,
-0.0108893281,
-0.0560408793,
-0.016513316,
0.0289376676,
-0.0493426919,
0.0253144968,
0.0543906093,
0.0010130341,
-0.0418860912,
-0.0710499585,
0.0318133272,
-0.0237921849,
0.0180561524,
0.0701217502,
-0.0048392718,
-0.055749923,
-0.0114804599,
0.007488477,
-0.004392677,
0.0265738554,
-0.0169089325,
-0.0322012417,
-5.934976938e-33,
-0.0266325679,
-0.0289157946,
0.0671255663,
-0.0594230704,
0.0054241819,
-0.0731727928,
-0.0332866982,
0.0394496173,
0.002008429,
0.0342560522,
-0.0265561696,
0.0057078847,
-0.002213049,
0.0353143662,
0.0014944244,
0.0495852605,
0.0484977327,
-0.0438004024,
-0.011844499,
0.0251326915,
0.0299986489,
0.0109618567,
0.0460239947,
-0.0548636839,
-0.0042035184,
0.0094921691,
-0.0100529892,
-0.0033526309,
0.0431589074,
0.0094017545,
0.0173111074,
-0.0120887654,
-0.0141526042,
-0.0257939063,
-0.0339513943,
-0.0022261089,
-0.0334856808,
-0.0653501973,
-0.0575337186,
-0.0079916399,
-0.0722618699,
-0.0382965244,
0.0556472875,
0.0122512747,
-0.011858128,
-0.0146463215,
0.0548056737,
0.0022214041,
0.0420033149,
0.0290905572,
-0.0253146812,
0.035293337,
-0.0195235703,
-0.0375699885,
0.013707933,
-0.0062365858,
0.0052371728,
-0.0572404526,
-0.0301456954,
0.0102428151,
0.0406770706,
0.0343367159,
0.05375598,
0.0037739817,
0.0344913304,
0.0026000151,
0.017111849,
-0.0059094694,
0.0178856365,
-0.0027762945,
-0.0157561395,
0.0880889148,
-0.016877804,
0.0152359614,
0.0304260515,
0.0067627775,
0.0012948076,
0.026195148,
-0.0810544789,
0.0588072911,
-0.015341159,
0.0206587631,
0.022892477,
0.0109764244,
0.001433595,
0.0029581795,
-0.0146824289,
-0.0466833115,
0.051946003,
0.0085369321,
0.0143029988,
-0.0566143803,
0.0533609353,
-0.0002119457,
-0.006062475,
-0.0477326885,
-0.0526684858,
0.0716712251,
0.0144786667,
-0.0340508409,
-0.0491700061,
-0.0339164212,
0.0583357438,
0.0214672014,
-0.0092189284,
0.0351293236,
-0.0176646337,
0.0438142158,
-0.031418141,
-0.0049713631,
-0.0308559593,
0.0278574359,
0.0220535174,
0.0387440696,
-0.0353088975,
0.0008271838,
-0.0468617268,
0.0116516287,
-0.0376049876,
-0.0367391147,
-0.0192808118,
-0.0130884713,
-0.0185087305,
0.0090109436,
-0.051072713,
0.0416842028,
-0.0344851017,
0.0298084039,
0.0278349705,
-0.052587308,
-0.0300210286,
0.0270481277,
2.712e-7,
-0.0023151,
0.0308202989,
-0.0174535494,
0.0257587656,
-0.0023077095,
0.0282345153,
-0.0471638702,
0.0234681778,
0.0049753231,
-0.0416955948,
0.0530356914,
0.0768936053,
-0.001436368,
-0.0113010667,
-0.0499154329,
0.0010345475,
0.0509793833,
0.0329699516,
-0.0319587216,
-0.0196525231,
0.05452732,
0.0317426473,
0.0034986997,
0.0017869713,
0.0387859903,
0.0053287293,
0.0710710362,
-0.0145803569,
0.0397707783,
-0.0108002573,
0.0207243878,
0.0328797586,
-0.0243266113,
0.031942036,
-0.0100541571,
0.0077009648,
0.0147399576,
0.0600580014,
-0.0664767921,
0.0111133168,
0.0224195123,
0.0011721944,
-0.011640273,
0.0051373532,
0.0432936996,
-0.0661178529,
0.0319922753,
0.0068951356,
-0.0108506773,
0.0331294276,
0.0088282116,
-0.0250057019,
-0.0307313036,
-0.0056973901,
0.0522454381,
0.0465251505,
-0.0369960591,
-0.0315490291,
0.0166521352,
-0.0192281269,
-0.0379721522,
-0.059588708,
-0.0440561399,
0.0000149576,
0.0194322653,
0.0241254549,
-0.036981117,
1.964616336e-34,
-0.0085288174,
0.0174011551,
0.0195861235,
0.0221694782,
0.0359153189,
0.0299231522,
-0.0419855118,
0.0183249451,
0.0255524665,
-0.043140579,
-0.0676940084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04369v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04369v1 | Beyond Static Datasets: A Deep Interaction Approach to LLM Evaluation | 2023-09-08T15:00:41 | 2023-09-08T15:00:41 | Jiatong Li, Rui Li, Qi Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have made progress in various real-world tasks,
which stimulates requirements for the evaluation of LLMs. Existing LLM
evaluation methods are mainly supervised signal-based which depends on static
datasets and cannot evaluate the ability of LLMs in dynamic real-world
scenarios where deep interaction widely exists. Other LLM evaluation methods
are human-based which are costly and time-consuming and are incapable of
large-scale evaluation of LLMs. To address the issues above, we propose a novel
Deep Interaction-based LLM-evaluation framework. In our proposed framework,
LLMs' performances in real-world domains can be evaluated from their deep
interaction with other LLMs in elaborately designed evaluation tasks.
Furthermore, our proposed framework is a general evaluation method that can be
applied to a host of real-world tasks such as machine translation and code
generation. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method through
extensive experiments on four elaborately designed evaluation tasks. | [
-0.009042195,
0.0604101494,
0.0052043819,
0.0724315271,
-0.0163460262,
0.0222310461,
0.0229299255,
-0.0214369893,
0.0090172859,
-0.0135817397,
-0.0719695985,
-0.0541278273,
0.0236613937,
0.0200405568,
0.0368013233,
-0.0158363339,
0.0060393591,
-0.0536084287,
-0.0455874763,
0.0248532798,
-0.0121715982,
0.0063598175,
0.0077397642,
0.068862386,
-0.0021008046,
-0.0003608164,
-0.0180450361,
0.0248478483,
0.0261794124,
-0.0037276947,
-0.0015703418,
0.0712533146,
0.0371451117,
0.050775066,
0.0000019058,
-0.041000288,
0.0195451677,
0.0051502911,
-0.0221356172,
0.0242924131,
0.0322885104,
-0.0102409413,
-0.0315087065,
0.0181778073,
-0.0573147014,
-0.0242476165,
0.0304078721,
-0.0097491285,
0.0903725997,
0.0628535971,
-0.0004734427,
-0.0168506913,
0.0285467245,
-0.0561768785,
0.0101843933,
-0.0295784418,
0.0339138098,
0.0302842446,
-0.0278027058,
0.0026811673,
0.0041844603,
0.0306173507,
0.0660115555,
-0.0573421642,
0.001737848,
0.0266181882,
-0.0446615554,
0.0029683367,
-0.0061916504,
0.115757823,
-0.0572284609,
0.0021395721,
-0.0200401228,
-0.027451843,
-0.0094738044,
-0.0250010099,
-0.0319820344,
-0.0308357384,
0.04820586,
0.0233611725,
0.0015785755,
0.0011125925,
0.051479008,
0.0178208463,
-0.0275838152,
0.0488662943,
0.0184339806,
-0.0147379739,
-0.0153507777,
-0.0019203685,
0.0039651035,
-0.0618987158,
0.0055700857,
0.0371192768,
-0.0336054787,
0.0113822771,
-0.0531799197,
-0.0274058748,
-0.0034270235,
-0.0635798946,
0.0483657345,
0.0234068837,
-0.0238977969,
0.0581930391,
-0.0249265078,
0.0719156414,
-0.0347300209,
-0.015554606,
-0.0238548014,
0.0237157885,
-0.0506332293,
0.0263720416,
0.009778982,
0.0604491718,
-0.0358518697,
-0.019896403,
-0.0209552012,
0.0328428745,
-0.0037627826,
0.0408259854,
0.015684789,
0.0000580295,
-0.0450656861,
0.0049944161,
-0.0106952898,
-0.016149519,
0.0060021481,
-0.0090342825,
-0.0126978336,
-0.0729941651,
0.0143200159,
0.0345917791,
-0.0225953162,
-0.0491070449,
0.0096184062,
0.1084093973,
-0.0042068325,
-0.008313165,
-0.0151747297,
-0.0059524472,
0.0183259863,
-0.0583732799,
-0.0384343415,
-0.0947533101,
0.0175909158,
-0.0109311724,
-0.0125814481,
-0.0600268655,
0.0101768347,
-0.0100840749,
0.0192701332,
0.0756770521,
0.0128167439,
0.0016224465,
0.0413620472,
0.019179821,
0.0100260088,
0.0574301518,
0.0634513274,
0.0131614637,
-0.0090980567,
-0.0032807759,
0.0447804779,
0.0876793191,
-0.0039323196,
0.018253183,
-0.028002182,
0.0230401121,
-0.0215153731,
0.0499250591,
0.0235584471,
0.0549412221,
-0.0329213552,
-0.0064956532,
0.054973457,
0.0324319303,
0.0424110964,
0.0458942465,
0.0766686574,
-0.0045638615,
0.0007078549,
0.0038008604,
-0.0402921364,
0.0250899382,
0.0021749907,
0.0048104092,
0.0301789306,
0.0124091031,
-0.0296511278,
-0.0750325844,
0.000584443,
-0.0046463213,
0.0137876952,
0.001782249,
0.0225905515,
-0.0019504792,
-0.0403501242,
0.0212464519,
-0.0075073829,
-0.0493447259,
0.0269475468,
-0.0511852503,
0.0049569393,
0.0817939565,
0.0738564879,
-0.0257003084,
-0.033781223,
-0.0179523043,
0.0078550195,
0.0409446657,
0.044445876,
-0.0170746259,
0.0306595732,
-0.0409073234,
-0.0292764511,
-0.0144555327,
-0.0010105206,
0.0341479518,
0.0280682091,
-0.0089354916,
0.0446460433,
-0.0107725319,
-0.0645333976,
0.0299667306,
-0.0262260996,
-0.0164286923,
0.0260046069,
0.0078484127,
0.0315955915,
0.0009218456,
-0.0361435115,
0.0089521939,
0.0184286702,
-0.0439050011,
-0.0178636182,
-0.005083234,
-0.0292448271,
-0.0529385209,
0.0273868777,
-0.0242625419,
-0.0252781752,
0.036015749,
-0.0522728004,
-0.0351561978,
0.0119815711,
-0.0350458547,
0.0110791223,
-0.0317305326,
0.0228322279,
-0.009826187,
0.0220969245,
-0.0453636535,
0.0333803929,
-0.0124950325,
0.0030350566,
0.0404448546,
0.0888126493,
0.0015250938,
-0.0319694877,
-0.05101059,
0.0111423042,
-0.0095864777,
0.0271379147,
0.0089297425,
0.057855323,
-0.0500346199,
-0.0429121964,
-0.0607087053,
0.0358884335,
-0.0207117386,
0.0509540252,
0.0330534466,
0.0013877996,
0.0062227058,
0.0043381057,
-0.0430393927,
-0.0050863312,
-0.0026867727,
-0.0064523756,
0.0521380752,
0.0005068912,
-0.039137058,
-0.0796183497,
0.0023718202,
-0.0008548218,
0.0764454603,
-0.0023610671,
-0.0006059157,
-0.0488435104,
0.0434990674,
-0.0339474417,
0.0293978211,
0.0013122401,
-0.0745979249,
0.0313692614,
-0.0200687926,
0.040030688,
0.0510570742,
-0.0212949999,
0.0210183244,
0.029983867,
0.0068363398,
-0.0632336959,
-0.0062142164,
-0.0096953623,
-0.019235475,
-0.0407923199,
-0.0098149152,
-0.0222585183,
0.0734246075,
0.00280925,
0.0044422741,
-0.0231592618,
0.0108146593,
-0.0100611933,
-0.0206192881,
-0.0279310178,
0.0024113108,
-0.0144417835,
0.0527656414,
-0.054875955,
-0.0715040937,
0.0862299129,
-0.0608854592,
-0.0336545892,
-0.0089408755,
-0.0180775225,
-0.0455199927,
0.069048956,
-0.0231677145,
-0.0212909412,
-0.0425959229,
-0.0409479737,
-0.0405189544,
-0.0185136963,
-0.038939029,
-0.0433944538,
0.0707786828,
-0.0855424255,
0.0204608645,
-0.0011283902,
-0.0104772383,
-0.0434330702,
0.0089478167,
-0.0034249229,
0.0349778607,
0.0341896862,
-0.0162837468,
0.0278281644,
0.0279149227,
-0.0021821738,
0.0379559919,
0.004982281,
-0.0228701439,
-0.0283221249,
0.0349400826,
0.0238519572,
0.0063451543,
-0.0271187145,
-0.0185428821,
0.0199149493,
0.005878638,
0.0313640051,
0.0398343466,
-0.1032742187,
0.0105079534,
0.0112514663,
0.0065650749,
-0.0031691324,
0.0057315603,
0.0164383203,
-0.070072338,
-0.0109852171,
0.1235881001,
0.0182897951,
-0.0589870289,
0.0074333861,
0.0105185704,
0.0311127435,
0.0151055194,
0.0098463371,
-0.0654298216,
-0.0328384712,
-0.0122508593,
-0.0145151541,
0.0199529156,
-0.015513815,
0.0067243022,
-0.116523087,
0.013531263,
0.0150867598,
-0.0125568556,
-0.0344761387,
-0.0337631591,
0.0094883032,
-0.0373443179,
0.0224926136,
-0.0069606495,
0.0410391949,
-0.0361150987,
0.0028563682,
-0.0277392715,
-0.0722387582,
0.0458862856,
-0.0374116823,
0.026473254,
0.0863725245,
0.0334004983,
0.0081045181,
-0.0120777944,
0.0496064685,
-0.0017313176,
0.0021021746,
-0.0228761397,
0.0143086035,
0.0014191628,
-0.0252245199,
0.0164540578,
0.0216587763,
-0.0552091077,
0.0282989573,
-0.0037989405,
0.0514082499,
-0.0322613642,
0.0056249439,
0.0129726082,
-0.0268991981,
0.031996116,
0.0351792835,
0.0671349168,
-0.048826728,
-0.0264110286,
-0.0390606932,
-0.0233235843,
-0.0680927038,
-0.0442835204,
-0.0319099985,
0.0273955483,
-0.0225736909,
-0.0549110509,
-0.0285091195,
0.0119106006,
0.0120109497,
0.0062732138,
-0.0012706124,
0.0130445203,
-0.0099407015,
-0.0314783268,
0.0495098718,
-0.0213924926,
0.0545263924,
-0.0243041888,
-0.0017013911,
0.0370050557,
-0.0190130565,
-0.0039368025,
0.0254609231,
-0.1252727658,
-0.0755757168,
-0.0521301478,
0.0523704253,
0.0222312473,
0.0429416001,
-0.0588527471,
-0.0665400326,
0.0115303388,
-0.0035256508,
-0.0091064367,
-0.0034264741,
0.030398123,
-0.0093892487,
0.0031919095,
0.0204245988,
-0.0378256254,
0.017318584,
0.0315244012,
0.0103980172,
-0.0343761928,
-0.0683787838,
-0.0100423479,
-0.0114315879,
0.024768658,
0.0079133352,
-0.031202415,
-0.0114296535,
0.0088471891,
0.0002353146,
-0.0247816108,
-0.0725856796,
-0.0005294767,
0.0346808992,
0.0019257193,
0.0183087233,
0.0074233427,
-0.0192232858,
0.0223997049,
-0.0136946356,
0.0338933058,
0.0029047041,
0.028964771,
0.0585550182,
0.010163025,
-0.0141880158,
0.006406018,
-0.0357001014,
0.0047838716,
0.0030523299,
0.0105721736,
0.0079011731,
0.0239186417,
0.0408042483,
0.0480096713,
-0.0413754806,
-0.0408570468,
-0.0458391346,
0.0270644929,
0.0885647759,
0.0413293354,
0.0601515956,
-0.0179941803,
0.0127170412,
-0.0250440072,
0.0667487234,
-0.0190663114,
-0.038131766,
0.0322005562,
0.0354698077,
-0.0080863545,
0.0287652798,
0.0678733885,
0.0185670238,
0.0055049215,
0.0028350493,
0.0267052446,
-0.0299514923,
-0.0260886867,
0.0218340047,
-0.0144257387,
-0.0326041877,
0.004202798,
0.0014159412,
-0.0803061202,
-0.0296125691,
0.0480377004,
-0.0003800803,
0.0090218401,
0.0373114981,
0.0730081499,
-0.0120731257,
0.0499737859,
-0.014004631,
0.0033674855,
0.0071879714,
-0.0512851439,
-0.0628524944,
-5.856468976e-33,
-0.0363443792,
-0.0610151514,
0.0218102988,
0.0074953306,
-0.0669076294,
0.0072423425,
-0.0623089857,
0.0182933137,
-0.0158389527,
-0.0144305304,
0.035403572,
0.0296480525,
-0.0054425248,
0.0030368513,
-0.003571002,
-0.0380602702,
0.0422445871,
0.0109574078,
-0.0225213561,
0.0200632382,
-0.0430922434,
0.0217905026,
0.0346732624,
-0.0537640192,
0.0274362992,
-0.0237341393,
-0.0081903776,
0.0209094044,
-0.0161022637,
0.0749088377,
-0.022813797,
0.0141354855,
0.0120555609,
-0.0511786602,
-0.027642956,
0.0041586529,
-0.0230219979,
-0.0034345316,
0.0038360623,
0.0220125448,
-0.0317635573,
-0.021358205,
0.0695033148,
0.007839689,
-0.0253748186,
-0.011976935,
0.0238306522,
-0.0206072815,
-0.0197281986,
0.0067551015,
-0.0455448627,
0.0486971252,
-0.0359665453,
-0.0515631959,
0.0350432917,
-0.0083424114,
-0.0175886638,
0.0286677685,
-0.0630811825,
-0.0123026818,
-0.0050248401,
0.0658572838,
0.1008003578,
0.0153914047,
0.0115726152,
0.0230129305,
-0.0096147805,
0.0022449989,
-0.0277459566,
-0.0235021114,
0.0483284853,
0.0765347555,
0.0430925786,
0.0622906461,
0.0096756779,
0.030126106,
-0.0708986819,
0.0285957418,
0.0270849634,
0.0179751944,
-0.0035939333,
0.029770799,
-0.0160834119,
0.0042983359,
-0.0565566756,
0.0161879174,
-0.0504969098,
-0.044398915,
0.0241645463,
-0.009477674,
-0.0188053548,
-0.0212990269,
0.0340537131,
-0.063297525,
-0.0087762363,
0.0357725285,
-0.0316600092,
0.0442245416,
-0.0061446023,
0.0228719413,
-0.0078798179,
-0.0568971187,
0.0129395816,
0.0349156931,
0.0418466367,
-0.0263068285,
0.0195947103,
0.0295481272,
-0.0313019454,
-0.0124295941,
-0.0485026166,
-0.0180290062,
0.0127503825,
0.0637980849,
0.0117407609,
-0.0346875824,
-0.0178059265,
0.0614192449,
-0.0165452939,
-0.0025228506,
-0.0250697918,
-0.007384954,
0.0017428726,
0.0277466942,
-0.0533506535,
-0.0159974191,
-0.0394894741,
0.0087758088,
0.0482100397,
-0.022020258,
-0.0377614237,
0.0055246768,
2.508e-7,
0.0282674264,
0.0221925452,
0.0243196841,
0.0747883245,
0.0345569327,
0.0314543061,
-0.0497105569,
0.0230253804,
0.0023298915,
-0.0227582734,
0.0279127061,
0.0294777472,
0.0949186534,
0.0071114381,
-0.0789505318,
-0.0048702876,
-0.0711601824,
0.0190563314,
-0.0571738407,
-0.043630708,
0.0214548837,
0.0899727568,
0.0091164429,
0.0000278587,
0.0067766313,
-0.0259750187,
0.0370494127,
-0.0169667602,
-0.0111719705,
0.0353961326,
-0.0184903182,
0.0478630476,
-0.0146197975,
0.0218194518,
-0.0037342112,
0.0028230215,
0.0161735862,
0.0792092159,
0.0088994503,
-0.0146459481,
0.0164506603,
-0.0184476133,
0.0203776397,
-0.0601997711,
0.052266214,
-0.0499644503,
0.0064718551,
-0.0095166173,
0.0186667219,
-0.0241157077,
0.0323665179,
-0.0364731848,
-0.001279604,
0.0123034259,
0.0383353904,
-0.032193847,
-0.0232218932,
-0.0336185321,
-0.0468990505,
-0.0047200713,
-0.051934693,
-0.0565885864,
-0.0509071797,
-0.0345966481,
-0.0123713613,
-0.0162676629,
0.0096280174,
2.231174374e-34,
0.0353762582,
-0.0008434028,
0.0167878289,
0.0413538367,
0.0525439866,
0.0003909314,
-0.0304288287,
0.0014740627,
0.0030075586,
-0.0507673584,
-0.0001974778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04333v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04333v1 | Encoding Multi-Domain Scientific Papers by Ensembling Multiple CLS Tokens | 2023-09-08T14:00:29 | 2023-09-08T14:00:29 | Ronald Seoh, Haw-Shiuan Chang, Andrew McCallum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL, cs.LG | Many useful tasks on scientific documents, such as topic classification and
citation prediction, involve corpora that span multiple scientific domains.
Typically, such tasks are accomplished by representing the text with a vector
embedding obtained from a Transformer's single CLS token. In this paper, we
argue that using multiple CLS tokens could make a Transformer better specialize
to multiple scientific domains. We present Multi2SPE: it encourages each of
multiple CLS tokens to learn diverse ways of aggregating token embeddings, then
sums them up together to create a single vector representation. We also propose
our new multi-domain benchmark, Multi-SciDocs, to test scientific paper vector
encoders under multi-domain settings. We show that Multi2SPE reduces error by
up to 25 percent in multi-domain citation prediction, while requiring only a
negligible amount of computation in addition to one BERT forward pass. | [
-0.0150321359,
0.0059417882,
0.0271798261,
-0.0041580419,
0.008199689,
0.0002561836,
0.0600866564,
0.030268304,
-0.0179412812,
-0.0569256581,
-0.0433844104,
0.0147732468,
-0.0029918279,
0.0130989952,
0.0143298171,
-0.0069612563,
0.0494210161,
0.0066255271,
0.0385686718,
-0.0185986944,
-0.0378200449,
-0.0102058882,
0.0289504845,
0.0426519886,
0.0391784608,
-0.0421479531,
0.0207483415,
-0.0300689153,
0.0373489596,
-0.0131034916,
0.0286839176,
0.0282699708,
0.0737012476,
0.0336257778,
0.0000016944,
-0.0234114621,
-0.0380870141,
0.0359041281,
0.0257070307,
0.025370026,
0.0363969654,
-0.0624437332,
0.0348236449,
-0.0054779439,
0.0011244963,
-0.0400958024,
0.0275012869,
0.0269131027,
0.0457947291,
0.0292254873,
-0.0042159623,
-0.0661348253,
0.0465438366,
-0.0061154864,
-0.0285867043,
-0.0231039152,
0.0387857966,
-0.0342391431,
0.0077354196,
0.0538845696,
-0.0171778016,
0.0072064656,
-0.0076545971,
0.0107384371,
0.0253046248,
0.0334099941,
-0.0145129915,
-0.0011643592,
0.0093776276,
0.0156035991,
-0.0196028054,
-0.0317296125,
0.007474333,
0.0368458815,
-0.0299738236,
0.0380804092,
-0.0388483182,
0.003344167,
-0.0057478002,
-0.0178894252,
0.0324761309,
0.0253836103,
0.0204481706,
-0.0043871575,
-0.041483175,
0.0464285947,
0.0312715769,
-0.0440010503,
-0.0042011878,
0.0398542881,
0.0077419258,
0.0135836992,
0.0388844982,
-0.0170899834,
-0.0144154187,
-0.0097280052,
-0.0231160168,
-0.0635890737,
0.0147408843,
-0.0060768579,
0.0154334772,
0.0058263163,
-0.0010314229,
0.0280846283,
-0.0233037006,
0.0159453005,
-0.0523288399,
0.0282213241,
0.009098703,
-0.0688782036,
-0.0319370031,
-0.0259382557,
-0.0236251689,
0.0304718055,
-0.0083924858,
-0.016696807,
-0.029677527,
-0.0024836257,
0.0040508094,
-0.0097729573,
0.0040869662,
-0.0138824768,
-0.043436788,
0.0210728031,
0.0315664671,
0.0752623156,
-0.0398765169,
0.0118333641,
0.0000557168,
-0.0000256797,
-0.0542667061,
0.0297740512,
0.0096579725,
-0.0477379709,
-0.0020166798,
0.0351612084,
-0.0037050436,
-0.0339479148,
0.0223760325,
0.0002718065,
-0.0101419743,
-0.0362042896,
0.0650707483,
-0.04015816,
0.0694132745,
0.0406417362,
0.0093322434,
-0.0627086684,
-0.036174912,
0.0098143741,
-0.0400468297,
0.036231257,
-0.0098819593,
-0.0617734566,
0.0478279516,
0.0121366428,
-0.0125473822,
0.0512935109,
0.0092337169,
-0.0280713793,
0.0193991847,
-0.0283983052,
0.0004315423,
0.0025199868,
0.0438757651,
0.0111106029,
0.0251880903,
-0.0117422985,
0.0088129463,
0.0480261892,
0.0498429462,
0.0144642312,
-0.0638165176,
-0.0280305874,
-0.0277685076,
0.0453976393,
0.037960127,
0.009506993,
0.0616968721,
-0.0139352316,
0.0118577126,
-0.008928135,
0.0096680056,
0.034298148,
0.0051665665,
-0.0007160645,
0.0466401801,
0.0215345025,
-0.0168723613,
0.0250335652,
-0.0033901399,
-0.0299359113,
-0.015718244,
-0.0826940164,
0.0725699812,
-0.0125614488,
-0.0036503116,
0.0977905244,
0.0253412444,
-0.0522108413,
0.0219926983,
0.0179690868,
0.0178370886,
-0.0200795978,
0.0522844233,
-0.0242822729,
-0.0440522023,
-0.0314820297,
0.0168909039,
0.0328451507,
0.0181426946,
-0.018551711,
0.0121396948,
-0.0488998815,
-0.0336477794,
-0.024481371,
0.0029607967,
0.0188424904,
-0.0137634818,
0.0252415929,
-0.0032316574,
-0.054362122,
0.0540290289,
0.0169346873,
-0.0381599851,
0.0260305312,
0.0053282348,
-0.0236955546,
0.0478023104,
0.0132686608,
-0.0199795291,
0.0063370392,
0.0626624376,
-0.0513850152,
-0.0605395846,
0.0101911724,
0.0028849184,
-0.0147706484,
0.0283476822,
-0.0615962856,
0.0112906396,
-0.0016289746,
-0.0126719931,
-0.0128399609,
0.0102804229,
-0.015188151,
0.0209064968,
0.0148313213,
-0.0290209576,
-0.029630797,
0.0394653045,
0.0055096177,
0.0360656381,
-0.0007574291,
0.0526157953,
0.0440504067,
-0.0383430757,
0.0094626267,
0.0028293105,
-0.0100454437,
-0.034952309,
0.0145788845,
-0.0085978992,
0.0211890955,
-0.0261060651,
-0.0017175969,
-0.0377646126,
-0.0170053784,
0.0069092168,
-0.0003655109,
0.0122358724,
-0.003345038,
-0.0123565318,
0.028220376,
0.0270052347,
-0.0155912172,
-0.0482321382,
-0.0506369434,
0.0136849675,
0.0393896699,
-0.024217587,
0.0079997936,
0.014609376,
-0.0319711827,
-0.0516300127,
0.0896961167,
-0.0291940905,
0.0152881546,
-0.0919658169,
-0.0156679656,
0.0021896621,
-0.0107998522,
-0.0329840556,
0.0059332699,
-0.0094019892,
-0.0069355201,
0.0181968398,
0.0436289795,
0.0259205438,
0.0294595901,
0.0413996316,
0.0049845716,
-0.0759772658,
0.0036657744,
-0.0218813941,
0.0389390402,
-0.0206063632,
0.0324076414,
0.0219169986,
0.0365914591,
-0.0335095115,
0.0036340561,
-0.017486373,
-0.0028039911,
0.0205457341,
-0.0176363252,
0.0179155506,
-0.0086195711,
0.0035193972,
0.018129278,
0.0580025949,
0.0152437175,
0.0606467612,
-0.0286170226,
-0.0369247198,
-0.0720719621,
0.0234677531,
-0.0600106679,
-0.0397345275,
-0.0091840681,
0.0151252924,
0.0395728722,
-0.0039732885,
-0.0284135807,
0.0295138564,
-0.0364535078,
-0.0144768897,
0.0075828508,
0.026549805,
-0.0085450877,
-0.0362166539,
-0.0335511565,
0.000861361,
-0.0068413657,
-0.0051635574,
0.0742973611,
0.0193654932,
-0.0547101721,
-0.103889145,
0.0006421753,
0.045451846,
0.0332994685,
-0.0281232074,
-0.0142318895,
-0.0234157257,
0.0742074326,
0.0425697379,
0.0132602733,
-0.0005267296,
-0.0038042623,
-0.0519160554,
0.0478567369,
-0.0146884797,
0.0081711086,
-0.0145634739,
-0.0115596717,
0.0344431922,
-0.0467420593,
-0.0061343149,
-0.0426472053,
0.0235305931,
0.0002990818,
-0.0276359133,
0.113773264,
0.0231112596,
-0.0750856027,
-0.0335934125,
-0.0422123224,
0.0221772231,
0.0284771733,
0.0105048157,
-0.0898556709,
-0.0200636946,
-0.0023820004,
0.0048800833,
0.0386501476,
-0.0242657028,
0.0013904393,
-0.079154186,
0.0183782261,
0.0137063302,
-0.0204805005,
-0.0518826209,
-0.0971280932,
-0.032585483,
-0.0139706777,
-0.0041071591,
-0.0120302597,
0.0122394124,
0.003584868,
0.0039383979,
-0.0103359222,
-0.0600846335,
0.0060374499,
-0.0073272348,
0.0116140749,
-0.0159444679,
0.0282866955,
-0.0248474814,
-0.072947368,
-0.0285917278,
-0.0278188009,
-0.0345752351,
-0.0260510538,
0.0327859595,
-0.0391703583,
0.0245657638,
0.0225883722,
0.0390680879,
-0.0440778062,
-0.0157625508,
0.0263112932,
0.1052126959,
0.0128226746,
-0.0203504711,
-0.0867568105,
-0.0251900442,
-0.0278904438,
0.0662884787,
0.0067110271,
-0.0639972389,
0.0139701525,
-0.0278593507,
-0.0032430892,
-0.0058174338,
-0.0417814143,
-0.0288389195,
-0.0419894271,
-0.0045803054,
-0.0386322774,
0.0189152304,
0.0065411078,
0.0324202105,
-0.013043154,
-0.0212201476,
-0.0028316905,
-0.0109881666,
-0.038923271,
-0.0151953949,
-0.0108055007,
0.0055063087,
-0.0426342078,
0.0308304876,
0.0987320989,
0.0320949629,
-0.0598188452,
0.0023342841,
0.0174922645,
-0.0479402766,
-0.0347838588,
0.0214987975,
0.0142787956,
0.0243238918,
-0.0166248865,
-0.0094428435,
0.0914014876,
0.0700819716,
-0.0383983925,
0.0016529576,
0.0493211299,
-0.0517590195,
-0.0290270187,
0.0008857465,
-0.0454174504,
0.0250008609,
-0.0396927036,
-0.0020387266,
-0.0112463301,
-0.0189924184,
-0.0247558355,
-0.015597553,
0.09825968,
-0.0257437509,
0.0348429829,
0.0127244676,
0.0048275627,
-0.0169669501,
0.0013036799,
0.0009057854,
0.0292341281,
-0.0030832675,
-0.0409672037,
-0.0099543082,
0.0762813389,
0.0103818327,
0.012988585,
-0.0289223026,
0.0462721512,
-0.0094080409,
0.0569356158,
0.0009483098,
-0.0117294714,
-0.0075525669,
-0.0853242725,
-0.0154036544,
-0.0088565927,
-0.0513242632,
0.0049313572,
0.0360830985,
0.0524483062,
0.0048716343,
0.0173641238,
-0.1057920307,
0.0396549106,
-0.0062776417,
-0.0099940812,
0.0227540191,
0.0255399104,
0.0544055626,
-0.018346874,
-0.0450982526,
-0.0272143297,
0.0197432227,
0.0295344647,
0.0183951259,
0.0746802464,
0.0009545167,
-0.0400417261,
-0.0450260416,
0.0783732682,
0.0118013797,
0.0191942789,
-0.011622698,
-0.0011797369,
-0.0285356082,
-0.030219106,
-0.0160130691,
0.0309834443,
0.0128986901,
-0.0400590636,
-0.0339100994,
0.0102907922,
0.0985182822,
-0.0411662385,
-0.0285404939,
-0.0062651937,
0.0313933305,
0.0331705585,
-0.0316286609,
-0.0066608158,
0.0153409261,
0.0310041253,
-0.0039983201,
-0.0823773369,
0.0121138683,
-5.715418838e-33,
-0.0029021632,
0.0001710072,
-0.0197995566,
0.0358929783,
0.002640683,
0.0334741734,
-0.0246865638,
-0.0506530069,
-0.0010157789,
0.0138473781,
-0.0238471236,
0.0018897471,
-0.0058927573,
0.0058313818,
0.0568535589,
0.0303246658,
0.0518158786,
0.0001690791,
-0.0275836214,
0.0217467137,
0.0822994933,
0.0297787879,
0.0703685135,
-0.0948108062,
0.0065956325,
0.0143069737,
0.0074461228,
-0.0409926847,
0.0476181842,
0.0694354251,
-0.0144737726,
0.0213793162,
0.0042156796,
-0.0884936303,
-0.0094871065,
0.0320412293,
-0.0651893541,
-0.0186338034,
-0.0052982662,
-0.0093714427,
-0.0033659381,
-0.0585767999,
0.0273264535,
0.0113850627,
0.0146553759,
-0.0546885915,
0.0578784421,
0.0009380086,
-0.0415290073,
-0.1069628224,
-0.0360267051,
-0.0140753016,
-0.0196295027,
0.0414288677,
0.0233445689,
0.0340174846,
0.0411507152,
0.1020857915,
-0.0543890744,
0.0242425408,
-0.0586162023,
0.0382187292,
0.0060695875,
-0.0573956929,
-0.0078579597,
0.0435158238,
-0.0117884437,
-0.0489452444,
0.0090923831,
-0.0035304043,
0.036197789,
0.0252776537,
0.0625822172,
0.0788264051,
0.0505250171,
-0.0228727981,
-0.061998859,
0.0539335683,
0.0214520395,
0.0197145585,
0.0396429114,
0.0286121089,
0.0535847731,
-0.0004671465,
0.0036574805,
-0.0040476965,
-0.0064600776,
-0.0215974692,
-0.0235119425,
-0.014735207,
-0.025001239,
0.0352121554,
0.0580595918,
-0.0516049676,
-0.0498099215,
0.0865649134,
0.0010763793,
0.0320491605,
0.0040734452,
-0.0024535605,
-0.0315680131,
-0.0800370127,
0.0356267579,
0.005304676,
0.0015655021,
-0.0093228016,
0.0716516003,
-0.0066817044,
-0.051663287,
-0.0310172569,
0.0101096574,
-0.0472351611,
0.0011961503,
0.044269681,
0.012066409,
0.0282153282,
0.0168264154,
-0.0037435396,
0.0348462202,
0.0399021171,
0.0154681681,
0.0423662402,
0.0256337076,
0.0414971374,
-0.0117026055,
-0.0293360315,
-0.0255572163,
0.0291343182,
0.0051830509,
-0.0534165241,
-0.0044945851,
-0.0279746614,
2.398e-7,
0.0583459251,
0.0813601464,
-0.0056282287,
-0.0519602075,
0.0371754281,
0.0280304402,
-0.0035794943,
0.0867158324,
-0.0077727917,
0.0318073072,
-0.0284736063,
-0.0466233976,
0.003769994,
0.0401130691,
-0.1099448428,
-0.0097679812,
-0.0390995145,
0.0027462086,
-0.0284945108,
0.0206000544,
0.0075171306,
0.0614761226,
-0.0058896192,
-0.0017200036,
0.010593568,
-0.0134978127,
0.0733748376,
-0.0053865565,
0.0273854937,
0.0232892185,
-0.0540575907,
0.0231700893,
0.0319735222,
-0.0031233195,
-0.0528798923,
0.0474345945,
0.0188877806,
0.0525229052,
0.0056572347,
-0.0253912788,
0.0550245903,
-0.0142937293,
-0.0071272319,
0.0048076916,
0.0363125987,
-0.0795626268,
-0.0447834656,
-0.0401813425,
-0.0379741266,
0.0304690078,
0.0028753243,
-0.0091430172,
-0.0026317316,
0.0269494448,
-0.0132207694,
0.0044037541,
0.0145599507,
-0.0866328105,
-0.020406045,
0.0329955928,
-0.0347010791,
-0.0372729935,
-0.0104136867,
-0.0445817932,
0.0793544278,
-0.0624745488,
-0.010716958,
2.339553346e-34,
0.0614957772,
-0.0229638126,
0.012930572,
0.056576632,
-0.0029722017,
-0.0668921918,
-0.0271798559,
-0.0030802265,
0.0092155924,
-0.042462457,
-0.0131769292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04292v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04292v1 | Fuzzy Fingerprinting Transformer Language-Models for Emotion Recognition in Conversations | 2023-09-08T12:26:01 | 2023-09-08T12:26:01 | Patrícia Pereira, Rui Ribeiro, Helena Moniz, Luisa Coheur, Joao Paulo Carvalho | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Fuzzy Fingerprints have been successfully used as an interpretable text
classification technique, but, like most other techniques, have been largely
surpassed in performance by Large Pre-trained Language Models, such as BERT or
RoBERTa. These models deliver state-of-the-art results in several Natural
Language Processing tasks, namely Emotion Recognition in Conversations (ERC),
but suffer from the lack of interpretability and explainability. In this paper,
we propose to combine the two approaches to perform ERC, as a means to obtain
simpler and more interpretable Large Language Models-based classifiers. We
propose to feed the utterances and their previous conversational turns to a
pre-trained RoBERTa, obtaining contextual embedding utterance representations,
that are then supplied to an adapted Fuzzy Fingerprint classification module.
We validate our approach on the widely used DailyDialog ERC benchmark dataset,
in which we obtain state-of-the-art level results using a much lighter model. | [
0.0499440208,
0.062819615,
-0.0351805612,
0.051295124,
-0.0022523964,
0.0292607471,
0.01804436,
-0.0091951871,
-0.0023519499,
-0.0855100155,
-0.0383324102,
0.000510786,
-0.0286493897,
0.0211266037,
-0.0355727971,
-0.0395131409,
-0.0075494265,
0.0075883735,
0.0298354793,
0.0214640796,
0.0378107727,
0.0279936958,
-0.0134969587,
0.0613283031,
-0.0442413054,
-0.0039385785,
-0.0399585962,
0.0226843785,
0.0138948578,
0.0051495377,
0.0204410311,
0.029908549,
0.045468539,
0.0228708219,
0.0000018819,
-0.0104525005,
-0.0124366302,
-0.000506554,
-0.0392853916,
0.0166916605,
0.0940854177,
0.0353288949,
-0.0131314397,
0.0049078618,
0.0006362405,
0.0058835144,
0.0544665754,
0.1048381701,
0.0784819052,
0.0570046604,
-0.0187178999,
-0.0249625649,
0.010959655,
0.0191159826,
0.0332577042,
-0.0156550035,
0.011408898,
0.0259129591,
0.0030820863,
-0.0382654294,
-0.0142295789,
0.0042586201,
-0.0100572761,
-0.0251772441,
-0.0353722535,
0.0154893659,
-0.0457953811,
0.001703083,
0.0149173224,
0.0846931785,
-0.0404779948,
-0.019931145,
0.0031700882,
0.015461646,
-0.0077412077,
-0.0089894524,
-0.0235039815,
-0.0100692995,
0.026996769,
0.0294980835,
0.0138076022,
0.0488810092,
0.0154534262,
0.0378995501,
-0.0311931446,
0.0356212296,
-0.0359592363,
-0.0179677736,
-0.0021465695,
-0.0092837783,
-0.0063418853,
-0.0027178542,
0.0137671446,
-0.0096019218,
0.0350603908,
0.0123203304,
-0.0360438116,
0.0247908514,
-0.0100860717,
-0.0573361814,
0.0048559061,
0.0418912508,
-0.0392602608,
0.0220051184,
-0.0238782559,
0.0142159211,
0.0088657392,
-0.0122146653,
-0.0322772264,
-0.046531152,
-0.085023649,
-0.0167444292,
-0.0330386274,
0.0217477735,
-0.0191029273,
-0.0440017357,
-0.0690498278,
0.0347109474,
0.0008910301,
0.00785603,
-0.0095817987,
-0.0120121203,
0.0117978686,
0.0125239603,
-0.0118580824,
0.0195004735,
-0.0220754221,
0.0207162052,
-0.0179992281,
-0.0573883504,
0.0125793433,
0.0147326849,
0.0331744924,
-0.0077098073,
0.0002856976,
-0.012991651,
0.0364365242,
-0.0434836149,
0.0041322461,
-0.0121480813,
-0.0281747282,
-0.0593587644,
-0.0392675102,
0.0026502986,
0.0296714865,
-0.007678987,
0.0055496781,
0.0088360282,
0.0317718014,
-0.0271008126,
-0.0224970356,
0.0940802544,
0.0162976328,
-0.0227630325,
0.0230018515,
0.0053144293,
0.0136416331,
0.0333855934,
0.0414660387,
0.0050211842,
0.044945024,
-0.0410700291,
0.0436492078,
0.0291700214,
0.0079035033,
-0.0242555849,
0.0054372102,
0.0082279686,
-0.029851608,
0.0008945398,
0.031039428,
0.0108050359,
-0.0433621109,
-0.0078280484,
0.051369708,
0.0869827271,
-0.0334339477,
0.0590960421,
-0.0059884815,
0.0676261857,
0.0017570223,
-0.0341174975,
-0.0323152728,
-0.0134573393,
-0.0325341597,
-0.0168749392,
-0.0285156947,
-0.0158288535,
-0.0344676115,
-0.0359391272,
0.0101241777,
-0.0550669096,
0.0080582583,
0.0236067846,
0.0207463354,
-0.0389744304,
-0.0278212056,
0.0408722758,
0.0225335453,
-0.0804687738,
-0.0184468143,
-0.059537936,
0.0052106995,
0.0706213117,
0.0113838185,
-0.039886564,
-0.0291671827,
-0.0682788864,
-0.0174136776,
0.0049597146,
0.025624387,
0.0037160874,
0.051560007,
-0.0842994601,
-0.0008968164,
0.0116391685,
0.0039106375,
0.0079414165,
-0.0455270372,
0.0112756733,
0.0316567421,
-0.0198956057,
-0.0073138559,
-0.0014173214,
0.0132098161,
-0.042350702,
0.0357632563,
0.0101750307,
0.0456715748,
0.022958627,
-0.0281981044,
-0.0271669123,
0.0257579405,
-0.0045735906,
0.003663362,
0.0292968079,
-0.0215276293,
-0.0950046852,
-0.0215597097,
0.0202163346,
-0.0026455303,
0.0082140891,
-0.0496502183,
-0.0243046414,
0.0071836491,
-0.0159330517,
0.0622960962,
-0.0395487212,
0.0491335057,
-0.0203650445,
0.0476178043,
-0.0036471246,
0.0290630292,
0.0078040725,
-0.0146820256,
-0.030140996,
0.0041986932,
0.0041919425,
-0.0745181963,
-0.0251007508,
-0.0255916901,
0.0122111067,
0.0049401917,
-0.000188368,
-0.0406307243,
-0.0269845482,
-0.0734897181,
-0.1021208018,
-0.0016428647,
0.0092939241,
0.0160772521,
0.0007568405,
0.0056337714,
-0.0088287676,
0.0087912437,
-0.0294938348,
-0.0067227362,
-0.0058405716,
-0.0106176315,
-0.0032161763,
-0.0033668994,
-0.0462221019,
-0.0494505689,
0.0188998356,
-0.0098114973,
0.0648963526,
-0.0226395614,
0.0203662179,
-0.0582090206,
-0.0476654842,
-0.0014121874,
0.0180293117,
-0.0060432577,
-0.0621584803,
-0.0310486834,
0.012268058,
-0.0144519219,
0.0513995774,
0.0133499214,
0.1002956256,
-0.0231368449,
-0.0210536569,
-0.0621496998,
0.0223030914,
-0.0146889715,
0.0508834235,
-0.044921238,
-0.0441861711,
-0.0136006055,
0.0366082005,
-0.0054407418,
0.0264426991,
-0.0282160118,
0.0052057416,
0.002939072,
-0.0371691287,
0.0046907561,
-0.0717566982,
-0.0216741581,
-0.0072418945,
0.0193285458,
-0.0368738025,
0.0359441452,
-0.0409423746,
-0.0301621668,
-0.0627003014,
-0.0707037747,
-0.0380925648,
0.0517614596,
-0.0201953594,
0.0075268694,
-0.0039023375,
-0.007755124,
0.0210926216,
-0.0634502545,
-0.0091086281,
-0.034784615,
0.0045475974,
0.0195208881,
-0.0134387985,
0.0464700237,
-0.0521956831,
-0.035336975,
-0.05284499,
-0.0541679934,
-0.0043144329,
0.0135387862,
-0.0091376258,
-0.0265216883,
0.0428108647,
0.0137521531,
-0.0288567096,
-0.0094016418,
-0.007487108,
-0.0000487215,
0.0452029817,
0.0340151712,
-0.0193428267,
0.0127970539,
-0.0038514936,
0.0527863353,
0.0175196603,
0.0737790912,
0.0097265793,
-0.0465231761,
0.0108178239,
-0.007463343,
-0.0053779548,
-0.0408743173,
-0.0234352946,
0.0151234781,
-0.0616383441,
0.0237615034,
0.1551785469,
0.0425373763,
-0.0238038301,
0.0125859706,
-0.0297915395,
-0.0109819146,
-0.0075985766,
0.0336429477,
-0.0263329744,
-0.0546544194,
0.0056915972,
0.0221616123,
-0.0182888061,
-0.0272929147,
0.0108082378,
-0.0564056709,
0.037862353,
-0.0166658591,
-0.022175407,
-0.021837445,
0.0123457899,
-0.0044760606,
-0.0155840805,
-0.0002631541,
-0.0507252514,
0.0023830561,
-0.001810695,
0.0310881436,
-0.0316291489,
-0.0198295433,
0.0394111536,
-0.0232393928,
0.0538877733,
0.0369380265,
0.0833562464,
0.0035732766,
0.0131644337,
0.0644425154,
-0.0302116815,
0.0022385502,
-0.0020068428,
0.0520189926,
-0.0199881867,
-0.0174902864,
-0.0273323096,
0.0334352143,
-0.0159139205,
-0.0085219638,
-0.0254840832,
0.0532311797,
-0.0584161021,
-0.0040862188,
0.001093155,
0.0174308866,
0.0377261937,
0.0856796429,
0.0379015431,
-0.0408126563,
-0.0530027971,
0.0003237234,
0.039338734,
0.0205505416,
-0.0336531289,
-0.006204424,
-0.0028968698,
-0.0129703889,
-0.0418323316,
-0.0654437989,
0.0014860569,
0.0307677947,
-0.0178753752,
-0.0211522933,
0.0492095985,
0.0162247531,
-0.0164465774,
0.0571224988,
0.0116896089,
0.0205135904,
-0.0468071923,
0.0109071992,
0.0578531846,
-0.0232733935,
-0.027171785,
0.0033181661,
-0.0060233311,
-0.0205717236,
0.0267802533,
0.0163145438,
0.018251149,
0.0285258275,
0.0016166971,
-0.0695179701,
0.0520501509,
0.0186081026,
-0.0413317457,
-0.0311172586,
0.0662932396,
0.0581340529,
-0.0048972792,
0.028512165,
-0.0337317884,
0.0282747466,
-0.0102354418,
-0.0067210766,
-0.0676260293,
-0.0918777063,
-0.0275682546,
-0.0224066991,
0.0620266795,
0.0634060353,
0.0130245052,
-0.0165356603,
0.0407314524,
-0.006807935,
0.0178630762,
-0.0571751334,
-0.0293479003,
0.0005101777,
-0.0142620262,
-0.0355898924,
-0.0440847836,
-0.0207328591,
0.0392812751,
0.0053999177,
0.0609473623,
-0.0118384743,
0.0114563312,
-0.0118886149,
0.0135555817,
-0.045197919,
0.0201456323,
0.01948452,
0.0242365934,
-0.0095463023,
0.0929594338,
0.0075597968,
-0.0218127929,
0.0040015462,
0.0377246179,
-0.0533711873,
-0.0146966046,
-0.0195167903,
-0.0100066336,
-0.0146864047,
-0.0331245176,
0.041987896,
-0.0280457102,
0.0197639391,
-0.008940055,
0.0418580547,
0.0017936404,
-0.0350196324,
0.0408118628,
0.0084214285,
-0.0411129147,
0.0034590217,
0.021023782,
-0.0120826988,
0.0510095917,
0.0170122068,
-0.033593405,
-0.0525224954,
-0.0020447755,
0.08683341,
0.0104272915,
-0.0153621947,
0.0483675487,
-0.0412483439,
-0.0450897925,
-0.0106111541,
-0.0823983178,
-0.0178179368,
-0.0389694273,
0.0177014153,
0.0142296972,
-0.0239332281,
0.0018589483,
-0.0437933356,
-0.0003995615,
-0.0272956584,
-0.0270584114,
-0.0031758628,
-5.478562603e-33,
0.0299452227,
0.0075493879,
-0.0410807021,
0.0361093804,
-0.0079509923,
0.0296281017,
0.0136429667,
-0.0143583287,
-0.0015901566,
0.0378036126,
-0.0023534193,
0.0152381761,
0.0156118684,
0.0372382477,
-0.0434300117,
-0.0240266491,
0.0590547547,
0.0194706209,
0.0042159264,
0.0356108211,
0.05891563,
0.0543709621,
0.0608466826,
-0.1051746905,
-0.0003285456,
0.0099141803,
-0.0078908503,
0.0196242686,
0.0616738647,
0.0686929673,
-0.0370550305,
0.0331879482,
0.0024512538,
-0.0137433466,
0.0104313726,
0.0468476824,
-0.0555678681,
-0.0084890695,
-0.0073464597,
0.0468537882,
0.0536215007,
-0.0192294661,
0.0023290059,
0.0013150638,
-0.0071578273,
0.015871441,
0.0130180428,
-0.0256541837,
-0.0054291044,
-0.0396630503,
-0.0270569324,
0.0431549437,
-0.0558627136,
-0.0506350175,
0.0462867953,
0.0399099663,
-0.0008370299,
0.0009257376,
-0.0630510002,
-0.0202981755,
-0.0056844419,
-0.0093715452,
0.0003417219,
-0.017592391,
0.0024992677,
0.06637308,
0.044489108,
-0.0451760143,
-0.0082079731,
-0.0409875847,
-0.0054200739,
0.0481339172,
0.0123726884,
0.0309265777,
-0.0039167241,
0.0125799794,
-0.0396135151,
0.0220837239,
0.1037963554,
0.018247189,
0.0849507377,
0.014076354,
-0.0872642919,
0.0022437132,
-0.0281779915,
-0.0083855372,
-0.0234278701,
-0.0034197415,
0.0390682034,
-0.0058631077,
-0.0117609492,
0.0404553227,
0.0329449847,
-0.0473228693,
-0.030945411,
0.0246770456,
-0.0101438845,
0.0047669937,
-0.0092406524,
0.0079687433,
-0.0095351329,
-0.0505601652,
0.0553633608,
-0.003656632,
0.0507397875,
0.0086480761,
0.0147689162,
0.0198246837,
-0.0658964887,
0.0040781517,
0.0025945059,
0.0268239174,
-0.041524265,
0.0477672443,
-0.0295952596,
0.027751442,
-0.0092961965,
0.0391810499,
0.0084735872,
0.0581526197,
0.0235281251,
-0.0135474848,
-0.0033314903,
0.020653002,
-0.0338516086,
-0.0258252677,
0.0054557836,
0.0079476601,
0.0144911818,
-0.0407305062,
0.009002245,
-0.0189203117,
2.655e-7,
0.01733426,
0.0694475248,
0.0013368885,
-0.0504632406,
0.0243771616,
0.0965127423,
-0.0030401528,
0.0260651112,
0.0341865793,
0.0284325164,
0.04215388,
-0.0078649074,
0.0476124994,
0.0128357448,
-0.0664105862,
-0.0368758217,
-0.0425520204,
-0.0211855303,
-0.033269316,
0.0487650186,
0.0997945592,
0.1443967819,
0.0633752421,
-0.0082116667,
0.0082103042,
-0.0396007374,
0.0246676691,
-0.0811603591,
-0.005185232,
0.0349141099,
0.0264270622,
-0.0185649265,
0.0058699776,
0.0138034755,
0.006856584,
0.0460805148,
-0.0158063341,
0.0407500006,
-0.0068370183,
-0.0424755737,
0.0195878483,
-0.0023486051,
-0.0272881519,
-0.10144151,
0.0549108461,
-0.0760292858,
-0.057711266,
-0.0124843223,
-0.0212855302,
-0.0418020748,
0.0127131427,
-0.0066029001,
-0.0147845047,
0.0340147689,
0.0057275691,
-0.0473265648,
-0.0320784599,
-0.0882234499,
0.0223381333,
-0.0211487077,
-0.0433714166,
-0.0219056457,
-0.03209484,
0.0065585789,
0.0662483871,
-0.039372202,
0.0382422209,
2.390366385e-34,
0.027776923,
0.0275860596,
-0.0180701092,
0.0741093382,
0.060840141,
0.0267331079,
0.0053134114,
0.0135099776,
0.0500650853,
-0.0799540654,
0.0125336591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04269v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04269v1 | From Sparse to Dense: GPT-4 Summarization with Chain of Density Prompting | 2023-09-08T11:31:08 | 2023-09-08T11:31:08 | Griffin Adams, Alexander Fabbri, Faisal Ladhak, Eric Lehman, Noémie Elhadad | cs.CL | cs.CL | Selecting the ``right'' amount of information to include in a summary is a
difficult task. A good summary should be detailed and entity-centric without
being overly dense and hard to follow. To better understand this tradeoff, we
solicit increasingly dense GPT-4 summaries with what we refer to as a ``Chain
of Density'' (CoD) prompt. Specifically, GPT-4 generates an initial
entity-sparse summary before iteratively incorporating missing salient entities
without increasing the length. Summaries generated by CoD are more abstractive,
exhibit more fusion, and have less of a lead bias than GPT-4 summaries
generated by a vanilla prompt. We conduct a human preference study on 100 CNN
DailyMail articles and find that that humans prefer GPT-4 summaries that are
more dense than those generated by a vanilla prompt and almost as dense as
human written summaries. Qualitative analysis supports the notion that there
exists a tradeoff between informativeness and readability. 500 annotated CoD
summaries, as well as an extra 5,000 unannotated summaries, are freely
available on HuggingFace
(https://huggingface.co/datasets/griffin/chain_of_density). | [
0.0396560878,
0.0186173562,
0.0152752157,
-0.0000538933,
0.0123427715,
0.0343103856,
-0.04358235,
-0.0132987704,
-0.0303821303,
-0.0046609323,
0.0284619331,
-0.024122877,
-0.0038320436,
0.0384796336,
0.0142941391,
-0.1348823458,
-0.0045257746,
0.0008231968,
-0.0001170893,
-0.0126373582,
0.0376175493,
0.0148033556,
0.0093343668,
-0.006421539,
0.0032302933,
0.0224573035,
-0.0378627554,
0.0373225249,
0.0692758337,
-0.0502788275,
-0.0296749435,
0.0693931654,
0.0202850476,
0.0234344006,
0.0000020249,
-0.0243915208,
-0.0058993171,
0.0069012493,
-0.0173383504,
0.0454411991,
0.0169754624,
-0.0702394694,
0.0274171103,
-0.0517962351,
-0.0058867121,
-0.0254673194,
0.02701151,
0.0834007412,
0.0430891253,
0.0572554208,
-0.021167174,
-0.022442298,
0.0436979681,
-0.0271679871,
-0.030212339,
-0.0308665354,
-0.0280838534,
-0.0007301208,
-0.0042948495,
0.064116165,
0.0020566792,
0.0203416087,
0.0344274752,
0.0067766174,
0.0227358434,
0.0853804126,
-0.0376894288,
0.0074677458,
0.0100076944,
0.0799953192,
0.0366429538,
-0.014493702,
-0.0019604331,
-0.0073203761,
0.0196841732,
-0.0198085122,
-0.0721483901,
0.0231137536,
-0.0260011535,
0.0247724745,
-0.0181710329,
0.0294935349,
-0.013740099,
0.0351402052,
-0.0223168451,
-0.0123490198,
-0.0007633908,
-0.0221329108,
0.019171549,
0.0477716848,
-0.0344591178,
-0.0738746151,
0.0045007826,
0.0285677928,
-0.0143650435,
-0.0284076221,
-0.0271335877,
-0.0125769759,
0.0236948915,
0.0034816286,
-0.0156742036,
0.0185442306,
-0.0289709307,
0.0226854905,
0.0150715178,
-0.0309776664,
0.0224387888,
-0.0192066878,
-0.0181437898,
0.0203774683,
-0.0078202477,
0.0039126407,
-0.0292722434,
0.0784741417,
-0.0287501533,
-0.0125979194,
-0.0377806909,
0.0101601835,
0.0087463725,
0.017996924,
-0.0248476993,
0.0135999974,
-0.0119118216,
-0.0073993965,
-0.0118022319,
0.0294800885,
-0.0770716369,
-0.0372145921,
0.0561157204,
-0.0199526791,
-0.0214864481,
-0.0017009573,
0.0144209974,
-0.0130940787,
-0.0381055437,
-0.012866525,
-0.0270482525,
-0.0380264148,
-0.0257449728,
-0.0241015144,
-0.0095345927,
-0.0481965244,
-0.0396054797,
-0.084760569,
-0.0037012221,
0.0002253937,
0.0068587251,
-0.0058509083,
-0.0108216582,
0.0176532976,
-0.0416970737,
0.0188139174,
-0.0705426782,
-0.0088945385,
0.0394479297,
0.0180713013,
0.028932713,
0.0720143095,
-0.00534902,
0.0527517498,
0.0259289257,
0.0083011733,
-0.0054195686,
-0.0175607502,
0.0084188031,
0.0582861379,
0.0340760686,
0.0039437823,
-0.0775844976,
0.0171676707,
0.0594980195,
0.06340231,
-0.0534500964,
0.0282804947,
0.0908668488,
0.0644304231,
-0.0240961276,
0.0159184057,
0.0283416994,
0.0280990396,
0.0146091264,
0.104699105,
-0.0406558923,
0.0497013256,
-0.0512665026,
0.0428439453,
0.0649294481,
0.0418205038,
-0.0302958861,
-0.0305089392,
0.0373360887,
0.014790074,
0.0288808607,
-0.0220006686,
0.0118116122,
0.000620491,
-0.0411310941,
0.0029925897,
0.0029106918,
-0.0637335107,
0.0026194039,
0.0258533694,
0.0463014953,
0.0126952296,
0.0213264022,
0.0303634126,
-0.0407745242,
0.0000210618,
0.0406594463,
0.0572005622,
0.0405315161,
0.0016077576,
-0.0054436419,
-0.0709776953,
-0.0546826497,
-0.0258219596,
0.0121801896,
-0.0073579075,
0.0127594173,
0.0192821603,
0.0394499227,
-0.0048391516,
-0.0447844006,
0.0007354252,
0.0509046875,
-0.0074327281,
-0.0105499793,
-0.0013964261,
0.0119786309,
0.0790970623,
0.0153739918,
-0.0014622755,
0.0106367711,
0.0107626328,
-0.0303290505,
-0.0134419855,
-0.0514326431,
0.0129078701,
-0.0253916923,
-0.049318295,
-0.023267176,
-0.0134797161,
-0.0339952037,
-0.0591750033,
-0.0405188315,
-0.0589180253,
0.0306715202,
-0.0195298549,
-0.0275374055,
0.0450876914,
0.0021432291,
-0.0394258797,
0.1077612117,
-0.0054739411,
-0.0038405694,
0.0400808118,
-0.0133490413,
-0.009432503,
-0.0690716654,
0.0070755635,
0.0044402061,
0.0237565897,
-0.0248232204,
0.0524620041,
-0.0135170268,
-0.0518603548,
0.0065088463,
-0.1287116706,
-0.0037258109,
-0.01427586,
0.0168934986,
0.0452587008,
0.0211881679,
-0.0119311241,
0.0030880871,
-0.0622415282,
-0.0162672289,
-0.0164186005,
0.0347917154,
0.0143682892,
0.0411344394,
0.0427864268,
-0.0101899905,
-0.0207357723,
0.008205073,
0.0079272948,
0.0268942658,
-0.0492695048,
-0.0490167141,
0.0123715196,
-0.0104366336,
-0.0503527969,
0.0118615683,
0.0125271631,
0.0050140265,
-0.0124814855,
0.0862856284,
0.0335267931,
0.0498943701,
0.0617581271,
0.0160447992,
0.0178377517,
-0.0225912128,
0.0089098895,
-0.0481107011,
0.0212637056,
0.0151473563,
-0.0355238505,
0.0251902491,
0.0061932732,
0.0050789728,
0.0036446024,
-0.0503318161,
-0.0104788449,
-0.0154023934,
0.0063637975,
-0.023564361,
-0.0113042081,
0.0131419692,
0.0706155822,
-0.0193719137,
-0.0097403582,
0.0857938305,
-0.0095548136,
0.0095337341,
-0.0359484591,
0.0138797481,
-0.0371628292,
0.0266104992,
-0.0069502019,
0.0144947786,
0.0123021724,
-0.0401662849,
-0.0312847085,
-0.0000498325,
0.0118083591,
0.0186699778,
0.122333698,
-0.033357922,
-0.0029024116,
-0.0423726626,
-0.0327408276,
0.0179377142,
-0.0332757346,
-0.0308692139,
0.0254459139,
0.023820417,
-0.02924647,
-0.040639665,
-0.0015662827,
0.0509746261,
0.049460385,
-0.0353320129,
-0.0287855174,
0.0049687456,
0.0426980779,
0.0673162043,
0.0468244441,
0.0195792336,
-0.0566696599,
0.0315481089,
0.0719644129,
-0.0218851008,
-0.0198527835,
0.0148752332,
-0.0062153623,
-0.0012250415,
-0.0589023866,
-0.043697007,
-0.010173237,
0.0902021751,
-0.0312223658,
0.0192546807,
0.108243458,
-0.0168537144,
-0.0810655206,
-0.0096756388,
0.0362679623,
0.0676991642,
-0.0126184421,
-0.009081725,
-0.0834030509,
0.010715263,
0.0012747016,
0.0382943116,
0.0120828617,
-0.0346646309,
0.0250451211,
-0.0642343089,
0.0350176878,
0.0000736698,
-0.0431316048,
-0.0057427264,
-0.0710437372,
0.0236675236,
-0.0185576659,
-0.0157261919,
0.0063967397,
-0.0120473905,
0.0249261968,
0.0067752125,
-0.0151193049,
0.0116576245,
-0.0337985307,
-0.0141161438,
-0.0126575138,
0.0510902628,
0.0390638672,
-0.033394102,
0.0218017399,
0.0055741244,
-0.0420106612,
-0.0086340392,
-0.0072143725,
0.1106610745,
-0.0141987661,
0.028401887,
-0.0496550314,
0.0721473247,
0.0394627564,
-0.023122143,
0.003278201,
0.0043283859,
-0.0026058741,
-0.026998926,
-0.0465086438,
0.0335402191,
0.0007530418,
0.0626794845,
0.0338180326,
-0.0068559111,
-0.0018172745,
-0.0185603313,
0.0344394706,
-0.0489571281,
-0.0219147969,
0.0031963808,
-0.0418877974,
-0.0218525939,
-0.0444853418,
-0.0864810646,
0.011273603,
0.0268941056,
0.0209357459,
0.0093925716,
-0.0294830929,
0.0099185389,
-0.030583933,
0.0115585737,
0.0171616431,
-0.0106574111,
-0.0579418615,
-0.0570372045,
0.0146299722,
-0.0294111762,
0.0015090413,
0.012842223,
-0.0348839238,
-0.0281017479,
-0.0371815525,
-0.0082820356,
0.0189079437,
0.0526590496,
0.0160833076,
-0.022446448,
0.0708986521,
0.0336958542,
-0.0017187519,
0.0210477412,
-0.0129064247,
0.0426335819,
-0.0104080345,
0.0113781923,
-0.0201474819,
0.0466711186,
-0.02299086,
0.0445815995,
-0.0352105871,
-0.0652889684,
0.0124481432,
0.0208642446,
0.0164223835,
-0.0493534654,
0.028474085,
-0.031446211,
-0.0034882454,
-0.0369942188,
0.0095236572,
-0.0284033678,
0.0162294284,
0.0002548047,
0.0163918138,
-0.0107729463,
0.077615492,
0.0168832131,
0.0462514162,
-0.0990580171,
-0.0143200224,
-0.0145401964,
-0.0274695978,
-0.0118575105,
-0.0227126367,
-0.0737081096,
-0.0226792973,
-0.0414824933,
0.0325025469,
-0.0053807748,
0.0501297526,
0.0668881908,
-0.0041215084,
0.0288342126,
0.0429294966,
-0.1034700945,
0.0115985367,
-0.0337753557,
0.0006399008,
0.012035015,
-0.0631838292,
0.0812691823,
-0.0392384082,
-0.019005917,
0.0058245487,
0.0255329628,
0.0164135545,
-0.0043698191,
-0.0060500777,
0.0469893999,
0.0106676985,
0.0029875517,
0.0812214166,
-0.0273017511,
0.0216962919,
0.0461065881,
-0.0139659103,
-0.0259836316,
-0.0346271172,
-0.000904251,
0.0662902147,
0.0017443543,
-0.0210865624,
-0.0652259141,
-0.0302926246,
0.0173663944,
-0.0170741528,
0.0046752575,
-0.0207438488,
0.0510038733,
0.0239049271,
-0.0038968143,
-0.0330303013,
-0.0398703441,
0.0153635824,
-0.0158686116,
-0.015385096,
-0.0069127348,
-6.6603554e-33,
-0.0269695222,
-0.0120136803,
-0.0231952369,
0.0443064012,
-0.0388816595,
0.0168597251,
-0.0700843781,
0.0068385457,
0.0015252596,
0.0623780191,
-0.0250126608,
-0.0006829213,
0.0107553964,
0.025555471,
-0.0109636495,
0.041388426,
0.0302682277,
0.0145347249,
-0.0324635878,
0.0766588449,
0.0233723391,
-0.0029669208,
0.0370757915,
-0.0363139696,
0.0593621209,
-0.0007109282,
-0.0143335508,
-0.0251512043,
0.0267277937,
0.0217479169,
0.001679119,
0.0020417792,
0.0379918888,
-0.0085836742,
-0.0369045846,
0.0182366166,
-0.0967680886,
-0.0195742361,
0.0426718295,
-0.0559989586,
-0.0482078642,
-0.0357295498,
-0.0036043113,
-0.0539230332,
0.0379635133,
-0.0605625585,
0.05278752,
-0.0243941322,
-0.0385948308,
-0.0673202872,
-0.0286476575,
0.0419070944,
-0.0346849076,
0.0285815969,
0.0210604221,
0.0085250838,
0.0270134658,
0.0051038507,
-0.0036908456,
0.0367369652,
0.0199474376,
0.0215078983,
-0.0013847038,
-0.0153832203,
-0.0214202758,
0.0426605754,
-0.014418385,
0.0106258215,
-0.0893744305,
0.0338184908,
0.0019161931,
-0.0069595701,
-0.0008977373,
0.0411659144,
0.035618417,
0.0191885065,
-0.0339977369,
0.0788945332,
-0.0492871143,
0.0045776744,
0.0074895625,
0.0094556799,
-0.0284201223,
-0.0141552128,
0.0029491708,
0.007776787,
-0.0194440652,
-0.0394638777,
-0.0406415872,
-0.0072854203,
-0.064791508,
0.0330414586,
-0.0037853555,
-0.0008846712,
0.016282469,
-0.0076652612,
-0.0089163342,
0.0265790932,
0.0121768303,
-0.0436744094,
-0.0241843965,
0.0040077805,
0.0193022005,
0.0619042106,
-0.013253578,
0.0123186074,
0.0769680813,
0.0143713169,
-0.0231723376,
-0.0081628049,
0.0000884112,
0.0208620448,
-0.0403956659,
0.0111186244,
-0.0041194446,
-0.0078216791,
0.001484085,
0.005178866,
-0.0015448764,
0.0067746285,
-0.0304528065,
0.020542549,
0.0289963931,
0.0275142938,
0.0044950233,
0.0015381534,
-0.0081778616,
-0.0079331836,
0.0510332361,
-0.0323594883,
-0.0282693543,
0.0205736626,
2.615e-7,
0.0102637438,
0.0136052398,
0.0725824013,
-0.0323826745,
-0.0293097235,
-0.0040323227,
0.0319687724,
0.0258893035,
-0.0016597062,
-0.0526993871,
0.0503917634,
0.0401227549,
0.0322898366,
0.0479473062,
-0.1201932058,
-0.0366378203,
-0.0631632209,
-0.0514834002,
-0.0676272586,
-0.0000885121,
0.0650051683,
0.0091874544,
-0.0120742526,
-0.0017381264,
0.0342186019,
0.0500256494,
0.0241651889,
-0.0159932543,
0.0314900428,
0.0249521788,
0.0369930379,
-0.0166641511,
-0.021328235,
0.0200444628,
-0.0250752289,
-0.0444188938,
0.0518594012,
0.0613805689,
0.0249358863,
-0.0229536146,
0.017198652,
-0.0146859447,
0.0359831192,
-0.0578380376,
0.0392953977,
-0.0084430911,
-0.0459130704,
0.0253380425,
-0.064897649,
-0.0128912581,
-0.0168330446,
-0.0020712407,
-0.0249364823,
0.0477479026,
-0.0200834684,
-0.0126823448,
0.0060416847,
-0.0562360212,
-0.0096674673,
0.0242914073,
0.0062293559,
-0.0429188721,
-0.0411210395,
-0.0305862352,
-0.0147326468,
-0.061450541,
-0.0178473499,
2.561076404e-34,
0.0654960871,
-0.0117724352,
0.0039916113,
-0.0254240185,
0.0169841144,
0.0033248302,
-0.0061938385,
-0.0130213732,
0.0118601257,
-0.0706039891,
-0.0095043331
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06384v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06384v1 | Towards Reliable and Fluent Large Language Models: Incorporating Feedback Learning Loops in QA Systems | 2023-09-08T09:39:53 | 2023-09-08T09:39:53 | Dongyub Lee, Taesun Whang, Chanhee Lee, Heuiseok Lim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as versatile tools in various daily
applications. However, they are fraught with issues that undermine their
utility and trustworthiness. These include the incorporation of erroneous
references (citation), the generation of hallucinated information
(correctness), and the inclusion of superfluous or omission of crucial details
(fluency). To ameliorate these concerns, this study makes several key
contributions. First, we build a dataset to train a critic model capable of
evaluating the citation, correctness, and fluency of responses generated by
LLMs in QA systems. Second, we propose an automated feedback mechanism that
leverages the critic model to offer real-time feedback on heterogeneous aspects
of generated text. Third, we introduce a feedback learning loop that uses this
critic model to iteratively improve the performance of the LLM responsible for
response generation. Experimental results demonstrate the efficacy of our
approach, showing substantial improvements in citation and fluency metrics for
ChatGPT, including a 4% precision increase in citation and an approximately 8%
enhancement in the MAUVE metric for fluency, while maintaining high levels of
correctness. | [
0.0776835084,
0.0031894939,
-0.0322391242,
0.0369036272,
-0.0183342136,
-0.016069755,
-0.0307157096,
-0.0194008313,
0.0302454922,
-0.0726271644,
-0.0040542074,
-0.0324455947,
-0.0191266928,
0.0188506059,
0.0322704241,
-0.0202120133,
0.0387527905,
-0.0477244109,
0.0063497578,
-0.0081298333,
0.0286366306,
0.0314011611,
-0.0110731665,
0.0750419348,
0.0143805118,
-0.0458811708,
0.0013865801,
-0.0078977905,
-0.0010068975,
-0.0160493236,
0.030968558,
0.0481652096,
-0.0092101442,
0.0593770631,
0.0000018664,
-0.0547667556,
0.0003318897,
-0.0042767902,
-0.0124430098,
0.0266493093,
0.0680636093,
0.0272539258,
-0.0130719701,
0.0597083457,
-0.0573493168,
0.0140490718,
0.0394223444,
0.0204785317,
0.0783317834,
0.0332648121,
-0.0016954032,
0.0035452696,
0.0335274376,
0.0008563861,
0.0058447048,
-0.048041191,
0.0206684265,
0.0579648502,
0.0480043925,
0.0197414327,
0.0031217751,
0.0241884589,
0.0095392261,
-0.0484503694,
0.0235189125,
0.0031594427,
0.0101186931,
0.002978713,
0.0016011569,
0.0741650909,
-0.0101064583,
-0.0323555693,
-0.0137283131,
0.0000238177,
0.0078576244,
0.0196033809,
-0.0353069231,
-0.0033700489,
-0.0104202013,
-0.0016088996,
-0.0112253623,
-0.0573234968,
-0.0035396412,
0.0013840002,
0.0032730203,
0.0255892109,
0.0113002621,
-0.0274717081,
-0.0063046115,
0.019393811,
-0.002797245,
-0.0479187705,
0.0100753792,
0.0662418157,
-0.0775757879,
0.0197310131,
-0.0124642178,
-0.0236361474,
0.0484369099,
-0.0357725248,
0.0087030623,
-0.0009746913,
-0.0068842745,
0.0257846322,
-0.0099690463,
0.0530991144,
-0.0170181226,
0.0083533842,
-0.0205303375,
-0.0175794605,
-0.0630884469,
-0.0274550989,
-0.0061739334,
0.049442023,
-0.0180598143,
-0.0118343364,
-0.06938003,
0.0485903807,
-0.0374294408,
0.0476142466,
-0.0009471063,
0.013066018,
-0.0252140611,
0.0060519595,
-0.0459805988,
0.0525366329,
-0.008478364,
0.029978795,
-0.0025177074,
-0.0654888451,
0.0096044643,
0.011443546,
-0.0025990056,
0.0026626845,
-0.0133373272,
0.0634575784,
-0.0090670651,
0.0073718498,
-0.02796847,
-0.0438887104,
-0.0257868301,
-0.0467806794,
-0.0343792811,
-0.078978233,
0.0045859567,
0.0243180282,
-0.0240177326,
-0.041159831,
0.019076854,
0.0576462038,
-0.0225704685,
0.050592415,
-0.0620497391,
0.0393185504,
0.030906545,
-0.0025840185,
0.026733797,
0.0524899065,
0.0522342324,
-0.0002975576,
0.050914295,
-0.0115274834,
0.0585674942,
0.032567542,
0.0078738704,
0.0230825339,
-0.005011322,
0.0048920885,
-0.0234807953,
0.0328153968,
0.0183701869,
0.0735349432,
-0.0217993129,
0.0180284437,
0.0553306155,
0.0151693365,
0.00271527,
0.0232973844,
0.04213956,
0.0341492593,
0.0197226927,
-0.0055144802,
-0.0153868543,
0.0171141643,
-0.0187437199,
0.0182788149,
0.0422923379,
0.0088781752,
-0.0341453366,
-0.0500795804,
-0.0121466713,
0.012835619,
-0.0320813544,
0.0179855656,
0.0306753982,
0.0267233327,
-0.0579774268,
0.0318192616,
0.0145927481,
-0.0406821333,
0.0196398143,
-0.0337822251,
0.0735215619,
0.0819562823,
0.0558437146,
-0.013166029,
-0.0207961611,
-0.0397200175,
-0.0110167842,
0.0672037527,
0.0303121395,
-0.04195261,
-0.0551274605,
-0.0416326486,
-0.0203170106,
0.0172793362,
-0.0039075152,
0.0025390119,
-0.0047419495,
0.0047364044,
0.006023108,
-0.018824378,
-0.0620623901,
0.0156081142,
-0.0088080121,
-0.0385494009,
0.0086136777,
-0.0268262662,
0.0273280833,
0.0322264209,
-0.0094756102,
0.0240220223,
0.0283082053,
-0.0075915544,
-0.0215556882,
0.0269091837,
-0.0029539056,
-0.0195304863,
0.0703451112,
0.009689738,
-0.0176039375,
0.0212963652,
-0.0432487614,
-0.045248583,
0.0130858384,
-0.0363929383,
0.0151329339,
-0.0271159597,
-0.002680304,
-0.0047692754,
0.0025381306,
-0.0555420965,
0.0226664282,
0.0219565202,
0.0479111448,
0.0049164272,
0.0350340232,
0.0239063501,
-0.0366073735,
-0.017569514,
0.0068811774,
-0.0034217003,
0.0362402797,
0.0371796787,
0.0166890416,
-0.034473829,
-0.0118702296,
-0.0801567286,
-0.0002051757,
-0.0176245905,
0.019117536,
0.0077964123,
-0.0097142439,
-0.0047595911,
-0.0215036683,
-0.0359206907,
-0.0007305225,
0.0305885244,
0.0322028883,
0.0351212472,
0.0125020137,
-0.0037873192,
-0.0675710887,
0.0079649556,
-0.0242961738,
0.031258177,
0.0457589924,
0.0103140157,
-0.0908861309,
0.0025218048,
-0.019284619,
0.0134975296,
0.0139204767,
-0.0349306725,
0.0135775656,
0.0154800732,
0.0624587722,
0.0312294047,
0.0275786184,
0.009662821,
0.0397666581,
0.0100002065,
-0.0740083009,
0.0139645254,
-0.0141251348,
-0.0913522542,
-0.0181586314,
-0.0197740104,
0.0107996725,
0.0377440155,
0.0247061122,
-0.0075861835,
-0.0451620035,
0.0411802232,
-0.0382770374,
0.0019832554,
-0.0414995253,
-0.0161682814,
-0.0452781767,
0.027583817,
0.0051854313,
-0.0042348085,
0.0706386715,
-0.0205232538,
0.0009165729,
-0.0460207537,
0.0054019787,
-0.0354553424,
0.017965626,
-0.002080967,
0.0108112879,
-0.0143084126,
-0.0273964945,
-0.0494227931,
-0.004313339,
0.0052800905,
-0.067172341,
0.0484780595,
-0.0493826643,
0.0094241872,
-0.0047403141,
-0.0377670042,
-0.0612971261,
0.0074741142,
-0.0534088872,
0.0177651178,
0.0066818665,
-0.0029478704,
-0.0163716916,
-0.0098075513,
0.0385675244,
0.0230054967,
-0.045406986,
-0.0220943261,
-0.0269576088,
0.0529142879,
0.0869986713,
-0.0023876675,
0.0463641435,
-0.030047683,
0.0142180528,
0.0409916192,
0.0476131439,
0.0144766299,
-0.0216063038,
-0.0618892685,
0.0256215315,
-0.0551658906,
0.0097272051,
0.0348270275,
0.0277836714,
-0.0636074468,
-0.0281350724,
0.1125833541,
0.0391898453,
-0.0673959851,
-0.005467888,
-0.0415999293,
0.0339230224,
0.0263042711,
0.0568115562,
-0.1135640964,
-0.0258816499,
-0.0136613501,
0.0438721776,
0.0080529526,
-0.0129587278,
0.0111949807,
-0.1625791043,
0.0369386896,
-0.000094538,
-0.0074262689,
-0.0323170312,
-0.0244445484,
0.0014395036,
-0.022023119,
0.039722126,
0.0508276932,
-0.0230081826,
0.0061720037,
0.038772922,
-0.0270228088,
-0.0400711,
0.0035512722,
-0.0392128155,
0.0708697364,
0.0546009727,
0.0348645858,
0.0155444006,
-0.034526743,
0.048303578,
-0.0344464146,
-0.0181568004,
-0.0008130089,
0.0031397464,
0.0080549996,
-0.0059626764,
-0.0166561641,
0.0150791984,
-0.0303527545,
0.0015908683,
0.0484919585,
0.078043811,
0.008167889,
0.0110867471,
-0.0314328596,
0.0205984823,
0.0240732618,
0.056683328,
0.0340384692,
-0.0587217584,
-0.0589148253,
-0.0384580344,
-0.0066424701,
-0.0672220662,
-0.0520310551,
0.0104330387,
-0.0225484949,
0.0270414297,
-0.0920327678,
-0.0491831414,
0.01047011,
-0.011082788,
0.0273817275,
0.0346169136,
0.0148166604,
0.0067967521,
-0.0153630655,
0.0017193727,
-0.043518953,
0.0288982186,
-0.0517838635,
0.0260608979,
0.0259485822,
-0.0270090066,
-0.0127678458,
0.0086421892,
-0.0211137477,
-0.0604113229,
-0.0217629243,
0.0607974455,
0.0257426202,
0.0263964813,
-0.0355399773,
-0.0802005231,
-0.0023743776,
0.0287791863,
-0.0636629686,
-0.0155507745,
0.005283413,
0.0089087235,
-0.0155928675,
0.0320940241,
-0.0566074885,
0.0075577735,
-0.0380139425,
0.0591413379,
-0.0039181616,
-0.0344943777,
0.023998756,
0.013331132,
0.0220319405,
0.0197192114,
-0.0021110417,
-0.0150832338,
0.0305090901,
-0.0212715045,
-0.0318108052,
-0.0353751332,
0.0281921308,
-0.0230095051,
-0.0374277458,
-0.0015057354,
-0.0480164513,
-0.0656993166,
0.0696438029,
-0.0121012619,
-0.0063427896,
-0.0109292381,
0.0322429352,
0.0264484733,
-0.0261605754,
-0.0278068874,
-0.019665841,
0.0255469438,
0.0292300973,
0.0174916964,
0.0429427624,
0.0077768569,
-0.010261978,
0.0327062644,
-0.0139065897,
-0.0377506986,
-0.0324036479,
-0.0311949532,
-0.0028952074,
0.0674872473,
0.0310008749,
0.0656884834,
-0.0197036713,
-0.008704355,
-0.0183419101,
0.0319470577,
-0.0240640845,
-0.0178874843,
0.0455358364,
0.0244823564,
-0.0125095295,
-0.0066849925,
0.0861079395,
0.010400543,
0.0018375469,
-0.0124837011,
-0.0210334491,
-0.0360754617,
-0.0327436477,
-0.0325583667,
0.0109675061,
-0.0170705114,
-0.0031946225,
-0.0565284491,
-0.0660521016,
0.0164152626,
0.0354692712,
-0.0018035924,
-0.0086613856,
0.0228094533,
0.0525845103,
0.0113547938,
-0.0116973668,
-0.0792439878,
0.0299595855,
-0.0344150998,
-0.0245298818,
-0.0171952676,
-5.914137994e-33,
-0.0229217354,
-0.0662741289,
0.0379454158,
0.007884535,
-0.0224143397,
-0.0279379785,
-0.0405120738,
0.0000156387,
-0.0065569743,
0.0188908577,
-0.02302281,
0.0162135605,
0.0019532833,
0.0220070705,
0.0250796434,
0.0029278458,
0.0583228469,
0.013023111,
-0.0038757073,
0.0545138977,
0.0202522445,
0.0082665933,
0.0349319391,
-0.0781388953,
0.0443568826,
-0.0279883947,
-0.0175967962,
0.0306781009,
-0.0112937437,
0.0960183069,
-0.0095081413,
0.0912610441,
0.0145818228,
-0.0349602774,
-0.0028072335,
0.0094022891,
-0.0375826061,
-0.0154797919,
0.0405484661,
0.0022943961,
-0.0114782434,
-0.0377314426,
0.0493691005,
-0.031139208,
-0.0276548583,
0.0289220065,
0.0573701859,
-0.0363670178,
-0.0313335694,
-0.0313975364,
-0.0726289675,
0.0247178394,
0.0128168706,
0.0132090645,
-0.0441030972,
0.0991557017,
-0.0106955627,
0.0085588424,
-0.0456544273,
0.0138180545,
0.0359159186,
0.0295293406,
0.06112995,
-0.0002208267,
0.0022402415,
0.0344897434,
-0.0121012181,
0.000106872,
0.0001439136,
-0.0452825874,
-0.0002950704,
0.023376748,
0.0787194669,
0.0985904709,
-0.0250128601,
-0.0122019872,
-0.060618028,
0.0189339649,
-0.0120190373,
0.0742066801,
0.0452441238,
-0.01587338,
-0.0241529867,
0.0085790148,
-0.0507000461,
0.051420223,
-0.0371542536,
-0.0418558978,
0.0381948799,
0.0162343495,
-0.0113400789,
0.0025955096,
0.020110609,
-0.0457847863,
-0.0359127969,
0.0126677565,
-0.0600013211,
0.0297544934,
-0.0153234657,
0.0205228738,
-0.0740950257,
-0.0133005874,
-0.0214434359,
-0.0211502556,
-0.0012878997,
0.0286972281,
0.0087059122,
-0.0060074995,
-0.0799830854,
0.0140375737,
-0.0127754509,
0.0491222031,
-0.0226504058,
-0.0209006201,
0.0139672793,
0.0024457797,
-0.0079149641,
0.066857487,
0.0140638808,
-0.004764704,
-0.007081694,
-0.0433995016,
-0.0006501283,
0.0150591247,
-0.0635704026,
-0.0211640168,
-0.0161366779,
0.0648044124,
-0.0133904777,
-0.061391037,
-0.012311724,
-0.0030575255,
2.524e-7,
0.0320571885,
0.065661639,
-0.0186766628,
-0.0084746042,
0.0241203103,
0.0125589427,
0.0067855082,
0.0168503989,
0.0518189892,
0.0362924747,
-0.0195862781,
-0.0154611133,
0.0462680236,
0.0209276583,
-0.1088771671,
-0.037171118,
-0.0700300336,
0.0151995784,
-0.0470624715,
-0.0059133535,
0.024429692,
0.0692741796,
-0.0151425628,
-0.0060271542,
-0.0341351517,
-0.0416941419,
0.0783310682,
0.0106552802,
-0.0326797739,
0.0410230383,
0.085782662,
0.0139173111,
0.0300649442,
0.0061670048,
-0.0098911198,
0.0032661329,
-0.0148851136,
0.0376266353,
-0.0001166647,
-0.0309156496,
0.0152400173,
-0.0368837304,
0.0450586751,
-0.0929114819,
0.0247205906,
-0.053659454,
-0.0042011654,
-0.0386202522,
-0.0377180204,
-0.0445654392,
0.0078974096,
-0.038063705,
-0.0431757681,
0.0068903239,
0.0052299122,
0.0174966156,
-0.0199012198,
-0.0337337814,
-0.0082002888,
0.0434934385,
-0.0044884267,
-0.0426244736,
-0.0122207077,
-0.0417454541,
-0.027113907,
-0.0717670172,
0.0552965328,
2.179859683e-34,
0.0568305179,
-0.0276034996,
0.0361014605,
0.0444007926,
0.0297744032,
0.0229030624,
0.0309571866,
0.0343449302,
0.0499045998,
-0.0610783324,
-0.0175620057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04213v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04213v2 | UQ at #SMM4H 2023: ALEX for Public Health Analysis with Social Media | 2023-09-08T08:54:55 | 2023-09-12T07:19:22 | Yan Jiang, Ruihong Qiu, Yi Zhang, Zi Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As social media becomes increasingly popular, more and more activities
related to public health emerge. Current techniques for public health analysis
involve popular models such as BERT and large language models (LLMs). However,
the costs of training in-domain LLMs for public health are especially
expensive. Furthermore, such kinds of in-domain datasets from social media are
generally imbalanced. To tackle these challenges, the data imbalance issue can
be overcome by data augmentation and balanced training. Moreover, the ability
of the LLMs can be effectively utilized by prompting the model properly. In
this paper, a novel ALEX framework is proposed to improve the performance of
public health analysis on social media by adopting an LLMs explanation
mechanism. Results show that our ALEX model got the best performance among all
submissions in both Task 2 and Task 4 with a high score in Task 1 in Social
Media Mining for Health 2023 (SMM4H)[1]. Our code has been released at https://
github.com/YanJiangJerry/ALEX. | [
0.0405031852,
0.0395600386,
-0.0074117063,
-0.0227566771,
0.0322678387,
0.0314412639,
-0.0051685111,
-0.0199385229,
0.0250048526,
-0.0349576324,
0.0382767394,
-0.0143958228,
-0.0453209244,
0.048803091,
0.0058448627,
-0.0419486277,
0.0173618738,
0.0210500285,
0.0315950476,
0.0275917035,
0.0362659544,
0.0156533383,
-0.0136489598,
0.0435984619,
0.0275422037,
0.03134837,
-0.0084426971,
-0.0164584424,
0.0542142242,
-0.0802004933,
0.0224525817,
0.0154873291,
0.0396958031,
0.018873319,
0.0000021785,
-0.0571099892,
-0.0112400241,
0.018714156,
-0.0259955935,
0.0088640759,
0.0104937181,
-0.0354466215,
0.0270659458,
0.0569767579,
-0.0397756062,
0.0034037801,
0.0717508569,
0.0456833057,
0.0580608323,
0.0817853361,
-0.0218254179,
-0.0329872258,
-0.0049083713,
-0.0334501676,
-0.0003667495,
-0.0252638217,
0.0462996215,
-0.0411587507,
0.0199297573,
0.0100705177,
0.0362847038,
0.0301274098,
0.0063213534,
-0.0076747932,
0.0329973064,
0.0289593711,
-0.042738989,
-0.0331139751,
-0.0031934564,
0.0700050145,
0.0066329758,
0.006316687,
0.0255844127,
-0.0208358616,
0.0039671627,
0.0396907181,
-0.0571759529,
-0.0029990119,
-0.0169926789,
0.0584741682,
-0.009685548,
0.0277521946,
0.0535591953,
0.0522872843,
0.0027155543,
0.0240902156,
-0.0332187228,
-0.0127870506,
-0.0224792752,
0.0158192459,
-0.0232015606,
-0.0191254187,
0.0518002883,
0.0453232788,
-0.042574849,
0.0049173636,
0.034844391,
-0.0520162545,
0.0646961629,
-0.1053323075,
0.0099411542,
-0.0127000902,
-0.020493729,
0.0278448462,
0.0505996495,
-0.0080034342,
-0.0024676055,
0.0303904414,
0.0255814437,
0.0148586128,
-0.0707323924,
0.0283661392,
-0.0270838477,
0.0109311305,
-0.001737648,
0.0252169427,
-0.0653119907,
0.0182279386,
-0.0157841165,
-0.0263529979,
-0.0098997932,
0.048914019,
-0.0142257251,
0.0003401166,
-0.0233419761,
0.0373257399,
-0.0054891813,
0.0488790423,
-0.0077520972,
0.0039912877,
0.0103846136,
-0.0135156848,
0.0484452508,
-0.0239242129,
-0.0177323781,
0.0460649207,
0.0437378176,
-0.0254381746,
-0.0364524573,
-0.0045820107,
-0.0013475098,
-0.043328613,
-0.0249862317,
-0.0579085574,
0.0380492993,
0.0198104437,
-0.0015226314,
-0.0157842208,
0.0129559208,
0.0049552019,
-0.0536020994,
0.026865419,
-0.0328867771,
0.0263120309,
0.0481584631,
0.042134326,
0.0333725139,
0.0824985802,
0.0347517505,
0.0237491652,
0.0181112681,
-0.0499292873,
0.0059778485,
0.0057456829,
0.0395943709,
0.0072589479,
0.0373592451,
-0.0080328956,
-0.0668488592,
0.0059473966,
-0.036918506,
0.0289806612,
0.0150646036,
0.0199376661,
0.0480311513,
0.0067331204,
0.0278640743,
0.0113091143,
0.0053617093,
0.0405611731,
-0.0071740127,
-0.0462065153,
-0.0230159219,
0.0403354131,
-0.0293814316,
-0.0108391065,
0.0462225899,
0.038770359,
-0.0411089584,
-0.0568937548,
-0.0027717915,
0.0051794616,
0.0271750316,
-0.0052578826,
0.0449071564,
-0.0256774966,
-0.0245231744,
0.0590271354,
0.0384310707,
-0.0395860896,
0.0105148815,
-0.0478573367,
0.0203504562,
0.0484240651,
0.0274805371,
-0.0373339504,
-0.0144493496,
-0.053694915,
0.0512245595,
0.0143151889,
-0.0029196723,
-0.0034477091,
0.0143482359,
-0.0241567176,
-0.0456766076,
-0.0211095605,
0.0285341796,
-0.0397610664,
0.0297972169,
0.0378995538,
0.0073662037,
-0.0287886765,
-0.0584965833,
0.0099057714,
-0.0174762085,
-0.0151273385,
0.005005829,
0.0205165874,
0.031416744,
0.0754689947,
0.0280070305,
0.0200919602,
0.0297094621,
-0.0474241823,
-0.033814799,
-0.0213054232,
0.0319900326,
-0.0246808305,
0.0354044326,
-0.0377536826,
0.0073286318,
0.0263261795,
-0.0763024092,
-0.005957643,
0.0423581302,
-0.0533735678,
0.0623558536,
-0.0164669286,
-0.0036578344,
-0.0004867899,
0.0200125556,
-0.0074951858,
0.0594347194,
-0.023518594,
-0.0337066129,
-0.0275040325,
-0.0621090308,
-0.0194132552,
-0.0324126258,
0.0226238538,
-0.0436659493,
-0.0049269204,
0.020503439,
0.023150038,
-0.022980528,
-0.0447379276,
0.0080520539,
-0.093572706,
0.0112659251,
-0.0229661558,
0.0203247964,
-0.0032845803,
0.0553561971,
-0.0104106935,
-0.0219174381,
-0.0082167294,
-0.0273220334,
-0.0011543456,
0.033331383,
0.0309164729,
0.0302624702,
-0.006633745,
-0.0248750877,
0.018913798,
-0.0478705727,
0.0187586565,
0.0476030782,
-0.0755093917,
-0.0024413266,
-0.0061844997,
-0.0375687853,
-0.027017042,
0.0037829548,
-0.0340225324,
-0.0099444035,
0.0118011488,
-0.0157214347,
-0.0285755992,
0.0271889642,
0.0336681418,
0.0315375552,
0.0350033231,
-0.0338991173,
0.0218983795,
-0.0507699028,
0.0045030164,
0.0001752587,
-0.0366173498,
0.0207975768,
0.0720031112,
-0.0216739122,
0.0107668089,
-0.0189455394,
-0.00744113,
-0.0009959412,
0.0196635406,
-0.045420032,
-0.0176573936,
-0.0088633122,
0.0282474868,
-0.0279896129,
-0.0487516895,
0.0415033698,
0.0107504576,
0.0282352101,
-0.0556957759,
-0.0438007675,
-0.0452684723,
0.0112110963,
0.0020594348,
0.02875017,
0.0147744846,
-0.002318003,
0.0714706704,
-0.0476861745,
-0.0145430118,
-0.0446143262,
0.035226956,
0.0074608792,
0.0123725459,
0.0068222461,
-0.0506334081,
-0.0281997696,
-0.1065973639,
-0.0698811561,
-0.0153608238,
-0.0602603629,
-0.011247511,
-0.0370923057,
0.0266987421,
-0.0181520432,
-0.0014126273,
0.0107315369,
-0.0208612029,
0.027854681,
0.003965199,
0.0472346954,
-0.0170252509,
-0.0222808775,
-0.017524099,
0.0357720479,
0.027019944,
0.0102401637,
0.0225535836,
-0.0476861745,
0.0016733223,
-0.0306949448,
-0.0126017844,
0.0116079217,
0.0151655162,
0.045952674,
-0.0309443157,
0.057676699,
0.0990879387,
0.0199729446,
-0.0215311609,
0.0356311686,
-0.0069554802,
-0.0401348025,
-0.0073171235,
0.0131011363,
-0.0928454995,
-0.0317203663,
-0.0190770719,
0.014951352,
-0.0114958286,
-0.0300595742,
0.0157784391,
-0.0578165799,
0.0537780747,
0.0232325681,
-0.0281057954,
-0.0411189571,
-0.0958533138,
0.0163057595,
-0.0517913438,
0.0163140837,
-0.0548767447,
-0.0047767791,
0.0103695206,
0.0465163402,
-0.0371232964,
-0.1025884897,
-0.0147341732,
-0.0515398085,
0.0575535633,
0.0506453961,
0.0759076104,
-0.0252379887,
-0.0151000535,
0.0349203274,
0.0581764691,
0.0137104671,
-0.0125897313,
0.0948787779,
0.0069296365,
-0.0087620215,
-0.0640058443,
0.0385297202,
-0.0363448039,
-0.0517031513,
0.0165625047,
0.1030677557,
-0.0306871478,
-0.017489532,
-0.0486534238,
0.0250860564,
0.0401280262,
0.0487810634,
0.0545948446,
0.0166017748,
0.0077000111,
-0.0265431907,
0.0026789685,
-0.0444382094,
0.0106117046,
0.0046496782,
-0.0341336876,
-0.0833449736,
-0.0061159567,
-0.0063219629,
0.0720349103,
-0.040196687,
-0.0239677429,
0.0109575875,
0.0281547252,
-0.0053506703,
-0.0508929044,
0.0615721568,
0.0120622749,
0.0535560846,
-0.0042992518,
-0.0670464635,
0.0246961713,
0.0081526218,
0.0086570652,
0.0136668608,
-0.0586387254,
-0.0642721951,
-0.0044274116,
0.0011644432,
0.0223820042,
0.0330471359,
-0.0106323855,
-0.0478013828,
0.0473578796,
0.0837678611,
-0.0384344012,
-0.0589269847,
-0.0014157116,
0.0100438446,
0.0189789552,
0.0186461229,
-0.0109044788,
-0.0247336198,
-0.0064525092,
0.0321500786,
-0.0829236284,
0.0195503309,
-0.0028416831,
0.0023992385,
0.0841245949,
0.0054889265,
-0.0564761385,
-0.0599348545,
-0.0059101535,
0.0262117758,
-0.0111024268,
-0.0222686939,
0.023363322,
0.0165684652,
-0.0058090333,
-0.0358756706,
0.0491632782,
-0.0492606498,
-0.0001699078,
-0.0641871542,
0.0888047591,
-0.0002071213,
0.0291409176,
0.0369913429,
-0.0014377339,
-0.0012865881,
0.0116843171,
0.0351285674,
0.0146014327,
-0.004683828,
0.0140908668,
-0.0183306448,
0.0549330898,
-0.0082717733,
0.0385572463,
-0.0158096012,
-0.0181056391,
-0.0260627139,
0.0347255766,
0.0312558673,
-0.0314971507,
0.0569784418,
-0.0041670585,
-0.0125005264,
-0.0096463077,
0.0410212837,
-0.0474004224,
-0.0349452756,
0.0411792919,
-0.0113600856,
-0.0308316536,
0.0012438908,
0.0905787572,
-0.0139960842,
0.0385832004,
0.0234502796,
-0.0285425074,
-0.0090555232,
-0.0044149128,
0.0533163734,
0.0596695468,
-0.0263584964,
0.0289724432,
-0.0187369362,
-0.0726535991,
-0.0107649192,
-0.1046615914,
-0.0393250324,
-0.0137245702,
0.0027631936,
0.0428060964,
0.0069089639,
-0.0138015645,
-0.0606227033,
-0.0050663371,
-0.0243717767,
-0.0270634796,
0.0184629653,
-6.770317754e-33,
0.0181609076,
-0.0402184762,
0.012991216,
-0.0306491144,
-0.0034343239,
0.0288473889,
-0.0528010949,
-0.027718382,
0.0072771902,
0.0300705153,
0.0143073695,
0.0168738663,
0.0122516351,
0.0143608227,
0.019276971,
-0.0212940313,
0.0190835185,
0.0142568825,
-0.0173130333,
0.0482116602,
0.0093427822,
0.0492864475,
0.027942501,
-0.0886613354,
0.0130881444,
0.0214764159,
-0.0112251164,
0.0034218479,
0.0225386638,
0.0648228973,
-0.0134800486,
0.0679013953,
0.0553243347,
-0.034397617,
0.0082348511,
0.0641558766,
-0.042961251,
-0.0489240363,
0.0043111607,
-0.0285387486,
-0.029508248,
-0.031450294,
0.0469282754,
0.0127462,
-0.0047604362,
0.0025101511,
0.0405884683,
-0.0369764045,
0.0253661182,
-0.019859042,
-0.029081298,
0.03956604,
-0.0630503669,
-0.0122565441,
-0.0202362388,
0.0044456115,
-0.015754357,
0.0421545953,
-0.0474554896,
0.0180915408,
0.039348308,
-0.012231092,
0.020813277,
0.026744524,
-0.0194862727,
0.03206883,
-0.0133292628,
0.0057057058,
-0.0577057377,
0.0408442877,
-0.0493314043,
0.0470566228,
0.0232880544,
0.0216460116,
0.0043969951,
-0.0062115872,
-0.1056757867,
0.064401269,
0.0266410057,
0.0237904973,
0.0088118864,
0.0060460684,
-0.0419145674,
-0.0266878717,
-0.0056613912,
-0.0130387684,
-0.0309577864,
-0.0349603966,
-0.0184497908,
0.0111504011,
-0.0234406311,
0.0586316809,
-0.0337002054,
-0.041379787,
-0.0522005819,
0.0146202566,
0.0441033728,
-0.0352242626,
-0.0024228611,
-0.0064879828,
-0.0576849766,
0.0013826477,
-0.0088037783,
0.0312840268,
0.0209735446,
-0.0200006329,
0.0412442125,
0.0057071303,
-0.0362081714,
-0.0180593431,
-0.0267674495,
0.005140991,
-0.016210055,
0.0177252423,
-0.0127890659,
0.0164397396,
-0.0134550249,
0.0913696513,
0.0020446377,
0.0241537839,
0.0028283051,
-0.0113522625,
-0.0396527573,
-0.0017616386,
-0.0174925756,
-0.0207234751,
-0.0195387416,
-0.0060381889,
0.0431734025,
-0.0695761293,
-0.0263047647,
-0.0729821846,
2.888e-7,
0.087951839,
0.0500274748,
-0.0111393211,
-0.0428308137,
0.009775511,
0.0364267975,
-0.0066310312,
0.0187368598,
-0.002851909,
0.0291729029,
0.0124584977,
0.0349430256,
0.0069924523,
0.0354127698,
-0.0550037548,
0.0041054608,
-0.106921792,
-0.0250136387,
-0.068168737,
0.0131780989,
-0.0020192012,
0.0770378038,
0.0199806057,
-0.0363708362,
0.0179634914,
-0.0568845719,
0.0239164941,
-0.0307545774,
-0.036784865,
0.0297416691,
-0.0054985536,
0.0369116813,
0.014432543,
-0.0171830412,
-0.0465966687,
0.0018424841,
-0.0260163452,
0.0579029731,
-0.02819217,
0.0155198602,
0.0189144555,
-0.047315523,
0.0077555715,
-0.0434471592,
0.0751061141,
-0.0576563925,
-0.0900638551,
-0.0327069983,
0.0060849017,
-0.0034152276,
0.018328391,
-0.0159285869,
-0.0172766037,
0.0024489698,
-0.0057223015,
-0.0209221356,
-0.0407928899,
-0.0783334598,
-0.0107825371,
-0.0137523701,
-0.0206050668,
-0.039994318,
-0.009778386,
0.0027686837,
0.0208185241,
-0.0555200949,
0.0782723799,
2.230099669e-34,
0.0270579644,
0.0163792782,
0.012702086,
-0.0095944926,
0.0302241687,
0.0121795153,
-0.0304877572,
0.0017445178,
0.0127919819,
-0.0576139465,
0.0119675482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04198v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04198v3 | Don't Ignore Dual Logic Ability of LLMs while Privatizing: A Data-Intensive Analysis in Medical Domain | 2023-09-08T08:20:46 | 2024-02-23T11:58:10 | Yanrui Du, Sendong Zhao, Muzhen Cai, Ming Ma, Danyang Zhao, Jiawei Cao, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Extensive studies have been devoted to privatizing general-domain Large
Language Models (LLMs) as Domain-Specific LLMs via feeding specific-domain
data. However, these privatization efforts often ignored a critical aspect:
Dual Logic Ability, which is a core reasoning ability for LLMs. The dual logic
ability of LLMs ensures that they can maintain a consistent stance when
confronted with both positive and negative statements about the same fact. Our
study focuses on how the dual logic ability of LLMs is affected during the
privatization process in the medical domain. We conduct several experiments to
analyze the dual logic ability of LLMs by examining the consistency of the
stance in responses to paired questions about the same fact. In our
experiments, interestingly, we observed a significant decrease in the dual
logic ability of existing LLMs after privatization. Besides, our results
indicate that incorporating general domain dual logic data into LLMs not only
enhances LLMs' dual logic ability but also further improves their accuracy.
These findings underscore the importance of prioritizing LLMs' dual logic
ability during the privatization process. Our study establishes a benchmark for
future research aimed at exploring LLMs' dual logic ability during the
privatization process and offers valuable guidance for privatization efforts in
real-world applications. | [
0.0228973217,
0.0716072544,
-0.0278348085,
0.0083007161,
-0.0641303435,
0.0136584444,
0.0146428375,
0.010390983,
0.0124102002,
-0.0457650013,
-0.0193442889,
-0.0394878238,
-0.0244954284,
0.0319663137,
-0.0033118189,
-0.0043685897,
0.0576231144,
-0.0289260373,
0.0333169736,
-0.0462843888,
-0.0116677443,
0.0119341407,
-0.0158816166,
-0.0068566897,
0.0389712714,
-0.0196438096,
0.0125275953,
-0.0158395693,
0.0043439483,
-0.0769372955,
-0.033884719,
0.0357414559,
0.0210675448,
0.0025581548,
0.0000020003,
-0.1002332121,
-0.0489162542,
0.0113350712,
-0.03933708,
0.0106372433,
0.0263701901,
-0.00135385,
0.0142136151,
0.0265910141,
-0.0678403452,
-0.01661749,
0.0054209353,
0.0568169504,
0.0283709522,
0.0532612242,
-0.0005622736,
-0.0339419693,
0.0076322178,
-0.0292532276,
-0.048125118,
-0.0667038262,
0.0527613908,
0.0374100693,
0.0007957998,
-0.0129793081,
0.0122346254,
0.0404193364,
0.024201598,
0.0342531055,
-0.0453657918,
0.0184875,
-0.0225307588,
-0.0041482262,
0.0141731696,
0.0305291805,
0.0978002027,
0.0167243257,
0.0272711478,
-0.0047328393,
0.0391131938,
0.002100223,
-0.0433609262,
0.0504916161,
-0.0157512501,
0.0222936533,
0.0395348184,
-0.0285317339,
0.02426452,
-0.0041342541,
-0.0692247748,
0.0979519784,
-0.0076890434,
-0.0728965998,
0.0251080729,
-0.0069848541,
-0.0254177824,
-0.0334674679,
-0.0032425597,
0.0323046856,
-0.0265838169,
0.0300844237,
-0.0198319517,
0.001502896,
0.0484577753,
-0.0477143973,
-0.0087699471,
0.0007061852,
0.0052441182,
0.029488897,
-0.0288221128,
0.0203129258,
-0.0555750728,
0.0724296495,
-0.0257666763,
0.0214195903,
-0.0339512788,
-0.0256591272,
0.0306384172,
0.0783185214,
0.0020827865,
0.0006904835,
-0.0802384987,
-0.0077045551,
-0.0175204966,
0.0287236124,
-0.0369829834,
0.0065604686,
0.0164834987,
-0.0460862331,
-0.0679116473,
0.0214748345,
-0.0112926103,
0.0646280795,
-0.0126625309,
-0.0653871596,
0.0291767213,
-0.0074075097,
-0.001460553,
0.0160214398,
0.0048481319,
0.0672490075,
-0.0159977078,
0.0239631664,
-0.084173508,
-0.0450349487,
-0.021896312,
-0.0807560012,
0.0209679529,
-0.0488636456,
-0.0057757297,
0.0385668948,
-0.0039179134,
-0.0838012099,
0.0050192047,
-0.0136011504,
-0.0335553661,
0.064697884,
-0.0204117652,
0.0321010575,
0.0201095566,
0.0285755042,
0.0006950673,
0.069601804,
-0.0085709775,
-0.0560902432,
0.0096832467,
-0.0165994838,
-0.0186649449,
0.015848957,
0.0072175013,
0.0010774854,
-0.0347949266,
0.0624989606,
-0.0146880029,
0.0436107628,
0.0108610969,
0.0646088347,
-0.0136059495,
0.0229570232,
0.0670244396,
0.0360611267,
0.0369738638,
-0.0079456922,
-0.0176370144,
-0.0067784055,
-0.0086371573,
0.0045913751,
-0.0275849886,
0.0009977254,
0.0176404938,
0.0125205731,
-0.0104397396,
0.0052071116,
-0.0183425192,
-0.0532644205,
-0.0354460515,
-0.0058439733,
0.0153851639,
0.0273979381,
0.0531224944,
-0.0239459779,
-0.0311584938,
0.105196543,
0.0011450717,
-0.029515747,
-0.0307494588,
-0.08433038,
-0.0100286752,
0.0189009998,
0.0158559959,
-0.0353831202,
-0.048790127,
-0.0293703321,
-0.0279031899,
0.0428476706,
0.0740474537,
0.0108630676,
-0.0392625928,
-0.0502641276,
0.0023878256,
-0.0241073463,
0.015684532,
0.0035028558,
-0.0165114608,
0.0342934094,
-0.0189592149,
-0.0073484196,
0.041249536,
0.0255050212,
-0.0638095289,
0.0134199485,
-0.031185437,
-0.0046729939,
0.049684763,
0.0023561595,
0.0147480927,
0.0471620001,
0.0362198241,
-0.0011881375,
-0.0207419563,
-0.0171400681,
-0.0500973091,
0.0246190373,
0.0247780681,
0.0078173196,
-0.0302828606,
0.0234144926,
0.0113230981,
-0.0070701172,
-0.0000857748,
-0.0092722969,
0.0305140913,
-0.0164465457,
0.0353581607,
-0.04158777,
-0.0213623233,
-0.0486605242,
0.0375482589,
-0.0271321014,
0.005121341,
0.0151220355,
-0.0588334017,
0.0163559727,
-0.0431790426,
-0.00588554,
0.0163502228,
-0.0227902681,
0.0234384388,
-0.0114825256,
-0.0338273942,
-0.0519162491,
-0.0084037548,
-0.0629876107,
-0.0128989881,
0.0132055394,
0.0131461676,
0.0108736698,
-0.0354514569,
-0.0001365888,
0.0366290659,
-0.0303649567,
0.0121641327,
0.043292962,
0.058458019,
0.0301512629,
0.014317858,
-0.0133884586,
-0.002330248,
-0.0009529923,
-0.0479264259,
-0.0059071952,
0.0025399921,
0.0463165604,
-0.0538748428,
0.0487715006,
-0.0297903996,
-0.0030256747,
-0.0175163634,
-0.0226971786,
0.0415063575,
0.0065460699,
-0.0244999398,
0.0699668378,
-0.0308892541,
0.0021908446,
0.0649792552,
-0.0056538191,
-0.0463114828,
-0.0036362149,
0.0033813671,
-0.0144323893,
-0.0784808174,
-0.0378644764,
0.0047507486,
0.0556800626,
0.014085249,
0.0049991435,
-0.0123634022,
0.0032960305,
-0.067192331,
-0.0420593098,
0.0290465001,
-0.0211908016,
-0.0329578668,
0.0913884938,
0.0453887582,
-0.0335398391,
0.0757670254,
0.0309879538,
0.0135501903,
-0.0536001325,
-0.0055496483,
-0.0674281791,
0.0425982922,
-0.065181464,
0.0026097116,
0.0262772311,
-0.0356037989,
-0.0523643196,
-0.0271573551,
-0.0006271821,
-0.0522704683,
0.116654858,
-0.0581850447,
-0.0039337701,
-0.0006704237,
-0.0517889932,
-0.0474640951,
0.0200948548,
-0.055269435,
-0.0094491262,
0.0300262906,
0.0007430635,
-0.0400402769,
-0.024114009,
0.0147587545,
-0.0030584112,
0.014195784,
-0.0093082758,
0.0057250955,
-0.056408383,
0.0090113981,
0.0172628537,
0.0459209718,
-0.0453471467,
0.0271704737,
0.0445216037,
0.0456154235,
-0.0025949155,
-0.0191116184,
-0.0128350491,
0.0261511523,
0.0007821879,
-0.0167757347,
0.0317178406,
0.0219487306,
-0.0333566777,
0.0172683001,
0.100508213,
-0.0022411954,
0.0045953812,
0.0083505595,
-0.0467278808,
-0.021207042,
0.035278473,
-0.0028135329,
-0.0520869456,
-0.0102126729,
0.0032822639,
0.0260424837,
-0.0328772552,
-0.0374384187,
-0.0033987348,
-0.0978294611,
0.0306981243,
-0.0104272077,
-0.0028677995,
-0.0026140017,
-0.0111370878,
0.0284704641,
-0.0219058003,
0.023202695,
0.0231924336,
-0.03114371,
-0.030905135,
-0.0026830651,
-0.0436417982,
-0.0388117842,
0.0321175978,
-0.0014468825,
0.0267880913,
0.0198898222,
0.0037028899,
-0.0538525879,
-0.0381949767,
0.0626682937,
0.034249723,
-0.0080366256,
-0.0128202662,
0.0139896935,
0.0276087485,
0.0248705223,
-0.0445322283,
0.0174775291,
-0.0134762153,
-0.008538831,
0.0102185765,
0.0551944748,
-0.0194470864,
-0.0611332878,
-0.0242690444,
0.0276741795,
-0.0334089957,
0.0784147754,
-0.0071314601,
-0.0218962785,
0.001674103,
0.0035217276,
-0.040911302,
0.011590464,
-0.0468499251,
0.0531072803,
-0.0084249582,
0.0131027848,
-0.033026237,
-0.0229473878,
0.0210803561,
0.0087809665,
-0.0019333061,
0.0475737303,
0.0648832098,
0.0044213817,
-0.0205679946,
0.0064170472,
-0.0116430409,
0.0211939141,
-0.0654486269,
0.0288672261,
0.0346391834,
0.0146644497,
-0.0260413382,
-0.0127424598,
-0.0076957741,
-0.0502675883,
0.0436483584,
-0.0067630829,
0.0411793068,
-0.0193468072,
0.0293761902,
-0.0169072784,
0.0146510359,
0.0341784991,
-0.0507407151,
0.0339750238,
0.037365824,
0.0210415944,
-0.0022973206,
0.0295474734,
-0.0148179941,
-0.0129589969,
0.0187436994,
0.0167392567,
-0.0343967937,
-0.0046850508,
0.0225016605,
0.0701582879,
0.0302162394,
0.0092183147,
-0.0064938334,
-0.0156621616,
0.0209644064,
-0.0409413502,
-0.0165571105,
-0.0144057209,
-0.0052786497,
0.0451294556,
-0.0043989015,
-0.0049896012,
-0.0283676796,
-0.0169512108,
0.0173416846,
-0.0075110933,
0.0433166921,
0.0117108403,
0.0029310577,
0.0659362376,
-0.0311795063,
-0.0098021496,
0.025249904,
-0.0086780824,
0.0267170314,
0.0184646714,
0.1001180038,
0.0265521798,
0.0080143744,
-0.0221819002,
0.0015554742,
-0.0235372707,
-0.1074105501,
0.0697143897,
0.0087193632,
-0.0132260229,
0.0247129835,
0.0507705584,
-0.0342926942,
0.0127052041,
-0.0254435875,
-0.0094654402,
-0.0104252091,
-0.0031991797,
0.084126927,
0.0153862452,
-0.0254034568,
-0.0126045533,
0.0711989254,
0.0002955574,
0.0408123247,
-0.079979144,
-0.0040526874,
-0.0315043107,
-0.0572297759,
0.0376832932,
0.0074974485,
-0.0441571027,
0.0107015055,
-0.1228628978,
-0.0452946126,
0.0060389084,
-0.0206859894,
-0.0208929125,
-0.0601673238,
-0.0055096322,
0.0969319046,
0.0132296896,
-0.0583910421,
-0.0225645974,
0.0359171033,
-0.010951316,
-0.0130804991,
-0.0167196039,
-6.159902272e-33,
0.0189367291,
-0.0085493699,
0.0364930443,
-0.0549915843,
-0.0264796671,
-0.0040963353,
0.0108815134,
0.0549966916,
-0.0421776585,
0.014513365,
-0.0223935191,
0.0246924739,
0.0164209418,
-0.0166719481,
0.0347486958,
-0.0496107414,
0.0117984805,
0.0140283406,
0.0022685183,
-0.0257267412,
-0.0270576663,
-0.0131366691,
0.0316814072,
-0.0792413652,
0.050742887,
-0.0032660312,
0.024384439,
0.0076649012,
-0.06770733,
0.0617523268,
0.0194066968,
0.0162124261,
0.043759916,
-0.0729022399,
-0.0088746473,
0.0469024666,
0.0099324388,
0.0122491578,
0.0652118474,
-0.0176992007,
-0.0119063063,
-0.0335581973,
0.0476705953,
0.0258494355,
-0.0406975709,
-0.028703995,
-0.0068263654,
-0.0364567712,
0.0241145156,
0.0188370664,
-0.0514379293,
0.0240075495,
-0.000682376,
0.0313632637,
-0.0153593039,
-0.004577558,
-0.0445013829,
0.0227733683,
-0.0232756473,
0.0270610619,
0.0061854203,
-0.0126159396,
0.0661505759,
-0.0198974609,
-0.003543742,
0.0564141609,
-0.0156411119,
0.0622473434,
-0.0225831904,
-0.0044414937,
-0.0000969138,
0.08904735,
0.0176883824,
0.0429083779,
-0.0149435364,
-0.0128477868,
-0.099247925,
-0.0063340389,
-0.0405789316,
0.0503368564,
0.0440174267,
0.0280360524,
-0.0245171245,
-0.0131932562,
-0.0446041673,
0.0561724268,
-0.0128875468,
-0.0055560945,
0.0266003143,
-0.00576348,
-0.0309008714,
0.018844815,
0.0337892286,
-0.0165538657,
-0.039259728,
-0.0366588198,
-0.0008523579,
0.0037645518,
-0.0164361913,
0.0556901246,
-0.0764045268,
0.0099221189,
-0.0126813473,
0.0084442161,
0.0523754358,
0.0330115817,
0.0006723042,
-0.0431698374,
-0.0709776655,
-0.0050149783,
-0.0126873385,
-0.0143149151,
0.0143924188,
-0.0252371803,
0.0375484303,
0.0291114841,
0.0253896788,
0.0376111865,
-0.0024282874,
-0.0306193382,
-0.0824120194,
0.0078362338,
0.0011034403,
0.0254646894,
-0.0332517922,
-0.0129714934,
-0.0351059251,
0.0237951688,
0.037012957,
-0.0331700556,
-0.0403394587,
0.0028162084,
2.852e-7,
0.0718121678,
0.055087693,
-0.0276070535,
0.0493257083,
0.0218167938,
0.0789417401,
-0.0237450916,
-0.0136186434,
0.0403816849,
-0.041009672,
-0.0045040008,
0.0195588041,
0.0096144611,
0.0390004739,
-0.0378249809,
-0.0270058755,
-0.0233984031,
-0.0026136646,
-0.0456537083,
0.0319747254,
0.0610207655,
0.0088094296,
-0.001210546,
-0.0009900158,
0.0059662582,
-0.0384683535,
0.0430293009,
-0.0199570637,
-0.0058499938,
0.0446824692,
0.0090503572,
-0.0026084832,
0.0098961862,
0.0564637147,
0.0324811935,
-0.0092215324,
-0.0080225095,
0.0888508335,
-0.0158674177,
-0.0054490543,
0.0248014405,
-0.0413786769,
-0.0081009092,
-0.0449115187,
0.062646918,
-0.0867378339,
-0.0557261221,
-0.0430107638,
-0.013143803,
-0.0432674475,
0.0553981327,
0.0141807161,
0.0079553323,
0.02647865,
0.0068044551,
0.0026666014,
-0.004605866,
-0.0388453752,
-0.0022967132,
0.0191976354,
-0.0493774153,
-0.0672715828,
0.004997619,
0.0160732046,
0.0458961688,
-0.0716757774,
0.0051192329,
2.548424687e-34,
0.0412311442,
0.0093919765,
0.0164005458,
0.0306134019,
0.0529369712,
0.007604714,
-0.0376131944,
0.0289832354,
-0.0219558664,
-0.0813990757,
0.0204451364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04175v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04175v1 | Knowledge-tuning Large Language Models with Structured Medical Knowledge Bases for Reliable Response Generation in Chinese | 2023-09-08T07:42:57 | 2023-09-08T07:42:57 | Haochun Wang, Sendong Zhao, Zewen Qiang, Zijian Li, Nuwa Xi, Yanrui Du, MuZhen Cai, Haoqiang Guo, Yuhan Chen, Haoming Xu, Bing Qin, Ting Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable success in diverse
natural language processing (NLP) tasks in general domains. However, LLMs
sometimes generate responses with the hallucination about medical facts due to
limited domain knowledge. Such shortcomings pose potential risks in the
utilization of LLMs within medical contexts. To address this challenge, we
propose knowledge-tuning, which leverages structured medical knowledge bases
for the LLMs to grasp domain knowledge efficiently and facilitate reliable
response generation. We also release cMedKnowQA, a Chinese medical knowledge
question-answering dataset constructed from medical knowledge bases to assess
the medical knowledge proficiency of LLMs. Experimental results show that the
LLMs which are knowledge-tuned with cMedKnowQA, can exhibit higher levels of
accuracy in response generation compared with vanilla instruction-tuning and
offer a new reliable way for the domain adaptation of LLMs. | [
0.0709881112,
0.0168652199,
0.0096804807,
0.0054813097,
-0.0068165837,
0.0103052594,
0.0046182941,
0.0344877616,
0.0368612222,
-0.0398282558,
-0.02498197,
-0.0605217889,
-0.0152496807,
0.0115488842,
0.0094909742,
-0.0373094715,
0.0273264851,
0.0173906926,
0.0219959412,
-0.006211672,
-0.0159832574,
0.0146810375,
-0.0506385863,
0.0429407097,
0.0391663983,
-0.0311570503,
0.0322557725,
-0.0008544911,
0.0108931568,
-0.0738337263,
0.0387542173,
0.043865107,
-0.0160508323,
-0.0091047473,
0.0000018726,
-0.0616729781,
0.0016610282,
0.0080991499,
-0.0416940898,
-0.0135693634,
0.0092559652,
-0.0369136594,
0.0171565358,
0.0288625248,
-0.0668744072,
-0.024569476,
0.0264274906,
0.0714682117,
0.0519055575,
0.077993162,
0.0026448115,
-0.0050310353,
0.0056907977,
-0.0160809923,
0.0217590872,
-0.0516338535,
0.0520127378,
0.0486320034,
0.0363221578,
-0.0013942542,
-0.0001761458,
0.0319893621,
-0.0218476765,
0.0284218322,
0.0166069418,
0.0348201767,
-0.0247549303,
0.0056714378,
0.007733596,
0.0931134969,
0.0254174564,
-0.0048034675,
0.0043592355,
-0.0115774246,
-0.0108622247,
0.02969997,
-0.0417582989,
-0.0011419841,
-0.0228693988,
-0.0232502315,
-0.0013024075,
-0.0339078344,
0.0247388929,
0.026371384,
-0.0189986229,
0.040009398,
0.014285991,
-0.0225869641,
-0.0089163547,
-0.0161879864,
-0.0259388853,
-0.0421248451,
0.0326640196,
0.0761644989,
-0.0599789731,
0.0301601533,
-0.0254675616,
0.0000306207,
0.0593913682,
-0.048966065,
-0.005094735,
0.0245382767,
0.0009544593,
0.025862515,
-0.0247924589,
0.0208999868,
-0.0381787531,
-0.0034350029,
-0.0545700938,
-0.0010851868,
-0.0739100575,
-0.0339504443,
-0.0057572783,
0.0240952671,
-0.0387823544,
0.0051176818,
-0.0526889898,
0.0202030763,
0.0053390237,
-0.0085265636,
0.0048133084,
0.0548410006,
-0.0333300568,
-0.0262864232,
-0.0597152412,
0.070063673,
-0.0162222758,
0.0305138044,
0.0039018691,
-0.0390087292,
-0.0109312991,
0.0058496962,
0.0084792608,
-0.0188715346,
0.0359698795,
0.0583620444,
0.0026729829,
0.0127754342,
-0.0104109971,
-0.0470353849,
-0.0468970835,
-0.038261231,
0.0186859109,
-0.0538940057,
0.0319100581,
0.0432500355,
-0.0044919597,
-0.0464331508,
0.0260250103,
0.0203997865,
-0.0630534291,
0.0431012809,
-0.0304812118,
0.0267755203,
0.0033329031,
0.0430703387,
-0.014453453,
0.0356559679,
0.0047318311,
-0.0734960958,
0.0057996139,
-0.018425975,
-0.0091664251,
-0.0275672972,
0.0285273828,
-0.0152418194,
0.0141007826,
0.036034774,
-0.0069222795,
0.0646434873,
-0.0028693224,
0.0371039212,
-0.0129854633,
0.0079816738,
0.0174410678,
0.0267635714,
0.0155716529,
0.0209124573,
0.0181483552,
-0.0285503585,
0.0207510907,
0.0086836293,
-0.0202305857,
0.0238124933,
-0.0209705904,
0.0241156649,
-0.0231475215,
0.0187690333,
-0.043701537,
-0.0296706911,
-0.0333062597,
0.0216045547,
-0.0332247205,
0.0244984515,
0.0268020816,
0.0131006418,
-0.0244354047,
0.0870119706,
0.0414397866,
-0.0232965928,
0.0138055999,
-0.0518346243,
0.0064217839,
0.085837923,
0.0569826141,
-0.0414647087,
-0.0683694109,
0.0007203799,
0.0159665514,
0.0463761725,
0.0429465026,
-0.0319399647,
-0.0078363037,
-0.0377958454,
-0.0044882409,
0.02622848,
0.0086677214,
-0.0228993949,
0.029100813,
0.0282292943,
0.0037447719,
-0.023687534,
-0.0078602647,
0.0299083237,
-0.0630668551,
-0.0217355993,
0.0136243105,
-0.0099111982,
0.0261796415,
0.0248646177,
-0.0117197074,
0.0485265404,
0.0248117484,
-0.0338707939,
-0.0355019979,
-0.0049380418,
-0.0625658557,
-0.0824711621,
0.0365024917,
-0.0096826088,
-0.0191869754,
-0.0236859675,
-0.0567525476,
-0.0447033904,
-0.0189269111,
-0.0083068656,
0.0495810993,
-0.0289519578,
0.0163493026,
0.0445022099,
0.0019957491,
-0.0544975288,
0.0455309227,
-0.0059480178,
0.0331053697,
0.0473104157,
-0.0097537348,
-0.0209687967,
-0.02327119,
-0.0208250098,
0.0069745956,
0.007981658,
0.0193423182,
0.0071217422,
0.0235102866,
-0.0504891127,
-0.0264093317,
-0.0915120542,
0.0190799888,
-0.008565627,
0.0191883743,
0.0542458519,
0.02535557,
-0.0039737565,
-0.0082620764,
-0.0776793808,
0.0087000448,
0.0309645366,
0.0185974147,
0.0293999184,
0.0190529246,
0.0113122305,
-0.0017829783,
0.0179491807,
-0.0350162424,
-0.0004436262,
0.0023697887,
0.0011058956,
-0.0380380712,
0.0253816079,
-0.0473285429,
-0.0042918776,
0.0059457393,
-0.013403954,
0.0014309455,
0.0033966161,
0.0016505201,
0.0461535715,
0.0047254963,
-0.0213403665,
0.0473440289,
0.0209662747,
-0.026897328,
0.0281869527,
-0.0348300934,
-0.0397842452,
-0.0210627019,
-0.019102484,
-0.001382297,
0.0892729908,
0.040321853,
-0.0164124705,
-0.0518483222,
-0.0111819794,
-0.0152834859,
0.0042727315,
-0.0524977595,
0.0352548398,
-0.0309610311,
0.0226091817,
-0.0033369253,
0.004349309,
0.0907993317,
0.0124459593,
0.0293968469,
-0.081057772,
0.0142750833,
-0.0229689348,
0.0089012273,
-0.0115678748,
0.037800692,
0.016514523,
-0.0031784831,
-0.0535211079,
0.0235308055,
-0.0261512976,
-0.0655646771,
0.0499747433,
-0.0349314325,
0.017542528,
-0.0144378869,
-0.0324587263,
-0.079298906,
-0.0067529958,
-0.0223353375,
0.0111868223,
0.0059261988,
-0.001632386,
-0.0239451546,
0.0283726249,
0.0216154922,
0.0417542942,
0.0130091356,
-0.0047082263,
-0.0047004507,
0.0364779346,
0.0611505657,
0.0574395806,
0.0218565594,
0.0020076085,
0.0608639978,
0.0743376613,
0.0133038713,
0.0219381377,
0.0417720862,
0.0095009748,
0.0107996305,
-0.0312087275,
0.0185062662,
0.0407305807,
0.0366006829,
-0.0629972667,
-0.0244525261,
0.1320859045,
0.0360134915,
-0.0199050121,
0.0277601723,
-0.0152726928,
0.0105196135,
0.0198789686,
0.0279200822,
-0.0748810396,
-0.0298338477,
-0.0306829344,
0.0268405117,
-0.0098128095,
-0.0255480353,
0.0245059431,
-0.1044683009,
0.0101543358,
0.0091615906,
-0.045451384,
-0.0648194775,
-0.0202928763,
-0.0021185128,
0.0344510153,
0.0312942229,
0.0157866683,
-0.0091708433,
-0.0107334005,
0.0218627397,
-0.0358369872,
-0.1020218804,
0.0621693842,
-0.0053857584,
0.0888848454,
0.0632428974,
0.0403969884,
0.0112475967,
-0.018239731,
-0.0218760595,
0.0063017663,
0.0161928087,
-0.0066818143,
0.032504607,
0.0229647867,
-0.0012344489,
-0.0348509215,
0.0286543295,
-0.0777642801,
-0.0221243594,
0.0338786393,
0.0570147671,
-0.0313076302,
-0.0253647808,
-0.0212378055,
0.038998723,
0.0127415713,
0.0938077942,
0.0126928408,
-0.012059316,
-0.0033047956,
0.0123467278,
-0.0024496843,
-0.0400076248,
-0.0278804023,
0.0821658,
-0.020469375,
0.0321723185,
-0.1000319347,
-0.000199456,
0.0615835637,
-0.0287373737,
0.0110371774,
0.0334509276,
0.0137873981,
0.007819565,
-0.0464747325,
0.0229979288,
0.0020766577,
0.0006137259,
-0.0627439544,
-0.0523604155,
0.0612490252,
-0.0306733996,
-0.0019175716,
-0.0043201237,
-0.0300391987,
-0.0471866354,
-0.0240408592,
0.0352754928,
0.0127985738,
0.0303792376,
-0.0043709348,
-0.0075326478,
0.036344748,
0.0306508262,
-0.071678035,
-0.0027573542,
-0.0100353686,
0.005635831,
-0.025012929,
0.0306333024,
-0.0367487743,
-0.0000254499,
0.032302551,
0.0741126165,
-0.0039166776,
-0.0361132212,
0.0287699476,
0.0376904048,
-0.00198028,
-0.0017553525,
-0.0057368684,
-0.0214680377,
0.0496034212,
-0.024211077,
-0.0003354706,
-0.0242996383,
-0.0219040811,
0.0281605199,
-0.0463209152,
-0.003351216,
-0.0207143128,
-0.042750068,
-0.0231759287,
-0.0229940135,
0.0260320567,
0.0040018982,
0.0072145783,
0.0632358417,
-0.033950638,
-0.0220136363,
-0.0037858014,
0.0183355566,
0.0169510655,
0.0006482862,
0.0776485056,
-0.0075889067,
0.0121105993,
-0.0064982534,
0.0101541569,
-0.0523704216,
-0.0628771558,
-0.0256676432,
0.0152720977,
0.0424680077,
0.0052882121,
0.0365195349,
-0.0384963155,
-0.0102413297,
-0.0357142352,
0.0161564928,
-0.0165398177,
0.0250959564,
0.0690299049,
0.0139875393,
-0.0075931475,
-0.0308920071,
0.1061759964,
0.0203364808,
0.0639233291,
0.0191479344,
-0.0257132184,
-0.0342757478,
-0.0398644395,
-0.0068826047,
0.004446276,
-0.0658932179,
0.0576324686,
-0.0708089247,
-0.0810872018,
-0.000756113,
-0.0197275411,
-0.0330615789,
-0.0240067933,
0.0400476344,
0.0310023371,
0.0111620724,
-0.0341821425,
-0.0365120322,
0.0559521429,
-0.0383756198,
-0.0093849134,
-0.0070592151,
-6.474001342e-33,
-0.0189886745,
-0.0306185633,
0.0389122739,
-0.0417085141,
0.0050567202,
0.0060584387,
-0.0463233218,
0.0166152585,
-0.0291852169,
0.0095402757,
-0.0164690968,
0.0060125864,
-0.00177183,
0.0571454614,
-0.0180848129,
-0.0472371168,
0.0258079786,
0.0043793591,
-0.0100012524,
0.0419553109,
0.0103515638,
0.0470375903,
0.0314386077,
-0.0599345192,
0.0011970635,
-0.0009820949,
0.0443786494,
0.0110381721,
-0.032217741,
0.0762416795,
-0.0357168615,
0.0495885611,
0.0595763102,
-0.0151573922,
-0.0130378688,
-0.0030187538,
-0.0928562284,
-0.0183944702,
0.0250590816,
-0.0137147475,
-0.0332517698,
-0.0313042328,
0.0453593209,
-0.0109070865,
0.0177517403,
-0.0165733602,
0.0161815956,
-0.0611157641,
-0.0113745416,
-0.0413972735,
-0.0327144265,
0.0204193704,
0.0286531802,
-0.01189774,
-0.0792800561,
0.0111361463,
-0.0373342671,
0.0208190121,
-0.0295819361,
-0.0181080606,
0.0487676375,
0.0525746532,
0.0184528288,
0.0076761167,
0.0013991552,
0.0349723436,
-0.0197706409,
-0.0142917056,
-0.0185449887,
0.0177882314,
-0.0520253666,
0.0260355789,
0.01503901,
0.0583894104,
0.0103253881,
-0.0303398762,
-0.1160938218,
0.0239324123,
-0.0608881153,
0.0566804856,
0.034121383,
-0.0319551304,
-0.0289536137,
-0.0000207043,
-0.0234726761,
0.0466728099,
-0.0412058197,
-0.0364196487,
0.0371784456,
-0.0044945842,
-0.0214208663,
-0.0378084928,
0.0178424492,
-0.0413585491,
0.0168312266,
-0.0073285387,
0.0151657807,
-0.0176900849,
-0.0299029741,
0.0187398456,
-0.0715363473,
-0.0076731113,
0.0226433743,
-0.0488792062,
-0.0007124465,
0.0365423225,
0.0047964444,
-0.0439479686,
-0.0655571595,
-0.0063662166,
-0.0194114484,
-0.0007123647,
0.0094701033,
0.0544187576,
0.0081312703,
0.0300291851,
-0.0088881366,
0.0323019251,
-0.0024839127,
-0.0396219753,
-0.0414480902,
-0.0375903361,
0.0082922764,
0.0161273479,
-0.0557971261,
0.0219291616,
-0.0255717114,
0.0173312947,
0.0186487641,
-0.0509156324,
-0.0275434814,
-0.0139002958,
2.695e-7,
0.1005843505,
0.0389119908,
-0.0167430136,
0.0151584027,
0.0343866087,
-0.0003540317,
-0.0015420773,
0.0232810173,
0.0270572379,
-0.0405578353,
0.0200262237,
0.0200720858,
0.0339916945,
0.0104937973,
-0.0955848917,
0.0030872116,
-0.0362906381,
-0.0061152605,
0.0002920471,
-0.0482495315,
0.0378890783,
0.0728357732,
-0.0632489473,
-0.016513424,
0.0173997153,
-0.0291667823,
0.0607713051,
0.0043587228,
0.0006859117,
0.0558319129,
0.0368683264,
0.0138731273,
0.0265927352,
0.0757371187,
-0.0289607365,
-0.0155103188,
0.0052122246,
0.0984857976,
-0.0241601374,
-0.026938349,
-0.006815563,
-0.0181935634,
0.0471135378,
-0.0360598452,
0.0632579103,
-0.0785466656,
-0.0287685543,
0.0144925322,
0.012842292,
-0.0240814891,
0.0182143375,
-0.0307358038,
-0.0342402495,
0.0247392207,
0.0284867268,
0.0373429842,
-0.0074807969,
-0.0577996783,
-0.040226236,
0.0419749059,
-0.0492645539,
-0.0827352181,
0.0307890177,
-0.0568084903,
-0.0027083294,
-0.0789022371,
0.0085527552,
2.273271535e-34,
-0.0096018128,
0.0301329792,
-0.0044761291,
0.0441848189,
0.0229817517,
-0.0303685088,
0.0063043423,
0.016532395,
0.0320382565,
-0.0982307643,
-0.0239101294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04174v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04174v2 | Manifold-based Verbalizer Space Re-embedding for Tuning-free Prompt-based Classification | 2023-09-08T07:42:29 | 2024-01-29T12:31:57 | Haochun Wang, Sendong Zhao, Chi Liu, Nuwa Xi, Muzhen Cai, Bing Qin, Ting Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prompt-based classification adapts tasks to a cloze question format utilizing
the [MASK] token and the filled tokens are then mapped to labels through
pre-defined verbalizers. Recent studies have explored the use of verbalizer
embeddings to reduce labor in this process. However, all existing studies
require a tuning process for either the pre-trained models or additional
trainable embeddings. Meanwhile, the distance between high-dimensional
verbalizer embeddings should not be measured by Euclidean distance due to the
potential for non-linear manifolds in the representation space. In this study,
we propose a tuning-free manifold-based space re-embedding method called
Locally Linear Embedding with Intra-class Neighborhood Constraint (LLE-INC) for
verbalizer embeddings, which preserves local properties within the same class
as guidance for classification. Experimental results indicate that even without
tuning any parameters, our LLE-INC is on par with automated verbalizers with
parameter tuning. And with the parameter updating, our approach further
enhances prompt-based tuning by up to 3.2%. Furthermore, experiments with the
LLaMA-7B&13B indicate that LLE-INC is an efficient tuning-free classification
approach for the hyper-scale language models. | [
0.0182862934,
0.0021023178,
-0.0045860861,
0.0590802617,
0.0028481947,
0.0106920004,
0.042414736,
-0.0023257525,
0.0592233986,
-0.0361381471,
-0.0627580583,
-0.0084987469,
-0.0242608059,
0.0269169863,
0.0705333054,
-0.0683575347,
0.0157334954,
-0.0256547648,
-0.0021334207,
-0.0258206427,
-0.0250100102,
-0.0226109643,
-0.0092375148,
0.0352638438,
-0.0017879133,
-0.00760422,
-0.0114182513,
-0.0061132973,
-0.0268992819,
-0.0324078947,
-0.0066200965,
0.0657374263,
0.0651592016,
0.0187106505,
0.0000019792,
-0.0449357592,
-0.0028852641,
-0.0125443609,
-0.0002690657,
-0.002851699,
0.0044280831,
-0.0340406969,
0.0311670825,
0.0083171651,
0.0017981577,
-0.087218374,
0.0429281555,
0.0304017197,
0.0718276426,
0.0619070604,
-0.0273323096,
-0.0495297946,
0.0138044748,
0.0050622388,
-0.0161531661,
-0.0302472617,
0.0222990084,
-0.0177144948,
-0.0017856251,
0.0445395708,
-0.0552635714,
0.0549078211,
-0.0011221421,
-0.0355106816,
0.0941671059,
0.0148781128,
0.0178466104,
-0.0105734542,
-0.005984846,
0.0874676928,
-0.0080333799,
-0.0147558143,
-0.0078411642,
-0.0010529853,
0.0227247048,
0.0158986598,
-0.0435930379,
-0.0049486808,
0.0406119525,
-0.0127520049,
-0.0236798748,
-0.002373982,
0.0088835908,
-0.0287691839,
-0.0099824024,
0.0189228803,
0.0174495578,
-0.0339962393,
-0.0196382869,
-0.050354477,
-0.0534653589,
-0.0286138393,
0.027083654,
0.0239025969,
-0.0462445505,
-0.0103657097,
-0.041250933,
-0.0216000844,
-0.002443922,
-0.0054164478,
0.03910264,
0.0365003049,
0.0014495556,
0.0540394112,
-0.0377607904,
0.0646498427,
-0.0055977199,
0.0759560913,
-0.0791694298,
0.0145011339,
-0.0120773856,
-0.0323658474,
-0.0495693833,
0.0471451432,
-0.0000686227,
-0.0456709713,
-0.015605079,
0.0475754328,
0.0208374895,
0.0239826255,
-0.0355349109,
0.015702825,
-0.0017758223,
0.0281873886,
-0.0247477088,
-0.0147054745,
-0.0361308567,
0.0068660262,
-0.0047830739,
0.0274230763,
-0.0325677916,
0.0190972965,
0.0431379452,
-0.0306851473,
-0.0119257411,
0.040454533,
-0.0075015565,
-0.0222724639,
0.0057821926,
0.0099444035,
-0.0086359046,
-0.0062168101,
0.0103265187,
-0.0199186616,
0.012006985,
-0.0069692386,
-0.0077356542,
-0.0190579239,
-0.0344110914,
-0.0020686204,
-0.0075570676,
0.0721030086,
0.0485262685,
0.0046427632,
0.0861121565,
-0.0219769124,
-0.0013116468,
0.0279991478,
0.0046022846,
-0.0035330139,
0.0425909534,
-0.0473963507,
-0.0230290666,
0.0210194793,
0.0138790431,
-0.0140556553,
-0.0643930584,
0.0049355584,
0.0952678099,
0.0879914016,
0.025348695,
0.0495700426,
-0.0471498072,
-0.0442835093,
-0.006188801,
0.1050770581,
0.0196829308,
-0.0170076527,
0.0630712286,
0.0116733508,
-0.0326258801,
0.011956919,
-0.0446810424,
0.0061125318,
-0.0196617711,
-0.0070909187,
0.0978825763,
0.0078104245,
-0.0563372634,
-0.0269307047,
-0.0143828792,
-0.0109405695,
-0.0325173661,
-0.0151498662,
0.0275750291,
-0.0093847346,
-0.0279991906,
0.0486814119,
-0.0088390838,
-0.0493676029,
-0.0139211956,
-0.014979017,
0.0498382039,
0.0203153901,
-0.0058864881,
-0.0558323972,
-0.0010154655,
-0.0159331933,
0.0435188264,
0.0410371311,
0.0649459437,
-0.0499321185,
-0.0068696081,
-0.0306221433,
-0.0191802606,
0.0020275733,
-0.0043725548,
-0.0196097437,
-0.0114175053,
-0.0234414618,
0.0043015638,
-0.0128407087,
-0.0006622074,
0.0419926196,
0.01643526,
-0.066742748,
0.0241792537,
0.0549850054,
0.0160267521,
0.0066459919,
0.0108209727,
0.0023549381,
0.039589528,
-0.0599863008,
-0.0160726514,
-0.0346985497,
-0.0665626526,
-0.0840943456,
0.0316948481,
0.0252026841,
0.0327963643,
-0.0152248973,
-0.03560495,
-0.0590775162,
-0.0047082203,
-0.0068030958,
0.0248142425,
-0.0309469104,
0.0079971785,
-0.026284609,
-0.002589097,
-0.0840686634,
0.0274785683,
0.0103298286,
0.0483322181,
-0.0000449241,
0.053292308,
0.0116834948,
-0.0353291072,
-0.0724096224,
0.0362307467,
0.037591897,
0.0152896876,
-0.0032471337,
-0.0242510941,
-0.0239942875,
-0.0485220104,
-0.0710034594,
-0.0317060053,
0.0172656681,
-0.0156787541,
0.0079263337,
-0.0032055911,
0.0032177083,
-0.0299264807,
-0.0321162269,
-0.0380825996,
-0.0186825953,
0.0265187155,
0.0595641956,
-0.0089078667,
-0.0323730037,
0.0037305262,
-0.0174373798,
-0.0141123794,
0.0588568039,
-0.0249262564,
-0.0158097669,
-0.0623781309,
-0.0053598159,
-0.010505748,
0.0297907386,
0.0117042447,
-0.0211098175,
0.0068498584,
-0.0409546345,
0.0447277762,
0.0870230496,
-0.0170186628,
-0.0168970414,
0.0419250764,
0.0395176932,
-0.0321530811,
-0.0013430113,
-0.0425764918,
-0.0128691113,
0.006122685,
0.0227407366,
-0.0025461076,
0.0538782291,
-0.0045601437,
-0.0187449232,
-0.0699178874,
0.0523871817,
-0.0249212906,
0.0322823748,
-0.0764135122,
0.028259458,
-0.0278412178,
0.010173074,
0.0038406637,
-0.0671815053,
0.0828834847,
-0.0239583757,
-0.0014755822,
-0.0193874966,
-0.013371096,
-0.0357225165,
0.0160558447,
0.0080093695,
0.0161940064,
0.0377217904,
-0.0555428229,
-0.0239049047,
-0.0002470981,
0.0137527697,
0.0012285314,
0.0037589232,
-0.0126628932,
0.0020023526,
-0.0066685923,
-0.0417421237,
-0.0142639531,
-0.0676906779,
0.0097440751,
0.0020549514,
-0.0031301428,
-0.0262605399,
0.0034145799,
0.0314464122,
0.0137629285,
0.0882338211,
-0.054046303,
0.0235659815,
-0.0353606045,
0.0466230325,
0.0251635909,
0.0842138603,
-0.0339414254,
-0.0056007951,
0.0390290655,
-0.0065225996,
0.0134669058,
-0.0334210359,
0.0067631993,
0.0401606783,
0.0357034467,
0.0041585448,
-0.0372437946,
0.010842721,
0.0457745045,
0.0000414606,
-0.0236568451,
0.1102278009,
0.0378318466,
-0.0214175582,
-0.0114363898,
0.0111834304,
0.0389037505,
0.0529847927,
0.020413015,
-0.0202649683,
-0.0086524673,
-0.0059633008,
0.0053328336,
0.0187098645,
0.0038013177,
0.0065837912,
-0.0781776682,
0.0180719849,
0.0355028398,
-0.0544838496,
-0.0143225826,
-0.0370163433,
-0.0094742198,
0.036477536,
0.006011996,
-0.0041836752,
-0.0058665443,
-0.0162682552,
0.0233987272,
-0.0308493003,
-0.049617324,
0.0174919926,
0.0007583628,
0.0283128768,
-0.0357716382,
0.013036334,
0.0000920828,
-0.0743199885,
0.0241206959,
0.0218278691,
-0.0054213116,
-0.0255910251,
0.032169465,
0.0216630083,
0.0046726088,
0.0280083977,
0.0385720916,
-0.0185073819,
0.0051482655,
-0.01114133,
0.1050650552,
-0.0079352921,
0.0408663861,
-0.0145818396,
-0.018067088,
-0.0151667092,
0.0631117821,
0.0534302965,
-0.0401926264,
-0.0200156681,
-0.0068755737,
0.016337499,
0.0330732502,
0.0085286573,
-0.0125641469,
-0.0384641103,
-0.0174082592,
-0.0706306472,
0.0260544773,
0.0442962721,
0.0780614763,
0.0137383919,
-0.0233445801,
-0.0176964439,
-0.0197979491,
-0.044428546,
0.0427396111,
-0.0006095908,
0.0117544783,
-0.0480901673,
-0.0244748946,
0.0674144402,
-0.0188286155,
-0.0341991745,
-0.0254208501,
-0.0318346955,
-0.053765852,
-0.0487068631,
0.006829774,
0.0051109241,
0.0418993719,
-0.0087817702,
-0.0626090616,
0.0769946277,
0.0246995352,
-0.030784348,
0.0500014089,
0.035591919,
0.0384272188,
-0.0291252285,
0.0294847898,
-0.0395488441,
-0.0047251023,
0.0195590034,
-0.0023425198,
-0.0042379247,
-0.0128372191,
-0.0225793459,
0.0257607084,
0.0621032789,
0.0146987876,
-0.0234093331,
-0.0494745448,
0.0224934388,
-0.025257932,
-0.0227231085,
-0.0278849993,
0.0194727182,
0.0231590569,
-0.0002084009,
-0.0195050612,
-0.0425033309,
-0.0289486274,
0.0363158807,
-0.0293700173,
-0.0047008353,
0.0026164388,
0.0196211897,
0.0338872261,
0.0467558205,
-0.0471017063,
-0.0227045193,
-0.0097833974,
0.0183199197,
-0.0286859609,
0.0296869557,
0.0201270394,
0.0371620171,
-0.0915357694,
0.0277012344,
-0.0493733548,
-0.0010916942,
-0.028495986,
0.0130770244,
0.0021828513,
-0.0147427944,
-0.0184365101,
0.0419382006,
-0.04196297,
0.0018274665,
0.0156752225,
0.025898464,
-0.06146577,
0.0886854082,
0.0167484749,
-0.0136197563,
0.0114367325,
0.0534693226,
0.0013039859,
0.006051607,
-0.0046828124,
0.0348832533,
-0.090177007,
0.0225084294,
0.0346422009,
0.0854140669,
0.0067285863,
0.0283705778,
-0.0136355693,
-0.0411516763,
0.0465791635,
-0.0096828742,
-0.0855976716,
0.0128333392,
-0.003809362,
0.0133797666,
-0.0174027048,
-0.0554359779,
-0.0258243568,
0.0139314663,
0.0203993078,
-0.0390442237,
0.021927068,
-5.926552317e-33,
-0.0251446664,
-0.0165114086,
-0.0090102153,
0.0242557712,
-0.0252158139,
0.0141270254,
-0.0101331156,
-0.0081899352,
0.0037725009,
-0.0124820797,
-0.0133178653,
-0.0282578059,
0.0025955997,
0.0257722642,
0.009322389,
-0.0149617027,
0.0319153778,
-0.0256930888,
-0.0143868933,
0.0508628562,
0.0343778841,
0.0441437587,
0.0232583601,
-0.0275888517,
0.0016903165,
-0.0007158357,
0.0204078313,
0.0558657981,
0.0072289277,
0.0357778482,
-0.068231374,
0.0469896346,
-0.0157757644,
-0.0169489272,
-0.0112783182,
0.0391470008,
-0.0684899241,
-0.0540854335,
-0.0296339784,
-0.0008131842,
0.002754017,
-0.0610628091,
0.0422037579,
-0.0103265597,
-0.0119461361,
-0.0311175101,
0.0416598842,
0.0065523414,
-0.0499089584,
0.0158986431,
-0.0298498701,
0.0023083445,
-0.0249604359,
-0.0169206597,
0.0411005244,
0.00793033,
0.0181538798,
0.0363039337,
-0.0523592234,
0.016737055,
-0.008003654,
0.0117171835,
0.0089482823,
0.0537132509,
0.0337594971,
0.0665300637,
0.0381985083,
-0.0254032295,
0.0052556787,
0.0295009799,
0.0369600505,
-0.0326777324,
-0.0062206984,
0.0163576901,
0.0097447643,
-0.0265057832,
-0.0539016426,
-0.0017724143,
-0.0116218571,
-0.0166549925,
0.0100184185,
0.0399065912,
-0.0337236114,
-0.0693626702,
-0.0303199142,
-0.0466936715,
-0.0305056274,
0.0249439441,
0.034923058,
-0.004103899,
-0.0025539938,
-0.0252503399,
0.0107409935,
0.0019648878,
-0.0165764652,
-0.0338679589,
0.0144812893,
0.0332379453,
0.0171895865,
0.0020730381,
-0.0411979109,
-0.0424966291,
0.0448287539,
-0.0021212108,
0.0239836797,
0.0124711134,
0.0012970701,
0.0479350872,
-0.0685087889,
-0.020523604,
-0.006287267,
-0.062505886,
-0.0092318757,
0.0387648679,
0.0071776393,
0.0156270936,
-0.0033370787,
0.1018508747,
-0.0132297333,
-0.000265974,
-0.0144710755,
0.0003696199,
0.0152724851,
0.0255711544,
-0.0073877787,
0.0125233419,
0.0307627674,
0.0299468264,
0.0715324506,
-0.0691885427,
0.0149873961,
0.0055596414,
2.687e-7,
0.0192245021,
0.0453429371,
0.0072990838,
-0.0765105635,
0.0086503364,
0.0378961451,
-0.0117072342,
0.0215218924,
0.0042598811,
-0.0027810817,
0.0024263624,
-0.0107251378,
0.0251257308,
0.0148091149,
-0.1400021315,
0.0651698634,
-0.0678026155,
0.0210200585,
-0.0513574369,
0.0486829616,
0.077117011,
0.0979508683,
0.0270126723,
0.0106741684,
-0.020027129,
-0.0322180167,
0.0228723437,
-0.0174385384,
0.0089845937,
0.0170404948,
0.0143473186,
-0.013930046,
0.0405164398,
0.0546774119,
-0.0139822345,
0.067338489,
0.0408578217,
0.0615905486,
0.0133970315,
-0.013671549,
-0.0292613432,
0.0271743946,
-0.0212071948,
-0.0707941577,
0.0563124605,
-0.0800307691,
-0.0298938211,
-0.0117668379,
0.0173049904,
-0.0224827547,
0.0525999777,
-0.0312972739,
0.0025573492,
0.0231289696,
0.0439115539,
-0.0199305564,
0.0404930748,
-0.1249713674,
0.0086057689,
0.0020581982,
-0.0876404718,
-0.0430799089,
0.0070099588,
-0.0251679495,
0.0334351622,
-0.0203115493,
0.0069352826,
2.611481923e-34,
0.0011775009,
-0.0057438952,
0.032392785,
-0.0046349135,
0.0181481503,
-0.0418941826,
0.0238664802,
0.009022546,
0.0581211224,
-0.1454575956,
-0.0216426812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04162v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04162v1 | GLS-CSC: A Simple but Effective Strategy to Mitigate Chinese STM Models' Over-Reliance on Superficial Clue | 2023-09-08T07:10:57 | 2023-09-08T07:10:57 | Yanrui Du, Sendong Zhao, Yuhan Chen, Rai Bai, Jing Liu, Hua Wu, Haifeng Wang, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained models have achieved success in Chinese Short Text Matching (STM)
tasks, but they often rely on superficial clues, leading to a lack of robust
predictions. To address this issue, it is crucial to analyze and mitigate the
influence of superficial clues on STM models. Our study aims to investigate
their over-reliance on the edit distance feature, commonly used to measure the
semantic similarity of Chinese text pairs, which can be considered a
superficial clue. To mitigate STM models' over-reliance on superficial clues,
we propose a novel resampling training strategy called Gradually Learn Samples
Containing Superficial Clue (GLS-CSC). Through comprehensive evaluations of
In-Domain (I.D.), Robustness (Rob.), and Out-Of-Domain (O.O.D.) test sets, we
demonstrate that GLS-CSC outperforms existing methods in terms of enhancing the
robustness and generalization of Chinese STM models. Moreover, we conduct a
detailed analysis of existing methods and reveal their commonality. | [
0.0510000847,
0.0103705367,
0.0183681361,
0.0216684025,
-0.0301934686,
-0.0077374536,
-0.0116816638,
0.0544378422,
-0.0214470644,
-0.0357543416,
-0.0376318507,
-0.0489682183,
0.0272571892,
-0.0033488867,
-0.0203664545,
-0.0317983292,
0.0051669343,
0.0259959996,
-0.0624562129,
-0.0073041143,
0.0650179684,
0.0050216275,
0.0811634734,
-0.0000745479,
0.036999166,
-0.0261988584,
0.0082014808,
0.0425023064,
0.0220687035,
-0.0312395319,
0.0375680588,
0.0471177511,
-0.011948253,
0.0501678996,
0.0000020935,
-0.0739860758,
-0.0550505444,
-0.0068342788,
0.002959715,
0.0254184548,
0.0359541923,
-0.0329085626,
0.0151412152,
0.0187342577,
-0.0010256561,
-0.0214297995,
0.0351089053,
0.1194426045,
0.019098755,
0.0997589827,
-0.0199262947,
0.0033706541,
0.0103145121,
-0.0401590429,
0.0265709907,
-0.0612381771,
0.0466148108,
-0.0158859883,
-0.0167934019,
-0.0016634528,
-0.0085667372,
0.0261488892,
-0.0276172832,
0.0022640305,
-0.0231774151,
0.0123041337,
-0.0020860627,
0.0595689416,
0.0290276017,
0.0618845858,
-0.0653085038,
-0.038606517,
-0.009699706,
-0.0292858202,
0.0059551015,
0.0391122438,
-0.0281740874,
-0.0234642886,
-0.057001818,
0.0230902601,
-0.0299422275,
-0.0213751011,
0.0258239862,
0.0212683715,
-0.0028145104,
0.001487032,
0.010435068,
-0.0584670007,
-0.0498627461,
-0.0257450808,
-0.0293285456,
-0.0443015285,
0.0255827531,
0.0160233807,
0.0277750194,
-0.0206276495,
-0.0516799092,
-0.0276249051,
-0.002810511,
-0.054876253,
-0.006019311,
0.0297599342,
-0.0336574316,
0.0201369729,
-0.0491482168,
0.0309127513,
0.0269938484,
0.0428666882,
-0.0456600115,
-0.0261376742,
-0.0395930149,
-0.0120249996,
-0.0597868338,
0.0437674448,
-0.0068255854,
-0.021619333,
-0.0346349701,
0.0088371243,
-0.0018432351,
-0.0176252164,
-0.0335300714,
-0.0114358589,
-0.0165769234,
-0.0271835253,
-0.0166278165,
0.0324335061,
-0.0057638534,
0.0485840105,
-0.0428235233,
0.0012760173,
0.0028759509,
0.0264551397,
0.0517318323,
-0.0561370924,
0.0270244293,
0.0020640346,
-0.0256317686,
-0.061369855,
-0.0367419496,
0.0068022194,
-0.0188840721,
-0.0103980107,
-0.0172502734,
-0.0549354367,
-0.005913056,
-0.0319918096,
0.0318091549,
-0.0735784248,
-0.0082438067,
0.0171322078,
-0.0487760603,
0.0731625333,
-0.0026643113,
-0.0020657382,
-0.007628575,
0.0251585972,
0.0170059148,
0.0342861675,
-0.0129020149,
0.0299219303,
0.0882956684,
0.0278333463,
0.0014632191,
0.0264752302,
-0.0019022389,
0.0177094396,
0.0025127081,
0.0149734672,
0.0672676861,
0.0157532319,
0.0473462194,
-0.0018692171,
-0.0425071232,
-0.0229970198,
0.0723859668,
0.0354266688,
0.0313328207,
0.0334081315,
-0.0094956337,
0.0131447483,
0.0070234002,
0.0470029712,
-0.0342207551,
-0.0040053823,
-0.0779896602,
0.038933754,
0.0329828039,
0.0066605988,
-0.0526811704,
-0.0111610191,
-0.0044821515,
-0.0192592498,
0.0014801988,
0.0111937243,
0.0497515574,
0.001480913,
-0.010205443,
-0.0041881604,
0.0016382806,
-0.028977111,
0.0024188373,
-0.0193856619,
-0.0245765205,
0.0700781643,
0.0288332272,
-0.0051824469,
-0.0123483697,
-0.00014884,
0.0249690115,
0.0265669376,
0.0427943319,
-0.0018969948,
0.0036753144,
-0.0156970993,
-0.0601657182,
0.0221767966,
-0.0201190691,
-0.009483235,
0.0455566123,
0.028511988,
0.0286704488,
-0.0357300825,
-0.0591979921,
0.0298776571,
-0.0090913279,
-0.0139048053,
0.0193239283,
0.0126269944,
-0.0291495882,
-0.0193979461,
-0.0323509313,
0.0322657563,
-0.0209895074,
-0.0079452582,
-0.0418510698,
-0.0130175911,
-0.0031871537,
-0.0305091664,
0.0792462826,
-0.0344133042,
0.0154543994,
0.0394906811,
-0.0365673192,
-0.0323956721,
-0.0121676493,
0.0329114422,
-0.022163298,
-0.0781256333,
0.0677397028,
-0.0505564623,
0.0177100264,
-0.0331453755,
0.0114411479,
0.0231576841,
0.0192482676,
-0.0250514634,
0.0295155626,
0.0463575721,
-0.0271477345,
-0.0628561825,
-0.0169754587,
0.0174921919,
0.0011879585,
0.0232396238,
0.0447980016,
0.0029673732,
-0.0182641875,
-0.0557606108,
-0.0049056294,
-0.039601583,
0.0040273275,
0.0238539595,
0.0123735825,
-0.0286873169,
-0.0319105461,
-0.0357417278,
-0.0405033045,
-0.0149252294,
-0.0022157594,
0.0204137713,
-0.0242782757,
0.0071825692,
-0.0192190744,
0.0133736031,
0.0072257644,
0.0144801419,
-0.0004774355,
-0.0593518466,
-0.0619693957,
0.0431660824,
-0.0243454743,
0.0055152015,
-0.0234520677,
-0.0177047979,
-0.0802626312,
-0.0065355748,
0.0074489862,
0.0082351128,
0.0374803767,
-0.0568032488,
0.0302343778,
0.0056653079,
-0.0218149163,
-0.0112054348,
0.0029387092,
0.0082411543,
-0.0096189892,
-0.0474245958,
0.0059640985,
0.0291817952,
-0.0192782655,
0.005645236,
-0.0182373356,
-0.0320879668,
0.0382342003,
0.031229306,
-0.0588344373,
0.0127189262,
-0.0369338654,
0.0008350025,
-0.0504127517,
-0.0269974489,
0.0820604265,
-0.0538327582,
0.0242952779,
-0.0696012452,
-0.0228150766,
-0.0591573231,
0.0376869962,
-0.0475917123,
0.0118004009,
0.0408689938,
0.0248048231,
-0.0413750522,
0.0078161126,
0.0340988822,
-0.0113370484,
0.0664440468,
0.0205126312,
0.0433379598,
-0.023658881,
-0.0270541981,
-0.0034929279,
-0.0636662319,
-0.0291792024,
0.0226670839,
0.0457044095,
-0.0299883913,
0.0008114074,
0.0925964564,
-0.0143069169,
0.0892364979,
-0.0424009003,
-0.0139118647,
-0.0053818929,
0.0137296701,
0.0736834854,
-0.0139021836,
0.0073730969,
-0.0263270102,
0.0652895868,
0.0369260535,
0.0318718478,
-0.0060249791,
0.0029480904,
-0.0295262188,
0.0183633789,
-0.0343559831,
-0.0004347368,
-0.0102890832,
0.0512244962,
-0.0322558507,
-0.0134009328,
0.1229489446,
0.0090740491,
-0.0495244414,
-0.0324527584,
-0.0110838991,
-0.0004324231,
0.0243103486,
0.0232502818,
-0.0785738751,
-0.0425256789,
0.0225107521,
0.0271942206,
0.0097965878,
-0.0050111557,
-0.0006673359,
-0.1041896045,
0.0028508015,
0.0073779868,
-0.0551804602,
-0.043592751,
-0.0459881425,
0.025121009,
0.0181171354,
0.0137402834,
-0.0084827533,
-0.0579080656,
-0.0414208286,
-0.0092467237,
-0.0199009739,
-0.0203169752,
0.0209368579,
-0.0993537828,
-0.0125710173,
0.0380389467,
0.0402397364,
0.0096934484,
0.0266477559,
0.0762809888,
-0.0148562165,
0.0007640225,
-0.0088452576,
0.0477728732,
-0.0242198482,
0.0154266302,
0.0314265788,
0.0115016038,
0.005752793,
0.0009647209,
0.0583173893,
0.0116833216,
-0.0266083926,
0.0099349935,
0.0255406071,
0.0173060019,
-0.0319172181,
0.091204688,
0.0310454257,
-0.0317544229,
-0.0263436809,
-0.0198863,
-0.0211792234,
-0.023597721,
-0.022096362,
0.0288435798,
-0.0778613463,
0.046887055,
-0.0541703664,
-0.0641754046,
0.0041306084,
-0.0014286245,
-0.0138875144,
0.0537527688,
-0.0455410145,
-0.0036796147,
-0.063914679,
0.0228966419,
-0.0470099859,
0.0313629955,
-0.0532573499,
0.0245680772,
0.0020340842,
-0.0869536251,
0.0039960821,
-0.0286117364,
-0.0884540007,
-0.0405919291,
-0.0178363752,
-0.0117918057,
0.0025213717,
0.0553747043,
-0.0285826437,
-0.0436507016,
0.0076899705,
0.0331171341,
0.0114191668,
0.0012702739,
-0.0004699405,
-0.0332145058,
-0.021630479,
0.0331603028,
-0.019587405,
0.0281074196,
0.0558338128,
0.0248464365,
0.025959773,
-0.0243202802,
0.030674031,
0.0185374152,
0.0406739749,
0.0113023082,
0.004079638,
-0.073523134,
0.0519580431,
0.0088943513,
-0.0235024709,
-0.0044862186,
-0.0048036422,
0.0160086434,
0.0193545241,
-0.0197665524,
0.0719579384,
-0.0003278843,
0.0133445887,
-0.0718029216,
-0.0160253011,
-0.0337598175,
0.0655186996,
-0.0242808964,
0.0157266092,
0.0177275054,
0.0249043107,
0.0256239977,
0.0243638121,
0.0011161689,
0.0371624231,
0.0492694452,
0.0472448729,
-0.0304965619,
0.0239602495,
-0.0724863037,
-0.0116658714,
-0.0595583841,
0.016412409,
0.0879237875,
-0.0398674272,
0.0213086307,
-0.0273722429,
-0.0053278189,
-0.057268098,
-0.0128031988,
-0.018725682,
0.0028161765,
-0.0113935573,
0.0083874436,
-0.0214011222,
0.026237322,
0.1075903177,
0.0158224534,
0.0619810149,
0.0269212276,
-0.0633815974,
0.0058544539,
0.0066950396,
0.0467895903,
0.0455732271,
-0.0266544316,
-0.0204338003,
-0.0340367816,
-0.0417639539,
0.0594889969,
-0.0546365678,
-0.0260834973,
0.0387503952,
0.0205402691,
0.0665702969,
0.0015772494,
0.0204594582,
-0.0145606836,
-0.0258334409,
0.019772945,
-0.0113753024,
0.0047839815,
-6.603960324e-33,
0.0127752321,
-0.0070498278,
-0.0021175703,
0.0095867459,
0.0099608116,
0.0289704073,
-0.0198951233,
-0.0398169644,
-0.0359546244,
-0.0063535119,
-0.0153628606,
0.0321288742,
0.0155546432,
0.0165662747,
-0.025795022,
-0.0039507793,
0.0643338114,
0.0299227815,
-0.0176159125,
-0.0201050006,
0.0576977991,
0.0655927658,
0.0707122609,
-0.0630824044,
-0.0013395034,
-0.0139478967,
0.001156474,
0.0057783616,
0.0484848209,
0.0623840801,
0.0154907228,
0.0157424994,
0.0313336924,
-0.0070162341,
-0.0322175622,
-0.01988234,
-0.1181102842,
-0.0294698514,
-0.0107325399,
-0.0027259781,
0.0224964153,
-0.0067094895,
0.0190630406,
-0.0189583302,
0.0235126093,
-0.0156167038,
0.0568621531,
-0.0476581678,
-0.0174212866,
-0.0370490253,
-0.0038124556,
0.0666214898,
0.0440676063,
0.0195922833,
0.0061513842,
0.0153755164,
0.0033280079,
0.0124420421,
-0.0595308244,
0.0034986341,
0.0709754303,
0.0852814019,
-0.0160663817,
0.0147646917,
-0.0021831491,
0.0281907041,
0.002964471,
0.0005573013,
0.0496867187,
-0.0126469778,
0.0520532094,
-0.0321153887,
0.0009513968,
0.0868132636,
0.0768213272,
-0.0093709454,
-0.0433679745,
0.0639716387,
0.0371967405,
-0.009650344,
0.005726323,
0.0137438253,
-0.0446273424,
-0.0478056967,
-0.0320074521,
0.0208005849,
-0.0537234247,
-0.0360122807,
0.030146081,
0.0647736266,
-0.0190682895,
0.0303853061,
0.0322074145,
-0.037242204,
-0.0160533804,
-0.0017018074,
-0.0034279418,
-0.0179197993,
-0.0079311915,
0.0028587212,
-0.03758239,
-0.0471315384,
0.0100585455,
-0.0385710225,
-0.0205566566,
-0.0199797172,
0.0868115425,
-0.0057713795,
-0.0517416708,
-0.0017074072,
0.0120962961,
-0.0477074534,
0.0051331795,
0.0085130716,
-0.0173752662,
0.0185974911,
0.0215226412,
0.0264710002,
0.070040226,
0.0024216622,
-0.0538916774,
-0.0523805283,
0.0003782676,
0.0234990772,
0.017058352,
0.0435755067,
-0.0272531807,
-0.0320747234,
0.0309815016,
-0.0664452612,
-0.0099998312,
-0.0028845198,
2.797e-7,
0.0301893353,
-0.0136404168,
0.0516335294,
0.0021667622,
-0.0187739562,
-0.0003487571,
-0.0044092475,
0.0243165996,
0.0067346608,
0.0660355911,
0.043106243,
0.018559929,
0.0447402485,
-0.0060136775,
-0.0674562156,
0.0306670107,
-0.0573118739,
-0.0225987341,
-0.0278232209,
-0.0122183673,
-0.0299811196,
0.0869740993,
-0.0058635352,
0.0082669342,
0.0090902867,
-0.0682815611,
0.0726702511,
-0.0085593211,
0.0305178817,
0.0672877356,
0.0158786904,
-0.0088325664,
-0.0137925083,
0.0188712161,
-0.0068828147,
0.0551593453,
0.0657554641,
0.0161457304,
-0.0033346305,
-0.0145714143,
-0.0285713319,
0.0163021162,
0.0111213075,
-0.0508996956,
0.0772487596,
-0.0189975258,
0.0203529838,
-0.0084228776,
-0.0035877503,
-0.0194560289,
0.0172079988,
-0.0011814657,
-0.0049569085,
0.065254122,
0.0194114111,
0.0334639512,
-0.0305360835,
-0.0606326908,
-0.0431914926,
0.0023940986,
0.0031857842,
-0.0243497733,
-0.0639045015,
-0.0365937874,
0.026672801,
-0.047203023,
0.019125171,
2.536512246e-34,
0.0052910382,
-0.0183094498,
-0.0584312417,
-0.0030787333,
0.0151334694,
-0.0137493806,
0.0144546023,
0.0176339541,
-0.0223448351,
-0.0424009115,
-0.0341653153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04156v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04156v1 | Cross-Utterance Conditioned VAE for Speech Generation | 2023-09-08T06:48:41 | 2023-09-08T06:48:41 | Yang Li, Cheng Yu, Guangzhi Sun, Weiqin Zu, Zheng Tian, Ying Wen, Wei Pan, Chao Zhang, Jun Wang, Yang Yang, Fanglei Sun | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Speech synthesis systems powered by neural networks hold promise for
multimedia production, but frequently face issues with producing expressive
speech and seamless editing. In response, we present the Cross-Utterance
Conditioned Variational Autoencoder speech synthesis (CUC-VAE S2) framework to
enhance prosody and ensure natural speech generation. This framework leverages
the powerful representational capabilities of pre-trained language models and
the re-expression abilities of variational autoencoders (VAEs). The core
component of the CUC-VAE S2 framework is the cross-utterance CVAE, which
extracts acoustic, speaker, and textual features from surrounding sentences to
generate context-sensitive prosodic features, more accurately emulating human
prosody generation. We further propose two practical algorithms tailored for
distinct speech synthesis applications: CUC-VAE TTS for text-to-speech and
CUC-VAE SE for speech editing. The CUC-VAE TTS is a direct application of the
framework, designed to generate audio with contextual prosody derived from
surrounding texts. On the other hand, the CUC-VAE SE algorithm leverages real
mel spectrogram sampling conditioned on contextual information, producing audio
that closely mirrors real sound and thereby facilitating flexible speech
editing based on text such as deletion, insertion, and replacement.
Experimental results on the LibriTTS datasets demonstrate that our proposed
models significantly enhance speech synthesis and editing, producing more
natural and expressive speech. | [
0.0075113233,
0.064551577,
0.0105470391,
-0.0362277739,
-0.0123348422,
-0.0662202314,
0.0402609482,
-0.0325084589,
-0.0801292434,
-0.0108109117,
-0.0543470085,
-0.0411121845,
0.0134825064,
0.0963240638,
0.0387105122,
-0.1034497693,
-0.0039035326,
-0.03959601,
-0.0175475236,
-0.0371585302,
0.0057807784,
-0.0004497277,
-0.0317229703,
0.0215417873,
-0.0475413203,
0.0125878444,
-0.0210598297,
0.0135924425,
0.0150958253,
0.0489798114,
-0.008232547,
0.0213742349,
0.0507614352,
-0.0278235115,
0.0000022306,
-0.0224560946,
-0.0293871183,
-0.0116511062,
-0.0261074379,
0.0177548975,
0.0476334058,
0.0141662136,
-0.0542281866,
0.0352057591,
-0.0003616076,
-0.0035853265,
0.0495146103,
-0.0167732127,
0.0606077947,
0.0424535275,
-0.0229690392,
-0.0201654378,
0.0043795295,
-0.0461817384,
0.000448073,
0.018140981,
-0.0292076897,
-0.0435282215,
0.0267188791,
-0.0264448281,
-0.0272260904,
0.0474488512,
0.0282431804,
-0.0406203978,
0.0202048644,
0.0180751532,
-0.0258439332,
-0.0612513833,
-0.0353651904,
0.0562291443,
0.0259483717,
0.0096537601,
-0.0092194574,
-0.0159256887,
-0.0171122029,
-0.0122849261,
0.0210134089,
0.0362032019,
0.0605468228,
-0.0001698339,
-0.0457483754,
0.0273309592,
-0.0093928939,
-0.0537697822,
0.0401837751,
-0.0262491554,
0.074894987,
-0.0166392513,
-0.0218151808,
-0.0216178615,
-0.0029893394,
-0.0054650586,
0.0676774159,
0.0121797426,
-0.0369251706,
-0.018606877,
-0.0760345683,
-0.0531264171,
-0.0554447025,
0.0480165631,
0.0238747932,
0.0367584564,
-0.0579917692,
-0.0262809824,
-0.0328902639,
0.0309917927,
-0.0145255951,
-0.0395594425,
-0.0246936493,
-0.0143739562,
0.023451291,
-0.0004250828,
-0.0411965661,
0.0016480575,
-0.0773693919,
-0.0307689141,
-0.0515549332,
-0.0160578452,
-0.0478255115,
0.0311786551,
0.01429174,
0.0807709023,
-0.0658444837,
-0.0091307545,
0.0177590642,
-0.0036421882,
0.008593576,
0.0639173165,
0.0166060254,
-0.0312127452,
0.007152888,
0.0198963024,
0.0697732493,
0.0057227914,
0.0476142615,
0.0445636213,
-0.0083013764,
0.0180899464,
-0.0225250646,
-0.0460195914,
-0.0355227552,
-0.0001879665,
-0.0087826215,
-0.0467279479,
0.0484443568,
-0.0318085402,
-0.0349719636,
-0.0073288563,
-0.0208010934,
-0.0209457856,
0.0411751531,
0.037398126,
-0.0172952358,
0.0446597561,
0.0775463507,
-0.0092460206,
0.0581183694,
-0.0088956049,
0.0735243782,
-0.0047474895,
0.0059658131,
-0.0188915841,
-0.0008594731,
0.0730757415,
0.0249668658,
-0.0172898844,
-0.0608198978,
-0.0410962775,
-0.0153736463,
0.0260772407,
0.0758149475,
0.0410706736,
-0.0110271629,
-0.0295911487,
0.0699002445,
0.0136463232,
0.0472331233,
0.033777561,
0.1040692925,
0.0458833985,
-0.016005367,
-0.0344756432,
0.0288232323,
0.0405171998,
-0.0034162917,
0.0470376015,
0.0352137089,
0.01437541,
-0.0321860984,
-0.019197382,
0.035666015,
-0.0207513105,
-0.0008998736,
-0.0108900117,
0.0040161125,
0.0600379817,
-0.049999889,
0.04016269,
0.0086187506,
-0.0932945386,
0.0476620086,
0.0007504066,
-0.001527289,
0.0818247572,
0.0041287472,
0.0122289192,
0.0411611758,
-0.059880022,
-0.0220316537,
0.0605812147,
0.0221101586,
-0.0358494148,
0.0567758083,
-0.0534278117,
-0.0203525033,
-0.0226158276,
-0.0144211929,
0.036810901,
-0.0319385752,
0.0409282632,
0.0299272221,
0.0221120082,
0.0723676458,
-0.0008175006,
-0.0708909929,
-0.0013411565,
0.0243341718,
0.0212169848,
0.0213010758,
0.0306465477,
-0.0586237684,
0.0323348492,
-0.01177614,
-0.0466797203,
0.0000537454,
0.0332072489,
-0.0750339776,
-0.0331613123,
0.0145447804,
-0.0652556419,
0.0355348848,
0.0149645545,
0.0439822748,
-0.0919527411,
0.0744379237,
-0.0047930856,
0.018784035,
-0.0283782687,
0.0002039318,
0.0423847958,
0.0055758446,
0.0424900949,
-0.0324815065,
0.0117640886,
-0.0224744529,
0.0647220761,
0.0952956527,
-0.0002040447,
-0.0446959771,
-0.00693066,
-0.0205461867,
-0.0010883176,
0.0125423661,
-0.0019425519,
0.0243754331,
-0.0277931411,
-0.0187727716,
-0.0849046931,
0.0173738264,
-0.0153160505,
-0.0283118952,
0.0310350712,
0.0458898954,
-0.0207541585,
0.0121383099,
-0.0359621048,
-0.0233514477,
0.0047796681,
-0.014506327,
-0.0132407676,
-0.0162410103,
0.0058970442,
-0.0377925411,
0.0027873481,
0.0276771579,
0.0163165815,
-0.0348189995,
0.024515707,
0.0159401428,
0.0122340219,
0.0092188036,
0.0267764758,
0.0180716831,
-0.0396485366,
0.00198975,
0.0168965105,
0.1046912149,
-0.0107157091,
0.0189661514,
-0.0268066246,
0.0157427713,
-0.037558537,
-0.0145452367,
0.0217405837,
-0.0107862772,
0.0524177365,
0.0023183369,
0.0201601032,
-0.0002879255,
-0.0202373397,
0.0920036212,
0.0324507728,
-0.0445010737,
0.0213049036,
0.0437184758,
-0.063133657,
0.0385306925,
-0.0370390825,
-0.0361597314,
-0.00596814,
-0.0311062876,
0.0044130706,
0.0285009984,
-0.038789656,
-0.0599872619,
-0.0277901348,
0.0052320831,
0.0147323059,
-0.0077524199,
-0.0078003849,
0.0351384468,
-0.0290864781,
-0.0227897223,
-0.0365945548,
0.0287494827,
0.0188988652,
-0.0350755155,
-0.0043980391,
-0.0259867199,
-0.0447357222,
0.0001492207,
-0.0106693227,
-0.038507238,
-0.0152342385,
0.0021682135,
0.0408770256,
0.030207891,
-0.0341397226,
0.0329816304,
0.009726353,
0.0173392892,
0.0542022325,
0.0025460529,
0.0248109754,
-0.0272008069,
0.0532521196,
0.0638856366,
0.0223880075,
-0.0320230946,
-0.0315398872,
0.0096740974,
0.0013906483,
0.0217799842,
0.017318543,
-0.0412648506,
0.0585931204,
0.0047267708,
0.0140509205,
0.0229148772,
0.0167822372,
0.0557143539,
-0.0194435641,
-0.0037018154,
0.085593529,
-0.0224860739,
-0.0190625358,
0.0129084811,
-0.0057511488,
0.0314538404,
0.0172886364,
-0.0012132318,
-0.0318823606,
-0.0206885058,
0.0299720522,
0.0196415801,
0.0041365102,
0.0435493886,
-0.0353350863,
-0.0808157995,
0.0654962212,
0.0288948547,
-0.018883042,
-0.0130861094,
-0.0093702013,
-0.018788835,
-0.0030341726,
0.0235158391,
0.0241919085,
-0.0020342288,
-0.009805995,
0.0325018913,
-0.0228100307,
-0.0586532839,
-0.0309338663,
-0.0748280138,
0.0831553563,
0.0803145394,
0.0195291005,
-0.0223551821,
-0.0350343138,
-0.0034575933,
-0.034919031,
0.0048700892,
0.0171660297,
0.0312399492,
0.0040696831,
-0.0159461033,
0.0154971741,
0.090561226,
-0.012802925,
-0.0064906715,
0.0105294464,
0.0067584212,
-0.0042721084,
-0.0040037874,
-0.0164400823,
0.0525746346,
0.0087449951,
0.0330530964,
0.0577918328,
-0.0870993286,
0.0165590867,
0.0048273965,
0.0256682355,
-0.0734827667,
-0.0235854313,
-0.0023571381,
0.0148209203,
-0.0478529371,
-0.0282440968,
-0.017508151,
0.0003835955,
0.0297183301,
0.0200692583,
-0.0460562445,
0.0289306492,
-0.0086501511,
-0.064021565,
-0.0111364294,
0.0143094314,
0.0267151557,
-0.0075936317,
-0.0297517851,
0.012396575,
-0.0953170657,
-0.0129836174,
-0.0347751752,
-0.0485672317,
-0.0515042245,
0.0017477529,
0.0152032925,
0.0120456237,
0.0805313513,
0.0021324246,
-0.021021124,
0.104966253,
-0.0037606058,
-0.0163147356,
0.0533815362,
0.0494973473,
-0.0081295995,
-0.0092108157,
0.0044520288,
-0.0252019279,
0.0258015897,
-0.0031462559,
0.0416906588,
0.0434140004,
-0.0731391236,
-0.0172931515,
-0.0388962179,
-0.0246254541,
-0.0249410514,
0.0237428416,
-0.0892175063,
-0.0014921407,
-0.0223356858,
0.0257366598,
-0.0685046539,
0.0134035051,
0.0172144249,
0.0594881289,
-0.0277584214,
-0.0164882857,
-0.0314117074,
0.0040231622,
-0.0212689601,
0.0468656123,
0.0096241683,
0.0422336869,
0.0024002984,
0.0071514538,
0.0221793577,
0.0413029902,
-0.0140068429,
0.0050712386,
-0.0160844997,
0.0188334882,
-0.0041482588,
-0.0165326893,
-0.0021861398,
0.0353539325,
-0.0337378457,
0.0165446345,
-0.0610643178,
0.001136558,
0.0102367559,
-0.0070944633,
0.06040271,
-0.0064373659,
0.0153920911,
-0.007022717,
0.0212040171,
-0.0277599562,
-0.0339141078,
0.0169250593,
-0.039193593,
-0.0164302792,
0.01954652,
0.0212459471,
-0.0205888562,
0.0255798325,
-0.0398169421,
0.0398369506,
-0.040198613,
-0.0323263519,
-0.0167141166,
-0.0063370033,
-0.0123044262,
-0.031756971,
0.0013962077,
-0.0434176438,
0.0533257611,
0.0093363831,
-0.008132603,
-0.012502403,
0.047325436,
-0.0147529067,
-0.0448893867,
0.0301561914,
0.0185150746,
-0.0109190457,
0.0197399203,
-0.0372868404,
-0.0099443281,
-6.425126491e-33,
-0.0439914092,
0.0336362645,
-0.0058612488,
-0.0151515258,
-0.0705479085,
-0.020561602,
-0.080327481,
-0.0021399164,
0.03141037,
0.0101695033,
-0.0043059471,
0.000501481,
0.0040366771,
0.051963903,
0.0066230185,
-0.0001106614,
0.0894554108,
-0.0287556406,
-0.0024401464,
0.0553500354,
0.0046334965,
0.0413615815,
0.0105298432,
-0.0545869246,
-0.0418794565,
-0.0112270368,
-0.0139103848,
-0.0500049181,
0.0264828354,
0.0252878517,
-0.0140606891,
0.0372952819,
-0.0491403379,
0.0004552023,
-0.0284832921,
0.0009305346,
-0.0273135938,
-0.0172781534,
-0.0197389256,
0.0239073709,
-0.041756846,
-0.0124590024,
0.0428663194,
-0.0039590602,
-0.0326239616,
-0.0067682252,
0.0294797923,
-0.019511234,
0.0230725203,
-0.1008368507,
-0.0579104535,
0.0069883582,
-0.0026968447,
-0.0518599674,
0.0450556874,
0.0332406498,
-0.0147162164,
-0.0234763976,
-0.0591037944,
0.0578159317,
0.0030466828,
0.0208899062,
0.0452666245,
0.0154169099,
-0.001098845,
0.0346858166,
0.0466840863,
-0.0679668784,
0.0287203938,
0.0431624763,
0.0452857167,
0.0588155203,
0.0101846671,
0.0330828913,
-0.0032995951,
-0.0653985441,
0.001740441,
0.0054272576,
-0.0407553911,
-0.034898974,
-0.0015616982,
0.0378515869,
0.0137998629,
-0.0069434401,
-0.0673224404,
-0.0598869175,
-0.019999925,
-0.0105231777,
0.03315394,
-0.0028637517,
-0.0146314139,
-0.0307700336,
0.0424719974,
0.0032498897,
0.0212219488,
0.0052411887,
-0.0764849856,
0.0181063917,
0.004551278,
-0.0034151755,
-0.0245434083,
-0.0210774522,
0.1049250886,
-0.0058592362,
0.0042807343,
-0.0028975063,
-0.0477594547,
0.0948108807,
-0.0259527136,
-0.0177082997,
-0.0174473729,
0.0508520268,
0.023725478,
0.0118296491,
-0.0040288731,
0.0147025902,
-0.037137188,
0.0339519382,
-0.0168948304,
0.0341330953,
0.0001764909,
-0.0454785824,
0.0456071012,
0.040045999,
-0.0641243979,
0.0228701551,
0.0063086078,
-0.0014846424,
0.0526399016,
-0.048066698,
-0.0173715912,
0.0112673286,
3.02e-7,
-0.0408272967,
-0.0346410573,
0.0592754558,
-0.0201828238,
0.0539084971,
0.0375474505,
-0.0025846451,
0.0170010887,
0.0014635319,
-0.0035735504,
0.0173948277,
-0.0113324486,
0.0837718323,
0.0001979646,
-0.0202712845,
0.0051076668,
-0.0369221121,
-0.0068402039,
-0.0175163876,
0.0022212316,
0.0167680643,
0.034617953,
-0.0165276993,
-0.0499139205,
0.0431572348,
0.0284541752,
0.0378579982,
-0.0134360595,
-0.0331236087,
-0.0314493589,
0.0026996587,
-0.0040070564,
0.0018260035,
-0.0059863725,
-0.0662807301,
0.0212083831,
0.0267749615,
0.0563876629,
0.0095714778,
-0.0731403828,
-0.0101671843,
0.0414072089,
-0.0323370099,
0.0633369833,
0.0282830242,
0.0019403567,
0.00954156,
-0.0297419466,
-0.0348927751,
0.0409587026,
-0.0023914394,
-0.0754315853,
-0.0252447464,
-0.0028897335,
0.0255830791,
0.0305928998,
-0.0161950402,
-0.0180578008,
-0.0094478149,
-0.0010065032,
-0.055850666,
-0.0028717178,
-0.0412051082,
0.0009774028,
0.0175248235,
0.0122665716,
-0.0249752123,
2.53462847e-34,
0.011061036,
-0.0038365305,
0.0197244603,
-0.0345494412,
0.0010795788,
-0.0093363347,
0.0248781089,
-0.0070705288,
0.0034154169,
-0.0179802794,
-0.0961710364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04146v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04146v2 | NESTLE: a No-Code Tool for Statistical Analysis of Legal Corpus | 2023-09-08T06:23:25 | 2024-02-05T23:28:15 | Kyoungyeon Cho, Seungkum Han, Young Rok Choi, Wonseok Hwang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The statistical analysis of large scale legal corpus can provide valuable
legal insights. For such analysis one needs to (1) select a subset of the
corpus using document retrieval tools, (2) structure text using information
extraction (IE) systems, and (3) visualize the data for the statistical
analysis. Each process demands either specialized tools or programming skills
whereas no comprehensive unified "no-code" tools have been available. Here we
provide NESTLE, a no-code tool for large-scale statistical analysis of legal
corpus. Powered by a Large Language Model (LLM) and the internal custom
end-to-end IE system, NESTLE can extract any type of information that has not
been predefined in the IE system opening up the possibility of unlimited
customizable statistical analysis of the corpus without writing a single line
of code. We validate our system on 15 Korean precedent IE tasks and 3 legal
text classification tasks from LexGLUE. The comprehensive experiments reveal
NESTLE can achieve GPT-4 comparable performance by training the internal IE
module with 4 human-labeled, and 192 LLM-labeled examples. | [
0.0675924346,
0.0468843095,
-0.0077762683,
0.0260222964,
-0.0620542094,
0.0509326458,
0.0310380962,
0.0537531599,
0.0301507637,
-0.0658460408,
-0.0023436451,
0.0108584734,
-0.0212605745,
-0.0071981438,
0.0007995734,
-0.0399399027,
0.0241856966,
0.0295132808,
0.0860380605,
0.0169522148,
0.0247044768,
0.0224177931,
0.0377112739,
0.0065495581,
-0.0282354075,
0.0036330598,
-0.0120039321,
-0.0020533497,
0.0078214081,
-0.0222509,
-0.0048014456,
0.0762210786,
-0.0058168261,
0.032200031,
0.0000018003,
-0.0704092383,
-0.0057608718,
0.0055622011,
-0.0056025279,
0.0370237753,
0.0622979701,
-0.0331899449,
-0.0463704728,
-0.0261201374,
-0.0398607999,
-0.0088251978,
0.0115743894,
0.0148227857,
0.034907572,
0.0897556841,
-0.02888209,
-0.0759618506,
0.0270554051,
-0.0378890932,
0.0019874964,
-0.0395875461,
0.0500385314,
0.0140085146,
0.0214920845,
-0.0110052135,
0.0211557969,
-0.0001979388,
0.0214597974,
-0.0424799882,
-0.0323618576,
-0.0176187064,
-0.0647640228,
-0.0076530585,
0.0147555079,
0.0457195826,
0.0235980153,
-0.0396329984,
0.0264759082,
-0.0073977611,
0.0537366457,
0.0004791743,
-0.0221171994,
0.0942317247,
-0.0314600244,
0.0163140483,
0.0424638093,
0.0037925311,
-0.0049126446,
0.0151645625,
-0.040239919,
0.0591175482,
0.0141712138,
-0.0582213365,
0.045364935,
0.0048057847,
0.0138946045,
-0.0391712971,
0.0401827693,
-0.0110374428,
0.0203507617,
0.0390564501,
-0.0277843941,
-0.0589189529,
0.0612282604,
-0.0655806288,
-0.0118156085,
-0.0100471759,
-0.0308817457,
0.0742314681,
-0.039573811,
-0.0011498407,
0.0200020429,
0.0159522574,
-0.0042430004,
-0.0308282264,
-0.0244253762,
0.0085565913,
-0.0379385166,
0.0239776988,
-0.0873059258,
0.0148931108,
-0.0405450948,
0.0193360168,
-0.0084314188,
0.0192872025,
0.0002200432,
-0.0358729921,
-0.0149627421,
-0.0147434035,
-0.0449365564,
-0.064447917,
-0.0278945882,
0.0268905293,
-0.0169104468,
-0.0050353683,
0.02966059,
0.0364634097,
0.0237317756,
-0.028984407,
0.0183633734,
0.0460180081,
-0.0241254345,
-0.0471302234,
-0.0290180929,
-0.0334594697,
-0.0504473411,
-0.0612319745,
-0.0368705094,
-0.0727614537,
-0.0072383517,
-0.0204717796,
-0.022676751,
-0.0551600046,
0.015160027,
0.039037127,
-0.0285705496,
0.0513898209,
0.0103199463,
-0.0291479118,
-0.0259693265,
0.0003018815,
0.05190029,
0.0256806705,
0.0026144984,
0.0247780643,
0.03630054,
-0.0100876531,
0.0178550929,
0.0754479542,
-0.020279618,
0.0100751538,
-0.0170801356,
0.0081284232,
-0.0059848102,
-0.0360622182,
-0.0025350067,
0.029492341,
-0.0006828887,
-0.0074664745,
0.0085902177,
0.0995493978,
0.0035869798,
0.0508787893,
-0.0183746777,
0.0011678163,
0.0447861962,
-0.0258014519,
-0.0345267951,
-0.0149477348,
-0.0208383556,
0.0300469026,
-0.0587710068,
0.0259348098,
-0.0040678508,
-0.0411028601,
-0.0141325975,
-0.0028032239,
0.0189624429,
-0.0071789105,
0.0825353861,
0.0132901352,
-0.0170805659,
0.0294330195,
0.0437765084,
-0.0599575378,
-0.0360597558,
-0.0152748348,
-0.0007797495,
0.0188933648,
0.0386888757,
-0.0371098109,
0.0229185559,
-0.027316872,
-0.0214307886,
0.0783223808,
0.0162668005,
-0.0196646508,
-0.019896701,
-0.0362397768,
-0.0383444764,
0.0492764339,
0.0496617034,
-0.0027851653,
0.0208471529,
0.0084187351,
0.051068563,
-0.0453165919,
-0.0023847495,
0.0419925302,
0.0023301314,
-0.0503616817,
0.0085241599,
-0.0087088645,
0.0661434531,
0.0242725667,
-0.0234191902,
-0.0304548088,
0.0337191261,
-0.0010887291,
0.003054827,
0.0063010976,
0.0384231694,
-0.0398716703,
0.0290202554,
-0.0447805263,
-0.026425438,
-0.0086025978,
-0.0477024354,
-0.0187936947,
-0.0438884608,
0.0051719341,
0.034289483,
-0.0733066723,
0.0048238751,
-0.0106747821,
-0.0127646374,
-0.0643927306,
0.047001522,
0.0231388882,
-0.0312374178,
0.011588661,
-0.023449989,
0.0254551321,
-0.027638074,
-0.0215575546,
-0.0098922914,
-0.0246433858,
0.0102849547,
0.0229119156,
0.0269016493,
-0.0492787138,
-0.0533997528,
-0.1144828126,
0.0166687332,
-0.0239647161,
0.0251362473,
0.017814422,
-0.0143766729,
-0.0444154814,
-0.0210560299,
-0.0225901902,
-0.015173018,
-0.0002564402,
-0.015902482,
0.0255907495,
-0.0345462821,
0.000035349,
-0.0178778023,
-0.0186383296,
-0.0351180062,
0.0103184851,
0.0522320494,
-0.0573782176,
-0.0106757488,
0.0733029619,
0.0043252255,
-0.0179116782,
-0.0223738179,
-0.0079544177,
-0.0201276746,
-0.031156702,
-0.0339142084,
0.0270450171,
0.0361799486,
0.0162454732,
0.0082926918,
-0.0322120599,
-0.0471849181,
-0.0001823522,
-0.000355132,
0.0199220367,
-0.0382256918,
-0.0107824886,
0.0236684512,
0.030636698,
0.0273799133,
0.0220083557,
-0.0112503804,
-0.0153491748,
-0.0201114565,
0.0173667334,
-0.0107937492,
0.0180659592,
-0.0445760451,
0.0319970958,
0.011170405,
-0.0662024915,
0.0399089083,
0.0044384766,
0.0488933399,
-0.0722412467,
-0.0013581835,
-0.0387850031,
0.0715693831,
-0.0032227323,
0.0000169262,
0.0059447633,
-0.06075757,
0.0370710157,
-0.009772934,
0.0440077521,
-0.0564069375,
0.0705057085,
-0.0188476294,
0.0618701167,
-0.0325855166,
-0.0291480459,
-0.0261793789,
-0.0559414923,
-0.0066245561,
0.0164482072,
0.0275254399,
0.0122687863,
0.0160953216,
0.0043691518,
-0.0139643541,
-0.0053076074,
0.0147876665,
0.0042259479,
-0.0242664255,
0.044706516,
0.0238318183,
-0.0466032028,
-0.0449336879,
-0.0029508919,
-0.0102260802,
0.0248336047,
-0.0243804213,
0.0307700485,
0.0231658183,
-0.0003245689,
0.0004728354,
-0.0497800708,
-0.0028254038,
0.0296083894,
0.0167008974,
-0.0525563918,
0.0519853346,
0.101628527,
0.0349085219,
-0.0485299788,
-0.0402840376,
0.0147988712,
0.0058144769,
0.0350494049,
0.0376081765,
-0.0966029614,
0.0062231454,
0.0203877855,
-0.0173558965,
-0.0386492796,
-0.0246901605,
-0.0010486897,
-0.0904757753,
0.1077185273,
0.0321816318,
-0.0278085154,
-0.0301041175,
-0.0308754388,
0.0120655084,
-0.007264609,
-0.0059217294,
0.0037905404,
-0.0138186412,
-0.0209288225,
-0.0024489379,
-0.0590658374,
0.0065673739,
0.0358241163,
-0.0297951717,
0.0247339513,
0.0238875654,
0.0478946306,
-0.0563570932,
-0.0027422577,
0.043419905,
-0.0392932706,
-0.0155236209,
-0.0175363868,
0.0660991073,
0.0364774168,
-0.0025516588,
-0.0660629794,
0.0397238173,
-0.0075718551,
-0.0025250723,
0.0554087907,
0.0496129133,
-0.010275797,
-0.0065468112,
0.0093948701,
-0.0364041515,
-0.0179201066,
0.0351038724,
-0.0086485026,
-0.0035364027,
-0.0286971238,
-0.0610433221,
-0.0309848543,
-0.0315435454,
-0.0269638728,
0.0073656132,
-0.0549261607,
-0.015187718,
-0.0507396907,
-0.0271813069,
0.0067400392,
0.0516966768,
0.028087467,
0.0200670734,
0.0360199548,
-0.0104065901,
-0.0402684361,
0.0157360695,
-0.0506029762,
-0.0139760049,
-0.0081717968,
-0.00687664,
-0.0006642541,
0.0256508589,
-0.0096165678,
0.0035002409,
0.0074997302,
-0.0453609899,
0.0037552239,
-0.019390095,
0.0144625083,
-0.0060155867,
-0.0474176407,
-0.0152121224,
0.0688060224,
0.0393305346,
-0.0254233107,
-0.0190923475,
0.0432676785,
-0.0473051108,
-0.0289239381,
-0.0153877242,
-0.0148164993,
0.0332113728,
0.0313428044,
0.0071512978,
-0.0516782254,
-0.0055131661,
0.0343689397,
0.084613733,
0.0353967734,
0.0099223386,
-0.0204817653,
-0.0440575294,
-0.0127826398,
-0.0282068588,
-0.0144633809,
-0.0076016122,
-0.0035026188,
0.0341823027,
-0.025522979,
-0.0370257199,
0.1061144546,
-0.037748497,
-0.002389723,
-0.037414819,
0.0372949727,
0.0065893196,
0.0310792699,
0.0186218694,
-0.0379217826,
0.0038564426,
0.0104754344,
-0.0093604503,
0.0557109378,
-0.0119059272,
0.0541751832,
-0.0208841246,
-0.020671973,
0.0174697395,
0.0108548393,
-0.0044910265,
0.0239279848,
-0.0212294664,
0.0246425942,
0.0706622005,
-0.0256642886,
0.0403129309,
-0.0472559296,
-0.0183851756,
-0.0181905515,
0.0284348056,
-0.0124228122,
-0.0132433698,
0.0087746372,
0.0054790066,
-0.0447650254,
0.0180178843,
0.0183951687,
0.0349448845,
0.018741684,
0.0176037345,
-0.031772878,
-0.0308557879,
-0.0162301622,
0.0317783952,
0.006318124,
-0.0421901904,
-0.0670734644,
-0.0696736351,
-0.0284342077,
-0.0333702378,
0.0067336336,
-0.0040048417,
0.0252872705,
-0.0015020542,
0.0627115965,
-0.0064104362,
-0.0248460006,
-0.0600502901,
0.0332459509,
0.0158225242,
-0.0206580348,
0.0050707143,
-5.91656686e-33,
-0.0091733299,
-0.0291130226,
-0.0010761539,
0.0466608591,
0.0016391275,
-0.0260509942,
-0.0219930578,
0.0030898056,
0.0017798985,
0.0223046094,
-0.0188377947,
0.0087499246,
0.0322813243,
-0.0025417469,
0.0468797199,
-0.0007794879,
-0.0051616691,
0.0085735992,
0.0033740145,
0.0122653525,
0.0186589938,
0.0255377889,
0.0372678302,
-0.0963578969,
0.0582031645,
0.0587124564,
0.0067502558,
-0.0488657802,
-0.0267992113,
0.0461015999,
-0.0101648197,
0.0328329913,
0.0250710919,
-0.039806813,
-0.0165496618,
0.039794255,
-0.0880786404,
0.0206532069,
-0.0096257981,
-0.0004495171,
0.0325367637,
-0.0349982008,
0.0277552921,
-0.0228552073,
-0.0238335952,
-0.0048325588,
0.0567388348,
-0.0413031057,
-0.0343978107,
-0.065704003,
-0.0676765516,
0.0898693949,
-0.0076328311,
0.0548400134,
0.0661922246,
-0.0161607862,
-0.0076952782,
0.0602250658,
-0.0314161144,
-0.0073381457,
-0.0096110199,
-0.0144679174,
0.0123913959,
-0.0518947132,
0.0066915788,
0.0455848537,
-0.0021110766,
-0.0034524677,
-0.0212591458,
-0.0035399615,
0.0304386169,
0.0896394476,
-0.0001844985,
0.0561227761,
0.0499977022,
-0.0478253327,
-0.0885321647,
-0.0140690831,
0.0455185883,
0.0090445271,
0.0157028195,
-0.0159188043,
-0.0535021648,
-0.0110216755,
-0.0095170531,
-0.0466448925,
-0.0003557191,
0.0025133339,
0.0309899282,
0.0133730592,
0.0182529017,
-0.0189590212,
0.0039834208,
-0.0352052487,
0.0016569027,
0.019129755,
-0.0052586128,
0.026802808,
-0.0178342164,
0.0166395381,
-0.0716983601,
-0.0483346209,
-0.0208350662,
0.0088049788,
0.0016677408,
-0.0068894378,
0.0510338247,
-0.0259569399,
-0.0801556483,
-0.0017241647,
0.0103231473,
-0.0026140276,
0.0394777991,
0.0162790343,
-0.0047964863,
0.0387723185,
0.0546390451,
0.0146739008,
0.0407558903,
-0.0166278072,
-0.0244906452,
-0.0164430141,
0.0033526991,
-0.0353324004,
0.0295624174,
0.0055779135,
0.0135111026,
0.0598483197,
0.0658366978,
0.0120449672,
0.0344775356,
0.0526237488,
2.517e-7,
0.1001256406,
0.0594710596,
0.0079493644,
-0.0084014079,
0.002888822,
0.0380620547,
0.0076306323,
0.0322015882,
0.034198273,
-0.0200333446,
0.0232112389,
-0.0157022364,
0.0884027034,
0.0573185869,
-0.0956706032,
-0.0049187862,
-0.0058921063,
-0.0626492128,
-0.0627949163,
0.0489664972,
0.0476037823,
0.0967397615,
0.0220723934,
-0.0102286292,
-0.0055591492,
-0.0474310741,
0.0480767004,
-0.0308600441,
-0.0284032729,
-0.0061155888,
0.0619259961,
-0.0492620096,
-0.0053502279,
0.040612381,
-0.0102819698,
0.0474277548,
-0.0477379598,
0.1016842946,
0.0031862184,
0.0794260576,
-0.0049119205,
-0.060501568,
0.0093544433,
-0.0497041717,
0.070530504,
-0.0019915078,
0.0106302844,
-0.0299024656,
-0.0210973509,
-0.0273560118,
0.0037711216,
0.0049556536,
-0.0153600425,
0.0095560774,
0.0361912102,
-0.0204506218,
-0.0142684141,
-0.0743646547,
-0.0037108145,
0.0453785993,
-0.0252195317,
-0.0000272581,
0.0054018074,
0.0196632445,
0.0313551761,
-0.0536446124,
0.0619086288,
2.312134481e-34,
0.0299905036,
-0.0036953406,
-0.0163689964,
0.0081500243,
0.0331691131,
0.0242061261,
-0.0344939195,
0.0470500514,
-0.0420699716,
-0.0890515968,
0.0451194718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04141v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04141v1 | RST-style Discourse Parsing Guided by Document-level Content Structures | 2023-09-08T05:50:27 | 2023-09-08T05:50:27 | Ming Li, Ruihong Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Rhetorical Structure Theory based Discourse Parsing (RST-DP) explores how
clauses, sentences, and large text spans compose a whole discourse and presents
the rhetorical structure as a hierarchical tree. Existing RST parsing pipelines
construct rhetorical structures without the knowledge of document-level content
structures, which causes relatively low performance when predicting the
discourse relations for large text spans. Recognizing the value of high-level
content-related information in facilitating discourse relation recognition, we
propose a novel pipeline for RST-DP that incorporates structure-aware news
content sentence representations derived from the task of News Discourse
Profiling. By incorporating only a few additional layers, this enhanced
pipeline exhibits promising performance across various RST parsing metrics. | [
0.0261505432,
0.0202239472,
-0.0068581579,
0.0141317025,
-0.0308977701,
0.0196653735,
-0.0354529358,
-0.0211440288,
0.0064633586,
-0.057513617,
0.0136635788,
0.0106655136,
-0.0037221406,
0.0020851456,
-0.0535268076,
-0.0622766651,
0.0310806036,
-0.0082834987,
0.0807323307,
0.0329915546,
0.0369835868,
0.0324493796,
0.019548934,
0.0055929981,
-0.0379494019,
-0.0858688429,
0.001182652,
0.0152304303,
0.0287973396,
-0.077496022,
0.0515958034,
0.0184560884,
0.0235924497,
0.0118229752,
0.0000016905,
0.0063190712,
-0.041869171,
-0.0064372709,
0.0013643246,
0.0352343768,
0.064908959,
-0.0357714258,
-0.0134620341,
0.0078556389,
-0.0111889997,
0.0069705229,
-0.0159174651,
0.1042548493,
0.06944222,
0.0689902678,
-0.0296054967,
-0.0310120564,
0.0360699929,
0.0347315706,
-0.0614967532,
-0.0286577102,
0.0011595694,
0.0094189551,
-0.0002878186,
0.0502880923,
0.0268449001,
-0.0010978674,
0.0116753783,
-0.031804245,
-0.0301456172,
0.026399862,
-0.0172708184,
0.0063000903,
-0.0038605484,
0.0201082882,
0.0403188653,
-0.0133597581,
0.0365281999,
-0.0034957218,
-0.0039654342,
-0.0357428305,
-0.0208944157,
0.0175826214,
-0.0678470209,
0.0560546592,
0.0428103544,
-0.0070241014,
-0.021754479,
0.0079543255,
0.028079683,
0.0719787702,
-0.0277644712,
-0.0395521149,
-0.0095478659,
0.0379369073,
0.0080145467,
-0.0392403789,
0.0259134099,
-0.0269156396,
-0.0380260088,
-0.0037461508,
-0.0253845565,
-0.0534501337,
0.0160954725,
-0.084594138,
-0.0042927405,
-0.0111104799,
0.0078461701,
0.0267307963,
-0.0199868381,
0.0191843454,
-0.0319759361,
-0.0494791009,
-0.0088449214,
-0.0255617015,
-0.0839346945,
-0.0709071755,
-0.0515227206,
0.0547002293,
-0.0971895903,
-0.0528030619,
-0.0135744382,
0.0014126453,
0.0186622217,
-0.0140005331,
-0.0026218779,
0.0189403091,
-0.01932461,
0.0321230143,
-0.0037168388,
0.0482537635,
-0.0375980251,
-0.014095353,
-0.0058510192,
0.0250529461,
-0.0249393843,
0.0330340005,
0.0177218374,
-0.0176661275,
-0.0346281417,
0.0423574299,
-0.0254318491,
-0.0041763145,
-0.0074783321,
-0.0334984362,
-0.0217088386,
-0.021451788,
0.0401625112,
-0.0322054923,
-0.0107265124,
0.0020325789,
0.0073455372,
0.0187073741,
0.0236306395,
0.029758472,
-0.0280000959,
0.0045980033,
0.0331553183,
-0.0004540198,
0.0228763241,
-0.00559776,
0.0275670625,
0.0933366045,
0.0558713749,
0.0164404344,
0.0265782177,
0.0111263599,
-0.0366103351,
-0.0110854479,
-0.0544703193,
-0.0380740166,
0.0242033228,
0.0295665804,
-0.035706114,
0.0009237968,
0.033131633,
0.0172653906,
-0.0296102371,
-0.0169910528,
-0.000226368,
0.0328486115,
-0.0152464109,
0.028678529,
0.0563582182,
0.0658383593,
0.0313973688,
0.0481733568,
-0.0000368537,
-0.0149450386,
0.0166186783,
-0.0152025912,
-0.0529970191,
0.0358425342,
0.0061945547,
0.0123571577,
-0.0001789905,
0.008867505,
0.004075075,
-0.0656918436,
0.0099225258,
0.0101297209,
-0.0410763323,
0.039598003,
0.0437386185,
-0.0280494392,
-0.0204047747,
0.0253934357,
-0.0285370518,
0.0241839364,
0.0221908744,
-0.0442852117,
-0.0050023422,
-0.0135681657,
0.069721356,
0.0728320926,
0.0090179574,
-0.0128692305,
0.00213624,
0.0050767041,
-0.0133433044,
-0.0413432531,
0.0259711556,
0.0258276928,
0.0153259216,
-0.0262898803,
0.0036817156,
0.0203931946,
-0.0200376343,
-0.0003013521,
-0.0026501773,
0.0027242587,
0.0253278464,
-0.0217041057,
0.0142881749,
0.0492378771,
-0.0013360906,
-0.0059251855,
-0.0098014511,
-0.0535011366,
0.0048739309,
0.0035038688,
-0.0759786218,
-0.0147263575,
-0.0086473348,
-0.0314908847,
-0.0656532496,
0.0029207466,
-0.011544887,
-0.0364258923,
0.0329236537,
-0.0449250676,
0.0278537348,
-0.0222259853,
-0.0240280703,
0.0044379947,
-0.0096374014,
-0.0173211917,
0.0983809754,
0.028524138,
-0.0268700533,
0.0067700283,
-0.0697633401,
0.0114604747,
-0.0012075168,
0.0115211345,
-0.0068054441,
-0.0008245141,
-0.0373746715,
0.0409861058,
-0.0150151672,
-0.0394750945,
-0.0318439342,
-0.0866621584,
0.015892202,
-0.0185577888,
0.0528404452,
0.0370833725,
-0.009580059,
-0.0037628575,
-0.02195956,
-0.0068015861,
-0.0463687442,
0.0027411701,
0.0029476928,
0.0619768798,
-0.0279221665,
0.0169857442,
-0.0187482424,
0.0051746056,
-0.0821803659,
0.0516480878,
0.0100769131,
-0.0532656349,
-0.01704216,
-0.0202461574,
0.0148716513,
-0.0112120528,
0.0018865701,
-0.0282552596,
0.0220512953,
0.0093310708,
0.0734743774,
0.0757818669,
0.0174579676,
0.0370126292,
-0.0158440769,
-0.0367234275,
-0.0078817001,
0.0444491766,
-0.0196285192,
0.0834490433,
-0.0757198781,
0.0235539712,
0.0190691017,
0.0694566369,
-0.0123629598,
0.0475912057,
-0.0190188512,
0.0119119165,
-0.0261557009,
-0.0064722211,
0.0492429323,
-0.0514749549,
-0.0049002427,
-0.0116087077,
-0.0444359109,
0.0325276814,
0.0417867526,
-0.0372010358,
-0.0175895784,
-0.073411949,
-0.0190580189,
-0.0518292636,
0.0513943098,
0.0126164127,
-0.0067705237,
-0.004888915,
-0.0905030295,
0.0119273541,
-0.0342683196,
0.0426241346,
0.0053811036,
0.0235880204,
-0.0167110432,
-0.0067170709,
-0.0358389579,
-0.0476203449,
-0.0225504488,
-0.0298559777,
-0.0232375376,
0.0220894683,
-0.0348774567,
-0.0251664463,
0.0027537502,
-0.0038906774,
0.0192328636,
0.0189210717,
-0.0404272042,
0.0033964082,
-0.0327038057,
0.0808683261,
0.028464539,
0.0173058361,
0.0273989625,
0.0006617699,
0.0611588992,
0.0501708314,
-0.0409061983,
0.0049548117,
-0.0152950604,
0.001990167,
-0.0388342366,
-0.0341520645,
-0.0425336361,
-0.0516418554,
0.065000087,
-0.0677382573,
-0.0253153071,
0.0906165391,
0.033336658,
-0.0120559158,
-0.0156034743,
-0.0129305804,
0.0268768575,
0.0061436105,
0.0199303348,
-0.0509961993,
0.0149325524,
0.0135904625,
-0.0091605261,
-0.0175502133,
-0.0657164007,
0.0031072113,
-0.0532383583,
0.030606674,
-0.0198801588,
0.0273366459,
0.0107857548,
-0.0307773277,
-0.0040695113,
0.0277213957,
-0.0003943716,
-0.0147790769,
-0.0576839745,
0.0044727148,
0.0068064057,
-0.0659668222,
0.0113044027,
-0.0048791436,
0.0153389052,
-0.0329305492,
0.0076259845,
0.0520589314,
0.0042917798,
0.0371793285,
0.0148806795,
-0.0470972061,
0.0083970064,
-0.0160100125,
-0.0015458042,
0.0006637968,
-0.0096352855,
-0.0574120954,
0.0201605074,
-0.027293494,
-0.025714742,
0.029187005,
0.0622079745,
-0.0345590934,
-0.0134433927,
-0.0255706497,
0.0129426317,
-0.0139063401,
0.0555220582,
0.0486090779,
0.0171080921,
-0.0903787091,
-0.0377636403,
0.0327742882,
-0.0622851364,
0.01136568,
0.007279804,
0.0291130617,
0.0536653064,
-0.0439709611,
-0.0464283153,
-0.013230226,
-0.0217428748,
-0.0325411409,
0.0072433162,
0.0456121527,
-0.0078286203,
-0.0359712876,
-0.0177890602,
-0.0075930157,
-0.0229294579,
-0.0099719148,
0.0086241011,
0.0404874943,
-0.0023448006,
-0.0387987755,
-0.0384104326,
-0.0337108858,
-0.0381352566,
0.007412055,
-0.0427576602,
0.0020820408,
0.0583189167,
-0.0192344878,
0.0120515265,
0.0541944094,
0.0419533141,
-0.0899089724,
0.0178041998,
0.0426839739,
0.0312120654,
0.0024895966,
0.0210286397,
0.0142437201,
0.0426856354,
-0.0277828444,
0.0311722346,
-0.0110037243,
0.026875278,
0.0102659361,
-0.0272173192,
0.0471562557,
0.0461340025,
0.0125726778,
-0.0244544763,
0.0291543864,
-0.0723486915,
-0.0262354389,
-0.0238114018,
0.0179647561,
-0.0084814746,
-0.0095911482,
-0.0340731852,
0.0464650057,
0.0101409545,
0.0918460488,
-0.0169301275,
0.0569309071,
0.0595966913,
0.0087823765,
-0.0215399116,
-0.0418611839,
0.0051735132,
-0.0002236858,
-0.0150287896,
0.0365954265,
-0.0131742312,
0.0217254478,
0.0236169044,
-0.0233963262,
0.0223944373,
0.0017817972,
-0.0815061852,
0.0169931445,
0.013792525,
-0.023883123,
0.0273653939,
-0.0387762524,
0.0838821456,
-0.0194044877,
-0.0016188257,
0.0034131599,
0.0365091078,
0.0134377833,
-0.0206995662,
-0.0104428977,
0.0245631766,
-0.0519472398,
-0.0031841767,
0.0346428677,
0.0053399387,
0.0082012787,
0.0746588707,
-0.0345176235,
-0.0384086706,
-0.1035104394,
-0.01891011,
0.0377810039,
0.0164072923,
0.0244268328,
-0.0271000229,
0.0251544453,
0.0582954809,
-0.0385023728,
0.0038244375,
-0.0376565531,
-0.0074425582,
0.0435679853,
0.0233003031,
-0.0469198823,
-0.0477287695,
-0.0051815035,
-0.0290925633,
-0.0227568615,
-0.0098792436,
-5.892245147e-33,
-0.0578228645,
-0.0180781055,
0.0109811304,
0.0655041486,
-0.047186885,
0.0881099552,
-0.0727275237,
-0.0021446384,
0.0246196594,
0.0609599575,
-0.0235588066,
0.0181217194,
0.0141555667,
0.0381072089,
0.0209692605,
0.0201936401,
0.0665509328,
-0.0264123268,
-0.0029818818,
0.0509373285,
0.0643794313,
0.0315343514,
0.0684675202,
-0.0503900126,
-0.0260494631,
-0.0032654032,
0.0078229764,
0.0062643136,
0.0498998091,
0.0457512513,
-0.0115635563,
-0.0141170705,
0.0481965393,
0.000085426,
-0.0112618543,
0.0813883618,
-0.1171327904,
-0.0344176032,
0.0075622615,
-0.0266596526,
-0.0258548763,
-0.0200237967,
0.0145870345,
0.0109437993,
0.0606251657,
-0.0344877057,
0.0404158458,
-0.0061745108,
0.0204367191,
-0.0487401709,
-0.0614267588,
0.0564055704,
-0.0024490361,
0.0640474558,
0.0239420347,
0.0293556191,
0.0326219276,
0.0262591187,
-0.0370558873,
-0.0328109786,
-0.0494530462,
0.0466330387,
-0.0511463732,
-0.0069305045,
-0.0121796746,
0.0747704133,
-0.0398311429,
-0.0052731629,
-0.0294951014,
0.081139043,
-0.0075564142,
0.0049176528,
-0.0057273237,
0.0262017064,
-0.037742395,
0.0239438005,
-0.0741670802,
-0.0290687662,
0.0344878137,
0.0542642623,
-0.0038921132,
-0.015206934,
0.0069662207,
-0.000649625,
-0.0038728893,
-0.02831861,
0.0179862082,
-0.0206153784,
-0.0002886757,
0.0038145743,
-0.0028641156,
0.006478325,
0.0321510285,
-0.0181107745,
-0.0149313044,
0.0307386965,
-0.0092515713,
0.0183840357,
0.0292434171,
0.0450298451,
-0.0184031501,
-0.0297627002,
-0.0070886393,
-0.0059726862,
0.0061322721,
-0.0228213724,
0.0411474109,
-0.0321596488,
-0.0334945843,
0.025338633,
0.002572919,
0.0466655828,
-0.0703798085,
0.0989815667,
0.0242539179,
0.0227140207,
0.0045961486,
0.0563779064,
-0.0051409206,
0.0390237495,
-0.0307230204,
0.0105672982,
-0.0179249998,
0.054838419,
-0.0098965131,
-0.0156352539,
-0.0139147826,
0.0007358358,
0.0246546343,
-0.0456215106,
0.008344112,
0.006783125,
2.359e-7,
0.0118766315,
0.0582103431,
0.071356371,
0.0085856654,
0.0569548272,
0.0126651097,
0.0529449098,
0.070013538,
-0.0233165566,
-0.0485403687,
-0.0244808979,
0.0093109347,
0.0223061666,
0.0599011369,
-0.1417941749,
-0.0208283067,
-0.0839118361,
-0.0460477024,
-0.0655362755,
0.0091557084,
0.0627574474,
0.0330437459,
-0.0168714505,
0.0148551334,
-0.0255906302,
-0.0031877796,
0.0393213592,
0.0124257142,
-0.0118636498,
0.0461909175,
-0.0257891081,
-0.0370907299,
0.0061579379,
0.0010398194,
-0.0107463896,
0.0444897637,
-0.0235208329,
0.0673357993,
0.040893577,
-0.0090973629,
0.0048593692,
0.0052282708,
0.00491367,
-0.0076337922,
0.0357108973,
-0.0495068803,
-0.0249936376,
-0.0822477341,
-0.0501160249,
-0.0300658774,
-0.0132341692,
0.0355595984,
-0.0073037595,
0.040333271,
-0.0240114443,
-0.0359594077,
0.0249200333,
-0.0684692934,
-0.008326048,
0.0144555215,
-0.0239013545,
0.0216447543,
-0.0207238831,
-0.0003574039,
0.010441443,
-0.0338563435,
0.0102039566,
2.207568289e-34,
0.0301595535,
-0.0228310972,
0.0102443406,
0.0118251974,
0.0447847173,
0.0224625096,
-0.0182934552,
0.0145078199,
0.0019415742,
-0.0783377364,
0.0273927357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06415v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06415v4 | Down the Toxicity Rabbit Hole: A Novel Framework to Bias Audit Large Language Models | 2023-09-08T03:59:02 | 2024-03-31T02:24:39 | Arka Dutta, Adel Khorramrouz, Sujan Dutta, Ashiqur R. KhudaBukhsh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | This paper makes three contributions. First, it presents a generalizable,
novel framework dubbed \textit{toxicity rabbit hole} that iteratively elicits
toxic content from a wide suite of large language models. Spanning a set of
1,266 identity groups, we first conduct a bias audit of \texttt{PaLM 2}
guardrails presenting key insights. Next, we report generalizability across
several other models. Through the elicited toxic content, we present a broad
analysis with a key emphasis on racism, antisemitism, misogyny, Islamophobia,
homophobia, and transphobia. Finally, driven by concrete examples, we discuss
potential ramifications. | [
0.0301083457,
0.0617442504,
-0.047927212,
0.0226606391,
-0.0135985995,
0.0359802581,
0.0498943292,
-0.0000037895,
0.0438998193,
-0.0479420014,
-0.0137767987,
0.0142390765,
-0.006577732,
0.0081436578,
0.0273423027,
-0.0197650343,
0.0486210994,
0.0174943954,
0.0012513723,
-0.0236664321,
0.0174921621,
0.0465866923,
0.0202818178,
0.0662382022,
-0.028205229,
-0.0163073428,
0.0523983128,
-0.0143054649,
0.0533910021,
-0.0203815885,
0.0238382574,
0.0342772491,
-0.030022135,
0.047417108,
0.0000018717,
-0.0425669439,
0.0056389226,
0.024306275,
0.008291482,
-0.0051835924,
0.0671403185,
-0.0129435109,
-0.0267547164,
0.0370780453,
0.0076168291,
-0.0027441548,
0.048950512,
0.0168089122,
0.0526594333,
0.0239788052,
-0.020648839,
-0.0079202857,
-0.0169746391,
0.0115586426,
-0.0048397407,
0.0170275345,
0.0650494695,
-0.0380871966,
-0.0531607158,
0.0027061454,
-0.0259524249,
0.0130260987,
0.0359830484,
-0.0218153764,
-0.0011107277,
-0.0374239013,
-0.0085485,
-0.0521928631,
0.0252964161,
0.0358186252,
-0.0340432413,
0.0075143655,
0.0060312622,
0.0107187359,
-0.009394248,
0.0012625835,
0.0109537067,
0.024981603,
-0.0229445901,
-0.0164567959,
0.0334915258,
0.0055528604,
0.0393264368,
0.0562813617,
0.0281689428,
0.0444199666,
0.0340731256,
-0.0182417594,
0.0285950582,
-0.021129854,
0.0287857372,
-0.0198234785,
0.0256091598,
-0.0233261343,
-0.0134121608,
0.0393830165,
-0.0120202163,
-0.0064932001,
0.0514927991,
-0.0707449988,
0.0283518415,
0.0454627126,
-0.0498576723,
0.0114140939,
0.0135935321,
0.0099619264,
-0.019571254,
-0.0020096572,
0.0152116399,
0.0149517693,
0.019851286,
-0.0058466168,
0.0156488847,
-0.0156006003,
0.0243063811,
0.0747299194,
-0.0475507416,
0.0135943312,
-0.0832176805,
0.0157651361,
-0.0160020031,
-0.0025922193,
0.0089022135,
0.0167307016,
-0.0087434277,
-0.003408456,
-0.0486362651,
0.0058791372,
-0.0406838991,
-0.0572316013,
0.0230843779,
0.0286969151,
-0.0478531756,
-0.0460226648,
0.0004650711,
0.0982541367,
0.0286489725,
-0.0229738299,
-0.0064617358,
-0.0223702434,
-0.0568942241,
-0.0387392566,
-0.0094134528,
-0.0599189103,
0.0078410106,
-0.0037790288,
-0.0165953618,
-0.0854817927,
-0.0113935834,
0.0168555919,
-0.0534004234,
0.0401621647,
0.011682217,
-0.0093395235,
0.0378509052,
0.0364587419,
-0.0066031208,
0.0665360391,
-0.011182541,
0.0201405156,
0.026642317,
-0.022012718,
0.0028899717,
0.0500562191,
0.018676931,
0.0646760911,
-0.0505295284,
0.0167599618,
0.0255995803,
-0.0601612031,
0.0083304318,
0.0580934174,
-0.0138270976,
-0.0557279512,
0.0311991125,
0.0600581653,
-0.0637016892,
0.0273338631,
0.0532002449,
-0.008450293,
-0.0417923629,
-0.0011279479,
-0.0738006681,
-0.0549583957,
-0.0307709798,
-0.0589287765,
0.0099257026,
0.0612438284,
-0.0025455735,
-0.0297351852,
-0.0252328347,
0.0254592001,
0.0627401471,
-0.0156955644,
0.0181731619,
0.008628387,
-0.0001547631,
0.0071297325,
0.0703430176,
-0.0284588374,
0.0145197092,
-0.0337107629,
0.023046134,
0.0436917171,
0.0216517467,
-0.0205940064,
0.0308095105,
-0.046122279,
-0.0170468837,
0.04682374,
0.0373013131,
-0.0151863405,
-0.0295992736,
-0.0044401949,
-0.0037380354,
0.0601855144,
0.0368126035,
0.0322367512,
0.0501611903,
0.0280046351,
-0.0036224981,
0.0208543539,
-0.0796125531,
0.0146437669,
0.003454223,
-0.04431016,
-0.0302092098,
0.0062195766,
0.0363313481,
0.0070751174,
-0.0429933779,
-0.0302291624,
-0.0154783465,
-0.0051419004,
-0.0285299998,
-0.0040612086,
-0.0375670679,
0.0394362807,
0.0246454012,
-0.0432750396,
-0.0249505341,
0.0429303609,
-0.0017634082,
0.0458549261,
0.0730506927,
-0.0110222977,
0.0035245351,
-0.0114900982,
0.0108544882,
-0.0593424067,
0.0122506972,
-0.0429119244,
0.0553592108,
-0.0334742181,
0.0200866722,
-0.0243653506,
-0.0449522361,
0.0176327042,
-0.0030089074,
-0.0375252105,
-0.0295459963,
-0.0298232958,
0.0390296094,
0.0221728757,
-0.002149296,
0.0007633861,
-0.0114891501,
-0.0408561677,
-0.0268553477,
0.004926526,
0.0030248291,
-0.0054008178,
0.001661609,
-0.0220493991,
0.0330396406,
-0.0111430408,
-0.071011208,
0.0374396816,
0.0538056158,
-0.024977494,
-0.0590545833,
-0.0517080538,
-0.0434108265,
-0.0265660957,
-0.0539759062,
0.0561518967,
0.0032745341,
-0.0137311099,
0.0271288007,
-0.0166119393,
-0.0488341115,
-0.0129291015,
-0.0042315205,
-0.0507682376,
0.051225882,
0.0419654176,
0.0189499576,
0.0424766317,
0.0443533659,
0.0811298937,
0.0281663761,
0.0111962222,
-0.0466392264,
-0.0271335803,
-0.0294593517,
0.0015289194,
-0.0043673879,
-0.0823792964,
-0.0182818472,
0.0754841641,
0.0752843171,
-0.0379422344,
-0.0725210682,
0.0528419912,
-0.1084587425,
-0.0203417316,
-0.0039274502,
-0.1038679555,
-0.0129190926,
-0.0054160533,
-0.0474610329,
-0.0495691597,
0.0386967696,
0.0145017868,
0.0251771379,
-0.0021574926,
-0.0089763589,
0.0059952438,
0.0511772446,
0.0037290151,
0.0520303808,
0.0367514715,
-0.0035872825,
0.0027360807,
-0.042646721,
0.0350390114,
-0.0327737816,
0.0171637014,
-0.001929184,
0.0059889802,
0.0085034417,
-0.0460882448,
-0.0497692823,
-0.0349108465,
-0.0395620316,
-0.020116888,
0.0197319295,
0.0137392348,
0.0036159651,
0.0106190303,
0.0087524336,
-0.039795287,
0.0070931423,
0.0047125849,
0.0282405205,
-0.059607029,
-0.0133098699,
-0.0780929327,
0.0697678179,
-0.0209753886,
0.0071346238,
0.0739116296,
-0.0326738395,
0.0309794322,
0.003675896,
0.0233023278,
0.0075801658,
-0.0053770365,
0.0132959085,
-0.0089233909,
0.0073773032,
-0.0294043496,
0.0151114222,
0.0523465201,
0.0149225853,
-0.0252294689,
0.0412975289,
0.0019000405,
0.0261726081,
0.0281956159,
-0.0159455985,
-0.1089276299,
0.0315073691,
0.0096405186,
0.00985274,
-0.0921458974,
-0.0703830644,
0.026950812,
-0.0930262879,
0.0241961516,
0.0116152903,
-0.0491247214,
-0.0187327601,
-0.0163115468,
0.0362106934,
-0.0179326665,
0.0137039106,
0.0032540103,
0.0194885209,
-0.0110974545,
0.0083734961,
-0.0820299014,
-0.0206582621,
0.0333925635,
-0.0327038355,
0.0193785578,
-0.0055256076,
0.018888019,
-0.0233991276,
0.001486337,
0.0906925127,
-0.0621079057,
-0.0572224408,
-0.0309173837,
0.0485171527,
0.0009687186,
-0.0515065715,
-0.0350095965,
0.0300583821,
0.01031751,
0.0043410151,
0.0200948752,
0.0473632254,
0.0282488558,
-0.0298882071,
-0.0481028706,
0.0118632969,
-0.0025440902,
0.0814146921,
0.0355625376,
-0.0670855567,
0.0383186676,
-0.0947760046,
-0.0187200978,
-0.0138394963,
-0.1103877127,
-0.0079473667,
-0.0112104937,
-0.0648811162,
-0.0167203415,
-0.0370146073,
0.0016334286,
0.0134878438,
0.0564350896,
-0.0506518185,
-0.0398077965,
-0.0359911583,
-0.0078112558,
0.0271595232,
-0.0072094537,
0.0404050797,
0.0066970787,
0.0374865122,
-0.0532677174,
0.0110384123,
-0.0195905045,
0.0336339846,
-0.032245893,
-0.0663843527,
0.0983091295,
0.0323595293,
0.026339598,
0.0070565497,
-0.0202552304,
-0.0341589525,
0.0397681966,
0.0214220509,
-0.020655157,
0.0148639865,
0.0311806444,
-0.0188794024,
0.0161669683,
0.0216564741,
-0.0195540302,
0.0410882942,
0.0573628955,
-0.0281075276,
-0.0661476254,
-0.0188305136,
0.0008496738,
-0.0149646476,
-0.0028720435,
-0.0202251486,
0.0031024327,
-0.0334806666,
-0.0239526629,
-0.0109380996,
-0.0480337292,
0.0073211328,
-0.0234969892,
0.0189655926,
0.0016958306,
-0.0270989724,
-0.0179555845,
-0.0342215188,
0.0523922257,
-0.0362604931,
0.0240681991,
0.0347569175,
0.0561999381,
0.0331345163,
0.0052003395,
-0.0133414026,
0.0142614748,
-0.0477635078,
0.0077832774,
0.002461141,
0.0134234624,
0.0186589528,
0.0233998895,
0.0382055677,
-0.006451448,
0.0260464326,
-0.0224521495,
-0.0040429193,
-0.0358035192,
-0.0129594123,
-0.0267905947,
0.0299188979,
0.0180465188,
-0.0316805542,
-0.0244364198,
-0.0057487725,
0.0037400022,
-0.0407027528,
0.022101758,
0.0149533562,
-0.0099369753,
-0.0034256727,
0.0122389765,
0.0208720006,
0.065504916,
0.0300281066,
-0.0354331657,
-0.0116502354,
-0.0235525444,
0.0361720249,
-0.0013668234,
-0.0087772226,
-0.024114741,
-0.1103289723,
-0.0916752368,
-0.0153480917,
-0.0110124042,
0.0356147103,
-0.0016242714,
-0.0061885174,
0.0369904861,
0.0172274653,
0.0129102068,
0.0030083421,
-0.0133962054,
-0.0184887424,
-0.0324264467,
0.0053349645,
-5.810228334e-33,
-0.0036974377,
-0.0376967825,
-0.0475361347,
-0.0079469085,
-0.0156058958,
-0.0149983186,
0.0049431189,
0.0212676749,
-0.0345775783,
0.013033811,
0.0181933027,
0.0054347566,
0.0070181144,
-0.0052624089,
0.0142094893,
-0.0206068866,
0.0337438621,
0.0043625818,
-0.0176393222,
-0.001756092,
0.0089347549,
-0.0061828061,
0.0152220195,
-0.090927653,
0.0744559243,
0.0143013876,
-0.032617934,
0.0064616017,
-0.0149331754,
0.0548133552,
-0.0153827565,
0.0740933865,
0.0201822408,
0.0066389991,
0.0386366732,
0.037585903,
-0.0193468463,
0.0011818638,
0.0473484956,
-0.0067396499,
0.0190046281,
-0.033991199,
0.029383013,
-0.018682912,
-0.0501252189,
-0.0276728682,
0.0346189812,
-0.0359858237,
0.0071880613,
-0.015295092,
-0.0581820384,
0.0240552817,
-0.0376445465,
0.0255331993,
-0.0458904877,
0.056516014,
0.0438974462,
0.0115215899,
-0.0302962884,
0.0039011498,
-0.0100364285,
-0.0246628392,
0.0117090205,
0.0139146606,
0.0192280877,
0.0711233765,
-0.0023373817,
0.0560184866,
-0.0177847929,
-0.0080053536,
0.0493221097,
-0.010471209,
0.0416483544,
0.0401313454,
-0.0306239855,
-0.0528721362,
-0.0139133483,
-0.0099322321,
0.0282284021,
0.0262119006,
0.0177154001,
-0.0327902324,
-0.0647803098,
-0.0444210283,
-0.0524960943,
-0.0709130764,
-0.0115809841,
-0.0256682616,
0.0348145477,
-0.0109363049,
-0.060604386,
-0.0200712383,
0.012305893,
-0.0114315748,
-0.0120563302,
0.0155701898,
-0.0054010595,
-0.0319020972,
0.027438296,
0.0237849113,
-0.0358399227,
0.0104297129,
-0.0290662032,
0.0002999978,
0.0479941182,
-0.002477905,
0.0266132094,
0.0314347446,
-0.0897459164,
0.0236394219,
0.0069592702,
0.0508598387,
0.020578552,
0.0815330818,
0.0377211049,
0.0256737452,
0.0047863964,
-0.0113020353,
0.0934248343,
0.0066838809,
-0.0273974482,
0.0383796133,
-0.0456766561,
0.0186652895,
-0.0173135251,
-0.0235741306,
0.0059939097,
0.0687678829,
0.0891069919,
-0.084052518,
0.0009343961,
-0.0476559177,
2.527e-7,
0.040106222,
0.0139911855,
0.0033147747,
0.0327747501,
0.0354392976,
0.0305723082,
0.0668721497,
0.0243872255,
0.0115457913,
-0.0084229792,
-0.0626671389,
0.028200807,
0.0339159332,
0.0336670578,
-0.0059296773,
0.0120196482,
-0.0730661079,
0.0412193015,
-0.0734414235,
0.0216622707,
-0.0250166934,
0.0932029486,
0.0652123392,
-0.0273304656,
-0.0347538553,
-0.0095719406,
0.0096027516,
-0.0234170202,
-0.0139524434,
0.0051561492,
0.0415546857,
0.0264441837,
0.0322467498,
0.0118665267,
0.0116348108,
0.0151177812,
-0.0090117101,
0.002681108,
-0.0002502232,
0.0555630215,
0.0118862307,
-0.0571189187,
-0.0177930668,
-0.0873628259,
0.0617643259,
0.0323478878,
0.0101611307,
-0.0781085268,
-0.0500713103,
-0.0251585543,
0.0619902685,
-0.0039954688,
-0.0323247761,
0.0003296521,
0.0109180762,
0.0071774474,
0.0285432655,
-0.0541415513,
-0.0274154991,
-0.0233487282,
-0.0201780722,
-0.0548176542,
0.0177474618,
0.0177384205,
-0.0371285193,
0.0010934634,
0.0298438724,
2.23459272e-34,
0.036813613,
-0.0250489302,
-0.0036031918,
-0.0452528484,
0.0441526547,
0.0257227123,
-0.0028930362,
0.0056811729,
0.0077409162,
-0.0170969479,
-0.0007139231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04106v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04106v2 | Meta predictive learning model of languages in neural circuits | 2023-09-08T03:58:05 | 2023-10-09T08:09:17 | Chan Li, Junbin Qiu, Haiping Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-bio.NC | Large language models based on self-attention mechanisms have achieved
astonishing performances not only in natural language itself, but also in a
variety of tasks of different nature. However, regarding processing language,
our human brain may not operate using the same principle. Then, a debate is
established on the connection between brain computation and artificial
self-supervision adopted in large language models. One of most influential
hypothesis in brain computation is the predictive coding framework, which
proposes to minimize the prediction error by local learning. However, the role
of predictive coding and the associated credit assignment in language
processing remains unknown. Here, we propose a mean-field learning model within
the predictive coding framework, assuming that the synaptic weight of each
connection follows a spike and slab distribution, and only the distribution,
rather than specific weights, is trained. This meta predictive learning is
successfully validated on classifying handwritten digits where pixels are input
to the network in sequence, and moreover on the toy and real language corpus.
Our model reveals that most of the connections become deterministic after
learning, while the output connections have a higher level of variability. The
performance of the resulting network ensemble changes continuously with data
load, further improving with more training data, in analogy with the emergent
behavior of large language models. Therefore, our model provides a starting
point to investigate the connection among brain computation, next-token
prediction and general intelligence. | [
0.0048711896,
0.0486760065,
-0.0389073044,
0.025068067,
0.0036965485,
0.0258739311,
0.0298075248,
0.0169634745,
0.0382558629,
0.010059529,
-0.0130336955,
-0.0374945849,
0.032011278,
0.0637460649,
0.0599336214,
0.0033172681,
0.0034451098,
-0.0500740409,
0.0098176785,
-0.053998407,
-0.0222673062,
-0.0463390052,
-0.0079723112,
0.0149300545,
-0.0456308611,
-0.0044579701,
0.0164428391,
-0.0493245162,
-0.0246345215,
0.004585993,
0.0137206912,
0.0719133541,
-0.0194166228,
0.0532516241,
0.0000022466,
-0.0474226438,
0.0390938073,
-0.0413990505,
-0.0312229712,
-0.0493573695,
-0.0148717184,
0.0220177379,
-0.0377959721,
-0.0335083716,
-0.0186992306,
-0.0411101058,
0.0880098492,
0.0476981252,
-0.0158884414,
0.0349458717,
-0.0189719163,
-0.0669848695,
0.0519449078,
-0.0167248994,
0.0667232424,
0.0469961502,
0.0050818436,
0.0060967281,
-0.0405135863,
-0.0559978113,
-0.0558899716,
0.0283361506,
0.0469371192,
-0.0207418315,
0.0387765132,
0.0835584924,
0.0037758383,
-0.0214876998,
-0.0407967642,
0.0312946811,
-0.0395192802,
-0.0635456145,
-0.0229182765,
0.0100390697,
-0.0098483814,
0.0083123082,
-0.0173991695,
0.0506997295,
-0.0110808518,
0.0290762577,
0.0093452279,
-0.0258526336,
0.0351967365,
-0.0162024163,
0.000446699,
0.0738017112,
-0.0067551574,
-0.05175706,
0.0275121182,
0.0308769532,
-0.0274986364,
-0.0313371941,
0.0175886005,
-0.0138305575,
0.0363666117,
-0.0178123619,
-0.0157948732,
-0.0752943158,
-0.0516311228,
-0.0418061502,
0.0462460704,
0.047647275,
-0.0267172493,
-0.0141126476,
-0.0662698671,
0.0649602786,
-0.0407759883,
0.0383728556,
-0.0443853177,
0.0290697906,
-0.0464355126,
-0.0400371067,
-0.0080661196,
0.063223362,
0.0186449699,
-0.0000750682,
-0.0317163877,
0.0245468821,
-0.0100331539,
-0.0314355828,
0.0171177574,
0.0045847446,
-0.0092039136,
-0.0074333791,
-0.0351486728,
-0.0165582746,
-0.0186452679,
0.0018634546,
-0.0224118698,
0.0069037485,
-0.0293191466,
0.0374057703,
-0.0189476293,
-0.0078112697,
0.005002954,
0.0491378382,
-0.0072380453,
-0.0407736823,
-0.0620259382,
0.0155170448,
-0.0290893577,
-0.0324631445,
0.0605427623,
-0.0504868552,
0.0040574097,
0.0208535418,
-0.0046690889,
-0.040154729,
-0.0311774518,
-0.017454356,
-0.0041346396,
0.0225098375,
-0.0349538773,
-0.001648445,
0.0635137931,
-0.0180539899,
-0.0071653826,
0.0198301896,
0.0440412723,
0.0388726443,
-0.0219080988,
-0.0049411096,
0.0272137932,
0.0297414064,
0.0563194007,
-0.0331412442,
-0.0579018742,
-0.0472997203,
0.0450599976,
0.024772862,
0.0598410852,
0.0300228875,
-0.0294186156,
-0.04838017,
0.0698289722,
0.0771054924,
0.0165805407,
0.0226985682,
0.0535944663,
-0.0378866717,
0.0255354755,
-0.0036633578,
-0.0597815402,
0.0965710133,
-0.0136739668,
-0.0086778011,
0.000621471,
-0.0316498056,
-0.0373654962,
-0.0201836042,
0.0397531465,
-0.0205408856,
-0.0247482397,
-0.0034899812,
0.0275759138,
-0.0167433433,
-0.0304704271,
-0.025014855,
0.0077346819,
0.0101838773,
0.0002604882,
-0.0707660839,
0.0513829775,
0.0277204365,
-0.0122359358,
0.0006893143,
0.0136523433,
-0.0050723613,
-0.0161253326,
0.0622446239,
-0.0106355706,
0.0051747938,
0.0160696376,
-0.003982849,
-0.0105362879,
0.0292515401,
-0.0312162358,
0.0344073959,
-0.0437669531,
-0.0281050708,
-0.0420013145,
-0.0206766762,
-0.060682565,
0.0359911285,
-0.0032759963,
-0.0424143597,
0.004016838,
0.0020636774,
0.0546736307,
-0.0257135089,
-0.0173293427,
0.0270963423,
0.0175534189,
-0.0099537764,
-0.0241210796,
0.0012762462,
-0.0526723042,
-0.0480232649,
0.0529293977,
-0.0077981902,
-0.0068744845,
0.0295027401,
0.034819629,
-0.0568023585,
0.0520257019,
-0.0399577506,
0.0744832009,
-0.0322340019,
0.0067708697,
-0.0058830702,
0.0159890205,
0.007789006,
0.0649221167,
-0.0153163793,
0.0106555354,
-0.0175351053,
-0.00456816,
0.0172855649,
-0.0142127965,
-0.0398591086,
0.0317457356,
-0.0153116733,
0.0004085585,
0.0244190842,
-0.0129767861,
-0.0105361547,
-0.0406215303,
-0.0665986985,
-0.0532035083,
0.0115776863,
0.0140963532,
-0.0142708719,
-0.0331318788,
0.0017142046,
0.0049100695,
0.0120032616,
0.0355355293,
0.0036222297,
0.0245051049,
-0.0051357811,
-0.0231589638,
0.0118865287,
0.0009566342,
-0.0515638292,
-0.0219502635,
0.0787564814,
-0.0049765077,
-0.0220119823,
-0.0505405664,
-0.0072502596,
-0.0206790436,
0.0285001602,
-0.0030230114,
-0.0486992896,
0.027895106,
-0.016743727,
0.0459181182,
0.0835585147,
-0.0034442772,
0.0062833894,
0.0479484573,
0.0184348393,
0.0023634373,
-0.0122479787,
-0.03345396,
0.023809908,
-0.0271080956,
-0.030400442,
-0.0566149242,
0.1268054992,
0.0604771301,
0.0069523281,
-0.0618679784,
-0.0099969544,
-0.0155178346,
-0.0721089244,
-0.0246239249,
0.0022485831,
-0.036880482,
0.0496005677,
-0.0168519598,
-0.0711758584,
0.0788775906,
0.0168956015,
-0.0116666304,
0.0146452589,
-0.0034069337,
0.0250968691,
0.0230023153,
0.0667162761,
0.0169426445,
-0.0140926959,
-0.0236861166,
-0.0512701124,
-0.0285532065,
-0.018429013,
0.0025792993,
-0.0225417651,
-0.0328557156,
0.0096100727,
0.014081127,
0.0010840575,
-0.0132175134,
0.0283659995,
-0.0178379025,
0.0197805669,
0.0257813912,
-0.0129227359,
-0.0028426624,
0.020281883,
0.0330880359,
0.0917645395,
-0.0518360361,
-0.0398882367,
0.0125328135,
0.0221282188,
-0.0275986381,
-0.0066742115,
0.0271763392,
-0.0030765564,
0.0450168587,
0.0103311464,
-0.0017867463,
0.0474225245,
-0.0695353672,
0.0624946095,
0.0246889703,
0.0010382627,
-0.0042914012,
0.0340063684,
-0.0020480142,
-0.034202069,
-0.0044395202,
0.0997036323,
0.0158528276,
-0.057439927,
-0.0166222788,
-0.0362896733,
-0.0110562379,
0.0304439962,
0.0336664692,
0.0068173385,
0.0049527525,
-0.028514741,
-0.0008230605,
0.0012985267,
-0.0557727143,
0.0374988019,
-0.0744808242,
-0.0022700517,
-0.0011415796,
-0.0616515614,
-0.0362926573,
-0.0180031452,
-0.0487193018,
0.005875261,
-0.0139505621,
0.0270746276,
-0.0042372881,
0.0001135033,
0.0380588584,
0.0188384671,
0.0343478695,
0.0132676652,
-0.0022154239,
0.085048832,
0.0667669177,
0.0104410686,
-0.0384526849,
0.0285091158,
0.0201076996,
-0.0303178616,
0.0120370518,
-0.0490909256,
0.0611425713,
0.0092998203,
-0.0119686704,
-0.0239214785,
0.0178134236,
-0.0161596816,
-0.0457543097,
-0.0280900076,
0.1011626497,
-0.0333521925,
-0.0655750558,
-0.0023071449,
0.0201310292,
-0.0109095881,
0.0386108719,
0.0299946722,
-0.0717657655,
-0.0161542743,
-0.0238820296,
0.0348897763,
-0.0392121822,
-0.0595041662,
0.0149013801,
0.0609149374,
-0.0375936404,
-0.0341229513,
-0.018062951,
0.022264801,
0.035992153,
0.0156308245,
-0.0313340724,
0.0191489812,
-0.0323427506,
-0.0336998142,
-0.0037771987,
-0.0107299946,
-0.0663255379,
-0.098692134,
-0.033060085,
0.0139372014,
-0.1036844328,
-0.0064134174,
-0.0193167664,
-0.0530342944,
-0.0476620868,
0.0212951172,
0.1010374352,
0.0141780805,
0.0066465265,
0.0218576826,
-0.0748762414,
0.0502374135,
0.0314808339,
-0.0293128025,
0.0450294353,
0.0227335449,
-0.0040536826,
0.0027533737,
0.0106782326,
0.0136501091,
0.0696645826,
0.0538811162,
-0.0130150625,
-0.0015732339,
0.0023870829,
0.0471098386,
0.0081976615,
0.0849547163,
-0.0222344045,
0.019501105,
-0.0520678386,
-0.0141918715,
0.0176380873,
0.035395883,
-0.0158185214,
0.0105912909,
0.034080945,
0.047200162,
-0.0006572674,
-0.0458094329,
-0.0065675261,
-0.0239112005,
0.0321119577,
-0.0030083708,
-0.0599416159,
0.0285001043,
-0.0024404717,
0.0633475184,
0.0259370077,
0.0024360185,
0.0059907255,
0.0200420637,
0.0160298049,
0.027660884,
0.0179059654,
0.0082138712,
-0.0220060609,
-0.0091556124,
-0.0816825628,
-0.0243745726,
0.0047344975,
0.0340487026,
-0.0048940415,
-0.0164622199,
-0.0242626294,
-0.0527063683,
0.037730746,
-0.0326459184,
-0.0171168912,
-0.0040594391,
0.0030247658,
0.0433358587,
0.0133445729,
0.0094525237,
-0.0317346454,
0.0637646839,
-0.0009082139,
0.0287050493,
0.0067455303,
0.0216544643,
-0.0332224183,
-0.0062169326,
-0.0267624855,
-0.0035135052,
-0.0322360285,
0.0097352844,
-0.034144789,
-0.0702306032,
0.0532363169,
0.0121955015,
0.0368766971,
-0.0140953716,
0.0209336318,
0.016550323,
-0.0127076693,
0.002552724,
0.0085357549,
0.0147368908,
0.0387550145,
-0.0066241696,
-0.0299299695,
-6.839082704e-33,
-0.0078572109,
-0.0581578799,
0.0193900056,
0.0447767302,
0.0173461251,
0.0098206112,
-0.0265830923,
0.0183756445,
-0.0021068964,
0.0145981321,
-0.0544834435,
0.0321787074,
0.0155875152,
0.0279796626,
0.0358160399,
-0.0090181623,
0.0046020481,
-0.0719506815,
0.0268432442,
-0.0020380372,
0.0587377511,
0.0127564194,
0.1030788347,
-0.0293238051,
0.0128028598,
0.0057143942,
-0.0036869543,
0.0370331071,
-0.0038613747,
0.0098701939,
-0.0464052297,
0.0594476461,
0.0400493369,
-0.0185090862,
-0.0114507228,
0.0056179417,
-0.0211782157,
-0.0657295808,
0.0159851871,
-0.0333833061,
-0.0285563413,
-0.0282072593,
0.0440288186,
-0.0420765914,
-0.0736927167,
-0.0068012192,
0.0338536426,
-0.0016865275,
-0.03597112,
0.0079472708,
-0.0494464897,
-0.0134363612,
-0.0037622261,
0.0083047636,
0.0633103251,
0.0024295831,
-0.0224403832,
0.0123177823,
-0.0565274246,
0.063428469,
-0.048674915,
0.0646561757,
0.0125383651,
0.0119802365,
0.0620165952,
0.0258482583,
0.1244632006,
0.0145637663,
0.0001827549,
-0.0063535031,
0.0356013328,
-0.0197763573,
0.0365100577,
0.0080827894,
0.0505427346,
-0.0592084751,
-0.0142824044,
-0.034739513,
0.0215052087,
0.0336508751,
0.0189594217,
-0.0345418863,
-0.0143721597,
-0.0221808385,
-0.0055684736,
-0.0484572798,
-0.0220290106,
-0.0081426138,
0.0098679066,
-0.0263667963,
0.014282804,
0.0006390293,
0.038882494,
-0.0524599813,
0.0610484071,
0.0219431687,
-0.0171660129,
0.0590527616,
0.0485960096,
0.0216102153,
-0.0881457031,
-0.0290701948,
-0.0282047614,
0.0228225403,
0.0322715901,
0.0262162518,
-0.0055680666,
0.0489676856,
-0.0173845328,
-0.0118385293,
-0.0183382761,
-0.0479534715,
0.069726035,
-0.0203633066,
0.0149247479,
0.0006927933,
-0.0052490253,
-0.047423888,
0.0097957822,
-0.0141594382,
-0.0144224428,
0.0124580627,
-0.0226304047,
0.037621133,
-0.0031393135,
-0.003234836,
-0.0661339611,
0.0283022597,
0.0541188121,
-0.0795620158,
-0.0137804411,
0.0325967483,
3.072e-7,
0.0141293453,
0.0388196446,
-0.0162760951,
0.0036042593,
0.043139454,
0.013948814,
-0.0028735152,
-0.0023175988,
0.02904623,
-0.0556170978,
0.0034492752,
0.0335642658,
-0.0071106981,
0.0037210321,
-0.0481328852,
0.0268198512,
-0.0648104772,
0.0468320288,
0.0245897919,
-0.0054858583,
-0.0385280736,
0.0414785296,
0.0244259331,
-0.0189545006,
0.0084179034,
-0.0065272744,
0.0477959327,
-0.0046803756,
0.0392267555,
-0.0189359523,
-0.0122466292,
-0.0230945945,
-0.0320439674,
0.0805075541,
0.001589282,
-0.0131128617,
-0.0034834249,
-0.0063939737,
-0.016028747,
0.047568012,
0.0235635601,
-0.0320859551,
0.0110071357,
-0.0033223801,
0.0116377687,
-0.0595752299,
-0.0271168128,
-0.0024233069,
0.0317998491,
0.0036653441,
0.0464174561,
-0.0313242301,
0.0112077631,
-0.0035817847,
0.002127433,
0.0136202257,
0.0172565561,
-0.0262844972,
-0.0221832208,
0.0728387982,
-0.0220279377,
-0.0405988358,
-0.0607207082,
-0.010935571,
0.1301341653,
-0.0664414391,
0.0114200367,
2.216435695e-34,
-0.0211169776,
-0.0200698767,
0.0487171188,
-0.0130784288,
-0.027216319,
-0.0364128947,
0.0014255916,
-0.0085287662,
0.0299305599,
-0.0335920714,
-0.0493212007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04087v1 | Unsupervised Multi-document Summarization with Holistic Inference | 2023-09-08T02:56:30 | 2023-09-08T02:56:30 | Haopeng Zhang, Sangwoo Cho, Kaiqiang Song, Xiaoyang Wang, Hongwei Wang, Jiawei Zhang, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-document summarization aims to obtain core information from a
collection of documents written on the same topic. This paper proposes a new
holistic framework for unsupervised multi-document extractive summarization.
Our method incorporates the holistic beam search inference method associated
with the holistic measurements, named Subset Representative Index (SRI). SRI
balances the importance and diversity of a subset of sentences from the source
documents and can be calculated in unsupervised and adaptive manners. To
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method, we conduct extensive experiments
on both small and large-scale multi-document summarization datasets under both
unsupervised and adaptive settings. The proposed method outperforms strong
baselines by a significant margin, as indicated by the resulting ROUGE scores
and diversity measures. Our findings also suggest that diversity is essential
for improving multi-document summary performance. | [
0.0224750806,
0.0119773448,
0.0289071556,
-0.0253085457,
-0.0245056711,
0.011374427,
0.0067697233,
-0.0149148703,
0.0014711132,
-0.0182210952,
-0.0033845373,
0.009502341,
0.003031241,
-0.0109355105,
-0.0059520113,
-0.0891664326,
0.0391505212,
0.0083950255,
0.0047539533,
-0.0053030956,
0.0052381442,
-0.0197198857,
0.0033330824,
0.0146774352,
-0.006641265,
0.0137241911,
0.0053326483,
-0.0056258077,
0.0593915209,
-0.0135487439,
0.0056454013,
-0.0032413814,
0.0351053253,
0.0039658053,
0.0000017457,
-0.0623517297,
-0.0712850317,
0.0052885646,
0.0345292278,
-0.0004937191,
0.0448369272,
-0.0442695841,
0.0416329689,
-0.0136273447,
0.0098963352,
0.0446916111,
-0.0121341851,
0.0436478518,
0.0378393978,
0.0487940647,
-0.0162357073,
-0.0163362101,
0.006979723,
0.0002829404,
-0.015986206,
-0.0304185376,
0.0134395622,
0.0306872353,
0.0077820374,
0.0169430505,
-0.018353736,
0.0382328816,
0.0098478468,
-0.0057158498,
0.0235786382,
0.0094283456,
-0.0962095931,
-0.0179444663,
0.0391868651,
0.0596623868,
0.0222533084,
0.0272312481,
0.0641634241,
0.0017421099,
-0.0003386677,
0.0048512048,
-0.0977722034,
0.0409434848,
-0.0043815933,
-0.0058461302,
-0.0019413277,
0.0514207035,
-0.0101583758,
0.0344374031,
-0.0116225574,
0.0308083426,
0.0308240764,
-0.0071812994,
-0.0451674759,
0.0071054157,
-0.0081601972,
-0.0049691298,
0.0209868066,
-0.0000982965,
-0.0276055168,
-0.0074248817,
-0.0433599539,
-0.067955777,
0.023403706,
-0.0314973742,
-0.0079285568,
-0.0008786333,
0.036126703,
0.0608495846,
-0.0025946284,
-0.0093681216,
0.0255822204,
-0.0301887114,
-0.0692843944,
-0.0600625686,
-0.0290678944,
0.0164540261,
-0.0179509409,
0.0562704466,
-0.0361717194,
-0.042444624,
-0.0508874133,
0.0155242672,
0.0180244781,
-0.0405765139,
-0.0391980372,
0.0046649375,
-0.0192593634,
0.0099389032,
0.018096406,
0.0558903106,
-0.0455737412,
-0.0310315285,
0.0199940708,
-0.0366808549,
-0.0208558459,
0.0461523347,
0.0361893699,
0.0023610312,
0.0093657942,
0.001854297,
-0.0303178076,
-0.0725057945,
0.0190573558,
-0.0237543769,
-0.0193257481,
-0.0244317222,
0.0362575948,
-0.0884261131,
0.0103264991,
0.0157609843,
-0.0168950781,
0.0280353036,
0.0002851597,
-0.0119970515,
-0.0345468894,
-0.0225135311,
-0.0163383391,
-0.0071920715,
0.0543892942,
0.0089152046,
0.0033579746,
0.0598308407,
0.0018168386,
0.075024277,
0.0816453919,
0.040969979,
-0.0225513112,
0.0125448955,
0.005490215,
0.0157419629,
0.03498419,
-0.0239059683,
-0.032458663,
-0.0226108078,
0.0289677437,
0.0004285492,
-0.0624147281,
0.0409893803,
0.0314314663,
0.0822855532,
0.0206504371,
-0.0036662822,
-0.0094929338,
0.0368711129,
0.0206991415,
0.0636622682,
0.026855344,
0.0512123629,
-0.0554309897,
0.0419172049,
0.1245890409,
0.0172321629,
-0.0249923076,
-0.0289736819,
0.0218119677,
0.0268098973,
-0.0373977944,
0.0026672899,
0.0515539721,
0.0007206994,
0.0080056349,
0.0384049527,
0.0312980376,
-0.0565079041,
0.0309940558,
0.0178297199,
0.0093304338,
-0.0042095929,
0.0350540169,
-0.057865832,
0.0095068468,
0.0099509228,
-0.015804749,
-0.0015706456,
0.0188347995,
-0.0172428954,
0.0204159208,
-0.0497061573,
-0.0410715379,
-0.0155331241,
0.0080703562,
-0.0096365027,
-0.0313182585,
-0.0286889244,
0.0169863235,
-0.0317562744,
-0.056181889,
0.0303690024,
-0.0112581169,
0.0128635326,
0.0206936412,
-0.0265357085,
0.0244597513,
0.0291649122,
-0.0118021518,
0.0000202326,
0.0229852833,
-0.0154209556,
-0.0310592633,
-0.0193398837,
-0.0442106649,
-0.0426466987,
0.0084113097,
-0.1106632277,
-0.0116516128,
0.0250115246,
-0.009642682,
-0.0476108007,
0.0291063339,
-0.0293524247,
-0.0910768658,
-0.0506110787,
-0.0262861233,
0.0261444468,
0.0308139659,
-0.0476682708,
0.0796887279,
0.0348092876,
0.0318117291,
0.0088393325,
-0.0505464152,
0.0007932291,
-0.0593835078,
-0.0072098793,
0.005802514,
-0.0099731414,
-0.003464062,
0.0679793134,
0.0083711492,
0.002321416,
0.0180483703,
-0.1050598472,
0.0000855835,
-0.0273356605,
-0.025976738,
0.0504218675,
0.0301040243,
0.0099594984,
-0.0072300807,
0.0124014588,
-0.0415933616,
0.0253432877,
0.0297142304,
0.0265153255,
0.0246058758,
0.056423977,
-0.0255651381,
-0.0236953869,
-0.0121253747,
0.0480651334,
0.001889519,
-0.0171279255,
0.0118603688,
0.0029757367,
-0.0158143789,
-0.0661608949,
-0.0053120526,
0.0341004469,
-0.0148886573,
-0.0134312008,
0.0376251303,
0.014943813,
0.0568237677,
0.0049401643,
0.0378709435,
-0.0016858175,
-0.0290568769,
-0.0127550941,
-0.0382063128,
0.109036386,
0.0152786933,
-0.0236135386,
0.0755569935,
0.0111711985,
0.0551073104,
-0.0141556859,
0.0039863549,
-0.0175183397,
-0.012048468,
-0.0205455832,
-0.0944864154,
-0.0031054406,
0.0182113145,
0.0146381352,
0.0003703063,
-0.0050679091,
0.0407585017,
0.003545389,
0.0189104602,
-0.0701104477,
-0.0117463758,
-0.0581444018,
0.0249552131,
0.007318039,
0.0330693088,
0.0078843897,
-0.0015675151,
-0.0340467319,
-0.0000473828,
0.0521798618,
0.0199102964,
0.0738958195,
-0.0418949239,
0.0145268524,
-0.0338346623,
0.0032673394,
-0.0011113452,
-0.0382312015,
0.0376190431,
0.0286194347,
0.0299604982,
0.0267230514,
-0.0542299561,
0.0062182252,
0.0713343844,
0.0569173992,
-0.0598905012,
-0.0169645175,
-0.0087085143,
0.0817100927,
0.0733315498,
-0.0043399185,
0.0408198386,
-0.0550628193,
-0.00971907,
0.0259952229,
0.0383179821,
-0.0215535499,
0.0258024205,
-0.0109684421,
-0.0157119334,
-0.069925651,
0.0138443839,
-0.0477194041,
0.0626952127,
-0.0190622043,
-0.00191132,
0.0782708004,
0.0102537964,
-0.0131626371,
-0.0171998404,
-0.0107343132,
0.0126776537,
0.013334549,
-0.0150844324,
-0.0229484271,
0.0038138963,
-0.0216478482,
0.0222125314,
0.0261454359,
-0.0461189523,
0.0051605599,
-0.046561908,
0.0032760755,
0.0109203197,
-0.0619636104,
-0.0256973151,
0.0052789128,
0.0247855578,
-0.0064312904,
-0.0121323001,
0.0190156698,
-0.0345270932,
-0.0104733817,
-0.0008210995,
-0.0724230111,
-0.0228428524,
-0.0415286161,
-0.0347441696,
-0.0494488142,
0.0150653692,
0.0357663557,
-0.014762735,
0.0716640428,
0.0036066305,
-0.0490891077,
-0.0150590008,
0.0011557675,
0.0607501268,
-0.018307019,
0.0164290294,
-0.0203245375,
0.0480489247,
0.0305704866,
-0.0001250889,
0.041484639,
0.0037400532,
0.00283303,
-0.0133550707,
-0.0321298689,
0.0020445155,
-0.0231455378,
0.0480680764,
0.0253238529,
0.000784773,
-0.0026458988,
-0.0210895296,
-0.0276305545,
-0.0299745798,
-0.0034326848,
-0.000179467,
-0.0462869778,
-0.0093554379,
-0.0720525607,
-0.0364975668,
0.0026812174,
-0.0005820404,
-0.0497849137,
-0.0136889284,
-0.0249783173,
0.0075356807,
0.0051534614,
0.0140999816,
-0.0178181715,
-0.0548268147,
0.0129543934,
-0.0050685932,
0.0398820639,
-0.0290509537,
-0.0396578722,
0.0278171245,
-0.0299129095,
-0.0177709199,
0.004679868,
0.0274603833,
0.0089482823,
0.0253000688,
0.0039314432,
-0.0165579692,
0.0984702855,
0.0349194929,
-0.0240333416,
0.0111521343,
-0.0005969902,
-0.0155076776,
-0.0246170666,
0.0073652174,
-0.0743829608,
0.0532593951,
-0.0370466113,
0.0640251338,
0.0101923384,
-0.0327660516,
0.0023083258,
0.0497750342,
0.0128835542,
-0.0399466343,
0.00133672,
-0.0606031418,
-0.0441768989,
-0.017385507,
-0.0230239909,
0.0055182292,
0.0385749042,
-0.0080778329,
0.0165795833,
-0.0172445308,
0.1285157949,
0.0166754201,
0.0355430953,
-0.0607630722,
-0.0219761115,
0.0001712132,
-0.0133669404,
-0.0812528357,
-0.0022779752,
-0.0354992412,
-0.0088667208,
-0.0332242809,
-0.0093184551,
-0.0150477327,
-0.0254235081,
0.0373046957,
0.0151773989,
-0.0239100065,
0.0279513504,
-0.1258840859,
0.0444385931,
-0.0473675653,
0.0118936813,
0.0415000245,
-0.0304408781,
0.0525911078,
-0.0086556189,
-0.0241315514,
-0.0456052274,
0.0211947057,
0.0378811136,
0.0174348056,
-0.0658637807,
0.0209533852,
-0.0015329767,
0.0130865499,
0.0823950246,
-0.078124404,
0.0134483231,
0.0024562322,
-0.0004495441,
-0.0570277907,
-0.024003936,
-0.0019512735,
0.0534286797,
-0.0103526143,
-0.0408523791,
-0.0326643586,
0.042103406,
0.0786886886,
0.0096669933,
-0.0069736005,
-0.0081622265,
0.0500090718,
0.0310216453,
-0.0079961168,
0.0279386211,
-0.0357723609,
-0.0302182846,
-0.0133801997,
0.0168839414,
0.0010497124,
-6.0222247e-33,
-0.0386292189,
-0.0098181516,
-0.0587146133,
0.0032167016,
-0.024672132,
-0.001078723,
-0.0505851582,
-0.0329033546,
0.0115506453,
-0.0191870611,
-0.0066491473,
0.0131428009,
0.0144825159,
0.0529152416,
0.0230878815,
0.0593211986,
0.0275577419,
0.0271215476,
-0.0691596717,
0.0375982709,
0.0544604808,
0.0174635295,
0.0646464527,
-0.0113896299,
-0.0009386027,
-0.0114897033,
-0.0076148827,
-0.051167395,
0.0536627285,
0.0259261001,
0.0069563407,
0.0146609051,
0.0330271758,
-0.0280164778,
-0.0412487835,
-0.010938541,
-0.0364117958,
-0.0600811988,
-0.0188031625,
-0.0549744628,
-0.0598012768,
-0.0496818721,
0.0156589337,
-0.019403005,
-0.0085315518,
-0.0417264402,
0.0908434838,
-0.030187279,
-0.0273857024,
-0.0898390263,
-0.0170409419,
0.0229821187,
-0.0695919469,
0.0268580448,
-0.0133641353,
0.0393007286,
0.0021601531,
0.0468396842,
-0.0005616557,
0.067472361,
0.003031245,
0.037166927,
0.0177247971,
-0.0015429213,
0.0243853871,
0.0887152702,
-0.0015759532,
-0.0430751592,
0.0337147638,
-0.0523009226,
0.0338992178,
-0.0182025693,
-0.0065703318,
0.0661658272,
0.0178766586,
0.0684256628,
-0.079707928,
0.1090642288,
0.0212647431,
0.0159325171,
0.0261412337,
0.0246917903,
0.0232671946,
0.0131680323,
0.0113714384,
-0.0165833216,
0.0077364212,
0.0011270767,
-0.03594248,
0.0188299641,
-0.0687489808,
-0.0001718866,
0.0724724829,
-0.0239088163,
0.0224882327,
0.0393195674,
-0.0234636292,
0.0256324299,
0.0510474332,
-0.025579622,
-0.0467018969,
0.0119727375,
0.0617695041,
0.017477721,
-0.0102559105,
-0.044171121,
0.0304398872,
-0.0025821512,
-0.0146782082,
0.0047690202,
0.0225483458,
-0.0289754495,
-0.0637503043,
0.0260758139,
-0.0044800746,
0.0064636143,
-0.0015950365,
0.0468275212,
-0.0160598662,
0.0268533211,
-0.0178026725,
-0.0209616423,
0.0232680589,
0.0093186684,
0.0186052453,
0.0529654212,
-0.023985656,
-0.0375196226,
0.0265170708,
-0.0126904566,
-0.0064743548,
0.0266040564,
2.525e-7,
0.0405410565,
0.0405524075,
0.0530209392,
0.0182461347,
-0.004650455,
0.0273036044,
-0.0295869671,
0.0530091114,
-0.0044802595,
-0.009210011,
0.0462396257,
0.0173259862,
0.0217719208,
0.0374061838,
-0.0648422241,
0.0108331339,
-0.0708173364,
-0.0587420389,
-0.0493429452,
-0.0302091464,
0.0223528668,
0.063231796,
-0.0247788951,
0.0043993872,
-0.0080123739,
0.01429471,
0.0474043675,
0.0185338054,
-0.0628612787,
0.01770721,
0.0084022591,
-0.0151143838,
-0.0252469759,
-0.0250128992,
0.0023044141,
0.021064166,
0.0857377574,
0.0293682739,
0.0043511675,
-0.0159065202,
0.0176639892,
0.0282425154,
0.0183493961,
0.0194521677,
0.0260490421,
-0.0311739687,
-0.0073470497,
-0.0340502784,
-0.0465942696,
0.0475034863,
-0.0235738922,
0.0131053086,
-0.0462971106,
0.0644387752,
-0.0279660001,
0.0096574975,
0.0046754787,
-0.0454766005,
0.0018249409,
-0.004930845,
-0.016580971,
-0.0168343186,
0.0105401799,
-0.0325599536,
0.0164987035,
-0.06651593,
-0.0019274201,
2.317641167e-34,
0.0530630648,
0.0183288567,
-0.0746795833,
-0.0474977084,
-0.0002335318,
-0.0380181596,
-0.0865692049,
-0.000974072,
-0.0122689381,
-0.0809130594,
-0.008418248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.11506v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.11506v1 | Matching Table Metadata with Business Glossaries Using Large Language Models | 2023-09-08T02:23:59 | 2023-09-08T02:23:59 | Elita Lobo, Oktie Hassanzadeh, Nhan Pham, Nandana Mihindukulasooriya, Dharmashankar Subramanian, Horst Samulowitz | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Enterprises often own large collections of structured data in the form of
large databases or an enterprise data lake. Such data collections come with
limited metadata and strict access policies that could limit access to the data
contents and, therefore, limit the application of classic retrieval and
analysis solutions. As a result, there is a need for solutions that can
effectively utilize the available metadata. In this paper, we study the problem
of matching table metadata to a business glossary containing data labels and
descriptions. The resulting matching enables the use of an available or curated
business glossary for retrieval and analysis without or before requesting
access to the data contents. One solution to this problem is to use
manually-defined rules or similarity measures on column names and glossary
descriptions (or their vector embeddings) to find the closest match. However,
such approaches need to be tuned through manual labeling and cannot handle many
business glossaries that contain a combination of simple as well as complex and
long descriptions. In this work, we leverage the power of large language models
(LLMs) to design generic matching methods that do not require manual tuning and
can identify complex relations between column names and glossaries. We propose
methods that utilize LLMs in two ways: a) by generating additional context for
column names that can aid with matching b) by using LLMs to directly infer if
there is a relation between column names and glossary descriptions. Our
preliminary experimental results show the effectiveness of our proposed
methods. | [
0.0424800441,
0.0773767382,
-0.0138061987,
0.0584302656,
-0.0247762837,
0.0408855751,
-0.0257550385,
0.0718701333,
0.0104322992,
-0.0325402468,
-0.0091533437,
-0.0305280499,
-0.0196819231,
0.0125673832,
0.0005130689,
0.005246372,
0.0284130313,
0.0522321761,
-0.054395657,
0.0160041917,
0.007454935,
0.0269951504,
0.033220388,
-0.0115856659,
0.0295766499,
0.039463751,
0.0283201765,
0.0016903253,
-0.0421439968,
0.026533898,
-0.0219241884,
0.0501258336,
-0.0010741936,
0.0358774401,
0.0000016595,
-0.0541790091,
-0.0775748566,
0.0148303239,
0.0137724001,
0.002200454,
0.0626970604,
-0.0385572985,
0.0246975403,
-0.0222201049,
-0.0089307772,
-0.0589389056,
0.0365679748,
0.0029698445,
0.0120237339,
0.004948365,
-0.0296527185,
-0.0947987735,
-0.044411622,
0.0339807831,
0.0295284539,
-0.0935789421,
0.0424007103,
0.0569444448,
0.0344432332,
-0.0093274545,
0.0012255169,
0.0631446913,
-0.0679308549,
-0.0019290143,
-0.0045696963,
0.0287489574,
-0.0151088582,
0.0660046563,
0.0229873564,
0.0475866981,
0.0264357887,
-0.0378624275,
0.0069000521,
0.0186796673,
-0.0022552272,
0.0199413896,
-0.0299594458,
0.0069279973,
-0.0091040032,
0.0056219595,
-0.002504918,
-0.026401002,
0.0120068016,
-0.0102649312,
-0.0541442037,
0.0503826886,
0.0198548734,
-0.0311159678,
-0.0206779242,
-0.0569709018,
-0.0269237068,
-0.0216676369,
-0.0388715826,
0.0367831513,
-0.0220128652,
0.0349267051,
-0.0091293547,
-0.0028912399,
0.0459150001,
-0.0228560567,
0.0006337472,
0.0356707014,
0.0155185172,
0.0409062393,
-0.0474013351,
0.0189880133,
-0.0147652496,
-0.0003691333,
-0.0479071252,
-0.062506713,
-0.0749069154,
-0.0055166986,
-0.0259615332,
0.0139343096,
-0.029905675,
0.0019480031,
-0.0221301075,
0.023911817,
-0.0331353582,
0.0923232138,
-0.0369448587,
-0.0237030666,
0.0474289544,
-0.0214674231,
-0.0536905713,
-0.0569509529,
-0.027972687,
-0.0102603901,
-0.0462934114,
-0.0413144007,
0.0056168204,
0.0062028528,
0.0389936045,
-0.0077000172,
0.0333016217,
0.0756596103,
0.0253846534,
0.0053300424,
-0.0835569054,
-0.0350507535,
0.0080395816,
-0.0071996991,
-0.0410369821,
-0.0206815265,
0.0389736742,
0.0053249258,
-0.0206271671,
-0.045993723,
-0.0225789174,
0.0190304108,
-0.0526778065,
0.0985524282,
-0.0461755246,
0.0401209146,
0.0248108804,
-0.0264539998,
0.0338132791,
0.0268025119,
-0.0320510492,
-0.0455178618,
0.033908315,
-0.0343388245,
0.0264142733,
0.0143325562,
0.004541446,
-0.0044110683,
-0.061353568,
0.0635450557,
0.0516358279,
0.0299705658,
0.0083262818,
0.0299751498,
-0.0064385775,
-0.002738124,
0.0436253138,
0.0870873034,
0.0159556791,
0.0434332564,
0.0058609005,
0.0213951077,
-0.0227709487,
-0.0073539088,
0.0258737281,
-0.034365844,
-0.0161744095,
0.0245789699,
0.0020721499,
0.0064583826,
-0.0189060811,
-0.0086551383,
-0.0305409916,
0.0103774155,
0.0025231922,
-0.0017984603,
0.0238517225,
0.0006452732,
0.0120059112,
0.0229359139,
0.0101898704,
-0.0225730501,
-0.0353555419,
-0.0307549238,
0.0037727936,
0.1078079864,
0.0527745858,
-0.0623628534,
-0.0499821343,
0.0173024423,
0.0427278616,
0.021431677,
0.0234083813,
-0.0373741351,
-0.0462678261,
-0.0082983216,
-0.0034282822,
0.0695239529,
0.014437831,
-0.0223577041,
0.021689862,
0.0150017021,
0.0261277352,
-0.0729105026,
-0.0556654893,
0.0338409878,
0.0391635559,
-0.0169146024,
0.0136716925,
0.0152927004,
0.0118749375,
0.019364018,
-0.0038868957,
0.0252804328,
0.0320273824,
-0.0360238217,
-0.0088840593,
-0.0291558802,
0.0439926796,
0.0941619501,
0.0333289579,
0.0404916406,
-0.0004444278,
-0.0573444478,
0.0021578658,
-0.0144233722,
-0.0110795684,
-0.0008108577,
0.0517838597,
-0.0078356666,
0.0267139394,
-0.0478417426,
-0.0024859286,
-0.0545536689,
0.0395010486,
0.0162936486,
0.0516657606,
0.0112442197,
-0.0710111186,
0.0364320651,
-0.0212325193,
0.0091883857,
0.0450060554,
-0.0011350053,
0.0425847657,
0.0097510936,
-0.0133157168,
-0.0236927308,
0.0241658874,
-0.0411820225,
0.0356863886,
0.0178931002,
0.025706565,
0.0237370096,
0.0118865957,
-0.0302987322,
0.010908735,
-0.0628455356,
0.0197370294,
0.0168889277,
-0.0167968702,
0.0433154926,
-0.0017794768,
-0.0649366975,
-0.0085294107,
0.0003400867,
-0.0254043713,
0.0313744359,
-0.0342571139,
-0.0455724932,
-0.0221082307,
-0.0121175945,
-0.0331619307,
0.0148942554,
0.0047659934,
0.0355542116,
-0.053618487,
-0.0272791516,
0.0086692302,
0.0086174691,
-0.0092967199,
-0.0514237471,
0.0487335622,
-0.0291380696,
-0.0247862507,
-0.0240078177,
-0.0141971894,
-0.0198708698,
-0.0000461001,
-0.0264635924,
0.0433075912,
-0.0510513186,
-0.0311130341,
0.0060440078,
-0.0271312371,
-0.0040100473,
0.0041066809,
0.0596208349,
-0.0644249395,
0.0210468899,
0.0167071577,
0.049363181,
0.0149658788,
-0.00047319,
0.0111857131,
-0.0425831079,
0.0277122073,
-0.0030502805,
-0.0189218093,
-0.0507130511,
0.0843732357,
-0.0363202244,
0.0410353839,
-0.0278393086,
-0.0276703984,
0.0057028271,
-0.0122277141,
0.055369366,
-0.0551763773,
0.0766248256,
-0.0371039025,
0.0374888629,
0.0008141423,
0.0228972249,
-0.0392001085,
0.0146258706,
-0.0249027181,
0.0361864902,
0.0408406444,
-0.0054282737,
-0.043530114,
0.0522302315,
0.0016499161,
0.0246173255,
0.0239347313,
-0.0157348309,
-0.0210236572,
0.0272273049,
0.0212282203,
-0.0195205826,
-0.0437086709,
0.0556480139,
0.0193274617,
0.007646237,
-0.0287697818,
-0.0260743499,
0.011317499,
-0.0102058873,
0.0096999481,
-0.0611520335,
0.0329850763,
0.0392286889,
-0.0966635793,
-0.0082868282,
0.0131041193,
0.0796769634,
0.031820748,
-0.029094981,
-0.0325531252,
0.0311432518,
-0.0068200775,
0.0414659716,
0.0491748229,
-0.1063124016,
0.0086493269,
0.0261118859,
0.0014450382,
0.0245360546,
-0.0236993264,
-0.0242976267,
-0.0992941931,
0.0199145991,
-0.0221833065,
-0.0289918613,
-0.079873994,
-0.0603879951,
-0.0082685817,
-0.0375891514,
0.0090169515,
0.0272222031,
-0.0321295373,
-0.0234327633,
-0.0074206353,
-0.0411817655,
-0.0764388517,
0.0251803827,
-0.0595882125,
0.0475577898,
0.0317049585,
0.0560533367,
-0.0157842152,
-0.0127890958,
-0.0115794158,
0.0121480245,
-0.0462145507,
-0.0214332286,
0.0461217389,
-0.0315020941,
-0.001556557,
0.024665717,
-0.0146889519,
-0.0313559473,
0.0256880447,
0.0229639672,
0.0621492304,
0.000478512,
0.0242724232,
0.0036663956,
-0.0265011173,
-0.0045923423,
0.0684907511,
0.0106874928,
0.012472013,
0.0189958718,
0.0121770417,
-0.0412163511,
0.0318897255,
-0.0391716212,
0.0396273956,
-0.0729029924,
-0.0006827028,
-0.0412665531,
0.0183163434,
0.0374972112,
0.0116277104,
0.0216004793,
0.0725971982,
-0.0327265821,
-0.020682184,
-0.08203125,
-0.0294533446,
-0.0646988973,
0.0437889844,
-0.0172493514,
-0.0298021212,
0.0188342985,
0.0114875706,
-0.0493869334,
0.0386063792,
0.0059753819,
-0.0288131088,
-0.0208218936,
-0.0308313295,
0.0145023055,
0.0101314746,
-0.000248963,
-0.0133162672,
-0.0153493956,
0.0332611091,
-0.044308573,
-0.0542024858,
-0.0433180667,
-0.0204891525,
-0.0010934643,
0.03127205,
-0.0229120422,
0.0083678691,
-0.0079148114,
0.0227689706,
-0.0220272113,
-0.0173867699,
0.0885775387,
0.0523582995,
-0.0254035406,
0.0188653953,
-0.0466405973,
-0.0204830263,
0.0254571103,
-0.0195385721,
-0.0644613951,
0.0301957056,
-0.0011511522,
0.0111147203,
-0.0412631072,
0.0068881805,
0.0219148472,
-0.0168655962,
0.0126568899,
-0.0384234786,
-0.0206315275,
-0.0459122062,
-0.0372615941,
0.0230455175,
-0.0258567873,
-0.0140805626,
-0.0230004843,
0.0180230923,
0.0284228753,
-0.0311254039,
-0.0140019208,
0.0437141992,
-0.0147028826,
-0.0578546673,
0.023444755,
-0.0157176461,
-0.0477465056,
-0.0051603084,
-0.023097882,
0.0408564247,
-0.0320237502,
-0.0087051811,
-0.0394392684,
-0.0522145107,
-0.0002068983,
0.0061537353,
0.0162750557,
0.0127440738,
-0.0144185815,
0.0175291542,
-0.0341574699,
-0.0186075121,
0.0609931536,
0.0446928851,
0.0365497693,
-0.0366399921,
-0.0459911339,
-0.0424855538,
-0.0223409403,
0.0483826064,
0.0140326172,
-0.0246447399,
-0.028660588,
-0.0581206232,
-0.0221199859,
0.0328243561,
0.0112269903,
-0.0491302274,
0.0078753354,
0.0149356807,
0.050096333,
0.0844134092,
-0.0009878599,
-0.0329812057,
-0.0064099897,
-0.0621560775,
-0.016307231,
-0.0290314425,
-5.397009377e-33,
-0.0391695537,
-0.0539026931,
0.0309092831,
0.0114652598,
0.0218005907,
0.0167185441,
0.0292991884,
-0.0295242835,
0.0034686017,
-0.009217767,
-0.0163671486,
0.0209935289,
0.0294186231,
-0.0472244583,
0.0367906988,
-0.0339706764,
-0.0086454675,
0.0154283438,
0.0033259639,
-0.0064912331,
0.0262837168,
0.0189050306,
0.0177654456,
-0.0870222673,
0.0541872978,
-0.0191069916,
0.0005890595,
0.0076744538,
0.0430995449,
0.0446105488,
-0.0505705737,
0.0428663976,
0.0246374719,
-0.0062956875,
0.0019871234,
-0.0200254954,
-0.0718714818,
0.0129893078,
0.011993954,
0.0017835262,
0.0674771518,
0.0044217259,
0.0143762361,
-0.0035404724,
-0.0349241942,
0.0411163308,
0.0368777029,
-0.0380012132,
-0.0380562767,
-0.0397536717,
-0.0334447771,
0.0250216201,
0.0244621243,
0.0479985587,
0.1176998243,
-0.0469402745,
0.0138890008,
0.0429808758,
0.0268190745,
0.0312497839,
0.0226382781,
0.0264203418,
0.041076757,
0.0211370979,
0.0632216409,
-0.0003723477,
-0.0188061092,
0.0031770528,
0.0084782019,
0.0001883149,
-0.0230187196,
0.0367652848,
-0.0280523933,
0.0264846925,
0.0076561659,
-0.0182527062,
-0.0118728587,
0.0648275167,
-0.0383152924,
-0.0023037151,
-0.0117447982,
-0.0057807053,
-0.0339551866,
-0.0259596296,
-0.0261782352,
0.0470551737,
-0.0633189902,
0.0132932086,
0.0339716002,
-0.022851456,
-0.005062283,
0.0151241431,
-0.0179732181,
-0.0197523329,
-0.0688587725,
-0.0035583519,
0.0069214134,
-0.0456587039,
-0.0071403203,
0.0087088263,
-0.008856236,
-0.071029298,
-0.0089195101,
-0.0571504161,
-0.0059809526,
0.0229404084,
0.0444749184,
0.0013793017,
-0.0680759773,
0.0169701669,
-0.006881116,
-0.0349997245,
-0.038922254,
-0.0337730609,
0.0210330039,
0.0368161015,
0.0412773602,
0.0245645754,
0.0847587362,
-0.0014025595,
0.0173397921,
-0.0304948092,
-0.0070878565,
0.0065964195,
0.0271430202,
0.0374032967,
-0.0126742842,
-0.0429137945,
0.0389656015,
0.0255165622,
0.0086440602,
0.0047580022,
2.462e-7,
0.0687931702,
0.037518844,
-0.0010583575,
0.0544358417,
-0.0285268649,
-0.0323629119,
0.0008327943,
-0.0149579477,
-0.0776850283,
-0.0261384416,
0.0754990354,
-0.0245341156,
0.0367986001,
0.0620078519,
-0.0286193006,
0.0293628387,
-0.0230486114,
-0.0288219433,
-0.0684918687,
-0.0034979612,
0.0371964872,
0.0362928286,
-0.0241721645,
0.0086344769,
-0.0091917878,
-0.0378612764,
0.005086517,
-0.0940461531,
0.0462466925,
0.0431543589,
0.0685717911,
0.0267523862,
0.0048946878,
0.0558294617,
0.0134962089,
0.0407299586,
-0.0256434269,
0.0317355804,
-0.0174724907,
0.0449310541,
-0.0576415174,
-0.1202734038,
0.0097157573,
-0.0223936774,
0.0519778803,
-0.0021087287,
0.005726432,
0.0523868389,
-0.0326292738,
0.0247287508,
-0.0183832943,
0.0082188621,
-0.0275624134,
0.0223862976,
0.0294957832,
0.0140992096,
0.0079252301,
-0.063428767,
0.048911754,
0.0785493553,
-0.0054400628,
0.0075186221,
-0.0059568519,
0.0073451302,
0.0062153186,
-0.0125544509,
0.0235603768,
2.324914308e-34,
0.009792896,
0.0323836282,
0.0102078812,
0.0537936501,
0.0392601267,
-0.0182874668,
-0.0430121869,
0.0381201133,
-0.0183678493,
-0.0792876929,
0.0220693089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04041v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04041v2 | Evaluation and Enhancement of Semantic Grounding in Large Vision-Language Models | 2023-09-07T22:59:56 | 2024-01-13T03:02:12 | Jiaying Lu, Jinmeng Rao, Kezhen Chen, Xiaoyuan Guo, Yawen Zhang, Baochen Sun, Carl Yang, Jie Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) offer remarkable benefits for a variety
of vision-language tasks. However, a challenge hindering their application in
real-world scenarios, particularly regarding safety, robustness, and
reliability, is their constrained semantic grounding ability, which pertains to
connecting language to the physical-world entities or concepts referenced in
images. Therefore, a crucial need arises for a comprehensive study to assess
the semantic grounding ability of widely used LVLMs. Despite the significance,
sufficient investigation in this direction is currently lacking. Our work
bridges this gap by designing a pipeline for generating large-scale evaluation
datasets covering fine-grained semantic information, such as color, number,
material, etc., along with a thorough assessment of seven popular LVLMs'
semantic grounding ability. Results highlight prevalent misgrounding across
various aspects and degrees. To address this issue, we propose a data-centric
enhancement method that aims to improve LVLMs' semantic grounding ability
through multimodal instruction tuning on fine-grained conversations.
Experiments on enhanced LVLMs demonstrate notable improvements in addressing
misgrounding issues. | [
0.0046659713,
0.0576910637,
0.0196861494,
0.0637766644,
-0.0097294273,
0.0003194356,
0.0113241002,
-0.0204160754,
-0.0431989767,
-0.0947104245,
-0.0232499745,
-0.0099673914,
0.0303925276,
-0.004082582,
0.0341032669,
-0.0681699887,
0.0253265891,
-0.0465474837,
-0.0550766066,
0.0048276405,
0.0135574732,
0.0016478471,
-0.0129696326,
0.0347282179,
-0.0542923249,
0.0006066518,
0.0087293684,
0.0247136094,
0.0333101489,
-0.030982649,
-0.0427460857,
0.0375655219,
0.0657520965,
-0.0040705898,
0.0000020326,
-0.0532722883,
0.0267880429,
0.0020769916,
0.0136202667,
-0.0034643179,
0.0405968837,
-0.0347392708,
-0.0066223401,
-0.0056077414,
-0.0200041365,
-0.0143693127,
0.0959411934,
0.0648558885,
0.0695747063,
0.0013340304,
-0.0089701489,
-0.0274650939,
0.0219227448,
0.0244876444,
0.0461448394,
-0.0345624648,
0.0275892001,
0.0683291554,
-0.0201280266,
0.0041794959,
-0.0643576682,
0.0178295467,
0.0416156016,
-0.0159198325,
0.0218311101,
0.048299972,
-0.0542518049,
-0.0189926773,
-0.0189017728,
0.0982812494,
-0.0090814037,
-0.0352735445,
-0.0371696576,
0.002411457,
-0.0186487287,
-0.0041333777,
-0.0402319394,
0.0368936472,
-0.0072559263,
0.0296578407,
-0.0552486181,
0.0025694349,
0.0143113965,
0.0379063897,
-0.0197658874,
0.0600518808,
0.007806214,
0.0105246957,
0.0210512057,
0.0115077794,
-0.0313561112,
-0.0444610752,
-0.024502432,
-0.0077016084,
-0.0249605272,
0.0042511402,
-0.059307076,
-0.0050949631,
0.0004105086,
-0.0510647036,
0.0638130605,
0.0259906948,
-0.0788989961,
0.0663780421,
-0.0321929716,
0.0403200276,
-0.0113972835,
0.0346001573,
-0.0202033836,
-0.0214639734,
-0.0120205218,
0.00460127,
-0.0335780531,
-0.0240806565,
-0.0743660256,
-0.0221395548,
-0.0139065208,
0.0060079182,
-0.0342991054,
0.017096797,
-0.0314878002,
0.0266600847,
-0.0401429646,
0.0045769145,
-0.0182402711,
0.0118576232,
-0.0123846279,
0.0264695715,
-0.0019342829,
-0.0933042243,
0.0253794715,
0.0474507287,
0.001312451,
-0.0223695543,
-0.0075364094,
0.0850132331,
-0.0073351492,
-0.0200800393,
-0.0584903322,
-0.0305166487,
-0.0095490059,
-0.0301870964,
0.0250563417,
-0.0570199862,
0.0002245496,
-0.001178471,
0.0166469384,
-0.0338181369,
0.0293170307,
0.0011984124,
-0.0124149024,
0.1310807317,
-0.0570021346,
-0.0148273204,
0.0106812166,
0.0077927164,
0.0122125922,
0.0804530308,
0.0320457742,
0.0209023952,
0.0359339975,
-0.03248946,
-0.0117550939,
0.0050230124,
-0.0086292755,
0.0065787346,
-0.0821113661,
-0.0058440873,
-0.006632424,
0.023255555,
0.0196468979,
0.0501032993,
-0.024976762,
-0.0314112566,
0.0796912238,
0.0347181372,
-0.0164441075,
-0.0151560614,
0.0622739121,
0.0084020235,
-0.0152070643,
-0.0101588173,
-0.0745595619,
0.0396455191,
-0.0417624339,
-0.0040150061,
-0.019760007,
0.0304629263,
-0.0427053049,
-0.0362809971,
-0.0114343334,
-0.0003700341,
0.0594374798,
0.0203603208,
0.0442602709,
0.0106699783,
-0.0063961362,
0.0205331799,
0.0466836207,
-0.045599997,
-0.0055787452,
-0.0322911106,
0.0019235841,
0.0686364323,
0.0106107704,
0.0249714907,
-0.0313850977,
-0.0101080695,
0.0798154473,
0.0532968976,
-0.0112773497,
0.0133737316,
0.0383867547,
-0.0696991906,
-0.0673805997,
-0.0249927044,
-0.0046055904,
0.012135921,
0.0159589984,
-0.0378785878,
0.0299755149,
-0.0402450413,
-0.0169838052,
0.0436654612,
0.0360662714,
0.0288380068,
-0.0318952017,
0.0111275986,
0.0073415595,
-0.0030923109,
-0.0364146158,
0.0033224479,
0.0172785092,
-0.0081037013,
0.0094931265,
0.0141680175,
-0.0210018288,
0.036550846,
0.039514903,
-0.0687071905,
-0.0034306538,
0.0083347037,
-0.0438831262,
-0.0131510422,
0.0143970335,
-0.0270493403,
0.0133056138,
-0.0259494521,
-0.0063505559,
0.0010541915,
0.025265066,
-0.0294378158,
0.028992977,
-0.0191272553,
-0.0077995714,
-0.0186770391,
0.0487745516,
-0.0049979901,
-0.0549212024,
-0.0063877041,
0.0111510307,
0.0023098714,
0.0411472693,
0.005727889,
0.0241606142,
-0.0500269458,
0.0212532375,
-0.1043056846,
-0.0587303042,
-0.0348539427,
-0.0370357148,
0.0179220308,
-0.0237542093,
0.0094495593,
-0.0231506303,
0.002967915,
0.0527710877,
-0.0077697951,
0.0251185466,
0.0145552838,
0.0038550333,
-0.0424343608,
-0.008490744,
-0.0049124984,
0.0177645907,
0.0648387149,
0.0422340818,
-0.035073299,
-0.049847696,
0.0329290889,
-0.0552535318,
0.0490790345,
-0.0152295874,
-0.014172879,
0.0065205046,
0.0093603749,
0.0120368544,
0.0741901323,
-0.0096862521,
0.0432748199,
0.0494256355,
-0.0225387849,
-0.0267613363,
-0.0163823273,
0.0051618982,
-0.0334201381,
-0.0178718921,
0.0196539126,
-0.0282124747,
0.0341421627,
-0.0060241125,
0.0250291657,
-0.0440884642,
0.0363275744,
-0.0281761698,
-0.0642380863,
-0.0646779388,
0.0045760209,
0.0073518581,
0.0583393238,
-0.0486730263,
-0.0782579854,
0.0425582901,
-0.0440288633,
-0.0132041369,
0.0146825416,
-0.0107383914,
0.0049458561,
0.0599032566,
-0.0036333157,
0.0282519292,
-0.0224611554,
0.0114592537,
-0.0342532881,
-0.0530125462,
-0.0149459289,
0.0110475728,
0.1012764201,
-0.097512722,
0.0257524028,
-0.0175208934,
-0.0209715869,
-0.0320566557,
0.0053529525,
-0.0516615696,
0.0120393634,
-0.0681377947,
-0.0105459606,
-0.0193747561,
0.0360237584,
0.0235554557,
0.0108369235,
0.0000466146,
-0.0162943285,
-0.0282571595,
-0.0145075023,
0.046826303,
0.0110327611,
0.0208341759,
-0.0331811905,
0.0166291632,
0.0564033426,
0.0297805052,
-0.0033208327,
-0.0875968486,
0.0300669335,
0.0210883152,
0.0449229851,
-0.0052195759,
0.0306135044,
0.0513251312,
-0.045397982,
-0.0076796482,
0.061444521,
-0.0030441587,
-0.0201334134,
0.0118168816,
0.0024912464,
0.0058633219,
0.024754243,
-0.0242790896,
-0.0683751032,
-0.0585727133,
-0.0185894594,
-0.011833854,
0.0300789196,
-0.0178254675,
-0.0216050781,
-0.10050001,
0.0616339631,
0.0158416517,
-0.0511725992,
-0.0721462443,
0.0150088063,
0.0168109182,
-0.0035910234,
0.0515443794,
-0.0168596078,
-0.0063389344,
-0.008616087,
0.0051566339,
0.0206155386,
-0.0737472996,
0.0195175298,
-0.0429954417,
0.0051792259,
0.0706293434,
-0.0221195556,
-0.0108417412,
-0.0735414997,
0.0463263169,
-0.0104870815,
0.0162592698,
-0.0144128082,
0.0499315932,
-0.0368555412,
-0.0266034752,
0.0203584153,
0.0215248056,
-0.0035474957,
-0.0311467424,
-0.0422588103,
0.029171912,
-0.0446637981,
0.0154514108,
-0.0275295582,
0.0275765397,
0.0057515977,
0.0408490971,
0.0338191204,
-0.0508879647,
-0.0063794074,
-0.0257297195,
-0.003631803,
-0.0186118353,
-0.0319319591,
0.0016367222,
0.0006078226,
-0.0111276815,
-0.0438116454,
-0.0180107672,
0.0611581951,
0.0408670977,
-0.0200381521,
-0.0383098572,
0.0058080601,
0.0122435633,
-0.0570411012,
0.0915179476,
-0.0286801495,
0.0369787961,
-0.0353032351,
0.0006272752,
0.0520562753,
-0.0331485197,
-0.0022693255,
0.0412900299,
-0.0523897819,
-0.0373194888,
-0.0039677895,
0.0393381491,
0.0243718363,
0.0287036598,
0.0005583218,
-0.0607451349,
0.0109046204,
0.0279480051,
-0.0261616837,
0.0487988964,
-0.0082437936,
0.0035089096,
0.0147521431,
0.0242783427,
-0.0423902459,
0.0436818451,
0.0472484976,
0.0189433713,
-0.0121329948,
-0.0325830653,
0.0188259352,
0.0034357186,
0.0728188083,
-0.0123497704,
0.0267694835,
-0.0058923215,
0.0252831634,
-0.0117079085,
-0.0283133127,
-0.0833864361,
0.0237213876,
-0.0006778833,
0.0019321532,
0.0342944078,
-0.002209164,
0.0070732231,
0.0573009364,
-0.0203961618,
0.0031743192,
-0.0015520992,
-0.0101429075,
0.0068159811,
0.032402426,
-0.0049991263,
0.003334064,
-0.0279719178,
0.0230670534,
0.028057836,
0.0666570663,
0.0326327868,
-0.0241672974,
-0.0499774702,
0.0522211343,
-0.0203802716,
-0.0397706665,
-0.0424042158,
0.0560896322,
0.0656076595,
0.0284863655,
0.0471126549,
-0.0251853317,
-0.0211857893,
-0.0246346742,
0.056810502,
0.0456282347,
-0.0450451896,
0.0840911642,
0.0309967715,
-0.01040552,
-0.0216843113,
0.0212588515,
0.0050154384,
0.0278462712,
0.0024376742,
0.0111739831,
-0.03083257,
-0.0203659423,
0.0319049843,
-0.0003712356,
-0.0027901295,
0.0453215018,
-0.0685135648,
-0.0773192793,
-0.0232572649,
0.0442112908,
-0.0107066045,
0.0081851091,
0.0814933851,
0.0447095521,
0.0086780777,
-0.012176225,
0.0048937863,
-0.0505752005,
-0.0031795232,
0.0040941783,
-0.009855683,
-6.0209739e-33,
-0.0439349338,
-0.0329105854,
0.0240371414,
0.0167086609,
-0.0212548412,
0.0295975208,
-0.0053286124,
0.0185867492,
-0.0164865125,
0.0410899632,
0.0286367908,
-0.0069548776,
0.013081097,
0.0320831314,
-0.0131493947,
-0.0227627084,
0.0279465895,
0.0114403851,
-0.0163744893,
-0.0140788527,
0.0174720157,
-0.0154752489,
0.0649798885,
-0.0956852734,
-0.020506829,
0.063367635,
-0.031463366,
0.0147618642,
-0.0033253543,
0.0772744045,
-0.011989031,
0.0577814616,
0.012308619,
-0.0332903601,
-0.0531077981,
0.0304324273,
-0.0447966196,
-0.0196199771,
0.0450301692,
0.0432229415,
-0.0833613053,
0.0285727326,
0.0406325683,
-0.0311177969,
-0.0268671587,
-0.0224835034,
0.0227402411,
-0.04039656,
-0.0145674217,
0.012991352,
-0.0449096188,
0.0218519066,
0.0190324318,
-0.0305856839,
0.0319046564,
-0.014697779,
0.0086674429,
0.0216235742,
-0.0283141602,
0.027381178,
-0.0015988377,
-0.012521049,
0.1001458466,
0.054184068,
0.0161314812,
0.0764032751,
0.0216496624,
-0.0297843684,
-0.018796362,
-0.0385849662,
0.0188204963,
0.0513707697,
0.0417538062,
0.0771798566,
-0.0004983937,
0.020785626,
-0.0380134471,
-0.0032627811,
-0.0558379032,
0.0837900192,
0.0188124478,
0.0161019396,
-0.0197780877,
-0.0263335146,
-0.058079835,
0.0103125088,
-0.0356652588,
-0.0171720609,
0.0579867736,
0.0000357398,
-0.0351993255,
0.0442358889,
0.0350602567,
-0.0437880121,
-0.0030035304,
0.0319079533,
0.0070491522,
0.0470799953,
0.0137881553,
-0.0223731995,
-0.0417003706,
-0.0133004533,
0.0534276366,
-0.0063014627,
0.0167243965,
-0.0096700229,
0.0017136392,
0.0117134098,
-0.0361095332,
0.009057492,
-0.0387995914,
-0.0159350205,
0.0026898226,
0.0145135485,
0.0473466329,
0.0160833672,
-0.0387606733,
0.0588941909,
-0.0064095282,
-0.020074673,
0.0018372406,
-0.0446157083,
-0.0243972093,
0.0339173041,
-0.0287601501,
0.0017377391,
-0.0499885716,
-0.0781837851,
0.0525590777,
-0.018360706,
-0.0193065479,
0.0135573968,
2.726e-7,
0.0199577753,
0.0323622301,
0.0073334756,
0.0094269235,
0.0063628089,
0.0491944626,
0.0018125859,
0.03051758,
0.0043569403,
-0.0905400887,
-0.0347243249,
0.0545403361,
0.0296447556,
0.003451349,
-0.0027997994,
0.0265771076,
-0.0054192287,
-0.0056745028,
-0.0455114469,
0.0069436412,
0.0421612449,
0.0815406367,
-0.0084894598,
-0.0123820184,
0.0458430983,
-0.04673253,
0.0502353236,
-0.0711798593,
0.003712541,
-0.0157272108,
-0.0048262663,
0.0199308097,
-0.0087049529,
0.0654498339,
0.0146012763,
-0.0177034717,
0.0268063191,
0.0200618915,
-0.0481547639,
0.0177021138,
-0.0447108671,
-0.0034633812,
-0.0245729983,
-0.0562355444,
0.0511534773,
-0.0567020401,
-0.0266130362,
-0.0121160364,
-0.0004996662,
-0.0009072162,
0.0146777937,
-0.0208735056,
-0.0389648303,
-0.032610029,
0.0297973733,
-0.0018787904,
-0.0567432456,
-0.0737013072,
-0.0086264843,
0.003685446,
-0.0192364007,
-0.0652050823,
-0.0053270785,
-0.0307052825,
0.0362506025,
-0.0383410789,
-0.0608014464,
2.388976684e-34,
0.0192771424,
0.0118373567,
0.0234766752,
-0.0210160185,
0.0180298965,
-0.003321371,
-0.0242476277,
0.0189523976,
-0.0103902873,
-0.0392731354,
0.0142839113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04031v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04031v2 | Multiple Representation Transfer from Large Language Models to End-to-End ASR Systems | 2023-09-07T21:57:39 | 2023-12-25T07:28:07 | Takuma Udagawa, Masayuki Suzuki, Gakuto Kurata, Masayasu Muraoka, George Saon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Transferring the knowledge of large language models (LLMs) is a promising
technique to incorporate linguistic knowledge into end-to-end automatic speech
recognition (ASR) systems. However, existing works only transfer a single
representation of LLM (e.g. the last layer of pretrained BERT), while the
representation of a text is inherently non-unique and can be obtained variously
from different layers, contexts and models. In this work, we explore a wide
range of techniques to obtain and transfer multiple representations of LLMs
into a transducer-based ASR system. While being conceptually simple, we show
that transferring multiple representations of LLMs can be an effective
alternative to transferring only a single representation. | [
-0.0278758649,
0.0291895755,
0.0106987488,
0.0548411943,
-0.003317215,
0.0028822001,
0.0210999083,
0.0049344543,
-0.0213951934,
-0.0627746955,
-0.0705515891,
-0.0006634991,
0.0043060929,
-0.0091651184,
0.0400530733,
-0.0384599976,
0.0038659158,
-0.081702061,
-0.0233162437,
-0.0341298543,
-0.0003696281,
0.0258789156,
0.0002055757,
0.041997049,
0.0104751671,
0.0224017706,
-0.0055300416,
-0.0068723923,
0.0439174846,
0.0075665917,
-0.0364676751,
-0.0319245234,
0.0471576974,
0.026438918,
0.0000015882,
-0.0263518095,
-0.034356609,
0.0266735163,
-0.0425045043,
0.0308713093,
0.022261411,
-0.0214339159,
-0.0017192586,
0.034863729,
-0.00489777,
-0.008645365,
0.0450132824,
0.0099586314,
0.0524564087,
0.0518822521,
-0.0164741296,
-0.0526207089,
0.0112813124,
0.0134532815,
-0.0322338045,
-0.0608857609,
0.0360311158,
-0.0022906945,
0.0309987906,
-0.016343873,
-0.0047777141,
0.0499136709,
-0.020194659,
-0.0034078904,
0.0195384342,
-0.0242251288,
-0.0191959906,
-0.0072221234,
-0.0391390733,
0.0478652939,
-0.0269117542,
-0.0198915079,
0.0075196056,
0.027627727,
-0.0274257455,
-0.0094252229,
-0.0300561376,
0.0148099558,
0.0024031152,
0.0253075082,
-0.0058173942,
-0.0245211143,
0.023909891,
-0.0233728159,
-0.0950391367,
0.0054852818,
0.0244580247,
-0.0026159147,
0.0171806198,
-0.0095896637,
0.0309863854,
0.0025315229,
0.0805342719,
0.0238315091,
0.028549457,
0.0219882932,
-0.0280145314,
-0.0291658044,
-0.0206876136,
-0.0531846881,
0.0765001699,
0.0484089404,
-0.083730109,
0.0165754426,
-0.0480780452,
0.0591565408,
-0.0478744246,
0.0207095034,
-0.0705996826,
-0.0481171161,
-0.0583329797,
-0.0128985625,
-0.0540318973,
0.0380599238,
-0.0003162754,
-0.0698795617,
-0.0283902809,
0.0508814827,
0.0210562069,
-0.033077918,
0.01936589,
-0.0268102735,
-0.0027187928,
-0.0141756134,
0.0644120649,
0.0790940076,
0.0420654155,
0.0282005258,
-0.0378648378,
-0.0372992642,
-0.0193069577,
0.0333603583,
0.0506961159,
0.0032638847,
-0.0192117132,
0.0508911312,
-0.0129186651,
-0.0217655227,
-0.0601280369,
0.0341480374,
-0.0361743011,
-0.0200715922,
0.0014766273,
-0.0222853739,
0.0377651788,
0.0186665319,
0.0170259811,
-0.0284637101,
0.0150064575,
-0.0361975729,
0.0024136622,
0.0916084945,
0.0154641345,
0.0310530476,
0.0572330467,
-0.0159257296,
-0.0035232513,
0.0445464104,
0.070544973,
0.0042499094,
-0.0113319792,
-0.0486524217,
-0.034255866,
0.0834641829,
-0.005915558,
0.0276441034,
-0.0394296385,
-0.0400846153,
0.0408807695,
-0.0135581447,
0.0227911007,
0.0608426705,
-0.0285375323,
0.0281792618,
0.0437203124,
0.0478428379,
0.0324788019,
0.0188813489,
0.0582387336,
-0.0250431988,
0.0377558507,
-0.0320505127,
0.0137619944,
-0.0240021534,
-0.0137746083,
-0.0062299287,
0.0293749515,
0.0528077707,
-0.0070530428,
0.0471121818,
-0.0246133562,
-0.0234018955,
-0.0107781403,
0.0335755311,
0.0892818496,
-0.0038475415,
-0.0460449457,
0.0762085691,
-0.0157386158,
-0.0485940054,
0.0528285168,
-0.0478546023,
-0.0233089607,
0.0369111821,
0.0008579159,
-0.0226789527,
-0.0280403029,
0.0032137849,
-0.0210935511,
0.0450286046,
-0.0058103059,
-0.0111759678,
0.0455709435,
-0.0545062795,
-0.0135416854,
0.05724141,
-0.0023765739,
0.1035269871,
-0.0422092564,
0.0419174321,
0.0173207838,
-0.0535394698,
0.0163663775,
-0.0050465162,
-0.023955673,
-0.0250221342,
0.0118433088,
0.0112728663,
0.0613894388,
0.0254443418,
-0.0214959662,
-0.0043587424,
0.0509965308,
-0.0644600317,
-0.0057063177,
0.0256391428,
-0.058920145,
-0.0135602113,
0.0341903679,
-0.01579706,
0.0435311794,
0.0190388002,
0.0071343174,
-0.0696232319,
-0.0073042372,
-0.0491619036,
0.0964577794,
-0.0221268386,
0.0509402119,
0.0389559865,
-0.0026059721,
0.0277314112,
-0.011159936,
0.0352293104,
-0.0444693714,
0.0380617529,
-0.0423172191,
0.000547178,
-0.0513902009,
0.0139986351,
0.047083348,
0.0014980963,
0.0215745233,
0.0090704663,
-0.0107021853,
0.0114635862,
-0.0331041515,
-0.0976656973,
-0.0397707932,
-0.0120460857,
0.0390855633,
-0.0079072788,
0.0225808956,
0.0291054826,
-0.009919364,
-0.0391572081,
-0.0531940982,
-0.0122934934,
-0.0009028483,
-0.029933447,
0.0006643625,
-0.056515418,
0.0019938457,
0.0088178562,
0.0050498126,
0.0658266693,
-0.0419611372,
-0.0497390069,
-0.0840553567,
-0.0308379102,
0.0277333055,
0.042526722,
0.0071290582,
-0.031267833,
-0.0220066756,
-0.0298783928,
-0.0099392338,
0.0225067735,
-0.0122296503,
0.0200528093,
0.0225373022,
-0.0558570884,
-0.0688173473,
0.0025338272,
0.0221680589,
0.0098989131,
-0.0220186766,
-0.0007560156,
-0.0193583425,
-0.0081828069,
0.0357487276,
0.016383402,
-0.0409246832,
-0.0232391469,
-0.0120423371,
-0.0402647592,
-0.0237895995,
-0.0449055992,
-0.0566879399,
-0.0136184832,
0.0173408426,
-0.0089367814,
0.0027695096,
-0.0940701887,
-0.041881416,
-0.020543227,
-0.0277895089,
-0.0299607068,
0.0396774448,
-0.0217425805,
0.0341930315,
-0.0383842215,
-0.0469662659,
0.0087458538,
0.0106892418,
0.0076384144,
-0.0516552366,
0.0420210548,
-0.060982883,
0.0477764644,
0.0093182428,
-0.0634000376,
-0.0143017499,
0.0207501035,
-0.039606601,
0.0553315319,
-0.0094424002,
-0.0574127994,
-0.0520398095,
0.0430861413,
0.0278094802,
0.0461692698,
0.0213809349,
0.031835217,
-0.0311374012,
0.0517292358,
0.0100846682,
-0.0005038281,
-0.0375059396,
-0.0333964601,
0.0229513664,
0.0004715649,
0.0538053066,
0.037769895,
-0.06337706,
0.0111442944,
0.0622647479,
-0.0172222275,
0.013070832,
-0.017668616,
0.0238420386,
-0.0406626761,
0.0110591706,
0.1009170413,
0.0006260086,
0.0127997994,
-0.0146992318,
-0.012683602,
-0.0100431414,
-0.0202092864,
-0.0005756362,
-0.0597245842,
-0.031783089,
0.0442403331,
0.0417688191,
0.0403738245,
0.0332316644,
-0.0268300492,
-0.1047271267,
-0.0012672826,
0.0568604283,
-0.0292655043,
-0.0421641469,
-0.0346762724,
-0.0126626212,
0.0091084363,
0.0280925333,
0.0024182678,
-0.0023697116,
-0.0594096296,
0.0244826786,
-0.0307357647,
-0.0342982039,
0.0200705938,
0.0060010906,
0.0621698871,
0.0628535599,
0.0317291208,
-0.0195827149,
-0.0298186447,
0.0085264156,
-0.0056099207,
0.0011983818,
-0.014242663,
-0.0067324941,
0.0081970878,
-0.0241188835,
0.0519677065,
0.0342254192,
-0.026576573,
-0.0156012736,
0.0008822171,
0.0682372451,
-0.0050443825,
-0.0180407539,
0.0326513685,
-0.0172842443,
0.0183841772,
0.0776671171,
0.00225721,
-0.0353786759,
0.0236832965,
0.0122588109,
0.0107545853,
-0.0141508598,
0.0113145337,
0.0320984684,
-0.0782388225,
-0.0304335319,
-0.0446550325,
0.0409708619,
0.0382940546,
0.0306779295,
0.0680323765,
0.0022540484,
0.0457250029,
0.0178473163,
0.0093934312,
0.0117370123,
-0.0326802917,
0.0065904236,
-0.0515293069,
-0.0268513821,
0.0454848148,
-0.0379900262,
-0.0149685927,
-0.0006104134,
-0.017223781,
-0.0680196062,
0.0227143019,
0.0033317739,
0.0205102973,
0.0046169064,
-0.0171917006,
-0.022601204,
0.0975786224,
-0.0085682627,
-0.0354418345,
0.0133783612,
0.0535374843,
0.0190542787,
-0.018806627,
0.0248263478,
-0.0782501698,
0.025653081,
-0.0136334775,
0.0360578597,
-0.0117769912,
-0.0919623524,
0.0124147711,
0.0509444214,
0.0366467759,
-0.0071290769,
0.0253324751,
-0.0059572621,
0.0231956169,
-0.007912307,
0.0433037356,
-0.0658755675,
0.0311656799,
0.040029604,
0.014876049,
-0.0226995237,
0.009321399,
0.0284274016,
-0.0143070742,
-0.0035984977,
0.063788943,
0.0063090324,
0.0075318879,
0.0359545238,
-0.0066362042,
-0.0376441292,
0.0502493754,
0.0243838355,
-0.0148019893,
-0.0431136079,
0.0131110279,
0.0131538976,
0.0052735656,
-0.0087873209,
0.0180671215,
-0.052681841,
-0.0524488427,
-0.0093921376,
0.0515670627,
0.0473312698,
0.0491326861,
0.0995182097,
0.0092215342,
0.0016872452,
-0.0380552784,
0.0327646732,
-0.0197145287,
0.0278116185,
0.0019614606,
-0.0035159837,
-0.0025000528,
0.0075281314,
0.01206984,
-0.0221933722,
0.0606777407,
-0.0324915461,
0.0010767163,
-0.031810198,
-0.0468041748,
0.0208312199,
-0.0320613012,
-0.0300682969,
-0.0042934171,
-0.0006536712,
-0.0492528304,
0.0747006238,
-0.0339802168,
-0.0027328164,
-0.0323798172,
-0.0098296255,
-0.0099526988,
-0.0277102068,
-0.0115118241,
0.0433352552,
-0.0263792463,
0.0139512559,
-0.0344500542,
0.0469902679,
-5.780240372e-33,
-0.0220731813,
0.0313156731,
-0.0239825509,
-0.044659704,
-0.0349644944,
-0.0042734179,
-0.0054975296,
-0.0166159384,
0.0279122274,
-0.0225026868,
-0.0126124108,
-0.0275837909,
0.0450361297,
0.0067967386,
-0.0068348926,
0.0184746552,
0.0785089508,
0.0046840394,
0.0179220922,
0.0028654279,
0.0518395901,
0.0716192499,
0.0518002696,
-0.0228417683,
-0.0272090454,
0.0131690586,
-0.0153927673,
0.0098034823,
0.015839614,
0.0455382243,
-0.0050105369,
0.0580963939,
-0.0195141323,
-0.0369023532,
-0.0282519534,
0.0525112562,
-0.072522223,
-0.008572787,
0.0216981824,
0.0598213263,
0.0076992693,
-0.0250408947,
0.0171566717,
-0.0312976688,
0.0197140444,
0.0132353297,
0.0048994138,
-0.0305719133,
-0.0055060224,
-0.0498434566,
-0.0158302393,
0.0132356118,
-0.0139425229,
-0.0157352425,
0.0815867037,
0.0466070771,
-0.0181042068,
-0.0298260916,
-0.0407390632,
-0.0031952786,
0.0178295206,
0.0097703831,
0.0447762609,
0.0626031309,
-0.0202665273,
-0.0042991447,
0.0093305213,
-0.1101563126,
-0.0161009859,
-0.075091444,
0.0193109605,
0.0282749552,
-0.0086571323,
0.0001208637,
-0.0183371566,
-0.0290648267,
-0.019957779,
-0.0366912335,
0.0202976428,
0.0113949105,
0.0176886208,
0.0296484251,
0.0149440086,
-0.0116496095,
-0.072535485,
-0.0263464823,
-0.0187214538,
0.007468455,
0.0812018365,
-0.0054379045,
-0.0272624828,
-0.0000372514,
0.0863287672,
-0.031091081,
-0.0309487488,
0.0248135328,
0.0085227638,
-0.0104417438,
-0.0293117668,
0.0534701459,
-0.0324221104,
-0.0650457442,
0.0037491175,
0.0041223932,
0.0194329284,
-0.0391523577,
0.0131818624,
0.0689274147,
-0.0646307692,
-0.0022504246,
-0.0147533547,
-0.0232886579,
0.0015567015,
0.0388516076,
0.0367244184,
-0.0079886187,
0.0232474469,
-0.000863964,
-0.004789379,
0.0372489728,
0.0123026799,
-0.0033045155,
0.0119855003,
0.0332868621,
-0.0507621206,
0.0154150845,
0.0095915217,
0.0148916095,
0.0466151834,
0.0129592493,
-0.001835598,
0.0084705614,
2.439e-7,
0.0071241204,
0.0052351714,
0.0466033332,
-0.0181059074,
-0.0022468287,
0.0121675665,
-0.0217091125,
0.0283536464,
0.0149549702,
0.0087027149,
-0.0159920175,
0.0259380713,
0.0691963211,
0.0093052499,
-0.1044000462,
-0.0483943596,
-0.0167089663,
0.0196220912,
-0.0296250526,
0.0099759391,
0.0388533324,
0.0594586655,
0.0119276512,
-0.0345840752,
-0.0053899987,
-0.0602084957,
0.0467509143,
-0.0334092118,
0.0390922539,
0.0195460115,
0.010332427,
-0.0347575322,
-0.0302960016,
0.0368298367,
0.0151686519,
0.0569988973,
0.0224852189,
0.0556252971,
-0.0318654738,
-0.0379726663,
-0.0090780016,
0.0280543491,
-0.0339690968,
-0.0099986494,
0.025450943,
-0.0377216861,
0.0048395512,
-0.0509914793,
-0.0364923105,
-0.0395739637,
-0.0115189943,
-0.0158772115,
0.0278100241,
0.0192822982,
0.0075109121,
-0.0161642861,
-0.0410187244,
-0.0964682773,
0.020749703,
0.0120004322,
-0.0611875206,
-0.0286449753,
-0.0135334441,
-0.0043134168,
0.0118291248,
-0.0629674494,
0.0081733819,
1.625835191e-34,
0.012653294,
-0.0396409892,
0.0007202575,
0.0608505383,
0.0143351136,
-0.0438712202,
-0.0142783094,
0.0337994434,
-0.0139375562,
-0.104129903,
-0.0475928336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04027v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04027v2 | TIDE: Textual Identity Detection for Evaluating and Augmenting Classification and Language Models | 2023-09-07T21:44:42 | 2024-01-12T16:20:15 | Emmanuel Klu, Sameer Sethi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Machine learning models can perpetuate unintended biases from unfair and
imbalanced datasets. Evaluating and debiasing these datasets and models is
especially hard in text datasets where sensitive attributes such as race,
gender, and sexual orientation may not be available. When these models are
deployed into society, they can lead to unfair outcomes for historically
underrepresented groups. In this paper, we present a dataset coupled with an
approach to improve text fairness in classifiers and language models. We create
a new, more comprehensive identity lexicon, TIDAL, which includes 15,123
identity terms and associated sense context across three demographic
categories. We leverage TIDAL to develop an identity annotation and
augmentation tool that can be used to improve the availability of identity
context and the effectiveness of ML fairness techniques. We evaluate our
approaches using human contributors, and additionally run experiments focused
on dataset and model debiasing. Results show our assistive annotation technique
improves the reliability and velocity of human-in-the-loop processes. Our
dataset and methods uncover more disparities during evaluation, and also
produce more fair models during remediation. These approaches provide a
practical path forward for scaling classifier and generative model fairness in
real-world settings. | [
0.047914505,
0.1146139205,
-0.0231389217,
0.0099425716,
-0.0018664976,
0.0221580379,
0.0595390573,
-0.0257198419,
0.004199265,
-0.06822671,
0.0132921925,
0.0017893233,
0.0228349101,
0.0024114412,
0.0128108552,
-0.0257752519,
0.0075591705,
0.0430812575,
0.0447786562,
-0.0387998335,
0.0173479747,
0.0492033809,
0.0278961007,
0.0664004534,
-0.0415682197,
-0.0198586807,
0.0709547028,
0.0159197357,
0.0154233519,
-0.0073864446,
0.0539302565,
0.0935089812,
-0.0268637035,
0.0805308819,
0.0000019679,
-0.0573661029,
0.0041282801,
0.0259383954,
-0.0503865965,
-0.0062498939,
0.0535299815,
0.0106151635,
0.0056682564,
0.0235549621,
-0.0191508122,
0.0209713262,
0.0625616014,
0.0016452472,
0.0348008163,
-0.0143804885,
-0.0090185851,
-0.0183223318,
-0.0299613923,
-0.003485919,
0.0197508633,
0.0132510494,
0.0498477072,
-0.0343978964,
-0.0540834032,
-0.0578502417,
0.0230801646,
0.0290546678,
0.0325347632,
-0.0108227339,
0.0679068193,
0.0160901584,
-0.02946008,
-0.0323348157,
0.0195008926,
0.0472002625,
0.0283539556,
-0.0206889007,
-0.0151615441,
-0.010848524,
0.0288104415,
0.0024208033,
-0.0227476023,
0.03248436,
-0.0093939966,
-0.0010330401,
-0.0498405583,
0.0038077107,
0.0413816683,
0.0610541739,
0.0012912182,
0.0573760942,
0.0077531761,
-0.0170259327,
-0.0298506282,
0.024834808,
0.001732248,
-0.0458813421,
0.0265411399,
-0.0259002838,
0.007040658,
0.0135417329,
-0.0334760584,
-0.0403438434,
0.0476468913,
-0.06079036,
0.0468937159,
0.0031794042,
-0.0229457766,
-0.0148265846,
0.0197983515,
0.0085291658,
0.054261636,
0.0235914495,
0.0256719217,
0.010048666,
-0.0127965389,
-0.0017317843,
0.0118916454,
-0.0183141567,
-0.0102338614,
0.0852718726,
-0.0514698997,
0.0048979754,
-0.0537736341,
-0.0055205575,
-0.0129631087,
0.0299965125,
-0.025466904,
0.0153752975,
-0.0368234962,
-0.0211672094,
-0.0007392649,
0.0220039263,
-0.022241069,
-0.0647446886,
0.0128344055,
-0.0117134498,
-0.0102370698,
-0.0487179719,
0.0080895266,
-0.0007441263,
0.0346801728,
-0.0386664718,
-0.0607744753,
-0.0558287166,
-0.0017560609,
-0.021327043,
-0.0513944551,
-0.0654900149,
0.007526556,
0.0027065664,
0.0029633276,
-0.083942093,
-0.0045620259,
0.0165599026,
-0.0310623627,
0.0759414136,
-0.0106828641,
-0.0083484622,
0.0622553602,
0.0232795645,
0.0214348007,
0.0546882153,
0.0423470698,
0.0037969607,
0.0620894246,
-0.012259271,
0.0133307213,
0.0133664608,
0.0326057486,
0.0136244129,
-0.018390853,
0.0034769271,
-0.0102347881,
-0.0068722628,
0.0190281719,
0.0261212289,
0.0276313387,
-0.0393134207,
0.0665674582,
0.0825041682,
-0.0409715176,
0.0182549451,
-0.0017495544,
0.0131289642,
-0.0362582356,
-0.0500075556,
-0.0823116004,
-0.0300342645,
-0.0279543493,
-0.0530256741,
0.0192857068,
0.0384843349,
-0.0152130406,
-0.0255494006,
-0.0254992265,
0.0225989185,
0.0537389442,
0.0278958809,
-0.0170744322,
0.0164210424,
0.0368176065,
0.0285930336,
0.0400351547,
-0.0726792142,
0.0182672497,
-0.0512798652,
0.0210977867,
0.0755558237,
0.0230985023,
-0.0211475678,
0.0359036252,
-0.0529442988,
0.0180359036,
0.0353941061,
0.0135074509,
-0.0107223177,
-0.0008954835,
-0.0291090161,
-0.0419972576,
0.0572596192,
0.0100841206,
0.026422916,
0.0705170482,
-0.0011199334,
0.0164141133,
-0.0229506381,
-0.0852528512,
0.0496719815,
-0.0065913107,
-0.0597471707,
0.0295398589,
0.0055462099,
0.0072792158,
0.0418835953,
-0.0220505614,
-0.0252074637,
-0.0254625827,
0.0245646462,
-0.0362373553,
0.0110266469,
-0.0174927078,
0.04115941,
0.0264032725,
-0.0292850267,
-0.0264041107,
0.0382728092,
-0.0219757855,
0.0130035887,
0.0309644658,
0.0058398698,
-0.0370056666,
-0.0229641441,
-0.0030918014,
-0.039085377,
0.0299527124,
-0.0418134369,
0.0598577037,
-0.0178818777,
0.0117607731,
-0.0379711874,
-0.0337923057,
-0.0115289921,
-0.0355608091,
-0.0236020274,
-0.0275430642,
-0.0170789231,
0.038291283,
0.0262767151,
-0.0032103942,
0.0133485347,
0.0331072584,
-0.0714961216,
-0.0148306675,
-0.0015554146,
-0.0175532307,
-0.0256851558,
0.0202442873,
-0.0286259837,
-0.0168911796,
-0.009512567,
-0.0849354863,
0.0090531521,
0.0361840613,
0.001329132,
-0.0284621548,
0.0018073866,
-0.0067135696,
-0.0518720821,
-0.0291264728,
0.0759598985,
0.0675750822,
-0.0085863126,
-0.0235534571,
-0.0618264638,
-0.018360367,
0.0049394006,
0.0117900968,
0.0146127073,
0.0180493202,
0.0602389872,
-0.0017133737,
0.0398535728,
0.0417545438,
0.0643186495,
0.0334494449,
0.0105099035,
-0.0227573924,
-0.0278648268,
0.0060863411,
0.0172706712,
0.0452998988,
-0.0939062238,
-0.0112974523,
0.0428960323,
0.0170658752,
-0.0577394255,
-0.0299630016,
0.0341395661,
-0.0502324514,
-0.05251972,
-0.0529692955,
-0.042258244,
-0.0242339112,
0.0107460618,
-0.0471397229,
-0.0471143685,
0.0678117946,
0.0043373047,
0.0268627144,
-0.0298957732,
-0.0242918022,
0.0003484216,
0.0510544032,
-0.0259373412,
0.0356107056,
0.033239726,
-0.0274498481,
-0.0054119714,
-0.020389948,
0.0460275635,
-0.0556392744,
0.0277252477,
-0.0516517274,
0.0106518688,
-0.0006694721,
-0.0449417047,
-0.0736310855,
-0.0680588111,
-0.0216459669,
0.002455062,
0.0294479169,
-0.0230138656,
-0.0117507316,
-0.0003936812,
0.0115364511,
0.0291659422,
-0.0128934579,
-0.0121117085,
0.0199989546,
-0.0258151032,
-0.0370995104,
-0.0038651582,
0.0273457225,
-0.0010738354,
-0.0123007093,
0.0262989253,
0.0124227582,
0.0228812713,
0.0248531904,
-0.0001010052,
0.0198849775,
-0.0550520718,
0.0114657544,
-0.0153965354,
0.0353086554,
-0.0479211062,
0.0079953214,
0.0742185563,
0.0242671706,
-0.0726289228,
0.0212978385,
0.0029732008,
0.0100375293,
0.0373151414,
-0.0146389157,
-0.1188282296,
-0.003562029,
0.0024264203,
0.0603655465,
-0.0745526478,
-0.0509436205,
0.0146851642,
-0.0559013896,
0.0270154737,
0.0036290796,
-0.0374113657,
-0.0458457209,
-0.0311099235,
0.0233455691,
-0.0269038957,
0.028798189,
-0.0238706265,
0.0241757035,
0.0232842974,
0.0119198449,
-0.0200737976,
-0.054838568,
0.0117305052,
-0.0587894842,
0.0279714949,
0.0442717299,
0.0441174507,
0.0057750032,
-0.0239716042,
0.0180986747,
-0.0334747881,
-0.0187277701,
-0.0174324848,
0.0636549294,
-0.0222185273,
-0.0150597012,
-0.0491485372,
0.0568423755,
0.0070972135,
0.0006975763,
0.005176153,
-0.0134457424,
0.0158585776,
-0.0002288556,
-0.0274029914,
-0.0326635763,
0.0144288791,
0.0868245587,
0.04598267,
-0.0329804905,
0.0130937034,
-0.0963983461,
0.046934709,
-0.0332535394,
-0.0699326321,
0.0327106155,
-0.0048482502,
-0.0641310364,
-0.0143164014,
-0.0336966217,
0.0135228261,
-0.0031218147,
0.0414354317,
-0.043279428,
-0.0193431303,
-0.0059750476,
-0.0928850397,
0.0559794456,
-0.06470678,
0.0706884935,
0.0072017224,
-0.0333647132,
-0.0588133708,
-0.0077899205,
-0.0316251628,
0.0495878905,
-0.0289397035,
-0.0429281741,
0.0588009022,
0.0006486739,
0.0166637041,
0.0403168909,
-0.0301087573,
-0.0951837301,
0.0538789742,
0.084936291,
-0.0132031366,
-0.0019812183,
0.000828517,
-0.0133122168,
-0.0092624603,
0.010823396,
-0.0245157108,
0.0216861162,
0.0194240492,
-0.0190887451,
-0.0455847606,
-0.0236684065,
-0.0056737554,
0.0263658538,
0.0225786883,
-0.0541899949,
-0.0301492438,
-0.0296434723,
-0.035438396,
-0.0012004348,
-0.053131897,
0.0048475685,
-0.0162726603,
0.0172436349,
0.0063267844,
-0.042142082,
0.0144888759,
-0.0258524213,
0.0165945124,
-0.0625061244,
0.0246642921,
0.0167630576,
0.0883128941,
0.0069579226,
0.0054622279,
-0.00410337,
0.0118339686,
-0.0160825253,
0.0376568548,
0.0368007049,
-0.0125087062,
0.0231040753,
0.0109940674,
-0.0181851145,
-0.0066241049,
-0.0337076411,
0.0109910145,
-0.0281382333,
0.0113667538,
0.0103413863,
0.0067667896,
-0.0161247868,
0.0214265417,
-0.0224847086,
-0.0013905072,
-0.0126427952,
0.0217887741,
-0.0201296471,
-0.0081488574,
0.0033245829,
-0.0270006675,
0.0005458095,
0.0334796719,
0.0133608691,
0.0716679692,
-0.0329259224,
-0.0550732538,
-0.0116970707,
-0.0219594445,
0.0213613585,
0.0292132758,
-0.007585749,
-0.0298831556,
-0.0949413329,
-0.0519188978,
-0.0019583842,
0.00471636,
0.0562712029,
0.0257837363,
-0.0091681732,
0.0291915387,
-0.0145686176,
-0.0585710891,
-0.0012246371,
0.0047300449,
-0.0380209982,
-0.0395287238,
-0.0048241173,
-6.1030021e-33,
-0.0255535357,
-0.0443832353,
-0.044029437,
-0.0261984542,
0.0052420371,
-0.0000632153,
0.0108276606,
-0.0117884092,
0.0121666305,
0.0176781714,
0.0035951925,
0.0370194167,
0.0161577612,
0.0174213275,
0.0181850679,
0.0023721952,
0.0659539253,
0.0258826483,
-0.0218761563,
0.0285170749,
-0.0013170755,
0.0147052063,
0.041662138,
-0.0975206047,
0.1025614217,
0.0005459758,
-0.0148194842,
0.0248390604,
-0.0284847822,
0.0237665195,
-0.012985195,
0.0958371535,
0.0156088853,
-0.0127628678,
0.0172972605,
0.0554031767,
-0.062529996,
0.0000275095,
0.0042369827,
0.0336896293,
0.0182192512,
-0.053913191,
0.0609754324,
0.0054266932,
-0.0471055247,
-0.0171626098,
0.0807727054,
-0.0021011815,
0.0343632363,
0.0021538769,
-0.0183014199,
0.0319061391,
-0.032273896,
-0.007050172,
0.0005226203,
-0.0036388708,
0.0275732763,
0.0116285784,
-0.0793984458,
-0.0076616458,
0.006500368,
-0.0377822779,
0.03623344,
0.0364984684,
0.016892815,
0.0385223329,
0.0176782794,
0.0134701421,
-0.0514676832,
-0.0193005353,
0.0357983373,
-0.0117987506,
0.0418393649,
0.0879660398,
0.0216170754,
-0.0399371572,
-0.0011949984,
0.0227286015,
0.0197703075,
-0.0406055748,
0.0383837596,
-0.0281914268,
-0.0765979514,
-0.044674173,
-0.0476692729,
-0.1118511483,
-0.0268737581,
0.0155710196,
0.0160072315,
-0.0207557902,
-0.0639571622,
0.051441431,
-0.0113934809,
-0.0478726998,
-0.063424252,
0.0134707382,
0.0317969657,
-0.0215688888,
0.0230078232,
-0.025278246,
-0.0234942567,
0.0384392068,
0.0352702402,
0.0317284577,
0.0348972492,
0.0034200854,
0.0390826799,
0.0104409,
-0.0571799129,
-0.003271143,
0.005859571,
0.043806009,
0.0116067184,
0.0117407944,
0.0257749613,
0.0414478593,
0.003343286,
0.0033626249,
0.0485191308,
0.0338207893,
-0.0304675233,
-0.024664849,
-0.0553132705,
0.0179294571,
-0.0013929644,
-0.0116706267,
0.0172071755,
0.0052830437,
0.0574147552,
-0.0124713918,
0.0021236588,
-0.0494227186,
2.484e-7,
0.013173704,
0.0188777857,
0.0147766126,
-0.0204564221,
0.0041415673,
0.0494365953,
0.0781022087,
0.023610903,
0.0112646818,
-0.0162935238,
-0.0255424827,
0.0530418865,
0.0296076033,
0.0127995126,
-0.0440038294,
-0.0254422724,
-0.0536475815,
0.0539747477,
-0.04821321,
0.0124847349,
0.0175490286,
0.0506480671,
0.0771755725,
-0.0410144292,
-0.0006937592,
-0.0115350951,
-0.0244283974,
-0.019341195,
0.0287700128,
0.0033537289,
0.0425806753,
-0.0074693644,
0.0537627377,
0.0326059274,
-0.0197466351,
0.0067557269,
-0.0134578478,
0.0064674322,
-0.028466735,
0.0587998554,
-0.047327932,
0.01002899,
0.0094487183,
-0.0558892749,
0.0327297449,
0.033782322,
-0.0261626672,
-0.0798103958,
-0.0273304842,
-0.0293146782,
0.0439418145,
0.01491802,
-0.0263718795,
0.0369536914,
0.0200682413,
-0.0036778315,
-0.0131232077,
-0.0890331641,
-0.0338114053,
-0.0125583038,
-0.0042406842,
0.0004013633,
0.0294918623,
0.0105951978,
-0.01926299,
-0.0165728852,
0.0651854053,
2.178252791e-34,
-0.0208315272,
0.028994007,
-0.0042363927,
-0.0031215344,
0.0360963568,
0.0268373359,
-0.0129684359,
-0.0193418674,
0.020374136,
0.0101729631,
0.0068830051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.04019v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.04019v2 | Evaluation of large language models for discovery of gene set function | 2023-09-07T21:10:48 | 2024-04-01T05:02:23 | Mengzhou Hu, Sahar Alkhairy, Ingoo Lee, Rudolf T. Pillich, Dylan Fong, Kevin Smith, Robin Bachelder, Trey Ideker, Dexter Pratt | q-bio.GN | q-bio.GN, cs.AI, cs.CL, q-bio.MN | Gene set analysis is a mainstay of functional genomics, but it relies on
curated databases of gene functions that are incomplete. Here we evaluate five
Large Language Models (LLMs) for their ability to discover the common
biological functions represented by a gene set, substantiated by supporting
rationale, citations and a confidence assessment. Benchmarking against
canonical gene sets from the Gene Ontology, GPT-4 confidently recovered the
curated name or a more general concept (73% of cases), while benchmarking
against random gene sets correctly yielded zero confidence. Gemini-Pro and
Mixtral-Instruct showed ability in naming but were falsely confident for random
sets, whereas Llama2-70b had poor performance overall. In gene sets derived
from 'omics data, GPT-4 identified novel functions not reported by classical
functional enrichment (32% of cases), which independent review indicated were
largely verifiable and not hallucinations. The ability to rapidly synthesize
common gene functions positions LLMs as valuable 'omics assistants. | [
-0.0079423059,
0.0832489282,
-0.0188850407,
0.0006814184,
-0.0205061324,
0.0183177982,
0.0696959794,
0.0596473217,
0.0111557776,
0.0054314616,
0.0057778717,
-0.0223624241,
-0.0026661388,
0.0711003765,
0.0086758109,
0.0655272305,
0.0309670996,
0.0047080978,
-0.0220504031,
-0.0278766472,
-0.0473500192,
0.0143272998,
0.0379748531,
0.0394382253,
0.0471543185,
-0.0397288725,
0.0818123296,
-0.0717445388,
0.0135710957,
0.0071870242,
-0.0496511497,
0.0154417893,
-0.0345761329,
0.0869464129,
0.0000019486,
-0.0424420275,
-0.0431416519,
0.0391526073,
-0.0270915665,
-0.0064364909,
0.0169761963,
-0.0099017918,
0.0254477803,
-0.0069907135,
0.0200718865,
-0.0454556048,
0.1018864289,
-0.0099042617,
-0.038476821,
0.0453267433,
0.0112160556,
-0.0383349285,
0.0816039294,
-0.012570736,
0.1023396701,
-0.0010361569,
0.0702844188,
-0.0048896782,
0.0588845499,
-0.0078549497,
0.0596722253,
0.0484601781,
-0.0490000807,
-0.0097318357,
0.0152863245,
0.0155405877,
-0.0445559286,
-0.0307645909,
0.0695410296,
-0.0058556423,
0.0135724181,
-0.0643361807,
0.0134593509,
0.0072385985,
-0.0080400137,
0.0468489267,
-0.0394964777,
0.0281463657,
-0.0372268446,
0.0104407771,
0.0402210243,
-0.0243296623,
0.0493987277,
-0.0108884703,
0.0126651209,
0.0905527622,
-0.004687625,
0.0139685208,
-0.0263745133,
-0.0052863769,
-0.0648511797,
-0.005455221,
-0.0133832674,
-0.0249345526,
0.0073803058,
0.0016329043,
0.0383198746,
0.0010891291,
0.0569353737,
-0.0211305432,
0.0086460467,
0.025257796,
-0.0194477495,
-0.0075406968,
-0.0219386965,
0.007645431,
-0.0339946225,
0.0314990878,
-0.0119901951,
0.0040957122,
-0.1086174697,
-0.0163760688,
0.0126776192,
0.0526832379,
0.0046060137,
0.0174951442,
-0.0621444173,
-0.0171225909,
-0.0118842591,
0.0201580822,
0.0214377232,
-0.0218511261,
0.0196810178,
0.0711292699,
-0.0195719972,
0.0008734956,
0.0325749889,
0.0194163993,
-0.043134205,
-0.0943539515,
-0.0041792206,
0.005039772,
0.0210939348,
0.0034183536,
-0.0011662308,
0.0898176804,
0.0183079336,
-0.059813574,
0.0199105218,
-0.0087086568,
-0.0300227441,
-0.035736762,
-0.0044655651,
-0.0398602672,
-0.0038771208,
0.0715467334,
-0.0077190944,
-0.0157754589,
0.0068296716,
-0.0177006926,
-0.0528776087,
0.0331978612,
-0.0722144991,
0.0022309266,
-0.0044822902,
-0.0173178315,
0.007324574,
0.0018938107,
-0.0232612453,
-0.0333186686,
0.0366399474,
-0.0101209087,
-0.0212126728,
-0.0085801911,
-0.0095300181,
-0.0452589244,
0.0035009061,
0.0165688191,
0.0863473639,
0.0341934375,
-0.01667553,
-0.0286510978,
-0.0128374156,
-0.0188821368,
0.0323081389,
0.0436676703,
0.0202968959,
0.0594223775,
0.0283971876,
-0.0329271816,
0.0354573764,
-0.0570103452,
0.0037312496,
-0.0107310042,
-0.0724266544,
0.0286991205,
-0.0190133005,
0.0083227614,
0.0304609835,
0.010298118,
-0.0339617878,
0.0026371791,
-0.0514342673,
-0.0370568112,
0.0522276796,
-0.038635958,
0.0088016298,
0.0007168914,
0.0276984852,
-0.0210043453,
-0.0001921799,
-0.0398253128,
0.0018506696,
0.0358161107,
0.0419043712,
-0.0788730234,
0.0041550961,
-0.002643192,
-0.0116755627,
0.0087100817,
-0.0368563235,
0.0005016924,
-0.0407310501,
0.0100579299,
0.0241196938,
-0.0204305332,
0.0334237106,
0.0337977484,
-0.0510821119,
0.0040638135,
-0.0111542754,
-0.0236220509,
-0.0500254855,
-0.0073178667,
-0.0520444587,
0.0038055466,
0.0202625673,
-0.0683864132,
0.0246774722,
0.0233960561,
-0.0513352491,
0.0725805387,
0.0188886914,
-0.054756809,
-0.0087936549,
-0.0265869815,
0.0452918112,
0.00382481,
0.0251966286,
0.0093276212,
-0.0150940502,
0.0194246136,
0.011979701,
-0.0248300601,
0.0081278663,
-0.0412923135,
0.049187474,
-0.0319938995,
-0.0018440424,
-0.0436523221,
-0.0012387227,
0.006682876,
0.0442505218,
0.008440854,
0.0428260304,
-0.0230003484,
-0.0140108727,
0.0582871698,
-0.0226528607,
-0.006014348,
0.015757855,
0.0092992121,
-0.004245562,
0.015382315,
-0.0140381251,
0.0304014198,
0.0182046276,
-0.0357963443,
-0.0019166043,
0.0461287908,
0.04528521,
-0.0371501334,
-0.030008873,
0.0147730699,
0.0344017521,
-0.0232530348,
0.0358038507,
0.0156562552,
0.0137475105,
0.003129642,
-0.0030055277,
-0.072567068,
-0.0362758264,
-0.0317975692,
-0.05308396,
0.0569549613,
0.0313053317,
-0.0021671061,
0.0054163719,
0.0700175911,
-0.0478351563,
0.009945197,
-0.0170784816,
-0.0329530127,
0.0263857972,
0.0158009883,
-0.044736404,
-0.0141258072,
-0.0449422561,
-0.0513409637,
0.0695339814,
0.0218403302,
0.0332760252,
-0.028588878,
-0.0516960025,
-0.0461368747,
0.0148925604,
-0.0182569791,
-0.0235969387,
-0.0007486245,
0.0220876373,
-0.0568404309,
-0.0356217623,
0.0225255992,
0.0061013284,
0.0180084389,
-0.0433931015,
-0.0326416083,
-0.0273342915,
0.0530328378,
0.0202261563,
-0.0761782825,
0.0229344163,
-0.0283332504,
0.0199143682,
-0.0166027211,
0.0290954746,
-0.0078622522,
0.0204379186,
0.0220666807,
0.0315149538,
0.0545401797,
0.0061429632,
0.0666329041,
0.0189827681,
0.0154578341,
-0.0614785664,
0.0125018414,
-0.0326038301,
0.0538950562,
0.0343645439,
-0.0060072434,
-0.0028448077,
0.0545689687,
-0.0119655179,
0.0550619178,
0.0667160451,
-0.0457538962,
-0.0655081868,
0.0530766733,
0.0442592353,
0.0045424546,
-0.0273729321,
0.0429116338,
-0.0213077106,
-0.0585890487,
-0.0150072807,
-0.0535103977,
0.0338896662,
0.0094764652,
0.0143696712,
-0.0116982888,
-0.049953863,
-0.0022984957,
0.039111115,
0.0436075293,
-0.0076700565,
-0.0086427024,
-0.0389718004,
-0.0110430624,
0.0204034727,
-0.0161170904,
-0.0368047878,
0.0782468095,
0.0501930118,
-0.0773877054,
0.0115224253,
-0.0199933797,
-0.0702355877,
0.0131667601,
0.0248787943,
-0.086791873,
-0.0014508032,
-0.0140219079,
-0.0223592576,
-0.0604837872,
-0.0849648565,
0.0364115871,
-0.0501998961,
0.0467448533,
0.0427884348,
-0.075368315,
0.0013873708,
-0.0723598674,
-0.004554932,
-0.0548763052,
-0.0349089094,
-0.0128271161,
0.0079150703,
0.0002244958,
0.0037387733,
-0.011518321,
-0.0722557902,
0.0263817739,
-0.0044440017,
0.0338872336,
0.0274077468,
0.0213190503,
-0.0143855894,
-0.0254105497,
0.008852995,
-0.0137469592,
0.011099224,
-0.0290306304,
0.056810461,
0.054012116,
-0.0211512353,
-0.0496472716,
0.0169229843,
-0.025010597,
-0.0180340782,
-0.0709804296,
0.071706675,
-0.0325556993,
-0.0110472683,
-0.0171285868,
-0.006262599,
-0.0221001543,
0.0595113672,
-0.0010737146,
0.0321473591,
0.0157438181,
-0.0157372896,
0.0191339906,
0.0071800658,
-0.0401937291,
0.0422569625,
-0.0189899076,
-0.0612357892,
0.0240401234,
-0.0030986955,
0.0348556489,
-0.0453745127,
0.0005348246,
0.0556133427,
-0.0006955783,
-0.0476431325,
-0.0287122894,
0.0180472396,
0.0338222794,
0.0241572578,
-0.0429430455,
-0.0441813096,
0.0667506233,
0.010867863,
-0.0123001896,
0.0732951835,
-0.0189684089,
-0.0716625452,
-0.0467926562,
0.0150503786,
0.0302043036,
-0.0882404894,
0.0076384954,
-0.0545196943,
0.0211656429,
0.0549202412,
-0.0133481184,
-0.0216893535,
-0.0625916049,
-0.0147524169,
0.0068771294,
0.0182304736,
0.0070273546,
0.0195111651,
-0.0155472327,
0.0245127287,
0.0251036901,
0.0260325409,
0.0558073632,
0.0586726964,
0.0481061302,
0.0074726222,
-0.0081473086,
-0.0207603239,
0.0095276898,
-0.0549120493,
-0.0072489795,
0.0039536241,
0.0051873876,
0.0414978452,
0.0270815287,
-0.0131756254,
-0.0150465081,
-0.0222278312,
0.0137475124,
-0.0529136099,
0.0409146138,
-0.0286830328,
-0.0159870256,
0.0157092661,
-0.0268495735,
0.0082633551,
0.0022609769,
-0.0480234884,
-0.0045202072,
0.0225113463,
-0.0202370938,
0.0023659985,
0.0218529738,
-0.0208751801,
-0.0205284767,
-0.0090635223,
-0.0370626152,
-0.0222229529,
0.0254168008,
0.0528025776,
-0.0191627853,
0.0523365848,
-0.0194342863,
-0.0239363853,
-0.0644144788,
-0.0008931522,
-0.013394787,
0.0263304673,
-0.0125935655,
0.0055129738,
-0.0670825765,
-0.1130113974,
0.0652463436,
0.0632987618,
0.0576215498,
-0.0368092544,
-0.0596243516,
-0.0012867294,
0.0001343118,
0.0373907126,
-0.0011392077,
-0.0414552279,
-0.0255038776,
-0.049519252,
-0.035168495,
0.0005325893,
0.012436741,
-0.0090742446,
0.0279149916,
-0.0273222532,
-0.0008959256,
0.0396081842,
-0.0652095601,
-0.028960906,
-0.0054379269,
-0.0642267615,
-0.0165621452,
0.0230585914,
-6.14154105e-33,
0.0024580325,
-0.0427167602,
-0.00605019,
0.0452557318,
0.0298293065,
0.0239276569,
-0.0371378958,
0.0035893684,
0.0393064991,
0.0437433347,
0.0325821415,
-0.0131944334,
-0.0223445054,
-0.0346754417,
0.0470171869,
0.0372916944,
-0.010644896,
-0.0143343536,
0.0056708297,
0.0125175333,
0.0759932995,
0.0083538704,
0.0364742316,
-0.041142974,
-0.0048043248,
0.0430894345,
0.0011300819,
-0.0087631764,
-0.0499853604,
0.0453382097,
0.014140253,
0.0235069692,
-0.0105018737,
0.0251715481,
0.0015474163,
-0.0430655852,
0.000188952,
0.0151513619,
0.0517414436,
-0.0563586242,
0.0211014654,
-0.0339213312,
0.0203238744,
-0.0080707734,
-0.037613105,
0.0218657758,
0.0016534863,
-0.0664516464,
-0.0489320643,
-0.0157524087,
-0.0112150917,
0.0280953664,
0.0182644688,
0.0541132949,
0.0340416916,
-0.0229158625,
-0.0237670373,
-0.0160921104,
0.0243021399,
0.0229317266,
0.060953781,
0.0307874475,
0.0354945771,
-0.0183936469,
0.0439382643,
0.0446740612,
0.0080094114,
-0.0103579331,
0.0433189012,
0.0489342138,
-0.0023961512,
0.070464775,
0.0333695225,
0.0000734178,
0.0003583427,
-0.027199205,
-0.0913593844,
0.031849876,
-0.0380460918,
-0.004288448,
0.0602690615,
0.0348053426,
0.0059677968,
0.0135345319,
-0.0207994208,
-0.0024671576,
-0.0297517516,
-0.0369664542,
-0.0036880663,
-0.0761925578,
-0.0044515696,
0.0564276502,
0.0404941589,
-0.0399282388,
-0.043429222,
0.0066554272,
0.0194350388,
0.0116702812,
-0.0214622449,
-0.0020210885,
-0.0740484595,
-0.0532610938,
0.0118245529,
-0.0196084138,
0.0369023532,
-0.017058596,
-0.0014912646,
-0.0006993117,
-0.0460281223,
0.0256357435,
-0.0432041027,
0.0026715281,
0.0227373596,
0.0223075729,
-0.0068908213,
-0.0285737328,
0.0322480761,
0.0082406169,
0.0453632735,
0.0118858321,
-0.0100216242,
0.0265786164,
0.0020302453,
-0.0174717512,
-0.02517418,
0.0088336114,
-0.0312633179,
0.0294759162,
0.0390546918,
-0.0003291172,
-0.0002476175,
0.0331894718,
2.933e-7,
0.0631144941,
0.0402107388,
-0.0170799326,
0.0439552777,
0.0354203992,
-0.0334513076,
-0.0242649075,
0.0159285385,
-0.0361391269,
-0.0081044752,
0.0340285525,
-0.0294582006,
0.0651914179,
0.0054225656,
0.0054712431,
-0.0116168186,
-0.0189132784,
-0.0247661658,
-0.0384035073,
-0.0102363415,
-0.0033891357,
0.0783234239,
-0.0193429124,
0.0285684913,
0.0510611087,
-0.049697537,
0.0440619811,
-0.0210813563,
-0.0114463186,
0.0290754102,
-0.0220486969,
0.0195021052,
0.0066670538,
0.0337188616,
-0.002005958,
0.0099798879,
0.0037223191,
0.0300960205,
-0.0107032312,
0.0334269553,
0.0479733758,
-0.0159221794,
0.0163898394,
-0.0755168945,
0.0001586442,
-0.0058305571,
-0.0910692886,
0.0195275936,
0.02976547,
-0.0175846275,
0.0257361755,
-0.0022871336,
0.0155475084,
0.0443820655,
-0.0159425046,
0.0130838342,
-0.0280872658,
-0.0004988598,
0.0028877961,
0.0618045703,
-0.067777589,
-0.0402514674,
-0.0239455793,
-0.0200161636,
0.000824682,
-0.0549910627,
-0.0102966474,
2.778654439e-34,
0.0165887345,
-0.0042505842,
-0.0336935744,
-0.0023383049,
0.0829728693,
-0.0269802772,
-0.0014881577,
0.0331835486,
-0.0651756078,
-0.0953611657,
0.0216429234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03992v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03992v2 | ConDA: Contrastive Domain Adaptation for AI-generated Text Detection | 2023-09-07T19:51:30 | 2023-09-20T22:17:30 | Amrita Bhattacharjee, Tharindu Kumarage, Raha Moraffah, Huan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being used for generating text
in a variety of use cases, including journalistic news articles. Given the
potential malicious nature in which these LLMs can be used to generate
disinformation at scale, it is important to build effective detectors for such
AI-generated text. Given the surge in development of new LLMs, acquiring
labeled training data for supervised detectors is a bottleneck. However, there
might be plenty of unlabeled text data available, without information on which
generator it came from. In this work we tackle this data problem, in detecting
AI-generated news text, and frame the problem as an unsupervised domain
adaptation task. Here the domains are the different text generators, i.e. LLMs,
and we assume we have access to only the labeled source data and unlabeled
target data. We develop a Contrastive Domain Adaptation framework, called
ConDA, that blends standard domain adaptation techniques with the
representation power of contrastive learning to learn domain invariant
representations that are effective for the final unsupervised detection task.
Our experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our framework, resulting in
average performance gains of 31.7% from the best performing baselines, and
within 0.8% margin of a fully supervised detector. All our code and data is
available at https://github.com/AmritaBh/ConDA-gen-text-detection. | [
0.0586324409,
0.0473362878,
-0.0095968619,
0.0438520759,
-0.0361009538,
0.021945497,
0.0155939041,
0.0043321722,
0.0086414916,
-0.0491656624,
-0.0353530087,
-0.0072933077,
-0.0225277189,
0.0723491907,
-0.0033597792,
-0.0232337974,
0.0259359982,
0.0086202426,
0.0233027749,
0.0260366462,
0.0079450496,
0.0207752641,
-0.0132939927,
-0.0127529092,
-0.005437491,
-0.0249904078,
0.0324096009,
0.0229424872,
0.0526639074,
-0.0290160906,
0.0268083531,
0.0505905449,
0.0298100933,
0.0741548166,
0.0000017565,
-0.0264851842,
-0.054451447,
-0.0164733119,
0.0072256643,
-0.0126643488,
0.0868364871,
-0.0787414014,
-0.0451822281,
0.0393414386,
-0.0324139036,
-0.0139022507,
0.0442907326,
0.0420536771,
0.0607988872,
0.1312250644,
-0.0334440023,
-0.0099078408,
0.0315374099,
-0.0246553067,
-0.0399276204,
-0.0499083735,
0.0674196184,
-0.0162884612,
-0.0339004695,
0.0455606543,
0.0033012489,
0.0036235671,
0.0175586715,
-0.0338043496,
-0.0309426747,
0.0046579107,
-0.004813686,
0.0191107597,
-0.0140576027,
0.0448070318,
-0.0031789555,
-0.0585610271,
0.0069606146,
-0.0093808109,
0.0073124403,
-0.0102933934,
-0.0168680511,
-0.0015657231,
-0.0357385315,
0.0370280817,
0.0183364991,
-0.0141552677,
-0.0023408008,
0.029281443,
0.0059528942,
0.0114554688,
0.0141235124,
-0.0217751414,
-0.011835793,
0.0113553954,
-0.0072198818,
-0.0362215377,
0.048740875,
0.0058913827,
0.0088774143,
-0.0164966304,
-0.1114405319,
-0.1036228985,
-0.0040991073,
-0.0365095623,
-0.0038361759,
-0.0148965418,
-0.0383374132,
0.0383445695,
-0.0370845273,
0.0286489315,
-0.0296620596,
0.0305587556,
-0.0351684727,
-0.0174485184,
-0.0250896998,
0.0084102387,
-0.0284720231,
0.0149813704,
-0.0253998116,
0.0003257138,
-0.029915886,
0.0198098831,
0.015818622,
-0.0134251928,
-0.0348330475,
-0.0185158402,
-0.0552424453,
-0.0315917097,
0.0176999774,
0.0295556691,
-0.0041616429,
0.0579287335,
0.014379547,
-0.0536288433,
-0.0462398343,
0.0635017529,
0.01452679,
-0.0048857261,
0.0042421217,
0.066157721,
-0.0134762181,
-0.0494627766,
-0.0726637021,
0.0101563325,
-0.0321532264,
-0.0187756382,
0.02706041,
-0.0488548987,
-0.0403332859,
-0.0216682777,
-0.0053040436,
-0.1013413891,
-0.0154365133,
0.0149557339,
-0.0203027204,
0.0492932759,
-0.0200995561,
-0.0474733263,
0.0425768048,
-0.0009689065,
-0.0294529069,
0.0682026669,
0.0316995606,
0.0815096796,
0.0359493382,
0.0186520107,
0.0244985987,
0.0157815237,
0.0529216193,
0.0636175722,
0.0171936546,
0.0096440492,
-0.0185134932,
-0.0332472026,
0.0570004918,
0.0266640522,
0.0264611188,
-0.035119839,
0.075364925,
-0.0241709556,
-0.0058949045,
0.0142155401,
0.0481235236,
0.0178765822,
-0.0340370536,
0.0312759951,
-0.0248976592,
0.0134638213,
-0.0509197414,
-0.0414305255,
0.0119758202,
0.048440244,
-0.0206929576,
-0.0246582944,
0.0183325298,
-0.0110992109,
-0.0150464401,
-0.0406979322,
0.0537515394,
0.0654416829,
-0.0284633525,
-0.034374781,
0.0409267284,
-0.0112112192,
0.0111209052,
-0.0695217922,
0.0451429747,
0.0262032319,
0.0448578075,
-0.0289597549,
0.0182833374,
-0.0312273968,
0.0407841392,
0.0650607497,
0.0119078616,
-0.0044203219,
-0.0263620894,
-0.0216797125,
-0.0290128943,
-0.0434654094,
0.0133527629,
0.0510177426,
0.0166626088,
0.0430725254,
0.0327015705,
-0.0282989684,
-0.0373173617,
0.038394779,
-0.0261802841,
-0.0657132119,
0.0353938527,
0.0035867381,
0.0295335986,
-0.0028835023,
-0.0331546068,
-0.0218712408,
0.0136310253,
-0.0445604734,
-0.0236994475,
-0.0437722132,
0.0054557039,
-0.0353938006,
-0.0134032881,
-0.0571324602,
-0.0050396435,
0.0656618923,
-0.0384919494,
-0.0009864026,
0.0652661398,
-0.0250736587,
-0.0180475768,
-0.0359521322,
0.0015249194,
-0.0027347722,
0.0651413649,
0.0041304487,
0.0737107173,
-0.0069677401,
-0.0574144758,
0.0141586447,
0.0234687869,
0.0154443374,
0.0052580959,
0.0405042619,
-0.0109938532,
-0.0356881917,
0.0132736256,
0.0285936929,
0.0217271447,
0.0009121335,
-0.0086773876,
-0.0115597416,
0.0088868309,
-0.0381990336,
0.0198373962,
0.0582108423,
0.0188350026,
-0.0171393864,
0.0009694864,
-0.0275513399,
0.0080639059,
-0.0025889995,
0.0219326094,
0.0168821067,
-0.0108160833,
0.0254701525,
-0.0346394069,
0.0389676392,
0.0014063054,
0.0373189449,
0.0118118506,
-0.0532543138,
-0.0524589345,
0.0524016134,
0.0052617663,
0.0265640095,
-0.0185837932,
-0.0355130397,
0.0005310226,
0.006378368,
0.0172552858,
0.0624549873,
0.0221413299,
0.0183815435,
0.030092448,
0.0441500396,
-0.0178045798,
0.001549427,
-0.0176619347,
0.0176035054,
-0.0261817016,
-0.0437918715,
0.0559059121,
0.0620370619,
0.0108559728,
0.0037710196,
-0.0122746136,
0.0332905799,
0.000302416,
-0.0278034713,
0.0346223526,
-0.0221900251,
-0.0044870246,
0.0448101684,
-0.0277198125,
-0.0782607719,
0.056074746,
-0.0091163963,
0.0395356268,
-0.071073927,
-0.0393498279,
-0.0419330038,
0.0096881138,
0.0069043729,
0.0277563576,
0.0065110666,
-0.0002870263,
-0.0334681608,
0.0061165076,
0.0406949446,
0.0100189056,
0.0162975825,
-0.0327286385,
0.0360377207,
0.006289064,
-0.0243955329,
-0.0644438639,
-0.0443485714,
-0.0040145349,
-0.0067858938,
0.0254554227,
-0.0244354419,
-0.0686426163,
-0.0076829931,
0.0379401632,
0.0597302914,
-0.0024839547,
0.0008372918,
-0.008232479,
0.0697802454,
0.0526914746,
-0.0393585078,
0.0460690521,
-0.0223083887,
-0.0055860179,
0.0604624189,
-0.0104614776,
0.0216982029,
-0.0236959513,
-0.0153592527,
0.0057466491,
0.0080757709,
0.0014073749,
-0.0197484959,
0.0123515222,
0.0085561788,
-0.0330798365,
0.069308646,
0.0234942585,
-0.0553273037,
-0.010495129,
0.0088095134,
0.0047187707,
0.0122932093,
0.0087209372,
-0.0601887964,
-0.0333474278,
0.0057706316,
0.0151614184,
-0.0282457005,
-0.0074120844,
-0.0303225406,
-0.0913750529,
0.0157094356,
0.0107621029,
-0.0263378341,
-0.0481411554,
-0.0559481159,
0.0408428907,
0.000749426,
-0.0256462228,
-0.0263005216,
0.0183884129,
-0.0150349969,
-0.0041935281,
0.0230728276,
-0.0753215179,
-0.0652047917,
-0.0009222639,
0.0112791117,
0.0903131291,
0.0134903733,
-0.012337517,
-0.0104398681,
0.0212948564,
-0.0136499079,
-0.0402592234,
-0.0332283005,
0.0959766656,
-0.0224886835,
0.0079323016,
0.0083342912,
0.0631274208,
-0.030740276,
-0.01004388,
0.0417181142,
0.0145169916,
0.0112994453,
-0.048675891,
-0.0629805326,
-0.0007530359,
0.0569684878,
0.056436874,
0.0261340961,
-0.0393209532,
0.0087750023,
-0.022926148,
-0.0138187986,
-0.0572290197,
-0.0006354447,
0.002673063,
-0.0213458482,
-0.0394666418,
-0.0990338847,
0.001557766,
-0.0273030326,
-0.0022817852,
0.0074103144,
-0.0419217423,
-0.0289593153,
-0.0343814567,
-0.0313980803,
-0.0330473147,
-0.0355164222,
0.0295189433,
-0.0442684665,
-0.0185327046,
0.0323011763,
-0.0476954989,
-0.0308202282,
0.0478807949,
-0.0799556822,
-0.036233075,
-0.0068293475,
0.0147408806,
0.0150729259,
0.0323568359,
-0.0339961126,
-0.0147171104,
0.0814877301,
0.0501373522,
-0.0218125228,
0.0123921074,
0.0051615974,
-0.0430473797,
0.0070869974,
0.0244799498,
-0.0519078523,
0.0774866045,
0.0444792174,
-0.0563175157,
-0.0090648821,
-0.0206980929,
0.0229410902,
-0.0058512497,
0.0376940854,
0.0088207787,
-0.0063079079,
-0.0431654453,
0.010522685,
-0.0114419125,
-0.0252540093,
-0.0309098512,
0.0251745805,
0.0399847962,
-0.002231875,
-0.0112396022,
0.0651673973,
-0.0276711844,
0.0269477051,
-0.0279178675,
0.0020373748,
0.0195092261,
0.0859829113,
0.0056388532,
-0.0023827958,
0.0037595048,
0.0185736995,
0.0019434429,
0.0541769266,
-0.0044694315,
0.0028051648,
0.0229680017,
-0.0270925425,
0.0298103094,
0.001407153,
-0.0542299151,
0.0256720316,
-0.0657900721,
0.0142617952,
0.0338122249,
-0.0128057878,
0.0560676157,
-0.0217744,
-0.0075911577,
-0.0142921191,
-0.000469971,
0.0279135704,
-0.0101555903,
-0.0105751809,
-0.0152964285,
-0.0102929482,
0.0317517333,
0.0759340003,
0.0213595312,
0.0497153141,
0.0128822401,
-0.0315747336,
-0.0555366501,
-0.0127189159,
0.0041213534,
0.0162623413,
0.0066776788,
0.0240587499,
-0.0187462438,
-0.0504965372,
0.0270464607,
-0.0399996117,
0.0095997425,
0.0133300684,
-0.0173257049,
0.0524961278,
-0.0114754634,
0.011375526,
-0.0409875736,
-0.0035024129,
-0.0221196152,
-0.060493812,
0.0098636998,
-5.707727798e-33,
-0.0126452157,
-0.0416620299,
-0.0130852712,
-0.0002804816,
0.0289482176,
0.0097821858,
-0.0145821823,
-0.0601143613,
-0.0274861567,
0.0039909729,
0.021838598,
0.0352248326,
-0.0066196192,
0.0355135761,
-0.0773680508,
-0.0119388038,
0.039658349,
-0.0056272633,
-0.0446067043,
0.043001119,
0.0364151821,
0.0163413677,
0.0386956595,
-0.1183101684,
-0.0114218816,
-0.0018816927,
-0.0568215512,
-0.0068910685,
0.021077279,
0.0651483759,
0.0085561536,
0.0267274082,
0.0391887985,
-0.035389144,
-0.0072040134,
0.0471089967,
-0.0236349348,
-0.0157368928,
-0.0198817179,
0.0046791607,
-0.0308472719,
-0.0785132274,
0.0275706761,
0.0183077157,
0.0102795027,
-0.0004942698,
0.0483798012,
-0.0636384189,
0.0177033376,
-0.0026720671,
-0.072891213,
0.0295757931,
0.0068021426,
-0.0106219547,
-0.0182913821,
0.0613506511,
0.0489479564,
0.0512171984,
-0.073032245,
0.0185529813,
0.0166775733,
0.0330095254,
0.0416315868,
-0.0034964762,
-0.0415013097,
0.0516094714,
0.0055117835,
0.011774919,
0.0170809366,
-0.0346429832,
-0.0173926484,
0.0029173205,
0.0216418151,
0.0976034254,
0.0107953986,
-0.049283389,
-0.1212807819,
0.0614207387,
-0.0208420474,
-0.0150195323,
0.0046845628,
-0.0097736996,
-0.0309682395,
0.0349291079,
0.005308527,
-0.0419926681,
-0.0383017175,
-0.0213683303,
0.019196175,
0.0264049284,
-0.0611674413,
0.0080066463,
0.0036237927,
-0.056251809,
0.0078372089,
0.0367243849,
-0.048410438,
-0.0066892649,
0.0155319041,
0.0376618654,
-0.0354426503,
-0.0212573651,
0.0721616521,
0.0122123007,
0.0039170133,
-0.025504956,
0.0912351832,
0.0181170497,
-0.080260016,
0.0143467449,
-0.0227200761,
0.056202963,
0.0247046277,
0.037973471,
-0.0200047027,
-0.0140258288,
0.0014373311,
0.0181280039,
0.0324180797,
-0.0195722356,
-0.0012759753,
-0.0134443985,
-0.0326318033,
0.0267633349,
-0.0539152771,
-0.0278714113,
-0.0036423821,
0.0378569327,
0.0159243904,
-0.0824933574,
-0.000163821,
-0.026442945,
2.585e-7,
0.02110897,
0.0405175202,
0.0034862503,
0.0019128195,
0.0320505239,
0.0478646941,
0.0147023322,
0.0761857405,
-0.0154157318,
-0.0337183326,
-0.0140580283,
0.022228824,
0.0336607993,
0.0177762751,
-0.0600929707,
0.0455669276,
-0.0158599727,
0.0376697257,
-0.0315046534,
-0.0069589815,
0.0617577136,
0.0974562168,
0.0033798027,
-0.0498099141,
0.0210894905,
-0.0823853612,
0.060401801,
0.025366405,
0.0079199234,
0.0105346339,
0.0163887851,
0.0392273255,
-0.0199896954,
0.0011136953,
-0.0296894219,
0.0265699849,
-0.0160104055,
0.0541632138,
0.0333766192,
0.0073964177,
0.0021638623,
0.0010907062,
0.0338382795,
-0.0002407861,
0.0915302262,
-0.0448768437,
-0.0122947097,
-0.0347061604,
-0.0408306681,
-0.0246195626,
-0.0028903587,
-0.0362806097,
-0.0056507494,
0.0115333358,
0.0072430731,
0.0424354896,
-0.0276742298,
-0.0319416374,
0.0175555553,
-0.013525744,
-0.0236006733,
-0.0059935944,
-0.0555382445,
0.0036725821,
0.0543535538,
-0.0497354493,
0.0718242452,
2.139920196e-34,
0.0284912102,
-0.0400978997,
-0.048495423,
-0.0206302609,
-0.0040494693,
-0.016532464,
-0.0242175553,
-0.0279198568,
0.0052085212,
-0.0401448384,
0.025047766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03978v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03978v1 | LanSER: Language-Model Supported Speech Emotion Recognition | 2023-09-07T19:21:08 | 2023-09-07T19:21:08 | Taesik Gong, Josh Belanich, Krishna Somandepalli, Arsha Nagrani, Brian Eoff, Brendan Jou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Speech emotion recognition (SER) models typically rely on costly
human-labeled data for training, making scaling methods to large speech
datasets and nuanced emotion taxonomies difficult. We present LanSER, a method
that enables the use of unlabeled data by inferring weak emotion labels via
pre-trained large language models through weakly-supervised learning. For
inferring weak labels constrained to a taxonomy, we use a textual entailment
approach that selects an emotion label with the highest entailment score for a
speech transcript extracted via automatic speech recognition. Our experimental
results show that models pre-trained on large datasets with this weak
supervision outperform other baseline models on standard SER datasets when
fine-tuned, and show improved label efficiency. Despite being pre-trained on
labels derived only from text, we show that the resulting representations
appear to model the prosodic content of speech. | [
-0.0012798556,
0.0919730514,
0.00767955,
0.0510266647,
-0.0042783548,
0.0411026254,
0.0159289055,
-0.0368426889,
0.0810766891,
-0.0529690348,
-0.0775590613,
0.0202493127,
-0.0389947481,
0.0016229164,
0.0208160058,
-0.0593296885,
0.0186687876,
-0.0048469123,
0.0880617723,
-0.0194928162,
0.0367566794,
0.0351266786,
-0.0057146712,
0.0130768027,
-0.060138315,
0.005014562,
-0.0159209408,
0.0120596737,
0.0363299288,
-0.0296914186,
0.0416001864,
0.0410777442,
0.0549533442,
-0.0131719178,
0.0000018854,
-0.0394708961,
-0.0116158575,
-0.028115375,
-0.0093819378,
-0.014061329,
0.042895779,
-0.019421488,
-0.0109752622,
0.006333733,
0.0002689835,
-0.0469642133,
0.0453810729,
0.0493983813,
0.0827797055,
0.0636111572,
-0.0537988544,
-0.0116634369,
-0.037605349,
-0.0206444394,
-0.0175053589,
-0.0429849587,
0.0202784725,
0.0084438687,
-0.0166557748,
-0.0458315834,
-0.0237292089,
0.0190068725,
0.000180164,
-0.0082560489,
-0.0045687715,
-0.0049212789,
-0.0635446012,
-0.0361657105,
-0.0061224704,
0.0745305046,
0.0031225129,
-0.0310896654,
0.0122642163,
-0.0238697138,
0.0060158106,
-0.0152162341,
0.0031966474,
0.0108961249,
0.0180133469,
0.0136374244,
0.0311579034,
0.0307073239,
0.0289149769,
0.0356326513,
0.0032136701,
0.0491233133,
-0.0089645749,
-0.004650848,
0.058636371,
0.0063328766,
-0.0963682681,
0.0059447512,
-0.0029779675,
-0.0342065804,
0.00565664,
0.0220552385,
-0.059068732,
-0.0036197952,
-0.0513453335,
-0.0516332649,
-0.0468466133,
0.0003714011,
-0.0683556423,
0.0592024401,
0.0103414217,
-0.0052662063,
0.023758905,
-0.032033775,
-0.0251605473,
-0.0398538262,
-0.0166910794,
0.0010221038,
-0.0300475489,
0.0221312176,
0.0105101131,
-0.0230141208,
-0.0572395436,
-0.0156140514,
-0.0474642552,
0.0183530729,
0.000127011,
0.0026359782,
-0.0133693982,
-0.0012054818,
-0.0005945767,
0.0113262944,
-0.0263975114,
0.0675880015,
-0.0008560512,
-0.0450285822,
0.0408105478,
0.0373387747,
0.0356086902,
-0.0112877563,
0.068609044,
0.0245494153,
0.0181752183,
-0.0321081989,
-0.0530945137,
-0.0157644022,
-0.0500954688,
-0.0462796837,
-0.0247807819,
-0.0449107476,
0.0399983972,
0.0109870723,
0.0173613913,
-0.0457432158,
0.0158177968,
-0.0474248417,
-0.0272676796,
0.0859365687,
-0.0049446695,
0.0000439468,
0.0043187193,
0.0093338368,
-0.0124020176,
0.0334387645,
0.0146460589,
0.0514472201,
0.053439796,
-0.0188038368,
0.0207800865,
0.044546701,
-0.006265875,
0.0155158043,
-0.0395286903,
-0.0156045221,
0.0206241962,
-0.004007047,
0.0257344972,
0.0548295863,
-0.0213748123,
-0.0002989682,
0.0351274908,
0.062733151,
-0.0275068041,
0.0311658215,
-0.0262655895,
0.0183228869,
0.0372368023,
-0.0573248267,
-0.0323930532,
-0.0001283331,
-0.0242716018,
-0.0077963504,
0.0235500112,
-0.0370846801,
-0.0488610938,
-0.0310932007,
-0.0287390146,
-0.0425314792,
-0.0439406,
0.0488356575,
0.0463322289,
0.0097303083,
-0.0076448144,
0.0378571488,
0.0542387925,
-0.0862495229,
0.0132110165,
-0.0415605381,
0.0167613514,
0.0734464005,
0.0083933091,
-0.0655726492,
-0.0250523873,
-0.0226175524,
0.0484397225,
0.0426373333,
0.012393333,
-0.0245512966,
0.0551063865,
-0.0568142906,
0.0170999113,
0.0148623893,
0.0074273576,
0.0272556972,
-0.0356142782,
0.0416952781,
0.0142693119,
-0.0543446094,
-0.0013550516,
0.0186193977,
-0.026457822,
-0.0557785258,
0.020304963,
0.0222095829,
0.0354132764,
0.0156087363,
-0.0262806993,
-0.0416687764,
0.0413997881,
-0.0129297441,
0.0037225666,
-0.0024913924,
-0.0346862264,
-0.0645610988,
0.033786919,
-0.0235301424,
-0.0260029733,
0.0495444797,
-0.0312715098,
-0.0326524265,
0.0118758017,
0.0063829608,
0.0433720164,
-0.040318802,
-0.0118997525,
-0.0240009595,
-0.0072148666,
-0.0174576398,
0.029959105,
0.0422458649,
0.008402505,
-0.0233977735,
0.0044653071,
0.0026451955,
0.0128725432,
-0.0840205625,
0.0179430731,
0.009751915,
0.002428808,
0.0185103361,
-0.0120349387,
-0.0389742702,
-0.0612763874,
-0.0985761657,
-0.005426622,
-0.0146374777,
-0.0100851087,
-0.008157677,
0.0079623573,
-0.0101498254,
0.0003982036,
-0.0443283506,
-0.0003215579,
0.0131812459,
0.0074796295,
-0.0223956462,
-0.0239309762,
0.0107760932,
-0.0972317159,
0.016502969,
-0.0229963325,
0.0051812357,
-0.017300183,
0.0169494376,
-0.0444687754,
0.035867542,
-0.0434835292,
0.0359668694,
-0.0005841953,
-0.0512388982,
0.0005151117,
-0.0359394364,
0.0178104509,
0.0216372125,
-0.0325642526,
0.0447158664,
0.0388922542,
-0.0119544668,
-0.0232787225,
0.0262967292,
-0.0270326771,
-0.0148580205,
-0.0282642767,
0.0253344122,
-0.0548452623,
0.0342407189,
0.0029111686,
-0.0000666283,
-0.0452520736,
-0.0201417878,
0.0006990505,
-0.0411916785,
-0.0032034542,
-0.046666529,
0.0071277115,
-0.0052436492,
0.0179572888,
-0.0260299314,
0.0240314174,
-0.0108152917,
-0.0490698256,
-0.0537266992,
-0.0352637284,
-0.0212204494,
0.0912792459,
-0.0305122826,
0.002596905,
-0.0107104946,
0.0094010867,
-0.0204783902,
-0.0532384813,
-0.0353617333,
-0.0428023823,
0.0201542675,
-0.0230671726,
-0.0209708232,
0.0360984504,
-0.0377603397,
-0.0513425954,
-0.0537705533,
-0.0511048436,
-0.0161587354,
0.0057246028,
0.005257918,
0.0009885348,
-0.0172300488,
0.0288047623,
-0.011471088,
0.0102126971,
-0.0082496265,
-0.0011211995,
0.0387135334,
0.058492437,
-0.0230779592,
-0.0080775311,
-0.0146851223,
0.0415005609,
0.0193955638,
0.0385333784,
0.0010623235,
-0.0228321888,
0.0495330691,
0.0273648482,
0.0553775802,
0.0048383228,
-0.0023507755,
0.0189178959,
-0.015662495,
0.0255881585,
0.1648079306,
0.0282383729,
-0.0515657216,
0.0114797726,
-0.0168887042,
0.0653075203,
0.0487582274,
0.0048696981,
0.011481843,
-0.0561092421,
0.013281472,
0.0384838656,
0.0056220577,
-0.0171925072,
0.0152952047,
-0.0725995675,
0.0352826975,
0.0035245842,
0.0194159038,
-0.009234312,
-0.0591884367,
0.0299620014,
-0.0235614888,
-0.0310474206,
-0.0581284873,
0.0212123469,
-0.0189499035,
0.0247862674,
-0.0413379073,
-0.04282533,
0.036966864,
-0.0344194621,
0.0470079333,
0.0126002124,
0.0751359984,
-0.0406802557,
-0.0271799527,
0.0550882407,
0.0014225692,
-0.0391553454,
0.0034662604,
0.0443715602,
-0.0135756331,
-0.0461569875,
-0.031591855,
0.0714958459,
-0.0409390405,
0.0065297978,
-0.0031692821,
0.0868540853,
-0.0101979095,
-0.0122630661,
0.0110970419,
-0.0144435335,
0.0352045968,
0.0584284104,
0.0211903173,
-0.0617580265,
-0.0021563128,
-0.0027133198,
0.0216390658,
0.0484289192,
-0.0499510355,
0.0037275676,
-0.0084139695,
-0.0526008643,
-0.0525199287,
-0.0633101985,
0.0388589464,
0.0257063154,
-0.0050430042,
-0.0387888364,
0.016518835,
0.0046789395,
-0.0484902263,
0.0778565705,
0.007200853,
-0.0046643014,
-0.0413874388,
-0.0297054872,
0.0648927316,
-0.009302875,
-0.0203228537,
0.0327294059,
-0.0071802344,
-0.0630292445,
0.0557248034,
0.0043854117,
0.0064995554,
0.032655865,
-0.0091529395,
-0.0197266303,
0.0514964573,
0.0738126263,
-0.0419787057,
0.0056842389,
0.0637130365,
0.0002760847,
-0.0144592151,
0.0174285006,
-0.0669760033,
0.0846769065,
0.033122398,
-0.0045306128,
0.0206673928,
-0.0952369422,
-0.0136861624,
0.0159640778,
0.0912614986,
0.0177773386,
-0.0210923497,
-0.0345095769,
-0.0208266694,
0.0115373582,
-0.0069819293,
-0.0378652252,
-0.0076217218,
0.0249198005,
0.0194231644,
-0.0639946982,
-0.0267339777,
0.0002448095,
0.010255415,
-0.0061419504,
0.0474465489,
0.0242958013,
0.0032705609,
-0.0048451489,
0.0081920205,
-0.0126900645,
0.0031783069,
0.0046345596,
-0.0001706499,
-0.0313140079,
-0.0081829084,
0.0240387078,
-0.0161631573,
0.0077935359,
-0.0058980854,
-0.0160311852,
-0.0023780798,
-0.0358513482,
-0.0067506991,
0.0239655674,
-0.0597490519,
0.0598702021,
-0.0324837714,
0.0322680846,
-0.0146268643,
-0.0038882492,
-0.0341300927,
-0.0324815623,
-0.0045821774,
0.0153774712,
-0.0482330397,
0.047648292,
0.0027218058,
0.0297237225,
0.0838348642,
-0.0172952674,
0.0181052275,
-0.0412225313,
-0.0272337198,
0.0530603863,
-0.0297839008,
-0.0020485991,
0.0543467365,
-0.0033951974,
-0.0682698712,
0.0246050842,
-0.0496814884,
-0.0245579723,
-0.0044577667,
0.0312505886,
0.0350648761,
-0.0433992334,
0.0342453346,
-0.0057529737,
0.0049279989,
-0.0333637707,
-0.0340944193,
0.0123625053,
-6.144918025e-33,
-0.0012618018,
0.0093359835,
-0.062701121,
0.003277574,
-0.0039590909,
0.0118931234,
-0.025058765,
0.0196204185,
0.0227414481,
0.0500539131,
-0.0106060784,
0.0388052352,
0.0121382158,
0.0527984835,
0.0192666203,
-0.0299610645,
0.0423870273,
0.0021043953,
0.0326456949,
0.0381195247,
0.0227718856,
0.0409683995,
0.0410646237,
-0.1244200319,
0.0047832546,
-0.017025765,
-0.01391045,
-0.0116784144,
0.0781163052,
0.0354808085,
-0.0206601117,
0.034819819,
-0.0196971614,
-0.0043060835,
0.0172414463,
0.0362283476,
-0.051118359,
-0.0025395611,
-0.0126248142,
0.0179268923,
-0.004511802,
-0.0182994474,
-0.0219618361,
0.0327186212,
0.0068411399,
0.0054251635,
0.0392974503,
-0.0185969155,
0.0229027811,
-0.0658744574,
-0.0365281105,
0.0287313648,
-0.0265418775,
-0.0086174384,
0.0476364717,
0.0808986574,
-0.0219137017,
0.0228929538,
-0.0108599365,
-0.0091490075,
-0.0147402743,
0.0324429274,
0.008858352,
0.0346537866,
0.0030718001,
0.0836952552,
0.0081163645,
-0.0043180673,
0.0308339521,
0.0269635022,
0.0242381375,
0.05249881,
0.0293283444,
0.0414894708,
-0.0002129048,
0.0044063833,
-0.039933417,
-0.0030553713,
0.0214568097,
-0.0182156619,
0.056652721,
0.0111889625,
-0.0497319102,
-0.0105577987,
-0.0321713947,
0.0028244385,
-0.0177355018,
-0.0001135456,
0.0624046884,
-0.025281338,
-0.0053481534,
0.0086261434,
0.0173061825,
-0.0068387468,
-0.0262822825,
0.0453428216,
-0.0240442324,
0.0362077467,
-0.0063980054,
0.0358450413,
-0.0384335555,
-0.0468138047,
0.0548242331,
0.0255291089,
0.0607054606,
-0.0019877185,
0.0167176705,
0.0533513762,
-0.0598964505,
-0.0022148627,
-0.0160582103,
0.0287142582,
-0.0326954238,
0.0098139597,
-0.0103517734,
0.0122803478,
-0.012581585,
0.0363329686,
-0.0044326829,
-0.0023859278,
-0.0082090963,
-0.0479864404,
-0.0202013515,
0.0147771295,
-0.0684929714,
-0.0333154388,
0.005637907,
-0.0177595858,
0.022015024,
-0.0498672724,
0.0062618922,
-0.027940413,
2.789e-7,
-0.0372394435,
0.0299758464,
-0.0322819389,
-0.0201074947,
0.0112451445,
0.0502866954,
-0.0232147332,
0.0407751761,
0.0331602842,
-0.0373886041,
0.0526502319,
0.0082882363,
0.0792079568,
0.0356074683,
-0.1139658988,
-0.0012019093,
-0.0376937762,
0.0053632599,
-0.0143842464,
0.0241645649,
0.1025903001,
0.1504049897,
0.0590420961,
-0.0053564822,
0.0040307385,
-0.026108535,
0.0167817529,
-0.0351390392,
-0.0030078597,
0.0175575353,
0.0003135887,
0.0135535812,
-0.0148032727,
-0.0079728682,
-0.009119398,
0.0075742197,
0.01975221,
0.0732897967,
-0.0020790882,
-0.0428276286,
0.0106422091,
0.0631811917,
-0.0001915946,
0.0205382258,
0.0696374029,
-0.0233322755,
-0.0324307568,
-0.0221603569,
-0.0127404658,
-0.0408913158,
-0.0118403491,
-0.0488262624,
0.0010111675,
0.0195962787,
0.0023366387,
-0.0510033257,
-0.0267082099,
-0.095951952,
-0.0233250856,
0.0519202836,
-0.0384055711,
-0.0134185478,
-0.0262783449,
0.0635113344,
0.0440068766,
-0.0446239561,
0.0340187475,
2.310009407e-34,
0.0297387987,
-0.0012938695,
-0.0259066075,
0.029199155,
0.0456303544,
-0.0022006768,
-0.0249659326,
-0.0066994582,
0.0413037352,
-0.0481879972,
0.0098842746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03905v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03905v2 | ImageBind-LLM: Multi-modality Instruction Tuning | 2023-09-07T17:59:45 | 2023-09-11T20:25:16 | Jiaming Han, Renrui Zhang, Wenqi Shao, Peng Gao, Peng Xu, Han Xiao, Kaipeng Zhang, Chris Liu, Song Wen, Ziyu Guo, Xudong Lu, Shuai Ren, Yafei Wen, Xiaoxin Chen, Xiangyu Yue, Hongsheng Li, Yu Qiao | cs.MM | cs.MM, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | We present ImageBind-LLM, a multi-modality instruction tuning method of large
language models (LLMs) via ImageBind. Existing works mainly focus on language
and image instruction tuning, different from which, our ImageBind-LLM can
respond to multi-modality conditions, including audio, 3D point clouds, video,
and their embedding-space arithmetic by only image-text alignment training.
During training, we adopt a learnable bind network to align the embedding space
between LLaMA and ImageBind's image encoder. Then, the image features
transformed by the bind network are added to word tokens of all layers in
LLaMA, which progressively injects visual instructions via an attention-free
and zero-initialized gating mechanism. Aided by the joint embedding of
ImageBind, the simple image-text training enables our model to exhibit superior
multi-modality instruction-following capabilities. During inference, the
multi-modality inputs are fed into the corresponding ImageBind encoders, and
processed by a proposed visual cache model for further cross-modal embedding
enhancement. The training-free cache model retrieves from three million image
features extracted by ImageBind, which effectively mitigates the
training-inference modality discrepancy. Notably, with our approach,
ImageBind-LLM can respond to instructions of diverse modalities and demonstrate
significant language generation quality. Code is released at
https://github.com/OpenGVLab/LLaMA-Adapter. | [
0.0065459204,
0.0747969151,
0.0096683102,
0.0621484965,
-0.0081646349,
0.0069301929,
0.0300878752,
-0.0395950824,
-0.0162870549,
-0.0380879268,
-0.0766973197,
-0.0341464356,
0.0120028863,
0.0132826008,
0.0672810376,
-0.0388847478,
0.0355478339,
-0.0238277502,
-0.0549504124,
-0.0116233602,
0.0245112889,
0.0211043525,
-0.009686213,
0.0298275985,
-0.0260041021,
-0.0054229978,
-0.0332325622,
0.0273228921,
0.0197062474,
-0.0129917432,
-0.0222656969,
0.0172046777,
0.0460317396,
0.0002984865,
0.0000020612,
-0.0037594012,
0.0189433377,
-0.0086424481,
0.041891817,
0.0535081029,
0.0434998237,
-0.0436823145,
-0.0221408159,
0.0185584128,
-0.0075499886,
-0.0145979915,
0.0871408507,
0.0221084598,
0.076696068,
0.0685851127,
-0.0198726691,
-0.0288878419,
0.0194673091,
-0.04710152,
0.0214634314,
-0.0057143169,
-0.0029439572,
0.0070249266,
0.0039454764,
0.0205701534,
-0.0686501712,
0.0726762936,
0.0405317917,
0.0211713407,
0.009982449,
0.0544567294,
0.012496436,
-0.0431118719,
-0.0455364622,
0.0706731677,
-0.0144129852,
-0.0107082976,
-0.0136472881,
-0.0025243636,
-0.0012428325,
-0.0055327872,
-0.0387101807,
0.0398470052,
0.0327998661,
0.0355962887,
-0.028257465,
-0.0172352493,
0.0320676044,
0.0087738559,
-0.001590269,
0.019948883,
0.0379209444,
0.0081051039,
-0.050368242,
0.0141937854,
-0.0408725552,
-0.0525151342,
-0.0058635301,
0.0445636511,
0.0235584974,
0.0351165086,
-0.07690119,
-0.0294304267,
0.00778466,
-0.0484376922,
0.0506242327,
0.0563161969,
-0.0738820285,
0.042281311,
-0.0518653654,
0.0614467487,
-0.0525911301,
0.0543848537,
-0.0483201593,
-0.0120170638,
-0.0090996781,
-0.0246261265,
-0.0316881649,
-0.0035755271,
-0.0538882017,
-0.0457955673,
-0.0362832732,
0.0362176225,
-0.0018232316,
-0.0220259558,
0.0230841804,
0.0185391847,
-0.0585837103,
-0.0202347301,
-0.0178448148,
0.0393484123,
-0.0163167808,
0.0434127785,
-0.0312296543,
-0.0495837554,
-0.0081000552,
0.0492082089,
0.0002016424,
0.0118890908,
0.0173429176,
0.1065110415,
-0.0621157326,
-0.0274272375,
-0.0391758829,
-0.0176126845,
-0.0204207525,
-0.0331686102,
0.0578317493,
-0.069306165,
0.0348589569,
0.0000941744,
-0.0128902122,
-0.0468221605,
0.0189365093,
0.0075562671,
-0.0151267927,
0.0679468885,
0.0109931882,
-0.0102565978,
0.0424640998,
0.0282923933,
0.026734449,
0.0791024044,
0.0645015463,
0.0307291988,
0.0129642235,
0.0146787204,
-0.0329970494,
0.0780723691,
0.0228682533,
0.0241301209,
-0.0544445179,
-0.0124340756,
0.0137127517,
0.0377289131,
0.0598610528,
0.054672353,
-0.0475926474,
-0.0204381682,
0.0459858142,
0.0229152497,
-0.0119687403,
0.0198026448,
0.0510398,
-0.0187133122,
-0.0098086698,
0.0063212453,
-0.0626602471,
0.0810027793,
0.0277746543,
0.0126910219,
0.038830705,
0.05801557,
-0.0514325611,
-0.0367606655,
0.0138813453,
-0.0014472905,
-0.004417574,
-0.0133934459,
0.0121315802,
0.0071507799,
-0.0614228435,
0.0537897125,
0.0142062595,
-0.036138963,
0.0087990221,
-0.0206057914,
-0.0045387172,
0.0360618196,
-0.0146844387,
0.039169997,
-0.0311525669,
0.0279782731,
0.0410364792,
0.0591100678,
-0.0165196061,
0.0135210957,
0.028540967,
-0.0840051994,
-0.0179459304,
-0.0276577454,
0.008096423,
0.0395303667,
0.0051511414,
0.0066054175,
0.0194264278,
-0.0070243729,
0.0376323685,
0.0388919525,
-0.0122057544,
-0.0114023974,
-0.032192532,
0.0097321095,
0.0157393217,
-0.0357439294,
-0.0141723435,
0.0031927014,
0.0156311877,
-0.0441662557,
0.0295467786,
0.0224072579,
-0.0815750733,
-0.0245391671,
0.0306636635,
-0.0359044559,
0.0202617086,
-0.0314402021,
-0.0311399121,
-0.0375646539,
0.0252433121,
-0.0204929393,
0.0404759757,
-0.0381851718,
-0.0015862146,
0.0215789396,
0.0232459232,
-0.0082266899,
0.0276906192,
-0.0442547649,
-0.0222543515,
0.0297250431,
0.0437276848,
-0.0004710163,
0.0099708773,
-0.0209927466,
0.0025386715,
-0.0004038759,
0.0215375274,
-0.0472211316,
0.0195397437,
-0.0253194254,
-0.0461742245,
-0.1101986766,
0.000653146,
-0.0197589211,
0.0177669898,
0.0252541415,
0.0095324246,
0.0132114496,
-0.0277192388,
-0.0377514809,
0.04154744,
-0.0018937079,
0.024356816,
0.0087343715,
-0.0092803501,
-0.0150373233,
-0.022166647,
-0.0098772673,
0.0243806299,
0.0267140996,
-0.0109654712,
-0.0110331811,
-0.0309680514,
0.0125558181,
-0.0417155996,
0.0329451673,
-0.0193601102,
-0.0653873086,
0.0210822448,
0.0068808203,
0.0609642752,
0.0786161944,
-0.0189728495,
-0.0025606449,
0.0377089009,
-0.0145657137,
-0.0419369563,
0.0042789951,
0.0099268323,
-0.0193599537,
-0.0214747731,
-0.0109252995,
-0.0316350684,
0.0692481175,
-0.0159102362,
0.0315172412,
-0.0598830171,
0.0021307953,
-0.0036550751,
-0.0282388888,
-0.0113029471,
0.0169045497,
-0.0260496475,
-0.0017418623,
-0.0440018661,
-0.0854909942,
0.0403565988,
-0.0720071569,
-0.0349888764,
-0.003392105,
0.0199798048,
-0.013617985,
0.0295952093,
0.031583827,
0.0404533111,
-0.0082099633,
-0.0129910903,
-0.0746041089,
0.0049695233,
0.0072076879,
-0.0153601877,
0.0428755358,
-0.034798488,
-0.0113838846,
-0.0336944237,
-0.0247212164,
-0.0192442313,
0.0113020809,
-0.0112194493,
-0.0061311098,
-0.0192531478,
-0.0404133275,
-0.0031308399,
-0.0142379021,
0.0264807213,
0.0300795641,
-0.0293055866,
0.0161193237,
-0.0470569171,
0.0152478339,
0.0455604978,
0.0399597548,
-0.0530445389,
-0.0308043547,
-0.0400749967,
0.0523714051,
-0.0096255885,
-0.0273888055,
-0.0505538583,
0.0744737089,
0.0441838354,
0.0754870996,
-0.0162410997,
0.0322024189,
0.0909342915,
-0.0462928899,
-0.0065573798,
0.0453295223,
0.0219389703,
-0.0465574749,
-0.0065294178,
0.0310808811,
0.0361775905,
0.0313511118,
0.0121913776,
-0.0858302861,
-0.0517385602,
-0.0085423151,
-0.0161445253,
0.0320826843,
0.0450714119,
-0.0297330059,
-0.0922851637,
0.0315130614,
0.0329643488,
-0.0104854712,
-0.0556012131,
-0.0107085798,
-0.0114171272,
0.009597796,
-0.0028402752,
-0.0004179693,
-0.0019050445,
0.002867104,
0.0089373821,
0.065141499,
-0.0622835755,
-0.0026177468,
-0.0239991602,
0.0473730639,
0.0537982881,
-0.0143237701,
0.0066034035,
-0.0831208453,
0.0338400826,
0.0276706126,
0.0065795318,
-0.0035058509,
0.0067743817,
-0.0047782529,
-0.0346430838,
0.0050583244,
0.0505951941,
0.0005879219,
-0.0023706951,
-0.03220658,
0.06851805,
0.0029581746,
0.0432795025,
-0.0173239727,
0.0111902785,
-0.0056881737,
0.0225639958,
0.0266283806,
-0.0314526744,
-0.0113821384,
-0.0374790877,
-0.0078530777,
-0.0573554821,
-0.0483831018,
0.008068637,
-0.0159518905,
-0.0148363337,
-0.0373939164,
-0.0076722275,
0.0237062313,
0.0316534489,
0.0100401985,
-0.0545647889,
-0.0051979455,
-0.0167274754,
-0.0573286191,
0.0431541763,
-0.0240384489,
0.0308303479,
-0.0643656328,
-0.0072710924,
0.0621104911,
-0.026973201,
-0.0109577142,
0.0332280733,
-0.1122745872,
-0.0615871102,
-0.0392729118,
0.0597830415,
0.0028122521,
0.0597356223,
0.0172505267,
-0.0470364951,
0.0346937068,
0.0278952979,
-0.0265625678,
0.0355294906,
0.0300297104,
-0.0225549415,
0.0028530594,
0.0254222732,
-0.0327420756,
0.0361484326,
0.0198784601,
0.0188044943,
-0.0117701134,
-0.0147928754,
-0.0059509035,
-0.0450000726,
0.0102172643,
-0.0393692292,
0.0189677142,
-0.0526048802,
0.0219453964,
0.0064136055,
0.0118158227,
-0.0670849532,
0.0034627733,
0.0169201456,
-0.009719979,
0.0064144125,
0.0011504685,
0.0337375179,
0.00819185,
0.0033958622,
0.0572377369,
0.0095983213,
-0.0009183515,
0.0137759838,
0.0407073423,
-0.0084744319,
0.0120394044,
-0.0192313623,
0.0217293706,
-0.0557158925,
0.05269631,
0.0016093779,
-0.0022568663,
-0.0649627224,
0.0408703499,
0.0031290113,
0.017556712,
-0.0670800507,
0.0612417646,
0.0701027662,
0.0085010557,
0.0382638685,
-0.0186468679,
-0.0151794106,
0.0048435079,
0.055353839,
-0.0219959393,
-0.0373221673,
0.0783246756,
0.0147239063,
-0.009261433,
-0.0132666789,
0.0571476258,
0.0137626538,
0.0301735271,
-0.0088622198,
0.0341090709,
-0.0226003677,
-0.0244429521,
0.0347581431,
-0.0112349186,
-0.0259749852,
0.0206903648,
0.0043114852,
-0.0658577681,
-0.0400530696,
0.0253368523,
-0.0337986238,
0.0007026216,
0.0271494165,
0.0224472508,
-0.001729683,
0.0018225528,
-0.0039945166,
0.0004470226,
0.0042919731,
-0.029639462,
-0.0033628272,
-6.443300368e-33,
-0.0465717539,
-0.0227129776,
0.0500628129,
-0.0354315042,
-0.0308565013,
0.012037673,
-0.0188370086,
0.011242033,
-0.0147181712,
-0.0034121296,
0.0272011682,
-0.0087395264,
0.0132939415,
0.037179783,
0.0002374706,
0.0249504149,
0.043818526,
-0.0321581364,
-0.0125026191,
0.0187576991,
0.0185113829,
-0.0048221434,
0.0419375263,
-0.0409547351,
-0.0334587172,
0.0119498996,
-0.0302954912,
0.0083501739,
-0.0067853611,
0.0657646954,
-0.0194541626,
0.0169210378,
-0.0079022199,
-0.0263650306,
-0.0197658185,
0.0180707667,
-0.0804066435,
-0.0128326314,
0.024342468,
0.0435949005,
-0.0628979877,
-0.0484400652,
0.04982296,
-0.0170123465,
-0.0100807594,
-0.0215651598,
0.018614741,
-0.0089408243,
-0.0172678176,
0.0054330728,
-0.0565658323,
0.0112122949,
0.0038303009,
-0.053956531,
0.0394783989,
0.004417405,
0.0384571999,
0.004798654,
-0.0629450753,
0.0110253263,
-0.0033151137,
0.0722536445,
0.0919098482,
0.0708515644,
0.0014659112,
0.0354295932,
-0.0005755757,
-0.0648147613,
-0.0084754834,
0.0227729119,
0.0445794873,
0.0355631337,
0.0071529984,
0.0327869691,
0.025540838,
-0.0043074205,
-0.0361510701,
-0.0199333038,
-0.0249688458,
0.0309205353,
0.0117995087,
0.0189800747,
0.0128515838,
-0.012351078,
-0.0224097129,
-0.0256026443,
-0.044652313,
-0.0242261216,
0.0433744937,
0.0433987193,
-0.0042332169,
0.0055574072,
0.0775736794,
-0.0031282483,
-0.0019772386,
0.0175068919,
-0.0286956728,
0.0744106174,
-0.0002728818,
0.0433447547,
-0.0542301424,
-0.0270421468,
0.0528547876,
-0.0184488036,
0.0210895836,
0.0241204035,
0.0352176167,
0.0417087451,
-0.0530715697,
0.0077096005,
-0.0485155582,
-0.021928953,
0.0203532819,
0.0453480929,
0.0322504006,
-0.0094634267,
-0.0482625663,
0.0230935086,
-0.0347516686,
0.0112943584,
-0.0190429892,
-0.0741494074,
-0.0289480183,
0.0400794521,
-0.0569393113,
0.0463735685,
-0.0670209974,
-0.0154981911,
0.0153303873,
-0.0677733794,
-0.0342231505,
0.0545606501,
2.799e-7,
0.0242412556,
0.0147968819,
0.0210702196,
-0.0096700862,
0.0148961907,
0.0168279354,
-0.0247795638,
0.0401502252,
0.0061719343,
-0.0501050949,
-0.0093273418,
0.0397939645,
0.0416272916,
0.0109233055,
-0.0482969619,
0.0454585031,
-0.0269202217,
0.0471793115,
-0.0249396283,
-0.0093741659,
0.0478811376,
0.129201591,
-0.0376130603,
0.0038281039,
0.0281540994,
-0.0133789051,
0.0710382015,
0.0055492083,
-0.0074386802,
-0.0070536206,
-0.0069408417,
0.0604190007,
-0.0487303697,
-0.0279206056,
-0.0269749705,
-0.0039688796,
0.0048077046,
0.0627056137,
-0.0139879063,
-0.0413324386,
-0.0196488909,
0.0118744019,
-0.0612510294,
-0.0237342622,
0.0668562204,
-0.0565124527,
-0.0136424173,
-0.0526092723,
0.0249145124,
0.0347769521,
0.0059294631,
-0.0437720977,
-0.0386697799,
0.001399966,
0.054522559,
-0.0328450873,
-0.0517272949,
-0.0619172566,
-0.0484211706,
-0.0188939106,
-0.044195883,
0.0002832872,
-0.0929492489,
-0.0477845445,
0.0382797681,
-0.022335019,
-0.0443350822,
2.535621212e-34,
0.0009495343,
-0.0586607307,
0.0377202779,
0.0182664953,
0.0108164763,
-0.0243699774,
-0.0023041647,
0.0179863367,
-0.01349275,
-0.0653492659,
-0.0467232428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03886v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03886v3 | FIND: A Function Description Benchmark for Evaluating Interpretability Methods | 2023-09-07T17:47:26 | 2023-12-08T05:18:40 | Sarah Schwettmann, Tamar Rott Shaham, Joanna Materzynska, Neil Chowdhury, Shuang Li, Jacob Andreas, David Bau, Antonio Torralba | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Labeling neural network submodules with human-legible descriptions is useful
for many downstream tasks: such descriptions can surface failures, guide
interventions, and perhaps even explain important model behaviors. To date,
most mechanistic descriptions of trained networks have involved small models,
narrowly delimited phenomena, and large amounts of human labor. Labeling all
human-interpretable sub-computations in models of increasing size and
complexity will almost certainly require tools that can generate and validate
descriptions automatically. Recently, techniques that use learned models
in-the-loop for labeling have begun to gain traction, but methods for
evaluating their efficacy are limited and ad-hoc. How should we validate and
compare open-ended labeling tools? This paper introduces FIND (Function
INterpretation and Description), a benchmark suite for evaluating the building
blocks of automated interpretability methods. FIND contains functions that
resemble components of trained neural networks, and accompanying descriptions
of the kind we seek to generate. The functions span textual and numeric
domains, and involve a range of real-world complexities. We evaluate methods
that use pretrained language models (LMs) to produce descriptions of function
behavior in natural language and code. Additionally, we introduce a new
interactive method in which an Automated Interpretability Agent (AIA) generates
function descriptions. We find that an AIA, built from an LM with black-box
access to functions, can infer function structure, acting as a scientist by
forming hypotheses, proposing experiments, and updating descriptions in light
of new data. However, AIA descriptions tend to capture global function behavior
and miss local details. These results suggest that FIND will be useful for
evaluating more sophisticated interpretability methods before they are applied
to real-world models. | [
-0.008119409,
0.0445182659,
-0.0139140803,
0.0389446355,
0.0125678061,
0.0106408997,
0.0101135466,
-0.0140369758,
0.0208879095,
-0.0080014495,
-0.0318329744,
0.0110004945,
-0.000896857,
0.0627819598,
0.0261814091,
-0.0296806395,
0.0347667821,
-0.0240762718,
-0.0015429901,
0.0376338959,
-0.0355718955,
0.0053770253,
0.0026610582,
0.0626165718,
0.0196176898,
-0.049229227,
-0.0082502114,
0.0095903771,
0.0052059148,
-0.0097190263,
-0.0225949399,
0.0017943459,
0.0019910436,
0.0526993088,
0.000002275,
-0.0087554352,
-0.0341792628,
0.0432187319,
-0.0885050893,
0.0464409254,
0.0289372783,
-0.017978169,
0.0186313801,
-0.0097847003,
-0.0025629897,
-0.0192794073,
0.087811172,
-0.0190315396,
0.0559759662,
0.0302410237,
0.0147740273,
-0.0175569709,
0.0011458523,
0.0111649595,
0.0332336798,
-0.0538944118,
-0.0087986002,
0.0195464697,
-0.0180850923,
-0.0202255696,
-0.0016204485,
0.0546901412,
0.0608032681,
-0.0239978544,
0.0253955461,
-0.0111026783,
0.0184017811,
-0.038506791,
0.0059049502,
0.0482570268,
-0.0211095307,
-0.0284354668,
0.0019377128,
-0.0201545563,
-0.0200775471,
0.0116212275,
-0.0130481506,
-0.0243366212,
-0.0151404822,
-0.0083569754,
0.0061286911,
0.0330312364,
0.0596066453,
-0.0012148853,
-0.0105147297,
0.0745587721,
-0.0403834991,
0.0016393049,
0.0106616132,
-0.0226358045,
0.0016820336,
-0.0145980641,
0.0480548292,
0.0325876884,
0.0019282619,
0.0416972302,
-0.0177570693,
-0.0284549221,
0.0232241526,
-0.0320106186,
0.0706737414,
0.023470087,
-0.0319333784,
0.0195057523,
-0.0268142074,
0.063765727,
-0.0393393859,
0.0254419129,
-0.012506499,
0.0317521952,
-0.0907362625,
-0.0412053466,
-0.0174196921,
0.0266312174,
-0.0299915578,
0.009528745,
-0.0417136103,
0.0227929037,
-0.046778582,
0.0296101719,
-0.0337452851,
-0.0230857115,
-0.0395105965,
0.0051442017,
-0.0170636848,
-0.0134492377,
-0.0322030038,
-0.0309964493,
-0.0151779866,
-0.0524890125,
-0.0250648204,
0.0121612558,
-0.0509513989,
-0.0024749432,
-0.0251389481,
0.0981078893,
0.0146371089,
0.035427466,
-0.031142924,
-0.0828918964,
-0.003702526,
-0.0071671694,
0.0172103588,
-0.0353180207,
0.007987882,
0.0120794242,
0.0106994202,
-0.0696498975,
-0.0175949354,
-0.0328231603,
0.0143224467,
0.1059787646,
-0.058438357,
-0.0145380972,
0.0093784211,
0.0145231318,
-0.0029895934,
0.0294200927,
0.0064629987,
0.0079024052,
0.0468058437,
-0.0391500741,
0.0289923884,
-0.0009740454,
0.0226076152,
-0.033532165,
-0.0019187807,
-0.0030050357,
-0.0201935545,
0.0209778771,
0.0075768442,
-0.0108680101,
-0.0167800933,
-0.0326322801,
0.0005464418,
0.0307215881,
0.0516801998,
0.0245704409,
0.1067631692,
0.0192619022,
0.0398747064,
-0.0095378729,
-0.0616130345,
-0.002740138,
-0.0406638272,
0.0118100215,
-0.0415089875,
-0.0205092989,
0.0045167417,
-0.1082418859,
-0.0082298433,
0.006908861,
0.0004354048,
-0.0088254288,
0.0472810678,
0.0407569595,
-0.0081899483,
0.0474316031,
0.0114529682,
-0.0351719074,
-0.0162877366,
-0.0942719057,
0.0207124017,
0.0627737045,
0.0390042365,
-0.0873164386,
-0.0091183996,
0.0281361118,
0.0002266974,
-0.0235071741,
0.0121839298,
-0.0068712607,
0.0312062427,
-0.0258113127,
-0.0141727934,
-0.054969646,
0.0448349863,
0.0330010019,
-0.0282085966,
-0.0650839731,
0.0228755791,
-0.0666398779,
-0.1051845923,
0.0301029608,
-0.0061453665,
-0.0440772213,
0.0176191032,
-0.0004226418,
0.0294327158,
0.029375881,
-0.0237574372,
0.0346155092,
0.0065127467,
0.0056538801,
0.0102896886,
0.0073124943,
-0.020742517,
-0.0002756793,
-0.0269900784,
-0.0145240929,
-0.0306494068,
0.036189694,
-0.0548077114,
-0.0024153059,
0.0300470535,
-0.0644201115,
-0.0074815857,
0.0143876132,
-0.0029392573,
-0.0240914635,
-0.0409500934,
-0.01047548,
0.0327425487,
0.0096344985,
-0.0137396306,
0.0020623787,
0.036783956,
0.0118332626,
0.0115376413,
-0.0244092084,
-0.0015244348,
-0.0223162752,
0.004955376,
-0.0145739736,
0.0084923031,
-0.0029173701,
0.0195968971,
-0.0346721672,
0.0027509579,
-0.0109023992,
0.0290000606,
0.0375145972,
-0.0266508237,
0.0377158374,
-0.0208669193,
0.0124317538,
0.010612919,
-0.0686908811,
-0.0168169271,
0.0584416203,
0.0304203052,
-0.0742341205,
-0.0624226145,
-0.0412877351,
-0.0551257879,
0.1099186093,
0.0359814093,
-0.0047860746,
-0.0578183196,
0.0382794999,
0.0094797332,
-0.0034875614,
-0.0312954076,
-0.0375397094,
0.0203275029,
0.0281827934,
-0.0556624867,
0.0615766272,
-0.045329541,
0.0923025832,
0.0247629974,
0.0269230697,
-0.0505800024,
-0.0047602672,
0.000110885,
-0.0285189766,
-0.0107691064,
-0.066008985,
0.0378015488,
0.1142294332,
-0.0026678729,
0.0176548101,
-0.0285014845,
0.023637224,
-0.0083811218,
-0.0335563496,
-0.0429699868,
-0.0256361403,
0.0005272295,
0.0504622199,
0.0031434156,
-0.0776720122,
0.0747993961,
-0.0278652646,
-0.0243726894,
-0.0177131817,
-0.0484213717,
-0.0401838496,
0.0890738964,
0.0191479214,
-0.0051585017,
0.0488439798,
-0.0424802788,
0.0162916873,
-0.0215843078,
0.0132307475,
-0.0142576937,
0.0365992077,
-0.0599059574,
-0.020573454,
0.0276501942,
0.0081956843,
-0.0077152732,
-0.007273342,
-0.0108082248,
0.0260615516,
0.0292536169,
-0.0005832299,
-0.027733719,
0.0116783101,
0.0323126316,
0.0284665842,
-0.0093151443,
-0.0215385612,
-0.042340681,
-0.0695677474,
-0.0286079682,
-0.0112087643,
0.0211356748,
-0.0255718436,
0.0113490839,
-0.0080465302,
-0.0330308042,
0.0084107434,
-0.0857006237,
0.0083118742,
-0.0467993803,
-0.0363354236,
-0.0203339048,
0.0284394734,
0.0543283075,
-0.1153796837,
-0.0189933069,
0.0392309055,
0.018811129,
-0.0441324078,
0.0210371055,
-0.0180419777,
-0.0115735028,
0.0093868626,
0.0391707793,
-0.0424340032,
-0.0236926805,
-0.0062592765,
0.0762642771,
-0.018526122,
0.0031680008,
0.0172127318,
-0.0484569035,
0.0376613848,
0.0169913452,
-0.0407406613,
-0.0337639488,
-0.0392594114,
-0.0440102294,
-0.0400957651,
-0.0276038032,
0.0245631337,
0.0115215806,
0.0251884703,
-0.0034291868,
-0.0755260512,
-0.0263155028,
0.0137666073,
-0.0064931707,
0.0164454114,
0.0697210953,
-0.0036283981,
-0.0007002775,
-0.0139485719,
0.0287883915,
0.0198106151,
0.0424196124,
-0.0026716124,
0.0663895383,
0.0096033383,
-0.0316678807,
-0.0001371205,
0.0173973627,
-0.0318872593,
-0.011996123,
0.0115123754,
0.0546279438,
-0.0126900142,
0.0031065852,
-0.0020396134,
0.027509721,
0.0264971461,
0.0521693341,
0.0950146988,
-0.0231011026,
-0.0519230291,
-0.0558454059,
0.0129526341,
-0.0911693722,
-0.0533827133,
0.0149788512,
-0.0165338702,
-0.0173626207,
0.0031083638,
-0.0141475592,
0.0125715733,
-0.0148607418,
0.0205954723,
-0.0634227097,
0.0191427357,
-0.0041357479,
-0.0537859686,
0.0552683473,
0.0067290151,
0.0192380715,
-0.0274323504,
-0.0410094857,
0.0373636,
-0.0124765197,
-0.045995988,
0.0533784777,
-0.0008897998,
0.0065631946,
0.0117060635,
0.0763507336,
0.0294702593,
0.016422851,
-0.030940963,
-0.0583467633,
-0.0114987884,
0.0401198529,
-0.0353379883,
-0.0240822434,
0.0641609281,
-0.0131721925,
0.0026049705,
0.0079028653,
-0.0418642759,
0.0219700057,
-0.0116518177,
-0.0142159536,
-0.0354858078,
0.0233597718,
0.0152921099,
0.029173404,
0.0368098654,
0.0345183276,
-0.0404309779,
0.0003167698,
-0.0248955097,
0.0101231849,
-0.0194080602,
-0.0734929293,
0.0470725372,
0.0142286327,
-0.0229057372,
0.0325333029,
-0.0244245473,
-0.0245451722,
0.007770496,
0.0003011357,
0.0525301211,
-0.000359827,
0.0524804704,
-0.0073953555,
0.0051400354,
-0.0388887674,
0.0304995924,
-0.0246901456,
0.0307361353,
0.0228604004,
0.0181295257,
0.0251342561,
0.0418811589,
-0.0441956073,
0.0348887369,
-0.0299159419,
-0.0657499805,
-0.0067451037,
-0.0089848544,
-0.0013483254,
0.0309009403,
0.0574356616,
-0.0146018174,
0.0044673095,
-0.0161463078,
0.0674070939,
0.0228269082,
0.0112377331,
0.0203140751,
0.0410509631,
-0.0165038183,
-0.0971772373,
0.0431824066,
0.0292290822,
0.012589829,
-0.0253577493,
-0.0401266925,
-0.0349671729,
-0.0238040574,
-0.0036119649,
0.004609494,
-0.0445862636,
-0.0436523966,
-0.0544347577,
-0.0643284917,
0.0176229682,
0.0438788496,
0.0112101249,
-0.0203372557,
0.0196934696,
0.0686010271,
0.0262912866,
-0.0305056758,
-0.0148100751,
-0.0018722416,
-0.0140728625,
0.0049769813,
-0.0300221872,
-5.669530477e-33,
-0.0420498513,
-0.0712462813,
0.0046930634,
0.0113520483,
0.0132091874,
0.0403780341,
-0.0842580423,
0.0016138302,
0.0240950547,
0.0429603457,
0.0633907318,
0.0279066041,
-0.0001210992,
-0.0237610303,
-0.0052936142,
-0.0271733999,
0.0416892394,
0.0204921812,
-0.0103681711,
0.0154986139,
0.028528966,
0.0143540408,
0.0374068916,
-0.1097444966,
0.0610834546,
0.0397134237,
-0.0144333066,
0.0064171017,
-0.018123772,
0.0809103772,
0.0001081493,
0.0180699378,
0.0064232661,
-0.0490138978,
-0.03403081,
-0.0226835031,
-0.04100658,
-0.0053666802,
0.0524862818,
0.0167378876,
-0.075541161,
-0.0531677157,
0.0868601874,
0.001963058,
-0.0166647565,
-0.0129606398,
0.0400842316,
-0.0154559603,
-0.0019313609,
-0.0059717833,
-0.0659701377,
0.0462718867,
-0.0329533927,
-0.0087311622,
0.0198350437,
0.0617453679,
-0.0192194618,
0.0135421455,
-0.0303215105,
-0.0465251729,
0.0558128953,
-0.006416054,
0.0555170849,
0.0400304683,
0.0135626253,
0.0144144166,
0.0611883625,
0.0137373134,
-0.0599897318,
0.0183781423,
0.0214018822,
0.0693289191,
0.0577512346,
0.0112790689,
0.039022278,
0.0323208608,
-0.0324577093,
-0.0029003525,
-0.0508066267,
0.0165349077,
0.0321120247,
0.0199745148,
-0.0556109175,
-0.0032517032,
-0.0339186378,
-0.022429036,
-0.0347891748,
-0.0416884981,
0.0282421596,
-0.0522613376,
-0.0633763745,
0.039272029,
-0.0170770492,
-0.0372121334,
0.0529398955,
-0.0017383019,
0.0052004084,
0.0319784619,
0.0067304666,
-0.0028271931,
0.0137934331,
-0.0436071754,
-0.0202911906,
0.0226491541,
0.1124145091,
-0.0072738067,
0.0194438454,
0.0106462277,
0.0126122842,
0.0040511088,
-0.0346366391,
-0.0332691185,
0.0043460461,
0.0320738889,
0.0388138779,
-0.011799749,
-0.0332429707,
0.038633395,
-0.0173754245,
0.005847062,
-0.0038316287,
0.0437375233,
-0.0139454436,
0.0376837701,
-0.0551423356,
-0.0551284924,
-0.0238087401,
0.021109676,
0.0322160348,
-0.0397722758,
-0.0230144765,
0.0418066569,
2.863e-7,
0.0754201114,
0.003128699,
0.0263081882,
0.0320562012,
0.0362502001,
0.0344713889,
0.0078501534,
-0.0188683271,
-0.0025495999,
-0.0300368536,
0.026586635,
0.0029172115,
0.0623971261,
-0.0027129264,
0.0020148628,
-0.0610413589,
-0.0309047066,
0.0136293424,
-0.0289118271,
0.0318551585,
0.0466994718,
0.0366970003,
0.0135059636,
0.0362880453,
0.0553046949,
-0.048467394,
0.0089424821,
-0.0401942953,
0.0375497416,
0.0207209215,
-0.000632313,
0.0351937301,
0.004400006,
-0.0018181131,
0.0026177743,
-0.0149331726,
0.008560719,
0.095319353,
0.0031314779,
0.0296150763,
-0.0211928617,
-0.0276541114,
0.0380880386,
-0.0633793995,
0.0166423619,
-0.071818307,
-0.0526301414,
0.0069190776,
0.0040200595,
-0.0352868624,
0.022636272,
-0.0152065223,
0.0413021185,
0.0146123879,
-0.0172902141,
-0.029066639,
-0.0061499607,
-0.0139280856,
-0.0441397056,
0.0269863512,
-0.0266612042,
0.0216644462,
-0.0612478182,
-0.0294783525,
0.0169082619,
-0.0399639569,
-0.0006797835,
2.885122085e-34,
0.0470188372,
-0.0125093302,
0.0313799381,
0.0231432244,
0.0627473146,
0.0174082927,
-0.0336469375,
0.0220484696,
0.0271532536,
-0.0143193388,
-0.0173410196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03884v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03884v1 | Zero-Shot Audio Captioning via Audibility Guidance | 2023-09-07T17:45:58 | 2023-09-07T17:45:58 | Tal Shaharabany, Ariel Shaulov, Lior Wolf | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | The task of audio captioning is similar in essence to tasks such as image and
video captioning. However, it has received much less attention. We propose
three desiderata for captioning audio -- (i) fluency of the generated text,
(ii) faithfulness of the generated text to the input audio, and the somewhat
related (iii) audibility, which is the quality of being able to be perceived
based only on audio. Our method is a zero-shot method, i.e., we do not learn to
perform captioning. Instead, captioning occurs as an inference process that
involves three networks that correspond to the three desired qualities: (i) A
Large Language Model, in our case, for reasons of convenience, GPT-2, (ii) A
model that provides a matching score between an audio file and a text, for
which we use a multimodal matching network called ImageBind, and (iii) A text
classifier, trained using a dataset we collected automatically by instructing
GPT-4 with prompts designed to direct the generation of both audible and
inaudible sentences. We present our results on the AudioCap dataset,
demonstrating that audibility guidance significantly enhances performance
compared to the baseline, which lacks this objective. | [
-0.0103083393,
0.0429009758,
0.0089647798,
0.0204223525,
-0.0091545116,
-0.0096341427,
0.0348351188,
-0.0336318947,
-0.0367899984,
-0.0393445119,
-0.0672384128,
0.002762456,
0.0328991637,
0.0373815894,
0.0239162724,
-0.0578737557,
0.0042197206,
-0.0342232473,
-0.0090244487,
0.0013394167,
0.0110311955,
0.0364156514,
-0.0588003397,
0.0378981829,
-0.0101682404,
0.0064610341,
-0.0060920068,
0.0393808074,
0.010681022,
-0.016848309,
-0.0378827564,
0.0529718213,
0.0431565791,
0.0439515561,
0.0000015018,
-0.0010471587,
0.0022466066,
0.0075968564,
0.0337178074,
-0.0193297956,
0.0362012312,
-0.0550427958,
-0.0400146991,
0.0160725582,
-0.0029151009,
-0.0241408441,
0.0811435655,
0.0439768992,
0.0503447503,
0.0325383879,
-0.0286016334,
-0.0604152009,
-0.0115648089,
-0.0287430938,
0.0208727177,
-0.0204570275,
-0.037809331,
0.0346243195,
0.0195983872,
-0.0082690297,
-0.0255068075,
0.0666041598,
-0.0142177977,
-0.0105135059,
0.0119700767,
0.0762175843,
-0.0496176332,
-0.0257059634,
-0.0130217336,
0.1133972853,
0.0435143933,
0.0065888357,
-0.0152422301,
0.0272443704,
-0.0101691158,
-0.0353448913,
-0.0284069665,
0.0412750579,
0.025261255,
0.0266287569,
-0.0611468107,
0.0521472842,
0.0283336286,
-0.0306236055,
0.0186756011,
-0.0290878769,
0.017182814,
0.007981875,
0.0093861157,
-0.024460597,
-0.0596724711,
-0.0366926566,
0.016182743,
0.0034948543,
0.017052453,
-0.0338392109,
-0.0527623557,
-0.0174017046,
-0.0243277308,
0.0078679677,
0.0151356841,
0.0212734714,
-0.0459398292,
0.0778967813,
-0.0238985959,
0.0121320188,
0.0284768008,
-0.0028476948,
-0.0274099968,
0.004336149,
-0.051431857,
-0.0161275491,
-0.0489229076,
0.0181434043,
-0.0159629211,
-0.0673697442,
-0.0420750044,
-0.0566349886,
-0.0563149489,
0.048164729,
-0.0229434334,
0.0329535753,
-0.0375563838,
-0.0067151119,
0.0169726647,
0.0581860766,
-0.000168819,
0.067848444,
-0.0312820263,
-0.0155080892,
-0.0250814855,
0.0434337705,
0.0384134166,
0.0097670555,
0.0268782284,
0.0889748335,
-0.0259690527,
-0.0172744878,
-0.0076449872,
-0.0270769149,
-0.0594575964,
-0.0303149838,
-0.0322075449,
-0.0500036702,
0.0331202187,
-0.0308669489,
-0.0104397573,
-0.0270346869,
-0.0055596237,
0.0219623074,
0.0270332005,
0.1068867296,
-0.0064829499,
0.0178129338,
0.0200703759,
0.0215769242,
-0.0153467767,
0.0411892422,
0.0731350183,
0.0046462207,
0.0081520434,
-0.0082800537,
0.040274743,
0.0533668026,
0.0177156851,
0.0001036026,
-0.0212406591,
-0.0548405275,
-0.0181309786,
0.0331440158,
0.0812576562,
0.0268015768,
-0.0145412544,
-0.0090146232,
0.0815076679,
0.0320361145,
-0.0070255799,
0.0035392419,
0.0522983894,
-0.0009869777,
-0.0310794618,
0.0224139374,
0.0185489114,
0.0560313277,
0.0095889159,
0.0273533892,
0.0360274911,
-0.0318607837,
-0.045570042,
-0.0198002141,
0.0035208953,
-0.0336512104,
-0.0144322263,
-0.0164992735,
0.0145816896,
0.0201107301,
-0.070435442,
0.0182733238,
-0.0285761151,
-0.046800863,
-0.0105114216,
-0.0241887327,
0.0214105956,
0.0315621942,
0.0296092816,
-0.017558299,
0.0034806458,
-0.0299919154,
0.0319784805,
0.0566980019,
0.0165485479,
-0.0106629487,
0.0351826027,
-0.0566912815,
-0.0185473785,
0.0073097306,
0.0107827755,
0.042001456,
-0.0422424041,
0.0306715611,
0.0334174894,
-0.0018527398,
-0.0187961981,
0.0020998875,
0.0278084669,
-0.0676329732,
0.0097307125,
0.0299861915,
0.0218070131,
0.0397263467,
-0.0581997447,
0.0035248594,
-0.0097848494,
-0.0003072423,
-0.00360201,
0.0660215691,
-0.0629663244,
-0.031427063,
0.0136060705,
-0.0846177936,
0.0130028026,
0.0108135352,
-0.0057495702,
-0.0644514337,
0.0523931421,
-0.0141532123,
-0.0093982201,
-0.0667012706,
-0.0087026889,
0.0136585599,
-0.0052250018,
0.0245040096,
-0.0001261911,
0.0402660258,
-0.022187816,
0.0275701173,
-0.0177383181,
0.0020557428,
-0.0542647168,
-0.0631441921,
0.0272359084,
0.0091015995,
0.0260990951,
-0.0138787068,
0.0134824486,
-0.0356265381,
-0.0012808975,
-0.0864973441,
0.0060308599,
-0.0071536768,
-0.0203070994,
0.0004813734,
-0.0248424616,
0.0206427891,
-0.0396642201,
-0.0332707539,
-0.0150634665,
0.0293238554,
-0.0156180691,
-0.0200117864,
0.0132080717,
-0.0462232903,
-0.0152201476,
0.0221541654,
0.0103239566,
0.0098310895,
0.0080070896,
-0.0183529519,
-0.0047579273,
0.0190429483,
-0.0082188593,
0.006936295,
0.0102964276,
-0.0094747879,
0.004710299,
0.0216975752,
-0.0013187107,
0.010773072,
-0.0303335767,
0.0061634751,
0.037851382,
0.0298706945,
-0.0178059097,
-0.0026031693,
0.0288797058,
-0.0294016916,
0.007515585,
-0.0015708501,
-0.0416243188,
0.0314496048,
0.0517774113,
0.0356564485,
-0.0479569137,
0.0201436039,
-0.0228548106,
-0.0187174194,
-0.0434892625,
-0.0080790482,
-0.0116425818,
0.0233715363,
-0.031193478,
-0.0459856577,
0.0398330428,
-0.0658128113,
-0.0779801235,
-0.0075462842,
-0.0324895531,
0.0008613234,
0.0455270037,
-0.007279281,
0.0343309306,
0.0136628281,
-0.0392079391,
-0.0178524721,
-0.0198703595,
0.0307615977,
-0.0277841371,
0.032464698,
-0.0357177705,
-0.0096545042,
-0.0300393645,
-0.0162168369,
-0.0076895268,
-0.017190557,
-0.0514215678,
0.0324351862,
-0.0641128123,
-0.0014438315,
-0.0480958335,
0.0476851352,
0.0523144007,
0.0627850443,
-0.0076093213,
0.010075653,
-0.0335573256,
0.057484515,
0.0268295705,
0.0316849574,
-0.0706535056,
-0.0217694752,
0.0476560555,
0.0076660947,
0.0024925265,
0.043251913,
-0.0562493764,
0.0179247763,
0.0211860016,
0.0277203862,
-0.0044889823,
0.0349685326,
0.0371641144,
-0.0240981951,
0.0076989438,
0.1108958572,
0.0038069859,
-0.0266422182,
-0.0128807435,
0.0390191786,
0.0145071698,
0.0147013199,
-0.0198038537,
-0.0776031464,
-0.07507734,
0.0088420277,
0.048353076,
0.0458012745,
0.0427717008,
-0.0358308554,
-0.0676659122,
0.0543502122,
0.0454461128,
-0.065958716,
-0.0556394868,
-0.0091852024,
-0.0073669627,
-0.0267369505,
0.0062555033,
-0.0130069461,
0.0091887992,
0.0070453961,
0.0236848537,
0.0101239923,
-0.0530046076,
0.0073164632,
-0.0453490652,
0.0978356004,
0.0786940828,
0.0343046747,
-0.0394279249,
-0.0064798654,
-0.0086076511,
0.002622966,
-0.0115187094,
0.0136756776,
0.0789454728,
-0.0277903564,
-0.0146518229,
0.0320513137,
0.046896901,
-0.0031079343,
0.0060958797,
0.0355799161,
0.0136859929,
0.0098438766,
0.0027080334,
-0.0208607484,
0.0944665894,
0.0157892797,
0.091462113,
0.0404932275,
-0.0129667381,
0.0045702225,
-0.0082052564,
0.0041913316,
-0.0971357971,
-0.0217348617,
0.0107913716,
0.016911298,
-0.0339925401,
-0.0441494919,
-0.004036013,
0.0362587422,
0.0216123238,
0.0553004779,
-0.0185738951,
-0.0063751084,
0.0291767288,
-0.0225762613,
0.018121453,
-0.0321500823,
0.0349724814,
-0.0345410928,
-0.0209617503,
0.0584412515,
-0.0508342385,
-0.0154123828,
0.0518511981,
-0.0211116932,
-0.0233020745,
-0.0458826721,
-0.0117027834,
0.0233129486,
0.0349614099,
0.0031470717,
-0.0295450483,
0.0227577165,
0.0531631298,
0.0136832483,
0.0275335237,
0.0427576751,
0.008566713,
-0.0250972994,
0.015287295,
-0.0335906371,
0.0643859282,
-0.0224954784,
0.0220864881,
-0.0000496983,
-0.0413697287,
-0.0268283747,
-0.0069430526,
-0.002823987,
-0.0336420871,
0.0493066795,
-0.0531254523,
-0.0212049186,
-0.0076994929,
0.0159816276,
-0.0592421368,
0.0185093898,
0.0375826471,
0.0483048297,
-0.0365692005,
-0.0256620403,
-0.039752204,
0.0252240989,
-0.0168372579,
0.016748447,
0.0607098006,
-0.0538573004,
-0.0309222601,
-0.0041272538,
-0.0094705261,
0.0064879926,
-0.0000772019,
0.0246383306,
0.0017512238,
0.0251682978,
-0.0024355794,
-0.015675256,
0.0035069233,
0.0386797972,
-0.0173666608,
0.0586647764,
-0.0196735431,
0.0647107884,
0.0674969032,
-0.0167577285,
0.0239105895,
0.003630321,
0.0129688876,
-0.0068743988,
0.0462642312,
-0.009921914,
-0.0428932272,
0.0373621993,
0.0041129314,
0.0106717199,
0.0205838755,
0.0457458496,
-0.0202966724,
0.0103023732,
-0.0144758038,
-0.015006463,
-0.0282177366,
-0.0080474885,
-0.0293486603,
0.0187751763,
-0.0191185325,
0.0202008374,
-0.0087090945,
-0.0754059032,
0.004081239,
0.0112302378,
0.0116009591,
0.0016830837,
0.0355533846,
-0.0214816313,
0.0016661818,
0.0142446626,
0.0179342087,
-0.0308543593,
-0.0346637182,
0.0081220623,
-0.0281327907,
-4.42655871e-33,
-0.047184974,
-0.047527723,
-0.0217839088,
-0.017518675,
-0.0335431062,
0.0116952918,
-0.05799805,
0.013424485,
0.0135743208,
0.0111996988,
0.0513484515,
-0.0249796491,
0.0244118385,
0.0159442704,
-0.0041045491,
-0.0267662778,
0.0611690842,
-0.0442617983,
-0.0242657028,
0.0281276386,
0.0298782717,
-0.0059883413,
0.0076193335,
-0.0432831533,
0.0061391955,
-0.021637179,
-0.0602129214,
-0.0098703289,
0.0482256748,
0.0521950722,
-0.0052049444,
0.0391678847,
-0.0182363112,
-0.0112956893,
0.0032628018,
0.0346260145,
-0.0651861951,
0.0145763559,
0.022519039,
0.0429576449,
-0.008774356,
-0.0203211494,
0.0146468077,
-0.023073284,
-0.020168148,
-0.0421029776,
0.0635549203,
-0.0174580831,
0.0005006993,
-0.0319649391,
-0.0671797171,
0.0017169793,
-0.0371532179,
-0.0726654977,
0.058895506,
0.079645887,
0.0064017563,
0.0116445823,
-0.0570269898,
0.050730437,
-0.0131882047,
0.0183324702,
0.0683083832,
0.0299495701,
-0.0464598089,
0.0527910776,
0.0014968778,
-0.075441882,
-0.044222232,
0.0070057525,
0.0192268435,
0.0130961062,
0.041227825,
0.0298914742,
0.0536915921,
-0.0058313846,
-0.024951661,
0.0196996927,
-0.0633310452,
-0.016824754,
0.038919393,
0.0227267165,
-0.0362894274,
0.0232190341,
-0.0739132166,
-0.0367541537,
-0.0586998686,
-0.0233133771,
0.0421804935,
-0.0114954794,
0.0083065685,
0.0070909229,
0.0642899126,
-0.0290816575,
0.0240964238,
-0.0170241743,
-0.0337507315,
0.0311607383,
-0.0148631725,
-0.0039686267,
0.0032232606,
-0.0072123818,
0.105050832,
0.0638147071,
0.060182903,
-0.0033453179,
0.0543804131,
0.0526184402,
-0.0251611788,
-0.0214473177,
-0.0139886355,
0.0020159294,
-0.0259903781,
0.0312000625,
-0.0037191708,
0.0196356717,
-0.0516623594,
-0.0217610952,
-0.0462244153,
0.0021582483,
-0.0115557555,
-0.032280907,
-0.0548887178,
0.004160766,
-0.0639829114,
0.0490466058,
0.0268927775,
-0.024505591,
0.0098493239,
-0.0426090062,
-0.0425649397,
0.0417892709,
2.264e-7,
-0.0343818143,
-0.0364004113,
0.0251525249,
-0.0068739308,
0.0460104644,
0.0412572622,
-0.0512420051,
0.0324931517,
0.0081802588,
-0.0096086403,
0.0641714931,
0.0033582975,
0.094210282,
-0.0122421905,
-0.0951619223,
-0.013204189,
-0.0420626141,
0.0361817069,
-0.0236908309,
0.0078501366,
0.097453095,
0.0642078891,
-0.023613777,
-0.0299665928,
0.0472371802,
-0.0517298989,
0.0392669402,
-0.0010038479,
0.031309709,
-0.0607990772,
0.0506773591,
0.0300536659,
-0.0570815355,
0.0203527734,
-0.0419724733,
-0.0183524154,
0.0668229088,
0.0480226465,
-0.0035198992,
-0.045652438,
-0.0432255566,
0.0807121173,
0.0032934467,
0.0157480966,
0.0824611858,
-0.0455802344,
-0.0433084741,
0.0006313382,
-0.0310404245,
-0.0186486635,
0.0022020002,
-0.0249711704,
-0.0445034131,
-0.0074787624,
0.0626394302,
-0.0060472684,
-0.0520224459,
-0.0365406498,
-0.0093473783,
-0.0010763804,
-0.0393920466,
-0.0210372861,
-0.0301359035,
-0.0334280059,
0.0319158845,
-0.0769818425,
-0.0125248572,
1.29232965e-34,
0.0374013558,
-0.059577696,
0.0228966847,
-0.0411746986,
-0.0046392782,
0.0302529987,
0.0229381267,
-0.0337778889,
0.0107874963,
-0.0415347256,
-0.0457452647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03883v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03883v2 | DoLa: Decoding by Contrasting Layers Improves Factuality in Large Language Models | 2023-09-07T17:45:31 | 2024-03-11T02:01:09 | Yung-Sung Chuang, Yujia Xie, Hongyin Luo, Yoon Kim, James Glass, Pengcheng He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Despite their impressive capabilities, large language models (LLMs) are prone
to hallucinations, i.e., generating content that deviates from facts seen
during pretraining. We propose a simple decoding strategy for reducing
hallucinations with pretrained LLMs that does not require conditioning on
retrieved external knowledge nor additional fine-tuning. Our approach obtains
the next-token distribution by contrasting the differences in logits obtained
from projecting the later layers versus earlier layers to the vocabulary space,
exploiting the fact that factual knowledge in an LLMs has generally been shown
to be localized to particular transformer layers. We find that this Decoding by
Contrasting Layers (DoLa) approach is able to better surface factual knowledge
and reduce the generation of incorrect facts. DoLa consistently improves the
truthfulness across multiple choices tasks and open-ended generation tasks, for
example improving the performance of LLaMA family models on TruthfulQA by
12-17% absolute points, demonstrating its potential in making LLMs reliably
generate truthful facts. | [
0.0066907224,
0.0739781633,
-0.0089975381,
0.048370447,
-0.0257817339,
0.0189691018,
-0.0217096098,
-0.0242928509,
-0.049345579,
-0.01261253,
-0.0335291252,
-0.0399730243,
0.011916399,
0.0087758368,
0.0211884137,
-0.0041449666,
0.0537216142,
-0.0367249809,
-0.0186331179,
-0.0227709301,
-0.0259059258,
0.0223353039,
-0.0142486366,
0.0377464406,
-0.0298998728,
-0.0319094434,
-0.017607158,
-0.0196858849,
0.0219361521,
-0.0001718237,
-0.0117931971,
0.0278297868,
-0.0246193465,
0.0657947958,
0.0000021062,
-0.0075683794,
0.0067561022,
-0.0167987067,
-0.0752502829,
0.037219882,
0.0180649757,
-0.0114669502,
-0.0021463777,
0.0118903155,
-0.0330609269,
-0.0465910658,
0.0571280234,
0.0897636265,
0.0503675789,
0.0801711008,
0.0067101568,
-0.0508207083,
0.0392342471,
-0.002716155,
-0.0060932613,
-0.0048913304,
0.0188354533,
0.0024872287,
-0.0341905393,
-0.0104477908,
-0.0193300713,
0.0348561034,
0.0488257445,
0.0239214916,
0.0109464498,
0.0713767782,
-0.0167767219,
-0.0598058738,
0.0242897179,
0.0590003207,
-0.0217988621,
-0.0467269458,
-0.0163734108,
-0.0194534585,
-0.0100723179,
-0.0173816923,
0.0059318319,
0.0573718473,
-0.0356453061,
0.0606764294,
0.0558593944,
0.0147745321,
0.0430170558,
-0.0017137607,
-0.0596492179,
0.0696642771,
0.0087579694,
-0.0346032567,
0.0139633948,
0.0397030376,
0.0334342159,
-0.0497615002,
0.0128733991,
-0.0004801053,
-0.0357841514,
0.0215438306,
-0.0419708043,
0.0088510364,
0.0239949729,
-0.0718455389,
0.0363529734,
0.0377268083,
-0.0755065382,
0.0119386297,
-0.0286816712,
0.0444758981,
-0.0350524262,
0.0668778569,
-0.0505265333,
-0.025424527,
0.0242376048,
-0.0012849235,
-0.0314428061,
0.0275996123,
-0.0497356169,
-0.0078739533,
-0.0128437607,
0.0030408201,
-0.004395986,
0.005964343,
0.0146880522,
0.0072011664,
-0.0362085514,
-0.0364859663,
-0.0252864882,
0.0581670254,
-0.0127056362,
0.0341762826,
0.0326512828,
-0.0715669841,
-0.0280901212,
0.016074406,
-0.0172434356,
-0.004913758,
-0.0147594828,
0.0167481154,
-0.0281666685,
-0.0182698276,
-0.0704350099,
-0.0019807192,
-0.0162972584,
-0.0854507759,
0.0182788726,
-0.0485920832,
0.0225180089,
-0.0066178469,
-0.0020981785,
-0.0293325596,
0.0136141069,
0.0091921957,
-0.0115310857,
0.0696058422,
-0.0031227404,
-0.0116024865,
0.0350824334,
0.0252603833,
-0.0153040932,
0.0797189847,
0.0020977675,
0.056364987,
0.0124022337,
0.0107597755,
0.0189108234,
0.0118771596,
0.0467859693,
-0.0045604394,
-0.0167095754,
-0.0214367714,
0.0171313491,
0.034995608,
0.0741449818,
0.0541084446,
-0.0557080172,
-0.0421751104,
0.0905441418,
-0.0279540271,
0.0293920208,
0.0247080792,
0.0358589478,
0.0001865984,
0.0249560624,
0.0648887679,
-0.0588470958,
0.0521331578,
0.0033255655,
0.0218351837,
0.0370981619,
0.0691149384,
-0.0379895493,
-0.0476833582,
-0.0062508541,
-0.0257911384,
-0.0103931976,
0.0119896885,
0.0123739755,
0.031902995,
-0.0528775342,
0.1085773483,
0.0434448048,
-0.0157806426,
0.0222219136,
-0.0714383274,
0.0343324132,
0.0374136642,
0.0254750233,
0.0165426135,
-0.0376649015,
0.0114429453,
-0.0070582363,
0.0767942742,
0.031790033,
0.0021994782,
0.0434228182,
-0.0506549142,
0.00770457,
-0.0090640383,
0.0409107506,
0.013973048,
-0.0074541089,
-0.0092114229,
0.0017444713,
-0.0462215915,
-0.0023945358,
0.0447848514,
-0.0393704809,
-0.0328172557,
0.0082240012,
-0.0017182935,
0.0153353671,
0.002021871,
-0.0176016726,
0.0327767022,
0.0185655188,
-0.0371628888,
-0.047155235,
0.0072353012,
-0.0880118459,
-0.0380552374,
0.0230626948,
-0.0076353163,
0.0149906464,
0.0434417687,
-0.0303932056,
-0.0235935859,
0.001800716,
-0.0436977334,
0.0557494909,
-0.0622232556,
0.008260523,
0.03491823,
0.0386459231,
0.0075431592,
0.0757554471,
-0.0489074998,
-0.0164077729,
0.0052379984,
-0.0107290996,
-0.0061040232,
0.001325078,
0.0122895604,
0.0298261717,
-0.0006941193,
0.0328426398,
-0.0202872548,
-0.0064648078,
-0.0303747877,
-0.0313106589,
-0.0567740165,
-0.0104012201,
-0.0321779065,
-0.0152986301,
0.0309931133,
-0.0148413638,
-0.0018166912,
0.0006095896,
-0.0424017645,
0.0085176909,
0.0087690717,
0.0084130941,
0.0244702622,
0.0090048416,
0.0010338573,
-0.0073725744,
0.0012796926,
0.0236487333,
0.0416087285,
-0.0348867811,
-0.0163159594,
-0.0794636235,
0.0114597585,
-0.0341195166,
0.0256706048,
-0.0037249946,
-0.0368366577,
0.0039782687,
0.0109037952,
0.0425427444,
0.0606089868,
0.0210135765,
0.0332551524,
0.0802504793,
0.0018362314,
-0.0297594443,
0.0055781156,
-0.0395842418,
-0.0061404821,
-0.0391000696,
-0.056497734,
0.0037041106,
0.0715089962,
0.043053899,
-0.0118104098,
-0.07054919,
0.0005307701,
-0.0379814468,
-0.0533427857,
0.0403683856,
-0.006735669,
-0.0333054289,
0.0483022891,
-0.0152904,
-0.0210045129,
0.0678034872,
-0.0591729507,
0.0067484011,
-0.0444029011,
-0.0043405066,
0.0050862068,
0.0027976844,
-0.0100829238,
0.0178905837,
0.0024383524,
-0.0292302109,
-0.0404586643,
-0.002563928,
-0.0039603035,
-0.0582416952,
0.0542307384,
-0.0358395837,
-0.0132685378,
0.0024588606,
-0.057513196,
-0.0843944699,
-0.0344968773,
0.0029653388,
-0.0116148386,
-0.0283321626,
0.006388579,
-0.0516213365,
-0.0560439937,
0.0179154668,
0.058193177,
-0.0123492097,
-0.0006011025,
-0.0173000116,
0.0297015626,
0.0497023538,
0.0350365117,
0.0870333314,
-0.0164587554,
0.0101818191,
0.0841800943,
0.0031630306,
0.0322827213,
-0.0187567137,
-0.0212270189,
0.0201744456,
-0.0054878714,
-0.0084810415,
0.0059095602,
0.0414309539,
-0.0325887054,
-0.0474447571,
0.1034247205,
0.0165935773,
-0.0195640773,
0.0151351029,
-0.0243283138,
0.0084928023,
-0.0018787003,
0.0126806777,
-0.0930649415,
-0.0041760509,
0.0007124411,
0.0095677022,
-0.0050894595,
-0.007329978,
-0.0028042167,
-0.1210483983,
0.0235556811,
0.0140749458,
0.0059172795,
-0.0539726987,
-0.0265804324,
-0.0351968035,
0.0091946181,
0.0499330983,
0.0236853808,
0.0354770049,
-0.0132271722,
0.0244372096,
0.0306554195,
-0.0383285433,
0.0337830745,
-0.0216023549,
0.0700287297,
0.0389976911,
0.0204517115,
-0.0078125186,
-0.0844285116,
-0.0037783503,
-0.0202169586,
-0.0218679849,
0.0143038938,
0.0080531128,
-0.0058674412,
-0.0111860707,
0.0033830667,
0.0189787559,
0.0046149557,
-0.0244960021,
-0.0386134237,
0.0420955867,
-0.0323051363,
-0.0611133426,
0.0067747626,
0.0288800541,
-0.0029001853,
0.0837893337,
0.0398130268,
-0.015293722,
-0.0091613494,
-0.0247900896,
0.0468022451,
-0.0381962769,
-0.0094561614,
0.0827257857,
0.0456309468,
-0.0286845379,
-0.0779735744,
-0.0207992792,
-0.0214729011,
0.0463168286,
-0.0312185492,
-0.0184312612,
0.0475344807,
-0.0400792621,
-0.0060393554,
-0.0078053721,
-0.0502896346,
-0.0074306247,
-0.0114061628,
0.0033227345,
0.0391628556,
-0.0474055558,
-0.0089581497,
-0.0049135122,
-0.0815944299,
-0.0559685566,
0.0450065024,
0.0259034634,
0.0267657842,
0.0828988031,
-0.0194296092,
-0.0474787764,
0.0584340319,
0.0218800232,
-0.0548125319,
0.0394009054,
0.0353808999,
-0.0244237073,
0.0143477377,
0.0467461534,
-0.0288281068,
0.0181504413,
0.0075885803,
0.0440956801,
0.0014234096,
-0.0115421144,
0.0521486774,
-0.00869649,
0.0524198711,
-0.0252960213,
0.0057034814,
-0.0471366495,
0.0315564498,
-0.0285730921,
0.0041889832,
-0.0306306165,
0.0118462481,
0.0467431396,
0.0052874265,
0.0117516024,
-0.0368457139,
-0.0216140989,
0.0452536233,
-0.018528996,
-0.0413038619,
0.0128099779,
-0.000270358,
0.0356428325,
-0.0140671805,
-0.069632329,
0.0069978824,
0.0180891324,
0.0416229703,
-0.0183426142,
0.052480612,
0.0184847061,
-0.0099178366,
-0.03995011,
0.0079495907,
-0.0442470089,
-0.0310673732,
-0.0374501571,
0.0295814406,
0.0404555462,
0.0314830802,
0.038059026,
-0.045122847,
-0.0059822258,
-0.0053683952,
0.0267406609,
0.0159073304,
-0.0320620649,
0.0279851351,
-0.0166238602,
-0.0238410383,
-0.034795139,
0.073238872,
0.008074726,
0.0470634922,
-0.0206992608,
0.0126156891,
-0.0363848805,
-0.0790311471,
-0.0302673839,
0.0004312866,
-0.0483625419,
-0.0006213863,
-0.0702058077,
-0.0774378181,
0.0130565148,
0.0165914502,
0.0128365317,
-0.041222278,
-0.00160463,
0.0626578853,
0.0014612089,
-0.0431962311,
-0.0186101552,
0.0111777335,
0.0580975711,
0.0127862757,
0.0042170249,
-7.389787113e-33,
-0.0240495987,
-0.0027598606,
0.0456498116,
-0.0468889326,
-0.0311888848,
0.0273036677,
0.0048075453,
-0.0040674163,
-0.0445668884,
0.0363365225,
-0.0069386563,
0.0316533186,
0.0293420088,
0.0469536409,
-0.0228889529,
-0.023530636,
0.0697893798,
-0.0106337015,
-0.0320303068,
0.0424884744,
0.0107953222,
-0.0006919101,
0.0659993887,
-0.0143518904,
0.0114470981,
0.0034322839,
-0.026611425,
0.0239111353,
-0.0448312908,
0.0478067696,
-0.0691617876,
0.034802068,
0.0176724829,
-0.0642785132,
-0.0229877234,
-0.0213720091,
-0.0713541582,
-0.0199340153,
0.0502953827,
0.0325127728,
-0.0206484813,
-0.0170801785,
0.0223992541,
-0.0016120558,
-0.0143268863,
-0.0280462522,
-0.0133585604,
-0.0156279597,
-0.0343857072,
-0.0072783465,
-0.0607098602,
-0.0023623474,
0.0492680632,
-0.0052358583,
-0.0116174789,
0.0100191915,
-0.0199748017,
-0.0037814029,
-0.1070649996,
-0.0026636566,
0.0137716644,
0.0012878934,
0.0644056723,
0.0096438723,
-0.0219275132,
0.0636649057,
0.0447528288,
-0.0312457979,
-0.0839231312,
-0.0005624209,
0.0372663662,
0.0201664902,
0.0176758897,
0.0395645611,
0.0242411625,
-0.0442336649,
-0.0668778941,
-0.0169387683,
-0.0113707902,
0.0110943234,
0.0613679253,
-0.0060374197,
-0.0195690021,
-0.0255389847,
-0.0442482121,
0.0193948168,
-0.0346613787,
0.0150265908,
0.027346557,
0.0372790471,
-0.01426592,
-0.0327274613,
0.0374947563,
-0.0321652368,
0.0187043343,
0.0346112922,
-0.0203044824,
0.0076187453,
-0.0281323101,
0.0155894123,
-0.0366206355,
-0.0019369425,
0.0120626185,
0.011924684,
-0.0012191798,
0.0298427138,
0.0402300134,
0.017906012,
-0.0593185797,
0.028164329,
-0.0532031395,
0.0167438164,
0.0379840098,
0.012879936,
0.0579903051,
0.003684931,
-0.0330057591,
0.0003601627,
-0.0025335494,
0.0473288894,
-0.0151381455,
-0.0020027342,
0.0304691475,
0.054028973,
-0.037440978,
-0.002032961,
-0.0512447506,
-0.0235014763,
0.0260839034,
-0.0613043346,
-0.0208046883,
0.0341677926,
2.762e-7,
0.0046363003,
0.0228202995,
0.0400565155,
0.0338759646,
0.0102567291,
0.0350493938,
0.0138946595,
0.0364161544,
0.0073132287,
-0.0507903211,
-0.027176477,
0.0294444207,
0.0591814741,
0.0595013946,
-0.0754869059,
-0.015263767,
-0.0416833013,
-0.0066404752,
-0.0572518185,
-0.034621425,
0.0541952848,
0.1074483097,
0.0094920956,
-0.0266641937,
0.0386224501,
-0.0237281788,
0.0570758097,
0.0213262625,
-0.0075600836,
-0.001753404,
0.0533690527,
0.0090739466,
0.0230611581,
0.0079162512,
-0.0057992726,
-0.0152665265,
-0.0183471832,
0.049772758,
0.015597227,
-0.0683425739,
-0.0192452148,
-0.0097881621,
-0.0020666812,
-0.0746655241,
0.0572280362,
-0.0469944887,
-0.0255604871,
-0.0415604338,
-0.0302649532,
0.0215483978,
0.0121949622,
-0.0386707224,
-0.0136334803,
0.0282314084,
0.0088962363,
0.0417327732,
-0.0146037089,
-0.0561893061,
-0.0367900878,
-0.0059344736,
-0.0463815928,
-0.0452082269,
-0.007239888,
-0.0153071703,
0.0528267138,
-0.0455772541,
0.0378712527,
2.61138894e-34,
0.0266114231,
-0.0059237587,
0.0255512409,
0.0248052403,
0.0048183389,
-0.0117191011,
0.0114394631,
0.0062631271,
-0.0128721455,
-0.0581840016,
-0.0191162117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03882v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03882v4 | Large Language Models Are Not Robust Multiple Choice Selectors | 2023-09-07T17:44:56 | 2024-02-22T01:40:35 | Chujie Zheng, Hao Zhou, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multiple choice questions (MCQs) serve as a common yet important task format
in the evaluation of large language models (LLMs). This work shows that modern
LLMs are vulnerable to option position changes in MCQs due to their inherent
"selection bias", namely, they prefer to select specific option IDs as answers
(like "Option A"). Through extensive empirical analyses with 20 LLMs on three
benchmarks, we pinpoint that this behavioral bias primarily stems from LLMs'
token bias, where the model a priori assigns more probabilistic mass to
specific option ID tokens (e.g., A/B/C/D) when predicting answers from the
option IDs. To mitigate selection bias, we propose a label-free, inference-time
debiasing method, called PriDe, which separates the model's prior bias for
option IDs from the overall prediction distribution. PriDe first estimates the
prior by permutating option contents on a small number of test samples, and
then applies the estimated prior to debias the remaining samples. We
demonstrate that it achieves interpretable and transferable debiasing with high
computational efficiency. We hope this work can draw broader research attention
to the bias and robustness of modern LLMs. | [
0.0110031562,
0.0546901934,
-0.0140159242,
0.0424782149,
-0.0331648774,
0.0109542813,
0.036326319,
-0.001297489,
0.0351137109,
-0.0577668957,
-0.0031362399,
-0.0248789415,
-0.0230339412,
-0.0164906345,
0.0334257744,
-0.0208216403,
0.0261982754,
-0.0587550923,
0.0212570131,
-0.0495752431,
-0.0187651683,
0.0094567938,
-0.0131130405,
0.02269415,
0.0421977304,
-0.0297042932,
-0.0089621879,
-0.0028994223,
-0.0033794476,
-0.03257576,
0.0102555482,
0.0912694782,
-0.0076585021,
0.0194919053,
0.0000021157,
-0.0620780066,
-0.0201080218,
-0.0311792027,
-0.0581587963,
0.0224263091,
0.0173539799,
0.0728415251,
0.0317264237,
0.0361752287,
-0.0055132844,
-0.0142275663,
0.0574429706,
-0.0047538569,
0.0060336059,
0.0263865162,
0.0189347379,
0.0220095851,
-0.0187333319,
-0.0209960714,
0.0165325049,
-0.0279316846,
0.0404629894,
-0.031108344,
-0.009275388,
0.0414252877,
-0.0504327007,
-0.001915204,
0.0001241193,
0.0098588411,
-0.0240280516,
0.0300288126,
-0.0089946482,
-0.0033507631,
0.0004468244,
0.0555944592,
-0.0287021752,
-0.0210974831,
-0.0111954492,
-0.037358731,
0.0298154373,
0.0445481278,
-0.0607590377,
0.0117348395,
0.0111242374,
-0.0085825995,
0.0360939801,
-0.0309799425,
0.0282991529,
0.0432523713,
-0.0189147405,
0.1009953544,
0.0408767536,
-0.0117409686,
0.0312301069,
0.0395146757,
-0.0195382256,
-0.0704472214,
0.0121577289,
-0.0061244825,
-0.0596880615,
0.0420965701,
-0.012325827,
-0.0164064262,
0.0176480766,
-0.0229710937,
0.0089752926,
0.0123523949,
-0.029301323,
0.0330793373,
-0.002093066,
0.0541042089,
0.0134053417,
0.037667416,
-0.0533948168,
-0.0062990901,
0.0070287399,
0.0062195277,
0.0049669179,
0.0321603008,
-0.0331804492,
0.0110848164,
-0.0484281592,
0.0185990762,
0.0004620539,
-0.0011592491,
0.0050611016,
0.0136801945,
-0.0176531635,
0.0055930307,
-0.0397762321,
0.0778118894,
-0.0230926182,
0.0152660161,
0.033836294,
-0.0713713393,
-0.0149103506,
0.005706049,
-0.0016318447,
-0.0747754723,
0.0091962898,
0.0971608311,
0.0030453959,
-0.0227545407,
0.0222168528,
-0.0247560516,
-0.0484073907,
-0.0443734266,
0.0048498064,
-0.0812422857,
0.0085639609,
0.0510245897,
0.0144696208,
-0.0433427691,
0.0109371524,
0.0318038426,
-0.0202693343,
0.0384956896,
0.0356900431,
0.0096825324,
0.0183468647,
-0.0125811789,
-0.0053968546,
0.0660301596,
-0.0015329024,
0.0248187128,
0.0660623461,
-0.0403645448,
0.0203423724,
0.0614744946,
0.0082784686,
0.0201715436,
-0.0150040435,
0.0274492279,
0.0440070815,
0.0191653296,
0.0241917334,
0.0429046154,
-0.0096663171,
-0.0536301136,
0.0968404338,
0.0423982032,
-0.028959414,
-0.02322465,
0.0163917784,
0.0135009317,
0.0016482656,
0.017688822,
-0.0548870452,
0.0122559145,
-0.0236223731,
0.0077430569,
0.0400126316,
0.0266081933,
0.0012526487,
-0.0386557318,
-0.0060176142,
0.0078239152,
-0.0151718017,
0.0866246149,
0.0430832803,
-0.0462344848,
-0.0325046331,
0.0680534989,
0.0309470017,
-0.0392669998,
0.0000857742,
-0.0486061238,
0.058386445,
0.0106603429,
0.0419399068,
-0.0293612033,
-0.0521424599,
-0.0242580343,
-0.0006777325,
0.0255107414,
0.0833876878,
-0.0358613692,
0.0283110179,
-0.0443898328,
-0.0288913548,
0.0261153933,
0.0164754447,
0.0166821871,
0.0020039207,
0.0011802623,
-0.0137426304,
-0.0500976518,
-0.0390972458,
0.0186808053,
-0.0039636856,
-0.08689522,
0.0250687171,
-0.0127396137,
0.0388723835,
-0.0141413501,
0.0013499039,
0.0048631323,
0.0061619575,
0.0055158115,
0.0109119909,
-0.0386689603,
-0.0573726296,
-0.0517710038,
0.0421800837,
-0.0095819412,
-0.0436624363,
0.0573869795,
-0.0520117693,
-0.0224501584,
-0.0105454102,
-0.0112814642,
-0.0319160745,
-0.005076936,
0.0149312029,
-0.0220792238,
0.0082959244,
-0.077908136,
0.060535688,
0.0011089308,
0.0391893536,
0.0049063959,
0.0168978944,
0.0154290432,
-0.0446413234,
-0.0414430164,
0.0407636352,
0.0010954932,
0.0143809831,
0.0351248682,
-0.0029598186,
-0.0547468476,
-0.0156730898,
-0.1030710414,
0.017432088,
-0.0052193375,
-0.0050596576,
-0.0045163175,
0.0195958689,
-0.0064199823,
-0.0148577392,
-0.0595943108,
-0.0558925755,
-0.005565973,
0.0442003906,
-0.0032704272,
-0.0062770345,
0.015493135,
-0.0394041128,
-0.0327938162,
-0.0332288593,
0.0667027682,
-0.0087836534,
0.0483572558,
-0.0186584983,
0.0050294842,
-0.0331465788,
-0.0129028261,
0.0028626339,
0.0220609624,
0.0035364374,
-0.0231435001,
0.0221355855,
0.0805756375,
0.0207368787,
-0.0060076285,
0.0597516149,
-0.0037858828,
-0.0691680089,
0.000261,
-0.02210702,
-0.0229734834,
-0.0553777516,
-0.0432406962,
-0.0111323353,
0.0740318373,
0.0225988105,
-0.0347016118,
-0.0139610199,
0.025326224,
-0.0371341519,
-0.0173780378,
-0.069650054,
0.0126922298,
-0.0228829663,
0.039635323,
-0.0006542428,
-0.0586537682,
0.0853109807,
-0.0253770947,
0.0120819109,
-0.0742297322,
-0.0016395609,
-0.0260345954,
0.0263718311,
-0.0005997059,
0.0098098516,
0.0252571162,
-0.0065711862,
-0.0942630321,
-0.0207137223,
0.0135044269,
-0.0688078552,
0.0793270767,
-0.0628599375,
-0.0182838067,
0.0000758877,
-0.0508377403,
-0.032367751,
-0.0475351624,
-0.0418280177,
-0.0011727762,
0.0254192967,
-0.002821218,
0.0172588564,
-0.0342783444,
0.0264274478,
0.0105346739,
-0.0434572585,
0.0136846295,
0.0008705048,
0.0662284866,
0.0799596608,
0.0133856628,
0.0508442558,
-0.0454093143,
0.0104028936,
0.045068983,
0.072011739,
0.0284043998,
-0.004143123,
0.0107778963,
0.0524205752,
-0.0469916724,
-0.013578767,
0.0377582051,
0.0771583766,
-0.0284923501,
-0.0076697106,
0.1096974015,
0.0201961324,
-0.0554857589,
0.0144524919,
0.0099718785,
0.0464668684,
0.0153723303,
0.0508017242,
-0.0450074114,
-0.0339492857,
0.0010218794,
0.0199506339,
-0.0096683772,
-0.0329821743,
0.019182438,
-0.1511667818,
0.0107679013,
-0.0133397533,
-0.0167317502,
0.029561542,
-0.0343384296,
0.0128511181,
-0.0272764955,
0.0455018729,
0.0166492052,
0.0032331916,
0.0123791546,
0.0382162072,
-0.0179673545,
-0.028540656,
0.0369366109,
-0.0323736742,
0.0433437675,
0.0267539825,
0.0160514954,
-0.0369102359,
0.0076128836,
0.0530776493,
-0.0498353988,
-0.0375128426,
-0.0233558379,
0.0479450189,
-0.0014629976,
-0.0030036704,
-0.0224100444,
0.0335546099,
0.0053942576,
-0.0026717687,
0.0371348113,
0.0638855472,
0.0025747318,
-0.0351098366,
-0.0030749277,
-0.0321030766,
0.0062024049,
0.067272976,
0.0294008218,
-0.1073685959,
-0.0176225789,
-0.0884593129,
-0.0186625738,
-0.02846702,
-0.0230588913,
0.000073652,
-0.005341053,
-0.0018790708,
-0.0460800231,
-0.0138685042,
0.0494702086,
0.0050651236,
0.0015856402,
0.0394416749,
0.0036830693,
0.0080643864,
0.0041547455,
0.041370362,
-0.0338628516,
0.032451164,
-0.0254126154,
0.0201569796,
0.0019804635,
-0.0229574032,
-0.0298311561,
0.025701277,
-0.0568949208,
-0.0583842546,
0.0011353497,
0.0391850024,
0.0189293902,
0.0146472519,
-0.0139127197,
-0.0737068951,
0.0525924675,
-0.0091577396,
0.0430062376,
0.0124531202,
-0.0063429815,
-0.003086088,
-0.014112575,
0.0238332134,
-0.0460796133,
-0.0018714372,
0.057327155,
0.0291123558,
-0.0171110034,
-0.0391399451,
0.0115400162,
0.0120917391,
0.0483195968,
-0.0077157933,
0.0347671844,
-0.0166967344,
0.0102349296,
-0.0045552109,
-0.0293914694,
0.0048295618,
-0.0151314791,
0.0376266949,
-0.0201511271,
-0.0115364436,
-0.0449322574,
-0.0126995565,
0.0470360704,
-0.0384018794,
0.0357373506,
0.0415601768,
0.0197877716,
0.0575038493,
-0.006530181,
-0.0337064117,
-0.0060774796,
0.0210626572,
0.05413609,
0.0191361457,
0.0574413016,
0.004595432,
-0.0326012857,
0.0353929922,
-0.0236068107,
-0.0527119115,
-0.0421952717,
-0.0211521499,
0.0183564294,
-0.0015697203,
-0.0362568609,
0.0165196918,
0.010071638,
-0.00463492,
-0.0581646152,
0.0014158542,
0.0252696164,
-0.0131915892,
0.043608699,
0.0200729519,
-0.0129858172,
0.0214472041,
0.0798565075,
0.0437608808,
0.0264999885,
-0.0019310819,
-0.0190226343,
-0.0231811088,
-0.0189741738,
0.0002604741,
0.0307430066,
-0.0380232856,
-0.0002592907,
-0.0626328811,
-0.0804696009,
0.0088941073,
0.0068254317,
0.0318549946,
-0.0359716341,
0.0008094385,
0.0563786589,
-0.0239726137,
-0.0285762399,
-0.046865683,
0.0280139726,
-0.0623002648,
-0.0321522355,
-0.0194846839,
-6.556004562e-33,
-0.0131791029,
-0.0161391422,
-0.0123544093,
-0.0610029064,
0.0124819307,
-0.0143202394,
-0.0238292441,
0.0232235361,
-0.0352177285,
0.0067827012,
-0.027386507,
-0.0130418353,
0.0078280903,
0.0533320792,
0.0427436829,
-0.046589423,
0.0222713258,
0.0009366813,
-0.0494267307,
0.0159909036,
0.0169405621,
0.0055098068,
0.0471665077,
-0.0302975867,
0.0384188294,
-0.0113151306,
0.0124431709,
-0.0043942546,
-0.0463630781,
0.0619990677,
0.0042814887,
0.0544746779,
0.015969526,
-0.0500298403,
-0.0099974452,
0.0380190685,
-0.0181572139,
-0.0410970524,
0.016327776,
0.0168107394,
0.0125747016,
-0.0367574096,
0.01358114,
0.0140874712,
-0.0285126865,
-0.0275210571,
0.0202075597,
-0.0210495684,
-0.044708997,
0.0186264906,
0.0052521597,
0.0154021746,
-0.0108038737,
0.0111537585,
-0.0320300907,
0.0795894861,
-0.0009843141,
0.0506209955,
0.0164193511,
0.0274852924,
0.0383339413,
0.0513802804,
0.0505370051,
0.037669789,
-0.0017365788,
0.0610097647,
0.0311670881,
-0.0243979357,
0.0345567279,
-0.0190942734,
0.011617491,
0.0122369677,
0.0708781779,
0.0536311679,
0.025259465,
0.0228357576,
-0.0718112588,
0.0302408785,
0.0351997092,
-0.01235973,
0.0570759885,
-0.0098245852,
-0.0419408195,
-0.0537361167,
-0.0712758601,
-0.0336235054,
-0.0306324363,
-0.0262265038,
0.0516086183,
-0.0253801886,
-0.0450913757,
0.0237610396,
0.0611510091,
-0.0466022454,
-0.0712380707,
0.0065134722,
-0.021452751,
0.0327556729,
0.0043466324,
0.0300833564,
-0.0457254201,
0.0221493356,
-0.0022081686,
-0.0276894402,
-0.0039644535,
0.0187940411,
-0.0163744334,
-0.0023361095,
-0.0691674277,
-0.0153277041,
-0.0358488373,
-0.0259518921,
0.0141355339,
0.0393529162,
0.0357019007,
-0.0026872265,
0.0129866675,
0.0141109601,
0.0094576972,
-0.0123622306,
-0.0236613452,
-0.0463970415,
-0.0156883858,
0.0024889933,
-0.026431866,
-0.0170171708,
0.0044062948,
-0.0055174362,
0.0136769461,
-0.0328466818,
-0.0081496909,
0.0133306878,
2.69e-7,
0.0419255868,
0.0777230859,
-0.0387795232,
0.0021335222,
0.0106720636,
0.0607857853,
0.005027228,
0.0214638673,
0.0689263642,
-0.0106730657,
-0.0224515796,
0.0057848622,
0.0413619094,
0.0402766876,
-0.1105058342,
-0.0443442911,
-0.0225072391,
0.0513862446,
-0.0490728095,
0.0062001054,
0.0109574273,
0.1148291603,
0.0113061527,
-0.0141142411,
-0.0173211023,
-0.0165996999,
0.0178325642,
-0.0516245924,
-0.0167671498,
0.0242768917,
0.0215099696,
-0.0208875779,
0.0273665432,
0.0416661799,
-0.0198136177,
-0.0022244502,
0.0224614479,
0.0689817667,
0.0245981831,
-0.0247245152,
-0.0189634115,
-0.0186695717,
0.0137940086,
-0.0718358904,
0.0837799832,
-0.0130546661,
0.0053618965,
-0.0550816692,
-0.0301406104,
-0.0446472056,
0.0244610626,
-0.0252320617,
-0.0019650231,
0.0058123781,
-0.002630437,
0.0010286637,
0.0154130887,
-0.0398609228,
-0.027257476,
-0.0057083541,
-0.0341946036,
-0.0885909721,
-0.0144533543,
-0.0260940958,
-0.0105118966,
-0.069727473,
0.0075950543,
2.601058824e-34,
0.034948118,
0.0016651697,
0.0093882671,
0.0167302098,
0.0337125212,
-0.0265199468,
0.0122051844,
0.0198834334,
0.0380162746,
-0.1072644815,
-0.0183616523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03877v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03877v1 | Introducing "Forecast Utterance" for Conversational Data Science | 2023-09-07T17:41:41 | 2023-09-07T17:41:41 | Md Mahadi Hassan, Alex Knipper, Shubhra Kanti Karmaker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Envision an intelligent agent capable of assisting users in conducting
forecasting tasks through intuitive, natural conversations, without requiring
in-depth knowledge of the underlying machine learning (ML) processes. A
significant challenge for the agent in this endeavor is to accurately
comprehend the user's prediction goals and, consequently, formulate precise ML
tasks. In this paper, we take a pioneering step towards this ambitious goal by
introducing a new concept called Forecast Utterance and then focus on the
automatic and accurate interpretation of users' prediction goals from these
utterances. Specifically, we frame the task as a slot-filling problem, where
each slot corresponds to a specific aspect of the goal prediction task. We then
employ two zero-shot methods for solving the slot-filling task, namely: 1)
Entity Extraction (EE), and 2) Question-Answering (QA) techniques. Our
experiments, conducted with three meticulously crafted data sets, validate the
viability of our ambitious goal and demonstrate the effectiveness of both EE
and QA techniques in interpreting Forecast Utterances. | [
0.0600210465,
0.0892833993,
-0.012765999,
0.010327084,
-0.0108542666,
0.0084975455,
-0.0046512634,
-0.0176815744,
0.0074635143,
-0.0108863879,
0.0288450271,
-0.0007782661,
-0.0233527925,
0.0550606661,
-0.0549375303,
-0.0730196834,
0.0060115447,
-0.0048699356,
-0.0017887967,
0.0252111237,
0.0092221797,
0.0032549121,
-0.0141222524,
0.0356177874,
0.0021620574,
-0.015949985,
-0.0631918311,
-0.0223945323,
-0.0174869578,
-0.0271350443,
0.0272710603,
0.0132383313,
0.0020774656,
0.0033755177,
0.0000022845,
-0.0512541011,
-0.0442644767,
-0.0310884211,
-0.0876811519,
-0.0709010586,
-0.0225620735,
-0.0251509324,
0.0266265012,
0.0003106427,
-0.074235037,
0.0014707941,
0.0482354611,
0.0318278633,
0.0369263478,
0.0356334001,
-0.0185752064,
-0.0054661501,
-0.0121581564,
0.0252910145,
0.0254110992,
-0.0481894799,
0.0352323242,
-0.0193805918,
-0.0011393854,
-0.0082905022,
0.0081761954,
0.0242302623,
-0.0025973173,
0.0288474876,
0.022854412,
0.0361453071,
-0.0103984503,
-0.0521317944,
-0.0557375029,
0.0652354136,
0.0718931705,
-0.0105474722,
0.0276053604,
-0.0011061538,
-0.0101550668,
0.0237540957,
-0.0472845323,
-0.0357995965,
-0.016839087,
-0.0058008106,
0.0040921555,
0.0553088449,
-0.0248903055,
0.001977013,
-0.0659330115,
0.1023373976,
-0.0348462723,
-0.053136535,
-0.0158561561,
0.0002965097,
0.060594596,
-0.0710195377,
-0.0074835564,
0.0442206375,
-0.0549498945,
0.0434553251,
0.0016545891,
-0.0151458578,
-0.0332858264,
-0.0286773816,
0.0226678643,
0.052487459,
0.0308197271,
0.0248756893,
0.039682623,
0.0121072941,
0.0495888889,
-0.0508649424,
-0.0492328778,
-0.0249792244,
-0.0584037453,
-0.0113125574,
-0.037396241,
0.0390410721,
-0.0254546106,
-0.0088068927,
-0.0162676461,
0.0061529432,
-0.0015856292,
0.0352670886,
0.0086430544,
0.0321937986,
-0.048605293,
-0.0260877162,
-0.0797656253,
0.0076232869,
-0.0706008971,
0.0216912962,
-0.0141938711,
-0.0725668147,
-0.0213354416,
0.0037812602,
0.0228266437,
0.0091974633,
-0.0111595904,
0.0810668021,
0.0290485565,
0.0265713967,
-0.0352973677,
-0.05931044,
0.0154694263,
-0.0638434216,
-0.0161793213,
-0.0064187241,
0.0303720646,
0.023165375,
-0.0128251584,
-0.00497982,
0.0037740136,
0.0159214772,
-0.0154230045,
0.079546988,
-0.0500464514,
0.0254056249,
0.0141327102,
-0.00134283,
-0.0099582281,
0.0491263717,
0.0283841398,
0.0471243784,
0.0389294438,
-0.0165065583,
0.0340221338,
0.0286874045,
0.0304710213,
-0.0635048822,
0.0246803388,
0.0578856692,
-0.0509482622,
-0.0067370445,
-0.0249559991,
-0.0123103801,
0.0017878028,
0.0041563888,
0.0301903449,
0.069006376,
-0.0111067183,
0.0137455706,
0.0324968733,
0.0154708102,
-0.0001499216,
-0.0060227895,
0.0041835438,
0.0320610777,
-0.0073153921,
0.0155656114,
0.0022130355,
-0.0149338227,
-0.0264958106,
-0.055972103,
0.0063672555,
-0.0265156757,
0.0034021141,
0.007052897,
0.0262866523,
-0.0167467482,
-0.0590018369,
0.053787265,
0.0015802667,
0.0039988016,
-0.0299156252,
-0.0189022757,
0.02548627,
0.0764124766,
-0.0046871263,
-0.0044841915,
-0.0633474067,
-0.0112209171,
0.0069015087,
-0.0030298508,
0.0190327466,
-0.0297995619,
-0.0002665773,
-0.0295053795,
-0.0183300134,
0.0253756456,
-0.0081853634,
0.0080781085,
0.0149775539,
-0.0092898607,
-0.013434587,
-0.0114098368,
0.0347280875,
-0.000003538,
0.0037105069,
-0.0365335457,
0.0424031466,
0.0276815724,
0.0436853282,
0.0114565203,
0.0219025407,
0.0208721403,
0.0221965462,
0.0040638973,
-0.0391826443,
0.0895049796,
-0.0108002629,
-0.0090690451,
0.0088107502,
-0.0029896481,
-0.016552344,
-0.01811569,
-0.0371854268,
-0.0538311601,
0.0225895233,
-0.0043784119,
0.0170739368,
-0.0269626714,
-0.0221419297,
0.0454254337,
-0.0099919299,
-0.0072360593,
0.0502460226,
0.0480146818,
-0.0239025373,
-0.0047098259,
-0.0501028784,
0.029467212,
-0.0568072721,
0.0139829414,
0.0103850402,
0.0014662837,
0.0054683075,
0.0212498251,
-0.0209102612,
-0.0902249441,
0.0213370733,
-0.0954083949,
0.0225781426,
-0.0022043206,
0.030608803,
0.0145027479,
0.0195549373,
-0.0195547193,
-0.0533955656,
-0.0103682689,
0.0082767168,
-0.006461279,
-0.0411057957,
0.0542797782,
0.0473613665,
-0.0034642844,
-0.0118421903,
0.0449014977,
-0.0331715196,
0.0367348567,
0.0458899662,
-0.030070493,
-0.0162854586,
-0.0421111248,
-0.0247543715,
-0.0156436861,
0.0089835525,
0.0123319598,
-0.0330378078,
-0.0215747282,
-0.0213482846,
0.0203739572,
0.002443976,
0.034931913,
-0.0307402294,
-0.0395224467,
-0.0637326166,
0.0331604816,
-0.0526563786,
0.0274470858,
-0.0169050805,
0.0033223149,
0.0324856676,
0.0459999107,
0.0126922037,
0.0412681997,
-0.0471418835,
0.0763540342,
0.0161205512,
-0.0205462854,
-0.0570943356,
0.0501544215,
-0.0047100279,
0.0808352306,
0.0185170788,
-0.0358305536,
0.0832972899,
0.0224814601,
-0.0262169335,
-0.0227413718,
-0.0342081897,
-0.0423341058,
0.014472248,
-0.0194840711,
0.0075409487,
0.032761842,
-0.0212421864,
-0.0110023273,
-0.0160393156,
-0.0403685682,
0.0024186419,
0.0044835992,
-0.0242655762,
-0.0135319764,
0.021497611,
-0.0335642211,
-0.0576871186,
-0.0183009338,
-0.0675460026,
-0.0093747322,
-0.0114094,
-0.0079122549,
-0.0584284887,
-0.0091757989,
-0.0242259223,
-0.0077576959,
-0.0018761239,
-0.0423065647,
0.0077154124,
-0.0033809361,
0.0684559941,
0.0500364006,
-0.0487663262,
0.0145571176,
0.0552373305,
0.0239039268,
0.0397136323,
0.0492974408,
-0.0332944766,
0.0263324529,
0.0127523616,
-0.0350185335,
0.0168675501,
0.0443821438,
0.0075161885,
-0.023088675,
0.0032827586,
0.1080283746,
0.0419472121,
0.0450632721,
0.0054195728,
-0.0230977647,
0.0160505902,
-0.0110164192,
0.0763760433,
-0.1036176607,
-0.0373962484,
-0.0098081585,
0.0610408075,
-0.0311316811,
-0.0839669183,
-0.0425325669,
-0.1006296277,
0.0554935373,
-0.0332976803,
-0.0207775626,
-0.0042959955,
-0.0833463147,
0.0091566537,
-0.0298107192,
-0.0421156995,
-0.0109608117,
0.01367353,
0.0052516111,
0.0346536599,
-0.0809837729,
-0.0156124001,
0.0356384777,
-0.004701843,
0.030772116,
0.0637637824,
0.0632702634,
0.0137766125,
0.0357076377,
-0.0975185111,
-0.005772498,
0.008479015,
-0.0241299216,
0.0613077134,
-0.0286293477,
-0.0112220738,
-0.0015814721,
0.0807286873,
-0.0224452615,
-0.0114893382,
0.0580265857,
0.0560656488,
-0.0255031008,
0.0028846373,
-0.0185603127,
0.0239832141,
0.053695038,
0.0812566504,
0.0043770238,
-0.03347864,
-0.0425438657,
-0.0513604358,
0.0091558956,
-0.0761092007,
0.0114397677,
0.0079822913,
-0.0042208619,
0.0092981169,
-0.0485761613,
-0.0658749267,
0.0594535246,
0.0004546205,
0.0105000008,
-0.0041797389,
0.0642350018,
0.0363094062,
-0.0406228937,
-0.0508106723,
-0.0021602798,
0.0002716284,
-0.0135023287,
-0.0325046107,
0.0265716743,
-0.0183736403,
-0.0315381959,
-0.0128732305,
-0.0628579259,
-0.0102712642,
-0.0124322986,
0.0664049461,
0.0238090064,
0.0275445096,
0.0329226404,
0.0017408699,
0.0441197753,
0.0689424425,
-0.0409680568,
-0.0321119577,
0.0236464422,
0.0690928474,
-0.0009472503,
0.0453509875,
-0.0162128359,
0.0290868022,
-0.0367397368,
-0.0001184681,
-0.07288827,
-0.0245388094,
0.0326648168,
0.0245720409,
0.0293177031,
0.0288427919,
-0.0474293754,
0.0079108477,
0.0201008245,
0.0108251497,
-0.0211656541,
-0.0393013172,
-0.0054779956,
-0.0133547401,
-0.0050652195,
0.0155915106,
0.0133679816,
-0.0451018587,
-0.0240929127,
-0.0046621114,
0.0066853524,
0.0325878449,
-0.0034978746,
0.0033910025,
-0.0088765519,
0.0200385656,
-0.0115911169,
0.048003193,
0.0482681654,
0.0234387368,
0.0376056395,
0.0082323588,
0.0183889698,
-0.0074133882,
-0.0021612167,
-0.071051985,
-0.0725614727,
0.0012657556,
0.0681687593,
-0.0431763791,
-0.0249549039,
-0.0264672879,
-0.0386867933,
0.0244326796,
0.0112267518,
0.0171655398,
-0.0017343765,
-0.002845566,
0.0449797735,
-0.0045951195,
-0.0471984893,
-0.0314495414,
0.0419169925,
-0.0336832218,
0.0703559443,
0.0008496616,
-0.027282482,
-0.0859968886,
-0.0198483188,
0.0183354821,
0.003348541,
0.0201175008,
-0.0007500129,
-0.0573320985,
-0.0152964937,
0.0141269816,
-0.004722836,
-0.0213371608,
-0.031440068,
0.0253290143,
0.0473085456,
0.0001830006,
0.0193137676,
-0.0393813476,
-0.0265973117,
-0.0665245503,
-0.0112050408,
-0.049354285,
-6.324695927e-33,
-0.0240545981,
-0.0260141175,
0.043919608,
0.0222668219,
0.0324330181,
0.0233822744,
-0.0174696464,
-0.0261233635,
-0.0044614347,
-0.0136670973,
-0.0302431881,
-0.0296229795,
0.0229282118,
0.0035400528,
0.0329999812,
-0.0164718628,
0.0400830023,
-0.0275696348,
-0.0073224725,
-0.0251912419,
0.044993829,
0.047974769,
0.026280297,
-0.0484517142,
0.0512322411,
-0.0087806433,
-0.0286283754,
0.0469631478,
0.0559791438,
0.030321667,
-0.005772402,
0.0206027776,
0.0175226722,
-0.0662477538,
-0.0381065235,
0.0488176756,
-0.0634904653,
-0.0780063868,
0.0132307345,
0.0018156855,
-0.0081688454,
0.0274643674,
-0.0056336452,
0.0006384695,
0.0002200002,
-0.0023612066,
0.0333084278,
-0.0087856902,
0.0279127806,
-0.0069378489,
-0.0302358828,
0.0204881039,
-0.0395657383,
-0.0239732768,
0.0620565601,
0.0915024355,
0.0290033631,
-0.017101068,
-0.0385911055,
0.0502696335,
0.0230887569,
-0.0122039467,
0.0471543968,
0.015988024,
0.018538367,
0.0498931706,
0.0558253303,
-0.0486367606,
-0.0486357994,
0.023864245,
-0.0140711656,
0.049328737,
-0.0347612426,
0.0260457955,
0.065727286,
0.0281804632,
-0.0323309302,
0.0663379058,
0.0306807887,
0.0415241495,
-0.010558147,
-0.0174414869,
-0.0608296953,
-0.0095996018,
0.0006855378,
0.0199782718,
-0.0219275244,
-0.039180629,
0.0317899138,
-0.0073175458,
-0.0319328643,
0.0510095768,
0.0145934699,
-0.0590710193,
-0.0014250133,
0.0305474792,
-0.0148846535,
-0.0242279489,
-0.0018114325,
0.0125610372,
-0.0637073815,
-0.0084749311,
0.0213685296,
0.0249347016,
0.0274975412,
0.0395391583,
-0.0303895194,
0.0157327522,
-0.0442378111,
-0.017327467,
-0.0112740826,
0.0105327554,
-0.0365157947,
0.008461331,
0.0221432596,
0.0376525633,
-0.0320382528,
0.0095879789,
-0.0050741215,
0.0184763763,
-0.0252498593,
0.0158278216,
0.0287179239,
0.0028376977,
-0.0116286119,
-0.045185443,
-0.0139694065,
-0.0595434941,
0.0034491024,
-0.0323498957,
0.0127650304,
0.0070409854,
2.937e-7,
0.0102435825,
0.0529246181,
0.0188044365,
0.0311851669,
-0.0161493979,
0.0616082326,
0.0138585409,
0.0067847832,
0.0206149593,
-0.0211904459,
0.0630270019,
-0.0170890111,
0.0242004562,
0.0531312078,
-0.1135814562,
-0.059909109,
-0.0346983708,
-0.0157138687,
-0.0682000071,
0.0357992128,
0.1045803279,
0.0770394355,
0.0373144783,
0.0203359984,
0.030007299,
0.0060081338,
-0.0050741276,
-0.0402266346,
0.0026290107,
0.0382955335,
0.0030585506,
0.0005310139,
-0.0101368073,
0.0331673101,
-0.0121848304,
0.018715892,
-0.0125317611,
0.0512803756,
0.0193814058,
-0.0394245386,
-0.0260415915,
0.0213882681,
-0.0003026356,
-0.0237112995,
0.03292685,
-0.1096955463,
-0.0407588482,
-0.0103910174,
-0.0114659099,
0.0333815962,
-0.0466535091,
0.0192730613,
0.0142155197,
-0.0116254352,
0.0183268692,
-0.0210403204,
0.0144708706,
-0.0472802296,
0.0040278072,
-0.0238830522,
-0.0250872299,
-0.0223288443,
-0.0173161868,
-0.0370429941,
0.0189928357,
-0.0672370046,
0.0275849141,
2.402161047e-34,
0.0031783751,
0.0574079268,
-0.0257915594,
0.0484758541,
0.0285198689,
-0.0206366535,
0.0216118731,
0.0295207519,
0.0427116863,
-0.0444894172,
-0.0363861434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03876v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03876v1 | OpinionGPT: Modelling Explicit Biases in Instruction-Tuned LLMs | 2023-09-07T17:41:01 | 2023-09-07T17:41:01 | Patrick Haller, Ansar Aynetdinov, Alan Akbik | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Instruction-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently showcased
remarkable ability to generate fitting responses to natural language
instructions. However, an open research question concerns the inherent biases
of trained models and their responses. For instance, if the data used to tune
an LLM is dominantly written by persons with a specific political bias, we
might expect generated answers to share this bias. Current research work seeks
to de-bias such models, or suppress potentially biased answers. With this
demonstration, we take a different view on biases in instruction-tuning: Rather
than aiming to suppress them, we aim to make them explicit and transparent. To
this end, we present OpinionGPT, a web demo in which users can ask questions
and select all biases they wish to investigate. The demo will answer this
question using a model fine-tuned on text representing each of the selected
biases, allowing side-by-side comparison. To train the underlying model, we
identified 11 different biases (political, geographic, gender, age) and derived
an instruction-tuning corpus in which each answer was written by members of one
of these demographics. This paper presents OpinionGPT, illustrates how we
trained the bias-aware model and showcases the web application (available at
https://opiniongpt.informatik.hu-berlin.de). | [
0.053746473,
0.0685839206,
-0.0067319679,
0.0377997458,
-0.0049808621,
0.0306487624,
0.0139811449,
-0.0210698433,
0.0573462509,
-0.0776694939,
-0.0084777353,
-0.0221209675,
-0.0322857574,
-0.022327181,
-0.0143378582,
-0.0520571098,
0.0555507652,
0.0142029831,
0.0539157726,
-0.0406700373,
0.0263418518,
0.0500313006,
-0.0089572025,
0.0343796574,
0.0064179641,
-0.0152663859,
0.0248610098,
0.0157704186,
0.0203852747,
0.0148925064,
0.0642556548,
0.0521106645,
-0.014381648,
0.0067409403,
0.0000020009,
-0.0343339071,
0.0061856876,
-0.0219062697,
-0.0049774731,
0.0019373772,
0.0835336,
0.0426543616,
-0.0142304571,
0.0457873642,
-0.0438914374,
0.0094214892,
0.030935403,
0.0203703921,
0.080757916,
0.0598497279,
0.0158093534,
-0.0172901805,
-0.0339396372,
0.0148255592,
0.0425253734,
-0.0038181844,
0.0300062541,
-0.0291166808,
-0.0398781598,
0.0178285316,
-0.0215063374,
-0.0026605269,
0.0104014277,
0.0088188397,
-0.0019568007,
-0.0001385828,
-0.0015033365,
-0.024737848,
-0.0236943997,
0.0576197915,
0.0138482014,
-0.0323119201,
0.0019231996,
-0.01648454,
0.024288157,
0.0084934859,
-0.0315807238,
0.0302429665,
-0.0101934206,
0.0205277745,
0.0348333009,
-0.0122908354,
0.0016213704,
0.0568332523,
0.0004448679,
0.0904554427,
-0.00035068,
-0.0363095626,
0.0088983607,
0.0309644919,
0.039027378,
-0.0524098165,
0.018340664,
0.0094795432,
-0.0164530575,
0.013093601,
-0.0407305509,
0.0326691382,
0.0252555124,
-0.0517232083,
0.0214483105,
0.0286858138,
-0.0185583606,
0.0496190898,
0.0376637205,
0.0046586683,
-0.0072985971,
0.0045081056,
-0.0288239084,
-0.0113450838,
-0.0208940264,
0.0033213042,
-0.0027592666,
0.0092573371,
-0.03415462,
0.0418008529,
-0.0188221727,
0.0064179036,
-0.0271155927,
-0.000757098,
0.015390018,
0.0176873803,
-0.0367721543,
-0.0223203357,
-0.0756296366,
0.0565820895,
-0.0549360625,
0.041085422,
-0.0356732532,
-0.0890344158,
0.0010031528,
0.0429397188,
-0.0124704624,
-0.0335012786,
0.0248742905,
0.035802912,
0.0224214327,
0.0102053285,
-0.018176103,
-0.034923546,
-0.0030158828,
-0.061525058,
0.0022957523,
-0.0549637489,
0.0265757814,
0.0084556397,
0.0247899126,
-0.0285407957,
0.0093127694,
0.0528400503,
-0.0539222322,
0.0405425876,
0.0197072383,
0.0123471487,
0.0381765999,
0.0143947573,
0.0345797166,
0.0827572197,
0.019638801,
0.0126605015,
0.0468011536,
-0.0393863469,
0.015500905,
0.0126211839,
-0.0061029978,
0.0219760407,
-0.0017725945,
0.0558825694,
-0.0383760445,
0.0037680501,
0.040657822,
0.0436225608,
0.0049080327,
-0.0350576043,
0.0687620789,
0.0272704624,
-0.0047101304,
0.0182754453,
0.007928201,
0.0395093821,
-0.003240343,
0.0224179216,
-0.0616085716,
0.0171516147,
-0.0221346002,
-0.0362609476,
0.0259040426,
0.0589918308,
-0.0296265557,
-0.0310676154,
-0.0110962419,
0.0029891299,
0.0205549877,
0.0409757867,
0.0077158217,
-0.0113448389,
-0.0103016878,
0.0605220869,
0.0549143888,
-0.0334152579,
0.0283749253,
-0.0609273016,
0.0347181261,
0.0430004261,
-0.0018803159,
-0.0068505863,
-0.0285870023,
-0.0448207483,
0.0286718663,
0.059922792,
0.0986428708,
-0.016741585,
-0.0138006685,
-0.0644285381,
-0.0328796916,
-0.000996607,
0.0157462135,
0.0291580316,
0.0522421002,
0.010391566,
0.0077694478,
-0.0359324142,
-0.0206554364,
0.0268416889,
0.0133432699,
-0.0516202077,
0.0195170194,
-0.0007804589,
0.0401469804,
0.0323030278,
-0.0170050096,
0.0026625122,
0.0083074905,
0.0045047598,
-0.0074258461,
-0.0294077303,
-0.0625059679,
-0.0086503122,
-0.0016018127,
-0.0678447857,
-0.025240371,
0.0120298574,
-0.0519850515,
0.0010831417,
0.0136386501,
-0.0228829682,
0.0077216015,
-0.0138094947,
-0.0085845143,
-0.0323543139,
-0.0222245865,
-0.0806175917,
0.0458024815,
0.0037158739,
-0.0017172436,
0.0332277976,
-0.0362125784,
-0.0108341156,
-0.0389035158,
-0.0024125606,
-0.0152178481,
0.0179442689,
0.0133586954,
0.0411182642,
-0.00035549,
-0.0478413031,
-0.0566982254,
-0.0747172013,
0.0225334782,
-0.0161618423,
0.0364589989,
0.0384323075,
-0.0033443887,
-0.0166769829,
-0.0204072967,
-0.0641219094,
-0.0402514301,
-0.0004890326,
0.0342805497,
0.0215407703,
-0.0227355193,
0.0169798601,
-0.0493082628,
-0.0122705428,
-0.0478253178,
0.0049904352,
0.0395470336,
0.0056562498,
-0.0655962527,
-0.0116498964,
-0.0171905905,
0.00723032,
0.0129201021,
-0.0399449058,
0.0056298212,
0.0162456725,
0.0045225457,
0.081850335,
0.0434606113,
0.001489101,
0.0455914214,
-0.0054198522,
-0.0703578293,
0.003304207,
-0.0603552386,
-0.004670938,
-0.038164597,
-0.0594024993,
0.0188401043,
0.0654652268,
0.0461373776,
-0.0056644659,
-0.0657399967,
0.0593759753,
-0.0433428958,
-0.0134173268,
-0.0031531039,
-0.0104955928,
0.0026685579,
-0.0019011082,
-0.0224724598,
-0.0445154645,
0.0762317181,
0.0153127825,
0.0437473878,
-0.0702634752,
-0.0047271452,
-0.0647339821,
0.0014860932,
0.0050530573,
0.0267519504,
0.0036497081,
0.0128779234,
-0.0584969483,
-0.0366226099,
0.0209148657,
-0.0409190021,
0.0162729118,
-0.0461912714,
-0.0251168646,
0.005473109,
-0.0553017743,
-0.0420824811,
-0.087048471,
-0.0161024239,
-0.0089591481,
0.0431223959,
-0.0209644623,
-0.0257251896,
-0.0285854843,
0.0310715642,
-0.0196439177,
-0.0290389936,
0.0025810821,
0.0036650822,
0.0295196287,
0.0564339049,
0.0081183948,
0.027943192,
-0.0101653021,
-0.0004093404,
0.0359906293,
-0.0007670514,
0.0318302587,
-0.0022548854,
-0.0162263531,
0.0481514335,
-0.0537730604,
0.0032212285,
0.0095316553,
0.0624992698,
-0.0454774164,
0.006765076,
0.11733675,
0.0192025881,
-0.0663631111,
-0.0114655532,
0.0054389555,
0.0197279397,
0.0441255234,
0.0266420282,
-0.1166987494,
-0.0170619786,
-0.0040059499,
0.0280919801,
-0.0351724662,
-0.0070742974,
-0.0187743232,
-0.1401153803,
0.0029429672,
0.0076520639,
0.0209614113,
-0.0122002587,
-0.0551518314,
0.0070492527,
-0.03017864,
0.0178772248,
-0.0096880533,
-0.0081145773,
0.0325996354,
0.0270571057,
-0.0639757961,
-0.0464768298,
0.0348410755,
-0.0173509922,
0.0686569884,
0.0613081269,
0.0467865728,
-0.0032179405,
-0.0161065217,
0.055671528,
-0.0455250144,
-0.0044936612,
-0.0294439774,
0.0356427841,
-0.0424735956,
0.0053173513,
-0.0491885468,
0.056953121,
0.0173708592,
0.0288590565,
0.0392866433,
0.0425646789,
-0.0123598343,
-0.0093546929,
-0.0397325605,
0.0047895033,
0.0360194445,
0.087780118,
0.0364466906,
-0.077977322,
-0.0059621194,
-0.0732695684,
-0.0098390523,
-0.0322138444,
-0.0773058608,
0.0234499387,
-0.0162312835,
0.0029209163,
-0.0330657698,
-0.0547641367,
0.0168915205,
-0.0166286547,
0.0102652702,
-0.0587889217,
0.0277797449,
-0.0157059971,
-0.0076955827,
0.0473733358,
-0.052993387,
0.0315778702,
-0.0391018391,
-0.0466362536,
0.0158049706,
-0.0358938761,
-0.0168954507,
-0.0086134523,
-0.0558908395,
-0.0531747974,
0.0531283878,
0.0534244217,
0.0164398346,
0.0424853601,
-0.0141055314,
-0.0718581975,
0.0445477292,
0.0512253195,
-0.0321385562,
-0.0158550274,
0.0043937373,
0.0404095277,
0.0062924367,
0.0144295935,
-0.0282576215,
0.042140618,
0.0469691791,
-0.0240225159,
-0.0661357641,
-0.0421265066,
0.0142470077,
-0.0154042291,
0.0611735098,
0.0110013345,
-0.0069575263,
-0.0306921806,
0.0033169028,
-0.0052481908,
-0.0425079688,
0.0025816229,
-0.0358285308,
0.0255891103,
-0.0472880788,
-0.0330297351,
-0.028117992,
-0.0434254222,
0.0076548927,
-0.0559111945,
0.0752654448,
0.0244110133,
0.0188738797,
-0.0002276585,
-0.0131062623,
-0.0481842346,
0.0612609386,
-0.0097841788,
0.0382369719,
0.0385781862,
0.0595084243,
0.0015684824,
-0.0004772958,
0.0426033996,
-0.0177291539,
-0.0345140472,
-0.0294837132,
-0.0350451507,
0.0136694051,
0.0060392478,
-0.0206907894,
0.0338228866,
0.0199844316,
-0.0140332747,
-0.0108761396,
-0.0017448046,
0.0321618766,
-0.0061617992,
0.0653823167,
0.0087264059,
-0.03249586,
-0.0194300767,
0.0505471751,
0.0126100508,
0.0664950609,
0.0307685491,
-0.0320730805,
-0.0240449291,
-0.0178868007,
-0.0072622593,
-0.0160722341,
-0.0038291176,
0.0032026414,
-0.0418816358,
-0.0252402388,
-0.0309875011,
0.0205588583,
0.0190826859,
-0.0206727814,
0.0340297408,
0.0369355381,
-0.0353186689,
-0.0315777361,
-0.0485078581,
0.0245948303,
-0.0749084055,
-0.0216421299,
-0.0314548947,
-6.486693742e-33,
-0.0329210609,
-0.0232818704,
-0.0224394836,
-0.0325054526,
0.0161746033,
-0.0168876238,
-0.0039142193,
0.0135945352,
-0.04882624,
0.0073969723,
0.0206788834,
0.0191285759,
0.0241014119,
0.0249907598,
-0.0087224878,
-0.0410886519,
0.0492921583,
-0.0012164804,
-0.0164982285,
0.0230201986,
-0.0005825373,
-0.0126333106,
0.0406894237,
-0.075050883,
0.0401771627,
-0.0079856766,
-0.0051208502,
0.0191599745,
-0.028127009,
0.0618454479,
-0.0118375197,
0.0739416182,
0.0274335817,
-0.011278037,
-0.0056611658,
0.0682818294,
-0.0257186145,
-0.0420003757,
0.0320187621,
0.0136395376,
0.0102718482,
-0.055222068,
0.0219304096,
0.0115841907,
-0.0644529834,
-0.0279225707,
0.0573880039,
-0.0216905288,
0.0394653939,
-0.003244719,
-0.0230137687,
0.0161677953,
-0.0094524808,
0.0017674859,
-0.0424757339,
0.0636914223,
0.0230257958,
0.033497259,
-0.0462899469,
0.0544530153,
0.045258496,
0.0413485765,
0.0367035419,
-0.0162841976,
-0.0035558257,
0.0509191416,
0.0470353514,
0.0334213674,
-0.0510322265,
-0.0360672921,
-0.0057500717,
-0.0193841308,
0.0335332118,
0.0711246505,
0.0246605016,
0.0045394115,
-0.0578017421,
-0.0067144549,
0.060356725,
0.0319624767,
0.0468255989,
-0.03052775,
-0.0507656895,
-0.0270995386,
-0.0645294785,
-0.0423984788,
-0.0375112966,
-0.0087604187,
0.0432824418,
0.0204496589,
-0.0254286192,
0.0030459049,
0.0019919386,
-0.0436447263,
-0.0111088268,
0.0120005244,
-0.0344328955,
-0.021315705,
-0.0075619509,
0.0260223746,
-0.0614586473,
0.0135828648,
0.0028084491,
-0.0119125135,
0.0155100524,
0.0281515643,
-0.0105740512,
0.008660404,
-0.0928659216,
-0.0064671417,
-0.0229401831,
0.0217987187,
-0.012012382,
0.0313244089,
0.0323958881,
0.0280685145,
0.0057184272,
0.0441326387,
-0.003911831,
0.001783626,
-0.0081880055,
-0.0438249297,
-0.0122646028,
0.0406083763,
-0.0310512111,
0.0039847656,
0.0050692311,
0.0078194113,
-0.0206396934,
-0.0330519155,
-0.0226033889,
-0.0174259227,
2.518e-7,
0.0234807003,
0.0745811313,
-0.0239929892,
0.0151688233,
0.0093362667,
0.0409368053,
0.0381563939,
0.0128817987,
0.0273384973,
-0.0165083241,
-0.0269395709,
0.0282498952,
0.0431307666,
0.0257742107,
-0.0951214135,
-0.0011039897,
-0.0418348312,
0.056391295,
-0.059974961,
0.007638311,
0.0306259934,
0.0706700906,
0.0334111713,
0.0152011709,
-0.0321317203,
0.020625852,
0.0355273448,
-0.046898663,
-0.0248057861,
0.0423153564,
0.0253710281,
-0.00932761,
0.0228965599,
0.0347936451,
-0.0225542448,
-0.0167109631,
-0.0532163791,
0.0860163793,
0.0066598351,
-0.0338019803,
-0.002610039,
-0.0037633386,
-0.0058202874,
-0.054538507,
0.068981275,
-0.0265177432,
-0.0185750332,
-0.0783340856,
-0.0263530612,
-0.0336747654,
0.0413147472,
-0.0262577087,
-0.0171849355,
-0.0321537219,
0.0410329327,
-0.0079572713,
-0.0195758119,
-0.0500079691,
-0.0188408624,
-0.003300986,
-0.0441506766,
-0.0891313776,
-0.008212449,
0.059204489,
0.006403469,
-0.0431156233,
0.0314773917,
2.244654677e-34,
0.0196455158,
0.0139960553,
0.025223095,
-0.0339497663,
0.0533821881,
0.0524830371,
-0.0151019944,
-0.0268327035,
0.0621571615,
-0.0866792873,
-0.0031865495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03852v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03852v2 | FLM-101B: An Open LLM and How to Train It with $100K Budget | 2023-09-07T17:07:36 | 2023-09-17T07:38:10 | Xiang Li, Yiqun Yao, Xin Jiang, Xuezhi Fang, Xuying Meng, Siqi Fan, Peng Han, Jing Li, Li Du, Bowen Qin, Zheng Zhang, Aixin Sun, Yequan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success in NLP and
multimodal tasks, among others. Despite these successes, two main challenges
remain in developing LLMs: (i) high computational cost, and (ii) fair and
objective evaluations. In this paper, we report a solution to significantly
reduce LLM training cost through a growth strategy. We demonstrate that a
101B-parameter LLM with 0.31T tokens can be trained with a budget of 100K US
dollars. Inspired by IQ tests, we also consolidate an additional range of
evaluations on top of existing evaluations that focus on knowledge-oriented
abilities. These IQ evaluations include symbolic mapping, rule understanding,
pattern mining, and anti-interference. Such evaluations minimize the potential
impact of memorization. Experimental results show that our model, named
FLM-101B, trained with a budget of 100K US dollars, achieves performance
comparable to powerful and well-known models, e.g., GPT-3 and GLM-130B,
especially on the additional range of IQ evaluations. The checkpoint of
FLM-101B is released at https://huggingface.co/CofeAI/FLM-101B. | [
0.0435267203,
0.0994361043,
-0.0015810388,
0.0400944874,
-0.0286572184,
0.0102288164,
-0.0061429427,
0.0100182574,
0.0035354684,
-0.0540009625,
-0.0878889859,
-0.0359027982,
-0.009770832,
0.0552183762,
0.0199624021,
-0.0278701764,
0.0583392195,
-0.0395248421,
0.0150086116,
0.0073740841,
-0.0130232573,
0.0057029612,
-0.0202844255,
0.0165888872,
-0.0477337502,
-0.0049160458,
0.003070869,
-0.011377288,
-0.0022431638,
-0.0591946095,
-0.0028329147,
0.0274114423,
0.0145044392,
0.0367281325,
0.000002305,
-0.0686725676,
0.0178513881,
-0.0295782797,
-0.0099069579,
0.0455481,
0.0172498822,
0.0040500984,
-0.0018345527,
0.0282065701,
-0.054228507,
-0.0061409469,
0.0069946144,
0.0904247835,
0.0340394042,
0.0863823369,
0.0029167752,
-0.0060420688,
0.06566111,
-0.0310834218,
0.0108127836,
-0.0902079716,
0.0061829505,
-0.0162014719,
-0.0239687115,
-0.0229868218,
-0.0227702502,
0.043094106,
0.0255874116,
0.0003250363,
0.0120805614,
0.0537514277,
-0.0308055393,
-0.0314371623,
-0.022806216,
0.0645321384,
-0.0302021448,
-0.0021395932,
-0.0105008138,
0.0145222088,
-0.0235455688,
-0.038178701,
-0.0438032784,
0.0501545109,
0.024054639,
0.0345843136,
0.0265355743,
-0.0184693709,
0.033473134,
0.0292892829,
-0.0313824415,
0.0504546016,
0.0036925953,
-0.0273891147,
0.0222796854,
-0.0054256725,
-0.0591326915,
-0.0387199558,
-0.0208792537,
0.039378088,
-0.0056905602,
0.0081552472,
-0.0266713649,
0.0025449255,
0.0269781891,
-0.0419187881,
0.0328425542,
0.0214183833,
0.002592816,
0.0843956694,
-0.069653891,
0.067486234,
0.0094978241,
0.0670919791,
-0.0177387428,
-0.0169613827,
-0.0459844209,
-0.0134148374,
-0.0383944213,
0.055771146,
-0.0194695629,
-0.0526390299,
-0.0387528874,
0.0116620688,
-0.0112435529,
-0.0162182525,
-0.0091607347,
0.0052000205,
-0.0030103801,
-0.0040662214,
-0.0311126243,
0.0203707647,
-0.0014492617,
0.0169558413,
-0.0326051079,
-0.0370447859,
-0.013373646,
0.038458094,
-0.0066741952,
-0.0133485915,
0.033206176,
0.0974762589,
-0.028856298,
-0.0669339746,
-0.0606159456,
-0.0162806101,
0.0285072848,
-0.0773226395,
0.0103588281,
-0.054069981,
-0.0035197733,
-0.0054440773,
0.013939742,
-0.0244566184,
0.0243135169,
0.0235470943,
-0.0055771847,
0.051522743,
-0.0196237527,
0.006739377,
0.0056210011,
0.0104225511,
0.0025045963,
0.0799788609,
0.0484791175,
-0.0155282449,
0.0517718419,
0.0063813208,
-0.0036733937,
0.0617992617,
0.0033000673,
0.0065897475,
-0.0177965574,
-0.0105424281,
0.023824269,
0.0449512601,
0.0513083041,
0.0678741783,
-0.0067688655,
-0.0124049103,
0.0766315088,
0.0443195812,
0.0095602497,
-0.0088810604,
-0.0006622949,
0.0138306739,
0.005760021,
-0.0558496453,
-0.068875961,
0.0155327851,
-0.0414493158,
-0.0115838638,
0.0179442838,
0.0328460895,
-0.026383508,
-0.0422083549,
-0.0202806443,
-0.007027626,
0.0172886383,
-0.0053742169,
0.0440149717,
-0.0104181822,
-0.0261358097,
0.0367107466,
-0.0042758859,
-0.0210179631,
0.0018725505,
-0.0771162957,
0.0539126694,
0.049026262,
0.0392971598,
-0.006877095,
-0.0253611896,
-0.002090377,
0.0227774624,
0.0604326241,
0.0347403958,
-0.0077261794,
0.0315801241,
-0.058695104,
-0.0325362273,
0.0044371877,
0.0141177382,
0.0074137133,
0.019089967,
0.0199075118,
-0.0052774688,
-0.0524256416,
-0.0080820723,
0.040475864,
-0.0254151151,
-0.0689047426,
0.0128421923,
-0.0096080778,
0.037394125,
0.0130358655,
0.0021528886,
0.0118784271,
0.04153952,
-0.0534322336,
-0.0120180212,
0.0057569076,
-0.0208059493,
0.0063091652,
0.0579740815,
0.0013892129,
-0.0091589242,
0.031936653,
-0.0362442546,
-0.029317297,
0.0191516783,
-0.0518742502,
0.0408319011,
-0.0212548543,
0.0382427685,
0.0299949273,
-0.0095027396,
-0.0299923681,
0.0568271913,
-0.0156531855,
0.0039093643,
0.0263221022,
-0.0244696569,
0.0380417854,
-0.0344673991,
-0.0284272563,
0.0158313904,
0.0016514165,
0.023444768,
-0.024790898,
0.0469058678,
-0.0378257558,
-0.0026650634,
-0.0860810131,
0.0240635388,
-0.0267090015,
0.0175910462,
-0.0009255032,
-0.0241088849,
-0.0095539289,
-0.0104079368,
-0.0238008276,
-0.0062310565,
0.0275678802,
-0.0008531443,
0.0275816657,
0.0225597881,
-0.0229451638,
-0.0322587229,
-0.000906024,
-0.023287192,
0.0274995714,
0.0056440234,
0.0167483557,
-0.0217392743,
0.0121620689,
0.0162128396,
0.0356257781,
-0.0175437536,
-0.0229845867,
0.0148416515,
-0.0255075004,
0.0193040334,
0.0602899231,
0.0400746465,
-0.008146299,
0.0108871264,
-0.0142885633,
-0.0648089796,
0.0264315549,
0.0216531642,
-0.0074018543,
-0.0186798126,
-0.0143886982,
0.0449323356,
0.0762861073,
-0.0320074521,
0.0107110022,
-0.0476215817,
0.029779464,
-0.0136731165,
-0.030994799,
-0.0385068096,
0.0376718491,
-0.01445131,
0.0383353494,
-0.027114924,
-0.0502534956,
0.0285471566,
-0.0457300432,
0.0180311855,
-0.0372288488,
-0.0286314692,
-0.0542677157,
0.0808226243,
-0.0155889923,
0.0062936028,
-0.0281076077,
-0.009191229,
-0.0399369672,
0.0009354132,
-0.0194412172,
-0.0056390855,
0.0509466268,
-0.0707904324,
0.0250318032,
-0.0081397071,
-0.0416644588,
-0.0490798205,
-0.0319544487,
-0.0249799434,
0.0225428827,
-0.0247422084,
-0.0072195269,
-0.0256580338,
0.011928793,
0.0295992121,
0.0382594764,
-0.0031884124,
-0.0006712842,
-0.0074296226,
0.0012880482,
0.060856849,
0.028265778,
0.0126350429,
-0.0301465876,
-0.0059101223,
0.0519370921,
0.0242417455,
0.0281030815,
0.0164351724,
0.0086639645,
0.039370086,
-0.0287011974,
-0.0388911329,
-0.0035974348,
0.0627282038,
-0.0504443385,
-0.0011767559,
0.1200660467,
0.0325524956,
-0.0336073898,
0.0149009461,
0.0129302759,
0.0186502915,
0.0122674843,
-0.0034116034,
-0.0882543474,
-0.0445978455,
0.0084848022,
0.0196869913,
-0.0130787417,
-0.0137116425,
-0.0036003042,
-0.131007731,
0.0073285964,
0.0081156688,
-0.0134038357,
-0.0499819219,
-0.0384965278,
-0.0226178449,
-0.0357218646,
0.018211646,
0.022580605,
-0.0176691432,
-0.0009918574,
0.0020143841,
-0.03095893,
-0.0717039704,
0.0309496988,
-0.0514748916,
0.0465886705,
0.0319896787,
0.0283474661,
0.0007556321,
-0.0728902966,
0.0422953218,
-0.0240443498,
0.0083164657,
-0.0448492244,
0.0396518223,
-0.0302094817,
-0.009760268,
-0.0324270464,
0.0213183127,
-0.0319038518,
-0.0359602645,
0.0279444624,
0.0493649691,
-0.0221700035,
-0.0008138991,
-0.0122569157,
-0.0089669079,
-0.0447164513,
0.0868462324,
0.0167897791,
-0.050646238,
-0.0427014008,
-0.0175223891,
-0.0188321769,
-0.0702136308,
-0.023315765,
0.0068713846,
-0.0164342523,
0.0194581132,
-0.0668417737,
-0.0110913031,
0.0326218382,
0.0431276485,
0.010139117,
-0.0161836427,
-0.0680033267,
0.0117017813,
-0.0571845621,
0.0576497093,
-0.0283091497,
0.0168832224,
-0.1035306975,
-0.0056756325,
0.0155477403,
-0.0182155222,
-0.0194423217,
0.0585769899,
-0.0466888882,
-0.0648649335,
-0.0246560313,
0.0701435506,
0.0249174908,
0.0279378425,
-0.0010893373,
-0.0406807661,
0.0366015658,
0.0212408602,
-0.0233682282,
0.0319342874,
0.019536892,
-0.0037166486,
0.0115771079,
0.0315048508,
-0.0375548676,
0.0167802572,
0.0313910954,
0.0763391852,
-0.0117252786,
-0.0067427452,
-0.0204955135,
0.0344514437,
0.0356062427,
-0.0064514903,
-0.0262899082,
-0.0334401689,
0.0235436205,
-0.0158845484,
0.0144866286,
-0.0436466932,
-0.0089126527,
0.0459185652,
0.029621996,
-0.0248475969,
-0.0337366126,
0.0134456223,
0.0185929984,
-0.0282712057,
0.014231734,
-0.0275556799,
-0.0397019163,
0.0074770334,
-0.0023894245,
-0.0283501614,
0.0146277091,
-0.016184438,
0.0101885991,
-0.0115848742,
0.0665525272,
-0.007447781,
0.0052445391,
-0.0209786166,
0.0319351628,
-0.0216895919,
-0.0393529721,
-0.0120576723,
0.0769030228,
0.0680603087,
0.0096214321,
0.0582720377,
-0.0592234731,
0.007345255,
-0.0243905168,
0.0010032085,
-0.0132492119,
-0.0340954475,
0.0445229039,
0.0466885008,
-0.0208560005,
-0.0209877733,
0.0868795291,
0.0185712464,
0.0485396981,
-0.0180364326,
0.0080364412,
-0.0382726304,
0.0149134826,
0.0702339485,
0.0403533317,
0.0011418059,
0.0423428528,
-0.0547365211,
-0.0608236156,
0.0442741066,
0.0097046001,
-0.0045515164,
-0.0336139239,
0.047056403,
0.0456642509,
0.0152934771,
-0.0416229181,
-0.0240869336,
-0.043651931,
0.0064045056,
-0.0385689177,
-0.0104054306,
-7.115007962e-33,
-0.0203063004,
0.0033897415,
0.0407519974,
0.0185940247,
-0.0335794985,
0.0210601594,
-0.0054414044,
0.0153999794,
-0.0137949297,
-0.0269123204,
0.0031749583,
-0.0052593597,
0.0002057023,
0.0354863591,
-0.0045034266,
0.0190355834,
0.0464122333,
-0.0250250697,
-0.0360739268,
0.0065602893,
-0.0015194712,
0.0404759236,
0.0855758712,
-0.0461549573,
-0.0419731252,
0.0398837924,
-0.0075957011,
0.0148921218,
-0.0274942406,
0.0599346943,
-0.0452708006,
0.0530161895,
0.0385266617,
-0.0317085497,
0.0091337031,
-0.0494498014,
-0.0720666274,
-0.0125744408,
0.0342122614,
0.0402610451,
-0.0104678115,
-0.0445221886,
0.0780028179,
-0.0100271022,
-0.0411978811,
-0.0029356447,
0.019388197,
-0.0073937364,
-0.0045392867,
-0.0060217837,
-0.0489338785,
0.0391468741,
0.0183770172,
-0.0192546789,
0.0027752221,
-0.0151796164,
-0.0373331532,
-0.0177798066,
-0.0740525723,
0.0053896499,
0.0015648182,
0.0575406477,
0.041758243,
-0.0011324807,
0.0196368117,
0.0808267444,
0.0141903982,
-0.0022385428,
-0.0096264565,
-0.0039031722,
0.0727748498,
0.0664744973,
0.0494307689,
0.0193165746,
0.0472602807,
0.0048195715,
-0.0666719079,
0.0150721781,
0.0537068732,
0.058708109,
0.0357343964,
0.0185363963,
-0.0167374406,
-0.0043643145,
-0.0273199789,
-0.0023260745,
-0.0346947275,
-0.0123693151,
0.0710689873,
0.0425561368,
0.0067508225,
-0.0325537212,
0.042351,
-0.0258209221,
-0.0291690715,
-0.0086571388,
0.0101297246,
0.0480658486,
-0.0077437633,
0.0162344389,
-0.0734169185,
-0.0401372425,
0.0245958306,
-0.025111286,
0.0278671999,
-0.0110140685,
0.0165622998,
0.0311773345,
-0.0785367414,
-0.0200296361,
-0.0094315745,
0.0288958009,
0.0216779057,
0.0414597467,
0.0201537684,
-0.0321810544,
-0.008729063,
-0.0087948721,
-0.034416724,
-0.0059459535,
-0.0296423864,
-0.0344546922,
-0.0220732074,
0.0177408196,
-0.0311554894,
0.0166328307,
-0.0215520635,
-0.0272724461,
-0.0314561091,
-0.0946246758,
-0.0054266914,
0.0427319594,
3.001e-7,
0.0358200967,
0.0439933538,
0.0013867338,
0.0266370978,
0.0182329677,
0.0231066737,
-0.0389055721,
0.0207604468,
0.0019720832,
0.0297913644,
-0.0185843986,
0.058910463,
0.0188998654,
-0.0015884275,
-0.092154406,
0.0029840502,
-0.0178764407,
-0.0015458631,
-0.0516363233,
-0.0025172769,
0.0170410797,
0.113081336,
-0.0111703044,
-0.0136400638,
0.0018382244,
-0.0806721374,
0.0658055022,
-0.0432568118,
-0.016314039,
-0.0089577194,
0.0639736801,
0.0064506745,
0.0067392052,
0.0196152404,
-0.0158160944,
0.0193642918,
0.0067138532,
0.0883889049,
-0.0067843092,
-0.0491717458,
0.0319937393,
0.017332878,
-0.0138990469,
-0.0496797077,
0.0937813148,
-0.0422666371,
-0.0522135571,
-0.0266357735,
-0.0195967183,
-0.0393557996,
0.0200702064,
-0.0241663046,
-0.0421257392,
0.0409142971,
0.0394475609,
-0.0195122454,
-0.0235574357,
-0.0861014351,
-0.0226643831,
-0.007171324,
-0.0565931462,
-0.0447287299,
-0.063660726,
-0.0044757687,
-0.0020569379,
-0.0455490425,
-0.0154306786,
2.802224937e-34,
0.0527138151,
-0.042540323,
0.0319235325,
0.0388179235,
0.0147115504,
0.0193016846,
-0.0197289307,
0.0035730724,
-0.0045789089,
-0.1031649932,
0.0049087424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03831v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03831v1 | Uncovering Drift in Textual Data: An Unsupervised Method for Detecting and Mitigating Drift in Machine Learning Models | 2023-09-07T16:45:42 | 2023-09-07T16:45:42 | Saeed Khaki, Akhouri Abhinav Aditya, Zohar Karnin, Lan Ma, Olivia Pan, Samarth Marudheri Chandrashekar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Drift in machine learning refers to the phenomenon where the statistical
properties of data or context, in which the model operates, change over time
leading to a decrease in its performance. Therefore, maintaining a constant
monitoring process for machine learning model performance is crucial in order
to proactively prevent any potential performance regression. However,
supervised drift detection methods require human annotation and consequently
lead to a longer time to detect and mitigate the drift. In our proposed
unsupervised drift detection method, we follow a two step process. Our first
step involves encoding a sample of production data as the target distribution,
and the model training data as the reference distribution. In the second step,
we employ a kernel-based statistical test that utilizes the maximum mean
discrepancy (MMD) distance metric to compare the reference and target
distributions and estimate any potential drift. Our method also identifies the
subset of production data that is the root cause of the drift. The models
retrained using these identified high drift samples show improved performance
on online customer experience quality metrics. | [
0.0114329746,
0.0716361031,
-0.0506312847,
0.0259011835,
-0.0361835472,
-0.0115120877,
-0.0097565195,
0.0332022831,
-0.0003003786,
-0.0537655093,
0.036671102,
0.0135774212,
0.0097018257,
0.0605185963,
-0.0087092808,
-0.018452283,
0.0279285964,
-0.020484535,
-0.0236295275,
0.0395917036,
0.0165205151,
-0.0230957028,
-0.0164621901,
-0.0201400835,
-0.0349197462,
-0.0683347806,
-0.0164648648,
0.0096924882,
0.0512454659,
0.001111996,
0.0502974167,
0.031730663,
-0.0244938955,
0.0396043621,
0.00000197,
-0.050593473,
-0.0208349768,
0.0154946502,
-0.0364673287,
0.0227177311,
0.0403586142,
0.0388128906,
-0.026604224,
0.0354987755,
-0.0176347271,
0.0692826584,
0.0399962068,
0.0241371766,
0.0256911479,
0.0576529019,
-0.0197698381,
-0.0193152763,
-0.0360535868,
0.0066266297,
0.0258748438,
-0.0249883216,
0.0381742641,
0.0529567488,
-0.0801435113,
-0.0598382205,
-0.048795443,
0.0188970957,
-0.0101475762,
-0.0154633746,
0.0606035478,
0.0385074094,
-0.0201187395,
0.0265851431,
-0.0090723569,
0.0648670197,
-0.0151290949,
-0.0175004154,
0.0335958526,
-0.0367057398,
0.0132020731,
0.0190744922,
0.029788712,
-0.052504655,
0.008279386,
-0.0107726967,
-0.0788540468,
-0.0276077464,
0.0318232626,
0.0031459881,
-0.0381205082,
0.0202499218,
-0.0171528198,
-0.0629668534,
-0.0196315404,
0.019020414,
0.0154779172,
-0.0369891711,
0.0226695687,
0.0123010501,
-0.0142065091,
0.0088202599,
0.0005448699,
-0.0794375017,
0.0103074145,
-0.1056703106,
0.025408268,
0.0022294514,
-0.0609233938,
0.0202475414,
-0.0292402729,
0.0680195093,
0.032926064,
-0.0115244035,
-0.0129104182,
0.0824541897,
-0.0966262147,
0.0275018662,
0.0163715258,
-0.0074737915,
0.0328818187,
0.0059183529,
-0.0323689692,
0.0783636644,
0.0123324934,
0.0388661772,
-0.0108826663,
-0.0166425314,
-0.0322207958,
0.056187924,
-0.057860069,
0.0055222739,
-0.0306841992,
-0.0062428494,
-0.01882766,
-0.0600168183,
0.0150558567,
0.0158237759,
0.0015608998,
0.0039846348,
-0.0036017417,
0.0434299968,
0.0225056559,
0.0121174138,
-0.0982247591,
-0.042399168,
-0.0257237721,
-0.0170583278,
-0.0374550186,
-0.0130947791,
-0.0135872941,
0.0065555149,
-0.0061322008,
-0.0254393164,
-0.0390155427,
-0.0220759753,
-0.0266064629,
0.041140534,
-0.0040590139,
0.0194189325,
0.0646978468,
-0.0363805629,
-0.0555013455,
0.0831177011,
0.0412533544,
-0.0003150453,
0.0740010589,
-0.0091016358,
-0.0027450447,
0.0103185633,
0.0035215926,
-0.0227719862,
-0.0306532122,
0.017208863,
-0.0283106193,
0.0015085405,
0.0191749707,
-0.0056500882,
0.0136828106,
-0.0246908199,
0.0640089959,
0.0064237504,
-0.0072968593,
-0.0117056491,
-0.0010517571,
-0.0116250766,
-0.059661366,
0.018367786,
0.0015091981,
-0.016694162,
-0.0041280393,
-0.0021154897,
0.014916962,
0.0095667113,
-0.0243899915,
-0.0676743314,
-0.0104648666,
-0.0325074159,
0.0021529179,
0.0008229813,
0.0653891191,
-0.0274451338,
0.0069831549,
0.0135726072,
0.0203158129,
0.0052287057,
0.0032854595,
-0.0200274531,
0.0471255183,
0.0867162794,
0.0147894584,
-0.054435201,
0.0038585614,
-0.0508094542,
0.0339027047,
-0.0284769777,
0.064488247,
-0.030777419,
-0.0117312595,
-0.0148467878,
-0.030135667,
0.0201062728,
0.0065389536,
-0.0256560072,
-0.0148260836,
0.0402256772,
0.0191278029,
-0.0866308287,
-0.0482711382,
0.0500170961,
-0.0191491861,
0.0272814203,
0.0262758788,
0.0029763165,
0.0615337454,
-0.0264718309,
-0.0137310345,
-0.0327031985,
0.0101428926,
0.026982436,
-0.0355967283,
0.0453304984,
0.042431429,
0.0117486306,
0.0417802706,
0.0023758695,
-0.0086821541,
0.0162127111,
-0.0936308876,
-0.007476849,
0.0400826223,
-0.0138271665,
0.0070865103,
-0.0066175987,
0.038050767,
-0.0417920873,
0.025278464,
-0.0537151732,
0.0504658893,
-0.0034320629,
0.0012515441,
-0.0610855035,
0.0228794757,
0.0181823391,
0.0043329871,
0.059467636,
0.0097075347,
-0.0104941949,
0.0542830937,
0.0288984645,
-0.0667665526,
-0.04053827,
0.013441042,
-0.0214124937,
-0.0224246252,
-0.0172364656,
0.0529605933,
0.021260988,
-0.0109553831,
-0.0264470465,
-0.0465906002,
0.0073753982,
-0.0102028279,
-0.0005018701,
0.0090527385,
0.0433137044,
0.0078259995,
-0.0081643285,
-0.0388254598,
-0.002333161,
-0.0089255041,
0.0643167421,
0.0389817506,
-0.0245539732,
-0.1107376963,
0.0039729178,
-0.0608502142,
0.0059910864,
-0.0008238676,
-0.0056933165,
-0.031858135,
0.0228959676,
0.051181037,
0.0794815719,
0.0361966416,
0.0281825252,
0.0265325438,
-0.0012987077,
-0.0405776165,
-0.0056058285,
-0.0171906017,
-0.0096281525,
-0.0100921914,
-0.0272110011,
0.0287255161,
-0.0054957932,
0.0110178338,
-0.0218855832,
-0.0371206366,
0.0099791726,
-0.037445616,
0.0126668066,
-0.0399218053,
0.0481841415,
-0.0252070352,
0.0456778035,
0.003287955,
-0.0602537543,
0.0454238355,
0.029310694,
0.0678454041,
-0.04626045,
-0.0246445108,
0.0037789803,
-0.0461129174,
-0.0039755232,
0.0269368831,
-0.0160053372,
-0.0100168297,
-0.0140369022,
-0.0037212351,
0.0530665442,
-0.0369928665,
0.0008870799,
-0.0130766397,
0.0371054374,
0.0333256051,
0.0344662257,
-0.0748680085,
-0.0469766781,
0.0051594065,
-0.0350668207,
0.010614316,
-0.0248092543,
-0.0369169749,
0.0297727734,
-0.0486666225,
0.0462770052,
0.0076887277,
-0.0353494696,
0.017151041,
0.0054462962,
0.0031773846,
-0.0098350635,
0.0061794193,
-0.055510316,
0.0165130962,
0.00335443,
0.0111245438,
-0.0060579786,
-0.0789636374,
-0.0087770708,
-0.0474085771,
-0.056135457,
0.025167862,
0.0386987031,
-0.0139788063,
-0.0249427948,
-0.0290844329,
0.0888072178,
0.0297435913,
-0.0013535197,
0.0038147673,
-0.0105014993,
0.0434951,
0.0087972311,
0.0382675827,
-0.0444615856,
0.0010139452,
0.0021802881,
0.0707761943,
-0.0071583316,
-0.0093103917,
0.0172561426,
-0.0762943104,
0.0326969624,
-0.0211779159,
-0.0446021706,
-0.0335895345,
-0.0712408721,
0.0108256908,
-0.0337258838,
0.0152655393,
-0.0038092788,
0.0026061691,
0.0155118126,
0.0517410263,
-0.0759931579,
-0.1104789823,
-0.0288267918,
-0.0297626425,
0.0131814713,
0.0962781012,
0.0139772249,
-0.0332287028,
-0.0577641316,
0.0283110812,
-0.016370995,
0.0286610704,
-0.0036390612,
0.1293308735,
-0.0185546596,
-0.0210308619,
0.0267774556,
-0.0049551371,
-0.0050384388,
0.0251669493,
0.033660274,
0.0432657897,
-0.0028917426,
-0.0446674265,
-0.003169745,
-0.0267167725,
0.007486559,
0.0443270132,
-0.0089626415,
-0.033322338,
-0.034917783,
-0.0307613891,
0.0259426758,
0.0431792699,
0.0627352521,
0.017440537,
-0.036985036,
-0.0262551345,
-0.0975940451,
0.001658597,
-0.0439967662,
-0.0110498006,
0.0168254301,
0.0055905054,
-0.0202602372,
0.0048585259,
-0.0721155852,
-0.012230142,
0.0213617496,
0.0482683443,
-0.0302063432,
0.0018224069,
0.0271837339,
0.0012681492,
-0.0463720299,
-0.0416123904,
-0.1118061617,
-0.0821020678,
-0.0152392536,
0.0365481935,
0.0194238815,
0.0719204769,
-0.0154286157,
-0.0313182995,
0.0373830162,
0.0380524695,
-0.0096458429,
0.0089610331,
0.0064619025,
-0.0284004286,
-0.0340290628,
-0.0411833152,
-0.0399988368,
0.0099734003,
-0.0010535904,
-0.033560846,
-0.0291788243,
0.0034818775,
-0.011907394,
-0.0153476829,
0.0460276157,
0.0377818383,
-0.0637046918,
-0.0220103189,
0.0159961395,
0.048398681,
-0.0165700335,
0.0030388865,
-0.0090368921,
0.0180601161,
0.0265706014,
-0.02219899,
0.0521281175,
-0.0181985386,
-0.0175172482,
-0.0417901725,
-0.0289468281,
0.0399644636,
0.0537348874,
-0.0011897592,
0.0248187054,
0.0171859134,
-0.0338253342,
0.0218872409,
0.0412032343,
0.0169315878,
0.046916265,
0.0614495352,
0.0413730592,
0.010319612,
0.001593438,
-0.0364265591,
0.0001548974,
-0.0246154536,
0.0070971963,
0.041611094,
-0.0333120599,
0.0346120894,
-0.0008416514,
0.0129201896,
-0.0272634458,
0.0126636112,
0.027890062,
0.0319506824,
-0.0231128894,
0.0086461641,
-0.0345304348,
0.0447020493,
0.031361673,
0.0060159392,
0.0379153229,
-0.079251796,
-0.0424880199,
-0.0362470746,
0.0569607466,
0.0376039855,
-0.0100300526,
0.0130355097,
-0.0339557566,
-0.0043904516,
-0.0620684288,
0.064157702,
-0.0073372703,
0.0543867536,
-0.0092454348,
0.004391199,
0.0766255036,
0.0029939176,
0.0247632638,
-0.0506713986,
-0.0588992126,
-0.0138905598,
0.0140224025,
-0.0382464938,
-6.101521345e-33,
0.0074415398,
-0.0353671089,
-0.0466224477,
0.0347121656,
-0.0214279965,
0.002192081,
-0.0143753961,
-0.031816557,
0.0110013494,
-0.0137846768,
0.0230412148,
0.0708619729,
0.0213354137,
-0.037866883,
0.0145543208,
-0.0526610091,
0.0535482503,
-0.0383076519,
-0.0350384302,
0.0119823702,
0.0202688519,
0.0541982688,
0.0244079307,
-0.0633903071,
0.0132115493,
-0.0096880067,
-0.0035318844,
-0.0135710277,
0.0260478482,
0.052850157,
-0.0108378949,
0.0469712429,
0.0126791187,
0.0025788508,
-0.0277479738,
-0.0395822488,
0.0043306602,
-0.0065346854,
-0.0500136316,
0.0541717112,
0.0104460046,
0.0294017904,
0.0381020829,
-0.0032734079,
-0.026713213,
0.0228394158,
0.0920170173,
-0.0538295247,
-0.0247891601,
-0.0107684471,
-0.0105391769,
0.0375780016,
-0.0678925887,
0.0109488703,
0.0287391264,
0.0515138395,
0.0407876074,
0.01913324,
-0.0426081158,
0.0024199425,
0.0231342874,
0.0081597716,
0.0736759156,
0.0521341413,
-0.0156312641,
0.0451955833,
0.0114935823,
0.0334026106,
0.0507138446,
-0.0049548405,
0.0509263761,
-0.0041731196,
0.0107043888,
0.0514452495,
0.0373765007,
-0.0535059795,
-0.0437193252,
0.0374765806,
-0.010739537,
-0.0038334525,
0.0173898172,
0.0246121194,
-0.0684372336,
-0.0188366733,
-0.0119179105,
-0.0333062559,
-0.0217478182,
-0.0172619615,
0.0556683801,
0.0157155022,
-0.048027616,
-0.007694649,
0.0207706932,
-0.0571861267,
-0.0308149587,
-0.0162632223,
-0.0377882235,
0.0077900258,
0.0242694858,
-0.0145154549,
-0.0059159757,
-0.0445429757,
0.0014618558,
0.0437320061,
0.0431508161,
-0.0537576154,
0.0268105604,
0.0120052136,
-0.0317357108,
0.0430984199,
0.0142217558,
-0.0198155884,
-0.048677586,
0.0164224207,
-0.0011505731,
-0.0121121723,
-0.019565504,
0.1002392247,
0.0620569587,
0.022359889,
-0.0271263123,
0.0036130324,
0.0105679492,
-0.0114424638,
-0.0308220517,
-0.0275828522,
0.0317581519,
0.0266015884,
0.0103235794,
-0.0586448126,
-0.0079056667,
-0.0367343724,
2.677e-7,
0.0427310839,
0.0845437124,
0.0131215574,
-0.0215380099,
0.0440821573,
0.0120655233,
-0.0453797579,
-0.0094099306,
0.0066845091,
-0.0544841886,
0.0469973497,
-0.0176913328,
0.0487083048,
0.0245360844,
-0.0098191807,
-0.0215669051,
-0.0717099458,
0.0220716819,
-0.0703167319,
0.0112843188,
0.0534358062,
0.0328120664,
0.020774141,
-0.0216495786,
0.0386260971,
-0.0231181607,
0.0232146028,
-0.032354489,
0.0432265289,
0.0163764041,
0.0645481497,
0.0204658285,
-0.0000663589,
0.0303436443,
-0.0610342734,
-0.0186896138,
-0.000151748,
0.0118776187,
0.0030540298,
0.0399608985,
-0.0180046204,
0.0608772188,
0.0337115936,
-0.049376864,
0.035014905,
-0.0038646301,
0.0163805,
-0.0585326217,
-0.0513880029,
-0.0253998209,
0.0600020513,
0.0186699405,
-0.0172277037,
0.0366299786,
-0.0038372772,
0.0243628751,
-0.0193146989,
-0.0627101585,
-0.0025390082,
-0.0253994651,
-0.0238447357,
-0.0338913091,
0.0008390554,
0.0047638575,
0.0110634351,
0.0056059374,
0.0261473209,
2.306135557e-34,
0.0570585728,
0.0039151842,
0.0008890716,
0.0048297527,
0.0147500541,
0.0118760094,
0.0513495021,
-0.0238721929,
0.0080177849,
-0.0152166951,
0.0178240798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03787v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03787v2 | USA: Universal Sentiment Analysis Model & Construction of Japanese Sentiment Text Classification and Part of Speech Dataset | 2023-09-07T15:35:00 | 2023-09-14T05:53:45 | Chengguang Gan, Qinghao Zhang, Tatsunori Mori | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment analysis is a pivotal task in the domain of natural language
processing. It encompasses both text-level sentiment polarity classification
and word-level Part of Speech(POS) sentiment polarity determination. Such
analysis challenges models to understand text holistically while also
extracting nuanced information. With the rise of Large Language Models(LLMs),
new avenues for sentiment analysis have opened. This paper proposes enhancing
performance by leveraging the Mutual Reinforcement Effect(MRE) between
individual words and the overall text. It delves into how word polarity
influences the overarching sentiment of a passage. To support our research, we
annotated four novel Sentiment Text Classification and Part of Speech(SCPOS)
datasets, building upon existing sentiment classification datasets.
Furthermore, we developed a Universal Sentiment Analysis(USA) model, with a
7-billion parameter size. Experimental results revealed that our model
surpassed the performance of gpt-3.5-turbo across all four datasets,
underscoring the significance of MRE in sentiment analysis. | [
0.0414330475,
0.0462695397,
-0.0037309248,
0.0504935235,
-0.0364685245,
0.0528575107,
-0.0390890986,
0.0140550192,
-0.0188215822,
-0.0492297858,
-0.0431849845,
-0.0428221337,
-0.0250849444,
0.026065208,
-0.0400726497,
-0.0670212805,
0.0497573875,
0.0440804064,
0.0324708745,
-0.042448733,
0.0380022116,
0.002924151,
0.0072050923,
-0.0020405301,
-0.0236046053,
0.0022399344,
0.0275739655,
-0.0067029949,
0.0210703071,
-0.0342343301,
0.028163556,
0.0236686673,
-0.0051399092,
-0.0079310304,
0.0000020116,
-0.00466948,
-0.0110602034,
-0.0273381192,
0.0659910589,
0.0036577305,
0.1004784927,
-0.0095582269,
0.0060960823,
0.0199213326,
-0.0545950681,
-0.0145948175,
0.0526853725,
0.0942377672,
0.0678854883,
0.0637507141,
-0.0204756036,
-0.0268114042,
-0.026114041,
-0.0144861927,
0.0038078604,
0.0027753478,
0.0128954658,
-0.029152805,
-0.0469351187,
-0.0105099445,
-0.0178481359,
-0.0073040812,
-0.0074212798,
0.0444890149,
-0.0118275769,
0.0023348189,
0.0222492404,
-0.0128302174,
0.0012849511,
0.0316744186,
0.0163559001,
-0.0104984902,
-0.0085450085,
-0.0165369827,
-0.0408592634,
-0.0043826411,
0.0021414522,
0.0209505744,
0.0138362153,
0.0709293187,
0.0420971848,
0.0614915416,
0.0175314657,
0.0289361589,
-0.0444947407,
0.0646841377,
-0.0148686832,
-0.0756967664,
0.0133834463,
0.0538620315,
-0.016930094,
0.0066882321,
-0.0100083398,
-0.0446437709,
0.0083584227,
0.0286807567,
0.0113122081,
-0.0137604084,
0.0373379663,
-0.1056055576,
-0.0060595721,
-0.0091035869,
-0.028188508,
0.0363992266,
0.0184971765,
-0.0266368445,
-0.0013408781,
-0.0125892432,
-0.004929339,
0.0069191358,
-0.0421894714,
0.0013571336,
0.0401862487,
0.0476769656,
0.0079212645,
-0.013612235,
-0.0930222049,
-0.0323646516,
-0.0550829135,
0.000926104,
0.0445185639,
-0.0167004876,
0.0266781729,
-0.0033977213,
-0.0346463323,
0.049875699,
-0.0732315779,
0.053518407,
-0.0655737147,
0.0132975644,
0.020723559,
0.0270248763,
0.0120281968,
-0.0114086047,
0.043635983,
0.0647868887,
0.0394370109,
-0.0581965633,
-0.0494922847,
-0.0166345481,
-0.0332944132,
-0.0459992476,
0.0219602976,
-0.0271148905,
0.0453473553,
-0.0016641234,
-0.0050599277,
0.0276722014,
0.0202459749,
-0.0103925867,
-0.0200122856,
0.0645947531,
0.0072735446,
-0.017130997,
-0.0317639075,
0.0086046439,
0.0100730229,
0.0437695868,
-0.0077887094,
0.0392712802,
0.065661639,
0.0190581474,
-0.0099832267,
0.0163995791,
0.007584916,
0.0092052408,
-0.0112174777,
0.0164863877,
-0.0231492277,
-0.0395650901,
0.0299054794,
-0.0038811057,
0.0077475151,
-0.0141894612,
0.0494988151,
0.0141613493,
-0.0529451333,
0.0462935865,
-0.0296641793,
0.0299646314,
-0.0253441948,
-0.0164854527,
-0.004073808,
0.0306767784,
-0.0444222875,
0.0044355537,
0.039447885,
0.0051633916,
-0.028546989,
-0.0647092089,
-0.0243644137,
-0.0398384631,
0.0298730619,
0.001772275,
0.0609176122,
-0.0193648022,
-0.0575974919,
-0.0062032947,
0.0826980472,
-0.0971169621,
-0.0013946777,
-0.0066923546,
0.0550815053,
0.0591305941,
-0.0140969697,
-0.0354847126,
0.0163883884,
-0.0065135052,
-0.0350975618,
0.0431269743,
0.0031002015,
0.0307565052,
-0.016032327,
-0.0435993448,
-0.0062763835,
-0.0033517794,
0.0294052921,
0.0462194197,
0.0182026494,
0.0513462275,
-0.0105452482,
0.0512863211,
0.001730885,
0.0028769302,
0.0403068885,
-0.0097364038,
0.0339579023,
0.0389802381,
0.082487911,
0.0361024588,
-0.0519534498,
-0.0072473115,
0.0343208201,
-0.0293503162,
-0.0767912716,
0.0309179351,
-0.0168387834,
-0.0477719195,
-0.0044456772,
-0.0049939994,
-0.0266491286,
0.0338935852,
-0.0119187636,
-0.0042703995,
0.0126869557,
0.0047514765,
0.0307995509,
-0.0496122912,
-0.0078566689,
-0.0335443765,
0.0286104437,
-0.0057098381,
0.0446382426,
-0.0175725687,
0.0116921952,
-0.0380923972,
-0.0427278653,
0.0421269014,
0.0013601785,
-0.0638668835,
0.0258575045,
0.02940825,
0.006339456,
0.0338810422,
0.0038244345,
0.0045746551,
-0.0934102088,
-0.0805709884,
-0.0082031814,
0.0173292551,
0.0323547944,
-0.0003697958,
-0.0018363544,
-0.0300797299,
0.0265963748,
0.0015927078,
-0.0055551417,
-0.0015935431,
0.0199734326,
0.0325076804,
-0.0122624263,
0.0400037095,
-0.0533318594,
0.0034847301,
-0.0027881907,
-0.0055851038,
0.0190134123,
-0.0229561888,
-0.0017137708,
0.035771627,
-0.0260598045,
0.0016988689,
-0.0007909928,
-0.0875726938,
-0.0064426968,
-0.0245807581,
0.0080056051,
0.0298658516,
0.0244119279,
0.0043320917,
0.0347993411,
-0.0327694602,
-0.0218044221,
0.0253629182,
-0.0594638065,
0.0144715235,
0.0101439795,
-0.0309646241,
-0.0035763674,
0.0756040514,
0.027956428,
-0.0238739792,
-0.0614258014,
-0.0271709617,
-0.0467566587,
0.0115795145,
-0.0109754167,
0.0110291215,
-0.0144807743,
-0.0268195365,
0.0078197904,
-0.0390884615,
0.0661375746,
-0.0046176952,
-0.007611786,
-0.0998139903,
0.0049326816,
-0.0658234134,
0.0741339102,
-0.0208163317,
-0.0034900382,
-0.0412187651,
0.0261314865,
0.0205441974,
-0.0252684299,
0.0134076923,
-0.0201907158,
0.0113661764,
0.0173154268,
-0.0016478308,
-0.0022356876,
-0.0455051921,
0.0238359198,
-0.0460219197,
-0.048152104,
-0.0406775214,
0.030308608,
-0.0313506573,
0.0350906327,
-0.0038656588,
0.0069313832,
-0.0779730156,
-0.0160575248,
-0.010397207,
0.0095212348,
-0.0146422964,
0.0287562646,
-0.0554535873,
-0.000313434,
-0.00559997,
-0.0159604326,
0.0234054718,
0.0135795241,
0.0099665327,
-0.0172280595,
-0.0122693852,
0.0275156442,
-0.0023482058,
-0.0087839961,
-0.0496961288,
0.0244899094,
-0.0381921865,
0.0531210899,
0.1094024926,
0.0368793793,
-0.062253233,
-0.0234760214,
0.0008455429,
-0.0054469137,
0.008840329,
0.0022578051,
-0.0342606306,
-0.0436173081,
-0.0178792346,
0.0041666497,
-0.0007154029,
-0.0031160228,
0.034862373,
-0.1276980788,
0.0206826217,
0.0023175513,
-0.0090397075,
-0.0429904573,
-0.0527475998,
-0.0192718487,
-0.0163894445,
-0.0183273125,
-0.0401759632,
0.0043069916,
0.000982107,
-0.0334976651,
-0.0358190611,
0.007753572,
0.0566175394,
-0.0237850603,
0.0170184225,
0.0244494099,
0.0582164824,
-0.0433108583,
-0.0148351723,
0.00137402,
-0.0231911168,
0.0002551793,
-0.0442724973,
0.0741105154,
-0.0338684469,
-0.0296290219,
-0.029310029,
-0.0067427699,
-0.0386001058,
0.0336379558,
0.012594495,
0.0352062173,
0.0146250594,
-0.0470262691,
-0.0451870449,
0.0610373206,
0.0296561774,
0.067032516,
-0.0321417265,
-0.0698800012,
-0.0151134888,
0.012118225,
-0.0118002072,
-0.0343228579,
-0.0093575045,
-0.0570743866,
-0.0230229534,
0.0256073885,
-0.0758387521,
-0.0499392077,
-0.0172085222,
-0.0190455988,
-0.0146841938,
0.0231765602,
0.0116538024,
0.0043273899,
-0.0016663875,
0.0141334198,
0.0272742417,
0.0195517633,
-0.0191396773,
-0.0391998626,
0.0496399701,
-0.0034748965,
-0.0225469731,
-0.0394401997,
0.0147392098,
-0.0422804393,
-0.0194032937,
0.0595535599,
0.0028013247,
-0.0066653895,
0.0383441783,
-0.0208386276,
0.0199845787,
0.0757591203,
-0.0634027421,
0.0278376248,
0.0764559656,
0.0852256343,
0.0155892903,
0.0121854553,
-0.0168224666,
0.0367779098,
0.0152259413,
-0.0180593245,
-0.0022201578,
-0.0015200627,
-0.028286282,
-0.0186041612,
0.0554384068,
0.0280498061,
0.0006731396,
-0.0585470088,
0.0136335138,
-0.0179742035,
-0.0309965592,
-0.0397905149,
-0.0078792898,
0.0190158766,
-0.0200936254,
-0.0929942355,
0.0221415814,
-0.0095135914,
0.012724461,
0.0193940178,
0.0534509122,
0.0582742654,
0.0298288092,
-0.0220829714,
0.0002050836,
-0.0019501445,
-0.0157072339,
0.0166482497,
-0.0406587496,
0.021374004,
0.0592839234,
0.0050509763,
-0.0249763839,
-0.0220022853,
0.014974908,
-0.0207253844,
0.0202923883,
0.0101019461,
0.0234704688,
0.0096246609,
-0.0132190064,
0.0485073924,
-0.0532583371,
-0.0020029137,
0.0307871439,
0.0240013581,
-0.0436622836,
0.0184768606,
0.0219838955,
-0.0105449138,
-0.0363614857,
-0.0171312392,
0.0582133085,
-0.0271598119,
0.0406282619,
0.0445556119,
0.0020347559,
-0.0205112994,
-0.014218756,
0.0815609023,
0.0224137455,
0.001653303,
0.0399615057,
-0.0503490232,
-0.0450931303,
0.0216479711,
-0.0148152886,
0.0160275213,
0.0082966164,
0.0086055202,
0.040377751,
-0.0081218854,
0.0429932699,
-0.0455747992,
0.0129381828,
-0.0639623404,
0.0125183538,
-0.0031500848,
-6.743744234e-33,
-0.0148808025,
0.0052727191,
-0.0304626357,
0.0673021823,
-0.0187770184,
0.0099298209,
0.00325389,
0.0360012762,
0.0068159192,
0.0417594723,
-0.0196483321,
0.0365000404,
0.002593192,
0.0173212439,
0.0470483638,
0.0075232554,
0.0370406657,
-0.0178513154,
0.0084143355,
0.0084326956,
0.0413674377,
0.0069098407,
0.0346657932,
-0.0941097736,
0.0690345839,
0.0089499447,
-0.0511347838,
0.0161157083,
0.0058609494,
0.0375758111,
-0.0295012593,
0.0662100017,
0.0273402147,
-0.0018452717,
0.0111287842,
0.0588389933,
-0.0140411165,
-0.0335246585,
-0.013038747,
-0.0129048964,
-0.0116631016,
-0.0000143264,
-0.002236513,
0.041932445,
-0.0247984026,
-0.0123622464,
0.027230721,
-0.0023178838,
0.0321401805,
-0.0665206239,
-0.0394725613,
0.0370472707,
0.0155732417,
0.0075389617,
0.0473329425,
0.0006159444,
0.0169044752,
0.0567054376,
-0.0333040319,
0.0319084339,
-0.0388606228,
0.0125964219,
-0.0441068038,
-0.0333436616,
0.0348364003,
0.0675001368,
-0.0004526157,
0.017453393,
-0.0180903375,
0.0051501938,
0.0110859191,
0.0062674796,
0.0574029349,
0.093168132,
0.0446158461,
-0.0599160381,
-0.04685333,
0.015704982,
0.0618640035,
0.0088562937,
0.0709339306,
-0.0029947211,
-0.0558142103,
-0.0219270475,
-0.0008713726,
-0.081444256,
-0.0344223194,
-0.0314225219,
-0.0070219235,
0.0328127928,
-0.0428468101,
-0.048299849,
-0.0057073054,
-0.0530120768,
-0.0241568722,
0.0518375598,
-0.04029724,
0.013871639,
0.0069982638,
-0.0261857845,
-0.046844285,
-0.0545802191,
-0.0690804049,
-0.0045698876,
-0.0082318876,
-0.0129871406,
0.0422075093,
0.0116751948,
-0.0843820572,
-0.0003657781,
0.0074865776,
0.0090133715,
0.007091078,
0.025795484,
-0.0180646572,
0.0089766765,
0.0161128826,
0.0587493367,
0.0298734773,
0.0774809122,
-0.018343959,
-0.0249330811,
-0.0027191497,
0.0087058209,
-0.0082010161,
-0.0196921378,
-0.00420189,
-0.0131457541,
0.0051770769,
-0.0564120412,
-0.0213587712,
-0.0376776345,
2.82e-7,
0.0296790581,
0.0855694413,
-0.0180429183,
0.010100293,
0.0043745213,
0.0931616873,
-0.0073334873,
0.0077831475,
0.0161603987,
0.0358691551,
0.0346947834,
0.0058779945,
0.01366081,
0.0215502214,
-0.0959907472,
0.0238187611,
-0.057731241,
-0.0101920925,
-0.0123185162,
0.0000469775,
0.0692480579,
0.0860983431,
0.0655105188,
0.0062589119,
-0.0293659382,
0.0064694416,
0.072337009,
-0.0703002885,
-0.0155487694,
0.0211299825,
-0.0327354297,
-0.0202705413,
-0.0309608355,
-0.0301362313,
-0.0022332012,
0.0602804944,
0.0103409067,
0.059563078,
0.022051733,
-0.0482713878,
0.0265444312,
0.0225063302,
-0.0239287969,
-0.0442629904,
0.0570818894,
-0.0780318528,
-0.0335787274,
-0.0776770264,
0.0111796902,
-0.0066178516,
0.0728332773,
-0.0021548232,
-0.0235955827,
0.0221797973,
-0.0154592972,
-0.0286269449,
-0.0484555624,
-0.0737579092,
-0.0217579547,
-0.0100854347,
-0.0140785007,
-0.0219828263,
-0.0101293754,
0.0708270893,
0.0276127253,
-0.0118804146,
0.0177826788,
2.317196683e-34,
0.0488762483,
-0.0696519315,
-0.0213482417,
-0.0318050943,
0.0432734601,
-0.0075279488,
-0.0452093184,
0.0138451951,
0.0120081808,
-0.0246949829,
0.0190158561
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03748v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03748v1 | Enhancing Pipeline-Based Conversational Agents with Large Language Models | 2023-09-07T14:43:17 | 2023-09-07T14:43:17 | Mina Foosherian, Hendrik Purwins, Purna Rathnayake, Touhidul Alam, Rui Teimao, Klaus-Dieter Thoben | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML, 68T50, I.2.7 | The latest advancements in AI and deep learning have led to a breakthrough in
large language model (LLM)-based agents such as GPT-4. However, many commercial
conversational agent development tools are pipeline-based and have limitations
in holding a human-like conversation. This paper investigates the capabilities
of LLMs to enhance pipeline-based conversational agents during two phases: 1)
in the design and development phase and 2) during operations. In 1) LLMs can
aid in generating training data, extracting entities and synonyms,
localization, and persona design. In 2) LLMs can assist in contextualization,
intent classification to prevent conversational breakdown and handle
out-of-scope questions, auto-correcting utterances, rephrasing responses,
formulating disambiguation questions, summarization, and enabling closed
question-answering capabilities. We conducted informal experiments with GPT-4
in the private banking domain to demonstrate the scenarios above with a
practical example. Companies may be hesitant to replace their pipeline-based
agents with LLMs entirely due to privacy concerns and the need for deep
integration within their existing ecosystems. A hybrid approach in which LLMs'
are integrated into the pipeline-based agents allows them to save time and
costs of building and running agents by capitalizing on the capabilities of
LLMs while retaining the integration and privacy safeguards of their existing
systems. | [
0.0752649307,
0.0640842319,
-0.0441054143,
0.0398024321,
-0.0389351994,
0.0139930276,
0.0643452853,
-0.0358887725,
0.0685190856,
-0.0419425778,
-0.023842318,
-0.0403016023,
-0.0203430224,
0.0753319934,
0.0007048966,
-0.0380128995,
0.0157197397,
-0.023909444,
0.0257256161,
-0.0088456515,
-0.0014949698,
0.0355517678,
-0.0064761769,
0.0490463302,
0.0034914713,
-0.0327460468,
-0.0226164944,
-0.0260976367,
0.0004773948,
0.0151702752,
0.0149000529,
0.026318159,
0.0688781068,
0.052496586,
0.0000021025,
-0.0752151385,
-0.0266879648,
0.0041687591,
-0.0744230151,
-0.0242156498,
0.014677031,
-0.0008070658,
-0.0036068875,
0.0268769898,
-0.0361449271,
-0.0119884918,
0.0354808047,
0.0234927703,
0.0663802773,
0.0567630418,
-0.0225397199,
-0.0596426651,
0.0159199145,
-0.0251883902,
-0.0136113781,
-0.1121705845,
0.0180707797,
-0.0215131417,
0.0086035552,
0.0199228954,
0.0172804166,
0.0387522615,
0.0288636368,
-0.0129190087,
-0.0007794646,
0.0377980061,
-0.0083802678,
-0.0492436923,
-0.0283705629,
0.0810733065,
0.0136905443,
0.012974794,
-0.0051533948,
-0.024061298,
0.0364260599,
-0.0340154208,
-0.0320611037,
0.053005863,
-0.0139332088,
-0.0249397624,
-0.0313546695,
-0.030478308,
0.0060283341,
0.0090404665,
-0.0557784364,
0.0577143617,
0.0058671837,
-0.0051348116,
-0.0162771121,
-0.0068823188,
0.030467527,
-0.0722999945,
0.0396546051,
0.033851888,
-0.0367043763,
0.0424127281,
-0.0189914256,
0.0111660436,
0.0109592238,
-0.0315126181,
-0.0471540131,
0.0058115083,
0.016358139,
0.0488756821,
-0.0167680979,
0.0577652156,
-0.0295640957,
0.0044604973,
-0.0142021785,
-0.0418614224,
-0.0749217346,
-0.0215948839,
-0.0554140359,
0.07024616,
-0.0690594837,
-0.0332155824,
-0.0302902982,
0.0795434341,
0.0062049017,
0.0451425985,
-0.0208129194,
0.0122683663,
-0.0003903724,
-0.0291534774,
-0.0688441917,
0.0213013999,
-0.0348788686,
0.0048353225,
0.0091081914,
-0.0868461207,
0.0166655127,
0.0155421877,
-0.0045255171,
-0.0129870633,
-0.0079646967,
0.0836805552,
0.0103173526,
-0.0470931344,
-0.0157534964,
-0.031168839,
0.0141293015,
-0.080973722,
-0.0380596109,
-0.0350375138,
0.0346223526,
0.0033284714,
-0.0296146758,
-0.0361589529,
0.0249251854,
0.0093355272,
-0.0084170913,
0.0558820628,
0.0042407219,
0.0232904274,
0.0553680994,
0.0047205924,
-0.014051728,
0.0481351949,
0.0246911775,
0.0158984866,
0.0635772198,
-0.0258346479,
0.0243578348,
0.0244819634,
-0.0301047843,
-0.0361278281,
0.0604198501,
0.0323207565,
-0.0131142605,
0.0192929134,
0.012951741,
0.0569847822,
-0.0197622292,
0.0104401326,
0.071792759,
0.0609322786,
0.0225263759,
0.0218520891,
0.0375508443,
0.0782976672,
-0.0108618261,
-0.0144986268,
-0.0523343645,
0.0181182604,
-0.0032228774,
0.0059979563,
-0.0356866568,
0.0459208228,
-0.0580348223,
-0.0154644297,
0.0317971371,
-0.0153116956,
0.0171290487,
0.0471875705,
0.0322258621,
-0.0079437066,
-0.0603380725,
0.0662598461,
-0.0242046528,
-0.0271075908,
-0.0253050141,
-0.050958816,
0.014724507,
0.1106100306,
0.0369745046,
-0.0065801907,
-0.030789759,
-0.0536947362,
-0.0291775465,
0.0616224967,
0.0540183075,
-4.036e-7,
0.0083443895,
-0.0411587395,
-0.0193423722,
-0.0363269672,
-0.0118227936,
0.036380589,
0.0106514487,
0.0138691282,
0.0254159905,
0.0088621574,
0.0055553862,
0.0085788211,
-0.0538140647,
-0.013822916,
0.0258913226,
0.018451618,
0.0117003405,
0.0528821498,
0.0167918466,
-0.0093841013,
0.0241909698,
0.008810549,
-0.0318771005,
0.0144884782,
-0.029208634,
0.0268380549,
0.0001241868,
0.0134867085,
-0.0170627888,
0.003797601,
-0.014484698,
-0.0401124917,
0.000899312,
-0.0297310464,
0.0548552051,
-0.0580738857,
0.027452426,
-0.0185722448,
0.020827882,
-0.0273265652,
0.0539278761,
0.0278699938,
-0.0229090713,
-0.0179569069,
0.0433614589,
-0.0001487532,
-0.0337153375,
0.0076488005,
0.0330027528,
0.0054642125,
0.0061399606,
0.0459173322,
0.0042031636,
-0.0508899428,
-0.0209869668,
-0.0888610631,
0.0201359745,
-0.0127222668,
-0.0037491992,
0.0127915833,
0.0405245274,
-0.0087575605,
-0.0252065565,
-0.0536927395,
0.0327408686,
0.0111190211,
0.0405821428,
0.0578315705,
0.0247564167,
-0.0747169778,
-0.0175148807,
0.0168874487,
-0.0004942851,
0.0132716084,
0.0078333747,
-0.0533277951,
-0.0458167456,
0.0158426631,
-0.0334902033,
0.0281739868,
0.0061095604,
-0.0130296033,
0.0112764342,
-0.0039456864,
0.0025557491,
0.0397548005,
-0.0028540178,
0.0457922034,
-0.0095018065,
-0.014222024,
-0.0463000201,
0.0277224705,
-0.0157957077,
-0.0314163603,
-0.0569444411,
0.0305556245,
0.0295070969,
-0.0000725701,
-0.0076775094,
-0.0014838668,
-0.0446198694,
0.0093383072,
0.0212209877,
-0.0346164741,
0.0094323503,
-0.0201333743,
-0.0238149147,
0.0424428247,
0.0108504109,
-0.0271101501,
0.0696452707,
0.0060597775,
-0.0245644487,
-0.0565944426,
-0.0601159893,
-0.0549190119,
0.0722306147,
-0.0483149961,
0.028803654,
-0.0273988415,
-0.0894284174,
-0.0285854619,
-0.0147111285,
0.0039009138,
-0.0191607848,
0.0464518629,
-0.0534602366,
0.0129683092,
0.0032145137,
-0.0401772521,
-0.0597128905,
-0.0177926589,
-0.0324186124,
0.0241652671,
0.0358975455,
-0.0104333432,
-0.0472266413,
0.0276023429,
0.006647415,
0.0463577472,
0.0033898812,
-0.0035272988,
-0.031213101,
-0.0191251505,
0.0346885957,
0.0196310915,
0.0212354437,
-0.0063992343,
0.105639033,
0.0131425811,
0.0094621945,
-0.0307430569,
-0.0029943574,
-0.0430227034,
-0.0112584988,
-0.0639279261,
-0.0258523338,
-0.0003634972,
0.0454468988,
-0.0655695945,
-0.0213702414,
0.1061638668,
0.0274299141,
-0.0552261658,
-0.014434116,
0.0083245216,
-0.0071494132,
0.0094340136,
0.0290463753,
-0.074332431,
-0.0053723375,
0.0011575893,
-0.0122898286,
-0.00452442,
-0.0353358835,
-0.0157289859,
-0.1124007627,
0.0460886918,
-0.0298969708,
-0.0323121659,
-0.030310601,
-0.0206567291,
0.0076377019,
0.0254815053,
0.0532750115,
-0.0187341217,
0.0092452066,
-0.0427575484,
-0.0158443097,
-0.0366454236,
-0.0264674034,
0.0163441896,
-0.0478420071,
0.0298367906,
0.071955204,
0.0177717656,
0.0065250867,
-0.0070459475,
0.0298777036,
-0.0137494821,
0.0143878087,
0.029067507,
0.0469332226,
-0.024179725,
-0.0027427657,
-0.010684629,
0.0394270048,
-0.0390748046,
0.0177933313,
0.02124325,
0.0528342463,
-0.0313555747,
-0.0093940869,
0.0063169347,
0.0080493735,
0.0170836803,
0.0879629403,
-0.0076020835,
-0.0593552068,
-0.0403391868,
-0.0095112929,
-0.0183941927,
-0.0128861349,
0.0398752354,
0.0189908519,
0.0073866118,
-0.008240982,
-0.0541261025,
-0.0849507973,
0.0548160709,
0.0139442319,
0.0205393787,
0.0213965829,
0.0541482083,
0.0280877259,
0.0115642119,
-0.0153435087,
-0.0587260649,
0.0619163364,
-0.0263012983,
-0.0018101279,
0.036998,
-0.0249148626,
-0.0134379491,
0.0184253529,
-0.07937859,
-0.0447244793,
-0.0096565103,
0.0161291659,
0.0252907518,
0.0337816402,
-0.0180340949,
-0.0367970578,
0.0263433866,
0.009798944,
-0.0858339742,
-0.0220302809,
0.0190124027,
0.0481180139,
-0.0206805803,
0.0406503528,
-0.0803053752,
-0.0106044766,
-0.0212908108,
0.0171502195,
-0.0335817821,
-0.0829856098,
0.0240269918,
0.0136752538,
-0.0424734764,
0.041217979,
-0.0130732739,
-0.0406192355,
0.0238513835,
-0.027392596,
0.0032785295,
-0.0267231297,
-0.0016654723,
0.0187441949,
-0.0273102708,
0.0605657846,
-0.0056042909,
-0.0271314271,
0.0115383416,
0.0013067371,
0.0134520968,
0.0223536287,
-0.0011019531,
0.0006435707,
-0.0092148762,
-0.0213069394,
0.0455307774,
0.0160708502,
0.0426564664,
-0.0003178993,
0.0677295327,
0.0036732599,
-0.0094934935,
-0.0034950175,
0.0318762586,
-0.0712357461,
-0.0879167244,
0.0371791348,
0.0699980557,
0.0154768946,
0.0235289503,
0.0165468138,
-0.0512745231,
0.0076713744,
-0.0058741318,
0.0135367196,
0.0108089875,
-0.0570627749,
0.0051850574,
0.0122790346,
-0.0329869315,
-0.0053333137,
0.050301645,
-0.0284019336,
0.0362981781,
-0.0242209118,
-0.0142851174,
-0.0617229566,
-0.0365693346,
0.0341446176,
0.0529401936,
-0.0060382867,
-0.0112596126,
-0.058534883,
-0.039843481,
-0.0290457513,
-0.0325758643,
-0.0364688188,
-0.0355652981,
0.0267101992,
0.0626078323,
0.0244435333,
-0.0368542038,
-0.0604342557,
0.0244679619,
-0.0310801473,
-0.0044342643,
-0.0384846926,
-5.90892835e-33,
-0.0208203588,
-0.0289158113,
0.0377626903,
0.0154510206,
-0.0327355936,
-0.0057731695,
-0.027106721,
-0.0079948055,
-0.0387886874,
0.0015458736,
-0.0221999604,
0.0298550352,
0.0218421426,
0.01108866,
-0.0321539789,
-0.0095044523,
0.047732953,
-0.0096741142,
0.0141099943,
0.0851788819,
0.0283929184,
0.0383408852,
0.0169313271,
-0.0650082976,
0.0284841787,
0.002483899,
-0.0134680588,
0.0504983813,
0.0040726638,
0.0592558868,
-0.0278937817,
0.0371326059,
0.006559113,
-0.0558275692,
0.0003010612,
0.0534950159,
-0.05608695,
-0.0141392304,
0.0222703218,
0.0219327789,
0.0041970178,
-0.0531418473,
0.0354179144,
-0.0405430309,
0.011409888,
0.0111007737,
0.0249619931,
-0.0044878931,
0.0083642071,
-0.0067346888,
-0.0791068748,
0.006994714,
-0.0128604667,
0.0170154758,
0.0225827452,
0.0177978054,
0.0211050063,
-0.0192215666,
-0.0475194044,
0.0139668407,
-0.0003857219,
-0.0582208782,
0.0454114117,
0.0194569752,
0.0044726045,
0.0290071554,
0.0472039431,
0.0376789011,
-0.0063275993,
-0.008121701,
0.0183078852,
0.0429290533,
-0.0195860229,
0.0370808393,
-0.0635914356,
-0.0240204856,
-0.0182994064,
0.0179667752,
0.0427117012,
0.0424576588,
0.0513196029,
-0.0051774695,
-0.0520325564,
-0.0033230712,
-0.0237952657,
-0.0003841321,
-0.0305688418,
-0.0251647923,
0.0362872109,
0.0047801104,
-0.0111259473,
0.0060758311,
0.0437507741,
-0.0702131838,
-0.0133234141,
0.0313855633,
-0.0091157891,
0.0031912802,
0.0201285332,
0.0308393613,
-0.0565232225,
-0.0174721107,
0.0085939681,
0.0146046979,
0.0196598265,
0.027578013,
-0.0322452299,
-0.0048344205,
-0.034725178,
0.0120240413,
-0.0393509753,
0.0540243424,
-0.0387970842,
0.048079364,
-0.009600007,
0.0115708522,
-0.0093309209,
0.0625488758,
0.0041205371,
0.0069624539,
-0.0428925119,
0.0281682368,
0.0107792737,
0.0244347565,
-0.0362929031,
-0.0094200484,
-0.0152578596,
0.0225753598,
0.0756834596,
-0.038958896,
-0.0098779965,
-0.015187961,
2.8e-7,
-0.0117044207,
0.023590859,
0.0207755566,
0.0440328605,
0.0300835166,
0.0595001094,
0.0442355759,
0.0206050612,
0.0038459112,
-0.0178537853,
0.0180016067,
0.034113232,
0.0123694604,
0.0218837839,
-0.1044170111,
-0.0314394012,
0.0050671902,
-0.0029868633,
-0.0899464712,
0.0138404053,
0.0634620935,
0.0867991745,
0.0211184993,
-0.0460439138,
-0.0092500029,
-0.0419121161,
0.0218561757,
-0.0255686603,
-0.0144328205,
0.0355512686,
0.0186605006,
0.0450500771,
-0.0019464905,
0.0393156335,
0.0170678888,
0.032769829,
-0.0250033271,
0.0642460957,
-0.0041372832,
-0.0334601998,
-0.0083053801,
-0.0247096252,
0.0184747484,
-0.084309049,
0.0417842194,
-0.0496517122,
-0.0299180299,
-0.0251036957,
-0.0164543707,
-0.0598854162,
-0.0225013494,
0.0000885327,
-0.0093545169,
0.0229360051,
0.0105157979,
-0.0365437604,
0.026173275,
-0.0668917894,
0.0512203537,
-0.0339528583,
-0.0473139547,
-0.0258535929,
-0.0240278263,
-0.0041961288,
0.0264131855,
-0.0275832862,
0.0542080849,
2.424080573e-34,
0.0170005839,
0.0132126212,
0.0075780633,
0.047326114,
0.0564864278,
0.0258606598,
0.0092781959,
0.0199758057,
0.0342673883,
-0.0839342028,
-0.0035818894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03747v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03747v1 | The Daunting Dilemma with Sentence Encoders: Success on Standard Benchmarks, Failure in Capturing Basic Semantic Properties | 2023-09-07T14:42:35 | 2023-09-07T14:42:35 | Yash Mahajan, Naman Bansal, Shubhra Kanti Karmaker | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we adopted a retrospective approach to examine and compare
five existing popular sentence encoders, i.e., Sentence-BERT, Universal
Sentence Encoder (USE), LASER, InferSent, and Doc2vec, in terms of their
performance on downstream tasks versus their capability to capture basic
semantic properties. Initially, we evaluated all five sentence encoders on the
popular SentEval benchmark and found that multiple sentence encoders perform
quite well on a variety of popular downstream tasks. However, being unable to
find a single winner in all cases, we designed further experiments to gain a
deeper understanding of their behavior. Specifically, we proposed four semantic
evaluation criteria, i.e., Paraphrasing, Synonym Replacement, Antonym
Replacement, and Sentence Jumbling, and evaluated the same five sentence
encoders using these criteria. We found that the Sentence-Bert and USE models
pass the paraphrasing criterion, with SBERT being the superior between the two.
LASER dominates in the case of the synonym replacement criterion.
Interestingly, all the sentence encoders failed the antonym replacement and
jumbling criteria. These results suggest that although these popular sentence
encoders perform quite well on the SentEval benchmark, they still struggle to
capture some basic semantic properties, thus, posing a daunting dilemma in NLP
research. | [
0.039739158,
0.0354712084,
-0.0142194852,
0.0348185226,
-0.0929820389,
-0.008495071,
-0.0472195633,
-0.0034780651,
-0.0748932511,
-0.0658849105,
-0.0005994961,
0.0470056571,
-0.014084165,
-0.0118163154,
-0.0102578457,
-0.0894268453,
0.0415242501,
0.0257348903,
-0.0330633968,
0.0086633246,
0.017251268,
-0.0016868602,
0.0227187164,
0.0391140729,
-0.0214857161,
0.00717152,
-0.0089894468,
0.0260126833,
0.0090930127,
-0.0147000439,
0.0384567976,
0.0136040905,
0.0110584879,
-0.0043531577,
0.0000019165,
-0.0657044873,
-0.0211399123,
-0.0213361364,
0.0166075677,
0.0194779057,
0.0666177794,
-0.0636217296,
0.0205285121,
0.0136742769,
-0.0025322142,
0.0311634466,
0.0192686804,
0.0075356886,
0.078873679,
0.0463593788,
-0.0331939161,
-0.0661494583,
0.0123054469,
-0.0044449554,
-0.0117594069,
-0.0448592044,
0.0027718882,
-0.0100178681,
0.0032092945,
0.0138813592,
-0.055717092,
0.0292681474,
0.0310900863,
0.0349981524,
0.0490106046,
-0.0022820681,
-0.0588149652,
-0.0201015081,
-0.0235157739,
0.0291003976,
-0.0274876431,
-0.0124031371,
-0.0146673592,
0.0084235193,
0.0091557801,
0.0345968232,
-0.0252708532,
-0.0020039757,
0.0154946782,
0.0264133643,
0.0218544472,
0.0180692468,
-0.027100455,
-0.0009391953,
-0.0120494245,
0.0390043482,
0.0551412217,
-0.0741238445,
0.0026880477,
0.036693383,
-0.0266170949,
-0.0232017916,
0.0234730225,
-0.0162240509,
-0.0032141323,
0.0174824465,
-0.0765060633,
-0.0363768041,
0.0186674222,
-0.0529159904,
0.0473580509,
0.0293543488,
0.0154521829,
0.0288469046,
-0.0597786941,
0.0741166547,
0.0195411127,
0.0550642833,
-0.0674219057,
-0.0578173846,
-0.0608501174,
0.0052411337,
-0.07633885,
0.0773620009,
-0.0473160632,
-0.0595329702,
-0.0331210718,
0.0081131784,
0.0313331448,
0.0069301901,
-0.0087315263,
-0.0006263999,
-0.0245660841,
0.022850005,
-0.0355395451,
0.0272643752,
-0.0279508308,
0.0253763217,
-0.0026143158,
-0.0204326529,
-0.0029506783,
0.0153859621,
0.0361539647,
-0.032193426,
0.0409936681,
0.0473630391,
-0.0122901713,
-0.0448309779,
-0.0021212187,
-0.0123285269,
-0.0246576555,
-0.035532508,
-0.0153926574,
-0.0419719964,
0.0360589698,
0.0289154742,
0.0020943987,
-0.0182997901,
0.0286926255,
0.0316029638,
-0.0344909802,
0.0570064634,
-0.0056639384,
-0.0060270275,
-0.0308399182,
-0.01457009,
0.0108489133,
0.0284999982,
0.0410512239,
0.0350082219,
0.065495953,
0.0042835507,
-0.0174125731,
0.0011425483,
-0.0007203854,
-0.0193420183,
-0.0270113945,
0.0010034322,
0.0040929937,
0.0309583917,
-0.0073146541,
0.0889217034,
-0.048119273,
0.0199578702,
0.0508201793,
0.0147402184,
-0.0063428199,
-0.0113183595,
0.0330028385,
-0.0033122613,
0.0106335692,
0.0103642428,
-0.0065819062,
-0.0109490855,
0.0343557335,
0.0171036273,
0.0088575957,
-0.0013632512,
-0.0149994427,
-0.0162729695,
-0.0464772284,
-0.0426542684,
-0.0153494254,
-0.0665435791,
0.0295927357,
0.037693657,
-0.0557788089,
0.0723889172,
-0.0077401837,
-0.0850048587,
0.0098948469,
0.002804993,
-0.0612878501,
0.0656200126,
0.0902712569,
0.0083938558,
-0.0248075388,
-0.0003253962,
-0.054154668,
0.045705758,
0.0169595852,
0.0013603925,
-0.0016974243,
-0.0498916954,
-0.0247447919,
-0.1010638699,
0.0163966436,
-0.0269374829,
0.030704163,
0.033033561,
0.017332362,
-0.0768070891,
0.0018197934,
0.0594865456,
0.0312396362,
0.0100520859,
-0.0030088173,
0.00735055,
0.0189394988,
-0.0003533094,
0.0000768342,
0.0289654192,
0.0175440442,
-0.0900931731,
-0.0437490717,
0.0277366024,
-0.0255292449,
-0.1137200445,
-0.0061732195,
-0.0998287573,
0.0063234721,
0.0831443071,
-0.0414200984,
-0.0215005446,
0.0003008322,
-0.0722664446,
0.0536222123,
-0.0345279351,
0.0250082966,
0.0002397794,
0.0206775907,
0.0024410423,
0.0540823489,
-0.0102309342,
-0.0167481843,
-0.0282324813,
0.0234372672,
0.0213778932,
0.0267940965,
-0.0577789061,
-0.022959685,
-0.0004103191,
-0.0223982818,
0.0237714928,
0.0058561917,
-0.0310375243,
-0.0651791692,
-0.0761720538,
0.0279580858,
-0.0247479789,
0.0062292549,
0.0626814738,
0.0236254595,
0.0231255684,
0.0087893642,
0.0050952188,
0.035752926,
-0.0147236148,
0.0390911661,
0.0736909285,
0.0002797942,
-0.0267705191,
-0.033384338,
0.0008636016,
0.0187487584,
0.0428342558,
-0.010153383,
-0.02218212,
-0.0127492007,
0.0449274257,
-0.0138247525,
-0.0356208235,
0.0189087205,
-0.0670861676,
-0.0174045432,
0.0273273997,
0.0141556403,
0.0335207321,
0.0575791895,
0.0634614453,
0.0093159778,
0.0205643419,
-0.0085086226,
-0.0035091625,
-0.0325315855,
-0.0195628963,
-0.0357696079,
0.0001056736,
0.0555284768,
0.0187580492,
0.0226943698,
0.0402628146,
-0.0196200702,
0.0039400221,
-0.0151178604,
-0.0148480665,
-0.0368898287,
-0.0322568081,
-0.0363662094,
0.0044227308,
-0.0224214047,
0.0242148619,
0.0545009971,
-0.0004293936,
-0.0226253308,
-0.0749924108,
0.0103586651,
-0.043042466,
0.0530932173,
-0.0188761037,
0.0354588106,
-0.0585081093,
-0.0250590835,
-0.0111939898,
-0.0357644446,
0.0533337817,
-0.0104343761,
-0.0228169225,
-0.0130892629,
0.0237988662,
-0.0204121787,
-0.0788219422,
-0.0366070494,
-0.0841251239,
0.0141534694,
0.0300521944,
0.0593084358,
0.0438342988,
-0.0164061822,
0.008117036,
-0.0174855776,
0.0198230296,
-0.010240878,
-0.0065394691,
-0.0646427125,
0.0542409308,
0.061127115,
-0.006063181,
-0.0053772647,
-0.0135244858,
0.0115275346,
0.0447330251,
-0.021000443,
-0.0192442313,
-0.0222925674,
0.0033627818,
-0.0180615112,
-0.054638762,
-0.0109978486,
-0.037277583,
0.0494209528,
-0.0371888727,
-0.0304665882,
0.1111906543,
0.0236042086,
0.028939236,
0.0094477255,
0.0010310927,
0.0101780603,
-0.0191413276,
-0.0206335895,
-0.0895952582,
-0.0650418699,
0.018990064,
0.0181499459,
0.0173317026,
-0.0103437938,
0.0063091186,
-0.1145144776,
0.0161031913,
-0.0160301402,
0.0169591643,
-0.0215523057,
-0.026695637,
-0.0036851275,
-0.0005865542,
0.0338218622,
-0.0018821544,
-0.0044086953,
0.0233595241,
-0.0287819244,
-0.0123287402,
-0.0353900455,
0.0077014114,
-0.0357779562,
-0.0088690538,
0.0511684604,
0.0508325659,
0.0025995073,
-0.0333907753,
0.0624612495,
-0.0510800816,
0.0015818344,
0.0145301269,
0.0924016088,
-0.026871847,
-0.0064819413,
-0.0071134209,
0.0081017697,
-0.0304762032,
-0.0083479034,
0.0004938826,
0.0283199511,
-0.0113557447,
-0.0242092535,
-0.0210698117,
-0.0071935328,
-0.0182869025,
0.1081232578,
0.0208414886,
-0.023224419,
-0.0785371065,
0.0100302678,
0.0046662958,
-0.0581816584,
0.0192548987,
-0.0089759231,
-0.0002072903,
-0.0092938533,
-0.082718946,
-0.0890305936,
-0.0082595833,
0.0101077724,
0.0040333648,
0.0373004861,
0.0005224927,
0.0047695609,
-0.0230694059,
-0.0322611965,
0.0087474072,
0.0064058965,
0.0038022704,
0.0163152944,
0.0426023379,
0.0543125384,
-0.02933513,
-0.0445049405,
-0.0026561858,
-0.0161656365,
0.0159756839,
0.0355578586,
0.0178580955,
0.0204088092,
-0.0138701377,
0.0214638375,
0.0374362655,
0.0311634969,
-0.0306703653,
0.0426083617,
0.0341285802,
0.0017859072,
-0.000070682,
0.0449408367,
-0.0238182135,
-0.0015168682,
-0.0057649994,
0.0684212148,
0.0363581888,
-0.0575412735,
0.0411346778,
0.0336666405,
0.0365867056,
-0.0093816333,
0.0074952734,
0.0154502159,
0.0215427149,
-0.0410749316,
-0.0166068412,
-0.0533677079,
0.0155368336,
0.0354925729,
0.0570088737,
-0.0252798442,
0.0509930663,
-0.0138841271,
-0.0186403617,
0.0345224626,
0.0072734221,
-0.0043505025,
0.0223552138,
-0.0166862775,
-0.0032493058,
-0.0398126766,
-0.0159034841,
-0.0140956929,
0.0134134544,
-0.0437494107,
-0.0056729652,
0.0355809852,
-0.0129432762,
-0.0174578875,
0.0622144006,
-0.0552220941,
0.0154138794,
-0.0290098004,
0.0199394319,
0.0383269563,
0.0202252977,
0.0627559572,
-0.0345149487,
-0.0178518351,
0.0189120695,
0.0398129225,
-0.002000506,
-0.0128978072,
0.0055398704,
-0.0294928588,
-0.0136604197,
-0.0355050005,
0.02915629,
-0.0608805045,
0.0575477034,
-0.0019833057,
-0.0052763931,
-0.0442800261,
-0.0124378186,
0.0132899052,
0.0114456629,
0.0179522336,
0.0107453698,
-0.0397736654,
-0.0017936656,
0.02639989,
0.011811763,
0.0100519313,
0.0064425142,
0.0433421507,
0.0370163321,
0.0238230843,
-0.0172830671,
-0.039228417,
0.0270743258,
-0.014976141,
-0.0298603717,
-0.0398389697,
-6.170157358e-33,
-0.0411799029,
0.0373536721,
-0.0297580063,
-0.0123775033,
-0.038183216,
-0.0081447139,
-0.035491731,
-0.0299110133,
0.0121392775,
0.0239667464,
0.0108530894,
-0.0327722393,
0.0075757978,
0.0286768004,
0.0308235325,
-0.0345744789,
0.0676609948,
0.0056744944,
-0.0441807881,
-0.0187161807,
0.0500384755,
0.0241243094,
0.0586879253,
-0.0257794727,
-0.0321570076,
0.0209715609,
0.0070895175,
-0.0221567005,
0.0467687547,
0.016876122,
0.0159325711,
0.0340751372,
0.0127176605,
-0.001024105,
-0.0187911019,
0.0089981304,
-0.0764152333,
-0.0408976823,
0.0321209542,
0.0213742778,
-0.0672644079,
-0.0519947372,
0.0350630656,
-0.0026421305,
-0.0413212068,
0.0044330093,
0.0188408718,
-0.0116495294,
0.0352697968,
-0.0259086825,
-0.0782225206,
-0.0148273539,
0.011473218,
-0.0189935248,
-0.0193777457,
0.0269168038,
-0.0037668897,
0.0297027193,
-0.0474654362,
-0.0222234819,
-0.0328955241,
0.0414456427,
0.013694902,
-0.0252487585,
0.0006942743,
0.080385156,
-0.0232425537,
-0.0161561593,
0.0093835918,
0.0328192674,
0.0150441239,
0.0714971572,
0.0695291385,
0.0786399171,
0.0576296113,
0.0243808124,
-0.03759389,
0.0438091718,
-0.00153473,
0.0357555263,
0.030450413,
0.0090161329,
-0.0213611908,
0.00444334,
-0.0236588009,
-0.0039901268,
-0.0057006762,
-0.0402885415,
0.0669421852,
-0.0167661682,
0.0046043275,
0.013765825,
0.0342941619,
-0.0394288823,
-0.02321003,
0.0100903893,
-0.0324361026,
0.0431559086,
-0.0111813778,
0.0198781751,
-0.0285367537,
-0.0262499917,
0.032662604,
0.0540745072,
0.0083494242,
-0.0025085323,
0.0457199328,
-0.0145913176,
-0.0265011042,
0.0125438254,
-0.0221623536,
-0.019895196,
-0.0574339442,
-0.0607876927,
0.0044316188,
0.0489327312,
-0.0179157201,
0.009296122,
0.0300895162,
0.0119010638,
-0.0408225991,
-0.0317178294,
0.0498651788,
0.0141247595,
0.0028703744,
0.0243339073,
-0.0576768555,
0.0206282996,
-0.0138116116,
-0.0353408419,
0.0124380989,
-0.018470075,
2.786e-7,
0.0721547082,
0.0397816524,
0.0521976165,
-0.0142040849,
0.0074513457,
0.0183835048,
0.0109437974,
0.0492200777,
-0.0168346167,
0.0071693477,
0.0218331963,
-0.0060199937,
0.0419502705,
-0.025236601,
-0.0927003473,
0.0220881179,
-0.0639387816,
-0.0410479791,
-0.0713355839,
0.0403058603,
0.1277838498,
0.0630088598,
0.028038986,
-0.0069995048,
-0.053985659,
-0.0214614384,
0.0696324259,
-0.0229934417,
-0.0432498269,
0.0267855022,
-0.0175697673,
0.018810004,
0.033069551,
0.0304647144,
-0.0113473274,
0.0430657901,
0.0270406622,
0.0202496313,
-0.0256016366,
-0.0509580299,
-0.0277183913,
0.0012541353,
-0.0079587949,
-0.060063526,
0.0898681208,
-0.0571591854,
-0.0182553791,
-0.0072415587,
-0.0668650195,
0.0625935346,
0.0257084332,
0.0044000125,
-0.0456540249,
-0.022590898,
0.0378764533,
0.029001886,
-0.0489668325,
-0.0539872684,
0.0149253421,
0.0235668402,
-0.0019683542,
-0.0379715711,
-0.0263585225,
0.0426976755,
0.0321734287,
-0.0600111187,
-0.0217241365,
2.509139758e-34,
0.0339453146,
0.0049858945,
0.0426629148,
0.0367975309,
0.0209759176,
-0.013518081,
-0.0186123997,
0.0012090636,
-0.0334483981,
-0.0409510918,
0.0079542864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03713v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03713v1 | Word segmentation granularity in Korean | 2023-09-07T13:42:05 | 2023-09-07T13:42:05 | Jungyeul Park, Mija Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper describes word {segmentation} granularity in Korean language
processing. From a word separated by blank space, which is termed an eojeol, to
a sequence of morphemes in Korean, there are multiple possible levels of word
segmentation granularity in Korean. For specific language processing and corpus
annotation tasks, several different granularity levels have been proposed and
utilized, because the agglutinative languages including Korean language have a
one-to-one mapping between functional morpheme and syntactic category. Thus, we
analyze these different granularity levels, presenting the examples of Korean
language processing systems for future reference. Interestingly, the
granularity by separating only functional morphemes including case markers and
verbal endings, and keeping other suffixes for morphological derivation results
in the optimal performance for phrase structure parsing. This contradicts
previous best practices for Korean language processing, which has been the de
facto standard for various applications that require separating all morphemes. | [
0.0493672863,
-0.0172547381,
-0.0279491395,
0.0339213796,
-0.0361866243,
0.0045737801,
-0.0157510191,
0.0288602635,
-0.0502945744,
-0.0301438496,
-0.0086445697,
-0.0146012194,
0.0521217138,
-0.0032180301,
0.0024381361,
-0.1135460287,
0.0709747598,
-0.0087216152,
0.0358770154,
0.021652,
0.032100562,
-0.0218975451,
-0.0027649165,
0.006500015,
-0.0016103267,
0.0296455659,
-0.0218321737,
-0.0078018224,
-0.0055700694,
-0.0401931554,
-0.0179592669,
0.0303303525,
-0.0960824862,
0.0252739619,
0.0000015707,
-0.0564706363,
-0.0279177185,
-0.0076370467,
-0.0010582972,
-0.0078280168,
0.0466362499,
-0.0568729788,
-0.0445786715,
-0.0295231082,
0.0207169838,
-0.0339077376,
0.0752414316,
0.0138993636,
-0.0161399003,
0.0614175163,
-0.0285683107,
-0.0791025758,
-0.0002449164,
0.0411886349,
-0.0570412502,
0.0045133992,
0.0070246384,
-0.0090401145,
-0.0035028802,
-0.0281617492,
-0.0356659032,
-0.0162809156,
-0.0398409516,
0.021707058,
0.0026659821,
0.014657639,
-0.0393773951,
-0.0291308276,
0.0227083601,
0.0098485397,
-0.0654175952,
0.0022599071,
0.0293875802,
0.0123973535,
0.0073985741,
-0.0357491337,
0.0042210706,
0.0288091525,
-0.0203854982,
0.0340958834,
0.0464234278,
-0.0066269855,
0.0066306381,
-0.0152911497,
-0.0358549207,
0.0828621909,
0.0309537016,
-0.0624061525,
-0.001757962,
0.00614519,
-0.004273654,
-0.0448818281,
0.0594315119,
0.0057235686,
-0.0045412858,
0.0522425808,
-0.0134879863,
-0.0098622488,
0.0281271599,
-0.0183399823,
0.0078146961,
0.0125496071,
0.0120746382,
-0.0224860925,
-0.0083857048,
-0.0589281358,
0.0441835895,
-0.0061355741,
-0.045303423,
0.0108962776,
0.0045619775,
0.0141823431,
-0.0829749182,
0.0315559469,
-0.0409031808,
-0.0148433009,
-0.0665420741,
0.0106644602,
0.0035468333,
-0.0101321982,
0.0129431756,
-0.0376243591,
-0.0243119486,
0.0267617349,
-0.0198240615,
-0.0485609397,
-0.0716000944,
-0.0059112441,
0.0272327531,
-0.0008949822,
0.0467335656,
0.0138146114,
0.0426162444,
-0.0148804039,
-0.0176840089,
-0.0406385362,
0.0301611926,
-0.0239033867,
-0.0428680703,
-0.0241732877,
-0.0558920167,
-0.044148583,
-0.0209290516,
-0.0814732388,
-0.0071882955,
0.0141796535,
-0.0107785044,
0.0688311979,
-0.012570342,
-0.0095368354,
-0.0221787281,
0.0511861145,
-0.0077428161,
0.0129697416,
-0.0118998503,
-0.017406024,
0.0726901889,
0.0466472134,
0.014646831,
-0.0290752091,
0.0720030889,
-0.0180876367,
-0.0306833964,
0.0396786593,
-0.0528144315,
-0.0299875569,
-0.0316796266,
-0.049457211,
-0.0345575698,
-0.0286056995,
-0.0165376104,
0.046933841,
0.0079948008,
-0.0018094487,
-0.0325373448,
0.101329416,
0.0012787824,
0.0299499035,
0.0074661053,
0.0161316581,
0.0300038513,
0.0506426729,
0.0373890214,
-0.0915457234,
-0.0666868314,
0.0530673377,
-0.0391248725,
0.0381862149,
0.0077786357,
-0.0123970807,
-0.0419013798,
-0.0182832852,
0.0564985611,
-0.0327107497,
0.0589377917,
0.0264222473,
-0.0379861481,
0.0167867523,
0.0219212417,
-0.023235064,
-0.0329114273,
0.0099342577,
-0.0417628251,
0.0303203017,
-0.0053121778,
-0.0003731763,
-0.0125592444,
0.0397470333,
-0.0465734005,
0.0328666829,
0.0287190285,
-0.0209442489,
-0.005695893,
-0.0300842877,
0.0232829358,
0.067783311,
0.040118333,
0.0290788524,
-0.0158058181,
0.0078268787,
0.0158461817,
0.016732242,
0.0166764092,
0.022159839,
0.0164915994,
0.0391447358,
-0.0350370668,
0.0040261238,
0.0447134785,
0.0193715934,
0.0054441877,
0.0112181641,
0.0210385304,
-0.0120948199,
0.0438083932,
0.053671699,
-0.0345351361,
-0.0450683385,
-0.0243437886,
0.0316814445,
0.0021448901,
-0.0648638085,
0.031524498,
-0.0394300297,
0.0152134746,
0.0045665875,
0.0657263026,
-0.0491598584,
0.0956354365,
-0.0284480844,
0.0221555065,
-0.0371172838,
0.0611545779,
-0.0150040016,
0.0291670654,
0.007962985,
-0.0165754035,
-0.0168518219,
-0.0370520763,
-0.0259274133,
0.0603061542,
-0.0088829827,
-0.0376105979,
-0.0117946053,
-0.0592802577,
-0.0503833704,
-0.0270505175,
-0.0935721844,
0.0114967087,
0.0000943832,
0.0675809607,
0.0093112309,
0.0288996194,
-0.0439287163,
0.0194390062,
0.0436370485,
0.061466489,
0.0471230298,
0.0192473624,
0.024979407,
0.0003806305,
-0.0160297155,
-0.012104637,
-0.0236583892,
0.0039263545,
-0.0078823483,
-0.0224360172,
-0.0514771119,
-0.047026258,
0.0241611693,
0.0157417599,
0.0001596963,
0.0381712094,
-0.0387004688,
-0.0144047849,
-0.042119842,
0.0528832488,
0.0318090618,
0.0042447811,
0.0172498822,
-0.0052514356,
-0.097529389,
0.029814681,
-0.0491434447,
-0.0326732434,
0.0501979142,
-0.0652013049,
-0.0115700839,
0.0205890164,
0.0958513841,
0.003584659,
0.015479615,
0.0246374421,
-0.0465065725,
-0.0887415782,
0.0067707594,
0.0662900433,
-0.0106520597,
-0.0754263699,
0.018413147,
-0.0082998965,
0.0009178845,
0.0452120304,
-0.0071161501,
-0.0217339136,
-0.0673958957,
0.0088454299,
-0.0235086028,
0.0040314333,
-0.0070033399,
0.0154025108,
0.0472752899,
-0.1089545786,
0.0151962591,
0.0157541689,
-0.0197301805,
-0.0322803706,
0.0297017135,
0.0008586132,
-0.0358733684,
-0.0211080108,
0.0170857608,
0.0012378279,
0.0115642631,
0.0051330277,
0.0363971442,
0.0598505735,
0.002842309,
0.0256399978,
0.0586862937,
-0.045469176,
-0.0100273155,
0.0016368688,
0.0211382788,
-0.0073288349,
0.0487903766,
-0.0261484105,
-0.0252141226,
-0.029730184,
-0.0001724634,
0.0401751101,
0.0112720476,
-0.0135516627,
-0.01301389,
0.012219619,
-0.0235907082,
0.0377501957,
-0.0621131621,
-0.0440485179,
-0.0001459201,
0.0671724826,
-0.0621517487,
0.0218346156,
0.0974579528,
0.0446874164,
0.0228617955,
0.0290268362,
0.0049049202,
0.0177636743,
0.0096942661,
-0.0149434227,
-0.0119966995,
0.0172646251,
0.040035706,
-0.0089418581,
-0.0359512679,
-0.0184005853,
0.0414925218,
-0.0911716819,
0.0310144518,
-0.0044476036,
-0.0070333583,
0.0086067403,
-0.0283085313,
0.0003564528,
0.013484098,
-0.0035855954,
0.0030867429,
-0.0417934954,
0.00110803,
0.040836066,
-0.0560281724,
-0.0106181186,
-0.0125339702,
-0.0241928957,
0.0100300452,
0.0043755597,
0.0721027032,
-0.0473804474,
0.0142408712,
0.0817845389,
-0.0731074214,
0.0062702447,
0.0012033937,
0.0223450419,
0.0292362124,
-0.0037947341,
-0.0289487839,
-0.0179251581,
0.0239619929,
0.0241824016,
-0.0146389846,
0.0120105082,
0.0274753459,
-0.0198075268,
0.0195076894,
-0.0230307765,
-0.0311820358,
0.007003013,
-0.0019618834,
-0.0137382802,
-0.0788700879,
-0.0215057004,
0.0196927916,
-0.0130221108,
0.002893677,
0.0220380966,
-0.0752331018,
-0.0279900637,
-0.0740882829,
-0.081718348,
0.0331748016,
0.055222746,
0.0006975667,
-0.0017682544,
-0.0093025006,
0.0155616496,
-0.0169141702,
-0.0250204038,
0.0347672775,
-0.002179197,
-0.0643760785,
-0.0275257193,
-0.0306076799,
0.0405399315,
-0.0102547863,
-0.0304636564,
0.0085015753,
-0.0470323451,
0.0753611252,
-0.0233177766,
0.0170091502,
0.0050217924,
-0.0442847535,
0.0148051009,
-0.0145584494,
0.0037039609,
-0.035691902,
-0.0064049293,
0.0416005142,
-0.0109446337,
-0.0087112319,
-0.0014950328,
0.018141482,
0.051200442,
-0.0393951721,
0.0323636495,
-0.0446372405,
-0.0328496471,
0.005218911,
0.040929012,
0.0219105855,
-0.0148726422,
0.0240755007,
-0.0216967277,
-0.0074471286,
-0.042054832,
0.0177360047,
0.0203053672,
-0.025030544,
0.0346023552,
-0.011693256,
-0.0082376078,
0.0384504944,
-0.0371306539,
-0.0208192579,
0.0122056082,
0.0295769777,
0.0584732369,
0.0486695357,
0.0082136709,
0.0129039846,
0.0047141206,
0.0042568874,
-0.0062736962,
0.0062276288,
-0.0560498536,
0.0280377772,
-0.0323876441,
-0.0173705332,
-0.0607916526,
0.021189006,
0.0278234668,
0.0711559877,
-0.0147926752,
0.0213621538,
0.03368387,
-0.0576501526,
0.0348046124,
-0.0377825461,
-0.0129726138,
-0.0230824407,
0.0213368256,
-0.0253905859,
-0.0533810779,
-0.0325060748,
0.0272787269,
-0.0447923578,
-0.0356397666,
0.0466473699,
-0.0017436425,
-0.004809821,
0.0093614832,
-0.0512662865,
-0.0020696444,
0.0104696378,
0.0129165277,
0.0426236019,
-0.0496078767,
-0.0159410816,
-0.0660882071,
-0.0088056372,
-0.0408025347,
0.0035736568,
0.0679897591,
0.0182460658,
-0.0224422775,
0.0408960134,
0.0265453737,
-0.0448817499,
-0.0424059369,
0.001274361,
0.0275139771,
0.0347182378,
0.0590178594,
-5.492498456e-33,
-0.0049421038,
-0.005978697,
-0.0451701246,
0.0264794063,
-0.0195842236,
0.0053162277,
-0.0213533789,
0.0539475344,
-0.0036193854,
-0.010792302,
-0.0331532881,
-0.0124323238,
0.0479130857,
-0.0109205004,
0.0582328513,
0.000789236,
0.0277413875,
0.00816797,
0.0136258928,
-0.0093179885,
0.0423569381,
0.0244318917,
0.0672760829,
0.0024613687,
0.0488261096,
-0.0049150432,
0.0049616396,
-0.0212463103,
0.0550039299,
0.0462492965,
-0.0358302407,
0.017094925,
0.0388098806,
0.0217908341,
-0.0500477068,
0.0057490971,
-0.0894277841,
-0.0009945546,
0.0187002569,
0.0454304293,
-0.0662126541,
0.0017157646,
0.0179217234,
-0.0344119892,
0.0160074066,
0.0435582697,
0.007059061,
-0.0325901024,
-0.0130927302,
0.0282729417,
-0.1085464284,
0.0616378151,
0.0142131597,
0.0426943675,
0.1043491513,
-0.0569446906,
-0.0231688432,
-0.0176050942,
0.022961637,
0.007131042,
0.0164039396,
0.0403855629,
0.0030739757,
0.0529426783,
-0.0091383774,
0.0043010879,
0.0379730016,
0.0184010826,
0.0597781427,
0.0374621972,
0.0421986245,
0.054955788,
-0.0738938376,
-0.0425058529,
0.0912607536,
-0.0637417883,
0.0039203153,
-0.0315500945,
0.0261717495,
0.0234820973,
-0.0032117246,
0.0196362063,
-0.0489554815,
-0.027599968,
0.0194965377,
-0.0502172858,
-0.0017665323,
-0.0210317522,
-0.0000790875,
0.0075915344,
-0.0274106525,
0.0614524744,
0.0269877072,
0.0009422832,
-0.00345541,
-0.0330684744,
0.0170918461,
0.0598794073,
-0.042634245,
0.018009983,
-0.0720984563,
-0.0587958284,
-0.0309753139,
-0.0188220907,
-0.0138950171,
0.0157174561,
-0.0076129213,
-0.008351299,
-0.0297072586,
0.0280579757,
0.0022525482,
-0.0158423819,
-0.0457670391,
0.0363269709,
0.0340141729,
0.0118187023,
0.0165238231,
0.0406203233,
0.0690390021,
0.04052357,
-0.0393926911,
0.0298451539,
-0.001880744,
0.0183073375,
0.0037670175,
0.0025176911,
0.0148417149,
0.0143481949,
0.0476154871,
0.0194856301,
0.0027656802,
0.0191398021,
2.395e-7,
0.050708469,
0.0417994,
0.0780820698,
-0.0345595106,
0.0170784481,
-0.0266322214,
-0.014024917,
0.0081551597,
0.0050827758,
0.0175765343,
-0.0005281473,
-0.0419196077,
0.0073620244,
0.0388546176,
-0.0991152301,
0.03153852,
0.0169680882,
-0.0172582399,
-0.0654795095,
0.0534593463,
-0.0041514663,
0.0437259302,
-0.0024766943,
0.0091504902,
-0.0338332988,
-0.0177413542,
-0.010380921,
0.0081380196,
0.0219535157,
0.0388667174,
0.0480630659,
0.0019351569,
0.0225272961,
-0.005478228,
-0.0084198248,
0.0313684456,
0.0223879032,
0.0619588755,
-0.0313092396,
0.0516739525,
0.0579493754,
-0.0583367795,
-0.03381842,
-0.0330848172,
0.0440296382,
0.0195593759,
-0.0219540298,
-0.0120183798,
-0.001121726,
0.0414281189,
-0.071885407,
0.0097937137,
-0.0251846574,
0.0425003096,
0.0272511151,
-0.022167258,
-0.0534384847,
-0.0001609613,
-0.029512519,
0.0403106436,
-0.0083364099,
-0.0185205042,
0.032093104,
-0.0046978374,
0.0197683014,
-0.0425260067,
-0.0231344867,
2.403421949e-34,
0.0025298048,
0.0182377733,
-0.0080379695,
0.0418504588,
-0.0350038409,
-0.0292786714,
-0.0235533975,
0.0870771557,
-0.0352256931,
-0.0379013941,
-0.0019722495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03667v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03667v2 | Exploring an LM to generate Prolog Predicates from Mathematics Questions | 2023-09-07T12:10:47 | 2023-09-08T03:46:33 | Xiaocheng Yang, Yik-Cheung Tam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, there has been a surge in interest in NLP driven by ChatGPT.
ChatGPT, a transformer-based generative language model of substantial scale,
exhibits versatility in performing various tasks based on natural language.
Nevertheless, large language models often exhibit poor performance in solving
mathematics questions that require reasoning. Prior research has demonstrated
the effectiveness of chain-of-thought prompting in enhancing reasoning
capabilities. Now, we aim to investigate whether fine-tuning a model for the
generation of Prolog codes, a logic language, and subsequently passing these
codes to a compiler can further improve accuracy. Consequently, we employ
chain-of-thought to fine-tune LLaMA7B as a baseline model and develop other
fine-tuned LLaMA7B models for the generation of Prolog code, Prolog code +
chain-of-thought, and chain-of-thought + Prolog code, respectively. The results
reveal that the Prolog generation model surpasses the baseline in performance,
while the combination generation models do not yield significant improvements.
The Prolog corpus based on GSM8K and the correspondingly finetuned Prolog
generation model based on LLaMA7B are released to the research community. | [
0.0248717498,
0.0537966639,
-0.0061845286,
0.0376001559,
-0.0769168064,
0.0075026145,
0.009747548,
-0.0235341862,
-0.0173151996,
-0.0425936505,
-0.0149335871,
0.0280638579,
-0.0438315198,
0.046810776,
0.0383034348,
-0.0144617297,
0.0182318185,
-0.0490811951,
0.0427677147,
-0.0151799759,
-0.0215747245,
0.005058981,
-0.0186116248,
0.005667774,
-0.0124005042,
-0.0303293224,
0.0005860624,
-0.0162559655,
-0.0015658381,
-0.0091532581,
-0.0427228957,
0.0461888053,
-0.0244195219,
-0.0092717456,
0.0000021983,
-0.0554818325,
-0.0298464466,
0.0166073386,
-0.0041590957,
-0.0271541346,
0.0051044119,
0.0135926614,
0.0012560625,
0.047369957,
-0.0873720422,
-0.0025580511,
0.0013010395,
0.0105624646,
0.0905749798,
0.0912885368,
-0.0120796328,
-0.0538085587,
0.0363756046,
-0.0055811526,
0.0562761873,
-0.0355928242,
-0.0152224302,
0.0357045569,
0.0317903571,
0.0264155623,
-0.0103574563,
0.0229451917,
0.0465954095,
-0.0253819022,
0.0113748414,
0.0111092748,
-0.0360899568,
-0.0190179944,
0.002292545,
0.0563311614,
-0.0131538725,
-0.034257073,
0.0129348533,
0.0004369436,
0.0257327687,
-0.0401485115,
-0.045075953,
0.0771977976,
-0.0335251763,
0.0243649054,
0.0590602644,
-0.0091245491,
-0.0153477602,
-0.0376380309,
-0.0610115528,
0.0542979464,
0.0191259142,
-0.0333756059,
-0.0237155035,
0.0073469039,
-0.0739814714,
-0.0317690261,
0.0355621539,
0.0382248648,
0.0093947686,
0.0210855454,
-0.0425431877,
0.0057327021,
-0.0165230948,
-0.0100400317,
0.0179605018,
0.089623332,
0.043169301,
0.0201329552,
-0.0489317439,
0.0527791716,
-0.0003698167,
0.0163464081,
-0.0513291135,
0.0056164316,
-0.0723748803,
0.0011017661,
-0.0574194454,
0.0508937798,
-0.0031073522,
0.0040517263,
-0.0240476374,
0.0448664092,
0.028014183,
0.0247935392,
0.0151685495,
-0.0208203159,
0.0059804679,
-0.0228764303,
-0.0389917791,
0.0213837586,
-0.0237496495,
0.003375337,
0.0271143392,
-0.0837458596,
0.0088289045,
0.0079874964,
-0.0156106902,
-0.0066090743,
-0.0020397655,
0.0666150674,
-0.0121889226,
-0.0013718269,
-0.019933166,
-0.0633324087,
0.0230360162,
-0.04396246,
0.0413633063,
-0.1075459644,
0.0273637902,
0.0125394128,
-0.0287601613,
-0.0302917864,
0.0229350179,
0.0433860123,
0.0291455705,
0.0593947768,
-0.0357609391,
0.0100175673,
-0.013683727,
-0.0070843068,
-0.0462951995,
0.0432472713,
0.0325867049,
-0.0016186521,
0.0065963059,
-0.0195620246,
0.0249693748,
0.0222100895,
0.0132501619,
-0.052332703,
0.0078423377,
0.0255128127,
0.002505067,
0.0034036934,
0.0163889285,
0.0640998557,
-0.0314992033,
0.0179006793,
0.0222793538,
0.0292292498,
0.0326918922,
0.0335546955,
0.0482590459,
-0.0098373769,
0.0410125479,
-0.0074241399,
-0.0687419176,
0.0375140421,
-0.0174246486,
0.0137433885,
-0.0009599391,
0.0372642316,
0.0025044491,
-0.0986369625,
0.0097535187,
0.0170124415,
-0.0720411018,
0.0061075399,
0.0415637232,
0.0447306558,
-0.0289912727,
0.0658271238,
0.0105322544,
-0.0711491704,
-0.0296398439,
-0.0647925064,
0.0198098291,
0.0103475926,
0.0436992198,
0.0041991556,
-0.0287618898,
-0.005320021,
-0.0177586246,
0.0571048707,
0.0219873618,
0.0123253502,
-0.044527676,
-0.0417734496,
0.0129196048,
-0.0162957609,
0.0092915632,
-0.0131951747,
0.021521084,
-0.0165261328,
0.0384595916,
-0.0154863689,
0.0433585793,
0.0253904294,
-0.0305843093,
-0.0016001594,
-0.0001067902,
-0.0109272571,
0.0200065207,
-0.0177449826,
0.0002926156,
0.0702694878,
0.0248051472,
-0.051119145,
-0.0170130786,
0.0058647869,
-0.0669748709,
-0.0844164342,
0.0621265359,
-0.0590609834,
0.0177672748,
-0.0181151871,
-0.0374704935,
-0.0246527307,
0.0323564932,
-0.0342291743,
0.048492942,
-0.0356523357,
0.0157799721,
0.0336495601,
-0.0504813045,
-0.0666826442,
0.0768355951,
0.0133074606,
0.008004887,
0.0054698396,
0.016235318,
0.0267088357,
-0.0018115453,
0.041506581,
0.01546505,
-0.0268581919,
0.0117801065,
-0.0208921377,
0.0518614389,
-0.037562415,
-0.0659490898,
-0.0356671847,
0.015922524,
-0.0128544215,
0.0420370027,
0.0202921387,
-0.0260925274,
-0.0025344607,
0.0145147741,
-0.0599216521,
0.0389881581,
0.0400483087,
-0.0065533277,
0.0272888411,
0.000035505,
-0.0345676281,
-0.0152863162,
-0.0026863667,
-0.0309763961,
0.0375312567,
0.0248838142,
0.0436641127,
-0.0184245817,
0.0580138676,
-0.032602977,
-0.0035886227,
-0.0097858319,
-0.0006987023,
0.0315626264,
-0.0481036976,
0.091540195,
0.0205208901,
-0.0154783325,
-0.0213445146,
0.0028995827,
-0.0283120405,
-0.0347699709,
0.0212086234,
-0.0103349416,
-0.0216535032,
-0.0121353101,
-0.0437956229,
0.0064314338,
0.0555180572,
0.0021021564,
-0.0197990667,
-0.031711109,
0.0612461381,
-0.0080468087,
-0.0056995791,
0.0225655586,
0.0116959522,
0.0048764641,
0.0909125209,
-0.0075042709,
-0.053285934,
0.0465965047,
0.0025755286,
-0.0066439016,
-0.0623183809,
0.0135362735,
-0.0565339401,
0.0428091027,
0.0242508966,
0.0018875541,
0.0019813061,
-0.0118218875,
-0.0380798019,
0.002734158,
0.0310186278,
-0.0354517736,
0.0494974628,
-0.038061209,
0.0059963875,
-0.0056590228,
-0.0501045324,
-0.06520316,
0.0377556682,
-0.0337143838,
0.0102710966,
0.0110241193,
0.0072216904,
-0.0059350091,
-0.009321508,
-0.0313106738,
0.0078062979,
-0.029157307,
-0.0548009276,
-0.0195059683,
0.0046415064,
0.016770618,
-0.0073860311,
0.0358350277,
0.0011702203,
0.0042346693,
0.0342852436,
0.0010962657,
0.0185821541,
-0.0109320413,
0.0370048732,
0.0096087521,
-0.0163723342,
-0.054424189,
0.0293999221,
-0.0048363404,
-0.0508265831,
-0.0379036926,
0.1113499403,
0.04858426,
-0.0163449291,
-0.0005669438,
-0.0587870702,
0.026911404,
0.0112659819,
0.0462752171,
-0.089482531,
-0.0375267901,
0.0171463117,
-0.0097030532,
-0.0128463972,
-0.0049957694,
-0.0268416349,
-0.1302174032,
0.0592822284,
-0.0061507584,
0.0157368295,
-0.011717597,
-0.0330263004,
-0.0268450696,
0.0164690185,
-0.0769495219,
0.0507940575,
-0.0236222595,
0.0471901633,
0.0146596972,
-0.0335155874,
-0.0088539179,
0.0066861077,
-0.0038354783,
0.0132819097,
0.0489072613,
0.0152265662,
0.0134641798,
-0.0722942129,
0.0201512743,
0.0459049232,
-0.0078455377,
-0.0282239635,
-0.0347699784,
0.0176758878,
-0.0264037792,
-0.0477031395,
0.0546063557,
-0.0628079027,
-0.0087372996,
0.049817469,
0.0879331157,
-0.019770585,
-0.0268343501,
-0.0322409682,
0.0473567694,
-0.0418819413,
0.0512697063,
0.0206824876,
0.0112050073,
-0.0344651788,
-0.0480231307,
-0.0345069505,
-0.0245796386,
-0.0437452346,
-0.0195694529,
0.0527972579,
0.0179404709,
-0.0620688312,
-0.0022138797,
0.0385800935,
0.0526842512,
-0.0164474659,
-0.0336233787,
0.0169996005,
0.0022725982,
-0.0443877578,
0.0109919105,
-0.0491274595,
0.0076070661,
-0.0514079072,
0.0613907389,
0.0393846259,
-0.0098633934,
-0.0448393971,
0.0314679369,
-0.0817598403,
-0.0379265323,
-0.0016574657,
0.0675829053,
0.0317756347,
-0.0371168181,
-0.0016486426,
0.023858387,
-0.0139324795,
0.0687749386,
-0.0240420531,
-0.0028196471,
0.0051634074,
-0.0081957383,
0.0129929772,
0.0045224186,
0.0133565888,
0.0236285906,
-0.0050281384,
0.0549053699,
0.0211359225,
-0.0369264446,
0.0516610481,
0.0585936084,
0.0025329487,
0.0132115828,
-0.0031686302,
-0.0001342416,
0.0026148078,
-0.0403097458,
-0.0168973859,
-0.0764178708,
0.0349436402,
0.0054585203,
0.0115656499,
0.0011007999,
-0.0317322463,
-0.0299768932,
0.0385762565,
0.0356998108,
0.0329258479,
-0.0105244508,
0.0034453582,
0.0166292805,
-0.0424054861,
0.0007865817,
-0.0100533189,
-0.0067329728,
0.0398501717,
-0.0255807228,
0.0651818067,
0.0120462636,
0.0119386921,
-0.0396839641,
-0.0077775852,
-0.04269173,
-0.0617425814,
0.0172913224,
0.0479383469,
0.0608983077,
0.0652755275,
0.0189189781,
-0.0468984172,
0.0127260424,
0.0201804582,
0.0494961105,
0.0297382213,
-0.0164418407,
0.0400720239,
0.0047669979,
0.0214033499,
-0.105753161,
0.0588895679,
-0.0093112662,
0.0170591939,
0.0174958725,
0.0234592203,
-0.0513488315,
-0.0547551811,
-0.0381683819,
-0.0366485678,
0.0242097341,
0.0091864299,
-0.0749789551,
-0.0463220254,
-0.0134289628,
0.0282607805,
0.0079496093,
0.000882194,
0.0496908277,
0.092136234,
0.0042733108,
-0.0762857571,
-0.0129395509,
0.0400197804,
-0.024865916,
-0.0332433619,
-0.0125321019,
-6.239572503e-33,
-0.0377135165,
-0.0334340483,
0.0716856942,
0.0512542762,
-0.0264062863,
-0.0550477989,
-0.0169452894,
0.0254395884,
0.0045279888,
0.012051777,
-0.0146185411,
0.0200133715,
0.007525858,
-0.0184344333,
-0.0124704521,
0.003417884,
0.0195538383,
-0.0223125778,
-0.0310878921,
0.0050985692,
-0.013350023,
0.0085171284,
0.0258350484,
0.0069498383,
-0.0177049749,
-0.0101413308,
-0.0025873478,
0.022451371,
-0.05398193,
0.0364144593,
-0.0018241366,
0.0043205223,
0.0059730574,
-0.0354747772,
-0.0295436271,
0.0131294494,
-0.047287859,
-0.0384054966,
0.0523308143,
0.0027565332,
-0.0444573574,
-0.0806652233,
0.0393551774,
-0.0110435635,
-0.0189620014,
-0.0250895284,
0.0209143236,
-0.014058684,
0.0036692671,
-0.0529957116,
-0.0520814881,
0.0258418843,
0.0143799484,
-0.0136068836,
-0.0284385718,
0.0504372902,
-0.0325100273,
-0.0112016285,
0.0247981418,
0.025528172,
0.0380561799,
0.0295454618,
0.0243339073,
-0.0249885153,
0.0041909795,
-0.0054251724,
-0.0023430292,
-0.0219864044,
-0.0365150534,
0.0321520194,
0.0224653743,
0.0696037784,
0.0649315938,
0.0072523779,
0.0695853755,
0.0277424455,
-0.0693353191,
0.0039729066,
-0.0041966927,
0.0373320766,
0.0128762657,
-0.0392726772,
-0.0023454311,
-0.0241250005,
-0.0667217299,
0.0283768456,
-0.0349098332,
-0.0371187367,
0.0232531745,
-0.0059103975,
-0.0070829303,
-0.0251546707,
0.0333368555,
-0.0145370681,
-0.0079048937,
0.0256910156,
-0.0271101836,
0.0245963875,
-0.027427068,
0.0520706959,
-0.0330505259,
0.0154854367,
0.0384666249,
0.0095890388,
0.0395300388,
0.011693445,
-0.0049602739,
0.0053136572,
-0.0590266511,
-0.0197141189,
-0.0708874613,
0.024983367,
0.0129066212,
0.0240457971,
0.0170837902,
0.0208763462,
-0.0011474508,
0.032831233,
-0.0283441041,
-0.0082617244,
-0.0419339165,
0.0717658252,
0.0004626038,
0.0405708142,
-0.0326910242,
-0.0088466294,
-0.0639865845,
0.0370230936,
0.0200710855,
-0.0538874641,
-0.0207601413,
0.0222965162,
3e-7,
0.0298815779,
0.0660182163,
0.0102745481,
0.0817580819,
0.0089304112,
0.0042955261,
0.0194671899,
-0.0103115654,
0.0646688938,
-0.024131598,
-0.0174008794,
0.055939056,
0.0009637686,
0.0478269868,
-0.0644560158,
0.0011198494,
-0.0097814407,
-0.0277682338,
-0.0324101932,
-0.0034249802,
0.1267523468,
0.0762444809,
-0.0042307493,
-0.0335097089,
0.0124801062,
-0.0246711057,
0.0648579225,
-0.0001039484,
-0.0392804109,
0.0210637674,
0.0349442177,
0.0009608485,
0.0074332873,
0.0054671387,
0.0285411086,
-0.0248772372,
-0.011422636,
0.0776203647,
0.045249898,
0.0387279354,
0.0305851176,
-0.0161883328,
0.0052874847,
-0.010368132,
0.0614500679,
-0.0888232142,
-0.0227253288,
0.0134204589,
-0.0507239997,
-0.0252566971,
-0.0077077788,
-0.0312873945,
-0.0053111124,
0.0093552461,
0.0372300074,
-0.0189343672,
0.0065234439,
-0.0371370241,
-0.0487292819,
-0.0019190235,
-0.0165959522,
-0.0380626693,
-0.03791482,
0.0053843628,
0.003421695,
-0.0163272358,
-0.0036114249,
3.095081447e-34,
0.0342974775,
-0.0210989527,
0.0290932301,
-0.0028340155,
0.0222897083,
0.004226218,
-0.0313896276,
0.0121004442,
-0.0066336379,
-0.0938359797,
-0.0072385846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03658v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03658v1 | BNS-Net: A Dual-channel Sarcasm Detection Method Considering Behavior-level and Sentence-level Conflicts | 2023-09-07T11:55:11 | 2023-09-07T11:55:11 | Liming Zhou, Xiaowei Xu, Xiaodong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sarcasm detection is a binary classification task that aims to determine
whether a given utterance is sarcastic. Over the past decade, sarcasm detection
has evolved from classical pattern recognition to deep learning approaches,
where features such as user profile, punctuation and sentiment words have been
commonly employed for sarcasm detection. In real-life sarcastic expressions,
behaviors without explicit sentimental cues often serve as carriers of implicit
sentimental meanings. Motivated by this observation, we proposed a dual-channel
sarcasm detection model named BNS-Net. The model considers behavior and
sentence conflicts in two channels. Channel 1: Behavior-level Conflict Channel
reconstructs the text based on core verbs while leveraging the modified
attention mechanism to highlight conflict information. Channel 2:
Sentence-level Conflict Channel introduces external sentiment knowledge to
segment the text into explicit and implicit sentences, capturing conflicts
between them. To validate the effectiveness of BNS-Net, several comparative and
ablation experiments are conducted on three public sarcasm datasets. The
analysis and evaluation of experimental results demonstrate that the BNS-Net
effectively identifies sarcasm in text and achieves the state-of-the-art
performance. | [
0.0393595845,
-0.0038025484,
-0.0430271141,
0.0483275764,
-0.0534510687,
0.0077124662,
0.0041992124,
0.0109761264,
-0.0023125035,
-0.0294165723,
-0.0411248356,
-0.0025499519,
-0.0266889576,
0.0303600039,
-0.0111622978,
-0.0184134413,
0.0334996171,
0.0758621246,
0.0174612366,
-0.0146326842,
0.0305156317,
0.0135605792,
-0.021472821,
0.0452651829,
-0.0328529105,
-0.0093803974,
-0.010297983,
0.1092580035,
0.0291152894,
-0.0259916447,
0.0792525187,
0.0213974956,
0.001733201,
0.0396331996,
0.0000018676,
-0.0372159332,
-0.0028655506,
-0.0251785703,
-0.0457069576,
0.0083118174,
0.1153772399,
-0.0129363546,
-0.0129295839,
0.0174911637,
-0.0359047577,
0.0348522067,
0.03561325,
0.0387327485,
0.065815419,
0.0696363971,
-0.006804409,
0.0040230309,
-0.0290173739,
-0.0048648794,
-0.0172570739,
-0.045433946,
0.0350213647,
-0.0193476081,
-0.0666415617,
-0.0126473578,
-0.0384817719,
-0.000591231,
-0.0193904731,
0.0155419242,
-0.039722845,
-0.0104992241,
-0.0063000536,
0.0081992624,
-0.0189759023,
0.0349616483,
0.0197493639,
-0.0112708388,
0.0004067626,
0.0086813485,
-0.0064892215,
-0.0841764435,
-0.0142688239,
-0.0097856522,
0.0021804003,
0.003211902,
0.0056344471,
0.0257313605,
0.0009753014,
0.0466324054,
0.0175447781,
-0.007927957,
-0.0269502066,
-0.033734303,
-0.01801496,
-0.0134793296,
0.0004958605,
-0.0151887229,
0.0607592054,
0.0152748683,
0.025428988,
0.0101318909,
-0.0476723574,
-0.1003101543,
0.0316288993,
-0.0638694987,
-0.0456881821,
-0.0054596229,
-0.0432965122,
0.0426597856,
0.0383412912,
-0.0019706602,
-0.0058119562,
0.049158331,
-0.0219002254,
-0.036806453,
-0.0090265358,
0.0243236534,
-0.0234033708,
0.0017605992,
-0.0121671213,
-0.0139911808,
-0.0565443859,
-0.001706477,
-0.0417245515,
-0.0249419771,
0.0126936007,
0.0288408455,
-0.0128228106,
-0.0125742881,
-0.0025155398,
0.0313088484,
-0.0185994375,
0.0394983627,
-0.0278514326,
-0.0232049096,
-0.0202315785,
0.0200802982,
0.0285094324,
-0.0221066531,
0.0368163176,
0.0432019457,
0.0321264975,
-0.0521253124,
-0.0786982551,
0.011271175,
-0.0645009577,
-0.0380411744,
-0.0017960414,
-0.0205351319,
0.0382089578,
-0.0400147736,
-0.0431312583,
0.0011388127,
-0.0024594255,
-0.0187679846,
-0.0013793932,
0.0694571137,
-0.0326981544,
-0.0592740066,
0.0383547805,
-0.0016929333,
-0.060863588,
0.0346940905,
0.0176773109,
0.008909801,
0.0352762379,
0.0454049297,
-0.0402945429,
-0.0093431594,
0.0247030873,
-0.0229479112,
-0.0514173508,
0.0045259316,
-0.0692460313,
0.0208927039,
0.000584375,
0.0400780141,
-0.0598934107,
-0.0435182489,
0.0309545416,
0.0067604459,
-0.0352609418,
0.0661461055,
0.0398744456,
0.0263747927,
0.0142064923,
-0.0071768169,
-0.0181878563,
0.01108691,
-0.0738366991,
-0.0558959395,
-0.0462406091,
0.0153443282,
-0.021265503,
-0.0543655083,
-0.010371143,
-0.0542678237,
0.0684920251,
-0.0229711216,
0.056303788,
0.0254284311,
-0.0497499332,
0.014581685,
0.0003762469,
-0.0380400904,
-0.0502826944,
-0.010696942,
-0.0276269317,
0.0609008558,
0.0094795609,
-0.0311463363,
-0.0658906475,
-0.035632126,
-0.0402894169,
0.0235118847,
-0.0048193163,
0.0176509824,
0.0020560632,
-0.0635595769,
0.0187074263,
-0.040519841,
0.013570454,
0.0053361715,
0.0051792716,
0.0615822822,
-0.0079215756,
0.0320473723,
0.0812339261,
0.0106871706,
-0.0312215388,
-0.0149800582,
-0.0012773754,
0.0372702666,
0.0504821129,
-0.0016161092,
0.0093369558,
-0.0250512641,
0.0171613842,
-0.0336283296,
-0.0927555189,
0.0049200766,
-0.0126854936,
-0.1111534759,
0.016127035,
-0.0649477616,
-0.0269798916,
0.0688955709,
-0.028186081,
0.006906474,
0.0375613458,
-0.0136946943,
0.0096465992,
-0.067919232,
-0.0209854301,
-0.0577076375,
0.0340677388,
-0.0059694606,
0.0507777967,
-0.0140084922,
-0.0442470498,
-0.0098896874,
0.0060696076,
-0.004281038,
0.0289353933,
-0.0374205895,
-0.0201252513,
0.0037891148,
-0.0035625503,
-0.0158825498,
0.0179636162,
-0.0285222791,
-0.0365172438,
-0.09549696,
0.0235183463,
0.0134004001,
-0.0001736453,
0.0384141579,
-0.0065547326,
0.0108761331,
0.0526357628,
0.0299162772,
0.0249733888,
-0.042927295,
-0.0211531594,
0.0300008245,
-0.0323482677,
0.0072587272,
-0.04348417,
-0.0025262453,
-0.0277770851,
0.0128735472,
-0.0332162715,
-0.0065154373,
0.0106889671,
0.0202764273,
-0.0282652546,
0.0400219336,
-0.0005246862,
-0.0829778016,
0.0018506605,
0.0077274903,
-0.0193528086,
0.0877520591,
0.0474106222,
0.0419982485,
-0.0074393409,
0.005313803,
-0.027912857,
0.0589251071,
0.0018930354,
0.0386514291,
-0.0381007604,
-0.0186476689,
-0.0208199527,
0.0341880061,
0.0129291797,
0.026181601,
-0.0285524018,
0.0176744834,
0.0151478592,
0.0062374882,
0.0339983106,
-0.0208367296,
-0.0458206125,
-0.0409477055,
-0.012998227,
0.0124500291,
0.0526082031,
0.0178961772,
-0.0327217393,
-0.0487556234,
-0.016572617,
-0.0221676473,
0.0491942093,
-0.0362713411,
0.0170169454,
0.0303850044,
-0.0114900665,
-0.0036854688,
-0.0651396215,
0.0196919683,
-0.0364335701,
0.0510814637,
0.0127689345,
-0.0183159858,
0.0282886103,
-0.027916776,
-0.0475305691,
-0.0265783723,
-0.0629282817,
-0.0266529378,
0.0291856229,
0.0146705909,
-0.0016858472,
-0.0303113684,
-0.0053184084,
0.0051815859,
-0.0042621917,
-0.0161912106,
-0.0095307501,
0.0054303058,
0.012753577,
-0.0078150127,
0.0605307035,
0.0312782787,
-0.0557830818,
0.0473078117,
-0.0601553023,
0.0000216105,
-0.0258114617,
-0.0194858462,
0.0038859958,
0.0059452401,
0.0276565738,
-0.0410027094,
0.0005442448,
-0.0181049742,
0.0063250372,
0.0890140235,
0.011015377,
-0.0302515104,
0.0254336093,
-0.0234581549,
-0.0537401997,
0.0407402106,
0.0044871457,
-0.0558302067,
-0.0579996482,
0.0049512791,
-0.0116360104,
-0.0188569054,
0.0077264039,
-0.0447329842,
-0.0835700482,
-0.0093617309,
-0.004609887,
0.016124038,
0.0556476302,
0.0713494569,
0.0119146369,
-0.0164537821,
0.0124420198,
-0.0411701649,
0.0406574905,
-0.048294168,
-0.0276737139,
-0.0336725488,
-0.0282998607,
0.0330164991,
0.0024446656,
0.045219034,
-0.0025947194,
0.0790561587,
0.0008797659,
-0.0317729674,
0.0223844927,
-0.090307042,
-0.0123510985,
-0.0283690207,
0.067740716,
-0.033658538,
0.0216241125,
-0.0152599877,
0.0103645613,
-0.0176866241,
0.0204146821,
-0.0044024093,
0.015257122,
-0.0172308404,
-0.0101465089,
-0.0598008558,
0.0248118825,
0.0351223275,
0.044694338,
0.0197953042,
-0.0609692782,
-0.0420654528,
0.0130688297,
-0.0471740775,
-0.0594376326,
-0.011467169,
0.0074119414,
0.0084157418,
-0.0027693401,
-0.048520986,
-0.013896212,
-0.0271528754,
0.0025988545,
-0.0570695773,
-0.0334744714,
-0.0028670805,
-0.0143707953,
-0.0099918684,
-0.0256898087,
0.0274967067,
0.0253188051,
0.0279847682,
0.003093739,
0.00627456,
-0.0263041724,
-0.0280605704,
0.0409196541,
-0.0474425517,
-0.0168610308,
0.0274331346,
0.0277425535,
0.0031806838,
0.0227273796,
-0.0042521972,
-0.0059336699,
-0.0218863226,
0.0127141159,
0.0233586319,
0.0330637991,
0.0637784973,
0.0641898066,
0.0065440745,
0.0612728894,
-0.0103746792,
0.0573670305,
0.0133017199,
-0.0049610054,
-0.0196603239,
-0.0158567149,
-0.0331601165,
-0.0286251809,
0.0717635453,
0.0194302518,
-0.0882509798,
0.0387445502,
0.0173464101,
-0.0209467523,
-0.0090133119,
-0.0288729966,
-0.0282344539,
-0.0246354546,
-0.0096326973,
-0.0522843786,
-0.0259274058,
0.0007164731,
-0.0153595833,
0.0394732468,
0.0309584662,
0.0476266146,
0.0283901952,
-0.0255355295,
0.0371321291,
-0.0575147159,
0.0178853422,
0.030041365,
-0.0245022215,
-0.0109288851,
0.0269303694,
0.0479273833,
-0.0070928223,
-0.0281600952,
0.043188639,
0.000404696,
0.0604138784,
0.0320614055,
-0.0137740485,
0.0433117934,
-0.0067507871,
0.0536085777,
-0.0255591813,
0.0081858421,
-0.0032078964,
0.0304609668,
-0.0576406196,
-0.049422089,
-0.002263831,
0.0112339621,
-0.0048135458,
-0.0216700528,
0.0012455548,
-0.0916914269,
0.0404306799,
-0.0090849958,
-0.0081609394,
-0.0311196316,
0.0336277708,
0.042308718,
-0.0025549377,
0.0198732819,
0.0091938246,
-0.0440927893,
-0.030818196,
0.1102360711,
-0.0329690315,
0.0140099209,
-0.0206289068,
0.0620829575,
0.0432161763,
-0.0004320377,
-0.0065020709,
0.0281967167,
0.0600037985,
-0.0529787242,
-0.0185550973,
-0.0274682753,
-5.995608569e-33,
0.006368787,
-0.0195147302,
-0.0348267332,
0.0197450686,
-0.023493791,
0.0557224527,
-0.0274091307,
-0.0167652592,
-0.0239785481,
0.0256814938,
0.0032500802,
0.0489968508,
0.000439987,
-0.0108746905,
-0.0003439669,
-0.022717094,
0.0548444465,
0.0041028545,
0.0136688398,
-0.0053704656,
0.0334732756,
0.0441360138,
0.0786730796,
-0.0828204155,
-0.0199993253,
-0.0220635831,
-0.0538542271,
0.0150960544,
0.0320795923,
0.0732434094,
0.0263558868,
0.0563819408,
-0.0019463998,
-0.0003516257,
0.0000829172,
0.0043476704,
-0.0215969477,
-0.0171977468,
-0.0198430121,
0.00029574,
-0.0475141816,
-0.0365172587,
0.0672812611,
0.0366592892,
-0.0297766905,
-0.0215119664,
0.0342432521,
0.0010751946,
0.0683827996,
-0.0646359846,
-0.0645919815,
0.0077300691,
-0.0314647369,
-0.007322507,
0.0001826134,
0.0038828701,
0.0166544039,
0.0051315012,
-0.0848594457,
0.0211025085,
-0.0765909776,
-0.0292518381,
-0.0389820375,
-0.022823764,
0.0060433177,
0.0571277291,
0.0308183897,
0.0320326313,
0.0120140454,
-0.0022521995,
0.0619485714,
0.0353431553,
0.0799353942,
0.0996992141,
0.0216555446,
-0.052078262,
-0.0485186763,
-0.0089797145,
0.0523107424,
0.0040928032,
0.0215870813,
-0.0026613036,
-0.032780759,
0.0155817233,
0.0339594111,
0.0098472284,
-0.0121412501,
-0.0196167715,
0.0089442348,
0.029314965,
0.0149983969,
0.024072146,
0.0148164602,
-0.0595500097,
0.0126517583,
0.0488988906,
0.0010493639,
0.0409806333,
0.0289177001,
0.0223613027,
-0.0163350627,
-0.0295009911,
0.0056182127,
0.0608596653,
0.0298955869,
0.0265367813,
0.0815188289,
0.0251238421,
-0.0143050421,
0.0009775233,
0.022983484,
0.014084423,
-0.0534978509,
0.0510524623,
-0.015225416,
0.0458805971,
0.001578244,
0.0294146109,
0.0179044828,
0.0263541136,
-0.0319182836,
0.0044742669,
0.0209804736,
0.0466626361,
-0.048122026,
0.0060247816,
-0.0012524804,
-0.0558682904,
-0.0047678668,
-0.0780770555,
0.0018402917,
-0.0385828651,
2.691e-7,
0.0342379212,
0.0685673431,
0.0127207953,
0.0116459792,
0.0522683784,
0.0816014037,
-0.0014124835,
0.0414245874,
-0.0387519151,
-0.0116288196,
0.04422196,
0.0108417999,
-0.0057240035,
0.0165202506,
-0.0771857426,
0.0378724299,
-0.0286244005,
0.0256546233,
0.0009008768,
0.0088713309,
0.1043833196,
0.0336488523,
0.0675590783,
-0.018314749,
0.0120005338,
-0.0225860029,
0.0218489654,
0.0329189487,
0.0381161422,
-0.0226210151,
-0.004063955,
-0.0353661813,
-0.0012708467,
0.010257991,
0.0085164998,
-0.013706482,
-0.0219766032,
0.0639275983,
-0.0477391034,
-0.047750745,
0.0147780385,
0.0345307775,
-0.0286969487,
-0.0184761826,
0.0344040468,
-0.0291481111,
-0.0058681206,
-0.0463513583,
0.002288474,
0.0004560714,
0.0832931474,
0.0306253508,
-0.028642837,
0.0017389177,
0.0180164129,
-0.0050832941,
-0.0280761495,
-0.1158850044,
0.0233489033,
0.0290429499,
-0.059412051,
0.0047592763,
-0.0078147259,
0.0397915393,
0.0648950338,
-0.069690004,
0.0242712405,
1.903510145e-34,
0.0372788832,
-0.0037769752,
0.0406225696,
-0.0280412529,
-0.006972569,
0.0299586318,
-0.0028748109,
-0.0016662275,
0.009868525,
0.0004667479,
-0.0212975666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03613v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03613v2 | Evaluating ChatGPT as a Recommender System: A Rigorous Approach | 2023-09-07T10:13:09 | 2024-06-04T14:25:45 | Dario Di Palma, Giovanni Maria Biancofiore, Vito Walter Anelli, Fedelucio Narducci, Tommaso Di Noia, Eugenio Di Sciascio | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently shown impressive abilities in
handling various natural language-related tasks. Among different LLMs, current
studies have assessed ChatGPT's superior performance across manifold tasks,
especially under the zero/few-shot prompting conditions. Given such successes,
the Recommender Systems (RSs) research community have started investigating its
potential applications within the recommendation scenario. However, although
various methods have been proposed to integrate ChatGPT's capabilities into
RSs, current research struggles to comprehensively evaluate such models while
considering the peculiarities of generative models. Often, evaluations do not
consider hallucinations, duplications, and out-of-the-closed domain
recommendations and solely focus on accuracy metrics, neglecting the impact on
beyond-accuracy facets. To bridge this gap, we propose a robust evaluation
pipeline to assess ChatGPT's ability as an RS and post-process ChatGPT
recommendations to account for these aspects. Through this pipeline, we
investigate ChatGPT-3.5 and ChatGPT-4 performance in the recommendation task
under the zero-shot condition employing the role-playing prompt. We analyze the
model's functionality in three settings: the Top-N Recommendation, the
cold-start recommendation, and the re-ranking of a list of recommendations, and
in three domains: movies, music, and books. The experiments reveal that ChatGPT
exhibits higher accuracy than the baselines on books domain. It also excels in
re-ranking and cold-start scenarios while maintaining reasonable
beyond-accuracy metrics. Furthermore, we measure the similarity between the
ChatGPT recommendations and the other recommenders, providing insights about
how ChatGPT could be categorized in the realm of recommender systems. The
evaluation pipeline is publicly released for future research. | [
0.0500869267,
-0.0241067838,
-0.0064707864,
0.0226875544,
-0.0358063951,
-0.007748737,
0.0187237617,
0.0015280414,
0.0791107118,
-0.0289925393,
-0.0837510601,
-0.0517921783,
-0.0164985545,
0.042308066,
-0.0095274718,
-0.0380386375,
0.0122723235,
-0.0461491458,
0.0208898038,
-0.0115683312,
-0.015308111,
0.0084058633,
0.0186986253,
0.0583255552,
0.0508689992,
-0.0057771485,
0.0194423459,
0.0032680647,
0.000292296,
-0.0195937436,
-0.0102559188,
0.0312359482,
0.0181465335,
0.0251524597,
0.0000020365,
-0.0303587727,
0.0161043182,
-0.0331773795,
0.0202855747,
-0.0104113705,
0.0439736471,
0.0798730776,
0.0070849233,
-0.0037721526,
-0.0311074797,
-0.0113843996,
0.0263019577,
0.0430841893,
0.0226574186,
0.058062911,
-0.0185959637,
-0.0003891342,
0.0139350919,
-0.0261158943,
0.0722241849,
-0.0122056156,
0.0081672985,
0.0031446933,
0.0603347756,
0.0401949733,
-0.0196133684,
0.0161489714,
0.0113535346,
-0.0292766839,
0.0432391278,
0.0496583655,
-0.0445294231,
-0.0037745975,
0.0043079401,
0.0674823821,
-0.0086038215,
-0.0211364627,
0.0018028669,
0.0159366075,
0.0091367336,
0.0044285343,
-0.0551223047,
-0.0177457444,
0.0060963375,
-0.0093974015,
-0.0100511275,
0.0347383507,
0.0593773611,
-0.0222068634,
0.0517295077,
0.0605996065,
0.0406712033,
-0.0452977233,
0.0059586046,
0.0030798819,
-0.0125275888,
-0.0722221956,
0.0005933901,
-0.0166845992,
-0.0801991299,
-0.0052182176,
-0.023706397,
0.0718513355,
0.0042724721,
-0.0193667375,
0.0183103774,
0.0369327441,
-0.0258781817,
0.0615730099,
0.0084353983,
0.0261759609,
-0.0033132632,
0.0054098554,
-0.0456908047,
0.0158529412,
-0.0426206999,
-0.0165977385,
-0.017101163,
0.0259678215,
-0.0048630065,
-0.0632461011,
-0.062576808,
0.0208668374,
-0.0152894547,
0.0210179556,
0.0276975259,
0.045682542,
0.0103777694,
-0.006024993,
-0.0619238056,
0.0114239184,
-0.0300683696,
-0.0098653296,
0.0283795521,
-0.0178327747,
0.0199514646,
-0.0011257981,
-0.0147983087,
-0.0449867584,
-0.0036771938,
0.0506181344,
0.0288223028,
-0.0474222377,
-0.0014364013,
-0.0193075743,
-0.0284732468,
-0.0858344436,
-0.0427662991,
-0.0556063913,
0.0409930423,
0.0347952396,
0.0290622599,
0.0227768868,
0.005213575,
0.0011338629,
-0.0154671138,
0.0571038835,
0.0594581887,
0.0036261424,
0.0092915613,
0.0367060341,
-0.0481842645,
0.0251424238,
-0.0131039126,
0.0523467958,
0.0494801365,
0.0119075151,
0.0498534031,
0.0336177498,
-0.0507471487,
0.0142874019,
-0.0067288894,
0.0147434762,
-0.0105789565,
0.0597907901,
0.0028620095,
0.0499389321,
-0.0860957354,
-0.0294453464,
0.0723474547,
0.035911303,
0.0370637625,
0.0525738448,
0.0864890367,
0.0330025032,
-0.0213082116,
0.0413634814,
-0.030531032,
0.0536779501,
-0.0168839842,
-0.0250557102,
0.0619708337,
0.0133707644,
-0.037027631,
-0.0157159269,
0.0282797478,
-0.0158161353,
0.0035526908,
-0.000350319,
0.0096248062,
-0.0049630678,
-0.0504991859,
-0.008335338,
0.0342653766,
-0.0248426888,
0.0230897982,
-0.0505541377,
0.0387329049,
0.153622672,
0.0947339237,
-0.0143704731,
0.0057572983,
-0.017971497,
-0.0008765324,
-0.015962638,
0.0501143038,
-0.020286249,
0.0160789154,
-0.0336862877,
-0.0197995268,
0.0068162014,
0.0141134039,
0.0512618087,
-0.0210857112,
0.0072861761,
-0.0082220268,
-0.0245924443,
-0.0160732698,
-0.0282794405,
-0.0256876536,
-0.0214588437,
0.0186674464,
-0.0252603348,
0.0118175186,
-0.0020501842,
0.0128404582,
0.0048305779,
0.0003155656,
-0.0218813997,
-0.0387026854,
0.0191932525,
-0.0723648816,
-0.023495052,
0.0065065534,
-0.0282824133,
0.0218476094,
0.0373464748,
0.0163868871,
-0.0263924487,
0.0030591737,
0.0052407407,
0.0381502248,
-0.0288290847,
0.0357044712,
0.0107116355,
0.0142179374,
-0.0053902278,
0.0740558207,
0.0202960223,
0.0408863239,
0.0114640435,
-0.0009000433,
-0.0026154073,
-0.0611279272,
-0.0549177788,
0.0173784308,
0.0210555512,
0.0032063157,
0.0329869129,
-0.0356308855,
-0.0517081283,
-0.0419229008,
-0.0970155671,
0.0038124667,
0.0043700398,
-0.0422102325,
0.0020872352,
0.0376636647,
-0.0121897394,
-0.0062769759,
-0.0507592224,
0.0072033298,
0.00775568,
0.0273242276,
-0.0149664292,
0.0001274223,
-0.0284877159,
-0.0297706332,
-0.0114801871,
-0.0093754176,
0.0458609574,
-0.0062840623,
0.0165889524,
-0.0410942808,
-0.0057267621,
-0.050211817,
-0.002812956,
-0.0246982183,
0.0279511902,
0.0085798493,
-0.0145766223,
0.0723346248,
0.0127606215,
0.0111568123,
0.0060923523,
0.0570368618,
-0.0288226437,
-0.0603728369,
-0.0060236147,
-0.0246056411,
-0.0217630323,
-0.013513362,
-0.0092340456,
-0.0164833348,
0.0137454905,
0.0061869989,
0.0092962068,
-0.0881444961,
0.029648928,
-0.0071710534,
-0.0081326915,
-0.0412161127,
-0.0169417728,
-0.0253136717,
0.0475321449,
0.0068766559,
-0.0202298481,
0.0743924528,
-0.0235875733,
-0.022253314,
-0.0189906377,
0.0000623404,
-0.0354053378,
0.0133167347,
0.0269730613,
0.0063775056,
0.005864874,
-0.0235287622,
-0.0196250994,
0.025712302,
0.0450667255,
-0.0481451973,
0.0043618488,
0.0076088407,
-0.0021182681,
0.0336068906,
-0.0358036421,
-0.0505187921,
-0.0511680208,
-0.0067366106,
-0.0233459063,
-0.0024399438,
-0.0066494602,
-0.0547186732,
0.0145272817,
-0.0052012615,
0.0408193804,
-0.022997098,
-0.0509541258,
0.0170537662,
0.0242851097,
0.0747128502,
-0.0424083844,
-0.0029005571,
0.0003925138,
0.0679288507,
0.0453711078,
0.001821246,
-0.0120989811,
-0.0281239543,
0.0099079125,
0.0461330414,
-0.0034947651,
-0.051015459,
0.0479598716,
0.0011931198,
0.0037060501,
-0.02345201,
0.1153341755,
0.0379251949,
-0.1040344536,
0.0085638585,
-0.015100861,
0.0324205384,
0.0214999113,
0.0168342646,
-0.0741336271,
-0.0012416418,
-0.0042839544,
0.0210258607,
0.0011162338,
-0.0355876386,
-0.0250706002,
-0.1135550439,
0.0890510604,
0.0041918326,
0.0023924354,
0.0317737274,
-0.0327210985,
-0.0103619397,
-0.0250097644,
0.0074453321,
-0.0073013129,
-0.0106406659,
0.0054070968,
-0.0259240214,
-0.0041373633,
-0.0259968434,
0.0817232728,
-0.0315768719,
0.0674084723,
0.0703911185,
0.0422467515,
0.0387272164,
-0.020627426,
-0.0161177386,
0.0220196415,
-0.0182074066,
0.0228783786,
0.0287793428,
-0.0303988326,
0.0235565417,
-0.0255370997,
0.0107789962,
-0.0019310534,
-0.023435263,
0.0084305918,
0.0637225956,
-0.0297769941,
-0.036290016,
-0.0112620015,
0.051385697,
0.0097580738,
0.0804855302,
0.0136713432,
-0.0483014546,
0.0013787047,
-0.0218075551,
0.0201000087,
0.0009261527,
-0.0714575425,
-0.0198466498,
0.0486079641,
-0.0042776573,
-0.06870763,
-0.0119416015,
-0.0222893115,
0.0061250664,
-0.0153424395,
0.0512051769,
-0.0421272069,
-0.0157868396,
0.0487621203,
0.0042659855,
-0.0128735155,
0.0102669522,
-0.0546642579,
-0.0008894179,
0.0465862751,
-0.0645201504,
0.000483389,
-0.0011593638,
-0.0586457886,
-0.0481441393,
-0.0102237388,
0.0398739316,
0.0319385678,
0.0444267131,
-0.0635394529,
-0.0590504408,
0.0244984925,
0.0431894027,
-0.0441293791,
-0.006258742,
-0.0244899783,
0.0491020456,
-0.0009264241,
0.0226533115,
-0.0644154623,
0.0118328119,
-0.022373151,
0.0011052716,
0.0183362775,
-0.0347555727,
0.0164729748,
0.0044408585,
0.0310509149,
-0.039921321,
0.0490380712,
-0.008811499,
-0.0086928289,
-0.0438486747,
-0.0276055653,
-0.0458206013,
-0.0010257567,
0.0839855894,
-0.0030537846,
-0.0441924185,
-0.0360812321,
-0.0538496189,
0.0147667294,
-0.0729073286,
-0.0324206315,
0.0132824853,
-0.0599450693,
0.0484802872,
-0.0053097396,
-0.0155495191,
0.0052840672,
0.0251760706,
0.0376879796,
-0.011877601,
0.0574861169,
0.0104131196,
-0.0247165859,
-0.0018853326,
0.0639511347,
-0.0573707223,
-0.0606475621,
-0.0145446118,
0.0750692934,
0.0454989299,
-0.0370173864,
0.0389789417,
-0.0353105031,
0.0124304462,
-0.043052379,
-0.0014644708,
0.0182407685,
-0.042836193,
-0.0064584254,
0.0555025451,
-0.0020703964,
0.0613012463,
0.0903715789,
-0.0249440502,
-0.0014904505,
0.0328153186,
-0.0529462881,
-0.0230806936,
-0.0139002614,
-0.0605382919,
0.0350416005,
-0.0158629399,
-0.0032855496,
-0.0554724112,
-0.0396101326,
-0.0113590108,
-0.0171878431,
0.0249503087,
-0.0296914615,
0.0293248259,
0.0663369596,
-0.0099939415,
0.0154420175,
-0.0485231653,
-0.0312253106,
-0.010562594,
-0.0159923937,
-0.0376041234,
-6.408383778e-33,
0.0234996546,
0.0108625637,
0.0254695695,
0.0239239801,
-0.046153035,
-0.0212492608,
-0.0139663769,
0.0075108027,
0.0737194344,
0.0026152683,
-0.0189706273,
-0.0035251766,
0.0076064616,
0.0064910813,
-0.0034919176,
-0.0491442308,
0.0593337491,
0.0149588762,
-0.0540435612,
0.0467996299,
0.0492154136,
0.0277252588,
-0.0085429456,
-0.0573927611,
0.0166911352,
-0.0523055084,
-0.0117459334,
-0.0260027424,
0.0122859087,
0.0670472234,
-0.0364333503,
0.0588405803,
0.0079032509,
-0.053130962,
-0.003058454,
0.0084742503,
-0.0507361852,
-0.0051520942,
0.0264414586,
-0.0106357979,
-0.0122911548,
-0.0051296349,
0.0081062587,
-0.0008264157,
-0.0168634765,
-0.0301025212,
0.024303956,
-0.010870751,
-0.0404127352,
-0.0099232327,
-0.0357058756,
0.0077695018,
-0.0087747695,
-0.0471893586,
0.0045459396,
0.0783986896,
-0.0216636714,
0.0486529134,
-0.0399570353,
0.0407997109,
-0.0363357924,
0.0279462021,
0.0142761795,
-0.032866694,
-0.0232313052,
0.0665353984,
0.0412990563,
-0.0089284685,
-0.0219201557,
-0.003675831,
-0.0202992037,
0.0327305831,
0.0015401599,
0.0343662091,
0.0378968157,
0.0050337934,
-0.024318492,
0.041150067,
0.0013744634,
-0.0169671662,
0.0782152936,
0.0239410922,
-0.0310169328,
-0.0331720747,
0.0009312602,
-0.0150656374,
-0.0523543507,
-0.0797329098,
0.0432583503,
0.0185312703,
0.0077504497,
-0.042630665,
0.0332525745,
-0.0535367876,
-0.0096136509,
-0.0097458577,
-0.0534246527,
0.0106940558,
0.0051296321,
0.0281481668,
-0.0173610859,
0.0076088924,
0.0648867339,
-0.0128615005,
-0.0298209917,
0.0101685468,
0.0071525183,
0.035858348,
-0.0452698655,
0.0001270356,
-0.0095699457,
-0.0056142849,
-0.0212506596,
0.0135584818,
0.0303641539,
0.0177372545,
-0.0487873517,
0.0468298905,
0.0062592761,
0.0307756271,
-0.0170200225,
-0.0356236659,
-0.0210151821,
-0.0114832725,
-0.0298416819,
-0.0135774324,
-0.0333427191,
-0.0454062633,
0.048779238,
-0.0444059297,
-0.0403818563,
-0.0241512861,
2.942e-7,
-0.0229713358,
0.0244282112,
-0.0218374021,
-0.026815623,
0.0324488245,
0.0233037509,
0.0084254891,
0.0533600822,
0.0645426884,
0.0107715782,
0.0353982002,
0.0014994477,
0.0253059473,
0.0169069581,
-0.0999192446,
0.0184662063,
-0.0922537968,
-0.0067087361,
-0.0414372571,
-0.0330566391,
0.0293106306,
0.0699447989,
0.0618282482,
0.0062547005,
0.0167378653,
-0.0420048311,
0.0817311183,
-0.0555950478,
-0.0530623756,
0.0009993968,
0.0749311969,
0.0140388319,
-0.0080121374,
0.0002197117,
-0.0152801704,
-0.0041920948,
0.0375489257,
0.0301009212,
0.002928525,
-0.0305849854,
0.0001118284,
0.0403339677,
0.0141174821,
-0.0608166344,
0.0906812027,
-0.0421173908,
-0.0200157911,
-0.0178692844,
-0.0610580631,
-0.0151836444,
0.0570041724,
-0.0266862679,
-0.034759406,
0.0128905075,
0.013226605,
0.0291121118,
-0.0102254814,
-0.0618794337,
0.0132904053,
-0.0239982586,
-0.0256446581,
-0.0635246038,
-0.0490005873,
0.0183038749,
-0.0054498101,
-0.0686504319,
0.0244823564,
2.547929694e-34,
0.0425611995,
0.0440943427,
0.0094573759,
-0.0264383815,
0.0272778161,
0.0041062809,
0.0244924109,
0.0201983564,
0.0291780997,
-0.054339014,
-0.0288044531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03595v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03595v1 | Loquacity and Visible Emotion: ChatGPT as a Policy Advisor | 2023-09-07T09:40:12 | 2023-09-07T09:40:12 | Claudia Biancotti, Carolina Camassa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, J.4; K.4.1 | ChatGPT, a software seeking to simulate human conversational abilities, is
attracting increasing attention. It is sometimes portrayed as a groundbreaking
productivity aid, including for creative work. In this paper, we run an
experiment to assess its potential in complex writing tasks. We ask the
software to compose a policy brief for the Board of the Bank of Italy. We find
that ChatGPT can accelerate workflows by providing well-structured content
suggestions, and by producing extensive, linguistically correct text in a
matter of seconds. It does, however, require a significant amount of expert
supervision, which partially offsets productivity gains. If the app is used
naively, output can be incorrect, superficial, or irrelevant. Superficiality is
an especially problematic limitation in the context of policy advice intended
for high-level audiences. | [
0.0446610078,
0.0110860383,
-0.0341140367,
-0.0221625771,
-0.035823863,
0.0017233769,
0.0123873968,
0.04225621,
0.0454858653,
-0.0130430087,
-0.0126980981,
-0.0114898831,
0.0148608293,
0.0683118254,
0.0053847414,
-0.087785989,
0.0150262238,
0.0207233168,
0.0725696534,
0.0107568838,
0.05878352,
0.0300023593,
-0.021554973,
0.0753229782,
-0.0387393162,
-0.0315630399,
-0.0460959561,
0.0199955143,
0.0196933504,
0.009101389,
0.0044903709,
0.0781189501,
-0.0201391838,
0.0030677684,
0.0000020825,
-0.0103552444,
0.0191392824,
-0.0339419879,
0.0430234559,
-0.0061113941,
0.1053267866,
-0.0084002288,
-0.0328688323,
0.0091728009,
-0.0385708213,
0.0522694774,
0.0461629555,
0.0283848122,
0.0480872206,
0.0577319972,
-0.0223227032,
0.0577256493,
-0.0158424433,
-0.01274746,
0.0385362916,
-0.0029156231,
-0.0326036885,
-0.0019324403,
0.0281639248,
-0.0201407094,
0.017276695,
0.0231321137,
-0.0056251097,
-0.052296374,
-0.0023959491,
0.0372783653,
-0.0183992926,
-0.0440772437,
-0.0031081429,
0.0468578376,
0.0264181551,
0.0222671349,
0.0152156698,
-0.0026274768,
0.0333964005,
0.0284709744,
-0.0394672826,
0.0135934921,
-0.0278701093,
-0.0239283871,
-0.0168522224,
0.0185504518,
0.0018256204,
0.0019989605,
0.0848528966,
-0.0197366588,
-0.0122856805,
-0.0258324239,
0.0246176664,
0.0290504619,
0.0399920344,
-0.0799690709,
0.0036446687,
0.0320532806,
-0.0380157121,
0.0104700355,
-0.0349523984,
0.0139983511,
0.0160778034,
-0.0698256046,
0.0214111302,
0.0516644306,
0.0127910245,
0.021399023,
0.0435154252,
0.0091241319,
0.0031289044,
0.0166107621,
-0.0051879915,
0.0374658816,
-0.056450624,
-0.0312550329,
-0.0505078435,
0.025198888,
-0.0636484474,
-0.0682509467,
-0.0414082892,
0.0064208382,
-0.0526860356,
0.0299748965,
-0.0046772156,
0.0246243905,
-0.0363523476,
0.0048012184,
-0.0531382337,
0.0210766308,
-0.0475389771,
-0.0047044777,
0.0110475132,
0.0072532147,
0.0040584765,
0.0301781986,
0.0027528664,
0.0195932649,
0.0095024332,
0.0360806547,
-0.014595449,
0.0009849793,
-0.0049137603,
-0.0377681367,
-0.0170785282,
-0.0555586144,
-0.0026959577,
-0.0440348648,
0.0163975097,
-0.0223621186,
-0.026871765,
-0.023695644,
0.0055362009,
0.0000701092,
0.0051290547,
0.0375353955,
-0.0424670987,
-0.0045423051,
0.0073625189,
0.03544835,
-0.0259770006,
0.031422969,
0.0242162272,
0.063949734,
0.0357357897,
-0.0003138024,
0.0805339217,
0.0292344261,
-0.0336495936,
0.0175171234,
0.0111317253,
-0.0297326539,
-0.0265330859,
0.0244854707,
0.0189054124,
0.0184743498,
-0.0213119015,
0.0799010694,
0.0974340066,
0.0624944866,
-0.0043106116,
0.0425770245,
0.0065435143,
0.0518173426,
0.0008551201,
0.0151283592,
-0.0066516409,
0.0811021551,
-0.0185034275,
0.0131100602,
-0.008606513,
-0.005043915,
-0.0191350374,
-0.0392559618,
0.0032988547,
0.002834352,
0.0153752537,
-0.0114724506,
-0.0043910383,
0.0011259136,
-0.0520338379,
-0.0083329557,
0.0151556395,
-0.0390165895,
-0.0232361648,
-0.0370415077,
0.0394126363,
0.1522619277,
0.026814077,
-0.0094454065,
0.0319687054,
-0.0285010431,
0.0407943875,
0.0895699561,
0.0818408653,
-0.0019008509,
-0.0213119294,
-0.0269988514,
0.0171306729,
-0.038921684,
0.0124078291,
0.0434818491,
0.0153814284,
0.0362048969,
-0.0028360893,
0.0277468748,
-0.0058663185,
0.0153827984,
0.0097913221,
-0.0346312895,
-0.0119957132,
-0.0055812276,
-0.0106716417,
0.0236856733,
-0.0453984998,
0.0077995555,
-0.00927117,
0.0021170562,
-0.025026869,
0.0332395583,
-0.0189828388,
0.0330497883,
-0.0112450542,
-0.0457825921,
-0.0271028578,
-0.0260393061,
0.0006303426,
0.010879891,
0.0114715891,
-0.0134358238,
0.0380202718,
-0.014668162,
-0.0080037676,
-0.0127729764,
-0.0137574393,
0.0144649725,
0.0212688204,
0.0221061651,
0.0128706861,
-0.0066599427,
0.0331929587,
-0.0324463658,
-0.038984485,
0.0254251473,
0.0546192192,
0.0143915918,
0.0010071786,
0.0064186915,
0.0297263283,
-0.0583920106,
-0.0680763051,
-0.1171259433,
-0.0102071669,
-0.0024622825,
-0.0103057567,
0.0305045694,
-0.0179034621,
-0.0273158215,
0.0058355229,
-0.0471741818,
-0.0104568359,
-0.0194407888,
-0.0082203634,
0.0369228795,
-0.0087255603,
0.0088640517,
-0.0316200107,
0.028382672,
-0.0132992519,
-0.0135815777,
0.0814366415,
-0.0412447378,
-0.0062211743,
0.0138373878,
-0.0103018675,
-0.0245724581,
-0.0049001533,
-0.0453027748,
0.0523248874,
0.0173303913,
0.0431086645,
0.0323721953,
0.013428323,
0.0627817065,
0.0292542744,
-0.0053703794,
-0.023503501,
0.0064671929,
-0.0113658216,
0.0528418943,
-0.0026549692,
-0.0499802008,
0.0118803652,
0.0105864741,
0.0248593371,
0.0667566583,
-0.062070027,
0.0895177722,
-0.0058132648,
-0.0152071696,
-0.0258420091,
-0.0188221633,
-0.0270163435,
0.0228377804,
-0.0190132223,
-0.0262959674,
0.0248726718,
-0.0002671058,
-0.0317303203,
-0.0054736105,
-0.0298322812,
-0.0176060405,
0.1058524698,
-0.0804111511,
0.008071824,
-0.0238160882,
0.0052400935,
-0.0272212401,
-0.0315715186,
0.0377570987,
-0.0345627442,
-0.0030971484,
-0.0627184212,
-0.0181630645,
-0.0025271822,
-0.0441635028,
-0.0039486261,
-0.0407106616,
-0.0398597494,
-0.0108313011,
0.0961187109,
-0.0571300164,
-0.036115922,
0.0047789523,
0.0314987376,
0.0545544103,
-0.0157284904,
-0.0327616259,
0.003575986,
-0.0236238446,
0.0090926224,
-0.0127638802,
-0.0228552204,
-0.0106270341,
0.0367857404,
0.0606936328,
-0.0250070617,
-0.0094338423,
-0.0052145733,
-0.0130157499,
-0.0393654443,
0.0015113126,
-0.0195441861,
-0.0065529742,
0.0450607948,
-0.0286515392,
-0.0075683817,
0.0836328566,
0.0228795726,
-0.040273305,
0.0072822389,
-0.0371349566,
0.0209575202,
0.0074265087,
0.0537659302,
-0.0409249291,
0.0075896075,
0.0148163317,
0.0279180426,
-0.05139881,
-0.0335927717,
-0.0184074044,
-0.0729739368,
0.0651712418,
0.0005252561,
0.0089795832,
0.0194878168,
-0.0235879235,
-0.0126698688,
0.031483002,
-0.0442804955,
-0.0342769586,
0.0005995815,
0.0070331269,
0.0102244057,
-0.0600211397,
0.019180093,
0.0114759384,
0.0180731602,
0.0564111918,
0.0584185421,
0.0976174846,
0.0047377055,
-0.0137646468,
0.0140112964,
0.0777672529,
0.0168430712,
0.0003819219,
0.0447121039,
-0.019229807,
0.0175274648,
-0.0675127134,
0.0196297653,
0.0051303413,
-0.0128399068,
0.0653229281,
0.0011147846,
-0.0470959321,
-0.0429026522,
-0.0093436893,
0.04905295,
0.0618318431,
0.043354284,
0.0213664342,
-0.0463427566,
-0.0386537202,
-0.0287855417,
0.021706529,
-0.0571015142,
-0.0748224556,
-0.0475495718,
0.003494974,
0.0044737514,
-0.0656465814,
-0.0687817857,
0.0341169499,
0.063553296,
-0.0088487547,
-0.0341756642,
-0.0159208775,
0.034657903,
0.0284293406,
0.0021315317,
0.0126247248,
0.0270205401,
-0.0058889277,
-0.0608694255,
-0.0677095652,
-0.0047002365,
0.0042484058,
0.0063254326,
-0.0362437032,
-0.0249415804,
-0.0090140486,
0.0294060651,
0.0336738117,
0.0060733333,
0.000713375,
-0.0033672466,
0.0209168661,
0.078078948,
-0.0372343622,
0.0130960559,
0.0191133004,
0.0364787206,
0.0233673081,
-0.0023133797,
-0.0051835533,
0.0060953898,
0.0143839298,
0.029720882,
-0.009283917,
-0.0258221421,
0.0032134056,
0.0166891366,
-0.0203869827,
-0.0291673541,
-0.0293113068,
-0.0429612733,
-0.0085618282,
-0.0293882918,
-0.0012512474,
-0.0312831178,
-0.0484310873,
-0.019389458,
-0.0318120867,
0.0177934058,
0.021157641,
-0.0704241097,
-0.0155304978,
-0.0002024045,
0.0047310931,
-0.0139218634,
0.0079875374,
0.0299091227,
0.0032136869,
-0.0322958007,
0.0743773952,
-0.0255792495,
0.0440720581,
0.0004462234,
0.0451119691,
0.0116911968,
-0.0383435488,
0.0272575282,
0.0205704942,
-0.059289027,
-0.0743256435,
-0.0058885226,
0.1013967246,
0.0230561681,
-0.008895088,
0.0013792856,
-0.0883422196,
0.0158944577,
0.0002617101,
0.0156552512,
0.0021213929,
-0.0464008376,
-0.0200397428,
-0.0115386229,
-0.0273033623,
-0.0504052751,
0.0440983102,
-0.0805111751,
0.0054733129,
0.0213220119,
-0.0273597613,
-0.0371128693,
-0.0484401695,
0.0252858903,
0.0201434102,
0.0222837739,
-0.0114946542,
-0.11033573,
-0.0148455761,
0.0012251303,
-0.0042819381,
-0.0074116103,
-0.0629165247,
0.0205506589,
0.0407581218,
-0.005948172,
0.0295935236,
-0.0362843871,
0.032821212,
-0.0572230183,
0.0144355157,
-0.0557174943,
-5.831666045e-33,
-0.0183695853,
-0.0560262538,
0.0267397519,
0.0157288983,
-0.0091324951,
0.009332397,
-0.0385848507,
0.0497394279,
0.0299380086,
0.0440052114,
-0.0495213568,
0.0063949693,
0.0118407439,
-0.0452376381,
-0.0050478512,
0.0131448898,
0.0413925722,
0.000920864,
-0.0380534343,
0.0124709727,
0.0080431411,
-0.0128776906,
0.0051850565,
-0.0839100629,
0.0506060608,
-0.0033688769,
-0.0301558618,
-0.0497444943,
0.0414611772,
0.0160524696,
0.0053202948,
0.0415077098,
-0.0010703055,
-0.0136146592,
0.0002493191,
0.0844795257,
0.011102099,
-0.0618637688,
-0.0046569137,
-0.0366800129,
-0.0193347707,
-0.0129557671,
-0.0077343397,
0.0108781774,
-0.0410728827,
-0.0074616312,
0.0121381152,
0.004460908,
-0.0227230527,
-0.0303781703,
-0.0971627682,
0.0241408497,
-0.0176677182,
-0.0279755238,
-0.0313173272,
0.0571639203,
-0.0144214239,
-0.0496700406,
-0.0527909733,
0.0270242803,
-0.0239950214,
-0.0090140318,
0.0320494287,
-0.0205651987,
-0.002228386,
0.0662233979,
0.0226543527,
0.1020508185,
-0.0551479161,
-0.0013356932,
0.0243596546,
0.0332754254,
0.046328675,
0.0509643778,
0.01348483,
-0.0523211323,
0.0259816684,
0.0430281535,
0.0449451804,
-0.0016374151,
0.0315519311,
-0.0111412816,
-0.0385718867,
-0.0281655379,
0.0133884652,
0.0088376887,
0.0054013906,
-0.0715492442,
0.0163276307,
-0.0083370591,
0.0445970446,
-0.0207308214,
-0.0404584892,
-0.0001242595,
0.0234252047,
-0.0331046768,
-0.0517209247,
0.043376945,
-0.0133777168,
-0.0426147804,
-0.039322529,
-0.0144660566,
-0.0022060366,
0.0873845443,
0.0579013824,
0.0323728137,
0.0016025,
-0.0134561891,
-0.0597197115,
-0.0175128281,
-0.0147458818,
0.0865255892,
0.0334193259,
-0.0323318541,
-0.0047106412,
-0.0312118735,
-0.0103831487,
-0.0129581885,
-0.0187514629,
0.0167559702,
-0.0218186677,
-0.0290768221,
-0.0249739178,
-0.0047812974,
-0.0533609986,
-0.0033427102,
-0.0465349033,
-0.01955414,
0.0219739322,
-0.0322058052,
-0.0224410109,
-0.0264215805,
2.817e-7,
-0.0184676647,
0.0460396484,
-0.0043470659,
0.0110772299,
0.0180724096,
0.0417794287,
-0.0081935031,
0.0500208586,
-0.015902821,
-0.0282761082,
0.0363637097,
0.019651847,
0.0590342581,
0.0473511368,
-0.1132823825,
-0.0590097606,
-0.073495023,
-0.002879695,
-0.0602803007,
0.0303305797,
0.0488032065,
-0.015755238,
0.0539066307,
-0.0266250093,
0.0144063365,
-0.002468751,
0.0419782661,
-0.0415858962,
0.0005985245,
-0.0112045575,
0.0168803055,
-0.0272078905,
-0.001476093,
0.0308616795,
-0.0222355966,
-0.0739948004,
-0.0186718311,
0.0958222002,
-0.0138116553,
0.0084859831,
0.0195458587,
0.0002753405,
-0.0005522356,
-0.0064043091,
0.0279287864,
-0.0454340801,
-0.0249993391,
-0.0250799712,
0.0001212685,
-0.0295555852,
0.0310459379,
0.0066801449,
-0.0368441418,
0.021144744,
-0.0038835837,
-0.0164854135,
0.0120305587,
-0.0044845548,
0.0077872491,
-0.0219372828,
-0.0379734226,
-0.0708971322,
-0.0495447032,
0.0408673659,
0.0005907434,
-0.0492660701,
0.0127484174,
2.430820151e-34,
0.0207450241,
0.0085524544,
0.0017569709,
0.0061952993,
0.067180872,
0.0554217957,
0.0701022968,
0.0123099377,
0.0469635651,
-0.0222642757,
-0.0082699182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03564v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03564v3 | Supervised Learning and Large Language Model Benchmarks on Mental Health Datasets: Cognitive Distortions and Suicidal Risks in Chinese Social Media | 2023-09-07T08:50:46 | 2024-06-09T12:49:52 | Hongzhi Qi, Qing Zhao, Jianqiang Li, Changwei Song, Wei Zhai, Dan Luo, Shuo Liu, Yi Jing Yu, Fan Wang, Huijing Zou, Bing Xiang Yang, Guanghui Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | On social media, users often express their personal feelings, which may
exhibit cognitive distortions or even suicidal tendencies on certain specific
topics. Early recognition of these signs is critical for effective
psychological intervention. In this paper, we introduce two novel datasets from
Chinese social media: SOS-HL-1K for suicidal risk classification and
SocialCD-3K for cognitive distortions detection. The SOS-HL-1K dataset
contained 1,249 posts and SocialCD-3K dataset was a multi-label classification
dataset that containing 3,407 posts. We propose a comprehensive evaluation
using two supervised learning methods and eight large language models (LLMs) on
the proposed datasets. From the prompt engineering perspective, we experimented
with two types of prompt strategies, including four zero-shot and five few-shot
strategies. We also evaluated the performance of the LLMs after fine-tuning on
the proposed tasks. The experimental results show that there is still a huge
gap between LLMs relying only on prompt engineering and supervised learning. In
the suicide classification task, this gap is 6.95% points in F1-score, while in
the cognitive distortion task, the gap is even more pronounced, reaching 31.53%
points in F1-score. However, after fine-tuning, this difference is
significantly reduced. In the suicide and cognitive distortion classification
tasks, the gap decreases to 4.31% and 3.14%, respectively. This research
highlights the potential of LLMs in psychological contexts, but supervised
learning remains necessary for more challenging tasks. All datasets and code
are made available. | [
0.0685390159,
0.029319223,
-0.009477037,
-0.021682851,
-0.0238479301,
0.0435000136,
0.0146160079,
0.0139724463,
0.0826332793,
-0.0348303951,
-0.0237430558,
-0.0266777799,
-0.0299180392,
0.0012979435,
-0.0324207209,
-0.0398044176,
0.039852757,
0.0279068425,
0.0657408386,
-0.0095779272,
0.004950128,
0.0309327245,
-0.0138355913,
0.0405359603,
-0.005137796,
-0.0269534662,
0.0328787379,
0.0144398464,
0.0321970508,
-0.0715039447,
-0.0022226525,
0.0631338954,
-0.0229232423,
0.0375881866,
0.0000022063,
-0.0573901273,
-0.0106379548,
-0.0338014476,
-0.0207113866,
-0.0442714877,
0.0372063518,
-0.0765367895,
0.0088198949,
0.0214484353,
-0.0506940149,
-0.0516450331,
0.0363086611,
0.0957455784,
0.0651512146,
0.0880639255,
-0.0193947628,
-0.0477495417,
0.0321245529,
-0.0102081317,
0.0090556219,
0.0024500506,
0.088169001,
0.0053084977,
0.0121118315,
0.0246643126,
-0.0236008503,
0.0187947005,
-0.01408426,
0.0056269639,
-0.0258090813,
-0.0041114558,
-0.027094312,
-0.0686639622,
0.0186125524,
0.0906587243,
-0.0386994593,
-0.0077573596,
0.0286766421,
-0.0300002471,
0.0004288409,
-0.0320597142,
-0.0028911005,
-0.0059953108,
-0.0160511415,
0.0221436955,
0.0317168497,
0.0055164192,
0.0144975604,
0.0231876858,
0.0494393371,
0.0091883671,
-0.0160195865,
-0.0293864775,
0.0168596935,
-0.0243191551,
-0.0645700246,
-0.0361520648,
0.0085985577,
0.0227560829,
-0.086303696,
0.0094655976,
-0.0657213256,
-0.0597263537,
0.0306248404,
-0.0704262182,
0.0645657033,
0.0356744304,
-0.0329083428,
0.0083422028,
0.0301052798,
0.021178551,
0.0267212074,
0.0379476957,
-0.0303748231,
0.0464427993,
-0.0648296475,
0.0264319275,
-0.0259986967,
0.0002849537,
0.0514557697,
-0.0181329437,
-0.1111104265,
0.0300764889,
-0.026689155,
0.0065309461,
0.0044609602,
-0.0506225377,
0.0003277159,
0.0218297653,
0.0078959689,
-0.0098144999,
-0.0023550482,
0.0205616113,
-0.0311528891,
-0.0192147009,
0.0170683172,
0.0183888655,
0.0154345995,
-0.0357281528,
0.0162251107,
0.0312837176,
0.0179363545,
-0.0210611727,
-0.0614212193,
-0.0206151456,
-0.0538676307,
-0.0140356133,
-0.0546615757,
-0.0256963037,
0.0180775374,
-0.0090487329,
-0.0141573744,
-0.0412886366,
0.0405937247,
-0.0260566492,
-0.0275022686,
0.0876097903,
-0.0290671363,
0.031377852,
0.0494134612,
0.0142852552,
-0.0289368667,
0.0844376236,
-0.0173245203,
0.0484255217,
0.0694532096,
-0.0323157832,
0.0233170297,
0.0102797067,
-0.0047094799,
-0.0046765185,
-0.0152617497,
-0.0192504972,
-0.001958827,
0.0164240841,
-0.0109814052,
0.0160051268,
0.0260404255,
0.0030309579,
0.0628468096,
0.0243232064,
0.014490243,
-0.0258349255,
0.0273304842,
0.056871172,
-0.0168341007,
-0.0248799846,
-0.0492049828,
-0.0333334804,
-0.0290293768,
-0.0015289799,
0.043273963,
-0.0132896453,
-0.0259047542,
-0.0390918255,
-0.0490528271,
-0.0208550841,
-0.0137359546,
0.0129004149,
0.0127696227,
-0.0149238864,
-0.008768593,
0.0197369251,
0.0386651233,
0.0123303905,
-0.0419522561,
-0.0208044853,
0.0197306108,
0.0396668203,
-0.0176742841,
-0.0740311742,
-0.0070518008,
-0.0215422641,
0.0419324934,
0.007202575,
0.0289470907,
0.0008576083,
0.0012921874,
-0.0133428611,
-0.0175830312,
0.0446132571,
-0.0005639865,
-0.0478973314,
0.0038561346,
0.0445916019,
-0.011959618,
0.0184920225,
-0.0433777161,
0.0542089418,
0.0264366567,
-0.0466277152,
0.0143654114,
0.0422900803,
0.0388441309,
-0.0032308586,
-0.0168487541,
-0.0185317136,
-0.0071125724,
-0.0130286431,
-0.0723970011,
-0.0577583648,
-0.0408069156,
-0.0454233736,
0.0460425392,
-0.0162996314,
-0.0191639271,
0.0326323882,
-0.0608517155,
-0.0370944925,
0.0021780666,
-0.0305138901,
-0.0348621905,
-0.0229057092,
0.0160971619,
-0.0556690842,
0.0299464781,
0.0001536504,
0.069343552,
-0.0136685958,
0.0415574461,
-0.0357216001,
-0.0184682589,
-0.014119165,
-0.0183833223,
-0.0455074385,
-0.0512032025,
-0.0427738652,
0.0204203296,
-0.0092439223,
0.0128294621,
-0.0219193045,
-0.0272209533,
-0.1076261476,
0.0179327205,
-0.048997581,
-0.0187492352,
0.0045360252,
-0.008667998,
-0.0438472964,
-0.0196853876,
-0.0232315063,
0.0309142526,
0.0109188501,
0.0444175526,
-0.0052529792,
-0.0081791738,
0.0253962465,
-0.0104617532,
-0.0064365715,
-0.0319752507,
0.0148589425,
-0.0014496731,
-0.0861002132,
-0.0357375816,
0.0153217772,
-0.0268094502,
-0.0194720626,
0.0058152857,
-0.0362546071,
-0.0106419371,
0.0044832909,
0.0432217419,
0.0404078029,
0.028883487,
0.067156747,
0.046710439,
0.0470317341,
-0.004145707,
0.0002196288,
-0.045026239,
-0.0400711,
-0.0455605946,
-0.0407449417,
-0.0177537147,
0.0444827005,
0.0616692528,
-0.0051462897,
-0.0386375934,
-0.0154516622,
-0.0388931036,
-0.0150137125,
-0.0266832244,
-0.0051417151,
-0.0089395558,
-0.0065573254,
-0.013807389,
-0.0284004919,
0.0624449439,
0.0289053377,
0.0378834233,
0.0137286047,
-0.0463447012,
-0.0288892426,
0.0284849517,
0.018623393,
0.0231244732,
0.0638780668,
-0.0140917003,
0.0192925129,
0.0255249161,
-0.0198782086,
-0.0344425775,
-0.0132714501,
-0.0013414522,
-0.0018361793,
-0.0032250206,
-0.0439768508,
-0.0392287783,
-0.0902909935,
-0.0382584445,
-0.0108399224,
-0.0382121615,
0.0210029017,
-0.0052009863,
0.0066962326,
-0.0197833683,
0.0172102805,
-0.0229391735,
-0.0107891979,
-0.015860958,
-0.0009813869,
0.063948907,
-0.0574759394,
0.0134288045,
-0.0246058479,
0.0756860748,
0.033170823,
-0.0437525399,
0.0615308583,
0.0084050987,
0.0277641807,
-0.0021271224,
-0.0068126549,
-0.0101912394,
0.0221148077,
0.0535501018,
-0.0020575798,
0.01264052,
0.1220121905,
0.0326853171,
-0.0625166222,
0.0180889256,
0.0129034296,
-0.0161631182,
0.031919498,
-0.0364025123,
-0.0522832647,
-0.0387604497,
-0.0274371412,
0.0365008637,
-0.0507218167,
-0.0382355452,
0.0190766808,
-0.0754637644,
0.061980579,
-0.0152900647,
-0.0269494355,
0.0125844833,
-0.0563359559,
0.0286202766,
-0.0097346418,
0.0019217437,
-0.0313286074,
-0.0111397197,
-0.0390344039,
-0.0009760278,
-0.0679531544,
-0.0587660596,
0.0346392021,
0.0013602247,
0.0732038543,
-0.0306300074,
0.0481316224,
0.0007972678,
-0.0331043303,
0.0281624533,
0.0342965908,
-0.0145040089,
-0.0199337024,
0.0684287697,
0.0214477796,
-0.0162612237,
-0.0415517502,
0.0682012737,
-0.0379797146,
-0.0023820628,
-0.0028726535,
0.0630929098,
-0.0293604452,
-0.0280728731,
-0.0095079839,
0.042807214,
0.0502009839,
0.0784589201,
0.03500228,
-0.0810622945,
-0.0023336441,
-0.0044361083,
-0.0470433719,
0.0005495326,
-0.0446175598,
0.038242165,
-0.050035581,
-0.0462264754,
-0.0425726846,
-0.011427341,
0.0182624757,
-0.0282853171,
-0.0123272277,
-0.0090693897,
0.0056834207,
0.0229263101,
-0.0710638687,
0.0396872722,
-0.0032095262,
0.0295677949,
-0.0569473691,
0.0369839855,
0.0231611505,
0.0026899469,
-0.0116039142,
-0.0098234219,
-0.0825074613,
-0.0385315791,
0.0319331773,
-0.0029516062,
-0.0001467184,
-0.0163357146,
-0.0189963859,
-0.0531565845,
0.048669491,
0.0427874699,
0.0027473755,
-0.0225130394,
0.0014416748,
0.0217107292,
0.000913476,
0.0485031679,
0.0094445813,
0.045145791,
0.0821946636,
-0.0144566456,
-0.0521917157,
0.0176237542,
-0.0170415156,
0.0307984147,
0.0721652284,
-0.0143716587,
-0.0371206589,
0.0065963096,
-0.0321049988,
0.0214526318,
-0.0488672964,
0.0243737325,
-0.026927406,
0.084765017,
-0.0034775313,
-0.0214002822,
-0.0192904398,
-0.0322609134,
-0.0179237239,
-0.061321605,
0.0156824179,
0.0042454065,
0.0462969355,
0.036726594,
0.00049219,
-0.0297419038,
0.0546396337,
0.0218621362,
-0.0071347454,
-0.0154258059,
0.0647999719,
-0.0047433502,
0.0305105746,
0.032512188,
0.028293984,
-0.03246402,
-0.0611268729,
-0.026208872,
-0.0073970528,
0.0612836182,
-0.0048751459,
0.0159270931,
-0.0008349565,
-0.0009741829,
-0.0312249865,
0.0459708795,
-0.0133013315,
-0.0574194193,
0.0265919529,
-0.0038348511,
-0.0337414742,
0.0251281038,
0.0753942505,
0.0128030255,
-0.0234977528,
0.0661654398,
-0.0378101468,
-0.0178818516,
0.0260778163,
0.0379490964,
0.035941042,
-0.0367920138,
0.0236801803,
-0.0295176413,
-0.0568744764,
0.0689010471,
-0.047648564,
-0.026676124,
0.0408012457,
0.0117583359,
0.0342647322,
0.0167289265,
-0.0064044115,
-0.0834682956,
0.0027418453,
0.0081473012,
-0.0549552627,
-0.0223788712,
-6.120258725e-33,
0.0280838814,
0.0040444732,
-0.0348869748,
0.0014884261,
0.0011682614,
0.009074281,
-0.005337372,
0.0331446342,
-0.0261616446,
0.0222842731,
0.0075479047,
0.0426951535,
0.0070049358,
0.0381961502,
0.0045180153,
-0.0132340258,
0.0030578326,
-0.005853856,
-0.0061897119,
0.0082442714,
0.0285506938,
0.0398566909,
0.0420491882,
-0.0743081644,
0.0360196605,
0.0335350223,
0.0042989547,
0.0215139296,
0.0444918387,
0.0446234979,
-0.0241144467,
0.1140261367,
0.0492275693,
-0.0231153518,
-0.0092278402,
0.0497326218,
-0.0390890054,
-0.0156913195,
-0.0221581366,
0.008898057,
-0.0057624984,
-0.0136831822,
-0.0135237779,
-0.018941028,
-0.0174374599,
-0.0304764453,
0.0362250917,
-0.029499568,
0.0192940012,
-0.0318245217,
-0.0099294698,
0.0067848116,
-0.0121296914,
0.0019255215,
-0.0066646468,
0.0312696844,
-0.021771457,
0.0646464676,
-0.0780916587,
0.0059361779,
-0.0372770689,
0.0013517608,
-0.0215617158,
-0.0241442453,
-0.0214888752,
0.0419457033,
-0.0052270694,
0.0170680527,
-0.0235655531,
0.0013394994,
0.0142461518,
0.0688739344,
0.0419780947,
0.0504241101,
0.0388402641,
-0.0698083565,
-0.0612956807,
0.0053976327,
0.0192926042,
-0.0187845156,
0.0366386361,
-0.0123447739,
-0.032887686,
-0.0117974067,
-0.0272401348,
-0.0185971446,
-0.0511103272,
0.022120636,
-0.0056656227,
0.0066539883,
-0.0069290022,
-0.0230812319,
0.0071035163,
-0.0633152127,
-0.0144127375,
0.0068959938,
0.0176080503,
0.0480764024,
0.0070855706,
0.0183026493,
-0.031669952,
-0.0241265129,
0.019859314,
-0.0059436201,
0.0393381193,
-0.0249576289,
0.0800087675,
-0.0148654748,
-0.0457919501,
-0.0109225139,
0.0240073688,
0.0027781583,
-0.0004543763,
0.0344612487,
0.0013020927,
0.0242117234,
0.0011889394,
0.0251845066,
0.0377408043,
0.0051575019,
-0.0082494766,
-0.0296404716,
-0.0378680937,
0.0064238957,
0.0013013459,
-0.0193366092,
-0.0297616329,
0.0386354849,
0.0127240568,
-0.0561154112,
-0.0013542931,
-0.005182269,
2.866e-7,
0.0373982638,
0.0515300818,
-0.0415073968,
0.049838271,
0.0111742439,
0.0424613282,
0.0263683498,
0.0636206493,
0.0165177491,
-0.0003409968,
0.0187986828,
0.0365986899,
0.0634057,
0.039155107,
-0.0521158837,
0.0013874688,
-0.0413669534,
0.0098915435,
-0.0839822963,
0.0217612702,
0.0945654884,
0.0757830963,
0.0147439297,
-0.0337700658,
-0.0022283059,
-0.0222400837,
0.0328029171,
-0.0096033737,
0.0167135373,
0.0423480421,
0.0331027284,
0.0145684695,
0.0300191175,
0.012478916,
-0.0144220684,
-0.0412037559,
0.0097177261,
0.05680364,
-0.0159643851,
-0.0091422396,
-0.0064581488,
0.0420123637,
0.0220603198,
-0.0500114858,
0.0909621045,
-0.0575549826,
-0.0374869257,
-0.0658413395,
0.0010312529,
-0.0262516681,
0.0649905503,
-0.0328684561,
-0.0106671127,
0.0525237508,
0.0596653856,
0.0134163955,
-0.0041013034,
-0.0662040487,
-0.0348397866,
0.0352872051,
-0.0122831399,
-0.0215140246,
-0.0016941526,
0.0303440876,
0.0298368894,
-0.0439212844,
0.027851304,
2.403107642e-34,
0.005564379,
0.0079822605,
0.0369318724,
-0.0390864834,
-0.0170935784,
0.0302795097,
-0.011404044,
0.0116501683,
-0.0187548585,
-0.0758023784,
0.01462097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03563v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03563v2 | All Labels Together: Low-shot Intent Detection with an Efficient Label Semantic Encoding Paradigm | 2023-09-07T08:50:45 | 2023-09-08T01:00:52 | Jiangshu Du, Congying Xia, Wenpeng Yin, Tingting Liang, Philip S. Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In intent detection tasks, leveraging meaningful semantic information from
intent labels can be particularly beneficial for few-shot scenarios. However,
existing few-shot intent detection methods either ignore the intent labels,
(e.g. treating intents as indices) or do not fully utilize this information
(e.g. only using part of the intent labels). In this work, we present an
end-to-end One-to-All system that enables the comparison of an input utterance
with all label candidates. The system can then fully utilize label semantics in
this way. Experiments on three few-shot intent detection tasks demonstrate that
One-to-All is especially effective when the training resource is extremely
scarce, achieving state-of-the-art performance in 1-, 3- and 5-shot settings.
Moreover, we present a novel pretraining strategy for our model that utilizes
indirect supervision from paraphrasing, enabling zero-shot cross-domain
generalization on intent detection tasks. Our code is at
https://github.com/jiangshdd/AllLablesTogether. | [
0.0407225266,
0.008237225,
0.0073782932,
0.0249116682,
-0.0186070614,
0.0042182487,
0.0267298743,
0.031339407,
0.0074917218,
-0.0723853856,
-0.0568568707,
-0.0037598372,
-0.0346379764,
-0.007866675,
-0.0021103069,
0.0020902075,
0.073056668,
-0.00807779,
0.0482099615,
0.0470730327,
0.0326923318,
0.0141071826,
-0.0243938286,
0.0629922897,
-0.0513735861,
0.0124359522,
-0.0101772351,
0.031879358,
0.0294551216,
-0.0484487973,
0.0060676914,
0.0165954735,
0.0304156262,
0.0126272039,
0.0000017548,
-0.0421814285,
-0.035417676,
0.0038682665,
-0.0713826939,
-0.0316231772,
0.0409459099,
-0.0475988127,
0.0236125831,
0.0072347447,
-0.0019221891,
0.0004087694,
0.0299480725,
0.0392326973,
0.0295954067,
0.0389713868,
-0.0283933356,
-0.051771529,
-0.0101306401,
-0.0256836023,
0.0795139894,
-0.0909679681,
0.0188440923,
-0.0122532742,
-0.0029573084,
0.0292261746,
-0.0153953675,
0.0444189273,
0.0029077898,
0.0279760752,
-0.0076574469,
0.0096076056,
0.0265229046,
-0.0489867926,
-0.0259287078,
0.0841605365,
-0.0050274772,
0.0034450586,
0.0312139075,
-0.0467146337,
-0.0022732499,
-0.0738429874,
-0.0110666892,
0.0177883171,
0.0114379944,
-0.0150550734,
-0.018483147,
0.0475121774,
-0.0095969969,
0.0206601825,
-0.0167408995,
0.0038702558,
0.0073318891,
-0.0055486504,
0.0065623559,
0.0041187075,
0.0108734304,
-0.0422827974,
-0.0081954235,
0.0294277649,
-0.060703706,
0.0143240551,
-0.0842852667,
-0.0695925355,
0.0349114463,
0.0202463679,
0.0339492932,
0.0360788815,
-0.030215513,
0.0828288123,
-0.0065391539,
0.0203631073,
-0.0112124942,
0.050367035,
-0.0576756969,
-0.0293924622,
-0.071506381,
0.0188628361,
-0.0805147514,
0.0320909396,
-0.0235797446,
-0.0306700338,
-0.0369625129,
-0.0056340732,
0.0186374877,
-0.0395172834,
-0.0170853958,
0.0067546223,
-0.0429482348,
-0.0033669213,
0.0463453308,
0.0453710482,
-0.0438837744,
0.0600565039,
0.0140946368,
-0.0341467299,
-0.059990067,
0.0241275523,
0.0516999997,
-0.0343693122,
0.0282099284,
0.0676900819,
-0.0109734451,
-0.1014144868,
-0.0456919,
-0.06589064,
-0.05798674,
-0.037233565,
-0.0214173216,
-0.0135559086,
0.0542280599,
-0.02680723,
0.0047983313,
-0.0200219061,
0.0026994997,
-0.0028962556,
-0.0187964644,
0.0611494072,
0.0144268423,
-0.0238123201,
-0.0269565042,
0.0225551017,
-0.02023191,
0.0643063188,
-0.0125746727,
0.030451417,
0.0095902793,
0.0480467305,
0.0047820229,
0.0119621521,
0.0479306057,
0.0248883329,
0.0120614748,
0.0118342843,
0.0455217138,
0.0252746418,
0.0054768552,
0.0076863193,
-0.0745989904,
-0.0325543135,
0.0540886968,
0.0144220758,
-0.0044175964,
-0.0581089295,
0.0792950913,
0.0672482476,
-0.041413337,
-0.0505948514,
-0.0244633425,
0.0165889207,
-0.0274818055,
-0.0047840816,
0.0060934066,
-0.0303080939,
-0.052602578,
-0.005248202,
0.0116243595,
-0.0384824462,
-0.0232222341,
0.0093578584,
0.0311500523,
0.0461900569,
-0.0534063764,
0.0595385134,
0.0069377967,
-0.0219797138,
-0.036627885,
-0.0360333063,
0.0226666313,
0.0050386768,
-0.0061878343,
-0.0287875067,
-0.0332236663,
-0.0439486615,
0.0368609056,
0.0309361629,
0.0003112286,
-0.0038810524,
0.0955421999,
-0.0457119942,
-0.0344633199,
-0.0420175083,
0.0188237708,
0.0118662594,
-0.0049329465,
0.0255721509,
0.0225209799,
-0.0484199598,
0.0394577533,
0.0322237983,
0.0330982171,
-0.0313939229,
0.0335215814,
0.0317441672,
0.0288839415,
0.0359168425,
-0.0046375245,
-0.0029560919,
0.0074421656,
-0.0278241672,
-0.0229597166,
-0.0106901908,
-0.019252615,
-0.0767915919,
0.0158487819,
-0.0128507558,
-0.0474599265,
-0.0009026523,
-0.0333580263,
-0.0388059318,
-0.0163550582,
-0.0213328041,
0.0080337077,
-0.012026256,
-0.0211810004,
0.0158206653,
0.0314988121,
0.0000712444,
0.0310089551,
0.0411090963,
-0.0076969494,
0.0380943976,
-0.0046271412,
0.0514102727,
-0.0054087169,
-0.0008380815,
-0.0515816845,
-0.0334717557,
-0.0152299013,
0.0032872432,
0.0409724526,
-0.0515389591,
-0.0050508315,
-0.0673479363,
0.0008919489,
-0.0125974631,
-0.0261613969,
0.0102179199,
0.0175493322,
0.0255546886,
-0.0362674557,
0.0128040463,
0.0349806808,
-0.0198725071,
0.0082550328,
0.0209067296,
0.0222155377,
-0.0404324085,
-0.0134888068,
0.0347420685,
-0.005698564,
0.0258437321,
-0.0064290394,
-0.0021251049,
-0.0291731581,
0.0320424102,
-0.0101293856,
0.0053231069,
0.0085725887,
-0.0252326131,
0.0324365124,
-0.0055261557,
-0.032469552,
0.0678691939,
-0.012079468,
-0.0105099063,
-0.0121243196,
-0.0271759853,
-0.0773672462,
0.0247616582,
0.0135618476,
-0.0128412675,
-0.0379915237,
0.0167893935,
-0.0050448407,
0.0746109113,
0.0313903056,
0.0368731953,
-0.0493725799,
-0.0453801751,
-0.0127383089,
-0.0816742629,
-0.0726727322,
0.0203844979,
-0.010799191,
-0.0035986388,
0.0054428256,
0.0004234288,
0.0607063062,
-0.0316436365,
-0.0548100583,
-0.0383335501,
-0.0398132205,
-0.0088135637,
0.0620215312,
-0.0212278664,
0.0297112782,
0.0562794097,
-0.0266862139,
-0.0395598002,
-0.0384700559,
0.0016707736,
0.0342204273,
0.0414133221,
0.0088776033,
0.0302031338,
-0.0243098196,
-0.0213921014,
-0.0295815449,
-0.1186328828,
-0.0455486923,
0.0032953902,
-0.05277922,
0.0089682573,
-0.0454782806,
-0.0070091365,
0.0363859348,
0.062228024,
-0.0070125069,
-0.0110573871,
-0.036151696,
0.0331384838,
0.0468895696,
-0.0398101434,
-0.0611394644,
-0.0050594155,
0.0186462943,
0.0429773852,
0.0271623749,
0.0131768277,
-0.0050533027,
-0.0072703967,
-0.0035689354,
0.018173255,
-0.0079745743,
0.0266501438,
0.0772539303,
-0.0230955612,
0.0058795293,
0.0876244903,
0.0014054478,
-0.0231622066,
-0.0060825069,
0.0228010807,
0.004968463,
0.0184313357,
-0.014203012,
-0.0978881866,
-0.1243887395,
-0.0027765383,
-0.0119911935,
-0.0039110091,
0.0038207264,
-0.0114384349,
-0.0882716104,
0.0070837568,
-0.024640223,
-0.0687514096,
-0.0026940114,
0.0215055086,
0.0267546866,
-0.0039876816,
0.0136407008,
-0.0395957641,
0.0272081513,
-0.033918757,
-0.0189622082,
0.0388474651,
-0.0149246156,
0.0513575748,
-0.022825785,
0.0485091507,
0.0301875602,
0.0331405886,
0.0280939043,
-0.0047212648,
0.0015726677,
-0.0230128504,
0.0038542256,
-0.0082684355,
0.0631872937,
-0.0608753115,
-0.0225606896,
0.0455832593,
0.0059582009,
-0.0426571295,
-0.0161836296,
0.010046537,
0.0225820504,
0.008834362,
0.0220405702,
-0.0138437143,
0.010526997,
0.0610024035,
0.080791913,
0.0270162299,
-0.026691759,
-0.0144236367,
0.0052408664,
-0.0439259633,
-0.0809753463,
-0.0266280677,
-0.0008352775,
-0.0108655961,
-0.0411891714,
-0.017127201,
-0.0625463799,
0.0344283618,
0.0254091602,
-0.0149482889,
0.0218908545,
-0.0284537524,
0.0203351285,
-0.0047777165,
0.0190766323,
-0.0549525507,
0.0619201623,
-0.0250051729,
-0.0021270034,
0.0613237955,
-0.0399472937,
-0.0244562123,
0.0664737299,
-0.0771654248,
-0.0119213918,
-0.0228344295,
0.038242843,
0.0073782778,
0.037175525,
-0.0551087447,
0.0286936071,
0.0413904563,
0.0255055148,
-0.0248889159,
0.0457101427,
0.0728474632,
-0.0124619892,
-0.0084932335,
0.0367974304,
-0.0588194504,
0.0497684851,
0.0477339961,
-0.0083795879,
-0.0709648356,
-0.0394066423,
0.0438616052,
-0.0087595126,
0.0575627759,
0.0034121876,
-0.012058028,
0.019780485,
0.0402949415,
0.017865127,
-0.0115594808,
-0.061014913,
0.0074687717,
0.0285361987,
-0.0260697082,
-0.0028943124,
0.0169039387,
-0.0209990945,
0.0240041297,
0.0058597666,
-0.0004904742,
0.0059933653,
0.0152880009,
-0.0007134149,
-0.0094359405,
-0.0222945008,
0.0395126641,
-0.0136012156,
0.0076174834,
-0.0030197629,
0.0627512038,
0.0342341587,
-0.016100036,
-0.0089726215,
0.0425551273,
-0.037482705,
-0.0042309971,
0.0086284457,
-0.0090154279,
0.0281934831,
0.0219382104,
0.0211131256,
0.0113616521,
0.0068161255,
0.0145501373,
0.0701242387,
-0.0500521548,
-0.0303461701,
0.0359693281,
0.0014348371,
0.0150723513,
-0.0050740554,
0.0509796441,
-0.0209992379,
0.0628562868,
0.016486153,
0.0544307418,
-0.0626522005,
0.0015858104,
0.0466709733,
0.0183473919,
-0.0022595404,
-0.0028945482,
-0.0092621474,
-0.0308353826,
0.015466759,
-0.0413624421,
-0.0273168758,
0.020405164,
0.0657145008,
0.0217123739,
0.0075676818,
-0.0456082486,
0.0171389859,
-0.0159352794,
0.0277162269,
-0.0067697698,
-0.0279665664,
-5.550352615e-33,
-0.0436546728,
0.0277640484,
0.013245374,
-0.0580525436,
-0.0010932985,
0.0156693533,
-0.038659662,
-0.0248650666,
-0.0352133587,
0.0160959829,
0.020002367,
0.0417100862,
0.0281773545,
-0.0011400314,
0.0211761743,
-0.0516984835,
0.0421365537,
-0.0225774404,
0.0235857517,
0.0049647312,
0.0063231671,
0.0361595638,
0.0609784387,
-0.0556569099,
-0.0284905825,
0.038804926,
-0.0431404859,
0.007772278,
0.0168675855,
0.0500961393,
0.0036125577,
0.0051757377,
0.0166543536,
-0.0524822809,
-0.0094874548,
0.027399106,
-0.0779486299,
-0.0027226126,
0.0069903629,
0.0121432468,
-0.0402829461,
-0.0327762999,
-0.001185788,
-0.0171665493,
0.040451441,
-0.0100479638,
0.0076382011,
-0.0038172316,
0.0013523576,
-0.0198117737,
-0.0665373281,
0.0027148752,
0.0002615862,
-0.049792055,
-0.0079908231,
0.0758919492,
0.0253532026,
0.0230625607,
-0.0444243476,
0.0089404667,
-0.0689797848,
0.0079071959,
-0.0153351212,
0.0243325569,
-0.0309107937,
0.0498848855,
0.0189818479,
-0.0473671928,
0.0013389259,
-0.0226744078,
0.0017764767,
0.0318747871,
0.0227954723,
0.0796189532,
0.0389320441,
0.0122651681,
-0.0498066358,
-0.0198957734,
-0.0034475795,
0.0177452248,
0.0086141508,
0.0372345373,
-0.0401811488,
0.0300029349,
0.0024398225,
-0.0247071851,
-0.0446351506,
-0.0108025791,
0.0709339976,
0.0594457909,
-0.0304847844,
0.0296413675,
0.0771032572,
-0.0343470387,
0.0179586746,
0.0265260246,
0.0003313111,
0.0211392026,
-0.007831024,
0.0059926375,
-0.0719124079,
-0.0449971557,
0.0683120117,
0.0454779789,
0.0381914154,
0.0094427848,
0.0727667361,
-0.0069895145,
-0.0401492231,
-0.0246660262,
-0.0047859242,
0.0000916117,
-0.057074856,
-0.012299207,
0.0199456848,
0.0450191461,
-0.0427955911,
0.0704317018,
-0.0028886683,
-0.054707218,
-0.0064547216,
-0.0255722534,
0.0269093476,
0.0131230317,
-0.023970006,
-0.0181918517,
-0.008878666,
-0.0499979705,
0.0217287261,
-0.0301476661,
0.0032413609,
0.0133296484,
2.612e-7,
0.0136141488,
-0.0281713493,
-0.0143917501,
0.0417818092,
-0.0009485262,
0.0908433124,
0.0174442381,
0.0478505418,
-0.0262827482,
-0.0392771736,
0.0373774469,
0.0095396368,
0.0283253379,
-0.0239578597,
-0.1054909825,
0.0176401846,
0.008927308,
-0.0156899914,
-0.0536026992,
0.0223263409,
0.079413332,
0.1229948178,
0.0457307436,
-0.0102928774,
0.019809138,
-0.0411607623,
0.0370693058,
0.0229304302,
0.0200028382,
-0.0182225406,
-0.0160470195,
-0.0219125692,
-0.0210678335,
0.049331408,
-0.0036465724,
-0.0096229026,
-0.0295606721,
0.0420934334,
-0.0550737977,
-0.0397791415,
-0.0252988245,
0.0190817267,
-0.0041342042,
0.0009270986,
0.0866140872,
-0.0468656756,
0.0039526336,
0.0145016471,
0.0002136569,
0.0157370493,
-0.0030642617,
0.0260293037,
0.0004290014,
-0.0181383211,
0.0429087766,
-0.0006884716,
-0.0280878413,
-0.0938489139,
-0.0107853096,
-0.0075014909,
-0.0228328146,
-0.0017297956,
-0.0307103042,
0.0104957772,
0.0445905365,
-0.0904836729,
-0.046270512,
1.860122809e-34,
-0.0069574076,
-0.0336982086,
0.039851591,
0.0355584584,
0.007324059,
0.0124934623,
-0.0640960932,
-0.0122330179,
0.0263918992,
-0.0365311094,
-0.019699553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03559v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03559v2 | An Anchor Learning Approach for Citation Field Learning | 2023-09-07T08:42:40 | 2023-12-14T12:58:11 | Zilin Yuan, Borun Chen, Yimeng Dai, Yinghui Li, Hai-Tao Zheng, Rui Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Citation field learning is to segment a citation string into fields of
interest such as author, title, and venue. Extracting such fields from
citations is crucial for citation indexing, researcher profile analysis, etc.
User-generated resources like academic homepages and Curriculum Vitae, provide
rich citation field information. However, extracting fields from these
resources is challenging due to inconsistent citation styles, incomplete
sentence syntax, and insufficient training data. To address these challenges,
we propose a novel algorithm, CIFAL (citation field learning by anchor
learning), to boost the citation field learning performance. CIFAL leverages
the anchor learning, which is model-agnostic for any Pre-trained Language
Model, to help capture citation patterns from the data of different citation
styles. The experiments demonstrate that CIFAL outperforms state-of-the-art
methods in citation field learning, achieving a 2.68% improvement in
field-level F1-scores. Extensive analysis of the results further confirms the
effectiveness of CIFAL quantitatively and qualitatively. | [
0.0237527024,
0.0470992737,
0.0139853554,
-0.0117363567,
0.0010357819,
-0.0116068572,
0.0314331315,
0.0081619192,
0.0134598315,
-0.0759812742,
-0.0199840479,
0.0243417807,
-0.0287165586,
0.0172063261,
0.0088975122,
0.0039289757,
0.0322466157,
0.0362869427,
0.0568711348,
0.0234247185,
0.0029779889,
0.0252414048,
0.0073057055,
0.0226176884,
0.0308074988,
-0.0440223999,
0.0014260412,
-0.0312264543,
0.0463331379,
-0.002241225,
0.0656300038,
0.0468851253,
-0.0110174417,
0.0327817053,
0.0000016246,
-0.0608329587,
-0.0247032326,
0.0200557038,
0.0136666726,
0.02710112,
0.0683398992,
0.0136758974,
0.0239354596,
0.0032713353,
-0.0180326365,
-0.0335104167,
0.0064326739,
0.0479571894,
0.0200765654,
0.041609209,
-0.0082332334,
-0.0710573941,
0.0265938565,
0.0141012743,
-0.0142982611,
-0.0191509612,
0.0456301831,
0.0005976305,
-0.0267905928,
0.0600909293,
0.0311010461,
-0.0118790008,
-0.0405300781,
-0.0041081537,
0.0591288731,
0.0262905806,
-0.0573047809,
0.0325829759,
0.0257783476,
0.0639076903,
-0.0372966006,
-0.0388140269,
0.0340652838,
0.0009331738,
0.0021344316,
0.0671218932,
-0.0272207428,
-0.0121714566,
-0.0326081999,
-0.0362410508,
0.0327836238,
0.0135954116,
0.0307740644,
0.0241870154,
-0.0424715728,
0.0504315458,
-0.0027536652,
-0.0342156738,
0.0387412831,
0.0149663649,
0.0362908766,
0.0093322238,
0.0045333286,
0.0053119827,
-0.0093202824,
-0.0050371685,
-0.0115851583,
-0.017449541,
0.0356120244,
0.0090056881,
-0.006128476,
-0.0332372524,
-0.0204671882,
0.0342957117,
-0.0068030446,
-0.0426178202,
-0.0379604027,
-0.0162901971,
0.0288774129,
-0.0054628951,
-0.0693144649,
-0.0150879407,
0.0019738781,
0.0131240692,
-0.027211491,
0.0003801553,
-0.0107256444,
0.004125691,
-0.0307722595,
0.0202330779,
-0.0312515385,
-0.002003273,
-0.0042181253,
0.0276897959,
-0.0035388528,
0.0503114052,
-0.0114750993,
0.0494470112,
-0.0239879899,
-0.00892324,
0.0222867075,
-0.0020690109,
0.0558639169,
-0.0542207398,
0.0365163945,
-0.0074919341,
0.0227097254,
-0.0309484117,
-0.0461915471,
-0.0287811179,
0.0480266362,
-0.0657313988,
0.0169083755,
-0.0617514551,
0.0438436121,
0.0238583144,
-0.0146267107,
-0.0770759583,
0.001503887,
0.0356733873,
-0.0401686467,
0.042878937,
-0.0573649965,
-0.0310887713,
0.021152636,
-0.0019450092,
0.0433604904,
0.0221549906,
-0.0020745783,
0.0228654146,
0.0505866557,
0.0225578342,
0.0093742218,
0.0015861804,
0.0620589554,
0.0376657024,
0.0636846051,
-0.0097925374,
0.0065267961,
0.0160913002,
0.0138455741,
-0.0050383643,
-0.0148356967,
0.0097411983,
0.0083284583,
0.0181840081,
-0.005871518,
0.0365065672,
0.0675407499,
0.0473658331,
0.0346118435,
-0.0307960175,
0.0103851454,
-0.0388741195,
-0.0033915464,
0.0290622581,
-0.0078676101,
0.0236089937,
-0.0315927118,
0.0002196499,
0.0031010222,
-0.020970419,
-0.0291789081,
0.0153326914,
0.062989749,
-0.0038972436,
-0.0252857227,
0.0511770323,
0.0389259867,
-0.0435234606,
0.024222631,
0.0528712496,
-0.0030518644,
0.005117103,
0.0098941242,
-0.0498606376,
-0.0195418615,
-0.0601611808,
0.0052961307,
-0.0093887914,
0.0101772808,
-0.0202989448,
0.0265381765,
-0.0206870139,
-0.0257130992,
0.0226027519,
0.0166115053,
-0.007113514,
0.0238411538,
0.0289268605,
-0.0030293043,
-0.0730641484,
-0.0477629267,
0.0375449322,
-0.031910345,
-0.0122940419,
-0.0267359689,
0.0022906873,
0.0202367585,
0.0457383804,
-0.0221129414,
-0.0117303496,
0.0624597929,
-0.0313247852,
0.0453334488,
0.021859996,
-0.0081211273,
0.0119759524,
0.0483104773,
-0.0211807154,
-0.0113348896,
0.0068726111,
-0.0559862442,
-0.0154593289,
0.0420700349,
0.0373756364,
0.0040029236,
-0.0086598061,
0.0048470758,
-0.0305413976,
0.0165742654,
-0.0425305702,
0.065740183,
0.0110049099,
0.056013409,
0.0184270777,
-0.0069085257,
0.0349070616,
-0.0138948038,
-0.0299337357,
-0.0527472347,
-0.0220495611,
-0.0028883989,
0.0433833823,
-0.017949203,
-0.0671248734,
-0.0124833258,
-0.044794932,
0.0090147853,
0.0080278199,
0.0137266871,
-0.0182968713,
-0.003388661,
-0.0075671203,
0.0091742352,
-0.0022456865,
-0.0762996301,
-0.0557462461,
-0.0267174467,
0.0658626184,
0.0134574622,
0.0083156796,
-0.0643841326,
-0.0213654656,
-0.0451735109,
0.0535100475,
0.0228890348,
0.0093877744,
-0.0495998859,
0.0126443142,
0.010429712,
0.0078169592,
-0.0202494431,
0.0345513858,
-0.0045582955,
0.0003994462,
0.0202983003,
0.0660183281,
-0.0148976054,
0.0662184879,
0.0267657526,
0.0327784941,
-0.0490872785,
-0.008819432,
-0.0071244249,
0.0274050124,
-0.0358223915,
-0.0062213168,
0.0279501174,
0.0168996565,
-0.0190652162,
-0.0234824419,
-0.0122926114,
0.0040799268,
0.0178335775,
0.0130026089,
-0.0440483168,
0.018817205,
-0.0039481935,
0.0501008593,
0.0191498194,
0.0191931836,
0.0051568523,
-0.0389209725,
0.0055618975,
-0.0282355305,
0.0127465613,
-0.0411660559,
0.0260745212,
0.018370891,
-0.0186962355,
0.0367452875,
-0.0249878,
-0.0217186231,
0.0116815474,
0.0168858431,
-0.0428278744,
-0.0268728882,
0.0283721313,
-0.0211537629,
-0.0283733178,
-0.0000639569,
-0.0124456203,
-0.0417394377,
-0.048141554,
0.0370445289,
-0.0109406719,
-0.0217649434,
-0.0383313037,
-0.0092466939,
0.0217917692,
0.0207771678,
-0.0281096045,
-0.0255644135,
-0.0172005687,
0.0563886166,
0.0694201812,
-0.0275294315,
-0.0163825359,
-0.0004229175,
-0.0699741244,
0.022735361,
0.0197876915,
0.0340763219,
-0.0376116857,
-0.0415603295,
0.0081892721,
-0.1079584435,
-0.0238398351,
-0.0061990283,
0.0127180349,
-0.0087803612,
-0.0067149154,
0.1261122227,
0.0391972847,
-0.0497954749,
-0.0405138172,
-0.0189960804,
0.0304487236,
0.0350054651,
0.0396485738,
-0.1113095433,
0.0053522917,
-0.0290314332,
0.0144210057,
0.0154966889,
-0.0390742868,
0.0137119032,
-0.1149197519,
0.0283341669,
-0.0127554461,
0.0076715224,
-0.0362823233,
-0.0703554302,
0.0155671807,
-0.0379124805,
-0.0391691104,
0.0102013536,
-0.0453180596,
0.0339673795,
0.0554920435,
-0.0160390288,
-0.0670435727,
-0.0133696403,
-0.0712283999,
0.0152826933,
-0.016122587,
0.0664899126,
-0.033605732,
-0.0197548065,
-0.0063910517,
-0.0453358106,
-0.0419010185,
-0.0102360919,
0.0490618385,
-0.0232936684,
0.0161669385,
0.0196787491,
0.0333995931,
-0.0189576652,
-0.0185883567,
0.03738131,
0.0604986958,
-0.0085496539,
0.0502682216,
-0.0471887849,
0.006298441,
-0.0077917287,
0.0399293266,
0.024997564,
-0.0385178812,
-0.0425743721,
0.0028788436,
0.0307063349,
-0.0535295159,
-0.0525214002,
-0.0009527587,
-0.0389556326,
0.0239868909,
-0.03450647,
-0.0508161634,
-0.0029495165,
0.013912674,
-0.0000748864,
0.0578899086,
0.040840853,
-0.0097174114,
-0.0975433066,
0.0226096213,
-0.0417301953,
0.0165450051,
0.028696727,
-0.0113328947,
0.0416459516,
-0.0269637965,
-0.0489268154,
-0.0107441228,
0.0720264837,
-0.0196425319,
0.0204485469,
0.0063126842,
0.0087026628,
0.0442336313,
-0.0331743173,
-0.0034868966,
0.0035784659,
0.0688252375,
-0.007845724,
-0.0234410539,
0.0384560935,
-0.0522001199,
-0.0236382522,
-0.0289116874,
-0.0430617891,
0.0075278529,
-0.0176617801,
0.0098499218,
-0.063923344,
-0.0138645023,
0.0052606524,
0.0232943352,
0.0932900459,
-0.0116117215,
0.0412719175,
-0.0266446043,
-0.0418253429,
0.0261702202,
-0.036602255,
0.0131165516,
0.0109495856,
0.0134286415,
0.0018448738,
-0.0188815221,
0.0348524936,
-0.0154925613,
0.065311335,
-0.0269259773,
0.0075404099,
-0.0225490034,
0.0935286433,
-0.0365452394,
-0.0273700226,
-0.036898911,
-0.0479532331,
0.0192805547,
0.0401056781,
0.0096519478,
0.0021686968,
0.0103913685,
0.0257498678,
-0.0166760515,
0.0108403014,
-0.0703613535,
0.0588015653,
-0.0174733792,
-0.0367774479,
0.0696561262,
-0.0500775985,
0.0431492031,
-0.0171006899,
-0.0354167558,
-0.0090959957,
0.0326173268,
-0.0022070156,
-0.0048259501,
0.0506768078,
0.0037752297,
-0.0149138877,
-0.0118097141,
0.0270643644,
0.1116717309,
0.0153472936,
-0.0034185583,
-0.0270730183,
-0.0238124449,
-0.0141599504,
-0.0377808101,
0.0372380763,
0.0148837231,
-0.0056189634,
-0.0358432531,
0.0020935864,
0.0683069304,
-0.0312210191,
-0.0055624843,
-0.0058640684,
0.0168822743,
0.0284262504,
-0.0130051225,
-0.0154328505,
-0.0723086298,
0.0496202596,
0.0222490728,
-0.053722389,
-0.0191049986,
-5.713275764e-33,
-0.030677801,
-0.0259553064,
-0.0032067643,
0.0178773105,
-0.0491397418,
-0.0016391831,
-0.0149395419,
-0.0122552263,
-0.0618544556,
0.0130595546,
-0.0421530195,
-0.0228710845,
0.0159524474,
0.0487321615,
0.0264862478,
0.0385418534,
0.0213624816,
0.008536581,
0.0055676671,
0.0290989224,
0.0499122441,
0.0228115357,
0.0560167655,
-0.1749005616,
0.0447709709,
-0.0721541271,
-0.0274798181,
-0.0175785702,
0.0757674053,
0.0564768054,
0.0034501802,
0.0193773992,
0.0029239785,
-0.059343908,
0.03996858,
0.0072723734,
-0.1288424879,
-0.0032413565,
0.0241200235,
0.0114777163,
0.0161645524,
-0.0412570424,
0.0232200827,
-0.0093535213,
0.0174898431,
-0.0329827517,
0.098406285,
-0.0168674644,
-0.0318000689,
-0.0866433308,
-0.0768177137,
0.0134456623,
0.0089050159,
0.0810945109,
-0.0134905353,
0.0198557395,
-0.0023974511,
0.059648104,
-0.048766762,
-0.0112505145,
-0.0138996225,
0.0215310883,
-0.0155523187,
0.0187335256,
0.0036804997,
0.0339826941,
-0.0048283972,
-0.0163496695,
0.0122747775,
-0.0258688852,
0.0427371562,
0.0171252843,
0.0071968283,
0.1001779661,
-0.012617562,
-0.0284040105,
-0.0501890704,
0.0246388037,
0.0342792161,
0.0022072927,
0.008386381,
-0.0025758313,
0.0127411345,
-0.00178901,
-0.0331811421,
-0.0166579541,
-0.0021619836,
0.0013036384,
-0.0099231247,
-0.0077338996,
-0.0289376788,
0.0538459532,
0.0240320247,
-0.0608390793,
-0.0486648455,
0.0908084512,
-0.0311200507,
0.0511956774,
-0.0164217241,
-0.0294736549,
-0.0874698535,
-0.0491002239,
-0.0285377149,
0.0013618534,
0.0106434682,
0.0063381726,
0.0621686578,
-0.0238103308,
-0.0375567712,
-0.0302602537,
0.0140502425,
0.0094034886,
-0.0264784209,
0.0079457732,
-0.0064401422,
0.0514546633,
-0.0028302053,
0.0287388545,
0.0834764391,
0.0347411148,
0.0006413958,
-0.0234502386,
0.0341353193,
0.0426712483,
-0.0210331436,
-0.0506880395,
-0.0343447626,
0.0725976005,
-0.043606203,
-0.0653249994,
0.0128606791,
-0.0430350713,
2.339e-7,
0.0778403729,
0.0374156982,
-0.0264714118,
-0.0295715556,
-0.0204366073,
0.0072415685,
0.0450149588,
0.0367253087,
0.0136176553,
0.0671016574,
0.0348136947,
-0.0231241677,
-0.000297979,
-0.0031217621,
-0.0925584435,
-0.0350682996,
-0.0687960088,
-0.0499685258,
-0.0227425322,
0.0100083705,
-0.0376427509,
0.0343262404,
0.0073309424,
-0.0126729403,
0.0049279025,
-0.0301206782,
0.0522658005,
0.0062248292,
0.0002381095,
0.038876649,
-0.0277704205,
0.0426751524,
-0.0106138131,
-0.0188759789,
-0.0141874999,
0.0487290733,
0.0051941462,
0.045747254,
-0.0151050733,
-0.0036139006,
0.0266004466,
-0.0253264867,
0.0200246368,
-0.0509678945,
0.0196941197,
-0.0129586561,
-0.0065111709,
-0.0406301208,
-0.0814733282,
0.0120174941,
-0.0122226002,
0.0068636793,
0.003348957,
0.0331077799,
-0.0155683476,
-0.0207154863,
-0.0419687927,
-0.0543323755,
-0.0015838373,
0.0826473236,
0.0185252223,
-0.0287094489,
0.0379690714,
-0.0553010814,
0.0212518536,
-0.0408797599,
0.0251649413,
1.991550539e-34,
0.0354398526,
0.0059764166,
-0.0017172322,
0.0368162356,
0.0145250307,
0.0105764028,
-0.0131257204,
0.0361895934,
0.0381915346,
0.0034631658,
0.0357493348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06578v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06578v3 | Can Large Language Models Discern Evidence for Scientific Hypotheses? Case Studies in the Social Sciences | 2023-09-07T04:15:17 | 2024-03-26T03:33:45 | Sai Koneru, Jian Wu, Sarah Rajtmajer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Hypothesis formulation and testing are central to empirical research. A
strong hypothesis is a best guess based on existing evidence and informed by a
comprehensive view of relevant literature. However, with exponential increase
in the number of scientific articles published annually, manual aggregation and
synthesis of evidence related to a given hypothesis is a challenge. Our work
explores the ability of current large language models (LLMs) to discern
evidence in support or refute of specific hypotheses based on the text of
scientific abstracts. We share a novel dataset for the task of scientific
hypothesis evidencing using community-driven annotations of studies in the
social sciences. We compare the performance of LLMs to several state-of-the-art
benchmarks and highlight opportunities for future research in this area. The
dataset is available at
https://github.com/Sai90000/ScientificHypothesisEvidencing.git | [
0.0208920892,
0.0611669347,
0.0319374539,
0.0123851653,
-0.0256447047,
0.0073080189,
0.0289652999,
-0.0224130619,
0.0060528335,
-0.041486647,
-0.0181214884,
-0.0191193037,
0.0082565732,
0.0171977039,
0.0275147837,
-0.0140654454,
0.0152545208,
0.0055965944,
0.0644148812,
-0.0064220419,
0.0071928413,
0.0042147203,
-0.0076633887,
0.0389791206,
0.0570890307,
-0.0075579351,
0.0464831665,
-0.0297417697,
0.0517763495,
-0.0597513542,
-0.0071721612,
0.057411477,
0.0217199605,
0.0767372549,
0.0000013443,
-0.0410739481,
-0.006912394,
0.0266618412,
0.00106331,
0.0238570236,
0.0693586618,
-0.0148615502,
0.0134036066,
0.0294206049,
-0.0221582893,
-0.0278111286,
0.0539944805,
-0.0186829064,
0.0281759109,
0.0277261529,
0.0047924421,
-0.0381838977,
0.016584022,
-0.0370098911,
-0.0004822293,
0.0363845006,
0.0776073858,
0.0187930577,
0.0185232721,
0.0462418236,
0.0495653376,
0.028341461,
-0.0111230193,
-0.0457341447,
-0.0087032551,
0.0312998109,
-0.0633226633,
-0.0121031217,
0.0304765254,
0.0504859388,
0.019075362,
-0.0707141608,
0.0405924208,
-0.0159869995,
-0.0240299832,
0.0876799449,
-0.0280350987,
0.0315741487,
-0.0084838709,
0.0108828275,
0.0526524223,
0.0053751487,
0.0641400144,
0.0307749882,
0.0159302056,
0.0937818959,
0.0148370918,
-0.0113277584,
0.0073234998,
0.0126768677,
-0.0266452525,
-0.067362152,
0.012815143,
0.002981317,
0.0077638617,
0.0236390047,
0.013937776,
-0.037318904,
0.0605465174,
-0.0585397147,
-0.0043315897,
-0.0170179885,
0.0028301401,
0.0714483559,
-0.0001080267,
-0.0708529577,
-0.050384894,
-0.0182884522,
0.0048492802,
-0.0048671463,
-0.0503145158,
-0.0047394522,
0.0251760799,
-0.0168417692,
-0.0137212621,
0.0287191253,
-0.0260153487,
-0.0048197065,
-0.0232309848,
0.0060933125,
-0.035682667,
-0.0186811592,
-0.0188002512,
-0.0317599475,
-0.0087392367,
0.0551072024,
-0.0200414751,
0.0688003376,
-0.0026360264,
-0.0297969859,
-0.0018799625,
0.0224717427,
0.0317931846,
-0.0022408536,
0.0134720746,
-0.0022811729,
0.0467228331,
0.018210981,
0.0042694798,
-0.043207936,
-0.0258377083,
-0.0535265617,
0.0034132842,
-0.1006448567,
0.0114099123,
0.0172545929,
-0.0011609729,
-0.0489136316,
-0.0064395703,
0.0175574552,
-0.0134197716,
0.033938542,
-0.0882660598,
-0.0171310194,
0.0675913543,
-0.0007979239,
-0.0183109213,
0.0570111983,
0.0091118272,
-0.0086915763,
0.0340920761,
0.0115628466,
0.0104352646,
-0.0089730052,
0.0368006527,
0.0215916019,
0.024951471,
0.0067050047,
-0.0154617867,
0.0355577841,
-0.0346744396,
0.0682874098,
-0.0430351421,
-0.0497453958,
0.0147015946,
0.0709827393,
-0.0248086695,
0.0031892774,
0.0029156881,
-0.0036404473,
0.0315445811,
-0.0486118123,
-0.0039903736,
-0.0064665782,
-0.0226897299,
-0.0243083294,
0.0413018018,
-0.0075480137,
-0.0119873285,
-0.0255594216,
-0.0433329977,
0.0016305088,
-0.0508707389,
-0.0301622823,
0.0456193872,
-0.0168797523,
0.0406102464,
-0.0058609601,
0.0569761544,
-0.0219346378,
0.0397054479,
-0.0034091591,
0.0548138879,
-0.0089986557,
0.0246207118,
-0.0570100397,
-0.0138027398,
-0.0204843562,
0.0318030491,
0.0318593718,
0.0193745606,
-0.0511174425,
-0.0428889617,
0.0028366174,
-0.0124599217,
0.0096458783,
0.0334591232,
-0.0183647219,
0.0045498051,
-0.0222205594,
-0.0116572892,
-0.0264951829,
-0.0564162843,
0.0301327333,
-0.0491136014,
0.03674962,
-0.0117155323,
-0.0694440603,
0.0402977206,
-0.0026125989,
-0.0364482664,
0.0497169122,
0.0402810685,
-0.0325726159,
-0.0360415019,
0.0420064256,
0.0381525941,
-0.0356452987,
0.0647984818,
-0.0705531463,
-0.0259176269,
0.0087127713,
-0.030710971,
-0.0283022597,
0.0139147639,
-0.0119516999,
0.0129778869,
0.0012645556,
-0.0279447753,
-0.025673639,
-0.0106916716,
-0.0070409542,
0.0451295786,
-0.0226370618,
0.0382997952,
0.0037318056,
-0.0278195608,
0.0111649921,
-0.0338755772,
-0.0507639125,
0.0084018614,
0.0397044979,
-0.0361868627,
0.0518061519,
-0.0723102465,
-0.0190369468,
0.0128038758,
-0.0576285161,
-0.0004974764,
-0.0081137903,
0.0199146308,
0.0286105499,
-0.0456198417,
0.0342076011,
0.0163845234,
-0.0163986571,
0.0076465034,
0.0062747546,
0.0436171256,
0.0503066964,
0.00888485,
0.0269188602,
-0.07146319,
-0.0406474322,
-0.0507440716,
0.059700679,
0.0520573743,
-0.0202050246,
-0.054598432,
0.0217283871,
-0.0473625213,
0.0028477754,
-0.0314785913,
0.0143527118,
0.0215616189,
-0.000846277,
-0.0061606439,
0.0656636506,
0.0043680482,
-0.0258605517,
0.0786140487,
0.0437071808,
-0.040860191,
-0.0528807454,
-0.036764577,
0.0409188829,
-0.0188718922,
-0.0233587585,
0.0203796756,
0.0429863557,
-0.0298965108,
-0.0128732733,
-0.0147646833,
0.0137901939,
-0.0301346667,
0.0006300025,
-0.0060453997,
-0.0312982686,
0.0058380882,
0.0433964282,
-0.0223545544,
-0.0321793742,
0.0505167097,
-0.0303818174,
0.0103958305,
-0.0414811336,
0.003466215,
-0.0326072052,
-0.0155156255,
0.0068023475,
-0.0032111297,
0.0025768236,
0.0338996276,
0.0032643827,
0.0045002503,
0.0135058202,
-0.0125958743,
-0.0122807277,
-0.0543137304,
0.0425144397,
-0.0037023923,
-0.0039606802,
0.0118835242,
-0.0703791827,
-0.0577260703,
0.0196762234,
0.0290758144,
-0.0391975567,
-0.0585901812,
-0.0064459709,
0.0397993997,
0.0325914584,
0.011811791,
-0.0134136248,
-0.0016739435,
-0.0122478837,
0.0632948354,
-0.0128042521,
0.0492721871,
-0.0233596712,
0.002048223,
0.0883944333,
0.0140450485,
-0.0003272269,
-0.0596036017,
-0.0531729646,
-0.0074717645,
-0.0304477792,
-0.002088655,
-0.0330877602,
0.0212756991,
-0.0068678418,
0.0192396324,
0.0987730995,
0.0112514384,
-0.0647006929,
-0.010972403,
-0.0068958569,
0.0286856722,
0.0272828881,
-0.0228030551,
-0.1100104153,
0.0001138092,
-0.0315534063,
0.0024554543,
0.0082089668,
-0.0623176582,
0.0101492498,
-0.0842306316,
0.048745431,
0.0010023621,
-0.0184076615,
0.0066643725,
-0.1075711176,
0.0328065492,
-0.0474542044,
-0.0335924923,
-0.005876807,
0.0068785609,
0.003609682,
0.0288426839,
-0.0523681082,
-0.0803803951,
0.0292062853,
-0.0557486005,
0.0651795641,
0.0274101775,
0.032562051,
-0.0177030414,
-0.0206521489,
-0.0106979171,
0.0010262772,
-0.0606086291,
0.0045257732,
0.0411777645,
-0.0001531516,
0.0151491612,
0.0079544187,
0.0767159238,
-0.0751857832,
-0.0157351736,
0.0236773789,
0.1041004732,
0.002822072,
-0.0352839194,
-0.0473336913,
0.0202769954,
-0.0058563538,
0.0888785124,
-0.0102925356,
0.0095756883,
0.0003452721,
0.0037170693,
-0.0053941659,
0.0369208567,
-0.0367287248,
-0.0066808718,
0.0276183933,
-0.0088397339,
-0.0670162961,
-0.0020101783,
0.048721984,
0.0237316005,
-0.0058265906,
0.0176622365,
0.0532533973,
-0.0055504539,
-0.0390923284,
0.0418836959,
-0.0202754308,
0.0005919031,
-0.010874317,
-0.0086029498,
0.0684920549,
0.0385603197,
-0.032394506,
0.02059846,
-0.0540662929,
-0.0785724595,
-0.016224578,
-0.0048120944,
0.0265459828,
0.0127882129,
-0.0068866089,
-0.0721650869,
0.0019551341,
0.0266321134,
0.0054193465,
-0.0272673517,
-0.0019821317,
-0.0086745266,
0.0137748178,
-0.0030166463,
-0.0254187435,
0.0351540223,
0.022892585,
0.008901001,
-0.0670459121,
-0.0213763565,
0.0218954626,
0.0295031052,
0.0534611978,
-0.0329131335,
-0.0093866559,
-0.0184554122,
-0.0350257643,
-0.0249680299,
-0.0215617437,
-0.0198181011,
0.0385484286,
0.020994341,
-0.0402778052,
-0.0215483066,
0.0465654358,
-0.0330146588,
0.041009102,
-0.0483624749,
0.0545019731,
0.0235768445,
0.0297802426,
0.0309485476,
-0.0318539552,
-0.0155701758,
-0.0419075638,
-0.0613806844,
0.0300631244,
0.0097441096,
-0.0093204472,
0.0308644027,
-0.0184497517,
0.0104190242,
-0.0031032066,
-0.0974517092,
-0.0287672225,
-0.0421335585,
0.0250490885,
-0.0091114612,
0.0226207227,
0.0484550558,
-0.0443736129,
-0.0385362729,
-0.0561033264,
0.0268293507,
0.0010742095,
-0.0049629239,
0.066397503,
0.0178252999,
-0.0632947162,
0.0131112924,
0.0612584539,
0.0149948066,
0.0375782959,
0.0260076243,
-0.0402727686,
-0.0036804336,
-0.0405606478,
-0.0568398274,
0.0213255361,
-0.0323730484,
-0.006976231,
-0.0527293123,
-0.0268767271,
0.0202238206,
0.0368437655,
0.0005271479,
0.0132524427,
-0.0431351066,
0.0376775227,
-0.0171569232,
0.009720359,
-0.0240552723,
0.0332019925,
-0.0479070507,
-0.0193589292,
-0.0331370793,
-5.250322008e-33,
0.0114864632,
-0.0222576465,
-0.0165116712,
-0.0030966736,
0.0465172566,
0.0177429579,
-0.0494808406,
0.0066886032,
-0.0237975139,
0.0728937536,
0.025853008,
0.0569766536,
-0.0083492193,
0.003137768,
0.0267587081,
0.0285346564,
0.0315728635,
-0.0005260523,
-0.028331358,
0.0277886931,
0.0435109213,
-0.0456422977,
0.0427391045,
-0.0538081452,
0.0503309667,
-0.0073910174,
0.0154409921,
0.0476797968,
-0.0299638826,
0.0385913886,
-0.0465648212,
0.0183180459,
0.0076470049,
-0.0399663113,
0.0086804386,
-0.002471972,
-0.048020456,
0.004499807,
0.0162231941,
-0.0581792183,
-0.0397631973,
0.0003572836,
0.0383523963,
0.019143628,
-0.0289967302,
0.0064542172,
0.0317683071,
-0.0459765606,
0.0138068711,
-0.0676293001,
-0.0558849759,
0.0744288713,
-0.0044313828,
0.0325434096,
-0.025364073,
0.0095417146,
0.0004160289,
0.0818128511,
-0.0216532033,
0.048713848,
0.0107083768,
0.0126994075,
0.0121084433,
-0.0221392941,
0.0163767189,
0.0853547826,
-0.0162024945,
0.0270052459,
0.0011019327,
0.0178522374,
-0.0024484203,
0.0193792842,
0.0538019203,
0.0923310965,
0.0408571623,
0.0481952056,
-0.0892647952,
0.0370640457,
0.0167401992,
0.0093836701,
0.0532303825,
0.0274045095,
0.0181768499,
0.0021414473,
-0.0358741842,
-0.0239427332,
0.003184357,
0.0082326401,
-0.0394575819,
-0.0207759216,
-0.0324731618,
0.0515991673,
0.0294733569,
-0.0336407311,
-0.0398891345,
0.0599342324,
-0.0054348214,
0.0125577608,
0.0296742413,
0.0399096087,
-0.1132848561,
0.0026846195,
-0.0043292614,
0.0432595164,
0.014028959,
-0.0145588964,
0.028531475,
-0.011634876,
-0.0453370474,
-0.0041621542,
-0.0281309634,
-0.0227301624,
-0.0066841287,
-0.0080755698,
0.0322178192,
0.031039441,
0.0338681117,
0.018343145,
0.0125934603,
0.0332616419,
0.0125058666,
0.0467644706,
-0.0210383851,
-0.0159506258,
0.0052001146,
-0.02561111,
-0.00338444,
0.0098719671,
0.015859535,
-0.03730876,
0.0220717136,
-0.0202837475,
2.164e-7,
0.0856756121,
0.0505262241,
0.0010697831,
-0.0321220458,
0.056152869,
-0.0029801514,
-0.0131137781,
-0.0097626336,
0.0395919904,
-0.0417057127,
-0.0161744952,
0.0049452945,
0.0319001675,
0.0401626714,
-0.0312218405,
-0.0330150835,
-0.0734799877,
-0.0294225384,
-0.0281710606,
-0.0369003937,
-0.0111960853,
0.081392549,
-0.0042537055,
0.0129671851,
-0.0232068729,
-0.0396316499,
0.0801810101,
-0.0347025469,
0.0136948954,
0.05440972,
0.0189336129,
-0.005644619,
0.0193616282,
-0.000162808,
-0.0141132763,
0.0214005057,
-0.015575042,
0.0290896669,
-0.0022656056,
0.0118846837,
0.0165663455,
-0.042445533,
0.0354392081,
-0.0346076451,
0.0369869806,
-0.0753075182,
-0.0508855022,
-0.0645334795,
-0.0361293927,
-0.0129248379,
0.0208377149,
-0.0139601594,
0.0167201534,
-0.0128797488,
-0.0364508666,
-0.0072806617,
-0.0289319139,
-0.0618818663,
-0.0173077807,
0.0483893417,
-0.0736227259,
-0.059420608,
0.0266361423,
-0.0338045843,
-0.0218474865,
-0.0589146428,
0.0568663627,
1.707546512e-34,
0.0605384968,
0.0029286663,
-0.0531401038,
0.0095717618,
0.0367794633,
0.0035926432,
-0.0322182737,
0.0053874026,
0.0407677367,
-0.0781177878,
0.0319756381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03470v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03470v1 | Machine Learning for Tangible Effects: Natural Language Processing for Uncovering the Illicit Massage Industry & Computer Vision for Tactile Sensing | 2023-09-07T04:04:01 | 2023-09-07T04:04:01 | Rui Ouyang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI | I explore two questions in this thesis: how can computer science be used to
fight human trafficking? And how can computer vision create a sense of touch?
I use natural language processing (NLP) to monitor the United States illicit
massage industry (IMI), a multi-billion dollar industry that offers not just
therapeutic massages but also commercial sexual services. Employees of this
industry are often immigrant women with few job opportunities, leaving them
vulnerable to fraud, coercion, and other facets of human trafficking.
Monitoring spatiotemporal trends helps prevent trafficking in the IMI. By
creating datasets with three publicly-accessible websites: Google Places,
Rubmaps, and AMPReviews, combined with NLP techniques such as bag-of-words and
Word2Vec, I show how to derive insights into the labor pressures and language
barriers that employees face, as well as the income, demographics, and societal
pressures affecting sex buyers. I include a call-to-action to other researchers
given these datasets. I also consider how to creating synthetic financial data,
which can aid with counter-trafficking in the banking sector. I use an
agent-based model to create both tabular and payee-recipient graph data.
I then consider the role of computer vision in making tactile sensors. I
report on a novel sensor, the Digger Finger, that adapts the Gelsight sensor to
finding objects in granular media. Changes include using a wedge shape to
facilitate digging, replacing the internal lighting LEDs with fluorescent
paint, and adding a vibrator motor to counteract jamming. Finally, I also show
how to use a webcam and a printed reference marker, or fiducial, to create a
low-cost six-axis force-torque sensor. This sensor is up to a hundred times
less expensive than commercial sensors, allowing for a wider range of
applications. For this and earlier chapters I release design files and code as
open source. | [
0.0225325432,
0.1005442664,
-0.0397442728,
-0.0074886167,
-0.0433469564,
0.0079210512,
0.0738361925,
0.0148751084,
0.0562044308,
-0.0205908474,
0.0328277387,
0.0051712818,
0.0462186858,
0.0638200715,
0.0333346315,
-0.0169144478,
-0.0359500237,
0.0503482893,
-0.060540311,
0.0386122949,
0.001833817,
0.011122101,
-0.0044929544,
0.0389256477,
-0.0464196876,
0.0031246231,
-0.0088430392,
-0.0144807966,
-0.0146350348,
-0.008717617,
-0.003391651,
0.0317008384,
0.0222944077,
0.0351484604,
0.0000022772,
-0.0338940844,
-0.0177130643,
0.0011194843,
0.0351894051,
-0.0159927458,
0.0795041844,
-0.0995335653,
0.0121563999,
0.0206707921,
-0.067236051,
0.0180842392,
0.0461553372,
0.0011131174,
-0.0079726754,
-0.0211468451,
-0.0371396653,
-0.0011316967,
-0.0239021499,
0.0211833026,
0.0068905298,
0.0145814288,
0.0116020571,
-0.0530721135,
0.053974621,
-0.037395779,
-0.0057936711,
0.0142466463,
-0.008961414,
-0.03672041,
0.0372716524,
0.053840261,
-0.0573629141,
-0.056883432,
-0.030890638,
-0.0070373616,
-0.0071250689,
0.02848107,
0.0394837745,
0.0207713079,
-0.0172078796,
-0.0160588287,
-0.0204691216,
0.0345966816,
-0.0317863934,
-0.0064682947,
-0.0629318878,
0.034806028,
0.0133443549,
0.0662892982,
0.0555185936,
-0.0151852025,
-0.0158528499,
-0.0012953981,
0.0131045366,
-0.0064228629,
0.0612913631,
0.0006911346,
0.0454499796,
-0.0071432535,
-0.0059574307,
-0.0289577432,
0.0119554223,
-0.016723739,
0.0178946424,
-0.1084672585,
0.0287620854,
0.0131876301,
-0.050168816,
0.0347825959,
0.0185404681,
-0.0025760159,
-0.0335678831,
0.0180671886,
-0.0121833598,
0.031096708,
-0.0170860104,
0.0164015852,
-0.0012759941,
-0.0450396799,
-0.0243948475,
0.0486359857,
-0.0403213203,
0.0257627554,
-0.0318874419,
-0.0189834274,
-0.0883856341,
0.0486272313,
0.0104649048,
0.0362817682,
-0.0261499118,
-0.0048655472,
-0.007677237,
0.0277492609,
-0.0071510463,
-0.0050895596,
0.0107521126,
0.0257356074,
0.0476664305,
0.0244719405,
0.0160364211,
0.0243821945,
0.0179111362,
0.015448615,
-0.0687306896,
-0.0087966872,
-0.0014035108,
0.0083602434,
0.0356001556,
-0.027035879,
-0.0051511354,
-0.0335765481,
-0.0261714999,
-0.0254786033,
-0.0064508659,
-0.0012903126,
-0.0620643757,
0.1036218181,
0.0050970637,
-0.0221378263,
0.0256837532,
-0.003348209,
-0.0098438086,
-0.0197088178,
0.0109089389,
0.1003496721,
0.0369707234,
-0.0467603356,
0.0284069553,
-0.0236049574,
-0.0628121346,
-0.0022171389,
0.0336771049,
0.0001190937,
0.0324744582,
0.0092581632,
-0.0310411397,
-0.0440256856,
-0.0177637748,
0.094190985,
0.0456978194,
0.1289209276,
-0.032062456,
0.0047111805,
0.0261517111,
0.011656451,
-0.0520421602,
-0.0564334169,
-0.0070973169,
-0.0284270532,
-0.0078652287,
-0.0311112218,
-0.0426460952,
-0.0023027372,
-0.0191847943,
-0.0649139583,
-0.021220874,
-0.0196535196,
0.0626211092,
-0.019829113,
0.0408957973,
0.003563914,
0.0047965152,
-0.0972496644,
0.0091580572,
0.016498832,
-0.0382233709,
-0.0463851392,
-0.00869912,
0.0753546581,
-0.0372373536,
-0.0108489487,
0.03586955,
-0.0224392135,
0.0006975452,
0.049539987,
-0.0296425167,
0.0175125785,
-0.0255968496,
0.0049863355,
-0.0132051753,
0.0477861948,
0.0187429395,
0.0148151638,
-0.0489267334,
0.0254270416,
0.0199944042,
0.051293768,
0.0097191632,
0.0203108955,
0.0351251327,
-0.0243653227,
0.00437757,
0.0234223083,
0.0054135751,
0.0198364481,
0.0379071534,
-0.0193848144,
0.0368887298,
-0.0399201028,
0.0275606252,
-0.0001644986,
0.0763802007,
0.1481516659,
0.0074415398,
-0.0390552655,
-0.0204325337,
0.0220694449,
-0.0142788524,
0.0150795951,
0.0688321814,
0.0265707895,
0.0377732851,
-0.0239088144,
-0.0107093574,
0.0064946292,
0.010144284,
-0.028784655,
0.0263521373,
-0.0170898475,
-0.0107842274,
-0.047245048,
-0.061215464,
0.0352335423,
0.0165712144,
-0.0009687531,
0.0047582928,
-0.03694373,
0.071981214,
0.0523463748,
0.0655252263,
-0.0064301938,
-0.0141226398,
-0.0537544675,
-0.0074997316,
0.0105243772,
-0.0422681198,
0.0105439797,
0.012798422,
-0.0193296429,
-0.0257641319,
0.0130873751,
-0.0530810282,
-0.0034497627,
-0.029251432,
0.0075686295,
-0.0076317932,
0.0068759308,
-0.0225673076,
-0.0049797338,
-0.0393037535,
0.0237580072,
0.0592202172,
-0.0058889906,
-0.0358734466,
-0.0791426674,
-0.004011116,
-0.0017744724,
0.0089308703,
-0.0173996724,
0.0156919453,
0.0132395485,
-0.040239118,
0.0262312703,
-0.0399281979,
0.0538597219,
0.0278742649,
0.0347223468,
0.0194228068,
-0.0238911863,
0.0101913493,
0.0690509081,
0.0075573321,
-0.0244410094,
0.0115645705,
0.0074374094,
0.0060370015,
0.0217222907,
0.0166331138,
0.0349228457,
-0.0047642947,
-0.022707345,
-0.0149040325,
-0.0211778544,
-0.0313472711,
0.044399593,
-0.0154839,
-0.0501999594,
-0.0121675711,
0.0136472136,
0.0011541552,
0.0038599358,
-0.0424872711,
0.0133741926,
0.0712630525,
-0.0015757006,
0.0259568226,
-0.011839835,
-0.0299094245,
0.0551043563,
0.0241714008,
0.0396687016,
-0.0364315361,
-0.0632365122,
-0.061417982,
-0.0078561902,
0.011851781,
-0.0532997772,
-0.0424544476,
-0.0719717592,
-0.0007508761,
-0.0016163936,
0.0188713521,
0.0070542158,
0.0111951977,
0.0327993631,
0.0379759297,
0.0576242991,
0.0486217886,
-0.0301073845,
-0.0496893972,
0.0095310276,
0.0148645369,
-0.0146241346,
-0.0388075039,
0.0451770648,
-0.0622742064,
0.0122241899,
-0.0356557779,
-0.0268369094,
-0.0728567615,
0.080945693,
0.013027953,
-0.0018031319,
0.006581259,
-0.0348214842,
-0.0600365698,
-0.0012918161,
0.0162587259,
0.0038159578,
0.0322598331,
-0.0401184,
0.0329081677,
0.0114544807,
-0.0613720082,
0.007976573,
0.0234883465,
-0.0610206984,
0.044409249,
-0.030423468,
0.0132525796,
-0.0479453281,
-0.0291361865,
0.0109030223,
-0.0524210446,
0.0747627094,
-0.0367749669,
-0.0005207047,
-0.0560069643,
-0.063107498,
-0.0203155037,
-0.019405527,
0.0145767638,
0.0007112893,
-0.0307864714,
-0.0045810393,
0.0244591981,
0.0153698307,
-0.0115090059,
-0.0167708062,
-0.0431109853,
-0.0263331328,
0.0838353783,
0.0824858993,
-0.0309076663,
0.0170742292,
-0.0108050155,
0.1036472321,
0.0125769153,
-0.0202118922,
0.0140720829,
0.0259795096,
-0.0077540544,
-0.0423651896,
0.050350599,
-0.0095615052,
0.0307869762,
0.0251040217,
0.0367012806,
-0.0247760769,
0.0184355527,
-0.0190452226,
-0.0497005284,
-0.0116161434,
-0.0376428701,
-0.0205283314,
-0.0424870141,
0.0120657282,
-0.0239068996,
0.0014384066,
0.0874058008,
-0.0889970139,
-0.0060917959,
-0.0432480164,
-0.0541031584,
-0.0536676683,
-0.0373528078,
0.0189325195,
0.0291200448,
0.0347347558,
-0.0332279392,
0.04179978,
0.0023109263,
-0.0504513085,
0.0193424728,
0.0197740234,
0.0153774461,
0.0674500018,
0.0202377737,
-0.0442918874,
-0.024674885,
0.0026003572,
0.0027139785,
-0.0249981899,
-0.0092258994,
0.0065115215,
0.0503739864,
0.0352124758,
-0.0147499386,
-0.0619613752,
-0.0124156196,
-0.0429887064,
0.0356404744,
-0.089430362,
-0.0443321802,
0.0114782928,
0.0027620844,
0.0070817005,
-0.0315708071,
-0.0011108458,
0.0032789984,
0.0087777711,
-0.048397541,
-0.0942657813,
-0.0122861993,
0.000897682,
-0.0024235295,
0.0711490065,
-0.010747307,
0.0573829003,
-0.0052374238,
-0.0056020427,
0.0076619573,
-0.0104426332,
-0.0320019685,
-0.0284313448,
-0.0165314693,
0.0045665451,
-0.0481635742,
0.0231419858,
-0.0045665074,
0.0037685074,
-0.0384942517,
0.0458802506,
0.0131340679,
0.0251729861,
-0.0357311331,
0.0058210874,
0.0016172419,
0.0188000426,
-0.030210061,
0.0449545011,
0.0231912378,
-0.0069837007,
0.0168148372,
-0.0032375359,
-0.0322226658,
0.0467863865,
-0.0206479598,
-0.0618519522,
0.0377238579,
0.0227863416,
-0.0021882337,
-0.0663671419,
0.0149200037,
-0.0004906451,
-0.0133337984,
0.0044375597,
0.0400286093,
-0.0018763152,
-0.0325577371,
-0.0229428951,
0.0090045324,
-0.0127682891,
0.0095858471,
0.0117852837,
-0.0423092991,
-0.0348775163,
0.0131119108,
-0.0573121309,
-0.023560077,
0.0111392699,
0.0925934464,
-0.0065781544,
-0.0055819228,
0.0349361375,
-0.0526699573,
-0.0196095891,
-0.0291703437,
-0.031835258,
-0.0061689429,
-0.017592201,
0.0093936967,
-0.0206897873,
-0.0195689388,
-0.0188318472,
-0.0068989908,
-0.0259880628,
-0.0108802551,
-0.021226557,
-0.0458330959,
-6.145171123e-33,
0.0417808145,
-0.0806514546,
0.0060273721,
0.0427783169,
-0.0194302704,
-0.0025045329,
-0.0081641749,
0.0042241355,
0.0374706686,
-0.0298670959,
-0.0136945751,
-0.0183282513,
0.0088620568,
0.0046958732,
0.0292418152,
0.0244290698,
0.026174102,
0.0162441246,
0.0088621955,
-0.0121964421,
-0.0386480205,
0.0271290299,
0.0729089379,
-0.0568211339,
0.0764643699,
0.0186778624,
-0.0504685193,
-0.0316276997,
0.0238656215,
-0.0216308367,
-0.0544063747,
0.0317738652,
0.0001758434,
-0.0182616133,
0.0142154926,
0.0628435537,
-0.0524132773,
-0.0091976225,
-0.0227405373,
0.044825118,
0.0119144665,
-0.0151703572,
0.0203757174,
-0.0277868118,
0.0247618183,
0.0291102398,
0.0818896443,
-0.0542965755,
-0.0080064628,
-0.0021098668,
-0.0062760212,
-0.0076879011,
-0.0447296128,
-0.0133756129,
0.0306024197,
0.0475657843,
-0.0288262796,
0.0152202081,
-0.1057803556,
0.0082758721,
0.0081650335,
-0.0417609327,
0.0109734973,
-0.0350792259,
0.0484020896,
-0.0022233615,
0.010622425,
-0.0403878912,
0.01315575,
-0.0212580487,
0.0276791081,
0.077713728,
0.0049685957,
0.056380026,
0.0641945899,
-0.0143738547,
-0.0211669393,
-0.0187066589,
0.0136108296,
0.0279232934,
0.0306493491,
0.0121627664,
-0.0041958448,
-0.0069906297,
-0.0147247138,
-0.0369184054,
0.0071477196,
-0.0180450808,
-0.0033629532,
-0.0085633928,
-0.0013352404,
0.0404323153,
-0.0347073264,
-0.0450890288,
-0.0059512779,
-0.0824663714,
-0.0020082542,
0.0129372077,
0.0170472246,
-0.0637997761,
-0.0415539667,
0.0360759422,
-0.071967043,
-0.0094906827,
0.0769904181,
0.015103478,
-0.0353185907,
0.0066256896,
-0.003779131,
0.015272853,
-0.0047874283,
0.0294581559,
0.0474314988,
0.0005590342,
0.0338566005,
-0.0316680521,
-0.0029626826,
0.0065793577,
0.0434905887,
0.0666656122,
0.0261132754,
-0.0065206275,
-0.0366498493,
0.0226997659,
-0.0403561965,
-0.025587948,
-0.026866626,
0.0461143181,
0.0371993035,
-0.0515003912,
-0.0148954811,
-0.0600560158,
2.897e-7,
-0.0173032917,
0.0341609977,
0.0072637084,
0.0171973985,
-0.010933578,
0.0576602519,
0.0290566757,
0.0563821383,
-0.0303620677,
-0.0576401204,
0.0007082979,
0.0011468442,
0.0713690892,
0.012936743,
-0.0686292425,
0.0221735239,
0.0371830836,
-0.0350906998,
-0.0456672907,
0.0441651978,
-0.0283047501,
0.0521196052,
0.0871736333,
-0.0202324595,
0.0047615687,
-0.0140958205,
-0.0091027999,
-0.0711201131,
0.0328035541,
-0.0519881099,
0.0557114109,
0.0134493131,
-0.0409110598,
0.0175161902,
-0.0229010656,
-0.0154824648,
0.0081298416,
0.0044641723,
-0.0492600724,
0.0576925166,
0.0070679309,
-0.0816165507,
-0.0170982461,
-0.0345105194,
0.0598723516,
-0.001526158,
-0.0214804113,
0.0073300526,
-0.0012867294,
0.0157660581,
0.0588814691,
-0.0030868622,
-0.031698145,
-0.0000275622,
0.0308816768,
-0.0492528044,
0.0232390203,
0.0225951616,
0.0365250632,
0.0536450371,
0.030037459,
-0.0105293756,
0.0174407922,
0.0350672454,
0.0170948114,
-0.0414613113,
-0.0034280415,
2.503027646e-34,
0.0194620602,
-0.0001432406,
0.0213988069,
0.01861226,
0.0257613845,
0.0424626358,
0.0079732034,
-0.0262944605,
0.0510680191,
0.0211870056,
0.0199370608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03450v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03450v1 | XGen-7B Technical Report | 2023-09-07T02:20:03 | 2023-09-07T02:20:03 | Erik Nijkamp, Tian Xie, Hiroaki Hayashi, Bo Pang, Congying Xia, Chen Xing, Jesse Vig, Semih Yavuz, Philippe Laban, Ben Krause, Senthil Purushwalkam, Tong Niu, Wojciech Kryściński, Lidiya Murakhovs'ka, Prafulla Kumar Choubey, Alex Fabbri, Ye Liu, Rui Meng, Lifu Tu, Meghana Bhat, Chien-Sheng Wu, Silvio Savarese, Yingbo Zhou, Shafiq Joty, Caiming Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have become ubiquitous across various domains,
transforming the way we interact with information and conduct research.
However, most high-performing LLMs remain confined behind proprietary walls,
hindering scientific progress. Most open-source LLMs, on the other hand, are
limited in their ability to support longer sequence lengths, which is a key
requirement for many tasks that require inference over an input context. To
address this, we have trained XGen, a series of 7B parameter models on up to 8K
sequence length for up to 1.5T tokens. We have also finetuned the XGen models
on public-domain instructional data, creating their instruction-tuned
counterparts (XGen-Inst). We open-source our models for both research
advancements and commercial applications. Our evaluation on standard benchmarks
shows that XGen models achieve comparable or better results when compared with
state-of-the-art open-source LLMs. Our targeted evaluation on long sequence
modeling tasks shows the benefits of our 8K-sequence models over 2K-sequence
open-source LLMs. | [
0.0076620439,
0.0548386425,
0.0136492308,
0.0062542195,
-0.0445212722,
-0.0136381304,
0.0268182643,
-0.0098101897,
-0.011167679,
-0.0600235909,
-0.0202099178,
-0.0358899981,
0.0214133225,
0.0204130206,
0.0282374099,
-0.0471950248,
0.0416862406,
-0.0404126607,
0.011123104,
0.0160465017,
-0.0172380917,
0.0138927419,
-0.0099894302,
0.0669340417,
0.017884871,
-0.027954828,
-0.0140549345,
-0.025105793,
-0.0011170022,
-0.014165489,
0.0038567011,
0.0861816928,
0.0352095328,
0.0262983199,
0.0000019234,
-0.0310654417,
-0.000091029,
-0.0061060726,
-0.0311901383,
0.0771223977,
0.0241757575,
0.0096540786,
-0.0024686931,
0.0437353812,
-0.005994413,
-0.031343773,
0.0250059776,
0.0084165214,
0.0441373624,
0.0681285858,
0.0171757229,
-0.0340493284,
0.0320306607,
-0.0563809685,
-0.003452451,
-0.0108301248,
0.0510611869,
-0.0222818404,
0.0471893474,
0.035522677,
-0.0235123411,
0.0286873579,
0.0304445736,
0.0264658947,
-0.0315388143,
0.0513668247,
-0.0251180474,
-0.016916398,
-0.0085591935,
0.063438274,
-0.0285707433,
-0.0131495064,
0.0269912444,
-0.0067209206,
0.0172564946,
-0.0461601876,
-0.0424676836,
0.0470796637,
-0.0046604238,
0.0118412664,
0.0256781094,
-0.0133093316,
0.0246638041,
0.0042041605,
-0.0488523021,
0.0125513216,
0.0251338817,
-0.0192303248,
-0.03298546,
-0.0455552824,
-0.0395802893,
-0.053439185,
0.0025096261,
0.0240704082,
-0.0061313366,
0.0170400906,
-0.0572302267,
-0.0487967767,
0.0575066693,
-0.0298982058,
0.0420596004,
0.0615949072,
-0.0519188084,
0.0334664695,
-0.0227075536,
0.0524080768,
-0.0016214346,
0.0231906865,
-0.0128400363,
0.0179252625,
-0.0312145129,
0.0242800154,
-0.0137076527,
-0.0035143334,
-0.0695967302,
-0.0229114015,
-0.0536795855,
-0.0044872225,
0.0479333252,
0.0103077339,
0.0399276912,
0.0002095753,
-0.0097455783,
0.0183396935,
0.0111957937,
0.0298316088,
-0.0138477068,
-0.0172066726,
0.0202803891,
-0.0711681694,
-0.0242585931,
0.0206347685,
0.0081182439,
-0.0404904932,
0.0090586059,
0.057323046,
0.0132580213,
-0.0682047829,
-0.0393264852,
-0.0355871841,
-0.0361428969,
-0.0895914212,
-0.0097330911,
-0.0698871315,
0.0155445412,
0.0144461337,
-0.0088694179,
-0.0075447159,
0.02823334,
0.0122631267,
-0.0114656994,
0.0474940911,
0.0206324868,
-0.0084418347,
0.0018743828,
0.0139942374,
0.0247739088,
0.0483401529,
0.0238259211,
0.0175636932,
0.0379151627,
-0.0335627571,
0.0032259997,
0.0557321906,
0.0216765553,
-0.032845404,
0.0033024882,
-0.0015510897,
0.0440988764,
0.0660430714,
0.026489865,
0.0601582415,
-0.0153714856,
-0.0523342639,
0.0467154309,
0.0542032197,
0.0165993161,
0.0071752029,
0.0682088509,
0.0309491493,
0.0086851027,
-0.0075951447,
-0.0359010398,
0.0185211226,
0.0429088734,
0.0408935137,
0.0722539574,
0.0384229086,
-0.0268202033,
-0.0310007501,
-0.0543110631,
-0.035484992,
-0.0174075291,
-0.0017698779,
0.0660045817,
-0.034451142,
-0.067496337,
0.0727268085,
0.0416700244,
-0.0621123537,
-0.0148512758,
-0.0294858236,
0.0684905276,
0.0554530919,
0.0406532399,
-0.024019042,
-0.0379145294,
-0.0316576026,
0.0486562401,
0.0422000773,
0.0452653281,
0.0061855516,
0.0177004859,
-0.0739539862,
-0.0199357215,
0.0022903848,
0.0268859975,
0.0333635099,
0.0195371211,
0.0038868247,
0.0390814207,
-0.0177846737,
-0.0346877053,
0.0329118893,
-0.0781145319,
-0.0524543338,
-0.0195958391,
0.0051264917,
0.0395127758,
0.0274217203,
0.0016813846,
0.0241205618,
0.0705076307,
-0.0298496243,
0.0061197565,
-0.05101455,
-0.0900833905,
-0.0255119856,
0.0650195628,
-0.0087132407,
0.0062708086,
0.0208209138,
-0.0491369478,
-0.0467553847,
0.0465950146,
-0.0493293367,
0.0589171201,
-0.025440719,
0.0158566181,
0.0174860433,
0.048469916,
-0.0170542225,
0.0185470004,
-0.0169817787,
0.0326664969,
0.0194394607,
-0.0316636004,
-0.003981357,
-0.0538255312,
0.0079578804,
0.0059877154,
-0.0139580136,
-0.0207530092,
-0.0135366609,
0.0172557551,
-0.0449602976,
-0.0003673818,
-0.074421078,
0.0144720897,
-0.0403539874,
0.0434008762,
-0.0148973381,
0.01276806,
-0.013768211,
0.0041706101,
-0.0309106261,
-0.0329661034,
0.0027608881,
-0.0040256018,
0.0055560581,
0.0205879882,
-0.0552981123,
-0.042214673,
-0.0291567966,
-0.0318791308,
0.0379805714,
-0.0285342261,
-0.0275000688,
-0.0352721103,
0.0159498546,
-0.0180525426,
0.0309542678,
-0.0274814945,
-0.0356498174,
0.0116316956,
-0.0308827907,
0.0660237148,
0.0409386158,
0.0107926419,
-0.016551476,
0.0202023815,
-0.0296354983,
-0.0577446371,
-0.0000919283,
-0.033634346,
-0.0104496069,
-0.032467965,
-0.0115177846,
-0.0430788398,
0.085857138,
-0.0095124813,
0.0066997134,
-0.067872934,
-0.0233947914,
0.0053297621,
-0.0109434398,
0.0039361902,
-0.0060661193,
-0.0193152241,
-0.0138447797,
-0.0163932331,
-0.0171257872,
0.0550422743,
-0.0634305775,
-0.0026674382,
-0.0313415937,
-0.0031376467,
-0.0507956482,
0.0434251353,
0.0126852011,
-0.0098248916,
0.0411610678,
-0.0332813375,
-0.0109768705,
0.0367215611,
-0.0373683125,
-0.0389188752,
0.0210265759,
-0.0468139239,
-0.0099160625,
-0.0147603275,
-0.0111249182,
-0.0155002344,
-0.0099397535,
-0.0070131705,
0.0084356647,
0.0149620762,
-0.0418362021,
-0.0545859113,
0.023411287,
0.0163437147,
0.0665957779,
-0.0201600287,
0.0452171154,
-0.0286786277,
0.0449987352,
0.0468582846,
-0.0147323487,
0.0142569132,
-0.0434673503,
-0.0174210574,
0.0484734289,
0.0441254713,
-0.0011526498,
-0.0190540422,
-0.018948663,
0.0343398526,
-0.0562025756,
-0.0151643874,
0.051269576,
0.0357109532,
-0.0758487061,
-0.0159056261,
0.1239539534,
0.0167439133,
-0.0342639685,
0.0161485281,
0.002815472,
0.0336047709,
-0.0048764609,
-0.013200447,
-0.0871690884,
-0.0606114827,
0.00722076,
0.0116359638,
-0.0031488549,
-0.0122033935,
-0.0131170917,
-0.1025201976,
0.0043138429,
0.020039672,
-0.0525339097,
-0.0237648729,
-0.0528648123,
-0.0121474992,
-0.0425327122,
0.0479725264,
0.0312647112,
-0.0315393433,
0.0132189114,
0.0535783358,
0.0035177234,
-0.068820864,
0.0364781469,
-0.039425686,
0.0361630768,
0.0249381401,
-0.0069178743,
0.0148608666,
-0.0609732419,
0.0318114385,
-0.0149012329,
0.0075844615,
-0.0135595854,
0.0512035824,
-0.033377137,
-0.0054891137,
-0.0083537288,
0.0548929647,
-0.0552809015,
0.0007101587,
0.0074870014,
0.0913457945,
0.0122963265,
-0.0179725941,
-0.0336933248,
-0.0128731495,
-0.0169444084,
0.0918726847,
0.058569245,
-0.0465075783,
-0.0222184509,
-0.0058766883,
-0.0040172734,
-0.0516865626,
0.0111152343,
-0.0194058288,
-0.0013434264,
-0.0424950235,
-0.0420641936,
-0.0401758589,
0.0383715853,
0.0178299714,
-0.003393278,
0.0146086486,
-0.0049456232,
-0.0144495014,
-0.0581729375,
0.0679289028,
-0.0193551611,
0.0174579192,
-0.1076839268,
-0.0022544486,
0.026059946,
0.0138549367,
-0.0279442556,
0.0626663268,
-0.1071947813,
-0.09049505,
-0.0150546385,
0.0654387176,
0.0178443436,
0.0661342517,
0.0127596296,
-0.0100478176,
0.0688993856,
0.0150574548,
-0.0136897145,
0.0074905925,
0.0225401334,
-0.0414376892,
-0.0162030961,
0.0194834676,
-0.0119084306,
-0.0042218966,
0.0137486318,
0.0479265526,
-0.0158406422,
-0.0418684483,
-0.0029410683,
0.0037913863,
0.0452718362,
-0.0181740392,
-0.0126184998,
-0.0077176024,
0.0352100842,
-0.0215945672,
0.0197341703,
-0.0293251574,
0.0162165929,
0.0266472213,
0.0046012397,
-0.0115351612,
-0.012376463,
-0.0127633912,
0.0332096405,
-0.0409545116,
0.0717400014,
-0.0249854177,
0.0011156356,
0.0312428903,
-0.0430203266,
-0.0305980351,
-0.0017565745,
-0.0066160355,
0.0367721394,
-0.0408827737,
0.0569790229,
-0.0024310972,
0.0293560196,
0.0334846936,
0.0346997641,
-0.0205513742,
0.0081715565,
-0.0601009689,
0.0194203481,
0.0652757585,
0.0032081485,
0.0384725481,
-0.0131048979,
-0.0034976373,
-0.0332751535,
0.0654783994,
-0.0249791685,
-0.0238432642,
0.0225615166,
0.0275180321,
-0.0246116482,
0.0043638493,
0.0949841067,
0.0429461673,
0.0563824363,
0.0122289676,
-0.014923322,
-0.026748782,
-0.0433002785,
0.0193791315,
0.0037800982,
-0.0380571783,
-0.0050950828,
-0.0184572581,
-0.052231431,
0.0167844743,
0.0377171636,
0.0022765996,
0.0153546976,
0.0349391624,
0.0513369963,
-0.0274749938,
-0.0389599241,
-0.0196911041,
0.0224677138,
-0.0045136758,
-0.0548708104,
-0.0026635998,
-6.111910878e-33,
-0.0133138383,
0.0201836545,
0.0217441246,
-0.0060917046,
-0.0409524068,
-0.0050819418,
-0.0484635122,
0.0001786749,
0.0207887683,
-0.026630912,
0.0051341401,
-0.0008623758,
0.017957598,
0.0494848676,
0.039675992,
0.014275264,
0.0589119233,
0.0089767398,
-0.0025871648,
0.0429753289,
0.0288085286,
0.0326712318,
0.0784989893,
0.0006589439,
-0.0020106994,
-0.0039047566,
0.0420487076,
-0.0237371121,
-0.0523782857,
0.065284878,
-0.0115471324,
0.0258958526,
0.005463935,
-0.0585492775,
-0.0217756946,
0.0169602633,
-0.0766933262,
0.0097899493,
0.0278457683,
0.0166058745,
-0.0202963632,
-0.0414819606,
0.0312535614,
-0.0122668566,
-0.0348971672,
0.000017936,
0.0286555551,
-0.0061919983,
-0.0338038094,
0.002464711,
-0.0306061227,
0.0397654884,
0.0002097175,
-0.0091604451,
0.0365964212,
0.0670045763,
-0.0109216105,
0.0157968476,
-0.0058150929,
0.0081557883,
0.0527219288,
0.0839135274,
0.0698872805,
0.0312020071,
0.0181445833,
0.0018556847,
0.0132006221,
-0.0549229756,
-0.0162111875,
0.027337512,
0.0251741782,
0.0278667789,
0.052517496,
0.0172025207,
0.0235168692,
0.0039575086,
-0.0812801644,
0.001106513,
0.0227488913,
0.0378896818,
0.0204555076,
0.0094846059,
-0.0175660048,
0.0084491316,
-0.0297033135,
-0.0357401371,
-0.0112764295,
-0.0265306998,
0.0433686376,
0.0183658954,
0.0016182405,
-0.0005780404,
0.0626530647,
-0.010296369,
-0.0256881136,
0.0284104813,
0.0238120146,
-0.0117836902,
-0.0291731413,
0.0380940996,
-0.0935885385,
-0.0438993573,
0.0290854387,
-0.0341744423,
0.0027084125,
-0.0147091886,
0.0295808818,
0.0038566871,
-0.0439358018,
-0.0102901543,
-0.0463697761,
0.0203961302,
-0.0183080342,
0.0308463201,
0.0812141746,
0.0107935658,
0.004573008,
0.0395158976,
-0.0044006766,
-0.0003439889,
-0.0000993571,
-0.041042272,
0.0147765977,
0.0209769215,
-0.0208477471,
-0.0172348749,
-0.0311360471,
0.0025494427,
0.0002184216,
-0.040352378,
-0.0068044127,
0.0476202667,
2.491e-7,
0.0074192602,
0.0443855301,
0.0315512046,
-0.0182568487,
-0.0029340293,
0.0236714836,
-0.0398086533,
0.0267004594,
0.0085141221,
-0.0060092453,
0.0053940187,
-0.0160012878,
0.0609750785,
-0.0138040427,
-0.1088782027,
-0.0300703347,
-0.0604710132,
0.0419409759,
-0.0850670338,
-0.0111778546,
0.0409592688,
0.1304844469,
0.0036141993,
-0.0018021441,
0.0152952392,
-0.0294238534,
0.0354567245,
-0.0221602265,
-0.0324745737,
-0.0038178568,
-0.0092267487,
0.0127508696,
0.0098468494,
-0.0133038005,
-0.0240792874,
0.0077538402,
-0.0075597614,
0.0795999616,
0.0257372968,
-0.0330286473,
0.0476252101,
0.0127465893,
-0.0268777423,
-0.0340268984,
0.0591488965,
-0.0378619172,
-0.0016159624,
-0.0028738419,
-0.0536915697,
-0.0039751441,
-0.0036125574,
-0.0169457085,
0.0152135957,
0.0250171758,
0.028278036,
-0.0434924066,
0.0035574113,
-0.0915667787,
-0.0111927651,
0.0080885906,
-0.0616143681,
-0.0111410543,
-0.070303373,
0.0307101496,
-0.0153672434,
-0.0485223271,
-0.0233321562,
2.656188132e-34,
0.0296410434,
-0.0505149886,
0.0013648371,
-0.0018590974,
0.0021962724,
-0.0262502972,
-0.0327500664,
0.0075218114,
-0.0062875231,
-0.0977132991,
-0.0388140902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03433v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03433v1 | Improving Open Information Extraction with Large Language Models: A Study on Demonstration Uncertainty | 2023-09-07T01:35:24 | 2023-09-07T01:35:24 | Chen Ling, Xujiang Zhao, Xuchao Zhang, Yanchi Liu, Wei Cheng, Haoyu Wang, Zhengzhang Chen, Takao Osaki, Katsushi Matsuda, Haifeng Chen, Liang Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Open Information Extraction (OIE) task aims at extracting structured facts
from unstructured text, typically in the form of (subject, relation, object)
triples. Despite the potential of large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT as
a general task solver, they lag behind state-of-the-art (supervised) methods in
OIE tasks due to two key issues. First, LLMs struggle to distinguish irrelevant
context from relevant relations and generate structured output due to the
restrictions on fine-tuning the model. Second, LLMs generates responses
autoregressively based on probability, which makes the predicted relations lack
confidence. In this paper, we assess the capabilities of LLMs in improving the
OIE task. Particularly, we propose various in-context learning strategies to
enhance LLM's instruction-following ability and a demonstration uncertainty
quantification module to enhance the confidence of the generated relations. Our
experiments on three OIE benchmark datasets show that our approach holds its
own against established supervised methods, both quantitatively and
qualitatively. | [
0.0387009531,
0.0964837447,
0.0331788436,
0.0730838329,
-0.0620561466,
0.0242119953,
-0.013108423,
-0.0029192592,
0.0015847274,
-0.0699752644,
-0.0043562474,
-0.0415385626,
-0.0303178113,
0.029954724,
-0.0270852018,
-0.0200176928,
0.0340585858,
-0.0288121514,
0.0373243317,
0.02018914,
-0.0247753337,
0.013698888,
-0.0093583371,
-0.0164094698,
-0.0259264447,
0.0071964143,
0.0111249527,
-0.0221698191,
0.0034686138,
-0.0636974871,
-0.000943193,
0.0645430163,
0.0008088547,
-0.0047256039,
0.000001848,
-0.0779865012,
-0.0401798226,
-0.0019691018,
-0.0594398081,
-0.016341459,
0.0134176798,
0.0056155641,
-0.0032079367,
0.0092743663,
-0.0318894684,
-0.0576067455,
0.0288229063,
0.0736329034,
0.0048284945,
0.0826010257,
-0.0099874055,
-0.0115494709,
0.0384973288,
-0.0242180042,
0.0303548668,
-0.0214168727,
0.0639007241,
0.0229368731,
-0.0238917377,
0.0441686697,
0.0041320166,
0.0053458354,
0.0254053269,
0.0255719349,
-0.0124693494,
0.057234861,
-0.068331778,
-0.0214741956,
-0.0030028555,
0.086632289,
0.0047726552,
0.0099073444,
-0.0078565171,
0.0005554648,
-0.0143537177,
0.0271354318,
-0.0417140312,
0.0553794689,
-0.040888384,
0.0325061642,
0.0136940237,
0.0189244021,
0.011532139,
0.0199498534,
-0.0289112292,
0.0499650575,
-0.0003786117,
-0.0387367569,
0.0512297973,
0.0203276705,
-0.0365599096,
-0.039999906,
-0.0148004033,
0.0283161998,
-0.0114367381,
0.0469848663,
-0.0216388926,
-0.0312047713,
-0.0075524817,
-0.0663851202,
-0.0130259199,
0.0189778507,
-0.0458220653,
0.0657675415,
-0.0190079827,
0.029136138,
-0.0062139989,
-0.000508768,
-0.009230271,
0.0017479383,
-0.035718374,
0.0301827565,
-0.00674864,
0.0344521217,
-0.062142279,
-0.0218358655,
-0.017086301,
0.0262818523,
-0.0015816614,
0.0293318462,
0.0056887022,
-0.0025862367,
-0.0433818065,
-0.0094898185,
-0.0377053358,
-0.0025784303,
0.0250217672,
-0.0015367748,
-0.0177275166,
-0.0432226956,
-0.0321206264,
0.0048854817,
0.0237801634,
-0.0221193954,
-0.0008278255,
0.0693998486,
-0.0091078877,
-0.0505533554,
-0.022728039,
-0.0170063172,
0.0010110418,
-0.069001548,
0.0079465359,
-0.0504068211,
0.0258786641,
0.0314875059,
-0.0292534679,
-0.0366432518,
0.0630834401,
-0.0017449447,
-0.0667845681,
0.0710293427,
-0.0100252768,
-0.0217505805,
0.0003388809,
0.0215270985,
0.0217920858,
0.0728217363,
0.0298819579,
0.0262541808,
0.0572512671,
0.0550497361,
0.0180000607,
0.0281384829,
0.0370142609,
-0.0062021147,
0.0079674935,
0.0228229426,
0.0389903523,
0.0095312074,
0.018772915,
0.0605843104,
0.0000462773,
0.0055836323,
0.0536761507,
-0.0229662415,
0.0065704854,
-0.0059123104,
0.018126525,
-0.0070033348,
0.0366132967,
0.016479291,
-0.0666189417,
-0.0128919287,
-0.0220646579,
0.0595574304,
-0.0098869437,
0.0546724871,
0.0150060598,
-0.0349797569,
-0.0436050668,
-0.0218252651,
-0.0087681571,
0.024830116,
0.1012207642,
0.0038998441,
-0.0593548827,
0.0274334867,
0.0774551034,
-0.0011295942,
-0.0003101882,
-0.0656448156,
0.0403244086,
-0.0089650666,
0.0491749756,
-0.0523936599,
-0.0199314002,
-0.0299131013,
0.008709196,
0.0226782728,
0.0197232906,
-0.0169159416,
0.0130235758,
-0.024233032,
-0.0396446325,
0.0203421563,
0.0209432933,
-0.0179457404,
0.0708101466,
-0.0069506043,
0.0250616688,
-0.0069526071,
0.0070760036,
0.037610177,
-0.0098434919,
-0.0688354522,
0.0304237511,
-0.0064818794,
0.0463226177,
-0.0095534129,
-0.0369673483,
-0.0142341135,
0.0449406169,
-0.0058971164,
-0.0177534018,
-0.0071392753,
-0.031917762,
-0.0455250479,
0.0345279798,
0.0470257737,
-0.0438500457,
-0.0392617173,
-0.0566020757,
-0.0065642698,
-0.0316508152,
0.0309761427,
0.0606030077,
-0.0400633179,
-0.0010383436,
0.0529787801,
-0.0024372872,
-0.0563624837,
0.1056274399,
-0.0154538285,
-0.0171688367,
0.0332089923,
-0.0282262228,
-0.0110704033,
-0.0084775342,
-0.0014235894,
0.0105801476,
-0.0044377502,
0.0022918666,
0.0090616951,
0.0239728615,
-0.0477405973,
-0.0493908226,
-0.085731715,
0.0325969197,
-0.0198463798,
0.0533204973,
0.0144843003,
0.0064054294,
-0.0365291089,
0.0035930038,
-0.0048049558,
-0.0161502417,
-0.0234709214,
0.0151616381,
0.0431413651,
0.0442181006,
0.0036309853,
-0.0247815456,
0.0057504214,
-0.0314256288,
0.0728920922,
0.0116986614,
-0.0006887651,
-0.0218670964,
0.0839103237,
-0.0276599433,
0.035724137,
-0.0096324068,
0.0235973131,
-0.0276292488,
-0.0277964789,
0.07152652,
0.0481097661,
-0.0076176925,
0.0675892532,
0.0292038359,
-0.0464571714,
-0.022563016,
0.0217131879,
-0.068737559,
-0.0336839296,
-0.0003067161,
-0.0004796443,
-0.0087622395,
0.0176245309,
0.0241740141,
-0.0052442197,
0.0051778723,
0.0212024357,
0.0011471029,
0.0071747266,
-0.0600790195,
0.0223102104,
-0.0064076246,
0.0274072699,
-0.0432175435,
-0.0210026782,
0.0834335759,
-0.015157463,
0.031103164,
-0.0472239964,
0.0079358015,
-0.0607200824,
0.068769075,
-0.006913092,
-0.0025898598,
0.0113829356,
-0.0183607526,
-0.0387127362,
-0.0127258347,
0.0097851101,
-0.0370275714,
0.0287048593,
-0.072398901,
0.0027508533,
0.0080396272,
-0.0175282434,
-0.0580919385,
-0.0690056086,
-0.0068098432,
-0.0052989409,
-0.0146454619,
-0.0060660047,
-0.0026016966,
0.0194145329,
-0.0010686567,
0.0143545698,
-0.0311648082,
-0.0139130037,
-0.0179764628,
0.0410051532,
0.0517096706,
-0.007673475,
0.0041845106,
-0.0378581695,
-0.0088680852,
0.0472491421,
0.0014771631,
0.0101333493,
-0.012136125,
-0.003462384,
-0.0227252431,
-0.0151156979,
0.0168252066,
0.0080453353,
0.0358536355,
-0.0597336665,
-0.0309612099,
0.1322209388,
0.0189803187,
0.0082748225,
-0.0174190328,
0.0168945882,
0.0255187992,
0.0024240662,
0.0259452872,
-0.0724671334,
-0.0195577666,
-0.0083103301,
-0.0116505744,
0.0005461019,
-0.0473337434,
-0.0220827721,
-0.1223539859,
0.0285871774,
-0.0222670846,
-0.0649793148,
-0.0514492728,
-0.0493401513,
0.036550764,
-0.0486169793,
0.0072364709,
0.0053398912,
-0.0476888381,
0.0326025598,
0.0000607229,
0.0075664618,
-0.0667241886,
0.0159582216,
-0.043795839,
0.0521672145,
0.0216555856,
-0.0182281006,
-0.0032440135,
0.0321747102,
0.0372554734,
-0.0104087386,
-0.0244124793,
-0.0173476003,
0.0671923459,
-0.0154981138,
0.0015062558,
-0.041488979,
0.0328826047,
-0.0218028277,
-0.024460841,
-0.005319281,
0.0667627007,
-0.0057882713,
0.0001963289,
-0.0022371721,
-0.0249282923,
0.0335111283,
0.0804659054,
-0.0215550624,
-0.0144935613,
-0.00667451,
-0.0252806619,
-0.0045545022,
0.0150944479,
0.0203601383,
0.0038537695,
-0.0586847775,
-0.0237547066,
-0.057409849,
-0.0204613581,
0.0383866206,
0.0187575445,
0.0071860473,
-0.0246936791,
0.0376207456,
0.0171999,
-0.0458880216,
0.0388732925,
-0.0225656107,
-0.0183116011,
-0.0203492288,
0.0300760083,
0.0389125049,
-0.0306427181,
-0.036622446,
0.0086800959,
-0.1162143424,
-0.0357665718,
-0.0027255241,
0.0125362594,
0.0218491685,
0.043884661,
-0.0073433272,
0.0016953304,
0.0185786299,
0.0686302036,
-0.0517264344,
-0.0008347908,
0.0142880995,
0.0239260979,
0.0180685204,
0.0090933871,
-0.0262821894,
0.0107665909,
0.0117626535,
0.0127370059,
-0.0522801019,
-0.0708302706,
0.0364432558,
0.0093122125,
0.0935043916,
0.0144714825,
-0.0174743682,
-0.0670924634,
0.000066844,
-0.043712683,
-0.0220281463,
-0.0333615914,
0.0353325047,
0.0234732386,
-0.0044683567,
-0.0286500137,
-0.0009298578,
0.0185464304,
0.0543832928,
-0.0182352886,
-0.0457910299,
0.0258874521,
-0.0120494049,
0.039026197,
-0.0311267078,
-0.0287759211,
0.0324182287,
0.0170386583,
0.0178490411,
-0.0180033818,
0.0589569584,
0.0138387429,
-0.0297871195,
0.0023187401,
-0.0327385888,
-0.0514583737,
0.0203674771,
-0.0447236337,
0.0798016042,
0.0213158205,
-0.0166570041,
0.0119905854,
-0.0651787668,
-0.0169905163,
-0.0055515394,
0.03156773,
-0.0136740645,
0.0164590031,
0.0530763976,
0.0033434022,
-0.0406795405,
0.0332831927,
0.0565577932,
0.012918652,
0.0508193374,
0.0236390475,
-0.0429617353,
-0.0366125479,
-0.0099899881,
0.0195863377,
0.0227319356,
0.0011544917,
0.03615674,
-0.0544959083,
-0.0409882665,
-0.0086907893,
0.0210657287,
-0.0096351355,
-0.0094207274,
0.0096017141,
0.0764292106,
0.0026598822,
-0.0525914989,
-0.0474282578,
-0.0073954258,
-0.004224109,
-0.0459828041,
-0.0188566614,
-6.655855461e-33,
-0.036806304,
-0.0565651804,
0.001721469,
0.0357312076,
-0.0181530304,
0.026263291,
-0.0110657243,
0.0076357783,
-0.0156562906,
0.0195241086,
-0.0112063577,
-0.0014004466,
0.0202223435,
0.0220229514,
-0.0143456925,
-0.0240826644,
0.0240053609,
0.0020776356,
0.0046598115,
-0.0034778679,
0.058058314,
0.0334471501,
0.0598776042,
-0.1380133331,
0.0281115323,
-0.0156919938,
0.0015406458,
0.054773137,
0.0178850926,
0.0386276767,
-0.0393710993,
0.0346106775,
0.0166862737,
-0.0205284208,
0.016719941,
0.0072941598,
-0.1178688183,
-0.0285337269,
0.0061102686,
-0.0076437755,
-0.0234675687,
0.0111526847,
-0.0005061565,
-0.0079281321,
0.027737787,
-0.0395672359,
0.024129685,
-0.0312492661,
-0.0106097823,
-0.0306276064,
-0.0484580249,
0.0518717319,
0.0411817133,
-0.0248959865,
0.0057764309,
-0.0112588378,
0.0243806913,
-0.0339304172,
-0.0196734834,
-0.0149112409,
0.0104434276,
0.0214228667,
0.0467914008,
0.0168886557,
-0.0119801704,
0.050904315,
-0.0524669699,
-0.0065371078,
-0.045847021,
-0.011919342,
-0.0126077421,
0.0843999237,
-0.0319371484,
0.0468042828,
0.0250370819,
0.0244908724,
-0.1062729284,
0.0105341524,
0.0301852785,
0.019199688,
-0.0076735695,
-0.0119039044,
-0.0692424476,
-0.0084852641,
0.0040874351,
0.0366414785,
-0.0168101843,
-0.0257584993,
0.0156542249,
-0.0053368756,
-0.0275783483,
0.0158158131,
0.0229616147,
-0.0296552964,
-0.0228802972,
0.0151686827,
-0.0046556978,
0.0117043564,
-0.0384050235,
0.0112377685,
-0.0667770505,
-0.0401417837,
-0.0019180371,
0.009801005,
-0.0150929755,
0.0328289345,
0.0423478857,
-0.0069919466,
-0.0785658062,
0.0021829624,
-0.0357328132,
0.0293568708,
0.0136628365,
0.0112631964,
0.0293890182,
0.0068707312,
-0.0089624273,
0.0803900883,
0.0538304485,
0.0241135024,
-0.0177685842,
-0.003336875,
0.0029452126,
-0.015551446,
0.0143295126,
0.0029190269,
-0.0001394549,
-0.043511752,
-0.011259974,
-0.0421794578,
0.012818696,
0.0402130112,
2.666e-7,
0.0535027795,
0.0714704171,
0.0286799222,
0.0621949956,
-0.0061395462,
0.0328949876,
0.015893029,
0.0055372166,
0.0233052187,
-0.0422611125,
0.0089955153,
0.0238183755,
0.0160720777,
0.0482620001,
-0.0502463207,
-0.0453967936,
-0.0373295173,
-0.0672180876,
-0.0644963384,
-0.0207835268,
0.1077382341,
0.1009102538,
0.0394972786,
0.0262633115,
-0.0377705172,
-0.0488729849,
0.0666609183,
-0.0156460591,
-0.0587797239,
0.0437756553,
0.0298117045,
0.0192459933,
-0.0135301528,
0.0553973988,
0.0016127013,
0.0137817385,
-0.0090783834,
0.0724577233,
0.0424442478,
0.0259327851,
0.0105024781,
-0.0209723953,
0.0117735956,
-0.027731413,
0.0821351409,
-0.0742563978,
-0.0146116773,
-0.0202259012,
0.0127176885,
-0.0134244403,
0.0061262245,
-0.0028192869,
0.0053500207,
0.0121641494,
-0.0040700636,
-0.008478391,
-0.0403308384,
-0.0637990907,
-0.0236334577,
0.0111376587,
-0.0206083432,
-0.0523617491,
0.0523571409,
-0.0047085299,
0.0346450061,
-0.0725110769,
0.0002912747,
2.859650592e-34,
0.0250303745,
0.0098930513,
-0.0355670229,
0.0258532148,
0.0427767895,
-0.005467806,
-0.0255364906,
0.0068261656,
-0.0237362552,
-0.0581539683,
0.016248513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03412v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03412v2 | From Base to Conversational: Japanese Instruction Dataset and Tuning Large Language Models | 2023-09-07T00:14:37 | 2023-11-05T06:32:30 | Masahiro Suzuki, Masanori Hirano, Hiroki Sakaji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction tuning is essential for large language models (LLMs) to become
interactive. While many instruction tuning datasets exist in English, there is
a noticeable lack in other languages. Also, their effectiveness has not been
well verified in non-English languages. We construct a Japanese instruction
dataset by expanding and filtering existing datasets and apply the dataset to a
Japanese pre-trained base model. We performed Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) tuning
on both Japanese and English existing models using our instruction dataset. We
evaluated these models from both quantitative and qualitative perspectives. As
a result, the effectiveness of Japanese instruction datasets is confirmed. The
results also indicate that even with relatively small LLMs, performances in
downstream tasks would be improved through instruction tuning. Our instruction
dataset, tuned models, and implementation are publicly available online. | [
0.0354586914,
0.0515907146,
-0.0185523499,
0.0495343767,
0.0372437313,
0.0505782589,
0.0439394005,
0.0061803628,
-0.0167444851,
-0.0055474443,
-0.1189536452,
-0.0288546421,
0.0208049845,
0.0104413051,
0.008281976,
-0.0906482935,
0.0360234231,
-0.0364272259,
-0.0364975184,
-0.0021480815,
0.0152600557,
0.007065862,
-0.0249217991,
0.0334644839,
0.0366075076,
0.0062568923,
-0.0142583214,
0.0254147593,
0.0051771761,
-0.0032076361,
0.0177422147,
0.0661020353,
0.0277489815,
-0.0148032345,
0.0000019739,
-0.0183877349,
0.0385868475,
-0.0585266128,
-0.0263631064,
0.0377018116,
0.0169438887,
-0.0142813316,
-0.0190748535,
0.0290716551,
-0.0114406655,
-0.0240727253,
0.0654457137,
0.0076496969,
0.0784112513,
0.0927227736,
0.000805199,
-0.0313308015,
-0.0089143319,
-0.0306939054,
-0.0255326908,
-0.0159445889,
-0.0009186045,
0.0056658476,
-0.0164806265,
0.0067719235,
-0.0596770756,
-0.000773082,
0.0202339627,
-0.0119682467,
-0.0192854274,
-0.0031805998,
-0.0068653086,
-0.0046274285,
-0.024330331,
0.0900353864,
0.0010257924,
0.0002778749,
-0.035986077,
-0.0163336154,
-0.0044132862,
-0.0324257687,
-0.0471357852,
0.0143718906,
0.0332389623,
0.0073750927,
0.0092908582,
-0.0252764411,
0.0084303049,
-0.0030111037,
-0.0130220195,
0.0448500663,
0.0318556689,
-0.0533854105,
-0.0129381744,
-0.0200554635,
-0.0072895251,
-0.035518568,
0.0002246455,
0.0376051217,
-0.0505291447,
0.0540595166,
-0.0602883883,
-0.0061033554,
0.0033976124,
-0.0475998931,
0.0982289985,
0.0621844828,
-0.0116481027,
0.0062433989,
0.0113333622,
0.0806228891,
0.0031542694,
0.0315897316,
-0.0621602461,
0.0181560945,
-0.0383911468,
0.018376682,
-0.0515280329,
-0.0087115029,
-0.0739971176,
0.0042736419,
-0.0430574603,
0.0564471707,
-0.0041577024,
-0.0091413949,
0.0244306251,
-0.0597803444,
-0.0757341385,
-0.0054193935,
-0.0203276277,
0.0418298841,
-0.0140504166,
0.0387524106,
0.011704036,
-0.0593290217,
0.0176348556,
0.0007141743,
0.0314838588,
-0.0261050127,
0.023248652,
0.0325275734,
-0.0164850112,
-0.0361727662,
-0.0305854063,
0.0319855325,
-0.0067894664,
-0.0424553826,
0.0095620118,
-0.0221000183,
0.0373159796,
-0.0147393104,
0.0484545007,
-0.0163904745,
-0.0259848069,
0.0069250888,
0.0003490307,
0.0310516246,
0.0151413241,
0.0209252331,
0.009761312,
-0.0075094514,
0.0173204485,
0.0634989068,
0.0275631566,
-0.0209194645,
0.0410788059,
-0.0406433009,
-0.0235091597,
0.0699106082,
0.0013677336,
0.0500752069,
0.0090646287,
0.0083604278,
0.0067706495,
0.030748276,
0.0511927679,
-0.011889128,
-0.0101961019,
0.0039603156,
0.0693574697,
0.0252076257,
0.0155222695,
0.0235313922,
0.0500986986,
0.0147260353,
0.0090566035,
0.0099772112,
-0.0546822287,
0.010986872,
-0.0539872311,
0.0190895256,
-0.0028449562,
0.0224054269,
-0.0583244003,
-0.0766053945,
-0.0202397574,
0.0174509231,
-0.0211243052,
0.017040493,
0.0315396897,
0.0155839082,
-0.0320778266,
0.0190943312,
0.0659163147,
-0.0521539338,
0.0145988381,
-0.0424716957,
0.0067266235,
0.0746363476,
0.0013984889,
0.0016556351,
-0.0326695815,
0.0345138162,
0.0654154271,
0.045998197,
0.046933677,
-0.0178705081,
0.0313562751,
-0.0565577522,
-0.0273500215,
-0.0037292037,
0.00240524,
0.0502190404,
-0.002604394,
0.0003221446,
-0.0037763631,
0.0014230382,
-0.0643277019,
0.0335347094,
-0.0632061511,
-0.0099249724,
-0.0102225076,
0.0090762787,
0.0482400246,
0.0011819341,
-0.0118509308,
-0.0253991578,
0.0026981309,
-0.0164450631,
0.0555804372,
0.0129727386,
-0.0460651517,
-0.0405663028,
0.0133189633,
0.0315689705,
-0.0022347479,
0.0392108373,
-0.0474025905,
-0.0410481021,
0.0136198122,
-0.0195750911,
0.0165902171,
-0.0387602523,
0.042002894,
-0.0198116619,
0.0327869803,
-0.0059693982,
0.0058047082,
-0.0047156345,
0.0092516085,
0.0442727953,
0.0162696149,
-0.011565553,
-0.075289458,
-0.0193638075,
0.0371962711,
-0.0103669195,
0.0018788314,
-0.0167563651,
0.0533533916,
-0.0386915505,
-0.0298641827,
-0.081232585,
0.0175286308,
-0.0270987097,
0.0340986326,
0.0392057113,
0.0187764168,
-0.0462193489,
-0.0412055068,
-0.0280993897,
0.0147584854,
-0.0042634746,
0.0209206361,
0.0029915422,
0.0217132457,
-0.0173097141,
-0.0495896339,
-0.0240709316,
0.0531367362,
-0.0038418723,
-0.021759415,
-0.0045554689,
-0.0811759233,
0.0516099818,
-0.0164930336,
0.0392038934,
-0.0098850504,
-0.0887950286,
-0.0098731061,
0.0010219171,
0.0628444552,
0.0776419565,
-0.0231073275,
0.023177417,
0.0426531024,
-0.0131648816,
-0.0389271826,
0.0287965368,
-0.0133485654,
-0.0447434075,
-0.0768485963,
-0.0371786058,
0.0042874338,
0.0821046233,
0.0007588369,
0.0080793882,
-0.0773188546,
-0.0287388172,
-0.0395095423,
-0.0260224063,
-0.0430072658,
0.0313770846,
-0.0291152969,
0.0090392707,
-0.0429861695,
-0.0351964682,
0.0633246526,
-0.031542182,
-0.0400605872,
-0.0691699088,
-0.0045682145,
-0.0214660205,
0.0050804112,
-0.0042603565,
0.0182014126,
-0.0398995243,
-0.0383311808,
-0.0462210476,
0.0157617088,
0.0252745599,
-0.0112238349,
0.0269397758,
-0.0684716552,
-0.0218897965,
-0.0097689303,
-0.0240509305,
-0.0069101145,
-0.0046884045,
0.0112323649,
-0.0044665541,
0.0265392568,
-0.0218401682,
-0.0306291115,
-0.000152782,
0.0164831039,
0.0677150413,
-0.0126823792,
0.0184086859,
-0.0194860455,
-0.0381541103,
0.05562656,
0.0469009764,
-0.0384650901,
-0.0596458055,
0.0616660453,
-0.0003624333,
0.0489548743,
-0.045571398,
-0.0220386367,
0.0481115617,
0.048053842,
-0.0191104319,
-0.0054508359,
0.0363079682,
0.0777715147,
-0.0327779986,
-0.0163693372,
0.1028387621,
-0.0007658851,
-0.0337422602,
0.0025821219,
-0.0077479412,
0.0222069528,
0.0174800027,
0.0329775102,
-0.0506495833,
-0.0114397593,
0.002833049,
0.0320106372,
0.0172805898,
0.0163221937,
-0.0049167103,
-0.1420983225,
0.0321528129,
0.0158293396,
-0.0484565273,
-0.0266648047,
-0.0419871509,
0.0170715544,
-0.0100345239,
0.0789350122,
-0.0078235026,
-0.0280824713,
-0.0299046747,
0.0324128456,
-0.0296900496,
-0.0909214318,
0.0133145051,
-0.0173692815,
0.068918407,
0.0294344686,
0.0252068434,
0.0028621501,
-0.0060818475,
0.0390253328,
-0.0155792013,
0.0072274441,
-0.039971292,
0.0231728088,
0.0169592705,
-0.0333374254,
0.0014510575,
0.0232676044,
0.0003883167,
0.0084258365,
0.0317971632,
0.018690791,
0.0007935622,
0.0242379159,
0.0098300772,
-0.0224723928,
0.0000374304,
0.0295086782,
0.0422988571,
-0.0755718648,
0.0248709731,
-0.0042567211,
-0.0486096181,
-0.0629272014,
0.0114756348,
0.0333153866,
-0.096720919,
0.0169952773,
-0.0688470826,
-0.0477304123,
0.0197226647,
0.0035857137,
0.0293253642,
-0.0187274795,
0.0010986475,
0.0088322721,
0.0190867037,
0.0491761267,
-0.0263600163,
0.0138467364,
-0.0939420834,
-0.0636054873,
0.0026266493,
-0.0239535682,
0.0224771388,
-0.0176688358,
-0.0266757198,
-0.04749671,
-0.0009928127,
0.075309664,
0.0059439526,
0.0540648475,
0.0148122702,
-0.0682576299,
-0.0126648666,
-0.0402013399,
-0.0036600437,
0.0420333408,
0.0458448529,
-0.0052454174,
-0.0143690053,
0.0225502905,
-0.0467519276,
0.0343106277,
0.0385648794,
0.0306887124,
-0.0276262779,
-0.0114003802,
-0.0008450592,
0.0159629136,
0.0280089304,
-0.0057384404,
-0.0281613711,
-0.0701356679,
0.0679308474,
-0.0340435505,
0.0128717013,
-0.0475562401,
-0.0363677777,
0.0403429084,
0.005093846,
-0.0180362556,
0.0122064594,
-0.0240280386,
0.0050515654,
-0.0609889589,
0.0395909175,
0.0253765695,
0.0287915897,
0.019002201,
0.0435649864,
-0.0318282396,
-0.0192314275,
0.0378244072,
0.0168168806,
0.0334751308,
0.0664851442,
-0.010811626,
-0.0206126105,
0.0078998255,
0.0399949029,
-0.0140984617,
-0.0076653194,
-0.0272363927,
0.0033899234,
0.0407165214,
0.0053291395,
0.058924038,
0.0023285088,
-0.0058213868,
-0.0143882222,
0.0337546878,
-0.005862304,
-0.0381221548,
0.0286835898,
0.0168013219,
0.0074321795,
-0.0013658472,
0.0670684427,
0.0523608886,
0.0605032183,
-0.0109724589,
0.0626058728,
-0.035789486,
-0.0033105339,
0.0336975865,
0.0234335624,
-0.0130544845,
0.0051933574,
0.0284829531,
-0.0610264279,
-0.0737306923,
-0.0004531676,
0.0012458971,
0.000669742,
0.0101158349,
0.0201574787,
-0.0389132127,
-0.024153294,
-0.034813717,
-0.0083613629,
-0.0174277909,
0.000677406,
0.0013813733,
-6.156235464e-33,
-0.0726553425,
0.0306279119,
0.0349645428,
0.0167463403,
-0.0073030633,
-0.0169998761,
-0.0452243499,
0.0069968682,
-0.038600333,
-0.0095829489,
-0.0171632525,
0.0144235305,
0.0194331333,
0.0536286421,
0.0087526804,
0.0157731269,
0.0412369482,
0.0002081189,
-0.0098320711,
0.0292310901,
0.0140279625,
-0.005668899,
0.0682225078,
-0.0114176814,
0.0063921311,
-0.0053732302,
-0.0097789196,
0.0244699977,
-0.0240419134,
0.083120957,
0.0012447425,
0.0893955752,
0.0099284407,
-0.0263013113,
-0.0442646518,
0.015530901,
-0.0607467033,
-0.0238248203,
0.0248789936,
0.0512346923,
0.0020745436,
-0.038462691,
-0.0186090823,
-0.0085194195,
-0.0368201025,
-0.0241020471,
0.0235152002,
-0.0640726015,
-0.0153648192,
0.0351904519,
-0.0591084808,
0.0058965473,
-0.0099898437,
-0.0226030555,
0.0136711281,
0.0532802455,
-0.0218240879,
-0.0445230752,
-0.0189738106,
0.0474032722,
0.0533163622,
0.0654637739,
0.0703831688,
0.0478526428,
-0.0132229496,
-0.0056123901,
0.0367098339,
0.0009935033,
0.0651848614,
-0.0058211517,
0.0333803743,
0.0247491505,
0.0241879541,
0.0350716151,
0.0001163542,
0.0054368866,
-0.0417835452,
0.0089356937,
0.0111386906,
0.0353036672,
0.0189765804,
0.0018874977,
-0.0319261737,
-0.0239899121,
-0.0256159939,
0.0152004892,
-0.0310080666,
-0.0332870446,
0.0507986359,
0.0093154768,
0.001033344,
-0.023516804,
0.0377848148,
-0.0344625004,
-0.0124938441,
0.0110103264,
-0.0066405544,
0.0173652843,
-0.0146365175,
0.0001369265,
-0.0731838271,
-0.0909004435,
0.0096207382,
-0.0122478288,
0.000160729,
-0.0080117509,
0.0237877835,
0.0253427457,
-0.0428958498,
0.0078410199,
-0.0215660166,
0.0207045041,
0.0255656,
0.0545087382,
-0.0026987595,
-0.0139544308,
-0.0374526344,
0.0936034471,
0.0007868225,
-0.0308606308,
-0.0353369229,
-0.0888828114,
0.0047946637,
0.0342820846,
-0.0358057544,
0.010354409,
-0.0393240489,
-0.001579912,
0.0107750688,
-0.0288606565,
-0.0207472127,
0.0129604051,
2.653e-7,
0.0066313506,
0.0345360935,
-0.008289841,
0.0144191403,
0.008007464,
-0.0106000695,
-0.0463378765,
0.003987358,
0.0586656667,
0.0241962448,
0.024067184,
0.0296692569,
0.0722245947,
-0.0454964526,
-0.0841172114,
-0.037664935,
-0.0637221038,
0.0421134792,
-0.0706698671,
-0.0028014407,
0.0027857455,
0.0928698927,
-0.0213122182,
0.0097969212,
0.0003046923,
-0.002449689,
0.0359400958,
-0.0383024886,
-0.0212074928,
0.0359172486,
0.0125537151,
0.0173200835,
-0.012008396,
-0.0006686996,
-0.0402582064,
0.048109211,
-0.021567326,
0.0866817832,
-0.0076814876,
-0.0124272583,
0.0373024344,
0.0515212752,
-0.0444228314,
-0.0415166318,
0.0544647053,
-0.0471092798,
-0.0064733326,
0.0330038369,
-0.0087689571,
-0.0244669095,
-0.0057222336,
-0.0352971107,
-0.0046494184,
0.0144105302,
0.0515129715,
-0.0429489762,
-0.0238026287,
-0.0133604128,
0.0045456267,
0.0247832108,
-0.0248957761,
-0.0874420851,
-0.0459560864,
-0.0287619606,
-0.0165685043,
-0.0249074437,
0.0139598036,
1.920097587e-34,
0.0103400908,
0.0042890231,
0.050552506,
0.0249096788,
0.0053851055,
-0.0228071008,
-0.0144197233,
0.0337454304,
0.0302661844,
-0.0968158767,
-0.0120906755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03409v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03409v3 | Large Language Models as Optimizers | 2023-09-07T00:07:15 | 2024-04-15T07:50:32 | Chengrun Yang, Xuezhi Wang, Yifeng Lu, Hanxiao Liu, Quoc V. Le, Denny Zhou, Xinyun Chen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Optimization is ubiquitous. While derivative-based algorithms have been
powerful tools for various problems, the absence of gradient imposes challenges
on many real-world applications. In this work, we propose Optimization by
PROmpting (OPRO), a simple and effective approach to leverage large language
models (LLMs) as optimizers, where the optimization task is described in
natural language. In each optimization step, the LLM generates new solutions
from the prompt that contains previously generated solutions with their values,
then the new solutions are evaluated and added to the prompt for the next
optimization step. We first showcase OPRO on linear regression and traveling
salesman problems, then move on to our main application in prompt optimization,
where the goal is to find instructions that maximize the task accuracy. With a
variety of LLMs, we demonstrate that the best prompts optimized by OPRO
outperform human-designed prompts by up to 8% on GSM8K, and by up to 50% on
Big-Bench Hard tasks. Code at https://github.com/google-deepmind/opro. | [
0.0364760272,
0.076618135,
0.0006890596,
0.0538499244,
-0.039193552,
-0.0012818022,
0.0300041642,
0.0096722711,
0.01074953,
-0.0206200499,
-0.0170924384,
-0.0431384817,
0.0040291864,
0.0004110034,
0.0337128527,
-0.0476851277,
0.024955608,
-0.0864805952,
0.0103057865,
-0.0066162292,
-0.03101274,
-0.0148710059,
-0.008046438,
0.0236879401,
-0.0227414649,
-0.0080452217,
-0.0412654988,
0.0265743248,
0.0289194398,
-0.0251883827,
0.0012940161,
0.0468606204,
0.0333982334,
0.0340358876,
0.0000023585,
-0.0307696387,
0.0047100098,
-0.006800958,
-0.062933065,
-0.0092296451,
0.050294999,
0.0013837606,
-0.0038421289,
0.0329578258,
-0.0599391833,
-0.0002125354,
0.0410171226,
0.0096479589,
0.1025241315,
0.1138549522,
0.0199657343,
0.0014024322,
0.0030489692,
-0.0314221866,
0.0206085313,
-0.0698351488,
0.028229,
-0.0299621206,
-0.0074502034,
0.0202679355,
-0.0348063,
0.0182202663,
0.0337955467,
-0.0084109539,
0.0082925633,
0.0313464478,
-0.004385618,
-0.0066899154,
-0.0569768883,
0.0767530948,
-0.0359482095,
0.0090332981,
0.018391531,
-0.0175447278,
-0.0097870016,
-0.0465427376,
-0.0355306789,
0.0175336208,
0.0026445831,
0.0029067085,
-0.0371434577,
-0.0100223627,
0.0319921635,
0.0246734247,
-0.0163203068,
0.0745913163,
0.0000529776,
-0.0259978548,
0.0319787376,
-0.0279746912,
-0.0290479567,
-0.0690930337,
0.0204130765,
0.0490406975,
-0.0841805637,
-0.0004236256,
-0.0124483798,
-0.0697268248,
-0.0287827775,
0.0036328167,
0.1144118831,
0.0475361645,
0.0021439942,
0.0558168106,
-0.0245796181,
0.0791216493,
-0.0351448208,
-0.0392820463,
-0.0557510331,
0.0154056828,
-0.0313656516,
0.0061355275,
-0.0407963581,
0.0251343194,
-0.0486612841,
-0.0315935314,
-0.0204407535,
0.0271255951,
-0.0112511003,
0.0174120758,
0.0206608269,
0.0255230218,
-0.0418423153,
-0.0396552123,
-0.0425971076,
-0.0278415885,
-0.0432730988,
0.0201036762,
0.0250709988,
-0.0207761191,
-0.0161065869,
0.0317564905,
-0.0045521967,
-0.0196589977,
0.006276587,
0.0860753506,
0.0026823014,
0.0038268205,
0.0004696968,
-0.022278998,
-0.000015274,
-0.0746863931,
-0.0186383445,
-0.0839681998,
0.034818612,
-0.0145348879,
-0.0160950702,
-0.042144414,
0.0314635374,
0.0172520652,
-0.0084105525,
0.0619382784,
0.0103934575,
0.0214335211,
0.0593451262,
-0.0219723489,
-0.0086676348,
0.0786269009,
0.0360540859,
0.0724138469,
0.0004308186,
0.0085946182,
-0.0031098651,
0.0638702363,
0.0041588447,
0.0280481782,
-0.0055552516,
-0.0253331363,
0.0174354706,
0.075099282,
0.0038035156,
0.0743984133,
-0.0255594105,
0.015282141,
0.0589145571,
0.0486736111,
-0.0001807382,
-0.0021816816,
0.0397108346,
0.0137411486,
-0.0224895738,
-0.05006532,
-0.0647015274,
0.011227048,
-0.0292464234,
-0.0146550452,
0.0242606085,
0.0053826002,
-0.0158228464,
-0.0556884818,
0.0049833031,
-0.0170468874,
0.0037072599,
0.0440772437,
0.0130545078,
-0.0044299723,
-0.0852266625,
0.0059040394,
0.0088771479,
-0.0034576298,
-0.0136470925,
-0.0436855368,
0.0210074615,
0.0707379356,
0.0170685109,
-0.0077257543,
-0.0178487115,
-0.015794808,
0.0117092244,
0.0463747457,
0.0427274182,
0.0009727683,
0.0052059763,
-0.0515214205,
-0.0264134426,
-0.0064169322,
0.0146410912,
0.0133353723,
0.0399830155,
0.0044073798,
0.0343526416,
0.0034823858,
-0.0180567168,
0.0394107811,
-0.0180976819,
-0.0607803501,
0.0579759777,
0.007603928,
-0.0003313218,
0.0128378207,
-0.0004435364,
0.0056124609,
-0.005437966,
-0.0524885394,
-0.0209559388,
-0.0361475199,
-0.0372194536,
-0.0226779338,
0.0364038311,
-0.0114261154,
-0.029717505,
0.0603483245,
-0.0528499968,
-0.0241117179,
0.0165373981,
-0.0523437336,
0.0043755299,
0.0042744903,
0.0012841191,
0.0052859844,
-0.009785099,
-0.0554883257,
0.0745956302,
0.0028690463,
-0.0102500524,
0.0622688569,
0.0169090331,
-0.0082432097,
-0.0612914935,
0.0108597176,
-0.0143367825,
0.0043083047,
0.0293538012,
0.036425747,
0.039076522,
-0.0164805483,
-0.0340172239,
-0.1170622483,
0.0403354391,
-0.0211439878,
0.0244087409,
-0.00864424,
0.005590654,
-0.0166614093,
-0.0189745352,
-0.0291535668,
0.0450728238,
-0.0236888081,
-0.0064397263,
0.0413487926,
0.0346224569,
-0.0185152907,
-0.0427642092,
-0.0176763218,
-0.0061150459,
0.0292835869,
-0.0094189532,
0.0126235746,
-0.0769803599,
0.0311103594,
-0.019781094,
0.0400304869,
0.01429037,
0.0033650275,
-0.0003395841,
-0.0425302163,
0.0533605665,
0.0908906087,
0.0394746028,
-0.0128904395,
0.0109107466,
-0.0091843307,
-0.0831164345,
0.0384216532,
-0.0518812016,
-0.0317188576,
0.0067315083,
-0.0435972326,
0.0385698974,
0.0767379403,
-0.0070047253,
-0.0133703724,
-0.0502826311,
0.034368258,
-0.0105237486,
-0.0149573525,
-0.0631155744,
0.025212327,
-0.0186745543,
0.0488280281,
-0.0072375499,
-0.0691618472,
0.0987384766,
-0.0107169943,
-0.0020299843,
-0.0070181326,
-0.0150660435,
-0.0608498901,
0.0512290597,
-0.0093383463,
0.0076206583,
-0.0082019754,
-0.0063297367,
-0.0210195314,
0.0041181659,
0.0138730146,
-0.018053703,
0.0194248017,
-0.0404838249,
0.001530893,
-0.0170730613,
-0.0882434621,
-0.0547744446,
-0.059884198,
-0.031127343,
-0.0014954788,
0.0214326978,
-0.0160077326,
-0.009380402,
-0.0171233751,
0.0150964502,
0.0449009202,
-0.0500468574,
0.0056729405,
-0.0386582501,
-0.0120353037,
0.0620133765,
0.0273608938,
0.0052652201,
-0.0633472055,
0.0413702913,
0.0105916178,
0.0544265918,
0.0327432603,
-0.0689647496,
0.0244864523,
0.0216157995,
-0.0082463166,
-0.0011825934,
0.0463893451,
0.0238815248,
-0.0670333728,
0.0008577405,
0.0881699696,
0.0266019963,
-0.0608658716,
-0.0040187989,
-0.0322478339,
0.0131388046,
0.0060619884,
0.0427002124,
-0.0700202659,
-0.0521215238,
0.0313573144,
0.0504236966,
0.006540467,
-0.0253470521,
-0.0200219434,
-0.131975174,
0.0309729874,
0.0000604544,
-0.0191515852,
0.0038855206,
-0.042746257,
-0.0255754367,
-0.0134038441,
0.0149048995,
0.0153178759,
0.0216087494,
-0.0000567771,
-0.001832168,
0.0064081233,
-0.0213236306,
-0.0021827498,
-0.0348662585,
0.0129327457,
0.0939602405,
-0.0081356168,
0.0002983337,
-0.0319657438,
0.0457302667,
0.0404885635,
0.0004154803,
-0.0198784322,
-0.0198741686,
-0.0097570578,
-0.025243707,
0.003934457,
0.0529235639,
-0.0416838825,
0.0123421699,
0.0397316292,
0.0656307265,
-0.017964635,
-0.0164083242,
-0.0149893453,
-0.0039977781,
0.0571803488,
0.0550126359,
0.0076043764,
-0.0823760331,
-0.0361783318,
-0.0642456785,
0.0005820646,
-0.0510798953,
-0.0389409848,
-0.0245395284,
0.009048189,
0.0079763718,
-0.0457294025,
0.0048734769,
0.0203267541,
0.0362088941,
0.0142356753,
-0.0299305711,
0.0114477742,
-0.0053155366,
-0.0375020877,
0.0367969759,
-0.0368081667,
0.0216020308,
-0.0899292603,
-0.0024155716,
0.047249008,
-0.0251214076,
-0.0052668247,
0.0376688577,
-0.1239718124,
-0.0755259618,
-0.0365131274,
0.0760446042,
0.0188711658,
0.0328539908,
-0.0000775669,
-0.0472908802,
0.0422820039,
0.0518550538,
-0.0044302531,
0.0135711702,
-0.0014110566,
0.0010680526,
-0.0113477325,
0.0150059508,
-0.0551117174,
0.016928805,
0.0222414508,
0.0517991036,
-0.0106871678,
-0.014017866,
0.0225360189,
0.0148893259,
0.0493594408,
-0.0102849929,
-0.0288454872,
-0.0220948476,
0.026864294,
0.0173781924,
-0.0384978503,
-0.0452441759,
0.0154447071,
0.0111807762,
-0.0186047219,
0.0477196798,
0.010274346,
0.0302797798,
-0.01239172,
-0.0383905284,
0.0007366187,
0.0083007272,
0.0077927113,
0.0551367365,
-0.0002933306,
-0.0072684959,
0.0435684137,
0.0112116123,
0.0150163136,
-0.0009327952,
0.0213778578,
0.0462105796,
0.0158472247,
-0.0550351888,
-0.0022600077,
-0.0269252397,
-0.1212496012,
-0.0083566196,
0.0063883103,
0.0617007874,
0.0289604645,
-0.0298538897,
-0.0393189564,
-0.0056381235,
-0.0236098021,
-0.0143998731,
0.0108075468,
-0.0223721415,
0.0435022153,
0.0244641546,
0.001660358,
0.0181292724,
0.052696187,
-0.0076726628,
0.0341528989,
0.004313156,
0.0198230706,
-0.0615594834,
-0.0124540068,
0.0216387492,
0.0165916756,
-0.0079310602,
0.0105724959,
-0.0020201509,
-0.0523624346,
-0.0271444917,
0.0138070602,
-0.0083482666,
-0.0173279978,
0.0698799193,
0.0323473662,
-0.0295282789,
-0.0178459324,
-0.0270544551,
0.0229653828,
-0.0195691586,
-0.0568655767,
-0.0334347114,
-6.614339204e-33,
-0.0109144961,
-0.0292639472,
0.0366775878,
0.0087310551,
-0.0313592069,
0.0155048324,
-0.0276274551,
0.0258398633,
0.0088646524,
0.0064233686,
-0.0304650813,
-0.0076819751,
0.0138883814,
0.0254098456,
0.0098559912,
-0.0013297552,
0.0325166062,
-0.0130907232,
-0.0590938255,
-0.0018153018,
-0.023649523,
0.0262377691,
-0.0048470683,
-0.0111132562,
0.0146449739,
-0.0049978197,
-0.0408290662,
0.049000483,
0.0195911266,
0.0336021259,
-0.0324373059,
0.0358546004,
-0.0161427222,
-0.0688756332,
-0.0310378075,
0.0460834056,
-0.0186230186,
-0.0236727688,
0.0106695006,
0.0003645568,
-0.1151564494,
-0.0545808636,
0.0341047794,
0.0119544109,
-0.0694286525,
0.0414169505,
0.0097934771,
-0.0124348206,
-0.0071811178,
0.0097601833,
-0.0277219247,
0.0072864504,
-0.0020124088,
-0.057498686,
0.0522860587,
0.0320056565,
-0.0275453273,
0.0138373096,
0.001807763,
0.0266579203,
0.023210384,
0.0361789763,
0.041130092,
0.0312175173,
0.0063428753,
0.0246297475,
0.0319119729,
-0.0074720555,
-0.0082218805,
-0.0219518375,
0.0143348603,
0.0316976756,
0.0276352037,
0.0110827666,
0.0215207413,
0.0052327104,
-0.0539056994,
0.0053482042,
0.0132109681,
-0.0077706007,
0.0452623926,
0.017491132,
-0.0052521047,
-0.0290719606,
-0.0625923052,
0.0020421522,
-0.0489781611,
-0.0127552524,
0.0125507461,
0.0432587899,
-0.0199034996,
-0.0393241309,
0.0343402624,
-0.0091649219,
0.0459385477,
0.005811444,
0.0000668285,
0.0079782223,
0.0218747742,
0.0185966678,
-0.0473686829,
-0.0550001115,
-0.0234093703,
-0.0015008437,
0.0320190527,
0.0240776278,
-0.0246321335,
0.0173084531,
-0.0552732609,
0.0084642479,
-0.0244231243,
0.0365666226,
0.0022463275,
0.0288241543,
0.027165724,
-0.0113389548,
0.005270327,
0.0752743781,
-0.0076901396,
-0.0065144412,
0.0037321099,
0.0128829582,
0.0065373708,
0.0216325317,
-0.0069194967,
0.0153073017,
0.005763561,
0.0322740972,
-0.0072264024,
-0.0257268827,
-0.0212251823,
0.0157735758,
2.952e-7,
-0.0007453282,
0.0724372342,
0.0130914822,
0.064749293,
0.0141474484,
0.0501586385,
-0.0018207997,
0.0060289339,
0.006238169,
-0.0206298716,
0.0074124821,
0.0454625934,
0.0468477644,
0.00478725,
-0.0881567746,
0.0088908402,
-0.0414931439,
0.0159203336,
-0.0874256939,
0.0029388398,
-0.0002886924,
0.1011051238,
0.0003307365,
0.0050930204,
-0.0049291304,
-0.0091523873,
0.0571030751,
-0.0637363866,
0.0018557516,
0.0180442501,
0.0033876237,
0.0017585665,
-0.0202728808,
-0.0003973573,
0.0081821,
0.0164783876,
0.0134729296,
0.0946910903,
0.037871182,
-0.0189766511,
-0.0010619429,
0.0053849132,
-0.0093099484,
-0.0462520532,
0.0344420113,
-0.0186620448,
-0.0175787341,
-0.0827086642,
0.0395403504,
-0.0419644825,
0.0436762832,
-0.0671650916,
0.0133745018,
0.0019536079,
0.0152186705,
0.0063047716,
-0.0195057914,
-0.050049156,
-0.0126444781,
0.0169828888,
-0.0496321432,
-0.0383324362,
-0.0468855649,
0.0480089076,
0.0178160481,
-0.0543216728,
0.0298372824,
2.638129829e-34,
0.0485880338,
0.0052726059,
0.0103760697,
0.0541289635,
0.0305796452,
0.0213835426,
-0.0471429937,
0.0187319107,
0.0351204313,
-0.0896036774,
-0.0428044312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03378v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03378v3 | RoDia: A New Dataset for Romanian Dialect Identification from Speech | 2023-09-06T21:56:24 | 2024-03-20T20:57:51 | Codrut Rotaru, Nicolae-Catalin Ristea, Radu Tudor Ionescu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | We introduce RoDia, the first dataset for Romanian dialect identification
from speech. The RoDia dataset includes a varied compilation of speech samples
from five distinct regions of Romania, covering both urban and rural
environments, totaling 2 hours of manually annotated speech data. Along with
our dataset, we introduce a set of competitive models to be used as baselines
for future research. The top scoring model achieves a macro F1 score of 59.83%
and a micro F1 score of 62.08%, indicating that the task is challenging. We
thus believe that RoDia is a valuable resource that will stimulate research
aiming to address the challenges of Romanian dialect identification. We release
our dataset at https://github.com/codrut2/RoDia. | [
-0.0000208912,
0.0499560237,
-0.0087544657,
0.0624266863,
-0.0111235129,
0.0174991414,
0.025036402,
-0.0259721708,
-0.0237081554,
0.023723552,
-0.0535931401,
-0.0298827067,
0.0100921169,
-0.011552386,
0.0264515858,
-0.0318497382,
0.0657268167,
-0.0420489125,
-0.0454600714,
0.0142025314,
0.0303111523,
-0.0134259546,
-0.0314012244,
-0.0105109084,
0.0314626582,
0.0225344859,
0.0164303202,
0.0170346424,
0.0278891791,
0.0332288668,
0.0173692089,
0.0257179253,
-0.0057193357,
0.0649330989,
0.0000014592,
-0.0226252414,
-0.0248773899,
-0.0352669209,
-0.0489705764,
-0.0137889627,
0.0390900783,
0.0207578335,
-0.0059909518,
-0.0040863669,
0.0083531132,
-0.0749484077,
0.078536272,
0.0037736592,
0.0289249066,
0.0241722818,
-0.0097006802,
-0.0293082017,
-0.0394486897,
-0.0207230151,
-0.0734718069,
0.0371700712,
0.0113101816,
-0.050643906,
-0.0410870165,
-0.0668114722,
0.0199428517,
0.0644105598,
-0.065237835,
0.0524542145,
-0.0399301685,
-0.024349276,
-0.0945791453,
-0.0103246281,
-0.0078134183,
0.0454325862,
0.0022934363,
-0.016047705,
0.0223009493,
0.0510878079,
-0.0466507226,
0.0277815666,
-0.0198193341,
-0.0101531632,
-0.0336588696,
-0.0088582067,
0.0034164269,
0.0340102986,
0.0060359635,
-0.0264984723,
0.0323422402,
0.0613079295,
0.0126362862,
0.0152692432,
0.0346272253,
-0.025698062,
0.031817887,
0.0145255597,
0.0168993399,
0.0213788282,
-0.0277569499,
-0.0039632036,
0.0043762927,
0.0214375444,
0.012987569,
0.0008434228,
-0.007174891,
-0.0049698655,
-0.0541217402,
0.0257729888,
-0.0402906351,
0.0263439231,
-0.0002002519,
0.0230134204,
-0.0136996591,
-0.0266786851,
-0.0371554755,
0.0344023444,
-0.0401094742,
-0.0262292046,
0.0234501325,
0.0311172605,
-0.0330315195,
0.0008177251,
0.0279498268,
0.048984576,
0.0182758495,
-0.0236897171,
-0.0199997816,
-0.019181069,
0.0236695986,
0.0679754391,
-0.0176364183,
0.0513336137,
-0.0745894462,
-0.0790793672,
-0.0088724205,
0.015209279,
0.0459092334,
0.0081238747,
0.0330744199,
-0.0173739269,
0.0057261563,
-0.0155203035,
-0.0482461229,
-0.0132806627,
-0.0142430132,
-0.0745986775,
-0.0142956795,
-0.0459554344,
0.0116027482,
0.0069188126,
0.0382692851,
-0.0696637258,
-0.0358341709,
-0.0236152671,
0.0299045388,
0.0487671234,
-0.0625270456,
0.0172785483,
0.028511757,
-0.0053929235,
0.0259868205,
0.057801526,
-0.0109552657,
0.0428419672,
0.0493612252,
-0.0061546564,
0.0111691058,
0.0388071314,
0.0056624035,
0.0421658009,
-0.0491596907,
0.0129474066,
-0.01115645,
-0.018899912,
0.0269637667,
0.0554182306,
0.0334873013,
-0.0238581784,
0.0693103075,
0.0298869144,
0.0339837261,
0.0189617332,
0.0180746615,
0.0109292371,
0.0453883931,
-0.007295575,
0.0682359263,
-0.0652649105,
0.012696133,
0.0149124572,
-0.0136276325,
0.0481053181,
-0.0338748358,
0.0216375161,
-0.0242980998,
-0.0403807871,
-0.0033390967,
-0.0019223954,
0.0833374336,
-0.009364442,
0.010562541,
0.0115237711,
0.0290814769,
-0.0343433395,
0.0109068519,
-0.0413333327,
0.0676897317,
0.0069070617,
-0.0168162119,
-0.0836919546,
-0.0034520095,
-0.0118265208,
0.02193073,
0.0172045901,
0.0185109563,
-0.0650753304,
0.0229596309,
-0.059735015,
0.0485311374,
0.0363489687,
0.0186152086,
0.0507328361,
-0.0647532344,
-0.0095991502,
-0.0035457108,
0.010615116,
0.0167750288,
-0.0016490901,
-0.0017988695,
0.0055368138,
0.0220048949,
0.0421165191,
0.0034043512,
0.0315879025,
-0.016986113,
-0.0200619195,
0.0314528607,
0.0001530538,
0.0965556577,
0.0337290429,
0.0798046365,
-0.0508683287,
0.0410957411,
-0.0019742509,
-0.0308255572,
0.0337475054,
0.0032432408,
-0.0530619882,
0.0753715634,
-0.0089266291,
0.0373380296,
-0.0157579612,
0.0307802036,
-0.0383360386,
0.0425459966,
0.0211699735,
0.0149989026,
0.006517435,
0.004653058,
0.0818068087,
-0.0195825379,
0.0379491709,
-0.0874597356,
-0.0300252754,
-0.0247930046,
-0.0426493213,
-0.0084861014,
-0.0515435822,
-0.0208664089,
0.0082956115,
0.0170209203,
-0.063631475,
0.0168226864,
-0.0547862388,
0.0556490012,
-0.0121643227,
0.0053404416,
-0.0233908594,
-0.0443863757,
-0.0245446432,
-0.0209305454,
-0.0156744104,
0.0006526362,
-0.0120449616,
0.0179966744,
-0.0172022749,
-0.0368208736,
0.0121546146,
-0.0102739064,
-0.0155306086,
-0.0318656079,
-0.0101093873,
-0.0278580133,
-0.0067670131,
-0.0274693146,
0.0458292663,
-0.0305546094,
-0.0343048014,
-0.0619185716,
0.0085538188,
0.0643841699,
0.0224212483,
-0.0904247686,
-0.0019636124,
0.0532422438,
-0.0331368968,
0.0541111156,
-0.0186447799,
-0.0241299905,
0.0174972154,
-0.0451444611,
-0.036122378,
-0.044626113,
0.0320457704,
-0.0030328189,
0.0121084834,
0.0040771174,
0.0348844454,
-0.0358252339,
0.0562419631,
-0.0017725395,
0.0072764843,
-0.0186620597,
0.0735333711,
0.0048520733,
-0.0135864206,
0.034110114,
-0.0935103297,
-0.019883208,
-0.0172830466,
-0.0633628666,
-0.0395429209,
0.0041753394,
-0.0199151114,
-0.0120123755,
-0.0088751195,
-0.0219379012,
-0.0192921795,
-0.0018709106,
0.0059529641,
-0.0323886052,
0.0719419792,
-0.0425395072,
-0.0198632479,
-0.0361998901,
-0.0358056687,
0.0095454762,
-0.0443721898,
-0.0536784083,
0.0156102376,
0.0170503668,
-0.0203960091,
0.0422414504,
0.0457471907,
-0.01230508,
0.0561590418,
-0.046525225,
0.0707414076,
-0.0006775784,
0.0775545612,
0.035170678,
0.0240872689,
0.0092269015,
0.0059537375,
-0.0022311278,
-0.0288658775,
0.062047448,
0.0134110907,
-0.0294593219,
-0.0286374297,
0.003530123,
-0.0087513728,
-0.0098712053,
-0.0469321534,
-0.0086703384,
0.004230178,
-0.0358067341,
0.0747583807,
-0.0083059622,
-0.0245174002,
-0.0376142077,
-0.0057817451,
0.043380145,
0.0085829748,
0.0194957796,
-0.0232084244,
-0.0306462739,
0.0389567986,
0.0343721807,
-0.0123894997,
0.0065182778,
-0.0238649063,
-0.0437263139,
0.0101664886,
0.0080398312,
-0.0289380737,
-0.0338641591,
-0.0237660725,
0.010461743,
-0.0886122137,
-0.0147068193,
-0.0027148242,
-0.0389347821,
-0.0123720933,
0.0664665699,
-0.0608693734,
-0.0796418712,
0.0180807915,
-0.0090269204,
0.0807788298,
-0.0238208901,
-0.0095666703,
-0.0692344233,
-0.0117371632,
0.0023200023,
-0.0329295695,
-0.051658731,
-0.0262460615,
0.0590835921,
0.0418314263,
-0.0234727431,
-0.0018535566,
-0.0008234362,
-0.0322545357,
0.0095272604,
0.0258947555,
0.0327444933,
-0.0169407763,
0.0135710025,
0.0616124757,
0.0151153235,
0.0369243287,
0.0234637652,
0.0341875628,
0.0159047116,
0.0205018092,
0.0109700682,
-0.0304353926,
-0.0065186988,
-0.0401614569,
0.0271690432,
0.0016631956,
-0.0789514631,
-0.027422579,
-0.0191349015,
0.0264639463,
-0.0002684968,
0.0401616953,
-0.0001709585,
0.0114885801,
0.0457242392,
-0.0635984689,
0.0387669019,
0.0050658402,
0.0053343251,
-0.0472978391,
-0.0312417131,
0.0860449523,
-0.0526881032,
-0.0426443145,
0.0342084691,
-0.1048298627,
-0.0225245971,
0.0427742004,
-0.0001191886,
0.0242618714,
0.039388366,
-0.0021481714,
-0.0434407331,
0.0063763298,
-0.0391776413,
0.036671076,
-0.0303413495,
0.0500646718,
-0.0234795734,
-0.0285000782,
0.033473365,
-0.0182549804,
0.0347910672,
0.0273615178,
-0.0694695562,
-0.0616746619,
0.0124456044,
-0.0054573584,
0.0055311937,
0.0703806728,
-0.0031013421,
-0.0335485637,
-0.0741173774,
0.0259617455,
0.0066793761,
0.0267792698,
0.0071895747,
-0.0011839346,
0.0424529128,
0.0033887818,
-0.0519211851,
-0.0030728329,
-0.027987184,
-0.0061075441,
-0.0141316243,
0.0232775938,
0.0355479643,
0.0686725527,
0.0220286902,
-0.0024283379,
-0.0330928937,
0.0694069043,
0.0260725562,
0.0383435488,
-0.0206438918,
-0.0027932792,
0.0013131385,
-0.0284278169,
-0.0193198659,
0.0253149681,
0.0160554461,
0.037032444,
-0.0211132355,
-0.0217370875,
0.0265737716,
-0.0177507829,
0.0817124322,
-0.0188600626,
0.0158166066,
-0.0348936841,
0.0155168558,
-0.0166074745,
0.0139136277,
-0.0041123857,
-0.0172637608,
-0.0600659363,
0.0454153307,
0.0425676703,
0.0214412436,
0.0323674269,
0.0113785723,
-0.0139905084,
-0.0215612482,
-0.02069607,
0.0039758747,
-0.0445828475,
-0.0411741883,
-0.05688335,
-0.0451079682,
-0.0612512268,
0.0345652252,
0.01130303,
0.0049351761,
0.0289095379,
-0.018040536,
-0.0129642291,
0.0010208722,
0.0087356837,
-0.0440517738,
-0.0026949819,
-0.022889914,
0.0329249352,
-0.0200336426,
-5.425786948e-33,
-0.0369558744,
0.0337435231,
-0.020007208,
-0.002447932,
-0.0010413579,
-0.0269775148,
-0.0127091259,
0.0141109796,
-0.0248013064,
-0.0096672159,
0.0010906541,
-0.0085669104,
0.0372548364,
-0.0028196338,
-0.0091298642,
-0.0394826233,
0.0340083502,
0.0042500943,
0.0011391133,
0.0289594475,
0.0463047251,
0.0019665209,
0.064551644,
-0.0658890903,
-0.0349691808,
-0.0448583849,
-0.0339687653,
0.0407045037,
0.0143913701,
0.0831493959,
-0.0346167721,
0.0530619062,
0.0159879103,
0.0133309057,
0.002254186,
0.0232057367,
-0.0190840513,
-0.0032412719,
-0.0089389123,
0.1010763943,
0.0003114034,
-0.0404536761,
-0.005913456,
-0.0049350061,
-0.0211052652,
0.0027977207,
0.0371861123,
-0.0419444367,
0.0304574948,
-0.0058220322,
-0.0245802589,
0.0243206508,
-0.0098410966,
-0.042424649,
0.0938482434,
0.060361959,
0.0155785335,
-0.038105201,
-0.0664186776,
0.0424172059,
0.0362965614,
0.0512498058,
0.0474187844,
0.0279510114,
-0.0284252986,
-0.0024823237,
0.054765597,
-0.0724714473,
0.0452879854,
-0.0293634124,
0.0398420393,
0.0126280496,
0.0286325961,
0.0333034359,
-0.0004906177,
-0.0393429324,
-0.0635267124,
-0.0333744101,
0.1033593267,
-0.0059411009,
-0.0190809015,
-0.057811372,
-0.0346656442,
-0.0007750186,
-0.0188551489,
-0.0771377906,
-0.0086518666,
-0.0074295267,
0.0453991182,
-0.0211206712,
0.0101895863,
0.0444106646,
0.0355692096,
-0.0265253708,
-0.0149063552,
-0.0180181954,
-0.0062813023,
0.0110746184,
-0.0287132189,
0.0397493616,
-0.0245144218,
-0.0426260531,
0.0083392682,
0.050010182,
0.043378938,
-0.0235857908,
0.0667392239,
0.0466050431,
-0.0333828703,
0.0325414725,
-0.0046289093,
0.0306160357,
-0.0356478281,
0.088104941,
0.0315819532,
-0.0046455399,
0.0079675615,
0.0392853692,
0.0233046487,
0.0259269867,
0.0027668793,
-0.0248640589,
0.0041099312,
0.0132652046,
-0.0047707646,
0.0099266358,
-0.0126238065,
0.011498333,
-0.0070941527,
0.0329514965,
0.0498427674,
-0.0191976018,
2.189e-7,
-0.0190647095,
0.034858346,
0.0049844878,
-0.0264810789,
0.0189162828,
-0.0350224189,
-0.0783749893,
-0.0369007476,
-0.0084680188,
0.050924588,
0.0340248756,
-0.0304265004,
0.0941036716,
0.0230505057,
-0.0751240179,
-0.0215586666,
-0.0749478489,
-0.023074748,
-0.0053387629,
-0.0169350728,
-0.0218849219,
0.1161294803,
0.0117014879,
-0.0016300436,
-0.0029325872,
-0.0125259934,
0.0073824283,
-0.0006140574,
0.0066254912,
0.0900112242,
0.0123103661,
0.009167145,
-0.0302402992,
-0.0389359668,
0.0133475838,
0.0384341292,
-0.0211449452,
0.0849325433,
-0.0053193914,
-0.0484910049,
0.0272984449,
0.0057317433,
-0.0334222093,
0.0047553438,
0.0542385355,
0.0189297013,
0.0138091249,
-0.0198376849,
0.0085731568,
0.0277140979,
-0.0038623605,
-0.011796359,
-0.0159878414,
0.0109518375,
0.0104274666,
-0.0356563218,
-0.0512602367,
-0.0443608463,
0.0147391055,
0.0432169288,
-0.064328894,
-0.0232246816,
0.0563168935,
-0.0294729415,
-0.0164781325,
-0.0743739456,
0.0122687407,
1.587058226e-34,
-0.0002537322,
-0.001338414,
-0.0311983991,
0.0187511556,
-0.013260995,
-0.0510712937,
-0.0494025722,
0.0360552929,
-0.0058553182,
-0.0191163495,
0.0045387875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03340v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03340v1 | Parameter Efficient Audio Captioning With Faithful Guidance Using Audio-text Shared Latent Representation | 2023-09-06T19:42:52 | 2023-09-06T19:42:52 | Arvind Krishna Sridhar, Yinyi Guo, Erik Visser, Rehana Mahfuz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.MM, cs.SD | There has been significant research on developing pretrained transformer
architectures for multimodal-to-text generation tasks. Albeit performance
improvements, such models are frequently overparameterized, hence suffer from
hallucination and large memory footprint making them challenging to deploy on
edge devices. In this paper, we address both these issues for the application
of automated audio captioning. First, we propose a data augmentation technique
for generating hallucinated audio captions and show that similarity based on an
audio-text shared latent space is suitable for detecting hallucination. Then,
we propose a parameter efficient inference time faithful decoding algorithm
that enables smaller audio captioning models with performance equivalent to
larger models trained with more data. During the beam decoding step, the
smaller model utilizes an audio-text shared latent representation to
semantically align the generated text with corresponding input audio. Faithful
guidance is introduced into the beam probability by incorporating the cosine
similarity between latent representation projections of greedy rolled out
intermediate beams and audio clip. We show the efficacy of our algorithm on
benchmark datasets and evaluate the proposed scheme against baselines using
conventional audio captioning and semantic similarity metrics while
illustrating tradeoffs between performance and complexity. | [
-0.0099503994,
0.0515359156,
0.0165407043,
0.0018915191,
0.0130673517,
-0.0073325485,
0.040555045,
-0.0371909961,
-0.0799209028,
-0.0334313363,
-0.0640516207,
-0.0182935726,
0.0099243158,
0.0296179075,
-0.001354531,
-0.0910727233,
0.0193012487,
-0.03096346,
-0.0458912626,
-0.0291387923,
0.0031741541,
0.0028055869,
-0.0524368547,
0.0335022025,
-0.0499861985,
0.004679828,
0.011097366,
0.0169301275,
0.0070894626,
-0.0287967026,
-0.0237861536,
0.042831257,
0.0544356927,
0.0322578028,
0.0000019801,
0.0061454084,
-0.0229015052,
0.0010795597,
0.0403225161,
0.0083870217,
0.0629591793,
-0.0614314228,
-0.0087647364,
0.0227462947,
0.0017165472,
-0.0485568345,
0.0850859508,
0.0710913092,
0.0571877845,
0.0319602489,
-0.0217519235,
-0.0714286864,
0.0054221805,
-0.0096503096,
0.0433616564,
-0.0016621519,
-0.0295930356,
0.0292537939,
-0.0021760149,
0.0082830628,
-0.0251514763,
0.0762480274,
0.0118032815,
0.0214122124,
0.0129134748,
0.0430310033,
-0.0458885357,
-0.0209123213,
-0.0220891591,
0.0607755519,
0.0314288251,
-0.0189991519,
-0.0046879509,
0.0077489242,
-0.0312901177,
0.003117726,
-0.0282404516,
0.0418644175,
0.0067043086,
0.0141959023,
-0.0224952493,
0.0724358186,
0.0247185454,
-0.0551327541,
-0.0188434552,
-0.0280770157,
0.0510246344,
-0.008894966,
-0.0220362805,
-0.0163509436,
-0.0622145943,
-0.0046490831,
0.0360041521,
-0.0143606886,
-0.0356576368,
-0.0186892021,
-0.0907212421,
-0.0551768281,
-0.0166117493,
-0.029661091,
0.0208662171,
0.0371543281,
-0.0615002513,
0.068765007,
-0.0193733126,
0.0179016311,
-0.0251891166,
0.0369731039,
-0.0564959422,
-0.0058251745,
-0.0439714864,
-0.0186580885,
-0.0587795153,
-0.0014390916,
-0.0043420983,
-0.0762257874,
-0.0379958861,
-0.0204400625,
-0.0284735616,
0.0215869844,
-0.0080500133,
0.0532462001,
-0.0274280645,
-0.0252531078,
0.0575325415,
0.0321572907,
-0.0041629309,
0.0267893504,
-0.0152569953,
-0.0497152321,
-0.0332544595,
0.0639710054,
0.0317125618,
-0.0084480196,
0.0207113363,
0.0600787178,
-0.0180614069,
-0.0495349653,
0.0151364598,
-0.0238602795,
-0.05599254,
-0.0150429839,
0.0116920676,
-0.0522770584,
0.0695130751,
0.0104114413,
-0.0201275386,
-0.0203887578,
0.0158852823,
0.0242532026,
0.0022574819,
0.0906577706,
-0.0220638998,
0.0270544924,
0.0387655683,
0.0318180434,
-0.0437745117,
0.0192803871,
0.0620274171,
0.0281964894,
0.0079535488,
-0.0264069159,
0.0324647091,
0.0472410247,
0.0026232474,
0.0027335116,
-0.0060139904,
-0.0449881628,
0.0041739037,
0.0310341381,
0.0548643768,
0.0509949699,
-0.0129291369,
-0.0022993684,
0.069802925,
0.0191000402,
0.0179240424,
0.0085336706,
0.0367858112,
0.0359030738,
-0.0258552078,
0.0099151637,
-0.0143394032,
0.0714497194,
0.0305625275,
0.026257351,
0.0843015909,
-0.0013795482,
-0.0348722488,
0.006266261,
0.0045016874,
-0.0429024957,
-0.0162319839,
-0.0327171832,
0.0114469258,
0.027715629,
-0.0715690106,
0.1030917913,
0.0035476219,
-0.045342721,
-0.00678065,
0.0013877131,
-0.0252706353,
0.026512254,
0.0438251533,
-0.0296040233,
0.0017085925,
-0.0231986735,
0.0366048217,
0.0387870446,
0.0243770406,
0.0094919447,
0.012173336,
-0.0481475778,
-0.0269234758,
-0.008257742,
0.0038602133,
0.0368371457,
-0.005823697,
0.0331604965,
0.0255486686,
-0.0031289619,
-0.0201206692,
0.0154177435,
0.0352210589,
-0.0389127769,
0.0006527954,
0.0067160623,
0.0308133755,
0.0281054806,
-0.0449558608,
0.0182847641,
-0.0000151315,
-0.0422858968,
-0.0190002564,
0.0725615025,
-0.1111980528,
-0.0222287234,
0.0056012641,
-0.0801798999,
0.0334940255,
0.0133269262,
0.0100523531,
-0.0508049056,
0.0590059347,
-0.062537998,
0.0292905364,
-0.0483957939,
0.0160072949,
0.0178796649,
0.0361907668,
0.0505056158,
0.0257920306,
0.010088806,
-0.0098272776,
0.0243215486,
0.016473433,
0.0167994238,
-0.0059424532,
-0.0618531182,
0.0090530179,
0.0099215424,
-0.0011843503,
-0.009278181,
-0.0318804383,
-0.008993566,
-0.0002694648,
-0.0859374404,
-0.0034767629,
-0.0210127868,
-0.0330759361,
0.0242986567,
0.006677785,
0.0274104141,
-0.0140585052,
-0.0147001129,
-0.0108146342,
0.0379169844,
0.0126394276,
-0.0342326015,
0.0108851353,
-0.0561956465,
0.0116113937,
0.0238779765,
0.0205256343,
0.0128668547,
-0.0053248154,
-0.0347644351,
-0.0452045426,
0.0204436351,
0.0159682781,
-0.0057580359,
0.0028417881,
0.0008834597,
-0.0006039058,
0.0236770585,
0.0488070771,
-0.017845042,
0.0268394463,
0.0271378215,
0.0454607718,
0.0040493282,
-0.0021922218,
-0.0075537339,
-0.0085945092,
-0.0153595116,
-0.005554874,
-0.0131809451,
-0.00808529,
0.026855452,
0.0627787188,
0.0523054413,
-0.0511334352,
-0.0230939407,
-0.0180404764,
-0.0272230059,
0.0058264197,
-0.0132108554,
-0.0340934433,
-0.0096516153,
-0.0138567733,
-0.0558882393,
0.0382352434,
-0.0570674874,
-0.0572227202,
-0.0064858817,
-0.0087537225,
0.0107447514,
0.0676384792,
0.0041776933,
0.0447716601,
-0.0497717708,
-0.0401579738,
-0.0168293063,
0.0510923937,
0.030433882,
-0.0399051867,
0.005452489,
-0.0117890444,
-0.0088212453,
-0.0040305192,
-0.0075518065,
-0.0326444842,
-0.0305071082,
0.0008014631,
-0.032232292,
-0.026560599,
0.0041232612,
-0.0667529777,
0.036669232,
0.0174100958,
0.044377625,
-0.0140267499,
0.003653805,
-0.0336283967,
0.0328677148,
0.0246023368,
0.028242629,
-0.0224655941,
-0.0206132866,
0.0162724648,
0.0302202441,
0.0336419232,
0.0148178209,
-0.0805935934,
0.0117189186,
0.019190615,
0.0231759492,
-0.0234943125,
0.0213225149,
0.0629509389,
-0.0282322373,
0.0201174244,
0.0991814286,
0.0080103697,
-0.0465415306,
0.0129151829,
0.0272647664,
0.0266016871,
0.0080761099,
-0.020233281,
-0.0822135583,
-0.0575953349,
-0.0114190178,
0.0415921286,
0.0528265461,
0.0213297158,
-0.0263962466,
-0.0411229879,
0.0405154042,
0.0360636376,
0.0044705803,
-0.0625123307,
0.0113916248,
-0.0287717842,
0.0136350151,
0.0161381029,
-0.015524759,
-0.0010982935,
0.0098359697,
0.0243439637,
-0.0097629428,
-0.0418590419,
-0.0086154798,
-0.0559124053,
0.0820513666,
0.0587071478,
0.0178843252,
-0.0025416731,
-0.0545160286,
-0.0364108272,
-0.0100900661,
0.0047328435,
0.0402246863,
0.0509736091,
-0.0085020633,
-0.007966822,
0.0528104454,
0.0448505692,
-0.0251661632,
-0.0234283507,
0.0045410423,
0.0387926139,
-0.0296743307,
-0.0000268456,
-0.0025247957,
0.0816072226,
0.0148861492,
0.0907137319,
0.012022946,
-0.0063863755,
0.0009908772,
0.0353349932,
0.0440839529,
-0.059476871,
-0.0167875793,
0.0185820051,
0.0201004855,
-0.0386730954,
-0.0415161364,
-0.0083052469,
0.0156700611,
0.0206746552,
0.0157698635,
-0.0104407733,
-0.0308504216,
0.0087753208,
-0.0514108986,
0.0309324395,
-0.0213897824,
0.0010449524,
-0.0254698079,
-0.0310824215,
0.0494507924,
-0.0529185943,
-0.0146329496,
0.0451011546,
-0.0875377879,
-0.0233614743,
0.0123238107,
0.0140228607,
0.0168968476,
0.0562557317,
0.0043710726,
0.0040740673,
0.0474377759,
0.0318517685,
-0.0289278179,
0.0451329723,
0.0372509435,
-0.0045801369,
-0.0245752856,
0.0065065091,
-0.051470954,
0.033365041,
-0.019329397,
0.0332668908,
0.0254874509,
-0.0445540063,
0.0187322553,
-0.0256783385,
0.0092703775,
-0.0660114735,
0.055639632,
-0.0383456387,
-0.0076112677,
0.0015832672,
0.0186923537,
-0.0441725105,
0.0231248401,
0.0304698776,
0.0070021846,
-0.0372593515,
-0.0004172762,
0.0050915596,
-0.0114148818,
-0.0367354788,
0.0066361185,
0.0085703414,
-0.0678326488,
0.0052596745,
-0.0066037001,
0.0070117973,
0.024139842,
0.014439079,
0.0035707732,
-0.0207488965,
0.0359288901,
-0.000724338,
-0.0114176804,
-0.0178437158,
0.0668356121,
-0.0122541888,
-0.0388113856,
-0.0423715264,
0.0255359802,
0.0307014585,
-0.0044657225,
0.0580901913,
-0.0284753051,
0.0218326375,
-0.0082402127,
0.0479624718,
-0.0028006178,
-0.049380254,
0.0216067918,
-0.0164834149,
-0.000558864,
0.0172341689,
0.0526223257,
-0.0602547787,
0.022952836,
-0.0155208092,
-0.0190644842,
-0.0335108116,
-0.0392219797,
-0.0389119312,
0.0069936025,
-0.0346954763,
-0.0133475503,
0.0083275437,
-0.0393278375,
0.0146954013,
-0.026694674,
-0.0093945591,
0.0139743853,
0.0543161929,
0.0241920948,
-0.0227777306,
0.0125906477,
0.029571496,
-0.0447622389,
0.0301853903,
0.0203049667,
0.0019149868,
-5.679824134e-33,
-0.0409695916,
0.008091501,
0.0135795437,
-0.0127792936,
-0.0340216719,
-0.020054955,
-0.0337219425,
0.0203329604,
0.0444620736,
-0.0246158279,
0.0247734301,
-0.0168459415,
0.0209642351,
0.0539082848,
0.0122424988,
-0.0176412389,
0.0717455149,
-0.0395185128,
-0.030054016,
0.0540164784,
0.0436187573,
0.0011930717,
0.0353503451,
-0.0801401809,
-0.0192944147,
-0.0227951277,
-0.0319554396,
-0.0494734012,
0.0610605888,
0.0131985759,
-0.0401484407,
0.0279780347,
-0.0140327672,
-0.0570238605,
-0.0224326551,
0.0131435692,
-0.0555153824,
0.0043223668,
-0.009964603,
0.0587765202,
-0.0392795131,
-0.0150204524,
-0.000387977,
-0.0137550458,
-0.0455321893,
-0.0177249461,
0.0308613405,
-0.0081285564,
0.0123773711,
-0.0151816374,
-0.0697006956,
-0.0077247121,
-0.0154521577,
-0.024851175,
0.025963977,
0.0489090085,
0.0140633015,
0.0289476886,
-0.0873269066,
0.0348723941,
-0.0417369045,
0.0118761901,
0.0716229156,
0.0045962972,
-0.0086304015,
0.0742632449,
0.0392955281,
-0.1054115742,
-0.0232870709,
0.0454274751,
-0.0019544647,
0.0282058418,
0.021316519,
-0.0051088622,
0.067434974,
-0.0174846519,
0.0093776817,
0.025354661,
-0.0812234357,
-0.0199226737,
0.0718967095,
0.0326353274,
-0.0124613242,
0.0125055937,
-0.0296178404,
-0.0008301547,
-0.0239367392,
-0.0768650249,
0.0547078811,
0.0396214277,
-0.027709404,
0.0204644706,
0.0800137892,
-0.0025549349,
0.0315009132,
-0.0193603896,
-0.0318730734,
0.0423919261,
-0.0296412539,
-0.0122914854,
0.0185994413,
-0.0033308298,
0.1155654714,
-0.0323502198,
0.0509683453,
0.0018198499,
0.0067114914,
0.0660871416,
-0.0589007959,
-0.0040755286,
-0.0048608887,
-0.0139915859,
-0.027156204,
0.0036789118,
0.0490986742,
0.0359935239,
-0.0380540416,
-0.0088079572,
-0.0260624476,
0.0440221913,
-0.0440219678,
-0.0448830351,
-0.0273723509,
0.0040459819,
-0.0311570559,
0.0537280664,
-0.0330036134,
-0.0672328323,
0.0039377138,
-0.0739885494,
-0.0481653176,
0.0260127205,
2.797e-7,
-0.0134893851,
0.0027832582,
0.0315296613,
0.0045786249,
0.0262243524,
0.0193519704,
0.0043971883,
0.0507757664,
-0.0243502017,
-0.058514636,
0.0421564989,
0.0273355301,
0.058401756,
0.0108161494,
-0.0591707937,
-0.0211606007,
-0.0790990517,
0.031029433,
-0.0401656441,
-0.0248673502,
0.0879961401,
0.0831884742,
-0.0108465627,
-0.0383721776,
0.0319744162,
-0.0503269993,
0.0603705086,
0.005959121,
-0.0027737063,
-0.0278539173,
0.0250283126,
0.0185723063,
-0.0591603182,
0.0205642302,
-0.0321795642,
-0.0323415324,
0.0663107187,
0.0072267605,
0.0180144235,
-0.0606376342,
-0.0604559258,
0.0460175797,
-0.0284717977,
0.0198869053,
0.06697914,
-0.0394390114,
-0.0245730653,
0.0125545925,
-0.0396087095,
0.0057030092,
-0.0111295525,
-0.0039231749,
-0.0060599004,
-0.0091732647,
0.0526265055,
0.0428706184,
-0.0322383977,
-0.0498395972,
0.0135107636,
0.0010071483,
-0.0499734394,
-0.0122476378,
-0.0500567853,
-0.0199051183,
0.0345221311,
-0.0531314388,
-0.0261905417,
2.564558117e-34,
0.0074579176,
-0.030930398,
0.0220948737,
-0.0399314277,
-0.0097629698,
0.0071504824,
0.0481035188,
-0.0125649665,
-0.0252084881,
-0.0563529097,
-0.0434337333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03175v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03175v2 | Gender-specific Machine Translation with Large Language Models | 2023-09-06T17:24:06 | 2024-04-16T19:16:46 | Eduardo Sánchez, Pierre Andrews, Pontus Stenetorp, Mikel Artetxe, Marta R. Costa-jussà | cs.CL | cs.CL | While machine translation (MT) systems have seen significant improvements, it
is still common for translations to reflect societal biases, such as gender
bias. Decoder-only Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated potential in
MT, albeit with performance slightly lagging behind traditional encoder-decoder
Neural Machine Translation (NMT) systems. However, LLMs offer a unique
advantage: the ability to control the properties of the output through prompts.
In this study, we leverage this flexibility to explore LLaMa's capability to
produce gender-specific translations. Our results indicate that LLaMa can
generate gender-specific translations with translation accuracy and gender bias
comparable to NLLB, a state-of-the-art multilingual NMT system. Furthermore,
our experiments reveal that LLaMa's gender-specific translations rely on
coreference resolution to determine gender, showing higher gender variance in
gender-ambiguous datasets but maintaining consistency in less ambiguous
contexts. This research investigates the potential and challenges of using LLMs
for gender-specific translations as an instance of the controllability of
outputs offered by LLMs. | [
0.0377502069,
0.067567274,
-0.0154137947,
0.036455337,
0.0066241678,
0.0138668995,
0.0445666686,
-0.0130710853,
-0.0178954732,
-0.005893555,
-0.0315060541,
-0.0666510016,
0.0280405097,
-0.0049075736,
0.0209020432,
-0.0227107294,
0.0004399292,
-0.0086297709,
0.0039386316,
-0.0383384787,
-0.0047512124,
0.0300097745,
0.0512493514,
0.0348950811,
0.0246724188,
-0.024305081,
0.0191373732,
0.0478472002,
-0.0035417983,
0.0090494053,
0.0493187346,
0.0334783942,
0.0002863785,
0.0459240787,
0.0000020399,
-0.0573860146,
0.0157908238,
0.0203843284,
-0.0032828159,
0.0420092493,
0.0330621153,
-0.0610096082,
-0.0245424695,
0.0183758326,
0.0102731669,
-0.0097223725,
0.0469474271,
0.0052675726,
0.0694756061,
0.0287660118,
-0.0086067133,
0.0086268373,
-0.0538004413,
-0.0828197449,
-0.0344273336,
-0.0464920439,
-0.0104619162,
-0.0280151125,
-0.0430760719,
0.0158440098,
-0.0232978873,
0.0412169322,
0.0298011508,
-0.0176548809,
-0.0346713886,
0.0224166326,
-0.0084816916,
-0.070296973,
-0.0073677101,
0.0738583878,
-0.0177448448,
0.0231060442,
0.0136776129,
-0.0057017505,
-0.0177850984,
-0.0336471125,
-0.0383446775,
0.038168069,
-0.0133313164,
0.0018397568,
-0.0078811105,
0.0030281588,
0.0412549451,
0.0435693376,
-0.0526595861,
0.0713889822,
0.0174534302,
-0.0077931536,
0.0091738114,
0.0176795367,
0.0088394275,
-0.0525376946,
0.0664701089,
-0.0053014592,
-0.0044161691,
-0.0041602748,
-0.0359340198,
-0.020061072,
0.015311216,
-0.0742175281,
0.0161507633,
0.0678670332,
0.0028383853,
0.0204126798,
-0.010484837,
0.075417228,
-0.0477036871,
0.0370506197,
-0.053385932,
-0.0631723553,
0.005242995,
0.0072974744,
-0.0296367928,
-0.0104235709,
-0.0636269003,
0.0386639051,
-0.0394365825,
0.0049324604,
-0.0116352644,
0.0031089247,
0.0190419517,
-0.0025701122,
-0.0383320525,
-0.0300213639,
0.0074356096,
0.0756245106,
-0.0238298643,
0.0026066247,
-0.0164854899,
-0.0746267736,
-0.0182210151,
-0.0029580574,
-0.0108717103,
-0.0318691842,
-0.0029812423,
0.0537031367,
-0.0156547111,
-0.0254138559,
-0.0050232699,
-0.0167097226,
-0.0411751904,
-0.0691534951,
0.0133641064,
-0.0626359433,
0.0658081472,
0.0568046346,
0.0261210389,
-0.073458612,
0.0097824028,
0.0160092264,
0.0087432219,
0.061144717,
0.0904526711,
-0.0030293448,
0.0712469071,
0.006433846,
-0.0010324471,
0.0858765841,
0.0645791888,
0.0496822037,
0.0177596752,
0.0269817058,
-0.0409540646,
0.0736475885,
0.0380211398,
0.0454259925,
-0.0375390425,
0.0197148509,
-0.0046796734,
0.0514517725,
0.0798520297,
0.0343125686,
0.0181116387,
-0.0018872046,
0.0722436011,
0.0427219979,
0.0040147826,
0.0480831303,
0.0196785908,
-0.012250538,
-0.005836945,
-0.0156459082,
-0.0656668022,
0.0257148873,
0.0086894333,
-0.0459291078,
0.014366298,
0.0458649099,
-0.0170101915,
-0.0580839887,
0.0117414529,
0.0040517133,
-0.0064689084,
0.0017876211,
0.0271306094,
0.0142081464,
-0.01758481,
0.0576561131,
-0.0024615796,
-0.0549622811,
0.0303210262,
-0.0505955294,
-0.0126671204,
0.0544505157,
0.0187062174,
0.0078427559,
-0.0422668308,
-0.0314976983,
-0.0151879173,
0.0589232333,
0.0493642241,
0.024487488,
0.0372027643,
-0.0581083968,
0.0002589501,
0.0322070904,
0.0151031082,
0.0420351923,
0.0508375987,
0.0615563579,
0.0491006486,
-0.0273969341,
-0.0716192573,
0.0060099731,
-0.011014726,
-0.0297330469,
0.0702284947,
-0.0082768165,
0.0284155626,
0.016002629,
-0.0203939006,
-0.0154439881,
-0.0176023524,
-0.052411966,
-0.0360205621,
0.0173882432,
-0.0690601692,
-0.0123696635,
-0.0093285823,
-0.0402136184,
-0.0622175485,
0.0185369998,
-0.0440886728,
-0.016414104,
0.0213350393,
-0.0293576047,
-0.0232739076,
-0.0237884782,
0.0173017662,
0.0165739153,
0.0185471382,
-0.0220377576,
0.0142230522,
-0.0538194776,
-0.0543955229,
0.0253360048,
-0.0093355542,
-0.0246537626,
-0.0523352288,
-0.049981609,
0.0691884458,
0.0254776739,
0.0099139819,
0.0428748727,
0.0183109213,
0.0054464135,
-0.0563775674,
-0.0394488983,
0.0011603448,
-0.0226041246,
-0.0083923852,
0.0174023584,
0.0491862521,
-0.0020066465,
-0.0040559401,
-0.0140344668,
-0.0074194102,
0.0221038591,
0.0218536332,
0.0285095666,
-0.0056552063,
0.0109855765,
-0.0313164629,
-0.0188804977,
-0.002323552,
0.0478399172,
0.025109442,
-0.03195462,
-0.0721484125,
0.0071430542,
0.0000547711,
-0.0131816184,
-0.0179932062,
-0.0391031094,
0.0062168809,
-0.0021105383,
0.0390789211,
0.0890538916,
-0.0183224231,
0.0270492267,
0.0386592187,
-0.0035942611,
-0.0699352175,
-0.0004342648,
0.0161593538,
-0.0415069275,
0.0023527397,
-0.0760054216,
0.0072567929,
0.0248041395,
0.0045436369,
-0.008463772,
-0.0590972751,
0.0375918262,
-0.0299926214,
-0.0565791093,
-0.0276226997,
0.0016079902,
0.0120993173,
0.0472429059,
-0.0501382835,
-0.0468468294,
0.0430053137,
-0.0177201442,
-0.0191828404,
-0.0004550677,
0.0054262974,
-0.0860210359,
0.0493474603,
-0.0316443145,
0.0234358776,
0.0067235692,
-0.0482846573,
-0.0384187028,
-0.0235511661,
-0.0056766053,
-0.037808504,
0.0491737239,
-0.0814562514,
0.0088838916,
-0.003654985,
-0.0317427963,
-0.0365134552,
0.031262964,
-0.0095544811,
-0.0181199741,
0.0024211179,
-0.0057738475,
0.008972263,
0.0151486229,
0.0074818637,
0.0626463443,
-0.0254432131,
0.017117558,
-0.0337995477,
-0.0057865824,
-0.0005898008,
0.008676352,
0.0099570965,
-0.0616257824,
-0.0015179894,
0.0324912369,
-0.0395152494,
-0.0131244678,
-0.0101705585,
0.0128735937,
0.0535028689,
-0.0061772442,
-0.0151520837,
-0.0389653109,
0.052731216,
-0.0794788375,
-0.0106439646,
0.1110444739,
0.0221623369,
-0.078767702,
-0.0181752518,
-0.0223465189,
0.0110264942,
0.0202080961,
0.0318693556,
-0.0471615605,
-0.0097202361,
0.0461806059,
0.0258712526,
0.0089920843,
-0.0155276461,
-0.0374081954,
-0.1073477268,
0.000832852,
0.0279670786,
-0.060184218,
-0.070352219,
0.0020698183,
-0.0266608801,
-0.0271152835,
0.0472305827,
0.0047594216,
0.0267827976,
-0.0153665235,
-0.0224948768,
0.0321684517,
-0.0425432622,
0.0173570644,
-0.0706421286,
0.0329608284,
0.0761002824,
0.0527059361,
-0.0021883028,
0.0124085061,
0.0379110016,
-0.012337449,
-0.0090054478,
-0.0328976028,
-0.0232782643,
-0.0035597333,
-0.0340728015,
-0.0129681975,
0.0486662462,
0.0467820801,
0.0509125106,
0.0019974601,
0.0074096797,
0.0046994472,
-0.0031668632,
-0.0201439802,
-0.0495399013,
-0.001627812,
0.0554743372,
0.0274769366,
-0.0574330017,
-0.0418911725,
-0.0523926169,
-0.0135573773,
-0.0115726376,
-0.0541746765,
-0.0109685296,
-0.0037629376,
-0.0218283422,
-0.0540758967,
-0.0510325171,
-0.0027125189,
-0.0164550021,
0.0185735505,
-0.0667354688,
0.0578524433,
0.0089210095,
-0.0503563061,
0.0251737554,
-0.0460965745,
0.019880414,
-0.0416027457,
0.0194722544,
0.0237158723,
-0.0272048395,
-0.0008220382,
0.0799480379,
-0.0596281141,
-0.0677699521,
-0.0001337753,
0.044236768,
0.022736609,
0.0502849706,
-0.0094349524,
-0.0476334728,
0.0199757088,
0.0383719541,
-0.0069749858,
0.0387548991,
0.0181975756,
0.0420683809,
-0.0009520287,
0.0710387677,
-0.0345723964,
0.0262820795,
-0.0021284246,
0.0244394243,
0.0027145753,
-0.0780365318,
0.0025771616,
0.0262207035,
-0.0436290726,
-0.0364701748,
0.0006226219,
-0.0335629173,
0.0302183311,
-0.0292704012,
-0.0162853878,
-0.0259961225,
-0.0350754894,
0.0504520088,
0.0170287658,
0.0055449526,
0.0096763745,
0.0047084708,
0.0130209122,
-0.0065936218,
-0.003508568,
-0.035860043,
0.0364326201,
0.0113526564,
0.0149289295,
0.0027423308,
0.0230976809,
-0.0159110073,
0.0381754637,
-0.0298866685,
0.024446696,
-0.0060867886,
0.0126208961,
-0.034345571,
0.0275175795,
-0.0229255669,
-0.0264626294,
-0.0265117083,
0.023740612,
0.0485538095,
-0.0024693888,
0.1003405303,
-0.000923775,
-0.0143156098,
0.0063358825,
0.000265611,
0.0165004674,
0.0135640604,
0.0143540259,
-0.0139157437,
0.0365648046,
0.002606045,
0.0416201167,
0.039684739,
0.0291450024,
-0.0030468919,
-0.0240912642,
-0.018325936,
-0.0235501062,
-0.0251499638,
-0.0723747835,
-0.0175130367,
-0.0038461473,
-0.0522966534,
-0.0237144958,
0.0426831953,
-0.0208608732,
0.0314588845,
-0.008627248,
-0.0182155892,
0.0645863861,
-0.0397625826,
-0.047505755,
-0.0391836651,
0.013861686,
0.0134203881,
-0.0374440476,
-0.0416315161,
-6.6178003e-33,
-0.0514473729,
-0.0069943606,
0.0147290323,
-0.0387011766,
-0.0374356993,
-0.0016344881,
-0.0334006585,
-0.020301912,
0.0310888551,
0.006140322,
-0.0218640491,
0.0423147082,
0.0155357914,
0.0150267622,
0.0078298366,
0.0117220925,
0.0992488563,
0.0257273708,
-0.0296600293,
-0.0038798756,
0.0088431882,
0.0207403395,
0.0403275825,
-0.0703181848,
0.0831220448,
-0.0043678614,
-0.0215959139,
0.0182202235,
-0.0196445007,
-0.0133240782,
-0.0068105827,
0.036351379,
0.0044317595,
-0.0477155671,
0.0035754344,
0.0405673943,
-0.1198517457,
0.0004623434,
0.0025415071,
0.0485958718,
0.0426293239,
-0.0820799768,
0.069293201,
-0.0027186596,
-0.0289097913,
-0.0160004273,
0.0120202322,
-0.0057754577,
0.0344024859,
0.0199894756,
-0.033903636,
0.009199976,
-0.0273945481,
0.0042697154,
0.0213651694,
0.0403151065,
-0.0371923968,
0.0240324195,
-0.1042088643,
0.0193532705,
-0.0062277955,
0.012436524,
0.0495503955,
0.0205505751,
0.0144189559,
-0.0152895525,
0.0394613557,
0.002881712,
-0.0465333872,
-0.0404190533,
0.0185174122,
-0.0423991233,
0.0453479849,
0.0531329699,
0.0231625866,
0.0021144187,
-0.06970606,
-0.0252819415,
-0.0141411051,
0.0213633161,
0.0483941212,
-0.0099907331,
-0.0545799583,
-0.0353239626,
-0.0556834005,
-0.0895387754,
-0.0231633559,
-0.0186332539,
0.0186760593,
0.0152573893,
-0.0739782602,
-0.0047390223,
0.039420221,
-0.0496254712,
-0.0034560987,
-0.0028053776,
0.0106504485,
-0.0064840275,
0.0386271738,
0.037486583,
-0.0257584471,
0.0186625142,
-0.0076214233,
0.0030133603,
0.0211162269,
0.0038421166,
-0.0100270184,
0.018277064,
-0.0734960735,
0.0035547712,
-0.0627334341,
0.0268566869,
-0.0095870635,
0.0285851192,
0.0199706107,
0.0256639589,
-0.025177421,
0.0218046196,
0.0422989316,
0.0490933582,
-0.0285289884,
-0.0053412616,
0.0234360304,
0.0622373633,
-0.0390234031,
0.0016065713,
-0.0090949824,
0.044896137,
0.0401004106,
-0.0399973504,
-0.013620995,
-0.029077448,
2.735e-7,
-0.0058351844,
0.0733842254,
0.0343994759,
0.0423226431,
0.0334590077,
0.0175343212,
0.0011971609,
0.0588479675,
0.0449981838,
-0.0041469927,
-0.0256486982,
0.0650587454,
0.0261625983,
0.0301375259,
-0.0765996948,
0.0007444944,
-0.0362370163,
0.0483178832,
-0.0177779961,
-0.0069579259,
0.0027848082,
0.0832754821,
0.0275151897,
0.005403785,
-0.0076765982,
-0.0110730063,
0.0680544525,
-0.0038430244,
-0.0013886038,
0.0207800232,
0.0147928521,
0.0293100346,
-0.020832466,
-0.0123336343,
0.0189685505,
-0.0042612427,
0.0296722744,
0.0901147127,
0.0075470796,
0.011062949,
-0.0148277339,
0.0017557211,
-0.0222230963,
-0.0405557267,
0.0824011713,
-0.0416071564,
-0.0230668206,
-0.0204998776,
0.01189736,
0.0216272753,
0.0628956556,
-0.0306347348,
-0.0035065878,
0.0264730137,
0.0200708248,
-0.0016189435,
-0.0123832738,
-0.049439881,
-0.0453534164,
-0.0518477336,
-0.013038232,
-0.0309044477,
-0.0457790792,
0.0124337543,
-0.010845202,
-0.0378215313,
0.0280474462,
2.152394671e-34,
0.0203757137,
0.0065254853,
0.0098167825,
-0.0013848755,
0.0072146473,
-0.0125509212,
-0.026998071,
0.0110597117,
0.0262338538,
-0.0102619231,
-0.0083355196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03079v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03079v1 | GPT-InvestAR: Enhancing Stock Investment Strategies through Annual Report Analysis with Large Language Models | 2023-09-06T17:18:55 | 2023-09-06T17:18:55 | Udit Gupta | q-fin.ST | q-fin.ST, cs.CL, cs.LG | Annual Reports of publicly listed companies contain vital information about
their financial health which can help assess the potential impact on Stock
price of the firm. These reports are comprehensive in nature, going up to, and
sometimes exceeding, 100 pages. Analysing these reports is cumbersome even for
a single firm, let alone the whole universe of firms that exist. Over the
years, financial experts have become proficient in extracting valuable
information from these documents relatively quickly. However, this requires
years of practice and experience. This paper aims to simplify the process of
assessing Annual Reports of all the firms by leveraging the capabilities of
Large Language Models (LLMs). The insights generated by the LLM are compiled in
a Quant styled dataset and augmented by historical stock price data. A Machine
Learning model is then trained with LLM outputs as features. The walkforward
test results show promising outperformance wrt S&P500 returns. This paper
intends to provide a framework for future work in this direction. To facilitate
this, the code has been released as open source. | [
-0.0091065243,
0.081193611,
-0.0029118303,
0.0044392585,
0.0061009848,
0.0040721269,
0.0122464327,
0.0493382178,
0.0109900562,
-0.0578074791,
0.0154668028,
-0.0088664219,
-0.0286242887,
0.0881419852,
0.0204485934,
-0.0082630543,
0.0261086319,
-0.0324357748,
0.0102510899,
-0.0117097814,
0.0136616388,
0.0106060291,
0.0673658103,
-0.006403055,
0.0099558057,
-0.0024119595,
-0.0231382195,
-0.0152252875,
-0.0164540056,
0.003785945,
-0.0226191003,
0.0008710554,
0.0265276972,
0.0539500602,
0.0000020535,
-0.0527364835,
-0.0335790552,
0.0121311508,
0.0428568386,
0.0508529283,
0.0511780009,
-0.0507808365,
0.0181014221,
0.0164975561,
-0.0473096371,
-0.029791452,
0.0493917726,
0.0547363758,
0.0547168665,
0.0649262443,
-0.0096900174,
-0.0546177663,
-0.0021510003,
-0.066545032,
-0.0230401456,
-0.0943042189,
0.0175734553,
0.0410833918,
-0.0075716809,
-0.015178632,
-0.0232995395,
0.0510494523,
0.0071877819,
-0.0211188067,
0.0032126345,
0.0117169693,
-0.0085987998,
0.0161910262,
-0.0293239988,
-0.0042106444,
0.0058817463,
0.0046691783,
0.005540397,
-0.025934035,
0.0076896958,
-0.0113802878,
-0.0066149929,
0.032635618,
-0.0034738586,
0.0394587368,
0.0426513143,
-0.0209247507,
0.0063671777,
0.0252832323,
-0.0434566475,
0.0425340086,
-0.0224931538,
-0.0185350217,
0.0673036277,
0.0340221971,
0.0285522435,
-0.0444413759,
-0.012490361,
0.0248778351,
0.0109486552,
0.0211016908,
0.0107546505,
-0.0201407075,
0.0130286301,
-0.0970493332,
-0.0052630226,
0.0254458766,
-0.0025693362,
0.0584028214,
-0.0533930957,
0.0664935485,
0.0039844969,
-0.0445218682,
0.00103748,
0.0214927886,
-0.0237613134,
-0.0041152881,
-0.0081420373,
0.0965422988,
-0.0284636486,
-0.0043308209,
-0.0750185624,
0.0078913765,
-0.0049669761,
0.0449125245,
0.0333829671,
-0.0442541428,
-0.0124792606,
-0.0177223291,
-0.0173668619,
-0.0041460623,
-0.0253339298,
0.0040914509,
-0.0474441163,
-0.0335984156,
0.0182980746,
0.0043576169,
-0.0188001003,
0.0091063092,
0.0139811039,
0.0649854764,
0.0250898022,
-0.0091926381,
-0.0530251823,
-0.0503763072,
0.0087497039,
-0.0559210703,
-0.0489943288,
-0.0245311763,
-0.0102972593,
-0.0186202656,
-0.0115733538,
-0.0220305156,
0.0185566656,
-0.0249579381,
0.0115085775,
0.0582045242,
-0.0037828395,
-0.016606098,
0.0029753724,
-0.0368719622,
0.0632868186,
0.0899459124,
-0.0056342739,
0.0147471558,
0.0406336822,
-0.0134202717,
-0.000066175,
0.0487023443,
-0.0100028021,
-0.0385425612,
-0.0206648856,
0.0381471254,
0.0021439774,
-0.0351827182,
0.0185624622,
0.0171712264,
0.0169639215,
-0.0033304913,
0.0441975296,
0.0176264923,
0.0528093427,
0.0631471574,
-0.0051320968,
0.008000168,
0.0108319577,
-0.0757431611,
0.0260277819,
-0.0091647925,
-0.0114831617,
0.0392790101,
-0.0038315579,
0.0034018075,
-0.0163012166,
-0.0348452739,
-0.0000063615,
-0.0102292458,
-0.024228137,
0.0153489625,
0.0575913712,
-0.0674986094,
-0.0282660648,
0.0449735038,
0.0335946046,
-0.0163812041,
-0.0019932226,
-0.0224126838,
0.0684549436,
0.0512668081,
0.0015082789,
-0.0307434294,
0.0492981933,
-0.0292694587,
-0.0370420069,
0.0034025637,
0.0197660625,
0.0049899574,
-0.0387171246,
-0.0222014841,
-0.0039839852,
0.0439504199,
0.0273280032,
0.0280838739,
-0.0524549596,
0.0211647749,
0.009878831,
-0.0127454298,
-0.034151569,
0.0235246792,
0.0090276236,
-0.0254467949,
0.0331855379,
-0.0262099467,
0.0013081741,
0.0463659093,
-0.0069383658,
-0.0039722598,
-0.0081950137,
0.0024343831,
-0.0246871877,
-0.0085495161,
0.0167290084,
0.0340530425,
0.0053396407,
0.0036638831,
0.0016671716,
-0.0104787145,
-0.0309453961,
-0.0049310047,
-0.0032901163,
-0.0318620875,
0.0405328013,
-0.0788010657,
-0.0364628062,
-0.0127720777,
0.0134851253,
-0.0048065563,
0.0640504658,
-0.0010848175,
0.0367105193,
-0.0518163219,
-0.0183799844,
0.0033682452,
-0.0630272329,
0.0187886991,
0.0658141226,
-0.0025044843,
0.0627068356,
0.0478402339,
0.0096068978,
0.0053498261,
-0.0479580611,
-0.094375357,
-0.0565566048,
-0.0326451361,
0.0278960634,
0.0284499414,
0.0232695621,
-0.0116550922,
-0.0063563953,
-0.0228013005,
-0.0517965779,
0.0102993697,
0.0060563004,
0.0281157736,
0.0127440784,
-0.0229609646,
-0.0346223563,
-0.021110177,
-0.0134958932,
0.0283560306,
0.0576764308,
-0.0387298875,
-0.052795738,
0.0328169651,
-0.0067458381,
-0.0017572348,
-0.0101021538,
0.0068402537,
0.0064086253,
-0.0425766371,
0.0049761692,
0.0783324763,
0.0216925573,
0.0657710209,
-0.015820859,
-0.0234776251,
-0.037131086,
-0.0006437257,
0.0091947755,
0.0057298243,
-0.006365573,
-0.0339256562,
0.0311884545,
-0.0140590444,
-0.0278450996,
-0.0000944293,
-0.0745882168,
0.0253871474,
-0.0233707428,
0.03291253,
-0.0583621748,
0.01223699,
-0.0171433613,
0.0974829644,
0.0401800759,
-0.0644915104,
0.0096362066,
-0.0264385939,
-0.025287861,
-0.0293677729,
-0.0391818471,
-0.0739226043,
0.0578552559,
-0.0315985866,
-0.0004111498,
-0.065008454,
-0.0346956439,
0.0023840917,
-0.0125939213,
0.0157399885,
-0.0563972369,
0.0558948182,
-0.0087718926,
0.0331390128,
0.0122653395,
0.0142580243,
0.0065394402,
-0.0770007968,
-0.0380382352,
0.0059961798,
0.007181244,
-0.0307973679,
-0.0689314902,
0.041611895,
-0.0162123013,
-0.0015194684,
-0.0078542158,
-0.0184156243,
0.0445679985,
-0.0466640778,
0.0589361191,
-0.0365858898,
0.0093867974,
-0.0551267602,
0.0523534901,
-0.0016558795,
0.0356993079,
0.0304319561,
-0.0168271456,
0.0001808899,
0.0053720055,
0.000169067,
0.0171593633,
0.0183519889,
-0.0237417687,
-0.0522661619,
-0.0062916642,
0.0889420137,
-0.0123085231,
-0.0165396426,
0.0005899893,
0.0157241952,
0.016194813,
-0.0179620516,
0.0706143901,
-0.0627555251,
0.0171547104,
-0.0273526125,
0.0226255748,
0.0218022857,
-0.0383469723,
-0.0154332761,
-0.1410026699,
0.0545816943,
-0.0108433012,
-0.0366517529,
-0.0921357125,
-0.0417386033,
-0.0238052644,
-0.0929157659,
0.0059150048,
0.0295338333,
-0.039295543,
0.0135476906,
0.0117542418,
-0.1093323454,
-0.0380210355,
0.0025472867,
0.0036015688,
-0.0601754524,
0.074524723,
-0.0007031147,
-0.0568572991,
0.0311789028,
-0.0400379337,
-0.0140210092,
-0.000480131,
-0.0199041981,
0.054914739,
-0.0206250679,
-0.0323136188,
0.0278425757,
0.0437911078,
0.0000998986,
0.0681803748,
0.0394200087,
0.0121542746,
-0.0265377257,
-0.0391877294,
0.0594233088,
0.0369263887,
-0.0049247094,
0.0246248506,
-0.0046634385,
-0.0227313414,
-0.023417715,
-0.0726264268,
0.0000815354,
-0.0282077733,
-0.0174681544,
0.0345021747,
-0.0391133688,
-0.0186958332,
-0.0541840568,
-0.0885277539,
0.0412235372,
0.0334437452,
-0.0012894074,
0.0337526053,
0.0058762329,
0.0193668529,
-0.0342087075,
0.0050060288,
0.010713811,
0.0397860929,
-0.0489871465,
0.0053397841,
0.0264622085,
0.021014547,
-0.0578267649,
0.0132922819,
-0.0792615563,
-0.0544381328,
-0.0076395371,
0.0149631863,
0.026648758,
-0.0392110348,
-0.0308923665,
0.0157126654,
0.0432953686,
0.0241457317,
-0.0583073497,
-0.0256300196,
0.0240525957,
0.0039308248,
0.0059584156,
0.0202941392,
-0.0261864383,
-0.0191140063,
-0.0205848422,
0.0231229607,
-0.0237862654,
-0.0385096446,
-0.0120524932,
0.024331117,
0.0100114336,
0.0385834426,
-0.0224926025,
-0.0210114215,
-0.0270076767,
0.0062888358,
0.0056324555,
-0.0362621062,
0.0059712613,
0.0364212245,
-0.0124883819,
-0.031660419,
0.0624661706,
-0.0392761678,
-0.0433322601,
-0.0432126671,
0.0902680829,
-0.0244273301,
0.0045326818,
0.038980294,
-0.0113467285,
-0.0158862043,
-0.0463598967,
0.0468380526,
-0.0105108079,
0.0143181924,
0.0018085237,
0.0249647889,
0.0395340472,
0.0080256034,
-0.0247654654,
0.0114956666,
-0.0239019897,
0.0009027492,
0.0433531292,
0.0150625827,
-0.0324803293,
-0.0012458345,
-0.0806346983,
0.0286557861,
-0.0012846714,
0.0501020066,
0.0482732989,
-0.0081136581,
0.0549338497,
0.0050379648,
-0.0744772032,
-0.02656666,
0.0746075287,
0.0465676785,
-0.025306588,
-0.0118725756,
0.0015343268,
-0.0643053949,
-0.0249433219,
0.0674012899,
-0.0093887225,
-0.0087854071,
0.0137211308,
-0.0446858518,
-0.0563181601,
-0.0044088359,
-0.0019920766,
0.0015530735,
-0.0292320903,
-0.0314417072,
0.0800990239,
0.0430251993,
0.0544278957,
-0.0389575176,
0.0190742239,
-0.0194952954,
-0.0198580511,
-0.0566948466,
-5.732062001e-33,
-0.0190666597,
-0.0219940562,
0.009449074,
0.0001000391,
0.0143352607,
0.0100067733,
0.0037111111,
-0.0101148328,
0.0039290739,
0.015211788,
0.0070997099,
0.0265660454,
0.0211875234,
-0.0204967447,
0.0464260355,
0.018934574,
0.0130550973,
-0.0156787336,
-0.0189381167,
-0.045364432,
0.0019358876,
0.0471302569,
0.0554940104,
-0.0070889182,
0.0169248749,
0.0045454968,
-0.0443531871,
-0.0138086434,
0.0444445722,
0.0352056958,
0.0182931032,
0.0191234462,
0.0170410294,
-0.0944070518,
-0.0011784817,
0.0016815906,
0.0202721842,
-0.0159874931,
0.0302857887,
0.0375286229,
0.0431474186,
0.035823673,
0.0326401964,
-0.0048669567,
-0.0060243499,
-0.0082617644,
0.019388888,
-0.0039029215,
-0.00632801,
-0.0794551671,
-0.0547012016,
0.0541550182,
0.0127793318,
0.0964719355,
0.0623731576,
0.0585348047,
-0.0307756122,
0.004141219,
0.0076221735,
0.0003648688,
0.0408296101,
0.0636156276,
0.0093104504,
0.0255895294,
0.015212412,
0.0098148463,
-0.0319534577,
0.0194273852,
-0.0020307282,
0.0462084152,
0.0418279842,
0.0161902122,
-0.0078030429,
0.026869487,
0.0214399919,
-0.0164065883,
-0.068544291,
0.029083591,
0.0148277814,
0.0441135131,
0.0270139053,
-0.0158611629,
-0.0186996385,
-0.0391982459,
0.0147917466,
0.0288377479,
-0.0143464776,
-0.019223284,
0.0009547875,
0.001136461,
-0.0232409257,
0.0255982038,
0.0302712433,
-0.0184666254,
-0.103107892,
-0.0076648318,
-0.0037087901,
0.0070048468,
-0.010850668,
-0.0005064434,
-0.008684326,
-0.0478361584,
-0.0336262994,
0.0178693533,
-0.0170001015,
-0.0544967167,
0.0183234513,
0.0208610334,
-0.061361149,
-0.0222410839,
0.0000064081,
0.0330388322,
0.0112956464,
0.010481908,
0.0387661792,
0.0038315288,
0.0055153407,
0.0458022691,
-0.0014710432,
0.0051299972,
0.0011980515,
-0.0148448646,
0.0224032886,
0.0145257991,
-0.0044118762,
-0.0055140504,
0.0071052341,
0.0394863449,
0.0606020838,
0.0095330887,
-0.0173392966,
0.0310068596,
2.738e-7,
0.0678875968,
0.052772548,
-0.0137962056,
0.053657122,
0.0090001412,
0.0231793001,
-0.0210853349,
0.0073730946,
-0.0065634148,
0.0135670733,
0.0535532758,
-0.0200337209,
0.0723580271,
0.0226579867,
-0.0692220032,
-0.0337088406,
-0.0764419213,
0.013660281,
-0.112347126,
0.0254487675,
-0.0013195927,
0.0987213328,
0.0008634073,
-0.0109769627,
0.005532356,
-0.0517502874,
0.048942022,
-0.0734416544,
-0.0477882586,
-0.0044688485,
0.0502103306,
0.0054787332,
-0.0226638336,
0.004433495,
-0.0167902485,
0.0263570901,
0.0157685336,
0.0373630673,
0.009117363,
0.0668680891,
0.0278571751,
-0.0121623231,
-0.0274728686,
-0.0625353977,
0.0481967032,
-0.0328068584,
-0.0492450632,
-0.0453305468,
-0.0368805751,
0.0146406861,
0.0342108123,
-0.00111052,
-0.0068015922,
0.0566478707,
0.008366067,
-0.0391310565,
0.0448737703,
-0.025646897,
-0.034577053,
0.0244044233,
-0.0375148281,
0.0163080506,
-0.0077546271,
0.0279335715,
0.023457054,
-0.0035882373,
0.0519170612,
2.537656745e-34,
0.0653147176,
-0.0261858106,
-0.0308532063,
0.0288582593,
0.0818633288,
0.0111249704,
-0.0369205326,
0.057933148,
-0.0136046177,
-0.0934736878,
-0.01535282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03164v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03164v1 | J-Guard: Journalism Guided Adversarially Robust Detection of AI-generated News | 2023-09-06T17:06:31 | 2023-09-06T17:06:31 | Tharindu Kumarage, Amrita Bhattacharjee, Djordje Padejski, Kristy Roschke, Dan Gillmor, Scott Ruston, Huan Liu, Joshua Garland | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The rapid proliferation of AI-generated text online is profoundly reshaping
the information landscape. Among various types of AI-generated text,
AI-generated news presents a significant threat as it can be a prominent source
of misinformation online. While several recent efforts have focused on
detecting AI-generated text in general, these methods require enhanced
reliability, given concerns about their vulnerability to simple adversarial
attacks. Furthermore, due to the eccentricities of news writing, applying these
detection methods for AI-generated news can produce false positives,
potentially damaging the reputation of news organizations. To address these
challenges, we leverage the expertise of an interdisciplinary team to develop a
framework, J-Guard, capable of steering existing supervised AI text detectors
for detecting AI-generated news while boosting adversarial robustness. By
incorporating stylistic cues inspired by the unique journalistic attributes,
J-Guard effectively distinguishes between real-world journalism and
AI-generated news articles. Our experiments on news articles generated by a
vast array of AI models, including ChatGPT (GPT3.5), demonstrate the
effectiveness of J-Guard in enhancing detection capabilities while maintaining
an average performance decrease of as low as 7% when faced with adversarial
attacks. | [
0.0684891045,
0.0593630336,
0.0005961273,
0.0220959075,
-0.0435405672,
0.017002238,
-0.0146552725,
0.015446472,
0.0378191508,
-0.0384491757,
-0.0053618755,
0.0155469375,
0.0023973142,
0.0526674986,
0.0121284025,
0.0084426748,
0.0485125035,
0.0331399553,
0.0568793714,
0.004627855,
0.0470259115,
0.0476584248,
-0.0214205552,
0.0343314372,
-0.0399770848,
-0.0441697948,
0.0251580812,
0.0249103997,
0.0313928947,
-0.0251655728,
0.0095832236,
0.0419379957,
-0.0121476632,
0.0898105204,
0.0000017071,
0.0064695133,
-0.0145152593,
0.008612874,
-0.0060396232,
0.0048494246,
0.0500182807,
-0.0768181607,
-0.0317127779,
0.019913476,
-0.0226779487,
-0.0053440691,
0.0248179063,
0.042344518,
0.0629448518,
0.1375032216,
-0.0361405425,
0.0122236414,
0.0763776377,
0.0039262548,
-0.0268199667,
-0.0428362638,
0.0241463762,
-0.0318483114,
-0.0476886295,
0.0189796537,
0.0349527001,
0.0229487885,
0.0333312042,
-0.0228290837,
-0.050480213,
0.0076468969,
-0.0363814384,
-0.0059738234,
-0.0187061783,
0.0115055442,
-0.0193384271,
-0.0737527609,
0.02896435,
-0.0119602652,
0.0248340741,
0.0173432101,
-0.0058008982,
0.0244556051,
-0.0562263057,
-0.0169573314,
0.0106015299,
-0.0204423927,
0.0152463745,
0.0612655357,
0.0300561208,
0.0353072137,
0.0277395714,
-0.0261002686,
-0.0125768771,
0.0184253883,
0.0133266477,
-0.0350338742,
0.0430437475,
0.0273236651,
-0.0060190065,
-0.0051348233,
-0.0981097519,
-0.0662193373,
0.012989956,
-0.0758838877,
-0.0083791912,
-0.0052614138,
-0.0093186414,
0.0244402327,
-0.0275465418,
0.0208184253,
-0.0122739673,
0.0558300912,
0.031540174,
0.0155563653,
-0.010890061,
-0.0137502719,
-0.0263645276,
0.0186923277,
0.0187860932,
-0.0264490955,
-0.0319068357,
0.0229025185,
-0.0091697201,
0.0431615636,
-0.0396641344,
0.0027481762,
-0.026372904,
-0.0294763055,
0.0377006121,
-0.0203441791,
-0.0070497654,
0.0211747661,
0.0029290919,
-0.048044987,
-0.0366073586,
0.0605647527,
-0.028191153,
-0.0104603628,
-0.0091174152,
0.0585198924,
-0.0184972789,
-0.030048402,
-0.0285041165,
-0.0335195921,
-0.0325512923,
-0.0434957109,
0.0228027515,
-0.0260235034,
-0.0299296025,
-0.0133210327,
-0.0040457416,
-0.0688859671,
-0.0164701995,
0.0417035818,
-0.0007222047,
0.0259092785,
0.0397685841,
-0.0256568249,
0.0440642796,
0.0278210621,
-0.0201244485,
0.0759546608,
0.0245112404,
0.0995841101,
0.0514706299,
0.0417090952,
0.0365590602,
0.0238941684,
0.040862754,
0.0355737917,
-0.0193178784,
-0.0016419195,
-0.0463613905,
-0.0015327936,
0.0103650447,
0.030564446,
0.0135512855,
-0.044589147,
0.1143182367,
-0.0072856932,
-0.0382793285,
0.0140544102,
0.0533476621,
0.0066811629,
0.0243239123,
0.0299542695,
-0.0271798391,
0.0226396415,
-0.0982596502,
-0.0551635139,
-0.0496746115,
0.0541012287,
-0.013225791,
0.0002539468,
0.0074111903,
-0.0049574617,
0.0016717848,
-0.0373037532,
0.0011814258,
0.0308409408,
-0.0354926959,
-0.0629711226,
-0.000233949,
-0.0052385991,
0.0065121814,
-0.087534152,
0.0336709395,
0.0220773797,
0.0754463077,
-0.0125072962,
0.0334597155,
-0.0110015711,
0.0095883394,
0.0456049368,
0.0378501378,
-0.0146582713,
-0.0271706749,
0.0009881912,
-0.0059168674,
-0.0353861898,
0.0198749416,
0.0274071842,
0.0437927879,
0.0722291023,
0.0118108969,
0.0203988813,
-0.0531888157,
0.0446526855,
0.0018549286,
-0.0265537202,
-0.0062941751,
0.0156696029,
0.0119241728,
0.0101552801,
-0.0233396553,
0.0125701595,
0.0198900886,
-0.0200502109,
-0.0271171257,
-0.0145065943,
0.007676994,
-0.0134396143,
-0.0288059227,
-0.0343627334,
-0.0407666154,
0.0687287748,
-0.0199666191,
0.0183162577,
0.0253574271,
-0.0286280364,
-0.0179310236,
-0.0564437397,
-0.0310286805,
-0.0216801818,
0.0290640816,
0.00554574,
0.0714336187,
-0.0206291191,
-0.0625822097,
-0.0135729481,
-0.0157091375,
-0.008070874,
-0.0044475258,
0.007996927,
0.0001163028,
-0.0248275325,
0.0194934662,
0.0234775692,
-0.0083473567,
-0.010543637,
-0.0395875871,
-0.0295380522,
-0.0076080267,
-0.0348366946,
0.0024462952,
0.0550455898,
-0.0152980015,
-0.0144975567,
0.0192972422,
-0.0276656616,
-0.0116633996,
0.0178019423,
0.0409740992,
-0.009014708,
-0.0232459083,
0.0202271584,
-0.0234850496,
0.0308280624,
-0.04240904,
0.0423317552,
0.0375563987,
-0.0560939796,
-0.0367403626,
-0.0016109748,
-0.0230529476,
-0.0089183338,
-0.0219472218,
-0.0313736349,
0.006812504,
-0.0033968117,
-0.0183809586,
0.0999547318,
0.0483669899,
0.0650216937,
0.0060805986,
0.0568755977,
0.0100142444,
-0.0046651796,
-0.0066905748,
0.0523961708,
-0.0129502267,
-0.008791713,
0.0618968271,
0.0061627161,
0.0203743391,
0.0262398813,
-0.0170277543,
0.0725888461,
-0.0066895038,
-0.0310831927,
0.0382983275,
-0.0367592946,
-0.0073146112,
0.011945392,
-0.0542294756,
-0.0398841053,
0.0703458488,
-0.0160781965,
0.0390446633,
-0.0311149228,
-0.0305368975,
-0.0063788863,
-0.0004354238,
-0.0131769897,
0.0308198631,
-0.0210612323,
-0.0062376629,
-0.051087711,
-0.0116586555,
0.063649781,
0.0010008714,
0.0056773676,
0.0040270686,
0.0169705488,
0.0287431218,
-0.0229763165,
-0.0571254827,
-0.0771403685,
-0.01228821,
-0.0143680749,
0.0271577332,
-0.0469591878,
-0.0446754098,
-0.0230206177,
0.0271599181,
0.0401184112,
-0.0521686077,
-0.0077655343,
-0.0140165491,
0.0669989511,
0.0397897847,
-0.0626831502,
0.0402476788,
-0.0131693836,
0.0194049738,
0.0698686019,
-0.0305178147,
0.0447388701,
-0.0003317978,
-0.0411190726,
0.0004520132,
-0.0129783638,
-0.0147072347,
-0.0078992127,
0.0310890228,
-0.0267482959,
-0.0184002575,
0.0596822873,
0.0155380992,
-0.0453347377,
-0.0033818379,
0.034415409,
0.0343774445,
0.0090425871,
-0.0040633068,
-0.0555674098,
0.0020667694,
0.0196295828,
0.0184170194,
-0.0221996997,
-0.0048635639,
-0.0399930142,
-0.0552903451,
0.002080692,
-0.0041743265,
-0.0164884515,
-0.0227084514,
-0.0478951931,
-0.0023324462,
0.0051584323,
-0.0184270721,
-0.0272947773,
0.0102164196,
0.0033528698,
-0.0117134005,
-0.0256282445,
-0.0452975556,
-0.0296121724,
-0.0110059036,
0.014120617,
0.0624268726,
0.0598912947,
-0.0302380584,
-0.016543733,
-0.0007453454,
0.0176201519,
-0.0210006852,
-0.0177402422,
0.0767921582,
-0.0555190444,
-0.0043824711,
-0.0222855434,
0.046881482,
0.0280735083,
0.0011192625,
0.0312607847,
0.0069355662,
-0.0077988179,
-0.0536631793,
-0.0469627529,
0.0182751231,
0.054037258,
0.062541306,
0.027791027,
-0.0433117524,
-0.0354023166,
-0.0310255941,
0.0163094215,
-0.0817089006,
-0.0291391034,
0.009891863,
0.0197600648,
-0.0477723703,
-0.099026978,
-0.041024141,
-0.05255365,
-0.0037707619,
-0.0044527007,
-0.0336698741,
-0.0270439256,
-0.0066960747,
-0.0234161858,
-0.063779898,
-0.0147454776,
0.0284980144,
-0.0025159358,
0.0109333117,
0.0000852992,
-0.0185529459,
-0.0176315773,
0.0525874831,
-0.0902966261,
-0.0553597361,
0.0132535053,
0.0372091681,
0.0117987674,
0.0254571941,
-0.0537863411,
-0.0227570571,
0.0723107159,
0.0542505309,
-0.0320267938,
0.0150815826,
0.0367331356,
-0.0265607983,
0.0237839222,
0.0219190884,
-0.0193835646,
0.0265711918,
0.0199138522,
-0.0538272187,
-0.0120336907,
0.004523132,
0.0086592436,
-0.0017219592,
0.0049173068,
-0.0189663079,
0.0147133665,
-0.0180776659,
-0.0237683468,
-0.036516007,
-0.0222341623,
0.0011633498,
0.0360136107,
0.0256326757,
0.002164793,
-0.0245248601,
0.0700328276,
-0.0182762779,
0.0510262474,
-0.0522348844,
-0.0222089309,
0.0072944914,
0.087092191,
-0.0114617469,
0.0081975553,
-0.0055497875,
0.0430730581,
-0.0140642012,
0.0169661008,
-0.0124151958,
0.0150448112,
0.0261782054,
-0.0350108854,
0.0073330915,
0.0007400006,
-0.0891421512,
-0.0101341475,
-0.0327569246,
0.0584728308,
0.0355134569,
0.0038119929,
0.0184789542,
-0.0344507843,
-0.022933444,
-0.0014099519,
-0.0083146309,
0.0190313235,
-0.0231474079,
-0.0291608125,
0.0019733098,
-0.0246963035,
0.0149027482,
0.0673418269,
0.0124438563,
0.0603302978,
0.0345008336,
-0.0602578297,
-0.0374506824,
-0.0212184228,
0.0478559136,
0.023623785,
0.0055079469,
-0.0139455572,
-0.0373927653,
-0.0493226573,
0.0197621901,
-0.0064044013,
0.0186890922,
0.0107117938,
-0.0551621988,
0.0746909454,
0.015396026,
0.0225417819,
-0.0413453802,
0.0056515005,
-0.0338555723,
-0.0636992529,
0.0209611319,
-5.68126889e-33,
0.01931151,
-0.0515186004,
-0.0360077508,
0.0040761973,
0.0224612188,
0.0443957187,
-0.0153242992,
-0.0330757163,
-0.0504604578,
0.0430662557,
0.0002555186,
0.0547784716,
-0.0244514346,
0.0028488401,
-0.0410639383,
-0.0261983033,
0.0487432703,
-0.0317486189,
-0.0457666591,
0.0351537056,
0.0338076614,
-0.0126359779,
0.0338514671,
-0.0643819049,
0.0297118053,
-0.0165573247,
-0.0842873082,
-0.0260824077,
-0.0321812369,
0.0613471791,
0.0128850788,
0.0131137092,
0.0403182767,
0.0116559491,
0.0080903061,
0.0511730984,
-0.0096449275,
-0.0323462598,
-0.0077372184,
0.0145942643,
-0.0284603201,
-0.0210830476,
0.011184522,
-0.0210379865,
0.0066182716,
0.005848981,
0.018610971,
-0.0124230888,
0.0024420004,
-0.0588147379,
-0.045710016,
0.0041013756,
-0.0153819108,
-0.0088673392,
-0.0129805226,
0.0321847759,
0.0498221368,
0.0361244194,
-0.06791877,
-0.0024479132,
-0.05055549,
0.0042434563,
0.005746407,
-0.0203359071,
-0.0449766144,
0.0544340163,
0.025460165,
0.0389309749,
-0.0452366173,
0.012591145,
0.0204894636,
0.003386809,
0.0678485632,
0.083631672,
0.0122540025,
-0.0563613512,
-0.0823300332,
0.035209544,
0.047811985,
-0.0083539896,
0.0126046007,
-0.0186823513,
-0.0572354347,
0.0356921889,
0.014029962,
-0.0924122334,
-0.0365290344,
-0.023209272,
0.0020120877,
0.0359870531,
-0.0434447005,
0.0216642022,
-0.014941345,
-0.0503069125,
0.0141748404,
0.0732009634,
-0.0698086172,
-0.0137541024,
0.0019309458,
0.0411083661,
-0.0451651104,
0.0159208626,
0.0441238582,
0.0259595029,
0.0281383917,
-0.0175119098,
0.1056340709,
0.0487696901,
-0.0541579351,
0.0017056005,
0.0002023084,
0.067787379,
0.0115617234,
-0.0027487134,
0.0168046337,
-0.0323572569,
-0.0091797039,
-0.0100772595,
0.0264570732,
0.0235047881,
-0.0081869541,
-0.0171766151,
-0.0316379443,
0.0273900032,
-0.013159099,
-0.0336602069,
-0.0195298214,
-0.0119085778,
-0.0015045414,
-0.1054377779,
0.0107660731,
-0.047358498,
2.48e-7,
-0.0028543735,
0.0558443107,
0.025573656,
0.0150583694,
0.049002666,
0.022452442,
0.0278484784,
0.0605558679,
-0.0526842475,
-0.0524525382,
-0.0032035862,
0.0309220906,
0.0367578119,
0.0319566391,
-0.0500748307,
0.0431297459,
-0.1077116802,
0.0243589208,
-0.0661295801,
-0.0133265853,
0.0659796521,
0.0420322344,
0.0270848721,
-0.0353317633,
0.0014281261,
-0.0502971411,
0.045514904,
0.0584422052,
-0.0003828638,
0.0072095688,
0.0791800395,
0.0138367703,
0.0265400186,
-0.0067398897,
-0.0393464603,
-0.0110824611,
-0.0005454049,
0.0424386039,
0.0018059714,
0.0057187178,
0.0013772824,
0.0000287051,
0.013012182,
-0.0396458171,
0.0978383496,
0.0003197358,
-0.0155209601,
-0.0862711146,
-0.0490994826,
-0.0496863909,
0.0402487218,
-0.0389828868,
-0.0154589908,
0.0225265529,
-0.0063973372,
0.0330267921,
0.0109696761,
-0.0361498445,
-0.0072539509,
-0.0048387507,
-0.0201016404,
0.0240494274,
-0.0218439735,
-0.0211295076,
0.0362139791,
-0.0504310019,
0.0333388299,
2.088240919e-34,
0.0398823954,
-0.0251467153,
-0.0174668543,
-0.0006031044,
0.0216295645,
0.0332056731,
-0.0072571328,
-0.0304834023,
0.006899362,
0.009222067,
-0.0038897584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06600v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06600v2 | Narrative as a Dynamical System | 2023-09-06T16:56:33 | 2023-09-29T15:41:37 | Isidoros Doxas, James Meiss, Steven Bottone, Tom Strelich, Andrew Plummer, Adrienne Breland, Simon Dennis, Kathy Garvin-Doxas, Michael Klymkowsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, J.5; I.2.7 | There is increasing evidence that human activity in general, and narrative in
particular, can be treated as a dynamical system in the physics sense; a system
whose evolution is described by an action integral, such that the average of
all possible paths from point A to point B is given by the extremum of the
action. We create by construction three such paths by averaging about 500
different narratives, and we show that the average path is consistent with an
action principle. | [
-0.0133317336,
0.0054824869,
-0.0496265404,
-0.0147454748,
-0.0397741459,
-0.0005760532,
-0.0461589135,
0.0214722008,
-0.0618044548,
-0.0163285714,
0.044301942,
-0.0644453913,
-0.0032509088,
0.0489032157,
0.0289994087,
-0.0628748164,
-0.0065681427,
-0.022288844,
0.0012715284,
0.0089547504,
-0.0466497838,
-0.0539018735,
-0.0226310473,
-0.0019039422,
0.0308477264,
-0.0251493119,
-0.0544318296,
-0.0298538618,
0.0961277634,
-0.0108352331,
-0.0454065315,
-0.0315087512,
0.0209969878,
0.0640897602,
0.0000016187,
-0.0551147312,
0.0629602969,
-0.0334589221,
0.0048024873,
0.0005615627,
0.0148690837,
0.0742153451,
-0.0081790909,
-0.0372919999,
-0.0095514432,
0.0342068858,
0.0073884563,
0.0036322165,
-0.0066336975,
0.0454367697,
0.0006396091,
-0.0387627967,
-0.0078654606,
-0.0203901213,
0.0399614275,
0.0472952761,
0.0213774983,
0.0405040421,
0.0754171833,
-0.0539675616,
-0.04660834,
-0.0191468298,
0.0043093199,
0.016080901,
-0.0191735923,
0.0617736876,
0.0631330311,
0.0379876941,
-0.0059153768,
0.0696730167,
0.032228265,
-0.0133164274,
0.0042614378,
-0.0206539743,
0.0057540685,
-0.017764518,
-0.0293566287,
0.052617088,
-0.0197931994,
0.0009992139,
0.030952815,
0.0259876326,
0.0026774826,
-0.0241692513,
0.0280560628,
0.0132028153,
0.0135408593,
0.0172255281,
-0.0642441958,
-0.0250879694,
0.0600281805,
-0.0740707368,
-0.0480161682,
0.0422383845,
0.0145278079,
0.0046782331,
-0.0053766337,
0.0329006016,
-0.0359157324,
-0.0772045553,
0.0418945514,
0.0073862667,
0.0935208201,
0.0121323559,
0.0291279592,
0.0530768298,
-0.0156951565,
-0.017970359,
-0.0549874902,
0.0843180567,
-0.0618337244,
0.0057786228,
0.0028397853,
0.0493468344,
-0.0223831646,
-0.0273405015,
-0.0253602099,
0.0539576225,
-0.0222212225,
-0.0469291955,
-0.0905770212,
0.0085417144,
-0.0108121829,
-0.0041843248,
-0.015530671,
0.0000876864,
-0.0430168994,
0.0233373474,
-0.0050211423,
0.0213853214,
-0.0146378875,
-0.0344351456,
0.0396932513,
0.02768635,
-0.0228845328,
0.03233096,
0.0319813974,
0.0008808315,
-0.019878123,
-0.0216878951,
0.0137677649,
-0.0413138531,
-0.0328781977,
-0.0604979843,
-0.0080728466,
0.004255679,
0.0152248489,
-0.0074124797,
-0.0271509215,
-0.0131469984,
-0.0552225858,
0.0083817262,
0.0497147813,
0.0129341967,
0.0230249446,
-0.0082440879,
0.0620244779,
0.0164842829,
0.0840102211,
0.0148809711,
-0.0373851657,
0.0486935228,
0.0551949143,
0.0142441886,
-0.0646990612,
0.0212761667,
0.036351908,
-0.048163034,
0.0240390152,
0.0412848629,
0.0252290368,
0.0332646109,
-0.0554160438,
0.0139693571,
0.02246527,
0.0879960731,
-0.0154803852,
0.0328101963,
0.0454113409,
-0.0487958416,
0.0326750241,
0.0721932799,
0.0077474508,
0.0148756411,
0.0478799678,
-0.0101408707,
-0.0241751764,
0.0097342292,
-0.0246438719,
-0.0294091478,
0.0272983015,
-0.0133320866,
0.0210513752,
-0.0417917781,
-0.0113488473,
-0.027443232,
0.0004840708,
-0.0280704591,
0.0102828527,
-0.0123826889,
0.0253247488,
0.0120878555,
0.0462120771,
0.0544272736,
0.0192298088,
-0.0131365079,
-0.0197327118,
-0.0266567711,
0.0206488054,
-0.0140087483,
0.0191729739,
-0.0093630832,
0.0054003345,
0.0133213531,
0.0145018212,
-0.0726362541,
0.0189953558,
0.0335243121,
-0.0943587124,
0.0222513918,
-0.0281358566,
0.064643994,
-0.0584650859,
0.0004076394,
-0.0648552328,
-0.0264221616,
-0.0401499793,
-0.0335311294,
0.0228312276,
-0.0135485288,
-0.0441858545,
0.0086079352,
0.0095204283,
0.009248374,
-0.0137694851,
0.0985769555,
0.0065760533,
0.0062077665,
0.0285712574,
-0.0863609314,
0.007062492,
-0.05045693,
0.0277449749,
-0.0249120072,
0.0404025726,
-0.0895163491,
0.0291180965,
0.0188891701,
0.0026620107,
-0.017631527,
0.0065900283,
-0.0144534325,
0.0525578856,
0.0237412117,
0.0346143059,
-0.0272735395,
-0.0163675342,
0.0376720726,
-0.0488397516,
0.0416446663,
0.0382101759,
0.0316855274,
-0.021825254,
0.0416956693,
-0.0213144124,
-0.037235301,
0.0120426975,
-0.0282966848,
-0.0360781439,
0.0092992513,
0.0008100441,
0.0334960297,
0.0141838631,
-0.0364236124,
0.0571850799,
-0.0048765908,
0.0328573138,
0.0488121845,
-0.0144056464,
0.0006730261,
0.0385178886,
-0.058266595,
-0.0050156252,
0.0458627343,
-0.0328978449,
0.0243901331,
0.0437182002,
-0.0072051268,
-0.0463071726,
-0.0436860062,
-0.01514793,
0.0092331013,
-0.0261069462,
-0.0099683451,
0.0244937297,
-0.0001681563,
0.0810514688,
0.0314209834,
-0.0126418937,
0.0311435591,
0.0244142655,
-0.0393131711,
-0.0057378006,
-0.0221925061,
-0.0482243411,
0.0185337197,
-0.057595633,
-0.0750491023,
0.0243965909,
0.0765146688,
0.0020755811,
-0.0020359023,
-0.0271716639,
-0.0196454637,
-0.0147415735,
-0.0389525928,
0.0306378994,
-0.0565246828,
-0.0732606649,
0.0171125047,
-0.0299511086,
-0.0022422727,
0.0552609749,
0.0264590513,
0.0254824497,
0.0288665034,
0.0273842718,
-0.0130937621,
0.11802724,
0.0661639795,
0.0330820382,
0.0498871021,
0.0111920843,
-0.0358698294,
-0.0367584303,
0.0567479804,
-0.0053983289,
-0.0112038106,
-0.0696184561,
0.010177101,
0.0270954352,
-0.010282876,
0.0037278181,
0.0014299579,
0.010339844,
-0.0151392827,
-0.0311572831,
-0.012217598,
-0.0188001767,
0.0020490545,
0.0639237091,
-0.0063942629,
0.0403075404,
-0.0245367996,
-0.0020897996,
0.0033257613,
0.0509039573,
0.0015402373,
-0.0024376914,
-0.0486124009,
0.0317102894,
0.0648838505,
0.0353093334,
0.0680136532,
0.003156217,
0.0175722465,
0.0072677843,
0.0011036805,
-0.0425688997,
0.0422540195,
0.0116116051,
0.0345602892,
-0.026161788,
0.0428511389,
0.0023721941,
0.0308667514,
0.0603366494,
0.0052707838,
-0.0520500205,
0.006546712,
0.0104851294,
-0.0014440009,
0.0639797598,
-0.0050540883,
-0.0190420803,
-0.0460235514,
-0.0456744358,
0.0086379815,
-0.0201879274,
0.0235324744,
0.0412834361,
0.0449734963,
-0.0045299185,
0.0196641274,
0.0168502778,
0.0073897117,
-0.0911877751,
0.0057964111,
0.0107967788,
0.0239523854,
0.0004982668,
-0.0050672614,
0.0361544415,
-0.0158878081,
-0.0303289313,
0.0052278037,
-0.0146823768,
0.0698029175,
-0.0264297612,
-0.0110750981,
-0.0499982759,
0.0402450189,
0.0173305422,
0.0380095951,
-0.0251869354,
0.0275877714,
0.0238903072,
-0.0389793143,
0.0320288911,
0.0054576145,
-0.0441630781,
-0.0233682115,
0.0482892059,
-0.0126577597,
-0.0314272568,
-0.0236626286,
-0.0382932723,
-0.0325289369,
0.0203821491,
-0.0198758282,
-0.0232761763,
-0.0363278463,
-0.0420094989,
-0.0280485172,
-0.0035746316,
-0.06093961,
-0.0500563607,
0.0039338781,
-0.0255864896,
-0.0482442454,
-0.0483480692,
-0.0629492253,
0.1357233524,
0.0152008981,
-0.0048163678,
0.0355604999,
-0.0057422984,
-0.0339765362,
-0.02617299,
-0.0491813309,
-0.0034265958,
0.0054060295,
-0.0019026604,
-0.0115390187,
-0.0428367145,
-0.0231788978,
0.0081324708,
-0.0328118801,
-0.0703001916,
0.0242071394,
0.0260185935,
0.0354795866,
0.0386591405,
0.0270041153,
0.0046932623,
0.024747178,
-0.0601415858,
0.0343686789,
0.0848989412,
-0.0287515037,
0.0351382345,
0.0092099877,
-0.0164106973,
0.0101868697,
-0.0732346326,
-0.0041490979,
-0.0006002672,
-0.0614953712,
-0.0255325567,
0.0175927281,
-0.0118155843,
-0.0035260385,
-0.0111382771,
-0.0625545382,
-0.0226223543,
-0.0260477718,
-0.0225089919,
0.0197433494,
-0.0182375666,
0.004289181,
0.0484721661,
0.039185077,
-0.0410078838,
0.0031362574,
-0.0018985657,
-0.025854636,
-0.0025128375,
-0.0505557172,
0.0174029544,
0.00221312,
0.0175892524,
0.0016576665,
0.0209614001,
0.018028846,
-0.0552894995,
0.0431332514,
-0.0133356843,
-0.0380267948,
0.0566235669,
0.029513536,
-0.0222624559,
0.0108585553,
-0.1138461605,
-0.0221233312,
-0.0038743266,
0.0241040606,
0.0464004241,
-0.005534532,
0.0122810369,
-0.0626954362,
0.0274971705,
0.008794724,
-0.0313695706,
0.0184648801,
-0.00636381,
-0.0815579966,
0.0444355682,
0.0052805347,
0.0201126505,
0.0529085584,
-0.0657030717,
0.0796151012,
-0.0473243892,
-0.025133146,
-0.0145516722,
-0.0141302142,
-0.0445645861,
0.0130258407,
0.0539749973,
-0.0064953007,
-0.0700200722,
-0.0206775814,
0.023580404,
0.0259952173,
0.0522292256,
-0.0397046842,
0.0258495789,
0.0164899919,
0.0093608322,
-0.0017392793,
-0.0308061466,
0.0070140627,
-0.0338040702,
-0.0200053472,
-0.0364396349,
-5.345364032e-33,
0.0110947369,
0.0171175897,
0.0185381211,
0.0571833849,
-0.0705865324,
-0.0404209271,
-0.0545304641,
-0.008784513,
0.0043589761,
0.0193063617,
0.027795542,
-0.0116481157,
-0.0137831243,
-0.024822006,
0.0157148261,
-0.0046340516,
-0.0111019379,
-0.0210282374,
-0.0706907362,
-0.0237669926,
0.0493856333,
-0.0269800127,
0.0241322592,
0.004862112,
0.0016088746,
-0.0165853556,
-0.0178124215,
-0.0003008679,
-0.0156610738,
-0.0203486402,
-0.0141008412,
-0.0012711762,
0.020808978,
-0.0257597715,
0.0000954416,
-0.0392611846,
0.014984902,
-0.0507850908,
0.0195977818,
-0.020277461,
0.0037476288,
-0.0231487677,
0.0037771873,
-0.0016176823,
-0.056271635,
0.0015678648,
0.0472874269,
-0.014097074,
0.0140644433,
-0.0077445651,
-0.0281346105,
-0.0315514952,
-0.0342042185,
-0.024594333,
-0.0463551059,
-0.0178706273,
0.0197217073,
-0.075167276,
-0.0112016052,
0.0879777744,
-0.0127799129,
-0.0086240293,
-0.0260829721,
-0.0001761715,
0.0731707662,
0.0427496061,
0.067739971,
0.013683456,
-0.0656750798,
0.0661115944,
-0.0203417391,
0.0248922072,
-0.0194869675,
0.0399874896,
-0.0401395895,
0.026197698,
-0.0293956697,
0.0183088239,
0.0490670428,
0.0265374072,
-0.0112543367,
0.04632679,
-0.0572246984,
-0.0278110001,
-0.0056265229,
0.0126498966,
0.0357894078,
0.0244119689,
-0.0353098512,
-0.0208563283,
0.0355056375,
-0.0069659278,
0.0066284863,
-0.0251429547,
0.004612572,
0.0297728553,
0.0256787762,
0.0349251032,
0.0363312028,
-0.0205666013,
-0.000360646,
0.0166945532,
-0.033772964,
0.0576879084,
0.0179343838,
0.0053026439,
-0.0546109825,
0.0517943911,
0.0242044944,
0.0058520273,
-0.0027530333,
-0.0757299513,
0.0560331568,
-0.0575315431,
0.0336043052,
0.0007989137,
-0.0148106134,
-0.0119583961,
-0.0064241178,
0.014989553,
-0.0074830372,
0.0336191878,
-0.049923081,
0.034117192,
0.0013664428,
0.0223510452,
-0.0300431605,
0.0552550592,
0.0399284922,
-0.0509019867,
-0.0277373325,
0.007897011,
2.544e-7,
-0.0338102132,
-0.0197431445,
0.0477108546,
-0.0009930088,
0.0466882475,
0.0254978836,
0.0009919128,
0.0157691184,
0.0438339822,
-0.0547900163,
0.0462007262,
0.022753384,
-0.0173444916,
0.0094611533,
-0.0302685387,
0.0228939336,
-0.0059334217,
-0.0362374783,
0.0142191062,
-0.0170607828,
0.0536241978,
-0.0318037383,
0.083276391,
0.0178653784,
0.0325680226,
-0.0421863385,
0.031678617,
0.0090644816,
0.0291534383,
0.0554884113,
-0.0222519711,
-0.0246299859,
-0.036529664,
-0.0810067877,
0.0180938598,
0.0060656983,
-0.0260854978,
-0.013351771,
-0.0102259722,
0.008716872,
-0.0401799493,
-0.0415717289,
-0.0014158855,
0.0123550845,
0.021583613,
-0.0122633511,
-0.0075093601,
0.060955219,
-0.0044128629,
0.0344986171,
0.0113892574,
0.0606733896,
-0.0165479705,
0.0093502998,
-0.0236757491,
0.0143024372,
0.0119001418,
-0.0571687669,
0.0013650854,
0.0232891291,
-0.0421846509,
-0.0320064202,
0.0247049797,
-0.0043541389,
0.0473468564,
-0.0678753629,
-0.0408807062,
1.850601419e-34,
0.0236898419,
-0.0062557766,
0.0287505109,
-0.0513642915,
0.0157659836,
0.0215213615,
-0.0026290531,
0.0066282442,
0.0830881372,
-0.0438647419,
-0.0722602457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03126v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03126v2 | Everyone Deserves A Reward: Learning Customized Human Preferences | 2023-09-06T16:03:59 | 2023-09-15T09:24:30 | Pengyu Cheng, Jiawen Xie, Ke Bai, Yong Dai, Nan Du | cs.CL | cs.CL | Reward models (RMs) are essential for aligning large language models (LLMs)
with human preferences to improve interaction quality. However, the real world
is pluralistic, which leads to diversified human preferences with respect to
different religions, politics, cultures, etc. Moreover, each individual can
have their unique preferences on various topics. Neglecting the diversity of
human preferences, current human feedback aligning methods only consider a
general reward model, which is below satisfaction for customized or
personalized application scenarios. To explore customized preference learning,
we collect a domain-specific preference (DSP) dataset, which includes preferred
responses for each given query from four practical domains. Besides, from the
perspective of data efficiency, we propose a three-stage customized RM learning
scheme, then empirically verify its effectiveness on both general preference
datasets and our DSP set. Furthermore, we test multiple training and data
strategies on the three learning stages. We find several ways to better
preserve the general preferring ability while training the customized RMs,
especially general preference enrichment, and customized preference imitation
learning. The DSP dataset and code are available at
https://github.com/Linear95/DSP. | [
0.0757263228,
0.0712804496,
-0.0125711067,
0.0279463455,
-0.0338263549,
0.0036368617,
-0.0367892459,
-0.0284986403,
0.0146162715,
-0.0014189513,
-0.0422508791,
-0.0647269636,
-0.01420883,
-0.0233048461,
-0.0068374239,
-0.0816012472,
0.0542519838,
0.0137606021,
-0.0010403348,
-0.0395102091,
0.0287127625,
0.0346122123,
0.013533378,
0.0284284186,
0.0271490254,
0.0094986167,
-0.0053382115,
-0.0207057092,
0.0299152434,
0.006381358,
0.0502063669,
0.0649430901,
0.0073517347,
0.0032984402,
0.0000022197,
-0.05963872,
-0.0071234875,
-0.0401814654,
0.0016860062,
-0.0227252189,
0.0748295113,
0.047296524,
0.0143542178,
0.0290791281,
-0.0693549514,
0.0268202834,
0.0300970729,
0.0470623225,
0.033222869,
0.030530002,
0.0046852301,
-0.0303933881,
-0.0463137813,
-0.0287547596,
0.0195749067,
-0.0229204074,
0.024699077,
-0.0128698619,
0.0386349969,
0.0060057053,
-0.0003027068,
-0.0197218806,
0.0123003498,
0.0128643345,
0.0319555625,
0.0178279262,
0.008799837,
-0.0127775548,
-0.0015851632,
0.0846090093,
0.0162535384,
-0.0067874757,
-0.0110797975,
-0.0111471573,
0.0207717177,
-0.0072039277,
-0.0044389698,
-0.031762328,
0.0048892279,
0.0294558071,
0.007052083,
0.0087155793,
-0.011842669,
0.0536522083,
-0.0676555336,
0.1063531041,
-0.0131504368,
-0.0313837454,
0.0127161713,
0.0133937094,
-0.0304165035,
-0.0242735445,
-0.0001157346,
-0.0286282506,
-0.0542841777,
0.0077372896,
-0.0542221218,
0.0210466143,
0.0227608159,
-0.0213290136,
0.0506029353,
0.0440216325,
-0.0056422735,
0.0438227318,
0.0482328422,
0.0402902588,
-0.0187938754,
0.0172762871,
-0.0486268178,
0.0054884907,
-0.0199118741,
0.0214354433,
0.0279724319,
0.0544580333,
-0.0398131385,
0.0135350451,
-0.0550662093,
0.0416406505,
-0.0144467596,
0.0353804082,
0.0337468199,
0.0435815156,
-0.0536785759,
-0.0268883258,
-0.0864403695,
0.0394940339,
-0.0499242954,
0.0213273019,
0.0205132607,
-0.0254791398,
0.0348582566,
0.0005426672,
-0.0026794074,
-0.0530831702,
0.0021036044,
0.0489909872,
0.00295326,
-0.0057338891,
0.0044365092,
0.0130231753,
0.0119022327,
-0.0388820767,
-0.0262705646,
-0.0574214123,
0.056050662,
-0.0073027788,
-0.0363868624,
-0.043773599,
0.0005175867,
0.0269447211,
-0.0360104889,
0.0665884688,
0.0086622052,
0.0024627373,
0.013932026,
-0.0142348371,
0.0100259371,
0.0695040673,
0.0124213686,
0.0603920445,
0.0533245988,
-0.0099859517,
-0.006105403,
0.0086008776,
-0.0036327308,
0.014601375,
-0.0316943489,
0.0451932698,
-0.0151464492,
0.0265468527,
0.0530949533,
0.0211281218,
-0.018875815,
-0.0645149127,
0.0576220192,
0.038175609,
-0.0087332344,
0.0002193202,
-0.0008127689,
0.0730950311,
-0.0132023003,
0.0294272676,
-0.0403596647,
0.0430042222,
-0.0003382653,
-0.0032940856,
0.0225063562,
0.0027534154,
-0.0379437394,
-0.0573727526,
0.0264961645,
-0.0372917391,
0.0377712399,
0.0587527119,
0.0473665595,
-0.0324127153,
-0.0299083628,
-0.022666622,
0.0626453981,
-0.0426206887,
0.0242810547,
-0.0247345343,
0.0517856963,
0.0924130082,
0.0090888236,
-0.0390506983,
-0.0057390863,
-0.0355208702,
-0.0392438918,
0.0236837063,
0.0608868897,
-0.0256815124,
-0.0003040576,
-0.0569186956,
-0.0518711843,
0.0336480476,
-0.0078754537,
0.0362052545,
0.051865086,
-0.0291774478,
-0.0164772868,
-0.0289949588,
0.0006764932,
0.0041732704,
-0.0256241541,
0.0008782183,
0.0515492186,
0.0268754177,
0.0553883351,
0.0197287109,
0.0247153398,
-0.0215977319,
0.0072898054,
0.0038630182,
-0.0203177892,
0.0030503601,
-0.0484680086,
-0.0125287054,
0.0346904583,
0.0001157143,
-0.0348511189,
0.1005748287,
-0.024513524,
-0.0125528108,
0.0024143448,
0.0111977393,
0.0618398041,
-0.0240031276,
0.0104377652,
-0.0215047449,
-0.006458554,
-0.0781656504,
0.0426843129,
-0.0297174696,
0.002334682,
-0.0199644398,
-0.0343250036,
-0.0024742379,
-0.0452862382,
-0.0281606279,
-0.0168436505,
0.000152008,
0.0524079762,
0.0503074415,
-0.0077883862,
-0.0575100593,
-0.0084867459,
-0.0482231341,
-0.0122392559,
-0.001700406,
0.0219344851,
0.0019239585,
0.0459852442,
0.0129671702,
-0.0385072455,
-0.0675125569,
-0.0395463929,
-0.0212508719,
0.0185227413,
0.0271315742,
-0.0003034736,
0.0105457269,
-0.0583519228,
-0.0075186132,
0.0035690314,
0.0019332285,
-0.0414548554,
0.0330547467,
-0.0245061889,
-0.0067687943,
-0.0410361625,
0.0161022674,
-0.0305497292,
-0.0363558158,
-0.0145388748,
-0.0098571535,
0.0082534617,
0.0879509971,
0.0677781701,
-0.0103464955,
0.0125605911,
0.0540784858,
-0.0999573171,
-0.0018037726,
-0.086947985,
-0.005348654,
-0.0296932422,
-0.0113267004,
0.013172063,
0.0523266457,
0.0125268623,
0.0005932415,
-0.0721069202,
0.0205733143,
0.0139188236,
-0.0296593998,
-0.0218270142,
0.0393328182,
-0.0148070883,
0.0371827744,
-0.0246344954,
-0.0322901048,
0.0998834074,
0.0463415384,
0.0077118864,
-0.0816898122,
-0.0018867663,
-0.0243148655,
-0.0089815632,
-0.0219057854,
0.0225579999,
0.0116713177,
-0.0132323364,
-0.0760798901,
-0.0405960009,
0.0241313763,
-0.0355667397,
0.06266734,
-0.0110656926,
0.0008582316,
-0.0036849969,
-0.0764675438,
-0.0483816341,
-0.0461748019,
-0.0169202145,
-0.0165046267,
0.0325604305,
-0.0284389853,
0.0043940628,
-0.0299047921,
0.0340497419,
-0.0279310551,
-0.0020351098,
-0.01133224,
0.0051866653,
-0.0028138107,
0.0840782449,
0.045758415,
-0.0110331727,
-0.0145739093,
-0.0338033587,
0.0337990597,
0.0520706587,
-0.0226141419,
-0.0001696063,
0.0038054429,
0.0767360032,
-0.0316482447,
0.0077056615,
0.013699241,
0.0071893549,
0.0080229361,
0.0418859199,
0.0990923792,
0.027955899,
-0.0944840461,
0.0101659019,
-0.0264906362,
0.0522165745,
0.0438668616,
0.0518402942,
-0.0869239494,
0.000964466,
-0.0200234894,
0.042097073,
0.0109321456,
-0.0214040745,
0.0076162703,
-0.1351253837,
-0.0313600004,
-0.0135622621,
-0.0459220596,
0.0090835765,
-0.0363785736,
0.0142591847,
-0.0419280119,
0.0335807502,
-0.0042926446,
0.0217728093,
-0.0186605435,
0.0159020945,
0.0004629274,
-0.0693455637,
0.0181163792,
-0.0222076923,
0.0418192483,
0.0950319543,
0.0323585048,
-0.0002044958,
-0.0278391633,
-0.0125457728,
0.0449553244,
-0.029593179,
-0.0262752343,
0.0117764715,
-0.0205165781,
-0.0073976982,
-0.0364055336,
0.0434894338,
-0.0290788505,
0.0233413465,
0.0115464143,
0.0484568998,
-0.0128316516,
0.0182002708,
-0.0136225484,
-0.0134367272,
0.0227939151,
0.0461162515,
-0.0044099218,
-0.1102367714,
0.0057554808,
-0.0375330821,
-0.0425716527,
-0.0466617607,
-0.0495254174,
-0.0123145245,
-0.0112230368,
-0.0089892335,
-0.0450407863,
-0.0452553108,
-0.0041925069,
0.0286265016,
0.0081225848,
-0.0115394238,
0.0306801628,
-0.0322064087,
-0.0155562833,
0.0264998488,
-0.037591815,
0.0136521962,
-0.0808537453,
-0.0281003062,
0.024766406,
-0.0682130679,
-0.0054358686,
-0.0857917517,
0.0154527677,
-0.0708925948,
-0.0068407147,
0.0665549785,
0.0141103566,
0.0774665475,
-0.0139463134,
-0.0575771146,
-0.0035371012,
0.026504023,
-0.0124741243,
-0.0204986893,
0.039336849,
0.0296697877,
-0.0075257248,
0.0308481269,
-0.0221874639,
0.0243934859,
0.0224936921,
-0.0058222595,
-0.0294098426,
-0.0171885528,
0.0455171503,
-0.0175856743,
0.0142875398,
0.0128767202,
-0.0128447963,
-0.0309088007,
0.0038971999,
-0.0080291647,
-0.0500956252,
-0.0335821286,
-0.0576183423,
0.0348719545,
-0.0215246081,
-0.0002245302,
-0.0629056394,
-0.0361103341,
0.0129684713,
-0.02874716,
0.0058495863,
0.0032880076,
0.0241292436,
0.0369170234,
0.0252828356,
-0.0173214078,
-0.0170952026,
0.0342425145,
0.0628113747,
0.0097102495,
0.0522370823,
0.0128119439,
-0.0102277547,
0.0172205139,
0.0228477903,
-0.0087312255,
-0.0240236744,
-0.0309528839,
-0.0442540273,
0.0316894837,
-0.0417989343,
0.0279000532,
0.0101014692,
0.0050112093,
-0.0312989764,
0.0474089608,
-0.0267858431,
-0.0007505093,
0.0176771246,
0.0185866468,
-0.0384374931,
0.0178252831,
0.0680031627,
-0.0144821536,
-0.0047064996,
-0.0256448966,
0.0000554133,
-0.0445968471,
-0.0053221346,
0.0136076882,
0.0387785435,
-0.0481774509,
0.0156183019,
-0.0505246818,
-0.0462754853,
-0.0270359758,
0.0135681732,
-0.0133154644,
-0.0047454354,
0.0802621618,
0.0484316722,
-0.0438302308,
0.0139366686,
-0.073368758,
-0.0248518083,
-0.0252466239,
-0.0308770053,
-0.0292554814,
-6.594992771e-33,
-0.0052858898,
-0.0004781738,
-0.0004958832,
-0.0100207496,
0.002845411,
-0.0669014752,
0.0162797496,
0.0321801417,
-0.038703315,
-0.0225053895,
-0.0197007339,
-0.0183011442,
0.0124202082,
0.0164668337,
0.0203167256,
-3.59e-7,
0.0442747548,
0.0103382375,
-0.0288581699,
0.0015412722,
0.0269076359,
0.0329301059,
0.0460950695,
-0.0938735083,
0.0263251476,
0.0136174103,
0.0023047822,
0.0246141385,
0.0036790834,
0.0813221037,
0.000744592,
0.0485906005,
0.0075749266,
-0.0300382767,
-0.0014881478,
0.0175662562,
-0.0592497326,
-0.0145937223,
0.0332826823,
0.0238966495,
0.0040090671,
-0.0183797758,
0.0131783793,
-0.0177052859,
-0.0261925664,
0.0179617088,
0.0393742062,
-0.0205545872,
-0.0385345034,
0.0556975231,
-0.0334874466,
0.0023995491,
0.0086141853,
-0.0161249973,
-0.0076588788,
0.066642873,
-0.008623831,
0.0508656614,
-0.0397792719,
0.0536981784,
-0.0196141098,
0.0333444811,
0.0347734801,
-0.0085403416,
0.0172765628,
0.0369022675,
0.0147358356,
0.0309921671,
0.0518513359,
-0.0169195104,
0.0198091175,
0.042524308,
0.0043802406,
0.0799314603,
0.0095401835,
-0.0305189826,
-0.002579476,
0.0560806245,
0.0372131653,
-0.0189628173,
0.0421614014,
0.0275394171,
-0.0476024933,
-0.0273374356,
-0.0143509302,
0.0222096201,
-0.0475946143,
-0.0465229228,
0.0210431684,
0.0291899629,
-0.0487229005,
-0.0373228043,
0.011751553,
-0.0721443146,
-0.0675159693,
0.0107575627,
-0.0393353887,
-0.0032497298,
0.0217755325,
-0.0195907,
-0.0766208395,
-0.0276017394,
-0.0464972407,
-0.0492901318,
-0.0356131494,
0.0356329903,
0.0125587704,
0.0030892398,
-0.0416908339,
-0.0049701706,
-0.0136646973,
-0.0076966104,
-0.0099320663,
0.0230037514,
0.0391232893,
0.007657832,
-0.0134185264,
0.0691442937,
0.0059125698,
-0.0413437486,
-0.0533574782,
-0.0502799787,
-0.0014907165,
0.0236958172,
-0.0124780871,
-0.0206799936,
-0.037991114,
0.0155763607,
0.0018784922,
0.0101370811,
-0.0330324806,
-0.0184717625,
2.789e-7,
-0.0151655013,
0.0369532593,
-0.0057433094,
0.0068271495,
-0.034116596,
0.0806779265,
0.0245242789,
0.0323255621,
0.0206468813,
0.0231115762,
0.008196841,
-0.008743315,
0.0619843788,
-0.0236205831,
-0.1231692806,
-0.0148861706,
-0.0010097764,
0.0175782125,
-0.0117166247,
-0.0179791655,
0.0195592418,
0.0707654506,
0.057914678,
0.0188162364,
-0.0098120486,
0.0742400214,
0.0613971502,
-0.0631409585,
-0.041047018,
0.0268432256,
0.0011773001,
0.0055849138,
-0.0082531953,
-0.0084043806,
-0.0179700088,
0.0140317772,
-0.0064670844,
0.0725441128,
0.0015727876,
-0.071729973,
0.0140904468,
0.0101742139,
0.0187756754,
-0.0479870625,
0.0388447903,
-0.0357144922,
-0.0293375272,
-0.0188880321,
0.0083729317,
0.0040105488,
0.0177904088,
-0.0390284657,
-0.0243814439,
-0.0268101804,
0.0359234251,
0.0214736778,
-0.0153658707,
-0.0516985878,
0.0187385362,
0.0163464621,
-0.0443023443,
-0.0314852819,
0.0006172484,
0.0459403321,
-0.0234784558,
0.0083326725,
0.0168840755,
2.272888581e-34,
0.0302423947,
0.0225075483,
0.0331721492,
0.0346990675,
0.0256955475,
0.0175560154,
0.0240561608,
0.0085700005,
0.0836001709,
-0.034630131,
-0.0160212312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03118v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03118v1 | Knowledge Solver: Teaching LLMs to Search for Domain Knowledge from Knowledge Graphs | 2023-09-06T15:55:01 | 2023-09-06T15:55:01 | Chao Feng, Xinyu Zhang, Zichu Fei | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT and GPT-4, are versatile and
can solve different tasks due to their emergent ability and generalizability.
However, LLMs sometimes lack domain-specific knowledge to perform tasks, which
would also cause hallucination during inference. In some previous works,
additional modules like graph neural networks (GNNs) are trained on retrieved
knowledge from external knowledge bases, aiming to mitigate the problem of
lacking domain-specific knowledge. However, incorporating additional modules:
1) would need retraining additional modules when encountering novel domains; 2)
would become a bottleneck since LLMs' strong abilities are not fully utilized
for retrieval. In this paper, we propose a paradigm, termed Knowledge Solver
(KSL), to teach LLMs to search for essential knowledge from external knowledge
bases by harnessing their own strong generalizability. Specifically, we design
a simple yet effective prompt to transform retrieval into a multi-hop decision
sequence, which empowers LLMs with searching knowledge ability in zero-shot
manner. Additionally, KSL is able to provide complete retrieval paths and
therefore increase explainability of LLMs' reasoning processes. We conduct
experiments on three datasets: CommonsenseQA, OpenbookQA, and MedQA-USMLE, and
found that our approach improves LLM baseline performance by a relatively large
margin. | [
0.0224888232,
0.0047148466,
0.000936176,
0.0372911915,
-0.0541064553,
-0.0113778133,
-0.0223340876,
0.0125869606,
0.0903000012,
-0.0267197471,
-0.0255200844,
0.0027550291,
-0.0477177128,
0.0315869041,
0.0145839397,
-0.0150077101,
0.0488671884,
-0.000407348,
0.0069622998,
-0.0045678932,
-0.0177711863,
0.0441791117,
-0.01901602,
0.0356213339,
-0.0030646694,
-0.0139387799,
-0.0294810664,
-0.0067648944,
0.0029550015,
-0.0264388118,
0.0089544905,
0.0177176967,
0.0538402796,
0.0350977071,
0.0000021869,
-0.0339635983,
-0.0303183869,
-0.0046280567,
-0.0576522425,
-0.0457604155,
-0.0199582204,
0.0181541312,
0.0438522324,
0.0230789185,
-0.052594386,
-0.0357332192,
0.0102538494,
0.0611320734,
0.0454711281,
0.0795430392,
0.0031059883,
-0.0538955331,
0.0042660949,
-0.0174193121,
0.0262760967,
-0.079098627,
0.0236795004,
0.0456071161,
0.044372119,
-0.0149012357,
-0.0233620964,
0.0347093157,
0.0353943557,
0.0126746865,
0.0201013815,
0.0408910289,
-0.0272746049,
0.0252760034,
0.0063881152,
0.109196499,
-0.0065676896,
-0.0308509916,
-0.0035604925,
-0.0062234355,
0.0402175337,
0.05466149,
-0.061112266,
0.0042807986,
-0.0249463618,
-0.0002073825,
-0.0380195342,
-0.034889482,
0.0883437172,
0.0038514046,
-0.0371040702,
0.1166363209,
0.0029158888,
-0.0259689111,
0.0692681596,
-0.0045309798,
-0.0440715514,
-0.0196521487,
0.0119073531,
0.0839920864,
-0.0421115048,
0.0351069085,
0.0087982854,
0.0297024399,
-0.002891886,
-0.0238187425,
0.0002070912,
0.0369040519,
-0.0209165681,
0.0663346127,
-0.049163267,
0.0435570292,
-0.0157620385,
0.0639995411,
-0.0374964811,
-0.038974449,
-0.0905552134,
-0.0289115217,
-0.0324920937,
0.0401047319,
-0.0178422537,
-0.0354175903,
-0.0125329783,
0.0312075522,
-0.0139492275,
0.0121757742,
0.0392962806,
0.0403050184,
0.0246648844,
-0.0307770148,
-0.0582084097,
0.0502703078,
-0.0166001339,
0.0086168842,
0.0095860129,
-0.0192902628,
-0.0227051303,
-0.0020071501,
0.0427629352,
-0.0052550822,
0.0179273039,
0.108712934,
0.0223261621,
-0.0227158461,
-0.0694294795,
-0.0309282038,
0.0110440198,
-0.08689823,
0.043284256,
-0.0514701009,
0.0242587272,
0.0033765074,
-0.0292494949,
-0.0384045094,
0.025366988,
0.0104181161,
-0.0337396152,
0.07387124,
-0.0169144645,
-0.0031957373,
0.0241189152,
0.0110442471,
-0.0315509103,
0.0527446084,
-0.0257224012,
0.0011395733,
0.0196680911,
0.0026673151,
0.0085687572,
0.0039877673,
0.0510588177,
-0.0183529276,
0.0253655128,
0.0035738782,
-0.0201471299,
0.044518508,
0.0084674601,
0.0340855233,
-0.0407935306,
0.0050338898,
0.0207771342,
0.0532809868,
0.0409384817,
-0.0038123762,
0.0576141067,
0.0144137125,
-0.0046711802,
0.0193586946,
-0.0590648688,
0.0443865657,
-0.0274100099,
0.0197840873,
-0.0035605365,
-0.0210127626,
-0.0319815315,
-0.0206682049,
-0.0081644077,
-0.0005099577,
0.0330364406,
0.0490711518,
0.0709048137,
0.0233633872,
-0.0593627132,
0.0677700862,
0.0231233407,
-0.0059666885,
0.0015614351,
-0.0551684275,
-0.0006190634,
0.0449909866,
0.0615598075,
-0.0224570129,
-0.0529064983,
-0.0144188404,
-0.0143885333,
0.0143056437,
0.0198565386,
-0.0203276575,
-0.0136198159,
-0.0758617744,
-0.0362575725,
-0.0338138901,
0.0160981733,
0.0178257506,
0.0397196561,
0.0061129155,
0.0281406082,
-0.0883121043,
0.0022294626,
0.0138224596,
-0.0379309468,
-0.020398885,
-0.0277954787,
0.0060003195,
0.0095497109,
0.0171149429,
0.0307449028,
0.0107321115,
0.0322508477,
-0.0172429401,
-0.0664547831,
0.0223463196,
-0.0499446392,
-0.0582951643,
0.060667254,
-0.0361439511,
-0.0154780112,
-0.0020691063,
-0.0547574162,
-0.0635194331,
0.0577741489,
-0.0082798107,
0.066137135,
-0.0470128655,
-0.0377922952,
0.0118342852,
-0.0366685726,
0.0014281406,
0.102306664,
-0.0015305473,
0.0161103345,
-0.0044749631,
0.0128460778,
-0.0020388933,
-0.0155731738,
0.0202994253,
-0.0042707692,
-0.0026577269,
0.0321200527,
-0.0007083032,
-0.0008579231,
-0.0553467087,
0.0105309095,
-0.08649344,
0.0149792815,
-0.0045943651,
-0.0138583351,
0.0050459583,
0.0042757057,
0.0198046491,
-0.0247431509,
-0.053890951,
0.0554345697,
0.0133833354,
-0.0064534494,
0.0307312235,
0.0125454962,
-0.0126987975,
-0.0121018263,
-0.0082085105,
-0.0226370897,
0.0433688946,
-0.0142276557,
0.0061775171,
-0.0188552178,
0.0746105388,
-0.0461759679,
0.0292448178,
-0.0407634787,
-0.0125705618,
0.0265254769,
-0.0312895104,
0.0096005835,
0.0518230386,
-0.0341621302,
0.0265723895,
0.0532457158,
-0.0086666699,
-0.0745101869,
0.0382898226,
-0.0448968373,
-0.0286300443,
-0.0310734306,
0.0263359062,
-0.0099120494,
0.0368941426,
-0.003116311,
-0.0156101845,
-0.0726267025,
0.00031192,
0.0041412041,
0.0110414755,
-0.0491134152,
-0.0015121319,
-0.0033098103,
0.0046312427,
-0.0208349098,
-0.0177309215,
0.0811752155,
-0.0011977657,
-0.0103371367,
-0.0102633787,
-0.0146760587,
-0.0595459603,
0.0447527058,
-0.0151630221,
0.0035767476,
-0.0125539517,
-0.0342953987,
-0.0655683205,
-0.0192880668,
0.0161067154,
-0.0287001692,
0.0702394024,
-0.0109070446,
0.0222113524,
0.0170832537,
-0.0079129394,
-0.0453582071,
0.0429812148,
-0.0392194353,
0.044918213,
-0.0217924975,
-0.0038721061,
-0.0250068307,
-0.0255752504,
0.0251595732,
0.0185173955,
-0.0170724187,
0.0081401234,
-0.0130631169,
0.0166640952,
0.0424714833,
0.0241095759,
-0.0067477128,
-0.0547167584,
0.0064911488,
0.0385303237,
0.0011461168,
-0.0492636748,
-0.0099984165,
0.003176973,
-0.0170846544,
-0.0294708256,
-0.0021304446,
-0.0098526711,
0.0327593461,
-0.0646489412,
0.0135102095,
0.1104174852,
0.0021532078,
-0.0227310974,
-0.0197527148,
-0.0457064174,
-0.0044412734,
0.0492262281,
0.0270240344,
-0.0969603881,
-0.0356273986,
-0.0025519738,
0.0259270407,
0.0312010832,
-0.0416394062,
-0.0083535258,
-0.119862698,
0.0010363463,
0.0138696218,
-0.0521496758,
-0.0628262758,
-0.0198816452,
-0.0206627194,
0.0139574585,
0.0090523902,
-0.0097685205,
0.0010489405,
-0.0006715041,
0.0192078184,
0.0250054076,
-0.0461493619,
0.0436875522,
-0.0273922868,
0.0349809751,
0.0233563781,
0.0344533063,
0.0067536058,
-0.0215721056,
0.0156992935,
0.0037837229,
-0.0030135082,
-0.0015455638,
0.0341875553,
-0.0143550392,
-0.0001353762,
-0.0135376118,
0.0382163152,
-0.0585468225,
-0.0115376497,
-0.0120992148,
0.114551954,
-0.0229174886,
-0.0448272862,
0.0017951198,
0.0134871304,
-0.0136769265,
0.0719633922,
0.0356382243,
0.0303740166,
-0.0365288109,
-0.0281013716,
-0.0055157184,
-0.0503801554,
-0.0534993671,
0.059328109,
0.0266742073,
0.0338986441,
-0.03361772,
-0.0240141954,
0.0524189398,
0.0299968403,
0.0054997611,
0.0166908037,
0.0210794341,
0.0198408496,
-0.0620756298,
0.032537479,
-0.038666375,
-0.0215048399,
-0.0239997953,
-0.0050593871,
0.0268845148,
-0.0420847051,
-0.014470092,
0.0208248477,
-0.0319923423,
-0.0689915046,
-0.0470067225,
0.0228304043,
0.024682587,
0.0528113134,
-0.0342012346,
-0.0045859478,
0.0543776676,
0.0467995629,
-0.0349989086,
-0.0183047242,
0.0300688595,
-0.0085170595,
0.0004316964,
0.0426962972,
-0.0617608614,
0.002399218,
0.017885536,
0.0452225283,
-0.0053022881,
-0.0142277358,
0.0289224647,
0.028606521,
0.0014288233,
0.0266354494,
0.0073492536,
-0.0692784265,
-0.0035038306,
-0.0102980481,
-0.0138806067,
-0.0431393906,
0.0060990974,
0.0278073866,
-0.0223447736,
0.006729411,
-0.0738018975,
0.0252619386,
0.0237283725,
-0.0045168502,
-0.0113135446,
0.0289431568,
-0.0161265265,
0.0472149216,
-0.0139654865,
-0.0199280959,
0.0159033295,
-0.002488361,
0.0163531397,
-0.0427107997,
0.0805623606,
0.036891941,
-0.0193852372,
-0.0267510545,
-0.0123113692,
-0.0715586245,
-0.0745175034,
0.0049208123,
0.0379666649,
0.0878017396,
0.0096588414,
-0.0107405549,
-0.0237019025,
-0.0063145873,
-0.0185495373,
0.032737691,
0.0101145059,
-0.0307096504,
0.0346658453,
0.0456503443,
-0.0154024521,
0.0068020686,
0.0763792172,
0.0130816856,
0.054640606,
-0.0034441862,
-0.020102581,
-0.051568903,
-0.049306374,
0.0131539684,
0.04652768,
-0.0099510923,
0.022518266,
-0.0483262204,
-0.0994585454,
-0.0190167297,
0.0146092465,
-0.0328338891,
0.0160594936,
0.0394587889,
0.0642172918,
-0.0004555704,
-0.0602674708,
-0.0227702502,
0.0406534374,
-0.0200028811,
-0.0003308013,
0.0138517646,
-6.422355997e-33,
-0.0237131082,
-0.0479225703,
0.0407356247,
0.0050454792,
-0.0202836134,
-0.0151195843,
-0.0656189024,
-0.0220472496,
-0.0519967005,
0.0137661323,
-0.0144593343,
0.042320855,
-0.0031882571,
-0.0077347877,
-0.0033916007,
-0.0396933481,
0.0323784649,
0.0040860502,
0.0144666983,
0.0421217866,
0.0664576665,
0.0590224415,
0.0731864646,
-0.0304426029,
-0.0078039137,
-0.0223335493,
0.0226578619,
0.0310735218,
-0.0253924914,
0.0532195494,
-0.0055469349,
0.0416572429,
0.0335034877,
-0.0283932798,
0.0080581373,
-0.0148285199,
-0.0912789106,
-0.047478728,
0.018977318,
0.0105259335,
-0.0322375074,
-0.0441991985,
0.0431349427,
-0.0141933039,
0.0305427127,
-0.0286740847,
0.0334714986,
-0.0102025867,
-0.034439262,
0.0003587966,
-0.0206348039,
0.0076930253,
0.00726511,
-0.0166727528,
-0.0157404616,
0.0274598394,
0.0050307158,
-0.022928942,
-0.0464262143,
0.014984495,
-0.0234153494,
0.0051277988,
0.0377798192,
0.0161132384,
0.0026200528,
0.0581827313,
-0.0208898969,
-0.0454607569,
-0.0509634763,
-0.0156271793,
0.0285077021,
0.0792932957,
0.0097163739,
0.0178706385,
0.0253523942,
-0.0170453358,
-0.0896316692,
0.0117872851,
-0.0112184351,
0.0579299107,
0.0059542004,
0.0159411598,
-0.0021034873,
-0.018062802,
-0.011763447,
0.0090540983,
-0.0337965339,
-0.0425624214,
0.025769446,
-0.0103930719,
0.0214670543,
-0.018797921,
0.0042387424,
-0.0741420016,
0.0260872636,
0.0783643126,
0.0058038495,
-0.0090684174,
-0.0173589587,
0.0304229464,
-0.0675870329,
-0.0331190415,
0.0146029321,
0.010772679,
0.0047956384,
0.0289051216,
0.0295143351,
0.0164216142,
-0.0265204031,
-0.0233582668,
-0.0763483271,
0.0079481183,
-0.0158263706,
0.0113842245,
0.0489046127,
0.0494774431,
-0.0139812957,
0.0233487841,
0.0030538794,
0.004451144,
-0.0171450935,
0.0097154677,
0.009656542,
0.008886449,
-0.021704087,
-0.0169840176,
-0.0273102876,
0.0094468687,
0.0174687523,
-0.0557257198,
0.0025847196,
0.0201530103,
3.028e-7,
0.0361905918,
0.0159130991,
0.00088641,
0.040697474,
0.0100230994,
0.018011,
-0.0211754367,
0.0103977304,
0.0129267359,
-0.0458441526,
0.0244692359,
0.0612179674,
0.0177490618,
0.0283105783,
-0.1327502131,
0.0004580343,
-0.0184327867,
-0.0729665533,
-0.0246018767,
-0.0152621605,
0.0437727571,
0.0535536781,
0.0422736928,
-0.0071183112,
0.0205516126,
-0.0855666175,
0.0558946319,
0.0069440892,
0.007821504,
-0.0042115315,
0.0325860381,
0.0454815589,
-0.0195196476,
0.0248324666,
0.0003745957,
0.039035175,
-0.0014110045,
0.0423179492,
0.0196369067,
-0.050055638,
-0.0085170409,
-0.0224721357,
0.0039394088,
-0.0396615453,
0.0774621069,
-0.0673700273,
-0.0314888768,
0.0161254797,
-0.004022731,
-0.0435765199,
-0.0073117223,
-0.0020539353,
0.0075737205,
0.0048601353,
-0.0111469356,
-0.0214277785,
0.0045365375,
-0.1030612066,
0.0093792295,
0.0216870047,
-0.0362852104,
-0.0352808721,
-0.0110932784,
-0.0144863334,
0.0269029681,
-0.0384990163,
0.0087522082,
2.680733464e-34,
0.0201912839,
-0.0043869135,
0.014010312,
0.0211294815,
0.027822461,
-0.0208728909,
-0.0179827083,
0.0190446861,
0.0242312383,
-0.0875427574,
-0.0080644973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03103v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03103v2 | ContrastWSD: Enhancing Metaphor Detection with Word Sense Disambiguation Following the Metaphor Identification Procedure | 2023-09-06T15:41:38 | 2024-03-23T03:15:42 | Mohamad Elzohbi, Richard Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper presents ContrastWSD, a RoBERTa-based metaphor detection model
that integrates the Metaphor Identification Procedure (MIP) and Word Sense
Disambiguation (WSD) to extract and contrast the contextual meaning with the
basic meaning of a word to determine whether it is used metaphorically in a
sentence. By utilizing the word senses derived from a WSD model, our model
enhances the metaphor detection process and outperforms other methods that rely
solely on contextual embeddings or integrate only the basic definitions and
other external knowledge. We evaluate our approach on various benchmark
datasets and compare it with strong baselines, indicating the effectiveness in
advancing metaphor detection. | [
0.0235040691,
-0.019081004,
-0.0236750748,
0.0570734665,
-0.0014177969,
0.0322334021,
-0.0459538475,
-0.0019078,
0.0186610781,
-0.0366511121,
-0.0031870869,
0.0393496677,
0.0215820726,
-0.044344794,
-0.0141216535,
-0.0381299108,
0.0470685847,
0.0498772077,
-0.0549082197,
0.0169973336,
-0.0565451086,
0.026018288,
-0.0137742609,
0.0505011491,
-0.0198715292,
-0.0555079505,
0.0298248846,
0.0322079025,
0.0319368802,
-0.0501320027,
-0.0192403216,
-0.0130029535,
0.0399081111,
0.0191139262,
0.0000019417,
-0.0559032448,
-0.0202329289,
-0.0347816497,
0.0294821393,
-0.0212390963,
0.1245673969,
-0.000377079,
0.0445653424,
0.0089918561,
0.007624153,
0.0179843605,
-0.0081971362,
0.0282423124,
0.014757446,
-0.0091382144,
-0.0113127753,
-0.0483314246,
-0.0638782829,
0.0471313223,
-0.0400592834,
0.0021095304,
0.0220128335,
0.030883953,
0.0000353692,
-0.0762666911,
-0.0573927462,
0.0415410362,
0.0128246145,
0.0760453492,
-0.02325668,
0.0109244948,
-0.0022952394,
0.0556674376,
-0.0132558951,
0.0393465683,
0.0285186656,
-0.0453524925,
-0.0043565668,
-0.0015860606,
-0.0166450497,
0.0663319305,
0.0261774678,
-0.0354260318,
-0.0055603189,
0.0371015631,
0.0473744348,
0.0373080336,
0.0170665588,
0.0267757159,
-0.0073514795,
-0.001132529,
-0.004648793,
0.0146586858,
-0.0145938154,
-0.0460869521,
-0.0049828291,
-0.0070245736,
0.0102791376,
-0.0066015893,
-0.0007091511,
0.0209877696,
-0.0559703223,
-0.0682800785,
0.0004924046,
-0.0758432895,
0.0305709969,
0.031525895,
0.0075350991,
0.0461349338,
-0.0258003287,
-0.0285543241,
0.0110469796,
0.0517828725,
-0.0575050078,
-0.0411528982,
-0.0575885028,
0.0337679759,
-0.0671826899,
0.0440098792,
-0.0336044766,
-0.0589720272,
-0.0248749554,
-0.0006731419,
-0.0025462683,
-0.0418312624,
-0.0496939197,
0.0057293968,
-0.0376926437,
0.0060539083,
-0.0551863462,
-0.0217688605,
-0.0423332825,
0.0043484662,
-0.0677149966,
-0.0343728475,
0.008586335,
0.0161120184,
-0.0063110348,
-0.0397276692,
0.0152765475,
0.0746697038,
0.013226198,
-0.0278860778,
-0.0561439395,
-0.0523725078,
0.019338429,
0.0263477601,
-0.0390314981,
-0.0219634697,
0.0107048638,
0.0032811738,
0.0395385176,
-0.0438990742,
-0.0095835524,
-0.0169160534,
-0.0295656677,
0.0652488396,
-0.0173727646,
-0.0173644014,
-0.0099011725,
0.0151652535,
-0.0860279575,
0.0428718999,
0.0341735445,
0.0330007523,
0.0364999622,
0.0471142456,
-0.0723081827,
-0.0248317085,
-0.0574849024,
0.0189598743,
-0.0817389265,
0.0140066678,
-0.0348945856,
0.0723571032,
0.0141636366,
0.0425665267,
-0.0492915399,
-0.0114987176,
0.0062307632,
0.0693152249,
0.0426311754,
-0.0090168305,
0.0925737247,
0.0349466801,
-0.0069933212,
-0.0040169489,
0.0273279361,
-0.0310861114,
0.0343779251,
-0.0023892389,
-0.0162280239,
0.0469856523,
0.0093744583,
0.0153743401,
-0.0375697017,
-0.0203935392,
-0.0144546647,
0.0006592127,
0.0134979151,
0.0144511946,
-0.005909265,
0.0073954673,
0.0393819138,
0.0211582948,
-0.0044136248,
-0.0274244472,
-0.0125988508,
0.0726177543,
0.0509655252,
-0.0493415408,
0.0044806646,
-0.0206845216,
0.0310152359,
0.041528251,
0.0021283892,
-0.0018124337,
-0.0014807881,
-0.0243632067,
0.0111820055,
-0.008104342,
0.0155046843,
0.0072652693,
-0.0119593041,
0.0397340432,
-0.0027634928,
-0.047053162,
0.000081394,
0.0400562994,
-0.0239750743,
0.0008708732,
-0.0130922152,
0.0143764243,
0.0193823427,
0.0058468468,
-0.0236063916,
-0.0081588058,
-0.0070869708,
-0.0637973994,
-0.0094956942,
0.0944387093,
-0.0333948843,
-0.0536503084,
0.0250866804,
-0.0721580535,
-0.0123006618,
0.0441166684,
0.0245419648,
-0.0056359717,
0.0409318618,
-0.0235330779,
0.0690130815,
-0.0394832827,
-0.0225324705,
-0.0382836536,
0.0089132404,
0.0108383317,
0.045609355,
-0.0061929212,
0.0355772339,
-0.0000992989,
0.0146248313,
0.0048336964,
0.0935394838,
-0.0084548136,
-0.0233127959,
0.0354296863,
-0.0058398745,
-0.0410797037,
-0.0586158223,
-0.0500307307,
-0.0086501893,
-0.0562398098,
0.0458723418,
-0.0077996678,
-0.0256963428,
0.0554704778,
-0.0177761223,
-0.0434613861,
-0.0201615747,
0.0563868806,
0.0083143329,
-0.0391429961,
-0.0197859015,
0.028131118,
-0.0697679967,
-0.0045979787,
-0.0111657176,
0.041619584,
-0.0451433659,
0.0737203136,
-0.0127256354,
-0.0099657038,
0.0343856961,
0.0127113443,
-0.0528255627,
-0.0282589141,
-0.012543763,
-0.0275173467,
0.0080296313,
0.0472219251,
0.0691321567,
0.0021157321,
0.0009918844,
0.0446473882,
0.0716034845,
-0.0286849905,
-0.0154423816,
-0.0003159602,
0.039844282,
0.0303716436,
-0.0131426128,
-0.0558172315,
0.0102017969,
0.0366425663,
0.0495690294,
-0.0173994526,
0.0239123777,
0.0288187061,
-0.0161523782,
-0.0007441735,
0.026187744,
0.0731287226,
-0.0153965913,
-0.0350145102,
-0.0024220929,
-0.0100930883,
0.0332444198,
0.0017029613,
0.0125329876,
-0.0677750558,
-0.031347163,
-0.0210656859,
0.0356768705,
-0.0516887158,
0.0598641224,
-0.0075705205,
-0.0024407636,
0.024186708,
-0.0688225627,
0.0300766677,
-0.028343372,
0.0635137483,
-0.0199142862,
-0.0033009292,
0.0060178009,
0.0377196372,
-0.0345036723,
-0.0434976518,
-0.039059151,
0.0237269998,
0.0232982822,
0.005455167,
-0.0147071397,
-0.0343657769,
0.0124118263,
0.0234186426,
0.0305272937,
-0.0456960201,
-0.0332951397,
0.0095598325,
0.0548752658,
-0.0368024036,
0.0130577721,
0.0191600975,
0.0792429447,
0.0123028308,
-0.0649394616,
-0.0671497509,
-0.0692917928,
0.0093554314,
-0.0088785952,
-0.0474420451,
0.0322695002,
-0.0103301639,
0.0315073207,
-0.0054468792,
-0.0037028096,
0.0789236426,
0.0657867864,
-0.0131387403,
0.024990635,
0.0043166736,
-0.0259350073,
0.0461582765,
-0.0268743411,
-0.044367902,
-0.0655308366,
0.0234791134,
-0.0192189757,
0.0155640244,
-0.0607532226,
-0.0026124902,
-0.0295826755,
0.0263391659,
-0.0144788017,
-0.0366717912,
0.008627912,
0.0186317936,
-0.0054374565,
0.0186672322,
-0.0029464508,
-0.0414418839,
-0.0450068004,
0.0147040384,
-0.0175796375,
0.0335931517,
-0.0036825545,
0.0061271787,
-0.0436061136,
0.0323284268,
-0.063943468,
0.0387954526,
0.0158337466,
-0.0107237631,
-0.0559854619,
-0.0451002494,
-0.0074989288,
-0.0130606992,
-0.0226639491,
-0.0195665266,
0.0159329139,
-0.017624801,
0.0134682124,
-0.0276592206,
-0.0281740222,
0.0092319176,
0.0379662402,
-0.0353158638,
-0.0040429896,
-0.0571033917,
0.0155499969,
-0.0156439506,
0.0762076452,
0.0295372214,
-0.0116206286,
0.0159345586,
-0.0034044296,
-0.0174400676,
0.0008069398,
0.028284654,
-0.0585688576,
-0.0935219824,
0.0537238978,
-0.0604230426,
-0.0163307432,
0.024688296,
0.0548471548,
-0.0076339776,
0.0273570791,
-0.0785764158,
-0.0391271412,
-0.1016574129,
0.0275854394,
-0.0193320233,
0.046948988,
0.0249508116,
0.0054615242,
0.0685768723,
-0.047759641,
-0.0213027,
0.0680664331,
-0.0090967147,
-0.0120611396,
-0.0162082035,
-0.0296885837,
0.0053215246,
0.0151859252,
-0.0112229818,
0.0192989036,
0.0438185818,
0.0290733892,
-0.0118736243,
0.0336238705,
-0.004587274,
0.0495833643,
0.0245292038,
0.0446446165,
0.0027861297,
0.0274493918,
0.037810348,
0.0208709463,
0.0101974709,
0.1054994911,
0.0196036417,
-0.0123085193,
0.0022690366,
-0.0092672203,
-0.0995810702,
-0.0334424861,
-0.0428693928,
-0.0237171352,
-0.0341053791,
0.001631437,
0.0238121338,
0.0400623009,
0.0333243161,
-0.0633631796,
-0.0204591583,
0.0139404321,
-0.000435278,
0.0918146893,
0.0214307401,
0.0400689952,
0.0112481313,
-0.0344441198,
-0.0009210747,
-0.0221717525,
-0.0583857596,
-0.022812739,
0.0018273868,
0.0196536127,
-0.0129876845,
0.0126003521,
-0.0304090418,
-0.0766223371,
0.0360811353,
0.0106849708,
-0.0384079367,
0.0463652276,
0.0542563871,
0.0434604995,
-0.0273674522,
0.0106748221,
-0.017017724,
0.0045424947,
0.0283931214,
0.0418056063,
-0.0184085574,
0.0204210822,
-0.0252787117,
0.0026393679,
-0.0120858829,
0.0010460948,
-0.0204504188,
-0.0679467246,
0.0402265713,
0.0350017548,
-0.0473227054,
-0.0203786865,
0.0290899985,
0.0143664237,
0.0617726594,
0.017435234,
0.0342288725,
-0.0735327527,
-0.0586166009,
0.084513925,
0.0095129646,
-0.0119407149,
0.0355999805,
0.0111946408,
0.0294045713,
0.0497628003,
-0.0016703804,
-0.0547231287,
-0.0120347142,
-0.0464601964,
-0.0129179889,
-0.0260326304,
-5.39350273e-33,
-0.0225682333,
0.009001378,
0.0016274384,
-0.0323358774,
-0.044052843,
0.0423205942,
-0.023817258,
-0.0412236042,
0.0006552373,
0.0240812115,
0.0196536481,
0.0196401533,
-0.0074437447,
-0.0192934424,
-0.0170981549,
0.0232065488,
0.0485103689,
0.0172548685,
-0.0387496911,
-0.0524929911,
0.0696739256,
0.0169871114,
0.0504365303,
0.0224186219,
-0.0311554223,
0.0201939233,
0.0278325751,
-0.009488998,
0.0597885326,
0.0392306559,
-0.0096293008,
0.0519756228,
0.012287898,
0.0546522737,
0.0067290808,
-0.0273743607,
-0.0697904527,
-0.0494957902,
0.0619376451,
-0.0012587532,
-0.0100382306,
-0.0135031901,
0.0604172572,
0.0169228297,
-0.0120983431,
-0.0137441186,
0.0576313138,
-0.0253966767,
-0.0122263692,
-0.025934035,
-0.0456822515,
0.0042014751,
-0.0314466693,
-0.0350965373,
0.0113059785,
-0.0296030566,
0.0202448592,
0.0727995709,
-0.0830719844,
-0.0079980921,
-0.0331556983,
-0.0452792943,
-0.025955705,
-0.0019901393,
0.0194688644,
0.0852860957,
0.0257360246,
-0.0560978539,
0.045166228,
0.0153926881,
0.0204305016,
0.0047481917,
0.0126420688,
0.0436903797,
0.0816013068,
-0.0267033912,
-0.0069285538,
-0.0008163304,
0.0563093461,
0.0041208086,
0.0377782024,
-0.0148786558,
-0.051288832,
0.0383341834,
-0.0590709038,
-0.0285202824,
-0.0050502387,
-0.0334540829,
0.0336966403,
-0.0199911539,
-0.0172599722,
0.0211240109,
0.0019929849,
-0.0195598621,
0.0129233347,
-0.0402144641,
0.0091206077,
0.0253236685,
0.0033729183,
0.0064998418,
0.0432666205,
-0.0250197556,
0.0117253466,
0.0238465313,
0.0256794225,
-0.0138921896,
0.002449763,
0.0039103054,
-0.0531703755,
0.0095878504,
0.0035528776,
-0.0428673998,
-0.0473776646,
-0.0568227768,
0.0047638793,
0.0151798259,
-0.0086144498,
-0.0180166103,
0.0148637239,
-0.0313373134,
-0.0098355254,
0.036254216,
-0.0426371023,
0.0378420055,
-0.0022415351,
0.0163873509,
0.0002916065,
0.0013634396,
0.0281917844,
-0.0633996874,
-0.0007459071,
-0.0300961304,
2.641e-7,
0.0253196973,
0.0072297337,
-0.0407394096,
0.023475064,
-0.0080625685,
-0.0107068419,
0.01469847,
0.0250031743,
-0.01775245,
-0.0062374678,
-0.0022412455,
0.0212667175,
0.0017496223,
0.0378888808,
-0.0800127611,
0.0566311963,
0.0141542619,
0.0170673393,
-0.0381273739,
-0.0268592183,
0.0620724,
0.0403874144,
0.0569386743,
0.0000641141,
-0.0019988255,
-0.0756232217,
0.0268530697,
-0.0766218677,
0.0486200303,
0.0050439076,
0.0533732362,
-0.0190909654,
0.0296785496,
0.0100095496,
0.0080985976,
0.0381316617,
0.0171854589,
-0.0040255487,
-0.0271341223,
-0.0035823171,
-0.0333216041,
-0.049636893,
0.0008683733,
-0.0436114818,
0.0217501055,
-0.0515151843,
0.007890624,
-0.029256139,
-0.0133975931,
0.0168749075,
0.0599259473,
0.0129996734,
-0.068543762,
0.0232942849,
0.0105251195,
-0.0148222763,
0.0028923657,
-0.070745416,
0.0297667794,
0.0351001211,
-0.036045488,
0.0080524907,
0.0212060511,
-0.0280657187,
0.0068499316,
-0.0794767514,
-0.0137579674,
1.718441875e-34,
0.0349497832,
0.0067894883,
0.0140702706,
0.0136482827,
0.0674966201,
-0.0249188617,
0.0194037762,
-0.0146155814,
0.0016103726,
-0.0255001336,
0.0045068623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.03064v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.03064v1 | A Multimodal Analysis of Influencer Content on Twitter | 2023-09-06T15:07:23 | 2023-09-06T15:07:23 | Danae Sánchez Villegas, Catalina Goanta, Nikolaos Aletras | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Influencer marketing involves a wide range of strategies in which brands
collaborate with popular content creators (i.e., influencers) to leverage their
reach, trust, and impact on their audience to promote and endorse products or
services. Because followers of influencers are more likely to buy a product
after receiving an authentic product endorsement rather than an explicit direct
product promotion, the line between personal opinions and commercial content
promotion is frequently blurred. This makes automatic detection of regulatory
compliance breaches related to influencer advertising (e.g., misleading
advertising or hidden sponsorships) particularly difficult. In this work, we
(1) introduce a new Twitter (now X) dataset consisting of 15,998 influencer
posts mapped into commercial and non-commercial categories for assisting in the
automatic detection of commercial influencer content; (2) experiment with an
extensive set of predictive models that combine text and visual information
showing that our proposed cross-attention approach outperforms state-of-the-art
multimodal models; and (3) conduct a thorough analysis of strengths and
limitations of our models. We show that multimodal modeling is useful for
identifying commercial posts, reducing the amount of false positives, and
capturing relevant context that aids in the discovery of undisclosed commercial
posts. | [
0.0738081858,
0.0669343248,
-0.0264326259,
0.0259355698,
-0.0169867445,
-0.0369992442,
0.0325147659,
0.0334428661,
0.0360868238,
-0.0473663025,
0.0081318151,
-0.0097598638,
0.0049552792,
0.0680945143,
0.0438281484,
-0.0272513982,
0.010631064,
0.0256735515,
0.0668167099,
0.0280263759,
0.055796288,
0.0360034481,
0.0486135036,
0.0163834989,
-0.0401732959,
-0.0684913918,
0.0209159926,
0.0052789645,
0.063767463,
-0.0162735097,
0.0274098851,
0.0522161499,
0.0308534876,
0.0457932875,
0.0000016825,
-0.0265649445,
-0.0244210176,
-0.0404162109,
0.0227685049,
0.0138209052,
0.0596790798,
-0.0521104559,
0.0514399149,
0.014688977,
-0.0276160128,
0.0792123899,
0.0339710787,
0.0638924986,
0.0615193546,
0.0441326424,
-0.0438054316,
0.0002082727,
0.0074550095,
-0.03467438,
0.0324669778,
-0.0479629859,
0.0201528538,
-0.0251604132,
-0.0467773564,
0.0399154685,
-0.0176221747,
0.0477597378,
-0.0137603609,
-0.0108152553,
0.0398322791,
0.0118219033,
0.0524322353,
-0.0138245849,
-0.0280354153,
0.0416987985,
-0.0620981231,
-0.0065755765,
0.0059939832,
0.0043867254,
0.0179729983,
0.0236160569,
-0.0314124264,
0.0440674648,
-0.0214334466,
0.025581995,
-0.0282156561,
-0.0043572974,
0.0064998241,
0.0241623688,
0.0278184582,
-0.0062342868,
-0.0014024115,
-0.0451259017,
0.02809944,
-0.0116016613,
0.0201802459,
-0.0616464503,
0.0013099388,
-0.0233199708,
-0.0014417107,
-0.0122912545,
-0.0385196134,
-0.0202827211,
0.0167430136,
-0.0620998405,
0.0137258237,
-0.035514947,
-0.0251587834,
0.0600837171,
0.0176069066,
-0.0068396004,
-0.0705437362,
0.0432794504,
0.0165694933,
0.0394600853,
0.0117466161,
-0.0169365201,
-0.0113110868,
-0.0170202218,
-0.0589581467,
-0.0446642265,
-0.0694053769,
0.0167776849,
-0.0327312909,
-0.0201923922,
-0.0246881843,
0.0441638902,
0.0092198169,
0.0028647122,
0.0018551555,
0.0000286509,
-0.0038128442,
0.0308565684,
-0.0062830742,
0.0272274129,
-0.0007477581,
0.0819342211,
0.0245438609,
-0.0540858731,
-0.0172312502,
0.0372176617,
0.0096010733,
-0.0562935844,
-0.0437861532,
-0.0546590388,
-0.0454689004,
-0.0427149348,
-0.0050688437,
-0.0301746335,
0.0221241191,
-0.0101058874,
0.0006812694,
-0.0122344717,
0.0134362625,
0.0245334618,
-0.0354134925,
0.0364680588,
0.0565884225,
0.0240242835,
-0.0276442114,
0.0271758065,
0.0344698355,
0.0350441076,
0.0004423605,
0.127282083,
0.0542985126,
-0.0147158783,
0.0005891449,
0.0475210138,
0.0228140466,
-0.0083474126,
0.0104906997,
0.0079999166,
-0.0229261965,
-0.0204421058,
0.0084449993,
0.0247790255,
0.0140058706,
-0.0163663123,
0.1072544456,
-0.0238402821,
-0.0132775586,
-0.0257526971,
0.02527746,
-0.0002137697,
-0.0367406234,
-0.0028879659,
-0.0357061289,
0.0296454243,
-0.0295018442,
-0.0311550815,
0.0575369373,
0.0322196931,
-0.0139906388,
0.0047310484,
0.0203978643,
0.0178478248,
0.0152840763,
0.0169023201,
0.0090298653,
-0.0191211123,
-0.055746235,
0.0175100211,
0.0160432421,
-0.0010806813,
-0.0064010276,
0.0044374219,
0.0507116951,
0.0701720193,
-0.0014503653,
0.0157117117,
0.0717077181,
-0.048080828,
0.0346667394,
0.0399455056,
-0.0187431928,
0.0230753049,
0.0014314761,
0.00313155,
-0.0480178818,
-0.0408354327,
-0.0025247156,
0.0110806599,
-0.0008842266,
0.0346317142,
0.0134779233,
0.0042207907,
0.0158724524,
-0.0135940788,
0.0333212316,
-0.0166979264,
-0.029503433,
0.0579651482,
0.0135165732,
0.0492587015,
0.0316825882,
-0.0359130949,
0.0401951559,
-0.0592276193,
-0.0343042165,
-0.0103550646,
0.0266425516,
0.033797808,
0.0389544107,
-0.0682745278,
-0.070213601,
0.0532882474,
-0.0232357476,
0.0141615784,
0.0915336236,
-0.0053446875,
0.0147340437,
-0.0371420793,
-0.0804730728,
-0.0018893315,
0.0346247479,
0.0372985192,
0.0562675148,
-0.0565189086,
-0.0123491921,
-0.0051927981,
-0.0876002237,
0.0029370801,
0.0085088331,
0.0359315164,
-0.0363558941,
-0.031629134,
0.0196313858,
0.0196506158,
-0.0274003185,
-0.0241555087,
-0.0007665737,
-0.0454257466,
-0.018575957,
-0.0490075462,
-0.0241566356,
-0.020608807,
0.0171031039,
0.0473527387,
0.0123794321,
-0.0300982576,
-0.0344038792,
-0.0172586031,
0.0281556956,
0.0077080242,
-0.0162043367,
0.0147995884,
0.0103277322,
0.00291177,
-0.0182878841,
0.0613987669,
0.0410227962,
-0.0549593493,
-0.0266151633,
-0.0790518224,
-0.0105432887,
0.0026751012,
-0.011254698,
0.0003491908,
0.0055260011,
-0.0088563412,
-0.0033119537,
0.0081646461,
0.0534506217,
0.0482912138,
-0.0136439661,
0.0114675658,
-0.0242797267,
-0.0017249532,
-0.0179000385,
0.0142687783,
-0.0372425169,
-0.0444441922,
0.0297669116,
0.0397913828,
0.0183084942,
0.0174042564,
-0.0080445232,
0.0377645455,
0.0420596637,
-0.0259627365,
-0.0370046906,
0.003848484,
-0.0080473991,
0.030011652,
-0.0332799405,
-0.0454936288,
0.0700649396,
0.0172353163,
0.006049227,
0.0655126199,
-0.0473709516,
-0.0429404974,
-0.00037702,
0.0145858359,
0.0330169536,
0.0277718902,
-0.0217082817,
0.0433219858,
0.010336468,
0.0408794172,
0.0183019694,
0.0314925872,
0.0485257916,
0.0237315893,
0.0267384909,
-0.0083733462,
-0.0284015331,
-0.1351118982,
-0.0062646088,
-0.0279899742,
0.0390441194,
-0.0205895677,
-0.0691440776,
0.0194702875,
-0.001452325,
-0.0553297773,
-0.0223133992,
-0.0341989845,
0.0125379795,
0.0733893886,
0.0216712486,
-0.0083500529,
-0.050489977,
-0.0478968546,
-0.0554985143,
0.0310439989,
-0.0395688377,
0.0040254011,
-0.0522448719,
-0.0300278515,
-0.0068556895,
0.0060805492,
0.033398442,
-0.0306433886,
0.0293366015,
-0.0085434318,
0.0727640986,
0.0448655486,
-0.0041358192,
-0.0063312668,
0.0113939298,
0.0642297491,
-0.017201893,
0.0034650085,
-0.0015332495,
-0.1301947087,
-0.0345502086,
-0.0483104438,
-0.0058459062,
0.0032774492,
-0.0196539909,
0.0080080694,
-0.0774419084,
0.0184791591,
-0.0032422969,
-0.027085444,
-0.0645853728,
-0.0419145301,
-0.0313038975,
-0.0364917926,
0.0175735801,
-0.0243851151,
-0.0344153382,
-0.0217843726,
-0.0143728061,
0.0182795115,
-0.0250234716,
-0.0151766744,
-0.0375215188,
-0.0412626155,
0.0259809811,
0.0121381944,
-0.0162801258,
-0.0476800054,
-0.0113586942,
0.0203141384,
0.022252338,
0.0081230979,
0.0888935253,
-0.0580622889,
0.0150964865,
-0.0042148484,
0.0279685557,
-0.0304824132,
0.0240197126,
-0.028198218,
0.0681148693,
0.0451875106,
-0.0728425533,
-0.0383419842,
0.0225556213,
0.0640726313,
0.037563365,
0.041791331,
-0.0586539842,
-0.0228751954,
-0.0552187711,
0.001206535,
-0.0102436701,
-0.0189133305,
-0.0151915448,
0.0055802055,
-0.0370848179,
-0.0054260031,
-0.028420845,
0.0095444014,
-0.0205640662,
-0.0002439048,
-0.0066999174,
-0.027293941,
-0.027586868,
-0.0051925746,
0.0320558995,
-0.016725935,
0.0777573362,
0.0062641772,
0.0203252099,
-0.0279841255,
-0.0353569463,
-0.0086853001,
0.0255399607,
-0.072876744,
-0.0550453849,
-0.0403929688,
0.0335594751,
0.0104818027,
0.0441559404,
-0.0122636277,
-0.0229555871,
0.0054269996,
0.0874139965,
-0.0331463479,
-0.0098497272,
0.0385454856,
0.0012057581,
0.012339035,
0.0298765637,
-0.0281050242,
0.0203208737,
0.0158777703,
-0.0478928275,
-0.0428158827,
-0.0012751712,
0.0173575208,
0.0018418642,
0.0331938192,
0.0079608755,
0.0125187859,
-0.045556847,
-0.0310539287,
0.0208042562,
-0.0344195031,
-0.0364577733,
0.0148161957,
0.0186463427,
-0.0144927911,
-0.0159419011,
0.0156401843,
-0.0289144553,
-0.0121536078,
-0.0927775204,
0.0491510853,
-0.0022773365,
0.0210949145,
-0.0230748728,
0.0230447911,
0.0003093139,
0.0457628816,
-0.0066757514,
0.0336253308,
0.0144110806,
-0.0102036055,
0.0103831291,
-0.026330078,
0.0088492846,
0.0115016503,
-0.0187677313,
0.0146664372,
0.0014036462,
0.0218248833,
0.0365313254,
-0.0358686447,
0.027490491,
-0.0054596812,
-0.0021408044,
0.0085351728,
0.0314098299,
-0.0407744832,
-0.0535437167,
0.0063985186,
0.0167880598,
-0.0124882897,
0.0244361721,
0.0802058801,
-0.0023457881,
-0.0421408229,
0.0068369638,
-0.0587151051,
-0.0376256295,
0.014427592,
0.0272815209,
0.0611200444,
0.0132824192,
0.0360058546,
-0.0418757908,
-0.0676445514,
0.031574849,
-0.0408380181,
0.0047478434,
0.0558523908,
-0.026563134,
0.0713255331,
0.0555265062,
0.027587831,
-0.0117754489,
-0.0069785123,
-0.0356355011,
-0.025060514,
-0.0220875759,
-6.123321255e-33,
0.0650149733,
-0.08398927,
-0.0572736934,
-0.024429623,
-0.0354659744,
0.0178955458,
-0.0100612948,
-0.0231848285,
0.0337928906,
-0.0003121786,
0.0151650691,
0.0094532659,
-0.0039600916,
0.0241126437,
0.0507619381,
-0.0203723274,
0.029736029,
0.0265177451,
-0.0207942985,
0.0503350645,
0.0632673204,
0.0141451396,
0.0215319842,
-0.0845069587,
0.0564831831,
-0.0159567222,
-0.0639951602,
0.0200930573,
-0.0092145624,
0.0643977076,
-0.0400511436,
0.0833104029,
0.0265589673,
-0.0296236314,
0.0483895019,
0.080757007,
-0.0460434966,
-0.0218595192,
0.0272810608,
-0.0226565488,
-0.0674569681,
-0.0303058326,
0.0458147265,
-0.0099185351,
0.0257727057,
-0.0220451187,
0.0515706092,
0.0034898848,
0.0213839784,
-0.0108197173,
-0.02292924,
-0.000985519,
-0.0672945976,
0.0317966044,
0.0179540906,
0.077786915,
0.0293842684,
0.0782120004,
-0.0404095985,
0.0235623997,
-0.0323499292,
-0.0516311452,
0.0232116673,
-0.0355969183,
-0.040032573,
0.0395578928,
-0.0273075942,
-0.0020230173,
-0.0038958788,
-0.0113615422,
-0.056059476,
0.0520014875,
-0.0013591285,
0.0449461825,
0.0214868672,
-0.0395066068,
-0.0515356213,
0.005016915,
0.0382154286,
-0.0118768979,
0.0084152855,
-0.0316003747,
0.010910077,
0.0212852564,
0.0142385233,
-0.0748827755,
-0.0768083259,
-0.022799436,
-0.0024432777,
0.037089847,
0.0028397746,
0.0894788727,
0.0321212746,
-0.0302419309,
-0.0317213312,
0.0057602539,
0.0155017516,
0.0282539725,
0.0487232693,
0.0227227174,
-0.0328034759,
0.0195594653,
0.0155491773,
-0.0556338914,
0.0043432917,
-0.0447039716,
0.0586956814,
0.0102868369,
-0.0174491629,
-0.0218794085,
0.0053122463,
0.011047503,
-0.0625385493,
-0.0088227699,
0.0054148259,
0.0133038918,
-0.0378108695,
0.0155306766,
0.0124566965,
0.054301735,
-0.001406838,
-0.0361077711,
-0.0138493152,
0.020560639,
-0.0143982023,
-0.0271543004,
-0.0053711827,
-0.0394449644,
0.0254774168,
-0.0821616426,
-0.0236136653,
-0.016592104,
2.568e-7,
0.0060526556,
0.0359192491,
-0.0411550999,
0.013388766,
0.0443918183,
0.0458660685,
0.0342664905,
0.0958968848,
-0.0330209285,
-0.0655266866,
-0.0321072005,
-0.0092194583,
0.0399639532,
0.0041745142,
-0.0158718638,
0.0098922076,
-0.036893636,
-0.0135526136,
-0.058989726,
-0.0037316363,
-0.0110625448,
0.0444456339,
0.0497522503,
-0.0273547098,
0.0047780978,
-0.0105864266,
0.0626976117,
-0.0012902688,
-0.0227409136,
-0.0334860906,
0.0532562584,
-0.0214480404,
-0.0240169447,
-0.0116298143,
-0.0335157588,
0.0312491395,
0.0135317994,
0.0276676379,
0.0130064022,
-0.0396324992,
-0.0390352644,
-0.0245523024,
-0.0081765652,
-0.0264362097,
0.0442183055,
-0.0262969732,
-0.0552424267,
-0.062200442,
-0.0045610936,
-0.010582123,
0.020114027,
-0.0054355529,
-0.0140072219,
0.0254175644,
-0.0206234977,
-0.0360007733,
-0.0078998031,
-0.0495426618,
0.0462793484,
-0.0044608279,
-0.0425964668,
0.0254040249,
-0.0045363773,
-0.003043581,
0.0644824207,
-0.0265082847,
0.0285846554,
1.687599383e-34,
0.0455952026,
-0.0262191482,
0.002647687,
-0.0319272391,
-0.0103921229,
-0.0029151484,
-0.03854331,
-0.0334197022,
0.027391145,
-0.0599664077,
0.0050009382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06364v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06364v3 | Framework-Based Qualitative Analysis of Free Responses of Large Language Models: Algorithmic Fidelity | 2023-09-06T15:00:44 | 2024-02-04T19:46:38 | Aliya Amirova, Theodora Fteropoulli, Nafiso Ahmed, Martin R. Cowie, Joel Z. Leibo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Today, using Large-scale generative Language Models (LLMs) it is possible to
simulate free responses to interview questions like those traditionally
analyzed using qualitative research methods. Qualitative methodology
encompasses a broad family of techniques involving manual analysis of
open-ended interviews or conversations conducted freely in natural language.
Here we consider whether artificial "silicon participants" generated by LLMs
may be productively studied using qualitative methods aiming to produce
insights that could generalize to real human populations. The key concept in
our analysis is algorithmic fidelity, a term introduced by Argyle et al. (2023)
capturing the degree to which LLM-generated outputs mirror human
sub-populations' beliefs and attitudes. By definition, high algorithmic
fidelity suggests latent beliefs elicited from LLMs may generalize to real
humans, whereas low algorithmic fidelity renders such research invalid. Here we
used an LLM to generate interviews with silicon participants matching specific
demographic characteristics one-for-one with a set of human participants. Using
framework-based qualitative analysis, we showed the key themes obtained from
both human and silicon participants were strikingly similar. However, when we
analyzed the structure and tone of the interviews we found even more striking
differences. We also found evidence of the hyper-accuracy distortion described
by Aher et al. (2023). We conclude that the LLM we tested (GPT-3.5) does not
have sufficient algorithmic fidelity to expect research on it to generalize to
human populations. However, the rapid pace of LLM research makes it plausible
this could change in the future. Thus we stress the need to establish epistemic
norms now around how to assess validity of LLM-based qualitative research,
especially concerning the need to ensure representation of heterogeneous lived
experiences. | [
0.0606196858,
0.1043282822,
-0.0419887714,
-0.0036475281,
-0.0177540891,
0.0124798389,
0.0082325796,
-0.0474379808,
0.0125728743,
-0.0311526749,
-0.0088791028,
-0.0498192348,
-0.0018510349,
0.0162041709,
0.0087257838,
0.0054341601,
-0.0002291212,
0.0020622604,
0.0097608585,
-0.0384061337,
0.0130461613,
0.0474373028,
0.021945918,
0.0265718251,
0.0180881713,
-0.0175612308,
-0.002436151,
-0.0116101187,
0.0121214716,
-0.0061627254,
0.0155659495,
0.0327333398,
0.0277081933,
0.0068578632,
0.0000023479,
-0.0495620519,
0.0277238954,
0.0085161757,
-0.0003723665,
0.0527377091,
0.044017382,
0.0357168578,
-0.0289169718,
0.0211701691,
-0.0713180155,
-0.0217293799,
0.0569631793,
0.0123730451,
0.0032970957,
0.0167006254,
-0.0121089919,
-0.04004151,
0.0260480549,
0.0015184734,
-0.0434620269,
0.0078067449,
0.0296634492,
-0.0129631925,
-0.0339504331,
0.0023106725,
-0.0128502194,
0.0343880355,
0.0054863347,
-0.0029164162,
0.0085792542,
-0.0032700782,
-0.0334636569,
-0.0518844463,
0.0276608057,
0.0531949215,
0.0396238267,
-0.0130759887,
-0.0131882895,
-0.0268425699,
-0.0017771916,
0.0521234833,
-0.0531562455,
0.0699253008,
0.0006182343,
0.0149875786,
-0.0127482489,
0.0034133261,
-0.0060315393,
-0.022686759,
-0.0182392746,
0.0681711212,
0.0012236066,
-0.0260938536,
-0.0150064621,
-0.0025000223,
-0.0254924558,
-0.0653478876,
-0.0439093076,
-0.017061675,
-0.0108701112,
0.044252757,
0.0017596931,
0.0422145016,
0.0411569215,
-0.0555384457,
-0.0043664942,
0.0261758938,
0.0263438001,
-0.0329750068,
0.0303145424,
0.0102170492,
-0.0101815443,
-0.0262600053,
-0.0451418087,
0.0063313181,
-0.0477194563,
-0.0333079174,
0.0066306037,
0.027445443,
-0.021493312,
-0.0130057614,
-0.0310272295,
0.0082971193,
0.0014974806,
-0.0018795754,
-0.0560758077,
0.0263806339,
-0.0235244185,
0.0136121213,
-0.0566391796,
0.0185485967,
-0.0514094643,
0.0606376901,
-0.0115185417,
-0.1182077155,
0.052080106,
0.0210904125,
0.0047959997,
-0.0252532624,
-0.0106984824,
0.0013522404,
-0.0124312853,
0.0076721045,
-0.0088040177,
-0.0072997417,
-0.0208756179,
-0.0489171818,
0.0050203595,
-0.055264689,
0.0414466374,
0.0499492511,
-0.0034393475,
-0.0539593622,
0.0087470822,
0.0338781774,
-0.0415354557,
0.0563391857,
0.025820937,
0.0515590198,
0.007011639,
0.0191214308,
0.0710884854,
0.0337982811,
0.0561489016,
-0.0053419466,
0.0107205343,
-0.0443498418,
-0.0039236271,
0.0139415441,
-0.0131065715,
0.0004314001,
-0.0155442702,
0.0485349894,
-0.0257138871,
0.0233234148,
0.0604849197,
0.0874608457,
0.0014964195,
0.0170434956,
0.0685341582,
0.105961971,
0.0280641001,
0.042335391,
0.0312328506,
0.0596109889,
0.0083517525,
0.0068149464,
-0.0233652703,
-0.019953385,
0.0115242098,
0.0011087264,
0.0158415604,
0.019826673,
-0.017440144,
-0.0238430426,
0.0012680573,
0.0324182361,
0.029018933,
0.0344864391,
0.016843481,
-0.0100654811,
-0.002722461,
0.0310765151,
0.0170008987,
-0.0743495002,
-0.0353712589,
-0.075379774,
0.0596163943,
0.0316951051,
-0.0023215311,
0.0358074456,
0.0176051687,
-0.0180386715,
-0.0230052602,
0.0657105893,
0.0430428125,
-0.0079027694,
-0.0293335766,
-0.0174720418,
0.0119771929,
-0.0338368341,
-0.0065221745,
0.0210772306,
0.0038331193,
-0.0111111831,
0.00340872,
-0.0112406081,
-0.0143562267,
-0.0014714835,
-0.0807375535,
-0.0201058239,
-0.0049520819,
-0.0175654944,
0.0193674341,
0.0329965688,
-0.0255465712,
0.0491826087,
0.0062558115,
-0.0040816064,
0.0029158061,
0.0504439883,
-0.0315832607,
0.060309127,
-0.0190884694,
-0.032158237,
0.0146773905,
-0.0022314417,
0.0022368412,
-0.0168853831,
0.0502755269,
0.0009701517,
0.0423643291,
-0.0431499369,
-0.0033494865,
-0.0221136529,
0.0459468178,
-0.018412862,
0.0442558005,
0.0051631406,
0.0062308693,
0.0361775234,
0.0031083163,
0.0481991954,
-0.0462361984,
-0.0142533323,
0.0194266625,
0.0001257392,
0.019347962,
0.0360570624,
-0.0274167452,
-0.0363464504,
-0.0091802999,
-0.0827831253,
0.026198402,
-0.0053917109,
0.0216026492,
0.0136483414,
-0.0031541907,
-0.0270372648,
0.0196502991,
-0.0669653118,
-0.0371272862,
0.0488906726,
0.0440679304,
0.0129271057,
-0.0103656603,
0.0233033951,
-0.0213497058,
-0.004135652,
-0.0346867628,
0.0151640363,
0.0269597732,
0.0447018109,
-0.0332076997,
0.0239292122,
-0.0594197661,
0.0077162716,
-0.0255999062,
-0.0257955119,
0.0212441105,
0.0371740237,
0.0459731109,
0.0563550554,
0.0186066646,
0.008471827,
0.0108225225,
0.013678072,
-0.0344701894,
-0.0062144101,
-0.0208382867,
-0.03465233,
-0.045192413,
-0.0979774296,
0.0082272897,
0.0569974743,
0.0671462119,
-0.0111575704,
-0.0696797743,
0.0885635093,
-0.0183654763,
-0.0409455411,
-0.0042994283,
-0.0167727154,
-0.0302577037,
0.0704103783,
-0.0072503765,
-0.0346943922,
0.0057443976,
-0.0056907632,
0.0119208833,
0.0038865698,
-0.025787618,
-0.0191809665,
0.0466505699,
0.0013846586,
0.0068370732,
0.0302197132,
0.0146378241,
-0.0641992167,
-0.0226161759,
-0.0204685014,
-0.0480742082,
0.0440066233,
-0.0750845,
-0.0059837638,
-0.0065958379,
-0.0186355133,
-0.0375869162,
-0.0210412163,
-0.0091964444,
0.0284341387,
0.0332298093,
-0.0218873583,
0.0243279319,
0.0001678274,
0.0423688591,
-0.0156105869,
0.0063737328,
-0.0127149802,
-0.0123535041,
0.0387768336,
0.0744707808,
0.0250904188,
0.0763424337,
0.0136268036,
0.0411938131,
0.0348946154,
0.0133971861,
0.0647991449,
0.0010489359,
-0.0340069272,
0.0247178953,
0.0117543116,
-0.0411807373,
0.03933594,
0.0770404339,
0.0095727285,
0.007824637,
0.0749764964,
0.0045745727,
0.0231255088,
0.0142233716,
-0.0193251017,
-0.0003969386,
0.0277320445,
0.0284620151,
-0.0867674723,
0.0394418053,
-0.0224913917,
0.0196255352,
-0.0671576634,
-0.0086131133,
-0.0375151113,
-0.124128446,
0.0610935986,
-0.0148836095,
-0.0255545713,
0.0105051883,
-0.0313623734,
0.0049414961,
0.009011236,
0.0325380899,
-0.0033989379,
-0.0181648005,
0.0142988693,
0.0072269398,
-0.0573643968,
-0.0296887904,
0.0505125336,
-0.0028222965,
0.0783782229,
0.0600058138,
0.0615688339,
-0.0130002974,
-0.0523054115,
-0.0155670503,
-0.0639205351,
-0.0070100352,
0.0163215883,
-0.0462811701,
0.011745411,
0.0191191752,
-0.0335283279,
0.0398153737,
-0.0299981218,
-0.0231854916,
0.0185833778,
0.0454858877,
-0.0141629204,
-0.059511587,
-0.0319453403,
0.016956199,
-0.0140477484,
0.0675523207,
0.0339748748,
-0.0603570677,
-0.003743951,
-0.0381362103,
0.0267219562,
-0.0093896035,
-0.0812856779,
0.0164438486,
0.0273809992,
0.0272206943,
-0.0203845091,
-0.0799760446,
-0.0372656211,
-0.0489221662,
-0.0002967998,
-0.0361205526,
0.0403288156,
-0.0432381034,
-0.0284672845,
0.0366785787,
-0.0282957051,
0.0341893025,
0.0146438535,
-0.0170754306,
0.0387850367,
-0.0539173782,
-0.0237217322,
-0.0074903853,
-0.0357104503,
-0.0744031966,
0.0261577014,
0.0122402627,
0.0192157943,
0.0155801633,
0.0351386964,
-0.0385258384,
0.0144078657,
0.0175545402,
-0.0419307463,
0.0433288366,
-0.0108783124,
0.0872136876,
-0.0201335214,
0.0177097432,
0.0111257471,
0.0412732922,
0.0270432197,
0.0144925825,
-0.0365827493,
-0.0995852277,
0.0208922476,
0.0071957423,
0.0306539237,
-0.013805056,
-0.0094875395,
-0.0404455811,
-0.0412382595,
-0.0242048744,
-0.0185798723,
-0.0484339856,
-0.0771498531,
0.0321989022,
0.0092093321,
-0.0222452581,
-0.0237818137,
-0.0813449696,
0.063384369,
-0.0300294235,
0.0312096588,
0.0031432349,
0.0136402715,
0.0248786993,
-0.0000543616,
0.0040074382,
0.0452720076,
-0.0369370095,
0.0588867627,
0.0198993348,
0.0638984293,
-0.021816235,
-0.0049871663,
0.032551229,
0.0100129992,
-0.0485747717,
-0.0968596712,
-0.0172263216,
-0.0077072396,
-0.0193255711,
-0.0277195014,
0.0238615535,
-0.0200962983,
0.0167382918,
-0.0113710202,
-0.00001875,
0.0202646535,
-0.0283538904,
0.0593789071,
0.001083868,
-0.052258607,
0.0057260669,
0.0385757163,
0.010423271,
0.0135044819,
-0.0468640774,
-0.0193110202,
-0.0245315861,
-0.0595165715,
0.0476824231,
0.0084443903,
-0.0139521621,
-0.026237525,
-0.081965737,
-0.0531142093,
-0.0181897469,
0.0259307064,
0.0043548965,
-0.0670876279,
-0.0038396947,
0.0644527152,
-0.0194257591,
-0.0396911018,
-0.0429166444,
0.0141602308,
-0.080349341,
0.008672501,
-0.03661374,
-7.014163036e-33,
-0.0230099522,
-0.0292849354,
0.0083212601,
-0.0466737151,
-0.0434607901,
-0.0309117939,
-0.0256772358,
0.0085990438,
-0.0252625905,
-0.0106898649,
-0.0382563025,
-0.0062391725,
0.0102379546,
0.0312761329,
0.025401039,
0.0114007248,
0.0607695468,
-0.0047025727,
-0.0076712188,
0.0221355762,
-0.0270876829,
-0.0310952421,
0.0219326764,
-0.0434566289,
0.0951246843,
-0.0551157892,
0.0222976636,
0.0029941238,
-0.0169826616,
0.0095260525,
-0.063575469,
0.0513322279,
0.0273786057,
-0.0600178465,
0.014024036,
0.0796448812,
-0.0335722268,
0.0049688788,
0.0647424757,
-0.007698474,
0.0087380633,
-0.0425749756,
0.0210688487,
-0.0135228718,
-0.0473274477,
0.0093285199,
0.0493636988,
-0.0179532301,
0.016663868,
-0.0216918308,
-0.0511598438,
-0.0062749251,
-0.0200271998,
0.0451031215,
-0.0459820479,
0.0748692676,
-0.0212849583,
0.0109520489,
-0.0579526462,
0.0393955149,
0.0145314168,
-0.0168547295,
0.0660824403,
0.0038159855,
0.0479997396,
0.0331321172,
0.0828172043,
-0.0034558545,
-0.0440419801,
-0.0113207689,
0.02355914,
-0.0084219035,
-0.0006368732,
0.099007979,
0.0036132578,
-0.0350374095,
-0.0210916921,
-0.0296046864,
-0.0124018108,
-0.0028670216,
0.0311994962,
0.014968941,
-0.0258291382,
-0.0458693095,
-0.0506683327,
-0.0073573375,
-0.0128051303,
-0.0490280129,
0.0283023119,
-0.0238855891,
-0.0353126638,
-0.0268779602,
0.0407781377,
-0.036425218,
-0.004716259,
-0.0322563089,
-0.0302962214,
0.0169245396,
-0.0015330884,
0.0455141813,
-0.1014896482,
0.0276213866,
-0.0061097788,
0.0047922949,
0.0351700447,
0.0504442118,
-0.0391756706,
-0.008903495,
-0.0530485325,
0.0055591506,
-0.0030696257,
0.0104513681,
-0.0228665415,
-0.0256928708,
0.0090066139,
0.052437678,
0.0124457022,
0.0037348503,
0.0037496442,
0.0026668606,
-0.0273426268,
-0.0396432579,
-0.0221935157,
0.0122244246,
-0.0562961884,
0.0143389823,
-0.036426764,
0.0318004414,
0.0551578775,
-0.0244652797,
-0.0352041386,
0.0200087223,
3.038e-7,
0.0235334691,
0.0293958485,
-0.0053010834,
0.01667572,
0.0375405252,
0.0191696882,
0.0291668773,
-0.009827964,
0.0636263639,
-0.0035643466,
-0.0007372928,
0.0310376044,
0.0303551182,
0.0313429311,
-0.056441661,
0.0275125466,
-0.0592276752,
0.0254018549,
-0.0357385576,
0.068031989,
0.0399223343,
0.0529881418,
-0.0262139942,
0.0084612733,
-0.0390978307,
0.022225827,
0.0525677241,
-0.0363169573,
-0.0340364128,
0.0376850329,
-0.0102403937,
-0.000572657,
-0.0009346727,
0.0430473909,
0.0125482958,
0.0240034312,
0.000197079,
0.0608926341,
0.010703492,
-0.0367408954,
-0.0021016661,
-0.0408537462,
0.0028051715,
-0.0781724527,
0.0675057545,
-0.0754043162,
-0.0495737903,
-0.0487586744,
-0.0147238998,
-0.0222342182,
0.0062618176,
-0.0318095572,
-0.0061022672,
-0.0207015462,
0.0351852775,
0.0167691354,
0.0059618452,
-0.0230242517,
0.00077583,
-0.0145075899,
-0.0450816862,
-0.0807999149,
-0.0138114421,
0.0189565755,
0.0205223914,
-0.0358179286,
0.0487870276,
2.447726147e-34,
0.0361568108,
0.0729076937,
-0.0000370729,
-0.0320420042,
0.0592214651,
0.0054638409,
0.0164961796,
0.0025278602,
0.0503317006,
-0.0705936253,
-0.0175504852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06550v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06550v2 | Synthetic Text Generation using Hypergraph Representations | 2023-09-06T14:14:37 | 2023-12-02T19:29:18 | Natraj Raman, Sameena Shah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Generating synthetic variants of a document is often posed as text-to-text
transformation. We propose an alternate LLM based method that first decomposes
a document into semantic frames and then generates text using this interim
sparse format. The frames are modeled using a hypergraph, which allows
perturbing the frame contents in a principled manner. Specifically, new
hyperedges are mined through topological analysis and complex polyadic
relationships including hierarchy and temporal dynamics are accommodated. We
show that our solution generates documents that are diverse, coherent and vary
in style, sentiment, format, composition and facts. | [
0.0013093477,
0.0162954666,
-0.0012435589,
0.0066445828,
-0.0347187966,
-0.0226839576,
-0.0168158822,
0.0257413369,
0.008547104,
-0.0529686995,
0.0120578054,
-0.0346701331,
-0.0256616995,
0.0550690293,
-0.003432445,
-0.0500229374,
-0.0080781709,
0.0057158652,
-0.00674668,
-0.0155602032,
0.0058322186,
0.0361560695,
0.0052619777,
-0.0065164086,
-0.0625240281,
0.0043414645,
-0.0487447269,
0.047596965,
0.0268793758,
-0.0375028849,
-0.029438531,
0.0274992753,
0.0283676516,
0.0193594452,
0.0000017278,
0.0054718875,
-0.0251998734,
0.0033359707,
0.0344252214,
-0.0303086322,
0.0650550872,
-0.0472640581,
0.000609105,
-0.0246921778,
-0.0418670848,
-0.019405473,
-0.0098732403,
0.0328937843,
0.0494542196,
0.1038613766,
-0.0401127711,
-0.0075745517,
0.022295285,
0.0119709326,
0.0367140248,
0.02357978,
-0.0184314083,
0.0313202441,
0.016059475,
0.0052508293,
0.0028674356,
-0.0318482853,
-0.0109492857,
-0.0445183739,
0.0290527642,
0.015663987,
-0.0191257969,
0.0170864183,
-0.0085109239,
0.0666297674,
-0.0140961651,
-0.0330549367,
0.056039311,
0.0197334811,
-0.0093929432,
0.0407257453,
-0.0482644513,
0.0457233749,
0.0000886454,
0.0506727695,
0.0625781044,
-0.0045768563,
-0.0012488546,
-0.0139203221,
-0.0030492933,
0.0518233515,
0.0312333815,
-0.026255602,
-0.0480609089,
0.0077467859,
0.0113106975,
-0.0342893824,
0.0153282406,
0.0311675929,
0.0090456493,
-0.0133425714,
-0.0691706538,
-0.0286000073,
0.0027246892,
-0.0420247875,
0.0396216512,
-0.0023294471,
0.0376772918,
-0.0069093867,
-0.0273107346,
-0.0443095639,
-0.0353123546,
-0.0063099368,
-0.0235313457,
0.0138230128,
-0.0502792187,
0.0061182147,
-0.0414380543,
0.0760284811,
-0.0632909983,
-0.0199556723,
-0.0245957021,
0.0666386336,
-0.0090571521,
-0.0014934805,
-0.0270567574,
0.0127094248,
-0.0141804209,
-0.0091625443,
-0.0029236712,
-0.0091968756,
0.008415102,
0.0025075183,
-0.0130887246,
0.0333334245,
0.0156499855,
0.0720995218,
0.0350699872,
0.0096171154,
-0.053178519,
0.0552620776,
-0.0173969418,
0.0305809956,
-0.0682886541,
-0.0508671589,
0.0174353849,
-0.0275065415,
0.0355956927,
-0.0955622643,
-0.0007196594,
-0.0348698907,
-0.0293684546,
0.0009138633,
0.0275454465,
-0.0120726889,
-0.0275255367,
-0.0087562762,
-0.0907556713,
0.0004626301,
0.0236785561,
-0.0287682489,
0.0515554063,
0.0254559331,
0.0214825049,
0.0537430122,
0.0177122597,
0.0155833568,
0.0037311376,
0.0047911392,
0.0144030293,
0.0290152486,
-0.0410264246,
-0.0396930799,
0.009232088,
0.0244899839,
0.0288420506,
0.058310926,
-0.0307801757,
-0.002130263,
0.046356786,
0.0068909023,
0.021241216,
0.0640522987,
0.0801213607,
0.0178236812,
-0.0319836773,
0.0724894404,
0.010218299,
0.0206299201,
-0.0168354232,
0.0202878658,
0.0202689674,
-0.0082871877,
-0.0170253161,
-0.0096544204,
0.0119323861,
-0.0078052916,
0.0090302024,
-0.0819381922,
0.0400725454,
0.0253697429,
-0.0609242171,
0.074780345,
0.0300316699,
-0.059080895,
0.0181362946,
0.0188289359,
0.0243974514,
0.0995949581,
0.0162956361,
-0.029979201,
0.0076921033,
-0.012974482,
-0.0178065877,
0.0725485235,
0.0180518012,
-0.0205560923,
-0.0580516309,
-0.0309890602,
-0.0021163365,
-0.035217233,
0.0011684282,
0.0232028607,
-0.0513791032,
0.0202532224,
0.0129972175,
-0.0063885502,
-0.0463144407,
0.0135147311,
-0.004536123,
0.0178684182,
0.0201887339,
-0.0089165326,
-0.0160517152,
0.0565025918,
-0.0267209224,
0.0105623659,
0.0451596938,
-0.0403540097,
-0.0479683131,
0.0107269604,
-0.0133613674,
-0.071041137,
0.0208840277,
-0.0991514698,
0.0157463569,
0.0155145479,
-0.0291855037,
-0.0556819737,
0.0102181286,
-0.0359399021,
0.0438961275,
-0.0472214855,
0.0000584893,
0.0104195075,
-0.0069570811,
-0.0234230869,
0.053886164,
-0.0044728578,
0.0187911782,
0.0171772018,
0.0091837253,
0.0135183251,
-0.033722844,
0.0152116818,
0.0273429435,
0.0262991097,
-0.003593551,
0.0194107741,
0.0206499714,
-0.011276545,
-0.0645889491,
-0.0754677206,
-0.0292764958,
-0.0231745783,
0.0023110313,
0.0555275008,
-0.0110627962,
0.0064525558,
0.0186601337,
-0.037883319,
0.0329810791,
0.0307700653,
-0.0134007605,
0.0520844832,
-0.0084301867,
-0.0119766491,
0.0041848747,
-0.0281214006,
-0.0178115088,
0.0533815473,
0.0345221832,
-0.0042929905,
-0.037488319,
0.032026764,
-0.0112969344,
-0.015601391,
0.0193148535,
0.0156275406,
0.0088194804,
-0.0408198051,
0.0276314113,
0.0055989097,
0.048372943,
0.0459758751,
0.0430781767,
0.0270418208,
0.0068010702,
-0.0228447858,
-0.0851914883,
0.0711696595,
-0.0409947857,
-0.0653444678,
0.0419261865,
0.0221430101,
0.0515319966,
-0.0174736977,
-0.0203535985,
-0.0079875002,
0.0043362491,
-0.0034631079,
0.0052709472,
-0.0060837446,
-0.0195359569,
0.0366533436,
-0.0120092183,
-0.0542822331,
0.0301093943,
0.0116256066,
0.05877579,
0.0010603035,
-0.0175134037,
-0.0536791794,
0.0225464255,
-0.0004734671,
0.0413374826,
-0.006149529,
-0.0028016558,
-0.0244929679,
0.0205879044,
0.0037399919,
0.0065061976,
0.0194791481,
-0.0236442797,
0.021177534,
0.0037091055,
0.0048508858,
-0.0233528018,
-0.0593277775,
0.0692527667,
0.0219656844,
0.0111427177,
-0.0109173609,
-0.0093516605,
-0.007376268,
-0.0365662314,
0.0186823811,
-0.0110178171,
-0.0251495559,
-0.0185657479,
0.1164069176,
0.0467118807,
-0.0027644008,
-0.0066535571,
-0.015329455,
-0.013428404,
0.0442578383,
-0.0417021066,
0.0265686177,
-0.0087240003,
0.0182589665,
-0.0114710657,
-0.0178371128,
-0.0256729387,
-0.010448534,
-0.015389937,
-0.0249084607,
0.0005076018,
0.0905482396,
0.0452107489,
-0.0105253477,
0.0238859002,
0.0104683926,
0.0465941243,
0.0156318229,
0.0041492279,
-0.1078467295,
0.0544498488,
-0.0328526013,
0.0252242722,
-0.0228676107,
-0.0326537564,
0.0315400027,
-0.0766207203,
0.0248212237,
0.0420222133,
0.0083047012,
0.0265095159,
-0.0184157826,
-0.0365219004,
0.0632397011,
-0.0687634498,
-0.0011645705,
0.0034874899,
-0.0160793606,
-0.0040380661,
-0.0109085813,
-0.0017784863,
-0.0480970778,
0.0275827814,
0.0319882147,
-0.0365581028,
0.0686287358,
-0.0021958177,
-0.0307518989,
-0.0197641496,
0.0626431108,
0.0124144703,
-0.037696179,
0.0144999269,
0.0371258222,
-0.0007989095,
-0.0132434713,
0.0595200285,
-0.0280485526,
-0.0288207736,
-0.0185944922,
0.0712781847,
-0.0573854744,
-0.0331446864,
-0.0398436151,
0.0089675514,
0.0664276406,
0.0118310256,
0.0109264618,
-0.0277066994,
-0.0356418043,
-0.0465567373,
0.0019093876,
-0.0660682544,
-0.0339241922,
0.0139784012,
-0.0423130319,
0.0160373319,
-0.0932227895,
0.0162219796,
-0.0339021273,
0.0786602572,
0.004701091,
-0.0166453291,
0.0146751218,
-0.0737334564,
-0.070099093,
0.0058699059,
-0.0066930433,
-0.0275687054,
0.009542427,
-0.0672171861,
0.0639503822,
-0.0244704727,
0.0064180735,
0.0116973035,
0.0021934209,
-0.066353865,
-0.0155375563,
0.0101380702,
0.0110818064,
0.0536066256,
0.0207380131,
0.0031617254,
0.0484026112,
0.0382105038,
-0.0070440536,
0.0233863462,
0.0056228475,
0.0406278335,
-0.0213479791,
0.0185015313,
-0.036520455,
0.0368275717,
0.0093033435,
0.032716997,
-0.0014044293,
-0.0139995832,
0.0213712119,
0.0198894925,
-0.0250124168,
-0.0433722883,
0.0382484421,
-0.0192869306,
-0.0090239914,
-0.0520382114,
-0.0074714296,
-0.0228741709,
0.0096259974,
0.0127210626,
0.0086466484,
-0.0004230968,
0.0190928858,
-0.024551237,
0.0569833107,
-0.0483459607,
-0.012846523,
-0.0388934761,
0.0228431039,
0.0273669846,
0.0021991043,
-0.0325966068,
0.015211707,
-0.0438550562,
0.0097950594,
-0.0288357288,
0.009154778,
0.0248005893,
0.0011186083,
-0.0358691886,
-0.0063986396,
-0.0527529046,
0.0370565318,
-0.0494389124,
0.0359640829,
0.0558333322,
0.0173525978,
0.0382171385,
-0.0640619099,
-0.0136545133,
0.0026004617,
0.0721876696,
0.02919182,
-0.0522608757,
0.0110062091,
0.0017426001,
-0.0293693114,
0.0036656316,
0.0767404065,
0.0406928062,
0.0019925435,
0.0176831074,
-0.0155883087,
-0.0525687821,
-0.0253636707,
0.001471663,
0.0472177453,
0.0183400493,
-0.0107297245,
-0.0584958121,
-0.0218438059,
0.103889212,
0.0366455652,
0.0206579734,
-0.0067188605,
0.0409868434,
0.0009712452,
-0.010812765,
0.0494705997,
-0.0487720482,
0.0503298081,
0.0199494902,
-0.0316317044,
-0.0192701723,
-5.678999451e-33,
-0.0166977365,
-0.0877514929,
-0.0277919415,
0.0250559915,
-0.0663735941,
-0.0094634807,
-0.0440569632,
0.0158442892,
0.0710612684,
0.0297388379,
0.0175517015,
-0.0254473854,
0.0034536524,
0.0558460318,
-0.009674307,
0.0292026196,
0.0297584068,
-0.0243681148,
-0.0232918039,
0.0557524264,
0.0922628716,
0.0080636526,
0.0304699,
-0.0841151103,
0.0074537732,
-0.057693243,
0.0168025084,
-0.0140330559,
0.0347327143,
0.0019364762,
-0.0113211721,
0.0660490096,
0.0242247507,
-0.0042545213,
-0.0124394642,
0.0364166535,
-0.0244478844,
-0.0289819092,
0.0123327198,
-0.036965359,
-0.0231362395,
-0.0954007357,
0.0350101553,
0.0184677485,
-0.0217717774,
0.0242364015,
0.0378994793,
-0.0364958532,
-0.047628969,
-0.121678941,
-0.091445677,
0.0142127406,
-0.0354299918,
0.0434571281,
-0.0222397968,
-0.0131310187,
0.0107895937,
-0.0211979784,
-0.0409400202,
0.0604701452,
-0.0346901342,
-0.0141510367,
0.0252188183,
-0.006882282,
0.0437501818,
0.0636107028,
-0.008785245,
0.0658523589,
-0.0439831801,
0.0924909636,
0.0189633779,
0.0479492657,
-0.0067929029,
0.046774365,
-0.0195297338,
-0.0339087509,
-0.0617136061,
0.0503381304,
-0.0654461235,
-0.0768249556,
0.0494491234,
0.0270048603,
0.0331833735,
-0.0240035672,
-0.0183550157,
0.0007773375,
0.0018291755,
-0.0153740114,
-0.021557793,
0.0180100631,
-0.024257673,
0.0054868129,
0.0069685099,
-0.0314015746,
-0.0345223658,
0.0079011722,
-0.0436977819,
0.0578708351,
-0.0234289858,
-0.0244038347,
0.030655032,
-0.0647717938,
0.0211118348,
0.0085351374,
0.0204930864,
-0.0066563096,
-0.0027480829,
0.0098539786,
-0.0438982807,
0.0073289284,
-0.0063788407,
0.020164622,
0.0293212719,
-0.0218345318,
0.0139223095,
-0.0383342281,
0.0118717132,
0.0532685108,
0.0041670329,
0.0252206642,
0.0262764636,
0.0463093407,
0.0041955546,
0.0541510172,
-0.0554416664,
0.0290446524,
-0.0178602096,
-0.0020959149,
0.047304064,
-0.0640511662,
-0.0193931758,
0.0254177731,
2.468e-7,
0.0169735868,
0.0088872407,
0.0493713021,
-0.0249990132,
0.0390520245,
-0.0213098433,
-0.0007049249,
0.0274936985,
-0.0505391657,
-0.0491406359,
0.0209787898,
0.0206225626,
0.0266484134,
0.0228886642,
-0.0903972685,
0.0494261459,
-0.0128625603,
-0.0430352464,
-0.0720209479,
0.0269292407,
0.0871673897,
0.0148894554,
-0.0235039443,
-0.024090318,
0.0027161092,
-0.007185488,
0.0732682124,
0.0230809692,
-0.0275689475,
0.0147021729,
0.0256098583,
-0.0654956922,
-0.0379314087,
-0.0355137251,
-0.0183337778,
-0.0073762801,
0.0025546397,
0.0572216436,
0.012901919,
-0.0393277854,
0.0435749069,
-0.0513034202,
0.0089534065,
0.0088639008,
0.0279407073,
-0.0379071012,
-0.0405335203,
-0.028113829,
-0.0048937919,
0.0227679051,
-0.0278363097,
-0.067332536,
0.0173515156,
0.0471556447,
0.0189303569,
-0.0006259789,
0.039389763,
-0.0261894353,
-0.0023609332,
0.0315346345,
-0.0676105395,
-0.0228051022,
-0.0031233728,
0.0152064599,
0.0391197391,
-0.0015610714,
0.0273949578,
2.388452992e-34,
0.0373133905,
0.0085595921,
-0.0379468016,
0.0146832131,
0.0019540172,
-0.0116567193,
-0.0251065884,
0.0054727485,
0.0224678572,
-0.091443032,
-0.0051556756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.02915v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.02915v1 | Persona-aware Generative Model for Code-mixed Language | 2023-09-06T11:20:41 | 2023-09-06T11:20:41 | Ayan Sengupta, Md Shad Akhtar, Tanmoy Chakraborty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Code-mixing and script-mixing are prevalent across online social networks and
multilingual societies. However, a user's preference toward code-mixing depends
on the socioeconomic status, demographics of the user, and the local context,
which existing generative models mostly ignore while generating code-mixed
texts. In this work, we make a pioneering attempt to develop a persona-aware
generative model to generate texts resembling real-life code-mixed texts of
individuals. We propose a Persona-aware Generative Model for Code-mixed
Generation, PARADOX, a novel Transformer-based encoder-decoder model that
encodes an utterance conditioned on a user's persona and generates code-mixed
texts without monolingual reference data. We propose an alignment module that
re-calibrates the generated sequence to resemble real-life code-mixed texts.
PARADOX generates code-mixed texts that are semantically more meaningful and
linguistically more valid. To evaluate the personification capabilities of
PARADOX, we propose four new metrics -- CM BLEU, CM Rouge-1, CM Rouge-L and CM
KS. On average, PARADOX achieves 1.6 points better CM BLEU, 47% better
perplexity and 32% better semantic coherence than the non-persona-based
counterparts. | [
0.0096960692,
0.0602482036,
-0.0285852943,
0.0133534633,
-0.0072101895,
0.0150098465,
0.0157116298,
0.001656467,
0.0058636139,
0.0252398346,
0.0091662602,
-0.0024080891,
0.0228462406,
0.071791023,
0.0618818514,
-0.0560557172,
0.013436757,
0.0134565374,
-0.0237282906,
-0.0155836158,
0.0293588601,
0.0607611686,
0.0248838253,
0.0634246692,
-0.0110485265,
-0.02666343,
0.0053019128,
0.048740834,
0.056158606,
0.0127202952,
0.025078766,
0.0529409014,
0.0001235968,
0.036597874,
0.0000020245,
-0.0379284024,
-0.0180344209,
-0.0129396003,
-0.00019923,
-0.0176113117,
0.0377894752,
0.0138190221,
-0.0384913422,
0.0261201654,
-0.0650581196,
-0.0273655709,
0.0674619153,
-0.0068362099,
0.059124846,
0.0631757006,
-0.0221919175,
-0.0420809053,
-0.0053541455,
-0.0132892337,
-0.0115676085,
-0.0017158164,
-0.0139236171,
0.0067233024,
0.0011077379,
-0.0121878339,
-0.005692373,
0.0198462717,
0.0329670906,
-0.006042168,
0.0514429696,
0.0158538148,
-0.0259488039,
-0.0238438472,
0.0197560918,
0.0575567782,
-0.0142452978,
-0.02361794,
0.0208557434,
-0.0032202327,
0.0043609804,
-0.026978083,
0.0001463137,
-0.010862452,
-0.0026572444,
0.0212749075,
-0.0196407996,
0.0369180031,
0.002261179,
-0.0250175688,
-0.0392276645,
0.0147874104,
0.0264918134,
-0.0010921706,
-0.0727073401,
0.0033197992,
0.0350635163,
-0.0708433911,
0.0261139534,
0.0198083948,
-0.0104258014,
0.0086295465,
-0.0589544848,
-0.0591289699,
-0.0049626934,
0.0032974244,
0.0132951615,
0.0476226397,
0.0014055427,
0.000455467,
-0.0222056881,
0.037741892,
-0.0054209982,
0.0039175111,
0.0138311218,
-0.0012516767,
-0.0228650253,
-0.0187170897,
-0.0489522442,
0.0055512749,
-0.0118193682,
0.0042707361,
-0.0526303835,
0.0435338765,
-0.0196396094,
0.0149757033,
0.0080519365,
0.0143662393,
-0.0423302166,
0.0004077267,
0.0028366735,
-0.00154487,
-0.0256761052,
-0.0281901322,
0.0093729161,
-0.0513052754,
0.0259491391,
0.007507008,
0.045699086,
-0.0278103314,
-0.017370753,
0.0456874184,
-0.0297402516,
-0.0032098738,
0.0102868862,
-0.0488359481,
-0.0124108512,
0.0038651917,
-0.0525096059,
-0.074528046,
0.0348289646,
-0.0084486119,
0.0108682867,
-0.1098143533,
0.0091487868,
0.0146981487,
0.0178972371,
0.0367654189,
-0.0398368761,
0.0118520632,
0.0200399905,
0.0028504457,
0.0186303481,
0.0293800291,
0.0504594669,
-0.0104655186,
0.0006381522,
-0.0458110273,
0.0181659553,
0.0431835391,
0.0042772964,
-0.0101479236,
0.0192151554,
-0.0418658964,
0.0319459885,
0.0054738997,
0.0617200471,
0.0644560158,
-0.0308313482,
-0.0107374946,
0.0246332474,
-0.003672051,
0.0247436073,
0.0435301922,
0.0718619972,
0.061528217,
-0.0151750557,
0.0249110367,
0.0253124423,
0.0443307385,
-0.0176562611,
-0.0030631232,
0.0244338512,
0.0710397065,
-0.0219317842,
-0.017886309,
0.0360041857,
-0.0121876774,
0.0619682744,
-0.0369596183,
-0.0096776346,
0.046899382,
-0.0465901904,
0.015385963,
0.0189377777,
-0.1070421487,
0.031198062,
-0.0194254871,
-0.0190264788,
0.1227162108,
0.0445909575,
0.0269266143,
0.0267240759,
-0.0140298354,
-0.0644909739,
0.0532135852,
-0.0197555572,
-0.0061572874,
0.0000441167,
-0.0647221059,
-0.0098882457,
-0.0094933175,
-0.0397265106,
0.0436518826,
0.0402933471,
0.0313571803,
0.0386456549,
0.025567608,
0.0240687039,
-0.0107754609,
-0.0723827109,
0.023420278,
-0.0066124075,
0.0170809366,
-0.0023478961,
0.0259278212,
-0.0155134266,
-0.0001182946,
-0.0240328219,
-0.0414406508,
-0.0293575861,
0.0563757755,
-0.0431408994,
-0.0416911356,
0.026282398,
-0.0859439969,
-0.0198796149,
0.015249677,
0.0134077864,
-0.0370752737,
0.0517947823,
-0.0487284847,
0.0551982336,
-0.0375433043,
0.0145197157,
0.0045245159,
0.0422331728,
-0.0156239644,
0.0442003347,
-0.0093480591,
-0.0028856681,
-0.0050428263,
0.0350855961,
-0.0035247004,
-0.038073767,
0.0079848012,
-0.0138163101,
-0.017955469,
0.0198729876,
0.0041536028,
0.0258414559,
-0.0244643614,
-0.0817504227,
-0.0741718933,
-0.0462988913,
-0.0079480363,
-0.0211421885,
0.0245829485,
0.0418299548,
-0.012888941,
-0.0088658314,
-0.0933094025,
-0.0048880684,
0.0014591202,
-0.0267135166,
0.0453771241,
-0.0290712547,
-0.0201469027,
-0.03341005,
0.0096824765,
-0.0032788757,
0.0485829972,
-0.0082595656,
-0.0120293312,
-0.0458875485,
0.0212182663,
-0.0252088644,
-0.0240498874,
0.0007361879,
-0.040661931,
0.020654792,
0.0221875552,
0.1337115616,
0.0054760338,
0.037578959,
0.0192761309,
-0.0323455855,
-0.0150349755,
-0.0475953743,
-0.0126276212,
0.0206083488,
-0.0216224045,
-0.0049559628,
-0.0928923115,
0.0509802774,
0.0461305045,
0.031841144,
0.0216192678,
-0.1146103367,
0.0426162109,
0.0180273447,
-0.0607746318,
0.0444786437,
-0.0148770539,
-0.0140980473,
0.0326380059,
-0.0344804265,
-0.017498998,
0.0795558617,
-0.0415294021,
-0.0176878702,
0.0284090154,
-0.0072856857,
-0.0237601399,
0.0083811553,
-0.0022753463,
0.0584226586,
0.0133495722,
-0.0424095951,
-0.0342940651,
0.0347182825,
0.0004588539,
-0.0552163199,
0.0173444077,
-0.0083019519,
-0.0145806083,
0.0130130248,
-0.0434982926,
-0.0178577565,
-0.0352284014,
-0.008436868,
-0.0244069174,
0.0835607797,
-0.0339103267,
0.0419038273,
-0.003478246,
-0.0025386242,
0.01958175,
-0.0069495458,
-0.0054164627,
-0.0380892716,
-0.0048012231,
0.0137899192,
-0.0144196292,
-0.0415876172,
-0.043903783,
-0.0098727373,
0.0049969954,
-0.0100312578,
-0.0115195587,
-0.0169862118,
-0.0083714603,
0.0361209437,
0.0312297065,
-0.0385527201,
0.028794704,
0.0550356135,
0.0002866785,
0.0072395653,
0.1050702855,
0.0028586916,
-0.0472651422,
0.0145628797,
-0.0478530526,
0.0674646273,
0.0056534591,
0.0353209935,
-0.0836657584,
0.0024848848,
-0.0136612048,
0.018435277,
-0.0111321555,
-0.0155453775,
-0.0121251941,
-0.0784702972,
0.016651446,
0.0436928347,
-0.0248824023,
-0.0296366382,
0.0330129005,
-0.0289056189,
0.0128537891,
-0.014717496,
0.006040114,
0.0136764254,
0.0030400122,
0.0160032772,
-0.0387993306,
-0.0361757949,
-0.0260689817,
-0.0248160828,
0.0793004185,
0.0821386278,
0.0490857027,
0.025151914,
-0.0587644689,
-0.0832007676,
0.0231079236,
0.0231780447,
0.0043543638,
0.0253736619,
-0.0326937772,
-0.0238440558,
-0.0454267003,
0.0273325294,
-0.0287374761,
-0.0274301544,
-0.0201494377,
0.0039825449,
-0.0038193068,
0.0012382369,
-0.0081431344,
0.011497763,
0.0157933068,
0.040920943,
0.0561869666,
-0.0595758781,
-0.0163950436,
-0.0495570861,
0.0609763637,
-0.0733237043,
-0.0396688208,
-0.0076655466,
0.0157028362,
-0.0820625275,
-0.0611497685,
-0.0299403239,
-0.0138193779,
0.0496603325,
0.0030801222,
-0.0349160917,
0.0446672216,
-0.0270141829,
-0.0485292412,
-0.0505497716,
-0.0680303946,
0.0545773283,
-0.0521448515,
-0.0434703827,
-0.009523022,
-0.0597040169,
0.0260430425,
0.0032380738,
-0.0799190402,
-0.0589193627,
0.014650262,
0.0206535906,
0.0192358214,
0.0626242384,
-0.0386601053,
-0.0609205551,
-0.0154643375,
0.0184262618,
-0.0292677227,
0.0463922098,
0.0238902252,
0.0321983732,
-0.011393344,
0.002803951,
-0.0232785493,
-0.0175398514,
-0.0171593875,
0.0130385803,
-0.0807167664,
-0.0771074072,
0.0097052949,
-0.0020868375,
-0.0226332881,
-0.034789741,
0.0029266605,
-0.01129709,
-0.0209409408,
-0.0444111079,
-0.01316207,
-0.0336182192,
-0.0572772808,
0.0416864306,
0.0163457729,
0.0284545794,
0.0046423455,
-0.0369343497,
0.0216086879,
-0.0015169156,
0.0133998403,
0.0074682799,
0.0389716737,
0.0309694614,
0.0037157766,
-0.0153539274,
0.022661848,
-0.0128494361,
0.0438141301,
-0.0051107951,
0.01546044,
-0.0125656091,
-0.0180398822,
0.0199091658,
0.0455597639,
-0.0201866738,
0.0200450644,
-0.0005288656,
-0.0208404027,
0.0249279309,
0.0400769673,
0.0943360403,
0.0314805172,
0.029600719,
0.0093917111,
0.0429299809,
-0.0119234379,
-0.0775917396,
-0.0339134932,
-0.0144639472,
-0.0223310106,
-0.0275674723,
0.066331163,
-0.0169133116,
-0.0185356755,
-0.0610519536,
-0.0032805926,
-0.0410840102,
-0.0045604329,
0.0233018585,
0.0293340907,
0.0102781635,
-0.0110908188,
-0.0769362748,
-0.0560242049,
0.0320434943,
0.0342822112,
0.021148406,
-0.0020948332,
0.0367240161,
0.0376116298,
-0.0392303877,
0.0052639837,
-0.0372889675,
0.035435155,
0.0142919831,
-0.0269883033,
0.0133413039,
-6.416943581e-33,
-0.0540468097,
-0.023126943,
-0.0179534499,
-0.0127913291,
-0.0478582457,
-0.0192987248,
-0.0761457011,
-0.0045240438,
0.0155795449,
-0.025526559,
0.0051758024,
-0.0148409288,
0.007905311,
0.0216710027,
0.0004968463,
0.0230412651,
0.0709845871,
0.040888153,
-0.0188856479,
0.0439842008,
0.0295390412,
0.0095035136,
-0.0074292193,
-0.055355303,
0.0018083751,
-0.0438876487,
-0.0197273213,
-0.034177158,
0.0611970946,
0.039653834,
-0.0059026727,
0.0237398017,
-0.0110036079,
0.0202627052,
-0.0222675148,
0.0314119719,
-0.0509883277,
-0.0122416429,
0.0018708754,
0.0396480225,
-0.0174623653,
-0.0964184999,
0.0371065736,
-0.0322761647,
-0.0285454672,
0.0043575675,
0.0514161512,
0.0225392152,
0.0392867178,
-0.0502014793,
-0.0794387758,
0.0316196457,
-0.0347662009,
-0.004084107,
-0.0241991822,
0.0529126823,
0.0111690313,
0.007270914,
-0.0674288124,
0.0413113534,
-0.0398034267,
-0.0045333067,
0.0744774491,
0.0396259502,
0.014900337,
0.0539367124,
0.0253757481,
0.0150522841,
-0.0634723827,
0.0424790941,
0.0359115303,
0.0029894894,
0.0205675196,
0.1060191914,
-0.0216905251,
-0.0378490277,
0.0078854607,
0.0399750583,
0.0046869717,
-0.0506231003,
0.0318096168,
0.0688078329,
-0.0387221575,
-0.0209999308,
-0.000654913,
-0.0425514877,
-0.0092998454,
-0.0622895919,
-0.0139777055,
-0.0298704784,
-0.0485227369,
-0.0250747707,
0.0194823369,
-0.0444817916,
0.0048258575,
0.0101492098,
-0.0381951295,
0.0419221893,
-0.0135955531,
0.0463753231,
0.0019089724,
-0.0221203882,
0.0965990275,
0.0211020671,
0.0532659143,
0.0439558886,
0.020327244,
0.0163582321,
-0.0780335963,
-0.0185005441,
-0.0129637057,
0.0339294188,
-0.0138393221,
-0.0238776859,
0.0167003032,
0.0161672402,
-0.0375017263,
-0.0150728635,
0.0292908829,
0.0086538531,
-0.0337140895,
-0.006621772,
-0.0127240373,
0.0224248618,
-0.0511115491,
0.0135346241,
-0.0390468501,
0.030809097,
0.0616093911,
-0.0307382736,
-0.0336474404,
0.0005038948,
2.825e-7,
0.0157747846,
0.0170645081,
0.0501404181,
-0.0078478819,
0.0416141301,
0.0420606025,
0.0314724334,
0.0554840267,
0.0144791435,
-0.0309334155,
-0.004393945,
0.0405492038,
0.0646362975,
0.0179019179,
-0.0509781279,
0.033730574,
-0.0197303053,
0.0167646967,
-0.0486915372,
0.0425486155,
0.0883909464,
0.0334958434,
0.0331361331,
0.0049908399,
0.0232911073,
0.040522851,
0.0449570902,
0.0073924982,
-0.0128067173,
-0.0041443179,
-0.0420618393,
-0.0262462385,
0.0189023614,
0.0021162669,
-0.0049158894,
0.0061471746,
0.0584913492,
0.0354552977,
-0.0326467454,
0.033158578,
0.0164430607,
-0.0162303802,
-0.0296345446,
-0.0516040847,
0.0295067988,
0.0089807184,
-0.019119015,
-0.0007614386,
-0.0445893705,
0.0032282516,
0.0031014208,
-0.0221438129,
-0.0675249845,
0.0416065156,
0.0349035896,
-0.0244142227,
-0.009385691,
-0.0467367582,
-0.0378565155,
-0.0331588462,
-0.0110567287,
-0.0182141084,
-0.0365662128,
0.0338615626,
0.0427145325,
0.0007672262,
0.0415508635,
2.445195161e-34,
-0.0115957027,
0.0367449671,
0.0119754011,
-0.0494372025,
0.0402260013,
0.0009633867,
-0.0028373101,
0.0509231314,
0.0271265395,
-0.0293498561,
-0.0282111373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.02914v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.02914v1 | Leave no Place Behind: Improved Geolocation in Humanitarian Documents | 2023-09-06T11:20:02 | 2023-09-06T11:20:02 | Enrico M. Belliardo, Kyriaki Kalimeri, Yelena Mejova | cs.CL | cs.CL | Geographical location is a crucial element of humanitarian response,
outlining vulnerable populations, ongoing events, and available resources.
Latest developments in Natural Language Processing may help in extracting vital
information from the deluge of reports and documents produced by the
humanitarian sector. However, the performance and biases of existing
state-of-the-art information extraction tools are unknown. In this work, we
develop annotated resources to fine-tune the popular Named Entity Recognition
(NER) tools Spacy and roBERTa to perform geotagging of humanitarian texts. We
then propose a geocoding method FeatureRank which links the candidate locations
to the GeoNames database. We find that not only does the humanitarian-domain
data improves the performance of the classifiers (up to F1 = 0.92), but it also
alleviates some of the bias of the existing tools, which erroneously favor
locations in the Western countries. Thus, we conclude that more resources from
non-Western documents are necessary to ensure that off-the-shelf NER systems
are suitable for the deployment in the humanitarian sector. | [
0.052335266,
0.0258692931,
0.0326826721,
-0.0249306168,
-0.0084834872,
0.0499638207,
0.0419541299,
-0.0242739543,
0.0204349235,
-0.0609839596,
0.0154220201,
-0.0014595145,
0.0014307749,
-0.0125596523,
0.013629429,
-0.0530144945,
0.0063884603,
-0.0108139664,
0.0218162686,
0.0255948976,
-0.0443149693,
0.0154602928,
-0.020948017,
0.0588389859,
0.0672562718,
0.0540089831,
-0.009870477,
0.0073746513,
0.0576315857,
-0.0673785806,
0.0047885403,
0.0001162352,
-0.0411605425,
0.005431491,
0.0000019398,
-0.0290666092,
-0.0519830585,
0.0349620245,
0.0100685516,
-0.0251363665,
-0.0132139763,
-0.091057539,
-0.030824272,
-0.009105158,
-0.0288788956,
-0.0417544991,
0.0421204418,
0.0476764701,
0.0348673165,
0.074638024,
-0.0021213717,
-0.0191242434,
0.0330694579,
0.0325811096,
-0.0122112613,
0.0172358491,
-0.0123315537,
-0.0260025524,
0.0335682817,
0.0391376317,
0.0470831431,
0.0438935943,
-0.0423867218,
0.0287968032,
-0.0000793703,
0.0438623168,
-0.0854552686,
0.0299707334,
0.0042083231,
0.0009628481,
0.0084959818,
0.0109847784,
0.0692935064,
0.0193002019,
-0.0240066908,
-0.0195014384,
-0.0005632553,
-0.0316215828,
-0.0250612125,
0.0210732091,
0.0186677836,
0.0315258503,
-0.0013474963,
0.0173865054,
-0.0014239078,
0.0449459478,
-0.0149015235,
-0.0279629491,
-0.0229292121,
0.0295532644,
-0.0313961245,
-0.035734728,
0.0603372231,
0.011172574,
0.0393778011,
-0.0221470483,
0.0045689587,
0.0078639379,
0.0163292922,
-0.0607299507,
-0.0271460712,
-0.0121175768,
-0.0161729921,
0.0479331985,
-0.0422169603,
0.0066232705,
0.0357838199,
0.0154553773,
0.0021978947,
-0.0025778203,
-0.0766612664,
0.0002778306,
0.0053591575,
0.0288618747,
-0.0081112813,
0.0111699803,
-0.049851954,
-0.0361364447,
0.0110225743,
0.0285406169,
0.0184518155,
-0.0034251336,
0.0243275557,
-0.0052786311,
-0.0237636007,
0.0364073999,
-0.026936939,
0.0241070744,
-0.0639181957,
-0.0225126389,
0.0209040567,
-0.0228362679,
0.048608806,
0.0252607316,
0.0050342022,
0.0352999009,
0.0294201355,
-0.0661317483,
-0.0795818046,
0.0352083743,
0.0121885538,
0.0017021165,
0.0213467032,
-0.0528806411,
-0.005198644,
0.0262983311,
-0.0083254119,
-0.0223707519,
0.0090841483,
-0.0342084393,
-0.0705563128,
0.0610116757,
-0.0331384353,
-0.0086835613,
0.0720347911,
-0.0201743711,
0.0645914525,
0.0309684835,
0.0286819376,
0.022139119,
0.0755485222,
0.0052407072,
-0.0064701848,
-0.0041540675,
-0.0362801775,
0.0163872726,
0.0187671389,
-0.0120955342,
-0.0333147943,
-0.0214026477,
0.0253751576,
-0.0312197171,
0.0130624101,
0.0162681472,
0.0561853871,
0.0724380016,
-0.0124687897,
-0.0430295542,
0.0223543197,
0.0598930344,
-0.0388405994,
-0.0350823775,
-0.0294599235,
-0.0491830893,
-0.0096106473,
0.0156562831,
0.0407850929,
0.0837111101,
-0.008878625,
-0.0154400785,
-0.0308021102,
0.0027289407,
-0.0113495309,
0.0148333386,
0.051471211,
-0.0336945467,
-0.034984909,
0.0537952706,
0.0153460549,
-0.0315388218,
0.0162083879,
0.0040474073,
-0.057674896,
0.0653253272,
0.0241905563,
-0.0405973755,
-0.0523624234,
-0.0293824393,
-0.0150815053,
0.0244872551,
0.0057809427,
0.0408478715,
0.0451358333,
-0.0287665762,
-0.0390613899,
0.0511883982,
0.0148479398,
-0.0137395132,
0.0375220515,
0.0801836699,
0.028223101,
-0.0412686504,
-0.0401601531,
0.0265621319,
0.0345109478,
-0.0266575161,
0.0045450618,
0.0177022889,
-0.0169258378,
0.0419590995,
-0.0014503062,
-0.0004201996,
0.023879271,
-0.0385453478,
0.0110533386,
-0.0039616143,
0.030745212,
0.0159007907,
0.007530049,
-0.0432240292,
0.006143074,
0.0143837389,
-0.0133865457,
-0.0136348633,
-0.0318965726,
0.0177127309,
0.0107047353,
-0.0162179898,
0.0869879425,
0.0322049521,
0.018643178,
-0.0468530618,
0.0445954911,
-0.0153168077,
0.0327999406,
-0.054138653,
-0.0185017176,
0.0228882134,
0.0109774992,
-0.0156010101,
0.0123717785,
-0.0203272365,
-0.0338094234,
-0.0091079883,
-0.0107414126,
-0.0100690434,
-0.0724146366,
-0.0991388559,
0.0031009105,
-0.0067563714,
0.0609978437,
0.0110539235,
0.0013029636,
-0.0376209728,
0.0021625089,
-0.0006670629,
-0.0708542615,
-0.0087385224,
-0.0073447465,
0.02054305,
-0.0117783193,
0.0270849541,
-0.0013756366,
0.0090457452,
-0.0204465967,
0.0207565818,
0.0110499142,
-0.0816533267,
-0.0556883886,
0.0499983132,
-0.0535021126,
0.0054879058,
0.0055430038,
-0.0389091074,
0.0099362899,
0.0138729708,
-0.0396522507,
0.0164327603,
0.0032322658,
0.0340333655,
0.0074305967,
0.0135921026,
-0.014280214,
0.0029928696,
-0.0292643551,
0.0530240014,
-0.0240790881,
-0.0374848917,
0.0114131449,
0.0177214779,
-0.0226285812,
0.0241306182,
0.0181409344,
-0.0417550132,
-0.0513689704,
-0.0190967657,
-0.016180085,
0.0289587658,
0.0151966615,
0.0238263272,
0.0045282659,
-0.0205423534,
0.020478325,
-0.0303449742,
0.0167742763,
-0.0366638191,
-0.0322233066,
-0.058099106,
0.0411379598,
0.0041819494,
0.0047325804,
0.0278682373,
-0.0747002512,
0.0474925898,
-0.0213847999,
-0.0032871093,
-0.0250349231,
-0.0355656408,
-0.0087607363,
-0.0051581389,
-0.0149779469,
-0.0374935679,
-0.0102279074,
-0.026392052,
-0.0195069332,
0.0132350847,
-0.0052009625,
-0.0225411449,
0.0187326632,
0.0788208097,
0.0577955469,
0.1072615683,
0.0054704538,
-0.0185362119,
-0.0145571567,
0.0570204295,
0.0244166385,
-0.0082113668,
0.0117595345,
0.0457147434,
-0.0589162931,
0.0208239947,
0.0002434522,
-0.0197711736,
0.0212811306,
0.0244454667,
0.0377083123,
-0.0876458213,
-0.0321148001,
-0.0372661836,
0.0378419571,
-0.0103223529,
0.0141123682,
0.0867206603,
0.05530148,
-0.0579730645,
0.0036486315,
-0.0175394714,
-0.0053324904,
0.0329099558,
0.025657827,
-0.0148121305,
0.0116299903,
0.0209394842,
0.0071934215,
-0.0554178096,
-0.0794166178,
0.0198968928,
-0.0805690587,
0.046913363,
-0.0230443738,
-0.0390816815,
-0.0116639808,
-0.0732802898,
-0.0158732366,
0.0130591867,
-0.0631067231,
-0.0538747348,
-0.030941708,
-0.0004607801,
0.0157639403,
-0.0764256343,
-0.0539605916,
-0.0329869539,
-0.076053828,
0.0405965485,
0.0310911927,
0.053402368,
-0.0121423192,
0.0099584768,
-0.0247127153,
0.0226804614,
-0.0072990269,
-0.0025340349,
0.0564451143,
-0.0014819447,
-0.0378247276,
0.0018578852,
-0.0265854895,
-0.0288669784,
-0.007474991,
0.0304614436,
0.0342236087,
-0.023921594,
0.058879178,
-0.0010677017,
0.0211398471,
0.0303141326,
0.0219179131,
-0.0410976261,
-0.006616354,
-0.0285892803,
-0.0094772354,
0.0315705575,
-0.0295531973,
-0.0189637057,
0.0419579372,
-0.0624644756,
-0.1146516129,
-0.0629448891,
-0.0393981524,
0.0476143099,
0.0562755652,
-0.005667205,
-0.018544225,
0.0449119583,
0.0242131464,
-0.0529680811,
0.0414630882,
0.0171862114,
-0.0137564633,
-0.0270121284,
-0.0072968458,
0.0153476754,
0.0398537926,
-0.0164870396,
0.0313331708,
-0.0171942338,
-0.0437546968,
0.022591047,
-0.0179676022,
0.0180593785,
-0.0253771264,
-0.0206234753,
-0.0016804892,
0.0137905069,
0.0586037114,
-0.0470640808,
-0.0345204845,
0.0123180998,
-0.0186277982,
-0.0052515748,
-0.0017398359,
0.0047375406,
0.0589191578,
0.0065802899,
0.0158414207,
-0.0604397319,
-0.0044367616,
-0.0257297922,
0.003911166,
0.0946157873,
-0.0322366953,
-0.0469493493,
-0.0395765454,
0.0071309861,
-0.0256724898,
0.0314798839,
-0.013687538,
0.0232248548,
0.0352840014,
0.0190888308,
-0.0195103213,
0.1079696342,
-0.0062735346,
-0.0507713035,
-0.0047269496,
0.0184070244,
0.0070741498,
0.0725622624,
-0.0309304111,
-0.0081574032,
-0.0008918162,
0.0191002171,
0.0349416882,
0.0256405231,
-0.0529825017,
-0.0117062666,
-0.0072803209,
0.0274575725,
-0.012783654,
0.0607224666,
-0.0556067489,
-0.0050482517,
-0.0680381507,
0.0551214628,
0.0747039244,
-0.0067231767,
0.0454338603,
-0.0043718508,
-0.0160718802,
0.0268038064,
-0.0149803804,
-0.0123372441,
-0.0253239255,
-0.038075868,
0.0061463085,
-0.0384608619,
0.0545786321,
0.0226585809,
0.0158409793,
-0.0049394318,
0.0524650626,
-0.0679992139,
-0.0010505613,
-0.0371887647,
0.0231211893,
-0.0284730121,
-0.0269247945,
0.0224426426,
-0.023338696,
-0.0404467173,
0.0354906768,
-0.0248334948,
-0.0553723164,
-0.0192539282,
0.0165522806,
0.0038170626,
-0.0036785735,
0.0050305096,
-0.071764864,
0.0134698814,
-0.0369203351,
-0.0202482101,
0.0183512047,
-5.932957659e-33,
-0.0149786342,
-0.060556367,
-0.0015825746,
-0.025133688,
-0.0210022088,
0.0478530936,
0.0010911652,
0.0061126933,
-0.0074457251,
-0.01946689,
-0.019139858,
-0.0123740369,
0.0513894819,
-0.0048939479,
-0.0131565081,
-0.0058440738,
0.0014000646,
0.0521888621,
-0.0232855808,
-0.029462494,
0.0753392503,
0.0337717123,
0.0969202071,
-0.1036705673,
0.0315848552,
0.0207896028,
-0.0259976983,
-0.0229477361,
0.1206511855,
0.0462776572,
-0.0412011743,
-0.0038585891,
-0.0014493652,
-0.0739834607,
0.0229897797,
-0.013103324,
-0.0974058881,
0.0061325179,
-0.0016496179,
0.015229946,
0.0109688332,
-0.033830151,
0.0084814373,
0.0257435832,
-0.0120385997,
0.0530832261,
0.0228570998,
0.0028064155,
-0.0606601797,
-0.0254791826,
-0.0719053224,
0.0398389921,
-0.0273070112,
0.0418914147,
0.0063925264,
-0.0041549522,
0.008002609,
0.0291485414,
-0.0367029198,
-0.0027267684,
0.0392446145,
0.0603802316,
0.0319157653,
-0.0288246535,
-0.0100270538,
0.0597049408,
-0.0187609009,
-0.0044995407,
-0.0057480293,
-0.0356309526,
0.0041633192,
-0.0202500299,
0.0199507736,
0.0532456227,
0.0203478076,
-0.0316600949,
-0.0542780347,
0.0898702666,
-0.0424723029,
0.0067942077,
-0.0221411344,
-0.0295846611,
-0.0444880985,
0.0110949567,
0.0151236989,
-0.0375209153,
-0.0099116219,
-0.0133905737,
0.0305703059,
0.0100890072,
-0.0375272185,
0.1180640683,
-0.004508771,
0.0066323043,
0.0080420673,
0.0192352142,
0.0321557,
0.0606797226,
-0.0269607324,
-0.012134498,
-0.0341932662,
-0.0195971075,
-0.0062974812,
0.0143149383,
0.0146009158,
-0.0177673679,
0.0192440618,
-0.0092942538,
-0.0563929193,
0.0260453168,
0.011166242,
0.0372451544,
-0.0298880003,
0.0354874693,
-0.0152254077,
-0.0592452139,
0.020221319,
-0.0179823618,
0.0581027828,
-0.0035227058,
0.01523278,
0.0150521137,
0.0166948996,
0.0349855423,
0.006942675,
0.0126788374,
-0.0202039257,
0.065604791,
-0.0199796837,
-0.018197868,
-0.012543682,
-0.0149919959,
2.659e-7,
0.0588293411,
0.0389377438,
0.0258902814,
-0.0612117387,
-0.0420639403,
0.0059495973,
0.0526911765,
0.0373847187,
-0.0044039614,
0.0433561653,
0.0236118566,
-0.0204660315,
0.0288213007,
0.0607584603,
-0.1318429112,
0.0171907246,
-0.0082811201,
-0.0073328516,
-0.0618695058,
0.0179349612,
0.0067381072,
0.0580624007,
-0.0166188404,
-0.0066109351,
-0.0544037074,
-0.0402886458,
-0.0025013944,
-0.0443960279,
-0.031904228,
0.0004095953,
0.0382230729,
-0.0059007313,
-0.0298079252,
-0.0426554307,
-0.0327135026,
-0.008135559,
0.0489621386,
0.072250016,
-0.0354228802,
-0.0177392252,
-0.0588768162,
-0.0646286607,
-0.0026697596,
-0.0612825677,
0.0626772642,
-0.0028190955,
-0.0089650117,
0.0236679856,
-0.0223529097,
0.0198820978,
0.0226667207,
0.0059312717,
-0.0296244174,
0.0379652232,
0.035554789,
-0.0380990691,
-0.0212962776,
-0.0611031912,
-0.0079217153,
0.0223470293,
0.0334231108,
0.014349252,
0.0186109673,
0.0093587376,
0.0312308762,
0.0028922167,
0.0243578441,
2.294066306e-34,
-0.0344261788,
0.0239049774,
-0.0167312585,
0.0148104206,
0.0286506712,
0.0320320278,
-0.0504596867,
0.0127979517,
-0.0086498819,
-0.0076044598,
0.0418169461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.02912v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.02912v1 | On the Challenges of Building Datasets for Hate Speech Detection | 2023-09-06T11:15:47 | 2023-09-06T11:15:47 | Vitthal Bhandari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Detection of hate speech has been formulated as a standalone application of
NLP and different approaches have been adopted for identifying the target
groups, obtaining raw data, defining the labeling process, choosing the
detection algorithm, and evaluating the performance in the desired setting.
However, unlike other downstream tasks, hate speech suffers from the lack of
large-sized, carefully curated, generalizable datasets owing to the highly
subjective nature of the task. In this paper, we first analyze the issues
surrounding hate speech detection through a data-centric lens. We then outline
a holistic framework to encapsulate the data creation pipeline across seven
broad dimensions by taking the specific example of hate speech towards sexual
minorities. We posit that practitioners would benefit from following this
framework as a form of best practice when creating hate speech datasets in the
future. | [
0.0607754253,
0.0993540213,
-0.0279806238,
0.0146306762,
-0.0065144058,
0.0433081128,
0.0260633137,
0.0056908359,
-0.0013137882,
-0.0648290515,
-0.0017524656,
-0.0292849019,
-0.0040582051,
0.0022463107,
-0.0169461258,
-0.0338274688,
0.0225450136,
0.0649751052,
0.0328799672,
-0.0077690799,
0.0663483515,
0.0127574801,
-0.0055135442,
0.0283941571,
-0.0759890676,
0.0194643997,
0.0536881685,
-0.023756545,
0.0129691996,
-0.0172045529,
0.0503947325,
0.0180115271,
0.0151449684,
0.0451639816,
0.0000016661,
-0.0367858335,
0.0292644259,
0.0015955109,
-0.0057515046,
-0.0745899007,
0.0674348548,
-0.0497205406,
0.0019038478,
0.0425654426,
-0.0146243153,
0.003105137,
0.0594534613,
0.0380265377,
0.0682595372,
0.0519486032,
-0.0176285896,
-0.0616547875,
-0.0011246769,
0.019384997,
-0.0006500055,
0.0762511045,
0.04445998,
-0.0486702658,
-0.0626141801,
-0.0266818926,
-0.0127190845,
-0.0081066182,
0.0189801902,
0.0549135581,
0.0100507932,
-0.0461682267,
-0.0742740333,
-0.0359974876,
-0.0055666026,
0.037124373,
-0.0314872935,
0.0044147926,
0.0204174649,
0.0053892359,
-0.0399285108,
-0.0334276929,
-0.0094556836,
0.0206173994,
-0.0462988652,
0.0157575849,
-0.0152467992,
0.0031890422,
0.0586983413,
0.0689739734,
0.0239364505,
0.0446311794,
-0.0253717378,
-0.0286056865,
0.0046609133,
-0.0267052744,
0.017048642,
0.0476297364,
0.0225164965,
-0.0236081108,
0.0015396636,
0.0346249789,
-0.0345349014,
-0.0399503671,
0.0165526904,
-0.0665634274,
0.0427843072,
0.0365889631,
-0.0219579116,
-0.0255273823,
0.0162558947,
0.0185859781,
0.0144848553,
0.0068440437,
0.0065158322,
-0.0162755884,
-0.03128713,
0.0245627426,
0.0180811789,
-0.0271159839,
-0.0015257169,
0.0809684247,
-0.0437377729,
-0.0191540215,
-0.0713207275,
0.0012233458,
-0.0221975558,
0.0154784592,
-0.0028034162,
0.014278762,
-0.034448646,
-0.0245211478,
-0.0438551679,
0.0324595682,
-0.0366802886,
-0.0644575059,
0.0379289687,
0.0375848897,
-0.0207505394,
-0.0141445352,
0.0450600311,
0.081371136,
0.0442913659,
-0.0234031025,
-0.0303646605,
-0.0380829647,
-0.0316216461,
-0.0267933179,
0.04448843,
-0.0503251366,
0.0522714891,
-0.0038226419,
-0.0364338495,
-0.0636979714,
-0.0154852169,
0.0216462947,
-0.0239374824,
0.0945870206,
-0.0019420382,
-0.0195152462,
0.0450192355,
0.0159460511,
0.0166891981,
0.0659318194,
0.0151125733,
0.016823424,
0.061216034,
0.0004190382,
0.0056151114,
0.0379798152,
0.0530813821,
0.0278981179,
-0.0230409075,
0.0514045097,
-0.0510412119,
-0.0291597545,
-0.0003796798,
0.0143303107,
0.0121718794,
-0.077200748,
0.022363143,
0.0811735466,
-0.0163305141,
0.007820745,
0.0482096039,
0.0285887253,
-0.0346533209,
-0.0490811057,
-0.0416603684,
-0.0696452782,
-0.0127298962,
-0.0536198504,
0.0030678404,
0.0450061336,
-0.0263363905,
-0.051737573,
-0.069838196,
0.011607199,
0.0464808829,
-0.042092748,
0.0123026697,
0.0246566813,
0.0255446136,
0.0257074106,
0.0462659784,
-0.0121011417,
0.0193713102,
-0.017932184,
0.0058548516,
0.0496539362,
0.0047638491,
-0.0164534617,
0.0127420658,
-0.072282806,
0.0052439691,
0.0142644951,
-0.0079418942,
-0.0217628237,
0.0150007773,
-0.029382702,
-0.0268250052,
0.0516103469,
0.0064635272,
0.0140402932,
0.1032032743,
0.0139105543,
0.00220045,
0.0335883833,
-0.0462919995,
0.0403056294,
0.0304357987,
-0.0298554543,
0.0084379138,
0.0091092885,
0.0560348704,
0.023468513,
-0.0259446688,
-0.0768128112,
-0.0082432376,
0.0182430651,
-0.0259417519,
-0.0043654521,
0.0020459569,
0.0164867267,
0.0162429977,
-0.0525817052,
-0.0246941447,
0.0564664938,
0.0002902736,
0.0450549759,
0.0369564258,
-0.032171458,
-0.0300157461,
-0.0136632677,
-0.0531191565,
-0.041015394,
0.0385299176,
-0.0121178776,
0.0483037829,
-0.0211105328,
0.0026912699,
0.0301821884,
-0.0379876643,
0.0480600968,
0.0285996366,
-0.0460933521,
-0.0346059315,
-0.0437603071,
0.042513065,
-0.0009269979,
0.0059450078,
-0.0017822539,
0.0329420678,
-0.0524624549,
-0.0103539852,
-0.0099751391,
-0.0327163227,
-0.0015401506,
-0.0059612747,
-0.0301189367,
0.0193946324,
-0.0003211172,
-0.0627161041,
0.0568884313,
0.0239348765,
0.0116337147,
-0.055238314,
-0.0180124622,
-0.0023478549,
-0.0241686944,
0.0036092119,
0.0046496498,
0.0106434207,
-0.0339220203,
0.0348019898,
-0.0444165245,
-0.0331445076,
0.0164166074,
-0.0138105629,
-0.0224847253,
0.0350349508,
0.0509415418,
-0.0314179026,
-0.0073778885,
0.0553231835,
0.090109393,
0.0158150904,
0.0008041143,
0.0172490571,
0.0028587114,
-0.0353811644,
0.0510999598,
-0.0033603609,
-0.045804061,
0.0077705039,
0.0633580536,
0.0392658524,
-0.0155321462,
-0.0428622663,
0.0317536704,
-0.0760383829,
-0.0534249805,
-0.04408985,
-0.045469638,
-0.0344034396,
-0.0337919556,
-0.0445100591,
-0.0486647226,
0.0493466854,
0.0091194399,
0.022203533,
-0.0372592695,
-0.0229210798,
-0.0225342829,
0.0583916456,
0.0008319144,
0.0148251047,
-0.0439719185,
0.0048583592,
0.0313160196,
-0.0131426472,
0.0194749869,
-0.0154978391,
-0.0112646343,
-0.0296398979,
0.0092794271,
-0.0043862453,
-0.0376901329,
-0.0811114833,
-0.0337474495,
-0.037494842,
-0.0399746858,
0.0328094848,
0.0041427626,
-0.0144992964,
0.0211609267,
0.0161768775,
0.0036555943,
0.0250231251,
0.0032210175,
0.0435977131,
-0.0265625734,
-0.0356452465,
-0.0056808051,
0.017188523,
0.0335796215,
-0.0592993349,
0.0399559587,
0.0014026276,
0.0156528242,
0.0132448748,
0.0300474446,
0.0234538633,
0.0200654119,
0.0263807066,
-0.0405818745,
0.013684121,
-0.0064040571,
0.0053458018,
0.0614734814,
0.0344559364,
0.0042715026,
-0.001137777,
0.0195594225,
-0.0227789506,
0.0130768921,
-0.0337272249,
-0.0825097114,
-0.0024477765,
-0.0200453047,
0.0321962163,
-0.1153130084,
-0.0486124568,
-0.0133605357,
-0.0303150862,
0.0318886712,
-0.0314964242,
-0.0513971448,
-0.0427115001,
-0.0178592261,
0.03760162,
-0.0186292566,
0.0426826589,
-0.0526879653,
0.0316396952,
-0.0030325751,
0.0219668932,
-0.0927482545,
-0.028731985,
0.0242065787,
-0.001583406,
0.0387896337,
0.0184995197,
0.0664369315,
-0.038612891,
0.0137566058,
0.0248606019,
-0.0125327623,
-0.0277487896,
-0.0586937182,
0.0581016839,
-0.0020231833,
-0.0715653598,
-0.0189261064,
0.0547135808,
-0.0219508596,
-0.0012546793,
0.0302232448,
0.0106045753,
0.0365249291,
0.0136257196,
-0.0752963051,
0.0209630392,
-0.0146240145,
0.0787563995,
0.0072263489,
-0.0439707972,
0.056411162,
-0.0835327432,
-0.0112520074,
-0.0183809903,
-0.1047540456,
-0.0062090419,
-0.0275123678,
-0.0084620444,
-0.0149753727,
-0.0328962766,
0.0416628197,
-0.0052661016,
0.0372957177,
-0.0239197295,
-0.0131791281,
-0.0124648884,
-0.0886733159,
0.0269536022,
0.0201128181,
0.0295192059,
0.0101973852,
-0.0239491276,
-0.0352022387,
-0.0015671218,
-0.0364852324,
0.045431748,
-0.0114479568,
-0.0137496246,
0.0909404606,
0.0181582291,
0.012355431,
0.0070062177,
0.0085291741,
-0.038525898,
0.0589747913,
0.0604530238,
-0.0343944766,
-0.0311489254,
0.0367907695,
-0.0127676334,
0.0023085719,
-0.0062039308,
0.0149686215,
0.0487018935,
0.0448575988,
-0.0738384277,
-0.0477628224,
0.0323158689,
-0.0122175803,
-0.0127157411,
0.0414614119,
0.0021276397,
-0.0311748479,
-0.041410502,
-0.0359530337,
0.0010315327,
-0.0614755079,
-0.0120415837,
-0.0042361203,
-0.0166124385,
0.0127480859,
-0.0818270892,
-0.0109543437,
-0.0499631502,
0.0181365721,
-0.0591261871,
0.0406890288,
0.0455212146,
0.0454072654,
0.0163607784,
0.0077060722,
-0.0013702384,
0.0313504003,
-0.0264852811,
-0.0317964144,
0.0245626159,
-0.0116134603,
0.0297878552,
0.01320606,
0.0347493626,
-0.0359321237,
0.0280685164,
-0.0161135886,
-0.0593728833,
-0.0322813466,
-0.05720108,
-0.0138088781,
-0.0026355798,
0.0005512854,
-0.0256717298,
-0.0186096616,
0.004097438,
-0.0092106489,
-0.0431924015,
0.0078960499,
0.0376515165,
-0.0457020961,
-0.0283845607,
0.000950662,
0.0128506562,
0.041054219,
0.0286738016,
-0.0438600257,
-0.0192558337,
0.0009085743,
0.0257989112,
0.0117169917,
0.0373306386,
0.011885955,
-0.0573227741,
-0.0312080886,
-0.0087180277,
-0.057691846,
0.0536829345,
0.0088332975,
0.0254934262,
0.066300258,
-0.012302788,
0.016825784,
0.0105216494,
0.0040291199,
0.0064176237,
-0.0581292026,
0.0112913651,
-4.979331622e-33,
-0.0104960687,
-0.0317853913,
0.0016720502,
-0.0152112022,
0.0164628886,
-0.0075822473,
0.0719226971,
0.0015994816,
-0.0040051308,
0.0066987481,
0.0075464076,
0.0476806127,
0.0066414014,
0.0042871125,
0.0180968884,
-0.0211195983,
0.0270642787,
-0.0474711023,
-0.0179033317,
-0.0264596716,
0.0322079882,
-0.010766549,
0.0418255813,
-0.074563168,
0.0718861148,
0.017997114,
-0.0188914891,
0.0055882139,
0.0192818921,
0.0547115728,
-0.0199570283,
0.1267274469,
0.041120775,
-0.0305068977,
0.0078961197,
0.0382362083,
-0.0372816771,
-0.0050168801,
0.0247986,
0.0348404199,
0.0401431099,
0.0172449332,
0.0162144862,
0.0071642501,
-0.0412389711,
-0.0152566489,
0.0471386276,
-0.0654865727,
0.0295319799,
-0.0243506785,
-0.0362277366,
0.0329025835,
-0.037290331,
0.0190577209,
0.0121687129,
0.0222232062,
0.0243680682,
-0.0054171192,
-0.0572099276,
0.0280085616,
-0.0027723876,
-0.0142122125,
-0.01491368,
0.0123942196,
0.035110347,
0.0628892481,
0.0471686907,
0.0115158837,
-0.0136999637,
0.0262829922,
0.0290265847,
0.034876164,
0.0282596964,
0.0583365485,
0.023245791,
-0.0824710801,
-0.0263919644,
-0.0209808592,
0.0538564511,
-0.0279374905,
-0.0041469419,
-0.0447645746,
-0.0642796084,
-0.0491340719,
-0.0243236423,
-0.0615039319,
-0.0092521794,
0.0021791535,
0.0249052923,
-0.0212096833,
-0.0252377689,
0.0070222914,
-0.0156637114,
-0.0232424848,
-0.0013536455,
0.0512650833,
-0.0397966169,
-0.0150923701,
0.0338474214,
0.0208837818,
-0.0509598181,
-0.0151209636,
0.0055467431,
-0.0269076396,
0.0518399291,
-0.0226436052,
0.0498026125,
0.0353721716,
-0.051869411,
0.0079521136,
0.0040441286,
0.0813055634,
-0.0231746789,
0.0459467396,
0.0042408016,
0.0635060892,
-0.0020285975,
-0.0108116288,
0.0325505659,
-0.0400819369,
-0.0099114357,
0.0159977861,
-0.0369308479,
0.0079266457,
0.0147839999,
-0.0271427073,
-0.0013066467,
-0.0303065926,
0.0371054299,
-0.0723808631,
0.0308903102,
-0.0800845399,
2.248e-7,
0.0039871512,
0.0093132742,
0.0067662406,
0.0380865484,
0.0030675286,
0.0145695787,
0.0573999882,
0.0257734302,
-0.018342888,
-0.017846847,
-0.0280348547,
0.0400588512,
-0.00271583,
0.0572101474,
-0.0094054826,
-0.0322330929,
-0.0389093645,
0.0091382824,
-0.0415964723,
0.017895326,
-0.0210448336,
0.0873548165,
0.0793243796,
-0.0527580492,
-0.0412717015,
0.0062510716,
-0.0149490386,
-0.062647514,
0.0032256665,
-0.002111942,
0.0748717561,
0.0349362865,
0.0168733075,
0.0087145846,
-0.0166672785,
0.0187544264,
-0.0014356447,
0.0230224021,
0.0351762287,
0.0062796785,
0.0093142791,
-0.0179082714,
-0.0408017449,
-0.013729021,
0.0518122502,
0.0084232995,
-0.0162909031,
-0.0465015806,
-0.0187508017,
-0.0055737165,
0.029236231,
-0.0065144696,
0.0081111165,
-0.0147283813,
0.0408136509,
-0.0321339443,
0.0134113161,
-0.0670831501,
0.0209363755,
-0.0063616754,
-0.0267520621,
-0.0260817781,
-0.0141377626,
-0.0123624047,
0.0333622694,
0.0467672572,
0.0397950783,
1.521287136e-34,
0.0040281378,
-0.0153519325,
-0.0091996584,
-0.0627032071,
0.0236202292,
0.0056599556,
0.0073568369,
-0.0147155644,
0.0322265774,
0.0302936584,
0.0066703032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.02902v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.02902v1 | ViCGCN: Graph Convolutional Network with Contextualized Language Models for Social Media Mining in Vietnamese | 2023-09-06T10:51:34 | 2023-09-06T10:51:34 | Chau-Thang Phan, Quoc-Nam Nguyen, Chi-Thanh Dang, Trong-Hop Do, Kiet Van Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social media processing is a fundamental task in natural language processing
with numerous applications. As Vietnamese social media and information science
have grown rapidly, the necessity of information-based mining on Vietnamese
social media has become crucial. However, state-of-the-art research faces
several significant drawbacks, including imbalanced data and noisy data on
social media platforms. Imbalanced and noisy are two essential issues that need
to be addressed in Vietnamese social media texts. Graph Convolutional Networks
can address the problems of imbalanced and noisy data in text classification on
social media by taking advantage of the graph structure of the data. This study
presents a novel approach based on contextualized language model (PhoBERT) and
graph-based method (Graph Convolutional Networks). In particular, the proposed
approach, ViCGCN, jointly trained the power of Contextualized embeddings with
the ability of Graph Convolutional Networks, GCN, to capture more syntactic and
semantic dependencies to address those drawbacks. Extensive experiments on
various Vietnamese benchmark datasets were conducted to verify our approach.
The observation shows that applying GCN to BERTology models as the final layer
significantly improves performance. Moreover, the experiments demonstrate that
ViCGCN outperforms 13 powerful baseline models, including BERTology models,
fusion BERTology and GCN models, other baselines, and SOTA on three benchmark
social media datasets. Our proposed ViCGCN approach demonstrates a significant
improvement of up to 6.21%, 4.61%, and 2.63% over the best Contextualized
Language Models, including multilingual and monolingual, on three benchmark
datasets, UIT-VSMEC, UIT-ViCTSD, and UIT-VSFC, respectively. Additionally, our
integrated model ViCGCN achieves the best performance compared to other
BERTology integrated with GCN models. | [
0.0659524202,
0.0414857939,
0.0118583785,
0.0469502211,
-0.0026190756,
0.0180646423,
-0.0408966728,
0.020216424,
0.0358749293,
-0.0458665192,
-0.0197114609,
-0.0473484285,
0.0116770295,
0.0000808897,
0.0020145641,
-0.0115595581,
0.0062932153,
0.0478821769,
0.0152013814,
-0.0231602807,
0.0292295236,
0.0418123491,
0.0445529334,
0.0218194705,
0.015519294,
-0.0073064091,
0.0397419296,
0.0600430481,
0.0076932828,
-0.0484582372,
0.0373670161,
0.0421085432,
-0.0169691648,
0.0633285344,
0.0000020079,
-0.0156100579,
-0.0033100159,
-0.0154515198,
0.0133425193,
0.0325215794,
0.0557935834,
-0.0351646245,
-0.0001700989,
0.0477152355,
-0.0444071814,
-0.0234063603,
0.0232759845,
0.011796671,
0.0185709987,
0.0674803555,
-0.0268546268,
-0.0110135311,
0.0092260614,
-0.0421881601,
-0.0108283134,
-0.0345001444,
0.0283437204,
-0.0107758883,
0.0185012538,
-0.0225508381,
-0.0382293575,
0.0131513085,
0.0381120965,
-0.0300561432,
0.0355004705,
0.0256702323,
-0.0531734452,
0.0090622716,
0.0219119787,
0.1016954184,
-0.0359163843,
-0.0470067784,
-0.0094923601,
-0.0181803796,
0.0058195326,
0.0097289616,
-0.0239971075,
0.0051875124,
0.004608274,
0.0734991282,
0.0111292265,
-0.0046314411,
0.0546783507,
0.0409508236,
0.0206632167,
0.0050213686,
-0.0183808915,
-0.0175129697,
0.0103888093,
0.0261176694,
-0.0819933414,
-0.010568752,
0.0209585093,
0.0243417565,
0.0037051868,
-0.0059915525,
-0.014714947,
-0.0427789465,
0.0411912203,
-0.1181468144,
-0.0205273628,
-0.0068023736,
-0.0249056816,
0.0201636665,
0.0132842856,
0.0087778326,
-0.0258252118,
0.0730646551,
-0.023917025,
-0.0282500219,
-0.049332317,
-0.0068620699,
-0.0312850848,
0.0442762449,
0.007630338,
-0.0349415392,
-0.059250474,
0.0191794429,
-0.0285143554,
-0.0226528961,
0.0222680531,
0.0542047136,
-0.0108624035,
0.0179901812,
0.0347856693,
0.0129381977,
0.0256025232,
0.0269373879,
-0.0221743695,
-0.0202004761,
0.0285387374,
0.0273644291,
0.0606294461,
-0.0146549903,
0.0019703847,
0.0129793324,
0.0044588381,
-0.0412692316,
-0.0449745655,
0.0298765823,
-0.0146475863,
-0.0450847,
0.0187116247,
-0.073007457,
0.0034807248,
0.0163907595,
0.0093826763,
0.0156518538,
0.0226105135,
0.010868934,
-0.0536905713,
0.0633429214,
0.0092192143,
-0.0088014062,
0.02035271,
0.0081572616,
0.0179774985,
0.0802450255,
0.0322813913,
0.0391088091,
0.0565236658,
0.0021729516,
-0.0390892103,
0.0087772273,
0.0050739259,
0.0176932793,
0.0058470205,
-0.019528022,
-0.0576784536,
-0.0142221637,
0.0027836508,
0.0680867806,
-0.0046202256,
0.017011594,
0.0312188081,
0.0192151275,
0.0132542551,
0.0108775413,
0.0285134837,
0.0345560908,
-0.0043676305,
-0.0016542787,
-0.0400953814,
-0.0128315091,
-0.0302743427,
-0.0065434636,
0.0250762012,
0.0033559678,
-0.0464434214,
-0.0147550413,
-0.0007077647,
-0.0234383401,
0.0976914465,
-0.0064380975,
0.0485896841,
-0.0060508717,
-0.0324881598,
0.0286851507,
0.0461749732,
-0.0143860811,
-0.0059173033,
0.0035540482,
-0.016405452,
0.0110865403,
0.0190477539,
-0.0178367756,
0.0285048727,
-0.0187158193,
0.0212867707,
0.0178704225,
0.0418598093,
-0.0120521318,
0.0038806638,
-0.0313952975,
-0.0204532333,
0.0136832548,
0.009220398,
-0.0037954459,
0.0130766621,
0.0592593923,
0.0210770089,
-0.0543303788,
-0.0450603291,
0.0011622526,
0.0363944508,
-0.0072731189,
0.0439794138,
0.0115163736,
0.0124939727,
0.052299656,
-0.0061797672,
-0.0019863346,
0.0298686009,
-0.0300421808,
-0.0383938551,
-0.0190704539,
-0.0380588211,
-0.0810203925,
0.0584703833,
-0.0103640389,
0.0036472273,
0.0432029441,
-0.0563084856,
-0.0156512428,
0.0593023226,
-0.0204680376,
0.0770675018,
-0.0409040377,
0.0076416633,
-0.0629707426,
0.049627766,
0.00806404,
0.0711231828,
-0.0421927199,
0.0182695612,
0.0063124951,
0.0137752676,
0.0216065552,
-0.0250809137,
-0.0220118202,
0.0134528019,
0.0172228143,
0.0252461787,
0.0202173851,
0.0077416236,
-0.0155337527,
-0.005186961,
-0.1403919756,
0.0184068736,
-0.0520192571,
0.0048737396,
0.0030237937,
0.0060208593,
0.0033592216,
-0.0302450769,
-0.015026073,
0.0231737364,
0.0164989773,
0.0336188115,
0.0005120545,
-0.0150604164,
0.0294591319,
-0.0449572913,
-0.0560029633,
-0.0159260891,
0.0548015982,
0.0203672294,
-0.0749176294,
0.0145739773,
-0.0122784264,
-0.0094579738,
-0.0184171498,
-0.005265607,
-0.0385172144,
-0.0214889739,
0.0095283119,
-0.0058886814,
0.0073410929,
0.0075216168,
0.0537018739,
-0.0048331073,
0.0198907163,
0.0003490574,
-0.0122534912,
-0.0348420218,
0.0071843667,
-0.0159657262,
-0.0072634206,
-0.011863105,
0.0072072381,
0.0077559729,
-0.0014275908,
-0.0350695178,
-0.0681941286,
-0.0273669679,
0.0306566656,
-0.0078358939,
-0.0441472568,
-0.0152315646,
-0.0533077791,
-0.0524489917,
-0.0245825164,
0.0542327277,
0.006791573,
0.0137034515,
-0.0194661152,
-0.0629406199,
-0.0466464758,
0.0280148722,
0.0571441874,
0.0191900115,
-0.0069127004,
-0.0315688662,
-0.0057434812,
-0.0155044701,
0.0280956645,
-0.0489183292,
0.014032078,
0.0484054349,
0.0132418554,
0.0053196419,
-0.0270915646,
-0.0222438388,
-0.0405563042,
-0.031550929,
0.0309729837,
-0.005638896,
-0.0111607946,
0.0438794233,
-0.0022530328,
-0.0470446385,
-0.0188847482,
0.0115427375,
0.004236402,
-0.0155381747,
0.0988212526,
0.0249943826,
-0.0498160571,
0.0111725191,
-0.0129762441,
0.0148124462,
0.0318250358,
0.0104474034,
0.014951027,
-0.028657794,
-0.0224821754,
-0.0076513682,
0.001321194,
-0.0179492887,
-0.0275591686,
0.0438955426,
-0.0122563392,
0.0371493287,
0.0872393325,
0.0268134978,
-0.0696740448,
0.0089460658,
0.0181836691,
-0.0023252803,
0.0188617576,
0.0065081422,
-0.0703953281,
-0.0119967395,
-0.0196818672,
-0.0047091986,
0.031459216,
-0.0236761775,
0.0013282131,
-0.0948950499,
0.013873186,
0.0162116066,
0.0128327776,
-0.042285651,
-0.0691338927,
-0.0227072015,
-0.0378968753,
0.0351510458,
-0.0482606739,
-0.0156461224,
-0.0122726848,
0.035370037,
-0.0485636555,
-0.0403865762,
0.0394368134,
-0.0547289513,
0.0203259252,
0.0067404336,
0.0586283468,
-0.0383106917,
-0.0143214017,
0.0860688686,
0.0071276817,
-0.0440834723,
0.007479101,
0.0537662245,
0.0012038124,
0.0003835957,
-0.0147710368,
0.0049577649,
-0.0619065166,
-0.0293165147,
-0.0588662252,
0.0556745827,
0.0103658037,
-0.0110951271,
-0.0192563329,
-0.0099349441,
0.0225660168,
0.0309517737,
0.0578198135,
-0.0393970981,
-0.0152182123,
-0.0308177751,
0.0094536534,
-0.0597813018,
0.0112508675,
0.0350556485,
-0.0278424341,
-0.0538994372,
-0.0436597131,
-0.0473602265,
-0.0109228352,
-0.0242458824,
-0.0365806445,
0.0345716216,
0.0506564938,
-0.041592855,
-0.0602118187,
0.0298110284,
-0.0111040631,
0.0521317832,
0.003145217,
-0.0094983503,
-0.0185787678,
-0.0223357733,
0.0182344168,
-0.0437901989,
-0.0763993189,
-0.0639522076,
-0.0382809229,
-0.0247181654,
0.0024685196,
0.0149907768,
-0.0426029563,
-0.0460903831,
0.0371263549,
0.055762928,
-0.0076100999,
-0.0225085914,
0.0111405579,
-0.0268396046,
-0.000117879,
0.0459049754,
-0.0425145067,
-0.0098987892,
0.0218680557,
0.0342196897,
-0.0273556765,
-0.0096735703,
-0.0138485078,
0.0071968455,
0.0723069832,
-0.0057470649,
-0.049128633,
-0.0868092328,
-0.0296898708,
0.0236486439,
-0.0143731795,
-0.018406041,
-0.0218569469,
0.0262552556,
-0.0159722827,
-0.0552805103,
-0.0392239541,
-0.0025569801,
0.0261775423,
-0.0454940088,
0.0465284325,
-0.0076196622,
0.0164037608,
0.0304070469,
0.0361052081,
0.016494941,
0.009744769,
0.0102274762,
0.0004104838,
-0.0079478212,
0.0018197475,
-0.0150263356,
0.0037314272,
-0.015805183,
0.001823779,
-0.0377134718,
0.012410203,
-0.0491346456,
-0.0119545385,
0.1001362577,
-0.0412578434,
0.0264276918,
-0.0163310338,
0.0015696706,
-0.0380234197,
0.04466369,
-0.046511665,
-0.0642654896,
0.0311994292,
-0.0109898699,
-0.0300951656,
0.0851899087,
0.0799980983,
0.0243687667,
0.0267511383,
0.0258325059,
-0.0415458009,
-0.0035030663,
0.0188168082,
0.0523462147,
0.0994378552,
-0.0317386761,
0.0320087299,
-0.0185979139,
-0.0972560346,
0.0247136168,
-0.0460637212,
-0.0099499598,
0.0259441957,
-0.0086625442,
0.0378768705,
0.0110812504,
0.0245704651,
-0.076370433,
0.000109521,
-0.0202805847,
-0.0143600842,
0.0055590356,
-6.714827073e-33,
0.0257275309,
-0.0430463441,
-0.0337499902,
0.0081230681,
-0.0290914308,
0.0326793864,
-0.0592280813,
0.0153215649,
-0.0412254818,
0.0379273556,
-0.0207072459,
0.0308045745,
0.0085081728,
0.0460249111,
-0.0213076007,
-0.0150961885,
0.0016292436,
0.0188537035,
0.015676029,
0.0288075469,
0.0210542846,
0.044509653,
0.0577545203,
-0.0932833552,
0.0114547499,
-0.0178474896,
0.0307870265,
-0.0016607859,
0.0504444726,
0.0626407489,
-0.0233789664,
0.1103734523,
0.0354045704,
0.0173308309,
0.0099702301,
0.0356485248,
-0.0820720643,
-0.0331773795,
-0.0203165691,
0.0404913537,
-0.0186450388,
0.0021666372,
0.0334907323,
0.0092705423,
0.0292390417,
0.0109649515,
0.0593830459,
0.0165720973,
-0.0310868043,
-0.0050215241,
-0.0318909958,
0.0513659753,
0.0001036271,
0.0049298559,
-0.0044830553,
-0.0128896125,
-0.0020586855,
0.0502622798,
-0.1098477691,
-0.0119311884,
-0.0507824905,
-0.0311075002,
-0.0156640895,
0.0205090418,
-0.003716941,
0.0390051156,
-0.0066718752,
0.0223828945,
-0.010961609,
0.0009448506,
0.0109758601,
0.0375129059,
0.0095487805,
0.0214509144,
0.0356046036,
-0.0683068857,
-0.1063372642,
-0.0107156308,
0.0417728499,
-0.0206746496,
0.0087619768,
0.0336561389,
-0.0313914195,
-0.0488202609,
0.0202791933,
-0.0484410971,
-0.039283596,
-0.0271004438,
-0.0393625312,
0.0293856971,
-0.0293540601,
0.0423355885,
0.01522147,
-0.1209927946,
-0.0392621383,
0.0722436905,
-0.0153152235,
0.0328286849,
-0.0074514984,
0.0331747532,
-0.0740811527,
-0.0036678568,
0.0054679182,
-0.0035656169,
-0.0287380368,
0.0006704627,
0.0652126521,
0.0215362832,
-0.0177343171,
0.0183134489,
-0.0348846801,
-0.0337251797,
-0.0321972296,
0.045787327,
-0.0009378901,
0.0517279096,
-0.0028508476,
0.0477293618,
0.0652893111,
0.0524144918,
-0.0010510205,
-0.0105779506,
-0.0274238382,
0.0065919454,
-0.0190086048,
-0.0088345846,
-0.00628488,
0.0880697072,
0.038721472,
-0.0383511223,
-0.0143053634,
-0.0346466675,
2.765e-7,
0.0824252293,
0.0083436109,
0.029026743,
-0.0299135447,
0.0067191902,
0.0348574556,
0.0062036938,
0.0356569253,
-0.0214809552,
-0.0105092982,
0.0275370758,
0.0560775697,
0.0195491314,
0.037083976,
-0.054718487,
0.0323775411,
-0.1059521511,
-0.031609755,
-0.0115447557,
0.0026607497,
-0.0108843641,
0.0921600983,
0.0391012914,
-0.0429364219,
-0.0350544937,
-0.0607419461,
0.0655564815,
0.004136547,
-0.0293752681,
0.0151105132,
0.0170414317,
0.0174243748,
-0.0102705006,
-0.0335329324,
-0.0499043018,
0.0226709787,
0.0580896027,
-0.0053473734,
-0.0276259296,
-0.0090508359,
-0.0033459284,
-0.0209467206,
0.003210976,
-0.0438604616,
0.0704337955,
-0.031490881,
-0.0510042496,
-0.0237110201,
0.0060385261,
0.0267879665,
0.0810875967,
-0.006469727,
-0.0528289042,
0.0348679461,
0.0435342006,
-0.04002266,
-0.0380245671,
-0.0761104152,
0.0080932099,
0.0024824718,
-0.0242657997,
-0.0100373346,
-0.0071476558,
0.0089694737,
0.0447453149,
-0.029881563,
0.0727675185,
2.170000683e-34,
0.0460723676,
-0.0064243404,
-0.0046634562,
-0.0315343998,
0.0224703234,
-0.004744018,
-0.0111900456,
-0.0195008684,
0.0141819147,
-0.0405678116,
0.0168464389
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.