id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09338v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09338v1 | Performance of the Pre-Trained Large Language Model GPT-4 on Automated Short Answer Grading | 2023-09-17T18:04:34 | 2023-09-17T18:04:34 | Gerd Kortemeyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automated Short Answer Grading (ASAG) has been an active area of
machine-learning research for over a decade. It promises to let educators grade
and give feedback on free-form responses in large-enrollment courses in spite
of limited availability of human graders. Over the years, carefully trained
models have achieved increasingly higher levels of performance. More recently,
pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) emerged as a commodity, and an
intriguing question is how a general-purpose tool without additional training
compares to specialized models. We studied the performance of GPT-4 on the
standard benchmark 2-way and 3-way datasets SciEntsBank and Beetle, where in
addition to the standard task of grading the alignment of the student answer
with a reference answer, we also investigated withholding the reference answer.
We found that overall, the performance of the pre-trained general-purpose GPT-4
LLM is comparable to hand-engineered models, but worse than pre-trained LLMs
that had specialized training. | [
0.0317479931,
0.0181363486,
0.0006852226,
0.0172846448,
-0.0109251337,
0.0039038432,
0.0130848791,
-0.0067733885,
-0.0016455835,
-0.0827396736,
-0.0116516948,
-0.0134846661,
-0.0236522295,
-0.003996342,
0.0138915721,
-0.0261004101,
0.0261737704,
-0.0208913665,
0.0097694099,
-0.0131691881,
-0.0055238302,
-0.0021802685,
0.0015775628,
0.0105510708,
-0.0072165183,
-0.037107382,
-0.0048445645,
-0.0334413685,
0.0145436283,
-0.0047664284,
0.0486313291,
0.1065470725,
-0.0247632544,
0.0645503849,
0.0000019046,
-0.0506467521,
0.0042900727,
0.003947861,
-0.0247900467,
0.0738659799,
-0.0000578524,
0.0384148285,
-0.0043608793,
0.0300692227,
-0.0657732114,
-0.0440113321,
0.0464906469,
0.0124314623,
0.0897321776,
0.0443080887,
0.0204086639,
-0.0432906784,
0.0632764921,
-0.0084820129,
0.0186705869,
-0.0342683196,
0.0361256115,
0.039110966,
-0.0034318902,
0.0348110981,
-0.0433910936,
0.0259761214,
0.0155661274,
-0.0050012865,
0.0153346937,
0.0330088586,
-0.0401146412,
0.0251813084,
0.0018539377,
0.0838687047,
-0.0247364454,
-0.0228240751,
-0.0316321328,
-0.0331087671,
-0.0098449774,
0.0301129911,
-0.0593450889,
0.009862259,
-0.0023545981,
0.0145226559,
0.0253295116,
-0.0257455092,
-0.0131860515,
0.0076021394,
-0.0001178386,
0.0545238331,
0.0289751999,
-0.0578503534,
0.0149645517,
0.0299249068,
-0.0117312744,
-0.0420483723,
0.0103891995,
0.0502312556,
0.0087353159,
0.0104139512,
-0.0311746001,
-0.0108607272,
0.0398138165,
-0.0289793182,
0.0364675187,
0.0237397086,
-0.0058141644,
0.0309328642,
-0.0370897651,
0.088570036,
0.0105003156,
0.0356034078,
-0.0326197594,
0.0173352771,
-0.0370484181,
-0.001609004,
-0.0125415763,
0.0330189727,
0.0013473736,
0.008589861,
-0.0754701495,
-0.0164950453,
-0.0099824229,
-0.0143933883,
0.0235945377,
-0.0149790654,
-0.0158329271,
0.0260948297,
-0.0313964486,
0.0704987645,
-0.0146709308,
-0.008291929,
-0.0025873245,
-0.0372599773,
-0.0080290847,
-0.0187853612,
0.016110681,
-0.0285801496,
0.0246251691,
0.0192651767,
-0.0012997602,
-0.0136932405,
0.0087181348,
-0.0189701207,
-0.0298730787,
-0.0853620693,
-0.0047588116,
-0.0661741719,
0.0042245919,
0.0484772138,
-0.0006403312,
-0.0041113854,
0.009249948,
0.0293003581,
-0.0055420217,
0.0210426264,
0.0032456138,
0.0094103534,
-0.0014923792,
-0.0092167594,
0.0324449912,
0.0102065559,
0.0196116287,
0.0041438281,
0.0214725677,
-0.0786217377,
0.048608318,
0.0526394397,
0.0186753478,
-0.0092303921,
0.0410241708,
0.0170694944,
0.0501576811,
0.0241414476,
0.0049957871,
0.0359529406,
0.0188880339,
-0.0055917613,
0.0502256565,
0.0525506213,
-0.0005632271,
0.0055623944,
0.0224793311,
-0.0029578356,
0.0512183458,
0.0336260833,
-0.061577335,
-0.011480757,
-0.0591566861,
0.0211609937,
0.0531044677,
0.009935786,
-0.0087372474,
-0.0468548238,
-0.0200153589,
-0.0086640026,
-0.0242416207,
0.0260777641,
0.0683002993,
-0.0447471775,
-0.0382699817,
0.0121409781,
0.0153995994,
-0.0674943775,
0.0343774781,
-0.061711777,
0.0615658239,
0.0409928747,
0.0564483888,
-0.0149953207,
-0.0422320962,
-0.0109815914,
0.020448111,
0.0277108308,
0.0722689703,
-0.0176261663,
-0.0195691623,
-0.0496303812,
-0.0271576457,
0.0034991368,
-0.0052424655,
-0.000503922,
0.0314220525,
0.02870759,
0.0177091882,
-0.0282066967,
-0.0744459257,
0.0277027283,
-0.0057817549,
-0.0875290036,
-0.040782541,
-0.0074757505,
0.0298594553,
0.0302573089,
-0.0134457648,
0.0080600567,
0.0388149843,
0.0006122346,
-0.0011591691,
-0.0929971114,
-0.0673673898,
-0.0070455745,
0.0719510689,
-0.0362583697,
-0.0194576699,
0.0536241494,
-0.0303254258,
-0.0720535144,
-0.0260399058,
-0.0136466874,
0.029017644,
-0.0286160931,
0.036245849,
-0.0089933034,
-0.0202848315,
-0.0687836558,
0.0239131097,
0.0523451157,
0.0637847781,
-0.0445270017,
-0.0118786627,
0.0382478796,
-0.0060483976,
-0.0523478016,
-0.002727018,
0.0154777933,
0.0234373957,
0.0199979059,
0.0206524692,
-0.046694994,
-0.0300423596,
-0.0743527636,
0.0092729768,
0.0001483042,
0.0153050162,
0.0216071662,
-0.0184458476,
-0.0039612064,
0.000361992,
-0.0820138007,
-0.0128218913,
0.0310276821,
0.0217867009,
0.0017882768,
0.0129623432,
0.0060450924,
-0.0613704473,
-0.048713509,
-0.0528611876,
0.0125968903,
0.0628006756,
0.011484731,
-0.0397285409,
0.0356758647,
-0.0184126645,
0.0135257598,
0.0380149111,
-0.0577192344,
0.0065489942,
-0.0316266492,
0.031933222,
0.0613312274,
0.0141739277,
-0.0302112121,
0.0361529179,
0.001625985,
-0.0778495148,
0.0092876311,
-0.032914035,
-0.0469764993,
-0.034570355,
-0.0279669669,
-0.0431732126,
0.0632776767,
0.0222876389,
-0.0408142097,
-0.0514468364,
0.0232516695,
-0.0231091361,
0.0095015625,
-0.0425393432,
-0.0133182863,
-0.0142281484,
0.0218329094,
0.0065164398,
-0.0464619324,
0.0623607747,
-0.0505870059,
-0.0095396647,
-0.0273073148,
0.0395373777,
-0.0341226161,
0.0088347532,
0.0351368785,
-0.0094006984,
-0.0462023839,
0.0073415106,
-0.0288862325,
0.0110845147,
0.0053998977,
-0.066232115,
0.0456095859,
-0.0241457056,
0.0026986296,
-0.0470992438,
-0.0224228986,
-0.01959447,
-0.0162686147,
-0.0189995356,
0.0195802767,
-0.0061564227,
-0.0252377149,
0.0185509343,
0.0249280203,
0.0038735534,
0.0296521205,
-0.0767770186,
0.0007615061,
-0.0144239012,
0.0551418886,
0.0481345579,
-0.0183940679,
0.0079289693,
-0.0191461779,
0.0097639374,
0.0389911346,
0.0703391135,
0.0196691584,
0.001519442,
-0.0170942489,
0.0523198508,
-0.0549718812,
-0.0149636511,
0.0273434352,
0.0297268592,
-0.0790178254,
0.0041158781,
0.1159973145,
0.0207485761,
-0.0456557721,
-0.0265313685,
0.0041908766,
-0.0008797013,
0.0016565054,
0.0417003483,
-0.0591714904,
-0.0270677842,
-0.0233357921,
0.0346070565,
0.0119466502,
-0.0432241261,
0.0252063088,
-0.1427662671,
0.0219575632,
0.0249589849,
-0.0626180843,
-0.0146588171,
-0.0472555123,
0.0017738724,
-0.010765478,
-0.0020723792,
0.0218263231,
-0.0354950577,
0.0339352302,
0.0500674397,
-0.0174270626,
0.0022517759,
0.0501402803,
-0.030113982,
0.0565203652,
0.0448907427,
0.0134631349,
-0.0370831192,
-0.0435785465,
0.0739560053,
-0.0495358966,
-0.025074752,
-0.0100857215,
0.0446644202,
-0.0104209678,
0.0019901998,
-0.0180894099,
0.0381399989,
-0.0379982851,
0.0456112511,
0.0525710806,
0.1275278926,
0.0021722559,
-0.0180100743,
-0.0348744579,
-0.0078715086,
-0.00863316,
0.0815130845,
0.0513284057,
-0.0707143843,
-0.065078035,
-0.0470805541,
0.0299804267,
-0.0205293912,
-0.0540161356,
0.0191341527,
-0.0225897171,
0.0079976097,
-0.01795738,
-0.0807420984,
0.0714725107,
0.0014361701,
0.0208016261,
0.0247919187,
-0.0079650767,
0.0059752301,
-0.0214361567,
0.0442048274,
-0.0316881649,
0.01375328,
-0.1010519266,
-0.0268605165,
0.0194842909,
-0.009631779,
-0.0225443561,
-0.0001476615,
-0.0328126028,
-0.0544700176,
0.030047968,
0.0508879796,
0.0227256548,
0.0098940255,
0.0077418354,
-0.0261090323,
0.0477071777,
-0.0363315754,
-0.0183655638,
0.0067088343,
0.0002695398,
-0.0199783146,
-0.0121178413,
-0.0138920695,
-0.0180879515,
0.0128139835,
0.0491662212,
0.0426260941,
-0.0163679384,
-0.0629573315,
0.0230933335,
0.0639657229,
0.0723762289,
0.0026954913,
-0.0136385048,
-0.0086211571,
0.0169593915,
-0.0104337363,
0.0081999619,
-0.0191840008,
-0.0411114283,
0.0253230482,
-0.0197090767,
-0.0229817033,
-0.0059090671,
-0.0465656109,
0.0637977719,
-0.0201614834,
0.0335256495,
0.0173362046,
0.0015337321,
0.0387155525,
-0.0261407718,
-0.0372263417,
-0.0072907489,
0.0370660685,
0.0379765034,
-0.0004899955,
0.0753204003,
0.000111296,
0.0147894137,
0.056751363,
0.0064022252,
-0.0642142892,
-0.0239977427,
-0.0651140809,
0.0065270863,
0.0051003257,
-0.0109481569,
0.05125596,
-0.000534921,
-0.0128393844,
-0.0438959152,
0.0118151987,
0.0129363285,
0.0102584772,
0.0570025817,
0.0101924296,
0.0154986223,
0.0246821847,
0.0639019832,
0.0354636982,
0.0526654683,
0.0050677042,
-0.0282219686,
-0.0141654341,
-0.0309264306,
-0.0096118059,
-0.0141613688,
0.012658868,
-0.0122513212,
-0.0552819297,
-0.051255051,
-0.0227020364,
0.0547426417,
-0.0018919581,
-0.0406444184,
0.0184158999,
0.0647771358,
-0.0378122404,
-0.0303310696,
-0.0364864208,
0.0377598964,
-0.0063641863,
-0.034484081,
-0.0270898659,
-5.970080505e-33,
-0.0289682597,
-0.0241511259,
0.0109791933,
0.0495058,
0.0009137426,
0.0096817333,
-0.0045340764,
0.0198202264,
-0.0170175992,
0.0025747598,
-0.0259518847,
-0.0061701322,
0.007985902,
0.0436627865,
0.0493894629,
0.003116427,
0.0259936694,
-0.0294864792,
-0.0168889798,
0.0457709059,
-0.0009266527,
-0.0090582063,
0.0779528096,
-0.0307534151,
0.0386005417,
-0.0182573944,
0.0153414812,
-0.0203091707,
-0.0801662952,
0.0556856804,
-0.0251155216,
0.0616093203,
0.0194791928,
-0.0273459256,
0.0051449444,
0.0238260534,
-0.0536951125,
-0.0379596204,
0.0166658144,
-0.0039107283,
-0.0189652834,
-0.0500885472,
0.0335892811,
-0.0073825028,
-0.0691292658,
-0.0219911262,
0.0484247282,
-0.022806704,
-0.0196265504,
-0.035558898,
-0.0311088767,
0.0027769573,
-0.0062905434,
-0.0011764872,
-0.0048869103,
0.0514554903,
0.004512582,
0.033521127,
-0.015558091,
0.0406492427,
0.0976319015,
0.0528586134,
0.0352640375,
0.0068014511,
-0.0127223628,
0.0349738896,
0.0423840843,
-0.0242230538,
0.0250004418,
-0.0377991386,
0.0190371927,
-0.0215676911,
0.1155870482,
0.036118865,
0.0585267656,
0.0320096239,
-0.0606201813,
0.0578307882,
0.0122809755,
-0.0026258132,
0.0091705713,
-0.058428742,
-0.0343189798,
-0.020399807,
-0.0535070747,
-0.0085984962,
-0.0302337911,
-0.0287378021,
0.037302129,
-0.0575675629,
0.0055857659,
0.0132298553,
0.050259959,
-0.0343506187,
-0.0475449413,
0.0106969643,
0.0126465987,
0.0287399646,
-0.020101605,
0.0240102895,
-0.0554887354,
0.0153909866,
-0.001889928,
-0.0118535878,
0.0068125259,
-0.0018174991,
0.029243933,
-0.0043881154,
-0.0564520992,
-0.0167839471,
-0.0222427547,
-0.0157099832,
0.024814764,
-0.0349190012,
0.0455242246,
-0.004349085,
0.0239863768,
0.0539910719,
0.0020102216,
0.0062448909,
-0.0244706385,
-0.0400478393,
0.0284463838,
0.0024617272,
-0.0206369739,
-0.0026201583,
-0.0173250716,
0.0132166147,
-0.0302444473,
-0.0256730374,
0.0132305669,
0.0182303097,
2.437e-7,
0.0777021348,
0.0454663523,
0.0205571745,
-0.0206909962,
0.003818288,
0.014192462,
-0.0131318849,
-0.0094784051,
0.0663150698,
0.0411290266,
0.0128929885,
0.003261491,
0.0479654931,
0.0168299768,
-0.0541459359,
-0.0109996414,
-0.0290690195,
0.0046545365,
-0.060289491,
0.0116535742,
0.0544912554,
0.0709524378,
0.0195321385,
-0.0205391031,
-0.0416614264,
-0.0091295112,
0.0434323177,
-0.0351339653,
-0.0252939053,
0.0376962423,
0.0161922351,
-0.0191883985,
0.0239778347,
0.0437906347,
0.0002761976,
-0.0108442567,
0.0285022985,
0.057736285,
0.0033597064,
-0.0187153853,
0.0247079227,
-0.0177283678,
0.001271424,
-0.0610197932,
0.0719912946,
-0.0337724984,
0.017893061,
0.0088529717,
-0.0700666234,
-0.0618782118,
0.0028399141,
-0.029813949,
0.0195101053,
0.0158945378,
0.0016191867,
-0.0209807754,
-0.0003995164,
-0.0299070496,
-0.0236424152,
0.025422534,
-0.0188726857,
-0.0708854198,
-0.0250637867,
-0.0129121086,
-0.0021875831,
-0.0593868569,
-0.0124521367,
2.325020608e-34,
0.048198536,
-0.0300828964,
0.0553312376,
-0.0071826605,
0.0015316522,
-0.0048054392,
0.0327453315,
0.0088097509,
0.0225516353,
-0.0984881297,
-0.0440206192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09329v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09329v1 | A Few-Shot Approach to Dysarthric Speech Intelligibility Level Classification Using Transformers | 2023-09-17T17:23:41 | 2023-09-17T17:23:41 | Paleti Nikhil Chowdary, Vadlapudi Sai Aravind, Gorantla V N S L Vishnu Vardhan, Menta Sai Akshay, Menta Sai Aashish, Jyothish Lal. G | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Dysarthria is a speech disorder that hinders communication due to
difficulties in articulating words. Detection of dysarthria is important for
several reasons as it can be used to develop a treatment plan and help improve
a person's quality of life and ability to communicate effectively. Much of the
literature focused on improving ASR systems for dysarthric speech. The
objective of the current work is to develop models that can accurately classify
the presence of dysarthria and also give information about the intelligibility
level using limited data by employing a few-shot approach using a transformer
model. This work also aims to tackle the data leakage that is present in
previous studies. Our whisper-large-v2 transformer model trained on a subset of
the UASpeech dataset containing medium intelligibility level patients achieved
an accuracy of 85%, precision of 0.92, recall of 0.8 F1-score of 0.85, and
specificity of 0.91. Experimental results also demonstrate that the model
trained using the 'words' dataset performed better compared to the model
trained on the 'letters' and 'digits' dataset. Moreover, the multiclass model
achieved an accuracy of 67%. | [
-0.0244739596,
0.0285093933,
0.0005843658,
0.0034346625,
0.0147179281,
-0.0001724029,
0.0710154101,
-0.0114956908,
-0.0265722964,
-0.0187675301,
-0.0426367335,
-0.0335174203,
0.0546562634,
-0.0291859936,
-0.0033747938,
-0.0034143329,
0.0297755152,
-0.0420387387,
-0.0142756728,
-0.0550857745,
-0.0094323372,
-0.0299750157,
-0.0580235384,
0.0577789918,
0.0129449405,
0.0097295353,
0.020719029,
-0.0160810985,
0.010783351,
-0.012755096,
0.0194642711,
0.0455941744,
0.0036144305,
0.0476373844,
0.0000020814,
-0.0151923494,
0.0125705898,
0.0111792358,
-0.0596455596,
-0.0409511067,
-0.0154934209,
-0.0165478718,
0.0063302135,
0.0195242725,
0.0106267566,
-0.0390381292,
0.0378100127,
0.0404652618,
0.0200246852,
0.0247352887,
-0.0141715473,
-0.038879279,
0.0535326116,
-0.0068231858,
0.0120718926,
-0.0151826749,
0.023892127,
-0.0367493667,
-0.0453575812,
-0.0382441618,
-0.0242112428,
0.0640116036,
-0.0288351476,
0.0169119406,
0.0243090633,
-0.0191344712,
-0.0343570188,
-0.0368474573,
-0.0060974634,
0.0234852545,
-0.0225270595,
0.0055831559,
0.0186188444,
0.0049423934,
-0.034004204,
0.0085459622,
-0.0314163715,
-0.0281118546,
-0.0051971315,
-0.0171065349,
-0.0036813363,
0.0391539223,
-0.0111194924,
-0.0292377155,
0.0083072167,
0.0017585945,
-0.0073203896,
-0.01956705,
0.0093316911,
-0.0328335539,
0.023916997,
-0.0066593019,
0.0476405881,
0.0256982315,
-0.0663979053,
-0.0094118332,
-0.014863492,
-0.0634967387,
0.0268545412,
-0.0267987177,
-0.0004433509,
-0.0023121876,
-0.0230432004,
-0.027492268,
-0.0362818465,
0.0593783595,
-0.0096219452,
0.0416613817,
0.0061518261,
0.0194814615,
0.0088342447,
0.024132764,
-0.0362654887,
0.0218821727,
0.0328816064,
-0.0077241296,
-0.0910741538,
-0.015706541,
-0.003222212,
-0.0153188147,
0.0335359648,
-0.021674199,
-0.0577119514,
0.0247302391,
0.0185186975,
0.0756843463,
0.0502237678,
0.032666117,
-0.0183217749,
-0.0678258762,
0.006845512,
-0.0131608611,
0.0219348893,
0.0001425557,
0.0006742365,
0.0799319148,
0.0126930987,
-0.0336954072,
-0.0655910075,
0.022099847,
-0.0592564493,
-0.0165879857,
-0.0070647397,
-0.0531289466,
-0.0241813753,
0.0502935052,
0.0244701281,
-0.0606958829,
-0.0043751569,
-0.0197842456,
0.0440157428,
0.0473531596,
-0.0080502629,
0.0185045693,
0.0605784915,
-0.015584534,
-0.0258089155,
0.048166953,
0.0309838746,
-0.0283612218,
0.007408916,
-0.056333337,
0.0553607643,
0.0192564651,
-0.0036210483,
-0.0225623623,
0.0084838718,
-0.05373694,
-0.0462760665,
-0.0014157481,
0.0221360009,
0.0252796989,
0.0070190239,
-0.0435034111,
0.0545772202,
0.0335033908,
0.1121111512,
0.0144392373,
-0.0270241033,
0.0079167895,
-0.0293865278,
-0.0158891343,
0.0395085327,
0.0104373815,
-0.0057396465,
-0.0038543774,
-0.0128546413,
0.0461316109,
-0.0362483077,
-0.023435967,
-0.0106735732,
-0.0440255664,
-0.017664317,
0.0565262735,
0.0608459637,
0.0093942918,
-0.0344864577,
0.0866616964,
0.0217918232,
-0.0278611407,
-0.0010208341,
-0.0696778074,
-0.0094385426,
-0.0201792605,
0.0069872644,
-0.0359810553,
-0.0211374126,
-0.0660866946,
-0.057652507,
-0.0023859055,
-0.0488123409,
0.0259194952,
0.0469042547,
-0.0617746264,
-0.025492141,
0.0380860567,
-0.0100252591,
-0.0033961495,
-0.035564974,
0.0073038274,
-0.0093534254,
-0.0215946622,
0.0319569409,
0.0017523478,
-0.0319507457,
-0.0187703259,
0.0232216343,
0.0236629657,
0.0670368969,
-0.0049318043,
-0.0054629548,
-0.0184862129,
0.0176628754,
-0.0008091301,
-0.0374025851,
0.0127137052,
-0.0315699317,
-0.0124071948,
0.0138295861,
-0.0164263826,
0.015819855,
0.0336837582,
0.0284977891,
-0.0456225984,
-0.0287795253,
-0.0928020179,
0.0250924472,
-0.0428716727,
0.0877594203,
0.006315513,
0.0491162278,
0.0013033847,
-0.0128607126,
0.0043870294,
0.0118081551,
-0.067838259,
-0.0493815467,
0.0301945359,
-0.0777597949,
-0.0542378835,
0.0087801786,
-0.0751225129,
0.0278517269,
0.0207161587,
-0.0237284098,
0.006308435,
-0.0467295162,
-0.007561136,
-0.0525621064,
0.0044315848,
-0.0157666579,
-0.0505695976,
0.0148125375,
0.0103055723,
-0.0209806599,
-0.0073765297,
-0.0169934742,
0.0063892612,
-0.0089723701,
-0.0056476737,
0.0184175633,
-0.0479334109,
0.0114704305,
-0.0069338689,
-0.0051979297,
0.0363925695,
0.0011131406,
-0.0450005718,
-0.0368297994,
0.0448300131,
0.0507423207,
0.0171604566,
0.004883782,
-0.0480144769,
0.0035217542,
0.0685259551,
0.0369065814,
0.0327421986,
0.0149912648,
0.0203184187,
0.0210607406,
0.0119132465,
-0.0111465612,
0.0073608998,
-0.0284190532,
0.044604253,
-0.0182272829,
0.0381939597,
-0.0131372549,
0.0760553926,
0.0510644466,
0.0170843825,
-0.0228552483,
-0.0046353363,
0.0053054001,
-0.0177719891,
0.0075219432,
-0.0200080369,
-0.0147715658,
-0.0107638873,
0.0291224495,
-0.0153720677,
0.0425323807,
-0.0594955161,
-0.0337835364,
-0.0336541086,
-0.0372396074,
-0.0014493037,
-0.04740173,
-0.0339733809,
0.0086773494,
-0.0120492447,
-0.0588858463,
0.0069880188,
0.0231295321,
0.0052355626,
-0.0594865642,
0.0940615088,
0.0063141626,
-0.0123124719,
-0.0191269852,
-0.0347155966,
-0.0590315498,
0.0430392772,
-0.0261511765,
0.0128884334,
0.0167302247,
-0.0281618387,
-0.0717911571,
0.0577421449,
0.0288334079,
0.1036138311,
0.018637253,
-0.0084534353,
-0.0003555808,
0.0221813861,
0.0122952135,
0.0102279996,
-0.0244945381,
0.0040807296,
0.0585123748,
0.0021518143,
0.0208580829,
0.0555010401,
-0.0296821613,
-0.0309159569,
0.0316401273,
-0.0218597762,
0.0089763375,
0.0159399435,
0.0184701178,
-0.0014227319,
-0.0039608791,
0.0807946995,
-0.0065920623,
-0.0409352072,
-0.0105349263,
0.0005814444,
-0.0191249289,
0.0061478838,
-0.0030219473,
-0.0544373989,
-0.0279068034,
0.0250243116,
0.034660168,
-0.0204523392,
0.0132018961,
0.0149886841,
-0.0212320071,
0.0233462509,
0.0160212237,
-0.007593472,
-0.0283913147,
0.0045581423,
0.0075823222,
-0.0464587696,
0.0625706241,
-0.0030343751,
-0.0127354115,
-0.0475802347,
0.0304855723,
-0.103374064,
-0.0372438431,
0.0446969047,
0.0011145684,
0.071735926,
0.0283581652,
-0.0060390327,
-0.01270705,
-0.0932384357,
-0.0226797666,
0.0424307995,
-0.01448482,
-0.0108885411,
0.0722440854,
0.0026629972,
-0.0223499723,
-0.0102061322,
0.041539371,
-0.031192828,
-0.0038844382,
-0.0255090576,
0.020258015,
-0.0513167568,
-0.0142184505,
-0.0137607632,
0.0369068272,
-0.0123494584,
0.0510723777,
0.0065545063,
-0.0375374891,
-0.0113538131,
0.0290893875,
0.0724710524,
0.0307903998,
-0.0381555855,
0.056787204,
0.0291393828,
-0.0909159482,
-0.0502412207,
0.0453568958,
0.0127195064,
0.026700031,
0.0104315458,
0.0197972897,
0.0237255711,
0.0601073354,
-0.0212830864,
-0.0268422924,
0.0612438284,
0.0397534035,
-0.0954896435,
-0.0213813055,
0.057114996,
-0.038154304,
-0.0553846918,
0.0001970041,
-0.0412305407,
-0.0304144975,
0.1081196293,
-0.0153316269,
0.0246219095,
-0.0101680122,
-0.0266462397,
-0.064547725,
0.0865670145,
0.0486693047,
-0.0542352237,
0.0119278049,
0.0776813552,
0.0159255583,
-0.0119993649,
0.0187331699,
-0.0182555094,
0.0567284189,
0.0048203054,
-0.008079635,
-0.0520387553,
-0.0086776773,
0.0117130252,
0.0285021979,
0.1077431887,
-0.0114823729,
-0.0210199226,
-0.0048105633,
0.0577071123,
0.012060402,
0.0783387348,
-0.0390439704,
-0.0369622707,
0.0006639558,
0.0033413856,
-0.0228381976,
-0.0222132076,
-0.0705308765,
-0.0347951762,
0.0068252231,
0.088918902,
0.0618433356,
-0.005625315,
-0.0038471872,
0.0048714364,
-0.0042726868,
0.0154097481,
0.0576416515,
0.0193902794,
0.0315771736,
0.0692050681,
-0.0142675256,
-0.0064290529,
0.0426912159,
0.0168284457,
-0.0002041788,
0.0113993166,
-0.0431993566,
0.0093095815,
-0.0453535989,
0.0443154536,
-0.0337815732,
0.031815853,
0.033158157,
-0.0258651227,
0.0144466124,
-0.0383528695,
0.0458538309,
0.0766243786,
0.011029603,
-0.0102203321,
0.0214652903,
0.0391106643,
-0.0320625715,
-0.0124975313,
-0.0166434441,
-0.0151734781,
-0.05525757,
-0.0381613113,
-0.0097923912,
-0.0191797465,
-0.0355136208,
-0.0112136398,
-0.0320234224,
-0.0577858947,
0.0420367718,
-0.0091987876,
0.0599601716,
-0.0314567052,
-0.0343304724,
-0.0257795025,
-0.0270448532,
-0.0417184606,
-0.0024930644,
-0.0681608617,
-0.0002786638,
0.0075676087,
0.0352684967,
-5.751357373e-33,
-0.0289743245,
-0.008643047,
-0.0000527257,
0.0502054058,
-0.0062173712,
0.0339098126,
-0.0137759326,
0.0391143337,
-0.0478859842,
0.0008035271,
0.0077955783,
-0.0179224331,
0.0385435224,
0.0126244966,
-0.0211864226,
-0.0270623248,
0.0621183701,
0.0119954618,
-0.0032017946,
-0.0128104184,
0.0218914784,
0.0284252185,
0.0624837242,
-0.0182721391,
-0.0518004633,
0.0238756742,
-0.0274803843,
-0.0309252627,
0.0023264384,
0.0150009356,
0.0030337453,
0.0560277551,
-0.0104794446,
-0.0284948926,
0.0116954548,
0.0202338416,
-0.0531244352,
0.0549471378,
-0.0546302982,
0.0482702032,
0.0408361256,
-0.0025186753,
0.0594255477,
-0.0177376326,
-0.0354637131,
-0.0545538329,
0.0444726609,
-0.0286944546,
-0.0031049585,
-0.0673353598,
0.0095180245,
0.0182826184,
-0.0027785038,
-0.0588459633,
0.0471996628,
0.0300871264,
-0.0076233377,
0.0140954638,
-0.0698140934,
0.0247400738,
0.0593010485,
0.033939667,
0.0188907571,
-0.0197169743,
-0.0020114218,
0.0293172095,
0.0844912603,
-0.0575354844,
0.0400398634,
-0.0283469688,
0.0240860004,
0.0594157763,
0.0382671654,
-0.0086796824,
0.0354705825,
-0.034201324,
-0.0269273277,
-0.0050095962,
-0.0093347849,
0.0698288605,
0.031960316,
0.0186584312,
-0.0428836457,
0.0013031311,
-0.0279868226,
0.0049707871,
-0.0119653801,
0.0002333929,
0.0264304224,
-0.0275962297,
0.0114027392,
0.0350134261,
0.0369524583,
-0.0644279718,
0.0289264433,
-0.0029260572,
0.0214808192,
0.022136841,
-0.0155104231,
-0.0110381413,
0.011151256,
-0.0087108053,
0.0782523751,
0.0709882751,
0.037247397,
-0.0433353074,
-0.0017177154,
0.0415561944,
-0.0707019344,
-0.0108647291,
0.0106534893,
0.0308663603,
-0.0042701694,
0.041875165,
0.0079264762,
-0.018704338,
-0.0367617086,
0.0297262855,
-0.0535194837,
-0.0134285763,
-0.0481022969,
0.0431026891,
0.0187911019,
0.0455040447,
-0.052241195,
-0.0217367988,
0.0131917978,
-0.0200357735,
0.0350978598,
-0.0055249762,
0.0089802658,
-0.0222109351,
2.866e-7,
-0.0158340037,
0.0472484902,
0.0065031955,
-0.0329518355,
0.0087228958,
0.013169731,
-0.0120437453,
-0.0204704851,
0.0210436713,
0.037671648,
0.0136283357,
-0.0430056415,
0.0715961605,
0.0144900829,
-0.0569276512,
-0.0289587919,
-0.0683524758,
0.0291981176,
0.010032448,
0.0254196823,
0.0071635498,
0.0364100561,
-0.0383271687,
-0.0795363113,
0.0266078934,
0.0039632767,
0.0142922262,
-0.0082109207,
0.0407758988,
0.0166645385,
0.0354902856,
-0.0283155311,
0.0657047331,
0.0511867404,
-0.0532839447,
0.0558079481,
-0.0287396647,
0.0250543933,
-0.0698064864,
-0.0514799953,
0.0370486043,
0.0923960879,
-0.0061173299,
-0.0123839704,
0.0004866156,
-0.0724590793,
-0.03234905,
-0.0141399354,
-0.0570111014,
-0.0250115972,
0.0408499315,
-0.0123007996,
0.0202587526,
-0.0292867199,
0.008962038,
-0.0080331312,
-0.0196773391,
-0.0309932977,
0.0208679195,
0.0199506935,
-0.0739229247,
-0.0089753857,
0.0296306759,
-0.0582604408,
-0.0025404559,
-0.0310352761,
-0.001226179,
2.265681791e-34,
0.0202441029,
-0.0114873322,
-0.0092062512,
0.0259019453,
-0.00871538,
-0.0391379744,
0.0767233297,
0.0351802297,
0.0151274046,
-0.0455864966,
-0.0487050265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09324v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09324v1 | How People Perceive The Dynamic Zero-COVID Policy: A Retrospective Analysis From The Perspective of Appraisal Theory | 2023-09-17T17:05:18 | 2023-09-17T17:05:18 | Na Yang, Kyrie Zhixuan Zhou, Yunzhe Li | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | The Dynamic Zero-COVID Policy in China spanned three years and diverse
emotional responses have been observed at different times. In this paper, we
retrospectively analyzed public sentiments and perceptions of the policy,
especially regarding how they evolved over time, and how they related to
people's lived experiences. Through sentiment analysis of 2,358 collected Weibo
posts, we identified four representative points, i.e., policy initialization,
sharp sentiment change, lowest sentiment score, and policy termination, for an
in-depth discourse analysis through the lens of appraisal theory. In the end,
we reflected on the evolving public sentiments toward the Dynamic Zero-COVID
Policy and proposed implications for effective epidemic prevention and control
measures for future crises. | [
0.0148881273,
0.0585308,
0.0093616284,
-0.0447573066,
-0.0067046368,
-0.053060513,
-0.0268251207,
-0.0181846004,
0.0300693903,
-0.0131532736,
0.0332477801,
-0.0122801084,
-0.0272207018,
0.0256904531,
-0.0056069964,
-0.0311620031,
0.0014380374,
0.0711025372,
0.0684334487,
0.0110032698,
0.0505799614,
-0.0222642627,
0.0187112931,
0.0017112768,
0.0332516953,
-0.0302346013,
-0.0017113402,
0.0297084153,
0.0614313483,
-0.1197733581,
0.0471570566,
-0.0300479997,
0.0672207251,
0.0158318728,
0.0000022521,
-0.0273383278,
-0.0389115438,
-0.0154611412,
0.0377758108,
-0.0110261841,
0.1024136171,
-0.0305113997,
0.00173094,
0.0061811116,
-0.0435983576,
-0.0149474088,
0.0072834985,
0.0418998413,
0.0585173778,
0.0337374881,
-0.0052272328,
-0.0467033312,
-0.0409248099,
0.0051229498,
-0.0469614677,
0.0101227388,
0.0098855756,
-0.0092376405,
-0.0121657541,
-0.0557107031,
0.0073694256,
0.014908825,
-0.0331054255,
0.0029304828,
-0.0328833126,
0.0536564961,
-0.0144382194,
-0.046058055,
-0.0041117617,
0.0431125574,
0.0744476765,
-0.0048971521,
-0.0142121604,
-0.0117991343,
0.0134827718,
-0.0037249739,
-0.0312154889,
-0.0422045104,
-0.0032222308,
0.0138845211,
-0.0191623848,
0.0512643829,
0.0246036183,
0.0271755178,
-0.013773432,
0.0678627566,
-0.066275306,
-0.0495558716,
-0.0249031466,
-0.0321468674,
-0.0279845577,
0.0027376763,
-0.0265112426,
0.0419543982,
0.0262071621,
0.0031509737,
0.0536248796,
0.0100437477,
0.0317460038,
-0.1209134609,
-0.0257319696,
0.0149969673,
0.000906227,
-0.0281196609,
0.0553968512,
-0.0046815658,
0.0266650021,
-0.0698191896,
0.019449085,
0.0483521409,
-0.0662812963,
0.03824481,
0.0171802491,
0.0200416874,
0.0462187119,
0.0169836469,
-0.0387134515,
-0.0486459918,
-0.0492003262,
-0.0141020697,
-0.0647618398,
0.0182507541,
0.0310781058,
0.0409148335,
-0.0314529948,
0.0962297991,
-0.0729325116,
0.0120546529,
-0.0365273841,
0.0550241582,
0.009945021,
-0.0086495969,
0.067528978,
0.0157111175,
-0.0081763864,
-0.0041109319,
0.0379692465,
0.0293022376,
0.0418298729,
-0.0333736166,
-0.0548480451,
0.0026091007,
-0.0284999814,
-0.0275161806,
-0.069026269,
-0.0092760017,
0.005158524,
0.0119908964,
0.0086904634,
-0.0240126718,
-0.0361721516,
-0.0321087651,
-0.0332663842,
-0.0490980335,
-0.0566414446,
0.0257154424,
0.0507750027,
-0.0389654934,
0.0150067676,
0.0701645538,
0.0030134318,
0.0578536689,
0.0208324939,
-0.0473387837,
0.0275843758,
0.0256192721,
-0.0250099804,
0.0006886952,
-0.0063716136,
-0.0421982259,
-0.0206001606,
0.0016028066,
-0.0086619407,
0.0245906133,
0.0142880827,
-0.0117672328,
-0.064897351,
-0.0426096581,
-0.0109722596,
0.0465582833,
-0.0397428982,
0.0059165866,
0.0137754874,
-0.0131833255,
0.0089114988,
-0.0058293878,
-0.0191609375,
-0.0512270443,
-0.0182937328,
-0.0360188,
-0.0256336927,
0.0184951946,
0.0471166819,
0.0000620735,
-0.0456217155,
-0.0350453183,
0.0039432845,
-0.0513143986,
0.0207647495,
-0.0416646637,
-0.004540137,
-0.0716642588,
0.046171207,
0.0866112858,
-0.0198427252,
0.0303236376,
-0.0302583594,
0.0001203323,
0.0129446499,
0.0152096227,
0.0225562956,
0.0121796876,
-0.0599189103,
-0.0019512714,
0.0265902225,
-0.0245635249,
0.040530961,
0.0137963118,
-0.0405798331,
0.0831770524,
-0.0111912834,
0.0604469888,
-0.0081893131,
-0.0327453353,
0.0383287519,
-0.0085890125,
-0.0402486026,
0.023173416,
0.0185838901,
0.0226571616,
-0.0204970464,
0.0270728301,
0.0576538518,
0.009057954,
-0.0301694274,
0.0616318397,
-0.0170141645,
0.0558724776,
0.0326156653,
-0.0421296544,
0.0212669186,
-0.0317692645,
-0.0051587569,
0.0280560441,
0.069404006,
0.0870014951,
0.0082901474,
-0.0142502524,
-0.0042879353,
-0.0351258181,
0.0106903482,
0.0422204472,
0.0163125489,
-0.0076686321,
-0.0295803491,
-0.0298313741,
-0.0507954583,
0.0245490409,
-0.0060684397,
-0.0441862829,
-0.0413058996,
0.0249785725,
0.0021612656,
-0.0099758003,
0.0134672252,
-0.0496281758,
0.0119156418,
-0.0776156336,
-0.0075220652,
-0.007316363,
0.0177378282,
0.0378912613,
-0.0160005707,
0.0039386451,
0.019331621,
-0.0166682713,
-0.0096894056,
-0.0418764018,
-0.0019277856,
0.0062652845,
0.0126389368,
-0.0189408734,
-0.0224265493,
0.0214662757,
-0.070780538,
-0.0452407263,
0.0584420189,
-0.0395931415,
0.0731182173,
-0.0380391851,
-0.0859108344,
-0.0067287851,
-0.0162161924,
-0.0708859339,
0.007486667,
0.0093173664,
0.0012268682,
-0.0224583298,
0.0077040382,
0.1049435437,
0.0547950044,
0.0201840475,
-0.0270222574,
-0.0197010152,
-0.0214301851,
-0.0314369537,
0.0018336145,
-0.0259326193,
-0.0426924452,
0.0274445564,
0.0228518192,
0.024339065,
-0.0292533785,
0.0143919541,
-0.0480269752,
-0.0082290201,
-0.0345154405,
-0.0181491319,
-0.0120249316,
-0.0152711589,
-0.0082946066,
0.0067375051,
-0.0264139418,
0.0558438189,
0.0434387587,
-0.0231210608,
-0.0142434901,
-0.0197787173,
0.0194592252,
-0.0345945172,
-0.0059126313,
0.0264924355,
0.0418700352,
0.0263473578,
-0.0654812977,
-0.0646065623,
-0.0305838492,
-0.0668246076,
-0.0260718241,
0.0020627326,
-0.0232609771,
0.0043353164,
0.0356986187,
-0.0782234073,
-0.0581200421,
0.0643421561,
0.0096659139,
0.0105034364,
0.063425459,
0.0373572223,
0.0312623158,
-0.0256492812,
0.0047443635,
-0.0157555062,
0.0187316462,
-0.045483429,
-0.0072483723,
-0.0051925262,
0.0420595445,
0.0290358346,
0.0268922895,
0.0409405567,
0.0989377052,
0.0442347042,
0.0007896731,
0.0149464998,
-0.0226483457,
0.0398660116,
-0.0013633633,
0.0197642017,
0.0393556543,
-0.0285617355,
0.0268441215,
0.0414662622,
0.0296937451,
0.0031793958,
0.0039782859,
-0.032320179,
-0.0245570131,
0.0269440599,
0.0132377436,
-0.0683364868,
0.0423017628,
-0.0129813952,
-0.0086397668,
-0.0554083884,
-0.0248341989,
-0.0186781939,
-0.0416480601,
0.0127804046,
0.0138682229,
0.0755667239,
0.0466113053,
-0.0142894806,
0.0497246943,
0.0342500731,
-0.0067544691,
-0.0434844904,
0.0124130053,
-0.0108270803,
0.000360584,
-0.0145818014,
-0.0121111711,
0.0419649854,
-0.0074613043,
0.0449390374,
0.0362410471,
0.0994897261,
-0.0234661661,
-0.0290783644,
0.0292222369,
0.0398154892,
-0.0027043612,
-0.0184175149,
0.0189875886,
-0.0255922843,
0.0107210008,
-0.0181796532,
0.0016458014,
-0.0367699042,
0.0107201012,
0.0178947784,
0.0050081415,
-0.0284790136,
-0.0958956555,
-0.0256480575,
0.0534975864,
0.0383179002,
0.0348717831,
0.0102693867,
-0.0124634663,
0.0083253076,
-0.00399584,
0.0245388784,
-0.0168640222,
-0.0299450643,
-0.0530802161,
-0.0201407187,
-0.0356395058,
-0.0303433724,
-0.0193131417,
-0.0582063422,
0.0417114608,
-0.0016689989,
-0.041571185,
0.0611357018,
-0.0145306289,
0.0128759686,
-0.0480686165,
0.033919774,
0.0016888169,
-0.0290825851,
-0.0032039576,
0.0276541561,
0.0618568584,
-0.0117115751,
-0.026399564,
0.0490265489,
0.0065952344,
0.0547247082,
-0.0121817477,
0.0148341581,
0.0101547502,
0.0081397695,
0.0760582089,
0.0371768735,
0.0648770481,
-0.0024019408,
-0.0057313936,
0.029239377,
0.0611449033,
-0.0101863928,
0.0012385254,
0.0336089544,
-0.0056146006,
0.02219446,
-0.0015375966,
-0.035371311,
0.0403112322,
0.0036559778,
-0.0018913258,
0.0127328495,
0.0049973004,
-0.0268184375,
0.011511514,
-0.0350714438,
-0.0192970298,
-0.0401661545,
-0.0099933259,
-0.0627633259,
-0.0237239785,
-0.0014451509,
-0.0780995712,
0.0600713529,
-0.0227412805,
0.0087393792,
-0.057373751,
0.0582452342,
0.0328703187,
0.0535597987,
-0.0014682775,
-0.0308902208,
0.0078704348,
0.0077505866,
0.0091740666,
-0.0184326768,
-0.0059735388,
-0.0154504655,
-0.0227339584,
-0.0235531498,
0.0287739672,
0.0281349439,
-0.0356939882,
-0.0390008725,
-0.0290288571,
0.003590097,
-0.0106356665,
0.0278509948,
0.0346827395,
-0.0037255501,
-0.0140230069,
-0.0275477618,
0.0557727814,
-0.0565961823,
-0.0566771589,
-0.0316649266,
-0.0354136042,
-0.0586245656,
-0.0184403788,
-0.0113346707,
-0.0367261656,
0.0448738821,
0.0106969019,
-0.0121812979,
0.016652165,
-0.0070161265,
0.0459520072,
-0.0424764119,
0.0140179573,
0.070616357,
-0.0878607407,
-0.0001701886,
0.0550987944,
-0.0328178667,
-0.0192701351,
-0.0076586911,
-0.0377800167,
-0.0118598463,
-0.0143938921,
0.0280723516,
-0.0013878865,
0.0120263398,
-0.027955832,
-0.0058040973,
-0.0166596901,
-7.071255328e-33,
0.0045710411,
-0.0086545544,
-0.0201192684,
-0.0553947873,
-0.0279696248,
0.0036918742,
-0.0170076992,
0.0193843562,
-0.0244539808,
-0.0125099868,
0.002709833,
-0.0124307191,
0.0130743654,
-0.0187748801,
0.0207829513,
-0.008599407,
0.0464274436,
-0.0118546188,
-0.0080830688,
-0.0062878649,
0.0470125377,
0.0053451844,
0.0232765134,
-0.0755668208,
0.0942133367,
0.0044905064,
-0.0101550231,
-0.0160898119,
0.0649682432,
-0.0179949645,
0.0044281692,
-0.0082634008,
0.0523608848,
0.0052998527,
0.0168531481,
0.0315288268,
-0.0248055421,
-0.0562904291,
-0.0080926074,
-0.0481735244,
-0.0182424337,
-0.0448390394,
-0.007090406,
0.0333372802,
-0.0286578313,
0.0426885672,
0.016701106,
0.0163696781,
0.0440627858,
-0.0036368617,
-0.0268479493,
0.0146902651,
-0.0045655337,
0.0562955849,
-0.0388688482,
0.0809374079,
-0.0341483764,
0.0759567842,
-0.0851161778,
-0.0025239841,
-0.0329070836,
0.0061536115,
-0.0034092278,
-0.0332671888,
0.0430092998,
0.0305366293,
-0.02209373,
0.0239765402,
-0.0472691134,
0.0281478111,
0.0219050031,
-0.051698029,
-0.0617151447,
0.064555876,
0.0137999132,
-0.07832174,
-0.042412769,
0.0145664252,
-0.0049543232,
0.0659299344,
0.0548578054,
0.0429869741,
-0.0197798312,
0.0127160195,
-0.0041918075,
-0.0510041676,
-0.0409019552,
-0.0078826444,
-0.0251055192,
0.005551816,
-0.0523395166,
-0.0317180008,
0.0327878743,
-0.0016176128,
-0.0720692053,
-0.0077068354,
-0.0041563637,
0.0030809883,
0.0309279542,
0.0245254263,
-0.0562112518,
0.0141551532,
-0.0487038158,
0.0933197737,
0.0418515466,
0.023239756,
0.023569189,
0.0515220948,
-0.0220287964,
-0.0119754644,
0.0154998982,
-0.0331107154,
0.0092435526,
0.0147852609,
-0.0402343273,
0.0530793369,
0.043011412,
-0.0600742586,
0.033934135,
0.0487179793,
0.0200285353,
-0.024520386,
-0.04518402,
0.0288683474,
-0.0152465617,
0.0259782746,
0.005210707,
0.0159088708,
-0.0347597897,
-0.0265478045,
-0.0055718124,
-0.0114591727,
2.992e-7,
0.0298341513,
-0.0062452457,
-0.0107150786,
0.0155345155,
0.0127731329,
0.0379478671,
-0.0518655144,
0.0056559336,
0.0066859811,
-0.0459429249,
0.0204312019,
0.0046699373,
-0.0261494778,
0.0153291905,
-0.0069564311,
0.0478880294,
-0.0135943098,
0.0378149115,
0.0119086243,
0.092746757,
0.0320560224,
0.0240229592,
-0.0215171445,
0.0354730301,
-0.0066414056,
0.0700643584,
0.0227133222,
-0.0271467585,
-0.0124298399,
0.0151197845,
-0.0287750643,
0.0355572514,
-0.0047022137,
-0.0525427721,
0.0191776101,
-0.013440459,
-0.0073035955,
0.0641161725,
0.020901924,
-0.0415051617,
0.027296586,
-0.0106564229,
0.0292489454,
-0.0040972824,
0.0482442901,
-0.0289136972,
-0.0334372297,
-0.0119939819,
-0.0196739491,
0.0112236356,
0.0556173995,
0.003212031,
-0.0806419551,
0.0605999902,
-0.0129700936,
0.0202974603,
-0.0068407059,
0.0184756964,
-0.0180912483,
-0.0543059148,
-0.0258192532,
-0.0714292005,
0.0255471431,
0.0394244269,
-0.0446906984,
-0.0146273738,
0.0597371981,
1.994320986e-34,
0.0243836995,
-0.0383015946,
-0.0619179942,
-0.0461151265,
0.0215747673,
0.0245677195,
-0.0481680594,
-0.0362102538,
0.0477882624,
0.0055434643,
-0.0169028435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.10003v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.10003v4 | A novel approach to measuring the scope of patent claims based on probabilities obtained from (large) language models | 2023-09-17T16:50:07 | 2024-04-15T18:44:21 | Sébastien Ragot | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.IT, math.PR, 62P99, 60E05, I.2.m; G.3 | This work proposes to measure the scope of a patent claim as the reciprocal
of self-information contained in this claim. Self-information is calculated
based on a probability of occurrence of the claim, where this probability is
obtained from a language model. Grounded in information theory, this approach
is based on the assumption that an unlikely concept is more informative than a
usual concept, insofar as it is more surprising. In turn, the more surprising
the information required to define the claim, the narrower its scope. Seven
language models are considered, ranging from simplest models (each word or
character has an identical probability) to intermediate models (based on
average word or character frequencies), to large language models (LLMs) such as
GPT2 and davinci-002. Remarkably, when using the simplest language models to
compute the probabilities, the scope becomes proportional to the reciprocal of
the number of words or characters involved in the claim, a metric already used
in previous works. Application is made to multiple series of patent claims
directed to distinct inventions, where each series consists of claims devised
to have a gradually decreasing scope. The performance of the language models is
then assessed through several ad hoc tests. The LLMs outperform models based on
word and character frequencies, which themselves outdo the simplest models
based on word or character counts. Interestingly, however, the character count
appears to be a more reliable indicator than the word count. | [
0.0553611517,
0.0475485697,
-0.0342321321,
0.0042219949,
-0.0741374344,
-0.0302556604,
0.034988407,
0.029349314,
0.0047018304,
-0.0474956781,
0.0327575244,
-0.0633869022,
0.027852634,
0.0250564609,
0.0379820317,
0.0146084959,
0.0004704581,
-0.0360108651,
0.0341911279,
-0.0273638684,
-0.0109047992,
-0.0170208327,
0.0134006627,
0.0434409231,
0.0096617909,
0.0397437476,
0.0722753406,
-0.0395114347,
-0.0306452829,
-0.0790216401,
-0.0367010273,
0.0449698791,
0.0119605735,
0.0122539829,
0.000001757,
-0.094979316,
-0.0286835879,
0.0268296842,
0.0479127467,
0.0482793264,
0.0299979113,
0.0232507102,
-0.0197226461,
0.0177136138,
0.0024703504,
0.0007729384,
-0.005480465,
-0.0086675491,
-0.0600681193,
0.0154127441,
-0.0015330506,
-0.0341327079,
0.0568150319,
-0.0489416569,
0.0206850283,
-0.0816579908,
0.0378209017,
0.03129052,
0.0438995548,
-0.0458143502,
0.0031111157,
0.062124081,
-0.0183940995,
0.0027117364,
0.0222276635,
0.0221197717,
0.0082888501,
0.0099244388,
0.0145040639,
-0.00859477,
0.0676484779,
-0.0052830512,
0.0122902039,
-0.0134335356,
0.0585090779,
0.0351575762,
-0.0131516717,
0.0523878001,
-0.0022959313,
0.0189254209,
0.0542116687,
0.0622183792,
0.0195769332,
0.0198719129,
-0.0014254121,
0.0900828615,
-0.0031370823,
-0.0245805811,
-0.0053357505,
-0.025528321,
0.0050710286,
-0.0580043159,
0.012686599,
-0.012804199,
0.0985930264,
0.072599262,
0.0034922489,
0.0305957869,
0.0418424048,
-0.0770447031,
0.0129093742,
-0.0239524636,
0.0059866053,
0.0513457209,
-0.0439301506,
0.0299249627,
-0.0264084227,
-0.0632165968,
-0.0042084185,
-0.0041320208,
-0.0341893919,
-0.0241061989,
-0.0385251679,
0.060596887,
-0.0137230111,
-0.0157886632,
-0.0635465086,
0.0006674273,
-0.0175957326,
0.0140119009,
-0.0138255097,
-0.0339065567,
0.0013477175,
-0.0682451501,
-0.0514037386,
-0.0170280226,
-0.015350312,
0.0122862039,
-0.0348565802,
-0.0432055332,
0.0339378938,
-0.0001379571,
0.0174492113,
-0.0103369039,
-0.0123897512,
0.0470498241,
0.0330939256,
-0.0297576487,
-0.0015226746,
-0.0353536867,
-0.0277767759,
-0.0026774174,
-0.0443008728,
-0.0449004546,
-0.0537452139,
0.0044381781,
0.0124832271,
-0.0557718389,
-0.0060291919,
-0.0209431984,
-0.047149431,
0.0063195927,
-0.0087341797,
0.0126012396,
-0.01469611,
0.0067778486,
0.0346952677,
0.0201787353,
0.0168691706,
0.0134334452,
0.0514852814,
0.0063515059,
0.0466210879,
0.018054124,
-0.0084828204,
-0.0031584348,
0.0146028986,
-0.0020696691,
0.0144143524,
-0.0236777365,
-0.0200128946,
0.0114159547,
-0.0081712613,
0.0334700271,
0.0757162869,
0.079332009,
0.032002598,
-0.0126465745,
-0.0287812203,
0.0066204048,
-0.0005402061,
-0.0233490746,
0.0349866338,
-0.0417998396,
-0.0725688711,
-0.0097856773,
0.0502207577,
-0.045226343,
-0.0058914809,
-0.0492311753,
-0.0225761104,
0.017394783,
0.0211073924,
-0.037865255,
0.0810712129,
-0.0084581692,
0.0002942776,
0.0210442115,
-0.0108312638,
0.0164395664,
-0.0220454838,
-0.0299513135,
0.0150500191,
0.0178725533,
0.0175523367,
-0.0178748202,
0.0487326495,
0.0230386052,
-0.0711137429,
0.0365025736,
0.0252247211,
0.0378931202,
-0.0272715222,
0.0238589663,
0.0077354717,
-0.012289064,
0.0348715112,
0.0311777052,
-0.0356969871,
0.0248824842,
-0.0117426859,
-0.0608796328,
0.0302181728,
-0.017696172,
-0.0161223467,
-0.0028235007,
0.0029050736,
-0.0360953063,
0.0284329597,
0.0207794681,
-0.0283086859,
0.0395144187,
0.0082942592,
-0.0532815084,
-0.0380643941,
0.024303792,
0.0623550415,
0.0921132937,
-0.0250823814,
-0.0408229455,
0.0584288053,
-0.0726847202,
0.0448636785,
0.0075890552,
0.0097425757,
-0.0395155512,
0.0417236276,
-0.0102217225,
0.0173133463,
-0.0356016122,
0.016304994,
-0.0168331061,
0.0298237186,
0.0081760027,
0.0483712703,
-0.0397236608,
-0.0203495715,
0.0653022304,
-0.0262159724,
-0.0028154904,
0.0110865794,
-0.0123891477,
-0.020126164,
0.0584968291,
-0.0754682273,
0.0255813226,
-0.0166076217,
-0.079085052,
-0.022925308,
0.0212222673,
0.0258021839,
-0.0147447651,
0.00438256,
-0.0157105699,
0.0127020795,
-0.0108787864,
-0.0548960678,
0.0006653953,
-0.0017158742,
0.0359931327,
0.0053456589,
-0.082255289,
0.0043820143,
-0.0446953587,
0.0043206885,
0.013816501,
0.0848868266,
-0.0509517714,
-0.0772124529,
0.0464984737,
-0.0366205201,
0.0258977786,
-0.0382163525,
0.0142292669,
-0.0051031942,
-0.0117029147,
-0.0619663335,
-0.0434786975,
-0.0117884194,
0.0327181332,
0.0184102748,
0.0035331843,
-0.0191004593,
-0.0286417622,
0.0299521387,
0.039144706,
0.0029779414,
-0.014547985,
0.0340514556,
0.0229058173,
0.0088917194,
-0.0211773328,
-0.0165774953,
0.015586569,
-0.0609215982,
-0.0258569829,
0.0156857669,
-0.0081367278,
0.0114141591,
0.1070212647,
-0.0069683162,
-0.0761144608,
0.021141652,
-0.0517794415,
0.0384699665,
-0.0342062153,
-0.0040362971,
-0.0003175247,
0.0930309966,
0.0055120019,
-0.0159258358,
0.0506155267,
-0.0260786489,
0.0199225899,
-0.0076434403,
0.0415998027,
-0.0314624943,
0.0277996473,
-0.0291962158,
0.0533469059,
-0.0072634807,
-0.012477993,
-0.0106625184,
-0.0412183776,
0.0358833447,
0.0131437397,
0.0365538076,
-0.0022509247,
-0.0167819653,
0.0181439109,
0.0187256839,
0.0200556591,
0.0221081972,
0.006924578,
-0.0020371962,
0.0145551804,
-0.0159383416,
-0.0523967259,
-0.0044857864,
-0.0112789664,
-0.0288358852,
-0.0333185792,
-0.0448425114,
0.0803370923,
0.0309158117,
-0.001079599,
0.0160947163,
-0.0123872822,
-0.0443248712,
0.043408107,
0.0504332632,
0.0032070822,
0.0227263588,
0.0674101338,
-0.0205383711,
0.0926078111,
0.0436492935,
0.0832347944,
-0.0561830066,
0.0232245382,
0.0089466125,
-0.098045297,
0.0812612176,
-0.0472200662,
-0.0233915597,
-0.0737717897,
-0.0348201171,
-0.0606974885,
-0.1061960012,
0.0642326921,
-0.0082363402,
-0.0034195725,
-0.0403167531,
-0.0049301926,
0.0065727541,
0.0143267587,
-0.0320284478,
-0.0129598128,
0.0085807899,
-0.0152440201,
0.0063689915,
-0.1284653544,
-0.0011995335,
0.0030331882,
-0.0045564766,
0.0010506044,
0.0138696078,
-0.0163545348,
-0.0542671494,
0.0005647119,
-0.0415611081,
-0.0179466717,
0.0039458862,
0.0168765429,
0.0073260977,
0.0620564111,
0.0158674698,
-0.0068855258,
-0.0276173558,
0.018289879,
0.0068433005,
-0.0025631806,
0.0270935986,
-0.0124356868,
-0.0593355782,
0.0205040146,
-0.0234656408,
-0.0059197852,
0.0598560236,
0.0020339435,
-0.0352362841,
-0.0125540206,
-0.0544903949,
-0.0064399717,
-0.038234558,
0.024794329,
0.0042999107,
0.0281970743,
-0.0652111694,
-0.0690244809,
-0.0022268188,
-0.0481134169,
0.0550382286,
0.0069615203,
0.089682363,
0.0660108998,
-0.0037285751,
-0.013037446,
-0.0162173603,
0.0225001387,
-0.0037853778,
-0.0211980175,
0.0443972796,
0.0263174567,
-0.0077043837,
-0.0423074849,
0.0115827098,
-0.0310244039,
-0.070809193,
-0.0149742262,
-0.0461391769,
0.0393415019,
-0.0380761363,
-0.0543568209,
-0.0673457161,
0.0716380849,
0.0063908766,
0.0326469354,
-0.0061035641,
0.0045565246,
-0.0099514369,
-0.0092491796,
-0.0146345226,
-0.0027158107,
0.0342582986,
0.0328882635,
0.0124952262,
0.0057824668,
-0.0307270903,
0.0239622779,
0.0614730045,
0.048849076,
-0.0057420637,
0.0403230377,
-0.0054548634,
-0.0312790386,
-0.0017189645,
-0.0019515548,
-0.0391654,
-0.0296924803,
0.0348976701,
-0.0446869172,
-0.0463719927,
0.0034761506,
-0.0176891517,
0.0083154477,
-0.061855495,
0.0206418857,
-0.0488946028,
0.0486261249,
0.0396871381,
-0.034879677,
0.0089699738,
0.0039935163,
-0.0442390181,
0.0205022525,
0.0153199043,
0.0223211087,
-0.0213863365,
-0.0046184841,
-0.0060001155,
0.023968,
-0.0078334399,
-0.0790766403,
-0.0182822812,
0.077743493,
0.01998212,
0.0274834912,
0.0112134982,
-0.0675108358,
0.0226241127,
-0.0146044707,
0.0227028728,
-0.0077440641,
-0.011216837,
0.0292269029,
0.0133900121,
-0.0112331714,
0.0092912307,
0.0378291942,
0.0584813431,
-0.0093882699,
-0.08607921,
-0.0205389448,
-0.0018146702,
-0.019783916,
0.0106868614,
0.0222048685,
-0.0225271303,
0.0546132363,
-0.0943233445,
-0.0161746759,
-0.0037508407,
0.0052051391,
0.0503981411,
0.0182825513,
-0.0253454801,
0.0652767569,
-0.0041739568,
-0.0288179219,
-0.0335124545,
-0.0065388279,
0.0113812378,
-0.0240633581,
0.0052037281,
-5.781481987e-33,
0.010340455,
-0.0396921262,
-0.0216941573,
-0.0135512147,
0.0181632843,
-0.0110043176,
-0.0306483805,
0.021201767,
0.0113190832,
-0.0019790675,
-0.0105986968,
0.0036743763,
0.0122355474,
-0.0035082982,
0.0220911056,
0.039852649,
-0.0024289349,
0.0259711538,
-0.0121568749,
-0.0291764736,
0.0229229648,
0.0148130311,
0.0420542322,
-0.0504830964,
0.0729897544,
0.0312559269,
-0.0209802557,
-0.0361850969,
0.0017851023,
0.0279528275,
0.0098024085,
0.0319243744,
0.0243237577,
-0.108300291,
-0.0019516267,
-0.022889208,
-0.0007785839,
-0.0031222655,
0.0268832836,
-0.0442459285,
0.0824520141,
0.0048714797,
0.0294464249,
0.0279553104,
-0.0861148536,
0.0238945931,
0.0388473347,
-0.0350590236,
-0.0295290686,
-0.0320365243,
-0.0437152795,
0.0321621969,
0.0202937666,
0.0683764368,
0.0324152298,
-0.0373106077,
-0.0211200863,
0.0311429873,
-0.010475128,
0.0262734611,
-0.0314141139,
0.0327795856,
0.0159984007,
-0.024785284,
0.010864079,
0.0419557467,
0.0070494218,
0.0443535596,
0.0218772795,
-0.021333795,
-0.0110114412,
0.0580075756,
-0.0004605843,
-0.002685423,
0.0579828732,
-0.0138256475,
-0.0429636128,
-0.0055332356,
0.0125029525,
-0.0396959893,
0.0481679589,
-0.0019439608,
-0.0637453049,
-0.0427397788,
0.0141060995,
-0.0312000122,
0.0120939845,
0.0376382396,
0.0081268139,
-0.0052530835,
0.0270965472,
0.0555396266,
0.025315078,
-0.0375683308,
-0.0665016174,
-0.0546655618,
0.0172356907,
0.0663755611,
-0.0251404028,
-0.0024780852,
-0.0324102566,
-0.0149116209,
-0.0258391071,
0.0527472459,
0.0015383601,
-0.0023439382,
-0.0275459718,
-0.0526730902,
-0.0543498136,
0.0040668407,
-0.0293746144,
-0.0129370969,
0.0448510982,
-0.0151027162,
0.0155625101,
0.0107972911,
0.0185804609,
-0.0030757885,
0.0021469328,
-0.0738726631,
-0.0339998826,
-0.0264881458,
-0.0251125712,
-0.0225735009,
-0.0101128127,
-0.0162858684,
0.0280364715,
0.0347700194,
0.0631158948,
0.0195591841,
-0.0163289029,
0.0443452336,
2.577e-7,
0.0585197471,
0.0288584437,
-0.018714495,
0.0520830415,
0.0123824878,
0.0162326656,
-0.0316054039,
0.0420799404,
-0.0003507432,
-0.0491586737,
-0.0067666383,
-0.047479514,
0.0136857983,
-0.0016617804,
-0.0383600518,
-0.0333441645,
-0.0209661853,
0.0014490719,
-0.0358336158,
-0.0030490193,
0.0393974669,
0.0227460843,
0.0257848781,
0.0017018374,
-0.0212661456,
-0.047658734,
0.02382157,
-0.0421763882,
0.0121367108,
0.0461282395,
0.0735397637,
-0.0000634407,
-0.0172081776,
0.0601399727,
-0.0187825412,
0.0579212308,
0.0090139704,
0.0055787321,
0.0173107758,
0.0890145823,
-0.0162276495,
-0.0510931239,
-0.0046497877,
-0.0685442835,
-0.0125445481,
0.0371533409,
-0.0324461237,
0.0070669106,
0.0246292092,
0.0252711289,
0.0126131922,
0.046196498,
-0.0002828132,
-0.0308127403,
-0.004872526,
0.0072552497,
0.0062786038,
-0.0411084481,
0.0216403753,
0.0063772178,
-0.0407629572,
-0.0183459539,
-0.0202176031,
-0.0088777905,
0.0274271667,
-0.0515523255,
0.0503568947,
2.184430106e-34,
0.0419423282,
-0.0401596054,
-0.02651814,
-0.0261499248,
0.0463331081,
0.032618884,
0.0429833643,
0.024136696,
-0.007983583,
-0.0680687875,
-0.0150722284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09300v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09300v1 | AutoAM: An End-To-End Neural Model for Automatic and Universal Argument Mining | 2023-09-17T15:26:21 | 2023-09-17T15:26:21 | Lang Cao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Argument mining is to analyze argument structure and extract important
argument information from unstructured text. An argument mining system can help
people automatically gain causal and logical information behind the text. As
argumentative corpus gradually increases, like more people begin to argue and
debate on social media, argument mining from them is becoming increasingly
critical. However, argument mining is still a big challenge in natural language
tasks due to its difficulty, and relative techniques are not mature. For
example, research on non-tree argument mining needs to be done more. Most works
just focus on extracting tree structure argument information. Moreover, current
methods cannot accurately describe and capture argument relations and do not
predict their types. In this paper, we propose a novel neural model called
AutoAM to solve these problems. We first introduce the argument component
attention mechanism in our model. It can capture the relevant information
between argument components, so our model can better perform argument mining.
Our model is a universal end-to-end framework, which can analyze argument
structure without constraints like tree structure and complete three subtasks
of argument mining in one model. The experiment results show that our model
outperforms the existing works on several metrics in two public datasets. | [
0.0105145071,
0.0130820759,
0.005207154,
0.0684942678,
0.0017369563,
0.0135365445,
-0.0403104462,
-0.015973391,
-0.0137192504,
-0.0419245139,
0.0247487929,
-0.0237273481,
-0.0143194981,
-0.0165356621,
0.0042235604,
-0.0609154701,
0.0297573097,
0.0282490198,
0.101718545,
0.0148032187,
0.0282741655,
-0.0099927178,
0.0095513342,
0.0353812128,
-0.031290669,
-0.0732329339,
-0.0149141932,
-0.0018343747,
0.0444336385,
-0.0431649759,
0.0398989879,
0.0074193161,
-0.0057691657,
0.0130167808,
0.0000019798,
-0.0112326816,
-0.0026943507,
-0.0535887741,
-0.0321425609,
0.0194743965,
0.0397482589,
0.0652593151,
-0.0090007726,
0.0316647403,
-0.0383740775,
0.0174236055,
0.029547587,
0.0978788808,
0.0636908263,
0.0910256207,
-0.0128675746,
-0.038049411,
0.0175358132,
-0.0253786072,
-0.046814207,
-0.0086666355,
0.016521126,
-0.0137180518,
-0.0290540736,
0.0579070672,
0.0090556508,
-0.0095320866,
0.0344949439,
-0.0132729327,
-0.0045166775,
0.018447062,
-0.0261666924,
-0.0335929058,
0.0146224536,
0.0739932209,
-0.0340803228,
-0.0414496325,
0.015262668,
-0.0366739072,
0.0351428166,
-0.0460825413,
-0.0423130989,
0.0677158311,
-0.0239637736,
0.0630716011,
0.0936811864,
0.0461108945,
0.0098686721,
0.003701468,
-0.0002913555,
0.0365559384,
-0.0505793281,
-0.0150205446,
0.0235611461,
-0.0281634517,
-0.0229039211,
-0.0477792583,
0.0358635597,
0.0458845831,
0.0340376534,
0.0221871622,
-0.0154120168,
-0.0111324228,
0.0504621118,
-0.125034228,
0.0233514663,
-0.017168615,
-0.0328449979,
0.0773825198,
-0.0046763839,
-0.0340401046,
-0.0400678068,
-0.0030397302,
0.0222742539,
-0.0504513681,
-0.0400867909,
0.0012396012,
-0.016358614,
0.0114111267,
-0.053017918,
-0.0269453581,
0.0073583806,
0.003218726,
-0.018807929,
-0.0430850126,
0.0298418086,
0.0357925557,
0.0145071968,
0.0019112282,
-0.0343572497,
0.0050846678,
-0.0649065971,
0.0370438248,
0.018452866,
-0.0129915765,
-0.0307195205,
0.0540899523,
0.0301491581,
-0.0053524249,
-0.010587723,
0.0322751477,
-0.0075146891,
-0.0107587557,
-0.0766730234,
-0.0461502969,
-0.0367672704,
-0.0219707936,
0.0258363858,
-0.0625214875,
0.017014591,
-0.0472532846,
-0.0189871173,
-0.0184537042,
0.0277145784,
0.0392372236,
-0.02411809,
-0.0001158693,
-0.0001406347,
-0.0406109579,
0.0262263902,
0.0029417572,
-0.007778218,
0.031399101,
0.0152263008,
0.0426631831,
0.0393870883,
0.0199093428,
-0.0136266006,
-0.0173193403,
0.0398515537,
-0.0166880153,
0.0829084367,
0.0124807619,
-0.0810698718,
-0.0228363629,
-0.0122518679,
0.0090509215,
-0.0255972818,
-0.0821302831,
0.0234734733,
0.0022429451,
0.0259720795,
0.0307002813,
-0.0082848342,
0.0161069632,
0.0173177142,
-0.0402232856,
0.0086921398,
0.020412311,
-0.0155867869,
-0.0226018541,
0.0314394906,
0.0103861587,
-0.0194509905,
-0.0807166472,
-0.0033332312,
-0.0123284422,
0.011154267,
-0.0256801434,
0.019919036,
0.0301056895,
-0.0299635176,
0.0289969724,
0.0391975082,
-0.0466148145,
-0.0541425794,
-0.0026964985,
0.0407655537,
-0.0450195931,
-0.0142858969,
-0.0286699776,
0.0161518194,
-0.0248861685,
0.0811997727,
0.0566711091,
0.0272572264,
-0.0125255901,
0.0174045805,
-0.0318122357,
-0.0108714318,
-0.0396407023,
0.016883228,
0.0076318644,
-0.0032137823,
-0.0176457092,
0.0240153577,
0.0228748918,
-0.0528455824,
0.0196016375,
0.0381869227,
-0.006000191,
0.025187498,
0.020317696,
0.0278327577,
0.0525089204,
0.0077346056,
0.0268292855,
0.0522586852,
-0.0425275713,
-0.0423647873,
0.0222712643,
-0.0310030598,
-0.0254985224,
0.0473138131,
-0.051251702,
-0.0134311272,
-0.0179948024,
-0.0380271561,
-0.0133114764,
0.0452956446,
-0.0335186459,
0.0015216373,
-0.0241166037,
-0.0053101419,
0.0371018238,
0.0074303588,
-0.0162936058,
0.1145614758,
0.0025607094,
-0.0126939537,
-0.0155271515,
0.0244760793,
0.0495053418,
-0.0516110957,
0.0027173716,
-0.0136508141,
-0.0267130807,
0.0016128806,
0.0191129968,
-0.0454672985,
-0.0359505042,
0.0071024057,
-0.0625375435,
0.0152564915,
-0.0091734305,
0.0429260023,
0.0287562553,
-0.044122383,
0.0209661461,
-0.0028163707,
-0.0268168841,
-0.00624019,
-0.042831786,
-0.0114049017,
0.0584824421,
-0.0443730839,
0.0408305787,
-0.0672481954,
-0.0161755234,
-0.0486408174,
0.0358957723,
0.0218067151,
-0.0126412017,
0.0003629434,
-0.0152830658,
-0.0089898994,
0.0220332444,
-0.020100724,
-0.0334571302,
0.0359437242,
-0.0002287175,
0.0024280313,
0.0984198824,
0.0444405563,
0.0218577795,
0.0018071029,
-0.0109495632,
-0.0453281142,
0.0257579554,
-0.0275891591,
0.0709769726,
0.0222252123,
-0.0111054834,
0.0575394928,
0.1170156524,
-0.0092995409,
0.0107051283,
-0.0353863873,
0.0289055351,
0.0267277434,
0.0375134386,
0.0390335247,
-0.0186991654,
-0.0032092072,
0.0370975249,
-0.0594335273,
-0.0037900836,
0.0537205078,
-0.0262475088,
0.0130844368,
-0.0284436233,
-0.0470221713,
-0.0356226638,
0.0150171947,
-0.0021272267,
0.0092958678,
0.0542660318,
0.002262227,
0.0387978144,
-0.0231384467,
0.0318990834,
-0.0061792908,
0.0276511684,
0.0037924252,
-0.0080944682,
-0.0038427936,
-0.0087358514,
-0.0280957501,
-0.0197187886,
-0.0309362821,
-0.0182896815,
-0.0157881528,
-0.0018598386,
-0.0038105615,
-0.0343612246,
0.0017845742,
0.0125843575,
0.001173568,
0.0081402948,
-0.0064801527,
0.0029842842,
-0.0074655903,
0.00401993,
0.03487508,
0.0020642665,
0.0337558351,
0.0836676583,
-0.0343493819,
0.0005776755,
-0.0750159696,
-0.046346195,
-0.0544283018,
-0.0146501558,
-0.0088941576,
-0.030497944,
0.014199907,
-0.0540293828,
0.0515324511,
0.0519869961,
0.0207794849,
-0.017502835,
0.0047163409,
-0.04141495,
-0.0278868061,
0.0010006075,
0.0005404342,
-0.0745104849,
-0.0410022922,
-0.0439374298,
-0.0093358932,
-0.0026622482,
-0.0313516743,
0.0215127449,
-0.0575202629,
0.0288138594,
-0.0041770898,
0.0166827459,
-0.0258497503,
-0.0396144763,
0.0138037689,
-0.0155336922,
-0.0468257554,
0.0031085033,
0.0139998868,
-0.0230581332,
-0.0026447084,
-0.0320382565,
0.0340734199,
0.0302874036,
-0.0491249524,
0.0122506497,
0.0129086589,
0.0926723704,
0.0196281336,
-0.0319731757,
0.0326547064,
-0.0376510881,
-0.0249127075,
0.0009341479,
0.0515145548,
-0.0207015686,
-0.017127255,
-0.0235450584,
0.0313929543,
-0.0282579269,
-0.0305090863,
0.0153571684,
0.0605366193,
-0.0256361552,
-0.0110882111,
-0.032713972,
0.0201896038,
-0.0185213666,
0.0379227214,
0.0393306538,
0.0193618033,
-0.0465187877,
-0.0439366996,
-0.0213449299,
-0.0671976581,
-0.0064279204,
0.0103963381,
0.0108151687,
-0.0044558141,
-0.0774878561,
-0.0529479608,
-0.0224990677,
0.0153200282,
-0.0486081243,
-0.0311913304,
0.0405348353,
-0.0219187438,
-0.0270889755,
0.0336953141,
-0.0068200384,
-0.0072522596,
0.0016899996,
0.0029117272,
0.0054616788,
0.013355528,
-0.0146108149,
0.0375001021,
-0.0077436692,
-0.0516408049,
-0.0444105454,
0.0398955047,
0.0068932446,
0.047575023,
-0.0183396507,
-0.0160447229,
-0.0092540113,
-0.0300515592,
0.0344801992,
-0.0093735969,
0.0731990039,
0.0116441259,
0.0105925724,
0.0084073683,
0.0136459256,
0.0676225573,
-0.0043286132,
0.0271887369,
-0.0598822236,
0.003079742,
0.0066239852,
-0.0298656225,
0.053920012,
0.0780602768,
-0.0607006736,
-0.0274788644,
0.0133487182,
-0.0270180218,
-0.0039160303,
-0.0217631608,
0.0314822011,
-0.0261769593,
-0.0380421616,
-0.0076100929,
-0.0444685705,
-0.0164984278,
0.0245592799,
0.025171373,
0.0392033607,
0.0280486494,
0.0249737948,
-0.0506063402,
-0.015152799,
-0.0271054488,
0.0172152482,
-0.0096154073,
0.0426587574,
-0.001150443,
0.0644798055,
0.0125034908,
-0.024968354,
0.0110457707,
-0.011632516,
-0.0460659862,
-0.0252244137,
-0.0154938167,
-0.0397218466,
0.0202595089,
-0.0356024578,
0.0587365367,
0.0111538405,
0.0053966655,
-0.0034136942,
0.0409979895,
-0.0144458599,
-0.0132036768,
0.0274436995,
0.0242379867,
-0.0378625542,
-0.0223192386,
0.0236537717,
-0.0198947228,
-0.0025228085,
0.0170059558,
-0.0174011644,
-0.0415351465,
-0.0170535501,
-0.0285165161,
0.0448333919,
-0.0236805733,
0.0127048315,
0.0000504429,
0.0024462836,
-0.0252980776,
0.0225480087,
0.0172866117,
0.0115497382,
0.0206370726,
0.0378439985,
0.0169468373,
-0.0030507199,
-0.0462215953,
0.0263139419,
-0.0035288231,
0.0124563323,
-0.0110848499,
-6.673309348e-33,
-0.0073636421,
-0.0273993984,
-0.0230715256,
0.0666170493,
0.0176943354,
0.0045268005,
-0.0693347082,
-0.0004503675,
-0.0588613339,
0.0639953762,
0.0290202592,
0.0402308889,
0.0084626088,
0.0041432572,
0.004410875,
-0.002080776,
0.0150982346,
-0.0043712095,
-0.0006627819,
0.0223720707,
0.0559054874,
-0.0135139488,
0.0473688357,
-0.0710862353,
0.0326607227,
0.0114665208,
0.0178457294,
0.0244552828,
-0.0122740483,
0.0778046697,
0.0131715164,
0.0261625126,
0.0435954258,
-0.0368395075,
0.0030320359,
0.0595341846,
-0.1111406907,
-0.0558250025,
0.0046724058,
-0.0705046058,
-0.060195107,
-0.0487902015,
0.0335126668,
0.0481744744,
0.0720049962,
-0.0417909399,
0.0458425544,
-0.0184864216,
0.0079717329,
-0.0338740647,
-0.0481895581,
0.053234417,
-0.0135094803,
-0.0177620072,
-0.0150373587,
0.0494808517,
0.0033926908,
0.0949845836,
-0.068293795,
-0.0027241141,
-0.0048233205,
-0.0014524389,
-0.0298785549,
-0.0542442128,
-0.0274426602,
0.0773530006,
-0.0135010034,
0.0138746779,
-0.0624940097,
0.0362114348,
-0.0179123618,
0.0854334459,
0.0712698549,
0.0247868393,
0.0255800486,
0.0244131107,
-0.0947386622,
-0.0510807447,
0.0633623153,
0.06993334,
0.0088591725,
0.0038806885,
0.0088160234,
0.0075234999,
0.0125584221,
-0.0904652029,
-0.0338964537,
-0.0266263951,
-0.0234626681,
0.0333944112,
-0.0037708995,
0.0160587691,
0.0021615361,
-0.0189045053,
0.0329670832,
0.0311212391,
0.0239228122,
-0.0092265829,
0.0226730909,
0.0162324235,
-0.0609130599,
0.0158562995,
0.0025301678,
-0.0113670416,
0.0290209185,
0.0105625149,
0.0340107046,
-0.0559317619,
-0.0299896952,
-0.0202955473,
-0.0112795224,
-0.0018244222,
-0.0503157154,
0.0797925517,
0.0094849458,
0.0319267213,
-0.004369935,
0.0590725839,
-0.0080462638,
0.0257077217,
-0.0502616949,
-0.0447746515,
-0.004604158,
0.0220350139,
-0.0041187578,
-0.0317251347,
-0.0040472266,
0.0159937665,
0.0136878444,
-0.0736310855,
-0.0035612022,
-0.014761379,
2.565e-7,
0.0638573095,
0.0379056185,
0.0236412864,
-0.0194594078,
0.0251049064,
0.0457005352,
0.0263929162,
0.0370806307,
0.0111224307,
-0.0580151118,
-0.0540361106,
0.0254650656,
0.0377719961,
0.0227863267,
-0.0893638059,
-0.0631879419,
-0.0757880881,
-0.0513525531,
-0.0127216792,
-0.0317821838,
0.0746997595,
0.0925914273,
0.0142411757,
0.0134522188,
-0.0256518964,
0.0186967701,
0.0506154075,
0.014165353,
-0.001866953,
-0.012154608,
0.0554916002,
-0.0556976348,
-0.0293194484,
0.0234231912,
0.0003395281,
0.0464403443,
-0.0296954121,
0.0631218478,
-0.0207819976,
-0.0341329537,
0.027003292,
-0.026844006,
0.0285158902,
-0.0531984866,
0.0415364094,
-0.0978420377,
-0.0220614523,
-0.0459718779,
-0.0389056876,
0.0356000774,
0.0171247981,
0.0160763264,
0.0014244351,
-0.0116335433,
-0.0227368679,
-0.0240536053,
0.0304892119,
-0.1062942594,
-0.0444322005,
0.0282844938,
-0.0146849407,
0.0071030678,
-0.0142165413,
-0.0258620605,
0.0435788333,
-0.0159020629,
0.024143137,
1.715189636e-34,
0.0330205001,
-0.0189248938,
-0.0023488926,
0.0313902162,
0.0414565839,
0.0120524894,
-0.0260771047,
-0.0091703823,
0.0239893887,
-0.0363130681,
-0.0067362036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09298v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09298v1 | OWL: A Large Language Model for IT Operations | 2023-09-17T15:19:29 | 2023-09-17T15:19:29 | Hongcheng Guo, Jian Yang, Jiaheng Liu, Liqun Yang, Linzheng Chai, Jiaqi Bai, Junran Peng, Xiaorong Hu, Chao Chen, Dongfeng Zhang, Xu Shi, Tieqiao Zheng, Liangfan Zheng, Bo Zhang, Ke Xu, Zhoujun Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the rapid development of IT operations, it has become increasingly
crucial to efficiently manage and analyze large volumes of data for practical
applications. The techniques of Natural Language Processing (NLP) have shown
remarkable capabilities for various tasks, including named entity recognition,
machine translation and dialogue systems. Recently, Large Language Models
(LLMs) have achieved significant improvements across various NLP downstream
tasks. However, there is a lack of specialized LLMs for IT operations. In this
paper, we introduce the OWL, a large language model trained on our collected
OWL-Instruct dataset with a wide range of IT-related information, where the
mixture-of-adapter strategy is proposed to improve the parameter-efficient
tuning across different domains or tasks. Furthermore, we evaluate the
performance of our OWL on the OWL-Bench established by us and open IT-related
benchmarks. OWL demonstrates superior performance results on IT tasks, which
outperforms existing models by significant margins. Moreover, we hope that the
findings of our work will provide more insights to revolutionize the techniques
of IT operations with specialized LLMs. | [
0.0826845914,
0.0623738132,
0.0078370823,
0.0405223332,
-0.0141186714,
0.0286957268,
-0.0188119449,
0.0012355793,
0.0250408836,
-0.1076172814,
-0.023490753,
-0.0123013202,
-0.0087495502,
0.0292666052,
-0.0206268784,
-0.0526900031,
0.0285027474,
-0.0215887725,
-0.0273402445,
0.0349090919,
-0.0095108096,
0.0507355742,
-0.0140367337,
0.0346659012,
0.0332878828,
0.0056847297,
-0.0035074041,
0.0188402534,
-0.0077223857,
-0.0105202207,
0.0119017204,
0.0067783259,
0.0302658975,
0.0552776642,
0.0000021465,
-0.0608972199,
-0.072247915,
-0.0009777066,
-0.0543126278,
0.0205842759,
0.0539164618,
0.0098354444,
-0.0133502111,
0.0445466377,
-0.0147729069,
-0.0336653665,
0.0560655929,
0.0820003152,
0.0523570552,
0.1208449677,
-0.013912403,
0.0043351981,
0.0265551824,
0.0162963774,
-0.0296314359,
-0.0465746261,
0.0313832387,
-0.0063902601,
0.0089241005,
0.0378118791,
-0.004063691,
-0.0108826617,
-0.0214983057,
0.0174220037,
0.010732674,
0.0053920187,
-0.0329915285,
0.0048894444,
-0.0526755862,
0.0651942492,
-0.0309739374,
0.0017162331,
0.0229674745,
-0.0074859252,
-0.0318903849,
-0.011217121,
0.003048277,
0.0088219997,
0.0079458719,
0.0173128992,
0.0367857814,
0.0071797739,
-0.0052681756,
0.0385541134,
-0.0598731861,
0.0625173301,
-0.0029283753,
-0.0155306924,
-0.0085201627,
-0.0248446055,
0.0274094027,
-0.0422297828,
-0.0135658784,
0.0778248757,
-0.0666768253,
0.0160456505,
-0.0269965716,
-0.0047897045,
0.0079401387,
-0.0565101542,
0.0349598601,
0.0415512435,
0.0370187759,
0.0598505549,
-0.0042308848,
0.0500910655,
0.00362847,
-0.0182931498,
-0.0484872349,
-0.0308183394,
-0.1059088185,
0.0074849357,
-0.0596128926,
0.0479931571,
-0.0355298221,
-0.0592424162,
-0.0325379595,
0.0484836474,
0.0135779371,
0.0221350845,
0.0043237223,
-0.0237525534,
-0.0089897765,
-0.0334216207,
-0.0405533351,
0.0403750315,
0.0037767387,
0.0136866914,
-0.0014381193,
-0.051976826,
0.0205350406,
0.040619012,
0.0217702184,
-0.0456747189,
0.0000707198,
0.1027521715,
0.0156097086,
-0.0396228582,
-0.0441968925,
-0.0275275987,
0.0395282507,
-0.0345592313,
-0.0144133717,
-0.0409626216,
0.040711537,
0.0149457892,
0.0205156635,
-0.0483770929,
0.0017680363,
-0.0187609233,
-0.0472835563,
0.0770875514,
-0.0431106575,
0.0034101915,
0.0283393022,
-0.006645232,
0.0291885305,
0.0553647615,
0.0327357464,
0.019952435,
0.0249362309,
0.0072486997,
0.003228493,
0.0395487249,
-0.0501409546,
-0.0218255855,
-0.001480884,
0.050297454,
-0.0040491694,
0.0068825036,
0.0156171704,
0.0595960841,
0.0167448074,
0.0231687948,
0.0317119621,
0.0139406594,
0.0300550275,
0.0192568954,
0.0181463473,
0.0595309064,
-0.0039259903,
-0.0441544615,
-0.0195589121,
0.000544333,
-0.0395269357,
0.0066579892,
-0.002683789,
0.0284089595,
-0.0463107675,
-0.0282229763,
-0.0242933575,
-0.0140487291,
-0.027768502,
-0.0029040554,
0.0495814122,
-0.0110314228,
-0.059724912,
0.0609091558,
0.0164524913,
-0.0083270548,
-0.001992194,
-0.0530330278,
-0.0254824422,
0.0792568401,
0.0261213891,
-0.0892169029,
-0.0343647264,
-0.0416907631,
-0.0073090945,
0.0562601946,
0.069710739,
-0.0050420379,
-0.0195572637,
-0.0476023555,
-0.0220793467,
0.023981547,
0.0078545632,
0.0104256421,
0.0242249221,
0.0022586817,
0.0188498423,
-0.0311321113,
-0.0612679869,
0.0415168181,
-0.0037832714,
-0.0353408717,
0.0215342883,
0.0166406743,
0.0532073639,
0.0046023065,
-0.0410170257,
-0.0238211956,
0.019841345,
-0.0057280781,
-0.0660525635,
-0.0015615325,
-0.0148006929,
-0.0020552403,
0.0242186263,
0.0297394283,
-0.0058277543,
-0.004665215,
-0.0569566824,
-0.0653186291,
0.0155969737,
-0.0362344235,
0.050473541,
-0.0119031481,
0.0285651516,
-0.0242175758,
0.0094622504,
-0.0465263128,
0.0326249041,
0.0095839528,
-0.0059300875,
-0.0049941582,
-0.0532028563,
0.0104507571,
0.005711149,
-0.0267134737,
0.0277561862,
-0.0018649556,
0.0366512984,
0.0332598239,
0.0083690612,
-0.0266985185,
-0.0437114388,
-0.0902938396,
0.0319808535,
-0.013490296,
0.0256296005,
0.0215569772,
0.0518797375,
0.0020460794,
-0.0116932606,
0.0123008741,
0.0185007825,
0.0064444374,
0.0150690824,
0.0166312773,
0.0011625399,
-0.0353658907,
-0.0005053338,
0.0057223882,
-0.0385199301,
0.0405103825,
-0.009626477,
-0.0619647391,
-0.0504973605,
0.0359060168,
-0.0276786238,
0.0119482046,
-0.0075058895,
0.0213196352,
-0.0237482097,
-0.0164165311,
0.05913895,
0.0505711883,
-0.0008372322,
0.0142146684,
-0.0013190771,
-0.0139812194,
-0.0537907369,
0.0058482978,
-0.0054993457,
-0.0050130398,
-0.0205710251,
-0.0221770909,
0.0265208539,
0.0449183285,
-0.0177571569,
0.0064840466,
-0.0276360773,
-0.0222754907,
-0.0349091031,
0.0191127025,
-0.0538037196,
-0.0064396961,
0.0179600995,
0.0218304694,
-0.0101524573,
-0.0332101062,
0.0710199699,
-0.0252206456,
0.0272429138,
-0.0647012889,
-0.0466793999,
-0.0795825571,
0.03650783,
0.0087110959,
0.0512554385,
0.0360486507,
-0.0766624212,
-0.0228890721,
-0.0260548871,
-0.0259428676,
-0.0266062599,
0.0520936362,
-0.0307320748,
0.0350960828,
-0.0344820619,
-0.006161334,
-0.0165113639,
-0.0211241189,
-0.041654285,
0.0301006269,
-0.0391807593,
-0.0384087339,
-0.0801619142,
0.0289170966,
0.008924704,
0.0588034876,
0.0423771217,
-0.032354407,
-0.0142803006,
-0.0153271416,
0.029048726,
0.0378014334,
-0.0005961633,
0.0269342624,
0.0438914411,
0.0001932632,
0.0553931706,
-0.0544153564,
-0.0449554212,
-0.0043207877,
0.0055661919,
-0.0894191638,
0.0039188601,
0.0145181622,
0.040291585,
-0.0533827916,
0.0156802908,
0.1452277154,
0.0133097321,
0.011019866,
-0.0110120438,
0.0263541099,
-0.0050408025,
0.0501997136,
0.0405601971,
-0.090744704,
-0.04012876,
-0.0033546374,
-0.0010117821,
0.0301852729,
-0.0501274206,
0.0217614882,
-0.1067864299,
0.0027866301,
-0.0185151398,
-0.0520677567,
-0.0357101075,
-0.0697767213,
-0.02450216,
-0.0464102849,
0.0133400755,
-0.013212801,
-0.0167615153,
-0.0448369682,
0.0233863667,
-0.0116399545,
-0.0248738006,
0.0198943615,
-0.030237725,
0.0672205016,
0.0237354226,
0.0114404373,
-0.0081167398,
0.0106223319,
0.0068935263,
-0.0061026402,
0.0057798293,
-0.0197470337,
0.0192691628,
-0.0098381415,
-0.0035060539,
0.0143112633,
-0.0003368114,
-0.0855881721,
0.0194831286,
0.023107918,
0.1089837477,
-0.0190094542,
0.0334556922,
-0.0150955366,
-0.0358369052,
0.0141770793,
0.0904084891,
-0.0174743719,
-0.045945134,
-0.0211721715,
-0.0181786679,
-0.0549014322,
0.0120537635,
0.0138469962,
0.0065069753,
-0.0080637252,
0.011913415,
-0.0528349616,
0.0208246093,
0.057012096,
0.021217268,
0.0160283167,
0.0142430998,
0.0215721559,
0.0128200948,
-0.0473921746,
0.0315987319,
-0.0467099287,
0.0304822084,
-0.0833993852,
-0.005031833,
0.0479669943,
-0.0024348141,
-0.0276396684,
0.037787389,
-0.0206318125,
-0.0719084442,
-0.0099792406,
0.0201771613,
0.0223231986,
0.0332660303,
0.0007675813,
-0.0399925299,
0.0229703411,
0.0270545594,
-0.0189862158,
-0.0194248073,
0.0089671155,
0.0014334531,
-0.0236016121,
0.0333854742,
-0.0615484565,
0.003394335,
0.0179605037,
0.0172859803,
-0.0153725529,
-0.0399027579,
0.0218016189,
0.012473953,
-0.0328852497,
-0.0148480646,
-0.0413273163,
-0.031872917,
0.0358367637,
-0.0018821504,
-0.0350715294,
-0.0099188769,
-0.0132913319,
0.0336965807,
-0.0105932234,
0.015051648,
0.0193793308,
-0.0210775807,
0.0263290163,
-0.0135503225,
0.0384957641,
-0.0011692733,
-0.0027119839,
0.033164598,
-0.0001106776,
-0.0003099131,
0.0203382745,
0.038691245,
0.0401059538,
-0.0339916125,
0.0427231602,
-0.0063750404,
-0.0027380427,
-0.0416246057,
0.0141218025,
-0.0193403922,
-0.046698194,
0.0019290257,
0.040556822,
0.0372059532,
-0.0216092039,
0.0102260029,
-0.0120038455,
0.002208533,
-0.0241572149,
0.0420863815,
0.0006973753,
-0.0060192039,
0.0184183717,
0.0355605669,
-0.0379443988,
0.0475282483,
0.0631813258,
0.0212645531,
0.0273516886,
0.0169403963,
-0.0102835968,
-0.0810269639,
0.0158932004,
0.0222211573,
0.0369657613,
-0.0535163209,
0.0324803926,
0.003773242,
-0.045697961,
0.0301087815,
-0.0346797146,
0.0249148384,
-0.023194205,
0.0316316299,
0.0447810069,
0.0160495695,
0.0160388257,
-0.0436263382,
-0.0413077362,
-0.0170782432,
-0.0153452922,
-0.0326004289,
-6.310420283e-33,
-0.0229918305,
-0.0006607601,
0.0230646003,
0.0272432938,
0.0284363758,
0.0357884876,
-0.0103765763,
0.0057095275,
-0.0330030434,
-0.0363126583,
-0.0068865973,
0.0064062192,
0.0227673929,
0.0387299396,
-0.0244526938,
0.0306044426,
0.0526751727,
0.0046288944,
-0.0193400495,
0.0173422638,
0.0557242259,
0.0167408641,
0.0730609372,
-0.046505142,
-0.0117255673,
0.0114784287,
0.0063571874,
0.0190503486,
0.047797285,
0.071316205,
-0.0182235837,
0.0618872643,
0.0341683589,
-0.0375164598,
0.0109733632,
0.0285237748,
-0.0853380561,
0.0079310108,
0.0005661924,
0.0236065686,
0.0445662439,
-0.027572114,
0.0333793648,
-0.0282702502,
-0.0028432517,
0.0200155228,
0.0331478268,
-0.0115930671,
0.0039691273,
-0.0096228123,
-0.0974907577,
0.0337532721,
-0.0327268317,
-0.0014234217,
0.0171316974,
0.0058412612,
0.0048201634,
0.0012081928,
-0.0649054721,
0.0113555044,
0.022238614,
0.023203766,
0.0264642667,
0.0281809587,
-0.0199983791,
0.026148092,
-0.0394311324,
0.021139374,
0.0247008484,
-0.0033601781,
0.0023553441,
0.0584380217,
-0.0065945452,
-0.0261927303,
-0.0280860085,
-0.0141403675,
-0.0652233511,
0.0372611955,
0.0342581049,
0.0471115708,
0.0441793948,
0.0386641659,
-0.0551873595,
0.0141073698,
-0.022129057,
0.0178986881,
-0.0559148639,
-0.0216693114,
0.0231912173,
0.0557741374,
-0.0463608019,
0.017975118,
0.0525578037,
-0.0643649921,
-0.0237508435,
-0.0080229128,
-0.0100700958,
0.0065344274,
-0.0037253683,
0.0502383038,
-0.094592467,
-0.0993372425,
0.0091777984,
-0.0009321844,
0.0028333645,
-0.0272161141,
0.0260795932,
0.0300554484,
-0.0852143988,
0.0287427921,
-0.0112627279,
0.0201352835,
-0.052068077,
0.0694582686,
0.0083025945,
0.0126270112,
-0.0059568398,
0.0201478414,
-0.025557965,
-0.0570327416,
-0.0152064729,
0.0069959001,
0.0053378753,
0.0010943081,
-0.0269649904,
0.0146855479,
-0.0243103057,
-0.0316803195,
0.0021584935,
-0.0289588459,
-0.0215728823,
-0.0005820529,
2.927e-7,
0.02678461,
0.0786183774,
-0.014457087,
0.0211877264,
0.0107869487,
0.0091113308,
0.0085108839,
0.0063940412,
-0.0043375855,
0.0008319543,
0.0005663274,
0.0062308703,
0.0229504015,
0.0077118417,
-0.0821725875,
-0.0416241102,
-0.0412002355,
0.0072326325,
-0.0821074918,
0.0208196919,
0.0315953791,
0.1384048611,
-0.0101518054,
-0.0101075517,
-0.0313321948,
-0.0683023185,
0.015885748,
-0.0363087021,
-0.00959362,
0.0537437536,
0.0269150138,
0.0943940654,
-0.0111037213,
0.0415988714,
-0.0196545441,
0.0489098467,
0.0009604156,
0.0759620443,
-0.013782016,
0.0028863894,
0.0174723435,
-0.0723642707,
0.0046522343,
-0.0505628213,
0.0595157072,
-0.0288454778,
-0.0349623784,
-0.0194919407,
-0.0188070219,
-0.005826619,
-0.0183822066,
-0.0279679168,
-0.0150028663,
0.0175020229,
0.0285205953,
-0.0399953872,
-0.0160044599,
-0.0731939897,
0.0232829247,
0.015154927,
-0.0176381338,
-0.0276917927,
-0.0113958232,
-0.0547458529,
0.0234072525,
-0.0369504839,
0.0137466723,
2.879174588e-34,
0.0142559437,
0.0226536933,
-0.0136079723,
0.0404416174,
0.0510347523,
0.0150906648,
-0.0260829087,
0.0092150494,
-0.0111973826,
-0.0901461169,
0.0121643739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09296v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09296v1 | Model-based Subsampling for Knowledge Graph Completion | 2023-09-17T15:12:50 | 2023-09-17T15:12:50 | Xincan Feng, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Katsuhiko Hayashi, Taro Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Subsampling is effective in Knowledge Graph Embedding (KGE) for reducing
overfitting caused by the sparsity in Knowledge Graph (KG) datasets. However,
current subsampling approaches consider only frequencies of queries that
consist of entities and their relations. Thus, the existing subsampling
potentially underestimates the appearance probabilities of infrequent queries
even if the frequencies of their entities or relations are high. To address
this problem, we propose Model-based Subsampling (MBS) and Mixed Subsampling
(MIX) to estimate their appearance probabilities through predictions of KGE
models. Evaluation results on datasets FB15k-237, WN18RR, and YAGO3-10 showed
that our proposed subsampling methods actually improved the KG completion
performances for popular KGE models, RotatE, TransE, HAKE, ComplEx, and
DistMult. | [
0.0206248406,
0.0019908096,
-0.0022174416,
0.0197207052,
0.0157718994,
-0.0014366888,
-0.0433655195,
0.0430580452,
0.0809915215,
-0.0105236741,
0.0419143364,
0.0205054525,
-0.012580514,
-0.0148488153,
0.0498356596,
-0.057020478,
0.0175724477,
0.0188249368,
-0.0372610167,
-0.0246173758,
-0.0299102943,
0.0309178401,
0.0173737705,
0.0038223679,
-0.0099675609,
-0.0111871772,
-0.0093236566,
0.0199898202,
-0.0172391292,
0.0228312053,
-0.0283389315,
0.0242537726,
0.014355897,
-0.0329078585,
0.0000020733,
-0.0159465391,
-0.0256287009,
0.0317187496,
-0.0558487736,
0.0154371941,
-0.0007848092,
-0.0031058968,
0.0835508108,
0.0005112921,
-0.010994548,
-0.0148979258,
-0.0042548534,
0.0804934725,
-0.0259538386,
-0.002470884,
-0.0045157429,
0.0001412118,
0.0291752722,
-0.0333751366,
-0.0096891653,
-0.0068771606,
0.0234721974,
0.0303335711,
0.008527183,
-0.0157717727,
-0.0290689617,
0.0368968509,
-0.0060092257,
0.0147609655,
0.0727399141,
0.0318636894,
-0.016634861,
0.0237897933,
0.044725053,
0.0830956772,
-0.0138597814,
0.0374494083,
4.569e-7,
-0.0143666752,
0.0039015012,
0.0731481463,
-0.0309762154,
-0.0755148083,
0.0026083742,
-0.0037451549,
-0.0504100546,
-0.0169085637,
0.0525488518,
-0.0125958575,
-0.0356439501,
0.0477894023,
-0.0000272368,
-0.0218501128,
0.0157472678,
-0.0009688484,
-0.0330404043,
-0.0558153391,
-0.0206727739,
-0.0243186448,
0.002543783,
0.018298272,
-0.0181138813,
0.0356121808,
-0.0038804535,
0.0082499813,
-0.0132806944,
0.01793251,
0.0244087968,
0.0659573302,
-0.0144310202,
-0.0020985669,
-0.009241567,
-0.0049303221,
-0.0333221853,
-0.009838786,
-0.0446976535,
0.0182094127,
-0.0086239651,
0.0456504114,
-0.0395490341,
-0.0253594201,
-0.0471268818,
0.0256615765,
-0.0024564762,
0.0323572904,
0.0229363907,
0.0487266034,
0.0002710718,
-0.0166296307,
-0.0378897265,
0.0166471433,
-0.0074934829,
0.0053832605,
-0.0128410021,
0.0198555104,
-0.0053010345,
-0.0278433729,
0.0357198045,
-0.0413609669,
-0.0048712688,
0.0145169748,
0.03274744,
-0.0347914435,
-0.0620804094,
-0.0694160014,
0.0145853199,
-0.00030097,
0.0063082925,
-0.0443009213,
0.0498381965,
0.0194195546,
0.0208294019,
-0.0234819334,
-0.0064200186,
-0.0283484999,
-0.0848432183,
0.0573271476,
-0.0312662385,
0.0097300448,
-0.0376153439,
-0.0137129389,
-0.0458747186,
0.0598511994,
-0.0031891791,
0.008435538,
0.0480100363,
-0.0158534311,
-0.0731695592,
0.0048063369,
0.0701561049,
0.0047698705,
0.0093318466,
0.0111427158,
-0.0159467943,
0.0148916841,
0.0201773029,
0.001811672,
-0.037629135,
-0.010646008,
-0.0046565449,
0.0127798533,
0.0084611708,
0.0072076726,
-0.0025967893,
0.0119336825,
-0.0228725001,
0.0455849245,
-0.0053371694,
0.0155887436,
-0.0193462297,
0.0180416442,
0.0510089546,
0.0188061036,
-0.0218897108,
-0.011294595,
0.0151359355,
-0.0190358311,
0.0095398361,
0.0372767188,
0.0631874055,
0.0107191727,
-0.0139815668,
0.0344197042,
0.0628141165,
0.0063604242,
0.0199217908,
0.0204189792,
-0.0139160166,
0.0542263761,
0.0587456115,
-0.0089636724,
0.0193176065,
-0.0032862034,
-0.0018413964,
-0.0650146529,
0.0038131257,
-0.0389365815,
0.0231670626,
-0.0251582488,
-0.1054108813,
0.0137794008,
0.0002358848,
-0.0118310833,
0.022508556,
0.0403330624,
0.0381070338,
-0.1198659241,
0.0260475967,
-0.0048789787,
-0.0604996718,
0.0371883623,
-0.0005308815,
0.0272949915,
0.0148457857,
0.039183706,
0.0114519224,
-0.0075838193,
0.0379321948,
-0.0133563057,
-0.0360050388,
-0.0633554831,
0.0365168676,
-0.0844931304,
0.0514469258,
-0.0354175009,
0.0165323392,
-0.0200002696,
-0.009822093,
-0.042539347,
-0.0161578171,
-0.0113789309,
0.1048009843,
0.0039281845,
-0.0090445718,
-0.0070593324,
-0.051672738,
-0.0212178547,
0.047115963,
-0.0420216881,
0.0143944742,
0.0052707368,
-0.1188284457,
0.0246953238,
-0.0177174117,
-0.050743334,
-0.0085751116,
0.0146932332,
-0.0289444607,
0.0056788349,
-0.0664438456,
-0.0785399005,
0.0192078035,
-0.0846334174,
0.0021965022,
0.0319125168,
-0.0227290913,
-0.0517037809,
0.0478763767,
0.0258886181,
-0.0121280979,
0.0052683507,
-0.0119068678,
-0.0378755592,
0.0184489973,
-0.0248563942,
0.0127900122,
0.0028805393,
-0.0001273173,
-0.0664398223,
-0.0193877481,
0.0693274513,
-0.0296077374,
0.0188841689,
0.0262080189,
0.0551924482,
-0.0579438508,
-0.014473903,
-0.0304877292,
0.0117715988,
-0.0296315998,
0.0075272098,
-0.00020051,
0.0141199995,
-0.0520105138,
-0.0314384811,
0.0098483181,
-0.0015917891,
-0.0637068301,
0.0116902646,
-0.0285850428,
0.0348759294,
-0.0316807628,
-0.0361441858,
-0.0428738743,
-0.0199951008,
0.0204867702,
-0.036661759,
-0.057818979,
0.0053559789,
-0.0045213522,
-0.0022468891,
-0.0095683271,
0.0350950137,
0.0523032583,
0.0030336671,
-0.0462887846,
0.0107244477,
0.0552565716,
0.0243520495,
0.0321632475,
0.0609876439,
0.0249306019,
0.0165550392,
0.0165569596,
0.0144230016,
-0.0021559256,
0.0211640727,
0.0140032498,
-0.0338094421,
-0.0289736837,
0.0158799738,
-0.0453197844,
0.028246196,
0.051327154,
0.0005845753,
0.0380824506,
-0.0052599194,
-0.0238890089,
0.0147698643,
-0.0159894526,
0.0304047614,
0.0386190899,
-0.0172368102,
0.0135384165,
0.0062910505,
-0.0128413523,
-0.0265454575,
0.0210406389,
-0.0375335291,
-0.010469446,
0.0349155366,
0.0663879812,
-0.0242452044,
-0.0032700885,
0.0158053804,
0.0061925249,
0.0309123751,
0.0378862135,
-0.0148050915,
0.0152581669,
0.0136469165,
0.0106525254,
-0.0212559476,
-0.0585714318,
-0.0108137876,
0.0060071042,
0.0199297387,
0.055812858,
0.0822026953,
0.0075150477,
-0.013597833,
0.0258309748,
0.0207609143,
0.052354183,
0.0578486584,
0.0081088366,
-0.0778734684,
0.0071768709,
0.0122788316,
0.037923228,
0.038850721,
-0.0829056576,
0.0359506086,
-0.071811758,
0.0490382984,
0.0312764719,
0.0170068387,
-0.0530005433,
-0.0438723639,
0.0323892385,
-0.0193613172,
-0.0516210645,
-0.0200156402,
-0.0139944339,
0.0052995849,
0.0263414904,
-0.0159564801,
-0.0772291124,
0.0162612516,
-0.0685313344,
0.0289508868,
-0.049230922,
0.0405976102,
0.0146019906,
0.0081106443,
-0.0835497454,
0.0099293925,
-0.0254639313,
-0.0077387532,
0.0870888829,
-0.0158290863,
-0.0066912449,
-0.0361302122,
-0.0370475836,
-0.0106398584,
0.0084304512,
-0.0089679146,
0.1241034567,
0.0048087761,
0.0019108907,
-0.0435768664,
-0.0573039129,
0.0092995698,
0.0427262075,
0.0210970063,
0.0372875035,
0.0387452766,
-0.0076353578,
0.0450554937,
-0.0036706869,
0.0568288341,
0.0512439944,
-0.0381798595,
0.0233715642,
-0.0214573964,
-0.0184595808,
0.0628977343,
0.002150482,
-0.0137924431,
0.0390644446,
0.0438217185,
-0.0273367893,
-0.0603164025,
-0.0174846519,
-0.0284118168,
0.0191033911,
0.0156823117,
-0.0273892079,
-0.019305462,
-0.0253666192,
-0.0343457833,
-0.0574333258,
-0.0472298376,
-0.0647739321,
-0.0453529954,
0.0190988332,
0.0098491628,
0.062909916,
-0.0073524253,
-0.0548945367,
0.0785805658,
0.0380110033,
-0.028737288,
-0.007244484,
-0.0082295844,
-0.0670479909,
0.0057580965,
0.0546809658,
-0.0440383777,
-0.0457678847,
-0.0111229056,
0.0201078095,
-0.0329318456,
-0.0231449828,
-0.0176724698,
0.0358929075,
0.0041345796,
0.0078425519,
0.0150799807,
-0.0632381216,
0.0060961153,
-0.004498499,
0.0085305236,
-0.0500533506,
-0.0005481019,
0.0536957569,
0.011069525,
0.0006040829,
-0.0152005609,
-0.0055973497,
0.0331433974,
-0.0346820951,
-0.0218150485,
0.01105884,
-0.0781498626,
0.0633620247,
0.0030584929,
0.0095146038,
-0.0063496269,
0.0088305185,
-0.0030048706,
-0.0086884852,
-0.0334949046,
-0.0020715478,
0.0084288483,
-0.0519285351,
-0.0184635185,
-0.0192852598,
-0.0233895928,
-0.0040045772,
0.0051888651,
0.0650401264,
-0.0575125068,
0.0373496003,
0.0125375027,
-0.0238263719,
-0.0250815805,
0.0255458038,
-0.0029244863,
0.0088972254,
0.0219965503,
0.0271454174,
-0.0245706365,
0.0477966741,
0.0906872004,
0.0462979078,
0.0813036114,
-0.0304472074,
-0.0724208355,
-0.0305639599,
-0.023121763,
0.08514788,
0.0797648057,
-0.0256716348,
0.0281208009,
-0.0362479612,
-0.087371327,
0.0329750925,
-0.0676279217,
-0.0838892758,
-0.0039864872,
0.0349672213,
0.0394233055,
0.0502327047,
-0.043266207,
-0.0493873991,
-0.0164414886,
-0.0297861546,
-0.0261495672,
0.0402317233,
-6.561410367e-33,
-0.0150310853,
0.001000807,
-0.0331307389,
-0.0277927946,
-0.0553133674,
0.0076077399,
0.0144471033,
-0.0313530825,
-0.0461324826,
0.0358097479,
-0.0270410497,
-0.0065098065,
-0.011624828,
-0.0047226199,
0.0117385332,
0.0041934256,
0.0310656875,
0.0183697063,
0.0216528755,
0.0239903424,
0.0055765817,
0.0641606152,
0.0489964969,
-0.0677373409,
0.0142611107,
-0.0014050253,
0.0421949327,
-0.0259088892,
0.010114383,
0.0684548691,
-0.0127732214,
0.0696003512,
0.0124756182,
0.0061137392,
-0.0120966146,
-0.0775341466,
-0.0824593306,
-0.0332051739,
0.0061622225,
0.0075299907,
0.0022495794,
0.0076689417,
0.0514860749,
0.009901166,
0.0375395082,
-0.088064231,
0.0423369035,
-0.0138833579,
-0.1073824167,
-0.0417699702,
0.0333509855,
0.0325043127,
0.0060110255,
-0.0152746774,
0.0186280664,
-0.0030134167,
0.0468616523,
0.0007889413,
-0.0547172353,
-0.0087532988,
0.0379401967,
-0.0076409499,
-0.0059768804,
-0.0079688299,
0.0135809882,
0.0206116233,
-0.0117038134,
0.0186263435,
0.0215961393,
0.01531896,
-0.0094341002,
0.068515189,
-0.0484820195,
0.025055252,
0.0128857447,
-0.0477783717,
-0.0433389358,
-0.0012790461,
-0.0228623319,
0.0010318384,
0.0100266421,
0.0263326075,
-0.0778712779,
-0.0432708226,
-0.0340660997,
-0.0375726968,
-0.0011498187,
-0.0534353927,
-0.0138776386,
0.0222914685,
-0.0009417718,
0.0127713419,
-0.0083705271,
-0.0616969876,
-0.0396875218,
0.0308420062,
0.0141080813,
-0.0178512521,
-0.0011391246,
0.025048444,
-0.0309113581,
-0.0150832301,
0.019463202,
-0.0586143583,
-0.037434198,
0.0170466509,
0.0391953923,
0.0088044452,
0.0009079909,
-0.0336456336,
-0.0038369352,
-0.055999659,
0.0079451362,
-0.0009628058,
0.0560012348,
0.0462482534,
0.0216062963,
0.0175646339,
0.0568205714,
0.0337918513,
0.0093371272,
-0.0175238047,
0.0341424868,
-0.0020001326,
0.0329203494,
-0.0236009508,
-0.0636841729,
-0.0340948403,
-0.0029892614,
-0.003340746,
-0.0453438833,
-0.0258163586,
2.875e-7,
0.0442417711,
0.0079338411,
0.0025453591,
0.058658544,
-0.0035170643,
0.0102887088,
0.0178948604,
0.027162442,
0.006273062,
-0.0365884602,
0.02143199,
-0.0172366258,
0.0081946691,
0.0118724843,
-0.0812653974,
-0.016464131,
-0.0022896926,
-0.0348630138,
-0.0541809425,
-0.0264163706,
0.0514144674,
0.0538692102,
0.0847962201,
0.0284864604,
0.0292545594,
-0.0198354498,
0.0527112298,
-0.0225732829,
-0.018439889,
0.0149792116,
0.0618812963,
0.0765971094,
0.0140241422,
0.0782271847,
-0.0321526006,
0.0254982561,
0.0479606874,
-0.0007149145,
-0.0097905993,
0.0322958753,
-0.0007843904,
-0.0172052849,
0.032339178,
-0.0550332554,
0.0949320048,
-0.0201195367,
0.0158026535,
0.0411579125,
-0.0231090356,
-0.0153857162,
0.0438187793,
0.0134543069,
0.0218351334,
-0.0150529547,
0.0247429125,
0.0258198231,
-0.0091607627,
-0.028433295,
0.028879784,
0.0279433485,
-0.0394966565,
-0.0476163886,
-0.0030663293,
-0.0418712981,
0.0114560761,
-0.008616386,
0.0010447607,
2.731687241e-34,
0.0287380088,
0.0658856854,
0.0233301837,
0.0123312473,
0.0248844475,
-0.0664983466,
0.0048726946,
-0.0425957367,
0.0134249162,
-0.083805643,
-0.0040991623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09274v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09274v1 | Leveraging Social Discourse to Measure Check-worthiness of Claims for Fact-checking | 2023-09-17T13:42:41 | 2023-09-17T13:42:41 | Megha Sundriyal, Md Shad Akhtar, Tanmoy Chakraborty | cs.CL | cs.CL | The expansion of online social media platforms has led to a surge in online
content consumption. However, this has also paved the way for disseminating
false claims and misinformation. As a result, there is an escalating demand for
a substantial workforce to sift through and validate such unverified claims.
Currently, these claims are manually verified by fact-checkers. Still, the
volume of online content often outweighs their potency, making it difficult for
them to validate every single claim in a timely manner. Thus, it is critical to
determine which assertions are worth fact-checking and prioritize claims that
require immediate attention. Multiple factors contribute to determining whether
a claim necessitates fact-checking, encompassing factors such as its factual
correctness, potential impact on the public, the probability of inciting
hatred, and more. Despite several efforts to address claim check-worthiness, a
systematic approach to identify these factors remains an open challenge. To
this end, we introduce a new task of fine-grained claim check-worthiness, which
underpins all of these factors and provides probable human grounds for
identifying a claim as check-worthy. We present CheckIt, a manually annotated
large Twitter dataset for fine-grained claim check-worthiness. We benchmark our
dataset against a unified approach, CheckMate, that jointly determines whether
a claim is check-worthy and the factors that led to that conclusion. We compare
our suggested system with several baseline systems. Finally, we report a
thorough analysis of results and human assessment, validating the efficacy of
integrating check-worthiness factors in detecting claims worth fact-checking. | [
0.0454989113,
0.0355790295,
0.0106717618,
0.012437542,
-0.036638204,
0.0249015018,
-0.0048034647,
0.0056089419,
0.022901807,
-0.0368797146,
0.0221834891,
-0.0079621011,
0.0364348739,
0.0262185317,
0.0279089827,
-0.0035323102,
0.0284102969,
0.0415057354,
0.0883694589,
-0.01300593,
0.023093123,
0.0314929783,
-0.0600354075,
0.0286721196,
-0.0705619752,
0.0123989703,
0.0796959028,
-0.0038933621,
0.0629238859,
-0.0398743637,
0.004064688,
0.0580905303,
-0.0036157721,
0.0847182199,
0.0000016717,
-0.0346166939,
0.0159982182,
0.0269224886,
-0.0375772603,
0.0125404848,
0.0456098951,
0.0117838411,
0.0156764891,
0.0108460709,
-0.0072287372,
0.010140934,
0.0438967831,
0.0500222407,
0.0751846656,
0.0679521635,
-0.0204847325,
-0.0032027112,
-0.0105931964,
0.0053876676,
-0.0302673522,
-0.0451559983,
0.0401035585,
0.0043012928,
-0.0306087658,
0.0077375374,
0.0402102806,
0.0236528441,
0.003770455,
-0.0307021234,
-0.0209386628,
0.002713752,
-0.0739162713,
-0.0233321264,
0.0174075961,
0.0273652729,
0.0253480654,
-0.0425505489,
0.0161883719,
-0.0282561015,
0.0122513259,
0.025930237,
-0.0032640039,
0.0290620737,
-0.0374588519,
-0.0118920272,
-0.0188927501,
0.0150841549,
0.0301236212,
0.0719026402,
0.0631312877,
0.0441586338,
-0.0287447628,
-0.0328729823,
0.0273464136,
0.0145091536,
0.0129449014,
-0.0620928444,
0.0123334853,
-0.0021818532,
-0.0111930016,
0.0014291231,
-0.0047865659,
-0.0227791891,
0.0843826011,
-0.0738617629,
0.0033470728,
-0.0134114325,
-0.0466563329,
0.0597794987,
-0.028908113,
-0.0078755096,
0.0117396004,
-0.0310003832,
0.0643782988,
-0.0042946739,
-0.0221033245,
0.0369605012,
0.0107814949,
-0.0083065778,
0.0179146696,
0.0371446796,
-0.0568416193,
-0.0561825037,
-0.0361228697,
0.0153169846,
-0.0080963178,
-0.00262686,
0.0216493662,
-0.0179673303,
-0.0309192333,
0.0273825843,
-0.0441693477,
0.033916913,
-0.0265923329,
-0.0436465852,
0.0164983924,
0.0106503321,
0.0310835894,
0.0055895676,
0.0149843935,
-0.0314545818,
0.0305905361,
-0.0204986427,
-0.0298572909,
-0.0313639753,
-0.0139378197,
-0.0468954779,
-0.000377817,
-0.0538610257,
0.012582696,
-0.0127293561,
-0.0095898798,
0.021634493,
-0.0015041502,
0.0345558897,
-0.0346284173,
0.0097366283,
-0.0095975697,
0.0126450174,
0.0361662097,
0.0179799069,
0.0113451593,
0.0329159647,
0.0231028143,
0.0670774877,
0.0678555816,
0.0279723145,
0.0224275813,
0.0071070441,
0.048023738,
0.0172968283,
0.068274118,
0.0038225404,
-0.060659837,
-0.0258093253,
-0.0354587808,
0.0354210064,
-0.0150606474,
-0.038568981,
0.0544021018,
0.0190446209,
-0.0356638394,
-0.0525609292,
0.0364691392,
0.0009914452,
0.023763122,
-0.0293020513,
-0.0198771488,
0.0227795299,
-0.0596946999,
-0.0628027022,
0.0327489004,
0.0650150403,
0.0142159378,
-0.0292238686,
-0.0154967187,
0.0313011557,
0.0285855308,
-0.0130696427,
-0.0171190798,
0.0069183894,
-0.0247247629,
0.0067042597,
0.0452254154,
-0.0457944795,
-0.0214426666,
-0.0381913595,
0.0267454851,
-0.0086541586,
0.0104704387,
0.0212557353,
0.0129446937,
-0.0212004408,
0.074655287,
0.0365449637,
0.0603028685,
-0.0153664006,
-0.0184626523,
-0.0001862681,
-0.0159229022,
0.0057400819,
0.0254302397,
-0.006535918,
0.1013778374,
0.0167175718,
-0.0047726631,
-0.0281975474,
-0.066313833,
0.0064109433,
0.0305119026,
0.0079908194,
-0.0160814635,
0.0221573431,
0.0119999181,
0.0263031442,
-0.0007889468,
-0.0291901492,
0.0083055524,
0.0255206823,
-0.0399062112,
0.0057549891,
0.0597721562,
0.0686365813,
0.0059541017,
-0.0679564327,
-0.0845863447,
0.0422466844,
-0.0253003091,
0.0296079796,
-0.007320411,
-0.0382154323,
-0.0546500422,
-0.0203990657,
-0.0589292869,
-0.0513693392,
-0.0036138841,
0.0217803866,
0.069776684,
-0.0192704257,
0.0214864798,
-0.0147622172,
-0.0492331199,
0.0106498916,
-0.0048116362,
-0.014662724,
-0.0211583506,
-0.000605832,
0.0068467506,
0.0240197293,
-0.0479233265,
-0.0475695208,
0.0348219387,
-0.0731659979,
-0.0273299236,
-0.0084286146,
0.0026227629,
0.013971352,
-0.0295663532,
-0.0133640338,
0.0051923953,
0.0020070111,
-0.0021261026,
0.0153809926,
0.0342353694,
0.0395378806,
-0.0187286697,
0.0167620368,
-0.0173960626,
0.0247057006,
-0.0271817558,
0.0085404459,
0.079824008,
-0.0362973474,
-0.0139151588,
-0.0188488401,
-0.0633391812,
-0.0161698181,
-0.0031792389,
-0.0059743705,
0.0315523706,
0.0297199879,
-0.0458687209,
-0.0178902186,
0.0497283228,
0.0050695557,
0.0056371535,
0.0295610856,
0.01665047,
-0.0312986448,
-0.035880141,
-0.0023373875,
0.0103609543,
-0.0798993483,
0.0336320624,
0.0177401714,
0.0096325837,
-0.0031418034,
-0.0530968308,
0.0209792182,
-0.0639189333,
-0.0186003521,
0.0252364986,
0.0040951786,
-0.0061053205,
0.0612331778,
-0.0436206162,
-0.0310942475,
0.0685422271,
-0.0240566544,
0.0544321537,
0.0062295822,
-0.0159911234,
-0.0078948606,
0.0300299171,
0.0036038219,
0.0072132787,
0.0189186577,
0.0107742809,
0.0351031423,
-0.0268448032,
0.0711232945,
-0.0133216903,
-0.023860177,
-0.0009748464,
0.022275541,
0.0249699857,
-0.0257461928,
0.0120270802,
-0.109931916,
-0.0595755875,
-0.0388419703,
-0.0493519008,
-0.0416387208,
-0.053196907,
-0.0462962799,
0.0453539342,
0.0183836091,
0.0124018788,
-0.0209089741,
0.0334026292,
0.0094555644,
-0.0154490471,
0.0413037911,
0.0720803291,
-0.0048772343,
-0.0619951077,
0.0700384974,
-0.0390920267,
0.0137927234,
-0.0292653572,
-0.0618470944,
-0.0363609307,
-0.0117333541,
0.0467413217,
-0.0334698558,
0.0555817112,
-0.0245743934,
0.0227376837,
0.0514415987,
-0.0132314935,
0.0646823794,
0.0036912267,
0.0192451067,
-0.0237842705,
0.0350041538,
-0.0115534142,
-0.1063474193,
-0.0043744631,
-0.037125878,
-0.0025409844,
-0.0420768075,
-0.0467729159,
-0.0045764428,
-0.0660983846,
0.0655514076,
-0.0223486293,
0.0476810224,
-0.0281007029,
-0.0521908626,
0.0310567692,
-0.0092937797,
-0.0106726093,
0.0021171728,
0.0361882672,
-0.0161508042,
0.0102295056,
-0.0443988107,
-0.0296759866,
0.0775675699,
-0.0131276287,
0.0036055606,
0.0052293288,
0.0487246104,
-0.0113749038,
-0.0638884604,
-0.0181939211,
0.0212022532,
-0.0474902801,
0.0037999849,
0.0695853755,
-0.0143341301,
-0.004559306,
-0.0302429069,
0.022414783,
0.0255849063,
-0.0435922481,
-0.0216578357,
0.0569574535,
0.0274871271,
-0.0634861365,
-0.0202109907,
0.0353490897,
0.0270127486,
0.0469810553,
0.0210500993,
0.0436911657,
-0.0038099224,
-0.0126568824,
-0.020406412,
-0.0545881055,
-0.0692467019,
0.0411140956,
0.0292788818,
-0.0573688187,
-0.0727401078,
0.000290871,
-0.0048047835,
0.019278679,
-0.0322583206,
-0.0422932692,
0.0563585497,
0.0230071507,
-0.0464026667,
0.0482222363,
-0.0399671011,
0.054707475,
0.0038313924,
0.0043934961,
0.0166664384,
-0.0002123664,
-0.0076056016,
0.0574428327,
-0.0593160763,
-0.0371251814,
-0.003655703,
-0.0008725358,
0.0186603907,
-0.0015654467,
-0.0351891778,
-0.045306433,
0.0259890463,
0.0534080118,
-0.0423915833,
0.0188321937,
0.0219375286,
-0.0205849409,
0.0159487613,
-0.0185408331,
-0.0008384407,
0.032232292,
0.0208439156,
-0.0221153237,
-0.0414401777,
-0.0003069734,
-0.0056042862,
0.0399800949,
0.0518716648,
-0.0039300118,
-0.0255354457,
-0.039845176,
-0.0305093955,
0.0161569323,
-0.0447182283,
0.0217258744,
0.0162548292,
-0.0209154841,
-0.0059291418,
-0.0552655384,
-0.0151588675,
-0.0291488152,
0.0242939405,
-0.0693807453,
-0.0041298312,
-0.0008993357,
0.0403947309,
-0.0071349083,
-0.0405309014,
-0.0272870902,
0.0064251423,
-0.0284418911,
0.0369476378,
0.0174680986,
0.000171293,
0.0252624508,
0.0013845379,
0.0363440141,
-0.0415032655,
-0.0413504057,
-0.0112777073,
-0.0246138964,
-0.0243219957,
-0.0037514267,
-0.0042694272,
0.0255978107,
-0.0131711941,
-0.0403599702,
0.0224513616,
-0.0319014788,
-0.0386422947,
-0.0319700912,
-0.0018367604,
0.0150234187,
-0.0198638551,
0.0460522361,
0.0242775809,
-0.0306118764,
0.04416712,
0.0307817664,
-0.07352864,
-0.0142192738,
-0.0697835833,
-0.0833967999,
0.0417238995,
0.0260471832,
-0.0078241909,
-0.0862870887,
-0.0359592848,
0.0360755846,
0.0251108911,
0.0358070955,
0.0411687493,
-0.0239920504,
0.0656115189,
0.0308419056,
0.0133060711,
-0.047174301,
0.001245887,
0.0100218887,
0.0036905641,
-0.0051291646,
-6.245658625e-33,
0.0133343199,
-0.0963782147,
-0.0196919721,
0.0155571578,
0.0129169449,
0.0465067923,
-0.0247787032,
-0.0116695259,
-0.0336369798,
0.0767876208,
0.019165514,
0.0535944663,
0.0162954722,
-0.028871242,
0.0037329677,
-0.0119737517,
0.0293287113,
0.0113019655,
-0.0537354313,
0.0178732239,
0.0326639935,
-0.0382117592,
0.013718266,
-0.0789086074,
0.0553816929,
-0.0113852778,
-0.0321302898,
0.0183107182,
-0.0274292622,
0.0276055783,
-0.0003143054,
0.0405327156,
0.051811289,
0.0046023321,
0.0247790869,
0.0288848169,
-0.0560870171,
0.0034306305,
0.0509439744,
-0.0322911367,
-0.0247607473,
0.040381372,
0.0214414652,
-0.0065044654,
-0.0328460634,
-0.0066394079,
0.0150403874,
-0.0171958823,
0.0656745955,
-0.0257214941,
-0.0592753366,
0.0408020876,
0.0193868224,
-0.0027456535,
-0.0392561927,
0.0479849204,
-0.0019725175,
0.0180215165,
-0.0822763517,
0.0502436385,
-0.0383210368,
-0.0383999906,
0.0044552176,
-0.0766850263,
-0.0546787269,
0.0564416684,
-0.0176689867,
0.0639268532,
-0.0520603806,
0.0026055872,
-0.0202105213,
0.050385803,
0.0736607164,
0.1209188849,
0.019133836,
-0.0552457757,
-0.0726799294,
-0.0027932411,
0.0536896065,
-0.0054748319,
0.0168327261,
-0.0620770119,
-0.0337111317,
-0.0032987474,
-0.0207819194,
-0.0071092388,
-0.0565144904,
0.0497279204,
-0.0288843606,
0.0382381268,
-0.0321445018,
0.0531306043,
-0.0118795279,
0.0004108795,
0.037254706,
0.0069464189,
-0.0015726298,
0.0175274145,
0.0258069653,
0.0130275851,
-0.0559176132,
0.0463716425,
0.0044716625,
0.0259118844,
0.0372145921,
-0.0236272682,
0.0694376677,
-0.0057620262,
-0.0428525507,
0.0108348951,
-0.0049297046,
0.0533623733,
-0.0455616899,
-0.0472302511,
0.0372432694,
0.0481954813,
-0.0018355226,
-0.0055605373,
-0.0034623679,
0.0185473133,
-0.0202706959,
0.0171620194,
-0.0065697636,
-0.0057105743,
-0.0037532169,
-0.026321495,
-0.0058022966,
0.0078085745,
-0.0062773386,
-0.0622266829,
0.0309176762,
0.0049391016,
2.565e-7,
0.016910553,
0.0626887977,
-0.0081758667,
-0.0097640809,
0.0298287403,
0.0255167317,
0.038344454,
-0.0081963781,
-0.0171151087,
-0.1024365798,
-0.0297996141,
0.0279542338,
0.0341699384,
0.055054985,
-0.0107662203,
-0.0474702343,
-0.0342884995,
-0.0227306653,
-0.0521355756,
-0.0104871579,
-0.0134471627,
-0.0147195552,
0.0539199263,
-0.0168192107,
-0.0169793312,
-0.0090232966,
0.0383230783,
0.0236286763,
-0.0302767307,
-0.0001344862,
0.0538743287,
-0.0102176089,
0.0167048927,
0.0325143822,
-0.0448245145,
-0.0077345269,
-0.0016622742,
0.0303096641,
0.046008639,
0.0086020483,
-0.0350969136,
-0.0168607309,
0.0241808016,
-0.0239733569,
0.0126548642,
-0.0473894402,
-0.0508466288,
-0.0819078013,
-0.0200938471,
0.0226578489,
0.0361860581,
-0.0000414414,
-0.0248614252,
0.000212096,
-0.011275948,
0.0273476858,
-0.0211129468,
-0.0391220823,
0.0044840723,
0.0194714256,
-0.0509633757,
-0.0550914928,
0.0306798313,
-0.0540120341,
0.0241751224,
-0.0411948748,
0.0355014503,
1.731701773e-34,
0.003645557,
-0.005044031,
0.0166613534,
-0.0881549194,
0.0688185245,
0.0546577573,
-0.0469078496,
-0.0306934938,
0.0301219411,
0.012567725,
0.0118242633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09264v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09264v1 | Code quality assessment using transformers | 2023-09-17T12:59:59 | 2023-09-17T12:59:59 | Mosleh Mahamud, Isak Samsten | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | Automatically evaluate the correctness of programming assignments is rather
straightforward using unit and integration tests. However, programming tasks
can be solved in multiple ways, many of which, although correct, are inelegant.
For instance, excessive branching, poor naming or repetitiveness make the code
hard to understand and maintain. These subjective qualities of code are hard to
automatically assess using current techniques. In this work we investigate the
use of CodeBERT to automatically assign quality score to Java code. We
experiment with different models and training paradigms. We explore the
accuracy of the models on a novel dataset for code quality assessment. Finally,
we assess the quality of the predictions using saliency maps. We find that code
quality to some extent is predictable and that transformer based models using
task adapted pre-training can solve the task more efficiently than other
techniques. | [
0.0248562433,
0.0432286263,
-0.0126665095,
0.0026141512,
0.0260232948,
0.0063442886,
-0.0541501269,
0.0059117656,
0.0072703306,
0.0049772905,
-0.019892212,
0.0386026911,
0.0317414738,
0.0051427307,
-0.0001212057,
-0.030758338,
0.0439551808,
-0.0068765515,
-0.0438460112,
0.0439267755,
-0.0069746217,
-0.022578638,
0.024811158,
0.0560259558,
-0.0167569611,
-0.0458500832,
0.0051558153,
-0.0012234559,
0.0113975098,
0.0074986867,
0.0232191812,
0.0633219182,
-0.0854744762,
-0.0167622622,
0.0000021039,
-0.0054384596,
-0.0078066355,
0.0094164927,
0.0660879537,
0.0436448753,
-0.0234953575,
-0.0096998541,
-0.0105031813,
0.0152139803,
-0.0206984226,
0.0148595935,
0.054546304,
-0.0105095208,
0.1104357541,
0.0259482898,
-0.0028264604,
0.0070229042,
0.0038812545,
0.0371637009,
0.0026599679,
-0.0034518861,
-0.0204533264,
0.0547901541,
-0.0230035,
0.0151376612,
-0.0077205757,
0.0091744736,
0.0347133316,
-0.0253439248,
0.046306219,
0.0036744571,
-0.0531629361,
-0.0068260655,
0.04224528,
0.0169829521,
-0.0959596336,
-0.0408746563,
-0.0155797526,
-0.0303209163,
-0.0297421515,
-0.020740971,
0.0138034457,
-0.0269041695,
-0.000094795,
-0.0090518501,
-0.0002140014,
-0.0090027992,
-0.005274707,
-0.0386718698,
-0.0141045889,
0.0380303524,
-0.0207096301,
-0.0067388625,
-0.0196253397,
0.0060784845,
-0.0188591033,
-0.0358347334,
-0.019958226,
0.0496210642,
-0.0108141284,
-0.0290857144,
-0.0187048335,
-0.0559821799,
0.0285988059,
-0.0407523327,
0.031270653,
0.0232738908,
-0.0471311174,
0.0177699868,
-0.0329347886,
0.0850421712,
0.0182603206,
0.0519029722,
-0.0139567126,
0.0047883526,
-0.0300621092,
0.0305395555,
-0.0274150707,
0.0291594528,
0.0569624826,
0.0624622181,
-0.045382522,
0.0230341218,
-0.0163221303,
0.0179663431,
0.0170960184,
-0.0142918266,
-0.0297673307,
0.0126238558,
0.0095726792,
-0.02227333,
-0.0186782405,
-0.0441497415,
-0.0290723499,
-0.0130730057,
0.015976673,
0.0239928979,
-0.0308494642,
0.0002622893,
0.0153955612,
0.058141686,
0.0415514335,
0.0313389637,
-0.0426721051,
-0.0038120982,
-0.0139380703,
0.0136177037,
-0.001764972,
-0.0803559497,
-0.0830976218,
0.0185677912,
0.0096763941,
-0.048624482,
-0.0175299961,
-0.0060218088,
0.0134079009,
0.0457579643,
-0.0352187604,
0.0442642607,
-0.0226984266,
0.0029534581,
-0.0829084963,
-0.0070213284,
0.0222707316,
0.0189848468,
0.0068691634,
-0.0796678141,
0.1012461782,
0.0094348928,
-0.0609585159,
0.0027441604,
0.0394546464,
0.0422892272,
-0.0025449416,
-0.0323861279,
0.0147000607,
0.0473118201,
0.006525774,
0.0258381516,
-0.0110254455,
-0.0023676211,
0.0523470938,
0.0631738678,
0.0235555079,
0.038251739,
0.0189187974,
-0.0089374781,
-0.0503222793,
0.0667944849,
0.0021443204,
0.0143226357,
-0.0151376361,
0.0212803148,
0.0170482658,
-0.1063419431,
-0.0108134784,
0.0115271574,
-0.0028853854,
-0.0276228301,
0.0254633278,
0.026145786,
-0.0319458097,
0.0263217352,
0.0088315997,
-0.0745804235,
-0.0340421535,
-0.0404522382,
0.0316549167,
0.0175540913,
0.015995577,
-0.0565429814,
-0.0140494741,
-0.0229719467,
0.0045028124,
-0.0795337185,
0.0370351039,
-0.0099033043,
0.0325750038,
-0.0446457006,
-0.034875229,
0.0105079357,
-0.0153920585,
0.0228142384,
-0.0101592457,
-0.0434966609,
0.048378218,
-0.0339942165,
-0.0721809044,
0.0358504802,
0.0408352911,
-0.0039809872,
0.0346051753,
0.0140761435,
0.007466374,
-0.0444546565,
-0.0316554345,
-0.0003780341,
0.0319609269,
0.0050326041,
0.0190914888,
-0.0115065658,
-0.012896359,
0.0075590727,
0.0006554734,
-0.0813833028,
-0.0500377379,
0.0810507908,
-0.0214773919,
-0.00485066,
0.0103239818,
-0.0376102254,
-0.0050728638,
0.0137355477,
0.042162098,
-0.0663045794,
-0.0505368672,
-0.0211737044,
0.0372641422,
0.0169961676,
0.0557622276,
-0.0131448805,
0.0183063354,
0.0272562038,
0.0441448577,
-0.0623379163,
-0.0242817402,
-0.0566535853,
0.0447496474,
0.0215839483,
0.0645694137,
-0.0337496065,
-0.0338784754,
-0.0573453009,
-0.0014237564,
-0.0030725983,
0.0256912708,
0.0094886646,
-0.0245160963,
0.0285498649,
-0.0046707555,
-0.0162687004,
-0.0337258391,
-0.0253623948,
-0.0196963083,
0.0333929397,
-0.0449443832,
-0.0439784899,
-0.0273131914,
-0.0114745079,
-0.0317522213,
0.0283510778,
0.0117006563,
0.0163977351,
-0.0855970979,
0.0934782252,
0.0331692509,
-0.0148025965,
0.016563423,
-0.0718877092,
0.0036457239,
-0.0017467269,
0.0420620106,
0.0669285804,
-0.0060901023,
-0.0245506335,
0.0232639834,
0.0053758076,
-0.0189244803,
-0.023799086,
0.0252148714,
-0.0367761813,
0.0261221081,
-0.0173534527,
0.0603043176,
0.0439354666,
-0.0374264158,
-0.0229312051,
-0.0540860891,
-0.0071481708,
-0.0118219526,
0.0612831376,
0.0568286739,
0.0087881824,
0.0105207879,
0.0477510281,
-0.0240447596,
-0.0884921923,
0.0617133342,
-0.0173686296,
0.0022827147,
-0.0330334641,
0.017441012,
-0.0343066044,
0.0220445506,
-0.0031644958,
0.0089633465,
0.0254084989,
-0.0435808487,
-0.0172406603,
0.0221035071,
0.0054971417,
-0.0378094427,
0.0711775944,
-0.0256404262,
-0.0256886594,
0.010348442,
-0.0025536735,
-0.0364928059,
0.0146517828,
-0.0004768783,
-0.0109918332,
0.0571785718,
0.0335593633,
0.0125667695,
0.0291441046,
-0.0183162335,
0.0047379998,
0.0330448858,
-0.0708921775,
0.0118519692,
-0.0564705729,
-0.0591833182,
-0.0227169972,
0.0250814911,
-0.0079246387,
-0.027681876,
0.0172691103,
0.0116477748,
0.0420169197,
-0.0754882842,
-0.0265658703,
0.0331041254,
-0.0183387734,
-0.0394336917,
0.0348668694,
0.0629630685,
-0.0336528756,
-0.0289211534,
0.0303623416,
0.0350465626,
-0.0076556215,
0.0113980221,
-0.0056626797,
0.0018739864,
0.0632498115,
0.0399387889,
-0.0491135009,
-0.0273276251,
0.0017689996,
0.0413618535,
0.0117856702,
-0.0027309551,
0.0374569967,
-0.0537026674,
0.0200171284,
0.0186398029,
-0.0006414619,
-0.0772696361,
-0.0318058133,
0.0169823747,
-0.0478927381,
-0.0518967807,
0.0101031559,
0.0183910429,
0.0061119199,
0.0148988105,
-0.0532358922,
0.0110281408,
0.0327169187,
-0.0327985138,
-0.0050334134,
0.1163040549,
0.0098787043,
-0.0032681392,
-0.044648245,
0.0118270749,
-0.023403557,
-0.00211677,
0.0029610512,
0.050878495,
0.0096034724,
-0.0342947505,
0.0281799212,
-0.0228168666,
-0.0195620973,
-0.0067105861,
0.0551236831,
0.0194667932,
-0.0079207225,
-0.0194819812,
-0.0249649305,
-0.0208965931,
-0.0310371406,
0.0031951263,
0.07850454,
-0.0188005045,
-0.0103943823,
-0.0846252218,
-0.004718381,
-0.0430684723,
-0.0260436367,
-0.0015866511,
-0.0240375139,
-0.0158098396,
-0.0497246496,
0.0031308592,
0.0040340954,
0.008883696,
0.0289298985,
-0.111097455,
0.0365546495,
-0.0067879935,
-0.0572191365,
0.0247929916,
0.0178344771,
0.0265401639,
-0.067289196,
-0.0074301176,
0.0250152592,
0.010812697,
-0.0137287239,
-0.027109189,
-0.0604254156,
-0.0149115557,
-0.0216855053,
0.0961870998,
0.006121207,
-0.0109234126,
-0.074408792,
-0.0452842154,
-0.0544641949,
0.0002246193,
-0.0405320153,
0.0005896227,
0.0567522869,
-0.0426804386,
0.0226765927,
-0.0183837358,
-0.0468283072,
0.0272789616,
0.0119187366,
-0.0329361521,
-0.0206270497,
0.001702302,
0.0245259907,
-0.0013239126,
0.076216273,
0.0470760651,
-0.0239318274,
0.0320493169,
-0.0144139491,
0.0322013907,
-0.021521477,
-0.0298060421,
0.0495007336,
-0.0030344611,
0.0119994394,
0.0015698841,
0.0800672695,
-0.0491585694,
0.0077633969,
0.0110077914,
0.0703515634,
-0.0104722939,
0.005767385,
0.0189564116,
0.0164024998,
-0.0047677099,
-0.0485926531,
0.0319734924,
0.0219010785,
0.0217185318,
0.0156086236,
0.015832549,
0.0810776427,
0.049832385,
0.0144401165,
-0.0336665623,
-0.0439734422,
-0.0343763791,
-0.0264830347,
0.0022550747,
0.0180624593,
0.0146167465,
0.0101479599,
0.0174478088,
-0.0409764498,
0.0605385453,
0.0047995448,
-0.0159914214,
-0.0327979475,
0.0428898148,
0.0012822577,
-0.0787493438,
0.0814026594,
-0.0500993356,
-0.0470397845,
-0.0340962559,
-0.0363254212,
-0.0368062779,
0.0623555779,
0.0291880332,
-0.0092923287,
-0.0057121972,
-0.0463113748,
-0.0220655203,
-0.0645821095,
0.0348823033,
0.0395712554,
0.0774157941,
-0.0097513665,
0.0119077843,
0.0681422725,
0.0181684606,
-0.0142854881,
-0.0031047927,
-0.0562808514,
0.018776007,
-0.0092876973,
-0.0298784189,
-5.107872297e-33,
-0.0158031061,
-0.0215900615,
-0.0436958037,
0.0397161767,
0.0432972759,
0.002950557,
-0.0392819159,
0.0016887734,
-0.0170315485,
-0.0121805798,
0.0182730649,
0.0352334306,
-0.0153449401,
-0.0388833694,
0.0765253007,
0.0120439986,
0.0342502967,
0.0600908436,
-0.0626172945,
0.0023990076,
-0.0601317883,
0.0038997368,
0.0300358087,
-0.0481906086,
-0.0315661393,
0.0112383142,
-0.0005211746,
-0.0170128439,
0.0335677005,
0.089762859,
0.0537567325,
0.0212798174,
-0.009659918,
-0.0446748659,
-0.0487150624,
-0.0465079546,
-0.0249427464,
-0.0163617618,
-0.0418014489,
0.0161304493,
0.0018297313,
-0.0336108394,
0.0591651909,
0.0149130346,
-0.0161206611,
-0.039956186,
0.0507333875,
-0.026009623,
-0.0050512622,
-0.0626752302,
-0.0396048017,
0.0410619825,
-0.0708763897,
-0.0607624799,
0.0004772364,
0.0347523652,
0.0115708765,
0.0524780191,
0.0093964338,
0.0159619749,
0.0437201895,
0.0478465632,
0.0338781029,
0.0171327125,
-0.0058912416,
0.0053407163,
0.011849381,
0.0264616832,
0.0180360693,
-0.0142270131,
0.0568487942,
0.050109759,
0.061311651,
0.0192072429,
0.0509926043,
-0.0404641628,
-0.0011119165,
0.0535515733,
-0.0598537512,
0.0313290283,
-0.0398916863,
0.0304608475,
-0.044964388,
-0.0125996852,
-0.0233658142,
-0.0137832584,
-0.0182963125,
-0.0264993142,
0.0301267784,
-0.0357174426,
-0.0392188691,
0.0337198563,
-0.0109980656,
-0.0414682589,
0.033305157,
0.0020659743,
-0.0722821057,
0.0538640618,
-0.0394082814,
0.0184925664,
0.0082972636,
-0.0029207349,
0.0018071409,
0.0059135659,
0.1003692746,
0.0005368174,
0.0553468429,
0.0110723842,
-0.077882722,
-0.0135340169,
-0.0174261499,
-0.0238781478,
-0.0063058725,
0.0383059382,
-0.0121514788,
-0.0134366574,
0.0125386622,
0.0538493693,
-0.0343965888,
0.013923198,
-0.0722540244,
0.0158817396,
0.0276595633,
0.0042570825,
-0.0108164735,
-0.0714309588,
-0.044075381,
-0.0005403322,
-0.010773764,
-0.0168293286,
-0.0760320872,
0.0326795392,
2.748e-7,
0.0215022862,
0.030900443,
-0.0132461144,
-0.0022437307,
-0.0373696163,
0.0597529933,
-0.0083865356,
-0.0138996784,
0.0293044075,
-0.007399471,
-0.023019759,
-0.0228852537,
0.0460531339,
0.0336021669,
-0.0410091318,
-0.0023167816,
0.0036112978,
0.0139125586,
-0.0167447831,
0.0328393951,
0.0723026916,
0.0634815469,
-0.0038315852,
0.0299112182,
0.0191292074,
-0.0035631494,
-0.0042445785,
0.000839919,
0.0393923186,
0.0462394394,
-0.0107362252,
-0.003199266,
-0.0028262872,
-0.0018683973,
-0.0268379655,
-0.0425106138,
0.0389776565,
0.0503491908,
-0.0017484491,
0.0435383618,
0.0398824438,
0.0081328144,
0.0251156427,
-0.0427826047,
0.0229343213,
-0.0668610185,
-0.0026234305,
-0.0190497003,
-0.0541297719,
-0.0034987251,
0.0368029028,
0.0098603657,
-0.0052511371,
0.0026823462,
0.0063362787,
-0.0415062569,
-0.0358432084,
-0.0051180725,
-0.0460116081,
0.0036006267,
0.0210656058,
-0.0327488109,
-0.0107375495,
-0.0288536996,
0.0528984964,
-0.0227079019,
0.0394490659,
2.389909962e-34,
0.0680250674,
-0.0441405326,
0.0532495975,
-0.0015698189,
0.0455827601,
-0.0085389791,
-0.0086261164,
0.0008351282,
0.0018967886,
0.056960132,
-0.0070484318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09198v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09198v1 | A Benchmark for Text Expansion: Datasets, Metrics, and Baselines | 2023-09-17T07:54:38 | 2023-09-17T07:54:38 | Yi Chen, Haiyun Jiang, Wei Bi, Rui Wang, Longyue Wang, Shuming Shi, Ruifeng Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | This work presents a new task of Text Expansion (TE), which aims to insert
fine-grained modifiers into proper locations of the plain text to concretize or
vivify human writings. Different from existing insertion-based writing
assistance tasks, TE requires the model to be more flexible in both locating
and generation, and also more cautious in keeping basic semantics. We leverage
four complementary approaches to construct a dataset with 12 million
automatically generated instances and 2K human-annotated references for both
English and Chinese. To facilitate automatic evaluation, we design various
metrics from multiple perspectives. In particular, we propose Info-Gain to
effectively measure the informativeness of expansions, which is an important
quality dimension in TE. On top of a pre-trained text-infilling model, we build
both pipelined and joint Locate&Infill models, which demonstrate the
superiority over the Text2Text baselines, especially in expansion
informativeness. Experiments verify the feasibility of the TE task and point
out potential directions for future research toward better automatic text
expansion. | [
0.0347937942,
0.0556803122,
0.0196493585,
-0.0009028694,
-0.0197093617,
-0.0215607937,
-0.024537703,
0.0585565493,
-0.0218080394,
-0.023164304,
-0.0011244399,
-0.041314438,
0.0261156205,
-0.0147671718,
0.0753086731,
-0.06678278,
0.0356086902,
-0.007428396,
-0.0215110388,
0.0471651256,
0.0512844399,
-0.0123308152,
0.030502703,
0.0429097861,
-0.0346849635,
0.0367503949,
-0.0230829958,
0.0579069443,
0.0435214937,
0.0041206493,
-0.0039361026,
0.0412626304,
0.0119713768,
0.0136274798,
0.0000017417,
-0.0256338269,
-0.0213304106,
0.0315485336,
-0.0042060986,
0.0407442525,
0.0463955365,
-0.0600754283,
-0.0204800609,
0.0144318482,
0.0068772798,
-0.0105045149,
0.0709571764,
0.0572666004,
0.0534573942,
0.0781226754,
-0.0265712813,
0.0092832167,
0.0198717564,
-0.0698826984,
0.0258811675,
-0.0131813763,
0.0201866347,
-0.0314057395,
0.0010153996,
0.0529161654,
0.0163987335,
0.0440805368,
0.0003417126,
-0.0660848543,
0.0733745173,
0.0089494577,
-0.0199555364,
0.0151097765,
-0.0033381267,
0.0517355464,
-0.0019515456,
-0.0163498875,
-0.0129499026,
-0.0258600861,
0.0180222746,
0.008207133,
-0.0411466919,
-0.038981799,
0.0074031921,
-0.0006028283,
-0.0213214755,
0.0097467713,
0.0447232276,
0.0373774953,
0.0290401001,
-0.00230213,
0.0176751167,
-0.0503026061,
-0.0337478593,
0.0105680935,
0.0132338693,
-0.0523135439,
0.0287443735,
0.0214110129,
0.0092029013,
0.0261826236,
-0.0631135255,
-0.0525356978,
0.0179183651,
-0.0127900392,
0.0565526895,
0.0192138068,
-0.0221042261,
0.0036937636,
-0.0475598089,
0.0303506013,
-0.0408237725,
-0.0002784083,
-0.0558604635,
0.0068220538,
-0.0186813474,
-0.0186480973,
-0.0422160886,
0.006134233,
-0.0308068711,
-0.0579974391,
-0.07042858,
0.0042879353,
0.0118242968,
-0.0100820605,
0.0064179557,
0.0010529517,
-0.0187091734,
-0.0095329983,
0.0175665338,
0.0047193835,
-0.0619695671,
0.0333033837,
0.0299631488,
-0.0052391347,
-0.0256897341,
0.0383374989,
0.0430937819,
-0.0070683197,
-0.0026415179,
0.0485159867,
-0.0378777012,
-0.0594720133,
-0.0110612316,
-0.0035950497,
-0.0169946384,
-0.0207708161,
-0.0349437743,
-0.0488181338,
0.0038921535,
-0.0318091437,
-0.0277364142,
-0.0495187528,
0.0235746484,
0.0256662406,
-0.027789209,
0.046699781,
-0.067895487,
0.0251366608,
0.0206349716,
-0.0146591393,
0.0365582705,
0.0152236912,
0.0416406654,
0.0335885175,
0.0598181821,
0.0251524542,
0.0403036177,
0.049526792,
0.0162071157,
0.0129023716,
-0.0072647417,
-0.0375497229,
-0.0442793667,
0.04348474,
-0.008288228,
0.0374499597,
-0.0582971983,
0.0340510532,
0.0820466951,
0.009772568,
0.0150565077,
0.0160074644,
0.0532761812,
0.029756967,
-0.0201459005,
0.0224072598,
-0.0274443775,
0.0059244749,
0.0036617259,
0.0415705852,
0.0689772964,
-0.047711812,
-0.0091073923,
-0.0492062345,
-0.0111528272,
-0.0250231344,
0.041159559,
-0.0498614274,
0.038204886,
0.0557932071,
-0.0553922355,
0.0288425218,
0.007159241,
-0.0816588253,
0.0214385539,
-0.0037090252,
-0.0035819474,
0.0747433901,
0.0655429661,
-0.0378765613,
-0.0223973561,
0.0098531842,
0.0083776442,
0.0359315388,
0.0227105413,
0.0150102256,
0.0360593423,
-0.0755982623,
-0.0173511319,
0.0146654164,
0.0005522348,
0.0017341059,
0.0739089698,
-0.0020516107,
0.0581475273,
-0.0337895639,
-0.0606353655,
0.0698645785,
-0.0115630291,
-0.0200206302,
0.0082539571,
-0.0042277775,
-0.0237272829,
0.0228882451,
-0.0390927903,
0.0204301532,
0.0228313301,
-0.035895627,
-0.0139450142,
0.0278728232,
-0.0024789001,
0.0332468636,
0.0158796217,
-0.0234542992,
0.0075070816,
-0.0094538908,
-0.0217969324,
-0.0616947971,
-0.0305499621,
-0.0421436951,
0.0003936366,
-0.0710345209,
0.0208826661,
0.0120822694,
0.00283168,
-0.0457503498,
0.0416576602,
0.021041045,
0.0219272729,
0.0411471725,
-0.0128674423,
0.0256968252,
0.0085313702,
-0.0242047738,
-0.0801293775,
-0.0116113285,
-0.0036710592,
0.0412606932,
0.0125720166,
-0.0355164669,
-0.0403940231,
-0.0826526657,
0.0072644115,
-0.0273680557,
0.0151563315,
0.0186924674,
0.0401771441,
-0.0144116646,
-0.0192507431,
-0.0386363789,
-0.0126537094,
-0.0019568726,
-0.0051854341,
0.0761866719,
0.0228303056,
0.0078442218,
-0.0520987436,
0.0003718112,
0.0348682217,
-0.0153114619,
0.0578412823,
-0.0555998236,
-0.0535427779,
-0.0144589702,
0.0021120196,
-0.0170915779,
-0.0035841141,
-0.0760728046,
-0.005938014,
-0.009336113,
0.0287293233,
0.0728272051,
0.0350095071,
-0.0091916285,
0.0011062602,
0.0334399492,
-0.0064877258,
0.0079917815,
-0.0079889726,
0.0156946946,
-0.0144413551,
-0.0150917377,
-0.004693226,
0.0301681198,
-0.0135293389,
0.0105171436,
-0.0356129743,
-0.0498395786,
-0.0000701156,
-0.0581280254,
-0.0136013906,
-0.0328218453,
-0.0660127401,
0.0347798355,
-0.0402130336,
-0.0637946427,
0.0315232165,
-0.0711634606,
-0.0333817936,
0.0019904887,
0.0036649357,
-0.0430016778,
0.0239008032,
0.0331868976,
0.0068847444,
-0.0164776966,
-0.0289249718,
-0.0453077145,
0.0290063322,
0.0192897972,
-0.0164151918,
0.0441578031,
-0.0242865831,
0.0092311362,
-0.0225106496,
-0.0308620874,
-0.0438762791,
-0.0685022473,
0.0185207389,
-0.0209833272,
0.0421195887,
-0.0536864027,
0.0095563726,
0.0043820268,
0.0352239534,
0.1091400087,
-0.0154983997,
0.0131485602,
-0.0585967079,
0.0424598642,
0.0415714607,
0.0382185355,
-0.0279989,
-0.047671292,
-0.0170636047,
0.013565111,
-0.0349149331,
0.0004228488,
-0.000826447,
-0.017702844,
-0.0082625179,
-0.0255015921,
-0.0248573534,
0.0095489109,
0.094470866,
-0.0356099904,
-0.0360473618,
0.0981113166,
0.0207968447,
-0.0230755117,
-0.0212127324,
0.0128646912,
0.0650646165,
0.0150549607,
-0.0043119872,
-0.0903758407,
-0.0215374455,
0.0291721076,
0.0208215211,
0.0062910989,
-0.0075613582,
0.0128481938,
-0.0958107486,
0.0444995426,
0.0223076511,
0.0023788013,
-0.0047132312,
-0.0017975192,
0.0321136191,
0.0302128941,
-0.0335018709,
-0.0052001942,
-0.002821757,
-0.0026574561,
0.0137900505,
-0.0069093015,
-0.0415798202,
-0.0988180414,
-0.0470060185,
0.0141457058,
0.0577181801,
0.0300496146,
-0.0034067121,
0.0199896637,
0.0352010168,
-0.0014759714,
0.00234048,
0.0148559567,
0.1038449258,
0.0218924563,
0.0029056661,
-0.0163335204,
0.041832272,
-0.0111639043,
0.0072601871,
0.0310648419,
-0.0097402688,
0.0221733972,
0.041678302,
-0.014595231,
0.011522674,
0.0337563753,
0.0412388146,
0.0529132523,
-0.0520222522,
0.0004231145,
-0.0306908637,
0.0312821418,
-0.0937033147,
-0.0085616307,
-0.0044950736,
-0.0509111881,
-0.0335343517,
-0.1225748137,
-0.0641934201,
0.0100767938,
0.0323685706,
0.0354210138,
0.0257628113,
-0.0247656778,
-0.0145704746,
-0.0332853086,
-0.0159828197,
-0.0000339389,
0.0241909008,
-0.0311347824,
-0.0283857174,
-0.0172660537,
-0.0392601825,
0.0199386347,
0.0593704954,
-0.0387125388,
-0.040898148,
-0.0034054401,
0.035510622,
0.0204043798,
0.0682003945,
-0.0368959866,
-0.0359860696,
0.0493036136,
0.0308054239,
-0.0209514573,
0.0346006937,
0.0212520901,
-0.0402415916,
-0.0130344909,
0.0317806229,
-0.0128365615,
0.0137817403,
-0.0184561815,
0.0102966828,
-0.0118926382,
-0.0572796687,
0.0066028074,
0.00386889,
0.0071756728,
-0.0594918244,
0.0578557216,
-0.03533867,
0.0279077757,
-0.0567406937,
-0.0228439085,
-0.0745077133,
-0.0096330009,
0.0392602943,
0.0336248986,
-0.0277788676,
0.0139266131,
-0.014769,
0.037083596,
-0.0302148405,
-0.0252994932,
-0.0063394234,
0.0812941119,
0.0042398139,
0.0338776261,
0.0082650045,
0.0263600834,
-0.0391199924,
0.0350338481,
-0.0227363836,
0.011779218,
0.0292990822,
0.0018212638,
0.0199108068,
0.0416542217,
-0.0588564985,
0.0266970918,
-0.0459627882,
0.0316946059,
0.033296708,
-0.0296794679,
0.1263278276,
-0.0482148975,
-0.0291458964,
0.0015386455,
0.0262274612,
-0.0142924348,
-0.0271336362,
-0.0577649549,
0.0142276548,
-0.0072077117,
0.0153407147,
0.0510853492,
0.0059599392,
0.0010790027,
-0.0030899816,
-0.0023858135,
-0.0422468185,
-0.003772029,
0.015274534,
0.0650098175,
0.0097402185,
0.0114487037,
-0.0293026902,
-0.0483677909,
0.0309964772,
-0.0045276321,
-0.0300413501,
0.0099543594,
0.0286063962,
0.0324637219,
-0.0362140462,
0.0162100922,
-0.061279133,
-0.0108209513,
-0.0014683537,
-0.0203829538,
-0.0158374365,
-5.600652018e-33,
-0.0359695144,
-0.0080956323,
-0.0247086342,
-0.0263318382,
-0.0485907607,
0.0363038331,
-0.057709001,
0.0078427475,
0.0167669151,
0.0232050158,
-0.0209537242,
-0.0059028286,
0.0244567748,
0.0518867671,
-0.0147322025,
0.0108337738,
0.0462702811,
0.0053204312,
-0.0187697224,
0.0273034256,
0.0207406711,
0.0033399605,
0.0527148545,
-0.0832164511,
0.0231951047,
-0.0320976451,
-0.0406144708,
-0.0010477571,
0.0354005024,
0.0338569619,
0.0164283775,
0.0496486872,
0.003961225,
0.0100913253,
-0.0160790384,
0.0445011519,
-0.0917036384,
-0.008861403,
-0.0048105367,
-0.0102137635,
-0.0626187697,
-0.0364961885,
0.0486198589,
-0.044903893,
0.0338353328,
0.015996024,
0.0400264412,
-0.0411726795,
0.0179808326,
-0.0045602364,
-0.0570602268,
0.0344024301,
-0.0012253891,
-0.0216584839,
-0.0102820238,
0.0164996311,
-0.0007337848,
-0.004814323,
-0.0548539385,
0.0126476772,
0.0510638356,
0.0767727569,
-0.007137978,
0.013504358,
-0.0415025465,
0.0157061759,
-0.0045268219,
0.0109817963,
0.0019724208,
-0.0258949529,
0.0167560577,
0.0271574706,
0.0670519695,
0.0903048813,
0.0352986716,
0.0020068067,
-0.0331900865,
0.0464922488,
-0.003780538,
-0.0216620956,
0.0075680804,
0.0127010178,
-0.0222060159,
0.0089758104,
-0.0092414618,
-0.0180551745,
0.000729884,
-0.0366115384,
0.0282497741,
0.05994175,
-0.0327369161,
0.0195261724,
0.0144147128,
0.0035297037,
0.0066855741,
0.0361999013,
-0.0396639518,
0.0545188636,
-0.010587601,
-0.020111559,
-0.020454431,
-0.0400820188,
0.0257582124,
0.0356585756,
-0.011975918,
-0.0167149194,
0.0477507748,
0.0288599581,
-0.0698560476,
0.0235388074,
-0.0081840623,
0.0356502831,
-0.0043178271,
-0.025257973,
0.0154847195,
-0.0187235493,
-0.0064284941,
0.0265794676,
0.0427635275,
0.0317920148,
-0.0094864955,
-0.0675515607,
0.0164865963,
-0.0171284061,
-0.024002824,
0.0216351449,
-0.0186166391,
-0.0242413208,
0.025666438,
-0.0569257475,
0.0080358163,
-0.0108420132,
2.415e-7,
0.0661414564,
0.0235409383,
0.1043594107,
-0.0069053564,
-0.0150960134,
-0.0111603672,
-0.006106595,
0.0344021134,
-0.0244951341,
0.0012251659,
0.0699669644,
-0.0150940679,
0.0448001213,
-0.0376171172,
-0.1008239016,
-0.0102350144,
-0.0659932792,
0.0059312214,
-0.0247971732,
0.0097537423,
0.0399622321,
0.0633886158,
-0.0069285627,
-0.0008084399,
0.004431081,
-0.0787424892,
0.0560606606,
-0.0446791761,
0.0135570318,
0.0345201828,
0.0532156341,
0.0377498828,
-0.0307114217,
-0.0173412617,
-0.0429268815,
0.032183934,
0.0597861372,
0.0493142381,
-0.0076429518,
0.0171410237,
-0.0212369356,
-0.0108267982,
0.0018167574,
-0.0373201855,
0.0418373011,
0.0095069176,
0.0284143686,
-0.0239946507,
-0.0514541119,
0.0097895376,
-0.00430567,
-0.0045724171,
-0.0438228399,
0.0347543657,
0.0406996645,
0.0237433277,
-0.0433736667,
-0.0741340518,
-0.0883651525,
-0.0165177993,
-0.0166773479,
0.0153823663,
-0.0762763098,
-0.0306210462,
-0.0193137657,
-0.0594762899,
-0.0011799742,
2.398286508e-34,
0.0321233533,
-0.0428876095,
0.0217964593,
0.0206445325,
0.037431214,
0.0080157593,
-0.0357249826,
0.016627254,
0.0046294797,
-0.0594234318,
-0.0009200159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09195v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09195v1 | SplitEE: Early Exit in Deep Neural Networks with Split Computing | 2023-09-17T07:48:22 | 2023-09-17T07:48:22 | Divya J. Bajpai, Vivek K. Trivedi, Sohan L. Yadav, Manjesh K. Hanawal | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.NE | Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) have drawn attention because of their outstanding
performance on various tasks. However, deploying full-fledged DNNs in
resource-constrained devices (edge, mobile, IoT) is difficult due to their
large size. To overcome the issue, various approaches are considered, like
offloading part of the computation to the cloud for final inference (split
computing) or performing the inference at an intermediary layer without passing
through all layers (early exits). In this work, we propose combining both
approaches by using early exits in split computing. In our approach, we decide
up to what depth of DNNs computation to perform on the device (splitting layer)
and whether a sample can exit from this layer or need to be offloaded. The
decisions are based on a weighted combination of accuracy, computational, and
communication costs. We develop an algorithm named SplitEE to learn an optimal
policy. Since pre-trained DNNs are often deployed in new domains where the
ground truths may be unavailable and samples arrive in a streaming fashion,
SplitEE works in an online and unsupervised setup. We extensively perform
experiments on five different datasets. SplitEE achieves a significant cost
reduction ($>50\%$) with a slight drop in accuracy ($<2\%$) as compared to the
case when all samples are inferred at the final layer. The anonymized source
code is available at
\url{https://anonymous.4open.science/r/SplitEE_M-B989/README.md}. | [
-0.0435934737,
0.0990952477,
0.0072564539,
0.0071871635,
-0.0490109473,
-0.0289397128,
0.1023985818,
-0.022014007,
-0.0037910503,
0.0086978264,
0.0144797517,
-0.0192404389,
-0.0338198766,
0.0418499783,
-0.0266580489,
-0.0284044612,
0.0354432799,
0.028665306,
-0.0240622051,
-0.0343485549,
0.0028405692,
-0.0018096936,
0.0025690766,
-0.0019609744,
-0.0257978588,
-0.0211340189,
-0.0360649489,
0.020179905,
0.0190743804,
-0.0171619821,
0.0074500837,
-0.0205369964,
0.0435832739,
0.0580571592,
0.0000021725,
-0.0102838939,
-0.0541002303,
-0.0074144462,
-0.0746995956,
-0.0097560426,
-0.0133365262,
0.012676632,
0.0109394547,
0.0046055764,
0.0046062055,
-0.0204610266,
0.0702682883,
-0.0159185864,
0.0499899276,
0.0406690538,
0.0015250659,
-0.0098937787,
0.0115412269,
-0.0150185777,
-0.0498982519,
-0.0566286854,
-0.0255036727,
-0.0516710095,
-0.0575560555,
-0.0651724413,
0.0002815668,
0.0001374852,
0.0972577929,
0.0614470653,
-0.034946993,
0.0371607468,
-0.0669073686,
-0.0472429991,
-0.0574647337,
0.0219800975,
-0.0502041578,
0.0081129353,
0.0348122194,
-0.0624793768,
-0.0348839611,
-0.03493407,
0.0056532617,
0.0085736485,
0.0055809994,
0.0165539719,
-0.0409619138,
0.0232991017,
0.0561590306,
0.0220401101,
-0.0695375577,
0.0554002374,
-0.0281086154,
0.0221887715,
-0.0031640246,
0.0318377055,
-0.0183453523,
-0.0472935885,
0.0387096033,
0.0113600921,
-0.0348041244,
-0.0282378346,
-0.0660163015,
-0.0342414528,
-0.0912932009,
0.0315364935,
0.0552075505,
-0.003689111,
0.0063134436,
0.0434935912,
0.0207581054,
-0.0473483577,
-0.0480175577,
-0.0178455655,
0.0177202169,
0.014732196,
0.0062770885,
0.0176906828,
0.0082354341,
0.0451925807,
0.0004732772,
-0.0395565592,
-0.0272539835,
-0.034003552,
-0.0445419587,
-0.0308508594,
0.0153804859,
0.0466009863,
-0.0152537664,
0.0045290906,
0.0294918902,
0.0149355475,
-0.0606344379,
0.0448649526,
0.0578002073,
-0.0827554837,
-0.0347136445,
0.0127121164,
0.041852396,
0.0190684907,
0.0410851166,
0.0410371274,
0.007557366,
-0.0240691546,
-0.0207337998,
-0.0181479342,
0.0321000628,
-0.0533819161,
0.0546102971,
-0.0520759001,
0.0769926235,
-0.034851633,
0.0276498031,
-0.0221396051,
0.0077049551,
-0.0267193355,
-0.014225821,
0.0317316577,
-0.023123024,
-0.0096750809,
0.0154651934,
0.0133780381,
-0.0598054491,
0.0559362136,
0.0243535694,
0.0289603379,
0.0463841856,
-0.0240308493,
0.0034898655,
0.036271926,
0.0683315247,
-0.0146699464,
-0.0236583818,
-0.058273863,
-0.0636528507,
0.009535972,
-0.0211086571,
-0.0326011479,
-0.0243732426,
0.0220013671,
0.0065958444,
0.0360049531,
0.0168552715,
0.0275063496,
-0.0122997463,
0.0287053883,
-0.0420792028,
-0.019878529,
-0.0648744479,
0.0361371711,
0.0431044213,
-0.024881972,
0.0657832921,
0.0372726656,
-0.0324279852,
-0.04778767,
0.0237701181,
-0.0512776598,
-0.0153743299,
0.0652736053,
0.0341133252,
-0.0252683237,
0.0252279025,
0.0384126119,
0.0356500521,
-0.0038311342,
-0.0233213883,
-0.0615436696,
0.0339059681,
0.013078982,
0.0147897378,
-0.027721718,
-0.0528302379,
0.0383438244,
0.0244237613,
-0.0356466472,
-0.0393424928,
0.046146974,
0.1000583321,
-0.0487747416,
-0.0312687121,
0.0267215818,
0.0323755704,
-0.0043060165,
0.0613458492,
0.0311141144,
0.0006172354,
-0.0161919668,
0.0114622228,
0.013985985,
0.0019332306,
-0.0012949248,
0.0755882785,
0.0422955863,
0.0646848977,
-0.0385917388,
-0.0260363389,
-0.0478892103,
0.0074214181,
-0.0102438005,
-0.0100589981,
-0.0337166004,
-0.0288005807,
-0.0149945328,
-0.0043371515,
-0.0532311834,
0.0261009354,
0.0535521507,
-0.0342190675,
-0.0203439929,
0.0151920924,
0.0116632758,
-0.0168648213,
0.0016008067,
-0.0199506506,
0.0007766737,
0.0305231828,
0.0631695539,
0.0186732896,
-0.019039413,
-0.006443256,
-0.0406824201,
-0.0453238823,
-0.0044864179,
-0.0080005731,
0.0201190822,
-0.0250124447,
-0.0315248668,
-0.0323696472,
0.0096314726,
0.0121235847,
0.0054979008,
0.0332857445,
-0.0350107737,
0.0472631119,
-0.0767546147,
0.035667628,
-0.0089255329,
0.0362474844,
0.0066385837,
-0.0300749149,
0.0188662261,
0.0630977675,
-0.0129482076,
0.0086532291,
-0.0360596925,
-0.0192769207,
0.0239974167,
-0.0080298427,
-0.0675600618,
0.0389864743,
0.0376464203,
-0.0143368775,
-0.0034123519,
0.0053590382,
-0.034205202,
-0.0273161754,
0.0093124807,
-0.0050933091,
-0.0051084124,
0.0297185052,
-0.0342659727,
-0.0405557118,
0.0499103256,
-0.0175040103,
0.0025238746,
0.0409087241,
0.0201274119,
-0.0346102603,
0.0112601016,
-0.0109851407,
0.0291254558,
-0.0142390355,
0.006249127,
-0.0362037271,
0.0592226237,
-0.045930434,
0.0012588503,
-0.0064914613,
0.0118360044,
-0.0045329165,
-0.0839734077,
0.0093275849,
0.0347675942,
-0.0174320713,
0.0424298905,
0.0248549152,
-0.0104286736,
0.0638865083,
0.0157102216,
0.000065574,
-0.028175354,
-0.0421001725,
-0.0243074186,
0.0309754815,
-0.0064235693,
0.0229424331,
-0.048414629,
0.0009334779,
-0.0295628123,
-0.005019275,
-0.0122894077,
0.0158269051,
0.0015280828,
-0.0440046154,
-0.0227621738,
-0.0128594674,
-0.0558536984,
-0.0175216869,
-0.0239600651,
-0.0273625664,
-0.0258799382,
-0.0293873455,
-0.0103263957,
-0.0246086232,
-0.017128326,
0.0039071101,
0.0989838988,
-0.0118300868,
0.0407840014,
-0.0059448178,
0.0252552833,
0.017287232,
0.0297696479,
0.0046732561,
-0.0202194136,
0.0313209705,
0.0375880338,
0.0757271424,
0.0235664528,
-0.063402921,
-0.0020644092,
0.0339745916,
-0.0080658104,
-0.0291528441,
0.031967964,
0.0551989377,
-0.1033923849,
-0.0395137407,
0.0456669666,
-0.0132272672,
-0.0728735402,
-0.0171021931,
0.0183815323,
0.0059413849,
-0.0163710583,
-0.0108814612,
-0.0284769926,
-0.0467867367,
0.0364182182,
0.0311536249,
0.0138682229,
-0.0099158501,
-0.0067482986,
-0.0768038258,
0.0545588881,
-0.0149642127,
0.011773468,
0.0118476478,
-0.0262671169,
-0.0095222658,
-0.0272765029,
-0.0287826471,
-0.0269259792,
0.0599417798,
-0.0158784036,
0.036724519,
-0.0547357835,
-0.0008950655,
-0.0119025875,
-0.0653895959,
-0.0380836576,
0.0534189753,
-0.0305048153,
-0.0475890674,
-0.0163681228,
0.0644953549,
-0.0320920944,
-0.0376408324,
0.000769294,
0.0526008978,
0.0049207187,
0.0029611632,
0.0084224446,
0.0669456348,
0.0079543712,
-0.0237862654,
0.036193531,
0.0733865127,
-0.0088226181,
-0.0289068297,
-0.0387915894,
0.0044280663,
0.0377135351,
-0.0005183284,
0.0158847775,
-0.0602742471,
-0.0404366516,
0.0454127491,
0.0118286023,
-0.0195990335,
0.0175464395,
-0.0331045799,
-0.0046158805,
-0.0599662513,
0.0129441684,
-0.0061130915,
-0.010667352,
0.0871636495,
-0.0106944917,
-0.0365224816,
0.0383677222,
0.075927563,
-0.046012342,
0.0025107509,
0.0050885263,
0.0018783291,
-0.008212843,
0.0293948408,
0.0320153199,
-0.0276968852,
-0.000155828,
0.0047643585,
-0.0639707819,
-0.0444024913,
0.0362341218,
0.018077502,
0.0195262674,
0.0511330515,
-0.0168868285,
-0.0311745759,
0.0839101821,
0.0623070672,
-0.0277928468,
0.0128756966,
0.0712673664,
-0.0435738117,
-0.0135376137,
0.046514485,
-0.0175301693,
0.0326301455,
0.0310768504,
-0.0014487493,
-0.0819173977,
0.0164278913,
-0.0108120367,
-0.0079285847,
0.0686474964,
-0.0246276055,
0.0457704365,
-0.0382075123,
0.0549064875,
0.0710932016,
0.0087765502,
-0.0523969904,
0.0296166874,
-0.013339702,
0.0152294505,
-0.0154019622,
0.0232235324,
0.1066202596,
-0.0707165971,
-0.0125272144,
0.0048401058,
0.0584349185,
0.0128140133,
0.0041706841,
-0.010066757,
0.0071602631,
0.0321569592,
0.0167622752,
0.0074372236,
-0.0472254306,
0.0147702675,
0.0475238226,
0.0009335344,
-0.0515449345,
0.0191664323,
-0.0138925388,
-0.0854880363,
-0.0167400129,
0.0602486618,
-0.0240272302,
0.0320148431,
-0.0080502266,
0.0120448386,
-0.014122963,
-0.006822065,
-0.0013789543,
-0.030663617,
-0.0102787018,
-0.0097772982,
0.0341797955,
0.0072153551,
0.0056666797,
0.0171912219,
0.0195830669,
0.0107774995,
-0.007581274,
0.0194093939,
-0.0321380794,
-0.0185286403,
-0.0282957647,
0.0152431121,
0.0092909569,
0.0051956968,
0.0233200844,
-0.0416886434,
-0.0350073725,
0.0135732116,
0.0479117222,
0.0033254463,
0.01811672,
0.0616160333,
-0.0116121182,
-0.0208451618,
-0.0027665193,
0.0327316262,
0.0051569412,
-0.0118528958,
0.0417346247,
-6.931736638e-33,
0.0527672805,
0.0410408229,
-0.0111284638,
-0.0080894753,
-0.0193225555,
0.0302644297,
0.0072527188,
-0.0066993576,
0.0035545609,
-0.0139454734,
-0.0385562629,
0.0628983676,
0.0454643816,
0.0338542983,
0.0112507669,
-0.049543526,
0.05053965,
-0.0340379328,
-0.0361580737,
0.0360903777,
0.0031126959,
0.0485229306,
0.0041197431,
-0.0091560893,
-0.0522912107,
0.0000520765,
-0.018780129,
-0.0241039265,
-0.0510094799,
0.0127021149,
0.004944182,
-0.0203601383,
0.0098299487,
-0.0162498765,
-0.0002850747,
0.0039341329,
-0.0712281987,
-0.0398219489,
-0.0959958583,
0.0331362598,
-0.1138753816,
-0.0133418394,
0.0653134286,
0.0393343493,
-0.013349426,
-0.0265781768,
0.0143448645,
0.0399853811,
0.0158094279,
-0.0397939421,
0.0284447838,
0.0146954926,
0.0157865938,
-0.0333536826,
0.0372349173,
0.0136638219,
-0.041173812,
0.0176193435,
-0.1051747128,
-0.008749431,
0.0203376934,
-0.008105102,
0.0098752771,
0.0096226791,
-0.0420281217,
0.0453820489,
0.0556727834,
-0.0450168364,
-0.0307234284,
-0.0321035683,
0.0370099097,
0.0521541014,
-0.0100368783,
-0.0195840392,
0.1219108328,
-0.0231718495,
-0.0594308823,
-0.0104965148,
0.034017086,
0.0014226045,
0.023071073,
-0.0026705209,
0.0156895183,
-0.0272347853,
0.0022635111,
-0.0607211366,
-0.0238000043,
-0.0019996949,
0.0071613081,
0.0281078946,
-0.0717251897,
0.0052217459,
0.0598825961,
-0.0358831622,
0.0522925891,
-0.0239029583,
0.050000038,
0.0272394493,
0.0430627912,
0.0118197221,
-0.065805994,
-0.018110672,
-0.0581369512,
-0.0066194702,
0.0165861379,
-0.0289080106,
0.0222621001,
0.0656321198,
-0.0116743129,
-0.0226772465,
-0.0299268495,
0.0492815189,
0.0018471365,
0.035031449,
0.0707557127,
-0.0128364973,
0.0164293461,
0.0219795741,
0.0106752999,
0.0281881243,
0.0004751269,
-0.012697476,
0.0157942586,
0.0087627172,
-0.0379755683,
-0.0058857412,
-0.060475152,
-0.0304665156,
-0.0179930553,
-0.0664650649,
-0.0154424831,
0.0379405916,
3.072e-7,
-0.0520311892,
-0.0249168165,
-0.0088543855,
-0.0186143611,
0.0300104618,
0.0143030919,
0.0162462406,
-0.0151810888,
-0.0366848409,
-0.0078981593,
0.0341222845,
0.0407704711,
0.0581503771,
0.0245867893,
-0.0261935033,
-0.0105471453,
-0.0435893089,
0.0335954502,
-0.0271627605,
-0.0409495197,
-0.0144254584,
0.0763976201,
0.0551382564,
-0.0476907492,
0.0481904037,
0.0461339876,
-0.0120167444,
0.0283590537,
0.0295197796,
-0.0273761433,
0.0132003604,
0.0329982191,
-0.0101597263,
-0.0228656717,
0.0024710866,
0.0273404364,
0.0018116792,
0.0411365591,
0.0333341025,
-0.0119939782,
-0.0316626839,
0.0295378175,
0.0189138483,
0.0084054088,
0.0879830942,
-0.014421639,
-0.0255813506,
-0.0375756957,
0.0099487919,
-0.0337077454,
0.0060612783,
-0.00238198,
0.0474409424,
0.0146091245,
-0.0346713141,
-0.0518457703,
-0.0122251585,
-0.0611039102,
0.0221630689,
-0.0052067814,
-0.0408725701,
-0.0284297653,
-0.0321788527,
0.0292054638,
0.0532112494,
-0.0375495479,
-0.0371465497,
2.462250619e-34,
-0.002390835,
-0.0095270872,
-0.0034197788,
0.0257755015,
-0.0338263288,
0.0011798642,
0.0080316393,
-0.0196902789,
0.0128125492,
0.0202458091,
-0.0449106209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.10000v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.10000v1 | Detecting covariate drift in text data using document embeddings and dimensionality reduction | 2023-09-17T07:34:57 | 2023-09-17T07:34:57 | Vinayak Sodar, Ankit Sekseria | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Detecting covariate drift in text data is essential for maintaining the
reliability and performance of text analysis models. In this research, we
investigate the effectiveness of different document embeddings, dimensionality
reduction techniques, and drift detection methods for identifying covariate
drift in text data. We explore three popular document embeddings: term
frequency-inverse document frequency (TF-IDF) using Latent semantic
analysis(LSA) for dimentionality reduction and Doc2Vec, and BERT embeddings,
with and without using principal component analysis (PCA) for dimensionality
reduction. To quantify the divergence between training and test data
distributions, we employ the Kolmogorov-Smirnov (KS) statistic and the Maximum
Mean Discrepancy (MMD) test as drift detection methods. Experimental results
demonstrate that certain combinations of embeddings, dimensionality reduction
techniques, and drift detection methods outperform others in detecting
covariate drift. Our findings contribute to the advancement of reliable text
analysis models by providing insights into effective approaches for addressing
covariate drift in text data. | [
-0.0067763478,
0.0524237715,
-0.035838794,
0.0262530409,
-0.0174061693,
0.0278131254,
0.012299831,
0.0277962815,
-0.005156911,
-0.0538444333,
0.0405007116,
-0.026655551,
0.0202126596,
0.0471248776,
-0.011815466,
-0.0110584917,
0.0514723323,
-0.0147780478,
0.0086721173,
0.0366713069,
0.0404990129,
-0.0521832332,
0.0027627812,
-0.0143296048,
-0.0118973088,
-0.0482486449,
-0.0144735696,
-0.0536911152,
0.0265789386,
-0.026186185,
0.0307917483,
0.0546955355,
0.0614034608,
0.0379016064,
0.0000020587,
-0.0269465819,
0.0073844302,
0.0119565139,
0.0325000733,
0.0337033309,
0.050032232,
0.0094565852,
0.0023416206,
0.0250375606,
-0.0189149044,
-0.0177840181,
0.0069948514,
0.0283035822,
0.0334248208,
0.0600480773,
-0.0089254184,
-0.0173932295,
-0.0085118674,
-0.0120650986,
0.058373794,
0.0029950107,
0.0648614913,
0.0104767028,
-0.037619397,
-0.0005041995,
-0.040927548,
0.0063629393,
-0.047464218,
-0.0159212425,
0.050855767,
0.0558301508,
0.0052432385,
0.0165075269,
0.0143025937,
0.0339267962,
0.0714429468,
-0.0139526632,
0.0450524427,
0.006836514,
-0.0057655517,
0.0591151901,
-0.030815633,
-0.0461549275,
0.0267178714,
-0.0068809362,
-0.0047984296,
-0.0151346195,
-0.0072782342,
-0.0186361317,
-0.012693475,
0.0066292286,
-0.0003285345,
-0.0944435075,
-0.011698477,
-0.0223823749,
0.032883808,
-0.0344646871,
0.0070610903,
-0.0112124598,
0.0291456077,
0.0274346918,
-0.0209173039,
-0.1199432835,
0.034641169,
-0.1424683928,
-0.0383975469,
-0.0202914774,
-0.0598129854,
0.0340705253,
0.0019172929,
0.0611556172,
0.0559893139,
-0.009515319,
-0.0421419889,
0.034502849,
-0.0518096387,
0.0070056445,
0.0158340484,
0.0618932508,
0.0502412058,
-0.0225944072,
-0.0118431989,
0.0509754978,
0.0075708563,
0.0208330192,
-0.0588206723,
0.0071648266,
0.0075256457,
0.0508708209,
-0.0067757247,
-0.003284422,
-0.0321765132,
0.0114297653,
-0.0554892719,
0.0218987372,
-0.0036132801,
0.0192408673,
0.0173907652,
-0.0157269277,
-0.0243221335,
-0.0154202925,
0.0113149174,
-0.0386699624,
-0.0537791699,
0.0054655783,
-0.0469655618,
0.0153164947,
-0.0148163801,
-0.0461751707,
-0.0068605924,
0.0145255411,
-0.0030156048,
-0.0196942426,
-0.0363304317,
0.023942776,
-0.0677561685,
0.0387146808,
0.0051220744,
0.0078907516,
0.0964164361,
-0.0251008421,
0.0096827699,
0.0725595877,
0.0295772664,
-0.0270367712,
0.0546266772,
-0.0523497611,
-0.0355176702,
0.0126860542,
-0.0094501451,
0.0041974895,
-0.0020339428,
0.0311464518,
0.000984314,
0.0242157839,
0.0141718173,
-0.012141644,
-0.0211853124,
-0.0292056408,
0.0286583938,
0.0885537863,
0.0081911571,
0.006166026,
-0.0083653349,
0.0256425925,
-0.0287348591,
0.0305183288,
0.0395357013,
-0.0252216905,
-0.0000522437,
-0.0262597948,
0.0335220248,
-0.0458265729,
-0.0497226007,
-0.0274416227,
-0.0283822846,
-0.0243216772,
0.0314160697,
-0.0642111972,
0.0546568818,
-0.0576954409,
0.0322991461,
0.0076097674,
0.0380388387,
-0.0145778181,
0.0051487545,
-0.0023591276,
0.059267018,
0.0620125681,
0.0351257212,
-0.0558576547,
-0.0047756638,
-0.0396350659,
0.0825692341,
-0.0204578266,
0.0402005836,
-0.0130584799,
-0.0426173024,
-0.0275618285,
-0.0048458478,
0.0003400021,
0.0222654399,
-0.0039866101,
-0.0418740325,
0.0688342974,
0.0157798622,
-0.0785614848,
-0.0088175014,
0.0637936592,
-0.0315799788,
0.010988567,
0.037795715,
-0.007936052,
0.0375795588,
-0.0127990907,
-0.0229716711,
0.0018708711,
0.0213302467,
0.0006926231,
-0.0232142229,
0.0134615246,
0.0365338698,
0.0213145111,
0.0341004841,
-0.0202394873,
0.021103913,
-0.0002878824,
-0.0543965176,
0.0090043098,
0.0581386909,
-0.0549342334,
-0.0071215485,
-0.0328155383,
-0.0093303937,
-0.0442125201,
0.0308437776,
-0.010303488,
0.0516895615,
-0.0198379979,
0.0306189787,
-0.0218540858,
0.0063061141,
0.0515876897,
0.0033149293,
0.0288742781,
-0.0155860791,
-0.0187602881,
0.03299715,
0.0263246372,
-0.0483307838,
0.0116392476,
-0.0172457136,
-0.0463826768,
-0.0219786391,
-0.0354482345,
0.0302895941,
0.0177625678,
-0.0245802104,
-0.0043458445,
0.0112507092,
-0.0053251483,
-0.0074922889,
-0.0164216273,
0.0256715678,
0.05145045,
-0.0376364551,
-0.005273262,
-0.034366902,
0.0119149266,
-0.0142878806,
0.0767223462,
0.006843965,
-0.0390730239,
-0.0618049204,
-0.0102782072,
-0.0564326495,
0.0125757679,
-0.0192073267,
0.0227319133,
-0.0182468109,
0.005476505,
0.0537814386,
0.034582451,
0.0811575055,
0.0688244179,
0.0177260209,
-0.0345131196,
-0.0397795662,
-0.0108860377,
-0.0208791699,
0.0524354167,
-0.0082330508,
-0.0394508839,
0.0563054979,
0.0039647631,
0.0268461052,
-0.0049410244,
-0.0326227434,
-0.0167381242,
-0.0376680195,
0.0283835009,
-0.0356641449,
0.008607137,
-0.0310291797,
-0.0363821089,
0.0032096272,
-0.0442158468,
0.0321293436,
0.0050833868,
0.0607880279,
-0.0693672374,
-0.0242701434,
-0.031111693,
-0.0156938024,
-0.0185745135,
-0.0104722129,
-0.0181944761,
0.0138857439,
0.0175864995,
0.002922104,
0.0417290218,
-0.0266727675,
0.0232273322,
-0.0296422523,
0.0697385743,
0.0244154297,
0.018251285,
-0.0380622931,
-0.0680038482,
0.0387764163,
-0.0165087543,
0.0313087776,
-0.0447214171,
-0.0168344099,
0.0186949298,
0.0133706275,
0.0255151857,
0.0060298909,
-0.0216147304,
0.0228110887,
0.0546505339,
0.0373192541,
-0.0289424062,
-0.0021635168,
-0.0242851172,
0.0084838616,
0.0167412199,
-0.0043126997,
-0.0079892483,
-0.0672269091,
-0.0190202128,
-0.0449691638,
-0.0565869212,
-0.0356074609,
0.0019696476,
-0.0492486916,
-0.0169275235,
-0.0321544781,
0.0981248021,
0.0563857481,
-0.0210701302,
-0.0012048752,
-0.0272539724,
0.0127651868,
-0.005222958,
0.0110080224,
-0.0405669659,
-0.0051895981,
-0.0283403471,
0.0263033472,
0.014201859,
-0.0476714,
-0.0081694769,
-0.0310340133,
0.0329785571,
-0.0059340801,
0.0197474658,
-0.0086631291,
-0.0905394182,
0.0278988946,
0.0147907417,
-0.0292680562,
-0.0223946664,
-0.0095811505,
0.0161789823,
0.0450692251,
-0.1290263087,
-0.0461885557,
-0.0141125163,
-0.0087418854,
0.0285554379,
0.0585317761,
0.0536160804,
-0.0466915295,
-0.0959933326,
0.0021818441,
-0.0581678972,
-0.0170670282,
-0.0090733618,
0.0844346583,
-0.0242746994,
0.0114100231,
0.0251052603,
0.0082769291,
0.0135644153,
0.0078937924,
0.0554042272,
0.0714405403,
-0.0425636619,
-0.0739973336,
-0.0369361937,
-0.0049808868,
-0.0045332294,
0.0486131012,
-0.0104203261,
-0.0332813039,
-0.0106694559,
-0.0126986476,
0.0404845439,
0.0568972416,
0.0810681134,
-0.0511054136,
-0.0007253353,
-0.0403365009,
-0.1013612822,
-0.0229540579,
0.0142105678,
-0.0565857142,
-0.0180748496,
0.0588188469,
0.0017964888,
-0.0375378877,
-0.0502322949,
-0.033916261,
0.0177213289,
0.0242409091,
-0.0082243783,
0.0012258053,
0.0330530405,
0.0000826262,
-0.0431628525,
-0.0252855662,
-0.1094007343,
-0.0499402732,
0.0095634619,
-0.0462078266,
-0.0004024945,
0.0078276936,
-0.025956288,
-0.0267038196,
0.0766608045,
0.0436701328,
-0.013132466,
0.0227082353,
-0.016919028,
-0.0015805988,
0.0070022312,
-0.0198377017,
-0.0206441581,
-0.003192025,
-0.0254220199,
-0.0340816006,
-0.0029587811,
0.0000521497,
-0.0257170834,
-0.010549725,
0.0457768925,
0.049599696,
0.0016413932,
-0.0563782007,
0.0078393742,
-0.000664045,
0.0034990658,
0.0200743303,
0.0018237517,
-0.0121144727,
-0.014711488,
-0.0637227297,
0.0868313536,
-0.034859322,
-0.0262748599,
-0.0215368494,
-0.0048267776,
0.0154550625,
0.0596421063,
-0.0046632909,
0.0090846652,
0.0114473952,
-0.0444256254,
-0.0112133007,
0.0232671332,
-0.0089770937,
0.0249115266,
0.017694572,
-0.0001403285,
-0.0006953919,
-0.0008985605,
-0.0439065695,
-0.0065193144,
-0.0042466507,
0.0233486146,
0.0113831814,
-0.0026808793,
0.0332670249,
-0.0315884799,
0.021248661,
-0.0232458543,
-0.0051422883,
0.037610732,
0.0104202749,
0.0153444549,
-0.004182091,
-0.0572147071,
0.0427231267,
0.0545943342,
0.051750388,
0.0108540077,
-0.0547543913,
-0.0696280971,
-0.0285761226,
0.0356411561,
0.0684146211,
0.0269213188,
-0.0304856487,
-0.0196616389,
-0.0313257761,
-0.0100875292,
0.0893194973,
-0.0508856364,
-0.0017599802,
0.0182696674,
-0.0098633152,
0.0631464347,
-0.0035361683,
0.0466800369,
-0.0179071613,
-0.0088582765,
-0.060644336,
-0.0474435613,
-0.0417378843,
-6.154856829e-33,
0.0078175813,
-0.0359833613,
-0.0162803289,
0.0472144671,
-0.0067938487,
0.0216103364,
-0.0027610864,
-0.0163546056,
0.0208445173,
0.0146758938,
0.029970821,
0.0458503477,
0.0029420676,
-0.0244579017,
0.0347512513,
-0.024737021,
0.0244774614,
-0.0213007629,
0.0098254504,
0.0169391185,
0.0531457849,
0.0366366655,
0.0519903563,
-0.0521791615,
0.0501050763,
-0.0141073326,
0.0284681115,
-0.0241259634,
0.034932863,
-0.000195719,
-0.0435476229,
0.0346431881,
0.0262717213,
0.0381984934,
-0.032526236,
0.0307874475,
-0.0203010738,
-0.0576302111,
-0.0061561884,
0.0071367738,
0.0126811257,
0.0235852674,
-0.000629782,
0.0475409031,
-0.027940616,
0.0265300311,
0.0956666842,
-0.0141732777,
-0.0572576411,
-0.0197572596,
-0.017837029,
0.0532363281,
-0.0440060794,
0.0306177568,
0.0093184924,
0.0152424406,
0.0207724702,
0.0389287099,
-0.0955244973,
0.0080569293,
-0.0080858339,
0.0211406779,
-0.0059532472,
-0.0109031368,
0.0115302242,
0.0650067925,
-0.0167335048,
-0.0044337688,
0.0255258866,
-0.0205450766,
0.0415857434,
-0.0356081314,
0.019844763,
0.0375281572,
0.0573119074,
-0.0480902456,
-0.0772827417,
0.0601764023,
0.0046602446,
0.0311365072,
0.0365901999,
0.0015047694,
-0.0761622041,
-0.0357841849,
-0.0159706213,
0.0247104615,
-0.0087944791,
-0.0393865854,
0.0409860834,
0.0120389387,
-0.0171391591,
-0.0369188488,
0.0018363348,
-0.0413239226,
-0.0631349385,
-0.0023524405,
-0.0510028638,
0.0119099747,
0.020163333,
-0.0068034776,
-0.0408477187,
-0.0398154147,
0.0197578594,
0.0281171575,
0.0114489496,
-0.0631994382,
0.0496235304,
-0.0054984349,
-0.0562985539,
0.0065269358,
0.0353063084,
-0.0366191044,
-0.0353909023,
0.001399688,
-0.0238025617,
0.0009697087,
0.0117807882,
0.0852365345,
0.0485361591,
-0.0078573991,
-0.0048788404,
-0.0334137119,
0.0316894688,
-0.0216943249,
-0.006226135,
0.0202120617,
0.0083326651,
0.0429649763,
0.037087068,
-0.0576244965,
0.0226001907,
-0.0179805811,
2.821e-7,
0.0558848232,
0.0881675035,
0.0350339934,
-0.0582414158,
0.0540260449,
0.0222741067,
-0.0455055349,
0.0201677345,
-0.0090489108,
-0.0022544269,
0.0341700613,
-0.0137963928,
0.0173958931,
0.0578950644,
-0.016490601,
0.0045931274,
-0.0820968226,
0.0185186602,
-0.0887862369,
-0.0069106775,
0.0322327912,
0.0070310934,
0.0158821549,
0.0143257119,
0.0012858199,
-0.0264802724,
0.0521015562,
-0.0137131596,
0.0073122187,
0.0120990723,
0.0286220741,
-0.0017953687,
0.0023551739,
0.0009015939,
-0.070299089,
0.0223310385,
0.0123104425,
0.0067107454,
-0.0117853833,
0.0435232334,
-0.0288668051,
0.0031396768,
-0.005737388,
-0.0235360153,
0.0635947809,
-0.0037515927,
0.0080744158,
-0.0685539693,
-0.051777482,
0.0237683617,
0.0623542257,
0.0082130292,
-0.022369992,
0.0027204643,
-0.0080116363,
0.0218947213,
-0.000694088,
-0.0527424961,
0.0315496773,
-0.0062134988,
-0.04276352,
-0.0072795521,
-0.0495432951,
0.0334586538,
0.0436430536,
-0.0031100411,
0.0722664371,
2.393492465e-34,
0.0374490544,
0.006484543,
-0.0366440155,
-0.0274470169,
0.0280071069,
-0.0038571081,
0.0290173143,
0.0025631941,
0.0045804731,
-0.0690462813,
0.0233474765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09150v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09150v2 | Can Large Language Models Understand Real-World Complex Instructions? | 2023-09-17T04:18:39 | 2024-01-08T07:49:23 | Qianyu He, Jie Zeng, Wenhao Huang, Lina Chen, Jin Xiao, Qianxi He, Xunzhe Zhou, Lida Chen, Xintao Wang, Yuncheng Huang, Haoning Ye, Zihan Li, Shisong Chen, Yikai Zhang, Zhouhong Gu, Jiaqing Liang, Yanghua Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) can understand human instructions, showing their
potential for pragmatic applications beyond traditional NLP tasks. However,
they still struggle with complex instructions, which can be either complex task
descriptions that require multiple tasks and constraints, or complex input that
contains long context, noise, heterogeneous information and multi-turn format.
Due to these features, LLMs often ignore semantic constraints from task
descriptions, generate incorrect formats, violate length or sample count
constraints, and be unfaithful to the input text. Existing benchmarks are
insufficient to assess LLMs' ability to understand complex instructions, as
they are close-ended and simple. To bridge this gap, we propose CELLO, a
benchmark for evaluating LLMs' ability to follow complex instructions
systematically. We design eight features for complex instructions and construct
a comprehensive evaluation dataset from real-world scenarios. We also establish
four criteria and develop corresponding metrics, as current ones are
inadequate, biased or too strict and coarse-grained. We compare the performance
of representative Chinese-oriented and English-oriented models in following
complex instructions through extensive experiments. Resources of CELLO are
publicly available at https://github.com/Abbey4799/CELLO. | [
0.0179647468,
0.0330114141,
-0.0094029419,
0.0435676053,
-0.0325095467,
0.0200261697,
-0.0300622191,
-0.0163690671,
-0.0355218388,
-0.0424816273,
-0.0499769896,
-0.0274925306,
0.0283141509,
-0.012180428,
0.024009848,
-0.0583902597,
0.0280791633,
-0.0345652103,
-0.0254421383,
0.0234555751,
0.0124957953,
0.0084164217,
0.0041900938,
0.0489081331,
0.0269400626,
-0.0350297838,
-0.0226923898,
0.0283424966,
0.004476273,
-0.0329223722,
0.0036089465,
0.0424233079,
0.0099109514,
0.0182531178,
0.0000017866,
-0.0236434527,
0.0189035702,
-0.0032964456,
-0.0578678213,
0.0351122133,
0.0134616531,
-0.0572849326,
-0.0200653244,
0.0077849892,
-0.0171462949,
-0.021017788,
0.0345029049,
0.0710296482,
0.0461502336,
0.102439329,
0.0081066964,
-0.0159906317,
0.0076946532,
-0.0232963096,
0.0306416061,
-0.0669167191,
0.0098053394,
0.0179369133,
0.0288338438,
0.0455009751,
-0.0183103681,
0.0188441258,
0.0388816223,
0.0058827964,
-0.0655488446,
0.0269333329,
-0.0058074943,
-0.0030980627,
-0.0144792395,
0.0953070596,
-0.0404929258,
0.0043324139,
0.0103754979,
-0.0122487731,
0.0003649324,
-0.0273724217,
-0.0666406751,
0.0447878689,
-0.0168593843,
0.0015754648,
0.0025826655,
-0.0147268092,
0.0332416818,
-0.006648907,
-0.009050007,
0.07188759,
-0.0024653729,
-0.0256671309,
-0.0023733298,
-0.0174497161,
-0.0221829433,
-0.0666574091,
-0.0028230834,
0.0536601171,
-0.0728091225,
0.023315426,
-0.0359889418,
0.0046936232,
0.0283915866,
-0.0501818806,
0.0609565862,
0.0500587076,
-0.0139041254,
0.0577345341,
-0.0125997206,
0.0859956816,
-0.0355848595,
0.0344792828,
-0.0520003624,
-0.0040356573,
-0.0487668924,
0.0046565067,
-0.0180359501,
0.030079212,
-0.0493001379,
-0.0356669165,
-0.0160295125,
0.0492294021,
-0.0211701598,
0.0560225956,
0.0215247087,
-0.026041409,
-0.0195333697,
-0.0201478489,
-0.0253363829,
0.0035598646,
-0.0444155671,
0.005125768,
-0.0014162512,
-0.0191683974,
-0.0068758256,
0.0207121205,
-0.0176042486,
-0.0267394818,
-0.0069882749,
0.0797207952,
0.0142117059,
0.0002856108,
-0.0140367281,
-0.0346565284,
-0.0089226784,
-0.072508648,
0.0095393751,
-0.0536248423,
0.0189280938,
-0.0013649492,
0.0168636199,
-0.0287612434,
0.0149243483,
0.0440406613,
-0.0237965658,
0.0665916428,
0.0499416366,
0.0135440342,
-0.0392256975,
0.0363641419,
-0.0084679974,
0.0437126607,
0.0255467705,
0.040446721,
0.0358039401,
-0.0047707777,
0.0161479674,
0.0476820581,
-0.026991019,
-0.0069573005,
-0.005532736,
0.0345134959,
0.0137025258,
0.0386482142,
0.031423524,
0.0675955042,
-0.0171955545,
-0.0054652542,
0.0487979949,
0.0207224805,
0.0051682983,
-0.0202243123,
0.0877041072,
0.0290761776,
0.00152649,
0.0453049578,
-0.1059765592,
0.0257218294,
-0.0159718841,
0.028390035,
0.0006251431,
-0.0067649377,
-0.0403313525,
-0.0362234339,
-0.0207809936,
-0.0333484784,
0.0095778424,
0.0061504017,
0.0407741629,
-0.0157519542,
-0.0607638806,
0.0370875001,
0.0141358022,
-0.0180080999,
-0.0073812711,
-0.0293024741,
0.028370358,
0.1065848991,
0.0383873694,
-0.0388122909,
-0.0212554559,
0.0164729301,
0.0143811069,
0.0095568132,
0.0580172278,
-0.0330043398,
0.0199624542,
-0.0354919508,
-0.0291625895,
-0.0146703357,
0.0239285622,
-0.0021306681,
0.0349960253,
-0.0091744419,
0.0087172789,
-0.0207736772,
-0.03720209,
0.0506611392,
-0.0163780693,
-0.0425338149,
-0.0148636159,
0.005798866,
0.0033214286,
0.0052835885,
-0.0181990471,
0.0257823542,
0.0406632535,
-0.0343838222,
-0.0073588351,
-0.0194028653,
-0.0667266473,
-0.0487793349,
0.0189518649,
-0.0221266281,
-0.0453115441,
0.0200147219,
-0.0563087426,
-0.0356307887,
-0.0016258206,
-0.0350904502,
0.0089560505,
-0.0034182372,
0.0330533795,
0.0284993816,
0.013865781,
-0.0307502579,
0.0531951413,
-0.0200365242,
0.0307458043,
0.0407531261,
0.0098607615,
-0.0157646108,
-0.0307849627,
-0.0306394026,
0.0021384337,
0.0010791462,
-0.0070245722,
0.0218634438,
0.0283873044,
-0.026994301,
-0.0330673791,
-0.070857577,
0.0386850052,
-0.0415236466,
0.025299523,
0.0511165,
-0.0170780364,
0.0168799777,
-0.0105403941,
-0.0377964154,
-0.0096694967,
-0.0277753435,
0.0176507253,
0.0194642376,
0.0243266318,
-0.0500642247,
-0.0202455651,
-0.0044820509,
-0.0204951949,
0.0130012017,
-0.0253810827,
0.0163636673,
-0.0799446851,
0.0084334789,
0.0352305062,
0.0224451497,
-0.0204599984,
-0.0352575704,
0.0146594746,
-0.0031964735,
0.0550818369,
0.0970889628,
-0.0276235007,
0.0331951939,
0.0444965847,
-0.021473987,
-0.0349459983,
0.0120692682,
-0.0062236981,
-0.0221106093,
-0.0651652813,
-0.0761356726,
-0.0208599474,
0.0855607763,
-0.0056984606,
0.0524407476,
-0.0477687791,
-0.0255748443,
-0.0190542378,
-0.0059728925,
-0.0069968887,
0.0041726292,
-0.0233917143,
0.0376381613,
-0.0420917049,
-0.0399821922,
0.0459901839,
-0.0558118038,
-0.0268175155,
-0.0045284117,
-0.0066401465,
-0.0265873857,
0.0930188671,
0.013061217,
0.0080405576,
0.0288056042,
-0.0143090133,
-0.0403180234,
0.0115443533,
-0.0054940921,
-0.0256949514,
0.076097548,
-0.0680496916,
-0.0125089586,
-0.0326601416,
-0.0303076971,
-0.0370004922,
-0.0600916296,
0.0016542145,
0.0358901434,
0.0486270189,
-0.049432613,
-0.0228141304,
0.0193278193,
0.0468389243,
0.049266316,
-0.0088165896,
-0.0051624407,
-0.0583515577,
-0.0007982176,
0.0666984692,
-0.003169169,
-0.005099949,
-0.0314824022,
0.0620172732,
0.0480530709,
0.0319786407,
0.0001129956,
-0.0299723577,
-0.0073992633,
0.0119161969,
-0.0237689279,
-0.0231281724,
0.0602079295,
0.0727885216,
-0.0815274492,
-0.0190761983,
0.1251284927,
0.0128199747,
-0.0179700181,
0.0252003279,
0.0097434046,
0.0284347311,
0.0169742387,
0.0313332118,
-0.0780617669,
-0.0401760601,
0.0224552024,
0.0040872614,
0.0064510694,
-0.0044184579,
-0.0027497157,
-0.1196598709,
0.0302010886,
-0.0035434165,
-0.0392676964,
-0.0591613464,
-0.0256155413,
-0.0077599348,
0.0020554909,
0.0609317347,
-0.0074277283,
-0.0210149568,
-0.0413919315,
0.0087484578,
-0.0521747507,
-0.0436397344,
0.0849946663,
-0.029639408,
0.0611874796,
0.0757789016,
0.0121376766,
0.0169185344,
0.0151661085,
0.0408707,
-0.0039121103,
-0.0033176122,
-0.003909444,
0.0300047807,
0.0204472858,
-0.0204322096,
0.0040869005,
0.0205904823,
-0.0688328519,
-0.0083697373,
0.0370392688,
0.0738120899,
-0.0220735576,
-0.018966103,
-0.0067066876,
-0.0171247181,
-0.0077550737,
0.0934379995,
0.0372226126,
-0.0336063094,
-0.0539777726,
-0.0463605821,
-0.0521894805,
-0.0744895115,
-0.0189241786,
0.0312173311,
-0.0304951202,
-0.0070308312,
-0.0793635994,
-0.0611735433,
0.030362688,
0.0236251932,
0.0143626863,
-0.0016841652,
0.0674649179,
-0.017714113,
-0.0255246405,
0.0074677798,
-0.0133334398,
0.0498608835,
-0.0705295056,
-0.0332472771,
0.0116681196,
0.0082983403,
0.0009366681,
0.0150511954,
-0.0797166005,
-0.0455740243,
-0.0083079301,
0.0468963683,
0.0145761417,
0.0453536175,
-0.0294173975,
-0.0211275574,
-0.0377231799,
-0.0094088688,
-0.0521195121,
0.0052191918,
0.0360149518,
0.0094281388,
0.0046719168,
0.0466791578,
-0.0486797616,
0.0330935866,
0.006368638,
0.0331186689,
-0.067197293,
-0.0299272835,
0.0433983579,
-0.0111866295,
0.0052825427,
0.0036630409,
0.0194795933,
0.0222510882,
0.0360502787,
-0.0218059793,
-0.0225880221,
-0.0417737812,
-0.0276953466,
0.0251627117,
-0.0037195953,
-0.0001918986,
0.0276984926,
0.0112590212,
-0.0058092079,
-0.0514042675,
0.0133324275,
-0.0019929195,
0.0282615777,
0.0130773121,
0.006157455,
-0.0200204309,
0.0287935156,
-0.0117779588,
0.0478918999,
-0.0033026028,
0.0494990163,
0.0185170565,
0.0115579609,
-0.0196069535,
0.0139036765,
-0.0537795238,
-0.029420739,
0.0140896784,
0.0089921895,
0.0642848238,
-0.0320251994,
0.0532404929,
-0.0224354267,
0.0032880679,
-0.0465686135,
0.0307734441,
0.0060523027,
-0.0194133986,
0.0265331734,
0.0667714551,
-0.007483257,
-0.0207760781,
0.0922644958,
0.0287555046,
0.0382354483,
0.0157730449,
0.000806899,
-0.0299143121,
-0.0369788483,
0.0186520889,
-0.0122695034,
-0.0528777242,
0.0128382063,
-0.0281706247,
-0.0575095601,
-0.0001906409,
0.0269682575,
0.0219240263,
-0.0389914922,
0.0121236611,
0.0222224332,
0.0033288586,
-0.0195319299,
-0.0325644612,
-0.0301893186,
-0.0076285936,
-0.0089765908,
-0.0201451033,
-5.979074874e-33,
-0.0450230129,
-0.0456564575,
0.0314295925,
-0.0361899734,
0.0162393171,
0.010373069,
-0.0697149634,
-0.0070195086,
-0.0064975009,
0.0201848783,
-0.0109663894,
0.0019475016,
0.0163469762,
0.0137657374,
0.0277557466,
-0.0266696773,
0.0428777002,
-0.0011908846,
-0.0185285714,
0.0185401067,
0.028317811,
-0.0136274528,
0.014204341,
-0.0464213602,
0.0286462307,
-0.0137485852,
-0.0152945984,
0.0198469497,
-0.030734472,
0.1005832553,
-0.0140636358,
0.0132496534,
0.0387784727,
-0.0323476493,
-0.0529056601,
0.0375136547,
-0.0965982601,
-0.0057945587,
0.0240887627,
0.0271110423,
-0.0477629565,
-0.0183186885,
0.0276864823,
-0.0218185149,
0.0064464901,
0.0104952874,
0.0252967924,
-0.0244999751,
-0.0058037057,
0.0190660805,
-0.0616901815,
0.0216133595,
-0.0075338283,
-0.0443613939,
0.0220981669,
0.0243974105,
0.0080893543,
0.0053117801,
-0.0484253541,
-0.0110954074,
-0.0198721457,
0.0811254457,
0.0508196093,
0.0132247796,
0.0047515235,
0.0293620527,
0.0144675709,
-0.008688665,
-0.0301269367,
-0.00091672,
0.006206173,
0.058178477,
0.0181258786,
0.0096131312,
0.0319028795,
0.038301833,
-0.0723084435,
0.0037413342,
0.0283462554,
0.0682637915,
0.0327410884,
0.0134500684,
-0.0547119938,
-0.0046066139,
-0.0276911762,
0.0511208288,
-0.0341141969,
-0.004270494,
0.0554296598,
0.0327345617,
0.0171956476,
0.0011102018,
0.0345692672,
-0.0441671498,
-0.0207600594,
-0.0118549913,
-0.0160211399,
0.0043783095,
-0.0135351894,
0.0266266484,
-0.0520447642,
-0.0741703734,
0.0193852652,
-0.018597614,
0.0283505097,
0.0207126234,
0.0669333562,
0.0278066248,
-0.0719740316,
-0.0025412873,
-0.045462098,
0.008076692,
-0.0075130546,
0.0027335065,
0.0431397259,
0.0060486975,
-0.0153164649,
0.0562866628,
-0.0120608276,
-0.0539548248,
-0.0212859418,
-0.0148325581,
0.0045730541,
0.0064770468,
-0.0317571312,
-0.0076751569,
-0.0517858192,
0.0006080433,
0.016491022,
-0.0239895768,
-0.0104390932,
0.039969638,
2.503e-7,
0.0260400083,
0.0362848826,
0.0189984497,
0.0859179944,
0.0136306165,
0.023901483,
-0.055615209,
0.0107894028,
-0.0539328121,
-0.0347380489,
0.0170178786,
0.0311825052,
0.0594668388,
0.0036309692,
-0.0845855176,
0.0205949433,
-0.0423310585,
0.019736778,
-0.0516995117,
0.0220539141,
0.05267445,
0.1144478619,
-0.0184954535,
0.0491424799,
0.0116445832,
-0.0260805376,
0.0295463521,
-0.0221814141,
0.0140409674,
0.0318963118,
-0.0123730432,
0.0203644466,
-0.0307415929,
0.0291145165,
-0.0091947019,
-0.0029663218,
0.0132631948,
0.1313243657,
-0.0032165996,
-0.0323082097,
-0.0102381883,
-0.0584756881,
-0.002853764,
-0.0285692085,
0.0418755971,
-0.0273386259,
-0.0211980008,
-0.0180409364,
0.0143348807,
-0.0037491391,
-0.0215758681,
0.0193590112,
0.0001934472,
0.0024589726,
0.0356066972,
-0.0410544463,
-0.01411126,
-0.0926456153,
-0.0305363368,
0.0079466812,
-0.029722767,
-0.0255108662,
-0.0621831492,
0.0081617804,
0.0154803554,
-0.0360684171,
-0.0222501718,
2.403025449e-34,
0.0261234473,
-0.0123516722,
0.0145911938,
0.0384804159,
0.0461198278,
-0.0070638647,
-0.0608461499,
0.0314610712,
0.0152635742,
-0.0657591894,
-0.0220902376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09126v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09126v2 | How much can ChatGPT really help Computational Biologists in Programming? | 2023-09-17T01:36:02 | 2023-12-04T06:53:49 | Chowdhury Rafeed Rahman, Limsoon Wong | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | ChatGPT, a recently developed product by openAI, is successfully leaving its
mark as a multi-purpose natural language based chatbot. In this paper, we are
more interested in analyzing its potential in the field of computational
biology. A major share of work done by computational biologists these days
involve coding up bioinformatics algorithms, analyzing data, creating
pipelining scripts and even machine learning modeling and feature extraction.
This paper focuses on the potential influence (both positive and negative) of
ChatGPT in the mentioned aspects with illustrative examples from different
perspectives. Compared to other fields of computer science, computational
biology has - (1) less coding resources, (2) more sensitivity and bias issues
(deals with medical data) and (3) more necessity of coding assistance (people
from diverse background come to this field). Keeping such issues in mind, we
cover use cases such as code writing, reviewing, debugging, converting,
refactoring and pipelining using ChatGPT from the perspective of computational
biologists in this paper. | [
0.0362105258,
0.0272853058,
-0.0332796201,
-0.0139776738,
-0.0431293473,
0.0153315766,
-0.0031766933,
0.0123175383,
0.0560531914,
0.0019796919,
0.0220806468,
0.0418132804,
0.0387532488,
0.0758729428,
-0.0219692104,
-0.0363135114,
0.0187263638,
0.0153026804,
0.028660588,
0.0083180228,
0.0070433104,
0.0199467409,
-0.0036611629,
0.0684003606,
0.0274260063,
-0.0659788772,
-0.0135826105,
-0.016098788,
0.0238141529,
0.0255890656,
0.0162077174,
-0.020783551,
-0.001595994,
0.0477653816,
0.0000020154,
-0.0498503074,
-0.0093960268,
0.0714147687,
-0.0254085604,
0.0089245308,
0.0482489578,
0.0275313091,
-0.0101886475,
0.0219222326,
-0.002998841,
0.0074528442,
0.1111689284,
-0.0142859751,
0.0697839484,
0.0387960635,
0.0123753613,
0.0012621048,
0.0526142605,
0.0349839777,
0.0704581738,
0.0091990707,
0.0017821237,
0.0295249503,
0.0905696303,
-0.0100941267,
0.0129064573,
0.0303341504,
0.0236229263,
-0.0365492031,
0.0186001789,
0.042800121,
-0.0258516856,
-0.0579691082,
-0.0006924162,
0.0061414074,
-0.0134810749,
-0.0458681211,
0.0021368642,
0.0097700115,
0.0082846107,
-0.0196106192,
-0.059492752,
0.00812985,
-0.0309198163,
-0.0189754497,
0.0147101218,
-0.0427892916,
-0.0252537429,
0.0007707941,
0.0208257455,
0.0007563469,
-0.0095537491,
-0.0308768526,
-0.0461628176,
-0.0106343767,
0.0279328041,
-0.039764829,
0.0130979428,
0.0603213869,
-0.0140682682,
-0.0383105017,
0.0174474437,
-0.016784586,
0.0440186448,
-0.054788541,
-0.0218410213,
0.0329666361,
-0.0185701456,
-0.0196127053,
0.0010900871,
0.0123351822,
-0.0287594665,
0.0651709735,
0.0309095643,
0.0028190359,
-0.1157135442,
-0.0174182542,
-0.0068760389,
0.0401910208,
0.0489310324,
0.0530402921,
-0.0372494161,
0.0434596427,
0.0044990405,
-0.0023520445,
0.0072612972,
-0.0078021702,
-0.0297217369,
0.0770071223,
-0.0074651432,
0.0053263637,
-0.0227487125,
-0.055883076,
-0.0102158682,
-0.0945308432,
-0.0188232325,
-0.000438776,
0.0010713445,
-0.0078164274,
-0.0019410052,
0.0949328095,
-0.0119948676,
0.0210810713,
0.0273697451,
-0.0296311844,
-0.0183857288,
-0.0249683335,
0.0005566004,
-0.0359182283,
0.0060574729,
0.0379902981,
-0.0009785834,
-0.0104929749,
-0.0024874718,
-0.0158394184,
-0.0332872607,
0.0382337868,
-0.0601860993,
-0.0220347904,
0.0309146363,
0.0002452081,
-0.0211382695,
0.0188055709,
-0.0105061857,
-0.0561128706,
0.0013264811,
-0.055877205,
0.0507328138,
-0.036616955,
-0.0523396693,
-0.0689748749,
0.039768029,
0.0272078626,
0.0298544094,
0.0338145718,
0.0063144695,
0.0000320445,
-0.0008230623,
0.0319984481,
0.005262502,
0.049843926,
0.0490778312,
0.0531719401,
0.0352419242,
0.053907942,
0.0137052508,
0.0168098733,
0.0064917519,
0.0693163797,
-0.001492102,
0.0322207883,
-0.0498301722,
0.0401704721,
0.0174084418,
-0.0322868526,
-0.0057721431,
0.0147752864,
-0.011781753,
-0.0531618521,
0.0049006217,
-0.0037078557,
-0.0041524931,
-0.036524836,
0.0247784648,
-0.0631872118,
-0.0562389567,
-0.0777739435,
-0.0067488779,
0.0420398414,
0.0359468758,
-0.0689651817,
-0.0319133848,
-0.0160420071,
-0.0462324359,
0.0002763564,
0.0501353592,
-0.0017366852,
-0.0322460942,
-0.0126497867,
0.0380447321,
-0.0150268888,
0.0048946538,
0.0031756556,
-0.0044003334,
0.0225320738,
-0.0224984083,
0.0563361645,
-0.0582739785,
0.0020858767,
0.0144611811,
0.0104084946,
-0.0147359492,
-0.0124332169,
0.0316296779,
0.0069640353,
-0.0555454008,
0.0315588377,
0.0258831345,
0.0074694091,
-0.0160494056,
0.0069422373,
0.0229218211,
-0.0170916263,
0.0091201914,
-0.0608941875,
-0.0699014142,
0.0160619989,
-0.0236095283,
0.0034437107,
0.0459888764,
-0.0297503471,
0.0460755117,
0.0100390948,
0.009858788,
-0.0621299557,
-0.0063638948,
-0.0016928065,
0.0060825567,
0.0880072415,
-0.0002118001,
0.0068237344,
-0.0264533572,
0.0237686932,
-0.056954328,
0.0121201482,
0.0223460216,
-0.007191984,
0.0009682141,
0.0278300755,
0.0494958758,
-0.0375233032,
0.0054519777,
-0.0785348937,
-0.0162473712,
0.030936785,
0.0307694823,
-0.0024564501,
-0.0070618158,
0.0188677739,
-0.0083449446,
-0.0190876294,
0.0309899468,
-0.0329442956,
-0.0212842654,
0.0639679953,
0.0006010501,
-0.051940985,
-0.0355692208,
0.0090423096,
-0.0772449374,
0.0505570583,
0.0595044009,
-0.0946869552,
-0.0173901767,
0.0385140888,
-0.0270874575,
0.0014673319,
0.0157218911,
-0.0287958588,
0.0444657318,
0.0118856793,
0.0212953929,
0.0461828373,
-0.0300217401,
0.0195043702,
0.0344966203,
0.0212758929,
0.0049546557,
0.0200286247,
-0.0043544681,
-0.0369121321,
0.0604729056,
-0.0032459591,
0.0080371723,
0.0312350132,
-0.0181247983,
-0.0397863686,
-0.0419966951,
0.0399540439,
0.026346717,
0.0372304469,
-0.0137921926,
-0.0106884195,
-0.0177588873,
0.0201558098,
-0.0159752015,
-0.0572688989,
0.0984819308,
-0.0056639956,
-0.0128914984,
-0.0734123439,
-0.0479825698,
-0.0339287035,
0.0607783869,
-0.0078920797,
0.0189237352,
0.0384156108,
-0.0203999821,
0.0246969312,
0.0217206366,
-0.0094434284,
-0.0145213436,
-0.023874769,
-0.0410896167,
0.0074240146,
0.0174470469,
-0.0274700224,
-0.0103224516,
0.0474222414,
-0.0418311357,
-0.0161154252,
0.0644060522,
-0.0370282345,
-0.0141073251,
0.0150216641,
0.021341728,
0.0116103971,
0.0042423438,
-0.0332798697,
0.0068285516,
-0.0605031215,
-0.0334190913,
-0.0096404338,
-0.0285661053,
0.029207442,
0.05808663,
0.0379316211,
-0.0540988222,
-0.0042077908,
0.0065170806,
0.0147842243,
-0.0125398012,
-0.0220517404,
-0.0340026021,
0.0330096446,
0.036678873,
-0.041439224,
-0.0491968915,
0.0424161777,
0.0377812423,
-0.0458014719,
0.0007391197,
-0.0594930798,
0.0054617883,
0.0032506292,
0.0834225267,
-0.080763869,
-0.0128742317,
-0.0081753088,
0.007904361,
-0.065956153,
-0.0349053741,
-0.0057900758,
-0.036815919,
0.0611994714,
0.0229817349,
-0.0844597816,
-0.0475488529,
-0.0821350738,
-0.0631412417,
-0.0414892398,
-0.0104819937,
0.0395210795,
0.000901545,
0.0420785062,
0.0048469137,
-0.0640679002,
-0.0125984494,
0.0252398495,
0.0197875891,
0.039239537,
0.0684929118,
0.0449282192,
0.0015351633,
0.0268868636,
0.0337959342,
0.0273023546,
0.0374028049,
-0.0289572384,
0.0523144826,
0.0241780877,
-0.0558078028,
-0.0679685697,
-0.0133996522,
-0.0310449172,
0.0084091155,
0.0163725354,
0.0705250576,
-0.0339271054,
-0.0436796919,
-0.0518330894,
0.0105364909,
-0.0272447001,
0.0370888524,
0.0522016622,
-0.0253464431,
-0.0507105887,
-0.0588422082,
-0.0107469168,
-0.0058578025,
-0.064882569,
-0.0200660769,
-0.0470498055,
-0.0695388317,
-0.0276520625,
-0.0088820746,
0.0786783025,
0.0068595726,
0.0365204327,
-0.04708625,
0.022645358,
0.000936859,
-0.0509059541,
-0.0006796244,
0.021962449,
-0.002130738,
-0.0265620891,
-0.0684683323,
0.0414528027,
0.0006571934,
-0.0109214867,
0.0399501063,
-0.019895792,
-0.0713334754,
-0.0222419407,
0.0779353604,
0.0332984477,
-0.0308933724,
-0.006867514,
-0.0286155324,
-0.0645746514,
0.0836273432,
-0.0116318446,
0.0015112072,
-0.0265620314,
0.015141286,
0.0046151499,
-0.044413805,
-0.0187112242,
-0.0291945562,
-0.015685467,
-0.0153434118,
0.0189248398,
0.000462145,
0.0449748412,
0.0610683002,
0.043924816,
0.0467579141,
-0.0550081134,
0.0038126991,
-0.0025020649,
-0.0111176847,
-0.001756225,
-0.0356972478,
-0.0118363407,
-0.0051659346,
0.0459399559,
0.0197334141,
0.0031387676,
-0.0685627609,
-0.013250553,
-0.0030351605,
0.0513517372,
0.0461442247,
0.0337117091,
0.0317661464,
0.0081694582,
-0.0476227328,
0.0101016723,
-0.0076720212,
0.0239178073,
0.0082375165,
0.0210556686,
-0.0131446514,
0.0478226431,
0.0063613807,
0.0011078326,
-0.0585225709,
-0.0481169149,
0.0020405729,
0.079724595,
0.0069758641,
0.0243679751,
-0.0164751653,
-0.0165103655,
0.0035805115,
-0.0382088646,
0.0455796011,
-0.0381571688,
0.00145579,
0.0020881586,
0.0129293418,
-0.05016727,
-0.1204298288,
0.0522384867,
-0.0044375896,
0.0429577902,
-0.0205102563,
-0.072957404,
-0.0012993938,
-0.0108070215,
0.0207770579,
-0.0129113104,
0.0204424802,
-0.0497306846,
-0.0218205843,
-0.0527361222,
-0.0228787549,
0.0177649166,
0.0008714829,
0.0146427248,
0.0305909384,
0.0029666261,
0.0291062724,
-0.0577372611,
0.0287201107,
0.0519410595,
-0.0175899491,
-0.0291396249,
0.0096444683,
-5.601781595e-33,
0.0009011442,
-0.0567685999,
0.0010876422,
0.0824991837,
0.0003110814,
-0.0192541275,
-0.0440650135,
0.0295663048,
-0.0064288811,
0.0393017456,
-0.0121030454,
0.0209437832,
-0.0061349599,
-0.0512724221,
0.0384335332,
-0.0117001003,
0.0283920057,
0.0128185507,
0.0107366303,
0.0107516535,
0.0067951661,
0.0308982376,
0.0125183659,
-0.0204492398,
-0.0071134996,
0.0144580873,
0.0199451689,
-0.0297238789,
-0.0533969589,
-0.0035780941,
0.0449854732,
0.0185882598,
-0.0109632732,
0.0078877239,
-0.0294276886,
0.0175040662,
-0.0349158831,
-0.0161915328,
0.0220948346,
0.005050587,
-0.0049783112,
-0.0522952341,
0.0397307128,
-0.0171389412,
-0.0246312562,
0.0175788142,
0.0324608944,
-0.012218562,
-0.013338713,
0.0042736484,
-0.0473388433,
0.0044816625,
-0.0731399804,
-0.0100272009,
0.0277990885,
0.0265752301,
-0.0122108161,
-0.0081269909,
0.0371589996,
0.0629456863,
0.0676144883,
-0.0007779037,
0.041581925,
-0.0301276259,
0.041790355,
0.0019686096,
0.0346838161,
-0.0142183974,
-0.0130966203,
0.0091192741,
-0.0079133064,
0.0122380499,
0.0212211385,
-0.0020383801,
0.037247397,
-0.0112490533,
-0.0539483353,
0.0445960984,
0.0264656693,
-0.0063498463,
-0.0366433673,
0.0437566973,
-0.0187737383,
-0.0508785471,
0.0290508326,
0.0106041757,
-0.0286716279,
-0.0373338833,
-0.0065958137,
-0.0815447196,
-0.0163592193,
0.0152716767,
0.0112575274,
-0.0077908318,
0.0261873342,
-0.0373012051,
-0.0380574912,
0.0171147622,
-0.0112371789,
-0.0145001421,
-0.0232221968,
-0.0233680978,
0.0119088255,
0.0281118918,
0.1039414704,
-0.0105512487,
0.0000259546,
0.0153897181,
-0.0367253572,
0.009991603,
-0.0223740917,
0.0186811462,
0.0220758822,
0.0420472957,
-0.006630552,
-0.0164500438,
0.0081981011,
0.0228403155,
0.0337047577,
0.002392156,
-0.0622773841,
0.0644598603,
-0.0225897878,
-0.0225026831,
-0.0506017879,
-0.0018638851,
-0.0219194908,
0.0583794862,
-0.0257770289,
-0.0489059165,
-0.0458554886,
-0.0138637517,
2.736e-7,
0.0522713363,
0.0698737502,
0.0350431465,
0.0139880804,
0.0296135731,
-0.0007728025,
-0.0226764176,
0.0050973757,
-0.0169846918,
0.002903691,
0.0095782764,
0.0124366255,
0.0283817519,
-0.0062413891,
-0.0454091541,
-0.0603698343,
-0.067536667,
-0.022563776,
-0.0316631272,
0.0094023235,
0.0558327287,
0.0400402136,
-0.0053358362,
0.0267339945,
0.0464444906,
-0.0088471891,
-0.0157052521,
0.0022657132,
0.0602876619,
0.0603859089,
-0.0662872046,
0.018471187,
0.0041052322,
0.0283899363,
0.0076012556,
-0.0927194655,
0.0260907412,
0.0474547893,
-0.0119716972,
0.0459612645,
0.0901491269,
0.0247444715,
0.01330096,
-0.0634779483,
0.0290286224,
-0.0549038537,
-0.0734934062,
-0.0532014892,
0.0505588762,
-0.0185291208,
0.0529026836,
-0.022221243,
0.0140360631,
0.0187852997,
-0.0308434069,
-0.0047336523,
-0.0347296707,
-0.0052607562,
-0.0478095822,
0.0041514635,
-0.0344123878,
-0.0730671883,
-0.0168160349,
0.012233505,
0.0806361064,
-0.0143671948,
0.0205823444,
2.473502993e-34,
0.0492445715,
-0.0187479537,
0.0302770212,
0.0274071582,
0.0362740681,
0.0017863333,
0.0463706926,
-0.0070984135,
-0.0053901244,
0.0360494964,
-0.0550140291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09117v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09117v2 | Contrastive Decoding Improves Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2023-09-17T00:29:32 | 2023-09-29T15:11:49 | Sean O'Brien, Mike Lewis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | We demonstrate that Contrastive Decoding -- a simple, computationally light,
and training-free text generation method proposed by Li et al 2022 -- achieves
large out-of-the-box improvements over greedy decoding on a variety of
reasoning tasks. Originally shown to improve the perceived quality of long-form
text generation, Contrastive Decoding searches for strings that maximize a
weighted difference in likelihood between strong and weak models. We show that
Contrastive Decoding leads LLaMA-65B to outperform LLaMA 2, GPT-3.5 and PaLM
2-L on the HellaSwag commonsense reasoning benchmark, and to outperform LLaMA
2, GPT-3.5 and PaLM-540B on the GSM8K math word reasoning benchmark, in
addition to improvements on a collection of other tasks. Analysis suggests that
Contrastive Decoding improves over existing methods by preventing some abstract
reasoning errors, as well as by avoiding simpler modes such as copying sections
of the input during chain-of-thought. Overall, Contrastive Decoding outperforms
nucleus sampling for long-form generation and greedy decoding for reasoning
tasks, making it a powerful general purpose method for generating text from
language models. | [
0.012974727,
0.0786479339,
0.0072424784,
0.0305578392,
-0.0549393557,
0.0154643068,
-0.0017304454,
0.0056397435,
-0.0318890363,
-0.0381990224,
0.0000181649,
-0.0515130945,
0.020197466,
0.0099013159,
0.0501984917,
-0.0491758585,
0.0236002188,
-0.045187626,
0.0215993673,
-0.0072887465,
-0.0109155439,
0.0143648246,
0.0016260033,
0.0151278889,
0.025627315,
-0.0272245072,
-0.0317166932,
-0.0169225596,
0.0096911471,
-0.0404495858,
-0.0176991876,
0.0480953865,
0.0001197714,
0.0155932121,
0.0000022242,
-0.0197625495,
0.0123567674,
0.0074225706,
-0.0078990953,
0.0247744136,
0.0739647299,
-0.0320330821,
0.0022608815,
0.0316346809,
-0.0276059564,
0.002840535,
0.046057336,
0.0397811532,
0.0190660246,
0.051762823,
0.0002547551,
-0.0629111677,
0.0412676111,
-0.0339488052,
0.0351483673,
0.0015850104,
0.0012141797,
0.0337757729,
0.0194344446,
0.0165821686,
-0.0012146966,
0.0358597673,
0.0595016554,
0.0036732859,
-0.021688927,
0.074008964,
0.0010962144,
-0.0048258081,
0.0177189,
0.0688405707,
0.0052466062,
-0.0530898571,
0.0099815661,
-0.0062855706,
-0.0197876133,
-0.0273359772,
-0.0299676675,
0.0755261034,
-0.0239424631,
0.0465766676,
0.1063793674,
0.003561086,
0.0169230793,
0.0050323084,
-0.0414962545,
0.020669695,
0.0378387608,
-0.0392371342,
0.001170396,
0.0243885163,
-0.0341535211,
-0.0668861121,
0.0171658453,
0.0203857981,
-0.0149465017,
0.0162756946,
-0.0609417669,
-0.0475644916,
0.014784514,
-0.0164210349,
0.0361118913,
0.0840473548,
-0.0049180114,
0.0015938592,
-0.0479404926,
0.0244634878,
-0.0356392488,
0.0095837899,
-0.0445518903,
0.012840393,
-0.0293024667,
-0.0119670723,
0.0019475778,
0.0384195149,
-0.0728259012,
-0.0285070762,
-0.0158039574,
0.0054395194,
0.0405906327,
-0.0248573571,
0.0327198617,
0.005633825,
-0.0368745252,
-0.0094433203,
-0.0164239407,
0.0238021724,
-0.0527691022,
0.0192989558,
0.0543952398,
-0.05675859,
-0.0093192346,
0.0133354291,
-0.0056098881,
-0.0241687503,
0.0113659967,
0.0528901927,
-0.0424823724,
-0.0193173215,
-0.0501450188,
-0.0338848494,
-0.0015664014,
-0.0693630055,
0.0173250828,
-0.1020293757,
0.0211520214,
0.0268870145,
-0.0404293127,
-0.0170364045,
0.0291429274,
0.036906518,
-0.0203540754,
0.0533839986,
-0.0351215936,
-0.0065373038,
0.0097032869,
0.0032599336,
-0.0089658247,
0.0551307313,
0.0356669948,
0.0005941822,
-0.0100738211,
0.0348256901,
-0.0132965306,
-0.0014570042,
0.0282006562,
-0.0200779177,
-0.0130492644,
-0.0237871446,
-0.0327927433,
0.023073053,
0.0664803162,
0.0719854608,
-0.0533202142,
-0.001361937,
0.0640994385,
0.0569652319,
0.0003840709,
0.0319870822,
0.0441824049,
-0.0074646459,
0.0043282406,
0.022389859,
-0.03648955,
0.0447471738,
-0.0357652679,
0.0498769209,
0.0253354292,
0.0495544784,
-0.0274773575,
-0.040205963,
0.0063432157,
-0.0158062577,
0.0281160027,
0.0089315893,
0.0323369578,
0.033177536,
-0.0628946275,
0.0475367233,
0.0466345735,
-0.0713274553,
0.0072845025,
-0.0500141978,
0.0614279844,
0.0501838885,
0.0412262566,
0.0431305915,
-0.010507185,
0.0154691599,
-0.0254070237,
0.0923602954,
0.0210082307,
0.0091848765,
-0.0201357789,
-0.0838835016,
0.0103859259,
-0.0131635368,
0.0137933623,
0.0203787945,
0.0156084802,
0.0002758235,
0.035596028,
-0.0369798169,
0.0027380385,
0.0178820454,
-0.0507619604,
-0.0174709745,
-0.0059817792,
-0.0168894604,
-0.0002683832,
-0.0134295104,
-0.0108907111,
0.0535675436,
-0.0039353967,
-0.0706675425,
-0.0066663376,
0.0098066432,
-0.0748479515,
-0.1093414351,
0.0225928091,
-0.0168976728,
0.0166586097,
0.0293023363,
-0.006674109,
-0.0459038168,
0.0246033948,
-0.0421595424,
0.036775101,
-0.0509185269,
0.0035601705,
0.0467432328,
-0.0047291876,
-0.0262655914,
0.1266326904,
-0.0228542425,
-0.0025385022,
0.0228855629,
0.0515577309,
0.0056997235,
-0.0571853295,
0.0185838863,
0.0208838414,
-0.0161141306,
-0.0049168961,
-0.0188084021,
0.0468291603,
-0.0279255584,
-0.0293387417,
-0.0478898846,
0.0203788299,
-0.015655715,
0.0225481596,
0.0543964542,
-0.0001615436,
0.0203397851,
0.0488343202,
-0.0649309531,
0.0018847917,
0.035021551,
0.0146780396,
0.0129031269,
0.0060488977,
-0.0000205208,
-0.0114699593,
-0.0129318666,
-0.018994119,
0.0327018611,
0.0025341178,
0.0359424166,
-0.0604824536,
0.0666087493,
-0.023755597,
-0.0174016878,
-1.71e-8,
-0.0433510281,
0.0242849234,
-0.0232153144,
0.0565071553,
0.0649079308,
0.0166940317,
0.0113272499,
0.0266510844,
-0.0055403193,
-0.0245913956,
-0.0014149131,
-0.019629335,
0.0311813857,
-0.0000264379,
-0.0798507184,
-0.0169838183,
0.0902509838,
0.0465611666,
0.013069028,
-0.0875808522,
0.0060858103,
0.0054776091,
-0.024488328,
-0.0035680819,
0.0128767397,
-0.013763004,
0.0572211556,
-0.0488187373,
-0.0325907655,
0.0597755611,
-0.0482617356,
0.0095426487,
-0.0640746653,
0.0065943804,
-0.0143083986,
0.028090952,
-0.0303853434,
0.0220695958,
0.0147690549,
-0.0171320271,
-0.0356772095,
-0.0221197158,
0.0045741298,
-0.0443534479,
0.0318619572,
-0.0628503859,
0.0043394519,
-0.0210142732,
-0.0644512028,
-0.0295702852,
-0.003317354,
-0.0186898336,
0.0253560618,
0.0487868488,
-0.0149758803,
0.0119828386,
0.0118593425,
0.0197329633,
0.0365373567,
-0.0426636189,
-0.0051040868,
-0.0283186231,
0.0653057992,
0.0310651138,
-0.0230127946,
0.0442593172,
-0.0542744212,
0.0181835201,
0.057616584,
0.0403768942,
0.0107309194,
-0.0181866847,
0.0310659278,
0.0087492121,
0.0142124426,
-0.0458497368,
0.035239093,
0.0469785035,
-0.0674949512,
-0.0404426455,
0.0987334847,
0.02477777,
-0.0066074026,
0.0028163816,
-0.0372865759,
0.0688647702,
-0.013949899,
0.0293438341,
-0.0486175753,
-0.0391040742,
0.042032972,
0.0402590223,
0.0108361924,
-0.0359943099,
0.0050530396,
-0.1264746636,
0.0506280102,
0.0227981731,
-0.0555894077,
-0.0390976779,
-0.0242000408,
-0.0415865518,
0.0106518958,
-0.0268546175,
0.0590672493,
0.0127916913,
0.0443288945,
0.0323185325,
0.0123380153,
-0.0424597226,
0.0028100079,
-0.010574854,
0.0147981234,
0.0633616671,
0.0302462913,
0.0200716723,
-0.0693348646,
0.0037341723,
-0.0426455587,
-0.0016191019,
-0.0288719498,
0.0142657012,
0.017017819,
-0.0177495666,
-0.0404675901,
0.069235675,
-0.0454073697,
-0.0349110849,
-0.0169354714,
0.0652301535,
-0.0101283966,
-0.0110903373,
-0.0016228717,
0.0133196237,
0.0098623056,
0.0825882703,
0.048561018,
-0.0179426316,
-0.066730544,
-0.0402977467,
0.0022049625,
-0.0807371289,
-0.0124181481,
-0.0075122388,
0.0491246656,
-0.0159276724,
-0.0919509828,
-0.0431076139,
0.0195891056,
0.0624508969,
-0.0239800941,
0.0127180768,
0.0080420775,
-0.0426585004,
-0.0292975847,
-0.0026980843,
-0.0494007319,
-0.002109553,
-0.0342248902,
-0.0010536321,
0.0137993172,
-0.0526196808,
-0.0208847467,
0.0078886412,
-0.0500172786,
-0.0697528347,
-0.0406718031,
0.0426319353,
0.0242817327,
0.0263007488,
0.0026766015,
-0.0245850813,
0.0263901148,
0.0251671243,
-0.0210510418,
0.0326582976,
0.0023432968,
-0.0217351858,
0.0311348122,
0.0379849523,
-0.0158188511,
-0.0086230068,
0.0013636742,
0.081570521,
-0.0133632543,
0.014069668,
0.0223521274,
0.0390260108,
-0.003383738,
-0.0391600244,
0.0183863416,
-0.0228255391,
0.003839076,
-0.0422437675,
0.0024447187,
-0.0503776483,
0.0329295695,
0.0289007258,
0.0166577715,
0.0056534647,
0.0123785995,
0.025958864,
0.0382859409,
0.0243224781,
0.0201021899,
-0.0138402991,
0.0383009389,
0.0303216428,
-0.047534585,
-0.0365553759,
-0.0354803652,
-0.0527958646,
0.0561208427,
-0.0390484668,
0.05018555,
0.0329511873,
-0.0125172604,
-0.0222255718,
-0.0046430309,
-0.0459892377,
-0.0523313768,
-0.022745749,
-0.0189369023,
0.0373416543,
0.0097292252,
0.0343538411,
-0.054827854,
-0.0092954012,
-0.0108867465,
0.0573151298,
0.0215981025,
-0.0323357247,
0.0267448071,
0.0193071123,
-0.0029382284,
-0.0593159497,
0.084923096,
-0.0138519658,
0.0360690244,
0.016680235,
0.0104424525,
-0.0413239934,
-0.0466812477,
-0.0088639688,
0.0100367889,
-0.0019063239,
-0.0047576022,
-0.0531928353,
-0.0645203441,
0.0164780077,
0.0357643701,
0.0107451482,
-0.01377156,
0.046802707,
0.0546720624,
-0.0184355639,
-0.0194578618,
-0.0209034011,
0.0330394991,
-0.0340040959,
-0.015048868,
-0.0429973938,
-6.761647748e-33,
-0.0220728666,
-0.0215617269,
0.0424620733,
-0.0635981783,
-0.0226110704,
-0.0251688175,
-0.0747544393,
-0.0093436083,
0.0074059623,
0.021426741,
-0.0152275236,
0.0006408624,
0.0038007062,
0.0524257906,
-0.0098816734,
-0.0214342158,
0.0331515335,
-0.0129130222,
-0.037119966,
0.0244364701,
0.0374310277,
0.0245247409,
0.0153059131,
-0.0263219643,
-0.011120772,
-0.0032047858,
0.0084731765,
-0.0096936496,
-0.067109026,
0.0454243235,
-0.0287387613,
0.0096296798,
0.0184531584,
-0.0164716467,
-0.0246394631,
0.0248415396,
-0.0773881078,
0.0011313787,
0.0484779887,
-0.0408647098,
-0.0609712303,
-0.0663458407,
0.0136088673,
0.0130983936,
-0.0119489515,
-0.0144112473,
-0.0099701742,
-0.0545529574,
-0.0198687408,
-0.010949824,
-0.0438133702,
0.0198765881,
0.0009812035,
-0.0112174368,
-0.0207982995,
0.0137624042,
-0.0321761854,
0.0419000499,
-0.0225420073,
0.0033726103,
0.0402688012,
0.0322327763,
0.0575844049,
0.0231253281,
0.0129058463,
0.0348369256,
0.010605162,
-0.0413307734,
-0.0261946637,
0.0052778525,
0.001046814,
0.0356085338,
0.0509372167,
0.0516816862,
0.0586052909,
0.0077948347,
-0.0674179867,
-0.0032927517,
-0.0120144272,
-0.0009368382,
0.054018829,
-0.0024497558,
-0.0410920903,
-0.0330763757,
-0.0363673568,
-0.0471838638,
-0.05133757,
-0.0331679359,
0.0489889123,
0.0117464233,
-0.032075949,
-0.0307359565,
0.0358003005,
-0.0021232464,
0.0207330119,
0.052036304,
-0.0341003463,
0.0141376853,
-0.0312369745,
-0.0148879634,
-0.0722009242,
-0.0212066844,
0.0228394568,
0.0264743865,
-0.0109333368,
0.036895588,
0.005236167,
0.0026877071,
-0.0346607789,
0.0061008483,
-0.0486522168,
0.024852816,
0.0283799227,
0.0084162457,
0.0399155654,
-0.0120624118,
0.0044181976,
0.0341826268,
-0.0143826734,
-0.0001303398,
-0.0334543698,
-0.0080151688,
-0.0089624804,
0.0513419546,
-0.0108501865,
0.0312184915,
-0.0613508224,
0.0289087184,
0.0339301415,
-0.0361919329,
-0.024712164,
0.0668937787,
2.843e-7,
0.0379207917,
0.0295373853,
0.0346043594,
0.0293914527,
0.007001467,
0.0380003452,
0.0119677559,
-0.00451905,
0.0124678854,
-0.0372776799,
-0.0199655928,
0.0428542979,
0.055509422,
0.0298162438,
-0.0680141002,
0.0454865061,
-0.0570581891,
-0.0248029586,
-0.0293943472,
-0.028746821,
0.1038252041,
0.0645411983,
-0.0098329857,
-0.0253122486,
0.0540614277,
-0.0218749139,
0.0664706081,
-0.0067185797,
-0.0142535185,
-0.0101393312,
-0.0040757991,
-0.0042679049,
-0.0005897147,
0.0004843699,
-0.0122372899,
-0.0145757385,
-0.0212556347,
0.0541717932,
0.0447552167,
-0.0212184526,
0.0180406664,
-0.037530791,
-0.0150172915,
-0.0463117808,
0.0770446807,
-0.0380827188,
-0.0143215386,
-0.0026652012,
-0.0321285948,
-0.0014579665,
-0.0373213738,
-0.0315643959,
-0.0072796904,
-0.0028585368,
-0.0028382353,
0.0047496357,
-0.0149592748,
-0.0508282259,
-0.0329770818,
0.0273242388,
-0.0329077616,
-0.0488303937,
-0.0656992048,
0.0376786925,
0.0665881857,
-0.0529871732,
-0.0109234173,
3.153689942e-34,
0.0194918662,
-0.0197016746,
0.0111541161,
0.0384094939,
0.0268487744,
-0.0040298584,
0.0054568704,
0.003636488,
0.0141979102,
-0.0798726007,
-0.0373499878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09092v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09092v1 | The Impact of Debiasing on the Performance of Language Models in Downstream Tasks is Underestimated | 2023-09-16T20:25:34 | 2023-09-16T20:25:34 | Masahiro Kaneko, Danushka Bollegala, Naoaki Okazaki | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained language models trained on large-scale data have learned serious
levels of social biases. Consequently, various methods have been proposed to
debias pre-trained models. Debiasing methods need to mitigate only
discriminatory bias information from the pre-trained models, while retaining
information that is useful for the downstream tasks. In previous research,
whether useful information is retained has been confirmed by the performance of
downstream tasks in debiased pre-trained models. On the other hand, it is not
clear whether these benchmarks consist of data pertaining to social biases and
are appropriate for investigating the impact of debiasing. For example in
gender-related social biases, data containing female words (e.g. ``she, female,
woman''), male words (e.g. ``he, male, man''), and stereotypical words (e.g.
``nurse, doctor, professor'') are considered to be the most affected by
debiasing. If there is not much data containing these words in a benchmark
dataset for a target task, there is the possibility of erroneously evaluating
the effects of debiasing. In this study, we compare the impact of debiasing on
performance across multiple downstream tasks using a wide-range of benchmark
datasets that containing female, male, and stereotypical words. Experiments
show that the effects of debiasing are consistently \emph{underestimated}
across all tasks. Moreover, the effects of debiasing could be reliably
evaluated by separately considering instances containing female, male, and
stereotypical words than all of the instances in a benchmark dataset. | [
0.0488316715,
0.0580256544,
-0.0386966392,
0.0141641805,
-0.0013624032,
0.0331202969,
0.0725835562,
-0.0259827171,
0.020558212,
-0.0814095661,
-0.0370238237,
-0.0370131359,
0.0253440645,
-0.0041584959,
0.0401988588,
-0.0627083629,
0.0506369658,
0.0205869507,
0.0642355755,
-0.0722556859,
0.0120111462,
0.0183409993,
0.0311942305,
0.0296956059,
0.0108220512,
-0.0009299209,
0.0660940856,
-0.0012399098,
-0.0090386169,
0.0280495919,
0.0504833646,
0.0728842244,
0.00483137,
0.0034555229,
0.0000019323,
-0.0790404677,
0.0019330708,
-0.0117685888,
-0.0233099572,
-0.0393327549,
0.0574471168,
-0.022721339,
0.023089936,
0.0318252891,
-0.0280777458,
-0.0342690796,
0.0313124247,
0.0324739628,
0.0055480278,
0.0343910195,
-0.0128776617,
0.003378401,
-0.0620375164,
-0.0217676498,
-0.0028749709,
-0.0016876411,
0.0588466264,
-0.0423593447,
-0.0827747732,
-0.0025903054,
-0.029231701,
-0.0165060181,
-0.0086639849,
0.0523148291,
0.0206340831,
0.0254536215,
-0.0198175758,
-0.024777418,
-0.0065878457,
0.0377238579,
-0.05569515,
-0.0277970415,
0.0118098464,
-0.0340339504,
0.037903171,
0.0338302739,
-0.0025737551,
0.0025399651,
-0.0065441299,
0.0000845298,
-0.0082701156,
0.005692841,
0.0364194214,
0.0575511232,
-0.0043304879,
0.0758969858,
0.0175387617,
-0.0392382778,
0.029087333,
0.033882048,
0.0207609311,
-0.060786657,
0.0269055609,
-0.0413330756,
-0.0026464909,
0.0327086076,
-0.0463426635,
0.0092870397,
0.0237106234,
-0.0613723621,
-0.0221482553,
0.0313381627,
0.0015240642,
-0.0150589729,
-0.0144648198,
0.008419618,
0.0108212754,
0.0215866826,
-0.0107133929,
-0.0141693391,
0.0004100517,
-0.0036802827,
-0.0029902328,
0.0188841019,
-0.0165950153,
0.0462830812,
-0.050565619,
-0.0174928438,
-0.0429426618,
-0.0466321595,
0.0264408663,
0.029561935,
-0.043850489,
-0.0043260185,
-0.0351350382,
-0.0140716676,
-0.0654847398,
0.0680383295,
-0.0390320942,
-0.1020817459,
0.0156453941,
-0.0340517312,
0.0223842151,
-0.0519878343,
0.0068794084,
0.0519368649,
0.018890582,
-0.0531122535,
-0.0195968226,
-0.0106074335,
-0.0370640382,
-0.0758272186,
0.0010696171,
-0.0335248671,
0.0318053551,
0.0357014872,
0.0040967059,
-0.0707703009,
-0.0080705611,
0.0107195685,
-0.0690937713,
0.0702591166,
0.0454652384,
0.0133104092,
0.0475287959,
0.0236113146,
0.0060951337,
0.1085531116,
0.0119203348,
0.0139589664,
0.0228345562,
-0.0072333147,
0.0101107983,
0.0251021963,
0.0458259098,
-0.0075033912,
-0.0180548877,
0.0068196682,
0.0166281201,
-0.001518392,
0.0873033926,
0.0274008103,
-0.0217159633,
-0.0326329432,
0.0783778653,
0.0371754952,
0.001100351,
0.0312154032,
0.0212638583,
0.0066635711,
-0.0185731724,
0.041857373,
-0.0930504128,
-0.0318379179,
0.0168912988,
-0.027558472,
0.0003824716,
0.031464681,
-0.0277683008,
-0.025071688,
0.0011049396,
0.0020207509,
0.048491545,
0.0201968253,
0.0396795496,
0.0252715386,
-0.0056482065,
0.0656158701,
0.0513414815,
-0.049518913,
0.0090962304,
-0.0414000414,
-0.0085271271,
0.0314756259,
-0.0033352429,
-0.0274102762,
-0.0118179014,
-0.0233433712,
-0.0335568674,
0.0311013218,
0.0875171721,
-0.0005426963,
0.0376901217,
-0.0524099693,
-0.0212136004,
0.0195628349,
0.035906706,
0.0162153933,
0.0661827922,
0.0329626128,
0.0271279812,
-0.0325278118,
-0.059918832,
0.0461625233,
-0.0200828686,
-0.032737691,
-0.0017185748,
-0.0047905971,
0.007025938,
0.0026479631,
-0.031687025,
-0.010185455,
-0.0271190498,
0.024576202,
0.0079053966,
0.0118048759,
-0.0707800835,
-0.0144507335,
-0.0007938283,
-0.0339290351,
-0.0277980119,
0.0571693033,
-0.0090230592,
-0.0008424839,
0.0638858825,
-0.0067307977,
0.0200104155,
-0.0126622608,
0.0124132549,
-0.0579672344,
0.0520790033,
-0.0276244935,
0.0464130901,
-0.0051910249,
-0.0177499317,
-0.0447242819,
-0.0427627601,
-0.0207194798,
-0.0607948415,
-0.0251513589,
-0.0080819288,
0.0008654149,
-0.0134953698,
0.0421430506,
-0.0564837568,
-0.0215141196,
0.0040770611,
-0.0865975171,
-0.0241140388,
-0.0085847331,
-0.0148454234,
-0.0260317791,
0.029040847,
-0.024640996,
-0.0231325012,
-0.0089298291,
-0.0115282927,
0.0094800424,
0.0602299757,
-0.0086471662,
-0.0288811699,
0.009481309,
-0.056400843,
-0.0309174713,
-0.0397152789,
0.0502580553,
0.0383839756,
-0.0231993776,
-0.0155752478,
0.0285623539,
-0.0297722984,
0.0276196413,
0.000034599,
-0.0161901843,
-0.0011941494,
0.065421842,
0.0495427214,
0.0808201879,
-0.0019476777,
-0.0008441259,
0.0697487146,
0.0028315047,
-0.0519057475,
-0.0198336486,
-0.0008415438,
0.0313981026,
-0.0060020946,
-0.0634395629,
-0.0228862278,
0.05356884,
0.0432656296,
-0.0423311964,
-0.0318926126,
0.0439800657,
-0.0439248309,
-0.0764957964,
-0.0278355479,
-0.0562081523,
-0.0207742602,
0.0242805071,
-0.0571529642,
-0.0734597743,
0.0425942615,
0.0174845047,
0.0080735208,
-0.0368811749,
0.0215449166,
-0.0226713996,
0.0381929874,
-0.0020097396,
0.02590115,
0.0117277261,
-0.008947433,
-0.0736451894,
-0.0395887159,
0.0314533748,
-0.0343868919,
0.0160856582,
-0.030982079,
0.0093826102,
-0.006705984,
-0.0568024665,
-0.0438383557,
-0.0505572893,
-0.0217908937,
-0.0077544022,
0.0342991836,
0.0151543459,
-0.0186638366,
0.0031377764,
-0.0130775496,
0.0281893052,
-0.0146218892,
0.0052334764,
0.0193344913,
-0.011892573,
0.0130209066,
-0.0087898588,
0.0309499875,
-0.0267288424,
-0.0089368345,
-0.006092214,
0.0345903113,
-0.0123819439,
-0.0216922089,
0.0059831459,
0.0265247487,
-0.0401390493,
-0.0179705024,
-0.0092613194,
0.0480197892,
-0.0480988584,
0.0065632826,
0.1078482568,
-0.0069249789,
-0.0516247787,
0.0187812243,
0.0415755473,
-0.0152668273,
0.0324672908,
-0.0016624555,
-0.0549726337,
-0.0057886532,
0.0287105776,
-0.0173279811,
-0.0242470521,
-0.0583383776,
-0.0210451558,
-0.1215999722,
0.0055869147,
-0.0196903124,
-0.0106890239,
-0.016125815,
-0.0306889154,
0.0251334291,
-0.0439250581,
0.0243458375,
-0.0079376753,
-0.0122816162,
0.0151243489,
0.0202576034,
-0.0360540375,
-0.0751679987,
0.0034335533,
-0.0794990882,
0.0598895662,
0.043109782,
0.0381282121,
-0.0460057296,
0.0120219849,
0.0337754004,
0.0122049619,
-0.0033265036,
-0.0182683524,
0.0794490427,
-0.0501016527,
-0.0123126116,
-0.0251097362,
0.0142898457,
0.0233125295,
0.0152954077,
-0.0267707463,
-0.0035359098,
0.0093328143,
-0.049542781,
-0.0105039189,
-0.0042013922,
0.013955065,
0.0914001465,
0.0279926583,
-0.0341929644,
-0.0218221918,
-0.0276968256,
-0.0057225348,
0.0298476778,
-0.0269526634,
-0.0086462535,
-0.0008146073,
-0.0297073778,
-0.0280001573,
-0.049058903,
0.0274588559,
0.006370137,
0.0118008684,
-0.0004598102,
0.0243108384,
0.0112399645,
-0.0591925979,
0.0352184586,
-0.0195666458,
0.0314531326,
0.0409418531,
-0.0271760263,
-0.0214348044,
-0.0368378237,
-0.0302798282,
0.004454392,
-0.0298962258,
-0.064559631,
0.0834035054,
0.0210956801,
0.0290530734,
0.0545288883,
-0.0151105477,
-0.0947141945,
0.0658040345,
0.0206906199,
-0.0478933081,
0.0273419395,
0.0373998508,
-0.0083029643,
0.020881936,
0.0271951258,
-0.0280459095,
0.0379174948,
0.0639003366,
-0.0496658534,
0.0124580897,
-0.0244620927,
-0.0158653632,
0.0062006819,
0.0634878799,
-0.0480476245,
0.0265502855,
-0.0603319928,
-0.0324438699,
-0.0256862603,
-0.0435503572,
0.0027708486,
-0.0246388819,
0.0377055928,
0.0542091839,
-0.0394064784,
-0.0276364256,
-0.0608847775,
0.0011625815,
-0.0415858142,
0.0220051631,
0.0214675236,
0.0373991728,
0.0093475301,
0.0246836562,
-0.0025849526,
0.0325180516,
-0.0126579758,
0.0115831792,
0.0181952082,
-0.0104513718,
0.0140983686,
0.0176863261,
-0.045164641,
-0.0089887744,
-0.0450262204,
0.0019403397,
-0.0168185681,
0.0110129155,
0.0033601581,
-0.051540751,
0.0212442577,
0.0138873402,
0.0076546203,
-0.0039322926,
-0.0330493897,
-0.0042114947,
0.0251839571,
0.0465819016,
-0.0032074116,
-0.0344113782,
0.0208847225,
0.0973740071,
0.038432464,
0.0561610349,
-0.0353938788,
-0.0437844805,
-0.0098646441,
-0.0184699632,
0.0221173782,
-0.009819,
-0.0415024795,
-0.0064492156,
-0.0644091964,
-0.0632327721,
-0.0331510864,
-0.0159136076,
0.0451842397,
-0.0027289852,
0.0394982733,
0.0592551976,
-0.0301401336,
-0.0281425416,
-0.0222784653,
0.0087837847,
-0.0223959815,
-0.0059759477,
-0.0055391714,
-6.030138348e-33,
-0.0183387827,
-0.0024464272,
-0.0187741276,
-0.0388398133,
-0.0016517563,
0.0062461006,
0.0037079889,
0.0033129419,
-0.0052295476,
0.0318542682,
-0.0046187374,
0.0429356359,
0.032379061,
-0.0285208989,
0.0121554723,
-0.0139054861,
0.0862553716,
-0.0001351174,
-0.0253479425,
-0.0215982925,
-0.0050493041,
0.0480464995,
0.0538889542,
-0.0527180992,
0.0810600594,
-0.0066806292,
-0.0064420602,
-0.019682359,
-0.0051723584,
0.0127882743,
-0.0265188944,
0.0774470493,
0.0312523767,
-0.0319515914,
-0.0129759181,
0.0706313774,
-0.0551012531,
-0.0411676913,
0.0279083494,
0.0308653861,
0.0075644059,
-0.0025212956,
0.0525096357,
0.0181949623,
-0.0910328254,
-0.0020237502,
0.0301450063,
0.0067728148,
0.0332040042,
0.0275746267,
-0.0543915592,
0.033592239,
0.0080389287,
0.0320023261,
0.0166208725,
0.013025403,
0.0009302573,
-0.0027739143,
-0.0162131824,
0.0255241804,
0.0116889486,
-0.0052323369,
0.0188468862,
0.0361481458,
0.0176753905,
0.0609216578,
0.1016532481,
0.0591154844,
0.0326079652,
-0.0545576997,
0.0565331951,
-0.0340846367,
0.0160741266,
0.0670117289,
0.0522289202,
-0.0232939105,
-0.0350447707,
-0.0084849549,
0.015710596,
-0.0030221913,
0.037169531,
-0.0213495176,
-0.0585459657,
-0.0803178549,
-0.0404517688,
-0.0509741902,
-0.0049308715,
-0.0182193127,
0.0248615462,
0.0335258432,
-0.0199230108,
0.0342411287,
-0.0028790385,
-0.0434321612,
-0.0296773911,
0.0169162713,
-0.0043698512,
-0.0459041484,
0.0258930083,
0.0050719525,
-0.0728833899,
-0.0057535376,
0.0019947051,
0.0641413182,
0.0112673026,
-0.0063697859,
-0.007032983,
0.0077546737,
-0.066119574,
0.0175766684,
-0.0147453947,
-0.0088297985,
0.0563231111,
0.0455842614,
0.0603699237,
0.0303238798,
-0.0106220301,
-0.0088475179,
0.0572910123,
-0.026863981,
-0.0425424464,
-0.0013157795,
0.0004052212,
0.0335542783,
-0.0291118063,
-0.0384539366,
-0.003098195,
-0.0252532344,
0.0381754674,
-0.0322811566,
-0.0130293267,
-0.0280137714,
2.529e-7,
-0.0010398816,
0.071506761,
-0.002879635,
0.0023450234,
0.0186050218,
0.017620137,
0.0380165875,
0.0488289148,
0.0215265304,
0.0204252377,
-0.0215533506,
0.0438182056,
-0.0012856819,
0.0217308514,
-0.0522813089,
-0.0080891363,
-0.0644466877,
0.0260800812,
-0.0130145093,
0.0037300037,
-0.0415902399,
0.064096719,
0.023539098,
-0.0086556161,
-0.0298764519,
-0.014485985,
0.0295595545,
-0.0413846709,
0.0221284274,
0.0165483803,
0.0343509838,
0.0241401549,
0.0217014644,
0.0754206181,
0.0012314764,
0.0430279151,
0.0204485729,
0.0277457554,
-0.0427142009,
0.0526743457,
-0.0103412606,
0.0026151058,
-0.0303741805,
-0.0715075657,
0.0736746117,
-0.0206090547,
-0.0398333855,
-0.0571891703,
0.007897147,
-0.0003998065,
0.0692650378,
-0.008165637,
-0.0002870961,
-0.0011798551,
0.0252010468,
0.0012295506,
-0.0204457603,
-0.068779774,
-0.0254205354,
0.0000273713,
-0.023832839,
-0.062111605,
0.014590079,
0.0117140887,
0.047755383,
-0.0407009684,
0.0340032429,
2.081766975e-34,
0.0207470078,
0.0342242531,
0.0069420999,
-0.0311486367,
0.0223516021,
-0.0132295508,
-0.0450291187,
-0.0000537802,
0.0438152291,
-0.0164713841,
0.0036366056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09996v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09996v1 | Improving Speech Recognition for African American English With Audio Classification | 2023-09-16T19:57:45 | 2023-09-16T19:57:45 | Shefali Garg, Zhouyuan Huo, Khe Chai Sim, Suzan Schwartz, Mason Chua, Alëna Aksënova, Tsendsuren Munkhdalai, Levi King, Darryl Wright, Zion Mengesha, Dongseong Hwang, Tara Sainath, Françoise Beaufays, Pedro Moreno Mengibar | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems have been shown to have large
quality disparities between the language varieties they are intended or
expected to recognize. One way to mitigate this is to train or fine-tune models
with more representative datasets. But this approach can be hindered by limited
in-domain data for training and evaluation. We propose a new way to improve the
robustness of a US English short-form speech recognizer using a small amount of
out-of-domain (long-form) African American English (AAE) data. We use CORAAL,
YouTube and Mozilla Common Voice to train an audio classifier to approximately
output whether an utterance is AAE or some other variety including Mainstream
American English (MAE). By combining the classifier output with coarse
geographic information, we can select a subset of utterances from a large
corpus of untranscribed short-form queries for semi-supervised learning at
scale. Fine-tuning on this data results in a 38.5% relative word error rate
disparity reduction between AAE and MAE without reducing MAE quality. | [
-0.0111820502,
0.0730563775,
0.0032623224,
0.01788963,
0.0127622597,
0.022733368,
0.0216473136,
-0.0069470564,
-0.0249351133,
-0.07722985,
-0.0682698041,
-0.0454795435,
0.0574603453,
0.0068957959,
-0.0133525329,
-0.035640195,
-0.004075346,
-0.0186277498,
0.0322336257,
-0.0475138351,
0.0131138889,
0.0539508834,
-0.0422352217,
0.0156443734,
-0.0315840021,
0.0127073824,
0.0031355489,
0.0102638463,
-0.025438536,
0.0162718706,
-0.0167660229,
0.0335253663,
-0.0133785037,
0.0011738172,
0.0000017946,
-0.0685170144,
0.015292706,
-0.0002102936,
-0.0352304243,
-0.0094774012,
-0.0065015126,
0.0376447663,
-0.0239158273,
0.0403932743,
-0.0221877266,
-0.0223987717,
0.037469428,
-0.0144637609,
0.0005332791,
0.0466092639,
0.006632579,
-0.0206678621,
0.0199218877,
0.0035611978,
-0.0446586311,
-0.0045706029,
-0.0147396205,
-0.0230253525,
0.034677811,
-0.0737539679,
-0.0238954127,
0.0273259003,
-0.0027394302,
-0.016144542,
0.0006293331,
-0.0080660162,
-0.0723158941,
-0.0054244515,
0.0081556756,
0.0356643684,
0.0112358155,
-0.015586731,
0.0191890392,
0.0366482995,
-0.0131844264,
-0.0117077474,
0.0104765333,
0.0197017882,
0.0061807418,
-0.0208572205,
-0.0354030989,
0.0313562453,
0.0312312264,
-0.0042889994,
-0.0115450053,
0.0223776978,
0.0224017724,
-0.0300980955,
-0.01227454,
-0.0203691684,
0.0182897281,
0.0152357752,
0.0748743713,
-0.0609028526,
-0.0224126279,
-0.0283961594,
0.0251052752,
-0.0259680431,
-0.0364537165,
-0.0315852575,
0.0356523655,
0.0436843298,
-0.0580234192,
-0.0234295987,
0.0064849728,
0.029700648,
0.0397085212,
0.0425541028,
-0.0184448343,
0.0072855507,
-0.0516556986,
0.0255105514,
-0.0084716892,
0.013324677,
-0.0163113289,
0.0256821159,
-0.07308539,
-0.0379831903,
-0.0583729148,
-0.0059680813,
-0.0044941483,
-0.01868698,
-0.0264214668,
0.0002819718,
0.032454405,
0.0111490237,
0.0130398478,
0.0662841871,
0.0012919727,
-0.0870894864,
0.0216449089,
-0.0251393616,
0.0770353526,
0.0001986272,
0.0107081402,
-0.0018193283,
0.0015038676,
-0.0548226349,
-0.0927078351,
0.0253934581,
-0.0466335043,
-0.0379003808,
-0.0435944386,
-0.0719247609,
0.0079661077,
0.0059674317,
0.0456629843,
-0.0250963159,
-0.0478452817,
-0.0379944034,
0.0465939902,
0.0589446016,
0.0262383241,
0.0310154632,
0.0950040147,
-0.0066121914,
0.0564917549,
0.0456227884,
0.032395158,
-0.0312668681,
0.0445459597,
-0.0564023778,
-0.0262892805,
0.0511322282,
-0.0071398728,
0.0215100646,
-0.0304003395,
-0.0250471234,
0.0040790113,
-0.0042768852,
0.0367733054,
0.0340159349,
0.0162624959,
-0.0285194051,
0.0456047803,
0.0711550191,
0.0093125161,
-0.0172669273,
0.0532661378,
0.0683945492,
0.0128440661,
-0.0341165587,
-0.0050442079,
-0.0397210047,
-0.0298712403,
-0.0151208825,
0.0780072436,
0.0779806897,
-0.0549820103,
-0.0076560606,
-0.0257285032,
-0.0443923175,
0.0040329425,
0.0635961071,
0.0334697776,
0.0162411444,
0.0181545224,
0.0139638903,
0.0300980955,
-0.0130520361,
0.0348166488,
-0.0640256181,
0.015406834,
0.0247145277,
-0.0227222759,
0.0027877577,
0.0467495881,
-0.0693084672,
-0.0102910753,
0.021678254,
-0.0035472242,
-0.0148861017,
0.0639477298,
-0.0738303736,
0.0120222401,
0.0719566643,
0.0328399129,
0.0258935411,
-0.0004812184,
0.0455417559,
0.034556739,
-0.0526515208,
-0.0068826168,
-0.0321293399,
0.0175968744,
-0.0312704667,
0.0500033386,
0.0224263631,
0.0923833102,
0.072234489,
-0.0314575024,
-0.0292575583,
-0.0148104755,
0.0014494127,
0.0075328243,
0.0216812138,
-0.0864192843,
0.001758386,
0.0461670086,
-0.0275315121,
0.0074436232,
0.048398491,
0.0481865965,
-0.1105740815,
0.0613033138,
-0.0345206,
0.031150626,
-0.0596855357,
0.0624593981,
0.0207527541,
0.0199842229,
0.0076100309,
-0.0390868075,
0.0108441748,
-0.0248636045,
0.0017479914,
-0.0131981261,
0.0045263041,
-0.0183976851,
-0.0348676741,
0.047550559,
-0.0570476577,
0.0461078323,
0.0012242568,
-0.0175771955,
-0.024331728,
0.024988493,
-0.0365600772,
0.0200752392,
-0.0680053011,
0.0057530357,
-0.0359112509,
0.0584816076,
-0.0413658284,
-0.0352773666,
0.0345323868,
-0.0381159931,
0.0291808322,
0.0109952549,
-0.0755325928,
-0.0180969089,
-0.0045733643,
0.0196991898,
-0.0411384478,
0.0089064986,
0.0063442416,
-0.0625076443,
-0.0182206631,
-0.0220298413,
-0.0015752704,
0.0529718399,
0.0046314816,
0.0294876266,
-0.038529221,
-0.036213778,
0.018888915,
0.0024129197,
-0.0154195577,
-0.0096063009,
-0.0278484467,
0.0288064685,
-0.0192389265,
-0.024049107,
-0.0085808197,
0.0327956751,
-0.0096612005,
-0.0179834571,
-0.0379342735,
-0.0343247876,
0.0307063852,
0.0454459861,
0.0060197446,
-0.0352253802,
-0.0464961119,
-0.0587981157,
-0.0461947098,
0.0114929546,
-0.0203000288,
-0.0390233845,
0.001495249,
-0.0318511315,
-0.0398538969,
0.0334176421,
-0.0535117574,
-0.0316574275,
-0.0430523567,
-0.056374725,
-0.0126904929,
-0.0248217527,
-0.029655084,
0.0204557758,
0.0054323366,
-0.0721447393,
0.0119060725,
-0.013592558,
0.0346641615,
-0.0411639251,
0.0806049332,
-0.0172381867,
0.0051659197,
-0.0056006629,
-0.0454583541,
-0.0106013296,
0.0166168846,
-0.0510515459,
0.0096560111,
0.0049397135,
-0.0163947791,
0.0125848521,
0.0257492866,
0.0082003251,
0.0681803226,
-0.0196137186,
0.0215448774,
0.0126603302,
0.0172562432,
0.0047450089,
0.0303751696,
-0.0460196584,
-0.0217433404,
0.0435216352,
-0.0406702459,
0.0403118543,
-0.0064942436,
-0.0105057806,
-0.0066854712,
0.0568644814,
-0.0120114405,
-0.0112093287,
0.0621830039,
0.0413767919,
-0.0138459867,
0.0026947744,
0.0969890282,
0.0182643533,
-0.0180530157,
-0.0156791657,
-0.0150859421,
0.0164299626,
0.0034923069,
0.0173724107,
-0.0596517622,
-0.0223391037,
0.0276000667,
0.0460380614,
0.0016176652,
0.038498804,
0.0065023932,
-0.1026270166,
0.0285734534,
0.011218599,
0.0102738971,
-0.0250294413,
-0.0394729823,
-0.0189260039,
-0.027019687,
0.0202294495,
-0.0425205044,
-0.0131093096,
-0.0431844033,
0.0562014878,
-0.0624008551,
-0.0901822746,
0.0253768936,
-0.0170884524,
0.0392468721,
0.015786808,
0.0038140845,
-0.0395947099,
-0.0256962273,
0.0130632967,
-0.0428454876,
0.006997643,
-0.0317712128,
0.0067391922,
0.0393402353,
0.0138303908,
0.045974873,
0.0218995623,
0.012409565,
0.0112836203,
0.0329493545,
0.0482169427,
-0.0228061415,
0.0200249031,
0.0091706645,
-0.0068071331,
-0.0072981664,
0.037107531,
0.0579863116,
-0.036385905,
0.003717053,
0.0013544814,
0.0280843973,
-0.0314140208,
-0.0093081836,
0.0446030833,
0.0137635749,
-0.0290448982,
0.0203040317,
-0.0036514476,
-0.0394180231,
0.0408414379,
0.0297610965,
-0.0359712951,
0.0544416867,
0.0209242348,
-0.0298656337,
0.0316405669,
-0.0215716753,
0.0569521189,
-0.0321625583,
-0.0248115622,
0.0184712932,
-0.0636358932,
0.0140082091,
-0.0153036425,
-0.0243769959,
-0.0260581933,
0.0818042085,
-0.0060213921,
0.017297741,
0.06173262,
-0.0353129394,
-0.0601586476,
0.045241043,
0.0099355802,
-0.012585273,
-0.0163021218,
0.0393003002,
-0.0335308127,
-0.0403940603,
0.0118230283,
-0.0467305183,
0.0486684069,
0.0063201794,
-0.0202524606,
-0.0323834755,
-0.0180434734,
-0.0455435365,
0.0096055707,
0.0265718754,
-0.0289683007,
-0.0130790118,
-0.0460470952,
0.0076676109,
0.0257071573,
0.0712459981,
-0.0049801418,
-0.009842786,
0.0161486827,
0.0122237662,
-0.0413540937,
0.0459239855,
-0.0302385669,
-0.0033001252,
-0.0426153392,
0.076951772,
0.0253217574,
-0.0076298984,
0.0169792622,
0.019809179,
-0.0115373172,
0.0776441321,
0.0799332708,
0.0478389971,
0.0135918157,
0.0290094819,
-0.0354914665,
0.0264563169,
-0.0114187011,
0.0205296054,
-0.0345721804,
0.038590271,
-0.0093556773,
0.0584774949,
0.0439485237,
-0.0739668533,
0.0242380369,
0.0292617511,
0.0228462107,
-0.0252840277,
0.0083427159,
0.0453430191,
-0.0231382307,
0.0391963199,
-0.0162868686,
0.0029465989,
0.0256632362,
0.0242142808,
-0.01739184,
0.0064986916,
-0.0126530305,
-0.0057802112,
-0.0399815813,
-0.0424555428,
-0.0059999623,
0.0160003025,
-0.046112597,
-0.0113508543,
-0.0136232339,
-0.0774454325,
0.0303405095,
-0.0381610543,
0.0630336776,
-0.0056986948,
0.0161853097,
-0.0082934499,
-0.0407460965,
0.0008411915,
0.0048345015,
-0.0758078098,
-0.0217597429,
-0.0352051668,
0.0353810191,
-5.829142773e-33,
-0.0034283623,
0.0017714901,
-0.0430717021,
-0.065041706,
0.0013581113,
0.0083073815,
-0.0011301278,
0.0239841435,
0.0027892764,
-0.0102323927,
-0.0488016754,
-0.0010859198,
0.0515496843,
0.0498211011,
0.0136246644,
0.0046934346,
0.0671543628,
-0.0000647743,
0.0029208451,
-0.0048870696,
0.0039234781,
0.0761276409,
-0.0025636493,
-0.0479608737,
-0.0499148928,
0.0271202698,
-0.0265482198,
-0.0267534945,
0.0347653106,
0.0702833682,
-0.0221337657,
0.0814483389,
0.0041626683,
-0.0234632064,
0.003917037,
0.0089901173,
-0.0869680792,
0.0362011418,
-0.0305730812,
0.0513042808,
0.0488095917,
-0.008638192,
0.0019241439,
0.0220849589,
-0.0479834117,
-0.0011913718,
0.0360344499,
-0.0441852957,
0.0226942208,
-0.0206122026,
-0.0088707665,
0.0601559393,
-0.0255913325,
-0.0216471143,
0.0439931937,
0.0212415103,
-0.0286440998,
-0.0522322655,
-0.0007955844,
0.0088188211,
0.0255406685,
0.0226260014,
0.0499963313,
0.0681395754,
-0.0515729561,
0.0021402715,
0.0232672151,
-0.068591617,
0.0295607373,
-0.0806118026,
0.0624048412,
-0.015650183,
-0.0123149585,
0.0666315407,
0.0395478792,
-0.0709647238,
-0.0141605278,
-0.0037590626,
0.004701829,
0.00532634,
-0.0311887134,
0.0098966602,
-0.0720227435,
-0.0329070911,
-0.0312667154,
-0.0096834945,
-0.003012754,
0.0207717773,
0.0539379008,
-0.0079672672,
0.0146602029,
0.0502521433,
0.0475069135,
-0.002578856,
-0.0140086589,
-0.0024984912,
-0.007969087,
-0.0379885286,
-0.0024406097,
0.0143772056,
-0.0551974215,
0.0064149667,
0.0238694157,
0.0343125761,
-0.0096338792,
-0.0075782686,
0.0398938693,
0.0654556081,
-0.0823957622,
0.0281231627,
0.0271653943,
0.0361870937,
0.0001862294,
0.0300502758,
0.0337599665,
0.0370193757,
0.0198491849,
0.0597265549,
0.0044751372,
0.0164467711,
0.0311964564,
-0.0316347964,
-0.0293325856,
0.031030925,
-0.0540213212,
0.0069753784,
0.043712467,
0.0105835628,
-0.0134009346,
-0.0403832905,
0.0144217201,
-0.0365289152,
2.515e-7,
-0.0629936233,
-0.0100263013,
0.0386671424,
-0.0305298381,
0.0067259371,
0.0216720533,
-0.0052228742,
-0.0050891177,
0.0102283843,
0.0305388197,
0.017678678,
-0.0117684091,
0.130728364,
0.0748184919,
-0.0990348011,
-0.0038695235,
-0.0521852486,
0.0357496589,
-0.0296814665,
-0.0034869683,
0.0182244871,
0.0790790096,
-0.0093583018,
-0.0562915988,
-0.0421984158,
-0.0530392714,
-0.0205411799,
-0.0203427225,
0.0063313078,
-0.0202560034,
-0.0073199319,
-0.0006355424,
0.0164664462,
0.002685057,
-0.0714788213,
0.0554966852,
0.0208115317,
0.0259125959,
-0.0182386562,
0.0252456497,
-0.0280758683,
0.0626114309,
-0.040812593,
0.0164141767,
0.04802927,
0.0344737098,
-0.0440965407,
-0.0364177413,
-0.0525509939,
-0.0232741814,
-0.0234796889,
0.0079858359,
0.0241533406,
0.0032954048,
0.005375715,
-0.0362457223,
-0.0105076013,
-0.0653616264,
0.0089151179,
0.0328563899,
-0.0205989145,
0.004506988,
0.0167922694,
0.0399885923,
0.0113368332,
0.0143728964,
0.0270772837,
1.902918839e-34,
0.0221883506,
0.0095246397,
0.0393986031,
-0.0197271463,
-0.005870122,
-0.0271580871,
0.027017286,
-0.0221117996,
0.0189310703,
0.0119636944,
-0.0256473124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09071v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09071v1 | RMDM: A Multilabel Fakenews Dataset for Vietnamese Evidence Verification | 2023-09-16T18:35:08 | 2023-09-16T18:35:08 | Hai-Long Nguyen, Thi-Kieu-Trang Pham, Thai-Son Le, Tan-Minh Nguyen, Thi-Hai-Yen Vuong, Ha-Thanh Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this study, we present a novel and challenging multilabel Vietnamese
dataset (RMDM) designed to assess the performance of large language models
(LLMs), in verifying electronic information related to legal contexts, focusing
on fake news as potential input for electronic evidence. The RMDM dataset
comprises four labels: real, mis, dis, and mal, representing real information,
misinformation, disinformation, and mal-information, respectively. By including
these diverse labels, RMDM captures the complexities of differing fake news
categories and offers insights into the abilities of different language models
to handle various types of information that could be part of electronic
evidence. The dataset consists of a total of 1,556 samples, with 389 samples
for each label. Preliminary tests on the dataset using GPT-based and BERT-based
models reveal variations in the models' performance across different labels,
indicating that the dataset effectively challenges the ability of various
language models to verify the authenticity of such information. Our findings
suggest that verifying electronic information related to legal contexts,
including fake news, remains a difficult problem for language models,
warranting further attention from the research community to advance toward more
reliable AI models for potential legal applications. | [
0.0717555806,
0.0584387071,
-0.0088682212,
0.0449169092,
-0.0667969137,
0.0224638972,
0.0331321135,
0.0415509529,
0.020336194,
-0.0488471352,
0.0033955507,
-0.0397880971,
0.0152501985,
0.0312112588,
0.0161714088,
-0.023346765,
0.0563546121,
0.0133206258,
0.1018903106,
-0.0185602661,
0.0395717174,
0.0278322659,
0.0183242094,
0.0338417739,
-0.0561061576,
-0.0055735675,
0.0000488866,
0.031186955,
0.00904838,
-0.0173413232,
-0.0152124502,
0.0717811137,
0.0108490875,
0.1079112142,
0.0000015662,
-0.0277670883,
-0.0111708511,
0.0032444624,
-0.0434929617,
0.0422450826,
0.0616768785,
-0.0610311553,
-0.0561162494,
0.0062557911,
-0.0202271212,
-0.0491852127,
0.0300161541,
0.0493508652,
0.0871148184,
0.1179131269,
-0.025633242,
-0.0151394187,
0.044541277,
-0.0214639679,
0.019964138,
-0.0184171703,
0.0756667256,
0.0407496616,
0.0149072818,
0.0090356264,
0.0429136455,
0.0223079938,
0.0428157859,
-0.0245494265,
-0.0929481536,
0.0025033767,
-0.0522469208,
-0.0104970438,
0.0124819344,
0.0158314575,
-0.0306186136,
-0.0684730783,
-0.0038714809,
0.0010389553,
0.0208618678,
0.0384143852,
0.0259716399,
0.0727420598,
-0.0419809408,
0.0206398554,
0.0692593306,
-0.0153906904,
0.027864784,
0.0433200821,
0.0124335252,
0.0402957983,
-0.0009782824,
-0.0380731039,
0.0122175887,
-0.0226058736,
-0.019240085,
-0.0693403631,
0.0269256253,
-0.0060931835,
0.0155328345,
0.0338142626,
-0.0593632422,
-0.0185976196,
0.0545266196,
-0.1095454469,
-0.0090075042,
-0.0100047272,
-0.0088726794,
0.034560129,
-0.0121438568,
0.0196008235,
-0.0177351478,
0.0538335927,
-0.0162485447,
-0.0491750687,
-0.0149838189,
0.0018919873,
-0.0201508924,
0.03405362,
-0.008910778,
0.0054164077,
-0.0387352742,
-0.0093989437,
-0.0328830257,
0.033632841,
0.0173328351,
-0.027092047,
-0.014974785,
-0.0391279347,
-0.0263533723,
0.0138336476,
-0.0132149244,
0.0663943663,
0.0120904613,
-0.0371433049,
0.0241596624,
0.0388398096,
-0.0173349399,
-0.0083961133,
0.010972986,
0.021354137,
-0.016004093,
-0.0022128527,
-0.0598895028,
-0.0265458245,
-0.0301630981,
-0.0689168349,
-0.0045833867,
-0.0642524511,
-0.014811188,
-0.0304759573,
0.0119666532,
-0.0479278453,
-0.0132438447,
0.0285376832,
-0.0294666775,
0.0638104305,
-0.0116583174,
-0.001064742,
0.049650304,
0.042480249,
0.0016468125,
0.0325320289,
0.0005549092,
0.0715758204,
0.054268878,
0.0053300569,
0.0439119861,
0.0471459106,
0.0205875896,
0.0340189226,
-0.0213577393,
-0.0064718402,
0.0033338377,
-0.0018051222,
-0.006459489,
0.0490081422,
-0.0144514721,
-0.0294724088,
0.0495391376,
-0.0045952392,
-0.0020900792,
-0.019361956,
0.0249719433,
-0.0168826375,
0.0345219038,
0.0023876056,
-0.0297775511,
-0.0128050046,
-0.0626688823,
0.0039295494,
-0.0117028905,
0.0215735938,
-0.0161616076,
-0.0313567407,
-0.0238486622,
-0.0220951159,
-0.0012500694,
0.0006696991,
0.0010948476,
0.0045027547,
-0.0151491519,
-0.0013126825,
0.0052258647,
-0.006495168,
-0.0381660163,
-0.0740616545,
0.0171637461,
0.0171129797,
0.0399547443,
-0.0054228865,
0.0281809699,
-0.0291082505,
-0.0007521423,
0.0504259802,
0.0197505485,
-0.027784586,
-0.0499189831,
-0.0004896867,
0.0002859329,
0.0133118639,
0.0383039974,
0.0285528265,
0.0340253636,
0.0383693352,
0.0209155623,
-0.0567191355,
-0.0406550243,
0.0197288878,
0.0110498806,
-0.0192597806,
0.005250222,
0.0077866819,
0.0510803051,
0.0446638688,
-0.0289496612,
-0.0285411011,
0.0504886024,
0.015294902,
-0.0150488429,
-0.0548298992,
0.0286462978,
0.0088020526,
0.0356325507,
-0.0309493262,
-0.0130920531,
0.0338428654,
-0.0267571229,
-0.0110618398,
-0.0320214443,
-0.0142491851,
-0.0091052437,
-0.0914299116,
0.0037427342,
-0.019858228,
0.0131189693,
0.0260501988,
0.073482886,
-0.0415607132,
0.0094546266,
0.0081054531,
0.0158025939,
0.0294015817,
0.0112950159,
-0.0226781052,
0.0299870651,
-0.0043731765,
0.0446643494,
0.0125853214,
-0.0008496352,
0.0053995633,
-0.0486863703,
-0.0550673231,
-0.0187306982,
-0.0395270959,
-0.0060238326,
0.021544151,
-0.048995655,
-0.0205230992,
0.0103696641,
-0.0210481547,
-0.0498852208,
0.0413547941,
0.0234244242,
-0.0158444718,
-0.0293263756,
-0.0133174881,
0.0021087916,
0.0022810933,
-0.0137240309,
0.0481949672,
-0.0062049534,
-0.0693443716,
-0.0281787906,
-0.0177403539,
-0.0430012867,
-0.0113745397,
-0.0296715219,
-0.0313533843,
0.0126215518,
0.0086666029,
-0.0208736379,
0.0162649322,
0.0388191119,
0.0415915176,
0.0227619149,
0.0157376099,
-0.0092678862,
-0.0469441675,
0.0035419473,
0.0318122245,
-0.0140175335,
-0.0682765394,
-0.0053737191,
0.0035089778,
0.0174886938,
0.0118756304,
0.0053820559,
0.0162770655,
0.0045176321,
-0.0174058042,
0.0257394668,
-0.0592463911,
-0.0287519656,
0.0132790515,
-0.0022709402,
-0.0413777418,
0.0947212949,
-0.0393818654,
0.0482387729,
-0.0256971493,
-0.0098184859,
0.019046627,
0.0443097353,
-0.0122778984,
0.0276766811,
0.033705879,
-0.0041233762,
0.0465425961,
0.005817689,
0.0578022934,
-0.0492280871,
0.0095656328,
-0.0376406573,
0.0369370282,
0.0124223493,
0.005091093,
-0.0591309294,
-0.0646337792,
0.0024957198,
-0.0027188896,
-0.0254029408,
0.0056942264,
-0.0770605505,
0.0105804121,
0.0165213067,
0.0429003499,
0.0052953959,
0.0198213104,
-0.0036369762,
0.0460527092,
0.0091255568,
-0.0323459096,
0.0126944399,
-0.0173648223,
-0.0188945476,
0.0171715282,
-0.0153479362,
0.0178973917,
0.0111657968,
-0.0143525712,
-0.0149358828,
-0.0056568477,
0.0167559665,
0.006317487,
-0.0334421284,
-0.0382599346,
0.0139121208,
0.0905320197,
0.0290814266,
-0.0239895042,
-0.0266106706,
0.0375812538,
-0.0236242805,
0.0165586006,
0.0023472717,
-0.0977439955,
0.0121577699,
0.0149797359,
-0.0322747491,
-0.0627435222,
-0.0012739754,
-0.0235991385,
-0.0954654217,
0.0529155992,
0.027496729,
-0.0022092948,
-0.0579743013,
-0.0579632148,
-0.0350191295,
0.01913343,
0.0433682874,
-0.0240268763,
0.0500372648,
-0.0557486266,
-0.0122091928,
-0.0067427754,
-0.0575192124,
0.0298802666,
-0.0216217209,
0.08073131,
0.035850767,
0.0152928876,
-0.0413649306,
-0.0741894245,
0.0150959464,
0.0026014529,
-0.0518309399,
0.0149940047,
0.0383353196,
-0.0308593716,
0.015976252,
-0.0156444982,
0.0505988561,
-0.0052505326,
-0.0227278434,
0.0158663746,
0.0626657829,
-0.0036226653,
-0.0673206002,
-0.0114025008,
-0.0329208262,
0.0264773332,
0.0455993749,
0.0048208311,
-0.0016398983,
0.0086067636,
-0.0441659987,
-0.0196144953,
0.020615628,
-0.0174928866,
0.0553035997,
-0.0320672877,
-0.061721161,
-0.0362507291,
-0.0223660264,
-0.0242299121,
0.0433285236,
-0.0027363314,
0.0041001858,
0.0359996371,
-0.031612847,
-0.0332360417,
-0.0055962945,
-0.0438595116,
0.0432293117,
-0.0257567652,
0.0083259381,
-0.0344931372,
0.0075169792,
-0.0008530085,
0.0172934886,
-0.0316998027,
-0.0362772197,
0.0167702213,
-0.0184004717,
0.0267237742,
0.02218071,
-0.0210698545,
-0.0502641313,
0.0317108817,
0.0465511717,
-0.0003514877,
-0.0231704619,
0.0297292117,
-0.0720465556,
0.0052030506,
0.0154291429,
0.010155974,
0.0566450059,
0.0408713408,
-0.0275660604,
-0.0532570966,
0.0037344566,
0.0537432842,
0.0508505404,
0.0347749032,
-0.012480271,
0.0006975274,
-0.0430887192,
-0.0196334831,
-0.0434885211,
-0.0340338312,
0.00469212,
-0.0073703225,
0.0441070274,
-0.022986969,
-0.0242600832,
0.0178436823,
-0.0502355061,
-0.0012239197,
-0.0354260802,
-0.0127761681,
-0.0054874774,
0.1047746316,
-0.0023846747,
-0.0349558368,
-0.0222636517,
0.0172378421,
-0.0073174117,
0.0406575203,
-0.0248397477,
0.0424833,
0.0326777175,
-0.0236490536,
0.0325684622,
-0.000795992,
-0.019812908,
0.0274040326,
-0.0559751391,
0.0464700907,
0.0472545363,
0.0074112513,
0.0003629168,
-0.0518657118,
-0.0069627212,
-0.0346134678,
-0.0076359697,
0.0087642279,
-0.0430301502,
-0.0094893984,
0.0238306783,
-0.041826386,
0.0694282055,
0.0694809705,
0.0088127078,
0.0287097525,
0.0023221842,
-0.0615828335,
-0.020515874,
-0.0228879824,
-0.0095598875,
0.0224938989,
-0.0416767858,
-0.0396935381,
-0.0717491284,
-0.0616110526,
-0.0146064442,
0.0463631153,
0.0364989191,
0.0510449558,
-0.0564469062,
0.0849981904,
0.0244279504,
0.0305482764,
-0.0463865064,
-0.0033773319,
0.0046837996,
-0.0258796141,
0.0269878041,
-5.276023825e-33,
0.0065383213,
-0.0582966432,
-0.0164019354,
-0.0097470097,
0.0208228845,
0.0577086732,
-0.018409634,
0.0057611316,
-0.0320447721,
0.037357416,
0.0001950055,
0.0366129354,
0.0210486855,
-0.0079268282,
-0.0264505986,
0.0180121921,
0.0105853043,
0.0142428856,
-0.0174037442,
-0.0144226942,
0.0252602044,
-0.025779618,
0.033744622,
-0.0908506066,
0.095600605,
0.0029686536,
-0.0750545263,
-0.0178714581,
-0.0565262251,
0.0649468228,
-0.0191064961,
0.0547013059,
0.0279344432,
-0.0312948972,
-0.0004470303,
0.0113448501,
-0.0552791953,
0.0075360001,
0.0236517135,
-0.0045814118,
0.0089572975,
-0.0196453128,
0.0246116761,
-0.0077214101,
-0.0393988416,
0.044597175,
0.0039732447,
-0.0414398573,
-0.0205250774,
-0.0119453277,
-0.046559263,
0.0408830941,
0.0401933491,
0.0130178602,
0.0060226931,
0.0162302982,
-0.0089080008,
0.0101081952,
-0.1073602438,
0.009722529,
-0.0115942433,
-0.0110966833,
0.0305690058,
-0.0664138123,
-0.0384800285,
0.0461583473,
0.0231750719,
0.0101786926,
-0.0203831401,
-0.0256701075,
0.0265364107,
0.0290577598,
0.0690884069,
0.0988966376,
0.0491281599,
-0.0889663845,
-0.0745275319,
0.0161651075,
0.0262735449,
-0.0301696826,
0.0125666894,
-0.0305220857,
-0.0597679801,
0.0041538333,
-0.0179070607,
-0.0228936393,
-0.0333730467,
-0.0045900769,
0.0048935148,
0.0342880674,
-0.0056489944,
0.0228512287,
0.0219585598,
-0.0509605668,
-0.004211606,
0.0003128351,
-0.033799164,
0.0291387327,
-0.001203152,
0.066491954,
-0.0499718525,
-0.0030907239,
0.0440506749,
-0.0101400837,
-0.0184294172,
-0.0130356038,
0.081983611,
0.0129532339,
-0.0685155094,
0.0221387241,
0.008088992,
0.0228100959,
0.0256955642,
-0.0286486819,
0.0235045105,
0.0102962963,
0.0205391068,
-0.0063999034,
-0.0052846977,
-0.0239769779,
-0.0358616598,
0.0120529216,
-0.0247379672,
0.0110095674,
-0.0033477272,
0.0130918259,
-0.0351963751,
0.0070951497,
0.0263472013,
-0.0158398673,
0.0186146013,
0.0330894515,
2.364e-7,
0.0261785109,
0.0379099697,
0.0307180993,
0.0190810915,
0.0006799735,
0.0416428857,
0.0054092659,
0.0106201274,
-0.013444406,
-0.0935548469,
0.0003148663,
-0.0081075858,
0.0685938895,
0.0555134304,
-0.0402696617,
0.000674368,
-0.0566893145,
-0.0224997401,
-0.0812186748,
0.0230698157,
0.0206752419,
0.0942353979,
0.0305852517,
-0.0322133787,
-0.0068802452,
-0.0204632338,
0.0324884132,
0.0299683418,
-0.0310126189,
-0.0049694842,
0.0914441049,
-0.0369812846,
0.0243240055,
0.0498566143,
-0.010997748,
0.0079623098,
-0.0126034934,
0.046188958,
-0.003697942,
0.0194385368,
-0.0440391339,
-0.0643648505,
0.0047993106,
-0.0721808076,
0.0680053532,
0.0373481736,
-0.0055170245,
-0.0266804118,
-0.0480486527,
0.0030045104,
0.035240382,
-0.0072771185,
-0.0358614177,
0.0336984135,
0.0178142842,
0.0178112425,
0.0058642314,
-0.0206628833,
-0.0114886835,
0.0079157837,
-0.0374021158,
0.0203437433,
0.0020831861,
-0.0298629217,
0.0616729707,
-0.0786910132,
0.0622903034,
2.041403668e-34,
0.0409119166,
-0.0376431122,
-0.0145880049,
-0.0225692168,
0.0757899657,
0.0196290966,
-0.0560339168,
-0.0106582725,
-0.0414134301,
-0.0340039581,
0.0064911931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09070v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09070v1 | NOWJ1@ALQAC 2023: Enhancing Legal Task Performance with Classic Statistical Models and Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-09-16T18:32:15 | 2023-09-16T18:32:15 | Tan-Minh Nguyen, Xuan-Hoa Nguyen, Ngoc-Duy Mai, Minh-Quan Hoang, Van-Huan Nguyen, Hoang-Viet Nguyen, Ha-Thanh Nguyen, Thi-Hai-Yen Vuong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper describes the NOWJ1 Team's approach for the Automated Legal
Question Answering Competition (ALQAC) 2023, which focuses on enhancing legal
task performance by integrating classical statistical models and Pre-trained
Language Models (PLMs). For the document retrieval task, we implement a
pre-processing step to overcome input limitations and apply learning-to-rank
methods to consolidate features from various models. The question-answering
task is split into two sub-tasks: sentence classification and answer
extraction. We incorporate state-of-the-art models to develop distinct systems
for each sub-task, utilizing both classic statistical models and pre-trained
Language Models. Experimental results demonstrate the promising potential of
our proposed methodology in the competition. | [
0.0745877698,
0.0555817708,
0.0082564708,
0.020919716,
-0.0351203158,
0.0288179591,
0.01558886,
0.0213612244,
0.0045704516,
-0.1155819669,
-0.0248174388,
-0.0018103264,
-0.0297311973,
0.0002056051,
-0.0056640222,
-0.0238445662,
0.0381675698,
-0.0129243135,
0.0526099093,
-0.0029625152,
0.0216995887,
0.0220148191,
0.0212978236,
0.0065091979,
0.0110351006,
0.0037764749,
0.0115458192,
-0.0071053118,
0.0131355627,
0.0221795272,
0.0356740803,
0.0697556883,
0.0197342578,
0.0003162011,
0.0000015073,
-0.0651036352,
0.0045054792,
-0.0015436345,
-0.0429551229,
-0.0009547859,
0.0078644408,
0.0080631254,
0.0206540506,
0.0352326669,
-0.0630885288,
0.0121063152,
-0.0139074139,
0.0202761423,
0.0682649389,
0.0689608157,
0.0064010485,
-0.0380286165,
0.0542402454,
-0.0388425551,
0.0076247309,
-0.0601047687,
0.0306805987,
0.0209548716,
0.0313142352,
0.0179024357,
0.0365934856,
0.0156080546,
0.0174984578,
-0.0111704729,
-0.0065308246,
-0.0090954704,
-0.0507774018,
0.0407076105,
-0.0110446047,
0.0694463551,
-0.0152393663,
-0.0414264575,
-0.0032372624,
0.0026676266,
0.0325661898,
0.0116860094,
-0.0414703414,
0.0613134503,
0.0090243081,
0.0012631482,
0.0323082469,
0.0294624045,
-0.023850657,
0.0405640341,
-0.0005837115,
0.061928235,
0.0204973761,
-0.0504209287,
0.033945404,
0.0112175485,
-0.007577186,
-0.0333181731,
0.032089442,
0.0573359765,
0.012737466,
0.0126135778,
-0.023917079,
-0.0670777559,
0.0602568239,
-0.0819971636,
0.0247643124,
0.0010268195,
-0.0062660775,
0.1175448671,
-0.0657936484,
0.0348110348,
0.0438910276,
0.0101019135,
-0.0556285717,
-0.0366554782,
-0.0205198564,
-0.0395342931,
-0.0354444124,
0.0760215744,
-0.0869316533,
-0.012558531,
-0.0011346078,
0.0043476536,
0.0209722556,
-0.0133416634,
0.0374568179,
0.0184221771,
-0.013970077,
-0.0163324736,
-0.0430571884,
-0.0327909291,
-0.0252465438,
0.0550814234,
-0.0263034441,
-0.0148787387,
-0.0164125524,
-0.0115016997,
0.0126635674,
-0.0169681981,
0.0475114621,
0.0522865616,
-0.0297067948,
-0.0455541834,
0.0090306615,
-0.0217993632,
0.0055497191,
-0.074728176,
-0.0412332341,
-0.0378021635,
0.0473901778,
-0.0046159672,
-0.0448547117,
-0.010258846,
0.0220439751,
0.0675621852,
-0.0337008461,
0.0709828362,
0.0394818299,
-0.0107690506,
0.0195500106,
0.0135802757,
0.0433518402,
0.0230848379,
-0.0023613488,
0.009346799,
0.0380678028,
-0.001904683,
0.0462996811,
0.0431475304,
0.0110847848,
-0.0050811409,
0.0240383297,
0.0407384858,
0.003077602,
-0.0073440708,
0.0016394213,
0.0325728729,
0.006731539,
-0.0350819081,
0.0316525884,
0.0731737614,
0.0202436298,
0.0306541901,
-0.0047668754,
-0.0177905727,
0.0400396958,
-0.030435171,
-0.0288654119,
0.0016724163,
-0.073651284,
0.023091089,
-0.0299170837,
0.0316266045,
-0.0407170802,
-0.0532075353,
-0.0029705013,
-0.0069277394,
-0.0108050639,
0.0510646142,
0.0386329032,
0.004306857,
-0.0459346175,
0.025247477,
-0.006968047,
-0.0507942662,
-0.0277697239,
-0.0482154898,
0.0245210864,
0.0159147885,
0.0249410942,
-0.073424831,
0.0065218126,
-0.0250829253,
0.0037947327,
0.0272166766,
0.0335310474,
-0.0182971545,
0.0180112068,
-0.0184930563,
-0.0388623811,
0.0061785947,
0.0077174557,
-0.0068831602,
0.0112316785,
0.0152888214,
0.0568674169,
-0.0574688725,
-0.0179259684,
0.0444728956,
-0.0189455189,
-0.0531274937,
0.0232736152,
-0.0202544462,
0.0237579662,
0.0140910577,
-0.0126861846,
0.0139232017,
0.045276586,
-0.0253073797,
0.0096976776,
-0.0279950704,
0.0039312565,
-0.0654193908,
0.0503450595,
0.0122317486,
0.0161819831,
0.0545992367,
-0.0550851636,
-0.0143828224,
-0.0432408117,
-0.0002171031,
-0.0090438388,
-0.0757302418,
-0.0099855233,
0.0188599043,
-0.0000980599,
-0.083130084,
0.0619733147,
0.0159070175,
0.002952781,
0.0084533216,
-0.0297089349,
0.0240591746,
-0.037428204,
-0.0167978201,
-0.0324080586,
-0.0369871855,
0.0294894129,
0.0280976109,
0.0180474445,
-0.0411737598,
-0.0277706962,
-0.0937066302,
0.0122566335,
-0.0246633571,
0.010565972,
0.0023297872,
-0.0272072535,
-0.0228145942,
-0.0441465825,
-0.0551624335,
-0.0315833576,
0.0439749844,
-0.0088475021,
0.0218058918,
-0.0133561539,
0.0135906385,
-0.066180639,
-0.0447613448,
-0.0000465089,
0.0551828705,
0.00688755,
-0.0060033035,
-0.011191179,
0.0710121021,
-0.0382614098,
0.0137676112,
-0.011757616,
0.0091002416,
-0.0334565975,
-0.0354610011,
-0.0112259118,
0.0725481808,
0.0368155055,
-0.0030807324,
-0.0002165594,
0.0127429087,
-0.0751410052,
0.0099796271,
-0.011626713,
0.0054851486,
-0.0077065257,
0.0046000672,
0.0349632427,
0.0380305126,
-0.0041104364,
-0.0302929841,
0.0040967176,
0.0232359264,
0.0135674691,
-0.019282544,
-0.0609443039,
-0.0003209388,
-0.013549584,
0.0161554348,
-0.005018766,
-0.0629109889,
0.0551308207,
-0.012070355,
0.020318659,
-0.0776261762,
-0.0074625676,
-0.0495879799,
0.0798379928,
0.0199063886,
0.0261349659,
-0.0403185673,
-0.01637589,
-0.0161587074,
-0.0134442514,
0.0324201658,
-0.0799743012,
0.0302580763,
-0.0105366353,
0.0493767262,
-0.0506437719,
-0.0574398041,
-0.0366629772,
-0.0939383581,
-0.0197429527,
0.0403101109,
-0.0358524956,
0.0306694154,
-0.01150975,
0.0182403754,
-0.0216228515,
0.0200735386,
-0.0101800961,
-0.0069469735,
-0.019263709,
0.0753360838,
0.0552607402,
0.0181174502,
-0.0074350471,
0.0081652487,
0.0125034712,
0.0349411704,
0.0247354917,
0.0022813131,
0.0184946842,
-0.0016684089,
0.0503009371,
-0.083736673,
-0.0090652658,
0.0143180145,
-0.0119530791,
-0.0430283435,
0.032990545,
0.1153807715,
0.0436065756,
0.0109575577,
-0.0397576243,
0.0018534196,
-0.0006389343,
0.0367660783,
0.0670584738,
-0.0762220994,
-0.0108542182,
-0.0218098219,
0.0060035149,
-0.027879905,
0.0020505039,
-0.0155435903,
-0.1100090742,
0.0637319162,
-0.0103575215,
-0.0207940973,
-0.0234011263,
-0.0195436832,
0.0079706386,
0.0003321234,
-0.0023845492,
0.0221117958,
-0.0393453278,
0.0068052756,
0.0081751607,
-0.0268938374,
0.020168636,
0.028056819,
-0.0272343438,
0.0317850783,
0.0543607473,
0.0101513071,
-0.0335373878,
-0.030996317,
0.022780776,
-0.0466362126,
0.0018263358,
-0.0081985444,
0.0379606523,
-0.0267079286,
0.0186047312,
-0.0390762202,
0.0381914973,
-0.0203672331,
-0.0131168617,
0.0243233554,
0.0397056229,
-0.0259685516,
-0.0126151228,
-0.026091015,
0.0122884596,
-0.0299122706,
0.0913068429,
-0.0018807832,
-0.0126431324,
-0.0565758161,
-0.0303198043,
-0.0100504747,
-0.0421315767,
-0.0375459455,
-0.0160547663,
0.0074651409,
0.0412316695,
-0.0465523601,
-0.0425605439,
0.0194633715,
0.0301618446,
-0.0100172134,
0.0373804718,
-0.0340733603,
-0.0007606281,
-0.0445688553,
0.0251823608,
-0.0171808191,
0.0085482243,
-0.0141288796,
0.0122526158,
0.0382862166,
-0.0261649545,
-0.0479076095,
-0.0268458594,
-0.0315694697,
-0.0243130773,
-0.0128934989,
0.0562935024,
0.0150820231,
-0.0160590019,
-0.0337090082,
-0.0523334369,
0.0840086192,
-0.0026168965,
-0.021377923,
0.00320186,
0.0572597273,
-0.0309850555,
-0.0304622632,
-0.0003355708,
-0.0446359105,
0.0260105506,
0.0421707965,
0.0285837408,
-0.0294613112,
-0.0580093563,
0.0273663569,
0.037803784,
0.0422829911,
0.0317676216,
-0.0213706922,
-0.0298171397,
0.0188922696,
-0.0277273282,
-0.0249796882,
-0.0392457619,
0.0087726945,
0.0206780676,
-0.0102883046,
-0.0231838394,
0.0609155931,
-0.0140366321,
0.0346407518,
-0.0435988046,
-0.0117668174,
0.0350299142,
-0.004411961,
-0.024265442,
-0.0284081176,
-0.0139830559,
0.0159093365,
0.0049136844,
0.0498479865,
-0.002171407,
0.0593572706,
-0.0009469095,
-0.0149530703,
-0.0272001959,
0.0454909801,
-0.0696555153,
-0.0576592274,
-0.0498525202,
0.0366928726,
0.0504088216,
-0.0134777566,
-0.0042702667,
-0.0072528087,
-0.0355614834,
-0.0131909577,
-0.018208636,
0.0326112397,
0.0123426998,
0.0459290221,
0.0227947775,
-0.0122654326,
0.0345995426,
0.061696697,
0.0337334722,
-0.002439328,
0.0032754734,
-0.0305512846,
-0.0278833341,
-0.0172377005,
0.0034695782,
0.024926668,
-0.0154077401,
-0.0122790048,
-0.036319118,
-0.0297605135,
-0.0044212551,
0.0064137876,
-0.0415231772,
0.0236290563,
0.0387008116,
0.0677670762,
0.0230325907,
-0.0232428648,
-0.0658859834,
0.0187385119,
-0.0011257718,
-0.0325863957,
0.0003347864,
-5.784758678e-33,
-0.0209043641,
-0.0222277623,
0.0018676566,
0.0147482688,
-0.0076070232,
-0.000075198,
0.0033563981,
0.0001561,
-0.034896031,
-0.0031513362,
-0.018809652,
0.0269241426,
0.013136535,
0.031453602,
-0.0027965901,
-0.0539108068,
0.0001011033,
-0.0184627231,
-0.0063184854,
-0.0142175034,
-0.0201496519,
0.0380580872,
0.0084059406,
-0.0406442992,
0.0212734286,
0.0189807974,
0.0089919111,
0.0066615562,
-0.0408044942,
0.0642569959,
-0.011210436,
0.0353329256,
0.0476279147,
-0.0694095492,
0.00112192,
0.0815813541,
-0.10595119,
-0.0110292584,
0.0157909766,
-0.0409814194,
-0.0199538209,
-0.0071321158,
0.010436425,
0.0006961095,
0.0078022135,
-0.0364667363,
0.0504511558,
-0.0438703597,
-0.0130144767,
-0.0809105188,
-0.0463015214,
0.0214322265,
-0.0199438725,
0.0120876348,
0.0338144042,
0.030630419,
0.0124647152,
0.052995462,
-0.0404540896,
-0.0062857387,
-0.0109427813,
0.0163097773,
0.0359126478,
-0.0037657863,
-0.0331767127,
0.0276293717,
-0.0300536696,
-0.0378235653,
-0.0458838567,
-0.017883826,
0.0008566265,
0.0676690415,
0.0568979532,
0.0190478899,
0.0213613026,
0.0097307656,
-0.0928196236,
0.0440201275,
0.0615047589,
0.0162017439,
-0.0094355764,
-0.0324840583,
-0.03652367,
-0.0105190119,
-0.045862224,
-0.0025326596,
-0.0152762821,
0.0019615702,
0.0462871417,
0.0256483313,
0.0204732977,
-0.0098718191,
0.0188443586,
-0.0523695797,
0.0108965896,
0.0379677415,
0.0014926079,
-0.0026259113,
-0.0046417057,
0.0521177799,
-0.047257863,
0.0193938967,
0.00933001,
-0.0218553711,
-0.020262599,
-0.02523176,
0.0164062679,
-0.0144848824,
-0.0589284785,
0.0106477775,
0.0306942407,
0.0206219256,
0.0107548656,
0.0596992299,
-0.0189782754,
0.0411715582,
0.0311732683,
0.0480440818,
0.0053403503,
-0.0108386539,
-0.0310256537,
-0.029205611,
0.0337281488,
-0.0076045352,
0.0106990701,
0.0414998382,
-0.0013396315,
0.0459879003,
0.0045287749,
-0.0116945729,
0.0198520645,
0.0470140129,
2.232e-7,
0.1209908277,
0.0086045917,
-0.0174987223,
-0.0035011289,
-0.0192515813,
0.0222031791,
0.0302128606,
0.0496733449,
0.0385374576,
0.0006906831,
0.0159909111,
0.0334065929,
0.0525338501,
0.0137552451,
-0.0676723123,
-0.0492116623,
-0.0540767573,
-0.0415838882,
-0.0615803637,
-0.0049130432,
0.0798570886,
0.1023051292,
-0.0056937132,
-0.028914297,
-0.0404430702,
-0.0614152513,
0.0627033785,
-0.0053614494,
-0.0174280554,
0.0105288522,
0.0748648271,
-0.0333059765,
0.0135254934,
0.0471208803,
-0.0336539149,
0.066302456,
0.0229024384,
0.0668931082,
-0.0141246896,
-0.0315084457,
-0.0298630539,
-0.0105945971,
0.0402361639,
-0.0388644002,
0.1201006621,
-0.0154653788,
0.0152083253,
-0.0173481572,
-0.0359246694,
-0.0227554198,
0.0163358375,
-0.016860513,
-0.0240019802,
-0.0082157515,
0.0464245379,
-0.017073663,
0.0166494586,
-0.1086165085,
-0.0040656431,
0.033553239,
-0.0377798676,
-0.0139721083,
0.000675168,
-0.015135292,
0.0384752266,
-0.0634247512,
0.0126253478,
2.016776602e-34,
0.027016677,
0.0154817887,
0.0246562921,
0.0578457154,
0.0058073574,
0.0211529322,
-0.0470375456,
-0.0018001194,
0.0159284007,
-0.1094851643,
0.0201703906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09069v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09069v1 | Constructing a Knowledge Graph for Vietnamese Legal Cases with Heterogeneous Graphs | 2023-09-16T18:31:47 | 2023-09-16T18:31:47 | Thi-Hai-Yen Vuong, Minh-Quan Hoang, Tan-Minh Nguyen, Hoang-Trung Nguyen, Ha-Thanh Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents a knowledge graph construction method for legal case
documents and related laws, aiming to organize legal information efficiently
and enhance various downstream tasks. Our approach consists of three main
steps: data crawling, information extraction, and knowledge graph deployment.
First, the data crawler collects a large corpus of legal case documents and
related laws from various sources, providing a rich database for further
processing. Next, the information extraction step employs natural language
processing techniques to extract entities such as courts, cases, domains, and
laws, as well as their relationships from the unstructured text. Finally, the
knowledge graph is deployed, connecting these entities based on their extracted
relationships, creating a heterogeneous graph that effectively represents legal
information and caters to users such as lawyers, judges, and scholars. The
established baseline model leverages unsupervised learning methods, and by
incorporating the knowledge graph, it demonstrates the ability to identify
relevant laws for a given legal case. This approach opens up opportunities for
various applications in the legal domain, such as legal case analysis, legal
recommendation, and decision support. | [
0.0708036795,
0.0108549036,
-0.0175258331,
0.0128022842,
-0.0653631985,
-0.0023471245,
0.0018031121,
0.0402618684,
0.0756435767,
-0.0587875769,
0.0104185594,
0.0333711468,
-0.016305849,
0.0057146675,
-0.0198591948,
-0.030825071,
0.0091504874,
0.0349356979,
0.0929240659,
0.0010310158,
0.0100621851,
0.0092497319,
-0.0017278702,
-0.003862631,
0.0064563905,
0.0084750531,
-0.0473833531,
0.0094582876,
-0.0340504795,
-0.0277574323,
-0.0274424292,
0.0419260748,
-0.0163958501,
-0.0078588324,
0.0000017491,
-0.0583070144,
-0.0227745697,
-0.0162073355,
0.0143437926,
-0.0116424942,
0.0410168916,
-0.0435256958,
-0.0256880075,
-0.011554718,
-0.0609583482,
-0.0195081159,
-0.0057408274,
0.010219845,
0.0263530109,
0.0798714608,
-0.0266596749,
-0.0375676304,
0.0066269953,
-0.0254126452,
-0.0032685201,
-0.0368121527,
0.0271580368,
0.0684640929,
0.0536061488,
-0.0411494635,
-0.016093079,
-0.0114690363,
-0.016253598,
-0.0488923304,
0.0155624626,
-0.0173513815,
-0.0162953511,
0.008084543,
0.0212993678,
0.0544104092,
0.0509013161,
-0.0261899401,
0.0310158841,
0.0048019094,
0.0581491403,
0.0582600012,
-0.0172115918,
0.0593319684,
-0.0595988445,
0.0203508418,
0.0146377236,
-0.0136566162,
-0.0101262862,
-0.001323549,
-0.0234776251,
0.0403970666,
-0.0295264013,
-0.0279598832,
0.0205970686,
-0.0187468734,
0.0586388446,
-0.0393371135,
0.052314505,
0.0442745723,
0.0086769927,
0.0449664593,
-0.0065373704,
-0.0363979153,
0.0640962869,
-0.0743454322,
-0.0171555635,
-0.0227479264,
0.0094360188,
0.0703447312,
-0.0192346014,
-0.0442049988,
-0.0021457514,
0.0001991249,
-0.0103512118,
-0.0344480835,
-0.0663241073,
0.0030794276,
-0.0219077673,
0.0647204295,
-0.0960109681,
0.0148737822,
-0.00594967,
0.0384063013,
-0.0305779055,
0.0158220809,
0.0383460037,
0.0051463498,
-0.0039963508,
-0.0254268795,
-0.0673234835,
-0.0483746342,
-0.035999991,
0.0465062223,
-0.0053989654,
0.020803703,
0.0366699211,
-0.0024567023,
0.0771344826,
0.0127917668,
0.0073286244,
0.0985762849,
0.0026721803,
0.0048819729,
-0.0683090016,
-0.0703760535,
0.0075551076,
-0.0327378996,
-0.0140842479,
-0.0874013677,
0.0167869106,
-0.0167728029,
-0.0271224715,
-0.0423344895,
0.0291154198,
0.016343493,
-0.0410430804,
0.0341784358,
-0.049237486,
-0.0065665916,
-0.0304899458,
0.0246302504,
0.0272831451,
-0.0222507417,
0.0057549677,
0.0237885844,
0.0568841137,
-0.0150649371,
0.008828897,
-0.0189332124,
0.002223209,
-0.0111068375,
0.0587452054,
0.0249750875,
-0.0463587642,
-0.0217129774,
-0.0088429851,
0.0162019003,
0.009936505,
0.0183825046,
-0.0244078562,
0.0506700575,
0.0081420988,
0.052463226,
0.0001146462,
0.0221786182,
0.0312147457,
-0.0058119562,
-0.0265847612,
0.0013853533,
-0.0387906842,
0.024075577,
-0.0830200613,
0.0249869879,
-0.006000584,
-0.0543753095,
0.0125990985,
-0.0016293827,
0.0442446396,
-0.0174840074,
0.0536576696,
0.0357290506,
-0.0118182702,
-0.0040911548,
0.0272544008,
-0.0288677458,
-0.0304051973,
0.010912437,
-0.0152301807,
0.0488668904,
0.0323755555,
-0.0323617645,
-0.0129593937,
0.0241508018,
-0.0223172456,
0.0194698181,
0.018417947,
-0.0220477842,
-0.0354729928,
-0.0192159526,
-0.0625250414,
0.0640800968,
0.0103361728,
0.0110952854,
0.0264999643,
0.0373482816,
0.0333012193,
-0.0890638307,
0.0069008302,
0.0160112064,
0.0202596895,
-0.0003374525,
0.0243365373,
0.0086715706,
0.0328111947,
0.0448084138,
0.0054302099,
-0.0202546343,
0.0491690338,
0.0162096657,
-0.0175002366,
0.0132851833,
0.0407497175,
-0.005084937,
0.0375983194,
-0.0762576014,
0.0099916197,
-0.0211607646,
-0.0375410616,
-0.0406559743,
-0.0222210158,
0.0283946674,
0.0291160028,
-0.0270371716,
-0.0133776767,
-0.0049152514,
-0.0213386994,
-0.0107582361,
0.0564283542,
0.009761231,
-0.0363184288,
-0.0019148479,
-0.0333571136,
0.035529118,
0.0031695738,
-0.0001501116,
-0.0191018339,
-0.0282499716,
0.006268735,
0.0268220305,
-0.0010153833,
-0.0482953861,
0.0003813948,
-0.0632726997,
0.0287115108,
0.0004180865,
0.0202986002,
0.0039947578,
-0.0122708902,
-0.0171468537,
-0.0359271131,
-0.0207524672,
0.0244837292,
-0.0008942619,
-0.0539274961,
0.017632015,
-0.0088228891,
0.0105330162,
-0.013880183,
-0.0336774252,
-0.0246975981,
0.0011143441,
0.0402266458,
-0.0804973915,
0.0166537445,
0.0739634335,
-0.0501190946,
-0.0046911906,
-0.019418966,
0.0084169609,
-0.0389519632,
0.0233022422,
-0.0395179763,
0.0063574114,
0.0123273749,
0.0378903486,
0.0205160398,
-0.0174639616,
-0.0116560627,
-0.0133984275,
-0.0212630052,
0.053363394,
-0.0323205292,
0.0205788687,
0.0461133756,
-0.0633021966,
0.0386055075,
0.0066712359,
0.0067305714,
-0.024615204,
-0.0030252896,
0.0290993266,
-0.0302249193,
-0.0049788393,
0.0044271192,
0.0267755669,
0.0266490635,
-0.0426100753,
0.0536113344,
0.053156238,
0.0997605771,
-0.0413964018,
-0.0231410228,
-0.0378998592,
0.0944389403,
0.0297881756,
0.0147608565,
-0.0117908968,
-0.0528780557,
0.0393523872,
0.015072831,
0.0801410824,
-0.0425090119,
0.0494426675,
-0.0146139478,
0.0290763304,
-0.0057455711,
-0.0275800973,
-0.0195217822,
0.0071663554,
0.0090672858,
0.0312002357,
0.0284621101,
0.0246563721,
0.018223213,
0.0084398361,
-0.0294423103,
-0.0228786618,
0.0364083499,
-0.026340181,
-0.0346528217,
0.0750659257,
-0.0081460197,
-0.0518690422,
-0.0102670537,
0.0378093645,
-0.0078766188,
0.0221566092,
-0.0159622021,
-0.0262197498,
0.0379739068,
-0.005469501,
-0.0276242606,
-0.0662402734,
0.008093141,
0.0131955389,
-0.0385592058,
-0.0429386087,
0.0701581761,
0.0643337294,
0.0425902195,
-0.0352972448,
-0.0171402302,
0.0116979945,
-0.0345177241,
0.0380986296,
0.0319226198,
-0.1130143031,
0.0497852676,
-0.0079736756,
-0.0232217293,
-0.0343181677,
-0.0411974303,
-0.0047294009,
-0.0830251053,
0.0543598123,
0.0262295585,
0.00381784,
-0.0504860952,
-0.0192200504,
-0.0104382513,
-0.0095513333,
-0.0466788858,
-0.0042540482,
-0.0383872651,
-0.0261685196,
0.0020024613,
-0.0624258332,
0.0006483778,
0.014991737,
-0.0496720448,
0.0220132153,
-0.0184003226,
0.0338397361,
-0.0201162659,
0.0286764093,
-0.0095230592,
0.0131516214,
0.0046158982,
-0.0098167099,
0.0090517569,
0.0099287871,
0.0366601236,
-0.067853801,
0.0281696096,
-0.0270442553,
-0.0053150682,
0.0710094571,
0.0789487064,
-0.048023209,
-0.0160246659,
-0.0013960493,
-0.0614798851,
-0.0202587862,
0.0263152104,
-0.0338224508,
0.0272817798,
-0.0272598267,
-0.0331129543,
-0.0252557006,
-0.0121027483,
-0.0115239685,
0.01029546,
-0.0684692636,
0.0026066529,
-0.0536527112,
-0.0081135835,
-0.0060930597,
0.0444795229,
0.0357420295,
0.0151344975,
0.0970102176,
-0.0091897398,
-0.0722895116,
-0.011478411,
-0.0287624393,
-0.0206709933,
0.0392103232,
-0.0112446053,
-0.0144126602,
0.0104925623,
-0.0001819133,
-0.032630723,
0.0638332739,
-0.0099563254,
-0.0248217564,
-0.0419558175,
0.0116627458,
0.0418415517,
-0.03889158,
0.0071107564,
0.0500532091,
0.0582068302,
-0.0280906092,
-0.0722936168,
0.0413864218,
-0.0581475608,
-0.016675137,
0.0004814345,
-0.0251384024,
0.0139220627,
-0.0007760398,
0.0064959931,
-0.0361982957,
0.0070094187,
0.0387470312,
0.0591196157,
0.0037501224,
0.0221192352,
-0.0159234609,
-0.0510294214,
0.0102704866,
-0.0321457833,
-0.0155344,
-0.0049844384,
0.0014145398,
-0.0131310755,
0.0028433504,
-0.0027449252,
0.0576909557,
0.0193918534,
-0.0068652602,
-0.034574043,
0.0251743756,
0.0269010942,
-0.0021473211,
-0.0149919214,
-0.0356760621,
0.0270789862,
-0.0082646683,
-0.0069055837,
0.0272279177,
-0.0285641141,
0.0274458025,
-0.005874956,
-0.02636737,
-0.012257874,
0.0082482854,
-0.0145452991,
0.0017054037,
-0.017882606,
0.0279775467,
0.0664587617,
0.0026011299,
-0.0250941683,
-0.0727045909,
0.0050181537,
0.0142967952,
0.0448182188,
-0.007318256,
-0.0319047123,
0.0060842102,
0.0192071702,
-0.0211138278,
0.022812264,
0.0498814359,
0.0003908297,
0.0041675549,
0.0123822186,
-0.0492926389,
-0.0243784003,
-0.0279306509,
0.0260919631,
0.0605314188,
-0.0365506224,
-0.0707673207,
-0.0513037145,
-0.0187253449,
-0.0431057662,
0.0278011076,
0.0057179751,
0.0315918215,
0.0380626619,
0.0470286012,
0.0529363155,
-0.0052638953,
-0.0573479906,
0.0517040715,
-0.0683873072,
0.0314164236,
0.0503268018,
-5.407160872e-33,
-0.0314139053,
-0.0808730498,
0.0173251592,
0.0564264096,
0.0053974078,
-0.0403542966,
-0.0231739487,
0.0078382539,
-0.0438534506,
0.0388202481,
-0.0098149721,
0.0417326577,
0.0220365636,
-0.0243013427,
0.0297433212,
0.0129030161,
-0.0091658961,
0.036038205,
0.024032183,
-0.0052179154,
-0.0137702972,
0.0307717752,
0.0260570906,
-0.1052465513,
0.0391785353,
0.0529701561,
0.0097645093,
-0.0295161586,
-0.0106272222,
0.0506931283,
-0.0161593929,
0.0636210442,
0.020237321,
-0.0077720406,
0.0008678575,
0.0028263924,
-0.1161276177,
-0.0017787807,
-0.0136159621,
0.0059406008,
0.0098465728,
-0.0065424531,
0.0272118505,
-0.0083384495,
-0.010910253,
0.0172277149,
0.0699990764,
-0.0321588032,
-0.0620956831,
-0.0537479483,
-0.0711132437,
0.0613258816,
0.008638056,
0.0481796488,
0.0292792954,
-0.0336750299,
0.0088101663,
0.0190690905,
-0.0786704347,
0.0033894067,
-0.0436957479,
-0.0237399489,
0.015521612,
-0.0847855732,
0.0103446273,
0.0375447199,
-0.0308055002,
-0.0046904343,
-0.0211016461,
0.0047724051,
0.0028986705,
0.1119663641,
-0.0052419761,
0.010140839,
0.0177743286,
-0.0716357306,
-0.0781419203,
-0.0109699108,
0.0405238718,
0.0016612968,
-0.0239281561,
-0.0104147308,
-0.0301003624,
-0.0084666107,
0.0242717229,
-0.0586733483,
0.006098663,
-0.0160325021,
-0.029319847,
0.0063332114,
0.0197252166,
-0.0210295711,
-0.0257760007,
-0.066260308,
0.0079954416,
0.0545358323,
0.0050480417,
0.0116581032,
-0.0235240124,
-0.0164821669,
-0.0501193218,
-0.0463291369,
-0.0138353473,
-0.0176803209,
-0.0157056618,
-0.008764755,
0.0147706633,
-0.0368400477,
-0.0422593616,
0.005783644,
0.0192829221,
-0.0116198072,
0.0204431601,
-0.0095872842,
0.0158651378,
0.0535285287,
0.031118311,
0.0037481028,
0.0647977665,
0.0114335185,
-0.020061221,
0.0086710732,
-0.0242041629,
-0.0579028018,
0.022218734,
0.0052007949,
-0.0198146924,
0.0632207692,
0.022719454,
0.0080053397,
0.0098470086,
0.0612195767,
2.522e-7,
0.0888957605,
0.0414642468,
0.0011554526,
0.0180517342,
0.0006459738,
0.0054920283,
0.0252346769,
0.0204106998,
-0.0013426086,
-0.0469033644,
0.0447677262,
-0.0125824213,
0.035600286,
0.0690096319,
-0.0870786011,
-0.003420494,
0.0129866414,
-0.0941820964,
-0.0630149469,
0.042546045,
0.033229135,
0.0442943461,
0.0052283029,
0.015733311,
-0.0104798647,
-0.0187288821,
0.0096110031,
0.0155222099,
-0.0171543714,
-0.0178821813,
0.1015167236,
-0.0373725817,
-0.020978367,
0.0361262821,
-0.0045596808,
0.0557101965,
-0.0378441736,
0.035371691,
0.0003785148,
0.0959725156,
-0.0118381893,
-0.0970565155,
0.0302844476,
0.0116082598,
0.0488755591,
0.0105940551,
-0.0074027283,
0.0062981397,
-0.0083187595,
-0.0097647747,
-0.0076392815,
0.0343515947,
-0.0257497597,
-0.0044794367,
0.0294934232,
-0.0050876341,
0.0166560002,
-0.0541438572,
0.02194166,
0.047265809,
0.0160157848,
0.007981156,
0.0517243855,
0.0015053401,
0.0592572279,
-0.050271675,
0.0558226258,
1.888486661e-34,
0.0200890843,
0.0071985438,
-0.0191805959,
-0.0099404762,
0.0235252846,
0.0051619238,
-0.053262841,
-0.0139236897,
-0.0226679873,
-0.065556556,
0.0331044979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09055v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09055v1 | Exploring the impact of low-rank adaptation on the performance, efficiency, and regularization of RLHF | 2023-09-16T17:31:36 | 2023-09-16T17:31:36 | Simeng Sun, Dhawal Gupta, Mohit Iyyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | During the last stage of RLHF, a large language model is aligned to human
intents via PPO training, a process that generally requires large-scale
computational resources. In this technical report, we empirically investigate
an efficient implementation of RLHF using low-rank adaptation (LoRA), which
allows us to align the LLaMA 7B checkpoint on the Alpaca dataset using only two
A100 GPUs instead of the eight required for full model fine-tuning. Despite
tuning only 0.2% of LLaMA 7B's parameters, our implementation achieves better
performance than the publicly-released AlpacaFarm checkpoint with full model
fine-tuning. Next, we analyze several configurations of our LoRA-based PPO
implementation, varying the form of the KL regularization term in the training
objective. We find that (1) removing this penalty term does not harm
performance on the AlpacaFarm evaluation set under our LoRA setup; (2) other
regularizers, such as Jensen-Shannon divergence, lead to improved performance;
and (3) while PPO training negatively impacts the factuality of model-generated
responses, training with LoRA largely mitigates this effect. We release our
code and pretrained checkpoints to facilitate future research on more efficient
RLHF. | [
0.046181649,
0.0890046135,
-0.0013178836,
0.0267592743,
0.0006786404,
0.0240419917,
-0.0219331291,
0.0329289474,
0.006058116,
-0.042700354,
-0.0499498509,
-0.0241046268,
0.0072080251,
-0.0195005871,
0.0102676097,
-0.0727889389,
0.0477192253,
-0.0301298257,
0.0151303923,
-0.0164878685,
-0.0006939758,
0.0072656134,
-0.0167408995,
0.0223586913,
0.0431851447,
0.0083313202,
-0.0223701298,
0.0286064446,
0.0506701507,
0.0037024082,
-0.0276136324,
0.0909633562,
0.0452568382,
0.0264024325,
0.0000020467,
-0.0769975483,
-0.0167272743,
-0.0067464788,
-0.0351679251,
0.00615614,
0.0327623039,
0.0024109487,
-0.0309879463,
-0.017986808,
-0.0034106213,
0.0077243424,
0.0617189296,
0.0445060879,
0.0153682707,
0.0914388746,
-0.0075135678,
-0.0103320135,
0.0255473386,
-0.029636655,
0.0112038618,
-0.0459305197,
0.0252731349,
-0.0127909044,
-0.0261479858,
-0.0294389222,
-0.0339459479,
0.0181530695,
-0.0087817796,
0.0249335952,
0.0147166485,
0.0059871599,
-0.0356799364,
-0.0143590206,
-0.0126696993,
0.0913340673,
-0.0520085208,
-0.0510311015,
0.0017861597,
0.0042811227,
-0.0218639169,
-0.0371599421,
-0.0179112311,
-0.0015445118,
0.0309297983,
0.0103974957,
0.0235816371,
-0.0239862259,
0.0376363099,
0.0195508935,
-0.0161723737,
0.039382562,
0.0433657989,
-0.0547415838,
0.0348623022,
0.0076648593,
0.0147444662,
-0.034667857,
-0.0420562252,
-0.0027393179,
-0.0342218019,
0.0294736587,
-0.0512121171,
0.0180560593,
0.0399979353,
-0.0302392002,
0.0199744254,
0.0615575127,
-0.0128880329,
0.0217195228,
-0.024779005,
0.0600571446,
-0.0256150551,
0.0329000391,
-0.0359610766,
0.0406047031,
-0.0318575166,
0.0034282466,
-0.0030069596,
0.0177415404,
-0.0359786488,
0.0011717294,
-0.0642067567,
0.0015565874,
-0.0217508394,
-0.0008695844,
-0.0164956246,
0.0075729368,
-0.0812333673,
-0.0132640097,
-0.0369484164,
0.0731917694,
-0.0168526247,
0.0163947884,
-0.0211386606,
-0.0578338578,
0.0019758292,
0.026849255,
0.027426675,
-0.0361045487,
0.0207194742,
0.0089878291,
-0.0327171609,
-0.0362437293,
-0.0166919455,
0.0224508084,
0.0058427327,
-0.103301309,
0.0088488059,
-0.0293130614,
0.0744812116,
-0.0162849165,
0.0366364308,
-0.0555761792,
0.0019868971,
-0.0049506328,
-0.0298428666,
0.0656658933,
-0.0247050747,
-0.0281379204,
0.0096366908,
-0.0167543888,
-0.0123528233,
0.0864527375,
0.0020298355,
0.0033792276,
0.002400582,
-0.0346893817,
-0.0586017668,
0.0493503623,
-0.0012427022,
0.0143512683,
0.0032573028,
0.0170898996,
0.0138453422,
0.0683650076,
0.0671052337,
0.0324548706,
-0.0179138035,
-0.0346412137,
0.0529427677,
0.0419053622,
0.0331566557,
0.027723711,
-0.0020767471,
0.0144331958,
0.0166600011,
0.0146873388,
-0.0404089503,
0.0022586512,
-0.0786975548,
0.0118754869,
0.0294257682,
0.0476945303,
-0.0145255988,
-0.0247513279,
-0.0165931005,
0.0249004737,
-0.0374914221,
0.0143451095,
0.057190612,
-0.0087374784,
-0.0401944704,
0.0114740292,
0.066638194,
-0.0567818955,
-0.0120801711,
-0.0543083772,
0.042418845,
0.0200668368,
0.0397210047,
-0.017455399,
-0.0048408345,
-0.0250179321,
-0.0099155046,
0.0454314612,
0.0632052943,
0.0158682987,
0.020740021,
-0.0545531772,
-0.0501651205,
0.0354397893,
-0.011615349,
0.0446474813,
-0.00352355,
-0.0066311085,
-0.0104156286,
-0.0148754697,
-0.0130557902,
0.0453851819,
-0.0202932693,
-0.0097116129,
0.0110279936,
0.0115631502,
0.0440693125,
0.0061380188,
-0.0110181095,
-0.0202694982,
0.0248428881,
-0.0158160552,
0.0430576839,
-0.0310130715,
0.0015108144,
-0.0286787953,
0.0401890799,
0.0065385061,
0.0231032446,
0.1044842079,
-0.0120297065,
-0.0279111657,
0.0171613302,
0.0066536823,
0.0355243757,
-0.0413639806,
0.0133296456,
-0.0309525933,
0.0619273409,
-0.0474031307,
0.0499981008,
0.0277671814,
0.0088949921,
0.0272738207,
-0.0391482152,
0.0041692797,
-0.0843784139,
-0.0247631073,
0.0270976238,
-0.0118141584,
0.0120736789,
-0.0051242104,
0.0166084673,
-0.0495676436,
0.0188689623,
-0.0723396987,
0.0177048538,
-0.0423658453,
-0.0028537794,
0.0450836569,
0.0000603524,
-0.0041084029,
-0.0271242242,
0.0105850743,
0.0116528235,
-0.00020972,
0.0217708424,
0.0076431292,
0.0139522254,
-0.0480420254,
-0.0553991906,
-0.0190566983,
0.0213329103,
0.0347708277,
-0.0076451073,
-0.0212771557,
-0.0334281772,
0.055245053,
-0.0501515493,
0.021886304,
-0.0004329315,
-0.0146351634,
-0.0134620368,
0.0015004775,
0.0371762291,
0.0416217484,
-0.0046816655,
0.0105303023,
0.0686426461,
0.0548688844,
-0.0533447303,
0.0304961521,
-0.0137494169,
-0.0554211736,
-0.0458638333,
-0.0070877555,
0.0001718931,
0.0478749722,
0.0035821625,
0.0168659538,
-0.0696605518,
-0.0584624223,
0.0001820941,
-0.0802039355,
-0.0703534931,
0.0375995599,
-0.0365180373,
0.0175369531,
-0.020240359,
-0.035188999,
0.0516777709,
-0.0105695873,
-0.0080132131,
-0.0470096916,
-0.015618653,
0.0062578944,
-0.0013213671,
0.0237145294,
0.0313769132,
-0.0390338413,
0.0227289498,
-0.0224963222,
-0.0192943327,
-0.0281025115,
-0.0134868259,
0.0371595882,
-0.0242197029,
0.0048242174,
-0.0402396545,
-0.0653687418,
-0.0237835459,
-0.0507213138,
-0.0116782375,
-0.0190499704,
-0.004709166,
0.0004336377,
-0.0218041874,
0.0027808121,
0.0265713949,
0.0378870033,
-0.0251901783,
-0.0183235537,
-0.0077279736,
0.0382012837,
0.0873311386,
0.0384548828,
0.0360685922,
-0.0000176382,
0.0463505574,
0.0241009928,
0.0708374977,
-0.0333134346,
-0.0256563686,
0.030560106,
0.0339122936,
-0.0133964326,
-0.0125074908,
0.0559359193,
0.0333250128,
-0.018134458,
0.0059190155,
0.0657586753,
0.0142102977,
-0.0731573179,
0.001287405,
-0.0639197901,
0.1250653863,
0.0294130724,
0.0504266545,
-0.0495035239,
-0.0266071931,
0.0107806288,
0.0405430123,
-0.0244012251,
-0.0196446069,
0.0161049943,
-0.0775214508,
0.0658244714,
0.0052089053,
-0.0595556647,
-0.0123358676,
-0.0619668625,
0.0326165967,
-0.0048948075,
0.0318386517,
0.0222784095,
-0.0184490979,
-0.0179590452,
0.020385664,
-0.0500281826,
-0.0369625688,
-0.0017996164,
-0.0089526549,
0.0490126461,
0.0422896892,
0.012789757,
-0.0196484625,
-0.0454088002,
-0.0225706734,
0.0177239627,
0.0137251811,
-0.0209047291,
0.0253011677,
-0.0081207203,
-0.0147500718,
-0.0283919051,
0.0261452645,
-0.0285850465,
-0.022383213,
-0.0241856705,
0.0760177746,
-0.0075781648,
0.0005141685,
0.0194595624,
0.0243290905,
0.0087411013,
0.0681068897,
0.00736902,
-0.0517145135,
-0.0365702547,
-0.0066718445,
0.0075641489,
-0.0596458726,
-0.0013423271,
0.0003208929,
-0.009826635,
0.0110972133,
-0.0147746578,
-0.0227775201,
0.0008812352,
0.0154189598,
-0.0122181587,
-0.0069380854,
-0.0375717282,
0.0123130474,
-0.0207147542,
0.0437484384,
-0.0514993444,
-0.0010118496,
-0.033730343,
-0.0228428617,
0.0012238972,
-0.0522833243,
0.0084176566,
0.0241113827,
-0.0446096584,
-0.0404638574,
0.0324411876,
0.029866999,
0.0215701591,
0.0431335717,
0.0477211215,
-0.0594524331,
-0.0089909947,
0.0081271091,
-0.021828033,
0.0817150399,
0.0029732564,
-0.021939151,
-0.034249451,
0.0374268666,
-0.0545678362,
-0.0264474135,
0.0362056047,
0.0823695883,
0.0212616529,
-0.0490358658,
0.0152616091,
0.046708487,
0.028686136,
-0.0354736559,
-0.0772698373,
-0.0181068014,
0.0190436039,
0.0022877476,
0.0244220402,
0.0015904506,
-0.0284141582,
0.0492994748,
0.0088098552,
0.0025972135,
0.0031806419,
-0.0064684162,
0.0308766644,
-0.0458132699,
-0.013147966,
0.0013794478,
-0.0157297999,
0.0092014074,
0.0397957563,
-0.0315073356,
0.0190866422,
0.0159572475,
0.0441059358,
-0.020447934,
0.0638736859,
-0.0029872188,
-0.0027372641,
-0.0401484817,
0.0257355552,
-0.0378361307,
-0.0240659118,
-0.0301127993,
-0.0042333961,
0.0867790878,
0.0295251179,
0.0775063485,
-0.0059541827,
-0.0290740095,
-0.0338732637,
0.0041614641,
-0.0291293357,
-0.0140702073,
0.0612433441,
0.0095496271,
-0.0108313849,
0.0485369638,
0.0327853747,
0.0336406045,
0.0555354916,
-0.0124414219,
0.0409016721,
-0.0668797493,
-0.0405695699,
0.0426580198,
0.0388442278,
-0.0405897796,
-0.0331193581,
-0.0181851741,
-0.056196522,
0.0104945395,
-0.0260635875,
-0.041560147,
-0.0454263054,
0.0318020321,
0.0338771306,
-0.0468134321,
-0.0498261787,
-0.0392252766,
-0.0109049603,
0.0062055299,
0.0233432259,
0.0035223516,
-6.438981161e-33,
-0.0375906006,
0.0393140465,
-0.0044115838,
-0.0436936766,
-0.015399023,
-0.0200279597,
-0.0027041782,
0.0159406066,
-0.0094294194,
0.0206243657,
-0.0162962358,
-0.0546494462,
0.0251668971,
0.0236655679,
-0.0065293605,
0.001750057,
0.0262114983,
-0.0387612022,
-0.0195442289,
0.0071532442,
0.0086332634,
0.0204597339,
0.0378751196,
-0.0275860485,
-0.0234970786,
0.0033356654,
-0.0291880108,
-0.0055477428,
-0.0334338993,
0.0577307753,
-0.0617040917,
0.0592156537,
0.0158118084,
-0.0415970869,
0.002597668,
0.0120038819,
-0.0835401118,
-0.0087374682,
0.0480765104,
0.0105087459,
-0.0624013096,
-0.0234643798,
0.025971029,
0.039455466,
-0.0440806448,
-0.0422760621,
0.0002947137,
-0.0304906722,
-0.0316835493,
-0.0012983995,
-0.0889062881,
0.0198990423,
-0.0186558403,
0.0311373081,
0.0212076008,
0.0472648442,
-0.0391891524,
0.0201385859,
-0.0826192349,
-0.0055395528,
0.0056311232,
0.0127342455,
0.0885509551,
0.0685931295,
-0.0225082338,
0.0426944494,
0.0301054996,
-0.0217330754,
0.0365202874,
0.0183394738,
0.036117319,
-0.0020716365,
0.0165414568,
0.0711937025,
0.0149017032,
0.0033555285,
-0.0821506083,
0.0068135485,
0.018271517,
0.0163829047,
0.0385610946,
0.0517432801,
-0.0603636242,
0.0023634802,
-0.0380602814,
0.0061306064,
-0.0311049223,
-0.0495537706,
0.0526496619,
0.0170950051,
0.0086427359,
0.0313154794,
0.0409770384,
-0.0419883169,
0.044284001,
0.0210524648,
-0.0123671722,
0.0156080471,
0.0290477537,
0.0143942088,
-0.0611447729,
-0.0234250966,
0.0305053461,
-0.0050194534,
0.0142396884,
-0.0314113721,
-0.0013426855,
0.0171448905,
-0.072201252,
0.0131794289,
-0.0097650755,
0.0160222296,
0.015399266,
0.0635431409,
-0.0062715299,
-0.0279032011,
0.0115031181,
0.0817551687,
-0.0124729704,
-0.0119580775,
-0.0126476632,
0.0132394098,
0.0131615745,
0.0144686578,
-0.0294128619,
0.0103093646,
-0.0039910683,
0.0023624361,
0.0260629356,
-0.0509357229,
-0.025428446,
0.0024945966,
2.823e-7,
0.0164776668,
0.0234111194,
0.0097254235,
-0.0240980536,
-0.0264491402,
0.0075670234,
-0.0210536998,
0.0384515822,
0.0256989915,
0.0015158738,
0.0350613967,
0.0191523079,
0.0442877002,
-0.0306615084,
-0.0449890532,
-0.0596427992,
-0.0445027016,
0.0101335458,
-0.0541458391,
-0.0166898221,
0.0544838719,
0.1080683246,
-0.0037614575,
-0.0374587812,
0.0414780118,
0.0070713744,
0.0598752759,
-0.051741112,
-0.0162657034,
0.0286049973,
0.0521501191,
-0.0455519855,
-0.0196860544,
0.0180279464,
0.0076303147,
0.0443596616,
-0.0108789885,
0.0901254267,
-0.053726919,
-0.0517083593,
0.0054046307,
0.0373255871,
0.0154170291,
-0.1086712405,
0.0643399805,
0.0094663268,
-0.0387551375,
0.0050905184,
-0.0177498143,
0.0008290313,
0.0199967045,
-0.049450811,
0.0100749061,
0.0028985066,
0.0400717035,
0.0116107343,
-0.065316312,
-0.0538154878,
-0.0087070875,
0.0148657728,
-0.0714594573,
-0.0436422564,
-0.0479596965,
-0.0132590178,
0.0159528088,
-0.0927624106,
0.0068995208,
2.622037725e-34,
0.0156270638,
-0.0019276747,
0.0212982278,
-0.0205975566,
0.0264080819,
-0.0375065245,
0.014355598,
0.0142134773,
0.0130234435,
-0.1269988418,
0.0288764667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12367v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12367v1 | Examining the Influence of Varied Levels of Domain Knowledge Base Inclusion in GPT-based Intelligent Tutors | 2023-09-16T17:12:05 | 2023-09-16T17:12:05 | Blake Castleman, Mehmet Kerem Turkcan | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have facilitated the
development of chatbots with sophisticated conversational capabilities.
However, LLMs exhibit frequent inaccurate responses to queries, hindering
applications in educational settings. In this paper, we investigate the
effectiveness of integrating a knowledge base (KB) with LLM intelligent tutors
to increase response reliability. To achieve this, we design a scaleable KB
that affords educational supervisors seamless integration of lesson curricula,
which is automatically processed by the intelligent tutoring system. We then
detail an evaluation, where student participants were presented with questions
about the artificial intelligence curriculum to respond to. GPT-4 intelligent
tutors with varying hierarchies of KB access and human domain experts then
assessed these responses. Lastly, students cross-examined the intelligent
tutors' responses to the domain experts' and ranked their various pedagogical
abilities. Results suggest that, although these intelligent tutors still
demonstrate a lower accuracy compared to domain experts, the accuracy of the
intelligent tutors increases when access to a KB is granted. We also observe
that the intelligent tutors with KB access exhibit better pedagogical abilities
to speak like a teacher and understand students than those of domain experts,
while their ability to help students remains lagging behind domain experts. | [
0.0856704712,
-0.0470896587,
-0.0531080104,
0.0175942164,
-0.0327918231,
-0.0029561841,
0.052533228,
-0.0269709453,
0.0592965223,
-0.0425668359,
-0.0107303429,
0.0152154583,
-0.0176262446,
0.0171373021,
0.0108336201,
-0.0802098662,
-0.0000927314,
-0.0035953827,
0.0078822542,
0.0050797756,
0.0118564228,
0.0211171806,
-0.0549211353,
0.0731480941,
-0.0034716595,
-0.0271052923,
-0.0351008214,
-0.0331128538,
-0.013822115,
0.0251078978,
0.0380374789,
0.0567735136,
0.0236017834,
0.0092915557,
0.0000020954,
-0.0316977687,
-0.0080735181,
-0.0191912502,
-0.0451476648,
-0.0051465938,
0.0049024541,
0.0667555779,
0.0097979112,
0.0255704895,
-0.0825636089,
0.029748233,
0.0041973586,
0.016066391,
0.052341979,
0.024567537,
0.0169914253,
-0.0017973372,
0.050382901,
0.0299424659,
0.0146041084,
-0.0500646867,
0.0223932993,
0.065639846,
0.053846512,
0.0544605441,
-0.0275792554,
0.0206756666,
0.0181953646,
-0.0501369052,
-0.0000647525,
0.0165936798,
-0.003872504,
-0.0166775156,
-0.0091275116,
0.0484326407,
0.0817990303,
-0.005161162,
-0.0238043647,
0.0201290082,
0.0565117225,
0.0746556297,
-0.0609069057,
0.0129180783,
0.0009950373,
-0.0163710192,
-0.0118061686,
-0.0157509148,
-0.0359361842,
0.030106185,
0.0118305441,
0.0273253154,
-0.0042803688,
-0.039220687,
-0.0170407034,
0.0542213097,
0.0098266462,
-0.0261314791,
-0.0060814978,
0.0728180483,
-0.0147016766,
0.0428203419,
-0.025120033,
-0.0008858613,
-0.0082553765,
0.025250027,
-0.0210394077,
0.0583242215,
-0.0242100451,
0.040399462,
0.0265912469,
0.1012736112,
0.0321750417,
-0.0011964019,
0.0053483211,
0.0002469147,
-0.0981416777,
-0.0322189927,
-0.0134693524,
0.0623409748,
0.0093232328,
-0.0034705277,
-0.0129329562,
0.0345156677,
-0.0473944023,
0.0266352333,
-0.0124179916,
-0.0047335448,
0.0003111463,
-0.0197514482,
-0.0610653721,
0.0608737767,
-0.0085041951,
0.0187203251,
0.0045494884,
-0.082867302,
0.0195832066,
-0.002442813,
-0.0124047026,
0.0217222739,
-0.010010764,
0.0324947797,
-0.0109755956,
-0.0342893153,
-0.0032179235,
-0.0385187119,
-0.0059808609,
-0.0479502305,
-0.0015479735,
-0.0479785204,
0.0084027955,
0.0227198154,
-0.0235186033,
-0.043530833,
0.008278613,
0.0220240559,
-0.0159666296,
0.0255244505,
-0.0319874957,
0.0185421072,
0.0644775108,
0.0379393883,
-0.0959877223,
0.0337989554,
-0.0066132606,
-0.0209697355,
0.0002794882,
-0.020501392,
0.016501151,
-0.0214107167,
-0.0010033668,
0.0090915803,
0.023764763,
0.0068036732,
-0.0135310497,
0.0219826829,
-0.0273960344,
0.0137941744,
-0.0207080115,
0.0147489915,
0.0573650263,
0.0482232161,
-0.0619643964,
0.0464563854,
0.0419765264,
0.059239585,
0.0705355927,
0.0271234531,
-0.0815303996,
-0.0105776927,
-0.0377686769,
-0.0165198352,
0.0304120854,
0.0005694393,
-0.0001731919,
-0.0666442066,
0.0103279036,
0.0009208207,
-0.0108438293,
0.0392056517,
0.0531460568,
-0.0444926806,
-0.0122510847,
-0.0100437105,
-0.0066122846,
-0.0454125479,
0.003810328,
-0.0875470415,
0.0434274189,
0.1127970144,
0.0439930521,
-0.0460149385,
-0.077524066,
0.0171244498,
0.025863044,
0.0553741083,
0.0410856307,
-0.0021577703,
-0.0511118807,
-0.0172079485,
-0.022498155,
-0.0059886314,
0.0264177732,
0.030066384,
0.0058860513,
0.0270921066,
0.0139882723,
-0.0087903794,
0.0020487136,
-0.004865183,
-0.0383108146,
-0.0216639917,
-0.0849020407,
0.0079691205,
0.005572272,
0.0561563447,
-0.0050439751,
0.0002265138,
0.0086645633,
0.0174553916,
-0.0484699234,
-0.0286026858,
-0.0542143285,
-0.0105727632,
0.0566044524,
-0.020309452,
-0.011889929,
0.0128632896,
-0.0003620725,
-0.0403225608,
0.0436963402,
-0.0212999471,
0.035622824,
-0.0176875796,
0.0158406422,
-0.0475514084,
-0.0346865319,
-0.0150946612,
0.0223861001,
0.055286698,
-0.0037654995,
0.023830127,
0.0143686989,
0.0146276206,
-0.0217713099,
-0.0014202548,
-0.0163655449,
0.0029271068,
0.0314193927,
0.0129988026,
-0.0121538378,
-0.057870537,
0.0070051081,
-0.1037778705,
-0.0208079834,
0.0115590226,
-0.0055223233,
0.0095778368,
-0.0214357283,
-0.0194982104,
0.0017726411,
-0.0569340773,
0.0041892175,
-0.0059465771,
0.0307449009,
-0.0042438335,
0.0152518591,
-0.0190940425,
-0.0534835532,
0.0219717063,
-0.0169894584,
-0.0007001315,
0.074411273,
0.01390405,
-0.0359649733,
0.0520253256,
-0.0380421691,
0.02334176,
0.0013045791,
-0.0450634919,
0.0297338571,
-0.0389764123,
0.026261121,
0.0713394657,
-0.0080061601,
0.0333546661,
0.0364133976,
-0.0328004621,
-0.0924833491,
0.0187553726,
0.0134630986,
-0.0444736108,
-0.0145076094,
-0.0022694273,
-0.0337963961,
0.038768921,
0.0353522934,
-0.0304513387,
-0.0589802712,
0.060942933,
-0.0253184196,
0.0058001177,
-0.0136776771,
-0.0270558652,
-0.0017907082,
0.0209023841,
0.0199776571,
-0.0144978901,
0.0814537928,
-0.0022557983,
0.0077039152,
-0.0196545944,
-0.0042751255,
0.0022070615,
0.0211487096,
-0.0092810439,
0.0051157493,
-0.0426339433,
-0.0087767886,
-0.0592054352,
0.0209101923,
0.0345260687,
-0.0701524541,
0.0231761932,
-0.0943304375,
-0.0060235988,
0.0107215075,
0.0078369565,
-0.0580209792,
0.0674322471,
-0.0426311307,
-0.0133947963,
0.0306235943,
-0.0277666636,
-0.0147391204,
-0.0181273371,
0.0492315032,
0.0132838357,
-0.0413622893,
-0.0065556248,
-0.0068005095,
-0.0201552939,
-0.0003150414,
0.0267388467,
0.0023618666,
0.0053360215,
0.0953009948,
0.034467563,
0.0360395536,
-0.0332128406,
0.000635104,
-0.0297877342,
0.031726446,
-0.0161965545,
-0.0412225537,
0.0175618734,
0.0222931933,
-0.0762698129,
0.0217710081,
0.1389639527,
0.0194745958,
-0.0665617213,
-0.0353359282,
-0.0352268293,
-0.0286430176,
-0.0043901745,
0.0355987996,
-0.0808282495,
-0.0259573758,
-0.0278145354,
0.0193132088,
-0.0265629496,
-0.0415199809,
-0.0096565979,
-0.0978131071,
0.0186489802,
-0.0072058099,
-0.0133545985,
-0.0564674847,
-0.0045078383,
0.0189653262,
0.0193651449,
0.0074947104,
-0.0075908527,
0.0006158061,
0.0239807069,
0.0353579931,
-0.0285568405,
-0.0565796308,
0.0307113435,
-0.009868145,
0.0504666865,
0.0549016446,
0.0253996737,
-0.0122759966,
0.0028205519,
-0.0296292286,
0.0454294905,
-0.0212449823,
0.0162899829,
0.0325392559,
-0.0133486204,
0.0246667191,
-0.0284039192,
0.0123523269,
-0.0227375142,
0.0352337249,
0.070538871,
0.1008736193,
-0.0179697443,
0.0188647136,
-0.0248324778,
0.0304912329,
-0.0021378596,
0.0694803819,
0.0250679906,
-0.0451538265,
0.0254138261,
-0.0346354693,
-0.0054474799,
0.004962197,
-0.0364039838,
0.0417507887,
-0.013518733,
0.0428459309,
-0.0639067143,
-0.0549028069,
0.0635987595,
-0.023417348,
0.0198117644,
0.0095251463,
0.0347516984,
0.0328477956,
0.0015548952,
-0.0041064038,
-0.0330388993,
-0.0009019743,
-0.0802702904,
-0.0474647135,
0.006591199,
-0.0717895702,
-0.0018246679,
0.0131913247,
0.0092602773,
-0.0816625431,
-0.0022114513,
0.0290893335,
0.020993663,
0.0002189649,
0.03637385,
-0.0044935918,
0.0282593556,
-0.0152080543,
-0.0413223319,
-0.004229317,
0.0052016671,
0.0145376241,
0.0174512286,
0.0033383153,
-0.0616897456,
0.003810273,
-0.0319749638,
-0.0064697606,
-0.0042173197,
-0.0505386926,
0.0355841406,
0.0202294439,
0.022329919,
0.0144897522,
-0.0000228037,
-0.0202389527,
0.0122851031,
-0.0644980296,
-0.0046382761,
-0.0404513329,
-0.0241726022,
0.0093559586,
-0.0204744544,
0.0320319459,
-0.0313565582,
-0.0294349343,
0.0121267634,
-0.0032109499,
0.007187827,
-0.0241074394,
0.0031472335,
0.0203192551,
-0.0095160846,
-0.0221580863,
-0.0286056641,
0.0170900188,
0.0235723909,
0.0192521513,
0.1093490198,
0.0059573697,
-0.0174936093,
0.0583533719,
0.0046661957,
-0.0387405045,
-0.1035535336,
0.0278766844,
0.0563758276,
0.0071952362,
0.0388599075,
0.0039101681,
-0.0550846234,
0.0230411738,
-0.0075553465,
0.0014039456,
0.0250211488,
-0.0090929819,
0.0405570939,
0.027389355,
0.0403170474,
0.024695199,
0.0407968685,
0.0184380077,
0.0291809514,
-0.0195049699,
-0.0355934985,
-0.0114974622,
-0.0247258991,
0.0367347822,
0.0132141002,
0.0167445615,
0.0042770244,
-0.056467142,
-0.0527577251,
-0.0503907837,
0.0178060848,
-0.0278214104,
-0.0536293983,
0.0316084437,
0.0299194828,
-0.0351978987,
-0.0323691629,
-0.0438495316,
0.0357866287,
-0.067454651,
-0.0188374221,
-0.0045813704,
-5.770513523e-33,
-0.0522415042,
-0.0456319451,
0.0443489291,
0.0502355583,
0.0046373587,
-0.0108653409,
-0.0101739718,
0.0191819575,
-0.0350159779,
0.0211700499,
0.0109572355,
0.0260031391,
-0.0130466884,
0.0067719324,
0.0279631577,
0.0133595932,
0.0267066285,
-0.0041964375,
0.0316861831,
0.0637603551,
0.0124951703,
-0.0105842091,
0.0282972362,
-0.0527525544,
0.0480803214,
-0.0389128737,
0.0266167894,
-0.0005467181,
-0.0324247964,
0.0345431007,
-0.0162608251,
0.069238171,
0.0231557954,
-0.047497116,
0.0052508642,
0.0167214945,
-0.0133540751,
-0.0804628059,
0.0252410136,
0.0042845034,
-0.0026511459,
-0.0234547108,
0.0071494118,
-0.0215439592,
-0.0178142507,
-0.0192626547,
0.0619727112,
-0.0155541366,
0.0227439143,
0.030852329,
-0.0581884235,
-0.0046414696,
-0.0268483628,
-0.0428783037,
-0.0272246674,
0.0305327158,
0.0142578706,
-0.0263662897,
-0.0101511283,
0.0469897687,
0.0709225759,
0.0020679948,
0.0520102307,
-0.0124102766,
-0.0116507625,
0.0171585493,
0.0149857122,
0.0182758551,
-0.0195110291,
-0.0181845985,
0.0074888552,
0.0313908793,
0.0604152679,
0.0442414023,
-0.0284919571,
0.0087380381,
-0.0230477992,
0.0440993384,
0.0476937965,
-0.0023611134,
-0.0145536037,
-0.0407636091,
-0.0833602101,
-0.007253462,
-0.0229988433,
0.0445107482,
0.0063240579,
-0.0643813908,
0.0377179608,
-0.0571416207,
0.0131531516,
-0.027166741,
0.0055361581,
-0.0489489809,
0.0122922221,
0.0218698531,
-0.0329212472,
-0.0035108631,
-0.0242760554,
0.0178595725,
-0.0206571259,
-0.0160432644,
0.0237494763,
-0.0423901752,
-0.0084639518,
0.0302258711,
-0.0215195995,
0.0095154047,
-0.0135268811,
-0.024586929,
-0.0532291867,
-0.0052168011,
0.0344086662,
-0.0276645329,
0.0217216201,
0.0274472553,
-0.0018914689,
0.0517806858,
0.030048741,
-0.034476772,
-0.0185298137,
-0.0449228697,
-0.0277880356,
-0.0573946871,
-0.0675005987,
-0.0235199984,
-0.0324642397,
-0.0101864524,
-0.0434048213,
-0.0437448062,
-0.0037000796,
-0.0222509876,
2.876e-7,
0.0029086091,
0.0556399189,
-0.0230574477,
-0.0169295128,
-0.0051128287,
0.0295413323,
0.0285377894,
-0.0113189686,
0.0432981737,
0.0025038815,
0.0198323894,
0.0342897698,
0.0433553755,
0.0205069873,
-0.0846377835,
-0.0449402593,
0.0511064641,
-0.0474359542,
-0.0672411323,
0.0502663292,
0.1026041806,
0.0004559979,
0.0366899297,
0.0094398428,
-0.0282758623,
-0.0229266826,
0.0075991438,
0.0000242119,
-0.0068130582,
0.0145383868,
0.0370148048,
0.0168026239,
0.01584398,
0.0860224515,
0.013333492,
0.0372843854,
-0.016392285,
0.0458093956,
-0.0029413239,
0.0283708666,
0.0144499736,
-0.0120101804,
-0.0124200825,
-0.0493566245,
0.044789277,
-0.0444019623,
0.0166618302,
0.0526183248,
-0.0409896895,
-0.082186833,
-0.0292543806,
-0.0296149701,
0.0081983097,
0.0077005997,
-0.0356267914,
-0.0438618734,
0.0356685482,
0.0021222513,
0.0479985103,
0.0068703177,
-0.0598676465,
-0.0688614622,
-0.0169591159,
-0.0338645913,
0.0157951545,
-0.0285536572,
0.031628225,
2.019247665e-34,
-0.0054415003,
-0.0051144627,
0.050701879,
0.0188921317,
0.0439930186,
0.0423892587,
-0.0274061561,
0.0314785652,
0.0389452726,
-0.0577701367,
-0.0215640999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08999v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08999v2 | Context-aware Adversarial Attack on Named Entity Recognition | 2023-09-16T14:04:23 | 2024-02-03T00:11:11 | Shuguang Chen, Leonardo Neves, Thamar Solorio | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, large pre-trained language models (PLMs) have achieved
remarkable performance on many natural language processing benchmarks. Despite
their success, prior studies have shown that PLMs are vulnerable to attacks
from adversarial examples. In this work, we focus on the named entity
recognition task and study context-aware adversarial attack methods to examine
the model's robustness. Specifically, we propose perturbing the most
informative words for recognizing entities to create adversarial examples and
investigate different candidate replacement methods to generate natural and
plausible adversarial examples. Experiments and analyses show that our methods
are more effective in deceiving the model into making wrong predictions than
strong baselines. | [
0.0373429433,
0.0680346191,
-0.0082471231,
0.0676867366,
-0.0137637788,
0.0156675316,
0.0093150288,
0.0225487072,
0.0172581747,
-0.0670461059,
-0.0274004638,
-0.0109390197,
0.0156342089,
0.0020423143,
0.0767683089,
-0.0180001259,
0.0566342212,
0.0079303887,
-0.0123484833,
0.0049461024,
-0.0107679944,
-0.0079532862,
0.0044929078,
0.0012405734,
0.0126719046,
0.0062427768,
0.0006803389,
0.0224919561,
0.0206057932,
-0.0559243523,
0.0476022288,
0.051940918,
-0.0183392223,
0.0988743156,
0.0000016692,
-0.0395021848,
-0.0396478288,
-0.0017946761,
-0.0345398858,
0.0461071134,
0.002629485,
-0.0197400674,
-0.0344204195,
-0.0153800016,
-0.031894289,
-0.0647475272,
0.0076624532,
0.0690572932,
0.037560977,
0.1276431382,
-0.001439043,
0.0009387479,
0.0274772402,
-0.061672613,
-0.0056517152,
-0.0701490268,
0.0593621358,
-0.0579186976,
-0.0559385456,
0.010330976,
0.0016586349,
0.0134585826,
-0.0114705963,
0.0376662239,
-0.0058216308,
0.0322165973,
-0.0127943633,
0.0178762451,
0.0099084536,
0.1080358103,
-0.0456337705,
-0.0185277909,
-0.0160619281,
-0.0181919653,
-0.0071438313,
-0.0272585358,
0.0021102948,
-0.0375325829,
0.0136927674,
0.0152415698,
0.0066493633,
0.0099364286,
0.0651234612,
0.0180975907,
0.0035744058,
-0.0233278479,
0.0439607203,
-0.0326553583,
0.0045066713,
-0.0171116088,
-0.037941467,
-0.0444766395,
0.0263474546,
0.0120935021,
0.0051104454,
0.0302759502,
-0.0845178813,
-0.0234681275,
0.0057999017,
-0.0574139208,
0.0361851156,
-0.0094956094,
0.0069550541,
0.0474335477,
-0.0440566391,
0.0165805854,
-0.0416303053,
0.0368232019,
0.008552039,
0.0115246838,
0.003248398,
-0.0215115696,
-0.0148857776,
0.0008326481,
-0.0288797952,
-0.0034884308,
-0.0386578515,
0.0310668889,
0.0043190974,
0.0297880433,
-0.0409000069,
0.0368122533,
-0.0264764559,
-0.0081472006,
0.0026189093,
-0.037274573,
-0.008186195,
-0.0091777043,
-0.022371497,
-0.0959258527,
-0.0347379334,
0.0032643855,
-0.0305325445,
-0.0532500297,
0.0240224209,
0.1139848605,
0.0416523814,
-0.0978086889,
-0.0505072139,
-0.0150526734,
-0.0046396567,
-0.0279070213,
0.0099080717,
-0.00627416,
-0.0051898374,
-0.0368303657,
-0.0114534339,
-0.0888618827,
0.002570546,
0.0002083196,
-0.0608628951,
0.1036887765,
-0.0080832001,
-0.0434623323,
0.0302199498,
0.0310660284,
0.0277069695,
0.0510309637,
0.0002217515,
0.0248969719,
0.0488638803,
0.0017351951,
-0.0025279103,
0.0298450757,
0.0615064874,
-0.0013734751,
0.023076931,
0.0220555067,
-0.003650785,
0.0165138673,
-0.0124980472,
0.0294330139,
0.0058868164,
-0.0675553158,
0.0829982534,
0.0160281621,
-0.0216720328,
0.0366850868,
0.0182665866,
-0.0283414759,
0.0167186521,
-0.0036841542,
-0.0725322366,
-0.0301139224,
-0.0989044458,
-0.0223365854,
0.0042732689,
0.0441741385,
-0.0295081679,
-0.0204103068,
-0.0113387676,
-0.0131208142,
-0.0146886492,
-0.0195950363,
0.0357933566,
0.0619389005,
-0.0853164792,
0.0309406631,
0.0137404129,
-0.0093404744,
-0.0117284087,
-0.0229704063,
-0.0008926965,
0.0234095734,
0.0799512714,
-0.0706086457,
0.0169007424,
-0.0129863182,
-0.0028920819,
0.0178533476,
0.0664781556,
0.000530832,
0.0280394834,
-0.0050295861,
0.0142612336,
-0.044163581,
0.0266506858,
0.0562813617,
0.0575005263,
0.0279572699,
0.0387760401,
-0.0252661761,
-0.0195154883,
0.0685969293,
-0.0106064398,
-0.0809914768,
0.0107753519,
0.0384031087,
0.0132043362,
0.0287515037,
-0.0167970583,
0.0271574631,
0.0562772192,
0.0028735937,
0.0033917767,
-0.0215430241,
-0.0127682248,
-0.0530976951,
-0.0055162776,
-0.0084872674,
-0.0162652805,
0.0424976237,
-0.02987995,
-0.0103343027,
0.031175334,
0.008046031,
0.0681191757,
-0.0051696016,
0.0263305828,
0.016269451,
0.0686796531,
-0.0244270917,
0.0754333138,
-0.0304851178,
0.0353597961,
0.0102546159,
0.0407524928,
-0.0372572988,
-0.0199201461,
-0.0602079257,
0.0250421204,
-0.0116496086,
-0.0403735004,
-0.0167080667,
-0.0269744694,
-0.0227009673,
0.0086406916,
-0.0290484447,
-0.021295391,
-0.0270220656,
0.0137198893,
0.0116768852,
0.0094630504,
-0.0312964246,
-0.0184960756,
0.0186177604,
-0.014153976,
-0.0332384259,
0.0353842713,
0.0207988732,
0.0001813077,
-0.002433002,
-0.0314325169,
0.0021690265,
-0.0185369998,
0.0928484052,
-0.0080775162,
-0.0211489443,
-0.0244692843,
0.0546963587,
0.005671171,
0.0646401048,
-0.0165362097,
0.0027079345,
0.0124566825,
0.0351633169,
0.0072976048,
0.0765620396,
0.0090756435,
0.0724408031,
0.0051463619,
0.0019279605,
-0.0009915791,
-0.001677924,
-0.0109048281,
0.0220280401,
-0.0344612561,
-0.0120171057,
0.033099521,
0.066540733,
0.0062977779,
-0.007010791,
-0.0011607916,
0.0685728639,
0.0067660632,
-0.0363609977,
0.0087239807,
-0.013605847,
-0.0308676325,
-0.0120614441,
-0.0203616098,
-0.033670295,
0.0546240099,
-0.0649187788,
0.0077648256,
0.0039651217,
-0.0072116214,
0.0309978463,
0.0528641716,
0.0390960276,
-0.006675995,
0.0231243744,
-0.0237643942,
-0.0205544829,
0.0195153356,
0.0101137552,
-0.0097397501,
0.0022411589,
0.0014940015,
0.0005972155,
0.0132684847,
-0.0002233448,
-0.0818231851,
-0.0532166883,
-0.0341545679,
0.0085008964,
0.0213486645,
0.0093362974,
-0.036392726,
-0.0065078102,
-0.0413073748,
0.0233888328,
0.0061213789,
0.0070263143,
-0.0325066298,
0.0465840809,
0.0282390714,
-0.0226715002,
0.0538561009,
-0.0058275149,
0.0130795874,
0.046247866,
-0.0073119141,
-0.0119234435,
-0.0252820123,
-0.0126836449,
0.0044630314,
-0.0419933535,
0.0291998331,
-0.0230245013,
0.0273992587,
-0.0279557649,
-0.0238211565,
0.0872578174,
0.0019183247,
0.0086896718,
0.0280113369,
0.0599228665,
-0.0088758543,
0.0060768328,
0.0033542837,
-0.0522299856,
-0.0319590047,
0.0104930075,
-0.0013368524,
-0.0158463139,
-0.0444991328,
-0.032528609,
-0.1213759705,
-0.038132675,
0.0028063508,
-0.0599830225,
0.0002844656,
-0.0202860422,
-0.0034730854,
-0.0306969173,
0.0280943289,
-0.0239329822,
0.0219292305,
0.0060819876,
-0.0292626172,
0.0220138766,
-0.0791800171,
0.011963591,
-0.0370444357,
0.06497816,
0.0856826603,
0.0281833336,
-0.0117593417,
0.0000071655,
0.0268818997,
-0.0343517773,
-0.0130295334,
0.0022757859,
0.0583534911,
-0.0556159541,
-0.0191623978,
0.0248006452,
0.0310100038,
-0.0240119211,
-0.0280023068,
0.0028956344,
0.0068351133,
0.0042456728,
-0.0160418823,
0.0034867309,
-0.0034370408,
0.0376029536,
0.0738700479,
0.0168954022,
-0.0366100743,
-0.0146459555,
-0.0306442026,
0.0102542089,
-0.0381249823,
-0.0400478765,
-0.0081591615,
-0.0030278522,
-0.0130682997,
-0.0521301702,
-0.0498762205,
0.0172661152,
0.0357585251,
0.0091116233,
-0.0020483723,
-0.0335707031,
0.0036884262,
-0.0405188352,
0.0236568954,
0.004123149,
0.034172006,
-0.0360401347,
-0.0242562592,
0.0165049732,
0.0136667648,
-0.0299590789,
0.0160099007,
-0.0928695723,
-0.0972773433,
0.0337755755,
0.0357404314,
0.0093088876,
0.0559907928,
-0.0480181538,
-0.0659208745,
0.0574472398,
0.0410785489,
-0.0280651059,
0.0249687154,
0.0447407849,
-0.0213037562,
0.0195776019,
0.0572504364,
-0.0389648378,
0.0168602522,
0.0844871923,
0.0072655096,
-0.0149691049,
-0.01669739,
-0.0193194915,
-0.0012563732,
0.0848844424,
-0.0227546114,
-0.0054337024,
0.0004931442,
0.0469341241,
-0.0070852526,
-0.0127573833,
0.0143795367,
-0.0036041338,
0.003144704,
0.0051438906,
-0.0096639534,
0.0352379791,
-0.0299943946,
0.0197276026,
-0.0407297425,
-0.0137068136,
0.0252267569,
0.0574610978,
0.0147255231,
0.0135890944,
0.0121455565,
0.0585949346,
0.0127139641,
0.0348045826,
-0.01126289,
0.0045127021,
-0.0086077703,
-0.0000644565,
-0.0229148418,
-0.000253043,
-0.0568536408,
0.0147714699,
-0.0513693057,
0.0595517084,
0.0351921171,
-0.0416880623,
-0.0068560834,
-0.024389714,
-0.0189438425,
-0.007438852,
-0.0392572246,
-0.0139247505,
-0.0120263118,
0.0173124447,
0.0096178511,
-0.01593915,
0.0434588231,
0.0596830025,
0.0411572978,
0.0636641309,
0.0490785688,
-0.010216183,
-0.0506473184,
-0.0295573175,
0.0398843363,
0.0072784829,
-0.0258679036,
0.0275175255,
-0.0329759717,
-0.0896749198,
0.0182461776,
-0.0137329921,
-0.0005032694,
0.0311646424,
-0.0139346039,
0.0409239791,
0.0084802881,
0.0504852124,
-0.0298646558,
0.0302945152,
-0.0014319565,
-0.0686756298,
0.0095177647,
-5.738208e-33,
-0.0190111455,
-0.0298359748,
-0.0055977302,
-0.0322210677,
0.0257638954,
0.0315986797,
-0.0289458614,
-0.0189336613,
-0.0198871735,
-0.03444409,
-0.0075914953,
0.0102222366,
-0.0072715641,
0.0240482111,
-0.092026487,
-0.0546844117,
0.0340725854,
0.0047947783,
-0.030278923,
-0.0024670409,
0.0207248181,
0.0555490926,
0.0680452809,
-0.0633574948,
0.0612996295,
-0.0095528383,
-0.0457909964,
-0.0011595448,
0.0006917752,
0.0477959812,
-0.0315821134,
0.0064389613,
-0.0099709909,
0.0049809776,
-0.0050235069,
0.0221492331,
-0.0816223398,
-0.0019255666,
-0.008963991,
0.0381250158,
-0.0368156135,
-0.0246153865,
0.0311043691,
-0.0178242512,
0.0227213241,
0.040927466,
-0.0050570532,
-0.0074911793,
-0.0087215928,
-0.0220672321,
-0.0504829213,
0.0271216165,
-0.0061407955,
0.0241262559,
-0.0003571634,
-0.017515339,
0.0556488037,
0.0244515035,
-0.0873358101,
-0.0061607016,
0.0431857482,
-0.0104179233,
0.0250074454,
0.0142125264,
0.0093728267,
0.0743548498,
0.0243823826,
-0.0113152657,
-0.0260129124,
0.0135376304,
0.0273210648,
0.0209178347,
0.0458807722,
0.0873827338,
0.0578595474,
-0.039400626,
-0.0733780041,
-0.0009722048,
-0.0215452388,
-0.0308353864,
0.0166191105,
-0.0067546382,
-0.048133973,
0.0270802863,
-0.0271299537,
-0.0767236277,
-0.0392697565,
-0.0212295409,
0.0293346699,
0.0114363693,
-0.0799935833,
0.0358162597,
-0.0383685231,
-0.0445752665,
-0.0454709567,
0.0219206456,
0.0042391731,
-0.0606616735,
-0.0054935403,
0.0348397754,
-0.0210851151,
-0.0124020074,
0.0313693397,
-0.056543678,
0.0239284541,
-0.0154888555,
0.0437003002,
-0.0115810791,
-0.0680715293,
-0.0168711785,
-0.0170934238,
0.0446752757,
0.0283592213,
0.0071511036,
0.0352751166,
-0.0215803441,
-0.0140830493,
0.0031557712,
0.0647099465,
-0.0183156263,
-0.0329932347,
0.0410951599,
-0.0023435119,
0.0249845665,
-0.0215601511,
-0.0616677105,
0.0302630682,
0.0123842042,
0.064313449,
-0.1095136702,
-0.0038686944,
-0.0329429209,
2.504e-7,
0.0219890252,
0.0295233596,
0.0138220545,
-0.0215292051,
0.0251975972,
0.0326161236,
0.0062379409,
0.0831905529,
-0.0410034619,
-0.0322187543,
-0.0149420714,
-0.0048010829,
0.0250796378,
0.0035298825,
-0.0605312176,
-0.0046483711,
-0.0413771085,
0.0189042166,
-0.0501687117,
-0.0262127984,
-0.0191505533,
0.1129055172,
0.0455534048,
-0.0113425264,
-0.016267417,
-0.0568581596,
0.0293750558,
-0.0278707985,
0.0256982222,
0.015684789,
0.000668379,
0.0605433695,
0.0012403575,
0.0071979854,
-0.0456226617,
0.0067373817,
0.0237170588,
0.0248599555,
0.010486423,
-0.0392613187,
-0.0518625341,
-0.0348241888,
0.0051682196,
-0.00547542,
0.0983998328,
-0.0346405134,
-0.0179000106,
-0.0251138378,
-0.0244487822,
-0.0102520641,
0.0414257534,
-0.014431648,
-0.020688029,
0.0139509803,
-0.0121334996,
0.0088581815,
0.00082788,
-0.0800187811,
0.0156440604,
-0.0182196517,
-0.0026971402,
0.0048784809,
-0.0050397427,
-0.0259586349,
0.0460768491,
0.004202432,
0.012099308,
2.122065769e-34,
-0.0000180928,
0.0095461505,
-0.004623109,
0.0048396201,
0.0177949872,
-0.0218898151,
0.0204717834,
-0.0248018056,
0.0003628528,
-0.0310160499,
-0.013178071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08969v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08969v2 | Rethinking STS and NLI in Large Language Models | 2023-09-16T11:58:39 | 2024-02-04T09:44:34 | Yuxia Wang, Minghan Wang, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent years have seen the rise of large language models (LLMs), where
practitioners use task-specific prompts; this was shown to be effective for a
variety of tasks. However, when applied to semantic textual similarity (STS)
and natural language inference (NLI), the effectiveness of LLMs turns out to be
limited by low-resource domain accuracy, model overconfidence, and difficulty
to capture the disagreements between human judgements. With this in mind, here
we try to rethink STS and NLI in the era of LLMs. We first evaluate the
performance of STS and NLI in the clinical/biomedical domain, and then we
assess LLMs' predictive confidence and their capability of capturing collective
human opinions. We find that these old problems are still to be properly
addressed in the era of LLMs. | [
0.0565096103,
0.0503801703,
0.0057607512,
0.0107721519,
-0.0543542504,
0.0072595421,
0.0232303366,
-0.0005081781,
0.0139144734,
-0.0376918763,
-0.0590129718,
-0.0411904305,
0.0206485093,
-0.0286370497,
0.0128941266,
-0.0223378725,
0.0115247509,
0.0096111428,
0.0036181663,
-0.0095095709,
0.0213021059,
0.0273525175,
0.0103113661,
0.0443745777,
0.0384273157,
-0.0050331694,
0.0562301204,
-0.0064289724,
0.0196165703,
-0.0641818717,
-0.0097940955,
0.0384339727,
0.0219581425,
0.0314877331,
0.0000018146,
-0.0598484129,
0.0235885307,
0.0048937327,
-0.0274589732,
0.0062981728,
0.0489658266,
0.0085356459,
0.0473019481,
-0.0001595926,
-0.0111023504,
-0.0112209134,
0.0287830215,
0.0420649312,
0.0027795287,
0.0424117297,
-0.0144225294,
0.0163509678,
-0.0039769216,
-0.0192898121,
-0.0038188808,
-0.0335538574,
0.0404730402,
-0.0087324167,
0.0384744368,
0.0077538607,
0.0336634666,
0.0565159954,
-0.0242717415,
0.0418013372,
-0.0151863135,
0.0328272469,
-0.0101549262,
-0.0164795443,
0.0162017718,
0.0450463071,
0.0319416486,
-0.039936237,
0.017065322,
0.0008795743,
-0.0196796656,
0.0548394918,
-0.0404399373,
0.0480816141,
-0.046635665,
0.0365029722,
0.0145778265,
0.0447097421,
0.0432258807,
0.0151860956,
0.0059244782,
0.0254711937,
0.0302697103,
-0.0317461863,
0.0398187973,
0.0515058674,
-0.0360143706,
-0.033449322,
0.0186371151,
-0.0170882847,
-0.0696041137,
0.0073858597,
-0.0269616209,
-0.0135709811,
0.0595314465,
-0.051114697,
0.033507295,
0.0101456819,
-0.0137545522,
0.0590485521,
-0.0086748628,
-0.004402278,
-0.0282526072,
0.0120805055,
-0.0386060029,
-0.0239253826,
-0.0468241498,
0.0132423537,
0.0091484897,
0.0004458897,
-0.0170366932,
-0.0121465791,
-0.0469278209,
0.0243337378,
-0.0207977481,
-0.0093957437,
0.0039363177,
0.0179998241,
-0.0039765905,
-0.0230694488,
-0.0405668728,
0.0112083191,
0.0120320413,
0.0435058773,
-0.0352544673,
-0.0576130338,
0.0157392379,
0.0371821746,
-0.0032357695,
-0.0229450278,
-0.0028705706,
0.0448855311,
0.0130559159,
-0.0054680565,
-0.0318181403,
-0.0254632365,
-0.0636475831,
-0.0240693185,
-0.0107683726,
-0.0744969547,
0.0282279663,
0.0164338686,
0.0046106214,
-0.0610662438,
0.0086403051,
0.0377340242,
-0.0671294108,
0.0659283921,
-0.0209328309,
0.0260463748,
0.0209861323,
0.018666219,
-0.0155628156,
0.0205618516,
-0.0046510948,
-0.0207968093,
0.0210235659,
0.0466514602,
-0.0158188716,
0.0020212429,
0.0029205077,
-0.0038351787,
-0.0157945268,
0.0142118596,
0.0426034816,
0.0582524389,
-0.0117398473,
0.1031769812,
-0.0135366078,
-0.0304528046,
0.0686200261,
0.1026073769,
-0.0219692569,
0.0177843701,
0.036841955,
0.0188974347,
-0.0024690572,
-0.0148729514,
-0.0201552976,
0.0004273883,
-0.0185586903,
0.0032211584,
0.0526799299,
0.0165160671,
-0.0333301127,
-0.0096596424,
-0.0583946891,
-0.0208672639,
-0.0317702107,
0.0132876523,
0.0333273076,
-0.0253034811,
0.0008348497,
0.0323933102,
0.0708515421,
-0.0368488133,
-0.0133734979,
-0.0475033484,
0.0260858219,
0.0529164635,
0.0595519468,
-0.0126885856,
-0.0065764454,
-0.002445796,
0.0186800975,
0.0367683098,
0.0320948884,
-0.0137917893,
-0.0033303362,
-0.037577603,
-0.0196462497,
0.0340813585,
0.0096898982,
-0.0059408597,
0.014998964,
0.0069834855,
-0.0045634029,
-0.021041872,
-0.0519389138,
0.047764454,
-0.0530108251,
-0.00466866,
-0.0105617568,
-0.0088544935,
0.0481553003,
-0.0060557504,
-0.028479347,
0.0289835818,
-0.0094655296,
-0.0394758917,
-0.053618297,
0.0025637588,
-0.0509388633,
-0.0440544337,
0.0050680474,
-0.0433196537,
-0.0194460507,
-0.0086650904,
-0.0371147543,
-0.0060547208,
-0.0301086567,
-0.0460423417,
-0.0049280087,
-0.0240203999,
0.0316950753,
-0.0123541458,
-0.0356767438,
-0.0603466481,
0.0380189866,
0.0041210516,
0.0167558435,
0.027376581,
-0.0287839808,
0.012102358,
-0.0215735007,
-0.0559930317,
0.0009415258,
0.0252973903,
-0.0091500767,
0.0337366089,
-0.0118427742,
-0.0145873735,
-0.0222694539,
-0.1075343937,
0.0079350518,
0.0008333799,
0.0140756536,
0.0077976952,
0.0155552421,
-0.0180715676,
-0.014449548,
-0.0371205434,
-0.0395846032,
0.0273378622,
0.0458997153,
0.0321290977,
0.0019021432,
0.0338417962,
-0.0690943226,
0.0070719039,
-0.0305693243,
0.057103198,
0.0147808678,
-0.0351916254,
-0.046472352,
0.0578967407,
-0.0659863949,
0.0161327571,
0.0013437744,
0.0373424254,
0.0014214389,
-0.0019956408,
0.032153897,
0.0392493904,
-0.0038226561,
-0.0172586963,
0.0766212344,
0.0266453922,
-0.0592934564,
-0.0268923771,
-0.0416561402,
-0.0387507156,
-0.0052477485,
-0.0476109311,
0.0369655192,
0.0801479444,
0.047083471,
-0.0152984317,
-0.0445229486,
0.000625253,
-0.032777302,
0.0159504674,
-0.0192514323,
-0.0324977525,
-0.0111364396,
0.0212088916,
-0.0065396004,
-0.0383985862,
0.1345590055,
-0.0224504396,
0.0496685542,
-0.0853235051,
-0.0305829309,
-0.0503852554,
0.0197514072,
-0.0207132455,
0.0068035801,
0.0132035837,
0.034931086,
-0.0219004322,
0.0163457431,
0.007762813,
-0.0244744271,
0.0831053331,
-0.0654510111,
0.024794627,
0.0109652616,
-0.0575434193,
-0.0291539188,
-0.0434916988,
-0.085379377,
-0.0313865654,
0.007633599,
-0.0002083448,
-0.0361300297,
-0.0077088838,
0.00096564,
0.0259510726,
0.0190185588,
-0.0333427899,
0.003814335,
0.0231639594,
0.0580013692,
-0.0381069556,
0.0144905439,
-0.034839116,
0.0300994162,
0.0786988661,
-0.0036512497,
0.0358394496,
-0.0221669674,
-0.0363306627,
0.0171661451,
-0.012191534,
-0.0122373831,
0.0337855592,
0.0636415333,
-0.0069348095,
-0.0043274797,
0.1404819787,
0.0298747849,
-0.0646152347,
-0.0007498354,
-0.0445947833,
0.0217220038,
-0.0094096335,
-0.018107485,
-0.0503521264,
-0.0679964349,
-0.0130679533,
0.0187051427,
-0.0265672039,
-0.0269043595,
0.0142481886,
-0.0560142994,
-0.0001686243,
-0.0043786615,
-0.0181319397,
-0.0029699658,
-0.0532009006,
0.0384779982,
-0.0016494819,
0.0024717348,
-0.0247202273,
-0.0240204185,
0.0131430374,
-0.0059535773,
-0.0650361404,
-0.0650796294,
0.041256424,
-0.0721305385,
0.0575787649,
0.0527923256,
0.0228020102,
0.0477947257,
-0.0384363532,
0.0142770335,
-0.0163561255,
0.0052067963,
-0.0031570252,
0.0626437366,
0.006755718,
0.0258485749,
-0.0955237895,
0.045086775,
-0.0222648811,
-0.018705491,
0.0064888117,
0.0688381568,
-0.0456659757,
-0.0428500995,
-0.0496024638,
0.0427268557,
0.0022581788,
0.1174585447,
0.0232724138,
-0.0234330557,
-0.0220475253,
0.0233549606,
0.0093602613,
0.0233373567,
-0.051461339,
0.02056369,
-0.0105302297,
0.0191096496,
-0.0554544926,
-0.0095205335,
0.0229082778,
-0.0363373794,
0.0073591052,
0.0105965585,
0.014459244,
-0.0199545678,
-0.0289498586,
0.0579619259,
-0.0289815161,
0.0214999933,
-0.0207439214,
0.0191141497,
0.0753666312,
0.0001606496,
-0.0130123077,
0.013490282,
-0.0869133398,
-0.0573638417,
-0.0365282446,
0.0040169698,
0.0195589103,
0.0213213563,
0.0036818821,
-0.02929499,
0.0497283861,
0.0461083315,
-0.0227879435,
-0.0067415377,
-0.0258593727,
0.0546402372,
0.0128284227,
0.055389747,
-0.0307084192,
0.0298945121,
0.0449356586,
0.0039994712,
-0.0051167244,
-0.0672864839,
0.0191728771,
0.0120968083,
0.0551984906,
0.0105073908,
0.006142776,
-0.0228165407,
-0.0185967498,
-0.013641878,
0.0136937154,
-0.0093236919,
-0.0135356756,
0.0159631018,
0.0085853394,
-0.0439104252,
0.0254704915,
-0.0346089751,
0.0496065319,
-0.0673789307,
0.019807633,
0.0310955029,
0.0285018105,
0.0221011043,
-0.0300730243,
-0.045585271,
-0.0145331174,
-0.0249255076,
0.0281212255,
0.0053094281,
0.0680299625,
0.0176156163,
-0.0103303818,
0.010581173,
0.0320926569,
-0.0855417624,
-0.0928777903,
-0.0059502129,
0.0123904971,
0.0131738419,
-0.0301979557,
0.0379193127,
-0.0227005202,
0.0112568643,
-0.0263766609,
0.0199290793,
-0.0359253734,
0.0281554926,
0.0670584291,
-0.0061412281,
-0.0098075503,
0.0184715092,
0.0928931609,
-0.0035835074,
0.0468143374,
0.0007907542,
-0.0810390934,
-0.0191976149,
-0.0585036911,
0.0201594625,
0.0008199614,
-0.0506840609,
-0.0082290573,
-0.0775395259,
-0.0315326191,
0.0407305583,
0.0062769931,
-0.0174036846,
-0.0178434476,
0.028394863,
0.061269287,
0.0007503866,
-0.0137270186,
0.0022151528,
0.029559968,
-0.0163304657,
-0.0261698943,
-0.0494869426,
-6.075593245e-33,
0.0219250955,
-0.0109921508,
-0.001560951,
-0.0095279748,
-0.0146063259,
-0.0032730235,
-0.0435139164,
-0.0000202349,
-0.015353838,
0.0570915118,
0.0083757518,
-0.0005306796,
0.002666895,
0.0320408382,
0.024506025,
-0.0393061787,
0.0314330161,
0.0209482014,
-0.0154638439,
0.0096494164,
0.0098091317,
0.0026494421,
0.0273130964,
-0.068042241,
0.0594600625,
-0.0052866363,
0.0575168617,
0.0147516206,
0.0165461935,
0.0223301034,
-0.0342056192,
0.0622482784,
0.0501772426,
-0.0129635967,
-0.0134301335,
0.0351992771,
-0.0249174871,
-0.0341551192,
0.0370850973,
-0.0653227717,
-0.0316435434,
0.0119154966,
0.0336431079,
0.0021254965,
-0.0561622865,
0.0029167491,
0.0333549678,
-0.0197175406,
-0.0092421575,
-0.0245084502,
-0.0444690175,
0.0346644036,
0.0172941256,
-0.0014200406,
-0.0121878181,
0.0604754128,
-0.0370703079,
0.0615407377,
-0.0398516506,
0.0224966053,
-0.031109618,
-0.0054094065,
0.0112065254,
-0.0296568908,
-0.0148601392,
0.0892261341,
0.0115037747,
-0.0179904941,
-0.0536268167,
-0.0158473682,
-0.0435509123,
0.0122265257,
0.0471708067,
0.0499558821,
-0.0206549522,
0.0194929149,
-0.0773153454,
0.029941868,
-0.0349989906,
0.0332898945,
0.0551010147,
-0.0040865783,
-0.0699476823,
-0.0501120463,
-0.0373011082,
0.0032449814,
-0.0164301842,
0.0028657964,
0.0259956438,
-0.0149065219,
0.0242437534,
0.0339709893,
0.0085356776,
-0.0153026832,
-0.002554256,
-0.0201828144,
0.0324961133,
-0.0045363847,
-0.0250856206,
0.0193323437,
-0.0702947676,
0.0086092688,
-0.0073871701,
0.010920845,
0.0287877098,
0.0113268029,
0.0229312088,
-0.0373777077,
-0.0669466183,
-0.0150492201,
-0.0209395476,
-0.0568094701,
-0.0150243938,
-0.0183500964,
0.044433333,
0.0365103856,
0.0114619071,
0.0678003728,
-0.0016104288,
-0.0291730724,
-0.021152677,
-0.0479125828,
-0.0068729278,
-0.0315494798,
-0.0226854272,
0.00553662,
-0.0442715883,
0.0121277859,
-0.0002524937,
-0.0261202194,
-0.017297104,
-0.0132467756,
2.553e-7,
0.072684899,
0.0379025079,
-0.0025749775,
-0.0352348424,
0.0110341916,
0.0336739123,
0.02362152,
0.0230631772,
0.0245625358,
-0.0182600636,
0.0319854729,
0.0275356509,
0.0478031449,
0.0317167193,
-0.0661018789,
-0.0020523893,
-0.1063681245,
-0.04000194,
-0.0508739129,
-0.0088703502,
0.0739143789,
0.0706142262,
-0.0110895429,
-0.0242500529,
0.0071799997,
-0.0340661407,
0.0684170872,
-0.0586404279,
-0.0130852209,
0.0380727835,
0.0407392196,
-0.048106242,
-0.0009644387,
0.0417819023,
0.0023042287,
-0.0085959816,
0.0149214277,
0.0527316891,
-0.0213401262,
0.0169601981,
-0.0142329549,
-0.0128011713,
0.0182719771,
-0.0567533225,
0.0727044269,
-0.0729676485,
-0.0307804756,
-0.0479200333,
0.0237893853,
-0.0169423912,
0.06205431,
0.0177508052,
-0.0302154999,
0.0125824222,
0.028915314,
0.0280079301,
-0.0303514581,
-0.0680562258,
-0.0072205048,
0.0142684784,
-0.0668210313,
-0.0486758053,
-0.0097092055,
0.0128423907,
0.0319339894,
-0.1004718468,
0.0473460294,
2.268232981e-34,
0.0407412201,
0.0209239442,
0.0063377125,
-0.0079069464,
0.0471394025,
0.0265063085,
0.001367229,
0.0120630693,
0.0295493323,
-0.0816726685,
0.0162593909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08968v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08968v2 | Sorted LLaMA: Unlocking the Potential of Intermediate Layers of Large Language Models for Dynamic Inference | 2023-09-16T11:58:34 | 2024-02-08T22:43:04 | Parsa Kavehzadeh, Mojtaba Valipour, Marzieh Tahaei, Ali Ghodsi, Boxing Chen, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized natural language processing
(NLP) by excelling at understanding and generating human-like text. However,
their widespread deployment can be prohibitively expensive. SortedNet is a
recent training technique for enabling dynamic inference by leveraging the
modularity in networks and sorting sub-models based on computation/accuracy in
a nested manner. We extend SortedNet to generative NLP tasks, making large
language models dynamic without any Pre-Training and by only replacing Standard
Fine-Tuning (SFT) with Sorted Fine-Tuning (SoFT). Our approach boosts model
efficiency, eliminating the need for multiple models for various scenarios
during inference. We show that this approach can unlock the power of
intermediate layers of transformers in generating the target output. Our
sub-models remain integral components of the original model, minimizing storage
requirements and transition costs between different computational/latency
budgets. The efficacy of our proposed method was demonstrated by applying it to
tune LLaMA 2 13B on the Stanford Alpaca dataset for instruction following and
TriviaQA for closed-book question answering. Our results show the superior
performance of sub-models in comparison to Standard Fine-Tuning and SFT+ICT
(Early-Exit), all achieved with efficient tuning and without additional memory
usage during inference. | [
0.054739859,
0.0635115951,
-0.0090217907,
0.0430544168,
0.0150112454,
0.0263813213,
0.0195155162,
-0.0047040875,
-0.0130234677,
-0.0407565534,
-0.0426778384,
-0.0202177446,
-0.0073206485,
0.0061513889,
0.0370532237,
-0.0388793759,
0.0422381759,
-0.0311317202,
-0.0288850144,
0.0052370308,
-0.0082934098,
0.0124775758,
-0.011055707,
0.0444471985,
0.0633780882,
-0.0251086764,
-0.0110423397,
0.0048780199,
0.0362321474,
0.0180845186,
0.0245905668,
0.0412126034,
0.0114563294,
0.053529907,
0.0000019812,
-0.0047379322,
0.002017457,
-0.0114137363,
-0.0410012156,
0.0348625034,
0.0293950047,
0.0471704789,
-0.0204944815,
0.0155372843,
-0.0354966074,
-0.0248050913,
0.0344495252,
0.0101432269,
0.0823442861,
0.0638829693,
0.0254432317,
-0.043704737,
0.0542176403,
-0.0613685735,
-0.0100243967,
-0.0611649938,
-0.0070699849,
0.0046398719,
0.0166432466,
0.0436150059,
0.0090246657,
0.0297943074,
0.0477032773,
0.0166956726,
-0.0282240137,
0.0596124455,
-0.0470786244,
-0.0036553585,
-0.004626859,
0.0847766101,
-0.0489299297,
-0.010107344,
-0.0149379391,
-0.0302345883,
-0.0183580928,
0.0054930449,
-0.0412989743,
0.020560462,
-0.0041655428,
0.0290213935,
0.054591991,
0.017438354,
0.0093001658,
0.0285633169,
-0.0253628865,
0.0743390322,
0.0210061781,
-0.0010768586,
-0.0211749189,
-0.0063774781,
-0.0206990708,
-0.047228843,
-0.0058279028,
0.0267012771,
0.0080451397,
0.0186930355,
-0.0370639786,
-0.0090225162,
0.0058188522,
-0.0284246225,
0.0392858572,
0.0353307277,
-0.0060597248,
0.0114294467,
-0.0272627976,
0.0434143543,
-0.0661689118,
0.0316902027,
-0.0544033088,
0.0164307151,
-0.0136644505,
-0.0522149168,
-0.0266212597,
0.0295777321,
-0.0536844097,
-0.0082281819,
-0.067453526,
0.0199015271,
0.0256192572,
-0.043124374,
0.0387997255,
0.0071704411,
-0.0410690121,
-0.0120539693,
-0.0369798951,
0.0159050804,
-0.0519053452,
0.0435545854,
0.0041618925,
-0.0528554544,
-0.0254001971,
-0.0028672679,
-0.0048453086,
-0.022365611,
0.0174539853,
0.0802744478,
-0.0182851478,
-0.054234799,
-0.057869643,
-0.0267164037,
0.0193189606,
-0.0493969768,
0.0309748817,
-0.0542812757,
0.0219523832,
-0.0159074757,
0.0148753552,
-0.0024939459,
0.012290298,
0.048534438,
-0.0335515887,
0.0478551239,
0.0002241461,
-0.011662134,
-0.0047080354,
0.0057898713,
0.0460881218,
0.0637820065,
0.04901715,
0.0229935106,
0.0177720692,
0.0179553889,
-0.0049642134,
0.0375414006,
0.014082524,
-0.0275243688,
-0.0211260226,
-0.0140435202,
-0.0548667125,
0.0200267322,
0.0188594535,
0.0121013988,
-0.048517134,
-0.0001457648,
0.0400021076,
0.0405380391,
0.0229907632,
0.0257957671,
0.0402765498,
-0.0098955892,
0.0331062451,
0.0472214855,
-0.0487545021,
0.0443942621,
-0.0153824827,
-0.0022236863,
0.0100139687,
0.0567674749,
-0.0237431042,
-0.0685406998,
0.0042152344,
0.0064399159,
-0.0144007429,
0.0116959326,
0.0211392082,
0.0416093655,
-0.0210771281,
0.0682725012,
0.0496208221,
-0.0134028662,
-0.0385026149,
-0.0995984301,
0.0173755717,
0.0841071829,
0.04461658,
-0.0340245143,
-0.0881797597,
0.0461923666,
0.0010119912,
0.0322056562,
0.0003732109,
-0.0231567044,
-0.0162059274,
-0.0587402247,
0.0119228167,
-0.0158818047,
0.0272686239,
0.0066052326,
0.060102988,
-0.0132547608,
0.020169219,
-0.016201064,
-0.0305315219,
0.035226468,
-0.064247489,
-0.036904823,
-0.0134161934,
0.0081807878,
0.0204103831,
-0.018425189,
-0.0137756066,
0.0162072089,
0.0336791389,
-0.0411617644,
-0.0062030307,
-0.0074049565,
-0.0295898113,
-0.0410721302,
0.006594616,
-0.0014420819,
0.003260128,
0.0455135405,
-0.0862105563,
-0.0257950723,
-0.0001973537,
-0.0053787823,
0.006751392,
-0.0572868623,
-0.0212677792,
0.047632318,
0.0337549038,
-0.0491546392,
0.0651914477,
-0.0356326103,
0.027539501,
0.0494094528,
-0.0255833697,
-0.0370092392,
-0.0189052261,
-0.0064441049,
0.0374442339,
0.0053728889,
-0.0235642623,
-0.0284100361,
0.0356704108,
-0.038050089,
-0.0495416261,
-0.0413733087,
0.0142944781,
-0.0204796027,
0.0260018148,
0.046168264,
0.0262634568,
-0.004534618,
-0.0085208789,
0.0026363123,
0.0075881607,
0.0115397787,
0.019123584,
0.0354798771,
0.0057430877,
-0.0324700065,
-0.0486725867,
-0.0490150265,
-0.0138972756,
0.0562375262,
-0.0160832237,
0.0043502375,
-0.0430078469,
0.0104005961,
-0.0294463485,
0.0402199142,
-0.0260489825,
-0.0590747334,
-0.011779435,
-0.0076987306,
0.0218446702,
0.0888485014,
-0.0099910265,
0.0106425909,
0.0199573096,
-0.0134308068,
-0.0310229361,
0.0285859387,
-0.0249967854,
-0.0247253478,
-0.016614303,
-0.0240993183,
-0.0460371897,
0.103294,
-0.0136629827,
-0.026447475,
-0.0516413115,
0.022557199,
-0.0231690779,
-0.0013189578,
-0.0127194999,
-0.0055148369,
-0.0138601232,
0.0271763727,
-0.0384008549,
-0.0422699302,
0.0734868795,
-0.0232037045,
-0.0085157594,
-0.046484068,
-0.0108736753,
-0.0685783103,
0.0413991362,
0.0271083545,
0.0010486942,
0.0079733226,
-0.0179078951,
-0.0742458105,
0.0127374157,
0.0024628576,
-0.0371791311,
0.0709860399,
-0.0427017212,
0.0090665631,
-0.0246659908,
-0.0281101577,
-0.0509253405,
-0.0320905596,
-0.0401795246,
0.0049337381,
0.022478655,
-0.0190769639,
-0.0148732997,
0.0089157009,
0.002999027,
0.0565873384,
-0.0293631405,
-0.0011219659,
-0.0430253558,
0.072311081,
0.0485229194,
0.0267948899,
0.03943903,
-0.0185487736,
0.0264151599,
0.0404797755,
0.0146171916,
-0.0096050566,
-0.0108979996,
-0.0009312321,
0.0181730147,
-0.0306451619,
-0.0236541647,
0.0020470098,
0.0423550941,
-0.071436584,
-0.0387881696,
0.1018040925,
0.0283301808,
-0.0170461871,
-0.0031351675,
0.0065566399,
0.057411097,
0.0334628783,
0.0738346726,
-0.071126096,
-0.0457279123,
0.0218795892,
0.0318497419,
-0.000440121,
-0.0208505485,
0.0006889664,
-0.1249088198,
0.0183007196,
-0.0032077809,
-0.004416741,
0.0214433335,
-0.0097162193,
-0.0138849998,
0.0204508901,
-0.02884656,
0.0128122633,
-0.0109388558,
-0.0011488179,
0.0286971275,
0.0101396348,
-0.0173206981,
0.04408345,
0.0029471333,
0.0466405265,
0.0441072583,
0.013689233,
-0.0014191365,
-0.0335321687,
0.0825636983,
-0.0454018265,
0.0038618636,
0.0072713071,
0.0346684642,
-0.0160342548,
-0.0042549968,
-0.0036726515,
0.0311741829,
-0.0311237201,
-0.0083852978,
-0.031631574,
0.0619932152,
0.0045537506,
-0.0054096575,
-0.0326250419,
0.0024151308,
-0.045119714,
0.0386329368,
0.051433783,
-0.0222981144,
-0.0193802807,
-0.0269813016,
-0.025480058,
-0.0325747728,
-0.0749679804,
0.0209095944,
0.0256472733,
-0.0192440413,
-0.0666008517,
-0.0110585745,
0.0013149322,
0.0181291886,
-0.0063424939,
-0.0098472713,
0.0558399856,
-0.0070623714,
-0.0348359048,
0.0206575505,
-0.0205180813,
0.0130573167,
-0.0654157922,
-0.0282050036,
0.1011629477,
-0.0102964668,
-0.0551668182,
0.0197062921,
-0.1141747162,
-0.0666190237,
0.0122279339,
0.0571717024,
0.031288065,
0.0203095581,
-0.0121634481,
-0.0562875941,
0.0138479397,
0.0297809429,
-0.0063583483,
0.0135535914,
0.0059631476,
-0.0279996973,
0.007065706,
0.0488436483,
-0.0255750418,
0.0542875379,
-0.0126624405,
0.0204990786,
-0.0175733641,
-0.0336970687,
0.0043714317,
-0.0118027879,
0.0193689615,
-0.0095408782,
-0.0283174794,
-0.0771451145,
0.0759906843,
-0.0068178088,
-0.0253184624,
-0.0474404953,
0.0032516615,
0.0142266983,
-0.0018962661,
-0.0354887322,
-0.0227657929,
0.027569145,
0.0525417924,
-0.0171017107,
-0.0013054269,
0.0133775594,
0.001205395,
-0.002570455,
-0.0237286706,
-0.0142187597,
0.0098898187,
-0.0105023207,
0.0753715113,
-0.0492666252,
0.0230444539,
0.0229647998,
-0.0260410868,
-0.0893189758,
0.079974927,
-0.0788167939,
-0.0436032265,
-0.0365562737,
0.0629322678,
0.032823883,
0.0119989002,
0.0161146447,
0.0067536812,
-0.014866244,
0.0204240456,
0.012250239,
0.0088702589,
-0.0067980504,
0.0525030419,
0.0346824862,
0.0022056031,
-0.0089386804,
0.0940777808,
0.0198171679,
0.0455994867,
-0.0069801859,
0.0103657246,
-0.012157456,
-0.0324617475,
-0.0434453599,
0.0023893218,
-0.0010161315,
0.0271857716,
-0.0473672599,
-0.0739958361,
0.010990642,
0.0275297426,
0.0238718074,
-0.0259300601,
0.0309215989,
0.0636922717,
0.0394015014,
-0.0238856692,
-0.0274425205,
-0.0228742901,
0.0129107088,
-0.0242502633,
-0.0168231837,
-6.965874463e-33,
-0.0553768389,
-0.0105320858,
0.0338314287,
0.0082198102,
-0.0365866646,
0.0319379605,
-0.0274324808,
-0.0216839518,
-0.0237512011,
-0.0101746768,
-0.0333030559,
0.0197589323,
0.016885981,
0.0074570738,
-0.0078017963,
-0.0214340258,
0.0261109266,
-0.0086093685,
-0.0231549069,
0.0373987444,
0.0225329548,
0.0282723699,
0.0566070601,
0.0127313826,
-0.0344654359,
-0.0032484175,
0.0130441878,
0.0229833052,
-0.0658085197,
0.0580303967,
-0.0282745734,
0.0083936621,
0.042737551,
-0.051131051,
0.0157387648,
0.0340359621,
-0.0848056972,
-0.0287089795,
0.0190896317,
-0.0145872664,
-0.0278129727,
-0.0407685302,
0.034358386,
0.0108066285,
-0.0012337827,
-0.0135207009,
0.0137442658,
-0.0267036613,
-0.0040873336,
-0.0369149782,
-0.0503723584,
0.0202982686,
0.0161717646,
-0.035525918,
-0.0235552769,
0.062225122,
-0.0170262381,
0.0380940065,
-0.0437887684,
0.0154921049,
0.0385170691,
0.0771268383,
0.040574275,
0.0244225152,
-0.0180018228,
0.0346394517,
0.0261346269,
-0.0163787715,
-0.0354765095,
0.004208907,
0.0202809814,
0.0368986912,
0.0133464318,
-0.0144562814,
0.0444269627,
0.0139996558,
-0.0871959329,
0.0054915394,
0.0437517799,
0.0509502888,
0.0200586002,
-0.0112759722,
-0.0256191771,
-0.0117280893,
-0.0223422274,
0.0107043842,
-0.028164411,
-0.0015524243,
0.044150807,
0.0224402901,
-0.0615818724,
-0.0202333257,
0.0135367215,
-0.0519058071,
-0.0004089255,
0.0284222979,
-0.0081910593,
0.0361473262,
-0.0082435142,
0.0334780887,
-0.0611501783,
-0.0168549176,
0.0074138148,
-0.01211059,
0.0082047954,
-0.0007684825,
0.0390544645,
0.0213328879,
-0.0582097583,
0.0104843089,
-0.0358585119,
0.0352379009,
-0.0129723381,
0.0740665942,
0.0290082321,
0.0100333737,
-0.0040824125,
0.0290503893,
0.023291301,
0.0154858921,
-0.0410040282,
0.0246625878,
0.032213632,
0.0437202044,
-0.0135951377,
0.0169129409,
-0.0365091339,
0.0049054311,
-0.0323452502,
-0.0853382945,
-0.0292707644,
0.0551602431,
2.842e-7,
0.0259149726,
0.0386119224,
0.0342801623,
0.0420427844,
0.0405903868,
-0.0030804479,
0.0007527733,
-0.0000512216,
0.0509408452,
-0.0117535442,
0.0119891129,
0.0430707969,
0.0274142139,
0.022838749,
-0.0767244771,
-0.0127067212,
-0.0330689996,
0.0151831387,
-0.0307657216,
-0.0950013772,
0.037476927,
0.1347018927,
-0.0149197336,
-0.0070550716,
-0.0081267338,
-0.0367575362,
0.0522371307,
0.0452059284,
-0.0036674081,
0.0090192752,
0.0308679324,
0.0401809625,
-0.012049132,
-0.02165672,
-0.0027439327,
0.0356081836,
-0.009062334,
0.0601917356,
0.0134492274,
-0.0480112284,
0.0152647356,
-0.029622538,
0.0059360578,
-0.0298444498,
0.0806531161,
-0.0807612389,
0.0006403541,
-0.0117154494,
-0.0004595595,
-0.0016960616,
0.0056833443,
-0.0439746156,
-0.0174298678,
0.0371270105,
0.020108331,
-0.0356809497,
-0.022839563,
-0.0996256769,
-0.0263117068,
0.0012425651,
-0.0752643049,
-0.0401326269,
-0.0424082354,
-0.046432361,
0.0026824772,
-0.0487703942,
-0.0162770245,
2.883479607e-34,
0.0264579672,
0.0161972549,
0.0227521062,
0.0791657418,
0.0061613885,
-0.0001332685,
0.0000157835,
-0.0016737307,
0.0022585702,
-0.1099000648,
-0.0380617119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08963v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08963v3 | Struc-Bench: Are Large Language Models Really Good at Generating Complex Structured Data? | 2023-09-16T11:31:58 | 2024-04-04T21:57:12 | Xiangru Tang, Yiming Zong, Jason Phang, Yilun Zhao, Wangchunshu Zhou, Arman Cohan, Mark Gerstein | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the remarkable capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) like
GPT-4, producing complex, structured tabular data remains challenging. Our
study assesses LLMs' proficiency in structuring tables and introduces a novel
fine-tuning method, cognizant of data structures, to bolster their performance.
We unveil Struc-Bench, a comprehensive benchmark featuring prominent LLMs
(GPT-NeoX-20B, GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and Vicuna), which spans text tables, HTML, and
LaTeX formats. Our proposed FormatCoT aids in crafting format-specific
instructions from the intended outputs to populate this benchmark. Addressing
the gap in task-centered evaluation, we propose two innovative metrics, P-Score
(Prompting Score) and H-Score (Heuristical Score), to more accurately gauge LLM
performance. Our experiments show that applying our structure-aware fine-tuning
to LLaMA-7B leads to substantial performance gains, outshining its LLM
counterparts across most measures. In-depth error analysis and creating an
ability map across six dimensions -- coverage, formatting, reasoning,
comprehension, pragmatics, and hallucination -- highlight areas for future
enhancements and suggest forthcoming research trajectories. Our code and models
can be found at https://github.com/gersteinlab/Struc-Bench. | [
-0.0086315814,
0.0574354827,
-0.023944011,
0.0114154937,
-0.0296811592,
0.0302002914,
-0.0095180515,
0.0292141866,
-0.0171934515,
-0.0211084001,
-0.0481858552,
-0.055491697,
0.0035252234,
0.0515470244,
0.0526426993,
-0.0323662274,
0.0249762703,
-0.026419716,
0.0047524804,
0.0455714725,
0.008308053,
-0.0258896016,
-0.0101018157,
-0.002559701,
0.0086858822,
-0.0364454612,
-0.0095507018,
0.0078823818,
-0.0408306047,
-0.0454856828,
0.0119222235,
0.0754131526,
-0.0176750515,
0.048310481,
0.0000022826,
-0.0053022923,
-0.0223494265,
-0.0095582651,
0.0078693079,
0.040558096,
0.0442985557,
-0.0352391675,
-0.0343593098,
0.0075794291,
-0.0511316918,
-0.0471805371,
-0.0021531107,
0.0324682705,
0.0417261012,
0.0733893365,
-0.0096695805,
-0.022013247,
0.0334522538,
-0.0192264728,
0.045129884,
0.0059171957,
-0.0132477814,
0.0279192626,
0.0326026604,
0.0089306077,
0.0199536402,
0.0169013832,
0.0271617249,
-0.0539464243,
0.0043943403,
0.0258519556,
-0.0653641745,
0.0250482,
0.0167931169,
0.06401667,
0.0206151418,
-0.0081318431,
0.0139482068,
-0.0016971703,
0.0098548653,
-0.0261412524,
-0.1004661471,
0.0158064105,
-0.0030832083,
-0.0218858197,
0.0313730873,
-0.0238385573,
0.022813594,
-0.0289560221,
0.0071029626,
0.054266341,
0.0026712257,
-0.0372027308,
-0.0066609466,
0.005112445,
-0.0012889582,
-0.0764065608,
0.0014274031,
0.0282661337,
-0.0405661203,
0.0029354314,
-0.0284744482,
-0.0605688468,
0.0364864618,
-0.0432693474,
0.0523846671,
0.0485951304,
-0.0007123019,
0.0305482652,
-0.0662758723,
0.0592968054,
-0.0361623764,
0.0198271964,
-0.0241683777,
0.0186092444,
-0.0457692742,
0.0028893689,
-0.01529295,
0.030377591,
-0.0620520636,
-0.0158555917,
-0.0101531912,
0.0375587717,
-0.0123199336,
0.0444093086,
0.0062218029,
-0.0261625815,
-0.0084627857,
0.0080161532,
-0.0209652316,
-0.0054893154,
-0.0425756425,
-0.0360973664,
0.0015002907,
-0.0547946692,
-0.0110279601,
0.0107726585,
-0.0145256082,
-0.0374357626,
0.0104687409,
0.0781399682,
-0.0379305407,
0.0232097656,
-0.0405775458,
-0.0317879431,
0.0056042396,
-0.0683266595,
0.0435867421,
-0.0785064027,
0.0460104607,
0.0425626934,
-0.007306492,
-0.0485934876,
-0.0015519937,
0.0173916277,
0.0059105228,
0.0239245612,
-0.0108224107,
0.0177211519,
-0.0020572273,
-0.0082711959,
-0.0214092117,
0.0703442767,
0.0400323831,
0.035673134,
0.0020401573,
-0.0392811336,
0.004373278,
0.0478008427,
0.0067739259,
-0.0020494929,
-0.0237094574,
0.0416983366,
0.0446055233,
0.0497968197,
0.0141049167,
0.05134416,
-0.027199842,
0.0571436211,
0.0730641782,
0.0226077456,
0.0390317328,
0.0728560239,
0.0167444125,
-0.0170149896,
0.0418522954,
0.0145893199,
-0.046361316,
0.0457346253,
-0.0108878277,
0.039261356,
0.0320307054,
0.0194383897,
-0.020323731,
-0.0484933071,
-0.0266922377,
0.0234551206,
-0.0003335307,
-0.0203367192,
0.0378094986,
0.0080122519,
-0.0737338588,
0.0034948261,
-0.0253853723,
-0.0768642649,
-0.0177260041,
-0.0070672086,
0.0220599752,
0.0731034353,
0.0697792694,
-0.0528882854,
-0.040472392,
-0.0081552174,
0.040494144,
0.0332867801,
0.0529539809,
-0.0265668016,
-0.0083463453,
-0.023135202,
0.0046540294,
-0.0281742401,
0.0145105412,
-0.0121848872,
0.0176932774,
-0.0213068016,
0.0045926855,
-0.0581460781,
-0.0535304733,
0.0434127748,
0.0166764632,
-0.0084921783,
-0.0289796237,
-0.0185909793,
0.0113134021,
0.0192854162,
-0.0195330754,
0.0349742435,
0.036510326,
-0.0442206822,
0.0240877401,
-0.0188417286,
-0.0435683914,
-0.0143327536,
0.0442842878,
0.0075984467,
-0.031841848,
-0.0138146477,
-0.0306002498,
-0.0509770028,
0.0309374724,
-0.0256164111,
0.0050632562,
-0.0145421214,
0.0456705056,
-0.0107566249,
-0.0157403853,
-0.0007255893,
0.0930962041,
-0.0084371669,
0.0327219889,
0.010949377,
-0.041186478,
0.0134576848,
-0.0165885221,
-0.0001875178,
-0.0077589443,
-0.0128393415,
-0.0002887812,
0.0086584957,
0.0594134256,
-0.07141646,
-0.0619517229,
-0.0726955459,
0.0325042717,
-0.0534139387,
0.0546980873,
0.0462941788,
-0.0168985035,
-0.013272089,
-0.0004364868,
-0.0631132647,
-0.015418658,
0.0121990023,
0.0285417177,
0.0642899573,
-0.0055796509,
-0.0344167985,
-0.0457327515,
-0.0366203599,
-0.0366964526,
0.0160968099,
-0.0048491689,
-0.0066442029,
-0.0063004242,
-0.0008895773,
0.0021978761,
-0.0146137709,
0.0109985918,
-0.0172553919,
0.0251195487,
-0.0296103247,
0.0818205252,
0.0770886689,
-0.0145669784,
0.0243975278,
0.0304159857,
-0.0234153457,
-0.0052513233,
0.0115981773,
0.0341558009,
0.0401341505,
-0.0259212088,
-0.0569720268,
0.0247286446,
0.0702554658,
-0.0249112193,
0.0440456979,
-0.0471858568,
0.0069889911,
-0.0038351822,
-0.0147565547,
-0.009778739,
0.0296898708,
0.0068237237,
0.0474378131,
-0.0326286964,
-0.0231916774,
0.0217753835,
-0.0563316531,
-0.0125443488,
0.0068243472,
0.0241045654,
-0.06853576,
0.0680032969,
0.0376804247,
-0.0144379539,
-0.0307039861,
-0.0187143721,
-0.0465935767,
0.0235848092,
0.0240674168,
-0.0397959426,
0.0840494856,
-0.0733709633,
0.0012492053,
-0.0477544591,
-0.050181713,
-0.0111204805,
0.0042468393,
-0.0056836591,
0.0100554274,
0.0541693605,
-0.0301189106,
-0.0354525633,
-0.0071514798,
0.0324019529,
0.0489740148,
-0.0282044448,
-0.0204799883,
-0.0146408025,
0.0353044793,
0.0224287566,
-0.0217047911,
0.0054830424,
-0.0554848015,
0.0065223253,
0.0585220382,
0.0028216348,
0.0001594863,
-0.0115639931,
0.0133857513,
0.0298280437,
-0.0242398232,
-0.0485368632,
0.0281218644,
0.0328188539,
-0.0629914701,
-0.0181978513,
0.1230208054,
0.0261866711,
-0.0052510761,
-0.0212972388,
-0.0539377108,
0.1020001397,
0.0352022201,
0.0444634408,
-0.080276899,
0.0029491324,
-0.0031930625,
-0.0001467475,
0.0159210283,
-0.0435745306,
0.0078575555,
-0.0895268619,
0.0385071486,
-0.0057752756,
-0.057985872,
-0.02104,
-0.0238046311,
-0.0060780477,
0.0016403688,
-0.0025223116,
0.0504043289,
-0.036868196,
0.0160450153,
0.0114625199,
-0.0673582256,
-0.0224396158,
0.0078297146,
-0.0196998324,
0.0530965477,
0.0589209571,
0.0249167215,
-0.0159146711,
-0.0522322878,
0.0417461358,
0.0329840444,
0.0056195394,
-0.0310097281,
0.0615407526,
0.0193489175,
0.005083329,
-0.0297636483,
-0.0008210498,
-0.0392374024,
-0.0066477624,
0.0197379328,
0.059581209,
-0.0229465049,
-0.0015864061,
-0.0061667757,
-0.0382382162,
-0.0168670602,
0.0642995685,
0.0657115355,
-0.009981811,
-0.0909017846,
-0.0638962388,
-0.0223381445,
-0.0717868283,
0.0286054332,
0.031363178,
0.0066836881,
0.0126881637,
-0.0490539148,
-0.0312938914,
0.0733854547,
0.0363615267,
0.0108457115,
0.0207221415,
-0.0414742678,
-0.0391109362,
-0.0514542907,
-0.0124335736,
-0.0260635763,
0.0139467716,
-0.0703314021,
-0.0413889289,
-0.0297540408,
-0.0136085739,
0.0167357121,
0.0008259587,
-0.0724008828,
-0.0380165577,
0.0110638626,
0.0362358093,
0.0241514593,
0.0033165754,
0.0150360232,
-0.0388723798,
-0.0352235436,
-0.0080407811,
-0.0726992562,
0.008371626,
0.0070107128,
-0.0489531495,
0.0218152311,
0.0269548781,
-0.0209890995,
0.0013723035,
-0.0098614348,
0.0535108671,
0.036613673,
0.0520502739,
0.0302928928,
0.0348209627,
-0.0284343157,
0.0147756236,
-0.032402236,
-0.0055308398,
0.0028828376,
-0.0923065096,
-0.0248030797,
-0.0122420369,
0.0052268831,
0.0144409314,
0.0042490955,
-0.0039571677,
0.0494730137,
0.0096517894,
0.0661988184,
-0.0581553988,
0.0178047195,
0.011678705,
-0.0302380081,
0.0268484857,
-0.030436771,
-0.0257699564,
-0.0200446527,
-0.0013328339,
0.0471764542,
-0.0232797731,
0.0621929429,
0.0172997508,
-0.0259388275,
-0.0128654186,
0.0638674498,
-0.0479874872,
-0.0368241332,
-0.0036841657,
0.0160005633,
0.0225308817,
0.0015726647,
0.0563669465,
-0.0209937952,
-0.0128038591,
-0.0014587621,
0.0282009188,
0.0439433828,
-0.0086454162,
0.0047310372,
0.0353799798,
-0.0173266847,
-0.076466158,
0.1033661291,
0.0446953177,
-0.0211787745,
0.023146864,
-0.0131938634,
-0.0552059785,
-0.0014218558,
-0.0088321129,
0.0149949221,
-0.0195141099,
-0.0460767746,
-0.0580564328,
-0.0369383954,
0.025800027,
0.073663272,
-0.0155989816,
-0.0299820658,
0.0098586287,
0.0799749047,
0.0236482583,
-0.0298823714,
-0.0390112624,
0.0129274596,
0.0107370149,
-0.0384536646,
0.0015497403,
-6.612251967e-33,
-0.0396148153,
-0.0167183559,
0.0299831796,
-0.0043532923,
-0.011598899,
-0.0316870101,
-0.0658019781,
0.0130332708,
0.0106631266,
0.0003205789,
-0.0555380769,
0.0278814528,
0.007136323,
-0.0148661202,
0.0415973216,
-0.0168787483,
0.0601762459,
-0.0102304183,
-0.0453051515,
0.0199877098,
-0.0194799211,
-0.0027792803,
0.050422851,
-0.0323847421,
0.0103670657,
-0.0142144719,
0.0220132153,
-0.0252312757,
0.0208464898,
0.0389879234,
-0.0141973002,
0.0029400256,
0.0407911688,
-0.0309291463,
-0.0346280485,
-0.0001480567,
-0.0975332409,
-0.0430258885,
0.0222049654,
0.0101519516,
-0.0552309342,
-0.0284375865,
0.0260064658,
-0.0028974556,
0.0000647554,
-0.023645822,
0.0156882871,
-0.0250918977,
-0.02164126,
0.009975791,
-0.0440892912,
0.0295273978,
-0.0080683008,
0.0260824114,
0.0441258214,
0.005454252,
0.0182999894,
0.0109885177,
-0.0534790568,
0.0129808998,
0.0026530165,
0.0519577712,
0.0848565102,
0.0050453832,
0.0205378849,
0.0442269929,
0.0133048305,
0.076180324,
-0.0328893661,
0.0270438325,
-0.0059447368,
0.0448140465,
0.0371114388,
0.0175053962,
0.0307063498,
-0.0026919057,
-0.0509103127,
0.0418801233,
0.0107180662,
0.012905919,
-0.0088298954,
0.021089578,
-0.038919989,
-0.0229953825,
-0.0137128122,
0.038176313,
-0.0303727668,
-0.0180444345,
0.0169200227,
-0.0322880596,
0.0233788509,
-0.0203607082,
0.015936397,
0.0126487045,
-0.0241372976,
0.0357300192,
-0.0495694838,
0.0422918573,
-0.0107081598,
0.0068801898,
-0.0199497901,
-0.0466411412,
-0.0057594473,
0.0185143482,
0.0479075238,
0.0287601463,
0.050175935,
0.0240106229,
-0.0876781568,
-0.0058356742,
-0.0418579914,
0.0477710254,
0.0308039431,
-0.0144246779,
0.0271868519,
0.0018416899,
0.0042255879,
0.0307826623,
0.037629243,
-0.0112374714,
-0.0440037139,
0.0124335559,
0.013142067,
-0.0151797608,
0.0113696828,
-0.0131898541,
-0.0724678636,
0.0127351955,
0.0450700782,
-0.0419549793,
-0.007202568,
0.0294785835,
2.832e-7,
0.0639416352,
0.061541792,
0.0386481136,
0.057412114,
0.011671531,
0.0005665131,
-0.0310494825,
-0.018687455,
-0.0269561447,
-0.0169029497,
0.0108172214,
0.0060469988,
0.0623228624,
0.0582985543,
-0.0442650057,
0.0087930076,
-0.0604003109,
-0.0075331875,
-0.0646878704,
-0.027287459,
0.0400646031,
0.0501947589,
-0.0588493869,
-0.0060957773,
-0.0072974591,
-0.0416653827,
0.0495416559,
-0.0231260341,
0.0213318355,
0.0447803698,
0.0194368437,
-0.0174971018,
-0.0200376566,
0.0455306657,
-0.0133334333,
-0.0269975159,
0.0102466475,
0.0792111307,
0.0043499591,
0.0435255542,
0.0344158337,
-0.0670118257,
0.0176387541,
-0.0871336907,
0.0687037185,
0.0005813612,
-0.0151471328,
0.0668840557,
-0.0174837206,
-0.0077063176,
0.014524959,
-0.0084439944,
0.0007689478,
0.0292902775,
0.0144891655,
-0.0415507741,
-0.0093982005,
-0.0259954687,
-0.0569036156,
0.0224643685,
-0.0075278766,
-0.0210821722,
-0.0690817982,
0.0011580923,
-0.0147158224,
-0.0446853861,
-0.0363621227,
3.14639476e-34,
0.0409384891,
-0.0101471012,
0.0463705882,
0.0342461765,
0.0570318624,
-0.0229903739,
0.0209881179,
0.0141646704,
-0.0099968286,
-0.0900943726,
-0.0104715908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08960v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08960v1 | ODSum: New Benchmarks for Open Domain Multi-Document Summarization | 2023-09-16T11:27:34 | 2023-09-16T11:27:34 | Yijie Zhou, Kejian Shi, Wencai Zhang, Yixin Liu, Yilun Zhao, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Open-domain Multi-Document Summarization (ODMDS) is a critical tool for
condensing vast arrays of documents into coherent, concise summaries. With a
more inter-related document set, there does not necessarily exist a correct
answer for the retrieval, making it hard to measure the retrieving performance.
We propose a rule-based method to process query-based document summarization
datasets into ODMDS datasets. Based on this method, we introduce a novel
dataset, ODSum, a sophisticated case with its document index interdependent and
often interrelated. We tackle ODMDS with the \textit{retrieve-then-summarize}
method, and the performance of a list of retrievers and summarizers is
investigated. Through extensive experiments, we identify variances in
evaluation metrics and provide insights into their reliability. We also found
that LLMs suffer great performance loss from retrieving errors. We further
experimented methods to improve the performance as well as investigate their
robustness against imperfect retrieval. We will release our data and code at
https://github.com/yale-nlp/ODSum. | [
-0.0033368338,
0.0227784663,
0.0424981229,
-0.0041285148,
-0.0226071905,
0.0001524769,
-0.0190879349,
0.0096203191,
-0.0088389227,
-0.0475259833,
0.0102359578,
-0.0107688606,
0.0146975163,
-0.0358230472,
-0.0528466068,
-0.0594339408,
0.0362587199,
0.0060692024,
-0.0222796779,
0.0008983188,
0.015126422,
0.0114529245,
-0.0055976054,
0.0242340807,
0.0290018078,
-0.0100993859,
0.0007999066,
0.0017908912,
0.0132203121,
-0.002952646,
0.024795346,
-0.0318084508,
0.025385011,
0.0037752378,
0.0000019012,
-0.0575278662,
-0.0699108317,
0.0011716236,
0.0458508544,
0.0054273331,
0.0861103982,
-0.0687709749,
0.0281981025,
0.0090256184,
-0.0038293875,
-0.0048538558,
-0.0236578062,
0.028370427,
0.0677856058,
0.0711834133,
-0.0092596123,
-0.0277135484,
0.0440686941,
0.0227360893,
-0.0402652547,
-0.0508127287,
0.0125419954,
0.0150140757,
0.0069378475,
-0.0404350497,
0.0152831776,
0.0000020877,
-0.0460288748,
-0.0118086329,
-0.0140970917,
0.0054728603,
-0.0554187857,
-0.0012016057,
0.0078734262,
0.0771916807,
0.0367538743,
0.0586808734,
0.0385897309,
0.0208901074,
0.0013977876,
0.0330833383,
-0.0852869079,
0.0614163503,
-0.0196646862,
0.0365171954,
-0.0320793651,
0.0654336736,
-0.0225194525,
0.0380817987,
-0.035258878,
0.0289217997,
-0.0050710118,
-0.0029563804,
-0.0280254651,
-0.0206117127,
-0.0100356778,
-0.0364836268,
0.0042739143,
0.0475945957,
-0.0029794679,
-0.0079577127,
-0.0549159534,
-0.095729053,
0.0647040829,
-0.0232461337,
0.0406633914,
-0.0041085817,
0.0433706865,
0.0503622554,
-0.00726307,
-0.000449247,
0.0278180223,
-0.0080266353,
-0.0560134239,
-0.0459388122,
-0.040674556,
0.0263156686,
-0.0092061386,
0.0759267434,
-0.0431246236,
-0.0090853078,
-0.024939511,
0.0260156412,
-0.0057890965,
-0.004742953,
-0.0158715378,
-0.0025609192,
0.0130865416,
-0.003178712,
-0.0250885319,
0.0504058301,
-0.0020705021,
-0.0395255946,
0.0368586145,
0.0048319232,
-0.0319816135,
-0.0045414376,
0.0446179286,
0.030679794,
-0.0123414807,
0.0388779491,
-0.0008536285,
-0.0658542216,
-0.0185012873,
-0.0513442345,
0.0204699207,
-0.0527840182,
0.0177710783,
-0.0649804771,
0.0112055158,
0.0089109084,
-0.0057827677,
-0.0338939503,
-0.0010968563,
0.0384961516,
-0.0452456027,
-0.0258839745,
-0.0387201384,
-0.0031788307,
0.0151600167,
0.02363028,
0.0025127705,
0.0712142289,
0.0255193859,
0.0266510546,
0.0713916197,
0.0506163128,
-0.0109547237,
0.0002476648,
0.0093925698,
0.0342702232,
0.0373254418,
0.0021163195,
-0.0085573075,
-0.0120153958,
0.0398332663,
0.0344082117,
-0.0573546514,
0.0212818384,
0.0124956034,
0.0608504638,
0.0170105193,
-0.0065139122,
-0.0449273363,
0.0375523418,
0.0524313375,
0.0443514735,
0.0434362404,
0.0333162583,
-0.0169378556,
0.0492863916,
0.0947758928,
0.0394807793,
-0.0195314642,
-0.0533200987,
-0.005067375,
-0.0156198116,
-0.0353110395,
-0.0065113972,
0.0512206964,
-0.0025212688,
-0.019857483,
0.0457820445,
0.0325659253,
-0.0910991654,
-0.0027362413,
0.0013189777,
0.0037961393,
-0.0072624101,
0.0431221575,
-0.0999071822,
0.0090299211,
-0.0089081526,
0.0257542152,
-0.0197232012,
0.0523128361,
-0.0106814848,
0.0040551331,
-0.0557082854,
-0.0470572822,
-0.0233148318,
0.0080828452,
-0.0018597661,
-0.0065573826,
-0.0287843328,
0.0429255106,
-0.0411041379,
-0.0514732599,
0.0163914058,
-0.0049703708,
0.0097506568,
0.0216807574,
-0.0503114574,
0.008840153,
0.0464320593,
-0.0076799942,
0.0219773147,
0.0303953774,
0.0028801716,
-0.0310616624,
-0.0339428186,
-0.0023623095,
0.0130129801,
0.0530917011,
-0.0648991168,
-0.0281569082,
0.0273267943,
-0.0287312679,
-0.0484218486,
0.0383223258,
-0.027923258,
-0.0150667503,
-0.0492385104,
-0.0120372577,
0.0314158835,
0.0059839641,
-0.0368150622,
0.0629762858,
0.0101534938,
0.0218117945,
0.0349151939,
-0.065644592,
0.0221299399,
-0.0117355781,
0.017761508,
-0.0193034969,
-0.0272227004,
0.036473006,
0.05515863,
0.0086442642,
-0.0347620547,
-0.0185013805,
-0.0845232308,
0.0271394216,
-0.0059580882,
0.0040942081,
0.0274887495,
0.0462780856,
0.0120358113,
0.0228058249,
-0.0286321416,
-0.024485549,
0.0377886929,
-0.0065470426,
0.0267862622,
-0.0119600957,
0.0292504895,
-0.0181827471,
-0.0102580013,
0.0005446739,
0.057060454,
-0.0254893471,
-0.0010100506,
0.009848455,
0.0152952336,
-0.0596416481,
-0.0215205327,
0.0047990493,
0.0537292287,
-0.0078626536,
-0.0332626961,
0.0343978181,
0.0085061127,
0.0407169908,
-0.0010868979,
0.0645720363,
-0.0208150782,
-0.0606860183,
-0.0151816234,
-0.0236270111,
0.0196118988,
0.046636153,
-0.0002364856,
0.048124209,
-0.0140648987,
0.011883175,
-0.0183641743,
0.0181686729,
0.0153444316,
-0.018028155,
-0.0011272617,
-0.0621141046,
-0.000221969,
0.0114230923,
0.0406031758,
0.0028635995,
-0.0249547884,
0.0283447877,
-0.0031627361,
0.0286441389,
-0.066060476,
0.0092637027,
-0.0943358615,
0.0439576395,
-0.0275244638,
0.0332565382,
0.0069559589,
0.0083380071,
0.0051034749,
-0.0113113774,
0.0400995687,
-0.0484694317,
0.0819232762,
-0.0486299954,
0.0185412914,
-0.0484256148,
-0.0142246485,
0.0036663306,
-0.0009763997,
0.0055695898,
0.0225091148,
0.002985524,
-0.0012936791,
-0.0871304348,
-0.0253936425,
0.0406757444,
0.0518898368,
-0.0390841216,
-0.0411613509,
0.0033682601,
0.0598342456,
0.0548692606,
0.0044147931,
0.023664372,
-0.0308684278,
0.0092687644,
0.0713919178,
0.0444645248,
-0.0435508415,
0.0273348074,
0.0004888952,
0.001961835,
-0.0786333978,
0.0246830154,
-0.0307731908,
0.0114681944,
-0.0145425573,
-0.0011281976,
0.0834850147,
0.0320253111,
-0.0504976436,
-0.0435078666,
0.010266521,
-0.0089852503,
0.0137527324,
-0.0158363041,
-0.0815866366,
-0.0037203433,
0.0011161875,
0.05196134,
0.0146228541,
-0.048274409,
-0.0284780469,
-0.0640150458,
0.0277754311,
0.0091420207,
-0.0538407154,
-0.0123789487,
-0.0604701936,
-0.0036170178,
0.0000948634,
0.0107298577,
0.0387044102,
-0.039700672,
-0.0097345449,
0.0009381605,
-0.0369557105,
0.0273988787,
-0.0261781886,
-0.0366002657,
-0.0262956154,
0.0251942147,
0.0329094939,
0.0211304463,
0.0146150831,
0.0190244634,
-0.0206031557,
-0.0364937596,
-0.0051100892,
0.0643208772,
-0.0107272491,
0.02309414,
-0.0392017551,
0.0351048671,
-0.0371807702,
0.0131866988,
0.0288949534,
0.0305261295,
0.013642868,
0.0010149602,
-0.0729852468,
-0.0047681397,
-0.0755399913,
0.0386135094,
-0.0092891818,
0.0227019079,
-0.0146645578,
-0.0215086844,
-0.028027175,
-0.0649541467,
0.0016488293,
0.0028798864,
-0.0709687546,
0.0054412661,
-0.0512766875,
-0.0434414819,
0.0169874933,
0.0060954657,
-0.0382720493,
-0.0378604271,
-0.0131006148,
0.0267656241,
-0.0417103469,
0.0087473253,
-0.0225859955,
-0.0060510919,
-0.022471644,
0.012428225,
0.0711375698,
-0.0158522837,
-0.0132907173,
0.0168411639,
-0.021145381,
-0.0416935198,
0.000599765,
0.0143781146,
0.0214318577,
0.0315856822,
0.0282122623,
-0.0092636198,
0.0502022952,
0.0499275066,
-0.0079122251,
0.0091620628,
0.0232500546,
0.0156303085,
-0.0213229489,
0.0197732821,
-0.0836813375,
0.0441587158,
-0.0802538544,
0.0300070886,
-0.0061112656,
-0.0468072332,
0.0176239386,
0.064985849,
0.0301314052,
0.004647783,
-0.0122670112,
-0.0224019233,
-0.0339657404,
-0.0370341614,
-0.0435357392,
-0.0279538594,
0.0629471987,
-0.012228827,
-0.0165040959,
-0.0014891957,
0.1005528271,
0.0112268422,
0.0288329907,
-0.0362781584,
-0.0098658018,
-0.0171871949,
-0.0148616517,
-0.0571694747,
-0.0225922484,
-0.0473950692,
-0.0248494372,
-0.0709481612,
-0.013532917,
-0.0131933978,
-0.0205108561,
0.0280392878,
0.0423023365,
-0.0143197412,
0.0123052085,
-0.1084247604,
0.0606525876,
-0.0347903743,
-0.0173238907,
0.0333926678,
-0.0212243181,
0.0669364259,
-0.0004159331,
-0.0108300606,
-0.0108320117,
0.0186490584,
0.0348795727,
0.0233436376,
-0.0491961651,
0.0165687613,
0.0135213379,
0.0176216997,
0.1152732819,
-0.0595888011,
-0.0146918008,
-0.0030886,
-0.0251471866,
-0.0328123122,
-0.0493090264,
-0.0054900441,
0.0611445494,
0.0035851831,
-0.0729868338,
-0.0386333764,
0.0286927689,
0.0448641814,
0.0151364449,
0.0169598144,
-0.0149748847,
0.0277144033,
0.0370118618,
0.0256604683,
0.0243437458,
-0.0441663712,
-0.0340045169,
-0.0664305091,
-0.0189501066,
0.0295522455,
-5.754784674e-33,
-0.0003634827,
0.0015803024,
-0.0354992077,
0.0349280387,
-0.0251189265,
-0.0034656047,
-0.0152667854,
-0.0177020319,
0.0323568657,
-0.0211338457,
-0.0225940477,
0.0265806857,
0.0107350647,
0.0415511467,
-0.0028103692,
0.0410607196,
-0.0041121985,
-0.0260568336,
-0.0498111136,
0.0083577428,
0.0697084963,
0.0032738312,
0.0286512692,
-0.043221537,
0.0328007154,
0.0044955635,
-0.0157546885,
-0.0388233475,
0.0591783784,
0.0038278301,
0.018993834,
0.0343066752,
0.0266568195,
-0.0019138781,
-0.0493306406,
-0.0262746662,
-0.062397372,
-0.0415104367,
0.0007245549,
-0.0568632856,
-0.0307625011,
-0.0197045859,
0.0316727795,
-0.0237737615,
0.0079914695,
-0.0711001828,
0.0380730256,
-0.0333185606,
-0.0696730614,
-0.0874642059,
0.0216758102,
0.0331493802,
-0.0495376065,
-0.0026459401,
0.037642695,
0.0287617594,
0.0206997413,
0.0192619525,
-0.0187245961,
0.0608414747,
-0.0157164484,
0.0321829692,
0.0084086843,
-0.0081679663,
0.0177172571,
0.0823572055,
-0.0032244092,
0.0003391623,
-0.0029088368,
0.0062892055,
0.002816909,
0.0039650425,
-0.0144703146,
0.0406691693,
0.0285641998,
0.0314354189,
-0.0785792023,
0.1283684373,
-0.0185767226,
-0.0083954986,
0.0067114993,
0.0086210119,
0.0281583648,
0.0083889915,
-0.0030692844,
0.0381378829,
-0.0114943665,
0.0119050099,
-0.0332138315,
0.0393307805,
-0.0438461266,
-0.0684286505,
0.0093972348,
-0.028331304,
0.0225188658,
0.0249491911,
0.0039966549,
0.0177407376,
0.0050236909,
-0.0464196615,
-0.0074563571,
0.0081070894,
0.0296800081,
0.0195493568,
-0.0138504105,
-0.0122630857,
0.0308054741,
-0.0036579443,
-0.0287670195,
0.0037623646,
0.0026467107,
0.0135165825,
-0.0491085686,
0.0200117119,
-0.0186859388,
0.0016357586,
0.016130656,
0.0264217239,
0.0061978484,
0.0168371312,
-0.0422860943,
-0.0244800914,
0.0291982796,
-0.0090134861,
0.0216209274,
0.0349674635,
-0.0064115971,
-0.0060634189,
0.0534906536,
-0.0030142427,
0.0046497425,
0.0213762708,
2.583e-7,
0.0543234274,
0.032401748,
0.0589171834,
0.0716316253,
-0.0261677764,
0.0117287338,
-0.0337255709,
0.0482820794,
0.011523312,
0.0233115554,
0.0394872874,
0.000801155,
0.045867186,
0.0661824644,
-0.0972182304,
-0.0569382049,
-0.0494325832,
-0.07561142,
-0.0271436032,
-0.0386339948,
0.0576796047,
0.0399291925,
-0.0190125387,
-0.0067242617,
-0.0293982401,
-0.0262115896,
0.0506282523,
-0.0071280361,
-0.0198312942,
0.0004962973,
0.0961617902,
-0.0451376475,
0.0098198391,
-0.0383814164,
-0.0014557453,
0.0282306056,
0.0636304095,
0.0349950567,
0.0245654173,
-0.0175990332,
0.0298411753,
-0.0526246578,
0.0343923196,
0.0445143208,
0.0463592261,
-0.0234135762,
-0.0028023899,
0.0087449569,
-0.0492184088,
0.0289310943,
-0.0167755876,
0.0211389437,
-0.0297953654,
0.0735579506,
-0.0274073128,
0.0094995983,
0.0455506109,
-0.0542123839,
-0.0085395984,
0.0387986749,
0.0275904667,
-0.04210696,
0.0128187994,
0.0099293618,
0.0037638869,
-0.0601170547,
-0.0256408062,
2.245831319e-34,
0.0839794204,
-0.0109925382,
-0.0598823316,
-0.0296235736,
0.0297693238,
-0.0494414866,
-0.0390581749,
-0.0042293668,
-0.0159792267,
-0.0945265889,
0.0158890728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08958v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08958v2 | Monolingual or Multilingual Instruction Tuning: Which Makes a Better Alpaca | 2023-09-16T11:22:46 | 2024-01-31T03:42:04 | Pinzhen Chen, Shaoxiong Ji, Nikolay Bogoychev, Andrey Kutuzov, Barry Haddow, Kenneth Heafield | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Foundational large language models (LLMs) can be instruction-tuned to perform
open-domain question answering, facilitating applications like chat assistants.
While such efforts are often carried out in a single language, we empirically
analyze cost-efficient strategies for multilingual scenarios. Our study employs
the Alpaca dataset and machine translations of it to form multilingual data,
which is then used to tune LLMs through either low-rank adaptation or
full-parameter training. Under a controlled computation budget, comparisons
show that multilingual tuning is on par or better than tuning a model for each
language. Furthermore, multilingual tuning with downsampled data can be as
powerful and more robust. Our findings serve as a guide for expanding language
support through instruction tuning. | [
0.0393392853,
0.0619704351,
-0.0099084349,
0.0725813136,
0.0007984625,
0.0345542207,
0.0395698883,
-0.0164265446,
-0.0021770517,
-0.0453939773,
-0.0610305741,
-0.0508468971,
-0.0281898528,
-0.0221571717,
0.018700581,
-0.0134909693,
0.0625256449,
-0.0569076352,
-0.0332407877,
-0.0309217442,
-0.0129218679,
0.0326205082,
0.0007202504,
0.0257175621,
0.0448690653,
-0.0293242875,
-0.0071466807,
0.0059579252,
-0.0042511048,
0.0230025928,
0.0242518187,
0.0361843817,
0.0252400786,
0.0342827588,
0.0000020021,
-0.0529036,
-0.0291592535,
-0.0220226981,
-0.0251691081,
0.0345791988,
0.0204035323,
-0.0032774748,
0.0010937263,
0.041659832,
-0.0191883594,
0.0111226467,
0.059274029,
-0.0155052906,
0.0802722275,
0.0717498064,
0.0069437874,
-0.0489379205,
0.001053817,
-0.0192968547,
-0.0174352974,
-0.0731704384,
-0.0023749955,
0.0047588577,
-0.0024709003,
0.0157284085,
-0.013350754,
0.0268866681,
0.0270736217,
0.0026896494,
-0.0331511982,
-0.0012397127,
-0.0563500114,
-0.0188733824,
-0.018742092,
0.0831331536,
-0.0215653647,
-0.0059652189,
-0.0379965082,
0.0220054556,
-0.003385884,
-0.0318127833,
-0.0382134207,
0.0343626589,
0.0316959061,
0.0054235212,
0.0665593445,
-0.0381569304,
0.0078944303,
0.0398592204,
-0.0293732658,
0.0563113466,
0.0235582776,
-0.0255762301,
0.0206666738,
0.0182065684,
-0.0404009521,
-0.0127595635,
0.0133177694,
0.0571066029,
-0.0453547426,
0.0232934114,
-0.0318863094,
-0.0229860414,
0.0301898941,
-0.0629735738,
0.0493884087,
0.0460274816,
-0.0074870051,
0.0683638155,
-0.0180090033,
0.0364756957,
-0.0103692692,
0.0099135917,
-0.0711105242,
-0.0254424624,
-0.0256746728,
-0.0005244577,
-0.0500547513,
0.0152887655,
-0.0696515739,
0.0233479552,
-0.0150498357,
0.0398348086,
0.033631932,
-0.0127953961,
-0.0048297187,
-0.028681349,
-0.0383998156,
-0.0101940995,
-0.0081337839,
0.0772137195,
-0.0577157103,
0.0190071557,
-0.0306985043,
-0.0874904394,
-0.0151480427,
0.0161630381,
-0.0165296178,
-0.0221505966,
0.0577658862,
0.0716020241,
-0.0205165278,
-0.0341194347,
-0.0261347722,
-0.0037886619,
0.0087495847,
-0.0722748712,
0.0089302482,
-0.0585499294,
0.0457812212,
0.0200127307,
0.0320005864,
-0.0123322038,
0.0016441045,
0.0311349928,
-0.0369803049,
0.0452622287,
0.0085839359,
0.0228447895,
0.0400827527,
0.0003919523,
0.0263352077,
0.1028793603,
0.0168125555,
0.0016401369,
0.0563398488,
-0.0344890058,
-0.0344659574,
0.0470932759,
0.0069339122,
0.0384403318,
0.0217778552,
0.0519609638,
0.0372776315,
0.0209779795,
0.0248369742,
0.0127483318,
-0.0052345246,
-0.0281547215,
0.0492011905,
0.0365465209,
0.0141945146,
0.035095986,
0.0191165265,
0.0008616805,
0.013633782,
-0.0184395779,
-0.0124663142,
0.0284206439,
-0.044129882,
-0.0114682419,
0.0278809909,
0.0445944369,
-0.0626497567,
-0.0411913767,
-0.0164685473,
-0.0038732102,
-0.0079269195,
0.0312624797,
0.0344708003,
-0.0190425068,
-0.0308972504,
0.0458430275,
0.0613330752,
-0.0071803294,
-0.0209343098,
-0.0696405172,
0.0234019943,
0.0432509109,
0.0139004951,
-0.0193090513,
-0.0323163457,
-0.020627765,
0.0444105901,
0.0545195788,
0.048043333,
-0.0108124139,
0.0420976654,
-0.0469932444,
0.0124535393,
-0.037520431,
-0.0130872661,
0.0432868451,
0.0182141159,
0.0128484145,
-0.0193725247,
-0.0217165463,
-0.0528029352,
0.0207340382,
-0.0485303923,
-0.0486690588,
0.0184462052,
0.0120859258,
0.0202203002,
0.0092122126,
-0.0049390323,
-0.0187680237,
0.0249391533,
-0.0310841836,
0.0113205798,
-0.0271077361,
-0.0198578611,
-0.0183769409,
0.0344237536,
-0.0072876937,
-0.0165024512,
0.0315616764,
-0.0427681282,
-0.034426067,
0.0297706332,
-0.0382551774,
0.0327539705,
-0.0248671863,
0.0254480187,
-0.0255836882,
0.0323678888,
-0.0410641022,
0.0236069709,
0.002794449,
0.0362650789,
0.0235775597,
-0.0094295731,
0.0108115468,
-0.0404611453,
-0.012708093,
0.0342594497,
0.0037777049,
0.023394715,
0.0156469792,
0.0730396211,
-0.0404845029,
-0.0328056589,
-0.0906623527,
0.0413057692,
-0.0342577323,
0.0368739814,
0.0356367342,
0.0325019024,
-0.0180726144,
-0.0312170442,
-0.0368348323,
-0.0048902873,
0.0037790802,
0.0471900105,
0.0293906387,
0.0134653021,
-0.0199952293,
-0.0474859662,
-0.0192699768,
0.0279048793,
0.0306990612,
0.0047878036,
0.002677273,
-0.0643627495,
0.0159098916,
-0.0391412973,
0.0246723294,
-0.0013441612,
-0.0679811239,
-0.0235275347,
0.008824409,
0.0300895385,
0.098958604,
-0.0135834478,
-0.0004991778,
0.0614801161,
0.0307807233,
-0.0384185538,
0.0417126976,
-0.0044922032,
-0.0908673853,
-0.0296458118,
-0.0250791255,
0.0132743428,
0.0733921304,
-0.0534675047,
-0.0261221137,
-0.035538666,
-0.0029023415,
-0.0117397495,
-0.0191768017,
-0.0745227933,
0.0489486307,
0.021456847,
0.020021759,
-0.0166388471,
-0.0526419915,
0.0679084808,
-0.0138797993,
-0.0257426128,
-0.0905988216,
-0.0351764373,
-0.0625323206,
0.0213153549,
-0.0160448533,
0.0386384353,
-0.0666964278,
-0.001037761,
-0.0456958413,
0.0223555863,
0.0141771883,
-0.0199498422,
0.0334408954,
-0.0545658506,
0.0105923889,
-0.0365297385,
-0.0563812442,
-0.0085429009,
-0.0257725753,
-0.0097886585,
0.004532095,
0.0205331817,
-0.0048893485,
-0.0516555011,
-0.0090708211,
0.0499736145,
0.0295366962,
-0.0099590896,
0.0084750261,
-0.0196932759,
-0.0033960622,
0.0553120039,
0.0292130858,
0.0032393702,
-0.0516632944,
0.0605717078,
-0.0066400161,
0.0160990339,
-0.0288201366,
0.014093467,
0.0073520504,
0.0631923229,
-0.0264897067,
-0.0333729386,
0.0027010206,
0.069786422,
-0.0267659742,
-0.0133585725,
0.0988063216,
0.0338268168,
-0.0451170243,
-0.0094240764,
-0.0465201996,
0.0296420474,
0.0312842391,
0.0736396536,
-0.0913078636,
-0.0409782976,
-0.0231266655,
0.0309358127,
0.0194830969,
0.0097670397,
-0.0220224988,
-0.1378504932,
-0.0030053181,
-0.0249378569,
-0.075197868,
-0.0408452712,
-0.0656206384,
-0.0188746229,
-0.0179854874,
0.0530453138,
-0.0085030673,
-0.0179834515,
-0.0117757535,
0.0187539887,
0.0117273675,
-0.0211854316,
0.0257239304,
-0.0151220802,
0.0340885445,
0.0288565233,
0.0332509801,
-0.0027852298,
-0.0308812968,
0.0166788734,
-0.0124644674,
-0.0007926031,
-0.02462532,
0.0031936122,
0.0044785202,
-0.0213515274,
0.0120819556,
0.0262969546,
-0.0423885547,
0.0411525182,
0.0407508388,
0.0606243834,
0.0149434814,
0.0246815812,
0.0184707884,
-0.0230092648,
-0.0069972719,
0.0675286204,
0.0211078115,
-0.0684598759,
-0.0282676332,
-0.0255965665,
-0.0611244701,
-0.0482279323,
-0.0217147693,
0.02455437,
-0.0639555082,
0.0195847265,
-0.0563387349,
-0.0315046459,
0.0446097292,
0.0044400245,
-0.0047432887,
0.0019423679,
-0.0314491354,
0.0317026488,
-0.0084013436,
0.0422393829,
-0.048116751,
0.0113794748,
-0.0851440579,
-0.0451390259,
0.0298858583,
-0.0363409147,
-0.0142113743,
0.0093541676,
-0.0494805835,
-0.0656309202,
-0.0098109851,
0.048769854,
0.0161787663,
0.0362220742,
-0.0079774875,
-0.0633265749,
-0.005503187,
0.0115449512,
0.001171381,
0.0255957264,
0.0435908921,
0.0137466993,
-0.0195665713,
0.0573563054,
-0.0315929204,
0.0233089142,
0.0246707741,
0.0363188274,
-0.0242762584,
-0.0547409877,
0.0072955596,
0.0460468195,
-0.0189097915,
-0.0017055433,
-0.0413986035,
-0.020313466,
0.0661154166,
-0.0214154664,
-0.009152744,
-0.0151198115,
-0.0191421434,
0.0194211863,
-0.0464729443,
-0.0012249647,
0.0084030237,
0.0036766506,
0.0002435444,
-0.0356824696,
0.0406705029,
0.0135081615,
0.0202821456,
0.0181641243,
0.0304018371,
-0.0285398867,
0.0100198211,
0.0243924856,
0.0593772046,
-0.0146289337,
0.0468334369,
-0.0031850641,
0.0096049281,
-0.0263482295,
0.0334112197,
-0.0226221364,
-0.0624571517,
-0.0015407024,
0.044845622,
0.0661729425,
-0.0069853282,
0.0751951188,
0.0025713898,
-0.0335144661,
-0.01851568,
0.0085206171,
0.0223061647,
-0.019452896,
0.0391239561,
0.0110272383,
-0.0100074885,
0.0209612902,
0.1010427848,
0.0006011084,
0.0699069425,
-0.0104415324,
0.0174561311,
-0.0164356455,
-0.0019037488,
-0.0141757755,
0.004168849,
-0.0053967549,
0.05097555,
-0.0086937156,
-0.0656711683,
-0.0661465973,
-0.0058866907,
0.0106346877,
-0.0072132819,
0.0186960138,
0.0636450425,
0.0162442159,
-0.0222620498,
-0.0616327897,
0.0098121883,
-0.03674151,
-0.0052745324,
0.0000274692,
-6.574383416e-33,
-0.0347887352,
0.027265694,
0.0107696522,
-0.0068113529,
0.0135748824,
0.0171132535,
0.0036470902,
0.0007309733,
-0.0637751669,
-0.0190614909,
-0.0298518464,
-0.0022870798,
0.0136699788,
0.0207141098,
0.0041177068,
-0.006856475,
0.0130435107,
-0.005996719,
-0.0153777339,
0.0183405429,
0.0355602242,
0.0117132328,
0.0562438481,
-0.002148798,
-0.0031542564,
-0.0246551614,
0.0050256881,
0.0376209281,
-0.0026888612,
0.0499451868,
-0.0218555871,
0.0591389798,
0.0275786128,
-0.0519710444,
0.0134693151,
0.011104567,
-0.0668226331,
-0.0304599293,
0.0378152132,
0.0095661478,
-0.023234548,
-0.0613167435,
-0.0077934242,
0.0183892101,
-0.0012430293,
-0.0091605587,
0.0150642265,
-0.0572195463,
0.0092463009,
0.0078905923,
-0.0629856363,
0.0007078514,
-0.0228296611,
-0.0157882161,
-0.0241974518,
0.0644888207,
-0.0269067176,
0.009941767,
-0.0215115864,
0.0199395977,
0.0264786948,
0.057308469,
0.0680811852,
0.0151149482,
-0.0125350263,
-0.0110350195,
-0.0164001361,
0.0088590486,
0.0206629056,
0.0028735159,
0.0149443969,
-0.0016025634,
0.0516562574,
0.0233115852,
0.0292651784,
0.0020324297,
-0.1249799281,
0.0100291111,
0.0539467931,
0.0226834603,
0.0068121608,
0.0051112701,
-0.0101398584,
-0.0071238368,
-0.0575619601,
0.0303553063,
-0.0305611473,
-0.0225447621,
0.0314065926,
0.0103127416,
-0.035402175,
-0.0186007116,
0.0355018228,
-0.0366016179,
0.0073347548,
-0.0068610325,
-0.0188792888,
0.0106309,
-0.0000180277,
0.0475894213,
-0.0590019338,
-0.0455050766,
0.0056183455,
-0.0308422334,
0.0103414441,
0.0097579472,
0.0479422361,
-0.0167009924,
-0.0720014796,
0.0101528838,
-0.0299904868,
0.0306822676,
-0.006049009,
0.0534310304,
-0.0019666106,
-0.0107954079,
-0.0085114418,
0.0968931392,
0.0102257393,
0.0189697277,
-0.0304995645,
-0.081235975,
-0.0050442116,
0.011687154,
-0.0584148467,
0.031970568,
-0.0301827267,
0.0045412723,
-0.0137043409,
-0.0731297433,
-0.0327503756,
-0.0112579931,
2.738e-7,
0.033239916,
0.057360854,
-0.0152318738,
0.0516366512,
0.0111025358,
0.0047103949,
-0.0113809407,
0.0177314691,
0.02199772,
0.0242982227,
-0.0248067416,
0.0443479121,
0.0676006079,
0.0259875599,
-0.064673312,
-0.0261584315,
-0.0540000163,
0.0297990311,
-0.061990764,
-0.030255422,
0.0101161236,
0.1189160272,
-0.0118746152,
-0.0058494769,
-0.0267493408,
-0.0291631967,
0.0596142672,
-0.0272467881,
-0.0410911143,
0.019657921,
0.0430326015,
0.0553596877,
-0.0075959335,
0.0031349964,
-0.0230641887,
0.032586392,
-0.0067154425,
0.0745172948,
-0.0074983011,
-0.0047520953,
0.0424310565,
-0.015772162,
-0.0220597424,
-0.0347172879,
0.0977536887,
-0.0146589093,
-0.0356978476,
-0.0215234626,
0.0259454045,
-0.0160769466,
0.0503292717,
-0.0590202734,
-0.0189829152,
0.0340310484,
0.0179122947,
-0.0431330502,
-0.0007471859,
-0.0553728603,
0.0098670311,
0.0178827848,
-0.0010112422,
-0.0438048355,
-0.0316555165,
-0.0218673088,
0.0126570221,
-0.0599038154,
0.0306036733,
2.35773884e-34,
0.0296423454,
-0.0186228994,
0.0397627614,
0.0349022709,
0.0335093215,
-0.0171062648,
-0.0146000599,
-0.0119843353,
0.0219663363,
-0.0936233848,
0.0009280867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08952v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08952v2 | Cross-Lingual Knowledge Editing in Large Language Models | 2023-09-16T11:07:52 | 2024-05-30T13:49:47 | Jiaan Wang, Yunlong Liang, Zengkui Sun, Yuxuan Cao, Jiarong Xu, Fandong Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge editing aims to change language models' performance on several
special cases (i.e., editing scope) by infusing the corresponding expected
knowledge into them. With the recent advancements in large language models
(LLMs), knowledge editing has been shown as a promising technique to adapt LLMs
to new knowledge without retraining from scratch. However, most of the previous
studies neglect the multi-lingual nature of some main-stream LLMs (e.g., LLaMA,
ChatGPT and GPT-4), and typically focus on monolingual scenarios, where LLMs
are edited and evaluated in the same language. As a result, it is still unknown
the effect of source language editing on a different target language. In this
paper, we aim to figure out this cross-lingual effect in knowledge editing.
Specifically, we first collect a large-scale cross-lingual synthetic dataset by
translating ZsRE from English to Chinese. Then, we conduct English editing on
various knowledge editing methods covering different paradigms, and evaluate
their performance in Chinese, and vice versa. To give deeper analyses of the
cross-lingual effect, the evaluation includes four aspects, i.e., reliability,
generality, locality and portability. Furthermore, we analyze the inconsistent
behaviors of the edited models and discuss their specific challenges. Data and
codes are available at https://github.com/krystalan/Bi_ZsRE | [
0.067395322,
-0.0009610558,
-0.0125644039,
0.0457847454,
-0.0377244502,
-0.0087749287,
0.0175157413,
-0.0227330737,
-0.0039086784,
-0.0562841743,
-0.1044746339,
-0.0214438513,
0.0165752955,
-0.0036307578,
0.0303553399,
-0.0467992797,
0.0601428188,
-0.0215461291,
-0.0367058702,
-0.0031907549,
0.0007200695,
-0.0177091602,
0.0471249484,
0.0204726141,
0.0273332987,
-0.0185861997,
0.0028624523,
0.0079970229,
0.0287162289,
0.016956795,
-0.0023845395,
0.056013234,
-0.0009608608,
0.0503191017,
0.0000020458,
-0.045477625,
-0.0554519072,
0.0182092655,
0.0231988151,
0.0565872192,
0.0266286265,
-0.0501134731,
-0.0443979017,
-0.0147881852,
-0.006077704,
-0.0234811697,
0.0577371344,
0.0446584709,
0.0613012761,
0.0859468803,
-0.0018380795,
0.0010397491,
0.0117868334,
-0.0546050146,
0.0032045767,
-0.0314208157,
0.055957444,
0.0434825867,
-0.0564103164,
0.0340875722,
-0.0222031102,
0.0503089353,
0.0017751022,
-0.025211975,
-0.0042949691,
-0.0097689573,
-0.0461962782,
0.0140207326,
0.0092914626,
0.0399871282,
-0.0115230996,
-0.0120997839,
-0.027845135,
0.0133840349,
0.0199899189,
0.0195894707,
-0.0429406315,
0.00167699,
0.0346971639,
-0.0063985186,
0.0058577317,
-0.076697059,
0.0395040251,
-0.0049611833,
-0.0071380064,
0.0648405254,
0.0522692651,
-0.041481398,
-0.0278229844,
-0.0063033011,
0.0039705224,
-0.0911621526,
-0.0225711558,
-0.0011521149,
-0.0162542257,
0.0271065328,
-0.0383019894,
0.0119092986,
0.0082896687,
-0.0577865764,
0.0196239743,
0.0379484817,
-0.0264102966,
0.0629436523,
-0.0194094162,
0.0478429943,
0.0073718862,
0.0006116645,
-0.0451341346,
-0.0140434895,
-0.0694135278,
0.0010662049,
-0.0459715948,
0.015495467,
-0.0150250392,
0.0187039841,
-0.0696026906,
0.0171419512,
-0.0231844839,
0.0339730196,
0.0115064625,
-0.0478162616,
-0.0354014486,
-0.0265837088,
-0.0156201376,
0.0572604574,
0.0055465186,
0.0003290701,
-0.0208177641,
-0.0230434202,
0.0113931,
-0.0230646897,
-0.0123066828,
-0.0515601486,
0.0052964231,
0.0561707579,
-0.0310155842,
0.0001556386,
-0.0549479872,
-0.03566771,
-0.0010650672,
-0.0639008209,
-0.000169094,
-0.0562087707,
0.0326857939,
-0.0047262027,
0.0078415107,
-0.0448943079,
0.0028107839,
-0.0310206413,
-0.0394226909,
0.0650363415,
-0.0166195054,
0.0410064943,
0.0271919668,
0.0136234779,
-0.0342626795,
0.0812899321,
0.025886612,
-0.0300081093,
0.090558894,
-0.0214398634,
0.002545974,
0.0643378273,
-0.0129313543,
0.0275818016,
-0.0192062035,
0.0130429128,
0.0364244618,
0.0146352192,
0.0219263919,
0.0204545241,
-0.0302744005,
0.0238236617,
0.0746925324,
-0.0066018612,
0.0386076942,
0.0413753428,
0.046090696,
-0.0488359183,
0.0171822421,
0.0181887541,
-0.0412200466,
0.0157068651,
-0.0298638456,
0.0383662656,
0.0081662973,
0.004723385,
-0.0272191465,
-0.0291839465,
-0.0141361542,
0.0067261416,
0.0125890383,
-0.0098214578,
0.0550072715,
0.0053764149,
-0.0059091216,
0.0333896503,
0.0323110186,
-0.0307478663,
0.0159971137,
-0.0458708517,
0.0037381882,
0.071546793,
0.0556108579,
-0.033058878,
-0.0497253872,
-0.0090913745,
-0.0177544393,
0.0113046067,
0.0846357197,
-0.0322672427,
-0.0343148485,
-0.0217753258,
-0.0349567235,
-0.0559044033,
0.0257057846,
0.0157027394,
0.0620534569,
0.0292283911,
0.0180732664,
-0.0551711284,
-0.0330183394,
-0.0082459711,
-0.0583660044,
0.0211342704,
-0.0213149749,
0.000870181,
0.0024118337,
-0.0168149658,
-0.0470145755,
-0.0180523861,
-0.0286932085,
-0.0140875783,
-0.0253409259,
0.0240333974,
-0.0005241759,
-0.042657312,
0.0577930883,
-0.0128951753,
-0.0267146379,
-0.0009398352,
-0.0472971983,
-0.0335921571,
0.0019836104,
0.0204234682,
0.053162314,
-0.0548534282,
0.0566406511,
-0.0113252578,
-0.0219155736,
0.0074329283,
0.0171425696,
0.015626194,
0.004400094,
0.0075848843,
-0.0057190731,
0.0093086204,
-0.0101538589,
-0.0464772321,
0.0375855416,
0.0100134732,
-0.0103115579,
0.0175360311,
0.0148578444,
-0.024296714,
-0.0376565494,
-0.093532443,
0.0026630724,
-0.036191754,
0.0058951918,
0.0488965772,
0.0336336903,
-0.0229505394,
0.0037688594,
-0.0160631072,
0.0072930674,
-0.0180889945,
0.0664666519,
0.0133560309,
0.0218497887,
0.0074493536,
-0.0481989495,
0.0034750488,
0.0285438858,
0.0385980494,
-0.0017666385,
-0.0324430913,
-0.0578819886,
0.0655377582,
-0.081265077,
0.0104593923,
-0.0105734868,
-0.0453856401,
-0.0459387675,
0.0105271544,
0.1043278277,
0.0235764179,
-0.0521037392,
-0.0028651727,
0.0739639476,
-0.0384502858,
-0.0016722765,
0.0069090412,
0.0337055735,
-0.0546343625,
-0.0341059417,
-0.0393784754,
0.009836778,
0.0585772172,
-0.001118998,
-0.0645117536,
-0.0456042252,
-0.0120556056,
-0.0410798118,
-0.0219186228,
-0.0266425256,
0.0134532657,
0.0049471138,
0.0206054673,
-0.0463544615,
-0.029456947,
0.059750434,
-0.0173496883,
0.0169387925,
-0.0369639955,
-0.0083285822,
-0.0364509672,
0.0482666641,
-0.0253322907,
0.0355486237,
-0.0224265344,
0.00965924,
-0.0768115744,
-0.0100329975,
0.0345573165,
-0.0043596546,
0.0468535535,
-0.0680119991,
0.0108556813,
-0.0324668698,
-0.0068584057,
-0.0042068199,
0.0184804499,
-0.0079299221,
0.0396349467,
0.0438207164,
-0.019654816,
0.000251437,
0.0350468941,
0.0562409051,
0.0812866911,
-0.0151965329,
-0.0111413524,
0.0058630933,
-0.0130658932,
0.0482418537,
0.0054271994,
-0.0103368536,
-0.0243696496,
0.0495483503,
0.0251774322,
0.0122917034,
-0.055383414,
0.0177525375,
-0.0051029874,
-0.0029022912,
-0.0910893306,
-0.0357557498,
-0.0193258766,
0.0745969191,
-0.054083433,
-0.0086347237,
0.1121469215,
0.0280365907,
-0.0284774974,
0.0017128476,
-0.0565337464,
-0.0143084321,
0.0453139842,
0.0418299325,
-0.0938427448,
-0.0136176925,
0.0193355661,
-0.0225348212,
-0.0082188109,
-0.0302922875,
-0.0112392241,
-0.1080855653,
0.0321857557,
0.0009774001,
-0.073943533,
-0.0580114499,
-0.0177590698,
0.0233606715,
-0.0156233329,
0.0117905382,
0.017198246,
-0.0107259238,
0.0019871495,
-0.0424687117,
-0.028741939,
-0.0507247671,
0.0342191234,
-0.0371573046,
0.046483472,
0.0354025401,
0.0212291759,
0.0054672407,
0.0011887334,
0.0165013336,
0.0275588091,
0.0040450087,
-0.0175428763,
0.0090421289,
0.0151648894,
-0.0015249887,
0.0447096042,
0.0016655505,
0.0316984281,
-0.0066746413,
0.0579023696,
0.0836670846,
-0.0006806929,
-0.0128379455,
0.0293434542,
-0.0224536248,
-0.020487627,
0.0811973214,
0.0165981725,
-0.0222800728,
0.0078099146,
-0.0513502769,
-0.0504709221,
-0.0059858151,
-0.01552667,
0.0067003113,
-0.0676520467,
-0.0064956541,
-0.0728512704,
-0.0624377429,
0.0475384891,
-0.0169008821,
0.0597645529,
0.0272693615,
0.0089521715,
0.0006090136,
-0.0024714051,
-0.0135020446,
-0.0594670512,
0.0118804015,
-0.0301097594,
-0.0154982479,
0.0268681068,
-0.0515729561,
-0.0004230751,
-0.0023980523,
-0.0318042636,
-0.0515231155,
-0.0162529927,
0.0294217337,
0.015748309,
0.0639188141,
-0.0022607991,
-0.027547067,
0.0200166125,
-0.007517979,
-0.0080545042,
0.0405322537,
0.0279581267,
0.0274467748,
-0.0035957389,
0.0553393215,
-0.0662217811,
-0.0151090492,
0.0445300043,
0.0520015135,
-0.0190600418,
-0.0188954081,
0.0042554433,
0.0311028063,
0.003603295,
0.0134558128,
0.0088358754,
-0.0741261765,
0.0620124675,
-0.0629752204,
-0.0377507582,
-0.0227502882,
0.0049473317,
0.0304263067,
-0.0085622193,
-0.0123487394,
0.0516050942,
-0.017629059,
0.0024872327,
-0.0284329336,
-0.0109778289,
0.0142186545,
0.0189245846,
0.0438370369,
0.0104453238,
-0.0226710085,
0.0006405145,
0.017495336,
-0.0090877637,
-0.0264718588,
0.0432323776,
0.0010178693,
-0.0339142308,
-0.0195151996,
0.0335773006,
-0.0528284833,
-0.0255301055,
-0.0068601421,
0.0481818803,
0.0670920834,
0.014220139,
0.0582257025,
-0.0475870036,
-0.0548639707,
-0.0334311873,
0.0478820764,
0.0423409678,
-0.0122404555,
0.0131592322,
-0.0135514773,
-0.034801811,
0.025931688,
0.0836075246,
-0.0008064155,
0.104820691,
-0.027876066,
-0.0437411778,
-0.029909702,
-0.029390065,
0.0354102775,
-0.0222330093,
-0.0355926715,
-0.0176671837,
-0.0605631843,
-0.0658839941,
-0.0072341384,
0.0099758171,
-0.0381574966,
0.0244515873,
-0.0195504054,
0.0736655518,
-0.004850137,
0.02405072,
-0.0425863527,
-0.0041787876,
0.0074557951,
0.0039541405,
0.0146102766,
-5.882237649e-33,
-0.019059822,
0.0307349674,
0.0268507004,
-0.0120043037,
-0.044577159,
-0.0081316857,
-0.0388365686,
-0.0019768677,
0.005747173,
0.0154817505,
-0.0258184057,
0.0061933533,
-0.0018715926,
-0.0155057525,
0.0135290409,
0.0218868367,
0.0797429085,
0.0290560126,
-0.0150381187,
0.0092245508,
0.0270605478,
0.0356883332,
0.1251319945,
-0.0067946189,
0.0726687312,
0.0310559887,
0.0096692806,
0.0165910292,
-0.0222209841,
0.0545577556,
-0.0077514816,
0.0292050466,
0.019007571,
-0.0592787713,
-0.0340590104,
-0.0674131066,
-0.039219711,
-0.0147700598,
0.0411646441,
0.0516842343,
0.0072413064,
-0.0496109426,
0.0341860503,
-0.0133369649,
-0.0249157883,
-0.0270900466,
0.0180763472,
-0.0503068231,
0.006315114,
-0.0081808735,
-0.0857695788,
0.0200596154,
0.015300652,
-0.0135681853,
-0.0157152731,
0.0080858935,
0.0237290561,
-0.0213855784,
-0.0571162775,
0.0200000498,
0.0489340723,
0.0619732663,
0.0773003921,
-0.0213511791,
0.0128355306,
0.010606288,
-0.0002968732,
0.0260283258,
0.0226354413,
-0.0107086515,
0.0028467618,
0.024384886,
0.0111061754,
0.0821382701,
-0.0184804909,
-0.0069350302,
-0.0780373812,
0.0163598433,
-0.0323737375,
0.0325115696,
-0.0252953619,
0.0425858162,
0.0166936945,
-0.0034206072,
-0.0411918163,
0.0032364079,
-0.0368779078,
-0.0361221917,
0.0213213768,
0.0091422815,
-0.00600413,
0.0034647402,
0.0424773581,
-0.035230767,
-0.0187419206,
0.0245928038,
-0.0325342454,
0.0392445102,
-0.0081122648,
0.0006977256,
-0.0250938796,
0.0063866875,
0.0212674141,
0.0010494082,
-0.023042053,
-0.0101267183,
0.0639291927,
0.0353167057,
-0.0610684343,
0.023444524,
-0.0118585061,
0.0167048443,
-0.0105806515,
-0.0066536446,
-0.0031540478,
-0.0155212227,
-0.0103316568,
0.0041294438,
0.0720353052,
-0.009746857,
-0.023753278,
0.0157171935,
0.0031359813,
0.0086758239,
-0.0075234291,
0.0367104635,
-0.0243347082,
-0.0027321989,
0.0239281282,
-0.0111645358,
-0.0299259387,
0.003152594,
2.734e-7,
0.0439981893,
0.0364721119,
-0.0093640452,
0.0245154109,
0.036255978,
0.0237264596,
-0.0575005449,
0.0229624286,
0.0214400254,
0.0193509813,
0.0184552632,
0.02686904,
0.0319804549,
0.0271095969,
-0.0679462925,
0.0178647377,
-0.0213137046,
-0.0044165398,
-0.0425877124,
-0.0232426245,
-0.0031278145,
0.0497974493,
0.0070057614,
0.0193126928,
-0.0204936676,
-0.0492170714,
0.0740762129,
-0.0425873473,
-0.0409539081,
0.0561834164,
0.042747546,
0.0502961837,
0.0149003351,
0.0259855147,
-0.0310497452,
-0.0069122245,
0.0341723748,
0.0757204965,
-0.0029520469,
0.039641656,
0.0029567282,
0.0138799502,
-0.0073075094,
-0.0747109875,
0.0788453519,
-0.0292938408,
0.0061317557,
-0.0056632897,
-0.0064286739,
0.0156661328,
0.030016683,
-0.0479021855,
-0.0051926216,
0.0288222861,
0.0199931283,
0.0564768463,
-0.0537666418,
-0.0030314738,
-0.0401843116,
-0.0023968096,
0.0093360944,
-0.1004301012,
-0.0252571199,
-0.0510374308,
-0.0059967819,
-0.0683385357,
0.0098733082,
2.385564536e-34,
0.0222555716,
0.011174283,
0.008668608,
0.0051858365,
0.05146854,
-0.0422682725,
-0.0174311064,
-0.003202386,
-0.0368961692,
-0.0538971126,
-0.0297240205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08949v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08949v1 | Enhancing Large Language Model Induced Task-Oriented Dialogue Systems Through Look-Forward Motivated Goals | 2023-09-16T10:56:00 | 2023-09-16T10:56:00 | Zhiyuan Hu, Yue Feng, Yang Deng, Zekun Li, See-Kiong Ng, Anh Tuan Luu, Bryan Hooi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, the development of large language models (LLMs) has been
significantly enhanced the question answering and dialogue generation, and
makes them become increasingly popular in current practical scenarios. While
unlike the general dialogue system which emphasizes the semantic performance,
the task-oriented dialogue (ToD) systems aim to achieve the dialogue goal
efficiently and successfully in multiple turns. Unfortunately, existing
LLM-induced ToD systems lack the direct reward toward the final goal and do not
take account of the dialogue proactivity that can strengthen the dialogue
efficiency. To fill these gaps, we introduce the ProToD (Proactively
Goal-Driven LLM-Induced ToD) approach, which anticipates the future dialogue
actions and incorporates the goal-oriented reward signal to enhance ToD
systems. Additionally, we present a novel evaluation method that assesses ToD
systems based on goal-driven dialogue simulations. This method allows us to
gauge user satisfaction, system efficiency and successful rate while overcoming
the limitations of current Information and Success metrics. Empirical
experiments conducted on the MultiWoZ 2.1 dataset demonstrate that our model
can achieve superior performance using only 10% of the data compared to
previous end-to-end fully supervised models. This improvement is accompanied by
enhanced user satisfaction and efficiency. | [
0.0761369988,
0.035136994,
0.0127632273,
0.0317886062,
-0.0244501419,
0.0123429382,
0.0059821727,
-0.0340439454,
-0.0149748223,
-0.0146882571,
-0.0570736565,
-0.0374936573,
-0.0390556492,
0.0530608445,
0.0176516585,
-0.062710993,
0.0512354448,
-0.0451612175,
0.0110733956,
-0.004421392,
0.0080724899,
-0.0006764827,
-0.0227042995,
0.0700540319,
0.0077804574,
-0.0145813022,
-0.0469755828,
-0.0020864997,
0.00197014,
-0.0186970122,
0.0251577329,
0.0470382981,
0.0322146863,
0.0498605892,
0.0000020971,
-0.0642141625,
0.0200036746,
-0.0234004166,
-0.0514464267,
-0.0146957813,
0.0263763387,
0.0392422527,
-0.0123019246,
0.0215214416,
-0.0334705114,
0.0139599768,
0.024849439,
0.0589306131,
0.0762208551,
0.0589892454,
0.0011672196,
-0.0235574879,
0.0248113647,
0.0091013806,
0.0234539825,
-0.0371656902,
-0.0061826664,
0.0354872867,
0.0154295284,
0.0043950737,
0.0158216413,
0.0195940882,
0.0228804182,
-0.0512796231,
-0.0085938843,
0.0263526738,
-0.0140573578,
-0.0241455249,
-0.0281881057,
0.0800585672,
0.0084291752,
0.0015416637,
0.0060170619,
0.0055193021,
0.0150294369,
-0.0394891873,
-0.0586280711,
-0.0001455191,
0.0015782189,
-0.0015234418,
0.0044539692,
0.0353705622,
-0.0012296676,
0.0377799869,
-0.0201190785,
0.0539505035,
0.0142519008,
-0.0244466774,
0.0018790966,
0.0016765316,
-0.0062903701,
-0.0683431923,
0.0049813138,
0.056768138,
-0.0904821157,
0.02990303,
-0.024901066,
0.0011579131,
0.0060960129,
-0.0399909019,
0.0332971923,
0.0351950563,
0.0056677703,
0.0531958491,
0.0059043034,
0.0306807216,
-0.0165176727,
-0.0181533098,
-0.0620472617,
-0.0243366286,
-0.0165967885,
-0.0156176761,
-0.0733937621,
0.0362841785,
-0.0264926944,
-0.0596649908,
-0.0315538719,
0.0802457035,
0.0265162624,
-0.0132178394,
0.0118021639,
0.0386315957,
-0.0149495136,
-0.0017206524,
-0.0495257676,
0.0155054126,
-0.0507022329,
0.0084563754,
0.0391466133,
-0.0239626002,
-0.013354552,
0.0443639271,
-0.0037631805,
-0.0202591531,
-0.0111120176,
0.0734013468,
-0.0207827799,
-0.0357793011,
-0.0028425544,
-0.0433674827,
-0.0181556549,
-0.0471592024,
-0.0040489668,
-0.0420551337,
0.038707979,
-0.0009944282,
-0.0350709558,
0.0223836266,
0.0226917509,
0.0221455749,
0.0119642261,
0.036030829,
-0.0147586055,
0.0127312895,
0.0374784954,
0.0079759508,
-0.0378694125,
0.0590248331,
0.0562951192,
0.0310422033,
0.0339361653,
0.0302383378,
-0.0124899596,
0.0301144961,
0.0223347489,
0.0165587924,
0.0539588928,
0.0466910228,
-0.0146064926,
0.0423495658,
0.0316518433,
0.0548564047,
-0.0346615165,
0.0250199903,
0.0748938993,
0.0356251001,
0.0003802133,
-0.0126351109,
0.0346928313,
0.0245275348,
0.0082984259,
-0.017212037,
-0.0242832098,
0.0415381528,
-0.0188018121,
0.0243367609,
0.0576582551,
0.0049290946,
-0.0499115176,
-0.0397157855,
0.0250761565,
0.0048806812,
-0.0086131319,
0.0393604301,
0.043836277,
0.0121874968,
-0.0726683661,
0.0210850909,
-0.0090653813,
-0.0428119116,
-0.003206674,
-0.0709309727,
0.040591836,
0.0650827363,
0.0565985143,
-0.0113273896,
-0.0599424392,
-0.0289917123,
0.0259533413,
0.080261007,
0.021403579,
-0.038934622,
0.0047202632,
-0.0308412854,
-0.0150392018,
-0.0169888958,
-0.0175561998,
0.0019772926,
0.0369247608,
-0.0208847709,
0.0193685945,
-0.0200344473,
0.0116098728,
0.0147335669,
-0.0069149705,
0.0069016898,
0.0002269246,
0.0128555065,
0.0062188623,
0.0068377038,
-0.0015212203,
0.0082581006,
0.0316055007,
-0.0082355114,
-0.0209267326,
0.0328131095,
-0.0609299019,
-0.054391738,
0.0292264167,
0.0182377249,
-0.0207419544,
0.0426455364,
-0.0108280638,
-0.0507008359,
-0.00406205,
-0.0575096346,
0.0257382598,
-0.0603202432,
0.0246426146,
0.020403048,
-0.005176859,
-0.0533068329,
0.0351793654,
0.0074130106,
0.0109941009,
0.0703441501,
-0.0079156766,
0.0200459771,
-0.0429140031,
-0.006098764,
0.0223932788,
-0.0160241369,
-0.009193141,
0.033071667,
0.03025309,
-0.0806725845,
-0.0440647788,
-0.0992565528,
0.0069736214,
-0.0269374344,
0.0226744134,
0.0264003351,
0.0190451462,
-0.0031859782,
-0.0093458518,
-0.056297373,
0.0134196598,
0.0685572028,
-0.0047111744,
0.0438503847,
0.0119745033,
-0.0341205634,
-0.0444432721,
0.0226439685,
0.0156607684,
0.0145344995,
0.0010067117,
0.0305100195,
-0.0647976622,
0.0188102964,
-0.0354058258,
0.0181447454,
-0.0038605884,
-0.0110913068,
0.0367141627,
0.0050414549,
0.0886348039,
0.0375885442,
0.0355917364,
0.0286512859,
0.0037772642,
-0.0356001295,
-0.0833120793,
0.0318367891,
-0.0292077996,
-0.0177413654,
-0.0342331119,
-0.0333942957,
0.0276210736,
0.0400838219,
-0.0022156867,
0.0085138045,
-0.0313062593,
0.013786816,
-0.0076469462,
-0.034350507,
-0.02494766,
-0.0028887626,
-0.0394506007,
0.0158473104,
-0.0261869673,
-0.0277824998,
0.0938445404,
-0.0061035561,
-0.0346382111,
-0.0511043482,
0.0086292755,
-0.0250889137,
0.0557753444,
-0.019343093,
0.025497226,
0.0056448798,
-0.0380704477,
-0.0342665091,
0.0016382624,
-0.0311306585,
-0.0371700488,
0.0573316962,
-0.0392645001,
0.0016700259,
-0.0060317325,
-0.0473171622,
-0.069024317,
-0.0352614149,
-0.000478276,
0.0122642927,
-0.0098807113,
-0.0068261884,
-0.0138013978,
0.0262857489,
0.0222772583,
0.0122175431,
-0.0203533806,
-0.0313653536,
-0.0159678012,
0.0351276882,
0.1128702685,
0.0120476345,
0.0138695007,
-0.0165472534,
0.0785554945,
0.0464513041,
0.0586420558,
-0.0343949348,
-0.0144000566,
-0.0419270732,
0.0546363555,
-0.03656362,
-0.0016519524,
0.0051887338,
0.0641409755,
-0.025253335,
-0.0343114287,
0.1394094527,
0.0425790288,
-0.0270184204,
-0.0136201242,
-0.0316330828,
0.0372299701,
0.0059386664,
0.0371294208,
-0.0611220859,
-0.0344403349,
-0.0049699927,
0.0117279198,
-0.007181115,
-0.0232876055,
-0.004588325,
-0.1188901514,
0.0190111659,
-0.0327478684,
-0.0378480852,
0.0029506232,
-0.0182963852,
-0.0026273772,
0.0487096012,
0.0262453649,
0.0268951356,
0.0246505346,
-0.0223406572,
0.0029394133,
0.0070213773,
0.0005524084,
0.0272601377,
-0.0329347998,
0.0615155324,
0.0919556841,
0.0368581228,
0.0205677971,
0.0198166016,
0.0222033113,
-0.001432626,
-0.0030946762,
0.0007822734,
0.0300806295,
-0.0188906044,
-0.009625501,
-0.0635047778,
0.0211729314,
-0.0268312972,
-0.0038472326,
0.0121869659,
0.0551776327,
-0.047282286,
0.0100191794,
-0.0377248898,
0.0281984955,
0.0271097161,
0.0710228533,
0.0137392273,
-0.0852696598,
-0.0372400843,
-0.0103872065,
-0.0565505959,
-0.0651709139,
0.0059492667,
-0.0359097272,
0.0299690757,
0.0130155683,
-0.0727386773,
-0.0644155368,
0.0190545917,
0.0154969869,
-0.0275858305,
0.0069059348,
-0.0386273973,
0.0080590146,
-0.014959516,
0.0147174597,
-0.0265319869,
0.0547199287,
-0.0868472904,
-0.0028557091,
0.0417204015,
-0.0537429489,
0.010455694,
0.045955658,
-0.0868352652,
-0.0552718304,
-0.0458163433,
0.0703920648,
0.0188135765,
0.0030771182,
-0.0020357631,
-0.0333110765,
-0.0096856719,
-0.020149108,
-0.0163917392,
-0.0070689558,
0.0243008938,
0.0699942484,
-0.0029142762,
0.0334238522,
-0.0442627817,
0.0019805168,
-0.0213624053,
0.0579807982,
0.005639764,
-0.071706742,
0.0219507925,
-0.008764755,
0.044585038,
0.0047273268,
-0.0203193054,
-0.0163355526,
0.0301764607,
-0.0419165567,
-0.0273778867,
-0.0514397286,
0.0341041088,
-0.0006150792,
-0.018589329,
0.0075511266,
-0.0072592399,
-0.0378928781,
0.0042911381,
-0.0281633474,
-0.005180194,
-0.0009442677,
-0.0143970428,
0.0210110266,
-0.0021130766,
-0.0344362967,
-0.0088624312,
0.0303368345,
0.0310382098,
0.0092088347,
0.0943099484,
0.0197019912,
-0.0368934385,
0.0125307543,
0.0452653579,
-0.079541631,
-0.0478870049,
-0.0028886821,
0.0236236807,
0.0393140838,
0.0537475944,
0.0592716448,
-0.040114399,
0.0153071117,
-0.0028608618,
0.0245052464,
-0.0133252898,
-0.041789826,
0.0566856116,
0.0189337246,
0.0003192528,
-0.0109748198,
0.0528168008,
0.0116212117,
0.0183867924,
-0.0116367424,
0.0146690523,
-0.0360066742,
-0.0313420482,
-0.0021153989,
0.0314908661,
-0.0342597105,
0.0073482045,
-0.0214137714,
-0.0520466678,
-0.0318460241,
0.0296135824,
-0.0045810151,
-0.0348501168,
0.069050163,
0.0559967346,
-0.0052963863,
-0.0336116552,
-0.0431003794,
0.0282069966,
-0.0154153509,
-0.0231076386,
-0.0308681,
-6.116627549e-33,
-0.0165977459,
-0.0399347879,
0.0520939603,
0.0257025119,
-0.0614840426,
-0.0386883393,
-0.0642132163,
0.0216777418,
-0.0233641919,
0.0005937178,
-0.0304795094,
0.0166767649,
0.0143587096,
0.0376229323,
-0.0129981199,
-0.0190427601,
0.0451308899,
-0.0228384081,
-0.0285249893,
0.0157847479,
0.0186357368,
0.0182550102,
0.0037292098,
-0.0044915876,
0.048786778,
-0.0172169618,
-0.0228129253,
0.0435976237,
0.0021813693,
0.064313516,
-0.0242273714,
0.0541238375,
0.0111213923,
-0.0490154997,
-0.0308765732,
0.0420664139,
-0.0555655695,
-0.0076564592,
0.0442743562,
-0.002612649,
-0.0554412007,
-0.0064440318,
-0.0227668602,
0.004736451,
-0.015592861,
0.0187313557,
0.0006790424,
-0.0176505018,
-0.0260799211,
-0.0237611309,
-0.0779850557,
0.0033863389,
0.0014729114,
-0.0836934596,
-0.006945306,
0.0818964615,
-0.0030052629,
-0.0344765782,
-0.0052968324,
0.0162066258,
0.001693076,
0.0024041687,
0.0685936138,
0.0712977126,
0.0040705078,
0.0451176576,
0.0147768883,
0.0105184847,
-0.0090672513,
-0.0221074875,
-0.0199956354,
0.0113326553,
0.0267047714,
0.0092258751,
-0.0104262456,
0.0277851932,
-0.0521404147,
0.0449686199,
0.0300454851,
0.0186966155,
0.0433338434,
0.007080778,
-0.0256549865,
-0.0123648643,
-0.0401283838,
0.0599500984,
-0.0299274493,
-0.0522487499,
0.0500744581,
0.0354794785,
0.0061081243,
-0.0437318869,
0.0376189053,
-0.0352601223,
0.0024621242,
0.0513878167,
-0.0266847871,
0.0360390171,
-0.0269050691,
0.0033747549,
-0.0630423874,
0.0056049442,
0.021754995,
0.0250138752,
-0.0248145275,
0.0336086825,
-0.0245583709,
-0.0033079663,
-0.049626641,
0.0255835224,
-0.0490586869,
0.0353586376,
-0.0305006802,
0.0078277001,
0.0096732378,
-0.0361008644,
-0.0374947935,
0.0784001052,
-0.008377308,
-0.0532746017,
-0.053275615,
-0.011263296,
0.0260274187,
0.0064258412,
-0.031536635,
0.0252207797,
-0.0219257828,
0.0267521758,
-0.0213518385,
-0.0397542752,
-0.0213057492,
0.0044566472,
2.747e-7,
0.0123808356,
0.0193362851,
0.0147258313,
0.085527122,
0.0066147302,
0.0419501252,
0.0127967717,
-0.0010950231,
0.0581999086,
-0.0013136255,
0.0119311409,
0.0177027769,
0.0394696333,
-0.0042611482,
-0.1189189851,
-0.0437707081,
-0.0333962664,
-0.0219864696,
-0.0376384258,
-0.0238592904,
0.0764931738,
0.0615894794,
-0.0111833671,
0.0022049332,
-0.0063909306,
-0.0196701344,
0.0519452468,
-0.0148319136,
-0.0245852359,
0.0191770904,
0.0377964191,
-0.0437688641,
-0.0077381008,
-0.0083376924,
0.0037743184,
0.0191168655,
-0.0000212054,
0.0667084605,
0.0027089678,
-0.0520631112,
-0.0181197878,
-0.0370911472,
0.0478385985,
-0.0611108281,
0.0527140684,
-0.0674212053,
-0.0052130506,
-0.0217860453,
0.0269751046,
-0.0277707241,
-0.0005665308,
-0.067281127,
-0.0348875411,
-0.0046590962,
0.0099133961,
-0.0026819308,
0.0163272768,
-0.0869887099,
-0.0252918769,
-0.0128916074,
-0.0393735841,
-0.0550016463,
-0.0527955331,
-0.0024341303,
-0.0064415354,
-0.0415089205,
-0.0185366347,
2.398838439e-34,
0.0316229165,
-0.0017769603,
0.034451317,
0.0450651869,
0.0376567841,
0.0098783821,
0.0005537231,
-0.0060047535,
0.0522908606,
-0.0767884254,
-0.0378180593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08943v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08943v3 | Contextual Label Projection for Cross-Lingual Structured Prediction | 2023-09-16T10:27:28 | 2024-04-14T19:38:57 | Tanmay Parekh, I-Hung Hsu, Kuan-Hao Huang, Kai-Wei Chang, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Label projection, which involves obtaining translated labels and texts
jointly, is essential for leveraging machine translation to facilitate
cross-lingual transfer in structured prediction tasks. Prior research exploring
label projection often compromise translation accuracy by favoring simplified
label translation or relying solely on word-level alignments. In this paper, we
introduce a novel label projection approach, CLaP, which translates text to the
target language and performs contextual translation on the labels using the
translated text as the context, ensuring better accuracy for the translated
labels. We leverage instruction-tuned language models with multilingual
capabilities as our contextual translator, imposing the constraint of the
presence of translated labels in the translated text via instructions. We
benchmark CLaP with other label projection techniques on zero-shot
cross-lingual transfer across 39 languages on two representative structured
prediction tasks - event argument extraction (EAE) and named entity recognition
(NER), showing over 2.4 F1 improvement for EAE and 1.4 F1 improvement for NER.
We further explore the applicability of CLaP on ten extremely low-resource
languages to showcase its potential for cross-lingual structured prediction. | [
0.0118934466,
-0.0042191544,
0.0187361985,
0.0638097376,
-0.0041587581,
0.0166448243,
0.0104888184,
-0.0109561365,
0.0459295921,
-0.0246501975,
-0.075858511,
-0.0142584853,
-0.0093384543,
-0.030548539,
0.0076848064,
-0.0505311079,
0.020268511,
-0.0338434391,
0.0018533778,
0.0176644567,
0.0043649832,
0.0267790072,
0.0087118484,
0.0050890851,
-0.0009732427,
0.002814848,
-0.0077377185,
0.0306713022,
0.0308056287,
-0.0439640246,
0.0182639416,
0.0033247243,
0.0124863237,
0.0271760337,
0.0000018678,
-0.0255324095,
-0.0508564264,
-0.0003607668,
-0.0017592512,
0.0107580489,
0.0112980716,
-0.0519719757,
-0.0290940031,
-0.0136369448,
0.0027758747,
-0.0735335574,
0.0537039749,
0.0494186506,
0.0054326318,
0.0822065324,
-0.0368697345,
-0.0360607132,
0.0064321724,
-0.0360012241,
-0.0024067154,
-0.0547448434,
0.0137512125,
0.0169017948,
-0.0366028622,
0.0729228556,
0.0064520687,
0.0576767549,
0.0051851594,
0.0326533839,
-0.0353046134,
0.0341072716,
-0.0346252881,
-0.0115142697,
-0.0164566152,
0.047175996,
-0.0114031918,
-0.0111602303,
0.0157950297,
-0.0194180496,
-0.0353963934,
-0.0546013378,
-0.03106438,
0.0255662873,
-0.0268668756,
0.0284719057,
0.0923602581,
0.0496918783,
0.0222156756,
-0.0394678786,
0.0267073642,
0.0638099834,
0.0291222781,
-0.0101386905,
0.0073076878,
0.0280863568,
0.0188635774,
-0.0585011207,
0.021412259,
0.0145032899,
-0.0032656672,
0.0476660915,
-0.0624997802,
0.0001820791,
-0.022945853,
-0.0671828687,
0.0002941959,
0.0536579415,
-0.0136728482,
0.060225185,
-0.0662975609,
0.0536308475,
-0.0267160274,
0.0065829866,
-0.0519299917,
-0.0516883433,
-0.0573663823,
0.0365087204,
-0.0391612872,
-0.0024825621,
-0.0415729471,
-0.0097894827,
-0.0258661639,
0.0090762898,
0.0223326962,
0.0129167093,
0.0444860272,
-0.051702626,
-0.0475219265,
-0.02983463,
-0.0164566506,
0.0393808857,
-0.010427881,
-0.0403170139,
-0.0467467457,
-0.0327663794,
-0.0298884977,
0.0181507096,
-0.003269732,
-0.0427225381,
0.0028502489,
0.0955233797,
-0.0321134739,
-0.0100921625,
-0.050135754,
-0.0346483476,
-0.0430617556,
-0.0489762053,
0.0277330671,
-0.0482316539,
0.0434905477,
0.0110048559,
0.0143198743,
-0.0383185633,
0.0567129254,
-0.0114037367,
-0.0562917367,
0.0620670393,
0.0250157453,
-0.0174018852,
-0.0024437034,
-0.0193607081,
-0.017069513,
0.0727574751,
0.0185187422,
0.0311704837,
0.0455617495,
0.0257406812,
-0.0449972264,
0.0680304244,
0.0202353168,
0.0340743773,
-0.0052376217,
0.006338886,
0.0665579215,
-0.0290432945,
0.0013365522,
-0.0035437879,
0.0229273196,
0.0320905894,
0.0389926657,
-0.0160886347,
-0.0283686072,
0.0027314345,
0.0403182283,
-0.0432468615,
-0.0557442755,
-0.0094254492,
-0.0259447657,
0.0182737913,
0.0150743732,
0.0109905871,
0.0471130721,
-0.0016748417,
-0.0312922895,
-0.0240611136,
0.0066564288,
-0.0177615695,
-0.0179682598,
0.0033954852,
0.0433325022,
0.0193766821,
-0.0938175246,
0.0674397647,
0.0346330106,
-0.041709248,
0.0082427636,
0.0416071154,
-0.0344047397,
0.032662712,
-0.0020579426,
-0.0293604098,
-0.0496077538,
0.0237688776,
0.0454672277,
0.0296112504,
0.0499359705,
-0.0107631078,
0.067681998,
-0.0222846735,
-0.0242615137,
0.010645316,
-0.0135116251,
0.0453900434,
0.0245840568,
0.0540863909,
0.0399587899,
-0.0394767039,
-0.0391141996,
0.0265665576,
-0.0553562604,
-0.061779879,
0.0281590503,
0.0300616268,
0.0091326851,
0.0132355578,
0.0226177052,
-0.0117834015,
0.0284600984,
-0.0684677809,
0.0077674072,
0.0136531759,
-0.0331314243,
-0.0723537654,
0.0096763242,
-0.0050010849,
0.0147303091,
-0.0618137196,
-0.0286695361,
-0.0538191311,
-0.020718921,
0.0179962944,
-0.00063686,
0.0089183142,
0.034760341,
0.0231257472,
0.0029515247,
-0.0079568895,
0.0404070243,
0.0236771908,
0.0183087625,
0.0282695554,
-0.0262086932,
0.0344847143,
-0.0093538389,
-0.0177914556,
0.0409013331,
0.0339716934,
-0.0459311977,
0.0434373692,
0.0132500231,
-0.0207366459,
0.0088174678,
-0.0951928645,
0.0513856597,
-0.0136593562,
0.0573143773,
0.0373507813,
0.0277076829,
0.0031766468,
-0.0376084745,
-0.0337485746,
-0.0449759513,
-0.0342670977,
0.0093068862,
0.0162727889,
0.0441725031,
0.0007447969,
-0.0309807658,
0.0290306341,
-0.0166650657,
0.0212873798,
0.0057143508,
-0.0584659688,
-0.0702896789,
0.0676950142,
-0.0082644979,
0.0363367274,
-0.0007400289,
-0.0035721692,
-0.0268963035,
-0.0075451871,
0.0489354171,
0.038786307,
-0.0629070103,
-0.0283184405,
0.0089641241,
-0.0512329787,
-0.050492201,
0.0218337104,
-0.0180616006,
-0.0324283913,
-0.0342971981,
-0.0442066379,
0.0075355521,
0.0837117508,
0.0016912707,
0.0367817357,
-0.0953564048,
-0.0606603511,
-0.0277022906,
0.0062775523,
-0.0109103722,
0.0221128277,
0.0255255215,
0.0214480311,
-0.0281238183,
-0.0125128226,
0.0819943547,
-0.0649345592,
-0.0226144325,
-0.022918202,
-0.0067692604,
-0.0445838347,
0.0568192713,
-0.0043505882,
0.0269999243,
0.0058817551,
-0.0196715295,
-0.0427093841,
0.032811638,
0.0055949977,
-0.0089324862,
-0.0282872934,
-0.0395459719,
-0.0019453366,
-0.004018263,
-0.0222002883,
-0.031346865,
0.0051334254,
-0.0263257269,
0.0080538383,
-0.0107584642,
0.0046718814,
-0.0206548795,
0.0322308242,
0.0179866944,
0.0365475751,
-0.0113869868,
-0.0040814937,
-0.0028744587,
0.0052549602,
0.0040450939,
-0.0714416951,
-0.0440758541,
-0.0299044959,
0.0096884621,
0.0166924652,
0.0395059548,
-0.0106729856,
-0.004792355,
-0.0066419733,
0.0383589938,
0.0068123834,
-0.0689809024,
-0.0281729326,
0.0973029211,
-0.0486041792,
0.0193890017,
0.1019895002,
0.0064823572,
-0.0236636791,
-0.0352348648,
0.0005397575,
0.0339789018,
0.0187004935,
0.0432362184,
-0.0668984279,
-0.043545153,
-0.0034690849,
0.0131811406,
0.0224050973,
-0.0311170463,
-0.0096026165,
-0.1310232133,
-0.0003986712,
0.0217989683,
-0.0530061051,
-0.0318392776,
-0.034908779,
0.0024613489,
-0.0144637162,
-0.0370240435,
-0.0381854959,
0.0194838643,
-0.0031322141,
-0.0001015861,
-0.0163320899,
-0.018881252,
0.0338171497,
-0.0423049591,
0.0236685816,
0.0481759906,
0.043728102,
0.0193595421,
-0.0027390232,
0.0295801423,
-0.0311874226,
-0.0024314292,
-0.0090568773,
0.0216532405,
-0.028157739,
-0.0202038102,
0.03978974,
0.0265671462,
-0.0310240034,
-0.0080956845,
0.0341365077,
0.0963638052,
0.0364376158,
0.0180790741,
0.030577017,
-0.0239468478,
0.0613649301,
0.0538221113,
-0.0054614199,
-0.0188417658,
-0.0067473268,
-0.0182887912,
0.0247780774,
-0.0504241884,
0.0070932768,
0.0364455394,
-0.1049050093,
-0.0580767132,
-0.0749908537,
-0.0573250465,
0.0363250598,
0.0084698163,
0.0280003548,
0.0045074699,
0.0049657081,
0.0109847421,
-0.014769949,
0.0012629197,
-0.0341877528,
0.0239256769,
-0.0418766029,
-0.0000115517,
-0.0170445051,
-0.0068100579,
-0.0018559167,
0.0343370438,
-0.0542846695,
-0.0607531369,
-0.0518295802,
0.0392452553,
-0.0081013599,
0.0703622997,
-0.0104801254,
0.0029059383,
-0.011157304,
0.0000900415,
-0.0050032265,
-0.0151805831,
0.0530348346,
0.0238187313,
-0.0045402572,
0.0596837886,
-0.0446605384,
0.0377836414,
-0.0035762452,
0.0539615154,
-0.0234998204,
-0.08870022,
-0.0023766642,
0.0260793325,
0.0549968369,
-0.0384618528,
-0.041431129,
0.005721563,
0.0432080813,
-0.0294942204,
-0.0268696249,
-0.0104960483,
-0.0028921508,
0.0230180621,
-0.0214132145,
0.0105712824,
0.0437053666,
-0.0265697241,
-0.0048786923,
-0.02525465,
0.0162722487,
0.0284061451,
0.0561420955,
0.0191378482,
0.0367266797,
-0.0129147079,
0.0206734687,
0.0523732863,
0.0499711335,
-0.0819010958,
0.0276962779,
0.0145707941,
0.0200280417,
0.0031416421,
-0.0030884561,
-0.017622387,
0.0030276582,
-0.0201177225,
-0.0282776523,
0.0479450896,
-0.0330674462,
0.088228412,
-0.0200317148,
-0.0114548663,
-0.0017375347,
0.0422622487,
0.0038437755,
-0.0161583349,
0.0086250817,
0.0005245086,
0.0028956966,
0.0252979528,
0.0728906244,
0.0281482171,
0.0396962799,
0.0240448043,
0.0056673097,
-0.0173778255,
-0.0083989166,
0.0164579246,
-0.035534393,
-0.0075634932,
-0.0126098143,
-0.013870433,
-0.0372122563,
0.0305760168,
-0.0162468925,
-0.0334142633,
-0.0226682667,
-0.0161036924,
0.0533778816,
-0.0087218154,
-0.000634236,
-0.0397267751,
0.013293013,
0.0220942572,
-0.0117317978,
-0.0396811701,
-5.463497174e-33,
-0.0429418273,
-0.0001176391,
0.0172620434,
0.0382545069,
0.0106982356,
0.0157347266,
-0.0528974533,
-0.0100924447,
0.0045023235,
0.0051206676,
-0.0002871182,
-0.0397426523,
0.0350853987,
0.0071941768,
0.006501419,
-0.0131113837,
0.0249585547,
0.0027909495,
-0.013359339,
0.0377329662,
0.0443188734,
0.0427161157,
0.1176222265,
-0.1109959036,
0.0801685452,
-0.0151499156,
0.0119153559,
-0.0022296228,
0.1206879392,
0.0353515595,
0.0060832216,
0.016164232,
-0.0044375597,
-0.0781788081,
0.0073665124,
0.0131181385,
-0.0953364298,
-0.006867765,
0.0152190812,
0.0276810993,
-0.0158780515,
-0.0308136027,
-0.034492217,
-0.0100405812,
0.0281539951,
-0.0166611057,
0.023360284,
-0.0348731689,
0.0056625716,
-0.0524195991,
-0.0615565665,
0.0268912334,
0.0060294867,
0.0096396161,
0.0655234829,
0.077621296,
0.039406158,
0.0223777164,
-0.0677364394,
0.0125443302,
-0.063635312,
0.0318274423,
0.0671878904,
0.0320635885,
-0.0221137218,
0.0038561546,
0.0184240304,
0.0157667343,
0.003092455,
0.0051953364,
0.0002024864,
0.0391303301,
-0.0030995926,
0.0428533927,
0.0016008597,
0.0232621636,
-0.0626181439,
0.0398958921,
-0.0037920107,
-0.0151359141,
0.0054755062,
0.015606856,
-0.0480891652,
-0.0199595243,
-0.0301710349,
-0.0396802165,
-0.0138871912,
-0.0204666406,
0.0018256512,
0.0178845432,
-0.0206475649,
0.0478471406,
0.0607047267,
-0.0048869005,
-0.035864722,
-0.0082129203,
-0.0105835348,
-0.0017447886,
-0.0238886941,
0.0723315477,
-0.0774663687,
-0.0451206863,
0.0226171333,
-0.0047058929,
0.0339112543,
-0.0057443813,
0.0409998447,
0.0055325916,
-0.0587070063,
-0.0140921436,
-0.0531161465,
-0.0009015996,
-0.02529094,
0.0474876426,
0.0134569658,
0.0021745604,
-0.0146155441,
0.0488332026,
0.0375507846,
0.0036361136,
0.0116372732,
-0.0219632592,
0.0194778629,
0.0248830914,
-0.0236602835,
0.0140477736,
-0.027092509,
0.0093097035,
-0.0030437571,
-0.0322387964,
-0.0239385813,
0.0107039763,
2.542e-7,
0.0604149699,
0.0240892526,
0.0022309243,
0.0165908318,
-0.0061711362,
0.0463877618,
-0.0178354848,
0.0497926064,
-0.0065787225,
-0.0429074094,
-0.008462837,
-0.0058936435,
0.0496392995,
0.0599811375,
-0.0785106346,
-0.064993225,
-0.0057938052,
0.0164099354,
-0.0439281277,
0.0298332889,
0.0272412468,
0.0843601897,
0.0069733374,
0.0203150027,
-0.0223418027,
0.0033849268,
0.0537684597,
-0.0211684071,
-0.0255618431,
-0.0021893145,
-0.0342522189,
0.0537199713,
-0.0721969604,
0.0387186669,
-0.0434451252,
0.0047346069,
0.032274466,
0.0735397413,
0.0104032317,
-0.0277299546,
0.0051244358,
-0.0174325295,
-0.0311357193,
-0.0148628224,
0.0706466958,
-0.0388530642,
0.0232315063,
0.0296012405,
-0.0256924648,
0.0698884875,
-0.0242538955,
0.0202633422,
-0.0369534567,
0.0393787734,
0.0355009623,
-0.0238387417,
-0.0493351892,
-0.0218877979,
-0.0293570962,
-0.0181947034,
0.0096256034,
-0.009710242,
-0.0164148584,
-0.0247020107,
-0.0423217453,
-0.0511359386,
0.0233971104,
2.355279945e-34,
-0.0252342559,
-0.004302246,
-0.0290580411,
-0.0121331522,
0.0452335179,
-0.0440987833,
-0.0308726225,
0.0177482106,
0.004407946,
-0.0201800037,
-0.018620288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08929v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08929v2 | Leveraging Multi-lingual Positive Instances in Contrastive Learning to Improve Sentence Embedding | 2023-09-16T08:54:30 | 2024-01-31T14:25:15 | Kaiyan Zhao, Qiyu Wu, Xin-Qiang Cai, Yoshimasa Tsuruoka | cs.CL | cs.CL | Learning multi-lingual sentence embeddings is a fundamental task in natural
language processing. Recent trends in learning both mono-lingual and
multi-lingual sentence embeddings are mainly based on contrastive learning (CL)
among an anchor, one positive, and multiple negative instances. In this work,
we argue that leveraging multiple positives should be considered for
multi-lingual sentence embeddings because (1) positives in a diverse set of
languages can benefit cross-lingual learning, and (2) transitive similarity
across multiple positives can provide reliable structural information for
learning. In order to investigate the impact of multiple positives in CL, we
propose a novel approach, named MPCL, to effectively utilize multiple positive
instances to improve the learning of multi-lingual sentence embeddings.
Experimental results on various backbone models and downstream tasks
demonstrate that MPCL leads to better retrieval, semantic similarity, and
classification performances compared to conventional CL. We also observe that
in unseen languages, sentence embedding models trained on multiple positives
show better cross-lingual transfer performance than models trained on a single
positive instance. | [
0.0068876781,
-0.0045674932,
-0.0232636705,
0.0621572025,
-0.0734138712,
0.0013177032,
-0.0203377735,
-0.0469152182,
0.0032131495,
-0.020370489,
-0.041964557,
-0.0570263565,
-0.0233284179,
-0.0289495252,
0.0426130369,
-0.0534114353,
0.0313241892,
0.0249480959,
0.0066076657,
-0.0067227059,
0.0140160471,
-0.004290361,
0.0084539736,
0.0130348913,
0.0148816155,
-0.0074544386,
0.0234840158,
0.0050532394,
0.0534518622,
-0.0333887003,
0.0044500167,
0.0104354722,
0.0061711445,
-0.0114811193,
0.0000015251,
-0.0384261943,
-0.0155354394,
-0.0217811707,
0.0389012285,
-0.032926321,
0.0631567538,
-0.0384566486,
0.0201661736,
0.0066936309,
-0.0138039142,
0.002941743,
0.0268548783,
0.0822510496,
0.0266964864,
0.0449636653,
-0.0273960717,
-0.0326353498,
0.0029139537,
-0.0092361793,
-0.0318163559,
0.0308803376,
0.002298034,
0.0060568494,
-0.0060097044,
0.0277459268,
-0.0178690143,
0.0271190852,
0.0342451073,
0.0470958464,
-0.02015974,
0.0333629996,
-0.0297023524,
0.0159412585,
0.003552078,
0.0597294606,
-0.0254531074,
-0.0133922501,
-0.0385725424,
-0.0120948125,
0.0063741007,
-0.0295407753,
-0.0378569178,
0.0022945192,
0.0218584836,
0.0722523853,
0.0717624277,
0.0147106107,
0.0255820844,
-0.0012941229,
-0.0109672751,
0.0010415131,
0.0352368616,
-0.0567127094,
0.0280137435,
0.04603168,
-0.0461023301,
0.0423603579,
0.0322552621,
-0.0447807387,
0.0266682804,
-0.0012592844,
0.0150404982,
-0.0310819261,
0.0428497121,
-0.0857104734,
0.0187415648,
0.0353091545,
-0.0757190138,
0.0563491099,
-0.0637707785,
0.0165805221,
-0.0368835814,
0.0132138999,
-0.0421698242,
-0.0522128083,
-0.0459793806,
-0.0116153145,
-0.0173459221,
0.0595100448,
-0.0271825064,
-0.0098516196,
-0.0121682538,
-0.0054774,
-0.0190364048,
-0.0150399162,
-0.0056209001,
-0.0072228941,
-0.0080794059,
-0.0113710267,
0.004798328,
0.0629814193,
-0.0412061289,
0.0157759935,
-0.0523861311,
-0.0309437271,
-0.0132406261,
0.0347737558,
-0.0063997842,
-0.0472439155,
0.0136893736,
0.035197746,
-0.0288840719,
-0.0253306665,
-0.0240561739,
0.0223823041,
-0.0184815992,
-0.0455705412,
-0.0098960567,
-0.0562556349,
0.0194890853,
0.022617938,
0.013951485,
-0.0349187367,
0.0173670035,
0.0097023798,
-0.0260262657,
0.0439284518,
0.0617896356,
-0.053219378,
-0.0502966642,
-0.0180444587,
-0.0004959588,
0.0646841079,
-0.0129806595,
-0.0413535163,
0.0532865636,
0.0343816876,
-0.0373393781,
-0.0050110184,
0.0104297278,
0.0241966899,
-0.0327327698,
0.011677824,
0.0261128768,
-0.0109016784,
0.008769569,
0.0287516899,
-0.0254825912,
-0.0241659973,
0.0472107232,
-0.0053409673,
-0.017813703,
-0.0056729973,
0.0474658385,
-0.0044358009,
-0.0690009817,
0.0216765236,
-0.0297284555,
0.0166093335,
-0.012048929,
0.0085906079,
-0.0225755088,
0.0274282526,
-0.0393105708,
0.0144947972,
0.0087469704,
-0.0503372811,
0.0155798458,
-0.0248098653,
0.0647340938,
-0.0059713274,
-0.06376113,
0.0341579653,
0.0684474483,
-0.0828798637,
-0.0144906063,
0.0200768542,
-0.0073548998,
0.0211863443,
-0.0189090986,
-0.0075016697,
-0.0438203923,
0.0029813081,
-0.0298548993,
0.0616413057,
0.0435800329,
0.0076010628,
0.0528231896,
-0.0389316604,
-0.005537665,
-0.0331771672,
-0.0081346622,
0.0432450958,
-0.0290424507,
0.0284770988,
0.0087632956,
-0.0494521223,
-0.0102430275,
0.0131524717,
-0.0363806263,
0.0033306361,
0.0404100716,
0.0478285141,
0.0044004782,
0.0225515496,
0.0209743138,
0.004597072,
0.0408989005,
-0.1006070822,
-0.0328772031,
0.0452166237,
-0.0734650716,
-0.1002292112,
0.022834627,
-0.0455537029,
0.0093089901,
0.0641376749,
-0.0246710628,
-0.019260291,
0.0149565535,
0.0160091519,
0.0242324043,
-0.0282046944,
-0.0026583588,
-0.0065957475,
0.0402238145,
0.008879438,
0.0601522289,
-0.0206767581,
0.0433696955,
-0.0094617084,
-0.0227035228,
0.0461524613,
-0.0335103609,
-0.0505232103,
0.0021482799,
0.0134783015,
-0.006210349,
0.0561081357,
0.0117073236,
-0.0346898958,
0.0068661869,
-0.0713310018,
0.0247192215,
-0.0024570848,
0.0361787565,
0.0317887738,
-0.022456456,
0.0171396974,
-0.0330463722,
-0.0464405529,
-0.0171415508,
-0.0002999747,
0.0393433571,
0.0394273922,
0.0168113094,
-0.0150142731,
-0.032640446,
-0.0000062131,
0.0103852972,
0.059745349,
-0.0755572319,
-0.0245823115,
-0.0333606936,
0.0425564572,
-0.027392745,
-0.0085785324,
0.0008069633,
-0.0561862662,
-0.0248565488,
0.0069668791,
0.0502028838,
0.0288072303,
-0.020024186,
-0.0390111171,
0.056024462,
0.0060222615,
-0.0033344741,
0.0092104897,
-0.0284262616,
0.0636403263,
-0.0348644443,
-0.0265678596,
-0.0339660719,
0.0606538728,
0.0129755707,
-0.0253469273,
-0.0670742393,
-0.0376310013,
-0.0148300556,
-0.0026085121,
0.0036833852,
0.0206766352,
-0.0103549389,
0.0011080283,
-0.0373340435,
-0.0000743703,
0.074858658,
0.0002293093,
-0.0356299803,
-0.0337427966,
-0.0215386823,
-0.0172236413,
0.0504830554,
0.005445505,
0.0275339205,
0.0092932601,
0.0103358263,
-0.0480377786,
-0.051914867,
0.0522883423,
0.0008072113,
0.0060051153,
-0.0120329401,
-0.0442458652,
-0.0240557939,
-0.0935371965,
-0.0193742402,
-0.0337485112,
-0.0015560453,
0.0454564616,
-0.0127902152,
0.0324467979,
-0.0438190438,
-0.0129065486,
0.0096220076,
-0.0114320815,
-0.0207085572,
0.0144058056,
-0.0129519831,
0.0614373907,
0.0131033435,
-0.0057695382,
0.0318390019,
-0.0119474661,
0.0433217213,
0.0186892599,
0.0065931287,
-0.010037275,
0.0092222076,
-0.0209835395,
0.0403117873,
0.0016436533,
-0.0674857646,
-0.0229494199,
0.0234705061,
-0.0069184834,
-0.0223985184,
0.0765485018,
0.0142444745,
-0.0313120484,
-0.0127805909,
-0.0407349132,
0.0155540528,
0.0434565693,
-0.0051427856,
-0.0513938889,
-0.0351924375,
-0.0126311881,
0.0003642362,
0.0206636582,
-0.0102797961,
-0.0171181243,
-0.1418868005,
-0.0255675092,
0.0057231863,
-0.0332737118,
-0.0286845416,
-0.0330853499,
-0.0095403381,
-0.0259997789,
0.0134229856,
-0.0066771759,
0.025702646,
0.0020909181,
0.0212543122,
0.0090587782,
-0.0464499742,
0.0107008461,
-0.0596885346,
-0.0222675335,
-0.0076911366,
0.0597431995,
-0.024745319,
-0.0290171765,
0.0028825309,
-0.0618739165,
-0.029229138,
-0.0160931684,
0.0440900959,
0.0104222856,
-0.0169528164,
-0.0222555287,
-0.0007491989,
-0.0455347896,
-0.0245450586,
-0.0058112992,
0.1085509285,
0.0405130684,
0.0252264068,
0.0006581476,
0.015157002,
0.0083056381,
0.0718436241,
-0.0050717695,
-0.0335801356,
-0.0057375785,
0.0310739279,
0.0170369167,
-0.051409401,
-0.0009225075,
-0.0204552952,
-0.0148133636,
0.0354139879,
-0.0705535412,
-0.0742958635,
-0.0117102563,
0.0364306793,
-0.0021445106,
0.0394815318,
-0.0552560985,
-0.0114230979,
-0.0174993128,
0.0010108872,
-0.0089448998,
0.0159480777,
-0.0227453653,
0.02314106,
0.0683981553,
-0.0305714924,
-0.027075246,
-0.0528650135,
-0.0314131863,
-0.0529224351,
-0.039515797,
0.0649897829,
-0.0075429687,
0.0323391072,
0.0059153461,
0.0169173721,
0.0036717092,
0.0526566878,
-0.0283626877,
-0.0083834259,
0.0964916274,
-0.0044945488,
0.0187202916,
0.0671476424,
-0.0225503258,
0.0014009814,
0.0332263969,
0.0733518526,
-0.0015089659,
-0.0295920055,
0.0347482041,
-0.0091018397,
0.0799344182,
-0.0160122663,
-0.0039222278,
-0.033033967,
0.0146626169,
-0.0216295104,
-0.0288497582,
-0.0238595735,
0.0099900076,
0.0185501929,
-0.0088390792,
-0.0277347639,
0.0384539552,
-0.0136157284,
0.0374015346,
-0.0043948689,
0.0089172693,
0.0584670305,
0.0060504675,
-0.0262430198,
0.0367822312,
-0.0232528877,
-0.0416453518,
0.0066019925,
0.0068659657,
-0.0447920933,
0.0072821397,
0.0162361749,
0.0055053718,
-0.0211584698,
0.0184744708,
-0.010046686,
0.049790021,
0.0262875706,
-0.0339825712,
0.0941255167,
-0.0224241521,
0.0730544403,
-0.0001010501,
-0.0365080424,
-0.0091971783,
0.0354494639,
-0.0305214599,
-0.0250369366,
0.0365879759,
-0.0109203784,
-0.0099715255,
0.0117451632,
0.057476934,
-0.0820585862,
0.0294919498,
0.0025619541,
-0.0397067405,
-0.0193080865,
-0.0041992068,
0.042690862,
0.0227895118,
0.0122526875,
0.0393165722,
-0.0472388417,
-0.0594754666,
0.0205045957,
0.0051116399,
-0.0106800077,
0.0220416691,
0.0169182215,
0.0464738831,
0.0067398865,
-0.0348374508,
-0.0361861773,
0.0111675616,
-0.0005876352,
0.0122163044,
-0.0257490389,
-5.210390465e-33,
-0.0001741526,
0.0442136303,
-0.021979114,
-0.0085741421,
-0.0002019076,
-0.0131221479,
0.0032747809,
0.0066499459,
-0.0320962183,
0.0567224734,
0.0265106671,
-0.0268375091,
0.009136972,
0.0348357894,
0.0178620666,
0.0074829231,
0.0647449568,
0.0311517976,
0.0064807259,
0.0144724343,
0.078951247,
0.0437627025,
0.1211434528,
-0.0367551446,
0.0167166851,
-0.0203151517,
0.0314922817,
0.0571264289,
0.0647591874,
0.0506282076,
0.0017252637,
0.040660236,
0.0195664801,
-0.0296972468,
-0.0094124889,
-0.0293431357,
-0.0732205585,
-0.0794051737,
0.0408707596,
0.0090538943,
-0.0282599833,
-0.0381039083,
-0.010558052,
-0.0301895775,
0.0337355211,
0.0202173665,
0.0267050453,
-0.0298477914,
-0.0063420925,
0.00011809,
-0.0628356785,
0.0030965135,
0.0251767039,
-0.0100107435,
0.0134528689,
0.0828619525,
0.0077036112,
0.0380981751,
-0.0313797407,
0.0127748493,
-0.0604925603,
0.0005634609,
0.0120708086,
-0.004978782,
-0.0071560605,
0.0443445779,
0.0185078513,
-0.0216741562,
0.068021521,
-0.030533677,
0.0120035922,
-0.0010971476,
0.056194663,
0.1195104122,
0.0202773251,
0.0077618561,
-0.0739711598,
0.0088790264,
0.0210573766,
0.0112775611,
0.0460268483,
0.0196126588,
-0.0123014115,
-0.0242744703,
-0.0145148011,
-0.0643492416,
-0.0074561443,
-0.0416360125,
0.0236358326,
-0.0034466272,
-0.0304101426,
0.0208705906,
0.061652977,
-0.0311559271,
-0.0449948348,
0.0763030946,
-0.0595344454,
-0.0125811584,
0.0314439982,
0.0104662823,
-0.0736400187,
-0.0340490453,
-0.0375376493,
-0.0083158016,
-0.0092087416,
-0.0041782749,
0.1197573096,
-0.0154018179,
-0.0842723474,
0.0263352878,
-0.0204842631,
-0.0317860059,
-0.0220006406,
0.0282231309,
0.0029242686,
0.0225998908,
-0.0218928289,
0.0839722604,
0.0706687421,
-0.0244542379,
-0.0469963402,
-0.0342203639,
-0.0113661019,
0.0430102423,
-0.0059909965,
-0.0031917999,
-0.0344773866,
0.0514191426,
0.0087906355,
-0.0539774485,
-0.0272509027,
-0.0052046496,
2.26e-7,
0.0276073981,
-0.0181141943,
-0.0155831371,
-0.0047268593,
-0.0061377785,
0.0689051151,
-0.0619925596,
0.0185025167,
-0.0047791721,
0.0478794649,
0.0011960029,
0.0177609865,
0.0041930405,
0.0451092049,
-0.0702612028,
0.0761067048,
-0.0228651334,
-0.057588309,
-0.0067736055,
-0.0041408166,
0.0734970495,
0.0864282027,
0.0344209075,
-0.0088783288,
-0.019740114,
-0.0374301672,
0.0909726545,
-0.0490997434,
-0.026232386,
-0.0598626658,
-0.041551102,
0.0081087872,
0.0009518147,
0.0101632131,
-0.0118046748,
0.049495019,
-0.0089601409,
0.0203841571,
0.0163642261,
-0.0346151777,
0.0133267771,
0.0001554125,
-0.0152153634,
-0.0270025339,
0.0692547262,
-0.0579982586,
-0.0114167361,
-0.0190306436,
-0.035573218,
0.0208849497,
0.0890825689,
-0.0073328484,
-0.0666077584,
0.0023065892,
0.0176277086,
0.0087042702,
-0.0411979444,
-0.0320163406,
-0.0103133293,
0.0676806867,
0.0134605216,
-0.00076678,
0.031936083,
0.0062715923,
0.0153498976,
-0.048813235,
0.0252945255,
1.565815528e-34,
0.029507434,
0.0074739973,
-0.0008189153,
0.0169884898,
0.0098391604,
-0.044154752,
-0.0572855957,
-0.0112117808,
0.0429758914,
0.0074063139,
0.0044370838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08922v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08922v1 | Multimodal Multi-Hop Question Answering Through a Conversation Between Tools and Efficiently Finetuned Large Language Models | 2023-09-16T08:22:22 | 2023-09-16T08:22:22 | Hossein Rajabzadeh, Suyuchen Wang, Hyock Ju Kwon, Bang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | We employ a tool-interacting divide-and-conquer strategy enabling large
language models (LLMs) to answer complex multimodal multi-hop questions. In
particular, we harness the power of large language models to divide a given
multimodal multi-hop question into unimodal single-hop sub-questions to be
answered by the appropriate tool from a predefined set of tools. After all
corresponding tools provide the LLM with their answers, the LLM generates the
next relevant unimodal single-hop question. To increase the reasoning ability
of LLMs, we prompt chatGPT to generate a tool-interacting divide-and-conquer
dataset. This dataset is then used to efficiently finetune the corresponding
LLM. To assess the effectiveness of this approach, we conduct an evaluation on
two recently introduced complex question-answering datasets. The experimental
analysis demonstrate substantial improvements over existing state-of-the-art
solutions, indicating the efficacy and generality of our strategy | [
0.0361195467,
0.0335862339,
-0.0227464754,
0.0624565184,
-0.0494695082,
0.0126819648,
0.0369031169,
-0.0380026661,
0.0125146704,
-0.0600881055,
-0.0311139952,
-0.0090481685,
-0.0444405861,
0.0116022155,
0.0319406986,
-0.0646198541,
0.035229072,
-0.0556157306,
-0.0474970601,
-0.0194654576,
0.0130760903,
0.0230634529,
-0.0353866294,
0.0431720614,
-0.0178824589,
-0.0468970425,
-0.0196500495,
-0.0032823735,
-0.0270458478,
-0.0226536114,
0.0184210185,
0.0395159535,
0.0572979152,
0.0372295193,
0.0000020074,
-0.0346519314,
-0.0011299266,
0.0054241796,
-0.0156806614,
-0.0327192247,
0.0078046895,
0.0251043607,
0.0387846343,
0.0055600749,
-0.0487797819,
0.0054947813,
0.0367964879,
0.0176618379,
0.0841291547,
0.0446045026,
-0.0049122772,
-0.0261413213,
0.019628454,
0.0105380295,
0.0113141509,
-0.0528623983,
0.0044187685,
0.0856039971,
0.0400302708,
0.0209889393,
-0.0292905327,
0.0446758382,
0.0538621917,
0.000275364,
-0.0041226419,
0.0124885971,
-0.0150159346,
-0.0152905108,
0.0006138667,
0.1047616601,
-0.0041066702,
0.0077814497,
-0.017166771,
0.0237544253,
0.0126628699,
0.0427327491,
-0.1068082675,
0.0272113848,
-0.0226089302,
-0.0202302728,
-0.0350555442,
-0.0206094105,
0.0126533154,
0.016420126,
-0.0052325954,
0.0521772988,
0.0224187039,
0.0133238137,
-0.0056972359,
-0.0055799871,
-0.0438782088,
-0.0553658605,
-0.0142875966,
0.0752584264,
-0.0427114703,
0.024416253,
-0.0105071152,
0.0156451035,
0.0259448737,
-0.0360916927,
0.020101171,
0.0205318779,
-0.0399041437,
0.0773259252,
0.0022414601,
-0.0212287009,
-0.0378007367,
-0.0006890415,
-0.0487894006,
-0.0437745862,
-0.0539767891,
-0.0371245779,
-0.0535262562,
0.0279322565,
-0.0677680671,
-0.0450465903,
0.0108227106,
0.054628659,
0.0236406028,
-0.0225432031,
0.0003486724,
0.0171439573,
0.0086351316,
-0.005115849,
-0.022989599,
0.052184917,
-0.101266399,
0.0227539726,
0.013176579,
-0.0621546656,
-0.0048198984,
0.021731589,
0.0174942389,
-0.0630279481,
0.0025473337,
0.1109801009,
-0.0256431252,
-0.0066421465,
-0.0019057556,
-0.077816464,
0.0132319732,
-0.0614753738,
0.0072927144,
-0.0811904073,
0.0639630854,
0.0205661058,
-0.0193246789,
-0.0140258465,
-0.001005217,
0.0281094536,
-0.0109489821,
0.0654996336,
-0.0002129965,
0.0205179099,
0.0455815904,
0.0130448397,
-0.0279757511,
0.0943095237,
0.0115081947,
0.0248775352,
0.0618544221,
-0.0064577949,
0.0175935756,
0.0507323593,
0.0095712049,
0.0024721536,
0.0123390323,
0.0224864446,
0.0065323221,
0.0231257603,
0.0012619862,
0.0433463641,
-0.0297380686,
-0.0501386262,
0.0561833158,
0.0308270138,
0.0055210921,
0.0191891175,
0.0373233929,
-0.0116926515,
0.0073732189,
0.0198052227,
-0.0462709665,
0.0595533401,
-0.0458836034,
-0.0132152354,
0.0428055562,
0.0509029441,
-0.0254477616,
-0.0004679433,
0.0080506383,
0.0298443027,
0.0022878165,
0.0436189808,
0.0479775704,
0.0070123789,
-0.0211698972,
0.0488940068,
0.0283962805,
-0.0239630435,
-0.015927244,
-0.0437629223,
0.0284996852,
0.0415157303,
0.0525954887,
-0.016443368,
-0.0389725193,
-0.0003403898,
0.0469540544,
0.0073462804,
0.0121230353,
-0.0242916364,
0.0071375826,
-0.0404823013,
-0.015099044,
-0.0318653099,
-0.0278848018,
0.0085291658,
0.0361683853,
0.0147630991,
-0.0123411436,
-0.0621973425,
0.0625147372,
0.0227737669,
0.0031644008,
0.0083622569,
-0.0365076326,
-0.0023501117,
0.0004678871,
0.0075089824,
-0.012065785,
0.0084815463,
0.008944192,
-0.0370433219,
-0.0351778157,
0.0077261678,
-0.0246881228,
-0.0684930012,
0.0364711285,
-0.036747545,
-0.0261813849,
0.0067533758,
-0.0357060283,
-0.0038821329,
0.0091784177,
-0.0306948833,
0.0205321554,
-0.0628797561,
-0.0429711007,
0.0490229316,
0.0208615251,
-0.0602012016,
0.0352541208,
-0.0095028598,
0.0125533883,
-0.0122087598,
0.0071186861,
0.0113149043,
-0.011135486,
0.0020709636,
0.035558559,
0.0012624423,
0.0141334608,
-0.0067838849,
0.0066796807,
-0.0657281727,
-0.0298353247,
-0.1034922153,
0.0018371089,
0.000818315,
-0.0009181973,
0.0207540039,
0.0135123488,
0.0075875544,
-0.0038201415,
-0.0626161844,
0.0284563713,
0.0285856463,
0.0397593491,
0.0193145182,
0.0070116543,
-0.0033392608,
-0.0223976504,
-0.0146782435,
0.0037374476,
0.074004598,
-0.0069485707,
0.0096957572,
-0.049868051,
-0.0394582972,
-0.062601164,
0.035114307,
-0.0056510442,
-0.0524891503,
0.0217644926,
-0.0393862613,
0.0272822827,
0.043465063,
-0.018918857,
0.0304615181,
0.0126255332,
-0.0349362604,
-0.0330976509,
0.0215684921,
0.0036417069,
-0.0250933822,
0.000024696,
-0.025541272,
-0.0154133812,
0.0541215949,
-0.0025129833,
-0.0207900591,
-0.0006318956,
0.0368744433,
0.023099592,
-0.0212147627,
-0.0436200574,
0.0160088986,
0.00896479,
0.0412561074,
-0.0140036615,
-0.0064539397,
0.0620759688,
-0.0201494973,
-0.0402077362,
-0.0202337708,
-0.0032358677,
-0.0412735231,
0.1038982496,
0.0064193681,
0.0356582217,
-0.0233845934,
-0.0031808452,
-0.0691559017,
-0.0387819223,
0.0294488706,
-0.0095472597,
0.0230508111,
-0.0421729833,
0.024223322,
-0.0174910277,
-0.0215775706,
-0.0208567195,
-0.0421997085,
-0.0365153663,
0.0060660681,
0.0063452492,
-0.0074352855,
0.0201920196,
0.0399794765,
0.0329918936,
0.0048456658,
-0.0208128877,
0.0006672794,
-0.012696825,
0.0938399062,
0.0823141262,
0.0596976206,
-0.0093529169,
-0.0362435505,
0.0510034785,
0.0801305026,
0.0108710472,
-0.0049763001,
-0.012759544,
0.0019973812,
0.0039014933,
0.0090053407,
0.0019399422,
-0.0109089985,
0.0853405297,
-0.0756547451,
0.0174579993,
0.0764206424,
0.0278189406,
-0.0304397531,
-0.003407744,
-0.0163352843,
0.0323895216,
0.0181706827,
0.0287100784,
-0.1144508421,
-0.0725275055,
-0.0047477148,
-0.0292386394,
0.0052231587,
-0.0399054363,
0.0003366319,
-0.1005887389,
0.0226280782,
-0.0166785046,
-0.055294808,
-0.0058383895,
-0.0205979981,
0.0036118787,
0.0482209995,
-0.0128395688,
0.0291552916,
0.0079718558,
-0.0012938348,
-0.021002261,
0.0190911684,
0.0075398968,
0.0529530607,
-0.0219714846,
0.0207029413,
0.0537611246,
0.0084269103,
0.0016673055,
0.0172549449,
0.0835446194,
-0.0295216348,
-0.0045882049,
-0.0117068272,
0.0264588054,
0.0146696968,
-0.023092242,
-0.0262052175,
0.0509142242,
-0.0092477649,
-0.0048629558,
0.0288713146,
0.085313201,
-0.0252186432,
-0.0039496752,
-0.0240638405,
0.0442150868,
0.0092004612,
0.0632488206,
0.0420657545,
-0.037193682,
-0.0417431965,
-0.0072030774,
-0.0432727858,
-0.0374250375,
-0.0186013281,
0.0229013786,
0.0214417484,
0.0224524606,
-0.0814849585,
-0.0542382933,
0.0640342534,
0.0464874059,
-0.0215601642,
0.0278023109,
-0.002924589,
0.0505442359,
-0.024760291,
0.0488126613,
-0.0450238325,
0.019625878,
-0.0262929145,
-0.0168064982,
0.0281366762,
-0.0359513573,
-0.0148205915,
0.0361048393,
-0.0896236449,
-0.0474927612,
-0.0342323668,
0.0412868634,
0.0220663454,
-0.009515699,
0.0002441106,
-0.0701918527,
-0.0242254771,
0.023341164,
-0.024010038,
-0.0079802629,
-0.0046346248,
0.0429263115,
0.0023411734,
0.0435871594,
-0.0527623743,
0.0019949661,
-0.0237680916,
0.0538434796,
-0.0230310895,
-0.0516195409,
0.00629564,
0.0075081331,
-0.0265300386,
0.0171022117,
0.0264930315,
0.0010309041,
0.0215436816,
-0.0133598531,
-0.0188336652,
-0.0494577773,
0.0146015519,
-0.0123631917,
-0.0378558189,
0.0176734123,
-0.015212426,
0.0079732947,
0.0152703421,
-0.0137291756,
0.0229784958,
0.0175417177,
-0.036124371,
0.0220781509,
0.0170406234,
-0.0240657199,
-0.0061895121,
-0.0127899554,
0.0424889773,
-0.0066799978,
0.1050955579,
0.026968753,
-0.041018974,
-0.0713465214,
0.0357030183,
-0.0443340577,
-0.0912236795,
0.0111596119,
0.0549337566,
0.0593050979,
0.0428931676,
0.0044520563,
-0.0182608534,
-0.0412683859,
0.0021547738,
0.031868726,
0.0237531755,
-0.0139607685,
0.0612296201,
0.0457547046,
-0.0184787642,
-0.0080614584,
0.065443702,
-0.0336779021,
0.0256471112,
0.0320675187,
0.005311701,
-0.0243625995,
-0.0367953666,
-0.0105947964,
-0.0061311405,
0.0155276814,
0.0280728489,
-0.03196631,
-0.0841452852,
-0.0612574629,
0.0196755808,
-0.0349758454,
0.0051382692,
0.0277205687,
0.0554318316,
0.0324816704,
-0.0389986672,
-0.0368752629,
0.0551256351,
-0.0133645581,
-0.0341090225,
0.0223764684,
-6.401105264e-33,
-0.0099194646,
-0.0447120257,
0.0594226755,
-0.033577472,
-0.0385892764,
-0.0303168017,
-0.0398935564,
0.0267994273,
-0.0416800678,
0.004750981,
-0.009459354,
-0.022114791,
-0.0066499598,
0.0577184483,
-0.0169070307,
-0.025528267,
-0.010476619,
0.0038534838,
-0.0117518352,
0.030549584,
0.0223851372,
0.0044608442,
0.0157440174,
-0.0066598877,
-0.0033641134,
-0.0056233653,
0.0072446419,
0.0591973141,
-0.0276967753,
0.0619224794,
-0.0294733346,
0.0288403984,
0.0429071784,
-0.0227952395,
0.010101229,
0.0351954065,
-0.0872432813,
-0.0221097693,
0.039211493,
-0.0017460417,
-0.0564701967,
-0.0089114821,
0.0305604059,
-0.0223031919,
0.0498705618,
-0.0288256872,
0.0101723587,
-0.0220887028,
-0.0044783442,
0.0093147187,
-0.0296752136,
0.0145098828,
-0.0302691218,
-0.0748938695,
-0.0130977435,
0.0460266843,
0.0148919411,
0.0063003935,
-0.0125380298,
0.0004335613,
0.0078044636,
0.0089573646,
0.038734518,
0.0182798784,
0.0161822382,
0.0437893569,
0.0356009528,
-0.0189108122,
-0.0306575205,
-0.0068454542,
-0.0048639202,
0.0411758013,
0.0275935736,
0.050831981,
0.0029446143,
0.0420516171,
-0.0451321714,
0.0212489646,
0.0467794724,
0.0142527297,
0.0304587334,
0.0096841278,
0.0021886514,
-0.0192113761,
-0.0291148294,
0.0154561782,
-0.0439059883,
-0.0442478172,
0.0318844579,
-0.0325286351,
0.000776388,
-0.0015653926,
0.078783758,
-0.0541999526,
-0.0271853413,
0.0166748539,
-0.0219220817,
0.051368434,
0.0113248779,
0.0430513583,
0.0100001609,
0.0323715508,
0.0314480476,
-0.0360942446,
-0.0020325042,
0.0295211449,
-0.0009070459,
-0.001918457,
-0.0473120771,
-0.0099645471,
-0.0575314797,
0.0290577691,
-0.0411738567,
0.0120463464,
0.0264884681,
0.0157728735,
-0.0452565886,
0.0359843001,
-0.0087013682,
-0.0110767325,
-0.052999571,
-0.0130118914,
-0.0171839036,
0.0076630944,
-0.0445054434,
0.0248837434,
-0.0554217473,
-0.0332823321,
-0.0255400706,
-0.0707160905,
-0.0119535541,
0.0128430761,
2.657e-7,
0.0378882959,
0.0132227652,
0.0023043961,
0.0520690233,
0.0374063514,
0.0192355551,
-0.0158196967,
0.0098118903,
0.037410222,
-0.0468915477,
-0.0192039851,
0.0515517332,
0.0359518491,
0.0441073589,
-0.0448511764,
-0.0067819883,
-0.0182957407,
-0.0360134281,
-0.0623607859,
-0.0122660557,
0.0688401088,
0.071542792,
0.0023310678,
-0.0183515064,
-0.0000635833,
-0.0564016812,
0.036181245,
-0.0112234326,
-0.0424453095,
-0.0029481272,
-0.0083214128,
-0.0148073891,
0.0321765691,
0.02160028,
0.0281766392,
-0.0303010959,
0.0152355721,
0.0417080671,
-0.0061530322,
-0.0546704568,
-0.0171489641,
-0.0328288563,
-0.0158031806,
-0.0529236011,
0.1062133089,
-0.0628406033,
-0.0540538467,
-0.0289832987,
0.0094855335,
-0.0389572009,
-0.0249958243,
-0.0411439501,
-0.0315725021,
0.0407854877,
0.0191025455,
-0.0156985279,
0.0192076974,
-0.0652861372,
-0.0203396808,
0.0506474599,
-0.067638509,
-0.0575962178,
-0.0137779675,
-0.0469527431,
-0.0066708359,
-0.0226086546,
-0.0241476689,
2.194238137e-34,
0.0422402807,
0.0100675663,
0.0424129739,
0.0629124045,
0.0568436012,
-0.0095108794,
0.0013607738,
-0.0079653468,
0.0256041382,
-0.0894392058,
-0.0125650587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08913v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08913v1 | A Statistical Turing Test for Generative Models | 2023-09-16T07:36:07 | 2023-09-16T07:36:07 | Hayden Helm, Carey E. Priebe, Weiwei Yang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | The emergence of human-like abilities of AI systems for content generation in
domains such as text, audio, and vision has prompted the development of
classifiers to determine whether content originated from a human or a machine.
Implicit in these efforts is an assumption that the generation properties of a
human are different from that of the machine. In this work, we provide a
framework in the language of statistical pattern recognition that quantifies
the difference between the distributions of human and machine-generated content
conditioned on an evaluation context. We describe current methods in the
context of the framework and demonstrate how to use the framework to evaluate
the progression of generative models towards human-like capabilities, among
many axes of analysis. | [
0.0159370247,
0.0853375942,
-0.0358639285,
0.0053260168,
-0.0458537973,
-0.0012625593,
0.0183990449,
0.0094817402,
-0.0287818108,
-0.013356125,
0.0136230821,
-0.0021160706,
-0.0146781113,
0.0188935697,
0.0402413383,
-0.0465687551,
-0.0175475702,
-0.0003776783,
-0.0130651956,
0.0196401831,
-0.0343116187,
-0.0214121286,
0.0060675992,
0.0036446152,
-0.0072410232,
-0.0079706768,
0.0031122598,
0.0099555161,
0.0377240404,
-0.0182811804,
-0.0432549454,
0.0516248271,
-0.0075846887,
0.0355425254,
0.000001798,
-0.0542802773,
0.0156038217,
0.0125576919,
0.0117056686,
-0.0263956171,
0.0490053371,
0.0159011111,
-0.0342511535,
0.0061065885,
-0.0514958501,
0.0207928512,
0.0334253907,
-0.0055604135,
0.0061178561,
0.0509975925,
-0.0305702388,
0.0029500141,
0.0359072909,
-0.0037188134,
0.0546438769,
-0.0127897402,
-0.0035120437,
-0.0031687019,
0.0264688935,
-0.046740409,
0.0087931966,
0.03075408,
0.0296853911,
0.0121705551,
0.0028842788,
0.074181065,
0.0387466252,
-0.0105480216,
0.0057435175,
0.017850738,
0.0117147295,
-0.027212847,
0.0328137204,
-0.0025232499,
0.0307322703,
0.0803472996,
0.0173039511,
0.0534889512,
-0.0347691104,
-0.0001307091,
0.0191564746,
0.0138715114,
0.0124359233,
-0.00070794,
-0.0003748316,
0.0153747182,
0.0212904029,
-0.0342470258,
-0.0269241408,
0.0217999294,
0.0376763493,
-0.068298772,
-0.0183038209,
0.0123837097,
0.0006953766,
-0.0314217657,
-0.0530345179,
-0.0217784308,
-0.0016140986,
-0.0089966282,
0.050250113,
-0.0078755077,
-0.0282286443,
0.0350436643,
-0.0359060876,
0.0500154272,
-0.0018485861,
-0.0135508981,
-0.0257420633,
0.0465084501,
-0.0678880215,
-0.0166689698,
0.0047492017,
-0.0273442231,
0.0170591865,
-0.0358767919,
-0.0395007841,
0.0553265251,
-0.0311672501,
0.0073427605,
-0.0240134522,
-0.006021834,
-0.0220809169,
0.019523954,
-0.0366808623,
-0.0790952742,
-0.0324050933,
0.0323710851,
0.0155309606,
-0.0468010828,
-0.0041647744,
0.0293488447,
0.0247738548,
0.0226149876,
0.0066203652,
0.0549746975,
-0.0021377301,
0.0045212265,
-0.0371302962,
-0.0293828882,
0.0086181704,
-0.0417856425,
0.0263233948,
-0.0598712936,
-0.0156873502,
-0.0213682503,
-0.0093725901,
-0.0118814558,
-0.0289659612,
0.0140159074,
0.0343735665,
0.0276742894,
0.022292221,
0.0319989212,
0.0476652309,
-0.0087340306,
0.0005227624,
0.0146379592,
0.0331305638,
0.0466002077,
0.0155375106,
0.0095468294,
0.0644583702,
0.0206966288,
-0.033613693,
-0.0395123139,
-0.0348267928,
-0.0469659008,
0.0148772169,
0.0178545974,
0.0383656323,
0.0769557133,
-0.041493658,
-0.0066067679,
0.0613280907,
0.074644275,
-0.017092349,
0.0276712999,
0.1416828483,
0.0037527145,
0.0061506769,
0.0873303786,
0.0143155269,
0.0055688191,
-0.014974378,
0.0130273988,
0.0300603118,
-0.0030306892,
-0.0129931141,
-0.044511389,
0.0101896971,
-0.0076367571,
-0.0011573443,
-0.0359488726,
0.0506596006,
0.0089681279,
-0.0198029485,
-0.0995628238,
-0.0209762901,
-0.0482585393,
0.025279576,
-0.1057707891,
0.0616691448,
0.0856766254,
0.0336484239,
-0.017722575,
0.0593593419,
0.026415972,
-0.0509051234,
0.0403313302,
-0.001377065,
-0.0362691283,
-0.0258810539,
0.0199790839,
-0.0034089852,
-0.0011829162,
0.0247955024,
0.0287667662,
-0.0116741499,
0.0082456954,
0.0197305027,
-0.0327943973,
-0.0173870344,
0.0340814702,
-0.0158556439,
0.0047166282,
0.0268134084,
0.0078529688,
0.047814738,
0.0064760768,
-0.0603679828,
0.0268525295,
0.0042774412,
-0.0409347303,
-0.0358034,
0.0507179014,
-0.0051378221,
0.0183885992,
-0.0122558754,
-0.085439913,
-0.0041294917,
-0.0010269003,
-0.0007219308,
-0.0223568119,
0.0457293764,
-0.0743342713,
0.0076471199,
-0.0735566542,
0.024045134,
-0.0028316868,
0.0182901211,
-0.0182528216,
0.0949145928,
-0.0012638256,
0.007259266,
0.0041857315,
-0.0245004259,
0.0341202468,
-0.0524675474,
0.0156271756,
-0.0114575028,
-0.0285828095,
-0.0016511111,
0.0344526619,
0.0033673192,
-0.0163916834,
-0.0382310227,
-0.0563248023,
-0.0411429033,
-0.0167891048,
0.0428472124,
0.0148593634,
-0.0454856604,
-0.0255571157,
0.0057142759,
-0.0181386732,
-0.0233353451,
0.0469560698,
-0.0028881193,
0.0305646714,
-0.0328205265,
-0.0035958306,
-0.0193970129,
0.004209083,
-0.0118683688,
0.0569212809,
0.0601824783,
0.0148681551,
-0.0545484312,
0.0548943877,
-0.0149704758,
-0.0118964398,
0.0147527345,
-0.0215167496,
0.0412421338,
-0.0189896952,
0.080193989,
0.1008370891,
0.0489375554,
0.0481415726,
0.0324864797,
0.0394248329,
0.0199672785,
-0.0245935172,
-0.012339442,
0.0371371396,
-0.0063135279,
-0.0881018937,
0.0315111913,
0.0432472788,
0.0267154705,
0.004773173,
-0.0355823822,
0.0823867247,
-0.0168938022,
-0.0493791066,
0.0036505738,
-0.0168105271,
-0.0231315587,
0.0611657873,
-0.0228918176,
-0.0606130846,
0.0487511568,
-0.0326293036,
0.0625402853,
0.0203881226,
-0.0211582202,
0.0132529801,
0.0513310805,
0.0436852239,
0.0267846845,
0.0129091749,
0.0000715143,
-0.0552308969,
0.0324303694,
0.0726018772,
-0.0127436491,
-0.0352902561,
-0.0699469373,
0.0009237676,
0.0018761542,
-0.0215139035,
-0.0441183448,
0.0267202724,
0.0204387996,
0.0115201091,
0.0372610427,
-0.0492959544,
0.0017809841,
0.0017704375,
0.0164367072,
0.0375139676,
0.006899558,
-0.0343452506,
-0.0130110011,
0.0669269785,
0.034390334,
-0.0093316939,
-0.0228888728,
-0.0404256694,
-0.0115430234,
0.0063158269,
0.0026456644,
0.0506595597,
-0.0297876988,
0.0080202064,
-0.0077883364,
-0.0144366398,
-0.0087236892,
0.0693844259,
0.0077940435,
0.0071688038,
-0.0045062113,
0.0889214724,
0.0274969414,
-0.0079107424,
0.0120132035,
0.0222546738,
-0.0455367342,
0.0072891726,
0.0500856042,
-0.0576811284,
0.0434814729,
-0.0135152601,
0.0138468882,
-0.0761487707,
-0.0154965241,
0.0141540952,
-0.0777300149,
0.0834622756,
-0.0219586138,
-0.0729666948,
-0.0329955742,
-0.0461277999,
-0.0137160812,
0.0082627758,
-0.0776778087,
-0.0388575532,
-0.012580242,
0.0103757111,
0.017514091,
-0.0280377828,
-0.0769301727,
-0.00590441,
-0.0176916141,
0.0436326489,
0.0880312249,
0.0301890112,
-0.0231898334,
-0.0701335892,
-0.0378490724,
-0.0042939871,
0.0357126705,
0.0155824665,
0.0146058463,
0.0080378149,
0.020175783,
-0.0345728695,
0.0442886911,
0.0262110922,
-0.0256331749,
-0.0103853857,
0.0519200452,
-0.0041930494,
-0.0900713056,
-0.0345725939,
0.0140040405,
0.018851459,
0.0575005673,
0.0595744886,
-0.0415775068,
-0.0679439679,
-0.0254141409,
0.036616765,
-0.0672982112,
-0.03054999,
-0.0125714671,
0.0200929567,
-0.0566635728,
-0.1132541001,
-0.0226646438,
-0.0429538935,
0.0326054841,
-0.0048984042,
-0.0395490527,
-0.0020653915,
-0.0106328642,
-0.0685377195,
-0.0439247824,
0.0090876818,
-0.0153019112,
-0.0547850989,
-0.0674870238,
-0.0024340209,
-0.0730236545,
-0.0425016135,
-0.0108451666,
-0.0560252257,
-0.0282919761,
0.0107638482,
0.0269790068,
0.024009034,
-0.0148351537,
-0.0044325427,
-0.0253262371,
0.1024276987,
0.073197715,
-0.0261954311,
0.0285797678,
0.004261178,
-0.0043122997,
-0.022102071,
-0.0263953339,
-0.0055881641,
0.0687485114,
0.0243121386,
-0.0132693574,
-0.01094703,
-0.0209796447,
0.0172953866,
-0.0179766081,
0.0025561319,
-0.0352302045,
-0.0201609544,
-0.0464074053,
-0.0535594299,
0.0002676388,
-0.0034766374,
-0.0228593461,
-0.0426446497,
0.0507909358,
0.04100715,
-0.0153237125,
0.0222046673,
-0.0546997339,
0.043080464,
-0.0424977653,
-0.0290536731,
0.0304539036,
0.0576379709,
-0.0299421009,
-0.0084277308,
0.0156237055,
0.0021638644,
-0.0236609727,
0.0360758528,
0.0154510261,
0.0737247542,
-0.0065071587,
0.0298975259,
0.0255329981,
0.0278933644,
-0.0916154459,
0.0191300381,
-0.0328877568,
0.0251067393,
0.0396523066,
0.0151002603,
-0.0035814142,
-0.016307462,
0.0185431931,
-0.0185940806,
0.0388028882,
0.0237831492,
-0.0184458438,
-0.0451266803,
0.0340708345,
-0.0038407838,
-0.0137584535,
0.0691813901,
0.0020312611,
0.0072228345,
-0.0582348518,
-0.0250737835,
-0.0328393616,
-0.0519999489,
-0.0285343081,
-0.0569418259,
0.0118108047,
0.0230404455,
-0.0368471928,
-0.0864379853,
-0.0007142044,
0.0807786658,
0.0970895886,
0.019741172,
0.0013773073,
0.0866335332,
-0.0346791483,
0.0073540057,
-0.0438169539,
-0.0206143651,
-0.0103866169,
-0.0109674502,
-0.0548570044,
-6.061329723e-33,
-0.0178891364,
-0.0541970469,
0.0231971517,
0.0298764762,
0.0046539437,
-0.0119955689,
-0.0504110903,
-0.0059968052,
0.0238092709,
0.0043488299,
-0.0047277273,
0.00154398,
0.0091712996,
-0.0027788356,
0.0061542364,
0.0218200069,
0.0476365015,
-0.0257712286,
-0.0453989133,
0.0295161139,
0.024314316,
-0.0441197082,
-0.0198512897,
-0.0484258384,
0.015822215,
-0.0294856299,
-0.0094787758,
-0.0178635791,
0.0045565511,
0.0180124287,
-0.0369915962,
-0.0071996921,
0.0466800444,
-0.0329751186,
0.0166705158,
0.0060472968,
-0.0219168067,
-0.0044836658,
-0.0352016725,
-0.0479935594,
-0.0570587553,
-0.0791563913,
0.006323969,
-0.0197177473,
-0.064658232,
0.0090386039,
0.0852389261,
0.0004343063,
0.0207147207,
-0.0899834707,
-0.0775688142,
0.0286018513,
-0.0499020554,
-0.0014209951,
0.000450192,
0.0066056401,
-0.0113317277,
-0.0608250201,
0.0034442227,
0.0821042582,
0.0231033154,
-0.0061683003,
0.0706514195,
0.022866549,
0.0268146694,
0.0481537692,
0.0395403467,
0.0037892302,
-0.0210362989,
-0.0098996842,
-0.0015799326,
0.0189295709,
0.0016750942,
0.0475904122,
0.0322424173,
-0.0258141477,
-0.0256745946,
0.0777684897,
0.0004335316,
-0.0048887869,
0.0249121841,
-0.0127248159,
-0.023274567,
0.0033369272,
0.0147964479,
-0.0670323819,
-0.0125853475,
-0.0105114048,
0.0132403197,
0.0043801041,
-0.0224791691,
-0.057614021,
0.0205696579,
-0.0357414149,
0.0563500039,
-0.022363849,
-0.0356828049,
0.037045259,
0.0171312056,
-0.0230210982,
0.0012840119,
-0.038044937,
0.0875350237,
0.0613768697,
0.0700779185,
-0.0014124657,
0.0078056324,
0.0306011941,
-0.0204884205,
0.0016906824,
-0.0237083845,
0.0095793121,
0.0076659438,
-0.0129549187,
0.0138934124,
0.0059323898,
-0.0129942186,
-0.0221348815,
-0.0266912598,
0.0122743417,
-0.0375327282,
0.0366209745,
-0.017451914,
-0.0038753517,
-0.0372223668,
0.0194538739,
-0.0356664658,
0.0356466398,
0.0277162381,
-0.0216333214,
-0.0107820677,
0.0034422593,
2.609e-7,
-0.0114231613,
0.0161351804,
0.028453961,
0.0213746671,
0.0351635627,
-0.0103684422,
0.0114954384,
0.012629875,
0.0145158209,
0.0136626661,
0.0413518474,
0.0407144874,
0.0452510752,
0.0227167439,
-0.0445497781,
0.014545341,
-0.0598473176,
0.0215852335,
-0.0134055205,
-0.0005325266,
0.0743947029,
-0.0107930908,
-0.0267371163,
-0.0186995976,
0.0458451658,
-0.0341898836,
0.0290959142,
-0.017549742,
0.0409395099,
0.0054696887,
-0.0031196724,
0.0003058183,
0.0083172312,
0.0527106263,
-0.0329922847,
-0.0094258869,
0.0186504591,
0.0222060792,
0.0236240942,
0.0238694828,
-0.0002620456,
0.02741546,
0.0434395112,
-0.0136087816,
0.0302274078,
-0.004730281,
-0.0179225542,
-0.0193640497,
-0.0423327163,
-0.0184980221,
-0.0162805784,
-0.0229915064,
0.011002643,
0.0150321918,
-0.0042290548,
0.0194806978,
0.0144201983,
-0.0181991979,
0.0139931422,
-0.046163898,
-0.0670931488,
-0.0375921279,
-0.0362924971,
-0.009463788,
0.0373208523,
-0.0218586065,
0.0138633475,
1.890164036e-34,
0.0042074164,
0.0346120559,
-0.0132088261,
-0.0551602617,
0.0483975261,
0.028047327,
-0.0318015255,
0.0149301523,
0.0206417106,
-0.058890745,
-0.0111815603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08902v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08902v3 | Investigating Subtler Biases in LLMs: Ageism, Beauty, Institutional, and Nationality Bias in Generative Models | 2023-09-16T07:07:04 | 2024-06-20T01:02:31 | Mahammed Kamruzzaman, Md. Minul Islam Shovon, Gene Louis Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL | LLMs are increasingly powerful and widely used to assist users in a variety
of tasks. This use risks the introduction of LLM biases to consequential
decisions such as job hiring, human performance evaluation, and criminal
sentencing. Bias in NLP systems along the lines of gender and ethnicity has
been widely studied, especially for specific stereotypes (e.g., Asians are good
at math). In this paper, we investigate bias along less-studied but still
consequential, dimensions, such as age and beauty, measuring subtler correlated
decisions that LLMs make between social groups and unrelated positive and
negative attributes. We ask whether LLMs hold wide-reaching biases of positive
or negative sentiment for specific social groups similar to the "what is
beautiful is good" bias found in people in experimental psychology. We
introduce a template-generated dataset of sentence completion tasks that asks
the model to select the most appropriate attribute to complete an evaluative
statement about a person described as a member of a specific social group. We
also reverse the completion task to select the social group based on an
attribute. We report the correlations that we find for 4 cutting-edge LLMs.
This dataset can be used as a benchmark to evaluate progress in more
generalized biases and the templating technique can be used to expand the
benchmark with minimal additional human annotation. | [
0.0444659069,
0.0919872522,
-0.0365338363,
0.0179552585,
-0.0101735312,
0.0420174785,
0.0316038504,
-0.0029893043,
0.0284742676,
-0.0404598936,
-0.0362116098,
-0.021243887,
0.0290900245,
-0.0315590352,
0.0324713476,
-0.0443526842,
0.0317121446,
0.0455929562,
0.0604151338,
-0.0553307571,
0.0059188735,
0.0292826686,
0.0383316018,
0.0596397594,
-0.0182626043,
-0.0137808295,
0.0683086738,
0.0009410621,
0.0147144888,
-0.008057286,
0.03292346,
0.0624613427,
-0.0410253033,
-0.0287898369,
0.0000019542,
-0.0809034929,
0.029268397,
-0.0070329388,
-0.0004621467,
-0.0257267393,
0.0699118972,
0.0203246437,
-0.0036945264,
0.007845412,
-0.0684892014,
0.0233002491,
0.0183162931,
0.0055229412,
0.0094976518,
0.005796833,
-0.0009928036,
-0.0061943866,
-0.0621768832,
-0.0359745845,
0.0565240346,
-0.0235673077,
0.0353629328,
-0.0519628264,
-0.0508808494,
-0.0239053126,
-0.0040532118,
-0.0061351946,
-0.0059198998,
0.0244845785,
0.0559228659,
-0.002227708,
0.014107137,
-0.0082986904,
0.0133352559,
0.041570276,
0.0621485114,
0.0270014945,
-0.0121093011,
0.0002864199,
0.0677459762,
0.0403012149,
-0.0319046564,
0.0248043053,
-0.031459868,
-0.002101016,
-0.0069820709,
0.0080489712,
0.0212484524,
0.0514979325,
0.0308907814,
0.0777828842,
0.0048243739,
-0.0294962209,
0.0076120906,
0.0481320135,
0.013163425,
-0.0424862914,
0.0083970455,
-0.0314195566,
-0.0066105896,
0.0030396897,
0.0006516518,
0.0332819708,
0.046018362,
-0.0557744019,
0.0109574767,
0.018748397,
-0.0096945586,
0.0133286947,
-0.0160537846,
0.0184647404,
-0.0095588742,
-0.0163725968,
-0.0080792932,
-0.0254162662,
-0.0127790729,
-0.0401054844,
0.0507590249,
0.0000150029,
0.0160427224,
0.0553296693,
-0.0982730538,
-0.0221334323,
-0.0826176703,
0.0012478884,
0.0166474208,
0.0491328686,
-0.0011596185,
0.0024052542,
-0.108660683,
-0.0069020744,
-0.0692982376,
0.0350587964,
-0.0362815261,
-0.061813809,
0.009658535,
0.0021166245,
-0.0121060824,
-0.058194939,
0.0077926158,
0.0716918856,
0.030550316,
-0.0104558598,
-0.0383257903,
-0.0160308573,
-0.0051740506,
-0.059180662,
0.0266230181,
-0.0434384532,
0.0022576347,
0.0450083725,
0.018960068,
-0.071899645,
0.0032061569,
0.0344995447,
-0.0527256578,
0.0544498675,
0.0658378229,
0.017584553,
-0.0019654708,
0.0110499393,
-0.0300615747,
0.0916325897,
0.0150931925,
0.0345534049,
0.043896772,
-0.0146532357,
0.044600971,
0.0294561107,
-0.01495378,
0.006907091,
-0.0308013074,
0.0177993253,
-0.0283479989,
-0.0092081632,
0.0907963216,
0.0254072808,
-0.002912604,
-0.0033711167,
0.0586238727,
0.0567100942,
0.0142302588,
0.0547355786,
0.0258454587,
-0.0310040116,
-0.0253267474,
0.0333846472,
-0.0844257846,
0.0408365279,
-0.0229406692,
-0.0375052467,
-0.0281752087,
0.0681139529,
-0.0252970513,
-0.0484321639,
-0.0104838321,
0.0201021712,
0.0262997448,
0.0243008509,
0.0049385428,
0.0261917971,
0.0164495036,
0.0309309997,
0.0407705866,
-0.0330166928,
-0.0197939351,
-0.0680330694,
0.0180731155,
0.0753285587,
-0.0027435336,
0.0027048036,
0.0224565808,
-0.0070694573,
-0.0347730033,
0.0315326639,
0.0534760132,
-0.0106670298,
0.0013454335,
-0.0285835639,
-0.012083157,
0.0142289866,
0.0229145028,
0.0137219448,
0.061426919,
0.0137310801,
0.011055639,
-0.0231720638,
-0.0184827521,
0.0292384848,
-0.0018441038,
-0.0163287874,
-0.0075797434,
0.0271695461,
0.0413629524,
-0.0056755445,
0.0073057814,
-0.0011695592,
-0.0304184277,
0.0110813519,
-0.0157359242,
0.0526693165,
-0.0599322431,
-0.0130025772,
-0.0064219404,
-0.0714939609,
-0.0714157447,
0.0122035993,
-0.0182701461,
0.0192865506,
0.0636802465,
0.000858854,
0.0024702479,
-0.0208482407,
0.0056727305,
-0.0249944367,
-0.0044121807,
-0.0594924092,
0.0802837387,
-0.0193778947,
-0.0067596491,
0.024253685,
-0.0508011691,
-0.0172452908,
-0.0370428637,
-0.0278422032,
-0.0216475278,
0.0356944054,
-0.0295282714,
0.0175732356,
-0.0021185523,
-0.0509846881,
-0.0296173338,
-0.0899510235,
-0.0079432204,
0.0112631954,
0.0009883094,
-0.0129070925,
-0.0097075747,
-0.0143749267,
-0.00954914,
-0.0416981392,
-0.0027053987,
0.0212451518,
0.0612730198,
0.0375496149,
-0.0457340032,
0.0090496382,
-0.0354793184,
-0.0301833935,
-0.033859577,
0.0501344465,
0.0354140066,
-0.0021813295,
-0.0337501802,
0.0156003572,
-0.0632271469,
-0.0090035861,
-0.0051967748,
-0.0139947878,
0.0190978087,
0.0370631926,
0.0578400642,
0.0902583674,
0.0175327118,
0.0240576677,
0.0273206718,
-0.0004052951,
-0.0388064273,
-0.0235469341,
-0.0073033795,
0.053673517,
-0.0013050131,
-0.1013913304,
-0.0345765911,
0.0302315019,
0.0289103892,
-0.0325681865,
-0.0515233725,
0.0660402328,
-0.0300384331,
-0.0521700904,
-0.0109564411,
-0.0122935474,
-0.005333514,
0.0273682382,
-0.0396825261,
-0.0753431544,
0.0587368309,
0.0500549749,
0.0004528163,
0.0251508225,
0.0045210342,
-0.0551310442,
0.0555027574,
0.0006970273,
0.001341398,
0.0108001484,
-0.0174727514,
-0.0737673193,
-0.0188309401,
0.0341368429,
-0.0364959463,
0.0316424295,
-0.0255503729,
-0.0207614638,
-0.0079559106,
-0.064371556,
-0.0371832475,
-0.037811555,
-0.0216104016,
-0.0184405744,
0.0320768654,
-0.0113425246,
0.0087730512,
-0.0365358219,
0.0056536621,
-0.0459061451,
-0.0459678695,
-0.0238746293,
0.0048151808,
0.0113003887,
0.0260671079,
0.0085848281,
0.0429558717,
-0.035091117,
-0.0273956265,
0.0404842384,
-0.0370967425,
0.0045292079,
-0.0087596094,
0.0211989693,
0.0565388724,
-0.0275744721,
-0.0228837039,
0.0042650346,
0.0292667467,
-0.0335582793,
0.0629618615,
0.0749967918,
0.0113079613,
-0.0519198589,
0.0043473453,
-0.0106299995,
0.0082007479,
0.0483493842,
-0.0027611982,
-0.0768556148,
0.0203699581,
0.0312801525,
0.005978588,
-0.0641043112,
-0.03358908,
-0.0059830216,
-0.1220330968,
0.0517017953,
0.0032417318,
0.0268971641,
0.0155745493,
0.0020690206,
0.0218449458,
-0.0213973504,
0.032123968,
-0.0146568902,
-0.0223756451,
0.0246298369,
-0.0115244295,
-0.0615121163,
-0.0425375029,
0.0381566696,
-0.0393852443,
0.0558099896,
0.0475119054,
0.0460839272,
-0.0138161266,
-0.0428392403,
0.060851492,
0.0282076802,
0.0308291633,
-0.0253417604,
0.0475247465,
-0.0231562443,
0.0006011853,
-0.0813171193,
0.0075629964,
0.0224984102,
0.0138021326,
0.0146666961,
0.0126198763,
0.0077846786,
-0.0410175174,
-0.0218427889,
-0.0059353476,
-0.0219943393,
0.0895449519,
0.014615343,
-0.0446322076,
-0.0263962019,
-0.0496574417,
-0.0060930434,
-0.0041170637,
-0.0745131746,
0.0175157264,
-0.0063991249,
-0.0073108203,
-0.041451294,
-0.0481716208,
0.0372177958,
-0.0112542985,
0.0057169222,
-0.0422590449,
-0.0191547107,
-0.0162914954,
-0.0232352763,
0.0463879853,
-0.0229160674,
0.0278797634,
0.0119276121,
-0.0397680812,
0.0112762526,
-0.0528093539,
-0.0146138808,
-0.0325971134,
-0.0201647338,
-0.0293162409,
0.036536742,
0.0620353371,
0.0285775233,
0.0358942524,
-0.0055711083,
-0.0740640983,
0.0331202559,
0.0416141264,
0.0147940498,
0.0451538153,
0.004050218,
0.0538928062,
0.0174250733,
0.0057083596,
-0.0142669948,
0.0461061522,
0.0607924648,
-0.0216511693,
-0.0222885273,
-0.0154321641,
0.0135217365,
0.0159220491,
0.0215641186,
-0.0569018237,
0.0088477628,
-0.025876781,
-0.0388237126,
-0.0211314373,
-0.0453259051,
-0.0111489147,
-0.0635094345,
0.0302761365,
0.0352100879,
-0.0296866223,
-0.0180422459,
-0.0367692038,
0.0414976366,
-0.0915660188,
0.0472253598,
-0.0041694101,
0.0225958824,
0.0025044796,
0.0258858874,
-0.0050825477,
0.0167486034,
-0.0325273648,
0.0427738093,
0.0372209586,
0.0488163121,
0.005246595,
0.0117705408,
-0.0139308916,
0.0158955455,
-0.0448962189,
-0.0057282643,
-0.0027171506,
-0.0012412304,
0.0298297033,
-0.0252413619,
0.0499861948,
0.0057940623,
-0.0037300887,
0.0127167767,
0.0015054556,
0.0153784538,
-0.0281427968,
0.0377852544,
0.0016187191,
-0.0190173239,
-0.0331233256,
0.0662466064,
-0.0081194835,
0.0286839642,
-0.0524826907,
-0.0596924648,
-0.0162727628,
-0.0443814434,
0.0437842533,
-0.0496402271,
-0.0042266827,
-0.0350464806,
-0.1102751866,
-0.058580853,
-0.0080877701,
-0.0083036385,
0.032536827,
-0.023919547,
0.0197311733,
0.0522616506,
-0.0224047285,
-0.0552257895,
-0.0142229097,
-0.0227333475,
-0.0308095161,
0.0236139223,
-0.0364958979,
-6.514134923e-33,
-0.0346752368,
-0.0426135063,
-0.0206223801,
-0.0095414948,
-0.0151570858,
-0.025179876,
0.0092664035,
0.0199796278,
0.0022885385,
0.0091630826,
-0.0174387954,
0.022252785,
0.0103486003,
-0.0126619525,
0.0369834192,
-0.022857558,
0.0690433681,
0.0114609674,
-0.0090888645,
-0.0314260423,
-0.0193624254,
0.0070493561,
0.0421595126,
-0.0608956367,
0.0825467855,
0.0160458665,
-0.0092973923,
0.0196083933,
-0.0132124247,
0.0253854115,
-0.0046509132,
0.0787629783,
0.0422826409,
-0.0298318192,
-0.0065246001,
0.0365227088,
-0.0384625196,
-0.044446703,
0.0504127517,
0.0251162294,
0.0031836275,
-0.0490809567,
0.0104270391,
0.0301954038,
-0.0714591891,
0.0022070678,
0.0678718314,
-0.0309365522,
0.0589529611,
-0.0223974995,
-0.0300849322,
0.0051642363,
-0.0051750946,
0.0556967854,
-0.0043785335,
0.0078047598,
-0.0139089245,
0.0473242179,
-0.015388188,
0.0408120118,
-0.0242271516,
-0.002083061,
0.02772131,
0.0142996414,
0.0270061847,
0.0445156954,
0.0553292446,
0.0640244558,
-0.0675962642,
-0.0600769632,
0.0150471134,
0.0213889163,
0.0090873772,
0.0693624169,
0.0468892828,
-0.0363537297,
-0.0171021409,
-0.0093366923,
0.0646452531,
0.0248353612,
0.020733498,
-0.0094204703,
-0.0454423279,
-0.0459628031,
-0.0188017823,
-0.0227791779,
-0.0357771777,
-0.0349381566,
0.0184022598,
-0.0045031528,
-0.0070787594,
-0.0143362917,
-0.0085851122,
-0.0300257951,
-0.0384110659,
0.0107847266,
-0.0344482735,
-0.0167554282,
0.0257194415,
-0.029166447,
-0.0511461794,
0.0279726461,
-0.0103004957,
0.0285984147,
0.0402568281,
0.0191104785,
-0.000115366,
0.0092625273,
-0.0872083902,
0.0077087972,
-0.0278704781,
0.0051150252,
0.0065465248,
-0.0239989534,
0.0459477678,
0.0189554803,
-0.001151431,
-0.02047709,
0.0275623947,
0.0367820151,
-0.052621644,
-0.001567536,
0.0022408608,
0.0357807465,
-0.0151250474,
-0.0182780139,
-0.0056339763,
-0.0007353114,
0.0470321625,
-0.0228633955,
-0.0215293895,
-0.0385830328,
2.612e-7,
0.0093247192,
0.0796262473,
-0.0291094165,
0.0673979074,
0.0299770571,
0.0222090725,
0.0082951374,
0.0019122957,
0.0651441365,
0.0098914094,
-0.0086281681,
0.0254418012,
0.0350007005,
0.0483892784,
-0.0684717372,
0.0353029408,
-0.0341045968,
-0.0012540969,
0.0080482103,
0.0228728317,
0.0323165506,
0.0011275979,
0.0226427317,
0.0076254914,
-0.0347211361,
-0.0300511383,
0.0576996543,
-0.0701212063,
0.0169890691,
-0.0033109828,
0.0288225897,
-0.0294776019,
0.0286604445,
0.0632319376,
0.0225219373,
-0.0003363476,
-0.0052384315,
0.028279027,
-0.0134977652,
-0.0117727267,
-0.0269187149,
0.0034150057,
-0.0056541041,
-0.0304376706,
0.0682600662,
0.0055259443,
-0.0438978262,
-0.0630510002,
-0.0322776176,
-0.0078065493,
0.0386354439,
0.0060468698,
-0.0249032527,
-0.0122643374,
0.0430670306,
-0.0058825933,
-0.0290380921,
-0.0722984523,
-0.026606923,
-0.0189730842,
-0.0168944746,
-0.1084833741,
-0.0045710825,
0.0780981332,
0.0110684093,
-0.0372847207,
0.0012011817,
2.274933988e-34,
0.0128350565,
0.0210398547,
0.0251018833,
-0.0177292451,
0.0246961974,
0.0177460294,
-0.044788681,
-0.0080732936,
0.0522347949,
-0.0274466947,
0.0023843874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08879v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08879v1 | Semantic Information Extraction for Text Data with Probability Graph | 2023-09-16T05:01:20 | 2023-09-16T05:01:20 | Zhouxiang Zhao, Zhaohui Yang, Ye Hu, Licheng Lin, Zhaoyang Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.SP | In this paper, the problem of semantic information extraction for resource
constrained text data transmission is studied. In the considered model, a
sequence of text data need to be transmitted within a communication
resource-constrained network, which only allows limited data transmission.
Thus, at the transmitter, the original text data is extracted with natural
language processing techniques. Then, the extracted semantic information is
captured in a knowledge graph. An additional probability dimension is
introduced in this graph to capture the importance of each information. This
semantic information extraction problem is posed as an optimization framework
whose goal is to extract most important semantic information for transmission.
To find an optimal solution for this problem, a Floyd's algorithm based
solution coupled with an efficient sorting mechanism is proposed. Numerical
results testify the effectiveness of the proposed algorithm with regards to two
novel performance metrics including semantic uncertainty and semantic
similarity. | [
0.051644884,
0.0115764309,
-0.0089913579,
0.0378806666,
-0.0935823768,
-0.0019366326,
-0.0636712909,
0.0421732292,
-0.0214075726,
-0.0535964891,
0.0765981153,
0.0198215675,
-0.0036993851,
-0.0570744537,
-0.0427936129,
-0.0495584719,
0.0225362647,
-0.0110386563,
0.0236359313,
0.0233288091,
0.0041483613,
-0.0279083233,
0.0041887299,
-0.0638691783,
-0.0337076969,
0.0405940972,
0.0072525702,
-0.0054581123,
0.0286060609,
-0.0605756156,
-0.0886095241,
-0.002092567,
-0.0425272398,
-0.0420081764,
0.0000019277,
-0.0263545066,
-0.0873543173,
0.0115149943,
-0.0012212601,
-0.0585964397,
0.0690905079,
-0.0228390973,
0.0134441024,
0.0039540036,
0.0050196233,
0.0263554007,
0.0632765964,
0.0432669036,
0.0226087794,
0.0448892042,
-0.0277510528,
-0.0147925876,
0.0075102528,
0.0260089897,
0.0445015654,
-0.0566149764,
0.0482956097,
0.0485572852,
0.0447164439,
0.0190164912,
-0.0084419921,
0.0185374841,
-0.0157480463,
0.0382682793,
0.0118228439,
0.0129385879,
-0.0051284172,
0.0018466049,
-0.0226601809,
0.0448242687,
0.0444475785,
0.0170100201,
0.0322331637,
-0.014796963,
-0.0451229177,
0.0381759293,
-0.0320173092,
0.0139771495,
-0.0452269241,
0.0355389714,
-0.0197562613,
0.0585083254,
-0.0092936233,
-0.0324031897,
-0.0141326915,
0.097047925,
-0.0106524583,
-0.0108548058,
0.0021815482,
-0.0137584936,
0.0253793281,
-0.0139253,
0.0331239402,
-0.0045645335,
0.0621958524,
0.0576097257,
-0.0400448777,
-0.0529265143,
-0.0403409638,
-0.044728633,
-0.0377309024,
0.0009397645,
0.0791915804,
0.0275862236,
0.0268760361,
-0.0298657976,
0.0144923963,
0.0238036476,
-0.0235876366,
-0.0328485072,
-0.0894509852,
-0.0061987895,
-0.0374883004,
0.0931218341,
0.0003104435,
-0.0165764485,
-0.0293019358,
0.0060417145,
0.0356730372,
-0.0542497747,
0.0146570979,
-0.0066241822,
-0.0067731976,
0.0002754176,
-0.0521805882,
-0.0449308641,
0.002283565,
-0.0214642249,
-0.0174523648,
0.0148619805,
0.0369177684,
0.0253637321,
0.0684848428,
-0.0223603733,
-0.0514929704,
0.1252303421,
-0.0049014809,
-0.0209581535,
-0.0409671143,
-0.0325995162,
-0.0118845813,
0.0130766518,
-0.0155282505,
-0.0474803597,
0.0389215089,
0.0191803314,
-0.0215524659,
-0.0162533391,
0.016171325,
-0.0188981909,
-0.0933441445,
0.040618699,
-0.0239255652,
-0.0021895661,
0.0411586836,
0.0084025552,
0.0095484909,
0.0003811822,
0.0429074243,
0.0306157842,
0.046998173,
0.0364724733,
-0.0536907613,
-0.0046073794,
-0.0049317367,
-0.031940531,
-0.007697524,
-0.0185820404,
-0.0170151368,
-0.0297687799,
-0.0161766708,
0.0388932377,
-0.0396830067,
-0.0136902304,
-0.0077246358,
0.0429334603,
0.0185865983,
-0.0253800396,
-0.0124512082,
0.0741862953,
-0.0111694252,
0.0272084456,
0.0313217193,
-0.0198928118,
0.0009083187,
-0.0087302271,
0.0220944211,
-0.009297478,
0.0312924199,
-0.009658956,
0.0110555748,
-0.0386452861,
0.0616894402,
-0.0203571692,
0.0536631159,
-0.044385165,
-0.0323043205,
0.0382923,
0.0310627613,
0.0154688377,
-0.0025948819,
0.0365135856,
-0.0435150079,
0.0320600048,
0.0194742419,
-0.0701929405,
0.0261057634,
0.0689780712,
-0.0174231082,
-0.0114968447,
0.0045046033,
0.0254993718,
-0.0048443149,
-0.0415572897,
-0.0445938259,
0.0933085606,
-0.0145555064,
-0.0071410756,
0.0153413201,
0.0437806807,
0.0155192893,
0.0135012427,
-0.0550882965,
0.0272194818,
0.0739292651,
-0.0048452057,
0.000038244,
-0.0157811232,
0.0389586166,
0.0271931421,
-0.0163419545,
0.0116808861,
0.0187959895,
-0.0497830883,
-0.0166148804,
-0.0068733408,
0.0062240218,
-0.0268473569,
-0.0006332201,
-0.0340888686,
0.0086141312,
0.0123388665,
-0.0246301163,
-0.0220276527,
0.0185380299,
-0.0099709751,
0.0389483608,
0.0057677962,
0.021921223,
0.0292327087,
-0.0143290879,
-0.0454912856,
0.0775134861,
0.0294337757,
-0.0027169485,
-0.0469585247,
-0.004446514,
0.0040786881,
-0.078200154,
0.0466771424,
0.013439931,
-0.0111020552,
0.0200601779,
0.0323307775,
0.0106860576,
0.0058518876,
-0.0260082576,
-0.0139396889,
-0.0089301495,
0.034943562,
0.0381158218,
0.0064365515,
0.0282384362,
-0.0132337594,
-0.0048404853,
-0.0276671126,
0.0732249767,
-0.0410173349,
-0.0272785891,
0.0296678357,
0.0086933393,
0.0031632367,
-0.032357987,
-0.0270429868,
0.0136396978,
0.0365304425,
0.0450079069,
-0.0967208669,
-0.0176458713,
0.0512720272,
-0.0866819918,
0.0033538814,
0.009301722,
0.0110672256,
-0.0377225988,
-0.0253986977,
-0.023246754,
-0.0396137536,
0.0033253457,
0.0267154016,
-0.0128004011,
-0.0238453411,
-0.0155228414,
-0.0090198955,
-0.0911048502,
0.0723835602,
-0.0261305105,
-0.0349003933,
0.0638025925,
-0.0046693999,
0.0611788519,
0.0048840065,
0.0024010947,
-0.0243098084,
-0.0328759253,
-0.0047160778,
-0.0744465962,
0.0160653032,
-0.0243537277,
0.0197620019,
-0.0223754011,
0.0203829426,
0.036456082,
-0.0058690263,
0.0738383308,
-0.0666942671,
-0.0392105505,
-0.016808385,
0.018566234,
0.0355987661,
0.0762737766,
-0.015377868,
-0.0156299826,
-0.0263666436,
0.0161756761,
0.0940788165,
-0.0120313317,
-0.0410658792,
0.0035343072,
0.0593388602,
0.0075428523,
-0.0024069105,
0.0017424609,
-0.0396083444,
0.0054387474,
-0.0317377821,
0.0689979419,
0.0080362642,
-0.0015992742,
0.0389904827,
0.0326423049,
-0.0154030276,
-0.0017532858,
-0.0047842977,
-0.0045002708,
0.0944589302,
0.0077422517,
-0.03618294,
0.0108170845,
0.0252628736,
-0.0185616557,
0.0618370324,
0.018604001,
-0.0069522681,
0.0437436551,
-0.0106503693,
-0.0370663106,
-0.0516589768,
-0.0189073272,
0.0156878736,
-0.0067873984,
-0.0067712958,
0.0214056,
0.0492077246,
0.0586667135,
0.0119927004,
-0.0194822568,
0.0198690351,
-0.0373177305,
-0.0217988994,
0.0392986462,
-0.0599384569,
-0.016766388,
-0.0140111195,
0.0152159007,
-0.0242816936,
-0.074567154,
-0.0176759493,
-0.0392133407,
0.007079259,
0.0022305071,
-0.0321010761,
-0.0428659953,
-0.0358572192,
-0.0158351306,
0.0103885913,
-0.0753827319,
-0.0185842328,
0.0319972783,
0.0132439304,
0.0143778045,
-0.0142891603,
-0.0033568926,
-0.0163764507,
0.029054651,
-0.0108726937,
-0.0051070894,
0.0273359064,
-0.0179051235,
0.0218676589,
0.0277279001,
0.0056306305,
-0.0112807592,
-0.0351744443,
0.0266238935,
-0.0001782942,
0.01181019,
-0.055877056,
-0.0482470803,
0.0528599583,
-0.0039165565,
-0.0005320027,
0.0595122799,
0.0065643154,
-0.0104173683,
0.0025841137,
-0.0090262834,
0.0009918772,
0.0293770563,
-0.0135634653,
0.0015598289,
-0.0141752101,
-0.006755474,
0.0235206913,
-0.0066613802,
-0.0038179394,
0.0051271389,
-0.0185898729,
-0.0508217514,
-0.0932890475,
0.0065585687,
-0.041119501,
0.0312558562,
-0.0267978255,
0.0466205366,
0.0886467993,
-0.0097737052,
-0.0430353656,
-0.0797163248,
-0.0242121127,
-0.0485172942,
-0.0373452604,
0.0266997125,
0.0277897567,
-0.0311050341,
-0.0443106331,
0.0113107478,
-0.0252609197,
-0.0616638213,
0.0057290769,
-0.0083134826,
0.0182697047,
0.0207788013,
-0.02922602,
-0.0289222766,
0.0467133634,
0.0570752136,
-0.0389880165,
-0.0277575571,
-0.0385441594,
0.0248302445,
0.0096026985,
0.0110934535,
-0.0419938639,
0.0511086285,
-0.0497048944,
0.00775785,
-0.0717979744,
-0.0488865227,
0.01188944,
0.1018661931,
-0.0091990447,
0.0468392335,
-0.0470034257,
-0.0340484902,
0.0239592381,
-0.0202290714,
-0.0184099972,
-0.0144158453,
0.0128295952,
-0.0173145831,
0.0053436356,
0.0162823759,
-0.0483486801,
0.088342756,
-0.0245218072,
0.06993521,
-0.0451522171,
0.0216042101,
0.0016019921,
0.0227305889,
-0.0123904292,
0.0352766998,
-0.001843454,
-0.0028553326,
0.0007540646,
-0.0211381726,
-0.0028554315,
0.0412920527,
-0.0643279701,
-0.0349902585,
-0.0172849819,
-0.0279001053,
-0.0097686006,
0.0043622744,
0.0496639609,
0.018922247,
0.0494829863,
-0.0147892758,
-0.0315248892,
-0.0055829668,
0.0101711405,
0.0248796754,
0.0449815392,
0.0300345737,
0.0270436835,
0.0159331318,
0.0045342119,
0.0217416715,
0.0213675108,
0.003207108,
-0.0163234286,
-0.0310261436,
-0.0960569084,
-0.0320617147,
0.0465762913,
-0.007802343,
0.0569827892,
0.0020709911,
0.0288275667,
-0.0313224681,
-0.0165132228,
0.0220640283,
0.0166447293,
0.0209524836,
-0.0178794023,
0.0510093793,
0.0123649891,
0.01817053,
0.0394702666,
-0.0500283614,
-0.0138826594,
-0.0458934642,
0.0014899282,
0.045852121,
-6.361429391e-33,
-0.0457272567,
-0.0491954498,
-0.0279832948,
0.092978552,
-0.0193625465,
0.0086666197,
0.0073611089,
-0.0365429074,
0.0046750172,
-0.0022432723,
0.019031778,
0.0040502772,
0.0204727557,
0.0101017812,
-0.064320147,
0.011132868,
-0.024406299,
-0.0131748458,
0.0034513075,
-0.0140768727,
0.0837951228,
0.0481612086,
0.0386763737,
-0.0781989694,
0.0005937028,
-0.0048398226,
0.0681691021,
0.0088547664,
0.1109225228,
0.0013582627,
-0.0184841976,
0.0306294579,
0.0164403431,
-0.0531227849,
0.0118877869,
0.0042094039,
-0.0572959036,
-0.1038627103,
-0.0172583796,
0.0083821202,
-0.0211122558,
0.0032053804,
0.0215206835,
0.0004157628,
0.0247572605,
-0.0074075679,
0.0338687971,
0.0174401421,
-0.0504771583,
0.0097202053,
0.0016746206,
0.0657048374,
0.0331927277,
0.0519232042,
0.0694289505,
-0.0428730808,
-0.0066233533,
-0.0406698138,
-0.0230020937,
-0.0015312969,
-0.0307909492,
0.0201244,
-0.0126715694,
0.0110572521,
0.0147319017,
0.0394058377,
0.014870082,
-0.0812614039,
0.0132061895,
0.0091267219,
-0.0674892515,
0.0091110449,
-0.0480077192,
0.0492155962,
0.0128840059,
-0.0140281124,
-0.1043427214,
0.0184432585,
0.0267553553,
-0.0252822209,
-0.0103920242,
0.0095087541,
-0.0803055316,
-0.0188810658,
0.0047474755,
0.0009534952,
0.0216441266,
-0.0427461155,
-0.0035361571,
-0.0248270929,
-0.0467233099,
0.0336071923,
0.001646854,
0.0018604983,
-0.0353653878,
0.0142626222,
0.0126787554,
0.0196071863,
-0.035349004,
-0.0241871588,
-0.0712965354,
-0.000344049,
-0.0203870088,
-0.0218868423,
0.0057610408,
-0.0079258252,
-0.0106390994,
-0.0170036387,
-0.0146779874,
0.0035523721,
0.0157465506,
0.0030835194,
-0.0196348224,
-0.0241231695,
0.0130307684,
0.0077558537,
-0.0123522393,
0.0290756859,
0.0672295764,
-0.0109963436,
0.050108958,
0.0019745163,
0.017051572,
-0.017797878,
-0.0101665603,
0.0109188864,
-0.0075332383,
0.0365292653,
-0.0172237139,
0.0062163151,
-0.0135030989,
0.0590497889,
2.943e-7,
0.0751630217,
0.0232012756,
0.0434872992,
0.0356295817,
0.0185016841,
-0.0104458565,
0.0278532468,
0.0087595787,
-0.0128153404,
0.0055706212,
0.0621617921,
0.0090264305,
-0.0321409293,
0.0281802025,
-0.0761310384,
-0.0254420098,
0.004060098,
-0.0820356682,
-0.0006371234,
0.0145395789,
0.1167371795,
0.0147878844,
0.0390139446,
0.0079034762,
-0.0483847857,
-0.0388022661,
0.0215252675,
-0.0004014292,
0.0128087085,
0.0153198596,
0.0240927711,
-0.0096348189,
-0.0524728559,
0.0393542461,
0.0173424184,
-0.0011455801,
0.0413030796,
-0.0178446248,
-0.0249085482,
0.006012348,
0.0287866388,
-0.0165536888,
-0.0204406884,
0.0284727607,
-0.0034798258,
-0.0497040711,
-0.0383682586,
0.0749061853,
-0.0085348263,
-0.0161090847,
-0.0533343516,
0.0629143268,
-0.0428829081,
0.0017485005,
-0.0211741831,
0.0015370303,
-0.0141549595,
-0.02007108,
0.0570841022,
0.0000391623,
0.016069416,
-0.0447202772,
0.0064395918,
0.0355871953,
0.0511735342,
-0.0805219337,
0.0126856975,
2.247714176e-34,
-0.0006913239,
0.0448825657,
-0.064957872,
-0.0241925269,
-0.0067650531,
0.0110083055,
0.0017378532,
-0.0030550263,
-0.0179287437,
-0.0399172865,
0.0134461224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08873v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08873v2 | X-PARADE: Cross-Lingual Textual Entailment and Information Divergence across Paragraphs | 2023-09-16T04:34:55 | 2024-04-15T18:39:01 | Juan Diego Rodriguez, Katrin Erk, Greg Durrett | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding when two pieces of text convey the same information is a goal
touching many subproblems in NLP, including textual entailment and
fact-checking. This problem becomes more complex when those two pieces of text
are in different languages. Here, we introduce X-PARADE (Cross-lingual
Paragraph-level Analysis of Divergences and Entailments), the first
cross-lingual dataset of paragraph-level information divergences. Annotators
label a paragraph in a target language at the span level and evaluate it with
respect to a corresponding paragraph in a source language, indicating whether a
given piece of information is the same, new, or new but can be inferred. This
last notion establishes a link with cross-language NLI. Aligned paragraphs are
sourced from Wikipedia pages in different languages, reflecting real
information divergences observed in the wild. Armed with our dataset, we
investigate a diverse set of approaches for this problem, including token
alignment from machine translation, textual entailment methods that localize
their decisions, and prompting LLMs. Our results show that these methods vary
in their capability to handle inferable information, but they all fall short of
human performance. | [
0.0246767215,
0.0180650353,
-0.0097558098,
0.0817149431,
-0.073062703,
0.0295387078,
-0.015034778,
-0.0173200797,
0.0077078049,
0.0148918619,
0.020557927,
0.0130805178,
0.0239417795,
-0.0267224945,
0.0267591756,
0.0106991706,
0.0693238601,
0.0000903963,
-0.0078895688,
-0.0092367548,
0.046497643,
0.0138493404,
-0.0269470252,
0.0193412714,
0.0017869532,
-0.0151027339,
0.0050619356,
0.0094853025,
0.0787234977,
-0.0094640423,
0.0020796945,
0.0055716941,
0.0141875055,
0.0524581634,
0.000001531,
-0.0447338335,
-0.0178851597,
0.0006713117,
-0.0174130872,
-0.0244528484,
-0.0433193259,
-0.049788624,
0.0265855845,
-0.0430031791,
-0.0035715406,
-0.0282447096,
0.0533416122,
0.054035794,
0.0816347897,
0.0881681144,
-0.0151235629,
-0.0155397402,
-0.0067424048,
0.0069010812,
0.0534174442,
-0.014070197,
0.0197016615,
-0.0228532832,
-0.0238578636,
-0.0131128803,
0.0108447475,
0.030527398,
0.0090225525,
-0.0054485956,
-0.0363629833,
-0.0039255279,
-0.0382354595,
-0.0153367277,
0.0103497365,
0.0479446948,
-0.0035976879,
-0.0609296262,
0.0225215349,
-0.0046026772,
-0.0152932461,
0.0205083322,
-0.0146395797,
0.0299981274,
-0.0594408177,
0.0169464815,
0.0825252458,
0.0016579832,
0.029125493,
0.0072781122,
-0.0134551004,
0.1006154269,
0.0299614388,
-0.0384298973,
-0.0042726728,
0.0271637514,
-0.0348999947,
-0.0642790273,
0.0314086005,
0.0125521282,
-0.0336395949,
0.0158756301,
-0.0439630449,
-0.0483761467,
0.0296582785,
-0.0534923337,
-0.0110008866,
0.0331295654,
-0.0481403433,
0.0528361984,
-0.0332686342,
0.0535521433,
-0.0461293086,
-0.0021836059,
-0.0244119819,
-0.0555671193,
-0.008214429,
-0.0040589618,
0.001692303,
0.0078848945,
-0.0075915647,
0.0057389913,
-0.0121315382,
0.0191827696,
-0.017252624,
0.0836290717,
-0.023939684,
-0.0693281144,
-0.0118746981,
0.0130317109,
-0.0439702682,
0.0344231576,
-0.0495534986,
0.0037058555,
-0.0401771069,
-0.0143558457,
-0.0249926802,
0.0323933549,
-0.0046717045,
-0.0398251638,
0.0035154847,
0.0237387884,
0.0097355824,
0.0454073474,
-0.0212059766,
-0.0248628594,
0.0091132289,
-0.0788218752,
0.0071450165,
-0.0985072628,
0.046712663,
0.0062974012,
-0.0058099232,
-0.014060881,
0.0080056004,
0.0463628545,
-0.0233292785,
0.0694410503,
-0.0268747993,
0.0118996333,
-0.0007525429,
-0.0304109026,
0.0175408609,
0.0606057085,
0.0142812012,
-0.0038662518,
0.0794397518,
0.0439016819,
-0.0298688542,
0.0200893991,
0.0064997566,
0.0162313487,
0.0230265185,
0.0150850611,
0.0410041623,
0.0245210994,
-0.017389508,
0.0323017128,
-0.0267770942,
-0.0256982464,
0.0144211687,
0.0316455476,
-0.0164291412,
-0.0386197753,
0.0434243456,
-0.0075356727,
0.00280701,
0.0511036851,
-0.0269850213,
0.0112723354,
0.0005736771,
0.0098056719,
0.0306893829,
0.037644051,
-0.0044683488,
-0.0323298462,
-0.0329528898,
-0.00285649,
-0.0168099962,
-0.0216274783,
0.0312697627,
0.0262820423,
0.001372068,
0.0525527149,
0.0480832644,
-0.0647273809,
-0.0010708525,
0.0272404756,
0.0591599904,
0.0644054636,
0.0047514881,
-0.0465830937,
-0.0441345647,
0.0110650072,
0.0388904475,
0.0715575814,
0.0139558874,
-0.0355377086,
0.0144808246,
-0.0132666267,
-0.0052054776,
-0.0058719818,
0.0131484196,
0.0041559604,
0.0158584472,
0.0279321745,
-0.0047281585,
-0.0690338239,
-0.0124175651,
0.0642049536,
-0.0311372466,
0.0401521809,
0.0031889735,
0.0364546739,
0.0111021008,
0.0249561276,
0.0052207476,
0.0026060825,
0.0324947909,
-0.058770638,
-0.017280627,
0.0305624865,
0.0258475654,
-0.0630566999,
0.0557026118,
-0.1057486236,
-0.0661858991,
-0.015536,
-0.0593824126,
-0.0376305766,
-0.0256049111,
-0.0374085456,
-0.0070589022,
-0.0281674173,
0.0176954996,
-0.0039840047,
-0.0149015561,
-0.0196616147,
0.0691871047,
0.0199360196,
0.0635729581,
0.0105718719,
-0.0034644883,
0.0577681065,
0.0089159012,
-0.0418544933,
0.0070186704,
0.0241928548,
-0.0364338011,
0.0494690947,
-0.0028800073,
-0.0114642074,
-0.020338688,
-0.0775167421,
0.0465009362,
-0.0213105939,
0.0478508696,
0.0378929451,
-0.0078315381,
-0.0070386538,
-0.0156123089,
-0.0432750918,
-0.0174732208,
0.0135463541,
0.0391650535,
0.0804834887,
-0.0113446563,
0.0210926142,
-0.029846888,
0.010080616,
-0.0297314003,
0.0328492559,
0.0230979118,
-0.0634518415,
-0.0891694054,
-0.023163734,
-0.0912253484,
0.0163659062,
-0.0080313617,
-0.0009937666,
0.0113078393,
0.0211763922,
0.0720940977,
0.0080662258,
-0.0153365275,
-0.0166493915,
0.0581395067,
-0.017205121,
-0.0295270942,
0.0117077641,
-0.0167176481,
0.0362941399,
-0.0230682585,
-0.0344750136,
0.0347773135,
0.0213121157,
-0.0094798869,
-0.0159403216,
-0.0369610414,
-0.0114563257,
-0.0199130028,
-0.0088077532,
0.0180196632,
-0.0205385666,
0.0010531332,
0.0727437213,
-0.0367265679,
-0.0068734325,
0.0865715146,
-0.0309230741,
0.0212339573,
-0.0457010306,
-0.0103528099,
-0.0454491191,
0.0584061109,
-0.0114623541,
0.0099769328,
0.0135041438,
-0.002958871,
-0.0061805625,
0.0391641669,
0.042542506,
0.0025189219,
0.0781956837,
-0.056067057,
0.0192912519,
-0.0302831158,
-0.0229977146,
-0.0458053537,
-0.0388855822,
0.0183108281,
-0.0429996699,
-0.0561949871,
-0.0078070224,
-0.0326553993,
-0.012495433,
0.0303497519,
0.029005738,
-0.0111853229,
0.0134180589,
-0.0292206388,
0.0136221359,
0.0473750867,
0.0074566924,
0.0082427599,
-0.0392645523,
-0.015672544,
0.0266367812,
-0.0371349826,
-0.004450486,
0.0073983013,
-0.0225975867,
0.0153729534,
-0.0502381846,
-0.0118604908,
-0.0494881123,
0.0339129083,
-0.0501214974,
-0.0208208337,
0.0768063813,
0.0205081422,
-0.0343891308,
-0.0065412386,
-0.0295095611,
0.0333600901,
0.0184402335,
-0.0069778054,
-0.1167212501,
-0.01994255,
0.0116271283,
-0.0259468481,
-0.0024231707,
-0.0132483467,
-0.0092743579,
-0.0880728811,
0.0043036309,
-0.0076089739,
-0.0430494323,
-0.0499969274,
-0.0521015711,
0.027394047,
-0.0041195182,
0.0212163385,
-0.0045848456,
0.0166396573,
0.0020584748,
-0.0139298392,
-0.0180942733,
-0.0312438104,
-0.0183286164,
-0.0638488904,
-0.0054014665,
0.0216140412,
0.0495727882,
-0.0066626663,
-0.0501944833,
-0.0053850659,
-0.0280288178,
-0.0599236228,
0.0011480965,
0.0475285463,
-0.0121287294,
-0.0184537694,
-0.023699956,
0.0003387283,
0.0077356994,
-0.0222998429,
0.055926308,
0.0658067688,
-0.0018041919,
-0.0000767186,
0.0055815703,
0.0012932802,
0.0064960807,
0.0807192996,
0.0014936605,
0.0098444708,
-0.0367428102,
-0.0099425502,
-0.0152917588,
-0.0434071012,
-0.0041758078,
0.0115679419,
-0.0303347576,
-0.0514749773,
-0.1018236205,
-0.0302159637,
-0.0041808346,
0.0244772099,
0.0268734042,
0.0199161433,
0.0212910324,
-0.0257745795,
-0.0530041866,
0.0157122836,
-0.0321462192,
0.0118190767,
0.0391635261,
0.0232333224,
0.0053248773,
0.0130424062,
-0.0086695775,
0.0249411222,
-0.1177735254,
-0.0722814053,
-0.0167669971,
-0.0117449127,
0.014503873,
0.0684769824,
-0.0448044911,
0.0452252626,
0.0031985259,
0.0409172401,
0.0004798869,
0.0084740482,
0.0094762156,
0.0334053077,
0.0230084881,
0.0486902073,
-0.0310382266,
-0.0120541826,
0.0157255195,
0.0339927711,
-0.0077138594,
-0.0551699288,
0.0186248459,
0.0348762758,
0.031197805,
-0.0122792143,
-0.0105411587,
-0.0410312898,
0.0237581357,
-0.0250867121,
-0.0469231494,
0.0074489182,
-0.0056089833,
-0.0185365733,
-0.0268708561,
-0.0046988265,
0.0655463263,
0.0101981265,
0.029589422,
-0.0676438063,
-0.0303805396,
0.0336285122,
0.0390307009,
-0.0279704779,
-0.0078496672,
-0.0377155431,
-0.018486321,
-0.0115751047,
0.0253254957,
-0.0411927812,
0.0067223292,
0.0613709129,
0.007273091,
0.0272979811,
0.0099030668,
-0.0521288179,
0.0243457258,
0.030044768,
0.0161642432,
0.0943633169,
-0.0235775374,
0.106085144,
0.006008435,
-0.0119724208,
0.009198566,
0.0237056706,
-0.0066549787,
-0.010396122,
0.0092686843,
-0.0066481526,
-0.0341040157,
0.0137604838,
0.0486643612,
-0.0603537373,
0.0624629408,
0.0108830128,
-0.0193164423,
-0.0160940606,
-0.0599650517,
-0.0204645246,
0.0048436187,
-0.0228748322,
-0.0388267376,
-0.0282306708,
-0.0320223048,
0.0355838425,
0.0488684103,
-0.0141098034,
0.0391990691,
-0.0214469656,
0.0592359938,
0.0294525046,
-0.0552337654,
-0.019917924,
0.0152801238,
-0.0219708402,
-0.0315586813,
-0.0214738995,
-5.478946108e-33,
-0.0411026552,
-0.0239619482,
-0.0054342248,
0.0283279307,
-0.0357217528,
-0.006579095,
-0.0540410802,
-0.0496217012,
-0.0346573032,
0.0426204577,
0.0386176966,
0.0073700389,
0.0394924395,
-0.0018707863,
0.011174961,
-0.0562725589,
0.0209476221,
0.0688814223,
-0.0509836599,
0.0042583151,
0.0702305436,
-0.0427959114,
0.0921507925,
-0.0292514693,
0.0981729925,
-0.0485659093,
-0.0210989229,
0.0574266836,
-0.0032208143,
0.0354379788,
0.0027253861,
0.0219201092,
0.0276421607,
-0.0011159792,
-0.0036903641,
0.0059662396,
-0.0669415891,
-0.0673549995,
0.0776601583,
0.0044248737,
-0.0360048711,
-0.0259648282,
0.0292793289,
-0.0229216665,
0.0227227677,
0.0368717685,
0.0602276064,
-0.0261627622,
0.0313562676,
-0.0230686683,
-0.081315808,
0.0250531863,
-0.0078384858,
0.0177191105,
0.0014077472,
0.0809310526,
0.0351222828,
-0.0054081921,
-0.088450253,
0.0410428233,
-0.0661792085,
0.026518736,
0.0184017457,
-0.0302531216,
0.0151864719,
0.0736733079,
0.0076046917,
-0.0179789197,
-0.0094419429,
0.0374261104,
0.0042577921,
0.0042961715,
0.0429159813,
0.0684095398,
0.0111438716,
0.0437697321,
-0.0975162238,
0.0371683836,
0.0098329438,
0.0188650768,
0.0001443992,
-0.0241784677,
-0.0066319308,
0.0002236643,
-0.0095285866,
0.0050548073,
-0.0149953952,
0.0001317649,
0.0009313294,
-0.0317449719,
-0.0143141085,
0.0404248759,
0.0195664167,
-0.0101870047,
-0.0077726617,
0.0267255064,
-0.0067735324,
-0.0145093147,
0.0040767957,
0.0354127884,
-0.0342785455,
-0.034576159,
-0.0238963831,
0.0122293476,
0.0502132289,
0.0071878931,
0.0776841342,
-0.0250101406,
-0.0464173742,
0.0136507479,
-0.0368864797,
-0.0178334527,
-0.0820901245,
0.0027226242,
0.0418340862,
0.0113985222,
-0.0050036577,
0.0058674212,
0.0528819673,
-0.0155936377,
-0.0482258908,
-0.0123136286,
-0.0234377794,
0.0195723604,
-0.0271994639,
0.0386214554,
-0.0277485438,
0.0551847778,
-0.028904777,
-0.0258408953,
0.031343963,
0.0405470766,
2.291e-7,
0.0175090339,
0.0111849736,
0.0580390245,
0.0409260541,
-0.0079628257,
0.000412638,
-0.0563485809,
0.0107621225,
-0.0153548522,
-0.0535296313,
0.0094810445,
0.0289087836,
0.0424829461,
0.0622039624,
-0.0850470588,
0.041145131,
-0.0389223583,
-0.0467856787,
-0.0701790974,
0.0201387238,
0.0591530763,
0.029682558,
0.0502718315,
0.0001082535,
-0.0349591859,
-0.0265160091,
0.0370832011,
0.0046540946,
-0.0311251711,
0.0172110442,
0.0294130053,
-0.0076735066,
0.0107803699,
0.0403999351,
-0.0046496745,
0.017366387,
0.0201879628,
0.0436796732,
0.0075542075,
0.0012729191,
-0.066155605,
-0.0442562141,
0.0181272402,
-0.0537389033,
0.0633981526,
0.0355709679,
-0.0039199335,
-0.0597105622,
-0.0058886185,
0.0103176897,
0.0338619761,
0.0138225267,
-0.0579356737,
0.02295045,
0.028856378,
0.0029571368,
-0.0470719486,
-0.0228246562,
-0.0435398705,
0.0044716457,
-0.0385758355,
-0.0253721643,
0.0174777824,
0.0144293122,
-0.0008408797,
-0.0663688108,
0.0096634664,
1.844807403e-34,
0.0092259189,
-0.0283125881,
-0.018715987,
-0.0126293227,
0.0313042775,
-0.0019399194,
-0.0617744438,
0.0149250496,
-0.0100717833,
-0.0017817375,
0.000671697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08872v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08872v2 | PDFTriage: Question Answering over Long, Structured Documents | 2023-09-16T04:29:05 | 2023-11-08T05:09:28 | Jon Saad-Falcon, Joe Barrow, Alexa Siu, Ani Nenkova, David Seunghyun Yoon, Ryan A. Rossi, Franck Dernoncourt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have issues with document question answering
(QA) in situations where the document is unable to fit in the small context
length of an LLM. To overcome this issue, most existing works focus on
retrieving the relevant context from the document, representing them as plain
text. However, documents such as PDFs, web pages, and presentations are
naturally structured with different pages, tables, sections, and so on.
Representing such structured documents as plain text is incongruous with the
user's mental model of these documents with rich structure. When a system has
to query the document for context, this incongruity is brought to the fore, and
seemingly trivial questions can trip up the QA system. To bridge this
fundamental gap in handling structured documents, we propose an approach called
PDFTriage that enables models to retrieve the context based on either structure
or content. Our experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed
PDFTriage-augmented models across several classes of questions where existing
retrieval-augmented LLMs fail. To facilitate further research on this
fundamental problem, we release our benchmark dataset consisting of 900+
human-generated questions over 80 structured documents from 10 different
categories of question types for document QA. Our code and datasets will be
released soon on Github. | [
0.0198595654,
0.021224875,
0.0007311116,
0.0475926623,
-0.0121846106,
0.005067674,
-0.0120801469,
0.0089067668,
-0.0116770491,
-0.0557168722,
-0.0395245701,
0.0055907201,
-0.0200769957,
0.0065689166,
0.0057842741,
-0.0421846323,
0.0177440811,
-0.0247576218,
-0.003946132,
-0.00056935,
0.0323929563,
0.0205106959,
0.0298113432,
-0.0075184093,
0.014069966,
-0.0619891919,
-0.0344811641,
0.0085387705,
-0.0160634406,
0.005045244,
0.0385349244,
0.007397668,
0.0401908942,
0.0189532768,
0.0000016814,
-0.0356769525,
-0.0243555196,
0.0325019211,
-0.007969453,
0.0116773164,
0.0296985451,
-0.0346123315,
0.0072255582,
0.0106366519,
-0.044221811,
0.0261480454,
-0.0155868381,
0.0493636876,
0.0168348849,
0.0608692504,
-0.0021094165,
-0.0216705296,
0.040898554,
-0.0228524879,
0.0570211932,
-0.0430696458,
-0.0130773531,
0.0270478111,
0.0695650503,
0.0498397648,
-0.0015517615,
0.0190532282,
0.0332936011,
-0.0148481363,
-0.0277897343,
0.0140446741,
-0.0411890708,
0.0490417741,
0.0077826078,
0.0802328661,
0.0299805645,
-0.0043769483,
0.0196105111,
-0.0115202451,
-0.0008160904,
0.0187305734,
-0.0770281926,
0.0021384757,
-0.0292282458,
-0.0242947713,
0.0127713205,
0.0020266636,
0.0247481801,
0.0310344752,
-0.0087230476,
0.0650981739,
0.0086096032,
-0.0332259014,
0.0111622121,
-0.0093064876,
-0.0249368995,
-0.0400368087,
0.0216384418,
0.0821508095,
0.0109216589,
0.0078615658,
-0.0402025431,
-0.0607665256,
0.0584251843,
-0.0428197794,
-0.0414952561,
0.0018550744,
-0.0260984376,
0.1020014361,
-0.0454231724,
0.0398149341,
-0.0404789783,
0.0006634664,
-0.0535208322,
-0.0212524533,
-0.0078073749,
-0.0251455866,
-0.0559359454,
0.0327490754,
-0.0596216805,
-0.0429165028,
0.0241047796,
0.059299618,
0.0014426123,
0.0157082025,
-0.0026116301,
0.0288421139,
-0.0052121631,
-0.0297686104,
-0.0237145592,
0.0466924682,
-0.0667359978,
0.0067680669,
0.0053913561,
-0.0299471617,
0.007929014,
0.0158427879,
0.0083031841,
-0.0283799041,
0.020603545,
0.0434462614,
0.001411563,
-0.018573191,
-0.016594734,
-0.032620281,
0.0197879206,
-0.0547832288,
-0.0090205828,
-0.0704414994,
0.023801541,
0.0327434242,
-0.0168393832,
0.0027153424,
-0.0085541187,
0.0382104404,
-0.0134331919,
0.0726079866,
-0.0076432535,
-0.0114491452,
0.0719847828,
0.0145669924,
-0.0298252497,
0.0524362847,
0.0019329537,
0.0066267927,
0.0631478503,
-0.0087069198,
0.0179411415,
0.0328460895,
0.0213667974,
0.0022057106,
0.0248013567,
0.0814584196,
-0.0249078702,
0.003463143,
0.0352049135,
0.0326727815,
-0.0163872615,
-0.0383658931,
-0.0075787269,
0.0614165664,
-0.0149927568,
-0.0085913492,
-0.0019551343,
0.0383921489,
0.0316469334,
0.0253755338,
-0.0289891046,
0.0121674538,
-0.0209649894,
0.0217370074,
0.0080964528,
-0.0009774066,
-0.0470018275,
-0.0191593841,
-0.0176889747,
0.0005923696,
0.0268000867,
0.0112121115,
0.0574792996,
0.0417318679,
-0.0402582623,
0.0103297029,
-0.0158096738,
-0.0306289289,
-0.0052954308,
-0.0086081335,
0.0674770996,
0.0375241414,
0.0809343457,
-0.0778613836,
-0.0302498005,
-0.0006565325,
0.0413706973,
0.0019646583,
0.0437542126,
-0.0302225705,
0.0113613652,
-0.0484863631,
-0.0053749755,
-0.0503623858,
-0.0093972441,
-0.0061468915,
0.0379898809,
-0.0046460344,
0.0393268391,
-0.1063917205,
0.0163303744,
0.0341672897,
-0.0007117335,
-0.0731770098,
-0.0215664748,
0.0054077222,
0.0251051374,
0.0173657276,
0.0077351336,
0.0288745519,
0.0499191694,
-0.0165410377,
-0.0101991743,
-0.0362840258,
-0.01313949,
-0.0188559424,
0.0170585066,
-0.0174679141,
-0.0289055761,
0.0168035869,
-0.040840216,
-0.0293589737,
-0.0155078713,
-0.0400997177,
0.0546540655,
-0.0407267138,
-0.0236503724,
0.0461907797,
0.0167438332,
-0.0490428843,
0.0768263116,
0.0207207892,
0.0280382242,
0.0300173406,
0.0264919624,
0.0206093267,
-0.0434350967,
0.0062873876,
-0.0076873279,
-0.0061857249,
0.0089812893,
0.0494360439,
0.0106342109,
-0.0552294701,
-0.0035841516,
-0.0795719847,
0.0157222897,
-0.0203731041,
0.0664810017,
0.0225888919,
0.022518307,
-0.0208753459,
-0.057222534,
-0.0919191092,
0.0020846128,
0.0367402323,
0.0269900076,
0.0470574908,
0.0285671949,
0.0014600464,
-0.0488252975,
-0.0312105399,
-0.0099150613,
0.0320037603,
-0.0022825934,
-0.0002236393,
-0.0089805834,
0.0457864739,
0.0117093641,
0.0329572149,
-0.0284291096,
0.0080180438,
0.00020759,
-0.0485358164,
0.0353235342,
0.101163432,
-0.0167246629,
0.0051838798,
0.0162006952,
0.0017726738,
-0.0842560232,
0.0236899182,
-0.0100908475,
-0.0118797515,
-0.0054698922,
-0.0092075979,
0.0349708609,
0.0364554748,
-0.0269942377,
0.0067766942,
-0.0089635262,
0.0117142582,
0.001323159,
0.0193640906,
-0.0570917055,
-0.0210630298,
0.0183881838,
0.0403445587,
-0.0041231215,
-0.0206187926,
0.0387643203,
-0.0279466696,
-0.0129247401,
-0.0469840951,
0.0450876094,
-0.0609229356,
0.0775532648,
-0.0009318535,
-0.0021953813,
-0.0394863188,
-0.0272447001,
-0.0384913608,
-0.0093330424,
0.0023401056,
-0.0380319208,
0.0084386421,
-0.02095576,
0.0340299867,
-0.0385727845,
-0.0546162277,
-0.0216254052,
-0.0149787841,
-0.0171363093,
0.00467148,
-0.0242738537,
0.0038861798,
-0.0322715193,
-0.0065423758,
0.0344691053,
0.0380335711,
-0.0409697518,
-0.0196290724,
-0.0142622078,
0.1151746586,
0.0708663762,
-0.0004150836,
0.0178478602,
-0.0350815207,
0.0272649322,
0.0803741962,
0.0049063177,
0.0076065985,
-0.0002594922,
-0.022453554,
0.0095766364,
-0.0385366157,
-0.0115657449,
0.0057068365,
0.0276534762,
-0.1086072251,
-0.0161319505,
0.0781817213,
0.0545076057,
-0.03211651,
-0.0405292362,
-0.0749069974,
0.0338838063,
0.0228194278,
0.0497080088,
-0.0861781165,
-0.0322489515,
0.0043972251,
0.0391520336,
0.0220432151,
0.0086878911,
0.0380530991,
-0.0924578384,
0.0324231274,
-0.029209191,
-0.0168634467,
-0.0132519985,
-0.025591081,
0.0126938932,
0.0267222151,
0.0023409938,
0.0200993046,
-0.0341484435,
-0.0049813432,
-0.0056609004,
0.003387793,
0.0077593629,
0.0328504741,
-0.0226891749,
-0.0354979858,
0.0898876339,
0.0139665995,
0.0154358642,
-0.0242129471,
0.0323870964,
-0.0284440983,
-0.0120636504,
0.0152530065,
0.0267910771,
-0.012415749,
0.0240410846,
-0.0355326943,
0.0667445138,
-0.0531096719,
-0.0074431873,
0.0368171521,
0.0463571958,
-0.0231269505,
-0.0065817926,
-0.061460346,
-0.0230127815,
-0.0267766844,
0.099303022,
0.0298623126,
-0.0133302892,
-0.0891192779,
-0.0204394292,
-0.0038235898,
-0.0407543294,
0.0284342933,
0.0098711848,
-0.0006537354,
0.0508702099,
-0.0991017967,
-0.0649962649,
0.039224904,
0.019948367,
-0.0322689861,
0.016770985,
-0.0360051543,
-0.008116507,
-0.0675629005,
0.0505180098,
-0.0104466192,
0.0155045027,
-0.0529228933,
0.002359896,
0.0152271595,
-0.0249761827,
-0.0068853195,
0.0308770519,
-0.0967624933,
-0.0178485774,
-0.0346836075,
0.0186482407,
0.0185724627,
0.0305923633,
-0.0345146544,
-0.0441895388,
0.0431688279,
-0.0073142028,
-0.0644459203,
-0.0064663133,
0.0198868215,
-0.0013682392,
-0.0180384517,
0.0403230041,
-0.0850604102,
-0.0076194913,
-0.0164809525,
0.0222200938,
-0.0101122279,
-0.0274038613,
0.0165810231,
0.0166079458,
-0.0393886343,
0.0251431428,
0.0281495191,
0.0154972514,
0.0362084359,
-0.0315492265,
-0.0393103175,
-0.0102782268,
0.0046765846,
-0.0004276827,
-0.0310891382,
-0.0046114633,
0.033820942,
0.0099059809,
0.0723631978,
-0.0286344346,
0.0122818975,
0.0680882484,
-0.0129797133,
0.025340423,
-0.0227678996,
0.0083638895,
-0.0082525285,
-0.0224956032,
0.0836707875,
-0.0209204163,
0.0662276745,
0.0367512777,
-0.0086004632,
-0.0192362331,
0.0100303106,
-0.0714785159,
-0.0547060892,
-0.0143093728,
0.0123158488,
-0.0018833362,
-0.0222925115,
0.0199081674,
-0.0114046177,
-0.0480375774,
-0.0112484805,
-0.0094990619,
0.0166550744,
-0.0130490381,
0.0486267731,
0.0702531636,
-0.0016196128,
0.035776563,
0.0758236572,
-0.0012016724,
0.0099319462,
0.0048703542,
-0.0210374892,
-0.0316754989,
0.0215302408,
-0.0009648022,
0.0473090746,
-0.0046584159,
-0.0040407875,
-0.0340788066,
-0.04407873,
0.022083329,
0.0217423588,
-0.0189265143,
0.0031382767,
0.0471457131,
0.0917370617,
0.0279945973,
-0.0498336442,
-0.0450952947,
0.0745625943,
-0.045077499,
-0.0527757183,
-0.0469082408,
-5.340649933e-33,
-0.0247889664,
-0.0384952389,
0.0091415383,
-0.0085659102,
0.0057922057,
0.0242406186,
-0.0483302921,
-0.0213652942,
-0.0036290612,
0.013440391,
-0.0610511191,
0.0169913266,
0.000284486,
0.0223108474,
-0.0196127817,
-0.0236860309,
0.0090935472,
-0.0236425642,
-0.0175109282,
0.020565208,
0.0129170828,
0.0059020366,
-0.0054586972,
-0.0352762267,
0.0224166419,
-0.0232107695,
-0.0192785673,
-0.0096700238,
0.001496987,
0.090037182,
-0.0310147014,
0.00322192,
0.0522132367,
-0.0041594584,
-0.014639819,
0.0932779238,
-0.134778142,
0.0010211228,
-0.004735494,
0.0224537775,
-0.0531057827,
-0.0413648859,
0.0327715501,
-0.027857447,
0.0377359763,
0.0036658428,
0.0448725447,
-0.0228946358,
-0.0082805762,
-0.0629378781,
-0.0568738058,
0.0142344218,
-0.0093402825,
-0.0178178269,
-0.0071784612,
0.0416493677,
0.0067254808,
0.0739596486,
-0.0439178161,
-0.0349460803,
0.0015045777,
0.0437091663,
0.0280311052,
0.0012387696,
-0.0001187079,
-0.0035788785,
0.0088636642,
-0.0081548272,
-0.0324695669,
-0.0299584586,
0.0003632543,
0.0116287712,
0.0365363546,
0.0479381979,
0.0476974994,
0.048523996,
-0.0507895201,
0.0784244984,
-0.0054203309,
0.0432828963,
-0.014680312,
0.0077757873,
-0.0358370282,
0.01145807,
-0.012343606,
0.0322751366,
-0.0301194731,
-0.0132413711,
0.0348967686,
-0.0075184512,
0.0050740559,
-0.0353997238,
0.0350257084,
-0.0572990291,
-0.0017710726,
0.0509582348,
-0.0393596627,
0.0357605219,
0.0169935692,
0.0378565863,
-0.0079660341,
0.0254472774,
0.0215881579,
-0.0397088602,
-0.0273189191,
0.022415854,
0.0346976928,
-0.0209682416,
-0.0697136521,
-0.0038886068,
-0.0144963767,
0.022008501,
-0.0288214628,
0.0456145033,
0.0272748731,
0.0265215952,
0.004607169,
0.0728093162,
-0.0172930881,
0.0052571502,
-0.052108448,
-0.0226590931,
-0.0141814845,
0.0079447059,
-0.0169373546,
0.0111191403,
-0.0329844989,
0.022043122,
0.009734964,
-0.0450821482,
0.0120729581,
0.0550089926,
2.301e-7,
0.0764208436,
0.0039265403,
0.0589205734,
0.0281904154,
0.0189489741,
0.0113870883,
0.0091450168,
0.0265530571,
-0.0107693253,
-0.026952453,
0.0061108894,
-0.0020690232,
0.0463962741,
0.0150557626,
-0.1093153656,
0.0041883141,
-0.0537392087,
-0.0294596087,
-0.0435594916,
-0.0332528763,
0.0142154526,
0.0781324953,
-0.0311673488,
-0.0076855617,
-0.011653726,
-0.0501238778,
0.047427509,
-0.0029846721,
0.0005623819,
0.0132216755,
0.0343605354,
-0.0276729483,
-0.0000332471,
-0.0403288193,
-0.0193514731,
0.0437951088,
0.0320354067,
0.0668619424,
0.0136559308,
-0.0408058688,
-0.0248378869,
-0.0634680763,
0.0299603697,
-0.0441526212,
0.0819098055,
-0.0079207383,
-0.016422864,
0.004617149,
-0.050305821,
-0.0287820417,
-0.0195838157,
-0.0096387314,
-0.0144194514,
0.0258216672,
0.0290757231,
-0.0494971499,
0.0095317848,
-0.0796933621,
0.0026630429,
0.0085667297,
-0.0425778404,
0.0127133792,
-0.0436624475,
0.0086984253,
0.0055152415,
-0.055481337,
-0.0272196345,
1.971436958e-34,
0.0543562621,
-0.0175515581,
-0.0157161914,
0.0280659758,
0.0381794274,
-0.0271567311,
-0.0097022373,
0.0038152523,
0.0339118503,
-0.0960567072,
0.0067908634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08868v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08868v1 | MHLAT: Multi-hop Label-wise Attention Model for Automatic ICD Coding | 2023-09-16T04:13:57 | 2023-09-16T04:13:57 | Junwen Duan, Han Jiang, Ying Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | International Classification of Diseases (ICD) coding is the task of
assigning ICD diagnosis codes to clinical notes. This can be challenging given
the large quantity of labels (nearly 9,000) and lengthy texts (up to 8,000
tokens). However, unlike the single-pass reading process in previous works,
humans tend to read the text and label definitions again to get more confident
answers. Moreover, although pretrained language models have been used to
address these problems, they suffer from huge memory usage. To address the
above problems, we propose a simple but effective model called the Multi-Hop
Label-wise ATtention (MHLAT), in which multi-hop label-wise attention is
deployed to get more precise and informative representations. Extensive
experiments on three benchmark MIMIC datasets indicate that our method achieves
significantly better or competitive performance on all seven metrics, with much
fewer parameters to optimize. | [
0.0044855527,
0.0212598462,
0.012754322,
-0.0026653057,
-0.0129449898,
0.0244539194,
0.0021976181,
0.0345304534,
0.0374461003,
-0.0312182643,
-0.0543080643,
-0.0662730634,
-0.0053090104,
0.0327863134,
-0.0083243968,
-0.0380940288,
0.0577238873,
-0.0078641707,
0.0418619737,
0.0214525461,
-0.0165304542,
-0.0110189132,
-0.0076383478,
0.0420440733,
-0.0329078771,
-0.0353204161,
0.0288895201,
0.0041779107,
0.0398261771,
-0.0784728229,
0.0181691069,
0.065146938,
-0.0046998109,
-0.0221955907,
0.0000020144,
-0.0230976492,
-0.012685624,
-0.0017712296,
0.0045643165,
-0.0056387046,
0.0244363267,
-0.045667991,
0.0274644811,
0.0012448471,
-0.0036521142,
-0.0384235643,
0.04853018,
0.1015701368,
0.0635597855,
0.080102779,
-0.0097113,
-0.0226533972,
0.0286452509,
-0.0409427024,
0.0549251065,
-0.0921410173,
0.0500741713,
0.0252621248,
0.0131621696,
0.0229821745,
-0.0236385837,
0.0711448938,
0.0266068354,
0.021278223,
0.0556021295,
0.0847523957,
-0.0030704017,
0.0103860572,
-0.0103471205,
0.0779782087,
-0.0422182903,
-0.0183956269,
-0.0016655372,
-0.002818391,
0.0093133347,
-0.0698093176,
-0.0258728079,
-0.0080775376,
-0.0296061598,
0.0162401255,
0.0210369434,
0.0306730159,
0.0296100173,
-0.0224540588,
-0.0099263145,
0.0091468887,
-0.0147804841,
-0.0484864898,
-0.0005896084,
-0.0121560572,
-0.0063341176,
-0.0344885737,
0.0426740497,
0.0530511364,
-0.0064952001,
-0.0037608328,
-0.0612768084,
-0.0340476818,
0.0456206277,
-0.066649884,
0.0000346465,
0.0233722534,
-0.0356483981,
0.0594469197,
-0.015687611,
0.014018951,
-0.0251673907,
0.0653284639,
-0.0494911149,
0.0121194208,
-0.0471253879,
0.0169464666,
-0.0721239522,
0.0157914422,
0.0269925501,
-0.0033876935,
-0.052153945,
-0.0077741793,
0.0108733661,
-0.0382578485,
0.0173531007,
0.018498797,
-0.0339751244,
0.0128850462,
0.0166312214,
0.0204722658,
-0.0257589426,
-0.0251086932,
-0.018202832,
0.0012215881,
-0.011537293,
0.0528155565,
-0.0051035443,
-0.0139101511,
0.0112744216,
0.065180555,
-0.0101233711,
-0.0463603176,
-0.0035162074,
-0.0211326871,
-0.0397524089,
-0.007733338,
0.0035873745,
-0.0305169001,
0.0515327975,
0.012144574,
0.0186035894,
-0.0603834614,
-0.0035538625,
-0.001509747,
-0.0634897053,
0.0507625379,
-0.026728306,
-0.0100179529,
0.0134739196,
0.0291626565,
0.0102802543,
0.0308767352,
0.0284085199,
-0.0130243339,
0.001621196,
-0.0252258051,
0.0368691646,
-0.0120990667,
0.0280410796,
-0.0089267669,
0.0081992242,
0.0453113765,
0.0092186481,
0.0405268036,
0.0419780985,
0.0424042456,
-0.0123793818,
-0.0402778536,
0.0396747328,
0.0356125273,
0.0270151775,
-0.0003598764,
0.0194634125,
-0.0213307478,
-0.0189161431,
-0.0422634967,
-0.020988008,
0.0517493747,
0.0375246331,
0.0208055731,
0.0641380176,
-0.0442871563,
-0.0403332785,
-0.0402910262,
-0.0229097083,
0.0022162502,
-0.0294212773,
-0.0052437629,
0.0296680499,
-0.0242091529,
-0.0315614305,
0.0821905956,
0.0267451294,
-0.0157898348,
-0.0095766485,
-0.049216345,
-0.011669416,
0.0557644069,
0.0204162337,
-0.0456545278,
-0.0217366125,
-0.0254158676,
0.0531088486,
0.0117817353,
0.0340927467,
0.0175912511,
0.0032385795,
-0.0560119897,
0.0019283728,
0.0272586551,
-0.0010835138,
0.0038980609,
-0.0148341702,
0.0164394267,
-0.0249697026,
-0.0140224639,
-0.0438239239,
0.0424563289,
0.0148854926,
-0.0369397104,
-0.0004603581,
0.0012259348,
0.0454880297,
0.0008553951,
-0.0118909869,
0.0453470536,
0.0281167682,
-0.0257486477,
-0.0277933273,
-0.058105398,
-0.055896841,
-0.0152381053,
0.0151883196,
-0.0236915275,
-0.0404989496,
-0.0133661237,
-0.0315392204,
-0.0140664279,
-0.0255167838,
-0.0716157407,
0.0105924653,
0.0084784767,
0.009150642,
0.0459888615,
-0.0005731455,
-0.03216381,
0.0457638241,
-0.0546726622,
0.0136388503,
-0.0081299506,
0.0130212931,
0.0248603243,
-0.0078576449,
-0.0126812067,
0.0034203557,
-0.0205740612,
0.0228785686,
-0.0269166827,
0.0288115051,
-0.000540095,
-0.0109195057,
-0.0928965881,
-0.0106273191,
-0.0010230262,
-0.013696624,
0.0370431952,
-0.0004719329,
0.0117394095,
-0.0255068708,
-0.0431958064,
-0.020177329,
-0.0180584993,
0.0179301631,
0.0277191438,
0.0127174817,
0.0097963875,
-0.0014110968,
-0.0029649665,
-0.0334570222,
0.006530331,
0.0234316103,
-0.0546868667,
-0.0510066636,
-0.0105206408,
-0.0229086187,
-0.0003510781,
0.0064952765,
-0.0457637832,
0.0189496838,
-0.004421317,
0.0171083584,
0.0613655224,
0.0103614945,
-0.0006072488,
0.0479122587,
0.0144881196,
-0.0133533878,
0.0447205901,
-0.0310713742,
0.0142957568,
0.011517386,
-0.0630068257,
0.0177568514,
0.1284713,
0.0172254927,
0.0151684908,
-0.0646065697,
-0.0594467446,
-0.0003873248,
0.0120641245,
-0.0626036525,
0.0013458214,
-0.0395710059,
0.0353537574,
-0.0111124413,
-0.0467858687,
0.0878461227,
-0.0158561971,
0.0129894363,
-0.0830610022,
0.009136592,
-0.0395758152,
0.0108046299,
-0.0308318343,
0.0437446125,
0.0063248794,
-0.0281944107,
0.0350910686,
0.0329171754,
-0.0395832956,
-0.0533753484,
0.0530784987,
0.0163931251,
0.0172211807,
-0.0011147507,
-0.025934279,
-0.0309684724,
-0.0020797427,
-0.027633911,
-0.0046998537,
-0.010394617,
0.0122590028,
-0.0721313208,
0.0662503988,
0.0065253624,
0.0739576444,
-0.0023789606,
0.009606434,
0.0000794468,
0.0352174714,
-0.0034028529,
-0.0211393386,
-0.0147754671,
-0.0274104923,
0.0049700411,
0.0814702362,
0.0214450397,
0.0455363877,
0.0241075102,
0.002498233,
-0.0004364198,
-0.0098509891,
0.0076028006,
0.0251423139,
0.0171678886,
-0.0567479171,
-0.0316583626,
0.1001669988,
0.0336218104,
-0.1263307184,
0.0096583571,
-0.0101002548,
-0.0068986015,
-0.0102451397,
0.0161048751,
-0.042887792,
-0.0522074476,
-0.0113621838,
0.0216752999,
0.0105255935,
-0.0300341472,
0.0288132988,
-0.003095143,
0.0054208864,
0.0287257787,
-0.0743048489,
-0.0878668427,
-0.0459941663,
-0.0219069142,
0.0295329764,
-0.018950399,
0.0119446106,
0.0162303001,
-0.0274549592,
-0.0018554728,
-0.0476087146,
-0.0451455303,
0.0558292046,
-0.001339167,
0.0305928774,
0.0787701458,
0.035955362,
0.0104656052,
-0.0433949009,
0.0637461096,
-0.0146825807,
0.0000378722,
-0.0195040666,
0.076075539,
-0.0555256866,
-0.0211928245,
-0.0277566854,
0.0117686475,
-0.0704772696,
-0.0106223719,
0.005166885,
0.102496244,
-0.008210687,
-0.0250269454,
-0.0708375573,
0.0120307943,
0.0310155805,
0.0538104773,
0.0408042297,
-0.0499850474,
-0.0219349768,
-0.0022527822,
0.0367284715,
-0.0374299139,
-0.0376227386,
0.0684132054,
-0.0547092371,
-0.0916351229,
-0.0536532924,
-0.0496622361,
0.0390149504,
-0.0192792322,
-0.0003450963,
-0.004023172,
0.0054599848,
-0.0081382114,
-0.0513025448,
0.0787728056,
-0.014375858,
-0.0146701746,
-0.10619618,
-0.0390781425,
0.0311903954,
0.0180503987,
-0.0193656962,
0.0439780541,
-0.0503760166,
0.006122001,
0.0013850154,
0.0384144597,
0.0089088902,
0.0308287889,
-0.0441566892,
-0.0288123004,
-0.0115225436,
-0.0090495357,
-0.0218538344,
-0.0058369222,
-0.0017885332,
-0.0292930715,
0.0070087379,
0.0260265693,
-0.0283721145,
0.079739064,
0.0394309387,
0.0373637378,
-0.0230688248,
-0.0309390016,
0.0053415853,
0.0019650683,
0.0573120564,
0.0035209276,
-0.0171197504,
0.0125930523,
0.0309257898,
0.0155128166,
-0.0047142836,
-0.0003673225,
-0.0016994551,
0.0437092446,
-0.0462431908,
-0.0249018744,
-0.0053621205,
-0.0264371578,
-0.0764228553,
-0.0035211369,
0.034390565,
-0.013731068,
0.0338935964,
0.0296963044,
-0.0223089755,
-0.050465446,
0.0045604529,
0.0064327642,
0.021936493,
0.0030647162,
0.04420764,
-0.001054766,
0.0336766839,
0.0054597515,
0.0332063772,
-0.0453896113,
0.0104223071,
-0.0436269939,
-0.0280366167,
0.0197775885,
0.0093651069,
0.0204176847,
-0.0108829737,
0.0226497501,
-0.0325070396,
0.0255723521,
-0.0189438537,
0.0097645251,
0.028323276,
0.009652785,
0.0060102972,
-0.0167587753,
0.0749361515,
0.0016481131,
0.0015590751,
-0.0008810183,
-0.0470241979,
-0.0452045985,
0.0217080656,
0.0056174891,
0.0152201047,
-0.037005607,
0.0140491826,
-0.0545592196,
-0.0350927785,
0.0634024888,
-0.0173231661,
-0.0208490603,
0.0107644862,
0.049866125,
0.021074079,
0.0052885474,
-0.0229615699,
-0.0254646,
0.0422851518,
0.0070487126,
-0.0335125923,
-0.0079222722,
-6.131137925e-33,
-0.0165315699,
-0.0198713373,
0.0061342423,
-0.0246112868,
-0.0153081315,
0.0336514898,
-0.0491149016,
-0.0209714659,
-0.0098099289,
0.0201525465,
-0.0146646872,
0.005107665,
0.0024672511,
0.047269512,
0.015791826,
-0.0224804096,
0.0245897174,
-0.0007093698,
-0.0428457223,
0.0616948493,
-0.0073002316,
0.0406642891,
0.050615292,
-0.0836556628,
0.0122443512,
-0.0111729456,
0.0447793119,
0.0098447334,
0.0139878336,
0.0476366095,
-0.0562968887,
0.0275232475,
0.0576297715,
-0.0084913708,
-0.0104051186,
0.0431976803,
-0.0839199498,
-0.0237224586,
-0.0175145045,
-0.0287594944,
-0.0119032478,
-0.0620995872,
0.0519794151,
0.0173155144,
0.0178325418,
-0.020560421,
0.0336340107,
-0.0087655298,
-0.0522429645,
-0.0253300741,
-0.0273445863,
0.0516790785,
-0.0072157141,
-0.0096159307,
-0.0012452992,
0.0327019803,
-0.03034137,
0.0617247783,
-0.0664223135,
-0.0011661083,
0.0114224171,
0.0384261012,
0.0130403554,
-0.0193864331,
-0.030241169,
0.0554622076,
0.044139538,
-0.0067187487,
-0.0247774217,
0.007583614,
-0.0281972643,
0.0041898936,
0.0581822954,
-0.0082528545,
0.0225445125,
-0.0187307224,
-0.0694423988,
-0.0063853166,
-0.0703667253,
0.0376331061,
0.063681446,
-0.0140593424,
-0.062659584,
-0.0065226648,
0.0106099807,
0.0245531444,
-0.0359866358,
-0.0278546475,
0.0520590283,
-0.0021063474,
-0.0140489638,
0.012810491,
0.0351768695,
0.003374442,
0.0148284305,
-0.0377385095,
0.0839259475,
0.0540821068,
-0.0218438562,
0.0282961223,
-0.0444407165,
-0.00497904,
0.0338510014,
-0.0224207491,
0.0324632116,
0.00456808,
0.0588240959,
-0.0485066697,
-0.0588916056,
-0.0454077348,
0.0153737282,
-0.0240416843,
-0.0086854836,
0.0582706742,
0.0293857511,
0.0322489925,
0.0003552537,
0.0773956478,
-0.0149146328,
-0.0278605148,
-0.0160835665,
-0.0414692871,
0.0117976358,
0.0215073656,
-0.021390181,
-0.0142458947,
-0.0654996112,
0.0405238457,
0.0020342744,
-0.0625946745,
-0.0141533585,
0.0468164086,
2.731e-7,
0.0927440971,
0.0367048122,
0.0121105025,
-0.0391707383,
0.0281881057,
0.0141016776,
-0.0053161653,
0.03528817,
-0.0054013287,
-0.017196415,
0.0305647962,
0.0169823449,
0.0217654705,
0.0137848109,
-0.0907417685,
-0.054061681,
-0.0428872108,
0.0221867915,
-0.0039234194,
-0.0210239217,
0.0630996302,
0.1001135632,
-0.0418242887,
0.0062744017,
0.0315313041,
-0.0127116265,
0.0383360386,
0.0001670925,
0.0145263327,
0.0268208999,
-0.0129897306,
0.0184160601,
-0.0116040614,
0.0470395461,
-0.0164037142,
-0.0355673693,
0.0083565852,
0.0981302708,
-0.0613080785,
-0.0383863263,
0.0159026682,
0.0307815522,
0.0196962506,
-0.0331561752,
0.0525900796,
-0.0695890635,
-0.003579336,
-0.0029103858,
-0.0035606262,
0.0177634303,
0.0436257124,
-0.0035828729,
-0.0451256819,
0.0423674509,
0.0250397064,
-0.0064403145,
-0.0175066032,
-0.1120487675,
-0.0318351202,
0.0301082581,
-0.0401812978,
-0.0062967632,
-0.0206807293,
-0.0129645886,
0.0403862037,
-0.0553676151,
-0.0290775616,
2.266578335e-34,
0.040144369,
-0.0357733183,
0.0091117285,
0.0550752841,
0.0077132382,
-0.0485668704,
0.0076679364,
-0.0037094941,
0.036140155,
-0.0642968267,
-0.0110843899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08845v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08845v1 | Has Sentiment Returned to the Pre-pandemic Level? A Sentiment Analysis Using U.S. College Subreddit Data from 2019 to 2022 | 2023-09-16T02:57:30 | 2023-09-16T02:57:30 | Tian Yan, Fang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | As impact of COVID-19 pandemic winds down, both individuals and society
gradually return to pre-pandemic activities. This study aims to explore how
people's emotions have changed from the pre-pandemic during the pandemic to
post-emergency period and whether it has returned to pre-pandemic level. We
collected Reddit data in 2019 (pre-pandemic), 2020 (peak pandemic), 2021, and
2022 (late stages of pandemic, transitioning period to post-emergency period)
from subreddits in 128 universities/colleges in the U.S., and a set of
school-level characteristics. We predicted two sets of sentiments from a
pre-trained Robustly Optimized BERT pre-training approach (RoBERTa) and graph
attention network (GAT) that leverages both rich semantic and relational
information among posted messages and then applied a logistic stacking method
to obtain the final sentiment classification. After obtaining sentiment label
for each message, we used a generalized linear mixed-effects model to estimate
temporal trend in sentiment from 2019 to 2022 and how school-level factors may
affect sentiment. Compared to the year 2019, the odds of negative sentiment in
years 2020, 2021, and 2022 are 24%, 4.3%, and 10.3% higher, respectively, which
are all statistically significant(adjusted $p$<0.05). Our study findings
suggest a partial recovery in the sentiment composition in the
post-pandemic-emergency era. The results align with common expectations and
provide a detailed quantification of how sentiments have evolved from 2019 to
2022. | [
0.0119772274,
0.0773163289,
-0.0177023616,
-0.031910032,
-0.0011930362,
-0.0267785881,
-0.0371156,
0.0016814366,
0.0314194858,
-0.0427465402,
-0.0132142818,
0.0027582799,
-0.0405990072,
0.0171749871,
0.023238916,
-0.0684371367,
0.0126357963,
0.0876281559,
0.0498629957,
-0.0220453832,
0.0303616356,
-0.0082329614,
0.0026843355,
0.0305624586,
-0.0022477023,
-0.0077086221,
0.0280622728,
0.040540386,
0.0650554448,
-0.0614220835,
0.0589187741,
0.0394577868,
0.0201531071,
0.0087638274,
0.0000023852,
-0.0413803495,
-0.0109924357,
-0.0225319602,
0.0285611227,
-0.0037674305,
0.0502766259,
-0.0186473057,
0.0159329996,
0.0247162692,
-0.0372035541,
-0.067364417,
0.0594828911,
0.0249764379,
0.0336981677,
0.049110759,
-0.018165905,
-0.0627567843,
0.0143881952,
0.0006098642,
-0.0281172879,
0.0253398698,
0.0132521903,
-0.0624578372,
0.0045525134,
-0.0429492742,
0.0098620523,
0.0091058929,
-0.0290905554,
0.0080301221,
0.0288875047,
0.0758764818,
-0.020148892,
0.0014609558,
-0.0108473785,
0.0474889278,
0.0362676941,
-0.0316998661,
0.0032632367,
0.0020089464,
-0.001825311,
0.01874144,
-0.0514587052,
-0.0467608124,
0.0166701637,
0.0303026214,
-0.0175306033,
0.0252685789,
0.0326055326,
0.0221520271,
0.0025773093,
0.0247101914,
-0.029594982,
-0.0650407821,
0.0072249179,
0.0227525551,
0.0083221933,
0.0011875316,
0.0372238457,
-0.0004146994,
0.0368515849,
0.0156601835,
0.0306441206,
-0.047928147,
0.0216500945,
-0.0880229101,
-0.0309538394,
0.0243106522,
0.0032535861,
0.0141021265,
0.0402058586,
0.0046728449,
-0.0213761497,
0.0100026373,
0.0229128171,
0.0609449111,
-0.0963999182,
0.0468004122,
0.0072955,
0.0187175032,
0.0634758472,
0.0243916009,
-0.0379694887,
-0.0488036349,
-0.0289671887,
-0.0393715128,
-0.0366552807,
-0.0020215525,
0.0067769829,
0.0187890306,
0.0039836722,
0.1027653962,
-0.0386452265,
-0.0052496511,
-0.0053257835,
0.0083919093,
0.0070040082,
-0.0062887678,
0.0567881316,
-0.0023035321,
-0.0115805306,
0.0151124354,
0.0450065993,
0.0109728249,
-0.0043426077,
-0.0130326673,
-0.034799166,
-0.0288991742,
0.0591659397,
-0.0395656265,
0.0131088942,
0.0232037771,
-0.0011554204,
0.0469691344,
0.0150078097,
-0.0068067936,
-0.0711240172,
-0.0078819189,
-0.030922005,
0.0066053146,
0.0264779814,
0.0053798188,
0.0326709859,
-0.0050714347,
-0.0189086106,
0.0418214239,
0.0219047833,
-0.0162273683,
-0.0394948162,
0.01014347,
0.0561091378,
0.0046118167,
-0.0273610279,
-0.0095024379,
-0.0210541748,
-0.0132634575,
-0.0314032361,
0.0105887521,
0.0066456194,
0.0043144692,
0.0266371071,
0.0408654176,
-0.072537072,
0.0441597365,
-0.0476668105,
0.0251332689,
0.0077036317,
-0.0109148873,
-0.0130176097,
0.0107992925,
-0.0096479366,
-0.0049566226,
0.0358162858,
0.0059709391,
-0.0200852919,
-0.0365250558,
-0.0426934846,
-0.0252276286,
0.0084017916,
-0.0295662973,
0.0334133506,
-0.0675349087,
-0.05343372,
-0.0013030623,
0.0620019883,
-0.0546558164,
0.0092471549,
-0.0489866212,
0.0280152913,
0.0708778277,
-0.019267723,
-0.0001081279,
-0.0521047935,
-0.0313472189,
0.0138249043,
0.0325937234,
0.0314869098,
0.0542685613,
-0.0467610769,
-0.0100531094,
-0.0091349892,
-0.0003475063,
0.0386119597,
0.0055366242,
-0.0168231577,
0.0283540804,
-0.0468575209,
0.0013204596,
-0.0159844533,
-0.0120949177,
0.0646935925,
0.0455798283,
-0.0207421128,
0.0125522818,
0.0383767448,
0.0063963914,
-0.0115049118,
0.0313349217,
0.0367230214,
-0.0221543871,
-0.0637470111,
0.0038745943,
0.0010133462,
0.0011172869,
0.0021311708,
-0.0402736887,
-0.0191799235,
0.0313651077,
-0.0408271961,
0.0318252109,
0.1046197787,
0.0048266454,
0.072164841,
0.0363747478,
-0.0456412137,
-0.0460651517,
-0.0036343371,
0.007034149,
0.0102043096,
-0.054365892,
-0.0048852018,
-0.042249795,
-0.0808466375,
-0.0173759814,
0.014757432,
-0.0220413692,
-0.0248321444,
0.0085462909,
-0.0038488309,
0.0152791087,
-0.0303840321,
-0.0545710176,
0.0019082925,
-0.0817842782,
-0.0201139227,
-0.0114147076,
0.0205594096,
0.0424177051,
-0.0120257195,
0.0002058333,
0.0119193392,
-0.0106208548,
0.0246671811,
-0.0193410572,
0.021335138,
0.0240383185,
-0.0153290927,
0.0395163521,
-0.0796306729,
-0.0391124338,
-0.0577272959,
0.0079908315,
0.0677421391,
-0.0667918921,
0.0387207121,
0.0115545765,
-0.0653761998,
-0.0201222654,
-0.0089427428,
-0.0759788305,
-0.0015981705,
-0.0161898304,
0.0429433286,
0.0345355906,
0.0151165109,
0.0504538231,
0.0352809094,
0.0468570367,
-0.0540996976,
0.020410452,
-0.0642660856,
-0.0105120679,
-0.0196410101,
-0.026233077,
0.0016249347,
0.0551513471,
0.0177445952,
0.0030803806,
-0.0427973196,
-0.023901578,
-0.0358101726,
-0.0014125253,
-0.0193225816,
0.0017424675,
-0.005154863,
-0.0074153948,
-0.0068011642,
-0.0282771401,
0.007870133,
0.0793306604,
0.0405809209,
-0.0357817896,
0.0041585425,
-0.0119803622,
0.0169311184,
-0.0029160767,
-0.003215658,
0.0006309606,
0.0180730708,
0.0113386242,
-0.0656376928,
-0.03511196,
-0.0374288782,
-0.0194584634,
0.0050994307,
0.0072259656,
-0.0062093483,
0.001357906,
0.0101882406,
-0.0181283168,
-0.0497618243,
-0.0183656253,
0.0147285582,
-0.0129735023,
-0.0135862008,
-0.0245690141,
-0.0155413412,
-0.0260743033,
0.0065151798,
-0.0305424295,
0.0661448613,
-0.000335463,
-0.0112726232,
-0.0216415022,
0.0048110974,
-0.0280360077,
-0.0279188454,
0.0325829461,
0.0255982876,
-0.0003256097,
-0.0158067793,
-0.0502237864,
0.0196382143,
0.0133250076,
-0.0240685996,
-0.0075767888,
0.0149534494,
-0.0432917364,
0.0164365824,
0.0692864582,
-0.0153913768,
-0.0335345566,
0.0033621285,
-0.0232048873,
0.0125706308,
-0.0059289979,
0.0034441706,
-0.0242151022,
-0.0072298893,
-0.0288643856,
0.0186635163,
-0.014874761,
-0.0253941268,
0.0198950246,
-0.0740367845,
0.034236297,
-0.0005395976,
-0.0287113674,
0.012515326,
-0.0598633699,
0.0248655416,
0.0320279896,
-0.019840695,
-0.0654974207,
0.0186194032,
0.0189718716,
-0.0010182486,
-0.0970927253,
0.0002138362,
0.0076004984,
-0.0135029983,
0.0225978568,
0.0062765297,
0.0964888334,
-0.0248693489,
-0.0515509658,
0.0741345137,
0.0524969026,
-0.0168652739,
-0.0338939466,
0.1050340161,
-0.0211625956,
0.0144605041,
-0.0332924239,
0.0076070018,
-0.0440501794,
0.0138104977,
0.002894525,
0.0923889056,
0.0226882547,
-0.0700340867,
-0.070536755,
0.0668912008,
0.0192956422,
0.0040708259,
0.0166165866,
-0.0126703205,
0.0123804417,
-0.0110052824,
0.0734614357,
-0.055625692,
-0.0111593893,
-0.0342532396,
-0.0389531776,
-0.0571016781,
-0.0226817522,
-0.0311390292,
-0.0110562053,
-0.0348441862,
-0.0314719453,
-0.0608044155,
0.0654519796,
-0.0192924682,
-0.0435260199,
0.0073523819,
0.0212883595,
0.017197255,
-0.0418231823,
-0.0440465957,
0.0357144065,
0.0500576869,
-0.0144664682,
-0.0205476526,
-0.0270700678,
-0.0017779544,
0.0342692286,
0.037406709,
0.0129462844,
-0.0017683206,
0.0316668451,
0.0377734452,
0.0493893959,
0.0369674563,
-0.0115444409,
-0.0256290883,
0.0605716221,
0.0304777026,
0.0033609024,
0.0029346694,
0.0055464222,
0.0326380916,
0.0262078717,
-0.0312404782,
-0.0175951608,
-0.0086420495,
-0.0033628317,
-0.0085252961,
0.0824089199,
0.0285664257,
-0.0493154339,
-0.0357349105,
-0.0327985324,
0.0327821523,
0.0232289787,
0.000512953,
-0.0722942948,
0.0141258789,
0.0085182004,
-0.061919976,
0.0062610488,
-0.0400309786,
0.0063558444,
-0.0585242696,
0.0752482787,
-0.0059148027,
0.0500223562,
0.0389614515,
-0.0103244716,
-0.0145734074,
0.0054927091,
0.0295656379,
-0.0125210192,
-0.0031400768,
0.0097686863,
-0.0070954543,
0.0141902911,
0.0305681229,
-0.0117241489,
-0.0525873825,
-0.0185818672,
-0.027327098,
0.0081579965,
-0.0047228807,
0.0331415534,
0.0560523234,
0.0186483283,
-0.0224440787,
-0.0274092965,
0.0527583174,
-0.0371114388,
-0.0159367826,
0.0212545078,
-0.0317916237,
-0.0268670134,
-0.0030538305,
0.0052986331,
-0.0692827255,
0.0893820375,
0.0486251861,
-0.0066028931,
0.0206248835,
-0.0295708682,
0.0350738913,
0.0035782601,
0.0183870662,
0.0463469923,
-0.0348524898,
-0.0186882429,
0.0682472587,
-0.0638875663,
0.0024219761,
-0.0367491767,
-0.0061010746,
-0.0101265786,
0.0087275542,
0.0544550531,
0.0171429086,
0.0571642779,
-0.0523846075,
-0.0288139731,
-0.0391326323,
-6.92982499e-33,
0.0365676656,
-0.021408502,
-0.0784908235,
-0.0070906705,
-0.0547498092,
0.0466322675,
-0.0369821377,
0.008522843,
-0.0197400935,
0.0295439251,
-0.0069157961,
0.0252801497,
-0.0009484705,
0.0230542608,
0.0449228957,
-0.0576826222,
0.0294162072,
-0.0128795998,
0.0081896819,
0.036362268,
0.0271960385,
0.0485783927,
0.0863893852,
-0.0539256521,
0.0351659507,
-0.0174822193,
0.027942216,
-0.011869085,
0.0411512554,
-0.001312511,
-0.0140521284,
0.0678703189,
0.0498371609,
-0.0135144247,
0.0125580467,
0.0461508892,
-0.015276785,
-0.0586451441,
-0.0063570566,
-0.0409666076,
-0.0195976812,
-0.0331713893,
0.0316523202,
0.0297001153,
-0.0234513395,
-0.0352161787,
0.0314895399,
0.0337023586,
0.0466022752,
-0.0598113351,
-0.0328889787,
0.024131598,
-0.0385828242,
0.0422524922,
-0.0716048256,
0.0680438876,
0.0317466557,
0.1035058647,
-0.0656947047,
0.0268953647,
-0.0386978835,
-0.0116089145,
-0.0047985599,
-0.0463740751,
0.0156332422,
0.0536547825,
0.0189369004,
0.0432160199,
-0.0599011406,
0.0082406215,
0.0262867939,
-0.0030718276,
0.0198979266,
0.043159198,
0.0644532815,
-0.0951122269,
-0.0746106058,
-0.0000466304,
0.0191929322,
0.0416489653,
0.0205062069,
0.0259799697,
0.0011135032,
-0.0063845329,
0.0209734477,
-0.0614131056,
-0.0097776838,
0.0059745326,
-0.0322723165,
-0.0420107096,
-0.0408590287,
-0.0328306258,
0.0019735501,
-0.0072955485,
-0.0576904789,
0.027658347,
0.0139127187,
0.0067114187,
0.0167817604,
0.0535511449,
-0.0683388859,
0.01219765,
-0.025543632,
0.0659513474,
0.0372754782,
0.0213796422,
0.0361793451,
0.0223157126,
-0.0540089607,
-0.0248517599,
-0.0321168192,
0.0109869922,
-0.0190464221,
0.0097069461,
0.0220294576,
0.0371052697,
0.0392421037,
-0.0045340341,
0.0440241136,
0.0763742179,
0.0167552195,
-0.0079018064,
-0.0235075224,
0.0105509469,
-0.0210463814,
-0.0296297669,
-0.0210792981,
0.0136989104,
-0.0200197771,
-0.0867339149,
-0.0147699751,
-0.047984466,
3.035e-7,
0.0782494396,
0.0568858795,
0.0027668516,
-0.0047213212,
0.0003835902,
0.0292529557,
-0.0184708498,
0.015391943,
0.0456449725,
0.0071945325,
-0.0023226046,
0.0237932168,
-0.0151102394,
0.0034034047,
-0.0520425439,
-0.0052076154,
-0.071870707,
0.0192124415,
-0.0092330184,
0.0383821689,
0.0937217698,
0.0394103155,
0.0588915385,
0.0014771142,
-0.0461174585,
0.0343030877,
0.0432515144,
-0.0734094903,
-0.0112713203,
-0.0060919067,
-0.0155871827,
0.017404424,
-0.0349111594,
-0.0038366474,
-0.0089603513,
-0.0098716579,
-0.0160016939,
0.0345126726,
0.0038993019,
-0.0108740376,
0.0272468776,
-0.0042904052,
0.0205535553,
-0.0298774876,
0.0320780948,
-0.1145804003,
-0.0274031777,
-0.0350628793,
-0.0848724321,
0.0383634456,
0.0632533953,
-0.0118258735,
-0.0495042093,
0.0213233214,
-0.0205377322,
0.0236874446,
-0.0241112076,
-0.0690701231,
0.0128719481,
-0.0081417924,
-0.0427115671,
-0.049053058,
-0.0016094717,
0.0490219779,
0.0230288096,
0.0017907502,
0.0378467031,
2.252933647e-34,
0.0606377684,
-0.0202130321,
-0.0176821165,
-0.0327921286,
0.0178423729,
-0.0252526198,
-0.0113900239,
-0.0070196567,
0.0248789061,
0.0063415146,
-0.001838836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08836v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08836v2 | Bias and Fairness in Chatbots: An Overview | 2023-09-16T02:01:18 | 2023-12-10T23:38:28 | Jintang Xue, Yun-Cheng Wang, Chengwei Wei, Xiaofeng Liu, Jonghye Woo, C. -C. Jay Kuo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Chatbots have been studied for more than half a century. With the rapid
development of natural language processing (NLP) technologies in recent years,
chatbots using large language models (LLMs) have received much attention
nowadays. Compared with traditional ones, modern chatbots are more powerful and
have been used in real-world applications. There are however, bias and fairness
concerns in modern chatbot design. Due to the huge amounts of training data,
extremely large model sizes, and lack of interpretability, bias mitigation and
fairness preservation of modern chatbots are challenging. Thus, a comprehensive
overview on bias and fairness in chatbot systems is given in this paper. The
history of chatbots and their categories are first reviewed. Then, bias sources
and potential harms in applications are analyzed. Considerations in designing
fair and unbiased chatbot systems are examined. Finally, future research
directions are discussed. | [
0.0987210795,
0.0243569016,
-0.0498718321,
0.0335661732,
-0.029639788,
-0.0046126451,
0.0456898473,
-0.017874755,
0.0587430932,
-0.0820860714,
-0.0057131383,
0.011730615,
-0.0283137057,
-0.0096256109,
-0.0179315303,
-0.0821878687,
0.022356132,
0.0001712569,
0.057126265,
-0.0413603038,
0.0410180725,
0.0216956027,
-0.010953078,
0.0788060203,
-0.0626441017,
-0.0109835137,
0.0132369054,
0.0017031831,
-0.0002634053,
0.0295235887,
0.0023633875,
0.0446376279,
-0.013078412,
0.0721502304,
0.0000017607,
-0.0319458283,
-0.0012233671,
0.0082207732,
-0.0545460396,
-0.0518442169,
0.071178332,
-0.0137940757,
-0.0156055894,
0.0479617119,
-0.0420629606,
0.0219443347,
0.059135545,
0.0238129087,
0.0550634414,
0.0497372784,
-0.0035146009,
-0.0114360675,
-0.0204593185,
0.0253897216,
0.0124199167,
-0.0425012298,
0.0137078809,
0.0023168218,
-0.0145559981,
-0.0239892416,
-0.0361366384,
0.0094180275,
0.0202364158,
-0.0230969153,
0.0222069342,
-0.0109735904,
-0.0511813909,
-0.0558195226,
-0.0224701036,
0.0745444149,
0.0121684866,
0.0018218963,
-0.0237382073,
-0.0164832547,
0.0466065817,
-0.0198473074,
-0.0464822985,
0.0619219579,
0.0059627383,
0.0142389368,
-0.0196598247,
0.0089937095,
-0.0122235538,
0.0289654024,
-0.0231315326,
0.026551988,
0.0085604163,
-0.0269856472,
-0.028005166,
0.0500291809,
0.0155122187,
-0.0637424216,
0.0087671503,
0.041182939,
-0.0419578366,
0.0267135892,
-0.0270719174,
-0.0200169608,
0.0192987286,
-0.0648145974,
-0.0516584069,
0.039814245,
-0.0066975313,
0.0229443293,
0.0384811386,
0.0454755314,
0.0096033458,
0.0379927382,
-0.0180608891,
-0.0427023396,
-0.0060330587,
-0.0066817431,
-0.0127037345,
0.0190670751,
-0.0358036794,
0.0252623893,
-0.0477445722,
0.041763369,
-0.0391993262,
-0.0311713461,
0.0099112764,
0.0165197384,
-0.0244824458,
0.0103532681,
-0.0532182381,
0.0077670799,
-0.0351753049,
0.0271978434,
-0.0290684383,
-0.1176347882,
-0.0066732583,
0.0014333111,
-0.0252136607,
-0.0331493206,
-0.0148843266,
0.0861164182,
0.0373389125,
-0.0455367304,
0.0082196193,
-0.0470585525,
-0.0122598661,
-0.0537781715,
-0.0244091358,
-0.0188842919,
0.0199155025,
0.0159885306,
0.0082225921,
0.0038472342,
-0.0085827587,
0.0112314103,
-0.0696328953,
0.0460715815,
0.0088041378,
0.0136974668,
0.0298859645,
0.0052577788,
-0.0207083449,
0.0946944728,
0.0252371542,
-0.000314116,
0.0473735966,
-0.0036871014,
0.0075157508,
-0.0014206914,
-0.0116170533,
-0.0350243598,
-0.0014266486,
0.0144823166,
-0.0302460026,
0.0310059078,
0.0316154584,
0.0473713763,
-0.0272104796,
-0.0206743442,
0.0679834932,
0.0468149893,
-0.0221206062,
0.0069299936,
-0.0110145239,
0.001794221,
0.0013546245,
0.0306012984,
-0.0584770292,
-0.0085539222,
-0.0142133404,
-0.058250621,
0.0008531451,
0.010817077,
-0.0394919738,
-0.0318018086,
0.0138029056,
-0.0180691294,
0.0496177189,
0.0052254815,
0.0235831477,
-0.0032396463,
-0.0006782506,
0.0259727575,
0.0243963916,
-0.0423728675,
-0.0275705848,
-0.0777291581,
-0.0054495363,
0.0609547794,
0.0284835696,
-0.0144048752,
0.0175910052,
-0.0119226994,
-0.0316356532,
0.0701584369,
0.0610402562,
0.0129718985,
-0.0019373855,
-0.0415700264,
-0.0385194533,
0.0127345314,
0.0113806091,
0.0010749119,
-0.0165445488,
0.0459467843,
-0.0249106437,
0.0096614268,
-0.0203094278,
0.041197408,
0.0435633361,
-0.0227464531,
-0.0369295031,
0.0013507613,
0.0463294238,
0.0321580879,
-0.0332058184,
-0.0169109628,
-0.0036384272,
0.0110969003,
-0.0179625899,
0.0435299091,
-0.0417580009,
-0.0411866978,
0.0213655066,
-0.0575708263,
-0.0226699207,
0.0758665204,
-0.0218770877,
0.0123077845,
0.0361773558,
-0.0451576859,
0.0466782823,
-0.02102484,
0.0351435691,
-0.0531813391,
0.0488233641,
-0.0554415248,
0.0041068979,
0.0100890826,
-0.0333444253,
0.0031494813,
-0.0172333643,
-0.0148689477,
-0.0563082173,
-0.0188011806,
0.0452555902,
0.0162893496,
0.0199774764,
0.0408898331,
-0.0117758438,
-0.0154514555,
0.0028908625,
-0.0961218327,
-0.0170812756,
-0.0015459919,
-0.038317509,
-0.0085154809,
0.0346472338,
-0.0041891094,
-0.0288037509,
-0.0222991649,
0.0024719911,
0.0389459059,
0.0449599326,
0.0316021629,
-0.010783378,
-0.0548125729,
-0.0277848914,
-0.0043309745,
-0.0089768581,
0.0367750004,
0.0780786574,
-0.0009571311,
-0.046547696,
0.0031074688,
-0.023623025,
0.0413592495,
0.006814451,
-0.0360509083,
0.034996815,
0.0397503227,
-0.0110211,
0.0818411261,
0.0630833805,
0.0601198003,
0.0390488729,
0.0161479339,
-0.0751785561,
-0.0039734938,
0.0167672206,
-0.005345772,
-0.0016046035,
-0.034395352,
-0.0030823494,
0.0411636718,
0.030481346,
-0.0126690576,
-0.0469304398,
0.0480351262,
-0.0182381477,
-0.083575137,
0.0051881014,
-0.0389822796,
-0.0282793287,
0.0047553685,
-0.0002533113,
-0.0671359897,
0.0618567429,
0.004611542,
0.0211735237,
-0.046981506,
-0.0164711066,
-0.0307511594,
0.030880874,
-0.0286697522,
0.0338218771,
-0.0158480331,
-0.0388525277,
-0.0600351505,
-0.0378099084,
0.0520480871,
-0.0480019413,
-0.0263336524,
-0.0116530033,
-0.0043401239,
-0.0150799891,
-0.0433509387,
-0.0717461705,
-0.0757082775,
-0.039277114,
0.0072111213,
0.0653277636,
0.0017232164,
-0.0515152104,
0.0317679085,
-0.0049941908,
0.0024960639,
-0.0073872213,
0.0091570392,
-0.0055902093,
-0.0495054051,
0.0109484866,
0.030502975,
0.042679064,
0.015241378,
0.0330846906,
0.0471990407,
0.0194718167,
0.0260629561,
0.0130182393,
-0.0274025854,
0.0300988425,
-0.0413783491,
0.0007232957,
-0.0079053426,
0.0534635,
-0.0446659103,
0.0443564914,
0.1082103029,
0.0159960762,
-0.058870066,
0.0249386113,
-0.0408807024,
-0.0213133693,
0.0012660823,
0.0059756665,
-0.0961770937,
-0.0253943037,
0.0177226812,
0.0128140552,
-0.0774001926,
-0.046531681,
-0.0014207049,
-0.1042945832,
0.0015508435,
-0.0005885923,
-0.050192818,
-0.0881093964,
-0.0178175643,
-0.0161494091,
-0.0245718081,
0.0735522285,
0.0110035874,
0.0114301499,
-0.0068177544,
0.0154717704,
-0.0536152571,
0.0073449728,
0.0166181158,
-0.0721356198,
0.0772316307,
0.0575915538,
0.0549242534,
0.0091011403,
0.0478553101,
0.0109953173,
0.0299576912,
0.0133157326,
-0.019461792,
0.0544181727,
-0.0448134243,
-0.017922312,
-0.087545827,
-0.0039169709,
0.0396337099,
0.0477136597,
0.0034827637,
0.0252824146,
-0.0170520172,
-0.0210542697,
-0.0755968839,
0.0078883162,
0.0228413083,
0.0632605851,
0.0066415486,
-0.0438348465,
-0.0535460338,
-0.0363681503,
-0.0091860862,
0.0277840532,
-0.0666808188,
0.0207316484,
-0.0145231169,
-0.0237632841,
-0.0578695945,
-0.0645984486,
0.008940124,
0.0037755677,
0.0145250857,
0.0002581529,
-0.0046843542,
0.0194472037,
0.0238912627,
0.005603726,
-0.0406880304,
0.0237963255,
0.0013468548,
-0.0203634202,
-0.0104509098,
-0.0525823645,
-0.00287581,
0.0070618428,
0.0027690146,
-0.046914123,
0.0246191882,
0.0261800755,
0.0250180364,
0.0388852544,
-0.0069733919,
-0.0644168481,
0.0215910599,
0.0519093238,
-0.0404182896,
0.0046230298,
0.0377554707,
0.0302762426,
0.013218835,
0.0218284391,
-0.0665170178,
0.0060654911,
-0.0002648518,
0.0063773175,
-0.0178121552,
-0.0535524301,
0.0140472781,
0.0414131172,
0.0160034746,
0.0115249241,
0.0034100916,
-0.0155663416,
0.0258010216,
-0.0497583002,
-0.0248814188,
-0.0274961106,
-0.0042827763,
-0.0132830814,
0.0335693918,
-0.024649132,
-0.0358716697,
-0.0887592658,
0.0147731137,
0.0060907812,
0.043595545,
-0.0120689571,
0.0244340766,
-0.0132029401,
0.0069959671,
-0.0071257073,
0.0217783432,
-0.0027999827,
0.0309676994,
0.0589232817,
0.0188212432,
0.0259647127,
-0.0148920696,
-0.0281123705,
0.0166581124,
-0.0807112455,
-0.0683951154,
0.0159877893,
0.0275715739,
0.0318792611,
0.0093760053,
0.0304530915,
-0.0102935405,
0.0281859767,
0.0143460259,
0.0246057268,
0.0210083406,
0.0295935031,
0.0068857488,
0.0009563225,
-0.0250650961,
-0.0162492599,
0.0320974179,
0.0081242658,
0.0679462329,
-0.0531920679,
-0.0545117967,
-0.013468598,
-0.0166637599,
0.0391324982,
-0.0274024457,
-0.0040098233,
-0.0194403734,
-0.0650293082,
-0.0483912937,
-0.0527387708,
0.0103798555,
0.0318683162,
-0.0319762491,
0.0276340321,
0.0380500481,
-0.0154846031,
-0.0265918877,
-0.0337240808,
-0.0052514966,
-0.0399212353,
-0.0042973557,
0.0129251648,
-5.521299905e-33,
-0.0081450203,
-0.0200805012,
-0.0088863103,
-0.008522437,
-0.0348270722,
-0.0274395738,
-0.0043827021,
0.0092306351,
-0.0495706052,
0.011056425,
-0.0172289424,
0.0271260757,
0.0295513365,
-0.0368536673,
0.0072953864,
-0.0189495124,
0.0591183528,
-0.0112792039,
-0.0138778398,
0.0025510043,
-0.0033276402,
0.0113867894,
0.032273069,
-0.0618442707,
0.050587669,
0.0004947825,
0.0184162389,
0.0258568786,
-0.0024951284,
0.0315322727,
0.0045870533,
0.0931218043,
0.0469619446,
0.0038789005,
-0.016933389,
0.0441178568,
0.0073923054,
-0.0133783976,
0.0166383367,
0.0681859404,
0.0288557317,
-0.0131251253,
0.0508480519,
0.0022561848,
-0.0586578809,
0.0140576744,
0.046521347,
-0.0055750716,
0.0554882847,
0.0781733021,
-0.0341883413,
-0.0010462143,
-0.0373388082,
-0.0329845995,
-0.0157245826,
0.0173710473,
0.0159375053,
0.0197241064,
0.0025212995,
0.0409889854,
-0.0109734507,
-0.0540255979,
0.0363549031,
0.013031303,
0.0441395789,
0.0832376182,
0.0943249315,
0.0489774607,
-0.0403686166,
-0.070047915,
0.0200307928,
-0.0083173886,
0.0322663262,
0.0647819489,
0.0298444554,
-0.0084851393,
-0.0602827407,
-0.0019846847,
0.080453977,
0.0352512971,
0.0303622,
0.000095869,
-0.0964760408,
-0.0255342796,
-0.0127592841,
-0.0311247874,
-0.0099360077,
-0.0282124076,
0.0224822164,
0.009217632,
0.0058538434,
-0.0197393466,
0.058837831,
-0.0766891465,
-0.0007439489,
0.0220165867,
-0.0062417947,
-0.0279024579,
-0.0095152454,
-0.0341063775,
-0.0315097906,
-0.0252100937,
0.0410089083,
0.0020134144,
0.019623762,
0.0159708913,
-0.0433646701,
0.0280333869,
-0.0181796364,
-0.0007046753,
-0.0150607182,
0.0224940181,
-0.0111939376,
0.0060142367,
0.0172308683,
0.0066454355,
-0.0278476421,
0.0259789024,
0.0137310326,
0.0033999926,
-0.0498538092,
0.0202038474,
-0.0176018514,
-0.0135269975,
-0.0447769389,
-0.0125597976,
0.0061017037,
0.0150427129,
0.021686215,
-0.0614103414,
-0.0284470376,
-0.0769740865,
2.405e-7,
0.0114626987,
0.0431453288,
-0.003588988,
0.0288854949,
0.0083831167,
0.0544714555,
0.0377325863,
0.061974477,
0.0051682848,
0.0340209454,
-0.0147191212,
0.0420223325,
0.0099777421,
0.017276898,
-0.0729844496,
-0.0292061567,
-0.0728528947,
-0.0117412861,
-0.0175372437,
-0.0006717187,
0.0347861312,
0.0615067147,
0.013241333,
-0.0235128067,
0.0024829211,
-0.0207709018,
-0.0059991339,
-0.0197865311,
0.0199710242,
0.0192875639,
0.0246288516,
0.0097192377,
0.044995442,
0.057349287,
0.0727635473,
0.0333239995,
-0.0144865261,
0.0238435026,
-0.0339802094,
-0.0030670958,
0.0095022069,
0.0048722476,
-0.0293936562,
-0.0377090089,
0.0384824276,
0.0096230442,
-0.0598776937,
-0.0685651675,
0.0122671258,
-0.0219830219,
0.0671631396,
-0.0061461073,
-0.0132121062,
0.0245806295,
0.0090661692,
0.0229086746,
0.0140499733,
-0.0575485043,
-0.0089675989,
-0.0605148785,
-0.0461167917,
-0.0802514404,
0.0141172782,
0.0098056477,
0.0220232513,
0.0058415616,
0.0494680591,
1.545514832e-34,
0.0050804992,
0.0299291201,
0.0269793533,
0.0573606454,
0.0253359284,
0.0434870049,
0.0266100168,
-0.0172942895,
0.0560179092,
-0.0120315375,
-0.0366725884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18316v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18316v1 | Cognitive modeling and learning with sparse binary hypervectors | 2023-09-16T01:58:51 | 2023-09-16T01:58:51 | Zhonghao Yang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Following the general theoretical framework of VSA (Vector Symbolic
Architecture), a cognitive model with the use of sparse binary hypervectors is
proposed. In addition, learning algorithms are introduced to bootstrap the
model from incoming data stream, with much improved transparency and
efficiency. Mimicking human cognitive process, the training can be performed
online while inference is in session. Word-level embedding is re-visited with
such hypervectors, and further applications in the field of NLP (Natural
Language Processing) are explored. | [
0.0130710183,
0.0326185301,
-0.0302900039,
0.026500769,
-0.0276438277,
0.0314649083,
-0.0216202326,
0.0159344617,
-0.0023794014,
-0.0672525838,
0.0522370674,
-0.0678773299,
-0.009072233,
0.0422643237,
0.0577192567,
-0.0221843421,
0.0551105514,
0.0251639169,
0.0418407731,
-0.0227801669,
-0.0155061502,
-0.0392802581,
-0.0202263314,
0.0140587753,
-0.0473725572,
0.0156068336,
-0.0275189336,
-0.0362121835,
0.0139118694,
-0.0336886458,
-0.0578839667,
0.0014511351,
0.092114836,
-0.0122762062,
0.0000018137,
0.0036148147,
0.000926697,
-0.0104764272,
-0.022892667,
-0.0450465009,
-0.0152960084,
-0.0264968015,
0.0073013529,
-0.0099397311,
-0.0182136875,
-0.0646285415,
0.0595705099,
0.0705535859,
0.0396255814,
0.0478656031,
-0.026484739,
0.0183087643,
0.0532487109,
0.0111395521,
0.0022369779,
0.0027427927,
0.0419769809,
-0.0051721637,
-0.0362302661,
0.0258197729,
-0.0236243177,
-0.0029631595,
-0.0313035361,
0.0516272262,
0.026398303,
0.0232242867,
-0.0346391946,
-0.0034530615,
-0.0272427648,
0.0471373424,
-0.0244242381,
-0.0068818554,
0.0089130634,
0.0382708795,
-0.0339553058,
0.0102236206,
-0.0541191325,
0.0331055708,
0.0264252499,
0.029995244,
0.0413979888,
0.0015956092,
-0.0133548621,
-0.0132200001,
0.0198617354,
0.0177333951,
0.0054182359,
-0.0382749066,
-0.0085313832,
-0.0113180978,
-0.0713437423,
0.0243776999,
-0.0324361622,
0.0493355207,
-0.0074520158,
0.0154483402,
-0.0157817379,
-0.0264094025,
-0.0097556394,
-0.0989094004,
0.1150881797,
0.0490669645,
0.0069246944,
0.0294236634,
-0.0287751686,
0.0161246322,
-0.0085170576,
0.0350954346,
-0.012038135,
0.0395546257,
-0.0511722639,
-0.0176074319,
-0.0488105677,
0.1153073162,
0.0140469624,
-0.0469458066,
-0.038662795,
0.02550756,
-0.0436228514,
0.0106843859,
-0.0720902532,
0.0139663434,
0.0258180685,
0.0560558885,
-0.0051590214,
-0.0170492809,
0.0036042049,
0.0012815893,
-0.0629384071,
-0.0076054987,
-0.0065701935,
0.0238578264,
0.003420129,
-0.0466818884,
-0.0147102708,
0.0543916859,
0.0118587958,
-0.0576224811,
-0.0545946024,
-0.0295339711,
0.0426612869,
-0.0673401281,
0.012711429,
-0.0465079732,
-0.0007947863,
-0.0109986905,
0.0283891745,
0.0108703207,
0.0165590215,
0.0024691343,
-0.0316286385,
0.0729652047,
-0.0259035416,
-0.0216085464,
0.0008610313,
-0.0180603266,
0.0120667201,
0.0607069582,
-0.0003409412,
-0.0252570901,
-0.0085752411,
0.0067237858,
-0.0063561937,
-0.0212744307,
0.0159870628,
-0.0374376476,
-0.0775127411,
-0.0199619122,
0.0352378488,
0.0044135307,
0.0042026071,
0.0674887076,
-0.0365205593,
0.0042450842,
0.0300800372,
0.0721933469,
0.0179073326,
0.0302678756,
0.0432502702,
0.0043720203,
-0.0015068292,
0.0354197547,
-0.022406185,
0.0559383258,
-0.0664279833,
-0.0123380842,
-0.0221674126,
0.0262485873,
-0.0468867868,
-0.0109646767,
-0.013721264,
-0.0081298184,
0.0062725078,
-0.0203938056,
0.0279602055,
-0.0461971276,
-0.0174341314,
0.0180034228,
0.0403863899,
-0.0090640783,
-0.030255625,
-0.0108030951,
0.0210075974,
-0.0023215259,
0.0391033888,
-0.0346929356,
0.0320709348,
-0.0493174419,
-0.0266399607,
-0.0165151935,
0.0144579737,
-0.0249294303,
-0.0144325187,
-0.0363422297,
-0.0077036973,
0.0005618185,
0.038543269,
-0.0007744944,
-0.0475117713,
0.0029017159,
-0.0050167842,
0.0238566771,
-0.0010506466,
0.0415038243,
0.0281368028,
-0.0202948432,
-0.0304911025,
0.0521505289,
0.02894051,
0.0162320249,
0.0034361202,
0.0045477385,
0.0446990058,
-0.0674901158,
-0.0403669998,
0.0205783602,
-0.0274938885,
-0.0346976258,
0.0605798475,
-0.025802305,
0.0577950142,
0.0903011039,
-0.0128033506,
-0.0345202349,
0.0193041284,
-0.0753550157,
0.0192070715,
-0.0390583947,
0.0161462054,
-0.0249017105,
0.0174055044,
0.0101487227,
0.0910006389,
-0.0104232421,
0.0939704254,
-0.00462374,
-0.0286138598,
0.0581541471,
-0.0571389608,
-0.0708109066,
0.0079362849,
-0.0224860795,
0.0227155332,
-0.0163271651,
-0.0480915122,
0.0088591715,
0.0369211733,
-0.0710593536,
-0.0275375992,
-0.0065039149,
-0.0008507865,
-0.0310812127,
-0.0289632492,
0.0459257253,
0.0149296056,
-0.0554188602,
0.0635801256,
-0.0037354953,
0.0310881007,
0.0372053497,
-0.0178700052,
-0.0225608628,
-0.0250019729,
-0.0418056622,
-0.0515172519,
0.045995824,
0.0044573429,
-0.0159157794,
0.0054377182,
0.0063950615,
-0.014681722,
0.0613102056,
-0.0205485187,
0.0056693042,
0.0031709732,
-0.0387715586,
0.0539040603,
0.0510604195,
0.0299837086,
0.0504745692,
0.0742770359,
0.0273327436,
-0.003283574,
0.0101710781,
-0.0518326536,
0.0392953902,
-0.0214478616,
0.0295357127,
-0.0343732163,
0.0547817089,
0.0062375381,
-0.0157385431,
-0.0469064489,
-0.0112872785,
-0.0154615054,
-0.0191787723,
-0.0839625746,
0.0026860395,
-0.0261913035,
0.0140576819,
-0.0141012259,
-0.0166052058,
0.0818436071,
0.0062524485,
0.025472356,
-0.0060588294,
-0.031762436,
-0.0228725281,
-0.0032949718,
0.0262421481,
0.0375683568,
0.0002898183,
0.0087627657,
-0.0355100296,
0.017010875,
-0.0087679354,
-0.0301012639,
0.0164244566,
-0.0013892673,
0.0098623391,
-0.0012373772,
-0.0110830888,
-0.037421111,
-0.0328356549,
-0.0147028826,
0.037098702,
0.0273031313,
0.0134416074,
-0.04330533,
0.0333199687,
-0.0076706465,
-0.0091861058,
0.0044617634,
-0.0417300425,
-0.0219504554,
0.0674163252,
0.054256551,
0.0418228544,
0.0052932235,
0.0129634356,
-0.0168617181,
0.0211206824,
0.0142388279,
-0.0109806694,
-0.0238664914,
0.0485387705,
0.0180470198,
-0.0109880455,
-0.0322503895,
0.0123202289,
0.0050623151,
0.0178363118,
-0.0163526293,
0.0804832056,
0.0532201268,
-0.0146473106,
0.0341790505,
-0.0162201878,
-0.0240170509,
0.0593633913,
0.0103976857,
-0.0952215269,
0.012626688,
-0.0358238444,
-0.0036158394,
-0.0123300795,
-0.0513457842,
0.0096397018,
-0.0561750419,
0.0044760122,
-0.0003210075,
0.0454980657,
-0.0192465056,
-0.0771135762,
-0.0007241827,
-0.0280950665,
-0.0435437188,
-0.0328871459,
-0.0009423427,
-0.0194213744,
0.0078425007,
0.0113371424,
-0.02410689,
0.0371270962,
-0.0165048223,
0.0511936508,
-0.0094671752,
0.0828478411,
-0.0168468915,
-0.0621404536,
-0.0791892037,
-0.0572364293,
0.0147096897,
-0.0197430793,
0.0446326435,
-0.0126167564,
-0.0078555485,
-0.0197241623,
0.0064921188,
-0.0009243409,
-0.0189604983,
-0.0420642421,
0.1125223115,
-0.0288001113,
-0.0191852041,
-0.0360230878,
-0.0208761562,
0.0089035751,
0.0523454733,
0.0108706262,
-0.0162504688,
-0.0451150499,
0.0019382364,
0.0075076306,
0.0272040591,
-0.0253363252,
-0.0191699117,
0.0290819667,
-0.031029718,
-0.0577231273,
0.015468481,
0.0355868526,
0.0709929764,
-0.0052155466,
0.0564116612,
0.0240295585,
-0.0386832654,
-0.0635707155,
0.0015088385,
-0.0014519426,
0.0509984866,
0.0135239884,
-0.0262119025,
0.0387703553,
0.0024339596,
-0.0275041573,
-0.0062786867,
-0.016204983,
-0.0721387193,
-0.0434843004,
0.0335443094,
0.0133605516,
-0.0018200978,
0.0032567203,
-0.0207584687,
0.0494086891,
0.0235440265,
-0.0446709618,
0.0200575534,
-0.0074500474,
-0.0005177569,
0.0051311962,
0.0370926298,
0.0207944959,
0.0405679084,
0.0066312961,
0.0444232449,
-0.0348766558,
0.0433939174,
0.047369577,
0.0220479108,
0.0529430956,
0.038057901,
0.0129832309,
-0.0371623822,
-0.0087900907,
-0.0173622295,
0.0117929028,
-0.0267148819,
0.0063415235,
0.002285684,
0.017845884,
-0.0268620718,
-0.0334545299,
0.0063379514,
0.0363128372,
-0.0245722644,
0.0138630373,
0.0324076489,
-0.0010830127,
0.0041202307,
0.0260020401,
-0.0018004014,
-0.033922188,
-0.0170223881,
0.0193952806,
-0.0158064999,
0.0356181599,
0.0110223899,
0.0186019447,
-0.0463852435,
-0.0081268288,
-0.0361381695,
-0.0360203236,
0.0096787401,
-0.0165184271,
0.0403287411,
-0.0324422605,
-0.0134988027,
-0.0598816313,
-0.0043415185,
-0.005381729,
0.0152142355,
-0.0278491601,
-0.040219754,
0.0939391553,
0.0555837788,
-0.0181035828,
-0.0072351065,
0.0612038299,
0.0265806671,
0.0380103104,
-0.0116663743,
0.0016592862,
-0.0717437938,
0.0384930633,
0.0757362619,
0.1079308763,
-0.0027269525,
0.0661140159,
-0.069229655,
-0.0409975946,
0.070931688,
-0.0408610329,
0.0426676683,
-0.0238583516,
0.0439953282,
0.0199668203,
0.0376077369,
-0.0047246576,
-0.0214746483,
0.0113580385,
0.0039693187,
-0.015193441,
-0.0718665197,
-6.149015725e-33,
0.0062992931,
-0.0215897318,
0.0103168739,
0.0105959307,
-0.0024056481,
0.015194973,
-0.0151622156,
0.0310792811,
-0.0423880182,
-0.0099615911,
0.0001749442,
-0.0184027031,
-0.0128598521,
0.0093443599,
0.0036261582,
0.0313954353,
0.0330866389,
-0.0204271246,
0.0129346801,
-0.0098761562,
0.0549876317,
0.0109031638,
0.0184109211,
-0.0994180888,
-0.0193487313,
0.0161924865,
0.0279439557,
0.0097560659,
0.0246062856,
0.0211497899,
-0.052673921,
0.0559895337,
0.0493825264,
0.0161531679,
0.024121413,
0.0430123359,
-0.0710743964,
-0.0328826644,
0.0248413291,
-0.0089169862,
-0.0124090752,
-0.0093472032,
0.0087205246,
-0.0081858095,
-0.0202741902,
0.0066669844,
0.0367278568,
-0.0363579951,
-0.0557858795,
-0.0794012174,
-0.1210361794,
-0.0081415512,
-0.0184826907,
0.0355088972,
0.0629771948,
0.0114350822,
-0.009709755,
-0.0200356562,
-0.0741828457,
0.0394092835,
-0.0124968728,
0.0014194364,
0.0143780839,
-0.0178346671,
0.0049961302,
0.0430297218,
-0.0039379597,
-0.0524702966,
-0.0495679826,
0.0846374929,
0.0330906808,
0.0175401252,
0.0097367214,
0.0007257818,
0.070033595,
-0.0559518076,
-0.0608669966,
-0.0058654011,
0.0193394776,
0.0379355438,
0.083351627,
0.0338422358,
-0.0450965501,
-0.0249287561,
-0.0172690842,
-0.012297282,
-0.051987078,
-0.0467508137,
0.0003131678,
0.020680232,
-0.0149328448,
0.0078096595,
-0.005687098,
-0.0722007975,
-0.034792956,
0.0293647312,
0.0263526011,
0.0300676655,
0.0119948871,
0.004180057,
-0.0759080499,
-0.077117011,
0.0118515017,
0.0070794737,
0.008029772,
-0.0027169487,
0.0408633724,
0.0258811619,
-0.0408078656,
-0.0280972756,
0.0006697807,
-0.0270747859,
0.0258394815,
0.0485550761,
0.0213150289,
-0.0099792518,
-0.0110310186,
0.004255312,
-0.0353202149,
-0.0367016383,
0.0047835712,
-0.0078236656,
-0.0056802435,
0.0378775001,
-0.0191398561,
-0.0162745621,
-0.0420918129,
-0.0245148987,
0.0341262817,
-0.0644904226,
-0.0105058784,
0.0120256897,
2.585e-7,
0.0054906919,
0.0357226692,
-0.0146290306,
-0.0374671593,
-0.0107192677,
0.0035845933,
0.0007127534,
0.0306825992,
-0.0187967755,
-0.0588594303,
-0.0194862783,
0.0440907255,
-0.0230559036,
-0.0129126515,
-0.0303118266,
0.0181345083,
0.0275462288,
-0.0289568081,
-0.0377471931,
0.0135778803,
0.1161053106,
0.1071429625,
-0.0027003216,
-0.0081600426,
-0.003274885,
0.0089365877,
0.0412232839,
0.050234478,
0.0216501374,
-0.0408704542,
0.0078036948,
0.0062288879,
-0.0053577893,
0.0250575636,
0.0208098218,
0.0417523831,
-0.012445868,
0.0230890326,
-0.0499954522,
-0.0038253232,
0.016157629,
0.0072408193,
-0.0232409351,
0.012424049,
0.0610875301,
-0.0868577436,
-0.0758933946,
-0.0234440602,
-0.0380096361,
0.0459019169,
0.0102399364,
0.0123386858,
0.010160977,
-0.0033259934,
0.00210998,
-0.0252818801,
0.039298676,
-0.07309971,
0.0492716357,
0.0542570464,
-0.0202293005,
-0.0346059948,
-0.0009527778,
0.0060898573,
0.0761847496,
-0.0109752752,
0.035405729,
2.23731725e-34,
0.0214979518,
0.0031919049,
0.0293235127,
0.0455465205,
-0.0111316219,
-0.0321520716,
-0.0239370074,
0.0123069314,
0.0283747558,
-0.072277613,
-0.0073375152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08832v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08832v2 | SLIDE: Reference-free Evaluation for Machine Translation using a Sliding Document Window | 2023-09-16T01:30:58 | 2024-04-02T09:36:24 | Vikas Raunak, Tom Kocmi, Matt Post | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Reference-based metrics that operate at the sentence-level typically
outperform quality estimation metrics, which have access only to the source and
system output. This is unsurprising, since references resolve ambiguities that
may be present in the source. In this paper, we investigate whether additional
source context can effectively substitute for a reference. We present a metric
named SLIDE (SLIding Document Evaluator), which operates on blocks of
sentences. SLIDE leverages a moving window that slides over each document in
the test set, feeding each chunk of sentences into an unmodified, off-the-shelf
quality estimation model. We find that SLIDE obtains significantly higher
pairwise system accuracy than its sentence-level baseline, in some cases even
eliminating the gap with reference-base metrics. This suggests that source
context may provide the same information as a human reference in disambiguating
source ambiguities. This finding is especially pertinent for reference-free
document-level evaluation, wherein SLIDE could provide higher-quality pairwise
system assessments while only requiring document boundary annotations. | [
0.0150521854,
0.0479766019,
0.0146544157,
0.0188716743,
-0.0264734998,
-0.000178589,
0.04727339,
0.0093453033,
-0.0613126047,
-0.0390388742,
-0.0340814181,
-0.0096438862,
0.0340758525,
-0.0129364217,
0.0375197865,
-0.0668490827,
0.0489744022,
-0.0020033461,
-0.0013119774,
0.0237177238,
-0.0000688923,
-0.0043520126,
-0.0052399985,
0.0300561432,
-0.0131872538,
-0.0342220366,
0.003527794,
0.0549527854,
0.0572198145,
0.0042557921,
-0.0184064209,
0.0263429824,
-0.0372109748,
0.0525024049,
0.00000193,
-0.0161846168,
-0.0346515551,
0.0424248278,
-0.0088059343,
0.0342819318,
0.0539829433,
-0.0413753279,
-0.0398412831,
0.0084465742,
-0.0071624727,
-0.0436673835,
0.0384182595,
-0.0141192041,
0.1083174571,
0.0692792609,
-0.0188510548,
0.0126049127,
-0.0316531435,
-0.023870727,
0.0115721412,
-0.0625770241,
-0.0359770767,
-0.0035179623,
-0.0045084646,
-0.0027682818,
0.0129747158,
0.0618314296,
0.0370488465,
-0.0488010831,
0.0123073924,
-0.0224569794,
-0.0754838884,
-0.021280881,
0.0169213004,
0.0536575317,
-0.0079250941,
-0.0082691414,
-0.0120675955,
-0.0210222211,
0.0001647239,
-0.0000740423,
-0.0025912256,
0.0181273483,
-0.0086004203,
-0.0271729771,
-0.031065274,
0.0300703831,
0.0225845277,
-0.004663724,
-0.0151381865,
0.021631103,
0.0066115241,
-0.0458790883,
0.011377681,
0.0299886186,
-0.0041605826,
0.0028365771,
0.0222487841,
-0.0334489793,
-0.0223970711,
0.0131879915,
-0.0350380391,
-0.028324537,
0.0340500697,
-0.0464090817,
-0.0017574939,
0.0199343003,
-0.0238015167,
0.0480361059,
0.0061488813,
0.0672485977,
0.0108842412,
0.0033559608,
-0.0780331269,
-0.0143902916,
-0.0066343155,
0.0503769591,
-0.0388140008,
-0.006499338,
-0.062983416,
-0.005621227,
-0.0285371188,
0.0129180448,
-0.0083083073,
0.0418721437,
0.005777475,
-0.0480161086,
-0.0358227938,
-0.0077713355,
0.0127072986,
0.0403422564,
-0.0338672325,
0.0032247158,
-0.0002483854,
-0.0597688407,
-0.0280607659,
0.0498488136,
-0.0096776029,
-0.0038537434,
-0.0080072293,
0.0681679919,
0.0124615645,
-0.0189590752,
0.0028668293,
-0.0191804375,
-0.0465361401,
-0.0497406647,
-0.0145147732,
-0.0503672771,
0.0295912214,
0.0265664104,
0.0067068832,
-0.0146936169,
-0.0058228713,
0.0069446042,
0.0062058475,
0.0370484851,
-0.0107213203,
0.000437213,
-0.0216469113,
-0.0057248715,
-0.0330010094,
0.0548240505,
0.0739991367,
0.0101401024,
0.0541448034,
0.0387310982,
-0.0094642825,
0.0411725529,
0.0219789278,
0.046305459,
-0.0024956348,
-0.0196904,
0.0157350823,
0.0109163793,
0.0306918658,
0.0817646161,
-0.0314901359,
0.0266117528,
0.0399625376,
-0.0210457295,
0.0270511042,
0.0125881918,
0.0847182423,
0.0388851762,
0.0034271169,
0.0399338417,
-0.0216268618,
0.0016414396,
0.054415945,
0.035109736,
0.0920436904,
-0.0076156934,
0.0062175863,
-0.0734552443,
-0.0127971815,
-0.0115582338,
0.0075394479,
-0.036035616,
0.0231097005,
0.0381013155,
-0.0518252738,
0.0456203856,
-0.0189415161,
-0.0679992959,
0.0118748834,
-0.0032612109,
0.003842301,
0.0683164895,
0.0632675588,
-0.0124667091,
0.0069352048,
-0.0284598228,
0.0187492147,
0.0619607493,
0.0451718532,
-0.0044160914,
0.0578840673,
-0.0353827402,
-0.0096109584,
0.0068856021,
0.0180348139,
0.0196552724,
-0.0262960922,
0.0176085848,
0.0366812423,
-0.0452882871,
-0.0607932135,
0.0167806149,
0.0354155079,
-0.0022155324,
0.0174485594,
0.0028113017,
0.0399481505,
0.0266922209,
-0.0545218438,
0.0068946397,
0.0042371475,
-0.0198854413,
0.0215537734,
0.0430358201,
-0.0439330898,
-0.0207578968,
-0.0046466091,
-0.0529181175,
-0.0251585841,
-0.0037560051,
-0.0467878841,
-0.0300208926,
-0.0320756845,
-0.057744503,
-0.023719335,
-0.034188699,
0.0361053199,
-0.0004124359,
-0.0095918439,
-0.0216310285,
0.0193238296,
0.0081710415,
0.0338675678,
0.0169619564,
-0.0095679499,
0.0650123879,
-0.0047398359,
-0.0206220895,
0.0283048246,
-0.0093319276,
0.0384582803,
0.0461359434,
0.0249805152,
-0.0527610965,
-0.0359206013,
-0.0334041268,
0.0365224145,
-0.0244814418,
0.0324223302,
0.0306120366,
0.014406248,
0.0136592174,
0.0006185675,
0.0181578584,
-0.0504858419,
-0.0005663526,
-0.0059072943,
0.0339031294,
0.0241360981,
0.0254337154,
-0.0357765891,
-0.0057332213,
0.0107852416,
0.0548718683,
0.0246903766,
-0.010248783,
-0.0731997862,
0.0557721183,
-0.0330104791,
-0.022747511,
0.0363266245,
-0.0329857543,
0.0281789284,
0.0165040251,
0.0029575778,
0.0570117645,
-0.0124066649,
-0.015049085,
0.0486017019,
-0.0045544249,
-0.0471829399,
0.0212152116,
0.0232840963,
-0.014307213,
0.012961085,
-0.0465870649,
0.0210144799,
0.0028135097,
0.0156925358,
0.0101016974,
-0.0351276435,
0.0331716239,
-0.0465158299,
-0.0356987081,
-0.0122076208,
-0.0153854396,
-0.0035542788,
0.0179004129,
-0.0235185437,
-0.0616343468,
0.0694939792,
-0.0485306606,
-0.0329961479,
-0.0547512323,
0.0382710211,
-0.0226934999,
-0.0039250203,
-0.039761126,
0.0088074617,
-0.0367719829,
-0.0088686217,
-0.0397123806,
0.0107700936,
0.0567954704,
-0.0392667539,
0.031221224,
-0.084666945,
-0.017355185,
-0.0199814569,
-0.0282581896,
-0.0214235056,
0.015536245,
0.0236922316,
-0.0035834315,
0.0156116197,
-0.0082708187,
-0.0446673669,
-0.0027486919,
0.0547100268,
0.0514042489,
-0.0125727914,
-0.015194146,
-0.0155980205,
0.0128929457,
-0.0262286495,
-0.0005977584,
0.0388354436,
-0.0344736874,
0.0312373545,
0.0187043492,
0.0275815949,
0.0315602198,
-0.0203459077,
-0.0338632427,
0.0056362171,
-0.0003752476,
-0.0548620559,
-0.0209195185,
0.0562503897,
-0.0823339075,
-0.0267764665,
0.0954031944,
0.0283085164,
-0.0276286434,
-0.0363866575,
-0.03769603,
0.0357640944,
-0.0036040484,
0.0246657338,
-0.0738230571,
-0.0147011019,
0.0067258207,
0.0689478144,
0.0273309723,
0.0233985521,
-0.0124032758,
-0.0680270121,
0.0443429537,
0.0567318797,
-0.0225269087,
-0.026749637,
-0.0398847237,
-0.0166621804,
-0.0248123556,
0.0385984741,
0.0216474477,
0.0195070449,
0.0098971184,
-0.0169424936,
-0.0167366005,
-0.0459535867,
-0.0264228713,
-0.056550812,
0.0306724757,
0.0583958402,
0.0419599116,
0.0193141326,
-0.0495315753,
0.026032282,
-0.1199908406,
-0.0092983507,
-0.0151499836,
0.0616962537,
-0.0248229094,
0.0052201771,
0.0082935533,
-0.0363893174,
0.0348707438,
0.0090054404,
-0.0173479393,
0.01809985,
0.0056278566,
-0.0001674141,
-0.012808295,
0.0017150061,
-0.0030992639,
0.060567636,
0.0265028421,
-0.0529373847,
-0.0254509058,
-0.0398769714,
-0.000731345,
-0.0606179498,
0.0114470851,
0.0129941367,
-0.0582121164,
-0.0334427841,
-0.0948247313,
-0.051499825,
-0.024455443,
0.0163521525,
-0.0240543131,
0.0052302717,
-0.018179873,
0.0028737241,
0.0159398261,
0.0010962853,
0.0040397933,
0.0164376106,
-0.0181741174,
0.0138446577,
0.0067829825,
0.0198843721,
-0.017430421,
0.0790363103,
-0.0063893879,
-0.0421012267,
-0.0168358926,
0.0177880656,
0.0207577776,
0.0434148349,
-0.0484137237,
0.0005718824,
-0.0000718847,
0.0108948313,
-0.0404646024,
0.0345906951,
0.0829456002,
0.0052432511,
-0.0159988515,
0.0390930958,
-0.0729376674,
-0.0128191225,
-0.0393894576,
0.0202631634,
-0.0044855257,
-0.013779684,
-0.0107774073,
0.0108436067,
0.0189992115,
-0.0168111529,
-0.0183613095,
0.0048319553,
0.0197590925,
-0.0010473226,
-0.0386123508,
-0.0442528427,
0.0148576805,
0.0114798006,
-0.0411021002,
-0.02602203,
0.0542454235,
-0.0449277572,
-0.0034567064,
0.0258355495,
0.0076698582,
0.0040053884,
0.0323132277,
-0.0431972072,
-0.0000430881,
-0.0159303974,
-0.0146506112,
-0.0021251356,
0.0160830263,
-0.0199305117,
0.0092305876,
0.0350267477,
0.0045074453,
0.0509244204,
0.0515967347,
-0.0421462767,
0.0315014347,
-0.043952316,
0.007264317,
0.0540347993,
0.0215937868,
0.145718202,
0.0106064696,
0.0043406067,
-0.0342871994,
0.0444390923,
0.0406837761,
-0.0331153236,
-0.0438639075,
0.0186150763,
-0.0034766151,
0.0402733125,
0.0341487266,
-0.0133708641,
-0.0137387598,
-0.0443169363,
-0.0144800525,
-0.0490463302,
-0.0113730971,
-0.071800895,
-0.0298727509,
0.0024992044,
-0.0209231135,
-0.0591025986,
-0.0586329661,
0.0336933732,
0.0513570309,
0.0381454006,
-0.0179942492,
-0.0025187933,
0.0658109561,
-0.0156675261,
-0.0111875786,
-0.0374468677,
-0.0410096496,
0.0129104555,
-0.0219445322,
-0.0485180467,
-5.732323548e-33,
-0.0557230748,
-0.0172109641,
-0.0461812057,
-0.0264536142,
-0.0254739337,
-0.0033434103,
-0.046083726,
-0.0191460028,
0.0040411493,
0.0358286537,
0.0187680591,
0.011462478,
0.0325560533,
-0.0497287922,
-0.0173970647,
-0.0149634788,
0.0740367845,
0.0141071007,
-0.0774238184,
0.013394298,
0.0369102545,
-0.0197153632,
0.0541921183,
-0.0869153589,
0.0637958199,
-0.0221466217,
-0.058661554,
-0.0213125851,
0.0374464579,
0.0390684828,
0.0497662462,
0.0364913493,
0.0061951294,
-0.0328489132,
-0.036885649,
-0.0248565376,
-0.0915030167,
0.000847046,
0.0198381748,
0.0200697146,
-0.0394966528,
-0.0404289961,
0.070403479,
-0.0264116377,
-0.0256966744,
-0.0100378711,
0.0331373811,
-0.0658250451,
-0.0296176784,
-0.0450019799,
-0.0162856337,
0.0260967426,
-0.0245807972,
-0.0000675489,
0.0146889314,
0.0717247054,
-0.0103150839,
-0.0286600478,
-0.063133575,
0.0152730504,
-0.0166490898,
0.0478482656,
0.0430499129,
-0.0524164811,
-0.0141657591,
0.0100131426,
0.0167135876,
-0.0460692607,
0.054922238,
-0.0735778585,
0.0357467197,
-0.0129474681,
0.0971433371,
0.060989026,
0.0430882685,
-0.0017478281,
-0.051415123,
0.0629720762,
-0.0409947298,
0.0612755641,
-0.0138771012,
0.0050037196,
-0.0236887839,
0.0066791992,
-0.0706470385,
-0.0552622601,
-0.0370099172,
-0.031458728,
0.0315746665,
0.0140121374,
-0.0319237709,
-0.0257096346,
0.0648828521,
0.0064713038,
0.0277357325,
0.0382427312,
-0.0461023673,
0.0457417704,
-0.0016485222,
-0.0044897879,
-0.0091702491,
0.0119819483,
0.0409896895,
0.0609016456,
0.0300267749,
-0.0295057222,
0.0603166819,
0.0287437886,
-0.0491298288,
0.0346949995,
-0.013361006,
0.0211042874,
-0.0331159644,
-0.0464482903,
0.0105037335,
-0.0279794335,
-0.0205550399,
0.0410682075,
-0.0103590777,
0.0383863933,
-0.0158710908,
0.0089539913,
0.0002923995,
0.0328182131,
-0.0836566985,
0.0052736052,
0.0290210284,
0.0139825968,
0.0439798199,
-0.0429252908,
-0.0157402251,
0.0029651632,
2.589e-7,
0.046771314,
0.0529612117,
0.0332171544,
0.0456294753,
0.0011123266,
-0.0080103707,
-0.0285575874,
0.0093800165,
-0.0084724138,
0.0071252566,
0.0087843407,
-0.0115059884,
0.0912231803,
0.0375802703,
-0.0864561573,
-0.0208726432,
-0.051280871,
0.0205779653,
-0.0299924314,
0.0017464836,
0.033536192,
0.082878612,
-0.0126663325,
0.0276110321,
-0.016658904,
-0.0641532168,
0.0551217236,
-0.0004820547,
-0.0071238233,
0.005253748,
0.0868306383,
-0.015011278,
-0.0289060585,
0.0013696643,
-0.0338511132,
0.0129950829,
0.0557323545,
0.0734463334,
0.0443211831,
-0.0116538601,
0.0077478224,
-0.0269278232,
0.0197937321,
-0.0097613949,
0.048795335,
0.0140651558,
0.014859207,
0.0050910637,
-0.0578303225,
0.0079841288,
0.0563656576,
-0.0046851491,
-0.0502330586,
0.0246132277,
0.0142670097,
0.0005208493,
-0.0101204244,
-0.0176964439,
-0.0573107637,
-0.0385789387,
0.0254350584,
-0.058335647,
0.0202590711,
-0.0191286746,
0.0038302457,
-0.0757825971,
0.0255790167,
2.28924609e-34,
0.102707468,
-0.0520552658,
0.0306409691,
-0.0206032917,
0.0477956198,
-0.0115542393,
-0.0402906761,
-0.022335371,
0.000021109,
-0.0341970213,
0.0103258016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08827v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08827v1 | S3-DST: Structured Open-Domain Dialogue Segmentation and State Tracking in the Era of LLMs | 2023-09-16T00:59:23 | 2023-09-16T00:59:23 | Sarkar Snigdha Sarathi Das, Chirag Shah, Mengting Wan, Jennifer Neville, Longqi Yang, Reid Andersen, Georg Buscher, Tara Safavi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The traditional Dialogue State Tracking (DST) problem aims to track user
preferences and intents in user-agent conversations. While sufficient for
task-oriented dialogue systems supporting narrow domain applications, the
advent of Large Language Model (LLM)-based chat systems has introduced many
real-world intricacies in open-domain dialogues. These intricacies manifest in
the form of increased complexity in contextual interactions, extended dialogue
sessions encompassing a diverse array of topics, and more frequent contextual
shifts. To handle these intricacies arising from evolving LLM-based chat
systems, we propose joint dialogue segmentation and state tracking per segment
in open-domain dialogue systems. Assuming a zero-shot setting appropriate to a
true open-domain dialogue system, we propose S3-DST, a structured prompting
technique that harnesses Pre-Analytical Recollection, a novel grounding
mechanism we designed for improving long context tracking. To demonstrate the
efficacy of our proposed approach in joint segmentation and state tracking, we
evaluate S3-DST on a proprietary anonymized open-domain dialogue dataset, as
well as publicly available DST and segmentation datasets. Across all datasets
and settings, S3-DST consistently outperforms the state-of-the-art,
demonstrating its potency and robustness the next generation of LLM-based chat
systems. | [
0.0275056437,
0.0140038654,
-0.0041245744,
0.0502982922,
-0.0340322889,
-0.0061522895,
0.0046356814,
0.0047884244,
0.0288712457,
-0.0532082804,
-0.0254336465,
-0.0720344409,
-0.012937827,
0.0761409253,
-0.0434178226,
-0.0582967512,
0.0371705033,
-0.029278269,
0.004653228,
0.0302168727,
0.0406647921,
0.0047794604,
-0.0422442965,
0.0401621126,
-0.0048278132,
-0.0126889739,
-0.0437170751,
-0.0017633371,
-0.0108666029,
-0.0235030651,
0.0035798021,
0.0295140278,
0.0358424261,
0.0163541548,
0.0000018862,
-0.0611668862,
-0.0404175781,
-0.0470740758,
-0.0583857186,
-0.0304626729,
0.0009427912,
0.0123770833,
-0.0203613844,
0.0275781099,
-0.0400770977,
0.026798673,
0.0189518128,
0.0519159362,
0.0732866004,
0.0627563372,
-0.0273187421,
-0.0090136472,
-0.0015573954,
0.0041279187,
0.0102919564,
-0.0634073466,
0.0159721859,
-0.0177917555,
-0.0174236577,
0.0136526302,
0.0204147696,
-0.0029847308,
0.0026447382,
-0.0383915156,
-0.016761234,
-0.0000926514,
-0.0319585651,
-0.0093266293,
-0.0360611193,
0.0998482853,
0.0653948411,
0.0414180197,
0.0232125632,
0.0088729719,
-0.0091986498,
-0.0589954779,
-0.0697427019,
-0.016024081,
-0.0253106803,
-0.0138493618,
-0.011309227,
0.0373308584,
-0.0323438905,
0.0160586797,
-0.0338404737,
0.0437872708,
-0.0018247509,
-0.0273850001,
-0.0367796049,
-0.0060713058,
0.0314286873,
-0.0790550485,
0.0512343347,
0.0188661963,
-0.0557570495,
0.0467391796,
-0.0526827462,
0.0158754196,
-0.0083251446,
-0.0130513487,
-0.0160452519,
0.0362797119,
-0.0297772978,
0.0711093545,
0.0302253012,
0.0401700176,
0.0003801111,
-0.0207391009,
-0.0131113622,
-0.0025090938,
-0.0354904719,
0.0074094562,
-0.045194082,
-0.0003497186,
-0.0450357236,
-0.0261390153,
-0.0293568205,
0.0551152602,
0.0026603744,
0.014597063,
-0.0051584127,
-0.0039050947,
-0.0147648863,
0.0070313681,
-0.0156823508,
0.0365009904,
-0.0324654281,
-0.0156076364,
0.0450432114,
-0.0477520525,
-0.0094923526,
0.0367966108,
0.0077592521,
0.0083192121,
-0.0632925555,
0.0268591009,
-0.0015324231,
-0.0447091274,
-0.0160197318,
-0.0561315194,
-0.0390860103,
-0.0451184921,
0.0008819123,
-0.0267420243,
0.0316635296,
-0.00499351,
-0.0129757719,
-0.0053124465,
-0.0062405537,
0.0195975713,
0.0054257563,
0.0290332325,
-0.0119863022,
0.001765106,
-4.73e-8,
0.0320712104,
0.0341595523,
0.0649272501,
0.0201733522,
0.0118689304,
0.0759462714,
0.0264182854,
0.0189916063,
0.0369265229,
-0.0026822989,
0.0201811306,
-0.0242147092,
0.0436128452,
-0.0091860285,
-0.0088520506,
-0.0052867983,
0.0294216219,
-0.0304441378,
-0.0495601259,
0.0414141342,
0.0884149298,
-0.0064659878,
-0.0092511931,
0.0098549435,
0.0439648889,
0.0064278352,
0.0277264342,
-0.0175097324,
0.006687067,
-0.0099543072,
-0.016189035,
0.0380835645,
0.01094638,
-0.0401332937,
-0.0260305367,
0.0224672351,
-0.0164428633,
0.0214823205,
0.0037971074,
0.0408076867,
0.0028543728,
-0.057222005,
0.0519150719,
-0.0107850907,
-0.0445764512,
-0.0394796357,
-0.0414681286,
0.0340055823,
0.0909369141,
0.0465117432,
-0.0395992436,
-0.0551986247,
-0.0466192663,
0.0482093766,
0.033298105,
0.0134551842,
-0.0215261225,
0.0347029492,
-0.0493994653,
-0.0230794493,
0.0279984381,
-0.01062983,
0.0155613692,
0.0268328972,
-0.0115463659,
0.0263550635,
0.0281718504,
0.084544681,
-0.0121926479,
-0.0040659471,
0.0171551611,
-0.019668309,
-0.0135955848,
0.0489287898,
0.0456362441,
0.015742911,
-0.0355180465,
0.021482097,
0.0216644071,
0.0193774253,
0.0270095728,
-0.0854797885,
-0.0489292406,
0.0222643018,
0.0575029477,
-0.0318299867,
-0.0169559941,
-0.0260399729,
-0.0645736232,
0.0028408244,
-0.00917562,
0.0429750606,
-0.0436550826,
0.0149253784,
0.0407616124,
0.0038425217,
-0.0111676594,
0.0149400746,
-0.0139624476,
-0.0284906961,
0.0331714526,
0.0082936008,
0.0088119805,
-0.0553376675,
0.0226952713,
0.0265365541,
-0.0327722281,
-0.0137583921,
0.0094641047,
0.0004107412,
-0.0816306174,
0.0112536736,
-0.1051252633,
0.0171859488,
-0.0434458889,
0.0040768348,
-0.0033764821,
0.0464958698,
-0.0386231765,
-0.0222587157,
-0.0493265353,
0.005568671,
0.0583919249,
0.008314386,
-0.0007961275,
0.007300084,
-0.0389804728,
-0.0333970785,
0.0299149919,
-0.0048460849,
0.0057942434,
-0.0198153351,
-0.0378540456,
-0.0816014335,
0.0442950204,
-0.04657555,
0.0459107757,
-0.0444060341,
-0.0196370035,
0.0105267055,
-0.0050318907,
0.0409063175,
0.0445947088,
0.0252887644,
0.0354061425,
-0.0300486758,
-0.0517394841,
-0.0345900916,
0.0127421562,
-0.0180168822,
0.0137725817,
-0.0325368755,
0.0266142152,
0.0317872465,
0.0376362577,
0.0142837195,
0.0424509458,
-0.0278796367,
-0.0342807211,
-0.0016358331,
-0.0097805271,
-0.0151870595,
-0.0019198362,
-0.0514023751,
0.0505972728,
-0.0040678577,
-0.0543131121,
0.0633194596,
-0.0361719504,
-0.0326722749,
-0.0339215584,
-0.0244631879,
-0.0481314659,
0.0514313318,
-0.0232490413,
-0.0044975867,
0.0536932796,
-0.043994762,
-0.0173359718,
-0.0169229843,
-0.0102032823,
-0.0494450554,
0.0639540628,
-0.0351478942,
0.0272358153,
0.006505949,
-0.0246557947,
-0.056794893,
-0.0219715312,
-0.0357560106,
-0.0084436992,
0.0075289747,
-0.0283946656,
0.01254215,
0.0624397546,
0.0086157694,
0.0597209744,
-0.0057752603,
0.0121164313,
-0.0136096179,
0.0422752425,
0.0352221057,
-0.0139218019,
-0.0363159329,
-0.0325686559,
0.0589532331,
0.0691243634,
0.0727592632,
-0.0236459672,
0.0093328012,
-0.0032246327,
0.0270438902,
-0.018311115,
-0.0217636339,
0.0090240072,
0.0649567544,
-0.0463501625,
-0.0169893876,
0.1346951425,
0.0411988646,
-0.0586173423,
-0.0446469672,
-0.0199531484,
0.0222515669,
0.014394464,
0.0014396032,
-0.0931233391,
-0.0534759127,
-0.0001264367,
0.011411964,
-0.0062525137,
-0.0492998958,
-0.0139320884,
-0.0747190043,
0.0170377828,
-0.0052186069,
-0.0522784553,
0.0075548165,
-0.0085003274,
0.0277461763,
0.0223954841,
0.014715109,
-0.0068357391,
0.0095660146,
-0.043392539,
0.0060023032,
-0.0353180356,
-0.000491894,
0.0323904268,
-0.0158284232,
0.0534437224,
0.0732404068,
0.0397723913,
0.0620666891,
-0.0127808079,
0.0391725264,
-0.0106016193,
-0.0070575522,
0.0086293202,
0.023987297,
-0.0346706808,
0.017392613,
-0.025567716,
0.0264906213,
-0.0212688614,
-0.0045577441,
0.0240488146,
0.0250131972,
-0.0588299781,
0.0616653748,
-0.0020548925,
0.0469854362,
0.0354872905,
0.0610359423,
0.0093699619,
-0.0356116928,
-0.0126671707,
-0.0238186792,
0.0069914977,
-0.0016077243,
0.0120737348,
-0.0239569861,
-0.0262213461,
0.0179693159,
-0.0791968033,
-0.035325706,
0.0564591549,
0.0207666364,
-0.0375592671,
-0.00136594,
0.0007315348,
0.0083009377,
0.0122884633,
0.0084348014,
-0.0577596091,
0.0220203027,
-0.0658491254,
-0.0097545469,
0.0565826446,
-0.001333521,
0.0039498331,
0.0374748819,
-0.0801508576,
-0.0392340086,
-0.0036592041,
0.0348801874,
0.0236164667,
0.0465672985,
-0.0127572687,
0.0156511851,
-0.0208678637,
-0.0203329585,
0.0038086667,
-0.0235237051,
0.0407472923,
0.098621808,
-0.0259337891,
0.0288063549,
-0.0267904643,
0.0111727677,
-0.0409052931,
0.0153657263,
-0.0736198202,
-0.1072984263,
-0.0343473516,
-0.0242272355,
0.0656435862,
0.0377677344,
-0.0111823771,
-0.0035371615,
0.0461857021,
-0.0353140756,
-0.0196651425,
-0.0573656112,
0.0018735928,
-0.0239463449,
-0.0615226068,
0.0181940924,
0.0440404639,
-0.0643798113,
0.0253379624,
-0.0474591963,
-0.004602781,
0.0088159842,
-0.0209480003,
-0.0039471257,
-0.0001366657,
-0.0006676113,
0.0285332631,
0.0327497981,
0.0272399019,
0.0028444573,
0.1435898542,
-0.0098382272,
-0.0404957756,
0.0221654624,
0.0534147136,
-0.0712320805,
-0.0059259087,
0.0046600811,
0.0563195497,
0.01965487,
-0.0088900356,
0.0496788844,
0.0080665322,
0.0276585631,
-0.0265018288,
0.0827414468,
0.0105360243,
-0.0467672646,
-0.0002177007,
0.0316721983,
-0.0300733093,
0.0546948649,
0.0504942872,
0.0009459195,
0.0041323113,
0.0359815024,
-0.0245984122,
-0.0371972322,
-0.0054051657,
0.0202461984,
0.0438529141,
0.0005769773,
-0.0158296674,
-0.0595455468,
-0.0112663694,
0.0188989453,
-0.0408060625,
0.010287229,
-0.0048269993,
0.0668934807,
0.0429406352,
-0.0298495293,
-0.0231712162,
-0.0275790617,
-0.045278769,
-0.034615837,
-0.0367677398,
-0.004316105,
-5.82497087e-33,
-0.011567981,
-0.0397455469,
0.0282021407,
-0.0125560053,
-0.0610827543,
-0.0101575013,
-0.0424450114,
-0.0051661683,
0.0167070385,
-0.0366806909,
-0.0280582514,
0.0463856608,
0.0282588415,
0.0478712246,
-0.0559501834,
-0.0618498549,
0.0604653098,
-0.0133606456,
-0.015295337,
0.0575152189,
0.0670167431,
0.0231096465,
0.0189798921,
-0.0661967397,
0.029103959,
-0.0062181675,
0.0208979677,
0.04720762,
0.0450027436,
0.0430414006,
-0.0167423896,
0.0092453612,
0.0136128357,
-0.0511624515,
-0.0194972251,
0.0348298885,
-0.0138928154,
0.0042003524,
0.0034019768,
0.0114482176,
-0.0076361964,
0.0463926606,
-0.0134986192,
0.0048155757,
0.0417976044,
0.0221983008,
0.0081689209,
-0.0157023538,
-0.0274728891,
-0.0072476584,
-0.0306947306,
0.0304278247,
-0.0163719859,
-0.0929119363,
0.0041691312,
0.0627162233,
0.0539367236,
-0.0294971708,
-0.027430987,
0.0269622281,
-0.0197078418,
-0.021759158,
0.0323880725,
0.0497023128,
0.0153829064,
0.0607188083,
0.0247100443,
0.0317860842,
-0.0322112255,
-0.0379993059,
-0.0353930332,
0.0418002717,
0.0039433017,
-0.0060200254,
-0.0327371433,
0.0135913696,
-0.0341190509,
0.0147147877,
0.0373059325,
0.0025909822,
0.0031184612,
0.0446912162,
-0.048983898,
-0.0117443521,
0.0211240444,
0.0085170111,
0.005078,
-0.0145597318,
0.0236718077,
0.0263539068,
-0.0263163634,
-0.0354336537,
0.0776682124,
-0.0119503913,
0.0153973205,
0.0191427711,
-0.0216661096,
0.0223793313,
-0.0285922401,
0.0054358807,
-0.0444095619,
-0.0086330306,
0.0408908501,
-0.0086340364,
0.0008360785,
0.0014748193,
-0.0131309628,
-0.0249246098,
-0.0409213938,
0.0064807348,
-0.0244307667,
0.055575449,
-0.054921601,
0.0667124987,
0.0406991504,
0.0055896421,
-0.0222920496,
0.1402762383,
0.0149773955,
-0.0224410407,
-0.0266992059,
-0.0542264655,
-0.0192372557,
0.0009387903,
-0.032987643,
-0.005725971,
0.0011607606,
-0.0062898044,
0.0283122398,
-0.044767525,
0.0076107774,
-0.0188472494,
2.608e-7,
-0.0414736271,
0.029901024,
0.0618024394,
0.0039868811,
0.015005568,
0.0651370212,
0.0101890583,
0.0217380226,
0.021351045,
-0.0532383434,
0.0087332735,
0.0265797302,
0.070191972,
0.0211098548,
-0.1113499552,
-0.0364680551,
-0.0250190105,
-0.0385788009,
-0.0507462136,
0.0092827277,
0.0435737632,
0.0560180768,
0.0370060578,
0.0245155618,
0.0050792811,
-0.0314267762,
0.0202025101,
-0.0305264443,
-0.0258015841,
-0.0010693285,
0.0318745226,
0.0178768821,
-0.0256257653,
-0.0112333847,
-0.0005654214,
0.0128170382,
0.0049788766,
0.0795011744,
0.0278321803,
-0.052179873,
-0.0331283361,
0.0163807757,
-0.006870151,
0.0027310955,
0.0420985222,
-0.0180548392,
0.0031787346,
-0.0173767507,
0.0316944122,
-0.032301221,
-0.0077630356,
0.0170219969,
-0.0318408497,
0.0404701047,
-0.0087537142,
-0.001337492,
-0.0036836243,
-0.0986894369,
0.0014710056,
-0.0381394066,
-0.0412325822,
-0.0436635613,
-0.0145413196,
-0.0072881491,
-0.0105270986,
-0.0239457246,
-0.0039856946,
2.554913324e-34,
0.0325689167,
-0.0012731802,
-0.0133172134,
0.0619516149,
0.0405983701,
-0.0050777616,
0.0057947771,
0.0077472688,
0.0458932929,
-0.0538776442,
-0.0044339364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.10687v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.10687v3 | EchoPrompt: Instructing the Model to Rephrase Queries for Improved In-context Learning | 2023-09-16T00:55:08 | 2024-02-20T20:07:16 | Rajasekhar Reddy Mekala, Yasaman Razeghi, Sameer Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models are achieving impressive performance on various tasks by
aggressively adopting inference-time prompting techniques, such as zero-shot
and few-shot prompting. In this work, we introduce EchoPrompt, a simple yet
effective approach that prompts the model to rephrase its queries before
answering them. EchoPrompt is adapted for both zero-shot and few-shot
in-context learning with standard and chain-of-thought prompting. Experimental
results show that EchoPrompt yields substantial improvements across all these
settings for four families of causal language models. These improvements are
observed across various numerical reasoning (e.g. GSM8K, SVAMP), reading
comprehension (e.g. DROP), and logical reasoning (e.g. Coin Flipping) tasks. On
average, EchoPrompt improves the Zero-shot-CoT performance of code-davinci-002
by 5% in numerical tasks and 13% in reading comprehension tasks. We investigate
the factors contributing to EchoPrompt's effectiveness through ablation
studies, which reveal that both the original query and the model-generated
rephrased version are instrumental in its performance gains. Our empirical
results indicate that EchoPrompt is an effective technique that enhances
in-context learning performance. We recommend incorporating EchoPrompt into
various baseline prompting strategies to achieve performance boosts. | [
-0.0094530815,
0.0429460593,
-0.0257564578,
0.024323985,
-0.07474076,
0.0324224383,
0.0304014236,
-0.0078335535,
-0.0232602339,
-0.0324855708,
-0.0007125915,
-0.0302675273,
-0.017494997,
0.0186393615,
0.0335894898,
-0.0208310429,
0.0779092014,
-0.0644830093,
0.0065356139,
-0.013292022,
-0.033375714,
-0.0178605523,
-0.0459027328,
0.0241634622,
0.0313416384,
-0.0356438607,
-0.0325967371,
0.0315680392,
-0.0155772101,
-0.0505998433,
-0.020286113,
0.069229573,
0.0052706799,
0.0522205308,
0.0000022673,
-0.047648605,
0.0034119245,
-0.0032866178,
-0.0596476458,
0.0176475104,
0.0250504036,
0.0015085856,
0.0203281995,
0.0428239517,
-0.0413749963,
0.007795501,
0.0366549864,
-0.0079250652,
0.0018750854,
0.0722734705,
-0.0054909163,
-0.0229503363,
0.0121459598,
-0.021027118,
0.0626877397,
-0.0244148187,
0.0001061017,
-0.0231411699,
0.0216340907,
0.0226533823,
-0.046470575,
0.053580489,
0.0730502754,
0.0143755823,
0.0089228675,
0.0418068469,
-0.0190605298,
-0.0343743339,
-0.006082051,
0.0491388477,
0.0327813365,
-0.049941346,
-0.0120304059,
-0.0060307113,
0.004413676,
-0.003265691,
-0.0602924265,
-0.0081144255,
0.0137289725,
0.0088313725,
0.0178396236,
0.0109668253,
0.0443023853,
-0.0012420665,
-0.033201348,
0.0397777334,
0.0128902486,
-0.0384305939,
-0.0132128866,
0.0107980175,
-0.0114183649,
-0.0556752346,
-0.0342277624,
0.0332434401,
-0.0521719716,
0.0387861133,
-0.02880897,
-0.0297953878,
0.0051191724,
-0.0006572636,
0.0431796461,
0.1030886173,
-0.0242348034,
0.0338856019,
-0.0451286659,
0.0422296301,
0.0164521672,
0.0532803908,
-0.0252832435,
0.0287199412,
-0.052460853,
-0.0296175424,
-0.0397304036,
0.0060590231,
-0.0335869789,
-0.0317482874,
-0.0411414057,
0.0407074802,
0.0330188088,
0.0040064217,
-0.0176521745,
-0.0197237823,
-0.0348739065,
0.0027458465,
-0.0276210569,
0.0268464684,
-0.04117864,
0.0175883267,
0.0284043271,
-0.0623766221,
-0.04052018,
-0.0211461503,
-0.0098207761,
-0.0398412719,
0.0035419359,
0.0569716841,
-0.0289052464,
-0.0619794987,
-0.0210110974,
-0.0130718658,
0.0054599731,
-0.0537662506,
0.021996459,
-0.0596441627,
0.0067796735,
0.0220279619,
-0.0161359478,
0.01333299,
-0.0022645372,
0.0279987883,
-0.0127546256,
0.0897805467,
-0.0038820992,
-0.0039011554,
-0.0080410996,
0.0219250638,
-0.0095259426,
0.1077741086,
0.0161773302,
-0.0025867831,
0.0042122849,
0.0011635928,
-0.0092117209,
0.006396289,
0.0730271116,
0.0089475466,
-0.0630776361,
0.0087860255,
0.0174978673,
0.0166181289,
0.0134887015,
0.0168053731,
-0.0449760519,
0.0026960815,
0.0610786527,
0.0352211781,
0.0144699868,
-0.0260671917,
0.042882286,
-0.0259683598,
-0.0115348501,
0.027173996,
-0.0884132609,
0.0350616463,
-0.0313678943,
0.0381322652,
0.0120402677,
-0.0261886623,
-0.0249823444,
-0.0712418035,
-0.0022802763,
0.025293123,
0.0242914055,
0.0859839842,
0.0537498444,
0.0415268876,
-0.0491157547,
-0.0202327631,
0.0307837501,
-0.032111764,
-0.0208431296,
-0.0919370204,
0.0509705469,
0.0622460879,
0.05284575,
-0.0130115645,
-0.0308737215,
0.0043681874,
0.0154613266,
0.0274820495,
0.0188197475,
0.0012995494,
0.0217412952,
-0.0161720328,
-0.0069413371,
-0.0183019564,
0.0213413239,
-0.0006279386,
0.0423108302,
0.0047546919,
-0.0099300612,
-0.0282028299,
0.0154608199,
0.0352634937,
-0.0240474828,
-0.0754151121,
-0.0071892738,
0.0080688521,
0.0017401894,
-0.0167059544,
0.0216978118,
0.016526293,
0.0269995034,
-0.0239101294,
-0.0106384438,
0.0079655992,
-0.0773417056,
-0.0759814531,
0.0117193665,
0.0092436606,
-0.003899897,
-0.0181031451,
-0.0183571614,
-0.0325462185,
0.0395850204,
-0.0091329357,
0.0694842637,
-0.0280872751,
0.0217957161,
-0.0309107341,
-0.0271008983,
-0.0488185696,
0.0611358956,
0.0173176192,
-0.0057363948,
0.0393413529,
0.0565360002,
-0.0293659922,
-0.0254786927,
0.0023469515,
-0.0251533799,
-0.0088152587,
-0.0221944824,
-0.0083746966,
0.003101619,
-0.0543895662,
0.0056722853,
-0.0855186731,
-0.0100518018,
-0.0276441276,
-0.0148371672,
0.0118676005,
0.0227111578,
-0.018684933,
-0.0187273975,
0.0010890472,
-0.0074346955,
-0.0106216604,
0.0471129529,
0.0100452742,
0.0050711138,
-0.009910617,
-0.0261236932,
-0.0249539092,
-0.029185988,
0.0427056625,
-0.002904502,
0.0338878855,
-0.0178229362,
0.0572881736,
-0.0123395231,
-0.0130491629,
-0.035024602,
-0.0059139701,
0.0397722311,
-0.0269736573,
0.0332785808,
0.0905678794,
-0.0140034296,
0.0212040674,
0.0515393876,
-0.0106159961,
-0.0643390492,
0.0272513796,
-0.0176150762,
-0.0194228981,
-0.0092945136,
-0.0166040808,
-0.028413076,
0.0736806691,
0.016275445,
-0.0032326751,
-0.0540102683,
0.0220924895,
-0.0202785917,
-0.0622772761,
-0.061170347,
-0.0121868495,
-0.0083451308,
0.0805600733,
-0.0197877605,
-0.0626351163,
0.0881293416,
-0.0028646388,
-0.0126664173,
-0.0481175967,
0.021969337,
-0.0055833841,
0.0621933229,
0.0000083814,
-0.0121055767,
0.0352793634,
-0.0203905907,
-0.0704557821,
-0.0419862345,
0.0208400059,
-0.0139828492,
0.0176248867,
-0.0325959735,
0.0144339995,
-0.0146109117,
-0.0380650721,
-0.0596015863,
-0.0277786665,
-0.0234710723,
0.0112827085,
-0.0134339649,
0.0026904347,
0.0093237692,
-0.0102632251,
0.0325337686,
0.0474650003,
-0.0324625373,
-0.035757985,
-0.015434687,
-0.0176116377,
0.0351655111,
-0.0382491462,
0.0112158917,
-0.0505367219,
0.0630065352,
0.0332071446,
0.0652700886,
-0.0121050309,
-0.0383118987,
0.0165050253,
0.0132338945,
0.0074919523,
-0.0098221321,
0.0499614254,
0.0481651612,
-0.0726052895,
-0.0428932011,
0.109710753,
0.0495109148,
-0.0437084138,
0.001307254,
-0.0430830382,
0.0645714104,
0.0297124069,
0.0357383378,
-0.1108308583,
-0.052409526,
0.046190083,
0.0215671863,
-0.0081774238,
-0.0124160144,
-0.0164880268,
-0.113140732,
0.032667093,
-0.0205854625,
-0.0363490246,
0.0068256017,
-0.0513561442,
-0.0083518671,
-0.0057357182,
0.0190815087,
0.0426472984,
-0.0047487528,
0.0237370543,
0.0179956891,
0.0364505574,
-0.033487428,
0.0141946217,
-0.0021024842,
0.0237292107,
0.0861053169,
-0.0096072825,
0.023364041,
-0.0156024937,
0.0022593185,
-0.0080200974,
0.0177162439,
-0.0367448851,
0.0481285974,
0.0030435147,
0.0055567226,
-0.0171879921,
0.0411964357,
-0.0040780073,
-0.0279462878,
0.0041082073,
0.0584271252,
-0.0239527915,
-0.0077754669,
-0.0279075187,
0.0044025634,
0.0051723812,
0.0734449923,
0.0470061637,
-0.0287476368,
-0.0390354395,
-0.0277566817,
-0.0231724493,
-0.0404939912,
-0.0140569331,
-0.0379145332,
0.0197426304,
0.0023951493,
-0.037308149,
-0.0364851393,
0.0380573571,
0.0823335722,
0.0037628936,
0.0219976846,
0.0142411776,
0.0103977136,
-0.0427300781,
0.0043396475,
-0.0262460895,
0.0259052105,
-0.0532541201,
-0.0006352978,
0.0123654865,
-0.0241908748,
-0.0206459146,
0.0231196526,
-0.0938130766,
-0.0689005479,
0.0009477504,
0.0444108658,
0.0355171524,
0.054898072,
-0.021747252,
-0.0282363091,
0.0305962954,
0.0236841477,
-0.0129277613,
0.0387810357,
0.0357027389,
-0.0076586916,
0.0096971821,
0.0384514071,
-0.0146367932,
0.0153290089,
0.0306028016,
0.0471528582,
-0.0473022275,
0.0316002741,
0.0254917387,
0.005617064,
0.0658543408,
-0.0098339962,
-0.0211865548,
-0.0115598207,
0.0497878566,
-0.0382449441,
0.0024584164,
-0.0207134336,
0.0120507898,
0.0052846037,
-0.0039565298,
0.0032541004,
-0.0528608114,
-0.0190483928,
-0.0026226405,
-0.0217484608,
0.0116950488,
0.0014145559,
0.0270273816,
0.0243435428,
0.0114288265,
-0.0123724993,
0.0322805233,
0.0074263746,
0.0616561733,
-0.0288545098,
0.0596934371,
0.0480503365,
0.0160733927,
-0.0371854529,
-0.0152706886,
-0.1069884598,
-0.0256852265,
0.0355482884,
0.0193818882,
0.0246444214,
0.0001966804,
0.0072805951,
-0.0292095467,
-0.0043219859,
0.0087387338,
0.0319531262,
0.0381901152,
-0.0315172188,
0.0258639175,
0.0297688469,
0.0098805958,
-0.0252298042,
0.0578393489,
0.0025670642,
0.0493114069,
0.0142532978,
0.021542931,
-0.0236030221,
-0.0415730812,
0.0336544514,
0.0269820224,
-0.0197473504,
0.0305996388,
-0.0709720105,
-0.0745199844,
-0.0204185322,
-0.0011515407,
0.0032446962,
-0.0446446501,
0.0373601988,
0.0689743534,
0.0064784167,
-0.0424331464,
-0.0258318894,
0.0170042925,
-0.0007327958,
-0.0363208763,
-0.0249040928,
-7.099491437e-33,
-0.0432479978,
-0.0165795721,
0.0631200001,
-0.0116378181,
0.0036891233,
0.0000134057,
-0.0640154257,
0.0178819485,
-0.0297037158,
-0.0065250262,
-0.0400408655,
0.047528699,
0.019037487,
0.0165764336,
0.0161700863,
-0.0285987519,
0.0406637304,
-0.0045163282,
-0.0440541394,
0.0034227101,
0.016339872,
0.0400866792,
0.0147643732,
-0.0025710727,
0.0264910087,
0.0166209936,
0.0128747858,
0.0016371715,
-0.0418981686,
0.0347123072,
-0.0118756201,
0.01358754,
0.0050382568,
-0.0228927881,
-0.0172391962,
0.0256562401,
-0.0724653006,
-0.0424072854,
0.0468351245,
-0.0054902239,
-0.0581152551,
-0.0271465145,
0.0161446203,
0.009550021,
-0.0226460807,
-0.0399951227,
0.0030565716,
-0.0157903489,
-0.0568091236,
0.012487785,
-0.0962884203,
0.0058554076,
-0.0138365431,
-0.0379347503,
0.0140934289,
0.0730855763,
-0.0087038605,
0.0470351465,
-0.0373534076,
0.0246994197,
0.0245661233,
0.0356707312,
0.0538892187,
0.0497060604,
0.023226548,
0.0292391647,
0.0432982817,
-0.0138879158,
-0.0141306417,
0.0130763315,
0.0745841488,
0.0099230213,
0.0543692298,
0.0495001525,
0.0982155874,
0.0085937427,
-0.0769726634,
-0.0138343424,
0.0425777026,
0.0000345993,
0.0530857779,
0.0052765412,
-0.0617891252,
-0.0355344899,
-0.0646110624,
-0.0146883959,
-0.0599329472,
-0.031922821,
0.047988683,
0.0342291631,
-0.0146689899,
-0.0299098529,
0.0445798747,
-0.0222472623,
0.024341885,
0.0204776917,
-0.010589934,
0.0258961506,
-0.0198880564,
0.0261590295,
-0.0443931408,
0.0037448891,
0.0394724868,
0.0498346351,
0.0212402865,
0.0099821286,
0.046471376,
0.027964605,
-0.0525218248,
-0.0206455458,
-0.0383522511,
0.0201560538,
0.0187210031,
-0.0175553318,
0.0292939898,
0.0341440216,
-0.0021242774,
0.0412946306,
-0.0142494263,
-0.0230496302,
-0.0550579503,
-0.0226217192,
-0.0239925552,
0.0269175917,
-0.0317562819,
-0.0277039837,
-0.0218550749,
0.044428464,
0.0155708734,
-0.0831077546,
-0.0338640213,
0.0397641137,
3.058e-7,
0.0440328643,
0.0435741693,
-0.0046069277,
0.0515965894,
-0.0103325369,
0.033673618,
-0.0280185603,
-0.0228681751,
0.0410838015,
0.0043163453,
0.010119291,
0.0501599722,
0.0511905178,
0.0113865556,
-0.0730885714,
-0.0169449765,
-0.0659995824,
0.0135656744,
-0.036633119,
0.0150134778,
0.0424070843,
0.0822410882,
0.0001789898,
-0.0256040674,
0.0488827713,
-0.0021766569,
0.0371038057,
-0.0168829709,
0.0009825365,
-0.0265165232,
-0.0572167337,
0.0212031249,
0.0348098427,
0.0283148736,
-0.011219928,
-0.008433314,
-0.049499955,
0.037121959,
0.0059917485,
-0.0408696346,
-0.0294573251,
-0.0003497748,
0.0049773129,
-0.0915707424,
0.0978136361,
-0.0424141549,
-0.0121242274,
-0.0025021741,
0.0026711852,
-0.014985471,
0.0242084265,
-0.0086394977,
-0.0390412509,
-0.0106093008,
0.0135338604,
-0.0011932101,
0.0048607835,
-0.0727835968,
-0.0395326428,
-0.0009671377,
-0.0101313489,
-0.0517854132,
-0.0471042395,
0.0232372768,
0.0113157062,
-0.0305623095,
-0.0199550353,
3.231563688e-34,
0.0437915288,
-0.000379751,
0.0332427919,
0.0643269792,
0.0041455631,
-0.0137702134,
-0.0136682391,
-0.0060778037,
0.0590070896,
-0.0847407132,
-0.0471848175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08777v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08777v2 | Self-training Strategies for Sentiment Analysis: An Empirical Study | 2023-09-15T21:42:46 | 2024-02-04T00:52:03 | Haochen Liu, Sai Krishna Rallabandi, Yijing Wu, Parag Pravin Dakle, Preethi Raghavan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment analysis is a crucial task in natural language processing that
involves identifying and extracting subjective sentiment from text.
Self-training has recently emerged as an economical and efficient technique for
developing sentiment analysis models by leveraging a small amount of labeled
data and a large amount of unlabeled data. However, given a set of training
data, how to utilize them to conduct self-training makes a significant
difference in the final performance of the model. We refer to this methodology
as the self-training strategy. In this paper, we present an empirical study of
various self-training strategies for sentiment analysis. First, we investigate
the influence of the self-training strategy and hyper-parameters on the
performance of traditional small language models (SLMs) in various few-shot
settings. Second, we also explore the feasibility of leveraging large language
models (LLMs) to help self-training. We propose and empirically compare several
self-training strategies with the intervention of LLMs. Extensive experiments
are conducted on three real-world sentiment analysis datasets. | [
0.0447629318,
0.0485349484,
0.0009244026,
0.0378562883,
-0.0403724238,
0.0214752331,
0.0185805522,
-0.0026715214,
0.0463010222,
-0.0970299989,
-0.0563720502,
0.0131329419,
-0.0561336502,
-0.017574925,
-0.011115985,
-0.0139190815,
0.0115517126,
0.0094410451,
0.0302274041,
-0.0339207463,
0.0188812632,
-0.0004158892,
0.0031376206,
-0.0266852695,
-0.0112537276,
-0.0261359569,
0.0201525651,
0.0057398989,
-0.0237233639,
-0.044716645,
0.0330987088,
0.0391220152,
-0.0088813659,
0.0031342749,
0.0000018009,
-0.0347483419,
-0.0234334804,
-0.0300511606,
0.0198250469,
0.0235125311,
0.1061997637,
-0.0334717445,
0.0019925174,
0.0312685482,
-0.056783814,
-0.0448689871,
0.0193346497,
0.0548854768,
0.0633535087,
0.0604911447,
-0.017853599,
-0.0501520783,
-0.06393525,
0.0027265111,
-0.0316411927,
-0.0171590224,
0.0330478549,
0.0103382347,
-0.0359862,
0.0147851268,
0.0067688627,
0.0108912252,
-0.0392188206,
0.0224013049,
0.0343048051,
0.0056807557,
-0.0508019254,
0.0026611146,
-0.0198962763,
0.0304888897,
-0.0019445304,
-0.0276750792,
-0.0037550647,
-0.0082743028,
-0.0216652174,
-0.0253803637,
-0.007108632,
-0.001009557,
0.0210912041,
0.0513193458,
0.0137052583,
0.036839433,
0.0075650606,
0.0234030467,
-0.0135372113,
0.0404993705,
-0.0420164764,
-0.0535041168,
0.0098280888,
0.0490316041,
0.0353010334,
-0.0004551716,
-0.0085176677,
0.0217555538,
0.0594307743,
0.0334361829,
0.0001735425,
0.009153923,
0.0249829646,
-0.1012034491,
0.0208264422,
-0.0126084378,
-0.0042935358,
0.0582325943,
-0.0381874293,
-0.0326660499,
0.0418545865,
-0.0067126746,
-0.0299010333,
0.025256874,
-0.1007201895,
0.010580021,
-0.0382723808,
0.0814416036,
0.0183836091,
0.0001742576,
-0.0697943792,
-0.0038220838,
0.0082190074,
-0.022178445,
0.0112307817,
-0.0188042335,
0.0210495573,
0.0063798879,
-0.030831011,
0.0288936161,
-0.0289723054,
0.021641707,
-0.0659815148,
-0.0449224599,
0.000023219,
0.0266366601,
0.01513856,
0.0178249311,
0.0195676479,
0.0583760515,
0.0269892663,
-0.0525091998,
-0.0672291741,
0.0049212966,
-0.0336337574,
-0.0563524924,
-0.0163713172,
-0.0610537082,
-0.0072576883,
-0.0051733404,
-0.0017837762,
0.0028641857,
0.0016408559,
-0.0252700225,
-0.0265010595,
0.0565706491,
-0.0613953732,
0.0189353023,
0.02265081,
-0.0096632922,
0.0326087363,
0.0937527418,
-0.0163625404,
0.0478349999,
0.0501968302,
-0.0281612221,
0.0359200202,
0.0125889322,
-0.0055102692,
-0.0167274438,
-0.0602842569,
0.0082726981,
-0.0412821136,
-0.0199122783,
0.010430648,
0.0102809388,
-0.007527621,
0.025388537,
0.0301977284,
0.0487862267,
0.0355464444,
0.0373604409,
-0.0298475213,
0.0079569248,
0.0371373557,
-0.0132250208,
-0.0008788424,
0.0103126131,
-0.001350061,
-0.0021613459,
0.012716189,
0.0057531726,
-0.0469065383,
-0.0790686831,
-0.0389332473,
-0.027531052,
0.0069927089,
-0.0084830783,
0.0718931779,
0.0096651632,
-0.0037408941,
0.0073161218,
0.0527709201,
-0.0502519459,
-0.0245952066,
-0.0376064926,
0.019803673,
0.0813065097,
0.0063591767,
-0.039700795,
-0.0142179374,
-0.0207740683,
0.015437061,
0.0231092926,
0.050722301,
0.0122911874,
0.0006050524,
-0.0317958407,
-0.0051252316,
-0.0280820392,
0.0355686098,
-0.0083716996,
-0.015869271,
0.0144055374,
-0.016137002,
-0.0046969312,
-0.0479995571,
0.0273189619,
0.0384505056,
-0.0620522089,
0.061325606,
-0.0101081105,
0.041444622,
0.0203552321,
-0.0370356441,
-0.0159462038,
0.0126334419,
-0.0100622131,
-0.0599429309,
0.0016549844,
0.0081921294,
-0.0724931434,
0.006404113,
0.0107806111,
-0.0181277581,
0.0041969083,
-0.0404606238,
-0.0036688934,
0.0303582624,
-0.0039806897,
0.0263713691,
-0.0416878946,
0.0019260166,
-0.0379687957,
0.0031980046,
-0.0220987573,
0.0385319255,
0.0336937904,
-0.0131611479,
-0.0759579539,
-0.0175880715,
0.0354976505,
-0.0034601749,
-0.0285246633,
-0.0052842116,
0.0065674647,
0.0427900292,
0.0309343264,
-0.0036604323,
-0.0387985744,
-0.0518038608,
-0.1060970053,
-0.0192493163,
-0.0099106766,
0.0152982799,
0.0153222997,
-0.0233800188,
-0.03052531,
-0.0122739514,
-0.0074626915,
-0.0060519902,
-0.0170000326,
0.0250743758,
0.0592805669,
0.0095083266,
0.0449677892,
-0.0654379874,
0.0019413442,
-0.0134640569,
0.0090052783,
0.0129226381,
-0.0085711554,
-0.0327384844,
0.0173174292,
-0.0438260138,
0.0175107736,
0.0177680645,
-0.0826045796,
-0.0148167619,
-0.0143596511,
-0.005768456,
0.0415066406,
0.0179058053,
0.0018300562,
0.0583783202,
0.0165327657,
-0.050013829,
0.010481189,
-0.0637056679,
0.0039532548,
-0.0013915072,
0.0048809224,
0.0051303157,
0.0687323287,
0.0142707583,
0.0010679872,
-0.0206915811,
0.045207601,
-0.0227590278,
-0.019990284,
-0.019512184,
0.0286646318,
0.0223483201,
-0.0121182781,
0.0347183309,
-0.041504018,
0.054123491,
0.0079299808,
0.0222885441,
-0.0660786927,
-0.0271283835,
-0.051534988,
0.0251794737,
-0.0214334223,
0.0052024024,
0.0086631887,
0.0300121661,
0.0441908874,
-0.0481111445,
0.024120111,
-0.0037513499,
0.0096719088,
0.025067674,
0.0283151921,
0.0317655653,
-0.0444147438,
-0.0164411701,
-0.0844495744,
-0.0575221628,
-0.0441013798,
0.0073191845,
0.0189541653,
0.0127874548,
0.035101749,
-0.0262488145,
0.0030963756,
-0.0253744423,
-0.0327256769,
0.038143754,
0.0015833146,
0.0149105936,
-0.0625155419,
0.0233344808,
0.0174720306,
0.0542006418,
0.0152730467,
0.0326422118,
0.0048946794,
-0.0484218225,
-0.0170381702,
0.000061408,
-0.0307450648,
0.015779594,
-0.0273408983,
0.0272148177,
-0.0305931941,
0.0200758427,
0.1463790089,
0.0199781898,
-0.0338789523,
-0.0137176216,
-0.0082988329,
-0.0077033369,
0.0462579541,
0.0163628254,
-0.0006072811,
-0.0283218175,
-0.0460823961,
0.0457999259,
-0.0236299969,
-0.0103385467,
0.002645951,
-0.1132048294,
0.0348997042,
0.0065725767,
-0.0000246973,
0.0026994681,
-0.054127302,
0.0005241768,
-0.0455437191,
-0.0281048715,
-0.0314430185,
-0.0494990572,
0.0110624777,
0.0184756089,
-0.1012892649,
-0.039959453,
0.0203175005,
-0.0065970384,
0.0406368747,
0.0066687702,
0.0278862491,
-0.0068806298,
0.0189445857,
0.042837847,
-0.0185822677,
0.0347384587,
-0.0501775779,
0.088319093,
-0.0502392687,
-0.0231242236,
0.0181380957,
-0.0155926766,
-0.0448442921,
0.0442355573,
0.0235781986,
0.0110476194,
0.0039036605,
-0.044990506,
-0.0017890781,
0.0402695052,
0.006926158,
0.0726261362,
-0.0090006199,
-0.0599344671,
-0.0084835757,
0.020972779,
-0.0123065114,
-0.0083652027,
-0.0310431011,
-0.0052015553,
-0.0212122872,
-0.0277740657,
-0.069367297,
-0.0601765439,
0.0258587915,
0.0528642312,
-0.0206184685,
0.0593731478,
0.0106128948,
0.0334596112,
-0.0141846696,
0.0081011215,
-0.0172493085,
-0.0520878881,
0.0041888752,
-0.0297023617,
0.0975136086,
0.0099395942,
-0.0058570942,
-0.0431192853,
-0.033322636,
-0.0518683083,
0.013383342,
0.0853317231,
0.0157051068,
0.0213953163,
0.0109587414,
-0.0547072887,
0.0103325648,
0.0810642764,
-0.0607040115,
-0.0088690165,
0.0545199253,
0.0589884445,
0.0218073223,
0.0190597512,
-0.0011668457,
0.0812100321,
0.0322851129,
-0.0213824213,
-0.0607105978,
-0.0083407871,
0.0275984351,
0.0013789033,
0.0749858841,
0.0151461447,
-0.0059191179,
-0.009826377,
-0.0135708852,
-0.0240228921,
-0.027695803,
-0.0311452933,
-0.0005353721,
-0.0013921651,
0.007264311,
-0.0720515102,
-0.0149126984,
-0.0621949695,
0.0163314342,
-0.0147379767,
0.0564692803,
0.0113939885,
0.0134429699,
-0.0032628567,
0.0063945446,
-0.0223675556,
-0.0052350941,
0.0319953486,
-0.0449613407,
0.0006279186,
0.0224084351,
-0.0012428655,
0.0373627543,
-0.0250988528,
0.0193994995,
-0.0086374758,
-0.0007153327,
-0.0222734045,
0.0215015225,
0.01616483,
-0.0293193646,
0.0408627987,
-0.0233449787,
-0.0095618721,
-0.0007820956,
0.005735829,
-0.0419421531,
0.0106121525,
0.0226848405,
0.0074427458,
-0.0750416219,
0.008305097,
0.0525385737,
0.0002197101,
0.0250022952,
0.0536499321,
0.0053792512,
-0.0651489198,
0.0187375508,
0.039251022,
0.0023552531,
0.0169730484,
0.0281395912,
-0.0413854234,
-0.0485710278,
0.0494176783,
-0.0354958884,
0.0029345292,
-0.0074292826,
0.0412421674,
0.0651243106,
0.0085172364,
0.0789142996,
-0.0696487427,
0.0132457195,
-0.0118316989,
-0.0205425788,
0.0119409822,
-6.301169142e-33,
0.0105476445,
0.0045586145,
-0.0123925544,
0.0410470366,
0.0345510393,
-0.015867142,
-0.0059747729,
0.0474615544,
0.0104219913,
0.0393050015,
-0.0153792249,
0.0057786168,
0.0087427702,
0.0022372224,
0.0356550217,
0.0004316337,
0.0548781455,
-0.048180759,
-0.006639583,
-0.0137153352,
0.000658592,
0.0409654118,
0.0412222445,
-0.1138089076,
-0.0056879479,
-0.0008963369,
-0.0298413262,
0.0299432334,
0.0782532692,
0.0484634452,
-0.0243048016,
0.071594812,
0.0388771668,
-0.0153088933,
0.0112513425,
0.0180702973,
-0.0240624957,
-0.0408096649,
-0.0217560101,
-0.0039705215,
0.0014873546,
-0.0172263347,
0.0323494114,
-0.010390575,
-0.0608533286,
0.0388425998,
0.0301961601,
-0.0282726623,
0.0061142012,
-0.0370196924,
-0.0449945852,
0.0316548981,
-0.0059089758,
-0.0036833151,
0.0658787042,
0.0239760857,
-0.0085253119,
0.046413321,
-0.0490734354,
0.0209239833,
-0.0043988372,
0.0367912166,
-0.0028823377,
-0.0186445713,
0.0293235108,
0.0728037208,
0.0350792781,
0.0358657166,
-0.0024390745,
0.0350797772,
0.0388063006,
0.0013838392,
0.0306054782,
0.0621588863,
0.0400501788,
-0.0566859208,
-0.05859394,
-0.0052024918,
0.037106242,
-0.0170540307,
0.0570622645,
0.0014247235,
-0.0502380393,
-0.0152295865,
0.0080517503,
-0.0486001596,
-0.0241632238,
-0.0232994929,
0.0089587523,
0.0375075005,
-0.042392619,
-0.0177696664,
-0.0143742403,
-0.0567083322,
-0.0556967556,
0.0198095832,
-0.0427243784,
0.0342337117,
0.0116367359,
-0.0068568382,
-0.0749111623,
-0.0242593493,
-0.0461094454,
0.0503140017,
0.0153772105,
-0.0161315277,
0.045014061,
0.0341623127,
-0.1016153321,
-0.0193231292,
0.0119319847,
0.0313102975,
-0.0122705828,
0.0098157739,
-0.0191747379,
0.0140108448,
-0.0051973299,
0.0673459321,
0.0081197815,
-0.0063570691,
0.0015339615,
0.0165194441,
-0.0039604241,
0.0000229928,
0.0012224785,
-0.0320862979,
0.0209195465,
-0.0115498286,
0.01528937,
-0.0469175205,
-0.0019924359,
-0.0000716001,
2.523e-7,
0.0300589222,
0.1133496016,
-0.0332661085,
-0.0364546441,
0.0351513028,
0.0688627288,
-0.0328044333,
0.0050418093,
0.0305612329,
-0.0204904843,
0.0245724134,
0.039837949,
0.017781226,
0.0247423071,
-0.0959914699,
0.0086293006,
-0.0347669944,
0.0258003194,
0.0140725235,
0.0072474838,
0.0575740635,
0.0953641981,
0.0265197679,
-0.0149244303,
-0.0575422496,
-0.0344491825,
0.0562161356,
-0.028895637,
-0.0134371957,
0.0379520096,
-0.0160135068,
0.0529383756,
-0.0302289333,
-0.0340938307,
-0.0103310132,
0.0301132873,
-0.0128706163,
0.0467288084,
0.0143643236,
-0.0228580926,
0.0402159542,
0.034233816,
0.0122284507,
-0.0115873544,
0.0588054508,
-0.1163773909,
-0.0442009866,
-0.075616613,
0.012427059,
0.0084608784,
0.0499656089,
-0.0144597804,
-0.0418775529,
0.0333537981,
0.0146244038,
-0.0226406083,
-0.0561972372,
-0.0692797601,
0.0052394336,
0.0114671793,
0.0027351354,
-0.0025835412,
0.0088527054,
0.0480413772,
0.022465907,
-0.0315242223,
0.0410392657,
1.805842406e-34,
0.0549581498,
-0.0472977087,
-0.0087336181,
0.0081563881,
0.003945224,
0.0156384874,
-0.0407086499,
-0.0081860479,
0.0304053985,
-0.0468207076,
0.0373545587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08741v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08741v1 | AlbNER: A Corpus for Named Entity Recognition in Albanian | 2023-09-15T20:03:19 | 2023-09-15T20:03:19 | Erion Çano | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Scarcity of resources such as annotated text corpora for under-resourced
languages like Albanian is a serious impediment in computational linguistics
and natural language processing research. This paper presents AlbNER, a corpus
of 900 sentences with labeled named entities, collected from Albanian Wikipedia
articles. Preliminary results with BERT and RoBERTa variants fine-tuned and
tested with AlbNER data indicate that model size has slight impact on NER
performance, whereas language transfer has a significant one. AlbNER corpus and
these obtained results should serve as baselines for future experiments. | [
0.0397558585,
0.0192848239,
0.003813073,
0.0403888859,
-0.024126051,
0.0421162955,
0.0061926944,
0.0374453664,
-0.0120134661,
-0.0291051418,
0.0076494515,
0.0147325182,
0.0120279174,
-0.0562688038,
0.0055390666,
-0.0206892472,
0.0393938348,
-0.0455294363,
0.0361136869,
0.0126410164,
0.0204139296,
-0.0046958276,
-0.0425250605,
0.0050824895,
-0.0026458136,
0.0645984113,
-0.0237321425,
0.0073212353,
0.0307743102,
-0.0488981083,
-0.0268427208,
0.0272007436,
-0.0504594967,
-0.0297282226,
0.0000016303,
-0.0871350765,
-0.0348137207,
-0.0018514998,
-0.0151099162,
-0.0461198017,
-0.0103397733,
-0.0390251353,
-0.0265379827,
-0.0089177787,
0.0442924313,
0.0108704539,
0.0542726777,
0.0840084106,
0.0223282389,
0.0825757161,
-0.0073090382,
-0.0383566804,
0.0591245107,
0.0367488228,
0.0112127652,
0.0031720793,
0.0437513143,
-0.080118008,
-0.0156291146,
-0.0096582966,
0.0360247493,
0.0172927715,
-0.0444160551,
-0.0186378397,
-0.0063221762,
0.0306002796,
-0.10291145,
-0.0210053306,
0.0182064995,
0.0107489666,
0.0312908925,
0.0412153527,
0.05858564,
0.0304886047,
-0.0128228543,
0.0217264779,
-0.0145821245,
-0.0166585017,
-0.0735462904,
0.0009477512,
0.0847896188,
-0.023719158,
-0.001148482,
-0.0186187793,
0.0099928537,
0.0670762807,
0.0684233531,
-0.0470405184,
0.0370542333,
0.0143725742,
-0.0154204145,
-0.0110963117,
0.047694359,
0.0390663967,
0.0390064828,
0.0138193024,
0.0025483053,
-0.013509253,
0.0102949068,
-0.0431692116,
0.0057037529,
0.0122018717,
0.0317773893,
0.0065551735,
-0.0842460021,
-0.0027252317,
0.0362613387,
-0.0332151726,
0.0029728494,
-0.0529972054,
-0.0716835037,
0.0070395726,
-0.0718644261,
0.0648450404,
-0.0311509501,
-0.0004969706,
-0.0303267036,
-0.0145831266,
0.0517222919,
0.025583379,
0.0348328985,
-0.0652908236,
-0.0119725736,
0.0042240811,
-0.0490048937,
0.0322459675,
-0.0148074077,
0.0059622875,
-0.0503060892,
-0.0593795441,
0.0242856164,
-0.0183593091,
0.0410565026,
-0.0335259847,
0.021861881,
0.0295298584,
0.0042225248,
-0.0767581984,
-0.05641561,
0.033828456,
-0.0053783581,
-0.0389930271,
0.0017581597,
-0.0376850739,
0.0445526578,
0.0352439992,
0.0214568693,
-0.0535846055,
0.0323058553,
0.0080122976,
-0.0466817543,
0.0901426896,
-0.0157272611,
0.0168863982,
0.0265577175,
-0.0305979811,
0.0606958717,
-0.0017573071,
0.0506860875,
-0.0432925411,
0.0508648343,
0.011720622,
0.0011051622,
0.0174662434,
-0.0079652118,
-0.0019267014,
0.0134699494,
0.0286830012,
-0.0395213924,
0.0111207282,
0.0077775232,
0.0544942841,
0.030709235,
0.0175235476,
0.026176421,
0.0503030531,
0.008504441,
0.0487090349,
-0.0088680573,
-0.007040998,
0.0394315608,
-0.0371589214,
-0.0111610573,
-0.0080113802,
0.0058161067,
0.0423500873,
-0.0102680326,
0.0321439244,
-0.0166895781,
0.0034350294,
-0.014601633,
-0.0183369201,
-0.0147726061,
-0.0649653599,
0.0696283355,
-0.0176224243,
-0.0322912298,
0.0574507043,
0.0835964829,
-0.012752709,
0.0489993058,
-0.0299606025,
0.0332562588,
0.0448282696,
0.023738334,
-0.050031852,
-0.0095637469,
-0.0122279497,
-0.0490298383,
0.069643572,
-0.0259825531,
-0.0337211303,
0.0188724343,
-0.0034669228,
0.0149157662,
0.0166451484,
0.0225842725,
0.0302055534,
-0.0166447852,
0.0878046304,
0.0190450177,
-0.0406737961,
-0.0369936638,
0.0318204202,
-0.0488085039,
0.0171948541,
-0.0085805543,
0.0290418249,
-0.01093206,
0.0166784637,
-0.0064542415,
-0.0052493932,
-0.0105266012,
-0.0377724022,
0.0461144634,
0.0002079803,
0.0576181747,
-0.075734131,
-0.0182121973,
-0.0623338446,
-0.0071223648,
0.012545241,
0.0188259054,
-0.0277109686,
-0.0237060413,
-0.0019311319,
0.023798015,
-0.0165555291,
0.0494452454,
0.012380084,
0.0372428484,
0.00042944,
0.0321933553,
-0.0093521755,
0.0175938699,
0.0482203886,
-0.0557582676,
0.0183563232,
-0.0156692378,
-0.0727025568,
0.0423910543,
0.0172510203,
-0.0622800179,
0.0484892912,
-0.0035848576,
-0.0052788276,
-0.0304429047,
-0.0980627015,
0.0053044427,
-0.0031067515,
0.0613670275,
-0.0128741395,
0.0314910561,
-0.0316017568,
-0.0013319011,
-0.0140250009,
0.0289774984,
-0.006616917,
-0.0226700958,
0.0329061225,
0.0390386172,
-0.0394895338,
-0.01036603,
0.0148898456,
-0.0157341231,
-0.0073215887,
0.0410292372,
-0.0698385015,
-0.0705205947,
0.0440528244,
-0.033788763,
-0.0083071152,
-0.0058718561,
0.0008585792,
-0.0253105648,
0.0024934607,
0.0045710322,
0.0023826847,
-0.0228408054,
-0.0038680467,
-0.0044308179,
-0.0365494564,
-0.0097722253,
0.0041182903,
-0.0075696572,
0.0476992317,
-0.0707125738,
-0.0470118262,
0.0469853766,
0.0687333569,
-0.0499746278,
0.0063745892,
-0.0141200433,
-0.0470191054,
-0.0585222095,
-0.007805204,
-0.0098988237,
0.0050711595,
-0.0136764701,
0.0257292539,
0.0169404782,
0.0215528887,
0.0388826877,
-0.0537623465,
0.0031853539,
-0.0609410144,
-0.002533481,
-0.0595887899,
-0.0206233654,
0.0045237276,
0.013508982,
0.034103252,
-0.0892160833,
0.0237741992,
0.0269560777,
0.0062976526,
0.0040778937,
0.0202943031,
-0.0415882692,
0.0169201493,
-0.022769168,
-0.0142491618,
-0.0271553025,
-0.0058147577,
0.0069576032,
0.0259371493,
0.0405869633,
-0.0061336565,
-0.011967022,
0.0536782853,
-0.0019326947,
0.0203092024,
-0.0046437639,
0.0094237523,
-0.0177360959,
0.0797277689,
0.0302063748,
-0.0214627571,
0.0144747831,
0.010036625,
-0.003272092,
-0.0258505885,
-0.0050011813,
-0.0148826092,
0.0002561708,
0.0066908961,
0.0066249762,
-0.0894246697,
-0.0289809387,
-0.033413399,
0.0065129776,
0.0144094592,
-0.0461577587,
0.0950841159,
-0.0008353032,
-0.0260689519,
-0.0397546925,
-0.0110171586,
0.0023564906,
-0.0053158957,
0.039362561,
0.0149717936,
-0.0052043805,
0.0337193161,
0.0134359859,
-0.0178139452,
-0.0655604303,
0.010530361,
-0.1103440896,
-0.0296889059,
-0.0340879895,
-0.0148773091,
0.0011302023,
-0.0742105916,
-0.0009962962,
-0.0152184125,
-0.0298014004,
-0.0380416475,
-0.0351467542,
0.0176579244,
0.0572202429,
-0.0261696838,
-0.0809009299,
-0.0419069752,
-0.011713258,
0.062077105,
-0.0212639421,
0.057351578,
-0.0877489895,
0.0115151461,
0.0263825599,
-0.0198638793,
0.0109140771,
-0.0142424786,
0.0455552153,
-0.0317943171,
-0.0172126926,
-0.0602091253,
-0.0169528425,
0.018345993,
-0.0102558406,
0.0163673908,
0.0046710107,
0.0248380974,
0.01492263,
0.0201060865,
-0.0507432148,
0.0335241519,
0.0444440693,
-0.0166860297,
-0.0011454243,
-0.0008796353,
0.0523963869,
-0.0278019197,
-0.0191899557,
-0.0127916588,
0.0052881571,
-0.0245725755,
-0.002020384,
-0.0878138319,
-0.0533941239,
0.0476744771,
0.01630372,
0.0389082953,
0.0235841908,
0.0152530009,
0.0346518941,
-0.0087136514,
0.0189477094,
-0.000906718,
-0.0178435724,
-0.079399772,
0.0017614133,
0.0425737612,
0.0383275524,
-0.0181068778,
-0.0225195084,
0.014292066,
-0.0310291462,
0.0262056272,
0.0392662846,
0.0180281531,
0.0362583771,
0.0060680276,
0.0130260317,
0.0343313105,
0.0347078554,
-0.014733661,
-0.0172859579,
-0.0109438328,
0.0437008813,
-0.0341970287,
0.0324355066,
-0.00093989,
0.0175940488,
0.0178248882,
0.016341541,
-0.0050180731,
-0.0863749236,
-0.0001858083,
0.0536274835,
0.0262501612,
-0.0424731821,
-0.0004040665,
-0.0623748377,
0.0266289897,
-0.0058613885,
0.0441126004,
0.0080077387,
-0.0259224158,
0.0286753904,
0.0051303264,
-0.0310845934,
0.0791651085,
-0.0178660508,
-0.0168716609,
-0.0419611298,
0.0332673788,
0.0157784875,
0.0463519543,
0.0062229307,
-0.0005041086,
0.017812375,
-0.0084776459,
0.0458150655,
0.0322538465,
-0.0427300856,
0.0154623017,
-0.0030034841,
-0.019278504,
0.0003952539,
0.0410717167,
-0.0013694823,
0.0574293882,
-0.0153845865,
0.0548557267,
0.0272610076,
-0.0112272669,
0.0663094223,
-0.010639539,
0.0007694239,
-0.0059096618,
0.0377203114,
-0.0181509163,
0.0211928263,
0.0484786108,
-0.006169409,
-0.0079018986,
-0.0167443566,
0.0178277139,
0.0088074189,
0.0096008098,
0.0218243785,
0.0029859557,
-0.0179974716,
0.0066552558,
-0.0078868028,
-0.0500154644,
-0.053969264,
0.0077251657,
-0.0252087284,
-0.0329134949,
-0.0376421213,
-0.0410000198,
-0.0077353837,
-0.0010014516,
0.0075128861,
-0.0199574046,
0.0467420369,
-0.0084290747,
-0.0351486392,
0.0097642606,
-0.0726289079,
0.0134481983,
-0.0155861489,
-5.491258677e-33,
-0.0711333379,
0.0451529957,
0.0143392012,
-0.0071960255,
0.0044209752,
0.010364919,
-0.0093951421,
0.0047468282,
0.0120054279,
-0.0118907262,
-0.0303395577,
-0.0151355537,
0.025749648,
-0.0214263536,
0.0156569779,
-0.0208935719,
0.0318881199,
0.058705166,
-0.0433788113,
-0.0187933408,
0.0440802611,
0.041257821,
0.0912075415,
-0.0542202592,
0.0181018226,
-0.0098656677,
0.0363782272,
0.0046987161,
0.0995844677,
0.0257795881,
-0.028224431,
0.0118763736,
0.0052193077,
-0.0856088623,
0.0063491426,
0.0263252035,
-0.1213091314,
-0.0011941636,
0.0079761129,
0.0630073622,
0.0169703253,
-0.0453553647,
-0.0260326453,
0.0102161774,
-0.0012706746,
0.0769064426,
0.0563575104,
-0.0125342486,
0.0184679925,
0.0295019504,
-0.0825764909,
0.0092884572,
-0.018432254,
0.0419600084,
0.0305038542,
0.0277756546,
0.0179538373,
-0.0615534484,
-0.0606064349,
-0.0098432656,
-0.0137546873,
0.0108092986,
0.0098760063,
-0.0250792596,
-0.028583942,
0.0305872038,
0.0152629139,
-0.0277746283,
0.01767518,
0.0027168165,
0.0016001048,
0.0212217961,
-0.0129027888,
0.0303396787,
0.0363140926,
-0.0667017326,
-0.053610459,
0.051451426,
0.03127845,
0.0845080391,
-0.0210378263,
-0.059997417,
-0.0529672243,
-0.0153865516,
0.0281187668,
-0.0500941873,
-0.0270891692,
-0.028266985,
0.0495684892,
-0.0072060241,
-0.0466739722,
0.0431329086,
0.0273562279,
0.0044279499,
-0.0708780363,
0.0045447862,
0.0341098495,
0.0248235129,
-0.050195381,
-0.0030686965,
-0.0777645707,
-0.0880736485,
-0.0030661162,
0.0035770864,
0.0499802008,
-0.0154546872,
0.0410934053,
0.0027705408,
-0.0518332012,
0.01577341,
-0.0136504853,
0.0361828841,
-0.0222005937,
0.0771077722,
-0.0198454447,
-0.0011086253,
-0.0043343636,
-0.0341391377,
0.0358258374,
-0.0135467639,
-0.0081033166,
-0.0173861347,
0.0490952954,
0.0023488065,
-0.0226445869,
0.0223794561,
-0.025107393,
0.0388561971,
0.0219781343,
0.0049714297,
0.0083547486,
-0.0158316419,
2.471e-7,
-0.0063639735,
0.0181176476,
0.0356796347,
-0.0472692586,
-0.0046399543,
-0.0205289926,
-0.0410382487,
0.0573432036,
-0.0149408029,
0.0411855467,
0.0016244195,
-0.0163419265,
0.0219843313,
0.0108961761,
-0.1055551395,
-0.0723931789,
0.0155197466,
0.0067090858,
-0.0738533735,
0.0666867793,
-0.0043803737,
0.0282564014,
-0.0021509111,
-0.0240933504,
-0.0611598119,
-0.0375659317,
0.0383077562,
-0.0122650024,
0.0062347134,
0.0460199378,
0.019215418,
0.0794766471,
-0.0017000502,
0.0623301566,
-0.0224316027,
0.0488104969,
0.0151974717,
0.0502639376,
-0.0223596096,
0.0106252069,
0.037376307,
-0.0387183577,
0.0000464713,
-0.0110857543,
0.0807553008,
0.0019013468,
-0.0415026806,
0.0317973271,
-0.0349481441,
-0.0382451974,
-0.0191250164,
0.0210455079,
-0.0084538348,
-0.0040812036,
0.0330646485,
-0.05167735,
-0.0049476647,
-0.0305310972,
0.04001664,
-0.006000434,
0.011498563,
-0.0385007076,
-0.0064582387,
-0.0198069513,
0.0185395386,
-0.0387313962,
0.0128631983,
1.814583308e-34,
-0.029138023,
0.0394441113,
-0.0380290858,
0.0726588219,
0.0004065818,
-0.0238679387,
-0.0422591977,
0.0179710668,
-0.0293105319,
-0.0279568117,
0.0153992483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.09992v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.09992v2 | OpenAI Cribbed Our Tax Example, But Can GPT-4 Really Do Tax? | 2023-09-15T20:00:27 | 2024-02-07T16:40:22 | Andrew Blair-Stanek, Nils Holzenberger, Benjamin Van Durme | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7; I.2.0 | The authors explain where OpenAI got the tax law example in its livestream
demonstration of GPT-4, why GPT-4 got the wrong answer, and how it fails to
reliably calculate taxes. | [
-0.0470263883,
0.087106891,
-0.0275795106,
0.0629819855,
-0.0458351336,
-0.0330963768,
0.0215514544,
0.0272901766,
-0.0187279563,
0.0028376798,
0.007578216,
0.0228030719,
0.0845792294,
0.0261596851,
0.0210086182,
-0.0906723812,
0.0454572067,
-0.0094488589,
0.0168112088,
-0.0072565973,
-0.0120071368,
0.0166935828,
-0.0163390264,
0.0533842817,
-0.0324883163,
-0.0378175899,
-0.0348901711,
-0.0232710373,
0.0673133954,
0.0269468743,
0.0150516471,
0.0113174384,
-0.0247118399,
0.1148003787,
0.0000019164,
-0.0533414856,
-0.0142162153,
0.034936022,
0.0298336856,
0.1413898766,
0.0807471052,
0.0358397812,
-0.0335754193,
0.0252966788,
-0.0428410694,
-0.015343626,
0.0374076143,
-0.026696872,
0.0450235568,
0.0393786058,
-0.0172614045,
-0.0352732278,
0.0708738565,
-0.0314077027,
0.0276474394,
-0.0847673789,
0.0193387736,
-0.0305953585,
-0.0502520092,
-0.0642549768,
-0.0041157077,
-0.0080531156,
0.0338782258,
0.0028580255,
-0.0320663415,
0.0637209639,
-0.0518799275,
0.0273711886,
-0.009757014,
0.0117100058,
0.0379006378,
-0.0006151945,
-0.0249462314,
-0.0189857036,
-0.01530373,
-0.0232061949,
-0.0187847409,
0.0384413823,
-0.0220386479,
0.0321315862,
0.0126429368,
0.0166812297,
-0.0041835872,
0.0563484319,
-0.0124344844,
0.0509769209,
-0.004789684,
-0.0188560672,
-0.019502718,
0.0626116097,
-0.0426677577,
-0.0326745585,
-0.0062818672,
0.0026555378,
0.0361467116,
0.011450897,
-0.0394044332,
0.0289731734,
0.01673498,
-0.0151000386,
0.0628420934,
0.0442699604,
-0.0614475906,
0.0047201831,
-0.0371547081,
0.0199056659,
-0.1132984683,
0.0365739726,
0.0464756489,
0.0209744032,
-0.0359147266,
-0.0288556553,
-0.0435889326,
0.047501076,
-0.0438802801,
-0.0088285357,
-0.0536621511,
0.0266851876,
-0.0608099364,
0.0089248847,
0.0246409439,
0.0106247691,
-0.0286083333,
-0.0210833196,
-0.0608390197,
-0.0098620048,
-0.0497621819,
0.0180991124,
0.0118628778,
-0.0282645207,
0.0004924465,
0.0219026711,
-0.0550548322,
-0.0094834846,
-0.0134169282,
-0.003463055,
0.0487361066,
0.0346220396,
-0.0063749659,
-0.0316548385,
-0.0007404952,
-0.0494927205,
0.0122987628,
-0.0647546202,
-0.0363216549,
-0.047654897,
0.0125629604,
-0.0093724774,
-0.0029094724,
0.0054131295,
-0.0383732393,
0.0520134903,
-0.0134047596,
-0.0180874113,
-0.0357601643,
0.0158984866,
0.0059335777,
0.0652416646,
0.0470910184,
-0.0394671522,
0.0189092178,
0.0115725277,
0.0566593781,
-0.0079991724,
0.0378146768,
0.0209684391,
-0.0417564921,
0.032969676,
-0.049065806,
0.0159268584,
0.0377749465,
0.0394838192,
0.0088967104,
0.020551743,
0.0189971719,
0.0287261512,
-0.0303940866,
0.0456895865,
-0.0256234091,
0.0035692274,
0.0007451836,
0.008179877,
-0.0144160492,
0.0152838146,
-0.0680709928,
0.0137595814,
-0.0349624231,
0.0290044453,
-0.0144111551,
-0.0175640173,
0.0189359281,
-0.0092214644,
-0.0233459305,
-0.0059956559,
0.0260448568,
-0.0129906032,
0.0164894667,
0.002980134,
0.0349993296,
-0.071094498,
-0.056662038,
-0.0604603849,
0.0272995085,
-0.0290003773,
0.0212920662,
-0.0371590666,
-0.0194193386,
0.005444176,
-0.0322031491,
0.0087187365,
0.0924080834,
0.0043950337,
0.0108711226,
-0.0421410911,
0.0254431069,
-0.0233148374,
0.0407310091,
0.0566608533,
0.0339196809,
-0.0090187686,
0.0141661549,
-0.0105279721,
0.0941829309,
-0.0075596771,
0.0574484356,
-0.0488105156,
-0.0038637202,
-0.0050135492,
0.0249733962,
-0.0081645371,
0.0028326353,
-0.0317915976,
0.0357786864,
0.0528991409,
0.0145008415,
-0.0089253802,
0.0307177585,
0.0234186593,
0.0058517316,
0.0289300866,
-0.0157272555,
0.0840252116,
-0.0324668288,
-0.0190412179,
-0.0152736623,
-0.0009033142,
0.065076597,
-0.0485848039,
-0.0144462353,
-0.0156528298,
0.0167998224,
0.0125378156,
0.0685029849,
0.0434602275,
-0.0356469788,
-0.004980084,
-0.005439105,
0.0078100176,
-0.0337763354,
-0.0024494028,
0.0371216387,
-0.0125270383,
0.0279832017,
-0.0316128917,
0.0174002014,
-0.0211383477,
0.0018698596,
-0.0363650285,
0.0511823818,
0.0134541653,
0.0421072654,
0.0137649262,
-0.0197127908,
-0.0245679356,
-0.0034438206,
-0.0300414022,
-0.029168779,
-0.0343881287,
-0.0296028052,
-0.0075473185,
-0.0219369084,
-0.0104923211,
0.0079925554,
-0.0080786236,
-0.0391366929,
-0.0026275606,
0.0172722302,
-0.0010233792,
-0.043553371,
-0.0100355325,
-0.0396081395,
-0.0191316996,
0.0200198088,
0.0147249158,
0.0151615581,
0.0003654332,
-0.0416465886,
0.0381822512,
0.0013655772,
0.0550017208,
-0.01593302,
-0.0161834173,
-0.0590434074,
0.0300253332,
0.0066660256,
-0.048790548,
0.0200925656,
0.0289776362,
-0.0274604037,
-0.0047857221,
-0.0135341426,
0.0130366432,
-0.0881180316,
0.0661676601,
-0.0243350733,
0.0111381514,
0.0032925166,
0.0388860106,
-0.0359713845,
0.0273323413,
0.0154560059,
-0.0512451828,
0.0149369808,
-0.0198549218,
-0.0300590862,
-0.0345500037,
0.0491461754,
-0.0434382446,
0.0687939525,
-0.0078924224,
-0.0232470445,
-0.0201442633,
0.0020925074,
0.032245256,
0.0357257165,
0.0242537931,
-0.0086026015,
0.0352475196,
-0.0065277657,
0.0142016038,
-0.028194977,
-0.0321391523,
0.0143211838,
-0.0101475744,
0.0307855513,
0.0010193996,
0.0039274534,
-0.0231129956,
0.0512857847,
0.0006409861,
0.0373327732,
0.0502527803,
-0.0489783995,
-0.0432079099,
-0.0395939499,
0.0311705172,
0.0019367888,
-0.0399711505,
-0.0382318646,
0.0115650985,
-0.0311004836,
0.01823554,
0.0741486847,
0.0523303747,
-0.0221248977,
0.0303309113,
-0.0004594185,
-0.0217607189,
0.0002338487,
0.0664019734,
0.0010446535,
-0.076469399,
-0.0252394993,
0.014600263,
0.0157255922,
-0.071164377,
-0.0024173274,
-0.0059410394,
0.0151376799,
-0.0240667313,
-0.0080833761,
-0.1128418893,
0.0315198265,
0.0133490199,
0.0513994545,
-0.0548980087,
-0.0270274356,
0.0467083082,
-0.0730641559,
0.1055613309,
0.0120158447,
-0.0486889109,
0.0053037154,
-0.0233830642,
0.0361646675,
-0.0478742868,
-0.0200636704,
-0.0174653251,
0.0147600006,
0.028241666,
0.0094989315,
-0.003320876,
0.016194351,
0.0098425103,
0.0101440605,
-0.0122706499,
0.1155938581,
0.0381561108,
-0.0624875613,
-0.0598549619,
0.0309613664,
-0.0003566023,
-0.0242747255,
0.0083651245,
0.0422005728,
0.0427464694,
0.0199257303,
-0.036134664,
0.0079862662,
-0.0242800731,
0.0176853891,
0.0284449887,
0.0714374781,
-0.0248993319,
0.0006869655,
0.0194690842,
-0.0618794337,
-0.0301498361,
0.0103645129,
-0.0158789661,
0.0293832868,
-0.043895252,
-0.0793662295,
-0.0010915559,
-0.0537212081,
0.0095949695,
-0.0330498368,
0.0571104437,
-0.0303580295,
-0.0121327704,
-0.1034919471,
-0.015563881,
0.0376465879,
-0.0076487488,
-0.050276041,
0.0203439891,
0.0260239393,
-0.0016497162,
-0.0080447756,
-0.0694112778,
0.0305786319,
-0.0149858054,
-0.0022741533,
-0.0360508151,
0.0492339619,
-0.0284643155,
0.0049983338,
-0.0588793531,
-0.0336576961,
0.0049894052,
0.0278567243,
0.0427532755,
0.0077301618,
-0.0270369835,
0.0923933163,
-0.0263324007,
0.0251241922,
-0.010439354,
0.0363579951,
0.0371030755,
-0.0488178991,
0.0139039764,
-0.0140004931,
-0.0061163688,
-0.0062399562,
-0.0020279039,
0.0118668247,
0.0278551672,
-0.0054372926,
-0.0017910851,
0.0371806286,
0.0645908788,
-0.0041467589,
-0.0022639299,
0.0239677764,
0.018912809,
-0.0213712994,
0.0213754717,
-0.0325261503,
-0.032758452,
0.0486458763,
0.0169875864,
-0.0187440161,
0.0379084013,
0.0456436425,
-0.0311059263,
-0.0363421701,
-0.0067937374,
0.0097825872,
0.0818705782,
-0.0045954208,
-0.0261626951,
-0.0083280923,
-0.01807235,
-0.014247559,
0.0026225192,
-0.0030610696,
0.0617382601,
0.0023709144,
0.0408978686,
0.0535233431,
-0.0060131503,
-0.0171163026,
-0.07110551,
-0.0067232624,
0.0392315388,
0.0610441566,
0.0279496964,
-0.0030174782,
-0.1018565968,
0.0098006576,
0.0170108657,
-0.0019775629,
-0.0134243323,
-0.028046323,
-0.0336728841,
-0.018167384,
-0.0198868718,
-0.0005034928,
0.0503142551,
-0.0195554346,
0.049014274,
-0.0232553724,
-0.0058632544,
-0.0049857418,
-0.0612298548,
0.0152553571,
-0.0038903253,
-0.0222180635,
-0.0619313903,
-0.0229535066,
-0.0142448489,
-0.0601780973,
0.0342358276,
0.0336471386,
-0.0185270123,
0.0015300818,
-0.0007534255,
-0.0327425376,
-0.0410679765,
-0.0000372488,
0.0101941423,
-0.0926955938,
0.0149285309,
0.0030695114,
-5.548742922e-33,
-0.0381062925,
0.0175038595,
-0.0051899576,
0.0396999791,
0.0086092865,
0.008594647,
-0.0028527286,
-0.0509188585,
0.0216032993,
-0.0241695065,
0.011296466,
0.0344561748,
0.0250422508,
0.0088184988,
0.0483231843,
-0.0207783841,
-0.0123188421,
-0.0097506819,
-0.0241491497,
0.0172281917,
-0.0309590828,
-0.0034406246,
0.0146961007,
0.0031996157,
0.0638920367,
0.0435086042,
-0.0583861955,
-0.0563130826,
-0.0744565502,
0.0322279446,
-0.0035230673,
0.0297779348,
-0.0434122048,
-0.0072632181,
0.0005151599,
-0.0102883773,
-0.000930667,
-0.0207734257,
0.0014134612,
0.0090313302,
-0.0549519025,
-0.0298182815,
-0.0124328882,
0.0248763952,
-0.0404295921,
-0.0063933511,
-0.0060781613,
-0.0320133492,
-0.0019831015,
0.0123818051,
-0.0654825792,
0.0217807386,
0.0203383882,
0.0324538015,
0.0199913159,
-0.0195051003,
-0.0315221138,
0.0090997182,
-0.0417206995,
0.0212415494,
0.0053382963,
-0.0321056806,
0.0002974108,
-0.0706037059,
0.0140119325,
-0.0408450961,
0.0336358622,
0.0113924984,
-0.0976751521,
-0.0161264297,
0.0146568883,
0.0307694264,
0.050688982,
-0.0030577381,
0.0631446466,
0.0126382187,
-0.0152332708,
0.0526933335,
0.0169260781,
-0.007288842,
0.0198158585,
-0.0151836434,
-0.043339543,
0.0134034967,
0.0159409679,
-0.051735457,
-0.0166235454,
-0.0159672536,
0.0421218425,
-0.0121440217,
0.0788069889,
0.0804237574,
-0.0250302777,
-0.0401870161,
0.0169361457,
-0.0300027877,
0.005307564,
0.0608845614,
-0.0215483792,
0.0043131597,
-0.0583937615,
-0.0004752087,
-0.0092745563,
-0.0128321545,
0.0481903255,
0.0239744503,
0.01131834,
0.0359752364,
-0.0465650745,
0.0254203789,
-0.0078531783,
0.0194463879,
0.0478817411,
0.011973436,
0.0245286711,
0.0060136556,
0.054978177,
-0.0408318974,
-0.0255867299,
-0.0165006705,
-0.0829024091,
0.0201691315,
-0.0541843064,
-0.008750665,
0.0035275307,
-0.0159153976,
0.0308038704,
-0.0105700493,
-0.0136997784,
-0.0332039855,
-0.0060146064,
0.0089559518,
2.452e-7,
0.0270303469,
0.0677435398,
0.0103701716,
-0.0186535809,
-0.0220105983,
0.0145809092,
-0.0596778989,
0.0522702262,
0.0006178964,
0.0464214385,
0.0131871225,
-0.0656536296,
0.0601963364,
0.0237972643,
-0.0001256683,
-0.0379618369,
0.0011942282,
0.0163882077,
-0.0478799455,
0.0337478705,
0.0052402951,
0.0488377921,
0.0784736201,
-0.0090846568,
0.0370275564,
0.0104642091,
0.0510615595,
-0.0130572738,
0.0136030372,
-0.0423608422,
0.01949347,
-0.013989903,
-0.0263482668,
0.0306297839,
-0.0072832908,
-0.0142323729,
-0.0225877091,
0.0978564993,
-0.0084013073,
0.042420119,
-0.0486096516,
-0.0462654047,
0.0180817023,
-0.0932696238,
-0.0201940853,
0.0231812019,
0.0167949032,
0.0401944369,
0.0282515381,
-0.0145526053,
0.0467377231,
0.030141959,
0.0768158138,
-0.0172057394,
-0.0163887646,
0.0014804323,
-0.0199564975,
-0.0279074702,
0.0133991698,
0.0429890715,
-0.0505300015,
-0.0229529273,
-0.0090304874,
0.0230598133,
0.0783232227,
-0.0424267426,
-0.0186415967,
2.117410398e-34,
-0.0325810052,
-0.0058058714,
0.0007977309,
-0.0318861417,
0.0133320251,
0.0328962281,
0.0505026206,
0.0282316115,
-0.0410260931,
0.0087990174,
-0.0388003066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08730v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08730v3 | MusiLingo: Bridging Music and Text with Pre-trained Language Models for Music Captioning and Query Response | 2023-09-15T19:31:40 | 2024-04-02T13:35:59 | Zihao Deng, Yinghao Ma, Yudong Liu, Rongchen Guo, Ge Zhang, Wenhu Chen, Wenhao Huang, Emmanouil Benetos | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM, cs.SD | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown immense potential in multimodal
applications, yet the convergence of textual and musical domains remains not
well-explored. To address this gap, we present MusiLingo, a novel system for
music caption generation and music-related query responses. MusiLingo employs a
single projection layer to align music representations from the pre-trained
frozen music audio model MERT with a frozen LLM, bridging the gap between music
audio and textual contexts. We train it on an extensive music caption dataset
and fine-tune it with instructional data. Due to the scarcity of high-quality
music Q&A datasets, we created the MusicInstruct (MI) dataset from captions in
the MusicCaps datasets, tailored for open-ended music inquiries. Empirical
evaluations demonstrate its competitive performance in generating music
captions and composing music-related Q&A pairs. Our introduced dataset enables
notable advancements beyond previous ones. | [
0.017770309,
0.0645040423,
-0.0086357342,
0.0623407997,
0.0185099673,
-0.0128340516,
0.0091517679,
-0.0261690393,
-0.0415894724,
-0.0048764357,
-0.0682638288,
-0.0197551996,
0.0006281004,
0.0148778427,
0.0326548517,
-0.0807675943,
0.0100137414,
-0.0521264859,
-0.007149477,
0.0062829163,
-0.0041645612,
0.0203213431,
-0.0153476214,
0.0533808842,
-0.0259710252,
-0.0177932438,
-0.0379258879,
0.0464377701,
-0.0255121216,
-0.0328092761,
-0.036053624,
0.0607416108,
0.0411462635,
0.0368728898,
0.0000014733,
0.0027352325,
0.0030770989,
-0.0218185373,
0.0562994182,
-0.0097750351,
0.0238457583,
-0.0005916753,
0.0046204166,
0.031398721,
-0.0380219743,
-0.0155487731,
0.0486473814,
0.0149681102,
0.0783893764,
0.0717926472,
-0.009588006,
-0.0575649329,
0.0037002985,
-0.0403925925,
0.0007371337,
-0.0169038568,
-0.0126879169,
0.0358930342,
0.0369634554,
0.017626524,
-0.0192169882,
0.090602994,
0.0063446751,
-0.0149288913,
0.0146729164,
0.0629806444,
-0.0509149097,
-0.029517604,
-0.0099569596,
0.1007485464,
0.0529154427,
-0.0029749975,
-0.0158814043,
0.0237721913,
0.0050458014,
-0.0386387147,
-0.0723506436,
0.018069027,
0.041604612,
0.0012265726,
-0.0505729876,
-0.0166036393,
0.0498949103,
0.0026444241,
0.0299850963,
-0.0031374393,
0.0271487646,
-0.0396706462,
0.016999403,
-0.025319742,
-0.0334540606,
-0.0699065924,
0.0017298724,
0.019910669,
-0.0255610626,
0.0105203521,
-0.0584994145,
-0.0313674286,
-0.0078748493,
0.0084613375,
0.0391889624,
-0.0103716822,
-0.0258043464,
0.0680337399,
0.0101225795,
0.0060312273,
-0.03719908,
0.0223092809,
-0.0437634587,
-0.0204816982,
-0.0209275801,
-0.0542914905,
-0.0598217845,
-0.0055838837,
-0.0006616993,
-0.0556247272,
-0.0030793922,
-0.0076527051,
-0.0085924184,
0.0131643666,
0.0011336742,
-0.0002429045,
-0.0086180624,
-0.0113848979,
0.0217561293,
0.0419610776,
-0.0088859238,
0.0421696194,
0.0106323482,
-0.0002067107,
-0.0133926971,
0.0308265891,
0.0272435527,
-0.0083135683,
0.0299478602,
0.048516605,
0.0138199367,
-0.0456004255,
0.0200526286,
-0.0331160203,
-0.0565355308,
-0.0508006476,
-0.0142724672,
-0.0447144285,
0.049716834,
-0.0162240267,
-0.0135044185,
-0.0377012044,
0.0083364081,
0.0428156145,
-0.0085349577,
0.094757989,
0.0201601647,
0.0398344286,
0.008949385,
0.0107484069,
0.0019268228,
0.0571687631,
0.0698422268,
0.0230200905,
0.0667684898,
-0.0318551548,
0.0039682356,
0.0546487272,
0.0343035646,
-0.0051135817,
-0.0625036433,
0.0108020399,
0.0087474873,
0.069432281,
0.0212251358,
0.0564610809,
0.0309430677,
-0.0081252437,
0.0723508522,
0.0371085107,
0.001984606,
0.0406445675,
0.0059511755,
0.0034708816,
0.0001883934,
-0.0240127612,
-0.0164850168,
0.0879251361,
0.0351880826,
0.0151185608,
0.0815454796,
0.0097059216,
-0.0193146784,
0.0078710448,
-0.0258179959,
-0.0218793545,
-0.0301949512,
-0.0005873608,
-0.009843627,
0.0107229799,
-0.0470137484,
0.0627442673,
-0.0205448456,
-0.069567211,
0.025134841,
-0.0277666692,
0.0075666667,
0.0633372664,
0.05248864,
-0.0595312528,
0.0050461967,
-0.028496217,
0.032502912,
0.0753171965,
0.0352403633,
-0.0238053501,
0.0208538417,
0.0073042717,
-0.0231791958,
-0.0308483113,
-0.0206069648,
0.0060418127,
-0.0377080142,
0.0144736357,
0.0344198793,
-0.0386404283,
-0.0089168428,
0.0189068299,
0.0168456584,
-0.0514573716,
0.0236703958,
0.0221470483,
-0.002979019,
0.0455186702,
-0.0225030612,
0.043119967,
0.0357938558,
-0.0014914556,
0.0124562429,
0.0366798788,
-0.0557032228,
-0.0304377154,
0.0555217564,
-0.0473874137,
0.0109354062,
0.0137135051,
-0.0109879998,
-0.05798278,
0.0430117697,
-0.0101730777,
0.0095450645,
-0.0140333371,
-0.0007569445,
-0.0084034232,
0.0036100505,
0.0041902843,
0.009607695,
0.0467686132,
-0.0001668222,
0.0318273008,
-0.0449327379,
0.0259870198,
-0.0284686144,
-0.0463777147,
0.0796029717,
0.0293487497,
0.0285037514,
-0.0115983365,
0.0002839187,
-0.044917278,
-0.0318669304,
-0.0820657313,
0.0436993986,
-0.0304096378,
-0.0193738714,
0.0406685024,
0.0098308576,
-0.0057955198,
-0.0296604577,
-0.0524479486,
-0.0373806171,
0.0323835798,
0.0235192645,
-0.0094761113,
0.0191798583,
-0.0226921011,
-0.0333868861,
-0.0077997963,
0.0068182857,
0.0014847491,
-0.0201178975,
0.02231583,
0.0040981066,
-0.0258903969,
-0.0733071193,
-0.0105812084,
0.0081367558,
-0.0032821058,
0.0150894597,
-0.055177398,
0.0371390767,
0.0324869528,
0.0071070171,
0.0019450281,
0.0816574469,
-0.0010728128,
0.0162049644,
0.0206094701,
-0.011044234,
-0.014848738,
-0.0064443983,
0.0055250372,
-0.0032109458,
0.0189532861,
0.0514799878,
0.0162788499,
-0.0122492285,
0.0315337591,
-0.014761148,
0.0073046503,
-0.0694628283,
0.0219280273,
-0.0472974703,
0.0207162257,
-0.0242287461,
-0.0035189816,
0.0370064229,
-0.0371714793,
-0.034367457,
-0.0239619222,
-0.0296161864,
-0.0511317551,
0.082375668,
-0.0316182189,
0.0270518921,
-0.0185683221,
-0.0463691279,
-0.0210844968,
0.0296119004,
0.0107350582,
-0.0600783974,
0.0271243621,
-0.0125897797,
0.0012765389,
-0.0003434388,
-0.0341430157,
-0.0089159356,
-0.0362316333,
-0.0233490709,
-0.0082868254,
-0.0378996879,
-0.0136741549,
-0.0089521557,
-0.0031955899,
0.0395159423,
0.0442948528,
-0.0303718373,
0.0114854462,
-0.0314548425,
0.0539598763,
0.0304636657,
0.0377226211,
-0.0526717752,
-0.0316970535,
0.0471817628,
-0.015673589,
0.0235700309,
-0.0190866571,
-0.0217691865,
-0.0035888394,
0.027382521,
0.0139694223,
-0.0019270345,
0.0374096781,
0.0245766416,
-0.0213979259,
0.0023961321,
0.1098344848,
0.0471076146,
-0.0290309303,
-0.0074262954,
0.0539520048,
0.0536124706,
0.030553475,
-0.0206607189,
-0.0414935909,
-0.0437290706,
0.0026667383,
0.0485455915,
0.0817986503,
0.0312411748,
-0.0387273692,
-0.0601001456,
0.0250499174,
0.010902402,
-0.0625727698,
-0.0443215445,
-0.0202266853,
-0.019454034,
0.0123798251,
0.0225890335,
0.0048609944,
-0.0410774872,
0.0313468874,
-0.0028154829,
0.0173239186,
-0.0453175791,
-0.0024181763,
-0.0591237433,
0.0221734922,
0.0754131377,
0.0663348213,
-0.0290273689,
-0.0356634632,
-0.0101070842,
0.0150868474,
-0.0316299498,
0.0229458865,
0.0485755913,
0.0110342326,
-0.0101889186,
0.0208212417,
0.0319598764,
-0.0360146798,
-0.0085001383,
0.0356401689,
0.0582092963,
-0.0011545938,
0.0130037358,
-0.0165474899,
0.0471650697,
0.0048653828,
0.0903046578,
0.0425981395,
-0.0164896827,
0.0185723752,
-0.0000312903,
0.0072164088,
-0.0868207589,
-0.0177969821,
0.0189184453,
-0.0039487546,
0.0145407878,
-0.0317773707,
-0.00265882,
0.030432038,
-0.0022073472,
0.0379298367,
0.0158601291,
-0.020796312,
-0.0179129615,
-0.0886564553,
0.0372872092,
-0.0231702216,
0.0388408788,
-0.0475831591,
-0.073691994,
0.0278499126,
-0.0464923792,
-0.0137114143,
-0.0024071087,
-0.0822489485,
-0.0405873954,
-0.0415736735,
0.0084780473,
0.017187966,
0.0260806046,
0.0138768498,
-0.0318843089,
-0.0183911137,
0.0409330539,
-0.0010394405,
0.0180557482,
0.0105116917,
-0.0329209007,
0.0071441145,
0.0187227689,
-0.0716130883,
0.010272624,
-0.0019694068,
0.0491069928,
0.0649067685,
-0.0683211461,
0.0234364495,
-0.0139758866,
0.0204897281,
-0.0206800252,
0.0229737088,
-0.0517380163,
-0.0147140492,
-0.0341137759,
-0.0152041558,
-0.0383531712,
0.0172422025,
0.0451296382,
0.0498259068,
-0.0365417376,
-0.0200070087,
-0.0049755457,
-0.0187799633,
-0.0464089736,
0.0288892314,
0.0586815178,
-0.0877101123,
0.0259524696,
-0.0034861981,
0.0176692232,
0.0435419567,
0.0332559198,
-0.0120542785,
0.0049588429,
0.0183529854,
0.0166856106,
-0.0310641676,
-0.0229559317,
0.0468339697,
-0.0607101843,
-0.0536241829,
-0.0289206114,
0.0082391175,
0.0671526864,
0.0035382174,
0.0148656536,
0.0159118287,
-0.0145542575,
0.009710798,
0.0799277574,
-0.0145663554,
-0.0717191771,
0.051478412,
0.0139720673,
-0.0065894774,
0.0141171869,
0.0650363863,
-0.0192564074,
-0.0010773093,
0.0136127751,
-0.0178690702,
-0.0038809169,
0.0105599556,
-0.0183584392,
-0.0054602739,
-0.0288209002,
0.0347695649,
-0.0147260353,
-0.0712921619,
-0.0034313747,
-0.0037169179,
-0.0126966406,
-0.0057931398,
0.0334697068,
0.0492893457,
0.0083797053,
0.0011665613,
-0.0051920069,
-0.0062215375,
-0.0426111072,
-0.0268485397,
-0.019980466,
-5.049837038e-33,
-0.0459488668,
-0.0137759456,
-0.0185805392,
-0.0055112806,
-0.0606559813,
-0.008972005,
-0.0667501315,
0.0206121299,
0.0226629935,
-0.0251076911,
0.0113083404,
0.0235831514,
-0.0079490496,
0.0382783264,
0.0119288554,
-0.0330504999,
0.0735898614,
-0.0285801999,
-0.0155264046,
0.0425943024,
0.0228199027,
0.0249004774,
-0.0064734281,
-0.0413984694,
0.0130955102,
-0.0404512547,
-0.0139941545,
0.0188882444,
0.0157218743,
0.061273288,
-0.0357293263,
0.0305016488,
-0.0013708076,
-0.0069712317,
-0.0233626422,
0.0356349349,
-0.0483397804,
-0.0009043042,
0.0023144383,
0.0465459116,
0.0060789962,
-0.0068427883,
0.0418975204,
-0.0202828012,
-0.0154912947,
0.0080058128,
0.0582822412,
-0.0080022514,
0.0047557731,
-0.0327791125,
-0.0375525281,
-0.0249967966,
-0.0478107445,
-0.04556394,
0.0474196188,
0.0392844453,
0.0171201415,
0.0646509156,
-0.0288505368,
0.0314711258,
0.0123119671,
0.0186214317,
0.062539421,
0.042609904,
-0.018784808,
0.0566889457,
-0.0189168025,
-0.0601721369,
-0.033271417,
0.032310158,
0.003632575,
0.0566662289,
0.0170390885,
0.0170517322,
0.0379797928,
-0.0124063687,
0.0020465928,
0.0152119109,
-0.0499989279,
-0.0353647918,
0.0020427133,
0.0367620997,
-0.0034474642,
0.024931062,
-0.0563978106,
-0.0258559808,
-0.0495035909,
-0.0232628994,
0.0519175567,
-0.0093457727,
-0.0022757992,
-0.0260253195,
0.0124700442,
-0.0375741608,
-0.0272429027,
-0.0024573668,
-0.0557333417,
0.0043459781,
-0.0217995532,
0.0037372368,
-0.0213051904,
-0.0067474442,
0.0830285177,
-0.0224408936,
0.0276729576,
-0.0036716007,
0.0130311549,
0.0715611875,
-0.0608523525,
0.0042488878,
-0.0120689459,
-0.0341884904,
-0.0119880103,
0.0245489478,
0.0297122058,
0.0295621678,
-0.0422426425,
0.0197841339,
0.0112791955,
0.029013209,
-0.0538421795,
-0.0899436399,
-0.0129645225,
0.0407561995,
0.0023955661,
0.0084814681,
-0.0270077828,
-0.029380111,
0.0087243579,
-0.0888563395,
-0.0465453714,
-0.004005759,
2.343e-7,
0.0375922136,
0.0069238055,
-0.0085566128,
0.0223943032,
0.0360362642,
0.0228345729,
-0.1084217429,
0.0277143102,
0.0008147328,
-0.0021487083,
0.0594246462,
0.0031386337,
0.0682482794,
0.0288014282,
-0.1177528426,
-0.0073059569,
-0.0930348635,
0.0131054558,
-0.0824917853,
-0.0377046503,
0.0761021376,
0.1004408747,
0.0254857,
-0.0161185581,
-0.031799458,
-0.0570755489,
0.0580079257,
-0.0259858165,
0.0162013024,
-0.0473990068,
0.0265852995,
0.0223502833,
-0.0308510344,
-0.0254743397,
-0.0519064628,
0.0423050299,
0.0846944526,
0.0266681593,
0.0236203317,
-0.0468519405,
-0.0122978929,
0.0575609282,
0.0122157559,
-0.0377869941,
0.0617128834,
-0.0076524168,
-0.0267106704,
-0.0286671203,
-0.0255560987,
-0.0002803523,
0.0182716995,
-0.0428439789,
-0.0464668497,
-0.0245562065,
0.0400807373,
-0.022051964,
0.0119200218,
-0.0561200976,
-0.0182389393,
-0.0004830965,
-0.0527963154,
-0.0046386877,
-0.0517466441,
-0.0276586581,
-0.009429005,
-0.0289041568,
-0.0019369471,
1.918519738e-34,
0.0501935557,
-0.0634922385,
0.0050030174,
0.0018287925,
0.0114761163,
-0.014030884,
0.0280607138,
-0.0175228603,
-0.016661454,
-0.0735395625,
-0.0277129319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08714v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08714v1 | Generating Semantic Graph Corpora with Graph Expansion Grammar | 2023-09-15T19:10:19 | 2023-09-15T19:10:19 | Eric Andersson, Johanna Björklund, Frank Drewes, Anna Jonsson | cs.FL | cs.FL, cs.CL, F.4.3; I.2.7 | We introduce Lovelace, a tool for creating corpora of semantic graphs. The
system uses graph expansion grammar as a representational language, thus
allowing users to craft a grammar that describes a corpus with desired
properties. When given such grammar as input, the system generates a set of
output graphs that are well-formed according to the grammar, i.e., a graph
bank. The generation process can be controlled via a number of configurable
parameters that allow the user to, for example, specify a range of desired
output graph sizes. Central use cases are the creation of synthetic data to
augment existing corpora, and as a pedagogical tool for teaching formal
language theory. | [
0.0144340498,
-0.0284347441,
-0.0366352983,
0.044174023,
-0.0094211278,
-0.0094436742,
-0.0418674275,
0.0068333317,
0.0357901156,
-0.0272349641,
0.043402493,
0.0076437891,
-0.0146226212,
0.0771724954,
0.0228237752,
-0.063463375,
0.0388161168,
0.0237660613,
-0.0055678808,
-0.00129288,
0.0350603759,
0.0402162001,
0.0240336712,
-0.0082682325,
-0.0535015613,
0.0440993309,
-0.0151113411,
0.0308924597,
-0.0300731994,
-0.0415801592,
-0.0547351763,
0.0124352099,
0.0084237838,
0.0358659513,
0.0000016213,
-0.0456268676,
-0.0223220568,
0.0337770171,
-0.0350527242,
-0.0332230777,
0.0543599799,
-0.0176330432,
0.0334793963,
-0.0020094668,
-0.0441372991,
-0.0639769286,
0.0746382922,
-0.03928883,
0.0697923154,
0.0931855738,
-0.0379858725,
-0.0357134826,
-0.0289144553,
0.0100721354,
-0.02517993,
0.0135074928,
-0.0028486929,
0.0294134524,
0.0632724017,
-0.0348169394,
-0.0473147631,
-0.0118023185,
-0.0008839819,
-0.047300417,
0.0967109129,
-0.0057653524,
-0.0008411699,
-0.0413546525,
-0.0023031698,
0.0686058253,
0.0638759136,
-0.0426437669,
0.0326590985,
0.0151205044,
0.0049831378,
0.0643189028,
-0.0515701994,
-0.0041017514,
-0.020211149,
0.0394160077,
-0.0106350454,
-0.0595111959,
0.04722137,
-0.0392378271,
-0.003372574,
0.0550844111,
-0.0071975286,
-0.0052582435,
0.0278618168,
0.0073582074,
-0.0003050799,
-0.0339324847,
0.0206943396,
0.0264202859,
-0.03159355,
0.0296035353,
-0.0446455218,
-0.032354679,
0.0191496853,
0.0117656672,
0.0334324054,
-0.0270098057,
0.0604969151,
0.0046100295,
0.0054686372,
-0.0002862657,
-0.0097986683,
0.0577405058,
-0.0477488078,
-0.0137443151,
-0.0654358491,
0.0184122473,
-0.0719265789,
0.0382894687,
-0.0252777506,
-0.0335547179,
-0.0462999865,
0.0714095384,
-0.012815713,
0.0214532595,
0.0333722867,
-0.0033160697,
0.0210825987,
0.008963909,
-0.023343036,
0.0048151906,
-0.0103042275,
-0.0381243266,
-0.0191096477,
-0.0326820537,
-0.0006014628,
0.0388660468,
0.0445950031,
0.0093012955,
-0.032447651,
0.0915824473,
0.0479978137,
0.0130781382,
0.0070262798,
-0.0320769735,
0.0157031734,
-0.0001776193,
0.0491714291,
-0.0856756121,
0.0069093597,
0.0375008397,
0.0093560461,
-0.0452757105,
-0.003831283,
0.0010374567,
-0.0132593028,
0.0268688817,
-0.1295756251,
-0.0112658702,
-0.0020210189,
-0.0638668016,
0.0194976684,
0.0166333858,
0.0420223251,
-0.0045297141,
0.0441141166,
-0.0235093869,
-0.0226968545,
0.0025233012,
0.0000100201,
-0.0008061393,
-0.0245772265,
0.0008853936,
-0.0405002758,
0.0343830548,
-0.0279322211,
0.0875169933,
-0.0215308908,
-0.0198500101,
-0.0394994356,
0.0474709868,
0.0463864803,
-0.0170673821,
0.0930445343,
0.0214638785,
-0.0182566978,
-0.0154188881,
-0.0355484821,
-0.0239456668,
0.0128820911,
0.0124989534,
-0.0725219622,
-0.0395191684,
0.0586599447,
-0.0217030831,
-0.0253547616,
-0.0268170219,
0.0816635713,
-0.0421205722,
0.0495243967,
0.0359198898,
-0.0129513461,
0.0148699787,
0.0442362987,
-0.0606729947,
0.0243138801,
0.0130227124,
0.0253824424,
0.0952893868,
0.0367293768,
-0.0011495065,
-0.0149885342,
0.02865538,
-0.0426999256,
0.0411419161,
0.0380568393,
-0.0477302931,
-0.0439538732,
-0.0456079729,
-0.0101806344,
-0.0146041745,
-0.0071289497,
0.0193566345,
-0.0049665715,
-0.0163116232,
0.0147100082,
-0.0741201937,
-0.0469728597,
-0.0056175431,
0.0380567685,
0.0275094286,
-0.0420216583,
-0.0237567481,
0.000756945,
0.0408412255,
-0.020913044,
0.0455573462,
0.0237633083,
0.0238816217,
0.0032282493,
0.0254372656,
0.0013023503,
-0.0139201153,
0.0403377414,
-0.0688690618,
-0.0350231938,
-0.0278680399,
-0.0187338088,
-0.0337711312,
0.0592385232,
-0.0668355525,
0.0725332052,
0.0008321926,
-0.0204644687,
-0.0027578739,
0.0024356684,
-0.0111346962,
0.0323754773,
0.0561150536,
0.0078141261,
-0.0229334198,
0.0310029704,
0.0165943168,
-0.0373607539,
0.0276437011,
0.0227246191,
0.0304751005,
0.0164701678,
0.052624248,
-0.0157999676,
-0.0416282825,
0.044180993,
-0.061394576,
-0.0171370432,
-0.0140988575,
0.0351805128,
0.0390816554,
0.0095192743,
-0.0102800997,
-0.0323410258,
-0.02351222,
0.1040590554,
0.0138098691,
-0.0099639613,
0.0300419517,
-0.0048514125,
-0.0253340676,
-0.0228611436,
-0.0399728417,
-0.0340816341,
0.0661656633,
0.0753366053,
-0.0578322075,
0.0203178972,
0.0151907522,
-0.0333322249,
0.0166512653,
0.0324599035,
0.0047186329,
0.0003442168,
-0.0468727872,
-0.0022558211,
-0.0240954794,
-0.0289869998,
0.0778485686,
0.0443940237,
-0.0155982375,
0.0065572704,
-0.016224768,
-0.0466261171,
0.0314357281,
-0.0758372471,
-0.0502381735,
0.0194309559,
0.002462154,
0.0291550942,
-0.003154028,
-0.0226255096,
-0.0235795546,
-0.0192028619,
0.0009146163,
0.0053674602,
-0.0305328891,
-0.0070691016,
0.0032217125,
-0.0095150331,
-0.0259148981,
0.0650684685,
-0.024020683,
-0.01115999,
0.0169024114,
-0.0191057026,
-0.0520213358,
0.0586032905,
0.0705028921,
0.0208347645,
0.0126034273,
-0.0381393917,
-0.0050053247,
0.0176760554,
0.078952767,
-0.0053477841,
-0.0258895531,
-0.0160790682,
0.0329797491,
0.0158653297,
0.0332094431,
-0.0121557228,
0.0286399685,
-0.0292905066,
-0.0009310204,
0.014840371,
-0.0415970422,
0.0183572154,
-0.0231329743,
-0.0261141621,
-0.0102192145,
0.0167994145,
-0.0033101987,
-0.016677605,
0.0350194797,
0.0212479476,
0.0062892023,
-0.0330308974,
-0.0100061279,
-0.0292549673,
0.0392751619,
-0.0370584838,
0.0038725459,
-0.0445548482,
0.0051288074,
-0.0007233956,
-0.015847424,
-0.0542904399,
-0.0081002684,
-0.0147577766,
-0.0255253632,
0.0080642616,
0.0693488494,
0.0364963934,
-0.0168768484,
0.0282918438,
0.0258277897,
0.0482892133,
0.0419378728,
0.0013716873,
-0.1107367203,
-0.0037206465,
-0.0330720469,
0.029102331,
-0.0100082774,
-0.0465454683,
-0.0230948199,
-0.0974451751,
0.00728813,
0.0338983238,
0.0067731906,
0.0270454958,
-0.0836430863,
-0.0221309718,
0.0079717133,
-0.049021814,
0.0023849469,
-0.0411877632,
0.0246138107,
0.0310506541,
-0.0111609418,
-0.0143044684,
-0.0253251698,
0.0041949623,
0.0058058435,
0.000627738,
0.0229765624,
-0.0117841037,
0.0157929901,
0.0118783955,
0.0404536054,
0.0101008723,
-0.0362232961,
0.0344448835,
0.018772848,
-0.0165576246,
-0.0451104194,
0.0018870744,
-0.0233633593,
-0.0002680308,
-0.0273930933,
0.0778985173,
0.0035441583,
-0.0251970049,
-0.029697137,
-0.0245392229,
-0.0039517237,
-0.0195895713,
0.044778645,
0.0529517122,
-0.0293580834,
-0.081290409,
0.0054409942,
-0.0679943934,
-0.0423810035,
0.0311638787,
-0.0517482832,
-0.0485448055,
-0.0468344875,
-0.0369481035,
0.0254938994,
0.0244795401,
-0.0041689682,
-0.0418354906,
0.0461038202,
-0.0144250765,
-0.0829526782,
0.0037528127,
-0.0027110691,
0.0064816345,
-0.0153148733,
-0.0653614923,
-0.0131760649,
0.0573142134,
0.0027197199,
0.0261531807,
-0.0283135083,
-0.0750428811,
0.0024267982,
-0.0078473939,
0.0180862788,
0.0160755422,
-0.007399559,
-0.0002886413,
0.0253500938,
0.0521420538,
-0.0385142528,
-0.0183505677,
0.0108680865,
-0.0526718497,
0.008141431,
0.0004127343,
-0.0310094692,
0.0161724687,
-0.0152298855,
0.0282836482,
-0.0310745072,
0.0274285506,
0.0543229282,
0.1184229329,
-0.0114312982,
0.0042336094,
0.0257091839,
-0.0151414806,
-0.0438220799,
-0.0611968376,
-0.0298974477,
-0.0122597488,
-0.0000825353,
0.0005297723,
-0.0255480856,
0.0386022814,
-0.0485769957,
-0.0190519635,
0.0360699855,
-0.0135934474,
0.0261550583,
0.037201602,
-0.0280796904,
0.0525627509,
0.010684941,
0.0009292699,
0.0046919379,
0.008413692,
-0.0014687661,
-0.0237642638,
-0.0352613591,
0.0334020555,
-0.0311126187,
-0.0391441509,
-0.0042378395,
-0.003332546,
0.0169195216,
0.0148422038,
0.0401794873,
0.0377313159,
0.0386769958,
0.0711329654,
-0.0480462797,
0.0130093861,
-0.0106778732,
0.0575570017,
-0.0065540047,
-0.0868401825,
0.0210375823,
0.0045509432,
0.0014474203,
-0.0320248343,
0.0508201234,
0.0170148984,
-0.0110816313,
0.0278370697,
-0.0331980139,
-0.0539020486,
-0.0120854648,
-0.0231379885,
0.0118591096,
0.0258451533,
0.0124251479,
-0.0477238409,
-0.0891329646,
0.0058919685,
0.0414803885,
0.0104211671,
0.0233003851,
0.0669644549,
0.0236488357,
0.0514185056,
0.0069286069,
-0.0237371027,
0.0591583289,
-0.0216267612,
-0.0183536205,
0.0297883041,
-5.429924688e-33,
-0.0199786983,
-0.0637891963,
0.0204011332,
0.0413152054,
-0.0255361982,
-0.0210636836,
-0.0392841883,
0.039897982,
0.0100816563,
0.0355106257,
0.0051767882,
0.0161015,
0.0112143364,
0.0048498139,
-0.0213596988,
0.0032960675,
0.0124074044,
0.0170749146,
-0.014932368,
0.0145666767,
0.0673641339,
0.0058981939,
0.0660649538,
-0.0403526723,
0.0392686166,
-0.0101132318,
0.0118704904,
-0.0060812915,
0.0275859069,
0.02158124,
0.0271393992,
0.1007398069,
0.0001136995,
0.0559218824,
-0.0359921902,
-0.0025005261,
-0.0317698903,
-0.0651227459,
0.0492515974,
0.0306357313,
-0.0523277186,
-0.0198799595,
0.0433824062,
-0.0281436909,
-0.0062098922,
0.0126525816,
0.0345281214,
0.03505731,
-0.0282348301,
0.0416747481,
-0.0236069635,
0.0308156312,
0.0005836747,
0.0402423292,
0.0258561522,
-0.0512996539,
0.0021359329,
-0.0426538512,
0.0038201208,
0.0767109692,
-0.0032894597,
-0.0126634147,
0.0021652696,
-0.0156024154,
0.0199390166,
0.0021040193,
-0.0108767301,
-0.0019257327,
0.0143968724,
0.0815707296,
-0.0134778358,
0.0669908375,
-0.0122046703,
0.0492598191,
0.0069167088,
-0.0347248316,
-0.059719,
-0.0188796334,
-0.0006620446,
0.0153465942,
-0.0635962337,
0.0227931105,
0.016741341,
-0.0787629485,
-0.0113268942,
0.0016687544,
0.013257754,
-0.045081526,
-0.0174653791,
-0.0486692153,
-0.0282621272,
0.0405755602,
-0.0392031744,
-0.0220875032,
-0.0259635802,
0.0426043943,
-0.0054572886,
0.0244271886,
-0.0139668807,
-0.0171018038,
0.0047272099,
-0.0467067845,
-0.0091266064,
-0.0136136236,
0.0358319394,
0.0128233302,
-0.0075439513,
0.0297837891,
-0.0092204874,
-0.0023488938,
-0.0326006785,
-0.0313752145,
-0.0567608178,
-0.0733386055,
0.022855226,
0.0560126677,
-0.0144849988,
0.0001684476,
0.0125380345,
0.0202527735,
-0.0181399416,
0.0381317586,
-0.0093086939,
0.020033123,
-0.041282095,
-0.0287490748,
-0.0434975587,
0.0255238246,
0.0764284357,
-0.0395749584,
0.0004082433,
-0.0340470374,
2.462e-7,
0.0550139658,
0.0515527911,
0.0755866095,
0.0327136256,
0.0188750401,
-0.0263503343,
0.004625944,
0.0542200021,
-0.0134524629,
-0.0348763652,
-0.0144751044,
0.0210192371,
-0.0736685619,
0.048952926,
-0.0409077555,
0.0514777265,
-0.0199040361,
-0.0261894949,
-0.0186350364,
0.0887114331,
0.0353210419,
0.0065308241,
0.054427553,
0.015477214,
-0.0303340163,
-0.0424234606,
0.0230187532,
-0.002506081,
0.0014472782,
0.0190991927,
-0.0095925974,
-0.0287554245,
-0.0037372105,
0.0142766815,
-0.0050779711,
-0.0008779567,
-0.0126477517,
-0.0287931804,
-0.041516602,
0.0552263707,
-0.0068457001,
-0.0967059508,
-0.0018621339,
0.0119475601,
-0.0230096262,
-0.0341417491,
-0.0614258014,
0.027373543,
-0.053782694,
0.0096184751,
-0.0484780148,
0.0021059534,
-0.0343707427,
0.0082475413,
0.0087853558,
-0.0138836438,
0.0065848324,
0.0024150242,
-0.0181460157,
0.0019134692,
-0.0118257822,
-0.0496560149,
0.0004959757,
0.0285731889,
-0.0071934606,
0.0391895063,
0.0390153565,
1.983557637e-34,
0.0268290769,
0.0352301262,
0.0226282123,
-0.0105915563,
0.0139029631,
-0.0586381741,
-0.002533816,
0.0448948927,
0.0269526839,
-0.0611219816,
-0.0353063531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08708v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08708v1 | Frustratingly Simple Memory Efficiency for Pre-trained Language Models via Dynamic Embedding Pruning | 2023-09-15T19:00:00 | 2023-09-15T19:00:00 | Miles Williams, Nikolaos Aletras | cs.CL | cs.CL | The extensive memory footprint of pre-trained language models (PLMs) can
hinder deployment in memory-constrained settings, such as cloud environments or
on-device. PLMs use embedding matrices to represent extensive vocabularies,
forming a large proportion of the model parameters. While previous work towards
parameter-efficient PLM development has considered pruning parameters within
the transformer layers, pruning the embedding matrix as part of fine-tuning or
inference has yet to be explored. We first demonstrate that a significant
proportion of the vocabulary remains unused in these scenarios. We then propose
a simple yet effective approach that leverages this finding to minimize the
memory footprint of the embedding matrix. We show that this approach provides
substantial reductions in memory usage across a wide range of models and tasks.
Notably, our approach maintains equivalent downstream task performance while
allowing a more efficient use of compute resources. | [
0.0346859023,
0.0443358533,
-0.0114697544,
0.0396645889,
0.0145518612,
0.0170327593,
0.0026344166,
-0.0283980016,
-0.021640446,
-0.0264791846,
-0.0077687264,
-0.033335343,
-0.0169436876,
0.0099648247,
0.0011991613,
-0.0250737518,
0.0449398719,
-0.0182199273,
-0.0364808552,
-0.0000514775,
0.002197179,
0.0175716206,
0.0241238438,
0.0173881166,
0.0111471899,
-0.0077720131,
-0.0437650755,
-0.0056891246,
-0.0279348195,
0.0129830847,
-0.0189168155,
0.0470747724,
0.0382697359,
0.0246872399,
0.0000021313,
0.007626133,
-0.0147205815,
-0.0083822347,
-0.0474912859,
0.0571853518,
0.0802566633,
0.0021228723,
0.0094314124,
0.0335356742,
-0.0146955037,
-0.0833601579,
0.0432986431,
-0.011628354,
0.0275341421,
0.0513522923,
-0.0152034564,
0.0079042725,
0.0018715486,
-0.0345563218,
-0.043565236,
-0.0251202285,
-0.0178908687,
-0.0548919775,
-0.0349317975,
-0.0028608937,
-0.0182244591,
0.0424139611,
0.0298345108,
0.0453914925,
-0.0155587764,
0.0450078808,
-0.0187656507,
-0.043506816,
-0.0159039441,
0.0403507836,
-0.0323117152,
-0.0244908929,
0.0108848894,
-0.0169635806,
-0.0274071023,
0.0055347998,
-0.0019600538,
0.0471907631,
0.0340672657,
0.0198567808,
-0.0194444656,
-0.0053112926,
0.0409460925,
0.0062477957,
-0.0451712757,
0.0288466364,
0.0444426462,
0.0074253166,
-0.0305958856,
-0.0107029164,
0.003603887,
-0.040412955,
-0.0058063022,
0.0201029871,
0.022444604,
0.0217404235,
-0.0794583261,
-0.0386563763,
0.0064064628,
-0.0395978726,
0.0875426829,
0.0486148857,
0.0114018274,
0.0472596176,
-0.0166920759,
0.0170655958,
-0.0278837923,
0.0079466132,
-0.0388909392,
-0.006312219,
0.0188366715,
-0.0050283559,
-0.0711675733,
0.0212038569,
-0.0119990427,
-0.0430603959,
-0.006372395,
0.0324731097,
0.0162969176,
-0.00989467,
0.0054175607,
0.0244896077,
-0.0076499665,
0.013897012,
0.0201751646,
0.0236070603,
-0.0205695592,
0.0009255193,
-0.0322791338,
-0.0710498318,
-0.021029735,
0.0274379812,
0.011488759,
-0.0364104323,
0.0335285775,
0.044765655,
0.0172607787,
-0.0925181583,
-0.0157477874,
-0.0022574512,
0.0153490342,
-0.0558105111,
0.0095336586,
-0.0415573157,
0.0413374156,
-0.0121600674,
0.0116544096,
-0.0355916731,
0.0013533343,
0.0474972948,
-0.0670437142,
0.061780531,
0.0019592191,
0.0067428406,
0.0026367269,
0.0101037174,
0.0338331982,
0.057941474,
0.0412581526,
0.017165916,
0.0412518866,
-0.0244096648,
-0.008794439,
0.0298046824,
0.0469368398,
0.0095300581,
-0.0439540446,
-0.0014698958,
0.0114601497,
-0.0085447757,
0.0402532257,
0.0407702886,
-0.0085913017,
-0.0023271244,
0.0506190732,
0.0752621517,
-0.0076649934,
0.0369609669,
0.0478294007,
0.0172941443,
-0.0085490569,
-0.0298026558,
-0.0474409051,
0.0110738361,
-0.0136797689,
-0.0113258725,
0.0317000896,
0.0729588419,
-0.0384669676,
-0.0105468631,
-0.017746048,
-0.0548176989,
0.0289883558,
0.0217582621,
0.0378146097,
-0.0006750625,
-0.0402833149,
0.1458498538,
0.0194368828,
-0.0735036135,
-0.0271037258,
-0.0241603889,
0.0052005299,
0.0408988968,
0.0244662128,
-0.003072991,
-0.0465492532,
0.0359159745,
0.0509199053,
-0.0016048622,
0.0311241448,
0.0146800196,
0.0465273298,
-0.0550992563,
-0.0005086916,
-0.011910704,
0.0207059719,
-0.0170681402,
0.0753708705,
0.0261887927,
0.0555570424,
-0.0272540897,
-0.0124787455,
0.0345045105,
-0.0477874689,
-0.0105286585,
0.0001767957,
0.0028271503,
0.0128685115,
-0.021236755,
-0.0142538892,
-0.0011431222,
0.0589465387,
-0.0150880776,
0.0078530312,
-0.0075720628,
-0.0702714473,
0.0182794221,
0.02847475,
0.0216371808,
0.0621837005,
0.0280507393,
-0.047763247,
-0.0229105968,
0.0305968858,
-0.0334975198,
0.0771326199,
-0.0388968252,
0.0237959381,
-0.0353873484,
0.0624082834,
0.0112048062,
0.0076626809,
-0.0293666478,
0.0185966566,
0.0000229365,
0.0161819458,
0.0045904126,
0.0020399811,
-0.0662937984,
-0.0010073135,
0.0101374025,
0.0132865515,
-0.0125288162,
-0.007464488,
0.0019849259,
0.0047512795,
-0.1013169363,
0.0254718717,
-0.0323109701,
-0.0073390645,
0.0125453658,
0.042195864,
0.0049527264,
-0.0186699145,
0.0230083428,
0.0150255933,
-0.0059133638,
0.0449118912,
-0.0260854978,
-0.0219164416,
-0.0141259804,
-0.0096625509,
-0.0250475705,
0.0217003766,
0.070049718,
-0.0470456667,
0.0021715579,
-0.0131209195,
0.0429309644,
-0.0179367755,
0.0533343107,
-0.0137553038,
-0.0482160784,
-0.0226735789,
-0.0268150289,
0.0566549525,
0.0428978913,
-0.0145274634,
0.0327964313,
0.0782003626,
-0.0252469331,
-0.0356663167,
0.0065277712,
-0.0328988507,
-0.0278980546,
-0.0279069226,
0.00593316,
-0.0391593874,
0.0917143673,
-0.0426937565,
-0.0071122381,
-0.04211412,
-0.020631291,
-0.0366219692,
0.003611793,
0.0021254113,
0.0045851115,
-0.034062624,
0.0205215048,
0.0026149708,
-0.0713363811,
0.0413504168,
-0.0640540794,
-0.0111715347,
-0.0341062322,
-0.0273670163,
-0.0151255643,
0.048212681,
0.0327071585,
0.0272790529,
-0.0163550768,
0.0254372414,
-0.0499251597,
0.0311829317,
-0.0272713751,
-0.032250911,
0.0390873738,
-0.0221220832,
-0.0007917028,
-0.0186595432,
-0.0249181297,
-0.0281545259,
-0.0402194783,
-0.0402470157,
-0.0140424659,
0.0238411315,
-0.0415005498,
-0.0105117597,
0.0234787446,
-0.0008557372,
0.0799807906,
0.0371642746,
0.0246680081,
-0.0027880501,
0.004339667,
0.0277570654,
0.0209999196,
0.0323016979,
-0.0061194384,
0.0013108329,
0.0595324598,
0.0360133611,
-0.0272774138,
-0.0397535898,
-0.0117242699,
0.0559264831,
0.0088798543,
-0.0292025842,
0.0379877612,
0.0200447645,
-0.0475240722,
-0.0374561958,
0.1019448563,
0.027493624,
-0.0660703629,
0.0004938454,
0.0391216241,
0.0478653535,
0.0234420113,
0.0521464013,
-0.0645809248,
-0.0201026294,
0.0289568566,
0.0030103477,
0.0266649667,
-0.0018632397,
-0.049752526,
-0.1274311692,
-0.0017729441,
-0.0109189646,
0.0447237082,
0.0221570898,
-0.0442130789,
-0.0323907398,
-0.0063058403,
-0.017593639,
-0.0133338114,
-0.0109787639,
-0.0007255041,
-0.0008362929,
-0.0300139897,
-0.0486752801,
0.0178874005,
-0.0286350083,
0.0301356763,
0.0102157732,
-0.0138340862,
0.0048981532,
-0.0451402366,
0.036677137,
-0.0094618918,
-0.0238060746,
-0.0130096124,
0.0393503048,
-0.0099256393,
-0.0025041234,
0.02118087,
-0.0124189146,
-0.0535706468,
-0.038920816,
-0.0301856175,
0.1138957366,
-0.0063579213,
-0.0089952219,
-0.0024652535,
-0.009251589,
-0.021215735,
0.0762566403,
0.0418556146,
-0.036057014,
-0.0198957659,
0.0139891021,
-0.0124308625,
-0.0021571149,
-0.0298987478,
0.0101112835,
0.0272700768,
-0.0506155789,
-0.00435253,
-0.0004045334,
0.0370625108,
0.0503632911,
-0.0107212458,
-0.0221402906,
0.0205758326,
0.0133578638,
-0.0935580209,
0.0371989943,
-0.0402054936,
0.001361934,
-0.0506641306,
-0.0067255809,
0.0360747762,
0.0216823351,
-0.0195213947,
-0.0098190634,
-0.1216479838,
-0.0540842824,
0.0200536158,
0.0604732744,
0.0197644327,
0.0369114205,
0.0016991438,
-0.0553885885,
0.04593895,
-0.0063810754,
-0.0739432126,
0.0530474782,
0.0372324325,
-0.0561400764,
0.0232330617,
0.04709813,
-0.0115909511,
0.0117956772,
0.0076887719,
0.0003870188,
-0.0201768372,
-0.0349697508,
-0.0230818689,
-0.0343848243,
0.0452837609,
-0.0149539365,
0.0091659157,
-0.021701064,
0.0503288321,
-0.0122144902,
-0.0023436206,
-0.0545008928,
-0.009074484,
-0.0085933283,
0.0313659422,
-0.0274876654,
0.02417331,
0.0399289019,
0.0047075115,
0.0126033602,
0.00847618,
0.0315696709,
-0.0429521762,
0.0611200519,
0.0284275431,
-0.0094823577,
0.0074810917,
-0.0378373228,
0.0130581539,
-0.0634331331,
0.009914712,
-0.011601747,
0.0044619213,
-0.0712221861,
0.0429889597,
-0.0244231839,
-0.1017049998,
-0.0062604942,
0.0068189739,
0.0124769881,
-0.0387998894,
0.0132852942,
-0.0135899046,
-0.0201748423,
-0.0115489662,
0.004302917,
-0.0203731023,
-0.0307246074,
0.0428013019,
0.0238451101,
-0.0382218845,
0.032532651,
0.0774063468,
0.0346205905,
0.045702327,
-0.0006583258,
-0.006896127,
-0.0157682821,
-0.0217287578,
-0.0209618025,
0.0269700419,
-0.0320366733,
0.0067762923,
-0.0445876718,
-0.095950298,
0.0097253602,
-0.0249630287,
-0.0212643761,
-0.010004824,
0.0261759423,
0.0576919354,
0.0132590169,
0.0221292228,
-0.0125658819,
0.0003576081,
-0.0154726068,
-0.0218335763,
0.0219162554,
-6.659309945e-33,
-0.0101693403,
0.0004395592,
0.0297575127,
-0.0282427259,
-0.0114337113,
0.0338791199,
-0.0347122028,
-0.0070085903,
-0.029418923,
-0.009311121,
-0.0291583166,
0.0313254073,
0.0140653476,
0.0537252799,
-0.0100652762,
0.0084214108,
0.046241872,
-0.0197406746,
-0.0160609316,
0.05146062,
0.0131479977,
0.0581814274,
0.0457608886,
-0.0086924201,
-0.0545847379,
0.0101503581,
0.0274709947,
-0.0028119332,
0.0033132839,
0.0345168747,
-0.0584945418,
0.0103322919,
-0.0045722905,
-0.0392408147,
-0.0191638693,
0.0339861698,
-0.0695538446,
-0.0130502051,
0.0112578664,
0.0282029286,
-0.0193756092,
-0.0159137268,
0.0017608748,
0.0165902935,
-0.0024907875,
-0.0009915851,
0.0082121706,
0.007102625,
-0.0430908613,
-0.034903381,
-0.0332264937,
0.0105902795,
0.0298352204,
0.0009975818,
0.0553324595,
-0.0115605425,
-0.0067441626,
0.0604977496,
-0.0650055483,
-0.0078259185,
0.0009038419,
0.0434486233,
0.0580030493,
0.0019479276,
0.0035742179,
0.0524037182,
0.013278312,
-0.0220871344,
-0.0339878201,
0.0325993262,
0.0574260652,
0.0130191157,
0.0286653899,
-0.0091937594,
0.0512124188,
-0.0218759477,
-0.0435959697,
-0.0534452945,
0.0092420476,
0.0402664468,
0.0453697331,
-0.0017865864,
0.0005408386,
-0.0487834103,
-0.0453699008,
4.7e-9,
-0.0386278704,
-0.0243728645,
0.0401817635,
0.0458427072,
-0.053171128,
-0.0013294364,
0.041870188,
-0.040713463,
-0.0019127363,
0.0184546039,
0.0108440891,
0.0070080152,
0.0020377091,
0.046335727,
-0.0413513184,
-0.0438349359,
-0.0194524657,
-0.04396227,
0.008383289,
0.0063836346,
0.0354633741,
0.0567005463,
-0.0820517913,
0.0002140149,
-0.0331070423,
0.0074722096,
0.0345532075,
0.079053767,
0.0397591144,
0.0244563576,
-0.0015056053,
0.0363668725,
0.0282505322,
-0.0027306352,
-0.0140768541,
-0.0364500992,
0.0312642381,
0.023873806,
-0.013930006,
-0.0161102992,
-0.0672416985,
0.0214157607,
0.036233414,
-0.0818627402,
-0.0206670258,
0.0232218355,
2.839e-7,
0.0362884998,
0.0225152783,
-0.0178221446,
-0.0427599549,
-0.0005553038,
-0.0043607741,
0.0223665554,
0.0032174797,
-0.0359502584,
0.002094096,
-0.0043566814,
0.0402629413,
0.0481003895,
0.0139152231,
-0.0888737738,
-0.0097344974,
-0.0921890661,
0.0253573153,
-0.0390174761,
-0.0265051126,
-0.0164655484,
0.1564713269,
0.0288262889,
-0.0137577103,
-0.0250392742,
-0.040401224,
0.0372496247,
-0.0326584242,
0.0259330794,
-0.0096400017,
0.0185916871,
0.0607057884,
-0.0414702781,
-0.0241538696,
-0.0473700091,
0.0319407061,
-0.035468895,
0.0664004385,
0.0153795499,
-0.0058024749,
0.0103193484,
-0.0401191749,
-0.0590888411,
-0.0427054316,
0.0722905546,
-0.0676620305,
-0.0331199281,
-0.0437208302,
0.0132827135,
-0.0235657021,
0.0116109839,
-0.0015019766,
0.0098128067,
0.023515977,
0.0231311861,
-0.0442017429,
-0.0062176948,
-0.1307540536,
0.0058446215,
0.0125889201,
-0.0501971245,
-0.0126566142,
-0.0727702081,
-0.0591981187,
0.0621462166,
-0.0159682054,
0.0253038388,
3.115090565e-34,
0.0417464823,
-0.0102759879,
0.0279128309,
0.0417898186,
0.0121770799,
-0.0213004276,
0.0603065528,
0.0024958281,
-0.009750274,
-0.1168562174,
-0.0244852379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08695v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08695v1 | Resolving Legalese: A Multilingual Exploration of Negation Scope Resolution in Legal Documents | 2023-09-15T18:38:06 | 2023-09-15T18:38:06 | Ramona Christen, Anastassia Shaitarova, Matthias Stürmer, Joel Niklaus | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2 | Resolving the scope of a negation within a sentence is a challenging NLP
task. The complexity of legal texts and the lack of annotated in-domain
negation corpora pose challenges for state-of-the-art (SotA) models when
performing negation scope resolution on multilingual legal data. Our
experiments demonstrate that models pre-trained without legal data underperform
in the task of negation scope resolution. Our experiments, using language
models exclusively fine-tuned on domains like literary texts and medical data,
yield inferior results compared to the outcomes documented in prior
cross-domain experiments. We release a new set of annotated court decisions in
German, French, and Italian and use it to improve negation scope resolution in
both zero-shot and multilingual settings. We achieve token-level F1-scores of
up to 86.7% in our zero-shot cross-lingual experiments, where the models are
trained on two languages of our legal datasets and evaluated on the third. Our
multilingual experiments, where the models were trained on all available
negation data and evaluated on our legal datasets, resulted in F1-scores of up
to 91.1%. | [
0.0308476537,
0.0185242463,
0.0104049491,
0.033140108,
-0.0676677749,
0.0034186456,
0.033276096,
-0.0035351866,
-0.0063586603,
-0.0538923293,
-0.0680082142,
-0.008890193,
-0.040428333,
0.0167051628,
-0.0376917981,
-0.018382784,
0.0534242503,
0.0328323804,
0.0599886477,
-0.0228629187,
0.0127059389,
0.0050333673,
-0.0115059474,
0.0171093158,
-0.0540280081,
-0.0163580608,
0.0173451882,
0.0115589658,
-0.0054356288,
-0.0216302127,
0.0098234601,
0.0667131916,
-0.0262170285,
0.0358556919,
0.0000014658,
-0.0321978889,
0.0070535089,
0.01047986,
0.0042923335,
-0.0189608876,
0.0405461267,
-0.0823300704,
-0.0381385237,
-0.0038764568,
-0.0292538386,
0.01988356,
0.0144608086,
0.0523700751,
0.0270783529,
0.0754952803,
-0.0055780462,
-0.0213318765,
0.0181698781,
-0.0675798506,
-0.0385056064,
-0.0564351529,
0.0189181287,
0.0023670318,
-0.0267772265,
-0.0124582583,
-0.0122838905,
0.0358945578,
0.0363939665,
0.0124520771,
-0.0549232811,
0.0062073609,
-0.0585207604,
-0.0184881724,
0.0159284193,
0.0320771597,
0.0213454384,
-0.0297194887,
-0.020125296,
0.0016856616,
0.0132639185,
-0.0008600574,
-0.0368430614,
0.0619087406,
0.0147094168,
0.0257045589,
0.0106496559,
0.0089349635,
-0.0072779786,
0.0130914412,
-0.0123703051,
0.0839955136,
0.0105936714,
-0.0504474156,
0.0320985131,
0.0164053049,
-0.0182777923,
-0.0107363807,
0.0569025874,
0.0057599377,
-0.0009314,
0.0374070071,
-0.0271699075,
-0.0079519562,
0.0674074665,
-0.0418882668,
-0.0214919709,
-0.013407832,
-0.0246290565,
0.0925820246,
-0.054991249,
-0.0197333824,
-0.0059882659,
-0.0042671892,
0.013775507,
-0.0783582628,
-0.0378338434,
0.0022364373,
-0.0182770882,
0.0459704027,
-0.1094456241,
0.0132839559,
-0.0077667977,
-0.0666735023,
-0.0541025773,
0.017664561,
-0.0323547907,
-0.009838229,
-0.0077662962,
-0.0164572597,
-0.0454336107,
0.0277100503,
-0.050565917,
0.0533560254,
-0.0440111272,
-0.0073570171,
0.0059128022,
-0.0007236047,
-0.0125661064,
-0.0207076613,
0.0300326794,
0.0803405195,
-0.017659409,
-0.0103343427,
-0.0045440728,
-0.0799043179,
-0.0453570522,
-0.0959082916,
-0.0347962566,
-0.0572498292,
-0.0049826116,
0.0040889122,
-0.0148277497,
-0.0919208452,
0.0230799057,
0.0329670273,
-0.0198581144,
0.0651703104,
0.0046654432,
-0.0545400344,
-0.0461078025,
0.0061721625,
0.0075416006,
0.0523821078,
-0.0296991691,
0.0112674506,
0.021611562,
0.0548246726,
-0.0048366711,
0.0140615553,
0.0711086839,
0.0444342457,
-0.0082026022,
-0.0132003948,
-0.0068725944,
-0.0134340581,
0.016668791,
0.0400824398,
-0.0137690874,
-0.0451746099,
0.0098117031,
0.0324107409,
-0.011977898,
0.0140387425,
-0.0440763496,
-0.0261857938,
0.005414058,
0.0041116076,
-0.0756739601,
0.0179814119,
-0.047445707,
-0.0001434944,
-0.0513433926,
-0.0233291592,
-0.0273163281,
-0.0442355834,
0.0071223821,
-0.0163274724,
0.0111321984,
-0.0143251447,
0.0635538027,
0.0492268167,
-0.0501969494,
0.0288570188,
0.0054317401,
-0.0868949592,
-0.0103556998,
0.0260654557,
0.0237722825,
-0.0109499935,
0.049614571,
-0.0541948415,
-0.067395553,
-0.0018440422,
-0.0163377784,
0.0692091957,
0.0356030688,
0.004499726,
0.0313742831,
-0.016447749,
-0.0367127135,
-0.0060130674,
0.0283075292,
0.0143157942,
-0.0088528916,
0.0363897718,
0.0319092982,
-0.0432724133,
-0.0050046328,
0.0309556015,
-0.0318004601,
0.0080652935,
0.0299399626,
0.0086507266,
0.0347210653,
0.032717336,
-0.0001458006,
0.0058140913,
0.0317703448,
-0.0259897076,
-0.0127278958,
-0.0055317031,
-0.0209899712,
-0.0226601865,
0.0573621765,
-0.0927186385,
-0.0310080871,
0.0119689768,
-0.0331599936,
-0.00957793,
0.0098953443,
0.0192446746,
-0.0219426937,
-0.0371615961,
-0.024479894,
-0.0072572655,
-0.0062217792,
-0.0299678221,
0.0321689807,
0.0106049096,
0.0089100599,
0.0136120729,
-0.0016565118,
0.0672038421,
0.0141713191,
-0.0424347445,
-0.0246859789,
-0.0216026101,
-0.0077383453,
0.0350339711,
0.0114275925,
-0.0378747843,
-0.0216876436,
-0.0794369131,
0.0393327884,
-0.0258812401,
0.0056638219,
0.0338376164,
-0.0280164331,
0.0145630501,
-0.0436253063,
-0.0079488922,
-0.0137703624,
0.0320168957,
-0.0022413472,
0.0364668965,
-0.0080122035,
0.0027797136,
-0.0307172537,
0.0007382332,
-0.0414525606,
-0.0007868255,
-0.0187911298,
-0.0258299485,
0.0169404838,
0.0730136707,
-0.0309216604,
0.0285692867,
-0.0203353949,
-0.0044475207,
0.0156168966,
0.0254033301,
-0.0493033305,
0.047193408,
-0.0185452476,
-0.0236263759,
0.034834411,
0.0079709291,
-0.0286884792,
0.006503976,
0.0220761113,
0.0115615036,
-0.0317232162,
-0.0121630253,
0.0172463059,
0.0373743176,
0.0023251537,
-0.0251989476,
-0.0254341345,
0.0380176865,
-0.0330794491,
-0.0129401488,
-0.0009186844,
0.0150575377,
-0.0060915668,
0.0839846358,
-0.0272739585,
-0.0273062307,
0.0375367701,
0.0223248973,
0.0334867537,
-0.0579233915,
0.0248396993,
-0.0326484405,
0.0956977755,
-0.028333554,
0.0005468049,
0.0286301263,
-0.0605351776,
0.0242508687,
-0.0556548163,
0.0594569147,
-0.0119773503,
0.0986405388,
-0.0255687945,
0.0080797058,
-0.0438656583,
-0.0412757508,
-0.0375361443,
-0.0205950513,
0.0027689387,
0.0327105112,
-0.0079778079,
0.052903574,
-0.0588822775,
-0.0144413179,
-0.0191490501,
0.0376931541,
-0.0081864456,
-0.0016556483,
-0.0447512381,
0.0117701357,
-0.0072484096,
-0.0235293023,
0.0056229075,
-0.0055489852,
-0.0420182496,
0.0529323407,
-0.062683776,
0.0157881007,
0.0306106564,
-0.0242531411,
0.0144979917,
-0.0537256151,
-0.0214378666,
-0.0113641405,
0.0412766524,
-0.0149626285,
0.0023365703,
0.0899762139,
0.0456708521,
-0.0032858332,
-0.0113451742,
-0.0064216838,
0.0220151134,
0.0503302403,
-0.0016414861,
-0.1156071648,
-0.023439372,
-0.0068562501,
-0.0240123197,
-0.0124605773,
-0.02495417,
-0.013608491,
-0.1065480784,
0.0450755954,
-0.0019706246,
-0.0255035739,
-0.0635675713,
-0.0416053049,
0.0319802798,
-0.0289887004,
0.0048719342,
-0.001103281,
-0.0119612943,
-0.010739347,
-0.033550296,
0.0086359568,
0.0001049342,
0.007447361,
-0.0511276461,
0.042520877,
-0.0105134817,
0.0597883463,
-0.0190740284,
0.0368954167,
0.0432830565,
-0.004897885,
0.013475691,
-0.0392401218,
0.0603682585,
0.0155523298,
0.0205644779,
-0.039233923,
0.0313204676,
-0.0184594933,
-0.0230193362,
0.0482196622,
0.0340080298,
-0.0034620755,
0.0144063178,
-0.0409758352,
0.0098211225,
-0.0048875101,
0.0612768754,
0.0211718976,
0.0411823094,
-0.0715064481,
-0.021893017,
-0.0168236215,
-0.0304311812,
0.0034653668,
-0.0080994572,
-0.0360127129,
-0.0060556238,
-0.0374739766,
-0.0558268614,
0.0269034207,
0.0401514806,
0.0239678696,
0.0134848468,
0.0796905011,
-0.0214036703,
-0.0244390853,
0.0087154554,
-0.0424508639,
-0.0123095354,
-0.0056938115,
0.032575164,
0.0158379637,
0.0425896011,
-0.0245489143,
0.026523646,
0.0205020327,
-0.0335744321,
-0.0259125568,
-0.0103092548,
0.0133963302,
0.01587555,
-0.0535892807,
-0.0101953316,
0.0106172217,
0.0738890469,
-0.0205477122,
-0.0290451515,
0.0877994299,
-0.0118237613,
0.0196443703,
0.0404743627,
0.0085133985,
0.0701838359,
0.0486555733,
0.0365717225,
-0.0154119451,
0.0432262905,
0.0219886191,
0.0289663505,
0.043067608,
0.027448561,
-0.0424055271,
-0.0276524499,
-0.0112033766,
-0.0657630041,
-0.0222293679,
0.0061386549,
-0.0050592055,
0.0306162797,
-0.0376634672,
-0.0209706519,
0.0655627698,
-0.0674847513,
0.0575054102,
-0.0412611477,
0.0229714438,
0.0728222206,
-0.0092759673,
-0.0316450559,
-0.0447505228,
0.0069422824,
0.000160814,
0.0191257074,
0.0474953391,
-0.019024523,
0.0159540307,
0.0218138359,
0.0218611695,
-0.0473370366,
-0.0053135632,
-0.0305185914,
0.0609843284,
0.0165931266,
0.0250643399,
0.0753657073,
-0.0103743616,
0.060405232,
-0.0309259314,
-0.0094001601,
0.0035078861,
0.0073855622,
-0.0054285405,
0.0166451968,
0.027006058,
0.0042046355,
0.0041626189,
0.0359015763,
0.0417439155,
-0.0278020389,
0.0266020093,
0.0133681409,
-0.0294619054,
-0.0409579314,
-0.0370797329,
-0.008153338,
0.0146996519,
-0.0388611257,
0.0047901841,
-0.0709765628,
-0.0260906406,
-0.0025444906,
0.0020563283,
-0.0144088268,
0.0136644738,
-0.0039366167,
0.0395817161,
0.0345457643,
-0.038426917,
-0.0425953008,
0.0579768084,
0.0435902029,
-0.0389419757,
-0.0554162078,
-5.234780871e-33,
-0.0317813121,
-0.0417333096,
-0.0127144279,
0.0144963572,
-0.0038038611,
-0.0024309943,
-0.0219614673,
0.0123681808,
-0.0293324348,
0.0698539391,
-0.0116522033,
0.021103086,
0.0302551351,
0.0032409113,
0.0064556883,
-0.0313309245,
0.0469824895,
0.0401593819,
-0.0128277754,
0.0058156904,
0.0045791776,
0.0225242134,
0.0356882289,
-0.0996954292,
0.0403850339,
0.0336557291,
-0.0347304605,
-0.028311478,
-0.0229297448,
0.0441166237,
0.0021812362,
0.0519376136,
0.0305866115,
-0.0659684166,
-0.0165670384,
-0.010094705,
-0.0979303867,
-0.0145709869,
0.043839246,
-0.0026076627,
0.0050683892,
-0.0217697546,
0.0400672443,
0.0193946511,
-0.03352651,
0.0107087605,
0.0420512818,
-0.0374312811,
-0.025305884,
-0.0392169766,
-0.1338319629,
0.0443179756,
0.003056095,
-0.0057510673,
0.0452228598,
0.0208213311,
-0.0152365668,
0.0295418594,
-0.0570097789,
0.0135808522,
-0.0403882489,
0.0004756317,
0.0080950763,
-0.0871855915,
-0.0268653482,
0.0386705324,
0.0138918068,
0.0309000295,
-0.00674689,
-0.0331345573,
0.0471803099,
0.0489372313,
0.0264503397,
0.067543909,
0.0168405958,
-0.0235257447,
-0.0786317289,
-0.028256122,
0.0209571775,
0.0612417422,
-0.001800873,
-0.0345785134,
-0.0075388169,
-0.0110767595,
-0.0550027005,
-0.0941656455,
-0.011511893,
0.020757705,
0.001733984,
0.0106363632,
0.023042202,
-0.0071943654,
0.0030250659,
-0.031788867,
0.0046810978,
0.0721648335,
0.0235516932,
0.0237019174,
0.0126453061,
0.0206880029,
-0.0627345219,
-0.0128781665,
0.0060724122,
0.0175058525,
0.0116562918,
-0.0335114673,
0.114210546,
-0.0559585653,
-0.06186869,
-0.0033020445,
-0.0050485558,
0.0426739678,
0.0086191557,
0.0696143135,
0.0157682449,
0.026020743,
0.0339769237,
0.0395497754,
0.0177936293,
-0.0129654128,
-0.0450038724,
0.0240627043,
0.0304777119,
0.0036200874,
-0.0235543568,
-0.0181146786,
-0.0107071791,
0.0213897042,
0.0191631503,
-0.0127158472,
-0.0090896413,
0.0538661219,
2.152e-7,
0.080006972,
0.0491727963,
0.0289040431,
0.0398324803,
0.0178121272,
0.044990886,
-0.0192278493,
0.0154246828,
-0.0032206248,
0.0245336574,
-0.0062295073,
-0.0049054995,
0.0207548719,
0.0447151177,
-0.0442272574,
0.0263811015,
0.002175428,
-0.0514578633,
-0.0404356197,
0.0366906263,
0.0215723142,
0.1096489578,
-0.0048563648,
0.0055825128,
-0.0114311306,
0.0060344967,
0.0483923703,
0.0047846269,
-0.0342647135,
-0.0117397904,
0.0321310796,
-0.037394695,
0.0127269505,
0.0416503474,
-0.0012507841,
0.0330309495,
-0.028459603,
0.0931643397,
-0.0134437289,
-0.0062046144,
0.0011804269,
-0.0113852527,
0.0130553916,
-0.0351122022,
0.08258266,
-0.0120445266,
-0.0187590346,
-0.0168257561,
-0.0451685376,
0.017968582,
0.0459636934,
0.0196594317,
-0.0503561385,
-0.0071262601,
0.0367262699,
0.0094639892,
-0.0257637296,
-0.0412835553,
-0.0067765666,
0.0265396833,
0.010475982,
0.0152069107,
0.051954899,
-0.0235968139,
0.0147758545,
-0.0483425967,
0.0308678467,
1.722406528e-34,
0.0632794201,
-0.0247193482,
0.0402074195,
-0.0169509202,
-0.0050813258,
0.0223086923,
-0.0675712451,
-0.007076249,
-0.0021516939,
0.0008092866,
0.0377132185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08674v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08674v1 | Fake News Detectors are Biased against Texts Generated by Large Language Models | 2023-09-15T18:04:40 | 2023-09-15T18:04:40 | Jinyan Su, Terry Yue Zhuo, Jonibek Mansurov, Di Wang, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The spread of fake news has emerged as a critical challenge, undermining
trust and posing threats to society. In the era of Large Language Models
(LLMs), the capability to generate believable fake content has intensified
these concerns. In this study, we present a novel paradigm to evaluate fake
news detectors in scenarios involving both human-written and LLM-generated
misinformation. Intriguingly, our findings reveal a significant bias in many
existing detectors: they are more prone to flagging LLM-generated content as
fake news while often misclassifying human-written fake news as genuine. This
unexpected bias appears to arise from distinct linguistic patterns inherent to
LLM outputs. To address this, we introduce a mitigation strategy that leverages
adversarial training with LLM-paraphrased genuine news. The resulting model
yielded marked improvements in detection accuracy for both human and
LLM-generated news. To further catalyze research in this domain, we release two
comprehensive datasets, \texttt{GossipCop++} and \texttt{PolitiFact++}, thus
amalgamating human-validated articles with LLM-generated fake and real news. | [
0.0551389121,
0.071984604,
-0.0011993414,
0.0590544306,
-0.0383739136,
0.0002928278,
0.008980643,
0.0153819742,
0.0257342365,
-0.0482705496,
-0.0238978956,
-0.0347017162,
-0.0000687531,
0.0522533134,
0.0380765311,
-0.0136552192,
0.049979832,
0.0082471762,
0.0392169133,
-0.0261149835,
0.0383448526,
0.0486720949,
0.018754309,
0.0246559568,
-0.0120621501,
-0.0054063918,
0.0407113954,
0.0236650538,
0.0255102031,
-0.0084761856,
0.0089804437,
0.043849688,
0.0268226173,
0.1175940931,
0.0000015486,
0.0024887256,
0.0090348069,
-0.0012284407,
-0.0269646812,
0.0304029249,
0.0819706097,
-0.0811161995,
-0.0211357791,
0.0345916376,
-0.0246447027,
-0.0445811637,
-0.0033031274,
0.0565697365,
0.0685635284,
0.11981754,
-0.0095728636,
-0.0100940783,
0.0445122309,
-0.0347319171,
-0.0174155887,
-0.041533865,
0.0533701964,
0.0017884274,
-0.0406092852,
0.0563342422,
0.028377844,
-0.0088151712,
0.0435856059,
-0.0164930746,
-0.04262821,
0.0115307169,
-0.0114097064,
-0.0265516061,
-0.0089708641,
0.0292160586,
-0.0702561885,
-0.0755912215,
0.0319606625,
-0.0183576085,
0.0065350742,
0.0427956209,
0.0019250589,
0.0333250724,
-0.0208983868,
0.0144631341,
0.0238177273,
-0.0187331438,
0.0515903793,
0.0739823729,
0.0253444109,
0.0275582168,
0.0125994012,
-0.0068989163,
0.0083615696,
0.0026647521,
-0.0151317064,
-0.0502172187,
0.0417342819,
-0.0040883659,
-0.0157420132,
0.0014986622,
-0.0781975687,
-0.0098996293,
0.0548513755,
-0.0802150816,
-0.021622261,
-0.0129094394,
0.0024473418,
0.053899385,
-0.0381980203,
0.0044279932,
-0.0480153486,
0.025814876,
-0.01835531,
-0.007566269,
0.0110657206,
0.0089328513,
0.0045383903,
-0.0124412337,
-0.0301972032,
0.006609689,
-0.0328500532,
-0.0185503401,
-0.0031488617,
0.0203890689,
-0.0156030543,
0.0131317489,
-0.0134794218,
-0.0283685811,
-0.0010436525,
0.0326180421,
0.0125551289,
0.0319503024,
-0.0037772958,
-0.0608169064,
-0.0213084202,
0.040644154,
-0.0408484489,
-0.0037392806,
0.0023269434,
0.0141034024,
-0.0082635013,
-0.0170408413,
-0.0294758305,
-0.0179535989,
-0.0233726874,
-0.0657559112,
0.0257867314,
-0.0680021867,
-0.0076288907,
-0.0267517194,
-0.0007240623,
-0.0622510016,
-0.0078166891,
0.0403754152,
-0.0255083125,
0.0338093974,
0.0131879393,
-0.0100070322,
0.0451998264,
0.0270374659,
-0.0025378414,
0.0887091756,
0.0165870786,
0.1033076867,
0.0433935709,
0.0259063691,
0.0120162237,
0.0336253941,
0.0544204488,
0.0546527356,
-0.0040824022,
-0.0097311335,
-0.0050708866,
0.0004674957,
0.0337152705,
0.037924163,
-0.0132357609,
-0.0575048998,
0.1015259847,
-0.0213400349,
-0.0145156756,
0.0162611604,
0.055223994,
0.0331504382,
0.0115943076,
-0.0005294433,
-0.0471532866,
-0.0055688261,
-0.065549016,
-0.0265587214,
-0.0125859603,
0.0686165169,
-0.010680466,
-0.0063375318,
-0.009196287,
-0.0046113264,
0.0191890318,
-0.016977001,
-0.0128765153,
0.019135572,
-0.0358547084,
-0.00484891,
0.0208869819,
0.0087105278,
0.0029151151,
-0.063133657,
0.0312586986,
0.0017570619,
0.0424940288,
0.0203689169,
0.038818296,
-0.0379602201,
0.019647751,
0.0466605388,
0.0461221151,
-0.0127821434,
-0.0357198715,
-0.0010722304,
-0.0070193242,
-0.0387520827,
0.0301617626,
-0.0062606209,
0.0500030406,
0.0115958462,
0.0091462918,
-0.0157254655,
-0.0753850043,
0.0163296498,
-0.0294721927,
-0.003804019,
-0.0057720891,
0.0109936083,
0.0050864751,
0.0087071666,
0.0023149687,
-0.0059813545,
0.051675614,
-0.0056675207,
-0.0320370905,
-0.0447156727,
-0.0112156197,
-0.0271249153,
0.0175996069,
-0.0319611728,
-0.0427583121,
0.0621840097,
-0.0198066849,
0.0138543304,
0.0097354557,
-0.0346685983,
0.0091489339,
-0.0301055815,
-0.0098242555,
-0.031833794,
0.0273036174,
0.0132905683,
0.0691330358,
-0.0477162413,
-0.0136868991,
-0.0006421276,
0.0253589153,
-0.0001474012,
0.0327922516,
-0.003615876,
0.0257322993,
0.0149409333,
0.0163399689,
0.0147537859,
-0.0198660661,
-0.0024102232,
-0.0375947841,
-0.0373539105,
0.0062316661,
-0.0363117233,
-0.0171126947,
0.0701363236,
-0.03107512,
-0.0023336308,
0.0317812078,
-0.0584135018,
-0.0212016515,
0.017273102,
0.0071972054,
-0.0021149467,
-0.0375307687,
0.0049282177,
-0.0233462509,
0.0192977395,
-0.0032398079,
0.0545738935,
0.0107277231,
-0.0122572603,
-0.0409937948,
0.0128675578,
-0.0176073052,
0.0115409056,
-0.0521910116,
-0.028556386,
-0.0003534862,
0.0145252198,
-0.0107678492,
0.0718673989,
0.0403688923,
0.0505993105,
0.0335656069,
0.0645165965,
-0.0187802296,
-0.0483776331,
-0.0234196596,
0.020745296,
-0.0485988148,
-0.0677873567,
0.0041932138,
0.0442456678,
0.0180541277,
0.0085748751,
0.0121731032,
0.0632878765,
-0.0119355004,
-0.0402576067,
0.0257490799,
-0.0573118478,
-0.0064249258,
-0.0008657006,
-0.0537310466,
-0.0375021957,
0.0857459679,
-0.036133524,
0.0437071919,
-0.0313235894,
-0.0452495925,
-0.014921302,
0.0122635774,
-0.0159658901,
0.0276234373,
-0.01817628,
0.0172204524,
-0.0225847736,
-0.0258882158,
0.0459191687,
-0.0359937027,
0.0305799153,
-0.0173676368,
0.0143755125,
0.0200696066,
-0.0095329508,
-0.0685101375,
-0.1117391065,
-0.018769294,
0.007222326,
0.0127636176,
-0.0422997065,
-0.0589169711,
-0.0156239187,
0.031079594,
0.0331116542,
-0.0244909041,
0.0262616929,
-0.0034202056,
0.0581151992,
0.050814908,
-0.0178999454,
0.0722434521,
-0.0274798498,
-0.0008314851,
0.0782623291,
-0.0089021921,
0.054703664,
-0.0175214931,
-0.0363635458,
0.0060790842,
0.0117543591,
-0.0096854968,
-0.0247641895,
0.0254894551,
-0.0472580791,
0.0111794611,
0.0863123909,
-0.0051927133,
-0.028993709,
0.0054526199,
0.0380862057,
0.0132623184,
0.0143226162,
-0.039390929,
-0.0611650236,
-0.001611346,
0.0084361704,
-0.0110055646,
-0.0300608035,
-0.0159136709,
-0.0257790666,
-0.0939540714,
0.0022442976,
0.0036602961,
-0.0101241432,
-0.0358700976,
-0.0617884062,
-0.0086948052,
0.0060236626,
0.0290151983,
-0.0075034779,
0.0217046719,
-0.0193879642,
-0.0218336564,
0.0160116032,
-0.061860323,
0.0056128758,
-0.0382173657,
0.0641388446,
0.0420998633,
0.0628468692,
-0.0105517739,
-0.0311169047,
0.0171084162,
0.0001719803,
-0.0512602255,
-0.0027476,
0.0676135421,
-0.0454293787,
-0.0101356767,
-0.024968164,
0.0654935017,
-0.0038598243,
-0.0099537065,
0.0024843181,
0.0129953288,
0.0349817276,
-0.0901318789,
-0.0156466756,
0.0234234836,
0.0315826759,
0.0699714944,
0.0326492712,
-0.0163889062,
-0.0061657261,
-0.0389330871,
-0.0061245277,
-0.0113136638,
-0.0739426091,
0.0523231477,
-0.0095375041,
-0.0392018333,
-0.0418042876,
-0.0251834802,
-0.0120929694,
-0.0050935908,
0.0050062174,
-0.0091225347,
0.0003628173,
-0.0416293442,
-0.0109755425,
0.0121207638,
-0.0303460229,
0.0660937876,
0.0006522068,
0.0058792001,
0.0050365352,
-0.0148995621,
-0.0122760078,
0.044255659,
-0.1211378276,
-0.0425159335,
0.0096006561,
-0.0048892125,
0.0164183341,
0.0297999792,
-0.0289366096,
-0.0599186309,
0.0522369817,
0.0261660703,
-0.0450205021,
0.0301899724,
0.022969367,
-0.023057051,
0.0516974404,
0.0204392131,
-0.0103447177,
0.024985373,
0.0424908064,
-0.0370049514,
-0.0420355573,
0.0048011448,
0.0316119157,
0.0137796281,
0.022544302,
-0.0247980505,
0.0249856971,
-0.0361543298,
-0.0369900912,
-0.0315547511,
-0.0217584744,
-0.0074842973,
0.0288814828,
0.0469656512,
0.0017003112,
-0.0068900981,
0.0055125505,
-0.0229160748,
0.0282308012,
-0.0368287377,
-0.0281342063,
-0.0165360104,
0.0439523458,
0.0222821757,
-0.0102655757,
-0.041666884,
0.0469556376,
-0.0359850787,
0.0253279228,
-0.0031799653,
-0.0065424624,
0.0276596509,
-0.0418261513,
0.0124904187,
-0.0172779132,
-0.0610104576,
-0.020314239,
-0.0368770771,
0.0391702913,
0.0414644442,
-0.0146566462,
0.0473575145,
-0.0190613065,
-0.0234323889,
-0.0030812873,
-0.0215844493,
-0.0137204714,
-0.0342558809,
0.0000993502,
0.0089618405,
-0.0320140123,
0.0463442095,
0.0717065409,
0.0356542654,
0.0420293361,
0.0357980654,
-0.0428280979,
-0.0217825491,
-0.0295513887,
0.006778121,
0.0212959051,
-0.0260127839,
-0.0112440884,
-0.0776207373,
-0.0648394078,
-0.000920594,
0.0163787883,
0.0252475832,
-0.0013926773,
-0.0399228185,
0.0719200224,
-0.008319716,
0.0166485533,
-0.0430023521,
0.029032303,
0.0251893438,
-0.0461480059,
0.009915364,
-5.548889492e-33,
0.0157965031,
-0.0559672266,
-0.0463875048,
-0.0368326791,
-0.0020938495,
0.0487529188,
0.0016455661,
-0.0328454375,
-0.0386828892,
0.0425488874,
0.0329401605,
0.0439582393,
-0.0180274602,
0.0225993488,
-0.0690850988,
-0.0221179277,
0.0718657002,
-0.0140705062,
-0.0400753468,
0.0096776374,
0.0411141701,
-0.0106818695,
0.0122524714,
-0.044203531,
0.0500238761,
-0.0371712781,
-0.0537797175,
-0.0083983801,
-0.0297885742,
0.0436778329,
-0.0098668886,
0.0475275032,
0.0265865438,
-0.0086362073,
-0.001858819,
0.0433293916,
-0.0311958436,
0.0183267314,
0.0403895862,
-0.0036894397,
-0.0255899876,
-0.0098945694,
0.0491394214,
-0.0115619404,
-0.0113435043,
-0.0015943064,
-0.0025564497,
-0.024059508,
-0.021661235,
-0.0147959925,
-0.0314977951,
0.013712693,
0.0085475212,
0.0103858076,
-0.0274845418,
0.0398272611,
0.0198480226,
0.0394471698,
-0.1009453014,
0.0091284038,
-0.0297524892,
0.0163216218,
0.0167977717,
-0.0403971225,
-0.0325541943,
0.0742860585,
0.0295519792,
0.0389604829,
-0.0521638244,
0.006868992,
0.0119682215,
0.0142602967,
0.0726237074,
0.1142315269,
0.0239805598,
-0.0713828504,
-0.0886313692,
0.0117405588,
0.0359984264,
-0.0146028325,
0.0190594215,
-0.0200569518,
-0.011290024,
-0.0011610822,
-0.0491133817,
-0.0423322804,
-0.027824806,
-0.0169718713,
-0.0061403359,
0.0373233892,
-0.0314030536,
0.0295578726,
0.000133921,
-0.0612616539,
0.002900969,
0.0450810492,
-0.0363124125,
-0.01939312,
0.0141968112,
0.0692267045,
-0.0638622344,
0.0073422343,
0.0284645204,
-0.0017309559,
-0.0037540826,
-0.0125439717,
0.0618664585,
0.009253568,
-0.0429099426,
0.0237539541,
-0.0424666218,
0.041454915,
0.0236436371,
-0.0125652412,
0.0345853977,
-0.0002550586,
-0.0156635735,
-0.0116159776,
0.0039669611,
-0.0136713069,
-0.0132261729,
0.0219991636,
-0.0169661231,
0.0407007076,
-0.0189775657,
-0.0178734623,
-0.0439480282,
0.0093514696,
0.0441428833,
-0.1029389799,
0.0212496258,
-0.0363088734,
2.347e-7,
-0.0039105313,
0.0548024923,
-0.0112206312,
0.0366450697,
0.031683065,
0.0455811508,
0.0325761512,
0.0351027884,
-0.0313778482,
-0.0707945973,
-0.0582215376,
0.0333286747,
0.0426701233,
0.0436054133,
-0.058171887,
0.0490630902,
-0.0962012485,
0.0051441994,
-0.0449631847,
-0.0206092726,
0.0024193467,
0.0909246877,
0.0407904871,
-0.0373160802,
0.0099603469,
-0.036708083,
0.0699130595,
0.0163498148,
-0.0591581464,
0.0032500001,
0.077335082,
-0.0120088076,
0.0258444678,
0.0093723126,
-0.0230363179,
0.0077128476,
0.0093318978,
0.0407004096,
0.028440766,
0.0151354233,
-0.0212575197,
-0.0672561452,
0.0013962426,
-0.0846555158,
0.082961075,
-0.0197909232,
-0.0172475353,
-0.070710279,
-0.0510887429,
-0.0157183949,
0.032267388,
-0.0322415195,
-0.0106590213,
0.026905911,
-0.0067789578,
0.0168914739,
0.0187031869,
-0.017572917,
-0.0208319966,
-0.019241862,
-0.0619644783,
-0.028812848,
-0.0281485412,
-0.0177559629,
0.0415206663,
-0.0119764423,
0.0370433666,
2.017396262e-34,
0.0495801456,
-0.0223656986,
-0.0163551848,
-0.0127223954,
0.0346332304,
0.0256269928,
-0.0090584485,
-0.0157345049,
0.0116079077,
-0.0114009399,
0.0003410717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08600v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08600v3 | Sparse Autoencoders Find Highly Interpretable Features in Language Models | 2023-09-15T17:56:55 | 2023-10-04T13:17:38 | Hoagy Cunningham, Aidan Ewart, Logan Riggs, Robert Huben, Lee Sharkey | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | One of the roadblocks to a better understanding of neural networks' internals
is \textit{polysemanticity}, where neurons appear to activate in multiple,
semantically distinct contexts. Polysemanticity prevents us from identifying
concise, human-understandable explanations for what neural networks are doing
internally. One hypothesised cause of polysemanticity is
\textit{superposition}, where neural networks represent more features than they
have neurons by assigning features to an overcomplete set of directions in
activation space, rather than to individual neurons. Here, we attempt to
identify those directions, using sparse autoencoders to reconstruct the
internal activations of a language model. These autoencoders learn sets of
sparsely activating features that are more interpretable and monosemantic than
directions identified by alternative approaches, where interpretability is
measured by automated methods. Moreover, we show that with our learned set of
features, we can pinpoint the features that are causally responsible for
counterfactual behaviour on the indirect object identification task
\citep{wang2022interpretability} to a finer degree than previous
decompositions. This work indicates that it is possible to resolve
superposition in language models using a scalable, unsupervised method. Our
method may serve as a foundation for future mechanistic interpretability work,
which we hope will enable greater model transparency and steerability. | [
0.0027786861,
0.0738381669,
-0.04442738,
0.0734978691,
0.0073637478,
0.0290929768,
0.0419800952,
-0.0122159012,
-0.046754159,
-0.0160100628,
-0.031839136,
-0.0429044589,
0.0161355473,
0.0666202381,
0.0555447862,
0.00553656,
0.0449979156,
-0.037990652,
-0.0299057271,
-0.0382249318,
-0.0132836569,
0.001400653,
-0.0045073768,
0.0509365611,
-0.0047854455,
0.0101221688,
-0.0293278601,
-0.0239629988,
-0.0332846045,
0.0565666221,
-0.0333243161,
0.0427585766,
0.0583491996,
0.071982272,
0.0000020903,
-0.0073257852,
0.007935402,
-0.0359142311,
-0.0736438408,
0.0159673616,
-0.0355582722,
-0.0614450872,
0.0205489695,
-0.0536676422,
0.0160626918,
-0.0535182655,
0.0449370779,
0.0043512089,
0.0209123492,
0.0352629721,
0.0091140298,
-0.0393805802,
0.023281442,
-0.033641655,
0.0148218917,
-0.0172942597,
0.0026495692,
-0.0466126539,
-0.0482673123,
0.0225609727,
-0.0674674883,
0.0144165661,
0.0484219454,
0.0042502433,
-0.002984049,
-0.0063267807,
0.0096548973,
-0.0435101613,
0.0022532132,
0.039583981,
-0.0227587558,
-0.0167729631,
-0.0109325908,
-0.0237085726,
-0.0158605017,
0.0090237102,
-0.0286282226,
0.0094031142,
0.0709397346,
0.0266919248,
0.009502707,
0.0094177872,
0.0700372905,
0.0000332786,
-0.0404862203,
0.0456657335,
0.0166535098,
0.0242525134,
-0.0236477852,
0.0178920478,
-0.0219268389,
0.0018990429,
0.0385448709,
0.0020003794,
-0.0057686311,
0.014679594,
0.0162876751,
-0.0278390683,
-0.0193598885,
-0.0200540125,
0.0847655311,
0.0405279621,
-0.035372708,
-0.000126666,
-0.019322494,
0.0539935455,
-0.0619874112,
0.0101060811,
-0.0357212909,
0.0035434694,
-0.0271196533,
-0.0609517694,
0.0129904626,
0.0284537431,
-0.0012598962,
-0.0110177817,
0.002947794,
-0.0135424444,
-0.0428540148,
-0.0129139749,
-0.0461743921,
0.0300382674,
-0.0409930609,
0.007175494,
0.0115357405,
0.0581021346,
-0.0436805934,
0.028292045,
-0.0248401873,
-0.0180404279,
-0.0191258863,
0.0269586798,
0.0199925676,
-0.050514318,
-0.0194682702,
0.0592417009,
0.0165184066,
0.0072893449,
-0.0261611883,
-0.0467804931,
-0.0281996541,
0.0009483433,
0.044664789,
-0.0626459271,
0.0199178495,
0.0109150801,
0.0130057698,
-0.0913206339,
-0.0021865738,
-0.0629987419,
-0.0373791605,
0.09027794,
0.004976552,
0.001705827,
0.002015441,
0.016747579,
0.0314628072,
0.0264341459,
-0.0013561035,
0.0472648926,
-0.0130489832,
-0.0043234364,
0.0361110009,
0.0399473235,
0.0322973952,
-0.0207706261,
-0.064922519,
-0.062591292,
-0.0245715268,
-0.0145097431,
0.0629541799,
0.0040350873,
-0.0048448374,
-0.0568119921,
0.028575927,
0.024630066,
-0.038614206,
0.0300841182,
0.0597858503,
-0.0053228536,
-0.0443937108,
0.0523987226,
-0.0265950244,
0.0304684117,
-0.0375119112,
-0.0060615423,
0.0080286758,
-0.0241673067,
-0.0348424539,
-0.0312074386,
-0.0026348396,
-0.0188596584,
0.0076324409,
0.0100744432,
0.0665662512,
0.0164919421,
-0.0075329156,
0.0499467738,
0.0310581829,
-0.018557895,
0.0434265286,
-0.0554762781,
0.0111532053,
0.0207309369,
0.0040923776,
-0.0201061144,
-0.0063424353,
-0.011701175,
-0.0108561758,
0.0316735096,
-0.019303821,
-0.0243611503,
0.0699472576,
-0.0202402081,
-0.0296420045,
-0.0240929648,
0.0499331169,
0.0299207158,
-0.070124954,
-0.0432997569,
0.025905339,
-0.0107744373,
-0.0039780703,
0.0372367688,
-0.0309777707,
-0.0182153545,
-0.0102809174,
0.0475931428,
-0.0012908215,
0.0312764347,
-0.0042979862,
0.0194243193,
0.0318856388,
-0.0705371797,
0.0234418139,
-0.0039706621,
-0.0486718006,
-0.0522398204,
0.0064642639,
-0.0101263709,
-0.0424054898,
0.0550544783,
0.0048860968,
-0.0491346866,
0.0682476535,
-0.0573348738,
0.0026643465,
-0.0107044671,
-0.0104933949,
-0.0192530379,
0.0193008948,
0.0142351193,
0.0508496277,
-0.0099494541,
0.0126763433,
0.0244105142,
-0.0302616414,
0.0361004062,
-0.030986324,
-0.0379856564,
-0.0110612083,
0.0071322219,
-0.0317177102,
0.0214864705,
-0.0547131337,
0.0054489542,
-0.0001373412,
-0.0136387479,
-0.043428652,
-0.0297363158,
-0.0123728504,
0.0199426021,
0.021867387,
0.0385610685,
-0.0108951256,
0.0043987669,
0.0120576173,
-0.0222185776,
0.0387495123,
0.0281693041,
-0.0063858349,
-0.014986001,
-0.0383588523,
-0.0652962029,
-0.0559638366,
0.0821630135,
-0.0193187688,
-0.0136739053,
-0.0293832812,
0.0235009473,
0.0123957796,
-0.0020892452,
-0.0051751756,
-0.0628571287,
0.0233750753,
-0.0290912632,
-0.0440476127,
0.0420870483,
-0.0526960604,
0.0808738172,
0.0544439815,
0.0035178743,
-0.0403792337,
-0.038510371,
-0.0525156856,
0.0089826286,
-0.0332372971,
-0.0335521847,
-0.035465993,
0.0869835988,
0.0319773406,
-0.0397898741,
-0.0367788933,
0.0282686539,
0.0037775582,
-0.0454969332,
-0.0276765134,
-0.0490808636,
0.0044882214,
0.0897276178,
-0.0390801169,
-0.0136709036,
0.0684701055,
0.0017386659,
-0.003414596,
0.0223488305,
0.0138344821,
-0.0137739116,
0.1044226512,
0.0611305237,
0.0153853437,
-0.0006231968,
-0.0424682759,
-0.0454102978,
0.0138244415,
-0.0169699285,
0.0302159153,
0.0351513922,
-0.0265800599,
-0.0112252524,
0.022235414,
-0.0192687716,
-0.0230321195,
-0.0368787982,
0.0125494385,
0.0479164757,
0.0046387967,
0.0116445469,
-0.0411831811,
-0.0046550445,
0.0128579382,
0.0197592191,
0.0049891425,
0.01838197,
-0.0363929942,
0.0216797441,
0.0162167717,
0.0277672391,
0.033261627,
-0.0502920598,
-0.0317707658,
0.0073002507,
-0.0067614871,
0.0144972159,
-0.0495858416,
0.0728239566,
0.035213653,
0.0133020664,
-0.0115518905,
-0.0343444198,
0.0597075447,
-0.081853494,
-0.0282153022,
0.0938833132,
0.0213737953,
-0.0587330349,
0.0429755114,
-0.0160340946,
-0.0189514849,
0.0312506743,
0.0061938451,
-0.0249174442,
-0.0215673484,
-0.0006764357,
-0.0137745086,
0.005115476,
0.0016528978,
0.0300785005,
-0.0861597955,
0.0070843007,
0.0157588962,
-0.0459560305,
-0.0619280376,
-0.0049238484,
-0.0094318781,
-0.031440381,
0.0123043237,
-0.0073626097,
0.0362080298,
0.003698396,
-0.0085362392,
0.0161429606,
-0.0380830616,
0.0149017731,
-0.0315074846,
0.0537515245,
0.0745852366,
0.018375393,
-0.0265197232,
-0.0050630504,
0.0079977373,
-0.0128743164,
0.0176062174,
0.0002602816,
0.0379870422,
0.0247001015,
-0.0305375773,
0.0176454149,
0.0269844029,
-0.0514854863,
-0.0183234066,
-0.0507225879,
0.0608776696,
-0.024433203,
-0.0440483466,
0.0027201183,
-0.0396752991,
-0.0007155771,
0.0514846221,
0.0853173509,
-0.0110315699,
-0.0136753442,
-0.0427996814,
0.0205548778,
-0.013910016,
-0.0788281634,
0.0029056503,
0.0764928535,
-0.0423492752,
-0.015190972,
-0.0179975536,
0.0036535093,
0.0145231849,
0.0306256339,
-0.0115863662,
0.0086268689,
-0.0545205474,
-0.0518340953,
0.0562500507,
0.0257538427,
-0.0079138363,
0.0073891124,
-0.0495365337,
0.032385055,
-0.0363344029,
-0.0346511044,
0.0026791084,
-0.0484127328,
-0.0562762208,
0.0221317708,
0.0362039693,
0.0248268452,
0.0350045934,
-0.018989617,
-0.0707782954,
0.0354516879,
0.0262184273,
-0.0143641252,
0.0222037658,
0.0165571161,
-0.02335627,
-0.0299404096,
0.0609425008,
-0.0278993845,
0.0236978643,
0.0380350016,
0.0099381562,
-0.0226612892,
0.014051199,
0.0057054078,
-0.0302941874,
0.0512271114,
0.0038802736,
0.0306681581,
-0.0466381274,
-0.0246516801,
0.0219793152,
-0.0131327352,
-0.041225668,
-0.0046665054,
0.0432524942,
0.0277623497,
-0.0128699364,
0.0029845769,
0.035916429,
0.0155770024,
-0.0397506468,
0.0086511131,
0.0227389373,
-0.0090599582,
-0.0415165536,
0.0521313995,
0.0035893256,
0.0766581744,
-0.0269873757,
0.0411871672,
-0.0111624179,
0.0141017018,
0.010629911,
0.031777326,
-0.0785985813,
-0.0015815402,
-0.0735389367,
-0.0465459302,
-0.0097402856,
-0.0049081813,
0.0244333297,
-0.0735761821,
0.0456543714,
-0.0114182141,
-0.0036690491,
-0.0154345613,
0.0285082273,
0.0100733796,
-0.0189726185,
0.0185430609,
0.0290404316,
0.011209948,
-0.0114325341,
0.0762836635,
0.0173918977,
0.0213811509,
0.009121744,
0.0276656616,
0.0024932078,
-0.0087788487,
0.0419871658,
0.0403751656,
-0.0422883965,
0.0338416398,
-0.0036384533,
-0.0801963434,
-0.01144969,
-0.0038105068,
0.028177483,
-0.0250164196,
0.0223927256,
0.024637891,
0.0014657619,
-0.0226131435,
-0.0243652053,
0.0313907191,
0.0061696297,
0.0031577777,
-0.026079502,
-6.915231228e-33,
-0.0261774063,
-0.0528260879,
-0.0577346794,
-0.0304172691,
0.0205180496,
-0.0019462107,
-0.0746806189,
0.005900661,
-0.0180892125,
0.0316135474,
0.0265376344,
0.0260384083,
-0.0040355707,
0.039688725,
0.0425368771,
-0.0253784582,
0.0417684987,
0.0046132486,
0.0019479145,
0.0005080568,
0.0484029241,
0.0382629037,
0.0757958144,
-0.093616277,
0.0359837301,
0.0120052956,
0.0312312711,
0.0533594489,
-0.0198222641,
0.0499440432,
-0.0289471336,
0.0325452611,
0.0232677031,
-0.0253523737,
-0.0264137127,
-0.0454335511,
-0.0307269767,
-0.0616163574,
0.0145117687,
0.0377994105,
-0.0345403627,
-0.0483205877,
0.0934109017,
-0.0463149026,
-0.0076950821,
-0.0197323598,
0.0253350865,
0.0000355102,
0.0014566364,
0.0041049919,
-0.0853748545,
-0.0225427244,
-0.0365078673,
-0.0134416651,
0.087696448,
-0.0270116646,
0.0056037321,
0.0172934178,
-0.0675800219,
-0.0092924079,
-0.0068216277,
0.0595624857,
0.0710362643,
0.037794251,
0.0059550568,
0.0669935122,
0.0667405054,
0.0174022038,
-0.0685277805,
0.0088558821,
0.0516859144,
0.0464104675,
0.0563934967,
0.0189103466,
0.0800219923,
-0.0055381316,
-0.0304965507,
-0.0276194122,
-0.0327545479,
0.0002774088,
0.0678885132,
0.0172639061,
-0.0047787577,
-0.04793128,
-0.0460099131,
-0.070394814,
-0.0663454458,
-0.0168051384,
-0.0165412687,
-0.0564709976,
-0.0336389132,
0.0281174742,
0.0404687785,
-0.0614403971,
-0.0144808609,
0.0372318327,
0.0122365551,
0.0368346572,
0.0362206772,
0.006564959,
0.0008790308,
-0.0201569404,
-0.0140422788,
0.0093080485,
0.0396981798,
0.0380374007,
0.0475939363,
0.0310933422,
0.038322717,
-0.0402781777,
-0.051089935,
-0.0690033361,
0.0239929259,
0.0230330341,
0.0457720608,
0.040909715,
-0.0324519686,
0.0356641337,
0.0254306681,
0.0305757057,
-0.0084820036,
0.0119405845,
-0.0175179187,
0.0460177772,
-0.0441053174,
-0.0749042779,
-0.0410326645,
0.0072927959,
0.0665115714,
-0.0476763994,
-0.0098005636,
-0.0008580356,
2.801e-7,
0.0591948032,
0.0095476843,
0.0378473811,
-0.0009699319,
0.0526464358,
0.0364245251,
-0.0143663259,
0.0070295767,
-0.0375060514,
-0.0434301235,
0.0131187011,
0.0525693782,
0.0483201444,
-0.0078437533,
-0.0052958475,
0.043231234,
0.0009030098,
0.0279464237,
-0.0252775773,
0.0157791469,
0.0237772819,
0.1183122024,
-0.0115559865,
-0.004980206,
0.0554319061,
0.0160699692,
0.0404132418,
-0.0285544936,
0.0277671386,
-0.0009316966,
-0.035794571,
-0.0036984943,
0.0036971529,
0.0164682269,
0.0229557138,
0.0383722149,
0.016210882,
0.0254571419,
-0.0402884968,
-0.0124901617,
-0.0605918616,
-0.0221199822,
0.0111781722,
-0.0121985991,
0.0345370732,
-0.0490791462,
-0.0786264092,
0.0005726059,
0.0288010128,
0.0100982534,
0.0321808271,
-0.0152245918,
0.0098830611,
0.0171087105,
-0.0026308934,
-0.0344708413,
-0.0161276367,
-0.0514432713,
-0.0303173568,
-0.006313887,
-0.0629567057,
0.0204304066,
-0.0207829513,
-0.0121942535,
0.0340305977,
-0.0228013564,
-0.0172744412,
2.562663321e-34,
-0.002507332,
0.0244721416,
-0.0096635623,
0.0199301578,
0.0304835048,
-0.0576125458,
-0.0459482037,
0.0041993419,
0.0182094779,
-0.0347890891,
-0.0507475249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08594v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08594v1 | "Merge Conflicts!" Exploring the Impacts of External Distractors to Parametric Knowledge Graphs | 2023-09-15T17:47:59 | 2023-09-15T17:47:59 | Cheng Qian, Xinran Zhao, Sherry Tongshuang Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) acquire extensive knowledge during pre-training,
known as their parametric knowledge. However, in order to remain up-to-date and
align with human instructions, LLMs inevitably require external knowledge
during their interactions with users. This raises a crucial question: How will
LLMs respond when external knowledge interferes with their parametric
knowledge? To investigate this question, we propose a framework that
systematically elicits LLM parametric knowledge and introduces external
knowledge. Specifically, we uncover the impacts by constructing a parametric
knowledge graph to reveal the different knowledge structures of LLMs, and
introduce external knowledge through distractors of varying degrees, methods,
positions, and formats. Our experiments on both black-box and open-source
models demonstrate that LLMs tend to produce responses that deviate from their
parametric knowledge, particularly when they encounter direct conflicts or
confounding changes of information within detailed contexts. We also find that
while LLMs are sensitive to the veracity of external knowledge, they can still
be distracted by unrelated information. These findings highlight the risk of
hallucination when integrating external knowledge, even indirectly, during
interactions with current LLMs. All the data and results are publicly
available. | [
0.040472243,
0.012199997,
-0.0538463853,
0.0330422111,
-0.0304212496,
-0.0076321908,
-0.0157993026,
0.0101035396,
0.0301591791,
-0.042720288,
-0.0379777029,
0.023895679,
0.0197660625,
-0.0170242544,
0.0338639803,
-0.0645363778,
0.0532001443,
-0.0578911155,
0.0011480487,
-0.0052670394,
0.0076023387,
0.0217202716,
0.0010783597,
0.0279753935,
0.0157332849,
-0.0212295074,
-0.0361855216,
0.0227501672,
-0.0045858682,
-0.0130247148,
0.0262135305,
0.0568964966,
0.0029709153,
0.07546518,
0.0000023137,
-0.0521250069,
-0.0125289951,
-0.013153919,
-0.0540692769,
0.0159563664,
0.0033034133,
0.0193349142,
0.017970074,
-0.0160030313,
-0.0513557158,
0.0200023297,
0.007489217,
0.0333155952,
0.064116545,
0.0283533353,
0.0160251856,
0.0316814445,
0.009128849,
-0.0004918003,
0.0272972416,
-0.0105467783,
0.022608418,
0.0120709119,
-0.0285924859,
-0.0036209319,
-0.0237499494,
0.023658216,
0.0193058588,
0.0209018476,
0.0295754429,
0.0306658372,
-0.0263512339,
-0.0120102176,
0.0055600139,
0.0803910866,
-0.0241444129,
-0.0429970771,
0.0211209934,
-0.0280554984,
0.032155931,
0.0637469366,
-0.0625507087,
-0.009398425,
-0.0472138375,
-0.0250770543,
-0.0170482229,
-0.0342238173,
0.0366769843,
0.0127470316,
0.0082053142,
0.0510040596,
0.0057228981,
-0.0485715829,
0.0293873549,
-0.0027911018,
0.0427730531,
-0.0983258784,
0.0003854623,
0.0382184461,
-0.0229007769,
0.058083497,
-0.0363146178,
-0.0461675264,
0.0301774982,
-0.0860108808,
-0.003536843,
0.0144562963,
-0.0409081876,
0.056214612,
-0.0146317994,
0.0451139025,
-0.0313238464,
0.0354341045,
0.0020354923,
0.0589820966,
-0.0560521632,
-0.0353700966,
-0.0231259055,
0.0182081033,
0.0038376332,
-0.0164945051,
0.014009038,
0.0443675332,
-0.0124163032,
0.041279275,
0.0052311486,
0.0027380909,
0.0005974533,
-0.0266829077,
-0.042656213,
0.0331290476,
-0.0091187432,
0.0168937352,
-0.0199013688,
-0.0514793471,
-0.0097362166,
-0.00482326,
-0.0273984596,
-0.0176973995,
-0.0136995455,
0.0633621067,
0.0010006427,
0.0199754033,
-0.0478362478,
-0.058358483,
-0.006281727,
-0.0361721627,
0.0409990847,
-0.049328614,
0.0267294422,
0.0318048336,
-0.0114618018,
-0.062250033,
0.008837455,
0.0161048919,
-0.0492532291,
0.0450156182,
-0.0331929214,
0.0274434183,
0.0374873504,
0.0252276044,
-0.0335810818,
0.0808697119,
-0.010006967,
-0.015094161,
0.0277069919,
-0.0477876179,
0.0078854868,
0.0331211053,
0.0141357854,
0.0014724545,
-0.0253013149,
0.0030311511,
0.0218848921,
0.0023766656,
0.0335041285,
0.0382714272,
-0.0368946828,
-0.0285792872,
0.0885913894,
-0.0076168822,
0.0056274333,
-0.0002618477,
0.0220324714,
0.0040017045,
0.0171031971,
0.0679611266,
-0.046957057,
0.0081366273,
-0.0474046506,
0.0126937404,
0.0121525005,
0.0115057956,
-0.0288322307,
-0.0345753841,
0.0063267448,
-0.0133810919,
0.0141439624,
0.0131475208,
0.0554427095,
0.0273373295,
-0.0431271531,
0.0736327544,
0.0323737152,
-0.0376417637,
-0.0150178373,
-0.0158602186,
-0.0145703377,
0.0980648696,
0.0570241474,
-0.0145177618,
-0.0273745768,
0.0222982932,
0.0260368306,
0.0380275398,
0.0710392445,
0.0053720218,
-0.0204056893,
-0.0427971557,
-0.0354932696,
-0.0500270575,
0.0066611883,
0.0267094206,
0.0346375555,
0.0083939377,
0.000524676,
-0.0371650532,
-0.0626970008,
0.024874242,
-0.0592339225,
-0.0119083636,
-0.0847576335,
-0.0187256616,
-0.0032585766,
0.0074833767,
-0.0248433612,
0.0312915072,
0.0325381644,
0.0112012811,
-0.0002486483,
0.0507449359,
-0.0297636595,
0.0279030893,
0.0425358377,
0.0132171996,
-0.0316386148,
-0.0558766909,
0.0011627091,
-0.0284702815,
0.0614881366,
-0.0326498114,
0.1126794219,
0.0176025033,
0.0285357889,
0.0036171637,
-0.0148785636,
-0.0044727544,
0.0486717001,
0.0043720515,
0.0126154656,
0.0199509189,
-0.0177211165,
-0.0033560188,
-0.0004540325,
-0.0003756482,
0.024941979,
0.0022229941,
0.0248600133,
-0.01734538,
-0.052675508,
-0.0908415765,
-0.0050525204,
-0.0954283997,
-0.046484828,
-0.0008471474,
0.0194217302,
0.0457483269,
-0.0386242978,
-0.0266206432,
-0.0177804902,
0.0054004225,
0.0033131933,
-0.0341650471,
0.0278726891,
0.0046318984,
0.0128184976,
0.0049111047,
-0.0388787836,
-0.0098062987,
-0.022660112,
0.0451109894,
0.0206534546,
-0.0161787812,
-0.0537275411,
0.0465890728,
-0.0333533883,
0.0309392307,
-0.0347871706,
-0.0020671235,
0.0392543636,
-0.0062983655,
0.0526479781,
0.0506960601,
-0.0043708934,
0.0292696916,
0.0736060068,
-0.0526056886,
-0.0650328174,
-0.0087764105,
0.0195409842,
-0.0688766912,
-0.0266515482,
-0.0339025892,
0.0052608806,
0.0568716787,
0.0160760246,
0.0142560089,
-0.0566530153,
0.0147893457,
-0.063886553,
-0.0435379185,
-0.0376116931,
-0.0636873618,
-0.0457988977,
0.035147842,
-0.0303042233,
-0.0515221506,
0.0683432892,
-0.0308929849,
-0.0020021226,
0.008427334,
0.0187178291,
-0.0147724785,
0.0488977544,
-0.013368859,
0.0123726958,
0.0404419526,
-0.0026219306,
-0.0904217437,
-0.0145504884,
0.0186991002,
-0.0634220168,
0.0184606686,
-0.0726853162,
-0.000668101,
0.0261712484,
0.0196745507,
-0.058158543,
-0.0113671366,
-0.0231219549,
-0.0259676855,
0.0143645927,
-0.0306211542,
0.0317200385,
-0.0401659235,
0.0461973362,
0.0133252796,
-0.0061312546,
-0.0207466763,
-0.0057850895,
-0.0069113364,
0.0221497361,
0.0049702949,
0.013415426,
-0.0873246491,
-0.0061923997,
0.0506335311,
0.0644246042,
-0.0519206449,
-0.0258414503,
-0.0508226976,
0.0071178367,
-0.0163447708,
-0.0286725126,
0.0052310559,
0.034369614,
-0.0612036251,
0.0312475115,
0.0899707228,
0.0204465631,
-0.0636893138,
0.0029920631,
-0.0587819517,
0.0344529971,
0.0368020386,
0.0113084679,
-0.0870960206,
0.0061040646,
-0.004040705,
0.0072170137,
-0.02110398,
-0.0384987704,
-0.0370913148,
-0.1399156153,
-0.0063274195,
0.0348499343,
-0.0048429156,
0.0216115844,
0.0054524979,
0.0064355973,
0.0345043018,
0.0147463335,
0.010107277,
-0.0349930972,
0.0019798728,
0.0140463691,
-0.0414168686,
-0.016887065,
-0.0064160698,
0.0010108558,
0.0094828028,
-0.0106337545,
-0.0200507715,
-0.0048312992,
-0.0466632992,
0.0601830333,
-0.0122795822,
0.0259939823,
0.003113661,
0.0591665469,
0.004655919,
0.0140828965,
-0.0108962245,
-0.0284125879,
-0.0311713796,
-0.0346932448,
0.0343026444,
0.0711782053,
-0.0098007703,
-0.0380469412,
0.0216725133,
0.0220562238,
0.0238712095,
0.0499830283,
0.0371242911,
-0.0302112401,
0.0129488837,
-0.0317228474,
0.0519150943,
0.0225750562,
-0.0353670679,
0.0512242876,
0.0025867037,
-0.0146396244,
-0.0649702027,
-0.0488723293,
0.0296620857,
0.0207890179,
0.0346273184,
0.040181268,
0.0068119816,
-0.0295275953,
-0.0238902494,
0.0508659407,
-0.0103698596,
0.0169783123,
0.0060165464,
-0.0430621803,
-0.0330973044,
-0.0094568813,
0.022586409,
0.0431639887,
-0.0514664054,
-0.087228395,
0.004771743,
0.0360817872,
0.0412432365,
0.0415441357,
0.0144124283,
-0.0250513051,
-0.0215496309,
0.0104698939,
-0.058714781,
0.0415844843,
0.0136820544,
-0.0166387744,
-0.0038780456,
0.0044334373,
-0.0523132905,
-0.0535404012,
0.0193172898,
-0.0247820858,
-0.0855999291,
-0.0191578362,
0.0284644235,
0.0227676798,
0.0258794446,
-0.0081446674,
0.0078724707,
-0.0218735375,
0.0067740767,
-0.0125196408,
-0.0199263338,
0.0012026438,
-0.0284971539,
0.0112083992,
0.0190818775,
0.0491237491,
0.0030286587,
-0.0039883563,
0.0136120608,
-0.005390686,
-0.0398473293,
0.0218983218,
0.0186732206,
0.0686209947,
-0.011150673,
-0.0107747978,
0.043703597,
-0.0060084183,
0.0290856007,
0.0167312901,
0.0835785866,
0.0142157516,
-0.0212295521,
0.0067717503,
0.0046691899,
-0.0452592112,
-0.1171806082,
0.0238116067,
0.004580162,
0.0280994233,
-0.017541144,
0.06805145,
-0.0389866196,
0.0204856358,
-0.0007074616,
0.0064143217,
-0.0104021942,
-0.0099208653,
0.0318461731,
0.0397756398,
-0.0034123836,
-0.000227394,
0.0699196234,
0.001418173,
0.0679750815,
-0.0341769382,
0.0073154233,
-0.0291319191,
-0.0326578803,
0.0195683502,
0.043515984,
-0.039863959,
-0.0078699403,
-0.0992301032,
-0.0711584836,
-0.0444905944,
0.0182499643,
-0.01390504,
-0.0481678843,
0.0513819493,
0.0601706095,
-0.0155347744,
-0.0276922155,
-0.0098142661,
0.0335434712,
-0.0087542143,
0.0075083948,
-0.0108351987,
-6.690049857e-33,
-0.0325675718,
-0.0609030314,
0.0097458791,
-0.0124531146,
-0.0243997853,
0.0184906125,
-0.0270856135,
0.0378117412,
-0.0280970726,
-0.030164618,
-0.0084237605,
0.026284866,
0.0041881171,
-0.0453397743,
0.041471839,
-0.0099073742,
0.0391190946,
-0.0047099665,
-0.0072962432,
0.035225831,
0.0533781871,
0.0042576035,
0.0487783104,
-0.0804129913,
0.0653079748,
0.0036336279,
0.0196245108,
-0.0096638603,
-0.0462779403,
0.049949836,
0.0035721166,
0.0639095157,
0.0163071025,
-0.0007759331,
-0.0463662483,
-0.0130611807,
0.009146749,
-0.0556655526,
0.0688185692,
0.0427255332,
-0.0422500968,
-0.0342993662,
0.0761822015,
-0.0070918989,
0.001408841,
-0.0173782203,
0.0249213595,
0.0005332875,
-0.0195168834,
0.0534960479,
-0.0393487625,
0.0311385654,
-0.018920254,
-0.0069791405,
0.0063506165,
0.0164360777,
0.0077353064,
-0.0383050367,
-0.0548155084,
0.0406647436,
0.0300949905,
-0.0020023312,
0.0760446265,
0.0187435746,
0.0083331931,
0.0508531779,
-0.0165108033,
0.0656968579,
-0.0147596709,
-0.0341742709,
0.0173285715,
0.081846334,
0.0146281533,
-0.0051831389,
-0.0133832013,
-0.0187968202,
0.0049465308,
-0.0112394467,
0.011453744,
0.0408765078,
-0.0018013694,
0.0248106103,
-0.0189106055,
-0.0489034504,
-0.0041745743,
-0.0095620714,
-0.0122165317,
-0.0294599533,
0.0132636484,
0.0022337022,
0.0410143472,
-0.0289127696,
-0.0073416736,
-0.0201648716,
0.0047978451,
0.0327965058,
-0.0275867805,
0.0256560761,
0.0085741775,
0.0105539728,
-0.0774113908,
-0.0091181984,
-0.000190073,
0.0238886196,
0.0424165316,
0.0514571592,
-0.0037592074,
-0.0172725953,
-0.047342509,
0.0007779455,
-0.042944517,
0.028087467,
0.0336420462,
-0.0680834353,
0.0813446939,
0.0238337312,
-0.0222236253,
0.0135922274,
0.0415843464,
-0.0437065437,
-0.0524729677,
0.0319174007,
-0.0252429731,
0.0025753425,
-0.0020604699,
-0.0319018252,
-0.0089002065,
0.0325209647,
0.0842793807,
-0.0261087529,
-0.0182613339,
-0.0205345694,
3.058e-7,
0.0426116809,
0.0341433771,
0.0014087454,
0.0318319798,
0.0332829133,
0.0271553993,
-0.0495438352,
0.0175276306,
0.0044705649,
-0.0639392436,
-0.0223384853,
0.0409655496,
0.030473955,
0.0458826832,
-0.0736634284,
-0.0582945086,
-0.0499259196,
-0.0037616377,
-0.0684748963,
0.0163509622,
0.0579720587,
-0.0117779644,
0.0220080055,
0.0159247015,
-0.0518377721,
-0.0614428185,
0.0658383071,
-0.026742328,
0.0124852499,
-0.0062380214,
0.051512558,
-0.0197274089,
-0.0260388777,
0.0773003697,
-0.0026428774,
-0.0263926182,
-0.0102775469,
0.0352092721,
-0.0041605071,
0.01863054,
-0.0056244382,
-0.0059009804,
-0.031281732,
-0.0931693241,
0.045418974,
-0.0304691344,
-0.0147321625,
0.0077887843,
-0.0132588651,
-0.0374661572,
0.0151528828,
0.0101945428,
0.0041149119,
0.0048506525,
-0.0151085043,
0.0080825565,
-0.0160519984,
-0.0314703248,
-0.0390281044,
0.0667372122,
-0.0341328643,
-0.0819940642,
-0.0329796262,
-0.0034638494,
-0.0043947096,
-0.0076915361,
0.0262115858,
2.532602808e-34,
0.0145632206,
0.0103083421,
0.0468378626,
0.0047987807,
0.0283487737,
-0.0334318988,
-0.0073021268,
0.0511019602,
0.0240180958,
-0.0569527559,
-0.0007963812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08591v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08591v2 | Are Multilingual LLMs Culturally-Diverse Reasoners? An Investigation into Multicultural Proverbs and Sayings | 2023-09-15T17:45:28 | 2024-03-30T17:13:58 | Chen Cecilia Liu, Fajri Koto, Timothy Baldwin, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are highly adept at question answering and
reasoning tasks, but when reasoning in a situational context, human
expectations vary depending on the relevant cultural common ground. As
languages are associated with diverse cultures, LLMs should also be
culturally-diverse reasoners. In this paper, we study the ability of a wide
range of state-of-the-art multilingual LLMs (mLLMs) to reason with proverbs and
sayings in a conversational context. Our experiments reveal that: (1) mLLMs
"know" limited proverbs and memorizing proverbs does not mean understanding
them within a conversational context; (2) mLLMs struggle to reason with
figurative proverbs and sayings, and when asked to select the wrong answer
(instead of asking it to select the correct answer); and (3) there is a
"culture gap" in mLLMs when reasoning about proverbs and sayings translated
from other languages. We construct and release our evaluation dataset MAPS
(MulticultrAl Proverbs and Sayings) for proverb understanding with
conversational context for six different languages. | [
0.0253221449,
0.0538935252,
-0.0138598299,
0.0939581692,
-0.0258885659,
0.0307248179,
0.0690145195,
-0.0212700851,
0.0247287713,
-0.0090428051,
-0.0349649303,
-0.0237243809,
-0.0006435949,
-0.0345460214,
0.0284833629,
-0.0370603874,
0.0084580304,
-0.0446824655,
0.0343668871,
-0.0408071652,
-0.0146733271,
0.0456435904,
0.0016989942,
0.0339918956,
-0.0237329882,
-0.0138777969,
0.0093629947,
-0.017572619,
0.0426222943,
-0.0228561405,
-0.0378692187,
0.0094913524,
0.0142429387,
0.0102212112,
0.0000018066,
-0.0634429529,
0.0288591385,
-0.0302641876,
-0.0122271478,
0.0171116982,
-0.0140568595,
-0.0066479011,
0.0034452896,
-0.0078942012,
-0.0461888425,
0.0329363719,
-0.0118002379,
0.070339404,
0.0095263906,
0.042884957,
0.0133449743,
-0.0493641496,
-0.0189465676,
-0.0116127618,
0.0071811425,
-0.0804569647,
0.0153064718,
0.0615492277,
-0.0399612635,
-0.032221552,
-0.052434098,
0.0340338908,
0.0267667286,
0.0008049915,
-0.0763047263,
0.0206970461,
-0.0177669972,
-0.0217149071,
0.0080898805,
0.0450410061,
0.0217420366,
0.0028251573,
-0.0041468632,
0.0274671502,
0.006674354,
0.0001896268,
-0.0753759369,
0.0951908007,
-0.0247853193,
0.0059518586,
0.0133020766,
-0.024612736,
0.0160782952,
0.0265509952,
-0.0388329141,
0.0772295743,
-0.0057210894,
0.0003062178,
0.0190744549,
-0.0195461437,
-0.0176575407,
-0.0538603738,
-0.0181470253,
0.0395053402,
-0.0219192486,
0.045771502,
0.0195256118,
0.0385948047,
0.0141998492,
-0.0521578081,
0.0012006325,
0.0508698374,
-0.0017556285,
0.0697876811,
-0.0203915704,
0.0217261724,
-0.0032346656,
0.0543844365,
-0.0170977544,
-0.0722557381,
-0.0256494768,
0.0010149849,
0.010869476,
0.019731842,
-0.0041616876,
0.0130626438,
-0.0266144276,
0.0327896215,
-0.0175359529,
0.0250378307,
-0.0421797968,
0.0120331757,
0.0242733564,
-0.0409205072,
-0.0429790467,
0.0389790386,
-0.0314444229,
-0.0064885695,
-0.0197220147,
-0.084865056,
0.0014464487,
0.0210422613,
-0.0267557185,
-0.063748084,
0.0398291759,
0.0548955239,
-0.00690282,
-0.0147665916,
-0.0662632883,
0.0061128349,
0.0041780178,
-0.0524920896,
0.0117041646,
-0.0340936296,
0.0353237428,
0.032203,
0.0306501854,
-0.0740400776,
0.0379715636,
0.03560289,
-0.0256768074,
0.0444334075,
0.0701866299,
0.0487133525,
0.0544779971,
0.0196885839,
-0.0584250428,
0.0419959575,
0.0274124909,
-0.0075079696,
0.0575948916,
-0.02838259,
-0.0377500206,
0.0080447495,
0.0063360347,
-0.0062405681,
-0.0382433496,
0.0392571352,
-0.0059639136,
0.0013362881,
0.0263803639,
0.0446957424,
-0.023742618,
-0.0074408688,
0.0538025349,
0.0943328291,
-0.0167582836,
0.0104417549,
0.0378091671,
-0.0347550474,
0.0179701522,
0.0064327884,
-0.0589594506,
0.0365243256,
0.0098684942,
0.0000809808,
0.0333119445,
0.0895497352,
-0.0601901039,
0.0008513547,
-0.0233321991,
-0.0295707304,
-0.0125437509,
0.0082604205,
0.0040323939,
-0.0320938714,
0.0135533949,
0.0799128786,
0.0233473349,
-0.0480956808,
-0.0544274151,
-0.0485544056,
0.0716209412,
0.0180170089,
-0.0063166795,
0.0117124412,
-0.0313769691,
-0.0046648886,
0.0757182613,
0.0338109061,
0.0594612993,
-0.0091226501,
0.0453516655,
-0.0473850146,
0.0008308791,
-0.009170955,
-0.0115904519,
0.021886548,
0.0116032409,
0.0672133714,
0.020996267,
-0.0484123975,
0.0003793924,
0.0013721599,
-0.0532225259,
0.0123886084,
-0.0285546444,
0.0073144143,
0.0292889234,
-0.0127899162,
-0.0130800363,
-0.0170366857,
0.0204164758,
-0.0378336087,
-0.0180479083,
0.1053146794,
-0.0661638901,
-0.0453333147,
0.0590556338,
-0.0849229172,
-0.0666117519,
-0.0031999974,
-0.0231982544,
-0.0353773274,
0.0015670783,
-0.0163193401,
0.0280015804,
-0.0321642421,
-0.0074713896,
-0.0123630436,
0.0104353167,
0.0016353911,
0.0638714656,
-0.0063467938,
0.0144658694,
-0.0039742626,
-0.0000639381,
0.0322811045,
-0.0195994545,
-0.0110146608,
0.0193661433,
0.0142465001,
-0.0270854943,
-0.0109767336,
0.0242342986,
-0.03150516,
-0.013228287,
-0.0874732286,
-0.0068584569,
0.0040087285,
0.0117703099,
0.0047493596,
0.0020639794,
-0.0178750679,
-0.0373182222,
-0.071188502,
-0.0177562349,
0.0367795825,
0.0276698451,
0.0189819355,
-0.0295981728,
0.0014955017,
0.0197316855,
0.0064736232,
-0.011284804,
0.0684921667,
-0.0092770206,
0.0427428372,
-0.0086834142,
-0.0192353074,
-0.0969942883,
-0.0205231961,
-0.0287277419,
-0.0062529235,
0.0021854711,
0.0298328325,
0.0629430488,
0.0944396555,
0.0151694315,
-0.0115260575,
0.0365323983,
-0.0192335434,
-0.0452418849,
0.0210376661,
0.0192674883,
0.0105225462,
-0.0353693143,
-0.0584872849,
-0.0179672185,
0.043990463,
-0.0025725341,
-0.0008466537,
-0.0418702774,
0.0535389185,
0.000286483,
-0.0126117989,
-0.0235391166,
0.0120191853,
0.0170871131,
0.0650826842,
-0.0175941195,
-0.0280772299,
0.0556380935,
-0.0051793172,
-0.0324880071,
-0.0185109749,
-0.0102354176,
-0.0662048683,
0.0475498848,
-0.0619310103,
0.0208049323,
-0.071743913,
0.0065784226,
-0.0237397403,
-0.0472784005,
0.0200600754,
-0.0213713273,
0.0674284175,
-0.0428704657,
-0.0284499768,
-0.0554043092,
-0.0402179323,
-0.029250659,
0.0163931567,
-0.0727694333,
-0.0089041432,
-0.014167604,
0.0087538203,
-0.0364182889,
-0.0193080846,
0.0546790175,
-0.0392533801,
-0.0170877725,
0.0110094547,
0.0288638119,
-0.0299535617,
0.0185016245,
0.0752275586,
0.0508813821,
-0.0414856002,
0.0812473744,
0.0118948473,
-0.0121072512,
-0.0524811149,
-0.0113995112,
-0.0163888298,
0.0065248217,
0.025631614,
-0.0160316899,
-0.0203698333,
0.0642047152,
-0.0107776355,
0.0257074907,
0.0908471197,
0.0102918996,
-0.011125315,
0.0136749968,
-0.0912387669,
0.0445941165,
0.0197161715,
0.0109285824,
-0.0770343319,
-0.0286681093,
-0.0029524518,
-0.037884444,
-0.0022928624,
-0.0218845438,
-0.0293573607,
-0.0969887301,
0.0360283405,
0.0085678305,
-0.0251041111,
-0.0281763393,
0.0175981913,
-0.0274390373,
-0.013101601,
0.0428098962,
0.0109530333,
-0.0019276649,
0.0093130041,
0.0203438904,
-0.0002165675,
-0.0508750156,
0.0416800193,
0.0077551748,
0.0205158014,
-0.0207085982,
0.0595164113,
-0.0018360567,
-0.0555582829,
0.019521255,
0.0042059803,
-0.0032795118,
-0.0085740807,
-0.0163224954,
0.0273845159,
-0.0177038461,
-0.0157447401,
0.012607283,
-0.0392182544,
-0.0257899128,
0.0539333522,
0.0863370895,
-0.0288039576,
-0.0158970654,
-0.001973337,
0.0455345213,
-0.0628715307,
0.0998134166,
0.0213625766,
-0.0170863885,
-0.0081913024,
-0.0301247146,
-0.0456588082,
-0.0204759426,
-0.0354890376,
0.0084786145,
-0.0083935307,
0.0426741354,
-0.0334768295,
-0.0609214604,
0.0070792167,
0.0136717921,
0.0137311602,
-0.0246904548,
-0.0365211777,
0.0085317371,
-0.0167855937,
0.0274919979,
-0.0424709506,
0.0174741875,
-0.0078604408,
0.0160120707,
0.0420832485,
-0.0705126002,
0.0021935103,
-0.0145270405,
-0.0676027089,
-0.0624454878,
-0.0312927701,
0.0540100448,
0.0233313181,
0.0225272588,
0.0359783098,
-0.0214771014,
-0.007670409,
0.0095593482,
0.0061916923,
0.0348886028,
0.0386438593,
0.0561939105,
0.0130056515,
0.0544273071,
-0.0040511051,
0.0342734605,
0.038198024,
0.0408503376,
-0.0156794284,
-0.0190758053,
0.0103394967,
-0.0015123787,
-0.0530371703,
0.0182425249,
-0.0380673707,
-0.0193343218,
0.054912582,
0.0105876634,
-0.0269674528,
0.0005786493,
0.0078005674,
0.0021348093,
-0.0284704212,
0.0093947761,
-0.0518994741,
0.0259537622,
-0.0169002935,
-0.0001289196,
0.015915269,
0.0587137341,
-0.0197453536,
-0.0244894177,
0.0158077404,
-0.0115581239,
0.0024039471,
-0.0198702421,
0.0677272603,
0.0170897152,
0.0850090533,
0.0280326139,
-0.0408086106,
0.0289049577,
-0.0253630709,
-0.0850068703,
-0.1070228741,
0.0947490036,
-0.0026542512,
0.0834131837,
-0.0305197556,
0.0452531502,
-0.0074110073,
0.0147342542,
0.0085966084,
0.0206560735,
0.0471453294,
-0.0095596043,
0.0152070727,
-0.0097219413,
-0.0090395473,
-0.0007647962,
0.0583844967,
-0.0648309514,
0.0365890786,
0.0160022601,
-0.0148173179,
-0.0192525778,
-0.0224043466,
0.0367692895,
-0.0159552936,
-0.0044558677,
0.0305794254,
-0.0758296549,
-0.07695847,
0.0127754565,
0.0257950202,
0.0006096862,
-0.0078484453,
-0.0067974054,
0.0777809322,
0.0099931024,
-0.0083218347,
-0.0353780389,
0.0494027063,
-0.0436127856,
0.0279266443,
-0.0338023677,
-5.936076392e-33,
-0.01479619,
-0.017249763,
0.0183051601,
-0.0131038036,
0.0412924215,
-0.0215782374,
-0.04592162,
0.0050197728,
-0.0632586479,
0.0369670279,
-0.0324293151,
0.0117558567,
0.0011757748,
0.0258196481,
0.0286766868,
-0.0089759044,
-0.0044737286,
0.0249960739,
-0.0321639776,
0.0083565703,
0.0529320203,
0.0200701971,
0.05759608,
-0.0616672821,
0.022425456,
0.0080086235,
0.0486217886,
0.0321261436,
-0.0478084609,
0.0723626986,
-0.011370982,
0.0342470109,
0.0381038152,
0.0133646205,
-0.018529132,
-0.0178208146,
-0.0492103659,
-0.0525151305,
0.0644258112,
0.0148787331,
0.018202357,
-0.0457387008,
-0.0193125904,
-0.0343812443,
-0.0020095545,
0.0106340107,
0.0207462814,
-0.0128197139,
0.0130767412,
-0.0029815154,
-0.0191951562,
0.0172891766,
-0.0379492566,
-0.0145133333,
-0.0285924636,
0.0275012031,
-0.0236102007,
0.0223260093,
-0.0477547683,
0.0283214897,
-0.008780174,
-0.0416009352,
0.0637465268,
-0.0318987332,
-0.0158970039,
0.0546626784,
0.0053084381,
0.0246240217,
-0.001602977,
-0.0271175914,
-0.0037238479,
0.0422499888,
0.0327247642,
0.0531600416,
0.0070726117,
0.0015390491,
-0.0582155883,
-0.0150621934,
0.017287381,
0.0014899799,
0.0556073375,
-0.0012997153,
0.0243777148,
0.0147394575,
-0.0367784426,
0.0386261903,
-0.0063634175,
-0.0244886652,
0.0244035367,
-0.0213038549,
-0.0170892738,
-0.0198782515,
0.0680924952,
-0.0283055827,
-0.0155284461,
0.0300119538,
0.0200071204,
-0.0661575422,
0.0003709037,
0.0100262426,
-0.0397282131,
-0.0266197473,
-0.0235569682,
0.0010591677,
0.0023243593,
0.0235374346,
0.0524377376,
-0.003100137,
-0.02733046,
-0.0004104154,
-0.0570323654,
-0.0020736048,
-0.0618069991,
-0.0077900263,
0.0204381086,
0.0432021953,
-0.0262467843,
-0.0208415445,
0.0147587918,
-0.0390989631,
-0.0304500852,
0.0105722202,
-0.0215714686,
0.0214684457,
-0.0270497501,
-0.0185621809,
-0.0347240567,
-0.0059056878,
0.0091221649,
-0.0286568198,
0.0045882044,
0.0081478646,
2.5e-7,
0.0277080424,
0.0184845403,
0.0037630205,
0.0196930859,
0.0146764666,
0.011056859,
-0.0551691316,
-0.0120693278,
0.0066070165,
-0.0241946504,
-0.0348528996,
0.0728844106,
0.057742998,
0.0421376824,
-0.0637462214,
-0.0278258659,
-0.0713496581,
-0.0236467943,
-0.0381606333,
0.0196576826,
0.0294651501,
0.0679825395,
0.0012014272,
-0.0140137197,
0.0013412673,
-0.0239906162,
0.0610266514,
-0.0629352629,
0.0298305154,
-0.0183899216,
0.0249001868,
-0.0366827734,
0.0349970832,
0.0584318265,
0.0318203904,
0.0082851881,
0.0065664779,
0.0539469942,
0.0234844182,
-0.0312953666,
-0.0325955935,
-0.0214040168,
-0.0154418927,
-0.0875023305,
0.0572919324,
0.0061268164,
-0.0679150894,
-0.0172912087,
0.0493739806,
-0.0291631836,
0.0502829887,
-0.0093017723,
-0.0233888794,
-0.0047399187,
0.017614251,
-0.0311288442,
0.0527895689,
-0.0590834133,
-0.001983908,
-0.0079092784,
-0.0268401392,
-0.0619856194,
-0.0107038775,
0.0102112237,
0.0223283954,
-0.0199322738,
-0.0413330495,
1.754171279e-34,
0.009994722,
-0.0093271853,
0.0126573807,
0.0561556183,
0.0569840036,
-0.0067959139,
0.0077516451,
-0.0037787252,
0.0022777217,
-0.0303231701,
-0.0133790346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08590v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08590v1 | Neural Machine Translation Models Can Learn to be Few-shot Learners | 2023-09-15T17:44:21 | 2023-09-15T17:44:21 | Raphael Reinauer, Patrick Simianer, Kaden Uhlig, Johannes E. M. Mosig, Joern Wuebker | cs.CL | cs.CL | The emergent ability of Large Language Models to use a small number of
examples to learn to perform in novel domains and tasks, also called in-context
learning (ICL). In this work, we show that a much smaller model can be trained
to perform ICL by fine-tuning towards a specialized training objective,
exemplified on the task of domain adaptation for neural machine translation.
With this capacity for ICL, the model can take advantage of relevant few-shot
examples to adapt its output towards the domain. We compare the quality of this
domain adaptation to traditional supervised techniques and ICL with a
40B-parameter Large Language Model. Our approach allows efficient batch
inference on a mix of domains and outperforms state-of-the-art baselines in
terms of both translation quality and immediate adaptation rate, i.e. the
ability to reproduce a specific term after being shown a single example. | [
0.0066542602,
0.0321770906,
-0.0036191226,
0.0191201568,
-0.0107716229,
0.0155946491,
0.0699835047,
-0.0022005136,
-0.0549885146,
-0.0316574275,
-0.0330909453,
-0.0343190953,
-0.0106259994,
-0.0012588544,
0.0406760722,
-0.0498852991,
0.0120874019,
-0.0096259611,
-0.0327212438,
0.0120263519,
-0.0360306576,
0.0281768963,
0.0090125343,
0.0202835277,
0.0224714503,
-0.0032609582,
0.0107012745,
0.044027362,
0.0190722644,
-0.022526972,
0.0047396156,
0.0273471866,
0.059793964,
0.0475504547,
0.0000018983,
-0.0667200238,
-0.0375934727,
0.0080905557,
-0.0071095899,
-0.0110249482,
0.041991204,
-0.0617473833,
0.001358875,
0.0115756579,
-0.0267677344,
-0.0333892852,
0.0643488616,
-0.008800393,
0.0279261768,
0.1132196859,
-0.0073134745,
-0.0183473546,
-0.045800142,
-0.0694710016,
0.0029935399,
-0.0723559856,
-0.0011917555,
-0.0138753513,
-0.017162824,
0.032060042,
-0.0071657156,
0.0250368658,
0.0226788241,
0.0174783412,
-0.0255795326,
0.0155225247,
-0.0119795697,
-0.0156309064,
-0.0050324108,
0.0697779953,
-0.0407787561,
-0.0152730281,
-0.0241008252,
-0.0387084484,
0.0141169205,
-0.0371675156,
-0.0592700727,
0.0041970341,
-0.0002243547,
-0.0059039555,
0.0125361001,
0.055338975,
0.0407502465,
-0.0025193091,
-0.0495180637,
-0.0173301809,
0.0158742573,
-0.003867161,
-0.031918589,
-0.004229465,
-0.0444736667,
0.0038023405,
-0.0168860741,
0.0288402475,
-0.01001151,
0.0352892801,
-0.068633981,
-0.036323674,
-0.0056718579,
-0.0440439992,
0.0652701408,
0.0509598888,
0.016829446,
0.0807922632,
-0.0134155564,
0.0209614597,
-0.0452992953,
-0.022422649,
-0.0628265217,
-0.0226647537,
-0.0404758789,
0.039454598,
-0.0459529907,
-0.0104841273,
-0.0210179035,
0.0186035503,
-0.0164769925,
0.037981078,
0.010444019,
-0.0012941314,
0.0132074924,
-0.0305258594,
-0.093551673,
-0.0480935127,
0.0259282272,
0.0512857884,
-0.0268459022,
0.0037927222,
0.0205664523,
-0.0486379489,
-0.0497363098,
0.0012160597,
0.0156464279,
-0.0603641979,
0.0185629893,
0.0863818899,
0.0042700577,
-0.0431960002,
-0.0331452377,
-0.007144189,
-0.0189869255,
-0.0624805205,
0.0197194386,
-0.0655406639,
0.0388807878,
0.0096683651,
0.0175932609,
-0.0728777796,
-0.0217422862,
-0.0009857335,
-0.0196361244,
0.0488438718,
0.0118365586,
-0.0243459772,
0.0506080687,
-0.0080002621,
-0.0158101637,
0.0848879367,
0.0134581123,
-0.0090785511,
-0.0090042409,
0.0029817873,
-0.0110427449,
0.0462357625,
0.0393927023,
0.0442115739,
-0.0457844324,
0.0114365872,
0.0090266503,
0.0459053181,
0.0421752855,
-0.0133686671,
-0.0147249373,
0.0174119789,
0.0612658784,
0.0218551867,
0.0119152395,
0.036541827,
0.0524062961,
0.0134159904,
-0.0316418223,
-0.0267356448,
-0.0499375165,
0.0399064869,
0.0189261585,
-0.0051663048,
0.0150882229,
0.0330501124,
-0.0311044715,
-0.0173598696,
-0.000156827,
0.0089602415,
-0.0290768705,
-0.0094657475,
0.0582983419,
0.0736322403,
-0.0380888171,
0.0081333369,
0.037508484,
0.0081865788,
-0.0024487099,
-0.023264097,
-0.0010995395,
0.0163104869,
0.0426796228,
-0.0203975998,
-0.0459669568,
-0.0429500975,
0.0584439225,
0.0578976013,
0.0720717534,
0.0176966507,
0.0495658852,
-0.0214651227,
-0.0036181738,
-0.0368000939,
0.0391849503,
0.0211136583,
0.0278488174,
0.0263547432,
0.0344254076,
-0.0496609695,
-0.0253101643,
0.0340002589,
-0.0529479198,
-0.0737875775,
0.0634042919,
0.0210372489,
0.0331248306,
-0.0142058479,
-0.0353810489,
-0.0181164257,
-0.0142880352,
-0.0380719416,
0.0029792103,
-0.003415992,
-0.0597909279,
-0.0797365233,
0.0144105954,
-0.0095342118,
-0.0071421959,
-0.0456250682,
-0.0597444363,
-0.0140621616,
0.0063126734,
-0.0101505555,
0.0216124933,
-0.0173054729,
0.0275932308,
-0.0196230337,
0.0296335109,
-0.0536364727,
0.0388875715,
0.0305178147,
-0.0151895806,
-0.0078802379,
0.0028149984,
0.0059627062,
-0.013379707,
-0.0029890623,
-0.0178006515,
-0.0071718874,
0.0411847495,
0.0137148611,
0.0626090989,
-0.0162737537,
0.0123092076,
-0.0437694043,
0.0180061329,
-0.0178521983,
0.0226984192,
0.0436541773,
0.0536481328,
-0.0029790497,
-0.0261922199,
-0.0097991917,
0.0050978409,
-0.02580899,
0.0153785618,
0.0254084915,
0.0168095473,
-0.0005522816,
-0.0157540869,
0.0042831297,
-0.0038389675,
0.0542110577,
-0.016347941,
-0.0024676064,
-0.0676589534,
0.0512552932,
0.0073044752,
0.0202787668,
-0.0064216102,
-0.0279922001,
-0.0144954491,
-0.0313345268,
0.0066729048,
0.0682799518,
-0.0259463973,
0.0124851912,
0.0215605572,
0.0157209262,
-0.075691402,
0.0088812858,
-0.0388522819,
-0.0254283771,
-0.0276946109,
0.002618158,
0.0213584621,
0.0333424695,
-0.0119544594,
0.001655032,
-0.0390366875,
0.0534543656,
0.0227267034,
-0.0207340568,
-0.048369091,
0.0414191633,
0.0099191079,
0.0119179301,
0.0003118267,
-0.0285500735,
0.0804991871,
0.0100058448,
0.0112750903,
-0.064318426,
-0.0124999015,
-0.0226285048,
0.0377494767,
-0.0204020776,
0.0362454318,
0.0253541376,
0.000907247,
-0.0674945861,
0.0188878756,
-0.0039151474,
0.0219490621,
0.0394276343,
-0.0616519824,
-0.0131627824,
-0.0244097859,
-0.0104352273,
-0.0351768024,
-0.0164160989,
-0.0132258702,
0.0131789371,
-0.025367327,
-0.0245068334,
-0.0398107879,
-0.0120861046,
0.0299213529,
0.0839971229,
0.0044697532,
-0.0204980448,
-0.0116781415,
0.0210962221,
0.0188348051,
-0.0014254859,
0.0253716148,
-0.0352381617,
0.0459792539,
0.0052672997,
0.0136889257,
-0.0130057922,
-0.0568562374,
-0.0161112659,
0.0197116379,
0.0026377314,
0.0023199606,
0.0370996892,
0.0511353724,
-0.0706292763,
-0.0373940095,
0.0984645188,
0.0062001371,
-0.0739518702,
-0.0062866369,
0.0039409786,
0.0051407749,
0.0293613095,
0.0628371164,
-0.05737276,
-0.0423091091,
-0.0082998648,
0.0107977642,
0.0271230433,
0.0222186185,
-0.0415287651,
-0.1038034558,
0.0167856738,
0.0473403223,
-0.0921892077,
-0.0391011536,
-0.0122488169,
0.001291774,
-0.0262245294,
0.0235020481,
-0.0050385376,
0.0021047019,
-0.0240746271,
0.021433359,
0.0714759752,
-0.1031005383,
0.0376949757,
-0.066025123,
0.044511117,
0.0684370697,
-0.0086296657,
-0.0054768287,
0.0283783283,
0.0522606485,
-0.0267961528,
0.0019194339,
0.0102545889,
0.041148901,
-0.0002255951,
-0.0252654459,
0.0580469333,
0.0183970463,
-0.0575687326,
0.0270136315,
0.0456082076,
0.0519597344,
-0.0079402849,
-0.0031648711,
0.0193263963,
-0.0607670471,
0.0045344383,
0.0574283898,
0.0223228354,
-0.0674142614,
0.0211215429,
-0.0044164332,
-0.0498777032,
-0.0680772886,
-0.0071550896,
-0.0104327081,
-0.0523382016,
-0.0308397152,
-0.0852577388,
-0.0339006856,
0.0331038199,
0.0771236569,
0.002554951,
-0.0130518368,
0.0263207518,
0.0147193689,
-0.0203707851,
0.0457685031,
-0.049274154,
-0.0009234252,
-0.0519199707,
0.0247558746,
0.0361074023,
-0.053057041,
-0.0053811646,
0.0341504477,
-0.0859662965,
-0.0526322201,
-0.0047251242,
0.0613846965,
0.0139650134,
0.0582015887,
-0.0581562556,
-0.0308787245,
0.0778338462,
0.0514944457,
0.0169449411,
0.0050843586,
0.0171106607,
-0.0083951028,
-0.0150171639,
0.0510906167,
-0.0301614124,
0.0333897099,
0.0416473337,
0.0250935797,
-0.0240238905,
-0.0071140546,
0.0261946116,
-0.0425025597,
0.016295569,
-0.0295836795,
-0.0498111732,
-0.0036271045,
0.0323994607,
0.0104940133,
-0.0236875862,
-0.0436133891,
-0.0385079831,
0.0262064636,
-0.001540305,
0.0054489807,
0.0108803827,
0.0299994368,
0.0269953813,
-0.0228752326,
-0.0387077071,
-0.0185115449,
0.020934131,
0.0094270725,
0.0253326595,
-0.0126464143,
0.0213182848,
-0.0203567818,
0.0172428805,
-0.0572980419,
0.0544624403,
0.0009898639,
-0.0103875706,
-0.0279462673,
0.0241633244,
-0.0478732549,
0.0086721322,
-0.0646358803,
0.0074246796,
0.0787090361,
-0.0055210167,
0.0574753769,
0.0050589223,
-0.0204154346,
-0.0184113029,
0.0303355213,
-0.00525124,
-0.0088425828,
0.0024540194,
0.0144868195,
0.0130775888,
0.0218619872,
0.0707199946,
0.0388864502,
0.0310682803,
0.0341962799,
0.0323979184,
-0.0108357547,
0.0042012786,
0.0080314865,
0.0041446118,
0.0107943974,
0.0139529333,
-0.0203972626,
-0.0500700139,
-0.0055198944,
-0.0280683152,
-0.0178487021,
0.0075071706,
0.0224616509,
0.0682226419,
-0.0596679114,
-0.0079556089,
-0.012736965,
0.0051930347,
0.0229728557,
-0.0253261328,
-0.0248863455,
-6.234979994e-33,
-0.0326530598,
0.0167186111,
0.031267494,
-0.034561716,
0.018457517,
-0.0390510038,
-0.0411435477,
-0.036545679,
-0.0542466529,
-0.0044595208,
-0.0058565168,
0.031118745,
0.0097416071,
0.0268690735,
0.0063634585,
0.0028826767,
0.059875831,
0.0126599101,
-0.0120143844,
0.0243775994,
0.0162576959,
0.0151255615,
0.1047192141,
-0.065761745,
-0.0072143273,
0.0111381933,
-0.0240516942,
0.0206758175,
0.0001975236,
0.012380437,
0.0075578559,
0.0079902774,
0.024994554,
-0.0413254276,
-0.0311417785,
-0.0426400118,
-0.0756950006,
-0.0177693795,
0.0015795921,
0.0285597239,
0.0163384508,
-0.0410430692,
0.0538188145,
-0.0179834589,
0.0111378599,
-0.0327360816,
0.0137506686,
-0.0527552553,
-0.0380045213,
-0.0257475749,
-0.0622160546,
0.0088571999,
0.0197430551,
-0.0275774952,
-0.0056413999,
0.0452726632,
-0.0188913494,
0.0335980058,
-0.070879519,
-0.0069562094,
-0.0291789453,
0.0597748049,
0.0647772998,
0.0160362143,
-0.0179143194,
-0.0005357892,
-0.0160383116,
0.0069710803,
0.0411690287,
-0.0264835581,
0.0339858271,
0.0152180344,
0.0232127104,
0.0894297212,
0.0594175421,
0.0047221403,
-0.07983426,
0.0249250531,
-0.0111072687,
0.0100638149,
0.0362629443,
-0.0011453058,
-0.022645928,
9.595e-7,
-0.0412296467,
-0.0273719132,
-0.0496141352,
-0.0150214583,
0.0158033986,
0.0199143626,
-0.0184513554,
-0.0071158702,
0.0877444297,
-0.0467704572,
0.0096732266,
0.0143225556,
-0.0199567378,
-0.0227962956,
0.0033141724,
0.0346167013,
0.0096514402,
-0.0520905219,
0.0029027236,
0.0451918617,
0.0079219891,
-0.008543794,
0.0914046839,
0.011966696,
-0.0703213662,
-0.0096488306,
-0.0557273589,
-0.0048525059,
0.0055352575,
0.045953244,
0.0038978718,
0.0129125733,
-0.0122218179,
0.0565542877,
0.0580855198,
-0.0518108048,
0.0186053757,
0.0213942435,
-0.022057265,
0.0218372215,
-0.0562927462,
-0.0184158273,
-0.0024225917,
0.0163707472,
0.0500732996,
-0.0538310595,
-0.0319899768,
-0.016537698,
2.658e-7,
0.0332323052,
0.059308365,
-0.0509818122,
0.0021234271,
0.020477714,
0.0543779768,
-0.0330281258,
0.0454367846,
0.0147585655,
0.0220542122,
0.0396889746,
0.0089061102,
0.0622785725,
0.0249567237,
-0.0734110996,
-0.0065964684,
-0.0174207538,
0.0687029213,
-0.0475097746,
-0.010657181,
0.0067245318,
0.1321612149,
0.0271489192,
-0.0091946414,
0.0221395977,
-0.0657644197,
0.0740088075,
-0.0093914038,
-0.0157147814,
0.0047536446,
-0.042733442,
0.0546066575,
-0.0160710625,
-0.0023417715,
-0.0359195359,
0.0520571955,
-0.0136748319,
0.0813275203,
0.0070455391,
0.0249249768,
0.0105273426,
0.0006298978,
0.0052262596,
-0.0328186713,
0.0425318517,
-0.1252105087,
-0.0014067874,
-0.0071091815,
-0.0188134145,
0.0074601434,
0.0206219368,
-0.0184489135,
-0.0210629981,
0.0022146415,
0.0435332954,
0.0039893077,
-0.0481129177,
-0.0568372272,
-0.0418451726,
0.00945218,
-0.0166621022,
-0.0224741716,
-0.0165881868,
-0.0055851904,
0.0297140907,
-0.0354540795,
0.024976017,
2.469491389e-34,
0.0109209428,
-0.0101777948,
-0.0013351593,
0.017787125,
-0.0066922461,
-0.0112096071,
-0.0180732198,
-0.0055957153,
0.0400044955,
-0.0557969026,
-0.0116073349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08589v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08589v2 | Chain-of-Thought Reasoning is a Policy Improvement Operator | 2023-09-15T17:44:17 | 2023-11-08T18:10:10 | Hugh Zhang, David C. Parkes | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models have astounded the world with fascinating new
capabilities. However, they currently lack the ability to teach themselves new
skills, relying instead on large amounts of human-generated training data. We
introduce SECToR (Self-Education via Chain-of-Thought Reasoning), a
proof-of-concept demonstration that language models can teach themselves new
skills using chain-of-thought reasoning. During the self-learning loop, SECToR
asks models to solve addition problems using chain-of-thought reasoning before
training the next version of the model to solve those same problems directly
without using such reasoning. This process often results in an improved model
which can, when again augmented with chain-of-thought reasoning, solve even
harder problems than the original model, allowing the self-learning loop to
continue. Language models trained via SECToR autonomously learn to add up to
the longest-length-digit numbers without access to any ground truth examples
beyond an initial supervised fine-tuning phase consisting only of numbers with
6 or fewer digits. Our central hypothesis is that chain-of-thought reasoning
can act as a policy improvement operator, similarly to how Monte-Carlo Tree
Search is used in AlphaZero (Silver et al., 2017). We hope that this research
can lead to new directions in which language models can learn to teach
themselves without the need for human demonstrations. | [
0.0330868699,
0.1007476822,
-0.0121910274,
0.016442094,
-0.0254538245,
0.0274530165,
0.0044541908,
-0.0261201151,
-0.0089896424,
-0.0051157395,
-0.0124152824,
0.000946297,
0.0077359276,
0.0289054569,
0.052237682,
-0.0588474758,
0.0445617512,
-0.0561254695,
0.0138971452,
-0.0247873403,
-0.029522568,
-0.0018114925,
-0.0468578376,
0.0116921766,
-0.0035237079,
0.0033309786,
-0.0600025207,
-0.0512492098,
-0.0039407024,
-0.0328473747,
-0.0220243428,
0.0201985631,
0.040173091,
0.0752608255,
0.0000019926,
-0.0674097762,
-0.0272734296,
0.0074365917,
-0.051138889,
-0.0182726569,
0.0159341041,
0.0052669533,
-0.0254625883,
0.0262547508,
-0.0320861489,
0.0233765375,
0.0329072438,
0.0139918225,
0.0694919899,
0.0756309927,
0.0341250636,
-0.0288351383,
0.023502158,
-0.0266077016,
0.0321641304,
-0.0229777452,
0.0011548026,
0.0131217446,
0.0188079067,
-0.0083317077,
-0.0341315717,
0.0127110733,
0.0689125657,
-0.031831257,
-0.0244953819,
0.054323893,
0.0013937243,
-0.0129333595,
-0.0013910532,
0.0193967447,
-0.0465874709,
-0.0213185605,
0.017293036,
-0.0143511295,
0.0201400798,
-0.0081589064,
-0.0416591167,
0.0187480487,
0.0263686553,
0.0208230112,
0.0192154162,
-0.0191165488,
0.0523211621,
0.0152190933,
-0.0370325036,
0.1089255065,
-0.031488128,
-0.0339256525,
0.0353151858,
0.0050164554,
0.0072351573,
-0.0673981905,
-0.0373596437,
0.0634267852,
-0.0049637686,
0.0369007401,
0.0130107794,
0.0061138701,
-0.0074696229,
-0.0239945035,
0.0488732122,
0.0595485009,
-0.002947886,
0.0417670347,
-0.0493969768,
0.0080083841,
-0.0179785155,
0.0380383171,
-0.0125870695,
0.0395149365,
-0.0635912418,
-0.0238199402,
-0.0599760711,
0.0490088388,
-0.0024565842,
0.0144076543,
-0.0133970231,
0.0286070239,
-0.0165651999,
0.0151539426,
0.0015572601,
-0.002207472,
0.0053852829,
-0.0422764122,
-0.0622560717,
0.0239321347,
-0.0498144105,
0.011666947,
0.0468718186,
0.0251764022,
-0.0178120565,
-0.0254337434,
-0.0179836713,
0.0137288282,
0.040345788,
0.0569909103,
-0.0289305784,
-0.0056551159,
-0.0448741429,
-0.0201443601,
-0.0112545295,
-0.0802509338,
0.0283122864,
-0.0795241669,
-0.0134802051,
-0.028881304,
-0.0207352359,
-0.0275818538,
0.0207724869,
-0.0139954686,
-0.0237915795,
0.0786914825,
-0.0446933657,
0.0026018913,
0.0137186218,
-0.0112662427,
-0.0001205632,
0.0772186518,
0.0485737771,
-0.0074103512,
-0.0167321488,
0.0040510837,
0.028388219,
0.0333915651,
0.0279057138,
0.0293737575,
-0.0017538987,
-0.0004816605,
-0.0325836316,
0.0475126132,
-0.0049702642,
-0.0003394495,
-0.0263386574,
0.02357856,
0.0172387697,
0.0517166443,
0.002563155,
0.0379305631,
0.0525947772,
-0.0237048119,
0.0211470295,
0.0387400314,
-0.0588643104,
0.0364676043,
-0.0218572356,
0.0382917523,
0.0262315031,
-0.0113332802,
-0.020934511,
-0.0881064981,
0.0025580872,
0.0159299038,
0.0297717731,
0.0181898195,
0.060863208,
0.0452211387,
-0.004849683,
0.0118140578,
0.0288011357,
-0.051583644,
-0.0035262371,
-0.1116430387,
0.0154544385,
0.0329072438,
0.0494445972,
-0.037774466,
-0.0217910297,
-0.0255760457,
0.0250791311,
0.0188643616,
0.0458953865,
-0.0215314273,
-0.0259419084,
-0.0121950991,
-0.0378427617,
-0.0203391071,
0.0358364768,
0.017862102,
0.000173927,
-0.0307018906,
-0.0025588905,
0.0034099137,
-0.0207922086,
0.0228401292,
-0.0325861759,
-0.0189027619,
0.0056274161,
0.0210456718,
-0.0025529002,
0.0079943137,
-0.0068867751,
0.0311737657,
-0.000674033,
-0.0030670387,
-0.0523083024,
-0.0175428446,
-0.0575511828,
-0.0115505513,
0.0458297357,
-0.0113813523,
-0.0252757836,
-0.0050454726,
-0.0345209017,
-0.0402961038,
0.0686722174,
-0.0564591549,
0.0268588532,
-0.0316618606,
0.0358397178,
-0.0220682826,
-0.0358293168,
-0.0041224468,
0.0978267938,
-0.0209155995,
0.0076299575,
-0.0127672432,
0.0424392186,
0.0139392121,
-0.0437025949,
0.0327813849,
0.0193596967,
-0.0046179877,
0.0345684178,
0.0467802249,
0.0290095769,
-0.0535776131,
-0.0420361608,
-0.0254772883,
-0.0116353566,
-0.0238320865,
0.015839234,
0.008786412,
-0.0159973949,
-0.0110163474,
-0.0358320661,
-0.0128586842,
-0.0009992494,
0.0171616301,
0.002577781,
0.0305707809,
0.0210091118,
-0.0437077582,
-0.0307290461,
-0.0254493412,
-0.0496479683,
0.0102727208,
0.0213213786,
0.0276027061,
-0.0397162177,
-0.0013269292,
-0.0310825482,
0.031536229,
-0.0131777683,
-0.0317994095,
0.0510379039,
-0.0269525982,
0.0037289411,
0.0804663375,
-0.0111831166,
0.028710356,
0.085056968,
0.0116149401,
-0.0307204239,
0.0439894348,
-0.0311190262,
-0.0296152551,
-0.0313700214,
0.0187583286,
-0.0272076372,
0.0807161108,
-0.0333857425,
-0.0205972157,
-0.0515511185,
0.034192618,
0.0136593701,
-0.0400455445,
-0.0541411638,
-0.0127950404,
-0.0214973316,
0.039861124,
-0.0172160361,
-0.0327473693,
0.0837015808,
0.0056305039,
-0.0107587697,
-0.0806606859,
-0.0124224657,
-0.0191650745,
0.0725306645,
0.032110516,
0.0132414708,
0.0162224155,
0.0095455954,
-0.0539653413,
0.0038681531,
0.051811669,
-0.0094099268,
0.0320512541,
-0.0586685203,
0.0171756521,
0.0294571333,
-0.0684825927,
-0.0629193783,
0.0109832417,
-0.0446221307,
0.0171046983,
-0.0183907151,
-0.0432947464,
0.0027482905,
-0.0431492701,
0.074517265,
0.0690608397,
-0.0085162958,
-0.0363074802,
-0.0247215126,
-0.0210409034,
0.0280900076,
-0.0163514912,
0.0423399396,
-0.0266170651,
0.0569738373,
0.0015234475,
0.0897251368,
-0.001531406,
-0.0339064598,
0.0549912117,
-0.027353052,
-0.0333491638,
-0.0206435155,
0.049344793,
0.0046443846,
-0.08741083,
-0.037025135,
0.0939403325,
0.0358584151,
-0.0200474393,
0.0145433117,
-0.0435723625,
0.0286209565,
0.0538249984,
0.0516561829,
-0.0527659431,
-0.0054469001,
0.0366511978,
0.0135150244,
-0.0447688438,
-0.0526055694,
-0.0134656392,
-0.1287555099,
0.0010282957,
0.0104890997,
-0.0494566523,
0.0070367004,
-0.0308806766,
-0.0192374699,
0.0098051867,
-0.0383449346,
0.0288653225,
-0.008537842,
0.0263446271,
0.0256207827,
0.0210265033,
-0.0122772809,
0.0032532117,
-0.0036208769,
0.0309917089,
0.0836830065,
0.0065226257,
0.0063230861,
-0.0400468521,
0.0478756092,
0.0280180573,
0.0058231214,
0.0214242116,
0.0184330754,
0.0178339109,
-0.0224019364,
0.0173344482,
0.0821666569,
-0.0011386331,
-0.0117153944,
0.00602995,
0.076439552,
-0.0084179025,
-0.0351560302,
0.0106665138,
-0.0037037029,
-0.0197783951,
0.0247826409,
0.0263030156,
-0.0297410022,
-0.0196618065,
-0.0710361898,
-0.0484005176,
-0.0118598612,
-0.0736482218,
0.0051049124,
0.0388582163,
0.0142072588,
-0.0502326488,
-0.0309904609,
-0.0016243705,
0.0704238117,
-0.0160452016,
-0.0384751782,
0.0193822868,
0.0212840028,
0.0034132253,
-0.023751637,
-0.0442612134,
-0.0015442672,
-0.0493959896,
-0.01631229,
0.0030184339,
-0.0208809227,
-0.0260014776,
-0.021457471,
-0.0772358403,
-0.0592422783,
0.0010145877,
0.0825012997,
0.0306310654,
0.0480569676,
-0.0098576294,
-0.0482912548,
0.0486460477,
0.0371986888,
-0.0585126504,
0.0016883898,
0.0510595068,
-0.0028950975,
0.0156427603,
0.0340893492,
-0.0209089331,
0.0113175772,
0.0214761589,
0.0187136233,
-0.0459580868,
0.0275148358,
0.0609081835,
0.0033795333,
0.0288585536,
-0.0115922485,
0.0223221891,
-0.0187352896,
0.018095633,
-0.0061141173,
-0.0147056989,
-0.0236842129,
0.0072868126,
-0.0007254232,
0.0029072424,
0.0339832343,
-0.0340433121,
0.0265761856,
0.0192903578,
0.0411255211,
-0.012103389,
0.0128619662,
0.0688461363,
0.0220714789,
-0.0134016033,
0.0187843777,
0.0224377066,
0.0196363386,
0.0356932469,
0.0118792746,
0.0608335808,
0.0405016616,
-0.0114861699,
-0.0258175824,
-0.0025942849,
-0.1117845029,
-0.0930746198,
-0.0075462619,
0.0153465141,
0.0699413344,
0.004372526,
-0.0308350287,
-0.0619313456,
-0.0167091489,
0.0301883928,
-0.0123691857,
-0.0009400556,
-0.0555573925,
-0.0161793008,
0.0349226035,
0.0108552091,
-0.0287515931,
0.0532205552,
0.049166102,
0.0707977787,
0.0098262578,
0.0531294383,
-0.0191896372,
-0.0414212383,
-0.0479842387,
0.0271129124,
-0.0167030618,
0.0311257448,
-0.0333764032,
-0.0941556394,
-0.0589468479,
0.0450128354,
0.0250718296,
0.0042207809,
0.0494711101,
0.0252682883,
-0.076026246,
0.00301926,
-0.0171364192,
-0.0011507659,
0.0430058576,
-0.0106096752,
-0.0171021018,
-5.836463899e-33,
-0.0124524878,
-0.0219123121,
0.0666285008,
0.0091934521,
0.0251657125,
-0.0371952392,
-0.0549736992,
0.0480043814,
0.0019956641,
0.0488603637,
-0.0187620688,
0.0112688011,
-0.0061418763,
0.0176262502,
0.0356111638,
0.0076608909,
0.0460588709,
-0.0303430501,
-0.0446023494,
0.0079253102,
-0.0014427477,
-0.0024458293,
0.0424166955,
-0.0521008149,
0.0127676008,
0.0287088715,
-0.0344242267,
0.0610975474,
-0.0462287366,
0.0449510254,
0.0226548184,
-0.0013404883,
-0.0096489564,
-0.0837325603,
-0.0365865119,
-0.0232168194,
-0.058252316,
-0.0568967462,
0.0005583296,
-0.0309749562,
-0.047983408,
-0.0313297957,
0.0341448858,
-0.0047171144,
-0.0283082724,
-0.0176552553,
0.0075008869,
-0.0424220003,
0.0172841419,
0.024591716,
-0.0091703087,
-0.0016469163,
-0.0256575961,
-0.0364668593,
0.0204212572,
-0.0094618173,
-0.0130651873,
-0.0442258492,
-0.0237801559,
0.0422265306,
0.0395507924,
0.0160856359,
0.0848984942,
-0.0192615949,
0.0023294718,
0.0222886167,
0.0485962853,
-0.0233254395,
-0.0298160799,
-0.0259937961,
0.0418431498,
0.0376256704,
0.0658267066,
0.015583734,
0.0344121344,
0.0275434833,
-0.0521161743,
-0.0065306821,
0.0090380814,
0.0321863629,
-0.0108583942,
0.0020464116,
-0.0166258737,
-0.0144289145,
-0.0792084485,
-0.0280592702,
-0.0310041066,
-0.0275552049,
0.0068173478,
0.0413634293,
-0.0015314012,
-0.0346492343,
-0.0210162606,
-0.0361417532,
-0.0182970036,
0.0231943186,
-0.0273887124,
0.0200512353,
0.0101735797,
0.0279044472,
-0.0641832799,
-0.0117458878,
-0.0342896208,
0.0406366512,
0.0112477774,
0.0097171841,
0.053304866,
0.0395357795,
-0.0791781619,
-0.0012084323,
-0.046461381,
0.0293377023,
0.0373250768,
-0.0113685792,
0.011971443,
0.0044773668,
-0.0021155467,
0.0314568095,
-0.0097554252,
-0.0411777683,
-0.0379017442,
0.0523484945,
-0.0546618104,
0.0452076048,
-0.0097567439,
-0.0131980814,
-0.0490920283,
0.0217278153,
0.039002914,
-0.0705135316,
-0.0073881494,
0.0243974589,
2.748e-7,
-0.0140753193,
0.0375907682,
0.0074229655,
-0.0033168239,
0.0410393476,
0.0664936826,
-0.0556651056,
0.0011199214,
-0.0050471905,
-0.0549270026,
-0.0111889439,
0.0479783155,
0.021854531,
-0.0008222815,
-0.0521239601,
-0.0021372442,
-0.0598857254,
0.0134223141,
-0.044160042,
-0.0248595476,
-0.0200262871,
0.0586955324,
0.0676668659,
-0.0086391317,
0.0149508584,
-0.0344163254,
0.0495617688,
0.0172216147,
0.0197653174,
0.0001086211,
0.001177012,
0.0344374031,
0.0021395797,
0.0021005766,
-0.0210364368,
0.0332217067,
-0.0405658633,
0.0275377184,
0.024961926,
0.0143529652,
-0.0191929042,
-0.0072552538,
0.0006178951,
-0.023514675,
0.0822027996,
-0.0761757866,
-0.0037974752,
0.0009849409,
0.0433729813,
-0.0225959662,
-0.0003077976,
-0.0100918123,
-0.0207742713,
0.0191475768,
0.0023260235,
0.0182382744,
0.046400439,
-0.0707012787,
-0.0268446188,
-0.0041651251,
-0.0085565625,
-0.0241230987,
-0.0427762046,
0.0351462923,
0.0001219088,
-0.0451345257,
-0.0141580598,
2.41403928e-34,
0.0392167456,
-0.0444558151,
0.0299802385,
-0.0036027667,
0.0428898893,
-0.002855018,
-0.0144955888,
0.0072785183,
0.0590731353,
-0.0254810695,
-0.0165374447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08583v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08583v2 | ICLEF: In-Context Learning with Expert Feedback for Explainable Style Transfer | 2023-09-15T17:41:14 | 2024-06-17T17:52:54 | Arkadiy Saakyan, Smaranda Muresan | cs.CL | cs.CL | While state-of-the-art large language models (LLMs) can excel at adapting
text from one style to another, current work does not address the
explainability of style transfer models. Recent work has explored generating
textual explanations from larger teacher models and distilling them into
smaller student models. One challenge with such approach is that LLM outputs
may contain errors that require expertise to correct, but gathering and
incorporating expert feedback is difficult due to cost and availability. To
address this challenge, we propose ICLEF, a novel human-AI collaboration
approach to model distillation that incorporates scarce expert human feedback
by combining in-context learning and model self-critique. We show that our
method leads to generation of high-quality synthetic explainable style transfer
datasets for formality (e-GYAFC) and subjective bias (e-WNC). Via automatic and
human evaluation, we show that specialized student models fine-tuned on our
datasets outperform generalist teacher models on the explainable style transfer
task in one-shot settings, and perform competitively compared to few-shot
teacher models, highlighting the quality of the data and the role of expert
feedback. In an extrinsic task of authorship attribution, we show that
explanations generated by smaller models fine-tuned on e-GYAFC are more
predictive of authorship than explanations generated by few-shot teacher
models. | [
0.0480910949,
0.0843396485,
-0.0263600424,
0.0235862564,
-0.0239242613,
0.0107091693,
0.0544172302,
-0.0219248664,
-0.0399571024,
-0.0038754779,
-0.0337832309,
-0.0284280423,
-0.0023425471,
0.011637588,
0.0340555459,
-0.0427652001,
-0.0338757224,
-0.0393411778,
0.0495077893,
-0.004339044,
0.0317196399,
0.0247790422,
0.0160716902,
0.0183373932,
0.0152351605,
-0.0219494458,
-0.0197839942,
0.0299711805,
0.0035632192,
0.0624308214,
0.0136636076,
0.0732804164,
0.0301342625,
0.0255203247,
0.0000019056,
-0.0141606322,
0.0031013226,
0.0017270752,
0.002419065,
0.0428657234,
0.0227300543,
0.0221936554,
-0.0049998187,
-0.0219785906,
-0.004209449,
0.0149290822,
0.0358488336,
0.0395921171,
0.100336194,
0.0836451799,
-0.0069867354,
-0.0386310965,
0.0196436588,
-0.0180523377,
0.0136143034,
-0.0063715642,
0.0115009891,
0.0202687569,
-0.0290736333,
0.0052808323,
-0.0115480814,
0.0115011251,
0.0382052623,
-0.0820619166,
0.0436354354,
-0.0203416068,
-0.0125200013,
0.0069979737,
0.0257588252,
0.0677305534,
0.0235191789,
-0.0476763435,
0.0108341426,
0.0024458896,
0.0324481353,
0.0456833914,
-0.0708454698,
-0.0122282701,
-0.0145800533,
-0.0048155775,
-0.012491459,
-0.0211466085,
0.0313557275,
0.0251849219,
0.0100406101,
-0.0052644215,
-0.0032504348,
0.0044853291,
-0.0343285836,
0.0195302349,
-0.025343433,
-0.0531995595,
0.0164770447,
0.0251393411,
-0.0023816922,
-0.0101025663,
-0.0434358418,
-0.0297878459,
-0.032899119,
0.0070424327,
0.0898019895,
-0.0237943251,
0.0049356353,
0.0257667154,
-0.0000915319,
0.0470373929,
-0.0218470991,
0.039784994,
-0.0326255262,
-0.0253051464,
-0.088506408,
-0.0057934378,
-0.03501096,
-0.0208076648,
0.003544691,
0.0115666054,
0.0079132887,
-0.0317903906,
-0.0499154478,
-0.0053159609,
0.0273169279,
0.0237847865,
-0.0355147198,
-0.047085952,
-0.0000517319,
0.0295435078,
-0.0231265165,
0.0200336948,
0.0337116905,
0.0008623443,
-0.0368399136,
0.0263904445,
0.0192804541,
-0.026690552,
0.0037510844,
0.0142904222,
-0.0303584188,
0.0229840837,
-0.0107587725,
-0.0373111889,
-0.0115020061,
-0.0535519049,
-0.0196619704,
-0.0660815313,
-0.0062687309,
-0.0178951602,
-0.002248022,
-0.1061546281,
-0.0289918669,
-0.0023407196,
-0.031795904,
0.0487032309,
-0.0202711876,
0.0295626149,
0.0376745313,
0.002282585,
-0.0331970416,
0.0024689927,
0.0543868765,
0.0517879725,
0.0222867541,
-0.0305764545,
0.0625928417,
0.0038151126,
0.0542605296,
0.0453650467,
-0.0396141559,
-0.0266033337,
-0.0265310984,
0.0512502678,
0.0703820735,
0.0446368866,
-0.0146532971,
-0.0005792878,
0.086929746,
-0.0075287363,
0.0444669649,
0.047043521,
0.0627415255,
0.0349724591,
0.0243484229,
0.0223664548,
-0.0459971614,
0.0435367003,
-0.0021536574,
-0.0088666966,
0.0219564456,
0.0003716808,
-0.0192364473,
-0.0426789112,
0.0264009666,
0.012091984,
-0.0343606845,
0.0142861614,
0.0329951011,
0.049121391,
-0.0104627339,
-0.0123392036,
0.0311541706,
-0.0804336891,
0.0022536893,
-0.0574878156,
0.0513802804,
0.1156117246,
0.042913612,
0.0041166376,
0.0157011244,
-0.0312802754,
0.0240815431,
-0.0072673536,
0.0122312754,
-0.024688324,
0.0199919436,
-0.0230600666,
-0.0104689794,
-0.0459099188,
0.0214277692,
0.0150292572,
0.0017576877,
-0.0230143927,
0.020188069,
-0.0631935522,
-0.0891505256,
0.0367561616,
-0.0412732698,
-0.0499173328,
-0.0072544343,
0.0186377298,
-0.0040477808,
0.0218357053,
-0.0431799628,
-0.0086342646,
-0.0371783376,
-0.0411224924,
-0.0268012229,
0.0265776608,
-0.0276517607,
-0.034394037,
0.0181218013,
-0.0317383409,
-0.002140064,
0.0153829642,
-0.0379723236,
-0.0645817593,
0.0303059518,
0.0084892344,
0.0032831929,
-0.0326961726,
0.0018655711,
-0.0030541262,
0.0015118303,
-0.0271517336,
0.0152953342,
0.02862739,
-0.0327787958,
-0.0064744987,
-0.0015733994,
-0.0112128835,
0.0184959732,
0.0182196554,
-0.0194577165,
0.0133509822,
0.0329633839,
0.0010364268,
-0.0053050024,
-0.0317449048,
-0.0481556952,
-0.0557769798,
-0.0245545488,
-0.0272430833,
-0.0086525902,
0.0282832589,
-0.0124541959,
-0.0073209489,
0.0066267299,
-0.0527058914,
-0.0338271782,
-0.0601224862,
-0.0123937251,
0.0444031879,
-0.0033856311,
-0.0154547319,
-0.0685377494,
-0.0056525772,
0.0035262215,
0.0544300564,
0.0427848883,
0.03750154,
-0.0414983742,
0.0069417204,
-0.0093799792,
-0.0169915445,
-0.0167732667,
-0.0435957238,
-0.0076166955,
-0.0473165065,
-0.0033458699,
0.0634984151,
0.0000163237,
0.0351637304,
0.0209839046,
0.0014618428,
-0.0528430603,
0.0016127982,
0.0247837082,
-0.015667947,
-0.0209951233,
-0.0310233049,
0.0075642494,
0.0586087406,
-0.0063508358,
-0.0264345612,
-0.0680674464,
0.0485790074,
0.0360411704,
-0.0419432484,
0.0239764825,
-0.0377345718,
0.0123937912,
0.0420070179,
-0.0397474617,
-0.0623390898,
0.0548147112,
-0.0316814668,
0.0047209375,
0.0423941091,
-0.0194795188,
-0.042637337,
0.0610494912,
-0.0179948024,
0.0092043821,
-0.0040996643,
0.0054878332,
-0.0505159535,
0.0103101274,
0.0995441154,
0.007518223,
-0.0037936303,
-0.0537286475,
0.0076751113,
0.0135124223,
-0.0144453133,
-0.0018258389,
-0.0659505799,
-0.0300294608,
-0.0002743108,
0.0412390754,
-0.0470502377,
0.0149557311,
-0.0210037995,
0.0093885576,
0.0534822643,
-0.0385228842,
-0.0130767394,
0.0091606332,
0.022596851,
0.0229898002,
0.0012669103,
-0.0291758403,
-0.0777002275,
0.0271149911,
0.0133919632,
0.0216803867,
0.0217008665,
-0.0530914366,
-0.0119037116,
-0.0014183183,
-0.0156866573,
-0.0319936089,
0.0000063572,
0.0921610594,
-0.0691463202,
-0.0099112866,
0.1151688695,
0.0102193495,
-0.065322198,
-0.027856091,
-0.019665895,
0.0267541241,
0.0028028644,
0.0326199718,
-0.0352145471,
-0.0351161622,
0.0007332609,
0.0316646658,
0.0347100198,
-0.0199886058,
0.0055994247,
-0.0859979689,
0.0515485741,
0.0141190216,
-0.0237937979,
0.009438117,
-0.0285329763,
0.0051133148,
-0.015984349,
-0.0241443757,
-0.0027227374,
0.0166028533,
0.041595418,
0.0327068046,
-0.010179773,
-0.0375835337,
0.0218673125,
-0.0317657664,
0.0656725317,
0.0473279469,
0.0776682422,
-0.0006254581,
-0.0326343887,
0.0042296504,
0.0168755818,
0.0267798584,
0.0045739799,
0.1076075882,
0.0083251493,
0.0031264951,
-0.0225083567,
0.0675463676,
-0.0310051683,
0.0088908365,
0.0354933329,
0.0245740525,
0.0035514324,
-0.0233177226,
-0.0183415599,
-0.0236873496,
0.0205850024,
0.0453118905,
0.0699869692,
-0.068160288,
-0.0467004552,
-0.0476204567,
-0.0053782668,
-0.0617178604,
-0.0476009883,
-0.0093135471,
0.000223786,
-0.0267315395,
-0.079830043,
-0.0180041194,
-0.0036466753,
0.0553035513,
0.0260605905,
-0.0060605886,
-0.0361834615,
-0.013804419,
-0.0155292647,
0.0100502856,
-0.0306911636,
0.0417728722,
-0.0097459452,
-0.0299168359,
-0.0033102925,
-0.0497352704,
0.0157013834,
0.0054593515,
-0.0761397108,
-0.0492282659,
0.0007878431,
0.061583098,
0.0175527651,
0.0699989721,
-0.0165776331,
-0.1002321169,
0.0388577208,
0.0301335249,
-0.0061178971,
-0.0127883367,
0.0560545661,
-0.0211344082,
0.00173088,
0.0543106571,
-0.0120631512,
0.0338204391,
0.0605804883,
-0.0011887819,
0.0022260202,
-0.0142936893,
0.0178491268,
0.0205915198,
0.01925328,
-0.0241132397,
-0.0162304733,
-0.0322164781,
0.0013165707,
-0.0117967129,
-0.0386679433,
-0.067604661,
0.0084161097,
0.0318700634,
-0.0125424806,
0.0089405356,
0.0041902447,
0.0282971244,
0.0218347143,
-0.0637714639,
0.0156731363,
0.0186168961,
0.0560422875,
-0.003135219,
0.0199594796,
0.0067269485,
0.01371687,
-0.0067509692,
0.0575410575,
0.0183377657,
0.0445572548,
0.0559014566,
0.0295289848,
-0.0012326202,
-0.0011175497,
-0.115063332,
-0.0451897271,
-0.0277319662,
-0.0019519092,
0.0376040377,
-0.0000457429,
0.0839314684,
0.0260242596,
-0.0072201923,
-0.0019461546,
0.0897855386,
0.0153099354,
0.0064874291,
-0.0383127965,
0.0107132923,
-0.0085537955,
-0.0047881412,
0.0664752945,
0.0165873989,
0.0221878216,
-0.010939844,
-0.0159221236,
0.005381363,
-0.025309924,
0.0164014902,
-0.0158582404,
0.0590213425,
-0.0106046125,
-0.0235502869,
-0.0520713292,
0.0003807522,
-0.0077454839,
-0.0051451772,
-0.0350496806,
-0.0067794709,
0.0678851679,
-0.0323862247,
-0.0141581502,
-0.0492993519,
0.0192128178,
0.0233324133,
0.0016648246,
-0.0133607779,
-5.791208469e-33,
-0.0222396348,
-0.0222291425,
-0.0152056878,
0.011961923,
-0.031714417,
-0.020034207,
-0.0488847531,
-0.027789481,
-0.0014242376,
0.075912796,
-0.0448126569,
0.0343598053,
-0.0050484887,
0.0192965791,
0.0601643287,
0.0103611303,
0.0670672953,
0.0209699254,
-0.0542247817,
0.0590580516,
0.0389014594,
0.0173305571,
0.0651602745,
-0.0904622525,
0.0346830077,
-0.0133755216,
-0.0311060213,
-0.0041992599,
-0.0045560598,
0.006169566,
0.0383751355,
0.0285679065,
0.008177002,
-0.0338488184,
-0.0212995224,
-0.0285101701,
-0.0597176477,
-0.027549196,
0.0094259772,
-0.017104784,
-0.0138796214,
-0.0433128476,
0.0609733574,
-0.0036614488,
0.0328543782,
-0.0369967818,
0.0829629079,
-0.0171873663,
-0.0007448028,
-0.038431026,
-0.045651149,
0.0047007538,
-0.0555777475,
-0.0450986437,
0.0096988762,
0.0031416868,
-0.0195637103,
-0.0224473942,
-0.0532473475,
-0.0105183488,
0.0223219711,
0.0181027297,
0.0377189517,
0.0217380244,
-0.0030398681,
0.0476989932,
0.0162583105,
0.0653014779,
-0.0801113546,
-0.0241329465,
0.0207627658,
0.0697240159,
0.052466888,
0.1065455452,
0.0246447679,
0.0041358275,
0.0094284732,
0.0302710775,
-0.0254138522,
0.0152110718,
0.0038141129,
0.0219555143,
-0.0342427939,
-0.0423788913,
-0.0617298186,
-0.0660217926,
-0.0086129131,
-0.0073988601,
-0.0000362539,
-0.0397167467,
-0.0426812619,
-0.0229554065,
-0.0032514106,
-0.0540976003,
-0.0086856503,
-0.0141992988,
-0.0667167753,
0.0448970422,
-0.0133524332,
-0.0223049745,
-0.0338780507,
0.0091180224,
0.0241637602,
0.0503009558,
0.0317436606,
0.0122492583,
0.0845189616,
0.0422836617,
-0.0456772856,
-0.0331052728,
-0.0578409955,
0.0069858693,
0.0043428871,
-0.0167762209,
0.0069124615,
0.0353220478,
-0.0511997268,
0.0220925882,
0.0136067336,
0.026680572,
-0.0179635864,
0.0050018337,
0.0006860444,
-0.0197923854,
-0.0294059794,
-0.0371173173,
-0.0159082394,
-0.072398074,
0.0387130864,
-0.0401335433,
-0.0241049826,
-0.0190192983,
2.492e-7,
0.0090678493,
0.0359861851,
0.0262140352,
-0.0288782418,
0.0169311315,
0.0460058786,
-0.0014444084,
-0.0076176524,
0.0105564957,
-0.0154183442,
0.0515726171,
0.0553961881,
0.0988008529,
0.0092468951,
-0.0411812365,
-0.010413155,
-0.0633397177,
-0.0042312671,
-0.0302971881,
-0.0331063718,
0.0310482569,
0.013315767,
0.0720398277,
-0.0406291708,
0.0316697657,
-0.0310937166,
0.0658464283,
-0.0367040634,
0.0289365966,
0.0503817052,
0.0521277338,
-0.0395231992,
-0.0050899973,
0.0167941079,
-0.0056950012,
-0.0029999639,
0.0013997199,
0.0661121905,
-0.0189187657,
0.0454691164,
-0.0370056219,
-0.0129931681,
0.0338726826,
-0.0600741394,
0.0362466834,
0.0088882865,
-0.0234137885,
-0.0286252107,
-0.0497196354,
-0.0314083099,
-0.0043499763,
-0.0014453356,
0.0315984972,
0.0468396693,
-0.0067150891,
-0.0002448443,
-0.0024794505,
-0.0537642464,
-0.0627431944,
-0.0402813293,
-0.015829999,
0.0100893937,
-0.0107804788,
-0.0270654019,
0.0087589957,
-0.0489536561,
0.0549059883,
1.935949886e-34,
0.0407134406,
0.0012963486,
0.0288032349,
0.0141382739,
0.0476201698,
0.0265358109,
-0.0264548585,
0.0047429628,
0.041648522,
-0.0419530533,
-0.0107351337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08573v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08573v1 | Casteist but Not Racist? Quantifying Disparities in Large Language Model Bias between India and the West | 2023-09-15T17:38:41 | 2023-09-15T17:38:41 | Khyati Khandelwal, Manuel Tonneau, Andrew M. Bean, Hannah Rose Kirk, Scott A. Hale | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Large Language Models (LLMs), now used daily by millions of users, can encode
societal biases, exposing their users to representational harms. A large body
of scholarship on LLM bias exists but it predominantly adopts a Western-centric
frame and attends comparatively less to bias levels and potential harms in the
Global South. In this paper, we quantify stereotypical bias in popular LLMs
according to an Indian-centric frame and compare bias levels between the Indian
and Western contexts. To do this, we develop a novel dataset which we call
Indian-BhED (Indian Bias Evaluation Dataset), containing stereotypical and
anti-stereotypical examples for caste and religion contexts. We find that the
majority of LLMs tested are strongly biased towards stereotypes in the Indian
context, especially as compared to the Western context. We finally investigate
Instruction Prompting as a simple intervention to mitigate such bias and find
that it significantly reduces both stereotypical and anti-stereotypical biases
in the majority of cases for GPT-3.5. The findings of this work highlight the
need for including more diverse voices when evaluating LLMs. | [
0.0487906262,
0.0348562114,
-0.0536697954,
0.0366259553,
-0.0038448069,
0.0363346823,
0.0365067273,
-0.0306949914,
0.0631927922,
-0.0463619456,
-0.0015244314,
-0.0549145862,
0.0220550839,
0.0054599671,
0.0028109399,
-0.046037741,
0.0453047007,
0.0418152474,
0.023670271,
-0.000800007,
0.0235402472,
0.0504963063,
0.0008621825,
0.0718118697,
-0.0184548721,
-0.026459042,
0.0577698387,
-0.0282624103,
0.0008568852,
-0.0577751435,
0.0363982357,
0.0494871922,
-0.0030580359,
0.0314004049,
0.0000018731,
-0.0668199882,
0.0251700189,
-0.0126707619,
-0.0014224029,
0.0101762637,
0.0424462743,
0.0182444677,
0.001329983,
0.0401804745,
-0.033078257,
0.0291603189,
0.0466262437,
0.0088404017,
0.0170943942,
0.022389669,
-0.0031029207,
-0.0202691052,
-0.0515898168,
0.0234598368,
0.0062807505,
0.044996921,
0.0477996096,
-0.0193998963,
-0.0202507209,
-0.0170732401,
-0.0359053276,
0.0015781863,
0.0274344385,
0.0003311632,
0.0043563102,
-0.0139697688,
-0.0318540856,
-0.0301060323,
0.0309282076,
0.0377760492,
0.0193141084,
-0.025827948,
0.0115879048,
0.001611067,
-0.0299659353,
-0.0061182268,
-0.0013233348,
0.0451309532,
-0.0337156504,
0.0208680145,
0.0334442407,
0.0187664367,
-0.0106451288,
0.032855127,
0.0731756315,
0.0480471328,
0.0233444665,
-0.0242831148,
-0.0467047766,
0.0162784867,
0.0118552186,
-0.0430109762,
0.0038372432,
-0.0216607172,
-0.0322242379,
0.0547287948,
-0.0041213888,
-0.0045298049,
0.0224608257,
-0.0599447787,
0.0183182508,
0.0628940612,
-0.0180655476,
-0.0353188701,
0.0442871749,
0.0098843174,
0.0012274266,
0.0056509753,
0.0305882525,
0.0295319352,
0.035294164,
-0.0486607514,
0.0565186068,
-0.026142925,
0.023373697,
0.0767970085,
-0.0814054534,
0.0017200495,
-0.0437077209,
-0.010809618,
-0.0084754433,
-0.024418842,
-0.0104973726,
-0.035614036,
-0.0309119299,
0.0302398875,
-0.0652005821,
0.0164282452,
-0.0291623101,
-0.1288219839,
0.0331357978,
0.0064480454,
-0.0624121651,
-0.0251458976,
-0.0366964638,
0.0324542411,
-0.0040241703,
0.0023066048,
-0.0469842441,
-0.0041935127,
-0.0500028208,
-0.0355467722,
-0.0433486365,
-0.047435388,
0.0182451773,
0.0452470742,
0.0123131713,
-0.063601017,
0.0033607376,
0.0506173447,
-0.0331524536,
0.0493721329,
0.0155380089,
0.0220200904,
0.0681442991,
0.0564870648,
-0.0014089798,
0.0696012825,
0.0082853837,
-0.0272684172,
0.0375846662,
-0.0433881693,
0.024667263,
0.0325581767,
0.0003810529,
0.006429641,
-0.0491935834,
0.0278487653,
-0.0144748008,
-0.0359790325,
0.0067388308,
0.026179567,
0.0024453441,
0.0341441035,
0.0154189803,
0.0755652636,
-0.0358382203,
0.0396249928,
-0.0029586463,
0.0178865418,
-0.0120967021,
0.0062263464,
-0.0697680563,
-0.0220684279,
-0.0093926163,
-0.0282078627,
0.0044745351,
0.0591324084,
-0.0069006998,
0.0066866288,
-0.01709144,
0.0197455343,
0.028112432,
-0.0032177891,
0.011917212,
-0.0027930469,
0.024722103,
0.0421797633,
0.0789456815,
-0.0567553416,
0.0035204112,
-0.0539557114,
0.0419930965,
0.0255577005,
-0.0141861327,
-0.0114046019,
0.0292316433,
-0.0154667441,
-0.0058114552,
0.0683848187,
0.0390674174,
0.0065649608,
-0.019991478,
-0.025368223,
-0.008530681,
0.0648791566,
-0.0018775157,
-0.0019834994,
0.0280277375,
0.0298070237,
0.0201325361,
-0.0003799602,
-0.0389756709,
0.008858121,
-0.012157443,
-0.0152389091,
-0.0342377499,
0.0031405038,
0.0377803817,
-0.0024962905,
-0.0345444866,
-0.0457373224,
-0.0376344919,
0.0307118297,
0.0142765343,
0.0502416342,
-0.1017802954,
0.0208428483,
0.0030889381,
-0.0729504451,
-0.0191856641,
0.0141943162,
0.0040314775,
-0.0013091303,
0.0618722662,
0.0106794378,
0.0210525356,
0.0025810564,
0.0127200922,
-0.0550405942,
-0.0132026291,
-0.0136153558,
0.0043117893,
-0.0046939682,
-0.0103757642,
0.0142570632,
-0.0119388551,
0.0692402571,
0.0000254036,
-0.0465504974,
0.0361764729,
-0.0002965153,
0.0300822277,
0.034791749,
0.0081951013,
-0.0479407758,
0.0017623428,
-0.0809742585,
-0.0476627685,
0.0170620792,
-0.0190594289,
-0.0037143331,
0.034856867,
-0.0490317084,
-0.0033022352,
-0.0212950166,
-0.0385963134,
0.055562295,
0.0443490446,
0.0088653024,
-0.070778966,
-0.0000834251,
-0.0093211671,
-0.0351245701,
-0.0497393347,
0.0381563194,
0.0027939719,
-0.0220870189,
-0.0178631451,
-0.0213568229,
-0.0387489237,
-0.0226156563,
-0.0102140214,
-0.0586276874,
0.0173719991,
0.0512163229,
0.02324575,
0.0192192756,
0.0252274871,
0.0100319246,
0.0222429261,
-0.0208012722,
-0.034960594,
-0.0490552075,
0.032586921,
-0.0056335726,
0.0126275495,
-0.0968444422,
-0.0025267799,
0.0673553646,
0.0350722112,
0.0011182097,
-0.0537808761,
0.0100277811,
-0.090444006,
-0.0244913958,
-0.0160923693,
-0.0424330123,
-0.0443340391,
0.0317280665,
-0.0323413126,
-0.0736769587,
0.0364506766,
0.015606897,
0.0211151671,
-0.0266234521,
0.0180669893,
-0.0132284537,
0.0034037216,
-0.0143990107,
0.0323595367,
0.0209701974,
-0.0361244753,
-0.0519306324,
-0.0311353561,
0.0113144116,
-0.0289211236,
0.0354616381,
-0.0405333303,
0.0140984291,
-0.025867587,
-0.026195623,
-0.0236577597,
-0.0356411524,
-0.01827549,
-0.0333017409,
0.023540616,
0.0018149368,
0.0602085814,
0.0440360084,
-0.0032024737,
-0.0201757047,
-0.0140046682,
0.0194387063,
0.0289147347,
-0.0769729987,
0.023675207,
0.0025061583,
0.0459285229,
0.0071574654,
0.0444989353,
-0.0191556867,
0.0135058984,
-0.015328967,
0.0162468571,
0.0217726603,
0.034169104,
-0.0137716802,
-0.0209149513,
0.0331385694,
0.0824104548,
0.0092852693,
0.0201708376,
0.0699638575,
0.0073095192,
-0.0588656291,
-0.0087802159,
-0.050055109,
-0.0055919206,
0.0097460775,
0.0117293671,
-0.1349470466,
0.0139347371,
0.0229994413,
-0.0059179761,
-0.054005444,
-0.0277949758,
-0.0128658488,
-0.1001199707,
-0.0121348882,
0.0083936593,
0.0079926522,
-0.0111072008,
0.0159068387,
-0.0211109351,
0.0168783125,
0.0513514616,
0.005802732,
-0.0120104961,
0.0094338581,
0.0139632989,
-0.1007478237,
-0.0199298095,
0.0150825121,
-0.0141478404,
0.0100404173,
-0.0009050108,
-0.0182373263,
-0.0315054096,
-0.0074020252,
0.028233489,
-0.0476667434,
-0.0395715795,
-0.0138934683,
0.0171576571,
-0.0323236659,
-0.0198816657,
-0.0300527196,
0.0142797176,
0.0060134027,
-0.0023070576,
0.0404094942,
0.0453690216,
0.0272347219,
-0.0273999106,
-0.0316412076,
-0.003295888,
0.0075893993,
0.0449640602,
0.0320767127,
-0.0538362563,
0.041027274,
-0.087779209,
-0.0254357029,
0.0474489257,
-0.0935483128,
0.0210621953,
-0.0229778346,
-0.0253228769,
0.0324746706,
-0.0761407018,
0.0085450662,
-0.0089405123,
0.0625188127,
-0.0181799307,
0.0060486235,
-0.0164896864,
-0.0034365458,
0.0021641906,
-0.0595717989,
0.0414955728,
-0.0326712132,
0.0269843694,
0.0069509535,
0.007092414,
-0.0129740117,
-0.021655133,
0.0101964055,
-0.050155621,
0.0448173657,
0.0452042632,
0.0235641878,
-0.0020102523,
0.0127724363,
-0.0750008076,
0.0329299569,
0.0025080936,
-0.001456896,
0.0089693787,
-0.0139757395,
-0.018120233,
0.0069285263,
0.0243699569,
-0.0359181948,
0.0625072941,
0.0141615449,
-0.0237665344,
-0.0279532541,
0.0273950733,
0.0274126939,
0.0026010841,
0.0270585082,
-0.0590328015,
-0.0040789642,
-0.04751385,
-0.0311778616,
-0.0199850071,
-0.0611869916,
0.0069335401,
-0.0342028104,
0.0165945273,
0.0262432098,
-0.0190177299,
-0.0242228173,
-0.0416722074,
0.0273972861,
-0.0202905107,
0.0714155808,
0.027333606,
0.0843270272,
0.0203256886,
0.0108184246,
0.0075086253,
0.0136167509,
-0.0309999082,
0.0094551705,
0.0228303466,
0.0929590762,
0.0077221356,
0.0436195172,
0.0535114072,
0.0042987159,
0.0565587468,
-0.0362773053,
0.0226379484,
-0.0102814231,
0.0251408946,
-0.0397274233,
0.0441004299,
0.0278516952,
0.0051508881,
-0.0260138325,
0.0163008012,
0.0073695905,
-0.0281534474,
0.0747408122,
-0.0200014599,
-0.0406766981,
-0.0111297462,
0.0218073335,
-0.0225937888,
0.0184483789,
0.0236837529,
-0.0546337813,
-0.0138712768,
-0.0098355394,
0.0335097872,
-0.0293070674,
0.0201443192,
-0.0295123942,
-0.1019573808,
-0.0531380735,
-0.0510248877,
-0.0244643874,
0.0277558137,
-0.0397450104,
0.0086162705,
0.0481372178,
0.0104424246,
-0.0289736167,
-0.003962806,
0.0055290512,
-0.0524638444,
-0.0130024608,
0.011501343,
-5.673380221e-33,
-0.0271368604,
-0.0198556725,
-0.0089985337,
-0.0366762802,
-0.0088756271,
-0.0049040895,
-0.0155833177,
0.0279619116,
-0.0384553149,
0.0201140903,
-0.027152203,
0.0076293522,
0.015912272,
-0.0057627629,
0.0577065498,
-0.0007860974,
0.0331163704,
0.0190110095,
-0.0255158525,
0.0042179888,
0.0093960473,
-0.037911538,
0.0661951378,
-0.042744007,
0.0695619956,
-0.0527783707,
-0.0147263771,
-0.0073058666,
-0.0075653601,
0.024082439,
-0.0406614169,
0.08636792,
0.0528539494,
0.0053102798,
-0.0017184273,
0.0910800323,
-0.0125115141,
-0.0263999477,
0.0411021225,
0.0472477116,
0.0342578702,
-0.036692813,
0.0160708427,
0.0002186542,
-0.0962010249,
0.0461482219,
0.0316179805,
0.0125221461,
0.0460282452,
0.0288300086,
-0.0376483835,
0.0226957332,
-0.0225537419,
0.0409401692,
-0.0445035212,
0.0565660074,
0.0082578463,
-0.0054307189,
-0.0302981921,
0.0190090742,
0.0465876348,
0.0035474531,
0.044442974,
0.0459594652,
-0.0117801428,
0.0395211019,
0.0318954997,
0.0111532407,
-0.014505961,
-0.0560262613,
0.0275620762,
-0.0520034395,
-0.0163435936,
0.0605366901,
0.036435008,
-0.1136118919,
0.0149513101,
-0.0176382344,
0.0510200411,
0.0230775401,
0.0178171359,
-0.0140521089,
-0.0747806728,
-0.0836622864,
0.0146108801,
-0.0537750572,
-0.0044993791,
-0.0568495691,
0.0800428391,
-0.0482516885,
0.0137702497,
0.02815024,
0.0441457964,
-0.0275535118,
-0.0197069682,
-0.0105735883,
-0.0240893625,
-0.031180393,
0.0233283751,
0.0247560609,
-0.0685960054,
0.0015331594,
-0.0349490866,
0.0320440345,
0.0135549447,
0.0213255491,
-0.0113959303,
-0.0232316758,
-0.0869352445,
0.0155509971,
0.013785176,
0.0194648728,
0.0182832852,
0.044122383,
0.0457891338,
0.0213888306,
-0.0045242701,
-0.0170213766,
0.0601990148,
-0.0119080581,
-0.0355142169,
0.0013709582,
-0.022649847,
0.0312030185,
-0.0222820193,
0.0053227018,
-0.0525055788,
0.0145626403,
0.051363539,
-0.0452854224,
-0.0106237084,
-0.0342460126,
2.482e-7,
-0.0204247385,
0.0567812324,
-0.0166664794,
-0.0074219634,
-0.0086138127,
0.0260161608,
0.0179078523,
0.0079511497,
0.0469420403,
0.0147647792,
-0.0422859564,
0.0010337646,
0.0319069736,
0.0341475829,
-0.0395060852,
0.0368770398,
-0.0955851153,
0.0280440953,
-0.0446620286,
0.026297614,
-0.0251579713,
0.0362997465,
0.0189028084,
-0.0073741251,
-0.0750959739,
-0.0168643668,
0.0137303909,
-0.0435213074,
0.0127014555,
0.019374527,
0.0224730819,
0.0174716264,
0.0164678507,
0.0033640803,
0.0386248305,
0.0108120544,
0.0046218634,
0.0298079941,
-0.0025211328,
0.0859750509,
-0.0111820986,
0.0064390162,
-0.0052657598,
-0.0777871758,
0.0411353074,
0.0487234928,
-0.020931825,
-0.044374004,
-0.0282229967,
-0.0487025119,
0.0473534651,
-0.020444287,
-0.0215428565,
-0.0116212955,
0.0243127793,
-0.0426007919,
-0.0046168501,
-0.0310171992,
-0.0251366813,
0.0018976134,
0.0146642588,
-0.0667422786,
0.0068904022,
0.0163826253,
-0.0331677161,
-0.0041906489,
0.0449139513,
1.938499928e-34,
0.0412069447,
-0.0023079528,
0.072779268,
-0.0344324075,
0.06436003,
0.0303143132,
0.0371448174,
-0.0151662976,
0.039937336,
-0.0304345731,
-0.0092655485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08565v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08565v3 | How Transferable are Attribute Controllers on Pretrained Multilingual Translation Models? | 2023-09-15T17:33:24 | 2024-01-24T17:48:31 | Danni Liu, Jan Niehues | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Customizing machine translation models to comply with desired attributes
(e.g., formality or grammatical gender) is a well-studied topic. However, most
current approaches rely on (semi-)supervised data with attribute annotations.
This data scarcity bottlenecks democratizing such customization possibilities
to a wider range of languages, particularly lower-resource ones. This gap is
out of sync with recent progress in pretrained massively multilingual
translation models. In response, we transfer the attribute controlling
capabilities to languages without attribute-annotated data with an NLLB-200
model as a foundation. Inspired by techniques from controllable generation, we
employ a gradient-based inference-time controller to steer the pretrained
model. The controller transfers well to zero-shot conditions, as it operates on
pretrained multilingual representations and is attribute -- rather than
language-specific. With a comprehensive comparison to finetuning-based control,
we demonstrate that, despite finetuning's clear dominance in supervised
settings, the gap to inference-time control closes when moving to zero-shot
conditions, especially with new and distant target languages. The latter also
shows stronger domain robustness. We further show that our inference-time
control complements finetuning. A human evaluation on a real low-resource
language, Bengali, confirms our findings. Our code is
https://github.com/dannigt/attribute-controller-transfer | [
0.012782515,
0.0270281192,
-0.0188506544,
0.0443727374,
-0.0207876768,
0.0223101713,
0.0464863628,
-0.044246763,
-0.0544551015,
-0.0019284646,
-0.0639821514,
-0.0439823419,
-0.0087863645,
-0.0171619412,
0.0505940244,
-0.0381076671,
0.0368815362,
-0.027066661,
0.006534264,
-0.0170949865,
0.01638088,
0.0051304619,
0.0203030128,
0.0192022901,
0.0170326494,
-0.0086867101,
0.0196478702,
0.0215986986,
0.0135629857,
0.0178864691,
-0.0015935053,
0.0582142025,
0.0009481438,
0.0346142314,
0.0000020794,
-0.0471302234,
-0.010632406,
0.0125025231,
0.0059616407,
0.0062115006,
0.0812315717,
-0.0244509187,
-0.0174738858,
-0.0132173141,
-0.0211416408,
-0.0137866,
0.0786359459,
0.0000999326,
0.028765697,
0.0677950978,
-0.0217357222,
-0.0562253408,
-0.012407585,
-0.0507936887,
-0.0259992387,
-0.0806420967,
-0.0277444478,
-0.0359836817,
-0.0099121751,
0.0129225953,
-0.0585151315,
0.0575737841,
0.0124228122,
-0.0036824322,
-0.0096492572,
0.0028911033,
-0.022538187,
-0.0527712703,
-0.000707497,
0.0665753707,
-0.0589128137,
-0.0280973129,
0.010391457,
-0.0051546567,
0.0053777639,
-0.0386625491,
-0.0117395995,
0.0272926949,
0.0006520714,
0.0068411208,
0.0401369259,
0.0041188584,
0.0278784446,
0.0100199431,
-0.0335050151,
0.0451757349,
0.0150506841,
-0.0132251391,
-0.0131494002,
0.0340944938,
-0.0031968136,
-0.0465111546,
-0.0097761434,
-0.0057771164,
-0.0086969342,
-0.004402915,
-0.08282502,
-0.0550631396,
-0.0171180796,
0.005527297,
0.056064602,
0.0707217157,
-0.0116695995,
0.0412357934,
-0.0204988327,
0.0493796468,
-0.0682319328,
0.0538826995,
-0.045467291,
-0.027410958,
-0.004950169,
0.0024281594,
-0.0436825305,
-0.0433039665,
-0.0310445465,
0.0244141985,
-0.0415146649,
0.015278684,
-0.0255917925,
-0.005422811,
-0.0094463844,
-0.0322395563,
-0.0772266984,
-0.0391318835,
0.0139909005,
0.0469355881,
-0.0286312457,
-0.007123719,
0.0260204412,
-0.0492666401,
-0.0197846964,
0.0047801584,
0.0210443456,
-0.0568172447,
-0.0160537604,
0.0786805376,
-0.0726514533,
-0.0190222971,
-0.017218221,
-0.0222251453,
-0.017634172,
-0.0783142522,
0.0092456769,
-0.0390092656,
0.0569760688,
0.0415220708,
0.0116990702,
-0.0807727501,
-0.0180828981,
-0.0065498622,
-0.0092998305,
0.068966791,
0.0355407186,
0.0017680152,
0.0231530536,
-0.0141313653,
-0.0359092951,
0.061336793,
0.0174992308,
0.0327021107,
0.0208616462,
0.0049071582,
-0.0083922911,
0.0719948933,
0.046790313,
0.0425130278,
-0.048475448,
-0.0021558662,
0.0251801275,
0.0304543097,
0.0463002846,
0.0054225731,
-0.0200681593,
0.0177000705,
0.0824934393,
0.0163790975,
0.0165500157,
0.0343996137,
0.0836846754,
-0.0276422258,
-0.0051572174,
0.017074354,
-0.0357263871,
0.0360498875,
-0.0133347819,
-0.0095549803,
0.0154245785,
0.0496874489,
-0.0183224343,
-0.024882162,
0.0343009233,
-0.0152707417,
0.0094412668,
-0.0347602032,
0.0317973383,
0.0601698458,
-0.0174084269,
-0.0325394049,
0.0133278519,
-0.0270703342,
0.0291301068,
-0.034401305,
-0.0151551701,
0.0155427372,
0.0109297307,
-0.0100168893,
-0.046151787,
-0.0175552834,
0.0529172309,
0.0540702529,
0.0800150633,
0.0206779391,
0.0355497822,
-0.0286484957,
-0.0007466564,
-0.0139000257,
0.0139329564,
0.0307230595,
-0.0264560711,
0.054717727,
-0.0008788963,
0.0018244543,
-0.0887341574,
0.0360154994,
-0.0187632944,
-0.0279095136,
0.024426043,
0.0202515479,
0.0343267135,
-0.0242005903,
-0.0122016072,
-0.0051823426,
-0.035558939,
-0.0363887399,
-0.0075735897,
0.0329326093,
-0.0399201103,
-0.0295065027,
-0.0060912226,
-0.0040491694,
-0.0316491388,
-0.0367459729,
-0.0212246142,
-0.0579219125,
0.0370732881,
0.0122046061,
0.004182362,
-0.0105791949,
0.0352777131,
0.0178555865,
0.0286648609,
-0.0148018599,
0.0036142434,
0.0218074881,
-0.0365390554,
0.0240665376,
0.0298366565,
0.0029707893,
-0.017395556,
-0.0248815697,
0.0493538715,
0.0349495001,
0.0148152243,
0.0625723004,
0.0448419303,
0.0181064084,
-0.0146354437,
0.0020443837,
0.0075840671,
-0.0264243595,
0.0347453728,
0.0095809074,
0.049352441,
0.0010230656,
0.0074193799,
-0.0238379966,
0.0184109751,
-0.0067163007,
0.0114076957,
0.0189966969,
-0.0014360342,
0.0168871749,
-0.0101774344,
-0.006773293,
0.0307785384,
0.0288640372,
0.003977966,
0.0006894043,
-0.0409578159,
-0.0134132644,
-0.0266208164,
0.0147308698,
0.0015482319,
-0.0746379495,
0.0035641401,
-0.0400797613,
0.0162373576,
0.075804241,
-0.0201013144,
0.0126070417,
0.0197223946,
0.0092493808,
-0.051229272,
0.0161204077,
-0.0164814685,
-0.0350984521,
-0.0314291753,
0.0327197015,
0.0150321396,
0.1049956009,
0.0040037222,
-0.0164048094,
-0.0739933103,
0.0041225036,
-0.032214161,
-0.0619545057,
-0.0000422661,
0.0783527717,
-0.0016663164,
0.0629066378,
-0.0540563762,
-0.0493556671,
0.0818193108,
-0.0009065386,
-0.0337115936,
0.0021919291,
0.0030963805,
-0.0045742039,
0.039186012,
0.0001120494,
0.0183100961,
0.0204128549,
0.0047582374,
-0.0678109825,
0.0197852757,
0.0786526501,
0.0012103488,
-0.0027318229,
-0.0735897869,
0.0032780494,
-0.0367057696,
-0.0316749662,
0.0156047884,
0.0014988701,
0.0226818714,
-0.0083971918,
-0.0094311107,
-0.0326443985,
-0.007388196,
-0.0007591892,
0.0258209649,
0.0607829206,
-0.0481352434,
-0.0042666704,
-0.0072328444,
-0.0053215246,
0.016328074,
-0.0110292565,
-0.0154185882,
-0.0386213772,
-0.0028746342,
-0.0013811487,
-0.0242639333,
-0.0335439779,
-0.0129829142,
0.0068708514,
0.0610865839,
-0.0066299229,
-0.0461281762,
-0.0284097251,
0.081881389,
-0.0517911613,
-0.0604619719,
0.0800528824,
0.0015734372,
-0.0272739828,
-0.0056990483,
0.0018783824,
0.038254045,
0.0093250154,
0.0242576487,
-0.088624008,
-0.0343304761,
0.0023410905,
0.0166126881,
0.0112988418,
-0.0009870155,
-0.0324802846,
-0.1011618897,
0.0054031983,
0.0264481846,
-0.0855350345,
-0.0310725681,
0.0467874371,
-0.003040022,
-0.0336975642,
0.0312581807,
-0.0148768937,
0.0322881155,
-0.002644253,
0.003702075,
0.0462937579,
-0.0496629141,
-0.008487449,
-0.0487400442,
0.0403590761,
0.078695856,
0.0395422652,
0.000185257,
0.0064847744,
0.0339528546,
-0.0235906579,
-0.0160109811,
-0.0066848574,
-0.0042253188,
0.0055100331,
-0.0519207343,
0.044955425,
0.0675616935,
0.0494579561,
0.0330585465,
-0.0138675719,
0.049785357,
-0.0045325249,
-0.0136442976,
0.0067903637,
-0.0806896016,
0.0192955006,
0.0485073738,
0.0097659817,
-0.0928089768,
-0.0539799556,
-0.0408187769,
-0.0480979346,
-0.0548370294,
-0.0671590716,
-0.0135975014,
-0.0599998459,
-0.0693754777,
-0.0880459845,
-0.0646021888,
0.027219139,
0.0396808274,
0.0016682366,
-0.0127915703,
0.0109722763,
-0.0234147701,
-0.0212777406,
-0.0063288999,
-0.051707156,
0.0358084552,
-0.0584565662,
-0.0470580198,
0.0282216575,
-0.0426357649,
0.0076050037,
0.0276568327,
-0.0198715124,
-0.0798544213,
0.015615873,
0.0783623531,
0.017760694,
0.0537921228,
-0.0426172428,
-0.0709992945,
-0.0027447473,
0.0147741958,
-0.0232250225,
0.0127527453,
0.0607284643,
0.0265884567,
-0.0037283446,
0.0859570727,
-0.0086799581,
0.0479204804,
0.05257966,
0.026928803,
0.0331410132,
-0.0257403627,
0.0110813342,
0.0043692105,
0.0010189197,
-0.0641633347,
-0.0041153934,
-0.0329405814,
-0.0229421351,
-0.0277146194,
-0.0460328609,
-0.0495289676,
-0.0366255045,
0.0385782048,
0.0023460367,
-0.0112158339,
-0.0202912316,
0.0348935202,
0.0058945492,
-0.0559316054,
-0.0094638141,
-0.0177990701,
0.0483029746,
0.0173507426,
0.0494355969,
0.0166712385,
0.0296550635,
-0.0037722052,
0.021540653,
-0.0304770358,
0.0548795611,
0.0349618942,
0.0438777655,
-0.0246860515,
0.0267667454,
-0.0016532831,
0.024276685,
0.0106955506,
0.0338385403,
0.0624036342,
-0.0188462418,
0.1165690348,
-0.0261900816,
-0.0329939425,
-0.0016821293,
0.0630245134,
0.0260655005,
0.0025870616,
0.0214049127,
-0.0210233387,
0.0115202358,
0.0006905496,
0.0628969297,
0.023879068,
0.0173061192,
-0.0204018634,
-0.0087721506,
-0.0036037664,
-0.021647172,
-0.0120257903,
-0.0714151263,
0.0207387581,
0.0218380336,
-0.0623017289,
-0.0556954108,
-0.0259321313,
-0.0183497965,
0.0115002142,
-0.005345148,
0.0184279289,
0.050614439,
-0.0417055637,
-0.0114700058,
-0.0478534326,
-0.0182126407,
0.0661214814,
-0.0010493428,
-0.0144796185,
-6.375422916e-33,
-0.056482695,
0.0260978956,
0.0054551922,
-0.0120779574,
-0.0236163773,
-0.0311889946,
-0.0292215236,
-0.0174851213,
-0.0005245914,
0.0433446392,
-0.0330815129,
0.0005814321,
0.0176502205,
0.013065014,
0.0388661586,
0.0026055665,
0.0460404865,
0.0015513473,
-0.042516984,
0.0404895134,
0.0475700274,
0.009664271,
0.0814449787,
-0.0274026897,
0.0417572036,
-0.0278912298,
-0.0292859711,
0.0032903033,
0.0163597837,
0.0157832727,
0.0168838315,
0.0044007427,
0.0014236777,
-0.0698837414,
-0.0548396856,
-0.0343932994,
-0.1092211828,
-0.0242138263,
0.0075042322,
0.0412281416,
-0.0256003924,
-0.0654039085,
0.0533789992,
-0.0303523634,
-0.0178691745,
-0.0000389582,
-0.0011155064,
-0.0226476993,
-0.0086879795,
-0.0441816375,
-0.0952978656,
0.0161904395,
-0.0074729868,
-0.0141316056,
0.0348920338,
0.0110281045,
-0.0336682424,
-0.0270659085,
-0.0324163213,
-0.0099306908,
-0.0143448059,
0.0443357304,
0.0705349296,
0.0317173786,
0.0118328538,
-0.0330747142,
0.0419311412,
0.0372560211,
0.043710541,
0.0421460345,
0.0365736224,
0.0121418145,
0.0051004468,
0.0695781335,
0.0354669504,
-0.0434406959,
-0.0257065147,
0.0086754132,
-0.0131404707,
0.0339263827,
0.0308668576,
0.0281031784,
-0.0160033591,
-0.0290260427,
-0.0232594013,
-0.0410512611,
-0.0112922126,
0.0012290524,
0.0241726227,
0.0054774303,
-0.0526925325,
0.0110848201,
0.0982864276,
-0.0097067961,
-0.002052424,
-0.0084060179,
-0.0446978584,
0.0403150171,
-0.007862214,
0.0114165489,
-0.043456085,
-0.0433706306,
-0.0060822074,
0.0141895032,
0.0050658579,
0.0227914732,
0.0561402217,
0.0302067772,
-0.030906396,
-0.000730622,
-0.0639799684,
0.0157822687,
-0.0096592065,
0.0209313929,
0.0331324078,
0.0127851311,
-0.0247823056,
0.0505967848,
0.0515828021,
-0.0197009649,
-0.0007430753,
-0.0015125031,
0.0372714289,
0.0166258235,
-0.0691919476,
0.0149484975,
-0.0359413363,
0.0101008592,
0.018661879,
-0.0756045878,
-0.0081944549,
0.0046821651,
2.827e-7,
0.0226407927,
0.0413027741,
0.0054725818,
0.033258725,
0.0127355568,
0.0225562323,
-0.0166173223,
0.0281222463,
0.0043882248,
0.0200547967,
0.0210521091,
0.0492958985,
0.0444477648,
0.0178573709,
-0.0512785763,
-0.0244143233,
-0.0009992047,
0.0808451623,
-0.0337401032,
-0.0514211357,
0.0077909045,
0.0567893349,
0.0176330805,
0.0209667254,
0.0065716603,
0.0081706159,
0.0750574842,
0.0212431476,
0.0201581288,
0.0138298338,
0.0518613569,
0.0339196585,
-0.0475877523,
-0.0253630448,
-0.0246491674,
0.0089560021,
0.026690755,
0.0733442232,
0.0049832244,
0.0271468423,
0.017863892,
-0.0463416874,
-0.003894181,
-0.0265593957,
0.0748877749,
-0.0804908127,
-0.0141264172,
0.0248770937,
-0.0114527792,
0.0225788299,
0.0020215809,
-0.0406784266,
-0.0286085717,
0.0348303244,
0.0488939919,
0.01025848,
-0.0420939364,
-0.0273461211,
-0.036818359,
-0.0048467754,
0.0163526572,
-0.0391528346,
-0.012256192,
0.0274791718,
-0.0185796041,
-0.07472983,
-0.0321080387,
2.386018204e-34,
0.0107463961,
-0.0073592779,
0.0228561442,
-0.0186060518,
0.0116372537,
-0.0149213597,
0.0055432762,
0.010919489,
0.035354279,
-0.0149683356,
-0.040103063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08551v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08551v2 | Augmenting conformers with structured state-space sequence models for online speech recognition | 2023-09-15T17:14:17 | 2023-12-27T20:01:07 | Haozhe Shan, Albert Gu, Zhong Meng, Weiran Wang, Krzysztof Choromanski, Tara Sainath | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Online speech recognition, where the model only accesses context to the left,
is an important and challenging use case for ASR systems. In this work, we
investigate augmenting neural encoders for online ASR by incorporating
structured state-space sequence models (S4), a family of models that provide a
parameter-efficient way of accessing arbitrarily long left context. We
performed systematic ablation studies to compare variants of S4 models and
propose two novel approaches that combine them with convolutions. We found that
the most effective design is to stack a small S4 using real-valued recurrent
weights with a local convolution, allowing them to work complementarily. Our
best model achieves WERs of 4.01%/8.53% on test sets from Librispeech,
outperforming Conformers with extensively tuned convolution. | [
-0.048810944,
0.0469665267,
0.0317598134,
0.0341833346,
-0.0101258047,
-0.0173109658,
0.0552156381,
-0.0347879566,
-0.0270817149,
-0.0102889929,
-0.0298054367,
-0.0813378096,
0.0275580175,
0.0851634592,
0.0251394082,
-0.0295363292,
0.0115847662,
-0.0353561416,
-0.0158884525,
-0.0183467474,
-0.0169249102,
0.0015380617,
-0.0450304635,
0.0614125729,
0.0313787013,
0.0347437747,
-0.0373570994,
0.0270263925,
0.0117793391,
-0.052669324,
0.0029268055,
0.0153808305,
0.0706442446,
0.022455126,
0.0000020751,
0.0022439261,
-0.0192624945,
0.0280109197,
-0.0543221198,
0.0142264562,
-0.0258925892,
-0.0041731852,
-0.0234943628,
0.0467773639,
-0.0198222268,
-0.0057598157,
0.0447510369,
0.0133823333,
0.0109558813,
0.0785359293,
0.0045205639,
-0.0516369157,
0.0052496484,
-0.0608235337,
-0.0318234451,
-0.0294178929,
0.0065581822,
-0.0327094495,
0.0029525578,
-0.0129420627,
-0.0575056411,
0.0419901721,
0.0512793437,
-0.0014487181,
0.0313200019,
-0.0193395428,
-0.0253547952,
-0.020421451,
-0.0075909179,
0.0549958684,
0.0086841425,
-0.0145070087,
0.0249188785,
-0.0261809714,
-0.0302039608,
-0.0328675769,
-0.0211179126,
0.0231452454,
0.0154946316,
0.0174223222,
-0.0156486873,
0.0299170129,
0.0373988971,
-0.0004442035,
-0.0315867364,
0.0456341803,
-0.0107079186,
-0.0413852148,
-0.0262297858,
-0.0193057936,
0.0089421216,
-0.0351289138,
0.0619958825,
0.0371553227,
-0.0042198398,
-0.0019242089,
-0.0508914627,
-0.0164229497,
-0.0261542592,
-0.0269679762,
0.026246218,
0.0501019433,
-0.0353641286,
0.0138452202,
-0.0079154205,
0.0470130965,
-0.019555632,
0.0013145562,
-0.0026787445,
0.0202022847,
-0.0152826263,
0.0214877073,
-0.0148488339,
0.0086009689,
-0.0593160093,
-0.0577745065,
-0.0518795997,
0.02510144,
-0.0181735773,
-0.0146027394,
0.0225555282,
0.0043941834,
-0.0500525013,
-0.0036884635,
0.0263789371,
0.0473527275,
0.0646899194,
0.0021837051,
-0.0000462491,
-0.0552030317,
-0.0262617171,
0.024936188,
0.0534120165,
-0.0146677392,
-0.017291205,
0.0340665802,
0.0399843268,
-0.0360486098,
-0.0040077758,
0.0062345322,
-0.0475453921,
-0.0088332258,
0.0233907346,
-0.0167282019,
0.0184163582,
-0.0152510647,
-0.0145249031,
-0.0595800616,
0.0226021428,
-0.0209137984,
0.0700225979,
0.0406509861,
-0.0050278325,
-0.0294618383,
0.0006810794,
-0.0139431087,
0.0195618756,
0.0201270729,
0.0411040448,
0.0077375779,
-0.0270815548,
-0.0669067875,
-0.0076051066,
0.0367182083,
0.00726246,
-0.0216974318,
-0.0592420846,
-0.017837815,
-0.0068485662,
0.0391828455,
0.0406212509,
0.0356094874,
-0.0200365838,
-0.0130068818,
0.0449254327,
-0.0012981442,
0.0427424945,
0.0177938901,
0.0260120798,
0.0097959694,
-0.0222110674,
-0.0356281772,
-0.0072765318,
0.0350774005,
-0.0077296989,
0.0426992401,
0.0354792215,
0.0368313789,
-0.0176136587,
-0.0443261191,
-0.033626698,
-0.0295023695,
0.022515161,
0.0648476556,
0.0677087456,
-0.0009274124,
-0.0686398223,
-0.0176706128,
-0.027819328,
-0.0523622371,
0.0492780656,
-0.0087664826,
-0.0212601963,
0.0486586913,
0.0490992963,
-0.0174147487,
-0.0858505592,
-0.0507762693,
-0.006984232,
0.065480195,
-0.0312463157,
0.0120837661,
0.0481127203,
-0.0786989108,
-0.0598583482,
0.0292981919,
-0.0370127894,
0.0507029779,
0.003174027,
0.0232697781,
0.0266812481,
-0.0039053597,
0.0370807052,
0.0010868863,
-0.0220380016,
-0.0228422862,
0.0209448356,
0.029555846,
0.071626544,
0.0351593867,
-0.0073909112,
0.0017245209,
0.0688554123,
-0.0543828607,
-0.0405972935,
0.0072185248,
-0.1210414097,
-0.0359873548,
0.0283302218,
0.0179061871,
0.0406678207,
0.0492032357,
-0.0095763039,
-0.0856630057,
0.0289156232,
-0.0213242043,
0.0914826393,
-0.050001286,
0.0281585697,
0.0911507383,
0.0381620266,
-0.0028201509,
-0.019116601,
-0.0394586846,
-0.0081481608,
0.0114301899,
-0.0034654127,
-0.0498709194,
-0.0874694511,
-0.0264207646,
0.0239413064,
-0.0281022228,
-0.0151113803,
-0.0127313295,
-0.0031560052,
0.0128497751,
0.0207896959,
-0.0315285362,
-0.0355649889,
-0.0365862213,
0.0302555878,
0.0071070241,
0.0341199078,
0.012752397,
-0.0359404832,
-0.0307815503,
-0.0589017868,
-0.019076243,
0.0212993249,
-0.0219885334,
0.0060598147,
-0.0672382265,
-0.0232072957,
-0.0145765981,
0.0392049067,
-0.033944767,
-0.0603713281,
-0.0637853965,
-0.0474212766,
-0.0231614225,
0.0169050861,
0.0536187552,
-0.0360348634,
-0.0288338941,
-0.0178222265,
0.0053019645,
-0.0187218115,
0.0254559889,
0.0084613813,
0.0340098292,
-0.0074008331,
0.026604468,
0.0121749258,
0.0208123419,
-0.0094088055,
0.0393898226,
0.0117252283,
0.0546441823,
-0.0099315187,
0.0498942584,
0.0017371674,
0.0420050025,
-0.0681516752,
-0.0541468635,
0.0064994432,
-0.021624377,
-0.0118654594,
-0.050856784,
-0.0368279666,
0.0158265512,
-0.0009586767,
-0.0049875155,
0.012974686,
-0.0743578896,
-0.0571529754,
0.0073339841,
-0.0284784604,
-0.0246858336,
0.0202726815,
0.045723252,
-0.014890329,
-0.0018498305,
-0.0132466629,
0.017756436,
0.0145147424,
0.0011915084,
-0.045391608,
0.0310618579,
-0.0325592794,
0.034011241,
-0.0183269605,
-0.0430110991,
-0.0210378021,
0.0315814503,
-0.007870662,
0.0139904357,
0.0027171343,
-0.0378570855,
0.0182775818,
0.0652718097,
0.0048536137,
0.0875347704,
0.0081760054,
0.0536276884,
-0.0458664075,
0.0371994376,
0.0624749735,
0.0046413266,
-0.0117578078,
-0.0078066289,
0.0063653938,
0.0069929622,
0.0385833941,
-0.0102106249,
-0.0540269166,
-0.0195028856,
0.0511766635,
-0.0128761064,
-0.0027125943,
0.050934419,
0.0426285155,
-0.0762869194,
-0.002657068,
0.0941104367,
-0.020694878,
-0.0360803194,
0.001405425,
0.0284735244,
0.0220705513,
0.0303782839,
-0.0500034653,
-0.0575494952,
-0.0405576192,
0.0479515009,
0.0061863274,
0.0306708347,
0.0187023468,
0.0024871833,
-0.0739906952,
0.0167777482,
0.0278416667,
-0.0800676495,
-0.0389095359,
-0.0151450206,
-0.0170835238,
-0.0249722581,
0.0331310555,
0.037658222,
-0.0086976336,
-0.0051788632,
0.0433927402,
-0.047665406,
-0.0592588224,
-0.0075094067,
0.0033214625,
0.0741672143,
0.0880730897,
-0.0197057165,
0.0045344294,
-0.0860122293,
0.0548386723,
-0.010001434,
0.030495476,
-0.0208836012,
-0.0277672485,
-0.0179272685,
-0.0042599025,
0.0306516718,
0.0468704849,
-0.0770134777,
0.0181042459,
-0.0205775686,
0.046717193,
-0.0234956853,
0.0353665128,
0.0021460983,
-0.0149512002,
0.0336999446,
0.0450124592,
0.0173581373,
-0.0071882638,
-0.0312792733,
0.0271780677,
0.0504013859,
-0.0142052304,
0.0318732485,
-0.0322216004,
0.0086069312,
-0.0400028974,
-0.0483446345,
-0.0007931325,
0.0110648368,
0.0283079781,
-0.013080108,
-0.0086098444,
0.0079313237,
0.0085767703,
-0.0440381728,
0.0020521311,
-0.034223333,
0.0434924811,
-0.0522742011,
-0.0272894111,
0.0174460728,
-0.0192361828,
-0.020053694,
0.0095079709,
-0.0736860558,
-0.0569152087,
0.0319608822,
0.001710383,
0.0160422679,
0.0404658653,
-0.0248434599,
0.0137586668,
0.0423571169,
-0.0301160347,
0.0178522374,
0.020058332,
0.0685423166,
0.0269442424,
-0.0152868629,
0.0110054817,
-0.0471852049,
0.018479282,
-0.006207942,
0.0405554846,
-0.0067878333,
-0.0357294343,
-0.0202563759,
0.0104637584,
0.074405551,
-0.0086605521,
-0.0518083014,
0.0228452776,
0.0665980056,
-0.0167647675,
0.0578516126,
-0.0267694946,
-0.0091520092,
-0.0067802481,
0.0040273014,
0.0116261235,
0.0541228689,
0.0081396261,
-0.0150865903,
0.0112147247,
0.0599689521,
0.0096313367,
-0.0111934142,
0.0027286143,
0.0086530168,
-0.0134481415,
0.046267774,
0.0581746399,
0.0255750027,
-0.0193362683,
0.0396761149,
-0.0057939095,
0.0585473813,
0.0141970031,
0.0627004206,
-0.0537767336,
0.0117259761,
-0.0619211234,
0.0044073216,
0.039212402,
0.0068580052,
0.0395001434,
0.0593675412,
0.0156947151,
-0.043312937,
0.0678260326,
-0.0140538756,
-0.0251491219,
0.0516258739,
0.0156076271,
-0.0251463279,
0.0603776611,
0.050981652,
0.0189953912,
0.0524580181,
0.0111705475,
0.0572278462,
-0.0216048509,
-0.0656352937,
-0.026408596,
0.0358605683,
-0.0210900437,
-0.0460160784,
0.0061307335,
-0.0689952895,
0.0541320033,
-0.0149841132,
0.0130496081,
-0.027311001,
0.0202093367,
-0.0367858894,
-0.0334122404,
-0.0149901109,
0.0086582145,
-0.0476126708,
0.0218714122,
-0.058316797,
-0.0290711038,
-6.691255473e-33,
-0.0200306103,
0.010780246,
0.0143033154,
-0.0247547925,
-0.0648410097,
-0.0061455318,
-0.03588311,
0.0027252575,
0.0252043922,
-0.0620307401,
-0.007963093,
-0.0052991966,
0.0370822959,
0.0549105629,
-0.0190042481,
-0.0454943329,
0.0854545012,
0.025748184,
0.0074180104,
0.000743547,
0.0187014751,
0.0304451771,
0.0271711759,
0.002682314,
-0.0488492809,
0.0169539619,
0.006979947,
-0.0447561666,
0.0002688339,
0.0153692821,
0.0075939219,
0.0289123096,
-0.0053575244,
-0.0253472123,
-0.0051309513,
-0.0099225109,
-0.030862432,
0.0392745435,
-0.0387948155,
0.0304880776,
-0.0209823325,
-0.0260516014,
0.0506399609,
0.0158090275,
-0.0412971564,
0.0055297809,
0.0192601532,
-0.0239706282,
-0.0737043843,
-0.050940074,
-0.0041054809,
0.0255187452,
-0.0282448772,
-0.0214996096,
0.0382198915,
0.0533991382,
-0.0103132408,
-0.0049965749,
-0.0708883032,
0.0042449683,
0.0010911665,
0.0678647906,
0.0826555863,
0.02902174,
0.0338428728,
-0.0077247536,
-0.0037811925,
-0.0583248362,
-0.0148343826,
-0.0101166917,
0.0234889984,
0.0124369841,
0.0254528522,
0.00393584,
0.0514828563,
-0.030072622,
-0.0087654656,
-0.021088941,
0.0079952953,
0.0409525856,
0.0103773428,
0.0661579669,
-0.0423359238,
0.0021496348,
-0.0154373711,
-0.0553468913,
-0.0026058885,
-0.0197772048,
0.0546676069,
0.0285375733,
0.0076258099,
0.0118601201,
0.060697712,
-0.0195012353,
0.0486628637,
0.0069510234,
0.0283538308,
-0.0000101768,
0.009803094,
-0.0161385052,
-0.0491801761,
-0.0091883373,
0.0475316457,
0.0153958676,
-0.0139384456,
-0.0577965789,
0.0250020809,
0.0804675445,
-0.0494144261,
-0.0239500254,
-0.0367172435,
0.0480571277,
0.0016481725,
0.0465766713,
0.0937198102,
-0.0244632028,
-0.0136166457,
0.088631697,
-0.0332451165,
0.011786758,
-0.0194679052,
-0.0334921554,
0.0312705413,
-0.0011828555,
-0.0154034896,
0.0089595048,
0.0081331357,
-0.0006696314,
0.0280374028,
-0.0331577025,
-0.0206870288,
0.0094943373,
2.907e-7,
-0.0341522768,
0.0017012947,
0.0850617662,
-0.0380545892,
0.0372016914,
0.0030260065,
0.0162149612,
-0.0048750448,
-0.0306026377,
0.0036811768,
0.0026480898,
-0.0112681817,
0.0874875039,
-0.0365388617,
-0.0552771203,
-0.0153459189,
-0.0759527832,
0.0257212054,
0.0189572703,
0.0128054591,
-0.0202339869,
0.0659060851,
0.002087791,
-0.0241729058,
0.04892537,
0.017721083,
0.0156658236,
0.0197243113,
0.0299987476,
-0.0537053384,
-0.0532016158,
-0.0152275683,
-0.0347501375,
-0.0279908683,
-0.0284235179,
0.0193385221,
-0.0067771412,
0.0456701927,
-0.0232472811,
-0.0802072734,
-0.0218234379,
0.0755024776,
-0.0132328169,
0.016075654,
0.0698247775,
0.0072878632,
-0.0244733598,
-0.0451638252,
-0.0772731155,
-0.0001120522,
-0.0305835865,
-0.0008208514,
0.0046966798,
0.0053618276,
0.0060233139,
-0.0207287539,
-0.0156490505,
-0.0552389659,
0.0313445404,
-0.0186547656,
-0.0748481229,
0.0356100798,
-0.0449272208,
0.0071056215,
0.0015441729,
-0.0079208734,
-0.0544668511,
2.565535017e-34,
0.0183163453,
-0.0181521401,
0.0260493513,
0.0252285078,
-0.0171687473,
-0.0178502351,
-0.0273702536,
0.0205289777,
-0.0139940409,
-0.0575801022,
-0.0660705045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08541v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08541v2 | When do Generative Query and Document Expansions Fail? A Comprehensive Study Across Methods, Retrievers, and Datasets | 2023-09-15T17:05:43 | 2024-02-26T20:57:33 | Orion Weller, Kyle Lo, David Wadden, Dawn Lawrie, Benjamin Van Durme, Arman Cohan, Luca Soldaini | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Using large language models (LMs) for query or document expansion can improve
generalization in information retrieval. However, it is unknown whether these
techniques are universally beneficial or only effective in specific settings,
such as for particular retrieval models, dataset domains, or query types. To
answer this, we conduct the first comprehensive analysis of LM-based expansion.
We find that there exists a strong negative correlation between retriever
performance and gains from expansion: expansion improves scores for weaker
models, but generally harms stronger models. We show this trend holds across a
set of eleven expansion techniques, twelve datasets with diverse distribution
shifts, and twenty-four retrieval models. Through qualitative error analysis,
we hypothesize that although expansions provide extra information (potentially
improving recall), they add additional noise that makes it difficult to discern
between the top relevant documents (thus introducing false positives). Our
results suggest the following recipe: use expansions for weaker models or when
the target dataset significantly differs from training corpus in format;
otherwise, avoid expansions to keep the relevance signal clear. | [
0.065847598,
0.0640818253,
0.0033089435,
-0.0235808305,
-0.0347712673,
0.0178065635,
-0.011505316,
0.0618286915,
-0.0359228551,
-0.022096945,
-0.0074744364,
-0.0570630394,
-0.0309882294,
-0.007224733,
0.0147536956,
-0.0292963609,
0.0504048802,
-0.0168179199,
-0.0043815533,
0.0021172948,
-0.0344254896,
0.0042865369,
0.0616215989,
0.0055120355,
0.0092850728,
0.0661971495,
-0.0139316767,
0.0449255668,
-0.0302070193,
0.0082499003,
-0.0287401807,
0.0166169591,
0.0555002838,
0.0465622358,
0.0000016549,
-0.0748826936,
-0.044220265,
0.0285928305,
-0.0242815837,
0.0204813574,
0.0623026714,
-0.0159555618,
0.0399074443,
0.018411139,
-0.0160753094,
-0.0678079799,
0.0114547387,
0.0357876904,
0.0011693608,
0.0816408247,
-0.0046414142,
-0.0357775018,
0.0202834848,
-0.048503004,
0.0585932247,
-0.06196348,
0.0479357317,
-0.0061483774,
0.0417281277,
0.0468083881,
-0.0011344318,
0.0134890778,
-0.0368521847,
-0.0217870139,
0.0267404839,
0.0144023895,
-0.0420433357,
0.0226487033,
0.0508180894,
0.0108442167,
0.0407780297,
-0.0192704797,
0.0107354848,
0.0199580081,
-0.0015154987,
0.0974673182,
-0.0762718916,
0.003640864,
-0.0120861009,
-0.0070898477,
-0.0044493983,
-0.0116365664,
0.0292611383,
0.0323997736,
-0.064123176,
0.0402235538,
0.0148712164,
-0.0671956837,
0.029473098,
0.0221459325,
-0.0174392723,
0.0001264884,
0.001233667,
-0.0069428552,
0.0146306781,
0.0283529274,
0.0050988933,
-0.0464501977,
0.0644619912,
-0.055485744,
0.0183362905,
0.0144211017,
-0.0044502863,
0.0529807098,
-0.0030670217,
0.0159981642,
-0.0145826042,
-0.0001936344,
-0.0443963781,
-0.025723543,
-0.0559712499,
-0.0471944734,
-0.0338817351,
0.0415772274,
-0.0202347282,
-0.0091353608,
-0.051174514,
0.0319396965,
0.0346386768,
-0.0255601294,
0.0103669269,
0.0188140478,
-0.0405200645,
0.0036763835,
-0.0457586646,
0.0082458137,
-0.0271684714,
0.0279784705,
-0.008309681,
-0.0505879894,
-0.0055512325,
0.0024352148,
0.0294045433,
-0.0349061564,
0.0231431071,
0.0094442703,
-0.0005692318,
-0.0708819032,
-0.0431733504,
-0.0062553855,
0.0173935909,
-0.0098430654,
0.0078230398,
-0.0324685983,
0.0259927902,
0.0186770801,
-0.017923994,
-0.0123500274,
-0.0269621406,
0.0246451721,
-0.0536728241,
0.0088007785,
-0.0017212623,
0.0614816099,
0.0619578809,
-0.004389992,
0.032038141,
0.077549994,
-0.0356893353,
0.0026907616,
0.068384774,
-0.0046496405,
0.0321447104,
0.0098267077,
0.0135172484,
0.0376051143,
-0.0157353766,
0.0154442126,
-0.0162591562,
-0.0173711386,
-0.0008625229,
0.0372023061,
-0.0603010096,
-0.0040270612,
0.0119398003,
0.0594665855,
0.0390510038,
-0.0181740038,
0.008363802,
-0.0023668222,
-0.0229036808,
-0.0002147886,
0.00300057,
-0.0551486649,
-0.0375105254,
0.0164359473,
0.0370467603,
-0.0195406768,
-0.0516059399,
-0.0342656113,
-0.0359620005,
0.028948633,
-0.0075834966,
0.0216765795,
0.0856165439,
-0.0073027313,
0.0218077321,
0.0349343866,
0.0261590481,
-0.0631936416,
0.0330430865,
-0.0434237532,
0.00525484,
0.0614707805,
0.0593584888,
-0.0522137247,
0.0147156753,
0.0297885668,
-0.0326817334,
-0.0345217399,
0.0237376224,
-0.008631777,
0.0068244347,
-0.041320309,
-0.0426469222,
0.0315532424,
0.0148320124,
0.0043719206,
0.0400002748,
0.0241452921,
0.0381245874,
-0.1100520641,
-0.0278072432,
0.0349318944,
-0.0269379206,
-0.047486838,
0.0194393247,
-0.0205642078,
-0.015456181,
0.0188444965,
-0.0172089394,
-0.0124705229,
0.0386914723,
0.0000325064,
-0.048619397,
-0.0217891168,
-0.0030762327,
0.0379781947,
-0.0032983867,
-0.0105980728,
0.0429526195,
-0.0302674565,
-0.0160541255,
-0.0349465944,
0.0029177212,
-0.0127278268,
0.0576161072,
-0.0733982623,
0.0240645949,
-0.0378884599,
-0.0095023997,
-0.0793334991,
0.0590575188,
0.0015740416,
0.0252249092,
0.0074217422,
-0.0100154262,
-0.0134579567,
-0.0383482389,
-0.035091605,
0.041180931,
0.0137190958,
0.0130860331,
0.0377105027,
-0.0463433191,
-0.0464804918,
0.0055857524,
-0.097793974,
-0.0187785532,
-0.047932256,
-0.0005102198,
-0.003968487,
0.0379893295,
-0.0410760269,
0.0114097744,
-0.0189669505,
-0.0555146188,
0.0329423584,
0.0503119044,
-0.0036586388,
0.0377116911,
0.0198607612,
-0.035141442,
-0.0521340407,
0.0210026372,
0.0663723871,
-0.0065745451,
-0.0254950095,
-0.0436225086,
0.0538239069,
-0.0480881743,
0.0025785319,
-0.0557629876,
0.0336830877,
-0.0198555905,
-0.0863857865,
-0.0019338373,
0.0171835721,
0.0154315513,
-0.0056756833,
0.0306087025,
0.000030003,
-0.095970802,
0.0079775779,
-0.0457767509,
-0.0354303122,
-0.0139373029,
-0.0543464832,
0.039868053,
-0.0186227225,
-0.0081695793,
-0.0075925598,
-0.0268663652,
-0.0025464885,
-0.020329129,
-0.0385082364,
-0.0569407716,
-0.0154054044,
0.0205871221,
0.0760190785,
0.0164693408,
-0.0510445312,
0.0211156439,
0.0009075707,
0.0060862391,
-0.024088487,
-0.0087169586,
-0.0433745123,
0.0644323155,
-0.0004823286,
0.0035760091,
0.0017273994,
-0.0387482867,
0.0189964063,
-0.0040386789,
0.0379189998,
-0.0444011092,
0.084796533,
-0.0136518879,
0.0579134002,
0.0037005534,
-0.0366754085,
-0.038575802,
-0.045115184,
0.0507429242,
-0.0003342213,
0.0286420174,
-0.0059733344,
-0.0519531108,
0.0293022972,
0.0229030754,
0.0165650118,
-0.0394054167,
-0.0345263146,
0.031292703,
0.025858704,
0.0398436897,
-0.0344211385,
-0.0270363484,
-0.0344846956,
-0.0373713449,
0.0145345042,
0.0165407248,
-0.0323208943,
0.0069747246,
-0.003432977,
0.0492790006,
-0.0317125954,
-0.0312078111,
-0.0205767024,
0.0086744232,
-0.0030846375,
-0.0375106446,
0.0698593035,
0.0202980768,
-0.0528827496,
-0.04098434,
-0.0557079278,
0.0390487239,
0.0236063469,
0.0481989011,
-0.0364880003,
0.0272761155,
0.032571353,
0.0603277981,
-0.0175294746,
-0.0213327557,
0.0153747508,
-0.1416134089,
0.067428574,
-0.0175854508,
-0.017452158,
-0.0246825423,
-0.0746977925,
0.0202522799,
-0.0160931163,
-0.0230726413,
0.0553273708,
-0.0527257919,
-0.0070587741,
0.0375538059,
0.0190320425,
-0.0768538117,
-0.051299125,
-0.0170362592,
-0.0461315326,
0.0622955859,
-0.0261897091,
-0.0206018109,
-0.0001519511,
0.0061327242,
-0.0032801118,
0.0285807885,
-0.0240635313,
0.0775993317,
0.0109879151,
0.0307357591,
0.0137641318,
-0.0303159989,
0.0210029874,
0.0280325413,
0.0071331314,
0.020533381,
-0.0247526821,
0.0190899298,
-0.0475267768,
-0.038818948,
-0.020197425,
0.0404501781,
-0.0015581459,
0.0102224713,
0.0109044965,
-0.0106042568,
0.0225555804,
0.0118601369,
0.0123782912,
0.0157866739,
-0.042539496,
-0.0489950813,
-0.0419071391,
-0.0403558947,
-0.0081155179,
0.0428956002,
0.0104643814,
0.0451282077,
-0.0474021621,
0.0173755661,
-0.0081373109,
0.0129530272,
-0.0092293117,
-0.0312881656,
-0.016827995,
-0.0071332813,
0.0456986167,
-0.0047497228,
-0.0200622845,
-0.0249512699,
-0.0627726838,
-0.0527060367,
-0.0006445507,
-0.0120859295,
0.028023582,
0.0366455466,
0.0153041407,
-0.0563275553,
0.0356166773,
0.0748584047,
0.0034867632,
0.0234261863,
0.0127412751,
-0.0285098907,
-0.0132990601,
0.0114880092,
-0.0601593256,
0.0260219295,
0.0026324352,
0.0340310335,
-0.0433527306,
-0.0147309266,
0.0166753624,
0.0435764492,
0.0581992045,
0.0068547879,
0.019734256,
-0.0335926972,
0.0086865434,
-0.0446199514,
-0.0118504688,
-0.0207340047,
-0.0055183461,
0.0465178266,
0.0134148672,
-0.0211926382,
0.0354781374,
-0.0316729248,
0.0839414671,
-0.0802576914,
0.0024343657,
0.0014742645,
0.0187919829,
0.0263508372,
0.0087767784,
-0.039196495,
0.0182628874,
0.0259972848,
0.0408899859,
-0.0346218906,
0.0176714901,
-0.0093441941,
0.0171167497,
-0.028717408,
-0.0202615522,
-0.0976170003,
-0.0492023006,
-0.0083525116,
0.0173196178,
0.0142796282,
-0.0567224286,
0.0169750266,
-0.0194216575,
-0.019325057,
-0.0265247114,
-0.0384673923,
0.0543504655,
-0.001517233,
0.0034884794,
0.0210439712,
-0.0149679342,
0.0158009864,
0.0755348206,
0.0143841524,
0.0337601453,
-0.061666403,
-0.0478827432,
0.0061365329,
-0.0046488317,
0.0662189126,
0.0154730342,
-0.0140160937,
-0.0221133549,
-0.0405798331,
-0.0230789445,
0.019076718,
-0.030965995,
0.0297790803,
-0.0074343127,
0.0499431901,
0.1378676891,
0.0111942561,
0.0136801219,
-0.0582597069,
-0.0017219869,
-0.0278089792,
-0.0038038262,
-0.0201531593,
-6.086254612e-33,
0.0033514285,
0.0222929399,
-0.0143996738,
-0.063963078,
-0.0246564262,
-0.0032494694,
0.0152008114,
-0.007134913,
-0.0064850068,
-0.0334009044,
-0.0531641953,
0.0214624293,
0.0264679622,
0.0228836462,
0.0261233579,
-0.0051397844,
0.0576105341,
0.0339811072,
-0.0224937741,
0.0029514157,
0.0753413215,
0.0674715191,
0.0406207517,
-0.055076085,
0.0217094161,
-0.0114222085,
0.0212869383,
-0.0005096751,
0.0403845161,
0.0335221887,
0.0303080436,
0.0557610132,
0.026276309,
-0.0352785699,
-0.005827642,
-0.0182916634,
-0.0592935383,
-0.0153733632,
0.0342751741,
-0.0326785333,
0.0175368078,
0.0033736092,
0.0427763015,
-0.0114909792,
-0.0190455522,
0.0048920629,
0.0404593199,
-0.0141301304,
-0.0724887177,
-0.0638627931,
-0.0050859475,
0.0331264772,
0.0294581465,
0.0606214367,
0.011485693,
0.0574923083,
0.0014529438,
0.0838199779,
-0.0122758625,
0.0427562259,
0.0459505543,
0.043391794,
0.0183559582,
0.0328678302,
0.000646073,
0.0327447429,
0.0094666015,
0.0028498622,
-0.0101986732,
-0.0444771275,
0.0277323686,
0.0158834048,
-0.0206185561,
0.0563406534,
0.0518467315,
-0.0460633337,
-0.0535209998,
0.0386158787,
-0.0087487744,
0.009901111,
0.0255423207,
0.0415797457,
-0.082895495,
-0.0466506034,
-0.01317582,
0.0133678708,
-0.0280120578,
-0.0149136605,
0.0345543437,
0.0525030531,
0.0018762611,
-0.0134175671,
0.040259365,
-0.0080185886,
-0.0456502661,
0.0494709313,
-0.021992512,
-0.0122759221,
-0.0275864396,
-0.0243944377,
-0.0139606735,
-0.039716661,
0.0178542454,
0.0140521768,
-0.0395643823,
-0.0310033932,
0.0004045475,
0.0096873865,
-0.0608463101,
-0.0118272882,
0.003470618,
0.0113181137,
-0.0166760124,
-0.019872386,
0.0273247305,
0.020431865,
0.0207727365,
0.0489103869,
0.0572965033,
0.0103624184,
-0.0138395494,
-0.0765150562,
0.0041071759,
-0.0212911107,
0.017400654,
0.0242884066,
0.003468151,
0.0050484445,
0.0541652776,
-0.0465284176,
0.002136227,
0.0370911881,
2.6e-7,
0.0668144897,
0.0529010296,
0.0005139473,
0.030767547,
-0.019289881,
-0.0065890132,
-0.0219388809,
0.0167091452,
0.0339236893,
0.0271257218,
0.0346440934,
-0.0042711785,
0.0180153456,
0.0498736426,
-0.0599456839,
-0.0158179272,
-0.0641835481,
-0.0416532047,
-0.0378859825,
0.0071515404,
0.0418432169,
0.0900870934,
-0.0027738521,
-0.0131331626,
-0.0036627187,
-0.0888773128,
0.0733284205,
-0.046484217,
-0.0200224593,
0.0255196914,
0.0590838268,
0.0378060229,
0.0330839455,
0.0100912396,
-0.0068518333,
0.0252322666,
0.024783114,
0.0091145774,
0.0084545016,
0.0004055067,
-0.0207694508,
-0.0148320105,
0.0206318311,
-0.0699919909,
0.0747698694,
-0.0029409197,
0.028123185,
0.0202742238,
-0.0274227485,
0.0117335124,
0.0243581831,
-0.0211412553,
-0.0165614858,
0.0216958579,
0.0073148389,
0.0321681164,
-0.0170076322,
-0.0807959437,
0.0391725898,
0.0113243656,
-0.0406215228,
-0.0402579121,
-0.0096887853,
0.0272778869,
-0.0386211053,
-0.0068849945,
0.0075052534,
2.170361826e-34,
0.0540240519,
0.027722301,
-0.0113619585,
-0.0170472153,
0.0067545036,
-0.0036917545,
-0.0085484814,
0.0347890891,
-0.017508287,
-0.0966295898,
-0.006345856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08532v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08532v2 | Connecting Large Language Models with Evolutionary Algorithms Yields Powerful Prompt Optimizers | 2023-09-15T16:50:09 | 2024-02-27T12:13:46 | Qingyan Guo, Rui Wang, Junliang Guo, Bei Li, Kaitao Song, Xu Tan, Guoqing Liu, Jiang Bian, Yujiu Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in various tasks, but they rely on
carefully crafted prompts that often demand substantial human effort. To
automate this process, in this paper, we propose a novel framework for discrete
prompt optimization, called EvoPrompt, which borrows the idea of evolutionary
algorithms (EAs) as they exhibit good performance and fast convergence. To
enable EAs to work on discrete prompts, which are natural language expressions
that need to be coherent and human-readable, we connect LLMs with EAs. This
approach allows us to simultaneously leverage the powerful language processing
capabilities of LLMs and the efficient optimization performance of EAs.
Specifically, abstaining from any gradients or parameters, EvoPrompt starts
from a population of prompts and iteratively generates new prompts with LLMs
based on the evolutionary operators, improving the population based on the
development set. We optimize prompts for both closed- and open-source LLMs
including GPT-3.5 and Alpaca, on 31 datasets covering language understanding,
generation tasks, as well as BIG-Bench Hard (BBH) tasks. EvoPrompt
significantly outperforms human-engineered prompts and existing methods for
automatic prompt generation (e.g., up to 25% on BBH). Furthermore, EvoPrompt
demonstrates that connecting LLMs with EAs creates synergies, which could
inspire further research on the combination of LLMs and conventional
algorithms. | [
0.0309000276,
0.0575933717,
-0.0152973905,
0.0263358541,
-0.0360352434,
0.0002681416,
0.0189397708,
-0.0092050014,
0.0174741745,
-0.0046129939,
0.001738055,
-0.0439628959,
0.0046120505,
0.0282739401,
0.0335100591,
-0.0453850031,
0.0534814671,
-0.0435209274,
0.0021894146,
-0.0167279895,
-0.015055038,
0.0020984497,
-0.0059589539,
0.0557229258,
0.0286969598,
-0.0171545204,
-0.0255232342,
0.0002685384,
0.0283125285,
-0.0122781396,
0.0200573169,
0.0574104004,
0.001749191,
0.0568802319,
0.0000022559,
-0.0650946721,
-0.0331695676,
-0.0307246447,
-0.048707962,
0.0016044569,
0.0409561619,
0.0148950797,
-0.0259514116,
0.0106499922,
-0.033670105,
-0.01488919,
0.0227546338,
-0.0095171733,
0.0678743199,
0.0604811572,
0.0099127432,
0.0022691805,
0.0249477178,
-0.0231557693,
0.0263344478,
-0.0345771648,
0.0252182819,
-0.0562421381,
0.0448148474,
0.0094217453,
-0.0047820723,
0.0162070841,
0.0033651053,
-0.0099102156,
-0.0058558704,
0.0389447063,
0.0033414625,
-0.0486204587,
-0.061657384,
0.0929435417,
-0.0273021795,
-0.0194836911,
0.0237621572,
-0.0169240739,
0.047511708,
-0.0396671928,
-0.0001887268,
0.0436214209,
-0.0325537138,
0.0259042755,
0.0177201163,
-0.0268356632,
-0.0181686692,
0.0077226157,
-0.0012968526,
0.0848003328,
0.0363959,
-0.0142714782,
0.0187665913,
-0.0309568867,
-0.0432725362,
-0.0638691187,
0.0278213974,
0.0368903019,
-0.0685920492,
0.0121806841,
-0.0682918578,
-0.0364790522,
0.0266355705,
0.0663350821,
0.0690715387,
0.0582062043,
0.0067425207,
0.0457545221,
-0.0348233804,
0.0696429312,
-0.0086525399,
-0.0221374668,
-0.0493814275,
0.0093611544,
-0.0365503319,
-0.0053544655,
-0.0616047867,
0.0027357333,
-0.044231005,
-0.0220815036,
-0.021555597,
0.04898002,
0.0254865773,
0.0067557096,
0.0277933367,
-0.0037507315,
-0.0205820668,
-0.019839935,
-0.0255784076,
0.0029584472,
-0.0336638652,
-0.0164961796,
0.0318258926,
-0.0435384437,
-0.0096298587,
-0.001499565,
0.0116529148,
0.0023220384,
-0.0108440528,
0.0566562004,
-0.0122290701,
-0.0249378104,
-0.0250411872,
-0.0170635451,
-0.0073643862,
-0.0335404649,
-0.0345747694,
-0.0331080668,
0.0587533116,
-0.012158934,
-0.0322085246,
-0.0181184188,
0.0066461125,
0.0265305042,
0.0014979372,
0.0440233462,
-0.0546697155,
0.0503582731,
0.0591549426,
-0.0096658813,
-0.0259793866,
0.0476326011,
0.013996182,
0.0208720565,
0.0079743695,
0.0034054029,
0.0021309783,
0.0634921044,
-0.0019774875,
0.0133050801,
0.0421397947,
-0.0090418896,
0.0449833274,
0.0485914424,
0.0397258326,
0.0605540723,
-0.0195853375,
-0.0108752642,
0.0447109565,
0.0178796127,
0.0066559841,
0.0363830216,
0.07795614,
0.0517717749,
-0.0238402467,
-0.0140972622,
-0.0344081037,
-0.011411339,
-0.0388195328,
0.0050357878,
0.0152554056,
0.0199246444,
-0.012227593,
-0.011484067,
0.0117683318,
0.0170830321,
-0.0042038015,
0.0089406176,
-0.0028108261,
0.0001666087,
-0.0956418365,
0.0182158556,
0.022299422,
-0.0186595563,
-0.0119832465,
-0.0669959933,
0.0840107948,
0.0804460049,
0.0221470036,
-0.0020233828,
-0.0313606374,
-0.0003032354,
0.0159241203,
0.0493744723,
0.0488102734,
-0.0150646251,
-0.013976342,
-0.0646823943,
-0.0344702117,
0.0121294865,
-0.0059028352,
0.0635351613,
0.0071216081,
-0.0048972033,
0.031832885,
0.0180826187,
-0.0199265927,
0.0547743663,
-0.0373899601,
-0.0132617429,
0.0228944644,
0.0021937359,
0.0238626692,
0.005448184,
0.0090425191,
0.014520823,
0.0089703454,
-0.029305581,
-0.0147309294,
-0.0220440477,
-0.0551919341,
-0.0459423475,
0.0411977172,
-0.0033919378,
-0.0273914784,
-0.0285691451,
-0.0260464996,
-0.0433973745,
-0.023016464,
-0.076509513,
0.0424422733,
-0.0560219735,
0.0418486111,
-0.0157858729,
0.0038137124,
-0.0470298454,
0.0740622729,
0.0116610173,
-0.0170661937,
0.0657091811,
0.0233710669,
0.020546902,
-0.0794335902,
-0.015373366,
-0.0146336826,
-0.0105882036,
0.0024800338,
0.0344114713,
0.0685291365,
-0.0528679155,
-0.040350955,
-0.0955385715,
0.0349973328,
-0.0077393702,
0.0307292268,
0.0293471329,
-0.0017370819,
-0.0462098084,
0.0100872954,
-0.0392245688,
0.0398946032,
0.0096963756,
0.0004637885,
0.0358571112,
0.0050675268,
-0.0396076366,
-0.0121601699,
-0.0078603625,
-0.0305495709,
0.0067024995,
0.0146114761,
0.0046395906,
-0.0976677611,
0.0231267288,
-0.0051148245,
0.0059450609,
0.012620098,
0.0111698471,
-0.0094576785,
-0.0144557003,
0.0923507437,
0.0687151626,
0.0404161513,
-0.0102249058,
0.0184241701,
-0.0060115363,
-0.0472552553,
0.0177789703,
-0.0383422337,
-0.025354214,
0.0162893999,
-0.0364938565,
0.0325322412,
0.0665215999,
0.0071232123,
-0.0209099464,
-0.0762722492,
0.0292258225,
0.0122540221,
-0.0120583503,
-0.0641674623,
-0.039814271,
-0.0371790789,
0.0343451649,
-0.0350996926,
-0.0287313126,
0.0956876427,
-0.0298536569,
-0.0066202455,
-0.0565906502,
0.0264174081,
-0.0309890006,
0.0391277224,
0.0032570441,
0.0225091614,
0.0302013587,
-0.0282730963,
-0.0407585911,
0.0431272238,
-0.0147260223,
-0.0227820147,
0.006788299,
-0.0467547663,
0.0063021262,
-0.0074364566,
-0.0612618066,
-0.0472404361,
-0.0464652963,
-0.0196315348,
0.005858798,
0.0043402174,
0.0123340301,
-0.0238369871,
0.006493316,
-0.0008836861,
0.0445317402,
-0.0350463949,
0.0038780496,
-0.0414899439,
0.0156318247,
0.0606738999,
0.0379249565,
0.0276301298,
-0.0391370542,
0.0528870933,
0.0051599476,
0.0333840959,
0.0192704741,
-0.0125267608,
0.0332184248,
0.0370991081,
-0.0341180153,
-0.0213918649,
0.0376042239,
0.0335475318,
-0.055929251,
0.0160968974,
0.09663333,
0.0155879138,
-0.0394900031,
-0.0008083193,
-0.0320204422,
0.0394510329,
0.0107469978,
0.0477289408,
-0.076633282,
-0.056659542,
0.0179394633,
0.0391702689,
-0.0242309459,
-0.043426916,
-0.0218028054,
-0.1438749433,
0.0353706852,
-0.0040570213,
-0.020702688,
0.0351387449,
-0.0209748149,
0.012105437,
0.0036056892,
0.0187947992,
0.0498669557,
0.0043123318,
0.0156831052,
-0.0018593095,
0.0240159966,
-0.0289819073,
0.0062710661,
-0.0230210125,
0.047443781,
0.0919164196,
0.0122692036,
0.0284624305,
-0.0744082853,
0.0737471879,
-0.0345512591,
-0.0011139771,
-0.0138969347,
-0.03500323,
-0.0043078284,
-0.0073161307,
-0.0337579958,
0.0782174319,
-0.0321483687,
0.0003655532,
0.0499771684,
0.0598607063,
-0.0087883985,
-0.0356264263,
-0.0196168236,
-0.0037982624,
0.0306641385,
0.0777516961,
0.03562776,
-0.0863355622,
-0.0306396037,
-0.0305473991,
-0.0011964217,
-0.0592858754,
-0.0198727269,
0.0145246685,
0.0070708501,
-0.0129659697,
-0.0690167472,
-0.0173070598,
0.0536095984,
0.0372820087,
0.0402254015,
-0.033703167,
-0.0116704432,
-0.013078074,
-0.0192047115,
0.02507139,
-0.0356310047,
-0.0088050738,
-0.1048230976,
-0.0143309897,
0.0149338804,
-0.0708445832,
-0.0243994053,
0.0390967838,
-0.0494477972,
-0.0700441301,
-0.0126646077,
0.050289046,
0.0229374096,
0.0164054893,
-0.0281001348,
-0.0498271473,
0.0657500327,
0.0298103243,
-0.0002385854,
-0.0069020106,
-0.0515413769,
0.0242274459,
-0.0275199935,
0.0165498909,
-0.0161791146,
0.0248789489,
0.0055316375,
0.0771413296,
0.0162929539,
-0.0520593412,
0.0456142277,
0.0452508964,
0.0013727975,
-0.0660655871,
-0.0338991992,
-0.049819503,
-0.0229800195,
0.0174495727,
-0.014918956,
-0.0388634019,
0.0279312953,
-0.001391297,
-0.0387363881,
0.0329615138,
-0.029081367,
0.0084555997,
0.0211900268,
-0.0306894369,
0.0152005414,
-0.0111046471,
0.0356943309,
0.0465630814,
-0.0223641098,
0.0092516476,
0.0629277602,
-0.0013563219,
0.0334299393,
-0.021384608,
0.0967464224,
0.0205441862,
-0.0134581393,
0.0036690754,
0.052280385,
-0.009808125,
-0.0507483296,
-0.0124564394,
0.0615722835,
0.0558392294,
0.0369438492,
0.0026776877,
-0.0254899524,
-0.0232586823,
-0.0324524716,
-0.0178096145,
0.019887384,
-0.039397005,
0.0191728696,
0.027436696,
-0.0248257015,
-0.0260861758,
0.0519045703,
-0.0247869734,
0.0378276706,
-0.0144917984,
0.0361345783,
-0.0690733641,
0.0041081994,
-0.0249845143,
-0.0252403505,
-0.03477256,
0.026660908,
-0.0316348001,
-0.0217164755,
0.0024061583,
0.0473779067,
0.0030545145,
0.014535903,
0.0652965233,
0.0330318362,
-0.0665916577,
-0.0110368812,
-0.033748392,
0.0070754946,
-0.0329684429,
-0.0487784408,
-0.0276898537,
-6.228246615e-33,
-0.035965886,
-0.0302970447,
0.0169264134,
-0.0115414131,
-0.0286757499,
0.0001895765,
-0.0479396954,
0.0247126389,
0.0117484713,
-0.0306759048,
-0.0263886061,
-0.0422208682,
0.0082867183,
0.0018263151,
-0.0050910721,
-0.0201403927,
0.0223328937,
-0.0148801431,
-0.0410658233,
0.0215002298,
-0.0109466389,
0.0410621092,
-0.0309387017,
0.0101360884,
0.0047396543,
0.0080018835,
-0.0254518818,
0.0433476791,
0.0071029989,
0.0438598879,
-0.0458309315,
0.0404300019,
0.0100019313,
-0.0649383888,
-0.0238589812,
0.0726466104,
-0.0551897474,
-0.0039687785,
0.0094470615,
-0.0306647643,
-0.0632742941,
-0.0640767515,
0.0007586388,
-0.0256241485,
-0.0423779264,
0.0412184224,
0.0292187873,
-0.027690189,
0.0097424434,
-0.0113268681,
-0.0270411074,
0.0016407878,
-0.0087282471,
-0.0340266451,
0.0161328968,
0.0227052364,
-0.0046033207,
0.0171383284,
0.0085700359,
0.0559250601,
0.0209185667,
0.0003524818,
0.0433259569,
0.0073147723,
0.0278667063,
0.0260792244,
0.0365888774,
-0.0217589661,
0.0058175279,
-0.0151762934,
0.0279918462,
0.0130757261,
0.0057410495,
0.0209211372,
-0.0235904567,
-0.0194137599,
-0.0318504646,
0.0508207567,
0.0446362086,
-0.0299929865,
0.0378165804,
0.0016556459,
0.00750494,
-0.0065140906,
-0.0341376849,
-0.0272688009,
-0.0454498045,
0.0114655877,
0.0369050279,
0.012045987,
-0.0416505001,
-0.0463569574,
0.0354974344,
-0.0011758899,
0.0112049757,
-0.0066921348,
-0.034567453,
-0.0197172649,
0.0008046717,
0.0635557622,
-0.0111459494,
-0.068030037,
0.0131521067,
-0.015277545,
0.0235734452,
0.0255013425,
-0.0228250269,
0.0041083158,
-0.052007772,
0.0352151506,
-0.0306423381,
0.064606145,
-0.0286942963,
0.0155987116,
0.0367812105,
-0.0020061471,
0.0195148624,
0.0213524792,
0.0387203507,
0.0005373808,
-0.042772714,
0.0231074542,
0.0108197946,
0.0491282642,
-0.0311054718,
0.0289423894,
0.0142704342,
0.0325840786,
-0.0267344043,
-0.0182996001,
-0.0241468269,
0.0210668463,
2.897e-7,
0.0114411879,
0.0535976514,
0.0186695978,
-0.0020048327,
0.0240933467,
0.0266076755,
-0.0020752547,
0.0158589724,
0.0160658322,
-0.0274980161,
0.013562507,
0.000354953,
0.0442903936,
-0.0274690799,
-0.1110242456,
0.0279431306,
-0.0384502746,
0.0368179269,
-0.094449617,
0.0343346819,
0.066560261,
0.0731623471,
-0.0213089697,
-0.004564052,
0.0180196352,
-0.0072714742,
0.0339433327,
-0.0079657286,
0.0077260747,
0.0327056088,
0.012192714,
-0.0010969461,
-0.0355687365,
0.0342586525,
0.0150147341,
0.027441062,
0.0119650373,
0.0722782314,
0.0387649834,
-0.007496173,
0.0496518649,
0.0150969485,
0.0065750205,
-0.0628938675,
0.0722215995,
-0.0280391108,
-0.0131955612,
-0.0237947926,
-0.011148016,
-0.0499123074,
-0.0225857981,
-0.0688544363,
-0.0137473634,
0.0023581695,
0.0097162351,
-0.0235601086,
-0.0059356983,
-0.0569384731,
0.0219429843,
-0.0087333638,
-0.0765393004,
-0.056019742,
-0.0659251586,
0.0478670523,
0.0237431098,
-0.0821540132,
0.0035200149,
2.817746055e-34,
0.016133558,
-0.0261005349,
0.0332439132,
0.0024024944,
0.0277044624,
0.0162307471,
0.0144170746,
0.0105219558,
0.0266552456,
-0.076119937,
-0.0610498115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08531v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08531v1 | Towards Practical and Efficient Image-to-Speech Captioning with Vision-Language Pre-training and Multi-modal Tokens | 2023-09-15T16:48:34 | 2023-09-15T16:48:34 | Minsu Kim, Jeongsoo Choi, Soumi Maiti, Jeong Hun Yeo, Shinji Watanabe, Yong Man Ro | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, eess.AS, eess.IV | In this paper, we propose methods to build a powerful and efficient
Image-to-Speech captioning (Im2Sp) model. To this end, we start with importing
the rich knowledge related to image comprehension and language modeling from a
large-scale pre-trained vision-language model into Im2Sp. We set the output of
the proposed Im2Sp as discretized speech units, i.e., the quantized speech
features of a self-supervised speech model. The speech units mainly contain
linguistic information while suppressing other characteristics of speech. This
allows us to incorporate the language modeling capability of the pre-trained
vision-language model into the spoken language modeling of Im2Sp. With the
vision-language pre-training strategy, we set new state-of-the-art Im2Sp
performances on two widely used benchmark databases, COCO and Flickr8k. Then,
we further improve the efficiency of the Im2Sp model. Similar to the speech
unit case, we convert the original image into image units, which are derived
through vector quantization of the raw image. With these image units, we can
drastically reduce the required data storage for saving image data to just 0.8%
when compared to the original image data in terms of bits. Demo page:
https://ms-dot-k.github.io/Image-to-Speech-Captioning. | [
0.0061935368,
0.0638895631,
0.0138432458,
0.030897839,
-0.0175155178,
-0.004779601,
0.0176658593,
-0.008928231,
-0.0026815345,
-0.0895114988,
-0.0459912531,
-0.0212059505,
-0.0019881104,
0.0485812612,
0.0211495589,
-0.0681813657,
0.0445302837,
-0.0678055659,
-0.0009925343,
-0.0135262106,
0.0304749701,
0.0114782695,
-0.006505352,
0.0189488456,
-0.0564669184,
-0.0149507346,
0.0057944525,
0.0258745309,
-0.0103659155,
-0.0147799524,
-0.0603941903,
0.0518855341,
0.0859501362,
-0.0080023622,
0.0000019113,
-0.0158303007,
-0.0112457145,
0.0246244706,
0.0047354298,
0.0059264093,
0.0366230272,
-0.0593562238,
-0.0159513187,
-0.005374914,
-0.0068630022,
-0.018310817,
0.0612351932,
0.0467219949,
0.0738391876,
0.0365546495,
-0.0391727835,
-0.0486976504,
0.0187057052,
-0.0228566118,
-0.0065419348,
0.0044108178,
-0.0342913829,
0.0409250222,
-0.0241552033,
-0.0238751955,
-0.0429980978,
0.0737648979,
-0.0264332611,
-0.0411769338,
-0.0100630429,
0.0324243382,
-0.0210855361,
-0.0563437156,
-0.0417558886,
0.085110195,
0.0242777206,
0.0073532392,
-0.0065015592,
0.0321779326,
-0.0366729721,
-0.0380369201,
-0.0419414826,
0.0405632555,
0.056737069,
0.0314669162,
-0.0501551703,
0.0233386923,
-0.011265167,
-0.0144737922,
-0.0135068735,
-0.0164962392,
0.0402784906,
0.0367634818,
-0.0198398139,
-0.0230245218,
-0.0496133417,
-0.0468495078,
0.0067353896,
0.0070850071,
0.0242338274,
-0.0170235485,
-0.0449048951,
-0.0216007289,
-0.0386979543,
-0.0173161849,
0.0318676457,
0.0212159008,
-0.0476258695,
0.0841328502,
-0.0086917477,
0.056511987,
0.0119361458,
0.0365441032,
-0.0464367568,
-0.0225330014,
-0.0159614328,
0.008222186,
-0.0649595484,
0.0419969335,
-0.0251176339,
-0.0724557415,
-0.0250339042,
-0.0121940011,
-0.0195430443,
-0.004203971,
0.0132298563,
0.0239569377,
-0.0116357133,
-0.0143681476,
-0.0357091613,
0.023861235,
0.0273259915,
0.0186857935,
-0.043448884,
-0.0538319983,
0.0029963807,
0.0430188812,
0.0365264341,
-0.0032290414,
0.0144187063,
0.0675706565,
-0.0374027826,
-0.0456767976,
0.0191283189,
-0.0075430409,
-0.0311879124,
-0.0440870374,
-0.0055239559,
-0.049700696,
0.0319208577,
-0.0089208791,
-0.0018416278,
-0.0281030275,
0.0078726355,
0.0080841957,
0.0086636553,
0.126175642,
-0.0567472503,
0.0226149112,
0.0267250668,
0.0072710705,
0.0047630589,
0.0658546984,
0.0289471578,
0.0197053961,
0.0369493216,
-0.0111375833,
0.015858233,
0.0496107601,
0.0094991801,
0.018216528,
-0.0437611453,
-0.0018064911,
0.0025483852,
-0.0041235676,
0.0897199064,
0.0767953023,
-0.0120670954,
0.0391995832,
0.0702339634,
0.0550724454,
-0.0032165342,
0.0025667497,
0.0504372418,
0.0281111207,
0.0208609719,
-0.0377942771,
-0.0356215276,
0.0394502021,
0.0428839996,
0.0076635703,
0.0241534412,
0.0101320278,
-0.0568443723,
-0.0194079671,
0.0118178483,
-0.0396568961,
0.0105156666,
0.0212076772,
0.0197671726,
0.003475748,
-0.037743222,
0.0948071629,
-0.002933657,
-0.0335656144,
0.0111801457,
-0.0411942899,
-0.0067224815,
0.0418560058,
0.0039304844,
-0.0093884692,
0.0047779116,
0.0083397897,
0.0419126377,
0.009331652,
-0.0092788953,
0.0147649311,
0.0275858752,
-0.0555283688,
-0.0388711318,
-0.0091509223,
-0.0327284522,
0.0183877461,
-0.0249935985,
0.0119937314,
0.015668653,
0.0323162377,
-0.0212710928,
0.0153162209,
0.0874080807,
-0.0109494375,
0.0041099978,
0.0252185389,
0.0208154861,
0.0255920123,
-0.0287393034,
0.0062627848,
0.0234518852,
-0.0070695952,
0.0184087232,
0.0674794391,
-0.0752069056,
-0.0561102219,
0.0546226054,
-0.0480395667,
0.0182931907,
-0.0045626597,
-0.01913427,
-0.0759394988,
0.0407148637,
-0.0517048165,
0.0195137709,
-0.0811130404,
0.00289166,
0.0307842474,
0.0545423664,
0.0342218094,
-0.010572833,
-0.0002353727,
-0.0542834364,
0.0302018002,
-0.0046811318,
0.0017880338,
-0.0459196307,
-0.0403378047,
-0.0096101956,
-0.0114621073,
0.0297412947,
0.0086426856,
0.0178557318,
-0.0391774811,
0.0178008825,
-0.1362362206,
-0.0314525701,
-0.0109995268,
-0.0324954875,
-0.0223829988,
0.0057805236,
0.0269946065,
-0.0322447829,
-0.039357502,
0.0105052069,
0.0285453703,
-0.005173475,
-0.0097829178,
0.0308352076,
-0.0211859327,
-0.0386961214,
0.002637729,
0.0377606153,
0.0264756996,
-0.0134977018,
-0.0167150721,
-0.0135051152,
0.0139301643,
0.0019059054,
0.0353283621,
-0.0196996499,
-0.0276622437,
-0.0234888587,
-0.0173231196,
0.0410843231,
0.0031600085,
0.0095103551,
-0.0011424121,
0.008342335,
-0.0302664246,
-0.0215521697,
0.0049030809,
0.0195983611,
-0.0325703658,
0.0091196951,
-0.0292751715,
-0.0302164871,
0.0183757432,
-0.0020112274,
0.0473398603,
-0.0699398369,
0.0109203979,
-0.0159899164,
-0.0368464738,
-0.0522475876,
0.0170907807,
-0.0095239067,
0.0287001077,
-0.0137090664,
-0.0713054165,
0.0049931919,
-0.0862495303,
-0.070332557,
0.0043367655,
-0.0084675504,
-0.0143466061,
0.0863589495,
0.0249379091,
0.0314048491,
-0.0298316311,
0.0029444499,
-0.0238927044,
-0.027023362,
0.0007411073,
-0.005279291,
0.0457267687,
-0.0417204052,
0.0205456279,
-0.0447170734,
0.0017428128,
-0.0052766497,
-0.0277847629,
-0.0435100421,
0.0216918197,
-0.0511412695,
-0.0021813486,
0.0093018739,
0.0690521672,
0.0098469956,
0.0142297447,
0.0280892868,
0.0126678962,
-0.0203370173,
0.0419023931,
0.0474263132,
0.0380620807,
-0.0453387424,
-0.0007550562,
0.0243764687,
0.0122934887,
0.0260663256,
0.0338922516,
-0.0428432226,
0.0338151902,
0.035729602,
0.0583759062,
0.000140519,
0.019401025,
0.0845434591,
-0.0229955856,
0.0066453549,
0.092823498,
-0.0064416481,
-0.030707946,
-0.0280321334,
0.0316369198,
-0.0037384168,
0.0365109593,
-0.0170699004,
-0.0712199509,
-0.0636078715,
0.0012458956,
-0.0230546985,
0.0347608887,
0.0268138237,
-0.0862034634,
-0.0546873026,
0.0454361923,
0.0118871536,
-0.0007383015,
-0.0278072655,
0.0306972042,
-0.061592672,
-0.0074568456,
-0.008889202,
-0.0179193374,
-0.0043965513,
0.006535559,
0.0089855595,
-0.0052914354,
-0.0148354946,
0.032291837,
-0.0385130718,
0.0316242985,
0.02385756,
0.0262151267,
-0.0296692383,
-0.0200333912,
0.0034044159,
0.0179387629,
0.0127275512,
-0.0024405303,
0.0307603944,
-0.0355504565,
-0.042391222,
0.0242515635,
0.0194562823,
0.0057378751,
-0.0163789131,
-0.0043361341,
-0.0027381473,
0.0094729867,
0.0154101476,
-0.01063562,
0.0356012583,
-0.004410631,
0.0439150929,
0.026042901,
-0.0337506942,
0.0005720827,
-0.0041436036,
0.0170780737,
-0.0527130254,
-0.0297881123,
-0.0198906139,
0.00984501,
-0.0187547039,
-0.0625172853,
0.0219589397,
0.0630502403,
0.0378863104,
0.0014180769,
-0.0091637122,
-0.0066546611,
0.0478185378,
-0.0831950158,
0.0437104851,
-0.0461952575,
0.0189369973,
-0.0655561835,
-0.0206755828,
0.0424682051,
-0.0219759867,
-0.0103784129,
0.0243803822,
-0.0752295777,
-0.010226653,
-0.0201484095,
0.0861719549,
0.0045280778,
0.0331302211,
0.016489001,
-0.0199215598,
0.0518685617,
0.0255073179,
-0.0226807185,
0.0230373479,
0.0427990593,
-0.009084288,
-0.0265654456,
0.0122960042,
-0.0203205794,
0.0430329293,
-0.0088376813,
0.001645191,
-0.0143825952,
-0.0335879773,
-0.0078178104,
0.0452312753,
0.0466839932,
-0.0510682985,
0.0438548811,
-0.012452458,
-0.0049709175,
-0.0173489712,
-0.0045014443,
-0.095597744,
0.0114750629,
0.0052747382,
0.0327920392,
-0.002280181,
-0.0034517874,
-0.0101154028,
-0.040537186,
0.0620080009,
0.0264129378,
0.0277710427,
-0.008277542,
-0.0035840638,
0.0041430313,
0.0056426334,
0.0150116216,
-0.0090439823,
0.0102906199,
-0.0445584916,
0.0245811716,
-0.0156923439,
-0.0144159785,
-0.0154338283,
0.0401889421,
0.0449020825,
-0.0246438887,
-0.0418569595,
0.055413764,
0.0527767353,
0.0079903379,
0.0302806012,
-0.0119061777,
0.0030127594,
-0.0208394118,
0.0443886481,
-0.0003777121,
-0.043524038,
0.0752987042,
-0.0107553117,
-0.0092146676,
0.0297303647,
0.0268666893,
0.0185876321,
0.0052272184,
-0.0190970879,
0.0006350263,
-0.0453506485,
-0.0111069754,
-0.0258294977,
-0.0045293807,
-0.0154294278,
0.0509229042,
0.0074183508,
-0.0679097772,
0.0017943642,
0.0139916046,
-0.0182037186,
0.016080102,
0.0813153461,
-0.0166383237,
0.0379329585,
0.0032615231,
0.0009062355,
-0.0443356112,
0.0089227948,
0.0188417621,
0.0046992972,
-5.597780506e-33,
-0.0576395132,
-0.0370440967,
0.0190207884,
-0.0183286276,
-0.014693792,
0.0111996522,
-0.0313684307,
0.0128066698,
0.0056194854,
-0.0351451002,
0.0150112687,
-0.0267812721,
0.0279984362,
0.0526324175,
-0.0207463391,
0.0422596708,
0.0666238144,
-0.0260172263,
-0.004087755,
0.014369389,
-0.0027711827,
-0.0012374141,
0.0264887661,
-0.0154538155,
-0.0327903777,
0.0101803327,
-0.0448976904,
-0.0115942471,
0.0592711419,
0.0376780592,
-0.0435744934,
0.0284978766,
-0.0249104053,
0.0025942943,
-0.0352725424,
0.0140444739,
-0.0693723857,
0.0220506657,
0.0714811906,
0.062272124,
-0.0431514941,
0.0171065666,
0.0075649242,
-0.0391772799,
-0.0159114581,
-0.0412634723,
0.0362936072,
-0.0185424313,
0.0255526286,
-0.0264080763,
-0.0456269644,
0.0012185848,
0.0018796093,
-0.0369721986,
0.0756335333,
0.0069559566,
0.0101695675,
-0.0014468727,
-0.0483469367,
0.0245445706,
-0.0076611708,
0.0362031907,
0.0827871338,
0.0511324704,
-0.0042364481,
0.0211853366,
0.0442849919,
-0.0645471141,
-0.0007555902,
0.0429403521,
0.0406692699,
0.0655767098,
0.0300706569,
0.0638457239,
0.0254733674,
0.0003523698,
-0.0236139782,
-0.0100218467,
-0.0710368529,
0.0238521714,
0.0279448908,
0.0235722382,
0.0341324992,
0.0157951452,
-0.078957282,
-0.0037084464,
-0.0449827276,
-0.0257077049,
0.0480449349,
0.0375844501,
-0.0215933956,
0.0218923502,
0.1042330489,
-0.0466651246,
-0.0101050818,
-0.0300933737,
-0.024912741,
0.0356402621,
-0.0124397781,
0.0212814882,
-0.0275450964,
-0.0313939191,
0.079372108,
0.0145995021,
0.0208649505,
0.0060917754,
0.0232118592,
0.0599106513,
-0.0316548385,
-0.0070567187,
0.0060350741,
0.0084000835,
-0.0491386913,
0.0151915867,
0.004857108,
0.021655174,
-0.0590299927,
-0.0033061295,
-0.0422036313,
-0.0023004867,
-0.0195931513,
-0.0379697904,
0.0019123399,
0.0583033077,
-0.037244752,
0.0567657873,
-0.0324715786,
-0.0529318489,
0.0217733253,
-0.0281641465,
-0.0361498147,
0.0586554632,
2.499e-7,
-0.0086339293,
0.0132618826,
0.0270351004,
-0.0231844857,
0.0223529898,
0.0428091846,
-0.0340100899,
0.0225132219,
-0.0093506789,
-0.0158758778,
0.0423238538,
0.0225991067,
0.0403660461,
-0.0402791798,
-0.043722868,
0.0472672097,
-0.0400006212,
0.0003147082,
-0.0303997733,
-0.0096829077,
0.0353750437,
0.1358792782,
-0.0536467396,
-0.0309110954,
0.0211339872,
-0.0749810785,
0.0908987299,
-0.0231547654,
-0.0067820535,
-0.0091579063,
-0.0033741775,
0.0448160097,
-0.0701859966,
-0.0080878567,
-0.013240234,
-0.0140210642,
0.048304189,
0.0528359525,
-0.0338057652,
-0.0208062604,
-0.0529740378,
0.0538668558,
-0.0546688922,
-0.0248346608,
0.0763911977,
-0.0412392952,
-0.0191040542,
-0.0370374061,
-0.0200687218,
0.0047350121,
0.005763696,
-0.0216959491,
-0.0474544205,
0.0318899564,
0.0808140039,
-0.0301266443,
-0.034836594,
-0.0990229473,
-0.0020567779,
-0.0065778424,
-0.0290926434,
-0.0170678832,
-0.0724550113,
-0.0365858041,
0.0579742678,
-0.0126071274,
-0.0163757019,
1.575099523e-34,
0.042140089,
-0.0338614434,
0.0176378526,
-0.0341780744,
-0.0029127633,
0.0006371677,
-0.0156004168,
-0.0150124356,
-0.0041134758,
-0.0544567667,
-0.0422433503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08503v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08503v2 | HealthFC: Verifying Health Claims with Evidence-Based Medical Fact-Checking | 2023-09-15T16:05:48 | 2024-03-25T08:33:37 | Juraj Vladika, Phillip Schneider, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the digital age, seeking health advice on the Internet has become a common
practice. At the same time, determining the trustworthiness of online medical
content is increasingly challenging. Fact-checking has emerged as an approach
to assess the veracity of factual claims using evidence from credible knowledge
sources. To help advance automated Natural Language Processing (NLP) solutions
for this task, in this paper we introduce a novel dataset HealthFC. It consists
of 750 health-related claims in German and English, labeled for veracity by
medical experts and backed with evidence from systematic reviews and clinical
trials. We provide an analysis of the dataset, highlighting its characteristics
and challenges. The dataset can be used for NLP tasks related to automated
fact-checking, such as evidence retrieval, claim verification, or explanation
generation. For testing purposes, we provide baseline systems based on
different approaches, examine their performance, and discuss the findings. We
show that the dataset is a challenging test bed with a high potential for
future use. | [
0.0780149549,
0.0400504507,
0.0122972652,
-0.0033599767,
-0.0307150166,
-0.0013419777,
-0.0025949567,
0.009727749,
0.0267390013,
-0.0119895702,
0.0460209548,
-0.008384251,
0.0243411362,
0.0598582327,
-0.002632872,
-0.0127586136,
0.0124043506,
0.0654078126,
0.0876918659,
0.0198258739,
0.0047805468,
0.0329655409,
-0.0639772713,
0.0651292652,
-0.0054173088,
0.0024877859,
0.0723471642,
-0.0202632491,
0.0368153304,
-0.0781870633,
0.0154761923,
-0.0139062712,
-0.0413050875,
-0.0037459244,
0.000001544,
-0.0491984226,
0.0013068211,
0.0370307751,
-0.0430733524,
-0.0206923448,
0.0465920381,
-0.0405755788,
-0.020248279,
0.020605199,
-0.0269524138,
0.0010903189,
0.0382766277,
0.0604115464,
0.059130352,
0.0977726132,
-0.0311576203,
-0.0317932107,
0.0035795597,
0.0199601743,
0.0007842877,
-0.0067943442,
0.0500783511,
0.0110156769,
0.0078833327,
-0.0157561414,
0.0435750112,
0.0141685596,
-0.0398712121,
0.0024657638,
-0.039183557,
0.0191016402,
-0.0561293885,
-0.0524311401,
-0.0033776215,
0.0488627851,
0.0158334039,
-0.015564573,
0.0169507172,
-0.0273011588,
-0.0329684503,
0.041816365,
0.0022561278,
0.0397767536,
-0.0510449745,
0.0034171042,
0.03181969,
0.0364899933,
0.0373960845,
0.0192666166,
0.0258215684,
0.0488834679,
-0.0144584142,
-0.0349255651,
0.0288115237,
-0.0181989558,
0.0257076044,
-0.0578638241,
0.0421640761,
0.0059213131,
-0.0028536911,
0.0393850654,
0.0204822998,
0.007242037,
0.1141866371,
-0.0540305153,
-0.0185581911,
-0.031245593,
-0.0383827873,
0.0408895127,
-0.000703313,
-0.0367785469,
0.0022664508,
0.00680546,
0.0056821369,
0.0311626811,
-0.0334157385,
0.0020023989,
-0.0119565306,
-0.0011562447,
-0.0105002644,
0.0340949036,
-0.0964236781,
-0.0441628061,
-0.0217338353,
0.0586282276,
0.0288156457,
0.0131653883,
0.0125501771,
0.0002761025,
-0.0651222616,
0.0471200943,
0.0059590014,
0.0199676659,
-0.0211462788,
-0.0604821742,
0.0465427823,
-0.0131957652,
0.0203877632,
0.000104558,
0.0407070033,
-0.004351276,
0.0305433944,
-0.0239228476,
-0.0222737473,
-0.0619040988,
-0.0323320851,
-0.0397391878,
-0.0189469699,
-0.0424847975,
0.033022888,
-0.0198900532,
0.0118498048,
-0.0352974683,
0.0080647981,
0.065448612,
-0.0437636077,
0.0597425066,
-0.0738737956,
-0.0000887434,
0.0011976898,
0.0038158281,
-0.0016598504,
0.0072463094,
0.0136566982,
-0.0155130951,
0.0448438674,
0.0216717292,
-0.0037788949,
-0.030011991,
0.0448862538,
-0.0396604389,
0.069944337,
0.0235517304,
-0.0165355317,
0.0417787842,
-0.0871418118,
0.0494178124,
-0.0038789401,
-0.0257339422,
0.0215111822,
0.0283319186,
0.0025703837,
-0.0192994885,
0.0001768685,
-0.0196192693,
0.0374184847,
-0.0125603713,
-0.0200619455,
-0.0306950789,
0.0041229101,
0.0085465424,
-0.0257245153,
0.0363221467,
0.0270563923,
-0.0567465313,
-0.0694519505,
-0.0022191969,
0.0012647733,
-0.0204965491,
0.0139594749,
0.0084513696,
-0.030167494,
0.0223475117,
0.0461125374,
-0.0469733179,
-0.0364878625,
-0.0078767547,
0.0032574534,
0.0328116119,
0.047873687,
-0.0289288815,
-0.0249994174,
-0.0244102683,
0.0182379931,
0.0285411477,
0.028192807,
-0.0131930057,
0.0292655118,
-0.0135429548,
0.0024080395,
0.0183617193,
-0.0069337669,
-0.0423432589,
0.0457450524,
0.03028992,
-0.0277538635,
-0.0060624531,
-0.0722171962,
0.0412343368,
-0.0165744908,
0.0148703037,
0.0248556491,
-0.0112861516,
0.033425916,
0.0534135848,
0.0049337484,
0.0314832553,
0.0290901829,
-0.0203302018,
-0.0327338688,
0.0370784514,
0.0457876176,
-0.0162627362,
0.0216119718,
-0.0743437484,
-0.0321162716,
-0.0125655262,
-0.0607445277,
-0.0030002559,
-0.052844625,
-0.0268639792,
0.017044453,
-0.001630298,
-0.0364549309,
0.052050963,
0.0086817229,
0.0158194602,
0.0291114636,
-0.0159657579,
0.0252762586,
-0.0328530632,
-0.0488770716,
0.0021486282,
-0.0165056214,
0.0014344195,
0.0203213207,
-0.0262491256,
0.0172900688,
0.0204302613,
-0.0052118539,
-0.0187230706,
0.0441420898,
-0.0732176602,
0.0031047494,
0.0139086312,
0.0256616864,
0.0247913618,
-0.013463119,
0.0084520616,
-0.0161556192,
-0.0511679649,
-0.0159696806,
0.0247037429,
0.0058966153,
0.0539711006,
0.0170598589,
0.0020479935,
-0.0060642841,
-0.012870119,
-0.0409465954,
0.027059447,
0.0563831478,
-0.0306801572,
-0.0170890409,
-0.0392941497,
-0.0586238764,
0.0138654672,
0.0012040209,
-0.0012236448,
0.0087787891,
0.0429924093,
-0.0286969729,
0.0171549544,
0.0083426358,
-0.0062341434,
0.0306841768,
0.0514912605,
0.0068378956,
0.000650443,
-0.064347744,
0.0068778419,
-0.0040259818,
-0.0680291727,
0.0536650643,
0.0389621407,
0.0357348919,
-0.003600793,
-0.0079774428,
-0.0136245806,
-0.0122569893,
0.0301800873,
-0.021401478,
0.0027512398,
-0.0128493281,
0.0672134012,
0.0127360011,
-0.0085469643,
0.1078954637,
-0.0191266276,
0.0348180495,
-0.0750440136,
-0.0238839369,
-0.0061448249,
-0.0171430502,
0.0049515348,
0.0306230597,
0.0865126699,
0.0091945343,
0.0854631215,
-0.027668329,
0.051329989,
-0.0381443724,
-0.0050348588,
-0.0287288502,
0.0524737127,
0.0133856898,
-0.0437646732,
-0.0360460766,
-0.0629133657,
-0.0400447138,
-0.0332477652,
-0.0285409801,
0.0071035335,
-0.0881607309,
-0.0279071312,
0.0075422111,
0.0652122125,
0.0352418199,
0.0017505613,
0.0135581102,
-0.0034669994,
0.0051169489,
-0.0019475253,
0.0457111858,
0.0476960763,
-0.0119006475,
0.0989832357,
-0.0426203497,
0.0185265671,
-0.0055215908,
-0.028234791,
-0.0482609011,
-0.0514927655,
0.037504714,
0.0119798901,
0.012667953,
-0.0648630634,
0.0086894874,
0.0581979975,
0.0310553256,
0.0116020674,
0.0299312621,
0.0339618549,
-0.0656739771,
-0.0073040179,
0.0024025107,
-0.1076694429,
-0.0198605862,
-0.033054091,
0.0099278567,
-0.0617496297,
-0.0086111007,
-0.0061165811,
-0.0386646576,
0.0346036218,
-0.0237012394,
0.0302415863,
-0.044786118,
-0.086887069,
-0.0210494045,
-0.0317523889,
-0.0142068388,
-0.029997889,
0.0086479932,
-0.0142132044,
-0.0068082418,
-0.0712242499,
-0.0894107446,
0.0486954004,
0.000252985,
0.0373214521,
0.0279337317,
0.0626027584,
0.0029410163,
-0.0597509034,
-0.0188887417,
-0.0131414291,
-0.0244018044,
-0.0050399196,
0.0990426168,
0.0049487264,
0.000400272,
-0.0448411554,
0.0298503749,
-0.0434848815,
-0.0417292304,
0.0070822164,
0.0372598805,
-0.0194666609,
-0.0298772361,
-0.0373676121,
0.0583063923,
0.0192175377,
0.0655189529,
-0.0126417577,
0.0598365441,
0.0027327538,
0.0069463812,
-0.0073931245,
-0.0096104108,
-0.0326251797,
0.0745730996,
-0.0283718053,
-0.0213586371,
-0.0710822716,
0.0254463963,
0.0092522139,
0.0091193039,
-0.0196368601,
-0.0234420002,
0.0606303327,
0.0342132561,
-0.0751763657,
0.0638006851,
0.0292322487,
0.0405046195,
-0.0059165601,
-0.002611154,
0.0791844353,
-0.01201485,
-0.0038943582,
0.0365789607,
0.0116098626,
-0.0309078675,
-0.0410689525,
0.0036480722,
0.0140489321,
0.0478906929,
-0.0164087247,
-0.0076397043,
0.0129134441,
0.0158526581,
-0.0449134894,
-0.0614470989,
0.0057660779,
0.0076896111,
0.0259892717,
-0.0203986131,
0.0035480433,
0.0138774766,
-0.0205934793,
0.0203839019,
-0.0274016168,
0.015990587,
0.0640172511,
0.062272884,
0.043313276,
-0.0258488227,
0.011713732,
-0.0209757332,
0.0092133088,
-0.0246339496,
-0.0250527319,
-0.008553477,
0.0284302868,
-0.0042337556,
-0.0254729073,
-0.0199887902,
-0.0093860291,
-0.0951095745,
-0.0206288956,
-0.016324427,
0.0407958776,
0.0078528877,
0.0399691276,
0.0292515997,
-0.0364925005,
0.0045296997,
0.025316719,
-0.0077655953,
0.0327790864,
-0.0031570131,
0.0133398008,
0.0188152567,
0.009770669,
-0.0000607494,
-0.0047012283,
-0.053218022,
0.0147722848,
-0.038184952,
-0.0094418516,
0.0142945116,
0.0083519537,
0.0635076016,
-0.0484874062,
-0.0076077678,
0.0041330364,
0.0080302823,
-0.0353982337,
-0.0029811368,
0.0434707142,
-0.0069392566,
-0.0399448499,
-0.024612328,
0.0583910979,
-0.0030618547,
0.0318556987,
0.0151228001,
-0.0922740251,
-0.0401694402,
-0.0540658459,
-0.0505172126,
0.0331772715,
-0.0393301509,
-0.0317752399,
-0.0658261403,
-0.0397493541,
0.0114396112,
0.0178509038,
0.0345739648,
0.020028241,
-0.0003423756,
0.0446546786,
0.0595543534,
-0.026325034,
-0.0442557707,
0.04933016,
-0.0123826507,
0.0011842018,
0.0080712438,
-5.434329118e-33,
0.032372579,
-0.0602500625,
0.0109632919,
-0.0121570406,
0.0468295813,
0.0478051901,
-0.0365426764,
-0.0471778996,
-0.0129763102,
0.0798801482,
0.0102875382,
0.0123993205,
0.0276558101,
0.0261212792,
-0.0140402205,
-0.0179578029,
0.0283595361,
0.0245034453,
-0.0328938179,
0.0011152368,
0.0096256761,
0.0089767771,
0.0779951885,
-0.0856524184,
0.0560310371,
0.0481829979,
-0.0110429171,
0.0101973945,
-0.0309998207,
0.0613262616,
-0.0226278361,
0.0703355372,
0.0392037965,
-0.0296210982,
0.0303629059,
-0.0022148909,
-0.0964925215,
-0.006664325,
0.020668285,
-0.0155073078,
-0.0531340428,
0.0244941544,
0.0521867983,
-0.0096984934,
-0.0387891345,
0.016119983,
0.033640489,
-0.0452619493,
0.00014263,
-0.0655060709,
-0.0326206572,
0.0486502312,
0.0026790595,
0.0260805003,
-0.0236374978,
0.014696571,
-0.0397621952,
0.0076034982,
-0.0446779095,
0.0214072522,
-0.0097015137,
-0.010609963,
-0.0136591978,
-0.1142484173,
-0.0390330963,
0.041233141,
-0.0219536722,
0.0048042601,
-0.0449406467,
0.0407376289,
-0.0596531928,
0.0261650681,
0.0336486697,
0.0612702742,
0.0296541415,
-0.0305401944,
-0.0862904415,
0.0279630478,
-0.0070644971,
0.018813232,
-0.0077521414,
-0.0496688746,
-0.0473123938,
0.0230725184,
0.0048174113,
0.0078501673,
-0.0060611591,
-0.0027294157,
0.0042849085,
0.0124592474,
-0.0045071468,
0.038081456,
-0.0526720509,
-0.0419448763,
0.032779038,
-0.005319112,
0.0371311568,
-0.0333844125,
-0.0287222695,
-0.0158623923,
-0.0581653453,
0.0252371989,
-0.0162625071,
0.0213250201,
0.0248896182,
-0.0089876326,
0.0471337251,
-0.0346508771,
-0.0347302593,
0.0118650068,
0.0037429733,
0.0220948197,
0.0089893229,
0.0082404288,
0.0184028503,
0.0288203228,
-0.0214629397,
0.0581311062,
-0.003150156,
0.0035089278,
-0.0345574431,
-0.0162967127,
0.0145250196,
0.0166860092,
-0.0508362651,
-0.0279631764,
-0.0238580145,
0.0294426922,
0.0217758343,
-0.0419338532,
0.0162485763,
-0.0002614599,
2.414e-7,
0.0716569647,
0.0446228459,
0.0188259445,
-0.0116901519,
0.0307051651,
-0.0034959847,
0.0283372421,
-0.0342659391,
-0.0314342082,
-0.0514517017,
-0.0014122931,
-0.0263088252,
-0.0039096773,
0.0521713682,
-0.0288964044,
-0.0378226079,
-0.063159056,
-0.080475457,
-0.0401641428,
-0.0076436577,
0.0484042764,
0.0428599156,
-0.0082334867,
-0.033952795,
-0.020774398,
0.0173870102,
-0.0145152053,
0.020990815,
-0.0161547866,
0.0103787156,
0.0694594085,
-0.0167191718,
0.0331184231,
0.0224969257,
-0.0517732166,
-0.0113708619,
-0.0335604325,
0.0658702105,
-0.0361182429,
0.0215783454,
-0.0094977049,
-0.0324787311,
0.0326890759,
-0.0163558871,
0.0384182297,
-0.0398725234,
-0.0552687943,
-0.0427691564,
-0.03028672,
-0.03581075,
0.0602909699,
-0.0070463587,
-0.0207093097,
0.0423037894,
-0.0003360427,
0.0232377481,
-0.0174091589,
-0.0534180738,
-0.0160082411,
0.0433379747,
-0.0078347083,
-0.0100535592,
0.0738326013,
-0.0243778694,
-0.0111616077,
-0.0852653906,
0.0016216959,
1.787403675e-34,
0.0084978435,
0.0186170731,
0.0040027844,
-0.0317382626,
0.0450724624,
0.0262432061,
-0.0257072952,
-0.0058790962,
-0.0055211987,
-0.0013999601,
-0.0059145023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08491v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08491v1 | Using Large Language Models for Knowledge Engineering (LLMKE): A Case Study on Wikidata | 2023-09-15T15:51:14 | 2023-09-15T15:51:14 | Bohui Zhang, Ioannis Reklos, Nitisha Jain, Albert Meroño Peñuela, Elena Simperl | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we explore the use of Large Language Models (LLMs) for
knowledge engineering tasks in the context of the ISWC 2023 LM-KBC Challenge.
For this task, given subject and relation pairs sourced from Wikidata, we
utilize pre-trained LLMs to produce the relevant objects in string format and
link them to their respective Wikidata QIDs. We developed a pipeline using LLMs
for Knowledge Engineering (LLMKE), combining knowledge probing and Wikidata
entity mapping. The method achieved a macro-averaged F1-score of 0.701 across
the properties, with the scores varying from 1.00 to 0.328. These results
demonstrate that the knowledge of LLMs varies significantly depending on the
domain and that further experimentation is required to determine the
circumstances under which LLMs can be used for automatic Knowledge Base (e.g.,
Wikidata) completion and correction. The investigation of the results also
suggests the promising contribution of LLMs in collaborative knowledge
engineering. LLMKE won Track 2 of the challenge. The implementation is
available at https://github.com/bohuizhang/LLMKE. | [
0.0543027632,
0.0485550165,
-0.0174165871,
0.0270441603,
-0.0555570312,
0.0239606071,
-0.0436295047,
0.0212246496,
0.0530438498,
-0.0697907731,
-0.0093773426,
-0.0234901458,
-0.0195505712,
0.0147191854,
-0.0057150209,
-0.023873331,
0.0283898246,
-0.0135846566,
-0.0300025437,
-0.0133214602,
-0.0577561185,
0.0120123327,
-0.0104827611,
0.0036690186,
-0.0411168858,
-0.0209023133,
0.0052778972,
-0.019968411,
-0.0054794429,
-0.0212312173,
0.0131664081,
0.041851256,
-0.0056397943,
0.0104838507,
0.0000022143,
-0.0792927966,
-0.0145484544,
0.0083146999,
-0.0141481198,
0.032393571,
-0.0078274133,
-0.0297544524,
-0.0183164887,
-0.0016497019,
-0.0273932721,
0.0074395821,
0.0270765275,
0.0490957387,
0.0438426845,
0.0617927052,
-0.0019203242,
-0.0495052822,
0.0665649995,
-0.0100086825,
0.0146921333,
-0.054459922,
0.0579548515,
0.0479174629,
-0.0050727804,
0.021996351,
0.0205583908,
0.0306399185,
-0.0116846794,
-0.0213787463,
0.026277652,
0.026749542,
-0.0089117168,
0.0036032808,
0.0196777154,
0.066100508,
0.0375238508,
0.0361707211,
0.0182333831,
0.014271888,
-0.0152119929,
0.0555469468,
-0.0245939102,
-0.0033415016,
0.004215952,
0.0064646676,
-0.0035086414,
-0.0278320089,
0.0412095524,
0.0209711846,
-0.0267869234,
0.0878939182,
0.0293877292,
-0.0180931743,
-0.0071655489,
0.014059145,
0.0059982599,
-0.0869596153,
-0.0147610335,
0.0520188995,
0.0061850054,
0.0519630313,
-0.0164885465,
0.0161086116,
0.0160890706,
-0.0621880554,
0.0023440889,
0.0066100862,
0.016708022,
0.0508435927,
-0.0464678816,
0.0341158621,
-0.0206048079,
-0.0294789802,
-0.0394677706,
-0.0378848575,
-0.1050105691,
0.0070753512,
0.0179616343,
0.0296768229,
-0.0264829751,
-0.0277572498,
-0.0308270846,
0.0212180242,
-0.0019118899,
0.0615407005,
0.0184188019,
-0.0327737518,
-0.0053813881,
-0.0039417916,
-0.0490421131,
0.0668206811,
-0.0105022248,
0.0326572098,
-0.08376766,
0.0310940556,
0.040191628,
-0.0051402086,
-0.001722437,
-0.0506629683,
0.0047385781,
0.0704128742,
0.0338447727,
-0.0156212999,
-0.0568025038,
-0.0620621555,
0.0161303412,
-0.0363728292,
0.0198791828,
-0.0631881952,
0.0294522028,
0.0437845662,
0.0197479837,
-0.0604478344,
0.0186862107,
-0.0024404682,
-0.0616247281,
0.0802901536,
-0.0668686479,
0.0501735322,
0.0372328758,
0.0199741386,
-0.0018228416,
0.0670737997,
0.0344333127,
0.0032504511,
0.0313220918,
-0.0130475117,
-0.0363021903,
0.0369663797,
0.0205693897,
0.0218888018,
-0.0007219611,
0.0466375761,
0.0331195258,
0.0110919559,
0.0140033336,
0.0200302117,
0.0161840562,
0.0361453108,
0.054615546,
0.0308691971,
0.0468153656,
0.0129998084,
-0.0058378526,
-0.0037119372,
0.0139161656,
-0.0241412986,
-0.0394893996,
0.0238712355,
-0.0431950204,
0.0099790525,
-0.0151092168,
0.0427939557,
-0.0168618616,
-0.0073839915,
-0.0150283193,
-0.0160742067,
-0.0321475454,
-0.0202160515,
0.0657999218,
-0.0014481336,
-0.0055219298,
0.1008355618,
0.0432343334,
-0.0215154048,
0.0391698815,
-0.0121468073,
0.0100148832,
0.0775285959,
0.0494764931,
-0.0386456363,
-0.0562695116,
0.0041128797,
-0.014165503,
0.0203585271,
0.0209008045,
-0.0535380431,
-0.053498596,
-0.009808844,
-0.0593169443,
0.0174350645,
-0.0093173375,
-0.0138827078,
0.0242811181,
0.0333498493,
0.0225672629,
-0.0790590197,
-0.0072483188,
0.0362196453,
-0.0479134619,
-0.0125274314,
-0.0333678983,
0.0181664377,
0.0153985778,
0.0378195383,
0.0040275478,
0.015204275,
0.0172319524,
-0.0486865118,
-0.0512265041,
-0.0100310016,
0.0467289537,
0.0055317469,
0.069580026,
-0.0192840584,
-0.0012356652,
-0.0184175745,
-0.0286037549,
-0.0463445783,
-0.0006069517,
0.0343869068,
0.0209204368,
0.005114669,
0.0161321592,
-0.001949245,
-0.0364697054,
-0.0200223122,
0.08362066,
0.0026910272,
0.0029882926,
-0.0180782527,
-0.0530737042,
0.0142959189,
0.0607147664,
-0.0317557827,
0.030832516,
0.0111668436,
0.025348546,
0.0091747036,
-0.009628688,
-0.0596242584,
-0.0392971821,
-0.0780309737,
0.0198000222,
0.0086692655,
0.0405954048,
0.0173932072,
0.014778601,
-0.0075612175,
0.0072775995,
-0.005769758,
0.0030761624,
-0.0501299277,
0.0165073872,
0.0237254519,
0.0320239067,
0.0085472642,
-0.0193870869,
-0.0037161098,
-0.0300825723,
0.0357370898,
0.0178101212,
0.0246608406,
-0.0553530492,
0.065131329,
-0.0364091359,
-0.021376092,
0.0128414975,
-0.0115811648,
-0.0118463608,
0.0178382732,
0.0697283819,
-0.0037646901,
-0.0284885317,
0.0047988188,
0.0329433307,
-0.0405618213,
-0.0280308854,
0.0059242346,
0.0225638784,
-0.0118709635,
-0.0675254986,
-0.0231677871,
0.018718509,
0.0186277963,
-0.038549643,
-0.0357038118,
-0.0364165939,
0.0376796313,
-0.0408569649,
0.0259809941,
-0.0237541031,
-0.0316124968,
0.0322959013,
0.0333881378,
0.019423876,
0.0061897961,
0.0371859856,
-0.0308125094,
0.0642732978,
-0.0333785452,
0.016145017,
-0.0220254455,
0.0797432438,
-0.0395765975,
0.0062714415,
-0.048299592,
0.0040302216,
-0.0412100703,
-0.0032808657,
-0.0158000719,
-0.0100775808,
0.0409425572,
-0.0384576134,
0.0451980196,
-0.0237346403,
0.0152371805,
-0.045129776,
-0.0030111501,
-0.0413995162,
0.0265847705,
-0.0128950151,
0.0036065057,
0.0053641321,
0.0276532192,
0.0050006276,
-0.0115950247,
0.0288557243,
-0.0088489326,
-0.00696429,
0.0218371004,
0.0561298206,
-0.0165104903,
0.0117878448,
0.0126549946,
0.0357183367,
0.013488709,
0.0296842195,
-0.000575987,
0.0072456836,
-0.0222242698,
0.0241677929,
-0.1078595892,
-0.0325771123,
-0.0272636693,
0.0439709239,
-0.0603202097,
0.015922511,
0.1261949986,
0.052774325,
-0.0380517878,
0.0128959483,
0.0121846804,
-0.047915671,
0.0204566978,
0.0299995076,
-0.0806413814,
0.0015399773,
0.0097910371,
-0.0154123446,
0.0188177731,
-0.0783950165,
0.0099429609,
-0.1305857301,
0.0119310571,
0.0155023728,
-0.0040288433,
-0.0316411667,
-0.0487845503,
0.0416546836,
-0.0026973442,
-0.0107284887,
-0.0094038323,
-0.0136332624,
-0.0017812948,
-0.0082488516,
-0.0001055189,
-0.0852130428,
0.0412746593,
-0.0699443221,
0.088992767,
0.0726395547,
0.0396396965,
-0.0171156656,
0.0021485728,
-0.0185156688,
-0.0165218432,
-0.003860279,
0.0084202541,
0.0322496109,
-0.0173096266,
-0.0287201945,
-0.0211847071,
0.0253945794,
-0.0623996072,
-0.0181077328,
0.0405391306,
0.1134167984,
0.0002485174,
0.0044985362,
-0.0176778249,
-0.07178922,
0.013958835,
0.0975132734,
-0.0192678645,
-0.0474439152,
0.0241467357,
-0.0105229886,
-0.0181590412,
0.0099122059,
-0.033405032,
0.0286819823,
-0.0388691239,
0.0256824959,
-0.0957813188,
-0.0591687001,
0.0709681809,
-0.0208463073,
0.0268162992,
0.0278664436,
0.0324759968,
-0.0079786722,
-0.0711700097,
0.0158936717,
-0.0468621999,
0.0476238057,
-0.0373584479,
-0.005264055,
0.0569708459,
-0.0188716948,
-0.0032588625,
-0.0233182292,
-0.0267811194,
-0.0422295406,
-0.0334525108,
0.0236029737,
0.0089165177,
0.014715136,
-0.0293398276,
-0.0476528741,
0.0146488827,
0.0416027121,
-0.0812005624,
-0.0085892323,
-0.0152579034,
0.0135565503,
-0.001342328,
0.0584169216,
-0.0574009158,
0.0018616236,
0.0030310119,
0.0865189731,
-0.0197459701,
-0.0554067902,
-0.0024306905,
0.0349390395,
-0.0135492338,
-0.0102490019,
-0.018229343,
-0.0213909112,
0.019852832,
-0.0183974933,
-0.0270061009,
-0.003323606,
0.0079869628,
0.0253391732,
-0.003002441,
-0.0098469155,
0.008069111,
-0.0048712399,
0.0374432243,
-0.0358837768,
0.0294175074,
0.014274559,
0.0225666463,
0.0464793332,
-0.0065225991,
0.0095834751,
-0.0336693972,
0.0039663473,
0.0037882507,
-0.0511859395,
0.006620388,
0.0092862472,
-0.0166218914,
-0.0247669388,
0.005261146,
0.0012122218,
-0.0006116866,
0.0115833329,
0.068061918,
0.0697630197,
0.0099071711,
0.0599967428,
-0.0585559942,
-0.0335159265,
-0.0056170658,
-0.0028012239,
-0.0161792506,
0.0041569769,
0.045002766,
0.0252698213,
-0.036425069,
0.0070299893,
0.0811341852,
-0.0048756716,
0.0713715777,
0.0236235522,
-0.0376880839,
-0.0311035383,
-0.0180471987,
0.0301271733,
-0.0157205798,
-0.0478907488,
0.0294112116,
-0.069001615,
-0.0896845087,
0.0407107733,
-0.0327012539,
-0.070243828,
0.0163180549,
-0.023822384,
0.0439247265,
0.0291366521,
-0.0241554659,
-0.0303913318,
-0.0033375211,
-0.0463863835,
-0.0471260846,
0.0232138,
-6.251816746e-33,
-0.0421153419,
-0.0422033146,
0.025356425,
-0.0124233291,
-0.0099012218,
-0.0094401194,
0.0194722731,
-0.049689088,
-0.0220282692,
0.0102620414,
-0.0149552291,
-0.0052119144,
-0.0013098121,
-0.0081515256,
0.0231084768,
0.023370659,
0.0572471879,
0.0260301083,
-0.002101864,
0.0020568059,
-0.0000247411,
0.0217639524,
0.0621852055,
-0.0930939764,
0.0343822092,
0.0027417175,
0.007887613,
0.0061939722,
0.0417954139,
0.0613614731,
-0.0433262624,
0.0541456938,
0.0127377398,
-0.0189034641,
0.0145627251,
-0.0328813866,
-0.0916912705,
-0.0360800065,
0.0207432825,
0.0109677259,
0.0546516739,
-0.0633956343,
0.0272361599,
0.0020513569,
0.0326073021,
-0.0108081372,
0.0301680155,
-0.0289649088,
-0.0038989384,
-0.0213080887,
-0.0624000803,
0.0101311589,
0.0053614792,
0.0083917882,
0.0013200323,
-0.0453323089,
0.0314289518,
-0.0177389551,
-0.1022131965,
0.0151892006,
0.0292223599,
0.0327593945,
0.0724399984,
-0.043168541,
0.0167845096,
0.0178070758,
-0.017516885,
0.0142471623,
-0.0023288052,
-0.0022217385,
0.0148510393,
0.059626732,
0.0045284219,
0.0473624691,
-0.0340214521,
-0.0337411836,
-0.0686732084,
0.0234947186,
-0.0275065973,
0.0369662829,
0.0021939576,
0.0021663429,
-0.0298753399,
-0.0093703158,
-0.070135057,
0.0351557992,
-0.0231855363,
-0.0447327532,
0.0329299904,
-0.0516802445,
-0.0438372046,
0.0006519347,
0.0011342686,
-0.0714179426,
-0.0353425518,
0.032521002,
0.0099662337,
0.0237062257,
-0.0195575207,
0.0124944616,
-0.0500235856,
-0.0059784176,
0.0134186456,
-0.0227879118,
0.0013998429,
0.0278457534,
-0.0027433913,
0.0322803482,
-0.0466363207,
-0.0080964407,
-0.0106488531,
-0.038164556,
0.0094931945,
0.0021925406,
0.0318845175,
0.0314062573,
0.0137887644,
-0.0117193032,
0.0530554131,
0.0053513627,
0.003610566,
-0.0293790195,
0.0047900616,
-0.0049130577,
0.0026054678,
0.0109055741,
-0.0214051064,
0.0053656488,
0.0147375735,
-0.0060367207,
-0.0064740181,
0.0046096249,
3.016e-7,
0.0434620157,
0.0684308633,
-0.0132812317,
0.062842764,
-0.008673856,
0.0016285295,
-0.0191760827,
0.023049349,
-0.0066631702,
-0.0204296093,
0.0303084925,
0.003151519,
0.0007739234,
0.0551179051,
-0.0874667764,
-0.0336427279,
0.0097599309,
-0.0368913747,
-0.0680834353,
-0.0034419196,
0.0296483207,
0.0100470372,
0.0296911001,
0.0111521287,
-0.0321906991,
-0.0518218949,
0.0319768675,
-0.0361878127,
-0.0104242694,
0.0611572638,
0.0083730044,
0.0036731088,
0.0240537468,
0.0771035329,
-0.007328324,
0.0240029003,
0.0114083672,
0.0518772267,
-0.0027790694,
0.0003753613,
-0.0503063723,
-0.0654456615,
0.0275811478,
-0.0393358059,
0.0789571553,
-0.0271323398,
-0.0238872319,
0.0318868309,
-0.0359846912,
-0.0242229886,
-0.0100548668,
-0.0235655978,
0.0418916345,
0.0230693892,
0.0034003113,
0.0126915881,
-0.0068287523,
-0.020148607,
0.0070116655,
0.0102199046,
-0.0027410279,
-0.0622258969,
-0.0192540511,
-0.0482926071,
0.0012037881,
-0.0587165803,
0.0398111753,
2.462320644e-34,
0.0094225155,
-0.0169341192,
-0.0226064883,
0.0455937386,
0.0342415571,
-0.0121257557,
-0.0530542508,
0.0141141815,
-0.0120636513,
-0.0916431025,
0.0191577021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08469v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08469v2 | Silver Retriever: Advancing Neural Passage Retrieval for Polish Question Answering | 2023-09-15T15:19:53 | 2024-02-22T13:26:31 | Piotr Rybak, Maciej Ogrodniczuk | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Modern open-domain question answering systems often rely on accurate and
efficient retrieval components to find passages containing the facts necessary
to answer the question. Recently, neural retrievers have gained popularity over
lexical alternatives due to their superior performance. However, most of the
work concerns popular languages such as English or Chinese. For others, such as
Polish, few models are available. In this work, we present Silver Retriever, a
neural retriever for Polish trained on a diverse collection of manually or
weakly labeled datasets. Silver Retriever achieves much better results than
other Polish models and is competitive with larger multilingual models.
Together with the model, we open-source five new passage retrieval datasets. | [
0.028168546,
0.032686878,
0.0141315404,
0.0529902205,
-0.0347714685,
-0.0044821985,
0.0082906783,
-0.0044583245,
-0.001271132,
0.0140163442,
-0.0133820418,
-0.0150530096,
-0.0308602769,
0.0193541571,
0.0253639817,
-0.0292621274,
0.0550375767,
-0.0069415323,
0.0157354847,
0.0047340221,
0.0102937454,
0.0070920102,
-0.0197419003,
0.0363131203,
0.000486702,
0.0057290024,
-0.0079430453,
0.0053787585,
0.0058603883,
-0.0371797197,
0.0828316808,
-0.0057025445,
0.0201670863,
0.0399648622,
0.0000015313,
-0.015935149,
-0.0309704486,
-0.0041194335,
-0.0163175296,
-0.0361779109,
0.0167755093,
-0.0490212403,
0.0536493659,
0.0168277249,
-0.0412406549,
-0.0449756421,
0.0226848237,
0.0786681622,
0.0598418526,
0.0600210279,
0.018660875,
-0.0228112135,
0.0074697263,
-0.0250827428,
0.0042980746,
-0.0593619868,
0.0174433086,
-0.0349319465,
-0.0232989155,
0.0718203858,
0.0146182468,
0.0460265949,
0.0150944898,
-0.0085381446,
-0.0219452642,
-0.0025313529,
-0.0293867495,
0.0252728593,
-0.0236970149,
0.0677842498,
0.0264996067,
-0.0086683547,
-0.0187890232,
0.0041520386,
0.0002822492,
0.0026727132,
-0.0663135424,
0.020842785,
-0.0121130366,
0.0064782761,
-0.003290653,
0.0341533571,
-0.0022057914,
0.0230631195,
0.0037152513,
0.0900412127,
0.0244329609,
-0.0243209619,
0.0460616164,
-0.0171003491,
0.0087868003,
0.0184983946,
0.0529745631,
0.0434500054,
0.0006626796,
0.0030091808,
0.0134895733,
-0.023090519,
0.0359707586,
-0.0255868174,
0.0100998003,
0.0219446849,
-0.0457836017,
0.0614760257,
-0.0474093668,
0.0394259579,
-0.0075160228,
0.0110682035,
-0.0440526269,
-0.0951614976,
-0.0235000942,
-0.0299413074,
-0.0873140916,
0.0133665046,
-0.0498387739,
0.0028225563,
0.000304801,
-0.0122226607,
0.0299908258,
-0.0101623116,
-0.004923827,
0.0515518524,
-0.0280298274,
0.0239241924,
-0.0240848064,
0.0830442011,
-0.0981790349,
-0.0088993749,
-0.0001756413,
-0.0153477844,
-0.0263182595,
-0.0099176653,
0.0202646293,
-0.0514701344,
0.0340081863,
0.02422994,
0.0034940555,
-0.0449201465,
-0.0320709608,
-0.0125044314,
-0.0142058851,
-0.0381077901,
-0.0076394072,
-0.0532901995,
0.0547041409,
0.0103760287,
-0.0222860053,
-0.0573321842,
0.0173218716,
0.0801615119,
-0.0380495451,
0.0460617021,
-0.0424437039,
-0.0372158512,
0.0048752087,
-0.0029970447,
0.0306955855,
0.0131707797,
-0.0212559272,
0.0103699537,
0.0927788541,
0.0298747327,
0.017099129,
0.0182009023,
0.0186786149,
-0.0330704413,
0.0232545696,
0.0574858375,
0.002094026,
-0.0134552037,
0.0244501345,
0.0678353235,
-0.0228104573,
-0.0511820614,
0.0119954199,
0.075746119,
0.0159433,
0.0096002845,
0.0260744151,
-0.0205017012,
0.0155107379,
0.0086749196,
-0.0014493484,
0.0030176286,
-0.0097975861,
0.0417040735,
0.0088354507,
0.0224395748,
-0.0272757448,
-0.031898018,
0.0055568325,
0.0088187233,
0.0105914529,
0.0149215432,
0.06700629,
0.0130428616,
-0.0314291641,
0.0770759955,
0.0530539379,
-0.051930096,
-0.0247705337,
0.0020293226,
0.0394214876,
0.0354744419,
0.0366532393,
-0.0545501672,
-0.0136999879,
-0.0193266068,
0.0170092806,
0.0226965044,
0.0214671548,
-0.0325058028,
0.0108657498,
-0.0513158217,
0.0036509393,
-0.0317613259,
0.0110107772,
0.0151094459,
0.0232232995,
0.020365078,
0.0270970594,
-0.038108781,
-0.0211694427,
0.0440255962,
0.0133609762,
-0.018243691,
0.0084278258,
0.0020364269,
-0.0233049095,
0.0495788828,
0.0144041292,
0.012871163,
0.0808675662,
-0.0473423339,
-0.0055755111,
0.0014790085,
-0.0319055989,
-0.0559688583,
0.0385500193,
-0.022494195,
-0.0169208962,
0.0315647237,
-0.0277647432,
-0.0214780718,
0.0170727298,
-0.0438203439,
-0.0433841161,
-0.050715398,
-0.0245454554,
0.0230252612,
0.0270875208,
-0.054035414,
0.0400944464,
0.0037651928,
0.0663704276,
0.0193264075,
0.0438416153,
0.0625359565,
-0.0485217161,
-0.0264314003,
0.0396631174,
-0.044714205,
0.0065627294,
0.0591908917,
-0.0000462959,
-0.0415452383,
0.0225406811,
-0.0743348524,
0.0593597479,
-0.0290839504,
0.0050568227,
0.0212253612,
0.0082903318,
0.010959195,
-0.0479465052,
-0.0584626906,
-0.0285615716,
0.0601243824,
0.0269952845,
0.0370284878,
0.0175364111,
0.0273476001,
-0.0726329461,
-0.0305087231,
-0.0016311511,
0.0212419536,
-0.0237453356,
0.0029394692,
-0.040113505,
0.0114284568,
-0.0289468765,
0.0538339429,
-0.0252211913,
-0.0516253784,
-0.0009445713,
-0.0397776999,
-0.0088600134,
0.0190077443,
-0.000853074,
-0.0346182659,
0.0033098171,
-0.0317969657,
-0.0489984863,
0.0410316214,
-0.0399599262,
-0.0040522064,
0.0176621843,
0.0055881292,
0.021696128,
0.0323765837,
-0.0030221168,
-0.0136098564,
0.0113286767,
-0.0104190605,
-0.035383299,
0.026663335,
-0.0510042906,
0.0205203947,
-0.0115829594,
0.0145335952,
-0.0135176852,
0.0052608596,
0.0499488376,
-0.0259782262,
-0.0292228516,
-0.0631472096,
-0.0519327894,
-0.0790041238,
0.0826557949,
-0.0031835092,
0.0159382969,
-0.0050459956,
-0.0419811383,
-0.014021242,
-0.0511986315,
-0.0166856069,
-0.0283795651,
0.0432558209,
0.0090788286,
0.012725574,
-0.0204591844,
-0.0398895927,
-0.0522733331,
-0.0646856651,
-0.0116283987,
0.0188838281,
-0.0283104442,
-0.01370015,
0.00268088,
-0.0163887423,
0.0443465039,
0.0636066124,
-0.0261850245,
0.0006508188,
-0.0379007421,
0.06571199,
0.0392574631,
0.0073388256,
0.0060165199,
-0.0294825137,
-0.0260839239,
0.0425090604,
0.0269401297,
-0.0258892421,
0.0188489351,
-0.0155474488,
0.0328309387,
-0.047999125,
0.0209602937,
-0.0161148105,
0.0095860688,
-0.0820205733,
-0.0615313724,
0.0876277909,
0.0324189998,
-0.0269544385,
-0.0366642475,
-0.036276076,
-0.0236302707,
0.0169284604,
0.0450932384,
-0.0802277625,
-0.0359054208,
-0.0051805363,
0.0447238162,
0.0215566438,
-0.0039550816,
0.0136308251,
-0.1192431003,
-0.019346023,
-0.0137850801,
-0.0735157356,
-0.0875335187,
-0.0439130962,
-0.0141119184,
-0.0002115129,
0.0222305804,
0.0467626825,
-0.0135663422,
0.0108415401,
0.0017677933,
0.0223094597,
-0.0156906955,
0.018433867,
-0.0451751426,
-0.0196723994,
0.0604243688,
0.0299559832,
-0.0191985406,
0.0117740156,
0.0081302924,
-0.0881954357,
-0.0148051418,
0.0039330451,
0.0831498951,
0.0254036002,
-0.0116190501,
-0.050076019,
0.0356666371,
-0.0083131809,
0.0074058869,
0.0206493586,
0.0270836595,
0.0079594934,
-0.0011107452,
0.0091210725,
0.0131271146,
0.0306399949,
0.0579646528,
0.0017113473,
0.0183092766,
-0.0412275828,
-0.0421012305,
-0.0067277662,
-0.0721371621,
-0.0565561727,
0.0478863791,
0.0087897358,
0.0321109928,
-0.0883460715,
-0.0875266045,
0.0338087305,
0.0366540626,
-0.0100063551,
0.0319023617,
-0.0357833914,
-0.0094027808,
-0.0478546359,
0.0663546175,
-0.0419239886,
0.0043138149,
-0.0605767593,
-0.0142140575,
0.0266714748,
-0.0051349942,
-0.0121614924,
0.0212428533,
-0.0283673964,
-0.0446059331,
-0.0063896431,
0.0542931482,
0.0172386821,
-0.0144078312,
-0.0233459342,
0.0034834645,
0.0087915007,
0.0204864256,
-0.0577982217,
-0.0278744996,
0.007411052,
0.0099567464,
-0.0250418037,
0.0158098564,
-0.0330664702,
-0.0032479896,
-0.0097657694,
0.0525067113,
0.0228441674,
-0.053778559,
0.0296217427,
0.0163575113,
0.022052398,
0.0566375069,
-0.0205892175,
-0.0485850051,
0.0229599643,
-0.0136031508,
-0.0477445833,
0.0146085517,
0.0295248311,
0.0080908444,
-0.047908254,
-0.027079355,
0.009567068,
0.0206545498,
0.0491972752,
-0.0906098559,
-0.0198852345,
0.049133271,
-0.0206727609,
-0.0253008101,
0.009340384,
-0.0134057375,
0.0262969062,
-0.0094334558,
0.0612542517,
-0.018696351,
0.0451689623,
0.0180907641,
-0.0427263491,
-0.0089521753,
-0.0005620415,
-0.0658567846,
0.0081447726,
0.0118186297,
0.0204038192,
0.0705111995,
-0.0259153061,
0.0243505314,
0.0214585736,
-0.0438921265,
-0.0214746315,
-0.028299585,
0.0056949402,
0.004095952,
0.0159224588,
0.0297921095,
-0.0217845738,
0.0162013918,
0.0412307307,
-0.0196957756,
0.0399206392,
0.0043806108,
-0.0189925469,
-0.0182904843,
0.0188864991,
-0.0305555463,
-0.0067535075,
-0.0203370657,
-0.0139149474,
-0.0113884863,
-0.0433361419,
0.0171427708,
0.0133361034,
-0.0175542682,
0.0159364697,
0.0340126418,
0.0327276103,
0.0344739705,
-0.0420754589,
-0.0540322736,
0.0550775155,
-0.0039721532,
-0.0288030226,
-0.0704149008,
-5.376520143e-33,
-0.0398949198,
-0.0117487106,
0.0168074481,
-0.0285894331,
-0.0247518327,
-0.0053446894,
-0.0318588763,
-0.0264291577,
-0.0643926635,
0.0158198196,
-0.0143070575,
-0.0110372184,
0.0153170181,
0.0514210835,
0.0183220264,
-0.0299310852,
0.0213089641,
0.0176276322,
0.0056547471,
0.0002826366,
0.0880833939,
0.0683736429,
0.0442019403,
-0.0290351976,
0.0198036544,
-0.0491094813,
0.0188191924,
0.0323940739,
0.0362691358,
0.0507400781,
-0.0026761265,
0.024793772,
0.0226959102,
-0.0244194735,
0.0138352141,
0.0259084664,
-0.1136995405,
-0.0394295864,
-0.0109452624,
0.0272681713,
-0.0051723979,
-0.030873023,
0.0142461592,
-0.0579893105,
0.0537023135,
0.0411377214,
0.0316589847,
-0.0204683859,
0.0135463318,
-0.0132709006,
-0.0411222577,
0.0044673975,
0.0065153558,
-0.0046567027,
-0.0122990115,
0.0760691538,
0.0241643656,
-0.0120926639,
-0.0358237699,
-0.0253572371,
0.0158203505,
0.065367341,
-0.0546480902,
0.0148930624,
-0.0045705764,
0.0246375035,
0.041336298,
-0.0596590042,
-0.0033899939,
-0.0082618957,
0.0100441743,
-0.0111952899,
0.0679083318,
0.0237292983,
-0.01477182,
0.0373429172,
-0.074646838,
0.0178723652,
0.0592921861,
0.0589244701,
-0.0130783217,
-0.0195491891,
-0.0235959496,
0.0006237535,
-0.008554494,
0.0113576278,
-0.0348578356,
-0.0264716931,
0.0719338804,
-0.0064386684,
0.0083670933,
0.0126526542,
0.0309598371,
-0.0291529596,
-0.0097550312,
0.0657887682,
0.0064147227,
-0.0047031445,
-0.0232784897,
0.0485001765,
-0.0327915996,
-0.0029174206,
-0.0262114909,
-0.0347061828,
-0.0052119517,
0.0108657861,
0.0344404168,
-0.0036685218,
-0.0729625747,
0.0285901986,
-0.0339954533,
0.0343737416,
-0.0040767235,
0.0641565025,
-0.0008119813,
0.0327410549,
-0.0156461392,
0.0775249749,
0.034125939,
0.018454317,
-0.0615281574,
-0.0576072894,
0.0374713577,
0.0112216491,
-0.0072129713,
0.0601581559,
-0.0189234223,
0.0867079869,
-0.0504035503,
-0.004324744,
0.0373449102,
0.0242165159,
2.269e-7,
0.0565469898,
-0.0107799564,
0.0283068996,
0.0513407849,
-0.0391829684,
0.0104935812,
-0.0291243382,
-0.0027177657,
0.0041529085,
0.0262847915,
-0.0231962278,
0.0195381381,
0.0265837722,
0.0340707563,
-0.1087795049,
0.0025497745,
-0.0473988131,
-0.0574556775,
-0.0300291572,
-0.010545277,
0.0318930484,
0.1064861491,
0.0160972141,
-0.000042239,
-0.0588722713,
-0.1065091565,
0.0492021516,
0.0351097547,
-0.0480255894,
0.0117668612,
0.0429183021,
0.0584454872,
-0.0139253801,
-0.0154872769,
0.0107149445,
0.0654478967,
0.0256402995,
0.0266638529,
0.0176823605,
-0.0792813003,
0.0075389482,
-0.0234135538,
-0.0213453304,
-0.0238855276,
0.0844508037,
-0.0185768474,
0.0152559346,
0.0212368183,
0.0047992431,
0.0065133763,
0.0208077375,
-0.0268682819,
-0.0202845745,
0.0287210047,
0.0198802613,
-0.0216235165,
0.0060972329,
-0.0889369622,
-0.0089342101,
0.0247035082,
-0.0130044715,
0.0074012578,
-0.0118021732,
0.0035476435,
-0.0618836321,
-0.0420574695,
0.0101504829,
1.722884877e-34,
0.0133391246,
0.0003343378,
-0.0121244742,
0.0211001243,
0.0262707323,
-0.0120175956,
0.00971046,
0.0080898739,
0.0010498147,
-0.0740328804,
-0.0287532937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08650v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08650v1 | Adversarial Attacks on Tables with Entity Swap | 2023-09-15T15:03:33 | 2023-09-15T15:03:33 | Aneta Koleva, Martin Ringsquandl, Volker Tresp | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR | The capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have been successfully
applied in the context of table representation learning. The recently proposed
tabular language models have reported state-of-the-art results across various
tasks for table interpretation. However, a closer look into the datasets
commonly used for evaluation reveals an entity leakage from the train set into
the test set. Motivated by this observation, we explore adversarial attacks
that represent a more realistic inference setup. Adversarial attacks on text
have been shown to greatly affect the performance of LLMs, but currently, there
are no attacks targeting tabular language models. In this paper, we propose an
evasive entity-swap attack for the column type annotation (CTA) task. Our CTA
attack is the first black-box attack on tables, where we employ a
similarity-based sampling strategy to generate adversarial examples. The
experimental results show that the proposed attack generates up to a 70% drop
in performance. | [
0.0169053953,
0.0853978619,
-0.0239514913,
0.0640303716,
-0.0073052985,
0.0408534557,
0.0075903004,
0.0227409434,
0.0015067114,
-0.0479238331,
-0.028528858,
-0.000310466,
-0.0027369449,
0.0095130932,
0.0884790421,
0.0360014774,
0.0265169721,
0.0096225236,
-0.0774774626,
0.0172171891,
0.0042328979,
-0.0286292415,
0.0208904967,
0.0106107453,
0.0079956399,
0.0040036985,
-0.0179382786,
0.0064782803,
-0.0199596211,
0.0040593357,
-0.0002146412,
0.0639688671,
0.0102091031,
0.0923933163,
0.0000020487,
0.0347221494,
-0.0745012164,
0.020877149,
-0.0223400686,
0.0415501781,
0.0337631293,
-0.0682778507,
-0.0133488942,
-0.0279480368,
-0.0320680141,
-0.0433926247,
-0.0007854968,
0.0502030291,
0.0519512147,
0.0849893093,
-0.0164813902,
-0.0239216276,
0.0017462185,
-0.0575671643,
0.0353697874,
-0.0633714944,
0.0138281304,
-0.0207931045,
-0.0444322377,
0.0041550421,
-0.0058586518,
0.0449226312,
0.0262629129,
-0.0012868771,
-0.0250647403,
0.0275293775,
-0.0175355747,
0.0562638603,
0.0301383659,
0.0787974671,
-0.0229907073,
-0.0069684759,
0.013309502,
0.0149138719,
0.0359545425,
-0.0227617193,
-0.0015631671,
-0.0097571081,
0.0110494411,
-0.0042537716,
0.0019780991,
-0.0316569507,
0.0364731252,
-0.0334193222,
-0.0390894301,
-0.0066730767,
-0.0125399027,
-0.036013931,
0.0070182891,
-0.0230102558,
-0.0043180808,
-0.0186505597,
0.0070379782,
-0.0047923457,
-0.014002596,
0.0153919263,
-0.0297213197,
-0.05643031,
0.036524497,
-0.0810442045,
0.0556750111,
0.0126973959,
0.0087477937,
0.0093124071,
-0.0477378555,
0.010819695,
-0.0452535115,
0.0656226203,
-0.0248817541,
0.0020168757,
-0.002320128,
0.000837068,
-0.006194483,
0.0120574981,
-0.0530143194,
0.0264348108,
-0.0071916603,
-0.0111120883,
-0.0238312427,
0.0791303068,
-0.007399709,
0.0207915772,
-0.0195959434,
-0.0008910156,
-0.0006385767,
-0.0270329081,
-0.0004341377,
-0.0101948353,
-0.0354224592,
-0.0907430649,
-0.039403636,
-0.0014639845,
-0.0328648426,
-0.0393771008,
0.0163740776,
0.1194322407,
-0.0195831209,
-0.0216705371,
-0.0549440235,
-0.0164896175,
-0.0298526902,
-0.0288932435,
0.008811662,
-0.0282495823,
0.0294793528,
-0.0125369998,
0.0128434766,
-0.069899492,
-0.0051188041,
0.0371909589,
-0.0403550006,
0.0975148454,
0.026188802,
-0.0119175371,
-0.0000794981,
-0.0054578125,
-0.0306763332,
0.0679668859,
0.0254008863,
0.0271419343,
-0.0105603039,
-0.022548005,
-0.021328168,
0.0649841502,
0.0408504046,
0.008019126,
0.0139613217,
0.0322165638,
0.0402154326,
0.023828309,
0.0119015714,
0.0212422144,
-0.0210560467,
-0.0555109642,
0.0727206841,
0.0076731816,
-0.0406566523,
0.0991008356,
-0.0004271761,
-0.0153118586,
0.0052490123,
0.022156205,
-0.0425612926,
-0.0042962609,
0.0011230108,
-0.0375855975,
0.0342769958,
-0.0132824993,
-0.0064636678,
-0.0394539796,
0.0165822189,
-0.0205341745,
0.0146103082,
-0.012294733,
0.0175319351,
0.053079199,
-0.0331881233,
0.0138291521,
0.0059240921,
-0.0354558229,
-0.0410193279,
-0.0343118608,
-0.0001663685,
0.05052156,
0.037164934,
-0.0764887407,
0.0180525444,
-0.0284130182,
0.0000719817,
-0.0073851077,
0.0467354432,
-0.0393536352,
-0.0094938222,
0.0208458882,
0.0173757635,
0.0003555451,
0.0372220539,
0.0041003702,
-0.0029617629,
-0.001168747,
0.0001491403,
-0.0736910105,
-0.0643935278,
0.0420502946,
0.0442364328,
-0.0349691436,
0.0202395804,
0.0366045162,
0.0091951666,
0.0110778138,
-0.0320719071,
0.028046038,
0.0610671714,
-0.0207694154,
0.0159818344,
-0.032654319,
0.02528424,
-0.0093617178,
0.001660939,
0.0143763544,
-0.0719932988,
-0.0032216562,
-0.0498451702,
0.0253921878,
0.0340998545,
-0.0287396424,
-0.0235005971,
0.0151374331,
0.0155015429,
0.0090799835,
0.038240999,
-0.0226699784,
0.0836837217,
-0.0475272685,
0.0187740326,
0.0012154543,
-0.0618130378,
0.0262881219,
-0.0474637672,
-0.0086133499,
-0.0008181643,
-0.0000524897,
0.013127733,
-0.0153397517,
-0.014352845,
-0.0243448112,
-0.0295524579,
-0.0541768484,
0.012882892,
-0.0335377268,
0.0366881825,
0.0201776512,
-0.0329025686,
-0.0077774939,
-0.0417238846,
-0.0283769481,
-0.0234994404,
-0.0555616245,
0.0203044433,
0.0431755371,
-0.0079401908,
0.0057125147,
-0.011224648,
-0.0256383587,
-0.041574277,
0.0724706352,
-0.0409806594,
-0.0154812094,
-0.004762318,
-0.0055634771,
0.0451966785,
0.0259098373,
-0.0030160395,
0.0045656394,
0.0021381213,
0.0054005682,
-0.0134010147,
0.110875234,
-0.0174439587,
0.0870073363,
-0.0009486846,
0.0133699309,
-0.019092774,
0.0027955933,
0.0440515615,
0.0261826403,
-0.038629327,
-0.0748867691,
0.0340603888,
0.0294922516,
-0.006170854,
0.0078149159,
-0.0076518073,
0.0245640744,
0.0088754538,
-0.0135438628,
-0.0395876281,
0.0670623705,
-0.0043129078,
-0.0582566895,
-0.0325701125,
-0.000971865,
0.0070400229,
-0.0346865393,
0.0279131625,
-0.0070124399,
-0.0177260526,
-0.0173920095,
0.0660044923,
0.0251971744,
-0.0096050901,
0.0054201367,
-0.015434159,
-0.0419755988,
0.0134003973,
0.0375488177,
-0.0365255885,
0.1006589383,
-0.0104151759,
0.0070195454,
-0.0177439637,
-0.0339893512,
-0.0155499261,
-0.0482916981,
-0.0082037337,
0.0235209726,
0.0518704727,
-0.0147568742,
-0.0528391898,
-0.051559072,
0.0071337079,
0.0362319313,
-0.001074095,
-0.0101613933,
-0.0251816418,
0.0579664372,
0.0251059569,
-0.0260134377,
-0.0202970002,
-0.0270324964,
0.0138099585,
0.0832247213,
-0.0260273665,
-0.0025568751,
-0.0211103819,
0.0059219925,
-0.0053916066,
-0.0134109957,
-0.0183252916,
0.0077492995,
-0.0573524088,
-0.058328595,
-0.010353243,
0.0399395898,
0.0044540763,
0.02009812,
0.0186995938,
0.0384599939,
0.0368150547,
0.0131313074,
0.0271628406,
-0.1253978163,
-0.0214901548,
0.0048469524,
0.007457477,
0.0134125296,
-0.0696676895,
-0.0116552664,
-0.1060358137,
0.0078853872,
-0.0341767818,
-0.0844718292,
-0.0677196458,
-0.0151197771,
-0.0255614817,
-0.0654606223,
0.0494596809,
0.0133246947,
0.0049142106,
0.02326403,
0.0206135176,
-0.0020066346,
-0.0274532028,
-0.0270031076,
-0.0621473528,
0.0439695492,
0.0654946417,
0.0452358052,
-0.0336120017,
0.0059521561,
-0.0107613783,
0.0340073854,
-0.017317662,
0.0082487417,
0.1123770028,
-0.0311627276,
-0.0134599069,
0.0301551633,
0.012048196,
-0.0111038014,
0.0038838303,
0.0351990648,
0.0345465317,
-0.0050621629,
-0.0103829382,
0.0267630406,
-0.0444476195,
0.0185590424,
0.0583903939,
0.0238566007,
-0.0267020669,
-0.0306390747,
-0.057852,
-0.0435121804,
-0.0532521084,
-0.0185076706,
0.0470831096,
-0.0135733476,
-0.0348218828,
-0.0558362752,
-0.0087365173,
0.0312803537,
0.0294360127,
-0.007226612,
0.0663872212,
-0.0559853949,
-0.0164371915,
-0.0438638218,
-0.0365746915,
-0.0450594239,
0.0291623399,
0.0163118839,
-0.0661037415,
-0.0021573093,
-0.0081455335,
-0.0195768382,
0.0126675041,
-0.0904453993,
-0.0416199937,
0.0148782972,
0.0318848267,
0.0117514534,
0.0290681161,
0.0141856764,
-0.0344033316,
0.000645281,
0.034475632,
-0.0494221151,
-0.0207965747,
0.0292363316,
-0.0432493836,
0.0202290621,
0.0572925024,
-0.0213015489,
-0.0375162885,
0.0398566499,
-0.0014868752,
-0.0188818928,
0.0535663068,
0.0285880473,
-0.0119094942,
-0.0045008762,
0.0339577682,
-0.0498628654,
0.0185059737,
0.058468949,
-0.0406796187,
-0.053018447,
0.029222453,
-0.0080848131,
0.0087011606,
0.0248898678,
-0.0255256239,
0.0361585468,
0.0533982255,
0.0408918299,
-0.0381149016,
-0.0053573512,
0.0586032607,
-0.0103310123,
0.0187154934,
0.00603808,
0.001424537,
0.0061407201,
0.0337196216,
0.0361430682,
0.0040852418,
-0.0145183951,
0.0331019014,
-0.0305731148,
-0.0158263016,
0.0371463075,
-0.0335559919,
-0.0155554647,
-0.0107419696,
0.0310871173,
0.0191701148,
-0.0261757076,
-0.0115276957,
-0.024132153,
-0.0234396439,
0.0228302889,
-0.0250251908,
0.0229251012,
0.0113404701,
0.0254566949,
-0.0083044413,
-0.0110265352,
0.0162375849,
0.0950616449,
0.0565849878,
0.0434490964,
-0.0050489148,
-0.0337741561,
-0.0624787025,
0.0040616775,
0.0202008188,
-0.0282057505,
-0.0236695558,
-0.0496257953,
-0.0266802255,
-0.0586752109,
0.0270000789,
0.0346011333,
-0.012253603,
0.0191025585,
-0.0138200521,
0.0530982353,
0.0503717922,
0.0214876439,
-0.0566080958,
0.0408190675,
0.0156493727,
-0.062988691,
-0.017233979,
-6.113176739e-33,
-0.0142343398,
-0.0147767533,
-0.012451645,
-0.0376834162,
0.0382608026,
-0.0053036278,
-0.0254054572,
-0.0194839817,
-0.016892245,
0.0057791406,
-0.0205269847,
0.0293200221,
-0.0018989687,
-0.011738521,
-0.0023254307,
-0.0879158229,
0.0268358327,
-0.0270913783,
0.001405393,
-0.0061723278,
0.0092401337,
0.0405821018,
0.0315161385,
-0.0447377041,
0.0625352487,
-0.0117729669,
-0.035926953,
-0.0229270831,
-0.0262245964,
0.0319254436,
-0.0255919807,
0.0130246729,
0.0278954674,
-0.0481897034,
-0.0142071126,
-0.0021907636,
-0.1086403355,
0.0232543964,
-0.0072467388,
0.0501834005,
0.0021018221,
-0.0491741188,
0.0320466869,
-0.0052798288,
-0.0028535891,
-0.0006404705,
-0.0021928712,
-0.0334101841,
0.0022056829,
-0.0031056835,
-0.0206184518,
0.0169648565,
-0.0210629031,
0.0269260127,
0.0579369664,
0.0051345676,
0.053228341,
-0.0287132766,
-0.0714301467,
0.0026442034,
0.0205540266,
0.0053948294,
0.0180676691,
-0.0194922723,
0.0238624718,
0.0387961492,
0.0332324356,
0.028444102,
-0.0299901571,
-0.0032285524,
-0.0077255918,
0.0219048392,
0.0581695214,
0.0504813455,
0.0531419814,
-0.0143265594,
-0.0877601579,
0.0519087277,
0.0039680325,
-0.0088082599,
0.0209140144,
-0.0003680182,
-0.0457826704,
-0.0007127752,
-0.0175309181,
-0.0393004231,
-0.0261387713,
-0.0151928645,
0.0056939442,
-0.0070683062,
0.0144482693,
0.011404206,
-0.0187833067,
-0.0426753163,
-0.0534696691,
0.038176287,
-0.0155706126,
-0.0203923807,
0.00964515,
-0.0164722167,
-0.0087603889,
-0.0176338684,
0.0317238756,
-0.0572744422,
0.0543299727,
0.0392676406,
0.104552269,
-0.0085221957,
-0.0650367141,
-0.0183590986,
-0.0124659576,
0.0287289247,
0.0294247866,
0.0435429141,
0.0226719137,
0.0009122391,
0.0015252077,
0.0120400619,
0.0482549891,
0.0367037095,
-0.0002898626,
0.035809733,
-0.0046475003,
-0.0058927559,
0.0171872955,
-0.0048962315,
0.0034181925,
0.0247760806,
0.0202063322,
-0.088014245,
0.0111130951,
-0.0360520929,
2.645e-7,
0.0818355605,
0.0162268244,
0.0398276187,
-0.0144561911,
0.0321694985,
0.0325754173,
-0.0139266858,
0.0650897995,
-0.0497126542,
-0.0411563143,
0.0258900449,
-0.0163760632,
0.074465178,
0.0200533736,
-0.0662297457,
-0.0048324782,
-0.0646844581,
0.0104830582,
-0.0360732488,
0.0052599739,
0.013926588,
0.1450949907,
-0.0408068039,
-0.001907369,
0.0204787608,
-0.0084376037,
0.0373637527,
-0.0536769331,
0.0281243268,
-0.0008444413,
0.0409346521,
-0.004545866,
-0.0058586611,
0.0690907016,
-0.0385674089,
-0.0077761402,
0.0306070969,
0.0023990169,
0.0209756158,
0.0145570552,
-0.0281725191,
-0.1032726243,
0.0035158445,
-0.0341977961,
0.1038462296,
-0.034302745,
-0.0265949052,
0.0436411723,
0.0018777429,
0.0305464026,
0.0361427553,
0.0068954886,
-0.0120809339,
0.0077959467,
0.023687806,
0.0004611077,
0.0177909378,
-0.0504158847,
0.0016574253,
0.005586735,
-0.0204505362,
-0.0054676281,
-0.0035557942,
-0.0259842742,
-0.0191929657,
-0.0322388746,
-0.0070831487,
2.497761569e-34,
0.0163067784,
0.0079314299,
0.0350524932,
0.0467888527,
0.0570701063,
-0.0327939689,
0.032508865,
-0.0089640655,
0.0017876099,
-0.0628952384,
-0.0280002784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08454v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08454v1 | Mixture Encoder Supporting Continuous Speech Separation for Meeting Recognition | 2023-09-15T14:57:28 | 2023-09-15T14:57:28 | Peter Vieting, Simon Berger, Thilo von Neumann, Christoph Boeddeker, Ralf Schlüter, Reinhold Haeb-Umbach | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Many real-life applications of automatic speech recognition (ASR) require
processing of overlapped speech. A commonmethod involves first separating the
speech into overlap-free streams and then performing ASR on the resulting
signals. Recently, the inclusion of a mixture encoder in the ASR model has been
proposed. This mixture encoder leverages the original overlapped speech to
mitigate the effect of artifacts introduced by the speech separation.
Previously, however, the method only addressed two-speaker scenarios. In this
work, we extend this approach to more natural meeting contexts featuring an
arbitrary number of speakers and dynamic overlaps. We evaluate the performance
using different speech separators, including the powerful TF-GridNet model. Our
experiments show state-of-the-art performance on the LibriCSS dataset and
highlight the advantages of the mixture encoder. Furthermore, they demonstrate
the strong separation of TF-GridNet which largely closes the gap between
previous methods and oracle separation. | [
-0.0133763766,
0.0168386679,
0.0261945855,
0.0749689341,
0.0097250799,
-0.0067646601,
0.0637140498,
0.0173616987,
0.0112510668,
0.01947085,
-0.0281718131,
-0.0206575729,
0.0167228375,
0.0354891717,
-0.0044382773,
-0.0836774409,
-0.0143750589,
-0.0414412208,
-0.0267417636,
0.009629406,
0.0009839671,
-0.0105251614,
-0.0702225789,
-0.0139284777,
-0.0314765386,
0.0256863963,
-0.0343119614,
-0.0207486413,
0.0564930476,
0.0725029185,
-0.035977412,
0.0088537699,
0.0860118493,
0.0536626987,
0.0000018241,
0.0095644081,
-0.0361158177,
0.0062876041,
-0.0444852747,
-0.0491335429,
-0.0298309699,
0.0565789267,
-0.0075900718,
0.0153176151,
-0.0186996516,
-0.0038196268,
0.0165139232,
0.0295920912,
0.0344316699,
0.0231029838,
-0.0046914336,
0.000049902,
0.0096388385,
-0.0006845274,
0.0144464234,
-0.0209449716,
0.0067802393,
-0.015463748,
-0.0279483311,
-0.0788117051,
0.0031998586,
0.0328567922,
0.0228142217,
0.0081104692,
0.0696203187,
0.040078517,
-0.0653573796,
-0.0523103662,
-0.0357850641,
0.0708199665,
-0.0152142597,
0.0331363231,
0.0598753132,
-0.0057794997,
-0.0379444696,
-0.0168583076,
-0.0315146223,
-0.0259137619,
-0.0224506762,
-0.0096035469,
-0.0891934037,
0.052187901,
-0.0033276223,
-0.0082017109,
-0.0515826382,
0.043138653,
0.007898299,
-0.0056877811,
-0.0391654819,
-0.0182846617,
0.0498129427,
-0.0146915419,
0.0652045459,
-0.0059410147,
-0.0385928787,
-0.0103532663,
0.0133413021,
-0.0265657771,
-0.0742654875,
0.0043661804,
-0.0361939184,
0.0498363003,
-0.0078018671,
-0.0155648785,
0.0346582197,
0.0422299169,
-0.032042332,
-0.0171384476,
0.0001497377,
-0.0120546585,
0.0172504373,
0.0207301285,
-0.047842484,
-0.0102582956,
-0.0473325178,
-0.0379099771,
-0.0175358895,
0.0249535386,
-0.0425245948,
0.0023583069,
-0.0026690285,
-0.0121070724,
0.0032526101,
-0.037348479,
0.0332089961,
0.0154951345,
0.0044427966,
0.0296821576,
0.0208340902,
-0.0867813081,
-0.0197296124,
0.0218435824,
0.0661671981,
0.0125543587,
-0.0617833436,
0.0305271447,
-0.0304034334,
-0.0072947936,
-0.0015804685,
0.0044906544,
0.0018029745,
-0.0261273198,
0.0040465631,
-0.0454239696,
0.1059518531,
-0.0013080704,
0.0038698346,
0.0037620354,
0.0133076496,
-0.0433445871,
0.0178901125,
0.0518504456,
-0.0491941608,
0.019107746,
0.1226086318,
-0.0021579249,
-0.0337112993,
0.0260303039,
0.0381930657,
0.0056334212,
0.0274164751,
-0.0084841205,
0.0181435756,
0.0642365813,
-0.026355423,
-0.0343014635,
-0.0022041986,
-0.0039510443,
-0.0007062805,
0.0127956597,
-0.0073490962,
0.002705639,
-0.0383495949,
0.0355227217,
-0.0040293625,
0.0309521873,
-0.0071772705,
0.0043755877,
0.0090649845,
0.0236912705,
-0.0240647588,
0.0269495901,
0.0172948111,
-0.0423491709,
-0.0145830037,
-0.0383387879,
0.0960058942,
0.0417473353,
-0.0361319333,
0.0084579615,
0.0419714302,
-0.0575662144,
-0.0143442722,
0.030947458,
0.0457645841,
-0.0433455333,
-0.0281123258,
0.0210668407,
0.0017493647,
-0.102278173,
0.0214856733,
-0.0082791578,
0.0107322317,
0.0727823228,
-0.0071942112,
-0.0234242156,
-0.0255394764,
-0.0279800501,
-0.0535103641,
0.0043990845,
0.0080598108,
-0.0018509895,
0.0704646856,
-0.0637678131,
-0.0315754376,
0.0681324527,
-0.0090186978,
0.0698520169,
0.0105086165,
0.0241769142,
0.0570814386,
0.0391392224,
0.0819701552,
-0.0133082625,
-0.0029495456,
0.0202416405,
-0.0160271488,
-0.0058542467,
0.0709204972,
0.0494870357,
-0.0497518666,
-0.0175783951,
0.0447291508,
-0.0273660049,
0.0021672028,
0.0125905778,
-0.0552826822,
-0.0593380667,
0.0353150293,
0.0117002372,
-0.0212573465,
-0.0071029579,
-0.002253399,
-0.0813708082,
0.0104633542,
0.004307643,
0.0566316582,
-0.0253819283,
0.0161948111,
0.0057867905,
0.0235493667,
0.0160305761,
0.0182168093,
0.0046402565,
0.0103568938,
-0.0008820128,
-0.0074710087,
0.006256714,
-0.0848869979,
0.0115230223,
0.0104191341,
-0.0087302085,
0.041371502,
-0.0189677496,
-0.0004154782,
-0.0140533717,
-0.0158088952,
-0.0850411803,
0.0305790696,
-0.0282277111,
-0.0210457537,
-0.0444674753,
0.0288827531,
-0.0109976809,
-0.0231867973,
-0.0465258099,
-0.0239996463,
0.0009744418,
-0.0518412367,
-0.0638540462,
0.0153061878,
-0.0670386925,
-0.0078663398,
-0.0323237441,
0.0388477258,
-0.0012764883,
-0.0477582291,
-0.1144437566,
0.0126562454,
-0.0320481323,
-0.0057638655,
0.0328321569,
-0.0130526088,
0.0636658221,
-0.0206952114,
0.003985968,
0.0570987985,
-0.0035059152,
0.0304712821,
0.0266090073,
-0.0262107905,
-0.0270362962,
-0.0305520259,
0.0210232791,
0.0106150089,
0.0772449225,
0.0471005701,
0.026099775,
-0.0085137868,
-0.039503362,
0.0096731707,
0.0422578752,
-0.0351468064,
-0.0439295359,
-0.0102723893,
-0.0748078451,
-0.067431882,
-0.0437994637,
-0.0432120003,
0.0033081151,
-0.013926547,
0.0033660945,
-0.0335721001,
-0.0562772453,
-0.0401317924,
0.0097404616,
-0.0551790297,
-0.0110654728,
-0.0473942906,
-0.0071091573,
-0.0068737133,
-0.0493815206,
-0.0584203564,
0.0178832263,
-0.0397441164,
-0.0347056612,
-0.0933437124,
0.0370888188,
0.0000302197,
-0.0067268698,
-0.0141260531,
0.0056861611,
-0.0422716439,
0.024737224,
0.0075222761,
0.0008772688,
-0.0080339704,
-0.0177095179,
-0.0293499343,
0.0528754592,
0.002715304,
0.0551552661,
-0.015177615,
0.0472271852,
-0.0411228612,
0.1241220981,
-0.0130988928,
0.0619831122,
-0.0001057026,
-0.0227933321,
-0.0212009326,
-0.0138235204,
0.0698203444,
-0.0180722773,
-0.0211173166,
-0.0227891039,
-0.0011402381,
0.0158344992,
-0.0170815717,
0.0143314535,
0.0546098128,
-0.012911262,
0.0466983803,
0.0978021994,
0.0221175328,
-0.0811655074,
-0.0472622886,
-0.0089074941,
-0.0009569942,
-0.0190936755,
-0.025640307,
-0.0172419343,
0.0044029495,
0.0538296774,
0.0004882328,
0.0232213754,
0.0162578411,
-0.0326815769,
-0.0581061356,
0.0232690722,
0.0384693854,
-0.0224251039,
-0.0340706967,
-0.0231403317,
-0.0282228645,
0.0076060914,
0.0666043833,
0.0069496618,
0.0181838721,
-0.0481997319,
0.0492363237,
-0.0454110764,
-0.0616152361,
-0.0459842794,
-0.0199438445,
0.0778258666,
-0.0053215115,
0.043435622,
-0.0070275757,
-0.0037668238,
0.0149270138,
-0.044840727,
-0.00839327,
-0.0241592135,
0.0263824631,
-0.0230365209,
0.0305830408,
0.0501355752,
-0.0010893405,
-0.0211862121,
-0.0370662585,
0.045949664,
0.0325959586,
-0.0317173786,
0.0256335828,
0.0094265155,
0.022759648,
0.0240240358,
0.0486985184,
0.0157205351,
0.0174254738,
0.0322067216,
0.0124185765,
0.0664989278,
0.0252048578,
0.0443523116,
-0.0115517629,
0.0080275917,
-0.0796556175,
0.0079084737,
0.0028913787,
0.0075727226,
0.0271424353,
-0.0120568173,
0.0097148614,
-0.0225243755,
0.0523647405,
0.0083932001,
0.0000448209,
-0.0150265247,
0.0055630519,
-0.0502146818,
0.0195947066,
-0.0215892345,
-0.0090489732,
-0.026876241,
0.0442855693,
-0.0502507575,
-0.0519638248,
0.0214254502,
-0.0532355867,
0.0242239665,
0.0644665658,
-0.0072147008,
0.0086937025,
0.0299522877,
-0.0259386506,
0.0005716531,
0.0170194283,
0.0269338954,
-0.0349262692,
-0.0268242285,
0.0165735111,
-0.0344384387,
0.0199460853,
-0.0599322058,
-0.0398950912,
-0.0876693502,
-0.0372287631,
-0.0238787159,
0.0175693147,
0.0244858284,
0.0052485382,
0.0359130763,
-0.035246145,
0.0453124978,
-0.0260227285,
0.0428039841,
-0.0310239047,
-0.0527930781,
-0.0504224449,
-0.0244290512,
-0.0068809595,
0.0414805003,
-0.0093133431,
-0.0032496541,
0.0111381393,
0.01385222,
0.0291057806,
-0.0673945993,
0.0102558769,
-0.0181566868,
-0.0162118692,
0.0255818702,
0.050713297,
-0.0181404985,
-0.0171014965,
0.0268455073,
0.0034208712,
-0.0122721111,
0.0044344324,
0.0412907712,
-0.0435942784,
-0.0312912539,
-0.0286559612,
0.0619662367,
-0.0194939952,
0.0010126026,
0.0345396698,
0.0169900823,
0.0302448142,
-0.0414765254,
0.0173671562,
0.0003406235,
-0.0144478185,
0.0081572328,
0.0131247528,
-0.0514518507,
0.0359348841,
0.0499344505,
-0.0076226583,
-0.0297169983,
-0.0098362612,
0.0343509093,
-0.0682157725,
0.0019475011,
0.0258377679,
-0.0004503831,
-0.0078388983,
-0.032232862,
0.0166336335,
0.0107729379,
0.0356330238,
-0.0200501382,
0.0149180777,
-0.0114762494,
0.020314008,
0.0068710363,
-0.0319637135,
0.0085704029,
0.0272059478,
-0.0246467032,
0.0338782109,
-0.0268319715,
0.002999346,
-5.82630175e-33,
-0.0531812161,
0.007995042,
0.0048654545,
-0.005942069,
-0.0388978273,
0.0113971634,
0.0072532119,
0.0116608143,
-0.0156760477,
-0.0462747738,
-0.0314174816,
0.0560134016,
0.0427517295,
0.0197449438,
-0.0288423039,
0.0141650317,
0.0835669413,
-0.0127120493,
0.0263102762,
0.0310484767,
0.0086974781,
0.031176541,
-0.0528579243,
-0.0427314639,
-0.0444667414,
-0.015109607,
-0.0128571037,
-0.0137957679,
0.009486868,
-0.0226428937,
-0.0226074625,
0.048992727,
-0.0087377662,
0.0002718074,
-0.0003089036,
0.0963039696,
-0.0470604151,
0.0059560565,
-0.0765075907,
0.0513615198,
0.0246354267,
-0.0243321918,
0.029572133,
0.0355588533,
-0.0333595164,
-0.0327151157,
0.0281517189,
-0.0046823337,
-0.0442273691,
-0.0506393239,
0.0551995374,
0.0567220449,
-0.0121411448,
-0.0212103315,
0.1012564078,
0.0018507305,
0.0068253162,
-0.0406968258,
-0.05924128,
0.0650897175,
0.0626563281,
0.0127520133,
0.027662605,
0.035790246,
-0.0021305289,
0.0414734744,
0.0499316379,
-0.067264922,
0.0485146567,
-0.0661837682,
0.0019626175,
0.0482486337,
-0.0225088689,
-0.0249263905,
0.0353907831,
-0.0499048792,
-0.0177095309,
0.0063313972,
0.0278744213,
-0.0479434393,
0.0302495304,
0.0496726595,
0.003014466,
0.0073128287,
-0.0104279928,
-0.0047043907,
0.0119367512,
0.0098421453,
0.0368338041,
0.0074406066,
0.0125850467,
-0.0005985643,
0.07033474,
-0.0463932008,
0.0331887417,
0.0221736357,
-0.0084276041,
-0.0118917264,
0.003897209,
0.0251903739,
-0.0372403599,
-0.0674428567,
0.0465637185,
0.0089889448,
-0.0228838958,
-0.0395033695,
-0.0113590583,
0.0595700741,
-0.0320243873,
-0.0109014511,
0.0215114318,
0.0406505242,
-0.0049180188,
0.0644900352,
0.0311169419,
-0.0358273983,
0.0131602967,
0.0392546579,
-0.0035532992,
0.006092337,
0.0139185013,
0.0148969982,
0.009553533,
0.042371165,
-0.0230031218,
0.0232391655,
-0.0191632453,
-0.0311084799,
0.0791421533,
0.0208892766,
0.0065587419,
-0.0277211405,
2.624e-7,
-0.0897593871,
0.0326086469,
0.0463081971,
-0.0477761142,
0.0483816825,
-0.0085535925,
0.001679896,
0.018717194,
-0.0208225641,
-0.0308421068,
0.0389677919,
0.0043703914,
0.0670439452,
0.0265815165,
-0.0412548371,
-0.0241938718,
-0.0459927283,
-0.0399409235,
-0.0328101628,
0.0397169776,
0.0320468284,
0.0612201616,
0.0292631034,
-0.0199363437,
0.0286002439,
-0.0062260116,
0.0258508958,
-0.0139312157,
-0.0046386835,
0.0134205492,
0.0066608521,
-0.0220574681,
0.0159815885,
0.0350675322,
-0.0169043411,
0.0412541814,
0.0566193201,
0.0403253473,
-0.0587450601,
-0.0168047678,
0.0206338521,
0.0462172627,
-0.0497223139,
0.0213726498,
0.0638536587,
0.0367782488,
0.0163082592,
0.005314589,
-0.0616242476,
0.020539958,
-0.0053006727,
0.0505774878,
0.0156539325,
0.0140358452,
-0.000990124,
-0.0080495421,
0.0025000316,
-0.0123762907,
0.0153191453,
-0.0106434328,
-0.1033839509,
-0.0200946163,
-0.0222274624,
-0.0472992137,
-0.0030677486,
0.0100556808,
-0.0348263085,
1.819615779e-34,
0.0116793923,
0.0314743035,
-0.0094623715,
0.0298708733,
0.0005030825,
-0.0563000515,
-0.0225010216,
0.0320445038,
-0.0322210453,
0.003024945,
-0.016349012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08448v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08448v2 | Advancing the Evaluation of Traditional Chinese Language Models: Towards a Comprehensive Benchmark Suite | 2023-09-15T14:52:23 | 2023-10-02T15:22:42 | Chan-Jan Hsu, Chang-Le Liu, Feng-Ting Liao, Po-Chun Hsu, Yi-Chang Chen, Da-shan Shiu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The evaluation of large language models is an essential task in the field of
language understanding and generation. As language models continue to advance,
the need for effective benchmarks to assess their performance has become
imperative. In the context of Traditional Chinese, there is a scarcity of
comprehensive and diverse benchmarks to evaluate the capabilities of language
models, despite the existence of certain benchmarks such as DRCD, TTQA, CMDQA,
and FGC dataset. To address this gap, we propose a novel set of benchmarks that
leverage existing English datasets and are tailored to evaluate language models
in Traditional Chinese. These benchmarks encompass a wide range of tasks,
including contextual question-answering, summarization, classification, and
table understanding. The proposed benchmarks offer a comprehensive evaluation
framework, enabling the assessment of language models' capabilities across
different tasks. In this paper, we evaluate the performance of GPT-3.5,
Taiwan-LLaMa-v1.0, and Model 7-C, our proprietary model, on these benchmarks.
The evaluation results highlight that our model, Model 7-C, achieves
performance comparable to GPT-3.5 with respect to a part of the evaluated
capabilities. In an effort to advance the evaluation of language models in
Traditional Chinese and stimulate further research in this field, we have
open-sourced our benchmark and opened the model for trial. | [
0.03629715,
0.0607403442,
0.0191771127,
0.0530792102,
-0.0265401378,
0.0199756995,
0.0013014325,
-0.0163145438,
-0.0355902836,
-0.0316993371,
-0.0538934506,
-0.0708076358,
0.0159272496,
0.0250090137,
0.0045702439,
-0.0421352945,
0.0390818939,
0.0066810166,
-0.0114627304,
0.0112218419,
0.0374811478,
-0.0098486654,
0.028840825,
0.035153456,
0.0141435312,
-0.0377084129,
-0.0016342034,
0.0195668712,
0.0135290278,
-0.0156484339,
0.0322931372,
0.0546191782,
-0.001844361,
0.0408442691,
0.0000020399,
-0.03192297,
-0.0275183935,
-0.0287292879,
0.0088845734,
0.0559252948,
0.0426521674,
-0.0188309513,
0.0039193747,
0.0205346849,
-0.0278460328,
-0.021290984,
0.0210220143,
0.054548122,
0.0680131391,
0.055052869,
0.0122804837,
-0.0397869237,
0.0228293892,
-0.0381263606,
-0.0292785186,
-0.0475177653,
0.0071676681,
0.0800789446,
0.0163654592,
-0.0345710292,
-0.0108420178,
0.0309421849,
0.0345402136,
0.0111488765,
-0.0384960659,
0.0456683226,
-0.0415825285,
0.031202944,
-0.0038286108,
0.0913630053,
0.0272276662,
-0.0362099223,
-0.0072282613,
0.0200556368,
-0.0140458811,
-0.0191504806,
-0.0715290681,
0.0243994649,
-0.0006877755,
0.0216018092,
0.0378652625,
-0.000206254,
0.0156225339,
0.0201963391,
-0.016229216,
0.0494448468,
0.0183212887,
-0.0264536552,
-0.0375160873,
-0.0071495627,
-0.0223575011,
-0.0443804003,
-0.0066392785,
0.0381785296,
-0.0236262754,
0.03510461,
-0.022693472,
-0.0039469688,
0.0054192622,
-0.0445686206,
0.0099751092,
0.0452766865,
-0.0144147258,
0.0273689479,
-0.0307481624,
0.0759693831,
-0.011965014,
0.0073439395,
-0.0851072595,
-0.0294249728,
-0.0399351269,
-0.0296639632,
-0.0499126911,
0.049836278,
-0.0480777249,
-0.041165255,
-0.034048792,
0.0142643973,
0.0161772836,
-0.0245680399,
0.0301287174,
-0.0059285266,
-0.0387664959,
0.0178827457,
-0.0202190354,
-0.0111498116,
-0.0438530371,
0.0036243454,
0.0102783516,
-0.076222226,
-0.0098495651,
-0.0043633226,
-0.0070148902,
-0.0212370977,
-0.0115207266,
0.0487198345,
-0.0274483692,
-0.0132121881,
-0.0334526189,
0.0044381786,
-0.0429555401,
-0.0655317307,
-0.0149703724,
-0.0673861429,
0.0084120128,
0.0058176029,
0.0265373904,
-0.0167298131,
0.0226380769,
0.0135163916,
0.0063055302,
0.0117550027,
0.0077445684,
0.0211088918,
0.0066767517,
0.017798407,
0.0062721777,
0.0828554556,
0.0395922512,
-0.0030546726,
0.0490039773,
0.0137698399,
-0.0322520211,
0.0260226279,
0.011718655,
-0.0089863651,
-0.0300976802,
0.0477272272,
0.0099560432,
0.0132347578,
-0.0010571162,
0.0623559803,
-0.0322003365,
0.0087273987,
0.0469106697,
0.0278108697,
0.005618453,
0.0111920992,
0.0425097533,
-0.023717029,
0.0284467675,
0.0304670278,
-0.0212125611,
0.0144625697,
-0.0247027967,
0.0568769462,
0.0386639386,
0.0032562155,
-0.0356632136,
-0.0733799413,
-0.0347945318,
0.0127505492,
-0.0053545511,
0.020162072,
0.02882782,
0.0078087114,
-0.0301302448,
0.0287197139,
0.0063414308,
-0.0607489608,
0.0091180261,
-0.0280313287,
0.0233149622,
0.0730500147,
0.0458851717,
-0.0023477168,
-0.020691134,
0.0182305519,
0.004480199,
0.052988898,
0.0585001223,
-0.0357457288,
-0.0145309707,
-0.0214974321,
0.0065996638,
-0.0002008645,
0.0186593384,
0.0082760379,
0.0336261578,
0.0131954737,
0.0244667213,
-0.0653871372,
-0.0172816105,
0.0351407714,
-0.041427739,
-0.0157075878,
-0.0333469659,
-0.022116147,
0.0323792957,
0.0352626517,
-0.0285676774,
0.0284837373,
0.0151959565,
-0.0391443297,
-0.0071976832,
0.035370037,
-0.069954522,
-0.0515047833,
0.0593750179,
-0.0151504576,
-0.0011189638,
0.0475980304,
-0.0536327064,
-0.0778016672,
0.01824403,
-0.0068984111,
0.0027434262,
-0.10625159,
0.0281032231,
-0.0071193967,
0.0257252306,
-0.0184139479,
0.1047047377,
-0.022338802,
0.0329071917,
0.0409457162,
0.0202944428,
0.0269741248,
-0.0527257808,
-0.0372360982,
0.0211416595,
-0.0053007193,
0.0270116124,
0.0288877469,
0.0210666992,
-0.039084956,
-0.0211020559,
-0.0903735906,
0.0458462834,
-0.0775927082,
0.0283802412,
0.0588634834,
-0.0091915037,
-0.0186303388,
0.0127153285,
-0.0685681254,
-0.0331442915,
0.0041304263,
0.0005201063,
0.0318286084,
-0.0065512336,
-0.0084019918,
-0.0508727282,
-0.0082761096,
0.0144267641,
0.0240636785,
-0.0320429653,
-0.0141524551,
0.0040957616,
0.0000923171,
-0.0340263844,
-0.0039218953,
-0.0055689877,
-0.0367270038,
-0.008764619,
-0.0029909932,
0.0532919131,
0.0210159831,
0.0138315214,
0.0303730909,
0.0169750433,
-0.0117055224,
-0.0306265652,
0.0047228374,
-0.0025105723,
-0.0076223668,
-0.0057681021,
-0.0659736916,
0.0003757761,
0.0858157426,
0.0303221438,
-0.0043743905,
-0.0615789481,
-0.0100508519,
-0.0521191396,
0.0058314656,
-0.0499188304,
0.0339464806,
-0.0339275375,
0.0191139523,
-0.061333701,
-0.0144824926,
0.0414266102,
-0.0615944751,
-0.0115999859,
-0.0424007066,
-0.0022107593,
-0.0783559456,
0.0536564104,
0.0129838241,
0.0248169862,
-0.0099222176,
-0.0047181598,
-0.0392341614,
0.0042287069,
-0.0050393348,
-0.0463336818,
0.0695982724,
-0.052122321,
0.0248781666,
-0.0301474072,
0.0073961839,
-0.0333570354,
-0.0059958501,
-0.0251675677,
0.0619664527,
0.0331579,
0.0128429886,
0.0364426039,
0.0709496588,
-0.005166979,
0.0467985459,
-0.0404477902,
0.0182953849,
-0.0163646452,
0.059117686,
0.0499347933,
0.015993597,
-0.0034792628,
-0.0307528172,
0.0789752677,
0.0465100817,
0.0535084717,
-0.0005172773,
-0.015215124,
0.004964212,
0.0063643157,
-0.050787691,
-0.0126572028,
0.0189769734,
0.0457607321,
-0.0473093018,
-0.0267517958,
0.1195999756,
0.0410640761,
0.0205242392,
0.0044362056,
0.0102652097,
0.0486785844,
0.0206208471,
-0.0077679912,
-0.0893411934,
-0.0269178189,
-0.0046359533,
0.0122237513,
0.016520489,
-0.0175474361,
-0.0001869888,
-0.132273972,
0.0282586776,
-0.0172060356,
-0.089001216,
-0.0321999937,
-0.0186998583,
0.0068769385,
-0.0034371442,
0.034030281,
0.0437072515,
-0.0109237181,
0.0077665821,
0.0274859108,
-0.0312899388,
-0.0477765948,
0.0250905268,
-0.014451188,
0.0204634462,
0.0463493168,
0.0346679799,
-0.0084881783,
0.0323915817,
0.0284715928,
-0.0654250607,
-0.0168378092,
0.0135274371,
0.0216440689,
0.0095215999,
0.0031652164,
0.0001515959,
0.0128929531,
-0.0231013317,
0.013666817,
0.0268791597,
0.0095589226,
0.0068601132,
-0.0206636544,
-0.0082802344,
0.0293666907,
-0.0432738289,
0.1150556281,
0.0502041019,
-0.014187878,
-0.0557167232,
-0.0167471506,
-0.0287512802,
-0.0898237228,
-0.0002405882,
0.0480612963,
0.0022157163,
0.0143123427,
-0.1129986197,
-0.0601758659,
-0.0136527224,
-0.0123790419,
-0.0063066273,
0.034631256,
-0.0430429727,
0.0013617548,
-0.0399235599,
-0.0015691959,
-0.0188525617,
0.0013123271,
-0.0723782554,
-0.0083465651,
0.0388467126,
-0.0423296131,
-0.0163891409,
0.0224478263,
-0.091269061,
-0.0449191704,
-0.0317430757,
0.0104964282,
0.0133895762,
0.0142460829,
-0.0020860527,
0.0091430712,
-0.0124738356,
-0.0419355482,
0.0058076689,
0.0074254302,
-0.0050279736,
-0.0190061703,
-0.0038922883,
0.0259016622,
-0.0663352162,
0.0405656025,
-0.0058415285,
0.0813360214,
-0.0209096093,
-0.0095242811,
0.0589915738,
0.0323755257,
-0.0258450732,
-0.0092848791,
-0.0089784637,
-0.0203786287,
0.030333709,
-0.0634697154,
-0.0375009254,
-0.0455473438,
0.0039388645,
0.0406573266,
-0.0119776009,
-0.0197994132,
0.0224832781,
0.0066198972,
0.0257529989,
-0.0297748558,
-0.0088284109,
-0.0004218844,
0.0010028016,
-0.0365728885,
-0.0314190239,
-0.036484655,
-0.0317379162,
-0.0167350043,
0.042308148,
-0.0130014922,
0.072915256,
0.0058310959,
-0.0054458622,
0.0340873599,
0.0427926593,
-0.0799237266,
-0.0248160008,
-0.0280335583,
0.0245949626,
0.0672133267,
0.006287266,
0.0492596738,
-0.0208455585,
-0.014314279,
-0.0342311077,
0.0185823962,
0.0614042953,
-0.0336690471,
0.0159818772,
0.0233317465,
-0.0085809017,
-0.0242860112,
0.0981353074,
0.0430826433,
0.0279629063,
0.0260666944,
0.0282122009,
-0.0429075956,
-0.0165269878,
0.0079612695,
-0.016780816,
-0.0124577694,
0.0054026986,
-0.0623909384,
-0.0470722169,
0.0109164147,
0.0230663978,
0.0165379699,
-0.0031509846,
0.0280261543,
0.0480978042,
0.0178806856,
-0.0075744716,
-0.0775676593,
-0.0056813671,
-0.0274422821,
0.0152100297,
-0.0132474173,
-6.689683249e-33,
-0.0436098799,
-0.0031556746,
0.0120640686,
-0.0457322448,
-0.0040223007,
0.0074126935,
-0.0653418675,
-0.0220578145,
-0.0445337147,
-0.0259345975,
-0.023591673,
0.0265538283,
0.0065373844,
0.040462397,
-0.0503268056,
-0.0227865968,
0.024922844,
-0.0200933777,
-0.013254256,
0.0117478976,
0.0379513092,
0.0206988249,
0.0272748061,
0.0103842104,
0.0204141904,
-0.0321009532,
-0.0082563777,
0.013520672,
0.0046988414,
0.0655437931,
-0.0222021397,
0.0190686751,
0.0471146405,
-0.0391025692,
-0.0351873673,
-0.0165762808,
-0.1217950881,
-0.0143455276,
0.0315600745,
0.0056872107,
-0.0173844751,
-0.0171119738,
-0.0139632709,
-0.0057170843,
0.0053934124,
-0.0050304681,
0.0201588031,
-0.052909065,
-0.0061391164,
-0.0254791435,
-0.0351685584,
0.0440539531,
-0.009579503,
-0.0025429353,
0.0059524351,
0.0552658625,
-0.0244348515,
0.0349191688,
-0.0291279834,
-0.0114745572,
0.047969941,
0.0390276313,
0.0671132952,
0.0305086169,
0.0144363651,
0.0240227785,
-0.0034768258,
-0.0197360609,
-0.0221414994,
0.0082173226,
-0.0003992106,
0.0347045101,
0.0347177163,
0.0471950583,
0.0233415384,
0.0213923305,
-0.0766237602,
0.0496335514,
0.0128814308,
0.0059358776,
0.0149316899,
-0.0168542489,
-0.0333345495,
-0.0098621715,
-0.040306516,
0.0084722005,
-0.024966808,
-0.0110319313,
0.0583878271,
0.0036120035,
-0.0300319791,
-0.0489397943,
0.0438027792,
-0.0566033274,
-0.0040231803,
0.06728407,
-0.0051451745,
0.0093044071,
-0.0032369751,
0.0676773787,
-0.0618192032,
-0.0123458505,
0.0155298943,
0.0027649405,
-0.0306577198,
-0.0092691947,
0.0144781023,
-0.0005660207,
-0.0343513526,
0.0302894767,
-0.0338345617,
0.0293220803,
-0.0327387974,
0.0251004826,
0.0037392811,
-0.0129045621,
0.0003840339,
0.039035812,
0.03373551,
0.0007830978,
-0.043635428,
-0.0025003091,
-0.0169451479,
0.0256693643,
-0.017743092,
0.0468703695,
-0.0223500058,
0.0365189686,
0.0228245277,
-0.0172960646,
-0.0077149118,
0.0363849029,
2.535e-7,
0.0896679163,
-0.0184379853,
0.0740155354,
0.0577991046,
0.0063924626,
-0.0086512556,
-0.0382268652,
0.0156330615,
-0.0024843174,
0.0085515864,
0.0256655626,
0.0452144891,
0.0911234915,
0.0082875844,
-0.048922535,
0.0088673737,
-0.0827234015,
-0.0105592581,
-0.0113854399,
0.001132114,
0.0232829563,
0.0952652767,
-0.0816103965,
0.0237321872,
-0.0271637253,
-0.0530598275,
0.0558513179,
-0.0119305551,
-0.0035520282,
0.0758370161,
0.0252992623,
0.0143667646,
-0.0047847242,
-0.0143744703,
0.0080026584,
0.0278790761,
0.0604108796,
0.0751896426,
0.0262125004,
-0.0362089463,
-0.0051562316,
-0.0298690032,
0.0287920367,
-0.0731630325,
0.1012090445,
-0.005517628,
0.0016519881,
0.0205380637,
-0.0254326947,
0.0205699932,
0.0023100118,
-0.0085708005,
-0.0185617227,
0.0594745763,
0.0123800784,
-0.021234924,
0.0024343759,
-0.0472556576,
-0.0808862969,
0.0002062179,
-0.0257982519,
-0.0490697697,
-0.0030912783,
-0.0201411527,
-0.0365354717,
-0.0267814472,
-0.0315963365,
2.201007332e-34,
0.0433886163,
-0.0223815031,
0.0009680938,
0.0495782979,
0.0287771206,
-0.0459921919,
-0.0040780883,
-0.0180794261,
-0.0118001513,
-0.0619879141,
-0.0143770659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08648v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08648v3 | MAPLE: Mobile App Prediction Leveraging Large Language Model Embeddings | 2023-09-15T13:15:54 | 2024-01-31T02:36:48 | Yonchanok Khaokaew, Hao Xue, Flora D. Salim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, predicting mobile app usage has become increasingly
important for areas like app recommendation, user behaviour analysis, and
mobile resource management. Existing models, however, struggle with the
heterogeneous nature of contextual data and the user cold start problem. This
study introduces a novel prediction model, Mobile App Prediction Leveraging
Large Language Model Embeddings (MAPLE), which employs Large Language Models
(LLMs) and installed app similarity to overcome these challenges. MAPLE
utilises the power of LLMs to process contextual data and discern intricate
relationships within it effectively. Additionally, we explore the use of
installed app similarity to address the cold start problem, facilitating the
modelling of user preferences and habits, even for new users with limited
historical data. In essence, our research presents MAPLE as a novel, potent,
and practical approach to app usage prediction, making significant strides in
resolving issues faced by existing models. MAPLE stands out as a comprehensive
and effective solution, setting a new benchmark for more precise and
personalised app usage predictions. In tests on two real-world datasets, MAPLE
surpasses contemporary models in both standard and cold start scenarios. These
outcomes validate MAPLE's capacity for precise app usage predictions and its
resilience against the cold start problem. This enhanced performance stems from
the model's proficiency in capturing complex temporal patterns and leveraging
contextual information. As a result, MAPLE can potentially improve personalised
mobile app usage predictions and user experiences markedly. | [
0.0320574045,
0.0264397226,
-0.0257955901,
0.0140692489,
0.0450713336,
-0.0235596951,
0.0190777108,
-0.0262121912,
0.0465240069,
-0.0309819002,
-0.0277745984,
-0.0337967388,
0.0051120659,
-0.0082649766,
-0.0090000965,
-0.004327374,
0.0074458076,
-0.0085378047,
-0.042762354,
0.022653956,
0.0099815112,
0.0294187292,
0.0706954375,
0.0612900257,
-0.0057703783,
-0.0398648083,
0.0097689191,
0.0441826954,
-0.0334957577,
-0.0784972981,
0.0169942118,
0.0364999622,
0.0190496426,
0.0193453617,
0.0000018962,
-0.0183138978,
0.0031507283,
-0.0412757918,
-0.0045568505,
0.000417101,
0.0387499109,
0.0514254794,
0.0201544277,
0.0253134463,
-0.0651504099,
0.0206183698,
0.0018110686,
-0.0332720317,
-0.0003189951,
0.0120617375,
-0.0263096578,
-0.0242296346,
-0.0017037804,
0.0211021602,
0.0670765117,
-0.0334746428,
-0.0058306241,
-0.0053499523,
0.0144062107,
-0.045132786,
0.027678756,
-0.0255034398,
0.0318752341,
0.0645062253,
0.0055721612,
0.0466893241,
0.0337428376,
0.0010426452,
-0.0406442694,
0.0415041111,
-0.0466200188,
-0.0476004891,
0.0154245924,
0.0164492372,
-0.0488980785,
-0.0053329174,
-0.0343120098,
-0.0204752982,
-0.0043846616,
0.0443819836,
0.0305635296,
0.0243951492,
0.0638058409,
0.0207247362,
-0.0366528891,
0.0708267167,
0.0159497987,
-0.0312092844,
-0.0012990634,
-0.0089746537,
0.0045013744,
-0.0203383826,
-0.0018959045,
-0.0090455925,
-0.0380357653,
0.0150798922,
-0.024982594,
0.0255596898,
-0.0011422836,
-0.0505364835,
0.0303446129,
0.013650463,
0.0116923433,
0.0154080531,
-0.0297331549,
0.0107097328,
0.0199855044,
-0.0673485771,
-0.0372741781,
-0.0145311272,
-0.0239868853,
0.0229293965,
0.0456444211,
0.00971244,
0.0196821485,
-0.0364288017,
-0.0435450412,
0.0772051811,
0.0073355148,
0.0107047679,
0.0386313945,
0.049994424,
-0.0049220803,
0.0118990215,
-0.0059577953,
-0.0236725863,
-0.0652309954,
0.0473337956,
-0.0158673432,
-0.0457322113,
0.0192169715,
-0.0008389753,
-0.0257175658,
-0.036407955,
-0.0058199088,
0.0133602675,
0.0383719765,
-0.0054381602,
-0.0446285009,
-0.05671506,
0.0267881006,
-0.0152654322,
-0.023834439,
-0.0617963523,
-0.0103006978,
0.0308548138,
0.044150129,
-0.037998639,
-0.0100227129,
0.0079152333,
-0.0443078205,
0.02769785,
-0.0027121925,
0.0026191554,
0.0060294638,
0.0217427388,
0.0186760649,
0.0359229147,
-0.0267972071,
0.0819849744,
0.0549906753,
0.0038055191,
0.0079552345,
0.0412708074,
-0.0196628999,
-0.0049517322,
-0.0338663161,
-0.0150523903,
-0.0141683808,
-0.0458054878,
-0.0136795612,
-0.0277351458,
0.0112930732,
-0.003719988,
0.0733221397,
0.0812342688,
-0.0105871549,
0.0458520725,
0.0556712337,
0.0091145653,
-0.0443249345,
-0.0884616897,
-0.0235411283,
0.004962387,
-0.0496495068,
-0.0073668752,
0.0325580463,
0.0489315838,
-0.0450483151,
-0.0005391848,
-0.0028331962,
-0.0528573543,
0.0011479228,
0.0224913303,
-0.011346749,
-0.0258174893,
-0.0199033022,
0.0438803844,
0.0257871486,
0.0175208859,
-0.0202124137,
-0.0156668946,
0.0681853518,
0.1082986295,
0.004873503,
-0.0157222711,
-0.0059063355,
0.0266769938,
-0.0231441017,
-0.0626399964,
0.0393089429,
-0.0150861386,
0.0380619057,
-0.0324636586,
-0.0170255601,
0.0496083982,
0.0281364545,
-0.0060024951,
0.0105568161,
0.05761718,
0.0301763043,
-0.027681753,
0.0132412724,
0.0001209862,
-0.062924169,
-0.0280384477,
0.0638270155,
0.0255454313,
0.0443206169,
0.0070809112,
0.039048668,
-0.018692404,
0.0293567888,
-0.0309289247,
0.0085764918,
0.0182935521,
-0.0227235574,
-0.0003193399,
0.036126852,
0.0250958614,
0.0709766895,
0.0211087428,
-0.0000115857,
-0.0034080576,
0.0300131142,
0.0383127555,
0.1226533726,
-0.0027953589,
0.0158518013,
-0.0120285023,
0.0154231591,
0.024213532,
0.0463537909,
-0.0078119324,
0.0312688537,
-0.024020087,
-0.0287174676,
-0.0089846859,
0.0320315808,
-0.0435889736,
-0.0272838268,
0.006246266,
0.0121824145,
0.0185840763,
-0.0172950346,
-0.0313445479,
-0.0084671089,
-0.106647253,
0.0551513806,
-0.014928339,
-0.0054651531,
0.0327276438,
0.0629205182,
-0.00372963,
-0.0301881544,
-0.012436294,
-0.006241437,
-0.0318163112,
0.0421003811,
-0.0027330893,
0.0137008717,
-0.0062551829,
-0.0171977375,
-0.0081488984,
-0.039109651,
0.0759717673,
-0.0465923995,
0.0013445228,
0.00717531,
-0.0152841508,
-0.039915584,
-0.0176904667,
-0.0382008739,
0.0050738328,
-0.0119624333,
-0.017553078,
0.0454679839,
0.0268898252,
-0.0177841205,
-0.0081402846,
0.0179551374,
0.0033851031,
-0.0492877774,
-0.0213023722,
0.0013927466,
-0.0109171038,
-0.0359439515,
-0.0693332925,
0.0013402788,
0.0724167675,
0.0063189929,
0.0079488531,
-0.0362785086,
0.0136751756,
-0.0346104205,
0.019894978,
-0.0393201895,
0.0525726229,
-0.0234655533,
0.0234485529,
-0.0015379129,
-0.0555709451,
0.0533181243,
-0.0067666923,
0.0452951044,
-0.0169568434,
-0.0505631678,
-0.0009292166,
0.0123003051,
-0.0055146236,
0.0148456534,
-0.0333118625,
0.0059314789,
-0.011439098,
-0.0229259916,
-0.0133047793,
-0.0488411449,
0.027098285,
0.0036864961,
-0.0398404263,
0.0483148433,
-0.0275089294,
-0.0282665398,
-0.0926666111,
-0.0619787015,
-0.0527141429,
0.0022012272,
-0.0170025807,
-0.0526266806,
-0.0216126218,
-0.0451495238,
0.0323300958,
-0.0125730615,
-0.0308878105,
0.0044010761,
-0.0153587246,
0.0392525084,
-0.0483354107,
-0.0145494118,
-0.0214967672,
0.0501527265,
-0.0093270307,
0.0401338376,
-0.0114629129,
-0.0521662571,
0.0048942277,
0.0451733693,
0.012211943,
-0.0692983121,
0.1335265338,
0.0068825204,
-0.0120565705,
0.0197235569,
0.1016400009,
0.0390427411,
-0.0745712891,
0.0076093003,
-0.006165083,
0.0285440981,
0.0680219159,
0.029438585,
-0.0785283074,
-0.052854199,
-0.0213313792,
0.0215458702,
0.0425898917,
-0.0167231616,
-0.0095436443,
-0.0526043288,
-0.0334753431,
0.0342402235,
-0.0267826468,
0.0484087244,
-0.0743647665,
-0.0183496643,
-0.0286954325,
-0.0255467389,
-0.0539768375,
-0.0212636795,
0.0209329408,
0.00560553,
-0.1169873923,
-0.0307541639,
0.0688809454,
-0.0384752564,
-0.001566608,
0.0291809961,
0.0228314325,
0.0070123221,
-0.0150282746,
-0.0208045263,
0.0171476677,
-0.0108240368,
-0.0126952762,
-0.0023748479,
-0.0136043383,
0.0607908256,
0.0041872431,
0.02423908,
-0.0622157566,
-0.0504164994,
0.0438194349,
0.123317346,
-0.0119051142,
-0.0121122822,
-0.0283677299,
-0.0123984916,
0.0304383822,
0.0370758697,
0.0036975804,
-0.0689466745,
-0.0110296384,
-0.029117113,
0.001219023,
0.028082978,
-0.0241430216,
-0.0055070622,
-0.0101783602,
-0.0152817899,
-0.0299465675,
0.0192595739,
0.0011717129,
0.0255995244,
0.0341075622,
0.1008176282,
-0.0104221618,
-0.0114196902,
0.0195119362,
0.002985049,
0.0127094593,
0.0541471131,
-0.0469145365,
0.0463544428,
0.0313281082,
-0.0277250167,
-0.0038786712,
-0.0257227216,
-0.0819175839,
-0.0140387518,
-0.0212049671,
0.0300612878,
0.013181149,
0.0362287685,
-0.0172613263,
-0.0369663946,
0.0563901179,
0.0293980483,
-0.0364352241,
-0.0111452378,
0.005384658,
0.0006342572,
0.009293166,
0.0402052477,
-0.0371308364,
0.0125656407,
-0.0303454958,
-0.0542969741,
-0.0463093556,
-0.0096687227,
-0.0112959873,
-0.0172698051,
0.0401917957,
-0.0195727516,
-0.0018602734,
0.0168565474,
0.0049425717,
0.0429087356,
-0.027696345,
-0.0054082582,
-0.0144246519,
0.0378489643,
0.006324538,
-0.0348072648,
-0.0255243722,
0.026290182,
0.0019203546,
-0.0458079316,
0.0228032097,
0.0238452666,
0.0529563688,
0.0173427463,
0.0541774035,
0.0001089281,
-0.002085998,
-0.0190675016,
0.0566164814,
-0.0701300502,
0.0070651774,
-0.0723635107,
0.0235479604,
-0.0562125929,
0.0346104987,
-0.0214382,
-0.0435542762,
0.0016342715,
-0.0332054384,
0.0347978733,
-0.064707689,
-0.0035242157,
-0.0289797876,
0.0206176713,
-0.0340676494,
0.0160303731,
-0.054693345,
-0.0158461109,
-0.0067907483,
0.0107683754,
-0.063496992,
0.02973729,
0.0633828044,
0.0046008108,
0.013182315,
0.0205881279,
-0.0657984912,
-0.0453271493,
0.02264609,
0.0576790236,
0.0657479912,
-0.0456085615,
-0.0276194084,
-0.0372633189,
-0.0607899204,
0.0120961033,
-0.0400198326,
0.0087502636,
-0.0002529006,
0.0123713911,
0.0731242746,
-0.0118228793,
0.0120070372,
-0.0570969619,
-0.0378866158,
-0.0310304258,
-0.0167119205,
-0.0380977131,
-5.564815603e-33,
0.0249073915,
0.0395704769,
-0.0200930126,
-0.0142220892,
0.0112701897,
0.0203920547,
-0.000541651,
-0.0117833978,
0.008165664,
-0.0417206474,
-0.0498312972,
-0.0092362082,
0.0003293898,
0.0022055781,
0.0317760296,
0.0145149631,
0.0308148786,
0.0098324157,
-0.0125781689,
0.0329852365,
0.020589849,
0.0632285699,
-0.0090716435,
-0.0563325323,
-0.0081404475,
-0.0178069044,
0.0319882929,
-0.036278028,
0.0319714583,
0.0429280624,
-0.0253430866,
0.0130031202,
0.0111505222,
-0.0245568864,
-0.0305346493,
0.0180882718,
-0.0032567878,
-0.0213591922,
0.0484947003,
-0.0132847149,
0.0134495944,
-0.0055446248,
0.0091970805,
0.0045188195,
-0.0190884452,
0.039214652,
0.05587589,
-0.0104244128,
-0.0513867289,
-0.0086219143,
0.012809121,
-0.0192010775,
-0.0119221406,
0.0172640551,
0.0035035266,
0.0252071284,
-0.0218845457,
0.0672891513,
-0.0539775081,
0.0317175426,
-0.0647446141,
0.0213629659,
0.0458893701,
0.0002590382,
0.0283171292,
0.0790880471,
-0.0141552575,
-0.0062574064,
0.0190601647,
-0.0340416245,
0.002892405,
0.0695592389,
-0.0305436254,
-0.0025403954,
0.0693303943,
-0.067325972,
-0.0398664922,
0.040652819,
0.0888636708,
-0.0144544514,
0.0312002338,
0.0035097417,
-0.0325284339,
-0.0267992895,
-0.0146992132,
0.0374542065,
-0.0118124997,
-0.0555345081,
0.0351222605,
0.0028619678,
-0.0063875667,
-0.0007260426,
0.0288122278,
-0.0801712871,
-0.0366765708,
0.0209380779,
0.0004883169,
-0.0165247153,
-0.0158562157,
0.033741042,
-0.0424006879,
-0.0092744138,
-0.0480531119,
-0.0360685028,
0.0218641758,
0.0030300161,
0.0219567232,
0.0038418001,
-0.0557029136,
-0.0229133684,
-0.0055572717,
-0.0368133709,
-0.0028935317,
0.0062080338,
0.0708553419,
0.0189570971,
-0.0041488921,
0.0861814916,
0.0141655589,
0.0059866989,
0.0014147154,
-0.084378168,
0.0340240411,
-0.0201735087,
-0.0342543684,
-0.0461714603,
-0.0686234981,
0.0155530078,
0.0377219841,
-0.030968897,
-0.0415939577,
-0.0202889424,
2.601e-7,
-0.0098239304,
0.0143599594,
-0.0833775699,
-0.0267315749,
0.0002569065,
0.011682719,
-0.0104315588,
0.024753917,
0.0037317856,
-0.0007886583,
0.0239835493,
-0.0106767332,
0.0418142676,
0.0717774406,
-0.0533089302,
0.0387804024,
-0.0962878093,
0.0486671738,
-0.0765662715,
-0.007812113,
-0.0069921641,
0.1166198179,
0.0644226298,
-0.0022597238,
0.019481428,
0.0015262169,
-0.0046484885,
-0.0640900508,
0.0005173286,
-0.0065694358,
0.0283825137,
0.0196299441,
-0.0111595448,
-0.0191731509,
-0.0579159334,
0.0273217577,
-0.019362919,
-0.0165166687,
0.0089965761,
0.0029359385,
0.0139457351,
-0.023939142,
0.0032851284,
-0.0565941036,
0.0751386508,
0.0017720775,
-0.0241645426,
0.0028461027,
0.0037631718,
0.0025106512,
0.0390254967,
0.0166440494,
0.0255717505,
0.0028021859,
0.0122396164,
0.0108569488,
-0.0302932989,
-0.0661323145,
-0.0159637984,
0.050124675,
-0.0204719901,
0.0136825619,
-0.0776181147,
0.0230573956,
0.0378355645,
-0.0143545447,
0.0769284219,
2.33448219e-34,
-0.0134787224,
0.0096373288,
0.0424041674,
0.014664053,
0.0264002178,
-0.0124157192,
0.0324236974,
0.0524242856,
0.0808363333,
-0.0269212984,
0.0126040354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08647v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08647v1 | Intent Detection at Scale: Tuning a Generic Model using Relevant Intents | 2023-09-15T13:15:20 | 2023-09-15T13:15:20 | Nichal Narotamo, David Aparicio, Tiago Mesquita, Mariana Almeida | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Accurately predicting the intent of customer support requests is vital for
efficient support systems, enabling agents to quickly understand messages and
prioritize responses accordingly. While different approaches exist for intent
detection, maintaining separate client-specific or industry-specific models can
be costly and impractical as the client base expands.
This work proposes a system to scale intent predictions to various clients
effectively, by combining a single generic model with a per-client list of
relevant intents. Our approach minimizes training and maintenance costs while
providing a personalized experience for clients, allowing for seamless
adaptation to changes in their relevant intents. Furthermore, we propose a
strategy for using the clients relevant intents as model features that proves
to be resilient to changes in the relevant intents of clients -- a common
occurrence in production environments.
The final system exhibits significantly superior performance compared to
industry-specific models, showcasing its flexibility and ability to cater to
diverse client needs. | [
0.0971086323,
-0.0043921676,
-0.0253620688,
0.0127808051,
-0.0365503542,
0.0111045167,
0.0206693634,
0.0127256308,
0.05316443,
-0.0732827634,
0.024190994,
-0.0483601838,
-0.0355583839,
0.0825528204,
-0.0452919714,
-0.0571600348,
-0.0084473761,
0.0020993282,
0.064501211,
0.0483770929,
0.0282757543,
0.0332953855,
0.0122369574,
0.0577803366,
-0.031706728,
-0.0264208317,
-0.0078645153,
0.0496894009,
0.016448725,
0.0094283689,
0.0462234095,
0.0214255508,
0.022393221,
-0.0172356348,
0.0000020462,
-0.0726781785,
-0.0740325674,
-0.0288612489,
-0.1078914776,
0.0143412584,
0.0350575969,
-0.0117997797,
0.0085027693,
0.0550351851,
-0.021570202,
0.0848272666,
0.0297810845,
0.0423925593,
0.026080301,
0.0300339665,
-0.0305107143,
0.0117287422,
-0.0253480766,
0.0097981691,
0.0388043374,
-0.0802030489,
0.0355808437,
-0.0062368088,
-0.010530361,
-0.0023370844,
0.0202477053,
0.0126809692,
-0.0387435742,
0.0179380309,
0.0130192926,
0.0152557222,
0.0285182111,
-0.0243828129,
-0.0523669682,
0.028666202,
-0.0081329076,
0.0318360999,
0.0095263636,
-0.0538415313,
-0.006223144,
-0.0106517728,
0.0035360982,
-0.0207199454,
-0.01130269,
-0.0357686207,
0.013050938,
0.0103095807,
-0.0070758811,
0.0005874413,
-0.0261403825,
0.0120066544,
-0.0204460993,
-0.0401265062,
-0.0317889489,
0.0050236331,
-0.0192904752,
-0.0605627261,
0.0466440506,
0.0258086044,
-0.0615737364,
-0.0027829395,
0.0052852719,
-0.0230960008,
0.020496916,
-0.0420369767,
0.0238113236,
0.0174454674,
-0.0310107842,
0.0402193144,
0.0025469996,
-0.0118396059,
0.0311262868,
-0.0437321775,
-0.0625119582,
0.023558354,
-0.0812617987,
0.0068186112,
-0.064180024,
0.0222269371,
-0.0367831364,
-0.0109787434,
-0.0265415348,
0.078609623,
0.0234476253,
0.0227465834,
0.030472558,
0.0230721291,
-0.0629428402,
-0.0148300547,
-0.0172535628,
0.0424470268,
-0.0657749921,
0.0252910815,
-0.0052423645,
-0.0629199147,
0.0262346584,
0.0145287942,
0.00940149,
0.0447229557,
0.0124006458,
0.0188160911,
0.0180724878,
-0.0532345995,
-0.0726693273,
-0.0684033409,
-0.0072247023,
0.0019948278,
-0.0632491112,
-0.0049483883,
-0.0136946971,
0.0140739987,
-0.0080712475,
0.0119742127,
-0.0034160574,
-0.0206605457,
0.0097939642,
0.0558241531,
-0.0235030744,
0.0254778471,
0.0194824375,
0.0162278637,
-0.0131779183,
0.0504250824,
-0.015040542,
0.0963610485,
0.0679175556,
0.0108172419,
0.0170259178,
-0.0006463422,
-0.0412886664,
-0.0273746159,
0.0378046371,
0.0402883701,
0.0184705388,
0.0205090679,
-0.0184831191,
0.0003501531,
0.0108521292,
-0.0058084815,
0.0667669699,
0.0170384422,
-0.0038746712,
0.0031360888,
0.0540840849,
0.0687111095,
-0.0673128739,
-0.0245944895,
-0.0094544506,
0.0320388414,
-0.0310723446,
0.0090412693,
-0.0519332215,
0.0137809794,
-0.054811243,
-0.0373355448,
-0.0148381423,
-0.012892846,
-0.0318012983,
0.0441968143,
0.0289909709,
-0.0039151241,
-0.0415915176,
0.0178244244,
-0.0224263649,
0.0189881343,
-0.0308710467,
-0.0682346523,
0.0182079077,
0.1131282672,
0.0355464704,
-0.0526043847,
-0.0578256398,
-0.0255387072,
-0.0427411944,
0.0057436004,
0.0481654704,
-0.0212080795,
0.0091734016,
-0.0429801978,
-0.044795312,
0.042897433,
0.0159140341,
0.0148060862,
-0.02833605,
-0.0200337861,
-0.0035806212,
-0.0236377958,
0.0089934301,
0.0174946841,
0.0174042657,
-0.022348389,
0.0005800684,
0.0277960598,
0.0612714626,
0.0385140441,
0.0368633494,
-0.0234797262,
0.0228346642,
-0.0175027512,
-0.0253912229,
0.0365963243,
0.0046083624,
0.0222677123,
0.0130818188,
0.0579561144,
-0.0334059298,
0.0233213548,
-0.015241907,
0.0003918416,
-0.0116865244,
-0.0207562149,
0.0421812758,
-0.0501317717,
0.001839767,
0.015152961,
-0.0215117484,
0.0054211537,
0.0397385359,
0.0241206717,
-0.0367415436,
-0.0327042043,
-0.0411715358,
0.0108469948,
-0.0287323482,
-0.0072361897,
-0.0119365361,
-0.0134886531,
0.0028669885,
-0.0081661269,
-0.0034802044,
-0.0408010222,
0.0111079188,
-0.1131786704,
-0.0008489356,
-0.0331939682,
-0.0162130985,
0.0149882687,
0.0602534898,
-0.0007788197,
-0.0405216776,
-0.0216140132,
0.0327815488,
-0.0124708889,
0.0132622886,
0.0062976563,
0.0339344181,
-0.0594350733,
-0.013529053,
0.0249362215,
-0.0085978555,
-0.0119245816,
0.0314602479,
-0.0276508592,
-0.0637931302,
-0.0059632878,
-0.0608258843,
0.0088619767,
-0.0173734967,
-0.0318100154,
-0.0153758954,
-0.0431530885,
-0.0249434765,
0.0605269186,
0.0363280773,
-0.0036732396,
0.0047029173,
0.0294401627,
-0.0568548329,
0.0098220613,
-0.0614594594,
-0.0346959941,
-0.0403169841,
-0.0410022363,
0.0339986049,
0.035011813,
0.0096249087,
-0.0020740933,
-0.055960048,
-0.0675134286,
0.0009056968,
-0.0153327798,
-0.064020656,
0.0347886384,
0.0004324103,
0.0442516953,
0.0453076214,
-0.0627508163,
0.0745261684,
0.0313122459,
-0.0171395577,
-0.0583625771,
-0.070634298,
-0.045018319,
0.0679046288,
-0.0403033458,
0.0484895818,
0.0472768396,
-0.0379585177,
-0.0075414651,
-0.0126567036,
0.0376332663,
-0.0321842246,
0.0267230198,
-0.0464333147,
0.0238689557,
0.0222848263,
-0.0347433165,
-0.0453942902,
-0.0653069392,
-0.0566480458,
-0.0069694351,
0.0324085876,
-0.0206211135,
-0.0506980345,
0.028730372,
-0.0125808567,
0.0544106178,
0.0285029653,
-0.0610096715,
-0.0013799918,
-0.0352067277,
0.011172005,
0.0255152341,
-0.0257443655,
-0.0382094719,
0.0284068342,
0.0432045758,
-0.0061835232,
-0.0464825071,
-0.0171911996,
0.0127214584,
0.0262648128,
-0.030818928,
0.0198365878,
0.0438757986,
0.0474676862,
0.0043383315,
0.0026137035,
0.0858868062,
0.0486112237,
-0.0479679182,
-0.012409918,
-0.0440517887,
0.0382139646,
0.0297670458,
0.0129150786,
-0.0412798524,
-0.0425744206,
0.0050471099,
0.0517899692,
-0.0050278911,
-0.0088880947,
-0.0065567777,
-0.0280146338,
0.0641757995,
-0.0260381587,
0.0081615457,
-0.0315997675,
-0.0169683024,
0.0165729746,
-0.0175161939,
-0.0142071014,
-0.0032655145,
-0.0200169329,
-0.0384664312,
0.0458336659,
-0.0445835404,
-0.0643888637,
0.0016252772,
-0.0428462327,
0.0854141787,
0.0589217246,
-0.0195805002,
0.0389591604,
-0.0137245888,
-0.0273930244,
0.0270038173,
0.0591389574,
-0.018128423,
0.0434033461,
-0.0327305607,
0.0413635187,
0.0136938943,
0.0161457267,
-0.0687913299,
0.0141485566,
0.0501968786,
0.0426708795,
-0.0353978388,
-0.0128669906,
-0.0238735266,
0.0068255342,
0.0674799681,
0.0942938402,
0.0014373687,
-0.0767725334,
0.0074724052,
-0.0171382353,
-0.0224522837,
0.0596550107,
0.010084792,
0.0141929835,
-0.0637571365,
-0.0158621222,
-0.0669700727,
-0.0318718478,
0.0535468683,
0.0123092821,
0.0147903627,
0.0023128523,
-0.0217336696,
0.0399125107,
-0.0148238279,
-0.0032069818,
0.0019079648,
0.0455257408,
-0.0486866124,
-0.0031782277,
0.0138842547,
-0.0451658443,
-0.0068260059,
-0.021900801,
-0.0417076163,
-0.0234210547,
0.0186100304,
0.0362018533,
0.0265254918,
0.0151930107,
0.0000248402,
-0.0207956098,
-0.0379328132,
0.0620171465,
-0.0017572589,
0.0053848471,
0.0388463847,
0.0262587182,
-0.0238433462,
0.0269896425,
-0.0664298832,
0.0511443876,
-0.0082160495,
0.0094503947,
-0.0612953119,
-0.0394758917,
0.0287624542,
0.0374671519,
-0.027827546,
-0.0001052568,
-0.0623713695,
-0.0092849545,
0.0195300505,
0.0303103607,
0.0020486333,
-0.0398668163,
0.0073449477,
0.0002391168,
-0.0150583228,
0.016510684,
-0.0024009671,
-0.0498502329,
-0.0464215092,
-0.0605122857,
-0.0090629915,
-0.0297527071,
0.0264838655,
0.0294806361,
-0.0167245492,
-0.003874704,
-0.0013707101,
0.0084154801,
0.0333932228,
0.0263013169,
0.050074704,
0.0110412678,
0.0107922256,
-0.0397013053,
0.0283058397,
-0.0335113071,
-0.1005127132,
0.0064243334,
0.0353891626,
0.0287599657,
-0.0009051065,
-0.0005172223,
-0.07384675,
0.0219187457,
-0.0293805953,
0.0504433066,
0.0097583048,
-0.0155284321,
-0.0177675169,
0.0107345348,
-0.0150836604,
-0.0113462256,
0.0415358804,
-0.0818686113,
0.0394578315,
-0.0473204926,
-0.041550979,
-0.0676117316,
0.0336636119,
0.0269362461,
0.0282338746,
-0.0306285173,
-0.0017845538,
-0.0754306465,
-0.0245218817,
0.0336252972,
-0.013265674,
0.0197461732,
-0.0281222444,
0.0679909736,
0.05430834,
0.0125678871,
-0.0301637203,
-0.0241361633,
-0.0042170249,
-0.0731323808,
0.0397256911,
-0.050254669,
-6.079442622e-33,
0.0217875596,
0.0020893563,
-0.0154666556,
-0.0077512674,
0.0277626924,
0.0475087538,
0.0173640344,
-0.0119074266,
0.036977686,
-0.0165528972,
0.0028572038,
0.0471185036,
0.0213239696,
-0.0328808166,
0.0234131888,
0.0039294185,
0.0602613091,
-0.0247011818,
0.0115328515,
0.0246791691,
0.0476201735,
0.0350515209,
-0.002680395,
-0.1158004031,
0.0260013863,
-0.0159390885,
-0.0259019285,
0.0357052013,
0.0055750636,
0.0406582318,
0.0035617691,
0.0314107575,
0.0471831597,
-0.0293389745,
0.0345084965,
0.030438941,
-0.0056326608,
-0.0165749118,
-0.0016727381,
-0.0192540567,
-0.0252086613,
0.0321847275,
-0.0078982376,
-0.0043503232,
0.0062006465,
0.0147891184,
0.0372223854,
-0.0057242615,
-0.0009435197,
0.0110596586,
-0.0272629727,
-0.0219987873,
-0.0084455619,
0.0052388953,
0.0014145667,
0.0514300801,
0.0205457695,
0.0163821783,
-0.0275214147,
-0.0032991029,
-0.0349409766,
-0.0082997624,
-0.0121178702,
0.0017394488,
-0.0492064767,
0.038061481,
-0.0313085057,
0.000950983,
0.0179275945,
-0.017474195,
-0.0447063148,
0.0720209256,
0.0229422022,
0.0256519374,
0.0232015457,
-0.0499743968,
-0.0075896834,
0.069180645,
0.0911385715,
-0.0070512667,
0.0628709793,
0.0183857847,
-0.0563106164,
0.0142190289,
0.0236944407,
0.0073756985,
-0.0341163091,
-0.0184412822,
0.0471186489,
0.0576028749,
-0.0318013243,
0.0211555921,
0.0084170019,
-0.0099334819,
0.034096472,
-0.0099233696,
0.0029885874,
0.0118120247,
0.0194559097,
-0.0040219887,
-0.0440795869,
-0.0251047574,
-0.0053310548,
-0.0263548214,
-0.0015817715,
-0.0081731593,
0.0161008555,
0.0147967376,
0.0042937864,
0.0187593475,
0.0103710331,
0.0166820977,
-0.0439667925,
0.030652063,
0.0308782086,
0.0098305484,
-0.013865795,
0.031248631,
0.003982435,
-0.0084608598,
-0.0609681271,
-0.0076072775,
0.0016897121,
0.0073666126,
-0.0531007908,
-0.0203244649,
0.0014974701,
-0.0403079987,
0.0423150361,
-0.0086615449,
-0.0227826312,
-0.0055621867,
2.822e-7,
-0.0014981177,
0.0269034803,
-0.0147572579,
0.0447732992,
0.0027608683,
0.0812970102,
0.0358893275,
0.0394366123,
0.0373915881,
-0.0307446253,
0.0681500062,
-0.0067188512,
0.0188963227,
0.0145842107,
-0.0832709149,
-0.0441293903,
0.0142568918,
0.0122851608,
-0.0658574551,
0.0305582751,
0.0640530586,
0.0676343888,
0.0079626273,
-0.0162065886,
0.0703089833,
0.01409877,
0.0100105675,
-0.0842283741,
0.0376160257,
-0.0023112448,
0.0652815551,
-0.0070769489,
-0.0124465534,
0.0541894324,
-0.0354176015,
-0.0113135967,
-0.0563577414,
0.0687530711,
-0.0363375507,
-0.0079129506,
-0.0238343943,
0.0034982243,
0.0275377985,
-0.028789036,
0.0001649247,
-0.0159637872,
-0.0026171054,
0.0124455383,
0.0176034681,
-0.0153297791,
-0.0311458185,
0.0436123982,
-0.0165565256,
0.0086433329,
0.0104711773,
-0.0185469724,
-0.0052745868,
-0.0941056237,
0.0631350279,
0.0414952189,
-0.046676185,
-0.0265449733,
-0.011021059,
-0.0195360892,
0.0167738181,
-0.0721170828,
-0.0012955612,
2.406568233e-34,
0.0146889137,
0.0164389294,
-0.0023051875,
0.0895505399,
0.0025692661,
0.0108828386,
-0.0130924257,
0.0191559624,
0.0581681915,
-0.0588094667,
0.0051431125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08380v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08380v1 | Unleashing Potential of Evidence in Knowledge-Intensive Dialogue Generation | 2023-09-15T13:13:30 | 2023-09-15T13:13:30 | Xianjie Wu, Jian Yang, Tongliang Li, Di Liang, Shiwei Zhang, Yiyang Du, Zhoujun Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Incorporating external knowledge into dialogue generation (KIDG) is crucial
for improving the correctness of response, where evidence fragments serve as
knowledgeable snippets supporting the factual dialogue replies. However,
introducing irrelevant content often adversely impacts reply quality and easily
leads to hallucinated responses. Prior work on evidence retrieval and
integration in dialogue systems falls short of fully leveraging existing
evidence since the model fails to locate useful fragments accurately and
overlooks hidden evidence labels within the KIDG dataset. To fully Unleash the
potential of evidence, we propose a framework to effectively incorporate
Evidence in knowledge-Intensive Dialogue Generation (u-EIDG). Specifically, we
introduce an automatic evidence generation framework that harnesses the power
of Large Language Models (LLMs) to mine reliable evidence veracity labels from
unlabeled data. By utilizing these evidence labels, we train a reliable
evidence indicator to effectively identify relevant evidence from retrieved
passages. Furthermore, we propose an evidence-augmented generator with an
evidence-focused attention mechanism, which allows the model to concentrate on
evidenced segments. Experimental results on MultiDoc2Dial demonstrate the
efficacy of evidential label augmentation and refined attention mechanisms in
improving model performance. Further analysis confirms that the proposed method
outperforms other baselines (+3~+5 points) regarding coherence and factual
consistency. | [
0.0518475249,
0.0316855125,
0.0058513801,
0.0332807377,
-0.0249056239,
-0.0175806209,
-0.0070346557,
-0.0357482433,
-0.0128282253,
-0.058793366,
-0.0088813938,
-0.005713515,
-0.0101080285,
0.0287536383,
0.0293980129,
-0.0429770872,
0.0515046529,
-0.0152869001,
0.0941693559,
0.0065662502,
0.0124553377,
0.0041719652,
-0.0150674926,
0.0557651035,
-0.0487269498,
-0.0184174888,
-0.0174605437,
0.0126767121,
0.0320447497,
-0.0380206816,
0.027164273,
0.0373632051,
-0.0126348501,
0.0492020808,
0.0000018636,
-0.0280070808,
0.0070377686,
-0.0053180722,
-0.0457150787,
-0.0141435489,
0.0072579696,
0.0379304513,
0.0139685031,
0.0167266633,
-0.0461873487,
0.0167748891,
0.0328305103,
0.0720581189,
0.0629747435,
0.0824711844,
-0.003702129,
0.0065380251,
0.0295335986,
-0.0066551059,
0.0380668081,
0.0078835087,
0.0087600918,
0.042526871,
0.0262504518,
0.0482759699,
0.0387664586,
0.0439019725,
0.0222157985,
-0.056859605,
0.011386781,
0.0437136851,
-0.0501193143,
-0.0189089794,
-0.0105821323,
0.0785761252,
0.0418594889,
-0.023355417,
-0.0036123639,
-0.0191093758,
0.0445339903,
-0.0006810881,
-0.0520608462,
0.0483592115,
-0.0345740244,
0.0016094225,
0.0500249304,
0.0154753504,
-0.000683699,
0.0207249802,
0.0312203597,
0.0635010973,
0.0009605906,
-0.0254884511,
-0.0166991632,
-0.0031225847,
-0.0195269175,
-0.0701091364,
0.0090981089,
0.0362700373,
-0.0260440838,
0.0350540206,
-0.054848548,
0.0104368748,
0.0479803756,
-0.0322993398,
-0.021818297,
0.008196176,
-0.0472449288,
0.0598463975,
-0.0172595065,
-0.0263711419,
-0.0081931325,
0.0067311656,
-0.0206282102,
-0.0152244642,
-0.0348368697,
-0.020912813,
-0.0433581546,
-0.002870006,
-0.0371287391,
-0.0284113232,
0.024458291,
-0.0007623908,
-0.0025510199,
0.0058251396,
0.025870515,
0.0130933421,
-0.0419867299,
-0.0061446563,
-0.0305820499,
0.0417709425,
-0.0352055095,
0.0311375186,
0.0941555277,
-0.0461852923,
-0.0234537795,
0.0723059326,
-0.0033839978,
0.0043815551,
-0.0063006501,
0.011365721,
-0.032299906,
-0.013243637,
-0.0103312898,
-0.0739337578,
-0.0825801343,
-0.0577146597,
-0.0061085979,
-0.0469017327,
0.0266703963,
-0.011551315,
-0.0592535809,
-0.0182219483,
0.031759236,
0.039470464,
-0.0337402597,
-0.005344044,
-0.056485083,
-0.0164319854,
0.039051231,
0.0143003585,
-0.0198053308,
0.0229178872,
0.0371957533,
0.0222579855,
0.0406124927,
0.0234156027,
-0.0203317516,
-0.0308322161,
0.0333421789,
-0.0026744334,
0.0282498095,
0.0256499127,
-0.0178756341,
0.0270941388,
0.0065615587,
0.0558360219,
-0.0719992742,
-0.0162689332,
0.084066689,
-0.023042975,
-0.0319208913,
0.0019181746,
0.0280794743,
0.0227492135,
0.0251502451,
0.0122082885,
-0.00983054,
0.0125008132,
0.0248952396,
0.025578279,
0.0764121413,
0.0365746468,
-0.0182643235,
-0.0564739928,
0.003396797,
0.0152816614,
-0.0172636006,
0.0359750055,
-0.0016910341,
0.0257478654,
-0.0396948904,
0.0495066531,
0.0214640535,
-0.0522079952,
-0.0265365019,
-0.0291637648,
0.052973181,
0.0268039238,
0.059132833,
-0.0131354602,
-0.0607906505,
-0.0409392342,
0.0262163393,
0.0653415024,
0.0198721476,
-0.004647166,
-0.0005088326,
-0.0431387275,
-0.0057709096,
-0.0312264226,
0.0036244264,
0.0105251763,
0.0018661157,
-0.008143818,
0.0358491763,
0.0173788685,
-0.0271359179,
0.0207410678,
0.0166027416,
-0.0019012161,
0.0351369232,
-0.0366118029,
0.0381779969,
0.0284293965,
-0.0113975005,
0.0280204881,
0.0458420292,
-0.0072835749,
-0.0007985153,
0.0379320607,
-0.058615081,
-0.0743756592,
0.0461463667,
-0.0249114819,
-0.0184697974,
-0.0843539163,
0.0014150965,
-0.0618089251,
-0.0242959931,
-0.0731559545,
0.0214100741,
-0.0419114791,
-0.0001416109,
0.0718350857,
0.0140525969,
-0.0448965169,
0.0603410006,
0.0000523204,
-0.0341401808,
0.031911388,
0.0010792306,
0.0132668791,
-0.0538223237,
0.0253048688,
0.0038704006,
-0.014395942,
0.0144214658,
0.0402155444,
-0.0089034392,
-0.0496324748,
-0.0474329703,
-0.0899660513,
0.0335563719,
-0.0108345412,
0.0070234584,
0.011325364,
-0.0348642953,
-0.0093297642,
-0.0068015307,
-0.0575627461,
0.0028101665,
0.0311133489,
-0.0080926567,
0.0159186926,
0.0350000896,
0.0095631704,
-0.0394653864,
0.0105182249,
0.0175523423,
0.028932238,
0.0331000239,
0.0002766405,
-0.0598471984,
-0.0009794736,
-0.0349897705,
-0.0129730962,
-0.0175609514,
-0.0203684177,
0.0539737232,
0.0247340817,
0.0470864475,
0.0559314005,
0.0451266095,
-0.0155366454,
0.0186708514,
-0.055304613,
-0.0650456697,
0.0434488505,
-0.0249510333,
0.0455825999,
0.015749855,
-0.0093897087,
0.0366784446,
0.0415208153,
0.0277962331,
0.0190715883,
-0.0183639321,
0.0050567016,
0.0520981625,
-0.0510270111,
0.0027688385,
-0.0270511918,
-0.0135370661,
0.0141819678,
-0.0489298627,
-0.043501582,
0.0682479963,
-0.0656034425,
-0.0026791333,
-0.0473998301,
0.0163756534,
-0.0013741062,
-0.0025808723,
0.0099183209,
0.0183692388,
0.0230435468,
0.0018745585,
-0.009216317,
-0.0091423439,
0.0265400987,
-0.0516266897,
0.0220444128,
-0.0281334259,
0.0110231386,
0.0209667496,
-0.0316648073,
-0.0808901787,
-0.0478862412,
0.004399254,
-0.0103556719,
0.0142338686,
-0.019211743,
-0.0596107654,
0.0080488287,
0.0643609092,
0.0383478813,
-0.0062702252,
-0.0071645239,
-0.0283751749,
0.0317242518,
0.0537001565,
0.0129011758,
0.0358811617,
-0.0112253185,
0.0242725872,
0.0793701336,
-0.0394016318,
-0.0080936514,
0.0007980622,
-0.0520623326,
-0.0243719593,
-0.017658243,
-0.017919071,
0.0123226661,
0.05295128,
-0.0554396622,
-0.0242033955,
0.080492124,
0.0230098814,
-0.0233848393,
-0.0282694642,
-0.046669364,
0.0348425284,
-0.0118348189,
0.020208329,
-0.0872193575,
-0.0512129329,
-0.0058567459,
-0.0041962662,
-0.0237800516,
-0.0325124003,
-0.0043920041,
-0.0790532455,
0.0580005981,
0.0156861767,
0.0182064734,
-0.0268281046,
-0.0204100311,
-0.0016499034,
0.0377236083,
0.0256328899,
0.0265435465,
0.0142374756,
0.0122737493,
0.008769948,
-0.0025810848,
-0.0266677495,
-0.0200510863,
-0.0118212551,
0.0667699724,
0.0458341688,
0.0508949347,
0.0334496684,
-0.0519119836,
-0.02713475,
0.0120242964,
0.0027932946,
0.0015691239,
0.0371519476,
-0.0231332798,
0.0135852993,
-0.0489178263,
0.0366875567,
-0.011812388,
-0.0463988297,
0.0550292544,
0.0417615138,
-0.0475457199,
-0.0122423545,
-0.0187360514,
0.0537531152,
0.0529667214,
0.0893322229,
0.0484076776,
-0.0041302671,
0.0192905534,
-0.0110158548,
0.0129107181,
-0.0288924072,
0.0212627351,
0.0289630573,
0.0195768625,
0.0297666937,
-0.1051667929,
-0.0551418066,
0.0213322677,
0.0220224876,
-0.0278954245,
-0.0090051508,
0.0013824938,
-0.0181447919,
-0.0247058682,
0.0486389957,
-0.0307119228,
-0.013479704,
-0.0655615106,
-0.017570341,
-0.0155444369,
-0.0427644998,
0.0000390137,
0.0629168898,
-0.0247674752,
-0.0676098466,
-0.0225089844,
0.0569048077,
0.0164339952,
0.0319710113,
0.0081596682,
-0.0212318636,
0.0023982613,
0.0078025609,
-0.0143292332,
-0.0229441319,
0.0347114876,
-0.0090661952,
0.0017769948,
0.0148246977,
0.0001566286,
0.0439163558,
-0.0183725581,
0.0482507087,
-0.0481209904,
-0.0818847343,
0.0200043581,
0.0171678662,
0.0557914227,
-0.0044203759,
-0.0144675989,
-0.0295491852,
0.0042642071,
-0.0368187577,
-0.0242484994,
-0.0475004502,
0.0348425731,
-0.0313606188,
-0.0512276068,
0.0147361206,
0.0087541705,
-0.0482663475,
0.0157400779,
-0.0071537877,
-0.0113507872,
-0.0151082855,
0.0101696383,
0.0164809115,
-0.0478935353,
-0.0414350294,
0.0020798058,
-0.0008973795,
0.0547684431,
0.004726632,
0.098836489,
0.0155478558,
-0.0500156507,
0.0281503499,
0.011237476,
-0.046113316,
-0.0098754866,
-0.0265399851,
0.008354295,
0.0181016866,
0.0161221381,
0.0644986182,
-0.0474908687,
-0.0078029432,
-0.0328419954,
0.0558267571,
0.0153115289,
-0.0300762076,
0.0272962078,
0.0103724468,
-0.0576755032,
0.0044325292,
0.0625452846,
-0.0308721513,
-0.0048882659,
-0.0115291728,
-0.0180309247,
-0.0550513379,
-0.0537860319,
-0.027500689,
0.0353493355,
-0.0301676467,
0.0119987335,
-0.0158341527,
-0.0105590215,
-0.0456128828,
0.0350565799,
-0.015566376,
-0.0032865168,
-0.0023744083,
0.0261723995,
-0.0165964514,
-0.0240123663,
-0.0342570059,
0.0417359844,
-0.0252942257,
-0.0051947343,
-0.0286034457,
-6.280044774e-33,
-0.0301534329,
-0.036358837,
0.0158358142,
-0.0178299919,
-0.012656753,
0.0210141037,
-0.062738128,
0.0076162596,
-0.0108305635,
0.0608229637,
-0.0006520452,
0.0094863214,
0.0110932095,
0.0386376046,
-0.0136665776,
0.0020423806,
0.0447658561,
0.0239652116,
-0.0407826379,
0.0706160143,
0.060940098,
-0.0199318063,
0.0169839673,
-0.0639598668,
0.0521930978,
-0.0036023958,
0.001581512,
0.0143994447,
-0.021820154,
0.0626994148,
-0.0067024608,
0.0418802164,
0.0001979393,
-0.0311974622,
-0.036945235,
0.0390564092,
-0.0508767329,
-0.0190438591,
0.0334450379,
-0.0440726131,
-0.0561264455,
-0.0479352623,
0.0113075925,
-0.0000213399,
0.0613378994,
0.0101078544,
0.0081031825,
-0.0307259932,
-0.0301560629,
-0.0266429335,
-0.0669909194,
0.0639196485,
-0.0054771928,
-0.0411704034,
-0.0450995192,
0.0574103929,
0.0181324929,
-0.0168523174,
-0.0542677417,
0.013699743,
0.0047637513,
0.0139445988,
0.0394302681,
0.0147968922,
-0.0248570219,
0.0843689144,
-0.0046510957,
0.0103779975,
-0.0262517612,
-0.0175919328,
-0.0197975449,
0.0531467833,
0.0403166413,
0.0518160462,
0.0239242725,
0.011676942,
-0.0644111261,
0.0077296663,
0.0441622995,
0.026310306,
0.0343929194,
-0.0224128161,
-0.0465649813,
0.0045537371,
-0.0019689489,
0.0012029369,
-0.0042887283,
-0.0050613047,
0.0316957012,
0.028139364,
-0.0164717808,
-0.0068189832,
0.0419942476,
0.0128849419,
0.0488465205,
0.0371790268,
-0.0212794561,
-0.0014083195,
-0.0302584097,
0.0209605712,
-0.0781515539,
0.004722687,
0.0448701531,
-0.0040082382,
-0.02110238,
0.0487696454,
0.0473257452,
-0.0275747031,
-0.0412565321,
0.021041885,
-0.0236264151,
0.076818198,
-0.0328429341,
-0.0293704532,
0.0345913023,
0.0178270563,
-0.0218342077,
0.0501903258,
-0.0071873483,
-0.0052322689,
-0.0306669511,
-0.0473563671,
0.0188446436,
-0.0051323106,
-0.0162845664,
0.0381758437,
-0.0072666947,
-0.0498430841,
-0.0120348278,
-0.0426447503,
0.0069630719,
0.0321252048,
2.581e-7,
0.021825403,
0.023399815,
0.0256820824,
-0.007500709,
0.0110937199,
0.0378047898,
0.0306503829,
-0.0063274102,
0.0442949496,
-0.0726197958,
-0.0014467458,
0.0246349685,
0.0691545531,
0.0388109796,
-0.0882084519,
-0.0882696062,
-0.0653481334,
-0.057695847,
-0.0404941514,
-0.0322106853,
0.0756772384,
0.0714004561,
-0.032538984,
0.0102172429,
-0.0069287848,
-0.0347536206,
0.0533923991,
-0.0148432571,
-0.0109463604,
0.0299024321,
0.1240139827,
-0.0416643843,
-0.0160397775,
0.0440322831,
-0.0134899095,
0.0423572101,
-0.0302796178,
0.0509259664,
0.0197584387,
-0.0239281561,
-0.0011832555,
-0.0280259978,
0.0294267274,
-0.0435357206,
0.0422054417,
-0.0916609168,
-0.0109927803,
-0.0233748611,
-0.0500073507,
-0.0217032041,
0.0003166031,
-0.0291352868,
-0.0330000818,
0.0280963778,
0.0040049562,
-0.0181191918,
0.017493248,
-0.0522156991,
-0.0323116891,
0.0260352604,
-0.0714026392,
-0.0243952423,
-0.0237405822,
-0.0502137244,
-0.0031314543,
-0.0583969206,
0.0191477425,
2.254974231e-34,
0.0435196273,
-0.0217093229,
0.0075924653,
0.020300338,
0.0720726773,
0.002841953,
0.0011504523,
-0.0069934973,
0.0343422145,
-0.0933286026,
-0.0128813507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08379v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08379v1 | PatFig: Generating Short and Long Captions for Patent Figures | 2023-09-15T13:10:36 | 2023-09-15T13:10:36 | Dana Aubakirova, Kim Gerdes, Lufei Liu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | This paper introduces Qatent PatFig, a novel large-scale patent figure
dataset comprising 30,000+ patent figures from over 11,000 European patent
applications. For each figure, this dataset provides short and long captions,
reference numerals, their corresponding terms, and the minimal claim set that
describes the interactions between the components of the image. To assess the
usability of the dataset, we finetune an LVLM model on Qatent PatFig to
generate short and long descriptions, and we investigate the effects of
incorporating various text-based cues at the prediction stage of the patent
figure captioning process. | [
0.0529380664,
0.0351934247,
-0.0095592551,
0.0192255564,
-0.0309805647,
-0.0178195871,
0.0335905962,
0.0160870571,
0.0054160119,
-0.0574981831,
-0.0024834801,
-0.0425604433,
0.0164795127,
0.0543829948,
0.0410921872,
-0.0755138546,
-0.0018907763,
-0.0388920829,
0.023365112,
0.0057747588,
0.0204956792,
0.0124116652,
-0.0266195238,
0.0437361225,
-0.0352778211,
0.008927105,
0.0074930554,
0.0024283063,
0.0005360547,
-0.0807616189,
-0.0383348539,
0.0724634305,
0.0352444798,
-0.019783441,
0.0000017046,
-0.0500779413,
0.0190036036,
0.0238882098,
0.029574858,
0.0439051427,
0.0706981495,
-0.0158602968,
-0.0037383479,
-0.0215952545,
-0.0048469086,
0.0003827449,
0.0681328699,
0.0883482173,
0.0135417925,
0.012029306,
-0.0239410698,
-0.0458515994,
-0.0028258252,
-0.0481378548,
0.0311936811,
-0.0561787225,
-0.0066558705,
0.049763035,
0.0435443707,
-0.0384377763,
-0.0110374363,
0.0690654665,
-0.0228089653,
-0.0255946126,
0.0368396938,
0.0571790636,
0.0039304523,
-0.0241881479,
-0.0082589183,
0.1058055684,
0.0420113243,
0.018095186,
-0.0173747074,
-0.0080695553,
0.0369849689,
0.003400817,
-0.0691231117,
0.0501298867,
-0.0050161169,
-0.0098965289,
-0.014410059,
0.0256419163,
-0.0258169305,
-0.0243547708,
0.0176098254,
-0.0337909795,
0.0199580807,
-0.0022937448,
-0.0449999534,
-0.0303378943,
-0.0434899367,
-0.0750825331,
0.0273868181,
-0.0116543937,
0.0625869483,
0.0273046531,
-0.0507433601,
-0.0300617516,
0.0374561176,
-0.0509081259,
0.0184188075,
-0.0519084558,
-0.0524765775,
0.0753281564,
-0.0662741661,
0.0443206318,
0.0033465105,
0.0206778292,
-0.0240974184,
0.00647762,
-0.0544715375,
-0.013220828,
-0.0519308224,
0.0138444416,
-0.0611493401,
-0.0566441119,
-0.0426057391,
-0.0129751079,
-0.014350906,
0.0449767001,
0.0237354394,
0.0279307012,
-0.0114904288,
-0.0115018645,
-0.0540145263,
0.0048023546,
-0.0016141545,
-0.0356435478,
-0.0239406265,
-0.0265192892,
0.016595738,
0.0185559765,
0.044171717,
-0.0132661257,
-0.0193078704,
0.0408631302,
-0.0076120058,
-0.0257494226,
0.0129888011,
-0.0720688701,
-0.0334116369,
-0.0076889596,
0.0123462351,
-0.0440948866,
0.0161696468,
-0.0327932499,
0.0082027698,
-0.0864895806,
0.0095670205,
0.035648711,
-0.0182656385,
0.0861163065,
-0.0444915257,
0.012199386,
-0.0227703564,
0.0023617153,
-0.0103113092,
0.0172442142,
0.019402815,
0.0515004322,
0.0559529439,
-0.0542837568,
0.0418571979,
0.0329053849,
0.0093232216,
-0.0230099298,
-0.0046461537,
0.007771953,
0.0017630901,
0.0083462624,
0.0078806998,
-0.0014290488,
-0.020912936,
0.0360658541,
0.0962486193,
0.0798266754,
0.0386515297,
0.0133733992,
-0.0110575762,
0.0084328447,
0.0034745093,
-0.0434586108,
-0.0261394978,
0.0667981505,
-0.0042471662,
0.0480512865,
-0.0401508994,
0.0270161647,
-0.0039105914,
-0.0522338673,
-0.0079074604,
0.0058365008,
0.0035833635,
-0.0626539662,
0.0503444113,
0.0429659486,
-0.0548229851,
0.0363409631,
-0.0070277881,
-0.0125296321,
-0.0449328497,
-0.0137027213,
0.0100555681,
0.0559934303,
0.0724563822,
0.0087471679,
-0.016272705,
-0.0213513412,
0.0168267079,
0.0556830727,
0.0705263913,
-0.0010400659,
-0.041249048,
-0.0244722888,
-0.045597557,
-0.0451249592,
0.0128175039,
0.0294217858,
-0.018878134,
0.0013643522,
0.0438332632,
-0.0170481429,
-0.0130831385,
0.0239443369,
0.0106711974,
-0.0518637784,
-0.0064816708,
0.0118500004,
-0.011983742,
0.015113987,
-0.0179568864,
0.0397075228,
0.0231421348,
0.0060075438,
0.0144593818,
0.0598733872,
0.0521576926,
-0.0272846725,
0.0087683154,
-0.0835090652,
-0.0172635186,
-0.026571326,
-0.0183554031,
0.0065773004,
-0.0283404924,
-0.0293203052,
0.0041834754,
-0.0248414148,
-0.0107748332,
0.0008988197,
0.0142937908,
-0.0097664678,
0.0322736613,
0.0175061766,
-0.0140409609,
0.0644894838,
-0.0238906574,
0.0117113208,
-0.0248894822,
-0.020707,
0.0077224607,
-0.0044290284,
-0.0002983122,
0.0065436414,
0.0206213184,
-0.0067913765,
0.0395808741,
-0.0964570269,
-0.0337431319,
0.0135953659,
-0.016406728,
0.0015197984,
-0.0300495941,
0.0030893201,
-0.0232185833,
-0.0347145572,
-0.0620199032,
-0.0364748351,
-0.0229522418,
0.0558508299,
0.0056991219,
-0.0672412813,
-0.0167762786,
-0.0189231019,
0.0040678764,
0.0328941867,
0.080156818,
-0.031142598,
-0.0679373816,
0.0269677155,
-0.0169994235,
-0.0093269683,
0.0047284155,
0.0111094695,
-0.0075442703,
0.0091595259,
-0.072586365,
0.0171319917,
0.0111429682,
0.0230198614,
0.0163595956,
0.0236235857,
-0.031662859,
0.004446771,
-0.0001341773,
0.009027686,
0.0430365466,
-0.0261362474,
-0.0014664086,
0.0172774587,
-0.0455263369,
0.0429642275,
-0.0450801104,
-0.0044315411,
-0.0048351171,
-0.0456652939,
-0.029924972,
0.0425720364,
0.0130077023,
0.0518578477,
-0.0175293479,
-0.0704288781,
0.0516242236,
-0.0582030751,
-0.0338419974,
-0.0153606124,
0.0206241421,
-0.0220083687,
0.0938769728,
0.0197312236,
0.0209737308,
0.0245717913,
-0.0061856946,
0.0122343414,
0.021419378,
0.0175283775,
-0.0149137946,
0.0531219617,
-0.0461885408,
0.0165701807,
-0.044718653,
-0.0328243859,
-0.009380375,
-0.0373110101,
-0.0034012739,
-0.0139563419,
-0.0158480555,
-0.0122434311,
-0.023402689,
0.0722765774,
-0.0102419518,
0.0123541728,
0.0235195253,
0.0001619674,
-0.014206388,
0.0372713953,
0.0655898452,
-0.0062905508,
-0.0452018343,
-0.0075888219,
-0.0183057562,
-0.0065367455,
-0.0376293808,
0.0171833467,
-0.0034579786,
-0.0032975764,
-0.0262439549,
-0.0016895862,
0.0013173862,
0.0371413417,
0.0529064722,
-0.0132667534,
0.0522579849,
0.071282573,
0.0026483766,
0.0435427874,
-0.0062397076,
0.0701901987,
0.0197193325,
0.0169679802,
0.0063861446,
-0.0990502536,
-0.0024938262,
-0.0526429117,
0.0106497128,
-0.0050364099,
0.0257770419,
-0.0568557344,
-0.0943468958,
0.0835474953,
0.0368000455,
-0.0290137511,
-0.0645456761,
-0.0043448824,
-0.0169267748,
-0.0073367623,
-0.0374235511,
-0.0091459695,
-0.0428726599,
-0.0077285888,
0.0088433558,
-0.0668113306,
0.0015967501,
-0.009514113,
-0.0242200587,
0.0103655672,
0.0497024097,
0.020091841,
-0.0021610842,
-0.0397194289,
-0.0309323054,
0.0297557395,
0.0207141507,
0.0032352461,
0.0636598766,
0.008092721,
-0.0341306143,
-0.0043962682,
0.0299749617,
-0.0272932351,
-0.0069452398,
0.0148824509,
0.0257695466,
0.0103487419,
-0.0277595259,
-0.055509638,
0.0150714042,
-0.0255553462,
0.0483379699,
0.0642350614,
-0.012346887,
-0.043754898,
-0.0425917767,
-0.0073513673,
-0.1059192494,
-0.005723563,
-0.0215722416,
-0.0565168746,
-0.0312065501,
-0.0860422775,
-0.0202428773,
0.0524142571,
0.0342981257,
0.0406698771,
0.0144486353,
-0.0063506444,
0.0536955073,
-0.0584108941,
0.0421676487,
-0.0189841148,
0.009396106,
-0.0084960582,
-0.0058041285,
0.0611981936,
-0.0292091556,
-0.034531258,
0.0293824393,
-0.0198380053,
-0.0362958536,
-0.0347059965,
0.0392469466,
0.0271917153,
-0.0010354735,
0.0064632669,
-0.0328504704,
0.0515758283,
0.0626860335,
0.0712567046,
-0.0146386521,
-0.0060083652,
-0.0227961093,
-0.0375193469,
-0.022562271,
-0.0189627782,
0.0034238016,
-0.0072276439,
0.0263747703,
0.030733224,
-0.0437068306,
0.004658028,
0.0536420569,
0.0207021236,
-0.0291553028,
0.0161340144,
-0.0195886139,
0.0031672704,
0.005303727,
-0.0020057634,
-0.0612060502,
0.0245149471,
-0.0154822525,
0.011689242,
-0.0076410058,
-0.0056184852,
-0.0285420418,
0.0221029259,
-0.0452529564,
0.0106525579,
0.0068650828,
-0.0174560044,
0.0191146974,
-0.0153056346,
0.0152751952,
0.02551613,
-0.0412384272,
0.0272443704,
-0.0063403985,
0.0275343508,
-0.004625218,
0.000790332,
-0.0234064236,
0.0794428214,
0.0028764545,
-0.0462350585,
-0.066726014,
0.050672818,
0.0836510882,
-0.0059154327,
0.0521638691,
-0.0562073253,
-0.0065823165,
0.0054157013,
0.0499402545,
-0.0227732696,
-0.0098287966,
0.0418037735,
0.0139514348,
0.0032916935,
-0.056598831,
0.0399426892,
0.0393533111,
0.03728351,
-0.0257197395,
-0.0192265417,
-0.0396759808,
-0.0176432226,
0.020620754,
-0.0207375269,
-0.0034871632,
-0.0047724065,
-0.0613015816,
-0.0395918936,
0.0359184854,
-0.0179951768,
0.0126185007,
0.0417607613,
0.0490495637,
0.0373574011,
0.0111763403,
-0.0346041285,
-0.0087933671,
-0.0256428178,
-0.0024827584,
-0.0070381025,
-0.0427592583,
-5.223914895e-33,
-0.0043293624,
-0.0588210821,
0.0052037928,
0.0163271129,
-0.0229247715,
-0.0227591433,
-0.0364000909,
0.0255745966,
0.0574633665,
0.0162914004,
0.0102704586,
-0.060410209,
0.022484215,
0.0104588512,
0.0151374117,
-0.0143524054,
0.0544612743,
0.0132996347,
-0.0229278449,
0.023713477,
-0.0195925925,
-0.0009777488,
0.0179952607,
-0.0737034157,
0.0338455625,
0.0360467695,
0.0038860887,
-0.0461644344,
0.0239846818,
0.0877044722,
0.0121505838,
0.0004255841,
0.0308679566,
-0.0381259993,
-0.0311634243,
0.0290170908,
-0.046972774,
0.0314917266,
0.0161632299,
0.0112331267,
0.0183457565,
-0.0257099587,
0.0144339493,
-0.0381973535,
-0.0170522053,
-0.006990979,
0.0759678259,
-0.0362994932,
-0.0103708524,
-0.030161066,
-0.0180770643,
0.0142876972,
-0.0157104731,
-0.0004019005,
0.0890570208,
0.0163957682,
0.0301696304,
0.0446182378,
-0.0498258322,
0.0537201948,
0.0015920793,
-0.0253682509,
0.101375483,
-0.0029940729,
0.0182083901,
0.0212677959,
0.0289327931,
0.0224977043,
-0.035215687,
0.0034599805,
-0.004887261,
0.1075497121,
0.0746998638,
0.0041845334,
0.0877157971,
-0.0046821493,
-0.0025449302,
0.0365566686,
-0.0806618482,
-0.000618414,
0.0325833783,
-0.0050956449,
-0.0034861204,
0.0289916415,
-0.027510047,
0.0008797438,
-0.0119752372,
-0.0213041827,
0.033422567,
0.0109260855,
-0.012460513,
0.0586073287,
0.0266724154,
-0.0483140387,
-0.021840008,
-0.0881426036,
0.0322934017,
0.101107657,
-0.038955912,
-0.0792068988,
-0.0145489238,
-0.0294117127,
0.026629407,
0.0261519067,
0.0399125479,
0.0026619802,
0.0382909924,
-0.0353099108,
-0.033297386,
0.0025278323,
-0.0128987236,
-0.0265056323,
0.0026576791,
0.0144495945,
0.0072954325,
0.0125498623,
-0.044859454,
-0.008525514,
0.0044928603,
-0.0192022007,
-0.0286749154,
-0.0377874449,
-0.0130535066,
-0.0044553834,
-0.0150130494,
0.017228432,
-0.0152069638,
0.018163655,
0.030203538,
-0.039690908,
-0.0246393885,
0.0312839188,
2.35e-7,
0.0335753299,
0.0534907915,
0.0509171151,
0.0219027344,
0.0033419612,
0.017315641,
-0.0267423559,
0.0293269958,
-0.0248729941,
-0.0569873005,
0.0541846454,
-0.0220286027,
0.0319941193,
-0.0190729219,
-0.0747872666,
-0.0768519193,
-0.0322295092,
-0.0043809619,
-0.0475816354,
0.011246278,
0.0892802477,
0.0336761661,
-0.0194914155,
-0.0262989365,
0.0290764291,
-0.0563109741,
0.0671568513,
-0.0417018011,
0.0360017084,
0.0118239345,
0.0847105831,
0.0001424565,
-0.0575122051,
0.0204320904,
-0.0437848531,
0.0002639857,
0.0249957424,
0.033448942,
-0.0094179371,
0.0501754805,
-0.0294554681,
0.0057879281,
-0.0058285655,
-0.0310655888,
0.0327683836,
-0.0214412753,
-0.010660409,
-0.0010334867,
0.0003899934,
0.0223512556,
0.0147161353,
-0.0118432269,
-0.0152993612,
0.0001526828,
0.0441788658,
-0.0276007168,
-0.0135696372,
-0.0615706332,
-0.0134929838,
-0.0009905845,
-0.0090368409,
0.0034496388,
-0.0364919454,
-0.0110367537,
0.018919671,
-0.01617462,
-0.0008706083,
2.116143068e-34,
0.0674005225,
-0.0412595272,
0.0062846895,
0.0160773881,
0.0561368167,
-0.0343339257,
0.0674612448,
0.0097454572,
-0.0182882976,
-0.0672020391,
-0.0027825225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08377v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08377v1 | DiaCorrect: Error Correction Back-end For Speaker Diarization | 2023-09-15T13:08:12 | 2023-09-15T13:08:12 | Jiangyu Han, Federico Landini, Johan Rohdin, Mireia Diez, Lukas Burget, Yuhang Cao, Heng Lu, Jan Cernocky | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | In this work, we propose an error correction framework, named DiaCorrect, to
refine the output of a diarization system in a simple yet effective way. This
method is inspired by error correction techniques in automatic speech
recognition. Our model consists of two parallel convolutional encoders and a
transform-based decoder. By exploiting the interactions between the input
recording and the initial system's outputs, DiaCorrect can automatically
correct the initial speaker activities to minimize the diarization errors.
Experiments on 2-speaker telephony data show that the proposed DiaCorrect can
effectively improve the initial model's results. Our source code is publicly
available at https://github.com/BUTSpeechFIT/diacorrect. | [
-0.0085507091,
0.0160865039,
0.0183330588,
0.0278624594,
0.0072543784,
0.0328411907,
0.0590088665,
-0.029844407,
-0.0328124352,
-0.0186267495,
-0.0173205491,
-0.0161745511,
0.0458673909,
-0.0120354174,
0.0092305765,
-0.0720266923,
0.0192316752,
-0.0030040124,
-0.0185184348,
-0.0037594158,
-0.0201466307,
-0.0237669647,
-0.0651380792,
0.0146066435,
-0.0358553343,
0.0223628897,
0.0275134835,
0.035173934,
0.033414118,
0.027656544,
0.0452989265,
0.0496262722,
0.0007472296,
0.0480228849,
0.0000020212,
-0.0119034806,
-0.0092627397,
-0.0159947164,
-0.0053924001,
-0.019700706,
-0.0060424581,
0.0143122235,
-0.0258602519,
0.0308468305,
-0.0297219772,
-0.0394592173,
0.0135621112,
0.0087350756,
0.05062126,
0.0102497023,
0.0150438612,
-0.0734927431,
0.0333501101,
0.0063428748,
-0.0345975719,
0.0077903164,
0.0246054046,
-0.0047102608,
-0.0790854245,
-0.0733612999,
-0.0048699887,
0.0469817184,
-0.0006213199,
-0.005091913,
0.0512434468,
-0.0122303721,
0.0185039304,
-0.0417340398,
-0.0041050804,
0.0301942173,
0.0057444568,
0.0188442357,
0.0171525329,
0.0395813137,
0.0019888333,
-0.0444888361,
0.0057775998,
-0.0368050672,
-0.0072413082,
-0.031125091,
-0.0771677867,
0.0119948331,
0.0155600654,
-0.0465056449,
-0.0314154588,
-0.0163352415,
-0.0063110408,
-0.0127635254,
-0.0503027104,
-0.0121566486,
0.0334584229,
0.0107211564,
0.0569651015,
-0.000657775,
-0.0249364879,
-0.0259942468,
0.0052454602,
-0.0367531069,
-0.0419376008,
-0.0375393964,
-0.0123843169,
0.011931275,
-0.0271465722,
0.0016615925,
0.0017820533,
0.0548467785,
0.0093106963,
0.0162844062,
-0.0205614641,
-0.0364823714,
-0.0315596759,
0.035110008,
-0.0306530464,
-0.0100130914,
0.0737316236,
0.004197713,
-0.064012222,
0.0020221542,
-0.0510557555,
0.007409432,
-0.001337338,
0.021344997,
-0.0166209731,
-0.0196057595,
0.0194398891,
0.0589251444,
-0.0100036673,
0.0422615819,
-0.0269500539,
-0.0258064028,
0.0253192559,
0.0049173855,
0.0198201146,
0.0063288957,
-0.019715244,
-0.0392693318,
0.0174695905,
-0.034779001,
-0.0179159176,
0.0002631173,
-0.0122113219,
-0.0022286919,
-0.017477233,
-0.0839925706,
0.0093781184,
-0.0138094025,
0.0215689596,
-0.0636211485,
-0.0161545165,
-0.0324617736,
0.0090355678,
0.0784387067,
-0.0362370908,
0.024038462,
0.1263616532,
-0.0029393395,
-0.0006467431,
0.0000429921,
0.0791766495,
-0.0578908622,
0.0167049803,
-0.0460234098,
0.0384651385,
0.0538839437,
-0.0080104321,
-0.0478534475,
-0.0266815647,
-0.0445964783,
-0.0083759734,
0.0278094281,
0.0277491696,
0.0357725322,
-0.0482726432,
-0.0221764222,
0.0169618186,
0.0440392643,
0.0349481553,
-0.0138470344,
0.0335138626,
-0.052283071,
-0.0108258128,
0.0234224275,
-0.0228945892,
-0.0143529065,
-0.0085964883,
-0.059279602,
0.0657395944,
0.0269368589,
-0.0522306785,
-0.0266493317,
0.0623481423,
-0.0539389364,
0.0144558419,
0.0030428378,
0.0225410238,
0.0082506165,
0.0247150753,
0.0997654572,
-0.0108123897,
-0.0706959963,
0.0147458203,
-0.0260754731,
-0.0345668048,
0.056099575,
0.0194105487,
-0.0239468534,
0.0211891551,
-0.0777837858,
-0.0206486136,
-0.0192638356,
0.0053712446,
-0.01509747,
0.0006668092,
-0.0650416389,
-0.0326178931,
0.0575806983,
-0.0083084833,
-0.0097254273,
0.0188642778,
-0.0167133845,
0.0455873311,
0.0066728177,
0.061500866,
-0.0103920633,
-0.0136119779,
-0.0414009616,
0.0144217797,
0.0228575729,
0.0365089476,
0.0687451661,
-0.0051280474,
-0.0290823188,
0.0129214479,
-0.0110756578,
0.0148168253,
-0.0038316466,
-0.0398672856,
-0.0216007754,
0.0661370158,
-0.0147237061,
-0.0105195334,
0.045873031,
-0.024516305,
-0.0764226615,
0.0435996056,
-0.0309822075,
0.0022541345,
-0.0279969182,
0.0407466367,
0.0009827252,
0.0097080804,
0.0052121282,
-0.0237680525,
-0.0174785387,
-0.000394932,
-0.0122510791,
0.0481225513,
-0.0072809476,
-0.0624375306,
-0.0031298939,
-0.0116223181,
-0.0005700507,
0.0849021152,
0.0118213799,
-0.0354235657,
-0.0079020709,
-0.0200545751,
-0.0611787811,
-0.0004256316,
-0.0414037891,
-0.0187602881,
-0.0024892194,
0.0508663319,
0.0371220931,
-0.0481605977,
0.0113527272,
0.0013239585,
0.0107608959,
-0.0076197665,
-0.0291894153,
-0.0032146953,
-0.0915108398,
-0.0005930655,
-0.0140485242,
0.0304883793,
-0.0026010901,
-0.0090831136,
-0.0195093378,
-0.0509946309,
-0.0717876107,
0.0215192791,
0.0209913366,
0.0069371825,
0.0080902213,
-0.0255578682,
0.0416254401,
0.012780115,
0.0147709846,
0.0481018536,
0.0071193445,
-0.012674218,
0.0317330509,
-0.0180368461,
-0.0017559334,
-0.0263193529,
0.0032641194,
-0.0220209938,
-0.0537763797,
-0.0270685386,
0.0196208991,
-0.0185502339,
0.0320261866,
-0.0133076822,
-0.0439276509,
-0.0176959913,
-0.0138795227,
0.0061095534,
-0.0304889102,
-0.0308250841,
0.0000553711,
-0.0141536724,
-0.0173748247,
0.0164818335,
-0.0241437871,
-0.0081295595,
0.0050181099,
-0.0521901287,
-0.0006690328,
-0.0177035313,
-0.0006624847,
0.0137884291,
-0.016846627,
-0.046724081,
-0.0082726069,
-0.0574985407,
0.0398444086,
-0.0681513324,
0.0440179855,
-0.0254213214,
-0.0001564108,
0.001950423,
-0.0302327778,
-0.0152660329,
0.0223639403,
-0.0131221479,
0.0236544479,
-0.0147441616,
-0.0506590195,
-0.0434369929,
0.0381982289,
0.0234739985,
0.0093477638,
0.012360869,
0.024430586,
-0.0306185987,
0.0611896105,
-0.0377470069,
0.0434737802,
-0.006418285,
-0.0260910783,
0.0131813092,
0.0212631021,
-0.0152735095,
0.0569359735,
-0.0438618399,
-0.0096116513,
0.0065183719,
0.0112778721,
-0.0497483052,
-0.002371347,
0.0035120584,
0.0092787212,
-0.0125245592,
0.1250308007,
0.0182098299,
-0.116881296,
-0.0312141273,
-0.0079709757,
-0.0536560714,
0.0160332136,
-0.0351301096,
-0.0269207526,
-0.0231512617,
0.0611103289,
0.0653463602,
0.0529036112,
0.0151149491,
0.0103325341,
-0.0458724611,
0.0269441102,
0.0454346575,
0.0081846043,
-0.0915484056,
-0.0616277903,
-0.0067084692,
-0.0296232048,
0.0804237351,
0.0285504423,
0.0214551985,
-0.0360522643,
0.0445201397,
-0.0950846747,
-0.0213722549,
-0.013513064,
-0.0244213063,
0.0901114568,
0.0495303832,
0.0371710993,
0.0206896663,
0.0031933172,
0.0020429569,
-0.0421359651,
-0.0470829308,
-0.0108509911,
0.0885323286,
0.0300331321,
0.0344422609,
0.0490165539,
0.0157169979,
-0.0246320609,
-0.0040869028,
-0.0103783272,
-0.0001506746,
-0.0117276888,
0.024982471,
0.0204123147,
0.0359746888,
0.0270524882,
0.0224790778,
0.0299385283,
0.0030570209,
-0.0281813536,
0.0017592042,
0.0388033986,
-0.0188527349,
0.0093106814,
0.0055852663,
-0.0108144227,
-0.1106721312,
0.0153968045,
-0.0018931449,
-0.0014378765,
-0.0209129099,
-0.0081781624,
-0.0188173633,
-0.0010803406,
0.0219694376,
-0.0174153857,
-0.0240460094,
-0.0129475575,
0.0735481679,
-0.0798596516,
-0.0100539606,
0.0390455127,
0.004843872,
0.0097574666,
0.0070788409,
-0.0364017114,
-0.0107732611,
0.0683345273,
0.0022022557,
0.0180103872,
0.0675086752,
-0.0379242562,
-0.0528802648,
0.0249766205,
0.0087295016,
-0.0200276002,
0.0570655651,
0.0254749302,
-0.0069112284,
-0.0450838841,
0.0223482903,
-0.0581243746,
0.0618618391,
-0.0437382646,
-0.0275142398,
-0.1286032945,
-0.1279318482,
-0.030118132,
-0.0116776908,
0.0567450151,
0.0006965243,
-0.0229115449,
-0.011970222,
0.0175500754,
0.0117225936,
0.0309919547,
-0.0033569918,
-0.0025188946,
0.0110374335,
-0.0071626678,
0.004623862,
0.0473688543,
-0.0304907002,
-0.0646632314,
-0.003883281,
0.0141144153,
0.0265125651,
0.029790638,
0.0117090913,
0.0065621492,
-0.0131928232,
0.0144724892,
0.0710284784,
0.0081557073,
0.0033335446,
-0.0094108256,
-0.0167759527,
0.0317590572,
-0.0206814073,
0.0214977302,
-0.0534973517,
-0.0233128816,
-0.0022072431,
0.015677128,
0.0329086185,
0.0742283687,
0.067879796,
0.022571642,
0.0218385793,
-0.0381736383,
0.0261906832,
-0.0182670038,
0.0205177739,
0.0245738961,
-0.030276509,
0.0024875128,
0.0273944065,
0.0183722656,
-0.027812127,
0.0332224183,
-0.080821313,
-0.0091451686,
-0.0199246872,
-0.0344754905,
-0.0443779565,
-0.0307235122,
-0.0300284587,
-0.0266917311,
0.0357715636,
-0.0439797603,
0.0100829313,
-0.001270937,
0.042598851,
0.0113362353,
0.0059809824,
-0.030620737,
-0.0404873677,
0.0094030341,
0.0034132181,
-0.0432073846,
-0.0076968656,
-0.0429550186,
0.018374376,
-5.846481315e-33,
-0.0386533774,
0.0061276867,
0.0083714742,
-0.003346222,
0.009663377,
-0.0264953412,
0.0022874628,
0.0199602414,
0.0339950733,
-0.00505576,
0.0124137336,
0.0475034043,
0.0263785142,
0.0059270342,
-0.0215629991,
0.0063827289,
0.1183380261,
-0.0423498154,
0.0080401348,
0.042616874,
0.0654870346,
0.046032764,
-0.0078110239,
-0.1057750583,
-0.04356521,
0.0179337356,
-0.0383461043,
0.0173044037,
-0.0040087304,
0.0017788276,
0.0155150704,
0.0137115521,
-0.0148791336,
0.0296867248,
-0.0269643087,
0.0674901977,
-0.1127289459,
0.0180762205,
-0.0906140357,
0.0863416493,
0.0040612621,
-0.0053669768,
0.0431750044,
0.0340197757,
-0.0577694513,
-0.0528350249,
0.0650035888,
-0.0217404254,
-0.0180268437,
-0.0209683441,
0.0493195839,
0.0271154363,
-0.0171638671,
-0.0473186821,
0.0675750747,
0.0459240191,
-0.0194133092,
-0.050736852,
-0.1046101674,
0.0259850733,
-0.0042869076,
0.0071783722,
0.0102005592,
0.0677963495,
-0.0453345478,
-0.0008067591,
0.100462243,
-0.0460262783,
0.0544756278,
-0.0829415321,
-0.0270691905,
0.0338072479,
0.0249225497,
0.0301963538,
0.0292716641,
-0.0696405545,
-0.0215956885,
0.0217089206,
0.0262414925,
-0.0062530455,
0.0066332072,
0.012221382,
-0.0263994131,
-0.0098744091,
-0.0248090811,
0.0282266419,
0.0002204164,
-0.0099458387,
-0.013102877,
0.015207951,
-0.0234480873,
-0.0370373204,
0.0372389667,
-0.0368825607,
0.0201316569,
0.0307625979,
0.0199582186,
0.0519041009,
-0.0091420067,
-0.0060405806,
0.0283706933,
-0.0559269562,
0.0604094304,
0.061591208,
0.0196290556,
-0.0271506347,
0.0178994723,
0.0547597297,
-0.0336024314,
-0.0053318706,
0.0369841456,
0.0409126319,
0.0057679848,
-0.0143361306,
-0.0158383418,
0.0140187759,
0.0106470725,
0.0255604815,
0.001308489,
0.0091977315,
0.0210459102,
-0.0092934109,
0.0310067888,
0.0471472517,
-0.0525212474,
0.0037494348,
0.0074851047,
-0.0000569997,
0.0562009327,
-0.0127887046,
0.0070649539,
-0.0215207599,
2.774e-7,
-0.0240272712,
0.0165440906,
0.0543286987,
-0.0528290868,
0.0489781909,
0.033457011,
0.0191567559,
0.0075448779,
0.0259856675,
-0.0135994554,
0.0289542861,
-0.0024823453,
0.0681799576,
0.04142626,
-0.0329519808,
-0.0390578136,
-0.0182526521,
0.0461229645,
0.0202905107,
0.0311963372,
0.0110165495,
0.0221192855,
0.0398241356,
-0.0378095284,
0.0111306757,
-0.0080052,
0.0175002795,
-0.0191124547,
0.0252477732,
0.0093338368,
0.0559525415,
-0.0228063818,
0.0284988172,
0.0754807591,
-0.0154863736,
0.0012499428,
0.0029825983,
0.0214063525,
-0.0156757534,
-0.0401006415,
-0.0686742514,
0.0184116848,
-0.0055133305,
0.0008552572,
0.0204166938,
0.0142505644,
-0.0167783592,
-0.0114845447,
-0.0696384609,
0.0245159268,
0.0059074797,
0.017857438,
-0.0059737968,
0.0138707906,
0.0132865021,
0.0282245949,
-0.0010937368,
-0.0740372539,
0.0281553101,
0.0581271835,
-0.0641648844,
-0.0500638485,
0.0363376439,
-0.0109276287,
0.019155914,
-0.0021288402,
0.0455099456,
1.750146588e-34,
0.0074867704,
0.0423255414,
0.0300814565,
-0.0241579656,
-0.0134744616,
-0.054641448,
0.0111444024,
0.0128230555,
0.011180697,
-0.0106388945,
-0.0265732855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08351v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08351v1 | Headless Language Models: Learning without Predicting with Contrastive Weight Tying | 2023-09-15T12:20:00 | 2023-09-15T12:20:00 | Nathan Godey, Éric de la Clergerie, Benoît Sagot | cs.CL | cs.CL | Self-supervised pre-training of language models usually consists in
predicting probability distributions over extensive token vocabularies. In this
study, we propose an innovative method that shifts away from probability
prediction and instead focuses on reconstructing input embeddings in a
contrastive fashion via Constrastive Weight Tying (CWT). We apply this approach
to pretrain Headless Language Models in both monolingual and multilingual
contexts. Our method offers practical advantages, substantially reducing
training computational requirements by up to 20 times, while simultaneously
enhancing downstream performance and data efficiency. We observe a significant
+1.6 GLUE score increase and a notable +2.7 LAMBADA accuracy improvement
compared to classical LMs within similar compute budgets. | [
-0.0189563558,
0.0782259703,
0.0128598455,
0.0454449318,
-0.0208661519,
-0.0045624548,
0.0212365557,
-0.011749276,
0.0365837179,
-0.0097369812,
-0.0533632599,
-0.0521041974,
0.0145932231,
0.0146477092,
0.0347912274,
-0.0379953645,
0.0023662634,
-0.0139763467,
-0.0678143278,
-0.0333567448,
0.0184077136,
0.0013366594,
-0.00752918,
-0.017263243,
-0.0294047426,
-0.0045049759,
-0.0221387465,
0.0153022101,
-0.0220564343,
-0.0149149364,
0.0079039773,
0.0816259831,
0.0158041008,
0.0377763361,
0.0000020787,
-0.0430763364,
-0.0079393219,
-0.0144527312,
-0.0205231365,
0.0255842544,
0.0365656801,
-0.0225227624,
-0.0194660816,
0.0179880951,
-0.0372566953,
-0.0302501135,
0.077544868,
0.0265396833,
0.0317850448,
0.0423986427,
-0.0164812151,
-0.0267303456,
0.0064069936,
-0.0547601283,
-0.0009195525,
-0.0006801718,
0.013931714,
-0.0120206261,
-0.0691289529,
-0.0312343296,
-0.0376478918,
0.0342675932,
0.0162947718,
0.0133852186,
-0.0162831284,
0.0715421289,
-0.0670518428,
-0.0268424749,
-0.0120686963,
0.0761186779,
-0.0443401001,
-0.042455148,
-0.0147496751,
-0.0230507422,
-0.0538499057,
-0.0100205978,
-0.0156979728,
0.02956466,
0.0678561553,
0.0638773888,
0.0270740408,
0.0312831365,
0.0441902764,
-0.0033336023,
-0.0387251303,
0.0449252091,
0.0184331927,
-0.022276694,
0.0229065362,
0.0170630142,
-0.0418948531,
-0.0370880254,
-0.0323709808,
0.0009595037,
0.0359644517,
0.0133350901,
-0.0336120278,
-0.030841507,
0.0141397752,
-0.0622373223,
0.0531980693,
0.0555776469,
-0.0281442925,
0.047001604,
-0.0444810875,
-0.0005352364,
0.0239344146,
-0.0013233277,
-0.0389512591,
0.0242590755,
-0.0011434848,
-0.0017505285,
-0.0265281163,
0.028285943,
-0.0640052855,
-0.0235155188,
-0.0146564124,
0.0031835677,
-0.0016250043,
-0.0282878559,
0.0190101732,
0.0185435619,
-0.0410236716,
-0.0274974685,
0.0006206061,
0.0439078659,
0.0105606858,
-0.0058316598,
-0.0424926877,
-0.0622539967,
-0.0345575884,
0.0601841919,
-0.0153105231,
-0.0411216728,
0.0215107724,
0.0555781759,
-0.0169212092,
-0.0300605875,
-0.0061214515,
0.0097351428,
-0.017655218,
-0.0494526252,
-0.0066585192,
-0.0723630413,
0.0226738267,
-0.0173821207,
0.0157421548,
-0.0678080618,
0.0185933337,
0.0178364031,
-0.0328617506,
0.1014013961,
-0.0036461204,
-0.0212799832,
-0.0224259291,
0.0099110659,
0.0038255928,
0.0761876851,
-0.0029480779,
0.0225166604,
0.0252818186,
-0.0170287155,
-0.0369701311,
0.0453336723,
0.050598871,
0.0283409711,
-0.1003155112,
0.0048932307,
0.054859601,
0.0046933373,
0.08049272,
0.0634803325,
-0.013656782,
-0.0207783636,
0.0701239929,
0.0829099119,
0.0493615121,
-0.0090147611,
0.0307182353,
-0.0149069689,
0.0048701591,
0.0209533982,
-0.0645906627,
0.0192025565,
-0.0227849875,
0.0138051836,
0.0670069754,
0.0228962544,
-0.0420995392,
-0.0294816159,
-0.0171614848,
-0.039323993,
0.005823689,
-0.0365490057,
0.0290043596,
0.0091214729,
-0.0137902778,
0.0336388312,
0.0671584234,
-0.0589887202,
0.0103020854,
-0.0274053849,
-0.0221828297,
0.0420431383,
0.0208185147,
0.0013797444,
-0.0071637919,
0.0158311278,
0.0583679974,
0.0869541988,
0.0243360177,
0.0086877905,
0.0520117134,
-0.078829594,
-0.0050323675,
0.0577654988,
0.0106488662,
0.0196582098,
-0.0046949405,
0.0055439575,
0.0086824475,
-0.0108578149,
-0.0253842101,
0.0394637734,
-0.0474765524,
-0.0699288696,
0.0464999713,
0.0224974193,
0.0155476779,
-0.0103842495,
-0.01410456,
0.0174054299,
0.0506046191,
-0.042060025,
-0.0212261677,
-0.0017089198,
-0.0849735215,
-0.0344684385,
0.0501861386,
0.0058368105,
0.0176524781,
0.023615228,
-0.0103753917,
-0.0807855502,
0.0265092682,
0.0278607663,
0.089472279,
-0.0699374676,
-0.0114674717,
0.0315268859,
0.0555101074,
-0.0373623036,
0.0370397642,
-0.0190843213,
0.0233128946,
-0.0216332152,
0.0163787622,
0.0213691778,
-0.0105841048,
-0.0451602079,
-0.0197382346,
0.006310103,
0.0440392233,
-0.006367581,
0.0241692122,
0.0032663783,
0.0039618532,
-0.0810156241,
0.012840447,
-0.0341710784,
0.0045000413,
0.0248173177,
0.0190401655,
-0.0042202994,
-0.0504689366,
-0.0138275344,
-0.0086825732,
-0.0313314125,
0.0273337904,
0.0127927717,
0.0017258845,
0.0311790854,
-0.0225953069,
-0.0379181914,
-0.0041912515,
0.0410509706,
-0.027465703,
0.0135153895,
-0.0133596146,
0.0391142443,
-0.0260679238,
0.0520467944,
-0.0027132833,
-0.0481818505,
-0.0009052592,
-0.0524030589,
0.0454960987,
0.0459381528,
-0.0061883391,
0.0048017637,
0.087521188,
-0.0053619952,
-0.0291864146,
-0.0061492659,
-0.0318722948,
0.0180395134,
-0.0221626237,
0.0071948199,
-0.0685550347,
0.0726992637,
-0.0013312717,
-0.0052336194,
-0.0661369711,
-0.019588029,
0.0083220461,
-0.0069388775,
-0.0328921415,
0.0444751233,
-0.0566267669,
0.0419439971,
-0.0037920596,
-0.0693196505,
0.0512003116,
-0.058322493,
-0.0088324659,
-0.0027344543,
-0.0267861318,
-0.0229711607,
0.0614845417,
0.0448091812,
0.0159588773,
0.0100310585,
-0.0173380505,
-0.0587111451,
0.0153880343,
0.0245935414,
-0.0159775987,
0.0337441564,
-0.0216770303,
0.0187747609,
-0.034069974,
-0.0455741771,
-0.0217454005,
-0.0333927684,
-0.0279366858,
-0.0159561485,
0.0063412171,
-0.0321613029,
0.0005907919,
0.0525404178,
-0.0157078747,
0.0781514719,
-0.0118967267,
0.0077181412,
-0.0160425454,
0.0169444829,
0.0283966493,
0.0163436849,
0.0091044493,
-0.0062889308,
0.0235067159,
0.0299999695,
0.0612784959,
-0.0148598477,
-0.0531843677,
0.0122196097,
0.0299115721,
-0.0128468182,
-0.0190994423,
0.0106273433,
0.0036373334,
-0.0125150336,
0.0191358272,
0.1320832372,
0.0014273128,
-0.0753284022,
-0.0117053874,
-0.0046560196,
0.0641306564,
0.0252247192,
0.0267208908,
-0.0405387245,
-0.0584782735,
0.0151894493,
0.0290094651,
0.0450429134,
-0.041721236,
-0.0149150472,
-0.1259315312,
0.0005422031,
0.0116334613,
-0.0331301019,
0.0075837788,
-0.0630698055,
-0.0031135813,
-0.0700989813,
0.0098949634,
-0.0010369098,
-0.0385558382,
0.0106185526,
0.0211726781,
-0.0504374094,
-0.0376583524,
0.0080221705,
-0.0293344483,
0.067654103,
0.0458839312,
-0.0178310908,
-0.02209129,
-0.0296410937,
0.0588001981,
-0.0579517856,
-0.0273354892,
-0.0247644819,
0.0652691647,
-0.0158137176,
-0.0215284079,
0.0242024139,
0.0081291758,
-0.0296482407,
-0.0049886117,
-0.0283680446,
0.0847318172,
0.0151812704,
0.0020547942,
0.0024239817,
-0.0050321487,
0.0231987946,
0.0820046142,
0.0083353864,
-0.0621483847,
-0.0135883847,
-0.0154867517,
0.0151746282,
0.0372098126,
-0.0452381372,
-0.0137182958,
0.0072463942,
-0.0217341855,
-0.0454364158,
-0.0237944648,
0.0115194358,
0.0701616853,
-0.0047139754,
0.0340056978,
-0.0177338384,
-0.0139420051,
-0.0547058694,
0.0401197858,
-0.06648276,
-0.0099523459,
-0.0630676597,
0.0184496902,
0.0606178157,
-0.0085284049,
-0.004754466,
-0.0111157466,
-0.0473947711,
-0.0710331649,
-0.0126373367,
0.049861677,
0.0254499391,
0.0695149302,
0.0029242258,
-0.0257754643,
0.0425431617,
0.0712859258,
-0.0411973037,
0.027961174,
0.0528991073,
-0.0517009199,
0.0096122175,
0.0529887415,
-0.0028791733,
0.0244055539,
0.0264954921,
0.0582372434,
-0.0261861309,
-0.0466889143,
0.0025778557,
0.0026253669,
0.0904372483,
-0.02152857,
0.0467761792,
-0.036794506,
0.0157791544,
-0.0165383108,
-0.0017642572,
-0.0278404728,
0.0093958536,
0.0160630513,
0.0111763095,
-0.0014907342,
0.0124666626,
-0.0127283651,
0.0184628349,
0.0156030906,
0.0000626696,
0.0080261808,
-0.0055686906,
0.0363912396,
0.0096209059,
0.001282963,
0.0061036772,
0.0004779745,
0.030103961,
-0.0409018956,
-0.0142874978,
0.0209335051,
0.0241145547,
-0.0386928357,
0.0206494275,
-0.0283278655,
-0.0187892336,
-0.0560485274,
-0.0375605486,
0.0387425385,
-0.0409921631,
0.0337076038,
-0.0040616491,
-0.0010351364,
-0.0403880179,
0.003498788,
-0.0200254712,
0.0159591753,
0.0440975763,
0.0245961975,
-0.0324477293,
0.0749415234,
0.0740510747,
0.0183361024,
0.0279929861,
0.0418741554,
0.0352000818,
-0.0267330185,
-0.0417323709,
0.036378704,
0.0337627269,
-0.0286105573,
-0.0022148129,
-0.0334060267,
-0.113479726,
0.0206218138,
0.0209582932,
-0.0232530888,
0.0111429906,
0.0434103459,
0.0188978221,
0.0129283182,
0.0553592443,
0.0070648515,
-0.0140627231,
0.01280923,
-0.0181758255,
-0.0068333577,
-7.199813267e-33,
-0.0026161636,
-0.0189598165,
0.0033833429,
0.011568971,
0.0080517223,
0.0151481228,
-0.0206679404,
0.0115594137,
0.0017471865,
0.0043857945,
-0.0422651954,
0.0001824148,
0.0183650237,
0.0436843857,
0.0079551777,
0.0388158597,
0.0304981433,
-0.022206597,
-0.0023012008,
0.0087915407,
0.0094995601,
0.0440013334,
0.0256228037,
0.000288854,
-0.012367147,
0.0017859102,
-0.0123863332,
0.0485675596,
0.0297316071,
0.0175475702,
-0.066406101,
0.0180745237,
0.0075610192,
-0.0256434698,
-0.0279962886,
-0.0159355514,
-0.0677344352,
-0.0545026511,
-0.0060748248,
-0.0189249143,
-0.0309478175,
0.0241753832,
0.024552241,
-0.0014243252,
-0.000130083,
-0.0203780923,
0.0159009341,
0.0034032925,
-0.0437719971,
0.0395253971,
-0.0136952121,
0.0357006565,
0.0247839298,
-0.0192909949,
0.0529723577,
-0.0312113874,
0.0110631343,
-0.0133363707,
-0.0575976335,
0.0041749985,
-0.0231817309,
0.0574042425,
0.0416304022,
0.032318864,
0.011421537,
0.0601555705,
-0.0005599697,
-0.060592752,
-0.0259396769,
0.0160935707,
0.0696648285,
-0.0111323595,
0.038262967,
0.0257807225,
0.0754831359,
-0.0251523517,
-0.0792053342,
0.0084790532,
0.0196260847,
0.0186200701,
-0.0015969868,
0.0322102979,
-0.0202640407,
-0.0437436402,
-0.0458829068,
-0.0837405324,
-0.0372397825,
-0.0572521351,
0.0093407826,
0.0370959751,
-0.0445585139,
-0.011825026,
0.0227720048,
-0.0223600306,
-0.0067450255,
0.004759565,
0.0069780247,
0.0005567835,
0.014110731,
0.0362966806,
-0.0589517057,
-0.0042168368,
-0.0074272682,
0.010234124,
0.006978875,
0.0055309772,
0.0386442356,
0.0540566742,
-0.0725366026,
-0.0215123687,
-0.0325634517,
-0.0238585901,
0.0036473158,
0.056147553,
0.0542739332,
-0.0073436825,
0.0110951522,
0.0136864046,
-0.0073244339,
-0.0098444214,
-0.0344697051,
0.0030259374,
0.0159171801,
0.027887946,
-0.0176927708,
-0.000597784,
-0.0154562369,
0.0297509339,
0.0722367838,
-0.0604673512,
-0.0077629499,
0.0317738801,
2.824e-7,
0.0366348438,
0.0146880159,
0.0043051741,
-0.0165892541,
-0.0043851836,
0.0356576294,
-0.0296159815,
0.0231731497,
-0.0373861492,
-0.0311684702,
-0.0204346869,
0.036035426,
0.0382026881,
0.0092976065,
-0.0902507454,
-0.0007303184,
-0.0571694188,
0.0248661153,
-0.0044623963,
-0.0436231606,
-0.005514022,
0.1289810687,
0.0142720994,
-0.0290513728,
-0.005944394,
-0.0079096751,
0.0407576598,
0.006748233,
0.010267009,
-0.0404087268,
-0.0090749906,
0.0305478442,
-0.0342601016,
-0.0058780862,
-0.0402864479,
0.0388055816,
0.0037093665,
0.0600125007,
0.0003749266,
-0.0268460326,
0.0323876701,
0.0032207465,
-0.0187381562,
0.0039682994,
0.0761014372,
-0.0556875654,
-0.0105454512,
-0.0357150622,
-0.0165898334,
0.0088004339,
0.0250460785,
-0.0211768467,
-0.0293615721,
0.0309560709,
0.0253772996,
-0.0076195262,
-0.0429452732,
-0.0866499245,
-0.0297517292,
-0.0130309211,
-0.0186985526,
-0.0150129013,
-0.0317874104,
-0.0061262958,
0.0350524448,
-0.0541624837,
-0.0006171393,
2.760022165e-34,
0.0541041493,
-0.0171092674,
0.019437531,
-0.005866834,
-0.0133164329,
-0.0366079099,
-0.0081920885,
0.0139780305,
0.0146890702,
-0.1044533029,
-0.0342162475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08347v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08347v2 | Reward Engineering for Generating Semi-structured Explanation | 2023-09-15T12:10:03 | 2024-01-24T04:53:13 | Jiuzhou Han, Wray Buntine, Ehsan Shareghi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Semi-structured explanation depicts the implicit process of a reasoner with
an explicit representation. This explanation highlights how available
information in a specific query is utilised and supplemented with information a
reasoner produces from its internal weights towards generating an answer.
Despite the recent improvements in generative capabilities of language models,
producing structured explanations to verify a model's true reasoning
capabilities remains a challenge. This issue is particularly pronounced for
not-so-large LMs (e.g., FLAN-T5-XXL). In this work, we first underscore the
limitations of supervised fine-tuning (SFT) in tackling this challenge, and
then introduce a carefully crafted reward engineering method in reinforcement
learning (RL) to better address this problem. We investigate multiple reward
aggregation methods and provide a detailed discussion which sheds light on the
promising potential of RL for future research. Our proposed method on two
semi-structured explanation generation benchmarks (ExplaGraph and COPA-SSE)
achieves new state-of-the-art results. | [
0.0189540517,
0.0241929553,
-0.0152236884,
0.0419951193,
0.0043817014,
0.013820298,
-0.0294953603,
-0.0310223158,
-0.0660152361,
-0.0091874646,
-0.0165343136,
0.0055643544,
-0.0113276588,
0.0384915397,
0.0363003351,
-0.0832247436,
0.0241565071,
-0.0499507077,
0.032176327,
0.0100406408,
-0.0071902606,
0.0376164988,
0.0040560178,
0.0402732939,
0.0386035629,
-0.0196938459,
-0.0552519076,
0.006840338,
0.0181127973,
-0.0108705014,
-0.0081173908,
0.0009884418,
0.0140933115,
0.0384374671,
0.000002238,
-0.0329730771,
-0.0485773273,
0.0015151834,
-0.0529906638,
0.024654096,
-0.051739689,
-0.0194598921,
0.0065026851,
0.0169783831,
-0.0107596628,
0.0039884606,
0.0531453565,
0.0668572411,
0.071489498,
0.0813798308,
0.0202721413,
-0.0439883657,
0.005583798,
-0.0319760218,
0.0459163934,
-0.0453381464,
-0.0189981293,
0.0154254669,
0.0266398303,
-0.0026465904,
-0.0087927487,
0.0013682113,
0.0481561348,
-0.0550668649,
0.0174143035,
0.0357255861,
0.0133740492,
-0.0031943128,
-0.0077458168,
0.0549879074,
-0.0165872164,
-0.0022681344,
0.00810125,
-0.0345744342,
0.0013064698,
0.0061586797,
-0.0358644463,
0.0301618464,
0.0098883053,
0.0330244601,
0.0730685741,
0.008416228,
0.0542776734,
0.018845534,
-0.0420394428,
0.0577003174,
-0.0272324961,
-0.0158910099,
-0.0425160415,
-0.016757898,
-0.0230426062,
-0.0755642727,
-0.047889635,
0.0825738907,
-0.0727064535,
-0.0106113777,
0.0232116766,
-0.004682228,
-0.0038499907,
0.0400721096,
0.0453156941,
0.0342222974,
0.0196097381,
0.050129313,
-0.0386202782,
0.0489174798,
-0.0116313733,
0.0610019751,
-0.0546133183,
0.0034196044,
-0.0604232885,
-0.0147943059,
-0.0251550376,
0.03338347,
-0.0484941229,
0.0079257097,
-0.0448359475,
0.0310416836,
-0.032280378,
0.0195113271,
0.0085979784,
0.0331914201,
-0.0135306865,
-0.0086805299,
-0.0551633351,
0.0083181942,
-0.0915856883,
0.0122842155,
0.0480150022,
-0.0100850482,
-0.0368663296,
-0.0011151696,
0.0005191782,
-0.0338159762,
-0.0265033469,
0.0708842874,
-0.0272462387,
-0.0096142981,
-0.0311051402,
-0.0926040784,
-0.0147982305,
-0.0660990551,
-0.0154819554,
-0.0331171826,
0.0053011072,
-0.0376182385,
-0.0188903678,
0.0020741324,
-0.0153818941,
-0.0222071446,
-0.0138857709,
0.0696996897,
-0.0047324011,
0.0186386816,
-0.0141522447,
0.0252885539,
-0.0057331892,
0.0670680553,
0.0350817367,
0.0358842686,
-0.0091364691,
-0.0187536106,
0.0065346542,
-0.0202711802,
0.0570156649,
-0.0026720704,
-0.0180768967,
-0.0016005595,
-0.0337432995,
0.0178440195,
0.0149189029,
0.0179401208,
-0.0445268266,
0.0301998463,
-0.0100244964,
0.0220959764,
0.0562611707,
-0.0230037365,
0.0470837355,
-0.0099697718,
0.0031208766,
0.0338613577,
-0.0499500483,
0.0533202477,
-0.033080209,
0.0220780391,
0.0543066785,
-0.0210923254,
-0.0510236137,
-0.0731011629,
0.0230239369,
-0.0008634879,
0.0131532159,
0.0283552725,
0.0495796576,
0.0242223497,
-0.030300241,
-0.0020735231,
0.0273230541,
-0.0210568663,
0.0210956,
-0.090521127,
0.0869933143,
0.0814205185,
0.059984941,
-0.0332048871,
-0.0219376534,
-0.0054464312,
-0.029097395,
0.0287458207,
0.0291963108,
-0.0366969444,
0.0208609086,
-0.0234303698,
-0.0478968024,
-0.0658614933,
0.0313973911,
0.021238938,
0.0055512916,
-0.0633177608,
0.0184673332,
-0.0388677344,
-0.0315975994,
0.0332677551,
0.0130473785,
-0.0435233228,
0.0444982797,
0.0095870467,
-0.00813781,
0.0352124125,
0.0041782558,
0.0387396999,
0.0200480577,
0.0032313848,
-0.0111127133,
-0.0029005492,
-0.0339620896,
-0.0373504907,
0.0081084613,
-0.0175137352,
-0.0144019155,
-0.0129430983,
-0.0500999615,
-0.079834938,
0.0234623216,
-0.0116784405,
0.0374430194,
-0.0361174643,
0.0034887693,
-0.0008731221,
-0.0030612664,
-0.0595983081,
0.0607087575,
0.0124268495,
0.0001848916,
-0.0119642103,
-0.0093514249,
0.0024170373,
-0.039107088,
0.0290205013,
0.0069453595,
-0.0094091464,
0.0133619113,
0.0278251506,
0.0064164177,
-0.0397776216,
-0.041769743,
-0.0007228142,
-0.0142197814,
-0.0287616663,
-0.0061245901,
0.0309523679,
0.0150296008,
0.0198828205,
-0.0099042356,
-0.0349371172,
-0.0269136634,
0.0369354449,
0.0156585276,
0.0552286394,
0.0312960111,
-0.0256677102,
-0.0369156823,
-0.0203344859,
-0.0227463078,
0.032363534,
0.0240111146,
0.0662491247,
-0.062208131,
-0.0252217967,
-0.0333640985,
-0.0261453297,
-0.0246351138,
-0.0407774076,
0.0368505605,
-0.0348800234,
-0.0030735203,
0.0621492825,
0.0202671401,
0.0428639911,
0.0492713973,
0.0186068974,
-0.0584461689,
0.0294128601,
-0.0381658599,
-0.0397434309,
-0.0086445278,
-0.0157632772,
0.005670812,
0.0824561641,
-0.0282024443,
0.0017534454,
-0.0894162357,
0.0566367283,
0.0381359756,
-0.0230871029,
-0.036256589,
-0.011786486,
-0.0012280372,
0.0814413503,
-0.0390390493,
-0.0636827573,
0.093238607,
-0.0157534387,
0.0080984393,
-0.0124525158,
-0.0264188126,
-0.035766013,
0.0460570753,
-0.0132211214,
0.0246449988,
0.029789336,
-0.0195711851,
-0.0230354164,
-0.0644607618,
0.0551298931,
0.0007757777,
0.0610164516,
-0.0206767209,
-0.0180221237,
-0.0011641931,
-0.0224602036,
-0.0467703305,
-0.038397789,
-0.0164468456,
0.0299198162,
0.0068455557,
-0.0406131335,
-0.0015588811,
-0.0253770445,
0.0386007652,
-0.0052835941,
-0.0258276798,
-0.0176795013,
-0.0227564275,
-0.0135328406,
0.0475352183,
0.0537017435,
0.0498461574,
-0.0582081862,
0.0390599556,
0.0138098337,
0.0443042479,
-0.0134087279,
0.0012527064,
0.0165873729,
0.0040890663,
-0.0387185961,
-0.0082856156,
0.0512464419,
0.0677208006,
-0.0685926378,
0.0035538045,
0.128033936,
0.0393149033,
-0.020007059,
0.0077656042,
-0.0258828644,
0.0616303533,
0.0168047082,
0.0500605367,
-0.0629195422,
-0.032693103,
0.0056771804,
0.0364645347,
-0.0038768712,
-0.0169220883,
0.0010345334,
-0.0999591723,
0.0305285081,
0.007060552,
-0.0341357142,
-0.0088809505,
-0.0298259314,
-0.01679416,
0.0077547352,
-0.028205229,
0.0460480005,
0.0052034156,
-0.0027078656,
0.0319751203,
0.0069747479,
-0.022625912,
0.0297595169,
-0.0222927742,
0.035957966,
0.0717200041,
0.029675249,
0.0002634138,
-0.0520860553,
0.0024621524,
-0.0059669884,
0.034099292,
0.0005137064,
0.0531077422,
0.018261712,
-0.017160533,
-0.0004442076,
0.0544889085,
-0.0229223333,
-0.0246843137,
-0.0252329186,
0.0983803272,
-0.0140440697,
0.0089057684,
-0.0016856035,
-0.0194888469,
-0.0081449319,
0.0654413402,
0.047006987,
-0.0037393568,
-0.0636829436,
-0.05606566,
-0.0283631105,
-0.0582844652,
0.0052111438,
0.0079396907,
0.0151089039,
0.0027984586,
-0.052408848,
-0.0551423952,
0.0068793814,
0.0372922309,
-0.0274648722,
-0.0002237248,
-0.0159940906,
-0.0306290183,
-0.0341072455,
0.0302211381,
-0.0219284296,
0.030736573,
-0.0269133653,
-0.0232867599,
-0.0262807999,
-0.0547931045,
0.0056468258,
-0.0289779771,
0.0048133838,
-0.0606119558,
-0.0404756367,
0.0339219049,
0.0207214803,
0.0616323054,
-0.0493096448,
-0.0402927548,
0.0349087454,
0.0100180767,
-0.0490633398,
-0.0352219194,
0.0572309792,
-0.0231043622,
-0.0088495836,
0.0516413376,
-0.0544234104,
0.0063271029,
0.0022928482,
0.0293605831,
-0.0057397047,
0.0161804389,
0.0457520038,
0.0111124525,
0.0253790822,
-0.0198840722,
-0.0199230742,
-0.0204359815,
0.008467651,
-0.0414942987,
-0.0469359607,
-0.0177663751,
0.0000798204,
0.0073623047,
-0.0456217043,
0.025286667,
-0.0155193508,
-0.0036395418,
0.0350537151,
-0.0204238929,
0.0156305768,
0.0013901069,
-0.0134789618,
-0.0088532381,
0.0240943842,
0.0308958311,
0.0200575106,
0.0085438443,
0.0763177201,
0.0078685731,
0.0615524128,
0.0402391441,
0.0521660633,
-0.058693178,
0.0084957229,
-0.0920819044,
-0.0678436607,
0.0206949636,
-0.0151380775,
0.0534868203,
-0.0089725694,
0.0564486943,
0.0212459583,
-0.0197482202,
0.012412833,
0.0461486578,
0.0154848173,
-0.0227767751,
0.0291667692,
0.0483851247,
0.0005790569,
-0.0401595496,
0.064955622,
-0.0187219158,
0.0406670347,
-0.0046925205,
0.0101377433,
-0.0260712802,
-0.0082368329,
-0.0185944289,
0.0551335476,
-0.0071717012,
0.004458542,
-0.037916135,
-0.0738623738,
-0.0404361524,
0.0661143661,
0.0049116001,
-0.014103014,
0.0325485952,
0.0218179617,
0.0027740318,
-0.0173160098,
-0.0565405376,
-0.0198512636,
-0.0175618306,
0.0043504531,
0.005883194,
-6.819523212e-33,
-0.0403853953,
-0.037792068,
0.035659641,
-0.0098565482,
-0.0143131157,
0.0210223291,
-0.0672654361,
0.000219579,
-0.0171516631,
0.0522545688,
-0.0146462135,
0.007721446,
-0.0098030269,
0.0197552424,
-0.0028794697,
-0.0460269786,
0.0314679854,
0.0173306931,
-0.0612072907,
0.036884021,
0.0313314795,
-0.0380898714,
0.0119834365,
-0.0369486958,
0.0479906201,
0.0527585223,
-0.0456096865,
0.0412618704,
-0.0568644851,
0.0786396563,
-0.0023036874,
0.0101062143,
0.0154077876,
-0.0233849902,
-0.0224974137,
-0.0022806649,
-0.080419898,
-0.0288856849,
0.0445931256,
-0.0325184017,
-0.08457122,
-0.0485730171,
0.0328299068,
0.0070286612,
0.0241744164,
-0.0251006708,
0.0141864363,
-0.0025254632,
-0.0073295147,
-0.0183143392,
-0.0270023439,
0.0214098338,
-0.052634187,
-0.053286057,
0.0324883237,
0.011048303,
0.0009134604,
0.0247572046,
-0.0012077147,
0.0087653147,
0.0729780048,
0.0244563837,
0.0516096763,
0.0412901267,
-0.013113495,
0.0470534973,
0.001736288,
0.0090057058,
-0.0620972067,
0.0225010887,
-0.008943107,
0.0664135814,
0.052291397,
-0.0014988976,
0.0371743143,
0.0422588736,
-0.0615135878,
0.0522884838,
-0.0223163869,
0.0497061685,
0.0190802775,
0.027182322,
-0.0346391872,
-0.0327091068,
-0.0796099529,
0.0099593196,
-0.0463572629,
-0.021576805,
0.0049776244,
0.0255970061,
-0.0509608462,
-0.0445689894,
-0.0183158312,
-0.0568338186,
0.0295733493,
0.0345612802,
-0.0344170183,
0.0053792698,
-0.0002963489,
-0.0122210877,
-0.0298313275,
-0.0089151505,
0.017809758,
-0.0050775949,
-0.0025813389,
0.035429094,
0.0355740376,
0.0198457893,
-0.0225668009,
0.0246116463,
-0.0595144294,
0.0094730239,
-0.0566805713,
-0.0345308632,
0.0352594666,
0.0172387734,
-0.0311515927,
0.0199978203,
0.0048689526,
0.0074341474,
-0.0161952246,
0.0233431086,
0.0014861833,
0.0345815122,
-0.0000040286,
0.0068020765,
-0.030202914,
-0.0257312674,
0.0625755563,
-0.0347409248,
-0.0270244945,
0.0269217286,
2.868e-7,
0.0205832813,
0.0092165405,
0.0500808321,
0.0486055724,
0.0186672788,
0.0630038828,
0.0064624776,
-0.0330844782,
0.013336557,
-0.005863098,
-0.0129577713,
0.0556685403,
0.0275630001,
0.0255928449,
-0.0100746248,
0.0235494357,
-0.0528507307,
-0.0197012965,
-0.0177386459,
-0.0138233267,
0.0592635609,
0.0514919907,
0.0079872571,
-0.0039509134,
0.0221050177,
-0.0147522297,
0.0323504023,
-0.0012394601,
-0.0153753897,
0.0299652517,
-0.0001035835,
0.0222526621,
0.035123419,
-0.0055593434,
-0.0038526114,
0.0204561669,
-0.050544586,
0.0419398583,
-0.022067016,
-0.0403210074,
-0.0382025018,
-0.034749072,
0.0455258228,
-0.0456496701,
0.0714179501,
-0.0468391106,
-0.0406126343,
0.0121416682,
-0.015052516,
-0.0327335708,
-0.0016266437,
-0.0177634358,
-0.0289031286,
0.0301531814,
-0.010222435,
-0.0016051418,
0.0247444939,
-0.1085909382,
-0.0571427569,
0.0601319931,
0.0111078899,
0.017549213,
-0.0235178955,
0.0238537919,
0.021730816,
-0.059705317,
-0.0337390304,
2.5973264e-34,
0.0260692742,
-0.010609217,
0.0134571763,
0.0240858719,
0.0672076717,
0.0213360321,
-0.0439679101,
-0.010318554,
0.0984038264,
-0.0521886721,
-0.0312780291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08345v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08345v3 | Data Distribution Bottlenecks in Grounding Language Models to Knowledge Bases | 2023-09-15T12:06:45 | 2024-02-09T07:09:27 | Yiheng Shu, Zhiwei Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language models (LMs) have already demonstrated remarkable abilities in
understanding and generating both natural and formal language. Despite these
advances, their integration with real-world environments such as large-scale
knowledge bases (KBs) remains an underdeveloped area, affecting applications
such as semantic parsing and indulging in "hallucinated" information. This
paper is an experimental investigation aimed at uncovering the robustness
challenges that LMs encounter when tasked with knowledge base question
answering (KBQA). The investigation covers scenarios with inconsistent data
distribution between training and inference, such as generalization to unseen
domains, adaptation to various language variations, and transferability across
different datasets. Our comprehensive experiments reveal that even when
employed with our proposed data augmentation techniques, advanced small and
large language models exhibit poor performance in various dimensions. While the
LM is a promising technology, the robustness of the current form in dealing
with complex environments is fragile and of limited practicality because of the
data distribution issue. This calls for future research on data collection and
LM learning paradims. | [
0.0737755671,
0.0544222072,
-0.0120036434,
0.0656513348,
-0.0261570979,
0.0002949231,
-0.0030743869,
-0.0269986354,
-0.0137073919,
-0.0536776632,
-0.012519137,
-0.0122269485,
-0.0263651665,
0.0070259324,
0.0268295668,
-0.0251556132,
0.0225103218,
-0.0321964733,
-0.0226244368,
-0.0361230522,
-0.0018729725,
0.0131276101,
-0.0036275738,
-0.0273663569,
0.0093304124,
0.0044539706,
-0.0083733182,
-0.0135062607,
-0.0052483319,
-0.0041002743,
0.0148119228,
0.0378776118,
0.0543930829,
0.0457494147,
0.0000017684,
-0.0381150879,
0.0165057387,
-0.0019981107,
-0.0662963316,
0.0219408311,
-0.0020998502,
-0.0452325195,
0.0103557371,
0.0053993687,
-0.0616657026,
-0.044389721,
0.0238640979,
0.0371935852,
0.0594592243,
0.048408106,
0.0095503991,
-0.038322594,
0.0292061269,
-0.0134911053,
0.0087315682,
-0.0251332335,
0.0591620468,
0.0429610945,
0.0304608587,
0.0165847298,
-0.0256573167,
0.0321408324,
0.0215571821,
0.0323635824,
0.0034347659,
0.0447346643,
-0.0616332404,
0.0250427816,
0.0090132942,
0.1039887667,
0.0165567435,
-0.0143404165,
-0.0257303528,
-0.0019879956,
-0.0008784154,
0.0221378338,
-0.0425046571,
0.027284082,
-0.0014345646,
0.0038189765,
-0.0223651957,
-0.0139987255,
0.0538344048,
0.0416967161,
-0.0607907288,
0.1071096212,
0.0184367225,
-0.0427414924,
0.0028504764,
0.0286294632,
-0.0578775182,
-0.0207527522,
0.0051450091,
0.0508861355,
0.0044257725,
0.0521246828,
-0.0332273766,
-0.013162503,
0.0364675187,
-0.0638705492,
-0.000839486,
0.0234405193,
-0.0312652774,
0.0700552166,
-0.0361664891,
0.0297750738,
-0.0373719633,
0.0319664367,
-0.0435537025,
-0.0254705083,
-0.0440042764,
-0.0371539667,
-0.0226831809,
0.0515631661,
-0.0431601815,
-0.025317248,
-0.0056335768,
0.0454172827,
-0.0065279421,
-0.0095864357,
0.0018553898,
0.0407848656,
-0.0021526732,
0.0048194923,
-0.0571711399,
0.0382029302,
-0.0646488145,
0.0539920218,
-0.0165810324,
-0.0615569167,
-0.013691741,
0.0023393657,
0.015753435,
-0.0459731333,
0.0229122024,
0.0462198406,
0.0199267101,
-0.0053775138,
-0.0671741292,
-0.0133373206,
-0.0291821193,
-0.046083387,
0.0150193591,
-0.0745279565,
0.0722397491,
0.0225304812,
-0.0302190222,
-0.0423176698,
0.0118269324,
-0.0037558163,
-0.0601946935,
0.0761917755,
-0.0223358274,
-0.000067105,
0.0421149619,
0.0032819889,
-0.0181371961,
0.0910774544,
0.0224614851,
-0.0347064659,
0.045504529,
0.0003410806,
0.0017322067,
0.0240258407,
0.0556468405,
0.0432267748,
-0.0100713996,
0.0442281291,
-0.0188769605,
0.0235001519,
0.0466008335,
0.0395578779,
-0.0241023954,
-0.0394506417,
0.0380949304,
0.0284814537,
-0.0197959598,
0.0072869882,
0.0342884399,
-0.0141892144,
0.0047547226,
0.0154523617,
-0.0489359051,
-0.0307962522,
-0.0417440422,
0.0355791897,
-0.0090551749,
0.0199599434,
-0.0536443666,
-0.020246394,
-0.0155976797,
0.0143407313,
0.0190168209,
0.0356063247,
0.0644358099,
0.0172651578,
0.0122472737,
0.068648085,
0.0400582068,
0.0019693947,
0.0372447036,
-0.0285305846,
0.026938023,
0.0580990687,
0.0432524495,
-0.0279500037,
-0.020638464,
-0.0012375438,
0.0540491641,
0.045114655,
0.0093342457,
-0.0160473082,
0.0105642872,
-0.0121098021,
-0.0266480241,
-0.0147531144,
0.0146957673,
0.0129515463,
0.0326087326,
0.0219120737,
0.0308431424,
-0.0911431536,
0.0105302418,
0.0381112136,
-0.0439304449,
-0.0079152565,
-0.010279513,
-0.0138446819,
-0.0005836962,
0.0145957842,
-0.0303982254,
0.0014107564,
0.047260128,
-0.040870335,
-0.039919626,
-0.0160384644,
-0.0055784979,
-0.052476868,
0.055816751,
-0.0196360089,
0.0091877962,
0.0139718633,
-0.0643468425,
-0.0304490849,
0.0334853381,
-0.0205956642,
0.0520548858,
-0.0396632329,
-0.0055392054,
0.014102757,
0.0271610711,
-0.0436143987,
0.0737958178,
-0.0249293875,
0.0321565792,
-0.0192256458,
0.0397347212,
0.0300802849,
-0.0438937955,
-0.0104863476,
-0.0147904363,
-0.0054400587,
0.0142065184,
-0.0065741604,
-0.0450914428,
-0.043585483,
0.0169475377,
-0.0840048864,
-0.0021279294,
-0.0116731972,
0.0265473519,
0.0198142864,
0.0304340404,
-0.0178516563,
-0.0249605365,
-0.0488447286,
-0.0107116848,
0.0448863618,
0.0463623665,
0.0434204489,
0.0423519686,
-0.0203791466,
-0.016827751,
-0.0187022816,
-0.0095637906,
0.0636285916,
-0.0205480624,
0.0027443701,
-0.0701904297,
0.0123887323,
-0.069079645,
0.060934633,
-0.0079637393,
-0.0082745925,
-0.0219919477,
-0.0155749824,
0.0080957357,
0.0406989343,
-0.0179699752,
-0.0132672405,
0.0696538612,
0.0191944279,
-0.0633209646,
0.0076319645,
-0.005672209,
-0.0071421191,
-0.0326654352,
-0.0149047766,
-0.0206487644,
0.036672689,
0.0152741773,
-0.0222991277,
-0.0229235291,
0.0421637483,
-0.0045857644,
-0.0022029332,
-0.0561066456,
0.0263403878,
-0.0028572234,
0.0432579294,
-0.0445224047,
-0.016018061,
0.0714010745,
-0.0251220185,
-0.0056739128,
-0.0363141522,
-0.0072532534,
-0.0220709648,
0.0237030052,
0.0022074794,
0.0062377648,
-0.0574242622,
-0.008072501,
-0.048122827,
-0.0222212002,
0.0022807755,
-0.0306438804,
0.0361817256,
-0.0519511513,
0.0288220365,
-0.0169391483,
-0.0116512096,
-0.0573691577,
-0.0267064013,
-0.0392348245,
0.0142821083,
-0.0007576397,
0.0015498487,
0.0140812537,
0.0059347241,
0.0215020683,
0.0305284206,
-0.016896775,
0.0001581579,
-0.0249831099,
0.0337645076,
0.0798511803,
0.0375001505,
0.0231627245,
0.0147210648,
0.0009385391,
0.0257895663,
0.0277490038,
0.0031819711,
-0.0179019738,
0.0226696339,
0.0073730294,
-0.014263981,
-0.0068190168,
-0.0058541,
0.0051706932,
-0.0219083373,
-0.0207376946,
0.1024957597,
0.0288398042,
0.0079154419,
0.0056362492,
-0.0286860447,
0.0249382202,
0.0264348276,
0.0435370542,
-0.0991747975,
-0.0106521286,
-0.0316912308,
0.032137461,
0.0121564548,
-0.0355041623,
0.0036812157,
-0.1459115297,
0.0001174351,
-0.0182109568,
-0.0736677572,
-0.0833078995,
-0.061605975,
0.018426979,
0.0035742407,
0.0522299595,
0.0004208421,
-0.0022683307,
-0.0023807876,
0.0322772264,
-0.0091247987,
-0.0878282115,
0.0104386443,
-0.0698823258,
0.0521708839,
0.058700759,
-0.0050346442,
-0.0154390903,
-0.0195254683,
-0.0291301738,
0.0058517763,
-0.0081851315,
0.0032791053,
0.0399197675,
0.0032755297,
-0.0076397764,
-0.0029069365,
0.0124663962,
-0.0728917643,
0.0262586735,
0.0396519154,
0.1058323234,
-0.0122771934,
-0.0114748217,
0.0053079408,
-0.0053994562,
-0.0013875637,
0.1025743783,
0.0077438415,
-0.0255901422,
-0.0303300228,
-0.0149056828,
-0.0420024842,
-0.0282704756,
-0.0065724445,
0.0677741915,
-0.0090146344,
0.0080578728,
-0.076043345,
-0.040401876,
0.0455796458,
0.0507743359,
0.0003394087,
0.0319147743,
-0.0143032223,
0.0115283802,
-0.025654247,
0.035643734,
-0.0484493747,
-0.0040195361,
-0.0240221079,
-0.0182489865,
0.0057435022,
-0.0480352454,
-0.0296733882,
-0.0119085852,
-0.0673040226,
-0.0713887215,
0.024501998,
0.02443734,
0.0288503692,
0.0630386099,
-0.030551374,
-0.0210336484,
0.0540540144,
0.0212222859,
-0.058280807,
0.0342618376,
0.028475279,
-0.0212270506,
0.01632002,
0.0324307457,
-0.0821516141,
-0.0037326431,
0.0428510718,
0.0497917235,
-0.0390391499,
-0.024251882,
0.0204729661,
0.006605471,
-0.0083512422,
0.0197820663,
-0.0345989689,
-0.0088549191,
0.0368938111,
-0.0205820668,
-0.0215761848,
-0.0314601101,
-0.0220624823,
0.0332883596,
-0.0082678432,
0.0084919948,
-0.0211392604,
-0.0326505676,
0.0584175177,
-0.0157736074,
-0.0229626745,
0.0533807762,
0.0085808784,
0.0533845052,
-0.0093378695,
-0.0277279355,
0.0009774651,
-0.0001899984,
0.0448044799,
-0.0048602596,
0.0179559607,
0.0149213467,
-0.0387877934,
-0.0527633578,
-0.0099151321,
-0.0766362697,
-0.0535428748,
-0.0219320226,
0.0379153453,
0.0396964811,
-0.0169284046,
0.0129104918,
-0.0177075695,
-0.0251019299,
-0.0037260992,
-0.0253797509,
0.0100571709,
0.0114939651,
0.0771537721,
0.0368637703,
-0.0148577131,
0.0382907502,
0.0759576634,
0.0535325743,
0.081423223,
-0.0177835971,
-0.0065438729,
-0.0099782543,
-0.0307575595,
-0.0142463259,
0.0153898578,
-0.0388249457,
0.0299789533,
-0.0452116169,
-0.0997744724,
-0.0125222495,
-0.0168363955,
-0.045627594,
-0.0256832875,
0.0295519251,
0.0564576313,
0.0367316566,
0.0028088116,
-0.0129504409,
0.0374562517,
-0.0186345261,
-0.016263973,
-0.0228886362,
-6.138766516e-33,
-0.0264364854,
0.0126513615,
0.0189774875,
-0.0551293306,
-0.0213622693,
-0.0094066048,
-0.0158301946,
0.0089438874,
-0.064298138,
0.0032978742,
-0.0312096067,
0.0207064506,
0.0091581997,
0.0549382009,
-0.0028743453,
-0.0407981798,
0.0015260663,
0.0054748827,
-0.0013078367,
-0.0057958914,
0.0278998204,
0.0471271724,
0.0431654565,
-0.0495962016,
0.0178485923,
-0.0409701578,
0.0285232179,
0.0470212139,
-0.0144238584,
0.0729089603,
-0.0324259438,
0.0700928196,
0.0308011565,
-0.0457781218,
-0.0123500358,
-0.0062926118,
-0.1053438485,
-0.0163081978,
0.0389386863,
0.0345714018,
-0.0103083272,
0.008475394,
0.0473758727,
-0.010300884,
0.0537799783,
0.011772492,
0.027596388,
-0.0675473288,
-0.0334736444,
0.0049833269,
-0.0363266692,
0.0101179034,
0.0238437187,
0.0198372304,
-0.0337696038,
0.0202254262,
-0.0101978891,
0.0096447803,
-0.0469326451,
-0.0168842897,
0.0560731515,
0.0221186616,
0.0630000159,
0.0418968089,
0.0038974741,
0.0218904503,
-0.0131946402,
-0.0200244766,
-0.0314913541,
-0.0256774612,
0.0075987838,
-0.0047432273,
0.0246458929,
0.0619231127,
0.0319532268,
0.03661016,
-0.0662912279,
-0.0083151925,
0.0176810548,
0.001042898,
0.0004262303,
-0.0111725405,
-0.0319005288,
-0.0391716249,
-0.0213758256,
0.0342399031,
-0.0224720649,
-0.0522814803,
0.0256736074,
0.0080734296,
-0.0320167802,
0.0084113525,
0.0111672878,
-0.0617599823,
-0.0411684252,
0.0736964047,
0.0194773581,
-0.0101225469,
0.0112024331,
0.0358378477,
-0.0395965055,
-0.0154177155,
0.0180717036,
-0.0146383177,
-0.0352610797,
0.0285262801,
0.0140142376,
-0.0259869695,
-0.0449793749,
-0.0077813864,
-0.0345686786,
0.0006022316,
-0.012546205,
0.0407562219,
0.0300115738,
0.0323686488,
-0.0040826835,
0.0264196303,
0.0417879149,
-0.0100163398,
0.0044559333,
-0.0142360926,
-0.0090814847,
0.0086876592,
-0.049124077,
-0.0264915228,
-0.0242694467,
0.0080306577,
-0.0015894872,
-0.0734474137,
-0.001461109,
-0.0084188385,
2.573e-7,
0.0763880983,
-0.0083531477,
0.0181273408,
0.0216747653,
0.0169369914,
-0.0204514172,
0.0018942263,
0.028293062,
0.0072186007,
-0.0698155761,
-0.004896434,
0.0467461534,
0.0048283078,
0.0260927975,
-0.0844240785,
-0.0321171544,
-0.0323684439,
-0.0027807609,
-0.0417663269,
-0.0283752829,
0.0232113227,
0.1109439284,
0.0311520398,
-0.013829018,
-0.0031051866,
-0.0638563782,
0.0383737944,
-0.0008436031,
0.0282055959,
-0.0045789434,
0.0303193051,
0.023139419,
0.0178298187,
0.0811839178,
0.0077013765,
0.0343059711,
-0.0188404974,
0.0393438004,
-0.0153293172,
-0.0027261439,
-0.0371546969,
-0.0642270371,
0.0332718603,
-0.0417814143,
0.1143575907,
-0.0571404397,
0.0007416693,
0.0232535526,
-0.0193574708,
-0.0296126083,
-0.0142840007,
-0.0353986472,
0.0080265319,
-0.0177727565,
0.0171736516,
-0.0125673143,
0.003648245,
-0.0789167881,
0.0185688417,
0.0321661867,
-0.0556408986,
-0.0633131564,
-0.0135585414,
-0.0113171134,
0.039821133,
-0.0493784174,
0.0286682546,
2.305245671e-34,
0.0244961549,
0.0315876231,
0.0096636135,
0.0328521691,
0.0228286553,
-0.0218573213,
0.0070695463,
-0.017703848,
0.0391497388,
-0.0727893487,
0.0176797081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08325v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08325v2 | Distributional Inclusion Hypothesis and Quantifications: Probing for Hypernymy in Functional Distributional Semantics | 2023-09-15T11:28:52 | 2024-02-10T17:57:14 | Chun Hei Lo, Wai Lam, Hong Cheng, Guy Emerson | cs.CL | cs.CL | Functional Distributional Semantics (FDS) models the meaning of words by
truth-conditional functions. This provides a natural representation for
hypernymy but no guarantee that it can be learnt when FDS models are trained on
a corpus. In this paper, we probe into FDS models and study the representations
learnt, drawing connections between quantifications, the Distributional
Inclusion Hypothesis (DIH), and the variational-autoencoding objective of FDS
model training. Using synthetic data sets, we reveal that FDS models learn
hypernymy on a restricted class of corpus that strictly follows the DIH. We
further introduce a training objective that both enables hypernymy learning
under the reverse of the DIH and improves hypernymy detection from real
corpora. | [
0.0259314273,
0.0987320915,
-0.0301166642,
0.0340397321,
-0.0151602728,
0.0076306807,
-0.090630874,
-0.0100119598,
-0.0274573397,
-0.0513373762,
-0.0166810974,
-0.0492081232,
-0.0294407345,
0.0377771407,
0.0434199311,
-0.0111405794,
0.1122908369,
0.0576862358,
-0.0421766527,
-0.0356647521,
-0.0298599675,
-0.0266609062,
-0.0130407885,
-0.0229765531,
-0.0363790765,
0.0549959801,
0.0061959294,
-0.0282337088,
0.0067102606,
0.0050575994,
-0.0088387337,
0.0133703016,
0.0425992273,
0.0314840004,
0.0000014968,
-0.0788734332,
-0.0268701129,
-0.0223330893,
-0.0293420497,
-0.0491016731,
0.0288368296,
-0.0412747934,
-0.0123140374,
-0.0420177095,
0.0017837024,
-0.030390406,
0.0515830703,
0.0080705285,
0.0073233387,
0.0332599469,
0.0014807932,
-0.029300563,
0.0818778574,
-0.0207066964,
0.041156292,
0.0043923957,
0.0317687541,
0.0263029728,
-0.026733106,
-0.0269584544,
-0.0448381528,
0.0356969722,
0.0312549621,
0.0538689196,
-0.0327058658,
0.0251945462,
-0.0413410738,
-0.012780048,
-0.0063014645,
0.0122106662,
-0.002873885,
-0.0370890014,
-0.0059878724,
0.0176927783,
-0.0085452739,
0.0778604597,
0.0070881071,
0.0292189587,
-0.0033846209,
0.0075095547,
0.0429839306,
-0.0081468206,
0.0614360273,
0.0393050946,
-0.0498800017,
0.0966758355,
0.0400115922,
-0.0478600822,
0.0250149053,
0.0090529723,
-0.0742232427,
0.0074413228,
-0.0096878493,
-0.0024150251,
0.0246594939,
0.0258602798,
-0.0164740104,
-0.0208119992,
0.0382260531,
-0.0453442633,
-0.0354226679,
0.0055000256,
-0.0284490976,
0.0211581066,
-0.0503899157,
-0.001258938,
-0.0184171144,
0.050159011,
-0.0431504659,
-0.0113376332,
-0.0376556888,
-0.038861867,
-0.0233008862,
0.0572691336,
-0.0076633547,
-0.0133917816,
-0.0230490956,
0.0190065894,
-0.015737243,
0.0296241026,
-0.0013392408,
-0.0173879433,
-0.0770620108,
0.0436406881,
-0.0272332672,
0.0047799647,
-0.049910292,
0.0470778681,
-0.0206754748,
0.0025084559,
-0.0133712217,
0.0009384432,
0.0188337881,
-0.0155543042,
0.0179273151,
0.0666600987,
0.0678125247,
-0.0343266949,
0.0047988798,
-0.0072109685,
-0.0201808829,
-0.0258643553,
0.0174271632,
-0.0438027084,
-0.0322725289,
-0.0367092825,
0.0317827649,
0.0026656794,
0.0000925047,
-0.0314484984,
0.0093333693,
0.0688323006,
-0.0170534886,
-0.0258242805,
0.0090252124,
-0.0276514404,
0.0138017694,
0.0600720756,
0.000452347,
-0.0281827282,
0.0421669483,
0.022075275,
-0.035074126,
-0.0000861455,
0.0346851908,
0.0037692462,
-0.0136153512,
-0.0203576703,
-0.0190473627,
0.0409070589,
0.0304837283,
0.0142597454,
-0.0266598929,
-0.0529345386,
0.0179718193,
0.0281328,
0.036723353,
-0.073786296,
0.0463424809,
-0.0093555124,
-0.0054444131,
0.0606857724,
-0.075513348,
-0.0329196341,
-0.0106675858,
0.0455108508,
-0.0527026467,
0.0206859205,
-0.0158694591,
-0.0209152624,
0.0062715504,
-0.0269924738,
-0.0107216183,
-0.0216079913,
0.0594449192,
0.0519883521,
0.0072157611,
0.0846412852,
0.0754393488,
-0.0482744798,
0.0468875431,
0.0034377787,
0.031792976,
0.012768778,
0.009836439,
-0.053639587,
0.0058139767,
-0.019693369,
-0.0610100441,
0.0111775463,
0.0034953903,
0.0011177189,
0.0101982299,
-0.00600531,
0.0039579361,
-0.0112257265,
0.0617435537,
0.0435507223,
-0.0469593257,
-0.024673678,
-0.0134681407,
-0.0434371158,
-0.004366559,
0.0493101068,
-0.0036830942,
-0.0049340622,
-0.0272232108,
0.0382993035,
0.008828993,
0.0149314189,
-0.0322753266,
0.0214055758,
-0.0132816443,
-0.0402076431,
-0.0400076546,
0.02128979,
-0.0136244223,
-0.0586153865,
0.0026473261,
-0.0210647043,
0.0127959037,
0.0747646168,
-0.0207097959,
-0.0153152253,
-0.0071611549,
-0.0400652029,
0.0401806273,
-0.0591102093,
-0.0020360295,
0.0076040123,
-0.0078866472,
-0.014626909,
0.0816392526,
-0.0231196415,
0.0660030171,
-0.0856251568,
0.069258295,
0.049951721,
-0.0238916129,
-0.0361308157,
0.0329014361,
-0.0263949577,
0.0161243659,
-0.0063506826,
-0.0403195284,
-0.0347962752,
0.0048148418,
-0.0237715617,
0.0006324822,
-0.0180164259,
0.0036363201,
0.0155369444,
-0.0182465687,
-0.0082870889,
0.0207884107,
0.0131473504,
0.0101961298,
0.0163060371,
0.044185672,
0.0313124098,
-0.0150942607,
-0.0097800018,
-0.035058327,
-0.0389386043,
-0.0516320355,
0.045925498,
-0.0164330434,
0.0376989283,
0.0334609076,
-0.0179091692,
-0.0731130093,
0.0111911353,
0.0034447052,
-0.0289176479,
-0.0066542625,
0.0339889452,
0.0208996758,
-0.003844128,
-0.0026908226,
0.0076357806,
0.0438241325,
0.0109616918,
-0.0147314006,
-0.0268408041,
-0.0563130938,
-0.039171122,
-0.0180314481,
0.0030147012,
0.0024107655,
0.0688925534,
0.0540707596,
-0.0367362052,
-0.0318024904,
0.0564629361,
-0.0643462613,
-0.0299752988,
-0.0079971543,
0.0104774386,
-0.0520376526,
0.0390194952,
-0.0472967513,
-0.027287228,
0.064592734,
-0.0005074769,
0.0183913019,
-0.025507506,
0.0012810496,
0.0026473794,
0.0391754769,
0.0293774139,
0.0261611119,
0.0506643094,
-0.0654014647,
-0.0379818082,
0.001520707,
0.0442060754,
-0.0101038571,
0.0189413652,
0.0183444694,
0.0041500488,
0.0221387688,
0.0154312458,
-0.0398082249,
-0.0910814181,
0.0173335504,
0.0469480157,
-0.0391120426,
0.0148439864,
0.0127861826,
0.0080160173,
-0.0198230594,
-0.0071257008,
0.0131464424,
-0.0046207192,
-0.0680415556,
0.045707535,
0.0628898516,
0.0014244888,
0.046024397,
0.0383870304,
-0.0807850957,
-0.0153720537,
0.0030567253,
0.0570062287,
0.0288751535,
0.0453030914,
-0.0198100973,
-0.0495583862,
-0.0257825833,
-0.0287700742,
0.0102189574,
0.0067286734,
-0.0197396968,
0.0667083263,
0.0259961467,
0.0143100498,
0.0415003523,
-0.0109316809,
0.024530042,
0.0287073813,
-0.0362692252,
-0.1486677974,
0.0097196354,
-0.0025872758,
-0.0219816044,
-0.0169076994,
-0.0516866669,
0.0136039639,
-0.0879593343,
-0.0313516818,
0.0118658077,
-0.0155041208,
-0.0142766377,
-0.0113675399,
0.0186189637,
-0.0116515364,
-0.0063059125,
-0.0058096,
0.0210685246,
-0.0115596708,
0.0093594017,
0.0523903891,
-0.0611880384,
0.0122777708,
-0.074419558,
-0.0003397396,
0.0707564428,
0.0395524651,
-0.0435589924,
-0.0373906717,
-0.0560567826,
-0.0363429338,
-0.0523397774,
0.0326527283,
0.0332728736,
-0.0336784162,
-0.0007553131,
-0.0046816547,
0.0203357935,
-0.0303279273,
0.0148800407,
-0.0173225608,
0.042200733,
-0.0171581917,
-0.0098110288,
-0.0165174473,
-0.0004297895,
0.0064426609,
0.0767107606,
0.0179127827,
0.0078937113,
0.0203575902,
-0.0237431768,
-0.0057314667,
0.0372069851,
-0.0087112086,
0.01750472,
0.0004946498,
-0.0633188188,
-0.1084523499,
-0.0615036264,
-0.0497819595,
0.0197444912,
0.001367952,
0.0119363042,
-0.0073430385,
-0.0476822294,
-0.0607761927,
0.0405246317,
-0.0213778894,
0.0223634485,
0.0289882347,
-0.0186819937,
0.0607141107,
0.0194995664,
-0.0714984536,
0.0180365853,
-0.0318060853,
-0.0502553582,
0.0107485149,
0.0386527888,
0.0237670671,
0.0144694112,
-0.0283592157,
-0.0023169054,
0.0434360914,
0.022066528,
-0.0242652074,
0.0322258882,
0.0707538426,
-0.003007177,
0.0170994792,
0.0554446094,
-0.023929989,
0.0142357768,
-0.0088880518,
0.0473059565,
0.0165017229,
0.0093006911,
0.0435118228,
-0.0188382883,
0.0385580324,
-0.030996345,
-0.0118416855,
-0.0226150658,
-0.0218390021,
-0.0095740203,
-0.0368392877,
0.0028292984,
-0.00158951,
0.0453914702,
0.0048109684,
-0.026029082,
-0.0452387556,
0.0214780923,
0.0914016664,
-0.0014683318,
-0.0236171316,
0.0512948483,
0.0153310485,
-0.0020169909,
0.0269528851,
-0.0131388716,
0.0045407652,
-0.0404826216,
0.0317796171,
-0.0193637777,
-0.0087439213,
0.009580195,
-0.0229259953,
-0.0437070876,
-0.0174778011,
-0.0386575945,
-0.012640615,
0.0058818813,
-0.0010472285,
0.0450792275,
-0.0403531753,
-0.0118460245,
-0.0461714976,
-0.0108726192,
0.007158794,
-0.0099433996,
0.0044551776,
-0.0211114455,
0.0924494043,
0.0366042629,
0.0095369238,
-0.0360486023,
0.0568163805,
-0.0107332403,
0.0568831377,
-0.0287691597,
0.0012688052,
-0.0430777222,
-0.0225601569,
0.0311466753,
0.0609508194,
-0.0292473491,
0.0428182371,
-0.074089542,
-0.0759679824,
0.0535937138,
0.0571632423,
0.0177662093,
-0.0241178274,
0.0065938048,
0.055796992,
0.0007945707,
-0.0193307679,
-0.035333585,
0.0160099026,
0.0176453274,
0.0425980091,
-0.0152642103,
-5.292606009e-33,
-0.0640018582,
0.001454647,
-0.0099657662,
-0.0559372716,
-0.001511573,
0.020739764,
-0.0330706239,
0.0056460011,
-0.0413442925,
0.0141339377,
0.0312535614,
0.0285425577,
0.0058393367,
0.0216945261,
0.0053404691,
-0.0164893195,
0.0179245807,
0.025064772,
-0.0162245966,
-0.0345363095,
0.0274693202,
-0.0056216447,
0.0831817612,
-0.0082589425,
0.0580215305,
-0.0135621894,
0.0301655978,
0.0423427783,
-0.0095429253,
0.0246019363,
-0.0137938866,
0.0733800158,
0.0350651257,
0.0104841767,
0.0105432384,
0.0204151403,
-0.0890972391,
-0.0684416667,
0.0635149255,
0.0075992718,
0.0097306492,
0.0129047241,
0.0667864904,
-0.0281362273,
0.0040099467,
0.0037977642,
0.0019766442,
-0.0223186295,
-0.0455771014,
-0.0483537614,
-0.0698081851,
0.0219355058,
0.064534694,
0.0083479751,
0.002584029,
-0.020436205,
0.0454299487,
-0.0407716855,
-0.014849402,
0.0162117593,
-0.0302442145,
0.0234297141,
0.0141735729,
0.0164753962,
0.0133620519,
0.054244712,
-0.0041648396,
-0.005134379,
0.0329464115,
0.04872315,
0.0673661083,
0.0184547883,
-0.0163988043,
0.0612562448,
0.0307789408,
-0.0155190257,
0.0077273441,
-0.0095046051,
-0.0238312576,
-0.0039667324,
0.0120798992,
0.0314104259,
-0.027581349,
0.0085997041,
-0.063396737,
0.0216665249,
-0.0060899695,
-0.0229731854,
-0.0070199473,
-0.0478693396,
-0.0115396725,
0.0700208694,
0.0150809232,
-0.0503578223,
-0.0360251442,
0.0438262857,
0.0157187786,
0.0261183921,
-0.0330637544,
0.0396264046,
-0.0099749807,
-0.0136491694,
-0.0304668173,
-0.002518628,
-0.0214267001,
0.0150004141,
0.0279247761,
-0.0082452334,
-0.0116782961,
-0.004560593,
-0.0146910464,
-0.0700994432,
-0.0213686638,
0.007775066,
0.0612262748,
0.056786783,
0.0066724489,
0.0140318573,
0.015269096,
-0.0251516402,
-0.0330375433,
0.071182169,
-0.024932839,
0.0797034502,
-0.0353980251,
-0.0421721935,
-0.0578337088,
-0.0056042066,
0.0379279591,
-0.0774113536,
0.0144465584,
-0.0331831798,
2.415e-7,
0.0553186685,
-0.019086564,
0.0116467616,
0.021304626,
-0.0231079813,
-0.0052831387,
0.0054339711,
0.0307823773,
-0.0280436091,
-0.059264265,
0.015903499,
0.0246324632,
-0.0010697645,
-0.0053015696,
-0.0170537308,
-0.0421415865,
0.0129293976,
0.0028551724,
-0.0327470154,
0.0619923547,
0.0474481471,
0.1176161692,
0.0545853153,
-0.0024939443,
0.0040080743,
-0.0450398363,
0.0416387022,
0.0167629234,
-0.0208720211,
0.0121015282,
-0.0212076437,
0.0103437724,
0.0396499224,
0.0206709392,
0.0062779887,
0.0235959832,
0.0128613655,
-0.0130267674,
-0.0126803191,
-0.0094738072,
-0.050064519,
-0.0447218828,
-0.0426482707,
-0.0279005412,
0.0299352892,
-0.0844796002,
-0.0597351491,
-0.0141885569,
-0.0371170789,
0.0350862816,
0.0156660192,
0.005411732,
-0.0391787253,
-0.0064253728,
0.0329426192,
0.0173758958,
0.0137378182,
-0.0554429479,
-0.0028259105,
0.0782408938,
-0.0438670404,
-0.0310495701,
0.0396825224,
-0.0444141962,
0.0083596893,
-0.0876925513,
-0.0040919562,
1.927536836e-34,
0.0337966643,
0.0335697345,
0.0128714489,
-0.0034568224,
0.0525872894,
-0.0088413889,
0.013438887,
0.0203104634,
0.026211584,
-0.021145409,
0.0124887899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08316v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08316v3 | How to Handle Different Types of Out-of-Distribution Scenarios in Computational Argumentation? A Comprehensive and Fine-Grained Field Study | 2023-09-15T11:15:47 | 2024-06-27T14:02:44 | Andreas Waldis, Yufang Hou, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advent of pre-trained Language Models (LMs) has markedly advanced natural
language processing, but their efficacy in out-of-distribution (OOD) scenarios
remains a significant challenge. Computational argumentation (CA), modeling
human argumentation processes, is a field notably impacted by these challenges
because complex annotation schemes and high annotation costs naturally lead to
resources barely covering the multiplicity of available text sources and
topics. Due to this data scarcity, generalization to data from uncovered
covariant distributions is a common challenge for CA tasks like stance
detection or argument classification. This work systematically assesses LMs'
capabilities for such OOD scenarios. While previous work targets specific OOD
types like topic shifts or OOD uniformly, we address three prevalent OOD
scenarios in CA: topic shift, domain shift, and language shift. Our findings
challenge the previously asserted general superiority of in-context learning
(ICL) for OOD. We find that the efficacy of such learning paradigms varies with
the type of OOD. Specifically, while ICL excels for domain shifts, prompt-based
fine-tuning surpasses for topic shifts. To sum up, we navigate the
heterogeneity of OOD scenarios in CA and empirically underscore the potential
of base-sized LMs in overcoming these challenges. | [
0.0239294544,
0.0548226908,
0.0258925483,
0.0534338094,
-0.0246206,
0.0243784972,
-0.0160464309,
-0.0170547049,
-0.0703087449,
-0.0978932083,
-0.0119032627,
-0.034840256,
-0.0336141363,
-0.0333307944,
-0.0125149023,
-0.0487079956,
-0.0027431701,
-0.0080885962,
0.0774329007,
0.0029319364,
0.0205061268,
0.0016367147,
-0.0404708162,
0.0247475021,
0.0002128274,
-0.071003072,
-0.0158644412,
0.009065981,
0.042944558,
-0.0287583917,
0.0331383757,
0.0640133098,
0.0463894568,
0.0182866789,
0.0000020341,
-0.0508158989,
-0.0231027752,
-0.0363587104,
-0.0341175124,
0.0298165865,
0.0514141731,
0.0010596778,
-0.0144113824,
0.0181203485,
-0.0469946042,
-0.0016232444,
0.047463838,
0.0563869774,
0.0629210398,
0.1175937802,
-0.0077702343,
0.0015583673,
-0.0043483735,
-0.030182872,
-0.0684445128,
-0.0231881868,
0.0308649,
0.0013431401,
-0.0328745022,
0.044866953,
-0.0209004693,
0.0095474208,
-0.0006564459,
-0.0030569017,
-0.0445367657,
0.0189846531,
-0.0280228239,
0.001800366,
-0.0255576782,
0.0786240622,
-0.0200841762,
-0.0507430658,
-0.009200789,
-0.0488978699,
0.0117716445,
0.0077278232,
-0.0411669165,
0.0415891521,
-0.0118373521,
0.0350523964,
0.0464367792,
0.0310473312,
0.030912552,
0.0290492736,
-0.0070141437,
0.0312368553,
-0.0481257737,
-0.0247477014,
0.0238531847,
-0.00514735,
-0.0543732569,
-0.0663421601,
-0.0145881353,
0.0281983353,
-0.0003031046,
0.0294114687,
-0.0201871805,
0.0090556005,
0.0338743515,
-0.0584499575,
0.040616747,
-0.002756835,
-0.0395542346,
0.0582717881,
0.053899236,
-0.0121401008,
-0.0573842525,
-0.0076342798,
0.0113448184,
-0.0074706469,
-0.0503247306,
-0.0187329743,
-0.0124155972,
0.0206159055,
-0.0423447266,
-0.0090967705,
0.0102098593,
0.0089665083,
-0.0397040918,
-0.0338266902,
0.0014193795,
0.0175856911,
0.0047448925,
-0.0216154233,
-0.044516746,
0.0619870983,
-0.0271817259,
0.0330105834,
0.0400877707,
-0.0329574943,
-0.0440592133,
0.0599424914,
-0.0042797322,
-0.0045800693,
-0.005434107,
0.0219331942,
0.0070773819,
0.0201137681,
-0.0249128807,
-0.0232109707,
-0.0585122742,
-0.0704532415,
0.034039285,
-0.0736261532,
-0.0053376001,
-0.0012629846,
-0.0090858052,
-0.0606549233,
0.005784905,
0.0345052257,
0.0009937501,
0.0441541485,
0.0287648886,
-0.0285657886,
0.0457495302,
-0.0000929154,
-0.0273593776,
0.0724270716,
-0.0044602389,
-0.0117686652,
0.0399700254,
0.0115871448,
0.0095738266,
0.0090540433,
0.0319973752,
0.0294240452,
0.0556007847,
0.0201588999,
-0.0316898227,
0.0092923176,
-0.0011051134,
0.0078134099,
-0.0316007063,
-0.0504714213,
0.049627088,
0.0489766411,
0.0084390054,
-0.0135444701,
0.0370378532,
0.0276342388,
0.0095801279,
-0.0001426355,
-0.0286421049,
-0.01505234,
-0.0046374346,
-0.0422034711,
-0.0105429925,
-0.0159097333,
-0.0337785967,
-0.0586741716,
-0.0068668718,
-0.0413371474,
-0.0155748175,
-0.0033067716,
0.0248192772,
0.0237789508,
-0.0125148511,
0.0108614406,
0.0399758071,
-0.0248443577,
-0.0678262413,
-0.0144134024,
0.024208216,
-0.0436280258,
-0.0061008856,
-0.053689789,
-0.0163792185,
-0.0331199281,
0.0974454731,
0.0636018813,
0.0676189885,
-0.0228671208,
0.014232209,
-0.0360820591,
-0.0131308343,
-0.0644477606,
0.0314075872,
0.0339993648,
0.0060532051,
-0.0022174071,
0.0111710168,
-0.0178424511,
0.006826038,
0.02191047,
0.0179443955,
-0.0148536954,
0.0130232591,
0.0118742893,
0.0419060253,
0.0308518857,
-0.0098092882,
0.0021870222,
0.035036318,
-0.0173764378,
-0.0300862789,
0.0356288962,
-0.0569658726,
-0.0353257246,
0.0380705483,
-0.0226516165,
-0.0050344313,
-0.0707185641,
-0.0441071279,
0.0118112396,
0.0349349305,
0.012280276,
0.0037135398,
-0.0338340923,
-0.0120253041,
-0.0093185324,
0.0088468539,
-0.0470754579,
0.0793614462,
0.0222063418,
-0.0237173196,
0.0329534188,
0.0369993001,
0.0459066294,
-0.0409091525,
0.0306984,
-0.0045136637,
0.0079563875,
0.0150422817,
0.0265585762,
-0.0379453003,
-0.0251996275,
-0.0087351846,
-0.1041704342,
0.013026854,
-0.0385451019,
0.0439596735,
0.0358400047,
-0.0530321859,
0.0049902722,
0.018925596,
-0.0227698013,
-0.0434193052,
-0.0173232928,
0.0032297536,
0.0503860712,
-0.0199755915,
0.0357804038,
-0.0337431766,
0.0027543115,
-0.0180902798,
0.0574561283,
-0.0217696428,
-0.0170503743,
-0.0623528846,
0.0025968705,
-0.0207845103,
0.014364861,
-0.0387236401,
0.0147371432,
0.0270035826,
0.0240491983,
0.0676045716,
0.0776908919,
0.036844369,
0.0541609451,
0.0247884337,
0.0041776127,
-0.0703150854,
-0.0062362473,
-0.0011330559,
0.0165379606,
-0.0327880159,
0.0442803204,
0.0506901145,
0.0675962195,
-0.0232356153,
0.0158820488,
-0.0370184965,
0.0345655382,
-0.0051277219,
-0.020943379,
0.0036767637,
-0.0069233491,
-0.0253500566,
0.0415136404,
-0.0070855203,
-0.0190467574,
0.0506627634,
-0.0248540342,
0.0464008786,
-0.0682473853,
-0.0499549583,
-0.0223460533,
0.0210051797,
-0.013611963,
-0.0192997213,
0.0408058502,
0.0165949631,
-0.0183097646,
-0.0444138385,
0.0331849121,
-0.0243737567,
0.0322152078,
-0.0488416329,
0.016976878,
-0.0018090423,
-0.0389941037,
-0.0202475637,
-0.0892248973,
-0.0357927419,
-0.003728606,
-0.025185328,
-0.0068946108,
0.0174102858,
-0.0059291134,
-0.0103748143,
0.0449127741,
-0.0026636575,
0.0156978127,
0.0170351546,
0.0334196761,
-0.0159486588,
0.0263767038,
0.0094520561,
-0.0054742573,
0.0126869492,
0.0601422973,
-0.0129768671,
-0.0463842414,
-0.0417732373,
-0.0111251371,
-0.0193310231,
-0.0174419656,
-0.028198909,
-0.005937825,
0.0667085648,
-0.0289871842,
0.0150712309,
0.0792672262,
0.0279088598,
-0.0339585096,
-0.0120377913,
-0.0174462553,
-0.0094670048,
0.006436551,
-0.0127801457,
-0.116131261,
-0.0442304909,
-0.0300252903,
0.0143785365,
-0.0331746452,
-0.0085675083,
-0.0156913083,
-0.0985127538,
0.0354685709,
-0.0112016369,
-0.016510129,
-0.0018505278,
-0.0555827245,
0.0206143223,
-0.019617103,
-0.0228644814,
-0.0201186612,
-0.0052532284,
0.0005003632,
0.037518084,
-0.0323106237,
-0.0128261475,
0.0201891847,
-0.0221868549,
0.0130965216,
0.0151910204,
0.0491479598,
0.0318617672,
-0.0338778384,
0.0452001952,
-0.0403309874,
0.0082330965,
-0.0135833481,
0.0247940961,
-0.0221195426,
0.0040369127,
0.0046705599,
0.0516326092,
-0.023345774,
-0.0598971248,
0.0152544873,
0.0626569465,
-0.0358531028,
-0.0074226069,
0.0011340529,
0.0411299542,
0.0447570831,
0.0423183665,
0.0183783155,
-0.0328287706,
-0.0610088743,
-0.0430161059,
-0.0106588369,
-0.013639112,
0.0195604116,
-0.0090872264,
0.0160861649,
0.003651001,
-0.069042936,
-0.0199393444,
-0.0443826988,
0.0503825173,
-0.0152345989,
-0.0066382554,
0.0332348496,
0.0051038619,
-0.03014699,
0.0426814035,
-0.0397715196,
0.0037518742,
-0.0266346391,
-0.0047144708,
0.0409412123,
-0.0073730778,
-0.0320689492,
0.0273370631,
-0.0334243961,
-0.0880716071,
-0.0139706386,
0.0232287087,
0.0230061878,
0.0693208426,
0.0017515465,
-0.0166486166,
0.058491461,
0.0452448688,
0.0224893373,
0.0253444482,
0.0672374293,
0.0043290006,
0.005908669,
0.0075291963,
0.0301317591,
0.0464713424,
0.0377390422,
-0.0012805572,
-0.0498368219,
-0.0040414613,
0.013809693,
-0.0457936153,
0.0756545737,
0.0271845926,
-0.1022778973,
-0.0194479916,
0.0255489815,
-0.0243407115,
-0.0367126241,
-0.0159153081,
-0.02437751,
-0.002882462,
-0.0535617247,
-0.0199320354,
0.0285891984,
-0.0308673754,
0.0728072375,
0.0055210921,
0.0398392826,
0.0538741723,
0.0417901911,
-0.0197000764,
-0.0034629367,
-0.0251372363,
0.0264924224,
-0.0140800104,
0.0503035672,
-0.0038051296,
0.0948513448,
0.0326162763,
0.0065452415,
0.0265794769,
0.0064691948,
-0.0596260205,
-0.0249762386,
-0.013577126,
-0.0025442154,
0.0153482752,
-0.0572257861,
0.045737315,
-0.0113014327,
-0.0235564522,
-0.0304799881,
0.0556915067,
-0.0048455312,
-0.0046913624,
0.054213427,
0.0338208452,
-0.0407446474,
0.0395181514,
0.0448666252,
-0.023081325,
0.0280609932,
0.0267215334,
0.0054548513,
-0.0488344394,
-0.0121427001,
-0.0264717322,
0.0191859771,
-0.0086094216,
0.0012385839,
-0.0401428491,
-0.0209496561,
-0.0098844571,
-0.0024496552,
-0.0051830532,
0.0040498958,
0.0198228415,
0.0803666264,
-0.0252236035,
0.029110549,
-0.0376103073,
0.0278771296,
0.0182414055,
-0.0055077914,
-0.0258297194,
-6.421483193e-33,
0.0082231183,
-0.0220535025,
0.0041498737,
0.0375979319,
0.0369432941,
0.0078157354,
-0.0068307454,
0.0322821438,
-0.0221656933,
0.0542249754,
0.0082030836,
0.0285634827,
0.0213547107,
0.0192650408,
-0.0490391776,
-0.009097022,
0.0160675831,
-0.0183264688,
-0.0465324149,
0.0147611899,
0.048437696,
-0.0258013271,
0.0335637629,
-0.0986497328,
0.0466295965,
-0.0138084972,
0.007769037,
0.0183639396,
-0.0023246557,
0.0367945395,
-0.0065402212,
0.0418879613,
0.0335639268,
-0.0618312843,
0.0189573877,
0.0631502271,
-0.068107143,
-0.0090278694,
0.018580148,
-0.0515336208,
0.0050272243,
-0.0359431729,
-0.0119228745,
0.0444041342,
0.0078663062,
-0.0305469185,
0.0054702763,
-0.0278054401,
0.0211316068,
-0.0164024327,
-0.0927930921,
0.0577382259,
-0.0244260207,
-0.0295686778,
-0.0328355469,
0.0294477493,
-0.0008190543,
0.0650445744,
-0.0493779927,
0.005440692,
-0.0207261741,
-0.0051226304,
0.0133193322,
-0.027287716,
-0.0250430349,
0.0551912561,
-0.0350643992,
0.0134057719,
-0.0504517071,
0.0103311967,
-0.0000121522,
0.0413136631,
0.0273721982,
0.0645101368,
0.0530044623,
0.0139270825,
-0.1003061756,
-0.0293218177,
0.021157302,
-0.0025354375,
0.0154877752,
0.0008784411,
-0.0028375247,
-0.0200852919,
-0.0236031674,
-0.0637045205,
0.0035460531,
-0.0226162039,
0.0059477808,
0.0248451997,
-0.0075893123,
0.0443760604,
0.012036778,
-0.0206335392,
-0.001594902,
0.0492429137,
-0.0031628974,
-0.0069376654,
0.0032494375,
0.0124506634,
-0.0497957133,
-0.0256036874,
0.0142230596,
0.0149060981,
0.0417911634,
-0.0032728552,
0.0820083171,
-0.0256590247,
-0.0591365844,
-0.0242480766,
-0.0291830748,
0.0385951921,
-0.0496472381,
0.1071760282,
0.0037544856,
0.0303311888,
-0.0068585789,
0.0633900687,
0.0002773938,
-0.0086798901,
-0.0043274299,
-0.0274242107,
-0.0323982425,
0.0064325402,
-0.0305248126,
-0.0249853693,
0.031853471,
0.0224277731,
0.0109130777,
-0.069192633,
-0.0006176334,
-0.0082286419,
2.717e-7,
0.0665339082,
0.0512627102,
0.0374741741,
-0.0600069501,
0.0350718424,
0.0383129455,
-0.013369102,
0.0057699317,
0.0374567993,
-0.0784211755,
-0.0139439125,
0.0562845096,
0.0282433704,
0.0300071444,
-0.0735306069,
-0.031866584,
-0.0384389162,
-0.0202022437,
-0.0308769643,
-0.0072852774,
0.0300942194,
0.0925229937,
0.011430393,
-0.0033441649,
-0.0118353795,
0.0074965009,
0.0903402716,
-0.0174134709,
0.0123477187,
-0.0175518077,
0.0200692993,
-0.0552919284,
0.0142853195,
0.0475855619,
-0.0130866244,
0.0553374328,
-0.0282238107,
0.0702214912,
0.0081695933,
-0.0470111892,
-0.01142825,
0.0003297738,
0.0261472948,
-0.0385178737,
0.063544713,
-0.1182219833,
-0.0357919857,
-0.0637622923,
-0.0608608164,
-0.0017249384,
0.0228036009,
0.0036777835,
0.0088548521,
0.0032340409,
-0.0063055996,
0.0165557414,
0.0123512335,
-0.0826449022,
-0.0472552441,
0.0409514271,
-0.0259310193,
-0.0331408605,
0.0077400412,
-0.0233114976,
0.0738921091,
-0.047822725,
0.0299330112,
2.135208806e-34,
0.0424836688,
-0.014698917,
0.0052702697,
0.0049176496,
0.0387526564,
0.0317194425,
-0.0003585244,
-0.0173662398,
0.0355873741,
-0.0247292686,
0.0126741985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08303v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08303v1 | Self-Consistent Narrative Prompts on Abductive Natural Language Inference | 2023-09-15T10:48:10 | 2023-09-15T10:48:10 | Chunkit Chan, Xin Liu, Tsz Ho Chan, Jiayang Cheng, Yangqiu Song, Ginny Wong, Simon See | cs.CL | cs.CL | Abduction has long been seen as crucial for narrative comprehension and
reasoning about everyday situations. The abductive natural language inference
($\alpha$NLI) task has been proposed, and this narrative text-based task aims
to infer the most plausible hypothesis from the candidates given two
observations. However, the inter-sentential coherence and the model consistency
have not been well exploited in the previous works on this task. In this work,
we propose a prompt tuning model $\alpha$-PACE, which takes self-consistency
and inter-sentential coherence into consideration. Besides, we propose a
general self-consistent framework that considers various narrative sequences
(e.g., linear narrative and reverse chronology) for guiding the pre-trained
language model in understanding the narrative context of input. We conduct
extensive experiments and thorough ablation studies to illustrate the necessity
and effectiveness of $\alpha$-PACE. The performance of our method shows
significant improvement against extensive competitive baselines. | [
0.0254473742,
0.0409095734,
0.0023918671,
0.0543030836,
-0.0964864343,
-0.0173750799,
0.0226705614,
-0.018645877,
0.0163815226,
-0.0349954665,
0.0056020534,
-0.0273611899,
0.0006677396,
0.0534287654,
-0.0315671265,
-0.0343089774,
0.060950458,
-0.0177118666,
0.0634391308,
0.0238392018,
-0.0186456088,
0.0267470013,
-0.041378893,
0.0018697259,
-0.0013065677,
-0.0493916832,
-0.0212493334,
0.0308972672,
0.0228876043,
-0.040591456,
0.0073104491,
0.0716727674,
0.0189629328,
0.0045058592,
0.0000021616,
-0.0912193879,
-0.013438954,
-0.0408955663,
-0.0538024381,
-0.0194789041,
0.0291157495,
0.0245792903,
0.0275511965,
-0.0244426504,
-0.0244417563,
0.0340186991,
-0.0124389278,
0.0642970726,
0.046066124,
0.0893063173,
-0.0053589288,
-0.0077962,
-0.0285660699,
0.0052811801,
-0.0124287298,
-0.0295332856,
-0.003887939,
-0.0036192692,
0.0584856309,
0.0223162603,
-0.0170156807,
0.0257827472,
0.0200405419,
0.0104166195,
-0.0334415175,
0.0654326305,
-0.0378682613,
-0.006303844,
-0.0415362157,
0.0528832972,
0.0476415195,
-0.01466644,
-0.0217546541,
-0.0172991455,
0.0030553641,
-0.0092141647,
-0.0166679267,
0.0480664112,
-0.0467280634,
0.01743358,
0.0737860724,
0.0568898171,
-0.0153731517,
-0.0083327135,
0.0085375467,
0.0329745971,
0.0288965423,
-0.0204338524,
-0.0337147266,
-0.0042012124,
-0.0267553534,
-0.0752253532,
0.0199252926,
0.0316229872,
-0.0439092889,
0.000814331,
-0.0600033812,
0.005286742,
-0.0200188272,
-0.0574420951,
-0.0007969046,
0.0334231742,
-0.0599176139,
0.0506764799,
-0.0075352262,
0.0410394669,
-0.0004285385,
0.0095190816,
-0.0301291402,
0.0205762777,
-0.0106918467,
0.0206604712,
-0.0419270694,
0.013775521,
-0.0187130217,
-0.0208260939,
0.014758653,
0.0138870915,
0.0420908369,
-0.0118288202,
-0.0421202704,
0.0078997146,
-0.0571876541,
-0.0147298193,
-0.0252005029,
0.0320966728,
-0.0610738546,
0.0173350535,
0.0142869987,
-0.0487655513,
-0.0606679097,
0.0084173679,
0.0543099605,
-0.0361047164,
-0.0010106444,
0.0071100136,
-0.0217377599,
-0.0240480062,
-0.1064885855,
-0.0375724882,
-0.0192104969,
-0.0619497448,
-0.072903581,
-0.0375167578,
0.0283182692,
-0.0133909117,
-0.0106574995,
-0.0307234563,
-0.0090194009,
0.0300079193,
-0.0157336928,
0.0339175761,
-0.0214025639,
-0.0140862064,
0.0071341889,
0.0102750929,
-0.0132440515,
0.0466673709,
0.0229694974,
0.060244631,
0.0490901768,
0.0307659283,
0.0284556113,
0.0144369211,
-0.0150390705,
-0.0182972588,
0.0411685631,
0.0225257259,
0.0109680612,
0.0526027046,
0.0344326906,
0.0345432311,
-0.0362390094,
-0.0255183354,
0.0640908182,
0.0760195628,
-0.0152700059,
-0.0251037069,
0.0687229112,
0.0177709423,
0.0011475073,
0.0691770837,
-0.0469141006,
-0.003980394,
-0.0245788898,
0.004441971,
-0.0037434357,
0.026852997,
-0.0412443876,
-0.0319544375,
0.0070388364,
-0.0098957149,
-0.028854318,
-0.0029984838,
0.029528778,
0.0229805838,
-0.0602669604,
-0.0061261351,
0.0275432821,
-0.0601037554,
0.0099903475,
-0.0008639287,
0.0465140156,
0.034726806,
0.0436908677,
-0.0285651218,
-0.0805424452,
-0.0247734301,
0.0796805322,
0.0320771784,
-0.0046043531,
-0.002352776,
0.0268458519,
-0.0190361906,
-0.0097835595,
-0.0096953139,
0.0037312612,
0.0183392987,
-0.0242952313,
0.0212157443,
-0.0100361845,
-0.0126521504,
-0.0186161343,
0.0646321625,
-0.0786499456,
-0.0266037676,
-0.0285821911,
0.0173827689,
-0.007562344,
0.0266106799,
-0.0066688955,
-0.0140065318,
0.0406552367,
-0.0284292288,
-0.010324155,
0.0781581327,
-0.0824578553,
-0.1034644023,
0.0040157908,
-0.0370450616,
-0.0610831715,
-0.0335770883,
-0.0034702518,
-0.0578964725,
0.0427391194,
-0.01560634,
-0.0201865938,
-0.0320614316,
0.0193646979,
0.0123760151,
-0.018965669,
-0.0341660678,
0.0881261081,
0.0154129528,
0.0168815032,
0.0308829453,
0.0376765467,
0.0295683872,
-0.0427500159,
0.0102819037,
0.0070786909,
0.0003768285,
-0.0430958755,
0.0661180392,
-0.0166738816,
-0.0297933258,
-0.0377090201,
-0.0530693717,
0.0418995097,
-0.0428383201,
0.0205770303,
0.0279422365,
0.0132477237,
-0.0330420248,
-0.0424842462,
-0.0022059763,
-0.0636394992,
0.0023182665,
-0.0218640082,
0.0209338125,
0.0054260814,
-0.009446919,
-0.0421180837,
0.0249141213,
-0.0300667454,
0.0390216112,
0.0327640697,
0.0051451209,
-0.0757858679,
-0.0007866792,
0.0080245044,
0.0188176949,
-0.0315213427,
0.0177592225,
0.0446087308,
-0.0039909189,
0.036507979,
0.0650136024,
0.0109326448,
0.000381994,
0.0174001027,
-0.0274586305,
-0.0143840695,
0.028339047,
-0.0118682561,
0.0164703745,
-0.0162463617,
-0.0467656553,
0.0193539727,
0.0631900951,
0.0159262773,
0.0110839689,
-0.0541042723,
-0.0172696579,
0.0002178649,
-0.0269022994,
0.0245371945,
-0.028884735,
-0.0056608072,
0.0355631448,
-0.028541388,
0.0009130269,
0.0920977369,
-0.0577983931,
-0.0111165037,
-0.0265731681,
-0.010824779,
-0.0460961387,
0.0835959017,
0.0020922923,
0.0217639972,
0.0365699492,
-0.034767475,
-0.029995149,
0.0088607045,
0.0498763546,
0.0040608225,
0.0004359489,
-0.039755743,
-0.0036135174,
0.0178997014,
-0.034963347,
-0.0773206949,
-0.091725193,
-0.0178647358,
-0.0065810732,
-0.0156087894,
0.0069302069,
-0.0268438794,
0.0017549813,
0.0009829582,
0.0543675534,
0.0147891371,
-0.0189436916,
-0.0517698862,
0.009701509,
0.0579481646,
0.0304957777,
-0.0097310822,
0.0159273688,
0.0573233813,
0.0524804182,
0.0103501882,
0.0055281804,
-0.0360084809,
0.0334395468,
0.0149701731,
-0.0479990728,
0.0047080605,
0.0063171661,
0.0269188918,
-0.0261434428,
-0.0397099555,
0.1376813501,
0.0268324912,
0.0107656363,
-0.0052664871,
-0.0388741642,
0.0233033411,
0.0136968466,
-0.0056813178,
-0.0574351698,
-0.026738571,
0.0043495391,
0.00185437,
-0.0031068588,
-0.0696120784,
-0.0303067639,
-0.093112424,
0.0357511155,
-0.0254411362,
0.0157019123,
-0.0124560483,
-0.0503307357,
0.0253868364,
-0.0260506216,
0.0099547151,
0.0353239886,
-0.0231135469,
0.0108836601,
-0.0110779842,
-0.0260219704,
0.0122036189,
0.0043039117,
-0.072813794,
0.0311704259,
0.0188530218,
0.0195241123,
-0.0016438825,
0.0063424241,
-0.0400582403,
0.0032143951,
-0.0086177504,
-0.0048357486,
0.0569305606,
-0.0592808239,
0.0091183214,
-0.0242453199,
0.0895596668,
0.0042349352,
-0.0571570806,
0.030049203,
0.0459904,
-0.0384885706,
-0.0392583013,
0.0267141964,
0.0062346281,
0.0180865396,
0.1073138639,
0.0222404338,
-0.0052055269,
-0.0308674611,
0.0195176303,
0.0147452597,
-0.0035869374,
-0.0333923921,
0.0144150909,
0.004001847,
0.0336621106,
-0.0334785394,
-0.0679694489,
0.0087042414,
0.0608874485,
0.0344942473,
0.0240765009,
0.0341419429,
-0.046346534,
-0.017385887,
0.0528857484,
-0.0344861113,
-0.0163593479,
0.0092316661,
0.0540289469,
0.0104351705,
-0.0446355194,
-0.0003742643,
0.0505463369,
0.0055860844,
-0.0410458893,
0.0180521905,
0.0116714304,
0.0137473829,
0.0688734651,
-0.0357058048,
-0.0087920902,
-0.0158270579,
-0.0648267046,
-0.0140305972,
0.0402655266,
-0.0134637691,
0.0164299402,
-0.0227553044,
0.0214235354,
-0.0047791474,
0.0226895679,
-0.0076337671,
0.0581179522,
-0.0067875506,
-0.0315237865,
0.0389286093,
0.0125172464,
0.0567998104,
-0.0141576342,
0.0033243024,
-0.0857412368,
-0.0039981385,
-0.0495842919,
-0.018119622,
-0.0179788619,
0.0526564009,
-0.0093931472,
-0.0157326721,
-0.0268542897,
-0.020913329,
-0.0804911777,
-0.0069860872,
-0.048842717,
-0.0325772204,
0.0408053882,
0.0078497715,
-0.0261994563,
-0.0168574378,
-0.0213916134,
0.01666517,
-0.0209404621,
0.0852236599,
-0.0209568255,
0.0537558794,
0.0583834797,
-0.0189373605,
-0.0023284014,
0.0209849309,
-0.0574935637,
0.0178431347,
0.0037924398,
0.0345926695,
0.0233832542,
-0.0363920033,
0.043567583,
-0.0185699333,
0.0344727896,
0.0093124909,
0.0414936766,
0.0735423192,
-0.0080054998,
-0.0256458409,
-0.0045636119,
-0.008842933,
0.0558414571,
0.0447842069,
-0.038311325,
0.0690057427,
0.0133010084,
-0.0022067218,
-0.0352820046,
-0.0474810265,
-0.0160445236,
0.0274372138,
-0.0017434092,
-0.011951522,
-0.0447080769,
-0.0044393032,
0.0448457003,
0.0011751681,
-0.0106644621,
0.0033302961,
-0.0036909734,
0.0279967226,
0.00230808,
-0.0495497473,
0.0142442686,
0.0400795601,
-0.0104147829,
-0.0228660554,
-0.0291983411,
-6.682990278e-33,
-0.0357439518,
-0.0119881239,
0.0288451109,
0.0348658301,
-0.0369731374,
0.0067132181,
-0.0335326679,
0.009353295,
-0.0041588531,
0.0086625135,
0.003598056,
0.0127788084,
0.0194452703,
0.0062322887,
-0.020568369,
-0.0060431422,
0.0231084805,
0.0426242538,
-0.074237816,
-0.0317820124,
0.0445996262,
0.044352863,
0.0548030213,
-0.0215932038,
0.0360398218,
-0.0712495744,
-0.0125997141,
0.0400835462,
0.0175715405,
0.0029992522,
-0.0181359965,
0.0134602543,
0.011961068,
-0.0246972945,
-0.0047409651,
0.061694786,
-0.0539098531,
-0.0803857446,
0.0529798679,
0.0157176163,
-0.0494526625,
-0.0307775103,
-0.0339853689,
-0.0238140617,
0.0214423891,
0.0117031019,
0.030730838,
0.0150157977,
0.0408045389,
0.0585983694,
-0.0900569856,
0.0277119968,
-0.0334989689,
-0.055380825,
0.0422562361,
0.0626364201,
0.0112308292,
-0.0289591942,
-0.0152929397,
-0.0112736672,
-0.0255516823,
0.0267649032,
-0.0019770495,
0.0055614486,
-0.0578964092,
0.0902828276,
0.0202315878,
-0.0027776801,
-0.0546001047,
0.0124237537,
-0.0012541228,
0.0494104996,
0.0185071621,
0.0484016351,
-0.0069547431,
0.0559316054,
-0.0663225055,
0.0357392319,
0.0168876089,
0.0243187584,
0.0185071304,
-0.0171807446,
-0.0351706482,
-0.0226294994,
-0.0833842382,
-0.0428762324,
-0.0161980037,
-0.0046044975,
0.036751356,
-0.0017244155,
-0.0052145175,
0.0180476848,
0.0321055166,
0.0126305679,
0.0082216272,
-0.0075552799,
-0.0346969031,
0.0121901603,
-0.0041850004,
0.0857972652,
-0.0218154266,
-0.0104172723,
0.0465288423,
0.0359299108,
0.0431016274,
-0.0138477804,
0.0411374569,
0.0091997376,
0.0025858406,
-0.0040931194,
-0.0259377509,
-0.0086544305,
-0.0395465083,
-0.038495034,
0.034054596,
0.0520753302,
-0.033214815,
0.0261468813,
0.0256322902,
0.0072690975,
-0.0444334,
-0.0312449504,
-0.0014650839,
-0.0038719275,
-0.0016464395,
0.0269913115,
0.0243137926,
0.0288356077,
-0.0292107631,
-0.0455504656,
0.0027998621,
0.0210965425,
2.825e-7,
0.008915022,
0.0007035888,
0.0799545124,
-0.0025728147,
-0.0293396674,
0.0081266109,
-0.0004725388,
0.0379142687,
0.0232297983,
-0.074528642,
0.0056374581,
0.0439545847,
0.0395547114,
0.0190930776,
-0.0557517894,
-0.0035741527,
-0.0472435281,
0.0109700141,
-0.0855041146,
-0.0301538575,
0.0921695754,
0.0063668108,
0.0196740739,
0.0086924043,
0.0036272486,
-0.0305034779,
0.0287179332,
-0.0212840419,
-0.0470810831,
0.0519674569,
0.0253441557,
-0.0074378899,
-0.0135588637,
-0.0038760253,
0.016637994,
0.0255731568,
0.0049070697,
0.0354246534,
-0.0228291117,
-0.0311022922,
-0.0168844815,
-0.007935469,
-0.0289517026,
0.0055528777,
0.0917035714,
-0.046257589,
-0.0446908884,
-0.0167842843,
-0.0335606448,
0.0200998466,
0.0181023013,
0.0266523249,
-0.0166295301,
0.0282976013,
0.0400999449,
0.0085352296,
-0.048257973,
-0.0790454969,
-0.0254452843,
0.0259665381,
-0.0208442863,
0.0057225465,
-0.0151482429,
-0.0089002158,
0.0136006633,
-0.0863560811,
0.0442488901,
2.470935273e-34,
0.0252086893,
0.0198469479,
0.0114881247,
0.0500671789,
0.0442925021,
-0.0069555743,
0.0011230308,
0.0040854285,
0.0159770474,
-0.086727187,
-0.0246874355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08646v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08646v3 | CoCA: Fusing Position Embedding with Collinear Constrained Attention in Transformers for Long Context Window Extending | 2023-09-15T09:36:51 | 2024-02-28T05:56:43 | Shiyi Zhu, Jing Ye, Wei Jiang, Siqiao Xue, Qi Zhang, Yifan Wu, Jianguo Li | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Self-attention and position embedding are two key modules in
transformer-based Large Language Models (LLMs). However, the potential
relationship between them is far from well studied, especially for long context
window extending. In fact, anomalous behaviors harming long context
extrapolation exist between Rotary Position Embedding (RoPE) and vanilla
self-attention unveiled by our work. To address this issue, we propose a novel
attention mechanism, CoCA (Collinear Constrained Attention). Specifically, we
enforce a collinear constraint between $Q$ and $K$ to seamlessly integrate RoPE
and self-attention. While only adding minimal computational and spatial
complexity, this integration significantly enhances long context window
extrapolation ability. We provide an optimized implementation, making it a
drop-in replacement for any existing transformer-based models. Extensive
experiments show that CoCA performs extraordinarily well in extending context
windows. A CoCA-based GPT model, trained with a context length of 512, can
seamlessly extend the context window up to 32K (60$\times$), without any
fine-tuning. Additionally, by dropping CoCA in LLaMA-7B, we achieve
extrapolation up to 32K within only 2K training length. Our code is publicly
available at: https://github.com/codefuse-ai/Collinear-Constrained-Attention | [
0.0212409832,
0.0698439553,
0.0099593149,
0.0539039671,
-0.0022936945,
-0.018199686,
0.0068314332,
-0.0212001111,
-0.0036958058,
-0.002980584,
-0.0720701516,
-0.0012987381,
0.0068085762,
0.0087554622,
0.0451101661,
-0.0548609495,
0.0263455268,
-0.040577542,
-0.0448072702,
0.0003665233,
-0.0173567142,
-0.0119002648,
0.0275089573,
0.0386392549,
-0.0054088342,
-0.0271252468,
-0.0354258493,
-0.0226306673,
0.0428558886,
0.0095744347,
-0.010713256,
0.0445586592,
0.0390236266,
0.0247405358,
0.0000020169,
-0.0264456738,
0.0003914034,
-0.0065293703,
-0.0022488958,
0.0548465401,
0.0163383074,
-0.0530552641,
-0.0033158925,
-0.0035030737,
-0.0221324861,
0.0100972708,
0.0475728624,
0.0253122281,
0.0523982085,
0.0688673332,
-0.0157765877,
-0.0455319211,
0.0213606786,
-0.0985009968,
0.0234141573,
-0.0717810839,
0.0188809335,
-0.0134990858,
0.0182780027,
0.0433083847,
-0.0442180745,
0.0457748473,
0.0510700867,
-0.0056969272,
-0.0280122496,
0.0587036945,
-0.0279477034,
0.0024950509,
-0.0123448344,
0.0578789376,
-0.0513202585,
-0.0252633467,
-0.0114758629,
0.0098671056,
0.0137668373,
-0.0469868854,
-0.0633609816,
0.0156179424,
0.0412655957,
0.0018873424,
0.0355566256,
0.0315566286,
0.0307968948,
-0.0170860458,
-0.0667397976,
0.0460892431,
0.0079809548,
-0.0409290604,
-0.045324631,
-0.0030628142,
-0.0427705534,
0.0028095525,
-0.0072494135,
0.0522067919,
0.017677445,
0.0109873954,
-0.0398229398,
0.0188080296,
0.0082784081,
-0.0120657207,
0.0288167018,
0.0669267848,
-0.0199670158,
0.0605044886,
-0.0333446264,
0.0752867833,
-0.0749130026,
0.0487021655,
-0.0344162099,
0.0320370831,
0.0219905991,
-0.0058446564,
-0.0681575388,
-0.0366011895,
-0.0387129821,
-0.0446398593,
-0.0013469731,
0.0530069582,
0.0126235858,
-0.0125196716,
0.0456270725,
0.012415193,
-0.0563462749,
-0.0261293482,
0.0624808893,
0.0305327307,
-0.0278987456,
0.0048816786,
0.0074733947,
-0.0200365875,
-0.0706182867,
0.0457935557,
0.0035214371,
-0.0245505273,
-0.0170421787,
0.0743878856,
0.001237805,
-0.0604654513,
-0.0044125426,
0.0326436721,
-0.0734402239,
-0.0531667471,
-0.0063257441,
-0.0390140228,
0.019993186,
-0.0066969302,
0.0077348831,
-0.0000474741,
0.0008997017,
0.0162204802,
-0.0049028657,
0.0510482527,
0.0440099463,
0.0152145382,
0.0094935661,
0.0169513281,
0.0046381489,
0.0743734017,
0.0312987044,
0.0382387713,
-0.0082081342,
0.0016714215,
-0.0074505955,
0.0381211787,
0.016350707,
0.0037199461,
-0.0328740664,
0.0096396906,
0.0053367601,
0.0266113933,
0.0629153177,
0.0316731744,
-0.0298001226,
-0.0431998894,
0.0398931168,
0.047397349,
0.0314598717,
0.0244233552,
0.0521778315,
-0.0014486117,
-0.0378855988,
0.0084340498,
-0.0930048898,
0.0587093793,
0.0656221136,
0.0409487486,
0.0359656885,
0.0367113985,
-0.0284235701,
-0.018094033,
-0.0021990859,
-0.0016995562,
-0.0108169056,
-0.0045476221,
0.013264453,
0.0022824577,
-0.0452275351,
0.0456856191,
-0.0043213689,
-0.0278542414,
-0.0347517356,
-0.0420895107,
0.0024903608,
0.0556919985,
0.0049076439,
-0.0445222966,
-0.0406814814,
-0.0124819716,
0.0134562701,
0.0458430238,
0.0186603535,
0.0308454763,
0.0239391048,
-0.0156962071,
-0.0086864354,
-0.0223150533,
0.026037721,
0.0128520224,
0.0635204837,
0.0278730318,
0.0336676054,
-0.0240077153,
0.0562107787,
0.0221794732,
-0.0264699552,
-0.0255908053,
-0.0548948422,
0.0160407554,
0.0168079883,
-0.0010645671,
0.0021110894,
0.0147460578,
0.0506725088,
-0.0512739606,
0.0432660431,
0.0016934512,
-0.1185761318,
-0.0553674214,
0.0463675968,
-0.0198589172,
-0.0048773368,
0.0363237523,
-0.0263352264,
-0.0470533706,
0.0336649604,
-0.0266490038,
0.0693700239,
-0.0204816666,
0.0139078712,
0.0062678079,
0.050191585,
-0.0381608158,
0.0402399376,
-0.0161986891,
0.0104642836,
0.018829843,
0.0281575937,
-0.0238821357,
-0.0286206864,
-0.0290132631,
-0.0036414848,
-0.0029001464,
0.0094386702,
-0.031478595,
0.0010847662,
-0.009202091,
-0.0678829625,
-0.0608925559,
0.0044404068,
-0.0403053239,
0.0228398424,
0.0248362143,
0.0283064023,
-0.0259345789,
-0.0107751787,
-0.0132756084,
-0.0043950006,
-0.0198299717,
0.0045344518,
0.0100011406,
0.0072701606,
-0.0287930258,
-0.0481272899,
-0.0145934494,
0.0226054098,
0.0408522971,
-0.0131724449,
-0.0181366839,
-0.0764573365,
0.0186548699,
0.0354522131,
0.0215305686,
-0.0507510304,
-0.0342039466,
-0.0194641203,
-0.0450537503,
0.0435241647,
0.1054087132,
-0.0200375896,
0.0115657095,
0.0400693677,
0.0087969564,
-0.0220418144,
0.0309766065,
-0.0326039344,
-0.0174916442,
-0.0479733944,
0.0403285958,
0.0017317284,
0.0972795337,
-0.0643561631,
-0.019202793,
-0.0465907566,
-0.0148777906,
0.0087340809,
-0.0050288653,
0.0271242112,
-0.0078246975,
-0.0617322363,
0.0007839478,
-0.0410097614,
-0.0650604516,
0.0419771969,
-0.0422077961,
-0.0372228585,
-0.0032340474,
0.0120576648,
-0.060942132,
0.0605776533,
0.037771862,
0.0145905912,
-0.0380412638,
-0.0290204491,
-0.0381666906,
0.0384698361,
-0.0476237573,
0.009560803,
0.0887512267,
0.0209608413,
0.01149379,
-0.0298416577,
-0.0367245674,
-0.0360556692,
-0.013351541,
-0.0242287479,
-0.0129231038,
0.0207050759,
-0.0360652544,
-0.0135838846,
0.0322466418,
0.010889248,
0.1019596234,
-0.0209184717,
0.0246801488,
-0.0324747302,
0.0149676194,
0.0352024101,
0.0546574816,
0.0020682723,
-0.0201522633,
0.0173998401,
0.023764614,
0.0205297358,
0.0080553638,
-0.0203906931,
0.0057813353,
0.017341502,
-0.0195491612,
-0.0158351902,
-0.0030029039,
0.048986502,
-0.0691296384,
-0.0287737828,
0.0803587139,
0.0196919534,
-0.0875532627,
0.0043441318,
-0.0299759321,
0.0640258119,
0.0381121486,
0.0459178723,
-0.036091093,
-0.0225676987,
0.007989835,
0.0010626086,
0.05757045,
0.0028467984,
-0.0177677907,
-0.0868157297,
0.0355719253,
0.0217871033,
-0.0187343825,
-0.03704492,
-0.0165972561,
0.0141328555,
0.0038537765,
0.0020171246,
0.0434082001,
-0.0324258953,
-0.0290515143,
0.0070249364,
0.0042601312,
-0.0286180116,
0.0017953155,
0.000896405,
0.0154441474,
0.0085786199,
-0.0021161661,
0.0119978208,
-0.0355022289,
0.0222371556,
-0.009537397,
0.0125937313,
0.0365837701,
0.0045241676,
-0.0245240703,
-0.0216182899,
0.0344070457,
0.0183085389,
-0.0436500795,
-0.007983055,
-0.0114977183,
0.0957585052,
0.0107388981,
-0.0045364331,
-0.0034694469,
-0.0034653738,
-0.0363518111,
0.04964827,
0.0618985407,
-0.0195825733,
-0.0378185995,
-0.0238536019,
-0.0033789738,
-0.0284227822,
-0.0257350449,
0.0100776786,
0.047717385,
-0.0529437773,
-0.0367254093,
-0.0240602139,
0.0167671256,
0.0433913209,
-0.0043664109,
-0.0204207748,
-0.0294836946,
-0.0121567706,
-0.0619515516,
0.0157705974,
-0.0400677808,
0.012466995,
-0.0444130152,
0.059100531,
0.0458236448,
-0.0140874544,
0.0006592693,
0.0215205196,
-0.1214583144,
-0.0627460256,
0.0087845456,
0.0525935292,
0.0214443859,
0.0760966316,
-0.0303082243,
-0.0013430683,
0.0239950325,
0.0290225632,
-0.0231753644,
0.048120331,
0.0324237272,
0.0041417703,
0.0143998712,
0.0428288728,
-0.020700248,
0.0114542926,
-0.0157544911,
0.0200229678,
-0.0472133495,
-0.0219808556,
0.0059224139,
-0.0632687137,
0.0417825282,
-0.0017728596,
0.0772391334,
-0.0123624299,
0.0451833606,
-0.0127710598,
0.0250431504,
-0.0505429171,
-0.00114659,
0.0280276854,
-0.0091364169,
0.0336568952,
-0.0133790551,
0.0142679662,
-0.0341704115,
-0.0109461267,
0.0479064249,
-0.0340248011,
-0.0192003008,
0.0269653741,
0.0321528986,
-0.0147014689,
-0.019482946,
-0.0133319655,
0.0298624784,
-0.0271215513,
0.0196593888,
0.0051317168,
-0.0201818272,
-0.0355579816,
0.0388249271,
-0.0788573325,
-0.0188347194,
-0.0267648194,
0.033419542,
0.0446848758,
-0.0187957287,
0.0509685613,
0.0103603033,
-0.0337475725,
-0.002020211,
0.0082767075,
-0.0112908939,
-0.0342447013,
0.0183541458,
0.0403017811,
0.0057307733,
0.0062125088,
0.0543139838,
0.0293433107,
0.0026916831,
0.0252567753,
-0.002438952,
-0.0192588996,
-0.0514685623,
-0.0147024449,
0.0024266483,
-0.002855733,
0.0039035804,
-0.013969834,
-0.0758930147,
-0.0018057858,
-0.0142678982,
-0.0429129153,
-0.0330222808,
0.0081329867,
0.0171395745,
-0.0133737894,
-0.0335499495,
-0.0114730708,
-0.0047579054,
0.0348210335,
-0.0295965616,
0.0216906369,
-6.230621849e-33,
-0.0242913589,
0.0115675889,
0.0148957223,
-0.0217480399,
-0.0651493222,
0.0128475195,
-0.0358021408,
-0.0030937982,
-0.0100240698,
-0.0104650557,
-0.0255248379,
0.0055590984,
0.0090937382,
0.0350180194,
-0.0150482357,
-0.0000435542,
0.0141299786,
0.0274292976,
-0.0146215688,
0.0290923305,
-0.0149541171,
0.0346298218,
0.0591705143,
-0.0239744093,
-0.0225648712,
-0.0052908855,
-0.012516465,
0.0135507742,
-0.0049748425,
0.0740016699,
-0.0434252471,
0.0147839822,
0.0149731357,
-0.0615043007,
-0.0377767235,
0.0371801965,
-0.0739060193,
-0.0201651081,
-0.0092956675,
0.0108437939,
-0.0289069749,
-0.0472838432,
0.0569527484,
0.0068234429,
-0.0027706795,
-0.050682269,
0.0019460937,
-0.0200835299,
-0.0482607447,
0.0332954638,
-0.0427997448,
0.0159564689,
0.0085777035,
-0.0175444782,
0.0178449415,
0.0180019103,
0.0062839095,
0.0372025333,
-0.0326633267,
0.0000018178,
0.0138621069,
0.0858644769,
0.0644795895,
0.0264973603,
0.0243243333,
0.0082246345,
0.0023514957,
-0.0216609053,
-0.0472221784,
-0.0715374127,
0.0199669749,
0.0335889906,
0.0068356926,
-0.0081118224,
0.0255945288,
-0.0012484902,
-0.0425879732,
-0.0250003338,
-0.034829475,
0.051315967,
0.037801411,
0.024707932,
-0.0258019082,
-0.020770235,
-0.0052360012,
-0.0106543964,
-0.0205135867,
-0.0170601923,
0.0553058833,
0.0535162836,
-0.0104820924,
0.0296904799,
0.0498034731,
-0.0493182391,
0.015429114,
0.0340130776,
-0.0301657543,
0.0513849594,
-0.0006320617,
0.040381588,
-0.0315283202,
0.0108747473,
-0.0085259685,
0.0109683154,
-0.0039999043,
-0.0258121639,
0.0564491414,
0.0395778343,
-0.0858322605,
-0.0338852033,
-0.0329630189,
-0.0012863736,
-0.0074032969,
0.0151987663,
0.0552662425,
-0.0161209591,
0.0069358745,
0.0830390751,
0.0163915288,
0.013876142,
-0.0063314964,
-0.009188748,
-0.0095408848,
0.0392160527,
-0.0234835017,
0.0004965611,
-0.0351583511,
0.0369862728,
0.0025088515,
-0.0963503867,
-0.0273019727,
0.000566588,
2.754e-7,
0.0546442159,
0.0196537506,
0.0444017313,
-0.005949086,
0.0408335887,
-0.0115960287,
0.0082658129,
0.0651279837,
-0.012574967,
-0.009139467,
0.0190184861,
0.0398188084,
0.0135083813,
-0.0178071614,
-0.1129799187,
0.0316962674,
-0.0618643425,
0.003931521,
-0.038891755,
-0.0467187464,
-0.0054607848,
0.1384172589,
-0.0113172941,
0.023380613,
-0.0073588011,
-0.044383686,
0.0448830687,
-0.0238764063,
0.0194912329,
0.0081972312,
0.020897327,
0.0209311042,
-0.0335601531,
-0.0539340414,
0.0183576401,
0.069028914,
-0.0043857102,
0.0948357433,
0.0021395974,
-0.0263378713,
0.0152007183,
-0.0072261789,
-0.0139616616,
-0.0951991379,
0.051719036,
-0.0906898677,
0.0006919552,
-0.0297180247,
-0.0163650308,
-0.0191944595,
-0.0023721403,
0.0029056168,
0.0268873107,
-0.0034081882,
0.0180161428,
-0.0315944515,
-0.012732395,
-0.114400737,
-0.0386314392,
0.0015242472,
-0.071913898,
0.0076372554,
-0.0656205565,
-0.0307140835,
0.052695822,
-0.0136274798,
-0.0167643912,
2.642876576e-34,
0.027239766,
-0.023076918,
0.0309118237,
0.0145966485,
-0.0054399017,
-0.0213636234,
0.0089692893,
0.0154383415,
0.0462965257,
-0.0836449265,
-0.0325624645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08272v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08272v1 | Structural Self-Supervised Objectives for Transformers | 2023-09-15T09:30:45 | 2023-09-15T09:30:45 | Luca Di Liello | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | This thesis focuses on improving the pre-training of natural language models
using unsupervised raw data to make them more efficient and aligned with
downstream applications.
In the first part, we introduce three alternative pre-training objectives to
BERT's Masked Language Modeling (MLM), namely Random Token Substitution (RTS),
Cluster-based Random Token Substitution (C-RTS), and Swapped Language Modeling
(SLM). These objectives involve token swapping instead of masking, with RTS and
C-RTS aiming to predict token originality and SLM predicting the original token
values. Results show that RTS and C-RTS require less pre-training time while
maintaining performance comparable to MLM. Surprisingly, SLM outperforms MLM on
certain tasks despite using the same computational budget.
In the second part, we proposes self-supervised pre-training tasks that align
structurally with downstream applications, reducing the need for labeled data.
We use large corpora like Wikipedia and CC-News to train models to recognize if
text spans originate from the same paragraph or document in several ways. By
doing continuous pre-training, starting from existing models like RoBERTa,
ELECTRA, DeBERTa, BART, and T5, we demonstrate significant performance
improvements in tasks like Fact Verification, Answer Sentence Selection, and
Summarization. These improvements are especially pronounced when limited
annotation data is available. The proposed objectives also achieve
state-of-the-art results on various benchmark datasets, including FEVER (dev
set), ASNQ, WikiQA, and TREC-QA, as well as enhancing the quality of summaries.
Importantly, these techniques can be easily integrated with other methods
without altering the internal structure of Transformer models, making them
versatile for various NLP applications. | [
0.059091676,
0.0305038001,
0.0210111104,
0.0321198255,
-0.0426748805,
-0.0011395661,
0.0069697867,
-0.0282857232,
0.0293520074,
-0.0928934142,
-0.0212139469,
0.0105916969,
-0.0205420516,
0.0076234667,
0.0242527034,
-0.0402957648,
0.0433760472,
-0.019660376,
-0.0044911904,
0.0003016436,
0.0088694431,
-0.0004504805,
0.0052984278,
0.0244837031,
-0.0351357274,
-0.0073699374,
0.0238567479,
0.0041840342,
0.0028823924,
-0.0075882128,
0.0502831377,
0.0815014094,
0.00058385,
0.0228264239,
0.0000020279,
-0.0643176213,
-0.0381370224,
-0.0041829166,
-0.0195071418,
0.0201294124,
0.0204017553,
-0.0085093593,
0.0137898279,
0.0309474003,
-0.0276866462,
-0.0298234206,
0.0275821518,
0.07233046,
0.1004930511,
0.0699203163,
-0.0109228864,
-0.0355083831,
0.014149433,
-0.0051350575,
-0.0238166582,
0.0179085396,
0.0354003347,
-0.0264627673,
-0.0562560335,
-0.0024756717,
-0.0006077489,
0.0285223424,
-0.0017499275,
-0.0098062176,
0.0424181148,
0.026344344,
-0.0908020586,
-0.0188874342,
-0.0042970651,
0.0597333834,
-0.0237283967,
-0.0619687065,
0.0375729799,
0.0280544199,
-0.0174186509,
0.027735766,
-0.0065646046,
0.0209339559,
0.0084171789,
0.0217383467,
-0.000115672,
0.0120736305,
0.0064278929,
0.0066265073,
-0.0589151867,
0.0610634759,
0.0472654253,
-0.0243697241,
-0.0344632119,
-0.0050176485,
-0.0271381494,
-0.0819744691,
0.0207783151,
0.0272283312,
0.0070699952,
0.007165323,
-0.0751053616,
-0.0500762388,
0.0173979755,
-0.054279428,
-0.0388211571,
0.011336172,
-0.0345358439,
0.0402010456,
-0.042858202,
0.028055869,
0.0007196673,
0.0664416701,
-0.0515213609,
-0.0214375891,
-0.033821065,
-0.022629641,
-0.0775409266,
0.068359226,
-0.0386604778,
-0.0221135896,
-0.0235259943,
0.0195754524,
0.0179178696,
-0.019319294,
0.0316524319,
-0.0106548881,
-0.017583305,
0.0204036571,
-0.0029179363,
0.0174579844,
-0.0186552797,
-0.0158551782,
0.0002205976,
-0.0392076485,
-0.0281810574,
0.0278742593,
0.0234665126,
-0.0336878337,
0.018799182,
0.0574419014,
-0.0142894732,
-0.0380143151,
-0.0292294174,
0.013569396,
-0.0261861105,
-0.0357506834,
0.0059611867,
-0.0756817013,
0.0141692683,
0.0186020955,
0.0085498933,
-0.000778908,
0.0177923571,
0.034059111,
-0.0150903659,
0.0764718652,
-0.0204906017,
-0.0029564623,
0.0395792052,
-0.0090471115,
0.0343199559,
0.0488869101,
0.0395255499,
0.003104832,
0.0776937157,
-0.0012646271,
0.0180204678,
0.0374414213,
0.0232141037,
-0.0194152649,
0.0296956915,
0.0160736833,
0.0024131231,
-0.0019162558,
0.0162636936,
0.0800393671,
-0.0227066111,
-0.0023468439,
0.0556249954,
0.0486271568,
-0.0072939056,
0.0098852785,
0.0366224647,
0.0274246205,
0.0498646274,
0.0403075404,
-0.0306056403,
0.0011572659,
-0.0084479917,
0.0150400354,
0.0081177177,
0.020408975,
-0.0423309542,
-0.026358325,
-0.0293361451,
-0.0126656275,
-0.0102982484,
-0.0298888646,
0.0425874814,
0.0543258339,
-0.036793299,
0.1200922355,
0.0113278767,
-0.075858891,
0.0255910624,
-0.0546794981,
-0.0043570064,
0.013758081,
0.040216215,
-0.0451444499,
-0.0371676534,
-0.0153402975,
-0.0069212853,
0.0424888209,
0.0332655646,
-0.0241941735,
-0.0151382564,
-0.0357207917,
-0.0184299946,
-0.0265838858,
0.0090716993,
-0.0122141503,
0.0274225883,
-0.0114527363,
0.0208023787,
-0.086619705,
-0.02280402,
0.0673973635,
-0.0007874538,
-0.0311379302,
0.019985931,
0.0140828015,
0.0115345158,
0.0120288096,
-0.0207865499,
0.0202765167,
0.0302851405,
-0.0321141183,
-0.0383602567,
0.030753063,
-0.056092985,
-0.0743458644,
0.0472497828,
-0.0576170012,
-0.0160644092,
0.0655318126,
-0.0375116765,
-0.0489600413,
0.0072303996,
-0.0615885295,
0.0472328737,
-0.0516875982,
0.0171127096,
0.0183334369,
0.0049690027,
-0.0166609325,
0.0642806739,
0.0259004589,
-0.0046175784,
-0.0006475424,
-0.0293056518,
0.0436344482,
-0.0065564197,
-0.0536705963,
-0.0412551612,
-0.0337165594,
0.0012392856,
0.0520370789,
-0.0013925665,
-0.0393277034,
-0.0234247055,
-0.0957918465,
-0.0060898159,
-0.0418067053,
0.0095700501,
0.042388726,
0.0309509598,
-0.0058401856,
-0.0135788247,
-0.0214194935,
-0.0788076147,
-0.008700653,
0.0027363955,
0.0472034067,
-0.0056002392,
0.0190009903,
-0.0236983448,
-0.0234480426,
-0.033307422,
0.0638184845,
0.0052727503,
-0.0348361544,
-0.0316452272,
-0.0232117493,
-0.0043735974,
0.0319358446,
0.0093482099,
-0.0345311202,
-0.0308304708,
0.0083302408,
0.08035364,
0.0262317639,
0.0565857589,
-0.0092710378,
0.0129301716,
-0.0057864524,
-0.0353316367,
0.0148314573,
-0.0417734012,
0.0365514942,
0.0032260071,
-0.0196212959,
0.0642003268,
0.0567924604,
0.0033902263,
-0.0369526297,
-0.0153723089,
-0.0205957647,
-0.027674187,
-0.0121227261,
-0.010770563,
-0.0162277445,
-0.0068126502,
0.0116792172,
-0.0231505521,
-0.0003615603,
0.078003414,
-0.0545372032,
0.0154860644,
-0.0794395357,
0.0123242671,
-0.0529850982,
0.020368509,
0.0341627635,
0.0081918053,
0.0084659718,
-0.0255545452,
-0.0173302647,
-0.0021352042,
0.0248195771,
-0.0162129216,
0.0517101586,
-0.0185096487,
0.0308893025,
0.0085520679,
-0.0355769917,
-0.0523361042,
-0.0759952068,
0.007540978,
0.0126966527,
0.0334208682,
0.0041972012,
-0.0360074937,
0.0268567856,
0.0153961955,
0.0946325809,
-0.022508081,
-0.0026201468,
-0.0122401109,
0.0752070695,
0.0513320081,
-0.0167249087,
0.0394728333,
-0.0171825774,
0.0126253199,
0.0310842115,
0.0519565754,
-0.0242872834,
-0.0170059539,
-0.0165425092,
0.0079363007,
-0.0991021395,
0.0195796844,
-0.0251503885,
0.0455474183,
-0.0040969965,
-0.0312130637,
0.133521229,
0.0313490927,
-0.008012712,
-0.0190652721,
0.0007326049,
0.0131767727,
0.0200327169,
0.0288526118,
-0.0622246675,
-0.0241591763,
0.0026124192,
0.0262185559,
0.0017194498,
-0.0280828234,
0.0049965424,
-0.111344777,
0.0152312685,
-0.0368400402,
-0.0576603562,
-0.0175132882,
-0.0545125082,
-0.0003067172,
-0.0354307964,
0.0093496786,
-0.0142363729,
-0.0280435123,
-0.000602036,
0.0291027352,
-0.0828823447,
-0.0063391044,
-0.0059339358,
-0.0344820842,
0.0114613883,
0.0250565745,
0.0154045597,
-0.0166897587,
-0.01888467,
0.0539377891,
-0.0259485543,
-0.0202809125,
-0.0005800503,
0.0928965434,
-0.0373627841,
-0.017865371,
-0.0195106827,
0.0359318852,
0.0041049197,
-0.0393787473,
-0.0232428163,
0.0371479727,
0.0236059129,
-0.0226082299,
-0.0182993133,
0.0146316607,
0.0024097855,
0.0947562978,
0.0188238192,
-0.0263203327,
-0.0350887217,
0.0031854408,
0.0261471551,
-0.0566445589,
-0.029844515,
0.0008897483,
-0.0159051977,
-0.0332294963,
-0.085647881,
-0.0229722634,
0.0300487354,
0.0279126242,
0.0185298864,
-0.0085686706,
0.0157911591,
-0.0007879799,
-0.0564802401,
0.0192733388,
-0.0569721684,
-0.0242739618,
-0.0475872457,
-0.0210278817,
0.0418170467,
-0.0248958692,
-0.024570534,
-0.0063131643,
-0.0639370531,
-0.0476874411,
0.0374840312,
0.0778022557,
0.0153100314,
0.0733373389,
-0.0174529087,
-0.0242334902,
0.0879777074,
0.0528096147,
-0.0619836003,
0.0017713126,
0.0074117263,
0.0009809808,
-0.0141625945,
0.019255612,
-0.0415559299,
0.0359804817,
0.0128712831,
0.0456325673,
-0.001257917,
-0.0111700194,
0.0357500054,
0.0444930308,
0.079207547,
-0.0114209466,
0.0626383647,
-0.0437883399,
0.018619068,
-0.0092604728,
-0.0213581994,
-0.0158698577,
0.0317597799,
-0.0236331858,
-0.0013830707,
-0.0231978465,
0.0754697248,
-0.048487734,
0.0106263682,
-0.0165377688,
-0.0079688933,
-0.0132200252,
0.0097204223,
-0.0256533101,
-0.0201560557,
-0.0212503858,
-0.0325574316,
0.0351288766,
0.006776501,
-0.0137395673,
-0.0159444604,
0.0421010926,
0.0067820633,
0.0005333854,
0.0334656313,
-0.0805580318,
0.0233835578,
-0.0623251647,
0.0106683737,
0.022055069,
-0.0515534803,
0.0486548655,
-0.0202639289,
-0.0358111523,
-0.016636638,
0.015730489,
0.0331372805,
0.0115877651,
-0.0071175834,
0.0002151229,
-0.0262336284,
0.0003944834,
0.0832574591,
-0.0028519847,
0.0442958511,
0.0272925496,
-0.0228681918,
-0.0664437115,
-0.0000699226,
-0.0021314344,
-0.0109732784,
-0.0126477191,
-0.0365132093,
-0.0226287581,
-0.0490236916,
0.0555552244,
-0.0033239762,
-0.00188545,
0.0158347953,
0.045422934,
0.0561063588,
0.022246547,
-0.0258443858,
-0.030365441,
0.0257731713,
0.0660101771,
-0.0082221022,
0.0164749939,
-6.729497243e-33,
-0.014834688,
-0.0226884279,
-0.0103967953,
0.0331721157,
0.0093408553,
0.0152258268,
-0.0336421877,
-0.0220393073,
-0.0044804211,
0.0220270623,
-0.0170019921,
0.004750255,
0.022443993,
0.0534200147,
-0.0168489963,
0.0021995744,
0.0711130723,
-0.0023007737,
-0.042119056,
-0.005823432,
0.0177621655,
0.032793425,
0.0767319128,
-0.0375089757,
-0.0130275292,
-0.0185755864,
-0.0010969198,
0.0249674488,
0.0230808593,
0.0379531607,
-0.0080029527,
0.0161594041,
0.0223913826,
-0.0437298641,
-0.0203837994,
0.0216179937,
-0.1123124063,
-0.0404604636,
0.0183080751,
0.0020000413,
-0.0362359919,
-0.0195471197,
0.0470041856,
-0.0348050334,
-0.0034698404,
-0.0031136759,
0.0635478422,
0.015140919,
0.0118820984,
-0.0446730368,
-0.0577287897,
0.0259408057,
-0.0111653814,
-0.022757465,
-0.0054440303,
0.0506268181,
0.0053573297,
0.0292549506,
-0.0857900903,
0.0383222029,
0.0001287187,
0.0375935137,
0.0311371405,
0.0157306753,
-0.000874947,
0.057856515,
0.0232983958,
-0.010203273,
-0.0362916403,
-0.0144255441,
0.0342045762,
0.0320106484,
0.0399976969,
0.0104301171,
0.011665348,
0.014317858,
-0.0869693384,
0.0687828958,
-0.0276049897,
0.0062419539,
0.0142743001,
-0.0329164639,
0.011444889,
-0.0001823985,
-0.0384675637,
-0.0052449335,
-0.031402152,
0.0211617276,
0.0034701463,
0.0313830785,
-0.0616151504,
0.0145098679,
0.0129158441,
-0.033922594,
-0.0155186942,
-0.0025291734,
-0.0055918409,
0.0087305773,
-0.018424781,
0.0393762924,
-0.0390977636,
0.000566737,
0.0236309431,
0.0129454546,
-0.0032762438,
0.0087567819,
0.0647848621,
0.0212446619,
-0.0639057383,
0.0128294844,
0.0016967498,
0.0102115991,
-0.033389587,
0.0091932584,
0.0132803218,
0.0300030187,
0.0027697552,
0.0232176892,
0.0284840986,
0.0141095184,
-0.031299267,
0.0274422932,
0.0252018142,
0.0412876047,
-0.0051842933,
-0.001014752,
-0.0232872423,
0.0472614355,
-0.0118047539,
-0.0683769286,
0.0051792017,
0.0035810673,
2.751e-7,
0.0684450716,
0.0583886877,
0.0600271598,
-0.0341354832,
-0.0006595589,
0.0241960846,
0.0102429949,
0.0521774255,
0.0258017257,
-0.0083532967,
-0.0014071419,
0.0121432357,
0.0101543721,
0.0147177307,
-0.1050358489,
-0.0105184922,
-0.0697262809,
0.0074333604,
-0.0306210797,
-0.018298436,
0.0275622327,
0.0974222645,
0.0051490795,
-0.0099450191,
-0.0482907183,
-0.0187485591,
0.0688283145,
0.0040294696,
-0.0327295102,
0.0583812743,
0.0285691563,
0.0220769048,
-0.000242669,
0.0171401035,
-0.0533200204,
0.0112777846,
0.0476503298,
0.0305064153,
0.0122818314,
-0.0460483544,
-0.0019788078,
-0.0073327897,
-0.0015195525,
-0.0312490389,
0.0771420151,
-0.0819296688,
-0.0093745347,
-0.0125276297,
-0.0569378026,
0.0109140538,
0.0036757912,
-0.0179182198,
-0.0476159714,
0.0640730932,
0.0319418944,
0.0269412231,
-0.0197290014,
-0.0779845193,
-0.0170230772,
-0.042897027,
-0.0355152674,
-0.0208407901,
-0.029328607,
-0.0154553587,
0.0270363893,
-0.0476907082,
0.029044183,
2.829910355e-34,
0.0451991484,
-0.0007071602,
-0.0337665416,
0.0052444879,
0.0040250318,
-0.039695479,
-0.0046707653,
-0.0051461696,
-0.0187311061,
-0.0831023306,
-0.0072560627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08255v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08255v1 | Cross-lingual Knowledge Distillation via Flow-based Voice Conversion for Robust Polyglot Text-To-Speech | 2023-09-15T09:03:14 | 2023-09-15T09:03:14 | Dariusz Piotrowski, Renard Korzeniowski, Alessio Falai, Sebastian Cygert, Kamil Pokora, Georgi Tinchev, Ziyao Zhang, Kayoko Yanagisawa | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | In this work, we introduce a framework for cross-lingual speech synthesis,
which involves an upstream Voice Conversion (VC) model and a downstream
Text-To-Speech (TTS) model. The proposed framework consists of 4 stages. In the
first two stages, we use a VC model to convert utterances in the target locale
to the voice of the target speaker. In the third stage, the converted data is
combined with the linguistic features and durations from recordings in the
target language, which are then used to train a single-speaker acoustic model.
Finally, the last stage entails the training of a locale-independent vocoder.
Our evaluations show that the proposed paradigm outperforms state-of-the-art
approaches which are based on training a large multilingual TTS model. In
addition, our experiments demonstrate the robustness of our approach with
different model architectures, languages, speakers and amounts of data.
Moreover, our solution is especially beneficial in low-resource settings. | [
-0.0265307035,
0.0216985494,
-0.0063189454,
-0.0052747498,
-0.0180571619,
-0.0401788764,
0.0193508342,
-0.0214828886,
-0.0389034934,
-0.0043899566,
-0.0436941199,
-0.0504799746,
0.0360115394,
0.0512057208,
0.0294770058,
-0.1054852679,
0.0091617098,
-0.0646568462,
-0.0160564426,
-0.0253976285,
0.0178957544,
0.0390248597,
-0.0178279597,
0.0042462307,
0.0100340219,
-0.0085945399,
-0.0050405748,
-0.0151144471,
-0.0039626034,
0.0506137535,
-0.0229248963,
-0.036775399,
0.0613207333,
0.0141942473,
0.0000021678,
-0.0315413959,
-0.0069153956,
-0.0035999217,
-0.0035395066,
-0.0048574978,
0.0000819398,
-0.0203620624,
-0.0052762707,
0.038977541,
0.0074506286,
-0.0404698402,
0.0367541946,
0.0160107967,
0.0376547463,
0.0680907741,
-0.0116060302,
-0.0608095974,
0.036122527,
-0.0057454999,
-0.0207477193,
-0.0129048629,
-0.0453440621,
0.0175541602,
-0.0068308581,
-0.041907914,
-0.0732915029,
0.0943532735,
-0.000238659,
-0.022454882,
-0.0307790544,
-0.0033070131,
-0.0030251485,
-0.0488800071,
-0.0163588189,
0.0494811237,
-0.0143758599,
-0.0112272762,
0.0101002846,
0.0134205222,
-0.021991225,
-0.012706493,
0.0091842534,
-0.0022308026,
0.0337444916,
-0.0197282117,
-0.0012937732,
0.0663847104,
-0.0101314709,
-0.0691349059,
-0.0222933665,
-0.0524038933,
0.0213742312,
-0.0251984857,
0.0184276197,
-0.0062245619,
0.032401301,
-0.0163775329,
0.0516379476,
0.0073463786,
0.0088991066,
0.0067379749,
-0.0086665563,
-0.0143978819,
-0.0624580309,
-0.0373434313,
-0.0004608048,
0.0511258096,
-0.0345173478,
-0.0236610845,
-0.0083355429,
0.0534071065,
-0.019635858,
0.0013367514,
-0.0301483776,
-0.0549300164,
-0.0372101106,
0.0085521098,
-0.0555817783,
-0.0152727701,
-0.0546761155,
0.0038124237,
-0.0260864086,
-0.0103082834,
-0.0315373875,
0.0191468075,
0.0293539185,
-0.0142341657,
-0.0307820551,
-0.0491300412,
0.0160293523,
0.0888297632,
0.0233141407,
0.0051400103,
-0.0416637361,
-0.0455057435,
0.0073850616,
0.0241098404,
0.0101945065,
-0.0042928495,
-0.0016142869,
0.0414476469,
-0.0387688316,
-0.0103862854,
-0.0459660403,
-0.0366818085,
-0.0314024426,
-0.0744874328,
-0.0008274266,
-0.0856346041,
0.0478086285,
-0.0233041905,
0.0115049873,
-0.0197854992,
-0.0112761371,
-0.0405462347,
0.0002034512,
0.0136833023,
0.0228633378,
0.0667730793,
0.0579060763,
-0.000042525,
0.0216950029,
0.0803079456,
0.0809366405,
-0.0129651874,
0.0034907756,
-0.0511138812,
-0.0002304899,
0.0999631435,
0.0290077422,
0.0367346816,
-0.0194214787,
0.0042743389,
0.0006491292,
0.0192155968,
0.0704017058,
0.0598850027,
-0.0238453764,
0.0348905027,
0.0727774873,
-0.0094346683,
0.042971503,
0.0287469029,
0.0902659446,
0.0224468969,
-0.0266372003,
0.0106191589,
0.0138131715,
0.0039810208,
0.0015763954,
0.0222782791,
0.0440275259,
0.0730287358,
-0.0572808497,
-0.0162120573,
0.0339519605,
-0.0379171446,
-0.0037858624,
0.0161717143,
0.0351117216,
0.0406316258,
-0.0288328398,
0.0579277761,
0.0040597701,
-0.0939826146,
0.0684359148,
0.0293091703,
-0.0252367314,
0.0374420509,
-0.0017791657,
0.0571334697,
0.031407997,
-0.0684594214,
-0.0211887583,
0.0379781425,
0.0283843689,
-0.0308549125,
0.0618597828,
-0.0653456077,
-0.0115547115,
0.0305928309,
-0.0286799669,
0.0369274244,
-0.0533147007,
0.0624642223,
0.0186098963,
-0.0243148431,
0.0457588695,
-0.0208199825,
-0.0903758183,
-0.002102464,
0.0265560634,
0.0264128558,
0.0177312363,
0.0490948185,
-0.0044764006,
0.0025246977,
-0.0057457131,
-0.0520156547,
-0.0039424114,
0.0591265932,
-0.0322519131,
-0.0588058867,
0.0102532012,
-0.0269152112,
0.0259626135,
-0.0065398873,
0.0279452484,
-0.1042434201,
0.0522318706,
0.0059500393,
0.018006254,
-0.0017503223,
0.0159367751,
0.0313577726,
0.022609273,
0.0575847626,
-0.022567112,
0.0251280814,
-0.0067639793,
0.0115769831,
0.0196478423,
0.0150616765,
-0.0450039729,
-0.0056129438,
0.0513688289,
-0.0021283268,
0.0132856546,
0.0172535405,
0.0258127693,
0.0309283491,
-0.005859762,
-0.0656267405,
0.0099116238,
-0.0053407131,
0.0255098306,
-0.0068674344,
0.064020589,
0.0110238157,
-0.0094712982,
-0.083984457,
-0.0338576362,
0.0314484835,
-0.0199160986,
-0.0473114923,
-0.0220338963,
-0.0020041466,
0.021950461,
0.0274108946,
0.0444722325,
0.0328623913,
-0.0629100651,
-0.028555274,
-0.0264055282,
0.0215547197,
-0.0190518089,
0.0391366296,
0.0326073654,
-0.01275698,
-0.0204410274,
0.033135429,
0.070547007,
-0.0148356715,
0.002196711,
-0.0618632585,
0.0213108473,
-0.0461291187,
-0.0720454156,
0.0216065366,
0.0073781237,
0.0047516059,
-0.0464724079,
-0.0161814503,
-0.0042583654,
0.0188661143,
0.0370257199,
0.0126195261,
-0.1029901952,
-0.0671683997,
0.0196948312,
-0.0606659278,
0.026434442,
-0.0046232985,
-0.0142729739,
-0.0080197062,
-0.0048932368,
-0.0003209948,
0.0091266194,
-0.0672539622,
-0.0621072501,
-0.0307728276,
-0.0161325503,
-0.0085719414,
0.0308680534,
-0.028092375,
0.037412867,
-0.0159315802,
0.0066608516,
-0.0565366261,
0.0071878885,
-0.0016157333,
-0.037081521,
0.026481539,
-0.0525430553,
-0.0231409743,
-0.016669238,
-0.0427954718,
-0.0100337146,
0.0346408524,
0.0065514599,
0.0397621952,
0.0324090198,
-0.017448809,
-0.0093309013,
0.0561545826,
0.0340624116,
0.0437660851,
0.0122021949,
0.0227097962,
-0.0069829314,
0.0610385574,
0.0041473382,
0.0242964402,
-0.0376535542,
-0.0075920234,
0.0603092983,
0.0017322906,
0.0410642028,
-0.016712904,
-0.0105826985,
-0.0151514476,
0.0401991233,
0.0296791326,
-0.0397036374,
0.0092668058,
0.0720370188,
-0.0236999281,
0.0001773242,
0.0605234504,
-0.0417742245,
-0.0254672263,
-0.0145663386,
0.0334264785,
0.0455546156,
-0.016663339,
0.0083771618,
-0.0582934506,
-0.0137937237,
0.034511067,
0.0326808803,
0.0199115667,
0.0492706262,
-0.0411624126,
-0.1029289663,
0.0136091746,
0.0519793816,
-0.0221772771,
-0.0474188402,
-0.028421348,
-0.0590458661,
-0.0174616072,
0.0203882623,
-0.0096445335,
-0.0038942227,
-0.0030389426,
0.0224281345,
-0.0523246862,
-0.0358045697,
-0.0101120938,
-0.0328291357,
0.0816547275,
0.0633469597,
0.0538262017,
-0.0055081304,
0.0061819479,
-0.0368693322,
-0.040397957,
-0.0262886062,
0.0254756119,
0.0146536967,
0.0191538837,
0.0021305499,
0.0680238232,
0.0369402617,
-0.0245349668,
0.0391028635,
0.0654686093,
0.042119205,
-0.0020362264,
-0.0088627851,
0.0174836237,
0.0222697556,
0.0331599265,
0.0536781177,
-0.0097341407,
-0.0363446176,
-0.0241403989,
0.0037175133,
0.0022294386,
-0.0485092215,
-0.069921501,
0.0178719796,
-0.0150027387,
-0.0500177369,
-0.038455274,
-0.0078647556,
0.0003030939,
0.0427155495,
0.0233071391,
0.0051011019,
0.0156204784,
0.0316070616,
-0.0263586137,
-0.028200848,
-0.021061698,
0.0272413939,
-0.0390279256,
-0.0057875952,
0.0048722886,
-0.0653448328,
0.0194429383,
0.0562862866,
-0.0492183156,
-0.0843697488,
-0.0189750753,
-0.0157437399,
0.0059977439,
0.0790660679,
-0.0159935486,
0.0071562165,
0.0807289705,
-0.0278237741,
-0.0507959686,
0.0421562567,
0.064628616,
0.0352372378,
-0.014786493,
0.0193159506,
-0.0335160531,
0.0102619976,
-0.0165309254,
0.0380621701,
-0.0047253347,
-0.0591951087,
-0.0082157534,
0.0140200257,
-0.0105236871,
-0.0392441526,
0.0596253313,
-0.0231317412,
-0.0016445494,
-0.0244464148,
0.0452006944,
-0.0632596686,
0.0017265409,
0.0492444895,
0.0247570742,
0.0351500474,
0.0189687591,
0.0217936356,
-0.0368526019,
-0.019978201,
-0.0016760544,
0.0273114368,
0.0030436816,
0.0197568461,
0.018603025,
-0.0019118096,
0.0273120012,
0.0189106129,
-0.0009633981,
-0.04948847,
-0.0057305009,
0.0071797026,
0.0273766592,
0.0331464782,
-0.0073142275,
-0.0394195467,
-0.0315732956,
-0.0358343534,
-0.0204191003,
0.0321416147,
0.0168336146,
0.1086263359,
-0.0128044952,
0.0342045575,
-0.0190277323,
0.0286389012,
-0.0581203215,
-0.0031970621,
-0.0311610568,
-0.0370324813,
-0.0264884457,
-0.0061563132,
0.0513468497,
0.0052268547,
0.0263272487,
-0.0299695358,
0.0399690345,
-0.0002971673,
-0.0766778514,
0.0027356667,
-0.0258928705,
-0.0277582556,
-0.0315553136,
-0.0521791466,
-0.0462909862,
0.0106742037,
-0.0314276069,
0.0034096164,
-0.0120839979,
0.0297173448,
-0.0005104215,
-0.0154310968,
0.0285033397,
-0.0290165674,
-0.0212881826,
0.0058015459,
-0.0107613215,
0.0227902178,
-5.334810297e-33,
-0.0179124996,
0.0658910722,
0.0154357189,
-0.0111720096,
-0.0536146499,
-0.0489482321,
-0.0187443309,
-0.0129790464,
-0.0130144767,
0.0067495466,
0.002063209,
-0.0100357188,
0.0010156207,
0.050229758,
-0.0043601119,
0.0361653082,
0.0985283256,
-0.0374822542,
-0.0113602169,
0.0810514539,
0.0777727962,
0.0286745522,
0.0336934924,
-0.0635848343,
-0.014805791,
-0.0271681044,
-0.0170195065,
0.0015362079,
0.0125223231,
0.0104764737,
0.0100177322,
0.0632366762,
-0.0271593127,
-0.0020496857,
-0.0536406226,
-0.0015081735,
-0.0698995367,
0.0029663802,
0.0117383851,
0.0384304747,
0.0009684976,
-0.015020702,
0.0222589951,
-0.0044123833,
-0.0076621487,
-0.0305269174,
-0.0085667968,
-0.0453143902,
-0.0118204812,
-0.0998062938,
-0.0417204835,
0.0139472513,
-0.0440440178,
-0.0411910526,
0.1032064408,
0.0875829011,
-0.029329231,
-0.0676780194,
-0.0465345643,
0.0708027184,
-0.0356684327,
0.049434904,
0.0528599173,
0.0125126513,
-0.0136182262,
0.0078180581,
0.0398751833,
-0.0692479834,
0.0167116169,
0.0452072695,
0.0592112653,
0.0246053766,
0.0047640451,
0.065077126,
-0.0014238982,
-0.0372455567,
-0.0186257958,
-0.0019213428,
-0.0091985334,
-0.0194049422,
-0.0051760208,
0.0161206573,
0.0152823264,
-0.017317092,
-0.0836230516,
-0.0514662825,
0.0289432276,
-0.0340717882,
0.0281408504,
0.0080802031,
0.0258062687,
-0.0355369039,
0.0872357488,
-0.0049067866,
0.0072994693,
0.0079897856,
-0.0375019945,
0.001356654,
-0.0000653644,
0.0258668046,
-0.044726003,
-0.0420017764,
0.0529231578,
0.0019285751,
-0.0024365438,
-0.0003254144,
-0.0189037379,
0.0644883811,
-0.043839924,
0.0030208367,
-0.01495854,
0.0316590369,
-0.0025334158,
0.0409721881,
0.0033399558,
-0.0323222727,
-0.0078149289,
0.0111514209,
-0.0136457654,
-0.0071445177,
0.0165689941,
0.0084571727,
0.0256580804,
0.0568967685,
-0.0514790006,
0.0167934876,
-0.0188783016,
-0.0200095922,
0.0663428605,
-0.0068455171,
-0.0061632721,
0.0031902099,
2.756e-7,
-0.0142061478,
-0.0274398495,
0.0054417881,
-0.0211983137,
0.027152881,
0.0320516191,
-0.0288264006,
-0.0028416032,
0.0090155927,
-0.0113706207,
-0.0057948367,
-0.0061940141,
0.1028543264,
0.0304964501,
-0.0750925094,
-0.0120708086,
-0.0053989268,
-0.0181198567,
-0.0152838165,
0.0011340061,
0.0134594338,
0.03286203,
-0.0141475042,
-0.0283684358,
-0.0003860449,
0.0384662412,
0.0422979183,
0.0097097596,
-0.0308842473,
-0.0099481847,
-0.0095608504,
-0.0568904281,
-0.0249305572,
-0.005721407,
-0.0633595809,
0.0531091653,
0.0041158507,
0.0676450133,
0.0301041435,
-0.0333435237,
0.0019431274,
0.0234594475,
-0.0598760098,
0.010484878,
0.0302686989,
-0.0135167828,
0.0037593793,
-0.0067272428,
-0.0219045896,
0.0539372601,
0.0220486075,
-0.0059257997,
0.0029559599,
0.0290226117,
0.0416008048,
0.0253567211,
-0.0174413137,
-0.0072528278,
-0.0156196477,
-0.0114494516,
-0.0319569632,
-0.0376990847,
-0.0052577844,
0.0274741687,
-0.0111639891,
0.0106622316,
-0.0122673642,
2.392092433e-34,
0.0059596528,
-0.0060241004,
0.0159817114,
-0.0135378111,
0.0053128186,
-0.0778940916,
0.0104429806,
0.0283709746,
-0.0030452965,
-0.0167560559,
-0.0356056057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08210v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08210v1 | Investigating Answerability of LLMs for Long-Form Question Answering | 2023-09-15T07:22:56 | 2023-09-15T07:22:56 | Meghana Moorthy Bhat, Rui Meng, Ye Liu, Yingbo Zhou, Semih Yavuz | cs.CL | cs.CL | As we embark on a new era of LLMs, it becomes increasingly crucial to
understand their capabilities, limitations, and differences. Toward making
further progress in this direction, we strive to build a deeper understanding
of the gaps between massive LLMs (e.g., ChatGPT) and smaller yet effective
open-source LLMs and their distilled counterparts. To this end, we specifically
focus on long-form question answering (LFQA) because it has several practical
and impactful applications (e.g., troubleshooting, customer service, etc.) yet
is still understudied and challenging for LLMs. We propose a
question-generation method from abstractive summaries and show that generating
follow-up questions from summaries of long documents can create a challenging
setting for LLMs to reason and infer from long contexts. Our experimental
results confirm that: (1) our proposed method of generating questions from
abstractive summaries pose a challenging setup for LLMs and shows performance
gaps between LLMs like ChatGPT and open-source LLMs (Alpaca, Llama) (2)
open-source LLMs exhibit decreased reliance on context for generated questions
from the original document, but their generation capabilities drop
significantly on generated questions from summaries -- especially for longer
contexts (>1024 tokens) | [
0.0248707719,
0.0102503169,
0.0012418203,
0.0427971333,
-0.0232248884,
-0.0034098474,
-0.0323491842,
0.0177823398,
-0.0047024507,
-0.0342609882,
-0.0067567336,
-0.0359095559,
-0.0306173675,
0.0053631724,
0.0275782179,
-0.027094014,
0.0116732568,
-0.0124020809,
-0.0148589527,
-0.0283050109,
0.0102021163,
0.0112430928,
-0.0053778258,
0.0043348889,
0.015958054,
-0.025041217,
-0.0427147262,
-0.0000868984,
0.0080476124,
-0.0126755871,
0.0081095733,
-0.0042563989,
0.0200890917,
-0.0081234546,
0.0000017631,
-0.0849946663,
-0.0233059078,
0.0035732642,
-0.0295740087,
0.0007536328,
-0.0291104112,
0.0166883692,
0.0347044952,
0.0442885682,
-0.0327199027,
0.0373166911,
-0.0297459122,
0.0459566377,
0.0707727522,
0.0774328038,
0.017899638,
-0.0403329171,
0.0502900556,
0.0003134575,
0.0775359794,
-0.0484580398,
-0.0212327261,
0.0134424902,
0.0549993031,
0.0027900431,
-0.0078480383,
0.0068525588,
0.0403805412,
-0.0103648426,
-0.0138114244,
0.0223319642,
-0.0319309048,
0.0235338397,
0.0028311831,
0.0881973803,
0.0423557907,
0.0129616568,
0.0121652652,
0.0121565172,
0.0228753462,
0.0086027989,
-0.0723870844,
0.0541998073,
-0.0304554254,
-0.0048154448,
0.0218578093,
0.0093348902,
-0.0050537484,
0.0055546975,
-0.0301563032,
0.0430482738,
-0.0013273972,
-0.0419358946,
-0.002509949,
-0.0170386247,
-0.0194967128,
-0.0641290843,
-0.0050873952,
0.1031009182,
-0.0370997414,
0.0171803441,
-0.0083524724,
-0.0095855417,
0.0734103695,
-0.000798679,
-0.0052978597,
0.0312876366,
-0.0263250601,
0.0291483589,
-0.0449949801,
0.0217027925,
-0.0150542874,
0.0059954119,
-0.0685270131,
-0.0232826602,
-0.04632698,
-0.0310283005,
-0.0423055105,
0.0752162188,
-0.0364013314,
-0.0155196087,
0.0014257174,
0.0733169094,
0.0469021089,
0.0104653919,
0.0016474403,
0.0096253818,
0.0098914681,
-0.0142099243,
-0.0632829145,
-0.0222811177,
-0.0640092865,
0.0058287764,
0.0181298628,
-0.0592326373,
-0.0137353428,
0.0308884792,
0.0011721263,
-0.0067677381,
0.0287142061,
0.0678814128,
-0.0119581418,
-0.0155701255,
-0.0507079698,
-0.0647852048,
-0.0031823055,
-0.0498840809,
-0.0064645857,
-0.0790953636,
0.0163683984,
0.0183323715,
-0.031914264,
0.0303121023,
0.0180811565,
0.0510626584,
0.0009241012,
0.0424536318,
-0.0157117639,
0.0087947901,
0.0456952266,
0.0273439176,
0.0108400406,
0.0334018022,
0.0373534039,
0.0340815969,
0.0571130812,
0.0300273225,
0.0448656343,
0.0109521113,
0.0361739472,
0.033568617,
0.0502421483,
0.0701516941,
-0.0309313294,
0.0209298935,
0.0284843314,
0.0519600064,
0.0025572875,
-0.0069346274,
0.0147499461,
0.0598430224,
0.028505329,
0.0110839587,
0.0345670581,
0.0135455364,
0.010691192,
0.0455374382,
-0.0161398184,
0.0441724919,
-0.0382344425,
0.0448352247,
0.0521265902,
-0.0077377148,
-0.0491964109,
-0.0436486863,
-0.0168990977,
0.0142380763,
-0.0472879522,
0.0110104783,
0.0053296397,
0.0148844831,
-0.0286561437,
0.076165922,
-0.0077048419,
-0.0480023585,
-0.0112654865,
-0.0519053489,
0.0825290754,
0.0359457843,
0.0354647711,
-0.0477358811,
-0.0525588505,
-0.0165238772,
0.0294448659,
0.0358089656,
0.0348085798,
0.0033384545,
-0.0000373021,
-0.0257623121,
0.0007225296,
-0.0424395315,
-0.0181198753,
-0.0095052123,
0.0329008028,
0.0145300161,
0.0199161787,
-0.0811036676,
0.0116367768,
0.0142289447,
-0.037835177,
-0.0385747291,
0.0062415744,
-0.0164345652,
0.0177523363,
0.0279678442,
0.0198412072,
0.0404940471,
0.0393023863,
-0.0508482642,
-0.0543630607,
-0.0016441207,
-0.0408758186,
-0.0330655463,
0.0396299846,
-0.035911914,
-0.0140308747,
-0.0065115825,
-0.0445483178,
-0.0577870049,
-0.0230878573,
-0.0724657178,
0.0218213648,
-0.0509827025,
-0.0318946131,
0.051091861,
0.0013607318,
-0.0416265205,
0.0590933412,
-0.0114290081,
0.0100802872,
0.0138762249,
0.0239447318,
0.0208874978,
-0.0573542826,
0.0120149571,
-0.0087095154,
0.0013004469,
-0.0112792645,
0.0017496436,
0.0400742181,
-0.0691173151,
-0.0505303778,
-0.0845410004,
0.0524369814,
-0.0341050439,
0.0555275716,
0.0301687922,
0.0016396712,
-0.0243994929,
-0.0008497253,
-0.1129012853,
0.0041068275,
0.0588173494,
0.0102831731,
0.0794873983,
0.0166901778,
-0.0157443099,
-0.0280358009,
0.0018031573,
0.0063685826,
0.0183119867,
-0.004366341,
0.0016109728,
-0.0601894632,
0.0263336245,
-0.0428792052,
-0.0155607183,
-0.0230958797,
-0.0059989579,
0.0159464814,
-0.0251913406,
0.0252656136,
0.0146812024,
0.0359578282,
-0.0095372517,
0.008766925,
0.0068157441,
-0.0409837365,
0.0205813162,
-0.0117582958,
-0.0434920229,
0.012752085,
-0.0541573279,
0.0116430847,
0.011888409,
-0.0159798507,
-0.0139182871,
-0.0070540817,
0.0130522549,
0.026038954,
0.0059477035,
-0.0398716815,
0.0048900926,
-0.0095427623,
0.0573836155,
0.0195018202,
-0.0506208912,
0.0370030254,
-0.0259516072,
0.0005635836,
-0.0460081659,
-0.018701667,
-0.1003836393,
0.0806074291,
-0.0232225694,
0.0102374274,
-0.0338862129,
-0.0203664005,
-0.033594761,
-0.0087262848,
-0.0162980501,
-0.0435335562,
0.066234149,
-0.0354845189,
0.0132348752,
-0.0387731493,
-0.0288866647,
-0.0334186889,
-0.0307040159,
-0.0009145838,
0.0180770159,
0.0000572218,
0.0143190417,
-0.0177836884,
-0.0196914282,
0.0394950584,
-0.0125231929,
-0.0209256019,
-0.025554182,
-0.0090513276,
0.0643367991,
0.0553086549,
0.0643309727,
0.0653335527,
-0.0427786149,
0.0325051881,
0.0760797709,
0.0315341428,
-0.0037004263,
0.0230515748,
-0.0177028589,
-0.0005848923,
-0.033567775,
-0.0002150152,
0.0031929309,
0.0593086556,
-0.0558331572,
-0.0205500871,
0.092757538,
0.0361697972,
-0.0093613192,
0.006626314,
-0.0457870513,
0.0452866554,
0.0138602918,
0.0438388325,
-0.0971386284,
-0.0224482585,
-0.0052822689,
0.0493379645,
-0.0178746544,
-0.0288884323,
-0.0206113588,
-0.1047858596,
0.0410893746,
-0.0267491098,
-0.0471533798,
0.0113322316,
-0.0104689142,
-0.0079273628,
0.0384928584,
0.007280732,
0.0389085859,
-0.0454408526,
0.0064664474,
0.0124245929,
-0.0586597994,
0.0484866872,
0.0204740707,
-0.0104545606,
-0.0067984364,
0.0333475582,
0.0013233474,
-0.0091073047,
-0.0327256694,
0.055278305,
-0.0355612077,
0.0186137147,
-0.0011087321,
0.0243777856,
0.0100640329,
0.0027728979,
-0.0164899006,
0.0589564703,
-0.060293816,
-0.0029221945,
0.0572714731,
0.0320107602,
-0.0342619307,
-0.004284916,
-0.040891923,
0.0318542048,
-0.0279022977,
0.1063728556,
0.0227801129,
-0.0111203399,
-0.0643625185,
-0.0094568674,
-0.0322278365,
-0.04421838,
0.0047933972,
-0.0049349032,
-0.0094216028,
0.0724280253,
-0.0876512825,
-0.0441138484,
0.026780339,
0.0328359492,
-0.0418532379,
0.0304847732,
-0.0478915982,
-0.0071916403,
-0.03221827,
-0.0013393272,
-0.0302372947,
0.0126244416,
-0.0627142116,
0.0107026342,
0.0370117761,
-0.0417537838,
-0.0096505387,
0.0112689808,
-0.090734452,
-0.0283205193,
-0.0345080905,
0.012197243,
0.0211998932,
0.0049769278,
0.0160214659,
0.0060263826,
0.0622403398,
0.0491061844,
-0.0194414239,
0.0525365733,
0.0143676559,
0.0735396072,
0.0058058449,
0.0325101763,
-0.0848880336,
-0.0096695544,
-0.0047138887,
0.0549286492,
-0.0117042372,
-0.042782519,
0.01334495,
0.0571744815,
-0.0599021055,
0.0034102218,
0.004754486,
0.0041863718,
0.053715717,
-0.0105585298,
-0.0127591202,
-0.0423454493,
0.0289525762,
-0.0265125092,
-0.0561711565,
0.0179666709,
0.0219124872,
-0.0430907607,
0.0546599329,
-0.0326881185,
0.0110619543,
0.008252711,
-0.0320335366,
0.008023669,
-0.0292535368,
-0.0287295897,
-0.0252482202,
-0.014203514,
0.0686772913,
0.0205485467,
0.043377474,
0.0126866288,
0.0121470392,
-0.0211454704,
0.03173621,
-0.1019849703,
-0.0788397416,
-0.0036287259,
0.0535687096,
0.0257103965,
0.0214025546,
0.0095161619,
-0.0090936748,
0.0088207945,
0.0107928896,
0.0060781534,
0.0129928999,
-0.0010387297,
0.0425464027,
0.0377784297,
-0.0128663173,
0.0080022151,
0.0626256689,
-0.0240617152,
0.0200448353,
0.008613389,
0.0326144584,
-0.0442636125,
-0.0442550741,
-0.0022393935,
0.0315958112,
0.0197517257,
-0.0228054989,
-0.0561897717,
-0.0404928587,
0.0355313309,
0.0315353461,
0.0063149529,
-0.0007394722,
0.0526624136,
0.0561369285,
0.0512484536,
-0.0287290569,
-0.0354950987,
0.0292562824,
-0.0571933873,
-0.0105083892,
0.0157524478,
-5.814902027e-33,
-0.0271316674,
-0.0626872256,
0.0513665713,
0.0105382102,
-0.0277164821,
0.0105160084,
-0.0401813835,
0.0050932341,
0.0064661778,
-0.0014348021,
-0.0320817418,
0.0073325429,
-0.0020525302,
0.0254345015,
-0.0148914326,
-0.0482680351,
-0.0171450153,
0.008726011,
-0.007944488,
0.0331016369,
0.0393183492,
-0.0013001806,
-0.0230493546,
-0.0072273989,
0.035887599,
-0.0463493206,
-0.0047213463,
0.0290911291,
-0.0412985235,
0.0841383711,
-0.0153525406,
0.0145274336,
0.0473264344,
-0.0169229396,
-0.0007921869,
0.0483602174,
-0.0548471324,
-0.02487785,
0.013557449,
-0.0577433258,
-0.0784953311,
-0.0338330865,
0.0333714411,
-0.0023365326,
0.032533478,
-0.0272422284,
0.0229992904,
-0.0196999758,
-0.0081254523,
-0.0715002418,
-0.0081107365,
0.0060879476,
-0.0168884415,
-0.0176711921,
-0.0648490489,
0.0088288011,
0.0192451254,
0.0382796153,
0.0016451032,
-0.0179618038,
0.0022137219,
-0.0026995216,
0.0412775241,
-0.0266960226,
-0.0229927618,
0.0250226799,
-0.0021986072,
-0.0140564358,
-0.0414817147,
-0.0170368105,
-0.0522973314,
0.0341417231,
0.0495275334,
0.0331094898,
0.037548285,
0.0447552167,
-0.0646724924,
0.0727879703,
0.0021434678,
0.0290570501,
0.0087431818,
-0.0053932769,
-0.0148617309,
0.0072270716,
-0.0428617932,
0.0757251233,
-0.0229519438,
-0.0033602414,
0.0295324102,
0.0010961478,
-0.0012843126,
-0.0627097785,
0.0090130083,
-0.0167046785,
0.0249344017,
-0.0090596434,
-0.0249401927,
0.0166483205,
-0.000166592,
0.0253823362,
-0.0211663581,
0.0243338272,
-0.0018034223,
-0.0058343941,
-0.0081393532,
0.0204035603,
0.0331816413,
-0.0263221022,
-0.0565115772,
0.0128202643,
-0.0364404023,
0.0562094934,
-0.0464627966,
-0.0173180327,
-0.0003895682,
0.0024667387,
0.0061934087,
0.0502995886,
-0.0235542245,
-0.0057246401,
-0.0270434972,
-0.0191932265,
-0.0008990429,
0.0199458264,
-0.0340766199,
0.0489395373,
-0.0040450357,
0.0597082153,
0.0080692833,
-0.0540888831,
0.0131706335,
0.0384747125,
2.429e-7,
0.0445478708,
0.0065173376,
0.0399422571,
0.056836132,
0.0230692234,
-0.0156909525,
-0.0057951775,
0.024764996,
-0.0028065518,
-0.0333932415,
-0.0000262115,
0.0382160097,
0.0377883725,
0.0542827882,
-0.09980461,
-0.008822808,
-0.077811189,
-0.0349802747,
-0.034516912,
0.0158124436,
0.084625937,
0.0357530639,
-0.0337349214,
-0.027386412,
-0.0015608628,
-0.046259027,
0.046874214,
-0.0154042402,
-0.0238580909,
0.028332131,
0.0553150326,
0.0175402146,
0.023694016,
-0.0164835136,
0.0079716407,
0.0069002178,
-0.0069326097,
0.0483201705,
0.0503420904,
-0.0824839175,
0.0000952549,
-0.0609871373,
0.0431165695,
-0.022473963,
0.0725788772,
-0.0023833155,
-0.0090426793,
-0.0095153041,
0.0064898133,
-0.0429212227,
-0.0076948809,
-0.0168933179,
0.0009253291,
0.023949042,
0.0001878522,
-0.0426725112,
0.0177290048,
-0.0807134956,
-0.0075270822,
0.0187514368,
-0.0432827361,
-0.0400036983,
-0.0348693132,
0.0195775945,
0.0015832973,
-0.0626111925,
-0.0541022196,
2.147689938e-34,
0.0375551358,
-0.0186255109,
-0.0059737936,
0.0547688082,
0.0209633727,
-0.0065944064,
0.008873553,
0.0053263302,
0.0224102046,
-0.0908677876,
0.0008760356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08187v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08187v1 | Encoded Summarization: Summarizing Documents into Continuous Vector Space for Legal Case Retrieval | 2023-09-15T06:33:49 | 2023-09-15T06:33:49 | Vu Tran, Minh Le Nguyen, Satoshi Tojo, Ken Satoh | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present our method for tackling a legal case retrieval task by introducing
our method of encoding documents by summarizing them into continuous vector
space via our phrase scoring framework utilizing deep neural networks. On the
other hand, we explore the benefits from combining lexical features and latent
features generated with neural networks. Our experiments show that lexical
features and latent features generated with neural networks complement each
other to improve the retrieval system performance. Furthermore, our
experimental results suggest the importance of case summarization in different
aspects: using provided summaries and performing encoded summarization. Our
approach achieved F1 of 65.6% and 57.6% on the experimental datasets of legal
case retrieval tasks. | [
0.0093245218,
0.0335034691,
0.0055058026,
0.0007347487,
-0.0349287465,
0.0219068527,
0.0127187213,
0.0189896263,
-0.0358933471,
-0.0500058383,
0.0102884723,
-0.0341853276,
-0.0112375366,
0.0410141125,
-0.0248452108,
-0.050839968,
0.0325830728,
0.0423455276,
0.054425206,
0.0053757322,
0.016144691,
-0.012451428,
-0.0039030223,
0.0225750674,
-0.0227421671,
0.0215224344,
0.0084106307,
-0.0227103159,
0.0109815691,
0.0165435839,
0.0173643939,
0.0111292135,
0.039526999,
0.0017479192,
0.0000014877,
-0.0529958755,
-0.03179143,
-0.0211483594,
-0.0087669687,
0.0147068836,
0.0301802512,
-0.0211972501,
0.0022569031,
0.0008187605,
-0.0216789749,
-0.0105076348,
-0.0047685839,
0.0641957149,
0.0356353447,
0.0716746897,
-0.0107270051,
-0.0948413834,
0.0879780501,
-0.0409672,
-0.0228580013,
-0.0298801158,
-0.0023871483,
0.0166301951,
0.008506679,
0.0014626016,
-0.0010534845,
0.0414324589,
0.0423741862,
-0.038872242,
-0.02044571,
-0.0021910411,
-0.0597970225,
0.0320026204,
0.0576036125,
0.051011879,
0.0020052874,
-0.0139129814,
0.0070090783,
-0.0067894231,
0.0441054255,
-0.0314487219,
-0.0568973944,
0.120072335,
-0.0109008532,
0.0086054839,
-0.0050581833,
0.0562314838,
-0.0310371388,
0.0257702563,
-0.0226485897,
0.0033842425,
-0.001775819,
-0.0239319429,
-0.0102066062,
-0.0246896259,
-0.0090111503,
-0.0089059724,
0.0641647652,
0.0394186378,
0.0199286081,
0.0038644893,
-0.0302956887,
-0.0861640424,
0.0614658482,
-0.1041564867,
0.017092092,
0.0093224524,
-0.0127139157,
0.0881967619,
-0.0882468149,
0.0377409048,
0.01813161,
-0.0171705764,
-0.0065505803,
-0.0440008417,
-0.0330652259,
-0.0350304097,
-0.0416221134,
0.1039204895,
-0.0627454445,
-0.0205739103,
-0.0254928153,
0.0176719781,
0.0013064778,
0.0131138414,
-0.0216243844,
0.0353630856,
-0.0016346422,
-0.0025878916,
-0.0245456882,
-0.0514133796,
-0.0589025207,
0.0154860411,
0.0245892238,
0.018990092,
0.0030243623,
0.0113011608,
0.0326881222,
0.0163113251,
0.0280236881,
0.0142865209,
-0.0277325828,
-0.0518801697,
-0.0116165997,
-0.0772402138,
-0.0166844372,
-0.0163823925,
-0.0214155093,
-0.0765485615,
0.0115058282,
-0.0222836137,
-0.046223063,
-0.0406710617,
-0.0147388466,
0.0530975126,
-0.0443348773,
0.0319322571,
0.0047627422,
-0.0226037726,
0.0359092578,
0.0186000951,
0.0598924644,
0.0096234037,
0.0267116763,
0.0637537763,
0.0375785269,
0.0085170446,
0.0335092843,
0.0064268261,
0.0330748148,
-0.0063237753,
-0.0156857278,
-0.0290421322,
-0.0185685027,
0.0317605473,
0.0138895763,
0.0330496579,
-0.0236190334,
-0.0221061874,
0.0191438105,
0.0749067441,
0.0513146296,
0.0665407777,
-0.021939842,
0.003696772,
0.0460812524,
0.0257472303,
-0.0145065971,
0.0323512927,
-0.0412363559,
0.0312838852,
0.0157506168,
-0.0250336137,
-0.0426986143,
-0.0762646273,
0.034668345,
0.0050424389,
0.0071248529,
-0.015726978,
0.0204530768,
0.0000900671,
-0.0290600788,
0.0533490479,
0.011183952,
-0.0698341355,
-0.0212144461,
-0.0278017651,
-0.0034877984,
-0.0040555196,
0.0501334928,
-0.0522942171,
-0.0166244283,
0.0027105764,
0.0051283794,
0.0232703928,
0.0281764697,
0.0109378686,
-0.0069225738,
-0.0569506921,
-0.0501136445,
-0.0108920867,
0.0175380204,
0.0069411173,
-0.0319759585,
0.0049955072,
0.066916585,
-0.0478510857,
-0.0418962017,
0.0208785627,
0.0079216631,
-0.048783116,
0.0370137803,
-0.0130784921,
-0.002400629,
0.0434846692,
-0.0000483282,
0.002275141,
0.0101409275,
-0.0357133187,
-0.035102088,
-0.0039037226,
-0.0111829434,
-0.019330658,
0.0156563129,
-0.0519306399,
0.0111053325,
0.0127742048,
-0.0295316279,
-0.0212057307,
-0.0128340945,
-0.0460048318,
-0.0061299861,
-0.0743758827,
-0.0364472307,
-0.0099078892,
0.0045567113,
-0.0359812453,
0.0461786054,
0.0047394074,
0.0033484364,
-0.0085864533,
-0.0253413916,
0.0359355062,
-0.0335431062,
-0.0042165946,
-0.0128321042,
-0.0343296006,
0.0189267416,
0.0607033446,
-0.0068649789,
-0.0216343291,
-0.0244359132,
-0.1234655455,
0.0085828016,
-0.0424702764,
0.002249521,
0.0017186109,
-0.0211242661,
0.0003178097,
-0.0237262975,
-0.0727090687,
-0.0208591428,
0.0282596052,
-0.0148141263,
0.0313341916,
0.0151685243,
0.0076014423,
-0.0373341404,
-0.0500106886,
-0.0105143553,
0.0603296608,
0.0019916228,
-0.0275826305,
0.0147591326,
0.0516123846,
0.0084406743,
-0.0075378055,
-0.030546926,
0.0127960481,
-0.0225879122,
-0.0052431785,
-0.0225534551,
0.0468691438,
0.0601423681,
0.0026764544,
0.0058964738,
0.0153498473,
-0.0744115859,
-0.0108469129,
-0.0221393947,
0.01732683,
0.0127026858,
0.0028726086,
0.0463436246,
-0.00509685,
0.0065606581,
0.009573373,
0.0004303533,
0.0186423324,
0.0046091927,
-0.0153894462,
-0.0463355482,
-0.0137022873,
-0.0062274253,
0.0243521649,
0.0099414736,
-0.0425228439,
0.0529778861,
0.0225811806,
0.0614767,
-0.0483635813,
-0.0057286411,
-0.0617061257,
0.0656310916,
0.0097187562,
0.0265728179,
-0.0493340306,
-0.0740225241,
0.0243954659,
-0.0200252999,
0.0374511518,
-0.0506698713,
0.0801247731,
0.0107488381,
0.0368080251,
-0.0500206687,
-0.0190670807,
-0.0361340493,
-0.0379709601,
0.0419006497,
0.0733137429,
-0.0156012392,
0.0392737091,
-0.0745554343,
0.0014975776,
0.0171648655,
0.0308129359,
-0.0239189938,
-0.0060673747,
-0.0233252961,
0.0675321817,
0.0211082045,
-0.0056559462,
0.0183531381,
-0.0049590417,
0.0070091169,
0.0243405085,
0.0116722407,
0.0452961288,
0.0166688114,
-0.0085463459,
-0.0054999194,
-0.0837861747,
0.0033435023,
0.0076556848,
-0.0239750147,
-0.0507846586,
0.0426215194,
0.0889739692,
0.0345861539,
-0.0396128073,
-0.0294401068,
0.0265448019,
-0.0111196246,
0.0017710048,
0.0432023741,
-0.0615607724,
0.0198876746,
-0.0026082441,
-0.0002485169,
-0.0160419215,
-0.0334435888,
-0.0012157622,
-0.0779142901,
0.0380662233,
-0.0014680525,
-0.0107993148,
-0.068559818,
-0.0165214483,
0.0056293197,
0.0289905332,
0.0256515983,
0.0168075748,
-0.0249902848,
-0.0452784672,
0.0085166739,
-0.0636492744,
0.0317554325,
-0.0165406466,
-0.0678809583,
0.0160545427,
0.0407601558,
0.0352586173,
-0.069646135,
-0.00372506,
0.0023785038,
-0.0226728152,
-0.0209849477,
0.0207479466,
0.0693206489,
0.0009013039,
0.027131401,
0.0024988223,
0.0248979386,
-0.0078717768,
-0.0139164245,
0.0127236666,
-0.0027607556,
-0.0296446886,
-0.0253531542,
-0.0495281518,
-0.0196818113,
-0.0570172928,
0.0381537862,
0.0188244972,
0.0139382994,
-0.0150159709,
-0.019458374,
-0.0102409059,
-0.0666483566,
-0.0248683747,
-0.0219304767,
-0.0230750833,
0.0117444675,
-0.0543900132,
-0.063586235,
0.0140208108,
0.0243892092,
-0.0138086686,
0.0059412112,
-0.0009303077,
0.0031201378,
-0.0739532635,
0.0178445112,
-0.0088167824,
0.0100238724,
-0.007258093,
0.0530321151,
0.0614307635,
-0.0109025845,
-0.0357459597,
-0.0092039034,
0.0371944457,
-0.0089008482,
0.0110897133,
-0.005821954,
0.0059720026,
0.0043318346,
-0.0291142538,
-0.0874914601,
0.076310344,
0.035153538,
-0.0021754967,
0.0071670953,
0.0458844006,
-0.0409132093,
-0.0379407071,
-0.0015202293,
-0.0582926571,
0.0430130288,
0.0094864722,
0.0315973237,
-0.0041472614,
-0.0208209883,
0.0189333167,
0.0052629244,
0.028391229,
0.0085174628,
-0.0201515593,
-0.0329507813,
-0.0012842279,
-0.0208175853,
-0.0058922982,
-0.0056347945,
0.0396113209,
-0.0118325371,
0.0103856195,
-0.0164617524,
0.1269368827,
0.0157589763,
0.0243647005,
-0.0323882662,
0.034067601,
-0.0054138098,
-0.0216903612,
-0.0653218403,
0.0048219105,
-0.0366814993,
0.021820562,
-0.0240222346,
0.0389057398,
-0.0234426819,
0.0052586659,
0.0396054573,
0.0240287725,
-0.0313401595,
0.0468091257,
-0.0476266965,
0.0164907407,
-0.0507766269,
0.0501821823,
0.0683424398,
-0.0386354476,
-0.0226247907,
-0.0137611935,
-0.0060196007,
-0.0142369773,
-0.0276735723,
0.0178531818,
0.020772038,
-0.0025087071,
0.0436132737,
0.0079543721,
0.0088881785,
0.0299754646,
-0.0119760651,
-0.0119461166,
-0.0147877252,
-0.0109368674,
-0.0058381665,
-0.0069619152,
0.0321859531,
0.0669756457,
-0.0266988762,
-0.053320758,
-0.0167722087,
0.0042378008,
0.0399851687,
0.0425910242,
0.0053193574,
0.0340724178,
0.0346213542,
0.0629313365,
0.0277609769,
-0.0148944762,
-0.0316680409,
0.0301375054,
-0.0096738804,
-0.0170338172,
0.0046652085,
-5.458025248e-33,
-0.0110142678,
-0.0522128232,
-0.0120527064,
0.0678096935,
-0.0305365212,
-0.0097378045,
-0.0249060802,
-0.0013073849,
-0.0116673782,
0.0221187137,
-0.0280621406,
0.0348120406,
0.0329178907,
0.0101809157,
0.0194385108,
0.0007440441,
0.0213781986,
-0.0102155386,
-0.0010692041,
0.0319054238,
-0.0205143783,
0.0285514947,
0.003842334,
-0.0855360776,
0.0356448963,
0.0380170159,
0.0152775152,
-0.0257011075,
0.021500973,
0.0619718209,
0.009861174,
0.0136074871,
0.0578233488,
-0.0531745888,
-0.0131452288,
0.0587321967,
-0.0882797688,
0.0063591702,
-0.0122283436,
-0.0420635156,
-0.03241276,
-0.0347528383,
0.0474048369,
-0.0258748308,
-0.0114023387,
-0.0090236887,
0.0638499856,
-0.0431415327,
-0.0550249964,
-0.1504911184,
-0.0442434177,
0.0525184274,
-0.0030670092,
0.0442772396,
0.0430896059,
-0.0418371931,
0.012207672,
0.0385199673,
-0.059988305,
-0.0089834332,
-0.0392588675,
0.0179599002,
-0.0126706595,
-0.0346031077,
-0.0343910605,
0.0473649837,
0.0009475923,
-0.012163002,
-0.0651342943,
0.0018634194,
0.065494597,
0.015269489,
0.0768045634,
0.0205281153,
0.0614722557,
-0.0145024676,
-0.0488350727,
0.0170835778,
0.0211869068,
0.0162841883,
-0.0000561067,
-0.0077669118,
-0.0498327203,
0.0074164011,
-0.0451051183,
-0.0075736474,
-0.0242256895,
-0.0033494683,
0.0038478046,
0.0254427716,
0.0351685248,
-0.0513630174,
0.0288728904,
-0.0670326501,
0.0384766981,
0.0205937047,
0.0390079767,
0.0354426615,
-0.0103271119,
0.0151777696,
0.0022263965,
-0.0100010214,
-0.0022195559,
-0.0201129187,
-0.0153606934,
-0.0326550156,
0.0527565889,
-0.0323432013,
-0.0406275913,
0.0082192812,
0.0602698363,
-0.0196117256,
0.0037764653,
0.0529040098,
-0.0339022167,
0.0305463318,
0.0464359,
0.031165421,
0.0079261474,
0.0062088296,
-0.0369991474,
-0.0294871517,
0.0299193431,
0.016508624,
-0.0105556138,
0.0140092466,
0.0049911924,
0.0671101734,
0.0360452086,
-0.0132546565,
0.0250793938,
0.0745626837,
2.259e-7,
0.0760633349,
0.0389828905,
0.0401548184,
-0.011623933,
-0.0288535971,
0.0167727619,
0.0404125974,
0.0410628803,
0.0247162469,
-0.0171714853,
0.0243133381,
0.0226463657,
0.0363655053,
0.0289314725,
-0.0818191692,
-0.0244141463,
-0.0427743196,
-0.0573051572,
-0.0191825759,
0.004473682,
0.0801848546,
0.0945876464,
-0.0060967105,
-0.0195542537,
0.0028667711,
-0.0639542937,
0.0399660096,
0.0293237939,
-0.0380155295,
-0.0077516078,
0.0781618282,
0.003508968,
-0.0135416519,
-0.0158171747,
0.0220384505,
0.0809598789,
0.011787761,
0.0390932634,
0.0115628205,
-0.0306197833,
-0.0229089912,
-0.02844676,
0.0183879696,
0.0159589257,
0.0471591577,
-0.0404541269,
0.0092179896,
-0.0011054275,
-0.0040713372,
0.0161326565,
0.0142433513,
0.032231316,
-0.0353607759,
0.0088496795,
0.029122198,
-0.0218414608,
0.027958028,
-0.1325449795,
0.0050373669,
0.0338808186,
-0.02062466,
0.0400206111,
0.0018851716,
0.0027700241,
0.0626700595,
-0.0275620949,
0.0068806224,
1.928081191e-34,
0.0708801597,
0.0056329961,
-0.0126200616,
0.0157498326,
-0.0072420849,
0.0261325426,
-0.0082988292,
0.0078890938,
-0.0188555699,
-0.0975166783,
0.0096772499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08185v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08185v1 | Multilingual Sentence-Level Semantic Search using Meta-Distillation Learning | 2023-09-15T06:22:37 | 2023-09-15T06:22:37 | Meryem M'hamdi, Jonathan May, Franck Dernoncourt, Trung Bui, Seunghyun Yoon | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual semantic search is the task of retrieving relevant contents to a
query expressed in different language combinations. This requires a better
semantic understanding of the user's intent and its contextual meaning.
Multilingual semantic search is less explored and more challenging than its
monolingual or bilingual counterparts, due to the lack of multilingual parallel
resources for this task and the need to circumvent "language bias". In this
work, we propose an alignment approach: MAML-Align, specifically for
low-resource scenarios. Our approach leverages meta-distillation learning based
on MAML, an optimization-based Model-Agnostic Meta-Learner. MAML-Align distills
knowledge from a Teacher meta-transfer model T-MAML, specialized in
transferring from monolingual to bilingual semantic search, to a Student model
S-MAML, which meta-transfers from bilingual to multilingual semantic search. To
the best of our knowledge, we are the first to extend meta-distillation to a
multilingual search application. Our empirical results show that on top of a
strong baseline based on sentence transformers, our meta-distillation approach
boosts the gains provided by MAML and significantly outperforms naive
fine-tuning methods. Furthermore, multilingual meta-distillation learning
improves generalization even to unseen languages. | [
0.0230614673,
0.0252537634,
-0.0192717221,
0.0462762378,
-0.0217520632,
0.0018622514,
-0.0187238473,
-0.0665376484,
-0.0775067657,
-0.0291364975,
-0.0411236919,
0.0325525217,
-0.0323571041,
-0.0348274931,
-0.0116541842,
-0.0565543212,
0.0472448878,
0.0072614467,
-0.0220079962,
-0.0021447709,
0.0198024083,
0.0304186884,
0.026745569,
0.0156262685,
0.0134415813,
-0.0035000187,
-0.0265125409,
0.0273333807,
0.0449370481,
0.0186195336,
0.0266506355,
0.002819295,
0.0064391089,
0.0709155872,
0.000001816,
-0.0493725836,
-0.0524333939,
-0.0096812397,
0.0152008859,
-0.0504172929,
0.0254626777,
-0.0378484838,
0.0333913118,
0.0171205662,
-0.0558626465,
0.0109299505,
0.0556573421,
-0.0070900703,
0.0751026943,
0.0480875373,
-0.0101707736,
-0.0450709909,
-0.0015182424,
-0.0092290752,
0.0200205948,
-0.0384995751,
-0.0043485621,
-0.0119172493,
-0.0146240536,
0.0007135174,
-0.0198245477,
0.0611060224,
0.0001253234,
-0.0159200002,
-0.0229108818,
-0.0299259517,
-0.0607250929,
-0.0114410315,
0.0011559515,
0.0639605224,
-0.0464280471,
-0.0155831613,
-0.0190336984,
0.0211067759,
-0.0005791545,
0.0226337872,
-0.0389325731,
-0.0114049194,
-0.0136076016,
0.0227877144,
-0.0069349706,
-0.0121275093,
0.0397086218,
0.0072957068,
-0.0657337531,
0.0815266818,
0.0246958081,
-0.0251145419,
0.0171655379,
0.013212285,
-0.0108188083,
0.0224151313,
0.016814772,
0.0165661834,
-0.0390352011,
0.0356456712,
-0.0271082707,
-0.0757701769,
0.015998479,
-0.0216745716,
0.0095996885,
0.056463521,
-0.0092711598,
0.0384727679,
-0.0030324615,
0.0149259232,
-0.0161961485,
0.0480889007,
-0.0882908404,
-0.0669929087,
-0.0757054165,
-0.0062822043,
-0.0624655224,
0.0162211843,
-0.0443698838,
0.0165925752,
-0.0416324399,
0.0196956582,
0.018934112,
-0.0200046077,
0.0318245068,
-0.0240942724,
-0.0441178679,
0.0017799564,
-0.0107874526,
0.1057144105,
-0.0336860716,
-0.0158940051,
0.0039507416,
-0.0433639735,
0.0029442848,
0.0231537335,
-0.0004473127,
-0.067180641,
0.0061221174,
0.0400589295,
-0.0215620995,
-0.036179699,
-0.0164989717,
0.0054956404,
-0.0078224735,
-0.069380939,
-0.000082022,
-0.0705766603,
0.0613486022,
-0.0115362732,
0.0076076798,
-0.018966902,
0.0174136721,
0.0130905975,
0.018669717,
0.0503307693,
0.0245474037,
-0.0112632401,
0.008581643,
-0.0055457051,
0.0118591562,
0.1030719131,
0.007447558,
0.0290543418,
0.0539190136,
-0.0017184855,
-0.0500803553,
0.001231548,
0.0286176279,
0.0314141586,
0.0013321505,
-0.0005059209,
0.0250802357,
0.0217086729,
0.0090489145,
0.0459058359,
-0.02995985,
-0.0038816307,
0.0104749603,
-0.0116662821,
0.0088644484,
-0.0075603034,
0.0499874651,
0.0015979244,
-0.0488874651,
0.0031936148,
-0.030142216,
0.029135691,
0.0110536255,
-0.0010308861,
0.0002663521,
0.0797859877,
-0.0317749828,
-0.0367081836,
0.0446374677,
0.0030876559,
-0.038019415,
0.0296484102,
0.0509175397,
0.0236816984,
0.0007748663,
0.0838615745,
0.0246718396,
-0.0473420098,
0.0483488403,
-0.0305038337,
-0.0532456078,
0.056106545,
0.0201911964,
-0.0479505137,
-0.0317594297,
-0.0224818364,
-0.0035098479,
0.049906645,
0.0141663887,
-0.0096709905,
0.0496000573,
-0.0650234073,
-0.0501606651,
-0.0187132992,
-0.005017512,
0.010247332,
0.010378819,
0.0389158539,
0.0325313434,
-0.0922721624,
-0.0140457116,
0.0198802967,
-0.0437402762,
-0.0118185515,
0.009076626,
0.0543047823,
-0.0185574871,
0.0168016385,
0.0276650731,
-0.019250676,
0.0161910616,
-0.0466775745,
-0.0202718507,
0.0142699648,
-0.0125958379,
-0.0634598359,
0.0652292147,
-0.0904161409,
-0.0277491361,
0.0322416909,
-0.0652222261,
-0.0493611991,
-0.0063940608,
0.004129393,
0.0355691351,
-0.0411484987,
0.0395169929,
-0.0165321529,
0.022302689,
-0.0537833124,
0.0404695496,
-0.0012361265,
0.0051308097,
-0.006766791,
-0.0741353333,
0.06144768,
0.0003526519,
-0.0624012984,
0.0193607975,
-0.020158805,
0.0405467488,
0.0415133312,
0.0149438065,
-0.0526244044,
-0.0255723149,
-0.0528220385,
0.0107901897,
-0.0447833911,
0.0208966676,
0.0410434604,
0.070661068,
0.0209585205,
-0.0309939254,
-0.047106415,
-0.0071237204,
0.0014999451,
0.0266043432,
0.0470123775,
0.0355167054,
0.0273093618,
-0.0334345065,
-0.0368139744,
0.0008987709,
0.0284493957,
-0.0353075936,
0.0024438682,
-0.0059367158,
-0.0167865455,
-0.0478919037,
0.0034237904,
-0.0051184702,
-0.0272353478,
-0.0188900009,
-0.0256593265,
0.0051805684,
0.0442945473,
0.0021185107,
-0.0287010223,
0.0596786402,
0.0310034212,
-0.054597728,
0.0647067353,
-0.0209639613,
-0.0126052322,
-0.0564710163,
-0.0407539345,
0.0200075619,
0.0431364886,
-0.0358252972,
-0.023887841,
-0.0513107926,
-0.0387659781,
0.0208197683,
-0.037391264,
-0.0425275527,
0.078698501,
0.0174666513,
0.0258790869,
-0.0349255577,
-0.0203331839,
0.0896693766,
0.0304426383,
-0.0079712188,
-0.0837115943,
0.0000952537,
-0.0471699126,
0.0184204504,
-0.0477581434,
0.0484038666,
-0.0489635319,
-0.003621533,
-0.0823546126,
-0.0307939686,
0.0653750151,
-0.0115932329,
0.0660514608,
-0.0019998967,
-0.0058091404,
-0.0195004642,
-0.0666642562,
-0.0152689386,
-0.0198434088,
-0.0233574584,
0.0050445748,
0.014012414,
0.0033557562,
-0.1076878533,
-0.0332700424,
0.0189283211,
0.0144183021,
-0.018985657,
-0.0199976116,
-0.0216271505,
0.030474972,
0.0672689751,
0.004063304,
-0.0082861204,
-0.0303061567,
0.0305486936,
0.0170503054,
0.0083791111,
-0.0518967248,
0.024891628,
-0.02886975,
0.0686232746,
-0.00425022,
-0.0222372003,
-0.0295553338,
-0.0057404479,
-0.0146954069,
-0.014660948,
0.0533020906,
0.033114858,
-0.03753547,
-0.0293635279,
-0.0557396673,
0.0676898286,
0.0458507538,
0.056363456,
-0.0699849874,
-0.0490591414,
-0.0262782201,
0.0004174416,
0.0364942439,
0.0140255122,
-0.0354199372,
-0.0722378716,
-0.0482602566,
-0.0126267495,
-0.0617610365,
-0.0089536365,
-0.0176208969,
0.0063472781,
-0.0415520594,
0.0578901805,
-0.0059322449,
-0.0214061812,
-0.0001330735,
-0.0055614952,
0.0360387005,
-0.0601489134,
-0.0248581506,
-0.0139266616,
-0.0477704257,
0.053479284,
0.042028252,
-0.0121678347,
-0.030051358,
0.0411103219,
0.005205032,
-0.0186692141,
-0.0144227957,
0.0476568788,
-0.0312415436,
-0.0064914417,
0.0082158921,
-0.0033548055,
-0.0453259349,
0.0165622998,
0.0362415165,
0.0924519598,
0.0369984135,
0.0249543488,
-0.0110552078,
-0.0515494682,
0.0202008393,
0.044065658,
0.0042518997,
-0.025547998,
-0.042976059,
-0.0072048563,
-0.0039366204,
-0.0464023836,
0.0225567929,
0.0378523432,
-0.0179577786,
0.0054303459,
-0.0305588394,
-0.0500378422,
0.0058216588,
0.0339324251,
0.0049519036,
0.036315687,
-0.0093179429,
0.0015494856,
-0.0666813627,
0.0038696679,
-0.0279843044,
0.0234094094,
-0.0401097499,
0.0075103622,
0.0132143488,
-0.0503353439,
0.0017804391,
-0.0335187316,
-0.1013362855,
-0.0742129013,
-0.0122003537,
0.0494394526,
0.0059925118,
0.0571378432,
-0.0223612729,
-0.0276605543,
0.0360299423,
0.0542608872,
-0.0028206271,
-0.0267281961,
0.0630274266,
-0.0106163211,
-0.0169784296,
0.0586489663,
-0.0382905528,
-0.008212829,
0.0062738881,
0.0539004691,
-0.0221038945,
-0.011386089,
0.0657906532,
0.0330762714,
0.0460148603,
-0.0121340863,
0.0065668379,
-0.0245029293,
0.0324909091,
0.0035364076,
-0.0463872142,
-0.0254583005,
-0.0063919025,
0.0374640748,
-0.0239656288,
0.0238870308,
0.0373806506,
-0.0095640225,
-0.0194896329,
0.0032216064,
0.0173499025,
-0.0200047232,
0.0091715949,
0.0336723104,
0.0314094163,
0.0099277534,
0.0214142948,
0.0447279476,
0.039452929,
-0.0336746462,
0.0119957328,
0.0467315316,
0.0255397558,
-0.0206373818,
0.0244443994,
-0.056593325,
0.0108898189,
0.0106873885,
-0.0256339088,
0.0754659846,
0.014169977,
0.0478693843,
0.0084110256,
-0.0211411566,
-0.0051807277,
0.0295470022,
0.0109173059,
-0.011468986,
0.0087149013,
0.0079101445,
0.0008151228,
-0.0165136848,
0.074091427,
-0.0711643547,
0.0279711075,
-0.0172091015,
0.0085773002,
-0.0362094715,
-0.0277429502,
0.004717581,
0.0414329804,
-0.0155550912,
-0.0130214784,
-0.0435067974,
-0.039443396,
0.000041489,
-0.0096517419,
-0.0347414613,
-0.005675239,
0.04083791,
0.0863415748,
0.0097154286,
-0.0319699943,
-0.0311699007,
-0.0102756275,
0.0169520881,
-0.0149053885,
0.0109137837,
-5.852750741e-33,
0.0119520035,
0.0153538128,
0.0228653476,
-0.0125815338,
-0.0173663367,
-0.0233287029,
0.0056648757,
-0.0167541709,
-0.0669034272,
0.0191033855,
-0.0206669625,
0.041975446,
0.0288774092,
0.0529382117,
-0.0007757333,
0.0049258424,
0.059182018,
0.0433455259,
-0.0182770677,
0.0040915818,
0.0535200834,
0.0575367324,
0.052667208,
-0.0294676535,
-0.0398607701,
0.0097938059,
-0.0028975771,
0.0597777255,
-0.0026015809,
0.050267335,
0.0302797463,
0.0710834563,
0.0151523007,
0.0007046376,
-0.0133750122,
-0.0186215658,
-0.0791102126,
-0.0596716292,
0.0286955312,
0.0138620716,
-0.0477747358,
-0.0479425266,
0.0079406388,
-0.0343980193,
0.0382598042,
-0.0139257507,
0.0490488894,
-0.0077153323,
-0.0266897772,
-0.0088151051,
-0.0423142649,
0.0073858928,
0.0073431968,
0.010034333,
0.0412308536,
0.0812404752,
-0.0005028031,
0.0224438384,
0.0072381166,
0.0481602624,
-0.0508057177,
0.0560513474,
0.0702886507,
0.0603419729,
-0.0191954542,
0.0195216667,
0.0201624781,
0.0241620839,
0.0730836391,
-0.0206945427,
0.0497582741,
0.0166780408,
-0.0163150746,
0.1288871467,
0.0217567887,
0.0175125934,
-0.0424158052,
0.0226737596,
-0.0160834454,
0.0454724021,
-0.002073202,
0.0094697587,
0.0025143842,
-0.023350874,
-0.0592118688,
0.0119402707,
-0.0330131948,
-0.0024819542,
0.0193712935,
0.0142998295,
-0.0182185415,
-0.011975199,
0.0203158464,
-0.0321734995,
0.0178890359,
0.074740231,
-0.0301218666,
-0.0229606684,
-0.0020655137,
0.0425893329,
-0.0291637611,
-0.0335816368,
0.0004522928,
-0.0066295909,
-0.011093244,
0.0119997375,
0.0752205551,
0.0148253925,
-0.034181729,
0.0178063121,
-0.0375241153,
-0.0030630811,
-0.0363251716,
-0.0149545651,
-0.0075720386,
0.0152685875,
-0.0303410515,
0.0171489548,
0.0827559903,
-0.0220491774,
-0.0270632599,
-0.0449541882,
0.0214801934,
0.0186806209,
0.003414826,
0.0437660664,
-0.0328081585,
0.0020912837,
0.0195868723,
-0.0826401412,
-0.0030990166,
0.021938527,
2.589e-7,
0.0671280473,
0.0098285601,
0.0103344778,
-0.0044684866,
-0.0285844076,
0.0059040939,
-0.0067854887,
0.0289614294,
-0.0011795451,
0.0096859625,
0.0358396135,
0.0285544638,
0.0443884954,
0.0372520126,
-0.0801752284,
0.036911238,
-0.0086688986,
-0.0274644438,
-0.0262945052,
-0.0119958548,
0.0632916987,
0.0732061788,
0.0181576498,
-0.00943314,
-0.0357134491,
-0.0248040315,
0.0568208545,
-0.0024209444,
0.0086576063,
0.0403955765,
-0.0410601087,
-0.0125403721,
0.0028439788,
-0.018180199,
-0.0250810869,
0.0403082445,
0.0262906887,
0.0654000267,
-0.0220855121,
-0.0229379237,
0.0171947479,
-0.0153941987,
-0.0188284945,
-0.0503148586,
0.038530726,
-0.0382533148,
0.0162933338,
0.0077977027,
-0.016565036,
0.0195010677,
0.0509435833,
-0.031502828,
-0.0578115024,
0.0275952946,
0.0282963477,
0.0110052945,
-0.0326445326,
-0.0645005405,
-0.0334607624,
0.0055857184,
-0.014361863,
-0.0309402421,
-0.0080499705,
-0.0241866745,
0.0156646539,
-0.0383947007,
0.0223662667,
1.847776445e-34,
0.0247681737,
-0.0146076633,
0.0049993559,
-0.0135791115,
-0.0091867158,
-0.0359175466,
-0.0859993547,
0.0138981165,
0.0359848365,
-0.0488502979,
-0.0148676448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08182v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08182v2 | Using Large Language Model to Solve and Explain Physics Word Problems Approaching Human Level | 2023-09-15T06:13:06 | 2023-09-20T07:08:53 | Jingzhe Ding, Yan Cen, Xinyuan Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Our work demonstrates that large language model (LLM) pre-trained on texts
can not only solve pure math word problems, but also physics word problems,
whose solution requires calculation and inference based on prior physical
knowledge. We collect and annotate the first physics word problem
dataset-PhysQA, which contains over 1000 junior high school physics word
problems (covering Kinematics, Mass&Density, Mechanics, Heat, Electricity).
Then we use OpenAI' s GPT3.5 to generate the answer of these problems and found
that GPT3.5 could automatically solve 49.3% of the problems through zero-shot
learning and 73.2% through few-shot learning. This result demonstrates that by
using similar problems and their answers as prompt, LLM could solve elementary
physics word problems approaching human level performance. In addition to
solving problems, GPT3.5 can also summarize the knowledge or topics covered by
the problems, provide relevant explanations, and generate new physics word
problems based on the input. Our work is the first research to focus on the
automatic solving, explanation, and generation of physics word problems across
various types and scenarios, and we achieve an acceptable and state-of-the-art
accuracy. This underscores the potential of LLMs for further applications in
secondary education. | [
-0.0040238937,
0.0285121854,
0.007830604,
0.0584184602,
-0.006018545,
0.0061518992,
0.0538662449,
0.0231583267,
-0.0261339974,
-0.0232787263,
0.0180236418,
-0.0360560603,
-0.0057620113,
-0.0050960081,
0.0164798498,
-0.0836194232,
0.0292495042,
-0.0603072196,
0.0051275021,
-0.0008503305,
-0.0123154782,
-0.0057444577,
-0.0540864617,
-0.0053105764,
-0.011810353,
-0.0213257968,
0.0051156455,
-0.0628295168,
0.0559077263,
-0.0393380187,
-0.0069132722,
0.045944605,
0.0396039821,
0.0583723709,
0.0000018538,
-0.0534524545,
0.0362836868,
0.0243814271,
-0.0141922655,
0.0429843366,
0.027809998,
-0.0230108667,
-0.0065844604,
-0.0016728239,
-0.0352586061,
0.0047743148,
0.070435904,
-0.0185928959,
0.0641716123,
0.0412872545,
-0.0004903388,
-0.0309859924,
0.0023209895,
-0.0103149805,
0.0793836936,
-0.0748341903,
0.0280706361,
0.0591152199,
0.0296736564,
0.0243499838,
-0.0546246208,
0.0422802456,
0.0777126253,
-0.0162326861,
-0.0080989245,
0.0519712791,
-0.0357670896,
0.0551469438,
-0.017018944,
0.1010336578,
-0.016686907,
-0.0109975096,
-0.0392008722,
-0.03427637,
-0.0356246382,
0.0442917012,
-0.0769737959,
0.0565541983,
0.0099341841,
-0.0201678444,
-0.048446212,
-0.0182392541,
0.0106507521,
0.0068775169,
-0.0472931638,
0.0862052962,
0.0330417268,
0.0038901668,
-0.0160219427,
-0.0027639722,
-0.0264750551,
-0.0536820889,
-0.0036877412,
0.0804140568,
0.021601133,
0.0484369919,
-0.0232535116,
-0.0569802262,
0.000111469,
-0.070243448,
0.0455853939,
0.0687650293,
0.0454369932,
0.0633818507,
-0.042130135,
0.0561767332,
-0.0140311271,
-0.014525339,
-0.0437927581,
0.0230375268,
-0.0683051869,
-0.0250171684,
-0.0145112211,
0.0164389834,
-0.0286741331,
-0.0272324514,
-0.0198621973,
-0.0097563444,
0.0122595374,
-0.0099398708,
-0.0089243306,
0.0141123841,
-0.0288933422,
-0.0725110769,
-0.0245700274,
0.062581107,
-0.0250745714,
0.0489592701,
-0.0015739931,
-0.0058787777,
-0.0209411997,
0.007770895,
-0.0095546516,
-0.0082880715,
0.004696046,
0.074309513,
-0.0026761089,
-0.0056358594,
-0.0158701073,
-0.0372430161,
-0.0170772038,
-0.0855865851,
-0.0153184161,
-0.0694625378,
0.0306663997,
0.0190291852,
-0.0192087088,
-0.0251555927,
0.0393460393,
0.0330808684,
-0.0174927097,
0.0777004212,
-0.0015034836,
0.0039142678,
0.0631285831,
0.0441687927,
0.01200887,
0.0406959839,
0.070348084,
-0.0010703636,
-0.0124530103,
-0.0094218329,
0.016081702,
0.0355463736,
0.0132670626,
0.0318270363,
-0.0677410513,
-0.0454194285,
0.0155614791,
0.0481125638,
-0.0052902163,
0.0275361519,
-0.0062215109,
0.0455481187,
0.0059273643,
0.0446368232,
-0.0507419743,
0.0538164042,
0.0200896338,
-0.028249491,
0.0386781916,
-0.0129828686,
0.007423636,
0.0574939065,
-0.025679294,
-0.0094527109,
0.0092173079,
0.0052622189,
-0.0153409615,
-0.038222082,
-0.0262987595,
0.0131192375,
0.0040804283,
0.0252462886,
0.0770978779,
0.0024273943,
-0.0058363075,
0.0282352455,
0.025710322,
-0.0455160327,
0.0174412969,
0.0070723109,
0.0510739572,
0.0274032298,
0.0412338264,
-0.033274103,
-0.0532322004,
0.0400750451,
0.0382592678,
0.0464074165,
0.0381920375,
0.0168954358,
-0.0308687259,
-0.050243929,
-0.0152443927,
-0.0367080383,
0.0043246401,
0.007934954,
0.0199081339,
0.0220228732,
0.0415396094,
0.0262674708,
-0.0254258141,
0.0394155234,
-0.0793009698,
-0.0457883701,
-0.0065041236,
-0.0395218581,
0.0293636192,
-0.020689765,
0.0014374021,
0.0016295172,
-0.0104059512,
-0.0452069044,
-0.0146198124,
-0.0190943889,
-0.0140509531,
0.0008549229,
0.0839635134,
-0.0383727476,
0.001595753,
-0.0044536758,
-0.0350433663,
-0.0495033488,
0.0272434466,
-0.0041109342,
0.0030318478,
0.006173844,
-0.0131775374,
0.0126983719,
-0.0229205899,
-0.0190176498,
0.0534620322,
0.0226505864,
0.0536838658,
0.0295080598,
0.0300156381,
0.0238401163,
0.0024869093,
-0.0231470615,
0.0137409912,
0.0187576786,
-0.0143706789,
0.0088237748,
-0.0062478306,
-0.0274695121,
-0.0093892654,
-0.0429509915,
-0.002465368,
0.035946507,
0.0044862982,
0.0341889821,
-0.0028170566,
-0.0234564673,
0.0205700956,
-0.0124893831,
0.0630390644,
-0.0129455393,
-0.0616485924,
0.0210130271,
0.0124233123,
-0.0140601657,
-0.0572944246,
-0.0019317226,
-0.0779123381,
0.0493767671,
0.0693724006,
0.0373502262,
-0.0402908809,
0.0886322707,
-0.0528525524,
0.0124649173,
0.0129287839,
-0.0575947575,
0.0319564939,
-0.0494831502,
0.0544329248,
0.0549587831,
0.0034696013,
0.020900188,
0.0746862367,
-0.0737725347,
-0.0493869111,
0.0131012183,
-0.0329457112,
-0.0139584308,
0.0060519837,
-0.0070667872,
0.0019799259,
0.0620137528,
0.021852307,
-0.0400488526,
-0.0512228571,
0.0301239863,
-0.0668518469,
0.0128022088,
-0.0421802066,
0.0163085219,
-0.0136768231,
-0.0077483393,
0.0178136155,
0.0123775788,
0.0507106856,
-0.0169645883,
0.0072709587,
-0.0466842242,
0.0284376759,
-0.0464688838,
0.073390916,
-0.0172005743,
-0.0006030321,
-0.0494349413,
0.0455577746,
-0.0111685675,
0.034875907,
0.0165359285,
0.020444544,
0.0130682122,
-0.0780097991,
0.023488177,
-0.0248478819,
-0.0144642238,
-0.0139923571,
-0.0225183778,
-0.0252347142,
-0.0073376819,
-0.0564425513,
-0.0889400244,
-0.0000684789,
-0.0178550538,
0.0583578497,
0.0224916134,
-0.046956297,
-0.0116904462,
-0.0362854265,
0.0083291447,
0.0558699556,
0.0065352251,
-0.0065721432,
-0.0651668981,
0.0557886437,
0.0213471279,
0.0473420024,
0.0232347865,
-0.0492351614,
0.0021038649,
-0.0008569345,
0.0069895769,
0.0337872095,
0.043275293,
0.0503958873,
-0.0693246573,
-0.012587009,
0.0746933296,
0.0287318472,
-0.0099025723,
-0.0096536782,
-0.0190858413,
-0.0211756099,
-0.0226333849,
0.009535173,
-0.086915262,
-0.0163379312,
-0.0121771069,
-0.0198162515,
0.0306040626,
-0.0369483866,
-0.0392592065,
-0.1116585359,
0.0123578021,
0.0530704409,
-0.0264285039,
-0.0308315177,
-0.0212256704,
-0.0282343011,
0.0139643205,
-0.0112072378,
-0.0007743548,
0.0141276317,
0.0101308152,
0.0077244639,
0.0143936947,
-0.0556306206,
0.0316750184,
-0.0374266803,
0.0125797167,
0.0255764686,
0.0126154991,
-0.0648260489,
-0.0664480329,
0.0256949831,
0.0111796204,
-0.0393360481,
0.0218741316,
-0.0137918759,
0.0271407459,
0.0121260658,
-0.0233164318,
0.059157256,
-0.0352334566,
-0.0802773535,
0.028470533,
0.0792782158,
-0.0192095637,
-0.0281020105,
-0.0399569869,
-0.0169103164,
-0.0167865772,
0.0862324089,
0.0030768695,
-0.0346435905,
-0.0299560707,
-0.0392027162,
-0.0411636308,
-0.0054835845,
-0.0247354191,
-0.0042218678,
0.0447049849,
-0.013590117,
-0.0264025461,
0.0240617171,
0.0752265379,
0.04347248,
0.0226540808,
-0.0024629862,
-0.003556442,
0.0147128031,
-0.008758056,
0.0218346156,
-0.0443552807,
0.0039067343,
-0.032083407,
0.0216897056,
0.0368298292,
-0.0132900774,
0.0029296735,
0.0245804843,
-0.0858222395,
-0.0750514567,
-0.0062538539,
0.027191909,
0.0247141011,
-0.0080297748,
-0.0117386803,
-0.0249604732,
0.0127172284,
0.0307753682,
-0.0509589426,
0.023891788,
-0.0569048226,
0.0143682705,
0.030875219,
-0.0441449322,
0.0134820389,
0.0093628867,
-0.0091317268,
0.0132428436,
-0.0405174717,
-0.0343252644,
0.0252569243,
0.0352594294,
0.0382407904,
0.0016840202,
-0.0066805058,
-0.050812453,
0.0081043821,
-0.0563052744,
0.0023322571,
-0.0396637954,
-0.0103277983,
0.0354756452,
-0.0689558536,
0.0058786604,
-0.0345204771,
0.0186591968,
0.0346632153,
0.0166869275,
0.042215962,
0.0154708633,
0.0293159522,
0.0470932685,
-0.0317983292,
0.0096267005,
-0.0227729082,
-0.0297694411,
0.0503492504,
-0.0057251942,
0.0520382747,
0.0510095917,
-0.0111878514,
-0.0495854393,
-0.0025392203,
-0.0569253378,
-0.0799625143,
-0.0539715402,
0.0474622957,
0.0151972771,
0.0209315103,
-0.0196857825,
-0.0849814117,
-0.0227831975,
0.008512143,
0.0174032561,
-0.0004434349,
-0.0082573649,
0.061534293,
0.0441006385,
0.0298706666,
-0.004481372,
0.0693333596,
0.0108055025,
0.0465124138,
0.0409674235,
0.0089998012,
-0.0142393801,
0.0120102437,
0.0049224752,
0.023809487,
0.018404929,
0.0075577549,
-0.0707931519,
-0.0340377502,
-0.030104313,
0.0385035053,
-0.0054004486,
0.0109952092,
0.0433504991,
0.0311419182,
-0.0385922268,
-0.0210247561,
0.0108966427,
0.0321911164,
-0.0196586717,
-0.0073748482,
0.0018065351,
-5.160689829e-33,
-0.0407894254,
-0.0433230996,
0.0460165925,
0.0194479618,
-0.008717482,
-0.0051689376,
-0.0547824204,
-0.0012196492,
-0.0116057117,
0.0001217873,
0.0168316811,
0.0170886945,
-0.0190788303,
0.0070955292,
0.0253504738,
-0.0086537749,
-0.0085902084,
0.0091401236,
-0.0189683735,
0.0134560429,
0.043864876,
0.0097121391,
0.0371452086,
0.0026373111,
0.0352240689,
-0.0033434811,
-0.0095080482,
-0.0107265376,
-0.0363004394,
0.0280342437,
-0.081362538,
0.0206291806,
-0.0037366785,
-0.03587595,
-0.0113738738,
0.0237447657,
-0.0327192694,
-0.0525613539,
-0.0261791218,
0.0034377109,
-0.0372749493,
-0.0325608961,
0.0303025115,
0.0079339379,
-0.0312762298,
-0.0314889364,
0.020924788,
-0.0268529374,
0.0128808999,
0.0166106634,
-0.0242566559,
0.0071948958,
-0.0128333112,
-0.0300156977,
0.0204955526,
-0.0243776478,
-0.0032189123,
0.0027252885,
-0.0138191991,
0.0074316291,
0.0388411097,
0.0261227824,
0.0336998664,
-0.020921478,
0.0131199546,
0.0604212806,
-0.0052289995,
-0.0613510907,
-0.0754838958,
-0.0008875735,
0.027415067,
0.0346068144,
0.0831212848,
0.0556813814,
0.0800622851,
-0.0149492426,
-0.0839786232,
0.0170211066,
0.0065713762,
0.0610520691,
-0.0063297092,
-0.0157506466,
-0.033564467,
-0.0194951724,
-0.0410560258,
0.0226018392,
-0.0296075288,
-0.0411371253,
0.0244115032,
-0.0585474409,
0.0127340062,
-0.0706287399,
0.0514648072,
-0.0271572713,
0.0094705457,
0.0529360324,
0.0155566474,
0.0333134644,
0.0117370402,
0.0298808441,
-0.0532582328,
-0.0078605115,
-0.0089285159,
0.0002012902,
0.0136175333,
0.0039631403,
-0.0204981659,
0.0549947321,
0.0044938228,
-0.0082388772,
-0.0319296569,
-0.0628168881,
0.0725814775,
0.0104952371,
0.0176032782,
0.0431233607,
-0.0053271153,
0.0544242822,
-0.0165867787,
-0.038840048,
0.042302575,
0.0013767245,
-0.0268648807,
-0.0148017844,
-0.0246483292,
-0.035436295,
-0.0007661722,
-0.0139304735,
0.0310595725,
-0.0646222532,
-0.0368285179,
0.0654342175,
2.577e-7,
0.0369050801,
0.0512626991,
0.0325874351,
-0.0035736703,
0.0130535774,
0.0012605797,
-0.0471265353,
0.0101351133,
0.0246297643,
0.0104725277,
0.0108563127,
0.0313813686,
0.0448887348,
0.0413406566,
-0.088196598,
0.0061947014,
-0.015149218,
-0.0094488934,
-0.0649458766,
-0.0092461025,
0.0526567474,
0.0258370657,
0.0535448976,
0.0265816282,
0.0087261964,
-0.028082598,
0.0482172221,
-0.0258031618,
0.0209801774,
0.0273153838,
-0.0280492231,
0.0075883409,
-0.018336745,
0.0039238515,
-0.0303546619,
0.0122770751,
0.0089065293,
0.0494923256,
0.029232379,
0.0150890825,
0.0068172426,
-0.0286066774,
0.0072121662,
-0.0425677598,
0.0463329703,
-0.0510505252,
0.0099413507,
-0.005956992,
-0.0067560812,
-0.0570005439,
0.0143473838,
-0.0156172905,
0.050955072,
-0.0189423747,
-0.008316596,
0.0099952053,
-0.0298436247,
-0.0642169118,
-0.044544939,
0.0338581428,
-0.0649086609,
0.0239014961,
-0.0365798883,
-0.0545018725,
0.0242003649,
-0.0469476245,
0.0015574307,
2.035336556e-34,
0.0039121294,
-0.0337757953,
-0.0111020571,
0.0230184887,
0.0044309651,
0.0103406683,
0.0043944535,
0.0379262045,
0.0362141579,
-0.0781842023,
-0.0275766067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08181v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08181v1 | Large Language Models for Failure Mode Classification: An Investigation | 2023-09-15T06:13:01 | 2023-09-15T06:13:01 | Michael Stewart, Melinda Hodkiewicz, Sirui Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper we present the first investigation into the effectiveness of
Large Language Models (LLMs) for Failure Mode Classification (FMC). FMC, the
task of automatically labelling an observation with a corresponding failure
mode code, is a critical task in the maintenance domain as it reduces the need
for reliability engineers to spend their time manually analysing work orders.
We detail our approach to prompt engineering to enable an LLM to predict the
failure mode of a given observation using a restricted code list. We
demonstrate that the performance of a GPT-3.5 model (F1=0.80) fine-tuned on
annotated data is a significant improvement over a currently available text
classification model (F1=0.60) trained on the same annotated data set. The
fine-tuned model also outperforms the out-of-the box GPT-3.5 (F1=0.46). This
investigation reinforces the need for high quality fine-tuning data sets for
domain-specific tasks using LLMs. | [
-0.0060669836,
0.0523761325,
-0.0057754023,
0.00731395,
0.026891537,
0.0469842069,
0.0093409009,
0.0525254719,
0.0177402403,
-0.067128107,
0.0563219376,
-0.0286008976,
-0.0331104919,
0.0547765829,
0.0243249517,
-0.0163653195,
0.0116330469,
-0.0085053975,
0.0107280789,
0.0172647201,
-0.0140324449,
0.0344293751,
0.0063908552,
0.0461767912,
-0.0374527164,
0.006496944,
0.0267789494,
-0.006561093,
0.0335032865,
-0.0285885651,
0.0399157405,
0.0505207814,
0.0432420261,
0.0349623337,
0.0000020583,
-0.0391805284,
-0.0231269524,
0.0083580352,
-0.0257976912,
-0.0005636018,
-0.0241743401,
-0.0279336143,
-0.0104467673,
0.0311826915,
-0.021084534,
-0.0298758373,
0.0617792048,
0.0715855584,
0.0556122735,
0.0586158112,
-0.0198229421,
0.0122382771,
0.0439365394,
-0.0184084196,
-0.0213499442,
-0.0467177033,
0.0300797392,
0.0641649514,
0.051835034,
-0.0111352736,
0.0040699719,
0.0214368198,
0.0324337631,
-0.0016579489,
-0.0464007966,
0.0522446297,
-0.01658592,
0.0720986277,
0.0092513561,
0.000608059,
-0.022921145,
-0.0210612025,
0.0104993237,
-0.0305020958,
0.0122868316,
-0.0046887649,
0.0124256071,
0.0069245421,
-0.0181724168,
0.0336384214,
-0.0066098087,
0.0241404381,
0.0065739867,
-0.0418924391,
-0.0215469804,
0.0369639806,
-0.0244109426,
-0.0181905553,
-0.0204026196,
0.0205040481,
-0.0579892658,
-0.0126593439,
-0.0239045285,
-0.0027713813,
-0.0177757628,
-0.0029500374,
-0.0234457236,
0.0072677457,
0.0407943912,
-0.0654796958,
-0.0349747688,
-0.0048100264,
-0.0508889295,
0.0299091972,
-0.0187099371,
0.0136715127,
0.0382045209,
0.0025553706,
-0.024351256,
0.0079779578,
-0.088511385,
-0.0436099768,
-0.0291169807,
0.0123975947,
0.0694266483,
0.0060724299,
-0.0443851314,
0.0236253608,
0.0010196754,
0.0025559117,
0.0068178982,
-0.0203999467,
-0.0340973176,
-0.0190742072,
-0.0030247075,
-0.020217143,
0.0119517371,
0.0210173093,
-0.0354129747,
-0.0392309576,
0.034223754,
0.0212342795,
-0.0177802294,
0.0010653996,
0.0081981234,
0.0229921546,
0.0023401217,
-0.0505280271,
-0.0763542727,
-0.0123489099,
-0.0379409194,
-0.0129229221,
-0.0503636487,
-0.001115671,
-0.0233322345,
0.0158438515,
0.0248805769,
-0.0217195489,
0.016052423,
-0.0442586988,
0.0337891206,
0.0588739999,
-0.0572489686,
0.0004402403,
0.030617293,
-0.0093086408,
0.0353130177,
0.0549579337,
0.0242529307,
0.0092664221,
0.016295027,
-0.0033468928,
0.0521754734,
0.0294108931,
-0.0811329037,
0.0273702797,
-0.0063975179,
-0.0201796293,
0.0424023829,
0.0100921225,
0.0053554848,
-0.0217168517,
0.0272264387,
-0.0090235025,
0.0330355503,
-0.0358238667,
0.03644225,
0.0160896573,
0.0143143693,
0.062437132,
-0.0372215249,
-0.059962336,
0.0211043954,
-0.029752614,
-0.0376714058,
0.0018668381,
0.0213788189,
-0.0068074176,
-0.0443340875,
-0.0586566813,
-0.0654561743,
0.0114548206,
-0.0249678902,
0.0117648095,
0.0884243697,
-0.0534648262,
-0.0120411823,
-0.0088645844,
0.0033679365,
0.0275157392,
-0.0202971026,
-0.0904595852,
-0.0054565989,
0.0693231821,
0.0320812799,
-0.1004699618,
-0.0372475609,
-0.0230287351,
0.0304452982,
-0.0508132018,
0.0213449318,
0.0189003684,
-0.0096701272,
-0.043740999,
-0.0276761465,
0.02702442,
0.0221045054,
-0.0072249528,
-0.0478590764,
-0.0189274997,
-0.0001421641,
-0.0085852845,
-0.0935765579,
0.0301679224,
0.0581953935,
-0.021430403,
0.0017099341,
0.0167073607,
-0.0192166828,
-0.0082343174,
-0.0389261469,
-0.0263450406,
0.0318393074,
-0.0171713736,
-0.0798266679,
0.007294415,
0.0031658271,
0.031019602,
0.0171610136,
0.0201999471,
-0.0123022338,
0.0257742442,
-0.0429766402,
-0.0506378599,
-0.058165662,
-0.0681783706,
-0.0081140064,
-0.035608042,
0.0131416507,
0.0025739414,
-0.0127935037,
-0.053625159,
0.0394108482,
0.0214361474,
0.008257933,
-0.0332035497,
-0.0067273788,
0.0402757786,
-0.043954812,
-0.058278054,
0.0476679541,
-0.0250748172,
0.0429005921,
0.006488557,
0.0388706885,
0.0022631444,
-0.0106781097,
-0.082996428,
-0.0210473742,
-0.0274659358,
0.0042714593,
-0.0067635919,
-0.0307953004,
-0.0315818116,
-0.0099595478,
-0.0201260746,
0.032987304,
-0.0012267721,
-0.0117906341,
0.0269698016,
0.0094062928,
-0.0423184931,
0.028458165,
0.0115262251,
-0.0034977274,
0.0334990658,
0.060263183,
-0.0278799888,
-0.1529408842,
0.0830876902,
0.0095656691,
0.0002662031,
-0.0163121186,
-0.0552754179,
-0.0109388437,
-0.0137700867,
0.024414869,
0.0007344931,
-0.0027485858,
0.0205972083,
0.0198627748,
0.0347741917,
-0.015071027,
-0.0058924155,
-0.0392463692,
-0.0424046405,
-0.0085209627,
-0.0255444068,
-0.0175601244,
-0.0065466054,
0.0226589497,
-0.0071349125,
-0.0553850941,
-0.0168152396,
0.0054828082,
0.0316669419,
-0.0190155599,
-0.0100922082,
-0.0114026163,
0.036664065,
0.0538504981,
-0.0425548628,
0.0533047616,
0.0231462196,
0.0111436807,
-0.055892799,
-0.070809789,
-0.0203662235,
0.0571932532,
-0.0143812411,
0.0032002991,
0.058207687,
-0.022191219,
0.0110693099,
0.0168087892,
-0.0426650681,
0.0021913478,
0.0025162245,
-0.0620204546,
0.065121986,
0.006433533,
-0.0503040552,
0.0092960931,
-0.0335611813,
-0.0311485101,
0.0077801249,
-0.0156659223,
-0.0080883177,
-0.0380497016,
0.0777182505,
-0.0003970392,
0.0930595174,
-0.0019865721,
-0.0132101737,
0.0020339824,
0.0141848102,
-0.0031697929,
0.0154642873,
0.0040138341,
-0.037292622,
0.0161101092,
0.0008272882,
-0.0047443346,
0.0352373533,
-0.0581391342,
-0.0249188282,
0.0385658741,
-0.0143348267,
-0.0140485419,
0.0241605788,
-0.0138278538,
-0.0709898919,
-0.0216847789,
0.0730967224,
0.0179747511,
-0.0488547198,
-0.0050159241,
0.0232418068,
0.009044514,
0.0292421337,
0.0165080372,
-0.0124275833,
-0.0057048867,
0.0245717447,
0.0562835671,
0.01089973,
0.0320107229,
0.0275636483,
-0.0228438415,
0.0585445203,
0.0002416586,
-0.0426306054,
-0.0872763544,
-0.0454341285,
-0.0150769083,
-0.0361570232,
-0.0092350254,
0.0077217519,
0.016421007,
-0.0303990114,
0.0875513852,
-0.0616820008,
-0.0969958305,
0.0447115041,
0.0135816317,
0.0596433356,
0.0894475654,
-0.0185274221,
-0.0549163073,
0.003189483,
0.0898996666,
-0.0097308541,
0.0170341581,
-0.0076524499,
0.0577559546,
0.0116863605,
-0.0008119546,
0.0225306638,
0.0253359955,
-0.0303873867,
-0.0021890525,
0.0245058518,
0.0696984679,
-0.0514177456,
-0.0125545477,
-0.0017522491,
-0.0239627548,
0.0250549521,
0.0031169283,
-0.0013578415,
-0.0906028524,
-0.0422032736,
-0.0176928695,
0.0095653608,
0.0022058019,
-0.0146987243,
-0.0184506774,
-0.0197383743,
-0.0271323621,
-0.0149085354,
-0.0304482337,
0.0340340696,
0.0226812065,
-0.0121238148,
-0.0088734971,
-0.010066417,
0.0147764189,
-0.0130819306,
-0.008305423,
-0.0096953632,
0.047849644,
-0.0788968727,
0.0067254519,
0.0437851585,
-0.0245391745,
-0.0521825552,
-0.0474008061,
-0.027941322,
-0.0405790955,
0.0259516966,
0.0471283123,
0.0200576764,
-0.0489285365,
-0.0049037212,
-0.1028172746,
-0.0148512339,
0.0465489179,
-0.0301111061,
0.0063389759,
-0.0166711397,
-0.0111704487,
-0.0303630438,
-0.003801917,
-0.0263885874,
0.0345666967,
-0.0226625931,
-0.0005735322,
-0.0109982817,
-0.0207936596,
-0.0190848559,
0.0141864941,
-0.0014237477,
-0.0084467726,
-0.0689599812,
-0.0232465975,
0.0219106227,
0.0418010019,
-0.0150205111,
-0.0131990565,
0.1010556892,
0.0249538068,
-0.0623649023,
-0.0235838369,
-0.0483599268,
-0.0022429142,
0.0434345379,
-0.026777558,
0.0174633879,
0.0099150455,
0.0253070239,
0.0361375026,
-0.0147281922,
0.0093832966,
0.009338351,
0.0621491671,
0.0103200022,
0.007484166,
0.070599772,
0.0147131421,
-0.0146796666,
-0.0238410141,
0.0343249068,
-0.0372090861,
-0.0359999165,
-0.050018426,
-0.02081028,
0.0645345822,
0.0210771393,
0.0380480923,
-0.0662038773,
-0.0010602053,
-0.0536223762,
0.0259543825,
0.0392870195,
0.051415205,
0.0393992029,
0.019492805,
-0.0684914067,
-0.0095247934,
0.0447255448,
0.0665248483,
-0.0076589067,
-0.0056525767,
-0.0366064645,
-0.0416120365,
0.0171424225,
0.069272548,
0.0115203494,
-0.0078292284,
-0.0012817286,
-0.0636315197,
-0.0078027658,
0.024505619,
-0.0024179546,
0.0197532997,
-0.0442882478,
0.006935074,
0.0612134747,
0.0162969399,
0.0725449473,
-0.0042993608,
-0.0509005673,
0.0483598933,
0.0142727681,
-0.013755084,
-5.407441154e-33,
-0.0040269266,
-0.0676943958,
-0.0283960644,
-0.0177524928,
-0.0100941649,
0.0311631393,
0.0427120924,
-0.0162989814,
0.0657042563,
-0.005449051,
0.0298077893,
0.0295680128,
0.00392312,
-0.01506228,
0.0216090661,
-0.0086412001,
0.0139708053,
0.0150308581,
-0.0259197112,
0.0430480614,
0.0723393857,
0.0001000153,
0.049359601,
-0.0983482674,
0.0369722806,
0.0085600773,
-0.028793823,
0.010518943,
0.0273513515,
0.0492948219,
-0.0279678795,
0.0673760921,
0.0377539024,
-0.0516726151,
0.025637975,
-0.0074603213,
0.0360961705,
-0.0074187252,
-0.0334684439,
-0.0230486318,
0.074539341,
-0.022357313,
0.0229512677,
0.0055508385,
-0.0407037735,
-0.0002761086,
0.0626210198,
-0.0126280459,
0.0050318819,
-0.0446672998,
-0.0342662446,
0.0535184741,
-0.0237053484,
-0.0157239139,
0.0145003367,
0.0167098138,
0.0101887537,
0.0210956782,
-0.0184067972,
-0.0039247987,
0.0322256312,
0.0379331,
0.0373148285,
-0.0115099261,
-0.0468406007,
0.03625267,
-0.0331963785,
0.0221456047,
0.0259776302,
-0.0361969322,
-0.0026487994,
0.0388141051,
0.0426097214,
0.0337406807,
0.0060709068,
-0.0616736971,
-0.0856088251,
0.0494007096,
-0.0114971548,
-0.0191269219,
0.0728548616,
0.0171982348,
-0.0762911141,
-0.0391585007,
-0.0251893774,
0.0165669322,
-0.0271053649,
-0.008362514,
0.0316118076,
0.007461777,
-0.0270449482,
0.019422723,
0.0248136707,
-0.0061529744,
-0.0130609516,
0.0172784124,
-0.0248566456,
0.0141273364,
-0.0214899965,
0.0370385833,
-0.0068732202,
-0.0204056166,
0.0126510374,
0.0264147148,
0.0188967753,
-0.0562481843,
0.0187840629,
0.0486188419,
-0.0700131133,
0.03472431,
0.0217165556,
-0.0423289798,
-0.0480424725,
0.0389370695,
0.0229720566,
0.0190953091,
0.0352772847,
0.0463445894,
0.0017652843,
-0.0535715371,
-0.0156252086,
-0.0053060129,
-0.0178182926,
-0.0053505078,
-0.0035906122,
0.0339639857,
-0.0051918174,
0.0089380601,
0.000344078,
-0.0098414663,
-0.0093299318,
0.0376029387,
2.598e-7,
0.0597499423,
0.0697222501,
-0.0192437805,
0.0031015512,
0.0041219546,
0.0450425297,
-0.0041579837,
-0.0168565325,
0.0151836053,
0.0475339666,
0.0449270271,
-0.0377971679,
0.0643744543,
0.0234272387,
-0.0399862155,
0.0244365204,
-0.008432392,
0.0274493769,
-0.0823608711,
0.0012776133,
0.1197595447,
0.0910185948,
-0.0030543711,
-0.0061218613,
0.0211635195,
-0.0372333899,
0.0249190889,
-0.0505370386,
0.0025604868,
0.0174895171,
0.0191731695,
0.0299772993,
-0.0114850737,
0.0449850373,
0.0027882867,
0.0094998777,
0.0069559785,
0.0598170497,
-0.0122875301,
-0.009513855,
0.0289886612,
0.0169648305,
0.0312622972,
-0.0444646701,
0.025558969,
-0.0492419936,
-0.0284070075,
0.0327129699,
-0.008576666,
-0.0599589013,
0.0295518208,
-0.0222080946,
-0.0295981709,
0.0386341102,
-0.0373917297,
-0.0300036222,
-0.0051973402,
-0.0516487807,
0.0145717636,
0.0423314869,
-0.05114685,
-0.0840493739,
-0.0066642752,
0.0101265348,
0.054021053,
-0.0457921736,
0.0091082891,
2.624473661e-34,
0.0388622321,
-0.0149253793,
-0.0224248525,
0.0430899709,
0.0235696696,
0.016327424,
0.0167939104,
0.0260719601,
-0.0121876216,
-0.0808537453,
0.0058714021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08173v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08173v3 | FedJudge: Federated Legal Large Language Model | 2023-09-15T05:45:44 | 2024-04-10T13:24:55 | Linan Yue, Qi Liu, Yichao Du, Weibo Gao, Ye Liu, Fangzhou Yao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have gained prominence in the field of Legal
Intelligence, offering potential applications in assisting legal professionals
and laymen. However, the centralized training of these Legal LLMs raises data
privacy concerns, as legal data is distributed among various institutions
containing sensitive individual information. This paper addresses this
challenge by exploring the integration of Legal LLMs with Federated Learning
(FL) methodologies. By employing FL, Legal LLMs can be fine-tuned locally on
devices or clients, and their parameters are aggregated and distributed on a
central server, ensuring data privacy without directly sharing raw data.
However, computation and communication overheads hinder the full fine-tuning of
LLMs under the FL setting. Moreover, the distribution shift of legal data
reduces the effectiveness of FL methods. To this end, in this paper, we propose
the first Federated Legal Large Language Model (FedJudge) framework, which
fine-tunes Legal LLMs efficiently and effectively. Specifically, FedJudge
utilizes parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods to update only a few
additional parameters during the FL training. Besides, we explore the continual
learning methods to preserve the global model's important parameters when
training local clients to mitigate the problem of data shifts. Extensive
experimental results on three real-world datasets clearly validate the
effectiveness of FedJudge. Code is released at
https://github.com/yuelinan/FedJudge. | [
0.0410864726,
0.0797307864,
-0.0307354871,
0.0127611933,
-0.0654970556,
0.0180106219,
0.1014853492,
0.0140389577,
0.035887368,
-0.0435764007,
-0.0409634076,
-0.0219051633,
-0.0093034934,
0.0085961241,
-0.0101210671,
0.0170285553,
0.0422284789,
-0.0163424108,
0.0154499626,
-0.0409025177,
-0.0168636851,
0.0031109462,
0.0314943194,
0.0020941789,
-0.0200369805,
-0.025981674,
-0.0133262509,
0.0005177394,
0.00708724,
0.0444631465,
0.0277307723,
0.0776666105,
0.0212606974,
0.0647999644,
0.0000021264,
-0.0401421636,
-0.0383578725,
0.0173785686,
-0.0129650654,
0.0412634201,
0.0287056901,
-0.0390746221,
-0.0266562644,
0.0054060016,
-0.0440551117,
-0.0036405327,
0.0127134947,
0.0009043543,
0.0717904344,
0.0984744132,
0.0020502645,
-0.0685714409,
0.0299031995,
-0.0427836142,
-0.0774701536,
-0.0500153191,
0.0367872752,
-0.0089157354,
-0.023219673,
-0.0112695191,
0.0153905991,
0.0138905142,
0.0264375042,
0.0056463908,
-0.0286489241,
-0.0180936996,
-0.0608885325,
0.004963181,
-0.0269354209,
0.0467497855,
0.0209198426,
-0.0164956171,
0.0128289098,
0.0026618137,
0.0299492572,
0.0271487702,
-0.0112585491,
0.07119634,
-0.0122602358,
0.0295064766,
-0.0026148353,
-0.0127419438,
0.0166500974,
0.0332459956,
-0.0240412597,
0.0701748803,
-0.017642064,
-0.0101983994,
-0.0396736674,
-0.0321744457,
-0.0028241079,
-0.0479133315,
0.0841766745,
0.0356706716,
-0.0053614788,
0.0032099788,
-0.0636146814,
-0.0490838923,
0.0477058515,
-0.0348240435,
0.0227871891,
-0.0493560098,
0.0083471779,
0.0696922317,
-0.0267776288,
0.0018399612,
0.0009225862,
0.0244054962,
0.0100264689,
-0.0385761634,
-0.0302060954,
0.00463966,
-0.0047864448,
0.0831128284,
-0.0793665946,
0.0041620233,
-0.0277699661,
0.0152360154,
-0.0200849455,
0.0487390347,
-0.0082420791,
-0.0250128414,
-0.0079150191,
-0.0459868722,
-0.0011913402,
-0.0304149911,
-0.0285912398,
0.0478776284,
0.0049444046,
-0.0126819108,
0.0081211096,
-0.0236203149,
-0.0073986812,
0.0158380382,
-0.0112128472,
0.078378424,
0.0313164443,
-0.0176757518,
-0.040547844,
-0.0645264015,
0.027922105,
-0.0575132854,
-0.0346207432,
-0.0676597059,
0.0172043517,
-0.0323052146,
-0.0140259508,
-0.0672732741,
-0.0035844119,
0.0275030788,
-0.0359091088,
0.0675533116,
-0.0287054982,
0.0106165484,
-0.0252123848,
0.0171096902,
0.0228679031,
0.0561195053,
-0.0049195555,
0.0167552065,
0.0508515202,
-0.018973371,
0.0153308241,
0.037537206,
0.0281430408,
0.0274889953,
-0.0194953382,
0.0124115385,
-0.0017296365,
-0.0193023626,
-0.0273579154,
0.0313309133,
0.0059451256,
-0.0160351861,
0.0602382384,
0.0788936913,
0.0573008023,
0.0507403165,
-0.0624812059,
0.0150767434,
0.0128810452,
-0.0180702582,
-0.0744116232,
-0.0065651136,
-0.0628146678,
-0.0431551486,
-0.0586145967,
0.0751262978,
-0.030952869,
-0.0245426558,
0.0159833338,
-0.0586729348,
-0.0197462719,
0.025762897,
0.0407002866,
0.005596811,
0.0273898747,
0.0449206792,
0.0300021768,
-0.0372963399,
-0.0415723808,
-0.0258375108,
0.009855873,
0.0629943311,
0.0439053774,
-0.0213880409,
-0.013364492,
-0.0428565033,
0.0331247933,
0.0199766904,
-0.007271071,
0.0075024571,
0.0300663076,
-0.0495908111,
-0.0478975587,
0.047149796,
0.0301332753,
0.0014378403,
-0.0110253561,
0.0076291836,
0.0241800714,
-0.0323441513,
-0.0031117019,
0.0168266892,
0.0057159881,
-0.0262254328,
0.0277860761,
0.001361732,
0.0229532532,
0.0127609037,
0.0001913014,
-0.0310402084,
0.0371745639,
0.0115235075,
0.0096203694,
-0.0179508235,
0.0264183804,
0.0060103736,
0.0230383798,
0.0013142978,
0.0247351043,
-0.0002294898,
-0.0713285208,
0.0044723274,
-0.0393022336,
-0.0013636861,
0.0289287306,
-0.0201105513,
0.0148266805,
-0.0175087582,
0.0102477279,
-0.0237503648,
0.0268794391,
-0.0341556147,
-0.0474859513,
-0.0249482282,
-0.0165378954,
0.0388041064,
-0.0057925112,
0.0266669709,
-0.0129893273,
-0.0169057362,
0.0298831258,
0.0069480273,
0.0384882055,
-0.0129508767,
-0.0395265743,
-0.0297052525,
0.016413616,
-0.039549388,
0.0117481593,
0.0113344323,
0.0000511425,
-0.0289296377,
-0.043822825,
-0.0351601914,
0.0098447539,
-0.0350568742,
0.009866124,
-0.0115703642,
-0.0168540962,
-0.0596849509,
0.0265343096,
-0.0326484554,
0.0028497346,
0.0134057794,
-0.0118498579,
-0.0203905981,
-0.0575331561,
0.025501024,
-0.0526729189,
0.0065061394,
-0.0007988309,
-0.0145963077,
-0.0408310257,
0.0267767403,
-0.0369133987,
0.0453076102,
0.0223211497,
-0.004818941,
0.026789844,
0.0083933044,
-0.052759137,
-0.0227720272,
0.0101038581,
-0.018410828,
-0.0591677055,
0.0184541997,
0.0220432859,
-0.003469337,
-0.0172935091,
-0.0086769974,
-0.0045313579,
0.0641638115,
0.0006038568,
-0.0229064971,
-0.0413117148,
0.0332703516,
-0.0093429536,
0.0129101295,
0.0167932827,
-0.0908072889,
0.0665443763,
0.0110986233,
0.0715753213,
-0.0318193771,
-0.0563725792,
-0.0439960398,
0.0629412457,
-0.0139623396,
0.0408922471,
-0.0312180761,
-0.0670246333,
0.0133226784,
0.0296330247,
0.0621522777,
-0.0641221106,
0.0441267006,
-0.0187571254,
-0.017737342,
-0.003525665,
-0.0566339642,
-0.015178171,
-0.0684932768,
-0.0119323889,
0.0101396292,
-0.0232815184,
-0.0196113847,
-0.0151969297,
-0.0118646305,
-0.001555186,
0.0126942238,
0.0022085628,
0.0262854043,
-0.0418384746,
-0.021110205,
-0.0063551604,
-0.0377356112,
-0.0058351839,
-0.0159398317,
0.0018308923,
0.0355266668,
0.021483643,
-0.0341325365,
0.0543946512,
-0.0057263887,
0.0202054251,
-0.0313524678,
-0.0180328768,
0.0252486058,
0.0385006666,
-0.0411866717,
0.0180027671,
0.0769227967,
0.0200003758,
-0.0705520362,
-0.0048508663,
0.0069330935,
0.0192190129,
0.0144556146,
0.014509052,
-0.1188570857,
-0.0035984435,
0.0111026466,
0.026046142,
-0.0081577012,
-0.0263527278,
-0.0294868704,
-0.0852667689,
0.055971317,
0.0621596538,
0.0005757242,
-0.0468569025,
-0.006268532,
0.0099123409,
0.0194303878,
0.0174326785,
-0.0342345126,
-0.0157796554,
-0.0318093598,
0.0110619348,
-0.0443445817,
-0.0180386156,
-0.0299884044,
-0.0605969168,
0.064942956,
0.0276267398,
-0.0029048373,
-0.009341849,
-0.0387269147,
0.010743008,
0.0406198502,
-0.0076904977,
-0.0160293393,
0.0196649469,
0.010729108,
0.016903894,
-0.0277231187,
0.0648951828,
0.0176901389,
-0.0265275128,
0.0637166649,
0.0514912009,
-0.0407946892,
0.0066315914,
0.0008927497,
-0.0202323869,
0.0265072733,
0.0380244032,
-0.0003851974,
-0.0247947704,
-0.01529055,
-0.020048961,
-0.0208552312,
0.022564346,
0.0156181948,
0.0284458864,
-0.0174139738,
-0.0007721685,
-0.013041744,
0.0248259325,
-0.0021100724,
0.0382373855,
0.0299230963,
0.0349242799,
0.0585688688,
-0.0499138832,
-0.032420069,
0.0043245503,
-0.0801589191,
0.028914243,
-0.0404957458,
-0.0080265636,
0.0268280637,
0.0181801375,
-0.0052963183,
0.0187009312,
-0.0516234972,
-0.053902138,
0.0080918586,
0.0095589934,
0.023329813,
0.0388565958,
-0.0640803874,
-0.0855606794,
0.0817924291,
0.0473723374,
-0.0729403123,
-0.0012591671,
0.0604859553,
-0.0594527908,
-0.0113010174,
0.0265497938,
-0.0362999849,
0.0131774554,
0.0779443681,
-0.0329698808,
-0.0238785706,
-0.0310827326,
0.0173456296,
0.0677290782,
0.0388743356,
0.0241331998,
0.003654439,
-0.004684635,
0.0381347425,
-0.0215123426,
-0.0127898483,
-0.0086708283,
-0.0009305601,
0.0251653064,
-0.0127354925,
-0.0029773011,
0.0343536325,
0.0663101673,
-0.0282492228,
-0.0677911267,
0.0276617762,
-0.0040122005,
-0.0177583564,
0.0415056832,
-0.0159633141,
-0.0016882111,
0.0631483868,
0.0143906912,
0.0551199205,
-0.0190514289,
0.0604052097,
-0.003965002,
0.0227700956,
-0.0588559173,
0.0435489602,
-0.0179681573,
-0.089603439,
-0.0094177211,
0.0628539771,
0.0644357577,
0.0308826342,
0.0004346874,
-0.0428467467,
-0.0060523557,
-0.0114456136,
0.0207712352,
-0.026984388,
-0.0362113267,
-0.0009118812,
0.0013253548,
-0.0182507932,
0.0764826462,
0.0611042269,
-0.004810432,
0.0005583761,
-0.0450928025,
-0.0141554661,
-0.0518834703,
-0.0066123647,
0.0180894658,
0.0353274383,
-0.0485805497,
-0.0218145754,
-0.0370608494,
-0.050437618,
-0.0132062379,
-0.0202299953,
-0.0059738806,
0.0056617851,
0.0052707293,
0.0334445983,
-0.0004386853,
-0.0333094895,
-0.063387692,
0.0284410305,
0.0190776177,
-0.0105478344,
0.021312613,
-5.916051111e-33,
-0.0208142307,
-0.0080219712,
-0.0157704186,
0.0497389287,
-0.0169066768,
0.0176227652,
0.0350805596,
-0.0182526112,
0.0067434143,
0.0001164065,
-0.026424665,
0.0352065228,
0.0172593631,
0.0100527182,
-0.0118975742,
-0.0238087401,
0.0088509182,
-0.019567674,
-0.0023569539,
0.0392272286,
0.0232276712,
0.0378284454,
0.0219661631,
-0.0987913236,
0.004700942,
0.023403978,
-0.0551319532,
0.0183495935,
-0.0991249904,
0.0574970171,
0.0142937386,
0.0321528912,
0.01556205,
-0.015720889,
-0.0281053428,
0.0508324206,
-0.0532001555,
0.0295843855,
-0.0117426831,
0.0212501716,
0.03397239,
-0.0504902564,
0.0619512834,
-0.033663068,
-0.0177948065,
-0.0027006518,
0.0075211525,
-0.041686669,
-0.0675042123,
-0.0526781976,
-0.0147310365,
0.033927545,
-0.0180621222,
0.0343788564,
0.0234320145,
-0.0225616787,
-0.0026801936,
-0.0173206106,
-0.0746072903,
0.0190254133,
0.028113272,
-0.0245911535,
0.043504186,
-0.0117067266,
0.0008244034,
0.0552094132,
0.0385796092,
0.0064517721,
-0.0494536459,
0.0023268939,
0.0174204241,
0.0791166872,
0.0182560515,
0.0306548905,
-0.0183880683,
-0.0647790059,
-0.0734934434,
-0.0225672014,
0.0323178992,
-0.0011314875,
0.0198281817,
-0.0055668871,
-0.0302187987,
-0.0104623651,
-0.0399633646,
-0.0025869333,
0.0016111175,
0.0008267884,
0.0058527915,
0.0110056112,
0.0022979926,
-0.0260968972,
0.0060840361,
-0.0641923249,
-0.0187644213,
0.0345685594,
0.0538118817,
0.0067278491,
-0.012099064,
0.0352034532,
-0.0524457581,
-0.0462778024,
-0.0301648639,
-0.0629448593,
0.0192314256,
-0.0000644652,
0.0935595781,
0.0098836282,
-0.0719978884,
-0.0039145844,
0.0098098135,
0.0291707274,
0.0510577522,
0.0056577092,
0.029026987,
-0.0029671197,
0.0389042646,
0.04786231,
0.0331899114,
-0.011963075,
-0.0194770899,
-0.0032861151,
0.0082268901,
0.000787753,
0.0097673852,
0.0014479349,
-0.0125740208,
0.0141999461,
0.0791972727,
0.0101310248,
0.0184634123,
0.0151291871,
2.824e-7,
0.0332122035,
0.0355939306,
-0.0488185808,
-0.0336883813,
0.0180161279,
0.0344399028,
0.0041449312,
0.0619416386,
0.024926614,
0.0127371205,
-0.0118017467,
0.0082061086,
0.0771563277,
0.023819685,
-0.0548693463,
-0.0020578732,
-0.0326490849,
0.0103930356,
-0.0865228325,
0.0264423955,
-0.0136979902,
0.0895326734,
0.0557244271,
-0.032255929,
0.0166370533,
-0.0305259973,
0.0285161659,
-0.0421551131,
-0.0507087708,
-0.0302616656,
0.0502092279,
0.0281538349,
-0.0009363865,
0.0348269492,
-0.0002354355,
0.0690296218,
-0.055198364,
0.0995116681,
0.0161309876,
0.0751073733,
-0.021174252,
-0.0712262094,
-0.025288118,
0.0114552211,
0.0573541075,
-0.0176924188,
-0.026383087,
-0.0080523994,
0.0199128184,
-0.0982084498,
0.0306672696,
0.0020324911,
0.0013146424,
-0.003901954,
0.0315975957,
-0.0191406738,
-0.0131763173,
-0.0856432319,
-0.0005205553,
0.0228785295,
-0.0137081156,
-0.0136673944,
0.0080657164,
0.0223094914,
0.0296896342,
-0.0670005754,
0.0642947406,
2.572138219e-34,
0.006604292,
-0.0328073688,
0.0151775032,
0.0385822617,
0.0147211757,
0.0022790921,
0.0004067475,
0.0134179927,
-0.000866288,
-0.068707332,
0.0412382111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08172v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08172v2 | LASER: LLM Agent with State-Space Exploration for Web Navigation | 2023-09-15T05:44:08 | 2024-02-21T17:42:32 | Kaixin Ma, Hongming Zhang, Hongwei Wang, Xiaoman Pan, Wenhao Yu, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have been successfully adapted for interactive
decision-making tasks like web navigation. While achieving decent performance,
previous methods implicitly assume a forward-only execution mode for the model,
where they only provide oracle trajectories as in-context examples to guide the
model on how to reason in the environment. Consequently, the model could not
handle more challenging scenarios not covered in the in-context examples, e.g.,
mistakes, leading to sub-optimal performance. To address this issue, we propose
to model the interactive task as state space exploration, where the LLM agent
transitions among a pre-defined set of states by performing actions to complete
the task. This formulation enables flexible backtracking, allowing the model to
recover from errors easily. We evaluate our proposed LLM Agent with State-Space
ExploRation (LASER) on both the WebShop task and amazon.com. Experimental
results show that LASER significantly outperforms previous methods and closes
the gap with human performance on the web navigation task. | [
0.0375753045,
0.0096268235,
-0.0245930441,
-0.0185265411,
-0.0306488797,
0.0126320617,
-0.0254712738,
-0.0021633438,
0.0632991046,
-0.0440401807,
-0.0097259609,
-0.0337789431,
-0.0343837328,
0.049161505,
-0.0010370045,
-0.0338616259,
0.0442461036,
-0.0636270866,
0.0122228228,
-0.0074090408,
-0.0242998414,
-0.0596834049,
-0.0065669883,
0.0467631258,
0.0607222356,
-0.0186401177,
-0.0695017651,
0.0170244928,
0.0144246854,
-0.0376374237,
-0.0133597096,
-0.0079433359,
0.0487315468,
0.0180948768,
0.0000019541,
-0.0404975265,
-0.002567254,
-0.025764972,
-0.0455210805,
0.0014338638,
-0.0161482934,
0.0444675758,
-0.0278921388,
0.041169472,
-0.0178492349,
0.0114936531,
0.0141836796,
0.0555977374,
0.0441683494,
0.0699208304,
0.0024538953,
0.0366891064,
-0.0149566475,
0.0114731006,
-0.0060691666,
-0.07345175,
0.029261576,
-0.0021819642,
0.0272614807,
-0.0164486468,
-0.018682681,
0.0076611829,
0.0100752432,
-0.0055134483,
-0.0324141271,
0.0286755804,
0.0095455591,
-0.0111732678,
-0.0356444195,
0.0445498712,
-0.0176948979,
0.0043422291,
0.0342117324,
0.0089949686,
-0.0145922294,
0.0028638251,
-0.0043451618,
0.0100969318,
-0.0191445947,
0.0195434168,
0.0193604194,
-0.0144877853,
0.0283678751,
0.0192038957,
-0.0752865002,
0.0924284533,
-0.0143496403,
-0.0547927432,
0.0385969095,
-0.0183171928,
0.0281769,
-0.0438464843,
0.0339596458,
0.0837954208,
-0.1083275527,
0.0435472205,
0.0027626085,
0.0526718125,
-0.0170739461,
-0.054729905,
0.0486111529,
0.0462418012,
-0.0092413342,
0.0609036982,
0.0025402708,
0.0491411127,
-0.0274933539,
0.0025549631,
-0.01494209,
0.0139687071,
-0.0439116955,
0.011594099,
-0.0422923639,
0.0201265849,
-0.037263792,
-0.0549558885,
0.0029771219,
0.0684619471,
-0.0039990759,
0.0520904176,
-0.0418569967,
-0.0048119607,
-0.0112165883,
0.0170447472,
-0.0901128501,
-0.0269075409,
-0.0358699672,
-0.0027182009,
-0.0052975561,
-0.0117219742,
0.0104050236,
0.0240405444,
-0.0362713039,
-0.010405628,
-0.0205334015,
0.1146371514,
-0.0159815177,
-0.0439950973,
-0.093390502,
-0.021574758,
0.0385978185,
-0.066069901,
0.0124487635,
-0.0344018899,
0.0366862826,
0.0069206753,
-0.0384295955,
-0.0268893689,
0.0064663072,
0.0260592178,
0.0042982814,
0.0499343574,
0.0216337051,
-0.0024508645,
0.0105864098,
-0.0080575943,
0.01736141,
0.0589839518,
0.0188513193,
0.0799568444,
0.0069083278,
0.0345675386,
0.0281175897,
0.0241588149,
-0.0221585166,
0.027497407,
-0.0239046998,
0.0250596125,
0.0123778135,
0.0496590249,
-0.0205165241,
0.0501121283,
-0.0389706194,
0.0344783887,
0.034869846,
0.0323295146,
0.0326497331,
-0.0011432897,
0.0320098139,
-0.0080112452,
0.0001628221,
-0.0186013952,
-0.0448764153,
0.0131858215,
-0.0470447466,
-0.0092723174,
-0.00826992,
0.0180112589,
-0.0239017792,
-0.0409007855,
0.0074754488,
0.0098490659,
0.0285106674,
0.0141597623,
0.054783348,
-0.0093993163,
-0.0500719845,
-0.0238913912,
0.0003774923,
-0.0033398939,
-0.0271046106,
-0.0555387214,
0.0020802238,
0.1205352098,
0.0662343949,
-0.0331522599,
-0.0434422232,
-0.0235267635,
-0.0151033029,
0.0420207903,
0.0364619456,
-0.0260461029,
-0.033101175,
-0.0200300012,
-0.063431263,
0.0245568585,
-0.0012511847,
0.0420966633,
0.0174697451,
0.0104270065,
-0.0078631239,
-0.0302678496,
0.0136963455,
0.0259392783,
-0.0142558822,
-0.0449997932,
-0.0263543595,
0.0066132289,
0.0392332152,
-0.0061144591,
0.0117235305,
-0.0142022446,
0.0307697337,
0.0234623253,
-0.0317570269,
-0.0023641321,
0.0032390305,
-0.0076241153,
0.039152544,
0.0005708144,
0.0079882853,
0.0204841103,
-0.0091681657,
-0.0791753456,
-0.0242570657,
-0.0347965993,
0.0398378409,
0.0084198341,
0.0309183002,
0.0041600917,
-0.0141625842,
-0.0319293477,
0.0610548481,
0.0047186939,
-0.0274941493,
0.0146477716,
0.0302360952,
-0.0176322684,
-0.0486693121,
-0.0241772998,
0.0059909252,
0.0184313729,
0.0105584562,
0.0304128826,
0.0023024308,
-0.0357774384,
0.0015040378,
-0.0719009638,
0.0075107147,
-0.0204389524,
0.0160370041,
0.0018341283,
0.0024048528,
-0.0017487211,
-0.0206378009,
0.0145777138,
0.0354199782,
0.0107094264,
0.0325917713,
0.0132923294,
0.0411308967,
-0.0699571073,
-0.0491796173,
-0.0193335991,
-0.014561614,
-0.0246841945,
-0.0127456682,
-0.0248992462,
-0.09187112,
0.0511551648,
-0.0090837134,
0.0558282398,
-0.0403611436,
-0.005718282,
0.0142530296,
-0.0345970355,
-0.010352782,
0.0515996404,
-0.0023465934,
0.0427922606,
0.0745693892,
-0.0410537645,
-0.0645442978,
0.0362947993,
-0.0059868577,
0.0349401534,
-0.0842830092,
0.0518291965,
0.0396231674,
0.02527049,
-0.0431960486,
0.0412195027,
-0.0140487272,
-0.0616441518,
0.0047059897,
-0.0332166106,
-0.0431309156,
0.0139089106,
-0.0485841744,
0.081675373,
0.0054516965,
-0.0322971083,
0.0714063272,
0.0167822856,
0.0042112879,
0.0017198498,
-0.0158651173,
-0.0263457112,
0.0394330509,
-0.0201721787,
0.0082128281,
-0.0266541187,
-0.0441856049,
-0.0139292693,
-0.0091505619,
0.0026557359,
-0.0221089106,
0.0790012926,
-0.0436861813,
0.0167823657,
-0.0081035467,
-0.0592943281,
-0.0657103434,
-0.0241391547,
-0.0168377608,
-0.0205671601,
0.0234178919,
-0.0309369192,
-0.0685520396,
0.0076882495,
0.0295476075,
0.035520941,
0.0027627074,
-0.0444313772,
-0.0228750724,
-0.0446932204,
0.0278771594,
0.0349716134,
0.0335279107,
-0.0180739332,
0.0245132428,
0.0457435697,
0.0525054559,
-0.0688350275,
-0.0064974669,
-0.0007899618,
0.0533967577,
-0.0724795759,
-0.0249463078,
0.0644638687,
-0.0319129191,
-0.0634891316,
-0.0418575965,
0.0938224792,
0.045771271,
-0.0466174036,
-0.0059673963,
-0.0521662757,
0.0062594386,
0.0253909621,
0.073404707,
-0.0394955873,
-0.010064424,
0.0229683556,
0.005814625,
0.0129698617,
-0.0126095423,
0.0254329182,
-0.0910004452,
0.0265318509,
-0.0021619692,
-0.0189068783,
0.0126878647,
-0.0522838421,
0.0044395234,
0.0049584946,
0.0121719847,
0.088737756,
0.001747591,
-0.0353498943,
0.0044240849,
0.0272509847,
-0.0308135841,
0.0223690979,
0.0064764181,
0.0315405764,
0.052638378,
0.023455197,
-0.0044438457,
-0.0229694992,
0.0226441193,
-0.0116455154,
0.0225207284,
-0.0400308333,
0.0076637478,
-0.0040955748,
0.0107098985,
-0.0095681185,
0.0007627213,
-0.0246589631,
-0.0053187544,
0.0132119823,
0.0672971755,
-0.0782414526,
0.0370016545,
-0.0118837152,
-0.0614802577,
0.006478413,
0.0297905877,
-0.0368261039,
-0.0373088643,
-0.1345933676,
-0.0544210076,
-0.0788505152,
-0.0128736496,
-0.0024644779,
0.0070628664,
0.0070615425,
-0.0122126183,
-0.0391526297,
-0.0553280935,
0.0267460886,
0.0652362406,
0.0098637547,
-0.0166460872,
0.0282969438,
0.0187142901,
0.0025540814,
-0.0244537368,
-0.06729725,
0.0536088943,
-0.0316723362,
0.0372276232,
0.0161470082,
-0.0457391515,
-0.0059544938,
0.0061863568,
0.0010391342,
-0.0520714559,
0.0254482646,
0.0415473208,
0.039202217,
-0.0004782492,
-0.0323291346,
-0.0055305427,
0.017542595,
-0.0052841944,
-0.0217667539,
-0.0237599276,
0.0408381708,
0.04784986,
0.0007618689,
0.0141807189,
-0.0672196299,
-0.0528229475,
-0.0078217983,
0.0541670434,
-0.0182950776,
-0.0363630354,
0.0039688665,
0.0020291291,
0.0341214947,
0.0088791475,
-0.002567301,
0.0037382438,
0.0437092148,
-0.0080598025,
-0.0103432788,
-0.022241516,
0.0193327218,
0.0141311437,
0.0141638294,
0.052414991,
-0.0061524371,
0.0121249929,
-0.0547774211,
-0.0186985992,
0.0009735383,
0.0462734513,
-0.004436546,
0.0412281044,
-0.0134536177,
0.0018105278,
0.0162101742,
0.0615349449,
0.0256687067,
0.0006178671,
0.053267099,
0.037664894,
-0.006089115,
-0.0763904452,
0.0109227737,
-0.0655246377,
-0.0582159013,
0.0205961,
0.0331423432,
0.0835708305,
0.0209967699,
0.0269315969,
-0.056463331,
0.0191757437,
0.0158278104,
-0.030666139,
0.0237030685,
-0.0427436344,
0.0369871929,
0.0465556569,
0.0017768509,
0.0103241149,
0.0727500841,
0.0160428006,
0.0525233373,
-0.023777416,
-0.043946024,
-0.058156725,
-0.0344609767,
0.0016711648,
0.0299581569,
-0.0274707191,
-0.0440949276,
-0.055091437,
-0.0339772776,
-0.0107313702,
0.0422753915,
0.0061383131,
-0.0512737297,
0.0562850647,
0.0577588156,
0.0639254972,
-0.0121561084,
-0.053889595,
-0.0532287471,
0.0090717459,
-0.0086027225,
-0.0496152975,
-5.408714729e-33,
-0.0205111187,
-0.03966932,
0.0781376883,
0.0092518507,
-0.0330863521,
-0.0818590298,
-0.0477300771,
0.0244276207,
0.0108169196,
-0.0051234821,
-0.0287453569,
0.0234553292,
0.0393236056,
0.010756663,
0.0240379889,
-0.0163039882,
0.0305951387,
0.038977582,
-0.0373151526,
-0.0010100922,
0.0308756605,
0.0290706884,
-0.0182885434,
-0.0375845842,
0.00349073,
-0.0168106854,
-0.0165546592,
0.0280317385,
-0.0260726996,
0.0438077636,
-0.0294905379,
0.0392874964,
0.003143914,
-0.0502869114,
-0.0033549475,
0.0033819564,
-0.0115203764,
-0.035020031,
0.0180736762,
0.019383736,
-0.0040615867,
0.0150861843,
-0.0059346026,
0.0265779532,
-0.0158815235,
0.0689907968,
0.0132014332,
-0.0312142149,
-0.0401808806,
-0.0197050702,
-0.0727683827,
0.0025078708,
0.0138649354,
-0.0224402398,
0.0476251133,
0.0524093769,
-0.0260928441,
-0.0453016162,
-0.014447201,
0.0222979281,
0.0164633598,
-0.0120127285,
0.0447707959,
0.0645430982,
0.0106847081,
0.024070397,
0.0080417236,
0.017639989,
-0.0042806533,
0.0200116392,
-0.0105485721,
0.0491389446,
-0.0275725964,
0.0038679235,
-0.0451076813,
-0.0021492695,
-0.0227679536,
0.0367870182,
0.0543545634,
0.0424707681,
0.0172729958,
0.050572753,
-0.0403572507,
-0.0165839177,
-0.0223179068,
0.0268007442,
-0.0074270014,
-0.0335544385,
0.042469006,
0.0303946901,
0.0063008927,
-0.0435537472,
0.0245904289,
-0.0041393405,
-0.0295572616,
0.0145612741,
-0.013204514,
0.0151082976,
0.0099713551,
-0.0050822892,
-0.0366513953,
-0.0919769928,
-0.0424365252,
-0.0228712466,
-0.0084732836,
-0.0083748428,
-0.0621153601,
0.0287322085,
-0.0798415542,
0.0087715182,
-0.0529372133,
0.0083791753,
0.0246980898,
-0.0062759425,
0.0536942072,
-0.038238015,
-0.0114310263,
0.0651686639,
-0.0113973757,
-0.0405776314,
-0.0062969015,
-0.023201514,
-0.0239900798,
-0.0157710239,
-0.0134679088,
-0.0057409597,
-0.0459936447,
0.1061187163,
-0.0276726149,
-0.0627204776,
0.0168113373,
0.0482656471,
2.647e-7,
-0.0240836106,
0.056357488,
0.0062902528,
0.0391481705,
0.0241591875,
0.0405800492,
-0.0144147789,
-0.006243824,
0.0080104964,
-0.0177350324,
0.0226456542,
0.0275068618,
0.0105789201,
0.0226242431,
-0.0569631234,
-0.0189202428,
0.0058098463,
-0.0219528377,
-0.0566750281,
-0.0033905099,
0.0465168506,
0.0688540712,
0.0060526906,
-0.0114250099,
0.0293192547,
-0.0475992523,
0.0362026468,
-0.0226125401,
-0.0109155113,
-0.0116513912,
0.0122974804,
0.0699041039,
-0.0133153573,
0.0140039921,
0.0171273984,
0.0348780826,
-0.0446652845,
0.0676884726,
0.046556294,
-0.0174485836,
0.0019799885,
-0.033652015,
0.0265398491,
-0.0303526502,
0.0607095584,
-0.0078888405,
-0.0038110835,
0.02464737,
0.0320682749,
-0.0290407781,
-0.0355808064,
-0.0083212024,
0.0007773917,
-0.0119646545,
-0.0201751497,
0.0043197386,
0.0120697441,
-0.0765672401,
-0.0049969167,
0.0302224495,
-0.0473295934,
-0.0168658718,
-0.01407672,
0.0463395752,
0.0163043141,
-0.0566940196,
-0.0271244962,
2.586387185e-34,
0.0372384116,
-0.0264784563,
0.0082256952,
0.0473823845,
0.022790242,
0.0397094451,
-0.0260449927,
0.0141226863,
0.0647667348,
-0.0433163531,
-0.0401653722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08168v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08168v2 | Draft & Verify: Lossless Large Language Model Acceleration via Self-Speculative Decoding | 2023-09-15T05:34:32 | 2024-05-20T02:37:20 | Jun Zhang, Jue Wang, Huan Li, Lidan Shou, Ke Chen, Gang Chen, Sharad Mehrotra | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a novel inference scheme, self-speculative decoding, for
accelerating Large Language Models (LLMs) without the need for an auxiliary
model. This approach is characterized by a two-stage process: drafting and
verification. The drafting stage generates draft tokens at a slightly lower
quality but more quickly, which is achieved by selectively skipping certain
intermediate layers during drafting. Subsequently, the verification stage
employs the original LLM to validate those draft output tokens in one forward
pass. This process ensures the final output remains identical to that produced
by the unaltered LLM. Moreover, the proposed method requires no additional
neural network training and no extra memory footprint, making it a
plug-and-play and cost-effective solution for inference acceleration.
Benchmarks with LLaMA-2 and its variants demonstrated a speedup up to
1.99$\times$. | [
0.0087171495,
0.1076337174,
0.0147083281,
0.0592909008,
-0.0212959908,
0.0038251295,
0.000754596,
-0.0054370277,
-0.0248466991,
-0.003722585,
-0.0237227101,
-0.0806265324,
-0.0046021654,
0.0096708657,
0.0083574206,
0.0264531188,
0.0093171513,
-0.0529668666,
0.0134239569,
-0.0296634361,
-0.0202250965,
0.0292106178,
-0.0130990213,
0.0139784748,
0.0130171394,
-0.036002934,
-0.02150058,
0.0074131112,
-0.035648331,
-0.0470348261,
-0.0100688869,
0.0378451869,
-0.0049737548,
0.0437403321,
0.0000022233,
-0.0184475966,
0.0117573906,
0.0061654481,
-0.0624444224,
0.0825652331,
0.0584205724,
-0.0117404833,
-0.0615305118,
0.005441349,
-0.0114600081,
-0.0357223004,
0.0451957993,
0.0117168771,
0.0284532886,
0.0750143826,
0.0013290502,
-0.0583882295,
0.0131941568,
-0.0368142314,
-0.0435610563,
-0.0381849222,
0.016933877,
-0.0514079519,
-0.0467378795,
-0.0063720327,
0.0119553013,
0.0471919216,
0.050465785,
-0.0122772083,
-0.0218858495,
0.0302039664,
-0.0043092067,
-0.01886837,
0.0072267302,
0.0331010595,
-0.0248190816,
-0.0775678083,
-0.0211531743,
-0.0046391017,
-0.0287717395,
-0.0517444424,
-0.0197968632,
0.0491172001,
-0.0171752814,
0.0451195911,
0.0660114363,
0.0260896273,
0.0724326521,
0.0058946675,
-0.0427040532,
0.0911789685,
0.0318089873,
0.0022432795,
-0.0217671804,
0.0204879716,
0.008359625,
-0.0499707721,
0.0132149691,
0.0153933428,
-0.0045317537,
0.0021792348,
-0.0542673171,
-0.0519863963,
0.0033714897,
-0.0685875192,
0.0582341366,
0.0746495724,
-0.0124847116,
0.0152449375,
-0.0662986189,
-0.0240960196,
-0.0468491688,
0.01727001,
-0.0438762344,
0.0008256207,
0.0406489298,
-0.0016662255,
-0.0653122216,
0.0405836888,
-0.0374901183,
-0.0163484216,
-0.0381920487,
0.0110805817,
0.0055127302,
0.0104873087,
0.0278883316,
-0.0039854469,
-0.0321644582,
-0.0348389894,
0.0061639543,
-0.0029657213,
-0.0211391002,
0.006390023,
-0.0102320695,
-0.0788601562,
-0.0224728193,
0.0274395272,
-0.0050254394,
-0.0042706598,
0.0116451802,
0.0723287016,
-0.0253342781,
-0.033969108,
-0.0518171787,
-0.0041277283,
0.0357545353,
-0.0763485208,
0.0162697062,
-0.0713765994,
0.0373313911,
-0.0069847475,
-0.0117503358,
-0.0381108224,
0.0111735286,
0.0199625213,
0.001970408,
0.062185999,
-0.0365199409,
-0.0086738942,
0.0245416686,
0.0159350988,
0.0185218956,
0.1113255173,
0.0361968242,
0.05167564,
0.0095492052,
0.0115348035,
-0.0141138239,
0.0832189918,
0.0483100861,
0.0005618562,
-0.0522658415,
-0.0183386263,
-0.0077212607,
0.0297767688,
0.062447641,
0.0581590869,
-0.0507017374,
-0.0264160074,
0.0335337482,
0.0479346402,
0.0362350047,
0.0309724323,
0.040887177,
0.0023019079,
0.0510447957,
0.0141141703,
-0.034279529,
0.0178397801,
-0.0036149325,
0.0147169875,
0.0455805138,
0.0476199463,
-0.0336963013,
-0.0209265109,
-0.0092198113,
-0.0105625866,
-0.0019609637,
0.0026614694,
0.0511158891,
0.0228264332,
-0.0405262746,
0.0481788106,
0.0225101467,
-0.0345125347,
-0.0351191051,
-0.0583301224,
0.0389639884,
0.0502156988,
0.0374151208,
0.0297969114,
-0.0038216347,
0.0355663821,
-0.0088785365,
0.0523357652,
0.0120928334,
-0.0005793577,
0.0403767973,
-0.0475484058,
0.0171309542,
0.0338285193,
0.0193389859,
0.045764178,
0.0600212738,
0.0040287115,
0.0055321185,
-0.0272628628,
-0.0151917646,
0.0262314398,
0.011268192,
-0.0365002826,
0.0523360483,
-0.0016263846,
0.028154606,
0.0010977472,
-0.0114387022,
0.022854453,
0.0331178568,
-0.0716565922,
-0.0160572641,
0.0040923581,
-0.0864518657,
-0.0396635458,
0.0249987114,
0.0273540691,
-0.0119501902,
0.0134322103,
-0.0265428331,
-0.0276748836,
0.0245844349,
-0.0126183443,
0.054610502,
-0.0648237318,
0.0350765251,
0.0245209746,
0.0416780412,
0.0201558881,
0.0352907553,
-0.0179171376,
-0.0045618047,
0.0097209746,
0.0329170004,
-0.0103291115,
-0.0122142164,
-0.0362253375,
0.0149040045,
-0.0201024376,
0.0072861849,
-0.0522011966,
-0.0293661989,
0.0108807888,
-0.000569702,
-0.0676635355,
0.0007476193,
-0.0406081267,
0.0451862812,
0.0089837871,
0.0059575289,
-0.0138189988,
-0.0299449228,
-0.0003820914,
-0.0065743555,
-0.0277107712,
0.0076145884,
0.0035867435,
-0.0048579345,
-0.011676264,
-0.0033416606,
-0.0321523026,
0.0195585601,
0.0418226495,
-0.0204550046,
-0.0324332938,
-0.0753190368,
-0.0036908553,
0.0240376182,
0.0323622636,
0.0010254763,
-0.0515554138,
0.0128940139,
-0.0357356854,
0.0091797309,
0.0424490087,
-0.000057653,
-0.013648212,
0.0340149812,
0.0322638154,
-0.0328393877,
0.0030355209,
0.0213401094,
0.0196181498,
-0.0213676319,
-0.0263134576,
-0.0255124439,
0.0780308992,
-0.0082318429,
-0.0011312901,
-0.0361932255,
-0.0109122787,
-0.0069172443,
-0.0333787724,
0.0010536131,
-0.0327658579,
-0.0029788541,
0.0244651083,
-0.0048914729,
-0.0473331809,
0.0555134788,
-0.0970031023,
-0.0162920877,
0.0212010853,
-0.008394924,
-0.0191801041,
0.0555647239,
-0.001473035,
0.0147405881,
0.0051602153,
-0.0249195229,
0.0189815722,
0.0260084067,
0.0086046075,
-0.0286167134,
0.0398981757,
-0.0531436093,
0.0249734931,
-0.0389495343,
-0.0378243402,
-0.0377593264,
-0.0321107954,
-0.0393393412,
-0.0029285217,
0.0219092201,
-0.0340261497,
0.0283414871,
0.0173393432,
-0.0852650702,
0.0893584564,
-0.0269630607,
0.0251814444,
-0.004470685,
0.0320780948,
0.0186979678,
-0.0105841225,
0.0126628261,
-0.0367420055,
0.0390596651,
0.0663658008,
0.0327245966,
0.0244843569,
-0.0969246626,
-0.0089174937,
0.0458798185,
0.007448025,
0.0222079195,
0.026777735,
0.0545127355,
-0.0716520324,
-0.005324136,
0.1014033109,
-0.0021615727,
-0.0441237688,
-0.0075224387,
0.0126265232,
0.034316916,
-0.012871868,
0.0291660465,
-0.0847726241,
-0.0331902318,
0.0494606197,
0.0235237014,
-0.001353309,
-0.0157818161,
-0.0225134045,
-0.0959677622,
0.0624758415,
0.0111926934,
-0.0042745667,
0.0158541854,
-0.0338288657,
-0.0486363173,
0.0277239662,
0.0061692731,
0.0353951678,
0.0246236343,
-0.0219530072,
0.0210304447,
-0.0373758897,
-0.031128712,
0.0067067975,
-0.0206397921,
0.077281557,
0.0243019722,
-0.0118848318,
0.0239279103,
-0.0166919436,
0.0359196439,
-0.0536520854,
-0.0051493971,
-0.0187896453,
0.0205149371,
-0.0157172531,
-0.0196064096,
0.02373988,
0.0211952589,
-0.0129711144,
0.0098068574,
-0.0295147486,
0.0284383334,
-0.0126104429,
-0.0302530844,
-0.0118619995,
-0.014922455,
-0.0183924288,
0.0472598709,
0.0349694528,
-0.0161471236,
-0.0322379023,
-0.0478872731,
-0.0211667661,
-0.0949457884,
-0.0110504599,
-0.0004486266,
0.0549877137,
-0.0323927663,
-0.0316459499,
-0.0048347972,
-0.0160404146,
0.0520678721,
-0.02320976,
0.0265829228,
0.0008249987,
-0.037877176,
-0.0886179358,
-0.0115963183,
-0.0439799763,
0.013848939,
-0.0440483578,
0.0229415651,
0.0364934951,
0.001621931,
0.0121004218,
0.0265313443,
-0.1381724477,
-0.068679601,
-0.0018186303,
0.0310577266,
0.0182875376,
0.0363859721,
-0.0468555503,
-0.0598988347,
0.0493194722,
0.0306777712,
-0.0489344262,
0.0176188219,
0.0270755608,
-0.0273152739,
0.0124748088,
0.0466504581,
0.0137243504,
0.0268384069,
0.0044551874,
0.021072505,
0.0132191163,
-0.0262409169,
0.0083211288,
0.0117923319,
0.0240862556,
-0.0475342236,
0.0179297794,
-0.0062292144,
0.0621312298,
-0.0170051195,
0.0031151234,
-0.0193021055,
0.0317475162,
0.0214340072,
-0.0402445197,
-0.0118446527,
-0.007792308,
0.034994062,
0.0100682545,
0.0238780919,
-0.0123132216,
-0.0357529446,
0.0260954946,
0.0415077135,
-0.0213080477,
-0.0105218589,
0.0033191298,
0.0165879652,
0.0265586749,
-0.0546611734,
-0.0027050341,
0.0292836148,
0.0195661299,
-0.0472667776,
0.0155562842,
-0.0229857154,
-0.0459757075,
-0.0610384643,
0.0419847034,
0.0560304001,
0.0155267855,
0.0222939998,
-0.0311398245,
-0.0082840146,
-0.0139108952,
0.0052581965,
-0.0178800412,
-0.0359849222,
0.058618214,
0.0068714782,
-0.0079717124,
0.0077043567,
0.0395953432,
0.0311476868,
0.037188895,
0.028761955,
0.0258266088,
-0.0239674971,
-0.0656893104,
-0.0481022336,
0.0214619208,
-0.0382336155,
-0.0269930623,
0.0010137672,
-0.0646571741,
0.0271012168,
0.0281125754,
-0.0005696983,
-0.0112125324,
0.0096805803,
0.0411439613,
0.01185048,
-0.0203249641,
-0.0114382328,
0.0077474583,
0.0410698168,
-0.0107797347,
0.0106793419,
-6.821345963e-33,
-0.0114152525,
-0.0199623257,
0.0336735733,
-0.0676749423,
-0.020660229,
-0.0117129534,
-0.0272963177,
-0.0219076127,
0.0116754426,
0.0139625836,
-0.0383355469,
0.0440050401,
0.0399879478,
0.0445399582,
-0.0138560943,
0.0197924636,
0.0814975351,
-0.0460530408,
-0.0231691338,
-0.0112345396,
-0.0111510782,
0.0260819346,
0.0057624211,
0.0020108619,
-0.0193100218,
-0.033932589,
-0.0228798371,
-0.0019029047,
-0.0105302911,
0.0366150402,
-0.0536874346,
0.0130711189,
0.0171114951,
-0.0137651376,
0.001825823,
0.0004760696,
-0.1181362271,
-0.0085217403,
0.0146339396,
0.0280661695,
-0.0352932252,
-0.0299964305,
0.0189554766,
0.0446153916,
-0.0346564315,
0.0044326652,
-0.0412814096,
-0.0057839626,
-0.0191891417,
-0.0241336301,
-0.0231849775,
0.0395890698,
0.0343461037,
0.0178159717,
0.0805512071,
-0.0231086109,
-0.0233950373,
-0.0136704165,
-0.0936856195,
-0.0204096865,
-0.0406241044,
0.0625956357,
0.0677512214,
-0.0004051307,
-0.026868185,
0.0300175846,
0.0505109876,
-0.0390814543,
-0.0831604898,
0.0039566602,
0.050134372,
-0.0116078733,
0.0108973244,
0.020225171,
0.0823623613,
-0.027737489,
-0.0723703727,
0.001038348,
0.0270976946,
0.0194128118,
0.0458392091,
0.0143505558,
-0.0137165347,
-0.0381028466,
-0.0487593375,
-0.0371961966,
-0.0503650233,
-0.0154629648,
0.0207402147,
0.0406457707,
-0.0294716377,
-0.014849144,
0.0218360536,
-0.043938797,
-0.004552945,
0.0026558724,
-0.0120189972,
0.0318198726,
-0.010465431,
0.0435241498,
-0.0099511957,
-0.0038265833,
-0.0036249128,
0.0001314135,
0.0099897599,
-0.0001100669,
0.0021255109,
0.0319445841,
-0.0777550712,
-0.010123292,
-0.0360549465,
0.0331950225,
0.025307687,
0.0305038262,
0.0609212294,
0.001675121,
0.0139194662,
0.0455820039,
-0.0313232839,
0.0503302775,
-0.033010561,
0.0210734662,
0.0313809253,
0.0558018498,
-0.0129109006,
0.0194534231,
-0.0401273593,
0.0143382205,
0.0129794842,
-0.0827158913,
-0.020581292,
0.062156301,
2.7e-7,
0.023261888,
0.0265797488,
0.0823347867,
0.0157377925,
0.0207740273,
0.0106845461,
-0.0168256704,
0.005022333,
0.0110753207,
0.0108247828,
-0.0007113494,
0.0464232489,
0.0589669049,
0.0350094847,
-0.0975859091,
0.0002232046,
-0.0305199195,
0.0323134921,
-0.0239010341,
-0.05544319,
-0.0019195105,
0.1022304296,
-0.0215257835,
-0.0348476432,
0.0405740924,
-0.0029330375,
0.0373775065,
0.0346773714,
-0.0027024308,
0.0175713804,
0.0090028346,
0.0247569978,
-0.0314278863,
-0.0112563055,
-0.0113676349,
-0.0059553348,
-0.0355315097,
0.0692787096,
0.0042982576,
-0.0058827656,
0.0040797931,
-0.0267193839,
-0.0147436308,
-0.0083881132,
0.0510186069,
-0.0243690182,
-0.0265517402,
-0.0506780632,
0.0076492778,
0.0033747095,
-0.0331368931,
-0.0019484006,
0.0155637665,
0.0397320129,
0.0506535284,
-0.0225451346,
-0.0322208218,
-0.0861051679,
-0.0537708513,
-0.0352055691,
-0.0442615151,
-0.0139158666,
-0.0593802854,
0.0246431343,
0.0432182811,
-0.0814099461,
0.0290931184,
2.389208798e-34,
0.0483675562,
-0.0002772503,
-0.0020882913,
0.0827201232,
-0.0079901852,
-0.0188283883,
0.0441486388,
0.0372650065,
-0.0220323745,
-0.0551962815,
-0.031268999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08163v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08163v2 | Self-Assessment Tests are Unreliable Measures of LLM Personality | 2023-09-15T05:19:39 | 2024-01-02T23:00:41 | Akshat Gupta, Xiaoyang Song, Gopala Anumanchipalli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As large language models (LLM) evolve in their capabilities, various recent
studies have tried to quantify their behavior using psychological tools created
to study human behavior. One such example is the measurement of "personality"
of LLMs using self-assessment personality tests developed to measure human
personality. Yet almost none of these works verify the applicability of these
tests on LLMs. In this paper, we analyze the reliability of LLM personality
scores obtained from self-assessment personality tests using two simple
experiments. We first introduce the property of prompt sensitivity, where three
semantically equivalent prompts representing three intuitive ways of
administering self-assessment tests on LLMs are used to measure the personality
of the same LLM. We find that all three prompts lead to very different
personality scores, a difference that is statistically significant for all
traits in a large majority of scenarios. We then introduce the property of
option-order symmetry for personality measurement of LLMs. Since most of the
self-assessment tests exist in the form of multiple choice question (MCQ)
questions, we argue that the scores should also be robust to not just the
prompt template but also the order in which the options are presented. This
test unsurprisingly reveals that the self-assessment test scores are not robust
to the order of the options. These simple tests, done on ChatGPT and three
Llama2 models of different sizes, show that self-assessment personality tests
created for humans are unreliable measures of personality in LLMs. | [
0.0361028798,
0.0112928106,
-0.0516723134,
0.0207422655,
-0.0480993055,
0.0075716889,
0.0050566504,
-0.0119002638,
0.0185880996,
0.0037869369,
-0.065775983,
-0.0081718722,
-0.0045149671,
-0.0203030929,
0.0311428308,
-0.0173851103,
0.0580473207,
-0.0288823992,
0.0129095558,
-0.0286191348,
-0.0313433036,
0.0087630637,
-0.0017941446,
0.0008845998,
0.0517675839,
-0.0217010248,
-0.0025128904,
-0.0378721282,
0.0203288086,
-0.0385517888,
-0.0124579947,
0.0594785027,
-0.0075744097,
0.0099557964,
0.0000020602,
-0.0617842041,
-0.0030850733,
-0.0160771012,
-0.0156332143,
0.0224474613,
0.0568985827,
0.0815858021,
-0.0057816948,
0.0472722203,
-0.0455495641,
-0.0163916517,
0.004101275,
0.0235929731,
0.0332078598,
0.0441521741,
0.0146500403,
-0.0068432596,
0.0234137047,
-0.0090373093,
0.0232317057,
0.0148361633,
0.0007360422,
-0.038933374,
-0.0064771646,
0.0386324823,
0.0109927524,
-0.0216222648,
0.0073751598,
0.0348930918,
-0.0575934611,
-0.0151393451,
-0.0090398788,
-0.0203997139,
-0.0042950138,
0.0224086735,
0.0565124191,
-0.0182190221,
-0.0318671726,
-0.035705585,
0.0483243763,
0.0380473323,
-0.004131631,
0.0316318981,
0.0262173247,
-0.0596006997,
0.0508247912,
0.0356018357,
-0.0260271169,
-0.0204315688,
-0.0173467342,
0.1053579822,
0.0032337066,
-0.0174622983,
-0.0067241476,
-0.0049576727,
0.0177811347,
-0.0529758707,
-0.0380824842,
0.0200932659,
-0.0196724441,
0.018726971,
-0.0196458846,
0.0241617057,
0.0499301888,
-0.0594940521,
0.0180739276,
0.0431804247,
-0.0401976071,
-0.0067264992,
0.0340498835,
0.0787039697,
0.014445994,
0.0542854443,
-0.0443877913,
0.0268452354,
-0.0204267967,
-0.0161097627,
0.0375375561,
0.0070280568,
0.0418511778,
0.0144549441,
-0.0868922472,
0.0433216356,
-0.0268600713,
-0.0150605887,
-0.0033198122,
-0.0274078567,
0.036618527,
0.028959604,
-0.0703206956,
0.0009323799,
-0.0363986269,
-0.0180602744,
0.0003761599,
-0.0469207242,
0.0609846711,
-0.0042038579,
-0.0041388744,
-0.0289953537,
0.0392408408,
0.0774923563,
0.0149252992,
-0.0309084281,
-0.0134594422,
-0.0235528909,
-0.0227061603,
-0.063291207,
0.0060826549,
-0.0448566265,
-0.0032072249,
0.0451814085,
-0.0151573913,
-0.0178718735,
-0.0013794185,
0.0292894542,
-0.0050839777,
0.0233172197,
0.0381504931,
0.043003127,
0.0125244688,
-0.0002815055,
-0.0141602289,
0.0316704251,
0.010595399,
-0.0213164389,
0.0535286628,
-0.0773523599,
0.0182165187,
0.0424168259,
-0.0353109911,
0.0048041902,
0.0060163694,
0.0211218596,
0.0280557219,
-0.0167536233,
0.0253142547,
0.0536999106,
0.0033870328,
-0.0097940369,
0.077459909,
0.0547380745,
0.0154174734,
-0.0089205392,
-0.0025454729,
0.0190120656,
0.0405370966,
0.0532173701,
-0.0362229571,
0.0263482556,
-0.037112087,
0.0199437011,
-0.0235992428,
0.0147163738,
-0.0014126109,
-0.0549170524,
-0.0321056508,
0.0065127709,
0.0190910865,
0.04394532,
-0.0131937275,
-0.0436910354,
0.0009483938,
-0.0064310431,
0.0093186479,
-0.0606346317,
-0.0485460237,
-0.0872089565,
0.0303940643,
0.0754865929,
0.0001048519,
0.0041540377,
-0.0237095654,
0.0273344684,
-0.0446066372,
0.038083896,
0.07816118,
-0.0119873062,
-0.0402609073,
-0.0132996701,
0.0428884923,
0.0001508945,
-0.0077237184,
0.0020451315,
-0.0164361745,
0.0157617312,
-0.0324507169,
0.0273761954,
-0.0036924568,
-0.0047521465,
-0.0765900388,
-0.0453542657,
-0.0069141113,
0.0140436441,
0.0290265083,
0.0055669425,
0.0076815244,
0.0311846137,
0.019181421,
0.0153994299,
0.0053328937,
0.0207107402,
-0.0337808393,
0.0028241428,
0.0155649297,
0.0564421341,
-0.0040727691,
0.0253155287,
0.0270794965,
-0.0042050662,
-0.0101751601,
-0.0170643087,
0.0023359552,
-0.0150308684,
0.0588971637,
-0.0497567318,
0.0384528898,
-0.0324635282,
0.0460144691,
-0.0216845032,
0.0576444454,
0.0179455411,
0.0259808823,
0.0084991921,
-0.0592737198,
-0.0491626263,
0.0060135028,
-0.0070008752,
0.0312497951,
0.0193131119,
0.0068335501,
-0.053414572,
-0.046003446,
-0.0515085682,
0.0036331157,
0.0230616443,
0.0220103208,
0.0305852331,
-0.0159048494,
-0.0428095721,
0.0148389786,
-0.0342810452,
-0.0008053302,
0.049153734,
0.0695244521,
0.049387034,
-0.0309342351,
-0.0245878976,
-0.0571815707,
-0.0055986885,
-0.0534479469,
-0.0125288777,
-0.0379654728,
0.0713907555,
-0.0212454423,
0.0307467412,
-0.0393679366,
-0.0238263998,
-0.0069800159,
-0.0512975417,
0.0556657687,
-0.0089253364,
0.0111931246,
0.0668752193,
0.0459219813,
0.0318220966,
0.0336526707,
0.0195038281,
-0.0348852761,
-0.0177204497,
-0.0041661775,
-0.0129035385,
-0.0230931565,
-0.0867671371,
-0.0277708899,
0.0503344871,
0.0147383567,
0.0038084849,
-0.0231000576,
0.0507698953,
-0.0084604248,
-0.0315343589,
0.0303696617,
0.0298494529,
-0.0360331014,
0.0770779178,
0.0279574841,
-0.0312912203,
0.0476519242,
-0.0222977102,
0.008221996,
-0.0249375291,
-0.044804208,
-0.0311190318,
0.091484949,
0.0010171178,
-0.0287827775,
0.0648131967,
-0.0043088128,
-0.0854825974,
-0.0718756095,
0.0151879592,
-0.0356712937,
0.0282825325,
0.0002927986,
-0.0432035327,
0.0241628494,
-0.0300135165,
-0.0331572071,
-0.0441259965,
-0.0213817935,
0.0000980119,
0.0334932581,
-0.0242157727,
0.0115840519,
-0.0403970033,
0.0470537692,
-0.0333987288,
-0.0438260436,
-0.000340878,
-0.0006505736,
0.0210749395,
0.0445043817,
0.0463273041,
0.0532852709,
-0.0310487188,
0.0090893218,
0.0175494384,
-0.0256987233,
0.0362584256,
0.0146977995,
0.0080099897,
0.0265591238,
-0.0258969795,
-0.0318717025,
0.0508201867,
0.026856631,
0.0094413394,
0.0099876989,
0.105946511,
0.0258271806,
0.035125494,
0.0318523422,
-0.0129582975,
0.005876522,
0.0547791421,
0.0603060573,
0.0070569292,
0.0205346849,
-0.020201942,
-0.0042740526,
-0.0662233084,
-0.0106137255,
-0.0121779256,
-0.1073360443,
0.0209116731,
-0.027562784,
-0.0522110946,
0.040621087,
-0.0188382771,
0.0213062167,
-0.0030897076,
0.0164198913,
0.0127550643,
-0.0183286257,
0.0006047222,
-0.0041843019,
-0.0632559136,
-0.0059156544,
0.0939909518,
-0.0141525092,
0.0335514136,
0.0142759401,
0.0110777887,
-0.0417125523,
-0.0467080697,
-0.0292217918,
-0.0063529923,
0.0148521839,
0.025130216,
0.0094274459,
-0.003049799,
0.0277277511,
-0.0843313634,
-0.028912615,
-0.002148258,
0.0281354133,
0.0086654089,
0.0345205627,
0.013389688,
-0.0772236362,
-0.0242866222,
0.011243524,
-0.0072102067,
0.0454680026,
-0.002774213,
-0.0753006712,
0.0015949204,
-0.0201686844,
-0.0092438655,
0.004790802,
-0.0873081312,
0.0065395292,
0.0325948596,
-0.0365600102,
-0.0544450209,
-0.0837262347,
-0.0188594796,
0.0010842643,
-0.0288616307,
-0.0098208496,
0.0006583087,
0.0150615377,
-0.0155015942,
-0.0303593893,
0.0080310833,
0.0224726852,
-0.0609239973,
0.0100758839,
0.0709666014,
-0.032432355,
-0.0251666028,
0.0135504156,
-0.0478411429,
-0.0456560217,
0.0441071726,
0.0175695978,
0.0234880745,
-0.0397274606,
0.0302880201,
-0.0313525461,
-0.0047368277,
-0.0051306481,
-0.0166849997,
0.0918892696,
-0.0122549757,
0.0521685593,
-0.0076415571,
0.0158697963,
-0.0178073552,
0.0096667605,
-0.0128427735,
-0.0195715316,
-0.0166492108,
-0.1061843634,
0.0161645655,
0.0603585988,
0.0030405077,
0.0036083357,
-0.0129506141,
0.0138695035,
-0.0015400986,
-0.0374744907,
-0.0253858659,
0.0208679046,
-0.0874476954,
0.0118737826,
-0.0176981576,
-0.0106851244,
-0.0618380196,
-0.0151948258,
0.0286528375,
-0.0146382255,
0.0224437285,
0.0124244308,
0.0413719825,
-0.016548397,
0.0199057516,
-0.0345473029,
-0.0136502432,
0.0018595286,
0.0540008731,
0.0196469091,
0.0819507986,
-0.0533574708,
-0.0071733878,
0.0014101112,
0.0541433506,
-0.0674748868,
-0.0515954122,
0.0419511236,
0.0068288487,
-0.0261390414,
0.0063856626,
0.0281453505,
-0.0218982529,
0.0264413245,
-0.0551608838,
0.0053040436,
-0.0072775348,
-0.0293425303,
0.0205628704,
0.0008704653,
-0.004176877,
-0.0256150663,
0.0225560218,
0.0478875563,
-0.0157256071,
-0.0184749421,
-0.0046676034,
-0.0400088243,
0.0136697423,
-0.0244237483,
0.0069524832,
-0.0241459291,
-0.0336322188,
-0.0801497102,
-0.0863230973,
0.0422061272,
0.0454289652,
0.0241946485,
-0.0406349525,
-0.0079208696,
0.0606816038,
-0.0216991864,
-0.0397332236,
-0.0495704748,
0.0110160401,
-0.0495129749,
0.0046719941,
-0.0276208315,
-6.000196303e-33,
-0.0302217864,
-0.0040989504,
0.0278640073,
-0.0195043366,
0.0332185589,
-0.0741679743,
0.0043623755,
0.0681631118,
-0.0614193827,
-0.0453338213,
-0.043519292,
-0.0207204428,
0.0217449572,
-0.032794401,
0.0167887714,
-0.0021155537,
0.0168649126,
-0.0296866354,
-0.0195658039,
-0.0266942736,
0.0093134455,
-0.0331109539,
0.0729094073,
-0.0420048609,
0.0392693952,
-0.0602847114,
0.0197518505,
-0.0269016158,
-0.0375312567,
0.0650829002,
0.0109119611,
0.0326270573,
0.0417416506,
-0.0243424512,
0.0001571549,
0.0182359461,
0.0061267037,
-0.0845896155,
0.0216767527,
0.0216357578,
-0.00420414,
-0.0476619639,
-0.0086973952,
-0.0174995437,
-0.0913597569,
-0.0384680219,
0.0264231823,
0.0045908373,
0.0385277048,
0.0800649375,
-0.0045312885,
-0.0082303388,
-0.0013815697,
-0.0250824392,
-0.0552073829,
0.0164707582,
-0.0175253712,
-0.0124084847,
-0.0485016592,
0.0746605322,
-0.0296258982,
0.0118392846,
0.0455235802,
-0.0004968128,
-0.0036136538,
0.0256463215,
0.065188691,
0.0768484995,
0.0435172729,
-0.023112623,
0.0355791375,
0.0497693568,
0.0299359187,
0.0456526913,
-0.0064617353,
-0.0237905942,
-0.0057589589,
0.0225290451,
0.1136634797,
-0.0548241511,
0.0360814743,
0.0012743948,
-0.0658002868,
-0.0412454382,
-0.0142704742,
-0.0121893166,
-0.0332566164,
-0.0478320383,
0.0411498956,
-0.0533599891,
0.0162214078,
-0.054615628,
0.0510345362,
-0.0417769663,
-0.0585489757,
0.0081123197,
-0.084707953,
0.0740545318,
0.0001989656,
0.01399823,
-0.0188865475,
0.0185484327,
-0.0187645797,
0.0198411401,
0.0422891341,
0.0389671698,
-0.0272960421,
0.0043012411,
-0.0792480782,
-0.0194256455,
0.029580988,
-0.0158315618,
-0.0045492644,
-0.0043908455,
0.0107069267,
-0.004700847,
0.0068528522,
0.023754634,
-0.0256344695,
-0.0195278935,
-0.082182914,
0.0056420541,
0.0070759873,
-0.0029191924,
0.0301248003,
-0.0045117978,
-0.0589693114,
0.048849158,
0.0148505829,
-0.0090405857,
0.0195872094,
0.0161883701,
2.805e-7,
-0.0276664384,
0.0479649492,
-0.0382552557,
0.0778632984,
0.0272786114,
0.053047359,
-0.0195683986,
0.0071657021,
0.0465840399,
-0.0186248738,
-0.0143674193,
-0.0027520617,
0.0128628276,
0.0303604323,
-0.0158700161,
0.0182837993,
-0.0181992725,
0.0476632565,
-0.0014824889,
0.0282306857,
0.0676273853,
0.0301120337,
0.0113485912,
0.0061091939,
-0.045521874,
0.0259437691,
0.012406772,
-0.0049493117,
-0.018311955,
0.0301756412,
-0.0295681339,
-0.0013403142,
0.0231301021,
0.0556260645,
0.0212892722,
-0.00741845,
-0.0369534269,
0.0510470569,
0.0105497716,
-0.0137901101,
0.0213314053,
0.0091115376,
-0.0117107397,
-0.0446546413,
0.0512455776,
-0.0108779846,
-0.0503385179,
-0.0202109702,
-0.0014860438,
-0.0243835095,
0.0506188534,
-0.0026858887,
-0.0266599208,
0.0148819657,
0.0239598043,
-0.0258661676,
-0.0015046189,
-0.0198491234,
-0.0004332913,
-0.0054337941,
-0.0162696261,
-0.0927932113,
-0.0256840643,
0.0177103188,
0.0353019014,
-0.0554919466,
-0.0026213664,
2.336015842e-34,
-0.0208166875,
0.0777467638,
0.0106606064,
-0.0334937535,
0.0416782796,
0.0232853405,
0.0283594821,
0.0327494852,
0.0355113968,
-0.056954477,
-0.0258193575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05964v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05964v2 | Exploring Embeddings for Measuring Text Relatedness: Unveiling Sentiments and Relationships in Online Comments | 2023-09-15T04:57:23 | 2023-10-30T18:38:39 | Anthony Olakangil, Cindy Wang, Justin Nguyen, Qunbo Zhou, Kaavya Jethwa, Jason Li, Aryan Narendra, Nishk Patel, Arjun Rajaram | cs.CL | cs.CL | After the COVID-19 pandemic caused internet usage to grow by 70%, there has
been an increased number of people all across the world using social media.
Applications like Twitter, Meta Threads, YouTube, and Reddit have become
increasingly pervasive, leaving almost no digital space where public opinion is
not expressed. This paper investigates sentiment and semantic relationships
among comments across various social media platforms, as well as discusses the
importance of shared opinions across these different media platforms, using
word embeddings to analyze components in sentences and documents. It allows
researchers, politicians, and business representatives to trace a path of
shared sentiment among users across the world. This research paper presents
multiple approaches that measure the relatedness of text extracted from user
comments on these popular online platforms. By leveraging embeddings, which
capture semantic relationships between words and help analyze sentiments across
the web, we can uncover connections regarding public opinion as a whole. The
study utilizes pre-existing datasets from YouTube, Reddit, Twitter, and more.
We made use of popular natural language processing models like Bidirectional
Encoder Representations from Transformers (BERT) to analyze sentiments and
explore relationships between comment embeddings. Additionally, we aim to
utilize clustering and Kl-divergence to find semantic relationships within
these comment embeddings across various social media platforms. Our analysis
will enable a deeper understanding of the interconnectedness of online comments
and will investigate the notion of the internet functioning as a large
interconnected brain. | [
0.0403843224,
0.0530899763,
0.0031054439,
0.0196199249,
0.001036116,
0.0204099696,
-0.0389340445,
0.0180203039,
0.012306341,
-0.0521533862,
-0.0036604344,
-0.0188527964,
-0.0064616911,
-0.0167031083,
0.0246591549,
-0.0672759712,
0.0100365439,
0.0781590194,
0.017779747,
-0.012191074,
0.0588012934,
0.0174830947,
-0.0290868692,
0.0547588877,
-0.0254487172,
-0.0056266212,
0.0544146374,
-0.0184606034,
0.0545579791,
-0.0110773034,
-0.0048884847,
0.0349333026,
0.0241815504,
0.028495213,
0.0000017412,
-0.0149632953,
0.017636206,
-0.0187601577,
0.0471593924,
0.0205063075,
0.0474989116,
-0.0508838445,
0.0202362016,
0.0353740826,
-0.0232520867,
-0.0307894498,
0.0807705075,
0.0474296212,
0.052528359,
0.0597740971,
-0.0229714811,
-0.065713264,
-0.0033613262,
0.0020787213,
-0.0237929709,
0.0112644229,
0.0176223945,
-0.0204969309,
-0.0461759605,
-0.0046170689,
-0.0206603501,
-0.0055032363,
-0.0140515054,
-0.0166570805,
0.0287596565,
0.0318851843,
-0.0155833606,
-0.0104233194,
0.0449681357,
0.0688692033,
0.0367243066,
-0.0062944209,
0.0395941883,
0.0211595427,
-0.0184161197,
0.0674559996,
-0.0314938426,
0.0115182176,
0.0035969308,
0.0274244156,
-0.000173435,
0.0296722539,
0.0538883805,
-0.0021811849,
-0.0096567124,
0.0349319428,
0.0050094826,
-0.0554101169,
-0.0017891064,
0.0271712672,
-0.0195352547,
-0.0017195574,
0.0429866351,
-0.0363357738,
0.0292517077,
0.0369001552,
-0.0296275504,
-0.0446330197,
0.0112288631,
-0.0867026597,
-0.0027573679,
-0.0036735961,
0.0033843606,
0.0466467999,
-0.0055533107,
-0.0237176903,
-0.0216964241,
-0.0293083303,
-0.0057406132,
-0.0081951506,
-0.0549112149,
0.0152180605,
0.0194204953,
0.0052218344,
-0.0079456605,
-0.0249946769,
-0.0243133046,
0.0405654535,
-0.0417574085,
0.0085970014,
-0.0148618305,
0.0099329557,
0.0697889626,
0.0007900946,
-0.0194425359,
0.0424919277,
-0.0930482075,
0.0127331419,
-0.0428398736,
0.0212970432,
0.0227932334,
0.0173903462,
0.0455060042,
-0.0196776036,
-0.0386556201,
0.037168134,
0.0557062179,
-0.0163152907,
-0.0217464454,
-0.0271929055,
-0.0096641919,
0.0035760966,
0.0453512073,
-0.0705596507,
0.0194633435,
0.0169785172,
-0.0153712742,
0.0254420266,
0.001420205,
0.021569578,
-0.0645462871,
0.0359827839,
-0.0108398655,
-0.006244801,
0.0175719429,
0.0259404387,
0.048361361,
0.0338890292,
0.0034759007,
0.0219416302,
0.0682154149,
-0.0159703866,
-0.0166969541,
-0.0118260719,
0.015348712,
-0.0219134931,
-0.0215434674,
-0.0126192421,
-0.0470826253,
0.011107862,
-0.0200161636,
0.0376088656,
-0.0219942983,
-0.0169253554,
0.0461859442,
0.0853706077,
-0.0399640389,
0.0143062053,
-0.0115823876,
0.0336178616,
-0.010399119,
-0.011760639,
0.0075576506,
0.0331095792,
0.0047597624,
-0.0266741253,
0.0763214752,
0.035367731,
-0.0270299837,
-0.0169683546,
0.003176657,
-0.008226797,
0.0542279929,
-0.0525940657,
0.0350690372,
-0.0210572518,
-0.0352328382,
0.033045169,
0.039761655,
-0.0553830825,
-0.0005692999,
-0.0065884944,
0.0272833314,
0.0360730141,
-0.0047618938,
-0.0165888797,
-0.0205011461,
-0.0375245288,
0.0341466554,
0.0400492437,
0.0124783292,
-0.0063050687,
-0.0215167049,
-0.0359932855,
-0.0067819222,
0.0194724072,
0.0386477597,
-0.0067611779,
-0.0109469444,
0.0258710179,
-0.0042681149,
-0.0282037519,
0.0680835918,
0.0173053015,
0.0298923925,
0.030000614,
-0.0035715224,
0.0528054461,
0.0310502872,
0.0655466914,
-0.0336307175,
0.0074005048,
0.0480483696,
-0.0420031026,
-0.070081912,
0.0019127134,
0.0123756146,
-0.0132414084,
0.014380279,
-0.1094428748,
-0.0291033313,
0.0562074743,
-0.0310646258,
-0.001105983,
0.0866740569,
-0.0418906808,
0.0986401513,
-0.0220568851,
-0.0477809645,
-0.0402674302,
0.0181955155,
0.0038844293,
0.0476953164,
-0.0482379422,
0.023760492,
-0.0458794907,
-0.0393172614,
0.022262929,
0.0493964218,
-0.0744971856,
-0.0186895411,
0.0118655888,
0.0190884229,
0.0639530569,
-0.0429304577,
-0.0356724113,
-0.0218463745,
-0.1172018871,
-0.0315654352,
-0.0330360606,
0.0367910825,
0.0217567906,
-0.011494033,
0.0182736199,
0.0125245461,
-0.015340562,
-0.0245810188,
-0.0272201225,
0.0230303686,
0.0377486125,
-0.0407793857,
0.0013688945,
-0.027851684,
-0.0400228426,
-0.0180353206,
0.0366913751,
0.0160491001,
-0.0235248804,
0.0100671677,
-0.0029852062,
-0.073664695,
-0.0419329666,
-0.0097633516,
-0.0390738957,
0.0203932505,
0.0298580043,
0.0245591141,
0.010400963,
0.0395589359,
0.0564090461,
0.008884754,
0.0194027536,
-0.0255591925,
-0.0145433955,
-0.0559135713,
0.0398877412,
-0.0316159204,
-0.0097905016,
0.0086885868,
0.0452697128,
0.0324977003,
-0.0220134631,
-0.0494504236,
0.0101146875,
-0.0227884017,
0.0040335176,
-0.0171732362,
0.0100237066,
0.0131172109,
0.0076822867,
0.0018209313,
-0.0292275045,
0.0321909152,
0.0228218026,
0.0483015999,
-0.0254669469,
-0.0295598954,
-0.0081720166,
0.0416628271,
0.0128897261,
0.019274734,
-0.0399780162,
0.0053832796,
0.020197887,
0.0078912815,
-0.001385611,
-0.0253726374,
0.033302404,
0.0140096517,
0.0016059162,
0.0216972176,
-0.0268691052,
0.0041293497,
-0.0469425991,
-0.0490576848,
-0.0369641297,
0.0492244326,
-0.0569799952,
-0.0065602832,
-0.0181928426,
0.0230382811,
-0.063400045,
0.037808612,
-0.0200365577,
0.0176482424,
0.042446129,
0.0305787325,
-0.0323866084,
0.0247478765,
0.0019523667,
-0.0149568636,
0.0365500934,
0.0047768462,
-0.0045446116,
-0.0489878803,
-0.054633528,
-0.0258229319,
-0.0249832124,
-0.012339538,
-0.0362808444,
0.0238352083,
-0.0099140955,
0.0329156853,
0.0956876576,
0.0269910414,
-0.013184228,
0.002122741,
0.0018289422,
-0.0156232379,
0.0244440492,
0.0011656021,
-0.0642767176,
-0.022171339,
-0.0267625935,
-0.0097572161,
0.0137997949,
-0.0425667539,
0.0072350861,
-0.0831219107,
-0.0005033641,
-0.0248267706,
-0.0081845578,
-0.0554918721,
-0.0936116055,
-0.0001186804,
-0.0069308691,
-0.0137494029,
-0.0577318221,
0.0128595252,
0.0129817426,
-0.0133094043,
-0.0850298181,
-0.0157364104,
0.0279348847,
-0.0568158627,
0.050249178,
0.0370813869,
0.0919997022,
-0.0076167905,
-0.0381702334,
0.0046193236,
-0.0026509201,
-0.042878639,
-0.0234615505,
0.072051771,
-0.032121107,
0.0030523485,
-0.0442836285,
0.0007164241,
-0.0459091403,
-0.0111834696,
-0.0254541803,
0.094406724,
-0.0119385896,
-0.0548483878,
-0.0575532354,
0.033980269,
-0.0072241714,
0.0528235175,
0.0173650179,
-0.0408005193,
0.0012625759,
-0.0026975763,
0.0540761277,
-0.0201959107,
-0.0118189715,
-0.0554934442,
-0.0109353093,
-0.0238530003,
-0.0651746541,
-0.0305192843,
0.0075866468,
-0.012819685,
-0.0193786528,
-0.0209385585,
0.0892767981,
-0.0480972305,
-0.0528244376,
0.03090946,
0.0105500659,
0.0154889952,
-0.0003427552,
-0.0358745828,
0.0377803221,
0.0304544494,
-0.0564505272,
-0.0530306585,
-0.0542099252,
-0.0297159795,
-0.0294792634,
0.0099596577,
0.0079010781,
0.0127556296,
-0.031402465,
-0.0458266772,
0.034663219,
0.0544006191,
-0.0337547697,
0.0066459258,
0.0099602519,
0.0336106047,
0.0172916763,
0.050294295,
-0.0172891356,
-0.0023571264,
-0.020975152,
-0.016323464,
-0.0688904673,
-0.0176209174,
-0.036264006,
-0.0233509,
0.0770330802,
0.0571887158,
-0.0240256432,
-0.0648887902,
-0.0422921963,
-0.0038996416,
0.0013531874,
-0.0176778473,
-0.0184144024,
0.015629746,
0.0016075418,
-0.0579322763,
0.0172753055,
0.0021019091,
0.0023243974,
-0.0109373182,
0.0324050114,
0.0121722361,
0.0287828259,
-0.0072373762,
0.0273237843,
-0.013558819,
0.0123093938,
0.0011922754,
-0.0206169374,
-0.0257917736,
0.0145048536,
-0.0225946065,
0.0154578574,
0.0168735869,
0.0324941613,
-0.0420626253,
-0.0259037446,
0.0009332986,
0.0097862249,
0.0227656979,
-0.0479268804,
0.0404329076,
-0.002194168,
0.0047043487,
0.0082890084,
0.0443581305,
-0.0553601757,
-0.0263402052,
0.0154010626,
0.0004049977,
-0.0481263064,
0.0128206173,
0.0670456365,
-0.0808900371,
0.0413203202,
0.0383570828,
-0.0507189184,
-0.0226164199,
-0.0062297038,
0.0532752872,
0.0488227904,
-0.0056227176,
0.0386666879,
-0.0420241952,
-0.0568696558,
0.0373501554,
-0.0215433184,
-0.0091985669,
0.0305555388,
0.0308111534,
0.0361382477,
0.0036094885,
0.0433379896,
-0.0379657485,
0.0064535788,
-0.0685205385,
-0.0605999678,
-0.0094675776,
-6.292007633e-33,
0.0270085521,
-0.0244598649,
-0.0415601954,
0.0059413477,
-0.0359004289,
0.015335572,
-0.0072611705,
0.0371085741,
-0.0103820274,
0.0544348247,
0.0113351727,
0.0360180363,
-0.0133265471,
0.034545593,
0.0086331889,
-0.0351167917,
0.0157542117,
0.0002829244,
0.0137061682,
0.0223898645,
0.051444944,
0.018785337,
0.0511235371,
-0.0982115045,
0.0218095109,
0.0037251597,
0.0170361698,
0.0123160109,
0.059249416,
0.0343062766,
-0.0407833904,
0.0433688201,
0.0437894315,
-0.0192276724,
0.0020685084,
0.1021085531,
-0.0428438485,
-0.0588636883,
-0.0021882628,
-0.0303058289,
-0.0539088063,
-0.0193479545,
0.0559620783,
0.0251792073,
-0.0091643594,
0.0188226383,
0.047903657,
0.0407014936,
0.0109014222,
-0.0026156765,
-0.0489632189,
0.0200662389,
-0.0725569502,
0.015712576,
0.0057227309,
0.0068424167,
0.0453987382,
0.0524879135,
-0.0747975111,
0.0361981727,
-0.0949345231,
-0.0016663773,
0.0158464462,
-0.0361217745,
0.0160412639,
0.0986353606,
0.0118413307,
-0.0135873463,
-0.0548114926,
0.009034005,
0.0047829435,
0.0297414009,
0.0180203989,
0.0564338826,
0.0406214222,
-0.0748087615,
-0.0655603036,
0.015464915,
0.0566879399,
0.0009065387,
0.0623755604,
-0.0006346994,
0.0004113075,
0.0029850309,
-0.0161014255,
-0.0595366098,
-0.0277126562,
-0.0225068107,
-0.0401044749,
-0.0133475279,
-0.0129148206,
-0.0056879804,
0.0072248597,
-0.0475689247,
-0.0155253643,
0.0561806448,
-0.0091416724,
0.0084847566,
0.0399909541,
0.0133709442,
-0.0432450809,
0.0331033505,
-0.0345524177,
-0.0063658152,
0.016067883,
-0.0061507295,
0.0285343993,
-0.0234114975,
-0.0485764295,
-0.0012015647,
-0.0177188963,
-0.0337897763,
-0.0465087928,
0.0218207352,
0.027967006,
0.0623015463,
-0.0079416959,
0.0173986573,
0.0403392017,
0.0625958219,
0.0193681531,
-0.0147780087,
-0.0239799209,
-0.0204588622,
-0.003247872,
-0.0518205799,
-0.0400934108,
0.0396093391,
0.0005910324,
-0.0878016874,
-0.0211471058,
-0.0291618016,
2.625e-7,
0.0745746195,
0.0750526562,
0.0218606405,
-0.0073243733,
0.014752009,
0.0505736247,
0.0359582305,
0.0495709032,
-0.0277216043,
-0.0350624062,
-0.0113317231,
0.0282988604,
0.0057173027,
0.0087972125,
-0.0693239942,
-0.0083049852,
-0.080698587,
-0.0021964868,
-0.0113582984,
0.0027874808,
0.0520126037,
0.0896223262,
0.0581943206,
0.0080474159,
-0.0299975798,
0.0030668178,
0.0492044687,
-0.0550856404,
-0.009935922,
-0.0185525361,
-0.0073210024,
-0.0179761425,
0.0032331375,
0.0069512851,
-0.0131658698,
0.0151298065,
0.0356049575,
0.0106345527,
0.0202100538,
-0.0212000534,
0.0134955896,
-0.0064362991,
0.0092252158,
0.0021782583,
0.0366913453,
-0.0409957692,
-0.0549869761,
-0.0542330667,
-0.0157675277,
0.0183445197,
0.0941984951,
-0.0050497195,
-0.0482807979,
0.0023600948,
0.0139529863,
-0.0010126772,
0.0041179666,
-0.0924303159,
0.0327057727,
0.0105276043,
-0.0653085336,
-0.0149737513,
0.0168945249,
0.0295532607,
0.0885635465,
0.0243187565,
0.0286376625,
1.97894474e-34,
0.0211096834,
-0.0160442386,
-0.0200133752,
-0.0300306529,
0.0358731374,
-0.0074091586,
-0.0366636887,
-0.0302372165,
0.0209707767,
-0.0665389448,
0.0211417768
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08156v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08156v2 | RADE: Reference-Assisted Dialogue Evaluation for Open-Domain Dialogue | 2023-09-15T04:47:19 | 2023-09-18T00:43:47 | Zhengliang Shi, Weiwei Sun, Shuo Zhang, Zhen Zhang, Pengjie Ren, Zhaochun Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluating open-domain dialogue systems is challenging for reasons such as
the one-to-many problem, i.e., many appropriate responses other than just the
golden response. As of now, automatic evaluation methods need better
consistency with humans, while reliable human evaluation can be time- and
cost-intensive. To this end, we propose the Reference-Assisted Dialogue
Evaluation (RADE) approach under the multi-task learning framework, which
leverages the pre-created utterance as reference other than the gold response
to relief the one-to-many problem. Specifically, RADE explicitly compares
reference and the candidate response to predict their overall scores. Moreover,
an auxiliary response generation task enhances prediction via a shared encoder.
To support RADE, we extend three datasets with additional rated responses other
than just a golden response by human annotation. Experiments on our three
datasets and two existing benchmarks demonstrate the effectiveness of our
method, where Pearson, Spearman, and Kendall correlations with human evaluation
outperform state-of-the-art baselines. | [
0.0555267036,
0.0458339192,
0.0125762904,
0.0155012729,
-0.0029505019,
0.0051586102,
-0.0034473059,
-0.0038011703,
-0.0225447621,
-0.0551340319,
-0.0774441361,
-0.0288245324,
-0.0023091563,
0.023746511,
-0.0042049694,
-0.041509375,
0.0339281373,
-0.0186444148,
0.0502375476,
-0.0136686116,
-0.0096944273,
-0.0079097953,
-0.0400250591,
0.0800057873,
-0.0090527721,
-0.005294384,
-0.0132424664,
0.0088673551,
0.0242290348,
-0.0134976516,
0.0142064672,
0.0736150146,
0.0040386505,
0.015216535,
0.0000016708,
-0.0332477391,
0.0116776787,
-0.0124555221,
-0.0210484378,
-0.014061545,
0.0350454487,
0.0449064076,
0.0247191545,
0.0238502603,
-0.0467903242,
-0.0347405411,
0.0571387559,
0.0485247597,
0.1075585634,
0.0506417863,
0.0046326397,
-0.0228261873,
-0.0005963162,
-0.0240806602,
-0.0150453961,
-0.0721202195,
-0.0123623554,
0.0212583169,
0.0081169391,
0.003890428,
0.005652823,
0.0082712593,
0.0256011058,
-0.0480177552,
0.0307445545,
0.0042122421,
-0.0455090292,
-0.0136139514,
-0.0196120329,
0.1278606951,
0.028543191,
0.0586226434,
-0.0189300869,
0.0123000471,
0.001999849,
-0.0098270876,
-0.0209618919,
-0.0286754202,
0.0188639928,
0.0030619046,
-0.0560287684,
0.0533168055,
-0.0345638953,
-0.0054884148,
0.034582831,
0.0437530577,
0.0044655162,
-0.02114884,
0.0320752636,
0.0381400511,
-0.0072986544,
-0.0322797075,
-0.0226347838,
0.0150119709,
-0.0790986568,
0.0005174323,
-0.0329697169,
-0.0265867617,
0.020936057,
-0.0229812283,
0.0816580132,
0.0169501957,
-0.0401900336,
0.0406729691,
0.0021594034,
0.0708383992,
0.00004936,
-0.0058243331,
-0.0265603997,
-0.0253598932,
-0.0534704141,
0.0172486007,
-0.0241540149,
0.0336662084,
-0.0592274331,
-0.0330825262,
-0.0470684953,
0.0025372948,
-0.0373785198,
0.0007269773,
0.0340255238,
0.0419426821,
-0.0241980515,
0.0366129465,
-0.0645881966,
0.0594672225,
-0.0491355918,
0.0200676899,
0.0113943079,
-0.036455635,
-0.0220507123,
0.0350789614,
0.0080794077,
-0.0192639418,
-0.0271277782,
0.0572878681,
-0.0289729685,
-0.0165093113,
0.0530968793,
-0.0340589732,
-0.0653444156,
-0.0811154768,
0.0223273337,
-0.0262213163,
0.050870128,
0.0067356275,
-0.0236926097,
-0.019166993,
0.0241256095,
0.0197275393,
-0.0033281792,
0.0382353775,
0.017876735,
-0.0088904072,
0.0011650581,
-0.0028537703,
-0.0087024774,
0.0603613257,
0.0297195781,
-0.0068416828,
0.0158404652,
0.0017411286,
0.0209208913,
0.011101068,
0.0145610785,
-0.0022938994,
0.0491203703,
0.0520577617,
0.027245868,
0.0287885126,
0.0272757765,
0.0365545116,
-0.0420579351,
-0.0360011049,
0.0312138926,
0.0253861826,
-0.0337469615,
-0.0065361038,
0.0528234541,
0.0385050476,
0.0227708817,
0.0163111351,
-0.0178542789,
0.0571759343,
0.0069735972,
-0.0091722049,
0.0913939849,
-0.02753013,
-0.0230946746,
-0.0576007031,
0.0134236775,
-0.0009456447,
-0.0135020548,
-0.0086387526,
0.0241663568,
0.0172904767,
-0.0724928603,
0.0256092362,
0.0120027391,
-0.0718925223,
-0.0051156548,
-0.0382418409,
0.0143494364,
0.0278511122,
0.0350285694,
0.0041678585,
-0.0273469333,
-0.0492579788,
0.0079766223,
0.061363399,
0.0425234437,
-0.0254860055,
0.0530245826,
-0.0541275814,
-0.0398715027,
-0.0329628028,
-0.0173052661,
0.0355897471,
-0.0057107648,
-0.0371373892,
0.0090577668,
-0.0061879549,
0.0238389093,
-0.0191327669,
0.0326847285,
-0.008349468,
0.0373027325,
-0.0055348314,
0.0324684978,
0.0407640003,
-0.02826689,
0.0021070337,
0.0274323914,
-0.0113010043,
-0.0239821821,
-0.0030987805,
-0.0627053678,
-0.0324204192,
0.0031676362,
-0.0381708033,
-0.0335827954,
0.0520959906,
-0.0221519247,
-0.0641347915,
0.0284385327,
-0.0404351465,
0.0181104466,
-0.0491794795,
-0.0168641936,
0.0300227441,
0.0200110991,
-0.0166531578,
0.0501623489,
0.0068911165,
0.0276629664,
0.0432059392,
-0.014009105,
0.0476785265,
-0.0697372407,
-0.0230305064,
-0.0162798092,
-0.0224095527,
0.0273451935,
0.004336148,
0.0069066817,
-0.0518665314,
-0.0291753653,
-0.0948986113,
0.0030407265,
-0.0229337849,
0.0103736883,
-0.0030291236,
-0.0160555597,
0.0181662068,
-0.0446286388,
-0.0417872258,
-0.0011135604,
0.0541410074,
0.0073709358,
0.0283294097,
0.0051597431,
0.0191100612,
-0.032692451,
0.017305376,
0.0203105211,
0.0525011607,
0.0154318092,
0.0413284376,
-0.0187059473,
0.00588312,
-0.0395330787,
0.0067320284,
0.0241342802,
-0.0360024981,
0.0457998961,
0.0245756377,
0.0401952974,
0.0301563833,
0.012410867,
0.0253770128,
0.0108496593,
-0.0317753814,
-0.0652760789,
0.0375095494,
-0.0170158539,
-0.0376419649,
-0.0263682175,
0.0370442569,
-0.0156050632,
0.0085937418,
0.0264849532,
0.025190264,
-0.0567362271,
0.0195718687,
0.0001901951,
-0.060656257,
-0.0474784151,
-0.0058670146,
-0.0340056047,
0.0071510761,
-0.0215057302,
-0.0091478806,
0.0820190087,
-0.0215178411,
-0.0515388697,
-0.0653506741,
0.0266205296,
-0.0215475317,
0.0358743034,
-0.0470235236,
-0.0047915764,
0.0253480654,
-0.0260441303,
-0.0296422113,
0.0096712885,
0.0175521392,
-0.0459612086,
0.0466595367,
-0.0252981093,
-0.0071695978,
-0.0114713088,
-0.0583323315,
-0.0614666343,
-0.0225299001,
-0.0149353826,
0.0304842964,
-0.0194435306,
-0.0220987592,
-0.0427893661,
-0.0026441128,
0.001710142,
-0.0169610139,
-0.0064163134,
0.0102438089,
-0.017527299,
0.0678866357,
0.0464372449,
0.065655686,
-0.0268244576,
-0.0156959556,
0.0190876275,
0.0223585777,
0.0331094302,
0.0121588241,
-0.0137635153,
-0.0077386615,
0.0312139299,
0.0025222274,
0.0114767598,
0.0099616572,
0.0414281674,
-0.016232593,
-0.0168951694,
0.1066175103,
0.0171918701,
-0.0341250636,
-0.0223057494,
-0.0345281251,
0.022022346,
0.0266561974,
0.0159335844,
-0.0724564195,
-0.0623019636,
-0.0192872304,
0.0288380235,
0.0124630313,
-0.0497156605,
-0.0021496764,
-0.1356639266,
0.0200609472,
-0.0266737454,
-0.0459196232,
-0.0040481868,
-0.016179556,
0.0260808766,
-0.0327316038,
0.0018599898,
-0.0114949746,
0.0359216966,
0.0111074792,
0.0147995725,
0.0171694793,
-0.0247254595,
0.0329287499,
-0.0306116734,
0.0714654401,
0.0881929472,
0.066458039,
0.054327067,
-0.0123725943,
-0.0255610589,
-0.0356537476,
0.0046268594,
0.0123285139,
0.0596865118,
-0.001533778,
-0.0188488849,
-0.0196662955,
0.0059787328,
-0.0347477384,
-0.002174004,
0.0285805017,
0.0384604968,
-0.0298511498,
0.0296329409,
-0.0059435884,
0.0517053269,
0.0574877076,
0.067906715,
0.017063722,
-0.0551568307,
-0.0301245674,
-0.0247153565,
-0.0117076924,
-0.0737899542,
-0.0148281874,
-0.0115531916,
0.0054397089,
0.0243246462,
-0.0959597379,
-0.049951423,
0.0031935417,
0.0093152262,
-0.0279191285,
-0.0356515907,
-0.0366481207,
0.0335823521,
-0.0004701106,
0.0134780798,
-0.0193254557,
0.0059429989,
-0.0480082519,
-0.0084892614,
0.056241557,
-0.0061557493,
-0.0235456638,
0.0717971846,
-0.0298805535,
-0.0170326512,
-0.0293907262,
0.0681748465,
0.0157643184,
0.0114480061,
-0.010004987,
-0.0095744887,
-0.0037272933,
-0.0061817747,
-0.0484306253,
-0.0031627573,
0.071976006,
0.0149019836,
-0.0291767232,
0.0326071493,
-0.0291442443,
0.0303042028,
0.0003325476,
0.0317698121,
0.0015904235,
-0.1072299555,
-0.0055246009,
-0.0099696498,
0.0760230944,
0.0226791091,
-0.0078166425,
0.0123241488,
0.031815879,
-0.0193816796,
-0.0183357093,
-0.0758539885,
0.0013317592,
-0.0193310473,
-0.0121876756,
-0.0063190381,
0.0290117487,
-0.0274051148,
0.0696722567,
-0.0266288593,
0.0048824414,
0.0697343126,
0.0166533273,
-0.0149030285,
-0.0134083647,
-0.0237375405,
0.0078741908,
0.0395170823,
0.0204154328,
0.020360807,
0.0749007538,
0.0034197955,
-0.028740786,
0.0786026344,
0.0366390385,
-0.0679278523,
0.0042391936,
-0.0398655199,
-0.005770368,
0.022070121,
0.0572337843,
0.0614387654,
-0.0049594427,
0.020056,
-0.012422245,
0.0633067563,
-0.0175111629,
-0.028337216,
0.0281566121,
0.0165973119,
-0.0071795979,
0.0323251933,
0.0540778711,
-0.0177333076,
-0.0031787562,
-0.0309954565,
0.0120149245,
-0.0632008687,
-0.0607245751,
-0.032582406,
0.0110734068,
0.013539779,
0.0146567859,
-0.0309178922,
-0.0300829802,
0.004884799,
0.0138355792,
-0.0108846892,
0.0058754236,
0.0557015315,
0.0157165173,
-0.0182740502,
-0.0028880129,
-0.039948523,
-0.0324676409,
-0.0373718441,
-0.0164388511,
-0.0457271002,
-5.431871233e-33,
-0.0441613495,
-0.0435130969,
-0.0030877141,
-0.0290883053,
-0.0242266208,
-0.0216246359,
-0.0381448381,
0.0210222006,
-0.0085918223,
0.0000561229,
0.0150302341,
-0.0067995363,
0.0157213677,
0.0373842306,
-0.0065493286,
-0.052838441,
0.0369023271,
-0.0116370562,
-0.0304820575,
0.044874765,
0.0300762001,
-0.0003947314,
0.0332386456,
-0.0902384892,
0.0429219157,
0.0109410957,
-0.0190571286,
0.0171029121,
0.0220239554,
0.0708732679,
-0.0242507998,
0.075389117,
0.0100953542,
-0.0576255098,
-0.0047694915,
0.0231569856,
-0.0749625564,
-0.0256112162,
0.0033669379,
-0.0150793465,
-0.0329390317,
0.0015908391,
-0.0109858634,
0.0011684514,
-0.0142362434,
-0.0132221952,
0.0248498637,
-0.0137195326,
-0.0010096905,
0.0065968726,
-0.0485804304,
-0.004623889,
-0.0193291586,
-0.0647924468,
-0.0299147852,
0.1101510972,
0.0077758092,
-0.0596483685,
-0.0301506184,
0.0304870456,
-0.0444389246,
-0.0238135848,
0.0314478837,
0.0062455265,
-0.021329686,
0.0591321588,
-0.0050472636,
-0.0132972617,
0.0060529802,
-0.0787314549,
-0.0376285948,
0.0526711605,
0.0645144656,
0.0810017586,
-0.0199156329,
0.0419474244,
-0.0430117548,
0.0455486178,
0.0104730316,
0.0196939949,
0.0107377982,
-0.0039204913,
0.0099529056,
0.0134667484,
-0.0448388383,
0.026358325,
-0.0419571623,
-0.0477809943,
0.055899851,
0.0017820937,
-0.0152903665,
0.0076847747,
0.0590503104,
-0.0374608301,
0.0254887901,
0.0569937378,
-0.0082895821,
0.0200294685,
-0.004458081,
-0.0332376398,
-0.0289919674,
0.0082834782,
0.0765124112,
0.0302198157,
0.0156479813,
-0.0056148292,
0.0042882757,
-0.0176802855,
-0.0517935492,
0.0049592955,
-0.0191501919,
0.0518574268,
-0.0421758331,
0.0318621881,
0.0072366023,
-0.0081396345,
-0.0279537085,
0.0870798156,
-0.0311093554,
0.0193376355,
-0.0189662222,
-0.04969972,
0.0606249683,
-0.0200131461,
-0.0323754139,
0.0185184479,
0.0177816674,
-0.0485127792,
-0.0241648145,
-0.0075599961,
-0.0076420642,
0.0114322426,
2.321e-7,
0.0148411803,
-0.0041364073,
0.0292930454,
0.0019964597,
0.0074167447,
0.0506437719,
0.004688648,
0.0403658748,
0.0315541625,
0.0086466856,
0.0085536493,
-0.010910783,
0.0796831176,
0.0098191267,
-0.1119914278,
-0.0698790327,
-0.0492320955,
-0.0149166565,
-0.0020023875,
-0.0041823667,
0.0676978528,
0.0438871123,
0.0073578316,
0.0187256876,
-0.0413412936,
0.0005651075,
0.0594787709,
-0.0153629696,
-0.0213136338,
-0.0220576618,
0.0329195186,
-0.0383280925,
-0.0146194482,
0.0404547825,
-0.0180822108,
0.0237875562,
0.0589376315,
0.0603516102,
0.0183159448,
-0.1176105812,
-0.0183270611,
0.0084477887,
0.0297716707,
0.0056134029,
0.0477369614,
-0.0582358725,
-0.0366163962,
0.0115171997,
-0.0300512686,
0.009241919,
0.0237227939,
-0.010844416,
-0.0128017925,
0.0179717783,
0.0183657706,
0.0084347976,
0.0219415538,
-0.0464987196,
-0.0120538501,
0.0145076988,
-0.0402149744,
-0.0652268007,
0.0005266688,
-0.0422926657,
0.0010807773,
-0.0577558316,
-0.0064707091,
1.527756947e-34,
0.0344767757,
-0.0158311762,
0.0372656286,
0.0303495601,
0.0329258554,
0.0063034976,
-0.0526540875,
-0.0258559585,
0.0721673146,
-0.059761174,
-0.0027047696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08150v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08150v2 | Unimodal Aggregation for CTC-based Speech Recognition | 2023-09-15T04:34:40 | 2024-03-20T02:17:16 | Ying Fang, Xiaofei Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper works on non-autoregressive automatic speech recognition. A
unimodal aggregation (UMA) is proposed to segment and integrate the feature
frames that belong to the same text token, and thus to learn better feature
representations for text tokens. The frame-wise features and weights are both
derived from an encoder. Then, the feature frames with unimodal weights are
integrated and further processed by a decoder. Connectionist temporal
classification (CTC) loss is applied for training. Compared to the regular CTC,
the proposed method learns better feature representations and shortens the
sequence length, resulting in lower recognition error and computational
complexity. Experiments on three Mandarin datasets show that UMA demonstrates
superior or comparable performance to other advanced non-autoregressive
methods, such as self-conditioned CTC. Moreover, by integrating
self-conditioned CTC into the proposed framework, the performance can be
further noticeably improved. | [
-0.0464836657,
0.0815521553,
0.0436629467,
0.0255115796,
0.0038687135,
0.0514856875,
0.0693621784,
-0.0280702468,
-0.0222283285,
-0.0119198821,
-0.0241715573,
-0.0630852431,
0.0640717596,
0.0530171953,
-0.0306180157,
-0.0599797554,
0.0016636271,
0.0060020001,
0.010498804,
-0.0138039142,
-0.002521673,
-0.0165812578,
-0.0736173689,
-0.0014553623,
-0.0194978006,
-0.0189229436,
-0.0330891572,
-0.0113584343,
0.0205565002,
-0.0473328121,
-0.0422602594,
0.0081473971,
0.0179787222,
0.0048652007,
0.0000020318,
-0.0337820202,
-0.0346352495,
-0.0264816824,
-0.0241582356,
-0.0078178961,
0.0450654477,
0.0289536808,
-0.0326243043,
0.0482752547,
-0.0224872064,
-0.0351750031,
0.0443896987,
0.0639680848,
0.0117733786,
0.0736788213,
-0.0118092541,
-0.0376126133,
0.0385540724,
0.0017331012,
-0.0277291965,
0.0111965528,
-0.0144717339,
-0.0146476915,
-0.0147485267,
-0.0694494024,
-0.0272610672,
0.0308354758,
0.0376040451,
-0.0140740033,
0.0148014734,
0.046448268,
-0.0542026795,
0.0283866487,
-0.0386020653,
0.035485182,
0.0031060276,
-0.0233226214,
0.0075333845,
0.0100620473,
-0.0462848581,
-0.0042125555,
-0.0098344097,
-0.0127945635,
0.0264536887,
0.0028416715,
-0.0154324779,
0.0607616678,
-0.0019026895,
-0.0011781427,
-0.0402538702,
-0.0405874178,
-0.0192403719,
-0.0163731016,
0.0100319004,
-0.0360426493,
0.0371134803,
0.0032703707,
0.0150161609,
0.0281187166,
0.0403778963,
-0.0277411956,
0.0343303531,
-0.0428478047,
-0.048681125,
-0.0323572606,
-0.0409569405,
0.0448632427,
-0.0408214629,
0.0453168713,
-0.0412223451,
0.0591055751,
-0.0296682678,
0.0085536717,
-0.0466975309,
0.0085387649,
-0.0573970377,
-0.0196424127,
-0.0312762968,
0.0716442615,
0.0298182983,
0.0131314527,
-0.0465299264,
0.0078328978,
-0.0059503261,
-0.0379306488,
-0.0184022319,
0.0311524235,
-0.0143943122,
-0.0191937275,
0.0003510154,
0.0519162342,
0.0138445906,
0.0328817777,
-0.0260181688,
-0.0558182634,
-0.020117892,
0.0193630531,
0.0494743213,
0.0258606002,
0.0044901529,
0.0508003943,
-0.0344177894,
-0.0380108356,
-0.01079123,
-0.006434367,
-0.0394488536,
-0.0242592469,
-0.019391682,
-0.0478804708,
0.0180521663,
-0.0095712906,
0.0354767852,
-0.0105352327,
-0.0283588525,
-0.0345568582,
0.059985511,
0.054247573,
0.0173943322,
-0.0283472687,
0.0753458664,
-0.0139830131,
0.03987436,
0.0468401983,
0.0342802964,
-0.0023332704,
-0.0506885238,
0.0418369099,
0.0040530819,
0.0047109975,
-0.0086165117,
0.0020429438,
-0.0623296313,
-0.0478137955,
0.0340304561,
-0.0061540827,
0.0377731845,
0.0510015041,
-0.0161650702,
0.0025500027,
0.0170009844,
0.0152212288,
0.0431357063,
0.0008637344,
0.0036840802,
-0.0012318981,
0.0119903712,
0.0190326422,
0.0036883745,
0.0316632241,
-0.015516107,
0.0272382721,
0.0555131733,
0.0174163505,
-0.0565882809,
-0.029763259,
0.0114984401,
-0.0549187809,
0.0370836183,
-0.0075050481,
0.0655949786,
-0.0202144831,
-0.0322462246,
-0.022510333,
0.0080318898,
-0.0609058253,
0.0273305438,
0.0050437134,
-0.0052325353,
0.0229180995,
0.0302634034,
-0.0348380022,
-0.0147075895,
-0.0311636012,
-0.0426329598,
0.0250242092,
-0.0042958381,
-0.009651565,
0.0283061154,
-0.0843166932,
-0.0608343482,
0.079167828,
-0.0430567637,
0.0838153809,
-0.0925060511,
0.0504236706,
0.0283205248,
0.0369215421,
0.0126914335,
0.0009689145,
0.0408268422,
-0.0536298454,
0.0304062646,
0.0228240509,
0.0787723213,
0.0592009127,
-0.0298938435,
-0.0062285522,
0.0329910293,
-0.0715058371,
-0.0260595232,
0.0692179874,
-0.1238778532,
-0.0716550499,
0.0406255946,
-0.00562937,
0.0315318108,
0.0062410166,
0.0163820628,
-0.1238317266,
0.04323522,
0.0014719013,
0.0765904412,
-0.063746281,
0.0392952003,
0.0365571752,
0.0112484284,
0.0290188733,
0.0339801423,
-0.0428313985,
-0.0264380723,
0.0339167304,
0.0103397779,
-0.0082454076,
-0.0538697876,
-0.0545601994,
0.0440987162,
0.0115786865,
-0.0040924153,
0.0257975161,
-0.0297786891,
0.0008627921,
-0.0142235216,
-0.1124394685,
-0.0105324872,
-0.0196964592,
0.0112000993,
-0.0413398594,
0.0191198718,
0.0063268822,
-0.0400215462,
-0.0253994819,
-0.0410775244,
-0.020756647,
-0.0104353931,
-0.0158905853,
0.0161119178,
-0.0252925325,
0.0210846048,
0.0045056194,
-0.0252582096,
0.020511603,
-0.0446778946,
-0.0695125014,
0.0011028727,
0.0010606935,
0.0242093746,
0.0298132431,
-0.0089149186,
-0.0247508474,
-0.0234237034,
0.0138057293,
0.012270363,
0.0448532254,
0.0572897717,
0.0105499905,
0.0153189655,
0.0035421213,
-0.0138513548,
0.0293133222,
0.0167812854,
0.0370005183,
0.0357236005,
0.0278037433,
-0.0367561392,
0.0683624372,
0.0224410761,
0.035450194,
-0.0181859098,
-0.0486612655,
-0.0319897905,
-0.0270244684,
-0.0244949274,
-0.0287243854,
-0.0452652723,
-0.0323385708,
0.0006295679,
-0.0146968579,
0.024624547,
-0.0675949603,
-0.036150597,
-0.0133073656,
-0.044895675,
-0.0513423271,
0.0203624163,
0.022083858,
-0.0008653394,
-0.0139614679,
-0.0750385597,
-0.008449967,
-0.0135201523,
0.0129239494,
-0.0413168967,
0.0524339564,
0.0223497339,
0.0037487862,
-0.0191853493,
0.0181585271,
-0.0148388948,
-0.0185289327,
-0.0146996761,
0.026347803,
-0.0215125363,
0.0068284506,
-0.0187052079,
0.0366581604,
0.0058822064,
0.0573782027,
-0.0012019806,
0.0125921378,
-0.0103848176,
0.0896221399,
-0.0092304079,
0.0493406877,
-0.035304036,
0.0030031896,
0.0760587901,
0.0059250183,
0.0620813221,
0.0164959766,
-0.070039168,
-0.0184290614,
-0.0288442466,
-0.0079734288,
0.0098653529,
0.0173911396,
0.0030329111,
-0.0508547202,
0.0456462018,
0.1012386233,
0.012151028,
-0.0667711571,
-0.0578346401,
0.0499550253,
-0.0033948745,
-0.0174711328,
-0.0655943081,
-0.0264592841,
-0.0223230105,
0.0074288971,
0.005433985,
0.0138392961,
0.0077460166,
0.0075700954,
-0.0370433331,
-0.0026424904,
0.0528398901,
-0.0117134573,
-0.0008836437,
-0.0635567531,
-0.0591296814,
-0.0580232851,
0.0270282105,
0.0314294994,
-0.0247872099,
-0.0471537486,
0.0740380809,
-0.0765265226,
0.0033096808,
-0.0090504829,
-0.0072499379,
0.0304710343,
0.0449648201,
0.0201978087,
-0.0276582632,
0.000140356,
0.0523569845,
-0.0119662471,
-0.0028794457,
-0.0146965329,
0.0157947671,
0.0085287634,
0.0029508751,
0.0461448841,
0.0312739126,
-0.0168752223,
0.0015311074,
-0.0079088919,
0.0536404587,
-0.032236632,
0.0231770948,
-0.0113173593,
-0.0237354506,
-0.0520508438,
0.0499090031,
-0.0283339322,
-0.0343864709,
-0.0012605975,
0.0330383629,
0.0097208926,
0.0004335987,
0.0166968144,
0.0184556656,
0.0276016239,
-0.0578766279,
-0.0633587688,
-0.030785121,
-0.015672816,
0.0395476148,
0.0073429625,
0.0367396884,
0.0117281061,
0.0311622247,
-0.0586003624,
-0.0064552831,
-0.0170094483,
-0.0059748902,
-0.0575609803,
0.0270403661,
0.0119773299,
-0.0497031435,
0.0020341384,
-0.0169005953,
-0.0182610396,
-0.064055942,
-0.0012775796,
-0.0622842163,
0.0000221472,
0.0393882617,
-0.0085727479,
-0.0026649183,
0.1222112775,
0.0274783298,
-0.0034877586,
-0.0121569093,
0.0118760252,
-0.0068016048,
-0.0277321767,
-0.0323745199,
-0.045201581,
0.0264993738,
-0.0575698987,
-0.0253977478,
-0.0480695181,
0.0238932222,
0.0230285861,
-0.0174032133,
0.0533285215,
0.000162355,
0.060076464,
-0.0217023585,
0.0444939658,
0.020760566,
0.0468655154,
0.0003705707,
0.0207972527,
-0.0127182156,
0.0125492606,
-0.0044541503,
0.0132771423,
0.0062016766,
-0.0483383015,
0.053349901,
0.0470596068,
-0.0107766753,
0.0126125589,
-0.0251074526,
0.0060281395,
-0.0089525478,
0.0203637853,
0.0024782908,
0.0003609267,
0.0033770562,
0.0488427468,
-0.0172943622,
0.0362043642,
0.009617094,
0.0246063415,
-0.0214506146,
0.0684965104,
-0.0348482579,
-0.0230659768,
0.0346853547,
-0.0409333669,
0.0058680661,
-0.0034935933,
0.0427572615,
-0.0433313958,
-0.03952666,
-0.0116866734,
0.0066655329,
0.0157030709,
0.0203563944,
-0.0217890833,
0.0163074955,
0.0492449217,
-0.0181184988,
-0.0228067581,
0.0398396626,
0.0524373613,
-0.0154056968,
0.0206066538,
0.0184191633,
0.0108828433,
-0.0508494005,
-0.0149507904,
0.0430421904,
-0.0043767616,
0.0719929039,
0.0036407488,
0.036001835,
0.0008337252,
0.0180126056,
-0.0413060375,
-0.037534263,
0.013996833,
0.0255245995,
-0.0263005085,
0.0262899343,
0.0163730811,
0.013956232,
-5.977296938e-33,
-0.0055727246,
-0.031168852,
-0.0266648512,
0.0018830056,
-0.0124397641,
0.0520695187,
0.0182227399,
0.0367804952,
0.0417319946,
-0.0410369746,
-0.0227016378,
0.0203487352,
0.0254400801,
0.0322073735,
0.0096298279,
0.0107854446,
0.0862088799,
-0.0120510077,
0.0117967082,
0.0221050717,
0.0531165451,
0.0131061831,
0.020245621,
-0.0677361786,
-0.0320868827,
-0.0042210212,
-0.0053721895,
-0.003049809,
0.0896496251,
0.0206413064,
-0.0170501713,
0.0117749302,
0.016975373,
0.0037726446,
-0.0293099508,
0.0344885103,
-0.0967410505,
-0.0200314559,
-0.0352351926,
0.0370493196,
-0.023221124,
-0.0267722905,
0.0134118544,
0.0344883651,
-0.0073667853,
-0.0380810052,
0.0164350327,
-0.0254694298,
-0.038257163,
-0.0662416071,
0.0500332117,
0.0661962703,
-0.0355119221,
-0.0206836294,
0.0577745289,
-0.0073442049,
-0.0109891379,
-0.012430273,
-0.0873822868,
0.0246697105,
0.0018363793,
0.0322538726,
0.0335494131,
0.0322505459,
0.0154801384,
0.0316278674,
0.0194508359,
-0.060743019,
-0.033629071,
-0.023294108,
0.0103031565,
-0.0295615997,
0.0103046196,
-0.0242677834,
0.064461723,
-0.0462727435,
0.0103812898,
0.0637853742,
0.0585942157,
0.0396345295,
0.0015991256,
0.0612518974,
-0.0539848357,
0.0227035899,
-0.0153105957,
-0.0261411238,
-0.0386936963,
-0.0377942622,
0.0192783922,
0.0215218868,
0.0170108359,
-0.0310786162,
0.0607338734,
-0.0051546199,
0.0227332599,
0.0264863279,
0.0154626621,
-0.0096366554,
-0.0085776066,
0.0081791487,
-0.0357243828,
-0.0278125126,
0.0298232827,
0.003996117,
0.0023842647,
-0.0427607149,
0.0058283228,
0.0797403082,
-0.0780892596,
-0.0102904672,
0.0594249927,
-0.0216760598,
0.0122140162,
-0.0035596779,
0.0375730693,
0.0072294902,
0.0135987904,
0.0446161032,
-0.0284954105,
0.0005383895,
-0.0578458905,
0.0257648975,
-0.0023776633,
0.0169464331,
-0.0031744407,
0.0030121456,
0.01327914,
0.0113418158,
0.042275358,
-0.0311755519,
0.011917253,
0.0193811525,
2.759e-7,
-0.0712065175,
-0.0127755534,
0.0615408234,
-0.0384285189,
0.0096546859,
0.0223905798,
-0.0018065128,
0.0114542088,
-0.0166293141,
0.0037864957,
0.0473073535,
0.0106323417,
0.0378209502,
0.0339941941,
-0.0735124871,
0.0307650287,
-0.0463740975,
0.0169474036,
-0.0187049042,
0.0104628131,
0.0213158131,
0.0816793442,
-0.0386150442,
-0.0034585635,
-0.0138099324,
-0.0414588042,
0.0472979285,
0.0490427539,
-0.0244463831,
-0.0021063937,
0.0036185177,
0.0004673751,
-0.0386887304,
0.0089671677,
-0.013657216,
0.0781975538,
0.022087926,
-0.0203253105,
-0.0246766396,
-0.1034668088,
0.028646823,
0.0411262438,
-0.0446188599,
0.0632879958,
0.0551756285,
-0.0148087963,
-0.0098284772,
-0.016004378,
-0.0341388807,
0.0382003188,
0.0475131869,
0.044469282,
0.0105504896,
0.0485408902,
-0.0009898597,
-0.0490310751,
-0.0256131534,
-0.0847642496,
0.004965628,
0.027503781,
-0.0227792766,
0.0048402715,
-0.0269913282,
-0.0040234821,
0.0535076931,
0.0020044697,
0.0011487226,
1.701536797e-34,
0.0206946954,
-0.0465259179,
0.0132695483,
0.0146107441,
-0.0229906756,
-0.0565959774,
-0.0505578034,
-0.0075777913,
0.0108564766,
-0.0763533786,
-0.0242803209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08140v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08140v2 | PromptTTS++: Controlling Speaker Identity in Prompt-Based Text-to-Speech Using Natural Language Descriptions | 2023-09-15T04:11:37 | 2023-12-27T10:41:36 | Reo Shimizu, Ryuichi Yamamoto, Masaya Kawamura, Yuma Shirahata, Hironori Doi, Tatsuya Komatsu, Kentaro Tachibana | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | We propose PromptTTS++, a prompt-based text-to-speech (TTS) synthesis system
that allows control over speaker identity using natural language descriptions.
To control speaker identity within the prompt-based TTS framework, we introduce
the concept of speaker prompt, which describes voice characteristics (e.g.,
gender-neutral, young, old, and muffled) designed to be approximately
independent of speaking style. Since there is no large-scale dataset containing
speaker prompts, we first construct a dataset based on the LibriTTS-R corpus
with manually annotated speaker prompts. We then employ a diffusion-based
acoustic model with mixture density networks to model diverse speaker factors
in the training data. Unlike previous studies that rely on style prompts
describing only a limited aspect of speaker individuality, such as pitch,
speaking speed, and energy, our method utilizes an additional speaker prompt to
effectively learn the mapping from natural language descriptions to the
acoustic features of diverse speakers. Our subjective evaluation results show
that the proposed method can better control speaker characteristics than the
methods without the speaker prompt. Audio samples are available at
https://reppy4620.github.io/demo.promptttspp/. | [
-0.0213785712,
0.0589637719,
0.0021258357,
-0.0040334724,
0.0029923143,
-0.0295445304,
0.0669857338,
-0.0399039872,
-0.0339795947,
0.0084813237,
-0.0329826735,
-0.0396213606,
0.0385329425,
0.0319698378,
0.0377312228,
-0.1007840708,
0.0094113369,
-0.0199066196,
0.0091204559,
-0.0126835499,
0.0105434516,
0.0495886058,
-0.0189236049,
0.0303009786,
-0.002586737,
-0.0123019069,
0.0035263349,
0.0259208623,
0.0553388707,
0.0404687822,
0.0089862188,
0.0383385718,
0.040317338,
-0.0038506319,
0.0000020257,
-0.0384163745,
-0.0249522682,
0.0043326076,
-0.0450407006,
-0.0204487182,
0.0197310299,
0.0773535222,
-0.0345392562,
0.025527399,
0.0148666892,
-0.0048100529,
0.0590672307,
0.0254249591,
0.0558366142,
0.0626375079,
0.0105976248,
-0.0602543354,
-0.020794807,
-0.0086141424,
0.0595407635,
0.0153168812,
-0.0155293206,
-0.0623406582,
0.017793335,
-0.0032508371,
0.0033346189,
0.0424894802,
-0.0208889693,
-0.0019391752,
0.0692953169,
0.0047999201,
0.0219997969,
-0.0414140858,
-0.0073254579,
0.0645151958,
0.0315569676,
-0.0067872624,
0.0396577008,
0.0175478142,
-0.0154048027,
-0.010961039,
0.02569809,
-0.0171297099,
-0.0102303261,
-0.0292210206,
-0.082303904,
0.0629735962,
0.0094973529,
-0.0371660255,
-0.0247233901,
-0.0017068912,
0.0094536897,
-0.0428320952,
0.0051838974,
-0.0545018837,
0.0119524766,
-0.0289307572,
0.064056024,
0.0038470377,
-0.0325396843,
-0.0274198819,
-0.0148581322,
-0.0444612615,
-0.0441611744,
0.0444589928,
-0.0081345076,
0.0193483364,
-0.0385401025,
-0.0323473476,
-0.0094173821,
0.0155165289,
-0.0088314069,
-0.0480154678,
-0.0349102542,
0.0033298139,
-0.0340055563,
0.021164244,
-0.02226004,
0.0088713113,
-0.0110588614,
0.0101069184,
-0.0522056334,
0.011284993,
-0.0587520935,
0.0053474056,
-0.0060906159,
0.0145133175,
-0.0550642535,
-0.0061446391,
-0.0117291259,
0.0246289559,
-0.0074798283,
0.0146495728,
-0.0006755989,
-0.0205067378,
-0.0065882117,
0.0230645277,
0.0449727662,
-0.0023587402,
0.0284462236,
-0.0037765063,
-0.0104776742,
-0.0077961669,
-0.0131148165,
-0.030879993,
-0.036579784,
-0.0411659218,
-0.0265016444,
-0.0731914863,
0.0209863335,
-0.0235420857,
-0.0041954266,
-0.0271285716,
-0.0336261764,
0.010767852,
0.0072379899,
0.0486583635,
-0.0227134544,
0.0309573542,
0.0653076023,
0.0084174909,
-0.0292752441,
0.0050476124,
0.0394193083,
-0.014137621,
-0.0163484346,
-0.0491121151,
0.015108604,
0.0524267368,
0.0246374682,
0.0219349358,
-0.0020241169,
-0.0026516723,
0.0105314124,
0.0467819758,
0.0689417571,
-0.0126429358,
0.0076376298,
-0.0209424365,
0.060065791,
0.0502554141,
0.0286960099,
0.0140776196,
0.0961982608,
0.0574873686,
0.0019155173,
0.0007486542,
0.002916869,
-0.0184318591,
-0.0233511403,
-0.0118347835,
0.0595312715,
0.0323497094,
-0.0409509018,
0.0145066148,
0.0253816042,
-0.0186319053,
-0.0067461692,
0.0197450258,
-0.0419390276,
0.0373438373,
-0.0030319877,
0.0410647206,
-0.0084485877,
-0.0749453753,
0.0208235793,
-0.040602915,
0.0074983495,
0.0691703483,
-0.0230552442,
-0.0233339928,
0.0144290943,
-0.0811394751,
0.0044362927,
0.0149856526,
-0.0018956965,
0.0017972346,
0.0409931913,
-0.0645215213,
-0.0019645642,
0.0390160456,
-0.017494468,
0.0607129373,
-0.0226112828,
0.0349672623,
0.0462902188,
0.0098161343,
0.0389580354,
-0.0215101205,
-0.0384618156,
-0.0501583666,
0.0568748154,
0.0127498591,
0.0405625403,
0.0549427904,
-0.0370923951,
0.0103973709,
-0.0257221945,
-0.002546679,
-0.0029066303,
0.0274354704,
-0.0668716654,
-0.0135495514,
0.0100051928,
-0.018252695,
-0.0199930929,
0.0042602806,
0.0100762164,
-0.0903370306,
0.0648365021,
-0.0333841741,
-0.011054392,
-0.0137347067,
0.0040330822,
0.0384387784,
0.0269021206,
0.0181809422,
0.0120635787,
0.0459835343,
0.0077445256,
0.065704599,
0.0635742843,
-0.0287219398,
-0.104371801,
-0.0017520592,
-0.0373134725,
-0.009126626,
0.0494608656,
-0.0114247911,
-0.0122508705,
-0.0113164056,
-0.0208340771,
-0.0475536287,
0.0262903646,
-0.0082047228,
-0.0221956689,
-0.0058058701,
0.0231645871,
-0.0210874658,
-0.0191139206,
-0.0696629956,
-0.0704210997,
-0.0086456211,
-0.0317645036,
-0.0226767696,
-0.0214692801,
-0.0473908558,
0.0001574102,
0.0136478916,
-0.0408015512,
0.0115390271,
-0.0423185565,
-0.0132826911,
-0.0134770432,
-0.0206895042,
0.0141903004,
0.0085472325,
0.0047865962,
0.050461825,
0.00547681,
0.001852105,
0.1130438223,
-0.0109247435,
0.0353586227,
-0.0246111173,
-0.027333321,
-0.0374072269,
-0.0334047601,
0.0305217002,
-0.0045411573,
0.0394393057,
0.0299998876,
-0.0770212263,
0.0261615161,
-0.0170127936,
0.0531167015,
-0.0330087468,
-0.072749123,
0.0177753847,
0.0154949008,
-0.0034977044,
-0.019753715,
-0.0389656499,
-0.0397570506,
-0.0131982574,
-0.0003851829,
-0.0310659073,
0.0444327854,
-0.0713398606,
-0.0488594957,
-0.0622073859,
-0.0553784929,
0.0033224721,
-0.0137115568,
-0.0211140886,
0.0516551249,
0.050019104,
-0.0269406103,
-0.0231610052,
-0.0172301382,
0.0263219289,
-0.0521240979,
-0.0003174773,
-0.0113993771,
-0.0015211029,
0.0040291604,
-0.0033179589,
-0.0069582383,
-0.072390601,
0.0203618668,
0.0430671796,
0.0106166322,
-0.0439712517,
0.0171548966,
0.0100363754,
0.0545477793,
0.0165284555,
-0.0274389386,
0.0218586642,
-0.0281423219,
0.0341177359,
0.0057439241,
0.0749440342,
-0.0300611705,
-0.0198140405,
0.0198990759,
-0.0582987182,
0.0275687668,
0.0082247593,
-0.0388506837,
-0.0091587342,
-0.0017763546,
0.0070610931,
0.0083713299,
0.0356460884,
0.0739459246,
-0.0115065007,
0.029356407,
0.0916023105,
-0.0124065299,
-0.0481171571,
-0.0369944014,
0.0415099971,
0.0630373657,
0.0010331715,
0.0035468822,
-0.0406689383,
-0.0126209464,
0.051639501,
0.0693921372,
-0.0168094337,
-0.0033448022,
-0.0663418695,
-0.0554630421,
0.0350335203,
0.042532973,
-0.0599365979,
-0.0120069273,
-0.0409800187,
-0.0467828847,
0.0342612751,
0.0257296506,
0.022823941,
-0.0203019641,
-0.0203242134,
0.0439340733,
-0.0634893328,
-0.0637013167,
0.0158772618,
-0.0659700409,
0.1145609915,
0.0560980849,
0.0342644006,
-0.0026822549,
-0.0319873318,
-0.0454330407,
-0.0169926919,
-0.0079684313,
0.0098005226,
-0.002571437,
0.0108579677,
-0.002845784,
-0.0117175672,
0.0798139274,
0.0178229567,
0.0094638485,
0.0117584383,
0.0202642661,
-0.0132175051,
-0.013234497,
-0.0249344893,
0.0611565895,
0.0553397797,
0.0736938715,
0.0394003093,
-0.0614165962,
0.0221736971,
0.0043099304,
0.0553244501,
0.0091562178,
-0.0433013216,
0.0182474274,
-0.0030021854,
-0.0674663037,
-0.0185268689,
0.0123013435,
-0.0361005925,
0.0199916866,
0.0248248465,
-0.0074390816,
-0.0489496402,
-0.001317575,
-0.0346427262,
0.047172673,
-0.0217107069,
0.0669160932,
-0.0677620769,
-0.0313586071,
0.0263645798,
-0.0822860897,
-0.0140778916,
0.0293211639,
-0.0423665084,
-0.0438204557,
-0.01393463,
0.0042382265,
0.0183001217,
0.0770036206,
-0.0427410007,
-0.0714269578,
0.1022207737,
0.0409655981,
-0.0005930134,
0.0044381092,
0.0540267229,
0.0439119488,
-0.0250472501,
-0.0192385465,
-0.0367565975,
0.0427456535,
0.0082469042,
-0.0279383995,
0.0093612177,
-0.0675664693,
-0.0265498124,
0.0342320502,
0.0086787427,
-0.0120156128,
0.0510729961,
-0.0459268242,
-0.0073989029,
0.0130722327,
0.0214845203,
-0.0149711045,
-0.0272958539,
0.0335587934,
0.037393149,
0.0117958458,
-0.0167942066,
-0.0171230026,
0.0120176794,
-0.0069479737,
0.0186415575,
0.0435548052,
0.0181231368,
0.0300944429,
0.0045176297,
-0.0189211145,
0.0216779057,
0.0118701095,
-0.0032929906,
0.0200045537,
-0.0020885817,
0.0123354085,
-0.0141277425,
0.0006540445,
0.0493079461,
-0.0542180464,
-0.0179603789,
-0.0289390255,
0.0142765287,
-0.0094352057,
0.0409586132,
0.0335152075,
-0.0019744784,
0.0510650054,
-0.0222345404,
0.0078150555,
-0.0116015198,
0.0071530612,
0.0285664313,
-0.0158562697,
-0.0204535481,
-0.0054526692,
0.0273250379,
0.0024539337,
0.0008941825,
-0.0492628291,
-0.001424985,
-0.0236222968,
0.0045283246,
-0.0439028554,
-0.0021669955,
-0.017291531,
-0.046702344,
-0.034213081,
-0.0370895229,
0.0465719067,
-0.0096497061,
0.0099012116,
0.0072425534,
0.0423142351,
-0.0314251035,
-0.0595233776,
-0.0108242221,
0.0124728903,
-0.0022004656,
0.0154002877,
-0.0348161049,
0.0258601233,
-6.121748664e-33,
-0.0339965858,
0.0024475434,
-0.0105945319,
-0.0126953907,
-0.0251273271,
-0.0343736522,
-0.0185548328,
-0.0027720642,
0.0151603622,
-0.0137235653,
-0.0439947918,
-0.0087194694,
0.0215815213,
0.0264431555,
-0.0554979853,
0.0120270057,
0.1098908558,
0.0142253824,
0.0074159876,
0.0548142605,
0.051984299,
0.0233911108,
0.0144243892,
-0.0401942991,
0.0192935467,
-0.0211289525,
-0.0390782915,
-0.0027998211,
0.0119998353,
-0.0133336121,
-0.0185855106,
0.0482118577,
-0.0285436641,
-0.0165994838,
-0.0393464975,
0.0792175606,
-0.0517838709,
-0.0199141279,
-0.042280782,
0.0181942955,
0.0213254932,
-0.030443918,
0.0370987542,
-0.0042025624,
-0.0439467654,
-0.0079301577,
0.0597412921,
0.0046379957,
0.0480916128,
-0.0315251686,
-0.0089375451,
0.0243834574,
-0.0243381653,
-0.0487107597,
0.0254970286,
0.0502925068,
-0.0334814452,
-0.0226281583,
-0.063195914,
0.0177813992,
0.009663485,
0.0006140544,
0.0031456396,
0.0623464212,
0.0098938644,
0.023974428,
0.0718889087,
-0.0338673964,
-0.0210935678,
-0.0098823989,
0.0429399721,
0.0296797827,
0.0530793518,
0.0303189084,
-0.0013780452,
-0.0269580577,
-0.0348297954,
0.0262357406,
0.0232079979,
-0.0534935743,
0.0031491632,
0.0031085953,
-0.0199642852,
-0.0028511102,
-0.0688606873,
-0.0647967458,
-0.0064808629,
-0.0023427519,
0.0222322438,
-0.0276271179,
-0.0429673344,
-0.0576852635,
0.0510091707,
-0.0160080735,
0.0023363479,
-0.0456421226,
-0.0603812225,
-0.0070698112,
0.0204375107,
-0.0002962774,
-0.0218805969,
-0.0421648063,
0.0941267461,
0.0399146937,
0.0174787138,
0.0003994759,
-0.0307357013,
0.0830217376,
-0.0559061915,
0.0126402564,
0.0146119921,
0.0699710548,
-0.0110308407,
0.0197674055,
0.0323582478,
-0.0069288537,
0.0016185188,
0.0176736098,
0.0246321801,
0.0174199995,
0.0415496081,
0.0319337584,
-0.0093431203,
0.0390212014,
-0.0334567055,
0.0273438655,
0.0158176199,
0.0144276265,
0.0760535598,
-0.0231450032,
0.0040061288,
0.0011412818,
2.789e-7,
-0.0794400871,
-0.0117410459,
0.0346946605,
-0.0388850011,
0.0426765457,
0.0490867645,
-0.0121501097,
0.0267633479,
0.024153199,
-0.0324071087,
0.0035724847,
-0.0477717184,
0.0866152793,
0.0294861458,
-0.1410318911,
-0.028478425,
-0.068488054,
0.039678853,
-0.0371544249,
0.0269652195,
0.0322008878,
0.0517440178,
0.024650339,
-0.021996906,
0.0524212122,
-0.0033340822,
0.0153519735,
-0.0204054937,
0.021862708,
-0.0144773144,
0.0509892255,
-0.0802887529,
-0.0089042559,
0.031514857,
-0.0215038471,
0.0548749194,
0.0139205772,
0.0530555919,
0.0280627627,
-0.0491744615,
-0.0360659845,
0.0395840332,
-0.0440863594,
0.0143618481,
0.0615483522,
0.0310831834,
-0.019065218,
-0.0400862731,
-0.055912815,
-0.0065827221,
0.0271695051,
-0.0161053166,
-0.0207931064,
0.0255991891,
0.0041592438,
0.0192059446,
0.0121046649,
-0.0568001978,
0.0090318369,
-0.0133334175,
-0.0694914982,
-0.0561290309,
-0.0193800889,
0.0204533152,
0.0360235013,
-0.0100825746,
0.0123270862,
2.334110026e-34,
-0.000299333,
-0.0125755407,
0.0160410516,
-0.0481376834,
-0.0004690582,
-0.0161625799,
0.011094505,
0.0126385204,
0.0481812656,
-0.0369029157,
-0.0461799391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08141v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08141v1 | Audio Difference Learning for Audio Captioning | 2023-09-15T04:11:37 | 2023-09-15T04:11:37 | Tatsuya Komatsu, Yusuke Fujita, Kazuya Takeda, Tomoki Toda | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.SP | This study introduces a novel training paradigm, audio difference learning,
for improving audio captioning. The fundamental concept of the proposed
learning method is to create a feature representation space that preserves the
relationship between audio, enabling the generation of captions that detail
intricate audio information. This method employs a reference audio along with
the input audio, both of which are transformed into feature representations via
a shared encoder. Captions are then generated from these differential features
to describe their differences. Furthermore, a unique technique is proposed that
involves mixing the input audio with additional audio, and using the additional
audio as a reference. This results in the difference between the mixed audio
and the reference audio reverting back to the original input audio. This allows
the original input's caption to be used as the caption for their difference,
eliminating the need for additional annotations for the differences. In the
experiments using the Clotho and ESC50 datasets, the proposed method
demonstrated an improvement in the SPIDEr score by 7% compared to conventional
methods. | [
0.024768414,
-0.0049538654,
-0.0084700901,
-0.0061900411,
-0.0018005379,
0.0040528569,
0.002551167,
-0.0358818769,
-0.0584155545,
-0.0387317054,
-0.0499466248,
0.0068664793,
-0.0068193101,
0.0564064384,
-0.0459775142,
-0.0995506793,
0.0046653538,
-0.0239203535,
0.0234904569,
-0.0264568925,
-0.0155034456,
-0.013968966,
-0.0482476838,
0.00682199,
-0.0140396822,
0.017490996,
0.001825111,
0.0211525932,
0.0285937209,
-0.0287428088,
-0.003497469,
0.0580274388,
0.0993131995,
0.0477559082,
0.0000017864,
-0.025781,
-0.0315065831,
0.0146849258,
0.0252265539,
0.0000156758,
0.0007144736,
-0.0071811713,
-0.0205141623,
0.0241891481,
0.0011334792,
-0.0664531514,
0.0778408945,
0.0449146889,
0.0696751252,
0.0481166393,
-0.0154442107,
-0.0918132439,
-0.0255889613,
-0.0246076137,
0.0009105881,
0.0102806175,
-0.0183605105,
0.0560975522,
0.0355492681,
-0.0269028582,
-0.0244380292,
0.0624368489,
0.0020195523,
-0.0008158641,
0.0377432555,
0.0636590421,
-0.0232152753,
-0.0394826196,
-0.0120602101,
0.0674886331,
0.0347726904,
0.0164783224,
-0.0252872631,
0.0024695764,
-0.0132563924,
0.0160870459,
-0.0575595349,
0.0122822477,
0.027003888,
-0.0064664106,
-0.0667046309,
0.0595762506,
0.0150181009,
-0.0371950865,
-0.0107953064,
-0.0492739156,
0.0280820262,
-0.0084035629,
-0.0135131339,
-0.0392094627,
-0.0252768267,
-0.006519997,
0.0662277117,
-0.0078045418,
0.0068380875,
-0.0406429954,
-0.0114450362,
-0.0504032001,
-0.0250858534,
-0.0260785092,
0.0013911035,
-0.0052736555,
-0.0712063909,
0.0580645464,
-0.0189798176,
0.0462794453,
0.0367858969,
0.001785946,
-0.0025652507,
0.0332946628,
-0.0889100209,
-0.0146921426,
-0.0287589952,
0.0552338473,
-0.0131243449,
-0.0435840711,
-0.0027377524,
-0.0424302071,
-0.0771820843,
0.0509694815,
0.0021831184,
0.0295949858,
-0.0243602134,
0.0136620142,
-0.0062832157,
0.0015799277,
-0.0190618429,
0.0547627695,
-0.0209690407,
0.0003095436,
-0.0164427813,
-0.0176845137,
0.0359302536,
0.0053279935,
0.0326644629,
0.0909203663,
-0.0047042826,
-0.0007990483,
0.0354527868,
0.0063729906,
-0.0169586614,
0.0031854855,
-0.012562274,
-0.0438343585,
0.0420684777,
-0.0241039563,
-0.0042823069,
-0.0194709692,
-0.002254735,
0.0000484356,
0.0402521268,
0.0935909674,
-0.0268809516,
0.0276060235,
0.0552236438,
0.0059072166,
-0.0140708201,
0.0535156913,
0.0724777058,
-0.0082739405,
0.0438449718,
-0.0163302962,
0.0070791719,
-0.0035764845,
-0.0058826115,
0.0056609209,
-0.0232498758,
-0.0364172161,
0.0115725761,
0.0251215752,
0.022530878,
0.0212337598,
-0.0092415875,
-0.0179511067,
0.0603767335,
-0.0003066123,
0.01120832,
0.030466713,
0.0156682208,
0.0424980223,
-0.0096837915,
0.0357530452,
0.0183774829,
0.0503074266,
0.0230194218,
0.0294566937,
0.0046143555,
-0.0154888891,
-0.0177253392,
-0.0012805471,
0.0126349907,
-0.0265688803,
0.0019626389,
-0.0270132348,
0.0006216635,
0.0372375287,
-0.0333729051,
0.0455631651,
-0.0086789932,
-0.0744518042,
0.0124263372,
-0.0139502417,
-0.0053954003,
0.0718386248,
0.0135348206,
-0.0465121344,
0.0009214124,
-0.0482498556,
-0.0055052014,
0.0647273287,
0.0233938936,
-0.0400811397,
-0.0124153672,
-0.0376430824,
-0.0326232873,
-0.0306392834,
-0.012283816,
0.0427381843,
-0.0330955312,
-0.0027038914,
0.0392485894,
0.0097761396,
-0.0261634551,
-0.0141585246,
0.0352246054,
-0.0257021524,
0.0018776503,
0.0347721763,
0.0427235886,
0.0555575825,
-0.0587181784,
0.0046511302,
-0.0101996064,
0.0105336886,
-0.0552357025,
0.0684372187,
-0.0682866946,
-0.0208084956,
0.0374896042,
-0.0855171606,
0.0501585826,
0.0374432839,
-0.0010271039,
-0.0536351316,
0.0162911955,
-0.0282481574,
-0.0050037359,
-0.0321182497,
0.0361284465,
-0.0244514812,
-0.0078009353,
0.0109528368,
0.0122555783,
0.0408847407,
-0.0251090396,
-0.0193212759,
0.0360094085,
0.0082361503,
-0.017371675,
-0.0271657407,
0.0457685851,
0.0308650173,
0.0075270343,
0.0000044965,
0.0001861195,
-0.0288085602,
-0.0081028584,
-0.0505870879,
0.0159307625,
-0.0203673542,
-0.0166585967,
0.008355136,
-0.0272242874,
0.0203190874,
-0.0477945358,
-0.0100238351,
-0.042697046,
-0.0099723786,
-0.0037779696,
-0.0328861997,
0.0393730216,
-0.0488872826,
-0.0049518473,
0.0215835087,
0.026385054,
0.0072300341,
-0.0192392115,
-0.0475652292,
0.0058673266,
-0.0071720267,
-0.0080317464,
0.0160980728,
0.0069531687,
-0.0168804508,
-0.0191410035,
0.0382189602,
0.0220378675,
-0.043581523,
0.0226463899,
0.025009295,
0.0725676194,
-0.0107965078,
-0.0148954876,
0.012044305,
0.0010549274,
0.005881133,
-0.000852911,
0.0298911873,
-0.0552550219,
0.0081501808,
0.0321362726,
0.0195010938,
-0.047068134,
-0.0189603008,
-0.0291774068,
-0.0244961306,
-0.018497698,
-0.0545395575,
-0.0267692879,
0.0025659816,
-0.0198399741,
-0.0488576926,
0.0660887286,
-0.0228802692,
-0.0523138382,
-0.0732753277,
-0.0157956686,
-0.0253256056,
0.0709954053,
-0.0402814485,
0.0254528653,
-0.0252622049,
-0.0629522279,
-0.0322726779,
0.0355473123,
0.0750553831,
-0.0411613286,
0.0436298363,
-0.0490956455,
-0.0095829461,
-0.007231486,
-0.0124283182,
-0.0174329039,
-0.010347995,
-0.0136787156,
0.0165065154,
-0.0537672155,
-0.0158928111,
-0.0157583542,
0.055266656,
0.0271752309,
0.0500089191,
-0.0012553199,
0.0431151316,
-0.0118888337,
0.0248460807,
0.0078820018,
0.0414069034,
-0.0520246737,
-0.0031413843,
0.0605295822,
-0.0433357731,
0.0128192725,
-0.0189596936,
-0.0323323421,
0.0323158354,
-0.0012357061,
-0.0387872458,
-0.0291003119,
0.0034580827,
0.0032931569,
-0.0387374982,
0.0175040476,
0.1231895909,
0.0325833224,
-0.0353090465,
-0.0138942488,
0.006521557,
-0.0031412407,
0.0386688299,
-0.0383459739,
-0.023004435,
-0.01798952,
0.0128633352,
0.0247479361,
0.0499119833,
0.0524650812,
-0.0176522024,
-0.0711209401,
0.0147074405,
0.0345815048,
-0.0957088172,
-0.0626258999,
-0.0198620129,
-0.0294882767,
0.0195518285,
0.0073092328,
-0.0139194522,
-0.0191307962,
0.0035835134,
0.0383288153,
0.0041492274,
-0.0478828736,
-0.0158678666,
-0.0638426393,
0.0635428205,
0.0906463861,
0.0225150418,
-0.0336784683,
-0.0068244515,
-0.0542134009,
-0.0133985169,
0.0022187957,
0.0164032485,
0.0837755874,
0.0069778473,
0.0013722975,
0.0474753827,
-0.0090437848,
0.0268371813,
-0.0177184921,
0.0346196368,
0.00591589,
0.0019531297,
0.0181828104,
-0.0095876884,
0.0814330205,
0.005519296,
0.0416508429,
0.0578569435,
-0.0013166916,
0.0313329846,
0.0131683201,
0.0149578024,
-0.0664352402,
0.0288673304,
0.0138969151,
-0.0333864801,
-0.0858974084,
-0.0702048838,
-0.0049467566,
0.0082388809,
0.0275055077,
0.0775244609,
-0.005337256,
-0.0055741277,
0.0309172217,
-0.0894218162,
-0.002984961,
0.0082682474,
0.0110689243,
0.0015855392,
-0.0554503985,
0.0831272528,
-0.010516637,
-0.0320927724,
-0.0172079187,
-0.0372281186,
-0.0252752844,
-0.0058017378,
-0.014446293,
0.0161644928,
0.0552126393,
0.021478422,
-0.0259211492,
0.0024595864,
0.0164812356,
0.0084712813,
0.0182880089,
0.070788458,
-0.0307486579,
-0.0228146985,
0.0047625168,
-0.0733314827,
0.0309614725,
-0.017808754,
0.0522951037,
0.0264773499,
-0.0159878209,
-0.0066066082,
-0.0349035338,
0.0254654996,
-0.026832154,
0.0065840567,
-0.0588905402,
0.0295391753,
-0.0187892672,
0.0129893133,
-0.0378799513,
0.0069908737,
0.0150556341,
0.0352708697,
-0.020864116,
0.0395873785,
-0.0180717409,
-0.0142170396,
-0.010833893,
0.0394591689,
0.0689329281,
-0.022076875,
-0.0188914966,
0.0148606291,
-0.0113170631,
-0.019216679,
0.0759155676,
-0.0097463988,
0.0129608074,
0.0162109546,
0.0082279807,
-0.0024384819,
-0.0042112218,
0.0415435843,
-0.0035310793,
0.0327772833,
-0.0325951949,
0.013864737,
0.0411313027,
-0.0133018112,
0.0330506861,
0.0298633929,
0.0032665858,
0.0065326202,
0.0273583215,
-0.0384677351,
-0.0307389814,
0.0221211649,
-0.0097450623,
0.022861762,
0.0436593629,
0.0514296927,
-0.0491826385,
0.0234883092,
-0.0458407477,
0.009646087,
-0.0206332132,
-0.0060578524,
-0.0540094525,
0.0169353206,
0.0229151342,
0.006910109,
-0.007583674,
-0.048091691,
0.0105767036,
-0.0476520546,
0.0365789495,
0.0352365188,
0.071114935,
-0.0019755468,
0.0031803888,
0.0077125225,
0.0257216897,
-0.0535666794,
0.0114406319,
0.0201958418,
-0.0202683099,
-4.583514021e-33,
-0.0611135848,
-0.0174026676,
-0.0287403073,
-0.0159396902,
-0.0447134823,
-0.010125529,
-0.0153282322,
-0.0021641396,
0.0351484567,
0.0045512416,
0.0428181365,
0.0027025891,
0.029254064,
0.0103919879,
0.0340545923,
-0.033618778,
0.115178749,
-0.0166672319,
0.0006786209,
0.0277319048,
0.0332696103,
0.0304663405,
0.0242217798,
-0.0766861513,
-0.0238412116,
-0.0256839823,
-0.0425943732,
-0.019379098,
0.0491185449,
0.0267786253,
0.0226636082,
0.017635772,
-0.021362897,
-0.0167694725,
-0.0408580974,
-0.0042375014,
-0.0723262504,
-0.0281831734,
0.0411101319,
0.0550360382,
0.0486365482,
-0.0294932462,
0.0057814871,
-0.021158509,
-0.0254191626,
-0.0331429243,
0.0600431152,
-0.0404717885,
0.0044540917,
-0.0394074842,
-0.0663576871,
0.0049014706,
-0.0269610565,
-0.0455449782,
0.0546481311,
0.0438436493,
0.0017075865,
-0.0059845215,
-0.0609232001,
0.0681136176,
0.0372859202,
0.0045208144,
0.0524188429,
0.0437965617,
-0.0164327379,
0.0710352361,
0.0240051094,
-0.0775757432,
0.0089061633,
0.0374391004,
0.0020481313,
0.0224301014,
0.0380591154,
-0.0050046593,
0.0335445516,
-0.012608543,
-0.0167430583,
0.0161572527,
-0.0914452448,
-0.016560033,
0.023760546,
0.061488267,
-0.0300081056,
0.031832438,
-0.0767591298,
-0.0017632482,
-0.0183335375,
-0.082320042,
0.0378544815,
-0.0101116458,
0.0027401568,
-0.0055247885,
0.0204006992,
-0.0150016043,
0.0285258293,
-0.0127806244,
-0.0501521453,
0.0216334797,
-0.0007747974,
-0.0582013316,
0.0203500278,
-0.0335191861,
0.1171701774,
0.0217971019,
0.0435498357,
-0.0382170081,
0.0292860996,
0.0800442398,
-0.0439014882,
-0.0016782098,
0.0213275179,
-0.0433284305,
-0.0105541525,
0.0218852554,
-0.009534928,
0.0354067162,
-0.0566271022,
0.0237521622,
-0.0260934103,
0.0183199197,
-0.0414888784,
-0.0169235542,
-0.0418751314,
0.0439587459,
-0.0234266333,
0.0469228365,
0.0271400269,
-0.0298069194,
0.0021550041,
-0.0359690152,
-0.0501793697,
-0.0013945858,
2.487e-7,
-0.0494543724,
0.0171288885,
0.0387692042,
-0.0278947055,
0.027879918,
0.0138276946,
-0.0663165823,
-0.0084771775,
0.025812313,
-0.0063372925,
0.0620163865,
-0.0121351257,
0.0364577845,
0.0238045584,
-0.0942390561,
-0.0470194928,
-0.0791160911,
-0.0113458736,
-0.0191323776,
-0.0196709372,
0.0615792684,
0.0635534227,
0.0239421651,
-0.016098097,
0.0127439741,
-0.0299233403,
0.0332005471,
-0.0166957751,
-0.0080815833,
-0.0701897964,
-0.0083959857,
0.0279807523,
-0.0391667895,
0.0493709259,
-0.0650586262,
0.0183887538,
0.0748126805,
0.0354694985,
-0.0009164536,
-0.0271199122,
-0.0555940233,
0.0812762454,
0.0026038913,
0.0261153132,
0.0498142652,
-0.0137944352,
-0.0256190207,
-0.014303132,
-0.0546079576,
-0.0098105865,
-0.0239913631,
-0.046159368,
-0.0096360361,
-0.0194064863,
0.0109966295,
0.0529380403,
-0.0273018237,
-0.0536119454,
0.0100783138,
0.0562757179,
-0.0154808387,
-0.0414423086,
-0.0233955737,
-0.0580377951,
0.0000556044,
0.0149947172,
0.0150281461,
1.737443673e-34,
0.0424566939,
-0.0484810658,
-0.0049971743,
-0.0136000402,
-0.0188096818,
0.0132090496,
-0.0048232405,
-0.0141212838,
-0.0035282576,
0.0129050892,
-0.0174091347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04905v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04905v1 | Detecting Relevant Information in High-Volume Chat Logs: Keyphrase Extraction for Grooming and Drug Dealing Forensic Analysis | 2023-09-15T03:18:31 | 2023-09-15T03:18:31 | Jeovane Honório Alves, Horácio A. C. G. Pedroso, Rafael Honorio Venetikides, Joel E. M. Köster, Luiz Rodrigo Grochocki, Cinthia O. A. Freitas, Jean Paul Barddal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The growing use of digital communication platforms has given rise to various
criminal activities, such as grooming and drug dealing, which pose significant
challenges to law enforcement and forensic experts. This paper presents a
supervised keyphrase extraction approach to detect relevant information in
high-volume chat logs involving grooming and drug dealing for forensic
analysis. The proposed method, JointKPE++, builds upon the JointKPE keyphrase
extractor by employing improvements to handle longer texts effectively. We
evaluate JointKPE++ using BERT-based pre-trained models on grooming and drug
dealing datasets, including BERT, RoBERTa, SpanBERT, and BERTimbau. The results
show significant improvements over traditional approaches and demonstrate the
potential for JointKPE++ to aid forensic experts in efficiently detecting
keyphrases related to criminal activities. | [
0.0946374014,
0.0552986935,
-0.0092971409,
0.0183210094,
-0.0906055793,
0.0097826393,
0.0383241326,
0.0762335062,
0.0177698173,
-0.0739549696,
-0.0193888359,
-0.004919034,
-0.0572118014,
0.0568954162,
-0.0163158849,
-0.0266002286,
0.0135527812,
0.0315154679,
0.029256938,
0.0282658394,
0.0447422564,
0.016200535,
-0.0006981439,
0.0274408404,
-0.0403734073,
-0.0020226804,
-0.0443422534,
-0.0213821586,
0.0129585508,
0.0167926643,
0.0387707762,
0.0816715434,
-0.0233509112,
0.0294810962,
0.0000016117,
-0.0562063195,
-0.0368397422,
-0.022521548,
-0.0467989035,
0.0207280777,
0.0505066887,
-0.0016462757,
-0.007548491,
0.01136762,
-0.0544298775,
0.0036198071,
0.0288967639,
0.051013574,
0.0490735881,
0.0735677183,
-0.0344985388,
-0.053777758,
0.0162865352,
-0.0081779808,
-0.0016483669,
-0.0453305952,
0.074587971,
-0.0149515243,
-0.0164480321,
0.0229475684,
0.0486456454,
0.0013409595,
-0.0237683263,
-0.0188702606,
0.0303800404,
0.0001691536,
-0.0667320266,
-0.0640994608,
0.0038408488,
0.0358349942,
-0.0586681291,
-0.0006257317,
0.0470862091,
-0.0115322294,
0.0017128618,
0.0363771282,
-0.0099675544,
0.0208788775,
-0.0557662733,
-0.0008093842,
-0.0350048877,
-0.0082184654,
-0.0205838885,
0.0260505993,
-0.0368018486,
-0.0337026902,
0.0291627105,
-0.0439279601,
0.0126479166,
-0.0243158434,
-0.0121839391,
-0.0107816746,
0.0697626621,
-0.0020833751,
0.0324627459,
0.0128737241,
-0.0148333404,
-0.0347241387,
0.0474398062,
-0.1212563366,
-0.03588048,
-0.0465776585,
-0.0428242199,
0.0278576165,
-0.0125360824,
-0.0082949866,
0.0346872471,
0.0119849946,
-0.0126026357,
-0.0014375348,
-0.0397686586,
-0.0167263169,
-0.0287896413,
0.0312246755,
0.0028845116,
-0.0138108218,
-0.0521065556,
0.0208433848,
0.0327332877,
-0.0358333886,
0.0072232587,
-0.0045529311,
-0.0107845264,
0.0227709599,
0.057227198,
-0.0166545995,
-0.0457826443,
0.0350300819,
-0.0165983699,
0.0167175755,
-0.0081148362,
0.0237277932,
0.0837703496,
-0.0409425013,
0.0179826077,
0.0264769085,
-0.0077083334,
-0.0501498803,
0.001494823,
-0.0333208889,
-0.0554723553,
0.0118725365,
0.0038882177,
-0.0337916203,
0.0278333947,
-0.0195758287,
-0.0263781901,
0.0338070057,
-0.0081454571,
0.0081018349,
-0.0835553706,
0.0246119481,
-0.023411043,
0.0171591844,
0.003519854,
0.0137002245,
-0.0031376688,
0.0156404432,
-0.0255733076,
0.110753797,
0.0666453317,
-0.0362906754,
0.0008052305,
0.0670972168,
0.0036804685,
-0.0477053523,
0.0133003155,
0.000767447,
0.0353638269,
-0.0258427206,
-0.0253279898,
-0.000296857,
-0.0206723195,
-0.0028834457,
0.0017597681,
0.1241257936,
0.0305298269,
0.0367677957,
0.0097835939,
0.044432126,
0.0156096676,
-0.0058523524,
-0.0080476822,
-0.0669240206,
-0.0037583443,
-0.0117935147,
0.0225423165,
0.015650779,
0.0118424864,
0.0116857011,
-0.0201093778,
-0.0087118791,
-0.0218467284,
-0.0367491767,
0.0552703366,
-0.0015559169,
-0.0198329333,
0.0251307935,
0.0322997309,
-0.0070267329,
-0.0529341921,
-0.0727380961,
0.0066294684,
0.0651325807,
0.0169163216,
-0.0026520202,
-0.052103173,
-0.0017754962,
-0.0136788497,
0.0259588473,
-0.0486986376,
-0.0142226163,
0.0332892872,
-0.0171460789,
-0.0374142081,
0.0209369753,
0.0202123113,
-0.0384945944,
0.0360019766,
0.0106443875,
0.0415345803,
0.0120712854,
0.0297787581,
0.0059658447,
0.0018619582,
0.0075173113,
-0.0169834625,
0.0206436664,
0.0063456255,
0.0048839571,
-0.0269307401,
-0.0099453637,
0.0518196225,
-0.0045773815,
0.0112185851,
-0.0156250279,
0.0485400483,
-0.0107285799,
0.0439317338,
-0.0070276852,
0.0250156689,
-0.0262577236,
-0.0332653709,
-0.0174639095,
0.0093748309,
-0.0410864055,
0.0797821805,
-0.027294701,
-0.0019744232,
-0.0274279378,
0.0064876284,
-0.0153117981,
0.061923299,
0.0302612223,
-0.0148461107,
-0.055338148,
-0.0895429403,
0.0105990544,
0.0231843237,
0.0281059667,
0.0054985904,
-0.0277325548,
0.0282103587,
0.074215658,
0.0291324202,
-0.0437487476,
-0.0404886492,
-0.087278299,
0.0101910019,
-0.0170159582,
0.0334691182,
0.016589608,
0.0484953299,
-0.0364844762,
-0.0414533243,
-0.0158801079,
-0.0593362302,
0.0092768902,
0.0317577012,
0.0148501331,
0.0272482205,
-0.0188589841,
-0.0222877469,
-0.0112826554,
0.0061632479,
0.027453633,
-0.0001562078,
-0.0760378465,
0.0183791127,
0.0137435058,
0.003722284,
-0.0391314887,
-0.0209117346,
-0.0299755167,
0.0049047167,
-0.0447651334,
0.0208060462,
0.0223720353,
0.0812034383,
0.0204889327,
-0.0392038748,
-0.0390126742,
-0.0391848423,
-0.0309471246,
-0.0288986973,
-0.0019342769,
0.0125057995,
-0.0310322456,
0.0395939052,
0.027175514,
-0.011648057,
0.0012277681,
-0.0068668798,
-0.0293114334,
0.0291519612,
-0.002260813,
-0.022703696,
-0.0464037247,
-0.0042910869,
-0.0184633266,
-0.0171077549,
-0.0639592558,
0.042991437,
0.0016633885,
0.0385938995,
-0.0189747531,
-0.0450711623,
-0.010248729,
0.066951178,
-0.0044682696,
0.0264220666,
0.0155554041,
-0.079591997,
0.0869933292,
-0.0214861315,
0.0432572551,
-0.0601403899,
-0.0044884766,
-0.0061289202,
0.0142904846,
0.0221691933,
-0.0063724862,
-0.0303961504,
-0.107151337,
-0.0091817481,
-0.0623829886,
0.0179993995,
-0.021936303,
-0.0168861635,
0.0494815111,
-0.0262927879,
-0.0000903883,
-0.0260499623,
0.011341569,
0.0096437987,
0.052043315,
0.0250219218,
-0.0895997509,
-0.0388537012,
-0.0227141697,
-0.0178644601,
0.0448836349,
0.0053896788,
-0.0136525007,
0.0199805014,
0.0067951735,
-0.0023366665,
-0.0444763638,
-0.012417119,
-0.0276006497,
-0.0078263292,
-0.015706148,
0.0071525504,
0.0894467235,
0.0571529418,
-0.0369076319,
-0.0049169515,
0.0037331302,
-0.0491772182,
-0.0327148028,
0.0316360109,
-0.0809175596,
-0.0149596194,
-0.0071946355,
0.0247968491,
-0.0440044664,
-0.0384607054,
-0.015503116,
-0.0559730455,
0.0385224223,
0.0187350921,
-0.0090029147,
-0.041726619,
-0.0873299167,
-0.0275114682,
-0.0259677358,
0.0165573861,
-0.0317733139,
-0.0621514469,
0.0130363675,
0.0100790514,
-0.0714671686,
-0.0383743495,
0.0230709221,
-0.0644305348,
0.0196474716,
0.0166283771,
0.0410652123,
-0.0168570634,
0.0086623402,
0.0266984589,
0.0541794375,
0.0024332951,
0.0217199959,
0.0430707932,
-0.0387946479,
-0.0050055101,
-0.0695640892,
0.0205375496,
0.0165164135,
-0.0218067337,
0.046672985,
0.0133516686,
-0.0064512757,
-0.0197174288,
0.0167741403,
0.0042071785,
0.0018296886,
0.019142773,
0.0364598818,
0.0127225546,
-0.0149003789,
0.0308168568,
-0.0316753276,
0.008499966,
-0.0262500253,
-0.0403568037,
-0.0712664798,
-0.0044585876,
-0.0544781946,
-0.0307920408,
0.0376498327,
-0.0050755744,
-0.018318262,
-0.0054763183,
-0.0084466413,
0.0083807837,
-0.0701958463,
0.0243695267,
0.0288232844,
-0.0011405328,
-0.0301233772,
0.0290098637,
-0.0167723466,
-0.0176383294,
0.0099762809,
0.034573514,
-0.0242459737,
-0.0090044905,
0.0185713377,
-0.0019359248,
0.0161277894,
0.0335488543,
-0.0356032699,
-0.0422337539,
0.0033129791,
0.043206092,
-0.0171173494,
-0.0721578822,
0.0619879365,
0.0003720764,
-0.008549639,
-0.0005494877,
-0.0107579492,
0.0439175069,
0.0244504139,
-0.0357458666,
-0.074213475,
-0.0498449691,
0.0117427483,
0.0336228125,
0.0404809453,
0.0068500289,
-0.00447969,
-0.0167369414,
0.0042525902,
-0.0040947269,
0.0047780965,
0.0011258378,
0.0344868936,
0.0019377889,
-0.008314251,
-0.0166172553,
0.0581645966,
-0.0559073277,
0.0039839526,
-0.0741012841,
0.0072336742,
-0.0080871601,
-0.0032211384,
0.02536349,
-0.024079375,
-0.005643792,
-0.0009415908,
-0.0045125061,
0.0566715114,
-0.0329113007,
0.0205347314,
-0.0114564011,
-0.0153905274,
0.0131754996,
0.0513943806,
-0.0444182232,
0.0130606284,
-0.031402871,
0.0380828008,
0.063364774,
-0.0441339538,
0.0371692032,
-0.0055440012,
0.0042300671,
0.0046699699,
0.0510607585,
-0.0334402658,
-0.0224308576,
-0.0583076328,
0.0258725379,
-0.0601534024,
0.0316714458,
0.0491405278,
0.0179188997,
0.0246382151,
0.0216295253,
-0.0792278796,
-0.0176566187,
0.0074696876,
0.0846707672,
0.021544449,
-0.0174962711,
-0.0027010352,
-0.0021104433,
0.0060197026,
-0.0151773188,
-0.0590862744,
-0.0139336856,
0.0629081726,
-0.0045674304,
0.0791143104,
0.0133948112,
-0.0030725631,
-0.0372464843,
0.0388938002,
0.0415210836,
0.0060348809,
0.0302926116,
-5.559225393e-33,
0.0557615496,
-0.0202469043,
-0.0329739228,
0.0335735753,
-0.0250717402,
0.02443799,
0.0242696572,
-0.0239938069,
0.0121445581,
-0.0095937178,
-0.0403595865,
0.0245094635,
0.0209809672,
0.001044451,
0.0198489185,
-0.0004612988,
0.015189521,
0.0298023447,
0.008750367,
0.0137276025,
0.0339282975,
0.0907455757,
0.0965209156,
-0.0381907858,
0.0592310056,
-0.0059932023,
0.0030290345,
0.0163195506,
0.0295684095,
0.030409744,
-0.0362397134,
0.0072823432,
0.0203544497,
-0.0281124078,
-0.0128614483,
0.0208601989,
-0.0350156799,
0.0204344094,
-0.0090163806,
0.0238724612,
0.0510249957,
-0.0104099279,
0.0421097465,
-0.0276457798,
0.0313938819,
0.0344658159,
0.0469842516,
-0.0339523777,
-0.0407627001,
-0.0405599512,
-0.0319161825,
0.0455687493,
0.0000085547,
-0.0147368582,
0.0284063667,
0.0091643138,
0.005469399,
-0.0440811962,
-0.0478958525,
0.0034243152,
0.011907653,
-0.0011604655,
-0.0447642468,
0.0236800723,
0.0051980382,
0.0368406549,
0.0202427972,
-0.0517586879,
0.0168646872,
0.0215190537,
0.011782418,
0.1056916192,
0.0097928289,
0.0147463288,
0.071387127,
-0.0060535911,
-0.0656190589,
-0.0025057551,
0.1000875309,
0.00019388,
0.0273360126,
0.0154206101,
-0.0576198809,
0.0188928545,
0.0130047351,
0.0419632867,
-0.0028155881,
-0.0308817625,
-0.0282042548,
0.0152820498,
-0.0414244235,
0.0539793223,
0.007518623,
-0.0241304748,
-0.0132016959,
-0.0139971841,
-0.0144906659,
0.0139546404,
-0.0305665992,
0.0229192767,
-0.0335934684,
0.0012523761,
0.0721799284,
-0.0074180067,
-0.0044401055,
-0.0236771349,
0.0551796481,
-0.0221826285,
-0.0543331839,
-0.007433672,
0.0110772708,
0.016837066,
0.002106182,
0.0385478809,
0.0216721389,
0.0383786857,
-0.0066590626,
0.039332509,
0.0256246403,
0.0535645485,
0.0274290424,
-0.0161388908,
0.010364403,
0.0039104158,
0.0451621339,
-0.0032298944,
-0.0280612838,
-0.0057387617,
-0.0073548602,
-0.0145193925,
0.0065109585,
-0.0104640285,
2.499e-7,
0.0584390424,
0.0285168346,
0.0563169904,
-0.0131082246,
-0.0154201984,
0.0305543635,
0.0526968129,
0.0162868574,
-0.0121982135,
-0.0345716029,
0.0376403667,
0.0276223198,
0.0424598008,
0.0158773363,
-0.0614579767,
-0.0685836226,
-0.0734976307,
-0.0790877715,
-0.0853749365,
0.0090066651,
0.0432671234,
0.0557315499,
0.0487681925,
-0.0244639479,
-0.0128942681,
-0.0431584753,
0.0046328283,
-0.0265049823,
-0.0466322191,
0.0014812873,
0.0520786196,
-0.0022695204,
-0.0154867759,
0.0949303806,
0.0142506026,
0.0316522606,
0.0203248337,
0.0166606139,
-0.0102967508,
0.0087880045,
-0.0245099384,
-0.0710541755,
0.0054710736,
-0.0378882997,
0.1144758388,
-0.0057986365,
-0.0208154339,
-0.061902795,
-0.045799654,
-0.0219844021,
0.0200746786,
-0.0389525071,
-0.0083156787,
0.0591400154,
0.0267345589,
-0.0152524123,
-0.0161145777,
-0.0939970165,
0.036841467,
0.0249619521,
-0.0260725096,
0.0039923713,
-0.022040138,
-0.0035814205,
0.0466509648,
-0.0720584989,
0.0714185089,
2.201540437e-34,
-0.0085889632,
0.0163020305,
-0.0132395793,
0.0164890066,
0.0374449529,
0.0188803263,
0.0155370682,
-0.0165082607,
-0.0208365209,
-0.0627822354,
0.0241305344
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.