id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13513v1 | The Study of Perceptual Training of Chinese Mandarin Tones for Monolingual Speakers of English Using Adaptive Computer Based Training Software | 2023-09-24T00:20:16 | 2023-09-24T00:20:16 | Yuke Wang | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL, H.4.m | The study explored a new technique of phonetic tone training, which may have
a positive impact on second language learning and tone training. | [
0.0072588748,
-0.0062957853,
-0.014588844,
-0.003626853,
-0.0074832491,
-0.0332753621,
0.0271943808,
-0.043929588,
-0.0217346065,
0.056298703,
-0.1116715223,
-0.0174381807,
0.0393271782,
-0.0347721986,
0.0011177723,
-0.109979935,
-0.0010999286,
0.000347491,
0.0284538753,
-0.0361149907,
0.0519775562,
0.0009855917,
-0.0550415479,
0.02076081,
-0.0170123428,
-0.0556932203,
-0.0158591177,
0.0129059926,
0.0181879327,
-0.0360424444,
0.0399721414,
0.007088738,
0.0084296046,
-0.0033394201,
0.0000016232,
-0.061688561,
0.0328801684,
-0.0093006939,
0.0130614787,
0.0129722971,
0.0777032152,
0.0872922689,
-0.0394349806,
-0.0008977202,
-0.0021869419,
0.0034564531,
0.0458605886,
0.0207859222,
0.0090234317,
0.0063619148,
-0.0094162542,
-0.0124068018,
-0.0308031514,
0.0439564697,
-0.0440119989,
-0.0124258837,
-0.00416116,
-0.0127517963,
0.0182461329,
-0.0367739052,
-0.0111050457,
-0.0190983303,
-0.0089253942,
0.042380292,
-0.0370707884,
0.0198031459,
-0.0472606756,
0.0085193375,
-0.0469823666,
0.0199813191,
0.0052330988,
-0.0027223132,
-0.0248983875,
0.0049994309,
0.0199983884,
-0.0594444275,
0.0008154998,
-0.0147221684,
-0.0232445616,
-0.0122907059,
0.0196084268,
-0.0170356371,
-0.0187050346,
-0.0227242392,
0.0218369327,
-0.0105324611,
-0.0081018033,
-0.0818841979,
0.0088460166,
-0.0276289806,
0.0465644561,
0.0466504619,
0.0418342017,
0.0583245195,
-0.0036074577,
0.0080802096,
0.0287743323,
-0.0258484762,
-0.0112363501,
-0.0597778931,
0.0214251,
0.0009625445,
-0.0597835071,
-0.0254835617,
0.0091302041,
0.0232499819,
0.0498922393,
-0.0625591874,
-0.0505239516,
0.0155581012,
-0.024414679,
-0.0319082923,
-0.0692158863,
0.0304224417,
0.0503194258,
0.0122889606,
-0.052113127,
-0.0427996181,
-0.0173632707,
-0.0010497639,
-0.0122268125,
-0.0175490547,
-0.0654586554,
-0.0099873533,
0.0272375513,
0.050195653,
-0.0434911326,
0.0632162467,
-0.0595461056,
-0.0626783296,
0.0535701923,
0.0261370912,
0.0082400795,
0.0459094681,
0.0599169694,
0.0038410588,
-0.0411137044,
0.0254386514,
-0.0150397569,
0.0072862045,
-0.0232481938,
0.0137044741,
-0.0536178276,
-0.0522305258,
-0.058485575,
-0.0236841943,
0.0334011056,
0.0234786496,
-0.0227685589,
-0.0124365333,
0.0176249091,
-0.0547618903,
-0.0397633426,
0.0441595763,
0.0293670762,
-0.0153010329,
-0.0105490182,
0.044565849,
0.051788006,
-0.0609783269,
0.0227573011,
-0.0596804246,
-0.0406117514,
0.0418211333,
-0.0402496047,
-0.0196022522,
0.0324557498,
-0.0511456989,
-0.0282612164,
0.0119237937,
0.0436697081,
-0.013196026,
-0.043045152,
0.0273865461,
0.0292626061,
0.0322001763,
0.0622824766,
0.0489933193,
-0.0170483645,
-0.0142354919,
0.0488106981,
0.0841506273,
0.0242392235,
-0.0138926199,
-0.0392620601,
0.061209105,
-0.034463305,
0.0508438647,
-0.0296429265,
-0.0322292037,
-0.0056983335,
-0.0140729975,
0.0054786024,
-0.0048710615,
0.029804267,
0.0327759981,
0.0396631695,
-0.0056766015,
0.0295494311,
-0.0378664061,
0.0347207114,
0.0071076597,
-0.0669525638,
0.0742906705,
-0.0468987338,
-0.0562205911,
0.0485023297,
-0.0013328431,
-0.0341117978,
0.0365791582,
0.0031502284,
-0.0041837227,
-0.018128477,
-0.0581255145,
-0.0080931708,
0.0421941727,
-0.0253056772,
0.0196234509,
-0.0215160102,
0.0449075811,
-0.0507495366,
0.0383712947,
-0.0601588599,
-0.050586272,
-0.0058245836,
-0.0329856612,
0.0131558729,
-0.0013667579,
-0.0068709515,
0.0581951365,
-0.0435553826,
0.0167016238,
-0.0144049404,
0.0118706785,
0.035417635,
0.074213542,
-0.0620318651,
0.0132776191,
0.044027023,
-0.0222728681,
0.0041146949,
-0.0532032214,
0.0176823623,
-0.0563464239,
0.0185295511,
0.0029663974,
0.0290226154,
-0.0361475348,
0.0266396627,
-0.0405616574,
0.031380482,
0.0292689912,
-0.0272728279,
0.0342946984,
-0.0351631492,
0.0132212546,
0.0127212247,
-0.0183685124,
-0.0584885553,
-0.0589191169,
0.0104244677,
-0.0457185917,
0.0612680726,
-0.0136200432,
0.0021684754,
-0.0441686846,
0.0168184731,
-0.011775556,
0.0059569739,
0.0095099816,
0.0064066853,
0.0077699893,
-0.0281459317,
-0.003936437,
-0.0389290713,
-0.031510774,
0.0263538584,
-0.0486852042,
0.0043086647,
-0.0395109057,
-0.0648125336,
0.032758154,
0.0019353133,
-0.0071451585,
0.0155647472,
-0.0327217877,
-0.005041698,
-0.0200271141,
-0.0270840507,
0.0019878857,
0.0302844997,
0.0148872305,
0.0480510518,
-0.0378739946,
0.0229296647,
0.0120749325,
0.085265629,
0.0415918678,
-0.0032391681,
-0.0100277271,
0.0398915336,
-0.0049499208,
-0.0005755632,
0.003919859,
0.0222547781,
-0.03128355,
-0.0482482277,
-0.0297066197,
-0.0345078819,
0.022663204,
0.0713014826,
0.0339673758,
-0.0211705565,
-0.0344557427,
-0.0181276836,
-0.0103218928,
-0.0070354771,
-0.0422241986,
-0.0573060289,
-0.0525679216,
-0.0010224509,
-0.0159128383,
0.0402711965,
-0.011419978,
-0.0353246108,
-0.0733264461,
-0.0237991177,
0.0280766301,
-0.0543466881,
-0.0466257855,
0.0109487912,
0.0361858495,
-0.0591820851,
0.003039886,
0.001385822,
0.0875240266,
-0.0207084101,
-0.0157554559,
0.0172302816,
-0.0576378182,
0.0010562651,
0.009712467,
-0.0223441869,
0.0807797313,
-0.0241009779,
0.0432905033,
0.002011722,
0.0279257372,
0.0835568458,
0.0185859036,
0.0441898219,
0.0122736078,
0.0078855241,
0.0413911305,
0.0163813047,
-0.0155754704,
0.0062563247,
0.0663138777,
-0.0092378221,
-0.0051331287,
0.0726833045,
-0.0134043563,
0.015795825,
0.0172459409,
0.0036702873,
0.0357976295,
0.0119129242,
-0.0120466575,
-0.0267859269,
0.0367760733,
0.0085208844,
0.003107429,
0.0123031503,
0.0395992063,
0.0065786848,
-0.0548116155,
-0.0176493023,
-0.0180850998,
-0.0198552646,
0.0041114595,
-0.0321885906,
-0.0216719899,
0.0640655532,
0.005498495,
0.0310366675,
-0.0022770814,
0.058555942,
0.0295417253,
-0.0475912169,
0.0095898174,
0.0342616327,
-0.053011775,
0.0269258339,
-0.0286482573,
-0.0073661134,
0.0467055403,
0.0404002964,
0.0259317793,
-0.0205724798,
-0.0247081555,
0.0375235043,
-0.0627711043,
-0.0271402523,
-0.0236336626,
-0.0391409323,
0.0292487219,
0.0934071988,
-0.0091706347,
-0.0233362876,
-0.0317973495,
-0.025508197,
0.0051479097,
0.036872752,
-0.0327982903,
0.0298906118,
0.0618246496,
-0.0016770109,
-0.0090709589,
0.044031173,
0.0126645984,
-0.004912864,
0.0800806582,
-0.0040264889,
0.0362542868,
0.0178338476,
0.0082540857,
0.0781480744,
-0.0259307045,
0.0266941842,
0.0126802707,
-0.0757003799,
0.077936694,
-0.0108770663,
0.0123463692,
-0.0021197821,
-0.0299884882,
0.064358905,
-0.029824622,
0.0151129393,
-0.050626222,
-0.0266485475,
-0.0277712028,
0.0197451748,
0.0024032418,
0.0623669662,
0.004082242,
0.0297368076,
0.0043951692,
-0.0413872227,
0.0418056063,
0.072729148,
-0.0194048882,
-0.0350840166,
0.00374534,
-0.0787843689,
0.0227291919,
-0.0834969506,
0.0816889331,
-0.0232593697,
0.0436352603,
-0.0038761206,
-0.0016902034,
0.0443359353,
0.014595733,
-0.0210423358,
0.0014162331,
-0.0000208875,
0.0358287171,
0.0105041172,
0.0750718266,
-0.0056501981,
0.0195191894,
-0.0134664588,
0.0104889823,
0.01763984,
-0.0088561727,
0.0252848659,
0.0181221571,
-0.047773093,
0.0370800644,
0.0320258774,
0.0006507475,
-0.0111882482,
0.0191269647,
-0.05380027,
0.040110372,
0.0142576192,
0.0033601017,
0.0249401834,
-0.0137426052,
-0.0058390335,
0.0230296571,
-0.0096201319,
-0.0270971488,
0.0014518286,
-0.0590854138,
0.0079697585,
0.0708004907,
0.0092872959,
0.0663902387,
0.0026751712,
0.0235785265,
-0.0307488255,
0.0437466279,
0.0059065395,
0.0200626478,
0.0163027644,
0.0334533006,
-0.001793907,
-0.0264998861,
0.0226398837,
-0.0022452925,
0.0081936549,
0.0333356559,
-0.0213583615,
-0.0110822124,
0.062113449,
-0.0054737255,
-0.0005017558,
0.0001453436,
0.018628601,
-0.0041778935,
-0.0467360094,
-0.0237933453,
-0.0004627327,
0.0195603259,
-0.0164021403,
-0.011454219,
-0.032698825,
0.0182862952,
-0.0670564771,
-0.0027316897,
0.0013667516,
0.0176511239,
-0.0111881904,
-0.0223410595,
-0.0026187319,
0.0353955775,
-0.0442000814,
0.040927317,
0.0000965856,
-0.0525635965,
0.0450639278,
0.0163427312,
0.026094215,
-0.0263545979,
0.0122068711,
-0.0121417362,
-0.0423379429,
0.0170544088,
0.0187006779,
-0.0047576684,
0.013793679,
0.0187244546,
0.0320665203,
-5.50987263e-33,
0.0163668785,
0.0102345133,
0.0338713415,
0.0755844191,
0.0024405727,
0.015832426,
-0.0097686537,
0.0331218988,
-0.047359243,
-0.0109253386,
0.0155166714,
-0.0493495725,
0.0052327211,
-0.0161322523,
-0.0166017581,
0.0688366592,
0.0356943682,
-0.0063871932,
0.0296394043,
-0.0335782841,
0.019879723,
-0.0183670297,
0.0880648643,
-0.0161962751,
-0.0176126789,
0.0022361311,
-0.0221554562,
-0.0215632915,
-0.002238337,
0.0375195853,
0.0333835818,
0.0691268966,
0.0137155745,
0.0043814583,
-0.0150582585,
-0.0476468503,
-0.1080056354,
-0.0360855684,
-0.004714943,
0.0619891286,
0.0060590417,
0.0067481799,
-0.0194596685,
-0.0060289935,
-0.0104962662,
-0.0087318998,
0.0270966012,
-0.0579701513,
0.0026956338,
-0.001835769,
-0.0238450132,
0.0009534557,
0.0239506047,
0.0350502953,
0.0101034073,
0.038823504,
-0.0871245861,
-0.0834839419,
-0.0428357385,
0.0412953645,
0.0725806728,
0.0306529421,
-0.0012888142,
0.0470511615,
0.0175496656,
-0.0636797622,
0.0673379302,
-0.0177362394,
0.0543530881,
0.0068723192,
0.0837436467,
-0.0407201909,
0.0039076069,
0.032152541,
0.0154021634,
-0.0001176826,
0.0149057163,
-0.00047614,
0.0434350148,
-0.0201139934,
-0.0140059264,
0.0570037328,
-0.0165524129,
-0.0266879108,
-0.0174139272,
-0.0179522093,
-0.0422459319,
-0.0678587258,
0.0173100997,
-0.0177497864,
0.0235927496,
-0.02154788,
0.0109078186,
-0.0045709508,
-0.0114772143,
-0.0717282668,
-0.0285157226,
-0.0171116926,
-0.0092440285,
0.0286987759,
-0.0757015422,
0.019603679,
0.0153815122,
0.0190719087,
-0.0055908072,
0.0399428383,
0.0194103513,
-0.0016555892,
-0.0306824502,
0.0106264036,
0.0263140444,
-0.0353408642,
0.089336358,
-0.0064921104,
-0.0309778024,
0.009853933,
-0.0259963423,
0.0436133966,
0.0137934554,
-0.0982772186,
-0.0611568727,
-0.0238536019,
-0.0165695753,
0.0437238514,
-0.0406555459,
0.0168524347,
-0.0266104061,
-0.0386968367,
-0.010190798,
-0.0386014804,
-0.0356462859,
0.0031441865,
2.386e-7,
-0.0289869402,
-0.022688238,
0.0306493714,
0.0714562461,
0.0364743248,
-0.0526016131,
-0.056829147,
0.0138234962,
0.0531845205,
0.0812834948,
0.0074880216,
0.0130998921,
0.0141530624,
0.0386482589,
-0.0188861992,
-0.002582426,
-0.0721499994,
0.010172816,
-0.0053257174,
0.0963522866,
0.0298815761,
-0.0064471122,
-0.0667997301,
-0.0307597034,
0.010411974,
-0.0039417874,
-0.0150359813,
0.013662532,
0.0663999319,
0.0175268129,
-0.0187600907,
0.0150880031,
-0.027515348,
0.0277566947,
-0.0494272262,
0.0447162092,
-0.0338792913,
0.015321862,
-0.0092685809,
-0.0045210766,
0.0479607135,
0.0567553006,
-0.0182135142,
0.020199202,
0.0030077391,
0.0374772251,
0.0230305307,
0.0060914191,
0.0079705222,
-0.0295202397,
0.0034466027,
-0.0452617295,
-0.0047796518,
-0.0109221917,
-0.0308899097,
0.0406700633,
-0.0411991999,
0.0761295632,
-0.016261762,
0.0284440927,
0.0133122252,
-0.0625794604,
0.0111598978,
-0.0577280372,
-0.0884970725,
0.0338570848,
0.0008388804,
1.204844631e-34,
-0.0117392708,
-0.0681973845,
0.0584774092,
0.0485107973,
-0.0141986404,
-0.0191782359,
0.040279571,
0.0151142608,
0.0436630845,
-0.024585491,
-0.0540785529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15074v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15074v2 | Natural Language based Context Modeling and Reasoning for Ubiquitous Computing with Large Language Models: A Tutorial | 2023-09-24T00:15:39 | 2023-12-26T07:42:13 | Haoyi Xiong, Jiang Bian, Sijia Yang, Xiaofei Zhang, Linghe Kong, Daqing Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.NI | Large language models (LLMs) have become phenomenally surging, since
2018--two decades after introducing context-awareness into computing systems.
Through taking into account the situations of ubiquitous devices, users and the
societies, context-aware computing has enabled a wide spectrum of innovative
applications, such as assisted living, location-based social network services
and so on. To recognize contexts and make decisions for actions accordingly,
various artificial intelligence technologies, such as Ontology and OWL, have
been adopted as representations for context modeling and reasoning. Recently,
with the rise of LLMs and their improved natural language understanding and
reasoning capabilities, it has become feasible to model contexts using natural
language and perform context reasoning by interacting with LLMs such as ChatGPT
and GPT-4. In this tutorial, we demonstrate the use of texts, prompts, and
autonomous agents (AutoAgents) that enable LLMs to perform context modeling and
reasoning without requiring fine-tuning of the model. We organize and introduce
works in the related field, and name this computing paradigm as the LLM-driven
Context-aware Computing (LCaC). In the LCaC paradigm, users' requests, sensors
reading data, and the command to actuators are supposed to be represented as
texts. Given the text of users' request and sensor data, the AutoAgent models
the context by prompting and sends to the LLM for context reasoning. LLM
generates a plan of actions and responds to the AutoAgent, which later follows
the action plan to foster context-awareness. To prove the concepts, we use two
showcases--(1) operating a mobile z-arm in an apartment for assisted living,
and (2) planning a trip and scheduling the itinerary in a context-aware and
personalized manner. | [
0.0480964854,
-0.0250408687,
-0.0205432717,
0.0435410216,
-0.0744483545,
-0.0155579681,
0.0283456221,
-0.0290867276,
0.0552327931,
-0.082384266,
0.0222654603,
0.0424324088,
-0.0119204847,
0.0158464126,
-0.0106735788,
-0.0231634546,
0.0202700477,
-0.0139135718,
0.0114118047,
0.0304790363,
0.0146704055,
0.0232256185,
-0.0269595776,
0.0428536721,
-0.0119557502,
-0.0274946857,
-0.0236772802,
-0.0211664718,
0.0070772092,
-0.0486272424,
-0.0160567816,
0.0239704885,
0.0588744916,
0.0129668312,
0.0000020473,
-0.0784227625,
-0.0302635692,
0.0045755468,
-0.0219996348,
-0.0641235337,
0.0481754169,
0.0509309359,
-0.0040741554,
0.019350376,
-0.0550702699,
0.0229072571,
0.0237045195,
0.0392519124,
0.021315366,
0.032200262,
-0.0153997084,
-0.0187297892,
0.0048155915,
0.0380284414,
0.0485496707,
-0.0385302156,
0.0079748547,
-0.0292537529,
0.0774295181,
0.0376790576,
0.0204761643,
0.0068954644,
0.0037254617,
0.0165022947,
-0.0026318959,
0.0140548265,
-0.0169638079,
-0.0038002806,
-0.0430414267,
0.0299574919,
0.0446236059,
-0.0083268061,
0.0591172576,
0.0280464739,
-0.0145047689,
-0.0021534071,
-0.0359065644,
0.0083954874,
-0.0000774499,
-0.0022308521,
0.022875566,
0.0313589722,
0.0060067051,
0.0200040527,
-0.0001034152,
0.1045782939,
-0.014864292,
-0.0032385404,
-0.0434756093,
-0.0261005089,
0.0120155392,
-0.065520905,
0.041707281,
0.0938396081,
-0.0645949468,
0.0389332511,
-0.0048297602,
0.0146286245,
0.0067386706,
-0.0458240248,
-0.0211583916,
0.0487114005,
-0.0011912768,
0.0338547118,
0.033236593,
0.0251685921,
-0.011031148,
-0.0168817174,
-0.0345161594,
-0.0010469978,
-0.060786169,
-0.0071740756,
-0.0439969935,
0.0241267588,
-0.0662366152,
-0.028070746,
-0.0119342888,
0.0603538901,
-0.0047411923,
0.0134261921,
-0.0474900939,
0.0352271795,
0.0010697297,
-0.0214937162,
-0.0348653346,
-0.0205110777,
-0.019566169,
0.0284955427,
-0.0064378558,
-0.0415608734,
0.049501583,
0.0112678958,
0.0445105769,
0.0100212945,
-0.0560072772,
0.0906749144,
0.0192026664,
-0.0376732498,
-0.0330971815,
-0.0568947755,
-0.0036659902,
-0.0374211855,
-0.0400286876,
-0.0896808207,
0.0076683462,
0.0268642884,
-0.0219469573,
-0.0012480603,
0.0199589394,
0.0428840742,
0.0021732133,
0.0873523131,
-0.0196748637,
0.0147152869,
0.081949167,
0.0213188846,
0.0127320411,
0.0063207969,
0.0485194437,
0.0443554744,
0.0376396738,
0.0312066507,
0.0023085298,
0.0167214479,
-0.0681430027,
-0.0515164956,
0.0489563197,
0.0254387911,
-0.0237385444,
0.0330022201,
-0.09661562,
0.0285172705,
0.0020378777,
0.0496250093,
0.0474006869,
0.1181499362,
0.0074052396,
0.0055812369,
0.0117111318,
0.036121916,
-0.047782734,
-0.0479750969,
-0.0358524881,
0.0211521257,
-0.087568298,
-0.0216777101,
0.0011755556,
-0.0025144902,
-0.0070607569,
-0.0622429326,
-0.0275206156,
-0.0297213085,
0.0361035801,
-0.0062043774,
0.0335058235,
-0.0385024101,
-0.0055066482,
-0.0195229314,
-0.017938856,
-0.0285671949,
-0.0125974687,
-0.0600657798,
0.0664080083,
0.1065876707,
0.0413958468,
-0.0384491831,
0.0068758712,
0.0117948884,
0.014752673,
-0.0141385049,
0.0137478067,
-0.0082556233,
-0.0194653273,
-0.0109176282,
-0.0353047177,
0.0269072484,
0.0125452997,
-0.0061181397,
-0.0271945391,
0.0338292196,
0.0271321572,
0.0167955272,
-0.0089396108,
0.0111998953,
0.0036469605,
-0.0326596871,
-0.0324409194,
0.0483573787,
0.0226733461,
0.0499811433,
0.0267041326,
0.0124218743,
0.023460485,
-0.0264660865,
-0.0223915726,
0.0430883989,
-0.0709319636,
0.013297407,
0.0223556533,
0.0077983108,
0.0126920948,
-0.0075398209,
-0.0198501181,
-0.0394812673,
0.0009965327,
-0.0214793514,
0.028123185,
-0.0291092116,
0.0024005116,
0.0177241024,
-0.0289648678,
-0.0159993768,
0.0714675337,
0.0289518107,
-0.0222652741,
0.0170614813,
0.0633264855,
0.0274880659,
-0.0312825814,
0.0143475924,
-0.0327392854,
-0.0033904284,
0.0364271402,
0.0492736474,
0.045945581,
-0.0204076227,
0.0230861306,
-0.1078084633,
0.0104421843,
-0.0434163958,
-0.0095850332,
0.019159548,
0.0410291106,
0.0008983643,
-0.0311899409,
-0.0104811974,
0.0386020467,
0.0086209085,
0.0133008109,
0.0334365517,
0.0094324863,
-0.0514847301,
-0.0259253345,
0.0393555053,
-0.036201708,
0.0046785753,
0.0324260555,
-0.0362009592,
-0.0453290157,
0.0022369623,
-0.0067992797,
0.0187768526,
0.0003186931,
0.0145899067,
0.0593970418,
-0.0552145168,
0.013010636,
0.0403407961,
-0.0181493536,
0.0466403626,
0.0345039181,
-0.020630477,
-0.0528863929,
-0.0106334835,
-0.0246998928,
0.0105795814,
-0.0312307552,
-0.0299539492,
0.0428324528,
0.0279194452,
0.0048579159,
0.0076264711,
-0.0094135972,
-0.0038154495,
-0.0182245225,
0.010155282,
-0.0379397757,
0.0040684845,
-0.0339085013,
0.0976716056,
0.0113119306,
-0.0222332366,
0.0479162149,
-0.0099198772,
0.0132834055,
-0.0469059832,
-0.0529029742,
-0.0377223939,
0.0779520199,
-0.0066389912,
0.0284741297,
0.0270952955,
-0.0295630917,
-0.0068591759,
-0.0272310842,
-0.008284742,
-0.0393069759,
0.0010353514,
-0.0841852054,
0.0216683634,
0.0232992489,
-0.0329515561,
-0.0389269777,
0.0213899873,
-0.0677330196,
-0.0016092325,
-0.052688621,
0.0043907277,
-0.00051397,
0.0032010535,
-0.0000186267,
0.0918973833,
0.0288226735,
-0.0289922114,
-0.0470236801,
0.0064454968,
0.0284085162,
0.0526486002,
-0.0366826579,
0.0820234716,
0.004813144,
0.0327570476,
0.0085898507,
-0.0241575446,
-0.0387569331,
0.0391307361,
0.0214803703,
-0.0133060431,
-0.0055351229,
0.0767569542,
0.0401257537,
-0.0360809304,
-0.0093319248,
0.1232304871,
0.0542618223,
-0.0221688356,
0.0102868984,
-0.050640732,
-0.0588167086,
0.0094487071,
0.0379876643,
-0.0618442819,
-0.0490940288,
-0.0074720508,
-0.006485675,
0.0084500918,
-0.015042779,
-0.0102488734,
-0.0490601845,
0.0276278462,
-0.0108824866,
-0.034665361,
-0.0044239974,
-0.0269112065,
0.0185418874,
-0.0145909144,
-0.0181289036,
-0.0138945673,
-0.0014941015,
-0.0329442993,
-0.0400900505,
-0.0479440019,
-0.043106623,
0.0313785709,
-0.0349585004,
0.0668159053,
0.0620424747,
0.0643613189,
0.0367191061,
-0.0165729411,
-0.0012127825,
0.0230098758,
0.0458475687,
-0.0479713604,
-0.0680585578,
0.006704614,
0.0261673294,
-0.0441084988,
0.0585491322,
-0.0626581833,
-0.0646900088,
0.029056251,
0.0643755943,
-0.0418645665,
0.019026259,
-0.0611982308,
0.0126791382,
0.061576914,
0.0509297177,
-0.0248816852,
-0.0296440236,
-0.0373659693,
-0.0474635474,
-0.0371226035,
0.0438283011,
-0.0066369539,
-0.0274348706,
-0.0273568612,
-0.0400017425,
-0.0605071969,
-0.0003321002,
0.0567757376,
0.0123591479,
0.021116605,
0.0240913872,
0.0580577999,
0.0353543237,
-0.0220469795,
-0.0045498088,
-0.0136139523,
0.0257686432,
-0.0023681542,
0.0137493499,
0.0264982264,
-0.0592927076,
-0.0062229647,
0.0307813175,
-0.0090688318,
-0.051916644,
0.0143412855,
0.0354355536,
0.027204182,
0.0302627385,
-0.0236146171,
-0.0187918525,
-0.0048241094,
0.0448479056,
-0.0517838262,
-0.0011453289,
-0.0137844859,
0.0605025627,
0.020809954,
0.0201830566,
-0.061455138,
0.0316796526,
-0.0605724305,
0.0320483521,
-0.0739376992,
-0.0300981216,
0.0268342346,
0.0060170772,
-0.0108579602,
-0.003127648,
-0.0126580773,
-0.0164877623,
0.0103915213,
-0.0339314118,
-0.0274693556,
-0.0183802117,
0.0024737194,
-0.059341561,
0.0116928257,
0.0445064753,
-0.0187995676,
-0.0385725163,
-0.0219332632,
0.0019946229,
0.0204282962,
0.0157131571,
0.0473309606,
0.0155036822,
0.0253563393,
-0.0111070378,
0.0210343301,
-0.0172947235,
0.0248815343,
-0.0435334854,
0.0676703826,
0.0075884042,
-0.0372169167,
-0.0591300279,
0.0571482815,
-0.040136274,
-0.0568581149,
0.0584973469,
0.0801011696,
0.0151762087,
-0.0004675373,
-0.0281456541,
-0.0910768732,
0.0134959137,
-0.0079345265,
0.0220089704,
0.0376510695,
-0.0217138398,
0.0173921064,
0.0246599242,
-0.0017518623,
-0.0172347315,
0.021111181,
-0.0171279516,
-0.0135376146,
0.0216125399,
-0.0833048671,
-0.0585414879,
0.0062519014,
0.0059907692,
0.0433826745,
-0.0413301289,
-0.0002648823,
-0.0219222289,
-0.0238297954,
0.0068618036,
0.024831282,
-0.0202983916,
-0.0141255129,
0.0538738593,
0.0304864123,
0.0011294445,
-0.0448880978,
-0.0114212409,
-0.0003362038,
-0.070778437,
-0.0130836936,
-0.0301477071,
-5.70619084e-33,
-0.0117927939,
-0.0679158792,
0.0508255512,
0.0235156026,
0.0260739438,
-0.0503880903,
-0.0287230797,
0.0041245329,
-0.0036379285,
-0.0167804286,
-0.0116907209,
-0.0028829533,
0.0124133537,
0.0041296631,
-0.0090901973,
-0.0246864613,
0.0228426643,
0.0007679152,
-0.0018235062,
0.0037807769,
0.0369127207,
-0.0043596798,
-0.0013650736,
-0.098758243,
0.0348779894,
-0.0442236885,
-0.0138449427,
0.0379246809,
-0.0185566284,
0.0083002467,
-0.0542400219,
0.0611465797,
0.0390613563,
0.0213613939,
0.008248168,
0.1036901176,
-0.0662681907,
-0.0583447888,
0.0269258488,
0.0199246332,
-0.0401017517,
-0.0332034752,
-0.0033765698,
0.0011097925,
-0.0466905385,
0.0763745084,
0.0580195077,
-0.0147027867,
-0.0188418478,
0.0399939977,
-0.0513952076,
-0.0117933927,
-0.0062612719,
-0.0277426634,
-0.011937594,
-0.0288178548,
-0.0120943971,
0.019190276,
-0.0409247167,
0.0247880183,
-0.0207974575,
-0.0101175671,
0.0390943959,
-0.0153034255,
-0.0011078416,
0.0403861813,
-0.00703457,
-0.0077408962,
-0.0242689736,
-0.0014747204,
-0.03865714,
0.0754704252,
-0.0167953745,
0.0342026614,
-0.010469663,
0.0023362162,
-0.0527271107,
0.0281428695,
0.0036160129,
0.0280795507,
0.0413292497,
0.0311932396,
-0.0370898768,
0.0008474764,
-0.0004855555,
0.0151899736,
-0.0392503291,
-0.0137712481,
0.0281206481,
0.0157093462,
-0.0158612914,
-0.0113875158,
-0.0176945571,
-0.0205725785,
-0.0244005974,
-0.0234314315,
0.0444943346,
-0.0176572371,
-0.001272162,
0.042050086,
-0.0094122877,
-0.0117251603,
-0.0227156524,
0.0026188802,
0.0295299571,
0.0063679661,
-0.024728125,
0.0633059144,
0.011686584,
0.0090054935,
-0.0100551685,
0.0001429658,
-0.0041616727,
-0.0121134846,
0.022319844,
-0.0143934125,
-0.0241577569,
0.0744673982,
-0.0072936541,
-0.0463830009,
-0.0081071919,
-0.0291569866,
-0.0107352138,
-0.0346569009,
-0.0213112794,
0.0081615383,
-0.0547340699,
0.0522312187,
0.0495386906,
-0.0124409301,
-0.0067132637,
0.0133848293,
2.821e-7,
-0.0130211692,
0.0168356989,
-0.003250699,
-0.0047687092,
0.0358746126,
0.049692601,
0.0093446122,
0.0437733047,
-0.0273265652,
0.044228483,
0.0186835714,
0.0057405741,
0.0173142049,
-0.0202670135,
-0.0543322079,
0.0240070596,
0.0117341867,
-0.0080023129,
-0.093971014,
0.065372251,
0.0937102363,
0.0249426458,
-0.0000189091,
0.0149575174,
-0.0016668977,
-0.0551391952,
-0.0149471108,
-0.0706040487,
0.0388196707,
-0.0109834215,
-0.0077317022,
0.0471060015,
-0.0076012285,
-0.038659364,
-0.0023390758,
0.0047597899,
-0.0168795269,
0.0539420694,
-0.032197278,
-0.0175863989,
0.0092643946,
-0.053653203,
-0.0060166931,
-0.0435072258,
0.0669056103,
-0.0328780897,
0.0038005309,
-0.0045086932,
0.0201125909,
-0.0292143319,
-0.0575747751,
0.0205379296,
-0.0171863567,
-0.0400408879,
-0.0112148104,
-0.019121442,
-0.0101812147,
-0.0797095671,
0.025084313,
0.0078559024,
-0.0147468606,
-0.0218608305,
-0.0530412011,
0.0021478119,
0.0301082954,
-0.048780147,
-0.0091084884,
2.143523132e-34,
-0.0253997743,
0.038158346,
-0.0284408834,
0.0353066362,
0.0284366701,
0.0361297652,
0.0014025065,
0.0402208082,
0.053997077,
-0.0512360744,
-0.0329837836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05629v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05629v1 | Experimental Evidence on Negative Impact of Generative AI on Scientific Learning Outcomes | 2023-09-23T21:59:40 | 2023-09-23T21:59:40 | Qirui Ju | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | In this study, I explored the impact of Generative AI on learning efficacy in
academic reading materials using experimental methods. College-educated
participants engaged in three cycles of reading and writing tasks. After each
cycle, they responded to comprehension questions related to the material. After
adjusting for background knowledge and demographic factors, complete reliance
on AI for writing tasks led to a 25.1% reduction in accuracy. In contrast,
AI-assisted reading resulted in a 12% decline. Interestingly, using AI for
summarization significantly improved both quality and output. Accuracy
exhibited notable variance in the AI-assisted section. Further analysis
revealed that individuals with a robust background in the reading topic and
superior reading/writing skills benefitted the most. I conclude the research by
discussing educational policy implications, emphasizing the need for educators
to warn students about the dangers of over-dependence on AI and provide
guidance on its optimal use in educational settings. | [
0.0185805429,
-0.0014769791,
-0.0475822166,
-0.0544448644,
-0.0369905233,
0.0167025216,
0.0742615089,
-0.0337287374,
0.0273338445,
-0.0217318796,
-0.011159908,
0.0467458852,
0.0205643196,
0.0253990497,
0.0143654589,
-0.0386664122,
0.014638369,
0.0023754628,
0.0615337901,
0.0096119475,
-0.0036952188,
0.0140572572,
-0.0534098111,
0.0381750427,
-0.0157721732,
-0.0674934834,
0.0320090503,
-0.0357650518,
0.005154165,
-0.0208898447,
0.0130048497,
0.0333990492,
-0.0002370869,
0.0025779852,
0.0000020697,
-0.0483315736,
0.0026913285,
0.023020288,
-0.0323245898,
0.0067314617,
0.0473681428,
0.0467083827,
0.0226972811,
0.0056815175,
-0.0498865098,
0.0232771765,
0.0159559976,
-0.0051521161,
-0.0448448025,
0.0062265424,
-0.0045772083,
-0.013285934,
0.0845649019,
0.0329169631,
0.0389812216,
0.0212470163,
-0.0104271313,
0.0380469896,
0.0381093845,
0.0217445511,
-0.0189976115,
0.0660129264,
-0.0006192452,
-0.0398384854,
0.0437181592,
0.0599570498,
0.0253818445,
0.0060719489,
0.0332927778,
0.0227030851,
0.0690353885,
-0.0223442875,
-0.0218742974,
-0.0158941653,
0.0277882926,
0.0653450042,
-0.0853412002,
0.0336296558,
-0.0304454025,
-0.0205501039,
0.0412935428,
-0.0223855823,
-0.0095402505,
0.0483116247,
0.0207271539,
0.0051600426,
-0.0041270335,
-0.0431154519,
-0.0287221298,
0.0492462926,
0.0218101963,
-0.0144777615,
0.0081231659,
0.0504331812,
-0.0042439997,
0.0314160548,
-0.0376186445,
-0.0930125564,
0.0005442986,
0.0136955082,
0.0407093428,
0.0573719144,
0.0323424861,
-0.0160347726,
0.0035958206,
0.0409568921,
0.0230324082,
0.0419196747,
0.0050143977,
0.0645417646,
-0.0422847979,
-0.0606891178,
-0.0270154681,
0.0487999767,
0.0055254642,
-0.0215094127,
-0.017227266,
-0.0155591117,
-0.0042456058,
-0.0044292044,
-0.050902456,
0.001644937,
-0.0556125715,
0.0233412273,
-0.0204787496,
0.0149731012,
-0.0391036309,
0.0432887375,
0.0032421066,
-0.0134309316,
0.0018967417,
0.0110481344,
0.0015949112,
-0.001741502,
-0.0093240123,
0.0178023539,
-0.0271651521,
-0.0585205331,
-0.047786925,
-0.0270184837,
0.0331270397,
-0.0523389913,
0.0091326218,
-0.0327012502,
0.0079432325,
0.0373960547,
-0.0091564404,
-0.0693453997,
-0.0200738627,
0.0177524239,
0.0224489141,
-0.0074414127,
-0.0427493155,
0.0147287855,
0.0889932513,
0.0175126623,
-0.0322079323,
0.0028756559,
0.0767203644,
-0.0259536952,
-0.0169749819,
-0.0045115105,
0.0492972285,
-0.0301483274,
-0.016298892,
-0.0034547616,
0.0253024362,
-0.0407581292,
-0.0498771444,
0.01889343,
-0.0027446924,
0.0288441554,
-0.0204745363,
0.0850062966,
0.074747771,
0.0745701864,
-0.0057859044,
0.0652965531,
0.0243875626,
0.0166203827,
0.0803538188,
0.0744892508,
-0.0121340388,
0.0330907181,
-0.0330872945,
0.0344493724,
0.002565166,
-0.0038997959,
0.0065741567,
-0.1006853655,
0.0122519275,
0.0293924734,
-0.0193912722,
0.019106796,
0.0311854947,
0.003503903,
-0.0070319809,
-0.1071176082,
-0.0266654454,
-0.0477550142,
0.0268297903,
-0.0377631262,
0.0624299683,
0.0976243466,
0.0781327933,
-0.0415291749,
-0.0101292161,
-0.0120378705,
-0.0066629988,
0.0449272916,
-0.0034665295,
-0.0223952755,
-0.032508824,
-0.0111256074,
-0.0114360992,
-0.0298622213,
0.0026567304,
0.0042716716,
0.0063922424,
0.0399266928,
-0.0042529982,
-0.00950824,
-0.0685673878,
0.0467299633,
-0.1133382991,
-0.0729143023,
-0.0420605764,
-0.0184373837,
-0.0110627217,
0.0185343493,
-0.0355871841,
0.0317645632,
-0.0096952301,
0.017008625,
-0.0179521739,
-0.0005403019,
-0.047161445,
0.0289707016,
0.0062452038,
-0.0634933785,
-0.0185484644,
-0.0095791332,
0.0391798653,
-0.0252711102,
0.0523169376,
-0.0368255153,
0.01237767,
0.0223514643,
-0.0017307434,
-0.0368579291,
-0.0205422975,
-0.0298917945,
0.0128926961,
0.0161959659,
-0.0011963105,
0.0177440755,
0.0202271007,
-0.0253840536,
0.0119823478,
0.00378984,
-0.003509477,
0.0345926248,
-0.0074526742,
0.0184913855,
-0.033930853,
-0.0539478026,
0.0257210527,
-0.0381719992,
-0.0247920249,
0.0245718006,
0.0034755822,
0.0148159759,
-0.0449412391,
-0.0313730799,
0.0472338907,
0.0173851661,
-0.0097632604,
-0.0125980079,
0.0022676524,
0.0022800968,
-0.0001101894,
0.0338210315,
-0.0595541596,
-0.0087368237,
-0.0405897833,
0.0051417341,
0.1434280872,
0.0273615327,
-0.047127977,
0.0313252583,
0.028731769,
-0.0242170505,
0.0179702975,
-0.0051927753,
0.0454174168,
-0.0170688238,
0.0782601312,
0.0675671995,
0.0197331645,
0.0036779586,
0.0529675484,
0.005741131,
-0.0538147762,
0.0081399819,
0.015034494,
0.0463419855,
0.0269873831,
-0.0531771965,
-0.0129197463,
-0.0092718992,
0.044427041,
-0.003969044,
0.0194262788,
0.053876292,
-0.0496078171,
-0.0618017204,
-0.0201699752,
-0.053227976,
-0.0353840813,
0.0317946933,
-0.0033950738,
-0.0346542858,
0.0606695749,
0.0319356993,
0.0197643321,
-0.0673889667,
0.0584141947,
0.0147888344,
0.0140250092,
-0.0162289627,
0.0016844608,
0.0032690929,
0.0004839941,
-0.0644716397,
0.0228108261,
0.0361135714,
-0.0057107266,
0.0488012396,
-0.0702270865,
-0.0074685928,
0.0054442422,
0.0314848199,
-0.0364107974,
0.0359924957,
0.0351918899,
-0.0340133682,
0.059804067,
-0.0301938113,
-0.0344600305,
-0.0643952042,
0.0928846076,
0.0408361107,
-0.0432169028,
-0.0385077335,
0.0082019549,
0.0138129229,
0.0189587474,
-0.0462729409,
-0.0065542762,
-0.0520261936,
0.0357615426,
0.0381231792,
-0.0183771811,
0.0004466179,
-0.0257263444,
-0.0329689495,
0.0187612399,
-0.0565621294,
-0.0073576453,
0.0007480973,
0.0313075036,
-0.0214747991,
0.0056648306,
0.0621860102,
0.0122151896,
-0.0388303064,
-0.022781413,
-0.0227643251,
-0.0110683311,
-0.0153142121,
0.0351834483,
-0.0319895074,
0.0392843075,
-0.0078663332,
0.0712270588,
-0.0411695801,
-0.0405513011,
0.0139260115,
-0.0615895092,
0.0337826014,
0.0075985948,
-0.0214581937,
-0.0118129188,
-0.0293922797,
-0.0043710154,
0.0275060982,
0.0038456151,
-0.0106485914,
-0.0110606495,
0.0492526405,
0.0240624771,
-0.0072583593,
-0.0150730191,
-0.0459973402,
0.0393695608,
0.0246786084,
0.0365689434,
0.0330796465,
-0.0376855955,
-0.0172112565,
-0.0117130065,
0.0369510613,
0.012020479,
-0.0019547241,
0.062593177,
-0.0063614557,
0.0569811314,
-0.0712788329,
0.0325162932,
0.005631411,
-0.0467112102,
0.0592218712,
0.0266191009,
0.0085043469,
-0.0235731341,
-0.059581466,
-0.0149356574,
0.0063349619,
0.0150781116,
0.0409527011,
-0.0278385282,
-0.0293510612,
-0.0481018089,
0.0385697111,
-0.0772657096,
-0.0271029063,
-0.0147149358,
-0.0141777387,
0.0137525946,
-0.0633545518,
-0.0806325078,
0.0368423387,
0.0094337445,
0.0363608487,
0.0263794344,
0.0187333189,
-0.0066799438,
-0.0249501299,
-0.0243759714,
-0.0015875521,
-0.0168066733,
-0.0397169739,
-0.0762679204,
-0.0226369444,
-0.0295146797,
0.022457581,
0.0091169393,
-0.0032769407,
-0.0408531874,
0.0321806483,
0.0631928593,
0.0164433233,
0.0023143804,
0.0420661643,
-0.0090569556,
0.0156285428,
-0.0016444912,
0.0016142471,
0.0245476719,
-0.0229386892,
-0.0081993071,
0.0083089108,
-0.0510863177,
0.0217491258,
-0.006368746,
0.0118991109,
0.020882098,
-0.0119116753,
0.0088546323,
0.0168617088,
0.0627012923,
0.0011785162,
-0.0543841384,
0.0096253976,
-0.0769582987,
-0.0361360013,
-0.0510793179,
0.0100234849,
0.0202188045,
-0.0258022696,
0.0300212055,
0.0238243043,
0.0191236772,
0.0393975414,
-0.0396878906,
0.0043002772,
-0.0367244259,
0.0549544208,
-0.0485792458,
0.0764145106,
0.0078774327,
-0.0008924255,
-0.0499261618,
0.0122506618,
-0.038948331,
0.0575788282,
0.0310631208,
0.0490845963,
0.0135371918,
0.005473563,
0.0397290997,
-0.0051283035,
-0.0563038588,
-0.0053791939,
-0.0232753772,
0.0454490408,
-0.0308402218,
0.0091552353,
0.0175501481,
-0.035092894,
0.0227726586,
-0.0174161345,
0.0056942333,
0.0159515627,
-0.0002283815,
-0.0339851938,
0.0046477937,
0.0421737209,
-0.0428953394,
0.0720186234,
-0.0272382498,
0.0255967677,
-0.0287760906,
0.0075685848,
-0.025921315,
-0.0499689952,
-0.0325661004,
0.0324993581,
0.0444343351,
-0.0188485552,
-0.0374082439,
-0.0353206284,
-0.0179662704,
-0.0116325412,
0.0392674692,
-0.061666891,
0.0080295941,
0.0161684435,
-0.0390257351,
-0.0245035589,
-0.032944493,
0.0636507943,
-0.0201475359,
-0.0368673615,
-0.0457710624,
-5.447361677e-33,
-0.0050375448,
-0.0781675503,
0.0440317653,
0.0406757444,
0.0099280039,
-0.0288129542,
-0.0542572811,
0.0420020632,
0.0008301545,
0.019847814,
-0.0177022684,
-0.015581823,
-0.0166136473,
0.0072837714,
0.0256947149,
0.0473080054,
0.0437601842,
-0.0039351252,
-0.0231030285,
0.0193962976,
0.0029316549,
-0.012507163,
0.0168830808,
-0.0579105392,
0.0423891693,
-0.0789670944,
0.0198195577,
-0.1009995267,
-0.0402640961,
-0.0035545705,
-0.0204500575,
0.0399676301,
0.0224126354,
-0.0121511221,
-0.0316396616,
0.0347543284,
-0.0354509316,
-0.0548362695,
0.0131433541,
-0.0030459925,
-0.0358082987,
-0.0715508983,
0.0120763881,
0.0047444608,
-0.025397798,
-0.0385227017,
0.0691744238,
-0.0138977785,
-0.0060283109,
-0.0342639424,
-0.1197702214,
0.0027289977,
-0.0395732746,
0.008223163,
-0.034767691,
0.0344658941,
0.0269104056,
-0.0190837514,
-0.0156477932,
0.0444782004,
0.0268208887,
-0.0041076331,
0.0444523282,
0.0032908504,
0.0111797499,
0.0223492626,
0.0422292463,
0.0216164198,
-0.0364667587,
-0.0379988514,
0.0358324237,
-0.0715113953,
0.0276181139,
0.0679824501,
0.0236343276,
-0.0305466205,
-0.0132983904,
0.0520345867,
-0.0260693375,
-0.0155909974,
0.0014319582,
-0.0271257684,
-0.0431673042,
-0.0289408974,
-0.0100829247,
-0.0079799751,
0.0007473019,
-0.0305617806,
0.0130092883,
-0.0401459001,
-0.0094295777,
-0.0219396371,
-0.0288624521,
-0.0203809328,
0.0113732833,
0.0260653738,
-0.0496493168,
0.0748716891,
-0.005031955,
-0.0310251415,
-0.046038609,
0.012986742,
-0.002650542,
0.0494200848,
0.0481978692,
0.0298748482,
0.0333743542,
0.0059375111,
0.0067913295,
-0.0252440069,
-0.0350403674,
0.0094329612,
0.106526956,
-0.0594379269,
0.0288516469,
0.019956708,
0.0111249024,
0.0047565014,
-0.0035064528,
0.0309368689,
-0.0296547506,
-0.033629328,
-0.0457909182,
-0.0230429228,
-0.0363463424,
-0.0177472793,
-0.0062471093,
0.0216227863,
-0.0121105229,
-0.0799601078,
-0.0156669598,
-0.024342509,
2.709e-7,
0.0451457947,
0.0400410369,
0.0338448547,
0.0096463002,
-0.0311969612,
-0.0213416051,
0.0037563066,
-0.0403610617,
0.0561832674,
0.0690738708,
0.0310775433,
0.0482182391,
-0.0104313223,
0.0234461818,
-0.052935943,
-0.041507706,
0.013217831,
0.0533156916,
-0.0253369901,
0.0403501838,
0.0904797465,
-0.0822906196,
0.0047361529,
-0.0254535004,
-0.0234977156,
-0.0045518056,
0.0270458013,
0.0326721333,
0.0407513231,
0.0147260064,
-0.0090412367,
0.0457939841,
0.0215602815,
0.0431100763,
-0.0407793634,
-0.0569945686,
-0.0069219149,
0.0163984019,
0.0176515486,
0.0203239452,
0.0635939613,
0.0241721328,
0.0317210704,
-0.0222039763,
0.0223552343,
-0.0098179486,
-0.000351467,
0.0388366617,
-0.068621777,
0.0053078919,
-0.0150074884,
-0.0232035052,
0.0122841345,
0.0097196717,
-0.0218540207,
-0.0153650185,
0.0218710955,
0.0147712277,
-0.0067711901,
0.0086221974,
-0.0040986268,
-0.039932631,
-0.0274276771,
-0.0453628674,
-0.0053286781,
-0.0290054437,
0.0035386381,
1.746138198e-34,
0.0141154462,
-0.022803491,
0.0402043983,
0.0241651461,
-0.0109804366,
0.0061488617,
0.0003865128,
0.0025871289,
0.0250637364,
-0.0006436535,
-0.0470416956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13476v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13476v2 | Hierarchical attention interpretation: an interpretable speech-level transformer for bi-modal depression detection | 2023-09-23T20:48:58 | 2023-10-06T11:46:11 | Qingkun Deng, Saturnino Luz, Sofia de la Fuente Garcia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS, F.2.2; I.2.7 | Depression is a common mental disorder. Automatic depression detection tools
using speech, enabled by machine learning, help early screening of depression.
This paper addresses two limitations that may hinder the clinical
implementations of such tools: noise resulting from segment-level labelling and
a lack of model interpretability. We propose a bi-modal speech-level
transformer to avoid segment-level labelling and introduce a hierarchical
interpretation approach to provide both speech-level and sentence-level
interpretations, based on gradient-weighted attention maps derived from all
attention layers to track interactions between input features. We show that the
proposed model outperforms a model that learns at a segment level ($p$=0.854,
$r$=0.947, $F1$=0.897 compared to $p$=0.732, $r$=0.808, $F1$=0.768). For model
interpretation, using one true positive sample, we show which sentences within
a given speech are most relevant to depression detection; and which text tokens
and Mel-spectrogram regions within these sentences are most relevant to
depression detection. These interpretations allow clinicians to verify the
validity of predictions made by depression detection tools, promoting their
clinical implementations. | [
0.0160600543,
0.0389770828,
-0.0207604636,
0.0113424473,
0.0156658329,
0.0078674303,
0.0195373502,
0.0141597539,
0.0086840205,
-0.0354929194,
-0.0313127376,
0.0008415582,
0.0212158095,
0.0304757655,
-0.0187837593,
-0.0849973857,
-0.008693709,
0.0346883722,
0.0354019329,
0.0324723125,
0.0082110558,
-0.0105256205,
-0.0284289178,
0.0710560083,
-0.0400961079,
-0.0319777243,
0.0141092828,
0.0257487223,
0.0229256731,
-0.0382822603,
-0.0332549177,
0.0256338678,
-0.0034290508,
0.0064758514,
0.0000022299,
-0.0043999813,
-0.0302513707,
0.0021229121,
-0.0420405231,
-0.0629099384,
0.0029026167,
-0.0505659506,
0.0128755281,
-0.0138665298,
-0.0065857037,
0.0020382153,
0.0167524274,
0.0584989749,
0.0711695701,
0.032936953,
-0.0235452522,
0.0123703089,
0.00615814,
-0.0120398654,
-0.0062287734,
-0.0176223554,
0.0371462703,
0.0188646466,
-0.0245249886,
-0.0350051373,
-0.0617405102,
0.0275365096,
-0.0367159359,
0.0386859886,
0.0353162363,
-0.0114729255,
-0.0060670264,
-0.0528780147,
-0.0020307929,
0.0768349692,
-0.0027533898,
0.018584976,
-0.0107502788,
0.0001795623,
-0.0074196667,
-0.0117074866,
-0.0071081682,
-0.0488609932,
0.0007088548,
0.0545263477,
0.0208906475,
0.029870905,
0.0006156763,
-0.0698259473,
-0.0077907769,
0.0520723276,
-0.0382925943,
-0.0185287111,
0.0038742516,
0.0014937294,
-0.0303784572,
-0.0143898921,
0.063907519,
-0.0039769416,
-0.0107826963,
0.0256980564,
-0.035885267,
-0.092049025,
-0.0212287363,
0.0159539171,
-0.0157188401,
0.0208054613,
-0.1013834178,
0.0309087504,
0.0243705772,
0.0250505116,
0.0019500294,
-0.0294060316,
0.0001297867,
-0.0474717543,
-0.0264952946,
0.0275740754,
-0.047825247,
-0.0117637068,
-0.014706037,
-0.0307349656,
-0.0429775342,
-0.022020787,
-0.027227914,
-0.029871108,
0.0183592327,
-0.0037294638,
-0.0183265228,
0.0157791991,
0.0310522038,
0.0784093961,
0.0008131259,
0.0042312285,
-0.0067820288,
-0.0244854409,
0.0045380243,
0.0186840743,
-0.005192419,
-0.0035199604,
0.0022674259,
0.0720579922,
0.0493547022,
-0.0007640736,
-0.0466772653,
-0.0425236523,
-0.0466709472,
-0.0124686807,
0.0192698892,
0.0110493442,
-0.0047370987,
0.0296821296,
0.0116638104,
-0.056063015,
0.0102015119,
-0.052801352,
-0.0130368695,
0.0483573787,
-0.0304714497,
-0.0145012205,
-0.0116420696,
0.0165101271,
-0.0351725444,
0.0325875953,
0.0743868351,
0.0246804375,
0.0205401145,
-0.0346302539,
0.0030328357,
-0.0108907027,
0.0113107478,
-0.0400696211,
0.0095145209,
-0.0266111344,
-0.061462231,
0.0256928951,
0.0265438557,
0.020895768,
0.0228376482,
-0.0063079535,
0.0438832454,
0.0494301952,
0.0287446864,
0.0547085479,
-0.0096686939,
0.0481800437,
-0.0460992567,
-0.0272826329,
-0.0345154665,
0.0205930006,
-0.0329267643,
-0.0364813209,
0.0097887106,
-0.0173147451,
0.0178250261,
-0.0559710637,
-0.0123316292,
-0.0117772492,
0.0058402224,
0.0176456869,
0.0349760391,
-0.0224793982,
-0.0024783744,
0.0872380063,
0.0196277928,
0.0145190954,
-0.0380846784,
-0.0451907218,
0.0019712341,
0.0268711839,
-0.0333056711,
-0.0555047281,
0.036142312,
-0.0179203488,
0.0394538753,
-0.0082671074,
-0.0271869227,
0.0456409268,
0.0698819831,
-0.0220073331,
-0.010970585,
0.0183440819,
0.0296780057,
0.0055564325,
-0.0737720728,
-0.0039453679,
-0.0251655299,
-0.0657721907,
0.0236835871,
0.0262348317,
0.0547861792,
-0.0053686993,
0.0384675376,
0.0239306856,
0.0247378238,
0.0091408715,
0.0025456948,
0.0067544472,
0.0312627479,
-0.0259438287,
-0.0214460399,
-0.0020019207,
0.0028047424,
-0.0412573479,
-0.0317611918,
-0.0537107773,
-0.0210067388,
0.0662600249,
-0.0189321376,
-0.03956737,
0.0452879928,
-0.0797889903,
0.045124352,
0.0223963112,
-0.0133081498,
0.003994755,
0.0609094463,
-0.0253628343,
0.0068239877,
-0.0263166092,
0.0031781993,
0.0276706927,
-0.035058625,
0.0047518942,
-0.0212225933,
-0.037923947,
-0.0074773654,
-0.0196447503,
-0.0206131469,
-0.0545735545,
-0.0303079151,
-0.0168516934,
0.0147927208,
-0.0984041914,
-0.0079696132,
-0.0156986229,
-0.0050002919,
0.0180587228,
-0.0095553687,
0.0029592589,
-0.0274816584,
0.012776399,
0.0395045467,
0.012074491,
-0.0187837407,
0.02735628,
-0.0065262388,
0.0037519678,
-0.0276837125,
-0.015740227,
-0.0249031633,
0.0328577198,
-0.0431195758,
-0.0739774182,
-0.0430999473,
-0.0358092114,
0.0122447405,
-0.0024485083,
-0.0077378009,
-0.0358553603,
-0.0168494061,
0.0129339695,
0.0438785218,
0.1042534858,
0.0107466932,
0.0871216208,
0.0206675958,
0.0206322987,
-0.0047437721,
0.0224845465,
0.0429991074,
0.0345017575,
-0.0245347768,
-0.0377432778,
-0.0083802883,
0.1127593145,
0.0408550724,
0.0248507317,
-0.0205982681,
-0.0572003908,
-0.0047351024,
0.0032713145,
0.0088127544,
0.0119829495,
-0.0045245844,
0.0065370365,
-0.006267522,
-0.0559819862,
0.0621391758,
0.0092465337,
-0.0624362156,
-0.0296115428,
-0.0423482843,
-0.0223023556,
0.025968641,
-0.0152639002,
0.0140572852,
0.0422796719,
-0.0447147898,
0.0191477183,
-0.0027748686,
-0.0294188932,
-0.0281496253,
0.0830046311,
-0.0196661353,
-0.0281352662,
0.0165482089,
-0.0107824523,
-0.0342239179,
-0.032506723,
-0.0604103431,
-0.0054151872,
0.0092612281,
0.0087487698,
-0.0632214695,
0.0013852859,
0.0379062966,
0.0187902153,
-0.0187289119,
-0.0127759073,
0.0332279131,
0.0216181558,
0.0137949092,
0.0471901596,
0.0316583999,
-0.0158185363,
-0.0129728885,
0.0290185716,
-0.0676648766,
0.0458702631,
-0.0250868499,
0.0117475921,
-0.044386398,
0.0147057492,
-0.0351843089,
0.0011868231,
0.0314360894,
-0.0646729842,
0.0097609609,
0.0751789734,
-0.0015702641,
-0.0462686978,
0.050823953,
-0.0280525014,
-0.0416697338,
0.0000489076,
-0.0167138521,
-0.0237580612,
-0.0879016668,
-0.0259931926,
0.0707737803,
0.0031146982,
0.0233905874,
0.0088179484,
0.0391631387,
0.0384187885,
-0.0166543704,
-0.0071494435,
0.0203942191,
-0.0249517746,
0.0424175449,
-0.0369436108,
-0.0426417589,
-0.0384996124,
-0.0181385856,
-0.0240794662,
0.0006584899,
-0.0891048387,
-0.0285681151,
0.044037208,
0.0084629031,
0.0327697545,
0.0272777341,
0.0496707782,
-0.0003383566,
0.0016788744,
-0.0240643192,
0.0342264324,
0.0211358368,
0.0212946385,
0.0512236729,
0.0047838846,
-0.0149975698,
-0.0378099456,
0.0644291639,
-0.0610652752,
-0.0070994538,
-0.0356724001,
0.0896373019,
-0.0248142667,
-0.0528669283,
-0.0506025739,
0.0440929458,
0.043975763,
0.0486502647,
0.0503479205,
-0.0622798018,
-0.0219025593,
-0.005318318,
0.0279099923,
-0.0042516324,
-0.0263442956,
0.035169363,
-0.021869503,
-0.009886303,
-0.0270000622,
-0.0241189469,
0.0386371389,
-0.0358945429,
-0.0236355085,
-0.0334637314,
0.0110674156,
0.0134468088,
-0.0579880849,
0.0767954215,
0.0543793663,
0.0145111978,
-0.0342776775,
-0.0188993234,
0.0425808206,
-0.0354665853,
-0.043442931,
-0.0001067085,
-0.064592272,
0.0106723858,
0.0670888126,
0.0005711031,
0.0142848454,
0.0085717402,
0.0125803277,
-0.0359063596,
0.0218405165,
-0.0293425806,
0.0090772202,
0.0142395496,
0.0676335469,
0.0017615824,
-0.0373526588,
0.0564829893,
-0.0260207783,
0.0498112291,
0.0252684038,
-0.0368564837,
-0.0050099045,
-0.003899503,
0.0084607732,
0.0046015289,
0.0810822695,
0.0272529498,
-0.0608063079,
0.0111547709,
0.0076493481,
0.0539722703,
0.017320605,
-0.0658937842,
-0.0279430002,
-0.0105214184,
-0.0376902968,
-0.0296701696,
-0.0465144329,
-0.0309592821,
-0.078748405,
-0.0075650313,
0.0622975565,
-0.0144340554,
-0.0020382365,
0.0110217081,
0.0037645863,
-0.0348715074,
0.0166179743,
0.0046574702,
0.0241648126,
0.0146730449,
0.0619971789,
-0.0152989421,
-0.0054483213,
0.019058926,
0.0387776271,
-0.0492299609,
-0.0355839506,
-0.00639599,
-0.0388003588,
0.035493236,
0.0131983142,
0.0576209836,
0.0014017199,
0.0313440152,
-0.0229686555,
0.0616009049,
-0.03945373,
-0.0186360758,
0.0075550079,
-0.0200792756,
-0.0026412581,
-0.0129253156,
0.0425591357,
-0.0046523493,
-0.020968074,
0.0021495498,
0.0030440059,
-0.0588147901,
0.0197604541,
0.0355810598,
0.0297832582,
-0.0412904695,
0.0108594634,
-0.0236055627,
-0.0470777005,
0.0363749154,
-0.0482743122,
0.0148748951,
-0.0709869415,
0.0176179539,
0.0093138684,
0.01430126,
-0.02768966,
-0.0442894921,
0.0292895678,
-0.0180933736,
-0.0020835225,
-0.036508441,
-5.752042099e-33,
-0.0148276454,
-0.015562431,
-0.0610667206,
-0.0073573147,
-0.0099423975,
0.0623831488,
-0.0451298691,
0.0322911739,
0.0177322645,
0.0550053306,
0.0324955098,
0.0793447196,
-0.0022072443,
0.0398102999,
0.0049968734,
-0.0170905832,
0.0428451635,
0.0089862179,
-0.0066229389,
-0.0038977254,
0.0279985331,
0.0760249645,
0.108313635,
-0.0692060888,
-0.0122304056,
0.0330777951,
-0.0025514218,
-0.0170053951,
0.0216327999,
0.0529713593,
-0.015163349,
0.0440088958,
0.048302833,
0.0003732287,
-0.0096714124,
0.0024369825,
-0.0558636636,
-0.0000214105,
-0.0103826839,
0.0267930292,
-0.0618207231,
0.0207826085,
0.0723896697,
0.0067411046,
0.0436406061,
-0.0652381554,
0.0517239459,
-0.0533559285,
0.0146447076,
-0.0354885608,
-0.0397444665,
0.0139114847,
-0.024085924,
-0.0224252138,
0.0039678565,
0.0591096655,
-0.0355072282,
0.0295032151,
-0.0267153271,
-0.0202658083,
-0.0038475601,
0.0024557081,
0.0278251208,
-0.0349663496,
-0.0285121668,
0.046405293,
0.0310775749,
-0.0314523131,
0.0164314974,
-0.0506121032,
-0.000419349,
0.0723665729,
0.077969484,
-0.0275011901,
0.0538786054,
0.0263238996,
-0.0624522269,
-0.0056164046,
-0.0324223675,
0.0150997229,
0.0142735206,
0.0061074868,
-0.0203465857,
0.017071506,
-0.0039412072,
-0.0157769527,
-0.0374957286,
-0.0271169487,
0.0094740689,
-0.0148169482,
-0.0149918012,
0.0334743112,
0.042972818,
-0.031174114,
0.0384817794,
-0.0380797125,
0.039602749,
0.031833306,
0.0320767388,
0.016092075,
0.0047749439,
-0.0083285272,
0.0465709306,
-0.0084935362,
0.0972008184,
0.0101702577,
0.0148137128,
-0.0238536466,
-0.0000087235,
-0.030077029,
0.0438976921,
-0.0148355281,
-0.0251910463,
0.0962915346,
0.0029833601,
0.0122886281,
-0.0229570195,
0.0517042652,
-0.0343337134,
0.0611646473,
-0.0636063516,
-0.0185973812,
0.0069237188,
0.0264752302,
-0.0392812341,
-0.0454303548,
-0.0498388149,
-0.0508184321,
0.041987095,
-0.0621275529,
-0.0201790724,
0.0112803066,
2.979e-7,
0.0523693785,
0.0566227064,
-0.0015795919,
-0.0140495356,
0.040325135,
0.019392306,
-0.0022479824,
0.063159354,
0.0296676271,
-0.0447152406,
0.019821167,
-0.0306615345,
0.055146236,
0.0578480698,
-0.0285149571,
-0.0428360067,
0.0171263665,
-0.0313607901,
-0.0285231601,
0.0350986011,
0.0866054818,
0.1062550172,
-0.0204351805,
0.0112949181,
0.0604687445,
0.0349122174,
0.0342728943,
-0.0084784469,
0.0501137972,
0.0007919036,
0.0577742681,
-0.0549271442,
0.011179978,
0.0224000271,
-0.0139063792,
0.0197529551,
-0.0114421342,
0.0542889796,
-0.0768300891,
-0.0342357643,
-0.0203306153,
0.046408236,
0.0004354626,
-0.0029544216,
0.0354782715,
-0.0909369513,
-0.0522401221,
-0.0668489709,
-0.0143280365,
-0.0252119284,
0.0440839119,
-0.0029995823,
0.0062040114,
0.0123507185,
0.0144274514,
-0.0196015872,
-0.0091392482,
-0.0610772222,
-0.0534315109,
0.0094865747,
-0.0554740801,
0.0036214376,
-0.033918608,
-0.0451407731,
0.0318076685,
-0.0722878799,
-0.0220729411,
2.493363108e-34,
0.0288320128,
-0.0004921053,
0.0226047058,
0.0025646708,
0.0110438652,
-0.0106969625,
-0.0346124433,
-0.0014063799,
-0.0072679147,
-0.0842112601,
-0.037170548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13448v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13448v1 | Grounding Description-Driven Dialogue State Trackers with Knowledge-Seeking Turns | 2023-09-23T18:33:02 | 2023-09-23T18:33:02 | Alexandru Coca, Bo-Hsiang Tseng, Jinghong Chen, Weizhe Lin, Weixuan Zhang, Tisha Anders, Bill Byrne | cs.CL | cs.CL | Schema-guided dialogue state trackers can generalise to new domains without
further training, yet they are sensitive to the writing style of the schemata.
Augmenting the training set with human or synthetic schema paraphrases improves
the model robustness to these variations but can be either costly or difficult
to control. We propose to circumvent these issues by grounding the state
tracking model in knowledge-seeking turns collected from the dialogue corpus as
well as the schema. Including these turns in prompts during finetuning and
inference leads to marked improvements in model robustness, as demonstrated by
large average joint goal accuracy and schema sensitivity improvements on SGD
and SGD-X. | [
0.029218046,
0.0402662866,
-0.0038157024,
0.0385403521,
0.0079842284,
-0.0254100356,
-0.0566913709,
-0.030378541,
0.000828832,
-0.0623065159,
-0.0279051401,
-0.0559526049,
-0.0298683103,
0.0758908913,
0.002813733,
-0.0814299136,
0.0813306421,
-0.0428264402,
-0.0243348349,
0.0357850306,
0.0481567569,
-0.0108875064,
-0.0459217988,
0.0562786385,
-0.0283784363,
-0.005446977,
-0.021446567,
0.0134640317,
0.0205149315,
-0.0151730981,
0.0068491148,
0.0359185971,
0.0245280378,
0.0192802865,
0.0000017074,
-0.0652687624,
-0.0163926445,
-0.0291039255,
-0.0612859912,
-0.0223406907,
-0.0457513221,
-0.0278225131,
-0.0067667919,
0.0174455866,
-0.0302734915,
0.006600637,
0.0222675148,
0.0545493588,
0.0752990916,
0.0923674926,
-0.0113455849,
-0.0073465989,
0.0080639254,
-0.0098958667,
-0.023485655,
-0.1032432467,
-0.0111044468,
0.003970434,
0.0023563411,
0.0282852147,
-0.0190610569,
0.0422773808,
-0.0197708569,
-0.0308839623,
-0.0076053743,
-0.0044307048,
-0.0368560851,
0.0168394148,
-0.0296422094,
0.0610267222,
0.071349822,
0.0334295742,
0.0025086217,
-0.0198036358,
0.0109065557,
-0.0093630254,
-0.0119393682,
-0.0227151625,
-0.0494678468,
-0.0065064388,
-0.0384115502,
0.0114619639,
-0.0115318717,
-0.01628666,
-0.0131652569,
0.0751003921,
-0.039010711,
-0.0493848436,
-0.0034934809,
-0.0040701157,
0.012224149,
-0.0515323132,
0.0146592772,
0.0191354323,
-0.028959848,
0.0414330103,
-0.0710726902,
-0.0022943858,
-0.0173109397,
-0.0040314756,
0.0062786466,
0.0584346466,
-0.0222592223,
0.0348057896,
0.0581221059,
0.0807546303,
-0.0115617439,
0.0022067381,
-0.017896669,
-0.010509626,
-0.0448467061,
0.0182972662,
-0.0484756902,
0.0191717874,
-0.0341884866,
-0.0353982002,
-0.0356716774,
0.0379343852,
0.0359816141,
0.0125718238,
-0.0383290686,
0.0239947177,
-0.0358579531,
0.0142259356,
-0.0304990392,
0.0549568981,
-0.012325217,
-0.0028141611,
0.015413939,
-0.006189106,
-0.0287120007,
0.0345126167,
0.0258784257,
-0.0119793611,
-0.0448030606,
0.0548439138,
0.0077411691,
-0.0570978187,
-0.0119085638,
-0.0346452706,
-0.0350472219,
-0.037433058,
-0.0055602035,
0.0187529251,
0.0624777712,
-0.021092955,
-0.0060795201,
-0.0550486706,
-0.0047466704,
0.0133747924,
0.0093373228,
0.0433546901,
-0.0376687758,
-0.0284051225,
-0.0584379099,
-0.0100531187,
-0.0805397779,
0.0594137609,
0.0252626743,
0.0225856025,
0.0442216173,
0.0031705741,
0.0233136602,
0.0090813255,
0.0136531312,
0.0238985941,
0.0153213404,
0.0406292304,
0.0123985261,
0.0151435072,
0.0295585655,
0.0340034589,
-0.027270427,
0.0095373336,
0.0707985908,
0.0609575436,
0.0117696822,
-0.0339784548,
0.025688,
0.0277035665,
0.0023668623,
0.025802996,
-0.0462915227,
-0.0042314841,
-0.0263352226,
0.0104779247,
-0.0229590647,
-0.0023881302,
-0.0085045919,
-0.0486334972,
-0.0009195334,
0.0244952049,
0.0079142628,
0.0125192851,
0.0134085212,
0.0123502407,
-0.0596870929,
0.0275479294,
-0.0124088535,
-0.0689516366,
-0.0211366825,
-0.0151602989,
0.0039147343,
0.0814439431,
0.0336722508,
-0.0279763732,
-0.0783307776,
-0.0425498746,
0.0310832243,
0.0649231896,
0.012396506,
-0.0341546312,
0.0575591549,
-0.0546069331,
-0.0219665952,
-0.0012488893,
0.0200602729,
-0.0152676208,
0.0310911555,
-0.0283485055,
0.0151699381,
0.0018011237,
0.0419248976,
0.0289114416,
0.0364803001,
-0.0225046277,
-0.0223131478,
0.0078586098,
0.024431996,
0.0273781363,
0.0068477164,
0.0041663344,
0.0055197491,
0.0234365221,
0.011887976,
0.0520876423,
-0.032830812,
-0.055093091,
0.0063412748,
0.0533217713,
-0.0350288264,
-0.0015968016,
0.0020782966,
-0.0753560364,
-0.0291566085,
-0.0452794395,
0.0392341316,
-0.0223471746,
0.0178285986,
0.0458592549,
-0.0108832465,
-0.0278317686,
0.0373663418,
0.0027993834,
-0.0186259188,
0.0153279454,
-0.021213742,
0.0236605722,
-0.0273087732,
0.0032951331,
0.0114266342,
-0.0089997696,
0.014329399,
0.0123348618,
-0.0261310879,
-0.0588489547,
0.0156581812,
-0.0367577597,
0.0030445766,
-0.0359430537,
0.0278718248,
0.0141260214,
-0.0010358535,
-0.0168490335,
-0.0316375121,
-0.0047107106,
-0.0276997015,
0.0123621551,
-0.0172297787,
0.0039814459,
0.0628231689,
-0.0188335273,
-0.0554130226,
0.0605257489,
-0.0081538325,
-0.0036565056,
-0.0235898737,
-0.0130910799,
-0.0791402459,
0.0717325136,
-0.0283633582,
0.0580622256,
-0.0471711904,
-0.0093758805,
0.035987895,
0.0446088202,
-0.0096878521,
0.0411895551,
0.0084220516,
0.0530681089,
0.008664446,
-0.0481394045,
-0.0357198566,
0.0459091514,
0.0054543465,
0.0235217772,
-0.0665869117,
0.0340041332,
0.0413239896,
0.0268205386,
0.0355331451,
0.0304987617,
-0.0733308122,
-0.0407844558,
-0.0117533151,
-0.035088677,
-0.0049988939,
-0.0048366194,
-0.049481526,
0.0272323266,
-0.012562112,
-0.0231061671,
0.071611315,
-0.0643025488,
-0.0271207895,
-0.0197572466,
-0.0204433855,
-0.00527409,
0.0503720231,
-0.0306777004,
0.012360476,
0.0339558646,
-0.0251212642,
-0.0078812549,
-0.0651806965,
0.0321566239,
-0.0089321276,
0.1112900898,
-0.0606837906,
0.0333440304,
0.0025560656,
-0.0390414335,
-0.0655024424,
-0.0128566651,
-0.0147595434,
0.0153904706,
0.0279022269,
-0.0549595989,
0.0074160844,
0.0459876619,
0.021372186,
0.0626656413,
-0.0156599134,
-0.002315911,
-0.0226253197,
0.0171392001,
0.0473870039,
0.0034571702,
-0.0164179113,
-0.017620042,
0.0726770312,
0.0609031208,
0.0711121559,
-0.0060645342,
0.012909255,
-0.0308924448,
-0.0076288083,
-0.0403849781,
-0.0426789857,
0.0085441424,
0.0936246663,
-0.0387701951,
-0.0404020399,
0.10271319,
0.011643176,
-0.0119419154,
-0.0098546194,
-0.0038022979,
0.0292464029,
0.0409277827,
0.0170089658,
-0.054718025,
-0.0359718986,
0.0175491404,
0.0519622974,
0.0093486635,
-0.0375607684,
-0.0331785232,
-0.0668820962,
0.0206195656,
-0.0091883847,
-0.1155749634,
-0.0514683649,
0.0100582158,
0.0527618378,
0.0170427449,
0.0123733133,
0.0108290855,
-0.0021294204,
-0.0240637343,
0.0320549905,
-0.0298562422,
-0.0283861328,
0.0071862941,
-0.0426894426,
0.0530984886,
0.0844527259,
0.028739661,
0.0342750736,
0.0130091384,
0.0076784561,
-0.0014184127,
0.031677857,
0.0250884425,
0.0354074687,
-0.0825507119,
-0.017245058,
-0.0034822535,
0.0417980254,
-0.0091199828,
0.0017231316,
0.0096132979,
0.0333532467,
-0.0607459359,
0.054984089,
-0.0072663892,
-0.0018445805,
0.0219559129,
0.0291096009,
0.026414711,
-0.032523293,
0.0103739155,
-0.0219439603,
-0.0233977269,
-0.0376763903,
-0.0098358057,
0.0045011197,
0.0032059676,
0.0335977226,
-0.0727651268,
-0.089352116,
0.0543893687,
0.0751237497,
-0.0305051599,
0.0366012789,
0.0150149111,
0.0198818631,
0.0141544156,
0.0349753723,
-0.0500129424,
0.0107155303,
-0.0328176916,
-0.0281883162,
0.0485743694,
0.006474976,
-0.0096813459,
0.0293736216,
-0.0549730025,
-0.0574326925,
-0.0096298419,
0.056234315,
0.022240283,
0.0651069954,
-0.0025112238,
0.0139137702,
-0.0699126422,
-0.0075253337,
-0.0030695889,
0.0124455374,
0.0642353445,
0.0243701078,
-0.0341369808,
0.0532689132,
-0.0109684058,
-0.0015546053,
-0.02035648,
0.0663493648,
-0.0514920019,
-0.0663985908,
0.0193416644,
-0.0140587613,
0.0326266028,
-0.0007543506,
-0.0186800845,
-0.0141486386,
0.0411157161,
-0.0143365758,
-0.0280969497,
-0.0502561554,
0.0009876033,
-0.0191567577,
-0.0474988744,
-0.0067083421,
-0.009581985,
-0.0268047713,
0.0303925835,
-0.0546274856,
-0.0314250775,
-0.0050036334,
-0.017769793,
0.0243539363,
0.0196833909,
-0.0020639698,
0.0692753866,
0.0148838377,
0.0449461713,
0.0283181835,
0.0846441239,
0.026197128,
-0.0303259417,
0.0038136221,
0.0088712797,
-0.0677131265,
-0.0666251406,
-0.0378079414,
0.013685436,
0.0458377972,
-0.0128677431,
0.0386298224,
-0.0145072881,
0.022529548,
0.0231476109,
0.0686438829,
0.0158981197,
-0.0183452163,
0.0540727898,
0.0275320802,
0.0082480758,
-0.0064326203,
0.0781445429,
0.0377731621,
0.069806926,
0.004330012,
0.0058155367,
-0.0611158423,
-0.0441978797,
0.0203416236,
0.0396891795,
-0.0028485274,
0.0282922257,
-0.0542997196,
-0.056385383,
0.0237504374,
-0.0232596789,
-0.008894234,
-0.0389182195,
0.0593142994,
0.0234614536,
-0.0115522798,
-0.0230486561,
-0.0312627181,
-0.0376146249,
0.0226972681,
0.024763478,
-0.0458775647,
-5.606371165e-33,
-0.0729364753,
-0.0357543305,
0.0384087525,
0.0098686041,
-0.0364495367,
-0.0344217084,
-0.0358841978,
0.0016316192,
-0.0174048766,
-0.0164435133,
-0.0012698253,
0.050027065,
0.0169758666,
0.0264632106,
-0.0345525481,
-0.0480481125,
0.0321554467,
0.0106538218,
-0.0378901213,
-0.0139659448,
0.0580563843,
0.0366098247,
0.0751828626,
-0.1007789001,
0.0368831195,
0.0075663738,
-0.0097612357,
0.0350995064,
-0.0167454164,
0.0352577344,
-0.0179227963,
0.013960883,
0.0014562138,
-0.0408358388,
-0.0188510176,
-0.0105881561,
0.006575014,
0.003981885,
0.050663881,
0.0297361873,
0.0125862397,
0.0133177852,
-0.0123139396,
-0.0296771564,
0.0129270544,
0.0623377822,
-0.0012604471,
-0.007201083,
-0.04674986,
-0.0231795181,
-0.0616343692,
0.0217068177,
0.0157123711,
-0.0846674666,
-0.0285235271,
0.0672295392,
0.0313163102,
-0.0375942886,
-0.0209612977,
-0.0110656777,
-0.0249813162,
0.0058090212,
0.0111132096,
0.0417179167,
-0.0131557034,
0.0823539346,
-0.0169362091,
0.0197066776,
-0.0145687666,
-0.0626562908,
0.0088730557,
0.021707084,
0.029846346,
0.0062391059,
-0.0296317935,
0.0160601065,
-0.0078431284,
0.0027789776,
0.0042253914,
0.0373554304,
-0.002217971,
0.0381280668,
-0.0892974585,
-0.0071873832,
-0.0302587859,
0.0244985111,
0.017964486,
-0.0188364647,
0.053316962,
0.0199752823,
-0.0269323681,
-0.0068309731,
0.0465775952,
-0.0210316144,
0.0296860095,
0.0194839146,
-0.0133523587,
0.0191102251,
-0.0356751978,
-0.0029363241,
-0.0502286479,
-0.0256241765,
0.039355956,
0.0018807827,
0.0222555604,
-0.0014228151,
0.0158579685,
0.0213031303,
-0.0434460975,
-0.0052968031,
-0.0481048487,
0.0513001159,
-0.0453395657,
0.0282728095,
0.0349352099,
-0.0020976516,
-0.0386043116,
0.0938817561,
-0.0156482104,
-0.0289709847,
-0.0320365205,
-0.0168739874,
-0.0004251988,
0.0189207252,
0.0047289827,
-0.0231579971,
0.0074645202,
-0.0076839691,
-0.0263355244,
-0.0487126336,
0.0182730779,
-0.0005977554,
2.575e-7,
0.0266742725,
0.0083409827,
0.0496518575,
0.0307346061,
-0.0033393707,
0.053584639,
-0.0129189705,
0.0088757314,
0.0175195839,
-0.0426150337,
0.0198695157,
0.003237861,
0.0339657441,
0.0193036012,
-0.1179968119,
-0.0701736882,
-0.0124834022,
-0.0139770517,
-0.0125149032,
0.0017111264,
0.0194143578,
0.0557100661,
-0.014486976,
0.0229094494,
0.0267150365,
-0.0084153777,
0.0555183552,
-0.011725462,
0.0024505449,
0.0051295799,
0.0170000158,
0.0033722774,
-0.0410641618,
0.0346106179,
0.0163218901,
0.0500429198,
-0.0162595753,
0.0581033826,
-0.0086591765,
-0.0365878008,
-0.0491053462,
0.0107976804,
0.0027018371,
-0.0181310344,
0.0223239642,
-0.0150820808,
0.0023144677,
-0.0237186123,
0.0012340692,
-0.0102924695,
-0.024959119,
0.0263645668,
0.0044369879,
0.0012759804,
0.0018028702,
0.0117794229,
-0.0156782623,
-0.0989920571,
-0.0332997032,
0.0170512535,
-0.0261908434,
-0.0260066893,
-0.0182065517,
-0.0312355589,
-0.0347340144,
-0.052654054,
-0.0398992673,
2.246191084e-34,
0.0458918624,
-0.0080901524,
0.022819275,
0.0656333938,
0.0460097231,
0.0048303842,
0.0098728705,
-0.0177005623,
0.0446305238,
-0.0467914641,
-0.0127519686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13430v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13430v1 | Resolving References in Visually-Grounded Dialogue via Text Generation | 2023-09-23T17:07:54 | 2023-09-23T17:07:54 | Bram Willemsen, Livia Qian, Gabriel Skantze | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Vision-language models (VLMs) have shown to be effective at image retrieval
based on simple text queries, but text-image retrieval based on conversational
input remains a challenge. Consequently, if we want to use VLMs for reference
resolution in visually-grounded dialogue, the discourse processing capabilities
of these models need to be augmented. To address this issue, we propose
fine-tuning a causal large language model (LLM) to generate definite
descriptions that summarize coreferential information found in the linguistic
context of references. We then use a pretrained VLM to identify referents based
on the generated descriptions, zero-shot. We evaluate our approach on a
manually annotated dataset of visually-grounded dialogues and achieve results
that, on average, exceed the performance of the baselines we compare against.
Furthermore, we find that using referent descriptions based on larger context
windows has the potential to yield higher returns. | [
0.0554755889,
0.0202714186,
0.025972696,
0.0185757801,
-0.0119524123,
-0.0024348081,
0.013446413,
0.0070388285,
0.0022464651,
-0.1040636227,
-0.0297732167,
-0.0080469456,
0.0123456456,
0.0220856965,
0.0260104407,
-0.0625780895,
0.0086393077,
-0.0319288969,
0.0158997085,
0.0324602164,
0.0124715399,
0.0164663531,
-0.0010561036,
0.0484194867,
-0.04531141,
-0.0265956521,
0.0158843715,
0.031028498,
0.0166820437,
-0.0174414329,
-0.0294073112,
0.028030768,
0.0345181562,
0.0050763832,
0.0000016066,
-0.0076092565,
0.0424771681,
-0.0103656426,
0.0145785976,
0.0131659191,
0.015057751,
-0.0375597738,
0.0265834741,
0.0082425885,
-0.025732547,
-0.0334758759,
0.0483734645,
0.0937047526,
0.0752894655,
0.0312704183,
-0.0206054971,
-0.0379141979,
0.0014735932,
-0.0263247788,
0.0179185513,
-0.0598749071,
0.0055256654,
0.0587623827,
-0.0118390666,
0.0136042302,
-0.0219773035,
0.0291160103,
0.0003813615,
-0.0432839915,
0.0505583063,
0.0430534296,
-0.0379923768,
-0.0051008794,
0.0041987943,
0.1253465712,
0.0465155579,
0.01203484,
-0.0053884778,
0.015674524,
-0.0215048455,
-0.0050598038,
-0.0542414039,
0.0630231798,
-0.0027910299,
0.0210567676,
-0.0499833561,
0.0164766181,
-0.0083703315,
0.0152406637,
0.0274758674,
-0.0072347042,
0.0101587493,
0.0089021446,
-0.0071476311,
0.0147742508,
-0.0117917825,
-0.0788372532,
-0.040765591,
0.031008577,
-0.0368900746,
0.0208463781,
-0.0363726057,
0.0242617093,
-0.0106963236,
-0.0564112924,
0.0386549756,
-0.0080758641,
-0.0494320728,
0.074323222,
-0.0210448056,
0.0676094964,
-0.0261489339,
-0.0288644433,
-0.0270078443,
-0.0179914851,
-0.0180017743,
-0.0062759551,
-0.0716165453,
0.0039989096,
-0.0879513398,
-0.066431351,
-0.0221643765,
0.0206440352,
-0.016480539,
-0.0073473016,
-0.0185739603,
0.0340613797,
-0.0323930159,
0.0112094991,
-0.0342881307,
0.0546422638,
-0.0248077139,
-0.0019788793,
-0.0233324394,
-0.0623746701,
-0.0174828656,
0.0746114999,
0.0352944806,
-0.0342149399,
-0.0450857542,
0.0630663857,
-0.0294670351,
-0.0364835486,
-0.013879979,
-0.0751492381,
-0.0493067801,
-0.0532173663,
0.0108456919,
-0.0325399078,
0.0018068529,
-0.0155353965,
-0.0176149197,
-0.0544551946,
0.0359263793,
0.0255440325,
-0.0446327664,
0.0651916489,
0.0100817885,
0.0034867609,
0.0264280643,
0.0071067102,
0.0516156405,
0.0546965264,
0.0163374227,
0.05024077,
0.0264958329,
0.0028374156,
0.0250251498,
0.0060719205,
0.0188537408,
0.0186452046,
-0.0473669171,
-0.0098858541,
-0.0136690419,
0.0229311641,
0.028725598,
0.0650063306,
-0.0470897593,
-0.0051710354,
0.0723612607,
0.0357460491,
-0.0392563045,
-0.0228014383,
0.0312439818,
0.0153140686,
-0.0062753754,
0.0150830317,
-0.0448573567,
0.0424448177,
0.0213514138,
0.01169053,
0.0496947616,
-0.0282537416,
-0.0560109913,
-0.0194767285,
-0.0075773089,
0.0043895566,
-0.0039004334,
-0.0151333837,
0.0343068764,
0.0522228777,
-0.0649897009,
0.0526269898,
0.0108508077,
-0.0495582521,
-0.0032066552,
-0.000765363,
0.0241034329,
0.0286950897,
0.0508752801,
0.0339797661,
-0.0221608151,
-0.026577333,
0.0806619376,
0.0627921,
0.0014499285,
-0.003162368,
0.003554096,
-0.0438715219,
-0.0523230135,
-0.04146621,
0.0100643011,
0.0235511996,
0.0144608505,
-0.0323814787,
0.0425288379,
-0.0089581897,
-0.0107328855,
0.0274381191,
0.0176532883,
-0.0315109864,
-0.0050868308,
0.0106313275,
-0.0082984893,
0.0120451115,
-0.0470204689,
-0.0094225323,
0.0137531953,
-0.0282839146,
0.024561571,
0.0713234544,
-0.0473434553,
-0.0025677579,
0.0124100335,
-0.065343529,
0.0033206881,
-0.0399071835,
-0.0382021777,
-0.0434103608,
0.0392503552,
-0.0404260345,
-0.0266639534,
-0.0594585873,
-0.0135632139,
0.0413182899,
0.0238375347,
-0.0359489918,
0.0556163453,
0.0249534268,
-0.0203789528,
0.0452207141,
0.0101168426,
0.0335158333,
-0.068407312,
0.0089700539,
-0.0214469396,
0.0175748672,
0.0046000811,
0.0293303914,
0.0016117494,
-0.0568210483,
-0.0057128062,
-0.1094402224,
-0.0449142717,
-0.0142603526,
-0.0432757102,
0.0086398348,
-0.0212719291,
0.020178318,
-0.0401031226,
-0.0255188048,
0.0120326998,
0.0453837886,
-0.0180945564,
0.0497219376,
0.0408511236,
0.0308665484,
-0.0398520604,
0.0244615227,
0.039171502,
0.0886014998,
0.0733723864,
-0.0327934548,
-0.0376622863,
0.0257686581,
-0.038211491,
0.0271871369,
0.0005160819,
-0.0174732115,
0.0024280255,
-0.0028924099,
0.034957923,
0.0580426455,
0.0122917341,
0.0291032102,
-0.0149241416,
-0.0585412979,
-0.0394331403,
0.0078355921,
0.0052605337,
-0.0341871977,
0.0042582829,
-0.0095957899,
-0.0098118493,
0.0431488678,
-0.0015312133,
0.0196028184,
-0.0464302525,
0.0495081805,
0.0279499143,
-0.0356031843,
-0.0522627868,
-0.0060883546,
-0.0006658371,
0.0538320281,
-0.0603728369,
-0.0561948605,
0.0350543596,
-0.0604838133,
-0.0013218084,
0.0433914065,
0.0101805469,
-0.0435679369,
0.0649139509,
0.0232565682,
-0.0007591687,
0.0185629074,
-0.0250402335,
-0.020480657,
-0.0289516728,
0.0176739171,
0.005762639,
0.0708402097,
-0.0636387691,
0.0442675315,
-0.0303079113,
-0.0222888142,
-0.0574570522,
-0.0166161042,
-0.0473763347,
-0.0107478015,
-0.0501206107,
-0.0039448575,
-0.0525984876,
0.0560627282,
0.033613611,
0.0075112735,
0.0051505854,
0.0088439565,
-0.0326855183,
0.0387437865,
0.0484894998,
0.0147930775,
-0.0214361232,
-0.0228151828,
0.015005704,
0.0285418779,
0.0099583967,
0.020820681,
-0.0562091582,
-0.0210431591,
-0.0276714582,
0.0232348312,
-0.0116226599,
-0.0011526198,
0.0440986156,
-0.0347959585,
-0.0329251215,
0.1039651707,
0.002976534,
-0.0133120213,
-0.0401077271,
0.0206913631,
0.0214307718,
0.0233619642,
0.0305211022,
-0.0917035937,
-0.0422494635,
-0.023739839,
-0.0209407564,
0.0362472311,
-0.0214050468,
-0.0294681285,
-0.105218038,
0.0537649542,
0.0093419868,
0.004709675,
-0.0356448591,
0.0159847774,
-0.0036367348,
0.0040708994,
-0.0136332782,
-0.0032614188,
-0.0216895994,
0.0182353482,
-0.0071127247,
0.0528536029,
0.0213817656,
-0.0027219553,
-0.0300330091,
0.0096869748,
0.033464171,
0.0529326685,
0.0364609733,
-0.0172975417,
0.0317923762,
-0.0312742442,
0.0158835985,
-0.0014315189,
0.0625351518,
-0.0287264008,
-0.0365011357,
0.0343678929,
0.0420360789,
0.0017141979,
-0.0306426808,
-0.0082209613,
-0.0194676053,
-0.0219916217,
0.0019348754,
-0.0038106239,
0.0674204007,
0.0067726267,
0.0531867892,
0.0568686202,
-0.0055838204,
-0.0463343598,
-0.0176600739,
0.0374578945,
-0.0497061945,
-0.0286120679,
-0.0270412248,
0.0067201797,
0.0197151769,
-0.0910719708,
-0.031925749,
0.0208247639,
0.0451050289,
-0.0151755,
-0.0179439019,
-0.0166679509,
0.0187015943,
-0.0286267307,
0.078355059,
-0.0566381738,
0.0118726091,
-0.0553539023,
-0.0006946814,
0.0488983393,
-0.0421903506,
-0.0215081759,
0.0428586453,
-0.0153472163,
-0.0290868916,
-0.0657136664,
0.0617348142,
0.0141570773,
0.03630279,
0.0168220364,
-0.0665015802,
-0.0110717099,
0.0369839296,
-0.0004604467,
0.047525607,
-0.0220859181,
0.0033111263,
-0.0270441081,
0.0405426957,
-0.0260719266,
0.0522299595,
0.0021355366,
0.018111188,
-0.0169398263,
-0.0756949112,
-0.0163702555,
-0.0013719657,
0.0485175885,
-0.0063161296,
0.0474458225,
-0.013512319,
0.0067493464,
-0.0199706461,
-0.0240614936,
-0.0678369701,
0.0267071594,
-0.0412868075,
0.0141044967,
0.0133082606,
-0.0250711553,
-0.0332236178,
0.0899626389,
-0.0102948267,
-0.0353389531,
0.0016789567,
-0.0222403668,
-0.0309205391,
0.0100124637,
-0.0040993178,
0.0402636975,
-0.0083132302,
0.0345219448,
0.0220497772,
0.0770994946,
0.020681588,
-0.0099256104,
-0.0097814817,
-0.0185053609,
-0.0268785749,
-0.0094284527,
-0.0101082353,
0.038350001,
0.0652651116,
-0.0012217853,
0.0362078324,
-0.0056237909,
-0.018776821,
-0.0138078565,
0.0493325479,
-0.0129683716,
-0.0467862003,
0.0445580408,
0.0252677966,
-0.0110335806,
0.022460971,
0.0587020628,
0.0480672978,
0.0252513196,
0.0127108134,
0.0038341864,
-0.0387603268,
-0.0484683029,
-0.0353062414,
-0.0198390838,
0.0276535116,
0.059464477,
-0.0323139504,
-0.0516782813,
0.0583030134,
0.0111479182,
-0.0080203153,
0.0196477864,
0.0754249692,
0.0203253329,
0.0387562662,
0.0134258308,
-0.0291648172,
-0.0004848386,
-0.0188823622,
-0.0024514704,
-0.0526092574,
-5.393979173e-33,
-0.0873226896,
-0.0810126588,
0.0404496528,
0.0135962833,
-0.0253049657,
0.0227947328,
-0.0566847287,
0.0080297031,
0.0119871404,
0.0293742046,
0.0297488663,
-0.0022341737,
0.0066112857,
0.062599808,
-0.0616307743,
-0.0107888505,
0.0526354015,
0.0086139813,
-0.027966423,
0.0454520956,
0.0294973776,
0.0023741797,
0.0193491206,
-0.0687239394,
-0.0265484415,
0.0080831451,
-0.0103424722,
0.0262418017,
0.0615418255,
0.0534849651,
-0.0268394556,
0.0349497199,
0.0042136195,
0.0105573693,
-0.0211298764,
0.0547070913,
-0.0800251737,
0.01270469,
0.0362359621,
0.0175410863,
-0.0361763313,
-0.0237950832,
0.0115603115,
-0.0290626734,
0.0093670031,
-0.0332219079,
0.053901989,
-0.0381209925,
-0.0359467827,
-0.0116266888,
-0.0503946282,
0.0139434328,
-0.0132423621,
-0.0218845811,
0.0240809899,
0.0460229106,
0.0138980169,
0.0206492562,
-0.007330047,
0.0392213799,
-0.0035705431,
0.0077265631,
0.0471119583,
0.0548852794,
0.0197668485,
0.0504027121,
-0.0004335754,
-0.0230119936,
-0.0642883778,
-0.0397498943,
-0.001667312,
0.0381924547,
0.0297138933,
0.0668965802,
-0.0454713032,
0.0270778928,
-0.0399121717,
-0.0013166872,
-0.0439742357,
0.0568266623,
0.0226514358,
-0.0134583255,
0.0262136422,
0.010572114,
-0.0680728257,
-0.0000776322,
-0.0395183973,
-0.0133605246,
0.0412730947,
0.0437871777,
-0.01037494,
0.0365867205,
0.0719856918,
-0.0356535949,
-0.009544584,
0.0610645376,
-0.0203712024,
0.0400994606,
-0.0180765875,
-0.014380848,
-0.0340523496,
-0.0259385984,
0.0683945641,
0.01836464,
-0.0093017947,
-0.0076726563,
0.0139895696,
-0.0268711429,
-0.0345367938,
0.0194160081,
-0.0186544433,
0.0375287458,
-0.0489339866,
0.0376071967,
0.0091996035,
0.0062734718,
-0.0444324762,
0.0430168025,
-0.0180831291,
-0.0164232031,
0.0042652646,
-0.0687320679,
0.0125737796,
0.034315072,
-0.0377069265,
0.0138076134,
-0.0023789448,
0.0021008751,
0.0165082794,
-0.0448345728,
-0.0157643203,
0.0218488704,
2.293e-7,
0.003953008,
0.0240257513,
0.0686305612,
0.0219480041,
0.0094690183,
0.0277498942,
0.017917566,
0.0220614485,
0.017101882,
-0.0326606221,
0.0004160126,
0.0394866876,
0.0366660058,
-0.0360904038,
-0.0464222282,
0.0119024487,
-0.0767900124,
-0.0231976174,
-0.0342771783,
-0.0421404988,
0.0077958112,
0.0648156628,
-0.0400262438,
-0.0011785508,
0.0083667003,
-0.0715091228,
0.0976341367,
-0.0381903797,
-0.0078349914,
-0.0012359984,
0.0062784692,
0.0145682562,
-0.0407788791,
0.0069447537,
0.0249653943,
-0.006054183,
0.0333837271,
0.0427197032,
0.0107994042,
-0.0363196768,
-0.0505736768,
0.0242235102,
0.000199844,
-0.0029272758,
0.0394349284,
-0.0787739754,
-0.0144783156,
-0.0045666206,
-0.0622005574,
-0.0269557796,
0.0152229927,
-0.0121062361,
-0.0377965122,
0.034276206,
0.038891498,
-0.0255789459,
-0.0047297608,
-0.0752435029,
-0.0212246384,
-0.0181563236,
-0.0247941613,
-0.0018331839,
-0.0162316393,
-0.0422335416,
-0.0028340272,
0.00371729,
-0.0202366412,
1.577941717e-34,
0.0619058497,
-0.0000153169,
-0.0218854193,
0.0010152506,
0.0268371999,
-0.0105647547,
-0.0520715006,
-0.0060830689,
0.0314408094,
-0.0669930801,
-0.0003159404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13426v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13426v2 | A Chat About Boring Problems: Studying GPT-based text normalization | 2023-09-23T16:32:59 | 2024-01-17T16:36:58 | Yang Zhang, Travis M. Bartley, Mariana Graterol-Fuenmayor, Vitaly Lavrukhin, Evelina Bakhturina, Boris Ginsburg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text normalization - the conversion of text from written to spoken form - is
traditionally assumed to be an ill-formed task for language models. In this
work, we argue otherwise. We empirically show the capacity of Large-Language
Models (LLM) for text normalization in few-shot scenarios. Combining
self-consistency reasoning with linguistic-informed prompt engineering, we find
LLM based text normalization to achieve error rates around 40\% lower than top
normalization systems. Further, upon error analysis, we note key limitations in
the conventional design of text normalization tasks. We create a new taxonomy
of text normalization errors and apply it to results from GPT-3.5-Turbo and
GPT-4.0. Through this new framework, we can identify strengths and weaknesses
of GPT-based TN, opening opportunities for future work. | [
-0.0236604623,
0.0452078395,
0.0112470258,
0.0083992407,
-0.0625999495,
-0.0229738317,
0.0238415059,
0.007096644,
-0.0242507998,
-0.0223515853,
-0.0213034172,
-0.0287333727,
0.0397615023,
0.017549023,
0.0038721228,
-0.0597348735,
0.0480070114,
-0.0567936972,
-0.021611508,
-0.0023295339,
0.043205224,
0.0132817561,
0.047095187,
0.0430277847,
-0.0027566385,
-0.0356769674,
0.0056928848,
0.0167938247,
0.0031347785,
0.0163626764,
-0.0394089483,
0.0567750111,
0.0107984822,
0.0568638183,
0.0000019485,
-0.0341591202,
-0.0238160174,
-0.0102800429,
-0.0086117722,
0.0759386644,
0.0313099697,
-0.0163148269,
-0.0499731451,
0.0557089075,
0.0099965334,
-0.0150028821,
0.0350283794,
0.0503981523,
0.0613219701,
0.0549399406,
-0.0216394886,
-0.0499915741,
0.024974782,
-0.0134925134,
0.0040167207,
-0.0448629707,
0.0075262049,
0.0274432693,
0.0071654385,
0.0102315387,
0.0090448353,
0.0687831342,
0.0142637622,
-0.0254197903,
-0.0283208638,
0.032625217,
0.0194106363,
-0.0095568318,
-0.0313139409,
0.0309538171,
-0.0043743365,
-0.012165322,
0.0198558159,
-0.0027046164,
-0.0173396133,
-0.0246510152,
-0.0135028716,
0.0233692732,
-0.0087014642,
0.0326966606,
0.0122541348,
-0.0001189084,
0.0343777761,
-0.0265419129,
-0.0365929604,
0.0667515025,
0.0378597975,
-0.0490328707,
-0.0065395762,
0.0061030951,
-0.0121428417,
-0.0412163809,
0.0689570829,
0.0081123831,
-0.0312542468,
0.0058722212,
-0.0288573597,
-0.0206947848,
-0.0000751436,
0.0007817186,
-0.0063896221,
0.0462388247,
-0.0131470812,
0.0183338337,
-0.0065142605,
0.068570517,
-0.0177507307,
-0.0008828797,
-0.0537885353,
0.0030564428,
-0.0303657483,
-0.0212771874,
-0.0878444985,
0.0213706829,
-0.0165124182,
-0.0132606402,
-0.0275965668,
0.0005567041,
0.0212166104,
0.0022851471,
0.048219379,
-0.0229040422,
-0.0493530482,
-0.0585282929,
0.0170747358,
0.0680963099,
-0.044654686,
0.0026773366,
-0.0136907743,
-0.0354446173,
0.0069912849,
0.0157488436,
0.0146938367,
-0.0076657473,
-0.0008124306,
0.0163880475,
-0.0218252055,
-0.0218047649,
-0.0571639091,
-0.0190174263,
-0.0560883209,
-0.0452749953,
-0.0850147605,
-0.0671965033,
-0.008658261,
0.0073885485,
0.0114626978,
-0.0360118598,
-0.0255018044,
0.0020421166,
-0.0197911933,
0.0974812135,
-0.0033177619,
0.0382575765,
0.0682559535,
0.0165686421,
0.0259546805,
0.0297657158,
0.0377072096,
-0.0176205114,
0.0037944478,
-0.0308518168,
0.0249996744,
0.0938954204,
-0.002756791,
-0.0055786241,
-0.0251096953,
-0.0310228448,
0.0131540075,
0.0564366989,
0.0359272733,
0.1146754175,
-0.015626207,
-0.0077140769,
0.0629365072,
0.0886076912,
-0.009311391,
-0.0091694696,
0.0251786001,
0.0275424868,
-0.0238156766,
0.0385595039,
-0.0355193317,
-0.0255227163,
-0.0464259796,
0.008836356,
0.0536595583,
0.0352870189,
-0.0441837609,
-0.0206412412,
0.0071649798,
-0.0137640508,
0.0122269299,
-0.0292658899,
0.0414003097,
-0.0071676541,
-0.0226152483,
0.0119921193,
-0.0309618674,
-0.0730865672,
0.0429355986,
-0.0409658588,
-0.0019257064,
0.0330684073,
0.0641431659,
0.0034477815,
-0.0087539358,
-0.0212962814,
-0.0144143775,
0.0460255891,
0.0168924555,
-0.0095217098,
-0.0265110768,
-0.0611904077,
-0.0046762219,
0.0617384687,
0.0146750305,
0.0221651439,
-0.0212107264,
0.015941618,
0.0388587043,
-0.0214204676,
-0.0312394928,
0.0136879347,
-0.0327935889,
-0.0466432869,
0.0073080542,
-0.0026297113,
-0.0136907008,
0.0497240424,
-0.0277077779,
0.0113680214,
0.0005281909,
-0.0136853047,
-0.0048821825,
-0.0168174338,
-0.0750396773,
-0.0013222366,
0.0544147417,
-0.0005515823,
-0.0075746905,
0.0202523638,
-0.0135224704,
-0.0858381987,
-0.0087757632,
-0.0223850757,
-0.0305434279,
-0.0612780936,
0.0446899571,
-0.007457423,
-0.014726148,
-0.0222392678,
-0.0164827015,
0.0282323007,
-0.0009745222,
0.0219680425,
-0.0137645658,
0.0274554677,
-0.0783975124,
-0.0578033812,
0.0632530823,
0.0167768225,
0.0434253328,
0.0616240464,
0.0045680944,
-0.01656859,
-0.0112251313,
-0.0797199756,
0.0199113805,
-0.023811128,
0.0459747799,
0.0460405499,
0.0602049045,
-0.0104208644,
-0.0281805173,
-0.0474939905,
-0.0248431675,
0.0473159142,
0.0060644303,
0.0495185629,
-0.006136266,
-0.0311372578,
-0.0188185889,
-0.0130313179,
-0.0101101017,
-0.0202561822,
0.0076617277,
-0.0244628005,
-0.0838578269,
0.0432853326,
-0.0091246041,
0.0339816362,
0.0298100896,
-0.0279330537,
0.0021776531,
-0.016561972,
0.0849831551,
0.0354969315,
0.0002343816,
-0.0013032254,
0.0322749652,
-0.0246193353,
-0.0553778037,
0.006430455,
0.0070213708,
-0.059278179,
-0.0143488953,
-0.0529473722,
0.0210977737,
0.0879558101,
0.0241870526,
0.0231231917,
-0.0759591833,
0.0033805673,
-0.0494837612,
0.0058478541,
-0.0258733444,
-0.0250528418,
-0.0318607502,
0.0287793316,
0.0017141741,
-0.0468639322,
0.0779627934,
-0.0780821964,
-0.0329934321,
-0.0481050238,
-0.0255684406,
-0.0137618287,
0.046368897,
-0.022525996,
0.0309526864,
0.0325782113,
-0.0615369603,
-0.0246600974,
-0.0314264484,
0.014582905,
-0.023132449,
0.0589918196,
-0.0464646891,
0.0258527491,
-0.0268061794,
-0.0516125038,
0.0051774401,
-0.0335154757,
-0.0376637094,
0.0159976874,
0.0065184976,
-0.0294878762,
-0.0065673306,
0.0656808987,
0.0215958972,
0.0673166513,
-0.0204161629,
-0.0099652754,
-0.0266187582,
0.0511198826,
0.0136224544,
0.01656265,
-0.0327705368,
-0.0075125122,
0.0540488176,
0.0120243505,
0.0555156656,
0.0119909458,
-0.0108919861,
-0.0236193296,
0.0142776286,
-0.0398343168,
-0.0383113138,
0.0216312967,
0.0519486032,
-0.0498464368,
-0.0070313723,
0.1351497471,
0.0147010274,
-0.0411582589,
-0.041846782,
-0.0049501285,
0.0447921306,
-0.0356051289,
0.0088664806,
-0.0539372154,
-0.0290949065,
0.033771798,
0.0419930033,
0.0278369021,
-0.0092750359,
-0.0029866786,
-0.0842904001,
0.0265717804,
0.0405057594,
-0.0399585031,
-0.0249221548,
-0.0205435958,
-0.0019652939,
-0.0084112007,
0.099274233,
0.0415776335,
0.0041176984,
-0.0078219501,
0.0262220241,
-0.0381746069,
-0.0435981117,
0.0126394071,
-0.0334110782,
0.0904849321,
0.0709238797,
0.0131776845,
-0.022518931,
-0.0252821799,
0.0436923131,
0.0127000306,
-0.0138306413,
-0.0003067937,
-0.0085313469,
0.0197451524,
-0.0088121276,
-0.0147771863,
0.0121784015,
-0.0101874666,
0.0064047859,
0.0223462768,
0.0768459141,
-0.0019168593,
-0.0454691425,
-0.0006771123,
-0.0144604854,
0.0084497193,
0.093588911,
0.0097402586,
-0.0462127775,
-0.0767235383,
-0.0410720371,
-0.0060229544,
-0.013558072,
-0.0570837781,
0.0039221537,
-0.0019634459,
-0.0249534044,
-0.032332629,
-0.0480016135,
0.0297302343,
0.0294842534,
0.0064420686,
0.0186070558,
0.0210363623,
0.0065442929,
0.022971658,
-0.0181409083,
-0.0692136064,
0.0204313006,
-0.0929046348,
0.0578088202,
0.0244909264,
-0.0023116982,
0.0003918095,
0.035970334,
-0.0297100097,
-0.054281462,
-0.0158476345,
-0.0398337394,
0.0346863791,
0.0193293672,
-0.0388246365,
-0.0720541477,
0.0222556423,
0.050600592,
-0.0464750268,
0.0180338789,
0.0056483001,
0.0144524751,
-0.0178835765,
0.0447387323,
-0.0048880656,
0.0171069894,
-0.0540346652,
0.0410196483,
-0.007052124,
-0.0576941036,
0.0201759078,
0.0901818275,
0.0319268964,
-0.0085119428,
0.0509398133,
-0.006799005,
-0.0285856128,
-0.0495280139,
0.0088059669,
-0.02961546,
0.040199291,
0.0649580434,
0.0069256066,
-0.0221128743,
-0.0346553214,
-0.0345871486,
0.0107315248,
-0.0279655177,
-0.0155584011,
0.0018324406,
0.0175050851,
0.0500995703,
-0.0418075658,
-0.0058116331,
0.010073253,
0.0221791957,
0.0331659205,
-0.0288398452,
0.0271259472,
0.0133249052,
0.0188201331,
-0.0158499815,
0.015954867,
-0.0463512093,
-0.0444778651,
-0.0261748936,
0.0458202027,
0.0370128676,
0.0420847125,
0.0855630636,
-0.0252032187,
0.0121907219,
-0.0600358509,
0.0109996162,
0.0438645333,
0.0081640808,
0.0095771402,
0.0003176068,
-0.0230647009,
-0.0087382831,
0.0477019623,
-0.0005522943,
0.0201525483,
0.0002251044,
-0.0283032879,
-0.0191547368,
-0.0192923248,
-0.0309235379,
-0.0037094988,
-0.057213217,
-0.0392141677,
-0.0573467575,
-0.0555960163,
0.0002185842,
0.0456154682,
0.0050500762,
-0.027124349,
0.004322533,
0.0375216343,
-0.0286456626,
0.0046571172,
0.0151070869,
0.016433524,
-0.0344914161,
-0.0425397493,
0.0129648428,
-6.123285623e-33,
-0.049152784,
0.0014983898,
0.0166099239,
-0.0192519259,
-0.0148109151,
-0.0071946527,
-0.0277674031,
0.0090091135,
0.0321819521,
-0.0023052366,
-0.0451351367,
0.0112302247,
0.0295829847,
-0.0079238452,
0.0153133897,
0.0059848176,
0.0732812285,
-0.0457275324,
-0.0413257629,
0.0339912437,
0.0160597693,
0.008178506,
0.0612727515,
-0.0495219007,
0.0269430038,
-0.0020723543,
-0.0634732693,
0.0326522626,
0.0293553844,
0.0221574493,
-0.042108085,
0.0615610592,
0.0072717504,
-0.0622091517,
-0.0322544388,
0.0632394105,
-0.0875743255,
-0.01361359,
0.01941544,
0.0036714245,
-0.0103227431,
0.0105500678,
0.0280961469,
-0.0276373774,
-0.0586234629,
0.0269051809,
-0.0176223405,
0.0205818117,
0.0293270182,
0.0172294676,
-0.0391248018,
0.0371013023,
-0.0136046754,
-0.0144765424,
0.0715618283,
-0.0032837992,
-0.0360752791,
-0.0189617872,
-0.0143602816,
0.0052853054,
0.036303848,
0.0522331856,
0.0514624305,
0.0190888997,
-0.0318042263,
-0.0112923756,
0.0435493253,
-0.0174512006,
-0.0467320085,
-0.0240959153,
0.0335075706,
-0.026854476,
0.03658868,
0.0314331278,
0.0124332886,
-0.0049062525,
-0.0171122774,
0.0543638542,
0.0392383598,
0.0180040225,
0.0093086995,
0.0259619281,
-0.0502803102,
-0.058332257,
-0.0545099415,
-0.0358651504,
-0.0249351691,
-0.0262482073,
0.0467194878,
-0.0002937958,
0.011220607,
0.0069576586,
0.0480920784,
-0.0161906369,
-0.0413562916,
0.0258357842,
-0.0197086576,
0.0173894353,
-0.016787583,
0.0562340878,
-0.0304026399,
-0.0061092423,
0.0001426952,
0.0325931273,
-0.0027179967,
0.0085013025,
-0.0531886294,
0.0371772312,
-0.0891931579,
-0.0041785296,
-0.0056949775,
-0.0003381677,
-0.0207233578,
-0.0068364423,
0.0406836793,
-0.0368777998,
0.0261909161,
0.0161611605,
0.0200454891,
-0.0275395773,
-0.0348805822,
0.0173506625,
0.011944239,
0.0121057667,
-0.0137528153,
0.0299997237,
-0.0070241578,
-0.0068388544,
0.0437214784,
0.0082646385,
-0.0122976936,
0.0054577738,
2.64e-7,
0.0458974317,
0.0335460715,
0.0736743584,
-0.0006439288,
0.0098216515,
0.0406442471,
-0.0170813855,
0.0348157957,
0.0208105668,
0.0000461912,
0.0444705412,
-0.0172203165,
0.0474636182,
0.0204443764,
-0.0709474906,
-0.0068986504,
-0.0767030641,
0.0121450489,
-0.0632817075,
0.0370355621,
0.0532130748,
0.0505849347,
-0.0069582756,
-0.0087911161,
0.010447708,
-0.0754690021,
0.0184293371,
-0.0300025996,
0.0086580114,
0.0418023877,
0.0743066519,
-0.0054369899,
-0.0019031108,
0.0084547345,
0.0469936952,
0.009302076,
0.0438097715,
0.0932526812,
0.0006655336,
0.0230717976,
-0.0343514755,
-0.0325394124,
-0.0059524416,
-0.0731878206,
0.054137364,
-0.0094005549,
0.0091208899,
0.0025876863,
-0.0104331831,
-0.0373964533,
0.016488459,
0.000946488,
-0.0330269039,
0.0197509155,
0.0297860671,
0.0236927662,
-0.0248880275,
-0.071356982,
-0.0169245768,
0.0324797407,
-0.0238825846,
-0.0379267223,
-0.042431131,
0.0381685272,
0.0138769578,
-0.0584665537,
-0.0058763959,
2.432680278e-34,
0.0341966227,
-0.0331942849,
0.0433176905,
-0.0051978421,
0.0061016981,
0.0137125915,
0.0220250245,
-0.0004661096,
-0.0038659093,
-0.1147146821,
-0.0277641434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15857v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15857v3 | A Survey on Image-text Multimodal Models | 2023-09-23T15:21:15 | 2024-06-19T02:53:38 | Ruifeng Guo, Jingxuan Wei, Linzhuang Sun, Bihui Yu, Guiyong Chang, Dawei Liu, Sibo Zhang, Zhengbing Yao, Mingjun Xu, Liping Bu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM | With the significant advancements of Large Language Models (LLMs) in the
field of Natural Language Processing (NLP), the development of image-text
multimodal models has garnered widespread attention. Current surveys on
image-text multimodal models mainly focus on representative models or
application domains, but lack a review on how general technical models
influence the development of domain-specific models, which is crucial for
domain researchers. Based on this, this paper first reviews the technological
evolution of image-text multimodal models, from early explorations of feature
space to visual language encoding structures, and then to the latest large
model architectures. Next, from the perspective of technological evolution, we
explain how the development of general image-text multimodal technologies
promotes the progress of multimodal technologies in the biomedical field, as
well as the importance and complexity of specific datasets in the biomedical
domain. Then, centered on the tasks of image-text multimodal models, we analyze
their common components and challenges. After that, we summarize the
architecture, components, and data of general image-text multimodal models, and
introduce the applications and improvements of image-text multimodal models in
the biomedical field. Finally, we categorize the challenges faced in the
development and application of general models into external factors and
intrinsic factors, further refining them into 2 external factors and 5
intrinsic factors, and propose targeted solutions, providing guidance for
future research directions. For more details and data, please visit our GitHub
page: \url{https://github.com/i2vec/A-survey-on-image-text-multimodal-models}. | [
0.0404962227,
0.0461393595,
-0.0211075749,
0.0301530603,
-0.0402144417,
-0.0083658379,
0.0348126516,
0.0392907783,
-0.0210087616,
-0.0714754015,
-0.0320895202,
-0.0667923987,
0.031108493,
0.0453916378,
0.0691821873,
-0.0893776044,
0.0079219164,
-0.0186657626,
-0.0244980548,
-0.0016744985,
0.0327560604,
-0.0113129532,
-0.0042245421,
0.0460540503,
-0.0350272357,
-0.0300436709,
-0.0004743683,
0.0300666746,
-0.0178112537,
-0.0343925171,
-0.0557737164,
0.0212409962,
0.0492988862,
-0.0333002433,
0.0000020246,
-0.0157445539,
0.0122550884,
0.0278205965,
0.0354124121,
-0.0088613732,
0.0890203044,
-0.0591675267,
0.0029759477,
-0.0564123914,
0.0002793611,
-0.006840039,
0.0863632187,
0.059086699,
0.0484295674,
0.0306435265,
-0.0356883481,
-0.0326180197,
0.0594938584,
-0.0172836594,
-0.0104642883,
-0.0136736296,
0.0170101169,
0.0148606226,
0.0439489074,
0.0516510382,
-0.0796672776,
0.061554309,
-0.0241479725,
-0.0020239826,
0.0088036489,
0.0439684354,
0.0467563793,
-0.072528027,
-0.0468257964,
0.0498928986,
-0.0431573316,
0.0239703786,
-0.0089972438,
0.0054480429,
-0.0439474508,
0.0511514656,
-0.0423967913,
0.0200047903,
0.0045065056,
0.0213315692,
-0.0447773635,
-0.0121732578,
0.0064698113,
-0.0216088686,
0.0064064856,
-0.0203061365,
0.0200346019,
-0.0034474421,
-0.0097437333,
-0.0016445651,
-0.0400250889,
-0.0252010543,
0.0290139522,
0.007254994,
0.0320419557,
-0.0032637888,
-0.0292414036,
-0.0777415261,
0.0285862871,
-0.0496680178,
0.0314432755,
-0.0157404784,
-0.0665979981,
0.0613529198,
-0.0180935636,
0.0355941355,
-0.0755630955,
0.0296571087,
-0.0241110083,
0.0030661169,
-0.0164204556,
-0.0171747264,
-0.0189832412,
0.0011748688,
-0.0369714797,
-0.0836452469,
-0.0295975637,
0.0147986524,
0.0415980108,
-0.0223158095,
-0.0148542039,
0.0270803142,
-0.0076464731,
-0.0023430709,
-0.0159459244,
0.0356226116,
0.0326757319,
0.0054554525,
-0.0347989649,
-0.0153602092,
0.0473986566,
0.0589053594,
0.0018666026,
-0.040397197,
-0.019730838,
0.0999804065,
-0.0132090328,
-0.0401158519,
0.0015443494,
-0.0348980241,
-0.0615754686,
-0.042782627,
0.0380170792,
-0.0272486806,
0.0279384758,
0.0150136799,
0.0396533869,
-0.0144736627,
0.000027285,
0.0223008897,
-0.0497550331,
0.1125478372,
-0.0238830987,
0.0054571675,
0.0545986257,
-0.0013480964,
0.0081863459,
0.0269111842,
0.0338306092,
0.0201560706,
0.0320379846,
-0.0391760208,
-0.0107818153,
0.0510959812,
-0.0165701341,
-0.0418360718,
-0.0444564633,
-0.0267797988,
0.0282277614,
0.0397579968,
0.0007707747,
0.0748077929,
-0.0204455797,
-0.0264193974,
0.0876302272,
0.0695994794,
0.0392841175,
0.0044806823,
0.006139725,
-0.0298683941,
0.0015056821,
0.0009233687,
-0.0065647922,
0.0304748826,
0.0010475541,
-0.0195713341,
0.0226841122,
0.0478490852,
-0.0096104955,
-0.0168077815,
-0.0392409787,
-0.0291914549,
0.0138405152,
-0.0377716869,
0.0852378756,
-0.0194845833,
-0.0348143838,
-0.0024059988,
0.0082537215,
-0.0168234538,
-0.0241033193,
-0.0351254866,
-0.0047176797,
0.0475610048,
0.0762708783,
-0.0071358769,
0.0236311853,
0.0011037962,
0.0208162926,
0.0373242721,
-0.0246650148,
0.0238500629,
0.0163859986,
-0.0602191538,
-0.0451627858,
0.0206171591,
-0.0057053491,
-0.0443774574,
-0.0322533287,
0.0044250167,
-0.0527927242,
0.0097998539,
0.020307567,
0.0347868986,
0.0115840277,
0.0257928129,
-0.0602393635,
0.0253281277,
0.0105359303,
-0.0033401856,
-0.0316446759,
0.0184554271,
0.0176155139,
-0.0408348218,
0.0000184505,
0.0040389583,
-0.0138584347,
-0.0293565895,
-0.0140209896,
-0.0500493422,
0.0273950323,
-0.0159843564,
-0.0000776372,
-0.0100395968,
-0.0119336918,
-0.0466746837,
0.0044307262,
-0.035091836,
0.0235340577,
0.0141649712,
0.0358820781,
-0.0527312309,
0.0335732885,
-0.0431426503,
-0.0177975446,
0.0006858024,
0.004676979,
0.0078293169,
-0.0149981165,
-0.0500175394,
0.0430226997,
-0.0000077027,
0.0194989368,
0.0151832504,
-0.0085420506,
0.0086821914,
-0.0156876575,
-0.0795679614,
-0.0290406048,
0.0083944565,
-0.0246520229,
-0.0317965299,
-0.0121669034,
0.0142618176,
-0.0290964227,
-0.001570917,
0.0306443386,
0.0170228966,
0.0227541644,
0.0461273566,
0.0084585892,
0.0230182316,
-0.0348700434,
-0.0302835666,
-0.0028032034,
0.0874555483,
-0.0116428407,
-0.0730613694,
-0.0068513192,
-0.013932067,
-0.0226398222,
0.0290550645,
-0.0025654172,
-0.0144919977,
0.0320556425,
-0.0174410865,
0.0663428158,
0.0337854847,
0.0178847034,
0.0594842732,
0.0043851165,
-0.0025723982,
0.0209469888,
-0.0045794421,
-0.0244346019,
0.0170529056,
-0.0006119962,
-0.030759478,
-0.015036108,
0.0824204534,
0.0167975351,
0.0221700463,
-0.0463916622,
-0.004849087,
-0.0250001624,
-0.0348401219,
-0.0579541959,
0.0164700057,
-0.027133463,
0.0044661611,
-0.056191843,
-0.076165475,
0.0150816906,
-0.0177213643,
-0.0089896116,
0.0043476196,
-0.0024276529,
-0.0135075804,
0.0827104598,
0.0564555228,
0.0468887165,
0.0268659014,
0.0258003268,
-0.0127299577,
0.0133193983,
0.0120563991,
-0.0415653363,
0.0543883629,
-0.032369636,
0.0255467203,
-0.00250698,
-0.0283792987,
0.0165304132,
-0.0143796429,
-0.0194757357,
-0.0279514138,
-0.0154260481,
0.0127732698,
-0.0116525628,
0.0666628033,
0.0311467089,
0.0016954333,
0.0174039584,
-0.0079196254,
-0.023062421,
0.0841279179,
0.0260234587,
-0.0011048137,
-0.060271021,
-0.0388817303,
-0.002778824,
0.057781525,
-0.0161978677,
0.0155174993,
-0.0344851948,
0.0398011245,
0.0344098322,
0.0640504956,
-0.0511654355,
0.0153291933,
0.0560747758,
-0.0309535004,
0.0491381213,
0.0380248129,
0.0160863474,
-0.0423137695,
-0.0083978288,
0.0288956426,
-0.0075177504,
0.0032466615,
-0.024883138,
-0.0638771653,
-0.0611927211,
-0.027496757,
-0.0481227376,
-0.0058282185,
0.0083119171,
-0.0037698718,
-0.036519222,
0.0461114235,
-0.0029884519,
-0.0128873056,
-0.0051368014,
-0.0133330049,
-0.0102969352,
0.0082021113,
-0.0272103865,
-0.0013689308,
-0.0091616279,
-0.0280465279,
0.0317483246,
-0.0080999862,
-0.0439174362,
-0.0199208427,
-0.0477373786,
-0.0065814806,
0.0829786956,
0.0345823616,
-0.0068953605,
-0.0441966206,
0.0155239655,
0.0414571613,
0.0517934784,
-0.0270012468,
0.0690087304,
-0.0202538874,
-0.0424687639,
-0.0402817763,
0.0277803317,
0.0262228064,
-0.0157465562,
-0.0732135177,
0.056530647,
-0.0052227848,
-0.021014424,
-0.0864292979,
-0.0026773855,
-0.0209801905,
0.012208092,
-0.0124535682,
-0.0875978619,
-0.0401005037,
-0.0102378847,
0.0463019609,
-0.0094457902,
-0.0515133962,
0.0045720274,
-0.0347756408,
0.007546688,
-0.0513573587,
0.0252405461,
0.0056129051,
0.0044806749,
-0.0231180042,
0.0271020215,
0.0053442973,
-0.0034585719,
-0.0406672955,
0.0416015759,
0.0174433719,
0.0349111408,
-0.0360665359,
-0.0002440921,
0.0458703786,
-0.0294562858,
-0.0046451613,
0.0393542759,
-0.059220016,
-0.0148675507,
-0.0410309918,
0.0579973906,
0.0096742278,
-0.0206660517,
0.0216504969,
-0.0823610872,
0.0322343856,
0.0156294033,
-0.0034900152,
0.0205586832,
-0.0182057153,
-0.018917216,
-0.02947543,
-0.0013335585,
-0.0126775606,
0.0270828661,
-0.015548354,
0.0118201599,
0.0127254687,
-0.0292574055,
0.0047604972,
-0.0195100997,
0.0661528334,
-0.0156792719,
0.0079917749,
-0.0183988381,
-0.0173270609,
-0.0115333842,
0.0045859665,
-0.0636136606,
0.0061671995,
0.009426469,
0.0207305606,
-0.015254342,
-0.016317172,
0.003367943,
0.0242998861,
-0.0347266532,
0.0565915518,
0.0257169679,
-0.0150610702,
0.0125971977,
0.0455804951,
0.0233046319,
0.0443976633,
-0.0620352104,
-0.0133104641,
0.0047760024,
0.073787041,
0.0227354672,
-0.0330690406,
-0.0147501705,
0.0618986674,
0.0041181846,
0.0389984399,
-0.049223721,
0.0310126822,
0.0552340746,
0.0334895477,
0.0379901454,
-0.0122398986,
-0.0201026686,
-0.0345182046,
0.0390273742,
0.0034000347,
-0.001938802,
0.0716640428,
-0.0201041121,
0.0133656124,
-0.0281850602,
0.0622233562,
0.0245987959,
0.0146399988,
-0.0018245452,
-0.0443001091,
-0.0255467817,
-0.0037387779,
0.0608992167,
-0.0034620392,
-0.025666805,
0.0307193529,
-0.0414505117,
-0.0441069975,
0.0351108685,
0.0098257111,
-0.013218753,
-0.0076874169,
0.0286947619,
0.0434021428,
0.0245673973,
-0.0205161143,
-0.0402972475,
-0.0055632805,
-0.0228085183,
-0.0015216208,
0.0412170067,
-5.902662231e-33,
0.0011144135,
-0.03421437,
0.0273647327,
-0.0333208777,
-0.0256211795,
0.019229291,
0.0050221761,
0.0352967754,
0.0066607026,
-0.001499971,
0.0382528603,
-0.0582776368,
-0.0029369723,
0.0312611684,
0.0012947235,
0.0407505929,
-0.0012958444,
-0.0419548638,
0.0148696462,
-0.0138269411,
-0.0014496332,
0.028034905,
0.0373018533,
-0.0452635996,
0.0080087436,
0.0279217064,
-0.0272655431,
-0.0014880991,
0.0095558586,
0.0663456097,
-0.0789054185,
0.0340346135,
0.0393561758,
-0.0285864566,
-0.0341098011,
0.0469512269,
-0.0405467786,
0.0215417426,
0.0086991964,
0.0086102653,
-0.0930276364,
-0.0006367192,
0.054890506,
-0.023126442,
-0.0208787248,
-0.0046840645,
0.0462333784,
-0.0326402634,
-0.0125945229,
0.0146969222,
-0.0499787889,
0.0443366505,
0.0098131793,
-0.0234256275,
0.0329587385,
0.0090624951,
0.0197652876,
0.079757452,
-0.0401822142,
0.0165568162,
0.0084157558,
-0.0021436631,
0.0544132479,
0.0338812843,
0.0236948188,
0.0525649823,
0.0286507364,
-0.0516629554,
-0.0324646533,
0.0128870336,
0.0127908466,
0.0863322094,
0.0569399782,
0.041608382,
0.0034067784,
0.006970922,
-0.0228259433,
-0.0078903977,
-0.0643555075,
0.0193519723,
0.0410865135,
0.0415864177,
-0.0136997197,
-0.0031141979,
-0.0345959961,
-0.0205278229,
-0.0308451839,
-0.0211580135,
0.0432701297,
0.0293902587,
0.0012883146,
0.0673647448,
0.0616161972,
-0.0319450982,
-0.0408730134,
-0.0532229804,
-0.0045661931,
0.1021346673,
-0.0218042433,
0.0086779315,
-0.0433711484,
-0.0457999855,
0.045033779,
-0.0068805073,
0.0065556117,
-0.014806821,
-0.0134276832,
0.0191720501,
-0.0272675715,
-0.0196158085,
0.0132253012,
-0.0480540842,
0.0038150649,
0.0316923298,
0.0414873026,
0.0065980251,
-0.0464852415,
0.0493461899,
-0.0076194159,
-0.0195524674,
-0.0318956822,
-0.077871643,
-0.005880414,
0.0039751315,
-0.0137452502,
0.0398766361,
-0.0425736718,
-0.0404567309,
0.0387178771,
-0.0513843931,
-0.0142863952,
0.0506690405,
2.559e-7,
0.0794922486,
0.0584748052,
0.0243714657,
-0.0301313121,
0.0401323624,
0.03669478,
-0.0330275074,
0.055009257,
-0.0356484801,
-0.041571252,
-0.0119977947,
0.0379726812,
0.0293271933,
-0.0271662232,
0.0169076454,
0.0176104456,
-0.033207316,
0.0035013882,
-0.0436015241,
0.0294726565,
0.0815456584,
0.0839011595,
-0.0573914163,
-0.0564371534,
0.0275922604,
-0.0309620947,
0.1090765446,
-0.0409321226,
-0.0078292033,
-0.0216099527,
-0.0080521973,
0.0086494209,
-0.0212157369,
0.0179276094,
0.0170825552,
-0.0440032855,
0.0761404186,
0.0307851881,
-0.0565061234,
0.0058989991,
0.033397723,
0.0342665352,
-0.0525342114,
-0.0308878049,
0.0825695395,
-0.0320142359,
-0.0163957868,
-0.0509521663,
0.0288913492,
0.0160283409,
0.0390547514,
-0.0265830364,
-0.0446013585,
0.02432454,
0.0404097177,
0.0140955197,
-0.0413233824,
-0.0673142895,
-0.0278266873,
0.0138157038,
-0.0542695336,
-0.0116477581,
-0.0677505136,
-0.0277054515,
0.0296748523,
-0.0705604479,
-0.0579349101,
1.959088528e-34,
0.0185462665,
-0.0283155534,
-0.0001404384,
0.0082202964,
0.0065775416,
-0.029938763,
-0.0319210254,
-0.0019514508,
-0.0349752381,
-0.0819772258,
-0.0138783548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13391v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13391v2 | D-Separation for Causal Self-Explanation | 2023-09-23T14:23:19 | 2023-10-31T08:43:05 | Wei Liu, Jun Wang, Haozhao Wang, Ruixuan Li, Zhiying Deng, YuanKai Zhang, Yang Qiu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Rationalization is a self-explaining framework for NLP models. Conventional
work typically uses the maximum mutual information (MMI) criterion to find the
rationale that is most indicative of the target label. However, this criterion
can be influenced by spurious features that correlate with the causal rationale
or the target label. Instead of attempting to rectify the issues of the MMI
criterion, we propose a novel criterion to uncover the causal rationale, termed
the Minimum Conditional Dependence (MCD) criterion, which is grounded on our
finding that the non-causal features and the target label are
\emph{d-separated} by the causal rationale. By minimizing the dependence
between the unselected parts of the input and the target label conditioned on
the selected rationale candidate, all the causes of the label are compelled to
be selected. In this study, we employ a simple and practical measure of
dependence, specifically the KL-divergence, to validate our proposed MCD
criterion. Empirically, we demonstrate that MCD improves the F1 score by up to
$13.7\%$ compared to previous state-of-the-art MMI-based methods. Our code is
available at: \url{https://github.com/jugechengzi/Rationalization-MCD}. | [
0.0022860677,
0.0465563945,
-0.000092213,
0.033582896,
-0.0275663808,
0.0130998623,
0.0218797661,
0.0259244386,
-0.0088712163,
-0.0494141318,
0.0420785733,
0.047360599,
-0.0218200535,
-0.004694073,
-0.0268896371,
-0.0434006751,
0.032227762,
-0.0163631402,
0.0204694308,
-0.01639295,
-0.018771844,
0.008157637,
-0.0267887358,
0.0193491876,
-0.0259786379,
-0.0531583093,
0.0193682499,
-0.0204025172,
-0.0340594947,
-0.0061434191,
-0.0413603522,
0.0665989667,
-0.0188654978,
-0.0198416356,
0.0000023637,
-0.0463176891,
-0.0357070677,
-0.0420965068,
-0.0304040257,
0.0199908689,
-0.0718040019,
0.0065855626,
0.0427496396,
-0.0165205803,
-0.0207830705,
0.0191194974,
0.0039135627,
0.124133572,
0.0372057818,
0.0624845363,
0.0032481586,
-0.0477751382,
-0.0178917032,
0.0023865281,
-0.007935863,
-0.0093178032,
0.0122284451,
0.0425326005,
-0.0629245117,
0.0085315183,
-0.0084932623,
0.020639779,
0.0148097854,
-0.0053909044,
0.0789367929,
0.0249983482,
0.0525388978,
-0.0384645052,
0.0140998904,
0.0566517413,
0.03527629,
-0.0449601449,
0.0335045531,
-0.0235377084,
-0.0024801511,
0.0478632934,
-0.0293764267,
-0.0110136438,
0.0095334239,
0.0203915183,
0.0815860033,
0.0355007388,
0.050345473,
0.0226779431,
-0.0387240127,
0.077391319,
-0.0078819329,
-0.0372334272,
-0.0027052807,
-0.0106278583,
-0.0373093188,
-0.0321747176,
-0.0378040969,
0.0182671957,
-0.0080095511,
0.0143190892,
0.0049931156,
0.0048502306,
0.0006884528,
-0.0203267802,
-0.0462779179,
-0.0295425057,
0.0412272401,
0.0108033838,
0.0051195822,
0.0346675105,
-0.0069652312,
0.0290512871,
-0.003286018,
0.0388861969,
-0.0799706727,
-0.0241105873,
-0.0135788638,
0.0482588112,
-0.0086285044,
-0.000953545,
-0.0184932724,
-0.0075599211,
-0.0593885742,
-0.0114601552,
0.0214577969,
0.0283842385,
0.0296216495,
0.0018541006,
-0.0258997399,
0.0098292315,
-0.086599946,
0.0110808844,
-0.0056403866,
-0.0184576083,
-0.0098323794,
0.0104708606,
0.0249352343,
-0.0278148912,
-0.0335212871,
0.0637061149,
0.020756349,
-0.0399782695,
-0.0538397133,
-0.0592665933,
-0.0280744694,
-0.0407117121,
-0.0224983711,
-0.0299864914,
-0.0290165432,
-0.0155869806,
0.0198893156,
-0.0692029074,
-0.0067482553,
-0.0180191211,
-0.0220295843,
0.0908405781,
-0.0456639342,
0.0274318438,
0.0086769899,
0.0050517167,
0.0043404396,
0.0692715347,
-0.0087309629,
0.0014812355,
0.0583003387,
-0.0460893996,
0.026040623,
-0.0507901572,
0.0271505136,
-0.0079268897,
-0.0210334789,
-0.0258244574,
-0.0432994738,
0.0096782409,
0.0223034341,
-0.0146688605,
-0.0006871028,
-0.003371326,
0.0285165161,
0.042715732,
0.048894003,
0.0074783531,
0.0354702249,
0.0506725982,
-0.0155405337,
0.0737123787,
-0.0155580891,
0.0195656139,
-0.0438618548,
-0.0110615455,
0.0601016246,
-0.0094516044,
-0.0229481254,
-0.0926996693,
-0.0119147105,
-0.0147195114,
-0.0171778798,
-0.002553215,
0.0707126334,
0.0349142179,
0.0033171745,
0.0302145854,
0.0368301906,
-0.0298967157,
0.0003221752,
-0.0034293698,
0.0381815135,
0.0616069585,
0.0325152054,
-0.0489767529,
0.0069982982,
-0.0043316521,
-0.0173219535,
-0.0064806878,
0.0080807917,
-0.0210499614,
0.0155083705,
-0.0006384647,
-0.0105433976,
-0.0408544429,
0.064961262,
-0.0245743953,
-0.0044307318,
-0.0300998278,
-0.0052947802,
-0.0360466056,
0.0037946608,
0.0546002612,
0.0079766978,
-0.0643390641,
0.0265302472,
0.0475633293,
0.0497698002,
0.0612849519,
-0.0131115951,
0.0165383127,
0.0187432803,
-0.0253471993,
-0.0543689094,
0.0339266807,
-0.0394850001,
-0.0374378823,
0.0072484817,
-0.0288184378,
-0.0134991454,
0.0083081611,
-0.0149771571,
-0.0740765259,
0.0808256194,
-0.0045233686,
-0.0164245367,
-0.0243430696,
0.0202252362,
0.0147138368,
0.0093880007,
-0.0437498167,
0.0915045589,
0.0228097141,
0.0356417447,
-0.0453379601,
0.006137012,
0.0498168208,
-0.0330336615,
0.0478704795,
0.023595266,
-0.0429554246,
-0.0075967903,
0.0418477841,
-0.0330307484,
-0.0428443514,
0.0095009124,
-0.0281512924,
-0.0338713042,
-0.026456872,
-0.0368147418,
0.0291146003,
0.0107222078,
0.0141930096,
-0.0063727405,
0.0177359208,
-0.0290268753,
-0.0113990214,
-0.0025324535,
0.0508687608,
-0.0355977342,
0.0205700155,
-0.0197202973,
-0.0002606345,
-0.022011172,
0.0611487292,
0.015165681,
-0.0014307234,
-0.000041357,
0.0139441919,
-0.0227623638,
-0.0036193018,
-0.0027334427,
-0.0158543717,
0.022940658,
-0.0287413504,
-0.0178014878,
0.0319739431,
0.0179984048,
0.036544133,
0.0474463962,
0.0074850242,
-0.0632599145,
0.0123005286,
-0.0375158079,
0.0751525313,
-0.0173942018,
-0.0356353633,
0.038773004,
0.1071458533,
-0.0012318082,
-0.0058143712,
-0.089704521,
0.022363456,
-0.0210444927,
-0.0486117378,
-0.0427477621,
-0.0137177147,
0.010413249,
0.0582678355,
-0.0019326349,
-0.0574793853,
0.0801519006,
-0.0312639773,
0.0378433913,
-0.0178558547,
-0.0198261719,
-0.0296957605,
0.0809345767,
-0.0399869904,
-0.0087770922,
0.0970125496,
-0.0227495767,
0.0360484496,
-0.0193020012,
0.0476119965,
0.0175489299,
0.0842713714,
-0.062398307,
0.0309414472,
0.0567040965,
-0.0349013954,
-0.0275529139,
-0.0652413964,
-0.0048792562,
-0.0496859476,
-0.0145940688,
-0.0143985953,
-0.004277423,
-0.0058870232,
0.0138331382,
-0.0076831887,
-0.0079643559,
0.0103159612,
0.0052650729,
0.0265762117,
0.0439701192,
-0.0013860905,
0.0087970505,
0.0047465614,
0.0868014619,
-0.002223324,
0.0352063477,
0.004027558,
-0.01937267,
0.01343711,
-0.0095428638,
-0.0362948626,
-0.0423233323,
-0.0247983653,
0.0633087829,
-0.014573534,
-0.0040185903,
0.1337139904,
0.0178832412,
-0.0202800967,
0.0106198797,
0.0151550602,
0.0103894649,
0.0104588615,
-0.031572178,
-0.007578094,
-0.0430327095,
0.0049825776,
0.0191534385,
0.0020641726,
-0.0171577595,
0.0051796786,
-0.0654727742,
0.0397196189,
-0.022045197,
0.0067643467,
-0.0275166519,
-0.0988366231,
-0.0162503812,
-0.0414514281,
-0.05766242,
-0.0338418931,
-0.0023340895,
0.0365415998,
0.0236555506,
-0.0720584244,
-0.0360000543,
-0.0071625682,
0.005491789,
0.0333565325,
0.0043238578,
0.0429812558,
0.0060446076,
-0.0253347829,
-0.0316169038,
-0.0380042717,
0.0118802357,
-0.0447544754,
0.0891562477,
0.0257723629,
-0.0146703608,
0.0004572192,
0.0150404163,
-0.031375248,
-0.035375677,
-0.0130361347,
0.0637954846,
-0.0428990275,
-0.027628962,
0.0185312834,
0.0153145073,
-0.0304664765,
0.0978800654,
0.053989768,
-0.0150343422,
-0.0563036501,
-0.0186686255,
0.0146446293,
-0.0599986203,
-0.0393278152,
-0.0132323308,
0.0276514906,
-0.0638931543,
-0.0748558119,
-0.0690864548,
-0.0110891648,
0.0561889112,
-0.0234110281,
0.0595054403,
-0.0231538247,
-0.0170127563,
-0.0305936206,
0.0371756777,
-0.0054013617,
-0.0256159529,
0.0199506357,
0.0013910901,
0.0124774519,
-0.028697148,
0.0056645875,
0.0070953462,
0.0321823731,
-0.0524583831,
0.0063418802,
0.0103319744,
0.0193695799,
0.0840522721,
-0.0413350724,
-0.0560073219,
-0.0228069071,
-0.0134440092,
-0.0041963002,
-0.0058621201,
0.0462568663,
-0.029415356,
0.0151441842,
0.0576775856,
-0.0187906493,
0.0236202087,
-0.0087024933,
0.0439720787,
-0.0352781191,
0.0120357471,
0.0474363156,
0.0362305678,
0.0689077973,
-0.0283604134,
-0.0109012388,
-0.0550875217,
-0.0177243538,
-0.0493393987,
-0.0377857424,
-0.0248183515,
0.0558385737,
0.0343242697,
0.0096416343,
-0.0106439097,
-0.0396226831,
-0.0426739231,
-0.0235356875,
0.0115431659,
0.0157009847,
-0.0041428362,
0.0315690823,
-0.0285380259,
-0.0027290364,
-0.0014838066,
0.005744007,
0.0332356542,
0.0206754748,
-0.0058752466,
0.0471329503,
0.0058557712,
0.0080302292,
-0.0397680737,
-0.0271372721,
-0.0696854889,
-0.0091478052,
0.0403301008,
-0.0245297346,
0.0610170178,
-0.0480681434,
0.1037014946,
0.0190228168,
0.0037482348,
0.0220073164,
0.0730973482,
0.0544058532,
-0.0059405952,
-0.0016523001,
0.026799513,
-0.0377222896,
-0.0001733774,
0.0634698719,
-0.002949435,
0.0065459055,
-0.0088188834,
-0.0120831346,
-0.0307547059,
-0.0337382033,
-0.0297581814,
0.0551893599,
-0.022183802,
0.0121846059,
-0.0640205219,
-0.0578127131,
-0.0095369024,
-0.0208542813,
0.0071544438,
0.0029377623,
0.0295449793,
0.0744960234,
0.0183104444,
-0.0420700684,
-0.06064808,
0.017987093,
-0.0149872685,
-0.0179271549,
-0.0053463075,
-7.153491443e-33,
-0.0084770285,
-0.0493350849,
-0.0063924342,
-0.0006539131,
0.0079101333,
0.020544393,
-0.0336018987,
0.0085026156,
-0.0188252218,
0.0606332198,
-0.0021674433,
0.0293901097,
0.0122688115,
0.0095853815,
0.0004398489,
0.0115591101,
0.0184622519,
0.0047478825,
-0.0114783021,
0.0036581163,
0.0387393869,
0.0310939215,
0.0124086309,
-0.1045324802,
0.0445070602,
0.0108542638,
-0.0209859703,
0.0229238179,
-0.0332019851,
0.0435258038,
-0.00310108,
0.0357599631,
0.0419584177,
-0.0739812702,
0.0222436655,
0.008260713,
-0.1037540212,
-0.0489132814,
0.0376381762,
-0.0231525563,
-0.0494165421,
-0.0452636629,
0.0494372733,
0.003124183,
-0.0172251239,
-0.0117356507,
0.0554140918,
0.0153993266,
-0.0039513358,
0.0135658365,
-0.0528251007,
0.0347073674,
-0.0718886256,
0.0031725389,
0.0561004095,
0.0077615678,
-0.0011775036,
0.0148840602,
-0.0148437051,
0.0177981053,
-0.0058123996,
0.0198552515,
0.0539473556,
0.0062128985,
0.012007717,
0.093916744,
0.034293294,
-0.0103396568,
-0.0386880636,
0.0036398885,
-0.0253621228,
0.0531781651,
0.07106895,
-0.0010175718,
0.0409496799,
-0.0033502351,
-0.0786378086,
0.0205253847,
-0.0384227969,
-0.0132606504,
-0.0090016332,
0.0013423476,
-0.0701750368,
-0.0135856662,
-0.0474418104,
-0.0228030588,
-0.0143578406,
-0.0302058142,
0.0168644655,
0.0119316168,
-0.0566296317,
-0.0120323142,
-0.0260853078,
-0.0507979952,
0.0118848905,
0.0309361089,
-0.0175982453,
0.0172043499,
0.0040693413,
-0.033759322,
-0.0153615056,
0.0169702396,
0.0021076084,
0.0066492911,
0.039171461,
-0.0108776921,
0.03029163,
-0.0571622849,
-0.0182411578,
-0.0202081576,
-0.0492814071,
-0.051775191,
-0.0329523422,
-0.009931433,
0.0339060426,
0.0453818142,
-0.0432686023,
0.007804255,
0.0578133836,
0.0399007946,
-0.0039960826,
-0.0282331984,
-0.0202453155,
0.0201922543,
0.0311702173,
-0.0412596799,
-0.027937239,
-0.0013031673,
0.0119665014,
-0.0277755316,
-0.0136162359,
0.0029812742,
2.928e-7,
0.0289228391,
0.0411926918,
0.019491788,
-0.0173601266,
0.0186844338,
0.063876763,
0.0026428336,
-0.0546632819,
-0.0173464734,
-0.0120114572,
0.0132473717,
0.0387722366,
0.0388163738,
0.0210733041,
-0.0366822146,
0.0109950388,
-0.0079143289,
-0.0586885996,
-0.0238909144,
-0.0209959596,
0.0484025814,
0.0384298451,
0.0482855439,
0.0043371702,
-0.0028492983,
-0.0069178543,
0.0092551298,
-0.0236804932,
-0.004404285,
0.0333451591,
0.0648907125,
-0.0493986681,
-0.0063890168,
0.0056794714,
-0.0253375396,
-0.0020483288,
-0.0146967564,
0.0308735035,
-0.0179060642,
-0.0581900291,
-0.0373653881,
-0.0167489089,
0.0504851155,
-0.0355765298,
0.0873695612,
0.0157960225,
-0.0573036522,
0.0321753137,
-0.0494167246,
0.0332404338,
0.0106818546,
0.0301532522,
-0.0249514319,
0.029639475,
-0.027951194,
0.002093541,
-0.0106182527,
-0.0957484841,
-0.0504446365,
0.0101384642,
-0.0052706064,
0.0477206744,
-0.0057887537,
-0.0022809575,
0.045553498,
-0.0285121575,
-0.017386565,
2.651893215e-34,
-0.0122770211,
0.0296861753,
0.0087122461,
-0.0011703921,
0.0465865061,
-0.0000082715,
-0.0512680784,
0.0003038453,
0.0157578457,
-0.0505304784,
0.0340684801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13356v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13356v2 | Probing the Moral Development of Large Language Models through Defining Issues Test | 2023-09-23T12:17:10 | 2023-10-07T09:14:43 | Kumar Tanmay, Aditi Khandelwal, Utkarsh Agarwal, Monojit Choudhury | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this study, we measure the moral reasoning ability of LLMs using the
Defining Issues Test - a psychometric instrument developed for measuring the
moral development stage of a person according to the Kohlberg's Cognitive Moral
Development Model. DIT uses moral dilemmas followed by a set of ethical
considerations that the respondent has to judge for importance in resolving the
dilemma, and then rank-order them by importance. A moral development stage
score of the respondent is then computed based on the relevance rating and
ranking.
Our study shows that early LLMs such as GPT-3 exhibit a moral reasoning
ability no better than that of a random baseline, while ChatGPT, Llama2-Chat,
PaLM-2 and GPT-4 show significantly better performance on this task, comparable
to adult humans. GPT-4, in fact, has the highest post-conventional moral
reasoning score, equivalent to that of typical graduate school students.
However, we also observe that the models do not perform consistently across all
dilemmas, pointing to important gaps in their understanding and reasoning
abilities. | [
0.046750553,
0.063830778,
-0.0234690607,
0.0139039829,
-0.0842447206,
0.0345451236,
0.0190895516,
0.0281795729,
0.0197764691,
-0.0268738326,
-0.0106696598,
-0.0316102579,
-0.0339033417,
-0.0574514307,
0.0047570337,
0.0033952573,
0.0320910253,
-0.0000704755,
0.1044729128,
-0.0040512886,
-0.0429640859,
0.0372380801,
0.0493522659,
-0.0268745963,
0.0326547138,
-0.010637478,
0.0199271496,
-0.0503395349,
0.0318541341,
-0.0431397595,
-0.0005417829,
0.0451040901,
0.0528547093,
-0.0099985143,
0.0000019463,
-0.0631530955,
0.0349501707,
-0.0125361439,
0.0123689501,
0.0296920557,
0.0911209285,
0.0395492017,
-0.0022704659,
0.018156806,
-0.0367410183,
0.0784351081,
-0.0204777699,
0.0867979452,
-0.0220916178,
0.0131723853,
-0.0025318644,
-0.0209629405,
0.0393252186,
0.001890245,
0.0044476977,
-0.011298243,
0.0321502313,
0.0620226823,
-0.0191634316,
0.0016475599,
0.0247982591,
0.0000508504,
0.0282413848,
-0.0156897753,
-0.0484203734,
-0.0431696363,
0.0279235113,
-0.0275830701,
0.0172521379,
0.0009029054,
0.0581323355,
-0.0180152636,
0.0154838683,
0.0305967014,
0.0261854883,
-0.0070957965,
-0.0079833036,
0.0344380699,
-0.0101273051,
-0.001141996,
0.0702893808,
-0.0222673491,
-0.0115524838,
0.0406848267,
0.0555225797,
0.0074876444,
-0.0396021865,
-0.0204259604,
0.0105788726,
-0.0277382825,
-0.0780463666,
-0.0293256119,
-0.0067145135,
0.0192181636,
0.0231647603,
0.0287656933,
0.0153106097,
0.078649044,
0.0555133633,
-0.0722287074,
0.0059654284,
0.0197564159,
0.0177375674,
0.0184406843,
0.0121041257,
0.0407647565,
0.0103913452,
0.0529795028,
-0.0265271682,
0.0633879825,
0.0142399324,
-0.0272395033,
0.0287650097,
0.0281593334,
0.0242551565,
0.0399332047,
-0.0247704517,
-0.0172461625,
-0.0514213741,
-0.0532889813,
-0.0611509271,
-0.0113753211,
0.0167651288,
-0.0100523364,
-0.0719675943,
-0.0066697625,
-0.0323479399,
0.0198939163,
-0.0117121954,
0.0037959109,
0.0408064984,
-0.0419655889,
-0.0245957877,
0.0121598262,
0.022842668,
0.0950413793,
-0.025635004,
-0.0116112372,
-0.0217461362,
0.0025162047,
-0.0227305256,
-0.0590831116,
-0.0209945478,
-0.0330937207,
0.0030603553,
-0.001146542,
-0.0267014895,
-0.0525887422,
0.0495070107,
0.0211728308,
-0.0314351544,
0.0120125748,
0.0298710205,
0.0244992264,
0.0064122053,
0.02702564,
0.0087781781,
0.0214079842,
0.0148851248,
-0.0164526664,
0.0106132785,
-0.0172247682,
-0.0392012,
-0.0230132807,
-0.0284545161,
0.0118382769,
-0.0222190376,
-0.0025976007,
-0.0343049094,
0.0154725024,
0.0283734389,
0.0180056468,
-0.0385212079,
-0.0234913733,
0.0520571359,
0.1271526963,
0.028720079,
0.0258989129,
-0.0095468014,
0.0061249733,
0.0573939905,
0.0071013928,
-0.0498640016,
0.0221263431,
0.0097285667,
-0.0271604303,
-0.081539847,
0.0406382568,
0.0044514011,
-0.0359963477,
-0.0190995112,
0.0028970574,
-0.0065259277,
0.0186421927,
-0.0317779668,
-0.0099981315,
0.0100239264,
-0.063318342,
0.0405481979,
-0.0560524091,
0.0023777711,
-0.0456691235,
0.0772183985,
0.0740793124,
0.0249563921,
0.0193174519,
-0.0522922873,
-0.0179776065,
-0.039390929,
0.0213399697,
-0.0046825432,
-0.0259931125,
-0.0194265116,
-0.0429519601,
-0.0143366586,
-0.0068643582,
-0.0235975068,
0.0173499621,
-0.0577453449,
-0.0072627123,
0.0060045673,
-0.0241171587,
0.0130406981,
0.0178092383,
-0.0267805308,
0.011013207,
-0.0785278454,
0.0130849881,
0.0420917831,
-0.0225250721,
0.0156264193,
-0.0247458164,
0.0016542175,
0.0149552468,
0.0073804362,
0.0091680577,
-0.0760458633,
0.0169880576,
0.003290307,
-0.0537865236,
-0.0158212949,
0.0154069932,
0.0124524841,
0.0435477532,
-0.021768935,
-0.0488423593,
0.0196891855,
-0.0450331308,
0.0209687632,
-0.099331513,
-0.0283714402,
-0.0268892013,
0.0804541409,
-0.0234811008,
0.0203377772,
-0.0052157361,
-0.006347944,
0.0047025327,
-0.0230667349,
-0.0222318377,
-0.0017194012,
-0.0218280982,
0.0366310962,
0.0182687957,
0.0669148043,
-0.0413483828,
-0.0455205441,
-0.052598428,
-0.0163928531,
0.0431029946,
0.016010439,
0.0060149631,
-0.0741930604,
-0.025896946,
0.0465518124,
-0.0066108867,
0.0065811439,
0.0271240734,
0.0251607876,
0.0042079017,
-0.0368963033,
-0.0160438567,
-0.0089347363,
0.0094192196,
-0.0356530324,
-0.0280240811,
0.0183060765,
-0.0039954674,
0.0052006915,
0.056139797,
-0.0886655152,
-0.0180198532,
0.0101431068,
-0.0646260902,
0.0150508899,
0.0619659573,
0.0200850014,
0.0753167421,
0.0641267002,
0.0518075973,
0.0081230979,
0.0272806883,
-0.0677254349,
-0.0262715444,
0.0049652047,
0.0134325186,
-0.0482903272,
-0.0776775628,
-0.0329551511,
0.0883511528,
0.0011318455,
0.0274466518,
-0.0261262562,
0.0475823805,
-0.0389555246,
-0.0316111781,
0.0226613823,
-0.0694035217,
-0.0380728766,
0.0506809801,
-0.0349399596,
-0.0491606668,
0.0513185225,
0.0479359068,
0.0175782871,
-0.0118099814,
0.0062926793,
-0.0096637914,
0.0659421161,
-0.0101369135,
0.0178973079,
0.0262330435,
-0.0532642156,
-0.051172547,
-0.0232202206,
0.0472224429,
-0.0459367074,
0.0765008777,
-0.0267819241,
0.0053819856,
0.0182295814,
-0.0327441655,
-0.0271011535,
-0.0292665958,
-0.0225055739,
-0.0136440052,
-0.0053038714,
0.0215386339,
0.0459447242,
-0.0292242728,
0.0347727016,
-0.0559704341,
-0.0088209799,
0.0145127876,
-0.0080447542,
-0.0651880652,
-0.0028217467,
0.0118074641,
0.0690795705,
-0.0032686619,
0.0695901662,
0.0369155221,
-0.0236991346,
0.0074762288,
0.0446729548,
0.0425983593,
0.0461669117,
0.0463986173,
-0.0184091423,
0.0265361704,
0.040798042,
0.0031271339,
0.0236722045,
0.0871265978,
0.0180580672,
-0.0196052678,
0.0146768726,
-0.0400593728,
-0.0313416533,
0.0307943616,
-0.0028760182,
-0.05029561,
0.0182075109,
0.0089055393,
-0.0068545914,
-0.0974288955,
-0.039910309,
0.0204052329,
-0.0316174328,
0.0351334438,
0.0186120849,
0.002885032,
-0.006549608,
0.00294537,
0.0241842922,
0.025842648,
0.0550691299,
0.0299470294,
-0.0046748267,
-0.0409242176,
-0.0136313196,
0.001363423,
0.0102686873,
0.0873302743,
0.0206049699,
0.0780418739,
0.0103920521,
0.0499024689,
-0.0269561745,
-0.0479467325,
0.0248284061,
0.0113414852,
-0.030538952,
-0.0048986734,
-0.0570810698,
-0.0141896056,
0.0199653283,
-0.0988944918,
0.0065733897,
0.0330140665,
-0.0242287666,
-0.0090052858,
0.0807223693,
0.0043825977,
-0.0563635491,
0.0207425859,
0.0403522961,
-0.0497631021,
0.0216009766,
0.016075138,
-0.0198891014,
0.0343947038,
-0.0195083693,
-0.0476054363,
0.0282079317,
-0.0453986079,
-0.0314878337,
-0.0111977626,
-0.0020880154,
-0.0617758073,
-0.0374849811,
-0.0304380096,
-0.0163250919,
0.0294846687,
-0.0551196896,
0.0141359502,
-0.0001993562,
-0.038236402,
0.0156035358,
0.0088722045,
-0.0388989113,
-0.0384349898,
0.0578633733,
0.0277505051,
-0.054042045,
-0.0176439118,
-0.0490786433,
0.0267529171,
-0.0078702318,
0.0356267355,
0.0144163929,
0.0128575433,
-0.036099676,
-0.0114189703,
-0.0099798702,
-0.0138617009,
0.0203586221,
-0.0460153259,
0.0603638217,
0.0186014585,
0.048706945,
-0.0072057587,
0.0079602804,
0.0085412282,
0.037433181,
-0.0040333057,
-0.0283844788,
-0.0444104783,
-0.0401576646,
0.0393464267,
0.0470015779,
-0.018239744,
0.0391970016,
-0.0159884952,
-0.0538310446,
-0.0591159761,
-0.0196179841,
-0.0315967761,
-0.0217573382,
-0.0140228746,
0.0420963466,
0.0034831578,
0.009143794,
-0.0149334529,
-0.0348100662,
-0.0142512685,
0.0312106423,
0.0167357493,
-0.0016449301,
0.0491267219,
-0.0502475053,
0.0319495387,
-0.0403588377,
-0.0031312725,
-0.0308520291,
0.0360195525,
-0.0187692977,
0.0969408527,
-0.0201278143,
-0.0150370281,
0.0253824964,
0.0003899389,
-0.0533144735,
-0.0359382778,
0.0038336937,
-0.0052818237,
-0.0296906978,
0.0439037681,
0.017120257,
-0.0181805864,
0.0060008261,
-0.0339181051,
0.0095115937,
-0.0131945461,
-0.0477221012,
0.0173335746,
0.024716666,
-0.0139024565,
-0.0092947539,
-0.0078029642,
-0.0304912236,
-0.0058264891,
-0.012038108,
-0.0172858052,
0.001132514,
-0.0474301875,
0.0194523651,
-0.0347902887,
-0.014081358,
0.0106988633,
-0.0722621456,
-0.025282234,
-0.0335597992,
0.0028431069,
-0.0065808911,
-0.0520872623,
-0.0256669763,
0.0689364001,
-0.0339643024,
-0.0031053601,
-0.0079090511,
0.00637032,
-0.0041980827,
0.030490825,
-0.0483445339,
-5.441622693e-33,
-0.0307547916,
-0.0365526006,
-0.0011509536,
-0.036957521,
-0.0333785191,
-0.0405312106,
0.005693581,
0.0511956066,
-0.0582636483,
0.0318847857,
0.0066740611,
0.0138328616,
0.0010849839,
-0.0443267412,
-0.0004971751,
-0.0442110673,
-0.0276897158,
0.0048642727,
-0.0116942134,
-0.011468241,
-0.0344324708,
-0.0114076706,
0.0731793195,
-0.0390137807,
0.0522684827,
0.01680802,
0.0075567011,
-0.007015442,
-0.0526131503,
-0.0075331116,
-0.0038653067,
0.0258060601,
0.0459653176,
-0.005804434,
0.0168996174,
0.0145413857,
0.009911905,
-0.01998928,
0.0981021449,
-0.0489715189,
-0.0396129303,
-0.0656656921,
0.007566676,
0.004823735,
-0.0632192045,
-0.0421444625,
0.0293881502,
-0.0168208778,
0.0315540321,
0.0006907965,
-0.0539120995,
-0.0221399479,
-0.0250729676,
-0.0386605486,
-0.0696150213,
0.0437010862,
-0.0401091203,
0.0235226322,
0.0351686291,
0.0375854187,
-0.0034224628,
-0.0126597835,
0.0246599521,
-0.0460895859,
0.0340584442,
0.0917697176,
-0.0136788962,
0.0290850718,
-0.0236050189,
-0.0149466954,
0.0264675617,
0.032704927,
0.0397326946,
0.060378857,
-0.0241009071,
-0.0649044514,
-0.0041364413,
-0.0570964441,
0.0727230161,
0.0110209417,
0.0014972391,
-0.0103820516,
0.0010342589,
0.0008839529,
-0.059602648,
-0.0526913851,
-0.0149230212,
-0.0248868,
0.0116000678,
-0.0465983152,
-0.0190965924,
-0.0630432218,
0.0079808673,
0.003356918,
0.0343326293,
-0.022617165,
0.0037054545,
0.0143568907,
0.0234421305,
0.0492720716,
-0.0327797048,
-0.0127763133,
0.003685832,
-0.019235827,
0.0596427284,
-0.0115746325,
0.0268761143,
-0.0224674083,
-0.0116683319,
-0.01029569,
-0.0152668534,
0.0144642629,
0.0312460028,
-0.0241965856,
-0.0073339036,
0.0304425973,
0.0121664405,
-0.0041150386,
0.0306300316,
-0.034664087,
-0.0647256598,
0.0029005378,
-0.0703208968,
0.0592981391,
0.0018469254,
0.0306268875,
-0.0202092491,
0.1042496264,
0.0024624411,
-0.0245192461,
-0.0302365366,
0.0454621948,
2.643e-7,
-0.0049347347,
0.0207507219,
-0.009235112,
-0.008224329,
-0.0085062198,
0.0423854403,
0.0392436683,
0.0164403543,
0.1032435372,
-0.0262606777,
-0.0025267599,
0.0005264917,
0.0546527691,
-0.0010756028,
0.0130573036,
0.0096618757,
-0.0277483948,
-0.0437779091,
-0.0288602933,
0.0414834432,
0.0683397874,
0.0331025459,
-0.0036747444,
-0.012128301,
-0.0001979235,
0.0219665542,
0.0160844177,
-0.0654330701,
-0.0436059497,
-0.0059109209,
-0.0226460658,
-0.0243105013,
0.0430505835,
0.0610327274,
0.0544452481,
-0.0272974167,
0.0224256217,
0.0745223686,
0.0144962166,
-0.0191734806,
-0.0228062086,
-0.012692119,
-0.0227973592,
-0.0302327164,
0.068761453,
-0.0314998813,
-0.0256348476,
0.0134483529,
0.0235200841,
-0.0267351568,
-0.0047721299,
-0.0203981716,
-0.0280368179,
0.0221037176,
0.027601894,
-0.0202118624,
0.0338366143,
-0.0228520632,
0.0172252357,
0.0074514961,
0.0116380434,
-0.0864991397,
0.0020639731,
0.0171538424,
0.0428844579,
-0.0450597368,
0.0073226001,
1.88069419e-34,
-0.0030193792,
-0.016523499,
0.0698757768,
-0.0037598081,
0.0497068353,
0.0710139349,
0.0193859022,
0.017701989,
0.0077534239,
-0.0049478612,
0.0039090579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13354v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13354v1 | Lexical Squad@Multimodal Hate Speech Event Detection 2023: Multimodal Hate Speech Detection using Fused Ensemble Approach | 2023-09-23T12:06:05 | 2023-09-23T12:06:05 | Mohammad Kashif, Mohammad Zohair, Saquib Ali | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | With a surge in the usage of social media postings to express opinions,
emotions, and ideologies, there has been a significant shift towards the
calibration of social media as a rapid medium of conveying viewpoints and
outlooks over the globe. Concurrently, the emergence of a multitude of
conflicts between two entities has given rise to a stream of social media
content containing propaganda, hate speech, and inconsiderate views. Thus, the
issue of monitoring social media postings is rising swiftly, attracting major
attention from those willing to solve such problems. One such problem is Hate
Speech detection. To mitigate this problem, we present our novel ensemble
learning approach for detecting hate speech, by classifying text-embedded
images into two labels, namely "Hate Speech" and "No Hate Speech". We have
incorporated state-of-art models including InceptionV3, BERT, and XLNet. Our
proposed ensemble model yielded promising results with 75.21 and 74.96 as
accuracy and F-1 score (respectively). We also present an empirical evaluation
of the text-embedded images to elaborate on how well the model was able to
predict and classify. We release our codebase here
(https://github.com/M0hammad-Kashif/MultiModalHateSpeech). | [
0.046024248,
0.0792533755,
0.0149439555,
0.0426097959,
-0.0053548436,
0.0371400118,
0.0362531468,
0.013926792,
-0.0037178488,
-0.0903340951,
-0.0052707945,
-0.0386096425,
-0.0146443611,
0.0004997365,
-0.0084482236,
-0.0535837039,
0.027286455,
0.0560695939,
0.0013710828,
-0.0283862688,
0.0769951046,
0.0210876055,
-0.0282582715,
0.0452676639,
-0.0780517608,
0.0136227449,
0.0369403102,
0.0039583943,
0.056821093,
-0.0009821563,
0.0535047688,
0.0534527116,
0.0374905504,
0.0709950477,
0.0000019373,
-0.0177569799,
0.001532338,
-0.0125693362,
0.0210699216,
-0.0611470789,
0.0521643125,
0.0102982344,
-0.0056338254,
0.0138094053,
-0.0199816544,
0.0500650071,
0.0860989317,
0.0862158537,
0.0567639507,
0.0612611771,
-0.0066494062,
-0.0217030458,
0.0125046074,
0.039799314,
-0.0135564888,
0.0324763134,
0.0049889521,
-0.0674668476,
-0.0503306389,
-0.0158688799,
-0.0186842959,
0.0375938453,
0.0085675092,
0.0230273977,
0.0282715969,
0.0016593145,
-0.0503349118,
-0.0545133315,
-0.0280929729,
0.0437743887,
-0.0392467342,
0.0155279795,
-0.0112733869,
0.0088186553,
-0.0325882807,
-0.0125344386,
-0.0152318235,
0.0043424917,
-0.0357901677,
0.039437037,
-0.0358824879,
0.0214837883,
0.0303392131,
0.064667359,
0.0168850478,
0.0133068003,
-0.0194416996,
-0.0052917758,
-0.0001027283,
0.0148903308,
-0.0168005209,
0.0223773848,
0.0288382396,
-0.0179411042,
0.0050448244,
-0.0047528548,
-0.0386423878,
-0.1066199616,
-0.0140888477,
-0.0755311027,
0.0339467973,
0.0013587065,
-0.0386577323,
0.0174058285,
-0.0006871787,
0.0193091966,
0.0073071187,
0.0057946979,
0.0036666058,
0.0045447783,
-0.0468838289,
0.0129598994,
0.0049253488,
-0.0137599744,
-0.0054017976,
-0.0201667845,
-0.0415690094,
-0.035973303,
-0.0420497172,
-0.0140198534,
-0.0102935825,
0.0322707109,
-0.0117230332,
-0.0094203427,
-0.0110166073,
0.0334813148,
-0.001008506,
0.0029346843,
-0.0505223945,
-0.065738,
0.0200168937,
0.0580584891,
-0.030845223,
-0.0013314341,
0.036931999,
0.0289524235,
-0.0075617763,
-0.0405128002,
0.0105060805,
-0.0119889323,
-0.0629757419,
-0.0342844389,
0.0204139724,
-0.0756190792,
0.0238534324,
-0.0248927996,
-0.0193652939,
-0.0534829982,
0.0225356724,
0.0256457813,
-0.0377034247,
0.0995005146,
-0.0035172813,
-0.0293498766,
0.0405192971,
0.0276983678,
0.0323817655,
0.0838499069,
0.0209710933,
0.0377558842,
0.0677420422,
0.0090123788,
0.0103411162,
0.0620730743,
0.022611361,
-0.006503976,
-0.0554733202,
-0.0097625162,
-0.0441559181,
-0.0115151573,
-0.0166154709,
0.019875994,
0.0013548409,
-0.0591405816,
0.056079343,
0.0582795851,
-0.0493437946,
-0.0219884478,
0.0214733183,
0.0064304736,
-0.0229031611,
-0.0402911082,
-0.0427555218,
0.0113423718,
-0.0316338576,
-0.0596917309,
0.0392528363,
0.0796597004,
-0.0081849145,
-0.0345250666,
-0.0145418774,
-0.0126719167,
0.0099203065,
-0.0409500413,
0.0190962832,
-0.0083727017,
-0.0314752385,
0.0261484515,
0.037698891,
-0.0322083235,
-0.0099119786,
-0.0349427052,
0.0154692009,
0.0713853389,
0.0114609618,
-0.0015707453,
-0.0136059308,
-0.0698622093,
-0.01225024,
0.0535430275,
-0.016898362,
0.013664146,
0.0148923676,
-0.0675273165,
-0.0348412953,
0.0402277857,
-0.0006164546,
0.0271315426,
0.0679977983,
0.0222553425,
-0.0066720564,
0.0594940484,
-0.0275356658,
0.0260432977,
0.0488463342,
-0.0228284281,
-0.0177505258,
0.0245069843,
0.0500371605,
0.0330133438,
-0.047111541,
-0.0585345961,
0.0195042137,
-0.0197035391,
-0.0861511752,
0.0234825872,
-0.0541013554,
-0.0481694564,
0.0176417641,
-0.0488137156,
-0.0142997392,
0.0468397401,
-0.0095381252,
0.0361853577,
0.05594901,
-0.0178632326,
-0.0341209136,
-0.0457792208,
-0.0554831997,
-0.0422076881,
0.0513343178,
-0.0056612836,
0.0444662012,
-0.0265400484,
-0.0258442089,
-0.0228171702,
-0.0396022536,
0.0505547263,
0.0348022729,
-0.0690754801,
-0.0098243998,
-0.0026966445,
0.051409144,
0.0066300756,
-0.0021724817,
-0.026028702,
0.0080179367,
-0.1001554355,
-0.0129935071,
-0.0387915447,
-0.0315456241,
-0.0052535329,
-0.0091153551,
-0.007000613,
-0.003669078,
-0.0094176363,
-0.003770482,
0.0525386706,
0.010833432,
-0.0151714152,
-0.0463337861,
-0.0148208216,
-0.0035335685,
-0.0035541772,
-0.0162406079,
0.0443206429,
0.0088322628,
-0.0746931583,
0.0525365286,
-0.0655507445,
-0.0342468396,
0.0394780822,
-0.0074998266,
-0.0473458134,
0.0360669196,
0.0039991243,
-0.0181063674,
0.0281069502,
0.0664415583,
0.1044270173,
-0.012176536,
0.0164400283,
-0.0051564001,
-0.0074112667,
-0.0019924054,
0.0416836217,
-0.0113899885,
-0.0108088478,
-0.0309290364,
0.0700879246,
0.0439015217,
0.0083317719,
-0.0492615774,
0.0068235551,
-0.0335131772,
-0.0629356876,
-0.0612474903,
-0.0535877496,
-0.015446756,
-0.0483013466,
-0.0155886784,
-0.0710015446,
0.0511305183,
0.0201858785,
-0.0003513268,
-0.0199634004,
-0.040430434,
0.0037983926,
0.0519261993,
0.0276558213,
0.0550991111,
-0.0175980814,
0.0232143942,
0.0019276594,
-0.0495580286,
0.012774338,
-0.0229380038,
-0.0166547894,
-0.0003771943,
0.0109274602,
0.0172803383,
-0.0337275527,
-0.0662903637,
-0.0695168003,
-0.0475059561,
-0.028154349,
-0.0278655887,
-0.0263667628,
-0.0373592339,
0.0098307412,
0.0425143801,
-0.0344089642,
0.0041702739,
0.0050149951,
0.0355772041,
0.035533525,
-0.0267079901,
-0.0044008982,
-0.0013258806,
-0.0334956646,
-0.0248162858,
0.0737102702,
0.0041628475,
0.0164456181,
-0.0720328987,
0.0010140528,
0.0102864746,
0.0425503999,
0.0081830006,
-0.0360093303,
0.0423731729,
-0.0040738778,
0.047938779,
0.0748603866,
0.0004880438,
-0.0199941155,
-0.0183965471,
0.0258964133,
0.0071974788,
0.0047586258,
-0.0211836081,
-0.0436765663,
-0.0368665121,
-0.0394611545,
0.0020202813,
-0.0594998226,
-0.030769648,
0.0025998098,
-0.0233306512,
0.0184276719,
0.0000121581,
-0.0259867962,
-0.0212702099,
0.0255925208,
0.0166050326,
-0.013834008,
0.0067223907,
-0.0238686614,
0.0520918593,
-0.0014321398,
0.0126726115,
-0.0576322265,
-0.0227147508,
0.0051005385,
-0.0360257551,
0.0337650105,
0.0584881231,
0.039821934,
-0.0463671088,
-0.0254911706,
0.0102990372,
-0.0030208551,
-0.0088418787,
-0.058171656,
0.092666328,
-0.0264069289,
-0.042577669,
0.0017023381,
0.0230375212,
0.004129691,
-0.0010263593,
0.0010170671,
0.0249461643,
0.0073030605,
-0.0052044359,
-0.0829171091,
0.0434504338,
0.0264497623,
0.0595504828,
0.0084292851,
-0.0570378564,
0.024636576,
-0.0474236347,
-0.0119413128,
-0.0706038326,
-0.0423412025,
0.0060744612,
-0.0127099864,
-0.0318177305,
-0.0274046846,
-0.0206634942,
0.0245651901,
0.0260829702,
-0.0068886089,
-0.0041457927,
-0.0400322191,
0.0262992941,
-0.0603901632,
0.0164273269,
0.0395701565,
0.0778985992,
-0.002704574,
-0.0057762102,
-0.0065152063,
0.0057124966,
-0.035218969,
0.0364542305,
-0.0467164814,
-0.0186445564,
0.0335933492,
0.0559158362,
0.003638143,
0.0129474532,
0.0207073241,
-0.0253041685,
0.0817096233,
0.1124752164,
0.0486811325,
-0.007526861,
0.0353100784,
-0.0174164213,
-0.0131880967,
0.0116184689,
0.0294843372,
0.0699756742,
0.0045532286,
-0.0576435141,
-0.0589934066,
-0.0178547893,
-0.0437637791,
-0.0321761332,
0.0375411734,
-0.0468894243,
-0.0473389551,
-0.0372060277,
-0.0280437656,
0.0274400599,
-0.0369853415,
-0.0377108827,
0.0212388486,
-0.0037398308,
-0.023249587,
-0.0315581337,
0.0195086785,
-0.002876444,
-0.0072269235,
-0.0233626943,
0.0432424732,
0.0538432188,
0.0091331499,
0.0073277457,
0.0300502889,
-0.022014752,
0.0397546627,
0.0283841025,
-0.0296209585,
-0.0075106891,
0.0453873351,
0.0266205072,
-0.0186532829,
0.0361721739,
0.0081864232,
0.0175646283,
0.0227249172,
-0.0718599111,
0.0156888235,
-0.0107178325,
-0.0071790745,
0.0141058909,
0.0029005667,
-0.0090191942,
-0.0203252267,
-0.0057603312,
-0.0259407964,
-0.0285814665,
0.0441487804,
0.0181988515,
-0.0077512893,
0.0093225623,
0.0316529833,
-0.0361848474,
0.0316218473,
0.063065514,
-0.0290040169,
-0.0489131361,
0.0278896838,
0.0637011975,
0.0181174651,
0.0250300057,
0.0568017513,
-0.0104586743,
-0.0057589081,
0.0296678636,
-0.0458227508,
0.0314429104,
0.0228307992,
0.0305148102,
0.0528303906,
-0.0059863343,
0.0359052718,
0.0085711442,
0.0043797861,
-0.0110308984,
-0.0330078751,
0.0234585162,
-5.648873368e-33,
-0.0235490277,
-0.0364999138,
-0.0099084536,
-0.0296578743,
-0.006581753,
-0.0026316787,
0.0406412221,
0.0117748408,
0.0071869865,
0.035832379,
0.0311551969,
0.006696356,
-0.0030790488,
0.0159027632,
-0.0138276992,
-0.0055843759,
0.0132597396,
-0.0265281145,
-0.0054996498,
0.0134150367,
0.0845979303,
0.020539742,
0.0507682823,
-0.0671711192,
0.0068470179,
0.0245002154,
-0.0503927283,
-0.0105814692,
0.0358231068,
0.0544635318,
-0.0158880465,
0.0613130778,
0.044764448,
-0.0206369627,
-0.007931198,
0.0523361936,
-0.0063001569,
-0.0058108126,
-0.012066029,
0.0186948534,
-0.0271692295,
0.0235558841,
0.0271040611,
-0.0062225331,
-0.0551645681,
-0.0368858837,
0.0535285175,
-0.0234560296,
0.0367540121,
-0.043094106,
-0.0549423434,
0.042111747,
-0.0217605866,
-0.0304116886,
-0.0200379677,
-0.0055637248,
0.0616702475,
0.0143828643,
-0.0410960503,
0.0168674756,
-0.033716701,
-0.0128222797,
0.0171135981,
0.0194819756,
-0.0163271185,
0.0854682028,
-0.0029202732,
-0.016622955,
-0.039469678,
0.0087423353,
0.0315461829,
0.0550819598,
0.0643748417,
0.0747803673,
0.0034357123,
-0.0418286808,
-0.0339902453,
0.021691151,
0.0513926633,
-0.0214504935,
0.0168337449,
-0.0333232358,
-0.0353657529,
-0.0008020841,
0.003539131,
-0.0709660873,
-0.0129720466,
-0.0045980806,
0.0143228611,
-0.0134841893,
-0.024804987,
0.0201221704,
0.0469776206,
-0.0315844454,
0.0018075991,
0.0501780063,
-0.0106025068,
0.0233607534,
0.0279617608,
0.0363929234,
-0.0309878811,
0.0047557177,
0.0165634733,
-0.0007853975,
0.0212622974,
-0.0057595773,
0.0761657208,
0.0373321511,
-0.0576969497,
0.0035287009,
0.0038318383,
0.0285720751,
-0.024168998,
0.049785234,
-0.0116531784,
0.03992787,
-0.0296023823,
-0.0367820337,
0.0043406454,
-0.0248064231,
0.0101867402,
-0.0458358899,
-0.0270079691,
0.014127464,
0.0040858355,
0.0071027298,
-0.0341068059,
-0.0506141856,
0.0075347284,
-0.0910661742,
0.0243539941,
-0.0189927537,
2.601e-7,
-0.0053198631,
0.0457581729,
-0.0015087761,
-0.0481265783,
0.0228942577,
0.0613860041,
0.0234939139,
0.0358291827,
-0.0356304795,
-0.0381433554,
-0.0266051758,
0.0718327686,
0.0057891966,
0.057367973,
0.0107362745,
-0.0334146321,
-0.0488400012,
0.0061074551,
-0.0607011691,
0.0570271611,
0.0080402289,
0.0785495266,
0.074355267,
-0.0590129383,
-0.0125718582,
-0.0192431044,
0.0221527051,
-0.0062114024,
-0.0283063073,
-0.0409470536,
0.048215948,
0.0110063218,
-0.0044543096,
0.0093442593,
-0.0168869812,
0.0263121277,
0.0461025871,
0.0129335932,
-0.0152144171,
0.0124490019,
-0.0067898058,
-0.0096399141,
-0.034601111,
-0.0151727824,
0.0315147601,
0.0037589134,
-0.0101507232,
-0.0860175937,
-0.0128208883,
-0.0082474817,
0.0580867641,
-0.0006202084,
-0.0212710258,
-0.0045592231,
0.0438516475,
-0.031549342,
-0.0396936461,
-0.1186847761,
0.0061452794,
-0.0026756583,
-0.0454386286,
-0.0262120496,
-0.0188194476,
-0.0125323152,
0.0512076691,
0.0190542731,
-0.0085623823,
1.957691021e-34,
0.0301445909,
-0.027807774,
-0.0228725541,
-0.0355651714,
0.008247437,
0.0039031554,
-0.0323200449,
-0.0403839946,
0.0306989085,
-0.0272180159,
0.0037333569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13347v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13347v1 | My Science Tutor (MyST) -- A Large Corpus of Children's Conversational Speech | 2023-09-23T11:52:36 | 2023-09-23T11:52:36 | Sameer S. Pradhan, Ronald A. Cole, Wayne H. Ward | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This article describes the MyST corpus developed as part of the My Science
Tutor project -- one of the largest collections of children's conversational
speech comprising approximately 400 hours, spanning some 230K utterances across
about 10.5K virtual tutor sessions by around 1.3K third, fourth and fifth grade
students. 100K of all utterances have been transcribed thus far. The corpus is
freely available (https://myst.cemantix.org) for non-commercial use using a
creative commons license. It is also available for commercial use
(https://boulderlearning.com/resources/myst-corpus/). To date, ten
organizations have licensed the corpus for commercial use, and approximately 40
university and other not-for-profit research groups have downloaded the corpus.
It is our hope that the corpus can be used to improve automatic speech
recognition algorithms, build and evaluate conversational AI agents for
education, and together help accelerate development of multimodal applications
to improve children's excitement and learning about science, and help them
learn remotely. | [
0.0071043153,
0.0413098559,
-0.0094328681,
-0.0130012622,
-0.0027953759,
-0.0271333307,
0.0419798084,
-0.0314094909,
-0.0232641827,
-0.0157019217,
-0.0332570262,
0.0023061112,
0.054321371,
-0.0015480811,
-0.0020357573,
-0.1057801023,
0.0343369022,
-0.0799758509,
0.034388721,
-0.0060892384,
0.0100693991,
0.0071843532,
-0.0764943883,
0.037305288,
-0.0029366326,
-0.024772292,
0.0156176761,
-0.017801851,
0.0425936244,
-0.0544395819,
0.0003237072,
0.0402836204,
0.0293169413,
0.0407708399,
0.0000017342,
-0.0284496117,
0.0016855636,
-0.0012036768,
-0.0446511693,
0.0382745825,
0.0523050055,
0.0465603173,
-0.0245558694,
0.0145597206,
-0.0553460792,
0.0151756825,
0.0966862962,
-0.0416046157,
0.0197243374,
0.0327423252,
-0.000098341,
-0.0145330532,
0.0098384898,
0.0246944018,
0.0407103486,
0.0094791055,
0.0101192929,
0.0586935841,
0.1018986329,
-0.0006877309,
-0.0317436196,
0.0761702731,
-0.0045098052,
-0.0490575731,
0.0379421115,
0.0301052295,
-0.044628635,
-0.0394360051,
-0.0305032786,
0.0985864624,
0.0588661134,
-0.0122042801,
0.0220498089,
0.031178562,
-0.0176564753,
0.0170415919,
-0.0751464367,
0.0280583221,
-0.0069278521,
-0.0001792745,
0.0030637372,
-0.0080234352,
-0.0339942239,
0.0155688087,
0.0205759965,
0.034216173,
-0.0111799063,
-0.0009355164,
-0.0264394898,
0.00785028,
0.0584649332,
-0.0247697569,
0.0562607758,
-0.0025196834,
-0.0042626765,
0.0074717156,
-0.0461516604,
-0.0609610155,
-0.0109065156,
0.0288177915,
-0.0056131352,
0.0151560064,
-0.0217409059,
0.0358468071,
0.0487307571,
0.0155660203,
0.0192734357,
0.0115462961,
0.0000695312,
0.0163579825,
-0.0386849605,
0.001077745,
-0.0224012677,
0.0082542151,
-0.0389700979,
-0.0235347208,
-0.0273232274,
-0.0247734636,
-0.0114733065,
0.0075477376,
0.0036767386,
0.0341412053,
-0.027053481,
0.0008254993,
0.029253291,
0.0662323758,
-0.0147023452,
0.0426660925,
0.0604775548,
-0.1026624069,
-0.039298933,
0.0325720236,
0.0298320558,
0.0049173199,
-0.0014086501,
0.0230772868,
-0.0091773607,
-0.0429833382,
0.0597691126,
-0.030912647,
-0.0180824194,
-0.0400237553,
0.0309393145,
-0.0339063071,
0.0200433731,
-0.0087546119,
0.0103167742,
-0.0060149212,
0.0134197352,
-0.0306543652,
0.0185198393,
0.0576810576,
-0.0376633517,
-0.0089962063,
0.0169296227,
0.0363732092,
0.024682818,
-0.0068180077,
0.0615357757,
-0.0362755321,
0.002784105,
-0.0691213086,
0.0143495351,
-0.0078827664,
-0.0289248582,
-0.0001086063,
0.0133436378,
-0.0310558863,
-0.0358775072,
0.0538105853,
0.0221472941,
0.0248619821,
-0.0222370848,
0.0320076831,
0.0691991001,
0.0709159225,
-0.0511775315,
0.0007080447,
0.0093141496,
0.0247758534,
0.070726648,
-0.0141906748,
-0.012766799,
0.0384000354,
-0.0141539536,
-0.0074323388,
0.0108812088,
0.0178344566,
-0.0082438225,
-0.0010203322,
-0.0407806002,
0.0077566537,
-0.0023537232,
0.0383513421,
0.0312665589,
-0.0192957576,
-0.0100136008,
0.002348542,
-0.005246358,
-0.0757441744,
0.0136348549,
-0.0230077766,
0.045875825,
0.0544600859,
0.0161949135,
-0.0496612266,
-0.0500192717,
-0.0061008544,
-0.0097060977,
0.0539132766,
-0.0149206426,
-0.0207212716,
0.0162598621,
-0.0315684527,
-0.0138664097,
-0.0018352993,
0.0337927788,
0.0253761988,
-0.0041685095,
0.0438484102,
-0.000090288,
-0.0177019723,
0.0386482142,
0.0108143808,
-0.0481516272,
-0.0327544659,
-0.00956148,
-0.0007572387,
0.0371224992,
0.0360188819,
-0.0217121504,
0.0111091956,
0.0481062233,
0.021507768,
0.0163060389,
0.0826141983,
-0.0350238159,
-0.0246263798,
0.0319651254,
-0.0989847034,
-0.0190331116,
0.0268174633,
0.0439744592,
-0.0347552858,
0.0669790655,
-0.0701925382,
0.0264073405,
0.0124592036,
0.0438726023,
-0.028022185,
0.004829119,
0.0181498379,
-0.0461221077,
0.041595038,
-0.0134915886,
0.0353662297,
-0.0301829576,
-0.0078456467,
-0.0930930004,
-0.012766609,
0.007728708,
-0.0330122449,
-0.0041692439,
-0.0163672287,
-0.0374654531,
-0.0968205333,
0.0231885109,
-0.048256848,
-0.0234819129,
0.0529948659,
0.0109017408,
-0.0034165641,
0.0001658264,
0.0084588993,
0.0150367916,
0.002479014,
0.0064855623,
-0.014490962,
-0.0168332979,
-0.0072138389,
-0.0379443876,
-0.0386151187,
-0.0599690042,
0.0186075643,
-0.032610219,
0.0236995816,
0.0340469889,
-0.0261709858,
-0.0391046219,
-0.0181270707,
-0.0095534977,
0.017281441,
-0.0062850295,
-0.0390156284,
0.0513277389,
-0.0324044488,
0.0325048082,
0.0753494278,
-0.0067165205,
0.0015230653,
0.0409833789,
-0.0634962022,
-0.0726881102,
0.0046142917,
0.0350812413,
0.0309993736,
0.0026468972,
0.0092815626,
-0.0236157812,
0.041157946,
0.0269653611,
0.0197919775,
-0.0259873942,
0.0591459647,
0.0179917589,
-0.0104548447,
0.0290075969,
-0.0453260541,
-0.0237307381,
0.008906953,
0.0243301112,
-0.0062225685,
0.0654439777,
-0.0488946848,
-0.054031346,
-0.0769725367,
-0.003146532,
0.0386706181,
0.022816455,
-0.0935456827,
-0.0184395909,
0.0433302224,
-0.0177610032,
0.005743484,
0.0268613081,
0.0274850391,
-0.0238698088,
-0.020822309,
-0.0990778506,
0.0092636608,
0.035130024,
-0.0219464246,
-0.0273122415,
0.0165398438,
-0.0580833107,
0.0030903325,
0.0053736214,
-0.085442774,
-0.0850407854,
-0.0159752741,
0.0342941321,
0.0461627878,
-0.0025043755,
0.0281995945,
-0.0128791537,
0.0160492957,
0.0262243841,
0.0448044389,
0.010122478,
-0.0067320112,
0.0502331704,
0.0271141827,
0.0445720591,
0.0155828176,
-0.0194104202,
0.0023955142,
0.0466026589,
0.0376504101,
0.0196608361,
0.0039119385,
0.0808371231,
-0.0652555004,
0.0012485071,
0.0457667224,
-0.0138811925,
-0.0230632965,
0.0054151136,
-0.0082393931,
-0.0264107734,
-0.0395082533,
-0.0318128616,
-0.0785401613,
-0.0284126773,
0.0041498304,
0.0091504119,
0.0090546981,
-0.0107081607,
-0.0354796275,
-0.0700462386,
0.032561373,
0.0727289394,
-0.0536686666,
-0.0510680005,
-0.070875451,
-0.0268101227,
-0.0067913453,
-0.0103642838,
-0.0057679764,
-0.0285952929,
0.0122268116,
-0.0041582645,
0.0214470197,
-0.0729142502,
0.0177496001,
0.0276149306,
0.0917461216,
0.0449879952,
0.0149467541,
-0.0154657289,
-0.0421099924,
-0.027098285,
0.0013181714,
-0.035512697,
-0.0024526536,
-0.020852726,
0.0208109263,
-0.0203608815,
-0.0071162838,
0.0845247209,
-0.0242189299,
-0.0075389887,
0.0383073799,
0.1049962342,
-0.0313046053,
-0.0349792801,
-0.0081145978,
0.0559241883,
0.0558742508,
0.0682122558,
0.0111393519,
0.0030652138,
0.0146294683,
-0.0103414198,
-0.0063912491,
-0.0383844078,
-0.0255042911,
0.0077094291,
0.0230206288,
-0.0142763564,
-0.0806854442,
0.0069027641,
0.0684890524,
-0.0044512511,
0.0200317353,
-0.0129172336,
0.0238403399,
0.0705770031,
-0.037547186,
0.0741301477,
0.0157901477,
0.0054339357,
-0.0631541908,
-0.0661484078,
0.0300207231,
-0.0227694716,
-0.0099681811,
0.0434951186,
-0.0635807812,
-0.0916889384,
0.0067189424,
0.0282075666,
0.0274091065,
0.0221668258,
0.0435277224,
-0.0356857739,
0.0331330001,
0.0227229148,
-0.0320492797,
0.002179388,
0.0142433085,
-0.003289328,
0.00479203,
-0.0031798962,
-0.0018265832,
-0.0037354128,
-0.0379042216,
0.0076432438,
-0.0390308201,
-0.0593481064,
-0.0059320172,
0.0297199693,
0.0757877156,
-0.0169450901,
-0.0249088854,
-0.0524561442,
-0.0134257376,
-0.021141408,
0.0386329368,
-0.0505312607,
0.0270649586,
0.0173381977,
0.010508717,
0.0031411669,
0.0046734475,
-0.0543085262,
-0.0241363421,
0.0211794656,
0.1204730421,
0.0148740616,
-0.0060745766,
0.022377599,
0.0230063386,
-0.0137449354,
0.0249896236,
-0.0239318907,
0.0581788942,
0.0171197224,
0.0006517009,
0.0083283149,
-0.016399892,
0.0309599862,
0.0293947067,
-0.0337816998,
-0.0210596435,
0.0068526883,
0.0461408645,
0.0185509752,
0.0219855402,
0.0608965829,
-0.042694252,
0.0045800372,
-0.0298519451,
0.0485678278,
-0.0184935927,
-0.005604954,
0.0470878519,
0.0002917208,
0.0139213391,
-0.0001544024,
0.0542035773,
-0.0227314997,
0.0498303212,
0.0139897168,
0.0302130524,
-0.0459842384,
-0.0118969008,
-0.0525681153,
0.007604755,
-0.0076476247,
0.0214979928,
0.0022920601,
-0.0077226562,
-0.0212328881,
0.0045303679,
-0.0408386514,
-0.042920135,
0.0381172113,
-0.0015130333,
-0.0486182496,
-0.0203659423,
0.0336693265,
0.0347770862,
-0.0270129498,
-0.0505220145,
-0.024024399,
-5.270039456e-33,
-0.0153121324,
-0.0517157987,
0.012825923,
0.0464514196,
-0.0353159346,
0.0191746131,
-0.0667043179,
0.0241908338,
-0.0177896302,
0.0097026033,
-0.000169547,
-0.0111074969,
0.0211647265,
-0.0045059575,
0.0255898535,
0.0361464061,
0.0344494022,
-0.0030700073,
0.0086393682,
0.0009158697,
0.0262976363,
0.0169029515,
0.0781753212,
-0.1029852405,
0.010714096,
0.025181463,
-0.0159350578,
-0.026096398,
-0.0070958771,
0.0332475118,
-0.0163839627,
0.0345275588,
-0.0271423813,
-0.0144958161,
-0.037025895,
0.0235339552,
-0.0631000847,
-0.0156787038,
0.0261221584,
0.0165946316,
-0.0467541888,
-0.0301455744,
0.0059061022,
-0.0196821596,
-0.0389342085,
-0.0246272869,
0.0392730795,
-0.0415744297,
0.0080403825,
0.0024382307,
-0.0614622496,
0.0018257553,
-0.0584442243,
-0.0669225082,
0.069228366,
0.0808127597,
-0.0128728291,
-0.0200186428,
-0.0050222743,
0.1195492893,
0.043836832,
0.0259425659,
0.0285115372,
-0.0104474109,
0.0285022408,
0.0571666434,
0.06559892,
-0.0335614122,
0.0201716051,
-0.0033845212,
0.0114902062,
0.0208441634,
0.0621429235,
0.0235629994,
0.0240143538,
0.0118246265,
-0.0204415359,
-0.0041829278,
0.0996717289,
0.0012126331,
-0.0419334322,
0.0282285791,
-0.0247654226,
0.01053234,
-0.022050336,
-0.0006032041,
0.0230491627,
0.0004268066,
0.0078666275,
-0.0288714189,
-0.0124195479,
0.0013320857,
0.0049121273,
-0.0083467001,
0.0190929715,
0.0031234024,
0.041323863,
-0.0089167003,
-0.0227862541,
-0.0171293374,
-0.0403893366,
-0.0267439261,
0.0495949574,
0.0073054587,
0.0581688248,
0.0418466814,
-0.023064157,
0.0241147466,
-0.0114308763,
-0.0237550512,
0.002816821,
-0.0127391219,
0.009534128,
-0.0043281172,
0.0340812802,
-0.0055072848,
-0.0029233035,
0.0485750064,
-0.0153768072,
0.048539158,
-0.0139536671,
-0.0040317117,
-0.0254907422,
-0.0055348212,
-0.0425580107,
-0.014904486,
-0.0558213331,
-0.0526355878,
-0.0072423886,
-0.0254170764,
0.0005387151,
-0.0436028577,
2.49e-7,
-0.0467920154,
0.0640730336,
0.0329815298,
-0.0369825102,
0.0266214404,
0.0145620266,
-0.0322741568,
-0.0280371755,
0.0078199795,
-0.0025254625,
-0.0208654422,
-0.0370611437,
0.0710903481,
0.0191928558,
-0.1008160263,
-0.0544200614,
-0.0341283046,
-0.0285442472,
-0.0174678173,
-0.0095580965,
0.0239783898,
0.0265041683,
0.0030113203,
-0.0047292854,
0.0195750277,
0.012303602,
-0.0211667512,
0.00024746,
0.0372131653,
0.0047251657,
-0.0352856964,
-0.0302395914,
-0.0245563053,
-0.0048706098,
-0.024427142,
0.0137875276,
-0.0127185788,
0.0375130102,
-0.0218726881,
-0.0670121685,
0.0113603482,
0.0315612592,
-0.0391950272,
0.0007048476,
0.0074409069,
-0.0249018334,
0.000094244,
0.0396493003,
-0.0077642086,
-0.0306160692,
-0.0089461626,
-0.0309099331,
0.010732268,
-0.0082589732,
-0.0449096896,
-0.0257103723,
-0.0056197653,
-0.0421817116,
0.0089503862,
-0.0251808055,
-0.0892695114,
-0.0732108578,
-0.0081812572,
-0.0122338152,
-0.0156035246,
-0.0187730063,
-0.0018629438,
1.543357846e-34,
0.0122714555,
-0.0190915,
0.0452113971,
0.0154254846,
-0.010560452,
-0.0157963857,
0.0806846768,
-0.0020370868,
0.0581890345,
-0.0517812595,
-0.0544879287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13345v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13345v3 | BAMBOO: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Evaluating Long Text Modeling Capacities of Large Language Models | 2023-09-23T11:36:15 | 2024-03-19T09:00:32 | Zican Dong, Tianyi Tang, Junyi Li, Wayne Xin Zhao, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved dramatic proficiency over NLP
tasks with normal length. Recently, multiple studies have committed to
extending the context length and enhancing the long text modeling capabilities
of LLMs. To comprehensively evaluate the long context ability of LLMs, we
propose BAMBOO, a multi-task long context benchmark. BAMBOO has been designed
with four principles: comprehensive capacity evaluation, avoidance of data
contamination, accurate automatic evaluation, and different length levels. It
consists of 10 datasets from 5 different long text understanding tasks, i.e.
question answering, hallucination detection, text sorting, language modeling,
and code completion, to cover core capacities and various domains of LLMs. We
conduct experiments with five long context models on BAMBOO and further discuss
four key research questions of long text. We also qualitatively analyze current
long context models and point out future directions for enhancing long text
modeling capacities. We release our data, prompts, and code at
https://github.com/RUCAIBox/BAMBOO. | [
0.0246924683,
0.0327078775,
0.0045369552,
0.0624772869,
-0.035501074,
0.0156687256,
0.0246749893,
0.00175313,
-0.008497877,
-0.0300395433,
-0.0237373803,
-0.0517346784,
0.0174701177,
0.0046021622,
0.0186485369,
-0.0392847806,
0.0232149046,
-0.0557216369,
-0.0137123019,
0.0234368443,
0.0182524621,
-0.0105444705,
0.0070587029,
0.0432113521,
0.003436995,
-0.0538488589,
-0.0137801617,
0.004823918,
-0.0014761389,
-0.0448184162,
0.010791678,
0.0613663234,
-0.0056617889,
0.0691858381,
0.0000017765,
-0.0478633456,
-0.0043281307,
-0.0026702215,
-0.0279305615,
0.0294669662,
0.0456437729,
-0.0098938243,
-0.0046794731,
0.00420791,
-0.0092663709,
0.0192986634,
0.0298922434,
0.0672327727,
0.029436022,
0.0559406728,
-0.0042262617,
-0.0392016768,
0.0452705547,
-0.0400617085,
0.0393153317,
-0.0295608081,
0.0333533771,
0.0226769894,
0.0566929094,
0.0265716612,
-0.0284922887,
0.0473220758,
0.0580079481,
0.0194104537,
-0.0123817641,
0.0406324752,
-0.0207903087,
0.0005529616,
0.0115428083,
0.0858205557,
-0.0082245618,
-0.0216753278,
-0.0050722859,
0.004706827,
-0.0013212375,
-0.0326674134,
-0.0450781696,
0.01456179,
-0.0261288602,
-0.0061317761,
0.0285873991,
0.0033196611,
0.0299458634,
0.0150963124,
-0.0419078246,
0.0706257969,
0.0206878446,
-0.0319836363,
-0.011363076,
-0.031646315,
-0.0068781245,
-0.0558354557,
0.0254313629,
0.043478556,
-0.0415538624,
0.0215642639,
-0.0286631063,
-0.0316328332,
0.0501533188,
-0.0582977571,
-0.0200501997,
0.0313646235,
-0.0462225676,
0.0732507631,
-0.0345723815,
0.0613847747,
-0.0339738615,
0.0199987739,
-0.0483885966,
-0.0156616755,
-0.0331819952,
-0.0165371951,
-0.0504917577,
-0.0077845347,
-0.0529030338,
-0.0557384752,
-0.0187192056,
0.0205084328,
0.0192962382,
0.0011379998,
0.0103764879,
-0.00069252,
-0.0131250974,
-0.0122843841,
-0.0027474342,
0.0176254362,
-0.0567785241,
-0.0043361532,
0.0138399219,
-0.0333945863,
-0.0207392201,
0.0303521007,
0.0003151031,
-0.0728544518,
0.0042117629,
0.0246431474,
0.0108249271,
-0.0200216491,
0.0039187362,
-0.0014005337,
-0.0642141178,
-0.0492007025,
-0.0124098333,
-0.0805158913,
0.0151810832,
0.0154896211,
0.0214015935,
-0.01891247,
0.0146574788,
0.0309925191,
-0.0170427449,
0.0767455176,
-0.0043882793,
0.0062547876,
0.0219403151,
0.0328590795,
0.0003775225,
0.0761546865,
0.0052826218,
0.0377255641,
0.0350015946,
-0.0128611112,
0.0338896923,
0.0430923589,
-0.0182189886,
0.0035359242,
-0.0419323705,
0.0438284092,
0.0324901193,
0.0341343731,
0.0133852288,
0.0542196818,
-0.0081894379,
-0.0358580388,
0.020540867,
0.05656958,
0.0390216522,
-0.0177059472,
0.0474632345,
0.0033583874,
-0.000726604,
0.0139951706,
-0.0535767935,
0.0104712043,
-0.0294622462,
0.0368417911,
0.0364957713,
0.0058477912,
-0.0300777927,
-0.0399650075,
-0.0347063988,
-0.0095057115,
0.0161009803,
0.0168036595,
0.0406236798,
0.0119091282,
-0.0350836925,
0.0287881326,
0.0117603755,
-0.032622803,
-0.0060356273,
-0.0237170067,
0.0347553752,
0.1065272242,
0.0394771546,
-0.0509058125,
0.0179183725,
-0.0128342537,
0.0408161804,
0.0595653877,
-0.0015581773,
0.0058705397,
0.0327668637,
-0.0314605311,
0.003293453,
-0.0010714668,
0.0257900544,
-0.0004338905,
0.0350847617,
0.0156446006,
0.0386828147,
-0.0481437668,
-0.0262475964,
0.0554630123,
-0.0625287071,
-0.0233983565,
-0.0492216088,
0.0054684542,
0.0102532655,
0.0001198395,
-0.0138246976,
0.0252865553,
0.0233767107,
-0.0525808223,
-0.0253114849,
-0.0116131213,
-0.0826753825,
-0.041986987,
0.0467553772,
-0.0126830544,
-0.0134154037,
0.0183247607,
-0.006389562,
-0.0513782129,
-0.0249922238,
-0.0233532507,
0.0237044226,
-0.0417930149,
0.0241324399,
-0.0091282334,
0.0405614153,
-0.0437504649,
0.0788082853,
-0.011108919,
0.0406055599,
0.0480859838,
0.0356631987,
-0.0024573009,
-0.0335368067,
-0.0518909693,
0.0163926538,
-0.0084756725,
-0.0028773206,
-0.0087365527,
0.0043052346,
-0.071792677,
-0.0387436487,
-0.1226034686,
0.0290594846,
-0.0468770564,
-0.002779736,
0.0300216433,
0.0113105383,
-0.023914244,
-0.0052235099,
-0.0371045955,
-0.0117424736,
0.0092574069,
0.0201022215,
0.0149733424,
0.0089610247,
-0.0358667038,
-0.0384035148,
-0.0211814884,
-0.0150240604,
0.0667486265,
-0.0059555797,
-0.0482919365,
-0.0572065935,
0.0605688728,
0.002874325,
0.0000140988,
-0.0271447301,
-0.0292479191,
0.0090062665,
-0.0277823973,
0.0906329602,
0.0592070296,
0.0269055273,
0.0100429608,
0.0210686997,
-0.0194228329,
-0.019818861,
0.0087430524,
0.0176021606,
0.0051808911,
-0.0384613425,
-0.0133340517,
-0.0141132995,
0.0789514482,
-0.0094869919,
0.0106781283,
-0.0377892144,
-0.0172868483,
-0.0268545263,
-0.0124064693,
-0.0101000248,
-0.005645535,
-0.0320952125,
0.0239705406,
-0.0607007295,
-0.0412179381,
0.0591798462,
-0.078532055,
-0.0247346796,
-0.0221370608,
-0.00449123,
-0.0595228486,
0.0949611813,
0.0001815575,
-0.0045038005,
-0.0302762315,
-0.0331405401,
-0.0197759476,
0.0161868948,
-0.0589229204,
-0.0325680971,
0.0399508029,
-0.022866454,
0.0235907063,
-0.0139974942,
0.0026879481,
-0.0331958197,
-0.030572176,
-0.0469134226,
0.0098178275,
0.0186607521,
0.020783117,
0.0060771084,
0.035133753,
0.0304273311,
0.054041218,
-0.0261999052,
0.0036188888,
-0.0269879308,
0.0370300375,
0.0493256636,
0.0040154355,
0.0176823661,
-0.0482009836,
0.0590391234,
0.0368245617,
0.0437519923,
0.0206171572,
-0.0218497943,
-0.027849121,
-0.0053411056,
-0.0384200439,
-0.0273805652,
0.0109007386,
0.0720190331,
-0.0905589759,
-0.0129162725,
0.1203003004,
0.0249167457,
-0.0572474301,
-0.0062456476,
-0.0414942577,
0.0447804481,
0.0270492267,
-0.0134312604,
-0.0994282216,
-0.0490844101,
0.0127606327,
-0.0056897742,
0.0211277921,
-0.0287212785,
0.0018471844,
-0.109275043,
-0.0135114333,
0.0057501895,
-0.0697096735,
-0.0115522351,
-0.0328517854,
0.0150570096,
0.0258439835,
0.0476459675,
0.0252965707,
-0.0150294602,
-0.0088555366,
-0.0036576998,
-0.0145040574,
-0.029112855,
0.0606365688,
-0.0355621427,
0.0501498505,
0.054794006,
0.0168245826,
0.0000626833,
0.0046860576,
0.0491051152,
-0.0395657904,
0.0039757504,
0.018117791,
0.0428083614,
-0.0000782813,
0.0019737666,
0.0011634509,
0.0259244386,
-0.0543581657,
-0.0025966607,
0.0566213094,
0.0598081313,
-0.0126104513,
-0.0179806016,
-0.0072838836,
-0.0061068651,
-0.0061137849,
0.0968546048,
0.0701725259,
-0.04725793,
-0.0730317011,
-0.0308475327,
-0.0190204941,
-0.0568648838,
-0.0047699641,
0.0153253768,
0.0295603424,
0.016992867,
-0.0540705547,
-0.06591212,
0.0462751314,
0.0343390703,
-0.0028554667,
0.0690778866,
-0.0320760496,
-0.0026067866,
-0.0514488965,
0.02940844,
-0.0475711189,
0.0526254363,
-0.0729568303,
0.0304102525,
0.0173525363,
-0.0249657482,
0.0029742036,
0.043183092,
-0.1215130314,
-0.050719548,
0.0196771156,
0.0007800924,
0.0258245189,
0.03752058,
-0.0294064078,
-0.0460077561,
0.0056168935,
0.0053175781,
-0.0530030355,
0.0216605812,
-0.0050092838,
0.0290061776,
0.0144571057,
0.0326758735,
-0.0301792175,
0.0073137018,
0.0020812762,
0.0384125859,
-0.013877565,
-0.0147440135,
-0.0000327537,
0.0120600257,
-0.0240041725,
0.0147182513,
-0.0107761258,
-0.0091051832,
0.0191727038,
-0.0289168376,
-0.018433312,
-0.0193486195,
0.0177031476,
0.0450195968,
-0.0288642384,
0.0153767345,
0.0028224476,
0.0027794272,
0.0064297733,
-0.0441343747,
0.0300766844,
0.0041683284,
0.0028160051,
0.0447740257,
-0.008974988,
-0.0204859413,
-0.011893318,
-0.0192903876,
0.043001391,
-0.0063538575,
0.0526915006,
0.0104376301,
-0.0371705107,
-0.0243644714,
0.0393228382,
-0.0927111357,
-0.036324311,
0.0129738329,
0.0260446854,
0.0434125438,
-0.0080998428,
0.0411719121,
0.0048316577,
0.0069246427,
-0.0327039696,
0.0266206488,
0.0167868491,
-0.0315606557,
0.0048689353,
0.054779008,
-0.0223451741,
-0.0019379316,
0.0927760676,
0.0358933955,
0.017788792,
0.0431817137,
0.0087429658,
-0.0316856354,
-0.022471223,
-0.0325899869,
0.0259254687,
-0.0319261514,
0.0004094311,
-0.0349829346,
-0.0677649006,
0.0258446801,
-0.014177775,
-0.0133076711,
-0.011532478,
-0.0051512583,
0.0671617091,
0.0018619832,
0.0089282161,
-0.0129769808,
0.0122266868,
0.0180227049,
-0.0218528081,
-0.0171254445,
-5.695715348e-33,
-0.0167418309,
-0.0452028885,
0.0272939112,
-0.0591594763,
-0.04196788,
0.0251831003,
-0.0493569896,
0.0004235756,
0.0036634547,
-0.0201708917,
-0.0368701853,
0.0368025899,
0.0061859735,
0.0389563888,
-0.0201876163,
-0.0343966931,
0.0277834758,
0.0164215583,
-0.007904917,
0.0207917765,
0.0154408338,
0.0332803987,
0.010357663,
-0.0267921649,
0.0393080302,
-0.0130764544,
0.0079155155,
0.0137587711,
-0.0073732603,
0.0889172107,
-0.0433243513,
0.0256430116,
0.0561796501,
-0.0484878831,
-0.0419012643,
0.0504290238,
-0.0868726969,
0.0254521891,
0.004126484,
0.0010466246,
-0.0513336807,
-0.0328615606,
0.0518690906,
-0.0064129825,
0.0354084931,
-0.0080718799,
0.0453921072,
-0.0705494359,
-0.0288455337,
0.0166183729,
-0.049723383,
0.0182871316,
-0.0125823766,
-0.0192461405,
0.0251071025,
0.0330963098,
-0.0054783607,
0.065052405,
-0.0481035002,
-0.0267930683,
-0.0038636564,
0.0432644896,
0.0389770865,
0.0397489257,
0.0191645641,
0.0433274731,
0.0398620628,
0.006235674,
-0.0387892909,
-0.0504648536,
0.0258224774,
0.0389685445,
0.0437370874,
0.0136911469,
0.0472714975,
-0.0080575496,
-0.033432968,
0.0040125893,
0.0023617574,
0.025376983,
0.0314991549,
0.0104870824,
-0.0329644009,
-0.0131247919,
-0.0362529643,
0.01768516,
-0.0394288823,
0.0001202804,
0.0656647384,
0.0063202833,
0.0005049509,
-0.0193573292,
0.0531874225,
-0.0375543833,
-0.0088384785,
0.0589007847,
-0.0059945998,
0.0400219485,
0.0130161699,
0.0536030419,
-0.029182462,
0.0134721017,
0.0240916796,
0.0302686431,
0.001648832,
-0.0299516041,
0.0322100483,
-0.0265202429,
-0.0738873035,
-0.0057953298,
-0.0461240336,
0.0019385804,
-0.0209422987,
0.0233685616,
0.0439328328,
0.0059293318,
-0.0003052711,
0.056637466,
0.0130592966,
-0.013558724,
-0.0283336099,
-0.0341822132,
-0.0286044236,
-0.0016663142,
-0.0293932185,
-0.0163572095,
-0.0254251212,
0.026014464,
0.0206786562,
-0.0499015264,
0.0071024513,
0.0253485925,
2.338e-7,
0.0402278118,
0.0343414098,
0.0521592274,
0.0196195897,
0.0227329899,
-0.0113557028,
-0.0092511922,
0.0079994453,
-0.0244453531,
-0.0344958454,
-0.025819445,
0.0421946533,
0.0703624263,
0.0006256921,
-0.0903947353,
-0.0078344671,
-0.0527572669,
0.0231802948,
-0.080268383,
-0.0133631723,
0.0555460565,
0.0961909816,
-0.0251700319,
0.0171066169,
0.0087698735,
-0.0633724853,
0.0395664945,
-0.0382723808,
0.0280377399,
0.0273354184,
0.0005047022,
0.0160121415,
0.0258022752,
0.0011824484,
0.0405867472,
0.007148596,
0.0302582923,
0.0698069036,
0.0242171083,
-0.0374726243,
0.0115780486,
-0.0267841052,
-0.0090028699,
-0.0822270215,
0.0830950513,
-0.0386848003,
0.005042274,
-0.0092126029,
-0.0146034425,
-0.0267883632,
0.0204960164,
0.0115969563,
-0.00028923,
0.0158566367,
0.0080013573,
-0.0387752019,
-0.0062090154,
-0.0888370499,
-0.0508489832,
-0.0086395629,
-0.060413029,
0.0028608216,
-0.0796079785,
-0.0139951305,
0.0195924994,
-0.0880069435,
-0.0004598513,
2.346939904e-34,
0.0410291962,
-0.0302671865,
0.008598011,
0.0207263548,
0.0411201008,
-0.0384004675,
0.0122387316,
0.0003791903,
-0.0020810047,
-0.096123673,
-0.0114146965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14365v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14365v1 | An In-depth Survey of Large Language Model-based Artificial Intelligence Agents | 2023-09-23T11:25:45 | 2023-09-23T11:25:45 | Pengyu Zhao, Zijian Jin, Ning Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Due to the powerful capabilities demonstrated by large language model (LLM),
there has been a recent surge in efforts to integrate them with AI agents to
enhance their performance. In this paper, we have explored the core differences
and characteristics between LLM-based AI agents and traditional AI agents.
Specifically, we first compare the fundamental characteristics of these two
types of agents, clarifying the significant advantages of LLM-based agents in
handling natural language, knowledge storage, and reasoning capabilities.
Subsequently, we conducted an in-depth analysis of the key components of AI
agents, including planning, memory, and tool use. Particularly, for the crucial
component of memory, this paper introduced an innovative classification scheme,
not only departing from traditional classification methods but also providing a
fresh perspective on the design of an AI agent's memory system. We firmly
believe that in-depth research and understanding of these core components will
lay a solid foundation for the future advancement of AI agent technology. At
the end of the paper, we provide directional suggestions for further research
in this field, with the hope of offering valuable insights to scholars and
researchers in the field. | [
0.0693319142,
0.0193448458,
-0.0386585332,
0.0407390445,
-0.0538072065,
0.0017489437,
0.0172797386,
-0.0092313001,
0.0508556962,
-0.0763558224,
-0.0223792903,
-0.0305801295,
-0.0609473214,
0.0216428041,
-0.0112907197,
-0.0284502245,
0.0220732186,
-0.0523325726,
0.0403180532,
-0.0037851615,
-0.0240307413,
-0.0262548253,
0.0244699437,
0.0116918413,
-0.0125511019,
0.0133372992,
-0.0300582256,
-0.0406964906,
-0.0136530139,
-0.0299234502,
-0.0256117824,
0.0009521637,
0.0403795019,
0.0347797573,
0.0000021753,
-0.0711866766,
0.017832797,
-0.014708559,
-0.0477477759,
0.0044832416,
0.0336838216,
0.0098401252,
-0.0136558423,
0.010302349,
-0.0562036186,
0.0101114539,
0.0196502712,
0.0412326083,
0.0309455805,
0.0716449991,
0.0029332545,
-0.0427732654,
0.0360832177,
0.0080759525,
0.0015964188,
-0.0585184619,
0.0355763212,
0.0291683115,
0.0327986032,
0.0328100175,
-0.0026334485,
0.0216043536,
0.0195751544,
0.0001035074,
-0.0287275743,
0.0260730181,
-0.0289009493,
-0.0237033442,
-0.0239052642,
0.0274964962,
0.0128759351,
-0.0131244967,
0.0279245619,
0.0169580374,
0.0014294761,
0.0050913719,
-0.0380653106,
0.0919016004,
-0.0154069401,
0.0068320958,
0.0548122227,
-0.0005987803,
0.0182706043,
0.0325824209,
-0.0668897629,
0.0601793826,
-0.0115939071,
-0.0164818242,
-0.0077406508,
-0.0558450259,
0.0156048536,
-0.0761266351,
0.0039379303,
0.081069082,
-0.0155496607,
0.0429877266,
-0.0193707626,
0.0072206887,
0.0207342487,
-0.0723286495,
0.0298845191,
0.0072281393,
0.0300982185,
0.0512946323,
-0.0419179723,
0.0931416377,
-0.0170114599,
0.0113376128,
-0.0282397717,
-0.0233443771,
-0.0572548322,
-0.0172020569,
-0.026957592,
0.0734379217,
0.0233978312,
-0.0396228619,
-0.0121438568,
0.0519382022,
-0.0089645758,
0.0601468347,
0.0005156788,
-0.0159962568,
0.0089603225,
-0.0200714059,
-0.0797687992,
-0.0041846894,
-0.0309866108,
0.0083547272,
-0.025841577,
-0.032084737,
0.0372382179,
0.0184828471,
-0.015329116,
-0.0012573535,
0.024285987,
0.0857081339,
0.0021663308,
-0.0420103557,
-0.0576303117,
-0.018066451,
0.0246577095,
-0.0946298167,
0.0015148622,
-0.048684366,
0.0294150822,
0.0128572425,
-0.0286823399,
-0.0413270667,
0.017898865,
0.0050502773,
-0.0098681999,
0.0451292209,
0.0176309962,
0.0270605609,
0.0440357476,
0.0020460582,
0.0105987135,
0.0310326684,
0.0427376442,
0.0308942329,
0.021074418,
0.0127319368,
0.0181688555,
0.0191907473,
-0.0234012138,
-0.0275042597,
-0.015728429,
0.0165313948,
0.0134182442,
0.0018068168,
-0.0243641865,
0.0676767752,
0.0051125442,
-0.0281096697,
0.0436433703,
0.0800631866,
0.0032991362,
0.0245865509,
0.0579452887,
0.0202466324,
0.021249745,
-0.0429229178,
-0.0238976032,
0.0250426624,
-0.0329825543,
-0.0131181087,
-0.039627336,
0.0208969563,
-0.0310851149,
-0.048992753,
-0.0274616629,
-0.0343351401,
0.0272038113,
0.0066171614,
0.0453269109,
-0.0409068279,
-0.0250001065,
0.002179309,
0.0013200097,
-0.0221899487,
-0.0164684467,
-0.1088663265,
0.0169231221,
0.0687494725,
0.0141072003,
-0.0351143219,
-0.0337050445,
0.0204285216,
-0.0279804152,
0.0281465966,
0.0216301549,
-0.0083967829,
-0.0617241412,
-0.0421811976,
0.0059593436,
-0.0171748418,
0.0108561171,
0.0418599918,
0.0103614852,
0.0248883665,
0.0048083742,
0.0135054663,
-0.0174272023,
0.0152727747,
-0.0172989443,
-0.0148920957,
-0.0385888107,
-0.005450469,
0.0571779981,
0.0057758139,
-0.0147744706,
0.0096205967,
0.0481854416,
-0.0344901718,
-0.047563687,
0.0013075707,
-0.0076711057,
0.0269705113,
0.0376887918,
0.0375258103,
0.0554786511,
0.0090331594,
0.0115221748,
-0.0446417145,
0.013151872,
-0.0170305334,
0.0585126057,
-0.0401935503,
0.0531907678,
-0.0257397331,
-0.0287543219,
-0.0293108243,
0.0925084725,
-0.0087081818,
-0.0469576269,
0.0108300587,
0.0545363948,
0.0230600499,
-0.0259683058,
-0.0212407019,
0.078867875,
0.0414822549,
0.0339545384,
0.0364100114,
-0.0355416536,
-0.0137827704,
-0.0590623915,
-0.0793529972,
0.0199441761,
-0.0017710105,
-0.0223419685,
-0.0256584212,
-0.0422795005,
0.0004458211,
0.0266110264,
-0.023395,
0.0428875387,
0.0098819612,
0.0190693922,
-0.005218253,
0.0175067261,
-0.0516128615,
-0.0183150247,
0.0064182873,
-0.0095031848,
0.0080074677,
0.0269970931,
-0.0347668678,
-0.0551306158,
0.0758742318,
-0.0517255887,
0.0312403217,
-0.0314842351,
-0.0451989844,
-0.0095540015,
-0.0496029779,
-0.0025660677,
0.1093534008,
-0.0083077848,
0.0469903648,
0.0738486499,
-0.0098399818,
-0.0419264585,
0.0271752272,
-0.0195816029,
-0.0288253166,
-0.048020795,
0.0034018413,
-0.0011091267,
0.0358518958,
-0.0015495679,
0.0218606442,
-0.0263306033,
0.012733941,
-0.0085800085,
-0.0314345062,
0.0165364221,
-0.0268052742,
-0.0031929831,
0.037060868,
-0.00512924,
-0.0326312408,
0.0522498153,
0.0001270314,
0.031346757,
-0.0187461972,
-0.0573446229,
-0.0601742156,
0.0879082456,
0.0123171546,
0.0462953039,
-0.0421912372,
-0.0006747317,
-0.0179563202,
-0.0263490714,
-0.0085900547,
-0.0266756453,
0.0193177648,
-0.0551494285,
0.0236549899,
-0.000568822,
-0.0294244587,
-0.0550373383,
-0.0031954267,
-0.0656888708,
0.015087341,
-0.0036022309,
-0.0361551642,
-0.0481909923,
0.025339298,
0.0348692499,
0.020616265,
0.0143351406,
0.0111301271,
-0.0093338061,
-0.0508861691,
0.0073169391,
0.0106562683,
0.0104185436,
0.0048027863,
0.0837321132,
0.0371548273,
0.016532911,
-0.0084709795,
-0.0220228154,
-0.0055283625,
0.0213554483,
-0.0304796249,
-0.0443325862,
0.0163543019,
-0.0110444482,
-0.0739817694,
0.0023572571,
0.1025536805,
0.0408385359,
-0.0370208882,
-0.0137208961,
-0.0287459493,
-0.0055076303,
0.0371047519,
0.0484433882,
-0.0230376739,
-0.0234284252,
-0.0117121609,
-0.0425517224,
-0.0411320478,
-0.0281652045,
-0.0188626684,
-0.1033961624,
0.0264886674,
0.0125235468,
-0.0020685368,
-0.0268352646,
-0.035683617,
-0.0209872648,
0.0315309688,
0.0049721966,
0.0023633093,
0.0136977881,
-0.0567128658,
-0.0009539336,
-0.0376029871,
-0.0128975408,
0.0241575539,
-0.0362836123,
0.0558492728,
0.0846662596,
0.0346138924,
-0.0126855271,
-0.0160636883,
0.0030586463,
0.0235656872,
0.042549558,
0.001900696,
0.0070457878,
-0.0102211153,
-0.0039339312,
-0.0238529816,
0.0105026895,
-0.0031310767,
-0.0070116739,
0.0394403897,
0.0845571756,
-0.0496936776,
-0.0314062275,
-0.0108152647,
-0.029352298,
-0.0167673305,
0.089518778,
-0.0407657847,
-0.0491129085,
-0.0534440577,
-0.0077105607,
-0.0333973952,
0.0068828263,
-0.0273529235,
0.032890372,
-0.0171405524,
0.0084934318,
-0.0406012349,
-0.0512507074,
0.0230907891,
-0.0024167339,
0.0277434792,
0.0197795853,
0.0435983427,
0.0086002685,
-0.0205519423,
-0.0292670187,
-0.0548619032,
0.000131896,
-0.0482332222,
-0.0177949723,
0.0682669207,
-0.0450479127,
0.005040572,
-0.0194876902,
-0.0562012866,
-0.04639538,
0.0326928832,
0.0452368259,
0.0224106666,
-0.0009063787,
0.0278617498,
-0.0261104293,
0.0542246141,
-0.0054210443,
-0.0431692936,
0.0492028818,
-0.0018817638,
0.0322277322,
0.0148171624,
0.0503156744,
-0.0604923517,
0.0187836085,
-0.0082900114,
0.0057872152,
-0.0677580312,
-0.0160001088,
0.0198071413,
0.0363205336,
-0.0362315774,
0.0261019673,
-0.0088455668,
0.0063654627,
0.0304304548,
-0.0466288775,
-0.0273582265,
-0.015630506,
-0.003719528,
0.0054169758,
0.0026646289,
0.0164981391,
-0.0104965065,
0.0255712792,
-0.020854488,
0.0479191504,
0.0024444405,
-0.0053595211,
0.0118311225,
0.0154119311,
0.0296688601,
-0.0263749342,
0.0330527946,
-0.0054921829,
0.0446005687,
0.0023838342,
0.0942139924,
-0.0008881616,
-0.0554454699,
-0.0616645664,
0.0166215561,
-0.0625409409,
-0.107045792,
0.0850096345,
0.0638076067,
0.0686723292,
-0.0006535596,
-0.0001425757,
-0.0779947564,
0.0066386154,
-0.0151017224,
-0.0115453079,
0.0359703712,
-0.0452621318,
0.0161729101,
0.0243304204,
-0.0182330646,
0.0081391344,
0.0279190298,
-0.0095966924,
0.0698323846,
-0.0177385602,
-0.0256645791,
-0.0415286832,
-0.0212430898,
0.0146560222,
-0.0076706717,
0.0083847838,
-0.0036164701,
-0.0993451923,
-0.0450452529,
0.0194706228,
0.0033203687,
-0.0079210987,
-0.0367791243,
0.0191251282,
0.0277776122,
0.0023721061,
-0.0234988425,
-0.0586549453,
-0.0151601192,
-0.0542597771,
0.0138532268,
0.0164862443,
-5.983285715e-33,
-0.0271640848,
-0.0378346108,
0.0698286965,
-0.0124452775,
-0.0092397872,
-0.0046157083,
-0.0062244255,
-0.0086286217,
-0.0304690525,
-0.0157315247,
-0.0199911874,
0.0109167099,
0.0051878877,
-0.0130582005,
0.0028245533,
-0.0023819548,
0.0193805471,
-0.0020455497,
0.0000559864,
0.0051276311,
0.0640330315,
-0.0195834264,
-0.012431425,
-0.0510589033,
-0.0125512118,
-0.0106076105,
0.0096384697,
0.0421315283,
-0.0208350308,
0.0597744584,
-0.0369030945,
0.0232245941,
0.0271980017,
-0.0029844365,
-0.0069840141,
0.0273248367,
-0.0119006606,
-0.0227473974,
-0.0022088459,
0.0068169003,
0.034256354,
-0.0605224967,
0.0005140303,
-0.0090677077,
-0.0476883091,
0.0428147279,
0.0246736743,
-0.0278849956,
0.0061220056,
0.0185515266,
-0.0667259991,
0.004045106,
0.0152535206,
0.003020149,
0.0178810544,
-0.0358734727,
-0.00839247,
0.0028571221,
-0.0419522598,
0.0228772946,
-0.0103356345,
-0.0171913207,
0.0526665486,
0.0335933901,
0.021994235,
0.0639031753,
0.0482293628,
0.0357538313,
-0.0343702212,
-0.010494275,
0.0077309622,
0.0526624434,
0.0145497909,
0.0319215953,
-0.0227177199,
0.0013250716,
-0.0460194536,
-0.0034016699,
0.0453975275,
0.0687672272,
0.0670125112,
0.0059184539,
-0.0622783601,
-0.0178502146,
-0.059628211,
0.0400820039,
-0.0285304449,
-0.0190425292,
0.0453353673,
0.0152119901,
0.0087188696,
-0.0390545465,
0.0438798591,
-0.0489651486,
0.0122761121,
0.0514352061,
-0.012331903,
0.0261804257,
-0.0234204251,
0.0335923918,
-0.0466701612,
-0.0324523225,
-0.0340258367,
-0.0212148298,
0.0117746973,
0.0122453533,
-0.0484858267,
0.041087579,
-0.0212134775,
-0.0023576531,
-0.0253094025,
-0.0309258699,
0.0236073863,
-0.0377551466,
0.0203185491,
0.0202828553,
0.0150852036,
0.047962755,
0.0188793186,
-0.0439756811,
-0.0082907779,
-0.0017834533,
0.0067736926,
0.0045752744,
-0.0236022975,
0.0278600696,
-0.062105298,
0.0507067665,
0.0106209749,
-0.0602917448,
0.0287841409,
0.002526632,
2.915e-7,
-0.0220600497,
0.0639639124,
-0.0181032214,
0.0292680729,
-0.0157776736,
0.0421511941,
-0.0164708775,
-0.0065945764,
-0.0111067314,
0.0134154139,
0.0181290451,
0.086032629,
-0.0067544403,
0.0178227257,
-0.0662171468,
0.0111577464,
0.0107012186,
-0.0387313664,
-0.0918884948,
0.0265380535,
0.0548026115,
0.0893837512,
0.035685543,
-0.0127084721,
-0.0314453728,
-0.0824546069,
0.0582475811,
-0.0490429848,
-0.0026812737,
0.0469364077,
-0.0077228681,
0.050720036,
-0.0216679517,
0.0438938625,
0.04642234,
0.0372502841,
-0.0329154134,
0.0927829072,
-0.002833874,
-0.0166752879,
0.0051879738,
-0.0295120776,
-0.0143369827,
-0.026954174,
0.0622733124,
-0.0198735539,
-0.0570606813,
0.0097295577,
0.0306835845,
-0.0002883241,
-0.0563821159,
-0.0139865521,
-0.000948132,
-0.002716209,
-0.0250928998,
-0.0331985578,
0.0331704691,
-0.090391703,
0.0211309623,
0.007480057,
-0.0296686403,
-0.0496313274,
-0.0214192849,
0.0060464623,
0.0412138477,
-0.0426204093,
0.0382599048,
2.717386388e-34,
-0.0056024729,
-0.0142621752,
-0.0063691009,
0.0571503118,
0.039295923,
0.0418520756,
-0.0201047901,
0.047100611,
0.0362302922,
-0.1060173213,
-0.0095412405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13340v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13340v2 | Towards LLM-guided Causal Explainability for Black-box Text Classifiers | 2023-09-23T11:22:28 | 2024-01-29T05:59:12 | Amrita Bhattacharjee, Raha Moraffah, Joshua Garland, Huan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | With the advent of larger and more complex deep learning models, such as in
Natural Language Processing (NLP), model qualities like explainability and
interpretability, albeit highly desirable, are becoming harder challenges to
tackle and solve. For example, state-of-the-art models in text classification
are black-box by design. Although standard explanation methods provide some
degree of explainability, these are mostly correlation-based methods and do not
provide much insight into the model. The alternative of causal explainability
is more desirable to achieve but extremely challenging in NLP due to a variety
of reasons. Inspired by recent endeavors to utilize Large Language Models
(LLMs) as experts, in this work, we aim to leverage the instruction-following
and textual understanding capabilities of recent state-of-the-art LLMs to
facilitate causal explainability via counterfactual explanation generation for
black-box text classifiers. To do this, we propose a three-step pipeline via
which, we use an off-the-shelf LLM to: (1) identify the latent or unobserved
features in the input text, (2) identify the input features associated with the
latent features, and finally (3) use the identified input features to generate
a counterfactual explanation. We experiment with our pipeline on multiple NLP
text classification datasets, with several recent LLMs, and present interesting
and promising findings. | [
0.0274986289,
0.0519741848,
-0.031516213,
0.0254474208,
-0.0308103804,
0.0423817635,
0.0420728661,
-0.0087864976,
0.0059121372,
-0.022747729,
0.0207735207,
0.0007732825,
-0.0164834037,
0.0544166788,
0.0099931927,
-0.0092169167,
0.0023521052,
-0.004444716,
0.003487047,
-0.0063494709,
-0.008116574,
0.0333505757,
-0.0001146818,
0.0357102454,
0.0106124915,
-0.0128231207,
-0.039724458,
0.009651755,
-0.0054043834,
0.0279207919,
0.0043953951,
-0.0074904165,
0.025996197,
0.0359725617,
0.0000019447,
-0.0088359332,
-0.0522442423,
0.0081979819,
-0.088031739,
0.0034059687,
-0.0205436684,
-0.0243003387,
0.0302519109,
0.0214741398,
-0.0037445866,
0.0308711529,
0.0413876139,
0.085480541,
0.0406752974,
0.076202102,
0.0012057513,
-0.0416171364,
0.0304389521,
-0.0191335008,
0.0302380193,
-0.0066783456,
-0.0116731552,
-0.0220736749,
-0.03291969,
0.018098563,
-0.0205820948,
-0.0002948259,
0.0716380328,
-0.0361141488,
0.0332983807,
-0.0012502053,
0.0288138166,
-0.0301158652,
0.0137567194,
0.0660277456,
0.0143538862,
-0.0519440584,
0.0147031639,
-0.040144112,
0.0102288919,
0.0479174443,
-0.0332982689,
-0.0178455003,
0.0299676899,
0.0377879478,
0.0494053103,
0.0034175059,
0.0889398381,
0.0394225344,
-0.0051929182,
0.0766420364,
-0.0204783063,
-0.0229864996,
-0.0321896449,
0.014001159,
0.0037431382,
-0.0304678772,
0.0272707324,
0.045538336,
-0.017736217,
0.0139722349,
0.0265919473,
-0.0210814551,
0.0041341628,
-0.034566991,
0.0296175331,
-0.0029184658,
-0.0295148958,
0.0609776266,
-0.0220609233,
0.0442034267,
-0.0472366586,
0.0144839799,
-0.0071791601,
-0.0156109668,
-0.0636350214,
-0.0570733771,
0.0269855969,
-0.0094461907,
-0.0458356775,
0.0191764291,
-0.010287052,
0.0004828979,
-0.0324193723,
-0.0052400506,
0.0083664199,
0.0552290976,
0.0083310595,
-0.044383876,
-0.0087052779,
-0.0032505551,
-0.0313217305,
0.025532905,
-0.0217469502,
-0.0260733776,
-0.0208785739,
0.0467270352,
0.0062160832,
-0.0278534628,
0.0270259008,
0.0761927664,
0.0182900243,
-0.0265218392,
-0.0266699344,
-0.0525836349,
-0.0412672237,
-0.0526518673,
-0.0054581794,
-0.0188609511,
-0.0394453891,
0.0137710767,
-0.0032250243,
-0.0278872177,
0.0030055118,
-0.0101127094,
-0.0394662805,
0.0814341083,
0.0149841933,
-0.0101466794,
0.0131241111,
-0.0015478032,
0.0144005883,
0.0327535346,
0.034548711,
0.0076246932,
0.0352015868,
-0.0439285487,
0.0401154906,
-0.0247290861,
0.055251684,
-0.0125881908,
-0.0341197513,
-0.0288891438,
-0.0354554392,
-0.0031154796,
0.0116565516,
-0.0204450432,
0.016756624,
-0.0262118224,
0.0302904863,
0.0027108027,
0.0211671181,
0.0336889215,
0.0549797341,
0.0027418118,
-0.0500912257,
0.0447404124,
-0.0309023838,
0.03562437,
-0.0474471375,
-0.0293657128,
0.0155421989,
-0.0118132662,
-0.0138843767,
-0.0913584679,
-0.0022652154,
0.0022850838,
0.0026746097,
0.0393701978,
0.0721093491,
-0.0013005642,
-0.0313149281,
0.0183586255,
0.0209310744,
-0.0305380132,
0.0034147287,
-0.0562306233,
0.0186089333,
0.0899366736,
0.0502920523,
-0.057147637,
0.0111604445,
-0.0256883148,
0.0106919529,
0.0236816611,
0.007574168,
0.0105052972,
0.0305549577,
-0.0438340865,
-0.0295806583,
-0.0425024666,
0.0537508614,
0.0054344707,
-0.0164178237,
-0.0534329377,
0.0405620635,
-0.0137120467,
-0.0519194007,
0.0400159694,
-0.0513591096,
-0.0545926951,
0.0232385136,
0.0194351934,
0.0402868651,
0.039855171,
0.0136832511,
-0.0013103904,
0.022398429,
-0.0495821163,
-0.0551195666,
0.0192977004,
-0.0064124046,
-0.0323673449,
-0.015958067,
-0.0276673473,
-0.0031566815,
0.0633412972,
-0.0433273986,
-0.0657904148,
0.0300823729,
-0.0215443987,
0.0508291163,
-0.0197215527,
-0.0031168358,
0.0007554067,
0.0360436514,
-0.0353969075,
0.0270699561,
-0.0052832938,
0.0165855065,
-0.0133539513,
-0.0163413733,
0.0109397462,
0.015154154,
0.0130687458,
-0.0072940304,
-0.0182513222,
-0.0365158767,
0.0228291117,
-0.0276398119,
-0.0219749752,
-0.003691765,
-0.0300893225,
-0.012196349,
-0.0485714935,
-0.0126082478,
0.0167438593,
-0.0313380621,
0.0302791912,
-0.0187103227,
-0.0131827742,
0.0110737132,
0.012739229,
0.0051448089,
0.0583590679,
-0.0303337537,
-0.0227559227,
-0.0325944796,
-0.0090728207,
-0.0426065437,
0.0938306153,
0.0186371878,
0.003621114,
-0.0393116213,
0.0251146052,
0.021743644,
-0.0303139687,
-0.0346396305,
-0.0442691594,
0.0106778862,
0.0006719612,
-0.0525041148,
0.0712564513,
-0.0125568034,
0.0727533996,
0.01395474,
0.0258744638,
-0.056749288,
-0.0036691299,
-0.0443597436,
0.0149829052,
-0.0454111695,
-0.0682308674,
-0.0206564181,
0.0825327858,
-0.0248385221,
-0.036806155,
-0.0524060726,
0.0067905751,
0.020475274,
-0.0188714378,
-0.0226465948,
-0.0482779518,
0.0022994056,
0.0412322357,
-0.0419883691,
-0.0976380855,
0.0627088323,
-0.0345372781,
-0.0059837308,
0.0125658624,
-0.051913213,
-0.0587287173,
0.0922645107,
0.0168266818,
-0.0213610679,
0.0165030975,
-0.0138273593,
0.0012901651,
-0.0047741397,
0.0251583047,
0.0221610572,
-0.0040713423,
-0.0449720882,
0.0047702556,
0.0192048494,
-0.0191160869,
-0.0357107334,
-0.0664520562,
-0.0203495696,
0.010931313,
0.0203069951,
-0.0356645957,
-0.0402045511,
-0.0086364495,
0.0128153926,
0.0129656643,
-0.0243877266,
0.0056972075,
-0.0220782403,
-0.007081151,
0.0298614446,
0.006825774,
0.046959281,
-0.0454660952,
0.0196970422,
0.0060519003,
0.0065787015,
-0.0110592833,
-0.0285882,
0.0070835892,
-0.0123878382,
-0.0169253498,
-0.057044398,
-0.0208970923,
0.0218931213,
-0.0851125643,
0.0097646369,
0.1165749505,
0.0320388079,
-0.0322538726,
0.0117384559,
0.0177786294,
-0.0000216559,
0.0189339854,
-0.0108544882,
-0.0132606244,
-0.0465723723,
0.0142862545,
0.01573723,
-0.0064158989,
-0.0113769677,
-0.0039736093,
-0.0648271441,
0.0294714328,
-0.011608134,
-0.0003937724,
-0.0192724243,
-0.0671800822,
-0.0479551144,
-0.0400343463,
-0.0265847836,
-0.0185597371,
0.035489209,
0.0187363755,
0.0326651819,
-0.0418214612,
-0.0196053013,
0.0113590546,
0.0177139398,
0.0349026062,
0.048174832,
0.0320571437,
0.0022635544,
0.012415709,
0.0048212558,
-0.0117672002,
0.0362477303,
-0.0125586381,
0.104204528,
0.0031037354,
-0.015990695,
-0.0261049662,
0.0596111938,
-0.075220041,
-0.0092173042,
-0.046642486,
0.0736681297,
-0.0236028973,
-0.0189236607,
-0.0141750602,
-0.0166558661,
-0.0043644425,
0.0992461368,
0.019783562,
-0.0335875116,
-0.0667943582,
-0.0343489349,
-0.0132926786,
-0.0484918393,
-0.020755196,
-0.0316712223,
0.0588363893,
-0.0349821039,
-0.011345759,
-0.0404086709,
-0.0003059163,
0.0205968823,
-0.0055460716,
0.0275085606,
-0.0432120822,
-0.0429852568,
-0.0434219502,
0.0320617035,
0.0191047359,
0.0306607336,
-0.0173804071,
-0.0324366987,
0.036779128,
-0.0566156022,
-0.0282372981,
-0.0072355312,
-0.044176545,
-0.0490408503,
-0.0033788385,
0.0066455486,
0.0243568774,
0.0665350854,
-0.0065888679,
-0.0917775631,
0.0050319023,
0.0483404584,
-0.030214157,
-0.036341399,
0.0626857728,
-0.0075678127,
0.0163023509,
0.0518162251,
-0.0173068158,
0.0107997954,
0.0432197712,
-0.0084018959,
-0.0639230609,
0.0182191599,
0.0200768523,
-0.0199464578,
0.0601287857,
-0.0141449915,
-0.0250893068,
-0.0392342843,
0.0333858244,
-0.000145195,
-0.0233444106,
-0.0379786193,
0.0495444983,
0.028594872,
-0.0250102244,
-0.0173413716,
-0.0292547178,
-0.0192637686,
0.0111390427,
-0.018172415,
0.0544798039,
0.0256127883,
0.0155531671,
-0.0090014199,
0.0191210229,
0.0088599501,
0.0385921262,
0.0111169061,
0.0367084444,
0.0239360649,
0.0629698709,
0.0050820685,
0.0422356203,
-0.0388726108,
-0.0354214087,
-0.1069988236,
0.0005256068,
0.0039693518,
0.0185195673,
0.0388422348,
-0.036282286,
0.0453963801,
0.0096961204,
-0.0198844597,
0.0202187486,
0.0754632503,
0.0488410629,
-0.0127762584,
-0.0079041636,
0.0148449307,
-0.0501972586,
0.0164174736,
0.067534253,
0.0552937537,
0.025997296,
0.0062767877,
-0.0215899181,
-0.0020119844,
-0.0403848551,
0.0403160974,
0.0474347584,
-0.0052532088,
0.0284284521,
-0.0521786846,
-0.0625907779,
0.0077603059,
-0.0334083065,
0.0012325264,
-0.0261345692,
-0.0173831936,
0.0696361735,
-0.0099270483,
-0.0402177982,
-0.0383898541,
0.0241361707,
-0.0046124179,
0.0112177217,
-0.0287658926,
-6.196034397e-33,
0.0024504582,
-0.091544196,
-0.0167675614,
-0.0212813057,
0.0393845774,
0.0259015858,
-0.0181531422,
-0.0448002815,
-0.0020051023,
0.0579619147,
0.0101410588,
0.0494126417,
0.002672174,
0.0487802848,
0.0117996605,
-0.044049643,
0.060737174,
0.0299991146,
0.0072819507,
0.0380341299,
0.0604709424,
0.0554150827,
0.0527791642,
-0.071057722,
0.0740210786,
0.0102924043,
-0.0137384282,
0.0329019986,
-0.0632260218,
0.0460132807,
-0.0069011273,
0.0279790331,
0.0420802459,
-0.0616259724,
0.0230524167,
-0.004965805,
-0.0337709226,
0.0072265468,
0.0202228241,
0.0108588859,
-0.0323966779,
-0.0585426018,
0.0469719358,
-0.0012647544,
0.0251841936,
-0.0104666548,
0.0565445796,
-0.0330899581,
0.0096594309,
-0.0006422268,
-0.0424455106,
0.0372805819,
-0.0671544671,
-0.0079931663,
0.0024812878,
0.0374453329,
0.0111107947,
0.0408726297,
-0.0237996262,
-0.0222455207,
0.0314382911,
-0.0084778471,
0.0672305301,
0.013866202,
-0.0169319715,
0.0584614538,
0.0158970188,
0.0075206244,
-0.0896738768,
-0.0033646927,
-0.0189943928,
0.0535829589,
0.1105873436,
0.0608937107,
0.0315551162,
0.0024844797,
-0.0893507749,
0.0009719302,
-0.0169040989,
-0.01368012,
0.0512678437,
0.0047427728,
-0.0527637266,
-0.0200901646,
-0.0472291112,
-0.0447934344,
-0.0217611995,
0.011891406,
0.0088441484,
0.0078419475,
-0.0643369183,
-0.035674721,
0.0027188081,
-0.061785426,
0.0120221879,
0.0460437275,
-0.0009690659,
-0.0037078233,
0.0253227614,
-0.0211082157,
-0.0431028977,
-0.0040935115,
-0.0065218061,
-0.0029691844,
0.0477221087,
-0.0051962081,
0.0638583601,
-0.0046534892,
-0.0303123798,
-0.0024608651,
-0.0494417846,
-0.014615668,
-0.0303707682,
0.0243432075,
0.0214758478,
0.0242197849,
-0.0413182862,
0.0519138761,
0.029031584,
0.0435525961,
0.0115114674,
-0.0144774849,
-0.0327745378,
0.0019531874,
-0.0148776853,
-0.0373021625,
0.0286965836,
-0.0149460537,
0.0465705916,
-0.0604486279,
-0.0005245628,
-0.012430137,
2.411e-7,
0.0664989278,
0.0389175564,
0.0115341265,
-0.0134246442,
0.0467601679,
0.0611920357,
0.0112123135,
-0.024167005,
-0.0294147115,
0.0033949723,
0.0415847749,
0.0367999487,
0.0851729661,
-0.0148269022,
-0.0129442131,
-0.0137519166,
-0.0579134598,
-0.0440305322,
-0.0275160633,
0.0045873309,
0.0687048435,
0.0772939846,
0.0341623239,
-0.0285959486,
0.0227503553,
-0.0330721103,
0.0423250757,
-0.0590154268,
0.0276078805,
0.0031205115,
0.033545088,
-0.014200082,
-0.0067055556,
0.0127287526,
-0.0214263536,
0.0232890602,
-0.0516999662,
0.0546573661,
-0.0171751454,
-0.0423787124,
-0.0433203094,
-0.0235410854,
0.0290109385,
-0.0615062788,
0.0943033844,
0.0112631973,
-0.0383403264,
-0.0077657816,
-0.0260765087,
-0.0270680971,
0.0239580702,
0.0093704779,
0.016407907,
0.0227340106,
-0.0409681201,
-0.042533204,
0.0099932263,
-0.0941078365,
-0.0517499894,
-0.0039242697,
-0.0216596276,
0.0278211366,
-0.0478004441,
-0.0031819323,
0.076581642,
-0.0288930964,
0.0027469874,
2.47499555e-34,
0.0382532924,
0.028797565,
-0.0112331221,
-0.0010076334,
0.0412304364,
0.0249922406,
-0.0366289653,
0.0039680563,
0.0486530177,
-0.0589046627,
0.0067180186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13339v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13339v4 | Enhancing Zero-Shot Chain-of-Thought Reasoning in Large Language Models through Logic | 2023-09-23T11:21:12 | 2024-03-26T01:53:30 | Xufeng Zhao, Mengdi Li, Wenhao Lu, Cornelius Weber, Jae Hee Lee, Kun Chu, Stefan Wermter | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SC | Recent advancements in large language models have showcased their remarkable
generalizability across various domains. However, their reasoning abilities
still have significant room for improvement, especially when confronted with
scenarios requiring multi-step reasoning. Although large language models
possess extensive knowledge, their reasoning often fails to effectively utilize
this knowledge to establish a coherent thinking paradigm. These models
sometimes show hallucinations as their reasoning procedures are unconstrained
by logical principles. Aiming at improving the zero-shot chain-of-thought
reasoning ability of large language models, we propose LoT (Logical Thoughts),
a self-improvement prompting framework that leverages principles rooted in
symbolic logic, particularly Reductio ad Absurdum, to systematically verify and
rectify the reasoning processes step by step. Experimental evaluations
conducted on language tasks in diverse domains, including arithmetic,
commonsense, symbolic, causal inference, and social problems, demonstrate the
efficacy of enhanced reasoning by logic. The implementation code for LoT can be
accessed at: https://github.com/xf-zhao/LoT. | [
0.0291436538,
0.0538590141,
-0.0259041376,
0.03219283,
-0.0678420141,
0.009101619,
-0.0019019091,
0.0053773304,
0.0444713719,
-0.0477720648,
0.0113405194,
0.023723511,
-0.008229075,
0.0090107005,
0.0227674376,
-0.0469533764,
0.0643407628,
-0.0700385645,
0.0398334675,
-0.0329726413,
-0.017995121,
0.0018281753,
-0.0386196002,
0.0088824863,
0.0203985069,
-0.0451568626,
-0.0340067483,
-0.0071936366,
-0.0008489727,
-0.0413714461,
-0.0743150786,
0.065398626,
-0.0173460506,
0.0503877401,
0.0000023964,
-0.0717196241,
0.0196585525,
-0.0115853539,
-0.0333006755,
-0.011758565,
0.0115378313,
0.0250597633,
-0.0217380505,
0.0201002173,
-0.0142941829,
0.0212874264,
0.0105424253,
0.0865026191,
0.0601985045,
0.0537116565,
0.0061526541,
-0.0323545821,
0.0259476658,
0.0165122375,
0.0600224771,
0.0098859761,
0.0067781406,
0.0426642634,
0.0632399395,
-0.0060494272,
-0.0070635593,
0.0240187012,
0.0459640771,
-0.0250633787,
-0.0054109069,
0.0363381431,
-0.0440566316,
-0.0362810828,
0.0137450332,
0.0281486195,
0.021692967,
-0.0231543612,
-0.0335262753,
0.0225340556,
0.0239988007,
-0.0188670829,
-0.0352412648,
0.0348061174,
0.0081404205,
-0.009067039,
0.0512188636,
-0.0103737181,
0.0084051723,
0.0196515638,
-0.0664501935,
0.0670444667,
0.0034853339,
-0.0494765453,
0.0217648782,
-0.0046268413,
-0.0050698686,
-0.0942881927,
-0.0241431035,
0.0486707501,
-0.0363593586,
0.0014033102,
0.0097757205,
0.0172026064,
0.0171849206,
-0.0445502959,
0.0202148892,
0.0605218634,
-0.0100693619,
0.0474228263,
-0.0378786027,
0.0153004462,
-0.0026414299,
0.0598378368,
-0.0108190449,
0.0219370313,
-0.0578488521,
-0.0091577722,
-0.0378828868,
0.0674885809,
0.0240899827,
0.0101659149,
-0.02022692,
0.0172084738,
-0.026258884,
0.0251911711,
-0.0057754498,
-0.0195325501,
0.0422035605,
-0.0639836267,
-0.0652129576,
0.0421972461,
-0.0516594984,
-0.0226209797,
0.0339732654,
-0.0357995592,
-0.0134820575,
-0.0483786725,
-0.0232569259,
0.0041321637,
0.0256284922,
0.0346760489,
-0.0044892747,
-0.0168409627,
-0.0419403762,
-0.0252793226,
0.0018896612,
-0.0634124428,
-0.0192217138,
-0.0724255443,
-0.0391079411,
0.0136718787,
0.0026260782,
0.0068723238,
0.0209698435,
0.0108913528,
-0.0354945101,
0.0746441111,
-0.0496758707,
0.0057087489,
-0.0046134409,
0.0191312488,
-0.0225313045,
0.0442452282,
0.0247540046,
-0.0062296628,
-0.006409389,
-0.0029155952,
0.0250648763,
0.004817321,
-0.0108048134,
-0.026206078,
-0.0395101719,
0.0075470759,
-0.0318952724,
0.0329221077,
-0.0352202393,
0.0351916961,
-0.0279835127,
0.0542291738,
0.039633736,
0.0303633958,
0.012254308,
0.0140076941,
0.0059475536,
-0.0240125768,
0.0049123554,
-0.0052844905,
-0.0686169341,
0.0692669079,
-0.0252338536,
-0.0007729699,
0.0078189066,
0.0251661092,
-0.0181616079,
-0.0462201722,
-0.0141501948,
0.0307837315,
-0.0007270758,
0.032715328,
0.0514785685,
0.0190786924,
0.01210564,
0.0002313845,
0.0346886367,
-0.0515799969,
-0.0174454581,
-0.0770543665,
0.0665005445,
0.0746266991,
0.0631381422,
-0.0222765449,
-0.026771266,
-0.0386144817,
0.0116219772,
0.0352055877,
-0.0086426465,
0.0022133305,
-0.0532116331,
-0.0243359264,
0.0056563686,
0.0110944733,
0.0135310451,
-0.0169486143,
-0.0265765581,
0.0107769147,
-0.012827266,
0.0042251605,
0.0195247009,
0.0117142517,
0.0081300363,
0.0107259825,
-0.0191250555,
0.0169627052,
0.0103321504,
0.020260226,
-0.0124355303,
0.0210905503,
0.0092676738,
-0.0314732715,
-0.0615657456,
0.0412773155,
-0.0437629409,
-0.0137167322,
0.0605795309,
0.0020502233,
-0.0292456336,
-0.0122412564,
-0.0098866494,
-0.0179981031,
0.0522268824,
-0.0226596594,
0.0084815565,
-0.0249299463,
0.0323491655,
-0.0257427748,
-0.0526762307,
-0.0101877032,
0.0960761085,
0.0117606809,
0.0010647295,
0.0424264185,
-0.0060705389,
0.0097226398,
-0.0329453349,
0.011054392,
0.0236225501,
-0.0115895178,
-0.010267172,
0.0093391174,
0.0218690578,
-0.0632381588,
-0.0291753504,
-0.071356371,
-0.0230245665,
-0.0101781655,
-0.0105672292,
-0.004642494,
-0.0005238555,
-0.0091508217,
-0.004587533,
0.0040214909,
0.0361944176,
0.0330720395,
0.026874084,
0.0197162852,
-0.0360205695,
-0.0365563706,
0.0176317319,
0.0013585299,
-0.0500996411,
0.0221516583,
0.0122213047,
0.0168533809,
-0.0368358046,
0.0305515956,
-0.0831224993,
0.007563591,
0.00605124,
-0.0180955213,
0.0471189357,
-0.0309890136,
0.052518703,
0.0779317692,
0.0042438204,
-0.0186975207,
0.0746627301,
-0.0423391946,
-0.0389035083,
0.02046372,
0.0082535185,
0.0224966072,
-0.0029991632,
-0.0011009279,
-0.0491783135,
0.0419108123,
-0.02474479,
-0.0035392758,
-0.0729310885,
0.0497715585,
-0.0380382687,
-0.0228006933,
-0.0324144289,
-0.0137224933,
0.0071328152,
0.0515417494,
-0.025503546,
-0.0273967944,
0.0763140917,
0.0112288333,
-0.009992226,
-0.0398570448,
0.0156803001,
-0.0122687779,
0.094262518,
-0.0050361073,
-0.001200562,
0.0277583171,
0.0060979389,
-0.0271545127,
-0.0158458967,
-0.0005497703,
-0.0244417861,
0.0378880836,
-0.045933377,
0.0154222157,
-0.003480938,
-0.0570735633,
-0.0697410405,
0.0135147385,
-0.068695426,
-0.0222548768,
-0.0757254958,
0.0063581578,
-0.0081232423,
-0.0303628203,
0.0648303404,
0.0258137323,
-0.0002229363,
-0.0516956076,
-0.0115512842,
-0.0342201628,
0.0251082536,
-0.0050012898,
0.0618399195,
0.0044922298,
0.0681545213,
0.0425720103,
0.0395015292,
0.0008181421,
-0.0397145897,
0.004777289,
-0.0102265365,
-0.0105190985,
-0.0071397289,
0.0278553106,
0.0404413752,
-0.0518841259,
-0.0253771134,
0.1275888085,
0.0420303605,
-0.0171453003,
0.024505157,
-0.1072080657,
0.0301517155,
0.0411525108,
0.0341410376,
-0.1162385419,
-0.056625627,
0.0480503291,
-0.0350673571,
-0.0219135918,
-0.0605576038,
0.0173862632,
-0.1202303991,
0.0458186679,
0.0057948064,
-0.0183614604,
0.0189952273,
-0.0129794106,
-0.0000120429,
0.0238558892,
-0.0588753782,
0.0253487322,
-0.0002297404,
0.0114014316,
-0.0158066321,
0.0217776746,
-0.0133150881,
0.0667267293,
-0.0217204168,
0.0558945648,
0.0291547514,
0.0070226705,
0.0216041617,
-0.0816690326,
0.0209436063,
-0.0031500889,
0.0099482359,
-0.0292887148,
-0.0072752815,
0.0151153356,
0.0122100282,
-0.0388317108,
0.0418714248,
-0.032323759,
-0.0571195409,
0.0400041081,
0.1179575473,
-0.0226474609,
-0.0464545116,
-0.0380494446,
0.0320085064,
-0.0472293422,
0.0460880063,
0.0080667753,
-0.0171927623,
-0.0167015232,
-0.0425757542,
-0.0451554395,
0.0011206256,
-0.0482157767,
0.0029131477,
0.0510475673,
0.011755852,
-0.0498238914,
-0.0319290683,
0.0375597589,
0.0260094963,
-0.0016779054,
-0.0027053757,
0.0112557942,
0.0355771184,
-0.0121612372,
0.0123985466,
-0.0457941927,
0.0252340473,
-0.0306191463,
0.0452832207,
0.0007594789,
-0.0264772847,
0.004163119,
0.0271646883,
-0.0308894627,
-0.0406110249,
0.0055321897,
0.0590509474,
0.0309122968,
0.0065240934,
-0.0351765677,
-0.043582961,
0.0228542648,
0.0258855894,
-0.007990405,
0.0243566073,
0.0233362652,
0.0005816829,
0.0452504233,
0.0392428301,
-0.0000210166,
0.0437506102,
0.0027956744,
0.0411073789,
-0.0155591574,
-0.0100133643,
0.0294849314,
0.0488952994,
0.00876424,
0.0122717544,
-0.0059973234,
-0.0257946439,
0.0267184917,
-0.0421970412,
-0.0362740196,
-0.015044325,
0.0325297043,
-0.0039819903,
-0.0283439681,
0.0156144733,
-0.0548752435,
-0.0338570699,
0.0160084944,
0.0316230692,
-0.0240814202,
0.026842963,
0.0342947058,
0.0449755751,
-0.0229921136,
-0.0059934496,
-0.0290736854,
-0.0069481456,
0.0466344319,
-0.0397693478,
0.1228046864,
0.0335863009,
-0.0312368833,
-0.0283569992,
0.0066572232,
-0.0782370716,
-0.0732148737,
0.077105701,
0.0192118883,
0.0471981876,
0.0562115125,
0.0296272449,
-0.0455212854,
-0.0003289432,
0.0113212382,
0.0355107933,
0.0358801931,
-0.0564148985,
-0.0111020142,
0.025082225,
-0.0033131486,
-0.0441704877,
-0.0026267881,
-0.0975868553,
0.0079603875,
0.0268833172,
0.0212185942,
-0.0290760398,
-0.0438015312,
-0.0770634115,
0.0169846322,
0.0026258291,
0.0361633226,
-0.1021706983,
-0.0528346747,
-0.0347309411,
0.0235632565,
0.0179559588,
-0.031598594,
0.0126027064,
0.0550723262,
0.0048157927,
-0.0477738939,
-0.0132430904,
0.0245489702,
-0.0315626673,
-0.0209781304,
-0.0222454928,
-6.396040352e-33,
-0.0068256031,
-0.0083183581,
0.0553233847,
-0.0093485108,
-0.0159611814,
-0.0403653979,
-0.0375070721,
0.0371555425,
-0.0080617219,
0.0537413619,
-0.031811323,
0.0210724361,
-0.0045359572,
-0.0182025488,
0.0533292927,
0.0195088349,
0.032327015,
-0.0031916106,
-0.0516845211,
0.0071137375,
0.0344513468,
-0.020598948,
0.0227519497,
-0.0216685366,
0.0102391979,
0.0192039702,
0.0000248592,
0.041099824,
-0.060183797,
0.0105571803,
0.0032781127,
0.0057643964,
0.0328623317,
-0.0162349083,
0.0057841488,
0.016849732,
-0.0324705616,
-0.0365914814,
0.0315923095,
-0.0273917969,
-0.0549547374,
-0.0364366919,
-0.0102697052,
0.0096300077,
-0.0201061014,
-0.0231221206,
0.0112597775,
-0.0329954363,
0.0063248798,
0.0430837348,
-0.06469623,
-0.002309911,
-0.0092491321,
-0.0323613733,
-0.0281276628,
0.0389739834,
-0.0284116603,
-0.0238705948,
-0.0659832582,
0.0316816755,
0.018325327,
-0.0016342942,
0.0662440509,
-0.0392574221,
-0.0119108893,
0.0454275422,
0.0196043383,
0.0146716246,
-0.048561886,
0.0206378642,
0.0119820405,
0.0364077389,
0.0912998766,
0.0019187139,
0.0492926501,
0.0261343811,
-0.0713049322,
-0.0295477137,
-0.0023687703,
0.0500888824,
0.0480631776,
-0.0018816298,
-0.0256251656,
0.0147039536,
-0.036237929,
0.0087606739,
-0.0550923757,
-0.0315042436,
0.0236542746,
0.0055138441,
-0.0174441356,
-0.0329312421,
0.010924967,
-0.0057829488,
-0.0284528788,
0.0071845255,
-0.0270153396,
0.0340233371,
-0.0088618286,
0.0196392499,
-0.0358018503,
0.0136570334,
0.0027512729,
0.0483636968,
0.0208182447,
0.0385612696,
0.0416324958,
-0.0021088475,
-0.0397875495,
-0.006263061,
-0.049779091,
0.032631848,
-0.014174995,
-0.0087934472,
0.0147404382,
0.0446089804,
0.0054062065,
0.0404926278,
0.0163220521,
-0.0242430307,
-0.0308523513,
0.0811500326,
0.0208522994,
-0.0081492057,
0.0071126572,
-0.026364686,
-0.0723909587,
0.0208345428,
0.035099864,
-0.0570711382,
-0.0145427547,
0.0086776996,
3.103e-7,
-0.0340418443,
0.0637927651,
0.0009486798,
0.0597410277,
0.0280489922,
0.0715176687,
-0.012338765,
-0.02199772,
0.0497314259,
-0.0268711727,
-0.0334310904,
0.0656596571,
0.0179518089,
0.0406366363,
-0.0463522784,
-0.0298746135,
-0.0163745284,
-0.0407047644,
-0.0667504445,
0.0006998899,
0.0749005079,
0.0514600538,
0.0588168092,
-0.028253125,
0.0167330652,
-0.0262238644,
0.0460077859,
0.0004331229,
0.0035389864,
-0.0156031027,
0.0128491465,
-0.0096480213,
0.0234875586,
0.0229444224,
0.0267204046,
-0.0221107211,
-0.0610248595,
0.0054569319,
-0.0323709361,
0.0401430801,
-0.0154753169,
-0.0138303014,
0.0041108611,
-0.0569358021,
0.0860504881,
-0.068762444,
-0.0257668439,
0.0123167234,
-0.0027719084,
-0.0295098294,
0.0178576,
-0.003858485,
-0.0377468579,
0.0021434301,
0.0144529399,
0.0093209958,
-0.0019008233,
-0.0473594144,
-0.0170747321,
-0.0342496857,
0.0045862873,
-0.0313475803,
-0.0286353771,
0.0087520182,
0.0146558145,
-0.0769357309,
-0.0077952333,
2.885665292e-34,
0.0227785781,
0.0054907999,
0.0576744452,
0.0132885259,
0.0359951071,
0.0126488321,
-0.0226451121,
0.0020439755,
0.0190704614,
-0.0642434955,
-0.0190991797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14362v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14362v1 | Diversifying Question Generation over Knowledge Base via External Natural Questions | 2023-09-23T10:37:57 | 2023-09-23T10:37:57 | Shasha Guo, Jing Zhang, Xirui Ke, Cuiping Li, Hong Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Previous methods on knowledge base question generation (KBQG) primarily focus
on enhancing the quality of a single generated question. Recognizing the
remarkable paraphrasing ability of humans, we contend that diverse texts should
convey the same semantics through varied expressions. The above insights make
diversifying question generation an intriguing task, where the first challenge
is evaluation metrics for diversity. Current metrics inadequately assess the
above diversity since they calculate the ratio of unique n-grams in the
generated question itself, which leans more towards measuring duplication
rather than true diversity. Accordingly, we devise a new diversity evaluation
metric, which measures the diversity among top-k generated questions for each
instance while ensuring their relevance to the ground truth. Clearly, the
second challenge is how to enhance diversifying question generation. To address
this challenge, we introduce a dual model framework interwoven by two selection
strategies to generate diverse questions leveraging external natural questions.
The main idea of our dual framework is to extract more diverse expressions and
integrate them into the generation model to enhance diversifying question
generation. Extensive experiments on widely used benchmarks for KBQG
demonstrate that our proposed approach generates highly diverse questions and
improves the performance of question answering tasks. | [
0.0458332524,
-0.011919627,
-0.0086314054,
0.0060390681,
-0.0453402288,
0.0055316854,
0.0045155422,
0.0240622386,
0.0096102664,
-0.0223498121,
0.0267408472,
-0.039933838,
-0.0298671089,
0.0210798308,
0.044482369,
-0.0533300154,
0.0161532145,
-0.0050209123,
-0.0118474411,
-0.0094378889,
-0.0017490508,
0.0040970123,
-0.0041397586,
0.0313470215,
0.0121504785,
-0.0051503005,
-0.0457811952,
0.0250086971,
0.0414186455,
-0.018448066,
-0.0003311028,
0.0311549623,
-0.008844004,
0.0102222543,
0.0000017633,
-0.0674118921,
-0.0384712368,
0.0180750303,
-0.0357057899,
-0.0226970389,
-0.0013968832,
0.0616366901,
0.0639772341,
0.0238006879,
-0.0461569428,
0.0034409859,
-0.0059238509,
0.0306326281,
0.0563918948,
0.034226913,
0.0143906968,
-0.0195586365,
-0.0086123617,
-0.000721312,
0.0505313426,
-0.0074272999,
-0.0127805714,
0.0278649814,
0.0270577352,
0.0285273101,
0.0036776876,
-0.0007601036,
0.0194329545,
0.0137330675,
0.0448316336,
0.0244014058,
-0.0237287916,
0.0084952097,
0.00505174,
0.110535115,
-0.0026612144,
0.0195168499,
0.0423726588,
-0.0089498246,
0.0405722894,
0.0412586853,
-0.0491621196,
0.0449919887,
-0.053898491,
-0.054408174,
-0.0138258347,
0.057588134,
-0.0043426328,
0.0338189267,
-0.0109757353,
0.0075449715,
0.0630322844,
-0.0011096924,
-0.0183793902,
0.003697745,
-0.0143730966,
-0.0461390316,
0.0068183788,
0.0123816812,
-0.0385523364,
0.0128734242,
-0.0282136817,
-0.0466391444,
0.0396140665,
-0.0005910698,
0.0144178746,
0.0147989858,
0.0015260723,
0.0378502682,
0.0099704489,
0.0402009971,
-0.0213300269,
-0.0183818936,
-0.0566026829,
-0.002184981,
-0.063388139,
-0.0190820079,
-0.0285696033,
0.0578652807,
-0.023549689,
-0.0245072022,
-0.012498538,
0.0461223796,
0.0354298502,
-0.0514065474,
0.0209091678,
0.039931085,
-0.0368317254,
-0.0233914386,
-0.0456094146,
-0.0092946952,
-0.0971449018,
-0.000887537,
0.0717277005,
-0.0722360462,
0.0002242867,
0.0260230545,
0.0466034189,
-0.0263965074,
-0.0126636466,
0.0047262041,
-0.0113293091,
0.0047468971,
-0.0246892404,
-0.0765591562,
-0.0150849484,
-0.0089496821,
0.0191559866,
-0.0798476487,
0.0493324921,
0.0030809925,
-0.0329711661,
-0.0064399089,
0.0037244586,
0.0338789932,
0.0054192152,
-0.0183856618,
-0.0099193873,
0.0077997721,
0.0612703077,
0.0098769106,
-0.0332872719,
0.048177544,
0.0073610544,
-0.0171602573,
0.0646321625,
0.0363114402,
-0.0387006626,
-0.0165894218,
0.0052951644,
0.0028684079,
0.0182829518,
0.0428627655,
-0.0029139244,
0.0466232374,
-0.0171220545,
0.0699506775,
-0.058997307,
0.0101328054,
0.0367991701,
0.0296372976,
-0.0022736914,
0.0204827562,
0.0767646059,
0.0498804636,
0.0031834322,
0.0414388999,
0.0292514879,
0.0362698399,
-0.0081793331,
0.0243008509,
0.0455474854,
0.0685925856,
-0.0217402298,
-0.023636058,
0.0023412493,
0.0389839895,
-0.0109072421,
0.0161780044,
-0.0165687855,
0.0117686847,
-0.0190078635,
0.0911128297,
-0.0221423097,
-0.0645633712,
0.0151092643,
-0.0060454803,
0.0512866639,
0.0138081713,
0.0347787775,
-0.0110366205,
-0.0706157535,
-0.0059802965,
-0.0079313079,
0.0422100574,
0.0450732373,
-0.0099059856,
0.0089257555,
-0.0751733482,
-0.027397722,
-0.0397435762,
-0.0057722176,
0.0275251325,
0.015488727,
0.0467009768,
0.0477006175,
-0.0806045309,
-0.0074220886,
0.0409241393,
-0.0332931839,
0.0127657801,
0.0368557833,
-0.00022238,
-0.0277798548,
0.0484868623,
-0.0014299953,
0.0460615531,
0.0129255531,
-0.0528815687,
-0.0445714071,
0.0228060987,
-0.0530235171,
-0.0605677329,
0.0211655125,
-0.0971894935,
0.016269939,
-0.0083637442,
-0.0136758769,
-0.0520402752,
0.0077746389,
-0.0374540612,
-0.0165976062,
-0.0363581143,
-0.0200894494,
0.0064513315,
0.0000448564,
-0.0556938276,
0.1134551838,
0.0307502914,
0.0161094815,
0.0183103047,
-0.0104847783,
0.0452172235,
-0.0584496781,
-0.0129267946,
-0.0174452253,
-0.0314536653,
0.0149448495,
0.0388725437,
0.0276781972,
-0.0964775085,
-0.0361481383,
-0.0714790449,
0.0375991724,
-0.0422958098,
0.0029486935,
0.0500801355,
0.0341487639,
-0.0049633863,
0.0020350728,
-0.0811766461,
-0.0168667361,
-0.0006187957,
0.0104317591,
0.0385578908,
0.0352087729,
0.0411473215,
0.0296463091,
-0.0006260941,
0.0233200938,
0.0686222017,
0.0108052976,
0.067509003,
-0.0399214178,
-0.0054711332,
-0.069003053,
-0.0589434505,
0.019193355,
0.024019124,
0.0183479432,
-0.0105480514,
0.0586302318,
0.0067584598,
0.0359467529,
-0.0517824851,
0.0068172296,
0.0107454294,
-0.037158113,
0.0061118933,
-0.0046788207,
0.0582000017,
0.0343973488,
-0.0452221595,
0.0381937884,
-0.0023716588,
0.0209432878,
-0.0302614812,
-0.0577548258,
0.0597494207,
-0.029016275,
-0.0368131511,
-0.076026082,
-0.0158088282,
-0.0114529422,
0.0362345465,
-0.0224290788,
0.0050268658,
0.0566355363,
0.0210074782,
0.0210418683,
-0.0582570247,
0.0355255567,
-0.0269239247,
0.0645217299,
-0.0391533971,
0.0383392721,
0.0636655539,
-0.0011190303,
-0.0776665732,
0.0334436186,
0.0435001813,
-0.0445781611,
0.0532349758,
-0.0737382695,
-0.0132173691,
0.0207495335,
-0.0206326414,
-0.0501587316,
-0.017810883,
0.0243104286,
-0.0155211864,
0.0439390801,
0.0290761124,
0.008120236,
-0.0055967718,
0.0305679161,
0.0143226283,
-0.038824372,
0.0003430548,
0.0016686267,
0.0940614119,
0.0762245432,
0.0478512757,
0.0632683188,
-0.014877703,
0.0209780056,
0.0212281067,
0.0095226886,
-0.0195190087,
0.0492785722,
0.0022232807,
-0.0361593701,
-0.0444061458,
-0.0292245541,
0.0161707439,
0.0544354394,
-0.0189398006,
-0.0569117926,
0.0606156178,
0.0511472076,
0.0071957917,
-0.0023622797,
-0.0546557307,
0.0769614503,
0.0039002388,
0.0433549993,
-0.0215770453,
-0.0033316407,
-0.0333526917,
0.0045064841,
-0.028381994,
-0.0656349808,
-0.0088949436,
-0.1108609214,
-0.0075730886,
-0.0167885106,
-0.0767324045,
-0.001789476,
0.028908927,
-0.0190689228,
0.0282292888,
-0.0197024439,
0.0436361693,
-0.0000224811,
0.0386702456,
0.0352169238,
-0.0260793287,
-0.0769522116,
-0.0158150066,
-0.0454239771,
-0.0490823947,
0.0284198355,
-0.0003119724,
0.012793446,
-0.0118004093,
-0.0458074473,
-0.0462227762,
0.0083218357,
0.0268377177,
0.0203460176,
0.0402622707,
-0.0113833053,
-0.0482705384,
0.0206878837,
-0.0128023103,
0.0249390267,
0.0238198675,
0.0314270593,
0.0165208764,
-0.0101145227,
-0.0103096161,
0.0036957446,
0.0114047639,
0.0790098906,
0.0342538916,
-0.0158598814,
0.006717924,
-0.0097949291,
0.0184302721,
-0.1279503107,
-0.009784041,
0.0528159551,
-0.0099570574,
0.0124884741,
-0.1259508133,
-0.0272547994,
0.0023161713,
0.0468681492,
-0.012739989,
0.0095871044,
0.0086147226,
0.0112161031,
-0.0053371303,
0.018767627,
0.0043766317,
-0.0238233339,
-0.0037411686,
-0.011525441,
-0.0146244122,
-0.0481967106,
-0.0374962762,
0.0190909747,
-0.0934744179,
-0.0368266664,
-0.0045236456,
0.0155520756,
0.0133742746,
-0.0256175213,
-0.0046752449,
-0.0183227398,
0.0365846492,
0.0246809907,
0.002674198,
0.0149870161,
-0.0326903239,
-0.0341623202,
-0.0151777295,
0.0441169739,
-0.0914865881,
-0.0417807065,
-0.0070840959,
0.0706528425,
0.021199055,
-0.0249427017,
0.0372729115,
0.0316291936,
-0.0676347613,
-0.0317531228,
0.0054281033,
-0.0102095334,
-0.0178600866,
-0.0102750072,
-0.027403364,
-0.0523600243,
0.025596289,
-0.0103469612,
-0.0185976252,
0.0075907158,
0.0394599922,
-0.0075877672,
0.04666676,
-0.0320064649,
-0.062167082,
0.0040677804,
0.0081161857,
0.0086701354,
-0.0258431472,
-0.051085297,
-0.0120419171,
-0.0366634876,
0.0301553663,
-0.011289034,
0.0452561602,
0.0259175003,
-0.0120970514,
-0.0149986986,
0.0207610447,
-0.0823129937,
-0.0578661636,
0.0036987432,
0.013607461,
0.0076795239,
0.016483549,
0.0207985621,
0.0116528124,
-0.0307377595,
-0.0045916098,
0.0284579732,
0.0289737433,
-0.0217179041,
0.014265365,
0.0215520877,
0.0053284927,
-0.0312913917,
0.0816007406,
-0.0212070197,
0.0121131726,
-0.0093590813,
0.0041482039,
-0.0600528307,
-0.0137421358,
-0.0067076841,
0.0387569554,
0.0030335868,
0.025209656,
-0.0912218392,
-0.0209062863,
0.059865322,
0.014881134,
0.0395306461,
0.0131567931,
0.0880363062,
0.0647153929,
-0.0193556789,
-0.0141992709,
-0.0211874433,
0.0438481867,
-0.0826464295,
0.0019190593,
-0.010284448,
-6.091304829e-33,
-0.0129227052,
-0.0280957315,
-0.0043813759,
-0.1151087061,
-0.051619146,
0.0015840908,
-0.0299301241,
0.0086516868,
-0.0253422726,
0.01698111,
0.0029280258,
-0.0100537427,
-0.0008566919,
0.0218848772,
0.014791524,
-0.0274963956,
0.0056374725,
0.0010930958,
-0.0382081755,
0.0396048538,
0.0249709934,
0.0125295445,
-0.0152378622,
0.0315175951,
0.0086634997,
-0.0377644487,
0.0304268952,
-0.0078097908,
0.0217434727,
0.0570790321,
0.0003844848,
0.0182033684,
0.0347299501,
-0.0565764047,
-0.0070287939,
-0.0283789244,
0.0045554466,
-0.069092989,
0.0012092924,
-0.0436591394,
-0.0645290166,
-0.0500660092,
0.0128229661,
-0.0081616072,
0.0437099673,
-0.0233045984,
0.0334417336,
-0.0064871032,
-0.0279413443,
-0.0476449393,
-0.0048754113,
0.026999224,
-0.0064171618,
0.0051325872,
-0.0972742811,
0.0643190444,
-0.0011753851,
0.0216511581,
0.0192032047,
0.0372449271,
0.0086835027,
0.0152368518,
0.0151461512,
0.0194421709,
-0.00443403,
0.0288247187,
-0.0428479835,
-0.0128971152,
-0.0181340631,
-0.0135268942,
-0.044161424,
0.0338133536,
0.0469864868,
0.1121133193,
0.0345507041,
0.0536672249,
-0.0673777312,
0.0554387309,
0.0155967381,
-0.0435547046,
0.0008704747,
-0.042282857,
-0.0149864685,
0.0105388574,
-0.0275239442,
0.0399163812,
-0.0231637191,
-0.0242306739,
0.0559856184,
-0.0073975581,
-0.0681259483,
-0.0194918271,
0.0383189619,
0.0051846867,
0.0439633913,
0.0156158423,
-0.0202980749,
-0.0025951725,
0.0035229295,
0.0239560269,
-0.0234103892,
0.0111093689,
0.0372420885,
0.0162474271,
0.0121244611,
0.0286851451,
0.0013260463,
-0.009240645,
-0.0277730729,
0.0148786809,
-0.0241559632,
0.0192090757,
-0.0200843457,
-0.0098953675,
0.0012262283,
0.0353409797,
-0.0114973672,
0.0306378547,
0.0305731278,
-0.0118629094,
-0.0150454445,
-0.0242386274,
0.0214587152,
0.0260075685,
-0.0133257816,
0.0236606319,
-0.0103881508,
-0.0281600878,
0.0030420348,
-0.0079588043,
-0.0289101619,
-0.0049538063,
2.528e-7,
0.0144407395,
-0.0082740784,
0.0222714376,
0.0348422825,
-0.0107678249,
0.0144139752,
0.0266646463,
0.0448198244,
-0.0329809673,
-0.0424547046,
-0.0003580504,
0.024714198,
0.0126628503,
0.0099562556,
-0.0913745686,
-0.0145233292,
-0.0607858859,
-0.0023087177,
-0.0279747155,
-0.0316981934,
0.0723835081,
0.0412138663,
-0.0247592144,
0.0023225353,
-0.0045014815,
-0.0457632989,
0.0594903342,
0.0133634126,
-0.0085628005,
0.0331694186,
0.0493637547,
-0.0056968099,
-0.006436463,
0.0333797932,
-0.0091514075,
0.0126117943,
0.0611129478,
0.0015050364,
0.0189508647,
-0.0165198743,
-0.0014304459,
-0.022512747,
0.0094619347,
-0.0885543898,
0.0527363978,
-0.0118727265,
0.0082421787,
-0.0034638138,
-0.0357063673,
0.0082975328,
0.0133815594,
-0.0374646783,
-0.0192746185,
0.0145229986,
-0.0037108895,
0.0123770628,
0.0242040418,
-0.03117433,
-0.0324029252,
-0.0277056526,
-0.034737844,
-0.0517361611,
-0.0417619273,
-0.008677383,
-0.0087985117,
-0.0140206302,
0.0139575312,
1.975999346e-34,
0.0115680536,
0.0263861567,
0.0054592178,
-0.0054663792,
0.0331740975,
-0.0287849139,
-0.0520932004,
-0.022165928,
0.0156452507,
-0.0727359205,
-0.01730185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13322v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13322v2 | From Text to Source: Results in Detecting Large Language Model-Generated Content | 2023-09-23T09:51:37 | 2024-03-27T10:50:24 | Wissam Antoun, Benoît Sagot, Djamé Seddah | cs.CL | cs.CL | The widespread use of Large Language Models (LLMs), celebrated for their
ability to generate human-like text, has raised concerns about misinformation
and ethical implications. Addressing these concerns necessitates the
development of robust methods to detect and attribute text generated by LLMs.
This paper investigates "Cross-Model Detection," by evaluating whether a
classifier trained to distinguish between source LLM-generated and
human-written text can also detect text from a target LLM without further
training. The study comprehensively explores various LLM sizes and families,
and assesses the impact of conversational fine-tuning techniques, quantization,
and watermarking on classifier generalization. The research also explores Model
Attribution, encompassing source model identification, model family, and model
size classification, in addition to quantization and watermarking detection.
Our results reveal several key findings: a clear inverse relationship between
classifier effectiveness and model size, with larger LLMs being more
challenging to detect, especially when the classifier is trained on data from
smaller models. Training on data from similarly sized LLMs can improve
detection performance from larger models but may lead to decreased performance
when dealing with smaller models. Additionally, model attribution experiments
show promising results in identifying source models and model families,
highlighting detectable signatures in LLM-generated text, with particularly
remarkable outcomes in watermarking detection, while no detectable signatures
of quantization were observed. Overall, our study contributes valuable insights
into the interplay of model size, family, and training data in LLM detection
and attribution. | [
0.0469298176,
0.0592565313,
-0.0370906554,
0.0570530482,
-0.0343785621,
0.0302923042,
0.0327010304,
0.0594583042,
-0.0095638074,
-0.0748427212,
-0.0164167341,
-0.0285209939,
-0.0109666921,
0.0268204417,
0.0548068881,
-0.0011079782,
0.032876756,
-0.0017321312,
0.0381571539,
-0.0004253364,
0.0159728862,
0.0123158926,
0.0797646642,
0.0232772846,
-0.0071620434,
-0.0024247519,
0.0264838059,
0.0152638042,
0.0081730029,
0.0039149579,
0.0141997254,
0.0615229309,
0.0195446853,
0.124453038,
0.0000017537,
-0.038544599,
-0.0230436511,
0.0018428148,
-0.0434687957,
0.0306559019,
0.0615686178,
-0.0277138054,
-0.0290298369,
0.0159930643,
-0.0214330573,
0.0323109217,
0.0438839905,
0.0724890754,
0.0327013694,
0.0763790682,
-0.0217320472,
-0.0083294995,
0.0674327388,
0.0092580281,
0.0044031609,
-0.0035393105,
0.0533647202,
0.0419203714,
-0.0284970049,
0.029852245,
0.0196206756,
0.0425162017,
0.0066341725,
-0.0382301211,
-0.0212125815,
-0.0102175493,
-0.0214644484,
-0.021925943,
0.0014013557,
0.0412276275,
-0.0344434977,
-0.0448186994,
0.0311127286,
-0.02023305,
0.0214922633,
0.0234746765,
-0.0045045516,
0.0628686175,
-0.0112501169,
0.0165868606,
-0.0066427211,
-0.0372882187,
0.0535749979,
0.0417255089,
0.0110573042,
0.0304890294,
-0.0089094033,
-0.0151717886,
-0.0199495964,
-0.0160081889,
-0.0339446776,
-0.0672110468,
0.0292991847,
0.0035817646,
0.0202593077,
0.0101934662,
-0.0730255693,
-0.0334831662,
0.025424527,
-0.0575220808,
0.0491170697,
-0.0021315932,
-0.0270293914,
0.0313649997,
-0.0430014879,
0.0610108785,
-0.05563109,
0.0471199043,
-0.0112647768,
0.023637576,
-0.0331413969,
-0.0450616442,
-0.0430996604,
0.0068737064,
-0.0172486473,
-0.012538176,
-0.0477641784,
0.0228351764,
0.0064883349,
0.0052440809,
-0.0301067978,
-0.0131800715,
0.0106406631,
0.0186271351,
0.0316158459,
-0.0057028206,
-0.0019147274,
0.0344558209,
0.0158577226,
-0.0801246688,
0.0066970899,
0.0580422916,
0.0087600425,
-0.0127312746,
0.0177340191,
0.0764965937,
0.008169001,
-0.0344906934,
-0.0209064484,
-0.0545752645,
-0.0287152249,
-0.0601455607,
-0.0043214429,
-0.0512736142,
-0.0458183922,
-0.0046966476,
-0.008900689,
-0.043581415,
0.002435202,
0.0043070894,
-0.037545085,
0.0389332175,
-0.0088513335,
0.0039475062,
0.0486991927,
0.0018130682,
-0.0069783567,
0.0607665665,
0.053026367,
0.0572885722,
0.0650343299,
-0.0220594481,
0.0221030507,
0.0449854508,
0.0267801508,
0.0308290254,
-0.0312841386,
-0.0285190269,
0.0189890843,
-0.0106739998,
0.0199649893,
0.0515425727,
-0.0215875078,
-0.0369908623,
0.0943736061,
0.0392397642,
-0.0220717415,
0.0236091819,
0.0307767373,
0.0498751774,
0.0220001787,
0.0354624242,
-0.0292828325,
-0.0380668566,
-0.0444576256,
-0.0366282463,
-0.0050293682,
-0.0005245846,
-0.0121213542,
-0.0291170273,
-0.0312844478,
-0.0129378252,
0.0069620111,
-0.010906931,
0.0354839787,
0.012847689,
-0.0104705319,
0.0377630405,
0.0131538706,
-0.0230617803,
0.0077086212,
-0.0995534956,
0.0421444736,
0.0465178639,
0.0163866505,
-0.0005377324,
0.0692808479,
-0.0454233363,
0.0093730437,
0.0375863127,
-0.0033278638,
-0.0025446534,
0.0049996283,
0.0036721164,
-0.0190646537,
-0.0421329886,
0.0300149266,
0.0222898405,
0.0180703755,
0.0001034569,
0.0254519731,
-0.0304305498,
-0.0617159903,
0.0395741165,
-0.0139868222,
-0.0240942389,
-0.0047312761,
-0.0063198344,
0.012234807,
-0.0010064781,
-0.0210477263,
-0.0072790678,
-0.0088601727,
-0.0174453072,
-0.0138341384,
-0.0148175033,
0.0031679906,
0.0127338553,
0.0192474984,
0.0053307917,
-0.0083309095,
0.0254943632,
-0.0076045226,
-0.0074341008,
0.010091397,
-0.0532980561,
0.021120796,
-0.0719168559,
0.03983685,
-0.0636130869,
0.0272765774,
-0.0126206717,
0.0631220788,
0.0010081982,
0.0012983411,
0.0198106878,
-0.0327549502,
0.0363107882,
-0.0207981281,
-0.0166271906,
-0.0081636896,
-0.0497708619,
0.0230992362,
0.0193118099,
-0.0073164599,
-0.0278047193,
-0.0270476453,
-0.0545700304,
-0.0161499772,
-0.0262430459,
0.0173095968,
0.0218481105,
-0.0233806763,
-0.0072852634,
0.0078900661,
-0.0461311564,
-0.0584951527,
0.0381378606,
0.0293358862,
0.0182226747,
-0.0139762545,
-0.0030787589,
-0.0327720195,
0.0096446685,
-0.0016797638,
0.0783098489,
0.0274571851,
-0.0420406014,
-0.0964352563,
0.0417212136,
-0.0270150416,
-0.0030491699,
-0.0145953074,
-0.0501930453,
-0.0012984837,
0.0254885145,
-0.0211723987,
0.087023139,
0.0376187339,
0.0319900401,
0.052206479,
0.0503550135,
-0.0442802459,
-0.0338085629,
-0.0049389061,
-0.0166392978,
-0.0490925461,
-0.0560679398,
0.0266043302,
0.0704883263,
-0.0112606939,
0.0094468947,
-0.0061677457,
0.0572996624,
-0.0082982332,
-0.0502953976,
-0.0023902499,
-0.0426896736,
-0.0163023435,
0.051368881,
-0.0144857466,
-0.0989973322,
0.037340112,
-0.0365824774,
0.0213737041,
0.0356857851,
-0.0409998223,
-0.0033595341,
0.0196609441,
0.002372856,
0.0546028465,
0.0256982446,
-0.0343901441,
-0.0070653837,
-0.0124361934,
0.0629727542,
-0.0193300545,
-0.0155088678,
-0.0115185389,
0.0116686821,
0.0173955001,
-0.0097277947,
-0.0522455536,
-0.058468502,
-0.0130464956,
0.0141375232,
0.0302362479,
-0.05408049,
-0.0154035678,
0.0094783623,
0.0262663849,
0.0149913663,
-0.0327330679,
0.0104572047,
-0.0167700183,
0.072249487,
0.0237386357,
-0.0502912402,
0.0472874977,
-0.0469148681,
0.0125694294,
0.0542141199,
-0.0297037829,
0.0372516997,
-0.0099911625,
-0.0155354049,
0.0110657802,
0.0239521954,
-0.0418097638,
0.0079300636,
0.0543663017,
-0.0570623688,
0.0063514435,
0.0963997915,
0.0126569793,
-0.020339312,
-0.0064318483,
-0.0169771668,
0.0188648067,
0.0099694943,
-0.0064904387,
-0.0887698978,
-0.0036041779,
0.0080309948,
-0.0018818628,
-0.0619338714,
0.0090268226,
-0.0145096201,
-0.054427281,
0.0298606679,
0.0153648425,
-0.0487690158,
0.0215852987,
-0.0424063988,
-0.0240495242,
0.0150954714,
0.0010172781,
-0.0512185693,
-0.0144072473,
-0.0336598605,
0.0129027739,
-0.0170672685,
-0.0663098097,
0.0060895272,
-0.0270209666,
0.0184918027,
0.0660374016,
0.0609453022,
-0.0259203929,
-0.0162065048,
0.0459119193,
0.00598625,
0.0059359744,
-0.0059774867,
0.0726048648,
-0.0179499052,
-0.003382304,
-0.0194020793,
0.0331214592,
0.0286391005,
-0.0070570209,
0.0013688524,
0.0640739501,
-0.0066889515,
-0.0548041463,
-0.0000123781,
-0.0197899733,
0.0410153195,
0.0750891194,
0.0442181602,
-0.0181947388,
-0.0528722666,
-0.0277590677,
0.0179276634,
-0.0000430403,
-0.0398708954,
0.0188034251,
-0.0206994545,
-0.0517086722,
-0.0694930553,
0.0068280865,
-0.0318319574,
-0.0177672673,
0.017561812,
0.0259742718,
0.0104538174,
-0.0102253864,
-0.0318146758,
0.0010491067,
-0.0519495197,
0.0344692171,
-0.0487319343,
-0.0067359395,
0.0029216963,
-0.0398777165,
-0.0094914427,
-0.0084299007,
-0.0978438184,
-0.0761127025,
-0.0029113458,
-0.0014347807,
0.0254456103,
0.0417962894,
0.0057239868,
-0.0691726953,
0.0591223016,
0.0251844786,
-0.0342535712,
0.0263785329,
0.0562270321,
-0.0238641948,
-0.0218331292,
0.0318665393,
-0.0278396532,
0.0331645869,
0.0483100265,
-0.0615409538,
-0.0744251907,
-0.0036251752,
0.0029654338,
0.0318617709,
0.0126396799,
-0.0176940728,
-0.0257750507,
-0.0107883178,
-0.0180496592,
-0.0223947894,
-0.0098485667,
-0.0475654937,
0.0012257767,
0.0312141553,
-0.0022478045,
0.0033271261,
0.0092105055,
-0.0274306647,
0.0462618694,
-0.0341946334,
0.0392630994,
-0.0390422754,
0.050629057,
0.0208372585,
0.0089672226,
0.0033708049,
0.0474233739,
-0.000401451,
0.0440799035,
0.0163842589,
0.0473218113,
-0.0014927501,
-0.0090605337,
0.005426479,
0.0227203947,
-0.0773990154,
-0.0155364918,
-0.0439000502,
0.0151165575,
0.0214148238,
-0.0306807905,
0.0420764722,
-0.0104336524,
-0.0227995701,
-0.0221831258,
0.0381033793,
-0.016133111,
-0.0577391461,
0.0074516996,
-0.0003358783,
-0.0605759732,
0.0299458932,
0.0516645312,
0.059752062,
0.043198742,
0.0019009809,
-0.0662080944,
-0.026270736,
-0.0168799814,
0.0371936075,
-0.0247449875,
-0.0076057594,
0.0039574807,
-0.0394149795,
-0.0562852323,
-0.0164374355,
-0.0229913127,
0.0190522578,
-0.009010395,
-0.0342907198,
0.0828625038,
-0.0040150802,
-0.0196882822,
-0.0570698939,
-0.0098277088,
0.0078348015,
0.0109643796,
0.0072685522,
-5.520016412e-33,
0.008917626,
-0.0619522072,
-0.0446774997,
-0.0023123489,
0.0030035665,
0.0380440429,
-0.0124034677,
-0.0193956811,
-0.0273395199,
0.0180255435,
0.004093559,
0.0243608262,
0.0062884754,
-0.0057460517,
-0.0197847057,
-0.0044526514,
0.0608493946,
-0.0189420097,
-0.0369654894,
0.0390220769,
0.0464673899,
-0.0110187326,
0.0405288674,
-0.0811551809,
0.0432580151,
-0.024166422,
-0.0376664661,
0.0034344015,
-0.0332225449,
0.0737740621,
-0.0212160088,
0.0227460861,
0.0224557407,
0.0106116245,
-0.0255727489,
0.0473647378,
-0.0333854966,
0.0193470083,
0.0114152972,
0.0093661137,
0.0042088772,
-0.0862684995,
0.0504293852,
-0.0397790298,
-0.012641605,
-0.0095241172,
0.0457285456,
-0.0451460481,
-0.0127978679,
-0.0516124293,
-0.0614846721,
0.0324790142,
-0.0100591434,
0.0237731226,
0.0414734632,
0.0430552326,
0.0034995934,
0.0172868837,
-0.0238338411,
0.0240597837,
0.0478982814,
0.0003100867,
0.044076059,
0.0326873921,
0.0059600747,
0.0544836484,
0.0184179787,
0.034724012,
-0.009294942,
-0.0299929846,
0.0298532452,
0.0490525439,
0.0780665576,
0.0769817382,
0.0217353422,
-0.0437384062,
-0.0461736768,
-0.0158450641,
-0.0175652672,
-0.007793251,
0.0404326804,
-0.0111979786,
-0.0448738225,
-0.0309057031,
-0.0561241582,
-0.0684645474,
-0.0364984237,
-0.0282381903,
0.0255251639,
0.0039335717,
-0.0240567029,
-0.0227688104,
0.0324418955,
-0.0794895366,
-0.0300384946,
0.0121964049,
-0.0224338118,
0.024548132,
0.0190449022,
0.0221925564,
-0.0277260914,
-0.0251381379,
0.0430403687,
-0.0244670119,
0.0407001749,
0.0103024356,
0.0831259936,
0.0164499283,
-0.0610726662,
0.0305720922,
-0.0079654325,
0.0099415118,
0.0163614843,
0.019637147,
0.0185674913,
-0.0285332706,
-0.0050747464,
0.0012915485,
0.0148605322,
0.0081160879,
-0.0521717034,
-0.0058178874,
-0.0385479145,
0.0459759422,
-0.0571439601,
-0.0250475518,
-0.0341726728,
0.0556048974,
0.0841161162,
-0.0461366475,
-0.0005038342,
-0.0295469649,
2.464e-7,
0.0121810781,
0.0453407653,
0.0173368659,
-0.0169238392,
0.0249636881,
0.0566449314,
0.0218298621,
0.0089818882,
-0.0000777409,
-0.0299997348,
-0.015712982,
0.009470378,
0.0829217583,
0.0191664658,
-0.0387381315,
0.0266744569,
-0.0897982195,
0.0001551735,
-0.0519543365,
-0.003667153,
0.0241817292,
0.0914503559,
0.0187260136,
-0.0330640674,
0.0032996163,
-0.0684282258,
0.0680370703,
-0.0549084097,
0.0072820932,
0.01975636,
0.0335012563,
0.0098559912,
0.0230927374,
0.0151153542,
-0.0163666364,
-0.0038877758,
-0.0184620451,
0.0663990006,
0.0001720432,
0.0480994657,
-0.0351660401,
-0.0300863925,
0.0062704212,
-0.0812619179,
0.0349194854,
0.003753189,
-0.0150486045,
-0.0841785222,
-0.0052415435,
-0.0930121019,
0.0322052576,
-0.0431030281,
0.0276305713,
0.033864174,
-0.0167146008,
0.0037843864,
0.012749441,
-0.0462781899,
-0.0276582353,
-0.0481447317,
-0.0347442739,
-0.0405000858,
-0.0563187562,
-0.0283894278,
0.0507873334,
-0.0579293855,
0.0538146347,
2.30685394e-34,
0.023403855,
-0.0277266037,
0.0100938715,
0.0210654028,
0.0406610705,
0.0367004424,
0.013626365,
0.0114846677,
0.0159414224,
-0.0546960756,
0.0318343341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13320v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13320v2 | GlotScript: A Resource and Tool for Low Resource Writing System Identification | 2023-09-23T09:35:55 | 2024-03-27T14:57:29 | Amir Hossein Kargaran, François Yvon, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present GlotScript, an open resource and tool for low resource writing
system identification. GlotScript-R is a resource that provides the attested
writing systems for more than 7,000 languages. It is compiled by aggregating
information from existing writing system resources. GlotScript-T is a writing
system identification tool that covers all 161 Unicode 15.0 scripts. For an
input text, it returns its script distribution where scripts are identified by
ISO 15924 codes. We also present two use cases for GlotScript. First, we
demonstrate that GlotScript can help cleaning multilingual corpora such as mC4
and OSCAR. Second, we analyze the tokenization of a number of language models
such as GPT-4 using GlotScript and provide insights on the coverage of low
resource scripts and languages by each language model. We hope that GlotScript
will become a useful resource for work on low resource languages in the NLP
community. GlotScript-R and GlotScript-T are available at
https://github.com/cisnlp/GlotScript. | [
0.0175444353,
0.0525484905,
-0.0082987621,
0.0481781363,
-0.0554927588,
-0.0178062208,
0.0178997964,
0.0495941751,
-0.0032472212,
-0.0236580763,
-0.0170739125,
-0.0195878353,
0.0536021888,
0.0281095207,
0.0413365066,
-0.0436304919,
0.0329968594,
-0.0300447382,
0.0257641971,
0.0246346928,
0.0470988527,
0.0458321162,
0.01663661,
0.0654549226,
-0.0449443161,
-0.0428598374,
0.0211720541,
0.0066496911,
0.031892065,
0.0032997152,
-0.0151630072,
0.049262587,
-0.0276595429,
0.0843412504,
0.0000019334,
-0.0390321836,
-0.0256989524,
-0.0239092354,
0.0010772299,
0.040646527,
0.0509236567,
-0.0226977691,
-0.069700025,
0.0368837081,
0.0135339396,
-0.0463930964,
0.0848216936,
-0.0170542877,
0.025807146,
0.0481696315,
-0.030133158,
0.012971431,
-0.0284904707,
0.0233710762,
-0.0268433727,
0.0257123169,
0.0221126638,
-0.0256337188,
0.03347902,
-0.0418461598,
0.0171216819,
0.0133229392,
-0.0226861946,
-0.0596360192,
-0.054703936,
0.0092265122,
-0.07149975,
-0.0016440231,
0.0110685211,
0.0011354503,
0.023879759,
-0.054037299,
0.0198026616,
0.024836421,
-0.0138926608,
-0.0236078948,
-0.0259581842,
0.0385937728,
-0.0208951645,
0.0043485737,
0.032776989,
-0.0123296641,
0.0175974779,
-0.0127415955,
0.004679156,
0.0753680691,
0.0369560383,
-0.0253302753,
0.0013104901,
0.0057001789,
-0.0127442945,
-0.0821617916,
0.0169315469,
0.0034906976,
0.0277208127,
-0.0090447925,
-0.0541862659,
-0.0489158519,
0.0368468612,
0.0162757244,
0.049817808,
0.0189155564,
-0.0066796392,
-0.0202380512,
-0.0221820474,
0.0340230614,
0.0381529145,
-0.0296467878,
0.0351711474,
0.0119389836,
0.0070147924,
-0.010684927,
-0.0583819859,
0.0229497049,
-0.0068157227,
0.0363473445,
-0.0210164785,
0.0305031613,
-0.0113568148,
0.0402146019,
0.0059585064,
-0.059840519,
0.0304840412,
0.0262729786,
0.02457924,
0.0115070669,
-0.0032417467,
-0.0282164626,
-0.0496702306,
-0.0563351884,
0.015181859,
0.0700799376,
0.0430775695,
-0.0272418819,
0.0208092108,
0.0713736489,
-0.0043583075,
-0.0279693212,
-0.0178942084,
-0.021445943,
-0.0287683662,
-0.0288624652,
-0.0643379167,
-0.083207801,
-0.0116713578,
0.0208872519,
-0.0065859221,
-0.0315258764,
0.005609965,
0.0281157363,
-0.005341989,
0.0329669043,
-0.0530434847,
-0.0057421094,
0.0002075545,
-0.036610093,
0.0031728959,
-0.0191500746,
0.0127966804,
0.0181880686,
0.0661192089,
-0.0691602752,
0.0384938084,
0.0851260275,
-0.0481298827,
0.0069128275,
-0.0046000048,
-0.0296432525,
0.0410797,
0.0062769712,
0.0206987709,
0.0950615332,
0.0046937917,
0.0084892884,
0.045638606,
0.0612006187,
0.0021192611,
-0.0060124937,
0.0299145728,
-0.0037046326,
0.0207195748,
0.0012472852,
-0.0080070505,
-0.0181167107,
0.0172137804,
-0.0100524379,
0.0064622704,
0.0283794198,
0.0309468061,
-0.0042389124,
-0.0497256629,
-0.0120338174,
-0.016644638,
-0.0408997424,
0.0388593972,
-0.021554064,
-0.0466421507,
-0.008095447,
0.0114266556,
-0.0586483218,
0.0007181072,
-0.0398425758,
0.02703931,
0.0621118434,
0.0987557024,
-0.011679925,
0.0156957433,
-0.033173468,
-0.0142899156,
0.0365594365,
-0.0282677356,
-0.0188880637,
0.0122050485,
-0.0404112302,
0.0322401151,
0.0184632856,
0.0157408901,
0.0535874106,
0.0086103994,
0.0225597434,
0.0064070225,
-0.0219831299,
-0.0437796526,
0.0277674049,
-0.0172258597,
-0.0237660427,
-0.0143141542,
0.0142199276,
0.0295261219,
0.0304180142,
-0.0547448397,
0.0132455966,
-0.0153399771,
-0.0193369407,
0.0388437845,
0.0363138542,
0.0125241335,
0.0101613076,
0.0794814974,
-0.0106083825,
0.0015104053,
0.0478629246,
0.0484430045,
-0.0377446823,
0.0032366398,
-0.0316779241,
0.0489689037,
-0.060340099,
0.0191235635,
-0.0277977996,
-0.0295958947,
0.0089844055,
0.025517555,
0.0307047796,
0.0288559552,
0.0190060996,
-0.0154846041,
0.0815008357,
-0.016880285,
-0.0323144756,
0.0076291831,
-0.0570797101,
-0.0046081212,
0.0335336663,
0.0440052301,
0.0259041153,
-0.0207870398,
-0.0723738819,
-0.0080430722,
-0.0081970245,
0.0164377484,
0.0363797881,
0.0407670625,
-0.0061256872,
0.0194700547,
0.0158734247,
-0.0299300626,
0.0442270674,
-0.0045414311,
0.0548535176,
-0.0277040191,
-0.0269846097,
-0.0176096857,
0.011581446,
-0.0104226423,
0.0106741153,
0.0032197223,
-0.0421464369,
-0.0486273468,
0.050060112,
0.0104494467,
-0.0232816841,
0.0426159576,
-0.0584333874,
-0.0005975473,
-0.0181808677,
0.0270667132,
0.0135758389,
-0.0472786687,
-0.0073889452,
0.0290026721,
-0.0281713177,
0.0284486059,
-0.0477232523,
0.064450562,
0.0104906289,
0.0239249598,
-0.1022179127,
0.0311587919,
0.0554697141,
0.0281818379,
0.0134756388,
-0.0445563309,
-0.0148583045,
-0.010848023,
0.0251668785,
0.0029476199,
-0.0345609225,
-0.0416130722,
-0.0009361289,
-0.0119384006,
-0.0555509031,
0.0199350026,
-0.0684524179,
-0.0411798991,
-0.0366533026,
-0.022504352,
-0.0132648656,
0.0342900008,
-0.0040560672,
0.0413105525,
0.0018436376,
-0.0833072811,
-0.001541798,
0.0323164202,
0.0246805996,
0.0044611897,
0.0171434283,
-0.0344678201,
0.0383855999,
-0.0416650139,
-0.0344250053,
0.0247363877,
0.0024291901,
-0.0061939964,
0.0038050839,
0.0490256213,
-0.0445495211,
0.0023414961,
0.0583784804,
0.0217255224,
0.0845697895,
0.0112753166,
0.0260276441,
-0.0161193274,
0.0390673429,
-0.0325791948,
-0.0866353437,
-0.0303924866,
-0.019835392,
-0.0022173019,
0.026676856,
0.0148484278,
-0.0175612029,
-0.0091422945,
-0.0480864421,
0.0163385738,
-0.0268163048,
-0.0289583635,
-0.0175079405,
0.0526538938,
-0.0090966253,
-0.0123490589,
0.1084373966,
-0.008982907,
-0.0495924763,
0.0153479353,
0.0093191043,
0.0469343625,
0.0054023182,
0.0107699698,
-0.075039804,
-0.0109016392,
0.0667833835,
0.0527262948,
-0.0226246081,
-0.0156425368,
0.0056314864,
-0.0784972385,
0.0552894361,
0.0342559218,
-0.0641237944,
-0.0151262023,
-0.0053593479,
-0.0103622768,
-0.0051356056,
-0.011557091,
0.0270432439,
-0.0201528929,
0.019170817,
0.0082672425,
-0.0701679215,
-0.0257513318,
-0.0403230861,
-0.030744113,
0.0376109481,
0.0107551143,
0.0313524231,
-0.0405456647,
0.0154014723,
0.01934845,
-0.0284214132,
-0.0303136595,
-0.0379584841,
0.0481599085,
0.0187573656,
-0.0440438464,
-0.0386146754,
0.0269828923,
-0.0345638432,
-0.0468889438,
-0.0052592517,
0.0323414765,
-0.0225958358,
-0.0288643129,
0.0279142857,
-0.0082214177,
0.0075461147,
0.0426336341,
0.0390261039,
-0.0107110254,
-0.0613681972,
-0.0877243429,
0.0349926353,
-0.0694140792,
-0.0105310911,
-0.0399764851,
-0.0290053338,
-0.0599149168,
-0.0595951527,
-0.0337224267,
0.0312982313,
0.0431086048,
0.0387027003,
0.0258370358,
-0.0399540104,
-0.0011324703,
-0.0617370605,
-0.0484838001,
-0.0193681214,
0.0372500792,
-0.1142081618,
-0.0411604084,
-0.0075483941,
0.0353336744,
-0.0057679568,
0.00935739,
-0.0329585038,
-0.054814972,
0.0241917986,
0.0249567963,
0.0268536042,
-0.0271199439,
-0.006360733,
-0.0257458724,
-0.0086862389,
0.0011756106,
0.0002863331,
0.0437510386,
-0.0083705084,
-0.0428042077,
-0.0099047879,
0.0087571628,
0.0099958712,
-0.0126490546,
0.0157660525,
0.0133092897,
-0.0222782791,
0.0092565119,
0.0302065201,
0.0592318028,
-0.025661489,
-0.0534118675,
-0.026279768,
-0.0310366433,
-0.0431406498,
-0.0264796242,
-0.0017415495,
-0.0341225564,
0.0212388951,
0.0046800966,
0.0155727267,
-0.0236048996,
-0.014634883,
-0.0289492216,
0.0130755873,
0.0305435508,
0.0517101474,
0.0174961891,
0.0636017397,
0.0258824732,
0.0083228219,
0.0010926321,
0.0258253478,
-0.0308933314,
0.0287928991,
-0.0241603013,
-0.0248626973,
0.0207070876,
-0.0240963474,
0.0509948097,
0.0554628149,
-0.001086822,
0.0021673231,
-0.0142703699,
-0.0242260862,
0.0762716979,
-0.0129485112,
0.078420788,
-0.0490973517,
0.0071073459,
-0.041513551,
0.0206670631,
0.0155481696,
-0.0133242011,
-0.0638249889,
-0.010548492,
-0.056035988,
-0.0384418815,
0.1035514623,
0.0273069572,
0.0177932996,
0.0184549857,
-0.0377261043,
-0.0469286107,
-0.0121241026,
0.0307299439,
-0.0085160732,
-0.0174590591,
-0.0325416401,
-0.0502715707,
-0.0775992125,
-0.027375998,
-0.0014055104,
-0.0053049112,
0.0091334749,
-0.0169503707,
0.0506838895,
0.0234300867,
0.0091182636,
-0.0242984928,
0.033318609,
-0.0272374563,
-0.0534418412,
0.0110443095,
-5.443788542e-33,
0.0103770541,
-0.0378392003,
-0.0544772521,
0.0199892316,
0.0349164456,
-0.0208458938,
-0.0456443876,
-0.004374275,
0.0085424967,
0.0022021662,
-0.0204467587,
-0.0065297568,
0.0268860478,
-0.0002641993,
0.0256148111,
0.071466811,
0.0551171601,
0.0177267622,
-0.0646342859,
0.0144918943,
0.0943238139,
0.0215078704,
0.1073551178,
-0.0422415882,
-0.0029812844,
-0.0479895324,
-0.0337742716,
0.0155592533,
0.0188276209,
0.0149378087,
-0.0293679554,
0.0116441352,
0.032694187,
0.0406825915,
-0.0063503231,
0.0673847795,
-0.0193635169,
-0.0041314564,
0.0259327088,
0.0183629766,
0.0261296872,
-0.0822469592,
0.002758123,
-0.0507282615,
-0.0557524599,
0.0450335294,
0.0067459079,
-0.0044568134,
-0.000383272,
0.0174941346,
-0.0470975041,
0.0479552262,
0.0105268545,
0.0188117735,
0.0155782737,
0.0096926484,
0.0056170165,
-0.0141593581,
-0.047370024,
0.0232241228,
-0.0280124899,
0.0567551926,
0.0079587838,
0.0005195421,
-0.0434231311,
0.0397110805,
0.006606272,
-0.0009090579,
0.0378629044,
0.049679555,
0.0139576709,
0.0058307615,
0.0393030904,
0.0245336927,
0.0174629577,
-0.0489308834,
-0.005617117,
0.0380517244,
0.013924038,
0.0174280871,
-0.0157092754,
-0.0127590671,
-0.0084750261,
-0.0334019996,
-0.0018867378,
-0.0448559001,
-0.0102947196,
-0.0262861531,
0.0536207147,
-0.0261985101,
-0.0124681965,
0.0098092379,
0.0371961296,
-0.0091495011,
-0.0253238548,
0.021618247,
0.0091567375,
0.0690207481,
-0.0258343536,
0.0182520449,
-0.0035733616,
-0.0131604522,
-0.0078794444,
-0.0023141277,
0.055214908,
0.0132519649,
0.0054240315,
0.0552400276,
-0.0930119231,
0.0273694508,
-0.0007705661,
0.0712071732,
-0.0064123245,
0.0082078166,
-0.0127775241,
-0.0252742674,
0.0666010678,
-0.033828713,
0.0865514949,
-0.0118415374,
-0.0082388464,
-0.0222166181,
-0.0191196334,
-0.0099318484,
-0.0298007783,
0.0003561801,
-0.0264653768,
0.0693806484,
0.0514992066,
0.015402616,
0.0036433861,
-0.0361799933,
2.607e-7,
0.0570505038,
0.0237015299,
0.062003009,
-0.02858839,
0.0259467568,
0.0298183635,
-0.0455321372,
0.024511436,
-0.060850054,
0.0318295285,
-0.0296057314,
-0.0899130553,
0.0827883855,
0.0085008787,
-0.0613539778,
0.0276878383,
-0.041889403,
-0.0246488471,
-0.0789849162,
0.0499186777,
-0.0207073949,
0.0547247082,
-0.0117296558,
-0.0292511247,
-0.0295675676,
-0.0929816589,
0.0080336183,
-0.03579548,
0.0017983336,
0.0025436436,
-0.0006448727,
-0.0254471637,
0.0189680513,
-0.0197368525,
-0.0072425939,
-0.0169404782,
0.0052692713,
0.0609264635,
-0.0298902653,
0.047375001,
0.0282430258,
-0.0302926768,
-0.0150302239,
-0.0602776147,
0.0482157543,
0.1309345365,
-0.0077925804,
-0.0362568572,
-0.0173535403,
-0.0157364327,
-0.0408341512,
-0.0170198884,
-0.0391946584,
0.024005793,
0.0021100494,
-0.0143811116,
-0.0040638288,
0.0060718092,
-0.0376047269,
0.0076854643,
-0.0098082758,
-0.0408353917,
-0.0437261723,
-0.0076899119,
0.031853579,
-0.0608002841,
0.0120195411,
3.232983694e-34,
0.0230156109,
-0.057075683,
-0.0050478107,
0.0394741297,
0.0203907341,
-0.0168263316,
0.0106366007,
0.0418979488,
-0.0377505422,
-0.0201300457,
-0.0056420704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13318v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13318v2 | Spanish Resource Grammar version 2023 | 2023-09-23T09:24:05 | 2024-03-26T11:26:04 | Olga Zamaraeva, Lorena S. Allegue, Carlos Gómez-Rodríguez | cs.CL | cs.CL, 03B65 | We present the latest version of the Spanish Resource Grammar (SRG), a
grammar of Spanish implemented in the HPSG formalism. Such grammars encode a
complex set of hypotheses about syntax making them a resource for empirical
testing of linguistic theory. They also encode a strict notion of
grammaticality which makes them a resource for natural language processing
applications in computer-assisted language learning. This version of the SRG
uses the recent version of the Freeling morphological analyzer and is released
along with an automatically created, manually verified treebank of 2,291
sentences. We explain the treebanking process, emphasizing how it is different
from treebanking with manual annotation and how it contributes to
empirically-driven development of syntactic theory. The treebanks' high level
of consistency and detail makes them a resource for training high-quality
semantic parsers and generally systems that benefit from precise and detailed
semantics. Finally, we present the grammar's coverage and overgeneration on 100
sentences from a learner corpus, a new research line related to developing
methodologies for robust empirical evaluation of hypotheses in second language
acquisition. | [
0.015141068,
0.0428567939,
-0.0180544574,
0.0419619195,
-0.0247565322,
0.0284371376,
-0.0710310265,
-0.0329679213,
-0.0370086618,
-0.0454447195,
-0.0036389797,
0.0065757972,
0.0098387906,
-0.0744010061,
0.0167876612,
-0.0571941584,
0.0563752837,
0.0089988718,
0.0255638808,
0.008614758,
0.0495160446,
0.0196381435,
-0.0026563811,
0.0326926298,
-0.0790267959,
-0.022254467,
0.0062358868,
-0.0365130454,
-0.0018228769,
-0.0392412581,
0.0004294858,
0.0308673214,
-0.0214058347,
0.0138250003,
0.0000020272,
-0.0711130574,
-0.0352521315,
0.0139658581,
-0.0290270988,
-0.0237836689,
0.0601107106,
-0.0135077639,
-0.0242466219,
-0.0229056142,
-0.0724257603,
-0.0163183343,
0.0228291508,
-0.021401301,
0.0247317217,
0.033614587,
-0.0205839239,
-0.0817462653,
0.0159992259,
-0.017585637,
-0.0135936933,
0.0148131028,
0.012315209,
-0.0035197863,
0.0261290036,
-0.0398920067,
0.0103794653,
-0.0075273048,
0.0239674244,
-0.0437333919,
-0.0263896361,
-0.0185050461,
-0.0845913813,
-0.0347845666,
0.0014136496,
0.0086540496,
-0.008383506,
-0.0381738357,
0.0358336866,
0.0150739951,
-0.0056643011,
-0.0129247196,
-0.0200301968,
0.0606313013,
-0.010734166,
0.0457565822,
0.1037287712,
-0.0209024269,
0.0065300874,
-0.0116765071,
0.0350254625,
0.1005583704,
0.0127589693,
-0.0395255201,
0.0289114434,
0.0609205067,
-0.0068833986,
-0.0369725376,
-0.0198285896,
-0.0076749269,
0.0206875652,
0.044315137,
0.0068389922,
-0.0246934183,
0.0425487012,
-0.042281393,
-0.004842706,
0.0183921438,
-0.0184877012,
0.0042689145,
0.0178299639,
-0.0037037879,
0.0206968468,
-0.005605075,
-0.0396394618,
0.0030951402,
-0.0189110283,
-0.0075841416,
-0.0796169564,
0.0159763135,
-0.0209364351,
0.0192861203,
-0.0409203246,
-0.0228951164,
0.0114155654,
-0.0013233995,
0.0082570175,
0.0003554657,
-0.0500310175,
0.0471123084,
-0.0094606131,
0.0167544372,
-0.0304324906,
-0.0000317236,
0.0021652097,
-0.1014129817,
0.0046091536,
0.0608300082,
0.0005788811,
-0.0109242192,
-0.0246160459,
0.0252972078,
-0.0037088427,
-0.0036374833,
-0.0168509129,
-0.0655758306,
-0.0436288156,
-0.0607303642,
0.0197556913,
-0.0861463472,
0.0048183915,
0.002566864,
0.0226038378,
0.003275957,
0.0103550442,
0.02846759,
0.0446955152,
0.0067583108,
-0.0569907054,
-0.0445877947,
-0.0377496406,
-0.0147115802,
0.0022206735,
0.0796867758,
0.0168875977,
-0.0202767793,
0.0477803349,
0.0150256399,
-0.0321693122,
0.030154774,
-0.0287207812,
-0.0584130399,
0.0134279076,
-0.0040492965,
0.0093338927,
0.0421905071,
0.0114512723,
0.0248687379,
-0.0328258909,
0.0220811069,
-0.0144931246,
0.0480333306,
-0.0150272762,
0.0028902139,
0.1080404222,
0.0048228749,
0.035989929,
0.022321634,
-0.0059614438,
-0.0356349386,
-0.0276259277,
0.02163711,
-0.1145194024,
0.0192856975,
0.037238393,
-0.066353783,
-0.0231130496,
-0.0006315272,
-0.0374385752,
-0.0358026102,
0.0370798968,
0.0557608195,
0.0199315213,
0.0325687043,
0.0449489616,
-0.0883760899,
0.0040248716,
0.0196627583,
0.0623496138,
0.0073586502,
0.0212781969,
-0.0231405925,
-0.0011003691,
-0.0116953822,
0.0098247323,
0.0328363851,
0.003352911,
-0.0236455612,
0.0261791665,
-0.0628758818,
0.0199367441,
0.0192424171,
0.0458254069,
-0.0003355748,
-0.0560971387,
-0.0173064489,
-0.0016032236,
0.004449096,
-0.0388419814,
0.0340809859,
0.0374663584,
0.0032899166,
-0.0273418482,
0.0104895942,
0.0325464569,
0.0402516723,
-0.0083150137,
0.0003505383,
0.0495380685,
-0.0151538979,
0.040901769,
0.0456911065,
-0.0600741841,
-0.0681240782,
0.0061894311,
-0.0547172353,
-0.0329173654,
-0.0118253836,
-0.0046834745,
-0.0159868654,
-0.0079506421,
-0.0520604961,
0.0966488048,
-0.0494438261,
0.0431016795,
-0.0232447404,
0.0426684991,
-0.0333593898,
0.0662727654,
0.0025687411,
0.0321884081,
-0.0592104979,
-0.0423836038,
0.0512275659,
-0.0613584109,
-0.0360238291,
0.0132812224,
-0.0241439864,
-0.022794893,
0.0301357899,
0.0342307687,
-0.0583321936,
0.0185248051,
-0.0448267609,
0.0211433321,
-0.0382125303,
0.0822614506,
0.0368757062,
-0.0311488844,
-0.0162579995,
-0.0233298466,
0.0368661471,
0.0114780599,
0.0171580911,
-0.0140215661,
0.0507188961,
0.0179482754,
-0.0044139219,
-0.0472852848,
0.0121354228,
-0.0328394696,
0.034017574,
0.0468107164,
-0.0334881358,
0.0065546334,
-0.0043089124,
0.0100133698,
0.0030658585,
0.045776885,
-0.0573363267,
0.0458914302,
0.0009202773,
0.0245160051,
0.0501130298,
-0.0484727658,
0.0303627606,
0.01849062,
-0.0129623609,
-0.0045860731,
0.0025940619,
0.0074716029,
-0.0342028737,
-0.0674617141,
-0.0325200707,
0.0211795662,
0.1086945087,
0.0254312064,
-0.0259254128,
-0.004963987,
-0.0122794425,
-0.0613390729,
-0.013721507,
0.0014087558,
-0.0324979573,
-0.0305683725,
0.0376949832,
-0.030322874,
-0.025854513,
0.0419345796,
-0.0466320924,
-0.0686207637,
-0.0798525438,
-0.0078140805,
-0.0213169064,
0.0106325522,
0.0498445667,
0.0032616791,
0.0509385392,
-0.018758459,
0.0231498778,
0.0154996132,
0.0696369633,
0.0339507647,
0.0340129845,
-0.0678371266,
-0.0288980827,
0.0125518087,
-0.0406732,
-0.0181873273,
-0.0178937837,
-0.0302234758,
0.0010848597,
-0.0066441107,
-0.0045210514,
0.0265312158,
-0.0486058295,
-0.0429299772,
0.0364509523,
-0.0021924097,
-0.0214575417,
-0.0131668635,
0.0352498032,
-0.018270988,
-0.0052019507,
0.0165534299,
0.0538873821,
0.0105723431,
0.0376365781,
-0.0357258394,
0.0301968511,
-0.0277948044,
0.0524101369,
0.0104026701,
-0.0290913451,
-0.0881169662,
-0.0052018282,
0.0091945622,
-0.0594419837,
-0.0024677797,
0.0636110529,
0.0380763635,
-0.0032426214,
0.0394048505,
-0.0341177732,
0.0511031821,
0.0298735313,
0.0289864056,
-0.0669137463,
-0.0015791603,
0.0056161443,
0.0041753002,
-0.0241962057,
-0.0411887653,
-0.0034386353,
-0.1078217775,
0.0351858772,
-0.006436022,
-0.0201616716,
0.0524143837,
0.0089745568,
-0.0085715298,
-0.0287477877,
-0.0218519196,
0.0368667357,
-0.0417860709,
0.0275016893,
0.0521254614,
-0.0629339814,
-0.0344593711,
-0.0226015113,
-0.0435312986,
-0.0278488789,
0.0690125152,
0.0282998327,
0.0047509549,
-0.0159160718,
-0.0018308435,
-0.0426199809,
0.0108390534,
-0.0181837436,
-0.0154105676,
0.0357108712,
-0.0151055548,
-0.051733844,
0.0253868829,
-0.0206589252,
0.0011216904,
0.017306326,
0.1308359653,
0.0105950478,
-0.0069046943,
-0.0040272772,
0.0047733542,
0.0046351678,
0.0227724109,
0.0461428091,
0.0153665673,
-0.0076264092,
-0.0601215437,
-0.0214151628,
-0.0406695046,
0.0080054589,
0.0408994518,
-0.0358841717,
-0.0211448073,
-0.0836589634,
-0.0722954646,
0.0034452863,
0.0081442939,
-0.016398862,
0.0068506286,
-0.0051351972,
-0.037575081,
-0.011762958,
0.0390964709,
0.0175379589,
-0.0005214255,
-0.0149093289,
-0.0150908381,
0.0268222559,
0.0451342836,
-0.0497663505,
-0.0300975554,
-0.0228106473,
-0.0561527573,
0.0144568924,
0.0593622848,
0.0162426084,
0.0249906145,
-0.041464664,
-0.0328679793,
-0.0466243699,
0.0162804555,
-0.0598643161,
0.0216228608,
0.0467770435,
-0.0214423016,
0.0207083691,
0.0261084214,
0.0286000129,
-0.0134029808,
-0.0279299449,
0.0289567821,
-0.0306515954,
0.0207109377,
0.0554378629,
0.0227557328,
0.0478683524,
-0.0184837542,
0.0203972347,
-0.0282503217,
-0.0121245803,
-0.0421514213,
-0.0173451882,
-0.0151119241,
0.0240784772,
0.0093154423,
0.0310942885,
-0.0307935607,
0.0096948706,
-0.0408357903,
0.0325613208,
0.009170155,
0.0591290966,
0.0746777058,
0.0222424269,
-0.0197080541,
0.064301677,
0.0284836311,
-0.000174808,
-0.0356167071,
0.0314589925,
-0.0275361463,
-0.015230814,
-0.0029244733,
-0.0209975112,
0.0179087427,
-0.0081293508,
0.0528432056,
0.0271799862,
-0.0006735995,
-0.0131795835,
0.068003431,
-0.0461729504,
0.0730411485,
-0.039982833,
0.0081198486,
0.0122873262,
0.0300688576,
-0.0123399282,
-0.079703033,
0.0616640858,
-0.0164340623,
-0.035063982,
-0.0419449508,
0.0461527072,
0.0029415549,
0.0149820345,
0.0035354986,
0.0231332947,
-0.0227593668,
-0.0364379585,
0.0367018282,
-0.0211565476,
-0.026400879,
-0.0161624197,
-0.0325343274,
-0.0687028989,
-0.042818334,
0.0186068267,
0.0212333072,
0.00276296,
0.0599186383,
0.0726172626,
-0.0158984009,
-0.0631758794,
-0.0430520102,
-0.0030704467,
-0.0452636108,
0.0182792768,
-0.0155667188,
-5.703121697e-33,
-0.0274015237,
-0.0330252796,
-0.0032023834,
-0.0203396119,
-0.0074122129,
-0.0230522472,
-0.0362823121,
0.0135146976,
0.0184385441,
0.0544588454,
-0.0112522123,
-0.0080826599,
0.0265149511,
0.009846691,
0.0703615546,
0.0453389324,
0.0297678355,
-0.0117972186,
-0.000769308,
-0.0452118777,
0.006919716,
0.0083044684,
0.1192240939,
-0.0565646365,
0.0234989263,
-0.0118168909,
-0.0209820159,
0.0599500351,
-0.0298151374,
0.0520580001,
0.0061131725,
0.0436098911,
0.002924022,
-0.0094791576,
-0.025970893,
0.0254008882,
-0.0744231343,
-0.0826743767,
0.072605148,
0.0623754375,
-0.0268234424,
-0.0396103673,
0.0093495334,
-0.0322242752,
-0.0126173757,
0.0742313191,
0.0232128743,
-0.0086470013,
0.0110955453,
-0.0017303964,
-0.0684342012,
0.0246945918,
-0.0018248782,
0.0351275504,
0.0378014483,
0.0494686924,
-0.0392318703,
-0.0509392917,
-0.0198017079,
0.0192095265,
-0.0131759662,
0.0324711092,
0.0751192123,
-0.0241677035,
-0.0032768468,
0.0251891259,
0.016893765,
-0.0570176914,
0.0482766256,
0.0661389902,
0.029026594,
0.0378978513,
0.0110421507,
0.0555949807,
0.0504079536,
0.013967488,
-0.0388632677,
-0.0172776356,
0.0400214791,
0.0616917349,
-0.0756733567,
0.0160433091,
-0.026700357,
-0.0184182338,
-0.0230386406,
-0.0319353119,
0.0240911078,
-0.0430460051,
0.0036490108,
-0.0143442685,
0.0001842134,
0.0299663283,
-0.009141624,
0.0048960852,
-0.009682931,
0.0185439512,
-0.006768065,
0.0216496978,
0.0133168083,
0.0426828749,
-0.0374852121,
0.0023203327,
-0.0023187457,
-0.0000590956,
0.0549200848,
0.021298198,
0.058544375,
0.0089261457,
-0.0120872986,
0.0343256667,
-0.0202534664,
0.0274295062,
-0.024593154,
0.029184822,
0.0305446908,
0.0241984595,
-0.0199568812,
0.047581885,
0.0134413466,
0.0201335065,
-0.0399270765,
0.0116720246,
-0.0239999201,
0.0182795506,
-0.0110382605,
-0.0151317082,
-0.0015938008,
0.0188951548,
0.0386680961,
-0.0129675642,
-0.0018492142,
-0.0033698664,
2.731e-7,
0.0546917319,
0.0387935862,
0.0340901501,
0.0035005875,
0.0187258851,
-0.0182902571,
0.0049422458,
0.0049333279,
-0.0472424962,
0.018838197,
-0.0406946018,
-0.0433940068,
0.022150293,
0.022709148,
-0.0954615176,
-0.0581021979,
-0.018089015,
-0.0254239775,
-0.0602660961,
0.0032442005,
0.0428536348,
0.0700983852,
-0.0067748791,
-0.0025211161,
-0.0176970884,
-0.0067729969,
0.0115833748,
0.0111564659,
0.0026914796,
0.0386765562,
0.041763477,
0.0309643839,
0.0001436254,
0.0048354683,
-0.018816907,
0.0115308464,
-0.0422141142,
0.0117320642,
-0.0108640743,
0.0518818982,
0.0552028678,
-0.0277475249,
-0.0258559957,
-0.0411804654,
0.0258991942,
-0.0453983918,
-0.0108210575,
0.0253031123,
-0.0124959387,
0.0067782598,
-0.0260353051,
0.0014176386,
-0.0175970271,
0.0072220443,
0.0285818614,
-0.0338843055,
-0.0649484694,
-0.0314168334,
-0.0198369753,
0.0807759464,
-0.0141402837,
-0.0502663925,
-0.0001801078,
0.0473372415,
-0.0304329209,
-0.0221459735,
-0.0002598178,
2.150896834e-34,
-0.0140004,
0.0001332113,
0.0492668636,
0.0041060741,
0.050941471,
0.0101663349,
0.0118566873,
0.0349552967,
-0.0041360208,
-0.0180132128,
0.0153302802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13308v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13308v1 | Calibrating LLM-Based Evaluator | 2023-09-23T08:46:11 | 2023-09-23T08:46:11 | Yuxuan Liu, Tianchi Yang, Shaohan Huang, Zihan Zhang, Haizhen Huang, Furu Wei, Weiwei Deng, Feng Sun, Qi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) on language modeling and
emergent capabilities make them a promising reference-free evaluator of natural
language generation quality, and a competent alternative to human evaluation.
However, hindered by the closed-source or high computational demand to host and
tune, there is a lack of practice to further calibrate an off-the-shelf
LLM-based evaluator towards better human alignment. In this work, we propose
AutoCalibrate, a multi-stage, gradient-free approach to automatically calibrate
and align an LLM-based evaluator toward human preference. Instead of explicitly
modeling human preferences, we first implicitly encompass them within a set of
human labels. Then, an initial set of scoring criteria is drafted by the
language model itself, leveraging in-context learning on different few-shot
examples. To further calibrate this set of criteria, we select the best
performers and re-draft them with self-refinement. Our experiments on multiple
text quality evaluation datasets illustrate a significant improvement in
correlation with expert evaluation through calibration. Our comprehensive
qualitative analysis conveys insightful intuitions and observations on the
essence of effective scoring criteria. | [
0.0321196131,
0.0494934022,
0.0165688563,
0.0125725903,
-0.0353214592,
0.0060050171,
0.0188301988,
-0.0132553028,
-0.0129826376,
-0.0411818661,
-0.055022046,
-0.0552835129,
0.0141631039,
0.0162093714,
0.0463560671,
-0.0151517531,
0.0059778723,
0.0049958555,
0.0334186405,
0.0137226675,
0.0252793618,
0.0143616237,
0.0174030587,
0.0436629988,
0.010120064,
-0.0079596564,
0.0399970114,
0.0245809797,
0.0403293893,
-0.0233718865,
0.0302347336,
0.0728687346,
-0.0303761978,
0.006407653,
0.0000020218,
-0.0412141383,
-0.0135736046,
0.0037853271,
0.0236758571,
0.0312289186,
0.0747235045,
0.0330914967,
-0.0453918949,
0.0220341925,
-0.045933228,
0.0177309588,
0.0103448769,
-0.0027119012,
0.0786914378,
0.0728152245,
0.0142208422,
-0.0031371047,
-0.0023185038,
-0.0323543288,
-0.0309645068,
-0.036172092,
0.0009826199,
0.0076909601,
-0.0240594,
0.0028254497,
0.0112456968,
0.0114727672,
-0.0016553428,
-0.0403070375,
0.0751669481,
0.0117531177,
-0.0196075402,
-0.030548472,
-0.0054225298,
0.0733657256,
0.0149558829,
-0.0251309928,
-0.002667252,
-0.0374980159,
0.0170069188,
-0.0162556134,
-0.0124648958,
0.0256049037,
0.0246773418,
0.0223294795,
0.0120370435,
0.0138249099,
0.0303618331,
0.0401970409,
0.0160480831,
0.0592906624,
0.0093245683,
-0.0247416031,
-0.004377061,
0.0258631799,
-0.0141747734,
-0.0518480726,
0.0303927027,
0.0123781348,
-0.059310019,
0.0100756548,
-0.0691113546,
-0.0124332504,
0.01735452,
-0.0290127043,
0.0560308285,
0.0227535293,
0.0094804447,
0.0031526089,
-0.0204305369,
0.0706174746,
0.0143293962,
0.004804872,
-0.0483867414,
0.0084721325,
-0.0106920013,
0.001497075,
0.0051779151,
0.0132543631,
-0.0125038847,
-0.0139453216,
-0.0782083496,
-0.0015781263,
-0.0150437662,
0.0031213302,
0.0182118732,
0.0424310826,
-0.0166504066,
0.0031601321,
-0.0494161472,
0.0180491973,
-0.0228101872,
0.0046122707,
0.050972078,
-0.0053944681,
0.0101967948,
0.0526215658,
0.001893791,
-0.0056084469,
0.0089973044,
0.0246625468,
-0.0103586409,
-0.022350641,
-0.0233001634,
-0.0314624682,
-0.0249050297,
-0.0571974888,
-0.0462426804,
-0.0621894822,
-0.0066367211,
0.0025065467,
-0.0003363586,
-0.0736420602,
-0.0081671113,
0.0326532647,
-0.0105610322,
-0.0022646021,
-0.0125367241,
0.0057947161,
0.0221228991,
-0.0013471198,
0.014915877,
0.0454697423,
0.0649638921,
0.0386860743,
0.0228311047,
0.0134659363,
0.0254513975,
0.0386433378,
0.0058063264,
-0.0006175162,
-0.0193540286,
-0.0186157022,
-0.0333770216,
0.0540561862,
0.0659199059,
0.0881766453,
-0.025968194,
0.0332442895,
0.0834965184,
0.010287784,
0.0498740152,
0.0192205235,
0.0730075911,
0.0387870558,
-0.0070549399,
0.0181150623,
-0.0087936949,
0.0318534784,
-0.0200000498,
0.008250135,
0.0738805234,
0.0405536145,
0.01033655,
-0.0747007951,
-0.014187213,
0.0139227333,
0.0023340946,
-0.0237002727,
0.0028418496,
0.0180908069,
-0.0547336787,
0.0117623592,
0.0018124736,
-0.0768617541,
0.046300102,
-0.0404369496,
0.0493777543,
0.0994865373,
0.0787362978,
0.038863875,
0.0082616638,
-0.0105666043,
-0.0258038528,
0.0515064895,
0.0399517864,
-0.0283488389,
-0.0181857217,
-0.0708198175,
-0.0337910689,
-0.0085497936,
0.0194280613,
0.0008816798,
0.0060886969,
-0.0016397024,
0.0524470136,
-0.0374178551,
-0.0924784094,
0.0535972565,
-0.0268626008,
-0.0378595814,
0.0249710511,
0.0017683267,
0.0316073112,
0.0236602258,
-0.0286093783,
0.0229004472,
-0.0067596165,
-0.0210200585,
-0.0140000405,
-0.0059374622,
-0.042926278,
-0.0204405785,
0.0127503471,
-0.039326515,
0.001282122,
0.012121669,
-0.0353848934,
-0.0415163897,
-0.0049346215,
-0.0421241559,
-0.0066472506,
-0.0757297799,
0.0266165733,
0.0003273234,
-0.0063834707,
-0.0555657074,
0.0624281839,
-0.0026785824,
0.0114787882,
0.0272333995,
0.0163798239,
0.0152566237,
-0.0304332301,
-0.029342195,
-0.0300085042,
-0.0118192425,
0.0523590185,
0.0562733226,
0.0480564348,
-0.0516687892,
-0.0461943746,
-0.06529852,
0.0244347956,
-0.0335799567,
0.0275414288,
0.0168807358,
-0.0340244137,
-0.0110162366,
0.0459516048,
-0.0574701093,
-0.0564357936,
0.0181715395,
-0.0109654004,
0.0653385222,
-0.0150143746,
0.0157054551,
-0.0486102886,
0.0235982966,
0.0161368232,
0.0418247618,
0.0330858789,
0.0532342345,
-0.0506170839,
0.0580040887,
-0.0475145876,
-0.0433057509,
0.028321635,
-0.0623446815,
0.0172290206,
0.0246178675,
0.0254527126,
0.0586282238,
0.0225575641,
0.0025487232,
0.042916581,
0.0219169408,
-0.0600654855,
-0.0154066207,
-0.0160412639,
0.0054103173,
-0.0091657303,
-0.0272828955,
0.0287398081,
0.0553197153,
0.0160201471,
0.001332004,
-0.0608312264,
0.0575278811,
-0.0512216687,
-0.0372785404,
0.0021742792,
-0.0009737182,
-0.0328751095,
0.0460316688,
-0.0175370667,
-0.0661207139,
0.0905008167,
-0.0352910459,
0.016749762,
-0.0277831946,
0.0030443659,
-0.0439953096,
-0.0091916136,
-0.0239044446,
0.0291715655,
-0.0009959956,
0.0113590425,
-0.059686441,
0.0005820315,
0.0575970933,
-0.053621456,
0.0088321269,
-0.0516304597,
0.0006715232,
0.0084029678,
-0.0230133049,
-0.0407683514,
-0.0315786637,
-0.0070042345,
-0.0002541078,
0.0519335493,
-0.0017253131,
-0.0045063482,
-0.0059204656,
0.0047917776,
0.0101924548,
-0.0384736881,
-0.0023747433,
0.0076452452,
0.0494753458,
0.040749155,
0.0049237167,
0.0245413464,
-0.0260883607,
-0.0077458741,
0.0241021104,
-0.0027323538,
0.0373783894,
-0.0117485859,
0.0002851197,
0.0387411565,
-0.0144164301,
-0.0218692441,
0.0355463661,
0.0797404721,
-0.0475956872,
-0.0211990029,
0.1288048327,
0.0253488719,
-0.0278854929,
-0.0024555931,
-0.0044198902,
0.0440843627,
0.0037243601,
0.0203877185,
-0.0404400937,
-0.0232786406,
-0.0073316391,
0.0562635213,
-0.032224495,
-0.0011866547,
-0.0252459235,
-0.1117275283,
0.0402279459,
0.039844308,
-0.0185778029,
-0.0090905419,
-0.0199374408,
-0.0065624695,
-0.0394987501,
0.0200519077,
0.0221272875,
-0.0016450196,
0.0255293977,
0.0255049281,
-0.0538655519,
-0.096365191,
-0.0004970363,
-0.0440307818,
0.0752534792,
0.096677199,
0.0403554104,
0.0169295613,
-0.0545053817,
0.0162650757,
-0.0401208065,
0.0068351608,
-0.0094353771,
0.0227653235,
-0.020527659,
0.0095679825,
-0.0521220006,
0.0183797907,
-0.0069932165,
0.0025353937,
-0.0263343547,
0.0270408187,
0.0152253779,
-0.0134084104,
-0.0262266956,
0.021972131,
-0.0003471243,
0.0865792632,
0.0397062488,
-0.0906088352,
-0.0241292622,
-0.0260195304,
-0.0051086699,
-0.0787163004,
-0.0514753051,
0.0391930901,
-0.0085730087,
-0.0285571907,
-0.1048046798,
-0.0347258225,
-0.017103631,
0.0154683813,
0.0009863107,
-0.0195639543,
-0.0446309,
-0.0293717049,
0.005212774,
0.0202457048,
-0.0207208209,
-0.0004178349,
-0.0796426982,
-0.0042497292,
0.0299777742,
-0.0334427319,
-0.0167268068,
0.0359406136,
-0.065848358,
-0.0665282831,
-0.0283587575,
0.0497431345,
0.0171482116,
0.0371975228,
-0.0103942379,
-0.081384629,
0.0814289972,
0.0682551041,
-0.0343104117,
0.0355761349,
0.0118321227,
0.0113914004,
-0.0273386706,
0.0206373949,
-0.033523526,
0.0204074215,
0.0231332742,
0.0527583919,
0.0083371149,
-0.0400558487,
0.026484197,
0.0177994631,
0.0109889992,
-0.0809171423,
0.0004301558,
-0.0414244197,
-0.0344542451,
-0.0102740247,
-0.0448651724,
-0.0457318462,
-0.0071676266,
0.0437123217,
-0.0150425574,
-0.028219454,
0.0229767505,
-0.0365363099,
0.0498043373,
-0.0391593613,
0.0123002855,
-0.0095802769,
0.0079088788,
-0.004564682,
-0.0056100613,
-0.0302116554,
-0.0244186036,
-0.025167305,
0.037073005,
0.0048151948,
0.0372300297,
0.0004782149,
0.0300061591,
0.0391840674,
0.0515096039,
-0.0254433602,
0.0025971381,
-0.0687162355,
-0.0011363442,
0.0456447601,
0.016452441,
0.0912507549,
0.0060556466,
0.0066279145,
-0.0303238947,
0.0281963311,
0.0019555611,
-0.0301500075,
-0.015833715,
-0.0049631102,
-0.0370565578,
-0.0122412229,
0.0479765236,
0.0122736823,
-0.0149253514,
-0.0433227383,
-0.0026177387,
-0.0453806147,
-0.032749407,
-0.0045709903,
-0.0141896959,
-0.0112899793,
-0.0030339146,
-0.0704879761,
-0.0482033677,
0.0051597874,
0.051919695,
0.0185547285,
-0.0271450002,
0.0238999836,
0.0686886236,
-0.0717720017,
0.0119086541,
-0.0678351298,
-0.0522028096,
-0.0126905087,
0.0044557797,
-0.0333059169,
-6.489102036e-33,
-0.0395804644,
-0.04376081,
0.0126884831,
-0.040616367,
-0.02355038,
-0.0041204304,
-0.0275418386,
-0.0040450636,
0.0160940066,
0.0085098771,
0.0025823337,
-0.018558627,
0.0062865606,
0.0219653249,
-0.0021861373,
0.0021398081,
0.0541134588,
0.0020069468,
-0.0853056535,
0.0213731974,
-0.0110401791,
-0.0013351627,
0.0203915946,
-0.0513416976,
0.0497313514,
-0.003537161,
-0.0624566376,
-0.0157925468,
0.0238719247,
0.0597518869,
0.008080313,
0.0410963669,
0.0148781044,
-0.0338001512,
-0.0105768414,
-0.0017259136,
-0.0377415568,
-0.0074610016,
0.0039069755,
-0.0226029586,
-0.0301116351,
-0.042355679,
0.0697995648,
-0.0134427017,
-0.0676325783,
0.0091921212,
0.04660739,
-0.0309706796,
-0.0112261968,
-0.060049057,
-0.0406789333,
0.0480517708,
-0.0176933166,
-0.031522058,
-0.0236976352,
0.0312398709,
-0.0246176645,
0.0234043505,
-0.0600371957,
0.025792418,
0.0086706299,
0.0334593952,
0.0864943713,
0.0214387625,
-0.0312177483,
0.0598914772,
-0.0028630032,
0.0079077221,
-0.0060959207,
-0.0391928814,
0.0327910557,
0.0142726842,
0.0391053222,
0.0887122974,
0.0082271658,
-0.0400658771,
-0.0508643873,
0.0883391351,
0.0056177545,
0.0044061108,
0.0160967242,
0.0017844894,
-0.022620799,
-0.0274602231,
-0.0447031632,
-0.0622314736,
-0.0314610451,
-0.0190629903,
0.028310461,
0.0172519851,
-0.0496890768,
-0.0529472865,
0.0021009445,
-0.030471921,
0.0077892789,
0.0152715975,
-0.061153207,
0.0114183733,
-0.003824264,
0.0121752741,
-0.0524348654,
0.0000906974,
0.0051543619,
0.0249287002,
0.0150107918,
-0.0142339403,
0.021587031,
0.0241861828,
-0.0605731905,
0.0315374099,
-0.0270526689,
0.0305087231,
-0.0094624637,
-0.0129617769,
0.0121393995,
-0.0226628538,
-0.0374674648,
0.0502648614,
0.0016455514,
0.0323302336,
-0.0089897327,
-0.0207964815,
0.0253446046,
0.0177376624,
-0.0526462942,
0.0146631133,
0.0082343379,
0.0057093631,
0.0302319117,
-0.0139166964,
-0.0206436347,
-0.0161003862,
2.673e-7,
0.0287109371,
0.0663345084,
-0.0027077293,
0.0033539461,
-0.0077435984,
0.0494906157,
-0.0009966634,
0.0307357125,
0.0075667766,
-0.004903113,
0.0345585756,
-0.0046351789,
0.0629561171,
0.0062046614,
-0.0756529793,
0.0313306637,
-0.0780525208,
0.0183847044,
-0.0155937197,
-0.0347042792,
0.04839921,
0.0442092977,
0.0025533838,
-0.0183184203,
0.0004180214,
-0.0522910282,
0.0873078778,
-0.0166354161,
-0.0138525479,
0.046131175,
0.0721918866,
0.0108052641,
-0.0084089357,
-0.0057113622,
-0.0230406839,
0.0199415628,
0.0213427246,
0.0923852921,
0.0195915662,
-0.0300583541,
0.0033589443,
0.0016986523,
0.0228854008,
-0.0513941981,
0.0594016537,
-0.028016055,
-0.0177182201,
-0.0376150981,
-0.043480821,
-0.0073860274,
0.0448621586,
-0.0374130197,
-0.0348123871,
0.0245651323,
0.0226815194,
0.0188632458,
-0.0232057832,
-0.0456320755,
-0.0573063307,
-0.0015366985,
-0.0109884115,
-0.0387677848,
-0.009955273,
0.0238656327,
0.0062003457,
-0.0709769353,
0.0261128042,
2.190511682e-34,
0.0596155971,
-0.023361465,
0.0203250609,
-0.0129576027,
0.0422123633,
0.0426115729,
-0.0269547999,
-0.0050833579,
0.0250699706,
-0.0422686115,
0.0192957222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13297v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13297v2 | OATS: Opinion Aspect Target Sentiment Quadruple Extraction Dataset for Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis | 2023-09-23T07:39:16 | 2024-03-06T16:33:41 | Siva Uday Sampreeth Chebolu, Franck Dernoncourt, Nedim Lipka, Thamar Solorio | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aspect-based sentiment analysis (ABSA) delves into understanding sentiments
specific to distinct elements within a user-generated review. It aims to
analyze user-generated reviews to determine a) the target entity being
reviewed, b) the high-level aspect to which it belongs, c) the sentiment words
used to express the opinion, and d) the sentiment expressed toward the targets
and the aspects. While various benchmark datasets have fostered advancements in
ABSA, they often come with domain limitations and data granularity challenges.
Addressing these, we introduce the OATS dataset, which encompasses three fresh
domains and consists of 27,470 sentence-level quadruples and 17,092
review-level tuples. Our initiative seeks to bridge specific observed gaps: the
recurrent focus on familiar domains like restaurants and laptops, limited data
for intricate quadruple extraction tasks, and an occasional oversight of the
synergy between sentence and review-level sentiments. Moreover, to elucidate
OATS's potential and shed light on various ABSA subtasks that OATS can solve,
we conducted experiments, establishing initial baselines. We hope the OATS
dataset augments current resources, paving the way for an encompassing
exploration of ABSA (https://github.com/RiTUAL-UH/OATS-ABSA). | [
0.0288210567,
0.0931548625,
0.0194770433,
0.0504581928,
-0.014611735,
0.000931704,
-0.002434443,
0.0024927622,
-0.0498060547,
-0.0362958312,
-0.0546639189,
-0.0235884003,
-0.030591825,
0.0550552085,
-0.0363632441,
0.0021564246,
0.0434989147,
0.0459561609,
0.02977347,
0.0308880601,
0.0331256315,
0.0480410084,
-0.0004865302,
0.0097151967,
-0.0434278622,
-0.0336262099,
0.0458490215,
-0.0056159464,
0.0136336237,
-0.0208388846,
0.0347780213,
0.0162739009,
-0.0097523294,
-0.0084568728,
0.0000019703,
0.0177176371,
-0.0268926919,
-0.0329707116,
0.0389834009,
0.0011928921,
0.090901494,
-0.0290668663,
0.0234492179,
-0.0172620788,
-0.0442788526,
-0.0514410101,
0.0115539441,
0.0861188695,
0.0245882235,
0.0585694127,
-0.0216387846,
-0.0256561283,
-0.0501572751,
-0.0216095652,
-0.0450468212,
-0.0265978985,
-0.0329945982,
-0.0375670679,
-0.0315588266,
0.0413387343,
0.0202449821,
-0.0160477255,
-0.0090493206,
0.0124297095,
-0.0132930893,
-0.0009191374,
0.0004595243,
0.0100280689,
0.002880919,
0.0680704266,
0.037329711,
0.0058338251,
-0.0013311916,
-0.0055706915,
-0.0131614273,
-0.0049378746,
0.0215948392,
-0.0147021944,
-0.0071466081,
0.0598214716,
0.0131699741,
0.0407820903,
0.0136826076,
0.0221584551,
0.0171293262,
0.0610051379,
-0.0283463113,
-0.0242180955,
0.0141507303,
0.0725402385,
0.0077322768,
0.0096778162,
0.0010401786,
-0.0222363416,
-0.0115122385,
0.025609035,
-0.0267945305,
0.0322412886,
0.022913035,
-0.0163881779,
0.0428283699,
-0.0204036273,
-0.0469202064,
0.0386778116,
0.0255333278,
-0.0390493013,
0.032150235,
-0.0289110821,
-0.022866752,
0.0335876681,
-0.0624721013,
0.0261737425,
0.035562925,
0.0500129722,
-0.0460775904,
0.0210135952,
-0.0597811081,
-0.0349812396,
-0.0251357909,
-0.0098149506,
0.0221102573,
0.0272809528,
0.0164918918,
-0.0152447987,
-0.0234767478,
0.0690413192,
-0.0574419461,
0.0517709069,
-0.0418775566,
-0.0007302337,
-0.0167085417,
0.0052661141,
0.0256201867,
-0.0277973041,
0.0182831064,
0.0309645794,
0.0315519013,
-0.0530229844,
0.0102385497,
-0.0525245033,
-0.0029409057,
-0.0521154702,
-0.0187542867,
-0.0473859757,
0.046594318,
-0.0157963559,
-0.000868607,
-0.0267479774,
0.0196861718,
0.0381845012,
-0.0134237567,
0.0385958664,
-0.0310995467,
-0.0234690011,
-0.0778060853,
0.0098960279,
0.0639687851,
0.0313086063,
-0.0376810841,
0.0561782978,
0.0538335443,
0.0256886743,
0.0216373298,
-0.0104583818,
0.0093464088,
0.0025191428,
0.0090119243,
0.0023634806,
-0.059013024,
-0.0317511484,
0.0335203335,
-0.0010608706,
0.0067285905,
-0.0334503613,
0.0644397959,
0.0093694106,
-0.0377735458,
0.0688422993,
-0.0086864447,
0.0005793064,
-0.0207489599,
-0.0155044366,
-0.0118950326,
0.0245134793,
-0.0023380574,
-0.0211541299,
0.0071880748,
0.032859154,
-0.0053036548,
-0.0520208441,
-0.0084458059,
-0.0158409737,
-0.0224604942,
-0.0392682068,
0.0601882339,
0.0088082189,
-0.0243590549,
-0.0213013384,
0.0554108992,
-0.0447148718,
-0.0219396669,
-0.0096419575,
0.0472128615,
0.0392236598,
0.0057614497,
-0.0332880095,
0.0137755759,
-0.0079358444,
-0.0273569543,
0.0123877041,
0.035322167,
-0.0240826812,
0.0162052978,
-0.0194482449,
0.0083747786,
-0.0345309041,
0.0153734647,
-0.0236257166,
0.0173870418,
0.0381762013,
-0.0247718878,
-0.0105894925,
0.0303101409,
-0.0097168041,
0.0441143215,
-0.0172301736,
0.032527674,
0.0023999463,
0.0221963488,
0.0579234026,
-0.0010516916,
-0.0165764559,
0.0204427578,
-0.0435172096,
-0.0560023598,
0.0214383714,
-0.0029384545,
-0.0192071982,
0.0226115528,
-0.0149063151,
-0.0309087131,
0.0248719212,
-0.0408454426,
-0.0059420113,
0.0359229296,
0.0337314457,
0.0036330984,
-0.00073925,
-0.0360824354,
0.0400088355,
0.0402700715,
0.0004981702,
0.067967616,
-0.0279300641,
-0.0181017183,
-0.0586434416,
-0.0730865598,
0.0011069911,
0.0602428317,
-0.0355002731,
-0.0257369466,
0.006625765,
0.0145997843,
0.0076767835,
0.0334092081,
-0.0380818173,
-0.0119052976,
-0.0775392875,
0.0026338366,
0.003918821,
0.0513246544,
0.0327383392,
-0.0025953755,
0.0030367335,
0.0331170671,
-0.037626937,
-0.0058181281,
-0.0230707321,
0.0113698477,
0.0412474275,
0.0119072301,
0.0469104722,
-0.0425686538,
-0.0147878015,
-0.0264165457,
0.0105983149,
0.0006322766,
-0.0386598632,
-0.0155085744,
0.0251545608,
-0.0177502465,
-0.0077492944,
0.0039435229,
-0.0129233655,
-0.0221879166,
-0.0135495421,
-0.0169999879,
-0.0019390759,
-0.0179269873,
0.0569193773,
0.0206698012,
-0.000373704,
-0.0070377095,
0.0316447616,
-0.0678638294,
0.0186293498,
0.0172980577,
-0.0080341632,
0.0296184868,
0.0583903529,
0.0010849464,
-0.0168012846,
-0.0066391565,
0.0293084737,
-0.0297681596,
0.0086637856,
-0.0090348031,
0.0359206088,
0.0200757124,
0.0262774173,
-0.0028055131,
-0.0017581965,
0.0587969013,
0.0202006847,
0.02203702,
-0.0581976436,
0.0162356813,
-0.0441609509,
0.0718425214,
-0.0447564647,
0.0032651995,
0.0043919045,
0.038465064,
0.0353287831,
-0.0169246327,
-0.0416080207,
-0.020241579,
0.066832833,
-0.0204297919,
-0.0055738674,
0.0063857795,
-0.0784494206,
0.0476420708,
-0.0310665704,
-0.0445492156,
-0.0119960597,
-0.019299861,
-0.029829355,
-0.0127982516,
-0.0323413946,
-0.036393553,
-0.0258737411,
-0.0173982531,
-0.0238323025,
0.0237414893,
0.0512819253,
0.0616168343,
-0.0211313535,
0.0258778445,
0.0067900014,
-0.0124974707,
0.0890502334,
-0.0220888369,
-0.0154166035,
0.0122252535,
-0.0009991786,
0.0363058634,
0.0159989204,
0.0026314619,
-0.0603765771,
0.0891196728,
-0.0460868292,
-0.0442492403,
0.0774817392,
0.0271541923,
-0.069942221,
0.013365428,
0.0095989723,
-0.0194625873,
0.0242338143,
0.0037419184,
-0.1045992002,
-0.0542365573,
-0.0604095645,
0.0280885752,
0.0005924629,
-0.0129101351,
-0.013270569,
-0.1227290332,
0.0269995723,
-0.0358738825,
-0.0332888998,
-0.0732630268,
-0.0172930621,
0.0210166741,
-0.0380854048,
0.0148179056,
-0.0391359963,
-0.0086125005,
0.015376932,
-0.0158567429,
-0.0013417574,
-0.0048464974,
0.0892828703,
-0.018100746,
0.029634295,
0.0334788971,
0.0413438529,
0.0038426025,
-0.0128565766,
0.0141898394,
-0.0927358195,
-0.0114217214,
-0.0334315524,
0.0692749247,
-0.0264431909,
-0.0420456417,
-0.0041351281,
0.0324329212,
-0.1130620018,
0.0061862986,
0.0012883567,
0.0316675864,
0.0152004929,
-0.0209869612,
-0.0378253423,
0.0359725691,
0.0198771395,
0.0396540388,
0.0034631819,
-0.0740614608,
-0.0328038856,
-0.0036141763,
-0.0426155813,
-0.0714372471,
-0.0335034728,
-0.0294283889,
-0.0101486389,
-0.0207483601,
-0.0766050741,
-0.0702911094,
0.019431619,
0.0408036858,
-0.0104518393,
-0.0117878169,
0.0251964275,
0.0176319368,
-0.0373132303,
0.0323623382,
-0.0071902154,
-0.0054259319,
0.0058055241,
-0.0327028446,
0.0796108693,
-0.0048035136,
-0.0168022867,
0.0184918195,
-0.0368443392,
-0.0131807905,
-0.0206237268,
0.0449676402,
0.0149644427,
0.0294624735,
-0.01779815,
0.0029996659,
-0.0144372182,
0.0282916836,
-0.02541757,
-0.0170553401,
0.0447919704,
0.0475989841,
0.0263604093,
0.0520265996,
0.0095281862,
0.0459549949,
0.0304043554,
-0.0143485563,
-0.0342986248,
-0.012514282,
0.0157732517,
-0.0219257046,
0.0605161376,
0.0347412154,
0.0248714332,
-0.0461516343,
-0.0002237746,
-0.0348404087,
-0.0268619768,
-0.0463451333,
0.0062422594,
0.0036667807,
-0.0031754116,
-0.0856374875,
0.032763049,
0.0000043219,
0.06966988,
-0.0472547337,
0.0464474112,
0.0114370584,
0.0117431385,
-0.0512639359,
-0.0093586724,
-0.0100357402,
-0.0060044979,
-0.0201916359,
0.0084197987,
-0.0316002928,
0.0401974805,
0.0062410799,
0.0343590155,
-0.0344935656,
0.0438557826,
0.0073179672,
0.0746920109,
-0.0184800513,
-0.044174064,
-0.028628109,
-0.057134673,
0.0699302629,
-0.0392874554,
-0.0051074661,
0.024440581,
0.0291630346,
-0.0385789014,
0.0121323047,
0.0279806051,
0.0171085838,
-0.0255856868,
-0.0134086208,
0.0811799988,
-0.1211233959,
0.0250261724,
0.0667495206,
0.0021945038,
-0.0219023563,
-0.0002779427,
0.0008212966,
-0.0034648727,
0.0320336781,
0.0163210612,
-0.0605139248,
-0.0247489344,
0.0161746517,
-0.0131337922,
0.0288149137,
0.0182385631,
-0.0011409986,
0.0534110479,
0.0470891669,
0.0289402865,
-0.0571366474,
-0.0344283395,
-0.0207496583,
-0.019285338,
0.0037415121,
-6.651628089e-33,
-0.01864429,
-0.0023849329,
-0.0326906219,
0.0077168788,
-0.0046095815,
0.0099607473,
0.0044662328,
0.0323993228,
0.0000184572,
0.0466646217,
0.0019044232,
0.0274057724,
0.0046060975,
0.0394104049,
0.0371487886,
-0.004495379,
0.0334048904,
-0.0227107462,
0.0009737002,
0.0486094505,
0.0514775477,
-0.0067180512,
0.0669836625,
-0.1047201455,
0.0200566519,
0.0146332989,
-0.0627981424,
-0.0039768429,
-0.0032757982,
0.0515998267,
-0.0331174694,
0.0791628435,
0.043231301,
-0.0275657102,
0.0134883281,
-0.006888133,
-0.0535655245,
-0.0121276928,
0.0008739826,
-0.0225894004,
-0.0050250846,
-0.0440705158,
-0.0069768974,
0.0270861406,
-0.0062130117,
-0.0144844176,
0.0072054472,
-0.0462522767,
0.0091199828,
-0.0915360004,
-0.0383593775,
0.0239929799,
-0.0035925398,
0.003593114,
0.0158975814,
0.0140292421,
0.0166533682,
0.0210430734,
-0.0410116129,
0.0242903065,
-0.0524611697,
0.0349548236,
-0.0126294531,
-0.0630003065,
-0.0148356706,
0.0795408711,
-0.0084872404,
0.0099250972,
-0.0097510619,
0.0546812266,
-0.0228528194,
0.0508443825,
-0.0022236814,
0.0424576551,
0.0353730395,
-0.0471165739,
-0.0471636504,
0.0221688636,
0.0495735668,
-0.0446142145,
0.0581980422,
-0.0211686995,
-0.0332961753,
0.015552327,
0.069941543,
-0.0389857255,
-0.0462979935,
-0.018167356,
-0.0166378636,
0.0170567147,
-0.0326897278,
0.0225987416,
-0.0367809087,
-0.0446860455,
-0.0140660256,
0.0190250501,
-0.0427080095,
0.0183462035,
0.0042559719,
-0.0148796504,
-0.046149306,
-0.027694786,
-0.0593576133,
0.0477092043,
0.0306226648,
-0.0034819986,
0.0902874842,
0.0109012024,
-0.1048424542,
-0.0106929783,
-0.028260963,
0.0542607382,
-0.0235230904,
0.0552800149,
0.0129610198,
-0.0054574949,
-0.0228437204,
0.1062868759,
0.0140368948,
0.0527114421,
-0.0159946885,
0.0305555314,
0.0042641419,
-0.000624755,
0.0044776769,
-0.0412555262,
0.0014439343,
-0.0677042827,
-0.0351199023,
-0.0412013493,
-0.022209011,
-0.0057443739,
2.625e-7,
0.0554527603,
0.0625135377,
0.0030389891,
-0.0004603169,
0.0060267928,
0.0488225818,
0.0119480584,
0.0281834286,
-0.0394104086,
-0.0027585709,
0.0273499638,
0.0027052967,
0.0082538705,
0.0398791917,
-0.0533771068,
0.0649483949,
-0.0060529374,
-0.0159276091,
-0.0303335842,
-0.0071348436,
0.0815425292,
0.0955346599,
0.0300246924,
-0.0113003971,
-0.0147395162,
0.0400632843,
0.029001208,
-0.0196563248,
-0.0381443128,
0.0020235064,
-0.0135146277,
-0.014569818,
-0.028200293,
-0.0495064817,
-0.0291397441,
0.0324063227,
-0.0007749143,
0.062258672,
0.0355989076,
-0.0755153,
0.0499633662,
0.0122680245,
0.0196447931,
0.0081122443,
0.0501289442,
-0.0291005,
-0.0668371767,
-0.0765908957,
0.0063220472,
0.0438192189,
0.0222284738,
-0.0094794892,
-0.0056392616,
0.0410375372,
-0.0148095135,
-0.0443337858,
-0.0679861382,
-0.0841962323,
0.004472333,
0.0595457442,
-0.0038559122,
-0.0156405307,
0.0254105367,
0.0250950437,
-0.0086729992,
-0.0513253659,
-0.0045509385,
2.141751166e-34,
0.0475713983,
-0.0122865243,
-0.0037883325,
0.006846332,
0.0214735921,
-0.0237836912,
-0.061929848,
-0.0432699732,
-0.0018355381,
-0.0057140007,
0.0311102774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13272v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13272v1 | Natural Language Processing for Requirements Formalization: How to Derive New Approaches? | 2023-09-23T05:45:19 | 2023-09-23T05:45:19 | Viju Sudhi, Libin Kutty, Robin Gröpler | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL, 68T50, 68N30, I.2.7; D.2.1 | It is a long-standing desire of industry and research to automate the
software development and testing process as much as possible. In this process,
requirements engineering (RE) plays a fundamental role for all other steps that
build on it. Model-based design and testing methods have been developed to
handle the growing complexity and variability of software systems. However,
major effort is still required to create specification models from a large set
of functional requirements provided in natural language. Numerous approaches
based on natural language processing (NLP) have been proposed in the literature
to generate requirements models using mainly syntactic properties. Recent
advances in NLP show that semantic quantities can also be identified and used
to provide better assistance in the requirements formalization process. In this
work, we present and discuss principal ideas and state-of-the-art methodologies
from the field of NLP in order to guide the readers on how to create a set of
rules and methods for the semi-automated formalization of requirements
according to their specific use case and needs. We discuss two different
approaches in detail and highlight the iterative development of rule sets. The
requirements models are represented in a human- and machine-readable format in
the form of pseudocode. The presented methods are demonstrated on two
industrial use cases from the automotive and railway domains. It shows that
using current pre-trained NLP models requires less effort to create a set of
rules and can be easily adapted to specific use cases and domains. In addition,
findings and shortcomings of this research area are highlighted and an outlook
on possible future developments is given. | [
0.0938905776,
-0.0080543412,
-0.0223843884,
0.013260901,
-0.0267756246,
-0.0432182215,
-0.0591523051,
-0.0005079223,
-0.0128048901,
-0.0711727962,
0.0603411309,
0.0065181479,
0.0047890898,
0.0607677139,
-0.0037165536,
-0.0635818988,
0.0177013762,
0.0359485894,
-0.0171851665,
0.0888215303,
0.0296094641,
0.0453033596,
-0.0162364747,
0.0381889045,
-0.0414441638,
-0.0311216004,
-0.0126488423,
0.0055902796,
0.0096956659,
-0.0352942571,
-0.0006422306,
0.0491648652,
-0.0009818104,
-0.0481146835,
0.0000019656,
-0.0720769539,
-0.0593635142,
0.0066950903,
0.0053371033,
0.0298337433,
0.0459196307,
0.0034471357,
-0.0185842756,
0.0254648421,
-0.0176491123,
0.0023765867,
0.0279828962,
0.0626641363,
0.0756048039,
0.0378739536,
-0.0344283581,
-0.0074709514,
0.0020776149,
0.0255580787,
-0.0038741354,
-0.0171331782,
0.0211098921,
0.040549811,
0.0663756579,
-0.000288757,
0.0307838377,
-0.0019146092,
0.0382400602,
-0.0031862112,
0.0260926411,
-0.0060793119,
-0.0292310528,
-0.0037351211,
-0.035929542,
0.0177682936,
0.0135044614,
0.0083100917,
0.005608479,
0.0038287507,
-0.028369423,
-0.017941596,
0.0226147529,
-0.005369843,
-0.0254117548,
-0.0179963801,
0.0047442396,
0.017600676,
-0.0429108888,
-0.0250766426,
0.0149169695,
0.0542184673,
-0.0083788773,
-0.0461234041,
-0.0229355376,
-0.0436702296,
-0.0206782091,
-0.028995553,
0.0435395502,
0.0098849563,
-0.0030036739,
0.0125268688,
-0.0020075417,
0.0186472069,
0.0635002479,
-0.0440602005,
0.0028900888,
-0.0435316637,
0.0088293888,
0.0031662385,
-0.0108054532,
0.0306484308,
0.0171344504,
-0.0360190086,
-0.071055539,
0.0415981337,
-0.0637018681,
-0.0446196571,
-0.0625738651,
0.0495050885,
-0.0125861522,
0.0087740468,
-0.0213645287,
0.0436387658,
-0.0196262039,
0.0479876138,
-0.0015452958,
0.0124769192,
-0.0151414732,
-0.0080744326,
-0.0439308919,
-0.0425241068,
-0.0054619079,
-0.0234587807,
-0.0497116484,
0.0019244641,
0.0573495552,
0.0375207998,
-0.0046535451,
0.04489493,
-0.0073000831,
0.0518290624,
0.0632552728,
-0.0273465868,
-0.072367996,
-0.075143598,
0.0143050328,
0.0284636393,
-0.0078023742,
-0.0397968329,
-0.0475965962,
-0.0048114974,
-0.0197494496,
0.0165343359,
-0.0093824407,
0.0380776003,
0.0451480187,
0.0472391136,
-0.0286167543,
0.016135592,
0.0048061158,
-0.007809205,
0.0610842034,
0.0342837647,
0.0369838551,
-0.0011007028,
0.0360168107,
0.0216026567,
-0.0174533576,
0.006049016,
-0.0781698152,
-0.0649418682,
-0.0078554777,
0.0494485311,
-0.0074582198,
-0.0384870172,
-0.0397547632,
0.0121737467,
0.0043413928,
0.042234391,
-0.0206726752,
0.0550783277,
0.0475815535,
-0.0113909338,
0.0638617426,
0.0957843438,
-0.0053170198,
-0.0176785737,
0.0579179488,
0.0302278437,
0.0039502461,
0.01018361,
-0.0544624515,
0.0133519322,
-0.012251717,
-0.1040001586,
-0.0134963887,
-0.039073199,
0.0380058587,
-0.0331564546,
0.0341672413,
0.0070068268,
-0.0440290906,
0.0289630573,
0.0093003912,
-0.0097521618,
-0.0140923215,
0.0121311713,
-0.0176568739,
0.093581669,
0.064641729,
-0.0841267928,
-0.0030108301,
-0.0001172108,
-0.0602618083,
0.0586587004,
0.0418933928,
-0.0450491011,
-0.0445438214,
-0.0215950161,
-0.0249109194,
-0.016072385,
-0.0164951831,
-0.0110175377,
-0.0232647378,
-0.0384552814,
0.0252076685,
0.0163346976,
-0.0536733679,
0.0679158047,
-0.0138093187,
-0.037587896,
-0.0027612252,
0.0333145484,
0.0075585763,
0.043586161,
0.0046612178,
0.0505479723,
0.0256139431,
0.0060395584,
0.0068120211,
-0.0177855771,
0.0107642608,
0.0330256186,
0.00255846,
-0.0353014618,
0.0201644991,
0.0332747959,
0.004641783,
-0.0030250857,
-0.0393666588,
-0.0147166541,
-0.0020899614,
-0.0010624795,
-0.0075168479,
-0.0114221144,
-0.0462708697,
-0.0332136825,
-0.003345801,
0.0571427457,
-0.0054741763,
-0.0345510691,
-0.065428853,
0.0527117401,
0.015604049,
-0.0449057333,
0.0060111023,
-0.03866468,
0.0491169244,
0.0397257656,
0.0598203391,
0.0038307088,
0.0301489457,
-0.0110343918,
0.0053068912,
0.0265012998,
0.0078400886,
0.0347008929,
-0.0063909246,
-0.003448654,
-0.0094505949,
0.0067454418,
-0.0321410783,
-0.057607118,
-0.0628087744,
0.0439818166,
0.0131534161,
-0.0368898138,
0.0365218818,
0.0054110596,
-0.0427179039,
0.0164233651,
0.0385190658,
0.0147475116,
-0.122108534,
0.0768539757,
-0.0144310091,
0.0193863958,
0.0044461661,
0.012025645,
0.0420487411,
0.0515599996,
0.0263344366,
0.0023249362,
-0.0173039436,
-0.0096385134,
0.0475242138,
0.0160905775,
-0.0130001977,
-0.0115481773,
-0.0159187932,
0.0740981027,
-0.0178898759,
-0.028855985,
0.0765287951,
-0.003390668,
-0.0275853891,
-0.015103722,
-0.057619784,
-0.0321542919,
-0.0304803178,
0.0422666781,
-0.0160160605,
-0.0339347161,
0.0062590698,
0.0716261715,
0.0056849611,
-0.0109953592,
0.0586937331,
-0.02302422,
0.0005984355,
-0.1041758806,
-0.0155311907,
-0.0294346567,
0.0654495358,
0.0109311985,
0.0415266789,
0.0802878737,
0.0086842328,
-0.0289316457,
-0.0147653185,
-0.0100857187,
0.0101326099,
0.0186844412,
-0.0361486785,
0.0333427154,
-0.0096961269,
0.0256973617,
-0.0459662005,
-0.0203062911,
0.0196158122,
0.0425646305,
-0.0457877778,
0.0231842957,
0.0460231267,
0.0509069152,
-0.0168112833,
0.04631247,
0.0719407126,
-0.0326145031,
-0.0375171937,
-0.0522541367,
0.0255382899,
-0.0546303876,
0.0036878202,
0.0575699545,
-0.0004185512,
0.0024087124,
-0.0105886636,
0.0437373519,
-0.0758169293,
-0.0308191497,
-0.0183114558,
-0.0667777434,
0.0297058206,
0.0605904832,
-0.0312834792,
-0.0364709496,
0.0284606889,
0.0282587335,
0.0608596019,
0.0331890285,
0.0375166871,
0.0366224423,
-0.0290299915,
0.0349237733,
0.0606453009,
-0.0512163714,
0.0224709809,
-0.0095761381,
0.0101146502,
-0.0102087203,
0.0005433757,
-0.0430925414,
-0.0722737461,
0.0276197921,
-0.0172330383,
0.0064847278,
-0.0121495035,
-0.0361719914,
-0.0328272805,
-0.0111352382,
-0.0116525562,
0.043862164,
0.0017996201,
-0.0383633189,
0.0234241113,
-0.11016725,
-0.0810627863,
0.0529172607,
-0.0077498863,
0.0142305708,
0.0614013746,
0.006338784,
0.0005429555,
-0.0188096203,
0.00227135,
0.015433765,
0.0423686467,
-0.0142007135,
-0.005479523,
-0.0022265527,
-0.0108530615,
-0.0198708065,
-0.0256982148,
-0.0888564363,
-0.0232424363,
0.038013462,
0.0837953314,
-0.0001913291,
0.0349494666,
-0.0479086116,
-0.0019421637,
0.0029281254,
0.0134602878,
-0.0219326615,
-0.0194826853,
0.0005425411,
-0.0287568625,
-0.0035617724,
-0.0554420315,
-0.0368202962,
-0.0011316935,
-0.0523417965,
-0.0215241443,
-0.0395684689,
-0.0360201001,
0.0227551702,
0.0283220597,
0.0150572434,
-0.0061553465,
0.1073537841,
-0.0337463431,
-0.0210388787,
0.0387581624,
0.0121457921,
0.0256106649,
0.0083533665,
-0.0096481964,
0.0029059362,
0.001175814,
-0.0239820853,
-0.0240298416,
0.0385986827,
-0.0115900123,
-0.0274053235,
0.048225794,
0.0135008665,
-0.0141887264,
-0.0189119224,
-0.0349970274,
-0.0365469716,
-0.0146270944,
-0.0256636441,
-0.0493897721,
0.0020593258,
-0.0111379437,
-0.0017338515,
-0.0188628975,
-0.0068967408,
0.0366224051,
-0.0642009526,
0.0324709527,
0.0398306102,
0.012056293,
0.0697779357,
0.0255903583,
-0.0240903627,
-0.012775233,
-0.0107023166,
-0.0009500755,
-0.0071708178,
-0.0330569483,
-0.0337151438,
-0.0528637916,
0.0462092683,
-0.0278509483,
-0.0019005459,
0.0312270634,
-0.0546285212,
-0.070291087,
0.0112305945,
0.0301007871,
0.0453062952,
0.0327482335,
0.0356739499,
0.0071700914,
-0.0594093204,
0.0151575208,
-0.0291309766,
-0.0440215059,
-0.0077845831,
0.0047594891,
-0.0033743265,
0.0028838983,
0.0235735271,
-0.0562880747,
0.0064448263,
0.0328670256,
-0.0063220565,
-0.0289577674,
-0.0271479692,
-0.0265852697,
0.0406993404,
-0.0372961052,
-0.0790233091,
0.0307864361,
0.0083050858,
0.0256913435,
0.0000952625,
-0.0069778929,
-0.0095902523,
0.0546687692,
-0.0129323732,
-0.0521742217,
0.0233324878,
-0.0001045521,
-0.0263404194,
-0.0368744954,
-0.0552043952,
-0.0738891214,
0.0029535717,
-0.007349079,
-0.0124975424,
-0.0741957426,
0.0168536156,
-0.0557360128,
-0.0477454178,
0.0134185385,
0.0300374161,
0.0484287366,
-0.0036724261,
0.0073013217,
0.0260122083,
0.0327945836,
-0.0333865471,
0.0131697003,
-0.0894558579,
-0.031139072,
0.0063742297,
-0.0219241343,
-5.342233911e-33,
0.0060294946,
-0.0278483815,
0.0593296774,
-0.004903134,
0.0399320461,
0.0078073768,
0.0119883353,
-0.0515755564,
0.0395004079,
-0.0405099802,
0.0283748619,
-0.0149082914,
0.0014741834,
-0.0255488325,
0.0339133218,
0.0143185053,
0.0291336123,
-0.0493999273,
-0.0121302372,
-0.0403631963,
0.0192851648,
-0.0360014178,
0.0652782023,
-0.0390109606,
0.0629652888,
-0.024730118,
-0.033952482,
0.0358518884,
0.0155612305,
0.0632447153,
-0.0218387637,
0.0712689236,
0.0419986248,
-0.0306582358,
-0.0032131511,
0.0549160875,
-0.0191805921,
-0.0609748475,
0.0138218757,
-0.0042909444,
0.0013813556,
0.0180420671,
0.0574624538,
-0.0400073566,
-0.0353485607,
0.0760650486,
0.0558510572,
0.0122089284,
0.0372533798,
-0.0015034557,
-0.0662242547,
0.0078823594,
-0.0413554348,
-0.0166835673,
0.0459045246,
0.0571181476,
0.0081282156,
-0.0507338382,
0.0181990657,
0.0044894945,
0.0196116231,
0.0234901663,
0.0405019447,
-0.0289643444,
0.0013401262,
0.0064449245,
-0.0259616245,
0.0298351869,
0.0141464751,
-0.0121001406,
0.0022155161,
0.0453102067,
-0.0132803041,
-0.030996006,
0.0495150127,
-0.0008656288,
-0.0368096009,
0.0501207784,
-0.0547069795,
0.0598318912,
0.0299443398,
-0.0219622049,
-0.0589917451,
-0.0226445999,
0.0252281129,
0.0203836914,
0.0090848189,
-0.0183595959,
0.035627339,
0.029952446,
-0.0346128084,
0.0492477342,
-0.0282214303,
-0.0306029133,
-0.0347794667,
-0.0195001289,
0.0122278342,
-0.0054314914,
-0.0456624106,
0.0125326319,
0.0326012596,
-0.0309426356,
0.0333490111,
-0.0299272221,
0.0320526883,
0.0016249411,
0.0066870409,
0.0159102827,
-0.030840572,
0.0330680944,
0.0009849255,
-0.0254168473,
-0.0016652332,
0.0540288761,
0.0074096303,
0.0179563127,
-0.0173411053,
-0.0048829392,
0.0012501637,
-0.079873234,
-0.0369992554,
0.0577020012,
0.0027111177,
-0.0067368438,
0.0149068767,
-0.0185977966,
-0.0172981508,
0.0282091498,
0.0589571483,
0.0602270514,
-0.0301441196,
0.0061566574,
2.744e-7,
0.015657885,
0.014892973,
0.0054040872,
0.0427720957,
-0.0368609838,
0.0098292418,
0.0217009,
-0.0341584794,
-0.0250170007,
-0.014324151,
-0.0017970765,
-0.0312808119,
0.0090464391,
0.0171933118,
-0.0822410807,
-0.0011981255,
0.0564814061,
-0.0056436281,
-0.0804087743,
0.0344297923,
0.1185607389,
0.0108953342,
0.0058536348,
-0.0081098992,
-0.037735492,
-0.0323817283,
-0.0450715795,
-0.027485108,
0.0311079696,
0.0495671108,
0.0500841103,
0.012349003,
0.0139833363,
0.0667394698,
0.000088019,
0.0063613672,
-0.0188565366,
0.0422360934,
-0.0283814538,
0.0313650817,
0.0358525291,
-0.0395137742,
-0.0054692822,
0.0068071145,
-0.004927536,
-0.0156496596,
-0.0240835864,
-0.0326560475,
-0.0539125279,
-0.0038100583,
-0.0454680249,
-0.0024270476,
0.0080265719,
-0.0282332934,
-0.0223425981,
-0.0335555524,
-0.0327784494,
-0.0475055575,
0.021629883,
0.0624207929,
-0.0074347383,
-0.0046078032,
-0.0051577627,
0.0268657543,
0.0580423139,
-0.0236218199,
0.0421717688,
2.468567294e-34,
-0.0058483477,
-0.0023532447,
0.0096279625,
0.0331735909,
0.0265201572,
0.0283064265,
-0.0614378564,
0.0201202277,
-0.0081926808,
-0.0356521085,
-0.0310859121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13249v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13249v1 | A Survey of Document-Level Information Extraction | 2023-09-23T04:18:24 | 2023-09-23T04:18:24 | Hanwen Zheng, Sijia Wang, Lifu Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document-level information extraction (IE) is a crucial task in natural
language processing (NLP). This paper conducts a systematic review of recent
document-level IE literature. In addition, we conduct a thorough error analysis
with current state-of-the-art algorithms and identify their limitations as well
as the remaining challenges for the task of document-level IE. According to our
findings, labeling noises, entity coreference resolution, and lack of
reasoning, severely affect the performance of document-level IE. The objective
of this survey paper is to provide more insights and help NLP researchers to
further enhance document-level IE performance. | [
0.0787362605,
0.0210040119,
0.0244426019,
0.0327378139,
-0.0584976338,
0.0262239743,
-0.0204345528,
0.0221654791,
0.0318747647,
-0.0677374825,
-0.0023048294,
0.0359941684,
-0.0007631382,
-0.0226963181,
-0.0178299639,
-0.031485904,
0.035511151,
-0.0043976912,
0.0629620403,
0.0403239615,
0.0242768414,
0.0165811609,
-0.0159116015,
-0.025874719,
-0.0322876051,
-0.0086681591,
0.0195829142,
-0.0072749811,
0.0231895726,
-0.020915674,
0.0056120786,
-0.0068202745,
-0.0391186662,
0.0269540325,
0.0000018383,
-0.048505526,
-0.0874265134,
0.0535334274,
-0.0385102071,
-0.0176429208,
0.014712452,
-0.025450252,
-0.0459322855,
-0.036038544,
0.0015093606,
-0.0135987038,
-0.0023064821,
0.0831979364,
-0.0020724509,
0.0524249077,
-0.0284695197,
-0.013708205,
0.0490026809,
0.0351238176,
0.0110076964,
-0.0577793606,
0.0255934261,
-0.0118161291,
0.0372968726,
-0.0024864206,
0.0379366316,
0.0138327805,
-0.0344344862,
-0.0165065117,
0.0105151357,
0.0336865522,
-0.0340879336,
-0.0111390427,
-0.015671052,
0.0625783578,
0.0501104072,
0.0626054257,
0.0549812205,
0.006239932,
-0.0189742073,
-0.0069908472,
-0.018501306,
0.0115989819,
-0.0746218339,
-0.0174031854,
0.0598354749,
0.026000211,
-0.008763372,
0.0049655382,
-0.0082887784,
0.0675911903,
0.0041031265,
-0.0677107722,
0.0801699311,
0.0147332661,
0.0292660035,
-0.0276137311,
0.048304271,
-0.0075803068,
0.0272327363,
0.0399345979,
-0.026957795,
-0.0285326187,
0.0038391019,
-0.0667774379,
-0.0070216996,
-0.0371921211,
-0.0044372478,
0.0717911422,
-0.0067201839,
-0.0043878788,
-0.0153234061,
-0.0115258517,
0.0369408317,
-0.0045963307,
-0.0211522039,
0.0136100072,
-0.0143066077,
0.0721733719,
-0.0361292735,
-0.0127576226,
-0.0090412218,
-0.0269321222,
0.0174306538,
0.0600129068,
-0.029610645,
-0.0307784807,
-0.0302889738,
-0.0303573422,
-0.0064561721,
0.0003748493,
0.0027067119,
-0.0004153647,
-0.0115917316,
0.0032296141,
0.0168350283,
0.0043372368,
0.0571388789,
-0.0169569459,
0.0272055287,
0.0531982109,
0.0116115035,
-0.0437801927,
-0.0466708317,
-0.0492708348,
-0.0089938072,
-0.0204426479,
-0.0412702486,
-0.0209073201,
0.0303632077,
0.0028988174,
-0.0125616761,
-0.055271171,
0.0161041189,
-0.0136850895,
-0.0657034889,
0.0631221384,
-0.0771014616,
-0.0325143375,
0.0343685262,
-0.0105601009,
0.0343472995,
0.0498792715,
0.0557719059,
0.0138519974,
0.0903477818,
0.0092768306,
-0.0133223506,
0.0093294326,
-0.0029297273,
-0.0727407485,
0.0763434172,
-0.0086523779,
-0.0296166092,
-0.0474766903,
-0.0024044584,
0.0480509624,
-0.0095073897,
0.0138377761,
-0.0078901555,
0.0291767754,
-0.0243229326,
-0.0156341866,
-0.0224520043,
0.0378766768,
0.0322896615,
0.04549779,
-0.0257539246,
-0.0492629334,
-0.0040960028,
0.0369300209,
0.0042947442,
0.0063963938,
0.0418960936,
-0.0214539077,
-0.0408903807,
-0.0126837427,
0.0046176412,
-0.0179054439,
0.1002499238,
-0.0054082857,
-0.0404465012,
0.0100382613,
0.0199444536,
-0.0348885581,
-0.0091309547,
0.0115115484,
-0.0278731994,
0.0166978501,
0.0442704894,
-0.0758588389,
-0.0426022634,
-0.0084190704,
-0.0035614073,
0.045487076,
0.0205354132,
-0.0438631214,
0.0399233252,
-0.0310108177,
-0.0273431521,
0.0289354771,
-0.0095704207,
-0.0432389081,
0.0047355033,
-0.0164453387,
0.0083404798,
-0.0582698658,
-0.0514021404,
0.0459011607,
-0.0203651302,
-0.0697732344,
0.0098014306,
0.0073911967,
0.0025819712,
0.0314869136,
-0.0156424697,
-0.0296252426,
0.0213438682,
-0.0012300661,
0.0196618605,
-0.0046033938,
0.0039538639,
-0.0072892983,
-0.0112330485,
-0.0228069834,
-0.0568713211,
-0.0557512827,
-0.0307285115,
-0.0015694122,
-0.0449923612,
0.0071235057,
0.0247860029,
-0.0113721639,
0.0241197832,
0.0437175557,
-0.0017695031,
-0.0497709401,
0.0653397143,
0.0291126426,
-0.0295982286,
0.0260611344,
-0.0311700962,
-0.0041398043,
-0.0122117214,
0.0099896276,
0.0332831554,
0.0047313492,
-0.0292802658,
0.0413120016,
0.0231139492,
-0.0514025874,
-0.0309816077,
-0.065341115,
0.0170382503,
0.0112068662,
0.0687899888,
-0.0056623886,
0.0186859071,
-0.0171022974,
-0.0201870855,
-0.0130398534,
-0.0079835607,
-0.0192320254,
-0.0347957052,
0.071315825,
0.0288567953,
-0.0080379546,
-0.0336759426,
0.0118427575,
-0.0281358492,
-0.0107474895,
0.0249899291,
-0.0704924986,
-0.0359368734,
0.0507615991,
0.0213991646,
0.0650482625,
0.0085817985,
0.0611027107,
-0.0226109549,
-0.0043446869,
0.0044871792,
0.0886558965,
-0.0115202991,
0.0583407767,
-0.0300289802,
-0.0550299175,
-0.0532574691,
0.0271012764,
-0.0223405287,
0.062085405,
-0.0224820562,
-0.0280508474,
0.0871019587,
0.0687586889,
-0.0300941393,
0.026379887,
0.0070344987,
-0.0025803419,
-0.0278596673,
-0.0119674262,
0.0007865271,
0.0113413259,
-0.0073803342,
0.0470370799,
-0.017247919,
0.0081524933,
0.065070495,
-0.0343604982,
-0.0073037725,
-0.0696558207,
0.0334839374,
-0.0338681936,
0.039551802,
-0.0267730691,
0.0052860738,
0.0678451359,
-0.0857198387,
0.0319754966,
-0.0192042664,
0.019710334,
0.0014923201,
0.010579206,
-0.0566878691,
0.0355124213,
-0.0300975423,
-0.0255502928,
-0.0254782792,
-0.0080773737,
0.0062572262,
-0.0137016987,
0.0273403227,
0.0084479386,
-0.0066591683,
-0.0183938164,
0.0053679948,
0.0442215204,
-0.0132486876,
-0.0315288492,
-0.0076165679,
0.0987883136,
0.016148597,
-0.0195806921,
0.0311312359,
-0.0034816645,
0.0055481405,
0.09749493,
0.0098222103,
-0.0069223829,
0.0440480262,
-0.0182598718,
0.0275912043,
-0.0753496736,
-0.0027558338,
-0.042397961,
0.0251765009,
-0.0939898342,
-0.0310315359,
0.0942482725,
0.0438621379,
-0.0060770563,
-0.046181988,
0.0024178184,
-0.0204848927,
-0.0413183831,
0.0186268985,
-0.0023472072,
-0.0279496051,
0.0332696885,
0.0395556167,
-0.0273042955,
-0.0404079817,
0.0242601596,
-0.0447054319,
0.0376510285,
-0.0335626528,
-0.00423706,
-0.0263720211,
-0.050335411,
0.035994906,
0.0097293695,
-0.0027322925,
0.0148650575,
-0.0376614369,
-0.0262839235,
0.0032936437,
-0.068005845,
-0.0524719134,
-0.0060001854,
0.0039314902,
-0.0041479934,
0.0548494048,
0.0556567013,
-0.0181192458,
0.0347137675,
0.0390156321,
-0.0348421074,
-0.0292154849,
-0.0386869274,
0.0592866875,
-0.0614992119,
0.0062745581,
-0.0174633805,
0.0282365102,
0.0066840365,
0.034463089,
0.0335573219,
0.018798802,
-0.0052957297,
-0.0169883762,
-0.0050002043,
-0.0047975709,
-0.0074917502,
0.0588060506,
-0.0053407787,
-0.014626448,
-0.0340752937,
-0.0056864982,
0.0136280926,
-0.0426880047,
0.0202542171,
0.0078681177,
-0.0687255412,
-0.0165883619,
-0.0649986342,
-0.0925543159,
0.0377229936,
-0.0038642543,
-0.0005121603,
-0.008730676,
0.0441364124,
0.0091808522,
-0.0147307059,
-0.0276529044,
0.0081373649,
-0.0278558712,
-0.0441408381,
0.0098652048,
0.0284940656,
0.0462882705,
-0.0375508144,
0.0434264019,
0.002721566,
-0.0348456539,
0.0302010532,
-0.0314477347,
0.0069079213,
0.0514616184,
-0.0139875114,
0.0082606692,
0.0137578202,
0.0176126137,
-0.0306765903,
-0.0508743078,
0.0368464328,
-0.006716087,
0.0002079204,
0.0248017851,
-0.037720263,
0.0324454531,
0.0067840144,
0.0103163403,
-0.0454013944,
-0.0276789702,
0.0185896065,
0.0455707535,
0.0317113139,
0.0083373766,
0.0146471811,
-0.0451140255,
0.0395606793,
-0.0451185517,
-0.0207099132,
-0.0122168949,
0.0053846459,
-0.0251405314,
0.012664522,
-0.010320073,
0.068752259,
-0.0046058106,
0.0189466793,
0.0255697519,
0.0269388035,
-0.0073652319,
0.0237987898,
0.0005473459,
-0.0707735866,
0.0099757398,
0.0256950203,
0.0380640067,
0.0792060792,
-0.035409119,
0.0053677582,
0.0183223151,
-0.0512256585,
0.0048756646,
0.0134994918,
-0.0290414616,
0.0354819223,
-0.0410633609,
0.0249230135,
0.0178425871,
-0.0228119604,
0.0835535601,
-0.0557563752,
-0.0129414462,
0.0313786753,
0.0111545948,
0.0384848304,
0.0390834399,
-0.0172590446,
0.0160128213,
-0.0337175764,
0.0258465074,
0.0322648846,
0.0088080103,
0.004469913,
-0.0194784589,
-0.0300852936,
-0.0661304519,
0.0174052659,
-0.0090307938,
0.0209678821,
-0.014660202,
-0.0035776151,
-0.0804500207,
0.023116257,
0.062611632,
-0.0012518449,
0.0109527912,
-0.0050420552,
0.0023812186,
0.0554728508,
0.0444634743,
-0.034012761,
-0.0422363766,
0.0160922818,
0.0116263321,
-0.0203378592,
-0.0035519947,
-6.030221e-33,
-0.0708305091,
-0.0153708085,
-0.020199623,
0.0469177924,
0.0071321018,
0.0390740447,
-0.0162585471,
-0.0220427196,
0.0217712652,
0.0314561948,
-0.0406210385,
-0.0157842673,
0.0401606001,
-0.0079556573,
-0.0377494134,
0.0326440707,
0.0264586713,
0.0122638419,
-0.01662568,
-0.0023669628,
0.0648057982,
0.0576639995,
0.1091109142,
-0.1280254424,
0.0936285257,
0.0388875827,
0.0064193099,
-0.0205472801,
0.0637843758,
0.0035737746,
-0.018213572,
0.0079465248,
0.0006225145,
-0.030883139,
0.0018829744,
0.0080354977,
-0.1509041488,
-0.0005256762,
-0.0321675912,
0.0166726205,
-0.0047751479,
-0.0062107062,
0.0227451921,
-0.0039773867,
0.002926569,
-0.0085055409,
0.0394515246,
-0.0264611803,
0.0026637884,
-0.0486824661,
-0.101919435,
0.0812349692,
0.016544316,
0.0567357428,
0.0647116378,
0.0084233442,
0.0046193143,
0.0040707993,
-0.0693605691,
-0.0486396365,
0.0011062491,
0.0247168727,
-0.0070108008,
-0.0474297628,
-0.0116124656,
0.0198967978,
0.0188110918,
-0.0036951425,
-0.0099145742,
0.0097037358,
0.0085270982,
0.0237546172,
-0.0497406833,
0.0466341749,
0.0351368897,
0.0192044005,
-0.0685294792,
0.0743856505,
0.0271462444,
0.040194314,
-0.0311707258,
-0.0363565981,
-0.1053396612,
0.0007268548,
0.0357743129,
-0.0138575956,
0.0114031332,
-0.0158416443,
-0.002852079,
-0.0042622997,
-0.0601881631,
0.0307649393,
-0.0175074786,
-0.0064353845,
-0.021038251,
-0.0120460326,
0.0008415959,
0.033982154,
-0.024404373,
-0.0286505893,
-0.0727778599,
-0.031508524,
-0.036439728,
0.0361007266,
0.022906458,
-0.010687693,
0.0183791928,
-0.0332747735,
-0.0610744804,
0.0008453495,
0.0059806481,
0.0344813503,
-0.0127433958,
0.0272781532,
0.0032295764,
-0.021247182,
0.0015216018,
0.0215193201,
0.0341273099,
0.0409320481,
-0.0204991829,
-0.0088455817,
0.0230181292,
0.0253742058,
0.0210474525,
-0.0069877412,
0.0088105537,
-0.0133491633,
-0.0168962665,
0.007727508,
0.0270155519,
-0.0064310445,
2.555e-7,
0.0294621158,
0.0524018556,
0.0670080557,
-0.0083917296,
-0.001399226,
0.0444372483,
0.0260138437,
-0.0109517183,
0.0044198949,
-0.0077267955,
0.0202222951,
-0.0479715206,
0.0267207418,
0.023199724,
-0.0970748737,
-0.0383455828,
0.0053511923,
-0.049851384,
-0.052875489,
-0.0004464241,
0.0133565255,
0.0254784636,
-0.016903175,
-0.0251840409,
-0.0435610004,
-0.0283682439,
0.0084813638,
-0.0053752,
-0.0062823617,
0.0532668345,
0.0681364685,
-0.0095877089,
-0.0238277111,
0.0325887129,
-0.0194259509,
0.0255341642,
0.0127616031,
0.0773805827,
-0.0197692439,
0.0229838789,
-0.0011792432,
-0.0414669067,
0.0292224903,
0.0111684185,
0.0624136515,
-0.0020378218,
-0.0367715359,
-0.0518912971,
-0.0475528836,
-0.0037499345,
-0.0520038009,
0.0023460966,
-0.0546306409,
0.0398384742,
0.002716505,
-0.0310885645,
-0.0314956345,
-0.0696402267,
0.0429802947,
0.0263353847,
0.0481424816,
-0.0202540196,
0.0520442054,
0.0084909014,
-0.0271020215,
-0.0260950904,
-0.0225495175,
2.493671216e-34,
-0.0187323578,
0.0236379653,
-0.0118541345,
0.0534598492,
0.0139064929,
0.0099434899,
-0.0267323926,
-0.0241213236,
-0.0365348756,
-0.0348938815,
0.0311127473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13243v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13243v2 | ChEDDAR: Student-ChatGPT Dialogue in EFL Writing Education | 2023-09-23T03:28:25 | 2024-03-20T08:16:14 | Jieun Han, Haneul Yoo, Junho Myung, Minsun Kim, Tak Yeon Lee, So-Yeon Ahn, Alice Oh | cs.CL | cs.CL | The integration of generative AI in education is expanding, yet empirical
analyses of large-scale, real-world interactions between students and AI
systems still remain limited. In this study, we present ChEDDAR, ChatGPT & EFL
Learner's Dialogue Dataset As Revising an essay, which is collected from a
semester-long longitudinal experiment involving 212 college students enrolled
in English as Foreign Langauge (EFL) writing courses. The students were asked
to revise their essays through dialogues with ChatGPT. ChEDDAR includes a
conversation log, utterance-level essay edit history, self-rated satisfaction,
and students' intent, in addition to session-level pre-and-post surveys
documenting their objectives and overall experiences. We analyze students'
usage patterns and perceptions regarding generative AI with respect to their
intent and satisfaction. As a foundational step, we establish baseline results
for two pivotal tasks in task-oriented dialogue systems within educational
contexts: intent detection and satisfaction estimation. We finally suggest
further research to refine the integration of generative AI into education
settings, outlining potential scenarios utilizing ChEDDAR. ChEDDAR is publicly
available at https://github.com/zeunie/ChEDDAR. | [
0.0558665916,
0.0231567342,
-0.0288022254,
0.0011776729,
-0.0566483401,
-0.0002512737,
0.0322498195,
-0.0540240146,
0.0600724332,
-0.0482859202,
-0.0354028232,
-0.0118921995,
0.001450071,
0.0452061035,
0.0020284371,
-0.0167820863,
0.0054617189,
0.0179143976,
0.0409135744,
0.0289826337,
0.0351876728,
0.0302716177,
-0.0541009642,
0.0872910768,
-0.035532333,
-0.0659506917,
-0.0441700779,
-0.008352302,
0.0207283646,
0.0141851436,
0.0550895855,
0.0736047849,
-0.0135387946,
0.049246259,
0.0000020938,
-0.0578434654,
-0.0050120722,
-0.0349455178,
-0.0279465932,
-0.0060162642,
0.0342436954,
0.0729592144,
-0.0415004119,
0.0081501417,
-0.0712252259,
0.0422419906,
0.0513876863,
0.0381810442,
0.0373115651,
0.0610857047,
-0.0166126471,
-0.0357892513,
0.0356850252,
0.0171922892,
0.0303847436,
0.0166763011,
-0.0113937445,
0.0012234219,
0.0005938928,
-0.0141250566,
-0.025637662,
0.0481196567,
0.0063295136,
-0.1095955446,
0.0198622681,
0.0169015359,
-0.0126934107,
-0.0275067482,
0.0221111141,
0.0446635112,
0.0657196045,
-0.0078791622,
-0.0110809188,
-0.0102136917,
0.0335062854,
0.0119508049,
-0.0586877987,
-0.0148751037,
-0.0326583162,
0.0006018062,
0.0003429137,
-0.0546428896,
-0.0348454788,
0.0108367885,
0.0296222586,
-0.0043477975,
-0.0091509754,
-0.0224947594,
-0.0368662477,
0.0131138954,
0.0276460666,
-0.0671049654,
-0.0016374667,
0.0547701009,
-0.0727801323,
0.0110090179,
-0.0365684219,
-0.0360294804,
0.0108872177,
0.0010108461,
0.0358807333,
0.0465567186,
0.0173800606,
0.0029805156,
0.0650299788,
0.0693584606,
0.0282344911,
0.0005357969,
-0.0294918232,
0.0208516177,
-0.0683369115,
-0.0246721059,
-0.0575381927,
0.0543858781,
0.0013890043,
-0.0331794769,
-0.0316966772,
0.0357813388,
-0.0118858526,
0.0341031887,
-0.0079109352,
0.0123857856,
-0.0434722342,
0.0352086015,
-0.0376807377,
0.0464316756,
0.0015851058,
0.006689535,
-0.0011733279,
-0.0215466302,
0.0142423734,
0.0108950371,
0.0251677558,
-0.024112625,
-0.0299178865,
0.0311150942,
-0.033796411,
-0.04484291,
-0.0091469614,
-0.0267028362,
0.0120191313,
-0.0589527078,
-0.0234968197,
-0.0378484428,
0.0222600494,
0.0096961902,
-0.0018817559,
-0.0563105829,
-0.0038219148,
0.0223821253,
0.0412068665,
0.032827124,
0.0009524957,
0.0139461728,
0.0636169836,
0.0000288559,
-0.0138478735,
0.0313915424,
0.0578899309,
0.0101037296,
0.0218217596,
-0.0163133666,
0.0510048196,
0.0121691953,
-0.0257722605,
-0.0303411912,
0.0524150543,
-0.0151715828,
-0.040647231,
0.0247055087,
-0.0270387586,
0.0407464765,
-0.0180583373,
0.0460573994,
0.0742509216,
0.0701279789,
-0.0009182607,
0.0255029816,
0.0189402625,
0.0267332289,
0.0289521627,
0.0524193086,
0.005610663,
0.0267409738,
0.0259165093,
-0.0026856873,
0.0281235576,
-0.01123349,
0.0107707623,
-0.0996982902,
0.0034702993,
0.0129028941,
-0.01797783,
0.014638382,
0.018838577,
-0.0009035252,
-0.0286354553,
-0.0498635657,
-0.0039290483,
-0.0878678486,
0.004881735,
-0.0688998401,
0.0535002351,
0.1249459386,
0.083444342,
-0.0306017268,
-0.0678429082,
-0.0427160226,
0.0061394372,
0.0224585645,
0.0195931569,
-0.0382231064,
-0.0075449455,
-0.005833799,
-0.0044360301,
-0.0676077232,
-0.0085627381,
-0.0249917395,
-0.0077939415,
0.0007034303,
-0.008399005,
0.0134443967,
-0.0660985634,
0.0178895593,
-0.0386518687,
-0.0236853287,
0.0068877889,
0.0235555358,
-0.0135191036,
0.0316741914,
-0.0336319655,
0.0022274298,
0.0017486552,
0.0046153576,
-0.0231842659,
0.0422203355,
0.0064257402,
-0.0258942097,
0.0513403267,
-0.05690597,
-0.0212544054,
0.0041542524,
-0.0045758942,
-0.0429781638,
0.0238367505,
-0.046973139,
0.0225417018,
-0.032173831,
0.0203035697,
-0.0229486059,
-0.027070269,
-0.0281504989,
-0.0101786703,
0.0283450987,
-0.0084148962,
0.026598772,
0.0360163786,
0.0161728878,
-0.0147555545,
-0.0098367799,
0.0158465877,
0.0113565195,
0.0047565363,
0.0156394597,
0.0153004387,
-0.0696983412,
-0.0309235826,
-0.1114738956,
0.0038355172,
-0.0002661981,
-0.001073661,
0.0444808416,
-0.0062606749,
-0.0082116397,
0.0213909261,
-0.0424906537,
-0.0169096384,
0.0108900378,
-0.0323706307,
0.0484395437,
-0.0251509417,
0.0219952632,
-0.0485319532,
0.0222221818,
-0.023710018,
-0.011599903,
0.0902334303,
-0.0448721126,
-0.0347579606,
0.0394500121,
-0.0196771249,
-0.0125074545,
-0.0108200097,
-0.0521802641,
0.0465960801,
-0.0099437358,
0.113284573,
0.071349062,
0.0315039121,
0.07104785,
0.0427386872,
-0.0338116996,
-0.0581099391,
0.0339242816,
0.0057320967,
-0.0009211508,
-0.0067386017,
-0.0562695935,
0.0067175548,
0.0192756113,
0.0258816481,
-0.0208272617,
-0.0223200507,
0.0473186821,
-0.0096917935,
0.0101081533,
-0.0170219149,
-0.0003701031,
-0.0268265903,
0.0234093145,
-0.0098192152,
-0.0421211608,
0.0560656637,
0.0230488647,
-0.0259296652,
-0.0429721475,
-0.001188782,
-0.015776759,
0.058222685,
-0.0193188395,
0.0179358013,
0.0168480091,
0.0064154603,
-0.0328929648,
0.0296918303,
0.0438748971,
-0.0331082568,
0.0248949584,
-0.0546208993,
0.0044416063,
-0.0045552142,
-0.0010063918,
-0.0548533946,
-0.0158014204,
0.0140782129,
-0.0113470871,
0.0472226925,
-0.0461615026,
0.0023077484,
-0.0368699729,
0.0093208514,
0.0521167442,
-0.0327355675,
-0.0417419225,
-0.0146421632,
0.0174113456,
0.0645408928,
-0.0261764638,
-0.0301134419,
-0.0057954276,
0.086437799,
0.0479220413,
-0.0001937398,
-0.014597401,
0.0002045617,
-0.0478792191,
0.0217168648,
-0.0220528971,
0.009182428,
-0.0056420565,
0.0596990399,
-0.0358305164,
-0.0472190976,
0.1151694879,
0.0271872766,
-0.0338936895,
-0.028926665,
-0.0258071199,
0.0079950336,
-0.0070261606,
0.0376504883,
-0.0701108277,
0.0029652789,
-0.0080842059,
0.0259609036,
-0.0577097796,
-0.0172219276,
-0.0219399352,
-0.0659526363,
0.0845095962,
-0.026721064,
0.0042258338,
0.0213180371,
0.0010314597,
0.0070423712,
0.0071842112,
-0.0031647801,
-0.0338598154,
0.0126443915,
0.0204410478,
0.0126204304,
-0.0180724878,
-0.0044086077,
-0.0202713907,
0.0010552045,
0.0612281784,
0.0389016457,
0.0836124271,
0.0096234279,
-0.0355405584,
0.04130226,
0.0566713661,
-0.0091014216,
0.0094433967,
0.0482086465,
-0.0042120973,
0.0210568346,
-0.0355018862,
0.0241316296,
-0.0043724314,
-0.0341176763,
0.0723766685,
0.0418092422,
-0.0691429973,
0.0104623381,
-0.0139139034,
0.0245089494,
0.0270721074,
0.0463568345,
0.0454346016,
-0.0549838021,
-0.0336275138,
-0.0453553684,
0.0154552506,
-0.0506394729,
-0.0005097379,
-0.0235923212,
-0.0104554975,
0.0077015911,
-0.0355556421,
-0.0965523645,
0.0491283014,
0.0034917153,
0.0135837328,
0.0238610413,
0.0139552187,
0.0138312606,
-0.0229250696,
-0.0326077975,
0.0145530114,
0.0164266974,
-0.0604777373,
-0.0876394659,
-0.0168427639,
-0.0305163302,
0.003959578,
0.0285231527,
-0.0771309882,
-0.0564042255,
0.0008671106,
0.0492205657,
0.0137800835,
0.0147555033,
0.0102760578,
-0.0139708361,
-0.0317669697,
0.0190171506,
0.0242168419,
0.0088952696,
0.0153402304,
0.0383254774,
-0.0055481386,
0.0035167304,
0.022168735,
-0.0141292233,
0.0147350412,
0.0203521792,
-0.0141096814,
-0.0527585149,
0.0321081318,
0.0304994471,
0.0078883255,
-0.0150743332,
-0.0301443934,
-0.0861765519,
0.008938442,
-0.044040408,
-0.039993573,
-0.0500852279,
-0.0462469049,
0.0053244191,
0.0105342604,
0.0045690136,
0.0270865615,
-0.0643725693,
0.0269206855,
-0.0331856385,
0.02740895,
-0.005928867,
0.0292592086,
0.0173845422,
-0.0193807241,
-0.0093706194,
0.036034327,
0.0274599418,
0.0450552702,
0.0290473308,
0.0940863118,
0.0215253439,
-0.007665317,
0.0845214799,
0.0468111113,
-0.0704809502,
-0.0337649435,
-0.010287039,
0.0184569769,
0.0259748027,
0.0285768267,
0.0463917479,
-0.0306360833,
0.0261054616,
-0.0174573679,
0.0754669532,
0.0086167669,
-0.0541362539,
-0.0412216112,
-0.0102873817,
-0.0008111867,
-0.0238974821,
0.0462537967,
-0.0730160996,
0.0239768866,
-0.0018577452,
-0.0155931469,
-0.0405078791,
-0.045339115,
-0.0076941964,
-0.0076759919,
0.0397000797,
-0.0090495981,
-0.0251275543,
-0.03024037,
-0.0117546245,
0.0137044434,
-0.0056332219,
-0.0472672097,
0.0060459697,
0.040623311,
-0.0371387899,
-0.0005037473,
-0.0555878133,
0.0406320021,
-0.0288674366,
-0.0393581577,
-0.0628019273,
-5.579926216e-33,
-0.0242945943,
-0.0716572031,
0.0347109735,
0.0663919374,
-0.02601441,
-0.0030549683,
-0.0502549037,
0.0249001291,
0.0243530869,
0.0240075253,
-0.019906966,
0.0356214233,
-0.0183137357,
0.0348620526,
0.0182466116,
-0.0081956303,
0.056328807,
0.003475344,
-0.0061013266,
0.0317831449,
0.0188125465,
0.0034023104,
0.0434161797,
-0.0475653559,
0.0574386753,
-0.0483462811,
-0.0139842695,
-0.0113227153,
-0.0448724926,
0.0269070771,
-0.0204469133,
0.0503462628,
0.0192623194,
-0.0035446456,
0.0053237765,
0.0087600006,
-0.0276748314,
-0.0619258843,
-0.0099426499,
0.014881202,
-0.0376197062,
-0.0374940932,
0.0069231968,
-0.0108170705,
-0.0464810804,
-0.0083599053,
0.0597067624,
0.032408867,
0.039600417,
-0.0118992086,
-0.1006128713,
-0.0091581689,
-0.060304299,
-0.0621118844,
-0.0298810527,
0.0563181378,
0.0343909897,
-0.0893576518,
-0.0288429186,
0.0421545617,
0.0123068336,
-0.0147365835,
0.0312640518,
-0.011482561,
-0.0080510508,
0.0430733785,
0.0485549867,
0.0391606092,
-0.0352751054,
-0.0168232154,
0.0053660674,
-0.0175572615,
0.0168982688,
0.0584775135,
-0.038569767,
-0.0175231714,
-0.0143106561,
0.0645195767,
0.0452970043,
-0.0029997854,
-0.0037587739,
-0.0171641801,
-0.0131459227,
-0.0302934907,
-0.0062301792,
-0.0138447126,
-0.0036963089,
-0.0238182042,
0.0268582292,
-0.0430762805,
0.0257363599,
-0.0493179299,
-0.0147956675,
-0.0234030876,
-0.0145115582,
0.0386333801,
-0.0585265309,
0.0461334735,
-0.0263961852,
-0.0198749471,
0.0023933309,
0.0242449138,
0.0160604268,
0.0356362425,
0.0401924215,
0.0232908558,
0.0323485248,
0.0309293214,
-0.0196677241,
0.0002474799,
-0.0545188412,
0.0601178147,
0.0084814085,
-0.0362375304,
0.0154531216,
0.0064218729,
-0.0287550557,
0.0349703543,
0.0357846096,
0.0157282855,
-0.0851657242,
-0.0315616056,
-0.0093922308,
-0.0465980992,
-0.0286784843,
0.0089001087,
-0.0200273972,
0.0182690956,
0.0004144141,
-0.0410866216,
-0.0061384393,
-0.0540895052,
2.79e-7,
0.0314113051,
0.0357064418,
0.0258071925,
0.0137787731,
-0.0000629221,
0.0165121369,
-0.0072691287,
-0.007047269,
0.0490634218,
0.0601259656,
0.0269893855,
0.0122331791,
0.03042005,
0.0403718203,
-0.0865491405,
-0.0057450477,
-0.0296067242,
-0.0280602295,
-0.0310051516,
0.0557837151,
0.1158208176,
-0.0214462001,
0.0320994817,
-0.0221285671,
0.0027295093,
0.0188474208,
0.0028209146,
-0.017390579,
0.0104064699,
0.0388123989,
0.0087336879,
-0.0410414152,
0.0343737788,
0.0155228395,
-0.006729254,
-0.038572114,
-0.0110445097,
0.0539580397,
-0.0067899642,
-0.0233600531,
0.0328376815,
0.0360564962,
0.0219121706,
-0.0569859557,
0.0504582226,
-0.01218988,
0.0019512565,
-0.0322535709,
0.0021205496,
-0.0277428105,
0.0214920789,
-0.0249912981,
-0.0079323221,
0.0070403335,
0.0013830921,
-0.0183891356,
0.040631257,
-0.019876726,
-0.0006945085,
-0.0305004511,
-0.0247367024,
-0.0181198493,
-0.0348332636,
-0.025942184,
-0.0101436963,
-0.0386442542,
0.0119704911,
2.067950095e-34,
0.0080939736,
-0.0073713735,
0.0543027744,
0.0464985184,
0.0398112051,
0.0380749963,
0.0170553159,
0.008078183,
0.0379008576,
-0.0311443731,
-0.0492227897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13233v1 | User Simulation with Large Language Models for Evaluating Task-Oriented Dialogue | 2023-09-23T02:04:57 | 2023-09-23T02:04:57 | Sam Davidson, Salvatore Romeo, Raphael Shu, James Gung, Arshit Gupta, Saab Mansour, Yi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | One of the major impediments to the development of new task-oriented dialogue
(TOD) systems is the need for human evaluation at multiple stages and
iterations of the development process. In an effort to move toward automated
evaluation of TOD, we propose a novel user simulator built using recently
developed large pretrained language models (LLMs). In order to increase the
linguistic diversity of our system relative to the related previous work, we do
not fine-tune the LLMs used by our system on existing TOD datasets; rather we
use in-context learning to prompt the LLMs to generate robust and
linguistically diverse output with the goal of simulating the behavior of human
interlocutors. Unlike previous work, which sought to maximize goal success rate
(GSR) as the primary metric of simulator performance, our goal is a system
which achieves a GSR similar to that observed in human interactions with TOD
systems. Using this approach, our current simulator is effectively able to
interact with several TOD systems, especially on single-intent conversational
goals, while generating lexically and syntactically diverse output relative to
previous simulators that rely upon fine-tuned models. Finally, we collect a
Human2Bot dataset of humans interacting with the same TOD systems with which we
experimented in order to better quantify these achievements. | [
0.0740484968,
0.0183365233,
-0.0160437748,
0.0206257664,
-0.0102677997,
0.0081030931,
-0.0026142057,
-0.0181218721,
0.0361702219,
-0.0290003084,
-0.0642049983,
-0.041866228,
-0.0180735141,
0.0305147357,
0.021865895,
-0.0664883703,
0.019504156,
-0.0372133888,
-0.0239851885,
0.0144425379,
0.0023244161,
0.0399155095,
-0.0361439958,
0.1036208719,
-0.0241769999,
-0.0102178119,
-0.0378236845,
0.0118606277,
-0.0018249362,
-0.0272952151,
0.0273089819,
0.0541113503,
0.0428628959,
0.038355846,
0.0000021287,
-0.0298541356,
0.0422783196,
-0.0266736392,
-0.0355561487,
-0.0401850753,
0.071804978,
0.0517128147,
-0.0110226376,
0.0266641639,
-0.0537268594,
0.0074573676,
0.0191549733,
0.0418285839,
0.0689059868,
0.0588833652,
-0.0004211225,
0.0110835014,
-0.0225275438,
-0.012155164,
0.0066876379,
-0.0548526049,
-0.0133935753,
0.0221738983,
0.0473160036,
0.013676459,
0.02988993,
-0.0132245794,
0.0196949374,
-0.0165300649,
-0.009423092,
0.0229487438,
-0.0133338738,
-0.0455060229,
-0.0352749601,
0.0898642242,
-0.0156709682,
-0.0075868866,
-0.0016124279,
0.0076255254,
0.0038021307,
-0.0200893804,
-0.0229519438,
-0.0281516407,
-0.0147471018,
-0.0015407867,
-0.0304373913,
0.0375730395,
-0.0191867277,
0.0257410966,
-0.0156232128,
0.0219317265,
-0.0036004081,
-0.0140074501,
0.0121753858,
0.0089327982,
0.0198111553,
-0.067281954,
0.0034797131,
0.0209606327,
-0.1132911295,
0.0154433157,
-0.0576909184,
-0.0239689648,
0.0090185842,
-0.0512228385,
0.0680791289,
0.0318636335,
-0.0252004955,
0.0370114706,
0.0301904827,
0.0651130602,
-0.0029638943,
-0.0030753496,
-0.0342081748,
-0.0061863717,
-0.0503506102,
0.0118106166,
-0.0460949689,
0.0263365917,
-0.0237674266,
-0.0400665961,
-0.043226514,
0.0575897209,
-0.0099345315,
0.007172517,
0.0123077473,
0.0287291836,
-0.0615262389,
-0.0048072245,
-0.0568257906,
-0.0205996856,
-0.0294037852,
0.0341101363,
0.0370586179,
-0.0453276262,
-0.0048456993,
0.0417901613,
-0.0114773158,
-0.0212351121,
0.0059476849,
0.0589766465,
-0.0226370711,
-0.028251294,
0.0241353624,
-0.0262056384,
-0.0150931813,
-0.064036034,
-0.0277377218,
-0.0526832119,
0.0404653773,
-0.0045882664,
-0.0128122875,
-0.0487304889,
-0.000687769,
0.033498317,
-0.0070042987,
0.0658293143,
-0.010867577,
0.0124984886,
0.0344579257,
0.0040359846,
-0.0306278355,
0.0601875335,
0.0301987287,
0.0624633208,
0.0171634145,
0.0148536749,
0.0253322218,
0.0629921034,
-0.0230336972,
0.0085877208,
0.0389373824,
0.0191266704,
-0.0043120929,
0.0359032154,
0.0254430175,
0.0507722013,
-0.0340709798,
0.021306539,
0.0679567158,
0.0613610819,
0.0012832128,
-0.0112582156,
0.0722172782,
0.052880846,
0.0082105305,
-0.0097888699,
-0.0307705868,
0.0060084071,
-0.0119299749,
-0.018420333,
0.0336198397,
0.0094403243,
-0.0566266961,
-0.0235833284,
0.012762513,
-0.0181366969,
0.0379817374,
0.0084698657,
0.0635253042,
0.0147130033,
-0.0730111301,
0.0269343052,
0.0001936435,
-0.0414222702,
-0.0198652633,
-0.0526581407,
0.0046017999,
0.0757003203,
0.0448518209,
-0.0235851947,
-0.0310361758,
-0.0201685261,
0.013510731,
0.0636032298,
0.029549351,
-0.0175222736,
0.0013791254,
-0.0362266079,
-0.0252125375,
-0.0082857478,
-0.0024086679,
0.0157365929,
0.0418711416,
-0.0196617432,
0.0068082269,
-0.0227157623,
-0.0132961823,
0.0375492573,
-0.0174226947,
0.0202514324,
-0.005125605,
-0.0108045125,
0.0423542373,
0.0269518383,
-0.0014455266,
-0.0061931014,
0.029305581,
-0.0099680424,
-0.0068083522,
0.029705517,
-0.0415333882,
-0.0290442612,
0.0266202614,
0.0087407203,
-0.0322893448,
0.0681582391,
-0.0215467419,
-0.0262282863,
0.0048309918,
-0.0262848977,
-0.0031301514,
-0.0533806831,
0.0236552637,
0.0056204782,
0.0080334311,
-0.0221142173,
0.0147812115,
0.0075823925,
0.0160307605,
0.0172751918,
-0.0055035045,
0.0055801952,
-0.0414347984,
-0.0044290759,
-0.0014530736,
-0.0314813629,
0.0160861202,
0.0127288047,
0.0532587394,
-0.0494036712,
-0.0382623412,
-0.1549108922,
-0.0135521488,
-0.0328558795,
-0.0082836989,
0.0127463201,
-0.0017810549,
-0.0098112673,
-0.0405606888,
-0.0142327994,
-0.0014228661,
0.0404609293,
-0.0174635593,
0.0309968274,
-0.0046640029,
-0.0213827156,
-0.0442040078,
0.0358668081,
0.0092731882,
0.0270225815,
-0.0087631773,
0.0153509527,
-0.0657764822,
0.0330310874,
-0.0058314442,
0.0351972766,
-0.0188837759,
-0.0136004342,
0.0676712617,
0.0215764642,
0.0838744715,
0.0261695776,
0.0431357473,
0.0647495613,
0.0082257679,
0.0014062765,
-0.0800724998,
0.0146765551,
-0.0027197185,
-0.0450702682,
-0.0520610586,
-0.055604592,
0.0402348228,
0.0417965278,
0.0050068973,
0.0336278602,
-0.0753703564,
0.0126836775,
-0.0190755576,
-0.0503211431,
-0.028431654,
-0.0070090811,
-0.0602089725,
0.0228428338,
-0.004183291,
-0.020261446,
0.0873862654,
-0.0227648448,
-0.0213344526,
-0.0405345932,
-0.0080102812,
-0.0001884379,
0.0732286647,
-0.0209864881,
-0.0038701734,
0.0309268385,
-0.004961262,
-0.0423120707,
0.021692453,
-0.0295002796,
-0.0499246903,
0.0383713171,
-0.0646754801,
-0.0059348322,
0.0039457153,
-0.0503603593,
-0.0652018413,
-0.0534844585,
-0.0188610945,
0.0067608813,
0.0118720233,
-0.018668374,
-0.027234152,
0.0100149214,
0.005656614,
0.0492715463,
0.007108226,
-0.0278962087,
-0.0199041814,
-0.0056088804,
0.0726146251,
0.0257340763,
-0.0313814729,
-0.0149154719,
0.0462020598,
0.0326575153,
0.0669186115,
-0.0117836427,
-0.027283635,
-0.0262529571,
0.0246748533,
0.0152444029,
0.0176071003,
0.0480081774,
0.0677130446,
-0.0047682403,
-0.0261126738,
0.1310619265,
0.0215042997,
-0.0245471578,
0.0183020551,
-0.034640599,
0.0170910377,
0.0249687172,
0.0364787877,
-0.0822296739,
-0.0299642738,
0.0038799392,
0.0188275687,
-0.0016268751,
-0.0369593725,
-0.0110488543,
-0.1072910205,
0.0247900635,
-0.0319718868,
-0.0393654555,
0.0069654938,
-0.0237476956,
0.0106599852,
0.0039712037,
0.0118828192,
0.0053850431,
0.0307241175,
-0.0179582052,
0.0100972261,
-0.0298996046,
-0.0403046608,
0.0711223409,
-0.0388919003,
0.0647025034,
0.0762752742,
0.0548956394,
0.0245805439,
0.0301328301,
0.0304214414,
0.0336001329,
0.0122992611,
0.009339489,
0.0155738574,
-0.0038323454,
-0.0099944547,
-0.0259348024,
0.0326868892,
-0.0455551483,
-0.0072154393,
0.034195397,
0.0302593242,
-0.0707711279,
0.0187942795,
-0.0154097127,
0.033215262,
0.0637649298,
0.0561644062,
0.0331318602,
-0.1034559608,
-0.0189903043,
-0.0229838565,
-0.0277692731,
-0.0354989953,
-0.0247481167,
-0.0183245875,
-0.0110139744,
0.0164574031,
-0.0610900484,
-0.0711008161,
0.023396438,
0.0116631845,
-0.0013131344,
-0.0029656105,
0.0033332496,
-0.0064239027,
0.0237637516,
0.0407205708,
-0.0142914681,
0.0547952466,
-0.0609849691,
-0.0100826016,
0.0266562756,
-0.0453095473,
0.0078190742,
0.0610334426,
-0.0717419386,
-0.0456861742,
-0.0293626785,
0.0724414513,
0.0192903653,
0.0247963313,
-0.0148737011,
-0.0374807566,
-0.0069138817,
-0.0066822474,
-0.0470459834,
-0.0023865874,
0.0181276426,
0.0531712808,
-0.0274425205,
0.0270347521,
-0.036894884,
0.0230346452,
0.0046669929,
0.0274087079,
-0.0219464824,
-0.0844559297,
0.0319422521,
-0.0159936007,
0.0669774115,
-0.0199434627,
-0.044115562,
-0.0187640879,
0.0161973685,
-0.0379259065,
-0.0250745565,
-0.0616714358,
-0.0075330664,
0.0008474818,
-0.0126496227,
0.0183450859,
0.0174633693,
-0.0625801012,
0.052669026,
-0.0266335849,
-0.0132629443,
-0.0129541615,
0.0224994887,
0.0146904169,
-0.0096568409,
-0.0318174809,
-0.0020401415,
-0.0114461463,
0.019062791,
0.0057301875,
0.0991146788,
0.0074910992,
-0.0151951201,
0.0182897821,
0.0598845296,
-0.0295747835,
-0.0571090467,
-0.0227995664,
0.0190429296,
0.039353177,
0.0437136069,
0.0533571206,
-0.0651057884,
0.0405122824,
-0.0359910056,
0.0339984372,
-0.0317526571,
-0.0192905851,
0.0233262964,
0.0139981145,
-0.01086176,
0.0013583272,
0.0648208112,
-0.0069754911,
-0.0041912082,
-0.0127772884,
0.0001795721,
-0.0658154562,
-0.0292750821,
0.0251465347,
0.0428641476,
-0.0255814958,
-0.0168312918,
-0.029441718,
-0.0490880832,
0.005224254,
0.0321812257,
0.0033942901,
-0.030517526,
0.0703415424,
0.0535044223,
-0.0462053008,
0.0110511854,
-0.0468375869,
-0.0400855094,
-0.0063997367,
-0.0380937457,
-0.0605671071,
-5.629882889e-33,
-0.0264151953,
-0.033573702,
0.0447214991,
-0.0153363124,
-0.0239726212,
-0.0474210419,
-0.0263922065,
0.0205666069,
-0.0178512651,
-0.0106362607,
-0.0320995674,
0.0071788835,
0.0206254758,
0.0261032507,
-0.0084508481,
0.0248752311,
0.0527482107,
-0.019508278,
-0.0213526525,
0.0258361604,
0.0188393816,
-0.0040728855,
0.0162138119,
-0.0660692155,
0.0641790703,
0.0094916644,
-0.0361571163,
0.0031769543,
0.0210478641,
0.0387859344,
-0.0288244057,
0.0609438196,
0.0156963095,
-0.0550650954,
-0.0285114478,
0.0314584076,
-0.0251285788,
-0.0071703987,
0.0118277231,
0.0107375272,
-0.0123634823,
0.0073352363,
-0.0089321742,
-0.0235169306,
-0.0479188934,
0.0292891953,
0.0179555658,
-0.0011789011,
0.0072340225,
0.0065624965,
-0.0864669457,
0.0042289337,
-0.0049076253,
-0.1056012958,
-0.0319618732,
0.0848194659,
-0.0361465327,
-0.0523647964,
-0.0177220292,
0.0275880992,
-0.0192646887,
-0.023160195,
0.0618593656,
0.0382618755,
0.0125457887,
0.0589568801,
0.0178273655,
0.0356477834,
-0.0259875208,
-0.0434788354,
0.0105310762,
0.0450448059,
0.0257635396,
0.0448007919,
-0.0258810371,
0.0097709876,
-0.0254611168,
0.0594909079,
0.0173820443,
0.037532974,
0.049639605,
0.02562676,
-0.0445653647,
-0.0011061525,
-0.0266361237,
0.0556355081,
-0.008956247,
-0.0612467825,
0.0478144884,
0.0140896337,
0.0070710541,
-0.0452424586,
0.0388769507,
-0.0303842612,
0.0000587371,
0.0035940555,
-0.0322532542,
0.0128301699,
-0.0207625404,
0.0015564469,
-0.0411596596,
-0.0283944607,
0.045133058,
0.0214317031,
0.0183973219,
0.0136760846,
-0.0092151342,
0.0047930544,
-0.047265131,
0.0058466885,
-0.0260507483,
0.0393861793,
-0.0124067739,
0.0355855003,
0.0311523024,
-0.0110382224,
-0.0430730842,
0.0692984685,
-0.0194057524,
-0.0830984488,
-0.0364954844,
-0.0082732299,
0.014010285,
-0.0050748945,
-0.0299542733,
0.0100434348,
-0.0375804231,
-0.0204463676,
0.0134409945,
-0.0083653927,
-0.0324214101,
-0.013412104,
2.69e-7,
-0.0048290147,
0.0298755467,
0.0001710818,
0.0506440774,
0.0003349688,
0.048093386,
0.0035170845,
0.0561197624,
0.0075588389,
-0.023401659,
0.0143441204,
0.0259564165,
0.0622333214,
0.0038270673,
-0.100398317,
-0.0239542462,
-0.0201905444,
-0.001485561,
-0.0488519408,
0.010263891,
0.0690887049,
0.0517219715,
0.0071210596,
0.0028196205,
-0.0064979624,
-0.0276512802,
0.0498358235,
-0.0480547361,
-0.0252755396,
0.0184817985,
0.0257791616,
-0.0218266807,
0.0121517088,
0.0301756896,
0.0009494171,
-0.0009666366,
0.0249665156,
0.0609731674,
-0.0191196837,
-0.0414473526,
-0.0099541163,
-0.0097307963,
-0.0010997609,
-0.06323158,
0.019403737,
-0.074591592,
-0.017945867,
-0.0346343815,
0.0332060121,
-0.0022381491,
0.0129890777,
-0.0559909157,
-0.0177585017,
0.0120067559,
0.0291072149,
0.0050521176,
0.0050822631,
-0.0510781296,
-0.0085155992,
0.0269306414,
-0.0881453753,
-0.0646704882,
-0.0459966771,
0.0162911173,
-0.0112784263,
-0.0414126329,
0.0144792767,
2.06085741e-34,
0.0153559502,
0.0342966057,
0.0189414006,
0.0450053886,
0.05077409,
0.0058271699,
0.0107142925,
0.0407632776,
0.0518907309,
-0.048517514,
-0.0203810725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13230v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13230v4 | Unify word-level and span-level tasks: NJUNLP's Participation for the WMT2023 Quality Estimation Shared Task | 2023-09-23T01:52:14 | 2023-12-11T10:53:48 | Xiang Geng, Zhejian Lai, Yu Zhang, Shimin Tao, Hao Yang, Jiajun Chen, Shujian Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce the submissions of the NJUNLP team to the WMT 2023 Quality
Estimation (QE) shared task. Our team submitted predictions for the
English-German language pair on all two sub-tasks: (i) sentence- and word-level
quality prediction; and (ii) fine-grained error span detection. This year, we
further explore pseudo data methods for QE based on NJUQE framework
(https://github.com/NJUNLP/njuqe). We generate pseudo MQM data using parallel
data from the WMT translation task. We pre-train the XLMR large model on pseudo
QE data, then fine-tune it on real QE data. At both stages, we jointly learn
sentence-level scores and word-level tags. Empirically, we conduct experiments
to find the key hyper-parameters that improve the performance. Technically, we
propose a simple method that covert the word-level outputs to fine-grained
error span results. Overall, our models achieved the best results in
English-German for both word-level and fine-grained error span detection
sub-tasks by a considerable margin. | [
0.0178629085,
0.0397430435,
0.0201584976,
0.0540602095,
0.001606192,
-0.0101217618,
0.0027283083,
0.0165356267,
-0.0313711911,
0.0150542911,
-0.0660148785,
-0.0603323877,
0.0288923718,
0.0082676765,
0.0525568835,
-0.0267626885,
0.0216666926,
-0.0014383529,
-0.0175965596,
-0.0017225873,
0.0213055294,
-0.0038778691,
0.0227270741,
0.0182365291,
-0.035699416,
-0.0106676491,
0.0276791472,
0.0679226816,
0.023336906,
-0.0296529178,
0.0419801772,
0.0425196551,
0.0002748682,
0.0333300866,
0.0000018847,
-0.0266538579,
-0.0526840277,
0.000332777,
0.0393622145,
0.0324602835,
0.0011571388,
-0.0164675526,
-0.0425985269,
0.047321897,
-0.0011202346,
-0.0290182829,
0.0214283448,
0.0774772614,
0.0674801692,
0.0763168633,
-0.0151239792,
0.0196502153,
0.0014708734,
-0.0503262393,
0.0123214182,
-0.0734826401,
-0.0180000681,
0.0279680341,
-0.0205499344,
0.0102991872,
-0.0241619851,
0.0318112001,
0.0144482721,
0.0036937741,
-0.0164896045,
-0.0166932438,
-0.0334061272,
-0.0031449534,
-0.0156853609,
0.0592148341,
-0.0176870469,
-0.0218828861,
-0.0040647425,
-0.0087100528,
-0.0253112521,
-0.0340595171,
0.0019360685,
-0.0008974167,
0.0127418935,
0.0362719074,
-0.0116814412,
0.0152660497,
0.024528617,
-0.0007748898,
0.0021095399,
0.045175083,
0.022801578,
-0.0795703977,
0.0160557125,
0.0364579223,
-0.0349938609,
0.0128316674,
0.0150290504,
-0.0298114847,
-0.0411455743,
-0.0025352661,
-0.0582515262,
-0.0500516519,
0.0046446752,
-0.0261739288,
0.0458531454,
0.0341192894,
-0.0072902758,
0.03488262,
-0.0231216773,
0.0635138005,
0.0144363958,
-0.0067683733,
-0.0566540807,
-0.0385164283,
-0.0176074952,
0.0393695906,
-0.0207636096,
0.0077294824,
-0.062378563,
0.0141155673,
-0.0373761803,
-0.0324407332,
-0.0086158644,
0.0368056744,
0.05804573,
-0.0176618211,
-0.0804267377,
-0.0052075302,
0.0079512661,
0.0418308675,
-0.0221834369,
0.001623898,
0.0072236354,
-0.0232186448,
-0.0278530549,
0.0416406766,
0.0066117966,
-0.0505930856,
0.0265338048,
0.0208295006,
-0.0216928013,
-0.0221521538,
-0.0107116615,
-0.0383841433,
-0.0361801013,
-0.0468164086,
0.0082659815,
-0.0567935742,
0.0277052894,
-0.0249493457,
0.0289714541,
-0.0027057603,
0.0016955374,
-0.0099171251,
0.0047067441,
0.0206370093,
-0.0352972224,
0.0078562824,
-0.0132582784,
0.0121460957,
0.0061489977,
0.0603719503,
0.0339342169,
0.0237085763,
0.0635811612,
0.0129536828,
-0.001768145,
0.061975196,
0.0194647163,
0.0391494893,
-0.0260985047,
-0.0524486005,
0.021360416,
0.0157579854,
0.0391460061,
0.0659391657,
-0.0121228602,
0.049584806,
0.0761711895,
-0.0061750822,
0.0729728788,
0.0127861723,
0.0290585682,
0.0088740746,
0.0029495568,
0.0107344091,
0.000990152,
0.025096843,
0.0031782545,
0.0302440505,
0.0956746861,
0.0562024005,
-0.0000562544,
-0.0572889112,
-0.0254599247,
-0.0278264452,
-0.0168856941,
-0.0574629828,
0.0221792851,
0.0014459634,
-0.0546414927,
0.0388942286,
0.0097133424,
-0.0604426861,
0.0452310964,
-0.0220428351,
0.0092668477,
0.0686396584,
0.065851666,
0.0042803898,
0.0136320405,
-0.0206872374,
-0.0029928866,
0.0705537274,
0.0423339568,
-0.0052549448,
0.0265086498,
-0.0631636158,
-0.043546699,
0.0120837009,
0.0213637818,
-0.0463123731,
-0.0013899719,
0.0283803977,
0.033087004,
-0.0870548561,
-0.0792312101,
0.0149273956,
0.0063548069,
0.0007729439,
0.024485413,
0.003418349,
0.0316910073,
0.0416210145,
-0.0338672623,
0.0002183562,
0.0040656542,
-0.047425691,
-0.0115449922,
0.0087504787,
-0.0277354345,
-0.0629832372,
0.0217171367,
-0.0623930208,
0.0170060508,
0.0556479134,
-0.0567049272,
-0.0544119738,
-0.0475742817,
-0.0337482616,
-0.0066510793,
-0.0622295178,
0.0119038038,
-0.0014034222,
-0.0146559812,
0.0051138778,
0.0186402742,
-0.010895473,
0.0373221859,
0.0005890398,
-0.0207988806,
0.0178804174,
-0.0045212624,
-0.0540777147,
0.0443159975,
-0.0067410851,
0.0765371546,
0.034573596,
0.0289544258,
-0.0496240035,
-0.0087682791,
-0.022219874,
0.0338310301,
-0.0444020145,
0.0377415866,
0.036316175,
-0.008407102,
-0.0125025967,
0.0134626096,
-0.0134050837,
-0.0496769622,
0.013394475,
-0.0266058203,
0.0224014949,
-0.0057454775,
0.0560214072,
-0.0362506807,
-0.0206811167,
0.0084466925,
0.0242963117,
-0.0365740508,
-0.016279459,
-0.0565375015,
0.0341431201,
-0.034334071,
-0.0130970301,
0.0387436934,
-0.0939825624,
-0.0159133039,
-0.0088300183,
0.0503075384,
0.0250343047,
-0.0009133915,
-0.0259667281,
0.0313753374,
0.0120967617,
-0.0433562212,
0.0213054195,
-0.0111416001,
-0.0011897904,
-0.0244767871,
-0.0532482006,
0.0500309877,
0.064995721,
-0.0081421072,
0.0089628231,
-0.0627214462,
0.0163016506,
-0.0271576736,
-0.0051559531,
0.0387733877,
0.0213575717,
-0.015674755,
0.025102919,
-0.0289327856,
-0.0399198756,
0.0633700565,
-0.0502559468,
-0.0037529659,
-0.079642117,
-0.0069150501,
-0.0133156711,
-0.0152479848,
-0.0367304422,
0.0332286805,
-0.0289761592,
-0.029573638,
-0.0274586584,
0.0085082455,
0.036828056,
-0.0275329258,
-0.0096102292,
-0.0160366409,
-0.0253630802,
-0.0034782141,
0.0043941024,
-0.0082369484,
0.0202326253,
-0.0241535418,
-0.0205879472,
-0.0110477814,
-0.0062758061,
0.0285531543,
-0.0114255324,
-0.0220242441,
0.0390597843,
-0.0256546997,
0.0141941672,
-0.0063398392,
0.0417369753,
0.036912553,
0.0079250922,
0.0245691482,
-0.0731333494,
0.028729802,
0.0333460867,
0.0265842807,
0.0020830575,
0.0261290446,
-0.0276397523,
0.0533014759,
0.0121155251,
-0.0275185797,
0.0205249246,
0.0844963565,
-0.0565731525,
-0.0155731663,
0.1132687107,
0.0387108661,
-0.0092212558,
-0.0116224242,
0.0017021522,
0.0616831332,
0.0180668123,
-0.0018275419,
-0.0706669763,
-0.0370340459,
0.0145855648,
0.0587576218,
-0.0069871959,
0.0117464829,
-0.0097321197,
-0.1166007593,
0.0059204157,
0.0449950844,
0.0160250682,
-0.0259865895,
0.0007560262,
-0.0004695818,
-0.0234425534,
0.0461673141,
-0.003604701,
0.0095861964,
0.0157852247,
0.0187672749,
-0.0136095695,
-0.1075582504,
0.0106232716,
-0.0676653236,
0.0551810823,
0.072770603,
0.0228379443,
-0.0316109136,
-0.0667546391,
0.0392129011,
-0.0820710212,
-0.010338936,
-0.0233434048,
0.050710123,
-0.0268913843,
-0.0252430644,
-0.0130351307,
0.0145617621,
0.0190894976,
-0.0090180933,
-0.00359628,
0.0633639321,
0.0043848483,
-0.0450779013,
0.0162597913,
0.0093961414,
-0.0124648502,
0.0786026642,
0.0250768289,
-0.0552858971,
-0.0247160997,
0.0016645322,
0.016567301,
-0.064892672,
0.0071033766,
0.0364947468,
-0.0573799126,
-0.0112527553,
-0.0836362839,
-0.0526664183,
0.0301635172,
0.0232155509,
-0.0181548502,
-0.0021638987,
-0.0252192505,
-0.0124074426,
-0.0200655703,
0.0161384903,
-0.0055165836,
0.0255139451,
-0.0597317517,
0.0276164319,
0.0197277386,
0.007423298,
-0.0062074657,
0.0081979996,
-0.0666659176,
-0.0641270131,
-0.0443189517,
0.0542748123,
0.0144205997,
0.0507612452,
-0.0227372646,
-0.0368365161,
0.0220128447,
0.0120710488,
-0.0279304441,
0.0237568952,
0.0807415396,
-0.0210979413,
-0.0278627463,
0.0503731146,
-0.0416076854,
0.0192510486,
0.0146038588,
0.0738088861,
0.0361638144,
-0.036421679,
0.0027773723,
0.012221219,
0.0367804579,
-0.0231772121,
0.0076643052,
-0.0434541069,
0.0106023727,
0.0089918468,
-0.0148187401,
-0.0617530681,
0.0378178135,
0.0292647518,
0.0028594367,
-0.0388982892,
0.0469890423,
-0.0316804945,
0.0339215361,
-0.0474914275,
0.0273168422,
-0.0409594811,
-0.0324624889,
0.0110930288,
0.0027555402,
-0.0142073948,
-0.0499337874,
0.0524349697,
0.0233435277,
0.0129592065,
0.0297081675,
0.0086712847,
0.0109195514,
0.0353519693,
0.0528747961,
-0.0152778914,
0.0159755088,
-0.0621806569,
0.0244920757,
0.0544422381,
0.0241071079,
0.1134731099,
-0.0080905277,
-0.013314697,
-0.0499846116,
0.0254279971,
0.0023378574,
0.0122781442,
0.0126475384,
-0.0096618766,
-0.0341797322,
-0.0121487454,
0.0610583462,
-0.0329830535,
-0.0001149227,
-0.0025580421,
-0.0054224548,
-0.0164831355,
0.0013288286,
-0.007997511,
-0.0321006924,
-0.0276659261,
-0.01436958,
-0.0178027768,
-0.0572417416,
0.0427931286,
0.0212381091,
-0.0098203616,
-0.0349075235,
-0.00721935,
0.031063484,
-0.0227899347,
0.0409955904,
-0.0082092667,
-0.0751775205,
0.0302049275,
-0.0094005093,
0.0240773316,
-6.361161231e-33,
-0.0107706515,
-0.0009510747,
-0.0547575243,
-0.0549606457,
-0.0349692814,
0.0153344823,
-0.0145926196,
-0.041696541,
0.0161103625,
0.0197122954,
0.0253521111,
0.0165626183,
0.0266841948,
0.0035557027,
-0.0090674143,
-0.0004580512,
0.0922837332,
-0.0002147004,
-0.0506209545,
0.0002079245,
-0.0221216101,
0.021280352,
0.0891680941,
0.0008136464,
0.022828795,
-0.0026682012,
-0.0374834761,
0.0105931163,
0.0416525938,
0.0608489811,
0.0187280886,
0.0613199547,
0.0224751756,
-0.0499767661,
-0.0348313302,
-0.0250704847,
-0.057992924,
0.0018293057,
-0.0090963151,
-0.0069243447,
-0.042792961,
-0.0127846552,
0.0390365981,
-0.0253721662,
-0.0297957752,
-0.0420830436,
0.0190160647,
-0.0377199538,
-0.0034244112,
-0.0803293958,
-0.026124049,
0.0242167506,
-0.0198200084,
0.0010743482,
0.0290619414,
0.0457882769,
0.0012183386,
0.0244313143,
-0.0737091154,
0.0144458525,
-0.0080514094,
0.0444120765,
0.0420362987,
-0.0140601676,
-0.0216971692,
0.0282423925,
0.0144313565,
-0.007682432,
0.0640086234,
0.0101028765,
0.0377320573,
-0.0022218875,
0.087257944,
0.0648145974,
0.0277959034,
-0.0363604426,
-0.0489469953,
0.0596727058,
-0.0279816594,
0.0174159184,
-0.0105033293,
0.0050668158,
-0.0132749164,
-0.0099205067,
-0.031935297,
-0.030353209,
-0.033500623,
-0.0363643281,
0.0177553203,
0.0144842258,
-0.0493997186,
-0.0124595743,
0.0502910614,
-0.0374598168,
0.0192241948,
-0.0236921143,
-0.0484691262,
-0.0005304099,
-0.0229907725,
0.0611912496,
-0.0272115096,
-0.007452969,
0.0322189219,
0.0147698345,
0.0059260326,
-0.0342190452,
0.04510184,
0.0194263179,
-0.086313881,
0.033707276,
-0.0336163007,
0.0362640098,
-0.0286689196,
-0.0030168137,
0.0118366387,
-0.0372787267,
-0.0210791063,
0.0494661704,
0.0244806949,
0.0318682045,
-0.0242544636,
-0.0138282189,
0.0176612325,
0.0251161288,
-0.0197095554,
0.0124722337,
-0.0291878767,
-0.0151397614,
0.0574261658,
-0.0443801619,
-0.0227617193,
-0.0126447463,
2.636e-7,
0.0209645499,
0.0359503813,
0.01129073,
0.0127070704,
-0.0153137669,
0.0271164477,
-0.0679250881,
0.0294103511,
0.0218077172,
0.0118292524,
0.013424349,
-0.0302312281,
0.0954538733,
0.0413119048,
-0.0729611218,
0.0288614538,
-0.0811552554,
-0.0001183822,
-0.0533983819,
-0.0298648607,
0.066450268,
0.097936675,
-0.0295980182,
0.0026545885,
0.0038626746,
-0.0144936265,
0.0471142754,
-0.0102902409,
-0.048686035,
0.0202938598,
0.0606233217,
-0.015391916,
-0.003445348,
-0.0183538068,
-0.0679643974,
0.0154345902,
0.0416571051,
0.0571105778,
0.0432136022,
-0.0504400879,
0.0152409608,
0.0261379089,
0.0021147672,
-0.0089127822,
0.072317034,
-0.0122912899,
-0.005053476,
0.0084000016,
-0.0489353649,
-0.0113306455,
0.0475087762,
-0.0450062789,
-0.0254745092,
-0.0057521127,
0.0357327759,
0.0268860999,
-0.0109216431,
-0.0280897301,
-0.0176276024,
0.0178080183,
0.0148339858,
-0.0837159157,
0.0097110933,
-0.007519478,
-0.0020164002,
-0.0761286169,
0.0184283797,
2.259771029e-34,
0.0847555324,
-0.037581902,
0.0428409725,
-0.0105983065,
0.0275175869,
-0.0258110501,
-0.0600860901,
-0.0402135737,
-0.0081627425,
-0.0349100307,
-0.0057458435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14356v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14356v2 | COCO-Counterfactuals: Automatically Constructed Counterfactual Examples for Image-Text Pairs | 2023-09-23T00:16:47 | 2023-10-31T15:41:25 | Tiep Le, Vasudev Lal, Phillip Howard | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Counterfactual examples have proven to be valuable in the field of natural
language processing (NLP) for both evaluating and improving the robustness of
language models to spurious correlations in datasets. Despite their
demonstrated utility for NLP, multimodal counterfactual examples have been
relatively unexplored due to the difficulty of creating paired image-text data
with minimal counterfactual changes. To address this challenge, we introduce a
scalable framework for automatic generation of counterfactual examples using
text-to-image diffusion models. We use our framework to create
COCO-Counterfactuals, a multimodal counterfactual dataset of paired image and
text captions based on the MS-COCO dataset. We validate the quality of
COCO-Counterfactuals through human evaluations and show that existing
multimodal models are challenged by our counterfactual image-text pairs.
Additionally, we demonstrate the usefulness of COCO-Counterfactuals for
improving out-of-domain generalization of multimodal vision-language models via
training data augmentation. | [
0.0601997524,
0.0790599138,
-0.0214661695,
0.0679279193,
-0.0442032702,
0.0114080803,
0.0021954547,
0.015032379,
0.0065151094,
-0.0734466538,
-0.0065591056,
-0.0192631576,
0.0020772077,
0.0615594201,
0.0261806622,
-0.0505973324,
0.0388660729,
-0.0167195313,
-0.0309579987,
-0.013269173,
0.0352354608,
-0.0044268318,
-0.0076934821,
0.016916208,
-0.0210740697,
-0.0357923433,
0.0089896284,
0.039688427,
0.0358828232,
-0.0367527865,
0.0166553427,
0.0232997462,
0.0389092714,
-0.0117288819,
0.0000019076,
-0.0246534105,
0.024649594,
0.018582629,
0.0176505595,
-0.0286121201,
0.0212431811,
-0.0444971286,
0.0016005182,
-0.0181629658,
-0.0452044681,
0.0328174159,
0.0723057166,
0.0476679951,
0.0719942153,
0.0755672902,
-0.030733278,
-0.0330171213,
0.0050473763,
-0.0215580687,
0.0130346315,
0.000168589,
0.0172115397,
0.037339054,
-0.0246784184,
-0.0051478916,
-0.0557124503,
0.0215072706,
-0.0019157443,
0.00029809,
0.0030027942,
0.0347343236,
-0.0274754055,
-0.0537138209,
-0.0369148366,
0.090184249,
0.0064503471,
-0.0111626526,
-0.0215851795,
-0.0309995431,
0.0021833479,
0.0473786741,
-0.0315788463,
0.0017895187,
0.0098878602,
0.0220168587,
-0.0471916758,
0.0089500481,
0.0212138593,
0.0098902686,
0.0140324989,
-0.0018292147,
0.0205948967,
-0.006863683,
-0.0380884595,
0.0090714805,
-0.060040731,
-0.0583957359,
0.0339479074,
-0.0012566326,
0.022521954,
-0.0024116761,
-0.0294773318,
-0.0819460154,
0.0172086544,
-0.0875995755,
0.0260598119,
-0.0232642069,
-0.0715192333,
0.0754905045,
-0.0409529433,
0.027542593,
-0.0452698283,
0.0313400738,
-0.0285044499,
-0.0275768321,
-0.0150888236,
-0.0299822409,
-0.0212720279,
0.0108867567,
-0.0823029727,
-0.0220054965,
-0.0116557665,
-0.0062406547,
-0.0367053151,
0.0195376724,
0.0107283797,
0.046287369,
-0.0227725375,
-0.0255907662,
-0.0237774979,
0.0153044825,
-0.0038891861,
0.0357740521,
-0.027093539,
-0.025684407,
-0.0117786666,
0.0322651453,
-0.0018270041,
-0.0358430147,
0.0079431701,
0.1001227647,
-0.0209783707,
-0.0121444408,
0.0175304543,
-0.024111839,
-0.0537233613,
-0.0598496869,
0.0258853678,
-0.0704641938,
-0.0228183549,
0.0012122047,
0.0171679668,
-0.0361248851,
0.0175385084,
0.0217142943,
-0.0306630023,
0.0958018526,
0.001685673,
-0.0272501521,
0.0180530325,
0.0019042834,
0.0002355711,
0.0914865211,
0.0439002924,
0.0019357528,
0.0508787669,
0.0155096073,
0.003955585,
0.0289847068,
0.0270698536,
0.0111277727,
-0.0610546321,
0.0153260436,
0.031796921,
0.0018015044,
0.0153568322,
0.0303248074,
-0.0206082612,
-0.0548376217,
0.0634804666,
-0.0169447027,
-0.0487344526,
-0.0169015322,
0.0172391515,
0.0062764473,
-0.031341698,
0.0430479571,
-0.0313376524,
0.0336265974,
-0.0250919871,
-0.0060914275,
0.0021974903,
0.0354582183,
-0.0235964581,
-0.0383544602,
-0.0141744912,
-0.0090669058,
0.0510568693,
-0.0218107905,
0.0523625351,
0.0497841425,
-0.0490880162,
-0.0295809209,
0.0020079156,
-0.0287739038,
-0.0280933212,
-0.0137020182,
-0.0321860351,
0.0704148859,
0.023790272,
-0.0278100129,
-0.0125010489,
0.0246151015,
0.0380247235,
0.0472884774,
0.0189098381,
0.0347985029,
0.0254420824,
-0.0501825921,
-0.0137446309,
-0.021121351,
0.0167627241,
-0.0085495943,
-0.0101674367,
0.0106003517,
0.0141324112,
0.0235093068,
0.000189048,
0.0430746637,
0.0254727844,
0.0158837251,
0.0074157738,
-0.001194929,
0.0065208478,
0.0074202586,
-0.0207141675,
-0.010262616,
0.0146882255,
-0.0095274188,
-0.0391847901,
0.0748911723,
-0.0268158242,
-0.0900454596,
0.0115528265,
-0.0969801247,
-0.0430260971,
0.0371457189,
-0.049508024,
-0.0205157232,
0.0444307029,
-0.0192471817,
0.0456122868,
-0.0547233671,
-0.0075379531,
0.0338506773,
0.0470799282,
0.014636673,
0.0333224833,
-0.0288959239,
-0.0184292663,
0.0041610398,
0.0171917733,
0.015095342,
-0.0070148469,
-0.0267654434,
-0.0278550368,
0.0039377622,
0.0060564261,
-0.0038233541,
0.0080467369,
-0.0239061899,
0.0162885897,
-0.0677083582,
-0.0214490891,
-0.0262332652,
-0.0459053069,
0.0086368863,
-0.0184653681,
0.0126614971,
-0.0553517565,
0.011644573,
0.0122120539,
0.0254527237,
0.0230251327,
0.0498995148,
-0.0017762152,
0.0183875766,
-0.0472478196,
-0.0051124706,
-0.0119017353,
0.0863197818,
-0.0082138954,
-0.0419520549,
-0.0034754563,
-0.0062678955,
-0.0176070388,
0.041830305,
-0.0298073497,
-0.0352006517,
0.0047441833,
0.0086654751,
0.0365687013,
0.0207855329,
0.016253259,
0.0049976567,
0.0161526427,
-0.0414803922,
-0.0174174849,
-0.0088638617,
0.0008264727,
-0.0095290346,
0.0179211609,
-0.0599391647,
-0.0473775081,
0.0369509608,
-0.0081960671,
-0.0054195896,
-0.0674620867,
0.0137062855,
0.0012075598,
-0.0733362734,
-0.0312552378,
-0.0245167036,
-0.010491604,
0.0095372861,
-0.0489240475,
-0.0319223292,
0.0603016131,
-0.0237618443,
-0.0095353872,
-0.0452175289,
0.0001663313,
0.0035396526,
0.0866354778,
0.0371429101,
0.0133594982,
0.022530444,
0.0306808986,
-0.0207843445,
-0.0217729528,
0.0195919499,
0.0090773199,
0.0179006495,
-0.0726442188,
0.0130139226,
0.0025223177,
-0.0144065525,
-0.0232718997,
-0.0761725754,
-0.0084540211,
-0.0258944333,
-0.0492550284,
-0.0135438787,
-0.0119711272,
0.0401565805,
-0.0193877518,
0.0391353555,
0.0111681307,
0.0110667478,
-0.0155217573,
0.0309919361,
0.0683652684,
0.038618207,
-0.0319970809,
-0.0425482541,
0.0018690496,
0.0426716879,
0.002263271,
-0.0432299525,
-0.0499248393,
0.0055079507,
-0.0373794734,
0.0565588586,
0.0069668898,
0.0106802471,
0.0538827628,
-0.0404274873,
0.0063420758,
0.0256225765,
0.030502269,
-0.0330890529,
-0.0017565987,
0.028277522,
0.0177177563,
0.0440041758,
-0.0556612797,
-0.0552910939,
-0.0595654026,
-0.0210393127,
-0.0521630086,
-0.0130536081,
0.0082871718,
-0.0347999446,
-0.0985634923,
0.0457708575,
-0.0006179438,
0.0042178473,
-0.0258694924,
-0.0109454263,
-0.0130614359,
0.0025972519,
-0.0352900624,
-0.0341053605,
0.0040281597,
-0.0003053082,
-0.0132372854,
0.008431945,
-0.0476514138,
-0.0010037372,
-0.0291368943,
0.0069920635,
0.060937129,
0.007809862,
-0.0056659481,
-0.0126146125,
0.0419835635,
0.0000840333,
0.0122927977,
0.0012656559,
0.0763700604,
-0.0128254276,
-0.0290312469,
0.0051498003,
-0.001082386,
0.0137785831,
-0.0386798941,
0.0065134563,
0.0338459425,
0.0014577818,
-0.0091569405,
-0.0925199464,
0.0436048545,
0.0197856985,
0.0628019646,
0.015094161,
-0.0512949266,
-0.0419918075,
0.0021166604,
0.0114523368,
-0.0451852903,
0.0132514676,
-0.0290678665,
0.0461484157,
0.0014125452,
-0.0948659405,
-0.0452515148,
-0.016263213,
0.0235800166,
0.0002796509,
0.0092655709,
-0.0291174073,
-0.0044793054,
-0.0627726838,
0.0458832271,
-0.0112868026,
0.0536081418,
0.0051574307,
0.0073479973,
0.0347369462,
-0.0319521539,
-0.0506088808,
0.0490434319,
-0.1237881407,
-0.0687391162,
-0.0206573326,
0.0575927347,
0.018378254,
0.0390044451,
-0.0075552585,
-0.0387826003,
-0.0007176345,
0.0702325925,
-0.0222339705,
0.0169130787,
0.0280536357,
-0.025836233,
0.004234646,
0.016871253,
-0.0092211422,
0.0281922538,
0.0060306201,
0.0467093103,
-0.0179334562,
0.0032925997,
0.0149483941,
-0.0451984182,
0.0562691912,
-0.0195535459,
0.0230029318,
-0.0184647515,
0.0511853471,
-0.053155072,
-0.0132478746,
-0.0548042879,
0.0114677008,
-0.0057758712,
0.0243994836,
-0.0273354482,
-0.0041889092,
-0.0486626253,
0.0292273089,
-0.0117078535,
0.0232839584,
0.0857168958,
0.0263708942,
0.0074412697,
-0.001131258,
0.0116012739,
0.0016870411,
-0.0137225026,
0.0125194276,
0.0033340873,
0.0400686972,
0.0335041098,
-0.0385610014,
-0.0206166804,
0.0312797278,
-0.0493668057,
0.0489453115,
-0.0546275042,
0.0487617217,
0.0446069054,
-0.011818896,
0.0216774996,
-0.0263982117,
-0.0143489121,
0.0004474327,
0.0230077263,
-0.0053873393,
-0.0436778814,
0.0732741281,
-0.0005508913,
0.004229615,
0.0386558697,
0.0501835681,
-0.0124268057,
0.0346128829,
-0.0086648241,
-0.009205577,
-0.0295240972,
-0.0326510482,
0.0092204968,
0.0139093222,
0.0081762355,
0.0366958603,
-0.0544484891,
-0.0883914232,
0.01636195,
0.0237045288,
0.0262268502,
0.0397424176,
0.0447154455,
0.0252172444,
0.0330009796,
-0.0071888156,
0.0011018822,
0.0120705925,
0.0095172161,
0.0129274111,
-0.0307835154,
-6.133909153e-33,
-0.0233793817,
-0.0497912429,
0.0144409146,
-0.0397938825,
0.0364043936,
-0.0115418918,
-0.0194909088,
0.0076922323,
-0.0147068966,
0.0194915831,
0.0353995487,
0.0226729736,
0.0213166587,
0.04292579,
-0.0189505443,
0.0197596233,
0.0452851355,
0.0106072919,
0.0036833687,
-0.0144013697,
-0.0023258796,
-0.0021958952,
0.0633184463,
-0.0822051987,
0.0297923703,
-0.0069381963,
-0.0386720635,
0.0113072498,
0.0033862125,
0.0531469025,
-0.0388275981,
0.0453236401,
0.0359259881,
0.0422027856,
-0.0405344553,
-0.0092413248,
-0.035965614,
-0.0097817183,
0.0516343899,
0.0119942082,
-0.0503850915,
0.0123619046,
0.0456251949,
-0.0232714284,
-0.00717148,
0.0341018662,
0.0760872886,
-0.0287550148,
0.043890696,
0.0585554913,
-0.0822357237,
0.0275934841,
-0.0141895702,
-0.0069939089,
0.0057927025,
0.0468023531,
0.0240645297,
0.0264292471,
-0.0637062415,
0.0341110788,
0.0023233793,
-0.0091480641,
0.0565509833,
0.0242442619,
-0.001194756,
0.0764058381,
0.0210575331,
0.0105256485,
-0.0240227096,
-0.0014682282,
0.0177242253,
0.0500935055,
0.0783850029,
0.1244902983,
0.0650912374,
-0.0020897377,
-0.0593882576,
-0.0135771725,
-0.096710369,
-0.0011539379,
0.0293224603,
0.0060290303,
-0.0032976328,
0.0273296684,
-0.0214521531,
-0.0238765143,
-0.0412307605,
0.0030402371,
0.0376813263,
0.0093609355,
-0.0253882427,
0.0637691915,
0.0602869391,
-0.0327031463,
-0.0426840484,
-0.0059092045,
-0.0216055177,
0.0267597605,
0.0274463799,
0.0537523925,
-0.0453491583,
-0.0171093736,
0.067193523,
0.0506168231,
0.0286190286,
-0.0111235268,
0.0565906428,
0.0088458881,
-0.0612731352,
-0.0054732976,
-0.0136660226,
0.0118392352,
-0.0485138558,
-0.005439288,
0.0294939354,
0.0435340442,
-0.0645904839,
0.0278848596,
0.0119794477,
-0.0203344654,
-0.0503943115,
-0.031816408,
-0.0171796251,
0.0250789188,
-0.017649278,
0.0201337561,
0.0027452174,
-0.025234988,
0.0321911089,
-0.0673313215,
-0.0088946959,
0.0472096018,
2.507e-7,
0.0382988788,
0.0229650307,
0.0446860567,
0.010674512,
0.0231538117,
0.0365177579,
-0.0508664921,
0.0310029965,
-0.001908483,
-0.0450223275,
0.0055433619,
0.0374456644,
0.00733002,
-0.0033978724,
0.0366287678,
0.0597475804,
-0.0511186123,
-0.0482470132,
-0.0354013443,
-0.019150516,
0.0668656379,
0.0776726231,
-0.0014199719,
-0.0067719379,
-0.0144654922,
-0.0277135521,
0.0867151171,
-0.0344628617,
0.0150425425,
-0.0494018532,
-0.0306809209,
0.016825093,
-0.041434817,
0.0586625636,
-0.0055872775,
-0.0107342424,
0.0585078374,
-0.0042998092,
-0.053505227,
-0.0446126424,
-0.0712363049,
0.0177772772,
-0.024189977,
-0.0343353041,
0.0695041642,
-0.0263691805,
-0.0017122888,
-0.0479650721,
-0.0587414354,
0.01288989,
0.0491079465,
-0.0108514614,
-0.0783772096,
0.0201177374,
0.0424867161,
0.0262965262,
-0.0277172998,
-0.0799161121,
-0.0325602107,
0.0091319801,
-0.0448011607,
-0.0022963709,
-0.0661336333,
0.0058882092,
0.0359063148,
-0.0136912894,
-0.0181364659,
1.949229987e-34,
0.0839298517,
-0.0170499533,
-0.0126461824,
-0.0418732204,
0.008248643,
-0.0034782006,
-0.0499007441,
0.0067526936,
0.012032955,
-0.0262347888,
-0.0085764043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13222v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13222v1 | Hindi to English: Transformer-Based Neural Machine Translation | 2023-09-23T00:00:09 | 2023-09-23T00:00:09 | Kavit Gangar, Hardik Ruparel, Shreyas Lele | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Machine Translation (MT) is one of the most prominent tasks in Natural
Language Processing (NLP) which involves the automatic conversion of texts from
one natural language to another while preserving its meaning and fluency.
Although the research in machine translation has been going on since multiple
decades, the newer approach of integrating deep learning techniques in natural
language processing has led to significant improvements in the translation
quality. In this paper, we have developed a Neural Machine Translation (NMT)
system by training the Transformer model to translate texts from Indian
Language Hindi to English. Hindi being a low resource language has made it
difficult for neural networks to understand the language thereby leading to a
slow growth in the development of neural machine translators. Thus, to address
this gap, we implemented back-translation to augment the training data and for
creating the vocabulary, we experimented with both word and subword level
tokenization using Byte Pair Encoding (BPE) thereby ending up training the
Transformer in 10 different configurations. This led us to achieve a
state-of-the-art BLEU score of 24.53 on the test set of IIT Bombay
English-Hindi Corpus in one of the configurations. | [
0.0447159708,
0.0086658364,
0.0102781262,
0.0639588162,
-0.0641828924,
0.0034399608,
-0.0016510939,
0.0230825711,
-0.0370993838,
-0.0324263312,
0.0005642058,
-0.0549405888,
0.0018688921,
0.0605042577,
0.0087926649,
-0.0371104255,
0.0152070438,
0.0166486967,
0.0029890854,
0.0083492557,
-0.000917827,
0.0360109769,
-0.0222513657,
0.0174741689,
-0.0741673484,
0.0124868164,
0.0338774808,
0.0321887322,
0.0001155352,
-0.0165545102,
-0.0360087529,
0.0020134111,
0.0081192534,
0.0594220422,
0.0000020396,
-0.0427290164,
-0.0536040477,
0.0021292865,
-0.0007403803,
-0.0167661961,
0.0736865476,
-0.0459240675,
-0.0024402929,
0.0438478403,
-0.0055468571,
0.0112910047,
0.0775370151,
0.0624402389,
0.0571175106,
0.1029168516,
-0.0357862227,
-0.0776910782,
0.0656630844,
0.0025835312,
-0.0285657961,
-0.0103087788,
-0.0242731702,
-0.0001634922,
-0.0431035385,
0.0287320893,
-0.0428894088,
0.0231178496,
-0.0024433492,
-0.0205926467,
0.0024901931,
0.0040766476,
-0.0096885264,
-0.0411777198,
-0.0091218175,
0.0496832728,
-0.0745370761,
0.0046792021,
-0.0265550017,
-0.0081978729,
-0.0381357484,
-0.0123874201,
-0.0199210364,
0.0338809602,
-0.0120081697,
0.0366684981,
0.0093708513,
0.0299257673,
0.0316639356,
-0.0082852999,
0.0130662164,
-0.0109139746,
0.009358786,
-0.0167904813,
-0.0536272749,
-0.0347326212,
0.0129379751,
0.0227051452,
0.0871920064,
0.0070985979,
0.0165760312,
0.0218899567,
-0.0030616757,
-0.0703244135,
-0.0041184835,
-0.0700212121,
0.0092983162,
0.0568047799,
-0.0066621327,
0.015510642,
-0.0329442509,
0.0543777198,
-0.0214324705,
0.021730423,
-0.0258001518,
-0.0327949859,
-0.0088528218,
-0.0199541785,
-0.0368976705,
0.0280033275,
-0.0678604245,
-0.0101315472,
-0.0124245277,
-0.0069452608,
0.0124580432,
-0.0365480669,
0.0623394363,
-0.0040853783,
-0.0718846768,
-0.0473566651,
0.003113423,
0.0494379774,
-0.0108775795,
-0.0107801007,
0.0000311683,
-0.0633347481,
0.0027416209,
0.0057984958,
0.0070042517,
-0.0317891687,
-0.0096705519,
0.0669554174,
-0.0280578528,
-0.0342598632,
-0.0641452521,
0.0444010794,
-0.0002924732,
-0.0102522541,
-0.0286873467,
-0.0768358186,
0.0693763867,
0.0019254702,
0.01066346,
-0.0108608697,
0.0224118121,
0.0301328562,
-0.0075636893,
0.089506492,
-0.0147605566,
-0.0147973811,
0.0551137961,
0.0053304061,
0.0324197002,
-0.0002645748,
0.0856951997,
0.0293867867,
0.0098225893,
-0.0277444962,
0.0013840403,
0.0402743593,
-0.0373662822,
-0.0321995877,
-0.0318002664,
-0.0279916339,
-0.0110811898,
0.0618280284,
-0.0047632372,
0.0649388507,
-0.0194935054,
0.0590190403,
0.0210047197,
0.0331971273,
0.0647493899,
0.1342351437,
0.0144169107,
0.0201440975,
-0.0145080909,
-0.0110228471,
-0.0156925954,
0.0378978066,
0.0156232724,
-0.0411050729,
0.014446605,
0.02290342,
-0.0042878361,
-0.0223699622,
0.0113746915,
-0.0693065971,
0.0464053378,
-0.0756761059,
0.0223710965,
0.0291545093,
-0.0915222093,
0.0678609014,
0.0055561932,
-0.0739481598,
0.0373840071,
-0.0401661247,
-0.0359784178,
0.0404399261,
0.0326366015,
0.0174504146,
-0.0100559704,
-0.030807402,
-0.0444249325,
0.0418813415,
0.0223418586,
0.0291313026,
0.0074296515,
-0.0772763416,
0.0238801036,
0.0167510472,
-0.0349973924,
0.0327383019,
-0.0575243384,
0.012641741,
0.0342955813,
-0.0019015745,
-0.06278947,
0.0436716825,
-0.0040564528,
-0.031247925,
0.0390357077,
0.0105495835,
0.0205481742,
0.0152010908,
-0.0018862106,
-0.0223671086,
0.0230821148,
-0.0321969427,
-0.0422793925,
0.0196765047,
-0.0447523259,
-0.0428669639,
-0.0064730658,
-0.0751911774,
0.0468172468,
0.0786254108,
-0.0192365218,
-0.0820719525,
-0.018923834,
-0.0431279503,
0.0050672814,
-0.0305469763,
0.0440547578,
-0.0310997497,
0.012262647,
-0.0286298394,
0.0260361657,
0.0185195263,
-0.0181337353,
-0.025827283,
0.0037633311,
0.066317074,
0.0009318521,
-0.0306450948,
0.0444635712,
0.0041146949,
0.0437803008,
0.0567546748,
0.0281111989,
-0.0342351198,
-0.0491454825,
-0.081439741,
0.0285948906,
-0.0036148881,
0.0124320555,
0.0144506404,
0.0683176592,
0.0121673401,
-0.0090561267,
-0.0084797163,
0.0305834394,
0.0100904768,
-0.0355536751,
0.0522932522,
-0.0232609548,
0.0190782957,
-0.0022000745,
-0.0397259556,
-0.0205546245,
0.0301805846,
0.039128121,
-0.0379778966,
-0.0621967874,
0.0103344396,
0.0222694725,
0.0087310169,
0.0083398726,
-0.087670587,
-0.0143004498,
-0.0251675788,
0.022657983,
0.0307959449,
0.0396253094,
-0.0259905942,
-0.0045181108,
0.0240605548,
-0.0439342558,
0.0009002312,
-0.0232917648,
-0.0042219791,
-0.0148947909,
-0.0263965707,
0.0043696989,
0.0098565267,
0.0020855595,
0.0058364058,
-0.0441285856,
-0.0393255092,
-0.0128368437,
0.0106004812,
0.0212017633,
0.0471091606,
-0.0417286009,
0.0192592777,
-0.0284391437,
-0.0148866521,
0.0276559032,
-0.0342519172,
-0.0063407579,
-0.1132946461,
0.0250988957,
-0.026224969,
0.0065792771,
-0.0105011147,
0.0231560208,
-0.0659288317,
-0.0706376657,
-0.0367768109,
0.0149727687,
-0.0265031476,
-0.0446327776,
0.0102824783,
-0.0393690914,
0.0043540071,
-0.0387034453,
0.0106795896,
-0.0352745801,
-0.022130413,
0.0243213959,
0.0103168851,
0.0514173806,
-0.0269493926,
-0.0118115451,
0.0530869737,
-0.0282009989,
0.0287744068,
-0.0199746005,
0.0113514569,
-0.0276474841,
0.0367880128,
0.0257767309,
-0.0013597545,
0.0307004154,
0.0263762455,
0.0082290592,
-0.0325096697,
0.0195254087,
0.0139808767,
-0.0573677458,
-0.0269872639,
0.0129183047,
-0.0314914398,
0.0088707348,
-0.0100820428,
0.0258298311,
-0.0188963581,
-0.0350816622,
0.1040365472,
0.0300539136,
-0.0416644849,
-0.0430859029,
-0.0355900824,
-0.0481090248,
-0.0232297052,
0.0329273865,
-0.0472490489,
-0.0262270626,
-0.0079269055,
-0.0139375068,
0.0458278172,
0.0067572081,
-0.0185179897,
-0.0855460465,
-0.0339694917,
0.0071273274,
-0.00631072,
-0.0410306193,
-0.0020297426,
-0.0665263012,
-0.0200851616,
0.0531476736,
0.006968678,
-0.0077832164,
-0.0536710918,
0.0289914832,
0.0319702588,
-0.0180113222,
-0.0089263869,
-0.0636918321,
0.0085538002,
0.0790789202,
0.0354584455,
-0.0877429321,
-0.0034482661,
-0.0016097167,
-0.0076704556,
-0.0059924289,
0.0235894062,
0.0188711621,
-0.0243601631,
0.0010910532,
0.0303118825,
-0.0100123556,
-0.01691336,
0.0279947091,
-0.0128909014,
0.0410217606,
0.0158931911,
-0.0023960844,
-0.0155257517,
-0.0242673457,
0.001253144,
0.0086598406,
-0.0025578171,
-0.0498438887,
-0.0133938575,
-0.0036155605,
-0.0014552934,
-0.0525144078,
-0.0173991192,
0.0283590965,
-0.0427680351,
-0.0434989445,
-0.0563650541,
-0.0344228148,
0.00642337,
0.0294891167,
0.0488951541,
0.0204665046,
0.0287199765,
-0.0064762342,
-0.0468997434,
0.0105385939,
-0.014621566,
0.0360871218,
-0.0766628012,
0.0373237915,
0.0532004237,
-0.0068659619,
0.009702879,
0.0020879104,
-0.0266904011,
-0.02197727,
0.0173221752,
0.0590714328,
0.0168036092,
0.0158078615,
-0.041923929,
-0.0447427481,
0.0515620187,
0.0286176279,
-0.0184578914,
-0.0597745627,
0.0115221608,
-0.0011866807,
0.0018444564,
0.0207923148,
-0.0030967854,
-0.0097864838,
-0.0406666398,
0.0246804561,
0.01957063,
-0.0282392278,
0.0502379462,
-0.002635875,
0.0341914408,
-0.0359923504,
0.0249373876,
-0.0149776787,
0.0194979757,
0.0052931434,
0.0041652741,
-0.0230367389,
-0.0084661404,
0.0912847519,
0.0317986719,
0.0101998644,
-0.0144705484,
-0.0007923715,
-0.0136260251,
0.0482849851,
0.056940373,
-0.0004996159,
0.0703489184,
0.0139324842,
0.0123291528,
-0.0012849541,
-0.0462885015,
0.0242090151,
0.005209465,
-0.0297353454,
0.0571775734,
0.0059119384,
0.0211321563,
-0.0099937683,
0.0739726424,
0.0376879238,
0.0170288347,
-0.0083393939,
0.0093778176,
0.0365694948,
-0.018593207,
0.0663856268,
0.0061633955,
0.0087535791,
-0.0032868206,
0.0477119386,
-0.0442923643,
0.0405233614,
0.0299315713,
-0.0090796975,
0.0050037694,
-0.0057026618,
0.0226915851,
-0.0535345301,
-0.0212217141,
0.0263932422,
-0.0114872549,
-0.0268096644,
0.0269407704,
-0.0062276288,
0.0036678086,
0.0161637589,
-0.0104121491,
0.0028829416,
-0.0273739174,
0.0435805954,
-0.0256469976,
0.0608777702,
-0.0316379778,
0.033858981,
0.0693717375,
0.0074365921,
-0.0073958538,
-0.0249768402,
0.0323762633,
0.0166050941,
-0.0070792641,
-0.0489859395,
-5.995396613e-33,
-0.0187774263,
0.0006244931,
0.0015717364,
0.0003340874,
-0.0231163651,
-0.0210779291,
-0.0053322064,
-0.0415066443,
-0.0163892675,
0.0046333098,
-0.0307106525,
0.0298832282,
0.0209577419,
0.0168742985,
0.0307411328,
-0.0010893299,
0.0671747252,
0.0238519013,
0.0013963263,
0.0129725682,
0.0442030542,
0.0540981106,
0.084173739,
-0.023448348,
-0.0038875341,
-0.045844961,
-0.0140764592,
0.0307551417,
-0.0034400949,
0.0132423397,
-0.0043284679,
0.0119677605,
0.0363680497,
-0.0362239592,
-0.0102106268,
0.0277249794,
-0.0929711312,
0.0126678329,
0.001721588,
0.0895192474,
-0.0343360156,
-0.0455213375,
0.0914947018,
-0.0284983888,
-0.0297399592,
0.0113060353,
0.00420492,
-0.0067840843,
-0.014061613,
-0.0191670563,
-0.0730054006,
0.0079277903,
-0.0037223701,
-0.0159120671,
0.0333872028,
0.0309006516,
-0.0170164108,
-0.0314244069,
-0.0948944017,
-0.0141871404,
0.0227335133,
0.0385469943,
0.0393263921,
0.0394642055,
-0.0632689744,
-0.0321875215,
0.0145077966,
-0.0439025015,
0.0371669829,
0.0421866626,
0.0225440767,
0.0280802306,
0.0587213039,
0.0054679434,
0.0726422817,
-0.0947096944,
-0.0262152329,
0.0513533019,
-0.0200077724,
0.0607765056,
0.0097078728,
0.013227785,
-0.0274404362,
-0.0175097659,
0.0062823868,
-0.0193148311,
-0.0254278351,
-0.0684578791,
0.0165239722,
-0.0273421947,
-0.0525050387,
0.0145942774,
0.0311766807,
-0.0585085936,
0.0415651873,
-0.0101834321,
-0.03226934,
0.0205658302,
-0.0243895259,
0.0554499403,
-0.0164261311,
-0.0894209594,
-0.0208769348,
0.0403385088,
0.0041456786,
-0.000965484,
0.0307749789,
0.0083251456,
-0.049278222,
0.0075374851,
-0.0301109217,
-0.0084321108,
0.0098075364,
0.0525777377,
-0.0314735994,
-0.0073096952,
-0.0189109296,
0.0098053087,
0.0289053265,
0.0180900916,
-0.0033757205,
0.0297653992,
0.0255467109,
0.0168031659,
-0.068770349,
0.0055124406,
-0.0764580369,
-0.0041776234,
0.0479814969,
-0.0556608252,
-0.0203855336,
0.0174519196,
2.774e-7,
0.023994511,
0.0912277251,
0.0605412424,
-0.0366981067,
-0.0348386765,
0.0247033946,
-0.0055729202,
0.0287158601,
0.0218969975,
0.0661138222,
0.0246507712,
-0.0234591067,
0.0268285293,
-0.0033352592,
-0.1094330102,
-0.0243643727,
-0.0413765162,
0.0148840118,
-0.0533680096,
0.0200033337,
0.0488956235,
0.094127126,
0.0071094208,
-0.0139271291,
-0.0343652554,
-0.0365826711,
0.0413058661,
0.0152454823,
-0.0105830198,
0.0291598979,
0.0253278334,
0.0357113741,
-0.0499709249,
-0.0098780738,
-0.0169635266,
0.0391785204,
0.0253879298,
0.0539741404,
-0.0177108571,
0.0301713124,
0.0443528295,
0.0211831089,
-0.0062452918,
0.0048102005,
0.0421270095,
-0.0415049605,
-0.0454787984,
0.0061996276,
-0.0014455456,
0.0398569927,
0.0302145742,
-0.0365507156,
-0.0119417431,
-0.0095546525,
0.0378892794,
-0.0457758196,
-0.0320499279,
-0.0194890648,
-0.0017557895,
-0.0125865368,
0.0014786475,
-0.0066602905,
-0.0111662988,
-0.0123946695,
0.0275009852,
-0.0076111406,
0.0169776417,
2.102542001e-34,
0.0643960461,
-0.0122509608,
0.0311474446,
-0.0156446584,
0.0261412691,
-0.0085078152,
0.0139591834,
0.0129732247,
-0.0262354128,
-0.0448150523,
-0.0452602468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13205v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13205v1 | A Practical Survey on Zero-shot Prompt Design for In-context Learning | 2023-09-22T23:00:34 | 2023-09-22T23:00:34 | Yinheng Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.ET, cs.LG | The remarkable advancements in large language models (LLMs) have brought
about significant improvements in Natural Language Processing(NLP) tasks. This
paper presents a comprehensive review of in-context learning techniques,
focusing on different types of prompts, including discrete, continuous,
few-shot, and zero-shot, and their impact on LLM performance. We explore
various approaches to prompt design, such as manual design, optimization
algorithms, and evaluation methods, to optimize LLM performance across diverse
tasks. Our review covers key research studies in prompt engineering, discussing
their methodologies and contributions to the field. We also delve into the
challenges faced in evaluating prompt performance, given the absence of a
single "best" prompt and the importance of considering multiple metrics. In
conclusion, the paper highlights the critical role of prompt design in
harnessing the full potential of LLMs and provides insights into the
combination of manual design, optimization techniques, and rigorous evaluation
for more effective and efficient use of LLMs in various NLP tasks. | [
0.0260592643,
-0.0065162238,
0.0000081809,
0.0305549167,
-0.0710695758,
-0.0114063611,
0.0719158575,
-0.0054974053,
0.0164438896,
-0.0644152462,
-0.0096469522,
-0.0567927547,
-0.004351553,
0.0198200662,
-0.018932756,
-0.0322679691,
0.0570441596,
-0.0444636643,
0.0072752247,
0.0190853868,
-0.0418780819,
-0.0146088973,
-0.0356044732,
0.0482586697,
-0.0226019416,
-0.0494218357,
-0.0259486269,
0.0054253656,
0.0029590193,
-0.0636045709,
-0.0142800026,
0.0515059903,
0.0080374684,
0.0568040088,
0.0000021825,
-0.0724746808,
-0.0145283295,
0.0097074332,
-0.092846185,
-0.0086332643,
0.0603129268,
-0.0311455131,
-0.0092224739,
0.0215688758,
-0.0049601612,
-0.0068635773,
0.0326950476,
0.0173546281,
0.0276785549,
0.0668038055,
-0.0138299651,
-0.0138675999,
0.0149844605,
-0.0048710126,
0.0027959007,
-0.0385737307,
0.0246173237,
-0.0746801421,
0.0576130524,
0.0302418638,
-0.0212060846,
0.0278843101,
0.0085312901,
-0.0064627975,
0.037056651,
0.0284675341,
-0.0102345077,
-0.0458398238,
-0.0571378767,
0.0691311359,
-0.0063321651,
0.0263739247,
-0.0077632829,
-0.0526966117,
0.0103390319,
-0.0031267619,
-0.0356410742,
0.0375621878,
0.004596673,
-0.0046013095,
-0.0252471566,
0.0142938988,
-0.014015655,
0.0076260953,
-0.0463445857,
0.06242631,
0.0173467435,
-0.0370801389,
0.0120845856,
-0.0073921499,
-0.0234476719,
-0.0669723377,
-0.0123906126,
0.0499461442,
-0.1027078852,
0.0250611287,
-0.0217408258,
-0.0227168687,
0.0308934972,
0.0097551234,
0.0516990572,
0.0410180427,
-0.0154418927,
0.0587798618,
-0.0361043774,
0.0620997585,
0.0188063178,
-0.0078801541,
-0.0176876131,
0.023137765,
-0.0499916114,
0.0004202238,
-0.0485286564,
0.0176232774,
-0.0343339704,
-0.0526728295,
-0.0232865624,
0.0590770207,
0.0193282645,
0.0363605805,
-0.013196554,
-0.0187557489,
-0.0083373822,
-0.0085720764,
-0.0105717629,
0.0262860153,
-0.0406226851,
0.0012832735,
0.0098417141,
-0.0617452711,
-0.0243104417,
0.0038832244,
0.0245762598,
-0.0287620891,
-0.0301442407,
0.0422018655,
0.0081803715,
-0.0877415612,
-0.0296281409,
-0.0348219052,
-0.0307302456,
-0.0420404039,
-0.0372929163,
-0.0429999828,
0.0111915423,
-0.0023209711,
0.0314277224,
0.0017967264,
0.0053789588,
0.036072664,
-0.0100250542,
0.0798440948,
-0.0190059114,
0.0126861343,
-0.0028696544,
-0.021308573,
0.0047152722,
0.0900997818,
-0.0271715391,
0.0125702806,
0.0659495443,
0.0025979159,
-0.0051143356,
0.0463256203,
-0.0017773013,
0.0002696993,
-0.0238798745,
-0.0106177218,
0.0681112632,
0.0365006775,
-0.0026083991,
0.0292507038,
-0.0172250364,
0.0344799869,
0.0452543572,
0.0773836821,
0.0144048641,
-0.0488246568,
0.045348037,
0.0296426974,
-0.0178824998,
-0.0019502373,
-0.0214549601,
-0.0352871865,
-0.0488618501,
0.0132402666,
0.0078045037,
0.0149334874,
-0.0247560404,
-0.0017948035,
-0.0255032778,
-0.0029429789,
-0.029698994,
0.0223837122,
0.0320712924,
-0.0032189079,
-0.0675509349,
-0.0049486626,
0.0077174986,
-0.0223915763,
-0.0173656121,
-0.0438709632,
0.0394377969,
0.0715889111,
0.047867544,
-0.0242328122,
-0.0099832406,
-0.0282390881,
0.036911957,
0.0648842454,
0.0302043539,
-0.0153518459,
0.0006071659,
-0.0347086489,
-0.0521751307,
0.0172541402,
0.0175967887,
-0.0051955935,
0.0001176216,
0.0101798885,
0.0195813905,
0.0375146493,
0.0037040364,
0.0544169322,
-0.0265144873,
-0.0655931011,
0.0353468396,
0.0241452511,
0.0203193873,
0.0303207058,
-0.0084427875,
0.0077893091,
0.0325874835,
-0.0167851411,
0.0125962049,
-0.023003675,
-0.0587655008,
-0.0539598614,
0.0312397666,
0.0136367334,
0.0038991398,
-0.0229435638,
-0.0317269713,
-0.0434107371,
-0.070372887,
-0.0255932529,
0.0186563898,
-0.0213557854,
0.0482276641,
-0.0152563704,
-0.0026547527,
-0.0767090246,
0.0588083304,
0.0192423426,
0.0304854829,
0.0728862286,
0.0373071656,
0.0086079473,
-0.0614706799,
-0.0415187255,
0.0151499044,
-0.0033148476,
-0.0274484586,
0.0251093395,
0.0146091506,
-0.0496178493,
-0.0016878684,
-0.1010412052,
0.0105348881,
-0.0242105704,
-0.0134994024,
0.0049848272,
0.0204652399,
-0.0405237116,
-0.0270635188,
-0.004539731,
-0.0019124276,
0.0100682415,
0.0417450853,
0.0270637386,
0.0185053498,
-0.0351099707,
-0.0036093877,
-0.0092991795,
-0.0057124053,
0.0580052026,
0.0174424052,
-0.0313140564,
-0.0402017049,
0.0421364196,
0.033024855,
0.0074919532,
0.0143219531,
0.0487696789,
0.0115841031,
-0.0138706984,
0.0403722338,
0.0392596275,
0.0105086733,
0.0174765084,
0.0206364002,
-0.0096795568,
-0.055703681,
0.0096335867,
-0.0423605293,
-0.0286791138,
0.0182609111,
0.0126729412,
0.0401059836,
0.0565134585,
-0.0003184979,
-0.0104684606,
-0.0446664877,
0.0091392947,
-0.0280513056,
-0.0114202751,
-0.0959563106,
-0.0194316283,
-0.0325574353,
0.0523197688,
-0.0050206175,
-0.0340119414,
0.0526572727,
-0.0325228162,
0.025906885,
-0.0457276069,
0.0138081554,
-0.0336667523,
0.0373343937,
-0.015282061,
-0.0127013978,
0.0442386456,
-0.0480221026,
-0.0233042911,
0.0075455955,
0.0175519288,
-0.0094806897,
0.0151974838,
-0.0076157316,
0.0286263134,
-0.0248349775,
-0.0148700383,
-0.0674246252,
-0.0825027972,
-0.0360194854,
0.0182328261,
-0.0145395119,
0.0402331948,
-0.0081264414,
0.0181031115,
0.0105173523,
0.0417785048,
-0.0195397753,
-0.0073509542,
-0.0395560823,
0.0556806736,
0.0326575898,
0.0103851687,
0.0043462012,
-0.0094646569,
0.0819184706,
0.0154782003,
0.0428833775,
0.0264409184,
0.0021856676,
-0.0022010084,
0.0644050613,
-0.0611901022,
-0.0279178899,
0.0562664643,
0.0483152084,
-0.0684973449,
-0.0057848343,
0.125356555,
0.0587463602,
-0.0689392239,
0.0014561968,
-0.0127159795,
-0.0024708232,
0.0227715261,
0.018146161,
-0.0860457718,
-0.0472356491,
0.0235614218,
0.0199171528,
-0.047817748,
-0.0388379246,
-0.0174181443,
-0.16339764,
0.0368846953,
-0.0248598475,
-0.0120845335,
0.0017197062,
-0.0627138168,
0.0172780734,
0.0088023832,
0.033530049,
0.0263766255,
-0.0358227789,
-0.0212065745,
0.016445715,
0.0079692509,
-0.0676256716,
-0.0020022059,
-0.045809269,
0.0577877425,
0.0640293658,
-0.0081862547,
0.0197924152,
-0.0223219302,
0.0475688428,
-0.0302517153,
0.0275621396,
-0.0289094187,
0.0175925829,
-0.0190386083,
-0.0004388978,
-0.0118721901,
0.0254480094,
-0.0039845556,
-0.0362352841,
0.0258960184,
0.0844798759,
-0.0185884889,
0.0409854613,
-0.0295959152,
-0.0114844507,
0.0403920151,
0.086094752,
0.0165751725,
-0.0579622425,
-0.0200018194,
-0.0054378225,
-0.0064836349,
-0.0255049486,
-0.0086434055,
0.0047005336,
-0.0231515225,
-0.0307550412,
-0.0399104618,
-0.0133205242,
0.0543564446,
0.0440481119,
0.0207364988,
0.0075973249,
-0.0211678892,
0.0262703989,
-0.0007755945,
0.0179360528,
-0.0357998945,
0.0457394235,
-0.1044223532,
0.0407167748,
0.0370338038,
-0.0187406316,
-0.0096786143,
0.0178934131,
-0.0421158746,
-0.0439723097,
-0.007854294,
0.0115349088,
0.0172679611,
0.0293468572,
-0.0294856671,
-0.0609812103,
0.0925964043,
0.0542268343,
-0.020534303,
-0.0107802041,
-0.007799882,
0.0513800681,
-0.0336756557,
0.0130611928,
-0.0137407444,
0.0055179377,
0.0118313218,
0.0502728857,
-0.0035180948,
-0.0451287106,
0.0301781073,
0.0383834466,
0.0650985986,
-0.0220218152,
-0.0336578377,
-0.0371727385,
0.0285191536,
-0.0304656178,
-0.0196218435,
-0.009810783,
0.0070190909,
0.0236418974,
-0.0452537276,
0.0065902011,
-0.0038320001,
-0.0462482609,
0.0603637137,
-0.0603495613,
0.0219148248,
0.0126393344,
-0.0067073745,
0.0154482657,
0.0027318508,
-0.0140848728,
0.0369304754,
0.0127385948,
0.0124252122,
-0.0121916253,
0.0838065967,
0.0118388636,
0.0042885328,
-0.0246650819,
0.0308316126,
-0.056031093,
-0.0133470558,
-0.0255967639,
0.0702257901,
0.0365982316,
-0.0059784455,
-0.0176298246,
0.0019330631,
-0.0224948507,
-0.0325709358,
0.0185241457,
0.0436946191,
-0.0379796997,
0.0220078565,
0.0447590426,
-0.0143371206,
0.0005140437,
0.05677085,
-0.0191815794,
0.0272449311,
0.0005570151,
-0.0049585546,
-0.0519709066,
0.0357413217,
0.0263322406,
0.0327762738,
-0.0230092779,
0.0313952602,
-0.0991458148,
-0.026788814,
0.0240693819,
-0.0100636221,
0.0063061565,
0.0060836314,
0.0518080518,
0.0301512685,
0.0031370767,
0.0029515657,
-0.0308264662,
0.0189785492,
-0.0009419094,
-0.0285813324,
-0.0338775814,
-6.027035043e-33,
-0.0397724882,
-0.0291750766,
0.0120318867,
-0.0201164614,
-0.0153722176,
0.0256027225,
-0.0122901844,
0.0224229041,
-0.0097141741,
-0.0281093698,
-0.0564796589,
-0.0394850411,
0.0303093847,
0.0233680289,
-0.0162318479,
-0.0165751316,
0.0565753318,
-0.0177168883,
-0.0333704054,
-0.0245097522,
0.0203605033,
0.0360647924,
-0.0129492953,
0.0065076528,
0.0349018201,
0.0114263305,
-0.0099914055,
0.0296780709,
0.0167365503,
0.0409440249,
-0.0553671643,
0.0530332364,
0.0254404061,
-0.0683759674,
-0.0222226717,
0.0879019797,
-0.058111079,
-0.029770555,
0.0083892317,
0.0152686602,
-0.0267936047,
-0.0527503416,
-0.0157083888,
-0.0316855013,
-0.0364696644,
0.0103706708,
0.0189978983,
-0.0204953477,
-0.0498403385,
-0.0273387972,
-0.0625401661,
0.0202355087,
-0.0008224124,
-0.0462831445,
0.0431519337,
0.0534129776,
0.0099584078,
0.0389121585,
-0.0327421501,
0.0276933219,
0.0296297371,
0.015748227,
0.0480834581,
0.0406994186,
0.009692152,
0.0532971285,
0.025911266,
-0.0019018746,
-0.0117353629,
-0.0271363761,
0.0297838561,
-0.0156298447,
0.0203151889,
0.0531373769,
0.0412784778,
-0.0110003343,
-0.0456486642,
0.0012981194,
0.0307553336,
0.0103073427,
0.0436879881,
0.0008320684,
-0.0341348462,
-0.0194190778,
-0.0607431121,
-0.0468179733,
-0.0418633409,
0.0058239554,
0.0464189835,
0.0347716399,
-0.0317394026,
-0.0115933381,
0.0712178722,
-0.0163854826,
0.0012041189,
0.0037981858,
0.0126148723,
0.0331078917,
0.0034340038,
0.0076280008,
-0.0565853268,
-0.0204280876,
0.0185435042,
0.0037523208,
0.0061895833,
-0.0202497598,
0.0134916911,
0.0166817829,
-0.0629052445,
-0.0033252689,
-0.0130693298,
0.0316767469,
-0.0002384891,
0.0300860181,
0.0498684272,
-0.0034519427,
-0.01525917,
0.070235759,
0.0184444431,
-0.047454983,
0.0112335524,
-0.0007889998,
-0.0201684255,
-0.0017548009,
-0.0062291012,
-0.0002531584,
0.0169031359,
0.0523239002,
0.0375764035,
-0.0147431791,
-0.0089968387,
0.0087136123,
2.761e-7,
0.024152834,
0.0509453602,
0.01829594,
0.0110385027,
0.0090187015,
0.0201278813,
0.0076441467,
0.0103349686,
0.0025009031,
-0.0192899127,
-0.0070966026,
-0.0143469069,
0.0315402225,
0.0053994982,
-0.1177205443,
-0.0047616973,
-0.019460829,
0.049651958,
-0.0989345089,
0.0305761192,
0.099731192,
0.0808768347,
-0.0226940718,
-0.0136988265,
0.0031900089,
-0.0254422911,
0.0230059493,
-0.0274505764,
-0.0099235689,
0.0096205575,
0.0245957207,
-0.0138328867,
0.0169033967,
0.0481988676,
0.0079207756,
0.0330380574,
-0.0052108979,
0.0604989305,
0.0252416022,
-0.0344643891,
-0.0021848497,
-0.0010842574,
-0.0001165423,
-0.054295592,
0.1017995626,
-0.0469402783,
-0.0027965279,
-0.0332064368,
-0.0185197517,
-0.0407263301,
0.0404204614,
-0.0207491629,
-0.0194510408,
0.0205190592,
0.0284391847,
0.0165813044,
-0.0362784378,
-0.0649491325,
0.0009405427,
-0.0361530297,
-0.0202236753,
-0.0420617387,
-0.0280904025,
-0.0182485245,
0.0180256553,
-0.077600807,
-0.0020117434,
2.875331962e-34,
0.011627608,
-0.0172778685,
0.0374893919,
0.0351788402,
-0.0246341899,
0.0052063391,
-0.0039411825,
0.0155851059,
0.0477041192,
-0.1111278832,
-0.0116364975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13202v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13202v2 | Investigating Large Language Models and Control Mechanisms to Improve Text Readability of Biomedical Abstracts | 2023-09-22T22:47:32 | 2024-03-16T12:15:24 | Zihao Li, Samuel Belkadi, Nicolo Micheletti, Lifeng Han, Matthew Shardlow, Goran Nenadic | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Biomedical literature often uses complex language and inaccessible
professional terminologies. That is why simplification plays an important role
in improving public health literacy. Applying Natural Language Processing (NLP)
models to automate such tasks allows for quick and direct accessibility for lay
readers. In this work, we investigate the ability of state-of-the-art large
language models (LLMs) on the task of biomedical abstract simplification, using
the publicly available dataset for plain language adaptation of biomedical
abstracts (\textbf{PLABA}). The methods applied include domain fine-tuning and
prompt-based learning (PBL) on: 1) Encoder-decoder models (T5, SciFive, and
BART), 2) Decoder-only GPT models (GPT-3.5 and GPT-4) from OpenAI and BioGPT,
and 3) Control-token mechanisms on BART-based models. We used a range of
automatic evaluation metrics, including BLEU, ROUGE, SARI, and BERTscore, and
also conducted human evaluations. BART-Large with Control Token (BART-L-w-CT)
mechanisms reported the highest SARI score of 46.54 and T5-base reported the
highest BERTscore 72.62. In human evaluation, BART-L-w-CTs achieved a better
simplicity score over T5-Base (2.9 vs. 2.2), while T5-Base achieved a better
meaning preservation score over BART-L-w-CTs (3.1 vs. 2.6). We also categorised
the system outputs with examples, hoping this will shed some light for future
research on this task. Our code, fine-tuned models, and data splits are
available at \url{https://github.com/HECTA-UoM/PLABA-MU} \begin{IEEEkeywords}
Large Language Models, Text Simplification, Biomedical NLP, Control Mechanisms,
Health Informatics \end{IEEEkeywords} | [
0.0213920847,
0.0052261506,
0.0104001909,
0.003477291,
-0.0393331014,
0.0301664677,
0.0176051222,
0.0214581247,
0.0098983375,
-0.0109208468,
-0.0409809127,
-0.0135683008,
0.0464773104,
0.0566397905,
0.0245444831,
-0.0760633498,
0.0302758478,
-0.0098994197,
0.0478478223,
0.0147291264,
0.0005482389,
-0.0033018987,
-0.0097936494,
0.0459410697,
0.1001211107,
-0.0326095,
0.038490925,
-0.0004211498,
0.0289839655,
-0.0410296023,
0.0051485505,
0.0552160479,
-0.0069086356,
0.014731748,
0.0000022113,
-0.0409710854,
-0.0348097943,
0.0530764163,
0.0109715331,
0.0588169396,
0.0853028595,
-0.0576098375,
-0.0053607733,
0.008502963,
-0.0097257094,
-0.0359008014,
0.0462975726,
0.0616208948,
0.0393606052,
0.049074769,
-0.018656278,
-0.043228779,
0.0304983128,
-0.0060282191,
-0.0078111063,
-0.0355309658,
0.0447305776,
-0.0013617121,
0.0185938645,
0.0200006925,
-0.0349551961,
0.0369038805,
-0.0110508241,
0.0005241244,
0.0192163754,
0.0346816517,
-0.0124588404,
-0.0250481721,
0.0059772041,
0.0725456625,
-0.0186837167,
-0.0379756056,
0.010640543,
-0.0061975932,
-0.0194607656,
0.0180795733,
-0.0621775389,
-0.0178589448,
-0.0218707174,
0.0161424503,
0.0176479742,
0.0020451252,
0.0260747001,
0.0270692352,
-0.025365185,
0.0171710048,
0.0333484486,
-0.053855516,
0.0074223788,
-0.0169767924,
-0.0198032111,
-0.0256550759,
0.0974636152,
0.0291352049,
-0.0268995091,
0.0100282095,
-0.0152981821,
-0.100524351,
0.0423829071,
-0.0250294544,
0.0001084071,
0.0347060822,
-0.0311820582,
0.0157755353,
-0.024742756,
0.0400851741,
-0.0332866907,
0.0555341579,
-0.0251932554,
0.0169023201,
0.0012223913,
-0.0035741138,
-0.0364730172,
0.0174108855,
-0.0736514255,
-0.0268883388,
-0.0640538409,
-0.0335656218,
0.0196097679,
-0.0282035433,
0.0198054928,
-0.0247779619,
-0.0483476259,
-0.0192403067,
0.0200183075,
0.0738559365,
-0.0022691966,
-0.0153161939,
-0.0148349991,
-0.0586159937,
-0.0137774041,
-0.0048511508,
0.0216943119,
-0.0199100282,
-0.0086686732,
0.0100126546,
-0.0237656739,
-0.0260670874,
0.0096496874,
0.0006524425,
0.0011685597,
-0.0084423255,
-0.020737268,
-0.0533185005,
0.0312377755,
-0.0073461011,
0.0152297616,
-0.0566137955,
-0.005016394,
0.0103701856,
-0.0558576286,
0.0645177439,
-0.0504214354,
0.0034807627,
0.0512054488,
0.0238275137,
-0.0091268159,
0.0120818513,
0.0424440093,
-0.0279786848,
0.0018478156,
-0.0340158194,
0.0328609198,
0.014345983,
0.0119218659,
-0.0244839787,
0.0481685475,
-0.01099547,
-0.0201254617,
0.0704535916,
0.0236320365,
0.0820535794,
-0.033486072,
0.0112411948,
0.0436425023,
0.0716948509,
0.01354839,
0.0271894727,
0.0231027082,
0.0168977678,
0.0562582538,
0.0032331268,
0.0102009987,
-0.0194085017,
-0.0176036693,
0.0371961817,
0.0300645679,
0.0099370619,
-0.0093919365,
-0.0290661901,
0.0020407885,
-0.0129064629,
0.0067110169,
-0.0340963528,
0.0580902956,
0.016147634,
-0.0960479826,
0.0061733858,
0.0428633541,
-0.0588174984,
0.0359448045,
-0.0451788232,
0.0164978709,
0.0584859177,
0.0815629661,
-0.026671052,
-0.0331832804,
-0.0028325398,
-0.0023203536,
0.0579997897,
0.0266125854,
0.0017798069,
-0.0052902391,
-0.0771090314,
-0.0079877051,
0.0426294133,
0.0097644934,
-0.0002203855,
-0.0153571004,
0.0117915813,
-0.0044205808,
-0.0501744077,
-0.0533296727,
0.0478547923,
-0.0686932355,
-0.0204389021,
-0.0266362056,
0.0012308171,
0.033045467,
0.0037265059,
0.0100628342,
0.0383970141,
0.0136637557,
-0.0451592617,
0.0067111216,
0.0023333386,
-0.028915897,
-0.0280833729,
0.0069295592,
-0.0500711538,
0.0017293711,
0.0467550717,
-0.028323641,
-0.0239998214,
-0.0261624511,
-0.0391334705,
-0.0128706442,
-0.0033627558,
0.0312460661,
0.0002773647,
0.000152058,
-0.0301388819,
0.0070755514,
-0.0011392419,
0.0129361115,
0.0457414202,
-0.0312113781,
-0.0003367393,
-0.0326534808,
0.007641457,
0.0040007387,
-0.002776355,
-0.0255621411,
0.0106343348,
0.0379980057,
-0.0187531523,
-0.0014976281,
-0.0984843373,
0.0023765434,
-0.0037323383,
0.0259568375,
0.0441629328,
0.0114129856,
-0.0047778618,
0.0032720338,
0.0004845496,
-0.0297086239,
-0.0226036012,
0.011491593,
0.0364670902,
0.0021161297,
-0.0264535341,
-0.0502409376,
-0.023011677,
-0.0253137704,
0.0433560275,
0.0315170176,
-0.060447026,
-0.0392853916,
0.0205343813,
0.0257028099,
-0.0280250907,
0.0219401419,
-0.0252801403,
-0.0079219006,
0.0022354461,
0.0408385955,
0.0653300807,
0.0168039165,
0.0354201607,
0.0370774753,
0.0441592708,
-0.0275130942,
0.0047191647,
-0.0373205952,
-0.0213511661,
-0.0126402853,
-0.0666354001,
0.0535572246,
0.0652169213,
0.0033019984,
0.0117677618,
-0.0727023855,
-0.0250866376,
-0.0428091809,
-0.0466921069,
-0.0451150686,
-0.0196411628,
-0.0392200649,
0.0226351414,
-0.0087991273,
-0.0279745907,
0.0887590125,
-0.0159368124,
0.0074212225,
-0.1100249067,
0.0298770256,
-0.0337130278,
-0.0119620254,
-0.0141920513,
0.0253552198,
0.0263055023,
-0.0551274829,
0.0127644502,
0.0133918887,
-0.0177249331,
-0.0446036272,
0.0106252609,
-0.0650777072,
-0.0062993504,
-0.00358797,
-0.033636678,
0.0112529919,
-0.0029250099,
-0.0170839783,
0.0097393794,
0.047541637,
-0.0108725252,
-0.0449321754,
0.0268026963,
0.0191299412,
0.0887844935,
-0.0219883062,
-0.0028942912,
-0.0328642204,
0.0182452053,
0.0420162044,
-0.0132831773,
0.0390316583,
-0.0443924218,
0.0196747277,
0.0413768999,
-0.0204736311,
-0.0079899486,
-0.0005554734,
-0.0050124596,
0.0281625353,
-0.065916203,
0.0160280503,
0.0215791669,
0.0449252687,
-0.0721912831,
-0.0331498757,
0.1253301948,
0.0295636076,
-0.0592363812,
0.0063516288,
-0.0297393389,
-0.0067993682,
-0.0618594289,
0.005106064,
-0.0609162562,
-0.0286317393,
0.0196290407,
0.0564722121,
0.0020703624,
-0.0149033619,
0.0158239473,
-0.0529214554,
0.0373907015,
0.0405305959,
-0.0780910775,
-0.0567073077,
-0.0640047044,
-0.0035214997,
-0.017057009,
0.0412820242,
0.0386327058,
-0.0109309144,
0.0066537312,
-0.0122878449,
-0.0538357832,
-0.1025055125,
-0.0232929494,
-0.0273460466,
0.0430995226,
0.0610044338,
0.0318434983,
-0.0057511507,
-0.0160284732,
0.0508251786,
-0.0213822797,
-0.019270042,
-0.0356805474,
0.0406832956,
0.0181650929,
0.0147987092,
-0.043280106,
0.0600674264,
-0.033028122,
-0.0110054146,
-0.0282480735,
0.0619606972,
0.0004203755,
-0.0392404683,
-0.0277940128,
0.005656349,
-0.0006875307,
0.094506599,
0.0509843826,
-0.0038380171,
-0.0523237176,
-0.0076672132,
0.0169135667,
-0.0379509144,
-0.0296021029,
-0.0065488955,
-0.0664297938,
-0.0437907502,
-0.0598152205,
-0.0048547438,
0.0595713593,
-0.036572963,
0.0449763872,
0.0299135614,
0.0535968989,
-0.0096866358,
-0.0367175788,
0.0438870639,
0.0051908013,
0.0000791657,
-0.079689309,
-0.0233274512,
0.0245164447,
0.0135499164,
-0.0181742664,
0.0436240025,
0.0112717273,
-0.0298183803,
-0.0047539431,
0.0402530245,
0.0242641419,
-0.0132886097,
-0.0037478141,
-0.0554274693,
0.0299838707,
0.0374653041,
-0.0075321412,
0.0079881102,
-0.0168266669,
0.015685847,
-0.0057807439,
0.0030016289,
-0.0164436009,
0.0057726013,
-0.0075984173,
0.057076633,
0.0382614173,
-0.0002900763,
0.0273531843,
0.0646885708,
0.0202268939,
-0.0255302172,
-0.0358693898,
-0.0327191502,
0.0014694018,
-0.0386658274,
0.0524312109,
-0.0318907239,
0.017179193,
0.057789851,
0.0132867424,
-0.0377874672,
0.0528269596,
-0.0250941403,
-0.0298385825,
-0.0407835543,
0.0397534445,
-0.027145138,
0.0382756628,
0.0487274714,
-0.0370128788,
-0.038856212,
-0.0187746566,
-0.0301206969,
0.0093876198,
0.0041344268,
0.025021458,
0.0313384831,
0.0365145393,
-0.0113150207,
0.0638898537,
-0.0355126783,
-0.0178688597,
-0.0324818417,
0.0388251543,
0.0164267104,
0.0222280622,
0.0888944492,
-0.033128161,
-0.0170421321,
-0.0484348387,
0.0415918194,
0.0073287352,
0.0231633987,
0.0316988006,
-0.0079737874,
0.0058915475,
-0.0422655493,
0.0885819048,
0.0063504255,
0.0382070914,
0.0200616475,
-0.032344915,
-0.0164471418,
-0.0242385473,
-0.0200249068,
0.0142351361,
-0.0656057224,
-0.0139470166,
-0.0536215343,
-0.0118833547,
0.0410411656,
0.003058868,
-0.0035396006,
-0.0172181893,
0.0198925734,
0.012828378,
-0.0201717,
-0.0663671717,
-0.0061712121,
0.0433993973,
-0.0199269466,
-0.0518602058,
-0.0278714336,
-6.249485594e-33,
-0.0126001434,
-0.0160960499,
0.0094569568,
-0.0181276072,
-0.0317912288,
-0.0003340019,
-0.0991279706,
-0.0347789973,
0.014006515,
0.0519637652,
-0.0129672689,
-0.0080209309,
0.0163277034,
0.0269566607,
-0.0320168249,
-0.0078325085,
0.0539788194,
-0.0027073177,
-0.0265899654,
0.0167635102,
-0.0043249284,
0.0474177375,
0.0142570753,
-0.0603356324,
0.0280395541,
0.005466396,
-0.0138582708,
-0.0069996971,
0.0062990584,
0.0358410999,
-0.0358880833,
0.0178759936,
0.0250714086,
-0.0073379087,
-0.0371603929,
0.0614541844,
-0.0988291353,
0.0264570862,
0.0399615057,
-0.0139745483,
-0.0669079199,
-0.0687156841,
0.0683709905,
0.0071449359,
-0.0402482748,
-0.0140542593,
0.0229155831,
-0.0522142835,
-0.0113516878,
-0.0709746778,
-0.0707580373,
0.0241247583,
-0.0252324454,
-0.0143375751,
0.0430085957,
-0.0011737415,
-0.060806863,
0.0683861151,
0.0017604753,
0.0065947436,
0.092443496,
0.0337577499,
0.0270443168,
-0.0348618068,
0.0125663653,
0.0042333235,
-0.0019271623,
-0.0035108312,
-0.0035205353,
-0.0311136097,
0.0166436471,
0.0168479849,
0.0575448908,
0.0002575569,
0.0434413962,
0.0013341786,
-0.0640658513,
0.0598477609,
-0.0560606942,
0.0414685979,
0.0132688563,
0.0188497063,
-0.0257356223,
-0.00357143,
-0.0343717188,
0.025364833,
-0.0220833234,
-0.0098674884,
0.0304898825,
-0.031566076,
-0.0195862651,
-0.0060103852,
0.0155184716,
-0.0210007913,
0.0230426285,
0.0028464356,
0.0393156186,
0.0367934369,
-0.0256599747,
-0.0060787983,
-0.0489459299,
-0.0097983526,
0.0268340595,
0.0005142914,
0.0220040381,
-0.006734171,
0.0127176913,
-0.0073212972,
-0.0378933661,
0.0043868707,
0.0108827297,
-0.0341558717,
0.0386773571,
0.0414580889,
0.0122231962,
0.0135889612,
0.0205846969,
0.0454426296,
0.0058460892,
-0.0089670401,
-0.0121040335,
0.0136155803,
0.0132503277,
0.0258837398,
-0.0312122945,
0.0105722472,
-0.0169490818,
0.0288389549,
0.0255412403,
-0.0491152108,
-0.0170794204,
-0.0009082443,
2.844e-7,
0.0888752788,
0.0974150822,
0.0424105749,
-0.0059781675,
0.0171774514,
-0.0110928807,
0.0023160987,
0.016194284,
0.0137433177,
0.0165184774,
0.047607407,
-0.0144486576,
0.05725272,
-0.0335267484,
-0.0813222155,
0.0032842979,
-0.0459073223,
-0.0062599168,
-0.0597904138,
-0.003502327,
0.0449100286,
0.0308765825,
-0.0592094548,
0.0055410806,
0.0342837982,
0.0039579915,
0.0340093449,
-0.0557335541,
0.0094444687,
0.0592594407,
0.0145835085,
-0.0056786174,
0.0159534886,
0.0070981174,
-0.0325821675,
-0.0272119511,
0.0327620357,
0.1061952114,
-0.0116475755,
0.0318031088,
0.0388401449,
-0.009671065,
0.0189164318,
-0.0357243568,
0.0244002528,
-0.0725110322,
-0.0289756916,
0.0084323091,
-0.0507836714,
-0.0116507551,
0.0209160782,
-0.0408593044,
-0.0239295326,
0.0456254967,
0.010913386,
0.0090340935,
-0.0229183752,
-0.0472129025,
-0.0074624475,
0.0104075745,
-0.0085491166,
-0.031217929,
-0.0247329157,
-0.0006349315,
-0.003362579,
-0.1124511063,
0.0009614564,
2.98538211e-34,
0.0725549757,
-0.036456693,
0.006776466,
0.0463155247,
0.0244011357,
-0.0343932137,
-0.0062595778,
0.0319893807,
-0.0019348447,
-0.0961840972,
0.0024747581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13184v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13184v1 | Document Understanding for Healthcare Referrals | 2023-09-22T21:19:47 | 2023-09-22T21:19:47 | Jimit Mistry, Natalia M. Arzeno | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, I.2.7; I.7.5 | Reliance on scanned documents and fax communication for healthcare referrals
leads to high administrative costs and errors that may affect patient care. In
this work we propose a hybrid model leveraging LayoutLMv3 along with
domain-specific rules to identify key patient, physician, and exam-related
entities in faxed referral documents. We explore some of the challenges in
applying a document understanding model to referrals, which have formats
varying by medical practice, and evaluate model performance using MUC-5 metrics
to obtain appropriate metrics for the practical use case. Our analysis shows
the addition of domain-specific rules to the transformer model yields greatly
increased precision and F1 scores, suggesting a hybrid model trained on a
curated dataset can increase efficiency in referral management. | [
0.0665230826,
-0.0205557812,
0.0063711056,
-0.0193645656,
-0.0096152881,
0.039016746,
-0.0054029361,
0.0544649027,
-0.0322576277,
-0.0549571887,
-0.0395549089,
-0.0586113334,
0.0227506589,
0.0312431995,
-0.0157866981,
-0.057591524,
0.0130033474,
0.0213144924,
0.021205049,
0.062149059,
-0.0188091267,
0.0035695692,
-0.0121882148,
0.0260945931,
-0.0194521584,
-0.0289244615,
-0.0286739264,
0.041818928,
-0.0018060599,
-0.0201680306,
0.0049355142,
0.0392964073,
-0.0311087053,
-0.0108084483,
0.0000016598,
-0.025870977,
-0.0439544134,
0.0262621697,
-0.0452196971,
-0.0212379787,
0.091237545,
-0.0925070345,
-0.0051467437,
-0.0038102963,
-0.0040153302,
-0.033180967,
-0.0006004459,
0.1246848926,
0.0128377182,
0.0707011968,
-0.0418976769,
0.0025010125,
0.0348107964,
-0.0061605149,
0.0152777955,
-0.0528992191,
0.0112043964,
0.030917041,
-0.0112062944,
-0.0276531912,
0.0169252139,
0.0077261133,
-0.0111905234,
-0.0063097053,
0.0250064489,
0.0203409102,
-0.0025804075,
0.0221484005,
-0.0051785284,
0.0535696857,
-0.0172911081,
0.0350668393,
0.0294513609,
-0.0169093553,
0.0049525802,
0.0310621802,
-0.0420802981,
-0.0549624898,
-0.0327750295,
-0.0265622362,
-0.0296900049,
0.0134347128,
0.0027616306,
-0.024785528,
-0.0163227879,
-0.0275207758,
-0.010252336,
-0.0286709927,
0.0097956527,
0.0069216611,
0.0802356228,
-0.0292013045,
0.0513035506,
0.0155570805,
0.0030265087,
-0.0053418009,
0.0018469412,
-0.0307295676,
0.0931522995,
-0.0099229785,
0.0089545632,
-0.0117311142,
-0.0136648538,
0.0724659264,
-0.0108999945,
0.0323518254,
-0.0397510044,
0.0215482246,
-0.0485169105,
0.0276323967,
-0.0361744128,
-0.0079590892,
-0.0125406422,
0.0124765169,
0.0169532616,
-0.0278665889,
-0.0374096632,
-0.0210257359,
0.0122879995,
0.0312513709,
0.0584955141,
0.0094182333,
-0.0268161148,
0.0004180115,
-0.0160911959,
0.0315096043,
0.0142512945,
-0.0064884485,
-0.0438668206,
-0.0252177212,
0.0495605618,
0.0215860885,
0.0224822685,
-0.0011155212,
-0.0316987969,
0.0284654461,
0.0012931329,
-0.0578413643,
-0.0352042876,
-0.0638976246,
-0.0112472791,
-0.0188504588,
0.0532698333,
-0.0212638695,
0.0120241027,
0.0112030804,
0.00377849,
-0.0229381695,
-0.0026983288,
-0.0020985336,
-0.0311780348,
0.0449785367,
0.015596862,
0.0254245605,
0.040444646,
0.0212328322,
-0.0094519071,
-0.0076581263,
-0.0265552439,
0.0151772583,
0.0019561481,
-0.0259601753,
0.0406053327,
0.0297513157,
0.0170993339,
-0.0660056174,
0.0508141741,
0.0347175449,
0.0064339396,
0.0039616283,
-0.0155866267,
0.037101984,
-0.025232641,
-0.0194122791,
0.0135924695,
0.0313671194,
0.0543114096,
-0.003217794,
-0.0009394405,
0.0060784612,
-0.0345799662,
-0.0019482048,
-0.0342535637,
-0.0013701854,
0.0281132255,
0.0299891084,
-0.0421677157,
-0.0237442143,
-0.048865322,
-0.027754223,
-0.052214738,
-0.0162239987,
-0.0312367603,
-0.0600386672,
0.0687394291,
0.0076370887,
-0.0619325228,
0.0792739764,
-0.0239648968,
-0.0182263833,
-0.0488842055,
-0.0321576111,
-0.0295200311,
0.0612895191,
0.0826703981,
-0.0391018912,
-0.0269361176,
-0.0403372236,
0.0058473134,
-0.0279353373,
0.0710097998,
-0.0254978202,
0.0001896253,
-0.0490709879,
-0.0481925532,
0.0490404293,
0.0072525437,
-0.0371772088,
0.0080418205,
0.0051562297,
0.0116877062,
-0.1004129499,
-0.0239283554,
0.0359667316,
0.008001538,
-0.0241421163,
-0.0042466181,
0.0337105915,
0.0370679423,
0.0426943749,
0.0138907395,
-0.0046659182,
0.0640497729,
0.0159162357,
0.0327625908,
-0.0076060332,
-0.0224852003,
0.041545812,
0.0199373253,
-0.0134392828,
-0.0122752134,
-0.0130352341,
-0.0223751049,
-0.00177368,
-0.0659098774,
-0.0296645965,
0.032445211,
-0.0352204032,
0.0447448455,
0.0541623347,
-0.0050395825,
-0.0299868155,
0.0312033016,
-0.0263144318,
-0.0018560286,
0.0414015092,
-0.0584859625,
0.0138469292,
-0.0064726649,
0.0420834199,
-0.01482502,
-0.0500964001,
0.0136146005,
-0.0122476742,
0.0380384587,
-0.0185071323,
-0.0416301377,
-0.0497496687,
-0.0189102497,
-0.012387624,
-0.0021784701,
0.0440012552,
0.007052904,
0.0034273998,
-0.0347093865,
-0.0325230658,
-0.0361785255,
0.0137387542,
-0.0425375625,
0.038382519,
0.0119782118,
-0.0222027041,
0.0016391259,
-0.0240158588,
-0.0389891341,
0.0235161241,
0.0451138429,
-0.0258263815,
-0.04284795,
0.0059213219,
-0.0001892164,
-0.0275571961,
-0.0117579307,
0.003601749,
-0.0424679071,
-0.0173889603,
-0.0072692987,
0.0483757965,
-0.0364240371,
0.0354049802,
0.0080693765,
-0.0067451564,
-0.0300470646,
-0.0035181979,
-0.0264244005,
0.0243276339,
0.009634072,
-0.0789462179,
0.0250860993,
0.0276047997,
-0.0057694451,
0.0182766896,
-0.0023103487,
-0.0246856119,
-0.011782703,
0.004295914,
-0.0366169699,
0.0217071455,
-0.0000769581,
0.0748223364,
0.0100356042,
-0.0094332471,
0.0514481999,
-0.0384926237,
0.0177224353,
-0.0495588072,
-0.0058253598,
-0.0484291092,
0.0107209468,
0.0057064379,
0.017864272,
0.0329964831,
-0.0455617532,
0.0100267734,
0.0107081924,
-0.0129239941,
-0.0376299582,
0.0686662123,
0.0056749345,
0.0433472097,
-0.0265133716,
-0.0218971111,
-0.0549900122,
0.0069808182,
0.0421078354,
0.009075419,
-0.0128814932,
0.0176443215,
-0.13382411,
0.0845098495,
-0.0179859549,
0.0917581916,
-0.0069450797,
-0.0380899981,
-0.006513474,
0.0764934123,
0.0280535202,
-0.0295340419,
-0.0001198203,
-0.0276968405,
0.0057984442,
0.0505971834,
-0.0007107652,
0.0087264935,
0.0058328104,
0.0162341204,
-0.0148177519,
-0.0458848402,
0.0006955405,
0.0202017818,
0.0069877901,
-0.057565596,
0.0101012429,
0.098599799,
0.0462031402,
-0.0621322468,
-0.0264138188,
-0.0527991764,
-0.043795716,
-0.0209094416,
0.0340401269,
-0.0361202247,
0.0095476862,
0.0035183176,
0.039701812,
0.0260300133,
0.0080418075,
0.0487427041,
-0.0009783637,
0.0651052967,
-0.0009905874,
-0.0292253867,
-0.0746294186,
-0.0145433657,
0.0086965691,
-0.0134751545,
-0.0238918569,
-0.0057481178,
-0.0637660027,
-0.0511625782,
-0.0137513867,
-0.0238598697,
-0.0472363606,
-0.0004554031,
0.0016386771,
-0.0344322324,
0.0406017266,
0.027643675,
0.0127981212,
-0.0384518877,
-0.0094418647,
0.0182867143,
0.0032304546,
-0.0163942557,
0.10934145,
-0.0028476815,
0.0549261272,
-0.0338866562,
0.0238222722,
-0.0600753948,
-0.0249330793,
-0.0141587649,
0.0510496534,
-0.026927324,
-0.0276450366,
-0.0103065148,
0.0182224624,
-0.000369718,
0.0367130265,
-0.0049565225,
0.0023588969,
-0.0309861451,
-0.0103671057,
0.0948181078,
0.0433643088,
0.0148065807,
0.0309140328,
-0.0592538938,
-0.0605957471,
-0.0523190312,
-0.0381610058,
0.0176146552,
0.0056159496,
0.0114853876,
-0.0302491877,
-0.0024160836,
-0.0089916419,
-0.0390212052,
0.0374877676,
0.0039010397,
0.0084809493,
-0.0696327016,
0.0112797963,
0.031121416,
-0.0046347361,
-0.0230074618,
0.0166255422,
-0.0048587248,
0.0266066808,
-0.0053894818,
0.0243998226,
0.0305066165,
0.0066562272,
0.021487616,
0.0177919101,
-0.0207202993,
0.0008596276,
-0.0494661108,
-0.0305816941,
0.0151520241,
-0.0665430203,
-0.0408516861,
-0.0037099044,
-0.0283815078,
0.0219620336,
0.0115176486,
-0.0022059069,
-0.0561565273,
-0.0449857786,
-0.0244785417,
-0.0032126338,
0.0092416899,
0.0224983431,
0.0217177868,
-0.0465762578,
0.0473255664,
0.0096590202,
0.0312822536,
0.0014227305,
-0.0351950414,
-0.0024636725,
0.0134648681,
-0.0102426577,
-0.0163126234,
-0.0638421327,
0.0136773093,
0.0045773545,
-0.0125191109,
0.0195096582,
-0.0002076676,
0.0086457813,
-0.0460985862,
0.0056219231,
0.0175855123,
0.0292826444,
0.0404429249,
-0.0049965633,
0.0923280418,
-0.0204113647,
0.0550672151,
-0.0182615463,
0.0229785703,
-0.0206680894,
-0.0437222309,
-0.0147108948,
0.004001339,
0.0109085841,
-0.0237316377,
0.0262216683,
-0.0390995815,
0.007505259,
-0.0135403685,
0.0275556203,
0.0258819982,
0.0163868628,
0.0248943195,
0.0198825672,
0.0260113943,
-0.010075382,
0.0517438315,
-0.0043069585,
0.0284074191,
-0.0528081581,
-0.0560257211,
-0.0904072002,
-0.0033395982,
0.0395143516,
0.0127144149,
-0.0285375677,
-0.0235052872,
-0.0873055831,
-0.0107641779,
0.0736732408,
-0.0290410817,
-0.0090890778,
0.0011926444,
0.0556213781,
0.0580491684,
0.0001665724,
-0.0697671995,
-0.04625104,
0.0188804269,
-0.004904767,
0.003451864,
-0.0139746945,
-5.257748194e-33,
-0.015936261,
-0.0366946384,
0.0050136461,
-0.0007018649,
0.0210246108,
0.0378837436,
0.0073746503,
-0.0431491025,
0.0300863963,
0.0017660412,
-0.0263991449,
-0.0091864979,
0.0343881324,
0.0271998327,
-0.0044570677,
-0.0090512289,
0.059052702,
-0.0053602508,
-0.0256928001,
0.0089678336,
-0.0359765366,
0.0472179502,
0.0184993185,
-0.0763335228,
-0.0045807036,
0.0129069146,
0.0170022212,
0.0110570053,
0.031190386,
0.0623835251,
-0.0235274266,
-0.0522647835,
0.0539337471,
-0.037043225,
0.0287696104,
0.0564708449,
-0.1211382076,
0.00586368,
-0.0058936826,
0.0492240936,
0.0144401593,
-0.0290537886,
0.0274797231,
-0.0246688295,
0.0005174188,
-0.0398810394,
0.0642021298,
-0.0066923923,
-0.022394212,
-0.017256448,
-0.0375836976,
0.0579257496,
-0.0170195792,
0.018752072,
0.0258689579,
0.0427474193,
-0.0267364737,
0.0510452166,
-0.1046876386,
-0.0224046726,
0.0160608292,
0.0101201851,
0.0725850165,
-0.0278832149,
-0.0598643795,
0.0149997193,
0.0221197251,
0.0045404756,
-0.0315670446,
-0.0431924202,
-0.0200069156,
0.0420677811,
0.0171270669,
0.0014112662,
0.0084681828,
0.0162991434,
-0.0200557653,
0.1009170413,
-0.0439649783,
0.094013989,
0.0306728911,
-0.0147491843,
-0.0461441055,
0.036552906,
0.012878566,
-0.0243020784,
-0.0070146802,
-0.0451985262,
0.0600369759,
0.0262652729,
0.0015343003,
-0.0088517936,
0.02999424,
-0.0109981317,
-0.0063238852,
0.0201101303,
0.0437736809,
0.0481527708,
-0.0676918328,
-0.0302812122,
-0.0382230654,
-0.0090986155,
0.0297167115,
0.0093661677,
0.023015907,
-0.0102899522,
0.0429489873,
-0.0390542075,
-0.0556039587,
0.0128851831,
0.0644528493,
-0.0032546942,
-0.0204171296,
0.0496001355,
0.0339792222,
0.0060229837,
-0.0099201091,
0.0484100878,
-0.0007714988,
-0.0212533735,
-0.0202349089,
-0.0335265063,
-0.001797446,
0.0299254339,
-0.0674367175,
-0.0063793249,
-0.0514866337,
0.016401045,
0.0744777992,
-0.0211036019,
0.0351081453,
0.0303533133,
2.387e-7,
0.1144523844,
0.0402387008,
0.0382082276,
-0.0016669362,
0.0264176335,
-0.0015294927,
0.008131735,
-0.0321862958,
0.0037529967,
0.0281532593,
0.096824564,
-0.0331597961,
0.0334121585,
0.0408234894,
-0.0863223821,
-0.0263036918,
-0.078741394,
-0.0460797399,
-0.0415910557,
-0.0027359221,
0.0056028427,
0.0533881448,
-0.0409867093,
-0.0567241237,
-0.018720204,
0.0076627391,
0.0109421434,
-0.0514117442,
0.0380558372,
0.0368535966,
0.0904795825,
-0.0391244106,
-0.0086680651,
0.0466154218,
-0.0061267521,
0.0359147079,
0.0191411804,
0.10756962,
-0.0441277474,
0.0482060835,
0.0256892946,
-0.0327467546,
-0.0021479079,
-0.0660155863,
0.0273269173,
-0.0201874804,
-0.0003676953,
0.0330725908,
-0.0298495423,
-0.0131130759,
0.0233654529,
-0.0006318362,
-0.019113332,
0.0825750083,
0.0271166135,
-0.0291593764,
-0.001256816,
-0.0343244784,
0.021751361,
0.0158977825,
0.0187360104,
0.008130597,
0.035467118,
-0.0472323224,
-0.0057864687,
-0.0259934515,
-0.0458488762,
2.118194443e-34,
0.0575282685,
-0.0082022725,
0.0020366588,
0.0410430543,
0.0199760795,
-0.0299284775,
0.0192676578,
0.0295564327,
-0.013770272,
-0.075961642,
0.0194517616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13182v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13182v2 | Effective Distillation of Table-based Reasoning Ability from LLMs | 2023-09-22T21:15:28 | 2024-03-25T06:49:16 | Bohao Yang, Chen Tang, Kun Zhao, Chenghao Xiao, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance across
a wide range of natural language processing tasks. However, their enormous
parameter size and extremely high requirements for compute power pose
challenges for their practical deployment. Recent research has revealed that
specific capabilities of LLMs, such as numerical reasoning, can be transferred
to smaller models through distillation. Some studies explore the potential of
leveraging LLMs to perform table-based reasoning. However, there has been no
prior work focusing on table reasoning skills in smaller models specifically
tailored for scientific table-to-text generation tasks. In this paper, we
propose a novel table-based reasoning distillation approach, with the aim of
distilling LLMs into tailored smaller models. Our experimental results have
shown that a 220 million parameter model (Flan-T5-base) fine-tuned using
distilled data, not only achieves a significant improvement compared to
traditionally fine-tuned baselines, but also surpasses specific LLMs on a
scientific table-to-text generation dataset. Our code is available at
https://github.com/Bernard-Yang/DistillTableCoT. | [
0.0280493926,
0.0534466989,
0.006769069,
0.006999847,
-0.0398922786,
0.0397560932,
-0.0010149446,
0.004783398,
-0.0129247382,
-0.0265994817,
-0.0165028255,
-0.0189405568,
-0.0095526595,
0.0400453098,
0.0282744411,
-0.0049238233,
0.0490809828,
-0.0319757536,
-0.010243142,
0.0075809127,
-0.0147451935,
-0.0041285148,
-0.0251115523,
-0.0187354553,
0.0280880202,
-0.0195036847,
-0.0166152511,
-0.0223723017,
-0.0019477996,
0.0137810977,
-0.0196590517,
0.0710377097,
0.0514967553,
0.0227893684,
0.0000021674,
-0.0017336061,
-0.044842761,
0.0115807336,
-0.0356288888,
0.0177619737,
0.0411292426,
-0.0103651322,
0.0119850924,
0.0063640988,
-0.0522510819,
0.0158605203,
0.0200099796,
0.0160900503,
0.0670351982,
0.0553999878,
0.0289077461,
-0.0567886643,
0.0278408304,
0.0071091061,
0.0544510968,
-0.0103538884,
0.0048454893,
0.0273144301,
0.0386592261,
0.0100184381,
0.0380127691,
0.0473417863,
0.0366771966,
-0.0045924061,
-0.0047038863,
0.0393179916,
-0.0392641388,
0.0048269043,
0.0093546286,
0.0856866688,
0.0101192603,
-0.0181941595,
0.0306920912,
0.025629878,
-0.0046999068,
-0.0403799526,
-0.0668166354,
0.0427655019,
0.0063859508,
-0.0060226195,
0.0510180779,
-0.0343068652,
0.0109669436,
0.0137358392,
-0.0572598241,
0.0763779506,
-0.0053763962,
-0.0282168332,
-0.0109945061,
-0.051010754,
-0.0195368547,
-0.0323191658,
0.0159591679,
0.0602055192,
-0.0317561999,
0.0204848032,
-0.0111770006,
-0.0192477554,
0.0257871337,
-0.0220912527,
0.045028951,
0.0528758205,
0.0357673317,
-0.0005609116,
-0.0531818084,
0.0250768028,
-0.0348097198,
0.0490905903,
-0.0252018627,
-0.0107928319,
-0.0693043694,
-0.0060255835,
-0.0129207522,
0.0379772782,
-0.0746974945,
-0.0056890254,
-0.0060130777,
-0.0171757787,
-0.006311255,
0.0244977642,
0.0373387076,
0.0355568752,
-0.0110723302,
-0.0003605258,
-0.0531023033,
0.0269351862,
-0.0310667697,
-0.0092266835,
0.0344716273,
-0.0766583309,
-0.0316201672,
-0.0361238383,
0.0120318998,
-0.0228692517,
0.0558433235,
0.0669425055,
-0.0334215574,
0.0060071205,
-0.0527470931,
-0.0485051721,
-0.0288069211,
-0.1114298627,
0.0356866308,
-0.0550334565,
0.0614484623,
0.0274986811,
-0.0284877289,
-0.0776960328,
0.0164508652,
0.0532895587,
-0.024043981,
0.0610965267,
0.0006634818,
0.018092012,
0.014379045,
-0.002733056,
-0.0348604247,
0.0558207743,
0.0412075222,
0.0264173336,
-0.0398858599,
-0.0049238736,
-0.022422174,
-0.0021911669,
0.0319006257,
-0.0221444704,
-0.0303307306,
0.0310137495,
-0.0303631201,
0.0396415442,
0.012580554,
0.0436943546,
-0.0145500135,
0.0492766052,
0.0424612239,
0.0226402134,
0.0332462192,
0.0768610612,
0.0349561796,
-0.0183370374,
0.021169059,
0.0083051939,
-0.0503528304,
0.0723858476,
-0.0093398634,
0.0375855342,
0.0482352674,
0.0180074219,
-0.0133450711,
-0.0550957844,
0.0138568096,
0.026373161,
-0.0105376514,
-0.0032522255,
0.0282912627,
0.0157388635,
-0.0541580804,
0.0478842072,
0.0172954667,
-0.0794541538,
-0.0088464608,
-0.0151473358,
0.0413726084,
0.0609936975,
0.0251228996,
-0.048534885,
-0.0110176336,
-0.0070486977,
0.0102310833,
0.0337477624,
0.0275185015,
-0.0109478747,
-0.0258469973,
-0.0274794474,
-0.0026237301,
-0.0045757312,
0.0295152739,
-0.0229581837,
0.0139922537,
-0.021388609,
0.0287217759,
-0.0505107231,
-0.0562752746,
0.0251280684,
-0.0264602862,
-0.0070637283,
-0.024543453,
-0.0153529178,
0.0313747264,
0.0059582628,
0.0007882402,
0.0621831305,
0.0316501334,
-0.0304752849,
0.0131936856,
-0.0446588099,
-0.0349639952,
-0.0338913053,
0.035328269,
0.0052235243,
-0.0332671963,
0.0089180199,
-0.0443116538,
-0.0397109091,
0.0304889865,
-0.0272969287,
-0.0380425788,
-0.0257242974,
0.026755197,
0.031130949,
0.005854873,
0.001615743,
0.0829829499,
-0.0414168946,
0.0217098445,
0.019053176,
-0.0456298068,
-0.0078964401,
-0.0356656611,
0.0396887809,
-0.0136724031,
0.001132727,
0.0076431036,
-0.0137744658,
0.0088333711,
-0.0606817082,
-0.0195839871,
-0.0557543971,
0.0604914799,
-0.0336952284,
0.013647723,
0.0376799777,
-0.01114293,
0.0222502947,
0.0385145545,
-0.0586939007,
-0.0025175447,
0.0197247993,
-0.0106068328,
0.0706336275,
-0.019603109,
-0.0199905317,
-0.022901997,
-0.022498494,
-0.0387213826,
0.0294869691,
-0.0295506604,
-0.00890812,
-0.0149928397,
0.0176631398,
-0.0277711116,
-0.0143912341,
0.0179475695,
-0.0108839525,
0.0060630324,
-0.0361648127,
0.031451039,
0.0431280471,
-0.0081551177,
0.0032204958,
0.02797346,
-0.0155586656,
-0.0374049544,
0.0360207297,
-0.017449325,
0.0366983339,
0.039083153,
-0.054865893,
0.008754747,
0.0374892056,
-0.0325459614,
0.0117640439,
-0.0245487168,
0.0429188944,
0.0355968773,
-0.0085625546,
-0.030021606,
0.0611242503,
0.0044069518,
0.0208609384,
-0.0237978846,
-0.0180896353,
0.0378081277,
-0.0438052192,
0.0193060618,
-0.0557998456,
0.0151267564,
-0.0464286171,
0.0618577637,
-0.0009153377,
0.0038840435,
-0.0221696366,
0.0158891641,
-0.0555717833,
0.0107995998,
-0.0220972337,
-0.0364934914,
0.1017021462,
-0.0771599263,
0.012468772,
-0.0185842775,
-0.0248844642,
-0.0167373214,
-0.0116578387,
-0.0289630331,
0.0606714748,
0.032109566,
-0.0307260565,
-0.0410646014,
-0.0372452736,
0.0482471474,
0.0334019922,
-0.0313903838,
-0.0146696893,
-0.0452187024,
0.0226391405,
0.0265630018,
0.0199947562,
0.027992608,
-0.0196037311,
0.0275412351,
0.049952548,
0.0139184706,
-0.0340070091,
-0.0128363259,
0.0451048799,
0.0043688645,
-0.0214843154,
-0.0176452771,
0.0418793596,
-0.0018842309,
-0.0905192494,
-0.0297640637,
0.0950924382,
0.0260366946,
0.0533588491,
0.0030448211,
-0.0030044864,
0.0595897995,
0.0174908955,
0.0576107576,
-0.0712442547,
-0.0395357944,
0.0106791025,
-0.0231516659,
-0.0010871867,
-0.0656062067,
-0.0503396988,
-0.1025145873,
0.0589967705,
0.0162884649,
-0.0228018127,
-0.0840585977,
-0.02585214,
-0.0391169079,
0.010199598,
0.0130530549,
0.0880386084,
-0.0199133325,
0.0163748562,
0.019730214,
-0.0097517008,
-0.0442243032,
0.0203047246,
-0.0161829274,
0.0470049493,
0.0218016356,
0.0416209735,
-0.0031864168,
-0.0427656285,
-0.0087327538,
-0.0050168298,
0.0289139003,
-0.0145956473,
0.0420846045,
0.0355754048,
0.0211998615,
0.0025688305,
0.0419820026,
-0.0468461961,
-0.0180823486,
0.0083657773,
0.079788655,
-0.0308969431,
-0.0178084765,
-0.0100515503,
0.0100490376,
-0.028828023,
0.0748822242,
0.035093233,
0.0258153901,
-0.0998273939,
-0.0514113978,
-0.0775885805,
-0.0667769164,
0.0139076402,
0.0261405278,
-0.014354798,
0.0074707544,
-0.054348167,
0.0336617492,
0.0591775142,
0.0536449477,
-0.0174664147,
0.0308605321,
-0.0335195251,
-0.0021791048,
-0.0422178432,
-0.0042059454,
-0.0458552539,
0.0189038385,
-0.0347762555,
-0.0264742449,
0.026987521,
-0.029420618,
-0.0279002674,
0.0366779901,
-0.0807894319,
-0.0448986143,
-0.0145404553,
0.0284006912,
0.0327266641,
0.0181527417,
0.0210874192,
-0.0221571624,
0.0299036242,
0.0021615643,
-0.0849579945,
-0.0091776168,
-0.0018165833,
-0.0245185345,
0.0085339732,
0.029760763,
-0.0060119182,
0.0037749084,
-0.0064086411,
0.0633352548,
-0.0047327732,
0.042305138,
0.0406469069,
0.0551472083,
-0.0165367778,
0.0274172351,
-0.0512570962,
-0.0255375672,
0.0235335417,
-0.0480672121,
-0.0366057269,
-0.0365702286,
0.0214793459,
0.0025397504,
-0.0025666503,
-0.0125871794,
-0.026219137,
0.0319537483,
0.0190943684,
0.0151157556,
-0.0102486704,
0.0269684326,
-0.0040434096,
0.0341044478,
-0.0553379394,
-0.0275954213,
-0.0149312979,
-0.0099427402,
0.0534101576,
-0.0297556818,
0.0614661314,
0.0185201522,
-0.0046426966,
-0.0756868273,
0.0305206794,
-0.0866393521,
-0.0825851485,
-0.0150969336,
0.0040590269,
0.0066978736,
0.0443520956,
0.0235921219,
-0.0592188574,
-0.0158694014,
0.0093789613,
0.0292505473,
0.0281718392,
0.0241837949,
0.0378105231,
0.0125032766,
-0.0134481424,
-0.0568869784,
0.0710893795,
0.0215743855,
0.0277982913,
-0.0118537489,
0.0038054488,
-0.0527259074,
-0.0390701629,
-0.0633701831,
-0.0152673665,
0.0171454679,
-0.0230201967,
-0.0380294211,
-0.0579777993,
0.0368259326,
0.0399332866,
-0.0112570059,
-0.0343884826,
0.0259881299,
0.0374667495,
0.0030986182,
-0.0224025268,
-0.0429266654,
0.0341488756,
0.014603259,
-0.0448070876,
-0.0298266001,
-6.65648435e-33,
-0.0242378134,
-0.0005067242,
0.0383610092,
-0.0272975415,
-0.0060608052,
-0.0294449143,
-0.0500186123,
-0.0179404207,
-0.0044563152,
0.0222769994,
-0.0407746024,
0.0335046202,
0.0068317661,
0.0012100792,
0.0092861056,
-0.0629782677,
0.0319280997,
-0.0111190379,
-0.0080515426,
0.0384897254,
0.0399816632,
0.0258394796,
-0.0057035876,
-0.0204557218,
0.0107427528,
0.0065887193,
0.0067540617,
-0.0057503097,
-0.0613796338,
0.0149726616,
-0.0251906142,
0.0212733801,
0.0180384107,
-0.0516797751,
-0.0551505759,
0.0115087247,
-0.1289950013,
-0.0045931814,
0.0248868726,
-0.0431497805,
-0.0179975424,
-0.0537570789,
0.0299507026,
0.0125589967,
-0.0042773201,
-0.0541379899,
0.0040476276,
-0.0507215261,
0.0116552841,
-0.0065064454,
-0.011711657,
0.0113258967,
-0.0084967809,
0.0070054065,
0.0465632156,
0.0351269767,
-0.0299723279,
0.0062875296,
-0.0170497056,
0.028998673,
0.0425799899,
0.0470951274,
0.0541642532,
-0.0246879738,
0.0113043329,
0.0408546142,
0.0066232625,
0.006142837,
-0.0412689932,
0.0153828077,
-0.0352421217,
0.1127984002,
0.0459956937,
0.0182731207,
0.0366224125,
-0.0033988527,
-0.0749737918,
0.0340265855,
-0.0110427625,
0.0296891779,
0.0122307958,
-0.0154867265,
0.0148120429,
-0.0295463167,
-0.0331801735,
0.0280316081,
-0.0389015786,
-0.0084851105,
0.0145065803,
-0.0253643431,
-0.0075079249,
-0.0503853895,
0.0188181903,
-0.0031936676,
-0.0072635412,
0.0563044623,
-0.0114264926,
0.0123805963,
0.0305993166,
-0.0018253977,
-0.0488795228,
-0.0287306346,
0.0087068854,
-0.0110058673,
0.0321273692,
0.0382958204,
0.0338623598,
0.0464570411,
-0.0354973264,
-0.0189726986,
-0.0661734566,
0.0552215055,
0.0160331391,
0.0378372073,
-0.0003909606,
0.0113179693,
0.0051763495,
0.0112687759,
-0.0160493702,
0.0095177842,
-0.0005391857,
0.0388464928,
0.0235096216,
0.0396585763,
-0.0093617355,
0.0014134811,
-0.0323968567,
0.0061661708,
0.0165484902,
-0.0542481877,
0.0014553518,
0.0235887449,
2.819e-7,
0.0599070266,
0.0357811674,
0.047475934,
0.0111898668,
0.0021613764,
-0.002178692,
-0.0159234796,
-0.0265441723,
0.0027137133,
-0.0526780263,
0.0155702662,
-0.0024139893,
0.0729571506,
0.0361802243,
-0.0196670517,
-0.0317970291,
-0.0551983006,
-0.0170198716,
-0.02846439,
-0.0325764455,
0.0287174601,
0.0779105648,
-0.0332659557,
-0.0300320834,
0.0036092056,
-0.0020357186,
0.0272036064,
-0.0398754738,
0.0494728275,
0.0371024795,
0.025443418,
-0.0402902998,
0.0093916841,
0.0522283241,
-0.0261145998,
-0.0015514062,
-0.0275003184,
0.097440064,
0.0151628042,
0.0260629728,
0.0061312891,
-0.0759104192,
0.0285093952,
-0.0774081349,
0.0888823494,
-0.0647611395,
-0.0163203869,
0.0503901727,
-0.0069873901,
0.0169638675,
-0.0160487108,
0.0119357277,
0.0242327638,
0.0204379316,
0.0009817189,
-0.0172961801,
0.0056709191,
-0.0793738663,
-0.0418563075,
0.0430625938,
-0.0637430251,
-0.0389196016,
-0.0410698205,
-0.0280310474,
0.015539648,
-0.0612624213,
-0.0552322343,
2.94992167e-34,
0.0260840729,
-0.0151363993,
0.0253635012,
0.022880625,
0.0657936633,
-0.0195744801,
0.0070057907,
0.0025075336,
0.0053052218,
-0.0854742453,
-0.0272340253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13173v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13173v2 | BenLLMEval: A Comprehensive Evaluation into the Potentials and Pitfalls of Large Language Models on Bengali NLP | 2023-09-22T20:29:34 | 2024-03-19T17:11:41 | Mohsinul Kabir, Mohammed Saidul Islam, Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Mir Tafseer Nayeem, M Saiful Bari, Enamul Hoque | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as one of the most important
breakthroughs in NLP for their impressive skills in language generation and
other language-specific tasks. Though LLMs have been evaluated in various
tasks, mostly in English, they have not yet undergone thorough evaluation in
under-resourced languages such as Bengali (Bangla). To this end, this paper
introduces BenLLM-Eval, which consists of a comprehensive evaluation of LLMs to
benchmark their performance in the Bengali language that has modest resources.
In this regard, we select various important and diverse Bengali NLP tasks, such
as text summarization, question answering, paraphrasing, natural language
inference, transliteration, text classification, and sentiment analysis for
zero-shot evaluation of popular LLMs, namely, GPT-3.5, LLaMA-2-13b-chat, and
Claude-2. Our experimental results demonstrate that while in some Bengali NLP
tasks, zero-shot LLMs could achieve performance on par, or even better than
current SOTA fine-tuned models; in most tasks, their performance is quite poor
(with the performance of open-source LLMs like LLaMA-2-13b-chat being
significantly bad) in comparison to the current SOTA results. Therefore, it
calls for further efforts to develop a better understanding of LLMs in
modest-resourced languages like Bengali. | [
0.0586936176,
0.0190992113,
0.0188599564,
0.0343591571,
-0.0650773644,
0.0009628289,
0.008714553,
-0.0116113788,
0.0198846851,
-0.0266064405,
0.0003212706,
-0.0632798225,
0.0126660364,
0.0126345158,
0.0165499486,
-0.0543312766,
0.0432606712,
-0.0152739184,
0.0096350843,
-0.0131846312,
0.0344542488,
0.0261634868,
0.0142057268,
0.0318230502,
0.0309153367,
-0.0115840416,
0.0219276939,
-0.0046085827,
-0.0438489579,
-0.0310491733,
-0.0010869022,
0.0459752083,
-0.015578609,
0.0199469626,
0.000001866,
-0.0636376441,
-0.0193863474,
-0.0127309253,
-0.0040561422,
0.0320470147,
0.0672937632,
-0.0062301429,
0.0025654843,
0.0620176755,
-0.0177222285,
0.0042065587,
0.0522790849,
0.0462599136,
0.067275025,
0.0698185489,
-0.0064097522,
-0.0874106362,
0.0145358527,
-0.0245215204,
0.0181186218,
-0.0215699822,
-0.0027190784,
-0.0098845987,
0.0554794632,
0.014044879,
0.0018854908,
0.0187825803,
0.0023935174,
-0.0290882923,
0.0110398578,
0.0075959782,
-0.0431507826,
-0.0294766761,
0.0195953231,
0.0678919628,
-0.0562581494,
-0.0251670647,
0.0120513337,
0.0323772095,
-0.0317917131,
-0.0416362435,
-0.0610790253,
0.0496252999,
-0.0318396315,
0.0339875221,
0.0456843674,
0.0173516311,
-0.0109012611,
0.0348725058,
0.0275852773,
0.0130505683,
0.0086162351,
-0.0075161434,
-0.0427919775,
0.0072719059,
-0.0436711088,
-0.0348535702,
0.0026706844,
0.0266871322,
-0.0191684961,
0.0183708686,
-0.0395293273,
0.0082496945,
0.0385692008,
-0.0383679047,
0.028082069,
0.0507218651,
0.0175997373,
0.0496683381,
-0.0332483165,
0.0387078524,
-0.0199004784,
-0.0171759538,
-0.0506163649,
-0.0198727045,
-0.0173973832,
-0.0418687426,
-0.0188903362,
0.0553492457,
-0.0749990717,
-0.0212121978,
-0.0669271573,
0.0277492218,
0.0274911262,
-0.0287759714,
0.0381747037,
0.0197878219,
0.0025167656,
-0.0137026226,
-0.0109620122,
0.009341592,
-0.0244603641,
-0.0119604915,
0.0077746222,
-0.0923034325,
-0.0160165038,
0.0042450083,
-0.0172353555,
-0.024856871,
-0.0084817875,
0.0570313781,
-0.012337029,
-0.0234557446,
-0.0229496378,
0.0079427818,
-0.0181621332,
-0.1016108692,
-0.0196836777,
-0.0648723319,
0.0393538736,
0.0271515865,
-0.01615154,
-0.0014886929,
0.0216895826,
0.0603448041,
-0.0214765947,
0.0675734282,
-0.0207449645,
0.0127916876,
0.040726833,
0.0199908968,
0.0536350533,
0.0789617002,
-0.0052517727,
0.0222594943,
0.0265968777,
-0.0167847965,
0.0010940715,
0.0286164377,
0.0047273007,
-0.0230212696,
-0.0287566315,
0.0240128841,
-0.0099786324,
0.0307148769,
0.0159931928,
0.0825165212,
-0.0407233052,
0.0295998715,
0.0578758158,
0.0419733524,
0.0196089577,
0.0720737651,
0.039543651,
0.0178891253,
0.0507442839,
0.019083593,
-0.0102508413,
0.0245787222,
-0.0409708992,
0.0099569065,
0.0814189762,
0.0308144856,
-0.0368875563,
-0.0237714443,
-0.0235225856,
-0.0139278313,
-0.0154258814,
-0.0017203608,
0.0223836936,
-0.0109613109,
-0.0274934247,
0.0493267663,
0.0503256358,
-0.058412876,
0.0192768108,
-0.0719744936,
0.0458308458,
0.0421592928,
0.038560342,
-0.0132961841,
-0.005264895,
-0.0008134542,
-0.013505308,
0.0635070875,
0.0496860966,
-0.0103416694,
-0.0148120718,
-0.034045238,
0.0629200265,
-0.000383343,
0.0034412642,
0.0178896096,
0.0110729467,
0.0125393346,
0.0148967421,
0.0050887973,
-0.0374366529,
0.0206819698,
-0.0171162542,
-0.00583784,
0.0066452245,
-0.0323461071,
0.0368205719,
0.0095576784,
0.0049862964,
0.0076980381,
-0.0011486176,
-0.0440380424,
-0.0215710234,
0.0123458598,
-0.0366834737,
-0.0904122591,
0.0264645778,
-0.0090791443,
0.0454982929,
0.0073802071,
-0.0137226395,
-0.0611630753,
0.0649778545,
-0.0415452793,
0.009325535,
-0.0486519337,
0.0500257127,
-0.0138101904,
0.0261858683,
-0.0512191094,
0.0693732873,
0.0206448361,
0.0201030187,
0.0094980504,
0.0109764664,
0.056619525,
-0.0319849476,
-0.0391136147,
0.0670573562,
0.0466458946,
0.0268514715,
0.0272670891,
0.0453855395,
-0.0385561325,
-0.0490234978,
-0.1260824651,
0.0367254466,
-0.008589169,
0.0306313578,
0.0329824723,
0.0268133003,
-0.017126685,
0.0049805357,
-0.0181867015,
-0.001487061,
0.059942022,
0.0071020159,
0.0397710577,
-0.0091108447,
0.008003179,
-0.0400487855,
-0.0128022162,
0.030879911,
0.06463743,
0.0082659647,
-0.0188946687,
-0.0214224923,
0.0046997629,
-0.0291880239,
-0.0213376433,
0.0118890917,
-0.0510763265,
-0.0334244892,
-0.0482156128,
0.0121936835,
0.0311670192,
0.0392755531,
-0.0225451998,
-0.0225522798,
0.0010319649,
-0.0176125448,
-0.0181096289,
-0.0171974506,
-0.0169570222,
0.0077749072,
-0.0184013564,
-0.0139280604,
0.0656401366,
-0.0014264889,
0.0053620981,
-0.0296198353,
0.0064497739,
-0.0170947462,
0.0042095422,
-0.045492582,
0.0301535688,
-0.0323590152,
0.0237370357,
-0.0263187774,
-0.0167658664,
0.0417898893,
-0.0508530624,
-0.0010202565,
-0.0789302662,
-0.0029997667,
-0.0664320588,
0.0432933345,
0.0008036935,
0.0230038799,
-0.024007868,
-0.0171889476,
-0.0241029821,
-0.020539362,
0.0259360075,
-0.0471975617,
0.0076625757,
-0.0811840594,
0.0503279977,
-0.0393892527,
-0.024750229,
-0.0182075314,
-0.0629756376,
-0.0258440971,
0.0167617835,
0.018968692,
0.026984917,
0.0126629537,
0.0702963769,
0.0163345579,
-0.0167564265,
-0.0496505089,
-0.0033537997,
0.016318446,
0.0421338417,
0.0618564002,
-0.0096993493,
0.0317267776,
-0.005494881,
0.0157444347,
0.0139600532,
0.0014957277,
0.0118037034,
-0.0290716495,
-0.0082238857,
0.0200698655,
-0.0307388231,
-0.0262683444,
-0.0275551118,
0.0398991965,
0.0011572542,
-0.0275014136,
0.1113756448,
0.0425584838,
-0.0218245294,
-0.0101575889,
-0.0290556028,
0.0253099632,
-0.0149150984,
0.0245865248,
-0.0406625792,
-0.0388414115,
-0.0186133869,
-0.0083716679,
-0.0119324382,
-0.0223198719,
-0.0447196998,
-0.1560666263,
-0.0206928942,
-0.0185913686,
-0.0411568396,
-0.0445013233,
-0.0044541433,
-0.0293848552,
-0.0046241931,
0.0380082726,
0.0265438389,
-0.0516249351,
0.0196618773,
0.0505783558,
-0.0398079567,
-0.0503975227,
-0.003193717,
-0.0300070886,
0.040712826,
0.0264934339,
0.0050087962,
-0.0206599571,
0.0832344294,
0.0318434201,
-0.061548572,
-0.0147518134,
-0.0155660463,
0.0372997895,
0.0137219355,
-0.0206025299,
-0.030202534,
-0.001682649,
-0.0083814133,
0.009120184,
0.020284228,
0.0211081542,
0.0058940966,
-0.0094437711,
-0.0259884037,
0.0294169001,
0.0036910698,
0.0642294213,
0.045721028,
-0.0362711959,
-0.0728239864,
-0.0147742713,
-0.0480557457,
-0.0567743368,
-0.0382664949,
0.0115703586,
-0.0651004016,
-0.0421258733,
-0.0759655535,
-0.0466516502,
0.0015212609,
0.0441585407,
-0.0226031356,
0.0406699255,
-0.0038250952,
0.0025962901,
0.0040922426,
-0.0157036111,
-0.0279209763,
0.0113952132,
-0.0529712215,
0.0192049537,
0.0652349889,
-0.0290255882,
-0.0106685916,
-0.0046123695,
-0.092849493,
-0.0605848618,
0.0050169495,
0.0299092829,
0.0314538479,
-0.0051526558,
-0.0189653691,
-0.0749594867,
0.0509302653,
0.0556870177,
-0.0509024821,
0.0139525086,
-0.0024133555,
0.0400346443,
-0.0118934074,
0.0520930588,
0.0005530176,
0.0323077478,
-0.0084876539,
0.0447875857,
-0.0159756504,
-0.0083157932,
0.0095549012,
0.0368604474,
-0.0105196377,
-0.059243165,
-0.0285352748,
-0.0081482613,
-0.0284733772,
-0.0247436315,
-0.0175643303,
-0.00358811,
-0.0104694581,
0.0197029803,
0.0104572773,
-0.0135524068,
-0.0101534883,
-0.0381193906,
0.0471479222,
0.0230366793,
0.0246964917,
-0.0118573671,
-0.0114650549,
-0.002690118,
0.0003705807,
-0.0252401717,
-0.0334868804,
-0.0086921509,
0.0198931806,
-0.0345672853,
0.0585552268,
-0.0086533586,
-0.0090166843,
0.0125485267,
0.0614419617,
-0.0150127457,
0.0316635035,
-0.0111194924,
0.0645265579,
0.0918838009,
-0.0043829195,
0.0736253411,
-0.0013211218,
-0.0153255882,
-0.0349784233,
0.039021939,
-0.0153883332,
0.0105450973,
0.0226072557,
-0.006726047,
-0.0331719704,
0.0022554393,
0.0884336084,
0.0095389299,
-0.0024025631,
0.0307134856,
-0.0113698244,
-0.0368029512,
-0.0539675839,
-0.0326206572,
-0.0070621967,
0.0208650529,
0.030131042,
-0.0878956318,
-0.0436913148,
0.0130215576,
-0.0274528433,
0.0216986425,
-0.025331879,
0.0577926375,
0.0713754073,
0.0501141511,
0.0567737073,
-0.082199432,
0.0299488585,
-0.0304511599,
0.0130147683,
-0.0066688135,
-6.254472629e-33,
-0.039153371,
-0.0004265145,
0.004950027,
-0.0383267701,
-0.0325312503,
0.0131636672,
-0.0395301878,
-0.0039508967,
-0.0141147999,
-0.0293920506,
-0.0570170879,
-0.0012855888,
0.0105648981,
0.0268048029,
0.0168978926,
-0.0353439935,
0.0070379013,
0.0257122181,
-0.0118585136,
0.0201317035,
0.0310153067,
0.0269179847,
0.0324614495,
0.0301208701,
-0.017103361,
-0.0414714254,
-0.0315224566,
-0.0018538914,
0.0011877459,
0.033002533,
-0.0435471907,
0.0582955554,
0.0366910137,
-0.0193108562,
-0.0162546542,
-0.0124184452,
-0.0499345027,
-0.0082093794,
0.0453729294,
0.0063884207,
-0.0315575004,
-0.0191464014,
0.0134991761,
-0.0056557064,
-0.0273240302,
0.0306541435,
-0.0035225921,
-0.0309524424,
-0.0330394246,
0.000847962,
-0.0513090491,
0.0397531539,
0.0010249413,
0.0043532834,
0.0121039264,
0.0162508637,
-0.0179266129,
-0.0219928101,
-0.0056018317,
0.0202454533,
0.0379419588,
0.0399591886,
0.0349728204,
0.0177813172,
-0.0083137639,
0.0266437344,
0.003289362,
-0.0463050529,
0.0061700833,
0.0341859348,
-0.0123670436,
0.0012348812,
0.0182039551,
0.0890676603,
0.0517358668,
-0.0181050375,
-0.0696221888,
0.0336910672,
0.0786353648,
0.0446975529,
0.0373277143,
-0.0251941681,
-0.0281194579,
-0.0511762314,
0.0190470796,
0.0042660874,
-0.036082387,
-0.0378563888,
0.0323448777,
-0.0005824154,
-0.0250330642,
-0.0080608083,
0.0464752018,
-0.0397956744,
0.0223437659,
0.023926096,
-0.0424228534,
0.0454223454,
0.0009551821,
0.0574116409,
-0.0722663999,
-0.0470941253,
-0.0033832241,
0.0328212902,
-0.0199066307,
0.0123895956,
0.0186556764,
-0.0157402623,
-0.064838402,
0.0167481918,
-0.0568561219,
0.0593387745,
-0.0331372358,
0.0448254086,
-0.0020120111,
-0.0051175281,
-0.0044979127,
0.0345855169,
0.0073332423,
0.0216519013,
0.012471715,
0.0038850694,
0.0134330709,
0.0079112472,
-0.0331503823,
0.0554606952,
-0.0416700505,
0.017475754,
-0.0129870819,
-0.0515168682,
-0.0067480956,
0.0124898376,
2.706e-7,
0.0305316169,
0.0487020947,
0.0348284915,
-0.0050461027,
0.0057500806,
0.0095118973,
0.0001279762,
0.0150933396,
-0.0014813842,
0.0531909987,
0.0092086801,
0.0325534754,
0.0476958007,
0.0189973358,
-0.1100195795,
0.012068308,
-0.0799460933,
-0.0094369324,
-0.0450782031,
-0.0267469026,
0.0340786427,
0.1057893932,
0.0042901747,
-0.0181049872,
-0.0395304784,
-0.0473685637,
0.0523950942,
0.0083624981,
-0.0824607387,
0.029899992,
0.0387122408,
0.0626194179,
-0.0225085337,
-0.0278687365,
0.0114113707,
-0.0112857968,
0.0432012752,
0.0548683852,
0.000925891,
-0.0013640178,
0.0452415273,
-0.0213265661,
0.0199699495,
-0.0546265729,
0.1062403545,
-0.0210344251,
-0.0350424461,
-0.0266020987,
-0.0350356735,
-0.0240753926,
0.01387846,
-0.0346588641,
-0.0526037365,
0.0157730915,
0.002899918,
-0.0764590651,
-0.0379088297,
-0.0446100198,
-0.0282711722,
0.0147922244,
-0.0247271955,
-0.040366292,
-0.0021974789,
0.0344974063,
0.0186144039,
-0.0627823099,
0.034075968,
2.473013969e-34,
0.0762929991,
0.0073107942,
0.0248371512,
-0.0337596945,
0.0218549781,
0.0126247788,
-0.0185752474,
0.0092041483,
0.0169025529,
-0.0778829902,
-0.000902236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13165v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13165v1 | Large Language Models Are Also Good Prototypical Commonsense Reasoners | 2023-09-22T20:07:24 | 2023-09-22T20:07:24 | Chenin Li, Qianglong Chen, Yin Zhang, Yifei Zhang, Hongxiang Yao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Commonsense reasoning is a pivotal skill for large language models, yet it
presents persistent challenges in specific tasks requiring this competence.
Traditional fine-tuning approaches can be resource-intensive and potentially
compromise a model's generalization capacity. Furthermore, state-of-the-art
language models like GPT-3.5 and Claude are primarily accessible through API
calls, which makes fine-tuning models challenging. To address these challenges,
we draw inspiration from the outputs of large models for tailored tasks and
semi-automatically developed a set of novel prompts from several perspectives,
including task-relevance, supportive evidence generation (e.g. chain-of-thought
and knowledge), diverse path decoding to aid the model. Experimental results on
ProtoQA dataset demonstrate that with better designed prompts we can achieve
the new state-of-art(SOTA) on the ProtoQA leaderboard, improving the Max
Answer@1 score by 8%, Max Incorrect@1 score by 4% (breakthrough 50% for the
first time) compared to the previous SOTA model and achieved an improvement on
StrategyQA and CommonsenseQA2.0 (3% and 1%, respectively). Furthermore, with
the generated Chain-of-Thought and knowledge, we can improve the
interpretability of the model while also surpassing the previous SOTA models.
We hope that our work can provide insight for the NLP community to develop
better prompts and explore the potential of large language models for more
complex reasoning tasks. | [
0.0668965131,
0.0666508079,
-0.0020367177,
0.0307681672,
-0.0293840393,
-0.0033124115,
-0.0067583192,
-0.0303402152,
0.0009037745,
-0.0428228416,
-0.0005296024,
0.0171175152,
-0.0109375827,
0.0563599467,
0.0088173719,
-0.0486474931,
0.0234786943,
-0.0444991067,
0.0206862185,
-0.001048708,
0.0018461387,
0.042359855,
0.001023698,
0.0765522048,
0.0372017957,
-0.047933042,
0.0003721027,
-0.010772543,
0.0097865928,
-0.0211213678,
-0.0222309027,
0.0580577031,
0.0221051462,
0.0096602002,
0.0000022632,
-0.0324545689,
0.0225393102,
0.0051830667,
-0.0403688587,
-0.009084655,
0.0086897397,
0.0246744864,
0.0135362856,
0.0248298962,
-0.0292328168,
0.0078759575,
0.0376648903,
0.0345747657,
0.0693328083,
0.0365548581,
0.0038347712,
-0.0348593295,
0.0223886017,
-0.0144182993,
0.0035879721,
-0.0444483832,
0.010031567,
0.0142831467,
0.0246336255,
0.0140326191,
-0.0112867365,
0.0068995049,
0.0395540372,
-0.0227036793,
-0.0293834545,
0.0269889422,
-0.0473599769,
-0.0238589905,
0.0047815326,
0.0964115784,
0.0215340592,
-0.0491329245,
-0.0153801935,
0.0036577387,
0.0191114191,
0.0316277556,
-0.045409888,
0.0379040129,
-0.0090887211,
0.005932379,
0.0797107369,
0.0231277049,
0.0216168538,
0.0361947715,
-0.0183487628,
0.0648627505,
-0.008825182,
-0.0021207542,
0.018887043,
0.0019237552,
-0.0671540424,
-0.0522353388,
0.0009431647,
0.0488737561,
-0.0511016175,
-0.0019443864,
0.0041948971,
0.0172241405,
0.015586162,
-0.0281935018,
0.0184761975,
0.0472509116,
-0.0196256936,
0.0617295168,
0.0100608831,
0.0154413581,
-0.0026790651,
0.0127299577,
-0.0362086631,
-0.0311412401,
-0.0747490525,
-0.008686142,
-0.0271448251,
0.0219089184,
-0.0408718847,
-0.0017534079,
0.0111261457,
0.0058753775,
-0.0153154433,
0.0171274617,
0.0443699658,
0.0110025657,
-0.0358542316,
-0.0343710184,
-0.0274101757,
0.0430440344,
-0.0739280134,
0.0285210926,
0.0284637697,
-0.0363719836,
-0.0162664596,
-0.0066338326,
0.0146733029,
-0.0215741713,
0.0028393229,
0.0249555632,
0.008457127,
-0.0174754001,
-0.033009313,
-0.0322019458,
0.0008143556,
-0.0629975125,
-0.0594971031,
-0.0649162903,
0.0054949312,
0.0224673394,
0.0029242451,
0.0052847313,
0.0014087168,
0.026192084,
-0.0222432688,
0.0707698986,
-0.0122011621,
0.0064316858,
-0.0117678316,
0.0343208089,
-0.0256855469,
0.0592051856,
-0.0176660269,
-0.0028525759,
0.0286664143,
-0.0047634342,
-0.0109226098,
-0.0152030466,
0.0036243179,
-0.0118860481,
0.0382519886,
0.0369310528,
-0.0079460721,
0.0286242533,
0.0353375636,
0.0195722878,
-0.0424427725,
0.0112182731,
0.0604660138,
0.0503079593,
-0.0009785719,
0.0218085498,
0.0390047431,
0.0233758464,
0.0161903035,
-0.0065235705,
-0.0570699126,
0.0074429591,
-0.0253392067,
-0.0028947906,
-0.0195608065,
0.0368072689,
-0.0184751321,
-0.0296005681,
0.0041836859,
-0.0040913397,
-0.0202217512,
0.0215755701,
0.0328543968,
0.0219951998,
-0.0240004864,
0.0379546955,
0.0350628011,
-0.0410307646,
-0.0074093691,
-0.0441441424,
0.0651669055,
0.0381871499,
0.0586999245,
-0.0099189449,
-0.0300817583,
-0.0159559008,
0.0126800528,
0.0431280807,
0.0262509249,
-0.0334149003,
0.0084094591,
-0.057656277,
-0.0213140436,
-0.0034515955,
0.0106941927,
-0.0155615099,
0.0113795409,
-0.0038929663,
-0.0125001352,
-0.0615311936,
0.011410987,
-0.0051769949,
-0.0185379554,
-0.0142096952,
-0.0194079578,
-0.0068071098,
0.0352674052,
0.0350078195,
0.0118467063,
0.0241193939,
0.0233069062,
-0.0315273106,
0.0168401841,
0.0416707769,
-0.0550059453,
-0.0644549951,
0.0365227461,
-0.0192015171,
-0.0467794426,
0.0383277647,
-0.0323144719,
-0.0452662893,
-0.0150130093,
-0.0218095221,
0.0327083543,
-0.0386996605,
-0.0230602305,
-0.0014555969,
-0.0179077089,
-0.0188688878,
0.1015367582,
0.0005881823,
0.0040889601,
0.0268589556,
-0.0026041795,
0.009212954,
-0.027678322,
-0.0088789333,
0.0348943807,
-0.0059898789,
-0.0078382781,
0.0298164748,
0.0329691656,
-0.0305769257,
-0.0130233709,
-0.0874633268,
-0.0044744965,
-0.0242394321,
0.004415507,
0.0102868946,
-0.0025158131,
0.0131881014,
0.0069625927,
-0.0380866937,
0.0104093803,
0.0140817259,
0.0308961123,
0.0142107494,
0.0028498014,
-0.0185750257,
-0.0074116336,
-0.0131425699,
-0.0162312593,
0.0535997003,
-0.0090662818,
0.0555211194,
-0.0353072546,
-0.000017076,
-0.0223227348,
0.002878522,
-0.0114856893,
-0.0155954026,
0.0153439781,
-0.0269046947,
0.0335147865,
0.0609661676,
-0.0220312551,
0.0245284121,
0.0354482569,
-0.0208182242,
-0.0567848198,
0.0213829353,
-0.0107327141,
-0.0052772402,
-0.0324054323,
-0.021074824,
-0.0158599336,
0.0549972616,
-0.0062942887,
0.0004648759,
-0.0940464363,
0.0150739821,
-0.0005673286,
-0.0032864749,
-0.0337605625,
-0.0130044855,
0.0179604646,
0.0483216234,
-0.0349222273,
-0.0206384547,
0.0844420567,
-0.0290916972,
0.0187843088,
-0.0521170422,
-0.0103198318,
-0.0322666727,
0.1003658995,
-0.018038461,
0.0136853363,
-0.0005159571,
-0.0187444445,
-0.0166091956,
-0.0438192338,
0.0244375896,
-0.0392068252,
0.0389460698,
-0.061315909,
0.0152489524,
-0.0101909637,
-0.0784198865,
-0.0082005206,
-0.0293766968,
-0.0564263463,
0.0097533194,
-0.0138380742,
-0.0217244104,
-0.0318091959,
0.0027881775,
0.0092967581,
0.0390865244,
0.0071849283,
-0.0106536942,
-0.017215522,
0.0344144963,
0.0482023507,
0.0538289063,
0.0307083577,
0.0243110117,
0.0545218848,
0.0561470725,
0.0087892702,
-0.026048854,
-0.001987017,
0.0336366333,
0.0224637259,
-0.0301764831,
-0.0385548323,
0.0336300991,
0.0875897482,
-0.0715416148,
-0.0361321867,
0.1088430732,
0.0379209183,
-0.0263644177,
0.0111484546,
-0.0290328246,
0.0383028388,
0.0094368849,
0.0211232491,
-0.0544156358,
-0.0674931332,
0.0350368544,
0.0349885114,
-0.0191643592,
-0.048951447,
0.0150250364,
-0.1311647445,
0.0485146679,
-0.0146934446,
-0.0347005352,
-0.0588216931,
-0.0850427523,
-0.0071397726,
-0.0340140089,
-0.013899249,
0.016014671,
0.0105575379,
0.0309413038,
0.0146082798,
-0.0025862916,
-0.0626611635,
0.0705893114,
-0.0349360369,
0.0740788057,
0.0492426232,
0.0344323255,
0.0190703217,
-0.0530419871,
-0.0009483747,
-0.0536276251,
-0.0038906524,
-0.0241226237,
-0.0120234443,
-0.0067126644,
-0.000088224,
-0.0572583079,
0.0644535273,
-0.0866824761,
-0.0593994781,
0.008322021,
0.1081166044,
-0.0143864993,
0.0003875111,
-0.0330971368,
0.0051281322,
0.0007953254,
0.1134879142,
0.0427661724,
0.0037532456,
-0.0310066752,
-0.051415544,
-0.0264600571,
-0.0400038473,
-0.048409503,
0.0021660055,
0.075091809,
0.0006159036,
-0.0466951244,
-0.037917085,
0.0420455858,
0.0158477444,
-0.0190162621,
0.0273796264,
-0.0051419088,
0.0228444934,
-0.038029436,
0.0637307167,
-0.0268198363,
-0.0036750163,
-0.0508290902,
0.0206236281,
0.0367432795,
-0.040512342,
-0.0292420723,
0.0510126948,
-0.0323784612,
-0.0373412706,
-0.0169379748,
0.0478084609,
0.0312012527,
0.0128470305,
-0.0385749117,
-0.0313341245,
0.0112070376,
0.0403041095,
-0.0188026801,
-0.0263091624,
0.0365089625,
0.0085955877,
0.0083360262,
0.072645925,
-0.0232592747,
-0.0069628661,
-0.0108455271,
0.0801910162,
-0.0015508836,
-0.0040577343,
0.0468901023,
0.0057060067,
0.0146578224,
0.0087937536,
-0.0185894351,
-0.042612642,
-0.0018584538,
-0.0255559403,
-0.0289038494,
-0.0399748199,
0.0443245359,
0.0241874084,
-0.0457653627,
-0.0045534433,
-0.0316071957,
-0.0211324673,
0.0236222651,
-0.0391094536,
0.0197527483,
0.0277141575,
0.0037237208,
0.0085551217,
-0.0479894392,
-0.0314663537,
-0.0184172001,
-0.0446128547,
0.0353297926,
-0.0261367317,
0.0800327584,
0.0421481021,
-0.0358728357,
0.0197734423,
0.0182794556,
-0.0797259882,
-0.056107495,
0.0150469793,
0.0499253348,
0.0327242427,
-0.0236329921,
0.0203875825,
-0.0279061049,
-0.0188056678,
0.0011873234,
0.0537012964,
0.0456284322,
-0.0210099071,
0.0520270094,
0.0283798091,
-0.0170253124,
-0.0346978046,
0.0775159001,
-0.0195125993,
0.047056932,
0.0338371359,
-0.0263927653,
-0.0344694555,
-0.0447595753,
-0.0139857121,
0.0515492372,
-0.0133196302,
0.0431003645,
-0.0803369433,
-0.0473494045,
-0.028722439,
0.0157632288,
-0.0022106848,
-0.0065861791,
0.0129995886,
0.0755011365,
0.0114990184,
-0.073167786,
-0.0317799561,
0.0448638648,
-0.0658569112,
0.0030958222,
-0.0233483184,
-6.712500329e-33,
-0.0145613495,
-0.0100728748,
0.0167170763,
-0.0222391114,
0.0099108517,
0.0045956145,
-0.0665385276,
-0.0215558745,
-0.0385982431,
0.0314343832,
-0.0134615852,
0.0257083233,
0.0014422954,
0.0351125933,
-0.012673825,
-0.0260933209,
0.0337922834,
0.036151465,
-0.0268473774,
0.02482103,
0.0488287844,
-0.0316236988,
0.0400681719,
-0.0038509308,
0.0315211527,
-0.008584924,
-0.0087521505,
0.0353347138,
-0.0749749094,
0.0632324368,
-0.0011155925,
0.0537068211,
0.0283907913,
-0.0432553068,
0.0190021284,
0.0320517793,
-0.1028384045,
-0.0484413952,
0.0601974204,
-0.0288016684,
-0.048946742,
-0.0406142622,
-0.0021166052,
0.0217194892,
-0.0018852731,
-0.0075999601,
0.0094676763,
-0.0363439135,
-0.0102273887,
-0.0123348413,
-0.0190617386,
0.0296103302,
-0.03084247,
-0.0422711186,
-0.0156777129,
0.0336883701,
-0.0090777176,
0.023335604,
-0.0647878125,
0.0149327479,
0.0068308078,
0.0029109351,
0.0555366687,
-0.0259787757,
-0.0028874525,
0.0318919048,
-0.0428200588,
-0.0158855245,
-0.0409056321,
0.0209016874,
-0.0270855203,
0.0489898399,
0.0508116409,
0.0387636088,
0.0214454681,
0.0258667562,
-0.0815688893,
0.0400119722,
0.0066984016,
0.0639098957,
0.0481807776,
-0.0022089912,
-0.0560068004,
-0.0172196124,
-0.066203922,
-0.0588679686,
-0.0268052053,
0.0126493862,
0.032178469,
-0.0098545039,
-0.0304988623,
0.0163628533,
0.0285413302,
-0.0335051306,
-0.0014092579,
0.0536729507,
-0.0125888912,
-0.0026121526,
0.0016216135,
0.0446151756,
-0.0568349175,
0.0090062078,
0.0256924182,
0.0057134796,
0.0004580354,
0.0314733051,
0.0233608037,
0.0048461501,
-0.0301835276,
-0.0023081705,
-0.0576571785,
0.0352285095,
-0.0455400199,
0.0332918279,
0.0630473346,
0.0265952442,
0.0039153313,
0.0486716554,
-0.0048269168,
0.0108610671,
-0.0182453711,
0.0318321176,
-0.0044142716,
-0.0085082836,
0.0053284913,
0.0044514248,
-0.043429926,
-0.0149342613,
0.017481951,
-0.0249109138,
-0.0134050203,
0.0240888,
2.779e-7,
0.0290444326,
0.0283321105,
0.0032911131,
0.0172838643,
-0.0022749072,
0.0523448102,
0.0110344589,
0.0077136871,
-0.0015184134,
-0.0555864163,
-0.0186162926,
0.0815444067,
0.0333934203,
0.0315260477,
-0.0509743802,
0.025664622,
-0.0650940388,
-0.0387669094,
-0.0736822262,
0.0115721142,
0.0793263987,
0.1141274199,
0.0106338849,
-0.0143342149,
0.0479617789,
-0.028103916,
0.0213119127,
-0.0389525071,
-0.0077088606,
-0.0139462184,
0.0228204504,
-0.0116473362,
0.021867685,
0.034922678,
0.0010318989,
0.0055151177,
-0.0274968073,
0.0539167896,
0.0002621505,
-0.0013059977,
-0.0237619188,
-0.0563059375,
0.0338840298,
-0.0892172828,
0.0955340713,
-0.042222932,
-0.0666173398,
-0.0207932312,
-0.0223457068,
-0.0221907925,
0.0026948375,
-0.0029496236,
-0.0108548636,
-0.0175066143,
0.0004650198,
-0.0223584585,
-0.0100713363,
-0.0688328445,
-0.0268132351,
0.0062118103,
-0.0023943316,
-0.0380334184,
-0.0408610962,
-0.0436714813,
0.0364031717,
-0.1106646508,
0.0078700846,
3.006103872e-34,
0.0197449327,
0.0059785936,
0.0140763102,
-0.0193453934,
0.0645114407,
0.0157649908,
0.0058456324,
-0.0081115626,
0.0321178995,
-0.0861368701,
-0.0121828662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13147v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13147v2 | Cardiovascular Disease Risk Prediction via Social Media | 2023-09-22T19:03:34 | 2023-09-28T22:49:01 | Al Zadid Sultan Bin Habib, Md Asif Bin Syed, Md Tanvirul Islam, Donald A. Adjeroh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Researchers use Twitter and sentiment analysis to predict Cardiovascular
Disease (CVD) risk. We developed a new dictionary of CVD-related keywords by
analyzing emotions expressed in tweets. Tweets from eighteen US states,
including the Appalachian region, were collected. Using the VADER model for
sentiment analysis, users were classified as potentially at CVD risk. Machine
Learning (ML) models were employed to classify individuals' CVD risk and
applied to a CDC dataset with demographic information to make the comparison.
Performance evaluation metrics such as Test Accuracy, Precision, Recall, F1
score, Mathew's Correlation Coefficient (MCC), and Cohen's Kappa (CK) score
were considered. Results demonstrated that analyzing tweets' emotions surpassed
the predictive power of demographic data alone, enabling the identification of
individuals at potential risk of developing CVD. This research highlights the
potential of Natural Language Processing (NLP) and ML techniques in using
tweets to identify individuals with CVD risks, providing an alternative
approach to traditional demographic information for public health monitoring. | [
0.0506574735,
0.0565092601,
-0.0012319336,
-0.050051745,
-0.0252611637,
0.0416743085,
-0.0270904358,
0.0269565992,
0.051284533,
-0.0371958278,
0.0772437155,
0.0077464739,
-0.0185516831,
0.0288438872,
-0.03216758,
-0.0385266505,
0.0054581035,
0.0543801673,
0.0674173534,
0.0192175899,
0.0236380883,
0.0275284909,
0.016670065,
0.046540264,
-0.0059982361,
-0.004058315,
0.044515755,
-0.0404306017,
0.0410093889,
-0.0564779192,
0.0344339684,
0.0216643084,
-0.0250781309,
-0.0141007556,
0.0000018513,
-0.054734949,
-0.0212125443,
0.0086889481,
0.0141639188,
-0.0424386263,
0.0849820077,
-0.0792376474,
0.0268019531,
0.0332727022,
-0.078855969,
0.0035280127,
0.0589677133,
0.0223936252,
0.0434669815,
0.0435110815,
-0.0198365021,
-0.017593123,
-0.0368531905,
0.0141994134,
0.0062698596,
-0.0077181687,
0.0450224355,
-0.0073146294,
-0.0038696234,
-0.0347417332,
0.0354488194,
0.0427276492,
-0.0265353527,
0.0609849691,
0.0475165099,
0.0216294304,
-0.034377113,
-0.0374152027,
-0.0010347733,
0.0187818706,
0.0155264148,
0.0001878672,
0.0142944278,
0.0067355558,
-0.0056838901,
0.0213134997,
-0.0152220447,
-0.0327083655,
-0.0438300185,
0.0422494411,
-0.0120544992,
0.029380301,
0.0102629885,
0.0352271684,
0.0206848942,
0.028778201,
-0.0365310721,
-0.0397255309,
0.0089155082,
0.0292153619,
0.006027828,
-0.0275723543,
0.0248267576,
-0.0171045307,
-0.0111581907,
0.0148842307,
0.0174214188,
-0.0358394608,
0.062266849,
-0.1254184395,
-0.0226482954,
-0.0169577394,
0.0250415802,
-0.0006529861,
0.0451592952,
-0.0261982735,
0.0334810652,
0.0116976127,
0.0058278404,
0.0408223793,
-0.0905573368,
0.0167403594,
0.030558452,
0.0237947553,
0.0166282356,
0.0100505557,
-0.1188936085,
-0.0435829125,
-0.0316473655,
-0.0383509174,
-0.0255506802,
0.0528977886,
0.0503787026,
0.0487177558,
-0.0311212987,
0.0352033116,
0.001105297,
0.0208971351,
-0.0355399698,
0.0056212186,
0.0688693225,
-0.0285869949,
0.0578392521,
0.0027055698,
0.021218447,
0.0376368165,
0.0314716138,
-0.0365890525,
-0.0220430717,
-0.021572981,
-0.0236107949,
-0.0044865226,
-0.0317870155,
-0.0552146994,
0.0123321814,
0.0366432108,
0.0088650482,
-0.0014321789,
0.0152845979,
0.0282909572,
-0.0475301966,
0.0374811515,
-0.0340906754,
0.0294839889,
0.0231421068,
0.0020570282,
0.0488692969,
0.0309407562,
0.042349685,
0.0212921221,
0.0273947883,
-0.0229923408,
-0.011179178,
0.0068795257,
0.0184586439,
-0.0449810363,
0.0024190196,
-0.0113514941,
-0.0367792174,
0.0053698141,
-0.0681080893,
0.0591514185,
0.027995104,
0.0227433145,
0.0375518352,
0.0352503546,
0.0142397396,
0.0247461963,
0.0134356776,
0.0378867052,
-0.001238269,
-0.053873226,
-0.0054641906,
-0.0281887725,
-0.046285402,
-0.0113412337,
0.0014253412,
-0.0010629899,
-0.0114472061,
-0.0419151299,
-0.0516532436,
0.0119049111,
0.0553355478,
-0.068234764,
0.0186698157,
-0.0470742323,
-0.0346785188,
0.0067526377,
0.0372303575,
-0.0340060703,
-0.0126348129,
-0.01335005,
-0.0241448861,
0.0652916506,
0.0063277083,
0.0084141865,
0.0269889534,
-0.0306032281,
0.0181785859,
-0.0291520245,
0.0239417627,
0.0216105077,
-0.0152545553,
-0.0106329471,
0.003993649,
0.0294557046,
0.0179663636,
-0.0356103852,
0.0360667259,
0.0632653683,
-0.0216846,
-0.0017872425,
-0.0530071333,
0.0285084341,
0.0072984374,
-0.0166383311,
0.0006477116,
0.0222328883,
0.0285805967,
0.0428128242,
0.0296224784,
0.0143638318,
-0.0026662524,
-0.0082489131,
-0.0704438761,
-0.0105674258,
0.0041445419,
0.0094316583,
0.0065402552,
-0.0585089996,
-0.0017598332,
0.0090739839,
-0.0459666923,
0.0249747094,
0.0355888605,
-0.0514105745,
-0.0168176927,
-0.0062882663,
-0.0402181596,
-0.0167091042,
0.0086269053,
0.0002793994,
0.0528692566,
-0.0404035114,
-0.0017748009,
-0.0291241426,
-0.0812469348,
-0.0106222862,
0.0166579746,
-0.0247171391,
-0.0549071282,
-0.0096990438,
0.0268522222,
0.0155200912,
0.0103819408,
-0.0279441997,
-0.0041753715,
-0.0808633938,
0.0012236927,
-0.0080623562,
0.0006453072,
-0.0206702538,
0.0188387763,
-0.0249712765,
-0.0029370475,
0.0131823216,
-0.008088653,
0.0412784964,
0.0314310566,
0.0289304201,
0.0220105927,
0.0606818534,
-0.0099546332,
0.0042256727,
-0.0686960965,
0.0322897136,
0.0717419609,
-0.0820431709,
0.0235849563,
-0.0062404415,
-0.0564966984,
-0.0313509069,
0.0269175507,
-0.0115673477,
-0.016865734,
0.016729787,
-0.0276966263,
-0.0132768601,
0.0211203005,
0.0701415315,
0.0157080665,
0.0235958975,
0.0102573344,
0.0318487734,
-0.0806002989,
-0.0239676908,
0.0080450913,
-0.0472001173,
0.0065707369,
0.0242953245,
0.0214296542,
0.0230559558,
-0.0310088657,
0.0193679612,
-0.0339520499,
0.000920644,
-0.0701066405,
-0.0142869735,
-0.0061047836,
0.0388362259,
0.0132555077,
-0.0618446991,
0.0311996937,
0.0504181013,
0.0516190231,
-0.0828979239,
-0.0474693291,
-0.0308525655,
0.0003558046,
0.0318203606,
0.0197448842,
0.0605526119,
0.0191452615,
0.0603345074,
-0.019653663,
-0.0391883738,
-0.0389105491,
0.0201222338,
-0.0187796149,
-0.0191300865,
0.0229329858,
-0.0391316786,
-0.011383038,
-0.0516733155,
-0.097888805,
-0.0053933631,
0.0087973615,
-0.0110838301,
-0.0202759244,
0.0248464774,
-0.0329467431,
-0.0413634367,
0.0028551531,
-0.0332819223,
0.0413641669,
-0.0110813817,
0.0424283743,
-0.045921877,
-0.000829261,
0.0070918566,
0.0208085068,
0.0483206138,
-0.0012589459,
-0.0007158729,
-0.0413258597,
0.0245654993,
-0.0300996993,
0.0003010439,
0.0037160919,
-0.0056016026,
0.0150066027,
0.0189322941,
0.029314978,
0.0966880918,
0.037514247,
-0.0122821843,
0.0278801825,
-0.0037656559,
-0.0133416289,
-0.0215704106,
-0.002406996,
-0.0486745164,
-0.0251827054,
-0.0378292166,
0.0195254069,
-0.043755956,
-0.0478061102,
0.0093028564,
-0.0331219994,
0.0336120278,
-0.0105496524,
-0.0043334272,
-0.0252259616,
-0.074639678,
-0.0025880872,
-0.0349306315,
-0.0242058001,
-0.0814177468,
-0.0334964767,
0.0125793517,
0.0223436039,
-0.1195630282,
-0.0522423908,
0.0328957997,
0.0004805063,
-0.013824394,
0.0550258271,
0.1003486216,
-0.0217646472,
0.000308557,
-0.0222359318,
0.0147210862,
0.0480084755,
-0.0307167135,
0.0965285152,
0.0105572594,
0.0073647765,
-0.0763019249,
0.0035968164,
-0.0278700795,
0.0024830452,
0.001237531,
0.0673098043,
-0.0160816759,
-0.063357532,
-0.0555493236,
0.0812183395,
0.0184086189,
0.0242865421,
0.0108929938,
-0.0176309273,
-0.0029223345,
-0.0038437669,
0.032235764,
-0.0013431073,
-0.0492857508,
-0.0320569947,
-0.0341704898,
-0.0772743076,
-0.0335862637,
-0.0306934994,
0.0285159256,
-0.0329047963,
-0.0087620961,
0.0165581349,
0.0665711537,
0.0011196128,
-0.0478812344,
0.0410822593,
0.0295541566,
0.0534410588,
0.0229795594,
-0.003824631,
0.0364215299,
0.0271218885,
-0.0073531545,
-0.0003882068,
-0.0512951128,
-0.0349123552,
-0.0150893051,
0.0346762389,
0.0234517734,
-0.0075127268,
-0.0038691014,
-0.0342952833,
0.0422279723,
0.075025633,
-0.0127310427,
-0.0459079593,
-0.029824011,
0.0395922996,
0.0198066328,
0.0048451978,
0.0298193321,
-0.0123855891,
-0.0143510159,
-0.0364111625,
-0.0551112145,
0.0150811588,
-0.0203229971,
0.0074058739,
0.0588764623,
0.015935557,
-0.0631834045,
-0.0032088456,
-0.0458176881,
0.0316819102,
-0.0024876113,
-0.0083702849,
-0.0057624574,
-0.0128440326,
0.0550928898,
-0.0953488275,
-0.0258200597,
-0.0093978904,
-0.0356928296,
-0.0674617589,
0.0783980489,
0.0203959905,
0.0589943267,
0.0231069513,
-0.0065772007,
0.0156539567,
-0.0315292552,
0.0203413479,
-0.0153140957,
0.0091044158,
0.0184880886,
-0.0356354602,
0.0343706086,
-0.0130298529,
0.0155348219,
-0.0464564599,
0.0112933284,
-0.022469379,
0.0148966247,
0.0001914207,
-0.0344833545,
0.017072415,
-0.029134905,
-0.0023387745,
-0.0090231523,
0.0208116993,
-0.0625115708,
-0.0152479252,
0.0628094226,
-0.0400428772,
-0.0372177437,
0.0047330949,
0.0515891239,
-0.0107412646,
0.023123594,
0.0243614782,
-0.0747029483,
-0.0238924697,
0.0226618834,
0.025298249,
0.0395966806,
-0.0138621945,
0.0193393007,
-0.060464453,
-0.0376752354,
0.1176427975,
-0.0612367429,
0.002723983,
-0.0219142009,
0.0036056268,
0.0392982997,
-0.0031269535,
0.0414475724,
-0.0563330799,
-0.0035017456,
-0.042506963,
-0.0286971461,
-0.0318286903,
-5.610430662e-33,
0.0229575131,
-0.0488548242,
0.0125273429,
0.0012202593,
0.0063675297,
0.0240874793,
0.000176753,
0.0199753437,
0.0157569535,
0.051890891,
-0.0119791422,
0.0000784294,
0.0116126761,
0.0126802316,
0.0303329062,
-0.0669020638,
-0.0076774112,
0.0008150216,
0.0109810447,
0.0014375603,
-0.0165075921,
0.0674550906,
0.0065915589,
-0.1257269531,
0.0349315479,
0.0323145539,
-0.0004207824,
-0.0121934107,
0.0502683483,
0.0375516824,
-0.0182065014,
0.1032383293,
0.0424782895,
-0.0032958896,
0.0032505421,
0.0664218813,
-0.0064779338,
-0.0586233363,
0.0131347701,
-0.0341347642,
0.0166570842,
-0.0009613889,
0.0444189496,
0.0425012968,
-0.0500701219,
0.0195514895,
0.0561111011,
-0.0059326664,
0.0129598808,
-0.0637590215,
-0.0168732349,
0.026685128,
-0.0061503984,
0.0198040307,
-0.0144667225,
0.0567711107,
-0.0298214462,
0.0339853652,
-0.0448981151,
0.0069932584,
0.0188671853,
-0.0256656799,
-0.0094601214,
-0.0328219831,
-0.0378048308,
0.05950322,
0.0077526611,
-0.0495116301,
-0.0498061106,
0.0364380404,
-0.04466879,
0.0477804877,
0.0563629828,
0.0677008554,
-0.0054981322,
-0.0569846556,
-0.0491652414,
0.0439686328,
-0.0151182087,
-0.0112727964,
0.0226425622,
-0.0342157595,
-0.0454987213,
-0.010945349,
0.0035208878,
-0.0061265822,
-0.023823021,
-0.0077086678,
-0.0314625837,
0.0009332879,
0.0198760219,
0.0138421878,
-0.0240770131,
-0.0283103418,
-0.02898442,
0.0281431433,
0.034568347,
0.0077074226,
-0.0173538513,
-0.0107859783,
-0.033994168,
0.0386048146,
-0.0254752841,
0.0458749533,
0.0270497911,
-0.0182491262,
0.0410806127,
-0.0143689141,
-0.0504934043,
-0.0247535072,
0.0295143556,
0.0150836175,
-0.0144030899,
0.0009804281,
0.0083632059,
0.0241677091,
0.0172325689,
0.0356965326,
0.0177711267,
0.0452055782,
0.0040179575,
-0.0329169817,
-0.0392618813,
-0.0303330962,
-0.019067049,
-0.0030002664,
-0.0084317429,
0.0178328082,
-0.0138971638,
-0.066433914,
0.009819313,
-0.0477664731,
2.539e-7,
0.1024867669,
0.0857726485,
-0.0531885587,
-0.0755439997,
0.0129745686,
0.0490646921,
0.0203636512,
0.0028187097,
0.0157527979,
-0.0051438631,
0.0302494317,
0.0006971951,
0.0046836957,
0.0610738397,
-0.0562115349,
0.0037214886,
-0.0664158985,
-0.0043928209,
-0.0330806002,
0.023791723,
0.0613649748,
0.0691176727,
-0.0028126237,
-0.0368102193,
-0.0201915372,
0.0277781021,
0.0053527909,
-0.0422439687,
-0.0158693213,
0.0044576344,
0.0204565283,
-0.0056972113,
0.0208083987,
0.0336660109,
-0.0424001403,
-0.0216529854,
0.018703416,
0.0267181154,
-0.0189056862,
0.0240431447,
0.0260178447,
0.0032808173,
-0.0057265195,
-0.0014417673,
0.0625332147,
-0.0621443875,
-0.0760175809,
-0.0749683678,
0.0162650235,
-0.0023166495,
0.0568897091,
-0.0042882455,
-0.0519902036,
0.0334795155,
-0.0017715752,
0.0044819424,
-0.0191481374,
-0.0397756994,
0.0004454118,
-0.0128577808,
-0.0007953023,
-0.0204567853,
0.0191408489,
0.0389614962,
0.0125919208,
-0.01826372,
0.0353876688,
1.664826476e-34,
-0.0005326734,
0.0243293922,
-0.018315345,
-0.0288640149,
0.0381266847,
0.0175646078,
-0.0085071186,
0.0063350243,
-0.0143657858,
-0.0323412791,
0.0268001147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13018v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13018v2 | Dynamic ASR Pathways: An Adaptive Masking Approach Towards Efficient Pruning of A Multilingual ASR Model | 2023-09-22T17:30:28 | 2024-01-11T19:15:32 | Jiamin Xie, Ke Li, Jinxi Guo, Andros Tjandra, Yuan Shangguan, Leda Sari, Chunyang Wu, Junteng Jia, Jay Mahadeokar, Ozlem Kalinli | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Neural network pruning offers an effective method for compressing a
multilingual automatic speech recognition (ASR) model with minimal performance
loss. However, it entails several rounds of pruning and re-training needed to
be run for each language. In this work, we propose the use of an adaptive
masking approach in two scenarios for pruning a multilingual ASR model
efficiently, each resulting in sparse monolingual models or a sparse
multilingual model (named as Dynamic ASR Pathways). Our approach dynamically
adapts the sub-network, avoiding premature decisions about a fixed sub-network
structure. We show that our approach outperforms existing pruning methods when
targeting sparse monolingual models. Further, we illustrate that Dynamic ASR
Pathways jointly discovers and trains better sub-networks (pathways) of a
single multilingual model by adapting from different sub-network
initializations, thereby reducing the need for language-specific pruning. | [
-0.0525150746,
0.065928854,
-0.0193537492,
0.0423423536,
-0.031549979,
0.0098988228,
0.0704116821,
0.0091163469,
-0.020866001,
0.0493052974,
-0.0745928288,
-0.0352141112,
0.0174917877,
0.0118771568,
0.0176880118,
-0.0136991497,
0.03307347,
-0.067199558,
-0.0169587359,
-0.0336648189,
-0.0043901829,
0.0331497155,
0.0146370986,
0.0542631522,
0.0297139604,
0.0096935546,
-0.0078707123,
-0.0019846072,
0.007250153,
0.0157556403,
-0.0205295756,
-0.0094314134,
0.0016495646,
0.0417169146,
0.0000020474,
-0.0020451366,
-0.0135348337,
0.0073089814,
-0.0747071356,
0.0278423056,
0.0359664373,
0.0255443733,
-0.0061994125,
0.0230079591,
0.0020093941,
-0.0569606163,
0.026197508,
0.0042245756,
0.0156761166,
0.0217946041,
-0.004138378,
-0.041468244,
-0.0392050631,
-0.0346256457,
-0.0911050662,
-0.053349521,
-0.0019322342,
-0.0516637303,
-0.0598124526,
-0.0687053576,
-0.0050985906,
0.0250467677,
0.0230062921,
0.0299472641,
-0.0361449644,
0.007238396,
0.0052938168,
-0.0408161655,
0.0164405871,
0.020862842,
-0.0794832036,
-0.0227922089,
0.0226960275,
-0.0182365589,
-0.0344366021,
-0.0359612256,
-0.0095695639,
0.0074671358,
-0.003160757,
-0.0076468098,
0.0017067143,
-0.0078618862,
0.0487317368,
-0.0032253852,
-0.0197127871,
0.0094379717,
-0.000583873,
-0.0058259363,
0.0082973307,
-0.0520920455,
0.042065911,
-0.0322628096,
0.0578749478,
-0.0004924662,
0.0300766695,
0.0190720446,
-0.018017916,
-0.0234702323,
-0.0034582338,
-0.0798470676,
0.0270637125,
0.0573679656,
0.0077183787,
0.0105273006,
-0.0202079862,
0.025731707,
0.0394693837,
-0.0255898964,
-0.0259316526,
-0.0007894421,
0.0006874321,
-0.0061407411,
-0.0594813935,
0.0603975169,
-0.0232170634,
-0.0067275241,
-0.0398309715,
-0.0223328955,
-0.0285808425,
-0.0313549303,
0.0234349817,
-0.0089585604,
-0.0269299019,
-0.001031716,
0.0659626275,
0.0465148091,
-0.0171781816,
0.0010483944,
-0.0280479342,
-0.0431107134,
-0.0108170602,
0.0151442466,
0.0183608513,
-0.0108880699,
0.0163707621,
0.0913346037,
0.015062632,
-0.0221340023,
-0.0951051041,
-0.0065077506,
0.0039373557,
-0.0394826531,
0.021695083,
-0.0396124497,
0.0459864065,
-0.0492085703,
0.0302707627,
-0.0748982206,
-0.0278994665,
-0.0102180047,
-0.0105138989,
0.0353754349,
0.0190163217,
-0.0041137179,
0.0370824933,
-0.0065473155,
0.0465243347,
0.0723605976,
0.0503587611,
-0.0201647487,
-0.0041476157,
-0.0429909192,
-0.0701087713,
0.0582062304,
0.0455249846,
-0.0196946785,
-0.020582296,
-0.0799667984,
-0.0003046305,
-0.0240344293,
0.0452779457,
0.0400772505,
-0.0673287436,
-0.0417685136,
0.0065689203,
0.0483702905,
0.0377714448,
0.0882209241,
0.0608473085,
-0.0229149424,
-0.0181465223,
0.0416329987,
0.0228055324,
-0.0040542344,
-0.0066156611,
-0.0123732528,
-0.0270972606,
0.0695308894,
-0.0517239533,
-0.0176656879,
-0.0003171137,
-0.0207815561,
0.0297519788,
0.0456488915,
0.030159248,
0.0105350269,
-0.0335927084,
0.0503475405,
0.0153049203,
-0.0524019562,
0.0195310451,
-0.0437243953,
-0.0675731525,
0.0109585393,
0.0017314347,
-0.0095807649,
-0.0442399867,
0.0258084536,
-0.0166516565,
-0.0080386838,
-0.0068330667,
-0.012390133,
0.1019612402,
-0.0811940804,
0.0029555012,
0.0095749889,
-0.0120858615,
0.0701033473,
-0.0320363045,
0.0083998358,
-0.0004416181,
-0.0066022868,
-0.0113794198,
-0.0018622355,
-0.0863476098,
-0.0136148492,
0.0659969747,
0.0283064283,
0.034382347,
0.0281197075,
-0.0331784785,
-0.0335506685,
0.0411309227,
-0.0344810188,
0.0120249512,
0.0346601643,
-0.0522519238,
-0.0480779745,
0.0563713759,
0.029147543,
0.0521418676,
0.0430529155,
-0.012635163,
-0.0506709963,
0.0505561754,
-0.0234390348,
0.0324230753,
-0.030833248,
0.0317293778,
-0.0016769101,
0.0519935526,
0.0327726044,
-0.0118455039,
-0.0000021531,
-0.0008304518,
0.021236632,
-0.0602614842,
0.0189241413,
-0.083815366,
-0.0268657617,
0.0376766771,
-0.0337529555,
-0.0172112752,
0.0154423648,
0.0060246191,
0.0368838049,
0.0119276997,
-0.0214865189,
-0.0303600635,
-0.0220009889,
0.0348632857,
-0.019644903,
0.0509216189,
0.0402074419,
-0.0247649737,
0.0187779311,
-0.0104501778,
0.0086651305,
0.0126212155,
-0.0544648468,
0.0000653435,
-0.0373281911,
0.0021426359,
-0.0510577559,
0.0444198176,
0.080896534,
-0.0340410024,
-0.0666106641,
-0.0278633144,
0.0129122129,
0.0013409836,
0.0518216081,
-0.0092395116,
-0.0514094532,
-0.05616346,
0.0558923334,
-0.0112648904,
0.0375054926,
-0.0575962327,
-0.0118225068,
0.070336841,
0.0051632612,
-0.0170364752,
0.0160082411,
0.0031460675,
0.0295615923,
-0.0249098018,
-0.0405050218,
-0.0323293172,
0.0658355057,
0.0257614031,
0.0142601114,
-0.0448951386,
-0.0485036634,
-0.016766414,
-0.0578801297,
-0.0451230891,
-0.0415403619,
-0.0179667119,
0.0072573847,
-0.0044705588,
-0.0007104322,
0.0194029566,
-0.0586398765,
-0.0123121105,
-0.0319266319,
-0.0479589142,
-0.0039665387,
-0.0023559597,
0.0204567928,
0.0550054982,
0.0261946395,
-0.0083852038,
-0.0387295708,
-0.0066398648,
0.0043921042,
-0.0097297179,
0.0184579901,
-0.0369504578,
0.0171776116,
0.0069206459,
-0.0366604701,
0.0030476656,
0.0512612797,
-0.0030715764,
0.0701358467,
0.0201273169,
-0.0324942358,
-0.017041564,
0.0348472968,
0.0123665351,
0.0954427272,
0.04541751,
0.0324712619,
0.0017480666,
0.0398209728,
0.0240312889,
0.021096414,
0.0172065236,
-0.0293635242,
0.0707517713,
-0.0049617975,
0.0585808456,
0.0037518647,
-0.0544834435,
-0.0069379807,
0.0430838428,
0.0020757529,
-0.0094871297,
-0.0048190816,
0.004122871,
-0.0476061925,
0.0089484528,
0.0541969948,
-0.0055549704,
-0.0395297818,
0.0040444476,
-0.0062509608,
0.0482686423,
0.0002299953,
0.0169464238,
-0.0487100966,
0.0067332485,
0.0437438339,
0.0178601854,
0.0112396777,
0.006460438,
-0.0111381281,
-0.0964564905,
0.0105186179,
0.0210118666,
-0.0511538833,
0.0494201817,
-0.0490962118,
-0.0117376987,
-0.0340569466,
0.0386642329,
-0.0150295561,
0.0008078981,
-0.0671738088,
0.0362364128,
-0.0712906793,
-0.0607790723,
0.0086138528,
0.0041443864,
0.0444262661,
0.0237473883,
0.0289275888,
-0.0184154361,
-0.0101907812,
0.0664098337,
-0.0132071096,
0.022059273,
-0.040249832,
0.023607539,
0.0605386682,
0.0079067117,
0.0408512615,
-0.0014342989,
-0.0169451497,
-0.0136158932,
0.0015281735,
0.0691845268,
-0.0031550704,
-0.0017158645,
0.0165304318,
0.003956933,
-0.0253453013,
0.0420106314,
0.0347338468,
-0.0037523655,
-0.0256228838,
0.0005657027,
0.0358237103,
-0.0646777898,
-0.0111239236,
0.0287418906,
-0.0430272743,
-0.0968691781,
-0.0024187753,
0.0092126196,
-0.0009257134,
0.0271287877,
0.0183697827,
0.0208390858,
0.0190762933,
0.0422984101,
-0.0180511158,
-0.0033759929,
-0.0118841948,
0.0212639906,
-0.0336006023,
0.003789074,
-0.0016429558,
-0.044431325,
-0.0342531353,
0.0099584134,
-0.0834308416,
-0.0672028884,
0.0036462063,
0.0345060416,
0.0171222091,
0.0694213808,
-0.0049429513,
-0.087847732,
0.0293041933,
-0.0164827667,
0.0144749936,
0.052718062,
0.0737963617,
-0.0405686423,
-0.0434124693,
0.0615761094,
-0.0222182777,
0.0217472874,
0.0038559132,
0.0097838277,
-0.026482027,
0.0236029122,
-0.0236318801,
0.0328602865,
0.0084917834,
-0.0304563437,
-0.032595057,
-0.0501560569,
0.0406613573,
0.0415142775,
0.0422224179,
-0.0380340219,
0.0176852196,
0.0042309701,
0.0456743911,
0.0098439585,
0.0039067348,
0.0159557313,
-0.0564106926,
-0.0309050344,
0.0534713455,
0.0443092324,
0.0029155368,
0.0156573523,
0.0266823731,
-0.0163173638,
0.0214227121,
0.0138696013,
-0.0254397932,
-0.0456535928,
-0.0307586305,
0.0015675867,
0.0345973931,
-0.0586235113,
0.0253183916,
-0.0017634383,
-0.0632330403,
-0.0156349782,
0.0371177942,
0.0489892401,
-0.0074114911,
0.0327517763,
0.003031983,
0.0090235956,
-0.0372974277,
0.0024861661,
0.021985922,
-0.0116948048,
0.0200111661,
-0.0030856575,
-0.0056944885,
0.0102603417,
0.0768611804,
0.0032151642,
0.0819821134,
-0.0189609379,
0.0022702857,
-0.0417792574,
-0.0487517007,
-0.0477608442,
0.0461600199,
-0.0380528942,
-0.0177516695,
-0.0154517693,
-0.0974257439,
0.0144338449,
-0.0090659736,
0.0534793101,
-0.0268471092,
0.0353257731,
0.0096511496,
-0.0021858383,
0.0182165317,
0.0108928168,
-0.0317371115,
0.0002703562,
-0.0345420614,
0.015919758,
-6.274321586e-33,
0.016803924,
0.0111404788,
0.014558062,
0.0130600538,
-0.0198793821,
0.0470506065,
-0.0281813201,
-0.02251333,
-0.0272514913,
-0.0159744155,
-0.0279301554,
-0.0271066874,
0.029599335,
-0.0034665777,
-0.039801158,
0.0131047787,
0.1088921726,
-0.0106832776,
0.009785831,
0.0343019105,
0.0285022184,
0.0413677841,
0.0659548938,
-0.0393981896,
-0.0749167055,
0.0415928103,
-0.0140566407,
-0.0058809184,
0.0020888038,
0.0442297384,
-0.0247469917,
0.0389416739,
0.008263234,
-0.0127094947,
-0.00090785,
-0.0053182361,
-0.0966215357,
-0.0316742584,
0.0075918939,
0.0366666988,
-0.0132115623,
-0.0388444401,
0.0487499349,
0.0127616888,
-0.0285484698,
0.0108326143,
0.014909206,
-0.0142077524,
-0.0556844957,
-0.0335222892,
-0.0153177651,
0.0484064594,
0.0068837376,
-0.0209844876,
0.0657993928,
0.0525757857,
-0.0487192459,
-0.0259198435,
-0.0634255558,
0.0021081548,
0.0151297264,
0.0516901538,
0.0561285987,
0.0404659249,
0.0202475246,
0.0157259163,
0.0587244555,
0.0048984117,
0.033894144,
0.0018750054,
0.0652869567,
0.0036308842,
0.0268900879,
0.0159071665,
0.0467029959,
-0.0476718917,
-0.0784183815,
-0.0457810797,
0.0354393646,
0.0445898771,
0.0310371611,
0.0391848162,
0.0139165679,
-0.0141718443,
-0.0408393368,
-0.0463056378,
-0.0365100168,
-0.007879517,
0.0134031996,
0.0341057181,
-0.0303158388,
0.0296672881,
0.0482277572,
-0.0355931222,
0.0125474269,
0.0657946095,
0.0205571502,
0.0076887663,
0.0355469659,
0.0344076343,
-0.0516296588,
-0.0245140865,
-0.0427132621,
-0.0010130025,
0.0284722485,
-0.0312757418,
0.0174357686,
0.0773907974,
-0.0173051488,
-0.0126557238,
-0.0303814486,
0.0313140601,
0.0408875905,
0.0772474185,
0.0503884964,
0.0015820703,
0.011392531,
0.0269758441,
0.0182925425,
-0.0057716956,
-0.0091387164,
0.0312584378,
0.0307121985,
0.0506955236,
-0.0496596992,
-0.0206897818,
0.0038837108,
-0.0223900359,
0.0431613661,
-0.0546884388,
-0.0316776447,
0.0436592773,
2.855e-7,
-0.0362659022,
-0.0271553975,
0.0052375603,
-0.0227505453,
0.0154978735,
-0.0067101987,
-0.013652171,
-0.0412124731,
-0.0349653475,
0.0362146907,
-0.0235401783,
0.0173516106,
0.0492346399,
0.0452502817,
-0.0649237931,
-0.0124674505,
-0.0427753888,
0.0039903349,
0.0048965481,
-0.000134212,
-0.077660732,
0.0703772902,
-0.0034640413,
-0.0412977561,
-0.0052970094,
-0.021677807,
-0.0071047088,
-0.0017199323,
0.015783716,
-0.0229308344,
-0.0257388242,
-0.0289494134,
-0.0351604298,
-0.0113669327,
-0.0219630823,
0.0262441244,
0.0000588524,
0.0446698964,
-0.0201113094,
-0.0204014201,
0.0561561659,
0.0456599928,
-0.0505866706,
-0.0026071649,
0.0407401249,
0.0239175353,
-0.012398798,
-0.034645047,
0.0102236839,
0.0103881238,
0.0178888254,
-0.0467576385,
-0.0107354624,
0.0535677895,
0.0043554483,
-0.0490904301,
-0.0157720819,
-0.0414776541,
0.0183378924,
0.0087274546,
-0.0660882518,
0.0149515914,
-0.0301852748,
-0.0247652195,
0.026287904,
-0.0344650112,
0.0142087061,
2.288614721e-34,
0.020370841,
-0.0422289521,
-0.0151199214,
0.0487904027,
0.0102675995,
-0.060663756,
-0.0166349337,
0.0463654585,
-0.0456324257,
-0.0562677309,
-0.0465853661
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13007v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13007v3 | ReConcile: Round-Table Conference Improves Reasoning via Consensus among Diverse LLMs | 2023-09-22T17:12:45 | 2024-06-21T19:34:27 | Justin Chih-Yao Chen, Swarnadeep Saha, Mohit Bansal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) still struggle with natural language reasoning
tasks. Motivated by the society of minds (Minsky, 1988), we propose ReConcile,
a multi-model multi-agent framework designed as a round table conference among
diverse LLM agents. ReConcile enhances collaborative reasoning between LLM
agents via multiple rounds of discussion, learning to convince other agents to
improve their answers, and employing a confidence-weighted voting mechanism
that leads to a better consensus. In each round, ReConcile initiates discussion
between agents via a 'discussion prompt' that consists of (a) grouped answers
and explanations generated by each agent in the previous round, (b) their
confidence scores, and (c) demonstrations of answer-rectifying human
explanations, used for convincing other agents. Experiments on seven benchmarks
demonstrate that ReConcile significantly improves LLMs' reasoning -- both
individually and as a team -- surpassing prior single-agent and multi-agent
baselines by up to 11.4% and even outperforming GPT-4 on three datasets.
ReConcile also flexibly incorporates different combinations of agents,
including API-based, open-source, and domain-specific models, leading to an 8%
improvement on MATH. Finally, we analyze the individual components of
ReConcile, demonstrating that the diversity originating from different models
is critical to its superior performance. Code:
https://github.com/dinobby/ReConcile | [
0.010180315,
0.075346835,
-0.0094349785,
0.057382036,
-0.0720483065,
0.0016716078,
0.0315221213,
-0.0261779726,
0.0113823274,
-0.0156427734,
-0.0187647473,
0.0127443615,
0.0114949392,
0.0142691294,
0.0086686648,
-0.0389578417,
0.0304364171,
-0.0346049666,
0.0403004922,
-0.0429088175,
-0.00701713,
0.0076199896,
-0.041124139,
0.0479981974,
0.0176843982,
-0.0329429246,
-0.0182570443,
-0.0383567363,
0.0037132883,
-0.0037423368,
-0.0113541093,
0.0601685047,
0.0356701873,
0.0530925654,
0.0000020756,
-0.0364338793,
-0.0145085268,
0.002200071,
-0.0463127457,
-0.0108059207,
0.0105267763,
0.0381182246,
0.008689044,
0.0145280994,
-0.0763656497,
0.0231294613,
0.0275904443,
0.0110433279,
0.0642688349,
0.0342180915,
0.0175726805,
-0.0196609031,
-0.0075550592,
-0.0029035439,
0.018204011,
-0.0709617436,
-0.0035325449,
0.0329460315,
0.0258630887,
-0.0120340399,
0.0040576803,
0.027904585,
0.0357280672,
-0.0236423425,
-0.0069775456,
0.0446997508,
-0.0574413911,
-0.0217190478,
-0.0016335555,
0.0801864117,
0.0587118417,
-0.0162405726,
-0.0146212354,
0.0113459704,
0.0231808443,
0.0362905227,
-0.0733696669,
0.0223874953,
-0.0016284923,
0.0172020365,
-0.0194333587,
-0.0199294891,
0.0332720689,
0.045511391,
-0.0113597587,
0.098510623,
0.0019745829,
0.0073604784,
-0.0103730923,
0.0129057653,
-0.0413536206,
-0.0739814192,
0.0019222794,
0.0579292104,
-0.0762817934,
0.0309205092,
0.0070129978,
-0.000783229,
0.0187389795,
-0.0099626696,
0.0226923618,
0.0456264466,
0.0299967583,
0.0705499277,
-0.013470876,
0.0263429526,
-0.0061272839,
0.0618140213,
0.0027746551,
-0.0234901719,
-0.065278016,
-0.0123928431,
-0.0121965855,
0.0533846617,
-0.0232723095,
0.0058678063,
-0.0094305025,
0.0208183881,
-0.0421071723,
0.0335695557,
0.0239135642,
0.0332752727,
0.0115636233,
-0.0388488621,
-0.0544230044,
0.061242763,
-0.0592745394,
0.028088659,
0.0436717272,
-0.073892042,
-0.0239186455,
-0.0139422566,
-0.0120214755,
-0.0084144399,
0.0275644902,
0.0507151,
-0.0123529602,
0.0288139973,
-0.0232544653,
-0.0387104899,
0.0160702858,
-0.0883124322,
-0.0391820148,
-0.0914253592,
0.0498169139,
0.0050610602,
-0.013961806,
-0.0569778755,
0.0297583435,
0.0159520824,
-0.0176367927,
0.1010038331,
-0.0356963165,
0.0130407615,
0.0606006756,
0.0336149372,
-0.0888002217,
0.0555851609,
0.0608918928,
0.0014679992,
0.0255463794,
0.0040929783,
0.0075489441,
0.0084792841,
0.0016914131,
-0.0017345995,
0.0387214832,
0.0288396403,
-0.0093363542,
0.0597218722,
-0.0526784584,
0.0649512857,
-0.0311442763,
-0.0361751541,
0.0798365176,
0.067513749,
-0.0249055848,
0.0015553331,
-0.0252399966,
-0.0012120476,
0.0197251216,
-0.0149121815,
-0.0548762232,
0.0724425688,
-0.0435362868,
0.0006556714,
0.0568525568,
0.0296001956,
-0.0324225314,
-0.0537730157,
-0.0048976704,
0.006842427,
0.0243236721,
0.0397102609,
0.031133512,
-0.0201115645,
-0.0309500266,
0.0290673468,
0.0244491212,
-0.056912329,
-0.0181666147,
-0.0536396839,
0.0740298182,
0.0158770923,
0.0703582466,
-0.0177607872,
-0.0677551702,
-0.0282071494,
0.019731516,
0.0408231802,
0.0527279414,
-0.0209806915,
-0.0224059299,
-0.040565826,
-0.0405612476,
0.0049760807,
-0.015862938,
0.0275984555,
0.0350132436,
0.0046055159,
-0.0211537797,
-0.0333588682,
0.0036655236,
0.0188989602,
-0.0263158809,
-0.0010351628,
-0.0272113271,
0.0037578545,
0.0410605557,
0.0274616685,
-0.0069284239,
0.033363305,
0.0377966911,
-0.006329474,
-0.0427573174,
0.0331221111,
-0.0349504948,
-0.0158897992,
0.065855518,
-0.010361826,
-0.0386048034,
0.0138606457,
-0.0386861414,
-0.0320372209,
0.0618746355,
0.0054234294,
0.0013455875,
-0.0282979496,
-0.0065111257,
-0.0046645436,
-0.0159076098,
-0.0111026,
0.0634098426,
0.0105749043,
-0.0101434914,
0.0164216142,
0.0125763919,
0.0282487087,
-0.0251870062,
0.0317865498,
0.0437603109,
0.0118599031,
0.0206690077,
0.0341574736,
-0.0141011756,
-0.0610449016,
-0.0247877967,
-0.0675316751,
0.0090962034,
-0.0040056719,
0.0212115683,
-0.0013761133,
-0.0290883426,
0.0170705952,
0.0128131751,
-0.0456355438,
0.0156730656,
0.0281662606,
0.0331662968,
0.0421122722,
0.002026065,
-0.0294811781,
-0.0370098464,
0.0004513093,
-0.0338508561,
0.0396046452,
0.0406651981,
0.0151756452,
-0.0445499681,
-0.0171355568,
-0.0735107213,
0.0194806568,
-0.0051750587,
-0.0035589649,
0.0569767766,
-0.0107695935,
-0.0114971958,
0.0749095157,
-0.0093724979,
0.0137768043,
0.0418037772,
-0.0150012821,
-0.0904319808,
0.0294884574,
-0.0019673882,
-0.0085810209,
-0.0395033732,
-0.0228924472,
-0.0188259631,
0.0644572228,
-0.0222784653,
-0.0222406425,
-0.045530349,
0.0484830067,
0.0226062816,
-0.0172190666,
-0.039987158,
-0.0232133195,
0.0032339252,
0.0319603086,
-0.0330302194,
-0.022555152,
0.0837390795,
-0.017304983,
-0.0156484731,
-0.0540681705,
0.0033140804,
-0.0674404427,
0.0723758787,
-0.0524808764,
-0.0053244652,
0.0053356821,
-0.0101289973,
-0.0591588244,
-0.0457675606,
0.0515113547,
-0.0354058221,
0.0659453943,
-0.0949388221,
0.0101412339,
-0.0145801911,
-0.0306690689,
-0.0218281392,
-0.0186305884,
-0.0550085381,
0.0345667563,
-0.0115874885,
-0.0255829412,
-0.0770765394,
-0.0357687324,
0.0437681824,
-0.0199881028,
0.0178634059,
-0.0144573627,
-0.0195396468,
-0.0147779007,
0.0290998854,
0.0494908057,
0.0523224585,
-0.0569292307,
0.0281590838,
0.0756521821,
0.0598372221,
-0.0272150412,
-0.0276877414,
-0.0211138315,
0.0191038977,
-0.0347489044,
0.0203573816,
0.0127143916,
0.050108403,
-0.0505121276,
0.0378595777,
0.1209133044,
0.0307839718,
-0.0374956094,
-0.0205485616,
-0.0540010557,
0.0568528213,
0.0280640814,
0.0087395916,
-0.0622949377,
-0.0317974053,
0.0072667315,
-0.0069418307,
0.014341047,
-0.0585765131,
-0.025203174,
-0.0980921164,
0.0325375646,
0.0134082902,
-0.0115213282,
0.0122563243,
-0.0443099625,
0.0225802083,
-0.031162262,
0.023599159,
0.0187278651,
0.0392153822,
0.0213482734,
0.0026155307,
-0.0041319667,
0.0073237508,
0.0380902141,
-0.0638328865,
0.0564622246,
0.0399854816,
0.0434550457,
-0.0079858666,
-0.0834159628,
-0.0009082503,
0.0351695158,
-0.0001392008,
-0.0154359853,
-0.001971141,
0.006382355,
0.0103836181,
-0.0030077726,
0.0333065912,
-0.0522037745,
-0.0367977656,
0.0244164374,
0.0892987326,
-0.0135180959,
-0.0111488793,
-0.0124148335,
0.0202312935,
-0.0179296955,
0.0827827901,
0.010301006,
0.0117164264,
-0.0437249839,
-0.0565410368,
-0.0522323549,
-0.0193683486,
-0.0228103101,
-0.0062637278,
0.0332008563,
0.0078856247,
-0.0386876985,
-0.0240242667,
0.0606030487,
0.004688303,
-0.006125927,
0.0240954682,
0.0187627468,
0.0229353439,
-0.0138361361,
0.0279707834,
-0.0549164563,
0.0373820513,
-0.0269843247,
-0.0088778073,
-0.0029238579,
-0.0273387227,
-0.0037725463,
0.0253824759,
-0.0547365099,
-0.0931856111,
-0.0354148149,
0.027674336,
0.0296553206,
0.0229005739,
0.0072226897,
-0.0317600146,
-0.0005104446,
0.0115688071,
-0.0171326417,
0.0087698391,
0.0141599579,
0.0197407678,
0.0064913784,
0.0450905748,
-0.0220988709,
-0.0086598974,
-0.0134827346,
0.0652404279,
-0.0380304754,
-0.0347530767,
0.0246657766,
0.0072484771,
-0.0161413755,
0.0167482626,
-0.0237016808,
-0.0023724856,
0.0234276168,
-0.0152038354,
-0.0215014704,
-0.0089597376,
-0.0127222892,
-0.0122655537,
-0.0632570684,
0.0463684276,
0.0317942277,
0.0039756387,
0.0337134302,
0.011695262,
0.0374222696,
0.0018905377,
-0.0109908208,
0.0077519258,
-0.0109366523,
-0.0035634625,
-0.0427908711,
-0.0319105908,
0.0462417267,
0.0052216128,
0.0501601957,
0.0166407749,
-0.0229407884,
-0.0000260872,
0.0164546445,
-0.0809566677,
-0.0966252834,
0.0398050062,
0.0378267542,
0.012169756,
0.0621468499,
0.0031674115,
-0.0498732068,
-0.0005665144,
-0.0098558357,
-0.0011982213,
0.0210849941,
-0.0112957861,
0.0446168967,
0.0215951037,
-0.0076520741,
-0.0454054028,
0.0640459135,
-0.066098772,
0.0320773609,
0.0057424642,
-0.0004422067,
-0.031059958,
-0.0572880618,
-0.0249684956,
0.0098134717,
-0.0120097781,
0.0102805756,
-0.0560814142,
-0.0216700118,
0.0159540605,
0.0283595081,
-0.016145587,
-0.0071906168,
0.006691671,
0.0521951914,
-0.0083905086,
-0.0275031235,
-0.0232717376,
0.0200195108,
-0.0434270836,
-0.0144576915,
-0.0297143925,
-6.028248374e-33,
-0.0358704589,
-0.0520962551,
0.0594175719,
-0.0051134313,
0.0122263078,
-0.0492588133,
-0.0502095185,
0.0184777733,
-0.0541492254,
0.0356186293,
-0.0186557509,
0.0255073495,
0.0107167112,
-0.0113637093,
0.0262517948,
-0.0341502577,
0.0096838819,
0.0063042603,
-0.0247724596,
-0.0055572577,
-0.011131037,
-0.0164313819,
0.0528164469,
-0.0671123341,
0.0410120413,
0.030574346,
-0.0075160153,
0.0279214159,
-0.0716157556,
0.0354116522,
0.0028826047,
0.019957386,
-0.0008263284,
-0.0347236469,
-0.024287425,
0.0053599416,
-0.0247604083,
-0.0244609509,
0.043665655,
-0.0167452171,
-0.0447473153,
-0.045266103,
0.0131359855,
0.0101629542,
-0.0200868864,
-0.0445785299,
0.0175613761,
-0.0312794186,
-0.0216595847,
0.0460591801,
-0.0165856928,
0.0154046174,
-0.0355311148,
-0.0256117545,
0.0013242395,
0.016353026,
0.0056551327,
0.0085476125,
-0.0527029112,
0.051411286,
0.0014081575,
-0.0032359357,
0.0831779018,
-0.0329294391,
0.0263435822,
0.0615125075,
0.0374687091,
0.0014335999,
-0.0679345876,
-0.0457818918,
-0.0111336382,
0.0943388492,
0.0938049704,
0.0686571822,
-0.0075222175,
0.0292570628,
-0.0414887965,
0.0445658118,
0.0143203046,
0.0438473113,
0.0182639994,
0.0390488133,
-0.0235342942,
-0.0027377028,
-0.0537167937,
0.0263319928,
-0.0389354378,
-0.0281053614,
0.0035334677,
-0.0090375682,
-0.0007019975,
-0.0056876591,
-0.0004641796,
-0.0557279214,
-0.0391280316,
0.003887671,
0.0354212895,
0.0087774601,
0.0144796791,
0.0008875632,
-0.0483577028,
0.0190074164,
-0.0142162153,
0.0245077498,
0.0300851539,
0.0293190964,
0.0078704618,
0.0136684161,
-0.0236511063,
0.0016527785,
-0.0624506846,
0.00743793,
0.0149811171,
-0.0381211117,
0.0143558048,
0.0098089594,
-0.0131075066,
0.0242014974,
-0.0316583775,
-0.017403625,
-0.022252515,
0.0409471951,
-0.0127914408,
-0.0029229363,
-0.0168312248,
-0.0215008166,
-0.046448376,
-0.0061609345,
0.0419199169,
0.0246067531,
-0.0195339564,
-0.0139336232,
2.649e-7,
0.0213253275,
0.0348958708,
0.0189165305,
0.0349551253,
0.0191921573,
0.0525396429,
-0.048169028,
-0.0003986613,
-0.00040405,
-0.0573255718,
-0.0000057172,
0.0633108392,
0.0641324371,
0.062872313,
-0.0609105267,
-0.0275186729,
-0.0397660024,
-0.015175174,
-0.0448896363,
0.0072410651,
0.0433179885,
0.0372843333,
0.0361769237,
0.0065523894,
-0.004604463,
-0.0219613202,
0.0421767123,
-0.0548219122,
0.0030682962,
0.0246521141,
0.0059431964,
-0.0528810397,
0.0281883739,
0.0292224493,
0.0055805845,
-0.0218436457,
-0.0286883805,
0.0455619097,
-0.0150674433,
-0.0415782034,
-0.0437638909,
-0.0467302278,
0.0204171035,
-0.0383602977,
0.0628550053,
-0.0244562495,
-0.0614870004,
-0.0023168905,
-0.0075918678,
-0.0224306714,
0.027310228,
-0.0072487113,
0.0074857948,
-0.0047181929,
-0.0079938881,
-0.0142792435,
-0.001661077,
-0.0552209318,
-0.0231681745,
-0.0292167515,
-0.0518246107,
-0.0499572195,
-0.022057008,
-0.0212519169,
0.000493054,
-0.0557620563,
-0.0102715297,
2.139424973e-34,
0.0342583098,
0.0051713595,
0.0181618147,
0.0793306381,
0.0661046356,
-0.002362048,
-0.0209114794,
-0.0001892811,
0.0358527526,
-0.0599139556,
-0.013153228
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12998v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12998v1 | Audience-specific Explanations for Machine Translation | 2023-09-22T17:00:45 | 2023-09-22T17:00:45 | Renhan Lou, Jan Niehues | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In machine translation, a common problem is that the translation of certain
words even if translated can cause incomprehension of the target language
audience due to different cultural backgrounds. A solution to solve this
problem is to add explanations for these words. In a first step, we therefore
need to identify these words or phrases. In this work we explore techniques to
extract example explanations from a parallel corpus. However, the sparsity of
sentences containing words that need to be explained makes building the
training dataset extremely difficult. In this work, we propose a semi-automatic
technique to extract these explanations from a large parallel corpus.
Experiments on English->German language pair show that our method is able to
extract sentence so that more than 10% of the sentences contain explanation,
while only 1.9% of the original sentences contain explanations. In addition,
experiments on English->French and English->Chinese language pairs also show
similar conclusions. This is therefore an essential first automatic step to
create a explanation dataset. Furthermore we show that the technique is robust
for all three language pairs. | [
0.0469696522,
-0.0002241017,
-0.0333238132,
0.0613647439,
-0.0343903527,
0.0455700345,
0.0545669384,
-0.0284266267,
-0.0568639114,
0.0042144433,
0.0320262089,
-0.0042462489,
0.0193087384,
-0.0324567258,
0.0129049793,
-0.0827459097,
0.0015618979,
0.0186476056,
-0.0068926942,
-0.0111821312,
0.0446727015,
0.0730240494,
0.008267127,
0.0393185616,
0.0384244733,
0.0176268909,
-0.0300815627,
0.0249618012,
0.0372200347,
0.020413734,
-0.0192430541,
-0.0240048002,
0.0662252903,
0.003305784,
0.0000019058,
-0.0182472952,
-0.0355216116,
0.0096778041,
-0.0311450623,
0.0076070013,
0.0115478775,
-0.0524802618,
0.0268466137,
0.01885508,
0.0138430065,
0.0191920307,
0.0352951363,
0.0240075793,
0.0541737676,
0.0663986057,
-0.0160281118,
-0.0449629948,
-0.0937392563,
-0.0153876366,
0.0051800148,
-0.0436183959,
-0.0234556068,
-0.0088003818,
-0.0357458666,
0.0086908136,
0.0089717368,
0.0041131251,
0.0373190232,
-0.0273973402,
-0.0289199706,
-0.0177338999,
-0.0006815035,
-0.0706454217,
-0.0048703579,
0.0690306053,
-0.014763345,
-0.0204833895,
-0.0025965439,
-0.0222478751,
-0.0151864532,
0.0526020229,
-0.0437964164,
0.0153779285,
-0.0152488509,
0.0182278249,
0.0479053147,
0.0090818973,
0.0259314459,
0.0037368943,
-0.0278079379,
0.0174903143,
-0.0119631775,
0.0001941249,
-0.038543392,
-0.0306521952,
-0.0236181896,
-0.018223105,
0.034935493,
0.0557431467,
-0.0095312335,
0.0486658812,
0.0296850968,
-0.0511154309,
0.0083200252,
-0.0644330457,
0.0174254756,
0.0324545763,
-0.0177620128,
0.0768497735,
-0.0077042109,
0.0587479882,
-0.00250838,
0.0063188197,
-0.0652377456,
-0.0512459204,
-0.0510101728,
0.0249914639,
-0.0332758538,
-0.0445577949,
-0.0628324822,
0.0166844279,
-0.0336214267,
0.0280490108,
-0.0050810603,
0.026970312,
0.0277868733,
-0.0067915432,
-0.0536018051,
-0.0392616019,
-0.0031500263,
0.0411673747,
-0.0821895897,
-0.0058862567,
-0.0038238643,
-0.0404040776,
-0.0264571551,
0.0312610753,
0.0082631009,
-0.0429672077,
-0.009210824,
0.0382351838,
-0.0026058643,
0.0025142655,
-0.0296670925,
-0.0525070056,
-0.0124341622,
-0.0508820713,
-0.020415986,
-0.0033974934,
0.0522722043,
0.0164074469,
0.0113825463,
-0.0186331421,
0.0116279637,
0.0057867691,
-0.0287048742,
0.0826998204,
-0.037110731,
0.0140773226,
0.0384229831,
0.0009016971,
-0.0076009394,
0.0674610436,
0.0198570061,
0.00996326,
0.081781961,
-0.0652046874,
-0.0053284811,
-0.0089961728,
0.0258085579,
0.0112474766,
-0.018642405,
0.0220802296,
-0.0344182104,
0.0195484087,
-0.00834582,
0.0182023589,
0.0169660375,
0.022429727,
0.0095556946,
0.0478314757,
0.0025893359,
0.0457683392,
0.0425281301,
0.0095284348,
-0.0208823029,
0.072592333,
-0.0056706527,
0.0468608849,
0.0313647538,
0.0123318871,
-0.0000966993,
0.0171599537,
-0.029519191,
-0.0772518367,
-0.0243507903,
-0.0089871231,
0.0330469571,
0.0275882017,
0.0739766061,
0.0230109021,
-0.0180803351,
0.0397819504,
0.0275066476,
-0.0595564395,
-0.0066826208,
-0.0226392504,
0.0130329533,
0.0870949253,
0.0028348127,
-0.0206336305,
0.0176746286,
-0.0134730898,
0.0305782277,
0.027050525,
0.0527430288,
-0.0062289815,
0.0290765557,
-0.0600817502,
-0.0280633364,
-0.0045588776,
-0.0054366295,
0.0171846859,
0.0082138767,
-0.0225482453,
0.0481175482,
-0.0313929915,
-0.0574368872,
0.0324665383,
-0.0457712337,
-0.0250252783,
0.0640816912,
0.0158219021,
0.0404438488,
0.0694690421,
0.0171501879,
-0.0175569225,
0.0399725065,
-0.0193611123,
0.0017454516,
0.0783782974,
-0.0120840361,
-0.0539323874,
-0.0003692682,
-0.0409505516,
-0.0098839626,
0.0353099182,
-0.0533439219,
-0.0574274026,
-0.0006745852,
-0.0313952602,
0.0414887741,
-0.0621100366,
0.0160223208,
0.0000336143,
0.0148260472,
-0.0215258673,
0.0265718307,
0.0159887914,
0.032940004,
-0.006383772,
-0.024790138,
0.0214809719,
-0.0249537956,
0.0205698237,
0.0001105074,
-0.0019965307,
-0.0018676126,
0.033747673,
-0.0299808867,
-0.0096799135,
0.0237910189,
-0.0381051823,
0.0111567341,
-0.0454635359,
0.0262144189,
0.0599575415,
0.0430256575,
0.0187452547,
-0.0231232997,
-0.0195539668,
0.0344844982,
-0.0197610818,
0.0053116987,
0.0608090684,
0.0001550504,
-0.0367178582,
-0.0233526882,
-0.0054583848,
-0.01112579,
0.0423482321,
0.0538485311,
0.0255149174,
-0.0735463649,
0.0065998696,
-0.0078635281,
-0.0455643572,
-0.0461421385,
-0.0845101774,
0.0016189588,
-0.017011933,
-0.0358289517,
0.0150787849,
0.0214486942,
0.0856513232,
0.0069390568,
0.070488289,
-0.0037538873,
-0.0197762232,
-0.0775306597,
-0.0188956652,
-0.0102360146,
-0.0696440861,
0.0211863201,
0.0537392423,
0.0140613904,
-0.0070036193,
-0.0581968985,
-0.0134983175,
0.0193917677,
0.0155764343,
-0.0295530185,
-0.0166983232,
0.0009736686,
0.061378587,
-0.0069200583,
-0.0306094233,
0.0869527534,
-0.0180548429,
0.0037301343,
-0.0435247831,
-0.0467772149,
-0.0451606177,
0.087481007,
-0.0424454398,
0.0324096605,
-0.0279591307,
-0.013245929,
0.0310863201,
-0.0117643932,
0.0426890217,
0.0143581321,
0.0124780601,
-0.0435237736,
-0.0369545259,
-0.0124519309,
0.0107428189,
-0.0152522419,
-0.0827577189,
-0.0166562088,
-0.0129470322,
0.0673504397,
-0.0393241495,
-0.0265650805,
-0.000436941,
0.017443914,
0.016743971,
0.0025918195,
0.0335512199,
-0.0132709062,
-0.0084902747,
-0.0051316065,
0.0092761442,
-0.0018219528,
-0.0742721036,
0.0546821915,
0.0038826277,
0.0236557256,
-0.0509070903,
-0.0202679597,
-0.052194044,
-0.0082169781,
-0.0500388071,
-0.0070216279,
-0.014789436,
0.0462711081,
-0.0534004457,
0.0355218388,
0.114581205,
0.0297118854,
-0.0451727584,
0.0034946601,
-0.0319070183,
-0.0199585967,
0.017056549,
0.0058907843,
-0.0962294564,
-0.0339042805,
-0.0148852319,
0.0321664698,
0.0197219532,
0.0433806591,
-0.0403474122,
-0.0642427504,
0.0346968435,
0.0230978262,
-0.0575748235,
-0.0393170156,
-0.0359251834,
-0.0314683877,
-0.0144419558,
0.0013489035,
-0.0042239213,
0.0460793115,
-0.0123112984,
0.009626261,
-0.0042064791,
-0.0637343749,
0.0179025307,
-0.0139544597,
0.0008973141,
0.0061294637,
0.0657870546,
0.0004062039,
-0.0302901156,
0.0048021716,
-0.0602933504,
0.0174724795,
-0.0093450211,
0.0635978356,
0.0190678798,
-0.0124993296,
0.0038709485,
0.038722571,
-0.0442962945,
-0.0027390008,
0.0550799221,
0.0320060477,
-0.0293165185,
0.0028140037,
0.0267918892,
-0.0123239253,
0.0269117821,
0.0876477137,
0.039826002,
-0.022107942,
0.0099723944,
-0.0310557187,
-0.0324113108,
-0.0718467981,
0.0421234295,
-0.0051723476,
-0.0526997074,
-0.0556035228,
-0.0268220231,
-0.032527823,
0.020976577,
0.0324777141,
0.0418143831,
0.005432128,
0.0025172522,
0.0099969888,
-0.0432006083,
0.0318620615,
0.0444624797,
0.0064559849,
0.0030119787,
-0.0327889435,
-0.0066115488,
-0.063405551,
0.0018758551,
0.0119745834,
-0.0399030522,
-0.0660945401,
-0.0093024494,
0.0016879678,
0.0199298393,
0.0879538655,
-0.0040035322,
-0.0539929718,
-0.0412338376,
-0.0146884164,
-0.0396931879,
-0.0625932068,
0.0294810552,
0.008497294,
-0.001302714,
0.0509104133,
0.0026865422,
0.0021082228,
-0.027707044,
0.0113806352,
-0.0665641725,
-0.0231561232,
0.0326236151,
0.0220876504,
0.0310861953,
-0.0355321243,
-0.0425658561,
-0.0398495384,
0.0403159559,
-0.029771626,
-0.0379584916,
-0.0227345321,
-0.0020829623,
0.0011829103,
-0.0718929321,
0.0183044132,
-0.0419750623,
-0.0497481786,
-0.0419462994,
-0.0225269198,
0.0513925813,
-0.0125694759,
0.0202443339,
-0.0269253645,
0.036069259,
0.0006030151,
0.0236558747,
0.0035512242,
0.0304844994,
0.010261911,
0.0851905867,
-0.004939903,
0.0414100252,
0.0233146921,
-0.0239213016,
-0.0250882562,
-0.0008582516,
0.0139801502,
0.0018508728,
0.0387682617,
-0.0351749808,
0.0926755592,
0.0069378861,
-0.0261707697,
0.0032571012,
0.1076545343,
0.017729776,
-0.0238574184,
-0.0123880776,
0.0097358935,
-0.0280798823,
0.0074462658,
0.0618105233,
-0.018391775,
-0.0159112997,
0.0330999084,
-0.0335637964,
-0.0075077424,
0.0153781148,
0.026401246,
0.026337672,
0.0040742722,
-0.0135139264,
-0.0136355404,
-0.0601417422,
-0.0307196882,
0.0054072933,
-0.0009346919,
-0.0172433462,
0.0147819631,
0.0807009339,
-0.041018568,
-0.0154335275,
-0.0854466558,
0.0524869598,
-0.068892926,
0.0185525361,
-0.015186891,
-6.034405393e-33,
-0.0075741825,
-0.0514186919,
-0.0304804221,
-0.01058318,
0.0420332439,
-0.0046470272,
-0.0445750281,
-0.0686111003,
-0.0160573404,
0.0664255694,
0.019012263,
0.0275742598,
0.0217336137,
0.0194927417,
-0.0030501909,
-0.0193823613,
0.0405444577,
0.0265067518,
-0.0121159377,
0.0430239402,
0.0912553892,
0.0091020623,
0.0805165842,
-0.075885348,
0.0820521563,
-0.0244462788,
-0.0293530282,
0.0202284884,
0.0053838487,
0.0617710724,
0.019245822,
0.0434685312,
0.0116952518,
-0.039892517,
0.0119851138,
0.0426022224,
-0.1040147915,
0.0099869212,
0.0668848902,
0.0563951321,
-0.0411291085,
-0.0452673174,
0.0073947986,
-0.051205188,
0.01279674,
-0.0179745108,
0.0473510884,
-0.0273687243,
-0.0050897356,
0.0307206865,
0.0000322039,
0.0295999926,
-0.0751194805,
-0.0247100424,
0.0443747826,
0.0506563298,
-0.0108377207,
-0.0064206133,
-0.0161473397,
0.0136140175,
0.006407443,
0.0178408436,
0.0462388806,
-0.0104790479,
0.0055700606,
0.0036462205,
0.0067902538,
0.002597597,
-0.0135144843,
-0.0020245933,
-0.0546225458,
0.025892416,
0.0707786158,
0.041423358,
0.0474124551,
-0.0245776679,
-0.0605088547,
0.0353949293,
-0.0040381616,
0.0062662619,
0.0473694801,
-0.0202676691,
-0.0584152639,
-0.0177665707,
-0.002077702,
-0.0200864542,
-0.01239888,
-0.0322194993,
-0.0178803969,
-0.0088562267,
-0.0571556985,
-0.0137897739,
0.0159622598,
-0.0347194746,
0.0464391261,
0.0027777716,
-0.0250504836,
-0.046506349,
0.0053086216,
-0.0073679499,
0.0005326181,
-0.0069092941,
-0.0236331802,
0.0341267884,
0.0320309661,
-0.0010700043,
0.0520371534,
0.0025324402,
-0.003194547,
-0.0023707179,
-0.0742038935,
-0.0148250125,
-0.0869357213,
0.0142990984,
-0.0048940326,
0.0381182432,
-0.060111016,
0.0270784162,
0.0374653749,
-0.0154541098,
-0.0086158579,
-0.0152298408,
-0.0270546898,
0.0067519564,
-0.0417203195,
-0.0071107284,
0.0225045085,
-0.021785045,
0.0650163218,
-0.0320440084,
-0.0145001318,
0.0087610902,
2.459e-7,
0.0474349633,
0.0222549774,
0.0379575603,
0.0171696413,
0.0036898449,
0.0146264574,
-0.0063215848,
-0.0250635594,
-0.0112257982,
0.0268517043,
0.0499660261,
0.0016354849,
0.0891297683,
0.0200220495,
-0.0742198974,
-0.0340148807,
-0.0384034812,
-0.0124644963,
-0.0388310365,
0.0610490218,
0.0650559813,
0.0514005348,
0.0358164683,
0.0141278692,
-0.0298261642,
-0.0271193534,
0.030202413,
-0.033409372,
-0.0209337231,
-0.0055029048,
0.0334715135,
0.0176660419,
-0.0271083675,
-0.0016343886,
-0.0411336422,
0.009887944,
-0.0148938196,
0.0747941062,
-0.0036566535,
-0.0068333084,
0.0014385007,
-0.0227630194,
0.0108951721,
-0.0610005073,
0.0475027673,
-0.0112906238,
-0.0314416438,
0.0082492298,
-0.0217544977,
-0.0098257437,
-0.00011801,
-0.0083029671,
-0.0005108616,
0.0292320941,
0.0131147634,
-0.0445695631,
0.0031181208,
-0.0815498158,
-0.0341193713,
0.0098766694,
-0.015260282,
0.0340683497,
0.0177618414,
0.0022890212,
0.0236279219,
-0.0246891901,
-0.0002561753,
1.912839942e-34,
0.0168480296,
0.0255279168,
-0.0321619697,
-0.005127687,
0.0448205024,
-0.0051745605,
-0.0246686377,
0.0072733387,
0.0501025282,
0.0042194715,
-0.0279773939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12960v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12960v3 | Nested Event Extraction upon Pivot Element Recogniton | 2023-09-22T15:58:06 | 2024-04-07T14:52:55 | Weicheng Ren, Zixuan Li, Xiaolong Jin, Long Bai, Miao Su, Yantao Liu, Saiping Guan, Jiafeng Guo, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Nested Event Extraction (NEE) aims to extract complex event structures where
an event contains other events as its arguments recursively. Nested events
involve a kind of Pivot Elements (PEs) that simultaneously act as arguments of
outer-nest events and as triggers of inner-nest events, and thus connect them
into nested structures. This special characteristic of PEs brings challenges to
existing NEE methods, as they cannot well cope with the dual identities of PEs.
Therefore, this paper proposes a new model, called PerNee, which extracts
nested events mainly based on recognizing PEs. Specifically, PerNee first
recognizes the triggers of both inner-nest and outer-nest events and further
recognizes the PEs via classifying the relation type between trigger pairs. The
model uses prompt learning to incorporate information from both event types and
argument roles for better trigger and argument representations to improve NEE
performance. Since existing NEE datasets (e.g., Genia11) are limited to
specific domains and contain a narrow range of event types with nested
structures, we systematically categorize nested events in the generic domain
and construct a new NEE dataset, called ACE2005-Nest. Experimental results
demonstrate that PerNee consistently achieves state-of-the-art performance on
ACE2005-Nest, Genia11, and Genia13. The ACE2005-Nest dataset and the code of
the PerNee model are available at https://github.com/waysonren/PerNee. | [
-0.006894879,
-0.001330709,
-0.0074772928,
0.0717378259,
-0.0452278219,
0.0276938677,
-0.0136156278,
0.0158031508,
0.0406371839,
-0.0582032837,
-0.0106485952,
0.0230116118,
-0.0196203981,
0.0821374133,
-0.0584925972,
-0.0529599823,
0.0510297939,
0.0016878177,
0.0105603663,
0.0607539266,
-0.0169679001,
0.0176257342,
-0.0527076833,
0.0379961766,
0.0074394201,
-0.015557209,
-0.0169353522,
0.0032041143,
0.0423098914,
-0.0179126319,
0.0230300464,
0.0116396137,
0.0238509327,
0.0253775306,
0.0000018541,
-0.0232671499,
-0.0195386205,
-0.0310051478,
-0.012534664,
0.004767437,
-0.0254263543,
-0.0440782644,
-0.0054891706,
-0.0195026677,
-0.0113048935,
-0.0671027675,
0.0013218501,
0.0740999356,
-0.006204885,
0.0580238029,
-0.0344607569,
-0.0510575175,
0.0612821728,
-0.0044536004,
-0.0442967638,
-0.0573063381,
0.0169215966,
-0.0653020293,
-0.0160809122,
-0.0325501598,
0.0261913873,
-0.0438456833,
0.0021003317,
-0.0198835507,
-0.0178271364,
0.0413578674,
-0.0445111208,
0.0041034324,
-0.0212720577,
0.0465350524,
-0.0563712195,
0.0136066452,
0.0482410789,
-0.0406665243,
-0.0084563782,
-0.0327140428,
-0.0495438501,
0.0012297889,
-0.0431901105,
0.0147179309,
0.0503030419,
0.0478135347,
-0.0239372384,
-0.0151990438,
-0.0046424125,
0.040168196,
0.0172268674,
0.0269130804,
-0.0387565047,
-0.003753406,
0.0738613382,
-0.0331381075,
0.0323368311,
0.0152184283,
-0.0267135184,
0.0046082451,
-0.0223065726,
0.0542470142,
-0.0139317755,
-0.0410544798,
0.0052595367,
0.0336509794,
-0.0097249858,
0.0369036607,
-0.0110768732,
0.0205089469,
-0.0217873883,
0.0043340223,
-0.0012138544,
0.0265477169,
-0.0450335406,
0.0318916813,
-0.0137399556,
0.0222154502,
-0.0793598667,
-0.0106008863,
-0.0026075745,
0.0133350072,
0.005173224,
0.004441855,
-0.0566166155,
-0.01174137,
-0.0242813434,
-0.0124698421,
-0.0005707943,
0.0466529243,
-0.0197714623,
0.0250356141,
0.0061044767,
-0.0488776527,
-0.0196143072,
0.0208968353,
0.0465323292,
-0.0293068234,
-0.034856189,
0.0271665975,
-0.0040023173,
-0.0212653372,
-0.0981271267,
-0.0484404527,
0.0030470914,
0.0136957495,
-0.0042377175,
-0.0217941962,
0.0637436807,
-0.0644404143,
-0.0291356947,
-0.0112347351,
0.018969886,
-0.0110792089,
-0.0337666385,
0.0287113059,
-0.0093140453,
-0.0051843962,
-0.0314844884,
-0.0042490219,
0.0135786571,
0.0561841466,
0.0356520638,
0.0484697036,
0.0487778634,
0.0095691951,
-0.0082801078,
0.0091309547,
0.0103574637,
-0.0235679112,
0.0538488217,
0.0185218938,
-0.0228957962,
-0.0177581944,
0.0481808633,
-0.0502365604,
0.0115325367,
-0.0205143522,
0.0178366024,
0.0159443337,
-0.0344224349,
0.0019009495,
0.0168928746,
-0.0533165298,
-0.0117621562,
0.0557343774,
0.001919688,
-0.0306544453,
-0.0320754237,
-0.0442879312,
-0.0365340412,
-0.0030056015,
-0.0149821118,
-0.0315454975,
0.0219842568,
-0.0101272305,
-0.0644178241,
-0.0182856694,
0.0531221814,
0.0135966986,
-0.0317611247,
0.0526069663,
0.0189686958,
-0.0153695308,
-0.0079022283,
-0.0272083879,
0.0155127849,
0.0002363816,
0.0102540059,
-0.0782523155,
-0.0950674191,
0.0052638734,
-0.0381448828,
0.0006636074,
0.0058508124,
-0.0399326943,
0.0528493896,
0.0043270621,
-0.0261182394,
-0.0016866089,
0.0142294774,
0.0074671181,
-0.0254120138,
-0.0253214221,
0.0086910576,
0.0499910116,
0.0144047951,
0.0215573255,
-0.0129829757,
-0.0363248475,
0.0183010362,
0.0125196856,
0.0418217592,
0.0110550253,
0.0142578194,
0.0027567716,
0.0529272333,
-0.0330829732,
-0.0152391065,
0.0374282263,
-0.0030804623,
-0.0693534538,
0.0355330259,
0.0106504932,
-0.0357241221,
-0.01064217,
-0.0679819211,
-0.0240085982,
-0.0074349255,
0.0412492193,
-0.0221270714,
0.0071735568,
0.0222765915,
0.00432515,
-0.0202582479,
-0.0323316492,
0.0838119611,
0.0024020516,
-0.0316834375,
-0.0249754712,
-0.039637357,
0.0344290026,
-0.0216685012,
0.0210637115,
0.0215658136,
-0.0375600345,
-0.0449542515,
0.0147687374,
-0.0235548057,
-0.0721118897,
0.0086393254,
-0.023255229,
0.0499368496,
0.0089635979,
0.068469055,
0.0215290263,
0.0263072886,
-0.0206512399,
-0.0053047715,
-0.0280657578,
-0.0533135198,
-0.0399088599,
-0.0018627531,
0.0431266502,
0.025899319,
-0.0335397646,
-0.0342987776,
-0.0063299043,
-0.0733138248,
0.0343528725,
0.0253339261,
-0.0165907741,
-0.0006679688,
0.0113581559,
0.0260007363,
0.0050109415,
-0.0188726392,
0.0113304025,
-0.0122239906,
0.0012981219,
0.0440183245,
0.0352649428,
-0.0174351167,
0.0622219853,
-0.0073048575,
-0.0389553607,
-0.0126123019,
0.0208338946,
-0.0508408882,
0.016389491,
0.0157462414,
0.037678197,
0.0566362105,
0.0328343436,
0.0108205099,
0.024617061,
-0.0349007137,
-0.0490432605,
-0.0116484296,
0.0058375895,
-0.0196476206,
-0.0607804619,
-0.0117048854,
0.0482471623,
-0.0454559959,
0.007524942,
0.0612663738,
0.0202308893,
-0.0218113419,
-0.0216634851,
-0.0006554525,
-0.0838534012,
0.1039085686,
-0.016865626,
0.0150828958,
0.0362788178,
-0.0678214878,
-0.0200972185,
-0.0231505595,
0.0141673926,
-0.0331293009,
0.0350382328,
-0.0139296595,
0.013998488,
-0.0367927328,
-0.0321722068,
-0.023474142,
-0.0013095841,
0.0249540787,
0.0111527918,
-0.0441755131,
0.0374528505,
-0.0216646977,
0.0303238686,
-0.0224671457,
0.0409042165,
0.0017515422,
-0.0049064676,
-0.0208722465,
0.1110675409,
0.0338736065,
-0.0329831168,
-0.0228103381,
0.0266711842,
-0.0128575144,
0.0751424953,
0.0288869217,
0.0222282074,
-0.0368373692,
0.0198144894,
0.0035614537,
-0.0221342109,
0.0262917243,
-0.029198546,
-0.010632867,
-0.1007053182,
0.0307222232,
0.0336390436,
0.0318932608,
-0.0382728204,
0.0030000834,
0.014584519,
-0.0032342726,
-0.0103577618,
0.0066399425,
-0.0622462742,
-0.0082986131,
-0.0134864934,
-0.0162925012,
-0.0000720216,
-0.0338191055,
0.0331782475,
-0.0890678465,
0.0675118491,
0.0011853705,
-0.0271583181,
-0.1354402751,
-0.0464409515,
0.037259914,
-0.0065389443,
-0.0501274914,
0.0314837024,
0.0124950642,
-0.0343758911,
-0.0013061139,
-0.0708553046,
-0.0642611161,
0.0278243329,
-0.0451839715,
-0.0272293035,
-0.0097586215,
0.0237813126,
0.0065026772,
0.0103735207,
0.0222922619,
-0.0361072235,
-0.0210608523,
-0.0133538451,
0.0177317206,
-0.0024460559,
0.0128479833,
-0.0212913398,
0.0480898321,
-0.0373427682,
-0.0596195906,
0.000766667,
0.1078447402,
-0.0056106532,
-0.009258328,
-0.0180647336,
-0.0416641273,
0.0364278294,
0.0259960461,
0.0204477012,
0.051905062,
0.0001499322,
0.0302005596,
0.0110927979,
-0.0375644825,
0.0008481868,
0.028510103,
-0.0242457613,
-0.0569336824,
-0.0741407871,
-0.0274516512,
0.0161710195,
0.0446249917,
-0.0563091151,
-0.0112572536,
0.0217445828,
0.0046463413,
-0.050319463,
0.0344976299,
-0.0287787411,
0.0167179964,
0.0296474583,
0.0317872688,
0.026701387,
0.0828920007,
-0.0483431444,
0.0477803834,
-0.0161840376,
-0.0141700571,
-0.0447097793,
-0.0249108374,
0.0113801481,
0.0244167335,
0.0055301441,
0.0160283372,
-0.0001938995,
0.0162917022,
-0.0201296899,
-0.0600494705,
0.027654428,
-0.0048745871,
-0.0262806956,
0.0286846478,
-0.0328032896,
0.0208824743,
-0.0261121616,
0.0489317812,
-0.0353558883,
-0.0143445516,
0.0209226049,
-0.0024844646,
0.0939834192,
0.0043486706,
-0.0524461828,
-0.0594180077,
0.0303755272,
-0.0307727605,
-0.0173420571,
-0.0352548249,
0.0619278587,
-0.0236801114,
-0.0048538763,
0.0065764422,
-0.0028331343,
-0.0268887095,
-0.0125595573,
-0.0401494801,
-0.0047590202,
0.0647291541,
0.0158252176,
-0.0109538101,
0.0112776645,
-0.0420861095,
0.0091626802,
0.0164211337,
0.0192932226,
-0.0419308543,
-0.0081422003,
0.0490230471,
0.0184495933,
-0.0408596806,
-0.0171720739,
-0.0136883045,
0.0914844051,
0.0096147787,
-0.074071154,
0.0803168416,
-0.0293674488,
0.0176709779,
0.0267114677,
0.0025945343,
0.0110813752,
0.0591033995,
0.0216309354,
-0.0127639687,
0.0247973725,
-0.0007643119,
-0.019701032,
0.0052035744,
0.0707149282,
-0.0332583152,
0.0683789477,
0.0076954872,
-0.0045979298,
-0.0288517363,
-0.0270566344,
0.0318957604,
0.0547588319,
-0.003681849,
-0.0122064957,
-0.0783730596,
0.0312199295,
0.013326711,
-0.0030526326,
-0.0015474986,
0.005064019,
0.0165685751,
0.0399754383,
0.0580550954,
-0.042220287,
-0.0168907288,
0.0304248147,
-0.0080465069,
-0.0306097474,
-0.0364036448,
-5.80192714e-33,
-0.0241635237,
-0.0044888873,
0.0017246614,
0.0894940421,
-0.023047775,
0.0063281376,
-0.0300270692,
-0.0362640694,
0.0400328338,
-0.0106331427,
0.0092336992,
0.0001995524,
0.0296482649,
-0.0335514806,
0.0159734916,
-0.0307461098,
0.0116960742,
-0.0166437067,
-0.0254795719,
0.039141845,
0.0575474426,
0.0363409147,
0.0212526172,
-0.1286062896,
0.0015222048,
0.0063205962,
0.0073324298,
0.000213816,
0.0672056004,
0.053452231,
0.0079081589,
-0.0226032231,
0.0512981452,
-0.035804294,
0.0200691931,
-0.0012372119,
-0.0645025522,
-0.012612287,
0.0129346624,
-0.0120931938,
-0.0227276217,
-0.0450522155,
0.024848599,
0.0456079543,
0.0583360121,
-0.0810755044,
-0.0020804964,
-0.0123057952,
-0.012837681,
-0.0547071062,
-0.0811891183,
0.0745880678,
-0.0100756893,
0.0023650937,
0.0023349118,
0.0103687989,
0.0542664267,
0.0122146662,
-0.0006085828,
0.0019496281,
-0.0327388421,
0.0164975487,
0.005996089,
0.0019646904,
-0.0163746718,
0.0483384728,
0.0114232861,
0.0162483398,
-0.0221958235,
0.0530301817,
-0.0384633206,
0.1209641099,
-0.0153435292,
0.0254124049,
0.0208385754,
0.0151938945,
-0.108471632,
0.0376877524,
0.0648140237,
0.0153237004,
-0.0433641784,
0.0322443359,
-0.0389544703,
0.0107544921,
0.0127409426,
-0.0004390891,
-0.024096325,
0.0121185277,
0.0154011901,
0.0436566696,
0.0385224298,
0.0690250993,
0.0096234269,
0.0131151387,
0.0193325281,
0.013240817,
0.0101862075,
0.0331402309,
-0.0139227509,
0.0191009101,
0.0246921759,
-0.078519173,
0.0101621887,
-0.0096922368,
0.0763531178,
0.0058546979,
0.027640447,
0.0217236876,
-0.0267293323,
0.0073232092,
-0.0006853898,
-0.0365005322,
-0.0216627065,
-0.0040411633,
0.0219484586,
0.0061425036,
-0.0109361848,
0.0581532829,
0.0200997274,
0.057257358,
-0.0023848144,
0.0049516023,
-0.0177992675,
0.0645193979,
0.0210251659,
-0.0452215858,
-0.014819501,
0.0163599253,
0.0126396576,
0.0155288605,
-0.0029587622,
-0.0105571374,
2.608e-7,
0.0294758026,
0.0145399394,
0.0407275259,
0.0139336661,
0.018932119,
0.028426623,
0.0026335423,
0.0398564488,
0.006681039,
0.0562563203,
0.0082151257,
-0.0499546155,
0.0351613425,
0.0479867384,
-0.0666239187,
-0.0570196472,
-0.0278817415,
-0.0127608925,
-0.0811120793,
-0.0131671019,
0.1075708717,
0.0549792051,
0.0425388888,
0.0010944468,
0.0116576264,
-0.0361262262,
0.0336341262,
0.0186858121,
-0.0349563137,
0.0323160999,
-0.0347767808,
0.0490828864,
-0.0348541401,
0.0311740208,
-0.0199704599,
0.0671355501,
-0.0070971735,
0.0841126293,
-0.016051732,
0.0254120566,
0.020566836,
-0.0295916814,
-0.0020383459,
-0.0347780772,
0.0584089085,
-0.0650627017,
-0.0090765134,
-0.016226707,
-0.0353677385,
0.0481033847,
-0.0635640845,
0.0151702929,
-0.0336145125,
0.0662739426,
-0.0105195139,
-0.0041387905,
-0.0231436752,
-0.0915299654,
0.0029385271,
0.046876736,
0.0033989274,
0.0117663005,
0.0205760393,
-0.0406804234,
-0.0073940237,
-0.0078131547,
-0.0080767507,
2.498208808e-34,
-0.0277956203,
-0.0043920814,
-0.0398590043,
0.0457667112,
0.0339884274,
-0.0399357341,
-0.0109765679,
0.0361599214,
0.0029194404,
-0.0041679549,
0.0168784037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12940v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12940v1 | Self-Explanation Prompting Improves Dialogue Understanding in Large Language Models | 2023-09-22T15:41:34 | 2023-09-22T15:41:34 | Haoyu Gao, Ting-En Lin, Hangyu Li, Min Yang, Yuchuan Wu, Wentao Ma, Yongbin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Task-oriented dialogue (TOD) systems facilitate users in executing various
activities via multi-turn dialogues, but Large Language Models (LLMs) often
struggle to comprehend these intricate contexts. In this study, we propose a
novel "Self-Explanation" prompting strategy to enhance the comprehension
abilities of LLMs in multi-turn dialogues. This task-agnostic approach requires
the model to analyze each dialogue utterance before task execution, thereby
improving performance across various dialogue-centric tasks. Experimental
results from six benchmark datasets confirm that our method consistently
outperforms other zero-shot prompts and matches or exceeds the efficacy of
few-shot prompts, demonstrating its potential as a powerful tool in enhancing
LLMs' comprehension in complex dialogue tasks. | [
0.0251315348,
-0.0096837012,
-0.0138726067,
0.0589093715,
-0.011835767,
0.0199905969,
0.0329378843,
-0.0274545886,
0.0192329846,
-0.0326990746,
-0.0394754224,
-0.020864673,
-0.0093466314,
0.0273580439,
0.0106493803,
-0.0458064675,
0.0497422703,
-0.0737795755,
0.0233856048,
-0.0205771532,
-0.0141488044,
0.0015295724,
-0.0419094972,
0.0520313568,
0.0352691188,
-0.0496679321,
-0.0621201769,
0.0052115573,
-0.0446145274,
-0.0400635451,
-0.0346171483,
0.0571778826,
0.0277077965,
0.0389633738,
0.0000020088,
-0.047246404,
0.0164978541,
-0.0410050638,
-0.1006284878,
0.0372915976,
-0.0089357942,
0.0322317183,
0.0169932339,
0.0180136021,
-0.0085065216,
-0.0051263217,
0.0288424138,
0.0818363801,
0.0773242489,
0.0423661694,
0.0082630226,
-0.0059876121,
-0.0205494706,
-0.0039111711,
0.0248092096,
-0.0698273033,
-0.0035064451,
0.0198341738,
-0.0022430255,
0.0503551885,
-0.0195820723,
0.0266154464,
0.0241999645,
-0.0448497906,
-0.0215543732,
0.0376355983,
0.015640283,
-0.0292651001,
-0.0335324034,
0.0869100168,
0.0303828456,
0.0128741199,
0.006920916,
-0.0019226957,
0.017383134,
-0.0074673477,
-0.074166283,
-0.0143928789,
0.0000393266,
-0.0181833599,
-0.0236083474,
0.0044128634,
0.0131807597,
0.0202922598,
-0.0364285782,
0.0663839504,
-0.0177819543,
-0.020255845,
-0.0331552625,
-0.022015417,
0.0199136306,
-0.0727644265,
0.0002127066,
0.0598539263,
-0.1195285469,
0.0239585526,
0.0060237376,
0.0137742395,
0.0154693974,
0.010777507,
0.0358530879,
0.0476536453,
-0.0481157452,
0.0728996694,
-0.0046451557,
0.0712539181,
0.0015596355,
-0.0014304237,
-0.0160316601,
-0.0050409134,
-0.0334489569,
-0.0101516815,
-0.0568351559,
0.0024298856,
-0.0416521095,
-0.013476667,
-0.0050877356,
0.0759783909,
0.0121356007,
0.0304239206,
0.0102000935,
0.0120983133,
-0.0182977021,
-0.0220817532,
-0.0358647965,
0.0502991043,
-0.0363865495,
0.0026890801,
0.0392003879,
-0.0577559881,
-0.0477281883,
0.0108370315,
0.0096220151,
-0.0109640369,
-0.0343289711,
0.0553746521,
0.0003979297,
-0.0255000032,
-0.0029437733,
-0.0181525759,
-0.0288175438,
-0.0578298643,
-0.0350540653,
-0.01337309,
0.0347281992,
0.011342058,
-0.0142509127,
0.0176686458,
0.0182953775,
0.0111616356,
-0.0237896312,
0.065589495,
-0.0209363699,
0.0606440678,
0.0230929069,
0.0196226314,
-0.0468735956,
0.0566654578,
0.0120111099,
-0.0110784341,
0.02828479,
-0.0498273447,
0.0296439622,
0.0244672429,
-0.0042047268,
-0.0061182361,
0.0259367414,
0.0260240678,
-0.0207899753,
0.0414092802,
0.0473369397,
0.0346568376,
-0.0337041952,
0.0084388312,
0.064640522,
0.0648278296,
-0.0152755994,
-0.0137461238,
0.0267104302,
0.0398293808,
-0.0038284909,
0.0291081518,
-0.0596069023,
0.0446271524,
0.0031543141,
0.0131682605,
0.053855706,
-0.0060730451,
-0.0457113087,
-0.0374064334,
0.0078233974,
0.0203952137,
0.0030709226,
0.0398352779,
0.0552080497,
0.0173019301,
-0.0490886718,
0.0382759571,
0.0100169405,
-0.0415940024,
-0.0286499001,
-0.0688684657,
0.0522246622,
0.0912246853,
0.0367556289,
-0.0000834359,
-0.0566855222,
-0.0404544473,
0.0448889248,
0.0243869554,
0.0278028287,
-0.0162955169,
0.0385759696,
-0.0363780521,
-0.0339041725,
-0.0177452322,
0.00184899,
0.0080040693,
-0.0213373769,
-0.0369270779,
0.0098189646,
-0.0346430391,
-0.0035823309,
-0.0040442152,
-0.0058156759,
-0.0332196169,
0.0221256651,
0.018399762,
0.0021691499,
0.04043632,
0.0076227593,
-0.0148358615,
0.0260780547,
-0.0061412305,
0.0025798806,
0.0375089496,
-0.0862987041,
-0.0620262325,
0.0173215773,
0.0325716138,
-0.0524349101,
-0.0176946446,
-0.0181972142,
-0.0668360218,
-0.0023554072,
-0.018067643,
0.0198249165,
-0.041302789,
0.0283796936,
0.0210406929,
0.0031454673,
-0.0158043616,
0.0300120208,
0.0064468593,
0.0285672266,
0.057396248,
0.0138273193,
0.0137377447,
-0.0518051051,
0.0104739582,
0.006776006,
-0.0270316135,
-0.0299914386,
-0.0088144075,
0.001879944,
-0.0628466308,
-0.0084699839,
-0.1074954271,
-0.0176246334,
-0.0329747088,
0.0052030617,
0.0224322304,
0.027367631,
-0.0227747448,
-0.047760345,
-0.0184239633,
0.0013683394,
0.0299537089,
0.0234078988,
0.0270618089,
0.0077985823,
-0.0256705191,
-0.0185463075,
0.0288901702,
0.0001758166,
0.0231669508,
-0.0020390772,
0.0065821144,
-0.0669804141,
0.0181253795,
-0.0003014676,
0.0017710618,
-0.0368390568,
-0.0253664739,
0.0279244911,
0.0016391156,
0.0716338158,
0.0618155226,
0.0023733974,
0.0227232128,
0.0299360473,
-0.0527593829,
-0.076068975,
0.0327338427,
-0.0007782516,
-0.0214267634,
-0.0228610635,
-0.0175576117,
-0.0019888356,
0.0754082277,
0.0014568714,
0.0362738743,
-0.0386790782,
-0.0297041014,
-0.0030470947,
-0.0328321867,
-0.0503297262,
-0.0275286082,
-0.0366747156,
0.0639684647,
-0.0259699505,
-0.030627491,
0.0850227401,
-0.0504094139,
-0.0561691597,
0.0008783301,
-0.0009667564,
-0.0134181939,
0.0853970572,
-0.0319319479,
-0.0010768689,
0.0359911434,
-0.0609389171,
-0.019657515,
0.0089081563,
0.0024898571,
-0.0188240223,
0.0798250362,
-0.0337536931,
-0.019384155,
-0.0005128629,
-0.0286183096,
-0.0601002946,
-0.0514474697,
-0.0246238466,
-0.0167287979,
-0.003087061,
-0.0204399191,
0.0122126201,
0.0209736265,
0.049060531,
0.0301964618,
-0.0246162526,
-0.018986566,
-0.0337704308,
0.0016622911,
0.0252192207,
0.0262979362,
-0.0044762483,
-0.022184208,
0.1273796558,
0.0115948142,
0.0737640336,
-0.0330667943,
-0.0055225044,
-0.0175717399,
0.0325580686,
-0.0071361139,
-0.0206802562,
0.0438462347,
0.0919017568,
-0.0553067438,
-0.001991655,
0.1532811522,
0.01602697,
-0.0540882349,
-0.0165527705,
-0.0603938587,
0.0164215937,
0.0352549963,
0.0181188136,
-0.0958566666,
-0.0407402031,
0.0249467064,
0.0024556096,
0.0196706858,
-0.0276401471,
-0.0156117175,
-0.102886349,
0.044075042,
-0.030997809,
-0.0109291133,
0.0084582185,
-0.0332657248,
0.0196988732,
0.0146971717,
0.055054538,
0.0354385562,
-0.0037756206,
-0.0214971397,
0.025936516,
-0.019655684,
-0.0161720831,
0.0432667695,
-0.0291006602,
0.0727841407,
0.0528872125,
0.0179013293,
0.0299881306,
0.0023646008,
0.0184605028,
0.0097543607,
0.0354659297,
-0.0152438059,
0.0428929105,
-0.0008340885,
-0.0245152563,
-0.0188969448,
0.0354024731,
-0.0241345968,
-0.0272752792,
0.0489048846,
0.0585512184,
-0.0539916158,
0.0093269544,
0.0200472921,
0.0103797996,
0.0309809037,
0.0998997986,
0.0569155589,
-0.040216215,
-0.0138598382,
-0.0277463757,
-0.0305403285,
-0.0404528677,
0.0026640589,
-0.0050981278,
0.0191878602,
-0.0146516645,
-0.0250248611,
-0.0615828,
0.0413199477,
0.0210554991,
-0.0019482579,
0.0297502242,
-0.0192676205,
0.0048356159,
0.0073338398,
0.0143361883,
-0.025034396,
0.033595819,
-0.0448583774,
-0.0000462535,
0.0211313423,
-0.0257121027,
0.0184915513,
0.0127549972,
-0.0525019504,
-0.0443956368,
-0.0206689723,
0.0359161012,
0.020988429,
0.0544983596,
-0.0044602407,
-0.0531111956,
-0.0191690121,
-0.0135982092,
-0.0596891157,
-0.017967768,
0.0293189269,
0.0477929935,
-0.0021452254,
0.0487818792,
-0.0327626206,
-0.0041384287,
-0.0334629305,
0.0442565084,
-0.0669661313,
-0.081700705,
0.0227743872,
0.0021817656,
0.0887966305,
0.0074511664,
0.0250666495,
-0.0289238542,
0.0432556421,
-0.0385323092,
-0.0092754867,
-0.0385323614,
0.0306856222,
-0.0180351771,
-0.0561076552,
0.0231893659,
-0.0029034868,
-0.0516436286,
0.010099316,
-0.0348266885,
0.0098183611,
0.000207871,
-0.0230022799,
0.0095519526,
0.0028612199,
-0.0208038166,
0.0114810765,
0.0468047634,
0.0203329008,
0.0226018894,
0.139789626,
0.0180110745,
-0.0173648968,
0.0080719311,
0.0237026475,
-0.0528722443,
-0.0643975213,
0.0681069419,
0.0144717749,
0.0225918703,
0.00713675,
0.0451945253,
-0.0040008877,
0.0291415807,
-0.0042397641,
0.0624292046,
0.0076301899,
-0.0338592678,
0.0313393958,
0.0339235812,
-0.0108201476,
-0.0029960538,
0.0626952499,
-0.018288916,
0.0150392167,
0.0193033833,
0.0183725953,
-0.0360596664,
-0.0326083377,
-0.0060993545,
0.03118385,
-0.0320979282,
0.0156573318,
-0.0408578627,
-0.0445555896,
-0.0279333796,
0.0138686672,
0.0029058508,
-0.0438714772,
0.0261816792,
0.0591350682,
-0.0123320473,
-0.0419642478,
-0.0353992246,
0.0136896707,
-0.0175673477,
-0.0121301254,
-0.0320242122,
-6.108292192e-33,
-0.0363792889,
-0.0538826361,
0.0435704403,
-0.0224385522,
-0.012041063,
-0.0150174033,
-0.0692579299,
0.0329487324,
-0.0191632584,
0.0175593141,
-0.0453468189,
0.0278059356,
0.0154211456,
0.017210599,
0.0200921353,
-0.0223762393,
0.0551386327,
-0.0055539128,
-0.0228580963,
0.0308978017,
0.0336771086,
0.0101910317,
0.0139204757,
-0.0385963768,
0.0557534434,
0.0081255566,
-0.0139355436,
0.0367449671,
-0.007617543,
0.0458635055,
-0.0277226381,
0.0290256571,
0.0290677305,
-0.0498744324,
-0.0313866176,
0.0518294126,
-0.0422630347,
-0.0161839966,
0.0525599122,
0.0071263937,
-0.0537985526,
-0.007196947,
0.0020802079,
-0.0097953351,
-0.0062104682,
0.0069292337,
-0.0012877282,
-0.0043204795,
-0.0219340213,
0.0294241905,
-0.0217952896,
0.0010017778,
-0.0540561937,
-0.1055849567,
0.0410220437,
0.0584020577,
-0.0033875706,
-0.0387403406,
-0.0168825984,
0.0195643231,
0.0084164487,
-0.0093904296,
0.0744233578,
0.0449789949,
0.0101666544,
0.0471779965,
0.031313438,
0.010067937,
-0.037381608,
-0.0287388768,
-0.0099740159,
0.038359832,
0.010703329,
0.0056385072,
-0.0145503758,
0.0200278237,
-0.0274340939,
0.0236078706,
0.0228378996,
0.0402425081,
0.0220215209,
0.0159867313,
-0.0383592211,
-0.0223464277,
-0.0478215218,
0.0118366377,
-0.0455059297,
-0.0316312164,
0.0395185575,
-0.0019466678,
0.0019356267,
-0.035034433,
0.0603303127,
-0.0206067525,
0.0015763104,
0.0161701031,
-0.0227433052,
0.0190202091,
-0.0059337774,
0.0137928464,
-0.0373051465,
-0.0053243507,
0.0128283957,
0.0244392082,
0.0145317549,
0.021973297,
0.0040735514,
-0.0034567358,
-0.0613123886,
-0.0148056382,
-0.0536679626,
0.0236374158,
-0.0482861884,
-0.0013538304,
0.0320565403,
0.0037229096,
-0.0539910384,
0.0873492435,
-0.0073274821,
-0.0530839562,
-0.0366380513,
-0.0036099469,
-0.0111092003,
-0.0040484113,
-0.038140621,
-0.0163662247,
-0.0170206781,
-0.0222635549,
0.0233041644,
-0.0184016675,
-0.0111839864,
0.0037083416,
2.616e-7,
-0.0037228125,
0.0530863889,
0.0104903672,
0.0451108105,
0.0114301182,
0.0586246662,
-0.0086909756,
-0.0114534115,
0.0333156921,
-0.029654583,
0.0181104839,
0.0399784259,
0.0388085619,
-0.0198428892,
-0.0994368717,
-0.0236233994,
-0.0646895021,
-0.0067416052,
-0.0463245101,
0.0067556906,
0.0586889386,
0.0420985632,
-0.0031291912,
0.0104089854,
0.0050879256,
-0.0138883861,
0.0340688191,
-0.0449744165,
0.0001249005,
0.0198607836,
0.0323370881,
-0.0199683011,
0.0081730587,
0.0249428097,
0.0057201721,
0.005837054,
-0.0196721144,
0.0599258095,
0.0123234009,
-0.0274232533,
-0.0268450994,
-0.008027886,
0.0151087409,
-0.0639559403,
0.0597376227,
-0.0564158075,
-0.0298983417,
-0.0244903769,
0.0140506914,
-0.0261759795,
-0.0060512917,
-0.0086971968,
-0.0177068431,
0.0178816803,
-0.0051271971,
-0.03443956,
0.0051562446,
-0.075251624,
-0.0123180142,
-0.023058163,
-0.0274020452,
-0.015888039,
-0.0517911687,
-0.0289660078,
0.0228879824,
-0.0464090444,
-0.0105457157,
2.025081056e-34,
0.0137043567,
-0.0079945866,
0.0345565528,
0.0636779219,
0.0285529569,
-0.0024595077,
-0.0111791445,
0.008152537,
0.0556556433,
-0.0696751997,
-0.0284035448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12934v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12934v2 | TOPFORMER: Topology-Aware Authorship Attribution of Deepfake Texts with Diverse Writing Styles | 2023-09-22T15:32:49 | 2024-04-09T11:27:48 | Adaku Uchendu, Thai Le, Dongwon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) have enabled the generation
of open-ended high-quality texts, that are non-trivial to distinguish from
human-written texts. We refer to such LLM-generated texts as deepfake texts.
There are currently over 72K text generation models in the huggingface model
repo. As such, users with malicious intent can easily use these open-sourced
LLMs to generate harmful texts and dis/misinformation at scale. To mitigate
this problem, a computational method to determine if a given text is a deepfake
text or not is desired--i.e., Turing Test (TT). In particular, in this work, we
investigate the more general version of the problem, known as Authorship
Attribution (AA), in a multi-class setting--i.e., not only determining if a
given text is a deepfake text or not but also being able to pinpoint which LLM
is the author. We propose TopFormer to improve existing AA solutions by
capturing more linguistic patterns in deepfake texts by including a Topological
Data Analysis (TDA) layer in the Transformer-based model. We show the benefits
of having a TDA layer when dealing with imbalanced, and multi-style datasets,
by extracting TDA features from the reshaped $pooled\_output$ of our backbone
as input. This Transformer-based model captures contextual representations
(i.e., semantic and syntactic linguistic features), while TDA captures the
shape and structure of data (i.e., linguistic structures). Finally, TopFormer,
outperforms all baselines in all 3 datasets, achieving up to 7\% increase in
Macro F1 score. | [
0.0356852375,
0.0453430973,
-0.038905818,
0.0548543558,
-0.0671854168,
-0.0012312365,
0.0731286108,
-0.0003264209,
0.0105572576,
-0.0165709052,
-0.0338017642,
-0.0367716774,
0.0254683383,
0.0722260326,
0.041855704,
0.0132705532,
-0.0313573368,
-0.0170909707,
0.0071611963,
-0.0129220998,
0.0100184083,
0.0298605766,
0.0449686684,
0.034793634,
-0.0203898251,
-0.0439391285,
0.0139671285,
0.0218822192,
0.0496093445,
0.0460179262,
0.03459052,
0.053713508,
-0.0310515128,
0.1233908385,
0.0000019161,
0.0052152122,
-0.0462422445,
0.0119645111,
0.0093984073,
-0.0166986026,
0.0578277893,
0.0076089636,
-0.0333286189,
0.002866195,
-0.0103928642,
0.0234315135,
0.0167214032,
0.0851686597,
0.0559101105,
0.0749968663,
-0.0333593152,
-0.045156341,
0.0614721291,
0.0339159518,
0.0043780762,
0.0353856646,
0.0284775458,
-0.0306524113,
-0.0398134328,
0.0171996988,
-0.0036419251,
0.0263567567,
0.0243410189,
-0.0337065049,
-0.0080863023,
0.0057301535,
-0.0106912097,
0.0095234793,
0.0289763752,
0.0733158588,
-0.0498087071,
-0.0378697664,
0.0436545126,
0.0006083078,
0.0074070049,
0.0484268926,
0.0019025176,
0.0559039228,
-0.0370473191,
-0.0259067025,
0.0026937949,
0.0119634243,
0.0191236548,
0.0073213694,
0.0073539242,
0.016443586,
0.0025730045,
-0.0149546303,
-0.0442546792,
-0.0100519191,
0.0096472232,
-0.0663011447,
0.0651287809,
-0.0120918183,
0.0328667723,
-0.028066203,
-0.0402976759,
-0.0714287832,
0.0200449917,
-0.0141847208,
0.0441742577,
-0.028013939,
-0.0432595946,
0.0100362981,
-0.0364721753,
0.0158724077,
-0.0313561745,
0.0468556844,
-0.0000309765,
-0.0141365491,
-0.0042858864,
-0.0220572148,
-0.0115791447,
0.0003666122,
0.0173101891,
0.0079306467,
-0.033302702,
0.0115875266,
-0.0210098065,
-0.0345076211,
-0.0075222515,
0.0146144405,
-0.0551222935,
0.0171148796,
0.0215094779,
-0.0087756459,
0.0081750583,
0.0190837644,
-0.0169102307,
-0.0313387774,
0.0035120647,
0.0444269441,
0.039812427,
-0.0359474458,
0.0391343795,
0.0050018635,
0.0202358477,
-0.0313629359,
-0.0084598232,
-0.065297842,
-0.0327049829,
-0.0378042161,
-0.014031467,
-0.0757719874,
-0.022594234,
-0.0319346339,
-0.0230016652,
-0.0378409959,
-0.0353949815,
0.0255656336,
-0.036655955,
0.0250636674,
0.0291803647,
0.0013944299,
0.071102947,
0.0010667794,
-0.0188592393,
-0.0313009806,
0.0309551843,
0.0883915946,
0.0301235057,
0.0115480041,
0.0326437205,
0.0405522287,
0.0313806199,
0.0347015262,
0.0023295234,
-0.0185377095,
0.0022742131,
-0.0001235134,
0.0215650313,
0.056291014,
-0.0041846232,
-0.063140057,
0.0720784888,
0.0368703157,
0.0256115366,
0.0514309481,
0.015862776,
0.0283189304,
0.0095868316,
-0.0082981726,
-0.0213962533,
0.011782608,
-0.0511329882,
-0.0259221494,
-0.0085063567,
0.0540228449,
0.0014094049,
0.0110070584,
0.0231249258,
-0.0150292432,
0.0260645151,
-0.0215139035,
0.0158003084,
0.0561886206,
-0.0303609837,
0.0017924942,
-0.0209700745,
-0.0589839444,
-0.0066159596,
-0.0520572625,
-0.0016590008,
0.0292392615,
0.0552151427,
-0.008957509,
0.003447498,
-0.0545246415,
0.0154197346,
0.0279590748,
-0.0378517471,
-0.0150737753,
-0.0103206709,
-0.0293226186,
-0.0294151194,
-0.0118497042,
-0.0117535228,
0.0324397199,
0.0145867849,
0.0089613618,
0.0275345687,
-0.0369086824,
-0.0526996031,
0.0234769955,
-0.0088114562,
0.0039410996,
0.0194967799,
0.0222937334,
0.0111783519,
0.0251432937,
-0.0356446318,
-0.027559815,
0.0248021577,
-0.0513493121,
-0.0408088751,
-0.0139952917,
-0.0039097457,
-0.0152539741,
0.0240281522,
-0.0643151253,
-0.0272148475,
0.0412484892,
-0.0088338852,
-0.0218430404,
0.0222286023,
-0.0349081568,
-0.0342415124,
-0.047884196,
-0.0012197959,
-0.0431484804,
0.0188682582,
-0.0403206907,
0.0677074865,
0.0173562635,
0.0180478264,
-0.0054775369,
0.001466449,
0.0265985411,
-0.004046326,
-0.0202635955,
-0.0512091443,
-0.0283995233,
0.0101761874,
0.0290805809,
0.0055472744,
0.0060542128,
-0.0836907029,
-0.0510080531,
-0.0165206529,
-0.0202257559,
0.0085143307,
0.0131048448,
0.0041151801,
0.0020430691,
0.0001758601,
-0.0627215132,
-0.0490791202,
-0.0108920475,
0.0058795833,
0.0462370962,
-0.0343616307,
-0.0277641024,
-0.0070743049,
-0.0066184117,
-0.0314569883,
0.0465740375,
0.0649252981,
-0.0004206351,
-0.0147449384,
0.0163175073,
-0.0007814548,
-0.0001467603,
-0.0072577498,
-0.0304498989,
-0.0115425615,
-0.0100778956,
0.0422079749,
0.065001443,
0.0366626233,
0.0103705749,
-0.0094808294,
0.0110442564,
-0.0143619422,
-0.0303430483,
-0.018025998,
0.0389936753,
0.0019415771,
-0.0563384444,
0.0044484134,
0.0134517364,
0.0243966524,
-0.0274616499,
-0.0329081155,
0.0304543581,
0.008118934,
0.0021945524,
0.0436330512,
-0.0213533342,
-0.0107704448,
-0.0096588815,
-0.0385389216,
-0.0386285968,
0.0796803832,
-0.0503872745,
0.0118094375,
-0.0026406199,
-0.0005552752,
-0.0346043371,
0.0668813884,
0.0101631051,
0.0428893007,
0.0437185839,
-0.0429018848,
-0.0297341812,
0.0366932005,
0.0506014563,
-0.0039957864,
0.0075402861,
0.0145927407,
0.0137699051,
0.0071620569,
-0.0237682313,
-0.0289453063,
-0.0523141399,
0.0124074146,
-0.0308639184,
-0.0023698907,
-0.0656020567,
-0.0308196675,
-0.0419396907,
0.0545504205,
0.0351722464,
-0.0353029594,
-0.0018587463,
-0.0128157549,
0.0649252981,
0.0259297304,
-0.0324478783,
-0.0061350754,
-0.0391406044,
-0.0519421026,
0.027005678,
-0.0355614386,
0.0416244827,
0.0121354256,
-0.0222990345,
-0.0013337452,
0.0064832321,
-0.0380291753,
-0.016997071,
0.0351008661,
-0.0483297892,
-0.0084972447,
0.0912288055,
0.0033202637,
-0.0018621738,
-0.017904032,
0.0070099779,
0.0217975955,
-0.0085935555,
0.0095274281,
-0.0796396807,
0.0055138366,
-0.0148984985,
-0.0041791149,
-0.0472700931,
-0.0088044293,
0.0187311675,
-0.0595466606,
0.042667225,
-0.0085006328,
-0.0608894974,
-0.0047298647,
-0.0356593952,
-0.0344340093,
0.0171737187,
-0.0238290876,
-0.0421660617,
0.0227278769,
-0.0139467185,
0.0015875301,
-0.0191919878,
-0.0061298693,
0.0312152207,
-0.0681860968,
0.0290560313,
0.0305238273,
0.0704072267,
-0.0385244414,
-0.0447848886,
-0.0222014096,
0.0064542866,
-0.0140685812,
-0.0108069303,
0.0852461383,
-0.0103461994,
-0.0078153368,
-0.0416863672,
0.0662941039,
-0.021867292,
0.0113892043,
-0.0201975815,
0.0616831183,
-0.0046700989,
-0.0210686848,
-0.0202445928,
-0.0038490021,
0.0239073411,
0.0650199354,
0.0159268044,
-0.049215395,
-0.0442732312,
-0.0675494,
0.0326336846,
-0.0581554584,
-0.0874630883,
0.0388991162,
-0.0013547582,
-0.0738130957,
-0.0662400424,
-0.0001455179,
-0.0272808112,
0.0202623568,
0.0303445607,
-0.0043135849,
-0.007711933,
-0.0348460786,
-0.0692381039,
-0.005653868,
-0.0359482169,
0.076010406,
-0.0184661876,
0.0084218681,
0.0254099816,
-0.0471563525,
-0.0038274352,
0.0222216044,
-0.0536902212,
-0.0437104851,
0.0566278361,
0.0098732235,
0.0114288833,
0.020878654,
-0.0241508782,
-0.0715140551,
0.1219125092,
0.0610785559,
-0.0202302057,
0.0064694174,
0.0479065888,
-0.035466969,
-0.0166532472,
0.0358008854,
-0.0292234868,
0.0286628045,
0.0482960902,
-0.050617896,
-0.0409051999,
-0.0139536988,
-0.029798314,
0.035956189,
0.0479627326,
-0.0180056542,
0.0053563137,
-0.0417169183,
-0.0272193588,
-0.0253864974,
-0.0273382552,
-0.0079040807,
0.0239564758,
0.0424514115,
-0.0086392378,
-0.0151978927,
0.0282043163,
-0.0078413263,
0.0719494224,
-0.0185578074,
0.0388353691,
0.0272229146,
0.0914819688,
0.0192987304,
0.012372613,
-0.0095566381,
0.0148370015,
0.0046453099,
0.0527055897,
0.0155657679,
-0.0226955321,
0.0322242938,
-0.0131615642,
-0.0286533367,
0.0303258952,
-0.0689614862,
0.042787727,
-0.0311442018,
-0.0278569721,
-0.0058939885,
0.0203821994,
0.033116132,
0.0040743905,
-0.0027056311,
-0.016804656,
0.0306542236,
0.0229736473,
-0.0366274603,
-0.0373396911,
-0.0190634523,
-0.0160330292,
0.0285237972,
0.0512502491,
0.026496755,
0.0330201536,
0.0254869033,
-0.0348650515,
-0.0175091587,
-0.0148895541,
0.0131206317,
0.0111668259,
0.0122482376,
-0.0349893793,
-0.0569118597,
-0.0408510678,
0.1021780968,
-0.0116656488,
0.0304337256,
-0.0008624972,
0.0141814146,
0.0403503999,
-0.0049353214,
-0.0074083037,
-0.0639438778,
0.0523523279,
0.0395854414,
-0.0507793874,
0.0217534117,
-5.734523927e-33,
0.0294422843,
-0.0830756053,
-0.04255208,
0.0497590266,
-0.0167670175,
0.0315767266,
-0.0132289426,
-0.0290154759,
-0.0124452319,
0.0088041918,
-0.0089579569,
0.0396871306,
0.0006982333,
0.0274457708,
-0.0261592045,
0.0041859075,
0.0367878042,
-0.0042427983,
-0.026045667,
0.059673693,
0.0519177131,
0.0103765614,
0.0348529369,
-0.09676525,
0.045547273,
-0.0494030192,
-0.048658859,
-0.0089473864,
-0.0422719158,
0.0432346798,
-0.0063909534,
0.0298424307,
0.0058402396,
-0.0185504723,
0.0041018962,
0.0394492485,
-0.0513567142,
-0.0122780306,
-0.0365032256,
0.0204973519,
0.0176275261,
-0.0785369053,
0.0730506927,
-0.0135517856,
0.0150792003,
-0.0418116376,
0.0837263167,
0.003773021,
0.0047692358,
-0.0561905466,
-0.037064001,
0.0250707176,
-0.0195782967,
-0.0077624335,
0.0161804501,
0.0147357862,
0.0440171808,
-0.0157003347,
-0.1185522303,
0.0217523277,
-0.0119674262,
-0.0099846227,
-0.0043410156,
0.0362215452,
0.0035984686,
0.05317555,
0.0075751916,
0.0388978645,
-0.0203350969,
0.0004524204,
0.0497075394,
0.0482267961,
0.0562550426,
0.1092905104,
0.0026549301,
-0.012840447,
-0.054568328,
0.0509620756,
0.0213853661,
-0.0671968237,
0.0158028454,
-0.0148681663,
-0.0527633354,
-0.0342798345,
-0.0160831064,
-0.0725916624,
-0.0265989173,
0.0166860782,
-0.0203230698,
-0.0182867572,
-0.0552076846,
0.0191214178,
0.0147960205,
-0.0643129349,
-0.0056598377,
-0.0064047719,
-0.0494062267,
0.0643212721,
0.0101117129,
0.0352726318,
-0.0007155744,
-0.0402793698,
0.0138310669,
0.0354016386,
0.0410658531,
0.0020882376,
0.1015109047,
0.0493450984,
-0.0682960749,
-0.009533599,
0.0257013291,
0.006967932,
0.0057026427,
0.0269096885,
-0.0256102066,
0.0082468903,
0.0146842189,
0.0181405265,
0.0366830342,
0.0282247476,
-0.0399543047,
0.0079171108,
-0.0164028164,
0.0045049894,
-0.0353029519,
-0.0353853926,
-0.0043797544,
-0.0186063331,
0.064989306,
-0.0683712065,
0.0002877144,
-0.0442758165,
2.63e-7,
0.022753235,
0.0315742902,
0.0495548211,
-0.0127978269,
0.0082615297,
0.0781962574,
0.0708934888,
0.0433998741,
-0.0261807833,
-0.0009432724,
0.0023421547,
0.0084135514,
0.0550460555,
0.0390949957,
-0.0899463221,
0.0305602495,
-0.0745889023,
0.0109086502,
-0.0630609617,
0.0249481816,
0.0087079378,
0.0548004508,
0.0350532234,
-0.0550342612,
0.0053452603,
-0.0302834436,
0.0465511493,
0.0350284763,
0.0153104253,
0.0403087288,
0.0500871092,
-0.0707543865,
0.0160159227,
0.0053921742,
-0.0172871742,
0.0085089374,
0.0014989182,
0.0376216248,
0.0020360027,
-0.0091700573,
0.0009068308,
-0.0521426983,
0.0066667502,
-0.0563543923,
0.0443684608,
0.0214722808,
-0.0274649523,
-0.0149871046,
-0.0181534421,
-0.0291744396,
0.026815841,
-0.0231258832,
-0.0129347211,
0.0462861173,
0.0228814371,
-0.0236517843,
0.0287553128,
-0.0619405806,
-0.0247000549,
-0.0314656794,
-0.0325996168,
0.0288573541,
-0.0238669831,
-0.0206308663,
0.0483005531,
-0.0760570318,
0.0425394885,
2.932624454e-34,
0.0153145976,
-0.0126435328,
-0.0065880753,
-0.032025978,
0.0261060633,
0.0113582052,
0.0592137501,
0.0126163429,
-0.0141359242,
-0.0403140597,
-0.0258417819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12931v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12931v2 | On Separate Normalization in Self-supervised Transformers | 2023-09-22T15:30:53 | 2023-11-28T19:06:49 | Xiaohui Chen, Yinkai Wang, Yuanqi Du, Soha Hassoun, Li-Ping Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Self-supervised training methods for transformers have demonstrated
remarkable performance across various domains. Previous transformer-based
models, such as masked autoencoders (MAE), typically utilize a single
normalization layer for both the [CLS] symbol and the tokens. We propose in
this paper a simple modification that employs separate normalization layers for
the tokens and the [CLS] symbol to better capture their distinct
characteristics and enhance downstream task performance. Our method aims to
alleviate the potential negative effects of using the same normalization
statistics for both token types, which may not be optimally aligned with their
individual roles. We empirically show that by utilizing a separate
normalization layer, the [CLS] embeddings can better encode the global
contextual information and are distributed more uniformly in its anisotropic
space. When replacing the conventional normalization layer with the two
separate layers, we observe an average 2.7% performance improvement over the
image, natural language, and graph domains. | [
-0.0120284958,
0.0130886026,
-0.0029590274,
0.0428970382,
0.0073712063,
-0.0007667326,
0.0879028216,
-0.0187621526,
-0.0207071006,
-0.0272171386,
-0.070453383,
0.0191877093,
-0.0343756676,
0.0471396558,
0.0211406555,
-0.0444503091,
0.0041715149,
0.0056092525,
-0.0486786813,
-0.0223258715,
-0.0471836925,
-0.0138550363,
0.016689444,
0.0600172915,
-0.0470184162,
0.0061935466,
0.0159768555,
-0.0060979431,
0.0299371723,
-0.0229261592,
-0.0160886105,
0.0304707121,
0.0365939923,
0.0178031381,
0.0000021802,
-0.0140401758,
-0.0024727772,
-0.0117861191,
-0.0348430984,
-0.0203445889,
0.0158605054,
-0.0622237325,
0.0073278225,
0.0089415256,
-0.0245992243,
-0.0575530343,
0.036250677,
0.0902259946,
0.0644522607,
0.0252579283,
-0.0234269779,
-0.0685062036,
-0.0074020964,
-0.0201544296,
-0.0689348578,
-0.010595995,
-0.0025386561,
-0.0311141554,
-0.0699095801,
-0.012539139,
-0.0611438118,
0.0549414791,
0.0537094809,
-0.0172116738,
0.0545920804,
0.0655271783,
-0.0131132863,
-0.0027600878,
-0.0117245838,
0.0370804444,
-0.0519509353,
0.0097459266,
-0.0454518721,
0.0054605617,
-0.002106138,
0.0030963437,
-0.0099349562,
0.0172207393,
0.0392676815,
0.0274802092,
-0.0624410287,
0.0700027421,
0.0270813126,
-0.0367562026,
-0.0612987354,
0.0491687432,
0.0076829894,
0.0081380913,
-0.0222302862,
-0.0103851743,
0.0000495021,
-0.0051948978,
0.0634456947,
0.0403433517,
0.0260986052,
-0.0286801625,
-0.0187559593,
-0.0522826165,
-0.0343087986,
0.0042761229,
-0.0042961054,
0.0210753456,
-0.0548952818,
0.0024999776,
-0.0647746846,
0.0683124289,
-0.0173949562,
0.1101286486,
-0.0429871827,
-0.0282619987,
0.0011799694,
-0.0343289524,
-0.0695927367,
0.050036408,
-0.010657711,
-0.0491101779,
-0.0537849404,
0.0066976361,
-0.0071106316,
0.0125342412,
0.0373864919,
0.036624331,
-0.0623220727,
0.0124871675,
0.0300092325,
0.0322004892,
-0.0367255025,
0.0054584164,
0.0120445816,
-0.0120128673,
-0.0123601947,
0.0153957382,
0.0457614399,
-0.016597461,
0.0128552774,
0.1050891057,
0.0040096361,
-0.0212182458,
-0.0149642313,
0.0361307859,
-0.035450276,
0.020622192,
0.0169644859,
-0.0309143253,
-0.0016985296,
0.012778081,
0.017287055,
0.0013136029,
-0.0148694664,
-0.0211177543,
0.0479582585,
0.0743372664,
0.0231938567,
-0.0365979075,
0.0498908311,
0.0122479945,
-0.0050289892,
0.0260722525,
0.0177587438,
0.0390827991,
0.0071947784,
-0.0534082912,
0.0215377845,
0.0235539079,
0.0025244243,
-0.0549617223,
-0.0253915433,
-0.047729183,
-0.0015249863,
0.0136039928,
0.0713965371,
0.0351324715,
-0.0401358604,
-0.0846788138,
0.022822395,
0.0676573291,
0.0355234928,
0.0078257956,
0.0303447023,
-0.0029082147,
-0.005564813,
0.021838313,
-0.0285369176,
0.0538196564,
0.0266450774,
-0.0231082402,
-0.0489111803,
0.0244326945,
-0.0704089403,
-0.0382057056,
0.0236622617,
-0.0349958427,
-0.0063233823,
-0.0366839878,
0.0459578075,
0.0449906699,
-0.0109454561,
0.0537577085,
-0.0140216341,
-0.0279834103,
0.0330994427,
-0.0210415348,
-0.0376631618,
-0.0296749547,
0.0396172404,
0.0184051115,
-0.027821295,
-0.0227725394,
-0.0274338629,
0.0537992604,
-0.0313819796,
-0.0134042995,
0.0350848809,
-0.0498809516,
-0.0653142855,
-0.0480449535,
-0.0086009586,
0.0346309505,
-0.0549709313,
0.0036446953,
0.0373982191,
-0.0550182313,
0.045842506,
0.0346323811,
0.0124738822,
-0.0476119667,
0.0375639237,
0.0554633886,
-0.0121008847,
0.020219367,
-0.0017716992,
-0.0063645057,
0.0100107957,
-0.0876733959,
-0.0615868792,
0.0435099304,
-0.0960473046,
-0.0129493177,
0.0221848562,
-0.0811293796,
-0.0048312037,
0.0727426186,
-0.0069682528,
-0.0401883274,
0.0198682174,
-0.0155002447,
0.0173881911,
-0.0157280825,
-0.0145022459,
0.0025527412,
0.0416185893,
0.0005600913,
0.0251777023,
0.0042410651,
-0.0274107121,
0.0010794506,
0.0087718535,
0.0438944623,
0.0125058629,
-0.0197561029,
-0.0260716993,
-0.0198890921,
-0.0137475878,
0.0252310634,
-0.0286845844,
-0.008364846,
-0.0100947246,
-0.0216223113,
-0.0316142291,
-0.0268258154,
0.0107813422,
0.015332791,
0.0281100646,
0.0109884338,
-0.0508343391,
-0.0228914283,
-0.0196623076,
-0.0133882314,
0.0015860997,
0.0393522792,
0.0008127237,
-0.0088929692,
0.0162386652,
-0.0462069809,
-0.008542723,
0.0632878393,
-0.0031832024,
-0.0091437586,
-0.0192189887,
0.0047625895,
0.0056454618,
0.0269048959,
-0.0133306133,
-0.07224866,
0.0018866898,
0.0165185723,
0.060832683,
0.0567839369,
0.0081908051,
0.0245674662,
0.0374679044,
0.0132442433,
-0.0303236581,
-0.0045825322,
-0.0448472053,
0.0020401226,
-0.0315501094,
0.0042115026,
0.0011408748,
0.0609469004,
-0.0044468883,
0.0004101099,
-0.0401303098,
-0.019935023,
-0.0222096201,
-0.0222303811,
-0.0058402624,
-0.0163010117,
-0.0005728748,
0.0091942186,
-0.0009262111,
-0.0030748239,
0.0637455136,
-0.0186726246,
-0.0230582878,
0.0073927902,
-0.0086581009,
-0.0279046707,
0.0276840813,
0.0241682511,
0.0420465618,
0.0058451542,
-0.07819473,
-0.0229280405,
0.0132067474,
0.0267184339,
0.0057508475,
0.0354600735,
0.0556241758,
-0.0444081575,
-0.0089149568,
-0.0474156104,
-0.0654349253,
-0.0054864939,
-0.0060584303,
0.0289098192,
0.0486949421,
-0.0294428542,
-0.0582556874,
0.0380351059,
0.0034536654,
0.0711848065,
-0.0071624429,
-0.0056868438,
-0.00904225,
0.0546029918,
0.0044532209,
0.0273774751,
0.0318972245,
-0.002534678,
0.0371921659,
0.031096641,
0.0357876979,
-0.0113686714,
-0.0609773025,
0.0138464151,
0.0014366624,
-0.0047339243,
0.0303182025,
-0.0159163661,
0.0236790422,
-0.0250278786,
-0.0220275,
0.1198487356,
-0.0034946087,
-0.0588483028,
-0.0072860583,
-0.0380264036,
-0.0204502661,
0.0276914649,
0.0038140432,
-0.0451591238,
-0.0097833583,
-0.0209360737,
0.0038410246,
0.0318094902,
0.0120190801,
0.0477120131,
-0.0718313605,
0.0223062653,
0.0105171856,
-0.040228188,
-0.0680559352,
-0.033745598,
-0.0073802737,
-0.0473518521,
0.0375603139,
-0.0473397709,
-0.003200026,
-0.0456831157,
0.0426139943,
-0.0398988537,
-0.0466165692,
-0.0135728428,
-0.0480847694,
0.0192615408,
0.0094159562,
-0.003165035,
-0.0164128542,
-0.047000248,
0.0319401547,
0.006379379,
0.0334009677,
-0.0019968774,
0.0696496591,
-0.0313025787,
-0.0205707755,
-0.0004482912,
0.006848746,
-0.0249452759,
-0.0140637336,
-0.067154184,
0.047442887,
0.0008650703,
-0.0408157967,
-0.0536303706,
-0.0127772084,
-0.0342422538,
0.0228611529,
0.0357455201,
-0.0042542308,
-0.0116731524,
-0.0145145096,
0.0485132858,
-0.0350895487,
-0.0399101265,
0.0263943169,
0.0142872641,
-0.0728179663,
-0.0146048777,
-0.020252062,
0.001316216,
0.044592794,
0.0034013491,
-0.0809098557,
0.0162788182,
-0.005021512,
-0.0488987677,
0.0115812328,
-0.0191135723,
-0.0107846214,
-0.0211465973,
0.0339115001,
0.0490562506,
-0.00951258,
-0.018531926,
-0.0117725264,
-0.0458976515,
-0.0226429515,
0.028457528,
0.0281234719,
0.0095262751,
0.0370915011,
-0.0132846404,
-0.0247600339,
0.1062483862,
0.0709999502,
-0.0336049087,
-0.0221112147,
0.0437590182,
-0.0440974645,
-0.0136341862,
0.0161224622,
-0.0307987444,
0.078059271,
-0.0125820395,
0.0092496658,
-0.0094725238,
0.0009177214,
0.0228491686,
-0.010478287,
0.0810683817,
-0.0083602536,
0.088808462,
-0.0192473959,
0.0017472478,
-0.0417588055,
-0.0019374468,
0.0041001346,
-0.0033454928,
0.0212693196,
0.0244144127,
0.0023633894,
0.0470654778,
0.0131003885,
0.0101749115,
-0.0276560318,
0.0087372502,
-0.0222357269,
-0.006703068,
-0.0386061892,
0.0300697517,
-0.0025827824,
-0.0106046572,
0.0953077599,
0.0075334618,
0.0026996487,
0.0020959107,
0.0359342545,
0.0402992442,
-0.0672540963,
0.0469304621,
-0.0704621077,
0.0291349273,
-0.0204508249,
-0.0569279008,
0.0129700573,
-0.0252829101,
-0.0080070682,
-0.0097077424,
-0.0124670826,
0.0038312171,
0.0086032934,
-0.0152566489,
-0.0213289168,
0.057763502,
-0.0324636661,
0.0032246113,
-0.0330845006,
0.060044609,
-0.0425745286,
0.01263241,
-0.0286881458,
0.0135007501,
-0.0504147187,
0.0230896976,
0.0080833416,
-0.0055992915,
-0.0200634729,
-0.0134214638,
-0.0050386102,
-0.0770217702,
0.0399117917,
-0.0286411326,
0.0077236309,
0.0129467407,
0.0447141454,
0.0099687455,
0.037638519,
-0.0477003045,
0.0231743213,
0.0505244844,
0.038547527,
0.0053775697,
0.0190524589,
-6.680941979e-33,
-0.0243302919,
-0.0416415632,
0.0063890452,
0.0285959933,
-0.0007369034,
0.0395827629,
-0.0152443079,
-0.0126983719,
0.0079765925,
0.0198788419,
-0.0103602745,
0.0182682965,
0.0170547627,
0.0301010143,
0.0043839812,
-0.0494049005,
0.0888636485,
-0.0075255195,
-0.0156660881,
-0.0103548924,
0.0156259555,
0.0375017039,
0.079664655,
-0.1060371771,
-0.0540376157,
0.0251420885,
-0.0068315398,
-0.0035538604,
0.0551154427,
0.0354327597,
-0.0170843955,
0.0527138337,
0.0050608143,
-0.0517908074,
-0.0258389693,
0.0011393242,
-0.0962950513,
-0.0465944037,
-0.0769818574,
0.070204623,
-0.0574377999,
-0.0262972396,
0.0795866102,
-0.0149911707,
-0.0332701877,
-0.0337070413,
0.0436433628,
0.0357978195,
0.0076830219,
-0.0226238165,
-0.0341625214,
0.0071541257,
-0.0160216391,
-0.0182100479,
0.074686192,
0.0310365167,
0.0141098155,
0.0268325116,
-0.0910410956,
0.0217090584,
-0.0235149395,
0.0160435457,
0.0634757206,
0.0391046107,
-0.0087668514,
0.0356198102,
0.0668852925,
-0.0074196206,
-0.0603835322,
-0.0361337624,
0.0622050092,
0.0249311589,
0.047882013,
-0.0114410575,
0.0224770047,
-0.0432599746,
-0.0497801565,
0.0463189967,
-0.0580720305,
0.0489991568,
-0.0133148851,
0.0408852436,
0.0046873684,
-0.0109830182,
-0.0154083651,
-0.0359576344,
-0.0139663666,
-0.0019291732,
0.0059624044,
0.0059926785,
-0.0254621375,
0.0298794396,
0.0211072695,
-0.0349234641,
-0.0013046532,
0.0092405714,
0.0228696,
0.035179466,
-0.0052999719,
0.0036736038,
-0.0260089524,
-0.0129509373,
0.0366574451,
0.01957318,
0.02639037,
0.0125909122,
0.050949648,
0.0622530058,
-0.0631332323,
-0.0455125272,
-0.0302560572,
-0.0272519421,
0.0107472325,
0.0112431999,
0.0296010897,
0.0094825048,
-0.0287985466,
0.0008903892,
0.0020124121,
0.0171687491,
-0.020328844,
0.0768796429,
0.0535950735,
0.0311966427,
-0.0111946063,
-0.0144094527,
-0.0519536473,
0.0176361874,
0.0664485544,
-0.0719780251,
-0.0294936802,
-0.0058008651,
2.824e-7,
0.0497069508,
0.0313080661,
0.0582530871,
0.008907754,
0.0080573363,
0.0450464599,
0.0057527293,
0.0637388825,
0.0152332606,
0.00211262,
0.0084936563,
0.0245860741,
-0.0139113627,
0.0246892106,
-0.0347619802,
0.0355432369,
-0.0367624275,
0.0086233476,
-0.0074482057,
0.0321413465,
-0.0099264579,
0.0871748403,
0.0010592263,
-0.0030046201,
0.0308103282,
-0.0092879487,
0.0509404801,
-0.0020987391,
0.0338720307,
0.0025279874,
-0.0224607121,
0.0597831234,
0.0134857595,
0.0520693883,
-0.0162731707,
0.0277938489,
0.0638943985,
-0.0095642935,
-0.0254448578,
-0.0385475978,
-0.0111286119,
0.0211587846,
-0.0090167597,
-0.0040151635,
0.0227738135,
-0.1042995378,
-0.0525621288,
-0.0389294215,
-0.0440084226,
0.0323380753,
0.0450186059,
-0.0032000453,
-0.028631594,
0.0327315219,
0.039426256,
0.0115391603,
-0.0139107266,
-0.0731418431,
-0.0170436557,
-0.0172726456,
-0.0424100906,
0.0313812308,
-0.0333434194,
-0.0236412771,
0.048990164,
0.0244547054,
-0.0265994351,
2.308896591e-34,
-0.0199700166,
-0.0064793006,
-0.0027334676,
0.0219609905,
-0.0293476898,
-0.0351849981,
0.0052492796,
-0.026682239,
0.0007045571,
-0.0472208448,
-0.0370674394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14355v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14355v1 | PopBERT. Detecting populism and its host ideologies in the German Bundestag | 2023-09-22T14:48:02 | 2023-09-22T14:48:02 | L. Erhard, S. Hanke, U. Remer, A. Falenska, R. Heiberger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | The rise of populism concerns many political scientists and practitioners,
yet the detection of its underlying language remains fragmentary. This paper
aims to provide a reliable, valid, and scalable approach to measure populist
stances. For that purpose, we created an annotated dataset based on
parliamentary speeches of the German Bundestag (2013 to 2021). Following the
ideational definition of populism, we label moralizing references to the
virtuous people or the corrupt elite as core dimensions of populist language.
To identify, in addition, how the thin ideology of populism is thickened, we
annotate how populist statements are attached to left-wing or right-wing host
ideologies. We then train a transformer-based model (PopBERT) as a multilabel
classifier to detect and quantify each dimension. A battery of validation
checks reveals that the model has a strong predictive accuracy, provides high
qualitative face validity, matches party rankings of expert surveys, and
detects out-of-sample text snippets correctly. PopBERT enables dynamic analyses
of how German-speaking politicians and parties use populist language as a
strategic device. Furthermore, the annotator-level data may also be applied in
cross-domain applications or to develop related classifiers. | [
-0.0095179249,
0.0729846954,
0.0032838453,
0.0302825551,
-0.0253303349,
0.0063389335,
-0.0281565338,
-0.0195426177,
0.0153875612,
-0.0401371345,
0.0123170801,
-0.0047085336,
-0.0129556982,
0.0214730836,
0.0068100551,
-0.0754553005,
0.0568102375,
0.0371591523,
0.0516226366,
-0.0367864855,
0.0190116316,
0.0029784248,
0.0095233014,
0.0506764688,
-0.0414256826,
0.007182756,
-0.0017688411,
-0.0008578919,
0.0827936381,
-0.0006024188,
0.0219023414,
0.0107321404,
-0.0175143518,
0.0534227751,
0.0000017152,
-0.0376801044,
-0.0484071709,
-0.0173071269,
0.0718342513,
-0.0532780215,
0.0828594863,
-0.0141696651,
-0.0339541771,
0.0102771651,
-0.0347173139,
0.0366819799,
0.0408514962,
0.080694668,
0.0699734464,
0.0439694934,
-0.001266325,
-0.0522456504,
0.0063884389,
-0.0069887969,
-0.012687739,
-0.025420852,
0.016854981,
-0.0238444563,
-0.0828770995,
0.0432452932,
-0.0269253328,
0.0134472856,
-0.0055945013,
0.0197838731,
-0.016124364,
-0.0238586962,
-0.0557194464,
-0.0318432897,
-0.000957606,
0.0102391215,
0.028856257,
-0.0076289643,
0.029453909,
-0.0260448568,
-0.0061396426,
0.088535063,
-0.0145306904,
0.0001740622,
-0.0430416353,
0.0187989697,
0.0586142279,
-0.0037446825,
0.0113532739,
0.0128576858,
-0.0289482716,
0.0842371359,
-0.0238646716,
-0.0258704666,
0.0472564884,
-0.0219614469,
-0.0134282941,
-0.0184701663,
0.0053306282,
-0.0236758683,
0.0081158988,
0.0182348415,
-0.0147563471,
-0.0684752613,
0.0288105477,
-0.0670199171,
-0.00470979,
-0.001422448,
-0.0083324434,
0.0606553964,
0.0419324525,
0.0086882673,
-0.0016143438,
0.0134826349,
-0.0112882275,
-0.0350753665,
-0.0279402696,
0.0034480144,
-0.011694259,
0.0006985933,
0.0234905779,
0.0277773123,
-0.056949053,
-0.016579872,
-0.021548247,
-0.0050107776,
-0.0546603464,
0.0123341996,
0.0217770506,
0.002528881,
-0.0457451232,
0.0840557218,
-0.0403721109,
-0.0032497568,
-0.0386633053,
0.0133860046,
0.0372063927,
0.054472208,
-0.018707836,
-0.0206352752,
0.0281892009,
-0.0050053652,
-0.0029173517,
0.022299055,
0.0037926727,
-0.0215376895,
-0.0447483733,
0.0055447766,
0.053589005,
-0.0609616227,
-0.0022979483,
-0.0083814347,
0.0185684152,
-0.053820692,
0.0221231021,
0.0092771901,
-0.0395242274,
0.042147126,
0.0349278376,
0.0010167907,
0.0234263595,
0.0123067619,
-0.041984845,
0.0334742032,
0.0031763006,
0.0067968536,
0.0361711979,
-0.0030739254,
0.0628760234,
0.0651949942,
-0.005407589,
0.0110197719,
-0.0235970151,
0.0018585277,
0.003328715,
-0.0503394343,
0.0345454887,
0.0145272855,
0.0426233299,
-0.01053786,
0.0204135571,
0.0421603136,
0.0071835141,
-0.033717446,
0.0018423705,
0.0072453846,
-0.019395696,
-0.0139868455,
0.0160645712,
-0.0244161543,
0.0108728828,
-0.0429241732,
0.023350371,
0.0355151333,
0.0071122935,
-0.018149903,
0.0065637701,
0.0165645555,
0.0207687933,
-0.0227198359,
0.0336470753,
-0.0068128952,
-0.0047553685,
0.0682245418,
0.0247645061,
-0.0304294117,
-0.0258364901,
-0.0280219372,
0.0065454235,
-0.0079078134,
-0.0076083774,
-0.0385224633,
0.0074862004,
-0.0502614379,
0.0293504205,
0.0311557315,
0.0817944258,
-0.0576666184,
-0.0476575531,
0.0054747039,
-0.0157927126,
0.006637217,
0.0430886038,
0.0561452247,
-0.0016657482,
0.0031805208,
-0.023330586,
-0.0348227918,
0.0134119838,
0.0285115298,
-0.005489273,
-0.00041106,
-0.0009687751,
0.012012125,
0.0095504746,
0.0327807516,
-0.0135000385,
-0.0316521153,
0.0570225082,
-0.0225917362,
-0.0271328688,
0.0015806285,
0.046853628,
0.0376641303,
0.0107854875,
-0.0431704484,
-0.0199635681,
0.0101812677,
-0.0380268507,
0.0030414897,
0.0500402637,
-0.0210355744,
-0.0079870922,
-0.0467201807,
-0.0148510141,
-0.0469912961,
-0.0113642905,
-0.0616788045,
0.0777221322,
-0.0130985361,
0.0295013338,
0.0059682289,
-0.0461767614,
0.0497687869,
0.0458765067,
-0.0170487557,
-0.0075194337,
-0.0106895361,
0.0754637942,
0.0298724324,
-0.0171314515,
-0.0085293166,
-0.0386143252,
-0.0222780909,
-0.013283791,
-0.0263452046,
0.0261240322,
0.0000879902,
-0.0026109356,
0.0283755921,
0.0292331539,
-0.0243871622,
-0.027769642,
-0.0367093459,
-0.0207055081,
0.0577822477,
-0.0076880539,
-0.0471099317,
-0.0079672029,
0.0268943962,
-0.0525504164,
0.0169631951,
0.0253429785,
-0.0273506846,
0.0379701555,
-0.0706521273,
-0.0755080208,
-0.0163931474,
-0.0666299835,
-0.010273708,
-0.0043911091,
0.0166898463,
0.0370097235,
0.0273999963,
0.0589227788,
0.0457710102,
-0.026371995,
0.050098639,
-0.0618154556,
-0.0393915437,
-0.0573854446,
0.0014072437,
-0.0276468061,
-0.0278878976,
0.0485000014,
0.0855576098,
0.0067348951,
0.0037172397,
-0.0253013931,
0.0258591175,
-0.0218079295,
-0.022355279,
-0.0197521672,
0.0282765869,
-0.0137338648,
0.0140207093,
0.0282970835,
-0.0375183523,
-0.0079096435,
0.0025762499,
0.0614397824,
0.0151398033,
-0.0739962906,
-0.0195478592,
0.0408172905,
-0.0002454361,
0.023804713,
0.0287206452,
0.0308892746,
-0.0121103153,
-0.0186705682,
0.0396201313,
-0.0481364653,
0.0289700516,
-0.0362918675,
0.0112239234,
-0.0026754788,
-0.0133575611,
-0.0252564605,
-0.117640458,
-0.0130625432,
0.0081899241,
0.0016149373,
-0.0388092473,
-0.0517941751,
0.0132028749,
0.0384517238,
-0.0134277567,
0.0256882124,
0.0022540085,
0.0249904357,
0.0078270091,
-0.0103149628,
-0.017367458,
0.025476668,
-0.0196332633,
-0.0609797873,
0.0344050378,
0.0221731178,
0.0437615961,
-0.0177597068,
-0.031235978,
-0.0104014436,
-0.0184831601,
-0.0091668144,
-0.0343202576,
0.01727801,
-0.0369750597,
0.0264792386,
0.0349877886,
0.013163968,
0.0185027365,
-0.0034307379,
-0.0144458329,
0.0179023203,
0.0143204611,
0.0042543272,
-0.0964796022,
0.0342889838,
0.0093768109,
0.0137064559,
-0.0530361682,
-0.0182960741,
0.0065287994,
-0.0837648287,
0.0131793497,
0.0080573307,
-0.0133670745,
0.0099306693,
-0.0239316486,
0.0033903182,
-0.0302442741,
-0.0696504042,
-0.0370352864,
0.0286187008,
0.0287828427,
0.0102712428,
-0.0632291809,
-0.0459522232,
0.0464268066,
-0.0130747687,
0.0298258252,
-0.0032995513,
0.0607942231,
-0.0160408244,
-0.0245858245,
0.0790533423,
0.0021016297,
-0.0225358177,
0.0123519916,
0.0478933714,
-0.0284785554,
-0.0330055803,
0.0316624641,
0.0450982749,
0.0387456864,
-0.0272577628,
0.0157191195,
0.0440798178,
-0.021713227,
-0.0354784876,
-0.0136623345,
0.0325824507,
0.0463599227,
0.0419929624,
0.0032331748,
-0.0129580498,
0.0305195916,
-0.0561116077,
0.0372644328,
-0.0436203964,
-0.0629025176,
0.0190504193,
-0.0393512025,
-0.0315822996,
0.0055456646,
-0.0295226909,
-0.020467408,
0.0225345958,
0.0082312115,
-0.0132745076,
-0.0100195343,
0.0025474974,
-0.0415773317,
0.0211113449,
-0.0031680549,
0.0249624085,
0.0035873621,
-0.07050661,
0.0236265417,
0.0333656743,
-0.0925624371,
-0.0162073579,
-0.0020882201,
-0.0447933078,
0.0008434938,
-0.000369009,
0.0208995994,
0.034806978,
-0.0082094222,
0.0002999275,
0.0644634739,
0.0762133375,
-0.0251199193,
0.0272619799,
0.0375981852,
0.0000912616,
-0.0023337309,
0.0060961167,
-0.0162852705,
0.0532737225,
0.0149848424,
-0.0728111267,
-0.080657579,
0.0330461748,
0.0040638535,
0.0019722648,
0.0493105426,
-0.0141369579,
-0.0844688639,
-0.0408330783,
-0.031640511,
0.0301610101,
-0.0394296385,
-0.0096314168,
-0.0149983894,
0.0268473066,
-0.0290751047,
-0.0198042821,
0.0103870677,
-0.018578168,
0.0467267409,
-0.046380613,
0.0264817718,
0.0272545125,
0.0202513039,
0.0021899168,
-0.0324571431,
0.0331833065,
0.0061559197,
0.0275850594,
0.0619633161,
0.025128372,
0.0290825441,
0.0151113253,
0.0223114695,
0.0678842962,
-0.0254704393,
-0.0436628945,
-0.04105445,
-0.0589385405,
0.0061720465,
-0.0252333377,
0.0313571766,
0.0330451801,
0.0311106704,
-0.0154896788,
-0.0231113713,
0.0254479963,
-0.0199071057,
-0.0650903732,
0.0325143561,
-0.0094671324,
-0.046853032,
0.0079391291,
-0.0015023495,
-0.0149271246,
0.0426571295,
0.0392592698,
-0.0190424323,
-0.0521417633,
-0.0274530258,
0.0163425934,
-0.0148650184,
-0.0061040809,
-0.0307993386,
-0.0868418142,
0.0041037109,
0.0511239134,
0.0237568095,
-0.0305433646,
0.0313659646,
-0.012529755,
0.0562222824,
-0.0273903422,
0.0962979272,
-0.0483912639,
0.0332642607,
-0.0487094373,
-0.0116681494,
0.0064925202,
-6.078221945e-33,
-0.0436400324,
-0.0320884399,
0.0123726251,
-0.0265086219,
-0.0260854606,
0.01330237,
-0.0037293897,
0.0300206468,
-0.0363027789,
0.0498017631,
0.0205206275,
0.0094932076,
0.0179963894,
0.0212862249,
0.0065147034,
-0.0431995727,
0.00507145,
-0.0056713824,
-0.0418475792,
0.0240516644,
0.0639005303,
0.0040724054,
0.0881429538,
-0.0937928185,
0.0285092033,
0.0632611513,
-0.0313816778,
-0.0411885381,
0.0454235934,
0.0229436923,
0.0144066596,
0.0098879933,
0.0206501856,
-0.0638372451,
0.0226404909,
0.1170729622,
-0.0195332598,
-0.0405690409,
-0.0125666652,
0.0219684318,
0.0418486111,
-0.0053131175,
0.0385169983,
0.0017435966,
-0.0291477703,
-0.0369441062,
0.0769754797,
0.0119474754,
0.0029906477,
-0.0192527249,
-0.0489121862,
0.0296750087,
-0.0540291332,
0.0364517495,
-0.0392216928,
0.0835865214,
0.06555859,
0.0713090077,
-0.0444578901,
0.0451621264,
-0.0148214875,
-0.0319621786,
0.015040786,
-0.0185638033,
0.0103700245,
0.1019987911,
0.0299846586,
0.0400605425,
-0.019578658,
0.0052339607,
0.0442560464,
0.0242736489,
0.047908023,
0.0808374062,
0.0365023986,
-0.0410849117,
-0.0487581678,
0.0211382173,
0.0673108101,
-0.0641186759,
-0.0196648128,
-0.0297031011,
0.0145513741,
-0.0078205839,
-0.0417379327,
-0.0607186928,
-0.0135908835,
0.0243946612,
0.0016048907,
0.0072941021,
-0.0455506556,
0.046081055,
0.0428117812,
-0.0615778826,
0.0027555933,
0.0022251057,
-0.0486648753,
0.0275819432,
-0.0217354279,
0.0102911806,
-0.0369533636,
-0.0442886166,
-0.0362826698,
0.0421486944,
0.0756900236,
-0.0077396599,
0.0438384674,
-0.0104786884,
-0.0759624988,
-0.0189418364,
0.0171890054,
-0.0178151987,
-0.0418003388,
0.0443465412,
0.0355006047,
0.0271220766,
-0.0066233096,
-0.051108487,
-0.005626318,
0.0068736318,
0.0030324468,
-0.0069250208,
-0.0213300437,
0.002559172,
-0.0243347138,
-0.0489111915,
-0.0323451832,
-0.0153605482,
0.0542299077,
-0.0579465814,
-0.0018220294,
-0.0413624085,
2.479e-7,
0.0777597129,
0.0371288918,
-0.0482053161,
-0.0084682787,
-0.0067978725,
0.0795801207,
0.0503725298,
0.0290828422,
-0.0439594835,
-0.0919154733,
-0.0170381181,
-0.0318170264,
0.0228507798,
0.0476279408,
-0.0394234918,
-0.012217937,
-0.0477124937,
0.0188870076,
-0.0666555986,
0.0410461016,
-0.0290912818,
0.0722271651,
0.0537143201,
-0.0161159504,
-0.0066960808,
0.0113895554,
0.0562993735,
-0.0227292497,
-0.0507833809,
0.0339407101,
-0.0415750891,
0.003061923,
0.0283301268,
0.0424745493,
-0.00133986,
0.0225820113,
-0.0000931075,
0.0533406399,
-0.0212745834,
-0.0133407088,
-0.0168884117,
-0.0345590599,
-0.0157577768,
-0.0010972777,
0.0435902327,
-0.0632369891,
-0.0129916174,
-0.0715478286,
-0.0668096095,
-0.0039121993,
0.0859575868,
0.0017563144,
-0.0005581045,
0.0242642369,
0.0093263276,
0.0078700539,
0.0028130352,
-0.0281995889,
-0.0170148704,
0.0250226278,
-0.0305641964,
-0.0280765928,
0.0189974625,
0.0111057805,
0.0147695867,
-0.0146048889,
0.0097980788,
2.258147377e-34,
0.026989134,
-0.0361796506,
-0.0445598289,
-0.0231454391,
0.0518670715,
-0.0146007556,
0.0190718193,
0.0157856662,
-0.0384229943,
-0.0466823317,
0.0260831062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12892v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12892v1 | ProtoEM: A Prototype-Enhanced Matching Framework for Event Relation Extraction | 2023-09-22T14:26:06 | 2023-09-22T14:26:06 | Zhilei Hu, Zixuan Li, Daozhu Xu, Long Bai, Cheng Jin, Xiaolong Jin, Jiafeng Guo, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Event Relation Extraction (ERE) aims to extract multiple kinds of relations
among events in texts. However, existing methods singly categorize event
relations as different classes, which are inadequately capturing the intrinsic
semantics of these relations. To comprehensively understand their intrinsic
semantics, in this paper, we obtain prototype representations for each type of
event relation and propose a Prototype-Enhanced Matching (ProtoEM) framework
for the joint extraction of multiple kinds of event relations. Specifically,
ProtoEM extracts event relations in a two-step manner, i.e., prototype
representing and prototype matching. In the first step, to capture the
connotations of different event relations, ProtoEM utilizes examples to
represent the prototypes corresponding to these relations. Subsequently, to
capture the interdependence among event relations, it constructs a dependency
graph for the prototypes corresponding to these relations and utilized a Graph
Neural Network (GNN)-based module for modeling. In the second step, it obtains
the representations of new event pairs and calculates their similarity with
those prototypes obtained in the first step to evaluate which types of event
relations they belong to. Experimental results on the MAVEN-ERE dataset
demonstrate that the proposed ProtoEM framework can effectively represent the
prototypes of event relations and further obtain a significant improvement over
baseline models. | [
0.0353484675,
0.0527991131,
-0.0189133584,
0.1013073772,
-0.0686648861,
-0.0084443791,
-0.0432961695,
0.0193187129,
0.0347867459,
-0.0380584411,
0.0212851595,
-0.0004484097,
-0.0168191213,
0.0778220817,
-0.0273077451,
-0.0598926395,
0.0266478918,
0.0646880791,
-0.033406157,
0.0483162291,
0.0252196006,
0.0648377463,
-0.0095948828,
0.0350975916,
-0.0330450311,
-0.0184691548,
-0.0047355397,
-0.0058046323,
0.0190411303,
-0.0615878552,
-0.0082782824,
0.0066842651,
0.019679267,
-0.020058183,
0.0000019295,
-0.0554552972,
-0.0258593541,
-0.0222016368,
0.0263785925,
-0.0125061218,
0.009675527,
-0.0288381856,
0.0037215461,
-0.01155922,
-0.0426451042,
-0.0647296458,
0.0332533792,
0.0666273758,
-0.01780474,
0.0575398393,
-0.0537716821,
-0.0369224511,
0.041622214,
-0.0097826971,
-0.0371010788,
-0.0137134166,
0.031619329,
-0.0138252042,
-0.0130240107,
-0.0303406641,
0.0144779077,
-0.0496057272,
0.0124579724,
0.0218980182,
0.0050561456,
0.0328716002,
-0.0302309208,
0.0227464084,
0.002151228,
0.077021271,
0.022481231,
-0.0294174366,
0.0451802872,
-0.0033107575,
-0.0045816726,
0.0140759395,
-0.0107285548,
-0.0139240753,
-0.0374801569,
0.0400315449,
0.0450697653,
0.0084740249,
0.0226087347,
-0.0007728938,
-0.025288403,
0.0422022156,
0.0052106455,
-0.0017101587,
-0.023418542,
0.0027884315,
-0.0108249225,
-0.0185684543,
0.054383412,
0.0371452495,
0.0131980032,
0.0166404024,
-0.0549284108,
0.0182859153,
-0.011555383,
-0.0802815035,
-0.0481077321,
0.0263819173,
0.0025408259,
0.0252259783,
-0.0186024196,
-0.0102685047,
-0.0077127242,
0.0232941993,
-0.0420893356,
0.004557583,
-0.0519098863,
0.0399799272,
-0.0441251881,
0.0569122471,
-0.0166798234,
-0.0380149372,
-0.0027129916,
0.0359979421,
0.0324454717,
0.0040336675,
-0.0404296927,
0.0159882624,
-0.0397583991,
-0.0022425752,
-0.0332249701,
-0.0298747569,
-0.0445021689,
0.0064953803,
-0.0423765816,
-0.0204547718,
0.0080065327,
0.0010261588,
0.0667837635,
-0.0137836384,
-0.0199629944,
0.0673694313,
0.018326994,
-0.0254784208,
-0.0559201799,
-0.0242909677,
0.0573901497,
-0.0009145844,
-0.031953495,
-0.0448514186,
0.0458344966,
-0.0026003227,
-0.0274298545,
-0.0282618795,
0.0286084469,
-0.0091704512,
-0.0538598038,
0.0391594395,
-0.0062110624,
0.0131133078,
-0.0121116703,
0.0091701364,
-0.0245944709,
0.0017070002,
0.0774435326,
0.0260051023,
0.0391302444,
0.0108730095,
-0.0340785272,
0.0306241997,
-0.0095057115,
-0.0512503348,
-0.0097367568,
0.0045671659,
0.0067167738,
-0.0036622267,
0.0354939997,
0.0096617453,
-0.015795799,
-0.0329728164,
0.0192985106,
0.0402006507,
-0.0129018482,
0.0485452525,
0.0271822754,
-0.0047467048,
0.0161831975,
0.049647063,
-0.0364080854,
-0.0324264988,
0.0147359185,
0.0012852497,
-0.0775012448,
0.0054326691,
-0.011551246,
0.0077487715,
0.0165859144,
-0.0220530368,
0.019448556,
-0.0186347924,
0.0649933591,
0.0057455963,
-0.0449885465,
0.0342711508,
0.0389288925,
0.0080260467,
0.0107394215,
0.0118909944,
-0.0249923225,
0.0388663076,
0.0601983629,
-0.0263675544,
-0.0623962991,
0.0092940293,
-0.0535894819,
0.0370619446,
0.0429798737,
-0.0319824927,
0.0217583608,
-0.0309004765,
-0.0065586595,
0.0106193312,
-0.0133821592,
0.0005194808,
0.0228426624,
0.0055649919,
0.0067551006,
0.0081376154,
0.0075501804,
0.0553427637,
0.0077702156,
-0.0277001821,
-0.0173524674,
0.0158307888,
0.0308870245,
-0.0079455422,
0.0134161683,
0.0046462356,
0.0626413748,
-0.0423325934,
0.0024022567,
0.0768792629,
-0.0388702117,
-0.033863809,
0.0367114916,
-0.0212969743,
-0.037224669,
0.0234568901,
-0.0519105904,
-0.0307704601,
0.0261094552,
0.0197052862,
0.0621643513,
-0.0102212178,
-0.0065873116,
-0.0060276655,
-0.0071023987,
-0.0141337058,
0.0646409318,
0.0342307836,
-0.0153664397,
-0.0358019099,
0.0143961627,
-0.0022770423,
-0.008996061,
-0.0288477428,
0.0096242381,
-0.0233500302,
-0.0184221342,
0.0176407862,
-0.0287839379,
-0.0505568124,
-0.0088476101,
-0.0507603176,
0.054067973,
0.0216024686,
0.0583253577,
0.0561250225,
0.021641735,
0.0006784949,
0.0031903558,
-0.023698559,
-0.0129168211,
-0.0157766175,
-0.0086318767,
0.0488742441,
0.0157580059,
-0.0090903696,
-0.0548305884,
0.0017709153,
-0.0675957128,
0.0762488246,
0.0283038076,
-0.031313926,
-0.0103655644,
0.0640944913,
-0.0056884191,
0.0395673811,
-0.0039321836,
-0.022017831,
-0.0276458617,
-0.0024315331,
0.0228945911,
-0.0026914463,
-0.003779677,
0.0474464484,
0.0167511385,
-0.0388344005,
-0.0236939415,
-0.0016361016,
-0.0651278272,
0.044461187,
0.0065108114,
0.0045634671,
-0.0080035534,
0.0093394732,
0.0323347747,
0.0209304262,
-0.0112006394,
-0.0218179598,
0.0173622798,
0.0374822766,
0.0130878659,
-0.0579869524,
-0.0265853927,
-0.0096284943,
-0.0569017567,
0.0185503513,
0.0833356678,
0.0235977396,
0.0203997511,
-0.0498570986,
-0.0007347618,
-0.0593337491,
0.0966501534,
-0.0086072721,
0.0149221923,
0.0078473259,
-0.0656622797,
-0.0314800367,
-0.035667751,
0.0240940098,
-0.015294916,
0.0166907571,
-0.0217952542,
0.0325670466,
-0.0127983131,
-0.000792922,
-0.0485448427,
-0.0032582025,
0.0248995014,
0.0017542889,
-0.0259818994,
0.0474615619,
-0.0137982881,
0.0358412713,
-0.0581053011,
0.002940946,
0.00356091,
-0.0040977178,
-0.0177447386,
0.0983823016,
0.058379963,
-0.0249081645,
-0.018186396,
0.0274745654,
0.0177137759,
0.0382368863,
0.0248995125,
-0.0158724412,
-0.0552347563,
-0.0013878515,
-0.0136173572,
-0.0587897748,
0.0171541646,
-0.0170361623,
-0.0294273403,
-0.0869663209,
0.0265778955,
0.0790598318,
0.0285307579,
-0.0482657813,
0.0257534739,
0.0325665139,
-0.0140124401,
0.0198699161,
-0.0050994521,
-0.0621401854,
0.0081713907,
-0.0121410163,
-0.0392952301,
0.0060577746,
-0.0495294854,
-0.0042274203,
-0.0484115556,
-0.0288248193,
0.0068893139,
-0.0503401347,
-0.0591593198,
-0.0596379675,
0.0177448448,
-0.0136432564,
-0.048925817,
-0.0043309894,
-0.0059525818,
-0.0160778984,
-0.0261097793,
-0.0472907722,
-0.0559591837,
0.0365762599,
-0.0330978818,
-0.0262057912,
-0.0120280273,
0.0446238257,
-0.0150879053,
0.0797142982,
0.0022685234,
-0.0765512362,
-0.0274677817,
-0.0096705109,
0.0380317569,
-0.0201871283,
0.0078952499,
-0.0290397611,
0.0350490957,
-0.0473082513,
-0.0394287854,
0.0107490001,
0.0808633491,
0.0071113207,
-0.0117021939,
-0.0217612162,
-0.0365788266,
0.0002034585,
0.0447455905,
-0.0047146068,
0.0191075522,
-0.0279798284,
0.0253175572,
0.0337177627,
-0.0518362634,
0.0195036773,
-0.0300078392,
-0.0050518629,
-0.0086189238,
-0.0597735159,
-0.0583468489,
-0.0095579261,
0.0070425197,
0.0024246359,
0.0275265817,
0.0502470657,
-0.0168287028,
-0.0908849165,
0.0637766868,
-0.0043888963,
-0.0054097334,
0.0356835648,
0.0156232016,
0.0334056094,
0.0148505429,
-0.0099540204,
0.0389168337,
-0.0208457373,
-0.0235468429,
-0.0318328068,
-0.0577087104,
0.0124384072,
0.0375751853,
-0.0311978217,
0.01484414,
-0.044714991,
0.0326864719,
-0.0308539961,
-0.0301668085,
-0.0099228313,
0.013954551,
-0.0223157573,
0.0204377323,
-0.0124823861,
0.0508398004,
-0.0224885829,
0.0480395854,
-0.0529760271,
-0.0859239027,
0.0257885661,
-0.0131261507,
0.0630045459,
0.0147215268,
-0.0102982586,
-0.0819707289,
-0.0026832416,
-0.0253615808,
0.0042136284,
-0.0212859493,
0.0497521833,
-0.0106379269,
0.0353749134,
-0.0229578502,
-0.066288583,
-0.0197677016,
0.0259599127,
0.0095387567,
-0.0031769653,
0.0477938727,
0.0113600697,
0.0120700719,
0.010059176,
-0.0316104814,
-0.0201949198,
-0.0089603104,
-0.0156195676,
-0.0789486766,
0.0093755024,
0.0367617495,
-0.0168411899,
-0.0330480598,
-0.0238172635,
-0.027958028,
0.0782800466,
-0.0373300985,
-0.006239743,
0.0867535323,
-0.0038217076,
-0.0115890624,
-0.0151123907,
0.0052538211,
0.0184677225,
0.0590633899,
-0.0188121665,
0.0008804679,
0.0379020981,
0.0089535201,
-0.0201480202,
0.0433715209,
0.0238883495,
-0.0197559111,
0.1017126814,
0.0359934829,
-0.0549461432,
-0.0428342856,
-0.0316698141,
0.040661864,
0.0423344001,
-0.0217925105,
-0.0086604254,
-0.0854038298,
0.0009178811,
0.0412974022,
-0.0208175573,
0.0005325813,
-0.016898239,
0.0232500769,
0.0309952013,
0.0557693392,
-0.0146752894,
-0.0032508192,
0.0566793196,
-0.0469006337,
-0.0332601108,
-0.036960125,
-5.551032197e-33,
-0.0274869855,
-0.0225673709,
0.0014835136,
0.0745117813,
-0.0535649285,
0.0303560533,
-0.0439219698,
-0.0657050312,
-0.028596757,
-0.0036035432,
0.0118648419,
-0.0090640327,
0.006156052,
-0.0396025255,
-0.0017510563,
-0.0181815382,
0.0309827495,
0.011631974,
0.0222866908,
0.0171089116,
0.0416040942,
0.0518681221,
0.0499412939,
-0.0886257961,
-0.0108574415,
-0.0214106645,
0.0172950085,
-0.0123033002,
0.0823378786,
0.0527541377,
-0.0406127907,
0.0177932624,
0.047096584,
0.0268457029,
0.025600262,
0.0295207594,
-0.1022054926,
-0.0459655002,
0.0047100512,
-0.0173019134,
0.0087047759,
-0.0283411909,
0.0321727283,
0.0071303048,
0.03138813,
-0.0175362788,
0.0635717288,
-0.0087490324,
-0.0233770348,
-0.0367683582,
-0.0711733177,
0.0518279821,
0.0137582505,
0.0183507558,
0.0362013057,
0.0018990557,
0.0377379283,
-0.0048092315,
-0.0313107036,
-0.0172768719,
-0.0865596831,
0.0121424897,
-0.0356896706,
-0.0006105718,
-0.0079291519,
0.0624291338,
-0.0507499911,
-0.0283801351,
-0.0032648982,
0.071877934,
0.0105382781,
0.0580562167,
-0.0189012028,
0.0222144909,
0.0314538553,
-0.0046237879,
-0.1089980304,
0.0529519133,
0.0638852641,
0.023688009,
-0.0298302043,
0.0096496418,
-0.013563632,
0.0006410129,
-0.0067302347,
-0.0022451126,
-0.0370864049,
-0.0430741645,
0.0149392923,
-0.0314023346,
0.0050618192,
0.1027829126,
-0.0224738289,
-0.0538525991,
-0.0294423457,
0.03912865,
-0.0246285088,
0.0260277074,
-0.0086795734,
0.0206953231,
-0.0460209139,
-0.0701720715,
-0.0008903972,
0.0036085432,
0.0438260809,
0.0212886855,
0.0111233061,
-0.0105590979,
0.0016241778,
0.0112674525,
-0.029838521,
-0.065273352,
-0.0372688547,
-0.0318715274,
0.0063907662,
0.0385073349,
0.009058062,
0.0175697301,
0.043217998,
0.0413488895,
-0.0113038057,
0.0014915281,
0.004683258,
0.0687507093,
0.016620893,
-0.0217173398,
-0.0189513136,
0.0460931249,
0.0300794896,
-0.0109931612,
-0.0232321806,
0.00069332,
2.57e-7,
0.0317184515,
0.0180701092,
0.0746964291,
0.0306540616,
-0.010365461,
0.0230156612,
-0.0082723629,
0.0711667314,
0.0055712909,
0.0230864435,
0.0144712552,
0.0170722306,
-0.0033175491,
0.0541407056,
-0.0513736308,
-0.0110801263,
-0.0505122766,
-0.0690192059,
-0.0648302808,
0.0338412039,
0.1206401438,
0.0406510755,
0.083587572,
0.0039713001,
-0.0503349043,
-0.0239804704,
0.0394748747,
-0.0090501374,
-0.0317399725,
0.0390964784,
-0.0564456433,
0.0308836959,
-0.0431345627,
0.040409822,
-0.0059772893,
0.0560411476,
0.0016212659,
0.0279254895,
-0.0383920446,
0.0444314852,
0.0018672827,
-0.0520207807,
0.0067919232,
-0.0234668143,
0.0556955971,
-0.052606795,
-0.015618383,
0.0075385836,
-0.0305851661,
0.032964766,
-0.0518581681,
0.0220652185,
-0.0398502052,
0.033085838,
0.020249689,
-0.0136760157,
-0.0392167382,
-0.0843280032,
0.0058826585,
0.0676015317,
0.016020054,
-0.0049242075,
0.0044107037,
0.0147604058,
0.0324528255,
-0.0341178253,
0.0139643056,
2.350590365e-34,
-0.024908293,
0.0149304699,
-0.0346359536,
0.0360480957,
0.0351147316,
-0.0482802875,
-0.0115748169,
0.04088239,
-0.0086016115,
-0.0280585065,
0.0226629656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12881v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12881v1 | Affect Recognition in Conversations Using Large Language Models | 2023-09-22T14:11:23 | 2023-09-22T14:11:23 | Shutong Feng, Guangzhi Sun, Nurul Lubis, Chao Zhang, Milica Gašić | cs.CL | cs.CL | Affect recognition, encompassing emotions, moods, and feelings, plays a
pivotal role in human communication. In the realm of conversational artificial
intelligence (AI), the ability to discern and respond to human affective cues
is a critical factor for creating engaging and empathetic interactions. This
study delves into the capacity of large language models (LLMs) to recognise
human affect in conversations, with a focus on both open-domain chit-chat
dialogues and task-oriented dialogues. Leveraging three diverse datasets,
namely IEMOCAP, EmoWOZ, and DAIC-WOZ, covering a spectrum of dialogues from
casual conversations to clinical interviews, we evaluated and compared LLMs'
performance in affect recognition. Our investigation explores the zero-shot and
few-shot capabilities of LLMs through in-context learning (ICL) as well as
their model capacities through task-specific fine-tuning. Additionally, this
study takes into account the potential impact of automatic speech recognition
(ASR) errors on LLM predictions. With this work, we aim to shed light on the
extent to which LLMs can replicate human-like affect recognition capabilities
in conversations. | [
0.0116711762,
0.048603259,
-0.0225615874,
0.0377740934,
-0.0162645467,
0.0435915962,
0.0137928231,
-0.0288953278,
0.0491583981,
-0.052049417,
-0.0600951351,
-0.0273139905,
-0.0099605294,
0.011589542,
0.0021933331,
-0.0394643359,
0.0016293748,
0.0257390775,
0.0654487684,
0.0175154638,
0.01789633,
0.0331439823,
-0.0116228405,
0.0420942418,
-0.0088167805,
-0.0228622481,
-0.0213961843,
0.0329566151,
0.0261866152,
-0.0215777978,
0.0419996157,
0.0537242405,
0.0159182735,
0.0034895076,
0.0000018665,
-0.0381118096,
0.0148358587,
-0.0330780819,
-0.04012914,
-0.0195612311,
0.0674633384,
-0.0168284941,
-0.0329172909,
0.013072649,
-0.0255329572,
0.0077819782,
0.0435698107,
0.0599425733,
0.0629192516,
0.0941476971,
-0.0347275101,
-0.0096778665,
0.0123559022,
-0.0161598437,
0.0148099503,
-0.0385255963,
0.0403988995,
0.0045005437,
0.0163082238,
-0.0483408011,
-0.0197461434,
-0.0026827219,
-0.0297535639,
-0.0095325839,
0.0143351164,
0.0100673223,
-0.0372650065,
-0.0371901356,
-0.0164338015,
0.0944702923,
0.0012127701,
0.0155643476,
-0.0027116705,
-0.0136099812,
0.01153633,
-0.0485025831,
-0.0433632471,
-0.0098239239,
0.0151312929,
0.0280424152,
-0.0008670379,
0.0188205224,
0.0198551733,
0.0381953083,
-0.0078558102,
0.0278879292,
-0.0322811678,
-0.0182625465,
0.0395510159,
0.0086255791,
-0.034532018,
-0.0343604237,
-0.0103468113,
0.0094126994,
-0.0397548564,
0.0240362044,
-0.0467164665,
-0.0011804397,
-0.0095261233,
-0.0530176982,
-0.0006558705,
0.0251833294,
-0.0373388976,
0.0398589112,
0.0468369685,
0.0518752374,
0.0403781608,
-0.0489703901,
-0.0113480231,
-0.0159879178,
-0.0525233448,
0.022950409,
0.0004473096,
0.0211001113,
-0.0604841709,
-0.0452371538,
-0.0801285207,
0.0200114269,
-0.0257959031,
0.0147578809,
0.0086811511,
-0.019236289,
-0.0030469792,
0.0000287287,
0.0169694535,
0.0391472317,
0.0012020145,
0.0283983778,
0.0028918032,
-0.0854940042,
0.0174954962,
0.0242844913,
0.0198135804,
-0.029742606,
0.0188734159,
0.0549008027,
0.0269777048,
-0.0725672916,
-0.0090703825,
-0.0193640608,
-0.0502232015,
-0.0791130438,
-0.002571316,
-0.0228205714,
0.0414084457,
0.0065381676,
0.0207439773,
-0.0344860144,
0.0201846045,
-0.0177573543,
-0.0302688126,
0.0634317324,
0.0005158308,
0.0030638771,
0.0064264047,
0.0133052589,
0.0168141406,
0.0631700233,
0.0136922412,
0.0300535932,
0.0539567694,
-0.0283965524,
0.0269099046,
0.0276377145,
-0.0156544,
-0.0280525088,
0.0060304399,
-0.0216629542,
-0.0139597626,
0.0302525256,
0.0405709371,
0.038320072,
-0.0290853735,
-0.0110100508,
0.0717696697,
0.0694313869,
-0.0154321864,
0.0425594151,
-0.0321931913,
0.0315126739,
0.0247603431,
-0.0334212482,
-0.0394113138,
0.0202127453,
-0.0246477071,
-0.0417565219,
0.009123995,
-0.0151274577,
-0.0362340137,
-0.035012044,
-0.0313753486,
-0.0174394399,
-0.0008050261,
0.0382514894,
0.0344269983,
-0.045020923,
-0.0428645089,
0.0038686988,
0.0373737514,
-0.0315974578,
-0.0311609935,
-0.0513075069,
-0.0091402279,
0.0715621412,
0.0085933823,
-0.0469405502,
-0.033493001,
-0.0186766963,
0.0231052954,
0.0336773433,
0.0386476815,
-0.0092200506,
0.0616022162,
-0.0307519678,
0.0515581034,
-0.0191559345,
0.0020300054,
-0.008888416,
-0.0297401398,
0.0287672933,
-0.0186178405,
-0.0091781411,
0.0074411957,
-0.0096498299,
-0.0530594364,
-0.0333346799,
0.0233551692,
0.0135564441,
0.0159577969,
0.0208696779,
-0.0284840353,
-0.0432057008,
-0.0027895716,
0.0008274675,
-0.0154217593,
0.0416225977,
-0.0398764871,
-0.0456455499,
0.0338497981,
0.0140608884,
-0.0142288813,
0.0035934364,
-0.0508661345,
-0.0188582744,
0.0267924201,
-0.0402478166,
0.0404212363,
-0.0285380278,
0.0371006466,
-0.0262609832,
0.0637403652,
-0.0002187337,
0.0279598869,
0.0023949095,
-0.0216092933,
0.0229061712,
-0.0164967962,
-0.0130238626,
-0.0358466581,
-0.0480546318,
0.0207766797,
0.0162517782,
-0.0027477902,
-0.0111307371,
-0.0092793433,
-0.0730797499,
-0.0601830967,
-0.1449650824,
-0.0020937105,
-0.0116388546,
-0.008228451,
-0.0004671221,
0.0127751948,
-0.0361951403,
0.0160507839,
-0.0295363013,
0.0257660393,
0.0289119538,
0.0102234008,
0.0212339424,
-0.0108631328,
-0.0046212729,
-0.0769366026,
0.016234694,
-0.0249575675,
0.0286803823,
-0.0236636344,
-0.0250356682,
-0.0214570239,
0.0215424933,
-0.0291302893,
0.0213097706,
-0.0181533284,
-0.0672412068,
-0.0139550893,
-0.0110906623,
0.0050406894,
0.1015336812,
0.0005310937,
0.1016867012,
-0.0098703234,
-0.0286545549,
-0.0140016926,
0.0382660367,
-0.0017748076,
0.0065938761,
-0.0502377339,
-0.0324885212,
-0.0323590003,
0.0606852993,
-0.0020738153,
0.0303183272,
-0.0333930254,
0.0150231235,
0.0166717209,
-0.0312936306,
-0.008599842,
-0.0049266056,
-0.0110694002,
0.0001157969,
0.0037264368,
-0.0491707884,
0.0263493676,
0.0235987119,
-0.0299774408,
-0.0441107191,
-0.0327627845,
-0.026960291,
0.0525579676,
-0.046780128,
-0.0004108922,
0.0105006816,
-0.0164974742,
-0.0157846957,
-0.0431964546,
-0.0484288894,
-0.0627807826,
0.0143495165,
-0.0401513763,
-0.0153518422,
0.0359667055,
-0.0564987659,
-0.0290531982,
-0.0544511937,
-0.0781072155,
0.0202438515,
0.0103654917,
-0.0209627878,
-0.0200109761,
-0.023323793,
0.0167482533,
-0.0228320174,
-0.0022515273,
-0.0202860106,
0.0109967869,
0.0199949797,
0.0643437803,
0.0119609563,
0.0293505136,
-0.0160539895,
0.0932620019,
0.0286193192,
0.0181166586,
0.0328468978,
-0.0095121898,
0.0282192826,
0.0205036681,
0.0329671428,
-0.0156284105,
-0.0143093001,
0.0644231513,
-0.0245103966,
-0.0001107875,
0.1701758355,
0.0303616095,
-0.0696430802,
0.0155074103,
-0.0283470377,
-0.0354576632,
0.0110724056,
0.0047424799,
-0.0486641787,
-0.0527463071,
0.0075469357,
0.0161202997,
-0.0336261019,
-0.0331974924,
0.0093443654,
-0.0960990936,
0.0282519087,
0.0101427622,
-0.0069837719,
-0.0320949592,
-0.0156791173,
0.0430411585,
-0.0179246683,
0.0188187305,
-0.0534179583,
0.0087048421,
-0.0477790795,
0.0189982876,
-0.0206033699,
-0.0904367715,
0.0765726715,
-0.0088778744,
0.0928336531,
0.0348257087,
0.1064391509,
0.0084342267,
0.021018004,
0.0368743949,
0.0099301049,
-0.0087669706,
-0.0089063477,
0.0544849671,
-0.0132382084,
-0.0117265098,
-0.0156566091,
0.0398026779,
-0.0265259985,
0.00464821,
-0.0105941389,
0.0651130602,
-0.0622527301,
-0.0244235471,
0.0140054831,
0.0199971944,
0.059772823,
0.0501483753,
0.0167294871,
-0.0561212972,
-0.0153891426,
0.0102798501,
0.0166908484,
0.0133031672,
-0.0258888062,
-0.0071244105,
0.0163578093,
-0.0155617883,
-0.0373977944,
-0.0651953146,
0.008459351,
-0.0064258296,
-0.0290537681,
-0.046924755,
-0.0100703416,
0.0355417542,
-0.0187884942,
0.0206151921,
0.0180992149,
0.0423017442,
-0.039625939,
-0.006212885,
0.0532398149,
-0.0303678531,
-0.005748109,
0.0077324989,
-0.0780667663,
-0.0470086448,
0.0116345398,
0.0144767333,
0.0152444076,
0.0071773855,
0.0139709925,
-0.0760670304,
0.0181530286,
0.0374896191,
-0.003023477,
0.026083922,
0.0336188786,
0.0410924107,
-0.0240670703,
0.031203948,
-0.0314177796,
0.0528944992,
0.0214711428,
-0.0045016496,
0.0025717013,
-0.0816929787,
-0.0279181916,
-0.0049399054,
0.0354539081,
0.0269734394,
-0.0524250232,
-0.0087137306,
-0.0112473983,
-0.0106542474,
0.0141714429,
-0.0468414947,
-0.0765819997,
0.0034468342,
0.0097748833,
-0.0578271672,
-0.0223126169,
-0.042403087,
-0.0143850073,
-0.0194188561,
0.0423437171,
0.0237091519,
-0.027150806,
0.0000249359,
0.030458618,
-0.0094771283,
0.0095264474,
0.0338720754,
0.012740952,
-0.0108915791,
0.0708659738,
0.0004609106,
-0.0098845297,
0.0208402723,
0.0378121659,
-0.0239765756,
-0.0040297452,
-0.0208826941,
0.0362948403,
0.0461194851,
-0.0283575095,
0.0543142855,
-0.0462529175,
0.021783324,
-0.0589979477,
0.0410860814,
-0.0347237028,
-0.021343274,
0.0079762861,
0.0078255339,
-0.0368916281,
0.0225350987,
0.0340030976,
-0.0318682864,
0.046725668,
0.0281331707,
-0.0129382173,
-0.0292144399,
0.0066453004,
0.0665683597,
-0.0308968071,
0.0065512797,
0.0431889817,
-0.0609838814,
-0.0761257038,
0.0469862297,
-0.0558247715,
-0.0042230319,
-0.0380025916,
0.0047297357,
0.0448961742,
-0.0133645553,
0.0372387134,
-0.0346262529,
0.01108413,
-0.0685527027,
-0.0255225878,
-0.023769686,
-5.663421947e-33,
0.0192084163,
-0.0042819092,
-0.04347587,
0.0208306853,
-0.0412435457,
0.0427467227,
-0.0398052596,
0.0245771129,
-0.0168427415,
0.0376487076,
-0.0256638136,
0.0651073232,
0.0040875422,
0.0303125903,
-0.004631205,
-0.0154506071,
0.0284674838,
-0.0206104405,
0.0104317944,
0.0307667907,
0.0125904167,
0.0429616645,
0.0425476953,
-0.0855526403,
0.0172537994,
0.0133302845,
-0.0044893986,
0.0002813622,
0.085540317,
0.034811262,
-0.0199988261,
0.0884289145,
0.0165901594,
0.006279483,
0.0056145797,
0.0342430621,
-0.0282660518,
-0.0032127083,
-0.019007137,
0.0056124306,
0.00100795,
-0.0311010312,
0.0055289473,
0.011444469,
-0.0333932377,
-0.0317492262,
0.0149206743,
-0.0175632183,
0.0180491228,
-0.0449795909,
-0.0402036533,
0.017791383,
-0.0551841222,
-0.047755003,
0.021326812,
0.0370879248,
-0.0030058664,
0.0366171636,
-0.0017874218,
0.0173485372,
-0.0324898623,
-0.0038784107,
0.0016175099,
-0.0146689117,
0.0124085322,
0.0934904367,
0.0516815074,
0.0471480563,
0.0086458446,
0.0099648917,
0.0238842797,
0.0451788865,
0.0080201477,
0.0564282089,
-0.0162330233,
-0.0068292059,
-0.0438846238,
0.001135961,
0.0565752834,
0.0220040958,
0.0528080054,
0.0001414734,
-0.0421891548,
-0.0075733038,
-0.0014180185,
0.0028739583,
-0.0186805557,
-0.0122454008,
0.0295468327,
-0.0229833256,
0.031951014,
-0.005885507,
0.0229214355,
-0.0527571477,
0.0060610892,
0.0454794578,
-0.0345214978,
0.0459120646,
-0.0013047863,
0.0152147114,
-0.0358562917,
-0.037486013,
0.0264720097,
0.0356162824,
0.0815959722,
-0.0074519948,
0.0004465145,
0.0393811278,
-0.0435487889,
-0.0127455462,
-0.0160565153,
0.0407513492,
-0.0210089087,
0.0493596792,
-0.020217279,
0.0108785508,
-0.0170334708,
0.0226013921,
-0.0129997926,
0.0444784164,
-0.0045660809,
-0.0505065657,
-0.0053973896,
0.0068279752,
-0.0665582865,
-0.0110169007,
0.002601471,
-0.0275872294,
0.0014922471,
-0.0276105516,
-0.0045665358,
-0.0382289104,
2.711e-7,
-0.0113537824,
0.0827542245,
-0.0138726914,
0.0036097716,
0.0461638272,
0.0414150171,
-0.0240370464,
0.0416637398,
0.058275938,
-0.0174273048,
0.0492525399,
0.0105606364,
0.1007085294,
0.0184900258,
-0.0947060809,
0.020227991,
-0.0239540394,
-0.0052206027,
-0.0142075187,
0.009401517,
0.0636567175,
0.1080317944,
0.0336133651,
-0.0034338452,
0.0169007387,
-0.0062868055,
0.0397572741,
-0.0593797788,
0.0016322258,
0.0304412395,
-0.0023020899,
-0.0118338903,
-0.0071136989,
0.0137437442,
-0.0040876991,
0.0128090773,
0.0068062269,
0.0781807899,
-0.0167082623,
-0.0551582053,
0.0047100787,
0.04973571,
-0.0169102196,
-0.0141032301,
0.0519553348,
-0.0890454128,
-0.0574495606,
-0.0414849706,
0.0067273295,
-0.0437498353,
0.0597406812,
-0.0248005707,
-0.0223561004,
0.0218884405,
0.0063084066,
-0.0266020205,
-0.011344756,
-0.0963213295,
0.0189307462,
0.0300905854,
-0.0537530631,
-0.0561456122,
-0.0068737706,
-0.0114216972,
0.0309855007,
-0.0390034094,
0.0345957093,
1.867165788e-34,
0.0296131484,
0.0169768855,
-0.0164722353,
0.0544670299,
0.0400341339,
0.0160438772,
-0.0225908086,
-0.0100453971,
0.0475972183,
-0.0878185928,
0.0262766853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12871v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12871v7 | AnglE-optimized Text Embeddings | 2023-09-22T13:52:42 | 2024-05-16T08:21:54 | Xianming Li, Jing Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | High-quality text embedding is pivotal in improving semantic textual
similarity (STS) tasks, which are crucial components in Large Language Model
(LLM) applications. However, a common challenge existing text embedding models
face is the problem of vanishing gradients, primarily due to their reliance on
the cosine function in the optimization objective, which has saturation zones.
To address this issue, this paper proposes a novel angle-optimized text
embedding model called AnglE. The core idea of AnglE is to introduce angle
optimization in a complex space. This novel approach effectively mitigates the
adverse effects of the saturation zone in the cosine function, which can impede
gradient and hinder optimization processes. To set up a comprehensive STS
evaluation, we experimented on existing short-text STS datasets and a newly
collected long-text STS dataset from GitHub Issues. Furthermore, we examine
domain-specific STS scenarios with limited labeled data and explore how AnglE
works with LLM-annotated data. Extensive experiments were conducted on various
tasks including short-text STS, long-text STS, and domain-specific STS tasks.
The results show that AnglE outperforms the state-of-the-art (SOTA) STS models
that ignore the cosine saturation zone. These findings demonstrate the ability
of AnglE to generate high-quality text embeddings and the usefulness of angle
optimization in STS. | [
0.0110963723,
0.014822579,
0.0126185874,
0.0642235801,
-0.0346779302,
0.0091473199,
0.021299826,
-0.0015810686,
-0.0090011135,
-0.0415520854,
-0.0438079275,
-0.0047436878,
0.0142474789,
-0.0024101806,
0.0400930196,
-0.0425862335,
0.0232782159,
0.0000416933,
-0.0166162457,
-0.0114927599,
0.0419549607,
0.0088856537,
0.0536027998,
0.0377184264,
0.0038463434,
-0.024550207,
0.0402544774,
0.0146374535,
0.0338201262,
-0.036788933,
0.0200221986,
0.0013004051,
0.0584070608,
0.023586981,
0.0000020483,
0.0034721883,
-0.0040938957,
0.0127940113,
0.011137113,
0.0349310338,
0.0791031942,
-0.02692548,
0.0062148427,
0.0179403666,
-0.0041700685,
-0.0339232013,
0.0218935553,
0.0368134156,
0.0275774468,
0.0638542026,
-0.015381352,
-0.0323164202,
0.0142600453,
-0.0470862202,
0.0045140809,
-0.0179822855,
0.0176218245,
0.0322855487,
0.0028918379,
0.0802438706,
-0.020551078,
0.0481535643,
0.0183778536,
0.022150388,
0.028841516,
0.0614708774,
0.006874952,
0.0336947292,
0.0277778842,
0.0630985051,
-0.074445568,
-0.0532889552,
0.0195569936,
-0.0190450903,
-0.0337724201,
-0.0098698847,
-0.0483805984,
-0.0103546921,
0.0232014693,
0.0650283247,
-0.0008686144,
0.0453146212,
0.0363938138,
0.0089090019,
-0.013172931,
-0.0108247641,
0.0256082043,
-0.054132048,
-0.0464373939,
-0.0163085964,
-0.0549663864,
-0.032637503,
0.023052793,
0.0011236714,
0.0113181723,
0.0164416581,
-0.0651391894,
-0.0288134571,
0.0233878158,
-0.0546621159,
0.0086213062,
0.0480569303,
0.0233103223,
0.0708561838,
-0.0592686683,
0.0367286019,
-0.0215471964,
0.0312818736,
-0.0657245219,
-0.0238891672,
-0.0390805304,
-0.0118890693,
-0.0311565939,
0.0089300824,
-0.0091422554,
-0.0380427912,
0.0301439594,
0.0235500149,
0.0106356628,
0.0124886055,
0.0084594646,
-0.0068090116,
0.0009986764,
-0.0288832691,
0.0334585905,
0.0112710586,
-0.0182423852,
-0.0019491314,
-0.0154681979,
0.0105501385,
0.0007584162,
0.0471847802,
0.0310846865,
-0.0180350877,
0.0047267065,
0.008710729,
0.0029348307,
-0.0533009991,
-0.0169809405,
-0.0181935895,
-0.002011745,
-0.0102557912,
-0.0286316164,
-0.0839786828,
0.034085568,
0.0021893755,
0.0017283425,
-0.043715626,
-0.0020805404,
0.065320529,
-0.0520508252,
0.0641263947,
0.0028607682,
0.0198972039,
0.0383775271,
0.0281370878,
-0.0095676593,
0.0491660796,
0.0021879654,
0.0444591194,
0.0456647649,
0.0283431597,
-0.0380748957,
0.0204892624,
0.0303922463,
0.0242872927,
0.0026253643,
0.0104288524,
-0.0101184417,
0.0515412651,
0.0413519628,
0.0783053115,
-0.0378595218,
-0.0446270704,
0.0432055555,
0.0678538084,
0.029054286,
0.0026121119,
0.0421878099,
0.0596067123,
-0.0174511261,
-0.0147290686,
-0.0175563823,
-0.0158428084,
0.0007426213,
0.0109148873,
0.0642652363,
0.0336480699,
-0.0575266853,
0.0010520607,
-0.02942634,
-0.0366783366,
-0.0295610223,
-0.015494003,
0.0236054063,
0.0041740267,
-0.0495144092,
-0.0018491088,
0.0273294561,
-0.0518753491,
0.0188925657,
0.0114188679,
0.0453842059,
0.064711228,
0.0760773718,
-0.0101656523,
-0.0335497782,
0.0038823613,
0.0229248554,
0.0486635715,
0.0236316044,
-0.0088173859,
0.0002024666,
-0.0824944004,
-0.0609905832,
0.0130421901,
0.0037302051,
0.002795828,
0.0109036034,
0.030027952,
0.0563847125,
-0.0416035317,
-0.0484250002,
0.05092825,
-0.052143544,
-0.0031565505,
-0.030910382,
-0.0019427586,
-0.0187347159,
0.0057524568,
-0.0165988505,
0.0174693502,
0.0182818547,
-0.0793835446,
-0.0540975966,
-0.038453076,
-0.0748453811,
-0.0641006976,
0.0192672908,
-0.0918852612,
0.0094624115,
0.0171021502,
-0.046002537,
-0.0135618094,
-0.0139667178,
-0.0174932089,
0.0043922965,
-0.014192827,
0.0188900419,
-0.0281803068,
0.0192632265,
-0.0623263419,
0.0427381843,
-0.0049835611,
0.0268052742,
0.0065356619,
0.0134373335,
0.0356947519,
0.0090014264,
-0.0534984581,
-0.0024925701,
0.0318834633,
0.0278578382,
0.022941241,
0.0175471622,
0.0139251305,
-0.0277267024,
-0.0791042149,
0.0329448134,
-0.005507037,
0.0116734318,
0.0250724666,
0.0065849964,
-0.0089200763,
-0.0119622909,
-0.027510345,
-0.0362009369,
-0.0309782159,
0.0298110377,
0.0313742198,
-0.026614055,
-0.0042844163,
-0.0621123053,
-0.0091788489,
0.0002515028,
0.0528325401,
-0.0154307913,
0.0029178245,
-0.0574594922,
0.0813577399,
-0.0014144019,
0.0019097268,
-0.0085689891,
0.014792541,
-0.0447190776,
0.0030783592,
0.0726651773,
0.036700096,
0.0101947039,
-0.0323761478,
0.0312076639,
0.0241892394,
-0.0705807433,
-0.0216051023,
-0.0394146331,
0.035625983,
-0.0222760178,
-0.0520366058,
0.0401020385,
0.0514478013,
0.0091191065,
-0.0028011838,
-0.0577990673,
0.0039454093,
-0.0474608652,
0.0227832757,
-0.0394285955,
0.0083517842,
0.0051973471,
-0.039413482,
-0.0345591977,
-0.0346064791,
0.062308833,
-0.0549238957,
-0.0064851586,
-0.0619865656,
-0.0122414613,
-0.0757751167,
0.0114362529,
-0.0065479204,
0.0192266311,
-0.0135907801,
0.0283350348,
-0.0222481899,
0.0086743608,
0.008486853,
-0.025254216,
0.0439851955,
0.0314899571,
-0.0073262658,
-0.0261122808,
-0.0310823582,
-0.0210166629,
-0.0571421273,
-0.028101407,
-0.0042863837,
0.0536089353,
0.0109666372,
0.007640529,
0.0272883046,
-0.0007256992,
0.0547209382,
-0.0049490184,
-0.0248550214,
-0.0492389053,
0.0168887824,
0.0650294721,
-0.0367394164,
-0.0195512734,
0.0168277193,
0.0147220921,
0.0174490213,
0.0125146303,
0.001614532,
-0.0353537314,
-0.0414719321,
0.0345831886,
-0.0063268235,
-0.0275089182,
-0.0519626588,
0.0264358819,
-0.0313443802,
0.0133597981,
0.1065833941,
0.0428171866,
-0.0826605558,
-0.0116490284,
-0.0296148211,
0.0724018589,
0.001123306,
0.0155880768,
-0.0562098697,
-0.0388756022,
0.0009388251,
-0.0010754415,
0.0363198519,
0.0155997705,
-0.0122731347,
-0.0853105187,
-0.0107584558,
0.0085386578,
0.0167027526,
-0.0653752387,
-0.04696301,
0.011687737,
0.0007594374,
0.016973028,
-0.012516791,
-0.0116251288,
0.0095743956,
0.0061582252,
-0.0369468704,
-0.0529436655,
-0.0052766697,
-0.0588321015,
0.0286872983,
0.0408623181,
0.056881018,
0.0314808823,
-0.0506643243,
0.029857086,
-0.0434997231,
-0.0248094816,
-0.0285444967,
0.0321208797,
-0.0221846402,
0.0096527347,
-0.0060335682,
0.0115617504,
-0.0361960307,
0.0064837392,
0.0228765085,
0.0838037655,
0.0086088516,
0.0081051784,
-0.0492737703,
-0.0265254155,
0.0024481553,
0.0818397626,
0.0445287377,
-0.043376565,
-0.0329786055,
-0.006403591,
0.0160352029,
-0.0298309084,
-0.042451825,
-0.0063418844,
0.0066431756,
0.0099727307,
-0.0798527151,
-0.0219025705,
-0.0122958058,
0.009601282,
-0.0024738952,
0.0115233427,
-0.0102201421,
-0.0635400638,
-0.0111721139,
0.0111095402,
-0.0723538026,
0.0403275639,
-0.0220287107,
0.050253097,
0.0361610427,
-0.0391101874,
-0.0324418619,
-0.0318103768,
-0.0735579357,
-0.0421641618,
-0.0404811502,
-0.0071013994,
-0.0006285119,
0.0463319644,
-0.048987627,
-0.0579488911,
0.0868746638,
0.028843388,
-0.0047353064,
0.0100707393,
0.0157677904,
0.0258119199,
0.0136238467,
0.0433649495,
-0.0248600524,
0.0144271944,
-0.0007916166,
0.0166497435,
0.0193765275,
-0.0187805202,
-0.0068584196,
-0.0219246373,
0.0606678016,
0.0008615154,
-0.0199264921,
-0.0395219475,
0.0078839064,
-0.0229068603,
-0.002712541,
-0.0317292362,
0.0309890974,
0.0409477986,
-0.0141383717,
-0.0115566337,
0.0632452741,
0.0321860202,
0.0496504791,
-0.0302573331,
0.0374069363,
-0.0257018078,
0.0416357964,
-0.0107110748,
0.0229353067,
-0.0136222774,
-0.0055325129,
-0.0465810299,
-0.004218542,
-0.0532531328,
0.0010701312,
0.0335128903,
-0.0399117805,
-0.0161485728,
0.0760931149,
-0.0474221334,
-0.0302701648,
-0.014996428,
-0.0098533724,
0.0526150353,
-0.0059070261,
0.0695066005,
-0.0108171329,
-0.0252368674,
-0.0208476763,
-0.0011166771,
-0.0116612352,
0.0037221333,
0.0256887469,
0.0119160032,
-0.0244164672,
0.0067324,
0.0860299319,
0.0286554955,
0.0281426571,
0.0031726889,
-0.0288225617,
-0.0096292822,
0.0217855275,
0.0539448969,
0.0336097889,
-0.0398922153,
-0.003760308,
-0.0385055318,
-0.0370766148,
0.0135084679,
-0.0127654057,
-0.0675704256,
0.0274046902,
0.0323897675,
0.0327928774,
-0.0323155113,
0.017210599,
-0.0266631655,
0.0139781572,
-0.0142576853,
-0.0621568859,
-0.0086452402,
-6.340585672e-33,
-0.0068521327,
-0.0017693101,
0.0075755357,
0.0078961048,
-0.0534540825,
0.0392702855,
-0.0266441219,
-0.0222597662,
-0.0331089124,
0.0122990627,
0.0143474275,
-0.0038397007,
-0.0012493011,
0.0397386551,
-0.041459959,
-0.0181956347,
0.0333678387,
0.0200778767,
-0.0185578503,
0.0373893268,
0.0155776162,
0.016760584,
0.0131717483,
-0.0686168671,
-0.0209496729,
-0.0171613283,
0.0140561983,
-0.0107588293,
0.0427284464,
0.0560069643,
-0.0587308519,
0.0517868325,
0.0185108539,
-0.0202811249,
-0.0617189109,
0.0197461993,
-0.0328041725,
-0.0297753066,
-0.0107981088,
-0.0338700637,
-0.0415790379,
-0.0219583791,
0.0252084825,
-0.0003273889,
-0.0130204307,
-0.0113333873,
0.0602346063,
0.0076897712,
-0.055426266,
0.0148089631,
-0.0671095178,
0.0723266006,
0.012053323,
-0.0482647344,
0.0554522313,
0.0516836196,
0.0359393209,
0.1012666449,
-0.0553289466,
0.009260864,
-0.0688063651,
0.051367972,
0.0330512151,
-0.0070283646,
0.0215038005,
0.0545164645,
0.023537863,
-0.022025954,
-0.0173171721,
-0.0417265929,
0.0403978266,
0.0029046186,
0.0519631244,
0.0490894392,
0.0208505318,
-0.0171894487,
-0.0157211442,
0.0363368541,
-0.0483598597,
-0.002555293,
0.0427609719,
0.0641270578,
-0.0657578185,
-0.0279866774,
-0.0529111624,
-0.0402290411,
-0.0306996424,
-0.0126326829,
0.0253470745,
0.0489772409,
-0.0123358667,
0.0560427904,
0.037210837,
-0.0396610126,
-0.002898298,
0.0239387173,
-0.0111936284,
0.0162777677,
0.0059092892,
0.0302105285,
-0.0581636354,
-0.040770907,
0.0167249236,
0.0025134985,
-0.0166313332,
-0.0277537312,
0.0780837759,
0.0097032366,
-0.0623352528,
-0.0039725397,
-0.0296326783,
-0.0741102248,
-0.0329018123,
-0.0065895943,
0.0055453568,
0.0029604996,
0.0122680161,
0.0902366266,
0.0709948316,
-0.0046410742,
-0.0232177135,
-0.0384445973,
-0.0141661325,
0.0132297669,
-0.0008755513,
0.027623605,
-0.0235703196,
-0.0063652555,
0.0077622216,
-0.0598112009,
-0.0255387258,
-0.0188015997,
2.605e-7,
0.0451260954,
0.0319970474,
0.0278445575,
0.0137742776,
0.0182204694,
0.0540842935,
0.0331651606,
0.0346688032,
-0.0309631489,
0.0275446717,
0.0105749434,
0.0080096256,
0.0407593027,
-0.0111254435,
-0.0655101314,
0.0724309832,
-0.0673514307,
-0.0252030194,
-0.0508566089,
-0.022489449,
0.0656122863,
0.117709294,
0.0322872177,
0.0090960823,
0.0050921561,
-0.0396008566,
0.0638882443,
-0.0388616845,
-0.00265228,
0.0350753367,
-0.0007440514,
0.0108872168,
0.0131584015,
-0.0473649651,
-0.0150428666,
0.0295902975,
0.0636678785,
0.0611616373,
0.0049567376,
0.0136950091,
-0.0104931574,
-0.0278365165,
-0.0223336592,
-0.0877992585,
0.0884287134,
-0.0429438613,
0.0129551254,
-0.0473851524,
0.0092326142,
0.0426151976,
0.0485742874,
0.0155753018,
-0.0520908646,
-0.0124235777,
0.0455894358,
-0.0025559478,
-0.0256995261,
-0.080070816,
-0.0259928908,
-0.0043844413,
-0.0638566315,
0.0002327143,
-0.0754644945,
0.0305134058,
0.0569222979,
-0.0266553741,
0.0199002624,
2.898365452e-34,
0.0206762776,
-0.0214290153,
-0.0189029668,
-0.0053648301,
0.0105237812,
-0.0046784445,
-0.020310415,
-0.0057237293,
0.010452088,
-0.0611784272,
0.0106847491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12863v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12863v1 | Domain Adaptation for Arabic Machine Translation: The Case of Financial Texts | 2023-09-22T13:37:19 | 2023-09-22T13:37:19 | Emad A. Alghamdi, Jezia Zakraoui, Fares A. Abanmy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Neural machine translation (NMT) has shown impressive performance when
trained on large-scale corpora. However, generic NMT systems have demonstrated
poor performance on out-of-domain translation. To mitigate this issue, several
domain adaptation methods have recently been proposed which often lead to
better translation quality than genetic NMT systems. While there has been some
continuous progress in NMT for English and other European languages, domain
adaption in Arabic has received little attention in the literature. The current
study, therefore, aims to explore the effectiveness of domain-specific
adaptation for Arabic MT (AMT), in yet unexplored domain, financial news
articles. To this end, we developed carefully a parallel corpus for
Arabic-English (AR- EN) translation in the financial domain for benchmarking
different domain adaptation methods. We then fine-tuned several pre-trained NMT
and Large Language models including ChatGPT-3.5 Turbo on our dataset. The
results showed that the fine-tuning is successful using just a few well-aligned
in-domain AR-EN segments. The quality of ChatGPT translation was superior than
other models based on automatic and human evaluations. To the best of our
knowledge, this is the first work on fine-tuning ChatGPT towards financial
domain transfer learning. To contribute to research in domain translation, we
made our datasets and fine-tuned models available at
https://huggingface.co/asas-ai/. | [
0.0035308923,
0.0410859697,
-0.0164870173,
0.0195637029,
-0.0331985652,
0.0285807084,
0.0602750927,
0.0175461713,
-0.0528218299,
-0.0151973078,
-0.0587418415,
-0.0544859245,
0.0027511101,
0.0125785349,
0.0217829924,
-0.0206155423,
0.0193275064,
-0.0290683508,
-0.0076856213,
-0.0115215443,
0.027658388,
0.016833473,
0.0125789689,
-0.0061394949,
0.0196763948,
0.0088519324,
0.0183534604,
-0.0048948261,
0.0395597629,
0.0221173093,
-0.0028792808,
0.0095974812,
0.0080442885,
0.0357636064,
0.0000020633,
-0.0505445935,
-0.0767150447,
0.0068211616,
0.0207303576,
0.024608979,
0.0578765348,
-0.0697325394,
-0.0071434267,
0.0245956965,
-0.0392227359,
0.0083661843,
0.0469679125,
0.0448215976,
0.0637278631,
0.1178901792,
-0.0351946801,
-0.0486034602,
-0.0226471853,
-0.0829147473,
-0.0412388667,
-0.1142974719,
0.0010916727,
0.0310897995,
-0.0484667383,
0.0283191837,
-0.0232406966,
0.0287274588,
-0.0042543807,
-0.0311846938,
-0.0215193462,
-0.033437524,
-0.0363845862,
-0.0021938784,
0.0025860968,
0.037048988,
-0.0178047363,
0.0156596564,
0.0159162208,
-0.0261399671,
0.0306537636,
0.0157042183,
-0.0533649623,
0.0445436575,
-0.0302958172,
0.0024488322,
0.0262926668,
0.0270402562,
0.0158592369,
-0.0213933326,
-0.0607153624,
-0.0114751495,
0.0184134375,
-0.003482098,
0.0413117036,
0.0144422054,
-0.0366572216,
0.0087347971,
0.0477483086,
-0.0369621776,
0.0383849405,
0.0001394746,
-0.0721342266,
-0.0364708863,
-0.0369567461,
-0.0998915508,
0.0197140388,
0.0814317092,
-0.0008707125,
0.0318931602,
-0.0573418103,
0.0163869094,
-0.0136713171,
-0.0088226423,
-0.0643659905,
0.0095272036,
-0.0750310197,
0.0401022695,
-0.0511431731,
0.0367189646,
-0.0591463782,
0.0054190811,
-0.0632904619,
-0.0044794092,
0.0165291112,
-0.025442902,
0.0200043991,
-0.0615506545,
-0.0550606623,
-0.0490808114,
0.0099394126,
0.0425143279,
-0.0027730553,
-0.0019074106,
-0.0048892293,
-0.0258639473,
-0.0208959542,
0.0305686872,
-0.0125147393,
-0.0298277028,
-0.0172273424,
0.0884385332,
-0.035140276,
-0.0449792221,
-0.0448160693,
0.0388675183,
-0.0272250921,
-0.0031545947,
0.0550810136,
-0.0025288486,
0.0406491309,
-0.002051407,
0.0064535784,
-0.0298933871,
-0.0239992533,
-0.0165442303,
-0.0025314172,
0.0477223434,
0.0363389887,
-0.0425345637,
0.0387232676,
-0.0083189262,
-0.0258033033,
0.0745233968,
0.0268591233,
0.0067998064,
-0.017446626,
-0.0212618094,
-0.0391143672,
0.0372597948,
0.0278343204,
-0.0032920034,
0.0135404496,
-0.0020775257,
-0.0003728723,
0.0525839515,
0.0383426175,
-0.0162374433,
-0.0033660023,
-0.0106483884,
0.0713829473,
-0.0223859195,
0.0406626053,
0.0519662984,
-0.0082760705,
0.0156280771,
0.0380553007,
-0.0106481491,
0.0036835701,
0.0126967337,
0.0052079116,
0.0232139919,
-0.0109781316,
0.0527547374,
-0.0111305891,
-0.0129192416,
0.020254869,
0.0018788619,
-0.004757565,
-0.0372886807,
0.069846496,
0.0214462113,
-0.0557316206,
0.0236658286,
-0.0050284369,
0.0270630233,
0.0192185771,
-0.0394216478,
-0.0243986323,
0.0228817612,
0.0133561958,
-0.0011116096,
-0.0261811223,
-0.0357687362,
0.0063923923,
0.0696354583,
0.0458668135,
0.027803069,
-0.0019645833,
-0.0465765819,
-0.0194835439,
0.0155828791,
0.0363777131,
0.0411792062,
-0.02556278,
0.0707424879,
0.019050058,
-0.0370556153,
-0.0029291119,
0.0257252604,
-0.0347496793,
-0.0243869536,
0.0463764407,
-0.0207053293,
0.003172403,
0.0249233544,
-0.0364033394,
-0.0233578645,
-0.0448255017,
-0.0241764523,
-0.0617887154,
0.0132022286,
-0.0529202893,
0.0111338254,
0.0051303371,
-0.0417860411,
0.0308973435,
0.0158583932,
-0.0540054925,
-0.0415696949,
0.0130245164,
-0.0136920922,
0.0025968393,
-0.0351701304,
0.0357552432,
0.0032870881,
0.0448252633,
-0.0329183489,
0.0311520677,
0.0225471202,
-0.0643104538,
-0.0444552265,
-0.0247890875,
0.0348114446,
0.0045198319,
0.0615455508,
0.0266359877,
-0.0198052861,
0.0455727801,
0.0656905845,
0.0289684143,
-0.0063087367,
-0.0144823929,
-0.0115254,
0.0018803693,
-0.007508521,
0.0847246945,
0.0062717386,
0.0373314396,
-0.0246570706,
0.0157902073,
-0.0215214211,
0.0161320884,
-0.0414298251,
0.0005248675,
0.0514065437,
-0.0140668293,
0.0306856669,
-0.0330826305,
-0.0038801192,
0.0235481001,
0.0270805657,
0.0156522915,
-0.0451503061,
-0.0229333993,
0.0143571207,
0.0200640261,
-0.0152470702,
-0.0075020678,
0.010934026,
-0.0006683895,
-0.0136281541,
0.0112387342,
0.034822572,
0.0059618531,
0.0245292932,
-0.0436127447,
0.0158669446,
-0.0381241664,
0.0223544259,
0.0017189179,
-0.0255464278,
-0.0336701348,
-0.0041168421,
0.0218673516,
0.0175777897,
-0.0258525293,
-0.0177439395,
-0.0706094727,
0.0228354577,
-0.0247564539,
0.0219038446,
-0.0003447178,
0.0567535982,
0.018744044,
0.0737177283,
0.0173165947,
-0.0173583757,
0.0072952802,
0.0049090544,
0.0207838491,
-0.0631240234,
-0.0039506438,
-0.0565603822,
-0.017647922,
-0.0501748435,
0.0023969177,
-0.0031733722,
-0.046915397,
-0.0213132855,
-0.0189232621,
0.0597742163,
0.0045158025,
0.0078499876,
-0.0403677411,
0.014785368,
-0.0472683571,
0.0047999676,
0.0089567741,
-0.0249753669,
-0.0137958499,
-0.0123635577,
0.0491270013,
-0.0509466678,
-0.0732261315,
0.0135475835,
-0.0091792438,
0.0441547371,
-0.0156001151,
-0.0143005727,
0.0075256014,
0.012405864,
0.0551123396,
0.0063158623,
0.0377423689,
-0.0373536982,
0.0284626614,
-0.0088844635,
-0.0667303428,
-0.0118926177,
-0.0449618176,
-0.0177435782,
0.0217077881,
-0.0368702263,
-0.0208331775,
-0.0407063365,
0.0084634032,
-0.0095970277,
0.0091411192,
0.0827802196,
-0.0144166509,
-0.0034103496,
-0.0004895994,
0.0076057655,
-0.0142915146,
-0.0507432595,
0.0343167111,
-0.1080741808,
-0.0263811778,
0.0097923093,
0.0140853273,
0.0676498339,
-0.0040380913,
-0.017820362,
-0.0770146772,
0.0146235311,
0.0066386028,
-0.0746812597,
-0.0517390668,
-0.0148732523,
-0.0202114005,
-0.0765455216,
0.0328888409,
-0.0512256734,
-0.0169815551,
0.0367172137,
0.0316416807,
0.0207301732,
-0.0482167006,
-0.0178869963,
-0.0228085928,
-0.0069098966,
0.0495323613,
0.0125745386,
-0.0309188906,
-0.0005621657,
0.0164307281,
0.0031298781,
-0.0213216897,
-0.0062953825,
0.0337801091,
-0.012074979,
-0.0082369139,
0.0304463468,
-0.0081084548,
-0.0359520763,
0.0500147045,
0.0320498496,
0.0097867772,
-0.0042250184,
-0.0267410688,
0.0103895152,
-0.0143103432,
-0.0326810479,
0.0435977653,
-0.0290663559,
-0.0666881353,
0.0089738341,
-0.0016841867,
-0.0466028638,
-0.0779467374,
0.0139412163,
-0.0040095262,
-0.0263002906,
-0.0111073051,
-0.0939949676,
-0.0443157852,
-0.009413708,
0.060358569,
0.0148135489,
-0.0193572138,
0.0490157381,
0.0066407342,
0.0057982905,
-0.0038849332,
-0.0415944047,
0.000793372,
-0.0349849537,
0.0470713153,
0.0192808248,
-0.0871702731,
-0.019742446,
0.0107888887,
-0.07243862,
-0.0299377181,
-0.0041893646,
0.0057174438,
0.0124200173,
0.0038326019,
-0.0367748067,
0.0117666349,
0.0345399268,
0.0325448699,
-0.0455815978,
-0.0073915208,
0.0432575233,
-0.0088622365,
-0.0462502241,
0.02860572,
0.0109536489,
0.0361801572,
0.0148625802,
0.0068858601,
0.0528535247,
-0.0257603154,
-0.0052165375,
-0.002671401,
0.0214437321,
-0.0039238189,
-0.0644624755,
-0.0345595293,
0.0211943518,
-0.0094571812,
0.0423459522,
-0.0462082364,
-0.047978688,
0.0752282441,
0.0274726804,
-0.0043779518,
0.0012927923,
-0.0056430157,
-0.0316414163,
-0.0072088991,
-0.0037477517,
-0.0427716859,
0.0431058109,
-0.0222127084,
0.0246534273,
0.0408568941,
-0.053582143,
0.0303674079,
0.0164008643,
-0.0286381282,
0.0121780923,
0.0090706274,
0.0365220122,
0.0395806283,
0.0182108153,
-0.0174161904,
0.0131608769,
-0.0268904828,
0.0466677621,
0.0497089066,
-0.0445213839,
0.0881869122,
-0.0088391881,
0.00538059,
-0.0054078489,
0.0358729623,
0.0167716034,
0.0281840321,
-0.0129780062,
-0.0339887291,
-0.010973148,
0.0080510685,
0.0596185774,
0.0116846152,
-0.0214534756,
0.0016395528,
-0.0016068693,
-0.0209962651,
-0.0121871848,
0.0163214151,
-0.0381260552,
-0.0008964016,
0.0122557571,
-0.050427407,
-0.0346682295,
-0.0146511262,
-0.0191533752,
0.0123804836,
0.0036905222,
0.0009340719,
0.0863671973,
-0.0203280393,
-0.001874176,
-0.0173801538,
0.0014733085,
-0.0083824145,
-0.0091024749,
-0.0522744507,
-6.359555946e-33,
-0.025019329,
0.005164647,
0.0414952785,
0.0026772548,
-0.0073955222,
-0.0280566551,
-0.0175923593,
-0.0509275161,
-0.0025082128,
0.015186172,
-0.0064869211,
0.0357933715,
0.0291858278,
0.0199259929,
0.0086310357,
0.0041622096,
0.035241928,
-0.01658036,
-0.0399740301,
0.0146657098,
0.002405552,
0.0640908778,
0.1022734493,
-0.0601602122,
0.0061290497,
0.0255879182,
-0.0427312031,
0.0020361403,
0.0561540201,
0.009714881,
0.02448586,
0.0178444292,
0.0127464216,
-0.1112763211,
-0.001870089,
-0.0384798497,
-0.0563586242,
-0.0080883643,
0.0286570657,
0.0688925236,
0.0596340038,
-0.024750907,
0.0032134275,
-0.0024102279,
-0.0063214889,
-0.0532851629,
0.009009772,
-0.0281360541,
0.0050795316,
-0.0191895235,
-0.1115696952,
0.0585847944,
-0.0012895226,
0.0342316628,
0.042689275,
0.0613509975,
-0.0166644007,
-0.0047499468,
-0.0238420684,
-0.0129740732,
-0.0170120206,
0.0408040658,
0.0472981222,
-0.0022597208,
-0.0750799403,
-0.0139602022,
-0.0200817417,
0.0236683711,
0.0640245751,
0.0252040811,
0.0246278923,
-0.0088532176,
0.0505389199,
0.0682485253,
0.0302551538,
-0.0305519104,
-0.0598283671,
0.0683847293,
-0.0415911786,
-0.0101089478,
0.0016436055,
0.0340319313,
-0.0316875093,
-0.0117852492,
0.0087076081,
-0.0019422767,
-0.0019711566,
-0.012661186,
0.006092988,
-0.0029198355,
-0.015965322,
0.0390661508,
0.0472268425,
-0.0296985544,
0.0241708141,
-0.039868366,
-0.0335386805,
-0.0278732646,
-0.0144728478,
0.0337256715,
0.0010646371,
-0.1011857092,
0.0086953714,
0.0482475087,
0.0099601522,
-0.0572167709,
0.0573410094,
0.0317104459,
-0.0618581586,
0.0075956583,
-0.0212145485,
0.0346000232,
0.0208218433,
0.0878646821,
-0.0421557128,
0.0216078684,
-0.0005730546,
0.0228734743,
0.0566187277,
-0.0182242058,
0.0079746088,
0.0193579942,
0.0078885304,
0.0204842072,
-0.0232000668,
0.0081695523,
0.0175876562,
0.0254775733,
0.0347445458,
-0.0698246807,
-0.0549274422,
-0.0038623116,
2.856e-7,
0.0547766127,
0.0668280572,
0.001887594,
-0.0123403529,
-0.0167710297,
0.0480514131,
-0.021499021,
0.0860265866,
0.0011710607,
0.0563278235,
0.0468208306,
-0.0091835298,
0.1107561737,
-0.0077748965,
-0.0732134134,
-0.0755243599,
0.0013147638,
0.0670270547,
-0.044135306,
0.0335837342,
0.0226954576,
0.1106481105,
-0.0317269787,
-0.0156119354,
0.008362161,
-0.0821295455,
0.0574337915,
-0.0213204175,
-0.0377224721,
0.0071296971,
0.0317539014,
-0.0060114963,
-0.0520389937,
0.0001001117,
-0.0282948706,
0.0352294371,
0.0559391603,
0.0833971351,
0.0615883134,
0.0513499752,
0.0025717118,
0.0097204447,
0.0229066927,
-0.0223701578,
0.0298716705,
-0.059313491,
-0.0344441943,
-0.0387194455,
-0.0483298935,
0.0103888651,
0.0546337515,
-0.0044551599,
0.0257297065,
0.0228236187,
0.0595976561,
0.0328775123,
-0.0115271825,
0.0068430481,
0.0217149891,
-0.0079631647,
-0.0114023518,
0.0187075567,
-0.0137604466,
0.0133007905,
0.0250304006,
-0.0168181509,
0.0153748533,
2.214002513e-34,
0.0584978946,
-0.0380927287,
-0.0176628549,
-0.0017855753,
0.0587662309,
0.001606442,
-0.0203969739,
0.0305064432,
-0.0174829792,
-0.0551151372,
0.0087904613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12829v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12829v1 | Synthetic Boost: Leveraging Synthetic Data for Enhanced Vision-Language Segmentation in Echocardiography | 2023-09-22T12:36:30 | 2023-09-22T12:36:30 | Rabin Adhikari, Manish Dhakal, Safal Thapaliya, Kanchan Poudel, Prasiddha Bhandari, Bishesh Khanal | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Accurate segmentation is essential for echocardiography-based assessment of
cardiovascular diseases (CVDs). However, the variability among sonographers and
the inherent challenges of ultrasound images hinder precise segmentation. By
leveraging the joint representation of image and text modalities,
Vision-Language Segmentation Models (VLSMs) can incorporate rich contextual
information, potentially aiding in accurate and explainable segmentation.
However, the lack of readily available data in echocardiography hampers the
training of VLSMs. In this study, we explore using synthetic datasets from
Semantic Diffusion Models (SDMs) to enhance VLSMs for echocardiography
segmentation. We evaluate results for two popular VLSMs (CLIPSeg and CRIS)
using seven different kinds of language prompts derived from several
attributes, automatically extracted from echocardiography images, segmentation
masks, and their metadata. Our results show improved metrics and faster
convergence when pretraining VLSMs on SDM-generated synthetic images before
finetuning on real images. The code, configs, and prompts are available at
https://github.com/naamiinepal/synthetic-boost. | [
-0.01474055,
0.0309012122,
0.0197747461,
0.0048091202,
-0.013985903,
0.0151793128,
0.0174749922,
0.0349948406,
-0.0627063811,
0.0305969231,
0.0153869195,
-0.0725362524,
0.0240871739,
0.0495738201,
-0.0252155084,
-0.1126069799,
-0.001440496,
-0.0303219669,
-0.0442670323,
-0.0053837835,
0.014879846,
-0.0142683135,
0.012842318,
0.0018219722,
-0.0349244028,
-0.0111206621,
0.0078164255,
0.0111067174,
0.0435311757,
-0.0411320589,
-0.0337503552,
0.0653531477,
0.0233491659,
-0.0222394671,
0.0000022973,
-0.0256520826,
0.0051847333,
0.0534547307,
-0.0416329131,
-0.0290395468,
0.0756231695,
-0.032248795,
0.0032182776,
-0.0325057693,
-0.0123915309,
-0.0056386236,
0.0577934757,
0.0122596351,
0.0753663927,
0.0294261221,
-0.0239530727,
-0.037993852,
0.0132651618,
-0.0342396498,
0.0652400181,
-0.0389094874,
0.0444593951,
-0.0060856435,
-0.020635264,
0.0363132097,
-0.0127877984,
0.0496208295,
0.0279628802,
0.0305808838,
0.0648785383,
0.050582286,
0.0223843716,
-0.047915142,
-0.0267977025,
0.0846520439,
0.0017083915,
0.0085777529,
0.0087514687,
-0.0210253783,
-0.0214535296,
0.0043301224,
-0.0075640338,
-0.002819997,
-0.0111729018,
0.0111467373,
0.0138537744,
-0.0032234963,
0.0216482412,
-0.0264947601,
-0.0069541559,
-0.0203372743,
0.0024585205,
0.0171616543,
0.0003428402,
-0.0062686931,
-0.0291480012,
-0.0289944001,
0.042300418,
-0.0018022725,
-0.004701301,
0.0286599807,
-0.025162993,
-0.0441939831,
0.0242964234,
-0.0202189498,
-0.0226127394,
-0.0091326209,
-0.028848432,
0.0843499675,
-0.0173419751,
-0.0000904451,
-0.0161548238,
0.0709311813,
-0.0552523471,
0.0142360628,
-0.0341559574,
-0.0076784221,
-0.0233852714,
0.0084554525,
-0.0362117626,
0.0052097556,
-0.075226739,
-0.0268995296,
-0.0183724537,
0.0017365988,
0.0316796154,
0.0541851632,
-0.0305424966,
0.0235319585,
-0.0095373457,
-0.0235831123,
-0.0028224061,
-0.0358313471,
-0.003515257,
-0.0012082615,
0.0260396451,
0.0239039604,
0.0023645971,
0.0003410169,
-0.0029114832,
0.0263048094,
-0.0366218872,
-0.0228763856,
-0.0016851022,
-0.0382297449,
-0.0273679532,
-0.0040174695,
0.0506141409,
-0.08120884,
0.0338241681,
0.0040186313,
0.0320082903,
0.0251610875,
-0.0141009148,
-0.0089532277,
-0.015085401,
0.0846030638,
-0.0741657019,
0.0030274473,
0.0101063531,
0.0438280143,
0.0506640859,
0.0691612437,
0.0032513016,
-0.0356488787,
0.023317324,
0.0128419111,
-0.0241964124,
0.0419422463,
-0.0099887066,
-0.005803423,
-0.0615069233,
-0.0051332456,
-0.0048631593,
0.0421881601,
0.0387717262,
0.0151324803,
-0.0188782439,
-0.0723069608,
0.0211171694,
0.0761601776,
0.0027063384,
-0.0046041678,
0.0593002848,
-0.0214057211,
-0.0311880745,
-0.0103784287,
0.011834234,
-0.0417036116,
0.0674579889,
0.0166560262,
-0.0561103188,
-0.0303657148,
-0.0155161917,
-0.0547872186,
-0.0336670391,
-0.0123588592,
0.0144315045,
-0.0077972636,
0.0589823835,
-0.0050920355,
-0.0128157828,
0.0248771477,
0.0087051848,
-0.0245741121,
-0.0247359965,
-0.0373485945,
0.0405193493,
0.0778073892,
0.0393761508,
-0.0602951497,
0.0110467579,
0.0154185854,
0.0626574904,
0.0470049046,
0.0164290089,
0.0115468204,
0.0301760044,
-0.0606812574,
-0.0423979685,
0.0648677871,
0.0086093666,
-0.0114244912,
0.0054641869,
0.0191687364,
-0.0116339661,
-0.0612590238,
-0.0128538366,
0.0450943522,
0.0135749308,
-0.010980878,
-0.0080074575,
0.0022457277,
0.0025533962,
-0.0061990977,
-0.0317281149,
-0.0361002274,
-0.0055372994,
-0.0016690033,
-0.0122282971,
-0.0020531341,
-0.0819875747,
-0.0506716892,
0.0201077014,
-0.0771683902,
-0.0570590235,
-0.0409423709,
-0.0624177493,
-0.0029203722,
-0.0398008376,
0.0066499063,
-0.0394650958,
-0.019209845,
0.0214533098,
0.0246335436,
0.0169338882,
-0.0137838572,
0.0372005478,
-0.0234438255,
0.0113727888,
0.017336214,
0.0575156882,
-0.0103008877,
0.0087129185,
0.020610366,
-0.0262868926,
-0.00537202,
0.0069833877,
-0.0229332391,
0.0348518081,
-0.0386547707,
0.0232659932,
-0.0299278758,
-0.0189519059,
-0.0073632183,
-0.0095565654,
0.0242848545,
0.0216350723,
-0.0229020026,
-0.0057550003,
-0.0007854741,
0.0454205573,
0.0202346426,
-0.0100356014,
0.0390280224,
0.0122954687,
0.0301234424,
-0.0118530262,
0.0088827368,
0.012864395,
0.0322471373,
0.0207485929,
-0.0256846119,
-0.0134291081,
0.0132126668,
-0.0055351001,
0.0036383595,
-0.0023656548,
-0.0150878327,
-0.0199212842,
-0.0082788318,
-0.0090792431,
0.0395171456,
-0.0058645681,
0.0513049923,
-0.0128324591,
-0.0021813053,
0.0271951091,
-0.0137353437,
-0.0441816673,
0.0136566395,
-0.0013085465,
-0.0626467243,
-0.0067674615,
0.0955283418,
0.0099748541,
0.043834608,
0.0091253137,
-0.0339253023,
-0.0221453998,
-0.0232020915,
-0.0977763161,
-0.0095398752,
-0.0328384899,
0.0280302856,
-0.0304652471,
-0.0783133283,
0.0688899159,
-0.0405950397,
-0.0164439306,
-0.0482993647,
-0.0563835837,
-0.012816852,
-0.0301888473,
0.017460797,
0.0440188721,
0.0269828383,
0.0308261197,
-0.0262434669,
-0.0065926411,
-0.0097516431,
-0.0442345366,
0.0179637056,
-0.0445674621,
0.0039138063,
0.0095319934,
0.0059328685,
-0.0313698687,
-0.0138295013,
0.0019500965,
0.0203916766,
0.0111791389,
0.0159000233,
0.0404227152,
0.0751250684,
-0.0177936871,
0.0428170115,
0.0145434653,
-0.0181900878,
-0.0085478257,
0.0677861869,
0.0267889518,
-0.0286349878,
-0.0528576151,
-0.0547945537,
0.0404244512,
0.0446460322,
0.0458371863,
-0.0239305496,
-0.0478626154,
0.0055299019,
-0.0272002723,
0.0221788548,
-0.0077497289,
0.0153724374,
0.0711833313,
-0.0193914529,
-0.0206481274,
0.0695217475,
0.0350061469,
-0.0400649682,
-0.0341052115,
0.0094389925,
0.0362499766,
-0.0063356482,
-0.0385535993,
-0.0614976585,
-0.0504388511,
0.0001673509,
0.0057028541,
-0.0134915169,
-0.00188693,
-0.0107233729,
-0.0179386027,
0.0924087614,
0.0102763996,
-0.1007103845,
-0.0105857793,
-0.0558965877,
0.0049240789,
-0.0189935472,
-0.028232459,
-0.0774368793,
-0.0271607824,
-0.0290347002,
0.0102514969,
-0.0430319309,
-0.0191549528,
0.0057603843,
-0.027767254,
-0.037960615,
0.0847606137,
-0.0120750796,
-0.0041709896,
-0.0311358944,
0.0478327237,
-0.0138675096,
-0.0055442029,
-0.0008010005,
0.0830071867,
0.0081691565,
-0.0009623286,
-0.0191769302,
0.0440955497,
0.014926888,
-0.0115117934,
-0.0107099265,
0.0701073036,
-0.0030523732,
-0.0282333754,
-0.0774701312,
0.0336257666,
0.0202981047,
0.0207647812,
0.0052153459,
-0.0186579153,
-0.0162741262,
-0.0181552973,
0.0545052662,
0.0119865425,
-0.0130324857,
0.0042898632,
-0.0807043836,
-0.0621598847,
-0.0515997857,
-0.0327736214,
0.0370757356,
0.0140234344,
0.0111645814,
0.0216345042,
0.0569714494,
-0.0354275368,
-0.0667842552,
0.0776931569,
-0.0363249443,
0.037531089,
-0.0044248649,
-0.0109197712,
0.0349689499,
-0.0134836836,
-0.0263620745,
0.0545061007,
-0.064495869,
0.0077093909,
-0.0122921364,
0.0688506961,
0.0163129587,
0.0378970914,
-0.0648724437,
-0.0124072712,
0.1129898354,
0.0786567405,
0.0288579129,
-0.0215733629,
0.0116734104,
-0.0210372955,
-0.0318236165,
-0.0144529762,
-0.015025666,
0.017365694,
0.0319934376,
-0.0131265782,
-0.0413596556,
0.027483074,
-0.0036400936,
-0.0057649803,
0.0796144456,
-0.0303527061,
0.0041413992,
-0.0247995667,
0.0165904295,
0.0006931323,
0.0162804406,
-0.0204164088,
0.0446041152,
0.0094491821,
0.0125061721,
0.0071621607,
-0.0413824953,
-0.0204017814,
-0.0626753196,
-0.020315988,
0.0437680297,
-0.0061881426,
0.0123532591,
0.0296018515,
0.0113077629,
0.0257758647,
-0.0263095535,
-0.0033237629,
-0.0015761975,
0.0297647491,
0.0890372172,
0.0119492421,
0.01861245,
0.0000701706,
0.0521141104,
-0.0199769251,
-0.001058607,
-0.0674708858,
0.048418656,
0.0330986865,
-0.0348859765,
-0.0262544993,
-0.0128557747,
0.0034086541,
-0.0211152099,
0.0180944037,
-0.0219236631,
-0.0063439165,
0.0883896276,
-0.0063944515,
0.0189660769,
-0.0081076082,
0.0676779076,
-0.001147703,
0.0177087225,
0.0024434999,
-0.0418787822,
-0.0485856943,
-0.0020899212,
-0.0038443645,
0.0379441939,
-0.0463845022,
0.0202193651,
-0.0359870829,
-0.0799501762,
-0.0057385596,
0.0018926285,
-0.0136653828,
0.0135719767,
0.0731961131,
0.073622033,
-0.047956448,
-0.0142217716,
0.0115626669,
0.0047941636,
-0.0424362719,
0.0074338405,
0.0552760586,
-6.370155232e-33,
-0.0083987117,
-0.0133413784,
0.0511557423,
-0.0429625139,
0.0039966796,
0.0485054106,
-0.0308828261,
-0.0139190797,
0.0259838197,
0.0466813855,
-0.0447760895,
-0.0263850726,
0.0437412895,
0.0488416664,
-0.0400346741,
-0.0410904288,
0.0327660181,
0.0038495576,
-0.008585806,
-0.0083217416,
-0.0326001011,
0.0137951588,
0.0715516582,
-0.0675378591,
-0.0213457681,
0.0432230942,
0.0118502108,
0.035879802,
0.030809667,
0.0156956296,
-0.0398093164,
0.0501391813,
0.0169808399,
-0.0553187057,
-0.0300945062,
-0.0028468636,
-0.0667542294,
-0.0018720257,
0.0404957272,
0.0156637225,
-0.0855001956,
-0.0005038235,
0.0280529186,
-0.0048703742,
0.0305673275,
-0.0054823477,
0.0523419119,
-0.0415930524,
0.0044729426,
0.016637126,
-0.0166370813,
0.0712160766,
-0.0054703541,
-0.0008431553,
0.025079336,
-0.0455241241,
0.0048028911,
0.0323457383,
-0.0593449734,
0.0206255037,
0.069207646,
-0.0010406299,
0.0444323532,
0.0485634618,
-0.0094518261,
0.0445678383,
0.0780680403,
-0.0778539702,
0.0238885302,
0.05842245,
-0.048671402,
0.0635897294,
0.0837581083,
0.0274249557,
0.0487480313,
-0.0062986538,
-0.0263982601,
0.0389443338,
-0.0964453891,
-0.0328965709,
0.0116836587,
-0.019496385,
-0.0200350359,
-0.0072318004,
-0.0104985833,
-0.0656142309,
-0.0155337704,
0.0054761502,
0.0198153481,
0.037775863,
-0.0044926652,
0.0363965258,
0.0432699025,
0.0169042479,
0.0212976038,
-0.0346294791,
0.0436602794,
0.0239163954,
-0.004133075,
-0.032084085,
0.0019053168,
-0.0342943557,
0.0654653385,
0.0331411585,
0.0219643004,
0.0239189677,
-0.0106871286,
-0.0532949045,
-0.0294294972,
0.0106126051,
-0.0131228613,
-0.0149778035,
-0.0417071246,
-0.0128041087,
0.0346103236,
0.0068747085,
-0.0495562069,
0.0824040771,
-0.0024387424,
0.0144811487,
-0.0121955043,
-0.0607491247,
-0.0620882362,
0.0416033715,
-0.0497145802,
-0.0204058848,
-0.008329724,
-0.0009158117,
0.0876532421,
-0.0361491963,
-0.0374472961,
0.0119449925,
2.885e-7,
0.0458248444,
0.00864904,
0.0116634937,
-0.0154453423,
-0.0182465799,
0.0469559133,
-0.0231675822,
-0.0145584578,
-0.0073155062,
-0.0837419555,
0.0282077584,
0.0613652654,
0.0131006092,
0.0147552602,
-0.0570465662,
-0.0081168162,
-0.0225031413,
0.0003109185,
-0.0322313718,
0.0098609766,
0.0323367752,
0.081689477,
-0.0406756662,
-0.0530656353,
0.0301164277,
0.001790107,
-0.0138105433,
-0.0550707951,
0.0149669498,
0.0087782461,
-0.043239437,
0.0063341763,
0.0234120097,
0.033487577,
-0.0147083635,
-0.041741766,
0.0612634569,
0.0484355614,
-0.0425930694,
0.0154397832,
-0.0078927539,
0.0297602918,
-0.0035045971,
-0.0386990607,
0.0457467027,
-0.0341876149,
0.0148675721,
-0.0603960045,
-0.0273950621,
-0.0006823947,
0.0483597293,
-0.0396070518,
-0.0396866538,
0.0317787118,
0.0131747313,
0.0191260763,
-0.0527515188,
-0.0395032503,
-0.0118307276,
-0.0084882518,
-0.0019844598,
-0.0507110357,
-0.0064194244,
0.0748343915,
0.0017450673,
-0.0461523123,
-0.0175723154,
2.462090596e-34,
0.0281697437,
0.0214248728,
-0.0234933235,
0.020360399,
0.0222066864,
-0.0199837815,
-0.0280840714,
-0.0242200904,
-0.0404689014,
-0.0246664453,
0.0088467775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12810v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12810v1 | StyloMetrix: An Open-Source Multilingual Tool for Representing Stylometric Vectors | 2023-09-22T11:53:47 | 2023-09-22T11:53:47 | Inez Okulska, Daria Stetsenko, Anna Kołos, Agnieszka Karlińska, Kinga Głąbińska, Adam Nowakowski | cs.CL | cs.CL | This work aims to provide an overview on the open-source multilanguage tool
called StyloMetrix. It offers stylometric text representations that cover
various aspects of grammar, syntax and lexicon. StyloMetrix covers four
languages: Polish as the primary language, English, Ukrainian and Russian. The
normalized output of each feature can become a fruitful course for machine
learning models and a valuable addition to the embeddings layer for any deep
learning algorithm. We strive to provide a concise, but exhaustive overview on
the application of the StyloMetrix vectors as well as explain the sets of the
developed linguistic features. The experiments have shown promising results in
supervised content classification with simple algorithms as Random Forest
Classifier, Voting Classifier, Logistic Regression and others. The deep
learning assessments have unveiled the usefulness of the StyloMetrix vectors at
enhancing an embedding layer extracted from Transformer architectures. The
StyloMetrix has proven itself to be a formidable source for the machine
learning and deep learning algorithms to execute different classification
tasks. | [
-0.0008626065,
-0.0073288437,
0.004569029,
0.0393488295,
-0.0247202832,
0.0475573689,
0.0359128527,
-0.0082765501,
-0.0040980629,
-0.0489033982,
-0.0126508009,
-0.0508356355,
0.0125300549,
0.03967987,
0.0442683659,
-0.0081268186,
0.0258674249,
0.0179512277,
-0.0081876973,
0.0236968081,
-0.0008605791,
0.0314157233,
0.0299520157,
0.0472829081,
-0.0181286614,
-0.0249775089,
0.0187229589,
-0.019232966,
0.0113540133,
-0.0373471342,
0.0064916057,
0.0328186825,
-0.0006731747,
0.0750079527,
0.0000020013,
-0.0315381289,
0.0073487866,
-0.005208306,
-0.004883491,
-0.026568532,
0.0812886879,
-0.0372153632,
-0.0149006313,
-0.0048844945,
-0.0362996235,
-0.0455338806,
0.0347430855,
0.0495027862,
0.0185720995,
0.0730257034,
-0.0155414846,
-0.072231181,
0.0336297639,
-0.0006622452,
-0.04972177,
0.0476091877,
0.0140243452,
-0.0610743314,
-0.03996481,
0.0649860948,
0.0014153782,
0.0420699008,
0.0245791059,
-0.0337403901,
0.0141786914,
0.0009433118,
-0.0440045781,
-0.0338537991,
0.0151358359,
0.0182501655,
-0.0301545132,
-0.0429701135,
-0.0145498253,
0.0032461656,
0.0120784584,
-0.0225355588,
-0.0517418385,
0.0083760722,
0.0183572974,
0.0208721254,
0.0457731225,
-0.0029016752,
0.0319445245,
-0.0244263429,
0.0249774177,
0.0251974184,
0.0120582208,
0.0166898668,
0.030650001,
-0.003959436,
-0.0038047247,
-0.0201355498,
0.0395536982,
0.0169810206,
0.022892151,
-0.0157032609,
-0.0261227749,
-0.0844956636,
0.0362724103,
-0.0964450613,
-0.0163843185,
-0.0090485979,
-0.0172126051,
0.037634179,
-0.0884977952,
0.0248731915,
-0.0412763692,
0.0444544517,
-0.000806507,
-0.052892819,
-0.0525803901,
-0.0387189537,
-0.0303783584,
0.0251769572,
-0.0117069427,
-0.0362690464,
-0.0596834645,
0.0111550586,
-0.0084416708,
0.022230329,
-0.0232463367,
0.0370080359,
-0.0038676478,
0.0606784895,
0.0109116649,
0.0626290515,
-0.0522270314,
-0.0049813478,
-0.0416861624,
0.0005858825,
0.0235251021,
0.0833383724,
0.0281240698,
-0.0229462553,
0.0363535583,
0.0364639796,
0.014480629,
-0.035078153,
-0.0134526929,
-0.0234624203,
-0.0352604538,
-0.0159891658,
0.0333300382,
-0.0760914013,
0.002782892,
0.0123787904,
-0.0153252324,
-0.0621853024,
0.0022224656,
0.0227031298,
-0.0284174494,
0.0482351035,
-0.0015114401,
-0.0573438443,
0.0288086273,
-0.0261098631,
0.0552774072,
0.0246507525,
0.0257538874,
0.0352266915,
0.0618557371,
-0.0571963973,
0.0119216992,
0.0210770518,
-0.0028270222,
-0.0116737541,
-0.0040489361,
-0.0254037343,
-0.0100994827,
-0.004901614,
0.0377756283,
0.012007948,
0.0140871257,
-0.0469758064,
0.0195027348,
0.0410764664,
0.0766733065,
0.0850076899,
0.0563276596,
-0.0176325738,
-0.0391214006,
-0.0222244021,
-0.0223657526,
0.0159867853,
-0.0242539272,
0.0005956614,
-0.0672759339,
0.054669302,
-0.0157261696,
-0.0113943368,
0.0073164236,
-0.0537781231,
0.0562637076,
-0.0235767383,
0.0805142894,
-0.026928274,
-0.0238247514,
0.0596707799,
0.0273844004,
-0.0289928094,
-0.0130568035,
-0.0194092523,
0.022314189,
0.0088225901,
-0.0146031436,
-0.0609066933,
-0.0108709699,
-0.0429112837,
-0.0131520228,
0.026244035,
0.0232625045,
0.0086779697,
0.0037219303,
-0.052052673,
0.0025303843,
-0.012245534,
0.006202417,
0.0672197714,
-0.0561653227,
0.0557264686,
0.0320085175,
0.0031011889,
-0.0329130143,
0.0240167491,
0.0285036135,
-0.0234332047,
0.0070515731,
0.0102882702,
-0.0016324575,
0.0616357811,
0.004878446,
-0.0058229747,
0.059332706,
-0.0600481443,
-0.0177918449,
0.0088251494,
-0.0321804658,
-0.0187651403,
0.0320701674,
-0.0524031557,
-0.0096348627,
0.0500186607,
-0.0133061958,
-0.0162217189,
0.0229578838,
-0.0228531379,
0.0003902757,
-0.0557659492,
0.003910399,
-0.0391541123,
0.0630230904,
-0.0060007116,
0.0393792726,
0.0113387071,
0.0390588492,
-0.0293335952,
-0.0575708598,
0.0564552993,
-0.0087324232,
-0.0455064103,
0.0257207751,
-0.0398198105,
0.0221876763,
0.0253852904,
0.0203976613,
0.0026316934,
-0.0274128523,
-0.0814683214,
0.0003015579,
-0.0430008695,
0.0289422963,
-0.0145840487,
-0.007668599,
0.0240049437,
-0.025231123,
-0.0621204823,
-0.0321051329,
-0.0125374869,
-0.0010918918,
0.0411163196,
-0.0084873755,
0.0081080161,
-0.0114399139,
-0.0341894887,
-0.0272072963,
0.0530756451,
-0.005617951,
-0.0043914495,
-0.0431714579,
-0.0226281304,
-0.0061438098,
0.0102330176,
0.0024447616,
-0.0588537566,
-0.0032398046,
0.0086895218,
0.0092135109,
0.0340778679,
-0.0213404726,
0.0335548855,
0.0480864234,
0.0400192104,
-0.0180157516,
0.0175424051,
-0.0353236757,
0.0836759731,
-0.0512616001,
0.0247444361,
0.0204533171,
0.0330620781,
-0.0162985977,
-0.0133243594,
-0.0321734063,
-0.0007578399,
-0.0117496783,
0.0139405644,
-0.0101279914,
-0.0002559665,
0.0060452912,
0.0006202473,
0.0442541167,
-0.0015350593,
0.0561092906,
-0.0378948525,
-0.0354199298,
-0.0452506803,
-0.0699373558,
-0.0565111302,
0.0322318561,
0.0180351883,
0.0105126025,
-0.033655066,
-0.0453875102,
-0.0236335155,
-0.0122096892,
0.0198705755,
-0.0208215881,
-0.015076411,
-0.0023280447,
-0.0302156378,
-0.0208113268,
-0.0137362685,
0.0052331788,
-0.0652595535,
-0.0212597996,
0.0125881853,
0.0231962018,
-0.0204899386,
0.0042539178,
-0.0235597454,
0.0055658994,
0.0254469048,
0.0096896281,
0.0242332648,
0.0016140197,
0.0630139485,
0.0057355589,
0.0217496734,
0.0162247159,
0.0211895946,
-0.0115979668,
0.0110306554,
-0.0458985157,
0.0158211775,
-0.0417397581,
0.008369375,
0.0297316723,
-0.0238815285,
-0.086245358,
-0.0285483766,
-0.000551605,
-0.0628900006,
0.0243018493,
0.1118257493,
0.0155286314,
-0.0735268369,
-0.0143953403,
-0.0448751077,
0.0396391861,
0.0212004744,
0.0178139266,
-0.0982621834,
-0.0118245436,
-0.0221814625,
-0.0149928229,
0.0113579836,
-0.0098377457,
0.0377630405,
-0.0616902597,
0.0128636872,
-0.0096169636,
-0.06227725,
-0.0504541658,
-0.0341396257,
-0.0507858619,
-0.0089330561,
-0.0100159477,
-0.0550589338,
0.0041429,
-0.0184593257,
0.0107936179,
-0.0734499916,
-0.0058046822,
0.0235113837,
-0.0186912958,
-0.005754625,
0.0515594073,
0.0747828409,
-0.0566250905,
-0.0297868717,
-0.0035000129,
-0.0024702754,
-0.0199797023,
-0.0344248712,
0.0459392145,
0.0275671128,
-0.0374248363,
-0.0036454194,
0.0173060317,
-0.0275027808,
0.0158857144,
-0.0298123602,
0.0844335705,
-0.0077507948,
-0.039973028,
-0.044511307,
-0.0356407985,
0.0216846559,
0.0414825939,
0.016666729,
-0.0312374774,
-0.0652070865,
-0.0265277512,
0.0057975082,
-0.0092117814,
-0.035228081,
0.0653627738,
0.0091381716,
-0.0651846156,
-0.0596195199,
-0.0658743903,
0.0381103456,
-0.0021194753,
-0.0348476619,
-0.000121293,
-0.001786266,
-0.0295917019,
-0.059264347,
0.0118858879,
0.0296938457,
0.0450827554,
-0.0523512587,
0.0250580627,
0.0422061235,
-0.0034269539,
-0.0161846615,
-0.0080113588,
-0.0420478731,
-0.0417922214,
0.0002062296,
0.0297078807,
0.0129230972,
0.0108429743,
-0.030597426,
-0.0394765921,
0.0574837923,
0.0382185802,
-0.0347334333,
-0.0208965242,
0.0610205159,
-0.0363609903,
-0.0168020148,
0.024440119,
-0.0148047889,
0.0203279741,
-0.0430210419,
-0.0330167152,
0.0001572633,
-0.0157489087,
-0.0164868981,
-0.0083310697,
0.0574013107,
-0.01696942,
-0.0484724194,
-0.0100629199,
-0.0003875632,
-0.0032333557,
0.0000331368,
0.0145242196,
-0.0018478793,
0.0464707166,
-0.0321655534,
-0.0251189265,
0.0532671474,
0.0426363051,
0.0247023311,
-0.0290973503,
0.0626066178,
0.0409380682,
-0.0085070245,
-0.02486757,
0.0461941101,
-0.0149729978,
0.0044353204,
-0.0142063657,
0.0435946696,
-0.0424844436,
0.0025590674,
-0.0147247398,
-0.0004352084,
-0.0189973544,
0.055043593,
-0.0251201782,
0.0291669536,
0.0025744818,
-0.0066768271,
0.0477606058,
-0.0457150936,
0.0496838093,
-0.0172052849,
-0.0366715677,
-0.016554974,
0.0461557843,
-0.0053891223,
-0.0121630644,
0.0459872931,
-0.0112477476,
-0.0353479795,
-0.0262745339,
0.0418934487,
0.0151526928,
0.0018733586,
0.0521753207,
-0.0400666893,
-0.0744775757,
0.0101156589,
0.0292560812,
0.0002772749,
-0.0164571609,
-0.0053477879,
-0.0381241441,
-0.0502168275,
0.0523392074,
-0.0358109251,
-0.0120975068,
-0.0280537512,
0.0152551308,
0.0500610285,
0.0037288149,
0.0116437487,
-0.0424350314,
0.0098119192,
0.0272694342,
-0.0165908877,
-0.0124803809,
-6.06352202e-33,
-0.0023393948,
-0.0287881736,
0.0009421937,
0.0381449535,
0.0024969988,
-0.0318406038,
0.0029503659,
0.011244189,
-0.0443441272,
0.0447584987,
0.0098924683,
-0.0118201356,
0.0062476387,
0.037606027,
0.0318281762,
0.0181895997,
0.0126924068,
0.0175847933,
0.0143174212,
0.0542702153,
0.0624109171,
0.0277715586,
0.1129550338,
-0.0672066361,
0.0176289771,
0.0126741128,
0.0261451378,
-0.0049700309,
0.0212087333,
0.0605921708,
-0.0135026332,
0.0527215526,
0.0199472439,
-0.0598892532,
0.0145135783,
0.0624108836,
-0.0497416556,
-0.0659496412,
-0.0373172052,
0.0548406914,
-0.0206572041,
-0.0343126766,
0.0460958555,
0.0136963623,
0.0310463924,
0.0191671439,
0.0736539289,
0.0077933315,
-0.0484155342,
-0.0704049394,
-0.0758645684,
0.019277256,
-0.0184877217,
0.0151404934,
0.0304701291,
0.036182832,
0.0050166734,
0.0229590274,
-0.0701213181,
-0.028742753,
-0.0446991809,
0.0166053455,
0.016758848,
-0.0135025559,
-0.0384535827,
0.036184486,
-0.0108722141,
-0.0383205265,
-0.0250004474,
0.0721673965,
0.0741305277,
0.0391450375,
0.0867264196,
0.0640877187,
-0.0049141617,
-0.0122170085,
-0.0772999004,
-0.007538476,
0.042510096,
0.0433033966,
-0.005151053,
-0.007254615,
-0.0215038639,
-0.021793602,
0.0096170045,
-0.019516753,
-0.0066395993,
-0.0363278054,
0.0006909773,
-0.0389082842,
-0.0452938527,
0.0678641722,
0.0132374354,
-0.0293455534,
-0.0409308225,
0.0366598256,
0.0033270915,
0.0642628372,
0.0077152653,
0.0337894224,
0.0185763221,
-0.0387922637,
-0.0351008549,
-0.0099021969,
0.0373230018,
-0.0076787951,
0.069002077,
0.0144740362,
-0.0572854578,
0.0143454596,
0.0208694134,
0.0069876988,
0.0117278099,
0.0857578889,
0.0003839752,
0.0043185977,
0.0062840483,
0.0432939939,
0.0185488854,
0.0322921984,
-0.0226308256,
-0.0338666439,
0.0444161035,
0.0017793613,
-0.0493410863,
-0.0144038899,
-0.0372801386,
0.0463895015,
0.0283230301,
-0.0262932554,
0.0133175952,
-0.0207727347,
2.674e-7,
0.0855003893,
0.0667389855,
0.0131269358,
-0.0021683422,
0.0232079867,
0.0471118055,
0.0262445882,
0.065889366,
-0.032472305,
-0.0036122885,
-0.0106437774,
-0.0180981196,
0.0199231002,
0.0267689973,
-0.0879878998,
0.0457958505,
-0.0685763583,
0.0041646296,
-0.0496119671,
0.0368233174,
0.0480173193,
0.1512966454,
0.0102303158,
-0.020424623,
-0.0204385743,
-0.0369715765,
0.0566837937,
-0.0140958251,
0.0183917135,
-0.0047736596,
0.0262090266,
0.0498227477,
-0.0102339992,
-0.0014104,
-0.0196866095,
0.0262780264,
-0.0139950337,
0.0210760068,
-0.0452157632,
-0.0052433112,
0.0310902726,
-0.0288169384,
-0.0094756316,
-0.0542790182,
0.0371987224,
-0.0360057242,
-0.0244223997,
-0.0307306051,
0.0115682837,
-0.0002999764,
0.046892684,
-0.0202122126,
-0.0154217463,
0.0332123488,
0.0271081869,
-0.0806258842,
-0.0131424936,
-0.0854870453,
-0.0115332212,
0.000753022,
-0.0237791166,
0.0259641577,
-0.0273085646,
0.0026922263,
0.0633314103,
-0.0181436073,
0.0293054897,
2.431798428e-34,
0.025793219,
0.031785138,
-0.0031334632,
0.04259184,
0.0052576377,
-0.0144769624,
0.0763320252,
-0.0022056582,
0.026801236,
-0.0518264547,
-0.0116389664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12808v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12808v2 | ChatPRCS: A Personalized Support System for English Reading Comprehension based on ChatGPT | 2023-09-22T11:46:44 | 2023-09-25T11:01:16 | Xizhe Wang, Yihua Zhong, Changqin Huang, Xiaodi Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | As a common approach to learning English, reading comprehension primarily
entails reading articles and answering related questions. However, the
complexity of designing effective exercises results in students encountering
standardized questions, making it challenging to align with individualized
learners' reading comprehension ability. By leveraging the advanced
capabilities offered by large language models, exemplified by ChatGPT, this
paper presents a novel personalized support system for reading comprehension,
referred to as ChatPRCS, based on the Zone of Proximal Development theory.
ChatPRCS employs methods including reading comprehension proficiency
prediction, question generation, and automatic evaluation, among others, to
enhance reading comprehension instruction. First, we develop a new algorithm
that can predict learners' reading comprehension abilities using their
historical data as the foundation for generating questions at an appropriate
level of difficulty. Second, a series of new ChatGPT prompt patterns is
proposed to address two key aspects of reading comprehension objectives:
question generation, and automated evaluation. These patterns further improve
the quality of generated questions. Finally, by integrating personalized
ability and reading comprehension prompt patterns, ChatPRCS is systematically
validated through experiments. Empirical results demonstrate that it provides
learners with high-quality reading comprehension questions that are broadly
aligned with expert-crafted questions at a statistical level. | [
0.0490171239,
-0.0513292775,
-0.0452949703,
-0.0096270032,
-0.0563125126,
0.0036466019,
0.0453986153,
-0.0258809216,
0.0403250158,
-0.0000806752,
0.0163826589,
-0.0133279767,
-0.0196478274,
0.0065398104,
0.0106798345,
-0.0707487464,
0.02880436,
0.001460624,
0.0280095208,
0.0110496329,
0.0203118734,
-0.0066938861,
-0.016723305,
0.023927182,
0.0337273814,
-0.0514326766,
-0.0159206111,
-0.0073206541,
0.0038506838,
-0.0461940318,
0.0437978432,
0.0270152967,
-0.0120585598,
-0.0186465066,
0.0000021529,
-0.0392967537,
-0.0315988958,
-0.0235895161,
-0.0175459236,
0.0134132253,
0.0672521219,
0.0768482611,
0.0233893171,
0.0007955385,
-0.0314328261,
-0.005714702,
0.0040628598,
0.0119138882,
0.0712323487,
0.041584041,
0.0235053562,
-0.0128455115,
0.0411475003,
0.0528202057,
0.0803939626,
-0.0354935415,
-0.0169060081,
0.0546113551,
0.0609826781,
0.0402757823,
-0.0313452184,
0.0385509096,
0.0218451526,
-0.0154972654,
0.0175734162,
0.016063977,
0.0417580679,
-0.0181384552,
-0.0141621362,
0.0446322635,
0.0553192757,
-0.034446869,
-0.0408619121,
0.0027040592,
0.0296527818,
0.0876537636,
-0.0753067136,
-0.0043199281,
-0.0313323215,
-0.0304068755,
0.0480532832,
-0.0220844783,
-0.0266036019,
0.0153037142,
0.017963646,
0.0309330951,
0.0137138162,
-0.0595945567,
-0.0517288335,
0.0007726685,
-0.0216047838,
-0.0054548909,
0.0504640751,
0.0570647977,
-0.025237646,
0.0283517111,
-0.0070889066,
-0.0559513196,
-0.0119641069,
0.0117359068,
0.0075801844,
0.0595882609,
-0.0100015542,
0.0206179582,
-0.0008368337,
0.0477534458,
0.047794234,
-0.0029056487,
-0.0811191499,
0.0281074736,
-0.041753877,
-0.028531488,
-0.0438133404,
0.0211565308,
-0.036480967,
-0.0453875922,
-0.0411889814,
0.0250484981,
0.0283122696,
0.0179508738,
0.0038386206,
0.0277532898,
-0.0239902809,
-0.0090265246,
-0.0274795499,
0.0093878144,
-0.0734000802,
-0.0192927811,
-0.0097897016,
0.0016020396,
0.0229720473,
0.0031267935,
0.0105638774,
-0.0034362155,
-0.0117223905,
0.0292438697,
-0.0344957039,
-0.035690628,
-0.0444368795,
-0.0355091617,
0.0234529078,
-0.0048815678,
-0.034568768,
-0.0204907637,
-0.0112061845,
0.0132443234,
0.0176074654,
0.0197016057,
-0.0082288627,
0.0320781209,
0.0212662425,
0.0247267727,
-0.0291525107,
0.0091720102,
0.0618098974,
0.03458336,
0.0144392019,
0.0252329223,
0.0171095077,
-0.0154599966,
0.0570786595,
-0.0209726058,
-0.0136785358,
0.020410778,
-0.0298239868,
-0.0356257893,
0.0255436096,
0.016249897,
-0.0065264306,
-0.0006737961,
-0.0575779118,
0.0090136742,
-0.0056647486,
0.0287609994,
0.057080254,
0.0652744472,
0.0216074362,
0.0799663737,
0.023413837,
0.0602707565,
0.0497608855,
0.0483626053,
0.0047752429,
-0.0158769302,
-0.0516662896,
0.02353766,
-0.0094086295,
-0.005775833,
-0.001253659,
-0.0695226863,
0.0016704082,
0.0429465137,
0.0074119051,
0.0257561021,
0.0513628125,
-0.0021250043,
-0.0240741093,
-0.0022561394,
-0.003191048,
-0.0375545807,
0.0496561415,
-0.0437270552,
0.0801459327,
0.0783509463,
0.0624645352,
-0.0521330796,
-0.0464115851,
0.0149166379,
-0.0079754563,
0.0117249647,
0.0049469429,
-0.0407932773,
-0.0307213124,
-0.0475682467,
-0.0025752182,
0.0364259407,
-0.0091218604,
-0.0096167019,
-0.0085318163,
0.0127420481,
0.0087487772,
-0.0266701225,
-0.0464228503,
0.0267436597,
-0.0690445453,
-0.0383298472,
-0.0057344134,
-0.0027934266,
-0.0068833227,
0.0813015029,
0.0221823119,
0.0005967058,
0.0105399154,
-0.0178481061,
-0.0056673833,
0.0332833864,
-0.0691168904,
-0.0275257304,
0.0308009423,
-0.039436359,
0.0327936225,
0.0089784851,
0.0251263287,
-0.0499154851,
0.0240267757,
-0.053183686,
0.060977675,
-0.0348324142,
0.0310567506,
-0.0330637097,
-0.0520576127,
-0.0662211776,
0.0411410704,
0.0297927894,
0.0454512313,
0.0075757955,
0.0576192141,
-0.0021023904,
0.0041399468,
-0.0265408363,
-0.0249711666,
-0.0083911978,
0.0105215656,
0.0444692709,
0.0359355956,
-0.1144108102,
-0.0165410098,
-0.0537757277,
0.0208980162,
0.0012591868,
0.027535772,
0.0416438356,
-0.0122333597,
-0.025837319,
0.0085774753,
-0.0480362549,
0.0217987783,
0.0062235747,
-0.0249139983,
0.0219759382,
0.0204509571,
0.0070220446,
-0.036213126,
-0.0125075709,
-0.0277557336,
-0.0014740047,
0.0611235872,
0.0469640046,
-0.0648184866,
0.0233129896,
0.0071880217,
-0.034617357,
0.0206940435,
-0.05491082,
0.0317359455,
-0.0375613347,
0.0819218308,
0.0455595292,
0.022970017,
0.0134769725,
-0.0157783199,
-0.0510884747,
-0.0500889383,
0.0370902084,
-0.0435089171,
-0.0067120562,
-0.0000514839,
-0.0551935621,
-0.0026125489,
0.0392351039,
0.0597387254,
-0.0310948025,
-0.0606875159,
0.0342444479,
-0.0415286124,
0.040031936,
-0.0626204684,
-0.0021793221,
-0.0174361765,
0.0317738913,
-0.0330059789,
-0.0281654,
0.0935749784,
-0.0079746209,
-0.0175938345,
-0.1034847721,
0.0197357498,
-0.0078319414,
0.0328588448,
-0.0076987986,
0.0184009504,
-0.0328464136,
-0.0366646759,
-0.0429498218,
0.0087160161,
0.0535378158,
-0.0297439098,
0.0018819716,
-0.0549432933,
-0.0520877503,
0.0366020165,
0.0135383122,
-0.0418515243,
-0.020906968,
0.0065522189,
-0.0596589185,
0.0212446172,
-0.0175741278,
-0.0199822094,
0.005586152,
0.0231619626,
-0.0005304065,
-0.0637398139,
-0.0340654328,
0.0108471401,
0.0172815751,
0.0392904729,
0.0003052576,
-0.0046737054,
-0.0471985824,
0.0526113473,
0.0456193909,
-0.0272478815,
-0.0115663121,
0.0274248142,
0.0266275499,
0.0444816723,
-0.0623676293,
0.0035219535,
0.0264736004,
0.0602012873,
-0.0786302239,
-0.0169471577,
0.1117464602,
0.0480997078,
-0.0329512246,
-0.041424457,
-0.0563809425,
0.0081912279,
0.0122106643,
0.0140642524,
-0.0373412222,
-0.0024056234,
-0.0312346835,
0.0495240577,
-0.0275287982,
-0.0160485506,
-0.0117608327,
-0.0721433908,
0.0064982725,
0.0093770158,
-0.0669733882,
0.0336977281,
-0.017170772,
-0.0121983914,
0.0424651019,
-0.0032908195,
0.0159201548,
-0.0120702041,
0.0212870389,
0.0173979718,
-0.0553881675,
-0.0091252774,
-0.0058490932,
0.0016570314,
0.0226876382,
0.0460043326,
0.0162144024,
-0.010411012,
-0.0170308501,
0.0002061369,
-0.0293890685,
-0.0082058022,
-0.0267923847,
0.018370064,
-0.0049179085,
0.0199335068,
-0.0927951932,
0.0534135029,
0.0161728375,
-0.0096102739,
0.0953581557,
0.0477234237,
0.0345268287,
-0.028250305,
-0.0559511371,
0.0556772612,
0.0101451213,
0.065483667,
0.018136479,
-0.0731192082,
0.0091504296,
-0.0324151404,
0.0121673709,
-0.0469997078,
-0.0186661389,
0.0331445448,
-0.0093238465,
0.0204942245,
-0.0413935259,
-0.0488915294,
0.0536211021,
0.0368967205,
0.037721023,
0.0533746108,
0.0013898311,
0.0043741418,
-0.0351177603,
-0.0194063131,
0.0018878226,
-0.0302484147,
-0.0454463251,
-0.0346989185,
0.0017664966,
-0.0591347888,
0.003755748,
-0.0119626736,
-0.0420137793,
-0.0235541984,
-0.003022315,
0.0432320684,
0.0175829735,
-0.0150362076,
0.0234337077,
-0.0476445295,
0.0243809987,
-0.0318261422,
-0.029995298,
-0.0243477151,
-0.0359376818,
0.0278395917,
0.0006227687,
-0.0140285641,
0.0229791123,
0.0225946773,
-0.0133267064,
0.0246982239,
-0.0108225532,
-0.0546593852,
0.0303354505,
0.0427276194,
-0.0013767724,
-0.0196886044,
-0.0480994396,
-0.0325867869,
-0.0008489983,
-0.0248708818,
-0.0237212479,
-0.0101011889,
0.0149959736,
0.025070617,
-0.0678396896,
-0.0021173793,
-0.00080959,
-0.0502979644,
0.0462645963,
-0.0358195268,
0.0660731867,
0.0207284614,
0.0370375514,
0.0096582398,
-0.0064732498,
-0.0236917567,
-0.0520316847,
-0.0069042174,
0.0737922862,
0.0356249101,
0.1159060895,
-0.0004926963,
-0.0199331064,
0.0446117409,
0.0024073825,
-0.0367349125,
-0.0165705588,
-0.0147430021,
0.049638316,
-0.0206721965,
0.0055448362,
-0.0048410501,
-0.0246037524,
0.003764218,
-0.0173993073,
0.0355760455,
0.0052472451,
-0.021860905,
0.0144245047,
0.0066593764,
0.0318833701,
-0.01996696,
0.0216623358,
-0.0075325919,
-0.0290159136,
0.0224644393,
-0.0260652695,
-0.0721320212,
0.0101138726,
0.018475702,
0.0833741874,
0.0195059888,
0.0288196411,
-0.06949047,
-0.0266516171,
-0.0184029192,
0.0449923202,
0.0255139433,
-0.0250231773,
0.0186531637,
0.0588275082,
-0.0626367703,
-0.039551463,
-0.0408468507,
0.0550530665,
-0.0647841617,
-0.0355731808,
-0.0169606656,
-6.065188651e-33,
-0.0110719083,
-0.0497457795,
0.0435993187,
-0.0036730969,
-0.0172983166,
-0.0190187544,
-0.0438580625,
0.0351767018,
0.0235247929,
-0.0080898209,
-0.0222586673,
-0.009694906,
-0.0155029353,
0.0437180214,
-0.0072321715,
0.0161090977,
0.0365741588,
0.0010994793,
-0.0035032965,
0.0311849099,
0.0379580744,
0.01966157,
0.0279637463,
-0.0058905552,
0.0595420264,
-0.1073923856,
-0.0072117541,
-0.0090962863,
0.0397043563,
0.0211574119,
-0.0240782313,
0.0384052619,
0.0339844674,
-0.0229393933,
0.0124272956,
0.0493889861,
-0.0452889316,
-0.0773352534,
0.0421472341,
-0.0221875757,
-0.0515134372,
-0.0153393522,
-0.0018933822,
0.0024997266,
0.0023005293,
0.0056512197,
0.0661198348,
-0.0128855985,
0.0077284444,
0.0284410249,
-0.0679959804,
0.007869971,
-0.0599504746,
-0.0237414446,
-0.0153924506,
0.0833397433,
0.0119866151,
-0.033220537,
-0.0160209984,
0.041251611,
0.030787468,
0.0169623084,
0.0278156176,
0.0329480059,
-0.0064854114,
0.0171044394,
0.0046159127,
0.0052217771,
0.0207691323,
0.0146305123,
0.0482144989,
-0.0311477855,
0.0336373039,
0.0684315413,
0.0257199649,
-0.0170097146,
-0.0396380387,
0.0891345963,
0.0726740956,
-0.0031586203,
0.0149588697,
-0.0442482941,
-0.057166364,
-0.028316848,
-0.0496907048,
0.0022783824,
-0.0205801167,
-0.0463913344,
0.0301328227,
-0.045097407,
-0.0617044009,
-0.0641674399,
-0.0166677758,
-0.0100421319,
0.0136234583,
-0.0078512793,
-0.0499050394,
0.0352333263,
-0.0292505044,
0.0497734919,
-0.0165673327,
-0.0157599058,
-0.0415313058,
-0.0120055629,
-0.0103405388,
0.0220896918,
-0.048733823,
-0.0065592011,
-0.0308004897,
-0.0078343786,
0.0000726568,
0.0203019958,
-0.0017965673,
-0.003050152,
0.0255568847,
0.0306041092,
-0.0224146694,
0.0598601624,
0.0186474472,
-0.000768172,
-0.0494498275,
-0.0097065605,
0.0003780945,
-0.0166147519,
-0.010103696,
-0.0224426705,
-0.0224873535,
0.041963134,
-0.0076140622,
-0.0676109418,
0.026560992,
0.0184898321,
2.789e-7,
0.0024381098,
0.0378367566,
-0.0002064367,
0.0140195219,
-0.0122953625,
0.0140162613,
0.0289980676,
-0.0273982324,
0.0717142746,
0.0050646854,
0.0287282597,
0.017911341,
0.0172886867,
0.026317412,
-0.1010660529,
-0.0728416368,
0.0020698996,
0.0268055685,
-0.0356289968,
0.0381374694,
0.1145570278,
0.0056101931,
0.0184711684,
-0.0203665923,
-0.0101979552,
-0.0244696178,
0.0188506451,
-0.0172040202,
-0.0206462331,
0.0552350618,
0.0207702555,
0.0322612561,
0.0144316154,
0.0209261291,
-0.0088307001,
0.005865966,
-0.0130013181,
0.0426873565,
0.0405433849,
-0.0025579145,
0.0088128094,
0.0281553138,
0.0111092925,
-0.0612940006,
0.0540051013,
-0.0209237467,
0.0029636316,
0.0394282229,
-0.0246983021,
-0.0348847434,
-0.0144568002,
-0.0333339609,
-0.0272955112,
0.0296323169,
-0.0209961198,
-0.041461464,
0.0501181409,
-0.0412692763,
-0.0091301454,
0.0249142945,
-0.0258847009,
-0.0339396931,
-0.0570647866,
-0.0104043819,
-0.0205966216,
-0.0480399206,
0.0325802304,
2.011880392e-34,
0.0006613032,
-0.0161808953,
0.0511249192,
-0.0285057407,
0.001342476,
0.0001395306,
0.0403803997,
0.0290586632,
0.0642372444,
-0.0602039993,
-0.0270278435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12767v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12767v1 | Furthest Reasoning with Plan Assessment: Stable Reasoning Path with Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models | 2023-09-22T10:15:13 | 2023-09-22T10:15:13 | Yin Zhu, Zhiling Luo, Gong Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs), acting as a powerful reasoner and generator,
exhibit extraordinary performance across various natural language tasks, such
as question answering (QA). Among these tasks, Multi-Hop Question Answering
(MHQA) stands as a widely discussed category, necessitating seamless
integration between LLMs and the retrieval of external knowledge. Existing
methods employ LLM to generate reasoning paths and plans, and utilize IR to
iteratively retrieve related knowledge, but these approaches have inherent
flaws. On one hand, Information Retriever (IR) is hindered by the low quality
of generated queries by LLM. On the other hand, LLM is easily misguided by the
irrelevant knowledge by IR. These inaccuracies, accumulated by the iterative
interaction between IR and LLM, lead to a disaster in effectiveness at the end.
To overcome above barriers, in this paper, we propose a novel pipeline for MHQA
called Furthest-Reasoning-with-Plan-Assessment (FuRePA), including an improved
framework (Furthest Reasoning) and an attached module (Plan Assessor). 1)
Furthest reasoning operates by masking previous reasoning path and generated
queries for LLM, encouraging LLM generating chain of thought from scratch in
each iteration. This approach enables LLM to break the shackle built by
previous misleading thoughts and queries (if any). 2) The Plan Assessor is a
trained evaluator that selects an appropriate plan from a group of candidate
plans proposed by LLM. Our methods are evaluated on three highly recognized
public multi-hop question answering datasets and outperform state-of-the-art on
most metrics (achieving a 10%-12% in answer accuracy). | [
0.0377218947,
0.0487047434,
0.0060343454,
0.0393037125,
-0.0547654405,
-0.0013078987,
-0.0168543141,
-0.0137561504,
0.0399624109,
-0.0428711399,
-0.017283259,
-0.0244987532,
-0.0653928369,
0.0133638754,
0.0052913553,
0.0026063125,
0.0475431234,
-0.0519625358,
0.0121324686,
-0.0095779765,
-0.0123338858,
0.0400642827,
-0.0126885464,
0.024020724,
-0.0074425037,
-0.0382014513,
-0.0273840111,
-0.0102697946,
0.0237593576,
-0.0449624844,
0.0202400666,
0.0064707464,
0.0291786306,
-0.0142479241,
0.0000020115,
-0.0564786866,
-0.0419420451,
0.0102870958,
-0.0459222719,
-0.0515827686,
-0.0682239234,
0.0307772141,
0.0413890146,
0.0370422527,
-0.0532877147,
0.0393563583,
0.0022302384,
0.0739309564,
0.0776281282,
0.0689782798,
0.0244246926,
-0.0843967795,
0.0135840718,
-0.0022631229,
0.0237849876,
-0.0660246313,
0.0433533899,
0.0435054824,
0.0254901834,
0.0334070921,
0.0016125244,
0.0052795196,
0.0310606807,
0.0097032748,
-0.02203466,
0.0162990354,
-0.0098187318,
-0.0160576589,
-0.0060499655,
0.0907522589,
0.0256802309,
-0.0083344011,
0.0062321364,
0.0227178093,
-0.020416759,
0.0161816422,
-0.0565042943,
0.0256868266,
-0.0231668688,
0.0028149956,
0.0056986078,
-0.0077860518,
0.0267535504,
0.0331861489,
-0.0434247591,
0.100433901,
-0.005459338,
-0.0415717624,
0.0431486852,
-0.0092128906,
-0.0062033162,
-0.0608400851,
0.0091299191,
0.1061811522,
-0.0494195335,
0.0394382365,
0.0439976007,
0.0123813488,
0.0384719186,
-0.0085473731,
0.002079448,
0.0331763662,
-0.0013394048,
0.0789809972,
-0.0245398115,
0.0213898066,
-0.0393428802,
0.0106378654,
-0.0420297012,
-0.0281368252,
-0.0599805005,
-0.0355979316,
-0.0278748088,
0.0781065971,
-0.0541671589,
-0.0136683984,
-0.0111166313,
0.039296411,
-0.0082546826,
0.0085075824,
0.0199931655,
0.0493021086,
0.0102112414,
-0.0358339958,
-0.070627369,
0.04331135,
-0.0652854666,
0.0306582488,
0.0150246313,
-0.0233456045,
-0.0300847739,
0.0084145116,
0.0248312354,
-0.0184429102,
0.0208560489,
0.0831392333,
-0.0148469163,
-0.0104458835,
-0.0323099159,
-0.080077827,
-0.0055202069,
-0.0824837461,
0.0111084832,
-0.0499985963,
0.0269842837,
0.0115222475,
-0.0298790857,
-0.0098931137,
0.0259523857,
0.0372971445,
-0.0177999288,
0.0431473665,
0.0205902122,
-0.0001439082,
0.0144108962,
0.0324695185,
-0.02044148,
0.0643966049,
-0.0064128013,
0.0190722011,
0.0367726609,
0.0275960751,
0.0153225577,
-0.0000931308,
0.0221187882,
-0.0128939096,
0.024855556,
0.0743214563,
-0.0007732662,
0.000483322,
-0.0273985472,
0.0450600497,
-0.0365338288,
0.01351579,
0.0004350413,
0.0285545178,
0.0263044666,
0.0031253933,
0.0390870422,
-0.0043509556,
-0.0079998635,
-0.0068219248,
-0.0375833288,
0.0424106494,
-0.0513326004,
0.0090884073,
0.0375939608,
0.0158238709,
-0.0242001731,
-0.0553823486,
-0.0102590723,
-0.0070918016,
-0.0225251894,
0.0607478879,
0.0474981889,
0.0090870578,
-0.046455916,
0.0580794178,
0.0002319305,
-0.0018829536,
0.0174883641,
-0.0288580582,
0.0619778037,
0.0714383796,
0.0378746763,
-0.0516312942,
-0.022852188,
-0.0052115875,
0.007487061,
-0.0090528568,
0.0228363425,
-0.037737634,
0.024440879,
-0.0471387096,
-0.0359613374,
-0.030702889,
-0.0115316631,
-0.0063062552,
0.0275325812,
0.0073652342,
0.0221617296,
-0.032083571,
0.029801514,
0.022842532,
-0.0387101918,
-0.0246625263,
-0.0056142784,
-0.0025244777,
0.0215765834,
0.0366564803,
-0.0119532282,
0.0425538942,
0.0434184819,
-0.0310907401,
-0.0519148074,
-0.0207673945,
-0.0219630655,
-0.0522934683,
0.0421507433,
-0.0169953741,
-0.0105647258,
0.0034928387,
-0.0427082814,
-0.0373512357,
-0.0045385687,
-0.0127460826,
0.0125040906,
-0.0471254326,
-0.0163369011,
0.0352510512,
-0.0315309539,
-0.0524643883,
0.081836015,
0.0095669581,
0.0257166252,
-0.009698783,
0.0008454382,
0.0026100159,
-0.0244825818,
0.0101282932,
0.025808854,
-0.0013893561,
0.0109010255,
0.0334068388,
0.0103950854,
-0.086411722,
-0.0408764482,
-0.0835662559,
0.031418208,
-0.0384475403,
0.0243621469,
0.011637521,
0.0105057014,
0.0161679052,
-0.0117389429,
-0.0668429807,
0.0090654036,
0.0194064919,
0.0247721691,
0.0325611494,
0.0315780528,
-0.0055538169,
-0.007871964,
0.0005943723,
-0.0220652614,
0.0298526268,
-0.0074788951,
0.0067857592,
-0.0419068784,
-0.0231155716,
-0.0683055893,
0.0174870435,
-0.0004951023,
0.0089721698,
0.0208024774,
-0.0338500105,
-0.0086992076,
0.031493932,
0.0086168535,
-0.0366061367,
0.0301324725,
-0.0072766785,
-0.0613794997,
0.0511181764,
-0.0495112129,
-0.0084700966,
-0.0233975705,
0.0092261517,
0.0061611203,
0.0390919596,
-0.0062965769,
-0.0159190688,
-0.0369131379,
0.0467851944,
0.017972922,
-0.0043247426,
-0.0414399952,
-0.0131627414,
0.0148033956,
0.0373561196,
-0.0042574028,
0.001542357,
0.0896034688,
0.0032097353,
0.0056998427,
-0.030767085,
0.0122774309,
-0.0844806582,
0.0613004677,
-0.0288295895,
0.0191461686,
-0.034416873,
-0.0111740539,
-0.0191408861,
-0.0317845009,
-0.0180187058,
-0.057116624,
0.0323481821,
-0.0554790646,
0.0193884224,
0.0152552789,
-0.0548031591,
-0.0567978173,
-0.026094405,
-0.0449335724,
0.0224769339,
-0.0524676479,
0.0116455033,
0.0039711781,
-0.0137526132,
0.0467476696,
0.0033320889,
-0.0254291873,
-0.0076026968,
-0.0086010862,
0.0316116363,
0.0823471397,
0.0418599211,
0.0309180394,
0.003052989,
0.0538451858,
0.0589304231,
0.0131671978,
-0.0100093726,
0.0226937868,
0.0183561295,
0.0099858474,
-0.0292579588,
-0.0128023867,
0.0198093243,
0.0713233203,
-0.0464794375,
-0.0145235788,
0.1035856977,
0.0309710186,
0.0034517853,
-0.0081179515,
-0.0334948264,
0.0145920729,
0.023165293,
0.0442579314,
-0.0781832337,
-0.0510238297,
-0.0112396916,
0.0194874108,
-0.0049866764,
-0.0560524538,
-0.0047828858,
-0.1145966649,
0.0196842961,
-0.0205993485,
-0.0305600837,
-0.0313754827,
-0.0468896218,
0.0035395606,
0.0135196997,
0.004834631,
0.0345142707,
0.0002756894,
0.0064593088,
0.0210536215,
0.002180136,
0.00585075,
0.0622821338,
-0.0018212908,
-0.0116984267,
0.069995895,
0.0113031985,
0.0180532932,
-0.0595698841,
0.0151306307,
-0.0556154437,
0.0169684179,
-0.0083764242,
0.0181968883,
-0.012850577,
-0.0067893369,
-0.0174637754,
0.0523645282,
-0.0530883074,
-0.0241677798,
0.0288297571,
0.0904983878,
-0.0404841155,
0.0056695398,
-0.0128801428,
0.0067906091,
-0.0064600948,
0.0686591566,
-0.0020149874,
-0.0089667011,
-0.0639631003,
-0.0090201814,
-0.0184354354,
-0.0655764863,
-0.0286914669,
0.0350539871,
0.0139535712,
0.0676865131,
-0.0568112843,
-0.0653666258,
0.0267552976,
0.064102307,
-0.023148546,
0.0218871515,
0.0091826664,
0.0259610936,
-0.0290495772,
0.013154665,
-0.0455606058,
0.0074909581,
-0.0056503536,
0.0173106696,
0.0242545493,
-0.0237216391,
-0.0236701313,
0.0115225567,
-0.0758653656,
-0.0416306555,
-0.0246657692,
0.0293039791,
0.0171460714,
0.0399756879,
-0.0232507065,
-0.0214280691,
0.0405311026,
-0.003417287,
-0.031400457,
0.0062520504,
0.0161252357,
0.0408300906,
-0.0186943095,
0.0485902801,
-0.0697310194,
0.0041632652,
0.0116047692,
0.0810962096,
-0.0147506045,
-0.013359298,
0.0383243971,
0.0479427986,
0.0167744271,
0.0340326317,
-0.005136664,
-0.0038796039,
0.0343288071,
-0.0357436314,
-0.0510958061,
-0.0115154833,
0.0341226608,
0.0245827027,
-0.0713803396,
0.0112635223,
-0.0310501382,
0.0157665648,
0.0128317298,
-0.0045719789,
0.0013446276,
0.0084933471,
-0.0265235435,
0.0235998929,
-0.0242654625,
-0.0489002168,
-0.0153812952,
0.0245658755,
0.0734982565,
-0.005807891,
0.0682539567,
0.0436317548,
-0.0170363113,
-0.0557880178,
-0.0093027428,
-0.0809147581,
-0.1025314033,
0.0009450861,
0.030514719,
0.027485773,
0.0283143874,
0.0228195935,
-0.0022183708,
-0.0125599783,
-0.0056525543,
-0.0124866115,
0.0273013208,
-0.0362927802,
0.0567359515,
0.0387980118,
-0.0143635925,
0.0028454976,
0.05163268,
-0.0407886133,
0.0368100367,
-0.0192954354,
-0.021738302,
-0.0454536006,
-0.0393464193,
-0.0335947834,
0.0092419479,
0.0092130313,
0.0090541281,
-0.0549562089,
-0.0499430597,
0.0061038053,
0.008433383,
-0.033140514,
-0.0082967877,
0.0228230618,
0.0636190921,
0.025509011,
-0.0645521507,
-0.0464241505,
0.0241780151,
-0.0308044776,
-0.0153391659,
-0.0184070431,
-6.42882342e-33,
0.0101337163,
-0.0307748448,
0.0628472641,
-0.0649773031,
-0.0509549826,
-0.0024246532,
-0.0330552794,
-0.0211908519,
-0.0515120551,
0.0023159347,
-0.0318192467,
0.0075333165,
0.0004279446,
0.0338807143,
0.0126744611,
-0.0520242378,
-0.0012383594,
0.007985102,
-0.0331102163,
0.018134648,
0.0641830936,
0.010243346,
0.0197803602,
-0.0073012174,
0.0055823429,
0.0049982965,
0.0052914438,
0.0801019073,
-0.0445761345,
0.0576529689,
-0.012150228,
0.0190499593,
0.0483692549,
-0.0411073603,
0.012834412,
0.0339439772,
-0.0923944041,
-0.0468081944,
0.0260109566,
-0.022014901,
-0.0626498535,
-0.0389534421,
0.0228201412,
-0.0067850105,
0.0352244228,
-0.0219771676,
-0.002350765,
-0.0055262158,
0.0037464127,
-0.0092883362,
-0.0101566017,
0.0111272661,
-0.0360963531,
-0.0057787201,
-0.0208380315,
0.0810678452,
0.0039979089,
0.0218210686,
-0.0430779606,
0.0051293601,
-0.0287746284,
0.0178316068,
0.0489144884,
0.0215703286,
0.0075855148,
0.0629723147,
0.016775826,
-0.0140186632,
-0.0398329459,
-0.0148440218,
-0.0411429144,
0.047656253,
0.0049930457,
0.0241456926,
0.0024717706,
0.0231819227,
-0.0996005833,
0.0077022589,
-0.0100784935,
0.0502397716,
0.0422732979,
-0.0073197642,
-0.0198311582,
-0.0199907143,
-0.0698127598,
0.0393438525,
-0.0270990804,
-0.0028928767,
0.0305806492,
0.0329734422,
-0.0162706785,
0.0262270086,
0.0230955686,
-0.0472853817,
0.0032332486,
0.0630217046,
-0.0233080685,
0.0026615567,
-0.005071803,
0.0574888438,
-0.0453389622,
0.0106169563,
0.0077890987,
-0.0083102025,
-0.0089794351,
0.0030434006,
0.0120535176,
-0.0120593486,
-0.0435517505,
-0.0135943927,
-0.061361976,
0.0289829597,
-0.0219071787,
-0.0127399703,
0.0498807877,
0.050346788,
-0.0104916226,
0.0400701277,
0.0096153133,
0.003120227,
-0.0096952226,
-0.0041857278,
0.0200107414,
0.0017407599,
-0.0165673438,
0.0113030067,
0.0066069849,
0.0040223482,
-0.0296231639,
-0.0565423481,
-0.0044841911,
0.0681672916,
2.719e-7,
0.0427766331,
0.0220221635,
0.0282544643,
0.0479339883,
0.0100930706,
0.025469603,
0.0095778955,
-0.001711507,
0.0256601442,
-0.0493536852,
-0.0073386766,
0.0578491203,
0.0183762945,
0.048614718,
-0.0645192415,
-0.006119661,
-0.0221886467,
-0.0700285137,
-0.0512030162,
-0.0267043784,
0.0947159305,
0.0577573664,
-0.0041402644,
-0.0100965705,
-0.017549647,
-0.0425072424,
0.052433338,
0.0081078904,
-0.0241997205,
0.0146079566,
0.0258339792,
-0.0190549698,
0.0269196332,
0.0159493368,
-0.0012024303,
0.0325811245,
-0.0298966188,
0.0761783868,
0.0062962505,
-0.0896447301,
-0.0352980755,
-0.0318663754,
0.0352786183,
-0.045086123,
0.1074904352,
-0.0326372981,
-0.0251907464,
-0.00377567,
-0.0304611381,
-0.0265545379,
-0.0055867061,
-0.0021442398,
-0.0042730328,
0.0289834738,
0.0044311746,
-0.0082171857,
0.0283065345,
-0.099382937,
-0.0047128997,
0.0217631217,
-0.0372041166,
-0.0312988795,
0.0060291975,
0.0035240673,
0.0006223753,
-0.0609386489,
-0.0083323447,
2.344615777e-34,
0.0218987521,
-0.0057804813,
0.0270076506,
0.0194804166,
0.0614415742,
-0.0015089008,
-0.0173773747,
-0.0038570964,
0.0212177429,
-0.1123704985,
-0.021272501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12763v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12763v2 | Reduce, Reuse, Recycle: Is Perturbed Data better than Other Language augmentation for Low Resource Self-Supervised Speech Models | 2023-09-22T10:09:09 | 2024-06-28T18:45:32 | Asad Ullah, Alessandro Ragano, Andrew Hines | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Self-supervised representation learning (SSRL) has demonstrated superior
performance than supervised models for tasks including phoneme recognition.
Training SSRL models poses a challenge for low-resource languages where
sufficient pre-training data may not be available. A common approach is
cross-lingual pre-training. Instead, we propose to use audio augmentation
techniques, namely: pitch variation, noise addition, accented target language
and other language speech to pre-train SSRL models in a low resource condition
and evaluate phoneme recognition. Our comparisons found that a combined
synthetic augmentations (noise/pitch) strategy outperformed accent and language
knowledge transfer. Furthermore, we examined the scaling factor of augmented
data to achieve equivalent performance to model pre-trained with target domain
speech. Our findings suggest that for resource-constrained languages, combined
augmentations can be a viable option than other augmentations. | [
-0.0385728329,
0.0766423568,
0.0002076529,
0.0099006286,
0.0165191572,
-0.0194389652,
0.0656386539,
-0.0474937446,
-0.0061777141,
0.02566709,
-0.092798464,
-0.0076945284,
0.0067018582,
-0.0067828237,
0.0382354409,
-0.0517182238,
0.0438868254,
-0.0515216365,
-0.0287669133,
-0.0401433371,
-0.0038375214,
-0.0001397362,
-0.0348266885,
0.0036837154,
-0.0348580815,
0.016997911,
-0.020938715,
0.0081831804,
0.0016341452,
-0.0035069436,
-0.0521634705,
0.0515160635,
0.039338246,
0.0222233534,
0.000001831,
-0.0694683716,
-0.026496252,
-0.0025895908,
-0.0786268339,
0.0500751734,
0.0655131713,
0.0047504478,
-0.0604103468,
0.0201760735,
0.0007657379,
-0.0624008812,
0.063540183,
-0.0101541216,
0.0395172462,
0.066424869,
-0.0086677223,
-0.014794237,
-0.0004800642,
-0.0317459814,
-0.0018251752,
0.0080253519,
-0.001472167,
0.0073388889,
-0.0298908316,
-0.0144093074,
0.0007487196,
0.0618293099,
0.0009561336,
0.0066542118,
0.0224695969,
0.0100278137,
-0.04944304,
-0.0130192395,
0.0085087633,
0.0259920117,
-0.0184081551,
-0.0258502811,
-0.0253383256,
0.0141399102,
0.0046822904,
-0.0324876793,
-0.0141085871,
-0.0231058542,
0.0748967826,
0.0206056703,
-0.0104207154,
0.0438840613,
0.054836534,
-0.0218664166,
-0.0193947833,
0.0027717152,
-0.0030791252,
-0.0325261354,
-0.0122848256,
-0.0243608095,
0.0077192783,
0.024848232,
0.0224395692,
0.0077523855,
0.0421239287,
-0.0060328199,
-0.0359231122,
-0.0816976652,
-0.0065456829,
-0.0140098808,
0.0080238488,
0.0242522955,
-0.0698095188,
-0.0021318877,
-0.0249025822,
0.0074162623,
0.0201668814,
-0.0263655651,
-0.0306404587,
0.0095004877,
0.0138666816,
-0.0044900221,
-0.0673142374,
0.0300562624,
-0.0008091147,
0.0308983754,
-0.0312471669,
-0.009519035,
-0.0461383834,
-0.0020264832,
0.0356646478,
-0.0155553883,
-0.0660343543,
-0.0175580401,
-0.0053726593,
0.0527476594,
0.0207923185,
0.04393306,
-0.0336862914,
-0.0831387639,
0.0021800811,
0.0201061834,
0.0457422547,
-0.0007145358,
0.04011539,
0.0509107374,
0.0028820152,
-0.0267159119,
-0.0587626286,
0.0300003272,
-0.0305602364,
-0.0466073155,
-0.0324531049,
-0.0709754676,
0.0238789339,
-0.0429267995,
0.0039933086,
-0.0240135994,
-0.0216588043,
-0.0536493286,
0.043417301,
0.0555530041,
-0.0427079201,
0.0310749188,
0.0391475558,
-0.0205904786,
0.0157122146,
0.0535902418,
0.0486285873,
-0.0379817076,
0.0075093638,
-0.0741766095,
-0.0244737789,
0.0358678289,
0.0473342985,
0.02532891,
-0.0231295899,
-0.0126697859,
-0.0088788746,
0.0041225287,
0.0589853004,
0.0040237089,
-0.0147447297,
-0.0471503772,
0.058373712,
0.0467985012,
0.023211604,
0.0262703504,
0.0149735808,
0.0132722072,
0.0011442072,
0.0027894103,
-0.0067049456,
-0.016028557,
-0.0080144275,
0.0075311209,
0.0480331741,
0.0514531881,
-0.0589807332,
-0.0263345838,
0.0194303673,
-0.0670016259,
-0.0020883556,
0.0341898799,
0.0618697368,
0.0163544808,
0.0272976812,
0.0345143378,
0.0196346771,
-0.0457196571,
0.0358250029,
-0.02402303,
-0.0418783464,
0.0224343296,
-0.024205301,
-0.0404841937,
-0.0261697005,
-0.0214327481,
-0.0106648412,
0.0155440168,
0.0389401279,
0.0415931344,
0.0681919828,
-0.021181155,
0.0089098774,
0.0123831853,
-0.0044342023,
0.0627325177,
-0.0345781296,
0.0335692018,
0.0035703261,
-0.04303471,
-0.0107657826,
-0.0408327468,
-0.0204272326,
-0.0430084579,
0.0471276455,
0.0292598382,
0.0414585359,
0.0450976826,
-0.0428299904,
-0.0005657778,
0.018598197,
-0.0299645532,
0.0367449746,
0.0495718271,
-0.07724756,
-0.0493235216,
0.0437514596,
-0.0007731467,
0.0255052652,
0.0155075071,
0.046245832,
-0.0837980956,
0.1118190512,
-0.0323703848,
0.0653151721,
-0.0714572817,
0.0395098291,
-0.0020825772,
0.0406348035,
0.034171015,
0.0045236456,
0.0542971902,
-0.0371708944,
-0.0254560914,
0.0602003075,
0.0444824882,
-0.0501329154,
-0.058046516,
0.0029095025,
-0.033444766,
0.0266372785,
-0.0133388629,
-0.034485437,
-0.0028494541,
0.036110457,
-0.0628383085,
-0.0426247716,
-0.013235773,
0.0275478177,
-0.0265739597,
0.0443967544,
0.004157349,
-0.0563850887,
-0.0177843701,
-0.0372367986,
0.0020727662,
-0.0020575623,
-0.0398641303,
-0.0020478007,
0.0260123089,
-0.0133667942,
-0.0036277447,
0.0481672958,
-0.021985421,
-0.0153175974,
-0.0238196421,
-0.0135322912,
-0.0010349811,
0.0046986053,
0.0588528253,
0.0168265346,
-0.0313484669,
-0.0347257666,
-0.0086532095,
0.0698440373,
-0.0059687663,
-0.0300841462,
-0.036299184,
0.0732709318,
-0.0126739666,
-0.0600877181,
0.0111471433,
0.0161697585,
0.0302190129,
-0.0361926593,
0.0387412123,
-0.026546225,
0.0111285578,
-0.0084043834,
-0.0052732853,
-0.0358465798,
-0.0429853089,
-0.0043810522,
-0.0497655757,
-0.0112708537,
-0.0173078291,
-0.0323535278,
0.0468599461,
-0.0062352978,
-0.0565481745,
0.0264029838,
-0.0805404037,
-0.0503228344,
-0.054464329,
-0.0690167323,
0.0011541289,
0.0037312133,
-0.0015011925,
0.0207072999,
-0.0153875751,
-0.0487952307,
0.0034454914,
0.0236567874,
0.0260623917,
-0.0517450646,
-0.0000316065,
0.0044096108,
0.0116942571,
0.0070276204,
-0.0315782465,
-0.0368843451,
-0.018467417,
-0.0013222474,
-0.0083096977,
0.0089223171,
-0.0208905488,
-0.0095064659,
0.0375083089,
0.0275346637,
0.0708821863,
0.0083293375,
0.0300677512,
0.0038646793,
-0.0143521521,
-0.0022664873,
0.0644143298,
-0.0166091695,
0.016059719,
0.0328178182,
-0.0376880094,
0.0691918731,
-0.0458680503,
-0.0701179951,
0.0396568775,
0.0236632936,
0.0307233762,
-0.0275537558,
-0.001356229,
0.0369625948,
-0.0367510766,
0.000107315,
0.0706417635,
-0.0165114775,
-0.0170393586,
0.0030998399,
-0.0345942862,
0.0000794014,
0.0057230573,
0.026499616,
-0.0234806854,
0.0045387433,
0.0181150176,
0.0128227174,
0.0113933347,
0.0358172283,
-0.0124829942,
-0.1165554971,
0.0451828614,
0.039646782,
-0.0511949658,
-0.0407729112,
-0.0504743308,
-0.0057821092,
-0.0397348925,
0.0235048477,
-0.0184710976,
-0.0302287079,
-0.0435145944,
0.0432696976,
-0.0783335716,
-0.0781093538,
-0.0360110216,
-0.0456837714,
0.077476427,
0.0503358059,
-0.022347087,
-0.0243886057,
-0.0641542152,
0.0245404616,
0.0329324044,
0.0134623786,
-0.0207302608,
0.050242871,
0.0509182587,
-0.0281361099,
0.0631558225,
0.0014635392,
-0.0023219713,
-0.0073511731,
0.0149542168,
0.0745313466,
-0.0122078694,
0.0564749204,
0.0324306712,
0.0299671236,
0.0069893124,
0.0500734597,
0.032691896,
-0.0194043703,
0.0135881035,
0.039942842,
0.0214746315,
-0.0303708538,
0.0094085597,
0.0376803875,
-0.0020813721,
-0.0933896527,
0.0008940816,
-0.0260914732,
-0.0043293238,
0.0467638448,
0.019143546,
0.0315877944,
-0.0156302787,
0.0242672767,
-0.0095081376,
0.0372404903,
-0.0145641007,
0.0222980808,
-0.0206531156,
-0.0462445207,
-0.0121521726,
-0.0724515989,
0.0096643884,
-0.0735449716,
-0.0278563648,
-0.0407135375,
0.0304720812,
0.0083450908,
0.0131282201,
0.0972050726,
-0.0475508049,
-0.0454279333,
0.0339900441,
0.0263652727,
-0.0559055321,
0.0041912687,
0.0918857232,
-0.0380769074,
0.0037003052,
0.0276144631,
-0.0090542873,
0.0730387419,
-0.0196665898,
-0.0272182412,
-0.0422319062,
-0.0258918833,
-0.0134070618,
0.0237340201,
0.0370813981,
-0.0117939916,
0.0588498712,
-0.0419982634,
0.0185016301,
-0.0030924119,
0.0645651147,
-0.0233855806,
-0.0330988839,
0.0426710732,
0.0450077578,
0.0262064878,
0.0085211117,
-0.0325263552,
-0.0339233875,
0.0137266442,
0.0488637909,
-0.0050072353,
0.0297670439,
-0.0170524195,
0.058496926,
0.0165830385,
0.0314291343,
0.0388940349,
-0.0055915117,
0.0014074808,
-0.0638758987,
-0.0149448896,
0.0064406022,
-0.0061205998,
0.0039993939,
-0.0125661604,
-0.0146211917,
-0.0133943791,
-0.014771224,
0.0292392168,
-0.0442645214,
0.0467702895,
-0.0108142402,
0.0287033673,
-0.0215787068,
-0.0287314989,
-0.0369153395,
0.0368907936,
0.0043885875,
0.0003448853,
-0.0132836923,
0.02121149,
0.0273434483,
-0.0176773742,
0.0340008028,
-0.0391405113,
0.0412172973,
-0.0231999811,
-0.0397888646,
-0.0258303396,
0.0364274159,
-0.0471067317,
0.0100720823,
0.0027036578,
-0.1081623584,
-0.0290570166,
-0.0000686221,
-0.0175800268,
-0.0021474524,
0.0128204431,
0.0024581398,
-0.0158468001,
0.0568052493,
0.0283888299,
-0.0397181958,
0.0388224572,
-0.0085662026,
0.0641163066,
-6.056849621e-33,
-0.0038326096,
0.0571440533,
0.0235420279,
-0.0253433939,
-0.0084787756,
0.0157279465,
-0.0328793451,
0.0420028307,
-0.0111512449,
-0.0221524443,
0.0107492432,
-0.0284869447,
0.0282375645,
0.043572031,
0.0057925745,
0.0358198807,
0.0881882533,
-0.0020406151,
0.0254173856,
0.0051268227,
0.0173567552,
0.0418866388,
0.0602956526,
-0.0830080882,
-0.0496499278,
0.0288543925,
0.005816048,
-0.0250212923,
0.0447989702,
0.0394999459,
0.0143250227,
0.0517384671,
-0.0238933004,
-0.0435776711,
-0.0365754291,
0.0013096968,
-0.0993282795,
-0.034383785,
0.0022945816,
0.0508246422,
-0.0094370339,
0.0038974923,
0.0210403632,
0.013091173,
-0.0182270017,
0.0222485438,
0.0122167077,
-0.0528803244,
0.0109893689,
0.008213033,
-0.026152296,
0.0424789786,
0.0089880815,
0.018953966,
0.0910856426,
0.0628036857,
-0.0485734455,
-0.0140751442,
-0.0598319694,
0.0461023264,
0.0298976023,
0.0237801746,
0.0574555025,
0.0284649711,
-0.0025503044,
0.019177353,
0.0644048154,
-0.0577205643,
0.0492108166,
0.0065620611,
0.0796502978,
0.0060579209,
-0.0033877036,
0.0217058435,
0.0607531965,
-0.0269394554,
-0.0131374951,
0.0066069933,
0.0303777736,
-0.0320199989,
-0.0039140512,
0.028172398,
-0.0361230448,
0.0002832403,
-0.0283888429,
-0.0172622818,
-0.0247713998,
-0.0621640868,
0.0326024145,
0.0033727554,
-0.0176428556,
0.0864535645,
0.0682678521,
-0.0026212067,
-0.0025012339,
-0.0415733457,
0.0189194363,
-0.0484720878,
0.0051458771,
0.0258252639,
-0.0438423976,
-0.00174958,
0.058666788,
0.0282965992,
0.0034800603,
-0.0145065524,
0.023382267,
0.0510387309,
-0.0549808554,
-0.0104238177,
-0.0081194947,
-0.0047341362,
0.0243112743,
0.0429428555,
0.0321231782,
0.0081797261,
-0.010753083,
0.0346743986,
0.0133570582,
-0.0271884352,
-0.0132731032,
-0.013524469,
-0.0081333285,
0.0146843595,
-0.0047258735,
-0.000568773,
-0.0086522587,
-0.0224593375,
0.0159834567,
-0.033789061,
-0.0101043349,
0.0128841568,
2.744e-7,
-0.0000434379,
-0.0308299176,
0.0147760827,
-0.0422583185,
0.0261122845,
0.0031546389,
-0.064707011,
-0.0177975129,
0.0055092215,
0.0309555773,
0.0276489034,
0.0314478949,
0.0626087114,
0.0253843907,
-0.0343215466,
-0.0236285087,
-0.0592760555,
0.0152067794,
-0.0202364866,
0.0086603602,
-0.0056679044,
0.0747544095,
0.0066409367,
-0.0759777501,
0.0186207369,
0.0098054968,
0.0101536,
-0.025069816,
0.0041019749,
-0.0298659317,
-0.0068248985,
0.0543860681,
-0.0275136326,
0.0177909844,
-0.0657526255,
0.0437700041,
-0.0099199684,
-0.0023585067,
-0.0133632403,
-0.0471224412,
0.0287255179,
0.0807798654,
-0.0409503952,
0.0088943923,
0.0475157723,
0.0017140716,
-0.0303581525,
-0.0099087479,
-0.0403072387,
0.0209671315,
0.0113648558,
-0.0203099847,
-0.0244891997,
-0.0232831482,
0.0183147825,
-0.0167287458,
-0.0551869981,
-0.0185772516,
0.0164095219,
0.0559917167,
-0.0566045381,
-0.0122345621,
-0.0414124206,
-0.0059835063,
0.0226468071,
0.0125226509,
0.0193251558,
1.984686065e-34,
-0.0006776122,
-0.0476082563,
0.0247805715,
-0.0133837024,
-0.0655224547,
-0.0268063284,
0.0468060151,
0.0128623601,
0.0028879682,
-0.0209491998,
-0.0504963472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12727v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12727v1 | In-context Interference in Chat-based Large Language Models | 2023-09-22T09:18:55 | 2023-09-22T09:18:55 | Eric Nuertey Coleman, Julio Hurtado, Vincenzo Lomonaco | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have had a huge impact on society due to their
impressive capabilities and vast knowledge of the world. Various applications
and tools have been created that allow users to interact with these models in a
black-box scenario. However, one limitation of this scenario is that users
cannot modify the internal knowledge of the model, and the only way to add or
modify internal knowledge is by explicitly mentioning it to the model during
the current interaction. This learning process is called in-context training,
and it refers to training that is confined to the user's current session or
context. In-context learning has significant applications, but also has
limitations that are seldom studied. In this paper, we present a study that
shows how the model can suffer from interference between information that
continually flows in the context, causing it to forget previously learned
knowledge, which can reduce the model's performance. Along with showing the
problem, we propose an evaluation benchmark based on the bAbI dataset. | [
0.036214903,
-0.0006795977,
-0.0282517206,
0.056878157,
-0.0287107117,
0.0030289069,
0.0173669904,
-0.0080158021,
0.050152529,
-0.0444864444,
-0.0598344319,
-0.0576483235,
0.0188245792,
0.0134732127,
-0.0024584017,
-0.0463646092,
0.0509023666,
-0.0543903783,
-0.0168397613,
-0.0138862319,
0.0051193791,
-0.026100602,
-0.0024924132,
0.0524637327,
-0.0051643457,
-0.0346762799,
-0.0242667142,
0.0040975921,
-0.0332040414,
-0.0143949809,
0.0025430929,
0.0587653592,
0.0121665038,
0.0567912012,
0.0000020535,
-0.038321279,
-0.007952516,
-0.0308815371,
-0.0478456952,
0.0290388595,
0.0538073517,
0.0377545469,
-0.0291076526,
0.0388467349,
-0.0568520315,
0.0285943057,
0.0383924544,
0.0271332879,
0.0619092286,
0.0297300518,
-0.0003745792,
0.0141334254,
0.0003193048,
-0.0183728337,
0.0175291859,
-0.074099496,
0.0367113575,
0.02074112,
-0.0072600441,
-0.0084995767,
-0.0352771282,
0.0360086523,
0.0381846316,
-0.0252198111,
0.0058957664,
0.0298117679,
-0.0254042689,
-0.0192847569,
-0.0173907951,
0.0770749375,
-0.0074135838,
-0.011562367,
0.0148954615,
0.0228752643,
0.0058418475,
-0.0140646957,
-0.0601746179,
-0.0180731732,
-0.0033931574,
-0.009726692,
-0.0133912675,
-0.0228680652,
0.0377140939,
0.0177083928,
-0.028509615,
0.0244213231,
0.0016239912,
-0.0344987102,
-0.0413488597,
-0.0037057013,
-0.0035541249,
-0.0779664367,
0.0044174204,
0.0293811392,
-0.0623393245,
0.0386594012,
-0.0333666988,
0.0037835282,
-0.0038584729,
-0.1019010246,
-0.0031205413,
0.0417437702,
0.0036067276,
0.0621166602,
0.0176580828,
0.018238103,
0.0118300831,
-0.0090960162,
0.0054389467,
0.0050554434,
-0.0666451901,
-0.0131677035,
-0.0507007875,
0.0221376661,
-0.0261589084,
-0.0444366559,
-0.0397779383,
0.0701632947,
-0.0085869404,
0.0203147195,
-0.0252375174,
-0.0236762594,
-0.0313150324,
-0.0104063349,
-0.0134660779,
0.0230660178,
0.005459066,
-0.0110673411,
-0.0021312716,
-0.0909906626,
0.0287797432,
-0.0173339378,
-0.0093504414,
0.0112961307,
-0.0415290669,
0.0632880405,
-0.0007988054,
-0.0292487126,
-0.0191548038,
-0.041396413,
-0.0069528082,
-0.0647079051,
-0.019952707,
-0.0514967144,
0.0070595476,
0.0154568888,
-0.0099747954,
-0.0399575196,
0.0023746907,
0.0075832461,
-0.0062870015,
0.0667056888,
-0.0304487627,
0.006122306,
0.0541276447,
0.0481483564,
-0.0040746797,
0.1033379212,
0.0157228131,
-0.0008194518,
0.0397585593,
-0.0210667215,
0.0009630149,
0.0633706078,
0.009160554,
0.0181644671,
-0.0332949087,
0.0016658913,
0.0276406985,
0.0352264568,
-0.005651501,
0.0363365971,
-0.0482944287,
0.0249477234,
0.0999774709,
0.0462502912,
0.0163332541,
0.0243193563,
-0.0101363547,
0.0239356142,
0.0163754802,
0.0310089309,
-0.0470316187,
-0.0047708456,
-0.0304086227,
0.007600741,
0.0380560569,
0.0120966369,
-0.0286910012,
-0.0304074772,
0.0194364972,
-0.0173057467,
0.0143451393,
0.0406584032,
0.0671080351,
0.0041115498,
-0.0164130088,
0.0422691628,
0.0585980862,
-0.0309762992,
-0.0001153654,
-0.0517201535,
0.0066160746,
0.1136448979,
0.0583705753,
-0.0174448006,
-0.0256347302,
-0.0010099636,
0.0131358132,
0.0312444195,
0.0419493727,
-0.0185244847,
-0.0001753658,
-0.0412634462,
-0.0431565605,
0.0176411625,
-0.0065673953,
0.0029026263,
0.0246452726,
0.0005080928,
-0.0044623762,
0.0390774757,
-0.0282265358,
0.007427488,
-0.0703849122,
-0.0029244204,
-0.0414475352,
-0.0017514409,
0.0122346096,
0.0033280125,
-0.0013842356,
-0.0204138979,
0.0291478485,
-0.0020627,
-0.0025575233,
0.0358487144,
-0.0841507167,
-0.0287584327,
0.0607267544,
0.0216141567,
-0.0180170648,
-0.0079618227,
-0.0094903428,
-0.0269012377,
0.0274750758,
-0.030821858,
0.1262601018,
-0.0128957247,
0.04767875,
-0.0260855015,
0.008668771,
-0.0187250543,
0.0431545898,
0.0054209074,
-0.0023753715,
0.0263809562,
0.0184678808,
-0.0043547899,
-0.0421415083,
-0.0105718384,
0.0326526612,
0.0083478112,
0.0201406479,
0.0020166785,
-0.0122008557,
-0.0544415638,
0.0048887208,
-0.1369361281,
-0.0031776517,
-0.0222179517,
-0.0026926151,
0.0300426353,
0.0394544452,
-0.0223165601,
-0.0584421493,
-0.0196509324,
0.0348983109,
-0.0090898229,
0.033623632,
-0.0129586142,
0.0229480565,
-0.0189786535,
-0.0466191471,
-0.0065637962,
0.0075146342,
0.0342533216,
0.0178624727,
-0.0430986546,
-0.0624248572,
0.0332599618,
-0.0181479063,
0.0610220954,
-0.0193016361,
-0.0224713515,
0.0086288974,
-0.0073323739,
0.069119148,
0.0584828481,
0.0293522105,
0.0463415869,
0.0374047644,
-0.0156581216,
-0.0726324841,
0.0057256091,
-0.001283666,
-0.0382693708,
-0.045928292,
0.0012305537,
-0.0047655012,
0.0684193447,
-0.0153175192,
0.01879148,
-0.0188087113,
0.0090184482,
-0.0451848134,
-0.0517471917,
-0.0768037885,
-0.0049042096,
-0.0458808355,
0.0331714861,
-0.0175021905,
-0.0598026812,
0.0530738607,
-0.0220991261,
-0.0046005454,
-0.0229415167,
-0.0236288998,
0.0002373897,
0.0583849624,
-0.0141746318,
0.0218252316,
-0.0033534244,
-0.0406750031,
-0.0396499708,
-0.0069999527,
0.0187968332,
-0.0504824668,
0.0129656037,
-0.040636953,
0.0215687547,
0.0123868035,
-0.0556703545,
-0.0569242537,
-0.0261476692,
-0.0471761636,
-0.0178824812,
0.0218243357,
-0.0249352343,
0.0087580401,
0.0216882229,
0.0337423123,
0.0384742469,
-0.016154876,
-0.0295095053,
-0.0286706518,
-0.0061072926,
0.0526047125,
-0.0144188404,
-0.0196692795,
-0.0694542155,
0.0308600534,
0.0515272431,
0.0375048965,
-0.0356779881,
-0.0071550291,
-0.0245157983,
0.0364030115,
-0.021002816,
-0.0321173631,
0.0397962332,
0.0470457785,
-0.0730167031,
-0.0360051505,
0.1071915105,
0.0235481784,
-0.0779537112,
0.0094314506,
-0.0526870079,
0.0242034551,
0.0210759155,
0.028661808,
-0.0885836259,
-0.0290533379,
0.0271812528,
-0.0023509571,
0.0062465109,
-0.0177835394,
-0.0159820728,
-0.1172035336,
-0.0086684255,
0.0118186381,
-0.0538784862,
-0.001597746,
-0.013130378,
0.0008340792,
0.0112243677,
0.0619795583,
0.0027586312,
-0.0264265276,
-0.0262096673,
0.0173097458,
-0.0336920507,
-0.0682415366,
0.018711023,
-0.0346230976,
0.0619758368,
0.0491163023,
0.0137696806,
0.0211579222,
0.0094914362,
0.0674782172,
0.0354954302,
0.009293355,
-0.0108268633,
0.0421278737,
-0.0095331706,
-0.0066071064,
-0.0343582258,
-0.0024181192,
0.0003096217,
-0.0036407351,
0.0304462649,
0.0522294827,
-0.0320002995,
0.0237225946,
0.0255874544,
-0.0061314548,
0.0515823774,
0.0600077547,
0.0335775688,
-0.0613331832,
-0.0150332088,
-0.0472474284,
-0.0169613212,
0.0313882828,
-0.0104338415,
-0.0029594898,
-0.0185610913,
-0.0315641947,
-0.0641539767,
-0.0234621074,
0.0258952696,
0.0318286046,
0.0294722971,
0.0503297709,
0.035207577,
0.0127622103,
0.0149390707,
0.0071110064,
-0.0546426699,
0.0166429281,
-0.0551652014,
0.006635793,
0.0163256489,
-0.0334630124,
0.0148725919,
0.01973789,
-0.051967632,
-0.0801906139,
0.0295300614,
0.0173016805,
0.0335414894,
0.0889511406,
-0.0303647611,
-0.079978995,
0.0226416439,
0.0027136973,
-0.0428140461,
0.0082099866,
0.0217083059,
0.0308653247,
0.0015205556,
0.0396209396,
-0.0340293981,
-0.032772962,
-0.0014836376,
-0.0087224385,
-0.071210511,
-0.0296582766,
-0.0037351246,
0.0171364173,
0.0259950813,
-0.0063868444,
-0.0431401469,
-0.0112282708,
0.0307943728,
-0.0258087162,
-0.0044656401,
-0.0254832171,
0.0022098802,
0.013396766,
0.0092930803,
0.0373043939,
0.0023199189,
0.0089321462,
-0.0133304317,
-0.0210455973,
0.0132007478,
0.0081209317,
0.0009124238,
0.0589538291,
0.0157030262,
-0.0195612274,
0.0071002515,
0.040160872,
0.0290039014,
-0.0195759777,
0.0746378973,
0.0294183362,
-0.0361501202,
0.0062265424,
0.0269068312,
-0.0653420314,
-0.0449871756,
0.0033457645,
0.0873164013,
0.0712095425,
0.0196246766,
0.0423758216,
-0.0334232189,
0.0049123038,
-0.0349240191,
0.0480058454,
-0.0078884941,
-0.0560999177,
0.004172259,
0.0175898988,
-0.0215662625,
0.0472217537,
0.0988944694,
0.0077634398,
0.0545560569,
-0.0156223383,
-0.007174775,
-0.0411399938,
0.0080629447,
0.0400074162,
0.058309976,
-0.0378586017,
0.0161073375,
-0.0422217324,
-0.0660542101,
-0.0405456722,
0.0088817915,
-0.0036816851,
-0.0413917154,
0.0452892184,
0.0601142608,
0.0042530978,
-0.0180405769,
-0.0383586474,
0.0059186844,
-0.0078585511,
0.0093477936,
-0.0212034713,
-6.40538994e-33,
-0.0364548229,
-0.033201877,
0.0338202156,
0.0131694442,
-0.0243885536,
-0.0070519857,
-0.034545362,
0.0132977432,
-0.0045118257,
-0.0133922966,
-0.0304259416,
0.0266613718,
0.0207450092,
0.0079452973,
0.0025476217,
-0.0221753418,
0.0553512126,
0.0064904601,
-0.0075573185,
0.0504414216,
0.0568450913,
0.0461724028,
0.0315062478,
-0.0597877651,
0.0299987514,
-0.0196452811,
0.0239778254,
0.0234533995,
-0.0260514971,
0.0437663086,
-0.0350885019,
0.0470915958,
0.0177120753,
-0.0355631933,
-0.0411774591,
0.0244207978,
-0.0280220564,
-0.0135287633,
0.0252092481,
0.0513184704,
-0.0069730496,
-0.0050413013,
0.0601576567,
-0.0031275447,
-0.0236061309,
0.0127032679,
0.0288867187,
-0.0175063759,
-0.0640830174,
0.0249677375,
-0.0603019558,
0.0239157993,
-0.0094647016,
-0.0378166996,
0.0152376303,
0.0190028306,
-0.0068971328,
-0.0459116064,
-0.052769769,
0.0252475757,
0.0266841948,
0.0286327358,
0.0756931603,
0.0442835353,
0.0429347456,
0.0594254546,
0.0334299132,
0.0363012627,
0.0047792774,
-0.0616346747,
0.0342776999,
0.0318506286,
-0.0082863029,
0.0416624397,
0.0190834291,
-0.0207431316,
-0.0450964458,
-0.0178520083,
0.0567400791,
0.022617111,
0.0455356501,
0.0149927996,
-0.045140814,
-0.0409245044,
-0.0425455458,
0.0219642669,
-0.0212279633,
-0.0343644805,
0.0275312047,
0.0192423332,
0.0303937104,
-0.0254419949,
0.0252733827,
-0.0529679433,
-0.0304485094,
0.004510324,
0.0063663349,
0.020625433,
0.0029446241,
0.0214012805,
-0.064317137,
-0.0262990259,
-0.0139432205,
0.0189991351,
0.0049847099,
0.0128889643,
0.0230034795,
0.0099469628,
-0.0510098003,
-0.0018368919,
-0.0482218601,
0.0266002771,
0.0336767584,
-0.0004828458,
0.074060604,
-0.0369532071,
-0.0276407562,
0.0656038374,
0.0224781223,
-0.0000677914,
-0.0264331549,
-0.0388624258,
-0.0186925549,
-0.0020240329,
-0.039606791,
-0.0124216648,
-0.0543193258,
0.01838075,
0.0631910414,
-0.0346960276,
-0.0217456389,
-0.0306463018,
2.724e-7,
-0.0098792035,
0.053064663,
-0.0041502998,
-0.0190219842,
0.0405464545,
0.0482752472,
-0.0365634747,
0.0119923158,
0.02375759,
0.0305037685,
-0.0173203144,
0.0316172726,
0.0581936017,
-0.0071468367,
-0.0932558998,
-0.0566472225,
-0.0960051641,
0.0106834434,
-0.0444103964,
0.0072905459,
0.0152343195,
0.06468568,
0.0123551227,
-0.0020271565,
0.0234642308,
-0.0554731004,
0.0734390393,
-0.0516888164,
-0.0187295768,
0.0129935136,
0.0306866094,
0.0416174904,
0.0029997106,
0.0137067642,
-0.0175139867,
-0.0194725096,
-0.0355322435,
0.0502524078,
0.0046687275,
0.0283734649,
0.0161598008,
0.0051233587,
-0.02912114,
-0.054937683,
0.0515629463,
-0.0724029019,
-0.0444985703,
-0.0393831804,
0.0407083854,
-0.0581947453,
0.0026022512,
0.0151040228,
-0.0244594123,
-0.0037092997,
0.0004622808,
-0.0050441083,
-0.0227017291,
-0.0495830812,
-0.0141870305,
-0.0069473623,
-0.0430822149,
-0.0724778175,
-0.0391352884,
-0.0037100022,
0.0026797599,
-0.0322279744,
0.0443182848,
2.244328201e-34,
0.0166340712,
0.0145298708,
0.0344299674,
0.0522717535,
0.0339554474,
-0.0100856638,
0.0240699947,
0.0221212506,
0.0393174514,
-0.0539672337,
0.0110412333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12697v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12697v2 | Semantic similarity prediction is better than other semantic similarity measures | 2023-09-22T08:11:01 | 2024-01-17T08:50:59 | Steffen Herbold | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Semantic similarity between natural language texts is typically measured
either by looking at the overlap between subsequences (e.g., BLEU) or by using
embeddings (e.g., BERTScore, S-BERT). Within this paper, we argue that when we
are only interested in measuring the semantic similarity, it is better to
directly predict the similarity using a fine-tuned model for such a task. Using
a fine-tuned model for the Semantic Textual Similarity Benchmark tasks (STS-B)
from the GLUE benchmark, we define the STSScore approach and show that the
resulting similarity is better aligned with our expectations on a robust
semantic similarity measure than other approaches. | [
0.0339746103,
0.009736958,
-0.0141916964,
0.0412596352,
-0.0467738882,
0.0124296136,
-0.0045554275,
-0.0079991445,
-0.0088171717,
-0.0389574356,
-0.0001700091,
0.0052003977,
0.0033919285,
-0.0343592912,
0.026638139,
-0.0432847589,
0.059701819,
0.0652424246,
-0.0173037499,
0.0197617859,
0.0433429554,
0.0112636192,
0.0370618589,
0.036641676,
-0.0175191071,
-0.0060572224,
0.0232589617,
-0.0066683628,
0.0312542431,
-0.0149337621,
0.0253451448,
0.0134844724,
0.0118547324,
0.0657212213,
0.0000015531,
-0.0564999543,
0.007509456,
0.0017462568,
0.0471236035,
0.0366906375,
0.0054098465,
0.0227416866,
0.0439056978,
0.0191681404,
-0.0185298622,
0.0119875623,
0.0287278201,
-0.0125558041,
0.0340434238,
0.0440064631,
-0.0249871537,
-0.0131541947,
0.0044325148,
0.0254468787,
0.0149214789,
-0.0198000651,
-0.0034720534,
0.0163005814,
-0.0011555071,
-0.0273882318,
0.0038868701,
0.0062258085,
-0.0020089822,
0.0440054312,
0.0211264901,
0.0168674774,
-0.0598034151,
0.0126917614,
0.0176117457,
0.0531389005,
-0.0571186244,
-0.0862187818,
0.0228116885,
0.0147107681,
-0.0170070156,
0.0414850302,
-0.0362911448,
-0.0194819495,
-0.0199388769,
0.0450879335,
0.0263577532,
0.0494307764,
0.0389266871,
0.0023263253,
-0.0157886799,
0.037825536,
0.0319073945,
-0.0362574346,
-0.026727397,
0.0054077976,
-0.0335899331,
-0.0244664699,
0.0088417958,
-0.0014852197,
-0.0535713397,
-0.0069529368,
-0.066126056,
-0.02651898,
0.0133962585,
-0.0461122766,
0.0126211736,
0.0890789554,
0.0134340366,
0.0498534702,
-0.0757706314,
0.0531589277,
0.0122750588,
0.0354100652,
-0.0532372706,
-0.0486018136,
-0.0731109157,
0.0432732515,
-0.0266604368,
0.0304559059,
0.0166131537,
-0.0592769161,
0.0016205463,
0.0227650367,
-0.0024220289,
0.0288284849,
-0.00844876,
-0.0271746907,
-0.0086066267,
0.025674263,
-0.0341092832,
-0.0322352089,
-0.0779503137,
0.0035874627,
-0.03793687,
-0.0113637131,
0.0021474324,
0.0342186503,
0.0112837292,
-0.0265130904,
-0.0048730159,
0.01660401,
0.0054087187,
-0.0103737563,
-0.0475440659,
-0.0322510526,
0.0198707879,
-0.005925037,
-0.0008291877,
-0.0818547457,
0.0274475794,
-0.0035395648,
-0.0221093167,
-0.0210387744,
-0.0119451582,
0.0690180063,
-0.040104907,
0.0531012602,
0.0008975153,
-0.0068445946,
-0.0340605266,
0.0095110284,
-0.0086575486,
0.0161571894,
-0.0143744433,
0.00645283,
0.0855267346,
0.0324676782,
-0.077591747,
0.0169670004,
-0.0069739437,
0.0057971706,
-0.0324120708,
0.03829078,
0.0396558121,
0.0510907657,
0.0117012328,
0.0542136505,
-0.0279620066,
-0.0621145032,
0.0123989452,
0.1008503065,
-0.0085643996,
0.0096125174,
0.0463406928,
0.030814968,
-0.022213785,
0.0234523658,
-0.0209421739,
0.0214251112,
-0.0125213703,
0.0134737445,
0.0627495572,
0.0308582317,
-0.0407787785,
0.0209570006,
-0.0513777882,
-0.0395675972,
-0.0079253698,
-0.0435264856,
-0.0278560445,
0.0220641065,
-0.0361700654,
0.0505343229,
0.0124067133,
-0.0573016256,
0.0003825141,
0.0160723347,
0.0303296112,
0.0493409038,
0.0626310483,
-0.035027314,
-0.0356247798,
0.0130931959,
-0.0032913778,
0.0106303804,
0.049701415,
-0.0271506384,
-0.0169891808,
-0.0709920749,
-0.0220350828,
-0.0278403182,
-0.0029270847,
-0.0067457743,
0.0373648033,
0.0086445659,
0.0343215801,
-0.0584506765,
0.005463304,
0.0741117299,
-0.0395657718,
0.029195305,
-0.0302074943,
0.0217084847,
0.0335063785,
0.021064613,
0.0143357087,
0.0485864803,
0.0274811797,
-0.0401825123,
-0.0601539537,
0.0066378512,
-0.0441745669,
-0.0510420427,
0.0770954266,
-0.0759891048,
-0.0030224496,
0.0584265739,
-0.0514645204,
-0.0074579702,
0.0131934015,
-0.0518705882,
0.0471917875,
-0.0524091832,
0.0169733837,
-0.043606218,
-0.0202103518,
-0.030310994,
0.0513602495,
0.0022039798,
0.0673783869,
-0.0156366155,
0.0407218039,
0.0635750517,
-0.0072505674,
-0.0757634565,
-0.0181696191,
0.0138185518,
0.0052156379,
0.0389734209,
-0.0276214145,
-0.0474327467,
-0.0147968717,
-0.0606602728,
0.0447610356,
-0.0116824387,
0.0311148744,
0.047134079,
0.0222141054,
0.0037388986,
-0.0229782071,
-0.0450267717,
-0.0031876767,
-0.0282667279,
0.01361279,
0.043198552,
-0.0114673199,
-0.0189149156,
-0.070533514,
-0.0081029721,
-0.0267356467,
0.0515057258,
-0.0130359661,
0.0130400155,
-0.0088362489,
0.0078883134,
-0.0837918818,
0.0068604872,
0.0283311959,
-0.0405181646,
-0.0214843582,
-0.0122302286,
0.0427883901,
-0.0024432573,
0.0299325045,
-0.0087079713,
0.0461646169,
0.0298244674,
-0.0583727807,
-0.022553578,
-0.0594753064,
0.033457242,
-0.0180634279,
-0.0120604374,
0.0342580043,
0.0201006252,
0.0127399825,
-0.0025255342,
-0.0385576226,
0.0294398647,
0.006655863,
0.0199178047,
-0.0057165213,
-0.0129082296,
0.0004029356,
-0.0066130068,
-0.031061301,
0.000237637,
0.0951340944,
-0.0459667109,
0.0223558899,
-0.0570307449,
-0.0076198089,
-0.059541449,
0.0399499647,
-0.0211030543,
0.0257916786,
-0.0554862171,
0.043799635,
-0.0204078555,
0.020598447,
0.0580398403,
-0.024325313,
0.0098499991,
0.0041079214,
0.0122155407,
0.0126892515,
-0.0234313402,
-0.0324299522,
-0.0194644295,
-0.0469313636,
-0.0032774594,
-0.0160650071,
0.0076777278,
-0.0555427633,
-0.0048858975,
-0.0091470918,
0.0317128226,
0.0277864244,
-0.0103446459,
-0.039169129,
0.0599323362,
0.0195458196,
-0.0207207147,
0.005418791,
0.0140235899,
0.0301738232,
0.0228698086,
0.0245281123,
0.0147460029,
-0.0618374534,
-0.0197439641,
0.0088334568,
-0.056788303,
-0.003879607,
0.0150740528,
0.0052228593,
-0.0031496077,
-0.0178212188,
0.1366157383,
0.0690162778,
0.0335321724,
0.0051771719,
-0.020043401,
0.0798142254,
0.0577470772,
-0.0237571355,
-0.0202832446,
-0.0599668436,
0.0109007163,
-0.0076808492,
0.0233212188,
-0.0306312963,
-0.002061625,
-0.066249676,
-0.0137787657,
-0.0105824424,
-0.0281340629,
-0.0306510124,
-0.0925650746,
0.0239386074,
0.0130673051,
-0.0133911446,
-0.0371778235,
-0.0132004377,
0.0264734495,
-0.0269085206,
-0.0345396772,
-0.0174474176,
0.0273790397,
-0.0763740465,
0.0206204299,
0.0502054133,
0.0285586622,
0.0174229126,
-0.0318955332,
0.0007266477,
-0.0519922189,
-0.0265064333,
0.0083911046,
0.0384374186,
-0.0299890842,
0.0147169577,
-0.0372722745,
0.0156419128,
-0.0225603748,
0.0078106369,
-0.0068921116,
0.0839486644,
0.0018277853,
-0.0288618635,
-0.0477937795,
0.0249627307,
-0.0144034345,
0.1099240035,
0.0359121412,
0.0075849853,
-0.029015962,
0.0426635034,
0.009447013,
-0.0188969076,
-0.0140346205,
0.0044175494,
-0.0104810279,
0.0273239203,
-0.0975385606,
-0.0517308973,
-0.0100308331,
-0.0087941187,
-0.0292340722,
0.0302520655,
0.0232088529,
-0.0650829151,
-0.0612346344,
-0.003958683,
-0.0246135276,
0.0528987348,
-0.0074046818,
0.0503592752,
0.06286221,
0.0343476757,
-0.0441314913,
-0.0397239588,
-0.0650599748,
-0.0390681177,
-0.0381783172,
-0.0030277066,
0.0065640877,
0.0236467347,
-0.0276556909,
-0.0131170321,
0.018092785,
0.035540089,
-0.0319134407,
0.0070413398,
-0.0002781299,
-0.0161346048,
0.0080275228,
0.0597806275,
-0.0333191641,
0.0055020065,
-0.008553423,
0.0437554196,
0.0305083022,
-0.0600108169,
0.0284829512,
0.0444638766,
0.0255397614,
0.0249722637,
0.0106411558,
0.0081532793,
-0.0072259665,
0.0166904721,
-0.0098889265,
-0.0028812115,
0.0141748488,
0.0113969585,
0.0070286402,
-0.0147190439,
0.0603007935,
-0.0149676893,
0.0320802368,
-0.0293789115,
-0.0000822869,
0.0072103641,
0.0493097752,
-0.0280529279,
-0.0071079354,
-0.0599672683,
-0.0323457271,
-0.0450718328,
-0.0029979467,
-0.0579479076,
0.0009637718,
0.0485751778,
0.0292311125,
-0.0105287107,
0.0347863585,
-0.0695595965,
-0.0282139555,
-0.0207664445,
0.0258907396,
0.0359348543,
-0.0500379466,
0.0265577547,
-0.0065284637,
-0.0176751167,
-0.0097245015,
0.0113007342,
-0.0305282772,
-0.0218722019,
0.0268054605,
0.0032007883,
-0.0138642648,
0.0006988752,
0.0675417781,
-0.0267798267,
0.0738784894,
0.0164138675,
-0.0702464879,
-0.0385605209,
-0.0509184003,
0.0530101731,
0.0704807043,
-0.0205364358,
-0.003901836,
-0.0333927535,
-0.0377331004,
0.0421367139,
0.0157585684,
-0.015594665,
0.0329446979,
0.0661815405,
0.0381891653,
-0.0169487633,
0.030607285,
0.0138409138,
0.0045948057,
-0.0406923853,
-0.0717603639,
-0.0352884382,
-5.402787666e-33,
0.001146124,
0.0068077268,
-0.0105308322,
0.017683601,
-0.0197201353,
-0.0240126736,
-0.0245295689,
-0.0600940399,
-0.0375232659,
0.0307586901,
0.0388751626,
-0.013653391,
-0.0041328976,
0.0180123802,
-0.0381902829,
-0.0200886186,
0.0356506966,
0.0200166106,
-0.0417118818,
-0.0041171121,
0.0273926631,
0.0005523426,
0.0067343544,
-0.0175530463,
-0.0418370664,
-0.0483311303,
0.040808592,
-0.0040904307,
0.0827113241,
0.0631769821,
-0.0228837691,
0.0253369547,
0.0280898977,
0.0241928101,
-0.0347089581,
0.0256547704,
-0.0455234982,
-0.0945600793,
0.015344019,
-0.0536282957,
-0.0446433686,
0.0181819182,
0.0089334277,
-0.0211150199,
-0.0073941564,
-0.0088256523,
0.0605252534,
0.0032755593,
-0.0300107077,
-0.0102472324,
-0.0643092543,
0.0219191816,
-0.0301213488,
-0.0075524203,
0.030143043,
0.0502591208,
0.0269762911,
0.0494714342,
-0.0344978757,
0.0156052969,
-0.0881673396,
0.0373396203,
0.0248833895,
-0.0380993374,
0.0115487864,
0.0749519095,
-0.0015347231,
-0.0638622567,
0.016494723,
0.0240614135,
0.0075095682,
0.0262670163,
0.0556679145,
0.0486527644,
0.0229699835,
-0.0011505,
-0.0494035333,
0.0752892792,
0.0593050383,
0.0079057403,
0.0276501607,
0.0227950141,
-0.0277154166,
-0.0025738808,
-0.0600368679,
0.0344408527,
-0.0186980665,
-0.0189102292,
0.0598661005,
-0.0322155766,
0.0235231742,
0.0222645905,
0.0002204842,
-0.0308829248,
0.0460017696,
0.0071616815,
-0.0233698469,
-0.0139476834,
-0.0048685949,
0.0410062373,
-0.0342473425,
-0.0502394661,
0.0233577378,
-0.0096999556,
0.0265047755,
-0.0150695769,
0.0715240836,
-0.0353157744,
-0.0409351587,
0.0147465281,
-0.0246583764,
-0.0855909064,
-0.0741886422,
-0.0426871739,
0.0135893459,
0.014673925,
0.0215919707,
0.0285249744,
0.0501540117,
-0.0116379922,
-0.0196887087,
-0.0378371477,
0.0228174683,
0.0064253272,
-0.0112396479,
0.0059943488,
-0.0679289252,
0.0064178095,
-0.0266410317,
-0.0431442112,
0.0042550038,
0.009641259,
2.315e-7,
0.0185927618,
0.0117229195,
0.0531536639,
0.0094322022,
-0.0078090555,
0.0172074698,
0.0016341498,
0.0621854141,
-0.0186840873,
-0.0064814142,
0.0019172801,
-0.0157647356,
0.0110319583,
0.0022307024,
-0.0555990525,
0.0292894561,
-0.1143882871,
-0.0608818755,
-0.0474804714,
-0.0282406509,
0.0679027811,
0.0590471625,
0.0511265397,
0.0023397713,
-0.0117538832,
-0.0369038247,
0.0601585247,
-0.0203876551,
-0.0056046378,
0.0164244696,
0.000396518,
0.0231359433,
0.0247705374,
0.0129157891,
-0.0140878474,
0.0542942323,
0.0437697209,
0.0064669144,
-0.0136348493,
0.0042060283,
-0.0363123454,
-0.0644051358,
0.006008707,
-0.0590587445,
0.0376403965,
-0.018410081,
0.0095388945,
0.0351698212,
-0.0237877369,
0.0466180667,
0.0353734531,
0.0317154713,
-0.0626660511,
0.0208396278,
0.0593598932,
0.0218968708,
-0.0156389493,
-0.0616424717,
-0.0241302438,
0.0144413942,
-0.0548448004,
0.0013519594,
-0.0292861313,
0.0308679678,
0.0545690395,
-0.0755948201,
0.0088634351,
2.064579503e-34,
0.0213667341,
0.0215158463,
0.0212283134,
-0.0231876355,
0.0344885997,
-0.0235301293,
0.0088954028,
0.0040326845,
0.0188526884,
-0.031137839,
0.0103797894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12689v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12689v3 | AMPLIFY:Attention-based Mixup for Performance Improvement and Label Smoothing in Transformer | 2023-09-22T08:02:45 | 2024-05-08T11:14:41 | Leixin Yang, Yu Xiang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Mixup is an effective data augmentation method that generates new augmented
samples by aggregating linear combinations of different original samples.
However, if there are noises or aberrant features in the original samples,
Mixup may propagate them to the augmented samples, leading to over-sensitivity
of the model to these outliers . To solve this problem, this paper proposes a
new Mixup method called AMPLIFY. This method uses the Attention mechanism of
Transformer itself to reduce the influence of noises and aberrant values in the
original samples on the prediction results, without increasing additional
trainable parameters, and the computational cost is very low, thereby avoiding
the problem of high resource consumption in common Mixup methods such as
Sentence Mixup . The experimental results show that, under a smaller
computational resource cost, AMPLIFY outperforms other Mixup methods in text
classification tasks on 7 benchmark datasets, providing new ideas and new ways
to further improve the performance of pre-trained models based on the Attention
mechanism, such as BERT, ALBERT, RoBERTa, and GPT. Our code can be obtained at
https://github.com/kiwi-lilo/AMPLIFY. | [
0.0180611406,
0.0420389399,
0.011149087,
0.0305493511,
-0.004584474,
0.0116305705,
-0.0230535306,
-0.0058983448,
0.0125245396,
-0.0617015772,
-0.0325078927,
0.0094537307,
0.0008353866,
0.0052554035,
0.0109024448,
-0.043381799,
0.0465228334,
0.0345255136,
0.0056098048,
0.0258955527,
0.0001290761,
-0.0055459784,
0.0382807143,
0.0221725833,
0.0024657578,
-0.0018080435,
-0.005786397,
0.035277728,
0.0631585047,
0.0251310319,
0.0369371548,
0.0537429489,
-0.0303015988,
0.0623041056,
0.0000022781,
-0.0491575114,
-0.0140716219,
0.0101768207,
-0.0084113777,
0.0280048195,
0.0080033951,
0.0034096958,
0.0149692139,
0.0161801875,
0.0042519267,
-0.026032744,
0.0387242213,
0.1119850203,
0.0666341707,
0.0947321653,
-0.0171213076,
-0.0240090247,
0.0367582589,
-0.033035621,
0.0641715229,
-0.0346422456,
0.024021931,
-0.0809422284,
-0.0187475756,
0.0045557371,
-0.021251779,
0.0330983885,
0.0393661335,
0.0005911966,
0.0604123101,
0.0468731672,
-0.0309001058,
-0.0019480599,
-0.0314130597,
0.0884518847,
-0.1070546582,
-0.0184554812,
-0.0237453543,
-0.04607201,
0.0172276702,
-0.0214840584,
-0.0031712067,
-0.0267320313,
0.0000969257,
0.0226014312,
0.010503591,
0.0127035659,
0.0217246823,
0.0019074148,
-0.0439207405,
0.0360531397,
-0.0056569688,
-0.0463715941,
0.0103673358,
0.0295952167,
-0.0121558476,
-0.05395668,
0.032059636,
0.054049287,
0.0172969401,
-0.0334208794,
-0.0793289244,
-0.0978576168,
0.0207982361,
-0.0403658561,
0.0230499208,
0.0459004641,
-0.0690104663,
0.0407713093,
0.0136559308,
0.0256851837,
-0.0317169167,
0.0693918616,
-0.0460091792,
-0.0039239991,
0.0140389092,
0.037932802,
-0.0690739751,
0.029559711,
-0.0151459575,
-0.0046000886,
-0.043962311,
0.0263658408,
-0.0006190017,
-0.0169912837,
0.0271151699,
-0.0015055522,
-0.0549902841,
-0.0031972236,
0.0121016679,
0.0346128382,
-0.0357827432,
0.0060989466,
0.0096110348,
-0.037481375,
-0.0478916615,
0.0400904417,
0.0334541574,
-0.0318946503,
0.0253765732,
0.0297298972,
0.0032675399,
-0.0681534633,
-0.0065388735,
0.0306075793,
-0.024830712,
-0.0358628295,
-0.0116835572,
-0.0255225692,
0.0125223659,
-0.0011323502,
-0.016201051,
0.0108973216,
0.0051773619,
0.0280099884,
-0.059564393,
0.0263299234,
-0.0059735873,
-0.0336769223,
0.0249464791,
-0.0140991537,
-0.0274278559,
0.0335653275,
0.0258713141,
0.0105895298,
-0.0042800442,
-0.0121326828,
0.0716545507,
0.0198090281,
0.0400401354,
-0.021638019,
-0.0017695101,
0.0156643912,
-0.0511725955,
-0.0218967553,
0.0261523817,
0.0210963096,
-0.0133300768,
-0.0291982889,
0.0394695438,
-0.0554761142,
0.0212948732,
0.043074213,
-0.0121031385,
0.0110985609,
-0.003561662,
0.0149611626,
-0.0583933815,
0.0572194308,
-0.0437381938,
0.0023790265,
0.0316697955,
0.0426731482,
-0.0548519269,
-0.0414500386,
0.0136865005,
-0.0039628013,
0.0294055939,
0.0144312233,
0.0349333696,
0.0216672067,
-0.0379498824,
0.0615779273,
0.0356142297,
-0.0356709622,
-0.0109428037,
-0.0359463766,
-0.017702844,
0.0483683199,
0.0122651923,
-0.0628016889,
-0.0356160961,
-0.0615615733,
0.0040346803,
0.0011151163,
-0.0057062861,
0.0625308007,
0.0150526678,
-0.053037107,
-0.0381994583,
-0.0093277851,
0.0053561176,
-0.0036301401,
0.0026272645,
0.0138670197,
0.0358026288,
-0.0427158698,
-0.028896559,
0.0315433592,
0.0273709092,
-0.0414900929,
0.0276529845,
0.013055291,
0.0220218897,
0.0011102956,
0.0138819339,
0.0006959285,
0.0489956848,
-0.0131822741,
-0.0069446424,
0.0145964622,
-0.0120500624,
-0.061668992,
0.0408957526,
-0.0105620697,
-0.0542242639,
0.0401385054,
-0.0387349613,
-0.0419111215,
0.0095533375,
-0.0541140698,
0.0434726588,
-0.0368379317,
0.0319427252,
0.0090086674,
0.045220755,
-0.0136928856,
0.0681858212,
-0.0312569737,
0.010855508,
-0.0403384827,
-0.0027262396,
0.0020104537,
0.0059807142,
-0.0202235896,
-0.0231501497,
-0.0130277677,
0.010222909,
0.0082657654,
-0.0175148416,
-0.0560517386,
-0.0440785699,
-0.0467553101,
-0.003846193,
-0.0505569018,
0.0018549187,
0.0027612047,
0.0525216982,
0.0160697363,
-0.0224583857,
-0.018773457,
-0.0171688218,
-0.0190717559,
-0.0128328819,
0.0155239925,
-0.0176508222,
0.0108157601,
0.0106662922,
-0.0094684679,
0.0042409892,
0.0398408026,
0.0133241173,
-0.0416950881,
-0.063159816,
-0.0506749824,
0.0039510182,
0.025615463,
0.0055650906,
-0.0465742983,
-0.0531526096,
0.0083735641,
0.0542348698,
0.0673992857,
0.0339825414,
-0.011031189,
0.0274122879,
0.0283463113,
-0.0166590568,
0.0637589395,
-0.025640836,
0.013441232,
-0.0245498996,
-0.0192461573,
0.006056061,
0.0687600821,
-0.0736978352,
-0.0220434237,
-0.0370965563,
-0.0130435675,
0.0282818321,
0.0103495717,
0.0260131005,
0.0003931265,
-0.043262165,
-0.004064647,
-0.0377959572,
-0.0403306335,
0.0825426802,
-0.0004032313,
-0.0302481297,
-0.0783526003,
0.0141355107,
-0.0176599827,
-0.0273934472,
0.0220570341,
0.0308536347,
-0.0386619568,
-0.0296462309,
-0.0149234515,
-0.0033078718,
-0.00836353,
-0.0275571607,
0.0626690835,
0.0555032194,
0.0233564302,
-0.0136939678,
-0.0114809414,
-0.0600130819,
-0.073410213,
0.004609657,
-0.0222014543,
0.0086632911,
-0.0492172576,
-0.1036324278,
-0.0253818259,
0.0189021267,
0.0567032695,
-0.0218647234,
-0.0109130386,
-0.0012778804,
0.0237001907,
0.0164693203,
0.0249554031,
0.0049897372,
-0.0206197165,
-0.0303154662,
0.0259790532,
0.0376043133,
-0.0068746447,
-0.0096505545,
-0.0155377006,
0.0345955156,
-0.0221053753,
-0.0163051188,
-0.0026574137,
0.0223180763,
-0.0382212326,
-0.0089384103,
0.0853725895,
0.0154243447,
-0.0578611605,
-0.0107572209,
-0.0102840206,
0.0221889801,
0.0151942698,
0.0373168737,
-0.0380988009,
-0.0239297319,
0.0073536844,
0.0348150618,
0.031195825,
-0.0192866251,
0.0060931612,
-0.0985540375,
0.0406891331,
-0.0167809241,
-0.0755224824,
-0.0532000028,
-0.0193868633,
0.0182129517,
-0.0095069828,
0.0335928872,
0.0004336192,
0.0226063654,
-0.0202349462,
0.0240243394,
0.0225449577,
-0.062629886,
-0.0250916276,
-0.0069380533,
0.0041818353,
0.0285182074,
0.0265816879,
-0.0216214545,
-0.0519876592,
0.0481600128,
0.0219570864,
-0.017810896,
0.0047817496,
0.085468024,
-0.013798058,
-0.0295752175,
-0.005736182,
0.0099356221,
-0.0159779005,
-0.0072425646,
-0.0394129381,
0.089877896,
0.0013775419,
-0.0100160073,
-0.0304490533,
-0.0062090675,
0.0175523721,
0.0537219457,
0.0225611627,
-0.0474889204,
-0.0156754609,
-0.0192982685,
0.0034743426,
-0.0319628567,
0.022116622,
0.0848783031,
0.0034398038,
-0.1221539825,
-0.0438781939,
-0.0701884255,
0.0050497148,
0.0187868848,
-0.0088846385,
-0.0114453323,
-0.0164663624,
-0.012285769,
-0.0537749827,
0.0301018506,
0.0095176985,
0.0192689952,
-0.0164805856,
-0.017688036,
0.0095033795,
-0.0148396539,
-0.0183885396,
0.0150420871,
-0.1079079062,
-0.0541839562,
0.0315945446,
0.0359937251,
0.0093106879,
0.0724214539,
-0.0475946255,
-0.0553945675,
0.0353947468,
0.0542702265,
-0.0283382144,
0.0240696538,
0.0534215905,
-0.0650099516,
0.0144996904,
0.0135744167,
-0.0405451581,
0.0179811902,
0.0451458059,
-0.0160152037,
-0.0458173044,
-0.0577208623,
-0.0075823213,
0.0011328087,
0.0706677809,
-0.0226041824,
0.0247217659,
0.0049392823,
0.057114698,
0.0319099203,
-0.0109570781,
-0.0493572243,
-0.0105707543,
0.0222208817,
-0.0292309821,
-0.0138897886,
0.0710965246,
-0.04152143,
-0.0472954921,
-0.0158738755,
0.0386245325,
-0.0476210825,
-0.0022875352,
0.0263166726,
0.0203567073,
-0.0171973296,
-0.0349506512,
0.0499466695,
0.0328473113,
0.0010798001,
-0.0062179212,
0.0403692201,
0.008608602,
-0.0253539663,
-0.0111055272,
-0.0894167721,
0.0171233639,
-0.0763050541,
0.0087071611,
0.0051955469,
-0.0522988439,
0.0396904536,
0.0074178576,
-0.0119755324,
-0.0202156939,
0.0042569512,
-0.00468437,
-0.0182008073,
-0.0333533399,
-0.0166711919,
0.0038133292,
-0.0027246925,
0.0685044229,
-0.0241241362,
0.0070042731,
0.0244051404,
0.0035003787,
-0.0444463417,
0.0075298832,
-0.0120863253,
0.0313245654,
-0.0016721202,
0.0342347026,
0.0148669761,
-0.0508134328,
0.059380848,
-0.0543887205,
0.0065943459,
-0.0007709578,
0.0331430249,
0.0114918007,
-0.0003659329,
-0.0145356245,
-0.0091410615,
0.0155124515,
0.0301688164,
-0.0117431134,
0.0210573543,
-7.103792277e-33,
0.0060237898,
-0.0076275086,
-0.0319474228,
-0.0290834159,
0.006721993,
-0.0034549797,
-0.007965113,
-0.0163503233,
-0.0169648938,
0.0133898929,
-0.0243481193,
0.042039331,
0.0060203141,
0.0412866846,
-0.0084913271,
-0.0384722427,
0.0633560494,
0.0301744882,
-0.0295986384,
0.0328945592,
-0.0038261137,
0.0552473627,
0.1206756532,
-0.0992581174,
-0.0134923952,
-0.015292597,
-0.0187421739,
0.000143795,
-0.0098899463,
0.0312766358,
0.020919906,
0.0566851348,
0.0066590332,
-0.0399419926,
-0.0155229177,
0.0116718477,
-0.0599905178,
-0.0520034283,
-0.0272029806,
0.0259281993,
-0.0242229849,
-0.0185046904,
0.0618977584,
0.0202568509,
0.03493407,
-0.0508161448,
0.0517690405,
-0.0259570144,
-0.0299230833,
-0.0176939685,
-0.0211325567,
0.0330041982,
0.0003038449,
-0.0049563167,
0.0029718743,
0.0398554876,
0.0286991615,
0.0500697531,
-0.0894410089,
-0.0171466246,
0.0823503882,
0.0181784313,
-0.0068510016,
0.0348561332,
-0.025967259,
0.0131075829,
0.0027751618,
0.0178546067,
-0.0371046104,
-0.0187357273,
0.0216197316,
0.0407369323,
0.0425231531,
0.0269131456,
0.0762552321,
-0.0012343277,
-0.0709992424,
0.0558105707,
0.004152338,
0.0180590842,
0.0298307203,
-0.0031203902,
-0.0246369764,
-0.0084842872,
0.0087063322,
0.0142271845,
-0.0554291941,
0.0003698849,
-0.0188521482,
0.0562972836,
-0.025963597,
0.0420387387,
0.0147435851,
-0.0291902963,
-0.0218300242,
0.0018142438,
-0.000545957,
0.0054542595,
0.0100491978,
-0.0116874902,
-0.0273456462,
-0.0047676777,
0.0409087092,
0.0254961476,
0.000204219,
0.0059091127,
0.0985968411,
0.0115240412,
-0.0843781605,
-0.0049099922,
0.0046445946,
0.0378306732,
0.0028812347,
0.0341009907,
0.0192207713,
0.0182248633,
-0.0069299657,
0.0925149247,
0.0277237296,
0.0614562482,
-0.0456891879,
-0.000850842,
0.0432498753,
0.0087872185,
-0.0223406274,
-0.0096858153,
0.0041844789,
0.0127963936,
0.0245666653,
-0.0655676275,
-0.0070961337,
-0.0122599797,
3.065e-7,
0.0585025847,
0.0448180996,
-0.0079517933,
-0.0321168453,
0.0049572256,
0.0174449831,
-0.0133677684,
0.0474002138,
0.0102729732,
0.0120091243,
0.0246346332,
-0.0116716931,
0.0386530422,
-0.0025509261,
-0.0704813004,
-0.053749457,
-0.0898051187,
0.0210883785,
-0.0089199608,
-0.0052774455,
0.0428193249,
0.1377952546,
0.0281949788,
-0.019766001,
0.0270009432,
-0.0111061987,
0.0444391444,
-0.0291325729,
0.0014077286,
0.0229326934,
0.0752850845,
0.0476304255,
0.0057367273,
0.0134397969,
-0.0523477867,
0.0278630536,
0.004411377,
0.041563645,
-0.0597724579,
-0.0459624454,
0.0124590835,
0.0243619233,
0.0184562244,
-0.0622384809,
0.0406996459,
-0.0452411063,
-0.0075484402,
-0.0125828218,
-0.0518710725,
0.0188670158,
0.034817107,
-0.0122546721,
0.002218842,
0.0032936139,
0.0123075284,
-0.0199722275,
-0.0260778647,
-0.1157425568,
-0.0420163423,
-0.0000616973,
-0.0086228587,
-0.0150776766,
-0.0487350449,
-0.0073865848,
0.0596292317,
-0.0281843971,
0.0039278837,
2.832208309e-34,
0.0502296127,
-0.0013306079,
0.0131811677,
0.0034766677,
-0.0177249089,
-0.0345762298,
0.0339190848,
-0.0005940085,
0.0112840421,
-0.0571486428,
-0.0202634502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12676v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12676v1 | JCoLA: Japanese Corpus of Linguistic Acceptability | 2023-09-22T07:35:45 | 2023-09-22T07:35:45 | Taiga Someya, Yushi Sugimoto, Yohei Oseki | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural language models have exhibited outstanding performance in a range of
downstream tasks. However, there is limited understanding regarding the extent
to which these models internalize syntactic knowledge, so that various datasets
have recently been constructed to facilitate syntactic evaluation of language
models across languages. In this paper, we introduce JCoLA (Japanese Corpus of
Linguistic Acceptability), which consists of 10,020 sentences annotated with
binary acceptability judgments. Specifically, those sentences are manually
extracted from linguistics textbooks, handbooks and journal articles, and split
into in-domain data (86 %; relatively simple acceptability judgments extracted
from textbooks and handbooks) and out-of-domain data (14 %; theoretically
significant acceptability judgments extracted from journal articles), the
latter of which is categorized by 12 linguistic phenomena. We then evaluate the
syntactic knowledge of 9 different types of Japanese language models on JCoLA.
The results demonstrated that several models could surpass human performance
for the in-domain data, while no models were able to exceed human performance
for the out-of-domain data. Error analyses by linguistic phenomena further
revealed that although neural language models are adept at handling local
syntactic dependencies like argument structure, their performance wanes when
confronted with long-distance syntactic dependencies like verbal agreement and
NPI licensing. | [
0.0740724578,
0.0639412925,
-0.0108653698,
0.0490313843,
-0.0119566545,
0.0209849328,
-0.0082610175,
0.0032404312,
0.0459329523,
-0.0034527567,
-0.0648120195,
-0.0284923725,
0.0325862691,
0.0361522846,
0.0033743959,
-0.0570021868,
0.0185761396,
0.0143669983,
0.0429015532,
-0.0014317016,
0.0367634706,
-0.0180289447,
0.0081162686,
0.0360884741,
-0.0219144672,
-0.0573440194,
0.0235542022,
-0.0371947028,
-0.0183778871,
-0.0089450637,
0.0378775224,
0.0489562526,
-0.0555260479,
0.0155904936,
0.0000018144,
-0.0066339625,
0.0401215889,
-0.0259264018,
-0.0040912167,
0.0469275042,
0.047812067,
-0.0334761366,
-0.0294411778,
-0.0090907952,
-0.0369641818,
-0.040314164,
0.0308238883,
0.0523704849,
0.0935328454,
0.0538946688,
-0.0294276867,
-0.024358958,
0.0311806332,
-0.0282711759,
-0.0776376799,
0.010773072,
0.0250847172,
-0.0440739915,
-0.0122923274,
-0.0135404542,
-0.0113854622,
0.0271100141,
0.0411152318,
-0.0194346886,
-0.0540586114,
0.0076247579,
-0.0121795489,
-0.0261909384,
-0.0358532518,
0.0639388636,
-0.017008407,
-0.0254065525,
-0.018702291,
-0.0003363433,
-0.0045757126,
0.0195934381,
-0.033528693,
0.021266615,
-0.0148796504,
0.0272624958,
0.0245211273,
-0.0052847401,
0.0355719216,
-0.0064749601,
-0.0043669292,
0.1134717688,
0.0165742766,
-0.0732000992,
0.0049453224,
-0.0162744243,
-0.0393370092,
-0.047456909,
0.0191650912,
0.016580848,
-0.003629881,
0.054979112,
-0.0110885631,
-0.0243198257,
0.0499795638,
-0.0786229521,
0.0494002104,
-0.014685546,
-0.0414953716,
0.020736549,
0.0231399015,
0.0443754643,
-0.0134193506,
0.0290873144,
-0.0256025959,
0.0110379383,
-0.0517060123,
-0.0171227567,
-0.01298167,
0.0275534317,
-0.0241934378,
-0.0327490084,
-0.054606732,
-0.0126463175,
-0.0360406078,
0.0072131255,
0.0513774417,
-0.0163243357,
-0.0091039725,
0.0028543244,
-0.0543522276,
0.0047686845,
-0.0189410318,
0.0253998656,
-0.0041181147,
-0.0303965285,
0.0193014257,
0.0178016163,
-0.0023020401,
0.0035365836,
-0.010705688,
0.0520203337,
0.0384429619,
-0.0303632412,
-0.0072735571,
0.0237966236,
-0.0742245987,
-0.0346983448,
0.0238915868,
-0.0179840252,
0.0263755061,
-0.0240108129,
-0.0010959421,
-0.0773363784,
-0.0141692227,
0.0341007076,
0.0038665344,
0.0401426852,
0.0338728577,
-0.0179322474,
0.0076826587,
-0.0146620739,
0.0101868622,
0.0222172346,
0.0559236556,
0.0007806538,
0.0343168974,
0.0268162545,
-0.0091849295,
0.057461597,
0.0170522574,
0.0177185964,
-0.0219080485,
0.0006598755,
-0.0223501548,
0.0341866836,
0.0418284722,
0.0864410475,
0.0074359123,
-0.0613206699,
0.0748976022,
0.0537221842,
-0.0050865463,
0.0237598773,
0.053923782,
-0.0054170117,
0.035174448,
0.0312717222,
-0.0590145178,
0.0161554571,
-0.0108961063,
0.0198450778,
-0.0032332798,
0.0180348381,
-0.0068538864,
-0.0968327075,
-0.0181223974,
-0.0373051427,
0.0392820984,
-0.0245845355,
0.0326010101,
0.0147680072,
-0.0377393551,
0.0254820138,
0.0274298675,
-0.0634486899,
-0.0115738139,
0.0113826171,
0.0486936048,
0.0032711828,
0.0209797211,
0.0093315644,
0.0053951452,
0.0064983829,
-0.0296008885,
0.0762866065,
0.0562063754,
-0.0028590187,
0.0109371934,
-0.0085037379,
0.0177465621,
0.0158643313,
0.0220531523,
0.0380789116,
-0.0226786472,
0.0077251527,
-0.0062046787,
-0.0028695303,
-0.0600977801,
0.0560482256,
-0.040748246,
-0.0072481609,
-0.0237252656,
0.0246092118,
0.0840626284,
0.0008678843,
0.0084604314,
0.0252140872,
0.0324561112,
-0.0342931636,
-0.0072253626,
0.0419431031,
-0.0482237078,
-0.0400602147,
0.0557417907,
-0.0045476793,
-0.0207828693,
0.04602658,
-0.0162894744,
-0.0313138515,
0.0197065789,
-0.0136664091,
-0.0170706529,
-0.0886290371,
-0.0056445948,
-0.01128597,
0.0460558981,
-0.0088633057,
0.0162886512,
-0.0284570176,
0.0156317856,
-0.0016574112,
-0.0232348777,
0.0621221624,
-0.0330461264,
-0.0910073444,
0.0225775447,
-0.0058022588,
-0.0017899466,
-0.0143892784,
-0.0155032892,
-0.0153008141,
-0.0137405656,
-0.086074017,
-0.0007614243,
0.0183510538,
-0.0106306449,
-0.004006125,
-0.0479679778,
-0.0053735208,
-0.0022505538,
-0.0139067108,
0.0073695858,
-0.0066737882,
-0.0015773107,
0.0466678552,
0.0037662976,
0.0098487809,
-0.0605564341,
-0.0183852185,
-0.0187000353,
0.0318935812,
0.0054596998,
-0.006271976,
-0.0376099348,
0.0331157856,
-0.0353911184,
0.0260860994,
0.0188171957,
-0.1051813439,
0.0221729539,
-0.0104449093,
-0.0104297707,
0.0665598959,
-0.0368414186,
0.0133688478,
0.0711607784,
-0.0252414048,
-0.0265422836,
0.0140308188,
0.0089336485,
0.0199546423,
-0.004602618,
-0.0190856569,
0.0229563676,
0.1181718633,
0.0206801463,
-0.0406556427,
-0.0336686708,
-0.0070210891,
-0.059412282,
-0.0283891801,
0.0130785098,
-0.0257709399,
-0.0574096777,
0.0524028167,
-0.0424240045,
-0.0453678407,
0.1021314785,
-0.0427509509,
-0.0257833526,
-0.0745109841,
0.039822612,
-0.0358926505,
0.0272792596,
0.0329179056,
-0.00138454,
0.0671623424,
-0.0508511215,
-0.0459345244,
0.0105972392,
-0.0102021769,
-0.0169995166,
0.0483394228,
-0.0557305291,
-0.0197057202,
0.0311515387,
-0.004533357,
-0.0300269648,
-0.0447456986,
0.0081316624,
-0.003230433,
-0.0078048124,
-0.0036099921,
0.0381055586,
0.0072781215,
0.0028123567,
0.035886161,
0.0009840702,
0.010099493,
-0.0288251359,
0.0101954686,
0.0327231511,
0.0329180695,
0.0011782704,
0.0024933787,
0.0183259938,
0.0160828382,
-0.0128388917,
0.0526441224,
-0.0802461579,
0.0178665407,
0.0097081028,
-0.0318407714,
-0.0209095664,
0.0168471541,
0.0291502867,
-0.0311369188,
-0.0314253457,
0.0789909363,
0.0418219492,
-0.0327817053,
0.0016060631,
-0.0063978937,
0.0014887288,
-0.0102258353,
0.0197836161,
-0.039831806,
-0.0101643885,
-0.0021117015,
-0.0077355639,
-0.0160673298,
-0.007788463,
0.0060091717,
-0.1225698516,
0.0269163661,
-0.0052702622,
0.0064115995,
-0.009852808,
-0.0080279466,
0.0098944856,
0.0009930651,
0.0827976018,
-0.0084981751,
-0.0067538195,
-0.0175344702,
-0.002133633,
-0.0188209824,
-0.0635812208,
0.0214575641,
-0.0342688598,
0.0608867183,
0.0332641117,
0.0463279188,
-0.0084052365,
0.0017878561,
0.0231459457,
-0.0044676298,
-0.015601824,
-0.0212610289,
0.0379289985,
0.0421658754,
-0.0183238983,
-0.0303813405,
-0.0100301141,
-0.0069786385,
0.0057581626,
0.0094500482,
0.0779526979,
0.0396595597,
-0.0125774145,
-0.0368259847,
0.0187978409,
-0.0350676291,
0.0742615312,
0.0824241713,
-0.0610307455,
-0.0192696657,
-0.0339768343,
-0.0362632163,
-0.0321347937,
0.0231054071,
0.039153669,
-0.0153452475,
-0.0118273506,
-0.1459423602,
-0.0709683672,
-0.0227084886,
-0.0137865795,
0.0520063192,
-0.0122647602,
0.0837826356,
-0.041763898,
0.0040700394,
0.0264670458,
0.0129802842,
-0.0233182609,
-0.0352995768,
0.0323761217,
0.0290807076,
0.0352175944,
-0.0039762757,
0.0213437751,
0.024020806,
-0.0530391,
0.0120710609,
0.0982650146,
0.0232677441,
-0.0014208913,
-0.0335211791,
-0.036197491,
-0.0259256326,
0.0210373476,
-0.0137334466,
0.0153826736,
0.0411359742,
0.0025602435,
0.0131633217,
0.0220144801,
0.0019654068,
0.0278254859,
0.0051430231,
-0.0087170471,
-0.0254252311,
-0.0345329195,
0.0350306556,
0.0063421908,
0.0145966625,
0.0129459426,
0.0134695293,
-0.0348707512,
0.0255494788,
-0.0385351814,
0.0005544138,
-0.0425073393,
-0.0205733348,
0.0509266108,
0.0018017384,
-0.0643185377,
-0.0162388366,
-0.0553489253,
0.0483571403,
0.0030385661,
-0.0134547018,
0.0385552794,
0.0400770903,
-0.037352711,
-0.0054357098,
-0.0162462592,
-0.0448313691,
-0.0519024618,
0.0132436343,
0.0046030385,
0.0796038285,
0.0149059026,
-0.0258259289,
0.0087205302,
0.0184612107,
-0.0213460568,
0.0385082215,
0.0257538315,
-0.0082262754,
0.0353498235,
-0.015040528,
0.0601097979,
-0.0383340232,
0.0046811858,
-0.0319412239,
0.0358345844,
-0.0200267155,
-0.0412142649,
0.045139391,
0.011363579,
0.0005850567,
-0.0396085195,
0.0762189478,
0.0285301283,
-0.0029615487,
-0.001360342,
0.0423891209,
-0.0500612557,
-0.0025030812,
-0.0126613658,
-0.0107146138,
-0.0503861159,
-0.0046623182,
-0.0428985916,
-0.0889958069,
0.0126573984,
0.0444254316,
0.0177102853,
-0.0132600665,
-0.0311095249,
0.0373245403,
0.0072766291,
0.0022252682,
-0.0346675888,
0.0071232649,
0.0021877042,
-0.0001809606,
-0.0552698374,
-5.547391838e-33,
-0.0574270114,
-0.0186798554,
-0.0145856133,
0.0141477287,
0.0187958833,
-0.0346727818,
-0.0823086128,
0.0020331678,
-0.0327928178,
0.0170852169,
-0.0401967242,
0.0179768316,
0.0081217065,
0.0211015418,
0.0427796021,
-0.0114976708,
0.0119416118,
-0.0021320258,
0.0067662862,
-0.0453227684,
0.027095506,
0.01531207,
0.0287942868,
-0.0359223224,
0.077279456,
-0.0056002601,
-0.005496629,
0.0071945777,
-0.0492064022,
0.0954789296,
-0.0321309529,
0.0242134873,
0.0214582123,
-0.0060043191,
-0.0131584071,
0.0302112494,
-0.0799872056,
-0.0103266239,
0.0232902132,
-0.0015848312,
0.0040085311,
-0.0329901874,
0.0630518347,
-0.0296650697,
-0.0052898899,
0.0165763739,
0.0404169373,
-0.0550208986,
-0.0123117203,
0.0358282812,
-0.0618721582,
-0.0151370494,
0.0146354232,
-0.0007115281,
-0.003062085,
0.0124533242,
-0.0196886286,
0.0101310471,
-0.0652549118,
-0.0073691881,
-0.0216065794,
0.0304543469,
0.013939904,
-0.0520492494,
-0.0080548758,
0.0608785674,
0.017454315,
-0.036138352,
0.0004012516,
-0.0140777174,
0.0788023844,
-0.0025917401,
0.0636376813,
0.060548,
0.040301118,
-0.0111539103,
-0.0637542382,
0.0087133944,
0.0526198298,
0.0326835513,
0.00838021,
-0.0294339638,
-0.0425692201,
-0.0249591637,
-0.0095872013,
-0.054166574,
-0.0513797067,
-0.0545598753,
0.0446967855,
-0.0267241728,
0.01417688,
-0.0190926194,
0.014224913,
-0.0443423092,
-0.0197743941,
0.0514128804,
0.0172223449,
0.0434971787,
0.0072500776,
0.0587229319,
-0.0653936267,
-0.0153302401,
-0.0764328912,
0.009910454,
0.0097789811,
0.023765929,
0.0441262536,
-0.0068885749,
-0.0186904408,
0.0203746036,
-0.0311251003,
0.0053815753,
0.003761648,
0.0518888943,
0.0234780852,
0.0351421759,
-0.0018549432,
0.0291974861,
0.0009176445,
0.0051163007,
-0.0627420619,
-0.0115246205,
0.0137636121,
0.0441510268,
-0.0230921861,
-0.0474862047,
0.016610628,
0.0308400244,
0.0160881598,
-0.0126988785,
0.0179947782,
0.0180859026,
2.492e-7,
0.0481259525,
0.0444640927,
0.0102708722,
0.0127651803,
0.0111427857,
0.0260032471,
-0.0707940161,
0.0153933261,
0.0480657667,
-0.0162358731,
-0.0167250484,
0.0029684198,
0.0682123601,
-0.0260727815,
-0.1491672397,
-0.0130623793,
-0.0203061476,
-0.0138865607,
-0.0410957858,
0.0112449108,
0.0300763249,
0.0630009174,
0.0003587228,
-0.0020291575,
-0.0214079861,
-0.0142057836,
0.0709112063,
0.0025342552,
-0.0290773548,
0.0247177277,
0.0563887022,
-0.0052165817,
-0.004835566,
0.0009367905,
-0.0018646293,
0.0457122549,
0.001508469,
0.0747661069,
0.0296557732,
-0.0382921398,
0.0187952183,
-0.0110452408,
-0.014141663,
-0.0714286268,
0.0225283522,
-0.0944409668,
-0.0391185209,
0.0065653254,
-0.0124746086,
-0.009696003,
0.0135866255,
-0.0027821714,
-0.0001475643,
0.0249722265,
0.0156317931,
-0.0651780218,
0.0115441456,
-0.0162776746,
-0.0393993855,
0.023902677,
-0.0123291817,
-0.0118396627,
-0.0619712472,
-0.0266598891,
0.0449404903,
-0.0770378336,
0.0094981836,
1.937104028e-34,
0.0286690798,
-0.0445504263,
0.0416272767,
0.0356378779,
0.0091375494,
-0.0110292826,
-0.0063851508,
0.0486820601,
0.0101495376,
-0.029406352,
0.0040445589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12669v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12669v1 | HRoT: Hybrid prompt strategy and Retrieval of Thought for Table-Text Hybrid Question Answering | 2023-09-22T07:26:17 | 2023-09-22T07:26:17 | Tongxu Luo, Fangyu Lei, Jiahe Lei, Weihao Liu, Shihu He, Jun Zhao, Kang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Answering numerical questions over hybrid contents from the given tables and
text(TextTableQA) is a challenging task. Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs)
have gained significant attention in the NLP community. With the emergence of
large language models, In-Context Learning and Chain-of-Thought prompting have
become two particularly popular research topics in this field. In this paper,
we introduce a new prompting strategy called Hybrid prompt strategy and
Retrieval of Thought for TextTableQA. Through In-Context Learning, we prompt
the model to develop the ability of retrieval thinking when dealing with hybrid
data. Our method achieves superior performance compared to the fully-supervised
SOTA on the MultiHiertt dataset in the few-shot setting. | [
0.033670824,
0.0146794124,
-0.0130312182,
0.0403839983,
-0.0591344945,
0.0189776998,
-0.0051436857,
0.018720841,
0.0260644145,
-0.0375621766,
-0.0571310185,
-0.0595370233,
-0.0559036359,
0.0090370215,
0.0236596316,
0.0284621548,
0.0520602316,
-0.0025520741,
-0.0228285305,
0.0020848201,
0.0152410772,
-0.0166516285,
-0.0194866285,
0.0068634115,
-0.0082807792,
-0.0369641744,
-0.011857084,
-0.0171588622,
-0.0079488605,
0.0093741547,
0.0247786492,
0.063984558,
0.0274511408,
0.037286669,
0.000001807,
-0.0165247917,
-0.0637320727,
-0.0070939395,
-0.0239004157,
-0.0264089387,
0.0307934899,
0.0038713054,
0.0249904953,
0.0187357608,
-0.0546722189,
0.0231168438,
-0.0057356884,
0.0469198711,
0.0677631199,
0.0460616164,
0.0152139757,
-0.0198308006,
-0.007279139,
0.0245752204,
0.0539697856,
-0.0284916367,
0.0197383706,
0.0058686459,
0.0267057996,
0.0368809737,
0.0251459647,
0.0723502487,
0.0267646201,
0.0185256395,
0.0017854881,
0.0314463265,
-0.0352652222,
0.0339263603,
-0.0023267888,
0.0909328163,
0.0381188281,
-0.0255402345,
-0.0005532628,
0.0216606259,
0.0115495501,
-0.0002054306,
-0.0498938523,
-0.0016511659,
-0.0239089821,
-0.0130841909,
0.0130782118,
0.0147818439,
-0.0219959039,
-0.0224682428,
-0.044549711,
0.0634233877,
-0.0115362173,
-0.0677528605,
0.0192937367,
-0.0143634025,
-0.0172229297,
-0.0023378003,
0.010896787,
0.0603521019,
-0.0471481085,
0.0209802631,
0.0508021973,
-0.0466195941,
0.0108132306,
-0.0441847928,
0.0283660125,
0.073303096,
-0.0373907834,
0.0361491516,
-0.030544024,
-0.0084902346,
-0.0237497892,
0.004867692,
-0.0462461039,
-0.0222915839,
-0.0533386581,
-0.0234655552,
-0.0735335425,
0.0436140932,
-0.0518941469,
-0.0116249556,
0.0073189423,
-0.0052324133,
-0.0103776203,
0.0322289765,
0.0225384794,
0.0178269371,
-0.0099018551,
0.0035013433,
-0.0534891263,
0.0327199548,
-0.0286257099,
0.0004542893,
-0.0036814853,
-0.0418152325,
-0.0336989388,
-0.042496141,
0.0201650672,
-0.0400111377,
0.0294655301,
0.0427916199,
-0.0535762385,
-0.0081012724,
-0.0412712768,
-0.0343984477,
-0.0303872991,
-0.0594825968,
-0.0085346717,
-0.0375740491,
0.0533349328,
0.0056921449,
-0.001799955,
-0.0029053963,
0.0245388485,
0.0617789812,
0.0062765819,
0.0634204075,
0.0151187526,
0.0017913902,
0.011562923,
-0.0139105991,
-0.0370712243,
0.0892625898,
-0.0107297525,
-0.011553036,
-0.000735948,
0.0238298327,
0.0022349469,
0.0488481708,
0.0709502622,
0.0027312338,
-0.012257643,
0.0614199676,
0.0461780168,
0.0326988846,
-0.0311621409,
0.0353317298,
-0.032719817,
0.0360816978,
0.0278210081,
0.0266540404,
0.0135439076,
0.0400012285,
0.040726468,
0.0082473317,
0.0162679944,
0.0327592194,
0.0149647193,
0.0350439399,
-0.0450868793,
0.0120855644,
0.0564202927,
-0.0021662866,
-0.0353286676,
-0.0314482041,
-0.0009096059,
0.0288987998,
-0.0494642742,
0.0481274761,
0.0407420583,
0.0168656427,
-0.0544091538,
-0.0090743601,
0.0080048712,
-0.0336326845,
-0.026690932,
-0.012657688,
0.0424970947,
0.035428524,
0.0218455736,
-0.0848616585,
0.0068132849,
-0.0191410035,
0.0071978047,
-0.0210927632,
-0.0004361428,
-0.0391998924,
-0.0276051946,
-0.0045034657,
0.0102058612,
0.0300281178,
0.0189616196,
-0.0278718714,
-0.0132569503,
-0.0021347639,
-0.0067465785,
-0.0068526058,
0.0169287678,
0.0154632879,
0.0182936583,
-0.0029606752,
-0.0065256567,
0.0291586053,
0.0056294939,
0.0334883668,
-0.0027511364,
0.0444411449,
0.0286120139,
-0.035523694,
-0.0321127102,
-0.0381646566,
-0.0341013633,
-0.0874857679,
0.0244911984,
0.0198727716,
-0.030324297,
-0.0570011213,
-0.0042599156,
-0.0456535928,
-0.0108556738,
-0.0214295294,
-0.0107179089,
-0.0497570299,
-0.0162181985,
0.0383455195,
-0.0098566478,
-0.0658330768,
0.1050839275,
0.009401056,
0.0670751035,
0.0439698175,
-0.0829223841,
0.0340707451,
-0.0487279743,
0.0159155261,
-0.0260733236,
-0.0168074705,
0.0339209326,
0.0050876555,
0.0266947411,
-0.0691146329,
-0.0364616215,
-0.0993638188,
0.041006688,
-0.04652467,
-0.0004955826,
0.0178938899,
0.0091192145,
-0.0140821775,
-0.0220825989,
-0.0637136102,
0.0114693036,
0.0204972308,
0.0234036073,
0.0487895794,
0.0197595116,
0.0058460571,
-0.0219872147,
-0.0187437478,
-0.0320793949,
0.0411929302,
-0.04164958,
-0.0514599457,
-0.0005220923,
0.007171094,
-0.021595858,
0.0191654507,
0.00975323,
0.007672173,
0.0011161234,
-0.038212046,
0.0450085513,
0.0309364479,
-0.0286772251,
-0.0152135501,
0.0153213954,
-0.0082474211,
-0.0541817807,
0.0436770171,
-0.0123080388,
-0.0142779555,
0.0587769151,
0.0054269331,
0.0340292528,
0.0172188208,
-0.0001043673,
-0.0282215402,
-0.0404788405,
0.0130523043,
0.0036592253,
0.0277994592,
-0.105141826,
0.0605095588,
0.0094295098,
0.0595134944,
-0.0077141682,
0.026842637,
0.0306210965,
-0.0104511119,
-0.0031406546,
-0.0459406637,
-0.0017302259,
-0.07775902,
0.0595241152,
0.0000818738,
0.0042820787,
-0.0256168582,
-0.0182465836,
-0.0839584991,
0.0305729285,
0.0141350869,
-0.0414458252,
0.091235958,
-0.0072874161,
0.040471375,
-0.0178813469,
-0.0384228937,
-0.0291450843,
-0.0431789607,
-0.0187634416,
0.0300982296,
-0.012288725,
0.0301914085,
0.0039054682,
-0.0259344634,
0.061349161,
0.047845643,
-0.0185657665,
-0.0249449275,
-0.0368337594,
0.0705621094,
0.0358026996,
0.0018198113,
-0.0345406272,
-0.0106878486,
0.074870415,
0.0264095478,
0.0157230347,
-0.0203181449,
0.0076110871,
0.0070953756,
0.0486848727,
-0.0165351108,
-0.0023515425,
0.0489743985,
-0.002700825,
-0.0342288651,
-0.0484321304,
0.0760311931,
0.062118113,
-0.0391068496,
-0.0269087106,
-0.0404448584,
0.0304897409,
0.038946487,
0.0643387362,
-0.1206528693,
-0.0327799544,
-0.0153662423,
-0.0467897356,
-0.0109838415,
-0.0514762402,
-0.0033045069,
-0.1033349261,
0.0209437422,
-0.0385399573,
-0.0922846496,
-0.0507361032,
0.0040277396,
0.0058968328,
0.0159293488,
0.0055352421,
0.0649945736,
-0.0177479144,
0.0316601396,
0.0108123804,
0.0012460632,
-0.0213857014,
0.0096502118,
-0.0460457727,
0.01081827,
0.0430821441,
0.0007488464,
-0.0065569873,
-0.0299054589,
0.0357192829,
-0.026984781,
-0.0015068511,
-0.0132271303,
0.0326980092,
-0.0226121489,
0.000171623,
-0.0033526716,
0.0279779378,
-0.0189238414,
-0.009837457,
0.0471384674,
0.0879603624,
-0.0315390639,
0.0157002825,
0.0055290074,
0.0027154277,
0.0142015452,
0.0741819963,
0.0241260324,
-0.0197693668,
-0.0057640863,
-0.0158086848,
-0.0416015089,
-0.0094833737,
-0.0212818459,
0.0402213149,
0.0230460335,
0.0586774386,
-0.0606839545,
-0.0176960621,
0.0635965019,
0.0664938241,
0.0022881101,
0.0476394966,
-0.0420970283,
0.024508886,
-0.0111440178,
-0.0150285559,
-0.0832236558,
0.0122424271,
-0.0195256751,
-0.0079777082,
0.0368412547,
-0.056308046,
-0.0325540043,
0.0045224875,
-0.0457515121,
-0.0051327576,
-0.0429590531,
0.0058897245,
0.0205031093,
-0.0012418203,
0.009635726,
-0.0229478348,
0.0250589028,
0.0343637727,
-0.0666320547,
-0.0356703028,
-0.0121542821,
0.0316878408,
0.0137390401,
0.0409782827,
-0.035510812,
-0.0157452431,
-0.0078444574,
0.0780171528,
-0.0103001669,
0.0196673833,
0.0881959721,
-0.0024944935,
0.00880735,
0.0514984317,
-0.0156987961,
-0.0383280292,
0.0358838998,
-0.0373284146,
-0.0738075301,
-0.0229488704,
-0.0001138017,
0.0047728778,
-0.0454666018,
-0.0173135418,
-0.060764607,
0.0048248912,
0.0676950067,
-0.011471129,
-0.0379596539,
0.0489324853,
-0.0186866801,
0.0161034688,
-0.0256634448,
-0.0185684822,
-0.0186918173,
0.0251844097,
0.0323007852,
0.0021624316,
0.0830275938,
0.052813191,
-0.0427407287,
-0.0478317514,
0.0117002605,
-0.0794297233,
-0.0452087894,
-0.0061312127,
0.0216203816,
0.0380109139,
0.0025257622,
-0.0370885506,
0.001694669,
-0.0217799004,
0.0163524486,
0.0153099364,
0.0300827269,
-0.0135539882,
0.0650445148,
0.0085233916,
-0.0084170122,
-0.0144330077,
0.0665033013,
-0.0239339452,
0.0028424093,
0.0152790137,
-0.0095272213,
-0.0491372719,
0.0090583805,
-0.0051954868,
0.0251521543,
-0.0102995755,
0.0010856693,
-0.0591716431,
-0.0289052054,
0.0279467218,
0.0220082644,
-0.0599462613,
0.0039680973,
0.0414451286,
0.0506142676,
0.0425133631,
-0.014384022,
-0.0425565019,
0.0274424385,
0.0271269735,
-0.0420433544,
-0.0387222283,
-6.096055296e-33,
-0.0257128198,
-0.0061510792,
0.0457571521,
-0.0279206932,
0.0006229643,
0.0021598088,
-0.0206178371,
-0.0049865358,
-0.0188885164,
-0.0093175648,
-0.0611723587,
0.0217318051,
0.007714876,
0.0221591704,
-0.0075597153,
-0.0879799649,
-0.0196046792,
-0.0336273685,
0.0059118569,
-0.0133843701,
0.0172312334,
0.0359623916,
0.0039420491,
0.0188243929,
0.0499919131,
0.000368676,
0.005064874,
0.0280472096,
-0.0173053928,
0.0272926837,
-0.0545645691,
0.0373370647,
0.0355072059,
-0.0613703988,
0.0078385565,
0.0492577739,
-0.0865981132,
-0.04867322,
0.013948109,
-0.0157271996,
-0.0332255214,
-0.0245222952,
-0.0132597713,
-0.0227642171,
0.0030634508,
-0.0065943375,
0.0084877433,
-0.0267650075,
-0.0139641287,
-0.0399393179,
-0.0305901635,
-0.0086038169,
-0.014654289,
0.017402105,
0.0219750144,
0.0775496662,
0.0217318051,
0.0215836558,
-0.0426084138,
0.0015653924,
-0.002949348,
0.0295430981,
-0.0017652937,
-0.0197273958,
0.0111205578,
0.0170479529,
0.0237502959,
-0.002943642,
-0.0772757009,
-0.0329756811,
-0.0271560624,
0.021264514,
0.0462128483,
0.0424706787,
0.0316609815,
0.0326843075,
-0.0780249014,
0.0353142954,
0.0350061171,
-0.0087843845,
0.0055895145,
-0.0215149522,
-0.0255076084,
-0.0140982969,
-0.0460457206,
0.0047316635,
-0.0533535779,
0.0023167832,
0.0259990394,
-0.0218275841,
0.0437291563,
-0.0177791268,
0.050948903,
-0.0198010784,
-0.0208641309,
0.0294583067,
-0.023546651,
0.0227544568,
0.0122648142,
0.0454542674,
-0.0264356993,
-0.0219541416,
0.007781215,
0.0021228145,
-0.003628586,
0.0271915048,
0.0543483086,
-0.007568046,
-0.0686953217,
-0.0240021851,
-0.0627297983,
0.0508977883,
-0.0272371732,
-0.001074426,
0.0030955209,
0.0453444943,
0.009506857,
0.0622775257,
0.0224974714,
-0.0351765677,
-0.009715003,
0.0191936716,
-0.0207766518,
-0.0208700337,
0.0051567378,
0.0421532653,
-0.0071702469,
0.0464788973,
-0.0150218969,
-0.0374808013,
0.0266557839,
0.0353286266,
2.458e-7,
0.0510171354,
0.0139073599,
0.0145277129,
0.0291898791,
-0.0061100153,
0.0072760279,
-0.0131676439,
0.0056089982,
0.0339235328,
-0.0588430129,
0.0603014566,
0.0085617313,
0.046715755,
0.0083562415,
-0.0747551098,
-0.068686679,
-0.054522898,
-0.0293182805,
-0.0531146079,
-0.011427572,
0.0966625512,
0.080989331,
-0.0417950079,
-0.0017219016,
-0.0306209717,
-0.0127509153,
0.0677312613,
-0.0364025161,
0.0191400126,
0.0061764359,
0.0310965125,
-0.0334607176,
0.0227878205,
0.0640331358,
0.0074098133,
0.0326959789,
0.0321503766,
0.0215795673,
0.0286086444,
-0.0057039792,
0.0019891697,
-0.0347756296,
0.017290961,
-0.0622050688,
0.1130187511,
-0.064283967,
0.0126709361,
0.048115734,
-0.0055602691,
-0.0085865529,
0.0320016481,
0.0015552854,
-0.007487277,
0.0417882986,
0.0211885814,
0.0324517041,
0.0255667903,
-0.0554949902,
-0.0026401496,
0.0065821311,
-0.0263451207,
-0.0133730723,
0.0151518891,
0.0186566394,
-0.0292188637,
-0.0717690736,
-0.0170361158,
2.365113231e-34,
0.0428449176,
-0.035015285,
0.0393611901,
0.0687299371,
0.0295312256,
-0.0370005369,
-0.0063025933,
-0.0051000295,
0.0310456064,
-0.0889421105,
-0.0201237462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12646v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12646v2 | Decoding Emotional Experiences in Dyadic Conversations of Married Couples: Leveraging Semantic Similarity through Sentence Embedding | 2023-09-22T06:37:45 | 2024-02-25T19:43:20 | Chen-Wei Yu, Yun-Shiuan Chuang, Alexandros N. Lotsos, Claudia M. Haase | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in Natural Language Processing (NLP) have highlighted the
potential of sentence embeddings in measuring semantic similarity (hereafter
similarity). Yet, whether this approach can be used to analyze real-world
dyadic interactions and predict people's emotional experiences in response to
these interactions remains largely uncharted. To bridge this gap, the present
study analyzes verbal conversations of 50 married couples who engage in
naturalistic 10-minute conflict and 10-minute positive conversations.
Transformer-based model General Text Embeddings-Large is employed to obtain the
embeddings of the utterances from each speaker. The overall similarity of the
conversations is then quantified by the average cosine similarity between the
embeddings of adjacent utterances. Results show that lower similarity is
associated with greater positive emotional experiences in the positive (but not
conflict) conversation. Follow-up analyses show that (a) findings remain stable
when controlling for marital satisfaction and the number of utterance pairs and
(b) the similarity measure is valid in capturing critical features of a dyadic
conversation. The present study underscores the potency of sentence embeddings
in understanding links between interpersonal dynamics and individual emotional
experiences, paving the way for innovative applications of NLP tools in
affective and relationship science. | [
0.0442718379,
0.0374404155,
-0.020820586,
0.0425143763,
-0.04891086,
0.0046604821,
-0.0015430558,
0.0029557985,
0.0228873771,
-0.0515985377,
-0.008244128,
-0.0328279324,
0.0103883184,
0.0081813764,
-0.0170595087,
-0.0404534228,
-0.0143798571,
0.0940305442,
0.0174273532,
0.0263145268,
0.0334983468,
0.0073848213,
0.0195743293,
0.0524328686,
-0.0280620456,
0.0059616012,
-0.0120856687,
-0.0002274885,
0.061792016,
0.0032801258,
-0.0278623383,
0.0405620821,
0.0130296387,
-0.0299933888,
0.0000021351,
-0.057812348,
-0.0132713392,
-0.0048132739,
0.0295341555,
-0.0079026753,
0.075084649,
-0.0189458001,
0.0386720821,
0.0199048948,
0.0110939993,
0.0159670431,
0.0076453928,
0.0921674967,
0.0293999873,
0.0385394134,
-0.0140031185,
-0.0343447328,
-0.0117728272,
-0.0036460403,
-0.0285404809,
0.043264851,
0.012432579,
0.0056168227,
-0.0126067484,
-0.0370655879,
-0.0411646292,
-0.0235093068,
-0.0207220912,
-0.006538915,
0.0353501402,
0.0386147574,
-0.0117069148,
-0.0085642897,
0.0119643183,
0.025523372,
0.0309248511,
0.0104509378,
0.0081654815,
-0.0041001369,
-0.0061917203,
0.0429427512,
-0.0041663866,
0.0100149745,
0.0072801854,
0.0083140507,
-0.0106973043,
0.0288134962,
-0.0264403019,
-0.0228855945,
-0.0158375148,
0.0125216274,
-0.0164039675,
-0.0698024705,
0.01625802,
0.0054304074,
0.001909941,
-0.0521959886,
0.0341739729,
-0.0497409627,
0.0606249459,
0.0243340768,
-0.0163893104,
-0.0333859622,
-0.0129948016,
-0.0620227493,
0.0111053046,
0.0370651521,
-0.0173204206,
-0.0202241614,
0.0337751135,
0.0476218648,
0.0624515377,
-0.007925556,
-0.0587664731,
0.001003457,
-0.0812316388,
0.0097188083,
-0.0170963835,
0.0424422882,
-0.0410300903,
-0.0451743156,
-0.0389418826,
0.008994868,
-0.0036264348,
-0.0090689221,
-0.0238817837,
0.0093959784,
0.0104531785,
0.0321586207,
-0.0242356379,
0.0027603202,
-0.0680738315,
0.0083776508,
-0.0442082547,
-0.0387308374,
0.0306339748,
0.0003512579,
0.0125736296,
-0.0076993043,
-0.0234994665,
-0.0001418428,
-0.0053734863,
-0.0478376374,
0.0144551173,
-0.0089369752,
-0.0786801577,
-0.018299941,
-0.0155392587,
-0.0037178115,
0.0838702321,
0.0207902808,
0.0091680195,
-0.0301174205,
0.0251257289,
0.0090623908,
-0.0619915947,
0.0537579767,
0.0674005225,
0.0104085114,
-0.0137606524,
0.0311375633,
0.0657881126,
0.0133778462,
0.0418844186,
0.0007409764,
0.0714006126,
0.0007871509,
-0.0063789566,
-0.0206108391,
-0.0149654048,
-0.040107511,
-0.0141499862,
0.0094326232,
-0.0133442376,
0.0616972782,
-0.0047217095,
0.0338000581,
-0.0404245146,
-0.0223616455,
0.0499122553,
0.109736912,
-0.0266459715,
0.0928042009,
-0.0044406215,
0.0445942394,
-0.0296143498,
0.042137254,
0.0084732911,
-0.0217982307,
-0.004714313,
-0.0287878215,
0.0288300421,
-0.0407898612,
-0.0067712599,
-0.0456245616,
-0.0344786942,
-0.0504144244,
0.0193537492,
-0.002232156,
-0.0131103573,
-0.0079545844,
-0.0084552672,
0.0074718967,
0.0159508418,
-0.06527403,
-0.0483499244,
0.0144408131,
0.0023335724,
0.0967127383,
0.0123431869,
0.0128236786,
-0.0458830148,
-0.0443507843,
-0.0011446108,
-0.003238241,
0.0166302808,
0.052318763,
0.0261048991,
-0.0317026116,
-0.0032154077,
-0.0180413239,
0.0016467669,
-0.0084778862,
-0.026636973,
0.0167661924,
0.0167991966,
0.0317066349,
0.0307756476,
0.0268740095,
-0.051644709,
0.0156842601,
0.0135528417,
0.0189472549,
0.0004994237,
0.0407120697,
-0.0227462444,
0.0185058638,
0.0635121539,
-0.024156902,
-0.0667703897,
0.0873846263,
-0.0185810514,
-0.0294105504,
-0.0305651501,
-0.0639807582,
0.0039871,
-0.0054791318,
-0.0138131185,
0.0221547224,
0.0350072347,
-0.0281945113,
0.0205254257,
0.0069105919,
0.0078235762,
-0.0097113848,
0.0351337157,
0.0204904191,
-0.0145173538,
-0.0403118506,
0.029079929,
-0.074174203,
-0.046605356,
0.0084054116,
-0.0038864403,
-0.0507396311,
-0.0208493564,
0.0022889078,
-0.014944274,
0.0150739551,
-0.011074747,
-0.0529451743,
-0.0766105279,
-0.1215165779,
0.0105115036,
0.0162246544,
0.0147592286,
0.0342002138,
-0.0211462136,
0.0141966343,
0.0236255862,
-0.0050121723,
-0.0034830545,
0.0217290297,
-0.0168187823,
0.0391699597,
0.0038057656,
-0.0138721075,
-0.0570971966,
0.0007301635,
-0.046021346,
0.0651234165,
-0.0046646949,
-0.0189736225,
-0.0445158519,
0.043186646,
-0.0533221997,
-0.004529966,
-0.0276110284,
-0.0634576231,
-0.0015094564,
0.0313398056,
0.0669002682,
0.0384878442,
0.0448689312,
0.0909665823,
0.0036082,
-0.0427158214,
-0.0314764753,
0.0018257231,
-0.0116173979,
0.0109212147,
-0.0623985715,
-0.0240416024,
-0.0139204552,
0.0203930046,
0.0004216003,
-0.0079931561,
-0.0195164327,
-0.013503314,
-0.0012235475,
-0.0015529533,
-0.003223019,
-0.052631259,
-0.0027284967,
0.0113608856,
0.0135811474,
-0.0100716259,
0.0252173878,
0.0220428593,
-0.0119990846,
-0.0819863155,
-0.0262841601,
-0.0159899481,
0.0705758855,
-0.0250359476,
0.0066600447,
0.0337122194,
0.0197769292,
-0.0540383458,
-0.0635669604,
-0.0096384212,
-0.0321858488,
0.0511838384,
-0.0279398151,
-0.0504206605,
0.039133165,
-0.0525307134,
-0.0339119583,
-0.0228597261,
-0.0627323389,
-0.0070217289,
0.0321910679,
-0.0011380671,
-0.0128511116,
-0.0240958091,
0.0094894776,
-0.092500113,
0.0241866205,
-0.0445201956,
-0.0004015411,
0.0649994761,
0.0439392962,
-0.0011582914,
-0.016159907,
0.0087097129,
0.0231197998,
0.035324309,
0.0305725429,
0.0151093258,
-0.012867569,
-0.0227726772,
-0.0340824798,
0.0095927324,
-0.0254026167,
-0.0214905664,
-0.0024116833,
-0.0091286916,
-0.0124471216,
0.1298119575,
0.0408018045,
0.0385161787,
0.0060924473,
-0.0645249635,
-0.0127220703,
0.0356147066,
-0.0031412926,
-0.0791269615,
-0.0017272509,
0.0038669682,
-0.0451054499,
0.0002425165,
-0.0347703993,
-0.0162795726,
-0.0739034712,
-0.0286620669,
-0.0027330813,
0.0545265824,
-0.0389993861,
-0.0104621919,
-0.0324661098,
0.0009724741,
-0.006938064,
-0.0414101183,
0.0107109519,
0.0160248931,
-0.0022688902,
-0.0652796179,
-0.0332602747,
0.0440754257,
-0.0691904575,
0.0133124972,
-0.0029474192,
0.1141977608,
0.0004262295,
-0.009406561,
0.0132049462,
-0.0040133856,
-0.0093356473,
0.0231306646,
0.0473882593,
-0.0329142213,
0.0402655862,
-0.0321581624,
0.0160047933,
0.0081330286,
0.0050913463,
0.0322236046,
0.052204594,
-0.0140955215,
-0.0420973487,
0.0163957793,
0.0725332871,
0.0215161107,
0.0646395013,
0.0103038084,
-0.0373405218,
-0.0170639008,
0.031192543,
0.0637887269,
0.0531230457,
-0.0417742506,
-0.0034505979,
0.0608465411,
0.0549694672,
-0.0523578003,
-0.0949174613,
0.0200131219,
0.0055689886,
0.0148015525,
-0.0338327102,
0.0194130968,
-0.0321767963,
-0.0463070385,
-0.0052252444,
-0.0011543498,
0.025781475,
0.0533053689,
0.0412049368,
0.0309358481,
0.0328293629,
-0.0275702458,
-0.0258807186,
-0.0230336357,
-0.0181198493,
0.0024380283,
-0.023476772,
0.0059583806,
0.0193581991,
0.0404621772,
-0.0235743467,
-0.0140428916,
0.0085336622,
-0.0166889057,
-0.0029248158,
0.0000121813,
0.0710950419,
0.0205158945,
0.0160590559,
0.0199915338,
0.004814391,
0.0101304492,
-0.0167280808,
0.0177064557,
-0.084961921,
-0.0042889235,
-0.0139631983,
0.0126208356,
0.008769583,
-0.0058164843,
-0.0452945828,
-0.0171281286,
-0.0541607775,
-0.0113118747,
-0.0583511367,
-0.0368612483,
-0.0001449178,
0.0326707996,
-0.0621549748,
-0.0002599605,
-0.0464204848,
0.0269570928,
-0.015841458,
0.0100996383,
0.0262009818,
-0.0136773279,
-0.0441672131,
0.0172625892,
0.0046972842,
-0.0477117896,
-0.0164149087,
0.0086382627,
-0.0329456516,
0.035497494,
0.0138259679,
-0.0232776105,
-0.0111705903,
0.044216644,
0.0018805149,
0.0133081097,
-0.0039460547,
-0.0250506736,
0.0129114501,
-0.0401321165,
0.0260283239,
-0.0579378791,
0.0205561016,
-0.0121041583,
0.0403537266,
-0.0502633899,
-0.0199646987,
0.04395096,
-0.0182032175,
-0.0458741151,
0.0058730599,
0.012324959,
-0.0439262502,
0.0233067069,
0.004147063,
-0.0519470796,
-0.0485259369,
0.0240480304,
0.0674996823,
0.006343211,
-0.0084641119,
-0.0016821354,
-0.0696938485,
-0.0126845194,
0.0733471662,
-0.0518499836,
0.0290508736,
-0.0438065678,
0.0341470018,
0.0036903305,
-0.0084194737,
0.0070113325,
-0.0021360321,
0.0434101783,
-0.0353251696,
-0.0571867377,
-0.0427664034,
-5.466567786e-33,
-0.0099222958,
-0.0217377469,
-0.031339068,
0.0463287495,
-0.048781272,
0.0223989654,
0.0206993632,
0.0124720139,
-0.0022933239,
0.0655961931,
-0.0101272305,
0.0329035632,
0.0083679045,
0.0167031456,
0.0373672321,
-0.0059456034,
0.0334495641,
-0.0419047587,
-0.001517109,
-0.0121208169,
0.0380197242,
0.0694284812,
0.0486683063,
-0.1084896624,
-0.0265026577,
0.0456659533,
0.0228405911,
-0.0449666232,
0.0602534227,
0.01606231,
-0.0478479266,
0.0392238051,
0.0087900404,
-0.0038545101,
0.0048405994,
0.0578032956,
-0.0288351513,
-0.0545684919,
0.0148481661,
-0.0100252563,
-0.0195372365,
0.0172095075,
0.0051368079,
0.0227729343,
-0.0048510428,
-0.0283448603,
0.0091379909,
-0.009413749,
0.0325085148,
-0.0139968153,
-0.0436392464,
0.0164879356,
-0.0415070169,
0.0136385234,
0.0311682951,
-0.0079527386,
-0.0049892566,
0.0173819922,
-0.0449041836,
-0.0266223475,
-0.010206297,
0.0316706039,
-0.0310951509,
-0.086441718,
0.0293800887,
0.0768964589,
0.0405105315,
0.0226484351,
-0.0220191889,
0.0128857708,
0.002297037,
0.0433690064,
0.0260557923,
0.0756432787,
-0.0119423717,
-0.0414446667,
-0.0523941889,
-0.0206761081,
0.0266384371,
-0.0225903746,
0.0529258959,
0.027141111,
-0.0103620393,
-0.022766551,
-0.0303467251,
-0.00039351,
-0.0160362255,
-0.0374310762,
0.0341524631,
0.0007652445,
0.0034534314,
-0.0113876676,
-0.0078305071,
-0.0703588128,
-0.0127508789,
0.0234228279,
-0.0650999397,
0.0144061763,
0.0094263572,
-0.0254939292,
-0.0237414073,
-0.030419793,
0.0232311785,
0.0435394421,
0.0742529258,
-0.0261856988,
0.0323431119,
-0.0289246626,
-0.0555924885,
-0.022944374,
-0.0217022318,
-0.0105415313,
-0.023745941,
-0.040670462,
-0.0183518343,
0.0639039427,
-0.0007550399,
0.0361511409,
0.0535308756,
0.0301660001,
-0.020628877,
-0.0162453242,
0.0360853821,
0.0077256458,
0.0021436666,
0.0261827745,
0.0101735676,
-0.0236950163,
0.0370873697,
0.0322206356,
-0.0053080101,
-0.0639828518,
2.893e-7,
0.0117832115,
0.0775247291,
0.0676324964,
-0.0325356759,
0.0317104943,
0.0322048366,
0.0250389595,
0.0411144793,
0.0474903807,
-0.008912175,
0.0329342559,
-0.0415815674,
0.0327131525,
-0.0153511027,
0.0079179984,
0.011588756,
-0.0549211986,
-0.0772783384,
-0.0147276456,
0.0005857661,
0.1147616729,
0.0590955876,
0.0580505207,
0.0385594964,
-0.0314530097,
0.0124486098,
0.0299832877,
-0.0946990848,
-0.0065259612,
0.0175048709,
-0.0043549105,
-0.0667491332,
0.0084415656,
0.0400970876,
-0.0051336437,
0.0385424234,
0.0192051064,
0.0389526114,
0.0055882237,
-0.0144599378,
-0.0008451215,
0.0202073827,
-0.0658827871,
-0.0541165285,
0.0432701372,
-0.1226054281,
-0.0332353637,
0.0128804995,
0.0127412872,
-0.0555903688,
0.0640075877,
0.0096900901,
-0.0201781597,
0.0381905064,
0.0366503187,
0.0397159047,
0.0361244008,
-0.0592456982,
0.0304338839,
0.0763485432,
-0.0613384284,
0.011125518,
-0.0194209497,
-0.0004354308,
0.0164097156,
-0.0108880913,
0.0063607795,
2.397053846e-34,
0.0276986677,
0.0553186126,
0.0050465954,
0.0006464878,
0.0701899007,
-0.013928147,
-0.0094588641,
0.005151073,
0.0278120078,
-0.0315580331,
0.005388543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12626v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12626v1 | Construction contract risk identification based on knowledge-augmented language model | 2023-09-22T05:27:06 | 2023-09-22T05:27:06 | Saika Wong, Chunmo Zheng, Xing Su, Yinqiu Tang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Contract review is an essential step in construction projects to prevent
potential losses. However, the current methods for reviewing construction
contracts lack effectiveness and reliability, leading to time-consuming and
error-prone processes. While large language models (LLMs) have shown promise in
revolutionizing natural language processing (NLP) tasks, they struggle with
domain-specific knowledge and addressing specialized issues. This paper
presents a novel approach that leverages LLMs with construction contract
knowledge to emulate the process of contract review by human experts. Our
tuning-free approach incorporates construction contract domain knowledge to
enhance language models for identifying construction contract risks. The use of
a natural language when building the domain knowledge base facilitates
practical implementation. We evaluated our method on real construction
contracts and achieved solid performance. Additionally, we investigated how
large language models employ logical thinking during the task and provide
insights and recommendations for future research. | [
0.0116081797,
0.0980537757,
-0.0150903277,
0.0188764315,
-0.0505787693,
-0.011663367,
0.0008556198,
0.020360861,
0.018920932,
-0.0656106323,
-0.0101876659,
-0.0045102672,
-0.0317204259,
0.0502466746,
0.0132914167,
0.00622629,
0.0146822771,
-0.0292234086,
0.0390054695,
0.0375431143,
0.0007258878,
0.0283555593,
-0.0123802247,
0.0351632014,
-0.0466755331,
0.0042239521,
-0.0223714709,
-0.0420172513,
0.0428771526,
-0.066394791,
-0.0044843578,
0.073051855,
0.01110934,
-0.0014004776,
0.0000020522,
-0.0458176062,
-0.0542633533,
-0.0053748237,
0.0265738536,
0.0145868845,
0.0369977653,
-0.0577967428,
-0.0086663319,
0.0081707565,
-0.0477676466,
0.0037143403,
0.0263406318,
0.0990832523,
0.0637184307,
0.0518877842,
-0.0157741755,
-0.0329322368,
-0.0277791191,
-0.0268368628,
-0.0200609006,
-0.0822285935,
0.0362787321,
0.0085595408,
0.034773048,
0.0358775742,
0.01981958,
0.0188539419,
-0.0158036333,
-0.0433652103,
-0.0022174574,
-0.012363934,
-0.0128799463,
0.0157072954,
-0.0103524001,
0.0370533802,
0.0298841242,
0.0280425195,
0.0033674068,
-0.0379345901,
0.0205362216,
0.0229040943,
-0.0243052766,
0.0468223654,
-0.0163521394,
-0.014452124,
-0.0105788279,
0.032780014,
0.00846167,
0.0253176074,
0.0009134171,
0.0818769261,
-0.0208215509,
-0.0027825136,
0.0077659814,
0.0135794859,
0.0243757982,
-0.0670370683,
0.0310102291,
0.0186091736,
-0.0169833805,
0.0458423123,
-0.0075695929,
0.0005632424,
0.0592073612,
-0.079628706,
-0.0305867214,
0.0129573792,
0.0110995416,
0.0817398503,
-0.0097475657,
0.0073768464,
-0.0078559471,
0.0201457292,
0.0008573636,
0.0371643603,
-0.0430073664,
-0.0349534862,
-0.0278064217,
0.0379816666,
-0.0232633762,
0.0065951324,
-0.0083051091,
0.0337473378,
-0.0316902213,
0.0360303521,
0.024294775,
0.0308333226,
0.0193018802,
-0.051013045,
-0.0966851637,
-0.0542196594,
-0.0113670537,
0.0511828735,
-0.0295145996,
0.0148018086,
0.0269050729,
-0.0036734352,
0.0007672125,
-0.0093514938,
-0.0000688109,
0.0774049982,
0.0510629825,
-0.002849957,
-0.0464558825,
-0.0517802499,
0.0001186161,
-0.0016258301,
-0.062940523,
-0.0560911112,
-0.0710941628,
-0.0124338707,
-0.0485988408,
-0.064590618,
0.0214007646,
0.0122254733,
-0.020633338,
0.0832775161,
-0.0933838561,
-0.0199693888,
0.0029952477,
0.0124313952,
0.012266174,
0.025550954,
0.0244144853,
0.0556491837,
0.0130276289,
0.0238031223,
0.0325098298,
0.0093298499,
-0.0593487956,
0.0081812255,
0.0044126362,
0.0184139274,
-0.0054476345,
-0.006227179,
-0.0280417241,
0.0021910239,
0.013928432,
0.0193832945,
0.0421334244,
0.0255898684,
-0.0198595431,
0.0332761928,
0.0072382549,
0.0859827921,
-0.0100559285,
-0.0641417727,
-0.0219806582,
0.0293242615,
-0.0122563327,
-0.0102332868,
-0.0561574958,
0.0067134118,
0.0018610508,
-0.0340819731,
0.000997275,
-0.0200342312,
0.0468284488,
0.0039883796,
0.0237433836,
0.0451692492,
-0.0282179266,
0.0205440037,
0.0260386597,
0.0076439367,
-0.0181013383,
0.00230752,
-0.0191135667,
0.0701787472,
0.0051649376,
-0.0851808786,
-0.0177958086,
-0.0254220646,
-0.0418618806,
0.0403303541,
0.0386991836,
-0.006822933,
-0.022874983,
0.0014845028,
-0.039496161,
0.01984464,
0.0251010265,
-0.0022677875,
-0.0138399228,
0.0097678555,
0.0106089218,
-0.0276840646,
-0.0488890707,
0.0252525862,
0.0519167297,
-0.0550355986,
-0.0067720776,
-0.0084850164,
-0.0113523714,
0.0112652583,
0.0185678042,
0.0398091748,
0.0475227237,
-0.0008755596,
-0.0945764482,
0.0168276355,
-0.0208340157,
0.0380221903,
0.0241542198,
-0.0327547714,
-0.0302919652,
-0.036395669,
-0.0477110036,
-0.0000475587,
0.0294182394,
0.0047045187,
0.0230822396,
-0.0348544605,
0.0195699167,
-0.011024666,
-0.0545006022,
-0.0527231507,
0.0823545828,
0.0279299747,
-0.0172013473,
-0.0103850206,
-0.0130374869,
0.0341579802,
-0.0313497372,
-0.0265416745,
-0.0212421995,
-0.0203254092,
0.0357033983,
0.0241517983,
0.0578316264,
0.0014478463,
0.0072390903,
-0.0848367512,
-0.0208310951,
-0.0217736773,
0.0424181409,
0.0051936833,
-0.0395654067,
-0.0291384999,
-0.024417527,
-0.037818335,
-0.0160255935,
-0.0316835493,
-0.0051652757,
0.0370502397,
-0.0314380303,
-0.0136449542,
-0.0217442214,
-0.0173500888,
-0.0427848548,
0.0366397165,
0.0906456262,
-0.0188173205,
-0.0858951733,
0.0709992424,
-0.0010269219,
-0.0189699735,
0.0231603235,
-0.0168113336,
-0.0018909352,
0.0402243175,
-0.0335955545,
-0.0406012051,
-0.0091081662,
0.0187997669,
0.043365974,
-0.0358036645,
-0.028972391,
-0.0191867892,
-0.0189950764,
0.0178303476,
-0.0170573052,
0.0203829464,
0.043197833,
0.032781627,
-0.0193822123,
-0.0249549709,
-0.0171619393,
0.0538736284,
-0.0228665918,
0.0124921491,
0.0194211025,
-0.0661723167,
0.0018630903,
0.0758540705,
0.02955232,
-0.0230752341,
0.0591103882,
0.0057786074,
0.0368220545,
-0.0533085093,
-0.0094785606,
-0.0675038397,
0.0745008662,
-0.0104526542,
0.0102176024,
0.066214025,
-0.0431513377,
-0.0213924441,
0.0111656878,
0.0772983879,
0.0111227976,
0.0313896351,
-0.0617969669,
0.0327639207,
0.0105510475,
-0.0311995987,
-0.0262896419,
0.0003480033,
-0.0619965456,
0.0447439477,
0.0640841201,
0.0146756368,
-0.018475486,
0.0261569601,
-0.0066071027,
-0.0104777496,
0.0218507797,
-0.0139544122,
-0.0156252291,
-0.0056187962,
0.0017190428,
-0.0288962554,
0.0379741155,
0.0014206531,
-0.0128674116,
0.0150363808,
-0.0189426281,
0.0036646919,
-0.047988534,
0.0152015267,
-0.0399056524,
-0.0467221849,
0.0256912,
0.0124061862,
-0.0354716517,
-0.0788186416,
0.0290107783,
0.0458055362,
0.025073804,
0.0052470905,
0.0171938073,
-0.0037623828,
-0.0122521026,
0.0174114127,
-0.006413891,
-0.071994409,
-0.016054593,
-0.0078839194,
-0.0254882686,
0.0223984588,
-0.0500852615,
-0.0005737871,
-0.0668549389,
0.0520905107,
-0.0238726549,
0.0059205266,
-0.0114973756,
0.0013672775,
0.0016647445,
-0.0485528149,
-0.0598722473,
-0.0021747046,
-0.0101156272,
-0.0181770436,
0.0099105658,
-0.042339839,
-0.0098103909,
0.0387721471,
-0.0439565144,
0.0261498448,
0.0379417539,
-0.0027515157,
0.0022658145,
0.0272164475,
0.0349677391,
0.0048872004,
0.0012484344,
0.0146441702,
0.0337598436,
0.0283027757,
-0.0186541323,
-0.0099670934,
-0.0317884237,
-0.0803619698,
-0.0301514473,
0.0382393077,
0.0835164115,
-0.0443082154,
0.0194843449,
-0.0114604663,
-0.0017487247,
0.0275358185,
0.012102806,
-0.0308451988,
-0.0329256132,
-0.0223230161,
-0.0393335894,
-0.043491561,
0.0040422291,
-0.039421007,
0.0270476174,
-0.0257408079,
-0.0067057516,
-0.0628035143,
-0.0311096068,
0.0353054143,
-0.0014522084,
0.0525413044,
0.0000483646,
0.0967180356,
-0.0126009891,
-0.0307410527,
0.0379632525,
-0.007106577,
0.0507507101,
0.0245004613,
0.0569238625,
0.0003545812,
-0.004634243,
-0.0133335516,
-0.0034420788,
-0.0798273385,
-0.036954239,
-0.0401484817,
0.0320476033,
0.0229893606,
-0.0417486243,
-0.0441368967,
-0.0312555097,
-0.0096088741,
-0.0063705212,
-0.0535576306,
-0.0549398549,
0.0396822393,
0.0044431635,
0.0117352027,
0.0053619132,
-0.0121921869,
-0.0011903512,
-0.0110233082,
0.0213874225,
-0.0758087933,
-0.0069543635,
0.0125001259,
0.019582808,
-0.0275780205,
0.0080163619,
0.0005130719,
-0.0360629335,
-0.0225230884,
-0.0265783817,
-0.0242315847,
-0.0137297846,
0.0501067862,
0.0206046272,
-0.0168704391,
-0.0054704593,
0.0435437895,
-0.0185240544,
0.0456115305,
0.0632026568,
0.0701577514,
0.0486535244,
-0.0155016193,
0.0536132753,
-0.0268829297,
0.0373444967,
0.0001974082,
-0.0083417566,
0.003611706,
0.0173861329,
-0.0209260397,
0.0207880959,
-0.0278022382,
-0.0168154016,
-0.0078457221,
0.0405747555,
-0.0864837617,
0.018371148,
0.0232604444,
-0.0040431647,
0.0083460025,
-0.0022665614,
-0.0674104318,
0.0309326481,
-0.0188890547,
0.0095541086,
0.0211930368,
-0.0464727655,
0.0295429751,
0.0291431341,
-0.0374341533,
-0.0072085545,
0.0602259003,
0.0371311195,
-0.0170647893,
-0.0680619478,
-0.0672565848,
-0.0200402252,
-0.0245720111,
0.0159034599,
0.033134114,
-0.0612360612,
0.0038022161,
-0.124610208,
-0.0278341472,
0.0245701335,
-0.026858557,
0.0159208626,
0.0015708848,
0.0141393449,
0.0360945575,
0.0254515782,
0.0096129542,
-0.0244491585,
-0.0292474069,
0.0169114582,
-0.0112590222,
-0.0502139367,
-5.612468308e-33,
-0.0092502218,
-0.1107378379,
0.0334887281,
-0.0085884072,
0.0274130646,
-0.0044891103,
0.0063789319,
0.0139444936,
0.0378869474,
0.0226116031,
-0.0098559139,
0.0385741889,
0.0050906334,
-0.0203059502,
0.0651275516,
-0.0020525977,
0.0209200103,
-0.0117054759,
0.0064180917,
-0.0340002999,
-0.017304223,
0.0074732457,
0.078157872,
-0.0970703661,
0.0507518649,
0.0318978913,
-0.0303880107,
-0.0077620237,
0.0267459545,
0.0261576045,
-0.015404826,
0.0231790971,
0.0297511108,
-0.0765817016,
0.0119275264,
0.0262239296,
-0.0466177091,
-0.0217786096,
-0.003454868,
-0.0006663348,
0.0261179134,
-0.0229167491,
0.0459503345,
0.0121224662,
-0.0260604508,
0.0049369698,
0.046260763,
-0.0515177362,
0.007684805,
-0.027455464,
-0.1191488653,
0.0544820093,
-0.0043012281,
0.0241964441,
0.0274415314,
-0.0091789104,
0.0031512966,
0.0203262735,
-0.0608591847,
-0.0170163848,
0.0124757104,
-0.0136322193,
0.0444094874,
-0.0596845932,
-0.0201750584,
0.0502971001,
-0.0556627996,
0.0006291074,
-0.0237950236,
-0.034605436,
0.0084503805,
0.0905692056,
-0.0052079177,
0.0634806976,
0.0198602043,
0.0041872701,
-0.0819070265,
0.0276297722,
-0.0215189978,
0.095823288,
0.0429004431,
0.0137174064,
-0.0146286665,
-0.014137038,
-0.0359008275,
-0.0139423879,
-0.0055720531,
0.0389846154,
-0.0008307972,
0.013080826,
0.0197040476,
0.0413052216,
-0.0253832322,
-0.0200500395,
-0.0234664194,
0.0259683467,
-0.0074572526,
-0.0238875989,
0.0029780392,
0.0459612571,
-0.0217242334,
0.023650229,
0.0031541418,
0.0134209003,
0.031688299,
0.0095853573,
0.0171685033,
0.0066195922,
-0.043451529,
0.0121159228,
-0.0003257276,
0.0065556215,
-0.0043609929,
0.0660601482,
0.0161649827,
-0.0225620531,
0.0003466363,
0.0172259975,
0.0408662669,
0.0050245547,
-0.0063663539,
0.0292402729,
-0.0431380682,
0.0141093247,
0.0047433358,
-0.0201906972,
0.017896615,
-0.03073656,
0.0616999343,
-0.0296977386,
0.0038448044,
0.0354751535,
2.697e-7,
0.0417511612,
0.0675642714,
-0.0082902331,
0.0463144742,
0.0169114023,
0.096574381,
0.0141366227,
0.0216756165,
-0.0101568345,
-0.0161935519,
0.0605227537,
-0.0130881667,
0.0235726759,
0.0507504195,
-0.0805459619,
-0.0091689797,
-0.0045591355,
-0.0532520041,
-0.0928154886,
-0.029313527,
0.0778764561,
0.0489057787,
0.0163205024,
-0.0179905389,
0.0002726479,
-0.0642685741,
0.0017683125,
-0.0167157967,
0.0032220641,
0.0080858655,
0.0837136284,
-0.0219694227,
-0.0193093065,
0.0476967096,
-0.0382062383,
-0.0098519996,
0.0375596657,
0.0160939768,
-0.0146461809,
0.0410554223,
0.0077481149,
-0.1012020186,
0.0068889861,
-0.002898813,
0.0072041736,
-0.0411123224,
-0.0219887681,
-0.0051517659,
0.0080709979,
-0.0211326871,
0.013390814,
0.0374916606,
0.0012706527,
-0.0101280594,
-0.004581396,
-0.0151389996,
0.0182837937,
-0.0576130114,
0.0401560441,
0.0560764149,
-0.0385389812,
-0.0163763929,
-0.0026979588,
-0.0042037466,
0.0276457369,
-0.0558188632,
0.0383631401,
2.049478074e-34,
0.0007831837,
-0.01847969,
-0.0444106683,
0.0418553799,
0.0710614845,
0.0503535643,
-0.0470781401,
0.0130892703,
-0.0059440224,
-0.0713916346,
0.0120400656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12625v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12625v2 | DRG-LLaMA : Tuning LLaMA Model to Predict Diagnosis-related Group for Hospitalized Patients | 2023-09-22T05:18:54 | 2023-09-29T02:32:51 | Hanyin Wang, Chufan Gao, Christopher Dantona, Bryan Hull, Jimeng Sun | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | In the U.S. inpatient payment system, the Diagnosis-Related Group (DRG) is
pivotal, but its assignment process is inefficient. The study introduces
DRG-LLaMA, an advanced large language model (LLM) fine-tuned on clinical notes
to enhance DRGs assignment. Utilizing LLaMA as the foundational model and
optimizing it through Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) on 236,192 MIMIC-IV discharge
summaries, our DRG-LLaMA-7B model exhibited a noteworthy macro-averaged F1
score of 0.327, a top-1 prediction accuracy of 52.0%, and a macro-averaged Area
Under the Curve (AUC) of 0.986, with a maximum input token length of 512. This
model surpassed the performance of prior leading models in DRG prediction,
showing a relative improvement of 40.3% and 35.7% in macro-averaged F1 score
compared to ClinicalBERT and CAML, respectively. Applied to base DRG and
complication or comorbidity (CC)/major complication or comorbidity (MCC)
prediction, DRG-LLaMA achieved a top-1 prediction accuracy of 67.8% and 67.5%,
respectively. Additionally, our findings indicate that DRG-LLaMA's performance
correlates with increased model parameters and input context lengths. | [
0.0662321597,
0.052956365,
-0.0114206653,
-0.0228087921,
0.0157739669,
0.0531402677,
0.0059393314,
0.0227275491,
-0.001574081,
-0.0176898893,
-0.0396195091,
-0.064669244,
0.0019902363,
0.0500960983,
0.0260924213,
-0.0403567478,
0.0587109737,
-0.0175817441,
0.0487366207,
-0.0089651048,
-0.0287103988,
-0.0034468095,
-0.0225036051,
0.0432720333,
0.0180298127,
-0.0040930137,
0.0541963577,
-0.0164212305,
0.0104196463,
-0.0869937688,
0.004697802,
0.0327464119,
-0.0330940038,
-0.0210918449,
0.0000021535,
-0.0946319625,
-0.0328332335,
0.005169848,
-0.0567221232,
-0.0217108186,
0.0028709231,
-0.0460927486,
0.0181859955,
0.0291372873,
-0.0133412657,
-0.0368728153,
0.021828508,
0.0599432662,
0.029791072,
0.0562680364,
-0.0239823814,
-0.0238319002,
-0.0124792978,
-0.0697736666,
0.016972186,
-0.069853805,
0.0518383086,
0.0235133711,
0.0119927283,
-0.0868046731,
-0.0161219016,
0.0198173728,
-0.010008594,
0.0222753417,
0.0351221673,
0.0505348295,
-0.0190308224,
0.0458471067,
0.0063951574,
0.0708357543,
-0.0164807104,
0.017594181,
0.0217600167,
-0.009757055,
0.0218242295,
-0.0074768309,
-0.0503674373,
-0.0165541526,
-0.0114264283,
0.0136637697,
0.0586994775,
0.0252862666,
0.0126330731,
-0.0150524862,
-0.043358963,
0.006326641,
0.0012505963,
-0.0053107385,
-0.0000471315,
0.0000753528,
-0.0590769053,
-0.0286997054,
0.0345558822,
0.0485109314,
-0.0878311172,
0.0132168299,
-0.0043312591,
-0.0087893745,
0.0776875019,
-0.0768949836,
0.0404235944,
0.033601962,
0.0042844424,
0.0212887526,
-0.0313889794,
0.0491842218,
-0.0286654476,
0.0118219284,
-0.074765183,
-0.0059643569,
-0.024203008,
0.0083068227,
-0.0138539784,
0.0383194797,
0.0103673367,
-0.0126541983,
-0.0904540718,
-0.0055310209,
-0.016104864,
0.0011192292,
0.0920024738,
0.03194445,
-0.0260784868,
0.0127875181,
-0.0143579207,
-0.0104340613,
0.0079434915,
0.0230539348,
-0.0192093477,
0.0098593682,
0.0398398228,
0.0015369256,
0.0049345656,
0.0036157374,
0.0339565128,
0.0847283229,
0.0146410763,
-0.0149403764,
0.0085768048,
-0.0211484712,
-0.0470332168,
-0.0134226019,
-0.0104265632,
-0.0443654656,
0.0344810858,
0.0375004597,
0.0225325096,
-0.0380785838,
0.0065335692,
-0.0209812559,
-0.0561913848,
0.0040939432,
-0.0306893867,
0.0042941161,
0.0080564823,
0.0034862659,
-0.0054007554,
-0.021614654,
0.0227248352,
-0.0094180843,
-0.0181646254,
-0.0329587571,
0.0227698497,
0.0382876396,
0.0014340272,
-0.0435399301,
0.0133678736,
0.0168963149,
-0.0117709022,
0.0458017774,
0.023567684,
0.0545855649,
0.0273299199,
-0.0445853844,
0.0374243222,
0.0252492558,
0.054162059,
0.0198521614,
-0.0179388225,
-0.0439798981,
-0.0163547471,
-0.0637260973,
-0.0026407484,
0.0263608638,
0.0054461602,
0.0094133206,
0.0270613264,
0.0029972752,
-0.0248373151,
-0.055651214,
-0.0510353483,
0.0041321106,
-0.0438758992,
-0.0095793661,
0.009500796,
-0.0210728645,
-0.0345858522,
0.0500402562,
0.0690389648,
0.0424653254,
-0.0610289797,
-0.0939780101,
0.0155231794,
0.0960354581,
0.0425226428,
-0.0257347189,
-0.0467055365,
-0.0185897052,
-0.0169447772,
-0.0237048361,
0.0054411166,
-0.0121051408,
-0.0212974064,
-0.0192289073,
0.0126907295,
0.0827972963,
0.0159313567,
0.0224534813,
-0.0343485363,
-0.0149280783,
-0.0346342698,
-0.0239244923,
-0.056630794,
0.0609206408,
-0.0091794794,
-0.0303841121,
0.0233315453,
-0.0341182016,
0.066951625,
-0.0070348619,
0.0103833796,
0.023751026,
0.0259624906,
-0.0493467413,
-0.0198020004,
-0.0119109144,
-0.0658543482,
-0.0276905596,
0.0039589754,
0.0439375155,
0.0294236299,
-0.0095971655,
-0.0254012737,
-0.0119068827,
-0.0092257531,
-0.039521005,
0.0134994574,
-0.0108306156,
0.0225120094,
0.047871083,
0.0202758536,
-0.0399027728,
0.0226245653,
-0.0333089232,
0.0072368854,
-0.020764092,
-0.0004905457,
0.002543008,
0.0043476825,
-0.006803365,
0.0210243706,
-0.0419090651,
0.0088437498,
-0.0486367233,
0.0034455513,
-0.0025206893,
-0.0188918654,
-0.0922170207,
-0.0104741678,
0.0246118437,
0.0035147627,
0.0351191759,
-0.008942401,
-0.0275253672,
-0.0158038661,
-0.0113352463,
-0.0066196253,
0.0446097702,
0.0041130795,
0.0254006796,
0.0660366416,
-0.0195692722,
-0.0248213634,
0.0161138438,
-0.0442624278,
0.03789673,
-0.0149284685,
-0.0515569896,
-0.0273369327,
0.0074780616,
-0.031111775,
-0.0472993702,
-0.002380426,
-0.0457195751,
-0.0420568697,
-0.0265265927,
0.0089004757,
0.0129836304,
-0.0226285364,
0.0005595534,
0.0271181539,
0.0069726864,
-0.0101053743,
-0.002864701,
-0.0222762842,
-0.0481990762,
0.0191728119,
-0.0488023497,
-0.0178644191,
0.1001609191,
0.0263940208,
0.0005720261,
-0.0130890291,
-0.0143484138,
-0.0411515236,
0.0479252636,
-0.0212524049,
0.0229555145,
-0.0486521088,
0.0183656253,
-0.0046825558,
-0.0527633429,
0.0621101186,
-0.0090236226,
0.0329185911,
-0.0777183548,
-0.0394016169,
-0.0625110418,
-0.0178042073,
-0.0070284372,
0.0152935171,
-0.002134145,
-0.0256950203,
0.0189243164,
0.0078874063,
-0.0252436325,
-0.0515685081,
0.0949632674,
0.0127272848,
0.0360227935,
0.0334282778,
-0.0152089754,
-0.024508398,
0.0075618653,
-0.0294355266,
0.0119110718,
-0.0100669051,
0.0143386321,
-0.0480760857,
0.0393391699,
-0.0474784933,
0.059668079,
-0.0171907581,
-0.0211502463,
0.013922357,
-0.0097360192,
-0.0038185325,
0.0159259308,
-0.0009427612,
-0.0484559461,
0.017624082,
0.0353246406,
-0.0056772297,
0.0260601174,
0.0330111943,
0.0258515049,
-0.0161364451,
-0.0284335557,
-0.0231273063,
0.0477425605,
-0.0114493491,
-0.038349051,
0.0067996527,
0.1077513546,
0.0146577759,
-0.0793326944,
0.0255431049,
-0.0532654226,
0.0092544407,
0.0135344407,
0.0272900257,
0.0081849722,
-0.0296961181,
0.004432891,
0.0508035719,
0.0017196111,
-0.04933073,
0.0231875516,
-0.0122040669,
0.0222625844,
-0.0007450487,
-0.043404296,
-0.0150378104,
-0.0384835377,
0.0300985966,
-0.019994542,
-0.0407072194,
0.0006121943,
-0.0167713501,
-0.0102227507,
0.0244922154,
-0.1284091622,
-0.0310837999,
0.0388973951,
-0.01214003,
0.0382073447,
0.0611250959,
0.0193607435,
-0.0345387496,
0.0187490042,
0.0044652722,
-0.0127913477,
0.0193940271,
-0.0343517289,
0.0611194372,
0.019525595,
0.0129150795,
-0.0468375087,
0.0138981976,
-0.0413294546,
-0.0213668607,
-0.00476341,
0.0834358037,
-0.0262828935,
-0.026769001,
-0.0269241333,
0.0174048245,
0.006755725,
0.0350119509,
0.0000711945,
-0.0172365308,
0.0095668873,
0.0228657927,
0.0321781114,
0.0061855842,
0.0301048961,
0.0091702631,
-0.0609996133,
-0.0265193284,
-0.0816720352,
0.0004965522,
0.0468694195,
-0.0028059664,
0.01065885,
0.0472757928,
-0.0036601319,
-0.0197685044,
-0.0542528518,
0.0240010917,
-0.0019002366,
0.0089074476,
-0.0797269493,
-0.0429538786,
0.054984197,
0.0116657829,
-0.0589252003,
-0.0119007947,
-0.0043598255,
0.0079710037,
0.0506768487,
0.0278296508,
0.0240444709,
-0.0330294892,
0.0394600071,
-0.0270625781,
0.0509723686,
-0.0023896568,
0.018445991,
0.0123335151,
-0.0419186875,
0.0037545066,
-0.0339774676,
0.0063124467,
-0.0287731215,
0.0762067512,
0.021899892,
0.0268506166,
0.0077547762,
-0.0237400103,
-0.0212316215,
0.0323354751,
0.0012649355,
0.0006218579,
-0.079994902,
-0.053399846,
0.0307808444,
-0.0044058664,
0.0511995703,
-0.0086548394,
-0.0222314578,
0.0560186952,
0.0081334366,
-0.0172852576,
-0.0111061605,
-0.0487481728,
-0.0503912754,
-0.0427136049,
0.0369862244,
-0.0044495566,
-0.0089085288,
0.0322075933,
0.0093371943,
0.0171284396,
-0.0292172059,
0.0370524786,
0.0279658996,
-0.0131650846,
0.0622209199,
-0.0239296593,
0.048722446,
-0.0413339622,
0.047629822,
-0.0171815697,
-0.0486888513,
-0.0352903828,
-0.0056886417,
0.0269691013,
0.0034374006,
0.0067284633,
-0.0353697389,
0.0197642334,
-0.0373409539,
0.0308639463,
-0.0328650624,
0.0416939631,
0.047102455,
0.0166027173,
-0.0125118373,
-0.0081861066,
0.0819617957,
0.038260106,
0.0453367643,
-0.042403955,
-0.0248711985,
-0.0411653817,
0.0122633735,
0.0284437332,
0.0106423218,
-0.044691734,
-0.0274647288,
-0.0683846921,
-0.0114284633,
0.0585671999,
-0.0273274276,
-0.0343375094,
-0.0394556373,
0.0373466946,
0.0279098786,
0.0067022052,
-0.0079841735,
-0.022282837,
-0.0074569979,
-0.0060744206,
-0.0082133645,
0.0238058474,
-5.731345684e-33,
-0.0260961019,
-0.0283451155,
-0.0002042232,
0.0081731072,
-0.0159831233,
0.0400554761,
-0.0153598953,
-0.0076425401,
0.0227817278,
0.0134790167,
-0.018765945,
-0.0094843609,
0.006992877,
0.0193989892,
0.0233520642,
-0.0262517631,
0.0070271865,
0.0066466206,
-0.0069599859,
0.0430412106,
-0.0073109134,
0.0646545514,
0.0212165564,
-0.086674355,
-0.0102624772,
-0.0080519738,
0.0147366505,
-0.0012379021,
-0.0099707507,
0.0783436224,
-0.0315127559,
0.0434533097,
0.0594213456,
0.0030474255,
0.0023630068,
0.0117726587,
-0.0361705422,
-0.0267495271,
0.0104389451,
-0.0525535606,
0.0533050969,
-0.0428878702,
0.0452496186,
0.0123713035,
-0.0421131924,
-0.0071054474,
0.0079190861,
-0.0566837937,
0.0039316528,
-0.0392363816,
-0.0264339503,
0.0459726825,
0.0107578272,
0.0140814129,
-0.0150771309,
-0.0149241425,
-0.0379917473,
0.0644871742,
-0.0290130228,
-0.0003684455,
0.0054991241,
0.0573712252,
0.0162709225,
0.0025264337,
-0.0510713123,
0.057574261,
0.030824773,
-0.0002374933,
-0.0308055226,
-0.0223547872,
-0.0581941307,
0.0294913054,
0.0808191001,
0.0144718504,
0.0467853919,
-0.0459742583,
-0.087864764,
0.0657608509,
-0.0310949441,
0.0368060395,
0.0740614384,
-0.0074080359,
-0.0512434244,
-0.0338052362,
-0.0232501924,
0.0399411879,
-0.0336825587,
-0.0209770091,
0.0520431846,
-0.0124852965,
0.0180295296,
0.0061831032,
0.0371355526,
-0.0250358842,
0.0122944461,
0.0082846005,
0.0593800955,
0.0557957217,
-0.0296840034,
-0.0079445262,
-0.0703536272,
-0.0108810915,
0.0263664797,
-0.0316467918,
0.0649521723,
-0.0120923528,
0.0441864729,
-0.0433284491,
-0.0508267432,
0.0094286771,
0.0629347116,
-0.0186314601,
-0.011711101,
0.0471063405,
0.0185194556,
-0.0037850721,
0.0057575163,
0.0453704484,
0.025115421,
-0.0110723041,
-0.0257194508,
-0.0303478818,
-0.0020147897,
0.001679451,
-0.0576538891,
0.0270571485,
-0.028447099,
0.0428097099,
0.0350693502,
-0.0453612991,
-0.014343936,
0.0169971008,
2.896e-7,
0.0999791846,
0.0789033249,
-0.0438553318,
-0.0516610704,
0.0356825255,
0.0010110914,
-0.0157305319,
0.0064467122,
0.0532884337,
0.0192369279,
0.0580271818,
-0.0128161591,
0.0290025864,
0.0345874056,
-0.0327372663,
-0.0529881008,
-0.0587858036,
-0.0040954393,
-0.0483725779,
-0.0193482637,
0.0463245101,
0.0965504348,
-0.0362398401,
-0.0405097678,
0.0007781838,
-0.0240537785,
0.0017347244,
-0.0556407124,
-0.0239541642,
0.0567831174,
0.0355554819,
0.0351015143,
-0.0138168102,
0.0377062634,
-0.0038069191,
0.0274794288,
0.0083648469,
0.0634346455,
-0.0521377027,
0.0238471888,
0.0327349007,
0.0022035073,
0.0472838841,
-0.0589661747,
0.0560864285,
-0.0463926606,
-0.0283706337,
-0.0211615041,
-0.0324022919,
0.0173311345,
0.0441201217,
-0.0073044756,
-0.0090528056,
0.0218989421,
0.0204262324,
0.0062035522,
-0.0558049269,
-0.0532517694,
-0.0397018269,
0.0586683415,
-0.0444139764,
-0.0288301948,
0.0238108542,
-0.0230444819,
0.0234753322,
-0.0854631141,
0.0266731437,
2.833997953e-34,
0.0546880774,
-0.0004637959,
-0.0097898981,
0.0460880324,
0.0371589772,
-0.0248421747,
0.0143938875,
0.0554617681,
0.0018766294,
-0.1060802042,
-0.0001339585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12619v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12619v1 | Learning to Diversify Neural Text Generation via Degenerative Model | 2023-09-22T04:57:10 | 2023-09-22T04:57:10 | Jimin Hong, ChaeHun Park, Jaegul Choo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural language models often fail to generate diverse and informative texts,
limiting their applicability in real-world problems. While previous approaches
have proposed to address these issues by identifying and penalizing undesirable
behaviors (e.g., repetition, overuse of frequent words) from language models,
we propose an alternative approach based on an observation: models primarily
learn attributes within examples that are likely to cause degeneration
problems. Based on this observation, we propose a new approach to prevent
degeneration problems by training two models. Specifically, we first train a
model that is designed to amplify undesirable patterns. We then enhance the
diversity of the second model by focusing on patterns that the first model
fails to learn. Extensive experiments on two tasks, namely language modeling
and dialogue generation, demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach. | [
0.0269325189,
0.0822894052,
-0.0108492039,
0.0239335243,
-0.0020174144,
-0.0064280266,
0.0033157929,
0.0050497018,
-0.0111610796,
-0.0263722241,
0.004637457,
-0.0720351562,
0.0252464414,
0.0623256713,
0.0347117893,
-0.0623468831,
0.0164455026,
0.0046156067,
0.0021627955,
-0.0212961882,
0.0323794745,
0.0233580302,
0.033167161,
0.0419350974,
-0.0307880975,
0.0044266563,
-0.0036152676,
-0.0019294621,
0.0207872633,
0.011864447,
0.0342298038,
0.04976511,
0.0030746723,
0.033681374,
0.0000018232,
-0.008743572,
-0.0006429725,
-0.0227701999,
0.0182126537,
-0.0274858009,
0.0444915853,
0.0365291163,
0.0242553465,
0.0262207966,
-0.0307911951,
-0.0068118717,
0.0355416536,
0.0674183443,
0.0391003527,
0.0538587011,
0.0006929244,
0.0054364474,
0.0261304937,
-0.0341840051,
0.033213079,
-0.0085709356,
-0.0067957463,
0.0028508785,
-0.0108096097,
0.0123759331,
0.0073959189,
0.024397701,
0.0378005654,
0.0149514936,
0.0471265875,
0.0672865361,
0.0333637558,
-0.0131798787,
0.0093082171,
0.0896715373,
-0.0674268007,
-0.0216163918,
0.0146006448,
-0.0177778881,
0.035017252,
-0.0250580963,
-0.0307717752,
0.0281956308,
-0.0205224473,
0.0297091845,
0.0129792383,
0.0281258468,
0.0300204195,
0.0298563503,
0.007337708,
-0.0255616382,
0.0188440867,
-0.0150985084,
-0.0277154241,
0.0021548211,
-0.0131815271,
-0.0481642634,
0.0185806267,
0.0194067378,
-0.0420683511,
0.0299450736,
-0.0716862604,
-0.0409355462,
0.0332404822,
-0.0162090492,
0.0544348769,
0.005083296,
-0.0241028946,
-0.0048007816,
-0.0261235945,
0.0114822509,
0.010690893,
-0.0146253565,
-0.0380503051,
0.0112410346,
-0.035672117,
-0.0330154523,
-0.0409935899,
0.0425019898,
-0.0102197574,
-0.0346544683,
-0.0202141404,
0.0041438807,
-0.0105257193,
-0.0105435792,
-0.0086284848,
0.0671002641,
-0.0685704201,
-0.0148728658,
-0.0138787255,
-0.0034390618,
-0.0562049672,
0.014958838,
0.0545940176,
-0.0548555255,
-0.0132245244,
0.0287470967,
-0.0151773887,
-0.014463163,
-0.0244299211,
0.0435563065,
-0.0444156341,
0.0110052712,
-0.0487036519,
-0.0420341678,
-0.0384711176,
-0.0642785877,
-0.0032951722,
-0.0750211328,
0.0212692674,
-0.0126675591,
-0.023201149,
-0.0711716861,
0.0210081134,
0.0104310447,
-0.0401427895,
0.0335987583,
-0.0300659239,
-0.006172576,
0.0893426314,
0.0266334433,
0.0320403129,
0.0650117695,
0.0419718176,
0.0264921095,
-0.0178328771,
0.0506748818,
0.0401390642,
0.0168512985,
0.0197936464,
0.012517727,
-0.0218584072,
-0.037936274,
-0.0180453211,
0.0524348766,
0.0387735926,
0.0837451592,
-0.0616780967,
-0.0122897569,
0.076832138,
-0.0096712084,
0.0008802349,
0.0330146104,
0.0812689438,
0.0145640476,
-0.0380339175,
0.0487147048,
-0.0064199106,
0.030759057,
0.0207109321,
0.031351652,
0.0372897796,
0.0328922756,
-0.0386371799,
-0.0734507218,
0.0270953141,
-0.0281329378,
0.0323119611,
-0.0397313535,
0.0113233216,
0.0534169301,
-0.0461671948,
0.0545555167,
0.0172953401,
-0.0566482134,
0.0136198243,
-0.0112995403,
0.0315648094,
0.0615027882,
0.0493974872,
-0.0029231077,
-0.0542777255,
-0.0301711224,
-0.0286375023,
0.0748204961,
0.0402106233,
0.0046276147,
0.0364708304,
-0.0989819616,
-0.0337741263,
-0.0296326373,
0.0159774255,
0.0516733155,
0.0150252413,
-0.0078837946,
0.0526856668,
-0.0069718505,
-0.0646097213,
0.041150637,
-0.055463776,
-0.0204220898,
0.0323094539,
0.0034302759,
-0.0100652948,
-0.0249593295,
-0.011732392,
0.024862498,
-0.0067574596,
-0.0474226288,
-0.0629074052,
0.0079831183,
-0.1214851663,
-0.0289491713,
0.0091424296,
-0.0683168694,
0.0236145556,
-0.0003537893,
-0.0069183074,
-0.0609829091,
0.0330542959,
-0.0708085522,
-0.0351091027,
-0.0486832708,
0.0070792194,
0.0055850884,
0.02670452,
-0.0564715192,
0.0980930999,
-0.0117972754,
-0.010966016,
0.0080437269,
0.020555526,
0.0032408834,
-0.0706299916,
-0.0245463476,
-0.0218814649,
0.013604925,
0.0360458195,
0.0406915061,
0.0270638876,
-0.0276135951,
-0.0602120459,
-0.0348946787,
0.0092591811,
-0.0133783044,
-0.0307909921,
0.0183263924,
0.0004102691,
0.0068769143,
-0.0036632833,
-0.0796910897,
-0.0043208725,
0.0240553338,
0.0041913837,
0.0544628091,
0.0294215325,
-0.0133432308,
-0.0098023815,
0.0009717144,
0.0211933181,
0.0506184883,
-0.0044722771,
0.0099026291,
-0.0530663729,
0.0406052731,
-0.0386172906,
0.0171323717,
0.0113770701,
-0.014315444,
0.0096704289,
0.0172734577,
0.0692738369,
0.0265136901,
0.0342832506,
0.028975565,
0.0357854851,
0.0188681204,
-0.043978963,
0.0063534435,
-0.0373015404,
0.0772353336,
0.0048128194,
-0.0472163372,
0.0061113229,
0.0307954568,
0.023764614,
0.0062421924,
-0.053512644,
0.0413096286,
0.0104333702,
-0.0610547811,
0.0031680749,
-0.0557399131,
-0.0186017416,
-0.007117983,
-0.0372694731,
-0.0391768701,
0.0629218817,
-0.017084891,
0.0238323323,
-0.0467568971,
0.0071720933,
-0.0225021783,
0.014524037,
-0.0159680936,
0.047498744,
0.0662782118,
-0.0126638357,
-0.0727686137,
0.0000209631,
0.0139288548,
-0.0209282637,
0.0997943282,
-0.0278968867,
-0.019337127,
0.0116214249,
-0.0380392447,
-0.083792001,
-0.0200754181,
0.0291392468,
0.0173731893,
0.0101892604,
0.0058813482,
-0.0356180258,
-0.0202263054,
-0.0059771105,
0.0464333147,
-0.0523618571,
-0.0094385939,
-0.002685583,
0.0643915907,
0.040187031,
-0.0013778006,
0.0053383019,
-0.0628262013,
0.0099190231,
0.0067954962,
-0.0258056894,
0.0022705607,
-0.0402044468,
-0.0010229757,
-0.0142532568,
-0.0054949112,
-0.0283984151,
0.0112652536,
0.0419890471,
-0.0494154878,
-0.0512907431,
0.0665862039,
-0.0013374577,
-0.0386096947,
0.023978753,
-0.0062478539,
0.1121762842,
0.0127356052,
0.0263408665,
-0.033958327,
-0.0154580455,
-0.0230357312,
0.0068151541,
-0.0111743677,
-0.0063317758,
-0.0234606918,
-0.0959395096,
-0.0177777614,
0.0319447592,
-0.0312516131,
-0.0053505637,
0.0622231364,
-0.0441919975,
-0.0178290568,
0.0455091372,
-0.0070204991,
0.0136961835,
0.011286757,
0.0350719057,
-0.0090809902,
-0.0611440837,
-0.0411995798,
-0.0252161697,
0.0656274855,
0.0610965155,
0.0255785827,
-0.0128284143,
0.0095498161,
0.0037150837,
0.0004580741,
0.0171923619,
0.0112818414,
0.0690304413,
0.029544238,
-0.01454629,
-0.0007381698,
0.0336370766,
0.0048813429,
0.0014785003,
-0.0036611962,
0.016180696,
-0.0134863416,
-0.0180855412,
-0.0246733371,
0.0194713529,
0.0388947353,
0.0663078725,
0.0554337911,
-0.0370358787,
-0.043059133,
-0.0462175831,
0.0000763477,
-0.1100081876,
0.0105603244,
0.0198587663,
0.0043845563,
-0.0244401246,
-0.1107231826,
-0.0473742634,
-0.0244508218,
0.0356779508,
-0.0000299822,
0.0065183425,
-0.0145893153,
-0.0342329293,
0.0071916054,
0.0041083605,
-0.0055126292,
-0.0081325527,
-0.0062927585,
-0.0281749349,
-0.043510031,
-0.0741841644,
-0.0109602073,
0.0287024155,
-0.1006709188,
-0.0827772766,
0.0072082756,
0.0552935787,
0.0207443498,
0.0800668448,
-0.0012221115,
-0.0805462822,
0.0486890413,
0.0471243858,
0.0188442804,
-0.0072922194,
0.0163915176,
-0.0082430625,
-0.0121439332,
0.047058098,
-0.0106937066,
0.023063587,
0.032403335,
0.0236130841,
-0.0270405561,
-0.0052554826,
0.0230276845,
-0.0218614619,
-0.0559655577,
-0.0604154468,
0.0085362652,
-0.0538605042,
-0.0166541319,
-0.004287329,
-0.0180448629,
-0.0669864863,
0.0368668213,
0.0090759015,
-0.0075964937,
0.0224208217,
-0.0190281812,
0.0000954382,
0.0595659129,
-0.0554733239,
-0.0409815982,
-0.0201655421,
-0.0019160381,
0.001139396,
0.0041186749,
-0.0364622697,
0.0567104295,
-0.0407672599,
0.0112196077,
-0.0175387263,
0.0379371718,
0.0225757714,
-0.0124658495,
-0.0113486676,
0.0069309999,
-0.0305895414,
-0.0012625874,
-0.0486099049,
0.0174235273,
0.0425191671,
0.0014663487,
0.0548138507,
-0.0282358937,
0.0211020373,
-0.014346689,
0.0266822353,
0.0130492141,
-0.0404345021,
-0.0059277476,
0.0179159697,
-0.0235451367,
-0.0320110582,
0.1289266944,
0.0315699503,
0.0073903664,
-0.0054552988,
0.0242181178,
-0.0592586808,
-0.0168117024,
0.0523474775,
0.0109708486,
-0.0204031002,
0.0220281575,
-0.0178832021,
-0.0372577347,
0.0127188945,
0.0173662156,
0.0597394779,
0.0064223986,
0.0670854151,
0.0186577141,
-0.03986343,
0.0237938892,
-0.0447904058,
0.0132385576,
0.0005583349,
-0.0044396818,
-0.028548751,
-6.138272441e-33,
-0.0141900983,
-0.0281073395,
0.0123777222,
-0.0460576862,
-0.0342818163,
-0.003250689,
-0.0308357459,
-0.010605474,
-0.0034817026,
0.0274846982,
0.0265930388,
0.0036378666,
-0.0014290272,
0.0481265225,
0.0069565312,
0.0068894462,
0.0673791692,
0.0156985559,
-0.0398551263,
0.0705725402,
0.0471148305,
0.0323605873,
0.0176408011,
-0.0349144638,
-0.0124030961,
-0.0330531858,
-0.0326400734,
0.0083033349,
0.0048654131,
0.0537234731,
-0.034470737,
0.040027611,
0.0242931247,
-0.0415118299,
-0.0611152649,
0.0199437886,
-0.0188850611,
-0.0472823977,
0.0008310441,
-0.0346701555,
-0.0338686705,
-0.0458654091,
0.0456297211,
-0.0122874416,
0.0109717688,
-0.0047682794,
0.0446639657,
-0.0175448954,
-0.0548143573,
0.0030545073,
-0.0724503025,
0.0313576497,
0.0223824158,
-0.0349114351,
-0.0442136377,
0.0256816242,
-0.0146090193,
-0.0216043759,
-0.0111208288,
0.0200992152,
0.0248237811,
0.0276621263,
0.01419897,
0.0238690004,
-0.0399839543,
0.070070371,
0.0012480683,
0.0318424217,
-0.0190420374,
-0.0277022347,
0.001848658,
0.0294055566,
0.038391985,
0.0467931405,
0.0407628343,
-0.0241606273,
-0.0461170822,
0.0352114327,
0.0048122793,
0.0087167015,
0.0630261675,
-0.0234807804,
-0.0116589516,
-0.0346855037,
-0.0348613225,
0.0168572087,
-0.022758333,
-0.0235413332,
0.0073951329,
0.0579932407,
-0.0161950234,
-0.0080253221,
0.0145854028,
-0.0210256092,
-0.0048124758,
0.0461467393,
-0.0439187102,
-0.029224094,
0.0171535723,
0.0097292196,
-0.0285957623,
-0.0511078909,
0.0471980572,
0.0509274974,
-0.0116669545,
0.0257835239,
0.0859329551,
-0.0046715289,
-0.0389203057,
0.0235907957,
-0.0370829254,
0.0463006869,
0.0193564855,
0.0386299007,
0.0065190531,
-0.0151081514,
-0.0355578065,
0.038267266,
0.0273471456,
-0.0173153225,
-0.0338534564,
-0.029305242,
0.0231361836,
0.043525368,
-0.038823802,
-0.0070704948,
-0.0294809639,
-0.0395855643,
0.0381969102,
-0.0350293815,
-0.0196868852,
-0.0011843122,
2.434e-7,
-0.0100794351,
0.0232964139,
0.0345444903,
0.004009306,
0.0189489312,
0.0443800092,
-0.016488377,
0.0498267412,
-0.038537208,
-0.0002652786,
-0.0009275807,
0.0185135566,
0.0637435764,
0.0268720593,
-0.0422880687,
-0.0057572844,
-0.0874766633,
0.0305167791,
-0.0517455749,
-0.0319421291,
0.0289496593,
0.0704404786,
-0.0157939475,
-0.0163624343,
0.0283069909,
-0.0075089992,
0.0917523652,
0.0121448869,
-0.0114568882,
0.0317825191,
0.0383364819,
-0.000516641,
0.01127824,
0.0120851044,
-0.0326838195,
0.0115661649,
0.0076796119,
0.0415184423,
-0.0087213013,
-0.037465781,
0.0407533683,
0.0113910455,
-0.0014720574,
-0.0655455589,
0.0155507969,
-0.0252604634,
-0.0224223323,
-0.0409352481,
0.0166444071,
0.0346146785,
0.0556425601,
-0.0455900915,
-0.0518224202,
0.0041532004,
0.0148937423,
-0.0027744265,
0.0061441865,
-0.0660007,
-0.0394563451,
-0.0098404568,
-0.0687560141,
-0.0080657331,
-0.0534686968,
0.0045277337,
0.028733395,
-0.0294432268,
-0.000059632,
2.347909917e-34,
0.0374257825,
-0.0289476123,
-0.0105134277,
0.0194239803,
-0.0026093249,
-0.0153425178,
-0.0039120703,
0.0262961015,
0.0102068847,
-0.0299153738,
-0.0482796021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12616v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12616v1 | Unlocking Model Insights: A Dataset for Automated Model Card Generation | 2023-09-22T04:46:11 | 2023-09-22T04:46:11 | Shruti Singh, Hitesh Lodwal, Husain Malwat, Rakesh Thakur, Mayank Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) are no longer restricted to ML community, and
instruction-tuned LMs have led to a rise in autonomous AI agents. As the
accessibility of LMs grows, it is imperative that an understanding of their
capabilities, intended usage, and development cycle also improves. Model cards
are a popular practice for documenting detailed information about an ML model.
To automate model card generation, we introduce a dataset of 500
question-answer pairs for 25 ML models that cover crucial aspects of the model,
such as its training configurations, datasets, biases, architecture details,
and training resources. We employ annotators to extract the answers from the
original paper. Further, we explore the capabilities of LMs in generating model
cards by answering questions. Our initial experiments with ChatGPT-3.5, LLaMa,
and Galactica showcase a significant gap in the understanding of research
papers by these aforementioned LMs as well as generating factual textual
responses. We posit that our dataset can be used to train models to automate
the generation of model cards from paper text and reduce human effort in the
model card curation process. The complete dataset is available on
https://osf.io/hqt7p/?view_only=3b9114e3904c4443bcd9f5c270158d37 | [
0.0392663404,
0.0532251596,
-0.0149597963,
0.0349525847,
-0.0265403651,
0.0066663479,
0.0092030242,
-0.0133089069,
0.0218482092,
-0.0622060858,
-0.0034654031,
0.0444350354,
-0.0261148047,
0.0628382862,
0.0068370407,
-0.034256313,
0.0172357969,
-0.0366582833,
0.019132521,
-0.001464611,
-0.0152451433,
0.0289619491,
0.0108774751,
0.0531831086,
0.0225259271,
-0.040715009,
-0.0285749137,
-0.0284144767,
-0.0081569236,
-0.0186712034,
0.0112353312,
0.0585264824,
0.0248243231,
0.0518797636,
0.0000020605,
-0.0443910509,
-0.0125234136,
0.0221251864,
-0.0256116372,
-0.0023592017,
0.0402070172,
0.0033864458,
0.0241625179,
0.0160229187,
-0.0507685654,
-0.0091619017,
0.0404076725,
0.0265953019,
0.0522593223,
0.0500066653,
0.0001237478,
-0.0146828508,
0.0725894049,
0.0188247878,
0.0184552148,
-0.009343355,
0.0079624644,
0.0489675477,
0.0191982388,
0.0275783073,
0.0358306728,
0.0788734183,
0.0336446501,
-0.0313785039,
0.0364007726,
0.0288612042,
-0.0215092786,
-0.0103212772,
-0.0032017967,
0.0665195361,
-0.0019885174,
-0.0452897809,
0.0040549724,
-0.0265301075,
0.0036388088,
0.0499035418,
-0.0557575934,
0.0243942328,
0.0105880937,
-0.0209680181,
0.0397562347,
-0.0216447953,
0.0232186206,
-0.0188120771,
-0.0105622979,
0.0681850091,
0.0080772145,
-0.0113187004,
-0.0211613346,
-0.0221192632,
0.0059432518,
-0.0857620016,
-0.014316625,
0.0579351038,
0.007285228,
0.0173690449,
-0.0386515595,
-0.0368803442,
0.029707348,
-0.0455264859,
0.0607495829,
-0.0064817555,
-0.0071055386,
0.0396522358,
-0.0075505241,
-0.0034206696,
-0.0050221356,
0.0263475906,
-0.0420113169,
0.0125142112,
-0.0561475642,
-0.0399006717,
-0.033177074,
0.03782079,
-0.0233821459,
-0.0075373622,
-0.0102797356,
0.0301660951,
0.01262761,
0.0106010586,
-0.0103053609,
0.0176886022,
-0.0085352538,
-0.0158215351,
-0.0354345888,
0.0076020556,
-0.0398105681,
-0.0025625895,
0.0132995397,
-0.0876793861,
-0.0048215366,
0.0155492174,
-0.0110255955,
-0.0336283632,
0.0304223374,
0.0700464919,
0.0181712806,
-0.0317087471,
-0.0284712482,
-0.0391699858,
0.0305153038,
-0.0698290318,
0.0339985192,
-0.0882864371,
0.0366148017,
0.0326940753,
-0.0115343519,
-0.0404564254,
0.0128189707,
0.0239466988,
-0.030075876,
0.0656558052,
-0.0470902883,
0.0078410637,
0.0633359775,
-0.0119744651,
0.0041554738,
0.058068525,
0.0636960492,
0.009397055,
0.0585679188,
-0.0241914559,
0.0520679876,
0.0438269712,
0.0386592038,
-0.0052371072,
-0.0085681388,
0.0379619487,
-0.0128690619,
0.0093350979,
-0.0119569702,
0.0253925528,
-0.0148586268,
-0.0035761523,
0.0529431999,
0.0697627589,
-0.024430085,
0.0304502584,
0.0317946821,
-0.0061039748,
0.0536998659,
-0.0179481711,
-0.0040859259,
0.0409952402,
-0.0454493798,
0.0148104122,
-0.0062888875,
0.0235478636,
-0.0108066294,
-0.0538508743,
-0.0125401253,
-0.0096005332,
-0.0147687895,
0.0152562186,
0.0450142212,
0.017606603,
-0.0237521641,
0.0382814668,
0.024570642,
-0.0339438394,
-0.0307061244,
-0.0883970559,
0.049486801,
0.0052963276,
0.068419084,
-0.0426864997,
-0.0293645859,
-0.0320069157,
-0.0278467853,
0.034770254,
0.0724840835,
-0.033711344,
-0.0230064522,
-0.0241979714,
-0.0002218591,
-0.0303019807,
0.0111033618,
0.0220490992,
0.0376518108,
-0.0341191888,
-0.0093663605,
-0.0305671487,
-0.0867010653,
0.0473744944,
-0.0726465285,
-0.0450293645,
0.0007171643,
-0.0416438654,
0.0581724681,
0.0147565147,
-0.0225203801,
0.0388894193,
0.0574998297,
-0.0399132371,
-0.0108294766,
0.0194664448,
0.0115605826,
0.0120006884,
0.0558845624,
-0.0342933647,
-0.0295860041,
0.0366706625,
-0.0235518571,
-0.0342013463,
-0.0161914546,
-0.0280290861,
0.0296514537,
-0.0240298938,
-0.0097378567,
-0.0010314813,
-0.0028081231,
-0.0335570425,
0.0502585657,
0.0005475914,
0.0087504983,
0.0300666839,
-0.016327031,
0.0237468965,
-0.0201218128,
-0.0154899051,
0.0094989864,
0.0056473622,
0.0129925525,
0.0227128435,
0.0169930514,
-0.0396808758,
-0.0085463831,
-0.0596082881,
-0.0087475115,
0.0088860905,
0.0018781463,
0.0309899598,
-0.0033114718,
-0.0141401729,
-0.0034561327,
-0.0278414618,
-0.0216245204,
0.0239089299,
0.0009378825,
0.0512232631,
0.0172906779,
-0.0095443092,
-0.0645325631,
-0.0096818507,
-0.0459532663,
0.0481329598,
0.0395636149,
-0.0263835546,
-0.0389406085,
0.0253117327,
-0.0132831559,
0.0147188082,
-0.0141229359,
-0.0148304123,
0.0224043317,
-0.0310544223,
-0.031221455,
0.0865919143,
0.0089857765,
0.0427997783,
0.0520320572,
0.0108538643,
-0.073164843,
0.0178269893,
-0.0130749959,
-0.0064857574,
-0.014944599,
-0.0559990145,
0.0321338065,
0.0739731863,
-0.0147448834,
0.0017283829,
-0.0333815552,
0.0393093564,
0.0140371546,
-0.0345353931,
-0.0180171411,
0.013676771,
0.0136885894,
0.0696798116,
0.0216953494,
-0.0531238355,
0.0609531626,
-0.0469702594,
0.0070144865,
-0.0562848188,
-0.0049124472,
-0.0337922983,
0.0465926565,
0.0204794724,
0.0252654683,
0.023835199,
0.0511147939,
-0.0359965563,
-0.0250080191,
0.0036670179,
-0.0231298599,
-0.0062967991,
-0.038482964,
0.0036987427,
-0.0106094535,
-0.0077786809,
-0.0190201756,
-0.0213608108,
-0.0536701232,
0.0292020012,
0.0173545685,
-0.0378129259,
-0.0557687916,
0.00455165,
0.030040944,
0.0201482456,
-0.0435406901,
-0.0263521597,
-0.0195992067,
0.0315048955,
0.1090175062,
0.0077486681,
0.0456135981,
-0.0244966503,
0.0408958867,
0.050216563,
-0.0083324984,
0.0403465331,
-0.0545815527,
-0.0249207914,
0.0165079981,
-0.0419252887,
0.0208471902,
0.0215370785,
0.0236898921,
-0.0455292873,
-0.0100615742,
0.0930886716,
0.0359562226,
-0.0402422287,
-0.0178918168,
-0.0473002978,
0.0529704913,
0.0146403015,
0.0710366741,
-0.0781157017,
0.0018672273,
-0.0202692617,
0.0389446765,
-0.0196545497,
-0.0196223352,
-0.0060915593,
-0.1029652432,
0.0615313388,
-0.0085919965,
-0.0645063519,
-0.023066042,
-0.0469597653,
-0.0281047262,
-0.0012034978,
-0.0059340089,
0.0195220076,
-0.0179724768,
0.0118685598,
-0.0021181128,
-0.0452919081,
-0.0180957932,
0.0311644301,
0.004134967,
0.0642569438,
0.0695985183,
0.0267894659,
-0.0174973551,
-0.0044807228,
0.0289896671,
0.0385435633,
-0.0181780662,
-0.0104119349,
0.0513659455,
-0.0382051878,
0.0007147205,
0.0176897664,
0.0678333566,
-0.0547189377,
-0.0193992071,
0.0578605272,
0.0658331513,
-0.0147026144,
-0.0097111538,
-0.0669625401,
-0.0044223075,
-0.0244352259,
0.0866552591,
0.0482914858,
-0.0351708047,
-0.028226234,
-0.0494707376,
0.0169641841,
-0.0328656659,
-0.0327624418,
-0.0057541272,
-0.0147199836,
0.0117304614,
-0.0610806309,
-0.0495428517,
0.032399565,
-0.0064779092,
0.0328276008,
-0.0138532482,
0.0421997719,
0.0022034601,
-0.0423633978,
0.0228052847,
-0.0412027799,
-0.0199030787,
-0.0364012718,
-0.0448570512,
0.046846509,
-0.048172228,
-0.0367169753,
0.0287053529,
-0.0587753169,
-0.0630506948,
0.005972757,
0.0961652175,
0.0343734063,
0.040846467,
-0.0119017735,
-0.051979661,
0.0151232146,
0.0546577647,
-0.0326380953,
-0.0261678882,
0.0193106625,
0.0059386459,
-0.0277426206,
0.0027788763,
-0.0429316983,
0.0102388728,
-0.0129742641,
0.0007879183,
-0.0595767125,
-0.0467123464,
0.043351382,
0.0359542817,
-0.0058020367,
-0.005102206,
-0.0169567708,
-0.0315212533,
0.020773422,
-0.0185550395,
-0.0226436853,
-0.0616823174,
0.011018699,
-0.0114745861,
-0.023382036,
0.0237733405,
-0.0446766727,
-0.0406847037,
0.0392887183,
-0.0101114307,
0.0144965108,
0.0319677368,
0.0350909792,
-0.0021270136,
-0.034781497,
-0.020188218,
-0.0053430814,
-0.0431308076,
0.0556908846,
-0.0041108569,
0.0446673185,
0.0216217935,
-0.0057456014,
0.001495427,
0.0310177542,
-0.0946856961,
-0.1013074815,
-0.0510458313,
0.0432515889,
0.0345840566,
0.0053152386,
0.0515140072,
-0.0528307706,
-0.027525574,
-0.0122688133,
0.0353768542,
0.0383423641,
-0.0100945914,
0.0413699262,
0.0323045217,
-0.034769088,
-0.033004541,
0.0807142034,
0.0117826946,
0.0562361851,
0.0306964144,
-0.0165213682,
-0.0587918907,
-0.0125112878,
0.0185391493,
0.0182795767,
-0.0024481765,
-0.0303926431,
-0.0524580777,
-0.0501958281,
-0.0047846129,
0.0562467575,
-0.0098019484,
-0.0064818035,
-0.0010337384,
0.0705216676,
0.0270982254,
-0.0308109522,
-0.0608802848,
0.0614301153,
-0.044264961,
-0.0406731144,
-0.0254020169,
-6.061909022e-33,
-0.0345733277,
-0.0343795344,
0.0274425652,
-0.001824579,
0.0234561041,
0.0031970406,
-0.0504962727,
0.0063749631,
-0.04729148,
0.0084393183,
-0.0249699429,
-0.0208831448,
-0.0021505554,
0.0158688463,
0.0203674212,
-0.0087292315,
0.001156678,
-0.0252244789,
-0.007193835,
0.0396302454,
0.0095562562,
0.0041834163,
0.0302527174,
-0.0733085349,
0.0357733332,
-0.0478283428,
-0.0014445175,
-0.0056567197,
-0.0525467508,
0.0857284591,
-0.0431881137,
0.0054283105,
0.0098766815,
-0.0281633474,
0.00465339,
0.009049885,
-0.0618096478,
-0.0198378358,
0.010375279,
-0.0101000713,
-0.0491347238,
-0.0528752953,
0.0316697173,
-0.0055815042,
0.0151271727,
-0.0066836667,
0.0685654208,
-0.0315444432,
-0.0198484622,
-0.0119516468,
-0.0572158284,
0.0185398217,
-0.0420786813,
-0.0057873614,
-0.0032844117,
0.0377987251,
0.0041345516,
0.0542176664,
-0.0144642992,
0.023595877,
0.0567138903,
0.0170350838,
0.0797385275,
-0.0036512122,
0.0397805348,
0.0513487235,
0.0212819483,
-0.0077117761,
0.0053115929,
0.002378905,
0.0129535748,
0.0460550264,
0.0535014197,
0.0338971354,
0.0218927339,
0.0316030979,
-0.0364334397,
0.0415079147,
0.0364337116,
0.0235219039,
0.0549384505,
-0.0124820853,
-0.0140585527,
0.0138614681,
-0.0413542949,
-0.0692719817,
-0.0142120039,
-0.0384420007,
0.0151459407,
-0.0272862632,
-0.0397435836,
-0.0357161649,
0.0322253853,
-0.0610697269,
-0.0279129334,
-0.0055378131,
-0.0107921287,
0.037052121,
0.0008703107,
0.030359827,
-0.0578127056,
0.004563489,
-0.0099372957,
-0.0001803018,
0.028084347,
0.0319491699,
0.0278963428,
-0.0070348056,
-0.0339961164,
-0.0065569724,
-0.0382039174,
0.0099883545,
-0.0046355338,
0.0347464569,
0.0020215153,
0.0204289649,
-0.0023557693,
0.0161138959,
-0.0166676585,
0.0108179394,
-0.0564573966,
0.0043887296,
-0.0152209504,
0.0136446608,
-0.001320961,
-0.0161231775,
-0.0573439933,
0.0523048081,
0.0462944098,
-0.0347151123,
0.008887765,
0.0218578558,
2.64e-7,
0.0699066073,
0.0405606031,
0.018671276,
0.0294564627,
0.0185823999,
0.0411119871,
0.0053599123,
0.0026346187,
0.0571115352,
-0.001207184,
-0.0149105322,
0.016918363,
0.0391922891,
0.0488022864,
-0.0804204866,
-0.0495547615,
-0.084843345,
-0.0105858697,
-0.0599397011,
0.0010987537,
0.0446479321,
0.070627667,
-0.0129932584,
-0.0075485101,
-0.02991933,
-0.00150134,
0.0314459912,
-0.0596769378,
-0.0096214255,
0.060856849,
0.0236285683,
0.0056187892,
0.0088566225,
-0.0095600411,
-0.0146073848,
0.0038849534,
-0.0237489827,
0.0540002137,
0.0156638939,
-0.028482642,
0.0181610286,
-0.0209518969,
0.0125947911,
-0.100789398,
0.0565549023,
-0.0442531183,
-0.0332277603,
-0.0909493417,
-0.0304325204,
-0.0216847453,
0.0183509961,
-0.04711584,
0.0207706876,
0.0311901551,
-0.0146093937,
-0.0369440727,
-0.0050859232,
-0.0444501489,
-0.0405751951,
-0.0228598751,
-0.0260386579,
-0.0304714739,
-0.0365359075,
-0.0295755249,
0.0187244508,
-0.0514187291,
0.0192271583,
2.643652357e-34,
0.0437240936,
-0.0064419713,
-0.0153039787,
0.0857015699,
0.0515841395,
-0.0144779021,
0.0196666121,
0.0225770343,
0.008824354,
-0.0920102596,
-0.0105183721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12570v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12570v3 | Creativity Support in the Age of Large Language Models: An Empirical Study Involving Emerging Writers | 2023-09-22T01:49:36 | 2024-01-30T15:56:47 | Tuhin Chakrabarty, Vishakh Padmakumar, Faeze Brahman, Smaranda Muresan | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | The development of large language models (LLMs) capable of following
instructions and engaging in conversational interactions sparked increased
interest in their utilization across various support tools. We investigate the
utility of modern LLMs in assisting professional writers via an empirical user
study (n=30). The design of our collaborative writing interface is grounded in
the cognitive process model of writing that views writing as a goal-oriented
thinking process encompassing non-linear cognitive activities: planning,
translating, and reviewing. Participants are asked to submit a post-completion
survey to provide feedback on the potential and pitfalls of LLMs as writing
collaborators. Upon analyzing the writer-LLM interactions, we find that while
writers seek LLM's help across all three types of cognitive activities, they
find LLMs more helpful in translation and reviewing. Our findings from
analyzing both the interactions and the survey responses highlight future
research directions in creative writing assistance using LLMs. | [
0.058974836,
-0.0032610984,
-0.0383954309,
-0.010096251,
-0.0704915747,
-0.0068483343,
0.0605537295,
0.0016321702,
-0.0057837279,
-0.003301163,
-0.0512407869,
-0.0415497236,
0.0082376981,
0.0085054813,
0.0008250975,
-0.0200178698,
-0.0015190752,
-0.0306590591,
0.0671145171,
0.0245699957,
0.0096252719,
0.0672844797,
-0.0182292741,
0.0840099379,
0.0195989124,
-0.0400719866,
-0.0070162374,
-0.0005519188,
-0.0144636706,
-0.0086204596,
-0.0258831829,
0.0640527681,
0.0324172787,
0.0214343965,
0.000002084,
-0.0301168393,
0.024742607,
-0.0282080658,
0.0251165424,
-0.0299708005,
0.0367793404,
0.0045010527,
-0.0272926968,
-0.0061154617,
-0.004560384,
0.0123064313,
0.0417260006,
0.0155206015,
0.0089544533,
0.0052128043,
0.0014083097,
-0.0035372383,
0.0079768412,
-0.006105483,
0.015327449,
0.0555788316,
-0.0405298248,
0.0374416038,
0.0548091121,
-0.0060255029,
0.0266468525,
0.0370936058,
0.0066073998,
-0.0996650606,
0.0258654132,
0.0185992066,
0.0145393675,
-0.0607055426,
0.0559172779,
0.0131182186,
0.0579827838,
0.0180697702,
-0.0498977639,
0.0031762915,
-0.00510679,
0.0605346374,
-0.0622797981,
0.0264744479,
-0.0003500925,
-0.0253725685,
-0.0048072054,
-0.0270677861,
-0.0123704635,
0.0218701866,
0.0491769724,
-0.0224976297,
0.0140904868,
0.0115851127,
0.0036149982,
0.0299527775,
-0.0176034886,
-0.0732905716,
0.0321499929,
0.0475466438,
-0.0266948882,
0.0079736123,
0.0004453619,
-0.0452943034,
0.0007040482,
-0.038706623,
0.1252109706,
0.0209335852,
0.0732821673,
0.0148655735,
0.0129092233,
0.0137908421,
0.0168269537,
0.0203862227,
-0.021312777,
0.0396685079,
-0.0322315507,
-0.0497871749,
-0.0337544978,
0.0176056735,
-0.0150041813,
-0.0488411784,
-0.0247465055,
0.0492006615,
0.0167133566,
0.0414038189,
-0.0018480599,
0.0006922931,
-0.01510699,
0.0146520995,
-0.0190141089,
0.02933833,
0.0041424301,
0.0234102178,
-0.0125267413,
0.0103277722,
0.0370687023,
0.0107169282,
-0.0262072571,
-0.0376695991,
-0.0098695299,
0.0244006533,
-0.0040208488,
-0.0178950951,
-0.0135399839,
-0.030671306,
0.0227245782,
-0.0255674087,
-0.0399135575,
-0.0586236827,
0.0077133025,
0.0478851609,
-0.0224279966,
-0.04453554,
-0.0117068961,
0.0297481064,
0.0052550905,
-0.0107548079,
-0.0273436811,
0.0385113768,
0.0547249317,
0.0227308869,
0.0082971761,
0.0019969437,
0.0819389671,
0.0049733999,
0.0080290772,
-0.0011824586,
0.0311940964,
0.0301915165,
-0.0789245889,
-0.003206477,
-0.056250982,
-0.0271564126,
-0.0074869934,
0.0452529117,
-0.0238957051,
0.0225137472,
-0.0240367651,
0.0808544531,
0.1200646013,
0.0546031855,
0.0458505712,
0.0619545169,
0.0287840459,
-0.0034091938,
-0.0004707983,
-0.0117165819,
-0.006777708,
0.0590913333,
0.0240827631,
0.0410832502,
-0.0400399081,
0.0277498923,
-0.0171598624,
-0.0371844992,
-0.0311343968,
0.0128811104,
0.0032469479,
0.005035006,
0.0035693641,
0.0048438907,
-0.0108634923,
0.0219806824,
-0.0460150801,
-0.0913289189,
0.023457991,
0.0083117224,
0.0579089634,
0.1368242949,
0.0611921884,
0.0011939099,
-0.0114437612,
-0.0186938327,
0.0166038685,
0.0606635399,
0.0199362077,
0.0159580521,
-0.0139804194,
0.0083799912,
0.0172556527,
-0.0453033969,
-0.0184569731,
-0.041808188,
-0.0041322717,
0.0291032065,
-0.0022089055,
-0.0124096945,
-0.0673903748,
0.00846186,
-0.0405660123,
-0.0041673225,
-0.0391592234,
0.0221758373,
-0.0339912027,
0.0596547984,
-0.0533533767,
0.0275403429,
0.0196897108,
-0.0405393429,
-0.026010748,
0.0924588814,
0.0028802583,
0.0271784589,
0.0149850454,
-0.0015861099,
0.0358752832,
-0.0366519354,
0.0442200862,
-0.0206219498,
0.0522960164,
-0.0023134805,
0.0226979163,
-0.0106001664,
0.0173651297,
-0.033699736,
-0.054038167,
-0.0124410512,
-0.0073463335,
0.0191696379,
0.0294666309,
0.0087872613,
0.0011092038,
0.0007256589,
0.0184389632,
-0.0216061212,
0.0683088154,
0.0467906147,
-0.0032207191,
0.0002200407,
0.0137024438,
-0.0469086915,
-0.0593279153,
-0.0666056722,
0.0025374372,
-0.0137697756,
0.0209708922,
0.0461281352,
-0.0002087053,
-0.0336804017,
0.0126795238,
-0.0295052212,
-0.0067157424,
0.0235703755,
-0.0098633226,
0.02786218,
-0.0082351305,
0.0136041725,
-0.0232687313,
0.0075291507,
0.0114180073,
0.0125248544,
0.0699974522,
-0.0554332212,
-0.0466408692,
0.0395039059,
-0.0568224639,
-0.0476201028,
0.0080285938,
-0.0075106029,
0.0360364616,
-0.0376328826,
0.0444995761,
0.0133736972,
-0.0020566348,
0.0205417313,
0.0915877372,
-0.025799457,
-0.017881874,
-0.0093650091,
0.0424006358,
-0.0015030436,
0.0183740258,
-0.0566130988,
0.0048299939,
0.010841148,
0.0345440358,
0.012836244,
-0.011067858,
0.0418616012,
-0.0139843924,
0.0276296679,
-0.0016384154,
-0.0352177173,
-0.0206930675,
0.0301072616,
-0.018887829,
-0.0394989066,
0.0362060703,
-0.019575661,
-0.0218833536,
-0.0124028521,
-0.0351627842,
-0.0284240469,
0.0783131868,
-0.0421911776,
0.0292773955,
-0.0177351721,
0.0056235045,
-0.04364888,
0.0182564706,
0.0330188461,
-0.00681544,
0.0018274985,
-0.0713376924,
-0.0225770492,
-0.0419057384,
0.0385542586,
-0.0064180717,
0.0285938308,
-0.0285450444,
0.0103369672,
0.0618125722,
-0.018959593,
0.0065256301,
0.0102426093,
0.0498695187,
0.0493032224,
0.0000321643,
-0.0035654756,
-0.0330265984,
-0.0067354999,
0.0075437753,
-0.01555626,
-0.0231872927,
-0.0576844551,
0.0712311044,
0.0406493768,
-0.060018599,
-0.0099562211,
-0.0085661206,
-0.0309876353,
0.0418912731,
-0.0113219898,
-0.0472816117,
-0.0108790305,
0.0911855623,
-0.026710948,
-0.0185522288,
0.1131918058,
0.0182682425,
-0.0821986049,
-0.0296517573,
-0.0512187295,
0.0066078738,
0.0343983136,
0.0353203863,
-0.0240297746,
0.0339944027,
0.0097618299,
0.0031322383,
-0.0265451334,
-0.0263030846,
-0.0267119408,
-0.0522498041,
0.0513983816,
0.00814059,
-0.0041833352,
0.0513542891,
0.0027886194,
0.0055696997,
0.0822313651,
-0.009112413,
-0.0126177957,
-0.0248214267,
0.0195851065,
-0.0269932915,
-0.0255158208,
-0.0154431257,
-0.0206413679,
-0.0496934317,
0.0297723934,
0.0337132178,
0.0407773778,
0.0254891776,
-0.0131657822,
-0.0006618709,
0.0338680446,
0.0409445465,
-0.0155414958,
-0.0093396688,
0.0237347651,
0.0472147949,
-0.0545962863,
0.0170422997,
-0.046443969,
-0.0395477638,
0.0447599068,
0.0318746231,
-0.0598581359,
0.021259835,
-0.0055787447,
0.0562223196,
0.0128691802,
0.0226248633,
0.0500704087,
-0.0733308569,
-0.003737425,
-0.0020868992,
-0.0086149722,
-0.0440832861,
-0.0298983678,
-0.039458584,
-0.0052229906,
0.0370726958,
-0.0533631742,
-0.0530956127,
0.0730620921,
0.0477024913,
0.0411347374,
0.0492310822,
-0.038426578,
-0.022437403,
-0.0373363085,
-0.0134129841,
0.03027834,
0.0507389866,
-0.0211890172,
-0.0274534412,
-0.0645299926,
-0.0483020395,
0.0433996543,
-0.0057747527,
-0.0923623443,
-0.0499430001,
-0.0414312072,
0.0109905694,
0.0219285488,
-0.0311953295,
0.0115704658,
-0.079610534,
-0.0392826609,
-0.0120537803,
-0.0172057282,
0.0296908431,
-0.0529762506,
0.0526536331,
0.0152808959,
0.0037239273,
0.0041786912,
-0.0131423036,
0.0229118057,
0.0307450444,
-0.0066713914,
-0.0854872391,
0.0070155263,
0.0259090811,
-0.0436556339,
-0.0390318185,
0.04351715,
-0.0814297348,
-0.002505064,
-0.0445422493,
-0.0216869526,
-0.0356560834,
-0.010339696,
0.0067516505,
-0.0358349048,
0.0187285338,
0.0287731159,
-0.0305096097,
0.0098875761,
-0.0411984287,
0.0426837802,
-0.0327719599,
-0.0035066255,
0.0184609331,
0.0089809112,
-0.0207307674,
0.0307162832,
-0.0460366085,
0.0226493906,
0.0168000199,
0.085561946,
-0.0186876431,
-0.0122122951,
0.019796649,
0.0345022008,
-0.030306153,
-0.1186738685,
0.0273285918,
0.0421895571,
0.0606011152,
-0.0086008562,
0.048813913,
-0.061511945,
0.0195485111,
0.0009715004,
0.0571479686,
0.0087345419,
-0.0557531938,
-0.012320945,
0.0022970068,
0.0086266464,
-0.0587679632,
0.0432517789,
-0.0636758357,
-0.025161989,
-0.0039392672,
-0.0375177488,
-0.0213054549,
-0.0101184035,
0.0108692646,
0.0158177894,
-0.0121829361,
0.0105537716,
-0.0730465427,
-0.0409365408,
0.0221409574,
-0.0256944057,
-0.015347736,
-0.0692087188,
-0.0150309969,
0.0329128802,
0.0086618783,
-0.0150425611,
-0.0587790869,
0.0365496911,
-0.0426978283,
-0.0017468844,
-0.0588794276,
-5.381526647e-33,
-0.0229311958,
-0.0769532025,
0.0365463644,
0.0017600994,
-0.0170776416,
-0.0381497629,
-0.0475718677,
0.0534939244,
0.0283327773,
-0.0119725699,
-0.0215308145,
-0.0059612701,
-0.0113516413,
-0.0269805416,
0.0279531088,
0.0567245446,
0.0684056208,
0.0083886962,
-0.0280538108,
-0.0223722346,
0.020518627,
-0.0074437731,
0.0325392559,
-0.0617849715,
0.0299186725,
-0.0602281801,
-0.0056078648,
-0.0002247212,
0.0056153676,
0.0076843989,
0.0012613133,
0.0087474352,
0.0329348706,
0.0230506714,
-0.0003764869,
0.0112290503,
0.0080986824,
-0.0088279881,
0.0397019424,
0.0199836157,
-0.0103654386,
-0.0558232889,
0.0316239595,
-0.0332042649,
-0.0166558828,
0.036446847,
0.0264866725,
-0.0145257162,
-0.0245706029,
0.0044466853,
-0.0792220756,
-0.0145486323,
-0.0065134135,
-0.0113517279,
-0.021663012,
0.0180642884,
-0.0119534954,
-0.0526204966,
-0.0712678879,
0.0239931047,
-0.0312844813,
0.0154608143,
0.0608955696,
0.0027399755,
-0.0334864371,
0.0351002701,
-0.0442956612,
0.0520454124,
-0.05120489,
0.0318048708,
0.0102503086,
0.0266858954,
0.0165656954,
0.0575023331,
-0.0185115412,
-0.0401394889,
0.0297590978,
0.0323224105,
0.0200504232,
0.0012328195,
0.0463116691,
0.0194173269,
0.0115671959,
-0.0500633903,
-0.0284437891,
-0.0058166226,
-0.0308065768,
-0.0550714433,
0.01575757,
-0.0194026288,
0.0329224132,
-0.0777719766,
-0.0146349175,
0.0280631166,
-0.0014079545,
-0.0025548718,
-0.0785968751,
0.070007652,
-0.0169905014,
-0.0266989283,
-0.0461737923,
0.0117042903,
-0.0355907753,
0.0296855699,
0.0020321009,
0.0444503576,
0.0008056057,
0.0109146172,
-0.0350968279,
-0.0215878505,
-0.0362317972,
0.0298879594,
0.0299959704,
-0.0127558308,
0.0231316146,
-0.0180619955,
-0.0145454882,
0.0102292513,
0.0137360198,
-0.0335755236,
-0.0381416269,
-0.0173923708,
-0.0164590422,
-0.0217989981,
0.0092358859,
-0.0088392394,
-0.0285203382,
0.0359143317,
0.0611519478,
-0.0257747062,
-0.0109531814,
-0.0475646891,
2.908e-7,
0.0537381023,
0.0141868284,
-0.0441794097,
0.0531603098,
0.0267032851,
-0.0145736896,
-0.0268628169,
0.0000652887,
0.0348630957,
0.0670743957,
0.0209975243,
0.0264100078,
0.034945745,
0.0514893755,
-0.0610426255,
-0.0047898064,
-0.0333998427,
0.0152263502,
-0.065879263,
0.0066626803,
0.0780517757,
-0.0501165539,
0.0058645885,
-0.0178169273,
-0.040458899,
-0.0746670887,
0.0632575005,
-0.0614415109,
0.0168623906,
-0.0028264506,
0.0243343953,
-0.0219291653,
0.0071430062,
0.0253423639,
-0.0114791906,
-0.0189032294,
-0.008642124,
0.0593554005,
-0.0056677349,
0.0405031741,
0.0312379319,
0.0070700422,
0.0011161844,
-0.0600572675,
0.0167993549,
-0.004201564,
-0.0069798511,
0.0116144903,
0.0434875637,
-0.0537315384,
0.0214969199,
-0.0315794647,
-0.0071862368,
0.0421199687,
-0.0023167955,
-0.0250932835,
0.0220998656,
0.0324487276,
-0.0182981901,
0.0151785212,
-0.0145987812,
0.0002102894,
-0.0694826171,
-0.0294137523,
-0.0736970603,
-0.0481134951,
0.021521898,
2.367682329e-34,
-0.0070293336,
0.007250241,
0.0343565866,
0.0422098972,
0.0575807542,
0.0220887717,
0.0199938025,
0.0156414788,
-0.004935801,
-0.0366866998,
-0.0410854816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12555v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12555v1 | PlanFitting: Tailoring Personalized Exercise Plans with Large Language Models | 2023-09-22T00:55:52 | 2023-09-22T00:55:52 | Donghoon Shin, Gary Hsieh, Young-Ho Kim | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, H.5.2; I.2.7 | A personally tailored exercise regimen is crucial to ensuring sufficient
physical activities, yet challenging to create as people have complex schedules
and considerations and the creation of plans often requires iterations with
experts. We present PlanFitting, a conversational AI that assists in
personalized exercise planning. Leveraging generative capabilities of large
language models, PlanFitting enables users to describe various constraints and
queries in natural language, thereby facilitating the creation and refinement
of their weekly exercise plan to suit their specific circumstances while
staying grounded in foundational principles. Through a user study where
participants (N=18) generated a personalized exercise plan using PlanFitting
and expert planners (N=3) evaluated these plans, we identified the potential of
PlanFitting in generating personalized, actionable, and evidence-based exercise
plans. We discuss future design opportunities for AI assistants in creating
plans that better comply with exercise principles and accommodate personal
constraints. | [
0.0551834963,
0.1026184559,
0.0054973466,
0.0000395854,
0.0082987892,
-0.0185344033,
0.0154570369,
0.0211250838,
0.0210986156,
0.0141030112,
0.0205655713,
0.0271147564,
-0.0255974103,
0.0522473902,
-0.0070949197,
-0.0465319455,
-0.0088110138,
-0.0240929127,
0.0519860834,
0.0087224105,
0.0319350585,
0.0231612697,
-0.0277912077,
0.0492768064,
-0.0149192177,
-0.0186787825,
-0.0261614863,
-0.009274045,
-0.0192077048,
-0.0997632444,
0.0047725574,
0.0470235683,
0.0145160854,
-0.0303543173,
0.0000019287,
-0.0137767727,
-0.0006200381,
-0.0022307907,
-0.0577181987,
-0.0305965152,
0.0321486555,
0.0157674905,
0.0251878146,
-0.0119143846,
-0.0412470512,
0.0796309784,
0.0429157354,
0.0351610221,
0.0262008421,
0.0758483112,
-0.0184101593,
-0.0000048038,
-0.0189062469,
-0.0125321886,
0.0295838844,
-0.0183715504,
-0.0217686351,
0.0231060535,
0.0473454967,
0.0148385577,
0.0155528365,
-0.0182893109,
0.0040450227,
0.0027953177,
0.0024773395,
0.031343665,
-0.001237087,
-0.0497862771,
-0.0122817764,
0.0690614432,
0.0413375758,
0.0265810378,
0.0157167707,
-0.014344166,
0.0231719557,
-0.0020498442,
-0.0289407875,
0.0221024137,
0.0078622056,
0.0167621709,
-0.0174606107,
0.0145831415,
0.0317263044,
-0.0136786876,
0.0083824415,
0.0475958362,
-0.0024740638,
-0.0233585518,
-0.0098219123,
-0.0036039902,
0.0209486652,
-0.1019459814,
0.0324208885,
0.018746309,
-0.0549175777,
-0.0205084737,
-0.028169062,
0.0076376274,
0.0089956541,
0.0252494942,
0.0771290809,
0.0495454744,
0.042401664,
-0.0298464894,
0.0831737071,
0.0376044549,
0.0117384503,
-0.0314294919,
-0.0861472636,
0.0435717106,
-0.0729026049,
0.0137967616,
-0.0576703548,
0.0376398824,
-0.0969910175,
-0.0446608514,
-0.0659937561,
0.0105461124,
-0.0213945955,
-0.0080294497,
0.0196088552,
0.0603883676,
-0.0144037316,
-0.0126153901,
-0.0664395466,
-0.0519655608,
-0.0763406754,
0.0493282937,
0.0246679038,
-0.0006594198,
0.003208935,
0.0092055127,
0.0265869983,
0.017399678,
0.0420178734,
0.0301933084,
-0.0258640237,
-0.0337567441,
0.0035423695,
-0.0429075882,
-0.0473599918,
-0.0509696417,
-0.0258787088,
-0.067032136,
0.0260454845,
-0.0572102815,
0.0014027043,
-0.0165524222,
0.0228588693,
0.0364763178,
-0.0148744686,
0.0805191919,
0.0204641987,
0.0427233987,
0.0008437849,
0.0216263123,
0.022341216,
0.0370131917,
0.0478541553,
0.0424721986,
0.0077452306,
0.0307297874,
-0.0086920913,
0.0306381304,
0.0122904247,
-0.043156594,
0.0017127162,
-0.0233803634,
-0.0194927827,
0.0422654636,
-0.0579558685,
0.0536229685,
-0.0286852587,
0.0504260994,
0.0794903114,
0.1097514629,
0.0082401913,
0.063693136,
0.0214757994,
-0.0026952124,
-0.0332472026,
-0.0421286114,
-0.0481367782,
0.0092543401,
0.0052307919,
-0.0423424654,
-0.0103992242,
-0.0002827137,
-0.0566918068,
-0.0619269535,
0.0190315936,
-0.0501747616,
0.052036155,
-0.0123324841,
0.0360035785,
0.0035262837,
-0.0132630803,
0.0300349016,
-0.0258270372,
-0.0339064486,
-0.0123963943,
-0.0285204332,
0.0070237415,
0.0989592671,
0.0181035288,
-0.0209697392,
0.0044889352,
0.0348583311,
0.0318484418,
0.0097024133,
0.0379242487,
0.0039974521,
0.0157031752,
-0.0461192355,
-0.0304894615,
-0.0314015485,
0.0151094534,
-0.0143811936,
-0.0144560868,
0.0016625993,
-0.0138524836,
0.0167734269,
-0.0708286688,
0.0282363091,
-0.0469775982,
-0.0528111532,
0.0488937236,
-0.0100244926,
-0.0006309925,
0.06781625,
0.0248901825,
0.0410784446,
0.0353682339,
-0.0418655314,
0.0061021489,
0.047965426,
0.013046586,
0.0439228751,
0.0068555661,
-0.0335719809,
0.0159447156,
-0.0355651937,
0.0236649644,
-0.0641586408,
0.0015836819,
-0.0181106385,
0.0175013393,
-0.0024522005,
-0.0060499837,
0.078806676,
-0.0310618896,
-0.0033929585,
0.0322690532,
0.0312260259,
-0.0461492315,
0.0398218744,
-0.0488573313,
-0.022529114,
-0.0821863934,
-0.0217896625,
0.0208805501,
-0.0026335369,
0.0005937876,
0.0459509455,
0.058690697,
-0.0536222048,
-0.0306912363,
-0.1051999629,
0.0160362143,
-0.0102083171,
-0.0170963313,
0.0041319868,
0.0265863594,
-0.0017738093,
-0.0505869538,
-0.0507093892,
0.013761594,
-0.0340118408,
0.0198656712,
0.0133213988,
0.0249302965,
0.0107625239,
-0.0364421308,
0.0208198931,
-0.001297442,
-0.0078572035,
0.0883864313,
0.023048142,
-0.0446987338,
0.0016668104,
-0.0119535234,
0.0260644741,
0.0143623007,
-0.0082019195,
0.0465748273,
-0.0055793999,
0.0443199649,
0.0130707333,
-0.0214172434,
0.0089744385,
0.0588049069,
0.0001062317,
-0.0537465848,
0.0256178305,
-0.0497700386,
-0.022207072,
-0.0366005562,
-0.0827796236,
0.0304509886,
0.0074278596,
0.0004718721,
0.0514458939,
-0.0498010814,
0.0630930588,
-0.0016584324,
0.0091458885,
0.0100442823,
0.0262301061,
-0.027746316,
0.0856750831,
-0.0027061936,
-0.0214807782,
0.0176145062,
0.0147852171,
-0.0141513478,
-0.0207689553,
-0.0366692245,
-0.0061719026,
0.0103181424,
0.0211906005,
0.0484255105,
0.0380730703,
0.0210381579,
-0.0064804605,
-0.0190551411,
-0.0025614733,
-0.0101727648,
0.015143374,
-0.0651067942,
0.0163297579,
0.0288005248,
-0.0576077923,
-0.0516658984,
-0.0241610669,
-0.0534034446,
-0.0215454008,
0.0124229388,
-0.021841377,
-0.0401558764,
-0.0358122736,
-0.0332607664,
0.0147284893,
-0.0056010219,
-0.0153800771,
0.021781629,
-0.024950644,
0.0708340928,
0.0710348189,
-0.0288459174,
0.0235164948,
0.0058296723,
0.0429116301,
-0.0044479962,
0.0004376734,
-0.0261866804,
0.0168078225,
0.0219384227,
-0.0042367075,
0.0086695924,
0.059266448,
0.0741854981,
0.008242012,
-0.0200206488,
0.067886509,
0.006211719,
-0.045598954,
0.0345028229,
0.0062803314,
0.0272955224,
0.0094591565,
0.0246632732,
-0.0711585879,
-0.0158970151,
-0.0164134279,
0.0492876992,
-0.0466629751,
-0.0213931073,
-0.0268355329,
-0.0526676513,
0.0081610531,
0.0155281974,
-0.0201384407,
0.0091966717,
0.007995124,
-0.0379345678,
-0.0524582379,
-0.0101832775,
-0.0278767608,
-0.0002071968,
0.0402932726,
-0.0207698382,
-0.0695559531,
-0.0328047015,
0.0286753867,
-0.0195578262,
0.0622632653,
0.0883924812,
0.0438188538,
-0.0048675686,
-0.0403185673,
-0.0039639026,
0.0622054338,
0.0130837737,
-0.0389297977,
0.0343447328,
0.0349097848,
-0.007470428,
-0.0333911665,
0.0960145593,
-0.0360626951,
-0.0679200366,
0.0544791929,
0.064434655,
0.003766442,
-0.0017918814,
-0.0440983959,
0.0115617979,
0.0753316358,
0.0347797908,
-0.0050924951,
-0.0562327169,
-0.0081087574,
-0.0399513803,
0.0322048068,
-0.0583349206,
-0.0279310457,
0.0063797701,
-0.0322272703,
0.051209297,
-0.0424487852,
-0.0423685089,
0.0167314932,
0.020953333,
0.0056063449,
-0.0242966451,
0.0273327474,
0.0450775437,
-0.0120196976,
0.0187807921,
0.0167705249,
-0.0253100637,
-0.0306862313,
-0.0931421444,
0.0045966483,
0.0230675396,
0.0101152491,
0.0124836117,
-0.0366788879,
-0.0010646763,
-0.0356989726,
0.082058236,
0.0195777472,
0.0088274805,
0.0081119984,
-0.0016307615,
-0.0571325645,
0.0145440409,
-0.0273923483,
0.0064645922,
0.0220253933,
0.0447244607,
0.024662666,
0.0224019364,
-0.0220644362,
0.0285312738,
-0.0111497156,
0.0233308021,
-0.0914885923,
-0.0539598837,
0.0296092536,
0.0245381668,
0.0035428482,
-0.0200674627,
-0.0178829134,
0.0028266266,
0.005996523,
-0.0505716018,
-0.0266731288,
-0.083527118,
0.0007874265,
0.0119563704,
-0.0022884875,
0.0357508622,
-0.0207194202,
-0.0741455182,
0.006341577,
-0.0238457341,
0.0343898907,
0.0080302842,
0.0440030023,
0.0049647223,
-0.0035890343,
0.0217830017,
0.0376580395,
-0.0229633674,
0.0143654179,
0.0048888545,
0.0605089366,
-0.0298503209,
0.0042813187,
-0.0526259728,
0.0122618536,
-0.000489114,
-0.0413290299,
0.0178721156,
0.0106261121,
-0.0222239308,
-0.0213090796,
0.0052137296,
-0.0131090861,
0.0080090128,
0.0001978285,
0.0514233336,
-0.0026889488,
-0.001000534,
0.0238715205,
-0.0071730097,
-0.029530894,
-0.0782254711,
0.0386477448,
-0.0020466249,
0.0378535278,
-0.0015091453,
-0.0396714024,
-0.0493869893,
-0.0357411727,
-0.0196046922,
0.011571059,
-0.0375129506,
-0.0331988744,
-0.0396365151,
-0.0262014866,
0.0028082039,
0.0131532475,
-0.0201039407,
0.0013514159,
0.0330417566,
0.0130237406,
-0.0493750535,
-0.0497785509,
-0.0207233839,
0.0219719745,
-0.0422418565,
-0.0332869701,
-0.0362467319,
-5.284755176e-33,
0.0140751172,
-0.0511859469,
0.0777170584,
-0.0201110151,
0.0463454686,
-0.0030581325,
-0.0597491302,
0.022720987,
0.0311706383,
0.0172527004,
-0.0008874241,
-0.0284802224,
-0.0087315626,
-0.0169303417,
0.040020071,
-0.0078343684,
0.0427121483,
-0.0175295826,
-0.0121255117,
0.0024970211,
-0.0109991152,
-0.00014893,
-0.0064053768,
-0.0788954347,
0.0138579905,
0.0345854126,
-0.0437106155,
0.0298577342,
0.00423889,
0.0414078943,
-0.0394978374,
-0.0094539244,
0.0154674361,
0.0249023344,
-0.0273923706,
0.046092838,
-0.021693483,
-0.0873329565,
0.0109691275,
-0.0526798517,
-0.0471335724,
-0.0709814802,
-0.0082484046,
-0.0116787935,
-0.0494715385,
0.0254230276,
0.0514615737,
-0.0113065429,
0.0246176887,
0.0532447919,
-0.0155159421,
-0.003943481,
-0.0363691971,
0.0057835584,
0.0276388843,
0.0027446786,
-0.0103568379,
-0.047903385,
0.0060010427,
0.0645214617,
0.0013118023,
0.0076041729,
-0.0070090331,
-0.0142960344,
-0.0186877735,
0.001260251,
0.0113689872,
-0.0065346016,
-0.0303347744,
0.0272935778,
-0.0208958182,
0.0975215584,
0.0229393393,
0.044600945,
0.0013211848,
0.0173777696,
-0.0314812362,
0.027199734,
-0.0236199666,
-0.0082427096,
-0.0042002224,
0.0462696292,
-0.0273119081,
-0.0200509317,
-0.0001763809,
-0.0100819841,
-0.0572309531,
-0.0210442729,
0.0242486186,
0.0199483186,
-0.0256516356,
0.0312990323,
-0.0453077815,
-0.0205476787,
-0.0009793052,
0.0159996431,
0.0247134082,
-0.0432832725,
-0.0136421211,
-0.0325714089,
-0.0963730738,
-0.0146642476,
-0.0037550528,
0.0334455147,
0.0449474826,
0.0290509183,
0.0065184911,
0.0199657902,
-0.0009435785,
-0.0314188898,
0.007718659,
-0.0020898797,
0.0029953427,
-0.0389133953,
0.0592496134,
0.0270174406,
-0.0521173254,
0.0793522671,
-0.0018808871,
-0.0183159132,
-0.0803088322,
-0.0101718251,
0.0592069328,
-0.0098367957,
-0.0229068492,
-0.0353097469,
-0.0374018364,
0.0140546476,
0.0676804483,
-0.0242367983,
-0.0074205804,
0.0003865871,
2.531e-7,
0.0113637671,
0.0306235198,
-0.0065286225,
0.0070670014,
0.0047037741,
0.0417768322,
0.0233758427,
-0.0074028922,
-0.0261857919,
0.0254210308,
0.0499989763,
0.0234781373,
-0.0146425581,
0.0282880589,
0.0080055157,
0.0264492705,
-0.0081099551,
-0.00325153,
-0.0546006709,
0.0027212182,
0.0582093224,
0.060436774,
0.0343220495,
0.0300599821,
0.0384950414,
-0.0206944868,
0.011641833,
-0.0525651574,
0.0076888748,
-0.0108796107,
0.0195346922,
-0.0267430376,
-0.0096047642,
-0.0234946609,
-0.0411786176,
-0.0268087108,
-0.0024958721,
0.124107264,
-0.0376000591,
-0.0250238925,
-0.01155682,
0.0229018386,
-0.0263171121,
-0.0031305449,
0.0249141157,
-0.059048973,
-0.0308905188,
-0.0284553748,
-0.0003423741,
-0.0228170864,
0.0001162406,
-0.0091726473,
0.0140864179,
0.0308486894,
0.0307552591,
0.026780013,
-0.0111049311,
-0.031284079,
0.0028129066,
0.0041624028,
-0.0657116696,
0.0124095175,
-0.0634572431,
0.0007445254,
-0.0528857224,
-0.0418282263,
0.013668594,
1.541249074e-34,
-0.0474879257,
0.0674903467,
0.0119945602,
0.0219780747,
0.0331726298,
0.0388269909,
0.0144804306,
0.0314084515,
0.0519882329,
-0.1029667035,
-0.0436125249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12551v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12551v2 | Is it Possible to Modify Text to a Target Readability Level? An Initial Investigation Using Zero-Shot Large Language Models | 2023-09-22T00:47:18 | 2024-05-27T18:05:31 | Asma Farajidizaji, Vatsal Raina, Mark Gales | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text simplification is a common task where the text is adapted to make it
easier to understand. Similarly, text elaboration can make a passage more
sophisticated, offering a method to control the complexity of reading
comprehension tests. However, text simplification and elaboration tasks are
limited to only relatively alter the readability of texts. It is useful to
directly modify the readability of any text to an absolute target readability
level to cater to a diverse audience. Ideally, the readability of
readability-controlled generated text should be independent of the source text.
Therefore, we propose a novel readability-controlled text modification task.
The task requires the generation of 8 versions at various target readability
levels for each input text. We introduce novel readability-controlled text
modification metrics. The baselines for this task use ChatGPT and Llama-2, with
an extension approach introducing a two-step process (generating paraphrases by
passing through the language model twice). The zero-shot approaches are able to
push the readability of the paraphrases in the desired direction but the final
readability remains correlated with the original text's readability. We also
find greater drops in semantic and lexical similarity between the source and
target texts with greater shifts in the readability. | [
0.0313550681,
-0.0094656646,
-0.0289036408,
0.0073650386,
-0.0603991635,
0.0009991266,
0.0237275083,
0.0477260202,
-0.0096385563,
-0.0231096093,
-0.0238085371,
0.0235177465,
0.0102978945,
-0.0139723076,
0.026411863,
-0.0806911215,
0.0363074094,
-0.0252356939,
0.002077423,
0.0133007858,
0.0250220913,
-0.0051310388,
0.0095477784,
0.0160269756,
0.0563419983,
-0.0355358608,
0.0125394398,
0.0286405981,
0.0118860975,
0.0129975723,
-0.0100174192,
0.043161124,
-0.0067155138,
0.0077002868,
0.0000020768,
-0.0227682423,
-0.0229321197,
-0.0013521842,
-0.0096450411,
0.0693515763,
0.1288182288,
-0.0082426481,
-0.0046716793,
0.0017144228,
0.0230049361,
0.0078473985,
0.0446204059,
0.0346261039,
0.0751910806,
0.0540431701,
-0.0130584752,
-0.0223488025,
-0.0061630127,
-0.007354246,
0.0675523877,
-0.015903499,
0.0002666567,
0.0439467281,
0.0072828387,
0.0418774858,
-0.0236997325,
0.0387306437,
0.0047836276,
-0.0090711638,
0.0287786275,
0.0176131986,
0.0243606046,
-0.01460151,
0.0150265638,
0.067966409,
-0.0362538025,
-0.0815356076,
-0.0066060871,
-0.0107989609,
-0.0135589372,
0.0310588833,
-0.0656109825,
-0.0160023514,
0.0064561511,
0.0235027485,
-0.0311044585,
0.0165860858,
0.0285020154,
-0.0005868798,
0.0092714634,
0.0015770386,
0.0270296447,
-0.0367962345,
-0.0330863483,
-0.0165419821,
-0.0058409139,
-0.0359993801,
0.0471355319,
0.0263709221,
-0.0058147162,
0.0214184467,
-0.0736393556,
-0.0943407342,
0.0303653069,
-0.031714309,
0.0779731274,
0.0440203846,
0.0237990469,
0.0395208485,
-0.0482350327,
0.0687440038,
0.0004478467,
0.0025543394,
-0.0656490698,
0.0279837102,
-0.0167048294,
0.0087191481,
-0.0365705937,
0.0034908829,
-0.0520647727,
-0.0400652923,
-0.0550352484,
0.0058546206,
0.0548861176,
-0.0380882397,
-0.0038390225,
-0.0196377449,
-0.0559725687,
-0.0371602252,
0.0387583561,
0.0413890891,
-0.0535828844,
0.0170305707,
-0.0198025443,
-0.0186915863,
-0.0029230712,
0.027651066,
0.0336954743,
-0.0096106278,
-0.0212688427,
0.05187729,
-0.0518752038,
-0.0163901933,
-0.0509759411,
-0.0119613418,
0.0153258452,
-0.0227224957,
-0.0240539983,
-0.0296820216,
-0.002879092,
-0.0356992669,
0.0123262005,
-0.0316476673,
-0.0037661784,
0.0125788627,
-0.0461212173,
0.0642489418,
-0.0132930493,
0.0125048049,
0.0326325372,
0.0196640268,
-0.0041286652,
0.0506963581,
0.0616083555,
0.0161528066,
0.0591394417,
-0.01817373,
0.0120209223,
0.0372999124,
0.0127538927,
0.0429680645,
0.01859973,
-0.0512065254,
-0.0422997661,
0.0126007721,
0.0328025185,
0.055363331,
-0.0588504672,
-0.0101697715,
0.1149779186,
0.033875335,
0.053524293,
0.0215470698,
0.0503464229,
0.0532361269,
0.0016774575,
0.046834439,
0.002346829,
-0.0011585701,
-0.0418278351,
0.0610862859,
0.0293862876,
-0.006280235,
-0.0164448339,
-0.0533013009,
0.0286239255,
0.0033758797,
0.0477929078,
-0.0454671159,
0.019883031,
0.0291158538,
-0.0891417265,
-0.0025205743,
0.0088443337,
-0.1021808386,
0.0188488141,
-0.0247361995,
0.0510348193,
0.0670335814,
0.0697031766,
-0.0094533749,
-0.0131548168,
0.0299658645,
0.0160458423,
0.0665626228,
-0.0131596541,
0.0038752228,
0.028515961,
-0.0880184844,
0.0128472876,
0.0087605882,
0.0243602376,
-0.005674527,
0.0183219686,
-0.0111132702,
0.0355655476,
-0.0533194244,
-0.0407416709,
0.0406873189,
-0.0447640829,
-0.019799063,
0.0047998955,
-0.0086682811,
0.0035526734,
0.0041348259,
-0.0093105603,
0.0029754792,
-0.0118460488,
-0.0298319366,
-0.0006622348,
0.019083688,
-0.0083562173,
-0.0265461598,
-0.0133545296,
-0.065356262,
0.0341955684,
0.0255820118,
-0.0107573671,
-0.0323838703,
0.0016394109,
-0.0627153665,
0.0200092979,
-0.0127571346,
0.0585730039,
-0.0524728708,
-0.0063315532,
-0.0599013902,
0.0198817551,
0.0214585382,
0.0022486644,
0.0150475288,
-0.0108146789,
-0.0080138659,
-0.0082079219,
-0.0101520019,
-0.0524466038,
0.0151221156,
-0.0016848044,
0.0237627607,
0.0290213283,
-0.0420760624,
-0.0377866924,
-0.0704672784,
0.0154607706,
0.0016785151,
0.0043187933,
0.0620859638,
0.0008158676,
-0.0080129001,
0.0202462245,
0.0072350367,
0.0328016467,
-0.0395609587,
0.0127348639,
0.0398150347,
-0.0056031873,
-0.0310932212,
-0.0557295606,
-0.0367019698,
0.0121889226,
0.0465989597,
0.0577534847,
0.0026823655,
-0.0592792891,
0.0562736914,
-0.006690389,
-0.0521679856,
0.039886795,
-0.048174452,
-0.0210765097,
0.0261144973,
0.0849706233,
0.0993188098,
0.0027936234,
0.0173977688,
0.0317522101,
-0.0074575339,
-0.0200943481,
-0.0130542703,
-0.0203390326,
-0.0351732634,
0.0135682095,
-0.1117509231,
0.0253346656,
0.0619259067,
0.015422008,
-0.0042069703,
-0.0928469449,
0.0169971194,
-0.0601775646,
-0.0639291033,
-0.0286109913,
-0.0161283314,
-0.0223577712,
0.0166486427,
-0.0509014018,
-0.0439005755,
0.042610053,
-0.0443400219,
0.0080563342,
-0.0546598509,
0.0283530615,
-0.0283319,
0.0120588485,
0.0082211057,
0.0309287943,
0.0163954757,
-0.0077664969,
-0.0240698904,
-0.0161631163,
0.0288427565,
-0.0094323531,
0.0439164974,
-0.0777559951,
-0.0131250583,
0.0039725821,
-0.0083508715,
0.0184706487,
-0.0128646949,
0.0257466156,
-0.0281517692,
0.0467861854,
-0.001727068,
-0.0448728837,
-0.0125155356,
0.042698767,
0.0581650585,
-0.0434198193,
-0.0057159425,
-0.0275265183,
0.032901369,
0.0327940024,
-0.0140954498,
-0.0151396031,
-0.0591842346,
-0.0056453161,
0.037225388,
-0.0115009332,
-0.0099510327,
0.0071844142,
0.0022440674,
0.0021025334,
-0.0396901481,
-0.0201090276,
-0.0013310482,
0.0604726486,
-0.0728692785,
-0.0157153364,
0.0811672211,
0.0248505138,
-0.0059094313,
0.0034295302,
-0.0412866957,
0.0439152792,
-0.0231920592,
0.0137005569,
-0.0673502684,
-0.0305456351,
0.0249082129,
0.0382311791,
-0.0211865082,
-0.0084521128,
-0.0216626171,
-0.0532647558,
0.0327625982,
0.0398222096,
-0.040164765,
-0.0043935226,
-0.0171225369,
0.0104647968,
0.0088164061,
0.0188595839,
0.0341877602,
-0.0078342175,
0.0106030321,
-0.0283093378,
-0.0158846527,
-0.0156091629,
-0.047282055,
0.0200856403,
0.048620522,
0.0445461199,
0.0178822279,
0.0104316641,
0.0090834415,
0.0376971141,
0.0021027017,
0.0236815121,
-0.0375552699,
0.0546829589,
0.0223716665,
0.0009911901,
-0.0492791571,
0.0518772192,
0.0502407029,
-0.0066525489,
0.0120360721,
-0.0011805019,
0.0651336983,
-0.0504142456,
-0.0214609113,
0.0246413108,
-0.0015212132,
0.075841181,
0.0748162568,
-0.0336011201,
-0.0395497084,
-0.0451684892,
-0.010141544,
-0.098114863,
-0.0583838634,
-0.0289894547,
-0.0500196777,
-0.0504231118,
-0.0912343264,
-0.0218443684,
0.002423937,
-0.0047974722,
0.0372186191,
0.0240144525,
0.0253477283,
-0.0129865091,
-0.026743982,
-0.047796201,
-0.0588226467,
0.0018752995,
-0.0494100563,
0.0062133768,
-0.0009571,
-0.0323879123,
-0.0002023998,
0.0146465991,
-0.0581297353,
-0.0392091535,
-0.0134481881,
0.0407088846,
0.0252812821,
0.0121942712,
0.0004403408,
-0.0791937038,
0.0503417104,
-0.0074731396,
-0.0300380737,
0.0870856196,
0.0188359134,
0.0201806389,
0.0224188492,
0.0262349229,
-0.0060130851,
0.0395789221,
0.0214528162,
0.0280113295,
-0.0158014502,
-0.0282740556,
-0.0090224789,
0.0435331352,
-0.0286986101,
0.0258089341,
0.011663056,
-0.0112832636,
0.0143143693,
-0.0575724654,
0.0203031506,
-0.0372011811,
-0.0057719713,
0.0203102734,
-0.0049281963,
-0.0334970281,
0.0249458086,
-0.0492488965,
0.0078151431,
-0.0294860378,
0.0198884923,
-0.0412744284,
0.0224508177,
-0.0008870777,
-0.0039703874,
-0.0436705053,
0.0049269409,
-0.0661923364,
0.0272847638,
0.0204115938,
0.051092416,
0.0102363629,
-0.0102274278,
-0.0439630821,
0.0561480522,
-0.0313556679,
0.0412864015,
-0.0042366534,
0.0452833511,
-0.0067894771,
0.0268772133,
0.1065179184,
-0.015600957,
-0.0084290216,
-0.0253939293,
0.0403006822,
0.0189961623,
-0.0366289355,
-0.0175479669,
-0.003402181,
0.0339225307,
-0.0056435545,
0.1029270366,
0.0067707063,
0.0037641451,
0.0075392462,
0.0000534318,
-0.0368274003,
-0.0190354455,
0.0020692383,
0.0302024335,
-0.00602793,
-0.0415771529,
-0.050199423,
-0.0345453657,
0.0384432413,
0.0268702228,
0.0193094537,
-0.0288553182,
-0.000117116,
0.0242658984,
-0.0486625135,
-0.0421600565,
-0.0383975655,
0.0264713056,
-0.0117140152,
-0.0122720292,
-0.0064806794,
-6.041819823e-33,
-0.0287693609,
0.0034204184,
-0.0065586185,
-0.0087319063,
-0.0570161492,
0.0168662164,
-0.0723372549,
0.0078084548,
0.0078003109,
0.0279708393,
-0.0044495305,
-0.0026332026,
0.0133414334,
0.0041541383,
-0.0464701802,
0.021573497,
0.0810990557,
-0.0115618324,
-0.0356620327,
0.032710582,
0.0154337315,
-0.0026779242,
0.0086818803,
-0.0392098166,
0.0358187407,
-0.0283878949,
-0.0315732621,
-0.0167192668,
0.0391007327,
0.0303314738,
-0.0081737414,
0.0387616046,
0.0222930294,
-0.0438118242,
-0.0363926068,
0.054690972,
-0.0561737828,
-0.0150827207,
0.0701458529,
-0.0085507166,
-0.0515773259,
-0.0886452571,
0.0666660368,
-0.0157386381,
-0.0072376365,
-0.0450085849,
0.0234198123,
-0.0468780845,
-0.0197084174,
-0.0013067815,
-0.077985011,
0.0156120248,
-0.0337384567,
-0.0245227702,
0.0168569032,
0.0572125837,
-0.0174604952,
0.0399800651,
-0.0280145761,
0.0375742093,
0.0503033027,
0.0477609299,
0.028789511,
-0.0012050545,
0.0108777601,
0.0037669775,
-0.0170954298,
0.0006682299,
-0.0422837995,
-0.0011234799,
0.0315706916,
-0.0121806245,
0.0696953535,
0.0752743706,
0.0354241133,
-0.0168773867,
-0.037377242,
0.0354298651,
-0.0001435842,
0.0170037523,
0.0459673516,
0.0398225002,
-0.0524744838,
-0.0185921527,
-0.0547828041,
0.0123061109,
-0.0534907728,
-0.04817174,
0.0277506243,
-0.00710731,
-0.0554109104,
-0.0180683881,
0.0123741468,
0.0027022145,
0.0274269432,
0.0072556832,
-0.0318900347,
0.0833936259,
-0.0322575271,
-0.0084106876,
-0.0233709533,
0.0180446412,
0.0362881683,
0.0397889577,
0.0105435038,
-0.0001435104,
0.0106213689,
-0.0171186794,
-0.0494829267,
-0.0093078148,
0.0078595998,
-0.012789323,
0.008139356,
0.0016335646,
-0.0077704228,
0.0018980149,
-0.0071104956,
0.0179078504,
0.0210662093,
-0.0308296625,
-0.0101514105,
0.0050796373,
0.0061903042,
0.0162721016,
-0.0542623512,
0.0043692165,
-0.0169267487,
0.022576306,
0.0030422804,
-0.0541588292,
-0.0222632065,
0.0130864941,
2.689e-7,
0.0180013683,
0.0710074678,
0.0264622103,
0.0016642886,
0.0108367773,
0.0166146774,
0.0328950323,
-0.0026263972,
0.0079144631,
-0.013046708,
0.0334850922,
0.0078737317,
0.043099381,
-0.0216423646,
-0.0704781264,
-0.0198129937,
-0.013001129,
0.0296120457,
-0.0338945277,
-0.0037185531,
0.0737523884,
0.0252336841,
0.0090070739,
0.0176440366,
0.0455240086,
-0.0313016437,
0.0505815893,
-0.0580324307,
-0.0004268138,
0.0505283102,
0.046326194,
-0.0139202243,
-0.0038534286,
0.0093310252,
-0.022953527,
-0.045959834,
0.0290960148,
0.0884719118,
-0.0003534482,
0.04106839,
0.0125716114,
-0.0291318018,
-0.0196902175,
-0.0450276136,
0.0662237927,
-0.0436416604,
-0.0219742954,
0.0333743878,
-0.0566344708,
0.0145465815,
0.0076173134,
-0.0401247181,
-0.0591244549,
0.0109502142,
0.0332161039,
0.0245897863,
-0.0354185365,
-0.0266561937,
-0.0367063358,
-0.0398261882,
-0.0157226417,
-0.0200162679,
-0.0729854628,
0.0031908271,
0.000558449,
-0.0937667191,
0.0140330577,
2.35482467e-34,
0.0324043594,
-0.0254848618,
0.0509217717,
-0.0152289001,
0.0029700471,
-0.0059169661,
0.0044901688,
0.0051177624,
0.0222127195,
-0.0893256441,
-0.0127809569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12546v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12546v2 | Automatic Answerability Evaluation for Question Generation | 2023-09-22T00:13:07 | 2024-02-26T04:39:08 | Zifan Wang, Kotaro Funakoshi, Manabu Okumura | cs.CL | cs.CL | Conventional automatic evaluation metrics, such as BLEU and ROUGE, developed
for natural language generation (NLG) tasks, are based on measuring the n-gram
overlap between the generated and reference text. These simple metrics may be
insufficient for more complex tasks, such as question generation (QG), which
requires generating questions that are answerable by the reference answers.
Developing a more sophisticated automatic evaluation metric, thus, remains an
urgent problem in QG research. This work proposes PMAN (Prompting-based Metric
on ANswerability), a novel automatic evaluation metric to assess whether the
generated questions are answerable by the reference answers for the QG tasks.
Extensive experiments demonstrate that its evaluation results are reliable and
align with human evaluations. We further apply our metric to evaluate the
performance of QG models, which shows that our metric complements conventional
metrics. Our implementation of a GPT-based QG model achieves state-of-the-art
performance in generating answerable questions. | [
0.0376797952,
-0.0153417643,
0.0029288058,
-0.0133907394,
-0.0565870181,
0.00902062,
-0.0035578995,
0.0137941977,
0.0116684735,
-0.0041230125,
0.0121231833,
-0.0559518151,
-0.0280287117,
0.0324340798,
0.0274931435,
-0.0368480831,
0.0113053238,
0.0136305783,
0.0070050098,
0.0133858006,
-0.0001185774,
0.0082318718,
-0.0297468528,
0.0424851365,
0.0140637169,
-0.0211787745,
-0.0201762579,
-0.005727049,
-0.0078253727,
-0.0230809506,
0.0004346015,
0.05770991,
-0.0451288857,
0.0058662076,
0.0000019874,
-0.090449661,
-0.0121977814,
0.0082570706,
-0.0086365081,
-0.0170357171,
0.0130106164,
0.0674322546,
0.0209405497,
0.0582161918,
-0.0608054735,
-0.0025812308,
0.0222495589,
0.0391232371,
0.0854640603,
0.0281657707,
-0.003286645,
0.0133329043,
0.0440119952,
0.0062253065,
0.0727424398,
-0.0259111896,
-0.0284957066,
0.0592165925,
0.0376483761,
-0.0070489496,
0.0078115673,
0.0223459005,
0.031052174,
-0.0265507437,
0.0229140073,
0.0150348218,
-0.014654207,
-0.0236984286,
-0.0007707995,
0.070084773,
0.0094839567,
-0.0149137368,
0.014300786,
-0.0130873062,
0.0243346319,
0.035614118,
-0.0318243504,
0.0135834208,
-0.0146811455,
-0.0301621053,
0.0030037963,
0.0378384553,
-0.0093092024,
-0.0095429551,
0.0359983929,
0.0546146445,
0.0478032306,
-0.0396814868,
-0.0236574579,
-0.0049400264,
-0.0379045866,
-0.0887256786,
0.0169530828,
0.041566588,
-0.0619629733,
0.0061203875,
-0.0195542648,
-0.0012613791,
0.0418356024,
0.023510145,
0.0179478843,
0.0384044945,
0.0148468316,
0.0089427633,
-0.0349674858,
0.0869115517,
-0.0221825689,
-0.0457575321,
-0.0799549371,
0.0092032477,
-0.0555052795,
-0.0158803351,
-0.0198297612,
0.0224281084,
-0.0178963486,
-0.0154887652,
-0.0356972292,
0.0326199941,
0.0163118578,
-0.0219230168,
0.0275706872,
0.0198387373,
-0.0401003845,
-0.0073976745,
-0.058629103,
-0.0113488957,
-0.0781671405,
0.0065687434,
0.0333686396,
-0.0453224331,
0.0082894219,
0.0259605758,
0.0494903587,
-0.0097393114,
0.0139799248,
0.0487876609,
-0.0303294975,
0.0000635383,
0.0007761216,
-0.0597113334,
-0.0049102078,
-0.0321165211,
-0.0276250485,
-0.0664187223,
0.0024624902,
0.0112093538,
-0.0443212278,
0.0333166048,
0.0197451245,
0.0708616674,
0.0190917738,
0.0133766429,
-0.006829171,
0.0435194969,
0.059315186,
0.01163573,
0.0065087806,
-0.0084123351,
0.0336885452,
0.0171444118,
0.04194526,
-0.0046439758,
0.0249157064,
-0.0131127583,
0.0197973382,
-0.0067902082,
0.0448443666,
0.0225106031,
0.0071508954,
0.0210712105,
-0.0329420008,
0.0617944971,
-0.0027931379,
-0.0000890427,
0.042504061,
0.0249627363,
-0.0030543902,
0.0034714213,
0.0684656203,
0.0234400332,
-0.0102748927,
0.0388209,
0.0040675928,
0.0628542006,
-0.0493303128,
0.0275793206,
0.0573307201,
0.0332519338,
-0.013014094,
-0.0351627357,
0.0238337964,
0.0377630666,
-0.0062449663,
0.0033029211,
-0.0067537464,
0.0419325531,
-0.0565020405,
0.0395060033,
-0.0237148404,
-0.0766775683,
0.0199824311,
-0.0442505516,
0.0831566975,
-0.0173227265,
0.0710774437,
0.0041702874,
-0.0391946845,
-0.0120093571,
-0.0084774662,
0.0385250635,
0.0221650526,
-0.0133978287,
-0.0092951292,
-0.0363680385,
0.0119125983,
-0.0140523901,
-0.0034957491,
-0.0060744188,
0.0172961354,
0.0254182909,
0.036826212,
-0.0667723492,
-0.0322225951,
0.0444559082,
-0.0066749337,
-0.0327571481,
0.0301683564,
-0.0132939015,
0.0066115265,
0.0388231836,
-0.003168223,
0.0554433875,
0.0087993266,
-0.0227227863,
-0.0270122942,
0.0083561707,
-0.0222824514,
-0.0227222927,
-0.000911959,
-0.0698081851,
0.0228277482,
0.0052530854,
0.0029256316,
-0.0722715855,
-0.0131156938,
-0.049148567,
-0.0319027491,
-0.0745252445,
-0.0161107108,
0.0020960076,
-0.0201901682,
-0.0522342436,
0.0691572577,
0.0200848263,
0.0485514142,
0.0360625945,
0.0298229568,
0.0573442355,
-0.0349552669,
-0.0294834953,
-0.0236023031,
-0.0437913612,
0.0147253405,
0.0548894592,
0.0607594848,
-0.0762010068,
-0.0503344685,
-0.0612857342,
0.053514611,
-0.0373662934,
0.0429615118,
0.0498158224,
0.0252390802,
-0.0240585618,
-0.0157041047,
-0.1121357158,
-0.0119759869,
0.062874727,
-0.0061205924,
0.0631831735,
0.0084523428,
0.0227887947,
-0.011673918,
0.0027323067,
0.0139746722,
0.0105366176,
0.0479451381,
0.0647123083,
-0.0406740233,
0.0151462182,
-0.0563503616,
-0.0390365385,
0.0442288592,
-0.0453669913,
0.0321388692,
-0.0116056018,
0.0350477248,
0.0163703822,
0.0436075702,
-0.0355835594,
0.013124017,
0.0057269544,
-0.0120507823,
0.0175032914,
-0.0536022708,
-0.0359644666,
0.0612629354,
-0.0771528482,
0.0309845209,
0.0397043303,
0.0370261148,
-0.0167131629,
-0.0587665364,
0.065970391,
-0.022718776,
-0.0117180003,
-0.0431841426,
0.0138666071,
-0.0194807742,
0.0577348247,
-0.0127639705,
-0.0537379943,
0.0531331226,
-0.0419890955,
-0.0158507731,
-0.0537232198,
-0.0025552844,
-0.0299471188,
0.0596059002,
0.0190531518,
0.0278536789,
0.0364912823,
-0.0237603914,
-0.0867800564,
0.0531948581,
0.019291237,
-0.0463809557,
0.015403579,
-0.0432319678,
-0.0124886772,
0.0101832496,
-0.0125383809,
-0.0543270595,
-0.0171976294,
0.040621154,
-0.0140254404,
-0.0132140918,
-0.0030546293,
0.0021786303,
0.0201115869,
0.0297048017,
0.0072254511,
-0.0276546553,
-0.0123063419,
-0.0264880508,
0.0964057371,
0.0683256909,
0.0479598604,
0.0286543723,
0.0217847843,
0.0128023196,
0.030417366,
0.0222420394,
0.0443985462,
0.0308603197,
0.0248190705,
-0.0209673475,
-0.0241365843,
-0.0151170325,
0.0532979034,
0.0583249256,
-0.0392408483,
-0.0678668544,
0.0755975544,
0.0683379769,
0.0125947194,
-0.0172500852,
-0.0218407661,
0.0537448749,
0.0126987612,
0.0547369532,
-0.0256027877,
-0.009304801,
-0.0225964654,
0.0364163704,
-0.0531509705,
-0.0399306044,
-0.0186911784,
-0.1068148166,
0.0271017719,
-0.0274182986,
-0.0268729199,
-0.0145147899,
0.0090455934,
-0.0096155517,
0.018730022,
-0.035464406,
0.0202352349,
0.0042925226,
0.0428298377,
0.0216888525,
-0.0307889488,
-0.0321901441,
0.0197461564,
-0.0162132867,
0.0331620686,
0.0768854246,
0.0264360663,
0.0047753816,
-0.0462315306,
-0.0554337762,
-0.0857513249,
-0.0189969707,
0.0219171792,
0.0099194003,
0.0349164233,
-0.0036665006,
-0.051780805,
0.0429352745,
-0.0255554095,
0.018510228,
0.0603913069,
0.0587534904,
-0.0084667839,
-0.0253154654,
-0.0201658718,
0.0396218598,
0.0136003792,
0.0788621455,
0.0528870896,
-0.0453967042,
-0.0147821251,
-0.0143145313,
0.0337287858,
-0.0849161148,
-0.0142662209,
0.0014138793,
0.007949301,
0.0106193293,
-0.1264055818,
-0.0290111098,
-0.0108393971,
0.0352829769,
-0.0061873766,
0.0003224064,
-0.0053617056,
0.0075381398,
-0.0420335494,
-0.0002817283,
0.0080733327,
-0.0089638876,
-0.0672186688,
-0.0053016036,
-0.0042057368,
-0.0473230407,
-0.039768789,
0.0139379911,
-0.0569468029,
-0.0157959871,
-0.0380130596,
0.0278574079,
0.0275362674,
-0.0688829646,
-0.034218397,
-0.0152329328,
0.0009369802,
0.0040532025,
-0.0155970845,
0.003456641,
-0.0408551469,
-0.0256138034,
-0.0146524673,
0.0090229539,
-0.0626472607,
0.0179046579,
-0.0388996117,
0.0640146732,
0.0103842849,
-0.0433373079,
0.0439053774,
0.0569533966,
-0.023047585,
-0.0068284888,
0.009927107,
-0.0283551477,
-0.0145641062,
0.0086244596,
-0.0076984009,
-0.0657861158,
0.0083051659,
0.0073708245,
-0.015524636,
0.0085453317,
-0.0348179936,
-0.0639022589,
0.0239973553,
-0.0011659174,
-0.02786557,
0.0158194844,
0.0503213555,
-0.0165962353,
-0.0300104972,
-0.0326635614,
-0.0473310016,
-0.0009837664,
0.0513789691,
0.0156605877,
0.0967997387,
0.0016578473,
-0.0048342901,
0.0448923446,
0.0425413959,
-0.0681812689,
-0.0236811303,
-0.0311050732,
0.0154249528,
0.0108917207,
0.027052531,
0.0128078591,
-0.0000124233,
0.0041521918,
-0.0082744481,
0.0447370969,
0.038250722,
-0.0348894894,
0.0296676494,
0.0031039526,
-0.0081337811,
-0.0103902025,
0.0538670085,
-0.0181397311,
-0.0156110795,
0.0004554079,
-0.0098904986,
-0.0384414755,
-0.0247439295,
-0.0378172658,
0.0061458605,
0.0064171767,
0.0340816863,
-0.0644491091,
-0.0352566093,
-0.006543397,
0.0457470901,
0.021835167,
0.0020138423,
0.0513275042,
0.0652221218,
-0.0127500845,
-0.0162525456,
-0.0543446392,
0.0231548268,
-0.1060301214,
0.0123262946,
-0.0034477459,
-6.279339477e-33,
-0.0365123153,
-0.0972372964,
0.0130735599,
-0.0274476912,
-0.0151805012,
-0.0038499301,
-0.0636843517,
0.006625229,
0.0018304113,
0.0041952836,
0.0065782866,
-0.0193196926,
-0.0085827541,
0.0075875763,
0.0071519315,
-0.039144855,
0.0140922973,
-0.0080242464,
-0.0512415841,
0.0668338388,
0.0233186055,
-0.0114708692,
-0.0314712077,
0.0115554705,
0.0310196839,
-0.0455948338,
-0.0071374429,
0.0043534497,
-0.0108855786,
0.0683631152,
-0.027154332,
0.0260527078,
0.0490395986,
-0.0239294488,
0.0018639378,
0.0641425923,
-0.0039032882,
-0.0722010359,
-0.0095321033,
-0.0556974337,
-0.0763678923,
-0.0015882582,
0.0027334713,
-0.0193268415,
0.0099916607,
0.0171602257,
0.0272246078,
0.0043189479,
0.019339988,
-0.0211340804,
-0.015734233,
0.0124532701,
-0.0120933941,
-0.0360539965,
-0.0460414961,
0.092121087,
-0.0011797496,
-0.0260343943,
0.0165347829,
-0.0031804398,
0.021073442,
0.0204257499,
0.0546629876,
-0.0032253969,
-0.0264414549,
0.0287503954,
0.0134900603,
-0.0275871176,
0.0059407186,
0.017858183,
-0.0271256566,
0.0189934541,
0.0991624296,
0.0613671355,
0.0296656713,
0.0450268276,
-0.0362149663,
0.0987210721,
0.0086893048,
-0.0008000507,
0.0145504186,
-0.0532537214,
-0.0071287081,
0.0004794931,
-0.0554437079,
0.0101110842,
-0.0591089949,
-0.0455376059,
0.068115361,
-0.026141014,
-0.0345394462,
-0.0351098105,
0.0167671032,
0.0232056174,
0.0383776017,
-0.0012522842,
-0.0295928288,
0.0227257404,
-0.0097617023,
0.0226243995,
-0.0316163041,
0.0441120639,
0.0315966234,
0.0227958802,
0.0115778372,
0.0169544406,
-0.0305207465,
-0.0156414863,
-0.0499850363,
0.0207368731,
-0.0316126682,
0.0461144038,
-0.0224295817,
-0.0349188931,
-0.0107793752,
-0.0210944582,
-0.0119156362,
0.0143009089,
-0.0012770081,
-0.014451623,
-0.0398701429,
-0.0252796542,
0.0124368872,
0.0235834066,
-0.045317851,
0.0343599617,
-0.0287163034,
0.0368514284,
-0.0178301204,
-0.0276898779,
-0.0125470841,
0.0120084397,
2.655e-7,
0.035328351,
0.0174548905,
0.0258556325,
0.0451837853,
-0.0032188762,
0.0226201992,
0.0112775546,
0.0275958292,
0.033012554,
-0.0154332509,
-0.0004842413,
-0.0406316034,
0.015399171,
0.021579193,
-0.0640728921,
0.0045439671,
-0.0588255785,
0.0141360397,
-0.0277296528,
0.0006671313,
0.0971713737,
0.0079223411,
-0.0280595776,
-0.0032877114,
0.0073583922,
-0.0397743545,
0.0285530128,
-0.0013072438,
-0.0019550445,
0.0443837605,
0.0710670352,
0.0376372896,
0.0200447682,
0.0274637062,
-0.0197553467,
0.010706014,
0.0620158911,
0.0044020163,
0.0462638959,
-0.0265349448,
-0.0097391605,
-0.0057444377,
0.0398516394,
-0.1014537215,
0.0574647672,
-0.0284649841,
-0.0174529646,
-0.0021517116,
-0.0259799808,
-0.0353315398,
0.0093321353,
-0.0297595486,
-0.0388121717,
-0.0195251331,
-0.0015399868,
0.0176878553,
0.0229151491,
-0.0003176596,
-0.0181092862,
0.0149186682,
-0.0119691901,
-0.0328748301,
-0.0584359542,
0.0001012527,
-0.025879778,
-0.0486363843,
-0.0222047027,
2.371540338e-34,
-0.0082952632,
-0.0123557877,
0.0293182954,
-0.0173432399,
0.0198287163,
-0.0001144698,
-0.0142118949,
-0.0124538988,
0.0154102631,
-0.0878886133,
-0.0243309122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13086v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13086v1 | Towards Lexical Analysis of Dog Vocalizations via Online Videos | 2023-09-21T23:53:14 | 2023-09-21T23:53:14 | Yufei Wang, Chunhao Zhang, Jieyi Huang, Mengyue Wu, Kenny Zhu | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Deciphering the semantics of animal language has been a grand challenge. This
study presents a data-driven investigation into the semantics of dog
vocalizations via correlating different sound types with consistent semantics.
We first present a new dataset of Shiba Inu sounds, along with contextual
information such as location and activity, collected from YouTube with a
well-constructed pipeline. The framework is also applicable to other animal
species. Based on the analysis of conditioned probability between dog
vocalizations and corresponding location and activity, we discover supporting
evidence for previous heuristic research on the semantic meaning of various dog
sounds. For instance, growls can signify interactions. Furthermore, our study
yields new insights that existing word types can be subdivided into
finer-grained subtypes and minimal semantic unit for Shiba Inu is word-related.
For example, whimper can be subdivided into two types, attention-seeking and
discomfort. | [
0.0232544057,
0.0574328117,
-0.025950091,
-0.0065820003,
0.0092723789,
0.0315047875,
-0.0064102793,
0.0300047435,
-0.0632282645,
-0.0722010508,
-0.0476934835,
0.0037839762,
0.0227573551,
0.0057125883,
0.0424611643,
-0.0741067007,
0.0361793563,
-0.001298788,
0.0492647402,
0.0104021709,
0.014181206,
0.0313012898,
-0.0458039418,
0.0479067601,
-0.0852329135,
0.0269847941,
-0.0276420526,
0.004078879,
0.0288215727,
-0.0654966906,
-0.0326265618,
0.0038375084,
0.0411165319,
0.0215889812,
0.0000016301,
-0.0647597015,
0.0320546329,
-0.0013220229,
0.0392974168,
-0.0417371318,
0.0056277122,
-0.0603325292,
-0.0208551586,
0.0094346674,
-0.033926487,
0.0078132106,
0.0633094087,
0.0082571413,
-0.0181387682,
0.0656027868,
-0.0178503357,
-0.0904655382,
0.0053643626,
-0.014270951,
0.0604917221,
-0.0240798742,
0.0204088688,
0.0076223444,
0.0031729699,
-0.0628494844,
-0.0421618521,
-0.0042730649,
-0.0185263101,
-0.0088598961,
-0.022711169,
0.030436296,
-0.0532589518,
-0.0958499312,
-0.0016920035,
0.0165400747,
0.0181155987,
0.0148708867,
0.0094267754,
0.015084954,
-0.0036966344,
-0.0111431731,
-0.0167174507,
0.0470735468,
-0.0013506225,
0.0248244349,
-0.0096737659,
0.0422188453,
0.0068382523,
0.0045040906,
-0.0007497791,
0.0816773847,
0.0113614537,
-0.0068519227,
-0.0163546316,
-0.0167023018,
0.0251492318,
-0.0309345927,
0.0234981906,
0.0121485041,
-0.0286095161,
0.0028446878,
-0.0124740927,
-0.0180749185,
0.0106361946,
-0.0330526717,
0.0163462441,
-0.0263689831,
-0.0339529887,
0.0165905971,
0.0138633689,
-0.0217822511,
-0.000393148,
-0.0075391363,
-0.0275185965,
0.0236774236,
-0.046766758,
0.0051948521,
-0.0055626789,
-0.0233503059,
0.015347058,
-0.0251798071,
-0.0008055951,
0.0125730308,
-0.035391748,
-0.0067607593,
-0.0628950745,
-0.0020317021,
-0.0237345304,
0.0280855335,
0.0103156455,
-0.0182950236,
-0.0714647695,
0.1067963317,
-0.0402706452,
-0.0676609874,
0.0323600508,
-0.0031368504,
0.0242361464,
-0.0025102077,
0.0390412845,
0.0261943154,
0.0282813329,
-0.0235045925,
-0.0116494596,
0.0232222546,
-0.05714738,
-0.0263630468,
-0.0491282605,
-0.0674672201,
0.005937296,
-0.0094688972,
0.0246537421,
0.0081879972,
-0.0301485248,
-0.0283162557,
-0.0113884201,
0.101714924,
-0.0014535383,
0.0454325713,
0.0195568949,
-0.0138554173,
0.0253452361,
0.031980224,
0.0395740755,
-0.0144907618,
0.0553039052,
-0.0317497626,
-0.0217363425,
-0.0083814124,
-0.0238885507,
-0.0313630514,
-0.0402757637,
-0.0124710444,
0.010129543,
-0.0185418781,
0.0110597396,
0.0653754249,
0.0078597693,
-0.0050014928,
0.0472869836,
0.0909348801,
-0.0127085056,
-0.0488590933,
0.0344102904,
0.0527952872,
0.0082703494,
0.020748267,
-0.0025027881,
-0.0323040448,
-0.0400560275,
-0.0402053557,
0.0475210361,
0.0344547406,
-0.0601612814,
0.0017583974,
-0.0467355847,
-0.0148024783,
0.0434525423,
0.0089116311,
0.0669244006,
0.0310443193,
0.0023812777,
0.0046465402,
0.0258175265,
-0.0177807547,
-0.0051351343,
0.0087612187,
0.0795571506,
0.0049512284,
-0.0116562443,
-0.0044793095,
0.0189088546,
-0.0062221074,
0.0316708162,
0.0229992736,
0.0028330605,
-0.0340783447,
0.0036542336,
0.0038087568,
0.0086880671,
0.0081968792,
0.0405760333,
-0.0139787011,
-0.0080785202,
0.0432831794,
-0.0042349505,
-0.0446003638,
0.0004436652,
0.061289344,
0.0392831489,
-0.0135119362,
-0.0017173194,
0.0091125192,
0.0485944562,
0.0307922456,
-0.044793997,
0.009883997,
0.0347975641,
0.003280499,
0.0431133695,
0.0734623894,
0.0205606222,
0.0069322619,
0.0587839559,
-0.038804628,
-0.0166464448,
0.0098331589,
0.001937281,
-0.0066092145,
0.0562552512,
-0.0594093576,
0.0686848834,
-0.0288917255,
0.010849393,
-0.0379609503,
0.0260486212,
-0.0012052592,
-0.0224556625,
0.0380218923,
0.0215115454,
-0.0545095839,
0.0377786495,
0.0203644987,
-0.0354580171,
-0.0479052104,
0.0100613898,
-0.0344594046,
-0.0258905496,
0.0272947587,
-0.0243546292,
-0.0686163306,
-0.0295259543,
-0.0760780498,
-0.0179791134,
0.0028773542,
0.0465193167,
-0.0090629756,
-0.0384422839,
-0.0061819884,
-0.0203188341,
-0.0014505421,
-0.0020024283,
-0.0397040583,
0.0582216233,
-0.019574292,
-0.0117352689,
-0.0538730845,
0.0061937259,
-0.0188069567,
-0.0245848522,
-0.0384693518,
0.0003807769,
-0.0139271263,
0.0066836504,
-0.0013366862,
-0.0529751703,
0.0056706788,
-0.003609559,
-0.0354938731,
0.0693641677,
0.0149409771,
0.021439109,
0.0054760375,
0.0678185076,
0.0614588521,
0.0456939004,
-0.0042597377,
-0.0015543506,
-0.0258329213,
-0.0432215966,
-0.0461998992,
-0.0835323408,
0.00365293,
-0.0400277637,
0.0214737002,
0.0032047245,
-0.0004361772,
-0.0288069192,
0.0320667773,
0.004613108,
-0.0696747229,
-0.0455093905,
-0.024263531,
-0.0348198675,
0.0560457781,
0.0197512191,
-0.0637026578,
0.048369348,
-0.0094907777,
-0.0273449942,
0.0158823412,
-0.0487426817,
-0.004598313,
0.111993365,
-0.0136538893,
0.0096579855,
0.0091533288,
-0.0229843501,
-0.0332780369,
-0.0355551839,
0.0043895417,
-0.0111987107,
-0.0151822092,
-0.0155604724,
0.0192670673,
0.0110825272,
0.0033299818,
-0.0424493775,
0.0142975273,
-0.044092156,
-0.0321907401,
-0.0587082915,
-0.0393058062,
0.0029859412,
0.0206898991,
0.0200105011,
-0.0257034395,
0.0166017991,
0.0015518207,
0.0060086865,
0.0221664701,
0.0799271092,
0.0212719291,
-0.0043051667,
-0.0016649755,
0.0193298962,
0.0247232616,
0.0549573191,
0.040374659,
-0.0087394211,
0.0177057572,
0.0264387112,
0.0020104784,
0.0030790912,
0.0351086706,
-0.0043353452,
-0.0102154333,
0.0013406208,
0.0959217846,
0.0306176245,
-0.0226495955,
0.0702058151,
0.0118015129,
0.0058823563,
0.0219291952,
0.0015878294,
-0.0604639202,
-0.0141363339,
0.0480721071,
0.0217080433,
0.018211931,
0.0444077365,
0.0012697518,
-0.0782692134,
0.0309855137,
-0.0112367822,
-0.0562411509,
-0.0181533825,
-0.0423169099,
0.0235582367,
-0.0462910719,
-0.0480369516,
-0.010871971,
0.0091726622,
0.0047166832,
0.0250127017,
0.0055802483,
-0.0659504905,
0.0134804985,
-0.0389097184,
0.0602381155,
0.0164302681,
0.0535492525,
-0.0349763595,
-0.0742880777,
0.0029292791,
-0.0246460643,
-0.0459363312,
-0.0060457867,
0.0348803848,
-0.0117719555,
-0.0175435208,
0.0290135797,
0.0260999445,
-0.0227274932,
-0.0003800154,
-0.0059145861,
0.0445735119,
-0.0543558151,
-0.0322792754,
-0.0393569507,
-0.0064070746,
0.0323634371,
0.1031303406,
-0.0190792046,
-0.0563501455,
0.0153656043,
0.036012616,
-0.0460195355,
0.0406466387,
-0.0296123531,
-0.0039160377,
-0.0191044882,
-0.109636575,
-0.0441695005,
-0.0315624177,
0.0015565563,
0.0027880359,
0.0309263412,
-0.004564072,
0.0230833087,
0.01497621,
-0.0802514628,
0.0755674392,
0.0647955015,
0.0326386169,
-0.0206786226,
-0.0548107512,
0.0627562478,
-0.0069049872,
-0.0101755476,
0.0272906255,
-0.0138716325,
-0.0736021101,
0.0252449233,
0.0097875185,
0.0182060264,
0.028189633,
0.0066078687,
0.0316283815,
0.0011730279,
0.0059818164,
0.022423476,
0.0445278473,
0.0158778094,
-0.0008759351,
0.0147399427,
0.0199293438,
-0.0132145388,
0.0557868257,
-0.0503935218,
0.0018742696,
-0.014149379,
-0.058026839,
-0.0062342659,
-0.0462699272,
0.0204281397,
-0.0338383168,
-0.0648660436,
-0.0393995047,
-0.0057647722,
0.016077593,
0.0271430761,
-0.0391647965,
-0.0163164195,
0.034740936,
0.0646036565,
-0.0287443791,
-0.0191939157,
-0.029916646,
-0.0149156936,
-0.0120716421,
0.0119768651,
0.0428339206,
-0.0155298673,
-0.0113956323,
0.0134632802,
0.0390233733,
0.0462000929,
-0.030542979,
0.0117106661,
0.0142241642,
-0.0224998556,
0.0193236433,
0.0056388099,
0.0262719858,
0.0510543175,
0.001337664,
-0.0160126388,
0.0240092035,
-0.0193493012,
0.0155229187,
-0.0410072468,
0.0545703918,
-0.0334227756,
0.0057551125,
-0.0390213467,
0.0138772521,
-0.0278555565,
-0.070801191,
-0.0116757341,
0.0035724221,
-0.0802344903,
0.0264727995,
0.0454349443,
-0.0584678948,
0.0838693157,
-0.0306064468,
0.025027765,
0.0228182841,
0.0061715236,
0.0351331718,
0.0514970683,
-0.014337928,
0.0148103824,
-0.0574397556,
-0.077994056,
-0.0389614217,
-0.0416584983,
0.0068438509,
0.0218452271,
0.0796047673,
0.0244896971,
-0.0057312613,
0.0453260131,
-0.0180830639,
-0.0804228038,
-0.0448364243,
-0.0239059664,
0.0031983212,
-5.275201713e-33,
-0.0109397462,
-0.0628996044,
-0.0316321664,
0.0314589143,
-0.0039612283,
0.0129899867,
-0.0391069464,
-0.0005290971,
-0.0310845599,
0.0217218976,
0.0150713949,
0.0296055898,
0.0068984181,
0.0170034319,
0.067677319,
0.0304002501,
0.0016834346,
-0.0392267182,
0.0087504564,
-0.0376172252,
0.0939711034,
0.0447655395,
0.0499337427,
-0.0986321121,
-0.0079273144,
0.0507590957,
-0.0626104549,
-0.0330016464,
0.0265622754,
0.0432035737,
-0.0530863404,
0.0386207439,
0.021575883,
0.0287976451,
-0.0135498177,
0.0243151598,
-0.0848016143,
0.0015876794,
0.0437984243,
0.0112530161,
-0.0124320928,
0.0385989174,
0.0090099294,
-0.0280803498,
-0.0489100069,
0.0235406309,
0.0174934268,
-0.0315388553,
0.0538316891,
-0.0178600736,
-0.1227156594,
0.0046729622,
-0.0369804315,
-0.0368981212,
0.0490781143,
0.0068750284,
0.0021973155,
-0.005506285,
-0.0186491553,
0.0767690986,
0.0215367619,
0.0568325482,
0.061562743,
0.0003753636,
0.0293520894,
0.0564058051,
0.0567480773,
-0.0665921792,
0.0241019893,
-0.0121966563,
0.0306210443,
0.0597549193,
-0.0099052954,
-0.0282502882,
0.0301587395,
-0.0551472194,
-0.0064154705,
-0.001504714,
0.069397755,
0.0070188818,
-0.021917453,
0.0616886392,
0.0076160822,
0.0118660443,
-0.0166710597,
-0.003945753,
0.0043464648,
-0.0290169884,
0.0313626267,
-0.005818774,
0.0202485174,
0.0388378687,
0.0303230193,
-0.0157414619,
-0.0109204045,
-0.0079839788,
-0.0055863219,
0.0130822472,
0.0324415118,
-0.0239345301,
-0.0140419239,
-0.0487289764,
0.0824947283,
0.0214327406,
0.0436973311,
0.0104726963,
0.0158165023,
0.0199685395,
-0.020819407,
0.0207307748,
0.0258725937,
-0.030773988,
0.0193752274,
0.0301634353,
0.0549222715,
0.0080691623,
-0.0249076877,
-0.027610423,
0.0135757504,
0.0350945629,
-0.0265121758,
0.0067485799,
-0.0853878334,
0.0364585891,
-0.0170565173,
-0.0035306984,
-0.0364145748,
-0.007085172,
0.0295527782,
-0.0029295727,
-0.0125697609,
-0.0243627075,
2.795e-7,
0.0117812334,
0.0382258445,
0.0242453553,
0.0435244888,
0.0764139295,
0.0441082343,
-0.0092164306,
0.0084258635,
-0.0309302043,
-0.0344673507,
0.0152588878,
-0.0235871878,
0.0663119853,
0.029602915,
-0.0272543281,
-0.0315895416,
-0.0496960133,
-0.0069227922,
-0.0422418192,
0.0034733743,
-0.0084651783,
0.1100589633,
0.0228790697,
-0.0251181759,
0.0228602532,
-0.0580284968,
-0.0198593605,
-0.0082006995,
0.0275045149,
-0.0002032052,
-0.0100390771,
-0.0406098329,
0.0000366765,
-0.0068089976,
-0.0246125087,
-0.0087728063,
0.0102792578,
-0.0060956739,
-0.0418301784,
-0.0430719219,
-0.0395586565,
0.0455633923,
-0.0367430113,
-0.0513726175,
0.067431964,
0.0255445614,
-0.0706971884,
-0.0085689975,
0.0351625197,
-0.0033982387,
0.0255002305,
-0.0175501686,
0.0389243998,
0.0038801569,
-0.0079747103,
0.0061583598,
-0.0272910595,
-0.062842384,
0.0139106512,
-0.0065708528,
-0.0665033087,
-0.0516737998,
0.0119110774,
0.0334120803,
0.0243262332,
-0.0459593982,
-0.0507728457,
1.482426487e-34,
-0.0095983399,
0.0222738851,
0.0249802042,
0.0231809337,
-0.0104359258,
0.0043513426,
-0.0200185906,
-0.0041834479,
0.0290825274,
-0.0259996913,
-0.026886614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12501v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12501v1 | Knowledge Graph Embedding: An Overview | 2023-09-21T21:52:42 | 2023-09-21T21:52:42 | Xiou Ge, Yun-Cheng Wang, Bin Wang, C. -C. Jay Kuo | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Many mathematical models have been leveraged to design embeddings for
representing Knowledge Graph (KG) entities and relations for link prediction
and many downstream tasks. These mathematically-inspired models are not only
highly scalable for inference in large KGs, but also have many explainable
advantages in modeling different relation patterns that can be validated
through both formal proofs and empirical results. In this paper, we make a
comprehensive overview of the current state of research in KG completion. In
particular, we focus on two main branches of KG embedding (KGE) design: 1)
distance-based methods and 2) semantic matching-based methods. We discover the
connections between recently proposed models and present an underlying trend
that might help researchers invent novel and more effective models. Next, we
delve into CompoundE and CompoundE3D, which draw inspiration from 2D and 3D
affine operations, respectively. They encompass a broad spectrum of techniques
including distance-based and semantic-based methods. We will also discuss an
emerging approach for KG completion which leverages pre-trained language models
(PLMs) and textual descriptions of entities and relations and offer insights
into the integration of KGE embedding methods with PLMs for KG completion. | [
0.0391982235,
0.0280737393,
-0.0049061156,
0.0550779253,
0.009025746,
-0.005697872,
-0.0425724387,
0.0072786678,
0.0688558146,
-0.0519873761,
0.032635726,
0.0325510204,
-0.0023487355,
0.0155347986,
0.0555304512,
-0.0318747386,
-0.0116972718,
0.00483474,
-0.017860746,
-0.0303643327,
-0.0128508545,
0.0449845418,
0.0107842414,
0.0176404957,
-0.0399787687,
-0.0039317086,
0.0069761705,
-0.0134288929,
0.0044702953,
-0.0064906199,
-0.0140169701,
0.0189284571,
0.0407704823,
-0.0415302441,
0.0000021359,
-0.0096567711,
0.0009256009,
-0.0057567586,
-0.0034322185,
-0.0196934398,
-0.035239514,
-0.049672313,
0.0756775513,
-0.0173014812,
-0.0486000068,
-0.0461402833,
0.0395576544,
0.0422996581,
0.0102731548,
0.0384194069,
-0.0391316377,
-0.0509468839,
0.0536651984,
-0.0270522479,
0.0067541758,
-0.0192004722,
0.040992979,
0.0333413556,
-0.0065131937,
0.0647586435,
-0.0312319677,
0.0387740433,
0.0103221638,
0.0149106868,
0.1022884771,
0.0446631312,
0.0028011536,
0.0244622622,
0.0100984946,
0.1220882908,
-0.0042610588,
0.0177869033,
0.0111101447,
0.0051062233,
-0.0171985291,
0.0618515685,
-0.0099333972,
-0.0498015471,
0.0183602981,
-0.0084884232,
-0.043986287,
0.0002497393,
0.0503276885,
-0.0016960618,
-0.0175518598,
0.0355431437,
0.0162974596,
-0.0317200124,
-0.0095149241,
0.0309923496,
0.0068459981,
-0.0311604477,
-0.017752558,
0.0121547533,
0.0242140163,
0.0326017626,
-0.0319517441,
0.0409924611,
-0.0187123846,
-0.0412185043,
0.014737349,
0.036035303,
0.0024351154,
0.0663935989,
-0.1051152274,
0.0186009929,
-0.0058407886,
0.0096269278,
-0.0603088737,
-0.0068757092,
-0.0181362424,
0.0087137856,
-0.0300523732,
0.0319528356,
-0.0088523356,
-0.0275445152,
-0.0207375325,
0.0545976982,
-0.0578210875,
0.0799821168,
-0.0023172908,
0.0217625126,
0.0325979181,
-0.0294464529,
-0.0373969004,
0.0055879862,
-0.0517177954,
0.019201044,
-0.0696260631,
0.047860574,
0.0045479331,
-0.0132102789,
0.0177456718,
-0.0439628214,
0.0191211011,
0.084495157,
0.0240522325,
-0.0416613892,
0.028230438,
-0.0663638711,
0.0024832645,
-0.0213755127,
0.05325111,
-0.0490339361,
0.092068471,
0.0137851881,
-0.0267657805,
-0.0479936562,
0.0129041299,
-0.0305812713,
-0.0853689015,
0.0621181875,
-0.0215268396,
0.0055018952,
-0.0227159634,
-0.0002232455,
-0.0089918524,
0.0228114091,
0.0056932829,
0.006464242,
0.0409522466,
-0.0112271626,
-0.0562929362,
0.0234519541,
0.0642865822,
0.0020909428,
0.0024304788,
0.0139870225,
0.0412333645,
0.0695283413,
0.0190602094,
0.0148918685,
-0.0529078245,
-0.0284673851,
0.018728083,
0.0520193018,
-0.0057864455,
0.0151741123,
0.0561872981,
-0.0141344862,
-0.0044183419,
-0.0079279859,
-0.0385491326,
0.0042744605,
-0.0253630094,
0.0133556603,
0.0198573917,
0.0429546051,
-0.0330538452,
-0.0107096517,
0.0177488327,
-0.0346728601,
0.0481783077,
0.008859612,
0.062523596,
0.0031973619,
-0.0257259049,
0.0508874804,
0.0180587023,
-0.0063121547,
0.0163478665,
0.0418522321,
-0.0111930259,
0.0511694029,
0.0546236672,
-0.0172176044,
-0.0329225026,
-0.0069640051,
-0.0170971565,
-0.0299145728,
0.0211902596,
-0.0394377224,
-0.0247077718,
-0.0323339999,
-0.086227797,
0.0186878741,
-0.0171018224,
0.0203052349,
0.05833501,
0.0218251254,
0.0562865958,
-0.0857226402,
0.0471610352,
0.0133171836,
-0.0385385826,
0.0100211594,
0.0047194245,
0.0583721697,
0.0045266636,
0.0279010683,
0.0498232879,
-0.0131979445,
0.0540933274,
-0.0362606086,
-0.0294192396,
0.0063903965,
-0.0057008932,
-0.0559215881,
0.0539350621,
-0.0082987482,
0.0157832317,
-0.0382254869,
-0.0313251801,
-0.0390771814,
0.035093911,
-0.0076662465,
0.0939205214,
-0.007527682,
-0.0222591162,
0.0229944028,
-0.0223722253,
-0.0144642796,
0.0677265599,
-0.014037923,
0.0079258233,
-0.0207927004,
-0.031679932,
0.0051395618,
0.0316750407,
-0.0525461361,
-0.0274203215,
0.0319593437,
0.008441641,
0.0101564778,
-0.0411477797,
-0.0174559895,
-0.0009567524,
-0.0425311886,
-0.0361123048,
0.0359971896,
-0.0127109457,
-0.0276146103,
-0.0052074036,
0.0250941962,
-0.0251211114,
-0.0001934189,
0.0301154628,
-0.0349279232,
0.0156213921,
0.027175298,
-0.0059757535,
-0.0288148094,
0.0071568377,
-0.044249583,
-0.0226042606,
0.0868152454,
0.0015266428,
-0.0053450218,
-0.0018581445,
0.0279821213,
-0.0903405249,
0.0232584998,
-0.0289464127,
0.0295776092,
-0.0137598496,
-0.0392557904,
0.032716956,
0.0016013699,
-0.0489796586,
-0.0031181981,
0.0254333243,
0.0135683268,
-0.0481486619,
-0.0009982031,
-0.0713843554,
0.027685741,
-0.0215768851,
0.023973817,
-0.0278297085,
0.0187106617,
-0.0143841887,
-0.0394659936,
-0.0775663108,
-0.0072488706,
0.0417816155,
0.0289279781,
-0.036664214,
-0.0102896551,
0.045233652,
-0.000124779,
-0.016960606,
0.0021983203,
0.068246305,
-0.0125417896,
0.0383485481,
0.0369942077,
0.0332945809,
-0.029339917,
0.0676760748,
0.0168875679,
0.020731153,
0.0018341641,
0.0217977576,
-0.027739536,
0.0023382469,
0.0289671477,
-0.0148986485,
0.0101632653,
0.0018219425,
0.0161528662,
0.0419995524,
-0.0048008058,
-0.0113518322,
-0.0083056912,
-0.0378340781,
0.0198531039,
-0.009480373,
-0.0134084318,
0.0131285265,
0.0285162739,
-0.0214496516,
-0.0205289498,
0.0198261421,
-0.0236701686,
-0.0499689095,
0.0357541628,
0.0418017954,
-0.0205722284,
-0.0190830193,
0.0241211895,
-0.023873277,
0.0406905003,
-0.0024092076,
-0.0020801651,
-0.0219829716,
0.0291305669,
0.0303854048,
-0.0204510726,
-0.0464193188,
-0.0061529935,
-0.022055909,
-0.0001844255,
0.0349066816,
0.0858555362,
0.0192236677,
-0.0279368721,
0.0065085897,
0.0344296359,
0.0188964624,
0.0333105847,
-0.0037690392,
-0.1094726473,
-0.0012487998,
-0.0267849006,
-0.0353360251,
0.0564563237,
-0.0747259408,
0.0283680167,
-0.0903829038,
-0.0159951821,
0.0282760635,
0.0057207732,
-0.0724189579,
-0.0468076393,
0.0112724081,
0.0058065443,
-0.0880215093,
-0.050181333,
-0.0126579851,
0.0172690041,
-0.0110145174,
-0.0089286631,
-0.0816530138,
0.0328213163,
-0.0624101162,
0.0425376184,
-0.0128557868,
0.0467294604,
-0.0030738465,
-0.0569992401,
-0.0398601592,
0.0463396832,
-0.0395510793,
0.0065601664,
0.03007189,
-0.0474679135,
0.0008936509,
-0.0036241696,
-0.0234387312,
-0.0606270023,
-0.0213780962,
-0.0242301542,
0.1445314437,
-0.0023970881,
-0.0107709486,
-0.0094412006,
-0.0082030278,
0.0083906762,
0.0645569786,
-0.0235870723,
0.0166630708,
0.0110056978,
-0.0026385628,
0.0671015531,
0.0300579891,
0.0172988959,
-0.0000343807,
-0.0338278152,
0.0599860474,
-0.0346125029,
-0.0223825965,
0.0733777359,
0.0115970774,
0.0164983664,
-0.0081104618,
0.0334599689,
-0.0396835171,
-0.0664847493,
0.0048401728,
-0.0176408552,
0.0196789019,
0.0265025869,
0.0205771197,
-0.0140669206,
-0.0491038039,
-0.0359182917,
-0.0290700234,
-0.0454829857,
-0.0142699946,
-0.0731371194,
0.0351775363,
-0.0013001147,
0.0539101586,
-0.0200932827,
-0.0206561871,
0.0395763256,
0.012975703,
-0.0587402843,
0.0200630315,
0.0142020499,
-0.0227356628,
-0.0017938057,
0.031321384,
-0.0462059677,
0.0018101707,
-0.0042031514,
0.0328630283,
-0.0586028621,
-0.0927066207,
-0.0268609989,
0.0110178199,
0.0178876873,
0.0091178892,
0.0223186333,
-0.0550710857,
0.0017769238,
-0.0379191749,
0.0047901575,
-0.0583918169,
-0.0101008024,
0.0357284471,
0.0109002069,
0.0199081991,
-0.0404493734,
0.0081905788,
0.0395114273,
-0.0103295743,
-0.0361748822,
0.0196722485,
-0.0436389148,
0.0522460341,
0.0067892633,
-0.0078418562,
0.0089273034,
-0.029329801,
0.0013554125,
-0.0617290325,
-0.0106147118,
-0.0066519021,
-0.0094595607,
-0.0465864167,
0.0142784314,
-0.0180011913,
-0.0253840704,
-0.0234122518,
0.0149650779,
0.0517754741,
-0.0180529989,
0.0072811851,
-0.0459911637,
-0.029690763,
0.0178477243,
0.0384996198,
-0.0252809972,
-0.0338777453,
0.0394435376,
0.0193873476,
-0.0159069207,
0.0124087129,
0.0305268355,
0.0217401292,
0.0342510194,
-0.0205635298,
-0.0602668971,
-0.0226107799,
-0.0265805889,
0.0142256431,
0.0622781552,
-0.0166548304,
0.0326462835,
-0.052118808,
-0.0912277773,
0.0131855123,
-0.0234453809,
-0.0941691771,
0.024445178,
0.0326146819,
0.0354427397,
0.0149307856,
-0.0255312044,
-0.0273139905,
0.0049306294,
-0.0402690023,
-0.0252474751,
0.0059151552,
-5.818470754e-33,
-0.0189031772,
-0.0034741077,
0.0284766238,
-0.0137075596,
-0.0422776565,
0.0348622836,
0.0069758128,
-0.0336419567,
-0.0314264745,
0.01495561,
0.0028840487,
-0.0275211353,
-0.0347476192,
-0.0019812437,
-0.0072915535,
0.0153721925,
0.0076912981,
-0.0080614295,
0.0292169526,
0.0168274902,
0.0049880454,
0.0123401005,
0.0491131209,
-0.0769927502,
0.0301090404,
-0.0227779038,
0.0119785471,
0.0079175159,
0.0267706439,
0.0654563978,
-0.057166744,
0.0341500677,
0.0208528806,
0.0189154875,
-0.0006426723,
-0.0091869924,
-0.1266941726,
-0.0382552296,
-0.0047877324,
-0.0134700257,
-0.0381365716,
0.0062778881,
0.0339580961,
-0.0063877893,
0.041165188,
-0.0826895535,
0.0486821495,
-0.009565657,
-0.0782184452,
-0.0144617902,
-0.0093557015,
0.0165434498,
0.0017392816,
-0.0022969251,
0.05677839,
-0.0068609421,
0.0697898045,
-0.0418571606,
-0.0567404851,
0.0161421467,
-0.0308642127,
-0.009016227,
0.0070457454,
0.0097825686,
0.0189361367,
0.0490185767,
-0.0037458832,
-0.0129023949,
-0.0274497401,
0.0243593436,
0.0096005807,
0.0338027328,
-0.0206497107,
0.0302436333,
-0.0293248184,
-0.0189430527,
-0.0500975139,
0.0124306949,
-0.0376282372,
0.0322415158,
-0.0061062537,
-0.022983266,
-0.0327453278,
-0.0522153452,
-0.0590358078,
-0.0048917374,
-0.0016044122,
-0.0384150222,
-0.008781773,
0.0207206085,
-0.0027035067,
0.0456512719,
-0.0089056203,
-0.0630485862,
-0.0280552879,
0.066912137,
-0.0079593239,
0.0130782509,
0.0164792296,
0.0360896923,
-0.0507496111,
-0.0404871851,
0.0015869266,
-0.0502360389,
0.0014496956,
0.0092523359,
0.0156892948,
0.0154632302,
-0.0236850753,
-0.0153146433,
-0.0174117424,
-0.0808329955,
0.0194927733,
0.0030477082,
0.0527645648,
0.0660777837,
0.0125385672,
0.0186782349,
0.0362240486,
0.0014410589,
0.0067595006,
0.016848037,
0.0304813329,
0.01788182,
0.0131878918,
0.0035260387,
-0.046974726,
-0.0084148068,
0.0420934223,
-0.0570635572,
-0.0153543679,
-0.0265293121,
2.747e-7,
0.045424521,
0.0093873302,
0.0231998451,
0.0297792442,
-0.0204778593,
0.0216870829,
0.0659555718,
0.0485492274,
-0.0205384139,
0.0207003057,
0.0542560704,
0.0193640087,
-0.0296932403,
0.017289808,
-0.0826182738,
0.05725253,
-0.0440066941,
-0.0258520059,
-0.0465513468,
-0.0038896254,
0.0634493828,
0.0228684358,
0.0702243745,
0.0127893155,
-0.0454101302,
-0.0228730217,
0.0808858573,
-0.0287337359,
0.0107077695,
0.0236402154,
0.0061161718,
0.0261282194,
-0.0008799622,
0.0658991709,
0.0013333089,
0.037517447,
0.0589895546,
0.044259686,
0.0078593735,
0.0222913828,
-0.0305210296,
-0.0579737239,
0.0098639391,
-0.047312025,
0.0842921659,
-0.0343946852,
0.0198853761,
0.0421683304,
-0.0383254662,
-0.0202498063,
0.0075723906,
0.0321730115,
0.0150195146,
0.0013206088,
0.0342789888,
0.0227626953,
0.0318239108,
-0.0802892521,
0.0223393328,
0.0364731885,
-0.0274638291,
-0.0149260331,
0.0016420702,
-0.0464905351,
0.0310638789,
-0.0152646871,
0.0139693264,
2.723658063e-34,
-0.0132496916,
0.0255053993,
0.0221969243,
-0.0057263537,
0.0177226532,
-0.0607614405,
0.0196418967,
-0.0028961867,
0.0444226936,
-0.0950540453,
0.0039839558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12491v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12491v2 | Exploring the Impact of Training Data Distribution and Subword Tokenization on Gender Bias in Machine Translation | 2023-09-21T21:21:55 | 2023-09-30T19:00:32 | Bar Iluz, Tomasz Limisiewicz, Gabriel Stanovsky, David Mareček | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We study the effect of tokenization on gender bias in machine translation, an
aspect that has been largely overlooked in previous works. Specifically, we
focus on the interactions between the frequency of gendered profession names in
training data, their representation in the subword tokenizer's vocabulary, and
gender bias. We observe that female and non-stereotypical gender inflections of
profession names (e.g., Spanish "doctora" for "female doctor") tend to be split
into multiple subword tokens. Our results indicate that the imbalance of gender
forms in the model's training corpus is a major factor contributing to gender
bias and has a greater impact than subword splitting. We show that analyzing
subword splits provides good estimates of gender-form imbalance in the training
data and can be used even when the corpus is not publicly available. We also
demonstrate that fine-tuning just the token embedding layer can decrease the
gap in gender prediction accuracy between female and male forms without
impairing the translation quality. | [
0.0295645371,
0.0577431992,
-0.0165973529,
0.0235833973,
0.022796154,
0.0063481568,
0.0653731599,
0.0195038244,
-0.0576416589,
-0.0107963607,
-0.0255082157,
-0.0712125227,
0.0400502868,
0.0003276987,
0.0505523346,
-0.0485542305,
0.0120527456,
0.0198975895,
0.0157096609,
-0.0288394038,
0.0102289515,
0.0175607651,
0.0329849795,
0.0636572614,
0.0065944856,
-0.006812138,
0.0418426059,
0.0480961986,
0.0014413429,
0.0303559639,
0.0357331336,
0.0355965346,
-0.0105252098,
0.0569289066,
0.0000016177,
-0.0465846285,
-0.0264633745,
0.0458757989,
-0.0070935511,
-0.0158738699,
0.0435681157,
-0.0550887585,
-0.0318174399,
0.0454362854,
-0.005932847,
-0.0205500051,
0.0341029502,
0.0174089074,
0.0272574313,
0.0202642363,
-0.003508823,
0.014996361,
-0.0645732656,
-0.0494773723,
-0.047193259,
0.0026122953,
-0.0162970331,
-0.0533636846,
-0.076191701,
0.0073079355,
-0.0266078562,
0.0054078093,
-0.0283509307,
-0.0072512501,
0.0013119245,
0.0443917215,
-0.0450320914,
-0.0528366268,
0.0180398766,
0.0335477665,
-0.0118355034,
0.000366494,
0.0094638085,
0.0068155732,
0.0336946696,
0.0142572587,
-0.0173722953,
0.0166917127,
-0.0102894865,
-0.0276435856,
0.0355475135,
0.0034875318,
0.0312788822,
0.0307548866,
-0.053816177,
0.0481965691,
0.0258531272,
-0.0506871529,
0.0019840277,
0.0011489294,
0.0135661801,
-0.0423181131,
0.0446090922,
-0.0487737916,
-0.0104998443,
-0.0024542131,
-0.0122903995,
-0.0546331666,
0.0148725323,
-0.0499933288,
-0.041844707,
0.0486240573,
0.0312793776,
-0.0055714934,
-0.0011762261,
0.0228853393,
-0.0046979599,
0.0226268433,
-0.0627531856,
-0.0486797877,
-0.0050927484,
-0.0013127978,
-0.0480521768,
-0.0332707912,
-0.0415234566,
0.0466341637,
-0.034751799,
-0.0188068002,
-0.030431563,
-0.0301811192,
0.0370295197,
0.0142135704,
-0.0538481027,
-0.0003447713,
0.0091828443,
0.021949986,
-0.0359288454,
0.0087995669,
0.0001417636,
-0.0641747564,
-0.008983044,
-0.0095264483,
0.0057682195,
-0.0267278496,
-0.0023763757,
0.014822566,
0.0128229577,
-0.0318403356,
0.0254880022,
-0.0431719124,
-0.0353159867,
-0.05960517,
0.0164015628,
-0.0602728017,
0.0299364291,
0.0408196822,
0.0406235196,
-0.0188878402,
-0.0275481269,
0.016116038,
-0.0378235281,
0.066545479,
0.0411830805,
0.0092496956,
0.075372763,
-0.0098795565,
-0.0537557639,
0.0795241594,
0.0739164054,
0.0104462411,
0.0305844396,
0.0077967872,
-0.0184399877,
0.0600249507,
0.0387528278,
0.0228412002,
-0.0199130047,
0.0028061196,
-0.0055277864,
0.0682183579,
0.0867653191,
0.0062624528,
0.0070124757,
0.0077220546,
0.0117344484,
0.0963835418,
0.0348399878,
0.0437354036,
0.0470722653,
-0.01782538,
-0.0112882089,
0.0157357212,
-0.0533534922,
-0.0218259711,
0.037390016,
-0.0403218158,
-0.0268384423,
0.0330267325,
-0.0251994487,
-0.0316620357,
0.0105289379,
0.0200269781,
-0.0190579612,
-0.0246608146,
0.0235665385,
0.0268560331,
-0.013936107,
0.0754961595,
0.0093938904,
-0.0589639619,
0.012410325,
-0.0406065173,
-0.0250413157,
0.0705204234,
0.011296588,
-0.0125466939,
-0.0071614385,
-0.0309464373,
0.0004192337,
0.0229989849,
0.0319943242,
0.0121108331,
0.036833901,
-0.042505201,
-0.0155757666,
0.0777279139,
0.0415506326,
0.0278357882,
0.0324643478,
0.0707083493,
0.0342271402,
-0.0849315748,
-0.0725372583,
0.0237301681,
-0.0346810631,
-0.0178331453,
0.0549182817,
0.0139827216,
0.0138980756,
0.0468543321,
-0.0470690429,
0.0015651906,
-0.000980924,
-0.019667495,
0.0053270138,
0.0442039259,
-0.0105194673,
-0.0078266002,
-0.0005027578,
-0.0752489939,
-0.046318613,
-0.0024560436,
-0.0168584082,
-0.0119410688,
0.0257111341,
0.0057105804,
0.0391575582,
-0.0403324924,
0.0395100378,
0.0181179624,
0.0149956821,
-0.0202600211,
-0.0141380662,
-0.0310001075,
-0.0179559365,
-0.0120905042,
-0.0418447889,
-0.0072563938,
-0.0894981846,
-0.0305564702,
0.0291104186,
0.0209708214,
0.0150335114,
0.0240466055,
-0.0215774085,
-0.0156715102,
-0.0433731265,
-0.061460048,
-0.0017129172,
-0.0211548395,
0.0112531129,
-0.0292048045,
0.0468926281,
-0.0319519006,
0.0026384108,
-0.0021467858,
-0.0341075696,
-0.0017913191,
0.0296799112,
0.0270559583,
-0.0263836216,
0.0400602147,
-0.0260800719,
-0.0355103053,
-0.036858391,
0.0542934388,
0.0447940603,
0.0039199684,
-0.056570828,
-0.0172565393,
-0.0191427581,
-0.0079647172,
-0.0090432679,
-0.0783594623,
-0.0043866113,
0.02742186,
0.0367128663,
0.0618130639,
-0.0043000146,
-0.0054699923,
0.0366054289,
0.0271761399,
-0.0403567664,
-0.0098558161,
0.0432647057,
0.0171403252,
0.0233267825,
-0.0764456913,
0.0002962071,
0.0099490983,
-0.0008865501,
-0.033648707,
-0.0308658369,
0.0173977669,
-0.0382794626,
-0.0440633707,
-0.007868587,
0.0168935023,
-0.0092629846,
0.0305765718,
-0.0116110211,
-0.0411790907,
0.0257763155,
-0.0332676731,
-0.0004265936,
-0.0187014211,
-0.0145595828,
-0.0503207408,
0.0112506999,
-0.0406338349,
0.0153857162,
0.0219641887,
-0.0201279204,
-0.0540860482,
0.0012782475,
0.013378391,
-0.0471520163,
0.0330233872,
-0.004522786,
-0.0153416703,
0.0000269121,
-0.0332305953,
-0.027893642,
-0.0192384124,
-0.0177170597,
0.0184185188,
0.0343334861,
-0.0251504555,
0.0016137605,
0.0220170543,
-0.0380552225,
0.0564055145,
-0.0117630837,
0.0032472715,
-0.0114175007,
0.0179103613,
-0.0031717883,
0.0053923614,
-0.0064769723,
-0.0636468306,
-0.0181259941,
0.0020329969,
0.0056444332,
-0.0087937135,
-0.0081718434,
-0.0183580928,
0.0603453852,
-0.0344204567,
-0.0351161249,
-0.0377455875,
0.0241081696,
-0.0547083057,
0.0300194379,
0.1291265339,
0.0204026699,
-0.0693614036,
-0.0087289307,
-0.006049925,
0.0342799053,
0.0259378422,
0.0250804741,
-0.0406776033,
0.0167813692,
0.0496856496,
0.0289436318,
0.0191072654,
-0.0184714515,
-0.0336544327,
-0.1020405591,
0.0278722737,
0.0112761408,
-0.0602883957,
-0.0449194014,
-0.0181053281,
-0.0374878943,
-0.0507235341,
0.0481739268,
-0.0103071127,
-0.0051575545,
0.0131226126,
0.020931175,
-0.0470575206,
-0.0399038121,
0.0127436602,
-0.134691298,
0.0309378337,
0.0548595004,
0.0694740415,
-0.0476635806,
-0.0079438072,
0.0045886789,
-0.0065194424,
0.0086973766,
-0.0277942885,
0.0432293341,
-0.0477333181,
-0.0181849711,
-0.0091384007,
0.0198243372,
0.0191989839,
0.0289927013,
0.0170662347,
-0.0008600531,
0.0202360135,
0.0056610359,
-0.0482673422,
-0.0316542238,
-0.005307212,
0.0895872042,
0.0022138224,
-0.040660385,
-0.0112074967,
-0.0356412008,
0.0335794464,
0.0270741582,
0.0188655183,
-0.0209495164,
-0.0435750149,
-0.0598451756,
-0.0372407213,
-0.046605166,
0.0330810063,
0.0658090413,
0.0007854158,
-0.0312635824,
-0.0004836412,
0.0274217725,
-0.0576803647,
0.0364436135,
0.0051790774,
0.0412211493,
-0.0213496145,
-0.020535117,
-0.0198420789,
-0.0358840786,
-0.0260048881,
0.0039612898,
-0.0523930788,
-0.0537147596,
0.0079428861,
0.0297361091,
0.0259167664,
0.0856287479,
-0.011364257,
-0.0512565076,
0.0567090884,
0.0382524207,
-0.0385209285,
0.0028872418,
0.0521523729,
-0.0136260325,
0.0089065321,
0.0310079753,
-0.039080523,
-0.0320908315,
-0.000191049,
0.0026896263,
-0.0030792188,
0.0006727331,
-0.0196145624,
0.0108925337,
0.0291465055,
-0.0785315484,
0.0185542181,
-0.0674330592,
0.0195230972,
-0.0220670495,
-0.0142513989,
-0.0259207767,
-0.0450530164,
0.0435990021,
-0.0060483287,
-0.0147712426,
0.0129350834,
-0.0344111212,
-0.0069092936,
0.0086365258,
0.0052071484,
-0.0257361587,
0.041578263,
0.0207627025,
0.0137917586,
0.0320152417,
-0.0333945565,
-0.024762094,
0.01877762,
0.0033951669,
-0.0219746009,
-0.0100047505,
0.0607803985,
-0.0326074772,
0.0298128575,
-0.0330857448,
-0.0049121906,
-0.0116936518,
0.0426879786,
0.0069963289,
-0.0582575239,
0.0600875057,
0.0166402254,
-0.0111383917,
0.0054404475,
0.0065413616,
-0.0104825776,
0.0432208106,
0.0293037239,
-0.0183212813,
0.0031726763,
-0.0186387617,
0.0772329643,
0.077588819,
0.0341455303,
-0.0323071256,
-0.0549483001,
-0.0108143976,
0.0220935717,
0.0338716544,
-0.0401040986,
-0.0342376828,
-0.021091789,
-0.0941019803,
-0.06087102,
0.0185662135,
-0.0387852378,
0.0152770681,
0.0080517251,
-0.0074919341,
0.0976586714,
-0.0381013192,
-0.0377377905,
-0.0381937064,
-0.0244250074,
0.0590792447,
-0.0252686795,
-0.0141802942,
-5.733404636e-33,
-0.0119418688,
-0.0327535123,
0.0035741176,
-0.0360756665,
-0.005797423,
0.0537843294,
0.0066639497,
-0.0270623919,
0.0160837416,
0.021696778,
-0.0347711407,
0.0472004972,
0.034569256,
-0.0102073085,
0.0277362317,
0.029122103,
0.0806881785,
0.0239437502,
-0.0181138162,
-0.0576304346,
-0.0389939174,
0.043507155,
0.0426189303,
-0.0111971786,
0.100055702,
-0.018992329,
-0.0069200685,
0.0116029195,
0.0046878271,
0.0261460003,
0.0186168291,
0.0288519785,
0.012990606,
-0.0222954676,
0.0066982033,
0.0236117449,
-0.1071126983,
-0.0187483858,
0.0156017607,
0.0540521815,
0.0368989632,
-0.0355713218,
0.0496801063,
0.0141292308,
-0.0505002849,
-0.0243213028,
0.0437120944,
0.0116895176,
0.0165725108,
0.0185118429,
-0.0415787064,
0.0275191218,
-0.0150381951,
0.0130969156,
0.0495954454,
0.0092625264,
0.0118088434,
-0.0160228889,
-0.0903242379,
0.0136849461,
0.0124827093,
0.0100638214,
0.0348462649,
0.0243943129,
0.0034560901,
-0.0159343537,
0.0892112181,
0.0326456018,
-0.0017112351,
-0.0534764789,
0.0378512889,
-0.0223935898,
0.0144609315,
0.0409824289,
0.0788758397,
-0.0128933527,
-0.0605046637,
-0.0131935412,
-0.0114139915,
0.0124499472,
0.0075056516,
0.0060452428,
-0.0801729113,
-0.0331978016,
-0.0310955886,
-0.0848781466,
-0.0017361473,
-0.0152387815,
-0.0012398817,
0.0361407846,
-0.0255133938,
-0.0041453918,
0.0028566546,
-0.0661757216,
-0.0182864107,
-0.015154345,
-0.0044047139,
-0.0578355379,
0.0070598861,
0.0231704991,
-0.0383587293,
-0.0045395005,
-0.0082001062,
0.0302513335,
0.0104032801,
0.0058344253,
0.0370547324,
0.0114189135,
-0.0738128722,
-0.022345623,
-0.0294486824,
-0.007805293,
-0.0001406215,
0.0502783135,
0.0369393267,
0.0168042779,
0.0035209802,
-0.0126141999,
0.0674173012,
0.0415532887,
-0.0201662872,
0.0117229056,
0.0126069384,
0.0347694159,
-0.0416209884,
-0.0010401986,
0.0111545492,
0.0109043019,
0.0643438622,
-0.0545050539,
-0.030822318,
-0.0504705869,
2.383e-7,
0.0304518528,
0.0821787938,
0.0197062902,
0.023261901,
0.0118444385,
0.0034192009,
0.020219788,
0.066873908,
0.0449481457,
0.0403934196,
0.0002774317,
0.0086427815,
0.022809932,
0.0461398885,
-0.1127299517,
-0.0004456686,
-0.0592510663,
0.0473646224,
-0.01184694,
-0.0067291264,
-0.0200042445,
0.102282688,
0.0479632281,
-0.009113132,
-0.0199682675,
-0.0171455555,
0.0416196212,
0.0081172064,
-0.0122485273,
0.0194261335,
0.0359726809,
0.0280355643,
0.0032026372,
0.0071027186,
-0.0235873219,
0.0195866097,
0.0705711693,
0.0167588405,
-0.0496082641,
0.0768035725,
0.0178950895,
-0.0388811417,
-0.0285821278,
-0.0425850488,
0.053983517,
0.0291453414,
-0.0061691008,
-0.0465011187,
-0.0170240235,
0.0259312242,
0.0713977888,
-0.016164504,
-0.0389210917,
0.0473350696,
0.0397120006,
0.0032786299,
-0.0179172363,
-0.0167720877,
-0.0288175996,
-0.0268248785,
-0.010106693,
-0.0691925436,
0.0146626849,
0.0332890898,
0.0208015535,
-0.038326852,
0.0055685602,
1.960681874e-34,
0.0414389744,
0.0338126644,
-0.0040429225,
0.0185875539,
0.0294397958,
-0.0281426851,
0.0306427646,
-0.0040867818,
0.0305521637,
0.0313703679,
-0.0156450123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12485v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12485v1 | Studying and improving reasoning in humans and machines | 2023-09-21T21:02:05 | 2023-09-21T21:02:05 | Nicolas Yax, Hernan Anlló, Stefano Palminteri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In the present study, we investigate and compare reasoning in large language
models (LLM) and humans using a selection of cognitive psychology tools
traditionally dedicated to the study of (bounded) rationality. To do so, we
presented to human participants and an array of pretrained LLMs new variants of
classical cognitive experiments, and cross-compared their performances. Our
results showed that most of the included models presented reasoning errors akin
to those frequently ascribed to error-prone, heuristic-based human reasoning.
Notwithstanding this superficial similarity, an in-depth comparison between
humans and LLMs indicated important differences with human-like reasoning, with
models limitations disappearing almost entirely in more recent LLMs releases.
Moreover, we show that while it is possible to devise strategies to induce
better performance, humans and machines are not equally-responsive to the same
prompting schemes. We conclude by discussing the epistemological implications
and challenges of comparing human and machine behavior for both artificial
intelligence and cognitive psychology. | [
0.0413916111,
0.0552053526,
-0.027943084,
-0.0037698322,
-0.0548835546,
0.0338078775,
0.0104712201,
0.0336877443,
0.0380376168,
-0.0252817702,
-0.0234486833,
-0.0011736697,
0.0059853694,
0.0078964932,
0.0440626852,
-0.0347030982,
0.0323540568,
-0.0812539384,
0.0509048365,
-0.0234806538,
-0.0671572611,
0.0026769787,
-0.006081928,
0.0109004853,
0.0429322533,
-0.0051354188,
-0.0120082637,
-0.0242653042,
-0.0099441735,
-0.0325462893,
-0.0627347901,
0.043709822,
0.0315710492,
0.0202168506,
0.0000021909,
-0.0916325524,
0.0374888033,
-0.0139065385,
-0.0734421611,
0.0237984061,
0.0080719916,
0.0090912441,
0.0049825716,
0.0200910401,
-0.029473858,
0.0582274832,
-0.0063643237,
0.0585024431,
0.0026899448,
0.0312941186,
-0.0050022383,
-0.0211977959,
0.0347570777,
0.0091684172,
0.0101834564,
-0.0315775871,
0.0230214614,
0.0281240605,
0.0553401746,
0.0078576133,
-0.0040270602,
0.004997998,
0.036256779,
-0.0066162497,
-0.0462668017,
0.039786566,
-0.0014623884,
-0.0552620366,
-0.0038346683,
0.0445004478,
0.0225974657,
-0.0242303442,
-0.0032927364,
0.0138473893,
-0.0037610177,
0.0045104609,
-0.0324349776,
0.0816326961,
-0.0014929905,
0.0085722758,
0.0386446752,
-0.0189588349,
0.0284371395,
0.0453758389,
-0.0358748473,
0.0966456532,
-0.0197589211,
-0.0372439623,
0.0670315921,
0.0107192192,
-0.0321408808,
-0.0578939915,
-0.0160850696,
0.0370075256,
-0.0476863049,
0.0092739603,
-0.0071743778,
0.0221532993,
0.0300528966,
-0.0326065123,
0.0298603121,
0.0371659696,
0.0295232087,
0.0322966352,
-0.0208501928,
0.0813984349,
-0.0144663267,
0.0610604249,
-0.0139330449,
0.0360569321,
-0.0473919287,
-0.0416382663,
0.0068621705,
0.020337116,
0.0107028186,
-0.0092661893,
-0.0370109491,
0.0120679196,
-0.0129129849,
0.0130437249,
-0.0235569384,
-0.0040671201,
0.0056850719,
-0.0168048143,
-0.1097019538,
-0.0293952078,
-0.0558930337,
0.0490940325,
0.0238432381,
-0.0332925692,
-0.0069258893,
0.0044434885,
-0.0469059795,
-0.025237618,
0.0326949731,
0.033052925,
-0.032991495,
-0.0036672608,
-0.0408675522,
-0.0224541444,
0.015362123,
-0.0622925013,
0.0036393555,
-0.0353188813,
0.007666769,
0.0354903489,
-0.0183842964,
-0.0319642238,
-0.0044064615,
0.0115544535,
-0.049799677,
0.0946546048,
0.0064852536,
0.025080448,
0.0459333397,
0.0189166311,
-0.0349286981,
0.0198780578,
0.0332615189,
0.0244737286,
-0.0014120468,
0.0088903317,
0.0156615842,
-0.0168639328,
-0.0280820969,
-0.0348961093,
-0.0362930931,
-0.0074151233,
-0.0158364493,
0.0440135635,
0.0270094257,
0.0826893672,
-0.0286010839,
-0.0169556793,
0.0678627864,
0.0819944739,
-0.0165101588,
0.0171009749,
0.0460127965,
-0.0104862442,
0.0153877465,
0.0221848562,
-0.0713624433,
-0.0007528675,
-0.0393141098,
0.0057844617,
0.0144913374,
-0.0073636179,
-0.0377269611,
-0.0369309075,
-0.0174628254,
-0.0076280013,
0.0483959541,
0.0280973315,
0.052078981,
-0.0285194162,
-0.024062762,
-0.0170158148,
-0.0054274346,
-0.0144085819,
-0.02301291,
-0.0905209631,
0.0692849904,
0.032952413,
0.036140915,
0.0009288212,
0.0321575515,
0.0171374641,
-0.0080026295,
0.0303881615,
0.066484645,
-0.0018548191,
-0.0267624464,
-0.0258307643,
0.0259255432,
-0.0206722543,
-0.0098563759,
-0.009094473,
-0.0004533349,
-0.007135774,
0.0003402986,
-0.0318724737,
0.0064201499,
0.0414434746,
-0.0393212028,
-0.002065416,
-0.0964551345,
-0.0111459941,
0.0239468608,
-0.0097226854,
0.0080697164,
0.0335693955,
0.043449454,
0.0065507418,
-0.0337346271,
0.0499562025,
-0.0481927879,
0.0113738179,
0.0212696698,
-0.0117440727,
-0.041258648,
0.0175878722,
0.0185209513,
-0.0056854519,
0.0257755984,
-0.0234458148,
0.0087248562,
-0.0348441936,
0.0504130758,
-0.0125597818,
-0.0202237554,
-0.0204824302,
0.1007868126,
0.0141023314,
0.0032553175,
0.0130403228,
0.0006806025,
0.0024986244,
-0.0588036552,
-0.0013336069,
0.049910441,
0.0223136824,
-0.0230855383,
-0.0142969647,
-0.031322334,
-0.0698804036,
0.0118257264,
-0.067597568,
-0.0320568085,
0.0207243375,
-0.0050641722,
-0.0327416435,
-0.0529214926,
-0.010855142,
0.0089357775,
0.0158013143,
-0.0073298523,
0.0490378439,
0.0577731766,
0.0267500188,
-0.024813462,
-0.0024813944,
0.0071149254,
-0.0076768151,
-0.0348180756,
0.0208073668,
0.0481304191,
0.0307203922,
-0.0481051058,
0.0498791635,
-0.0388091616,
0.0176260937,
-0.0083457222,
-0.0279786009,
0.045081757,
0.0053168442,
0.0447669849,
0.1408697516,
0.0196859483,
0.0289499443,
0.0664195493,
0.0310229696,
-0.0500354394,
0.0105355121,
0.0075840824,
-0.0336513445,
-0.0376524329,
-0.0456461795,
-0.0262974128,
0.0486605614,
-0.0063251634,
0.0239461605,
-0.0228141807,
0.05902569,
-0.0148051018,
-0.0503782667,
-0.0383451805,
-0.0629196167,
-0.0191799961,
0.098222211,
-0.0081141889,
-0.0268079676,
0.0930845067,
0.0065741492,
0.0179563854,
-0.034769062,
0.0053102379,
0.0144882621,
0.0794128776,
-0.009330133,
-0.0031744251,
-0.006945082,
-0.0041030366,
-0.0508380458,
-0.0361710638,
-0.0094759725,
-0.0171918925,
0.0186039824,
-0.0622604787,
0.0137376506,
-0.0027912771,
-0.0552044623,
-0.0575676523,
0.0011588449,
-0.08704146,
0.0038168726,
0.0114043299,
-0.0062144184,
-0.024552634,
0.0080521461,
0.0544285476,
-0.0245937686,
0.0285627022,
-0.0213107448,
0.0034275714,
-0.0352132656,
-0.0028359769,
0.0593705326,
0.0558429845,
-0.0439840741,
0.0838602334,
0.0531799346,
0.025096165,
-0.005631011,
-0.0211087093,
0.042410519,
-0.0038813332,
-0.0150607461,
-0.0120472591,
0.0424644053,
0.0652353466,
-0.0306907408,
-0.0045296033,
0.1163447872,
0.0648804903,
-0.0028396281,
0.0081274183,
-0.045091819,
0.0140577452,
0.0280744601,
0.0317675248,
-0.0303429291,
-0.0356594101,
0.052809976,
0.020613946,
-0.0329240784,
-0.0412618518,
0.0214123707,
-0.1191347614,
0.0439060144,
-0.0146141462,
0.0270735957,
-0.0363767222,
-0.0695206597,
-0.0118400529,
-0.0006453135,
-0.0092715593,
0.0489538908,
0.0063464907,
-0.0027752589,
-0.0110292528,
-0.0084487954,
-0.0276595708,
0.0512081087,
-0.0249393675,
0.0391044244,
0.0200063977,
0.029226942,
-0.0087194322,
-0.1095217392,
0.0164128486,
0.0147223594,
0.0386551879,
-0.0169269983,
0.0104400432,
0.0161713194,
0.0202910304,
-0.053349115,
0.0356644206,
-0.0053301672,
-0.0683050528,
0.0118831275,
0.078358531,
-0.03726146,
-0.0556285977,
0.0074421624,
0.0414148606,
-0.0720404685,
0.0823163614,
0.0151811531,
-0.0297763199,
-0.0441506617,
-0.0264153574,
-0.0340281427,
-0.0205509029,
-0.0288832746,
0.0272251703,
0.0098110093,
0.0296837892,
-0.0460676216,
-0.0478031747,
0.0347598344,
0.0162165239,
-0.0027530047,
-0.0349486321,
0.0021445148,
0.0025896686,
-0.0215721186,
0.0419493467,
-0.033003699,
0.0083388779,
-0.0505638123,
0.0124013554,
-0.0035803311,
-0.0675404817,
-0.0144522097,
-0.0104663707,
0.000115013,
-0.0598868504,
0.002893735,
0.0084703751,
0.0333281681,
0.0003462109,
-0.0084622726,
-0.0295150466,
-0.0285231955,
-0.0203409046,
-0.0242116228,
0.0350008681,
0.0147603909,
0.0055609252,
0.0072363392,
0.0132451849,
0.0084377863,
0.042363219,
-0.0054025589,
0.0242637862,
-0.0287984349,
-0.0513113961,
0.0465302095,
0.0433149002,
0.0190512538,
0.0002343888,
-0.0146910883,
-0.0199056771,
-0.0083448207,
-0.0031597437,
-0.020279713,
0.0163384397,
-0.0344212651,
0.0102174729,
0.0233572535,
0.0029730955,
-0.0405773744,
-0.036097955,
0.0062121428,
0.0252752546,
0.0254338607,
-0.0031859379,
0.0483115911,
0.0077186143,
0.0061678905,
0.0036554986,
0.0278359298,
-0.0356711969,
0.0786126107,
0.0070877802,
0.098092638,
0.0213638674,
-0.002781292,
-0.023583591,
-0.0241266638,
-0.0796771571,
-0.1110106781,
0.0801510215,
0.0047829263,
0.0225045457,
-0.0132442452,
-0.0142242014,
-0.0623241328,
-0.0009620328,
-0.0043915184,
-0.0045719529,
0.0140999136,
-0.0017873773,
0.0232546888,
0.0169715099,
-0.0416388363,
0.0008445929,
0.0378468968,
-0.0417205282,
0.0102750808,
-0.02960499,
-0.0244083181,
-0.016440725,
-0.0481559932,
-0.0064031435,
0.000477964,
-0.0095059918,
-0.0103889005,
-0.0326011106,
-0.0950387642,
0.0037239285,
0.0276208241,
0.0284408424,
-0.0166576263,
0.0044184276,
0.0496489666,
-0.0059653223,
-0.0290460214,
-0.0160387121,
0.0374042988,
-0.0341977254,
0.014346634,
-0.0411008112,
-6.239876662e-33,
-0.0136439325,
-0.0371394679,
0.0297932029,
-0.037093576,
0.0026815261,
-0.0528578274,
-0.047594469,
0.0181650203,
-0.0406643972,
0.0281955842,
-0.0478809513,
-0.0015534608,
0.0132030267,
-0.0394881815,
0.0176474061,
0.000363995,
-0.0043528602,
-0.0050790184,
-0.0331084616,
-0.0471582413,
-0.0109863617,
-0.013532728,
-0.0017133754,
-0.0142542152,
0.0190755557,
0.0104168318,
-0.0015911048,
0.0285859108,
-0.0631755516,
0.0343067721,
0.0030513003,
-0.0014813694,
0.0512495264,
-0.0173276328,
-0.0070325285,
0.0657364428,
-0.0447368883,
-0.0104750758,
0.0376283117,
-0.0420900658,
-0.0318239927,
-0.0264601167,
0.0114487121,
-0.0161416139,
-0.0412864573,
0.0281465147,
0.0151767805,
-0.0333285369,
0.0140131284,
0.0398360789,
-0.0370481871,
-0.0066813184,
-0.024266284,
0.0124179227,
-0.0120234182,
0.0403899066,
-0.0531435274,
0.0302809458,
-0.0587943755,
0.0406604148,
0.0304998346,
-0.038323164,
0.0623704717,
-0.0114959087,
0.004954949,
0.0489513241,
0.011806055,
0.0070488895,
-0.0471960828,
0.0229720902,
0.0267741363,
0.0527570471,
0.0729692206,
0.0130349556,
0.0126714427,
-0.0374443457,
-0.0548674315,
-0.0037582463,
0.0191707723,
0.0449659005,
0.0532211475,
0.0335992537,
-0.0459894538,
-0.032510899,
-0.0420647748,
0.0341803581,
-0.0524107739,
-0.0293889455,
0.039361842,
-0.0267705675,
-0.0085128536,
-0.0385104939,
0.016402794,
-0.0130191576,
0.0283179265,
-0.020269895,
0.0099903764,
0.0060443631,
-0.0146837654,
0.0022803158,
-0.0624560267,
-0.0391178504,
0.0048075807,
0.0449428335,
0.0244816151,
0.0151421614,
-0.0153268343,
-0.0177428834,
0.0171011258,
-0.0132375387,
-0.0264214445,
-0.0082394825,
0.0304258429,
-0.01367098,
0.0463372394,
0.0418075845,
-0.005549381,
-0.0293777846,
-0.0278910734,
-0.0287407916,
-0.0604069717,
0.0144427186,
-0.0062407553,
0.0224367641,
-0.0038474028,
-0.0099521112,
-0.0432991982,
0.0442897193,
-0.0026467538,
-0.0388641469,
-0.0148408366,
0.0171515923,
2.943e-7,
0.0031549034,
0.0629569292,
-0.0163822435,
0.0128639843,
0.0044006482,
0.0301426109,
-0.0219297409,
-0.0531572476,
0.0475111753,
-0.007370194,
0.0055508618,
0.0833849311,
0.0375070497,
0.0212437231,
-0.0323758274,
-0.0199476779,
-0.0225934535,
-0.0183418635,
-0.0565854311,
0.0357886255,
0.0884715915,
0.0179364663,
0.0158226863,
-0.0143575808,
0.0138647798,
-0.0596456304,
0.0197274201,
-0.0315410681,
0.0019539227,
-0.026336221,
0.005645006,
0.0154989045,
0.0151835708,
0.0921712741,
0.0054313513,
-0.0207414478,
-0.0161842164,
0.0391006619,
-0.0123275351,
-0.0295230709,
-0.045389872,
-0.0057971501,
0.020267101,
-0.0642504245,
0.0750185475,
-0.05712457,
-0.0586059913,
0.0106703844,
0.0258043371,
-0.0428206809,
-0.0117618451,
0.0014771413,
0.0022695791,
0.0020729296,
-0.0039467616,
0.0111450581,
0.0061306423,
-0.0689370707,
0.0131484913,
0.0285738278,
-0.0620416477,
-0.0628755018,
-0.0402819254,
0.0012442077,
0.0495351627,
-0.0267433356,
-0.0263267606,
2.345689794e-34,
0.0238180961,
0.0252657253,
0.0398493819,
0.0256063845,
0.0645300075,
0.0421161205,
0.0070404601,
0.0219298769,
0.0448324569,
-0.0807162896,
-0.0051217754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12481v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12481v2 | HANS, are you clever? Clever Hans Effect Analysis of Neural Systems | 2023-09-21T20:52:18 | 2024-05-02T06:36:26 | Leonardo Ranaldi, Fabio Massimo Zanzotto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Instruction-tuned Large Language Models (It-LLMs) have been exhibiting
outstanding abilities to reason around cognitive states, intentions, and
reactions of all people involved, letting humans guide and comprehend
day-to-day social interactions effectively. In fact, several multiple-choice
questions (MCQ) benchmarks have been proposed to construct solid assessments of
the models' abilities. However, earlier works are demonstrating the presence of
inherent "order bias" in It-LLMs, posing challenges to the appropriate
evaluation. In this paper, we investigate It-LLMs' resilience abilities towards
a series of probing tests using four MCQ benchmarks. Introducing adversarial
examples, we show a significant performance gap, mainly when varying the order
of the choices, which reveals a selection bias and brings into discussion
reasoning abilities. Following a correlation between first positions and model
choices due to positional bias, we hypothesized the presence of structural
heuristics in the decision-making process of the It-LLMs, strengthened by
including significant examples in few-shot scenarios. Finally, by using the
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) technique, we elicit the model to reason and mitigate
the bias by obtaining more robust models. | [
0.0383211449,
0.048524458,
-0.0368255004,
0.0473354496,
-0.0435293131,
0.0261503682,
0.0217200331,
-0.0147413164,
0.0279264431,
-0.0381172001,
-0.0367354602,
-0.0385715552,
-0.0046259151,
-0.0372450463,
0.0709847137,
-0.0102980034,
0.0484444797,
-0.050756041,
0.0161242336,
-0.029038338,
-0.0232686698,
-0.0348573178,
-0.0258631967,
0.021428952,
0.0403457619,
-0.0117958924,
-0.0202165358,
0.0127002345,
0.0292848703,
-0.0552976206,
-0.006088824,
0.0677054375,
0.0115946233,
0.0590636656,
0.0000022803,
-0.0440340601,
0.0072342111,
-0.0104194321,
-0.0417296104,
0.0387294963,
-0.007316146,
0.0377106778,
-0.0054767509,
0.0250298399,
-0.053515166,
0.0105419494,
-0.0154263619,
0.0508416109,
0.0312851071,
0.0903078094,
0.0132632088,
-0.0460744165,
0.0283979308,
-0.0467291363,
0.0092349565,
-0.0757270157,
0.0399749577,
0.002484299,
-0.013871708,
0.0210112166,
-0.0047486909,
0.0149843553,
0.0260758959,
0.0174959768,
-0.041694887,
0.0159896296,
0.0053519695,
0.0031860401,
-0.0179712102,
0.0913021788,
0.0158519838,
0.0145862522,
0.0043990575,
-0.0164365042,
0.0652003884,
0.0234404374,
-0.0531054288,
-0.0043156906,
0.0425630882,
-0.0347403437,
0.0193296615,
-0.007801387,
0.0275122952,
0.0229185466,
-0.0242950693,
0.0837972537,
-0.0000604533,
-0.0381255113,
0.0377812311,
-0.0003692313,
-0.0137422383,
-0.0678089932,
-0.025019303,
0.0242338832,
-0.0389649197,
-0.0046306341,
-0.0042575309,
-0.0182677824,
0.0090093371,
-0.0529777221,
0.043510247,
0.0189200323,
0.0099590048,
0.0179939885,
0.0129036438,
0.0426193401,
-0.0340570286,
0.0654041618,
-0.0254448466,
0.0305059366,
-0.0260369126,
-0.0190403759,
0.0067344001,
0.0425408334,
-0.0280856807,
-0.0086616306,
-0.0494970605,
0.0240846518,
-0.0051074517,
-0.0106077082,
-0.0468812324,
0.0238472,
0.0420493707,
0.0289095957,
-0.0674816221,
0.025654383,
-0.0473489277,
0.0161681864,
0.0252283663,
-0.0364602506,
-0.0283289552,
0.0233481508,
-0.0160690956,
-0.0651491582,
0.0256120395,
0.1140946299,
-0.0085971495,
-0.0500149429,
-0.0039609228,
-0.0250324272,
-0.0255359486,
-0.0722453073,
0.0646480545,
-0.0210705064,
0.0225583985,
0.0183753371,
-0.0275027193,
-0.0383601077,
0.0118228393,
0.0124335578,
-0.0674919486,
0.0370044149,
0.0835886449,
0.0039751008,
0.0268283654,
0.0201123115,
0.0036330509,
0.0222262666,
-0.0018488996,
0.0146470731,
0.0297841579,
-0.0299420003,
0.0338061526,
0.0412212275,
-0.0080126962,
-0.0139307296,
-0.028837977,
0.0268274471,
-0.0207645595,
0.0475299545,
-0.0093491068,
0.0340924487,
-0.0378191881,
-0.0301778447,
0.1000242084,
0.0382525288,
-0.0267226361,
0.0074264496,
-0.0132953394,
0.0085137654,
0.032146927,
0.0392222032,
-0.0810885131,
0.0520009063,
-0.0618505254,
-0.0365211293,
-0.0018625516,
-0.0038479306,
-0.0294691846,
-0.0331602171,
0.0098106125,
0.0379188508,
0.0305969995,
0.0481321067,
0.0242259093,
-0.0381914526,
-0.055913683,
0.0054108878,
-0.0037770933,
-0.0002229865,
-0.0400489531,
-0.0836911723,
0.0108342841,
-0.0036727295,
0.04128474,
-0.0076073348,
-0.0457064882,
0.0183982048,
0.0036151218,
0.0104825329,
0.081281729,
0.0046554138,
0.0230676215,
-0.0282223243,
-0.0045540668,
-0.0277050026,
0.0044718692,
0.0438062996,
-0.018758826,
-0.0299558882,
-0.0181211028,
0.0234350115,
-0.0213959049,
0.0320471786,
0.0056811278,
-0.0264757741,
-0.0016796703,
0.0108401179,
0.0537623949,
-0.0071133738,
-0.0361178145,
0.0248085242,
0.0295079257,
-0.0106347799,
-0.0073632458,
0.003873528,
-0.0544979125,
-0.03970588,
-0.0121277133,
-0.036507953,
-0.066872254,
0.0385733396,
-0.0428244323,
-0.0133741004,
0.03651594,
-0.0321733095,
-0.0357497036,
0.0000213796,
0.0149004841,
-0.0203891601,
0.0237947535,
-0.0605424903,
0.0673177466,
-0.0185886044,
-0.0078840367,
-0.0155181568,
0.013436649,
0.000102454,
-0.0404417031,
-0.0318912417,
0.0016994893,
-0.0326377451,
-0.0212091208,
-0.0039057692,
0.000903955,
-0.0500206389,
-0.0200906396,
-0.0860714316,
0.0005332694,
-0.0144207897,
-0.0109963901,
0.002329028,
-0.0216396358,
-0.0025286847,
-0.0112143494,
-0.0271858908,
0.0454485677,
0.0144261625,
0.036506135,
0.0276806168,
-0.0048956568,
-0.0229410175,
-0.0339488983,
-0.0064186184,
-0.0364436395,
0.0539777242,
0.0183629189,
-0.0064511229,
-0.0324402153,
0.0089230165,
-0.0552977882,
0.019266827,
-0.0194409005,
-0.0681682006,
0.0405465662,
0.0054384922,
0.0197404381,
0.1426925361,
0.0351736322,
0.0021687297,
0.0346833803,
-0.0000364488,
-0.0365765169,
0.0218114965,
-0.0308364145,
0.0186740328,
-0.0439244434,
-0.0282619428,
-0.0196796581,
0.0720963404,
0.0234755483,
0.00755338,
-0.0169580709,
0.0518893935,
-0.0032701662,
-0.0518851094,
-0.0634900406,
-0.0125528742,
-0.0116814962,
0.0447935313,
-0.0008246955,
-0.0121747674,
0.0699071512,
0.0038351091,
0.0064763608,
-0.0284504127,
-0.004178612,
-0.0039847908,
0.073822841,
0.038276542,
-0.0127760302,
0.0114059215,
-0.0052705887,
-0.1086537987,
-0.0644552708,
0.0070801801,
-0.0172086228,
0.0072248317,
-0.0513112471,
-0.04929116,
0.0096356589,
-0.0451855436,
-0.0385482311,
-0.0591599159,
-0.0288601331,
0.0076065478,
0.0392020866,
-0.004970063,
-0.0385175534,
-0.0462822951,
0.0559439808,
-0.0054494026,
-0.0386356637,
-0.0021265817,
-0.0283442866,
0.0586207919,
0.0451333784,
0.0324883685,
0.0896254852,
-0.036200434,
0.0618782789,
0.0494374335,
0.0064625177,
0.0530621894,
-0.0024670535,
-0.0078709852,
0.0247136112,
0.0072603486,
-0.0033419167,
0.0425250232,
0.0666218475,
-0.0221604854,
-0.0076153418,
0.0960279182,
0.0230580121,
-0.0147898588,
0.0083752116,
-0.0023358248,
0.0222730171,
0.024662694,
0.0184320789,
-0.0524914116,
-0.0303106047,
0.0162159223,
0.0030143238,
-0.0328023992,
-0.0264997594,
0.0288983379,
-0.123638548,
0.0315963216,
-0.030557448,
-0.0583939627,
0.0239610802,
-0.0330842622,
-0.0223639067,
-0.0104048969,
0.0509184748,
0.020032078,
0.0425200351,
-0.0126904882,
0.0052602529,
-0.0004276783,
-0.0324333124,
0.0615474992,
-0.0094701452,
0.0643205419,
0.0611077175,
0.0555419959,
-0.0319776833,
-0.0560030229,
0.0623128079,
-0.0116769942,
0.0221883599,
-0.0013318367,
0.0437309705,
0.0069829063,
0.0017171997,
-0.0523771904,
0.0562007353,
0.0025843326,
-0.0041582114,
0.0200071149,
0.0142888371,
-0.0237570237,
-0.0398646183,
0.0141641293,
0.0325911902,
-0.0243298411,
0.0783604532,
0.0678818449,
-0.0766391754,
-0.0373743847,
-0.0291984584,
-0.0115138311,
-0.054342024,
-0.0541144907,
0.0233263653,
0.0357342362,
0.0439408496,
-0.0457394347,
-0.0408788286,
-0.001243224,
0.0232448261,
-0.0076572592,
-0.0353151895,
-0.0018805857,
0.0067664087,
0.0076699634,
0.0327763408,
0.0014100859,
0.0056074038,
-0.0560282171,
0.0254539717,
0.0172248743,
-0.0432192348,
-0.0412559137,
0.0141403107,
-0.0440004691,
-0.0668026879,
0.0466096103,
0.0749897957,
0.0166949853,
0.0273799971,
-0.0210259371,
-0.0776048526,
0.026936667,
-0.0023638019,
-0.0121180341,
0.046460174,
0.0248814896,
-0.007129286,
-0.005545334,
0.0274379998,
-0.006512478,
0.0535879061,
0.0613992736,
0.0247044936,
-0.0189956278,
-0.0280422121,
0.0131406542,
0.0229103379,
0.0687659457,
0.0149785746,
-0.016260488,
0.0183852352,
0.033110749,
-0.0050561004,
-0.025485158,
-0.0094694281,
-0.0453809313,
0.0389360376,
0.0144805638,
-0.0075326106,
-0.0480031818,
0.0007758556,
0.0284637418,
-0.0270369779,
0.0041702953,
-0.007876114,
0.0364214703,
0.0015428044,
0.0282729249,
-0.010481419,
0.065998815,
0.0020673762,
0.0543080382,
0.022310717,
0.1143432781,
0.0147383912,
-0.0164983291,
-0.0111007616,
0.0223891512,
-0.1012509763,
-0.0612610355,
0.0153953489,
-0.003457794,
0.0308310445,
0.011085853,
0.0141598741,
-0.0000561268,
0.0055497601,
0.0025823142,
0.0019287197,
-0.0031578699,
-0.0099827768,
0.0311685149,
0.024390718,
-0.0118185719,
0.0140998187,
0.0445040427,
0.0161550641,
-0.0000329663,
0.0207971986,
-0.0027056891,
-0.0148738213,
-0.0458546802,
0.0277217273,
0.0111044534,
-0.0105287516,
0.0160082504,
-0.0635481775,
-0.0721837133,
-0.0378470048,
0.0151572777,
0.0423659161,
-0.0216178354,
-0.0016196647,
0.0479457229,
0.0068770559,
-0.0002070709,
-0.0102732331,
0.0183067191,
-0.0484672599,
-0.0343105756,
-0.0146845737,
-7.053340794e-33,
-0.0205632988,
-0.0382655561,
-0.0027035091,
-0.0460995026,
-0.0174464677,
-0.0134107554,
-0.0328848176,
0.023067113,
-0.0448332205,
-0.0011070721,
-0.0089510353,
0.0220568441,
-0.012151449,
0.0371135697,
-0.0110155195,
-0.0408871025,
-0.0265454222,
-0.0297378637,
-0.0212094672,
-0.0087986775,
0.0217072014,
0.0055027935,
0.0327563174,
-0.0403780863,
0.0139909172,
0.0003681244,
0.0190090388,
0.0138450097,
-0.0899945796,
0.0307460614,
0.0002880326,
0.0000651353,
0.0226909984,
-0.0430805199,
0.0357443504,
0.043495547,
-0.0331514664,
-0.0397990681,
0.0297088102,
-0.0097240424,
-0.0159106627,
-0.0229611024,
0.0292541664,
-0.0234746151,
-0.011905429,
-0.0000132144,
0.0102156308,
0.0218134206,
-0.0127289128,
0.0104819126,
-0.025915822,
-0.0005295142,
-0.0601688474,
-0.0075895321,
-0.0234682802,
0.0468742363,
-0.0135184461,
0.0064694355,
-0.074422352,
0.0027297272,
0.005204597,
-0.0059449151,
0.0063337041,
0.0095315333,
0.0106093939,
0.0697539821,
0.0312939063,
0.0495280214,
-0.0268023219,
-0.0449916795,
0.009945537,
0.0400857627,
0.0842285976,
0.0337473452,
0.0192124248,
0.0156176686,
-0.1230181679,
-0.0127769308,
0.0179186352,
0.0038402292,
0.0436531268,
0.0013225976,
-0.0250398293,
-0.0041784174,
-0.0543583855,
-0.0181602221,
-0.0489376746,
-0.0216084421,
0.048816938,
-0.0402132981,
-0.0261779167,
-0.031538818,
0.0403387584,
-0.0170888193,
0.00895005,
-0.0071171564,
-0.0213248935,
0.0281481761,
0.0163070839,
0.0355216376,
-0.0535112508,
-0.0218904689,
-0.0078818221,
0.0072972463,
0.0333004817,
0.002798415,
0.038228523,
-0.0220077764,
0.005087743,
-0.0432131141,
-0.0337102897,
0.0151434373,
0.0101835839,
-0.0011571442,
0.0395690724,
0.0267069116,
-0.01954294,
-0.0350278355,
0.0284396149,
-0.0179609656,
-0.028399365,
-0.0016222498,
-0.0109879635,
0.0179453753,
-0.0188928023,
-0.0270280968,
-0.0028151402,
-0.0252819061,
0.0157427769,
-0.0746409073,
-0.023141684,
-0.0000095481,
3.139e-7,
0.0020440333,
0.0771214068,
-0.0316571258,
0.0240570996,
0.0431016758,
0.0633390546,
-0.0150690461,
0.0165902451,
0.0465575047,
0.0073508732,
-0.000373872,
0.029524561,
0.0363726914,
0.0082748355,
-0.0399695598,
-0.0130818291,
-0.0653876215,
0.0238473937,
-0.0127836866,
0.0022908407,
0.0313933082,
0.0724563003,
0.0054002386,
0.003132015,
-0.0154158594,
-0.0231198985,
0.0440541506,
-0.0337548368,
0.0039133248,
0.0073434399,
-0.0125372941,
-0.0251958445,
0.0001705743,
0.0887861773,
0.0319722854,
-0.000524994,
-0.004034875,
0.0184663534,
0.0088263052,
-0.0711092949,
-0.0167436209,
-0.0079912003,
0.0221664533,
-0.058391016,
0.085260503,
-0.1129034907,
-0.083016701,
0.0253744535,
-0.0209847409,
-0.0186325815,
0.0472443961,
0.0098762866,
0.022266373,
-0.0102435807,
-0.0044679567,
-0.0093693929,
0.0186147615,
-0.0650250614,
-0.0015199605,
0.035125345,
-0.0266746655,
-0.0695352554,
-0.0569512844,
-0.0123414462,
0.0257758666,
-0.0161794089,
-0.03336218,
2.772770539e-34,
0.0057714484,
0.011666432,
0.019897256,
0.0133021455,
0.0773328766,
0.0106403548,
0.0142230513,
-0.0139567144,
0.0374242887,
-0.1009634808,
-0.0000673826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12460v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12460v2 | Multimodal Deep Learning for Scientific Imaging Interpretation | 2023-09-21T20:09:22 | 2023-09-25T23:11:34 | Abdulelah S. Alshehri, Franklin L. Lee, Shihu Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.CV | In the domain of scientific imaging, interpreting visual data often demands
an intricate combination of human expertise and deep comprehension of the
subject materials. This study presents a novel methodology to linguistically
emulate and subsequently evaluate human-like interactions with Scanning
Electron Microscopy (SEM) images, specifically of glass materials. Leveraging a
multimodal deep learning framework, our approach distills insights from both
textual and visual data harvested from peer-reviewed articles, further
augmented by the capabilities of GPT-4 for refined data synthesis and
evaluation. Despite inherent challenges--such as nuanced interpretations and
the limited availability of specialized datasets--our model (GlassLLaVA) excels
in crafting accurate interpretations, identifying key features, and detecting
defects in previously unseen SEM images. Moreover, we introduce versatile
evaluation metrics, suitable for an array of scientific imaging applications,
which allows for benchmarking against research-grounded answers. Benefiting
from the robustness of contemporary Large Language Models, our model adeptly
aligns with insights from research papers. This advancement not only
underscores considerable progress in bridging the gap between human and machine
interpretation in scientific imaging, but also hints at expansive avenues for
future research and broader application. | [
0.0121461665,
0.1025640741,
-0.0026160553,
0.0486907065,
-0.017628951,
0.0019308317,
0.0299729966,
0.0161659885,
-0.0132127311,
-0.015580927,
-0.0209382437,
-0.0210427847,
0.0123083396,
0.065290682,
0.0360863507,
-0.0557048209,
0.0063001136,
0.0100858007,
0.0374585874,
-0.0250381846,
0.0070320135,
-0.0058093835,
-0.0297823586,
0.0145437978,
-0.0286349934,
-0.026364699,
-0.0187499784,
0.0328113735,
0.0487497412,
-0.0217077695,
-0.0016244677,
0.0547735281,
0.0214099232,
0.0286519863,
0.0000021888,
-0.0326658934,
0.0137902126,
0.0051533701,
0.0189128313,
0.0452197492,
0.0753605962,
-0.0780309513,
-0.0120908078,
-0.0422158614,
-0.0352081545,
-0.0165121071,
0.071456708,
0.0229379348,
0.0510091409,
0.0107419286,
-0.0207911078,
-0.0221539028,
0.0498375781,
0.0002016008,
0.0489466898,
-0.0235519093,
-0.0054624379,
0.0366745368,
-0.0085276691,
0.0477276258,
-0.0103575476,
0.0631752312,
0.045139458,
-0.0170514937,
-0.0061573987,
0.0417667925,
0.0127691478,
-0.0329216048,
-0.0121769719,
0.0648081601,
-0.0306623131,
0.0022185254,
-0.0503321402,
-0.024239609,
-0.0431331769,
0.0427577347,
-0.0262729861,
0.0138399098,
0.0236744657,
0.0078587672,
-0.0796513259,
-0.0122723598,
0.0447032526,
0.0116090709,
-0.0254952461,
-0.0175567884,
0.0095025115,
0.0276035052,
0.0109643731,
0.0252958089,
-0.0246888138,
0.013180973,
0.0213649999,
0.0252253488,
-0.012560728,
0.0088147298,
-0.0072504529,
-0.014382584,
0.0423888005,
0.018477222,
-0.0080344733,
0.000326057,
-0.0570902191,
0.0835122392,
-0.012718372,
-0.0314062014,
-0.0461717248,
0.0522127226,
-0.0239475239,
-0.0369433537,
-0.0554398112,
-0.0333973728,
0.01195875,
-0.0579625927,
-0.0147308605,
-0.0465209223,
-0.0162941813,
-0.0306915604,
0.0219788626,
-0.0089655612,
-0.0306245144,
0.0634745434,
-0.0707292557,
-0.0089745121,
-0.0223118905,
0.0516785495,
-0.0138545902,
0.0164747667,
-0.0224073958,
-0.0196998902,
0.0007880275,
0.0332930423,
-0.0117606139,
-0.0023360066,
0.018884249,
0.0645978376,
-0.0349413715,
-0.0259335395,
-0.0007142418,
-0.0597281381,
-0.0126817739,
-0.0211400203,
0.0647109151,
-0.0565216839,
0.0744700134,
0.0143835675,
0.0206175931,
-0.0468823276,
-0.0007456117,
-0.0007211484,
-0.0081114694,
0.0926425084,
-0.0568987466,
-0.0723351538,
0.0363493003,
0.0128423907,
0.0298993196,
-0.0038613435,
0.0406515487,
0.049684383,
-0.0136556467,
-0.0233050175,
0.0031895624,
0.0181679036,
-0.0044907718,
-0.0188950188,
-0.0469641574,
-0.052549921,
-0.0159828849,
0.0632436723,
0.0492878817,
0.0610520095,
-0.0247141905,
-0.0587579533,
0.0524179824,
0.0687469915,
-0.0388984643,
0.0199458525,
-0.0214845091,
0.0359991081,
0.0445672758,
-0.0224366318,
0.0009920433,
0.0460033342,
0.0514906198,
-0.0138609549,
0.0060438784,
0.0146697564,
0.0006502881,
-0.0555214621,
-0.0291630067,
-0.0006435905,
0.0234447736,
-0.0242346115,
0.0353884846,
-0.0314978473,
-0.0113341399,
0.0048858221,
0.0297464412,
0.0057634022,
-0.0256693438,
-0.030110715,
0.0150052644,
0.0680342689,
0.023297295,
-0.03400952,
-0.0120215863,
0.0283161197,
-0.0048497044,
0.0492815785,
0.0048097246,
0.0190184694,
0.0704076514,
-0.0371947922,
-0.0355103612,
-0.0485073328,
0.0064348411,
0.0031589379,
-0.0315415338,
-0.0202711783,
-0.0074281334,
-0.0622709021,
-0.0014184068,
0.028579725,
0.0279718991,
0.007248099,
0.0030896654,
0.0187435411,
0.0001245028,
-0.0095632989,
0.0012369466,
-0.0217196811,
0.034902662,
-0.0250063688,
0.0048059854,
-0.0065009072,
-0.0250646546,
-0.0209326241,
0.0102637634,
-0.0902622342,
-0.026212018,
0.0188230406,
-0.0593995824,
-0.004734979,
0.0187606141,
-0.051638633,
0.0007279874,
-0.0359347612,
-0.0621759705,
0.0161800496,
0.0582348593,
-0.0347001925,
0.0413847417,
-0.0140933143,
-0.0371376574,
0.0500550978,
0.0103854965,
0.0157606062,
-0.0179041252,
-0.0499993525,
0.0035519404,
0.0409959666,
0.0266563576,
0.0113040619,
0.0051289974,
-0.0496388599,
0.0371065699,
-0.0354337692,
-0.0197661221,
0.0120072477,
-0.0441054143,
0.0346045122,
-0.0409781747,
0.0280648675,
-0.0045455652,
0.0159869827,
0.041882325,
0.014060514,
-0.0275406986,
0.0808118507,
0.0085099023,
0.0167494025,
-0.0607539676,
-0.0183495134,
-0.0304830503,
0.0575157888,
0.0264081433,
0.0038240657,
-0.0152508523,
-0.0468539111,
-0.0238481369,
0.0339889377,
-0.0129939038,
-0.0576130152,
0.0376069024,
-0.0503732674,
-0.0336492024,
0.0889336839,
-0.0346382633,
0.0504529551,
0.0202594455,
0.0013147391,
-0.0228362065,
-0.0484079458,
0.0047762026,
0.0122996895,
-0.0036757246,
-0.0342799239,
-0.0069691641,
0.0252626035,
0.0043518436,
0.049332317,
-0.033441145,
0.0768904537,
0.011882077,
-0.0631639138,
-0.0155635066,
0.0354185104,
0.0057315468,
0.02274823,
-0.037242081,
-0.0223411508,
0.0843387097,
-0.0023558557,
0.0049579986,
-0.0149465185,
-0.0241867453,
0.0195305459,
0.0599535406,
0.0157418307,
0.060316354,
0.0167316385,
-0.0047163642,
-0.0207497384,
0.0319033191,
0.011120759,
-0.024208555,
-0.0246317051,
-0.0648729056,
-0.0116800126,
0.005410023,
-0.0055785845,
-0.0116110584,
0.0075247148,
-0.0154343368,
0.0413276516,
0.0002064117,
-0.0178059097,
-0.0748713762,
-0.0008214791,
0.0285428707,
-0.0110182082,
0.0182023514,
-0.0136169195,
-0.043745704,
0.0662175417,
0.034680821,
0.0136967599,
-0.029539641,
-0.0438150167,
0.013418599,
0.0301590655,
-0.0277763642,
0.0365700498,
-0.1233862415,
0.0207252335,
-0.0178261418,
0.0592163168,
0.0058704568,
-0.0126338378,
0.0298697632,
-0.0504331663,
0.0126740793,
0.0399505459,
-0.0056444784,
-0.0729555041,
0.0053575006,
0.0170873944,
-0.024223946,
-0.0442173705,
0.0017836525,
-0.0671386719,
-0.0665376484,
-0.0272662416,
-0.0152100641,
0.0536593236,
0.0020793269,
0.0098119872,
-0.0367484316,
0.0589843057,
-0.0006960272,
-0.0432481356,
-0.0484561138,
-0.0453384742,
-0.0070924121,
-0.0351002105,
0.0387928225,
0.0074502802,
0.0133685023,
0.0056336313,
0.0100343497,
0.0644227341,
-0.0534995124,
0.0262720101,
-0.0354515649,
-0.0284883119,
0.0201413557,
0.0263843574,
-0.0358203351,
-0.0489696972,
-0.025309423,
0.001887081,
0.0192304812,
0.0208145566,
0.0728817508,
-0.004046245,
-0.032264851,
-0.0053981077,
0.0701665357,
-0.0107255457,
-0.0001323824,
-0.048203323,
0.0437872484,
0.0040996294,
0.0144749209,
-0.0605857149,
-0.0163282137,
0.0055064321,
0.0160429068,
0.0192685183,
-0.041660998,
-0.0783717111,
-0.0110963825,
0.0767683834,
-0.005591833,
-0.0373741016,
0.0350906812,
0.0333899073,
0.009530508,
-0.029217571,
-0.0497998893,
-0.0178777631,
0.0171343535,
-0.0056826156,
-0.0431972295,
-0.022054242,
-0.0089736404,
-0.0656534731,
0.0868627056,
0.0045211897,
0.0367153846,
0.0106047569,
-0.0089027742,
0.0167472009,
-0.0226108916,
-0.031084789,
0.0683471635,
-0.0474605374,
-0.0318098255,
0.0054236753,
0.0596328899,
0.0193429254,
0.005353549,
-0.0095489239,
-0.0953460559,
0.0443742611,
0.0113845365,
-0.012713613,
0.0003423328,
-0.0014106669,
-0.0030332396,
-0.0164019279,
-0.0153961796,
-0.0135527225,
0.0204368308,
-0.0439430103,
-0.0140025252,
-0.0168740116,
-0.0827288181,
0.0224789828,
-0.036072053,
0.0515511408,
-0.0043676961,
-0.0017142018,
-0.0175815299,
-0.0080240695,
0.0537457317,
0.0006487796,
-0.0280723888,
0.0010578989,
0.0195905529,
-0.0268749762,
-0.0149856489,
-0.0320409089,
0.024782382,
0.0216446761,
-0.0531558394,
0.0448094569,
0.0161032602,
-0.0271075796,
-0.0053904727,
0.0008851385,
-0.0250357203,
0.0247292258,
-0.0305578988,
0.0232391041,
0.007523247,
0.031409055,
0.0301628653,
0.0246160198,
-0.0250195637,
0.0505515486,
-0.0319954641,
-0.0782009885,
-0.0471591689,
0.0322010145,
0.034453921,
-0.0080964062,
0.066127792,
-0.042690333,
-0.0263470393,
-0.0251978915,
0.0458795503,
-0.0155099127,
0.0075525423,
0.0443708487,
0.0203701463,
0.0556679368,
-0.0261098556,
0.0405261628,
0.0067638862,
0.0239792299,
-0.0318275616,
-0.0151290204,
-0.0372257642,
-0.0136865536,
-0.0115125384,
-0.0111232335,
-0.0068290127,
-0.005304819,
-0.002346162,
-0.074874945,
-0.018142499,
0.0666742027,
-0.0208911654,
-0.0181130748,
0.0270777401,
0.086353682,
-0.0031691389,
-0.0234637093,
0.0141301882,
0.0175005682,
0.0132101933,
-0.012551304,
-0.0182945821,
-6.340684854e-33,
0.0370678566,
-0.0231651086,
0.0076755527,
-0.0204412378,
0.0000163397,
0.0079194643,
-0.0696985871,
-0.0025111877,
-0.0127595104,
0.0775551647,
0.0312189516,
-0.0015565464,
0.0093114916,
0.0108238161,
-0.0025000188,
0.0412785187,
0.0156701934,
-0.0146084698,
-0.0111456979,
0.0225862898,
-0.0063007432,
0.0125183817,
0.0695971996,
-0.0650474057,
0.015900569,
0.0515999869,
0.0010199093,
-0.0297156703,
-0.0019427937,
0.0423399247,
-0.0711910203,
0.0354936123,
0.004248132,
-0.0701467246,
-0.0102507351,
0.0034866792,
-0.0579188541,
-0.0165288541,
-0.023171097,
0.0245929901,
-0.115117684,
0.045686435,
0.0378197506,
-0.0222413689,
-0.0180705078,
-0.0024832662,
0.062868908,
-0.0139030674,
0.0231534205,
-0.0030586259,
-0.0803338662,
0.0276574343,
-0.0154067948,
-0.0283354893,
0.0510311276,
0.0032070347,
-0.0021152268,
0.0635921434,
-0.0290043317,
0.0062700259,
-0.0105060125,
0.0096301576,
0.0388410203,
0.0030457319,
0.0019794183,
0.0855208337,
0.047866568,
-0.0586590171,
0.0145906555,
-0.0372254103,
0.04431355,
0.048854176,
0.0655481741,
0.0576128364,
0.0376683399,
0.0229586549,
-0.0499932729,
0.0176809784,
0.0191677026,
0.0723974705,
-0.012314762,
0.0180985499,
0.0618658587,
-0.0073016454,
-0.0354185477,
-0.0375030152,
-0.0201827269,
-0.0085022729,
-0.0172946323,
-0.018052604,
-0.0562947355,
0.0355964005,
0.0406993963,
0.0017210055,
-0.0204314757,
0.0170188826,
0.0230869148,
0.0312746987,
0.0056405473,
-0.0073635625,
-0.0446475707,
-0.0045610829,
0.0142709818,
0.031231204,
0.0493212789,
-0.0212784279,
-0.014022842,
0.023113817,
0.0430279784,
0.024537757,
-0.032442905,
-0.0511352234,
-0.0202375557,
0.0133876922,
0.0364895277,
-0.005431883,
-0.0241749287,
0.010815341,
-0.0153044658,
0.0379157364,
-0.0150268041,
-0.0387406163,
0.0045764893,
0.0011180217,
-0.0572139844,
-0.0192960408,
-0.0338538215,
-0.0854853764,
0.0159931537,
-0.0747280493,
-0.0124317184,
0.0276604407,
2.86e-7,
0.0705514401,
0.0624570847,
0.0227436014,
0.0424681902,
0.0210651476,
0.0357442759,
-0.0361102037,
0.0147789614,
-0.0302970819,
-0.1015002578,
0.0255085714,
0.062976785,
-0.009474379,
0.0471850224,
-0.0117054861,
0.0046880953,
-0.0401435569,
-0.0038505322,
-0.0365759991,
0.039136041,
0.0454142764,
0.0575335808,
-0.0451569185,
-0.0828682035,
0.0496958643,
-0.008972167,
0.0518224612,
-0.0344240144,
0.0552069582,
0.0080256481,
0.0363200791,
0.0107842991,
-0.0012103833,
0.0621642284,
0.027666783,
-0.0545116924,
0.0518548191,
-0.0101880208,
-0.0412890092,
-0.0262024496,
0.003891181,
0.0216068104,
0.0367239937,
-0.0599763915,
0.0302730408,
-0.0155899022,
-0.0267542303,
0.0012472989,
-0.0429032706,
0.0013525197,
0.0422711447,
-0.0395365208,
-0.0532488488,
0.0059768204,
0.0015704231,
0.0160753056,
-0.0364546031,
-0.0555982925,
-0.0253734067,
-0.0152375111,
-0.0498201959,
0.014981973,
-0.005550744,
-0.0950787142,
0.0242585503,
-0.0257788077,
-0.0362507403,
2.111520069e-34,
0.0525328293,
0.0043350663,
0.0171472263,
-0.0029086333,
0.0060722996,
0.0031328052,
0.0196360443,
0.0066702124,
0.0050858306,
-0.0495846309,
-0.0343200229
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12455v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12455v2 | LongDocFACTScore: Evaluating the Factuality of Long Document Abstractive Summarisation | 2023-09-21T19:54:54 | 2024-05-28T08:26:17 | Jennifer A Bishop, Qianqian Xie, Sophia Ananiadou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | Maintaining factual consistency is a critical issue in abstractive text
summarisation, however, it cannot be assessed by traditional automatic metrics
used for evaluating text summarisation, such as ROUGE scoring. Recent efforts
have been devoted to developing improved metrics for measuring factual
consistency using pre-trained language models, but these metrics have
restrictive token limits, and are therefore not suitable for evaluating long
document text summarisation. Moreover, there is limited research and resources
available for evaluating whether existing automatic evaluation metrics are fit
for purpose when applied in long document settings. In this work, we evaluate
the efficacy of automatic metrics for assessing the factual consistency of long
document text summarisation. We create a human-annotated data set for
evaluating automatic factuality metrics, LongSciVerify, which contains
fine-grained factual consistency annotations for long document summaries from
the scientific domain. We also propose a new evaluation framework,
LongDocFACTScore, which is suitable for evaluating long document summarisation.
This framework allows metrics to be efficiently extended to any length document
and outperforms existing state-of-the-art metrics in its ability to correlate
with human measures of factuality when used to evaluate long document
summarisation data sets. We make our code and LongSciVerify data set publicly
available: https://github.com/jbshp/LongDocFACTScore. | [
0.0345055386,
0.0203295369,
0.0352222808,
-0.0111922175,
-0.0468399748,
0.0086723687,
-0.0236266833,
-0.023856584,
-0.0310751703,
-0.0336245932,
0.0157283992,
-0.0117006917,
0.0616212897,
0.0047657895,
0.0015967315,
-0.0639550984,
0.0226528998,
0.003132761,
0.0255628563,
0.0046515404,
0.0301533174,
-0.0113337934,
0.0005810342,
0.0336052664,
-0.0008845359,
-0.0355417095,
0.0462582111,
-0.0260504112,
0.0543582886,
-0.0183201525,
0.0116162011,
0.0113480836,
-0.0083148824,
0.0348179974,
0.0000017102,
-0.0914970413,
-0.0304151382,
0.0277847629,
0.0046351324,
0.0690087229,
0.0399401411,
-0.0293716323,
0.0257233344,
0.0007369104,
-0.0061862511,
-0.0023528056,
-0.001320908,
0.0500929765,
0.074159503,
0.0638083965,
0.0054877433,
-0.0434043668,
0.0367193408,
-0.0116856666,
-0.0444518477,
0.0167771149,
0.0161372144,
0.0699834526,
-0.0053906422,
0.0158373304,
-0.0053787939,
0.0142175034,
0.0021408519,
-0.0305269882,
0.0203064475,
0.0147954626,
-0.0635888651,
-0.00717706,
0.0616496876,
0.0528844558,
0.0339049026,
-0.0050088703,
0.0451316722,
0.0102845067,
-0.0207165498,
-0.0056719743,
-0.0707630664,
0.034310855,
-0.0158993453,
0.0023992483,
0.0162569918,
0.0392798297,
-0.0044311751,
0.0494999252,
-0.0243860893,
0.0384373255,
0.0105467243,
-0.0109045431,
-0.0397415645,
-0.0140317297,
-0.0187467337,
-0.063955009,
0.0262467507,
0.0335517675,
0.0107605262,
-0.024486063,
-0.0512661375,
-0.0319897756,
0.0648946688,
-0.0469744876,
-0.0088239089,
-0.0063010291,
-0.0166730024,
0.0460203812,
-0.0268884823,
0.0309301578,
0.0329991095,
0.0155434757,
-0.0360677578,
-0.0013404208,
-0.0114764934,
0.038154453,
-0.0110149505,
0.0081923166,
-0.0073345434,
-0.0301930942,
-0.0531212687,
-0.0306829568,
0.0084931729,
0.0240320861,
-0.0119384173,
-0.0184003823,
0.0009010599,
-0.0006287794,
-0.0164629146,
0.046904657,
-0.048050154,
-0.0142102446,
0.0373409465,
0.0106609724,
-0.0071481899,
0.0297204517,
0.007510283,
0.0177531783,
0.0188483577,
-0.0112952925,
0.0055299313,
-0.0069452999,
-0.0021357997,
-0.0427900963,
-0.010170172,
-0.0775954127,
-0.0100125307,
-0.0747107938,
-0.0069851591,
0.0000664512,
-0.0108850449,
-0.0156786237,
-0.0108993566,
0.0095277205,
-0.0079112193,
0.0153165124,
-0.0260176416,
-0.0052365423,
0.0646694154,
0.0074437517,
0.0116300322,
0.0033702143,
0.0569719933,
0.0217654482,
0.0785971507,
0.0322869234,
0.0008520952,
-0.0148062203,
0.0210530981,
0.0029218567,
0.0712885931,
0.01821642,
-0.0215149522,
0.0203593876,
0.0081974231,
0.0572536923,
-0.0245306194,
-0.0068821781,
0.0383083187,
0.0307043977,
0.0207321215,
0.0037208891,
0.0258954,
0.0231096912,
0.0538434908,
0.067460157,
-0.0003096953,
0.0235808194,
-0.0166808739,
0.0938099027,
0.1003078669,
0.0386398211,
0.0118542043,
-0.0848991051,
-0.0095286937,
-0.0020787166,
0.0009693021,
-0.02632007,
0.0292289853,
-0.0052066129,
-0.0129611511,
0.0170263834,
-0.0016677874,
-0.0650196001,
0.0393404178,
0.0089744907,
0.0337228179,
0.0127228927,
0.0520847142,
-0.0570294447,
-0.0428696461,
-0.0071032513,
0.0151323108,
0.0265812706,
0.0406113416,
-0.025314441,
-0.0138958907,
-0.0342288427,
-0.0146001363,
-0.0084172124,
0.0190860499,
-0.0562572777,
0.0077219401,
0.0049494328,
0.0625302568,
-0.0434970036,
-0.0800470561,
0.045856528,
-0.0187876206,
0.0015669619,
-0.0306664985,
-0.0248630084,
0.0094025303,
0.0329867341,
-0.0273167547,
0.0400769822,
0.0048182891,
-0.0093144625,
0.0128294351,
-0.0034682665,
-0.0158491284,
-0.0065489546,
0.0687924325,
-0.0641701669,
-0.0014247253,
0.0397241935,
-0.0143349404,
-0.0381792337,
0.0034838833,
-0.0700153857,
-0.0327501111,
-0.020124102,
0.0257320553,
0.0273805875,
0.0141619127,
-0.0101802992,
0.0269614737,
0.0112066511,
0.020565832,
0.0204376988,
-0.0288897492,
0.0235604085,
-0.035309568,
-0.002388662,
-0.0145845115,
0.0221249666,
-0.0047569973,
0.0790434852,
-0.0123576475,
-0.0337070823,
-0.0074568437,
-0.0931436867,
0.0092155887,
-0.0209161658,
0.000964033,
0.0338193588,
-0.0170814674,
-0.0004962598,
0.0245620739,
-0.0248936918,
-0.0539545715,
0.0122151226,
-0.0056789117,
0.0546415187,
0.001438673,
0.0233646184,
-0.0782326311,
-0.0271964371,
-0.0126325814,
0.0394256227,
0.0447113886,
-0.0154802771,
-0.0332053937,
0.0139646493,
-0.0454921387,
-0.0437589549,
0.0029319758,
-0.0058366088,
-0.008938388,
0.0129772574,
0.0508688092,
0.0586945117,
0.0677231401,
-0.0234242808,
0.0437688306,
0.0167328715,
0.0026118606,
-0.0378039181,
-0.0505523048,
0.0493096933,
0.0358042046,
-0.0167712979,
0.0483672358,
0.0097489739,
0.0052003493,
-0.01550123,
0.0112830559,
0.0086119287,
-0.0452511609,
0.0040662205,
0.0037524968,
-0.0115222661,
0.0042951838,
0.030390542,
-0.0050215027,
-0.0229551475,
0.0911059603,
-0.066663608,
0.0308091715,
-0.0639498234,
0.0030250314,
-0.0566954203,
0.0359405018,
0.021784991,
-0.004486863,
-0.0098875379,
0.0267929882,
-0.0046122991,
-0.0249433685,
0.0389031619,
-0.0256149508,
0.0606248863,
-0.0453498103,
0.0198178254,
-0.0198960789,
0.007053094,
0.021409614,
-0.0323100276,
-0.0053080847,
0.0243541896,
-0.0118815023,
-0.0279824436,
-0.0454427116,
-0.0058886432,
0.0598004535,
0.0776680335,
-0.0323186964,
-0.0172784496,
-0.0040958556,
0.0406308696,
0.0707348958,
0.018651247,
0.0641836077,
-0.035810452,
0.0068927915,
0.0516409427,
0.0003866376,
-0.0112318508,
0.0018212717,
-0.0476234592,
-0.0409357585,
-0.0824943185,
0.012897226,
-0.0174895842,
0.0453533716,
-0.0630226955,
0.0049092011,
0.1025068685,
0.0129351271,
0.0262618121,
-0.0111280074,
0.0037054166,
0.0225107167,
-0.0118452879,
-0.0200198013,
-0.0540210605,
-0.0072189802,
-0.0105394265,
0.0376042202,
0.0238999818,
-0.0372727774,
-0.0006625385,
-0.0470942184,
0.0212077089,
0.0250986647,
-0.046541322,
-0.0265499521,
-0.048148144,
0.0171759538,
-0.0236924123,
-0.0103045441,
0.0244937725,
-0.0134410542,
0.0118451407,
-0.0095416447,
-0.0869492814,
0.0175648704,
0.0020194862,
-0.0534960553,
0.005081695,
0.0467927419,
0.0476409718,
0.0031015193,
0.0149887055,
0.0314819179,
-0.0324325971,
-0.0480129272,
0.039769236,
0.0621123873,
-0.0087778624,
0.0328436159,
-0.0194327086,
0.0600535944,
0.0410770066,
-0.0155249136,
0.0288555138,
0.033342801,
0.0005927719,
-0.0128276348,
-0.0703059435,
0.0495015457,
-0.0493570715,
0.0867912248,
0.0409014896,
0.0195963588,
-0.0507737882,
-0.029677799,
-0.0074033192,
-0.0468576886,
-0.0225860663,
-0.0147905564,
-0.0614399053,
-0.0116124982,
-0.0960630924,
-0.0571994446,
0.0071767373,
-0.0356970653,
-0.0170458127,
-0.0147047006,
0.0097331526,
0.0114471596,
-0.0461608842,
0.0288843066,
-0.0067592319,
0.0218168292,
-0.0330940299,
-0.0028269072,
0.0771776438,
-0.0022782313,
-0.0088185407,
0.0212212484,
-0.0314871073,
-0.0308777634,
-0.006655178,
0.024058653,
0.0188517757,
0.0545227081,
0.0088991132,
0.0068470538,
0.0671567619,
0.0215819683,
-0.0291578714,
0.0587840155,
0.0283993091,
0.0307935793,
-0.0174556021,
-0.0112161608,
-0.0579254292,
0.0078734821,
-0.0558283217,
0.0494788513,
-0.0144539345,
-0.0593209937,
0.0104229283,
0.087070398,
0.0069159181,
-0.0354482345,
0.0207894202,
-0.0125801535,
-0.0387926027,
-0.0305453818,
-0.0288681742,
-0.023960514,
0.0498476736,
-0.0103654237,
0.0415035896,
-0.0198618341,
0.0664269701,
-0.0256848764,
-0.0078899944,
-0.0164243393,
0.0072746957,
-0.0252644345,
-0.0144229475,
-0.0452556424,
-0.0354664288,
-0.0677165389,
-0.0621058121,
-0.0604261495,
0.0251617786,
-0.0086111054,
-0.0087931678,
0.0547015555,
0.0334638543,
-0.0158963613,
0.0294436738,
-0.0926610902,
0.0552105159,
-0.073867254,
0.0235358402,
0.010889628,
-0.0371686257,
0.0767738745,
-0.0361264423,
-0.0173226055,
-0.0423634052,
0.0490582772,
0.0291325282,
0.0145832421,
-0.0635008588,
0.0179168247,
0.0026417642,
0.0195319578,
0.0640426651,
-0.0373227336,
0.0002003289,
0.0162603837,
-0.0287156478,
-0.0404262953,
-0.059722051,
-0.0734964237,
0.0048956769,
0.0083223181,
-0.0434930474,
-0.0709805936,
-0.0118324235,
0.0562822782,
0.0603623539,
0.0119976066,
-0.0190881882,
0.0075789234,
0.0354725011,
-0.0214422029,
-0.0088241668,
-0.0480962768,
0.0146681815,
-0.0071646413,
0.0116816023,
-0.0225821938,
-5.160204203e-33,
-0.0287981536,
-0.0190347899,
-0.0293626934,
0.027728593,
-0.0739172474,
0.035459023,
-0.0640587881,
-0.0247010458,
0.005559375,
0.0417584218,
-0.003889729,
0.0167994816,
-0.0019290234,
0.0134064006,
-0.0049518556,
0.0356757306,
0.0254695565,
0.0165287554,
-0.0760141015,
0.0171392485,
0.035037186,
-0.0393052585,
0.0211667717,
-0.0486775301,
0.0659662113,
-0.0119436206,
-0.0178133678,
-0.0129768169,
0.0120224589,
0.0358495452,
-0.0022965944,
0.0063680732,
0.0304856617,
-0.0483177677,
-0.0442542583,
-0.0056693018,
-0.0940429568,
-0.0251673982,
0.0388695672,
-0.0513917208,
-0.0673990399,
-0.0318234153,
0.0511823595,
-0.023435263,
-0.020658059,
-0.0832850561,
0.0652123317,
-0.0611327663,
-0.0223380998,
-0.079087913,
-0.0346141867,
0.0489589013,
-0.0252927765,
-0.0084456103,
-0.0030283981,
-0.0019796484,
0.0028986891,
0.0231970381,
-0.0302103553,
0.0346489586,
0.011530959,
0.0529670976,
0.0057323035,
-0.0034756444,
0.0195740033,
0.0694967881,
-0.0211270712,
-0.0046530128,
-0.0307766497,
0.0144382967,
-0.0063162511,
-0.0077246279,
0.0645560175,
0.0528195165,
0.0359659828,
0.023435317,
-0.0522582605,
0.1043322459,
-0.0273558479,
0.0226701126,
-0.0063544535,
-0.0278411433,
0.0107807526,
0.0114927944,
-0.0316008963,
0.0344902277,
0.0050679897,
0.013435198,
-0.0364134237,
-0.0072369454,
-0.059396293,
-0.0140178725,
0.0077325352,
-0.0332747661,
0.0244665891,
0.0085467761,
-0.0378682017,
0.0340705514,
0.0193427969,
-0.025660418,
-0.029132627,
0.0467669144,
0.0015692695,
0.0242462531,
0.0087818475,
-0.0307215825,
0.0571579561,
-0.0149656413,
-0.0063931011,
0.0122805238,
0.0170480255,
-0.0200794172,
-0.0162708461,
-0.0217701495,
-0.0125672016,
0.0285002831,
-0.0002953165,
0.0347892791,
-0.0001323825,
0.0399253555,
-0.0094239851,
-0.0024837076,
0.0461146906,
0.0356947593,
-0.0353950895,
0.0277807582,
-0.0141749782,
0.0015942121,
-0.0062959027,
-0.0396937057,
0.0072253593,
-0.0053130393,
2.22e-7,
0.0483760573,
0.0335389264,
0.0886715055,
-0.0066516087,
-0.0362162776,
0.0120068761,
-0.0216584075,
0.0134269521,
-0.0193582792,
-0.0312425271,
0.0217136275,
0.0150782289,
0.0401727445,
0.0327328146,
-0.0702211037,
-0.0122727063,
-0.0935250744,
-0.0650082678,
-0.0336714685,
-0.0260533094,
0.0329476111,
0.040722277,
-0.0024067843,
0.0109492196,
-0.0059886076,
-0.0379577652,
0.0263547227,
-0.0029508912,
-0.0408546701,
0.039374128,
0.0784988627,
-0.0300827026,
0.0168506391,
-0.0468129218,
-0.0137493312,
-0.0063526118,
0.0614364259,
0.0487416759,
0.0380461626,
0.0077104196,
-0.0135660749,
-0.0375793427,
0.030496506,
0.0005144414,
0.0313941836,
-0.0387541316,
-0.0027549691,
-0.0457052067,
-0.0629763976,
0.0306670442,
0.015950717,
0.0194251835,
-0.0349400043,
0.0603897087,
-0.0075679035,
0.0018459591,
0.0191343743,
-0.0574872307,
-0.0692036524,
0.023528697,
-0.0056904121,
-0.0420261733,
0.0165767074,
-0.0224268828,
0.0149065545,
-0.0813817233,
-0.024905052,
2.103550125e-34,
0.1165587008,
-0.034159705,
-0.0293269195,
-0.0440745167,
0.0385561921,
-0.0262612514,
-0.0043088184,
-0.0120688975,
0.0224646963,
-0.0477566868,
-0.0015095236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12444v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12444v3 | Foundation Metrics for Evaluating Effectiveness of Healthcare Conversations Powered by Generative AI | 2023-09-21T19:36:48 | 2024-02-28T20:15:54 | Mahyar Abbasian, Elahe Khatibi, Iman Azimi, David Oniani, Zahra Shakeri Hossein Abad, Alexander Thieme, Ram Sriram, Zhongqi Yang, Yanshan Wang, Bryant Lin, Olivier Gevaert, Li-Jia Li, Ramesh Jain, Amir M. Rahmani | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generative Artificial Intelligence is set to revolutionize healthcare
delivery by transforming traditional patient care into a more personalized,
efficient, and proactive process. Chatbots, serving as interactive
conversational models, will probably drive this patient-centered transformation
in healthcare. Through the provision of various services, including diagnosis,
personalized lifestyle recommendations, and mental health support, the
objective is to substantially augment patient health outcomes, all the while
mitigating the workload burden on healthcare providers. The life-critical
nature of healthcare applications necessitates establishing a unified and
comprehensive set of evaluation metrics for conversational models. Existing
evaluation metrics proposed for various generic large language models (LLMs)
demonstrate a lack of comprehension regarding medical and health concepts and
their significance in promoting patients' well-being. Moreover, these metrics
neglect pivotal user-centered aspects, including trust-building, ethics,
personalization, empathy, user comprehension, and emotional support. The
purpose of this paper is to explore state-of-the-art LLM-based evaluation
metrics that are specifically applicable to the assessment of interactive
conversational models in healthcare. Subsequently, we present an comprehensive
set of evaluation metrics designed to thoroughly assess the performance of
healthcare chatbots from an end-user perspective. These metrics encompass an
evaluation of language processing abilities, impact on real-world clinical
tasks, and effectiveness in user-interactive conversations. Finally, we engage
in a discussion concerning the challenges associated with defining and
implementing these metrics, with particular emphasis on confounding factors
such as the target audience, evaluation methods, and prompt techniques involved
in the evaluation process. | [
0.0747672766,
0.0363365524,
-0.0257706326,
-0.0272542965,
-0.0368250385,
0.0279329922,
0.0189750809,
0.0015051195,
0.052188389,
0.0281757824,
-0.0068213679,
-0.0372151695,
0.012401483,
0.0756697282,
-0.0054849354,
-0.0639999211,
-0.0004074234,
0.0390298776,
0.0566610657,
0.0259458758,
-0.005280158,
0.0055191354,
-0.0415048748,
0.1012947187,
-0.0163468197,
-0.0151664792,
0.0307338294,
0.0111107277,
0.0419658907,
-0.0702175647,
-0.0272489451,
0.0110212695,
-0.0284092501,
0.0055862986,
0.0000021285,
-0.0576012246,
0.0111991717,
0.0286578462,
-0.0396881588,
-0.0806233659,
0.0863530412,
-0.0067862459,
-0.0363794379,
0.0333370641,
-0.0387976691,
0.0092483796,
0.041573327,
0.0251792483,
0.0379685834,
0.05818877,
-0.023693962,
0.0241507292,
0.0156888105,
-0.0019580959,
0.0256738383,
-0.0442950875,
-0.0016829914,
0.0407345816,
0.0270704906,
-0.0367908776,
-0.0015442284,
0.054796312,
0.0151183512,
-0.0209662896,
0.027489407,
0.0406785719,
0.0034152425,
-0.045389872,
-0.0118882321,
0.0611319691,
0.0056514135,
0.029385224,
-0.0023421457,
0.0104397144,
0.0168432835,
-0.0171065275,
-0.0439616106,
-0.0075254776,
-0.0109788775,
-0.0098176291,
-0.0455770679,
0.0216123369,
0.0423931219,
-0.0049605947,
0.0321976356,
0.0010030732,
0.0277212318,
-0.0173800532,
-0.0073122974,
-0.0286516473,
-0.0208958797,
-0.0415455922,
0.0194257572,
0.0383787639,
-0.061760921,
0.0235141832,
-0.0047862888,
0.009404432,
0.0498613305,
-0.0527069643,
0.0196421836,
0.0407922752,
0.0185922943,
0.0347997248,
0.0222856458,
0.0288890842,
0.013077125,
-0.0115436129,
-0.0411803201,
0.0206334107,
-0.0424105823,
-0.0059264251,
-0.0227328874,
-0.0002299182,
-0.0129127549,
-0.0467067435,
-0.0738674253,
0.0308372565,
-0.0198742282,
0.0268416163,
0.026438171,
0.0291900132,
-0.0077272411,
0.0126203485,
-0.038881138,
-0.0184166748,
-0.0452266037,
0.0000656316,
0.0223155618,
-0.1026809737,
0.0337409675,
0.0212068204,
-0.0112183569,
0.0142503111,
0.0000189239,
0.0726224184,
0.0143301161,
-0.038346108,
0.0310375132,
-0.0183378141,
-0.0376930833,
-0.0334666334,
0.0024993243,
-0.0399004743,
0.0407578871,
-0.0117044002,
0.0369171165,
-0.0369813293,
0.0204428602,
0.0048690247,
-0.0011123026,
0.0361237302,
-0.0356698073,
0.0395789258,
0.0207358059,
0.0483468436,
-0.0085399784,
-0.0089612808,
0.0437965542,
0.0103358235,
0.0455023646,
-0.0272810217,
0.0387209356,
-0.0008234295,
-0.0145752616,
-0.0366021469,
0.0384004116,
-0.0135262609,
-0.0183891207,
0.0768344551,
-0.0407245569,
0.081107311,
-0.0252931751,
0.0151926884,
0.0605535507,
0.0739361718,
0.0120952409,
0.0315278023,
0.0435324982,
-0.0124731902,
0.0069619492,
-0.0307836309,
0.0100954361,
0.0075969165,
-0.001407183,
-0.0285610277,
0.0001995676,
-0.0059746923,
-0.0204054546,
-0.0793904364,
-0.0099166781,
-0.0452359095,
0.017597286,
-0.0006220077,
0.0015619174,
-0.0028263254,
-0.0301350243,
-0.0108153215,
0.0148389153,
-0.0778435543,
-0.0298515782,
-0.0893946663,
0.0156328436,
0.1295310408,
0.0729984269,
-0.005226986,
-0.0255628135,
-0.0047216318,
-0.0303832199,
0.0308706574,
0.022258332,
-0.0090002893,
-0.0075585376,
-0.0246444866,
-0.0075685154,
0.0234615654,
0.0023890056,
-0.0142067615,
-0.0075216102,
0.0302679241,
-0.0149906008,
-0.0091001252,
-0.0308818258,
0.0221467093,
-0.047299929,
0.0029414662,
-0.0041048392,
-0.0052474113,
0.0633762702,
0.0502708368,
-0.000892431,
0.0296703409,
0.0176487286,
-0.0150671583,
-0.0223231018,
0.0578146838,
-0.0420915857,
0.0160309188,
-0.0023773366,
-0.0270969402,
0.024790585,
0.0150736813,
0.0080868341,
-0.0062326076,
-0.0211217664,
-0.0911721513,
0.0162525382,
-0.0203681439,
0.0304124616,
0.0222985409,
0.0131729348,
-0.0196755454,
-0.0043471558,
-0.0332186446,
0.0060497802,
-0.0043478296,
0.0204054434,
0.0008642072,
-0.0372016877,
-0.0278021581,
0.0255941823,
-0.0151657425,
0.0088054882,
0.0175948087,
0.0302997027,
-0.0521442294,
-0.0421548784,
-0.1536497921,
-0.0344918668,
0.0149379699,
-0.0336499363,
0.0088587441,
0.0297501758,
-0.0088909669,
-0.0129039614,
-0.0620789677,
0.0307358857,
0.0450968333,
-0.005609727,
0.0204936322,
0.0177141652,
-0.0446363203,
-0.0254469756,
0.0174072366,
-0.0134097198,
0.0173868407,
0.0392512344,
0.0094464011,
-0.0053015486,
-0.0298982039,
-0.0600236505,
-0.0336121917,
-0.0105957771,
-0.0652694404,
0.0533655398,
0.0176648218,
0.0361372344,
0.057785362,
0.0371922068,
0.0449059345,
0.0001563883,
0.0068606106,
-0.0232405607,
-0.0025149181,
-0.0383268632,
-0.0403129645,
0.0001721577,
-0.0772192404,
0.0194168258,
0.0573260784,
0.0336718895,
0.035026364,
-0.058653757,
0.0227587242,
-0.0184182562,
-0.0322740935,
-0.0261353366,
0.0103260549,
-0.0415996835,
0.0552194789,
0.0095752869,
-0.0469664633,
0.0618649945,
-0.0184707195,
0.0154968668,
-0.0421989225,
-0.041786775,
-0.0368074551,
0.0131954066,
-0.0160480812,
0.0383009985,
0.0062283454,
-0.0131355748,
0.0169403907,
0.0261449367,
-0.0271505471,
-0.0835702717,
-0.006019738,
-0.0194894429,
-0.0206568651,
0.0333133526,
-0.0125340708,
-0.0525836684,
0.0098108863,
-0.0203376878,
0.0023094737,
0.0704207793,
-0.0122788483,
-0.0346569344,
0.0165683329,
0.0093004163,
0.0474758968,
0.0295501146,
-0.0316701755,
0.0020127501,
-0.0334899016,
0.0205373671,
0.0380960628,
0.0133954613,
0.0281295162,
0.0740870088,
0.050612174,
0.0004042839,
0.0108074723,
0.0001393613,
-0.0115168309,
-0.0117118517,
-0.0044355448,
0.0187504832,
0.0302597266,
0.0537621677,
-0.0163533911,
-0.0177086424,
0.1145752966,
0.0203519594,
-0.0433612764,
0.04961586,
-0.0358488224,
-0.0333799124,
-0.026157761,
-0.0101897279,
-0.0589784421,
0.001624906,
-0.0049967375,
0.048163224,
-0.062424738,
-0.0205414444,
0.0262392573,
-0.0447273403,
0.0278139245,
-0.0108387256,
-0.0103872996,
-0.0290829837,
-0.0165663045,
0.0123664876,
0.0030418944,
0.0156791229,
-0.0267133415,
0.0164223406,
-0.0260072183,
-0.018079225,
-0.0584131666,
-0.0733042285,
0.0504056066,
0.0081177112,
0.0877994746,
0.1036889181,
0.0762953386,
0.0335481428,
-0.0294096544,
-0.0144603159,
0.0641587153,
0.0178822111,
0.002346888,
0.060393557,
0.0064389044,
0.016724268,
-0.0589326173,
0.0137879085,
-0.0004618749,
-0.0214835797,
0.0020116656,
0.0176108461,
-0.0252258945,
-0.0213079713,
-0.0466790199,
0.0600993522,
0.0484008454,
0.0579818338,
0.0410398208,
-0.0372209884,
-0.0114755249,
0.0005239623,
0.0617595091,
0.0178977326,
-0.0292526651,
-0.0054888362,
0.0053223171,
-0.0552425198,
-0.0843990147,
-0.0391933694,
0.0060406597,
-0.0169756375,
0.0003758124,
-0.0231153928,
0.0232831128,
0.0452420078,
-0.015248308,
0.0079458682,
0.0195561536,
0.0228996575,
-0.0722466111,
-0.0347112902,
0.0106170299,
-0.0277743973,
0.0080487374,
0.0215609092,
0.0028118051,
0.0200295597,
0.0236885566,
0.0624119863,
0.0207139365,
-0.0321198851,
-0.0340740755,
-0.0236049164,
-0.0032493593,
0.0418803655,
-0.0606274195,
-0.0212910715,
0.0142782014,
0.0816420764,
-0.0025010719,
0.0035798696,
-0.021171825,
0.0368631966,
-0.027910592,
0.0465902947,
-0.016174674,
-0.0557359494,
0.0171299726,
0.059517961,
-0.004050802,
-0.0160688702,
-0.0147840194,
0.0174179226,
-0.000538224,
-0.0612286627,
0.0106075043,
-0.0563153848,
-0.0196059868,
0.016141437,
0.0232418273,
0.0009160649,
0.0048113926,
-0.0830799416,
-0.0427976064,
-0.0352779366,
0.0147900358,
0.0038870829,
0.008225169,
0.000485939,
-0.003522295,
-0.0166374315,
0.0111021167,
-0.0304663051,
0.0114989057,
0.0370728895,
0.0736228898,
-0.0223332364,
-0.0058493936,
0.0349956751,
0.0870649815,
-0.0383580513,
-0.0724047944,
-0.0074380734,
0.0627636388,
0.0231410209,
0.0583731867,
0.0309575479,
-0.0357474834,
0.0053009908,
-0.0286612306,
0.0084467493,
0.0007959634,
-0.0346451066,
-0.0085620657,
0.0014426055,
-0.0008575771,
-0.0426032841,
0.0453102887,
-0.0587802678,
0.0176057275,
-0.0395605564,
-0.0471124537,
-0.0460040346,
-0.0127675142,
-0.001862811,
-0.0022441812,
-0.0358313397,
0.0008771068,
-0.06238598,
-0.0521579087,
-0.0069038621,
0.0217935294,
-0.0113462992,
-0.0368564166,
0.0573564023,
0.0399888083,
-0.0278953332,
-0.0202249028,
-0.0346965119,
0.0343575515,
-0.0572967716,
0.0216257591,
-0.0057009575,
-5.863659328e-33,
0.007445192,
-0.0425783917,
0.0194280799,
0.0023622762,
-0.0238032769,
0.0001626643,
-0.0542269163,
0.0077565936,
-0.0114083132,
0.0279366262,
-0.0125429882,
0.0086028939,
-0.0098137762,
0.0270964094,
-0.0360844992,
-0.0360554196,
0.0429704934,
-0.0041118478,
-0.0443525799,
0.0572691225,
-0.0236447006,
0.0140265413,
-0.003953075,
-0.09691374,
0.0473271124,
-0.0057085212,
-0.0149396854,
0.0160335079,
0.0286206212,
0.0420488976,
-0.0273393095,
0.0469160601,
0.0369620025,
-0.0040407535,
0.0068014376,
0.0364959054,
-0.0323600844,
-0.0180535968,
0.0167523455,
-0.0168714635,
-0.0794839934,
-0.0466587916,
0.0107748192,
-0.011450395,
-0.0691742301,
-0.0072283344,
0.0130099924,
-0.0534409545,
0.0142038483,
-0.0262882542,
-0.0463467799,
0.0263632704,
-0.0150092943,
-0.0503420793,
-0.0342091806,
0.0298685022,
-0.0566782728,
0.0322992131,
-0.0100419736,
0.0079244692,
0.0171308629,
-0.0367563963,
0.0376505852,
-0.0477514789,
0.011947386,
0.0373787358,
0.0278149433,
0.0251867492,
-0.074622184,
0.0107037611,
-0.039898362,
0.0412956402,
0.070805274,
0.0416845009,
-0.0363301635,
-0.0116805062,
-0.0296144374,
0.0546453372,
-0.0095794527,
0.0377562791,
0.0458831079,
0.0055616717,
-0.0895373449,
0.0168079846,
-0.0307126716,
0.0022637378,
-0.0205918178,
-0.06256257,
0.0317988172,
-0.0130679142,
0.007915956,
-0.0514381826,
-0.0317970105,
-0.0342355967,
0.055402752,
-0.0022737144,
0.0368000381,
0.0098081166,
-0.0172654185,
-0.0201267675,
-0.0245935582,
0.0347340703,
0.0469875522,
0.0283214673,
0.0555119328,
-0.0256427508,
-0.0198319517,
-0.0345851518,
-0.0047954395,
-0.012406894,
0.0035679308,
0.0341888145,
0.01096767,
-0.002304696,
0.0194616504,
-0.0018853985,
-0.0417710356,
0.0304671712,
-0.0059783524,
0.0338744149,
-0.06300769,
-0.0337240137,
-0.0236584563,
-0.0265727807,
-0.0843324289,
0.0049927742,
-0.0448984504,
0.0318347029,
0.0321552157,
-0.0373338498,
-0.0121372892,
-0.0214334913,
2.903e-7,
0.0261304695,
0.0326641351,
-0.0005758458,
0.0001655887,
0.0271537825,
0.0168587733,
0.0182995219,
0.0121685117,
0.0071576713,
-0.0171781592,
0.0283181965,
0.0250583496,
0.0655678585,
0.017743405,
-0.0320843235,
-0.0256358311,
-0.0812471062,
-0.0061906474,
0.0044449321,
0.0028031266,
0.0746869519,
0.0315297507,
-0.0397121944,
-0.0222973544,
0.0305732433,
0.010647174,
0.0104180509,
-0.0751041993,
-0.0215606932,
0.0355523676,
0.0457269251,
0.0062455018,
0.0401418135,
0.0051794471,
0.0001381666,
-0.0276716743,
0.0287023913,
0.0823272169,
-0.0413767844,
-0.013115338,
0.0191380698,
0.0149361668,
0.0228853673,
-0.0614807345,
0.0429513492,
-0.061263904,
-0.0591353439,
-0.0143871559,
-0.0061726789,
-0.0326778591,
0.0784395412,
-0.0572721325,
-0.0569920875,
0.0228334032,
0.0316903926,
0.0103475722,
0.0163400471,
-0.0254813228,
0.0076243421,
-0.0111529762,
-0.0510155708,
-0.0903111696,
0.0017284007,
-0.013537528,
-0.0277466346,
-0.0473735183,
0.0420670807,
2.058930013e-34,
0.0282173622,
0.0245584231,
0.0150218271,
0.009884079,
0.0599420145,
0.0263530295,
0.0340707712,
0.0160197672,
0.036064934,
-0.0638378337,
-0.0065762126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12443v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12443v2 | Active Learning for Multilingual Fingerspelling Corpora | 2023-09-21T19:36:22 | 2024-06-13T15:04:18 | Shuai Wang, Eric Nalisnick | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | We apply active learning to help with data scarcity problems in sign
languages. In particular, we perform a novel analysis of the effect of
pre-training. Since many sign languages are linguistic descendants of French
sign language, they share hand configurations, which pre-training can hopefully
exploit. We test this hypothesis on American, Chinese, German, and Irish
fingerspelling corpora. We do observe a benefit from pre-training, but this may
be due to visual rather than linguistic similarities | [
-0.0401125811,
0.0238387473,
-0.0285370257,
0.0026433861,
-0.0346330181,
0.0566942021,
0.0219077244,
0.0078119333,
0.0141314194,
-0.0025399558,
-0.0583511889,
-0.0465617441,
0.0381237864,
0.0218210183,
0.0397342518,
-0.0553232245,
0.0379357897,
-0.0349657126,
-0.0568000339,
-0.0391593426,
0.0217246041,
-0.012784088,
-0.0596641377,
0.0364300236,
-0.0715659931,
0.034115281,
0.001545902,
-0.0186062921,
-0.0277678967,
-0.0142160365,
-0.049285993,
0.0415808596,
0.0323071182,
0.014675837,
0.0000018961,
-0.0126380194,
0.0297940988,
-0.0329656154,
0.0282032099,
0.0215454306,
0.0150805162,
-0.0424996428,
0.0112239989,
0.0132650537,
-0.0260279607,
-0.0812426731,
0.05982887,
0.0263463818,
-0.0127926376,
-0.0126076043,
-0.0162946675,
0.0626439229,
0.0223721415,
-0.0362411365,
0.0130377365,
0.039800927,
0.0282669161,
-0.031664975,
0.0067080115,
-0.0905129164,
-0.0399817266,
0.1032008082,
0.0105217211,
-0.0166245177,
-0.0492603257,
0.0253149122,
0.0060226396,
-0.0065343687,
-0.0055298391,
0.0140950484,
0.0049390462,
-0.0006311993,
0.0215265714,
-0.0523892567,
0.0404074043,
0.0814449564,
-0.0118804229,
0.024127543,
-0.0143755721,
0.0161958318,
0.0032992417,
-0.0332598425,
0.0408183038,
-0.0268628616,
0.0152198821,
0.0340044461,
0.0095162801,
-0.0623782799,
0.0388235971,
0.0241088718,
0.0082427198,
-0.0083254958,
0.0180358142,
-0.0175570715,
-0.0288223792,
-0.00813103,
-0.011831875,
-0.0231896862,
-0.0264560711,
-0.0555560067,
-0.0122347083,
0.0422616079,
-0.0219701845,
-0.0273346044,
0.0692199096,
-0.0314726606,
-0.0177722871,
0.0582159571,
-0.0433129184,
0.0298061874,
-0.02187475,
-0.0215965901,
-0.0263712462,
-0.0163955912,
0.0388851836,
0.002079403,
-0.0354677364,
0.0148694422,
-0.0006218677,
-0.0340922661,
0.0229628645,
-0.0076245875,
-0.0065092612,
0.0142393271,
-0.0167654771,
0.044953946,
-0.0027450849,
0.0472610295,
-0.0781484246,
-0.0529068857,
0.0270666517,
0.0226949751,
-0.0079780184,
-0.0185783003,
0.0178604089,
0.026124021,
-0.0380347371,
0.0046245772,
0.0119548794,
0.0454380773,
0.0349646471,
0.0051575974,
-0.0282802768,
-0.0338928066,
-0.0068592541,
-0.0241323188,
0.0284226015,
-0.0785193071,
-0.0287704803,
-0.0397106707,
-0.0091070058,
0.0268143229,
-0.0385068841,
0.0243829433,
0.0527924411,
-0.0436717495,
-0.0532076955,
0.0557253808,
0.0100179128,
-0.0311900266,
0.015195475,
-0.0481956191,
0.0172137767,
0.0753181502,
-0.0112651968,
0.0123657892,
0.0248400383,
-0.0509664007,
0.0017080774,
-0.0055256295,
-0.0405291989,
0.0142937824,
-0.0501496904,
-0.0009864001,
0.0352926254,
0.0968766212,
0.0169413015,
-0.0535835698,
0.0300567634,
-0.0101581421,
0.0091988007,
0.0200101715,
-0.0262495503,
-0.0089846076,
0.0331221409,
-0.0230175499,
-0.0293631256,
0.0069563519,
-0.0435684733,
-0.0306042843,
-0.0176590588,
-0.0473004133,
0.0160787702,
0.0252977218,
0.0414334461,
0.0208477397,
0.0131461499,
-0.0085153235,
0.0444927588,
-0.0174212102,
0.0209022406,
0.0014883794,
-0.0452025123,
0.0034664739,
-0.0225340277,
-0.0150206937,
-0.0305538587,
-0.0077937325,
-0.0181401689,
0.0210467316,
0.0094691487,
-0.0274984594,
0.0496282615,
-0.0167711396,
-0.0411595181,
0.0750891045,
-0.00147724,
0.0416513532,
-0.057758715,
0.0426002704,
-0.0259366594,
0.0075762062,
-0.0003867136,
0.025503194,
-0.031715069,
-0.0246189572,
0.0421614423,
0.0104351053,
0.0216398481,
0.004283898,
-0.0368756875,
-0.0093570231,
0.0108985659,
-0.0379416719,
-0.0149077941,
0.0489694551,
-0.0412693731,
0.0256327372,
0.0554748103,
-0.069819726,
-0.0466322526,
-0.0093406932,
0.0237846468,
-0.0458867103,
0.018895667,
0.0161795095,
0.0411199033,
-0.055441834,
0.0285478327,
-0.0103158308,
-0.026891863,
0.004821219,
0.0330026597,
-0.0303638764,
-0.0011086887,
-0.0197989866,
-0.0409171395,
0.031771522,
-0.0920296982,
0.001277108,
0.0163689852,
-0.0115442602,
0.0182095319,
0.063104324,
0.0397508368,
0.0123586617,
0.0180813186,
-0.0311725456,
-0.0269550458,
-0.0070262477,
0.0250094794,
0.0058913468,
0.0086334478,
-0.0145271728,
-0.0291389227,
-0.0340345465,
-0.0015748321,
0.0319232792,
-0.0052061682,
-0.005283915,
0.0035436694,
-0.0288906135,
-0.0190796796,
-0.0303539038,
-0.0036696505,
-0.0043188897,
0.025882462,
-0.0684924498,
-0.0235371832,
-0.0138850119,
0.0144209284,
0.0513125062,
0.005610304,
-0.0120834503,
0.0264088307,
-0.0112772398,
-0.0544678383,
-0.0262844861,
-0.0485555828,
0.037425328,
0.06222881,
0.0137025062,
-0.0150623061,
-0.0238345023,
-0.0188063271,
0.0286580566,
-0.0793945193,
-0.0344571993,
0.0210067146,
0.0564446263,
0.0361517929,
0.0169632025,
-0.051349882,
-0.0616221465,
-0.0190096833,
-0.0660661459,
-0.0275867544,
0.008838295,
-0.0348104946,
-0.0344748981,
0.0006495806,
-0.063613981,
0.0390195735,
-0.0310590547,
-0.0004742401,
0.0353902876,
-0.0320775993,
0.0156002529,
0.0305145439,
0.0183885619,
-0.0013014523,
-0.0425595865,
-0.0488517247,
-0.032710731,
0.0185270663,
0.0566342473,
0.019850567,
-0.0205008257,
-0.0310910717,
0.0265852232,
-0.0181934778,
-0.0471065231,
-0.0023042685,
0.027175298,
-0.0007357443,
-0.0019482609,
0.0396978669,
-0.0478717312,
0.0137588633,
-0.0080433739,
0.047793217,
0.0592271611,
0.0540640168,
-0.0057669152,
-0.0034282818,
-0.0474081263,
0.0115097966,
0.0106145674,
-0.0369405709,
-0.0848341212,
-0.032997448,
0.0057305614,
0.0015240752,
0.0108702006,
-0.0030484379,
0.0296634473,
0.0380018279,
0.0209905282,
-0.0440154821,
0.0228048451,
-0.0197806004,
0.0444131717,
0.0344419889,
0.0612621717,
0.0147690792,
-0.0964348689,
0.0135731753,
0.0298524629,
-0.0013915603,
0.0011466412,
0.0036374545,
-0.0553499833,
-0.0178034324,
-0.0208300687,
0.0339152142,
0.0243801866,
-0.0295683425,
0.0011789086,
-0.0772196054,
-0.0118048927,
0.0022384464,
-0.0616257824,
-0.0203893054,
0.0106469141,
0.0104032438,
-0.0078271395,
0.0212792587,
0.0094807455,
-0.0127201332,
0.0277688093,
0.061983984,
-0.021352658,
-0.0716366172,
-0.04372973,
-0.0158172939,
-0.0017035519,
-0.0108920559,
0.0013488949,
0.0015561348,
-0.0556972213,
0.0336437263,
0.0083882371,
0.0153805884,
-0.0513521656,
0.0158922151,
0.0442645513,
-0.0301249456,
-0.0050734878,
0.0508131497,
-0.0471255481,
0.0179966241,
0.0413082875,
0.0281989817,
-0.0584954098,
0.0513151325,
0.0321992114,
-0.0705280378,
0.0094948225,
-0.0044437293,
0.0087339962,
-0.0269690976,
0.000618124,
0.0020783909,
0.0058023324,
0.0519313812,
-0.0264094118,
0.0441026539,
-0.0677661002,
-0.1008705571,
-0.0598909557,
-0.0251876768,
0.0328057297,
0.1295877844,
0.0461775027,
0.0589405969,
0.039685972,
0.0055201985,
0.0018025807,
0.004615407,
-0.0160911251,
0.0349713266,
-0.0704890564,
-0.0837969258,
-0.0603281371,
-0.0396358557,
0.0244648159,
-0.0362504199,
-0.0475214496,
-0.0668551177,
0.0396172032,
0.0278334655,
0.0234252997,
0.0222267807,
-0.0032715851,
-0.08400888,
-0.0029966761,
0.0363552384,
-0.0039643035,
0.0329334773,
0.0356712379,
-0.0809815004,
0.0152690271,
0.014632416,
-0.0112676686,
0.0073075728,
0.0420571454,
-0.0039181411,
-0.1030451059,
0.0007654073,
0.0004156187,
0.0488331504,
0.047701139,
-0.0428720452,
-0.0059509845,
-0.0563696884,
0.0282622296,
0.0027817872,
0.0331827849,
-0.0438535623,
0.0089414399,
0.0213593692,
0.0468891524,
0.0050009303,
-0.0090786796,
0.0470804647,
0.0601521023,
0.0024088933,
0.0528592877,
0.0697697699,
0.0238306802,
-0.0035384907,
0.0369245447,
0.0165587105,
0.1022161543,
-0.0086464528,
0.0226214416,
0.008758272,
0.0047390605,
0.0148553979,
0.0438465811,
0.016415434,
-0.0049687857,
-0.0248346049,
-0.0978625268,
0.0273330491,
0.0280611739,
0.0451484621,
-0.0077948892,
0.0408222452,
-0.0412410647,
0.0387653112,
-0.0106299855,
0.0058038561,
-0.010636542,
-0.0109031405,
0.0257353131,
-0.0232494026,
-0.0224115308,
-0.0001667248,
0.0432275273,
-0.045469217,
0.0079986285,
-0.0497443229,
-0.0072024479,
-0.0279002693,
-0.0186991673,
0.0829515457,
-0.005706985,
-0.0279128905,
0.0314521119,
-0.0198506247,
-0.0482241698,
-0.0258683637,
0.0075900764,
0.0018150032,
0.0272091236,
0.0372240543,
-0.0175942648,
0.000188179,
0.0507968143,
-0.0190664008,
-0.0281716697,
0.0329079591,
-0.0129930675,
0.0225575436,
-5.499702767e-33,
-0.0134938518,
-0.0163540058,
-0.0174525026,
0.0166455694,
0.0006433933,
0.0475982279,
0.0079864506,
0.0218623448,
-0.0071410183,
0.0153368907,
-0.0049662697,
-0.0200814959,
0.0121422531,
-0.0383064859,
0.0381888449,
-0.0169668142,
0.0239619389,
0.0047095707,
-0.0041011409,
0.0044744336,
0.0463686772,
0.0318729393,
0.0697617233,
-0.0558546111,
-0.0030668203,
-0.0265075434,
-0.030864032,
0.0100070974,
-0.022858886,
-0.006131005,
-0.0333470851,
0.0224548727,
-0.0100881578,
0.0087443199,
-0.0039193272,
-0.027224727,
-0.0332379304,
-0.0451398902,
-0.0294174105,
0.0810872391,
0.023059275,
0.0636336282,
-0.0130965225,
-0.0027941873,
-0.0769009963,
0.0620243624,
0.0334389322,
0.0163115449,
-0.0293866154,
-0.0574257597,
0.0431351326,
0.0144166853,
-0.0166584235,
0.0059398683,
0.0313123167,
-0.0098811202,
-0.0370814838,
-0.1068637148,
-0.0337466188,
0.0554119684,
0.0200975649,
0.0331409201,
0.0473021641,
-0.039877709,
0.0655110255,
0.0259348601,
0.0372020602,
-0.0408436097,
0.0352898017,
0.0216586012,
0.067577377,
-0.010070594,
-0.0231790747,
0.0798446387,
0.0655345917,
-0.0451559015,
0.0154915722,
0.0170586221,
0.1191512346,
0.0127765834,
-0.0404906087,
0.0439803265,
0.0212586168,
-0.0506870896,
-0.0304315295,
0.0674826205,
0.0335390978,
-0.020282438,
0.0211055875,
0.0055839592,
0.0157030616,
0.0202679243,
0.0566778369,
0.0090782503,
-0.0661359504,
-0.0047670663,
0.0086852731,
0.0432785191,
0.0042811958,
-0.040631067,
-0.0372553356,
-0.0424045287,
0.0030679903,
-0.0100062564,
0.0519450195,
0.0308728162,
-0.0074395393,
0.0589497089,
-0.0546315312,
0.0147485035,
0.0083391163,
-0.0078192111,
0.0573571064,
-0.0174734704,
0.0577429347,
-0.0322726071,
-0.0215135198,
0.0264052581,
0.0053465129,
-0.069202207,
-0.0028518811,
0.0103861578,
-0.0283408985,
0.0516281016,
-0.0361097269,
-0.0060046944,
-0.0189550351,
-0.0428648293,
0.0612708703,
-0.0928416401,
-0.0066433847,
-0.0027610925,
2.567e-7,
0.0277670212,
0.0145790875,
-0.0083827339,
0.0113918642,
0.013365984,
0.024549162,
-0.042212151,
-0.0077957367,
-0.0130632073,
0.0373337194,
0.0158074833,
-0.0137366597,
0.0108208815,
0.0359507427,
-0.042774301,
0.0091707306,
-0.0331533886,
0.0607535802,
-0.0231431052,
0.0787262097,
-0.0049361433,
0.030055901,
0.0058340635,
-0.0373403952,
0.0072521116,
-0.0924206078,
0.0211278219,
-0.0361081474,
0.0461819768,
-0.026424529,
0.0467853285,
-0.0736622065,
-0.0187871642,
0.0221078247,
-0.011327072,
-0.0246278793,
0.0330984108,
-0.0459695347,
-0.0362267792,
0.0605149642,
0.0494937822,
-0.005547537,
-0.0426742807,
0.0343439505,
0.0417723693,
-0.0036311799,
0.0109058637,
0.0119881621,
-0.0036719153,
0.013085084,
0.0316583328,
0.0124910735,
0.0437647626,
0.0292884391,
0.015786523,
-0.0128462734,
-0.0147816194,
-0.0015349904,
0.0142570408,
-0.0171529483,
0.0034727561,
-0.0277328733,
0.0112794284,
0.0131940776,
-0.0344366692,
-0.0201609023,
-0.0107117463,
1.774040577e-34,
0.0164295789,
0.003569263,
0.0567466654,
0.0260890946,
0.0026702348,
-0.0515249446,
0.0876092091,
0.0449448787,
0.0081163151,
0.0052727736,
0.0034896515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12426v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12426v1 | Can LLMs Augment Low-Resource Reading Comprehension Datasets? Opportunities and Challenges | 2023-09-21T18:48:02 | 2023-09-21T18:48:02 | Vinay Samuel, Houda Aynaou, Arijit Ghosh Chowdhury, Karthik Venkat Ramanan, Aman Chadha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive zero shot
performance on a wide range of NLP tasks, demonstrating the ability to reason
and apply commonsense. A relevant application is to use them for creating high
quality synthetic datasets for downstream tasks. In this work, we probe whether
GPT-4 can be used to augment existing extractive reading comprehension
datasets. Automating data annotation processes has the potential to save large
amounts of time, money and effort that goes into manually labelling datasets.
In this paper, we evaluate the performance of GPT-4 as a replacement for human
annotators for low resource reading comprehension tasks, by comparing
performance after fine tuning, and the cost associated with annotation. This
work serves to be the first analysis of LLMs as synthetic data augmenters for
QA systems, highlighting the unique opportunities and challenges. Additionally,
we release augmented versions of low resource datasets, that will allow the
research community to create further benchmarks for evaluation of generated
datasets. | [
0.0291935038,
0.0194988474,
-0.0144421505,
0.056734357,
-0.0396374948,
0.0397537276,
0.0382544883,
-0.0465828106,
0.0372705534,
-0.0783526227,
-0.0164159499,
0.0233839191,
-0.02183792,
-0.0050881403,
0.0255116317,
-0.031513419,
0.0546232723,
-0.0220299941,
0.0043939552,
0.0254311133,
0.0074659386,
0.0284738634,
-0.018652318,
0.0339300968,
0.0348010622,
-0.0351863764,
-0.0004864526,
-0.0075630839,
0.0385835059,
-0.0355113782,
-0.0142886089,
0.0463321544,
-0.0083471183,
0.0599361695,
0.0000017413,
-0.0300715789,
-0.0211197101,
0.0257001854,
-0.0530560315,
0.0261047594,
0.0229861848,
-0.0114565641,
0.0024510112,
0.0105402675,
-0.0348634347,
-0.0270124245,
0.0305271484,
-0.0008321448,
0.0850685462,
0.0624609478,
-0.0005649902,
0.0029837796,
0.0218637921,
-0.0102826348,
0.0628245994,
-0.0892620161,
0.0203475282,
0.0453524664,
0.0348084345,
0.0218740068,
-0.0013225034,
0.0496209487,
0.0247526076,
-0.0038860715,
-0.0133574102,
0.0280443449,
-0.0352955014,
0.0061918763,
-0.0242082272,
0.1091554835,
0.0284377392,
-0.0190086868,
-0.0268176794,
-0.0051741595,
-0.0016597608,
0.0123347435,
-0.0321096033,
0.008738582,
-0.0224162117,
0.0226952266,
0.0445758626,
-0.0123272017,
0.0257103052,
0.0190067515,
0.0002705247,
0.0564169623,
0.0088131195,
-0.0312161781,
0.0099495491,
0.0370300896,
-0.0462843217,
-0.0282978807,
0.0004749147,
0.0478713922,
0.0182606354,
0.0402550586,
-0.0702356547,
-0.043463219,
0.0155993942,
0.0040322174,
0.0331638083,
0.0637268052,
-0.0250792615,
0.0738145411,
-0.0130644878,
0.0266227648,
-0.0054292004,
0.0384704024,
-0.0445164517,
-0.0228581317,
-0.0374258012,
-0.0126258535,
-0.0309489742,
0.0282508619,
-0.0748216808,
-0.0118904021,
-0.0186951514,
0.0353510492,
0.0257807989,
0.0053268205,
0.0158997774,
-0.0049684262,
-0.0496353693,
-0.0161938462,
-0.0261259712,
0.0254293233,
-0.0537326671,
0.0266795158,
0.0063001192,
-0.0845460966,
-0.0168605018,
0.0009849645,
0.0231708363,
-0.0464196317,
-0.0083968407,
0.0693916529,
-0.0121385129,
-0.0588010661,
-0.0628523603,
-0.0067369519,
0.0266827345,
-0.0570584685,
-0.0303493012,
-0.0397768468,
0.0275938977,
0.0228672177,
0.009741406,
0.0007016043,
0.006507861,
0.0474686474,
-0.01077257,
0.1099671498,
-0.0573713258,
-0.0019500102,
0.0191307254,
-0.0078756884,
-0.0125331236,
0.0827023089,
0.0338051729,
-0.0389791057,
0.0595018566,
-0.0054856404,
0.0043037273,
0.0421357006,
-0.0149198882,
0.0007795793,
0.0156891625,
0.024721384,
-0.0312363803,
0.009367981,
0.0291486382,
0.0249620769,
-0.0289779287,
-0.0129768075,
0.056663543,
0.0761333555,
0.0059568342,
0.0168562848,
0.0398121886,
0.0462299734,
0.0293545257,
0.0003623978,
-0.0398977436,
0.0165768713,
-0.0355517827,
0.0269855596,
0.006547702,
-0.0115645248,
-0.0198020488,
-0.0401861295,
-0.0120043652,
0.0231558997,
-0.0134652304,
0.0375317559,
0.0474992841,
0.0235336237,
-0.0487484597,
0.0131755052,
0.0141484747,
-0.0485596135,
-0.0093826298,
-0.0242680814,
0.0666892454,
0.0511052534,
0.0599379614,
-0.0382833257,
-0.0535804406,
0.0088939248,
0.000156972,
0.0432471819,
0.0314435214,
-0.0381967388,
0.0068082516,
-0.0675998479,
-0.007413893,
-0.0031344157,
0.0202762,
0.0237542372,
0.0338695496,
-0.009188382,
0.0104679996,
-0.0628723875,
-0.0389718451,
0.0498885959,
-0.0564057268,
-0.0632928684,
-0.0013416052,
-0.0045229625,
0.0154119506,
0.0414269418,
0.0115138022,
-0.0030669624,
0.0272007715,
-0.0450320877,
0.0303478166,
0.0020715636,
-0.0023573092,
-0.0529283397,
0.0344582684,
-0.0171040706,
-0.0416725464,
0.048161149,
-0.0394219421,
-0.0525728539,
-0.0372241251,
-0.0485312827,
-0.0151434075,
-0.0663679168,
-0.0224171467,
0.02288194,
0.003799323,
-0.0495945476,
0.0435523354,
0.0149498014,
0.0286338422,
0.0172012001,
0.0277713872,
0.009868199,
-0.0321329348,
-0.0138639156,
-0.0211672131,
0.0128014134,
0.0053865085,
-0.0225693565,
0.0194324031,
-0.0682536215,
0.0099718506,
-0.0801236406,
0.0375131667,
-0.014449724,
0.019019641,
0.0417984836,
0.0139547847,
-0.0130676171,
-0.0161366612,
-0.0244585853,
-0.0092640696,
0.0018206387,
0.0179627836,
0.0485473126,
0.0192032307,
0.0113430992,
-0.0435042493,
-0.0099829799,
-0.0220135488,
0.0116441818,
0.0350803323,
0.0167537201,
-0.0482760519,
-0.0014324915,
0.0006511184,
0.0160024222,
-0.0017369712,
-0.0296349898,
0.0125409113,
-0.0172111765,
0.0203417595,
0.0719640628,
-0.01880401,
0.019719027,
0.0330714956,
0.0047413837,
-0.0455730632,
0.0425852574,
-0.0052965702,
-0.0137595003,
-0.0168626457,
-0.0312986858,
-0.0188179817,
0.0563765764,
-0.0015033785,
-0.0099438597,
-0.0551301353,
0.0427577384,
-0.0240229238,
-0.0242150258,
-0.0617201105,
0.0358023793,
-0.0282816719,
0.0600253269,
-0.0442795493,
-0.0174688343,
0.0768288374,
-0.031076977,
-0.0215173829,
-0.0478295349,
0.0150093641,
-0.0576863997,
0.0452751368,
-0.0277182087,
-0.0314995684,
-0.0520651117,
-0.0145338075,
-0.0133458907,
0.0066645853,
0.0064477129,
-0.0463467054,
0.0587897748,
-0.0669615045,
0.022691302,
-0.0406297781,
-0.0117972465,
-0.0415646732,
0.0056860093,
-0.0608191229,
-0.023387624,
-0.0116388248,
-0.0094632292,
-0.0193495676,
0.0086871767,
0.0177886318,
0.0853772312,
-0.0411746204,
-0.0157181975,
-0.0230257828,
0.0702115446,
0.0533822626,
0.0151534639,
0.000825226,
-0.0172195602,
0.0367249139,
0.0313748941,
0.0083107715,
-0.0160591491,
0.0189973861,
0.0130426297,
0.0270825904,
-0.0383391604,
0.0258255638,
-0.001639621,
0.0591823943,
-0.0820608586,
-0.0427741744,
0.0911726132,
0.0343994051,
-0.0343503356,
-0.0255854949,
-0.0148793478,
0.0127708223,
0.0292440858,
0.0053235698,
-0.1160028875,
-0.0669737458,
0.0001005422,
0.0788288787,
-0.0059198085,
-0.0406172983,
-0.0193686746,
-0.1187152788,
0.0362062491,
-0.0093033379,
-0.0859865546,
-0.0185139906,
-0.0313709602,
0.0139043489,
-0.0394578055,
0.024857346,
0.0247429609,
0.0133269792,
0.0085111959,
0.0098795975,
0.0041548512,
-0.0417916067,
0.0200377144,
0.0126755396,
0.0346929394,
0.0380153656,
0.0274928175,
0.0128337983,
-0.0255019106,
0.031524159,
-0.0694505274,
-0.0264918767,
0.0004631547,
0.0635505542,
-0.0328976214,
-0.0200915691,
-0.0290615056,
0.0581409782,
-0.05086172,
0.0018480108,
0.0345098078,
0.0569843762,
0.0066067739,
0.0169888213,
-0.0340100639,
-0.0053833835,
0.0163754504,
0.0976716354,
0.0378950275,
-0.0419262275,
-0.0527037941,
-0.0206711125,
-0.008051917,
-0.1226711795,
-0.0401328839,
0.029643571,
-0.0016020581,
-0.0224044193,
-0.0522996224,
-0.099485293,
0.0632935315,
0.0087679308,
0.0170635451,
0.0410906896,
0.0174444616,
0.0119912568,
-0.0454448722,
0.0343932323,
-0.0466789566,
-0.0138838561,
-0.0425701998,
-0.0323090516,
0.0160361733,
-0.0170363635,
-0.0143951718,
0.0512819476,
-0.088069059,
-0.0412824266,
0.0043956568,
0.0231587309,
0.031681031,
0.0429270118,
-0.0215387736,
-0.034979783,
0.0007145475,
0.024093749,
-0.0353474319,
-0.0134066409,
-0.0019351291,
0.023581678,
-0.0159124322,
0.0375243016,
-0.0131666977,
0.0285215154,
-0.0218899734,
0.0555299446,
-0.041856423,
-0.0170171093,
0.0234533008,
0.0380373672,
0.0148302242,
0.0074744658,
0.0075943749,
-0.0370309539,
0.0140176332,
-0.0487948172,
-0.0266964566,
-0.0367582813,
0.0045295032,
0.0350139551,
-0.0556548797,
-0.0457269698,
-0.0046486515,
-0.0268699788,
0.05908693,
-0.0442019105,
0.0244636107,
0.0388220325,
0.0098446812,
-0.0163018089,
-0.0462606736,
-0.0351413712,
-0.00045192,
-0.0145921474,
0.0548068695,
0.0156853646,
0.0459035933,
0.0158156566,
-0.0180537682,
0.0251979958,
0.0168365333,
-0.0463619754,
0.0067183655,
-0.0032431751,
0.0518847033,
0.0154357143,
-0.0108435294,
0.058162678,
-0.0147766741,
-0.0351527929,
-0.0090833763,
0.0331301652,
0.0249632485,
0.0150581375,
0.040114589,
0.040055871,
0.0009136285,
-0.0024278115,
0.0607326627,
0.014401827,
0.0386406891,
0.008283929,
-0.0141018583,
-0.059854757,
-0.0244126394,
-0.035297893,
0.0277080573,
-0.0008101427,
0.019798357,
-0.079683207,
-0.0702814311,
0.006555811,
0.0159335788,
0.0027113999,
-0.0131449923,
-0.0092586288,
0.0480769761,
-0.0138612222,
-0.0371496826,
-0.0553158559,
0.0349932164,
-0.0532255135,
-0.0243222248,
-0.0113576632,
-6.133245366e-33,
-0.0378157049,
-0.0453836732,
0.027099371,
-0.0099897189,
0.002651226,
0.0245555211,
-0.0380259603,
-0.0189009309,
-0.0182891563,
0.0017491293,
-0.0170309898,
0.0210767146,
0.0159739964,
0.0385163762,
-0.020657111,
-0.0128287384,
0.0170505103,
-0.0102392128,
-0.0173661951,
0.0286705587,
0.0482838079,
0.0139421728,
0.0402160659,
-0.0255711097,
0.0491906926,
-0.0419129319,
0.0058434159,
0.0185672361,
0.0022080338,
0.0437546223,
-0.0458185971,
0.055846829,
0.0495144911,
-0.0140257264,
0.0275480151,
0.0444748141,
-0.1027883515,
-0.0338829271,
0.0445448607,
0.0020399459,
-0.0497632846,
-0.0278934389,
0.0068823099,
0.0063665863,
0.0181021485,
-0.0125060724,
0.0342710279,
-0.0420101099,
-0.0274587423,
0.0053927256,
-0.0682123303,
0.0473900363,
-0.0159781538,
-0.0198825635,
0.0335295573,
0.0610790402,
-0.0002416659,
0.0529990941,
-0.0646184608,
-0.0064103077,
0.0336560681,
0.0190515872,
0.0348742604,
0.0291805752,
-0.0035901538,
0.0099003445,
-0.0177174695,
-0.0051913559,
-0.0264014937,
0.0206720997,
0.0196504109,
0.0077184294,
0.0370784216,
0.0685885996,
0.044827532,
0.0180805456,
-0.0496707559,
0.0521502532,
-0.0019204654,
0.0002777861,
0.0246440042,
-0.0383338965,
-0.0558148734,
0.0233568139,
-0.044022426,
-0.0165073778,
-0.0410563983,
0.0147643462,
0.0598819628,
-0.0070483624,
-0.0531436503,
0.0238935538,
0.0206638724,
-0.0157285873,
0.0232310947,
0.0179007091,
-0.007870906,
0.0218716878,
-0.019157961,
0.0200312827,
-0.0411689691,
-0.0037325204,
0.0149161927,
0.0245759431,
0.0230753869,
-0.0163547918,
0.0301809199,
-0.0137266601,
-0.0495822392,
-0.0104218647,
-0.0279607344,
0.0607802197,
-0.0485927649,
0.0338953733,
0.0309532452,
0.0190077666,
-0.0120008532,
0.0496853888,
0.014197655,
0.022143105,
-0.0163028482,
0.0018015937,
-0.0248607863,
-0.0140199792,
-0.0207382757,
-0.0032208557,
-0.0049633505,
0.0086890711,
-0.0191247314,
-0.0627248213,
0.0227350686,
0.0447413363,
2.365e-7,
0.0450700857,
0.0277917683,
0.0446621589,
0.0179478545,
0.0034590312,
0.0201512538,
-0.0056447336,
0.011098993,
0.0437667407,
-0.0261835493,
0.0147641581,
0.0301097184,
0.0548972115,
0.0195625219,
-0.0838669017,
-0.0349990055,
-0.0242760647,
0.0284874048,
-0.0562784672,
-0.0078032231,
0.0745195523,
0.0740946457,
0.0078397663,
-0.0254991837,
0.0093227699,
-0.0298857447,
0.0371019319,
-0.0100303777,
-0.0189807452,
0.0247130394,
0.0672817007,
0.052363839,
0.0075570378,
0.0282312687,
-0.0098609375,
0.0126482239,
0.0131602408,
0.0619273596,
0.013046599,
-0.0700714216,
-0.0109522752,
-0.0210023895,
0.0217667297,
-0.0454053171,
0.0998493955,
-0.0459500514,
-0.0427219011,
0.01469607,
-0.0623123236,
-0.005003883,
-0.0087818913,
-0.0182518791,
-0.021703735,
0.0229335092,
0.0156278349,
-0.0460682847,
-0.0034757373,
-0.0610553697,
-0.0135722514,
0.0126333749,
-0.0129069602,
-0.030746216,
-0.0475117676,
-0.0386256091,
0.0004625109,
-0.0885767639,
0.0047065909,
1.935787107e-34,
0.0069554001,
-0.0168443564,
0.0345053896,
0.0332241096,
0.01451483,
0.0070316936,
0.0169655792,
0.0003127697,
0.0030601502,
-0.0972118303,
-0.0064360434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12415v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12415v1 | Constraints First: A New MDD-based Model to Generate Sentences Under Constraints | 2023-09-21T18:29:52 | 2023-09-21T18:29:52 | Alexandre Bonlarron, Aurélie Calabrèse, Pierre Kornprobst, Jean-Charles Régin | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | This paper introduces a new approach to generating strongly constrained
texts. We consider standardized sentence generation for the typical application
of vision screening. To solve this problem, we formalize it as a discrete
combinatorial optimization problem and utilize multivalued decision diagrams
(MDD), a well-known data structure to deal with constraints. In our context,
one key strength of MDD is to compute an exhaustive set of solutions without
performing any search. Once the sentences are obtained, we apply a language
model (GPT-2) to keep the best ones. We detail this for English and also for
French where the agreement and conjugation rules are known to be more complex.
Finally, with the help of GPT-2, we get hundreds of bona-fide candidate
sentences. When compared with the few dozen sentences usually available in the
well-known vision screening test (MNREAD), this brings a major breakthrough in
the field of standardized sentence generation. Also, as it can be easily
adapted for other languages, it has the potential to make the MNREAD test even
more valuable and usable. More generally, this paper highlights MDD as a
convincing alternative for constrained text generation, especially when the
constraints are hard to satisfy, but also for many other prospects. | [
0.0208030026,
0.0507791489,
-0.0082886824,
-0.0016481793,
-0.0632704049,
-0.0303982776,
0.030711554,
0.0158259012,
-0.000412452,
-0.0863518938,
0.0334381461,
-0.048813533,
0.0278191827,
0.0053618797,
0.0161175206,
-0.0357783772,
0.0278967097,
-0.0204421747,
-0.0216668583,
-0.0002795216,
0.037182305,
0.007722815,
-0.021492077,
0.0132303182,
-0.0719137341,
-0.0016037911,
-0.0008703544,
0.0002490232,
0.0602172911,
-0.0185153354,
-0.0476961657,
0.0585559942,
-0.0219341666,
-0.0264644679,
0.0000021749,
-0.0484726205,
-0.0413225554,
-0.049869623,
0.0469415039,
0.0108261425,
0.0240590945,
-0.0517330393,
0.006674747,
0.0111963265,
-0.0258533563,
0.0249940492,
0.068919234,
0.0229512192,
0.0845295712,
0.0785390511,
-0.0423511751,
0.0087196389,
-0.0197396465,
-0.0105444947,
-0.0152902426,
0.0017400811,
0.0217821375,
0.0118893255,
0.0320175104,
-0.0424446352,
0.0005391819,
0.0114424527,
-0.0063537057,
-0.026663363,
-0.0009032279,
0.011120881,
-0.0485298522,
-0.0574756563,
-0.0281559005,
0.0460867658,
0.0283594225,
-0.0217335597,
0.0285517313,
-0.0265361946,
0.0111234998,
0.0238243621,
-0.0305823926,
0.0539225079,
-0.0232646093,
0.0079396013,
-0.0076902942,
0.0230616629,
-0.0212774482,
-0.0003779386,
-0.0017444625,
0.0062136999,
0.0313563347,
-0.0422410257,
-0.0013478381,
0.0157128647,
-0.0393789262,
-0.0498025194,
0.0116585903,
-0.0045088357,
-0.0638191774,
-0.0032755344,
-0.0979081616,
-0.0415466093,
0.0343069062,
-0.0196271297,
0.0454879887,
0.0123130949,
0.0254551247,
-0.0024747115,
-0.0122617502,
0.069385998,
-0.0191356912,
-0.0028609911,
-0.0707317814,
0.0318348892,
-0.0130395535,
-0.0114909708,
-0.0549685918,
0.0243151411,
-0.0025540481,
-0.0548361242,
-0.0838932395,
0.0242805053,
-0.0044675022,
-0.0097141219,
0.001158256,
-0.0039552916,
-0.0157131478,
0.0343828648,
-0.0003711667,
-0.0265397429,
-0.0218973998,
0.0011147477,
-0.0058152527,
-0.0214569233,
0.0021477921,
0.0732493103,
0.0197041854,
-0.009407565,
-0.0330350101,
0.0865798369,
-0.0379445069,
-0.0022265855,
0.0224325676,
-0.0434184112,
-0.0752882808,
-0.0538191274,
0.0198911782,
-0.0396370478,
-0.017339712,
-0.0079081738,
0.0146623235,
-0.0048202965,
0.0278457236,
0.0375000723,
0.0289800093,
0.0092928698,
0.0183176603,
-0.0050028032,
-0.0335718915,
-0.010175772,
0.0242536422,
0.0581686087,
0.039128568,
0.048037868,
0.0099781109,
0.0104685714,
0.0382404327,
0.0609786287,
0.001634427,
0.0029555717,
-0.04896928,
-0.0391689539,
-0.0032541982,
0.034623418,
-0.026677968,
0.0782900974,
-0.0293298382,
0.0243743341,
0.0443368964,
0.0249846913,
0.045546148,
0.0025768843,
0.0345041305,
0.0062951604,
-0.0144649912,
0.0575271137,
0.0076737851,
0.0287541486,
-0.0080434764,
0.0104352999,
-0.0239817761,
0.0297006089,
0.0163592752,
-0.0219288878,
-0.0009528811,
0.0128490208,
0.0173732881,
-0.0410903506,
-0.0014809346,
-0.0087419786,
-0.0353561938,
0.0186332054,
-0.0097895795,
-0.0771805942,
-0.0336382128,
-0.0099531747,
-0.0039132014,
0.0419627726,
0.0723714456,
0.0158483218,
0.0112308068,
0.0109962253,
-0.0021684712,
0.0810299963,
0.0360381342,
0.0038483876,
-0.0051714871,
-0.0797090158,
-0.0077480879,
0.0228509791,
0.0146178827,
0.0227148402,
-0.0248799939,
0.0188449733,
0.0214326456,
0.0173455253,
-0.0280008093,
0.0424692072,
0.0415464342,
0.0214545317,
0.0148242852,
0.0254954007,
-0.0004582843,
0.013568447,
-0.0230145268,
0.0383956954,
0.0305743609,
-0.0331768505,
0.0130827026,
0.0089663062,
-0.0564465746,
-0.0412393957,
0.0232641809,
-0.1059296504,
-0.0145348888,
0.0353354625,
0.0022903741,
-0.0691531748,
-0.0122218924,
-0.0895734578,
-0.0584960356,
-0.0525018312,
0.0175159145,
0.0307739843,
-0.0116624311,
-0.049935814,
0.0931417868,
0.0052206949,
0.0032244064,
0.0269768182,
-0.0381041765,
0.0633749515,
-0.0831804872,
0.0025421069,
0.0023179366,
-0.0127942404,
0.0512744226,
0.0724259913,
0.075216338,
-0.0161865801,
-0.0300526507,
-0.068033345,
-0.0084613394,
-0.0093011186,
-0.0227026548,
0.0006631076,
-0.0069590607,
0.0041591427,
-0.0110900439,
-0.0609666854,
0.0339017957,
0.0668294281,
-0.0056765373,
0.063023299,
-0.0021144717,
-0.0517896898,
-0.0029404447,
-0.0036161116,
-0.0226232708,
0.0542344823,
0.064893052,
-0.0643967167,
-0.023443358,
0.0934737474,
-0.0123571362,
0.011946653,
0.0166077353,
0.0030099403,
0.0147567932,
0.0209418647,
0.0154124154,
0.0406880043,
0.0361419804,
0.0148024708,
0.022031894,
0.0023475792,
0.0213917103,
0.0043726033,
-0.0168944728,
0.0289615635,
0.0014836042,
-0.0269044451,
0.0406562164,
0.0073639909,
0.0514314584,
-0.0098520517,
-0.0852917135,
0.0483153947,
0.0125638824,
-0.023855092,
-0.0582172461,
-0.0046248608,
-0.0233283155,
0.0612110905,
-0.0090537705,
-0.0531216636,
0.05118962,
-0.028618712,
0.01995828,
-0.0486512221,
0.001059178,
-0.0345771275,
0.0425768979,
0.03115879,
0.05501258,
0.0499598496,
0.0138992006,
-0.1032704338,
-0.0111475345,
0.0504667051,
-0.0130784307,
0.0561589636,
-0.0513825901,
0.0161783639,
-0.0424449854,
-0.0541087277,
-0.0400566645,
-0.008396483,
0.0110494476,
-0.0053168824,
0.0586647168,
-0.0003007737,
-0.0406255461,
0.0147803919,
0.0024752601,
0.0351995453,
-0.0212832093,
0.008117998,
-0.042002257,
0.0520188473,
0.0583126582,
-0.0080609079,
-0.022962179,
-0.046243459,
-0.0216255579,
0.0441382527,
-0.0429940075,
0.0589309447,
0.0011562523,
0.0152958678,
0.0127967959,
0.0012240943,
-0.0035311917,
0.0121640172,
0.0001260495,
-0.0122898081,
0.0053366753,
0.0538063273,
0.0182287432,
-0.0203790981,
0.0063000303,
0.0145099964,
0.0227390751,
0.008156172,
0.009318768,
-0.0968639255,
-0.0245819725,
-0.0327795073,
0.0224252772,
-0.0402572453,
0.0115457373,
-0.0594626404,
-0.0615724809,
0.0551824458,
0.0277335849,
-0.0143363792,
-0.038958475,
0.0457799695,
-0.0333487354,
-0.0110859843,
-0.0220328216,
0.0088002337,
-0.0152355954,
0.0023504291,
0.0177021846,
0.0188869685,
-0.0438492112,
-0.0209101271,
-0.0101541774,
-0.0177814551,
0.0441051647,
0.0281524174,
0.0028427225,
-0.0463350229,
0.0260021836,
-0.0188051462,
0.0101385172,
0.0042601707,
0.0097506698,
-0.0041042101,
-0.0186917931,
-0.0436116681,
0.0162975863,
0.005698768,
-0.049393069,
0.0319400467,
0.0513878502,
-0.0152647495,
-0.0292250998,
-0.0115432376,
0.0302320737,
0.0035208121,
0.0308932662,
0.0158297513,
-0.0547440574,
-0.0282319747,
-0.0330894701,
0.0191473886,
-0.1195585355,
-0.0100555774,
0.0049710558,
-0.0157787018,
-0.0357810296,
-0.1043422222,
-0.003031983,
0.0221818313,
0.0941776931,
0.0154479612,
-0.0082116481,
0.0315227099,
-0.0113001131,
-0.0164597761,
-0.0212683361,
0.0001502257,
0.0113127893,
-0.0413098224,
-0.0036865915,
-0.0058237375,
-0.0549613908,
-0.0033884833,
0.0386028215,
-0.0613351949,
-0.0636578128,
-0.0448575504,
0.0291408971,
0.0286265742,
-0.0154379299,
0.0159505066,
-0.0233108662,
0.0198492967,
0.0589344986,
0.0474206358,
0.0248603001,
-0.0134108197,
-0.0634292662,
-0.0326012075,
-0.0069664614,
-0.0198473092,
0.031328924,
-0.0403016359,
0.0698182061,
-0.0344930291,
-0.0352226794,
0.0746977404,
0.0612999201,
-0.0163597614,
-0.083155185,
0.0015322508,
-0.0123832524,
0.0027357352,
-0.0359354429,
-0.0432095379,
-0.0357753448,
0.0352931246,
0.0000614726,
-0.0107342554,
0.023471443,
-0.0689442009,
-0.0198325515,
-0.0074688396,
0.0064859171,
0.0060287979,
0.0414826497,
-0.0262262207,
0.0328186303,
-0.0356781036,
-0.0144498078,
0.0516831465,
-0.0726270303,
0.0136568146,
-0.0097655114,
0.0511035584,
0.0558529943,
-0.0216522403,
-0.0094900643,
0.0190160535,
-0.0095348079,
0.0236684531,
-0.0379716232,
0.0121890353,
0.0583610423,
0.0129694333,
0.0469685979,
-0.0642660111,
0.0200027656,
-0.0324541219,
0.0655880496,
0.0417006612,
-0.02142708,
0.0033888747,
0.0124086887,
-0.0026617253,
-0.0456502624,
0.0826836228,
0.0131765399,
-0.0177402142,
-0.0326473862,
-0.0291238837,
-0.0908980966,
-0.0279738959,
0.0164060872,
-0.0067562722,
0.0017726499,
0.0133043695,
-0.0561595187,
-0.0197726246,
0.0251783952,
0.0210247841,
0.0770796239,
-0.0081519112,
0.0293276235,
0.0187643562,
0.0025026856,
0.0013476022,
-0.0361475423,
-0.0056616608,
-0.0307719763,
-0.0028174967,
-0.0374839008,
-6.256628926e-33,
-0.0488821678,
-0.0584403127,
-0.0007557151,
-0.0146587892,
-0.0190364029,
-0.0218417905,
-0.0094240066,
0.0149484621,
0.0503673218,
0.0028909168,
0.0268755276,
-0.0354414061,
0.0162707884,
0.0422884114,
-0.0122344336,
0.0285647977,
0.0176776312,
0.000879093,
-0.0620191842,
-0.0307432059,
0.040084146,
-0.0121368812,
0.0110971006,
0.0151445596,
-0.0434632674,
-0.0203522332,
-0.0741793439,
-0.0024376905,
-0.0473143868,
0.0592482686,
-0.0008530181,
0.0235418379,
0.037112195,
0.0088484837,
-0.0110648219,
0.0605398268,
0.0009931595,
-0.0337965377,
0.0387169234,
0.0022228884,
-0.0339725688,
-0.0250387508,
-0.0103535717,
-0.0632034317,
-0.0212007947,
0.0277971383,
0.0316102505,
-0.0417143777,
-0.0359369181,
-0.0505583771,
-0.0444791391,
0.0103779081,
0.0052976338,
-0.0120144086,
0.0005476835,
0.0873126611,
-0.0170000531,
-0.0277557205,
0.0044335462,
0.0874009207,
0.0364392102,
0.0398325436,
0.0368964821,
0.0294634625,
-0.0285820216,
0.0597775243,
-0.0356190018,
-0.0783030987,
-0.0012042534,
-0.0371202528,
-0.0120499833,
0.0359350704,
0.0315754823,
0.0837803856,
0.0046397178,
-0.0068074963,
-0.079146795,
0.0073930318,
-0.0272889044,
0.0316346325,
0.0541373752,
-0.0037761214,
-0.046999231,
-0.0495221876,
-0.016163839,
-0.0068617552,
-0.017034512,
0.0130030755,
0.0662481785,
0.0341566689,
-0.0542755015,
0.0313083455,
0.0453657955,
-0.0025782918,
-0.0074012834,
0.0201051496,
-0.0632632002,
0.0299006533,
-0.0309961196,
0.0078700026,
-0.0095964093,
-0.0418003537,
0.0730239004,
0.0223049,
0.0471206307,
0.0343819782,
0.0258566774,
-0.0058379285,
-0.0483964123,
0.0346584171,
-0.0115898084,
0.013903467,
-0.0210815147,
-0.0053117094,
0.0071173259,
-0.0251253657,
-0.0065870075,
0.0070064235,
0.0190776642,
-0.0411453247,
-0.0175202936,
-0.0240129773,
0.0055942079,
0.0502838232,
0.0023004708,
0.0323373564,
0.0156435966,
-0.0018008854,
0.060881976,
-0.0157314129,
-0.0168717038,
-0.0038357007,
2.897e-7,
0.0134085258,
0.0492372252,
0.0342231952,
0.0439675897,
0.0094648609,
0.0399087742,
0.0035046749,
0.0491444282,
-0.0376701653,
0.0046776403,
0.008240452,
-0.0075224135,
0.0338191353,
0.0093179988,
-0.0320380032,
0.0439785384,
-0.0129254954,
-0.0216101911,
-0.0332690328,
0.0235403795,
0.1141456291,
0.0300218705,
-0.0547934994,
0.0026632159,
-0.0107841585,
-0.072668232,
0.0563492849,
0.0217324682,
-0.0110773798,
0.0063335723,
0.0467695259,
-0.0576131828,
-0.0102933543,
0.0926426575,
0.0071287761,
-0.0029275909,
0.0524330735,
0.0426355563,
-0.0054520559,
0.0397769324,
0.0404016897,
0.0065746862,
-0.013306167,
-0.0145726791,
0.0285664033,
-0.0257775784,
-0.0139369341,
-0.0200368613,
0.0069265878,
0.0182529632,
0.023164615,
-0.0130004594,
-0.0295155663,
0.0003999007,
0.0118964352,
0.0268435758,
0.0047938572,
-0.0279993024,
-0.0126165561,
-0.0158155821,
-0.0223231912,
-0.0305528659,
-0.0189714655,
0.018278392,
0.0326265283,
-0.07705421,
-0.0347448066,
2.877685476e-34,
0.0515330061,
-0.0050384193,
-0.0023000478,
-0.023239404,
0.0155317718,
-0.0295319818,
-0.0266549177,
0.03186436,
0.0075980239,
-0.0360052586,
-0.0270885974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12311v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12311v1 | LLM-Grounder: Open-Vocabulary 3D Visual Grounding with Large Language Model as an Agent | 2023-09-21T17:59:45 | 2023-09-21T17:59:45 | Jianing Yang, Xuweiyi Chen, Shengyi Qian, Nikhil Madaan, Madhavan Iyengar, David F. Fouhey, Joyce Chai | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.RO | 3D visual grounding is a critical skill for household robots, enabling them
to navigate, manipulate objects, and answer questions based on their
environment. While existing approaches often rely on extensive labeled data or
exhibit limitations in handling complex language queries, we propose
LLM-Grounder, a novel zero-shot, open-vocabulary, Large Language Model
(LLM)-based 3D visual grounding pipeline. LLM-Grounder utilizes an LLM to
decompose complex natural language queries into semantic constituents and
employs a visual grounding tool, such as OpenScene or LERF, to identify objects
in a 3D scene. The LLM then evaluates the spatial and commonsense relations
among the proposed objects to make a final grounding decision. Our method does
not require any labeled training data and can generalize to novel 3D scenes and
arbitrary text queries. We evaluate LLM-Grounder on the ScanRefer benchmark and
demonstrate state-of-the-art zero-shot grounding accuracy. Our findings
indicate that LLMs significantly improve the grounding capability, especially
for complex language queries, making LLM-Grounder an effective approach for 3D
vision-language tasks in robotics. Videos and interactive demos can be found on
the project website https://chat-with-nerf.github.io/ . | [
0.0183862038,
0.0367006958,
0.0475442335,
0.018769687,
-0.0231482629,
0.0073622158,
-0.0044284523,
0.000758625,
0.0015110536,
-0.0760370269,
-0.0340172388,
0.0265752245,
-0.0083319061,
0.023743134,
-0.0063381442,
-0.0176884159,
0.025987938,
-0.0315301195,
-0.0496858917,
0.0195568111,
-0.0238818489,
0.0251750294,
-0.0308372546,
0.0305550098,
-0.0139776897,
0.0063859159,
-0.0295045525,
0.010276081,
0.0130398339,
-0.0758787319,
-0.0196906663,
0.0514009409,
0.0804028288,
0.0135602737,
0.0000020713,
-0.050450258,
-0.0301978048,
-0.0059835496,
0.0144805126,
-0.0561346225,
0.0205049701,
-0.0337755941,
0.004569639,
0.0039831507,
-0.0259901434,
-0.0031879109,
0.064342238,
0.0764371082,
0.0277333912,
0.0240354072,
-0.0113010127,
-0.0349426605,
0.0006505403,
0.0314953104,
0.0739431903,
-0.0333827138,
0.0212877374,
0.0607591234,
0.029356584,
0.0113868136,
-0.0404342115,
-0.0015315911,
0.01815206,
-0.0251552183,
0.0330899246,
0.0536199063,
-0.0521048382,
-0.0235071573,
-0.0152070094,
0.0971275717,
-0.0053948662,
-0.0183876697,
-0.0045763212,
-0.006951483,
-0.0074147945,
0.024014879,
-0.0368708447,
0.0405510515,
-0.0119552948,
0.0030835953,
-0.0459822044,
-0.0057732044,
-0.0130907344,
0.0297241714,
-0.0531009212,
0.0775843784,
0.0211284943,
0.024469465,
0.0340268128,
0.0025710079,
0.0168428142,
-0.0737397522,
-0.004497631,
0.0293711927,
-0.0203128904,
0.0136037907,
-0.037788786,
0.0054791039,
-0.0162899047,
-0.0407355726,
-0.0137706371,
0.0400519148,
-0.0618892349,
0.0587369539,
-0.0323504247,
0.0654684305,
-0.0160011984,
0.0586832799,
-0.0390352197,
-0.0064021512,
-0.031105848,
0.0225797705,
-0.0509169064,
0.0307941493,
-0.0858253166,
-0.0570976026,
0.0212655868,
0.0156281721,
0.0018062845,
-0.009445793,
-0.0246139988,
0.0612309724,
-0.0168036819,
-0.0125634866,
-0.0297281984,
0.0226643234,
-0.0302500594,
0.0224198457,
-0.0276465192,
-0.0480259284,
0.0091424705,
0.0467242151,
0.0313207693,
-0.0211368669,
0.0245818626,
0.0547174215,
-0.0352600627,
-0.0541102812,
0.0052423216,
-0.0206147507,
-0.0035569766,
-0.0348537378,
0.0423278958,
-0.0817741752,
-0.0316321962,
-0.0063690809,
0.0046562399,
-0.0373918302,
0.030591188,
0.0132262511,
-0.0130239511,
0.1067567244,
-0.0448774025,
-0.0370860733,
0.0206966847,
0.0133014331,
0.0413606986,
0.038110435,
-0.0034306806,
0.0211124998,
0.0030990087,
0.0152611919,
0.0173174758,
-0.0012853718,
-0.0388063528,
-0.0003190952,
-0.0529710427,
-0.0053936034,
0.0120884441,
0.0282878485,
-0.0185080692,
0.012748084,
-0.0023747485,
0.0038839192,
0.0342081115,
0.0673904419,
-0.0938897505,
-0.0144567499,
0.0175292157,
0.0171316341,
-0.0122259092,
-0.0188129153,
-0.0489329472,
0.0415152982,
-0.026653355,
-0.0166667569,
-0.0583031178,
0.0068551349,
-0.0308676474,
-0.019497836,
-0.0092708664,
0.0086194267,
0.0635541379,
-0.013435618,
0.0697034374,
0.031460993,
-0.0525010526,
0.0669401512,
0.0174495913,
-0.0439188927,
-0.025388943,
0.0010941301,
0.0429102443,
0.0384103283,
0.0094932634,
0.0037990496,
-0.0644147843,
-0.0029869482,
0.0740904659,
0.0529212505,
-0.0443548299,
0.0012154055,
0.0197912306,
-0.0424581319,
-0.0571816452,
0.0008765496,
0.0029788224,
0.0430275388,
0.0445087962,
-0.0127107631,
0.0171557367,
-0.0597644188,
0.0372233801,
0.053979978,
0.0118554132,
0.0251408126,
-0.0262399521,
0.0200232398,
-0.0071813031,
-0.0045473948,
0.0059878682,
-0.0252716541,
0.0406983271,
-0.0348591581,
-0.0324233919,
0.011714736,
-0.0413758606,
0.0134692769,
0.0243988559,
-0.0304456372,
-0.013579444,
0.0280865394,
-0.0289927907,
-0.0096321106,
-0.009395781,
0.0046317633,
0.0354660377,
0.0050691632,
0.0031845437,
0.0002279927,
-0.0162994936,
-0.0487680733,
0.0487720519,
-0.0391861685,
-0.0122745335,
-0.0150446501,
0.026670441,
0.0020142726,
-0.0262027271,
0.0164054893,
-0.0042783748,
-0.0038670658,
0.005346253,
0.0327320173,
0.0717147291,
-0.0357323438,
0.0074648862,
-0.066329293,
-0.0427220576,
-0.0173664596,
-0.0447403453,
0.0131986355,
-0.018397579,
0.0060074632,
-0.0289121605,
0.0171440579,
0.0686823502,
0.0038606119,
-0.0114366896,
0.0343798287,
0.0018230595,
-0.059412241,
-0.0094175544,
0.0334856026,
0.0120412093,
0.0330842622,
0.0688711628,
-0.0413674973,
-0.0139544243,
0.0293922238,
-0.0572804324,
0.0436914414,
-0.0250035916,
-0.0055282917,
0.032150805,
-0.0633106977,
-0.0036629373,
0.0678902864,
-0.038009081,
0.0093153603,
0.0427535437,
-0.0040211226,
-0.0448334217,
-0.0096076215,
-0.0084491586,
-0.0441674441,
-0.0220739301,
0.0311389342,
0.0181199629,
0.018335456,
-0.0092245135,
0.0310233366,
-0.0336511247,
0.0132501796,
-0.0243060812,
-0.047396455,
-0.0628945529,
0.0276179146,
-0.0125373704,
0.0499304645,
-0.0365956947,
-0.0527888425,
0.0009835343,
-0.0454256274,
0.0001536391,
0.0217438303,
-0.0010865283,
-0.0236431416,
0.0656286329,
0.0072395783,
0.0301638991,
0.0025947907,
-0.0396286584,
-0.0090978853,
-0.0445461124,
0.0014487876,
0.0366633497,
0.0621335208,
-0.1017270908,
0.0575536638,
0.0023013735,
-0.0503488034,
-0.025932014,
0.0024623051,
-0.0499239415,
0.0152544351,
-0.0616482981,
-0.0452790037,
-0.0393117554,
0.0104977926,
0.0073703919,
0.0548859276,
-0.0007253122,
-0.0131420931,
-0.0294715874,
-0.0127978874,
0.0418309011,
0.0498125739,
-0.0478107929,
0.0098815337,
-0.004939558,
0.0593887754,
0.0245328844,
-0.0058205416,
-0.0739356875,
0.0696645975,
0.0148790916,
0.0321874805,
0.0100218551,
0.0026461273,
0.0086386856,
-0.0291626956,
-0.0368514322,
0.0718249455,
0.0156803112,
-0.0084670754,
-0.0302231144,
-0.0266666487,
-0.0152318664,
0.058762297,
-0.0061759381,
-0.0788469687,
-0.0627693757,
-0.0066580619,
-0.0273946039,
0.0665561631,
-0.067232199,
-0.0115737999,
-0.1263667941,
0.0393341072,
-0.0048157447,
-0.0755572245,
-0.1058577374,
-0.0017743973,
0.0166439507,
-0.0399877727,
-0.0337551236,
-0.0082078744,
-0.008609659,
-0.0169413071,
-0.0008036451,
0.0614526756,
-0.0247537959,
0.0236518234,
-0.0680929869,
-0.0046922159,
0.015711274,
0.0233334154,
-0.0137934908,
-0.0551944524,
0.0275145434,
0.0282690823,
-0.0012007207,
-0.0448910855,
-0.0094594099,
-0.0228613969,
-0.0154407779,
0.0316893831,
0.0344943888,
-0.0138301933,
-0.0358395725,
-0.053637974,
0.0484725647,
-0.0474781729,
0.0309997629,
-0.0027144174,
0.0138980104,
0.0328907147,
0.058647044,
-0.0120231528,
-0.001395765,
-0.0335872956,
-0.0158213489,
-0.0309175439,
0.039393805,
-0.0456100255,
-0.0154271182,
-0.0364653245,
-0.0083697196,
-0.0653762966,
0.0349570364,
0.1053816825,
0.0563677847,
0.002572868,
-0.0283957701,
-0.0068119778,
0.0409538671,
-0.045444902,
0.030425502,
-0.0544115864,
0.0010893818,
-0.0465037897,
0.0343925059,
0.060493391,
-0.0507584475,
-0.0301441289,
0.0020055398,
-0.0050060535,
-0.0048640133,
0.0016488757,
0.0452984683,
0.0143590095,
0.0239919797,
0.0114482623,
0.0104178609,
0.0194640011,
0.0342230387,
-0.012496436,
0.0373492166,
0.008344043,
0.0159694795,
0.00152434,
0.018230442,
-0.0579255112,
0.0288600363,
-0.0066347984,
0.0298220254,
-0.0365689471,
-0.0379370749,
0.0185741335,
-0.00056698,
0.0744866505,
0.0143802715,
0.0253558047,
-0.0431006402,
0.0119782612,
0.0120207984,
-0.0179705508,
-0.0830683783,
0.0441977233,
0.0192513745,
-0.0156209813,
0.0377457738,
0.0407918431,
-0.0210722145,
0.0787562802,
-0.0029473873,
-0.0314409807,
0.0078558885,
-0.0034694758,
0.0238474589,
0.0079127308,
-0.0046686898,
0.0374630503,
-0.0365391262,
0.057973057,
-0.0007974696,
0.0563312098,
0.0206748024,
-0.0169538427,
-0.0624470226,
0.0423017927,
-0.0049401987,
-0.0414289162,
0.0062907441,
0.0653842315,
0.0580875687,
0.0046310714,
0.0322761014,
-0.0279635694,
-0.0137083009,
0.0021613103,
0.0398666747,
0.0398598649,
-0.056274306,
0.0616531447,
0.0291218571,
-0.0013872271,
-0.0040789358,
-0.0012047228,
0.034245491,
0.0389958993,
0.0317689888,
-0.0368815921,
-0.032255169,
-0.0108908117,
0.0348878577,
0.0168573782,
0.0098003484,
0.0430210717,
-0.0279794782,
-0.0183478016,
-0.0467423834,
0.0219193865,
-0.0405429341,
0.0251359958,
0.0924837962,
0.0459887534,
0.0044382992,
-0.0372743309,
-0.0080067646,
-0.0111797489,
-0.0539781004,
-0.0019970164,
-0.0079690041,
-5.88801153e-33,
-0.0516087301,
-0.087189965,
0.0372919254,
-0.0155520188,
-0.0039046716,
0.0029435884,
-0.0234374776,
0.0068148579,
-0.0160356108,
0.0192231461,
0.0160041098,
-0.0032250511,
0.019672472,
0.0341804698,
-0.0115583269,
-0.0477008857,
0.0327054448,
0.0077312561,
-0.0217165891,
-0.0271836519,
0.0372416638,
0.0172043908,
0.0622044541,
-0.0583480783,
-0.0361436643,
0.0208953116,
-0.0057405294,
0.0417448096,
0.0037121922,
0.035686858,
-0.0116155827,
-0.0032366486,
-0.0086813495,
-0.0179821476,
-0.0096486388,
0.0221797079,
-0.1001197174,
-0.0247557033,
-0.0112792505,
0.0334305726,
-0.034000814,
0.0252110213,
0.0077341045,
-0.023222629,
0.0030415421,
0.0067194011,
0.0323167443,
-0.017777374,
-0.0216611922,
0.0286746919,
-0.0414602645,
0.0139747271,
0.0178906117,
-0.0524290502,
0.0045510018,
-0.0050079329,
0.0328556634,
0.0206775814,
-0.0260755531,
0.0017372738,
-0.0321407169,
0.0046760323,
0.0729502961,
0.0370712727,
0.0057290555,
0.1046295464,
0.011188372,
-0.0490024462,
-0.0162050128,
-0.0163885336,
0.0197158493,
0.0799702704,
0.0177823659,
0.0358299837,
0.0222397223,
0.0585606769,
-0.0467120111,
0.0253885183,
-0.0968807861,
0.1068207696,
-0.0046639373,
0.0037735912,
-0.0019374416,
-0.0048427549,
-0.0199967343,
-0.0177647434,
-0.0200073235,
0.0058904942,
0.0522980317,
0.0217202902,
-0.0439675897,
-0.028734399,
0.0549192652,
0.0072456812,
0.0181014463,
0.0746919513,
-0.0010364664,
0.0236928891,
-0.0116381375,
-0.0186557975,
-0.0416141339,
-0.0247115102,
0.0274087079,
-0.0154664172,
0.0135769164,
0.0133163352,
-0.0351209231,
0.0394049995,
-0.0309116393,
-0.015529287,
-0.022349894,
-0.0282925759,
-0.0000873821,
0.0637820065,
0.0515692383,
0.0069367131,
-0.0236122441,
0.0590070263,
-0.0275503397,
-0.0335077979,
-0.0040644207,
-0.0298846029,
-0.0370816886,
0.0073253629,
-0.036976669,
0.0118326871,
-0.0506716855,
-0.0269935839,
0.0689042434,
-0.0632281005,
0.0002636766,
0.0228973422,
2.765e-7,
0.0096096201,
0.0490815938,
0.0186030827,
0.0389121734,
-0.0564329401,
0.0475791022,
0.0193421151,
0.038243711,
-0.0264275409,
-0.0499978885,
0.0051750182,
0.0445075445,
-0.0134707401,
-0.0020414304,
-0.1023777723,
0.0572164804,
-0.0142593822,
-0.0250509474,
-0.0521331914,
-0.0007588889,
0.0335751288,
0.053127598,
-0.0123535916,
-0.0238312352,
0.0247357264,
-0.0741636604,
0.015013407,
-0.0387149341,
0.0294463709,
-0.0087528899,
0.0185341351,
0.0267178658,
-0.0145786218,
0.0153256794,
0.0095726596,
0.0120097874,
0.0237480737,
0.0446974114,
-0.0254039951,
-0.0153198335,
-0.0241703819,
-0.0084651494,
-0.0058760978,
-0.0220685173,
0.0670084581,
-0.0434608757,
0.0339242332,
0.0198153444,
0.0087419692,
-0.0312669016,
0.0039322977,
-0.0082597742,
-0.0124830147,
-0.0348199271,
0.0272235703,
-0.0181914363,
-0.0475803465,
-0.0573264956,
0.0044150655,
-0.0215627048,
-0.015348684,
-0.0165171362,
0.0165737662,
-0.0721190274,
-0.0214196108,
-0.0017768047,
-0.0500833541,
2.375040648e-34,
0.0004423318,
0.033637926,
-0.0128769139,
0.0248429663,
0.0293079857,
0.0340997055,
0.0153747872,
0.0076472489,
-0.0179664772,
-0.0619820952,
0.0161108486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12309v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12309v2 | Rehearsal: Simulating Conflict to Teach Conflict Resolution | 2023-09-21T17:59:20 | 2024-02-29T06:38:27 | Omar Shaikh, Valentino Chai, Michele J. Gelfand, Diyi Yang, Michael S. Bernstein | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | Interpersonal conflict is an uncomfortable but unavoidable fact of life.
Navigating conflict successfully is a skill -- one that can be learned through
deliberate practice -- but few have access to effective training or feedback.
To expand this access, we introduce Rehearsal, a system that allows users to
rehearse conflicts with a believable simulated interlocutor, explore
counterfactual "what if?" scenarios to identify alternative conversational
paths, and learn through feedback on how and when to apply specific conflict
strategies. Users can utilize Rehearsal to practice handling a variety of
predefined conflict scenarios, from office disputes to relationship issues, or
they can choose to create their own setting. To enable Rehearsal, we develop
IRP prompting, a method of conditioning output of a large language model on the
influential Interest-Rights-Power (IRP) theory from conflict resolution.
Rehearsal uses IRP to generate utterances grounded in conflict resolution
theory, guiding users towards counterfactual conflict resolution strategies
that help de-escalate difficult conversations. In a between-subjects
evaluation, 40 participants engaged in an actual conflict with a confederate
after training. Compared to a control group with lecture material covering the
same IRP theory, participants with simulated training from Rehearsal
significantly improved their performance in the unaided conflict: they reduced
their use of escalating competitive strategies by an average of 67%, while
doubling their use of cooperative strategies. Overall, Rehearsal highlights the
potential effectiveness of language models as tools for learning and practicing
interpersonal skills. | [
0.1008509547,
0.0392848775,
-0.0293464102,
0.0245605651,
-0.077061519,
-0.0075799711,
0.0452324823,
-0.0002517822,
0.0127481632,
-0.0215597618,
-0.0101610366,
-0.0446794592,
0.0026500304,
-0.0264966488,
0.0094262296,
-0.0954457968,
0.0296575576,
0.0207147188,
0.1031156853,
0.0003836463,
0.019470131,
0.0073605166,
-0.0386331007,
0.0336091034,
-0.0678989887,
-0.0080738058,
-0.0273633134,
0.0243962668,
0.0283249393,
-0.0157182869,
0.0373537093,
0.0709777772,
0.0375711694,
-0.0134363994,
0.0000022999,
-0.0669672191,
-0.0010752167,
-0.0319896676,
0.0120098749,
0.0022175964,
0.1054451466,
0.0342051499,
0.0119603435,
0.0172962677,
-0.0461308323,
0.0512980111,
-0.0194257405,
0.0560450815,
0.0179230776,
0.0228687413,
-0.0024839249,
0.0160986334,
-0.0405747145,
-0.0267755128,
-0.0373037159,
-0.0244931877,
-0.0014831339,
0.0094495704,
0.0005829387,
-0.029724719,
0.027004132,
-0.0193478689,
-0.000571042,
-0.0239459891,
-0.0351214819,
0.000822705,
-0.0129500674,
0.0098156836,
-0.0014860848,
0.0346998945,
0.0226696599,
0.0147739323,
0.0028623301,
-0.0114277089,
0.0510401949,
0.0095689148,
-0.0119850645,
0.0121902646,
0.0148738287,
0.0034725189,
0.0032576674,
0.0177852605,
-0.0315059535,
0.0316662304,
0.0740150213,
-0.0394983888,
-0.0268569551,
-0.0022641344,
0.0150028951,
-0.0206268504,
0.0193148423,
-0.0701017976,
-0.0248861685,
0.0264492333,
-0.0631650686,
0.0333567485,
-0.0322195478,
0.0071165087,
0.025600072,
-0.0699445158,
-0.0086014494,
0.0233529657,
0.0461625569,
0.0102837635,
0.0577963032,
0.0107127111,
0.0201316699,
0.0428255834,
0.0181389116,
0.0495718159,
-0.0395214446,
-0.0242694672,
-0.0369031429,
-0.0082569188,
-0.0486343987,
-0.0184431318,
0.0098045729,
-0.0344247073,
-0.0909710079,
-0.0050134258,
-0.08223515,
-0.0016555054,
-0.0020592888,
0.010562188,
-0.0585969053,
-0.0082726525,
-0.0313059129,
0.020579733,
-0.0171263255,
-0.0719570592,
0.0150634516,
-0.0407215171,
-0.0374067426,
0.0129692117,
0.009167322,
0.0384653062,
-0.0616427325,
-0.0056688865,
-0.0329073295,
-0.0230543055,
-0.0105368905,
-0.0553270355,
0.0216603279,
-0.053593345,
0.0572659969,
-0.0214220062,
-0.0106380777,
-0.0617780313,
0.0373950489,
0.0038110474,
-0.0195980985,
0.0562448539,
0.0117180729,
0.0264126994,
0.0418089218,
0.0647603571,
-0.0030596841,
0.0327476747,
0.0296355728,
-0.0513428822,
0.0220013,
-0.01831319,
0.0219703466,
-0.0012428587,
-0.0136256153,
-0.0120290043,
0.0001867853,
-0.0239720289,
0.003959896,
0.0179572273,
-0.0295540243,
0.0281434916,
-0.0513268895,
-0.0256732348,
0.0474684499,
0.0582457744,
-0.036383938,
0.057765685,
-0.0285173971,
0.0418497287,
-0.0149449855,
-0.0071425247,
-0.0276509356,
0.0101751508,
-0.0279302523,
-0.0201149639,
0.0113612013,
0.0048947507,
-0.0185638499,
-0.0014861082,
-0.0088510951,
-0.0069414228,
0.0611559153,
0.0149149569,
-0.0202660635,
0.0134033095,
-0.0284817666,
-0.0069630337,
0.0327436589,
-0.0567844063,
-0.0028827703,
-0.0257221591,
-0.0264261644,
0.1249982044,
0.0460200757,
-0.0188866071,
-0.00795257,
-0.0599423423,
0.0118907588,
0.052869346,
0.0652975738,
0.0005570438,
-0.0104135917,
-0.0283202194,
-0.0051340698,
-0.0133748492,
-0.012567699,
0.0181030426,
0.0079904748,
-0.007012662,
-0.0062843412,
0.0659235567,
-0.0546760745,
0.0185774565,
-0.0258707535,
-0.0331846699,
-0.046435032,
-0.0033012817,
0.028996991,
0.0234042928,
-0.0328243524,
-0.0120996824,
0.0199522432,
0.0224223603,
0.0175219979,
0.0331556387,
-0.0567355193,
0.0418602936,
0.0313846357,
-0.0140886242,
-0.0387518331,
-0.0279849581,
0.0137466127,
0.0522061847,
0.0457828715,
0.006943102,
0.0353119336,
0.0045338562,
0.0043519991,
-0.0472017676,
-0.0113923494,
-0.0234132521,
-0.0395808369,
0.0014142119,
0.0001869308,
0.0177307893,
-0.0057464731,
-0.0132589703,
0.0029291795,
-0.0063837669,
0.0379355401,
-0.0220413301,
-0.010442229,
0.0156690106,
-0.0080489283,
-0.0249372553,
-0.0185711272,
-0.0904283524,
-0.0447245277,
0.0115696061,
-0.0384433903,
0.036565844,
-0.0607872605,
-0.020282438,
0.022108417,
0.0272958688,
-0.0476083681,
0.00858487,
0.0157717951,
-0.028786039,
-0.0200448185,
-0.0019578559,
-0.0283384025,
0.0024313084,
-0.029777009,
0.0450026691,
-0.0173852332,
-0.0056540058,
0.0105941566,
0.0356304422,
-0.0183302071,
0.0326807834,
-0.0350760967,
-0.0553913452,
0.0632887408,
0.0198282618,
0.070713751,
0.0223519895,
0.0873872936,
0.0776902884,
0.0669774041,
-0.0462658554,
-0.0667249113,
0.010669725,
-0.0006162216,
-0.0563504212,
-0.0567486361,
-0.0807696134,
-0.0474086516,
0.034795247,
0.0307760909,
0.0411288962,
-0.0427821092,
0.0085125007,
-0.0087509155,
-0.0365218818,
0.0063330308,
-0.0766734704,
-0.0278521907,
0.0262645148,
-0.0089749293,
0.0027347747,
0.0589453466,
0.0010883659,
0.015164136,
0.0118186502,
0.0285199806,
0.0175359659,
0.1053780168,
-0.0588922016,
-0.0182834379,
0.0342849791,
0.0091859056,
0.0045540631,
-0.0742240325,
0.0467819348,
-0.0672998503,
-0.0031773089,
-0.0691894442,
-0.031888511,
0.0130262105,
0.0199956354,
-0.0476756021,
-0.0258400999,
-0.0021872614,
0.0135248853,
0.0437328778,
0.0259876549,
0.0100518726,
-0.0244489517,
0.0461020879,
-0.0131585952,
0.0257311333,
-0.0104682921,
0.0289397351,
-0.0367969461,
0.0024862557,
0.0337263793,
0.0266200174,
-0.0062561161,
0.008434847,
0.0291929431,
0.0311845709,
-0.0212703999,
-0.0031614681,
-0.0178719778,
-0.0058879512,
0.0334106088,
0.0364003032,
0.0035946977,
0.0092535242,
-0.0046253931,
-0.0129062785,
0.0911648273,
0.025921762,
-0.0042940583,
0.0101557979,
-0.0628280714,
0.0272436831,
0.0249557346,
-0.0123149101,
-0.0968728885,
0.0366952755,
0.0054993113,
-0.0032731027,
-0.0685687959,
-0.0433371365,
0.0032757143,
-0.1128812432,
0.0158385225,
0.0235964432,
0.0319966674,
-0.0305585079,
0.0471079908,
-0.0055400911,
0.0328037664,
0.0010010074,
0.0021424864,
0.0308337733,
-0.0084944498,
0.0131849488,
0.0013695087,
-0.0249900073,
0.0138962399,
-0.0274125803,
0.0244343728,
0.017885346,
0.0709231347,
0.0377849042,
-0.0023335533,
0.0158048775,
0.0255969949,
0.0130386679,
0.0016055508,
0.0310313292,
-0.0327414982,
0.0349310748,
-0.0107435044,
0.0381183848,
0.0466637723,
-0.0584055744,
0.0476407595,
0.0232726336,
-0.0133963674,
-0.0031308043,
0.003474175,
0.0361797586,
0.0778202042,
0.0047884164,
0.0458157659,
-0.0211184714,
0.0015170105,
-0.008371002,
0.0319559127,
-0.0007744505,
-0.0151290866,
-0.0230268072,
0.0351542532,
0.0282452404,
0.0056601842,
-0.1040397733,
0.0464404263,
0.0164601225,
0.0152028473,
-0.0398118645,
-0.0107189249,
0.0004205133,
-0.0213802643,
-0.0007329381,
0.0260353535,
0.0455904081,
0.0177571345,
-0.0410496704,
-0.0419103764,
-0.004697531,
0.0075985962,
0.0356033854,
0.0467847213,
-0.0568358973,
0.0366620161,
0.0467735492,
0.0246174596,
0.0199035108,
0.0513509661,
-0.0086673573,
-0.0564477034,
0.0008084002,
-0.0253364574,
0.0243286639,
0.0294886921,
0.0143694049,
0.025405664,
-0.0272895023,
0.0383432135,
0.0066052419,
0.0417946316,
0.0078166081,
-0.0357927941,
-0.1020655856,
0.0204898901,
-0.0297031961,
0.0092455652,
0.0097633032,
-0.0177831501,
-0.0230172127,
-0.0152600762,
-0.0256364811,
-0.0195605345,
0.0128748333,
-0.0459948555,
-0.0209148843,
0.003408208,
0.0101205222,
-0.0174198337,
-0.0569936261,
-0.0079551423,
0.0294535812,
0.0142346323,
0.0031467292,
0.0067961379,
-0.0159941483,
-0.0032164603,
-0.0151169896,
0.0570007823,
-0.0335313864,
0.0006552419,
0.017949691,
0.1066917852,
0.0275767595,
-0.0105209481,
-0.0123326536,
0.0050422768,
-0.0063261469,
-0.0501552075,
0.0213802848,
0.0092608565,
-0.0095011741,
-0.0238833502,
-0.0131555973,
-0.0522913113,
0.0195453912,
0.017384572,
0.02036516,
-0.0415519141,
-0.0802532583,
0.0475951731,
0.0227147751,
-0.0148985749,
0.0239727031,
-0.0102232182,
-0.0543805063,
0.0297007896,
0.0014945527,
-0.0207301285,
-0.0193938762,
-0.0493526459,
0.0494643338,
0.0503796302,
-0.0133444956,
0.0012820049,
-0.105905883,
0.0004140744,
-0.005558826,
0.0226648357,
0.0199061129,
-0.0850181654,
0.0222707,
0.0280998424,
-0.0227029286,
-0.0072151679,
-0.0265996922,
0.0487044826,
0.0088170599,
-0.0404398553,
-0.0416898802,
-5.700722587e-33,
-0.0252129342,
-0.0632916763,
0.0218712427,
0.0133438446,
-0.0522848964,
-0.045279406,
-0.0256954376,
0.0329097137,
-0.0229693782,
0.0227608122,
0.0000118907,
-0.0205203276,
-0.0038598597,
-0.0281739254,
0.0140281683,
-0.0033948261,
0.005803897,
0.0118121542,
-0.0100400709,
-0.0041524065,
0.0050365143,
0.0057532019,
0.0162516739,
-0.0783675984,
-0.0069134198,
-0.0034914969,
-0.0100707132,
-0.0326035246,
-0.0383811928,
-0.0080173062,
-0.0024821339,
-0.0090634692,
-0.0000235675,
-0.0310494453,
0.0134102069,
0.0609627366,
-0.015401653,
-0.0155805964,
0.0433142968,
-0.0548306033,
-0.0175348651,
-0.0094540613,
-0.030216312,
0.0137840193,
-0.0269992687,
-0.0225018337,
0.0115057761,
0.007685984,
0.0223114043,
0.027579546,
-0.0950652212,
-0.0168760493,
-0.0463655218,
-0.0617262423,
-0.0149330776,
0.0380299836,
-0.0191145688,
-0.0434173606,
-0.0773958415,
0.049131155,
0.044681605,
-0.013421475,
0.0140585322,
0.0193495061,
0.0186988935,
0.0644859225,
-0.0237653181,
0.0754346848,
0.0036044603,
-0.0467310734,
0.0523752794,
0.0325644501,
0.0271870792,
0.0762184635,
-0.0380205587,
-0.102243945,
0.0028711986,
-0.0111092879,
0.0500297546,
-0.0142949019,
0.0318921283,
0.0374600701,
0.0124438908,
-0.0347079374,
-0.0198193789,
-0.0614525042,
0.0029569482,
-0.0542918742,
0.0137635367,
0.0076539675,
-0.0079595838,
0.008273921,
0.0319671035,
0.029648073,
-0.019600451,
0.0453798808,
0.0087451264,
0.0308808703,
-0.0134578664,
-0.0541896857,
-0.0600953102,
-0.0220865253,
0.0061653908,
-0.0145764463,
0.0562793724,
0.001286927,
-0.0100269206,
-0.0155208763,
-0.008422384,
-0.0020493919,
-0.0205801167,
0.0963161066,
0.0008943248,
-0.060676612,
-0.0168588161,
0.0635888577,
-0.0285398792,
0.0062784646,
0.0051456406,
-0.0865174532,
-0.033159852,
0.0532432385,
-0.0219481848,
-0.00692868,
-0.0059382403,
0.0085829394,
-0.010023064,
0.0620674454,
0.0218198262,
0.0171202328,
-0.0169477165,
-0.0515952297,
2.911e-7,
-0.0314730406,
0.040322721,
0.0370510742,
0.0143680684,
-0.0050656572,
0.0579655692,
0.0198912825,
0.0694271326,
0.0400436781,
-0.0165165961,
0.0527432337,
0.0066025956,
0.0361407958,
0.0217356961,
-0.0047342833,
-0.0410859399,
-0.0456881672,
-0.0584710687,
-0.0292149968,
-0.0148862014,
0.0913010687,
-0.0465566255,
0.0536796488,
0.0121570034,
-0.035270229,
0.0312803611,
0.0090161944,
-0.0759222135,
-0.0232715458,
0.0169469602,
-0.0245323684,
-0.0744900256,
-0.0047683795,
0.0626087561,
0.0173422247,
-0.0078990534,
-0.0495577678,
0.055821564,
-0.0291779451,
-0.016831601,
0.0180677678,
0.0194302611,
-0.038431555,
-0.0727575049,
-0.0324395448,
-0.0656937882,
0.0165403001,
0.0122777484,
-0.019519588,
-0.012605588,
0.0136429658,
-0.0119892024,
-0.0375882424,
0.0226285588,
0.011588796,
0.0339372531,
0.0237176996,
-0.0067756851,
0.0180855505,
0.046509333,
-0.0282182638,
0.0202100947,
-0.0073520113,
0.0148428679,
-0.057211116,
0.0231805686,
0.0344272107,
2.098697997e-34,
-0.0213543382,
0.0380348265,
0.0335049666,
0.0218910631,
0.0810044259,
0.0388763212,
0.0263523534,
0.0312221795,
0.0029977921,
0.0490450636,
-0.0100236144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12307v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12307v3 | LongLoRA: Efficient Fine-tuning of Long-Context Large Language Models | 2023-09-21T17:59:11 | 2024-03-08T15:26:38 | Yukang Chen, Shengju Qian, Haotian Tang, Xin Lai, Zhijian Liu, Song Han, Jiaya Jia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We present LongLoRA, an efficient fine-tuning approach that extends the
context sizes of pre-trained large language models (LLMs), with limited
computation cost. Typically, training LLMs with long context sizes is
computationally expensive, requiring extensive training hours and GPU
resources. For example, training on the context length of 8192 needs 16x
computational costs in self-attention layers as that of 2048. In this paper, we
speed up the context extension of LLMs in two aspects. On the one hand,
although dense global attention is needed during inference, fine-tuning the
model can be effectively and efficiently done by sparse local attention. The
proposed shifted sparse attention effectively enables context extension,
leading to non-trivial computation saving with similar performance to
fine-tuning with vanilla attention. Particularly, it can be implemented with
only two lines of code in training, while being optional in inference. On the
other hand, we revisit the parameter-efficient fine-tuning regime for context
expansion. Notably, we find that LoRA for context extension works well under
the premise of trainable embedding and normalization. LongLoRA combines this
improved LoRA with S^2-Attn. LongLoRA demonstrates strong empirical results on
various tasks on Llama2 models from 7B/13B to 70B. LongLoRA extends Llama2 7B
from 4k context to 100k, or Llama2 70B to 32k on a single 8x A100 machine.
LongLoRA extends models' context while retaining their original architectures,
and is compatible with most existing techniques, like Flash-Attention2. In
addition, we further conduct supervised fine-tuning with LongLoRA and our long
instruction-following LongAlpaca dataset. | [
0.016001204,
0.0712403357,
0.0099295005,
0.0712106079,
0.005499112,
0.0201317854,
0.0350941829,
-0.0352381319,
-0.0399063341,
-0.0441563018,
-0.0632012561,
-0.0329900049,
-0.0095000472,
0.0087037645,
0.0560685471,
-0.0226029269,
0.0354579464,
-0.0470801704,
-0.011826844,
0.0023623479,
-0.0013328458,
-0.0007904192,
0.0445240699,
0.014670141,
0.0208388865,
-0.012637537,
-0.0081859715,
-0.0098829307,
0.0213869959,
-0.0316800661,
0.0030382797,
0.0349388197,
0.0528220758,
0.0148524409,
0.0000022886,
-0.0288714003,
0.0108344918,
-0.0060598231,
-0.0238142386,
0.0779464766,
0.0399532579,
0.0065017631,
-0.0003616942,
0.002141,
-0.0186780598,
-0.0154786445,
0.0475813858,
0.0166551787,
0.0443944149,
0.0655786991,
-0.0062843286,
-0.065080151,
0.0159722641,
-0.092915006,
0.0000403391,
-0.0842362344,
0.0263908636,
-0.032314226,
-0.0030695724,
0.0248671975,
-0.0192060601,
0.0401980095,
0.0320494585,
0.0154502476,
-0.012252422,
0.0463012122,
-0.0261866935,
-0.0099888667,
0.0080252727,
0.0705487952,
-0.0306397118,
-0.0177638903,
-0.0142195383,
-0.0070757447,
-0.0203312337,
-0.0692063496,
-0.028953027,
0.0193755124,
0.0468724333,
0.0220989008,
0.0632201582,
-0.0055553974,
0.0514025725,
0.0108351801,
-0.0618627965,
0.0195161719,
0.0273159146,
-0.0024687413,
-0.0373351239,
-0.0142078456,
-0.0476947278,
-0.031390544,
-0.005295306,
0.045066949,
0.0002666722,
0.0180594493,
-0.0680577829,
-0.0057118661,
0.0237670969,
-0.0211899225,
0.0609579906,
0.0537848249,
-0.0524484403,
0.0702316463,
-0.0580320992,
0.0174352694,
-0.0479278453,
0.0131529439,
-0.0434638076,
0.0073751602,
0.0458763875,
0.0367723554,
-0.0441711023,
-0.004721411,
-0.0647504628,
-0.0374443568,
-0.0274503045,
0.0286790859,
0.0095652193,
-0.0150642768,
-0.013523872,
0.0007498857,
-0.0321576819,
-0.0168978702,
0.0233336054,
0.0250270925,
-0.0529210158,
0.0400817692,
0.0011048585,
-0.0562363006,
-0.0380285978,
0.021825267,
0.0322141387,
-0.0252955854,
0.0463259406,
0.065742299,
0.0098355776,
-0.0647039488,
-0.0633700117,
0.0237717964,
-0.0102439756,
-0.0774864033,
-0.0170117151,
-0.0548902899,
0.0285528656,
-0.0146224713,
-0.0059156548,
0.0007745092,
0.0177214034,
0.0244896915,
-0.0260156244,
0.0611637458,
-0.0086777359,
0.0001511472,
0.0002262556,
-0.0003242592,
0.0447032377,
0.0646457523,
0.0206198748,
0.0265219267,
-0.006487764,
0.0024215388,
-0.0362527929,
0.035287112,
0.0456644259,
0.0281958226,
-0.032730978,
0.0389725305,
0.0156926028,
0.0139461374,
0.0714178979,
0.0358539782,
-0.0289081633,
-0.0257468037,
0.0253542252,
0.0412542969,
0.0324635617,
0.028918758,
0.0558131523,
-0.0284059476,
-0.025661299,
-0.0230379049,
-0.0828240961,
0.0557668582,
-0.0151096387,
0.0144044552,
0.0571514033,
0.0220173653,
-0.0493478365,
-0.0257628262,
0.0134791983,
-0.0082175517,
-0.0053009405,
0.0335837938,
0.0263482742,
-0.0102420589,
-0.0447198376,
0.0484031215,
0.0496960245,
-0.0277864095,
-0.0246761777,
-0.0584253818,
0.0524296425,
0.0527828783,
-0.0005933568,
-0.0386793874,
-0.0294561926,
-0.0078661088,
0.0402884819,
0.0248281714,
-0.0011751921,
0.0208293926,
0.0308429506,
-0.0633827895,
0.0116082653,
-0.0632806197,
0.0211897753,
0.0167397168,
0.0376884751,
0.0255288836,
0.0254383646,
-0.0134572079,
0.0025363753,
0.0337453485,
-0.0377878584,
-0.0517236777,
-0.0331568606,
0.030394569,
0.0308682416,
-0.0092853606,
-0.0018474854,
0.0100126863,
0.0325457826,
-0.0601230636,
0.0400033258,
-0.0448542871,
-0.0842023194,
-0.0271504018,
0.0271414034,
0.0170733277,
0.0061187311,
0.0063573909,
-0.0385100022,
-0.0341166779,
0.0248360075,
-0.0219498724,
0.0459897332,
-0.0285699069,
0.0200985726,
0.0034222414,
0.0614177957,
-0.0473282859,
0.0319692306,
-0.0166445449,
0.0095841354,
0.0354586914,
0.0490294695,
-0.0020295295,
-0.0212846473,
-0.040242143,
-0.0189216714,
-0.0103817657,
0.0051874514,
-0.0329543129,
0.0295193288,
-0.009527524,
-0.0184325874,
-0.0710519031,
0.0243364964,
-0.0423668474,
0.0332457535,
0.0300311521,
0.0339291468,
-0.0074953181,
-0.0005515027,
-0.0119029442,
0.0072109001,
-0.041890502,
0.0255405568,
-0.0001367256,
0.0040607601,
-0.0338459872,
-0.0760594606,
-0.0297131576,
0.0233658627,
0.0415248126,
-0.0222459827,
-0.0196103826,
-0.040708147,
0.0557410717,
0.0027926276,
0.0436080061,
-0.0338634662,
-0.0566382669,
-0.0181201752,
-0.0354306176,
0.0439384095,
0.1136298403,
-0.0170634314,
0.0047321771,
0.0593014136,
0.0227287449,
-0.0061051724,
0.0285008587,
0.0153578445,
-0.049965214,
-0.0229792222,
0.0010398522,
-0.0165053196,
0.0922053605,
-0.0552607775,
-0.0059603201,
-0.0286029559,
-0.0259895865,
0.0040281406,
-0.0023664711,
0.01469028,
0.0111183338,
-0.0282035805,
0.0266128741,
-0.0333193466,
-0.0404425524,
0.034056861,
-0.0519630797,
-0.0100798709,
-0.0202824231,
-0.0134043843,
-0.0539845861,
0.0602202155,
0.0117214285,
0.0264685657,
-0.033967495,
-0.0087158745,
-0.0364147201,
-0.0026028408,
-0.0273558665,
0.0091359122,
0.0800084025,
-0.0081136441,
0.0191004481,
-0.0416682139,
-0.035307195,
-0.0151618412,
-0.0212902371,
-0.0519653074,
0.0100372257,
0.0212387089,
-0.0057240236,
-0.0038859735,
0.0052958373,
0.0152505348,
0.0918274745,
0.0009224411,
0.0379770473,
-0.0318028666,
0.014913952,
0.0413552895,
0.0142036909,
0.01148907,
-0.0228803083,
0.0022912023,
0.0173041504,
0.0097879581,
-0.0004580123,
-0.0461934358,
0.0091460682,
0.0224263966,
0.0103268903,
-0.0245847013,
0.0239259135,
0.0803562403,
-0.0814441666,
-0.0145130111,
0.0864225626,
-0.0038638317,
-0.0499786027,
0.0053042835,
0.0021809223,
0.0081364037,
0.0395606309,
0.0160106104,
-0.0754264444,
-0.055777818,
0.0039157788,
-0.0130212968,
0.0273849647,
0.0017107424,
-0.0057589402,
-0.0939342603,
0.0122094825,
0.0173137616,
-0.0662745535,
-0.0449506938,
-0.0325211436,
0.0187499225,
0.0178457685,
0.0117499745,
0.0264903195,
-0.0129841212,
-0.020305736,
-0.0074286996,
0.0314542875,
-0.0355509259,
0.0628419518,
-0.0176022835,
0.0501904674,
0.040266186,
0.0039795986,
0.0297404639,
-0.0265114289,
0.0534872338,
-0.0315588862,
0.0081538837,
0.0022923716,
0.0106312474,
-0.0109877689,
-0.0224489272,
0.0099736508,
0.0477565266,
-0.0270742029,
0.0003805227,
0.002105251,
0.0652801991,
0.023823984,
-0.0158068277,
-0.0053658085,
-0.0132969683,
-0.0250202697,
0.0520888604,
0.0818755552,
-0.0347230993,
-0.0323810913,
-0.005036212,
-0.043975424,
-0.0402298458,
0.0039807609,
-0.0029732399,
0.0008745867,
-0.0339054912,
-0.0042426987,
-0.0244561434,
0.0266625583,
0.0400160365,
-0.0238446686,
-0.0174756106,
-0.0018621266,
-0.0134410104,
-0.060435202,
0.0454773717,
-0.0667345226,
0.0228216387,
-0.0495256074,
0.0005699248,
0.0475623868,
0.0071375896,
0.0053305598,
0.029092256,
-0.1215057597,
-0.0655911416,
-0.0042149955,
0.0298063215,
0.0095347781,
0.0452315733,
-0.0142271426,
-0.0511197411,
0.0511211157,
0.0154721458,
-0.0517718233,
0.0592791028,
0.0230799895,
0.009625975,
0.0186787676,
0.0706550926,
-0.0237734225,
0.0301188137,
0.0507609397,
0.026167592,
-0.0385947078,
-0.0145173818,
-0.0264042038,
-0.0007995979,
0.0234483108,
0.000737801,
0.0013554121,
-0.0232783407,
0.0442206003,
-0.0175729655,
0.0065498557,
-0.0328604728,
-0.0222132076,
0.0141264694,
-0.0081573948,
0.0020326441,
-0.0093733259,
0.0339440666,
-0.0169964619,
-0.0275525711,
0.0781709179,
-0.0003439302,
0.0271219946,
0.0387939885,
0.0120498082,
-0.039950747,
-0.0163527243,
-0.0110756904,
0.0263576359,
-0.0531304292,
0.0194832254,
0.0040129558,
-0.0014521531,
-0.0778532103,
0.0468639582,
-0.0404031314,
-0.0235303808,
-0.0269639697,
0.0252551753,
0.0632318258,
-0.0251755379,
0.0255596898,
0.0304511208,
-0.0283420216,
-0.0097951777,
0.0288629588,
-0.0168446153,
-0.0352120735,
0.0369652696,
0.0289759487,
-0.0046774941,
0.0177497678,
0.0610091798,
0.0224123709,
0.0390452109,
0.0314339064,
0.0380925536,
-0.0253600553,
-0.018969072,
-0.0175375957,
0.0404262953,
-0.0213953778,
0.0244064108,
-0.0012195867,
-0.0882538557,
-0.0173438583,
-0.0271774456,
-0.0327745341,
-0.013104042,
0.0263155848,
0.0312876888,
0.0110046677,
-0.000632596,
0.0086905453,
0.017376896,
0.0326861702,
-0.0277895592,
-0.0024244962,
-7.358600514e-33,
-0.0279518422,
0.005834871,
0.0340906754,
-0.0457224324,
-0.0473912321,
0.0191588327,
-0.0525618047,
-0.0104672331,
-0.0519349277,
-0.0147599205,
-0.0232184622,
0.0047408077,
-0.0030833769,
0.0203735456,
-0.0164025743,
-0.0226516519,
0.0366256796,
0.0219822656,
0.0008041887,
0.0329730473,
-0.0060264971,
0.0147449663,
0.0503101982,
-0.0120129855,
-0.048098132,
0.0052776514,
-0.0068036295,
0.0087396456,
-0.0233010296,
0.0327732302,
-0.041631747,
0.0292463414,
0.0159236696,
-0.0229607373,
-0.013870812,
0.0200544763,
-0.0963086784,
-0.0354491286,
0.021595018,
-0.0262241755,
-0.0293612238,
-0.0595355332,
0.0560950078,
0.0318576545,
0.0104480842,
-0.0324529968,
-0.0149807651,
-0.0204973128,
-0.0328311734,
0.0145400073,
-0.0667205453,
0.0219662357,
0.0124690216,
-0.0128537575,
0.033584848,
-0.023395665,
-0.0146495905,
0.0308671147,
-0.0498116724,
-0.0064175678,
0.0175555944,
0.0609547719,
0.0471284427,
0.0298918784,
0.0123924194,
0.015186524,
0.006385278,
0.0046502054,
-0.0445048958,
-0.0257302634,
0.0472267866,
0.0499319136,
0.0146287447,
0.0069616949,
0.0357681364,
-0.0162059758,
-0.0941040069,
-0.0501359217,
0.018308768,
0.060572993,
0.0404266715,
0.0343030393,
-0.011593408,
-0.029085068,
-0.0391721092,
-0.0098642893,
-0.0640096813,
0.0072102346,
0.0324440934,
0.0446556807,
-0.0158350691,
-0.008363408,
0.0247944128,
-0.0245847534,
0.0164787136,
0.0214002188,
-0.0057590576,
0.012629902,
0.0044845482,
0.0355477296,
-0.0590201952,
-0.0262370314,
0.005096552,
-0.0116671091,
0.0097790901,
-0.0045715803,
0.0572187379,
0.0188747831,
-0.090549469,
-0.0364517011,
-0.05158066,
-0.0031709846,
0.0191530231,
0.0343340933,
0.0424085557,
0.0013424187,
0.0110676726,
0.0929167569,
-0.0161096863,
0.0093596773,
0.0048132348,
-0.0243478715,
0.0062125833,
0.0373339392,
-0.0551581569,
0.016773859,
-0.0649542734,
0.0281240083,
0.0182510391,
-0.07812576,
-0.0418646522,
0.0025171218,
2.967e-7,
0.0170589369,
0.022642035,
-0.0058001853,
0.0193194561,
0.0290723797,
0.0128903762,
0.0281524286,
0.035530556,
-0.0002044654,
-0.0073225917,
-0.0062291506,
0.0427668132,
0.0109383492,
-0.0136714308,
-0.0603804998,
0.0287955571,
-0.0389735699,
0.0290827081,
-0.0394513309,
-0.0448711142,
-0.0023972706,
0.1691431403,
0.0102650253,
0.0081958491,
0.0312030185,
-0.0284164269,
0.0326854028,
-0.0121502662,
-0.0071689603,
0.0092873471,
-0.0345859118,
0.0582986772,
-0.0345377475,
-0.0310181621,
0.0059275208,
0.0419009812,
-0.0267087128,
0.1012018844,
-0.0110523561,
-0.0076180031,
0.0265636761,
-0.0050398116,
-0.023313133,
-0.0533167124,
0.0820840374,
-0.0519403182,
-0.0392699465,
-0.0474905334,
0.0076342267,
-0.0102585871,
-0.0095999734,
-0.0050113504,
0.0220576376,
0.0087537849,
0.0075099408,
-0.041732762,
-0.0269755665,
-0.1208999604,
-0.0330477729,
-0.0026575814,
-0.0356776789,
-0.0074355458,
-0.0845214427,
-0.0154285636,
0.0630419254,
-0.0355289616,
0.028923247,
2.915609174e-34,
0.0346152112,
-0.0223782063,
0.0214774013,
0.0115307998,
0.0210606009,
-0.025809329,
-0.0229203142,
0.0106410049,
0.0300840344,
-0.0945466384,
-0.0238221698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12294v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12294v1 | Reranking for Natural Language Generation from Logical Forms: A Study based on Large Language Models | 2023-09-21T17:54:58 | 2023-09-21T17:54:58 | Levon Haroutunian, Zhuang Li, Lucian Galescu, Philip Cohen, Raj Tumuluri, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities in
natural language generation. However, their output quality can be inconsistent,
posing challenges for generating natural language from logical forms (LFs).
This task requires the generated outputs to embody the exact semantics of LFs,
without missing any LF semantics or creating any hallucinations. In this work,
we tackle this issue by proposing a novel generate-and-rerank approach. Our
approach involves initially generating a set of candidate outputs by prompting
an LLM and subsequently reranking them using a task-specific reranker model. In
addition, we curate a manually collected dataset to evaluate the alignment
between different ranking metrics and human judgements. The chosen ranking
metrics are utilized to enhance the training and evaluation of the reranker
model. By conducting extensive experiments on three diverse datasets, we
demonstrate that the candidates selected by our reranker outperform those
selected by baseline methods in terms of semantic consistency and fluency, as
measured by three comprehensive metrics. Our findings provide strong evidence
for the effectiveness of our approach in improving the quality of generated
outputs. | [
0.0364571735,
0.0474117734,
-0.0039792224,
0.034505602,
-0.0243062433,
-0.0150468769,
-0.0266461074,
-0.0238799658,
0.0561769418,
-0.065392077,
0.0288865976,
-0.0064086989,
-0.0028195174,
0.0314636603,
0.0330342688,
-0.0414202064,
0.02865416,
-0.0041018017,
-0.0169769768,
-0.0000563889,
-0.0112225106,
0.036324665,
0.0233496521,
0.0328454897,
-0.0026896431,
0.0107588647,
-0.0001474127,
0.0062120394,
0.0362295434,
-0.0320928469,
-0.0249630585,
0.0372035354,
0.0050776303,
0.0346572772,
0.0000019855,
-0.0647208691,
-0.0179027747,
-0.0125634912,
0.010699179,
-0.014708193,
0.0426960737,
-0.0105912238,
-0.0176486485,
0.0193805695,
-0.050277207,
0.0120299393,
0.0027122337,
0.0158726145,
0.0960732177,
0.0699043274,
-0.0054204855,
-0.0426582322,
-0.0040717069,
-0.0230707005,
0.0067363358,
-0.0172019061,
-0.0032249871,
0.0454536751,
-0.0117217805,
0.0037110851,
0.0094095133,
-0.0172671918,
0.0321028084,
-0.0305768643,
0.0297259968,
0.026429709,
-0.0615059622,
-0.0147164408,
-0.0029207368,
0.0850680023,
-0.0584966317,
-0.0133726457,
0.0251308847,
-0.0125762261,
0.0176217686,
-0.0004544621,
-0.0159843061,
0.0822761059,
0.0050076996,
0.0289895814,
0.0543426648,
0.0260511115,
0.0189923886,
0.0255944915,
-0.0462297425,
0.08503066,
0.0283259246,
-0.0316936783,
0.0122590875,
-0.0057118456,
-0.0219098665,
-0.087974295,
0.0115071665,
0.0075386157,
-0.0750287548,
0.0327062346,
-0.0837821513,
0.0045017558,
0.0336453915,
-0.0391222835,
0.0052938741,
0.023090072,
0.0304191168,
0.0017350439,
-0.0394109339,
0.0635523871,
0.0252547991,
0.0322538018,
-0.059253078,
0.0396756716,
-0.0522150062,
-0.0201698877,
-0.0202959124,
0.0350427553,
-0.0388560444,
-0.0413371585,
-0.077258803,
0.0071868752,
-0.0112851579,
0.0227917936,
0.0200486686,
0.0324376076,
-0.042441614,
-0.0209532212,
-0.063744083,
0.0090000434,
-0.0032148082,
0.0183895752,
0.0487932265,
-0.0297425501,
0.0178462602,
0.0262170266,
-0.0171992052,
0.0045028091,
-0.013213695,
0.0527525023,
-0.0260690805,
0.0273846742,
-0.0232861619,
-0.0797287524,
-0.0150711415,
-0.0520583913,
-0.011520803,
-0.0697821602,
0.0110194515,
-0.0192725044,
0.0019974604,
-0.0332339406,
0.0470512733,
0.0268453024,
-0.0063561285,
0.0325217769,
-0.0184266418,
0.0021768361,
0.0131381154,
0.0192365665,
0.0249459073,
0.0266096778,
0.0466314629,
0.0607118011,
0.0324391983,
-0.0060798549,
-0.0052331085,
0.013279642,
-0.0249924157,
-0.0385739319,
-0.0181724411,
0.0071674869,
-0.0578556582,
0.0494254827,
0.0333663002,
0.0588987581,
-0.0215387754,
0.014974148,
0.0369027071,
-0.0156482887,
0.0567710698,
0.0115912631,
0.0730747133,
0.0285490658,
-0.0363324583,
0.0442851968,
-0.0243177358,
0.0001574276,
0.0307622775,
0.040334329,
0.0474306419,
0.0652263388,
0.0125028407,
-0.0549903028,
0.0204143561,
-0.0167479701,
-0.0042240783,
-0.0157084838,
0.0220451541,
0.078168124,
-0.0450298972,
0.0670253187,
0.0183664132,
-0.0779257417,
0.0170018673,
-0.0361788422,
0.0337665267,
0.0937761217,
0.035640955,
0.0068723424,
-0.0379685722,
0.0178420097,
-0.0267893746,
0.0564818084,
0.0253007282,
-0.0140281599,
-0.0141974017,
-0.0433013923,
-0.0026508209,
0.0039898041,
0.0222335719,
0.0298499912,
-0.0129046878,
-0.0213825721,
0.0692336783,
-0.0506911092,
-0.052968353,
0.038876228,
-0.0037918796,
0.0067655169,
0.0478616916,
-0.0320198722,
0.0357024558,
0.0024565714,
-0.0226837937,
0.0588071942,
0.0178166497,
-0.0393252745,
-0.0305781476,
0.0225202926,
-0.0405198298,
-0.0421357006,
0.0221304316,
-0.0635474622,
0.0086761862,
0.0194336921,
-0.0763523355,
-0.0450846218,
0.0065313205,
-0.0483494513,
-0.0207431372,
-0.0445936173,
0.0186195802,
0.0607349351,
-0.0375841707,
-0.0495409071,
0.1068434119,
0.0090997936,
0.0046153995,
0.0574928485,
0.0246707797,
-0.0147592742,
-0.0697860122,
0.0407511853,
0.0213757008,
-0.0345488749,
0.004006091,
0.0327382013,
0.0504731573,
-0.0644996986,
-0.0650987625,
-0.0487936325,
0.0023202607,
-0.0023051857,
0.0008695983,
0.0360272638,
-0.0088003902,
0.0065695685,
0.0035684516,
-0.0655394942,
-0.0351430327,
0.0645824298,
-0.0126444912,
0.0331355706,
-0.0227469783,
-0.0291557554,
-0.0243547708,
0.0067698983,
-0.0019981998,
0.0259863324,
0.0513229854,
0.026468467,
-0.0551172681,
0.0715569854,
-0.0717587471,
-0.0277949702,
0.0119095705,
-0.0199258272,
0.0029467228,
0.0187755823,
0.0469964296,
0.0252820663,
0.0442394018,
0.0328651667,
0.0639176741,
-0.0094114412,
-0.0326468609,
-0.0234298222,
-0.0473115854,
0.0188169163,
-0.0132246185,
-0.066737473,
0.0303102788,
0.0258826911,
0.0312106945,
0.0020576352,
-0.0478076302,
0.0739488378,
-0.0308451671,
-0.0433267951,
-0.0233969614,
-0.0183807313,
-0.0169487055,
0.0354149379,
-0.0116332965,
-0.0455728173,
0.0585044846,
-0.0292905085,
0.0345849954,
-0.0654194877,
0.0175760165,
-0.034833122,
0.0172801446,
0.0178536959,
0.0413293839,
-0.0057783192,
-0.0163933765,
-0.0558880977,
0.0095629515,
0.0181620717,
-0.0461233705,
0.0093106376,
-0.061390169,
0.0017745667,
-0.0077058082,
-0.0235245191,
-0.0415061563,
-0.0384495482,
0.0053613442,
0.0040045562,
0.0178679265,
0.0188496523,
0.0088034514,
-0.003957368,
0.0026011351,
0.0035997983,
-0.003353982,
-0.0176378358,
-0.0266108718,
0.0449123532,
0.0473055057,
0.0108644897,
0.013177759,
-0.0077585811,
0.0335703045,
0.0324994102,
-0.0031949903,
0.030257104,
-0.0156390797,
0.0078485366,
0.002264444,
-0.0220910218,
-0.0272296257,
0.0504771657,
0.0238212347,
-0.0472921431,
-0.0146553321,
0.1133242846,
0.0414419211,
0.0518197455,
0.0301702805,
0.0229484886,
0.0714566708,
-0.0020459031,
0.012374511,
-0.0857849196,
-0.0174737163,
-0.0003907345,
0.0154067362,
-0.0531658754,
-0.021182077,
-0.0119840633,
-0.1522033215,
0.0713557154,
0.0324615315,
-0.0003915415,
0.0127995554,
-0.0089484844,
-0.0464169346,
-0.0089716734,
-0.0179142263,
0.0254125111,
-0.0233794171,
0.0292468574,
0.0085777687,
-0.0315825641,
-0.0361140892,
-0.0029724031,
-0.0183971189,
0.0288471319,
0.0797764435,
0.0353396498,
0.0013986825,
-0.0394017398,
-0.0185798779,
0.0075925482,
0.0000110712,
0.0032260502,
-0.011748679,
0.0147092436,
-0.0013941219,
-0.0493528061,
0.0320761725,
-0.0033357993,
-0.0052028629,
0.0043050055,
0.0290217008,
-0.0246670749,
-0.0212369412,
-0.0118632698,
0.0449539088,
-0.0022053239,
0.0567320585,
0.0144690126,
-0.0149222426,
-0.0354229994,
-0.0399640501,
0.0369688459,
-0.0552153364,
-0.0401735939,
0.0426306874,
-0.0271436609,
-0.0134991324,
-0.1007787287,
-0.028486263,
-0.0026082778,
0.015376037,
0.009512987,
-0.0021286951,
0.0300981775,
-0.0142723517,
-0.0056859101,
0.0280873515,
-0.0124128694,
0.005044031,
-0.0218137018,
-0.0075872564,
0.0087513952,
-0.0301266406,
-0.0316462182,
0.033274617,
-0.0207079574,
-0.0587755516,
-0.0228312816,
0.0579609126,
0.0317377932,
-0.0074405852,
0.0056960061,
-0.0152603425,
0.0092649013,
0.0608400591,
-0.0114334635,
0.0055045555,
-0.0196783952,
0.0130441748,
0.0032563978,
0.0273179058,
-0.0452212282,
0.0279877614,
-0.0241593439,
0.0765880346,
0.0032880143,
-0.0373916924,
0.0636274293,
0.0545916148,
-0.015312803,
-0.0712829903,
0.0076646167,
-0.031983532,
-0.0079158107,
-0.0846726596,
-0.052289959,
-0.0557643063,
0.0512572005,
0.0430008061,
0.022250019,
0.0258595608,
-0.0330224931,
-0.0406089686,
0.0343246982,
-0.032224495,
-0.0213767197,
-0.0072911959,
-0.0232090037,
0.0339788161,
-0.0391717777,
-0.0389646143,
-0.0124948127,
-0.0272072554,
0.0486428961,
-0.0092309965,
0.0363549329,
0.0164295547,
0.004705715,
-0.0422767401,
0.0459191613,
-0.0189092234,
-0.0464301072,
-0.0628277063,
-0.0102530988,
0.0617264882,
0.0336757824,
0.0866289139,
-0.0241577346,
0.004000016,
-0.012717545,
0.0401228592,
0.0481665991,
-0.0755090266,
0.0087098982,
0.0158909354,
-0.044108659,
-0.0347744301,
0.0897911564,
0.0116997799,
-0.0101538328,
0.0051408987,
-0.0192924142,
-0.0562613569,
-0.050472118,
-0.0219827145,
0.002065094,
-0.0013453165,
-0.0172343049,
-0.0592967235,
-0.047405038,
0.0091778832,
0.0430132858,
0.0393939279,
-0.0061973245,
0.0600910969,
0.0526475757,
-0.0144037325,
-0.0152872801,
-0.0542094111,
-0.0246539619,
-0.0498519503,
-0.0485185869,
-0.0344495699,
-5.878318845e-33,
-0.0528894141,
-0.0708461553,
0.006182001,
-0.0556646399,
-0.046233397,
-0.0218844097,
-0.0322725251,
-0.0002578783,
0.0426971354,
0.0418732092,
0.0322732329,
-0.0284681544,
0.0202355906,
0.0482651331,
0.0148970643,
-0.0046826024,
0.0294787027,
0.0161359757,
-0.0406323262,
0.0209767595,
0.0380349606,
-0.0052401102,
-0.0127249416,
-0.0440157428,
-0.0077070394,
0.0049355519,
-0.0346862935,
0.0120958919,
-0.0250717979,
0.0407033898,
0.0057169572,
0.0430427752,
0.0330448523,
-0.0552320145,
-0.020938227,
0.0537338667,
0.0061417995,
-0.0017228111,
0.0158636011,
-0.0484443009,
-0.0340009108,
-0.0372360721,
0.050541807,
-0.0145095848,
-0.0266953111,
-0.0054609356,
0.0231943224,
-0.041769594,
-0.0219479054,
-0.0475872867,
-0.0674948618,
0.033455234,
-0.0232372116,
-0.0350241773,
-0.0322084688,
0.0579772294,
-0.0307474937,
0.009523496,
-0.0007178429,
0.0459031165,
0.0188808292,
0.0535035729,
0.066867806,
0.0137229757,
-0.0211239569,
0.0580639951,
0.0196972545,
-0.0084702773,
-0.0146309538,
0.0259889439,
-0.0398770012,
0.0812313482,
0.016837595,
0.0455731787,
0.022490209,
0.0149062658,
-0.0751274973,
0.0420804471,
-0.0046124705,
0.0071198181,
0.018669147,
-0.0278425589,
0.0008404375,
-0.0213359501,
-0.0412240364,
0.0251575299,
-0.0051266276,
-0.0240809582,
0.0517373867,
0.0080718445,
-0.0154254194,
-0.0283023864,
0.0005166926,
-0.0180713609,
-0.0103781791,
-0.0243294183,
-0.0396829173,
-0.0094111701,
-0.0191568714,
0.0173027199,
-0.0145938667,
-0.0150756454,
0.0492610596,
0.0047879121,
0.0116829481,
0.0075179436,
-0.0039900327,
-0.0119006047,
-0.0253556594,
0.0357845277,
-0.0293660667,
-0.0002887628,
-0.0269699097,
0.0258609746,
0.0048578312,
-0.0051957169,
-0.0344932526,
0.0130631346,
0.00081757,
-0.0144163314,
-0.0223283768,
0.0039238022,
0.0333065763,
0.0271512475,
-0.0225112475,
0.0075531057,
-0.0296508539,
0.0057135201,
0.0367879793,
-0.0132097714,
-0.0339431651,
-0.0169517752,
2.75e-7,
0.0113910511,
0.0382272117,
0.0039136726,
0.0630811974,
0.0102627482,
0.0233779475,
0.0207032226,
0.0538946055,
0.0340601094,
-0.0142307533,
-0.0058136075,
-0.0239242315,
0.0450615883,
0.0299185775,
-0.0634762794,
0.0057786806,
-0.0802323744,
-0.0505539328,
-0.0462361164,
-0.0375059955,
0.0984766707,
0.0551878326,
-0.0397872813,
-0.0126745459,
0.0020778526,
-0.0200620033,
0.0425816476,
0.0057354043,
-0.0201222301,
0.0123703834,
0.077015914,
-0.0092587629,
-0.013528768,
0.0222411156,
-0.0190439634,
-0.0174849126,
0.004268209,
0.0644748732,
0.0121772122,
0.0085162409,
0.0036095504,
-0.0128336512,
0.0275037773,
-0.0528183989,
0.0262883306,
-0.0892701522,
-0.0283532962,
0.011307125,
-0.0653023943,
-0.0061002709,
-0.0117219714,
-0.0421771333,
-0.0208720025,
0.0211089458,
0.0270924289,
0.019037379,
0.0035014085,
-0.0143559007,
-0.0419539511,
-0.0100793336,
-0.0547831357,
-0.0406506509,
-0.0119195003,
0.0273893122,
0.0086648157,
-0.0472522862,
-0.0151635315,
2.51521215e-34,
0.0326994956,
0.0149199227,
0.0289687905,
-0.001939498,
0.0634941384,
0.0123692648,
-0.0196427237,
0.0287154242,
-0.0152555956,
-0.0635465384,
-0.0198871009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12288v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12288v4 | The Reversal Curse: LLMs trained on "A is B" fail to learn "B is A" | 2023-09-21T17:52:19 | 2024-05-26T17:45:21 | Lukas Berglund, Meg Tong, Max Kaufmann, Mikita Balesni, Asa Cooper Stickland, Tomasz Korbak, Owain Evans | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We expose a surprising failure of generalization in auto-regressive large
language models (LLMs). If a model is trained on a sentence of the form "A is
B", it will not automatically generalize to the reverse direction "B is A".
This is the Reversal Curse. For instance, if a model is trained on "Valentina
Tereshkova was the first woman to travel to space", it will not automatically
be able to answer the question, "Who was the first woman to travel to space?".
Moreover, the likelihood of the correct answer ("Valentina Tershkova") will not
be higher than for a random name. Thus, models do not generalize a prevalent
pattern in their training set: if "A is B" occurs, "B is A" is more likely to
occur. It is worth noting, however, that if "A is B" appears in-context, models
can deduce the reverse relationship. We provide evidence for the Reversal Curse
by finetuning GPT-3 and Llama-1 on fictitious statements such as "Uriah
Hawthorne is the composer of Abyssal Melodies" and showing that they fail to
correctly answer "Who composed Abyssal Melodies?". The Reversal Curse is robust
across model sizes and model families and is not alleviated by data
augmentation. We also evaluate ChatGPT (GPT-3.5 and GPT-4) on questions about
real-world celebrities, such as "Who is Tom Cruise's mother? [A: Mary Lee
Pfeiffer]" and the reverse "Who is Mary Lee Pfeiffer's son?". GPT-4 correctly
answers questions like the former 79% of the time, compared to 33% for the
latter.
Code available at: https://github.com/lukasberglund/reversal_curse. | [
0.074865669,
0.0948795155,
-0.0309193004,
0.0370755084,
-0.0268111229,
0.0363924354,
-0.0070833671,
0.0283437632,
-0.0024290306,
-0.0237540845,
-0.0104099233,
-0.0418608636,
-0.0054207854,
-0.0038242715,
0.0386274457,
-0.0116780736,
0.0487236679,
-0.0043962752,
0.0200701933,
-0.0474673398,
-0.0194768272,
-0.0173597597,
0.0272549801,
0.0048297131,
0.0071694562,
0.0102911144,
0.0611616857,
-0.0117765656,
-0.0083173839,
0.0053088726,
-0.0211860854,
0.0446447395,
0.0320392288,
0.0333610736,
0.000001923,
-0.0663967878,
0.0023143508,
-0.0184112377,
-0.0360395163,
0.0103152441,
-0.0205996614,
0.0211017057,
0.0079342071,
0.0185366552,
-0.0422034562,
-0.022902403,
0.0244912226,
0.0683003962,
0.0130271139,
0.072620146,
0.0145819606,
-0.0518888496,
0.0563533418,
-0.0528111346,
0.0702602491,
-0.0652675778,
0.0570396818,
0.0134650469,
-0.0610178672,
0.0108274631,
-0.0135701681,
0.0477452055,
0.0054715965,
0.0494026616,
0.0038600347,
0.0351200625,
-0.0456039086,
-0.0097752316,
0.0052903043,
0.0456189811,
0.0465155877,
-0.0362435952,
0.0214054845,
0.019961277,
0.0222038403,
0.0442392454,
-0.0437544882,
0.0595522709,
-0.0007653879,
-0.0039653541,
0.0110595115,
-0.016794553,
0.0467006341,
0.0157375298,
-0.0199934319,
0.0514923111,
0.0299983639,
-0.053339202,
0.0151256537,
0.0281963367,
-0.029241642,
-0.0450268053,
-0.0030925337,
-0.0139815249,
-0.0129753277,
0.0182986502,
0.0076427134,
0.0056719333,
0.0134825753,
-0.0486402772,
0.022595264,
0.0108160712,
-0.0383384675,
0.0433642492,
-0.0318971723,
0.0695620626,
-0.0502267554,
0.0185330082,
0.0009401651,
-0.007921597,
-0.0197760258,
-0.0340128876,
-0.0223760623,
0.0266587064,
0.005599353,
0.0224151388,
-0.0358796194,
-0.0064844126,
-0.0240929835,
-0.0062790923,
-0.0539959371,
0.0231141858,
-0.016565837,
-0.0096578095,
-0.0483188517,
0.0457382053,
0.0041381721,
0.0526374802,
-0.0157075543,
-0.0251806676,
0.0038541458,
0.0158286747,
-0.0136881405,
0.0008560846,
0.0461566299,
0.0845834911,
0.0152696446,
-0.0371969752,
-0.0305422805,
-0.004479154,
-0.030247394,
-0.0824919343,
0.0103019439,
-0.0372945815,
0.0007074798,
0.0382951237,
-0.0218171813,
-0.0628735051,
0.0050424179,
0.0051699951,
-0.0722305551,
0.0756993294,
0.0844433382,
0.0208146423,
0.0690471381,
0.0458899662,
0.0024798312,
0.0563786067,
0.0449765436,
0.0110353604,
0.0341992117,
-0.0068434086,
0.034032803,
0.0476369374,
0.0390568599,
0.031100411,
-0.0128531652,
0.0299748778,
-0.0074080871,
0.0438833646,
0.0446589105,
0.0468247682,
-0.0065597696,
-0.0412141494,
0.0463508591,
0.0414359756,
-0.0473068953,
0.0748463869,
0.0345666967,
-0.0446047671,
0.0210068524,
0.0658715293,
-0.0622036643,
0.0175914895,
-0.0549864657,
-0.0051032109,
0.027241597,
0.0115746642,
-0.0332301296,
-0.0373267084,
-0.0002389669,
0.0022979134,
0.0090058623,
0.0231554173,
0.0293099098,
-0.001555845,
-0.0288445503,
0.0444256812,
0.0281358156,
-0.0465529747,
-0.0302239619,
-0.082777679,
0.0117079085,
-0.0081979232,
0.0216189865,
-0.022017071,
0.011851511,
-0.0091022076,
0.0108011011,
0.0042415299,
0.0286312494,
0.0173512436,
-0.0150324944,
0.0024147455,
0.0120890075,
0.0533998534,
0.0427004285,
0.0259855967,
-0.0078686234,
0.027355358,
0.02048737,
-0.0032010444,
-0.0077133719,
0.0232259016,
-0.0703851581,
-0.0734928176,
0.0030602459,
-0.0191028714,
0.0351032689,
-0.0053948783,
-0.0191300772,
0.0043519316,
0.0285790078,
-0.0124393133,
-0.056563355,
-0.0162892006,
-0.0490107685,
-0.0320189744,
0.0040796166,
-0.0756226927,
-0.0546416678,
0.080155924,
-0.0142807271,
-0.0373937152,
0.0314870737,
-0.0233201031,
0.0617495142,
-0.0232756343,
0.0199138429,
-0.0201953202,
0.003981017,
-0.0452288389,
0.0556500182,
-0.0238754265,
0.0490827672,
-0.0447738841,
-0.0312572159,
0.0033422043,
-0.0570029914,
-0.0426227786,
-0.0004114794,
0.0271720123,
0.0084559405,
0.0009180063,
-0.0317170322,
-0.0341918282,
0.0024067939,
-0.0643994287,
0.0104098786,
-0.0137675488,
-0.0141015314,
-0.0050654677,
0.0052040364,
-0.0318161473,
-0.0219352897,
-0.0324566215,
-0.012251948,
0.0350837819,
0.0487218685,
0.0424462743,
-0.014366243,
-0.0084839584,
-0.0446432568,
-0.014188746,
-0.0500462838,
0.0156620778,
0.0113425218,
0.041493997,
-0.0573524274,
0.0440735742,
-0.0439174026,
0.0123955598,
-0.0285571553,
-0.0296910852,
0.0025301923,
-0.0057292902,
0.0043836953,
0.075499922,
-0.0045019011,
0.0098720063,
0.0593442731,
0.0226598177,
-0.0244748332,
-0.0086849406,
-0.0096186884,
-0.0416058749,
-0.0117169926,
-0.0557260849,
-0.024576515,
0.0404279269,
0.0280562751,
-0.0370646454,
-0.0130892238,
0.0379331522,
-0.0173817277,
-0.0086115366,
0.0013116107,
-0.0307382457,
-0.0279871058,
0.0508159734,
0.0138761299,
-0.0394874029,
0.062574923,
-0.0183858927,
0.0071837506,
-0.0228565615,
-0.0139599042,
-0.0177333318,
0.0630467758,
0.0052449987,
-0.0067835115,
0.054716792,
-0.0154326139,
-0.0866402462,
-0.0230629388,
0.0307908338,
-0.0262631085,
0.0658363029,
-0.0253558289,
0.0197508503,
0.0020704935,
-0.0741510093,
-0.0401480384,
-0.0775309429,
-0.0251257755,
-0.0427342653,
-0.0167279635,
-0.023858523,
-0.0351749137,
-0.03272181,
0.0419045277,
-0.0235206019,
-0.0310592595,
-0.0185804926,
-0.0066432301,
0.036356166,
0.072213389,
0.0034093873,
0.0372388773,
-0.011307979,
-0.0256941225,
0.0052528232,
-0.0309909414,
0.0349221714,
0.0055785407,
0.0058376738,
0.0298734419,
-0.0070510991,
-0.0382222943,
0.017684659,
0.0192112084,
-0.0276914947,
0.0069334498,
0.105566442,
0.0286228005,
-0.0282949023,
-0.0262155868,
0.0008570304,
0.0165634863,
0.0188220926,
-0.0103659835,
-0.0788484886,
-0.0029268246,
-0.0022266398,
-0.0196323339,
-0.0236400198,
-0.0259185005,
-0.0241104458,
-0.1057511121,
0.0358370468,
-0.0133171333,
-0.030189598,
-0.0264558848,
-0.0388639681,
-0.0209478848,
-0.0385593399,
0.0217630677,
0.0240425095,
-0.0369335078,
0.030986106,
-0.0000023276,
-0.0428526625,
-0.0202793349,
0.0298899002,
-0.0356370099,
0.0547613092,
0.068492949,
0.0201349668,
-0.0578167811,
-0.0230337344,
0.0098668821,
0.0221148171,
-0.0183811057,
-0.0095414082,
0.0334218256,
-0.0006286063,
-0.0062462436,
-0.0473819971,
0.0434087142,
0.0069212001,
0.0314910486,
0.0105780233,
0.0589516424,
0.0047634905,
-0.0396652818,
-0.0194002129,
0.00527108,
-0.0103232209,
0.1362218559,
0.0253688619,
0.0010670712,
-0.0316094644,
-0.0306558423,
0.0255663283,
0.0492268465,
-0.0696525574,
0.009930905,
-0.0002478593,
-0.0291926507,
-0.0637578741,
-0.0191602111,
-0.015373433,
0.0118711274,
-0.0290035605,
0.0256001912,
0.0004730531,
0.0035395825,
-0.0351083875,
0.012638133,
-0.0347703993,
-0.0321600921,
-0.0248736981,
0.0063602552,
0.0839951262,
-0.0229921117,
-0.0346815996,
-0.0028716237,
-0.1222447082,
-0.0750285685,
0.0297411662,
0.0161136221,
0.0447894745,
0.0480578244,
0.0136520369,
-0.0589025617,
0.0001862971,
0.0500023998,
0.0036056675,
0.0485380851,
0.016129639,
0.0304144491,
-0.0042036278,
0.0340098627,
-0.02066423,
0.0209376551,
0.0314217098,
-0.0257660858,
-0.0610286966,
-0.0318403132,
0.0158677436,
0.0562605187,
0.0740692392,
-0.0189376846,
-0.0246637743,
-0.0007442932,
0.008934184,
-0.0205816943,
0.0093500623,
-0.004212575,
0.0034037274,
0.0499886945,
0.0285059307,
-0.0433595218,
-0.0623054132,
-0.0240066219,
0.0348246656,
-0.0843998343,
0.0161185972,
0.0156568363,
-0.0034547914,
0.0311102364,
-0.0194754545,
0.0001912539,
0.0259154085,
0.0416536778,
0.0427719168,
0.020204505,
0.0269465633,
0.02677981,
0.0200851876,
-0.0332640223,
-0.0180270839,
-0.1137827709,
-0.0602274649,
0.0099834483,
0.0522678047,
0.0515541285,
-0.025469007,
0.0248288251,
0.0027178889,
-0.0143685807,
0.0196303166,
-0.0155490842,
-0.0181214456,
0.0213894285,
0.0639855266,
0.0077012428,
-0.0328277871,
0.0422892347,
0.0846417323,
0.0742007121,
0.0432540104,
0.0025085241,
-0.0089432104,
-0.013272495,
-0.0381723717,
0.0221549664,
-0.0261571817,
0.004514826,
0.0208638143,
-0.0608674176,
-0.0663413703,
0.0130885215,
-0.0004973599,
0.0212567113,
-0.046269279,
-0.0198914763,
0.0955943838,
0.0009690885,
-0.0596801192,
-0.0126461331,
0.004984552,
-0.013963596,
-0.0331318863,
-0.0281288419,
-6.864161876e-33,
-0.0307345241,
0.0093525089,
0.021778455,
0.0040283534,
-0.0247757584,
-0.0161228776,
-0.0075363363,
0.0190299917,
-0.0537832789,
0.010985693,
-0.026600901,
0.0251276549,
0.0121622095,
0.0023258778,
0.0188736953,
-0.037908975,
0.0363493003,
0.011023866,
-0.0249192659,
-0.0001285427,
0.0349744372,
0.0421584137,
0.0283527505,
-0.0631276891,
0.0045745759,
-0.0597274974,
-0.0217852127,
-0.0002423771,
-0.055745542,
0.0086442167,
-0.0365976915,
0.0292370301,
0.0228731204,
-0.0433608033,
0.0053385482,
0.0249219127,
-0.0476893485,
-0.0699064657,
0.0468463264,
-0.0053834245,
0.0297072418,
0.006309568,
0.0728240013,
-0.0191371031,
-0.049381122,
0.0243561771,
0.0370882191,
-0.0134905279,
0.0189631935,
0.0135137439,
-0.0517064147,
0.0016221257,
0.0117531801,
0.0128440112,
-0.0208590496,
-0.0231605731,
-0.0167445671,
0.0209546331,
-0.0287463162,
0.019175604,
0.0091453623,
0.0241058916,
0.0004766549,
0.0025489612,
-0.0004736816,
0.0188209414,
0.0738534108,
0.0106572397,
-0.0430968069,
-0.0150246546,
0.0015694655,
0.021338651,
0.0249075294,
0.0949972793,
0.0390976779,
-0.050397791,
-0.0934706852,
-0.0220468417,
0.0068704495,
-0.0258798916,
0.008943961,
0.0129049737,
-0.0527164824,
-0.0500699393,
-0.040637847,
-0.0183126219,
-0.0133898389,
-0.0218180064,
0.0219822992,
0.0040189167,
0.026539389,
-0.016674852,
0.0101490682,
-0.0566924773,
-0.044236742,
0.0106637469,
-0.0268722065,
-0.0118811596,
0.0136273801,
0.0339883938,
-0.0641916096,
0.0010461366,
-0.0102543794,
0.0368703566,
0.0210511182,
0.0301811118,
0.0478129275,
-0.0108798398,
-0.0795253143,
-0.0238569546,
-0.0146628898,
-0.0085853888,
0.0306861233,
-0.0268180743,
0.0161902271,
0.0223528296,
0.0028677636,
0.0014873373,
0.0303955618,
0.0038683838,
-0.0531837754,
-0.0177213494,
-0.0422389396,
0.0407512933,
-0.0230699182,
-0.0037018238,
-0.0038052746,
0.0304118395,
0.0416330509,
-0.07500007,
-0.0176443271,
0.0009830637,
2.808e-7,
0.0245066974,
0.0486306734,
0.0079857223,
0.0158618353,
0.0196805689,
0.0525405109,
-0.0422594696,
0.0347852297,
0.0584207289,
0.0081880856,
0.0266462658,
0.0122571308,
0.0191347823,
0.0106072063,
-0.0598011501,
0.0143844634,
-0.0873401538,
-0.0223771334,
-0.0228810273,
0.0161002353,
0.0526400432,
0.0789994895,
0.040547844,
-0.0109357629,
-0.0170825422,
-0.0622525699,
0.0693026483,
-0.0307837892,
-0.001615182,
-0.0010834812,
0.0059400974,
0.0441824831,
-0.011735877,
0.0453281552,
-0.0079871872,
0.0327523388,
-0.0032651678,
0.033254806,
0.004237202,
-0.0095297759,
-0.0282428898,
0.0057959603,
-0.0188841075,
-0.0615717694,
0.0914208964,
-0.0129707707,
-0.0441265851,
-0.0255929381,
-0.0209780987,
-0.0002665273,
0.0606148914,
0.016415026,
-0.0198709201,
-0.0126209632,
-0.0015816147,
0.0179724693,
0.005425184,
-0.0999549329,
0.0156465508,
0.0445349775,
-0.0444942079,
-0.062927492,
-0.0128296632,
-0.0106580677,
0.0318008028,
-0.0534570776,
-0.0052781012,
2.655537936e-34,
0.0342606008,
0.0150344074,
0.0054637655,
-0.0034421254,
0.0356583633,
0.0217254292,
0.0045612906,
0.0260423776,
0.0078494502,
-0.0617582463,
0.0091604833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12284v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12284v4 | MetaMath: Bootstrap Your Own Mathematical Questions for Large Language Models | 2023-09-21T17:45:42 | 2024-05-03T17:36:07 | Longhui Yu, Weisen Jiang, Han Shi, Jincheng Yu, Zhengying Liu, Yu Zhang, James T. Kwok, Zhenguo Li, Adrian Weller, Weiyang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have pushed the limits of natural language
understanding and exhibited excellent problem-solving ability. Despite the
great success, most existing open-source LLMs (e.g., LLaMA-2) are still far
away from satisfactory for solving mathematical problem due to the complex
reasoning procedures. To bridge this gap, we propose MetaMath, a fine-tuned
language model that specializes in mathematical reasoning. Specifically, we
start by bootstrapping mathematical questions by rewriting the question from
multiple perspectives without extra knowledge, which results in a new dataset
called MetaMathQA. Then we fine-tune the LLaMA-2 models on MetaMathQA.
Experimental results on two popular benchmarks (i.e., GSM8K and MATH) for
mathematical reasoning demonstrate that MetaMath outperforms a suite of
open-source LLMs by a significant margin. Our MetaMath-7B model achieves 66.4%
on GSM8K and 19.4% on MATH, exceeding the state-of-the-art models of the same
size by 11.5% and 8.7%. Particularly, MetaMath-70B achieves an accuracy of
82.3% on GSM8K, slightly better than GPT-3.5-Turbo. We release all the
MetaMathQA dataset, the MetaMath models with different model sizes and the
training code for public use. | [
-0.0180954784,
0.0918723717,
0.0076381359,
0.070833452,
-0.038620729,
0.0253225286,
0.0131349275,
-0.0103327371,
-0.0495925955,
-0.0343381502,
-0.0515706465,
0.0078636315,
-0.0278973784,
0.0332734287,
0.0295694396,
-0.0364581198,
-0.0021814429,
-0.0588375553,
0.0097830221,
-0.0180918332,
-0.0195421651,
-0.0102591291,
-0.0263697021,
-0.0092283282,
-0.0035540403,
-0.0611297488,
0.0179882348,
-0.0336607844,
0.0061999732,
-0.0270658936,
-0.0079949507,
0.0553192124,
0.018946223,
0.0566672944,
0.0000022543,
-0.0485140309,
0.0028831072,
-0.0102754952,
-0.064750351,
-0.0023233935,
-0.0094570816,
-0.0116473837,
0.0313323848,
0.0171748865,
-0.0826301798,
-0.0028071573,
-0.0115525452,
0.0351110213,
0.095266819,
0.0573217832,
0.0049951151,
-0.056232024,
0.0275619552,
-0.0209865831,
0.0747266114,
-0.0783123598,
0.0196193121,
0.0543121211,
0.0061768545,
0.0270361286,
-0.0417789444,
0.0444914438,
0.0558960512,
-0.0077765631,
-0.0290772449,
0.0172057301,
-0.0407068357,
0.0280680619,
-0.0017191939,
0.1130464226,
0.0135146808,
-0.0213309117,
-0.0218885466,
0.0038100383,
-0.0060051796,
0.027609881,
-0.0730370134,
0.0327399522,
-0.0074573131,
-0.0018241579,
-0.017955428,
0.0200200938,
0.0311705414,
0.015949646,
-0.0327367559,
0.121846959,
0.0030336576,
-0.0276977904,
0.0106570078,
-0.0219804104,
-0.0749508068,
-0.0356025323,
0.0199652277,
0.0488216318,
0.0328944139,
0.0195505973,
-0.0336290598,
-0.0390432589,
-0.0089047104,
-0.0112012289,
0.0414718837,
0.0681703836,
0.0172023606,
0.0694964752,
-0.0162536278,
0.0256403349,
-0.0121252108,
0.0267154258,
-0.0431501456,
0.0052453978,
-0.0406149253,
-0.0154084163,
-0.0032669494,
0.0438960344,
-0.0223842189,
0.014518437,
-0.0432870202,
0.0333135538,
-0.0042284266,
0.0105935642,
0.0192946494,
-0.0083275028,
-0.004575226,
-0.0535077676,
-0.0420311168,
-0.0045428956,
-0.066485554,
0.020768296,
0.0079332367,
-0.0600755811,
-0.0303777009,
0.0115964031,
-0.0141563099,
-0.0303791091,
0.0323924087,
0.0643867999,
0.040738795,
-0.0123850359,
0.007089505,
-0.0130573129,
0.024782436,
-0.0726298168,
-0.0132575566,
-0.0904944763,
0.0531855077,
0.0022422099,
-0.0246190615,
-0.0154303601,
0.0005779918,
0.0295434408,
0.029941434,
0.0769655704,
-0.0058038025,
0.0010293059,
0.0522672012,
0.0137357051,
-0.0334271342,
0.0558449477,
0.0344136134,
-0.0260908175,
0.0310517326,
-0.0025615026,
0.0115774525,
0.0130113838,
0.0257667154,
-0.0088693127,
0.003923628,
0.0547408983,
0.0030515438,
0.0619919226,
-0.0235657226,
0.0300884601,
-0.0408032723,
-0.0194898229,
0.0227678586,
0.064293161,
-0.0265629478,
0.0119563453,
0.0262684152,
-0.0182975624,
0.0483014286,
-0.0330084488,
-0.0574713126,
0.0311058313,
-0.0253600478,
-0.0066206367,
-0.005019377,
0.0006535199,
-0.0399541706,
-0.0648284927,
0.0131646749,
0.0004403122,
-0.0645865574,
0.0262271501,
0.0466026403,
-0.0028049964,
0.0194658749,
0.0377333984,
-0.0057357578,
-0.0329125971,
-0.03246044,
-0.0461938158,
0.0499654859,
-0.024587635,
0.0478416979,
-0.0631435588,
-0.0752822459,
-0.0294550247,
0.031078551,
0.0303938501,
0.0572494045,
-0.0150221791,
-0.013472572,
-0.0648545697,
0.0129279317,
-0.0417581126,
0.0163651314,
-0.006966949,
0.0280640256,
0.0108953351,
0.0254438873,
-0.0605908595,
0.04515424,
0.0293908026,
-0.0690438077,
-0.0456948429,
0.0077424445,
-0.0212570205,
0.0117764641,
-0.0339554697,
0.0337404348,
0.0482678041,
0.0126184002,
-0.0473619699,
-0.0137007711,
-0.0150824934,
-0.0698838457,
-0.0690668598,
0.0746909529,
-0.0438780412,
-0.0249966606,
0.039341867,
-0.0698438957,
-0.0340043791,
0.0434756316,
0.0095756343,
0.0085431281,
-0.0347218364,
-0.0006995872,
-0.0101628359,
0.0072137034,
-0.0241645444,
0.0696141124,
-0.0024731853,
0.0110809775,
0.0059943995,
-0.0252127666,
0.0322710127,
0.0035713171,
0.0029496967,
-0.0109750004,
-0.0201348569,
0.0010839102,
-0.0395812355,
0.0108911917,
-0.05786971,
-0.0155615937,
-0.0209149066,
0.0348961838,
0.0029744732,
0.059262231,
0.0313784294,
-0.032369975,
-0.0121813957,
-0.0141191073,
-0.0376518145,
-0.0151309073,
-0.0012472597,
-0.0222004205,
0.0541100092,
0.0105379019,
0.032774467,
-0.0265641026,
-0.0357834548,
-0.0370763727,
0.0554217957,
0.0065697245,
0.0693548322,
-0.0004268204,
-0.0044999355,
-0.0619986467,
0.0080347247,
-0.0165064465,
0.0402323008,
0.0286641531,
-0.0468931943,
0.0306579955,
0.0620403364,
-0.0122177359,
0.0019420099,
0.0265665427,
-0.005204434,
-0.0501884669,
0.0221842676,
-0.0078905309,
0.0048595299,
-0.0114475535,
-0.0239599869,
-0.008544161,
0.0665100664,
-0.0324888639,
-0.0228788238,
-0.0235650353,
0.0776348114,
-0.0032174406,
0.0024564802,
-0.0441851504,
0.0378432758,
0.0025413169,
0.0431068391,
-0.0134627735,
-0.0258116126,
0.070625931,
-0.0033540179,
-0.0029094878,
-0.0491136014,
0.0230924152,
-0.0778929591,
0.0352754593,
-0.0261726957,
-0.0263863113,
-0.0098448517,
0.0085527878,
-0.0293453876,
-0.0319739319,
0.034032695,
-0.0415808894,
0.0416453406,
-0.0504662991,
0.013703065,
-0.0076319021,
-0.0500627793,
-0.033944048,
-0.0102215698,
-0.0414068997,
0.01233509,
-0.0509375557,
-0.0102720968,
-0.0231174584,
-0.0179755632,
0.0271445829,
0.013652321,
-0.0364143625,
-0.0263814442,
-0.0135853803,
0.0118401907,
0.044571802,
0.0435002893,
0.0650422946,
-0.0554695576,
0.0549234822,
0.0351234414,
0.0469828136,
0.0316201523,
-0.0129275881,
0.0142673934,
-0.0115767336,
-0.0074948263,
-0.0200721957,
0.0135261957,
0.009082783,
-0.0650331154,
-0.0017588692,
0.1148166656,
0.0367140919,
-0.0040389039,
-0.0269326512,
-0.0762442425,
0.0225933362,
0.039675992,
0.0233289506,
-0.0641610846,
-0.0488111973,
0.022745464,
0.0147973457,
0.0229651202,
-0.0363424867,
-0.0012519021,
-0.1104317531,
0.0064204615,
-0.0102230674,
-0.0404021107,
0.0024206263,
-0.0242611952,
0.012244191,
0.0026607492,
-0.0282443017,
0.0183135681,
-0.0107161412,
0.0358912833,
0.0049075102,
-0.0006176845,
-0.018579077,
0.0416433886,
0.0014938638,
0.0108556608,
-0.0041992064,
0.031641081,
-0.0477270819,
-0.0615430884,
0.0507675931,
0.011432224,
-0.0488528237,
-0.007162109,
0.0383548662,
-0.0161541477,
-0.009306985,
-0.0362709276,
0.0598184057,
-0.086151734,
-0.0258517489,
0.0460987017,
0.1123390198,
-0.0163280964,
-0.0236741342,
-0.01267129,
0.0127091445,
-0.0655910075,
0.0561762191,
0.0316219591,
-0.0082014129,
-0.04147714,
-0.027036719,
-0.0384731591,
-0.0403289311,
-0.0249245632,
0.0306730494,
0.0795346051,
0.0079007167,
-0.0478463545,
-0.0130890179,
0.0515909344,
0.047060933,
0.0058028335,
-0.0110144606,
-0.0049343733,
-0.0082226191,
-0.0296186469,
0.0372973457,
-0.0672259331,
0.0119552407,
-0.0472287349,
0.0616721176,
0.0338083245,
-0.0234769434,
-0.0413132235,
-0.0019886019,
-0.092355229,
-0.0473793037,
-0.030061448,
0.049645666,
0.02352852,
0.0018147914,
-0.0069404445,
-0.0127102304,
0.028283624,
0.0057564452,
-0.0368663296,
0.0238891803,
0.0404462032,
-0.0189846251,
0.0003900614,
0.0292827878,
0.0036476112,
0.021271985,
0.0097534582,
0.0461937226,
-0.0430186875,
-0.0027686195,
0.0116548436,
0.0434467904,
0.0080679944,
0.0572950393,
-0.0029642677,
-0.0143449241,
0.0409667417,
-0.0197550151,
0.0066074464,
-0.0313315354,
0.0317336544,
0.0310369078,
-0.0426493697,
0.005927491,
-0.0573789477,
-0.0040833731,
0.0216672607,
0.0202401597,
0.0667216703,
-0.0136792082,
0.0409163311,
0.0256774239,
-0.0256134458,
0.0019441351,
-0.0124347126,
0.0043789176,
0.0526227057,
-0.0106758969,
0.0554736182,
0.0277441833,
0.0102391941,
-0.0270953178,
0.0052457023,
-0.0613665245,
-0.0864980817,
0.0093670031,
0.0508127771,
-0.006194416,
0.0393827111,
-0.0272066705,
-0.0198680367,
-0.0034182104,
0.0076815207,
0.0286236443,
0.0117611429,
-0.0103009427,
0.060171131,
0.0465315506,
0.0062811798,
-0.0341117866,
0.0515228584,
-0.0330026187,
0.0393681489,
0.0235764366,
0.0337524898,
-0.040875461,
-0.0062192269,
-0.0309039336,
0.0145171219,
0.0097759506,
0.0322996192,
-0.072192423,
-0.0823360458,
0.0147252129,
0.0212260969,
-0.037909817,
0.0056673912,
0.0284741614,
0.0537234209,
-0.0053335447,
-0.0229311436,
-0.0039062239,
0.0821451098,
-0.0539944023,
-0.0310741682,
0.0143680722,
-5.992397265e-33,
-0.0048103798,
-0.0181383248,
0.0480942838,
0.0318845548,
-0.0041766288,
-0.0264702216,
-0.0383288898,
0.0129471887,
-0.0466894992,
-0.0057817181,
-0.01374494,
0.0416527539,
-0.0004423211,
0.0121073276,
-0.0124134487,
-0.020395169,
-0.0202618185,
-0.0224597249,
-0.0173234139,
-0.0084766941,
-0.0072519402,
0.0269672517,
0.0628977716,
-0.0301938374,
-0.0027125019,
-0.033371754,
-0.0002300459,
0.0338178948,
-0.0671319142,
0.0494963862,
-0.0372068994,
0.0185327288,
0.0214526374,
-0.0342994109,
0.0162206199,
0.0066411458,
-0.0387625434,
-0.0522285886,
-0.0091206525,
-0.0117279282,
-0.0641010627,
-0.0289853271,
0.039275188,
0.0314020552,
0.0007733236,
-0.0352395512,
0.0172843449,
-0.0413011946,
-0.0043382389,
0.0378871262,
-0.015509773,
0.0443006828,
-0.020489756,
-0.0114484848,
0.0203939881,
0.0352386981,
0.0010136324,
0.0246669371,
0.0231163371,
0.0097017111,
0.0093725985,
0.0184294153,
0.0233644638,
-0.0061627408,
0.0319742337,
0.035840217,
-0.0029534379,
-0.0218244605,
0.0119868061,
0.0100671155,
0.0143702282,
0.0562953018,
0.0575804226,
0.0506263115,
0.0556160808,
0.0070650796,
-0.0535902418,
0.0300241672,
-0.0053352281,
0.0414955765,
0.0145652071,
-0.0213143937,
-0.0269543137,
0.020478528,
-0.0783930123,
0.0206314493,
-0.0647649243,
-0.0041634203,
0.0349005386,
-0.021959804,
-0.0284150019,
0.0234886371,
0.0076161851,
-0.0315008499,
-0.0207857955,
0.0051361183,
-0.010008906,
0.019740371,
-0.0035619461,
0.0606005788,
-0.025409868,
-0.0099507198,
-0.0157424044,
0.000953952,
0.0385467224,
0.0014715594,
0.0245350935,
0.0029385788,
-0.0544872098,
-0.0350885876,
-0.0330265909,
-0.0047279219,
0.0433480069,
0.0538335294,
-0.0033282347,
0.049873434,
-0.0109809078,
0.0231658686,
-0.0212644897,
-0.0184739176,
-0.0389147513,
-0.0075416309,
-0.0137394704,
0.0259761978,
-0.0347703844,
-0.0175823104,
-0.0196803957,
-0.0049875122,
0.0438481867,
-0.0689195693,
-0.0004717542,
0.0282630008,
2.835e-7,
0.0690382272,
0.0481313728,
0.0003540959,
-0.0042827441,
0.0030682194,
0.0451281033,
-0.0447455198,
-0.0233553927,
0.0356707498,
-0.0401956476,
-0.011324659,
0.0658268556,
0.0213205386,
0.0535002165,
-0.0777138472,
0.0312553868,
-0.0359699465,
0.0032193952,
-0.0435100868,
-0.0066905171,
0.0484735444,
0.1160358042,
0.0232517868,
-0.0276875123,
0.0058640791,
-0.0187348686,
0.0623629093,
-0.0172280855,
-0.0081645446,
0.0338227153,
-0.0154932057,
0.0027413743,
0.0038219092,
-0.0083312672,
0.0063485573,
0.0076527158,
0.0272538271,
0.0805464163,
0.019389281,
0.0082695857,
-0.0178684238,
-0.0210809093,
0.0128472159,
-0.0265221931,
0.0615504533,
-0.0384227931,
-0.0476666279,
-0.0293882582,
-0.0165139697,
-0.031189505,
0.0371192321,
-0.0192393549,
0.0333257578,
-0.0119888466,
0.0096110366,
-0.0302513372,
0.0055636135,
-0.0701973215,
-0.0390557013,
-0.0050486731,
-0.0549469702,
-0.0196220726,
-0.0521624051,
-0.0224517267,
0.0415182486,
-0.0315821953,
0.0096479002,
2.587699514e-34,
0.0313631371,
-0.0080148345,
0.0317605399,
0.0234715268,
0.0152716795,
-0.0154103357,
-0.0262397211,
0.0008556598,
0.0201481618,
-0.0948302224,
-0.0153092882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12278v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12278v1 | Inspire the Large Language Model by External Knowledge on BioMedical Named Entity Recognition | 2023-09-21T17:39:53 | 2023-09-21T17:39:53 | Junyi Bian, Jiaxuan Zheng, Yuyi Zhang, Shanfeng Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated dominating performance in many
NLP tasks, especially on generative tasks. However, they often fall short in
some information extraction tasks, particularly those requiring domain-specific
knowledge, such as Biomedical Named Entity Recognition (NER). In this paper,
inspired by Chain-of-thought, we leverage the LLM to solve the Biomedical NER
step-by-step: break down the NER task into entity span extraction and entity
type determination. Additionally, for entity type determination, we inject
entity knowledge to address the problem that LLM's lack of domain knowledge
when predicting entity category. Experimental results show a significant
improvement in our two-step BioNER approach compared to previous few-shot LLM
baseline. Additionally, the incorporation of external knowledge significantly
enhances entity category determination performance. | [
0.053229738,
0.0568221845,
0.0321126319,
0.0008845863,
0.0208069459,
0.0584810413,
0.0070504304,
0.030063156,
0.0360640101,
-0.0456258282,
-0.0432730503,
-0.0473729856,
0.0047828676,
0.0277771298,
0.0529913865,
-0.0054141246,
0.0121592106,
-0.0091397539,
0.0235212501,
0.0166091155,
-0.0364617445,
-0.0035293975,
-0.0085871331,
0.0128142284,
0.0479560867,
0.010710937,
0.0058575445,
-0.000567086,
0.0491540395,
-0.0856749564,
-0.0017093144,
0.0202901196,
-0.0035501595,
0.0606241375,
0.0000016289,
-0.0558095947,
-0.0376396962,
0.0514602251,
-0.0341546349,
-0.0034682758,
-0.0033815862,
-0.0423813872,
-0.0090555167,
-0.0032593592,
0.0224023946,
-0.0919920504,
0.0125512416,
0.080933392,
0.0052452311,
0.0650119707,
-0.0025054372,
-0.0326497033,
0.0639887825,
-0.029235946,
-0.008490474,
-0.0338469148,
0.091365166,
-0.0325124227,
0.030598253,
0.0216961317,
0.0043036188,
0.0284705274,
-0.0400780737,
0.0298154745,
0.0443825386,
0.0647342131,
0.0052825888,
0.0002523011,
-0.0028375247,
0.0641322359,
-0.0336592086,
0.0047977292,
0.0631497875,
0.0103182131,
-0.0474518351,
0.0003165626,
-0.0198898409,
0.0193365458,
-0.0612318479,
0.0049153995,
0.022242995,
-0.0093505783,
0.0467948876,
-0.0047465805,
-0.0404262468,
0.0164429452,
0.025437329,
-0.0281138476,
0.0311519504,
0.0196160451,
-0.0031334462,
-0.0460767411,
0.04952446,
0.0346816443,
0.0074250582,
0.0183375273,
0.0184611678,
0.0210232679,
0.027734356,
-0.0578756705,
-0.0027521192,
-0.0176050663,
0.002807321,
0.0371725895,
-0.0657390431,
-0.0056865523,
-0.0691249222,
0.0027344823,
0.0125710573,
-0.0231392477,
-0.0540230125,
-0.0040563182,
-0.0053714635,
0.0540677048,
-0.0121805649,
-0.0171464942,
-0.0507042743,
-0.0095460769,
0.0078154318,
0.0324885063,
0.0153001072,
0.0023962634,
0.0064122137,
-0.0170751624,
-0.021045696,
0.0260657761,
0.021202689,
-0.0032360214,
-0.0424417146,
-0.0416966788,
0.0093415808,
-0.0263482984,
0.0184553787,
-0.0565257743,
0.030456081,
0.0968198106,
0.040571209,
-0.0776361153,
-0.0505002737,
0.012365683,
-0.016922202,
-0.0577456206,
0.0084711928,
-0.0212650355,
0.0295233764,
0.0177554935,
0.0035421322,
-0.0400504135,
0.0291872937,
-0.0126889329,
-0.0502553694,
0.0955877826,
-0.0506995283,
-0.0260167047,
0.0409355313,
0.0119460262,
0.0297178887,
0.0202209242,
0.0104126818,
-0.0447858386,
-0.0146679636,
-0.0138967894,
0.0190492291,
0.02913942,
0.0138834445,
-0.070169434,
0.0010027313,
0.0203322526,
0.0192315206,
0.0547324829,
0.0420785435,
0.0493713468,
0.0056054583,
0.0068470263,
0.0075623025,
0.035410136,
0.0415144004,
-0.0007331343,
0.0403266996,
-0.0250377469,
0.0153432982,
-0.0247129686,
-0.0206223726,
-0.0073144091,
-0.0111852288,
0.0405166969,
-0.0007581186,
0.0773601234,
-0.0303434432,
0.0418452621,
-0.014420948,
-0.0030636813,
-0.0495285988,
0.0043972614,
0.0699506029,
0.0078871464,
-0.0391509347,
0.0844240114,
0.070804894,
0.0036593927,
0.0404735729,
-0.0333720408,
0.0019155842,
0.0328748189,
0.0424505882,
-0.0344705805,
-0.0396163538,
-0.039709311,
-0.0498978235,
0.0578890927,
-0.0172851477,
-0.0462214015,
0.0078625483,
-0.0341345109,
0.0109300418,
0.0470832027,
0.024250675,
0.002836088,
0.022312738,
0.0540019162,
0.0073436662,
-0.0311841816,
0.0039818906,
0.0466694981,
-0.0845293105,
-0.0374268964,
-0.0236376673,
0.0049669822,
0.0217993297,
0.0317459032,
-0.0273877438,
0.0029143894,
0.0146496575,
-0.0624286085,
-0.0340951495,
-0.0367671512,
0.0037669998,
-0.0624741279,
0.0229404811,
0.0047497875,
-0.0133541282,
-0.0506740361,
-0.0100809168,
-0.0151613262,
-0.0377838016,
0.0169117246,
0.0273671336,
-0.0131540066,
0.0524734892,
0.0133444276,
-0.0127978427,
-0.0442184396,
0.0469976664,
-0.0064462419,
0.0124923214,
0.0194420721,
-0.0416245796,
-0.0043222927,
-0.0261440538,
-0.0189727135,
0.0618512742,
0.0197733119,
-0.0167763662,
-0.0114205778,
-0.0179284625,
-0.0609817021,
-0.0359641388,
-0.0784692466,
-0.0010124926,
0.0263312757,
0.0518113896,
-0.0034901709,
0.0264515206,
0.0015706654,
0.0055621006,
-0.0150832618,
-0.0275648609,
-0.045668453,
-0.0028995646,
0.0234367345,
0.0243567713,
-0.0326121449,
-0.0045923418,
0.0183740612,
-0.0560613349,
0.0575012416,
-0.0107213231,
-0.0562659018,
-0.057444524,
0.0377585888,
-0.0321198031,
0.0039007892,
0.0016070054,
0.015000809,
-0.0184955727,
0.0126778865,
0.0177159663,
0.0460119434,
0.0110835535,
0.0112276571,
0.0194680709,
0.0032234585,
-0.0124599934,
0.0198544059,
-0.0355070494,
0.023228582,
-0.0256640818,
-0.0147308083,
0.0226545483,
0.0877053067,
-0.0319046676,
0.0121991131,
-0.0151765877,
-0.0006905436,
-0.0102688717,
0.0033203366,
-0.0240730885,
0.0338616148,
-0.042507574,
-0.0035293365,
-0.0151655478,
-0.0003589594,
0.083701767,
-0.0426175147,
-0.0155521845,
-0.0070247212,
0.0052997465,
-0.0691052824,
0.015624634,
0.0154187288,
0.0139569519,
0.0180831663,
-0.0586045496,
0.0243959781,
0.0652115121,
-0.0320742242,
-0.0365175828,
0.0473107845,
-0.0129317269,
0.0338648967,
0.0060778526,
-0.0203406382,
-0.0523204729,
0.0240791738,
-0.055935096,
0.038328547,
-0.0066713644,
-0.0183024891,
-0.009354542,
0.0304929242,
0.0401668213,
0.0337228253,
0.0128725553,
-0.0163383074,
-0.0170676205,
0.0657023638,
0.047453966,
-0.0163775384,
0.0240547378,
-0.0070563299,
0.0108033279,
0.0392848179,
-0.0336475186,
0.0132869054,
0.0040241187,
0.001247409,
0.0217761267,
-0.0534370914,
0.0308155846,
-0.0079161385,
0.0297839623,
-0.0158205982,
0.0003005374,
0.106340453,
0.0125345103,
-0.0451915525,
0.0073852916,
0.0197543483,
-0.0113877784,
0.0065810974,
0.0367717706,
-0.0528302677,
-0.0194175411,
0.0165066142,
-0.0276310071,
-0.0198119227,
-0.0959874839,
0.0073534609,
-0.1075888798,
0.0074725775,
-0.0145168956,
-0.0461924151,
-0.0115002282,
-0.0607130527,
0.0038116903,
-0.0271920748,
-0.0225734785,
0.0067952503,
-0.025310412,
-0.021903716,
0.0200978648,
0.0075963116,
-0.1010394767,
0.0180206969,
-0.0454560667,
0.0603756905,
0.0526099391,
0.0322895385,
-0.025150042,
0.0336932503,
0.0275263358,
-0.0554351471,
-0.0282996818,
-0.0176191647,
0.0644013956,
-0.0147057576,
-0.0168939512,
-0.0303190127,
0.0144107714,
-0.0292310324,
-0.0130413901,
-0.0029883927,
0.085439913,
0.0094159069,
-0.05653321,
-0.0094352318,
-0.0483667403,
0.0021163891,
0.0808832124,
0.0084652063,
-0.0468685925,
-0.0074169878,
0.0181859434,
-0.0153472321,
0.0097422553,
-0.0546332598,
0.0341235735,
-0.0279638208,
-0.0415375717,
-0.0236771386,
-0.0077330968,
0.0531624071,
0.0334749371,
0.0152037079,
0.0505093858,
0.0575915426,
-0.0014944159,
-0.0474483855,
0.0378951393,
0.0005649997,
0.0007803866,
-0.0556398183,
-0.0441797785,
0.0598477498,
-0.0062890365,
-0.0308420248,
0.0194174685,
-0.0245660059,
-0.0642415062,
-0.0255409572,
0.0137750302,
0.0162585732,
-0.0009140251,
-0.0002779378,
-0.0182714928,
0.0701831207,
0.0495940112,
-0.0512809791,
-0.0094888601,
-0.0420206301,
0.0516827703,
-0.0242110509,
0.0305780862,
-0.0202855561,
0.0175797418,
0.048164133,
0.0464083068,
-0.013844572,
-0.0190697685,
0.002068179,
0.0408881679,
0.0461035967,
-0.0386702865,
-0.0077565149,
-0.0570378155,
0.0079083918,
0.001406095,
0.0399167091,
-0.0249797478,
-0.0286443122,
0.0552242063,
0.013833167,
-0.0175866261,
0.0366035141,
0.0066391104,
-0.0063588959,
-0.0409286059,
0.0245567579,
-0.0008166083,
0.03110951,
0.0730894431,
-0.0371931717,
0.0036750049,
0.0241495278,
0.0449180901,
0.0188870188,
-0.0459013954,
0.0213371236,
0.0193771236,
0.007558364,
-0.0291225165,
0.0137650063,
-0.0348958112,
0.0083493441,
-0.0291839335,
0.0573323928,
0.0353060663,
0.0033796448,
0.0424927361,
0.0089761596,
-0.0264082663,
-0.0142216673,
0.0215479899,
-0.0364421234,
0.0093523599,
0.0636522323,
0.0262406114,
-0.0457677171,
-0.0339852348,
0.0605886653,
0.0628233254,
0.0637360662,
0.0094224112,
-0.0193434414,
-0.0370961837,
-0.007171331,
-0.0120923417,
-0.0457882434,
-0.0575546026,
0.0427286699,
-0.0653578788,
-0.051885087,
0.0563146919,
-0.0582912564,
-0.0068993862,
0.0014167164,
0.0250059422,
0.0150804846,
0.0306712743,
-0.0393049605,
-0.0117956065,
0.0202774312,
0.0077471281,
-0.0500864536,
0.0030767184,
-5.918813523e-33,
-0.0209566411,
-0.0517924167,
0.0312110297,
-0.0285022371,
-0.0142266043,
0.0545513481,
-0.046288792,
-0.0066319397,
0.01483614,
-0.00289271,
-0.0074565616,
-0.0244523752,
-0.0007132001,
0.0174346827,
0.0046122666,
-0.0214006212,
0.048651062,
0.0258341692,
0.0038665948,
0.0140745481,
0.0101990802,
0.100046508,
0.0553011931,
-0.0849905312,
-0.0048079891,
0.0257293656,
0.0257730931,
-0.0071691722,
0.0251722354,
0.0578106232,
-0.0771828666,
0.0090290215,
0.0248538144,
-0.0416743197,
0.0125441551,
-0.0309874509,
-0.1291006953,
0.0416656807,
-0.0171458274,
0.0060900529,
-0.0071017193,
-0.0580101013,
0.0273382533,
-0.0053027333,
-0.0145172039,
-0.0398603566,
0.0318153277,
-0.0189014152,
-0.0142598804,
-0.0572472923,
-0.0676355138,
0.0425950326,
0.0366343148,
0.0465066209,
0.0708861202,
-0.0605544038,
-0.0145985903,
0.0580663644,
-0.0229311138,
-0.0175244175,
0.0347538777,
-0.0123917954,
0.0075255809,
0.0167901926,
-0.0049787178,
0.0576892532,
0.0101587083,
-0.0133078219,
-0.0718861744,
-0.0020237747,
-0.0264901742,
0.0236906242,
-0.0181227569,
0.0302741025,
0.0050877403,
-0.0048621255,
-0.0886619538,
0.0265773982,
-0.0327935554,
0.0070150965,
-0.0066652517,
-0.0270880628,
-0.0261367094,
0.0124453958,
-0.007014323,
-0.0146724638,
-0.0416572578,
0.0063816784,
0.0082753608,
0.006922124,
-0.0199891366,
0.0315557718,
0.0199181754,
-0.0422198661,
-0.0625789687,
0.0293198582,
0.0505695492,
0.0303198751,
-0.0075480114,
-0.0099715823,
-0.0860907733,
-0.0571997613,
0.0191608313,
-0.0106214629,
0.0314894915,
-0.0057146098,
0.0247868691,
-0.0375484116,
-0.0588104762,
-0.0144127253,
-0.0150417872,
-0.0005472355,
0.0210904758,
0.055560451,
0.0049606888,
-0.0002138996,
0.0079526696,
0.0405240171,
0.0492338464,
-0.0081271986,
0.0132814869,
0.0576852858,
0.0362369977,
0.0328222923,
-0.0271132421,
-0.0089946594,
0.0064585931,
0.023627039,
0.0031696998,
-0.0613653474,
-0.0045132833,
-0.0416551717,
2.506e-7,
0.0365337953,
0.0318801887,
0.0142103182,
-0.0129354149,
0.0212689824,
0.0030593004,
-0.0079166126,
0.0189708881,
-0.0442822091,
-0.0224260855,
-0.0063950815,
-0.0056149899,
0.0196624286,
0.0064118523,
-0.0944233462,
-0.0222986285,
-0.0165810697,
-0.018016845,
-0.0493595675,
-0.0163109414,
0.0014484201,
0.0693099499,
-0.0326422639,
-0.0225325711,
0.0175245535,
-0.0147692533,
0.0512405224,
-0.0032470266,
0.0202299599,
0.0685431585,
-0.0128105329,
0.0364813879,
-0.0019481899,
0.0290342476,
-0.0077319313,
0.005105067,
0.0071495422,
0.0788158923,
-0.0152085181,
0.0210359246,
0.0395374708,
-0.0064640203,
0.0309646595,
-0.0414392874,
0.0425526761,
-0.0478578173,
-0.0427744649,
-0.006637183,
-0.0047890889,
-0.0207386632,
0.0000984402,
-0.0333981439,
0.0291198976,
0.0280664321,
0.0247056577,
-0.0281087868,
-0.0142857544,
-0.0853197947,
0.0117783155,
0.056792032,
-0.0415575653,
-0.0358759314,
0.0077213082,
-0.0083419615,
0.0234095585,
-0.1005249918,
0.0233539306,
2.320086287e-34,
-0.0090751955,
0.0139362859,
-0.0401611105,
0.0653787479,
0.026895754,
-0.0400546938,
-0.0506654531,
0.0031540089,
-0.0318174846,
-0.0950549617,
0.0039977049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12276v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12276v3 | LLMR: Real-time Prompting of Interactive Worlds using Large Language Models | 2023-09-21T17:37:01 | 2024-03-22T17:28:17 | Fernanda De La Torre, Cathy Mengying Fang, Han Huang, Andrzej Banburski-Fahey, Judith Amores Fernandez, Jaron Lanier | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.ET | We present Large Language Model for Mixed Reality (LLMR), a framework for the
real-time creation and modification of interactive Mixed Reality experiences
using LLMs. LLMR leverages novel strategies to tackle difficult cases where
ideal training data is scarce, or where the design goal requires the synthesis
of internal dynamics, intuitive analysis, or advanced interactivity. Our
framework relies on text interaction and the Unity game engine. By
incorporating techniques for scene understanding, task planning,
self-debugging, and memory management, LLMR outperforms the standard GPT-4 by
4x in average error rate. We demonstrate LLMR's cross-platform interoperability
with several example worlds, and evaluate it on a variety of creation and
modification tasks to show that it can produce and edit diverse objects, tools,
and scenes. Finally, we conducted a usability study (N=11) with a diverse set
that revealed participants had positive experiences with the system and would
use it again. | [
0.0059738583,
-0.0031978523,
-0.0131333042,
0.0207005888,
-0.0261109658,
0.0095631219,
0.0210081022,
-0.0035228131,
0.0324476436,
-0.0200645886,
-0.0338374861,
-0.0453443155,
-0.0032896216,
0.0548695326,
-0.0053661908,
-0.0701906607,
0.0059222984,
-0.0723892301,
-0.0476919077,
0.0044673155,
-0.0284687188,
0.0113626188,
-0.071955502,
0.0349966362,
0.0099417148,
-0.0418801345,
-0.0590204783,
0.0374810062,
0.0264729634,
-0.0406213403,
-0.0200590957,
0.0584518053,
0.072032094,
0.0282544214,
0.0000023607,
-0.0495861955,
0.0080459993,
-0.0201041177,
0.0313079283,
-0.0026068597,
-0.0025151318,
0.0251854695,
-0.0000993983,
-0.0035560057,
-0.012490022,
-0.0253618136,
0.0589284673,
0.0217800997,
0.0618355609,
-0.0020613065,
-0.0096128313,
-0.0169662088,
-0.0242265482,
0.0221487843,
0.0018571195,
0.0383625142,
0.0017100326,
0.0262493081,
0.0879380628,
-0.01187535,
0.0291003752,
0.0170750357,
0.0265183598,
0.0146375485,
-0.0007813789,
0.0429123193,
-0.0158093795,
-0.0055558071,
-0.021171201,
0.043424014,
-0.0411524698,
0.0019673652,
0.0502067506,
0.016067626,
-0.0283526182,
0.0181870572,
-0.0411609858,
0.0256593097,
-0.0509594753,
-0.0122619672,
-0.0562211685,
-0.0306728557,
-0.0122145405,
-0.0285868347,
-0.0083910609,
0.0501569174,
0.0536262691,
-0.0009276206,
-0.0543115288,
0.0145904906,
0.0308692679,
-0.066678606,
-0.0055416492,
0.0141573437,
-0.0307056718,
0.0096554002,
-0.063072212,
0.0045482311,
-0.0237175766,
-0.0574227422,
0.0178234745,
0.0280982386,
-0.0351888388,
0.0655515492,
0.0171367489,
0.0526187904,
-0.0092543522,
-0.032539662,
0.0016511868,
0.0171903986,
-0.0317929238,
-0.0076952288,
-0.024590902,
-0.0043485514,
-0.1118894145,
-0.0067794025,
-0.0031079573,
0.0480515137,
-0.0070368494,
0.0359421261,
-0.0040688016,
-0.0208139997,
-0.026230067,
0.0099188071,
-0.0208857805,
0.0067181094,
0.0145173036,
0.0231828801,
-0.015076234,
-0.0794105083,
0.0275680646,
0.0244845767,
0.0306589715,
0.0006297185,
-0.0380438343,
0.1132007018,
-0.0237773582,
0.0136141777,
-0.0101372181,
-0.0435366631,
0.0013550771,
-0.0300648492,
0.0169595126,
-0.0505063906,
0.0221124496,
-0.0155714741,
0.0059802546,
-0.0139294835,
0.0377483405,
0.0344376974,
0.0191739704,
0.0623215958,
-0.0561570898,
0.0396430828,
0.0553749129,
0.0154564008,
0.018682966,
0.0582620502,
0.0099200848,
0.0538972989,
-0.0015032133,
-0.0043321969,
0.033267729,
0.0742484704,
-0.0490883403,
-0.0074026133,
-0.0292169992,
-0.0138799381,
0.0068052225,
0.0581681393,
-0.0650257021,
0.0142923333,
-0.0444189794,
0.0181132089,
0.0715874583,
0.001523194,
0.0020201523,
0.0141388411,
0.0737428963,
0.0148869008,
0.0339982621,
-0.033864446,
-0.0318722986,
0.0752432495,
0.0030506032,
-0.0063602617,
0.0021549198,
0.0220637284,
-0.0005581966,
-0.0272541996,
-0.0067081414,
-0.0158796031,
0.0148651255,
0.0105614075,
0.0510256514,
-0.0123211937,
-0.0526221395,
0.0160596799,
0.0025792385,
-0.0582797751,
0.0205661319,
-0.0087411273,
0.0255870558,
0.1296188682,
0.0106341764,
-0.0291774832,
-0.0507399999,
-0.031975925,
0.0252223779,
0.0488977507,
0.0342556126,
0.0004246632,
0.0402545109,
-0.013171372,
-0.0299902223,
-0.0326332897,
0.0023020315,
0.0863687769,
0.002633513,
0.0210037138,
-0.0206977036,
0.00045231,
-0.0065827351,
0.0152290314,
-0.0537804216,
-0.044371631,
-0.0570257157,
-0.0113358768,
-0.015358761,
0.017930299,
-0.031412717,
-0.0451598689,
0.0279202182,
-0.0250006523,
-0.0073786248,
0.0343995467,
-0.013610852,
0.0090195071,
0.049458351,
-0.0288286731,
-0.0161439069,
-0.0094839865,
0.0113312295,
-0.0195606016,
0.001744711,
0.0494411178,
0.0551772118,
-0.0149128446,
0.0059402422,
0.0133669702,
-0.0403331444,
-0.0512688756,
0.0408867598,
-0.0065478194,
0.0039784233,
0.0275575854,
-0.0201926492,
0.024807008,
-0.0237039328,
0.0263340473,
0.0191891715,
0.0051667914,
0.001110877,
-0.0042210896,
0.0192411281,
-0.0457438156,
-0.0277909692,
-0.0722620562,
-0.0573840588,
-0.0290148109,
-0.0138313128,
0.0417225473,
0.0053755795,
-0.0374982171,
-0.0135686509,
0.0027715811,
0.0200373642,
0.0092245853,
0.0016368557,
0.0151204662,
0.0330398045,
0.015219735,
-0.0231966525,
0.0369899422,
-0.0060904236,
0.0168082193,
0.0340989344,
0.0058323098,
-0.0617170259,
0.0333044417,
-0.0294449907,
0.0396088921,
-0.0103899706,
-0.0134166954,
0.0440892316,
-0.0294077806,
0.103154853,
0.016570162,
-0.0334311239,
0.0228602756,
0.0666908994,
-0.0823412389,
-0.0236986838,
0.016797727,
0.0204425845,
0.000272377,
-0.0261410121,
-0.0011911057,
0.0570758209,
0.0725112408,
0.0031387475,
0.0005828595,
-0.0439295284,
0.0401567109,
-0.040353857,
-0.0357935615,
0.0273565482,
0.0096780937,
-0.0280863419,
0.0336717218,
-0.0214564353,
-0.0145665007,
0.033265356,
-0.0727519542,
-0.0366826802,
0.0151501875,
-0.0105390223,
-0.0173138343,
0.0567954294,
-0.02862175,
0.0095304176,
-0.0229573362,
-0.0063643446,
0.0305745248,
0.0292598382,
0.0162879005,
-0.0001960678,
0.0182473008,
-0.1544663757,
-0.0145112332,
0.002401208,
-0.0157622453,
0.0041687693,
0.0388670005,
-0.0544630922,
-0.0458339527,
-0.0220554192,
-0.0104763554,
-0.0281209014,
0.0269914176,
0.025334524,
0.0851577073,
-0.0031517181,
-0.0230731778,
-0.0354607888,
-0.0412663221,
0.0490342788,
0.0314841978,
-0.0765538439,
-0.0476711206,
0.0137194851,
0.0169424675,
-0.0110343779,
-0.0342385732,
-0.0573460907,
0.0103945909,
0.0481367856,
0.010000621,
-0.0095737902,
0.0215738248,
0.0481944531,
-0.0546339601,
0.0029210495,
0.095100902,
0.0065815439,
-0.0271841343,
-0.0053569465,
-0.0619123913,
0.0182603691,
0.0286603495,
0.0135840774,
-0.0520856939,
-0.0244972967,
0.0069863857,
-0.0374117158,
0.0744973794,
-0.0456290096,
0.012449434,
-0.0569988489,
0.0290053207,
-0.002632637,
-0.0380193554,
-0.010576779,
0.0516028963,
0.0516582429,
0.0144179901,
-0.0299375877,
-0.0116225686,
0.0156856049,
0.0229401793,
-0.0165620185,
-0.0188823938,
-0.0307765659,
-0.003654683,
-0.0018315687,
0.0622195899,
0.0288671851,
0.0458846092,
0.002896487,
-0.0503466874,
0.0059451545,
0.0865183547,
0.0109142223,
-0.0442759432,
-0.0061317645,
0.0152667444,
-0.0122025982,
-0.0237002559,
0.0067033106,
0.0089675682,
-0.0424991921,
0.0488698371,
0.0622265823,
-0.0184727944,
0.0152412327,
-0.0253619868,
-0.0136537058,
0.0491816141,
0.0082971947,
-0.0283273924,
-0.0374114588,
-0.0169519614,
-0.0411149748,
-0.0140554095,
0.0126559269,
-0.0645099208,
-0.0298459549,
-0.0059826849,
0.0023141189,
-0.0535809696,
0.0035054958,
0.0584736168,
0.0601308942,
0.0030003842,
0.0077246642,
0.0151118403,
0.0297468975,
-0.0247828383,
0.0185964014,
-0.0155898053,
-0.0023269968,
-0.0429414771,
-0.0090934616,
0.0150532331,
-0.080257237,
0.0243452657,
0.038479846,
0.0185445566,
-0.0468298495,
0.0032120766,
0.0764273778,
0.0161911026,
0.0186068639,
0.0111553967,
-0.0271231532,
-0.0434783995,
-0.0383709744,
-0.03424941,
0.0173504483,
-0.010806716,
0.0739631578,
0.0323675498,
-0.0097936448,
-0.0455927141,
-0.0233217403,
-0.0033713107,
0.0112317279,
-0.0156735964,
-0.0590162389,
0.0087057184,
0.02780037,
0.0577957705,
-0.0371241905,
0.0356589369,
-0.030323619,
-0.0018699255,
-0.0774300322,
-0.0033440844,
-0.0669113174,
0.0358546302,
-0.0253716838,
-0.0098767327,
0.0135353403,
0.0282649323,
0.0152441645,
0.0094713876,
-0.0065280763,
0.0026538884,
0.0080432678,
-0.0194685366,
0.0584811233,
0.0231844522,
0.016960049,
0.0264677778,
-0.0413519554,
0.0689939037,
0.0108289756,
0.0455934778,
0.0076677073,
-0.0605400577,
0.0124132633,
0.0503846668,
0.0328309312,
-0.0901165083,
0.0404209346,
0.1032954678,
0.0582409091,
0.0295113046,
0.0476527326,
-0.0403659679,
0.0121142427,
-0.0390740708,
0.0111084841,
0.0607848093,
-0.048772119,
-0.0165775958,
0.0206346326,
-0.028402295,
-0.0337243117,
0.0266694911,
0.0037237005,
0.0085593127,
0.0191084649,
-0.0501215011,
-0.0451519452,
0.0198878478,
0.0316203423,
0.0232870094,
-0.0255826972,
0.0342620835,
-0.0597292483,
-0.0138391918,
-0.0251436625,
0.0695913807,
-0.0346790701,
-0.0457046032,
0.0235916767,
0.0463140719,
-0.0166599527,
-0.0260756575,
-0.0228129961,
0.0116007729,
-0.0096550882,
-0.0274007805,
-0.0021432035,
-5.516719885e-33,
-0.0505530685,
-0.0332619436,
0.0600045472,
-0.0611884929,
-0.0232721847,
-0.0515945554,
-0.0502430014,
-0.0051935776,
0.0278243758,
-0.0354579575,
0.0145358816,
-0.0470850915,
-0.0228432529,
-0.0045198197,
0.012435155,
0.0016222561,
0.043143224,
0.0319701172,
-0.0522393584,
-0.0108054066,
0.0152941169,
0.0299126599,
0.0382253416,
-0.0728862882,
-0.0087119946,
0.0167174656,
-0.0052816197,
-0.001442701,
-0.0073833219,
0.0063106539,
-0.0672259107,
0.0175754987,
0.0040673558,
-0.0273841191,
0.0127013763,
0.0066714827,
-0.0345646963,
-0.0267075803,
0.0066642952,
0.0384048745,
-0.058049649,
-0.0183482058,
-0.0286703873,
-0.0032532772,
0.0027565134,
-0.0245755333,
0.0418125428,
-0.0188703965,
-0.0052934918,
0.0182036348,
-0.0660993904,
0.0284228437,
0.0090798913,
-0.0470966138,
0.0169349872,
0.0401458032,
0.0069882083,
-0.0112650879,
-0.0575258918,
0.0112580871,
-0.0218902454,
-0.0331913792,
0.0764999539,
-0.0107920635,
0.0390536971,
0.0602260083,
0.0140966065,
-0.0024212918,
-0.0602012463,
0.034203656,
0.0133657483,
0.0614792891,
-0.0003212452,
0.078916803,
-0.0129717011,
0.0245806929,
-0.0055231866,
0.0055272048,
-0.043024227,
0.0230630189,
0.0046788454,
0.0542890951,
-0.0227250159,
0.0216072071,
-0.0064574145,
0.0640775412,
0.0044847033,
-0.0460553169,
0.0685667694,
-0.0118521219,
-0.0021503575,
-0.0820442215,
0.0377948172,
-0.0046609682,
-0.0319104902,
-0.0423469767,
-0.0134151466,
0.0072127511,
-0.0125994608,
0.0253419597,
0.0159860961,
0.0095684268,
0.0235105995,
-0.0036331881,
0.0255520903,
0.0314183049,
-0.0533919483,
0.0905960649,
-0.0319121704,
0.0188770592,
-0.0198420025,
0.0434411205,
0.0599104278,
0.0477045961,
0.0299409572,
-0.0855899081,
-0.0099453991,
0.02903747,
0.0087222643,
-0.0777720585,
-0.0194608402,
-0.0398724452,
-0.0352080874,
-0.0166633464,
-0.0346817225,
-0.0223255232,
-0.0551858507,
-0.0245903842,
0.039403528,
-0.0216537751,
-0.0146916015,
0.0091837291,
3.145e-7,
-0.0651311129,
0.0344589613,
-0.0266863182,
0.0099323923,
0.0025195244,
0.0242362171,
0.0091004744,
0.0350913815,
-0.0023233832,
-0.0257993955,
0.0110455947,
0.0255362913,
0.0225045737,
-0.0095426263,
-0.1008622721,
-0.0144231142,
0.0393025428,
-0.0011349771,
-0.0698054358,
0.0152953789,
0.031038532,
-0.0153337196,
0.0332055986,
0.0332170129,
0.0745996237,
0.0024605363,
0.0019861932,
-0.0680734739,
0.0139245866,
-0.0135182533,
0.0419823378,
0.0362676159,
-0.0330937803,
-0.0432381332,
-0.0059087663,
-0.0096241906,
0.0160573348,
0.0729077905,
-0.0371089913,
0.0381126516,
0.0262022614,
-0.0343809947,
-0.0176810753,
-0.065326497,
0.0395006686,
-0.0133836102,
0.0251552425,
-0.0081568118,
-0.0025846357,
-0.0457839891,
-0.0337172672,
-0.0157628115,
-0.0086931475,
-0.030704692,
-0.018480286,
0.005464789,
-0.0039552227,
-0.0254771616,
0.0245865919,
0.0140730357,
-0.0569968745,
0.0005843231,
-0.0817731097,
-0.0259630997,
-0.0245338827,
-0.0310304053,
-0.0205005035,
2.57132846e-34,
-0.0268883929,
0.0326251499,
0.0159130413,
0.0138681242,
0.0554366186,
0.0361971222,
0.0230104849,
0.0437622853,
0.0091116251,
-0.0385361798,
-0.0003686718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12273v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12273v2 | Improving VTE Identification through Adaptive NLP Model Selection and Clinical Expert Rule-based Classifier from Radiology Reports | 2023-09-21T17:29:37 | 2023-10-20T17:49:27 | Jamie Deng, Yusen Wu, Hilary Hayssen, Brain Englum, Aman Kankaria, Minerva Mayorga-Carlin, Shalini Sahoo, John Sorkin, Brajesh Lal, Yelena Yesha, Phuong Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Rapid and accurate identification of Venous thromboembolism (VTE), a severe
cardiovascular condition including deep vein thrombosis (DVT) and pulmonary
embolism (PE), is important for effective treatment. Leveraging Natural
Language Processing (NLP) on radiology reports, automated methods have shown
promising advancements in identifying VTE events from retrospective data
cohorts or aiding clinical experts in identifying VTE events from radiology
reports. However, effectively training Deep Learning (DL) and the NLP models is
challenging due to limited labeled medical text data, the complexity and
heterogeneity of radiology reports, and data imbalance. This study proposes
novel method combinations of DL methods, along with data augmentation, adaptive
pre-trained NLP model selection, and a clinical expert NLP rule-based
classifier, to improve the accuracy of VTE identification in unstructured
(free-text) radiology reports. Our experimental results demonstrate the model's
efficacy, achieving an impressive 97\% accuracy and 97\% F1 score in predicting
DVT, and an outstanding 98.3\% accuracy and 98.4\% F1 score in predicting PE.
These findings emphasize the model's robustness and its potential to
significantly contribute to VTE research. | [
0.0425955169,
0.0454148948,
0.0180457849,
-0.0112077547,
-0.0009563734,
0.031118622,
-0.0044594873,
0.0532968678,
-0.0180497766,
-0.0279969275,
0.0213743728,
-0.020512579,
-0.0340464599,
0.0805286393,
-0.0105423164,
-0.0559733436,
0.0273702797,
0.0119725149,
0.0547116287,
0.0259742662,
0.0382335633,
0.0217648726,
-0.0080145113,
0.033755552,
-0.0246249307,
0.0166107882,
0.0325198472,
-0.0334269814,
0.0073827426,
-0.0253481008,
-0.0014219601,
0.0227369517,
0.0431580991,
0.0005724719,
0.0000020177,
-0.0579980463,
-0.0408547707,
0.0212524198,
-0.0555702597,
-0.0300425664,
0.070305869,
-0.0765957013,
0.0440667421,
0.0037435095,
-0.0297006685,
-0.0722548887,
0.0555733852,
0.0756691247,
0.0470283777,
0.0449645296,
-0.0170204006,
0.0045580734,
0.0139221428,
-0.0184628703,
0.0067409156,
-0.0638360083,
0.0335088745,
0.0169838164,
0.0013150207,
-0.0142826689,
0.0164384432,
0.0213403441,
0.0129776951,
0.0271046218,
0.0444528684,
0.0439809896,
-0.0082584154,
-0.0131961172,
-0.0270128027,
0.084605813,
-0.0258354023,
-0.0168232676,
-0.0096439617,
-0.0187221523,
-0.0439835265,
0.0432480127,
0.0163476281,
-0.0318078808,
-0.0159208979,
-0.013419739,
0.0075301751,
0.01865701,
-0.0029779719,
0.0263027735,
-0.0177899301,
-0.0484297797,
-0.0077754222,
0.0101036029,
0.0248447265,
0.0314809158,
-0.0164980628,
-0.0294235665,
0.0487655327,
-0.0086319307,
-0.0365965366,
0.0082716467,
-0.0112243854,
-0.0307481494,
0.0576323122,
-0.0434705056,
-0.0143990992,
-0.0001865201,
-0.0290385429,
0.0536856651,
-0.0377592817,
-0.035044115,
-0.0388598219,
0.0397871993,
-0.0254378114,
0.0074205999,
-0.0311957523,
-0.0036745847,
-0.0361868963,
0.0223324299,
0.0291566234,
-0.0175642818,
-0.0751032084,
-0.047009021,
-0.0000846181,
-0.0061002178,
0.0271825641,
0.0728936121,
-0.0267584585,
-0.002402785,
-0.0123014282,
0.0260981098,
-0.0074888999,
0.020219326,
-0.0469725989,
0.0090718176,
0.0363762118,
0.0028856311,
0.03517754,
0.00683136,
0.0378829613,
0.0535312109,
0.0059816856,
-0.0179214552,
-0.0012595918,
-0.0594180115,
-0.0249612425,
0.0082734181,
0.0141223222,
-0.0631321445,
0.0281590354,
-0.0127595989,
0.0241529383,
-0.0253281221,
-0.0174214337,
-0.0037255732,
-0.0236177091,
0.0634400174,
-0.0862863958,
-0.0030713144,
0.0260345731,
0.0065650321,
0.0319499113,
-0.0232853256,
0.0454440042,
-0.0289409757,
-0.014871574,
-0.0200127829,
0.0272648539,
0.0020775539,
-0.0122794099,
-0.090469785,
-0.0423958376,
0.0183602218,
-0.0248048045,
0.0793023258,
0.0024102598,
0.0258676782,
0.0097461166,
-0.0486415848,
-0.0125051113,
0.0218461081,
0.0563849248,
0.0328047797,
0.045134984,
-0.0004531684,
-0.0262165088,
-0.0242877193,
0.0095041683,
-0.0038396388,
0.016252974,
-0.0185572896,
-0.0298923682,
-0.0393106379,
-0.0377640538,
-0.0600591823,
-0.0377871655,
0.0146821095,
0.0060299542,
-0.0069891349,
0.036377579,
-0.0278062075,
-0.0425349176,
0.0310283266,
0.0584268123,
0.0148728509,
-0.0398119353,
-0.0265746452,
-0.0274768975,
0.0868355557,
0.0292120688,
-0.047895506,
-0.0259458069,
-0.0257792734,
0.0579321571,
0.0157102346,
0.0232726671,
0.0137379337,
0.0423509106,
-0.0407590456,
-0.043917682,
0.0398526303,
0.0229261182,
0.0002855048,
0.0008706301,
0.000197489,
-0.0199436173,
-0.0393296927,
-0.0734616295,
0.0599939488,
-0.0238704104,
-0.0281598028,
0.0012687668,
0.014639643,
-0.0045034951,
-0.0090596443,
-0.0367079601,
-0.0034017067,
0.0095668808,
-0.0301222354,
-0.0782707408,
-0.0211849306,
-0.0559340864,
-0.0174516197,
0.021710325,
-0.0688221753,
0.0119925393,
-0.0225160439,
-0.0428282358,
0.0049536382,
-0.0291923266,
-0.0404899828,
-0.0180181153,
0.0134893944,
-0.0045077819,
0.0353101902,
0.0059211804,
-0.0086420411,
0.0324749313,
0.0171597898,
-0.0022219482,
0.0065566464,
-0.040127974,
0.0058238786,
0.0083003733,
-0.0068375142,
-0.0242513716,
-0.0178072713,
0.0095695602,
0.0222810395,
0.0497186445,
-0.010237786,
-0.0147621846,
-0.0437571518,
-0.0035207991,
0.0061269673,
-0.0092087043,
0.0200344808,
0.0214480869,
-0.0323133953,
-0.0638767406,
-0.0228725411,
-0.0053360714,
0.0517040975,
-0.0143914437,
0.0680763572,
0.0553677268,
0.007234185,
-0.0330734253,
0.0063048806,
-0.0437373631,
0.0286855884,
0.0504051894,
-0.078997381,
0.0115833329,
0.0335062407,
-0.0256398562,
0.0260299277,
0.0198805667,
-0.0401746891,
-0.0073421602,
-0.0223805308,
-0.0737838671,
0.0311877783,
-0.0269374307,
0.0463820212,
0.0175158959,
-0.0063440404,
-0.0315009244,
0.0441759899,
-0.0596257411,
-0.0167322233,
0.0278790127,
-0.0100717098,
0.0015428961,
0.051986035,
0.0037930261,
-0.003701841,
-0.0199559685,
-0.012885415,
-0.0019211856,
-0.0068455297,
-0.0160520766,
-0.0137987044,
-0.018409919,
0.0272828974,
-0.0082285758,
-0.0503329784,
0.0971086249,
0.0311024468,
0.0293751396,
-0.0792509615,
-0.0331688635,
-0.0580358543,
-0.0100152334,
0.0081234975,
0.0218128096,
0.0301041026,
-0.0417834483,
0.027868893,
0.0339398459,
-0.0023817443,
-0.0399186239,
0.0450847,
-0.0009343036,
0.0308206752,
0.0312662534,
-0.0274150521,
-0.0378650315,
-0.0318306759,
-0.014514924,
0.0021913133,
-0.0135575058,
0.0265544206,
-0.0521546528,
0.0297554974,
-0.0151317688,
0.06908831,
0.0067421664,
-0.0286762919,
0.0007876767,
0.0228655655,
0.0200255178,
0.0017833941,
-0.0113529572,
0.0260591358,
0.0422275029,
0.0698527694,
-0.0385761857,
0.034159936,
-0.042305287,
0.0291765835,
-0.0129376268,
-0.0457631424,
0.0078623947,
0.0304754302,
0.0031254652,
-0.0617458858,
-0.007435218,
0.095345147,
0.0304686483,
-0.052497711,
0.0020850834,
0.0282121189,
0.003284568,
-0.0182869453,
0.0057357838,
-0.0529472083,
-0.0490127727,
-0.030404849,
-0.010076276,
-0.013096801,
-0.0479662344,
0.0163974427,
-0.0237939972,
0.0185166206,
-0.0033048096,
-0.0329014324,
-0.0060356017,
-0.0780953169,
0.0055411905,
-0.04098754,
-0.0137487762,
-0.0814718455,
-0.0389347114,
-0.000692762,
0.0226133205,
-0.1005571261,
-0.1059495956,
0.0427141897,
-0.0545875207,
-0.0263301898,
0.0218434706,
0.0232021008,
-0.0582063086,
0.0179270729,
-0.0256885178,
0.0272575337,
0.0093958452,
-0.0031881393,
0.1234725565,
-0.002496534,
-0.0006635798,
-0.023382172,
0.0167724043,
-0.0253970232,
0.0132183619,
-0.014886206,
0.0604976043,
-0.0298144445,
-0.0234410577,
-0.0372830369,
0.0265907068,
0.0266726241,
0.0293559935,
-0.0209082868,
0.0005920063,
-0.0284193549,
-0.0048912452,
0.0641701743,
-0.0118948547,
-0.0732498989,
0.0020435073,
-0.0419333316,
-0.0697595999,
-0.0202810392,
-0.0288289562,
0.074260205,
-0.01113779,
0.0352578387,
0.0434083007,
0.0288127623,
-0.0175201595,
-0.0378146097,
0.0553219877,
0.010279078,
0.0143750655,
-0.0254900474,
-0.0072158319,
0.0387798175,
0.0184908099,
-0.0216657147,
0.0330580547,
-0.0298088491,
0.0161129627,
-0.0028271342,
0.016846519,
0.0205115695,
0.0335644409,
-0.0157600567,
-0.0388643555,
0.0346853547,
0.0344607346,
-0.0196959805,
-0.0627528951,
-0.0097489022,
-0.0404858403,
-0.0078464532,
-0.0135665052,
-0.0019379597,
0.0327112041,
0.0244987719,
0.0023573989,
-0.0275143869,
-0.0222121831,
0.0278475527,
0.0413880982,
0.0411210135,
-0.0285245907,
-0.0387379937,
-0.0598234162,
-0.0126723973,
0.0218141321,
0.0296861194,
-0.0390904099,
0.0564239584,
0.0174240302,
-0.005400653,
-0.0203195997,
-0.0248318519,
-0.0099888826,
-0.0202813894,
-0.0719500855,
0.0414605886,
0.0444569066,
0.0026413391,
0.0332460664,
0.0068008364,
0.0048318771,
-0.0088109886,
0.0189720541,
0.0140759395,
-0.0239546616,
0.0249658674,
0.001798125,
0.0577504598,
-0.0574231893,
0.0365757346,
-0.0290692765,
-0.0223383475,
-0.0385040604,
0.0259230081,
0.0718973354,
-0.0608884618,
-0.0217469931,
-0.0276551377,
0.0268843491,
-0.025749689,
0.0579145998,
-0.0240344331,
0.014742028,
0.0497571714,
-0.0097016096,
0.0014099167,
-0.0024562064,
0.086407803,
0.0563913286,
0.0383622646,
0.0111211957,
-0.0715002716,
-0.054429017,
0.0015203819,
0.0265135877,
0.0085378038,
-0.0558162071,
0.024003556,
-0.0253284164,
-0.0187393855,
0.0431368984,
-0.0375255905,
-0.0178305283,
-0.0011652225,
0.0587146804,
0.0861107185,
0.0015912687,
0.0112685878,
-0.014993988,
0.0171759184,
0.0261814594,
0.0133474022,
-0.0040902821,
-5.446473077e-33,
0.0294341333,
-0.0011997313,
0.0370644666,
-0.0884063542,
0.0292442124,
0.0669284835,
-0.0047865333,
-0.0199050065,
-0.0131607,
0.0260453094,
-0.038146317,
-0.0344082154,
0.0249095261,
0.0163651388,
0.014294765,
-0.0662194043,
0.0241980702,
0.0183786489,
0.0044323565,
0.0063393982,
-0.0263283197,
0.0642396435,
0.0736730769,
-0.0960225984,
-0.011867567,
0.0567481108,
0.0278964937,
-0.000869813,
0.0303309932,
0.0655075386,
-0.0584271699,
0.0172132794,
0.0476389416,
-0.0459770821,
-0.0170121938,
-0.0067168013,
-0.0555819906,
-0.0373480543,
-0.0089714387,
0.0144027304,
-0.0242118575,
0.0023217611,
0.0703135207,
0.001071486,
-0.0123303011,
-0.0117610916,
0.0462158248,
-0.0072882124,
-0.0203133654,
-0.0235133171,
-0.0301655848,
0.0567227304,
-0.0152170304,
-0.0062872884,
0.0088648535,
-0.0260776281,
-0.0143180182,
0.0324622728,
-0.0808998048,
-0.0339455083,
0.0227062535,
0.0050642486,
0.0025856677,
-0.0485795997,
-0.0708185732,
0.0751565173,
0.0318768919,
-0.0140388655,
-0.0376897864,
0.0369425304,
-0.0484022573,
0.0563805513,
0.0804190338,
0.0181770343,
0.0679257587,
-0.0147062419,
-0.0938887894,
0.0283315256,
-0.053711161,
0.0661451295,
-0.0076888306,
-0.0355444252,
-0.0975402296,
0.0035006029,
0.0145716872,
-0.0163660608,
0.0027854533,
-0.0296898596,
0.0152103743,
0.0031077189,
0.0220844317,
0.0441663675,
0.0227959212,
0.0017163295,
-0.0133427046,
-0.0238891579,
0.0299428906,
0.0065679029,
-0.0297340453,
-0.0116617903,
-0.036402449,
-0.0195753928,
0.0302244648,
-0.0319297202,
0.0454772562,
-0.0149549199,
0.0318150707,
-0.0185486712,
-0.0468071923,
0.0147620449,
0.0325598232,
-0.0402857065,
0.0104997372,
0.0750820339,
0.0487832949,
0.0226574764,
0.0037687786,
0.0571537241,
0.0109279919,
0.0085882917,
-0.0144180572,
-0.0527000949,
0.0207316298,
-0.0056489478,
-0.0362094007,
-0.0284090936,
-0.0307854265,
-0.0119683398,
0.0254137013,
-0.0585390404,
-0.0183194056,
-0.0056422199,
2.665e-7,
0.0955352262,
0.046109423,
0.0032881971,
-0.0358926393,
-0.0100603141,
0.0048126411,
0.0198804233,
0.0124946553,
0.0109343873,
-0.0253697243,
0.0455740988,
0.0154950814,
0.0001387862,
0.0334257148,
-0.0746924505,
-0.069031328,
-0.0453909487,
0.0297576673,
-0.0098802587,
-0.0179550368,
0.0680759922,
0.0883916095,
-0.0124163367,
-0.0390967168,
-0.0186112616,
-0.0255780406,
0.0063043339,
-0.0409100391,
0.0108891018,
0.0368813574,
0.0385945737,
0.0376945995,
0.008303293,
0.0615180694,
-0.0094801681,
0.0179902185,
0.0213715564,
0.063343592,
-0.0498232469,
0.0552397743,
-0.0057330667,
0.0186570659,
0.0162066557,
0.0089502968,
0.0714113191,
-0.0447937772,
-0.0265734382,
0.0183688998,
0.0072842701,
-0.0095145032,
0.0809419975,
-0.0303204469,
-0.034609098,
0.0401280895,
0.0315844789,
0.0077509577,
-0.0593697242,
-0.0696312562,
-0.0061377981,
0.0116852336,
-0.0000019101,
0.0352204405,
0.0402377881,
-0.0117371501,
0.0396979116,
-0.0370874666,
0.013158503,
2.360104752e-34,
0.0267747045,
0.0302286968,
-0.0023672513,
0.0428065658,
0.0302202106,
0.0002305057,
0.0196018647,
-0.0128538134,
-0.0323767327,
-0.0500679575,
0.0155974124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12269v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12269v4 | The Cambridge Law Corpus: A Dataset for Legal AI Research | 2023-09-21T17:24:40 | 2024-01-01T23:48:58 | Andreas Östling, Holli Sargeant, Huiyuan Xie, Ludwig Bull, Alexander Terenin, Leif Jonsson, Måns Magnusson, Felix Steffek | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, stat.AP | We introduce the Cambridge Law Corpus (CLC), a dataset for legal AI research.
It consists of over 250 000 court cases from the UK. Most cases are from the
21st century, but the corpus includes cases as old as the 16th century. This
paper presents the first release of the corpus, containing the raw text and
meta-data. Together with the corpus, we provide annotations on case outcomes
for 638 cases, done by legal experts. Using our annotated data, we have trained
and evaluated case outcome extraction with GPT-3, GPT-4 and RoBERTa models to
provide benchmarks. We include an extensive legal and ethical discussion to
address the potentially sensitive nature of this material. As a consequence,
the corpus will only be released for research purposes under certain
restrictions. | [
0.029750729,
0.0627318472,
-0.0105751017,
0.0260392651,
-0.0911983326,
0.0352495424,
0.0045768847,
0.0024923477,
-0.006939718,
-0.0468091667,
0.018497372,
0.0369793922,
-0.0381182171,
-0.0088241296,
-0.0094827451,
-0.0560422949,
0.0263423529,
0.0164973997,
0.0327166505,
0.0223566461,
0.0284498371,
0.013734485,
-0.0102787325,
0.0083171949,
-0.0408442914,
-0.0225434192,
-0.0052365381,
-0.0270400569,
0.0163149275,
-0.0028212429,
0.0078041758,
0.0602176823,
-0.0025631886,
0.0066087712,
0.0000016859,
-0.0430558622,
0.0015559157,
-0.0180973653,
-0.0054571852,
-0.0002830873,
-0.0194958244,
-0.01869536,
-0.0247535948,
-0.0222452674,
-0.0591999404,
0.0254729167,
-0.0081742033,
0.0021001764,
0.0238271914,
0.0891103148,
-0.0031075499,
-0.0482420623,
0.0623509325,
-0.0393382795,
0.0075937551,
-0.062366493,
0.0352586098,
0.0015387652,
0.0317326821,
-0.0370570868,
0.0528922565,
-0.0029726289,
0.0309509635,
-0.0172338914,
-0.0859341025,
-0.0043614442,
-0.0710919648,
0.0164291821,
-0.0302536562,
0.0357170887,
0.0589645877,
-0.0147246085,
0.0220655501,
0.0085661132,
0.0728952587,
0.0072215456,
-0.0112102423,
0.0881415009,
-0.058129102,
0.0101108588,
0.0247725043,
0.042786099,
-0.0061912308,
0.0204973202,
-0.0312386826,
0.0461178608,
-0.0007562757,
-0.0305468049,
0.0171744246,
0.0310289003,
0.0105068311,
-0.0159404799,
0.0327215157,
0.0125322556,
0.0304141827,
0.019366391,
-0.017727565,
-0.0186779182,
0.0420932174,
-0.074915804,
0.0014600651,
0.0027204852,
-0.0264562164,
0.0619035661,
-0.0052789305,
-0.0134186018,
-0.029873779,
0.0263161696,
0.0133551937,
-0.0162640642,
-0.0582191907,
0.0196692888,
-0.0113606183,
0.0732361004,
-0.0965617225,
0.0451525152,
-0.0169321764,
-0.0013123103,
-0.0335738957,
0.0520232804,
0.0024805653,
-0.0026249385,
-0.0163829941,
-0.0329391323,
-0.026696736,
-0.0783559382,
-0.0550332181,
0.0484782495,
-0.0070224176,
-0.0245244205,
0.0057624942,
-0.0156353097,
0.0049496596,
-0.0236567259,
0.0179190896,
0.1142487004,
0.0066944254,
-0.0287910197,
-0.0409431681,
-0.0627516657,
0.0011954219,
-0.0822106525,
-0.0307254493,
-0.0390365683,
0.0236260761,
-0.0406598598,
-0.032683216,
-0.0586422086,
0.0133923199,
0.0314804763,
0.0046873097,
0.0397159196,
-0.0121530918,
-0.0363893434,
-0.0107813757,
0.0289623309,
0.0053541334,
-0.007491414,
0.0284053367,
0.0477055535,
0.0190891493,
0.0136226695,
0.0665826276,
0.0403684564,
0.0191716775,
-0.0078985859,
0.0089201918,
0.0328991786,
-0.0131673394,
0.0320815556,
0.001615058,
0.0406921245,
0.0009660094,
-0.0468630567,
0.0187900942,
0.043846298,
-0.0039613,
0.0924929157,
0.0100896303,
-0.0431924164,
0.0462720506,
0.0116677526,
-0.081088461,
-0.0061970339,
0.0037585534,
0.0231759511,
-0.0621640161,
-0.0046182126,
-0.011018143,
-0.0549868569,
0.0319527164,
-0.0147066163,
-0.0183869582,
0.0000676297,
0.036639262,
-0.0007546725,
-0.0055963425,
-0.0284613017,
0.0069666742,
-0.0386427008,
-0.032018885,
-0.0424133688,
0.0306717567,
-0.0194890201,
0.0546891205,
-0.0834416524,
-0.0234151315,
-0.0160260759,
-0.0433928557,
0.0117721455,
0.0249890685,
-0.0155777102,
0.0268807542,
-0.0254455302,
-0.0299689174,
0.0380741172,
0.0250698514,
0.0050036954,
-0.0018093245,
0.0037142634,
0.0058953892,
-0.0451251827,
0.0101773692,
0.0325328894,
-0.0042746281,
-0.0503320284,
0.0223745536,
-0.0182453506,
0.0431767963,
0.0351816192,
-0.0134476582,
-0.0205923617,
0.0187521745,
-0.0018138373,
0.0178324934,
0.0188870989,
0.0174604785,
-0.0235888418,
0.0367113799,
-0.0667577982,
-0.0361409858,
0.0111252423,
-0.0780368969,
0.0082682855,
-0.0286654085,
-0.0000474262,
0.0159752425,
-0.0423949398,
-0.0332638994,
0.0131604681,
-0.0344015025,
-0.0086723203,
0.0783322677,
0.0052188509,
-0.0498888642,
-0.0214498173,
-0.0462246574,
0.0220263526,
-0.0356513113,
-0.0080930237,
-0.0481117181,
-0.0142888837,
0.0158815235,
0.0207300372,
-0.0127649223,
-0.0623119213,
-0.0129118841,
-0.068358697,
0.0496043935,
-0.0204610638,
0.0230235085,
-0.017380096,
-0.0074295793,
-0.021839438,
-0.0219112616,
-0.0310277659,
-0.0319848135,
-0.0182526149,
-0.0178690217,
0.0214691106,
0.0113863647,
0.0214302279,
-0.0435610265,
-0.01504796,
-0.034991689,
0.0210239999,
0.0359097607,
-0.0019979146,
0.0062891529,
0.04642554,
0.0078698043,
0.0287689827,
-0.0519127324,
0.0047312551,
-0.0350000635,
-0.0168364048,
-0.0533206388,
0.0226097219,
0.0328866206,
0.0122887194,
-0.0050207516,
0.0005375006,
-0.0324138589,
0.0058662104,
-0.0181322824,
0.0211311188,
-0.0176650081,
-0.0028891359,
0.0265194681,
0.0028236776,
0.0287738144,
0.0224855747,
-0.0083470941,
0.0197989307,
0.0171048492,
-0.0045092418,
-0.0086220512,
-0.0162281692,
-0.021157654,
0.0635824651,
0.0038334001,
-0.0600872152,
0.0588103831,
0.0483046062,
0.0674619004,
-0.0526616611,
0.0042874198,
-0.0455220677,
0.0986900404,
0.0223854203,
-0.0001009593,
-0.0271029174,
-0.0600224212,
0.0238829888,
-0.0512162931,
0.0728829727,
-0.0454446748,
0.0740286261,
-0.0249523167,
0.0493189879,
-0.0338714756,
-0.0699090287,
-0.0106118079,
-0.0814897493,
-0.0128772426,
0.0250612218,
-0.000123907,
0.0070711658,
-0.0249157436,
-0.021203341,
-0.0224670451,
0.0419971794,
0.0059008021,
-0.0082035372,
-0.039486859,
0.0294600278,
0.0073638838,
-0.0158080049,
-0.0175252277,
-0.0077540497,
-0.0316470265,
0.0290899612,
-0.0089057377,
0.0223356206,
-0.0054515828,
0.0133300805,
-0.0233767033,
-0.0787511319,
-0.0094649047,
0.0294879209,
-0.0221911427,
-0.0518158749,
0.0225555468,
0.0815526992,
0.0016193907,
-0.0511842817,
-0.0104478234,
0.0065304488,
-0.0350084305,
0.0033059681,
0.0152424145,
-0.1130361855,
0.0147112049,
-0.0124708591,
-0.0021754738,
-0.0445703901,
-0.0577197671,
0.0072498489,
-0.0732528195,
0.1117850319,
0.0242091212,
-0.0158974752,
-0.0691233799,
-0.0025537584,
0.008497823,
-0.0303972736,
-0.0371198952,
0.0004602447,
-0.0226939302,
0.0037873152,
0.0285176896,
-0.0534604229,
0.036600925,
0.0329785123,
-0.0444086343,
0.041148454,
0.0552233271,
0.031466607,
-0.0522824004,
0.0109306676,
-0.0029253692,
-0.0214506015,
-0.0102654202,
0.0257473905,
0.0770256668,
0.0217617173,
0.0257063434,
-0.053687647,
0.052013889,
0.003853827,
-0.0314521305,
0.1007040218,
0.0575745255,
-0.0526736155,
-0.0242673438,
-0.0189885236,
-0.0408821627,
0.0054046069,
0.0438506603,
0.0036974819,
0.0236598235,
-0.0610458292,
-0.0061518564,
-0.0126827955,
-0.0224055089,
-0.0116532911,
-0.0038667098,
0.0077165351,
0.0131457988,
-0.0300640408,
-0.0368424989,
0.0216617156,
0.0582452975,
0.0281921923,
-0.0161230266,
0.0389496163,
0.0150437085,
-0.0520197414,
0.0217552334,
-0.0302038081,
-0.0275470074,
-0.022553388,
0.0456445664,
0.0176433567,
0.0019497062,
-0.0110282591,
-0.0121750021,
0.0056889998,
-0.0069862898,
0.0035374886,
0.0416170582,
0.0236921068,
0.0179191642,
-0.0329610333,
-0.0268540923,
0.0291336104,
0.0313330814,
0.0070547271,
-0.0344553329,
0.0571627878,
-0.0230887029,
-0.0397710055,
-0.0069249081,
-0.0054066572,
0.0491810441,
0.0072104558,
-0.002885231,
-0.0605398491,
0.0523333512,
0.0241357554,
0.0058609424,
0.0530496463,
0.0082072448,
-0.0329119526,
-0.0382259153,
-0.0131546343,
-0.0353706405,
-0.0020703252,
-0.007149721,
0.0092869541,
0.0114374394,
0.0098454896,
-0.0620979182,
0.0081794141,
-0.042131532,
0.0014970191,
-0.089391619,
0.0430781692,
0.0696564242,
0.0183325447,
0.0030438188,
-0.0484312437,
-0.0080281543,
0.0276770107,
0.0003155431,
0.0885958597,
-0.0208546445,
0.0381909758,
0.0177756492,
0.025360262,
0.0192612968,
0.0002850529,
-0.0501082316,
-0.0001731264,
-0.0079226131,
0.0359377451,
0.0382024609,
0.0010056914,
-0.0165521,
-0.0153186787,
0.0072297771,
0.0154711977,
0.0416959785,
-0.0008995187,
0.0170828179,
0.0057237251,
0.0156467594,
-0.027195042,
0.0111574382,
0.0183494296,
-0.0363776423,
0.0395340472,
0.0249483529,
-0.0286219679,
-0.0291360244,
-0.0572527088,
-0.0185792223,
0.0100801187,
-0.0008513598,
-0.0566736273,
-0.0734608695,
-0.0007413084,
-0.0263934359,
0.0334765799,
0.0025884495,
0.0209086668,
-0.009242475,
0.0439905412,
0.0405877233,
-0.0099695139,
-0.0593604743,
0.0557046793,
-0.0228479709,
-0.0451100059,
-0.0219664536,
-5.151466974e-33,
-0.0156218885,
-0.0096000321,
0.0141570112,
0.0507912673,
-0.0234447159,
-0.0336675681,
-0.0007484233,
-0.0101876725,
-0.02512905,
0.048762206,
-0.0253263414,
0.0400364585,
0.022955453,
-0.0160871595,
0.0306217335,
-0.0385375954,
-0.0144282114,
0.0017846394,
0.0048568207,
0.0355412401,
-0.0141217355,
0.0230157729,
0.0206192918,
-0.1056066677,
0.0372126848,
0.0409463122,
-0.0155246621,
-0.0282163862,
-0.0441753529,
0.0424839258,
0.0001897666,
0.0198357869,
0.0363682732,
-0.023446437,
0.0205471739,
0.0389877707,
-0.0595060214,
0.0020878976,
-0.003995914,
-0.0149865849,
0.0301254224,
-0.0263904873,
0.0168061201,
0.0121840956,
-0.0330335088,
-0.0066500306,
0.047569178,
-0.0338416249,
-0.016961636,
-0.0731779486,
-0.0881219581,
0.0619539805,
-0.0327433832,
0.0182156991,
0.0434441529,
-0.0167618766,
0.0075570387,
0.0266044457,
-0.0469817109,
-0.0203843862,
-0.0479764007,
-0.0275700204,
-0.0005583257,
-0.0816736892,
-0.0327457562,
0.0493536517,
0.0106776645,
0.0201299284,
-0.0480672196,
0.0317190699,
-0.0232812483,
0.1148790121,
0.0324899666,
0.0457281396,
0.0258973185,
-0.0145808859,
-0.0771416128,
-0.000636052,
0.0614487901,
0.0191269722,
-0.0032978528,
-0.0688858405,
-0.0614950545,
0.0292441621,
-0.008290939,
-0.0864883289,
0.0099156583,
0.0235483628,
0.0083356509,
-0.0139180394,
0.065647088,
-0.0051045688,
-0.0168657135,
-0.021581741,
0.0298630856,
0.0236733183,
-0.0017443955,
0.0246064831,
-0.0348736495,
0.0300287418,
-0.0048868218,
-0.0622101277,
0.002679402,
-0.0023365282,
0.0316429511,
-0.0139697492,
0.0551766083,
-0.0161173809,
-0.0320365056,
-0.021086188,
0.0157585982,
0.0641693994,
0.0299703516,
0.0219144858,
0.0068231653,
0.0377912335,
0.0343350247,
0.0041322513,
0.0103114424,
0.0178667437,
-0.0122013139,
-0.021307677,
0.0117562879,
-0.0196517408,
0.0252717715,
-0.0219893977,
0.0244395472,
0.0693275034,
0.0258295648,
0.0076252716,
0.0288128834,
0.0524794012,
2.393e-7,
0.0695262477,
0.0114195142,
0.0262656249,
-0.0039122901,
-0.0127843795,
0.0357669406,
0.0251958277,
0.0512911901,
0.0355960838,
-0.0067073652,
0.0453384481,
-0.0194895659,
0.0601082742,
0.0359516591,
-0.0521284714,
-0.047547292,
-0.0380579047,
-0.0599434115,
-0.0889733732,
0.0450286232,
0.0358457789,
0.0953404531,
0.0449252725,
-0.0186295956,
0.0016228119,
0.0024189122,
0.0201839134,
-0.0226656012,
-0.024069218,
0.0052130697,
0.0676101074,
-0.0353512913,
-0.0184784792,
0.0272339303,
0.0076661292,
0.0622296073,
-0.0439457372,
0.0632827803,
0.0180644076,
0.0607344471,
-0.030071266,
-0.0344552882,
0.0499800928,
-0.0075683137,
0.0479003415,
-0.0163887888,
-0.010192642,
-0.0143576758,
-0.0398593284,
-0.0352521501,
0.0227988791,
0.0421300307,
0.0110252155,
-0.0225436464,
0.0395180061,
-0.0111108171,
0.0087849312,
-0.0937756971,
0.015835518,
0.0587813184,
-0.0281794257,
0.0037052196,
0.0377473421,
-0.0110152336,
0.0353231356,
-0.0694396347,
0.0162881333,
1.559901667e-34,
0.0280661862,
-0.0133844707,
0.0081987632,
0.0502122231,
0.0235747863,
0.0472608842,
-0.0070097656,
0.0044858688,
-0.005828843,
-0.0431391448,
0.0444921479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12263v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12263v2 | On the Relationship between Skill Neurons and Robustness in Prompt Tuning | 2023-09-21T17:13:21 | 2024-03-25T10:52:14 | Leon Ackermann, Xenia Ohmer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompt Tuning is a popular parameter-efficient finetuning method for
pre-trained large language models (PLMs). Based on experiments with RoBERTa, it
has been suggested that Prompt Tuning activates specific neurons in the
transformer's feed-forward networks, that are highly predictive and selective
for the given task. In this paper, we study the robustness of Prompt Tuning in
relation to these "skill neurons", using RoBERTa and T5. We show that prompts
tuned for a specific task are transferable to tasks of the same type but are
not very robust to adversarial data. While prompts tuned for RoBERTa yield
below-chance performance on adversarial data, prompts tuned for T5 are slightly
more robust and retain above-chance performance in two out of three cases. At
the same time, we replicate the finding that skill neurons exist in RoBERTa and
further show that skill neurons also exist in T5. Interestingly, the skill
neurons of T5 determined on non-adversarial data are also among the most
predictive neurons on the adversarial data, which is not the case for RoBERTa.
We conclude that higher adversarial robustness may be related to a model's
ability to consistently activate the relevant skill neurons on adversarial
data. | [
0.0264275577,
0.0268571302,
-0.0338234492,
0.0161410607,
0.0032351632,
0.0174870826,
0.0302625038,
-0.0221201256,
-0.051607009,
-0.0081825629,
-0.0955448672,
0.0134005127,
0.0111139435,
-0.0119306352,
0.0703346059,
-0.0333323367,
0.0514846034,
-0.0331149586,
-0.0192269161,
-0.0107281273,
-0.0126148462,
-0.0294980351,
-0.0190289002,
0.0428896137,
0.0132828467,
-0.0074406178,
0.0051398287,
-0.0023123976,
-0.0168429222,
0.0175695959,
0.0347867645,
0.0658020154,
-0.0093637742,
0.0325277373,
0.000002081,
-0.0303761195,
0.0038382814,
-0.02487427,
-0.0455701612,
0.0295954254,
0.0185848195,
-0.0186788477,
-0.0175225995,
0.009568044,
-0.0226174537,
-0.0587979406,
0.0533048846,
0.0327624828,
0.0339048579,
0.1106764749,
0.0143436166,
-0.0118753025,
0.061438825,
-0.0479778014,
-0.0395783819,
-0.0678918362,
0.0260621123,
-0.0550101697,
-0.0192284249,
0.0190879535,
-0.0304626785,
0.0084133996,
0.027131211,
-0.0143628391,
-0.0582203604,
0.0075462144,
0.015936112,
-0.038339857,
-0.0186846294,
0.0234588683,
-0.054407604,
-0.0246298686,
-0.0125664547,
-0.0096524786,
0.019976547,
0.0266168267,
-0.0153856613,
0.0113946721,
0.0297698341,
0.0155820958,
-0.0044701728,
-0.0141306324,
0.0361527465,
0.0026871893,
-0.0017566244,
0.031391982,
0.0276857596,
-0.025054384,
0.0079524172,
-0.0014733979,
-0.0387411565,
-0.0556391478,
0.0154220378,
0.0096268402,
-0.0794106051,
0.0016905452,
-0.0743720978,
-0.0189291593,
-0.005672866,
0.0172382649,
0.0769987404,
0.0468003824,
-0.0213980637,
-0.0100899199,
-0.0450844839,
0.0562566444,
-0.0350283347,
0.0948612913,
-0.0291166697,
-0.0029132934,
-0.0323377103,
-0.0226048939,
-0.0464829467,
-0.0230848957,
-0.0001441787,
-0.0110641569,
-0.0432635397,
0.0436025783,
0.0140991565,
-0.0082389666,
-0.0174058471,
-0.011853545,
-0.0764466077,
-0.0055236532,
-0.0169067066,
0.0328838788,
-0.0457494594,
0.0242162365,
0.0243475381,
-0.0865130946,
-0.0169729814,
-0.0077254153,
-0.0086350162,
-0.0460866168,
0.0134646781,
0.0374568179,
-0.0083206091,
-0.0257530659,
-0.0371952429,
0.0168704689,
-0.0114137447,
-0.0392191708,
0.034769319,
-0.0154586621,
-0.0172021631,
0.0148215741,
0.0083461795,
-0.0453701727,
-0.0209157094,
0.0035112882,
-0.0317681022,
0.0479769409,
0.0205848701,
0.0039873626,
0.0384578332,
-0.0090954611,
-0.0184000414,
0.0295650214,
0.0122058121,
0.0442407131,
0.0259294324,
-0.0385833941,
0.0159690119,
0.0580029488,
0.0340957195,
-0.005457948,
-0.0226967689,
-0.0301592071,
0.0492007211,
0.0153536927,
0.0487494953,
0.0298020784,
-0.0266424865,
-0.0149917025,
0.1009688079,
0.0083742468,
0.0476064496,
0.020168826,
0.0504049882,
-0.0308401827,
0.0129479021,
0.0519562922,
-0.0896702632,
0.0184841286,
-0.051279597,
0.0028405564,
-0.0021468515,
0.0274061076,
-0.043732252,
-0.0287756342,
0.0185303912,
0.0142705264,
-0.0355924852,
-0.0083606457,
0.0322506204,
0.0482494161,
-0.075021103,
-0.0070769605,
0.0089000622,
0.0089629637,
0.0031855463,
-0.0790728778,
-0.0013309498,
-0.0097543439,
-0.012031123,
-0.0394838192,
0.0150662623,
-0.0177225191,
0.0480159372,
0.0528725609,
0.0891183987,
0.0231816396,
-0.0137395654,
-0.0455875918,
-0.0242009312,
-0.0230620522,
0.0141093051,
0.0362114832,
-0.0028981699,
0.0041213394,
-0.0152632119,
0.037629962,
-0.0335738473,
0.0475048125,
-0.0029872225,
-0.0377182774,
-0.0111970743,
0.0166421477,
0.0207052995,
-0.0292241722,
-0.0289483834,
0.0405960791,
0.0121056633,
-0.0150082437,
0.0559835508,
-0.0101176873,
-0.0744614303,
-0.0154263107,
0.0174529031,
0.0190727934,
0.0011094031,
0.0658287406,
-0.0102647543,
-0.0310614798,
0.0074776667,
-0.0081663541,
0.008575622,
-0.0227297209,
0.0430563055,
-0.010471426,
0.0503939167,
-0.0374972485,
0.0227099229,
0.017940037,
0.0181177687,
0.0093013374,
0.0454984717,
-0.0250817295,
-0.0555085093,
-0.0663321093,
0.0275974553,
-0.0091073532,
0.0161641836,
0.0078528691,
-0.0253474358,
-0.012296699,
-0.0437333919,
-0.0385353491,
0.0182393175,
-0.0302590784,
-0.0114236344,
0.0176119097,
-0.0117743658,
-0.0309764892,
-0.0063395211,
-0.0187508855,
0.0444518626,
0.0170216393,
0.037680313,
0.0101883681,
0.0087253647,
-0.0205227565,
-0.045730263,
-0.043913465,
0.0103573781,
0.0495941937,
0.006425675,
0.0006819445,
-0.0475018695,
0.0499868989,
0.0295844618,
0.044880338,
-0.0143590569,
-0.0789293349,
0.0121407574,
0.0061340253,
0.0283769704,
0.0794075355,
0.0127010206,
-0.001926,
0.0258895587,
0.0263442229,
-0.0061299475,
0.006347137,
-0.0418768637,
-0.0538310409,
-0.0687210858,
0.0207031425,
0.03210539,
0.076835826,
0.0417696834,
-0.0162011124,
-0.0371348783,
0.0310213622,
-0.0139609398,
-0.0239813644,
0.011034905,
-0.0113366786,
-0.0425220132,
0.0302596986,
-0.0303465985,
-0.0638534054,
0.0636983365,
-0.0382291563,
-0.0030823268,
-0.0028046879,
-0.0223781131,
0.0228179973,
0.0205385238,
0.0555002391,
0.004860064,
0.0123707969,
-0.0193872489,
-0.0869696066,
-0.0370409042,
0.0313269421,
0.0084649976,
-0.0052039693,
0.012790231,
-0.0261339992,
-0.0030609132,
-0.0402782187,
-0.0500381663,
-0.0403827466,
-0.0122912461,
0.040914014,
0.0567134656,
-0.0034738893,
-0.0127635859,
-0.0188691244,
0.004666782,
0.0618248433,
-0.052265022,
0.0001368045,
-0.0451851673,
0.0164045934,
0.0400340781,
0.0365407318,
0.0288271494,
-0.0560731702,
0.0193096846,
-0.0288496055,
-0.0221399013,
0.021548206,
-0.0533781908,
0.0200667735,
0.0207788851,
-0.0496866107,
-0.0206607077,
0.032991346,
0.0453304313,
-0.0293712858,
-0.0089782979,
0.0775480196,
-0.006699645,
-0.0443918929,
-0.0083576813,
0.0393741429,
0.0001509022,
0.0343652777,
0.0481124856,
-0.021281505,
-0.0179615114,
0.0258233882,
0.0211924613,
-0.0047405022,
-0.0076921904,
0.0013074788,
-0.1263114065,
0.0339455083,
-0.0110463817,
-0.0584574006,
-0.0320349075,
0.0213876236,
-0.0092703244,
0.0010661979,
0.088201955,
0.0313835442,
-0.0124765132,
-0.0006631776,
0.0455641523,
0.0449359454,
-0.0498772711,
-0.0027191504,
-0.0601187311,
0.0857142061,
0.0895446539,
-0.0186168365,
-0.02548966,
-0.0366317332,
0.0716057792,
-0.0010723507,
0.0216301065,
0.012286216,
0.0471616983,
0.0073575815,
-0.0439135619,
0.0067568123,
0.0384930149,
0.0141928447,
-0.0106009254,
-0.030780809,
0.0149992164,
-0.0045255595,
-0.024546247,
0.025009891,
0.0192944612,
-0.0131433709,
0.055542767,
0.0535254031,
-0.0538151637,
-0.0288688764,
-0.0090963496,
0.0126583371,
-0.0494524539,
-0.0577847622,
0.0284072291,
0.0210491754,
-0.0565685853,
-0.0411461778,
-0.001521141,
0.0241675191,
0.0371633209,
0.0083946278,
-0.0411153063,
-0.0153822843,
0.0003227918,
-0.0044078892,
0.0285736471,
-0.0170213692,
0.0117879054,
-0.1151003242,
-0.0284409001,
0.0382953212,
-0.081397973,
-0.0143191414,
-0.0435715429,
-0.0591547042,
-0.0475435406,
0.044706855,
0.0611850806,
0.0244562291,
0.025355367,
-0.0270484015,
-0.079273276,
0.068194434,
0.0383245237,
-0.0682225153,
0.0357152671,
0.0458477177,
-0.0072924932,
-0.0177930016,
0.0277689938,
-0.0170590673,
0.0145025169,
0.0732717961,
0.0104107084,
0.0556562953,
-0.0420073196,
0.0342916027,
0.0093027074,
0.0863119364,
0.0098002823,
-0.0173006393,
-0.0553618744,
0.0036022,
0.0274934992,
0.0048530474,
-0.0158506874,
-0.0142041435,
0.035728585,
0.0344908983,
0.0109519875,
-0.0231033731,
0.0267394166,
0.0211126246,
-0.0391312689,
0.0082326662,
0.0192953479,
0.0320185423,
0.0209262446,
0.0435084514,
-0.0191665813,
0.0339251682,
0.0089794938,
0.0267957281,
0.003483566,
0.0598875992,
0.0304199457,
0.0047036721,
-0.0495019741,
0.0349519439,
-0.0990254357,
-0.0824715793,
-0.0145107452,
0.0338011384,
0.0421434492,
-0.0207990762,
-0.0059366557,
-0.0111302696,
-0.0208742693,
-0.0060428209,
-0.0040269005,
0.0447277166,
0.0272735413,
0.0573748723,
-0.0030946659,
0.0094429487,
-0.0191367269,
0.0548536852,
-0.002748698,
0.072876744,
0.0020155616,
-0.012059221,
-0.0265825875,
-0.0177021474,
0.0081332019,
-0.0197046399,
-0.0349084362,
-0.0081560435,
0.0133328978,
-0.0650127605,
-0.0235125273,
0.0399902724,
-0.0032494469,
-0.0127764661,
0.0032778049,
0.0309245512,
-0.020834554,
-0.0051478469,
-0.0304255188,
-0.0055042412,
0.0533996038,
-0.0100426693,
-0.0038138623,
-6.215590949e-33,
-0.048661191,
0.0150090335,
0.0122168036,
0.0095401751,
0.0020450186,
-0.012175736,
-0.0288053919,
-0.0087188594,
-0.0415317044,
0.0084220981,
-0.0470395796,
-0.0151711861,
0.0164351165,
0.0187033787,
-0.0134637421,
-0.0500396602,
0.0595857315,
-0.0324376523,
-0.0372240469,
-0.0104302634,
-0.0005093648,
0.0232024677,
0.0583180226,
0.0061237919,
0.0263205878,
0.0061933617,
-0.0486536175,
0.0197608341,
-0.0368935131,
0.0432200022,
0.0067381165,
0.0034571418,
0.0063079479,
-0.0542733595,
-0.0264863465,
0.0313701853,
-0.0650476888,
-0.0306688976,
0.0166697167,
0.0333463512,
-0.0074554794,
-0.0346625336,
0.0702259988,
-0.046773769,
-0.0253682323,
0.0161493737,
0.008850107,
-0.0287211072,
-0.0207638592,
-0.0154852904,
-0.0474836491,
-0.0150600774,
-0.0028748226,
-0.0716353804,
0.0025240246,
0.0037601157,
-0.0141953127,
0.0288741365,
-0.0600608252,
0.0067657838,
0.0213030186,
0.0736017153,
0.0142889833,
0.059116561,
0.012458507,
0.0315484889,
0.0972723439,
0.0190690812,
0.0358682834,
-0.0288091581,
0.0359468795,
0.0118700461,
0.0485003032,
0.0289243422,
0.0404981524,
-0.0347500369,
-0.0494100526,
-0.0046869004,
0.0361236632,
0.0193508081,
0.0466177911,
0.001800866,
-0.0001879589,
-0.0330512039,
-0.0481383167,
-0.0807533935,
-0.0336542279,
0.0049019251,
0.0275257174,
0.0161187109,
0.0046776365,
-0.0053870273,
0.0316695794,
-0.0359509215,
0.0199115798,
0.0192188714,
-0.0355730467,
0.0075921989,
-0.0243691001,
-0.0052712816,
-0.0398307405,
-0.0302668214,
0.0000247229,
-0.0062555857,
0.0190754775,
0.0187503677,
0.0262816008,
0.0556061827,
-0.0516486652,
0.0007593304,
-0.0180713739,
0.0406390242,
0.0587926582,
0.0433740392,
0.037658643,
-0.0231076609,
-0.01394324,
0.0193494819,
-0.0028550117,
-0.0426356457,
-0.0170314871,
0.0422665551,
0.0277095586,
0.0326768421,
-0.0250931047,
-0.0120216804,
-0.0235205702,
0.0735075101,
0.0185990576,
-0.0521650277,
-0.0130915344,
-0.0080651427,
2.868e-7,
0.0349650942,
0.0258127451,
0.0133569539,
0.0125408648,
0.0218665823,
0.0230329521,
-0.0392258503,
0.0216285028,
0.0407100879,
0.0077487221,
-0.002102603,
0.0087333731,
0.0411305875,
0.0195381362,
-0.0517385118,
-0.0552139506,
-0.0697715953,
0.0574911535,
-0.0368278548,
-0.010381069,
0.0060278988,
0.1007345021,
0.0118930312,
-0.0144425444,
0.010662769,
-0.056450054,
0.032553453,
-0.0642635375,
0.0095316079,
0.0281265639,
0.0324541591,
-0.0113045229,
-0.0173658486,
0.0479872003,
0.0016249378,
0.0542416535,
-0.007514575,
0.0503516085,
0.0380127355,
-0.0148729989,
-0.0082463752,
-0.0047423644,
-0.0197647847,
-0.048217833,
0.059580978,
-0.1050743535,
-0.0272135884,
0.0137907034,
0.0087942118,
-0.0367977209,
0.0323309377,
-0.0560034141,
-0.0146223381,
0.012930844,
0.0277132429,
0.0326208994,
-0.0344696343,
-0.0433027074,
-0.0064404896,
0.0218829773,
-0.0530417934,
-0.0776454434,
-0.0424695611,
-0.0490019061,
0.0476019979,
-0.0241593197,
0.0128537044,
2.539003283e-34,
0.0280705635,
0.0022575089,
0.0523729213,
-0.0437922329,
0.0431765318,
0.0002628221,
0.0605671518,
0.0176633429,
0.0131570864,
-0.082716234,
-0.0503113978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12250v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12250v1 | SQUARE: Automatic Question Answering Evaluation using Multiple Positive and Negative References | 2023-09-21T16:51:30 | 2023-09-21T16:51:30 | Matteo Gabburo, Siddhant Garg, Rik Koncel Kedziorski, Alessandro Moschitti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Evaluation of QA systems is very challenging and expensive, with the most
reliable approach being human annotations of correctness of answers for
questions. Recent works (AVA, BEM) have shown that transformer LM encoder based
similarity metrics transfer well for QA evaluation, but they are limited by the
usage of a single correct reference answer. We propose a new evaluation metric:
SQuArE (Sentence-level QUestion AnsweRing Evaluation), using multiple reference
answers (combining multiple correct and incorrect references) for sentence-form
QA. We evaluate SQuArE on both sentence-level extractive (Answer Selection) and
generative (GenQA) QA systems, across multiple academic and industrial
datasets, and show that it outperforms previous baselines and obtains the
highest correlation with human annotations. | [
0.0264340695,
0.0251024123,
-0.0084502315,
0.0294847433,
-0.0198115632,
0.0218774192,
-0.0025962531,
-0.0031595209,
-0.0169899613,
-0.0444409512,
-0.0210625269,
-0.0103045674,
-0.0196843334,
-0.0069797412,
0.0066700433,
-0.0028387294,
0.0281004477,
0.0060106176,
-0.0228105653,
-0.0019314025,
0.0022437787,
-0.0014758619,
-0.0111518009,
0.0206329264,
0.0036857473,
-0.0146084549,
0.0283211116,
-0.0273644272,
0.0672029182,
-0.0060569667,
0.0106846923,
0.0410030559,
-0.0387724601,
-0.0019913844,
0.0000014135,
-0.0533956327,
-0.0025843508,
-0.0087786848,
-0.0283487383,
0.0265959632,
-0.014656364,
0.0311077964,
0.0353668034,
0.0206763204,
-0.0578408428,
-0.0154953413,
0.0357049033,
0.0302850492,
0.0990086645,
0.0113615924,
0.0134492395,
-0.0365193412,
0.0253689997,
0.0094151208,
0.0281787757,
-0.0612485521,
0.0412180759,
0.0244634021,
0.0018654428,
0.0203513261,
-0.0007752631,
0.0441406369,
0.0257554799,
-0.0109249111,
0.017070394,
0.0025250278,
-0.0385809243,
0.0248840135,
0.0256312862,
0.0999801531,
0.0173813142,
-0.0270656385,
-0.0355492979,
0.004361596,
-0.0009208557,
0.0582177192,
-0.0231403317,
-0.0263822656,
-0.0170062333,
0.0071896333,
-0.029203793,
0.0175317433,
-0.0125419367,
-0.0022965355,
0.0258232746,
0.0672454983,
0.0297886096,
-0.0744410232,
0.0201452561,
0.0536998995,
-0.0261905547,
-0.0157242548,
0.0031374206,
0.0294272192,
0.0027734926,
0.0155711491,
0.0161940772,
-0.0359053276,
0.0422667786,
-0.045350302,
-0.0023848021,
0.0000121544,
-0.010109094,
0.0338494405,
-0.0341526642,
0.1030537859,
-0.0134977149,
0.0099963807,
-0.0705462992,
-0.0774130076,
-0.0399401113,
-0.0118576456,
-0.0143805398,
0.0521935262,
-0.0157042481,
0.0136149041,
-0.0486246683,
-0.0143933017,
-0.0330166928,
-0.0176753458,
0.0040828818,
0.0412293971,
0.025713386,
0.0302708559,
-0.0632749945,
0.0505878069,
-0.0791928992,
0.039148327,
-0.036130853,
-0.0579938963,
-0.0233317614,
0.0246300548,
0.0475825109,
-0.0233329814,
0.0064863935,
0.0300197043,
-0.0216504671,
-0.0197014455,
0.0272773355,
-0.0083772819,
0.0091312146,
-0.0184862893,
0.0054819426,
-0.0412953459,
0.0679994673,
0.023611445,
-0.0242367573,
-0.0217425358,
0.0128192967,
0.0649112985,
0.0034335961,
0.0341960788,
0.0043657548,
0.0046458174,
0.0387741439,
-0.0009024466,
0.0258766878,
0.016440263,
0.0564683639,
-0.0161004663,
0.0645552352,
-0.0014203849,
0.0750607774,
-0.0014042507,
0.0138378264,
0.003718517,
0.0502160527,
0.0506495088,
0.0057771769,
0.0174894314,
-0.0062490548,
0.0474855602,
-0.0143325785,
-0.0404178686,
0.0162436347,
0.0353164412,
-0.0207043625,
0.0022491864,
0.0091442764,
0.0098016476,
0.0174429901,
-0.0100520337,
0.0041465862,
0.0581324175,
-0.0241114032,
0.0016335959,
0.0419847555,
-0.0072961492,
-0.013980058,
-0.0253689829,
0.010102381,
0.0082602268,
-0.0277090501,
0.0141690085,
-0.001264322,
0.0106989108,
-0.0328431465,
0.0638801157,
0.0009127649,
-0.060450539,
0.0201070681,
-0.0234866161,
0.0665354356,
-0.0076619759,
0.0308999252,
-0.0062557892,
-0.0331474841,
-0.0100035314,
-0.0348241441,
0.0343391486,
0.0002517719,
-0.03467419,
0.0261144694,
-0.0351855867,
-0.0238621477,
-0.0050631599,
-0.0226664115,
-0.0190099701,
0.0164403636,
0.0368398204,
0.0315892845,
-0.0783819333,
0.0017880297,
0.0385711938,
0.0151151884,
-0.0336308256,
0.0377572849,
0.0016809012,
0.0260920599,
0.0334058851,
-0.0122553818,
0.0179502629,
0.0285363346,
-0.0522695892,
-0.0518910885,
0.0015438271,
-0.0297198612,
-0.032993488,
0.0011408555,
-0.0693356097,
0.0036311557,
0.0756700635,
-0.065361008,
-0.0546458736,
-0.0091791637,
-0.0633679032,
-0.0217129383,
-0.0413928963,
-0.0327211879,
-0.0194974449,
0.0156004308,
-0.0429248028,
0.049142085,
0.0107880812,
0.0484592319,
-0.0022139982,
-0.0073113684,
0.0288996268,
-0.0130874654,
-0.034407679,
-0.0428241082,
0.0114982501,
0.0249262303,
0.0346925631,
-0.0056649623,
-0.0594986305,
-0.0163387731,
-0.035052862,
0.0164341889,
-0.0185101312,
0.0492402948,
0.0347911641,
-0.0076466901,
0.0071996548,
-0.0365525782,
-0.0636857226,
-0.0112227956,
0.0206078589,
0.019791184,
0.0666086376,
0.0159048811,
0.030850742,
-0.0436199792,
-0.0176294278,
0.0004559127,
0.0545369387,
0.037309546,
0.0413735919,
-0.0612927191,
-0.0212610308,
-0.0570062548,
-0.0095383627,
0.0337633267,
-0.0363519862,
0.006470059,
0.039054703,
-0.0106559489,
0.0296301395,
0.0215043928,
-0.0307265483,
0.0339982584,
0.0500989631,
-0.0385544449,
0.0181478839,
-0.03994596,
-0.0294733532,
0.0082751792,
-0.0372998565,
0.0385874696,
0.0052919798,
0.0225452054,
-0.0163133293,
-0.0264790934,
0.0236076601,
-0.0023634699,
-0.001359509,
-0.0597923547,
0.0044088722,
-0.0159161426,
0.0554506928,
0.0109809823,
-0.0037744066,
0.0848014727,
-0.0310962237,
-0.0416570008,
-0.0495421812,
0.0105338395,
-0.0811529905,
0.0229374897,
-0.028369315,
-0.0134860147,
-0.0077350573,
0.0012312552,
-0.03135515,
0.0005749284,
0.0091207949,
-0.0581833534,
0.0191013347,
-0.0156717319,
0.0172501821,
-0.0006573389,
-0.0409970954,
-0.0564439967,
-0.038784828,
-0.0023656583,
0.0347046889,
-0.0306064896,
0.0189438723,
-0.0368085466,
0.0031766542,
0.0221069138,
-0.030544566,
-0.0152569683,
-0.0101570133,
-0.0224291999,
0.1074106917,
0.0859002471,
0.0692794248,
0.0320194438,
0.0213310849,
-0.0069723977,
0.0460254624,
-0.0191000942,
0.0407947339,
0.032486394,
-0.034647841,
0.0196065307,
-0.0426881164,
0.0089759342,
0.0076747905,
0.0590306893,
-0.0228147581,
-0.0692865103,
0.0956942737,
0.0343178958,
-0.0166768171,
-0.0209435001,
-0.0270650387,
-0.012799005,
0.0204795375,
0.0437644348,
-0.082296744,
-0.0409064852,
-0.0564336479,
0.0566432998,
0.0044929604,
-0.00324255,
0.0313013978,
-0.120059289,
-0.0214096736,
-0.028500583,
-0.0595023111,
-0.0626274198,
-0.0670637563,
0.0443292819,
-0.034037374,
-0.0111579392,
0.0136693036,
-0.0035331624,
0.0242064688,
0.0174536873,
-0.0073731137,
0.0106969662,
0.0457593799,
-0.0258419085,
0.02291595,
0.0581588633,
0.0250399634,
-0.0046142139,
-0.0783955827,
-0.0322707258,
-0.1369460225,
-0.0276243072,
0.0231476761,
0.048083812,
0.0006689319,
-0.0053142109,
-0.0405694172,
0.0119604263,
-0.0441026092,
0.0079960292,
0.0425434448,
0.0855102465,
-0.0085995765,
-0.0224006921,
-0.0233972594,
0.0290896427,
-0.0011437158,
0.0707300007,
0.0281891823,
-0.0164886229,
-0.0553874373,
-0.0120741148,
0.0235013999,
-0.0497020334,
-0.0211222749,
0.0056120828,
0.0119546037,
0.0413127728,
-0.0913809538,
-0.0494554527,
-0.0010649555,
-0.0290097166,
-0.0422026217,
-0.0044378405,
0.0142666847,
0.0234727897,
-0.015420978,
-0.0320013799,
-0.0240983646,
0.0163984001,
-0.0216459278,
0.0088913906,
0.0437780842,
0.0127145266,
-0.0538213886,
-0.024194086,
-0.0384423546,
-0.0051024463,
-0.0351434797,
0.0476811938,
0.0059894598,
-0.0275490545,
-0.027150657,
-0.0038570571,
0.0534532331,
0.0185018238,
-0.0083096977,
0.0173407625,
0.0145281525,
-0.0105951484,
-0.0188051499,
0.027005991,
-0.0557098016,
0.0144978939,
-0.020774914,
0.0605851971,
-0.0375050828,
-0.0702481195,
0.0083820848,
0.0057619065,
0.0214530695,
0.0376147814,
0.0094175544,
0.0069873719,
0.0343608484,
-0.005949812,
0.0086622732,
-0.0114410324,
-0.0168520287,
-0.0107400669,
-0.0226437822,
-0.0129820602,
0.0074831159,
-0.0372835882,
0.0541773289,
-0.024407519,
0.0110463835,
0.0777318552,
0.0183411334,
-0.0401054174,
-0.0183679461,
-0.047307387,
-0.0635133982,
0.0465036929,
0.0645924136,
0.0077663967,
0.0467944071,
0.0106117642,
0.0230228528,
0.0202699024,
-0.0002570736,
-0.0847261846,
-0.0031221448,
-0.0322174244,
0.000531413,
0.026857974,
0.0335475318,
0.0633388385,
0.0467665792,
-0.010485095,
0.0037024168,
0.0013676946,
-0.0138233788,
0.0036801076,
0.0675595105,
0.0050199246,
-0.004550369,
0.0171918292,
0.0508790798,
-0.0432955138,
0.035102766,
-0.0482014082,
-0.0268993396,
-0.0122924652,
-0.0098700356,
-0.0673336014,
-0.0070719668,
0.03322386,
0.0129132643,
-0.0478120111,
-0.0375441276,
0.0459167883,
0.0094096782,
-0.0075538228,
-0.0015033437,
0.0432378575,
0.0282134414,
0.0338767208,
-0.0533755012,
-0.0504810214,
0.0210507419,
-0.0551671982,
0.0008584876,
-0.0511144921,
-6.046503066e-33,
-0.0253942981,
-0.0452420451,
-0.0073844208,
-0.0039060512,
-0.0069611021,
-0.0033068131,
-0.0212761741,
-0.02842726,
-0.0577262193,
0.0055520078,
0.0167249553,
-0.0067001511,
-0.0089997062,
0.0373982526,
0.0255909003,
-0.049682904,
0.0111763487,
0.0145463459,
-0.0289010312,
0.0199765302,
0.0446423851,
-0.0003459591,
0.0586397238,
-0.0331412293,
0.0216381345,
-0.0471951924,
0.0267983247,
0.0333051719,
0.0035469092,
0.0559478924,
-0.0144620668,
0.070057869,
0.0367475525,
-0.0470615029,
0.0428598821,
0.031533625,
-0.0702612847,
-0.0848004892,
-0.0043444186,
-0.0244255811,
-0.0207131486,
-0.0133153554,
0.0179042779,
0.010309061,
-0.0233385693,
-0.0081503568,
0.045834437,
-0.0071655293,
0.0120801255,
-0.0453533307,
-0.0140277119,
-0.0094460584,
-0.0040919846,
0.006548686,
-0.0595805794,
0.1003078222,
-0.0260532219,
0.0049280794,
-0.0329859443,
-0.0134393107,
-0.0008791334,
0.0035376376,
0.0338180587,
-0.0272542499,
-0.0232978612,
0.0329670906,
0.0128949024,
-0.0683179498,
-0.0136729656,
-0.0267791171,
-0.0473810211,
0.0105512077,
0.1028822809,
0.0630844831,
0.0198607985,
0.0381516851,
-0.0638374388,
0.070792079,
-0.0021469349,
0.0728396922,
-0.0026314431,
-0.0255956296,
0.0085924445,
0.002237445,
-0.0535872988,
0.0466932915,
-0.0468863733,
-0.0198673308,
0.0430324189,
-0.0342100039,
-0.0272055436,
0.0357514024,
0.0258723628,
-0.0197166987,
0.0028007685,
0.0431294814,
-0.0265276115,
0.0141519029,
0.0101451408,
0.0027105841,
-0.045612976,
0.0245909132,
0.0322280787,
-0.0054036458,
0.0152554708,
-0.0203936026,
0.0064889519,
-0.0405157469,
-0.062138319,
0.0034916683,
0.001154486,
-0.0028592441,
-0.0330796279,
-0.0504762679,
-0.0235438496,
0.060200721,
-0.0064748893,
0.0251871478,
0.0033841208,
0.0392999984,
-0.0075110975,
-0.0388186499,
0.0290020742,
0.0019152556,
-0.0530508831,
0.0306973066,
-0.0266697053,
0.0412284881,
-0.0459453799,
-0.0410986468,
-0.0024484643,
0.0192026664,
2.167e-7,
0.0916799605,
0.0190403145,
0.0320440345,
0.020980766,
0.002433842,
0.0225041099,
0.0231359806,
0.0325856581,
0.0525211431,
0.0471810475,
0.0102563798,
-0.0107713202,
0.0194858219,
0.053910546,
-0.0515839681,
-0.0313121118,
-0.0833082348,
-0.0443789363,
-0.0176823586,
0.0069565596,
0.1020434797,
0.0494940951,
-0.0005285051,
-0.0044115027,
-0.0673249811,
-0.0296292547,
0.0590001382,
0.0027259612,
0.0267545506,
0.0036263522,
0.0349386409,
-0.0276813786,
0.0422780253,
0.0444180034,
0.0110009359,
0.0057697161,
0.0509576686,
0.0307276379,
0.0015450731,
-0.1008829698,
-0.0355313718,
0.0003675038,
0.0405875333,
-0.051558625,
0.0895015076,
-0.0240320396,
-0.0181836225,
-0.0244337879,
-0.0900203437,
0.0109415529,
0.0355345868,
-0.0055130422,
-0.038650725,
0.0133462949,
0.0279039815,
0.0196247846,
-0.0182658322,
-0.0181553364,
0.0146116596,
0.0235479064,
0.0055976128,
-0.0401739329,
-0.0114852563,
-0.0418037735,
0.0009977169,
-0.0474550277,
0.0390703641,
1.083014284e-34,
0.019930616,
0.010330745,
0.0410798751,
0.0418303981,
0.019757567,
-0.0031533132,
-0.0158471204,
-0.0053161094,
0.0091402857,
-0.0891314968,
0.0225704461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12247v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12247v2 | Bad Actor, Good Advisor: Exploring the Role of Large Language Models in Fake News Detection | 2023-09-21T16:47:30 | 2024-01-22T07:24:30 | Beizhe Hu, Qiang Sheng, Juan Cao, Yuhui Shi, Yang Li, Danding Wang, Peng Qi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Detecting fake news requires both a delicate sense of diverse clues and a
profound understanding of the real-world background, which remains challenging
for detectors based on small language models (SLMs) due to their knowledge and
capability limitations. Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have
shown remarkable performance in various tasks, but whether and how LLMs could
help with fake news detection remains underexplored. In this paper, we
investigate the potential of LLMs in fake news detection. First, we conduct an
empirical study and find that a sophisticated LLM such as GPT 3.5 could
generally expose fake news and provide desirable multi-perspective rationales
but still underperforms the basic SLM, fine-tuned BERT. Our subsequent analysis
attributes such a gap to the LLM's inability to select and integrate rationales
properly to conclude. Based on these findings, we propose that current LLMs may
not substitute fine-tuned SLMs in fake news detection but can be a good advisor
for SLMs by providing multi-perspective instructive rationales. To instantiate
this proposal, we design an adaptive rationale guidance network for fake news
detection (ARG), in which SLMs selectively acquire insights on news analysis
from the LLMs' rationales. We further derive a rationale-free version of ARG by
distillation, namely ARG-D, which services cost-sensitive scenarios without
querying LLMs. Experiments on two real-world datasets demonstrate that ARG and
ARG-D outperform three types of baseline methods, including SLM-based,
LLM-based, and combinations of small and large language models. | [
0.0790945813,
0.0757754967,
0.0121940011,
0.0668160096,
-0.02648063,
0.0228312239,
0.0443761423,
0.0248623956,
-0.0021268367,
-0.0277813915,
-0.0006192982,
-0.0116634239,
-0.0147916935,
0.0589125752,
0.0255163126,
-0.0259030014,
0.0430528261,
0.0048341779,
0.0946186334,
-0.0219817925,
0.0580535159,
0.06670288,
0.0190893319,
0.0385655724,
0.0048731766,
-0.0152370827,
0.0070295711,
0.026020268,
0.0396905765,
0.0017949064,
-0.0178550165,
0.0210440904,
0.0464553759,
0.0763962194,
0.0000019273,
-0.0318370163,
-0.0360747054,
-0.0189032219,
-0.0392232537,
0.005110763,
0.0239663888,
-0.027531106,
-0.0287617706,
0.0347806104,
-0.0284256786,
0.012031042,
0.0210079681,
0.0784161165,
0.0943522155,
0.1221842244,
-0.015582961,
-0.0133709526,
-0.0166513845,
-0.0253758859,
-0.0332814008,
-0.0334416144,
0.0582527332,
0.0138569949,
-0.0314317606,
0.0661077723,
0.0286316816,
-0.005378311,
0.0154624349,
-0.0403943099,
-0.0628214553,
0.0190699995,
-0.0030118497,
-0.0072064311,
0.0208860394,
0.0135143483,
-0.0897119343,
-0.063316524,
0.022223942,
-0.0242628008,
0.0157856159,
0.0378761664,
-0.011732487,
0.0455203876,
-0.0217230562,
0.0293814987,
0.0695882291,
-0.0226696134,
0.037453346,
0.0765770301,
-0.0208346806,
0.0263228733,
-0.0149166891,
-0.0061252597,
0.0045846305,
-0.0109803053,
-0.0437992476,
-0.0630908236,
-0.0014623705,
0.0208492316,
-0.0229164101,
0.0183776766,
-0.0708243102,
0.0118427509,
0.0087584686,
-0.0766497627,
-0.0220558103,
0.0158854146,
0.0326117612,
0.043283876,
-0.0240859687,
0.0255259592,
-0.0439450257,
0.032767456,
-0.0201273207,
-0.0196585525,
-0.0082768938,
-0.0102550667,
-0.0249764193,
0.0396103039,
-0.0535118394,
-0.0020822748,
-0.0229852889,
0.0135991098,
-0.0324858017,
0.0130593395,
0.0080434056,
0.0233666562,
0.0058438866,
-0.0491188802,
-0.0193144996,
0.0145449452,
-0.0256517846,
0.0152479634,
-0.0173978116,
-0.0417087525,
-0.0160036255,
0.0477726087,
-0.0101455906,
-0.0107103502,
0.0126970336,
-0.0038247069,
0.0119294319,
-0.0080624903,
-0.053062506,
-0.0313949808,
-0.0233846661,
-0.0436106212,
-0.0203092732,
-0.0519133992,
-0.0420569889,
-0.0188528113,
0.0087639289,
-0.0279603917,
-0.0193063729,
0.0302180573,
-0.0475751907,
0.0629337952,
0.0008840691,
-0.0000694199,
0.0320160091,
0.0406506211,
0.0025533524,
0.1001180857,
-0.0009036587,
0.0730302408,
0.0612143725,
0.002905695,
-0.0000647441,
0.0106781982,
0.0394229926,
0.0475527979,
-0.0270173848,
-0.0060051833,
-0.0503786504,
0.0037433701,
0.0172906965,
0.0179347731,
-0.0070627709,
-0.0365067869,
0.0870402604,
0.0024960921,
0.0192762166,
0.0121706584,
0.072223641,
0.026074769,
-0.0366100669,
0.0009043436,
-0.0376430154,
0.0210135803,
-0.0584218092,
-0.0338572972,
-0.0145205129,
0.0445171818,
-0.0133649837,
-0.0103989746,
-0.0050451192,
-0.012692838,
-0.0190786514,
0.0021069127,
0.0077344449,
0.002918771,
-0.0517837368,
0.0147948116,
0.0067999372,
-0.0155053204,
0.0096095428,
-0.0858469307,
0.0534313433,
0.0548078753,
0.0586949326,
0.0254058223,
-0.0057157557,
-0.02976905,
-0.0056185396,
0.0269738082,
0.027670458,
-0.0334306061,
-0.0278581847,
-0.0261055715,
-0.0266721752,
-0.019795971,
0.0304082613,
0.0089079719,
0.0325991176,
0.0241854172,
0.0036513701,
-0.0212199613,
-0.0422247015,
0.0090437513,
-0.0119979577,
-0.0252020694,
-0.0057956148,
0.0127602536,
0.0403946973,
0.0123706376,
0.0083419159,
-0.0014945902,
0.0479212552,
-0.0116357505,
-0.0383896753,
-0.0351922922,
-0.0331237242,
-0.0261153076,
-0.017994225,
-0.0181541704,
-0.0041109319,
0.0723366663,
-0.0133275948,
-0.0036896823,
0.0126302466,
-0.0326310582,
-0.0007648448,
-0.0685400218,
-0.0213189721,
-0.0278270449,
0.0047482718,
0.0184794795,
0.0825260729,
-0.0161447134,
-0.0021459302,
0.0269482564,
0.0305276029,
-0.0029433898,
-0.016410267,
0.0153284809,
0.0186392758,
0.000768418,
0.005444577,
0.0311092176,
0.0132706175,
0.0100198714,
-0.0269416925,
-0.053124886,
-0.0156995915,
-0.043676585,
-0.0040905075,
0.06024478,
0.0032053597,
-0.0005755637,
0.0306948964,
-0.0482927077,
-0.0196935609,
0.0157823097,
0.0131975291,
-0.0048497263,
-0.0295905285,
0.0173216984,
0.0062625036,
0.0223337747,
-0.0067775091,
0.0487191491,
-0.0070956438,
-0.0329291709,
-0.0596205853,
-0.0195850115,
-0.03501001,
0.0105490014,
-0.0372712761,
-0.0234105699,
-0.0011133852,
-0.0158127714,
-0.0125264088,
0.0471772589,
0.0542323291,
0.0780648366,
0.0279599186,
0.0263515785,
-0.0501314625,
-0.0248970836,
-0.0321763903,
0.0516885146,
-0.0478373803,
-0.0533583052,
0.0324154459,
0.0426007025,
0.0005663335,
0.0048808064,
-0.0533815883,
0.0811345205,
0.0053966767,
-0.0142758228,
0.0206283201,
-0.0843616053,
-0.0110301226,
0.0172097906,
-0.0157052204,
-0.0276807342,
0.1140125915,
-0.0191919785,
0.0373839326,
-0.0238364097,
-0.0476548411,
-0.0241215099,
0.0068314024,
-0.0433030613,
0.0244134218,
0.006006029,
0.0013243514,
-0.001388645,
-0.0482645556,
0.0695695505,
-0.0231162775,
0.047084827,
-0.0665854886,
0.0255638901,
0.02582152,
-0.0075639887,
-0.0594369732,
-0.095436424,
-0.0352090783,
-0.0255930461,
-0.0064941999,
-0.0294425096,
-0.071941331,
0.0265670717,
0.0251954533,
0.0454037115,
-0.0329400003,
0.0181935262,
0.0128381308,
0.0280979872,
0.0353874378,
-0.0054572932,
0.0326256379,
-0.0062256339,
0.0405552611,
0.0557899252,
-0.0095632598,
-0.0141822072,
-0.0134329796,
-0.0076175211,
0.0139729111,
0.0124475528,
0.0147664268,
-0.0236643571,
0.0164414383,
-0.0335404836,
-0.0094951447,
0.1175737679,
0.0064624832,
-0.0171180759,
-0.0105111357,
0.0356788561,
0.0113763493,
0.0087924637,
-0.0241088029,
-0.027098529,
-0.0280820485,
0.0028980693,
0.0219655223,
-0.069109872,
-0.0319488272,
-0.0460456833,
-0.1165359542,
0.0243118517,
0.0025192951,
-0.0119423335,
-0.025658194,
-0.0717478693,
-0.0274654403,
-0.0257381853,
0.0069505605,
-0.0068938867,
0.0337644368,
-0.0338815786,
-0.0057543661,
-0.0033372664,
-0.0422532372,
-0.0032661036,
0.0027398716,
0.0448930785,
0.0365352109,
0.050799042,
-0.015610557,
-0.0593501478,
0.0080763521,
-0.0355235711,
-0.0196881071,
-0.0250209849,
0.0542197339,
-0.0294647515,
-0.0078582941,
-0.015789425,
0.0492507294,
-0.0132989502,
-0.0044685155,
-0.0122657511,
0.0558871292,
-0.0009522786,
-0.0674236119,
-0.0214778297,
0.019862486,
0.0262524076,
0.0781222954,
0.0128899813,
-0.027266793,
0.0112514868,
-0.016337283,
-0.0359543599,
-0.0144830029,
-0.0566453896,
0.016371632,
-0.0140680429,
-0.0338418707,
-0.0297859088,
-0.0081234034,
-0.0130726481,
0.0422017835,
-0.0162144955,
-0.0129716815,
0.010320357,
-0.0003738419,
-0.0135287009,
0.0015740232,
-0.0211504288,
0.0480352938,
0.0051518446,
0.0498798788,
-0.0004059137,
-0.0343095288,
-0.0054433495,
0.0277451463,
-0.0504943468,
-0.0287786424,
-0.0187238399,
0.0061231898,
0.0321502499,
0.0605544746,
-0.0406055711,
-0.0355116799,
0.0404238068,
0.0123923337,
-0.0079471786,
-0.0017779983,
0.0344562158,
-0.0119317099,
0.0417570285,
0.0461828634,
-0.0247004312,
0.0296394471,
0.025239978,
-0.0177469607,
-0.0747118294,
-0.0011197772,
0.0439127423,
0.0114907259,
0.0252192486,
-0.0004209225,
0.0193189867,
-0.0582154505,
-0.0275321454,
-0.0312586054,
-0.0259495955,
-0.0164878611,
0.0394441821,
0.0449759886,
-0.0100324973,
-0.0198906064,
-0.0159013309,
-0.0507873408,
-0.0086173955,
-0.0311638173,
-0.0276892371,
-0.019292701,
0.0512158982,
0.029463917,
-0.0136333406,
-0.0478379838,
0.0176679734,
0.0077666426,
0.0255230535,
-0.0158891659,
0.0319382511,
0.0572254844,
-0.0384517126,
0.0541872904,
-0.0167423058,
-0.0434638262,
-0.0396715775,
-0.0344382823,
0.0288231391,
0.0129938023,
-0.0291134361,
0.0558770373,
-0.0042318222,
0.0013811724,
0.0068812128,
-0.0149686299,
0.0222659353,
-0.0585547499,
0.0094201211,
0.0343764201,
-0.0315445662,
0.0437345132,
0.0718543306,
0.0043738033,
0.0186614208,
0.006288189,
-0.0683390424,
-0.0255174637,
-0.0182285979,
0.0045208973,
0.0546424277,
-0.0199046973,
0.0066097495,
-0.0809292644,
-0.0441966392,
-0.0337128714,
-0.0092447344,
0.0139136212,
0.0034378301,
-0.0249125138,
0.0807338357,
-0.0064754202,
0.0309228357,
-0.0369572975,
-0.0004595153,
-0.0298931804,
-0.0501090772,
0.0205480196,
-6.272600956e-33,
0.0356157683,
-0.0760224685,
-0.0325715654,
-0.0346202254,
0.00541641,
0.0509078093,
-0.0253184773,
-0.0340271704,
-0.0468848646,
0.0467262492,
0.0268878918,
0.0438838452,
-0.0057640914,
0.0123728598,
-0.0609331205,
0.0001075352,
0.0340832099,
0.0203557741,
-0.0373443179,
0.0388529636,
0.0730886236,
-0.0199602935,
0.0341642834,
-0.0617755242,
0.0490092598,
-0.011697853,
-0.0689186379,
0.055681143,
-0.0355542712,
0.0546034835,
0.0052955244,
0.0379231125,
0.0367779583,
-0.0459250323,
0.0116517534,
0.013648604,
-0.023579143,
-0.0284151807,
0.035035748,
-0.0366954505,
-0.0239859242,
-0.0095069902,
0.0322345868,
0.001676739,
-0.0094774198,
0.0262748245,
0.0207712762,
-0.0298777074,
-0.0048489729,
0.0085182153,
-0.0272471886,
0.0119315181,
-0.0154814254,
0.0009090907,
-0.0236209482,
0.0319117568,
0.0164369233,
0.0453265607,
-0.0488515124,
0.0181951709,
-0.0164489821,
-0.0083546788,
0.0313359313,
-0.0326990634,
-0.058033783,
0.071941413,
-0.0247859061,
0.0386828296,
-0.0479694046,
-0.0130186696,
0.0037081963,
0.0321115106,
0.0973661914,
0.0776208341,
0.0121511007,
-0.0303061046,
-0.090455018,
0.0292721074,
0.0187388286,
0.0025703053,
0.0377250016,
-0.0192228239,
-0.030320365,
0.0064731259,
-0.0056060771,
-0.0373309441,
-0.0329887681,
0.0086090472,
-0.006470663,
0.0295976494,
-0.0473606214,
0.0378118083,
0.0086365044,
-0.047326386,
0.0291443635,
0.0384298079,
-0.0369352251,
-0.0404054895,
0.0161203966,
0.0592244454,
-0.0551248416,
0.0084907664,
0.0560136735,
-0.0095681362,
-0.0329032503,
-0.0235718116,
0.0493988097,
0.0079485066,
-0.0382375307,
0.006011419,
-0.0404677875,
0.0407833308,
-0.0432499796,
0.0054309592,
0.0325333364,
-0.0022969486,
-0.0126726897,
-0.008798507,
0.0057385145,
-0.0213442985,
0.0003530635,
0.011948972,
-0.0264184363,
0.0240012277,
-0.0165714137,
-0.0204310361,
-0.0146844527,
0.0053459099,
0.0432212204,
-0.0890739858,
-0.0048281355,
0.0156799983,
2.743e-7,
-0.0144924046,
0.0439499915,
-0.0051673381,
0.0074523361,
0.0340100043,
0.0798541084,
0.0295622908,
0.015573062,
-0.0173646547,
-0.0660506636,
-0.0216075014,
0.0279664397,
0.0084537286,
0.0378360115,
-0.0562758818,
0.0208263639,
-0.0721914843,
-0.0348691046,
-0.061356727,
-0.0034839734,
0.0361671709,
0.0643139407,
0.0648714378,
-0.0481216274,
0.0280741509,
-0.0294883382,
0.0249198172,
0.0297995117,
-0.0388847254,
-0.0042799348,
0.090018779,
-0.0140570495,
0.0048612203,
0.0184318833,
-0.013142555,
0.0089063197,
-0.0339959487,
0.0624539293,
0.0042957407,
-0.0179092381,
-0.0338127278,
-0.0581027158,
0.0356691815,
-0.0999396667,
0.0785227194,
0.0095909182,
-0.0276338253,
-0.0208344236,
-0.0278504677,
-0.0225616004,
-0.0080612544,
-0.0229383055,
-0.0214759354,
0.0257179383,
-0.0166531671,
0.0150915664,
0.014776201,
-0.0637283102,
0.012736599,
-0.0143065685,
-0.0570889227,
-0.0162591096,
-0.0098392135,
-0.0076233712,
0.0966823176,
-0.0590702556,
0.0515302792,
2.5120025e-34,
0.0305498317,
-0.0098144552,
-0.0195158906,
-0.012008707,
0.0520896837,
0.0471279323,
-0.0614371039,
-0.0131134316,
0.0296697393,
-0.0186203308,
-0.027424179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12244v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12244v4 | ChaCha: Leveraging Large Language Models to Prompt Children to Share Their Emotions about Personal Events | 2023-09-21T16:43:17 | 2024-02-19T03:22:07 | Woosuk Seo, Chanmo Yang, Young-Ho Kim | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, H.5.2; I.2.7 | Children typically learn to identify and express emotions through sharing
their stories and feelings with others, particularly their family. However, it
is challenging for parents or siblings to have emotional communication with
children since children are still developing their communication skills. We
present ChaCha, a chatbot that encourages and guides children to share personal
events and associated emotions. ChaCha combines a state machine and large
language models (LLMs) to keep the dialogue on track while carrying on
free-form conversations. Through an exploratory study with 20 children (aged
8-12), we examine how ChaCha prompts children to share personal events and
guides them to describe associated emotions. Participants perceived ChaCha as a
close friend and shared their stories on various topics, such as family trips
and personal achievements. Based on the findings, we discuss opportunities for
leveraging LLMs to design child-friendly chatbots to support children in
sharing emotions. | [
0.0303845387,
0.0468507186,
-0.0467543378,
-0.0073351958,
-0.0295736566,
-0.0090873428,
0.0267238803,
-0.0098413564,
0.0652450174,
-0.0208406541,
-0.0017862723,
-0.0296125356,
0.0259688646,
0.0478796624,
-0.0516384803,
-0.0875369683,
0.0223734714,
0.0097777667,
0.0719835907,
0.0111459149,
0.0317453705,
0.0327246264,
-0.029375704,
0.0567554049,
-0.0439807698,
-0.0299977679,
-0.0224016905,
0.0264727809,
0.0110785905,
-0.043055132,
0.0040222388,
-0.0065643173,
0.0302158538,
0.0115442015,
0.0000017768,
-0.0256872196,
0.0200640149,
-0.0409628116,
0.0043246686,
-0.0319523253,
0.0845927224,
-0.0026282836,
-0.0119494591,
0.0395354591,
-0.0256606638,
-0.0043071369,
0.0791413262,
0.0455620438,
0.0635229275,
0.0792218074,
-0.0282069929,
0.0068227206,
-0.0180452485,
-0.0087435925,
0.0469788499,
-0.017429674,
-0.0152341649,
0.0314956754,
0.0990405157,
-0.0458052233,
-0.0213970505,
0.0332865603,
0.0210066754,
-0.0612090752,
0.0129240314,
0.0338681377,
0.0065608993,
-0.053607814,
-0.0077807168,
0.0737273023,
0.061084535,
0.004726802,
0.0341812856,
0.0061024544,
0.0362714715,
0.0257492252,
-0.0559312105,
0.0399671942,
0.0040340736,
0.0382504389,
-0.0114539191,
0.0062984736,
0.0042527453,
0.0253453702,
0.0506556146,
0.0419062115,
-0.0376181006,
-0.0160699245,
-0.0222147405,
0.017380422,
0.0671864673,
-0.0894392729,
0.0566763915,
0.0192197897,
0.0050174752,
0.0248548817,
-0.058552105,
0.0374405682,
-0.0373879336,
-0.0072010565,
-0.0185771044,
0.0278276969,
-0.0185231678,
0.0211683325,
0.070886381,
0.0196902473,
0.0313426815,
0.0202334393,
-0.0223941673,
0.008914643,
-0.0212864112,
-0.0201329775,
-0.0380267315,
0.0425509773,
-0.0237050653,
-0.0666024983,
-0.0582995676,
0.0472629555,
0.0125570865,
-0.0037890039,
-0.0178054497,
0.012254077,
0.0184226539,
0.0097091366,
-0.034553472,
0.0338950381,
-0.0480604768,
0.0038031051,
0.0378761441,
-0.0460675657,
0.0029994173,
-0.0045030038,
0.0264401529,
0.0123305162,
-0.0233841185,
0.0274281465,
-0.0039935652,
-0.0204511881,
0.0116773294,
-0.0151510304,
-0.0024300902,
-0.0669040233,
0.0064047691,
-0.0129509587,
0.022542946,
0.0084692854,
0.0322447047,
-0.0509051681,
0.0273611061,
-0.0135945641,
-0.0065613016,
0.0258088913,
-0.0166842677,
0.0054887743,
-0.0170559473,
0.0405493937,
0.0664675906,
0.0387559719,
0.0534773879,
0.0171624664,
0.0298707746,
0.0163049903,
0.0298647955,
0.0137681803,
-0.0509851575,
-0.0265521333,
-0.0214358717,
-0.0518936962,
-0.0150281945,
0.0423201099,
0.0003398691,
0.0434284732,
4.12e-8,
0.0223374702,
0.0902874544,
0.0632188767,
-0.0490361825,
0.0491342805,
-0.0269863158,
0.0470885411,
0.0429122522,
-0.0247556102,
-0.0117286574,
0.0675225854,
0.0058594085,
-0.037641041,
0.0141719263,
-0.0212286748,
-0.0418305211,
-0.0302006248,
-0.0363661572,
-0.0589589998,
0.0635721385,
0.0199375059,
0.0036801165,
-0.0116597693,
-0.0099185361,
-0.0007587547,
-0.0056524538,
-0.0741865411,
0.0058284658,
-0.054697413,
0.0505694598,
0.1085991859,
-0.0031157704,
-0.0183200855,
-0.0094181914,
-0.0020197651,
-0.011600838,
0.0244191382,
0.0044646123,
0.017479226,
0.0296148118,
-0.0094664497,
0.0210313592,
0.0041568074,
0.0177570134,
-0.0331124961,
-0.0360840335,
0.0135500897,
-0.014086999,
0.0225356761,
0.0444515534,
0.0217284393,
-0.0146193532,
-0.001881388,
-0.0055970247,
0.0023775625,
-0.0016624029,
0.0256245211,
0.0177251101,
-0.0032055718,
0.0302220564,
0.008105468,
-0.0166524053,
0.0873063579,
-0.0382155329,
-0.0456981733,
0.0089956345,
-0.0401400737,
-0.0090228617,
0.0322119445,
-0.0003980208,
-0.0209594909,
0.0533728302,
-0.0434892066,
0.0691080987,
0.0085002631,
0.0414928682,
-0.0420391224,
-0.008839367,
0.0340348072,
0.0099497838,
-0.0006493962,
-0.0388620868,
-0.0405226536,
0.0212909766,
-0.0614752658,
-0.0324308947,
-0.014050818,
0.0306721497,
0.0181834344,
0.0262866355,
0.0188326873,
-0.0126466062,
-0.0868603513,
-0.049957484,
-0.1319696158,
-0.0073362989,
0.0396510661,
-0.0313938893,
0.0047455947,
0.0120676663,
-0.0034541758,
-0.0044979025,
-0.0491834283,
0.0543735549,
0.0095405858,
0.0301273912,
0.0336676911,
-0.0034298811,
-0.0186558869,
-0.073971197,
0.0007111065,
-0.024389036,
0.0401394069,
0.0441140085,
-0.0130531983,
-0.0434555486,
0.0091574183,
-0.0894381329,
0.0483735427,
-0.0264946986,
-0.0302161872,
0.0430039652,
-0.030291304,
0.0238411222,
0.0714733675,
-0.0006374863,
0.0517506264,
0.024767518,
-0.0498066582,
-0.0473697893,
0.0185771491,
0.0324660987,
0.0033476423,
-0.0248183105,
-0.0337701179,
-0.0130641051,
0.051512789,
-0.0025770618,
0.0341736078,
-0.0532293729,
0.0227056742,
0.0160220508,
0.0278198011,
-0.0039351103,
-0.0820101276,
-0.0199959371,
0.0324146189,
-0.0079269893,
-0.0680156499,
0.0436340421,
0.0149940215,
-0.0463508442,
-0.0058287322,
-0.0151756275,
0.0010680583,
0.130253762,
-0.0476767607,
0.0097732022,
0.0164896585,
-0.0137630589,
-0.0096426811,
-0.0218087658,
-0.0119205937,
-0.0540799759,
-0.0112387175,
-0.0237005539,
-0.0141707528,
0.0605080575,
-0.0171644129,
-0.0345886238,
-0.053376656,
-0.0611751638,
-0.0122678569,
-0.0010535483,
-0.0505501479,
-0.0416844115,
-0.0117391404,
0.0365342014,
-0.0098641971,
-0.01507504,
0.0030668888,
0.0027890871,
-0.0134851998,
0.0499934219,
-0.0430834554,
0.0291469377,
-0.0391160958,
0.0573890768,
0.0318095945,
0.0431098789,
0.0241835304,
0.0188423321,
0.0002798801,
0.0219543539,
0.035892874,
-0.029823631,
0.0013557186,
0.0753768459,
-0.0437178276,
-0.0104353568,
0.0834591687,
0.020675119,
-0.0426120423,
0.0116553884,
-0.0419431552,
-0.0086373566,
-0.0087173469,
-0.0028641897,
-0.0522545539,
-0.0050431513,
0.0178992096,
-0.027149763,
-0.0252935886,
-0.0218377225,
-0.0091478182,
-0.0629107282,
-0.0342197753,
0.0280296411,
-0.0420445986,
-0.0398764126,
-0.0155778686,
0.0033051367,
0.0548045449,
0.0054833833,
0.007468381,
-0.0357064381,
-0.0329378322,
-0.0300799459,
-0.0251481067,
-0.0436639301,
0.0569675565,
-0.0252444632,
0.0900496691,
0.0114451554,
0.0670583919,
0.0071103619,
-0.028203154,
-0.0024445793,
0.0660183281,
-0.017138619,
0.0067846347,
-0.0166271906,
-0.004626838,
-0.0110673914,
-0.0394243225,
0.0188581143,
0.0130339535,
0.009234786,
0.0077306428,
0.0526138432,
-0.0408062264,
-0.0383756272,
0.006453489,
0.048590444,
0.0426429436,
0.0223823134,
-0.0102526881,
-0.0652823523,
0.0181001835,
-0.0010168994,
0.009661383,
0.0604523942,
-0.0254014209,
-0.0111237904,
0.0064302282,
0.0094504654,
-0.0887129456,
-0.0428449512,
0.0266899783,
-0.0168129038,
0.0023882785,
-0.0272372831,
0.0162990876,
0.0272475611,
0.0103820143,
0.0287231747,
-0.0544917695,
0.0007998703,
-0.0107245948,
-0.0342825092,
-0.0040113716,
-0.0426646098,
0.0237232447,
0.014047835,
-0.0580672286,
-0.0149960229,
-0.0040800297,
-0.0041876752,
0.0279270597,
-0.0148320682,
0.0191803388,
-0.0678930283,
-0.0329157934,
0.0074328063,
-0.0333721489,
-0.0173266567,
0.0105443997,
0.035975825,
0.0132107297,
-0.0015684906,
-0.0062258518,
0.0035863433,
-0.0356562547,
0.0087555349,
-0.0322621055,
-0.1149295196,
0.00592682,
0.0060018976,
0.0250726882,
0.010467913,
-0.0378470942,
-0.0227069911,
-0.016606424,
-0.0523149855,
0.0252554789,
-0.0566525981,
-0.0160324108,
0.0060597379,
0.0334995314,
-0.0082372157,
-0.0769479945,
-0.0534277074,
0.0121215163,
0.004395071,
0.0396146886,
-0.0244972724,
0.029141726,
-0.021239344,
0.033875376,
-0.0102143763,
0.0248477198,
0.012938532,
0.0152523629,
-0.0063954708,
0.074115999,
-0.0257274192,
-0.0343036093,
0.0029027609,
-0.0016649797,
-0.0119581716,
-0.0300951693,
-0.0018714857,
0.0519619957,
0.0481150858,
0.0140618728,
0.0201342925,
-0.0501602218,
0.0316868462,
-0.0237256456,
0.0366056114,
0.018856762,
-0.0772920623,
0.0095684594,
-0.0212649498,
-0.0209390521,
0.0306997187,
-0.0317463316,
-0.0258611701,
0.0496962182,
0.0049645784,
0.0159730222,
-0.020414643,
0.0157300979,
0.0548074245,
0.0031360476,
-0.0090869032,
0.0082223918,
-0.0679848418,
-0.0239580832,
0.0263012238,
-0.0162596125,
-0.0363926366,
-0.0721558481,
0.0441761166,
0.0028608441,
-0.0308955181,
-0.003301485,
-0.0551956631,
0.0038676222,
-0.0364695489,
-0.0058425744,
-0.0220923219,
-5.391255699e-33,
-0.0017237937,
-0.0332938544,
-0.0137766972,
0.0028518008,
-0.0507279783,
0.0067442339,
-0.0564514399,
0.0536984093,
-0.0020659945,
0.0188926477,
-0.0398862474,
0.0115320003,
0.0074627348,
-0.0108155254,
0.0172969382,
-0.0325267762,
0.0232944209,
-0.0030699768,
-0.0153402016,
0.027376214,
0.0236845072,
0.0139789069,
0.0459353328,
-0.0733712763,
0.036668174,
-0.0251726694,
-0.0561419539,
0.0397554673,
0.0583045445,
0.0256139096,
-0.0060143447,
0.0180743113,
0.0013371529,
0.0318031833,
-0.0016122904,
0.0756798461,
-0.035847947,
-0.0348724313,
0.0492378958,
-0.03374492,
-0.0736008361,
-0.0366373993,
-0.0015766952,
-0.0254716836,
0.0010808848,
0.0128260609,
0.0279312823,
-0.0222561173,
0.0147384321,
-0.014293341,
-0.0232562125,
-0.0347713716,
-0.0186699945,
-0.0557976291,
0.0160192456,
0.0534283556,
-0.0041825077,
-0.0341931656,
0.0050424789,
0.0489204265,
0.0003756588,
0.0236472525,
-0.011305864,
-0.0015904381,
0.055860199,
0.0892573297,
0.0210935716,
0.0295357741,
-0.0508096591,
0.0594673343,
0.0402027741,
0.0291594137,
0.0304628164,
0.0168992616,
-0.0386252329,
-0.0342357494,
-0.0396949239,
0.0035153397,
0.0638288558,
0.0315508284,
0.0138568869,
0.0401437394,
-0.0357804894,
0.0273957439,
-0.0253154803,
0.0216665883,
-0.0041277423,
-0.0511921868,
-0.0227079298,
0.0117507698,
-0.0485430323,
-0.0316386335,
-0.0246992856,
-0.0172341615,
-0.0189944711,
0.0158666316,
0.0061593154,
0.0268548001,
-0.0151741663,
-0.011912805,
-0.0022187422,
-0.0357462578,
0.0278860964,
-0.0075632031,
0.0492495224,
0.0546455607,
-0.0215867069,
0.0235211886,
-0.054394681,
-0.0044812416,
-0.0234010089,
0.055077929,
0.0019717414,
-0.0509412475,
-0.0118117137,
0.0057473793,
-0.0515130498,
-0.0095465668,
0.0050647985,
0.0562957749,
-0.0382660329,
0.007019361,
-0.0176144745,
-0.0339501984,
-0.0292730499,
0.0016364561,
-0.0862836316,
0.0497394763,
0.0392700955,
-0.0217405856,
-0.0065557556,
-0.0343720727,
2.527e-7,
-0.0477224737,
0.0592504553,
-0.0030956238,
0.0181393716,
0.0398320407,
0.015866464,
-0.0124716526,
0.0075733322,
0.0449339226,
-0.0244997852,
0.0082320496,
0.0244597327,
0.0824904889,
0.000994136,
-0.0896219984,
0.0279212203,
-0.0321024656,
-0.0071471687,
-0.0005485429,
0.0196380503,
0.0882470384,
0.078158237,
0.0764918551,
-0.0037449047,
0.0177531466,
0.0191030167,
0.0460266732,
-0.0581044853,
-0.004628974,
0.0038667182,
-0.0493512973,
-0.0076268055,
-0.0094544915,
-0.0337581113,
0.0431683101,
-0.023322003,
-0.0127955936,
0.0883367211,
0.0133082671,
-0.034333732,
0.037185844,
0.0535423048,
-0.0600728467,
-0.0187960993,
0.0290000308,
-0.0484124087,
-0.0177977588,
-0.0143989772,
0.0390410684,
-0.0368795916,
0.020109877,
-0.0322665758,
-0.0459040105,
0.0463793091,
-0.0408835784,
-0.0106642544,
0.0131826159,
-0.0399656147,
-0.0254424587,
-0.0384539589,
-0.0477635972,
-0.073170945,
-0.0069769556,
0.0114185736,
-0.0523891523,
0.00761974,
0.0454748496,
1.312417747e-34,
-0.0174346492,
-0.0256942715,
-0.0086026154,
0.0153635917,
0.0612447225,
0.0227577314,
0.0266059283,
0.0017205221,
0.050788857,
-0.0286113806,
-0.0080303699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12234v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12234v1 | Bridging the Gaps of Both Modality and Language: Synchronous Bilingual CTC for Speech Translation and Speech Recognition | 2023-09-21T16:28:42 | 2023-09-21T16:28:42 | Chen Xu, Xiaoqian Liu, Erfeng He, Yuhao Zhang, Qianqian Dong, Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu, Dapeng Man, Wu Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | In this study, we present synchronous bilingual Connectionist Temporal
Classification (CTC), an innovative framework that leverages dual CTC to bridge
the gaps of both modality and language in the speech translation (ST) task.
Utilizing transcript and translation as concurrent objectives for CTC, our
model bridges the gap between audio and text as well as between source and
target languages. Building upon the recent advances in CTC application, we
develop an enhanced variant, BiL-CTC+, that establishes new state-of-the-art
performances on the MuST-C ST benchmarks under resource-constrained scenarios.
Intriguingly, our method also yields significant improvements in speech
recognition performance, revealing the effect of cross-lingual learning on
transcription and demonstrating its broad applicability. The source code is
available at https://github.com/xuchennlp/S2T. | [
-0.0364841819,
0.088500835,
-0.0065275542,
0.0522122867,
-0.0251150317,
0.0301168766,
0.0522123054,
-0.0432632007,
-0.0192963034,
0.001100242,
-0.0556705333,
-0.0588539131,
0.0901624709,
0.0078934534,
-0.0279550124,
-0.0077213873,
0.0416402817,
-0.0193659682,
-0.0119740339,
0.0055098953,
-0.0574792922,
0.0036234045,
-0.0297348704,
0.0133719621,
0.0223792978,
0.0127439816,
0.0146750463,
0.0147670358,
0.0426515825,
-0.0174790863,
-0.0309773758,
0.0166510623,
0.026576262,
0.0875673816,
0.0000018584,
-0.013601305,
0.0001235707,
0.0225112569,
0.0089594396,
-0.006843952,
0.0419028886,
-0.0119806351,
-0.0209849589,
0.0245449357,
-0.0240605902,
-0.0644721538,
0.0490940735,
0.0317143761,
-0.0135287941,
0.0663869679,
-0.0064846803,
-0.012128422,
0.0306211263,
-0.0480662808,
0.0207273606,
-0.0240607411,
-0.0308350362,
-0.0140755931,
-0.0069786981,
-0.0074281627,
-0.0140419444,
0.0926889032,
0.01228981,
-0.0228402596,
-0.0278173387,
0.0161199067,
-0.0164998621,
-0.0075161415,
-0.0034868862,
0.0342569798,
0.0051272376,
-0.0046409043,
-0.006649245,
0.0408969261,
-0.0237310864,
-0.0385875292,
-0.0127029847,
-0.0104992893,
0.0201866422,
0.0087983971,
0.0217215493,
0.0452758409,
0.0516818576,
-0.0282766875,
-0.005076353,
-0.0324158706,
0.0100329136,
-0.004585702,
-0.0036053045,
0.0077425791,
0.0700890049,
0.0042446372,
0.0480896011,
-0.0025807298,
-0.0344102792,
-0.0260895975,
0.0091501074,
-0.0229213946,
-0.0276682936,
-0.0283255577,
-0.0159499869,
0.0732551962,
-0.0403305031,
0.0514872894,
-0.0650401637,
0.0402732491,
-0.0425413363,
0.0328320302,
-0.0376583934,
0.0004777794,
-0.0432963185,
0.0092840577,
-0.00225779,
-0.0338315628,
-0.0270134602,
-0.0064144405,
-0.031434685,
0.0079350024,
0.0005075299,
-0.0027501383,
0.0042386302,
-0.0169098247,
-0.0614016913,
0.012402839,
0.0323729552,
0.0571578667,
0.0287217908,
0.028574327,
-0.0383187346,
-0.0561390705,
-0.0249737091,
0.0396167822,
0.0039199763,
-0.0395276956,
0.0008477146,
0.0637029484,
-0.0512655824,
-0.022899894,
-0.0052976538,
0.0035733064,
-0.0281004403,
-0.0498388335,
-0.0254587419,
-0.05465848,
0.0558538139,
0.0119821662,
0.022428995,
0.0142418817,
-0.0069794203,
-0.0468960069,
0.0285163261,
0.0770408809,
0.0373035073,
-0.0321673378,
0.0675299987,
0.0049056569,
0.0529845804,
0.058848042,
0.0544324815,
-0.033663746,
-0.0213732496,
0.0100360988,
-0.0709271803,
0.0551092476,
-0.0008954916,
0.0136245573,
-0.076513119,
-0.0075065806,
0.0753951222,
0.0651256517,
0.0275498964,
0.0425154157,
-0.0356713869,
-0.0142519576,
0.0496281236,
0.0073972894,
0.0418779552,
0.0422294997,
0.0607723668,
0.0079029342,
-0.0098616257,
-0.0232964642,
-0.0259346254,
0.0178808086,
-0.0039493684,
0.0084065571,
0.0165614393,
0.0445712432,
-0.0426745825,
0.0023096013,
0.029473966,
-0.037405666,
0.0502423234,
-0.0049197162,
0.0192922056,
-0.0001494423,
-0.0147315683,
0.0465925522,
-0.0173054524,
-0.0347056314,
0.030723324,
-0.027451938,
-0.0587095357,
0.0287583862,
-0.0062698275,
-0.0210998468,
-0.0331451818,
-0.0595835038,
-0.0247034598,
0.048470702,
0.0743837729,
0.003288208,
0.0739468485,
-0.0490166284,
-0.0158912316,
0.0335023701,
-0.0338098072,
0.0477512032,
-0.0427620001,
0.069861494,
0.0340381749,
-0.0162004046,
0.0074932165,
-0.0066603767,
-0.0124003636,
-0.005344104,
0.0737538189,
0.0100130169,
0.0453094505,
0.0186597649,
-0.026819082,
0.0036295035,
0.0066131731,
-0.0655143633,
0.0036000449,
0.091545321,
-0.0801581964,
-0.0820115134,
0.0446697958,
-0.0058643897,
0.0266207755,
0.0243306849,
0.003438195,
-0.0812563151,
0.0505575463,
-0.0147337168,
0.0381174833,
-0.0424531214,
0.0287658609,
-0.0072072488,
0.0246190559,
0.0277335923,
0.0002284439,
-0.0033989311,
-0.0182163082,
0.0524445288,
0.0002775427,
0.0081807254,
-0.0440157689,
-0.0440427363,
0.0723861977,
0.0191118922,
0.0043583051,
-0.0057033445,
0.0296411738,
0.0147225354,
-0.0519846864,
-0.1118108556,
0.0083101662,
-0.0178309232,
0.0329309404,
-0.0180458315,
0.0159216505,
0.0140332421,
-0.011180154,
-0.0304186996,
-0.0166104771,
-0.011934978,
-0.0014245722,
-0.0363418572,
0.0196423996,
-0.01756154,
0.0167813692,
-0.0200644732,
0.0101141939,
0.0441901833,
-0.0223909393,
-0.0283542909,
-0.0487145707,
-0.005794785,
0.0181041043,
0.0141195115,
0.0079715634,
-0.0141363544,
-0.0166320652,
0.0056765266,
0.0643104687,
0.021080032,
0.0174141563,
-0.0355206728,
0.0129107097,
-0.0180581715,
-0.0428811871,
0.0322684683,
0.020860767,
0.0229325779,
-0.0375206023,
-0.0011112757,
-0.0513625778,
0.0768502355,
0.0168152153,
0.0096754944,
-0.0482923388,
-0.0751684904,
-0.0264408775,
-0.0320595466,
-0.0249650385,
0.0288351048,
-0.0292059947,
-0.0172416698,
-0.0193652455,
-0.0318200216,
0.0619803891,
-0.0716409534,
-0.027596103,
-0.0391789712,
-0.0342783816,
-0.0465761796,
0.0546050817,
-0.0202015582,
-0.0021301804,
-0.0428010114,
-0.0530926846,
-0.0371065177,
0.0109251169,
-0.0006154766,
-0.0394720361,
0.0159345828,
-0.018092813,
-0.002031588,
-0.0393831395,
-0.0434339419,
0.0057018744,
-0.0281675663,
-0.0148370834,
0.0126764877,
0.022301279,
-0.0366044194,
-0.0569407307,
0.0096112275,
0.0269186553,
0.0804299116,
-0.0319518708,
0.0254199486,
-0.003237657,
0.0741976798,
-0.0366084203,
0.0192800425,
0.0021485731,
-0.0210174173,
0.0192786958,
-0.0186199788,
0.0571632795,
0.0236636456,
-0.0679065287,
-0.0212443098,
0.0374397673,
0.0336077437,
-0.0812999979,
0.0040080622,
0.0351871885,
-0.0347179845,
-0.0148086138,
0.0863534138,
-0.0091784177,
-0.0781301856,
-0.0545634776,
0.0038281211,
-0.0117056686,
0.0130947391,
-0.0010931317,
-0.0754202232,
-0.0321335159,
-0.0012112523,
0.0080695888,
0.0275857355,
0.0287498273,
-0.0217254926,
-0.0058608986,
-0.0094133597,
0.0533553436,
-0.0626463816,
-0.0145321125,
-0.024757823,
-0.0421720035,
-0.0387436822,
0.0214262158,
-0.0085486118,
0.0130232656,
-0.0456801616,
0.029852448,
0.0178994704,
-0.0375587121,
0.0344344676,
0.0132255992,
0.0386560075,
0.0421762988,
0.0461582616,
-0.001329188,
-0.0449048914,
0.060586758,
-0.0411567986,
-0.0078628575,
-0.0313354433,
-0.0244189687,
0.0182616767,
-0.0130376946,
0.0575200357,
0.0122982087,
-0.0097694639,
0.0264496673,
0.0005259725,
0.0845277905,
-0.0258272011,
0.0294884667,
0.0352235138,
0.036962349,
0.0290438682,
0.0356602818,
0.0171018001,
-0.045070406,
-0.0159865525,
0.0144098699,
-0.0129792057,
-0.0776857063,
-0.0285295453,
-0.0093809702,
0.0250440836,
-0.0503786504,
-0.0106353313,
-0.0175631158,
-0.0331722163,
-0.0005826656,
0.0206686761,
0.0131629212,
-0.0310630724,
0.0005901603,
-0.0394484662,
0.0395381078,
-0.0309426636,
0.0539402366,
-0.0673874989,
0.021418361,
-0.0023740944,
-0.0876124278,
0.0101673324,
0.0435966328,
-0.1164748073,
-0.0611317977,
-0.0174136683,
-0.0098805698,
0.0064368513,
0.0550429113,
-0.0409458503,
-0.0235106796,
0.0181440227,
0.0418250561,
-0.0343622752,
-0.0257210694,
0.045893725,
-0.0112101343,
-0.0330112763,
0.0367023982,
-0.0058434005,
-0.0214448292,
-0.0018957347,
0.020275658,
-0.0123114865,
-0.0247615669,
-0.0217612181,
-0.0271609947,
0.0605228171,
-0.004710821,
0.0257758312,
-0.0188527405,
0.0183977727,
-0.0053108335,
0.036867775,
-0.0103616156,
-0.0291766897,
0.0472931676,
-0.0109490035,
-0.0021570218,
0.01946114,
0.0172167849,
-0.0411459617,
-0.0057833851,
0.0441735201,
0.005302832,
0.0029988862,
0.0130112255,
0.0130407512,
-0.0215615295,
0.0430330113,
0.008654004,
0.0174845383,
-0.0309711006,
0.0612195432,
-0.0306090713,
0.036457628,
-0.0058733542,
0.0010293282,
-0.0235564411,
0.0127665503,
0.0208658371,
0.0033092019,
0.0811749548,
-0.0102073923,
0.0857314765,
0.0050829989,
0.0005479992,
-0.026749108,
0.0252005029,
-0.001385961,
-0.0296901911,
0.0103391483,
-0.01510638,
0.0079412926,
0.0250897091,
0.0394487083,
-0.0278950259,
-0.0276357569,
0.0208216961,
0.0101982318,
-0.0313406438,
-0.0282364581,
0.0056947847,
-0.0338445306,
-0.0504718274,
-0.046265021,
-0.0148146329,
-0.0186831113,
0.0555986762,
-0.0118095893,
0.0056882515,
0.0051552695,
-0.020413395,
0.0447929464,
-0.0247640815,
-0.0299809538,
-0.0259844717,
-0.0035282737,
0.1061519906,
-0.0150539186,
-0.0410629623,
-5.647279838e-33,
0.0016175421,
0.0369814634,
0.0151008442,
-0.0427224673,
-0.0273182113,
0.0355853736,
-0.0282035209,
0.0068447152,
-0.0045790118,
-0.0272074454,
-0.0059640585,
0.0283057895,
0.0426465645,
0.0166776851,
0.0187640544,
0.0133203426,
0.0835900828,
-0.030826848,
-0.0239341035,
0.0616605729,
0.0760104582,
0.0027890825,
0.0665772781,
-0.0783925205,
0.0014244874,
0.0084364479,
0.0246415809,
0.0247812234,
0.0282895751,
0.0128759407,
-0.0011632546,
0.0038928592,
0.0120189032,
-0.0417776853,
-0.0200352725,
0.0031514906,
-0.1022297144,
0.0186772086,
0.0144738844,
0.0472674929,
-0.0336384252,
-0.0563372187,
0.0064162337,
-0.0018426594,
-0.0112960143,
-0.0787748545,
-0.0001258716,
-0.0335071273,
-0.0677810013,
-0.0581306219,
-0.0383568034,
0.0574782863,
-0.0265419055,
-0.0111197252,
0.0701460466,
0.0375240818,
-0.0126961116,
-0.0494125672,
-0.084976919,
0.0237605125,
-0.0552340336,
0.0366662182,
0.0615798607,
0.0318078995,
-0.018716611,
-0.0045353933,
0.0310245361,
-0.0259380657,
0.0482216217,
0.0031251512,
0.0301256776,
-0.0358137898,
-0.0038747611,
0.0282966271,
0.010876921,
-0.0543681979,
-0.0294103641,
0.0168566238,
0.0514552444,
-0.0165366679,
0.0269729607,
0.0081582507,
-0.0091229286,
0.0248806104,
-0.0421953648,
-0.0124533661,
-0.0211861171,
0.0026364035,
-0.0136227338,
0.024679251,
0.0214384459,
-0.0439367332,
0.1024558246,
0.0146270189,
0.0258947555,
0.028847767,
-0.0071180575,
-0.0141504453,
-0.0361061953,
0.0561940596,
-0.0398067869,
-0.0447392985,
0.0276518781,
-0.0093908152,
0.0283105224,
-0.0459096842,
0.0254635867,
0.0449282378,
-0.0390182436,
-0.0058373152,
-0.0114755463,
0.0293679703,
0.0014350268,
0.0242170729,
0.0519015528,
-0.0275503807,
0.0087456545,
0.0412951112,
0.0007462938,
0.0309264734,
-0.0098899771,
-0.005107753,
0.0091672484,
0.0456109792,
-0.0136092799,
0.0285324864,
-0.0280089527,
0.0076058866,
0.0094378376,
-0.0518859401,
-0.0125041921,
0.0193797126,
2.547e-7,
-0.0055500115,
-0.0002877719,
0.0046737632,
-0.0084111858,
0.0361972004,
0.006755258,
-0.0293605868,
0.0001224391,
0.0015044886,
0.0719475374,
0.0478703901,
0.0018660657,
0.1078969538,
0.0596957244,
-0.0432142504,
-0.0385195538,
-0.0563930124,
0.0569350794,
-0.03489713,
-0.0102895321,
0.0128972242,
0.078397207,
-0.0337106697,
0.0097743021,
-0.0053814696,
-0.0421436839,
0.0839414671,
-0.0058304765,
-0.0311456304,
-0.0199553799,
0.0067997985,
-0.0017001294,
-0.0443410836,
-0.006718541,
-0.0398648717,
0.0511946231,
0.0033508961,
0.0528870858,
0.0243471786,
-0.0564016253,
0.0256388485,
0.0031354423,
-0.0505493954,
0.0060511115,
0.0487314463,
-0.0295474008,
-0.0234419052,
-0.00775408,
-0.000910544,
0.041156508,
0.0604059026,
-0.012509387,
-0.0309710037,
0.0107406257,
0.0213297736,
-0.0267111138,
-0.0287356526,
-0.0529493205,
-0.0177846719,
0.0356333219,
-0.0665462613,
-0.0023198791,
-0.0287078042,
0.0128806373,
0.0553368628,
-0.0157211833,
0.0064161457,
2.127678754e-34,
0.0211257245,
-0.0333447717,
0.0251655299,
-0.0606931262,
0.0003833666,
-0.0358618572,
0.0063961968,
-0.0054035843,
0.0121961199,
-0.0402282216,
-0.0325452499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12224v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12224v1 | Towards Answering Health-related Questions from Medical Videos: Datasets and Approaches | 2023-09-21T16:21:28 | 2023-09-21T16:21:28 | Deepak Gupta, Kush Attal, Dina Demner-Fushman | cs.CL | cs.CL | The increase in the availability of online videos has transformed the way we
access information and knowledge. A growing number of individuals now prefer
instructional videos as they offer a series of step-by-step procedures to
accomplish particular tasks. The instructional videos from the medical domain
may provide the best possible visual answers to first aid, medical emergency,
and medical education questions. Toward this, this paper is focused on
answering health-related questions asked by the public by providing visual
answers from medical videos. The scarcity of large-scale datasets in the
medical domain is a key challenge that hinders the development of applications
that can help the public with their health-related questions. To address this
issue, we first proposed a pipelined approach to create two large-scale
datasets: HealthVidQA-CRF and HealthVidQA-Prompt. Later, we proposed monomodal
and multimodal approaches that can effectively provide visual answers from
medical videos to natural language questions. We conducted a comprehensive
analysis of the results, focusing on the impact of the created datasets on
model training and the significance of visual features in enhancing the
performance of the monomodal and multi-modal approaches. Our findings suggest
that these datasets have the potential to enhance the performance of medical
visual answer localization tasks and provide a promising future direction to
further enhance the performance by using pre-trained language-vision models. | [
0.0397917889,
0.043226596,
0.0010718522,
-0.0083136596,
0.0067158961,
0.012217137,
0.0255805161,
0.008467772,
0.0150813544,
-0.0399684161,
-0.0181433707,
-0.0524469577,
-0.0145259257,
0.0367150418,
0.0257567037,
-0.0877803043,
0.0125418864,
0.0250029862,
0.0024947301,
0.0291446839,
0.0314037465,
-0.0047762273,
-0.046483919,
0.0487065241,
-0.0226805769,
-0.0160966106,
0.0017816841,
0.0078150136,
0.064347297,
-0.0886037797,
-0.0039050127,
0.0310340561,
0.0452840403,
-0.0711993948,
0.000001876,
-0.0162793547,
0.0252139736,
0.0172623303,
-0.0157653335,
-0.0308069419,
0.000692423,
-0.0558698922,
0.0391547829,
0.0364327133,
-0.0386414491,
-0.0245171431,
0.0229094233,
0.0003612202,
0.0665656254,
0.0372854099,
-0.0246204082,
-0.0065548318,
0.0010619217,
0.0147385821,
0.0353631377,
-0.0135632763,
-0.0193829332,
0.0399067327,
0.0305971652,
0.005235252,
-0.0445077159,
0.0737606436,
-0.0035381035,
0.0156318247,
0.0002243029,
0.0287756827,
-0.0337167531,
-0.0390214175,
-0.0310647041,
0.1118324995,
-0.0083275782,
0.0205281433,
-0.0189029127,
0.0064251972,
0.0064272755,
0.0423769318,
-0.0653596818,
0.0013662509,
-0.0206574649,
-0.0147309117,
-0.0773408711,
-0.0076086046,
0.0008001302,
-0.0264885537,
0.0408908725,
-0.0487545617,
0.0299785826,
0.0259402189,
-0.0137774562,
-0.0325671434,
-0.0458225608,
-0.0318312794,
0.0358606577,
0.0466304794,
-0.009922049,
0.0142561533,
-0.046690736,
-0.0004902504,
0.0144616552,
-0.0626299903,
0.0712008551,
0.0268437825,
-0.0752187446,
0.0574881472,
-0.0284069646,
0.0165198594,
-0.0483983681,
0.0346419029,
-0.0353578553,
0.0216672551,
-0.0334247015,
0.0060232622,
-0.0405466594,
-0.0231463853,
-0.0334507637,
-0.0059413249,
-0.031063972,
-0.0156438295,
-0.0053059342,
0.0096939448,
-0.0380154364,
0.0700741261,
0.0040588835,
-0.00425355,
-0.0307385698,
0.053849645,
-0.0384996869,
0.0333973616,
-0.0210468657,
-0.0570562445,
0.0194089096,
-0.000045438,
0.0561606698,
-0.0030203182,
0.0456204638,
0.0361181535,
-0.0148605816,
-0.0459263697,
-0.0142144179,
-0.0361419469,
-0.0245420393,
-0.0050336462,
0.0134873865,
-0.0476238579,
0.0401352756,
0.0258350838,
0.0087630181,
0.0047100983,
0.0230881963,
0.0465740189,
-0.024229005,
0.083428897,
-0.003303238,
0.033995837,
0.0394877791,
0.0014875989,
0.0233788304,
0.0061141294,
0.0177737623,
-0.0202529151,
0.0586815998,
-0.0418286584,
0.0380362831,
-0.0005059543,
-0.005276856,
-0.016833486,
-0.0305255782,
0.0422640629,
0.0171200056,
0.0714404136,
-0.0300021674,
0.0391790308,
0.0167751387,
-0.0393823534,
0.0349069759,
0.0567028597,
0.0047652572,
-0.0655417442,
0.0093164835,
0.0052502374,
0.0140330987,
-0.0106602982,
0.0007180058,
0.0381224677,
0.0150353685,
-0.0292460956,
-0.019039575,
0.0171223339,
-0.0674610585,
-0.0293238405,
-0.0717190132,
-0.004978192,
-0.0472408682,
0.0241640117,
0.0602528974,
-0.0018047553,
-0.0648783296,
0.0216096491,
0.0100768944,
-0.0309546199,
0.0044818074,
-0.0235935748,
-0.0043073981,
0.040847484,
0.0002785738,
-0.0392538011,
-0.0540213063,
0.0146913705,
0.0744243339,
-0.0301469546,
0.022746101,
-0.0312403776,
0.0393950231,
-0.0399313122,
-0.0249432568,
0.0146905137,
-0.0173804723,
-0.0246027838,
0.0157064199,
0.0202576704,
-0.0251989178,
-0.0200083125,
0.0095853871,
0.0595992394,
0.0125186136,
0.0151626049,
-0.0121882884,
0.0137288738,
0.0144236404,
0.0246796887,
-0.0024408281,
0.0123703787,
0.0361902937,
-0.015629435,
0.0189917721,
0.0076793572,
-0.0276180822,
-0.0289869774,
0.0271526687,
-0.0800178424,
0.0162423104,
0.0139204497,
-0.0355862975,
-0.0182384141,
-0.0337364823,
-0.0487369597,
-0.0307164527,
-0.0087978654,
-0.0162162818,
0.0721210241,
-0.0101220468,
-0.0250185858,
0.003933446,
-0.0151263261,
0.0357701257,
0.0186564028,
0.012421241,
0.018131176,
-0.0262996498,
-0.0030621714,
-0.0327409208,
-0.0665464401,
0.0023775173,
0.0005572957,
0.0070419628,
-0.0506976098,
0.0122175748,
-0.08402998,
-0.0086552836,
-0.0029212837,
-0.0153258378,
0.0494022928,
0.0112098334,
-0.0189884696,
-0.0810256749,
-0.0397117287,
0.0195160862,
0.0430432595,
0.0098296413,
0.0269178431,
0.0327345431,
0.0320581943,
-0.0303606894,
-0.0074551017,
-0.0152904158,
0.0180263706,
0.0220237039,
0.0044446844,
0.0063736215,
-0.0529274866,
-0.020727532,
0.0340828635,
0.0063136169,
-0.0163177252,
0.0267196279,
-0.0029034407,
-0.0020318599,
0.0430865362,
-0.0156035759,
0.0270747021,
0.0031541062,
0.018855039,
-0.0129388329,
0.0184008423,
-0.0344935656,
-0.0280171074,
-0.0135128936,
-0.0392947868,
-0.0224099848,
0.0117358174,
0.0167221036,
0.0010782499,
-0.0262538157,
0.0006053945,
-0.0028645268,
0.0077061192,
-0.093264088,
0.0265745148,
-0.0253672395,
0.0607763045,
-0.0092517044,
-0.0512806997,
0.0152372662,
-0.006711361,
0.0266302899,
0.0043105944,
-0.0125826048,
-0.0443851389,
0.0433744937,
0.013390868,
0.0365842655,
-0.0160776656,
-0.0184458904,
-0.0540228449,
0.0179979019,
-0.0035529549,
-0.0376349315,
0.0223376919,
-0.0355332494,
-0.0039571738,
-0.018692296,
-0.007281722,
-0.0680295974,
-0.0354486369,
-0.0139714405,
-0.0321126245,
-0.0285754353,
0.032699585,
-0.0325695388,
0.0326252356,
-0.0030765098,
0.068261534,
0.0295934416,
0.0014117585,
-0.0109605473,
0.0855728537,
0.046373006,
0.0612282604,
-0.0286450833,
-0.013623449,
0.0407687053,
0.0663750991,
0.0084820967,
-0.0069785761,
-0.0158768706,
0.0018898675,
0.0069681965,
0.0046353708,
0.013618934,
0.0478627346,
0.0635447875,
-0.0282519665,
-0.0083115138,
0.0720863938,
0.0414404683,
-0.0240168013,
0.0129623841,
0.0211954992,
-0.0423345156,
0.0329888798,
0.0083709806,
-0.0733369887,
-0.0429445058,
-0.0266668182,
0.0154643971,
0.0233226847,
0.0209168829,
0.0065546469,
-0.0338030346,
0.0647931695,
-0.0189462677,
-0.034480162,
-0.0635806918,
-0.0107141845,
0.0125424974,
0.0039526485,
-0.0205112491,
-0.0278022457,
-0.0291476175,
-0.0076046605,
0.0129870521,
-0.0004024089,
-0.0558775812,
0.0131282192,
-0.0288472641,
-0.0150117259,
0.0470467731,
0.0156429689,
-0.0014505303,
-0.0474132225,
0.0214078911,
-0.0038030429,
0.0300877094,
0.0022125607,
0.095354408,
-0.0119118169,
-0.0225206986,
-0.0263563637,
0.0713482648,
-0.0188503899,
-0.0408148952,
0.0205409024,
0.0505165309,
-0.0299065653,
0.01337469,
-0.0976530239,
0.0221037716,
0.0197914727,
0.0169608817,
-0.0188900996,
-0.042677477,
0.0039339922,
0.0408065915,
0.0438999422,
0.003339198,
-0.0465964451,
0.0084549095,
0.0071678404,
0.0160045065,
-0.0489504114,
0.0014107851,
0.1007182822,
0.0349181145,
-0.0036402715,
-0.03423943,
0.0312737748,
0.0586830899,
-0.0633656234,
0.0935411453,
0.0157711618,
0.014466675,
-0.0701254159,
-0.0100432644,
0.0368803665,
-0.0220127981,
-0.0228320975,
0.0045817373,
-0.0299867503,
0.0156413987,
-0.0249118842,
0.0621678904,
0.0078798663,
0.007109527,
0.0002670501,
-0.0092670387,
0.0418177955,
0.0259250849,
-0.0291544721,
-0.0314487852,
-0.0222674701,
-0.0388972647,
-0.0227774102,
-0.0022512604,
-0.0092034135,
0.0067848666,
-0.0201926921,
0.0146556348,
-0.0086932154,
-0.0362769999,
0.0280055534,
-0.0082806265,
0.0671453103,
-0.0059155161,
-0.0064544273,
-0.0268060844,
0.0260265507,
0.0089847688,
0.0199264269,
-0.0460107774,
0.0292968955,
0.0439958461,
-0.0241163895,
-0.0089823036,
0.0112041207,
-0.0243701637,
-0.0384927727,
-0.0531731583,
0.0247502178,
0.050688751,
-0.0212043244,
0.0134941181,
0.0117863845,
0.0216034614,
0.0549318604,
-0.0098511474,
0.0275067613,
0.0425845832,
0.1259593666,
-0.022886781,
-0.0101641836,
-0.0047205817,
0.0480703041,
-0.0268835202,
-0.0338180438,
-0.038549412,
0.0541655608,
0.0424893573,
-0.0158623606,
-0.0416558683,
0.0242823157,
-0.0354360193,
-0.0166338887,
0.0242244639,
-0.01231944,
-0.0318248644,
0.1078571975,
0.0171045419,
0.0081819957,
-0.0129852071,
0.0776301771,
-0.001425576,
0.0297428798,
0.0212616306,
-0.0458790325,
-0.0279873256,
-0.0063893152,
0.0422026254,
0.0350332037,
-0.0498260856,
0.0600640438,
-0.0350704715,
-0.0708354339,
-0.0225945301,
-0.0099325525,
-0.0611947961,
0.0105965342,
0.0783775747,
-0.0000027638,
0.0255135689,
-0.0505592413,
-0.0262361951,
0.054706689,
-0.0702292249,
-0.0160009917,
0.0256321542,
-5.62313849e-33,
-0.017727403,
-0.0498142391,
0.0200274326,
-0.0154874902,
0.0404404849,
0.0212408081,
-0.0136970822,
0.0347629301,
-0.0604624934,
0.0260639619,
0.0243034791,
-0.0091113523,
0.0167660452,
0.0717532188,
0.0007048928,
-0.0559993349,
0.0092408024,
-0.021545032,
-0.0219053291,
0.0122357812,
-0.0109657152,
0.0212408081,
0.0619959012,
-0.089191176,
-0.0277843531,
0.0044211172,
-0.0061481018,
0.0231042653,
-0.0047080512,
0.0496853106,
-0.0426657535,
0.0409147553,
0.0216342229,
-0.0234960429,
-0.0205022637,
0.0371424407,
-0.0710676834,
0.0020562802,
-0.0118033541,
0.0203070734,
-0.1274453998,
0.0080283917,
0.032134112,
-0.0296226535,
0.0015570422,
-0.0478917472,
0.0524052121,
-0.026865283,
0.0033590165,
-0.0143048838,
-0.0307144243,
0.0248740464,
-0.0083769718,
-0.0600815751,
-0.0279944278,
0.0719370916,
0.0135506736,
0.0139206517,
-0.0227493681,
-0.0032746496,
0.0183237921,
0.0222921446,
0.0440274961,
-0.0063634631,
-0.0141339619,
0.0317781419,
0.0137562901,
-0.0776111707,
-0.0196551755,
-0.0197282154,
-0.0434757136,
0.0619706139,
0.0741917565,
0.028546527,
0.0259912405,
0.0213856753,
-0.0750135183,
0.0388450362,
-0.1141203567,
0.0517885014,
0.0073070289,
-0.0494421497,
-0.0026681242,
0.0343613885,
-0.0146718957,
-0.0189143866,
-0.011140015,
-0.0062275394,
0.0646823049,
-0.0034070308,
0.0155152362,
0.021852592,
0.0295038838,
-0.0235199016,
0.0127207078,
0.0117501235,
0.0377750508,
0.0504952222,
-0.0022970631,
0.0360251516,
-0.0652052611,
0.042395141,
0.0396854542,
-0.042547185,
0.0114134531,
-0.0020135287,
0.0037121456,
-0.0010190627,
-0.041486647,
-0.0046152053,
0.0181692895,
-0.0068800305,
-0.0151609099,
0.0694977716,
0.0476679355,
0.0255178027,
-0.0596401989,
0.0611073263,
-0.040156249,
-0.0064652362,
-0.0224138387,
-0.0816059783,
0.0019339876,
0.0096845664,
-0.0297843106,
0.0036530583,
-0.0849626735,
-0.0141143594,
0.0059051113,
-0.0722818002,
-0.0106601203,
0.0388298891,
2.539e-7,
0.0878152624,
0.0061776512,
0.0144691579,
-0.0117349615,
0.0085152145,
0.0214709044,
0.0092313923,
0.031557072,
0.0365982205,
-0.0403094813,
0.030941369,
0.0260193069,
-0.021288218,
0.0164372064,
-0.033364635,
-0.0000955587,
-0.0455029123,
0.0012752928,
-0.0181924049,
-0.0067927702,
0.0703687072,
0.0926104486,
-0.068662867,
-0.035837058,
0.0088839652,
-0.0340428278,
0.0452676751,
-0.011699806,
-0.0052889036,
-0.0072391098,
0.0131556457,
0.0243513286,
-0.0094554275,
0.0086528715,
-0.0288279578,
-0.0416091233,
0.0448088385,
0.0450317562,
-0.0261947308,
-0.0215187054,
-0.0397647433,
0.0656820759,
-0.0000468289,
-0.0237238109,
0.1029702276,
-0.0621822551,
-0.0345202908,
-0.0262239818,
-0.0120716067,
-0.0042763576,
0.0318915173,
0.0021935063,
-0.0148931816,
0.0301178955,
0.04932338,
-0.0090321759,
-0.0535231866,
-0.0779040605,
-0.0481307767,
0.0042965407,
-0.0165186394,
-0.0000223129,
0.0393554568,
-0.0172249824,
-0.0169804841,
-0.0228977185,
-0.0643741637,
1.758589484e-34,
-0.0088262539,
0.0213379171,
0.022097744,
-0.0312914252,
-0.0092347153,
-0.0118686454,
-0.0367557034,
-0.0121286288,
0.0313335136,
-0.0515280627,
-0.0105767138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12161v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12161v2 | Code Soliloquies for Accurate Calculations in Large Language Models | 2023-09-21T15:16:58 | 2023-10-31T20:27:53 | Shashank Sonkar, MyCo Le, Xinghe Chen, Naiming Liu, Debshila Basu Mallick, Richard G. Baraniuk | cs.CL | cs.CL | High-quality conversational datasets are crucial for the successful
development of Intelligent Tutoring Systems (ITS) that utilize a Large Language
Model (LLM) backend. Synthetic student-teacher dialogues, generated using
advanced GPT-4 models, are a common strategy for creating these datasets.
However, subjects like physics that entail complex calculations pose a
challenge. While GPT-4 presents impressive language processing capabilities,
its limitations in fundamental mathematical reasoning curtail its efficacy for
such subjects. To tackle this limitation, we introduce in this paper an
innovative stateful prompt design. Our design orchestrates a mock conversation
where both student and tutorbot roles are simulated by GPT-4. Each student
response triggers an internal monologue, or `code soliloquy' in the
GPT-tutorbot, which assesses whether its subsequent response would necessitate
calculations. If a calculation is deemed necessary, it scripts the relevant
Python code and uses the Python output to construct a response to the student.
Our approach notably enhances the quality of synthetic conversation datasets,
especially for subjects that are calculation-intensive. Our preliminary Subject
Matter Expert evaluations reveal that our Higgs model, a fine-tuned LLaMA
model, effectively uses Python for computations, which significantly enhances
the accuracy and computational reliability of Higgs' responses. Code, models,
and datasets is available at https://github.com/luffycodes/Tutorbot-Spock-Phys. | [
0.0362307094,
0.0519526303,
-0.0129891234,
0.0466468446,
-0.006014057,
-0.0218484569,
0.0601266176,
-0.0002615546,
0.019921802,
-0.0120438943,
-0.0061776219,
-0.0097517585,
-0.0158436969,
0.0637651831,
-0.0023702385,
-0.068471849,
0.0305545591,
-0.0597509481,
0.006261915,
-0.0127187101,
0.006158812,
-0.0112622669,
-0.0371976979,
0.0227611307,
-0.0058122068,
-0.042756848,
-0.0366961621,
-0.022569716,
0.0245548021,
-0.0162122659,
-0.0017452436,
0.0777914971,
-0.0120229041,
0.0565021373,
0.0000020948,
-0.0390632749,
0.0236423761,
0.0362125002,
-0.0359044895,
0.0328639038,
0.0245024469,
0.0295194462,
0.0023767408,
0.0080005731,
-0.0674151555,
0.0607245266,
0.063005358,
-0.0431910753,
0.0966270864,
0.0561283417,
0.0175541788,
-0.0018875371,
0.0270589143,
0.0039448426,
0.0557798743,
-0.0557595342,
0.011497193,
0.0418191329,
0.0383484289,
0.0309482981,
-0.0249747541,
0.0284003355,
0.071548067,
-0.0743412301,
0.020999182,
0.0274065416,
-0.0206622239,
0.0270645488,
-0.0355542228,
0.0653993562,
0.0402800143,
-0.050223358,
-0.0159473438,
-0.0081554903,
0.0110432245,
0.0163114481,
-0.0774833113,
0.0077789356,
0.0076453025,
-0.0158046111,
0.0059552942,
-0.0327997655,
-0.0270821191,
0.0134890955,
-0.0011692141,
0.092624329,
0.032133393,
0.0019650753,
-0.0658960938,
0.0235199742,
0.0118368631,
-0.0664321333,
0.0300034415,
0.0518862642,
-0.0363698564,
0.0045014154,
-0.0315918177,
-0.0380671732,
0.0059992922,
0.0045126923,
0.0223923158,
0.0902156532,
0.0163084082,
0.0300315209,
0.0363085456,
0.0521346815,
-0.0072316979,
0.0021918258,
0.0026455477,
0.041863963,
-0.0502349213,
-0.0169170331,
-0.0339550748,
0.0079426095,
-0.0212414805,
-0.0150739579,
-0.0301324707,
0.0309259351,
-0.0209331345,
0.0131489038,
-0.0194779336,
-0.0057116193,
-0.0367166363,
-0.0018586685,
-0.0328525975,
0.0487001128,
-0.0070291846,
-0.0368520916,
0.0560283102,
-0.0844391212,
-0.0457367562,
-0.0037048857,
-0.0310222246,
0.0093645584,
-0.0084844921,
0.044132188,
0.0231399331,
0.0050742798,
0.0513217114,
-0.0470042303,
-0.0077821263,
-0.0618687756,
0.0245320201,
-0.0669368729,
0.0244104639,
0.0267842859,
-0.0115601467,
-0.0482790358,
0.0343784839,
0.0044856644,
0.0225749668,
0.0656758472,
0.0056318911,
-0.0091651101,
0.0317524932,
0.022175137,
-0.0316517241,
0.0220888481,
0.0095664794,
-0.0206346326,
0.0083272336,
-0.0335920267,
0.0607493743,
0.0275011975,
0.0270009879,
0.0147029283,
-0.0192296878,
-0.0079158675,
0.0061308863,
0.024479486,
-0.0263609551,
0.0221293289,
-0.022695547,
0.0320281014,
0.0166987441,
0.0355668627,
-0.0681693926,
0.0350018106,
0.0289669167,
0.0226040203,
0.0467572957,
-0.0011382533,
-0.0358215049,
0.0790658295,
-0.05812658,
-0.0184464268,
0.0529787391,
0.0092444811,
-0.0039639398,
-0.0381660573,
0.0216496084,
0.0186344553,
0.0081164781,
0.0286861714,
0.0603967346,
-0.009742423,
-0.0199832283,
0.023191005,
0.0257701818,
-0.0838626623,
-0.035229411,
-0.0573149584,
0.0532467291,
0.0709145963,
0.0498803295,
-0.0269345716,
-0.0388994552,
0.011827453,
0.0228841845,
0.0613098703,
0.073741965,
0.0190588832,
-0.0205501635,
-0.0168589726,
-0.0116342409,
-0.0470230877,
0.0150943073,
0.0007780603,
0.0249520428,
-0.0148261823,
0.0199817568,
0.0512179956,
0.0009138558,
0.0133999027,
-0.0416492335,
-0.0372711383,
-0.027047338,
-0.0422634631,
0.0326538607,
0.0123217395,
0.011148111,
0.0438716076,
0.0221884418,
0.0047207549,
0.012349491,
-0.0308580101,
-0.0173972845,
-0.0123575516,
0.080678001,
-0.0375729464,
-0.0203875452,
0.0143757779,
-0.0195794739,
-0.0303576682,
0.0558997504,
-0.0155802006,
-0.0018900123,
-0.0147989122,
-0.013021322,
-0.0380234942,
0.0071607996,
-0.010767526,
0.002021668,
0.0529478826,
0.041936297,
0.0345883369,
0.0347068757,
0.0170824919,
-0.0604024641,
-0.033979889,
0.0251939539,
0.0078487853,
0.006156648,
0.0048395987,
-0.0007119442,
-0.0394610129,
-0.0004410453,
-0.0556849055,
-0.0209254045,
-0.0194589794,
-0.0125847654,
0.0417528041,
-0.0151405279,
-0.0290128756,
-0.0076892893,
-0.0008296304,
0.0023192547,
0.006846949,
-0.0076431287,
0.0085369414,
0.0196114052,
-0.0376382805,
-0.0518416502,
-0.0221406296,
-0.0589749515,
0.0233298857,
0.0575502552,
0.0615455508,
-0.0490657166,
0.0355454423,
-0.0162407532,
-0.0017733399,
-0.0047021224,
-0.0428725407,
0.0586771742,
-0.0673230141,
0.035502594,
0.0198928043,
-0.0327089392,
0.0199607089,
0.0505245551,
-0.0626043305,
-0.0701276213,
0.0126847764,
-0.0250117369,
-0.0255315769,
0.0129450047,
-0.0206614509,
-0.0199804585,
0.0441126525,
-0.0027862329,
-0.0232200809,
-0.0408231094,
0.0672488809,
0.019855734,
0.0013103003,
0.0172811467,
0.0112110795,
-0.0130329961,
0.032729391,
0.0382395498,
-0.0395984352,
0.0707981139,
-0.0228620693,
-0.034635026,
-0.0406362191,
-0.0109942807,
-0.0210088175,
0.0469834059,
-0.0156711806,
-0.0128948074,
-0.0438620336,
0.010974451,
0.0134926746,
0.0268435217,
0.0183714442,
-0.0250284597,
-0.0070380927,
-0.0433347225,
-0.0117793763,
-0.0015369073,
-0.0007570339,
-0.0266812146,
0.027294565,
-0.0533009917,
0.0053740446,
-0.0021543177,
-0.080231972,
0.0109083792,
-0.0330017731,
0.036506407,
0.053815484,
-0.053729102,
-0.0134375896,
-0.041236829,
-0.0373827107,
0.0206865147,
-0.0001333292,
-0.0080947615,
-0.0337436348,
0.0746816769,
0.0452574305,
0.0310692843,
0.0234307125,
-0.0491361991,
-0.0387872942,
0.0187501423,
0.0152664678,
0.0150703089,
0.0593573265,
0.0260523297,
-0.0623717308,
-0.0237475708,
0.0717224628,
0.015007589,
-0.032817591,
0.0043006972,
-0.0581634119,
0.0058079087,
0.0210353639,
0.0432124883,
-0.0828103721,
-0.0073150089,
0.005414709,
0.0084016724,
-0.0094682369,
-0.0408437066,
-0.0108639561,
-0.0661141649,
0.0291392729,
0.0244501494,
-0.0105720554,
-0.0283347648,
-0.0410841703,
-0.0051896246,
0.0045729829,
-0.0174936615,
0.0363493264,
0.0163978133,
0.0386786982,
-0.0111422157,
-0.0075227288,
-0.0273699295,
0.022242533,
0.040271651,
0.0264962539,
0.032496158,
0.0184191335,
-0.0268741772,
-0.0366298556,
0.0172472857,
0.0451157391,
-0.0327341482,
-0.0024708065,
-0.0008956751,
0.038263198,
-0.017483281,
-0.0149122542,
0.0623436421,
-0.0546615645,
-0.0243434906,
0.0233056862,
0.0774367303,
-0.0594289377,
-0.0001912985,
-0.0451006405,
0.0010758867,
0.0287812743,
0.0570192598,
0.0255987905,
-0.018558884,
-0.0583544075,
-0.0667440146,
0.0026051039,
-0.0266083051,
-0.0251375828,
-0.0367980301,
0.0689065456,
0.0089593185,
-0.0257823206,
-0.0008083897,
0.0662489384,
-0.0148865785,
0.0028276818,
-0.0282295458,
0.004490172,
0.0102125611,
-0.0156755298,
0.0345645323,
-0.0291086771,
0.0432258025,
-0.0571522787,
-0.049768772,
0.0321353674,
-0.0527021289,
-0.025433654,
0.0482864156,
-0.0563874356,
-0.0804096088,
-0.023633549,
0.0410509445,
0.033554595,
-0.0020156719,
-0.0020793853,
0.0002195537,
-0.0181036871,
0.0399391688,
-0.0368494466,
-0.0078851394,
0.0036444576,
0.0310147572,
0.0225033294,
-0.0270722024,
-0.0014647208,
-0.0227469448,
-0.0150026903,
0.0275857225,
-0.0501310825,
-0.0696764216,
0.0343507454,
0.0761124715,
0.0390718207,
0.0110346535,
-0.0239493567,
-0.0134608215,
0.0017498778,
-0.0651670769,
0.0089415042,
-0.0763888657,
-0.0208533984,
0.0039281501,
-0.0322532281,
0.0537984706,
-0.0343876556,
-0.0254320856,
0.0366455987,
0.0106847929,
0.0606917664,
-0.0175218321,
0.0167272054,
0.0756702721,
-0.0246582292,
0.0027358991,
-0.0259654652,
0.002620521,
0.0490739048,
-0.0053728116,
0.0554297753,
0.0477040596,
-0.0121004023,
0.0096788602,
0.015653329,
-0.1006930545,
-0.1110106111,
-0.0162142236,
0.0410990827,
-0.0084885759,
0.0733141005,
-0.0026284889,
-0.08926972,
-0.0149729233,
-0.0224362984,
0.0605571419,
0.0390708186,
-0.0383722112,
0.0456055701,
0.0248841047,
0.0288215242,
-0.0258778557,
0.0249857046,
-0.0275534131,
0.0391197465,
0.028652586,
-0.0034778041,
-0.0464208871,
-0.0264958981,
-0.0196300428,
0.0224929396,
0.0311676003,
-0.0203850269,
-0.0443892665,
-0.0415894911,
-0.0368705839,
0.034620937,
-0.0487934016,
-0.05627314,
0.0903330445,
0.0392699689,
-0.0497882515,
-0.0131674316,
0.0037915984,
0.0521630757,
-0.0167252645,
-0.0367853977,
-0.0322801396,
-5.738416283e-33,
-0.0468311496,
-0.044265762,
0.0271836929,
0.0960125104,
-0.0055386019,
-0.0269116033,
-0.0497567169,
0.0113989711,
-0.0145870363,
0.0049426337,
-0.0209227204,
0.0354939438,
0.0070396923,
-0.0079410197,
0.0201557651,
-0.0107049346,
0.0620089993,
0.0061800694,
-0.0311303306,
0.077896893,
0.0256280974,
-0.0003570533,
0.0618977137,
-0.0520921908,
0.0427607186,
-0.0224146191,
-0.0089443577,
-0.0005635506,
-0.085160397,
0.0298131183,
-0.0523127392,
0.0656885728,
-0.042454239,
-0.0278680753,
-0.0159368813,
0.0314466357,
0.0167720504,
-0.0524262302,
-0.0106277196,
-0.0133071188,
-0.0237974823,
-0.0606610253,
0.0053445008,
-0.0107817361,
-0.0340238512,
-0.0336528495,
0.0145020941,
-0.0184039045,
0.0168925896,
0.0225409158,
-0.0462454893,
0.0103182988,
-0.0363380387,
-0.0284665767,
0.0210435856,
0.0031440577,
-0.0297712199,
0.001940779,
0.0031893777,
0.0613588542,
0.0697113276,
0.0155893732,
0.0515939966,
-0.0427487604,
0.0172395613,
0.0371313691,
0.0632401258,
0.0035628907,
-0.0258695036,
-0.0040311287,
0.0043940465,
0.0257383045,
0.0650546551,
0.0157776102,
0.0486715548,
0.0032696635,
-0.0513990819,
-0.0021687243,
0.0668579489,
0.0242530648,
0.0010620771,
-0.0178339034,
-0.0424064882,
-0.0155809084,
-0.0251096543,
-0.0085816672,
-0.0092411591,
-0.0451164544,
-0.0182193238,
-0.0526813194,
-0.0102757243,
0.0013251635,
0.0274696834,
-0.0389044173,
-0.001379637,
0.0345662385,
-0.0033707032,
0.0353065841,
0.0117995087,
-0.0025236441,
-0.011068048,
0.0010753619,
0.0111705232,
-0.0358252823,
0.0382903665,
0.0256009977,
-0.0405728109,
0.0536514036,
-0.0265751071,
-0.0001603242,
-0.0454251729,
-0.0040604882,
0.0302320924,
0.0104816519,
0.0020871998,
0.013969087,
-0.0123421494,
0.0442818552,
-0.0199523028,
0.0055883159,
-0.0374681428,
0.0349601693,
-0.0109097455,
-0.007492586,
-0.0308757927,
-0.0500987694,
-0.045232527,
-0.0192328859,
0.0454914235,
-0.0543380491,
-0.0233810358,
-0.001785278,
2.821e-7,
0.0156341065,
0.0650827661,
0.0143863792,
-0.003163547,
0.0257563498,
0.026921967,
-0.0257868227,
-0.0029971106,
0.0444853976,
-0.0312547907,
-0.0259346738,
0.0027198407,
0.0496084653,
0.0370356552,
-0.0603315905,
-0.0162688941,
-0.0255860947,
-0.0513484143,
-0.0586925149,
0.0135327382,
0.0603664033,
0.0095597254,
0.0581059195,
0.0187566597,
0.0173442457,
-0.012041023,
0.0294325091,
-0.0010745503,
0.0300836898,
0.0618310496,
-0.0327537358,
-0.0261128973,
0.0141616222,
0.0180383399,
0.0133559098,
-0.0027832135,
-0.004676458,
0.0575102456,
0.0251074266,
0.0065954034,
-0.0164023973,
-0.0099275811,
-0.0039141686,
-0.0532316826,
0.0106177498,
-0.0239124596,
0.0044973698,
-0.0004094738,
-0.0243967734,
-0.0634860918,
0.0112498319,
-0.0238910541,
0.0276242457,
-0.0158525389,
-0.0373099148,
0.0014665703,
0.017677715,
-0.0050787111,
-0.0419653431,
-0.0400314815,
-0.101296179,
-0.0760876909,
-0.0352734886,
-0.0253893305,
0.013562873,
-0.0303710122,
0.0143939359,
2.972420678e-34,
0.0354831256,
-0.0056772553,
0.0495741218,
0.0587218031,
0.0040071444,
0.0314495675,
0.0039027827,
0.0174259171,
0.0484921448,
-0.0637481362,
-0.0636284649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12137v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12137v1 | OSN-MDAD: Machine Translation Dataset for Arabic Multi-Dialectal Conversations on Online Social Media | 2023-09-21T14:58:50 | 2023-09-21T14:58:50 | Fatimah Alzamzami, Abdulmotaleb El Saddik | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While resources for English language are fairly sufficient to understand
content on social media, similar resources in Arabic are still immature. The
main reason that the resources in Arabic are insufficient is that Arabic has
many dialects in addition to the standard version (MSA). Arabs do not use MSA
in their daily communications; rather, they use dialectal versions.
Unfortunately, social users transfer this phenomenon into their use of social
media platforms, which in turn has raised an urgent need for building suitable
AI models for language-dependent applications. Existing machine translation
(MT) systems designed for MSA fail to work well with Arabic dialects. In light
of this, it is necessary to adapt to the informal nature of communication on
social networks by developing MT systems that can effectively handle the
various dialects of Arabic. Unlike for MSA that shows advanced progress in MT
systems, little effort has been exerted to utilize Arabic dialects for MT
systems. While few attempts have been made to build translation datasets for
dialectal Arabic, they are domain dependent and are not OSN cultural-language
friendly. In this work, we attempt to alleviate these limitations by proposing
an online social network-based multidialect Arabic dataset that is crafted by
contextually translating English tweets into four Arabic dialects: Gulf,
Yemeni, Iraqi, and Levantine. To perform the translation, we followed our
proposed guideline framework for content translation, which could be
universally applicable for translation between foreign languages and local
dialects. We validated the authenticity of our proposed dataset by developing
neural MT models for four Arabic dialects. Our results have shown a superior
performance of our NMT models trained using our dataset. We believe that our
dataset can reliably serve as an Arabic multidialectal translation dataset for
informal MT tasks. | [
0.0562366359,
0.052243486,
-0.0055527133,
0.0045701098,
-0.0466721281,
0.021199761,
0.0703983828,
-0.0098793441,
-0.0405673385,
-0.0177948419,
-0.0319236703,
-0.1050149202,
0.0546021238,
-0.0058147302,
0.0323271789,
-0.0199659467,
-0.0131591521,
-0.0237191543,
-0.0203233287,
-0.0147971883,
0.0182750039,
0.0576336794,
-0.0006519385,
0.0053783683,
-0.0113773104,
-0.025233373,
-0.014199282,
0.0482455604,
0.0221910179,
0.0472474992,
0.0015217252,
0.0494481586,
0.0180362333,
0.074542895,
0.0000019378,
-0.0257606581,
-0.0216781534,
-0.0383331142,
0.0101766353,
0.003725698,
0.0929847509,
-0.0876498222,
-0.0178924501,
0.0436906442,
-0.0299855955,
0.0159015283,
0.06232531,
0.0158563573,
0.0606376976,
0.0662239641,
-0.0202262029,
-0.0225957464,
0.0118736494,
-0.0389446057,
-0.0192316584,
-0.0330482945,
-0.0296657104,
-0.0002238004,
-0.0359165408,
0.0324270353,
0.0064018928,
0.0468150377,
-0.0095145004,
-0.0144665521,
-0.0422702879,
-0.0411426499,
-0.0178860165,
-0.0517966487,
0.0069445064,
0.0823485777,
-0.0082548456,
-0.0081706839,
0.0051855198,
0.0070546311,
-0.0009645461,
0.0110692373,
-0.0292883776,
0.0415484197,
-0.0317997746,
0.0016164557,
-0.0010757907,
0.0416710675,
0.0109480936,
0.0009164406,
-0.0329079889,
0.0160009302,
0.0104027409,
-0.0111575397,
0.0000799099,
0.0186793655,
0.0061799968,
0.0092008086,
0.0770003796,
-0.0322899334,
-0.0010666284,
0.013404252,
-0.015429439,
-0.0273335762,
0.017288873,
-0.0945382938,
0.019103121,
0.0675465837,
0.0077829063,
0.0246595684,
-0.0173188932,
-0.0191051383,
-0.0129303373,
0.0281067695,
-0.0513500907,
-0.0362606645,
-0.071655713,
0.0405370891,
-0.0161661264,
0.0232238974,
-0.046725411,
0.0129510062,
-0.0479418077,
0.0190034956,
0.0035935065,
0.0195954107,
0.0262351222,
-0.0152219636,
-0.0424277633,
-0.0393055379,
0.0083619813,
0.041651912,
0.0046239714,
0.0004977168,
-0.0309914071,
-0.0869801417,
-0.0009675708,
0.0007316462,
0.0370363444,
-0.0002766442,
-0.0411208272,
0.0476811901,
-0.0334007032,
-0.0539234653,
-0.0676342845,
0.0130907111,
-0.0132479602,
-0.0030854153,
-0.0133471023,
-0.0705731809,
0.0960172713,
0.0102571109,
-0.0071214782,
-0.0078647248,
-0.0163653847,
0.0264312718,
0.0301233996,
0.0474116728,
0.0194511004,
0.0360151269,
0.0912545696,
0.0118808523,
0.0394492969,
0.0772033036,
0.0216192976,
0.0290492214,
0.0290493667,
0.0081877466,
-0.0380882733,
0.0472913049,
0.0191799719,
0.0364193469,
-0.0550396554,
-0.0401903912,
-0.0252148937,
0.0691397712,
-0.0286589749,
0.0610730872,
-0.0284062624,
0.0077714887,
0.0698657557,
0.0049963179,
-0.0166275706,
0.0568416677,
0.0289124697,
0.061958544,
0.0259494148,
-0.0265370496,
0.0094783008,
0.0108572803,
0.0003566369,
-0.0268475283,
0.0341178887,
0.0773854554,
-0.0395142734,
-0.0490908772,
0.0117922863,
-0.0520756096,
0.0438528396,
-0.0178619344,
0.0705510303,
-0.0189440027,
-0.0269741118,
0.035374701,
0.0040049315,
-0.0225075446,
0.003484125,
-0.032521069,
-0.0661432147,
0.0509265997,
0.0159494989,
0.0110298861,
-0.0458233021,
-0.0623687916,
0.0441186428,
0.0425536521,
0.0684080422,
-0.0005043534,
0.0252906028,
-0.0598607101,
0.0021909499,
0.0176007207,
-0.0010781199,
-0.0069018146,
0.046057336,
0.0547134355,
0.0152214048,
-0.0237194505,
-0.0312388074,
0.0073164315,
-0.0136504574,
0.0367080905,
0.031990435,
0.017693704,
0.0051745465,
0.0775353983,
-0.0047031343,
-0.0349773243,
-0.0103607969,
-0.0237046387,
-0.0388487875,
0.0149741918,
-0.0485474318,
0.0048107072,
0.0483266413,
-0.012642609,
0.0021312588,
0.0148557536,
-0.0440644175,
-0.0778743252,
0.0826106444,
-0.0370075703,
0.0279270634,
-0.0153608955,
0.0303700566,
-0.0126583055,
0.0284740031,
0.0186428651,
0.0395605862,
-0.0428758413,
-0.0559270233,
-0.0032590115,
-0.0305187367,
0.0411606245,
0.0052246451,
0.016186744,
0.0209241547,
0.0035327771,
0.037655171,
0.0362449475,
0.0069441926,
-0.0225026868,
-0.0502886996,
-0.0908432528,
-0.0147421658,
-0.0424855947,
0.0387779437,
0.0062611676,
0.0831998736,
-0.0050732843,
-0.0067821606,
0.000203697,
0.0123303887,
-0.0025246022,
0.0172084104,
0.0147428298,
-0.0308922529,
0.040167395,
-0.033059597,
-0.0343276896,
0.0221265256,
0.0483687557,
0.0074266545,
-0.063922219,
0.0167369116,
-0.0383682139,
-0.0366449729,
0.0074446267,
-0.005518829,
-0.0422075838,
0.0375486873,
-0.0285856836,
0.0264873523,
0.0251909997,
0.0095790317,
0.0313622579,
-0.0202834606,
-0.0027420139,
-0.0659114495,
-0.0029734196,
-0.0055090045,
-0.0503656901,
-0.044266589,
-0.0734592527,
-0.0466528311,
0.0115705151,
0.0069587445,
0.022135349,
-0.0624248236,
0.0033199668,
0.0179518797,
0.0080758957,
0.0200499222,
0.0509481467,
0.015752824,
0.061143212,
-0.0263473857,
-0.0352241658,
0.0192061905,
-0.0023621486,
0.0077479975,
0.0215718336,
-0.0109300707,
-0.0487702303,
0.0149892867,
-0.0277452338,
0.0264669824,
-0.023681052,
-0.0516811013,
-0.0026518379,
-0.0019252225,
0.0152705219,
-0.0208789948,
0.0104948292,
-0.0465754047,
-0.0137710311,
-0.0136202574,
0.0037194269,
0.0230593607,
0.0026878554,
-0.0440517105,
-0.0077522113,
0.0033681619,
-0.0480937213,
-0.0293273088,
-0.0007724662,
0.0141190644,
0.0535603315,
-0.0185332205,
0.0107325148,
-0.0215876158,
-0.0020347959,
0.0320141651,
0.0104913693,
-0.0006061697,
-0.0075738663,
0.0321009196,
0.0155334994,
-0.0313002281,
-0.0534282997,
-0.0526864305,
-0.0533881858,
0.0280029476,
-0.0165157225,
-0.03456074,
-0.0412005931,
0.0314833708,
-0.0016867337,
0.0157444738,
0.1039484665,
0.0294489656,
-0.0509809665,
-0.011564143,
-0.0197134651,
-0.008716506,
-0.0048483787,
0.0020778468,
-0.1297516227,
-0.0059046717,
0.0017873183,
0.0305687152,
0.0400819853,
0.0165359508,
0.0009898413,
-0.0634078681,
-0.0049772668,
0.0198002663,
-0.0392400026,
-0.0381451286,
0.0066914577,
-0.0363705009,
-0.0468947552,
0.0066794748,
-0.0721634254,
0.0238818713,
-0.02013967,
0.0285698138,
0.0555384867,
-0.0906950757,
0.0276095197,
-0.0289202705,
0.0516864546,
-0.0108355638,
0.0420220308,
-0.0133266496,
-0.0368983932,
0.0274920855,
-0.0096160518,
-0.0214345604,
-0.0019959828,
0.0001057342,
-0.0018332688,
0.0067688632,
-0.0086324709,
-0.0188688356,
-0.0737212449,
0.0237149354,
-0.0287554301,
0.0162107814,
-0.0357452892,
0.0198769812,
0.0157093406,
-0.0007448357,
-0.001900972,
0.0195255764,
-0.019232383,
-0.0479275286,
-0.0278020892,
-0.0157481954,
-0.0312542506,
-0.059406627,
-0.0013001806,
-0.026460832,
0.0289937146,
-0.016779419,
-0.0804156736,
-0.0367538445,
0.0091574723,
0.0222832672,
0.0042256038,
-0.0074007493,
0.0644612685,
-0.0012487646,
-0.017920075,
0.0079881707,
-0.0228839051,
0.005450407,
-0.0243917294,
-0.0076599116,
0.0414258726,
-0.0969101042,
0.0621037669,
-0.0252852123,
-0.0934676975,
-0.0513002016,
-0.0197971947,
-0.003269688,
0.0193559378,
0.015906645,
-0.0543165803,
-0.0503564999,
-0.0082659749,
-0.013637607,
0.0223120321,
-0.0258604735,
0.0351678878,
0.0417610817,
-0.014159753,
0.0595373213,
0.0247011315,
0.008302141,
-0.0134915328,
-0.0103185968,
-0.0349417031,
-0.0678978488,
0.0102732424,
-0.0326302201,
0.0107010603,
-0.0043117059,
-0.0739418343,
-0.0555374473,
-0.0079388013,
-0.0156844221,
0.0197438952,
-0.041139435,
0.0181295238,
0.0467898287,
0.0262693018,
-0.00346556,
-0.0332266465,
-0.0229488388,
-0.0179680642,
0.0175507814,
0.0114254151,
-0.0486128181,
0.0222409591,
-0.0226748642,
0.0236897133,
0.003679398,
0.0059444029,
-0.043921914,
0.0188872255,
-0.0456821844,
0.0224643834,
-0.0293951929,
0.0108944094,
0.042133294,
0.0736471936,
-0.0022285532,
-0.0022367828,
-0.0339293517,
0.0533319041,
0.0657002479,
-0.0212794952,
0.0981505737,
0.0293109193,
0.0180030446,
0.0096231475,
0.0488556102,
-0.0092925485,
-0.0364094116,
-0.0136115402,
-0.0220444296,
0.0008419236,
0.0730202198,
0.0592165366,
-0.0172396712,
-0.0255900398,
0.0217574593,
-0.0164261255,
0.0198850017,
-0.0125148306,
0.0054484401,
0.027846517,
-0.0354320258,
-0.0020602481,
-0.0139412638,
-0.0748807564,
0.0219528135,
-0.021005936,
0.00571936,
0.0107724722,
0.0137855113,
0.1000526249,
-0.0130258473,
0.0134314476,
-0.0723856986,
-0.0142359259,
0.0163849629,
-0.0549054444,
-0.016965609,
-6.318437889e-33,
0.0374030061,
-0.0148200374,
0.002860317,
-0.0087999543,
-0.0197291691,
-0.0369227938,
-0.0297619551,
-0.0056411913,
-0.0195824485,
-0.0191943347,
-0.0464271456,
0.0660517141,
0.0304926392,
0.0156611372,
0.0412579849,
-0.0079972064,
0.0263458192,
-0.0387782417,
-0.0156661198,
0.0564156398,
0.0362885334,
0.015123439,
0.1111850813,
-0.0804183856,
0.0233119559,
-0.0100066597,
-0.0302356705,
0.017195629,
0.0172335263,
0.0506671816,
0.0068323156,
0.033563856,
0.0255954564,
-0.0102962377,
0.0185953304,
0.0125072375,
-0.0427622013,
0.0080196457,
-0.0078896796,
0.0541505255,
-0.0137913302,
-0.0489281155,
0.0200002082,
-0.0380949005,
-0.0090072798,
0.0348623432,
-0.0042167506,
-0.0221174881,
0.0223638844,
-0.0031865472,
-0.0737056732,
0.0496650077,
-0.0048921653,
-0.0049445638,
0.0319773331,
0.0769874156,
-0.0011355176,
0.0007193945,
-0.0736309066,
0.0350122526,
-0.0261195935,
-0.0033527494,
0.0666917861,
0.0026580556,
-0.067467764,
-0.0220989455,
0.0020403126,
0.0094224084,
0.0536012128,
0.0151467295,
-0.0086288769,
-0.0302278809,
0.0253324341,
0.0672250465,
0.0011592079,
-0.0381423309,
-0.0321175642,
0.0304538142,
-0.0080129877,
0.0020999652,
0.0117816217,
-0.0182270277,
-0.0250134766,
0.0081188735,
-0.0119466027,
-0.0503692441,
-0.0197037905,
-0.0169728342,
-0.0201999322,
0.0033389903,
0.0076189656,
0.043854326,
0.0379124992,
-0.0143089117,
0.0346483886,
-0.0157682523,
-0.0156587977,
0.0223161485,
-0.0138147194,
0.0601762757,
-0.0145110739,
-0.0489644893,
0.0180552844,
0.0292960256,
0.0038810519,
-0.0001692582,
0.0309653115,
0.0535412319,
-0.0450892299,
0.0136029469,
-0.0385148562,
0.0172744934,
-0.0468079001,
0.0434548333,
0.0064892615,
-0.010210311,
-0.0203881152,
0.0437212065,
0.0492179617,
0.0074447659,
-0.0208958089,
-0.0425567701,
0.0026987926,
-0.0163376033,
-0.0270230193,
0.0411677845,
-0.0395507067,
-0.0127966776,
0.0144939618,
-0.0324348845,
-0.0235192198,
-0.0030994778,
2.827e-7,
0.0176740028,
0.059880849,
-0.0140999341,
0.0020314774,
0.0375757478,
0.0180761367,
0.0161638595,
0.0271839164,
-0.0213025343,
0.0207259059,
0.0333480462,
0.0346651189,
0.0871385336,
0.0100324582,
-0.0768023878,
-0.0245370101,
-0.0446506962,
0.0286995918,
-0.0443335921,
0.0044656033,
0.0453060083,
0.1390700042,
-0.0337577574,
-0.0106713846,
-0.0682368428,
-0.0229685325,
0.0722992718,
-0.0180068649,
-0.0343055502,
0.0231420062,
0.0825266168,
-0.0176515952,
-0.0173829291,
-0.0394316427,
-0.0262897611,
0.0001654971,
0.0522103459,
0.0955225453,
0.0274572261,
-0.0181490537,
0.0053628315,
-0.0448065698,
-0.0080525512,
-0.014089006,
0.0518350787,
-0.0092360023,
-0.0339038074,
0.0093593858,
0.0280892532,
0.0495921895,
0.0506068096,
-0.0503839552,
0.0085555827,
0.0119854156,
0.0586471073,
-0.0120929638,
-0.0095661804,
-0.0191277899,
0.0215553064,
-0.0062816171,
0.0056945281,
-0.0010855867,
-0.0004855971,
-0.0192002859,
0.0036347751,
0.0078843627,
0.0240512285,
2.074909389e-34,
0.0390408076,
0.002389845,
-0.0012697673,
-0.0265512466,
0.0220558923,
-0.0161487292,
-0.0603689551,
-0.0000872077,
0.0001510177,
-0.0118170641,
-0.0210636426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12117v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12117v1 | How-to Guides for Specific Audiences: A Corpus and Initial Findings | 2023-09-21T14:35:42 | 2023-09-21T14:35:42 | Nicola Fanton, Agnieszka Falenska, Michael Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instructional texts for specific target groups should ideally take into
account the prior knowledge and needs of the readers in order to guide them
efficiently to their desired goals. However, targeting specific groups also
carries the risk of reflecting disparate social norms and subtle stereotypes.
In this paper, we investigate the extent to which how-to guides from one
particular platform, wikiHow, differ in practice depending on the intended
audience. We conduct two case studies in which we examine qualitative features
of texts written for specific audiences. In a generalization study, we
investigate which differences can also be systematically demonstrated using
computational methods. The results of our studies show that guides from
wikiHow, like other text genres, are subject to subtle biases. We aim to raise
awareness of these inequalities as a first step to addressing them in future
work. | [
0.0656511635,
-0.0183571652,
-0.0393797308,
0.0313415676,
-0.0303191636,
0.0347773843,
0.0232410841,
0.0036466972,
0.0448898152,
-0.0500379391,
-0.0149573591,
0.0020650888,
0.0757933632,
-0.0042865542,
-0.0008689532,
-0.0787737146,
-0.0071826652,
0.0226420891,
0.0094757751,
-0.0163799096,
0.0249233525,
0.0491104983,
-0.0487842523,
0.0420289077,
0.0460996665,
-0.065202266,
0.0248068422,
0.0264389832,
-0.0070636682,
-0.0234745573,
0.089766033,
0.0150744384,
0.0023719568,
-0.0128803169,
0.0000022213,
-0.0340164304,
0.01135296,
-0.0138758058,
-0.0083909407,
0.0538023785,
0.0367143676,
0.0245125517,
-0.0105660856,
-0.0151479719,
-0.0074205594,
0.0438312404,
0.0157958381,
0.0215931684,
0.0389078371,
0.0320444405,
0.0151607934,
-0.0439297408,
-0.0132500427,
0.0399386436,
0.0544995852,
-0.0075309025,
-0.0382934958,
-0.0028263349,
0.0312305428,
-0.0324693918,
-0.0178551916,
0.0353980437,
-0.0067190365,
0.0193992201,
0.0121425819,
-0.0004035841,
0.0052835713,
-0.0341026485,
-0.0143553289,
0.018448839,
0.0712419078,
-0.0011455886,
-0.0057390118,
-0.0047524301,
0.0141170919,
0.0699262545,
-0.0360972583,
0.0260819327,
-0.0372152403,
-0.0127757499,
-0.043634478,
-0.0067461231,
0.000670651,
0.0248502884,
0.080799222,
0.0764082074,
-0.0092198541,
0.000927772,
-0.0103602447,
0.021777194,
0.0378702581,
-0.0443155989,
0.0314310603,
0.0400709584,
0.0356943011,
0.0039431602,
0.0127022658,
0.0256328192,
0.0339453518,
-0.0649530143,
0.0256921723,
0.0307604875,
0.0421653241,
0.0042260517,
0.0315609351,
-0.0278702173,
0.0420034342,
0.0263898876,
-0.0127119115,
0.0718229935,
-0.0548115745,
-0.0043156161,
-0.0229383055,
-0.0139136929,
-0.0045799995,
-0.0048718345,
-0.0456348732,
-0.0478913933,
-0.0104453973,
0.0271138977,
-0.0129771316,
0.0112244179,
-0.0367194116,
-0.0062024603,
-0.012194098,
-0.0130996825,
-0.0919961184,
0.0507557727,
-0.0728587285,
-0.0013825413,
0.0675655454,
-0.014563214,
0.0082639167,
0.0094123669,
0.0173427835,
0.0336626992,
-0.0246536992,
0.0171936713,
-0.0945374072,
-0.0330169946,
0.0185036156,
0.0094291931,
-0.0027031221,
-0.0274459496,
0.0133912954,
0.0490250736,
0.0473138653,
-0.0506893098,
-0.0373327322,
0.0348778032,
-0.0430682823,
0.0510447547,
0.0488952808,
0.003701037,
0.1248774454,
0.0518962964,
-0.0264342297,
0.0600926168,
0.0276501235,
0.0077313534,
0.049466487,
0.0029219964,
0.0256070048,
0.0016278746,
-0.0188891646,
-0.0140398825,
0.0236803386,
0.0497656725,
-0.0031722891,
0.005549022,
-0.0275582261,
0.0162534285,
-0.0086275302,
0.0412496105,
0.0087501267,
0.0704677999,
0.0577014722,
0.0251941625,
0.0121362126,
0.0621313937,
0.0219202302,
0.0154505447,
-0.0136767523,
-0.0091407513,
-0.0235678945,
-0.026914075,
-0.0496310592,
0.0364359058,
-0.0228136126,
-0.0444470458,
-0.030018039,
0.0273347739,
0.0432154201,
-0.0446115173,
0.0033564731,
0.0102034202,
0.0021307264,
0.0310559645,
0.030561829,
-0.0315116607,
0.0174045395,
0.0149031589,
0.0260901153,
0.0528160483,
0.0092014503,
-0.0067927442,
0.0402511843,
0.0022797603,
0.0423988402,
-0.000765322,
0.022785088,
-0.0173776858,
-0.0391992629,
-0.071031414,
-0.0253179576,
-0.0196906235,
0.00612219,
-0.0021242162,
0.0300609861,
0.0596237406,
0.0203771405,
-0.0412583761,
-0.078215383,
0.0406632721,
-0.0134762302,
-0.0544788465,
-0.0631753206,
0.0260942895,
-0.0075794449,
0.0493469127,
0.0111600636,
-0.0010588255,
-0.0505237728,
0.024320852,
0.0238748491,
-0.002092096,
-0.0022949853,
0.0399359427,
0.0271152016,
-0.127599597,
-0.0079950364,
-0.0146025708,
0.0180715453,
0.0121091167,
0.0376610123,
-0.0206656419,
0.0360494629,
0.032642778,
-0.0286903549,
-0.0030187443,
-0.0914946496,
0.0132720936,
0.0022852516,
0.0053781546,
-0.0080208806,
-0.0139545146,
-0.0809361488,
0.0024710279,
0.0286385734,
0.0035863956,
0.0087325741,
-0.0371137112,
0.0313358232,
0.004557725,
0.0150122978,
-0.0285929088,
-0.0024087951,
-0.0427236259,
-0.0612521656,
-0.0230289083,
0.0238359049,
-0.0083361454,
-0.0572647639,
-0.0287263822,
-0.0173201002,
-0.0369797945,
-0.0263499077,
-0.0765151829,
-0.0212235451,
0.0026058787,
0.048497092,
0.024560798,
-0.0250398759,
-0.0287840888,
-0.0492948554,
0.0061368244,
0.0811938196,
-0.0036159267,
-0.0559826456,
-0.0469022095,
-0.0169846341,
-0.0439814553,
-0.0023301747,
-0.0128606837,
0.0257380027,
0.0335049853,
0.0190730728,
-0.0036845864,
0.042215731,
0.0282969959,
0.0078544533,
-0.0169909373,
-0.0162892062,
0.0167245213,
0.0126062483,
-0.0175808165,
0.0002819936,
-0.1368880272,
0.0403704867,
-0.0149484277,
0.0115603302,
0.0001820798,
-0.0560691953,
0.0377291776,
-0.0837026462,
0.015747631,
-0.0614115484,
-0.0537726618,
0.0226790868,
0.0213165805,
0.0405482613,
0.0013389497,
0.0336757824,
-0.0064904788,
0.0184590835,
-0.0941054747,
0.0015948736,
-0.0371113159,
0.0177644454,
-0.0182248913,
0.0611921698,
0.016130738,
-0.0213174056,
-0.0301018059,
-0.0075646793,
0.083206147,
-0.0045070802,
0.0416578054,
0.0050345897,
-0.0405508652,
-0.004913976,
0.0338712856,
0.0143092275,
-0.0384538807,
-0.0192149933,
-0.0722895041,
0.0573288314,
-0.0177072138,
-0.008329913,
0.0052648922,
0.044365976,
0.0078778081,
0.0273188669,
-0.0101892333,
0.036235407,
-0.028947195,
0.0095404461,
-0.0469822139,
-0.0104161575,
-0.0542607158,
-0.0391178168,
0.0395659618,
0.0034737438,
-0.0397366881,
0.0574443787,
-0.035474766,
0.0340173133,
-0.0861432776,
-0.0312483981,
0.0260004997,
0.0272358228,
-0.0505746603,
0.0607950948,
0.0539973825,
0.0568324216,
-0.0822973847,
0.007865007,
-0.0429547466,
-0.0284008887,
-0.0241207462,
0.025408823,
-0.1011900306,
0.0087701855,
-0.0046573454,
0.112973325,
-0.0288779158,
0.0249901414,
-0.0118032619,
-0.0282602739,
0.0012132247,
0.0319668986,
-0.0061362358,
0.02396545,
0.0084607853,
-0.0156284086,
0.0275886431,
0.0151099097,
0.0171367843,
-0.0524223335,
0.0298888702,
0.0006889356,
-0.0964730531,
-0.0251825489,
0.0074389824,
0.0217817165,
0.0252192672,
-0.004897838,
0.0104428846,
-0.0194706935,
-0.0544312261,
0.008865173,
0.0051831561,
-0.004203592,
-0.0277395137,
0.0424236655,
-0.0359765626,
0.0426217914,
-0.0474511571,
0.0513156317,
-0.0092838034,
-0.0446700752,
0.0398139693,
-0.0306027718,
0.0750402063,
-0.0567877032,
-0.0403578021,
0.0196269583,
0.0263246838,
0.0484136678,
-0.0027145203,
-0.0215858817,
0.0155540034,
-0.0898167193,
0.0265926998,
-0.0070640086,
-0.0728638917,
-0.0171642564,
-0.0278186202,
-0.0238627791,
-0.0475575887,
-0.0610463545,
0.0158203728,
0.0319763273,
0.0441101119,
-0.0178590603,
0.0592849441,
0.0118924808,
-0.0297407582,
0.0057750922,
-0.0205887221,
0.0042961603,
-0.0888937265,
-0.048955597,
-0.0183251183,
-0.0315107778,
0.0131805325,
0.0236779135,
0.0706594661,
-0.0276931152,
0.0378273576,
0.018862512,
0.0265696198,
-0.0459164344,
0.014797275,
-0.0100128176,
0.0094001926,
0.0336842723,
-0.0222408753,
0.0336538702,
-0.0044622677,
0.0096464837,
-0.0103271175,
-0.0057624122,
-0.0124860033,
0.0030267611,
-0.0412838273,
-0.0029676761,
-0.0688813999,
0.0259825382,
-0.0257302821,
-0.0067893891,
-0.0379364453,
-0.0330786817,
0.000540679,
0.0012598952,
0.0311598647,
0.0296118166,
-0.0319753587,
0.0155959846,
-0.015313196,
-0.0001790381,
-0.0218802895,
-0.0269170236,
0.0088648517,
-0.0309920441,
0.0206713621,
-0.1077355072,
0.0674074143,
0.0519150794,
0.06106681,
0.0046502301,
-0.0143686067,
-0.0179870259,
0.014699813,
-0.0298774019,
0.0420134105,
0.0397488847,
0.0699351355,
0.03362244,
-0.0137809059,
-0.0353000686,
-0.0018805503,
0.0093857348,
-0.0309690703,
-0.0112110283,
0.0023054462,
-0.0411083363,
-0.0139771653,
-0.0034918115,
-0.0007036529,
0.0004170624,
0.0144026605,
0.0143398792,
-0.0019603723,
-0.025266286,
0.0260894783,
0.0115645686,
0.0015376681,
-0.029129345,
0.0477252305,
-0.0352332219,
0.0008137759,
0.018606415,
-0.0504747443,
-0.0220448654,
-0.0230859779,
0.0631774813,
0.0393118374,
-0.0237885304,
-0.0421221592,
-0.0949152485,
-0.0509819686,
-0.0184963215,
0.0073125707,
-0.0014716601,
-0.0110883061,
0.0300340727,
0.0157332271,
0.0160401668,
-0.0381465331,
-0.0177698266,
0.0125503121,
-0.1073785126,
-0.0010740343,
0.0447998345,
-6.398935742e-33,
-0.0324781463,
-0.0303266868,
-0.01051482,
0.0363949649,
0.0643342063,
-0.0370407403,
0.0089238752,
0.0152315255,
0.0123310881,
0.008586362,
-0.0013192485,
-0.0107786004,
0.0079382034,
0.0004246276,
-0.0053014774,
-0.0079389969,
0.0368225388,
0.0255887993,
-0.0534122325,
0.0136790238,
0.0038690781,
-0.0157382227,
0.031771861,
-0.0618980341,
0.0914521068,
-0.0625362992,
-0.0347242393,
-0.0550910048,
0.0335580371,
0.0198456775,
0.0028839502,
0.0217012484,
0.0061185178,
0.0155765181,
0.0088629099,
0.0495253205,
-0.0177131351,
-0.0186520647,
0.0370632373,
0.0300869755,
0.015558999,
-0.0555962473,
0.0071005397,
0.0097848875,
-0.0258113388,
-0.0010851036,
0.0849085525,
0.0156121124,
0.0629042014,
0.0534230992,
-0.0440360457,
-0.0176128298,
-0.0222019702,
0.0236722734,
-0.0173107367,
0.0467661247,
0.0060192752,
-0.0374065228,
-0.062026687,
0.0324746706,
0.0397809632,
0.0030701999,
0.0485527366,
-0.0688962415,
-0.0320112333,
-0.0079680774,
-0.0494532175,
0.0182104241,
-0.0408225283,
-0.026652826,
0.0179404262,
-0.0094575826,
0.012268262,
0.0197079126,
-0.0001094262,
-0.0247728843,
0.0089664394,
0.0299845524,
-0.000518186,
0.0293609761,
-0.0043925131,
-0.0240704753,
-0.111640498,
-0.0488478653,
-0.0273859017,
-0.006474454,
0.0138885854,
-0.0206200965,
0.0000665935,
-0.0343556516,
-0.061426241,
-0.0033334338,
-0.0570703968,
0.0060657454,
-0.056473501,
-0.0148705766,
-0.008280877,
0.0140313655,
0.0091237174,
0.0076259789,
-0.0677082464,
0.0200175568,
-0.035688024,
-0.0137936454,
0.0360956267,
0.027416056,
-0.0371574797,
0.0241433959,
-0.0364995673,
-0.0094603235,
0.0489253253,
-0.0008894033,
0.015190674,
-0.0095275631,
0.0192887634,
0.0103176553,
-0.0091631655,
0.0114095304,
-0.0147053879,
-0.0317831635,
-0.0125786318,
-0.0388281904,
-0.0197244715,
-0.0166169535,
-0.0457384735,
-0.0247692838,
0.0304667,
0.0649332553,
0.0878221691,
-0.0054183481,
0.0037881492,
-0.0222577993,
2.858e-7,
0.054115694,
0.0734874457,
0.0012891786,
0.027813537,
-0.0306812245,
0.0129788555,
0.0364225022,
0.03110056,
-0.0053196158,
0.0159108341,
0.0104518253,
0.0360032804,
-0.0103716506,
0.0497478768,
-0.027627334,
-0.0415357389,
0.0050456449,
0.0390870646,
-0.0314167626,
0.0361447148,
0.0135369059,
-0.0540388748,
0.0015066044,
-0.0090329284,
-0.0553827658,
-0.0500092842,
0.0187556334,
-0.051212877,
0.0535753369,
0.0575673208,
0.0279466771,
-0.002366354,
0.0224270225,
0.0030918485,
-0.0148497336,
-0.0213875566,
0.0088058542,
0.0474505499,
0.0157996938,
0.0328594595,
-0.0195063874,
0.0097166095,
-0.0064013954,
-0.0696466938,
-0.0009189519,
0.039432954,
-0.0016396944,
0.0606143363,
-0.0213016532,
-0.0212567691,
0.0221111886,
-0.0168024711,
-0.001877408,
0.0017044331,
0.0118005918,
-0.0261299405,
0.0127560822,
-0.0519675016,
0.0079917377,
0.0023981791,
0.0177281965,
-0.0246513393,
-0.0330670327,
0.0318016149,
-0.0282999929,
-0.0410366058,
0.0225562938,
1.894374924e-34,
-0.0064259493,
-0.0176531151,
-0.0078221085,
-0.0551138371,
0.022751173,
0.0336444192,
0.0347886495,
-0.0046855286,
0.0450709425,
0.0155140823,
-0.0073896996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12109v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12109v1 | PEFTT: Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning for low-resource Tibetan pre-trained language models | 2023-09-21T14:29:23 | 2023-09-21T14:29:23 | Zhou Mingjun, Daiqing Zhuoma, Qun Nuo, Nyima Tashi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this era of large language models (LLMs), the traditional training of
models has become increasingly unimaginable for regular users and institutions.
The exploration of efficient fine-tuning for high-resource languages on these
models is an undeniable trend that is gradually gaining popularity. However,
there has been very little exploration for various low-resource languages, such
as Tibetan. Research in Tibetan NLP is inherently scarce and limited. While
there is currently no existing large language model for Tibetan due to its
low-resource nature, that day will undoubtedly arrive. Therefore, research on
efficient fine-tuning for low-resource language models like Tibetan is highly
necessary. Our research can serve as a reference to fill this crucial gap.
Efficient fine-tuning strategies for pre-trained language models (PLMs) in
Tibetan have seen minimal exploration. We conducted three types of efficient
fine-tuning experiments on the publicly available TNCC-title dataset:
"prompt-tuning," "Adapter lightweight fine-tuning," and "prompt-tuning +
Adapter fine-tuning." The experimental results demonstrate significant
improvements using these methods, providing valuable insights for advancing
Tibetan language applications in the context of pre-trained models. | [
0.0517007224,
0.0143936202,
-0.03481948,
0.0502071753,
0.0070502632,
0.012773863,
-0.0162187628,
0.0141681135,
-0.0261712708,
-0.0264426675,
-0.0524467006,
-0.0208612438,
-0.0009880842,
-0.0479269885,
0.0023608604,
-0.0838784575,
0.0503288247,
-0.0236100201,
0.0116022918,
0.0082667172,
0.0205602013,
-0.0061212699,
0.0010590763,
0.012633644,
0.0351327993,
-0.0128202634,
-0.0077880663,
0.0335028172,
0.0278307833,
-0.0106467074,
-0.0175807755,
0.0893953368,
-0.0502142906,
0.0134434653,
0.0000019872,
-0.0591253191,
-0.0309427474,
-0.0358326212,
-0.0188022815,
0.0577167161,
0.0541931652,
-0.0026342729,
-0.0178099666,
0.0287682917,
0.0055148457,
-0.0290779695,
0.0705039501,
0.0454719178,
0.024672227,
0.0744488314,
0.0006989962,
-0.0219504274,
0.0167532861,
-0.0090714963,
-0.0447043926,
-0.0332305841,
0.0222984497,
-0.002447038,
-0.0039668367,
-0.0079191923,
-0.0371882096,
-0.0059359442,
0.0053900308,
-0.0068656835,
-0.0406815447,
-0.0246549398,
-0.0602054149,
-0.0632429719,
-0.0220802594,
0.0377624892,
-0.0640527457,
-0.0377899371,
-0.0101665314,
-0.0075251851,
-0.0368940234,
-0.0284415707,
0.0121836802,
-0.0022705083,
0.0023004364,
0.0179233588,
0.0402749218,
-0.0183180999,
0.0071622282,
0.022886062,
0.0056203878,
-0.0137253748,
0.0300939232,
-0.0136855431,
0.0020973817,
-0.0263657998,
-0.0498410128,
-0.0155133214,
-0.0167472977,
0.0121750059,
-0.0436645038,
0.0091806976,
-0.0269497298,
-0.0345631465,
0.0236326773,
0.0365565009,
0.09422227,
0.0444037318,
-0.0209234674,
0.0015212607,
-0.0146970758,
0.0004029982,
0.0168907288,
0.0139493663,
-0.0403406098,
0.0153142661,
0.0203613993,
-0.0003847094,
-0.1077820957,
-0.0410798378,
-0.0291419234,
0.0175800938,
-0.0237088613,
0.0172157511,
0.043421708,
-0.0397010744,
0.0027988446,
-0.0532274954,
-0.0649808943,
-0.0325490609,
0.0165112503,
0.0498727225,
-0.038256526,
0.038900841,
-0.0122886337,
-0.0669312179,
0.0206433106,
0.0107451556,
0.0155128101,
-0.0321721993,
-0.0017254255,
-0.0004061051,
0.0121544274,
-0.0196198653,
-0.0610826574,
0.022650931,
0.0010443592,
-0.0496139973,
-0.0514379665,
-0.0590538681,
0.0016781533,
0.0218030233,
0.0363260768,
0.0012385241,
-0.0095427744,
-0.0298119672,
-0.0210668705,
0.058861278,
-0.0402277149,
0.0140343858,
-0.0224227868,
0.0096117035,
0.0384048112,
0.0762804449,
0.024744058,
0.0337913372,
0.0660027787,
-0.0586967468,
-0.0158511288,
0.034132719,
-0.0090812454,
0.0247680768,
-0.0286733769,
0.0238161329,
0.0453016758,
-0.0104988823,
0.0022275872,
0.0457829274,
-0.016225338,
0.0346140303,
0.0650704578,
0.0214121863,
0.0782295093,
0.0186656825,
0.0090846904,
-0.0007417526,
0.0379409418,
0.005914391,
-0.0284971744,
-0.0133530768,
-0.0613191053,
0.0176877938,
0.0257165991,
0.0553214476,
-0.0179651696,
-0.0358178988,
-0.0409081168,
-0.0195569005,
-0.0455046333,
-0.030574739,
0.032443881,
0.0184032451,
-0.0182064883,
0.0127923777,
0.0740501657,
-0.0239742827,
0.0368517637,
-0.0376880765,
-0.0102336043,
0.0504099168,
-0.0007957364,
-0.0282662306,
0.003072521,
0.0078130178,
0.0632805899,
0.0258100722,
0.084513478,
-0.0062103472,
-0.0026625989,
-0.0582647249,
0.0337459147,
0.0431758389,
0.0076130317,
0.0074398401,
0.0057059578,
0.0170867313,
-0.0064517371,
0.0025428603,
-0.0687215328,
0.0274388324,
-0.0436988436,
-0.0315339901,
-0.0060571842,
0.0302665494,
0.0368097536,
-0.0071950844,
-0.0255920552,
-0.0171033703,
0.0202638097,
0.0072070458,
0.0261124633,
-0.0104828691,
0.0028338535,
-0.033575099,
0.0131133283,
0.0128290979,
0.0308575761,
0.0036129681,
-0.0211230014,
-0.0515985601,
0.0137329409,
0.0350315236,
0.0586432181,
-0.0693197176,
0.0482235774,
-0.0281409658,
0.0036950067,
-0.0477739237,
0.0251822695,
0.0298881661,
0.0364358388,
0.0348687395,
0.0430082269,
0.0299240164,
-0.0592099167,
-0.0693880692,
0.0109616276,
0.019476356,
0.0406844653,
0.0356848277,
0.0236415192,
-0.0038745718,
-0.0493242666,
-0.0639313981,
0.0285585299,
-0.0550148301,
0.0060041002,
0.0040112403,
0.0409350358,
-0.0345388204,
-0.0092912149,
0.0022169761,
0.0073107472,
0.0137579925,
0.005593597,
0.0133942785,
0.0087027978,
-0.0135465693,
-0.0368107297,
-0.0275099743,
0.0354891233,
-0.0042954772,
-0.0189248826,
-0.0114260102,
-0.0273130406,
0.012332025,
0.0019672862,
0.0215838514,
-0.0071398518,
-0.1061616018,
-0.0373606756,
-0.0180092063,
0.0196857844,
0.0149994679,
-0.0045303563,
0.0128345117,
-0.0095895622,
0.0250050314,
0.0136781288,
0.0020513178,
-0.0153720444,
-0.0655191019,
-0.0775987357,
0.0125058908,
-0.023725681,
0.0562680252,
0.0040017599,
-0.0213157535,
-0.0686522499,
-0.0160079263,
-0.0521359667,
0.0053878226,
0.0167956911,
0.0402491502,
-0.039934326,
0.0624714456,
-0.032266099,
-0.0633695722,
0.0596209168,
-0.0252341833,
-0.0133387512,
-0.0552401021,
0.0324871913,
-0.023175668,
0.040133059,
0.0101846177,
0.0455542132,
0.0251948237,
0.0021743381,
-0.0429877639,
0.018411262,
0.0103924656,
-0.0277288668,
0.0268441923,
0.0024347112,
0.011849165,
-0.0546737909,
-0.0221944451,
-0.0024758107,
-0.0436890423,
0.0015900029,
-0.010258547,
0.0442285948,
0.0056660376,
0.0336215086,
0.0655012801,
-0.0341889448,
-0.0000662246,
-0.0203543287,
0.035658285,
-0.0324277915,
-0.0086906543,
0.0444056094,
0.0329869762,
0.0514331348,
-0.0017045046,
0.0624743253,
-0.0440620594,
0.0294807386,
-0.0163992941,
0.0152758332,
0.0066337287,
0.0444806628,
-0.0344763622,
-0.0078465091,
0.0410618596,
0.0667078644,
-0.0458064303,
0.0248944089,
0.1050984338,
0.0383096859,
-0.0085922647,
0.0112583209,
0.0054728398,
0.0162259489,
0.0129020279,
0.0226903129,
-0.1201700643,
-0.0344669744,
0.0084438045,
0.0091977064,
-0.0055131558,
0.0136903012,
0.0165158473,
-0.1250111461,
-0.0013582022,
0.0208263788,
-0.0018375065,
0.0261155404,
-0.0123091023,
-0.0043283803,
-0.0252832994,
0.0329989381,
0.0488008,
-0.0576003678,
-0.0150433071,
0.0351460762,
-0.004716971,
-0.0902045444,
-0.0023778938,
-0.0630712733,
0.0467587449,
0.0263127722,
-0.0145289535,
-0.0313932784,
-0.0052281464,
0.035909988,
-0.0517341606,
-0.0127544161,
-0.0042928034,
-0.0225712899,
0.0230047572,
-0.0357364826,
0.0255669933,
0.0320566297,
-0.0041239453,
0.0027026411,
0.0022390746,
0.0356457271,
-0.0019738055,
-0.0012334817,
0.0412671342,
-0.0126953889,
0.011026266,
0.0485749058,
0.0371742062,
-0.0400389768,
-0.0178098585,
-0.0203227364,
-0.0353339761,
-0.0306272097,
-0.0280703865,
0.0214073099,
-0.0378343463,
0.0041276463,
-0.0434829071,
-0.0302975625,
0.0359301046,
0.0540714785,
0.0388403125,
0.0451459326,
0.0049681114,
0.0263269003,
-0.0151172411,
0.0375786051,
-0.004683292,
-0.0024358372,
-0.1082299873,
-0.0547082648,
0.0523209572,
-0.0106346486,
0.0095534986,
0.0082391333,
-0.033598125,
-0.0625925288,
0.0347598717,
0.0660721362,
0.0225005057,
-0.0016109622,
-0.0352866538,
-0.0651663318,
0.0022121985,
0.0257848557,
-0.026880471,
0.0206423532,
0.038023714,
-0.0351916216,
-0.015744118,
0.0583837442,
-0.0098895244,
0.0451564789,
0.017029047,
0.0103709251,
0.0002804944,
-0.0733744577,
-0.0011030345,
0.0212207548,
0.0485477969,
-0.0371514559,
-0.0113475528,
-0.0613466352,
0.0527734198,
-0.0129780192,
-0.0177896786,
-0.0190006923,
-0.046752274,
0.0165656283,
0.0284443107,
-0.0499942489,
-0.0029765593,
-0.0180141777,
0.0241334997,
-0.0423164219,
0.0624778979,
0.0050814319,
0.0248661246,
0.0426702462,
0.012294855,
-0.0026230314,
0.052564349,
0.0137117403,
0.0294400454,
-0.0200648159,
0.0330396779,
0.0237341505,
0.0422459133,
-0.0257956013,
0.042426277,
0.0111078545,
-0.0332841836,
-0.0009223831,
-0.031771671,
0.0560118966,
-0.0272363741,
0.0429131314,
-0.0203375239,
-0.0281475931,
-0.0272540543,
0.0292871222,
0.0411481075,
-0.0013052631,
0.0195934903,
0.0095005902,
-0.0468612276,
-0.0009371508,
0.0363056995,
-0.0093427505,
0.0442015044,
0.0249793734,
0.0084359441,
-0.0089769037,
-0.0066563264,
-0.0068694274,
-0.0193462148,
-0.0237568431,
0.0021279473,
-0.0692472532,
-0.0459410921,
-0.0250857677,
-0.0038727645,
0.0100378059,
-0.0170016009,
0.002011314,
0.0356967971,
0.0253019668,
0.0039501097,
-0.0543536246,
-0.0673996508,
-0.020165313,
0.014883277,
0.0466235466,
-6.458701548e-33,
-0.047721494,
0.0528496057,
-0.0191664565,
0.0067658857,
0.0030782514,
-0.0115623232,
-0.009538956,
0.0001417838,
-0.047284808,
-0.0196173247,
-0.0513258725,
-0.0414718278,
0.0290692206,
0.0069278344,
-0.010124906,
0.0325916857,
0.066376403,
0.0308786221,
-0.0262012631,
-0.0065868627,
0.0302251149,
0.0152973784,
0.0619437136,
0.0328266695,
-0.0098106163,
-0.0124743981,
-0.0053029153,
0.0362896994,
-0.0215773452,
0.0549152568,
-0.0134610822,
0.037467014,
0.0121471416,
-0.018816052,
-0.033743795,
-0.0144469747,
-0.085400492,
-0.0046814526,
0.0437909923,
0.0433904938,
-0.0004019563,
0.001714729,
0.010704359,
-0.0286711771,
-0.054828763,
0.0427291021,
-0.0088235801,
-0.052730158,
0.0029688152,
0.000600866,
-0.0756925717,
0.0156336334,
0.0165543277,
-0.013961751,
-0.0137119703,
-0.0338027291,
-0.0340423174,
-0.0021417413,
-0.0401457101,
-0.024876833,
0.1197347492,
0.09195216,
0.014646478,
0.065968655,
-0.0019691337,
-0.0012011621,
0.0012621606,
-0.0060017807,
0.0518039167,
0.0433852337,
0.0613108166,
0.014728304,
0.0089419894,
0.0454079323,
0.033573132,
-0.0908413678,
-0.0677120015,
-0.0157050453,
0.0428043008,
0.0409931093,
0.0215496756,
0.015912313,
-0.012142729,
-0.0401350223,
-0.0498273186,
-0.0396458879,
-0.0132628027,
-0.0302552506,
0.03298847,
0.0210957788,
-0.0493453406,
0.0426876582,
0.064141877,
-0.0414142534,
-0.001818218,
-0.0100625232,
-0.0147944484,
0.0172545537,
-0.0457816236,
0.0161861423,
-0.0640051439,
-0.0697464272,
0.0069929748,
-0.0313846692,
-0.0077416729,
-0.0320538506,
0.0694753081,
0.0134158731,
-0.0643736497,
0.055547405,
-0.0065241633,
0.0360444374,
0.0407768376,
0.0627184808,
0.0066598211,
-0.0129463514,
0.0020807255,
0.0487933308,
0.0335438587,
-0.0403258428,
-0.0378188603,
0.00684507,
0.0197607148,
-0.0048371856,
-0.0062053753,
0.0220244788,
-0.0378892869,
0.0276136473,
0.0198130067,
-0.0296262,
0.0114066377,
0.0141773215,
2.77e-7,
0.0407838337,
0.020640105,
0.0414016992,
-0.0300453659,
0.0086633489,
-0.0171960443,
-0.0275387,
0.0118763922,
-0.0215268973,
0.0246124584,
0.0051133675,
0.0279741716,
0.0680699572,
0.0066262763,
-0.0768976584,
-0.0065529975,
-0.0499880947,
0.0336792432,
-0.0852523744,
-0.0279011782,
-0.0309749469,
0.1313329488,
-0.0143097006,
0.01764304,
0.0155807119,
-0.0420110412,
0.0329406373,
-0.0139278453,
-0.0158348214,
0.0813458115,
0.0396326557,
0.0157460459,
-0.0140614212,
-0.048494298,
-0.0236119069,
0.0557546504,
-0.0291322023,
0.0813256577,
-0.0011058148,
0.0024312129,
0.0413733348,
-0.0094858054,
-0.0102770841,
-0.050238736,
0.0614445172,
-0.0005755305,
-0.0200295486,
0.010147118,
0.0077850851,
-0.0346345939,
0.0152487801,
-0.0586968362,
-0.0089626405,
0.0346101895,
0.0295223799,
-0.0245370548,
-0.0467577204,
-0.0418875776,
-0.0444784649,
0.0187171716,
0.0123574222,
-0.0635250807,
0.0086262152,
-0.0482544042,
0.0031808747,
-0.0526737906,
0.0143188136,
2.442073902e-34,
0.0614827387,
-0.0195290986,
0.0254701693,
-0.0384252071,
0.0492359698,
-0.0295449253,
0.0177761931,
0.0358779766,
0.0161175393,
-0.0941793621,
-0.0231480021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12107v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12107v1 | A Computational Analysis of Vagueness in Revisions of Instructional Texts | 2023-09-21T14:26:04 | 2023-09-21T14:26:04 | Alok Debnath, Michael Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL | WikiHow is an open-domain repository of instructional articles for a variety
of tasks, which can be revised by users. In this paper, we extract pairwise
versions of an instruction before and after a revision was made. Starting from
a noisy dataset of revision histories, we specifically extract and analyze
edits that involve cases of vagueness in instructions. We further investigate
the ability of a neural model to distinguish between two versions of an
instruction in our data by adopting a pairwise ranking task from previous work
and showing improvements over existing baselines. | [
0.066813454,
0.0365510546,
-0.0387721509,
0.0088060126,
-0.0109996079,
0.0210499242,
-0.0112769874,
0.0398487225,
-0.0550216064,
-0.0883358419,
0.0066983849,
-0.0193081088,
0.0360318199,
-0.0314212404,
0.0319235697,
-0.0497476533,
0.0416953973,
-0.0003814283,
0.023482779,
0.0060481792,
0.0006807101,
-0.0241811033,
-0.0136890644,
0.0323448405,
0.0263344329,
-0.056036707,
-0.0513720885,
0.0010671585,
-0.0087287445,
-0.0046378789,
0.0329312347,
0.0812190399,
-0.017364243,
0.0588723011,
0.0000018795,
-0.0372377448,
-0.0091401432,
-0.0043128245,
-0.0309008844,
0.053651344,
0.0108990502,
0.0254284944,
-0.0241223406,
-0.0517914146,
-0.0456005298,
0.0174127705,
0.0122659029,
0.0451841503,
0.0792559534,
0.0816245899,
0.0053339154,
-0.0206943154,
0.0261648055,
-0.0038026543,
0.0916329846,
-0.0032533896,
0.0257732421,
-0.0472167842,
-0.0030068983,
0.0656627566,
-0.0012967102,
0.0284407157,
-0.0033391858,
-0.039877031,
-0.0087831039,
0.0234520473,
-0.0131392376,
0.0157382712,
0.0241610073,
0.0633696467,
0.0464317277,
0.0214043278,
0.0275281798,
-0.0010677524,
0.0336689837,
0.0451943018,
-0.0398855321,
-0.0026455568,
-0.0215932615,
-0.0423046276,
-0.0343357883,
-0.0454297289,
0.016947953,
0.043672964,
0.0391490832,
0.0248099081,
-0.0162488036,
-0.0614299066,
0.0046289121,
0.012426558,
-0.0093077309,
-0.0582092181,
0.0307188071,
0.0338900164,
0.010185834,
-0.0003380845,
-0.0293330401,
-0.0361688584,
0.0279720724,
-0.085008435,
0.0141195077,
0.0077312174,
-0.0246117022,
0.0389229953,
-0.040426597,
0.0558791161,
0.0119115124,
0.0250752587,
-0.0059093162,
0.0531899221,
-0.0693204328,
-0.0247018076,
-0.0351555459,
0.0750558227,
0.0110036787,
-0.0009876036,
-0.0526116043,
0.0012609022,
-0.0344256349,
0.0212915614,
0.0020931175,
0.014852046,
-0.0640315637,
0.0086676143,
-0.0533312112,
-0.0248044804,
-0.0064768726,
0.0353648737,
-0.0063416124,
0.0169175752,
-0.0004627786,
-0.019127015,
0.0272276122,
-0.0066390373,
-0.031145649,
0.0233874992,
-0.0034136416,
0.0287163127,
-0.0564197563,
-0.0519987382,
0.0251797605,
0.0234397259,
-0.0184583031,
-0.0699097365,
0.0122474059,
-0.0102718677,
-0.0008168139,
-0.0632742494,
-0.0197669268,
0.0317907184,
-0.0701270252,
0.0591861717,
-0.044654429,
0.0125163114,
0.0880453959,
0.0340729132,
-0.054218851,
0.0051656151,
0.0235760994,
0.0087341405,
0.0566905327,
0.0144214323,
0.0063331206,
0.018184077,
-0.0050713532,
-0.0139143793,
0.0162122343,
-0.0167404115,
-0.0237956792,
0.0215231422,
-0.0244522244,
0.0316572152,
-0.0445478968,
-0.0324385576,
0.0539529249,
0.0326991491,
0.0353899188,
0.0037085766,
0.0476359576,
0.016013395,
0.0307131652,
0.0712412298,
-0.0313669071,
0.0247236602,
-0.0347694457,
0.0120783644,
0.0094933482,
-0.0678701773,
-0.0096385358,
-0.0747885779,
0.0010149862,
-0.0007166573,
0.0084521538,
-0.0628781691,
0.0458055101,
0.0220680255,
-0.0524546057,
0.0114335977,
0.0300626848,
-0.0256548356,
0.0404752418,
-0.017827604,
0.0106520001,
0.0856969878,
0.043432638,
-0.0611771829,
-0.0494095683,
-0.0359855369,
0.0244206991,
0.0059641409,
0.0439361297,
-0.0524694808,
0.0054839319,
-0.0759560987,
-0.0285332706,
-0.0373203605,
0.0287589096,
0.0013601403,
0.0265769772,
-0.0002697228,
0.0322008282,
-0.0111580808,
-0.0792419836,
0.0287444443,
0.0188349057,
-0.0216239989,
-0.0056287111,
0.0222547147,
-0.005381092,
0.0114664007,
0.0075447746,
0.0069411835,
0.0115505001,
0.0155482572,
-0.0188970584,
-0.0461395644,
0.0055907848,
-0.0046833791,
0.0363183245,
-0.0135253863,
-0.0324420333,
-0.0088138366,
-0.0562383831,
-0.0108631011,
0.0092576267,
-0.0351961367,
-0.0191890169,
-0.0227866285,
0.032481689,
0.0054585277,
-0.0370997861,
-0.0455152802,
0.0599664971,
0.0205806028,
0.048912432,
0.0708761215,
-0.0320046209,
-0.011808998,
-0.0377077237,
-0.0501645282,
-0.0289549474,
-0.0324286446,
0.0149286948,
0.0017709739,
0.0229231156,
-0.0373174362,
-0.0278762523,
-0.0422750674,
-0.0199481007,
-0.0182500631,
0.0139822215,
0.0331792235,
-0.025292201,
0.0032221621,
-0.0419309512,
0.012510756,
-0.0042513171,
-0.0472353287,
0.0401898175,
0.0594545603,
0.065969035,
0.031492956,
-0.0558085628,
-0.0471875556,
-0.0294345953,
0.0285751577,
0.0495907925,
-0.0355789773,
-0.0900409296,
0.0466939211,
-0.0558703691,
-0.0093499143,
0.0050616562,
-0.0239258036,
0.0098581892,
-0.0038832109,
0.0673416629,
0.0517449938,
0.0294061173,
0.0412718393,
0.0606364608,
-0.0323928557,
-0.0777951479,
-0.001790109,
-0.0171920862,
0.0043078978,
-0.0076512923,
-0.0570672639,
0.0345982313,
0.0130054848,
0.0069574611,
-0.0159093142,
-0.0480179265,
0.0377702974,
-0.0509020947,
0.0221403334,
-0.0763215646,
-0.0370633788,
0.0003757412,
0.0214622691,
-0.0110368961,
-0.0274351519,
0.0952192545,
0.0254711714,
0.0504852831,
-0.0492171831,
0.0224973727,
-0.0010804811,
0.0160656739,
-0.0135783432,
0.0078114001,
-0.0067529222,
-0.0229565054,
-0.0779575184,
0.0395932831,
0.0402839296,
-0.0300003737,
0.0647965521,
-0.0525976121,
-0.0189187285,
-0.030508928,
0.0264903624,
-0.0213439688,
-0.0535798073,
0.0741704404,
-0.0180409439,
0.0118648298,
0.0145912841,
-0.0111019416,
-0.0325079672,
0.0114457225,
0.1131995693,
-0.0262993816,
-0.0437780321,
-0.0072368667,
0.0263357684,
0.0172810908,
-0.0192598291,
-0.0051394878,
-0.0465925597,
0.0220070481,
0.0469878167,
0.0076240133,
-0.0247148871,
-0.0195663907,
-0.041329287,
-0.0151611166,
-0.0883747861,
-0.0357082635,
0.0512470379,
-0.0020575186,
-0.045458667,
-0.007093112,
0.09785676,
0.0473982543,
-0.0775076374,
-0.0214467086,
-0.0432413109,
-0.0453265086,
-0.0080334386,
0.0337091126,
-0.0574298799,
0.0134346047,
0.0039923685,
0.0492398106,
-0.0026527757,
-0.0287336335,
0.0211839266,
-0.0529113375,
0.0312895104,
-0.0141245686,
-0.0182188023,
0.0372433066,
-0.0086213984,
0.0120978206,
0.0275890585,
-0.0433279239,
0.0038589372,
-0.0134908762,
0.0169935375,
0.0155170085,
0.000511145,
-0.0498348214,
-0.0084987776,
-0.0167422835,
0.0279660057,
0.0309810918,
0.0421625674,
-0.0215692427,
-0.0165650975,
0.0475436151,
-0.0004023957,
0.0151790855,
-0.0245299898,
0.0848697871,
0.0307259634,
0.0252166707,
-0.0016445874,
-0.0062657222,
0.0249091238,
-0.019149201,
0.0373061076,
0.0548895374,
-0.0205257274,
0.0032231775,
-0.0085094813,
-0.0106537258,
-0.0061699222,
0.0401264355,
0.030765444,
-0.0210091993,
0.0186839104,
-0.0583068691,
0.0297788158,
-0.0381863043,
-0.0143365953,
-0.0414139405,
-0.0459393449,
0.0353708677,
-0.1219465882,
-0.0656123236,
0.0155415488,
-0.0362778939,
0.0623350181,
0.0040792157,
0.0602940656,
-0.0257239733,
-0.0692858845,
0.0094764158,
0.0275461003,
-0.0075661903,
-0.0803816542,
-0.0671672672,
0.0295066498,
0.0146106388,
-0.0221428256,
-0.0069771116,
-0.017449718,
-0.0465116613,
0.0193205811,
0.0729797632,
0.0187321585,
0.0106845312,
-0.0099957548,
-0.0521169901,
0.0127852261,
0.0474101752,
-0.0221833643,
0.0083452966,
0.0302499495,
0.0229944233,
-0.0273960438,
0.024540633,
-0.0559364781,
-0.0083784163,
-0.0000706475,
-0.0028279058,
-0.0491637513,
-0.0083302734,
-0.0016388075,
0.0049039521,
0.0624703579,
0.0350529589,
-0.0119148968,
-0.0546096377,
0.031221021,
-0.0039832331,
-0.0311239157,
0.0085462611,
0.0063985493,
0.0062848572,
0.0071801171,
-0.0247387234,
0.0778834075,
0.019762462,
0.0565807931,
-0.0863700733,
-0.0197604932,
0.0449737757,
0.0286245495,
0.0165596046,
0.0235726684,
-0.0076332586,
0.0050670113,
0.0114550916,
0.0424631462,
-0.0190814044,
0.0449050665,
0.0371461771,
0.0341168121,
-0.0130879702,
0.0380267799,
-0.0665621236,
-0.0136212604,
-0.0165187605,
-0.0168160852,
-0.008076326,
-0.0044893944,
0.0455769971,
0.0050076777,
-0.0188914463,
-0.0165863167,
0.0347183384,
0.0237954445,
-0.0147852618,
0.0257858112,
0.0380488597,
0.0463013165,
0.054231178,
0.0674305111,
-0.0661976933,
0.044056613,
-0.0013796653,
-0.0598798692,
-0.0318386927,
-0.0101546757,
0.0130997663,
0.0524930134,
-0.0290069878,
-0.0266163666,
-0.0165402349,
0.0009575651,
0.0052808672,
0.0085140625,
0.0543236285,
0.0000329767,
0.0108991433,
0.0396059453,
-0.0003504129,
-0.002562467,
-0.0438233316,
0.0163425095,
-0.0294210017,
-0.0426688343,
-0.0723615363,
-5.52386689e-33,
-0.0456068181,
-0.0343086757,
-0.0107935034,
0.0238387063,
-0.0063214852,
0.0521947332,
-0.057043612,
-0.0049900045,
0.0007829036,
0.0169325415,
-0.0166524667,
0.0179334003,
0.0025366209,
-0.026288351,
0.0609186478,
0.0158032794,
0.0738769844,
0.006436917,
-0.0072473385,
0.0060775606,
0.0302481204,
-0.0044031409,
0.0562443472,
-0.0358283818,
0.0867489874,
-0.0018660035,
-0.0115467971,
-0.0264087152,
-0.0447641909,
0.0772347003,
-0.0035480817,
0.0030945207,
0.0376938395,
-0.0233775936,
-0.0266535655,
-0.0315317437,
-0.0625306889,
-0.0493590906,
-0.0233028457,
0.0009937014,
-0.0014797898,
-0.0516815446,
0.0566491969,
0.0009944575,
-0.0303713121,
-0.0199462418,
0.0910954475,
-0.0010239703,
-0.0031787325,
0.0175085515,
-0.0556974784,
0.00950763,
-0.0332463123,
-0.0189582799,
-0.0056341193,
0.036804527,
0.0015634634,
-0.0091446387,
-0.1400902122,
0.0237599872,
0.0430413261,
0.0546712428,
0.002069101,
-0.0477096923,
-0.0293278769,
0.0272683892,
0.0112011638,
0.0310333893,
-0.0205402095,
0.0062506888,
0.0077399658,
0.0124072935,
0.0588754006,
0.0079714926,
0.0745777339,
-0.0304297525,
-0.024347553,
0.0508367084,
-0.0505173728,
0.0580630898,
0.0015392485,
-0.0154014723,
-0.0305992234,
-0.0068473923,
-0.0214298256,
-0.0130885039,
-0.0434754267,
-0.0197466835,
0.0127055021,
-0.0077316561,
-0.0297945887,
0.0283020586,
-0.0072419015,
-0.0090631656,
0.009585564,
0.0014582436,
-0.0538052507,
0.0474536009,
0.0195071045,
-0.058761891,
-0.009406792,
0.0143209537,
0.0183881782,
0.0146702109,
0.036198698,
0.0311944634,
0.0750121996,
0.0009439791,
-0.0364846624,
0.0025263911,
0.0187029913,
-0.0128845563,
-0.0146613885,
0.0005388818,
-0.0128124943,
0.0042605684,
-0.0101736067,
0.0504335277,
0.0354568101,
0.0238737147,
-0.0585063696,
0.0117457695,
0.0329601429,
-0.0048602349,
-0.011375241,
0.003490722,
0.0080510611,
0.047425665,
0.0042696777,
-0.018173676,
-0.0121079125,
0.0100250933,
2.557e-7,
0.0238750633,
0.0663555712,
0.0279104393,
-0.0360355154,
0.0141393859,
0.0101597486,
-0.0310272686,
-0.0179710612,
0.0256313439,
0.0184497442,
0.0150631722,
0.000297886,
0.0046372097,
0.0375262238,
-0.0408898965,
-0.0539311469,
-0.0515962429,
-0.0311539434,
-0.0569753759,
-0.0082963351,
0.0760990828,
-0.0007241022,
0.01205834,
0.0278823916,
-0.0274973027,
0.0001430368,
0.0515471622,
0.0057935463,
0.0292448178,
0.0290475022,
0.0527671836,
-0.021602422,
-0.0028493674,
0.002049339,
-0.0416660942,
-0.0148355979,
0.0371096134,
0.0349019282,
-0.0115417344,
0.0470837951,
0.0120759998,
-0.0170442797,
0.0099880779,
-0.0161291566,
0.012047058,
-0.040066082,
-0.0097050052,
0.0862391815,
-0.041083429,
0.0026403926,
0.0493384674,
-0.025556121,
0.0027998013,
0.002875492,
-0.0220420063,
-0.0002935841,
-0.0157535803,
-0.0500499643,
0.0076807449,
-0.0202442631,
-0.0149919614,
-0.0068035191,
-0.0301820803,
-0.0134022431,
-0.0149412239,
-0.0456347838,
0.0442241579,
1.676907665e-34,
0.0183394384,
0.0134365568,
0.0209117532,
-0.0076084835,
0.010430268,
0.0031236324,
-0.0094299875,
-0.0017371651,
-0.0098634809,
-0.0499454923,
-0.0420589745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12102v1 | SemEval-2022 Task 7: Identifying Plausible Clarifications of Implicit and Underspecified Phrases in Instructional Texts | 2023-09-21T14:19:04 | 2023-09-21T14:19:04 | Michael Roth, Talita Anthonio, Anna Sauer | cs.CL | cs.CL | We describe SemEval-2022 Task 7, a shared task on rating the plausibility of
clarifications in instructional texts. The dataset for this task consists of
manually clarified how-to guides for which we generated alternative
clarifications and collected human plausibility judgements. The task of
participating systems was to automatically determine the plausibility of a
clarification in the respective context. In total, 21 participants took part in
this task, with the best system achieving an accuracy of 68.9%. This report
summarizes the results and findings from 8 teams and their system descriptions.
Finally, we show in an additional evaluation that predictions by the top
participating team make it possible to identify contexts with multiple
plausible clarifications with an accuracy of 75.2%. | [
0.0642264485,
-0.0701512173,
-0.0187716503,
0.0051151435,
-0.0171128903,
0.0127743995,
0.0364399068,
0.01125779,
-0.0028295899,
-0.0661895648,
-0.0090528019,
0.0371566899,
0.0465881638,
-0.0119833779,
0.0362045765,
-0.1029244363,
0.0393056385,
-0.0268361345,
0.0062994119,
0.0208833423,
-0.0015832953,
0.024967365,
-0.0577344894,
0.0387833454,
0.0087682661,
-0.0681825206,
-0.0230226871,
0.0126772802,
0.018475065,
-0.0220522787,
0.0214537513,
0.0403955691,
0.002458537,
-0.0550128967,
0.0000022697,
-0.0770832002,
-0.0117315762,
-0.0184738375,
-0.0489734188,
0.047571674,
0.0053994646,
0.0325939693,
0.0348724797,
0.0028380051,
-0.0110222762,
0.0276137013,
0.0169808231,
0.0372934826,
0.0808380544,
0.0261375476,
-0.0044403123,
0.0067152614,
-0.0465537384,
0.0353430882,
0.0470168702,
-0.0644450858,
-0.0117022526,
0.0048498581,
0.0028245444,
0.0193716288,
0.0078351907,
0.0245467667,
0.02110691,
-0.0628933907,
0.0182421654,
0.000712564,
0.0061319931,
-0.0240567196,
-0.0068203015,
0.0542768091,
0.09217152,
-0.0171341505,
-0.0295448247,
-0.0340693407,
-0.0014735372,
0.051479578,
-0.0220231581,
0.0105267446,
-0.0221944451,
-0.0360666849,
0.0115450118,
0.0312241185,
-0.0030955025,
0.0362641625,
0.0678719804,
0.0310961176,
-0.0141524887,
-0.0211615451,
0.0226359516,
0.0044647162,
-0.0095667383,
-0.0561658181,
0.0490621962,
0.0832576007,
-0.0371964797,
0.0413574763,
-0.0290883593,
-0.0215645041,
0.0454811826,
-0.0733546093,
0.0486216359,
0.0444939248,
-0.0119016189,
0.0635468215,
-0.024711404,
0.0527012125,
0.0281050056,
0.0015547194,
-0.0372677445,
0.0153930588,
-0.0483664535,
-0.0060994043,
-0.0452394746,
0.0555420667,
-0.0059825084,
-0.0048061451,
-0.0539851189,
-0.0186641235,
-0.0372521169,
0.0354709253,
-0.0429465473,
0.0294150561,
-0.0515316613,
-0.0100057926,
-0.0508965291,
-0.0461255088,
-0.0497065037,
0.0263384525,
-0.0151909357,
-0.0297822356,
-0.0081815431,
0.041363731,
-0.0066979122,
-0.0058925692,
-0.0040723397,
0.0213826112,
-0.0352304988,
0.0233718045,
-0.0656246841,
-0.0943451151,
0.0122842146,
-0.0211407673,
-0.038793508,
-0.0187269337,
-0.0261610225,
0.0099649327,
0.0243471991,
-0.015268351,
0.0084780008,
0.0479597002,
-0.0200100653,
0.0508582443,
0.0034137429,
0.0317264125,
0.0672879666,
0.0314391032,
-0.0536259152,
0.0351323262,
0.018897621,
0.0338407159,
0.0655450523,
-0.0070448751,
0.023532683,
-0.0121969003,
-0.0008389808,
-0.0373366177,
-0.0156633593,
0.034397427,
-0.0500942655,
0.0277744196,
-0.0327915661,
0.044302918,
0.0136297196,
0.0289914533,
0.0133391889,
0.0628376082,
-0.0245404225,
0.0270790868,
0.0841921791,
0.031315323,
0.0640109479,
0.0144268526,
-0.0361047275,
0.0034599102,
-0.0543265305,
-0.0000256163,
0.0200477093,
-0.0308661629,
-0.0112968059,
-0.0869572759,
-0.0522813015,
0.006834181,
0.0098181972,
-0.0098833106,
0.0524897501,
0.0250650644,
-0.0486768857,
0.0661092103,
0.0049202894,
-0.0403198637,
0.0251991116,
-0.0325251259,
0.0418625735,
0.0937257558,
0.0338569283,
-0.0433962755,
-0.0469588265,
0.0009541569,
0.0796617717,
0.0389267243,
0.0324970521,
-0.0397848077,
-0.0102366898,
-0.0744831637,
-0.0490501709,
-0.0222614463,
0.0221359339,
-0.0406153426,
0.0424686931,
0.0120606367,
0.020799486,
-0.0259808712,
-0.0681748465,
0.0744154304,
0.0078403233,
-0.0507438332,
-0.0309217889,
0.0300103333,
0.0000199402,
0.0421643667,
0.0260143187,
0.0108081475,
0.0216524117,
0.0104646431,
-0.0031577989,
0.0005783867,
-0.0899014175,
0.0177540574,
0.014545897,
-0.0563715436,
-0.0314408466,
-0.0245719105,
-0.0436022952,
-0.0126807149,
-0.0103190886,
-0.0668255165,
0.0140946964,
-0.0052562882,
-0.0087955082,
0.0044098995,
-0.0323354006,
0.0095419157,
0.0310405083,
0.0162285678,
0.0278124325,
0.0368759967,
-0.0027379869,
0.0106617594,
-0.0032642705,
0.0331810005,
-0.0606810227,
-0.0199493077,
-0.033990588,
-0.0025140913,
0.0297973882,
-0.058704704,
0.0374063514,
-0.0579914749,
-0.032917168,
-0.0041463654,
-0.0003226997,
0.0297876019,
-0.0528878123,
-0.000438495,
-0.0248797256,
0.0075180451,
-0.0189955737,
-0.0494594499,
-0.0175615046,
0.0594279505,
0.0041128849,
0.0111931674,
-0.030104747,
0.0128887836,
-0.0500488989,
0.0427653529,
0.0769028589,
-0.0300303046,
-0.0815807432,
0.0865309909,
-0.0014950276,
-0.053578347,
0.0289921314,
-0.0092937192,
0.0097279428,
0.0323398635,
0.0270026941,
0.0353743136,
0.0226762425,
0.0620767958,
0.0338980928,
-0.0125240255,
-0.0460413061,
0.0089744469,
0.0178068094,
-0.0278358404,
-0.0067583555,
-0.074482806,
-0.0262879692,
0.0054213395,
0.0164501201,
0.0014844353,
-0.0706062913,
0.0089423303,
-0.055424165,
-0.0185731798,
-0.0474913493,
-0.05296297,
-0.0207773503,
0.0330328122,
-0.0198863931,
-0.0300002079,
0.0907592401,
-0.0018502445,
0.0068384749,
-0.0465753041,
-0.0154413376,
-0.0219009053,
0.0464101881,
-0.0474537425,
0.0078829508,
0.0452198163,
-0.0168167036,
-0.0012969605,
-0.0224035438,
0.0685035288,
-0.0122012394,
0.0781988949,
-0.0700366423,
-0.0340774059,
0.0153583745,
0.0362213552,
-0.0433657691,
-0.0449868329,
0.0024817684,
-0.0266661048,
0.0086492598,
0.0157576129,
-0.0633970201,
-0.0137044657,
0.0104869548,
0.0293394905,
0.0017959543,
-0.0291950572,
0.0014378258,
-0.031320516,
0.0299072992,
0.0199680887,
0.0021616144,
-0.0329290964,
0.0396741815,
0.0475033335,
-0.0094989492,
-0.0540039092,
0.0024331312,
0.0031977699,
0.0061098379,
-0.0828608721,
0.0065780524,
0.0262457877,
0.0606728978,
-0.089773953,
0.004363318,
0.1045405716,
0.0364914164,
-0.0569175258,
0.0030990888,
-0.0294542834,
-0.0535348579,
0.0045254156,
-0.015262384,
-0.0540756062,
-0.049977053,
-0.0088442685,
0.0405972824,
-0.0028332151,
-0.0044429125,
-0.025914371,
-0.0632020831,
0.0326259658,
-0.0077497037,
0.0095644351,
0.0016276543,
-0.0293964632,
0.0056405482,
-0.0031433289,
0.004942501,
-0.0458957218,
-0.0328684971,
0.0149924932,
0.0429180935,
-0.023059072,
-0.0485417694,
0.0197243597,
0.0072109317,
0.0012754125,
0.0066627655,
0.01772549,
0.0014959495,
-0.0451107547,
0.0320144445,
0.0023185881,
0.023757888,
-0.0225649159,
0.0452396646,
0.0041033234,
0.0600250624,
-0.0302295033,
0.0398490354,
-0.0107502155,
-0.057301335,
0.0555083342,
0.0746177882,
0.0060842372,
-0.0049987216,
-0.0398548916,
0.0705484152,
-0.0021740233,
0.092823796,
0.0314600505,
-0.0026533462,
0.0280400757,
-0.0219984464,
0.026220426,
-0.0237026718,
0.0137588885,
-0.0146206478,
-0.0576424599,
0.019784119,
-0.038899783,
-0.0548090078,
0.0580556206,
0.0077594048,
0.053145308,
0.0104223927,
0.0094462549,
0.0159948524,
-0.033142224,
0.0108686695,
0.0074974848,
0.0106163146,
-0.0311155822,
-0.0378991403,
-0.0069100223,
-0.0075779855,
-0.0181809589,
0.0652856827,
-0.0068735071,
-0.0409842879,
0.0050652563,
0.0262529161,
0.0259193443,
0.0195358396,
-0.007790742,
-0.032939624,
0.0348128378,
0.0247392897,
-0.0491474792,
0.0181489345,
0.0094088502,
0.0214835908,
-0.0021660302,
0.023822384,
-0.0296024475,
-0.0101850508,
-0.0288987774,
0.0092270877,
-0.0205643233,
-0.0404016338,
0.0309511274,
0.0275655463,
0.0063612144,
-0.0347046144,
-0.019555632,
-0.0268824324,
0.0387980491,
-0.0009992551,
-0.0343616791,
0.0009330313,
0.0641082451,
-0.012297323,
-0.033401262,
-0.0135971159,
0.0149834324,
-0.042414479,
0.0019223164,
0.0002323703,
0.0340993591,
0.0395165384,
0.0572398044,
-0.0397550799,
0.0103939697,
-0.0350150689,
-0.0012767354,
-0.0208373144,
0.0421832576,
0.0433980897,
0.0921934918,
0.0076654251,
0.0176706444,
-0.0159532074,
-0.0025167121,
-0.0005608722,
-0.0118457116,
-0.0348262452,
0.0123586534,
0.0104801478,
-0.0081541827,
0.0333839245,
-0.0364384875,
0.0009006981,
0.0206465293,
0.0534041189,
0.0040433374,
-0.0424090326,
0.0171789713,
0.0318235457,
0.0368200876,
0.0181999095,
0.0131592527,
-0.0593034551,
0.0584049597,
0.0292791333,
-0.0600320622,
-0.0303233173,
-0.0049263653,
0.0249558296,
0.0496114083,
-0.0114497319,
0.006229707,
-0.0735773072,
-0.0498908684,
0.0286129732,
0.0337481722,
0.0247763041,
-0.0044265944,
0.0376508422,
0.0471245907,
0.0145042501,
-0.0697430372,
-0.0447217859,
0.0212713927,
-0.0493371226,
0.0044682785,
-0.0580414459,
-6.47485284e-33,
-0.0661762878,
-0.0773046166,
0.0016735718,
0.0338998735,
-0.0035888124,
0.0429967977,
-0.0573276579,
-0.003361885,
0.0044590156,
0.0703413785,
0.0146369673,
0.0242930762,
0.0219147932,
-0.0181755517,
0.0150651522,
-0.0119255492,
0.0428402126,
0.0056146309,
-0.0199267678,
0.0370597504,
0.0185475592,
-0.0177268703,
0.0694693401,
-0.0759700462,
0.0883210674,
-0.0313391685,
-0.0507036336,
0.0138237588,
-0.0288318228,
0.0646365434,
-0.0232933983,
0.018618023,
0.0122073339,
0.0146464696,
0.0161330532,
-0.0009824443,
-0.0633929595,
-0.0491651297,
0.0589108765,
0.0070690583,
-0.0704349875,
-0.0493756868,
0.034112677,
-0.0211921837,
-0.0298335478,
0.0001243333,
0.0943266153,
-0.0198661406,
0.0272931904,
0.0108193057,
-0.0781619474,
0.0146526238,
-0.0424629785,
-0.033465486,
0.0031006385,
0.078027375,
-0.0096242717,
-0.0202367511,
-0.0591731034,
0.0435840115,
0.045783598,
-0.0124312323,
0.0608947128,
-0.0372706242,
-0.0233003143,
0.0269030109,
-0.0110554192,
-0.0262817182,
-0.0475349054,
-0.029654175,
-0.0225685686,
0.0209920723,
0.0337621123,
0.0380015783,
0.0201702528,
0.0218701363,
-0.0276242588,
0.0511670001,
0.0387970507,
0.0367644131,
0.0104300175,
-0.059553273,
-0.0750754923,
0.0111532155,
-0.0494927801,
-0.0088260379,
-0.0208076816,
-0.0490501523,
0.029380599,
-0.0134843383,
-0.0299674105,
0.0109943654,
-0.0419353731,
0.0058876863,
0.0092043877,
-0.0378950126,
0.0348703228,
-0.0213328023,
0.004625442,
-0.0095186485,
-0.0479094163,
-0.0062378375,
0.018429134,
-0.0043094954,
0.0594782978,
0.0095724836,
0.0272981953,
0.0276682172,
-0.0125876181,
0.0037982706,
-0.0055774674,
-0.0342485681,
-0.0336350203,
-0.0474771224,
0.0284957867,
0.0291642863,
-0.0387416519,
0.0426934175,
-0.0181058235,
0.0157578606,
-0.0023924462,
-0.0279769767,
0.0157663096,
0.0163557604,
-0.0072640185,
-0.0147335408,
0.0163857583,
-0.0391644761,
0.0115304608,
-0.0325253382,
0.0077141626,
0.0111283259,
2.882e-7,
0.0417409949,
0.0551413931,
0.0153110148,
-0.0115491506,
-0.032303527,
0.0326681398,
-0.0108947875,
-0.0349562839,
-0.0108108977,
-0.0052515725,
0.0464170873,
0.0031851414,
0.0119625106,
0.0207469277,
-0.0453631207,
-0.0315729752,
0.0303936619,
-0.0255071558,
-0.0263780486,
0.0299010873,
0.0976056308,
0.0024148023,
0.0280797705,
0.0143949278,
-0.0343449079,
-0.0516353436,
0.0099883722,
-0.0356479771,
-0.0036860879,
0.0162552707,
0.0257287025,
0.0034984178,
0.0021484371,
0.0269320905,
-0.0193695016,
-0.0344188586,
0.0322677083,
0.064944379,
-0.0182806961,
0.0083905617,
-0.0451297015,
0.0071487962,
0.0167752672,
-0.0491060466,
0.0026588205,
-0.0192832593,
-0.0126579767,
0.0364907607,
-0.0376164466,
0.0019521886,
0.024392264,
0.0107139051,
-0.0003951095,
-0.017209433,
-0.0107387761,
-0.0136584183,
-0.0348644368,
-0.0745267719,
0.0032394209,
0.0179720614,
-0.0016227206,
0.0156291295,
-0.0197459105,
0.0025076161,
0.0046390211,
-0.062061511,
0.005612941,
2.214002513e-34,
0.0094399778,
-0.0265384093,
0.0188689008,
-0.0157480445,
0.0291804317,
0.0226181708,
-0.0108221937,
0.0233262461,
0.0246070269,
-0.0030621579,
-0.0261314418
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.