id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15402v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15402v3 | Navigate through Enigmatic Labyrinth A Survey of Chain of Thought Reasoning: Advances, Frontiers and Future | 2023-09-27T04:53:10 | 2024-06-06T01:58:54 | Zheng Chu, Jingchang Chen, Qianglong Chen, Weijiang Yu, Tao He, Haotian Wang, Weihua Peng, Ming Liu, Bing Qin, Ting Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Reasoning, a fundamental cognitive process integral to human intelligence,
has garnered substantial interest within artificial intelligence. Notably,
recent studies have revealed that chain-of-thought prompting significantly
enhances LLM's reasoning capabilities, which attracts widespread attention from
both academics and industry. In this paper, we systematically investigate
relevant research, summarizing advanced methods through a meticulous taxonomy
that offers novel perspectives. Moreover, we delve into the current frontiers
and delineate the challenges and future directions, thereby shedding light on
future research. Furthermore, we engage in a discussion about open questions.
We hope this paper serves as an introduction for beginners and fosters future
research. Resources have been made publicly available at
https://github.com/zchuz/CoT-Reasoning-Survey | [
0.0287401378,
0.034168154,
-0.0213498846,
0.0304098409,
-0.0816778019,
0.0182736814,
0.0052138926,
0.0180839431,
0.0197808221,
0.0019613749,
-0.0189087708,
0.0075412318,
0.0103560193,
-0.0041102464,
0.024583675,
-0.0551526546,
-0.0028439059,
-0.0507089347,
-0.0025302295,
-0.0056712278,
-0.0470748618,
0.0147537589,
-0.0612042584,
0.0137213096,
-0.0095119067,
-0.0321575888,
-0.0511790849,
0.0244117305,
0.0592550933,
-0.0733538717,
-0.0291359834,
0.031283509,
0.0080486545,
0.0171676315,
0.0000025039,
-0.0850524381,
-0.0460904278,
-0.0178316589,
-0.0430810563,
-0.0692569688,
-0.0551286601,
0.0475227498,
0.0399897359,
0.0415282324,
-0.0339136273,
0.0708603114,
-0.0078750076,
0.0595771223,
0.0037119277,
0.0326537341,
0.0061214073,
0.0065743341,
0.0049338313,
0.0082915891,
0.027755158,
-0.0431635417,
-0.0168913323,
-0.0042281896,
0.0101795485,
0.0050852341,
-0.003103683,
-0.0125544621,
0.0295548718,
0.0108596133,
0.0047210171,
0.0379345641,
-0.0114470087,
-0.0434315354,
-0.0093565239,
0.0444732644,
0.0342668779,
-0.012423533,
0.0059602549,
0.000410689,
0.0231290944,
0.0360904001,
-0.0396783873,
0.0272167549,
-0.0354863256,
0.0177607816,
0.0217391476,
0.0325759687,
0.0097381361,
-0.0111661535,
-0.0514040962,
0.0725901499,
-0.0365696214,
-0.046252057,
0.0568713024,
0.0256398432,
0.02628625,
-0.0706906542,
0.0070164031,
0.0418285467,
-0.0456912592,
-0.0089771301,
0.0504097492,
0.0163315646,
0.0125236642,
-0.0051531554,
0.0301981084,
0.0285824537,
-0.0219992138,
0.0140212402,
-0.0537164025,
0.0018499771,
-0.0455427915,
0.0344290398,
-0.0241102111,
0.0144362729,
-0.0593324229,
-0.0061197695,
-0.0102495188,
0.0769247711,
0.0024968293,
0.0053859404,
-0.0125499601,
0.0098165432,
-0.0321520679,
0.0284261759,
-0.0117507186,
0.0101957479,
0.0557475463,
-0.0115171494,
-0.0810056701,
-0.0160383619,
-0.0568871684,
0.0434057675,
0.0381480157,
0.0105403448,
-0.0036711909,
-0.0179586615,
-0.0018526569,
-0.0073528574,
0.0421827883,
0.0821539685,
-0.0103155682,
-0.0120538836,
-0.0670230091,
-0.0666915253,
0.0121348286,
-0.066592969,
0.0376132131,
-0.0681675822,
0.0001603374,
0.0247426797,
0.0041053304,
0.0548814982,
0.016216455,
0.0294362847,
-0.0325454623,
0.0785820559,
-0.0178554617,
-0.0059480616,
0.0106738321,
0.0347995237,
-0.031365864,
0.0200990029,
0.0360563211,
0.0746700019,
0.0110452184,
0.0523373261,
0.0171184521,
-0.017623039,
-0.0035781311,
-0.0620728582,
0.0233243611,
-0.0017053641,
-0.0575670004,
0.009806755,
-0.0332862847,
0.0250135995,
-0.041601859,
0.0340493508,
0.0394311026,
0.0868020505,
0.0261369701,
0.0080205407,
0.0523535758,
-0.0398145877,
-0.0039286828,
0.0303799883,
-0.0285750199,
0.0907499418,
-0.0439991839,
-0.0226254389,
-0.0044957269,
0.0252882931,
-0.014599218,
-0.0679858625,
-0.0050171232,
0.0285453089,
0.0076364437,
0.0108732516,
0.0322877578,
-0.0140962144,
-0.0021351981,
0.0212477595,
0.0103313969,
-0.0308515895,
-0.0484498143,
-0.0445200354,
-0.0098379506,
0.031058684,
0.0386580862,
-0.0113281514,
-0.0389338583,
-0.0192732569,
0.0155552709,
0.017566191,
-0.0181415007,
0.0108712092,
-0.033883445,
-0.0394072309,
-0.0045831958,
0.0044178846,
-0.0112745902,
0.0103765037,
-0.0251564216,
0.0083542652,
-0.031702362,
-0.0092637381,
0.0526714586,
-0.0016508579,
0.010531228,
0.0369244702,
-0.0189430416,
0.0615639612,
0.0194125064,
0.0135206301,
0.0332707688,
0.0170461833,
0.0268644169,
-0.0109587861,
-0.0671208724,
0.0279718749,
-0.0325186662,
-0.0111623015,
0.0099673113,
-0.0716004819,
-0.0432026982,
-0.0319547206,
-0.0118991481,
-0.024469763,
0.0077379234,
-0.0075948075,
-0.000342378,
-0.027025884,
0.0297196731,
0.0015845055,
-0.0347447246,
-0.0037378399,
0.0982186124,
-0.028744692,
-0.0125203682,
0.0260357857,
0.0068413462,
0.0414142646,
-0.0183138419,
0.0371947102,
0.0057443758,
-0.0048474651,
-0.0328042433,
-0.0095524834,
0.0290596467,
-0.0772021785,
-0.0079345517,
-0.0673790053,
-0.0060528615,
0.0065589179,
0.0215385128,
-0.026506776,
-0.0470131673,
0.0091452664,
-0.0003758526,
-0.0340733342,
0.0313554481,
0.0223541167,
0.0010960607,
0.0557363406,
-0.0372945257,
-0.0423810072,
0.0337000564,
0.033323627,
-0.0533131026,
0.0433471352,
0.0174167063,
-0.0647735968,
-0.0053885314,
0.013118539,
-0.0543842912,
-0.0064746574,
-0.0175420158,
0.0235171337,
0.0552548431,
0.0081491712,
0.0503703505,
0.0762875676,
0.005211812,
-0.0190207604,
0.0601802319,
-0.0108104898,
-0.0203239769,
0.0293030515,
-0.0087834056,
0.0166343823,
0.0041343253,
-0.0283014551,
-0.0292761493,
0.0043998039,
0.0131249093,
0.0080493186,
-0.0480480492,
0.0076911729,
0.0468730927,
-0.0180367567,
-0.0393542722,
-0.0376264639,
-0.000085554,
0.1415554285,
0.0000018675,
-0.023352854,
0.0857043862,
-0.0075508379,
0.0327232517,
-0.0299081635,
0.0186233614,
-0.0450072438,
0.0848880932,
-0.0069222748,
0.0034880089,
0.0190659296,
-0.0051821726,
-0.0557828471,
-0.0116202496,
-0.0031164573,
-0.0024872411,
0.0342552774,
-0.0489774346,
-0.0233780574,
-0.0107552987,
-0.0562221855,
-0.0504409298,
0.0487545207,
-0.0344929881,
-0.004394793,
-0.0194637422,
-0.0141293043,
-0.0054563768,
-0.0542875491,
0.0419665538,
-0.0277309027,
0.0224748626,
-0.0548376031,
-0.0229295362,
0.0212602913,
0.0106235072,
0.0228309799,
0.0785166174,
-0.0073026652,
0.0443171449,
0.0746559277,
0.0389625393,
0.0017536727,
-0.0098609366,
0.0488829464,
-0.004311664,
0.0038046071,
-0.0086771827,
0.0039989469,
-0.003955116,
-0.0076490641,
-0.0020785183,
0.0900612399,
0.0391760357,
-0.0496792607,
0.0136241661,
-0.0705210119,
0.0071491222,
0.015756119,
0.024932757,
-0.0806641951,
-0.0256160814,
0.0313153118,
-0.0372968651,
-0.0632360727,
-0.0623894297,
-0.0032479507,
-0.0718837306,
0.0507709272,
-0.0468861908,
0.0115218507,
-0.0128957191,
-0.0396409146,
0.0085004345,
0.0458370633,
-0.0593990386,
0.0103810616,
0.0258547757,
-0.0069059185,
0.0261160936,
-0.0191268269,
0.0294231474,
0.0329461247,
-0.0349019207,
-0.0107063064,
0.0043668444,
0.0375332162,
0.0246877056,
-0.0725122839,
0.0169295464,
-0.0206534937,
0.0175298303,
-0.0215732921,
-0.0007720707,
0.0018762934,
0.0145361656,
-0.0347750261,
0.0270715691,
-0.009307011,
-0.0510327034,
0.0491163395,
0.1264781207,
-0.0679365695,
-0.0331206098,
-0.017006997,
0.0370508693,
-0.0536915138,
0.0565381497,
0.0067475876,
-0.0242270529,
0.0053123604,
-0.0089207673,
-0.0403645709,
-0.0052195359,
-0.0263064634,
0.0085541653,
0.0571761467,
0.0475760661,
-0.0589856021,
-0.0121553019,
-0.0045959274,
0.0641663,
-0.0173681825,
0.0280574672,
-0.011482277,
0.0262863804,
0.0027012306,
-0.0108925961,
-0.0214782245,
-0.0003034208,
-0.017578369,
0.0302100331,
-0.0153492158,
-0.0641545579,
-0.0200315788,
0.0274598971,
-0.0598439127,
-0.0149514992,
-0.0477137864,
0.0412098058,
0.0328479595,
0.0285702627,
-0.0002686336,
0.0225404315,
0.0465196334,
0.0339033417,
0.0113159791,
0.0213688184,
0.0246249586,
0.0633750781,
0.0143589443,
0.0256837793,
-0.0147368424,
0.0077445675,
0.0083958413,
0.0221719388,
-0.0145282838,
-0.036990542,
0.0334898755,
0.0055017406,
0.0376120433,
-0.008736996,
-0.013672119,
-0.0085159121,
0.0597830899,
0.0064077866,
-0.0385694355,
-0.0170440674,
-0.0006489996,
-0.0210639704,
0.028834125,
-0.0133085838,
-0.0717494115,
0.0052179606,
0.0034794642,
0.0403664559,
-0.023332702,
0.0311556123,
0.0696860477,
0.010968036,
-0.0217532124,
0.010900557,
-0.0053834799,
-0.0015295839,
0.0542755909,
-0.0049538184,
0.1229232699,
0.047560025,
-0.0354794934,
-0.0622355267,
0.0280961972,
-0.091830641,
-0.066788964,
0.0666107535,
0.0081175398,
0.0408745632,
0.015355817,
-0.0199458431,
-0.0640780628,
0.0113175772,
0.0754647627,
0.0281716138,
0.0194133446,
-0.0260293912,
0.004774278,
0.0022049362,
0.0037341269,
0.0065949271,
0.0108130462,
-0.0612010323,
-0.0168666467,
-0.0130069694,
-0.0211078804,
-0.0214348268,
-0.0489428304,
-0.0485083722,
0.0216463115,
0.0154732261,
0.0103123756,
-0.0793609172,
-0.0551051907,
0.0188790224,
0.0009418781,
0.0653766841,
-0.0017141356,
0.0334081054,
0.0725373253,
0.0260433163,
-0.0501502864,
0.0085948166,
-0.0220573694,
0.0012806014,
-0.0085614175,
-0.023605803,
-6.827884651e-33,
0.0114851799,
-0.0755061656,
0.0452947691,
0.0418394059,
-0.0074500656,
-0.0154417148,
-0.0282707047,
0.0133696627,
-0.0182940736,
0.0165356006,
-0.0318565518,
-0.0027306962,
0.0025683972,
-0.0222875904,
0.0137208486,
-0.0055903899,
-0.0100455452,
0.0175792072,
-0.0368623883,
-0.0125921108,
0.0481389239,
-0.0106298747,
-0.0019845432,
-0.0437701605,
0.0174572784,
-0.0005709425,
-0.0016429581,
0.0403629132,
-0.0859642848,
0.0282124728,
0.0152696222,
-0.0316547416,
0.0471224189,
-0.0040231189,
0.019763438,
0.0157261062,
-0.0554638393,
-0.0377849974,
0.0170602258,
-0.042134881,
-0.0612882636,
-0.0274541099,
-0.0109166894,
0.0113440994,
-0.0217662919,
-0.0330965482,
0.0391825065,
-0.016521262,
0.0146327717,
-0.0013343593,
-0.0295905098,
-0.019136047,
-0.0324598141,
0.0064148037,
0.0052373237,
0.0395166986,
-0.0341070667,
-0.0022342843,
-0.043539729,
0.0357278064,
-0.031391114,
-0.0473578498,
0.0586428009,
-0.0417866893,
-0.0213954058,
0.0425959863,
0.0064387638,
-0.0041055582,
-0.0676474646,
0.0000897088,
-0.0342102237,
0.0820005536,
0.069057554,
-0.0133988149,
0.0050578415,
0.0554615185,
-0.1026756242,
0.0120960642,
0.0010541267,
0.0411865264,
0.0313819759,
-0.0031103967,
-0.0189237911,
-0.005812176,
-0.0155349318,
-0.0389290787,
-0.0425703153,
-0.023981981,
0.016593188,
-0.0032058652,
-0.0015888854,
-0.0263078045,
0.0158814155,
-0.0007038236,
0.0142837446,
0.0063308724,
0.029294014,
0.0271255821,
0.0066066161,
0.0037445256,
-0.0313275792,
0.0075206147,
-0.0084510893,
0.0224365089,
0.047885064,
-0.0064700255,
0.0545003042,
-0.0216347873,
-0.0199476425,
-0.027654279,
-0.0773804933,
0.013534504,
-0.0080055967,
-0.0349179879,
0.0274209604,
0.0124821328,
-0.0178257693,
0.0219729003,
-0.0151407402,
0.006609431,
-0.0421797819,
0.0553743318,
-0.0545018204,
0.0195925497,
-0.0024586325,
0.0001725811,
-0.0317192525,
-0.0251476057,
-0.0007537133,
-0.0689665005,
-0.0141364597,
0.0256753657,
3.188e-7,
-0.0474371165,
0.0259125885,
0.0080541652,
0.0236551575,
0.0343539156,
0.020083189,
-0.0288981609,
-0.0312749781,
0.0300014447,
-0.0654321164,
0.01698629,
0.0585851558,
0.034902487,
0.0523973107,
-0.0516348928,
-0.0687681586,
-0.0041253977,
-0.0500013307,
-0.0377174914,
0.0090977838,
0.0690732151,
-0.0042699827,
0.0226511545,
-0.0321974456,
0.0159894507,
0.0226513743,
0.0216211528,
-0.0186016224,
0.0436212271,
-0.0235282425,
0.0043818126,
-0.035649389,
0.0018508553,
0.0803964436,
0.0198352206,
-0.0076739732,
-0.0368246548,
-0.021872675,
0.0470095463,
-0.0385601521,
-0.0051053348,
0.0013674076,
0.0460932329,
-0.0544235706,
0.0872612596,
-0.0182069894,
-0.0214329176,
0.0403143056,
0.0262695942,
-0.0067863581,
0.0146125322,
0.0472324267,
-0.0164795648,
0.0023586003,
0.0058520697,
0.0270817894,
0.0127315959,
-0.1087857112,
0.0029351651,
0.0329080448,
-0.0102360183,
-0.0514413938,
-0.0159316994,
0.0118735684,
0.0302512087,
-0.0274096187,
-0.0488435924,
3.228723446e-34,
-0.0257928539,
-0.0387951173,
0.0333843865,
0.0164941829,
0.0480275452,
-0.0057279877,
-0.0312905535,
-0.0103510329,
0.0491582155,
-0.0943965912,
-0.0131863598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15337v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15337v1 | Beyond the Chat: Executable and Verifiable Text-Editing with LLMs | 2023-09-27T00:56:17 | 2023-09-27T00:56:17 | Philippe Laban, Jesse Vig, Marti A. Hearst, Caiming Xiong, Chien-Sheng Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Conversational interfaces powered by Large Language Models (LLMs) have
recently become a popular way to obtain feedback during document editing.
However, standard chat-based conversational interfaces do not support
transparency and verifiability of the editing changes that they suggest. To
give the author more agency when editing with an LLM, we present InkSync, an
editing interface that suggests executable edits directly within the document
being edited. Because LLMs are known to introduce factual errors, Inksync also
supports a 3-stage approach to mitigate this risk: Warn authors when a
suggested edit introduces new information, help authors Verify the new
information's accuracy through external search, and allow an auditor to perform
an a-posteriori verification by Auditing the document via a trace of all
auto-generated content. Two usability studies confirm the effectiveness of
InkSync's components when compared to standard LLM-based chat interfaces,
leading to more accurate, more efficient editing, and improved user experience. | [
0.0606836304,
0.0229410939,
-0.0051672044,
0.0024427462,
-0.0570949763,
-0.0114982966,
0.0166121852,
0.0363718346,
0.0242489316,
-0.0386615507,
-0.0518714823,
0.0129752411,
0.035636358,
0.0378793366,
0.0218314379,
-0.0181680191,
0.0422090068,
-0.0072221472,
0.011389073,
0.0295593757,
0.0348683335,
0.0086746579,
0.0012986379,
0.046054177,
-0.0000627319,
-0.0513957515,
-0.0413340777,
-0.0009825478,
-0.0437104851,
0.0352857485,
-0.0375344902,
0.1010354385,
-0.0051077399,
0.0860488117,
0.0000024495,
-0.0518376976,
-0.0326601006,
0.0218470935,
-0.06021934,
0.0476352833,
0.041240599,
-0.0133827031,
-0.0644449815,
-0.0153688835,
0.0162274558,
0.0194009747,
0.0295209978,
0.0428582095,
0.0838805139,
0.0371602587,
-0.0235772431,
0.0463134311,
-0.0063101556,
0.0010803561,
0.0248895995,
-0.006058136,
0.0140891541,
-0.0003545733,
0.0456477739,
0.0331253484,
0.0442487821,
0.0316488221,
-0.011921471,
-0.1027479842,
0.0081956806,
-0.0007170648,
-0.0339066163,
-0.0465327241,
0.0023682883,
0.0182727855,
0.0502410941,
-0.008960885,
-0.0230241437,
-0.0164826866,
-0.0083110882,
0.054071486,
-0.0487516262,
0.0152174234,
-0.0022199638,
-0.0477856584,
-0.0044800742,
-0.0799922273,
0.0330253579,
0.0104973111,
0.0400824919,
-0.0145634236,
0.0337677188,
-0.0235098843,
-0.0449472927,
0.0076715625,
0.0181221664,
-0.0949650183,
0.0155957518,
0.0346371867,
-0.0153024755,
-0.0214036703,
-0.0310192071,
-0.0266244579,
0.04256282,
-0.0641599149,
0.0171120781,
0.0033884374,
-0.0127364006,
0.0444436148,
0.0077765551,
0.0351778753,
0.0022876759,
0.0043939576,
0.0444944687,
0.0177829377,
0.039857354,
-0.0164967962,
-0.0397732556,
0.0093108667,
-0.0432116091,
0.0005746946,
-0.0326937027,
0.0546716452,
-0.004700576,
0.0868683755,
0.0128002791,
-0.032439962,
-0.0109972795,
-0.0499907508,
-0.0243817475,
-0.0385063738,
0.0540671162,
0.0076711331,
-0.0116978316,
-0.0399142802,
0.0098966388,
0.0107505005,
0.019934237,
0.0164975841,
-0.0280435402,
0.0540860407,
-0.0010385991,
0.0298407413,
-0.0153764375,
-0.0438830033,
-0.0172380805,
-0.011700308,
-0.0797749013,
-0.058099512,
-0.0130165787,
0.0261084531,
-0.0419837683,
-0.0485746898,
0.0067234482,
0.0132448692,
0.0002467733,
0.0257322732,
-0.0784978941,
0.0170494001,
0.0444087312,
0.0264429767,
-0.0492744148,
-0.003127435,
0.0322287455,
0.0109163364,
0.068401821,
0.0197405498,
0.0657954812,
0.0501154661,
-0.0402270444,
0.0164619759,
0.0033445416,
-0.0013478999,
0.030564107,
-0.0079548648,
-0.0514345281,
0.0335366502,
-0.0384547263,
0.0041629141,
0.1175005212,
0.0415365882,
0.0116923153,
0.0094449418,
-0.0410235077,
-0.0157766733,
0.0236089546,
0.0001648669,
-0.0268551651,
0.0488170832,
-0.0019317514,
-0.0038755629,
0.016474871,
-0.0481446199,
0.0146533931,
-0.0300784726,
-0.0499757417,
-0.0050268336,
0.006690478,
-0.0288367663,
0.0168298464,
-0.0068693543,
-0.00444153,
0.0004626339,
0.0113286795,
-0.0721512288,
-0.0384712555,
-0.0534998477,
0.0099902228,
0.1295200735,
0.0958712474,
0.005178791,
-0.0123064825,
-0.0620034449,
0.0044465065,
0.0420346335,
0.0597362369,
-0.0229642522,
-0.02439663,
-0.0132373851,
0.0018530504,
-0.0271508414,
0.002161257,
-0.0090293381,
0.0176738705,
-0.0166530423,
0.0122633409,
-0.0049175196,
-0.0583049133,
-0.000834635,
-0.0130724981,
-0.0297837742,
-0.026319351,
0.0351053402,
-0.0090667568,
0.0092525827,
-0.0317845531,
0.0170072466,
-0.006429493,
0.033645045,
-0.0148082664,
0.0298737381,
0.048835285,
0.0443445183,
0.0201626569,
0.006322098,
-0.0342692174,
-0.0377309695,
0.0172991958,
-0.0014177816,
-0.0219124947,
-0.0424757153,
0.0391284786,
-0.0560368337,
0.0501812771,
-0.0202000774,
-0.0335232131,
0.004913195,
-0.033378005,
0.0142863402,
-0.0089989351,
0.0169513505,
0.0224538483,
0.0089187287,
-0.0028237945,
-0.0208749641,
0.0425484292,
0.0522326529,
-0.0046938839,
0.0010216734,
0.0268914755,
0.0270544887,
-0.0472608283,
-0.0838298723,
-0.0171235166,
-0.0090524079,
0.0221526101,
0.0245694742,
0.0391264185,
-0.0355905965,
-0.0259168148,
-0.0060095941,
-0.0177830644,
0.0255541597,
0.0143376514,
0.0487416349,
-0.0281280708,
-0.0000136462,
-0.0499351434,
0.0158411711,
-0.0077397414,
0.030456055,
0.0484160334,
-0.0768172219,
-0.0436917357,
0.0407080017,
-0.0131346751,
-0.0151418848,
0.0259731188,
-0.010778957,
-0.0014962537,
-0.0205622874,
0.0353475064,
0.0251646899,
-0.0058233528,
0.0254163574,
0.0537667871,
-0.033957459,
-0.0265123844,
-0.0399896018,
0.0446435697,
-0.0053012106,
0.0393835008,
-0.0131167499,
0.0553210601,
0.03134913,
-0.0042055771,
0.00017642,
0.0182109065,
0.031656079,
0.0095359739,
0.0241368823,
0.0211270675,
-0.059480533,
-0.0398546122,
0.0378806032,
-0.0458743013,
-0.0723421052,
0.0421766341,
-0.0610877462,
-0.0058269226,
-0.007998975,
-0.0305432044,
-0.0013045232,
0.0426461212,
-0.0270516314,
0.0062518767,
-0.0220009759,
-0.0067343363,
-0.0354805738,
-0.0078352327,
0.0899660289,
-0.0121865254,
0.0213283598,
-0.0681153685,
0.0203433968,
-0.0167399459,
-0.0133768171,
-0.0117020449,
-0.0337239616,
-0.029507814,
0.0044292007,
0.0458727628,
-0.0284661166,
-0.0192674249,
0.0167565159,
0.0660035908,
0.0899937227,
-0.0099618332,
-0.0219861045,
-0.005364778,
-0.0484288037,
-0.0260028131,
-0.0407379195,
-0.0164173972,
-0.0698985383,
0.0148293069,
0.0871619508,
-0.0321038775,
-0.0309873801,
-0.0020148396,
-0.0429806188,
-0.0049051773,
-0.0421463475,
-0.0272204522,
-0.0402293205,
0.0061932602,
-0.0575771444,
0.0052376189,
0.1069038361,
0.0253880024,
-0.0669961199,
-0.0248872302,
-0.0727474466,
-0.009972278,
0.0229281113,
0.0517667904,
-0.1003763154,
0.0079992041,
0.0414293446,
-0.0070273494,
-0.0129122715,
-0.0205226708,
0.0216126163,
-0.0301913135,
0.0721855685,
0.0062287212,
0.0199323297,
0.0005243197,
-0.0237026252,
0.0520113818,
0.0495128334,
-0.0335831903,
0.018207537,
0.0074792253,
-0.0206633732,
-0.0501841567,
-0.0383881591,
0.0313796736,
-0.0279014558,
-0.0328880921,
-0.0016679142,
0.0593639538,
0.0278849509,
0.0337687321,
0.0105384262,
0.0593784899,
0.0756418556,
-0.0083545186,
-0.007790193,
0.0129458876,
0.0028436,
0.0349282958,
-0.0407297835,
0.0037639188,
0.0794558376,
-0.0347478501,
0.0279352143,
0.0619701445,
-0.0528103597,
0.0294873379,
0.0145175811,
-0.014794494,
0.0304916743,
0.0100373039,
0.04256339,
-0.039795246,
-0.039240893,
-0.0706825554,
-0.0067817396,
0.0221643355,
-0.0008904993,
-0.0289585516,
-0.0352425911,
-0.0223235879,
-0.0774978101,
-0.0241068043,
0.0216299891,
-0.0002803636,
0.0669712648,
0.0021413493,
0.0326195545,
-0.0196724273,
0.0220728368,
-0.0517642424,
-0.0265265219,
0.024210833,
-0.011786717,
0.016173318,
0.0116748363,
-0.0088196332,
0.0262909494,
0.0118969427,
-0.0092065679,
-0.0380690284,
-0.0480762534,
0.0132587953,
0.0200825129,
0.0206068084,
-0.0257186592,
-0.0785576254,
-0.0112307332,
0.0018300827,
-0.0459705517,
0.0126430597,
0.0136819631,
0.0309342984,
0.0015529293,
-0.0065240432,
-0.0551971719,
-0.0633591413,
0.0092446171,
-0.0338184386,
-0.0194154605,
-0.0980464965,
-0.0002694619,
0.0549446456,
-0.0155228581,
0.0280631892,
0.0465812832,
-0.0689690337,
0.0526758134,
-0.0436082743,
-0.0129686911,
0.0065206843,
0.0318001509,
-0.0329118632,
-0.032580968,
0.0234652031,
0.0613555387,
-0.0625571311,
0.0338910446,
-0.0180106238,
0.0627677068,
-0.013588896,
-0.0029411938,
0.0266869031,
0.0059945332,
-0.0196391381,
0.0184642896,
-0.0196824353,
0.0155627383,
-0.0196376089,
0.0386680178,
-0.0049803234,
-0.0434878208,
0.0207725316,
0.027807178,
-0.0730251372,
-0.0115098311,
0.005607672,
0.0947204605,
0.0165167917,
0.015632797,
0.0337554589,
-0.0604016036,
-0.0190231819,
-0.0222703293,
0.0356215909,
0.0238809381,
-0.0234299842,
-0.041563388,
-0.0113745499,
-0.0150115266,
0.0205744039,
0.0241969079,
-0.0572242476,
0.0440770201,
-0.036879804,
-0.0876601189,
-0.0273981802,
-0.0291864667,
0.0092317266,
-0.0010885169,
-0.0455611274,
-0.048517637,
-0.040816728,
-0.019144902,
0.0143844821,
0.0394021012,
-0.0224985033,
-0.0229759868,
-0.031928625,
0.0721670017,
0.0241126157,
-0.0086301593,
-0.0456043407,
0.0404992998,
-0.0033037807,
0.0019363578,
-0.0401751995,
-5.705833783e-33,
0.0099655027,
-0.0588584468,
0.001612206,
0.0467811562,
0.0210910216,
-0.0041627134,
-0.0663043186,
0.0070428238,
0.0317130834,
0.0039858804,
-0.0495804846,
0.0337982066,
0.0064781215,
-0.040661566,
-0.0038641612,
0.0684564337,
0.0634426922,
0.0155132851,
-0.0138899125,
0.0011162393,
0.0225566197,
-0.0087058498,
0.0302887335,
-0.0873030871,
0.0683265999,
-0.0021601901,
-0.0050599435,
-0.0035881063,
-0.0493890382,
0.0373575911,
0.0100568617,
-0.0083521493,
-0.0081724562,
0.002563244,
-0.0124742845,
0.0217434205,
0.0036789032,
-0.0015395696,
0.0040966175,
0.0480570458,
0.0205040127,
-0.0200521592,
0.0333417356,
-0.0131118475,
-0.0356894396,
0.027202636,
-0.0048534218,
-0.0166688841,
-0.0395053886,
-0.0034603919,
-0.0652259961,
0.0257171113,
0.0194370151,
-0.000344502,
-0.0022452341,
0.0200875457,
-0.0044335807,
-0.0779562518,
-0.081506595,
0.0197600219,
0.0693449304,
-0.0091157863,
0.0282812715,
-0.0095042605,
-0.0123823425,
0.0373386852,
0.0091207856,
0.0351430587,
-0.0320167318,
0.0318223983,
-0.0148745459,
0.0304723661,
0.0291147325,
0.0892562792,
-0.0441276543,
-0.010491549,
-0.0218577478,
0.0471276678,
-0.00070163,
0.0331736207,
0.0342411436,
0.0138807073,
-0.0132327033,
-0.0136715155,
-0.0182453152,
0.0136961881,
-0.0307118073,
-0.036383152,
-0.0056953686,
-0.0057338765,
0.0471853688,
-0.037307255,
-0.00805136,
0.0017868276,
-0.0356704406,
-0.013782463,
-0.0300112572,
0.0132128447,
-0.015089727,
-0.0607827306,
0.0124462927,
0.0593271554,
-0.0156977009,
0.0176373608,
0.0159381796,
0.0499225371,
0.0200466625,
-0.0005193745,
-0.0801127478,
0.0224768855,
-0.006619235,
0.0092762634,
0.0178654268,
-0.0362190716,
0.0160124041,
-0.0455719493,
0.0019521294,
0.0552734137,
0.0001674225,
0.003220157,
-0.0546098128,
-0.0069737062,
-0.0075708209,
0.0177339893,
-0.0063379081,
0.0192194767,
-0.000195556,
0.0406965278,
0.0626016706,
-0.021423215,
0.0174298193,
-0.0176473744,
3.002e-7,
0.0330200307,
0.0487807393,
0.0230892655,
-0.0153519455,
0.0428057984,
0.0423351862,
-0.0283269733,
-0.0068551125,
0.0134700397,
0.0083514694,
0.0177867766,
-0.0017676024,
0.0706409216,
0.0617090762,
-0.0397024155,
-0.0299701169,
-0.0585082881,
-0.0127396071,
-0.0477602333,
-0.023573529,
0.0399553627,
-0.0303184185,
0.0142645277,
-0.0099721067,
-0.0163995475,
-0.048889365,
0.0559168048,
-0.0207673144,
-0.04166485,
-0.0185234286,
0.0572386943,
-0.016864093,
0.0316818953,
0.0273574591,
-0.050142929,
-0.0404868051,
-0.0273979381,
0.0733618736,
-0.0350291803,
0.0735413134,
0.0228110068,
-0.0551285632,
0.0035263153,
-0.0295109861,
0.0416458435,
0.0028193914,
-0.0095748901,
-0.0490479246,
-0.0050271419,
-0.0512960143,
0.0461007319,
-0.0319034308,
-0.016459072,
0.006138443,
-0.0154473456,
0.0249203667,
-0.0100219687,
0.0215230584,
-0.0210558809,
-0.0153969703,
0.0065613869,
-0.0329634845,
-0.0227739476,
-0.0071527697,
0.0034250193,
-0.0554340295,
0.032943584,
2.770158049e-34,
-0.0033052962,
0.0175871309,
0.0161306541,
0.0429782569,
0.0815449655,
0.0135723716,
0.0538647771,
0.0135336658,
0.0216592364,
-0.0344991088,
-0.0313306861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15317v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15317v2 | Joint Prediction and Denoising for Large-scale Multilingual Self-supervised Learning | 2023-09-26T23:55:57 | 2023-09-28T02:28:16 | William Chen, Jiatong Shi, Brian Yan, Dan Berrebbi, Wangyou Zhang, Yifan Peng, Xuankai Chang, Soumi Maiti, Shinji Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Multilingual self-supervised learning (SSL) has often lagged behind
state-of-the-art (SOTA) methods due to the expenses and complexity required to
handle many languages. This further harms the reproducibility of SSL, which is
already limited to few research groups due to its resource usage. We show that
more powerful techniques can actually lead to more efficient pre-training,
opening SSL to more research groups. We propose WavLabLM, which extends WavLM's
joint prediction and denoising to 40k hours of data across 136 languages. To
build WavLabLM, we devise a novel multi-stage pre-training method, designed to
address the language imbalance of multilingual data. WavLabLM achieves
comparable performance to XLS-R on ML-SUPERB with less than 10% of the training
data, making SSL realizable with academic compute. We show that further
efficiency can be achieved with a vanilla HuBERT Base model, which can maintain
94% of XLS-R's performance with only 3% of the data, 4 GPUs, and limited
trials. We open-source all code and models in ESPnet. | [
-0.0197211225,
0.0687759444,
0.0089103049,
0.0489474125,
0.0171834584,
0.0009658269,
0.0567135178,
0.0075468491,
0.0137340548,
0.021131184,
-0.0595250055,
-0.0016907604,
-0.0425300114,
-0.0052946666,
-0.0031688577,
-0.0024116735,
0.0236131474,
-0.0299521759,
0.0228815749,
-0.0793764144,
-0.0202404335,
0.040541172,
-0.0050469982,
0.0043228543,
-0.0316286609,
-0.035236571,
-0.0000301647,
0.0068337522,
-0.0048078466,
0.0017666707,
0.0294870548,
0.0956110731,
0.0397676118,
0.0430231951,
0.0000025515,
-0.0652118325,
-0.0267949048,
0.0111828744,
0.0125132678,
0.0625595525,
-0.0123068979,
-0.0084163258,
-0.0000905337,
-0.016727766,
-0.0128074912,
-0.0226436555,
0.0437885299,
-0.0102168806,
0.0496321432,
0.0287780669,
-0.0097246468,
-0.0351517834,
0.0001663823,
-0.0198472571,
-0.0218899697,
-0.0166126825,
0.010987822,
0.0218690019,
-0.0561470203,
-0.0689512417,
-0.0000832343,
0.0768375993,
0.0358323231,
0.009604888,
-0.0164890289,
0.024456894,
-0.0291430932,
-0.0719043091,
-0.0126988692,
0.0491897352,
-0.0648677796,
-0.0309024714,
0.0056663183,
0.0102180354,
-0.0212921612,
-0.0301846825,
-0.0142785069,
0.023818383,
0.0221753549,
0.0292269215,
-0.0062629706,
0.0449902453,
0.0686560422,
0.0333870091,
-0.0021382433,
0.0252865069,
0.0053587756,
-0.0088410228,
0.0233437698,
0.0234313291,
0.0211764257,
0.0006874721,
0.0050644274,
-0.0122551294,
-0.0205518883,
-0.0179854948,
-0.0055277273,
-0.0444322973,
0.0081696203,
-0.027133774,
-0.006744354,
0.010607644,
0.0034700779,
0.048224166,
-0.0168487336,
-0.0317399949,
0.0088073714,
-0.0195760392,
-0.0105811497,
-0.025370894,
0.0194602441,
0.0305358227,
-0.017761847,
0.0549715012,
-0.053141579,
0.039430391,
-0.0566112548,
-0.0353988446,
-0.0345870331,
-0.033449769,
0.0218221098,
0.0196833778,
-0.0404362381,
-0.0325198136,
0.0549118258,
0.054073438,
0.0059842481,
0.0013038059,
-0.0378130674,
-0.0335087366,
0.0048922142,
0.0331428796,
-0.0095208474,
-0.0327506177,
0.0558123142,
0.0591722168,
-0.0321031399,
0.0101152211,
-0.0409716517,
-0.0161847956,
-0.0041305269,
-0.0839306563,
0.0039290888,
-0.1031235605,
0.0133379139,
-0.0011148389,
0.0409326218,
-0.0741835088,
0.0105739618,
-0.0281048156,
0.0166659839,
0.0750546679,
-0.0271610301,
0.0041298396,
0.0152630517,
0.0166279096,
0.0303880107,
0.1160329953,
-0.0051791817,
-0.0021014244,
0.057530228,
-0.0131602697,
-0.0152631812,
0.0617101826,
0.0449860953,
0.0433466993,
-0.0112101138,
-0.0064645698,
0.0116324695,
0.0128265871,
0.0888964608,
0.0211675912,
-0.0134896133,
-0.0629165694,
0.0778338909,
0.0280819964,
0.0304821189,
0.0509306714,
0.0317217782,
0.0272810087,
0.0205220841,
-0.0103079313,
-0.0028807928,
-0.0049126358,
-0.0266298931,
-0.0008727952,
0.0416091233,
0.073711887,
-0.0479027256,
-0.063569665,
0.0452370048,
-0.0164812934,
-0.0114242323,
0.0437761769,
0.0674082711,
0.0073643844,
-0.0010925577,
0.0063215261,
0.0711898208,
-0.0582201406,
0.0038862398,
-0.038107723,
0.0459380783,
0.0081468998,
-0.0053068488,
-0.0459146388,
-0.0093269814,
-0.017465746,
-0.022016665,
0.0325949788,
0.0144163528,
0.0320689566,
0.0851996019,
-0.0625737906,
-0.037019331,
-0.0035009626,
-0.0009583401,
0.0720078424,
-0.0108497785,
0.0367714055,
-0.013556743,
-0.0350584202,
-0.039050512,
0.0035650947,
-0.039378237,
-0.0569700487,
0.0579020493,
0.0219989512,
0.0215185955,
0.035522975,
-0.02850773,
-0.0281493925,
0.0391022749,
-0.0292453282,
-0.014071784,
-0.0154410833,
-0.0469333157,
-0.0357334204,
0.0702800006,
-0.0082901213,
-0.0244530793,
0.0151549047,
-0.0172611736,
-0.029654365,
0.0550973415,
0.0309957564,
0.0120992213,
-0.0665677264,
-0.0187094118,
0.0188747831,
0.0728688166,
0.001474697,
0.0425082967,
0.0221994054,
-0.0134867923,
0.0019217453,
-0.0094807642,
0.0309922621,
-0.0064371028,
-0.0543602705,
-0.0262296796,
-0.0091095688,
0.0348523781,
0.052252274,
0.0448317006,
-0.0287983418,
0.0500247627,
-0.0654109716,
0.0145871174,
-0.0423003547,
-0.0274989661,
-0.0087939352,
0.0222663693,
-0.0168440565,
-0.0614428222,
-0.0216462314,
-0.0328469425,
-0.0037063323,
-0.0221406296,
-0.0152064068,
-0.0067700353,
0.0397699997,
-0.0222688019,
-0.036582686,
0.0334197208,
0.0210259054,
-0.0149123697,
-0.0316226743,
0.0051433425,
0.0040349532,
-0.0297181737,
0.0438614488,
0.0188959111,
-0.0572141893,
-0.0378984064,
-0.0091597037,
0.0168114193,
0.0376367234,
-0.0252319053,
-0.0151879564,
0.0749334171,
-0.0126067139,
-0.0453521386,
0.0405645743,
-0.0028227277,
0.0238820221,
-0.040214479,
0.0258352291,
-0.0320283994,
0.048712261,
0.0167903583,
-0.0229446404,
-0.0423535407,
-0.0147622311,
0.0032654714,
-0.076091975,
-0.0653356165,
0.0466371998,
-0.0185002945,
0.0380104892,
0.0189724825,
-0.0406677239,
0.0510978438,
0.0058600833,
-0.0337177403,
-0.0462470837,
-0.0448956788,
0.0046530915,
0.0150459576,
-0.0263690241,
0.0464095026,
-0.0150735574,
0.0132211195,
-0.063071169,
-0.0187502317,
0.0260998309,
-0.0144190611,
-0.0144361416,
-0.0219896678,
-0.0011975447,
-0.0065239426,
-0.0801141411,
-0.0066800797,
-0.0099987881,
-0.0209839903,
-0.0343661048,
-0.0159625914,
-0.0230872426,
-0.0303913821,
-0.0178040452,
0.0239689816,
0.0527734011,
-0.001428614,
0.0071067126,
0.0147945983,
0.0519887395,
0.0010190654,
-0.0223277994,
0.0259867292,
-0.011803275,
0.0349730477,
0.0277493298,
0.0031589854,
-0.0382041484,
-0.0195352864,
-0.0025492858,
0.0588991679,
-0.0132091157,
-0.0119858403,
0.0058202255,
0.0533574373,
-0.0394592695,
0.0236847233,
0.0986092538,
-0.0173143223,
-0.0564732477,
-0.0188201107,
-0.0114127705,
0.0178643782,
0.0130543886,
0.0073513617,
-0.0720693469,
-0.0169339664,
-0.0159013588,
-0.0031094921,
0.0432654694,
0.0008085863,
0.0316073485,
-0.0818587244,
0.0414941013,
0.0001210176,
-0.0512103997,
-0.0030639574,
-0.0714126006,
-0.0198785029,
-0.068927072,
0.023468446,
-0.027005747,
-0.0148467207,
0.000815744,
0.0360608324,
-0.0468330458,
-0.0544253327,
0.0016427202,
-0.0371230207,
0.028885847,
0.0138352849,
0.0399644636,
-0.0425620638,
-0.0444252826,
0.0030017027,
0.0029673632,
-0.0459401309,
-0.0593385845,
0.0530324243,
0.0380492173,
-0.0193614718,
-0.0029321651,
0.0468452796,
-0.0371087231,
0.0082395002,
0.0330185592,
0.0575159863,
0.011169943,
-0.0134009598,
-0.0191920828,
0.0113204336,
0.0088072121,
0.0494247153,
0.005864983,
-0.0364124924,
-0.0189608335,
-0.018109072,
0.0138868578,
-0.0134369526,
-0.0596757606,
0.01562679,
-0.0258488078,
-0.0769498497,
-0.00358274,
-0.037116833,
0.0062065138,
0.0172743425,
0.0132193789,
0.0525079109,
-0.0223017726,
0.0140263261,
-0.0530061014,
0.0112808794,
-0.0385915563,
-0.006593354,
-0.0228089746,
-0.0012480654,
0.0054671783,
-0.0290480722,
0.0112411408,
0.0314041339,
-0.0043737222,
-0.0628994182,
-0.0076109734,
0.0901311561,
0.0075463736,
0.0571775772,
0.0030637186,
-0.0289734323,
0.0823138356,
0.0600243583,
-0.0703669563,
-0.0106414231,
0.0752739012,
-0.0323519185,
0.0060264189,
0.0586374328,
0.0211592391,
0.0516949631,
0.0040338612,
-0.0131824678,
-0.0343544111,
-0.0189002044,
0.0039148424,
-0.0024881575,
0.0451351628,
-0.0565110669,
0.0116692334,
-0.0459534228,
-0.0296536572,
-0.0071624839,
-0.0333559103,
-0.0325678959,
0.0088406149,
0.0138449837,
0.0055193878,
-0.0162855685,
0.0434903502,
0.0103381174,
-0.0604175106,
-0.026836453,
0.0302294288,
0.008185884,
-0.0070701307,
0.0252875835,
0.0237480476,
0.004940053,
0.0357782431,
0.0562988929,
0.0137172816,
0.0261845905,
-0.0332837366,
-0.0103740515,
0.0381153487,
-0.0110242125,
-0.0170689467,
-0.0082042599,
-0.0581398122,
-0.0210000966,
-0.021850979,
0.0642202422,
-0.0311135706,
0.0832357109,
-0.0110597014,
-0.0311762765,
-0.0505707711,
0.0140384557,
-0.0231019966,
0.0487566553,
0.008922087,
-0.0332395136,
-0.0332461745,
0.021049276,
0.0981660187,
-0.0335397013,
0.048266802,
0.0658304542,
0.0137794456,
-0.0625044182,
-0.0455225147,
0.0229113679,
0.0388940051,
-0.0395085923,
0.0101836966,
-0.0077876858,
-0.0867609531,
-0.019175563,
-0.0143226301,
-0.0277936943,
-0.0036792818,
0.0335429609,
0.0441327989,
-0.003774141,
0.0180434175,
-0.0247451626,
0.0141805261,
0.0067187347,
-0.0455941856,
0.0373461321,
-7.030756609e-33,
0.0318918265,
0.0094904602,
-0.0111007625,
-0.0194034074,
0.0603936277,
0.0384429917,
0.0027660835,
0.0244707596,
0.003035665,
0.0587580949,
-0.0074064406,
-0.0241341759,
0.0192174688,
0.0216567423,
0.0264112391,
0.0633655488,
0.0836214647,
-0.0315814279,
0.0118423915,
0.030538369,
-0.0105981883,
0.0589507073,
0.0692040622,
-0.0996085182,
-0.0353916548,
0.0201362986,
-0.0001631508,
-0.0227120649,
0.0057739923,
0.0421234444,
-0.0238062534,
0.0844284594,
-0.0218748245,
-0.010706272,
-0.0244702827,
-0.0510173067,
-0.0616548955,
-0.0271291528,
-0.0282481369,
0.02949824,
-0.0423919111,
-0.0173426569,
0.0286881849,
0.0152833499,
-0.0299894214,
-0.0206607543,
0.0553426184,
-0.0272309575,
-0.0185475573,
-0.0608561486,
-0.0511374399,
0.0351981111,
-0.0356585197,
-0.0214995276,
0.0692623034,
-0.002555182,
-0.0217200369,
-0.0121875638,
-0.0651150867,
0.0160477739,
-0.0533491001,
0.0292517375,
0.0522609279,
-0.0130555043,
-0.0024916872,
0.0270540565,
0.0526443385,
-0.0313418359,
0.0535477884,
-0.0046595898,
0.0582198091,
0.032053005,
0.0378660075,
0.0600142032,
0.0324706808,
0.0061348169,
-0.1041515395,
0.0433851555,
-0.002027727,
0.0053094667,
-0.0001532275,
0.0032969995,
0.0321852304,
-0.0194729827,
-0.0251918081,
-0.0539476313,
-0.0113931671,
-0.0204197019,
-0.0314954817,
0.00009493,
-0.0130725093,
-0.0039011294,
0.0207086876,
-0.0470667183,
-0.0271188729,
0.0175564419,
-0.0020305216,
-0.0485123619,
0.0237177629,
0.0359805524,
-0.0582436174,
-0.0184819214,
-0.0396086574,
0.0025550243,
0.0098638078,
-0.0182312205,
0.034885224,
0.0074927453,
-0.0609639101,
0.0008022561,
-0.0260567274,
0.0064419806,
0.0589151122,
0.0637973845,
0.0049715191,
-0.0407225937,
-0.0000436517,
0.0167164616,
0.034643054,
0.0072462792,
0.0135579836,
-0.0341553688,
0.0027819863,
0.0040325783,
-0.0075905067,
-0.0159688834,
-0.0596491545,
-0.0215465501,
0.036357794,
-0.0542683005,
-0.0086929649,
-0.0142560368,
3.065e-7,
0.0252737291,
0.0438918211,
-0.011808319,
-0.0230207983,
-0.0279817283,
0.0234166849,
-0.0161332227,
-0.012110007,
-0.0258035921,
0.008108383,
0.0118895369,
0.0585634299,
0.0616486482,
0.0211550277,
-0.0371009298,
-0.0063886596,
-0.0579206981,
0.030701315,
-0.0447771326,
-0.0243851691,
-0.0661941618,
0.102056466,
0.0422761701,
-0.0413421988,
0.0370236449,
0.0169818643,
0.050944306,
-0.0252720919,
-0.0184848346,
0.000069531,
0.0375751629,
-0.0016489981,
-0.0070627984,
-0.0094142277,
-0.0463093445,
0.0050976179,
0.0138547691,
0.0181123409,
-0.0011644152,
0.0089155883,
0.0603447556,
0.0451272465,
-0.0258021709,
-0.0495459251,
0.0606836602,
0.0091008805,
-0.0422448814,
-0.0147412196,
-0.0135713611,
0.000651004,
0.1124449596,
-0.0337988846,
-0.0277277995,
0.0185768045,
0.017083684,
-0.019641526,
-0.0461482517,
-0.0167925414,
-0.0277069267,
0.0052652596,
-0.0188409779,
-0.0156990346,
-0.0096360799,
-0.0297108814,
-0.00097072,
-0.0250960961,
0.0734233409,
2.512483718e-34,
0.0450765789,
-0.0195194464,
0.0017746957,
-0.0108638313,
-0.0256609805,
-0.0474996902,
-0.0481707118,
0.0033992981,
-0.0087738046,
0.0099138236,
-0.0009566176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.01420v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.01420v2 | Ruffle&Riley: Towards the Automated Induction of Conversational Tutoring Systems | 2023-09-26T23:27:06 | 2023-11-14T15:41:45 | Robin Schmucker, Meng Xia, Amos Azaria, Tom Mitchell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Conversational tutoring systems (CTSs) offer learning experiences driven by
natural language interaction. They are known to promote high levels of
cognitive engagement and benefit learning outcomes, particularly in reasoning
tasks. Nonetheless, the time and cost required to author CTS content is a major
obstacle to widespread adoption. In this paper, we introduce a novel type of
CTS that leverages the recent advances in large language models (LLMs) in two
ways: First, the system induces a tutoring script automatically from a lesson
text. Second, the system automates the script orchestration via two LLM-based
agents (Ruffle&Riley) with the roles of a student and a professor in a
learning-by-teaching format. The system allows a free-form conversation that
follows the ITS-typical inner and outer loop structure. In an initial
between-subject online user study (N = 100) comparing Ruffle&Riley to simpler
QA chatbots and reading activity, we found no significant differences in
post-test scores. Nonetheless, in the learning experience survey, Ruffle&Riley
users expressed higher ratings of understanding and remembering and further
perceived the offered support as more helpful and the conversation as coherent.
Our study provides insights for a new generation of scalable CTS technologies. | [
0.0486756116,
-0.0389093868,
-0.0485158563,
0.0312867127,
-0.0449679755,
-0.0000547747,
0.0396198705,
-0.0412508585,
0.0427485481,
-0.0535721481,
-0.0044030678,
0.0271976087,
-0.0074346093,
0.0455623306,
0.0059503983,
-0.0811288431,
0.0211282726,
-0.0296381116,
0.0097591272,
0.0266530756,
0.0290784668,
0.0029966375,
-0.0465866439,
0.046896413,
0.0107530262,
-0.032061968,
-0.0478830263,
-0.0095547577,
0.0086064162,
0.0047299233,
0.0176756475,
0.0387022533,
0.040582452,
0.0215673503,
0.0000020548,
-0.0632190406,
-0.0237310175,
-0.0177392419,
-0.0389615521,
0.0006137111,
0.0671411306,
0.112072669,
-0.010547447,
0.0188933574,
-0.0544950254,
0.0616884157,
0.0303847175,
0.0063986378,
0.0796718448,
0.0408554077,
0.0093470998,
-0.010778591,
0.0165663604,
0.0445645638,
0.0472707674,
-0.0369541943,
-0.0080782734,
0.0666009039,
0.074206233,
0.0181324538,
-0.0316484012,
0.0406584032,
0.0160112139,
-0.0923314393,
0.0158289429,
0.0219420604,
-0.0171763804,
-0.0461164713,
-0.0133896647,
0.067231752,
0.0533938333,
-0.0091015436,
-0.0136860535,
0.0213121455,
0.0556396358,
0.0534369461,
-0.073623091,
0.0182029679,
-0.0093968371,
0.0083225891,
0.0118336845,
-0.0242910087,
-0.0168856159,
0.011343373,
0.0154154208,
-0.0211550444,
-0.0117140943,
-0.043383453,
-0.0279749297,
0.0135753378,
0.0353158414,
-0.0421319343,
0.0133723551,
0.0806075856,
-0.0433044583,
0.0374189951,
0.0022857001,
-0.0380330794,
-0.0015793132,
0.0053902506,
0.0081504034,
0.0600709468,
-0.0339668244,
0.0536210053,
-0.0075035887,
0.042563159,
0.0500527062,
0.009092032,
-0.0030345735,
0.0233270098,
-0.0697704852,
-0.0148956291,
-0.0438900255,
0.0597551428,
-0.0216583572,
-0.0382898003,
-0.0266540255,
0.036623355,
-0.0117012486,
0.0657187253,
-0.0399584994,
-0.007411635,
0.0016298087,
0.0119655076,
-0.030796906,
0.0394715667,
-0.0076515116,
-0.014481876,
0.0098946234,
-0.0909565091,
0.0222697183,
0.0001496403,
-0.0053255656,
0.0330633856,
-0.0032141276,
0.0441370383,
-0.0343841128,
-0.0616748855,
-0.0255565941,
-0.0439710841,
0.0081514362,
-0.0399438515,
-0.0319585465,
-0.065358147,
0.0111912563,
0.0278555006,
-0.0028925058,
-0.0069946162,
0.0240937229,
0.0364605263,
-0.0055584805,
0.0468926616,
-0.0261354446,
0.0179529525,
0.0544565953,
0.0226014834,
-0.0347285159,
0.0351738185,
0.0518852659,
-0.0181184523,
0.0245572124,
-0.0257239994,
0.0287112184,
0.0258238055,
-0.0151605401,
-0.0117565291,
0.0149314879,
-0.0066327238,
0.0293927211,
0.042296119,
-0.0521288291,
0.0181097072,
-0.031364426,
0.0451284312,
0.0673571005,
0.0720141008,
-0.0332232155,
0.0386848785,
0.0323368534,
0.0471980907,
0.0495476015,
-0.0010340671,
-0.0396316014,
0.0229563657,
-0.0549347624,
-0.0044982927,
0.0272869747,
0.0039072377,
0.0001954407,
-0.0750610158,
0.010708211,
-0.018050218,
0.0364880711,
0.0341869481,
0.0533724837,
-0.0122336382,
-0.037511833,
-0.0206606109,
0.0219094139,
-0.0573054291,
0.0088834241,
-0.0770860538,
0.0479526892,
0.0991300941,
0.0537987798,
-0.0407042019,
-0.0633558854,
-0.01115329,
0.0418100059,
0.0446232259,
0.0169860218,
-0.0191829838,
-0.0385176577,
-0.0281447433,
-0.0069347951,
-0.0285237674,
-0.0188373849,
-0.0048129926,
0.0256730188,
0.0016624515,
-0.0132825803,
-0.0039233444,
-0.0444238707,
0.0107061109,
-0.0682071969,
-0.0261173341,
-0.0692361146,
0.0164721254,
-0.0047189621,
0.0399914123,
0.0041315258,
-0.0084235547,
0.019010501,
0.004319849,
-0.0282080285,
0.0154513223,
-0.0267039761,
-0.0303850565,
0.0345577486,
0.0121579794,
-0.0183462054,
0.0135672605,
0.0205765683,
-0.0148699954,
0.033996325,
-0.0176384784,
0.0466805138,
-0.0035042111,
0.0246544834,
-0.0323032998,
-0.0441242345,
-0.0373282246,
0.0100445589,
0.0567390472,
0.0123288305,
0.0286743287,
0.0144762294,
-0.0311741661,
-0.0283837114,
0.0131816473,
-0.0121542746,
-0.0060888114,
-0.0055314829,
0.001397158,
0.0035555537,
-0.0827701241,
-0.0277265534,
-0.0573062934,
0.0121247927,
0.008943432,
-0.0038618338,
0.0080370884,
0.0038362981,
-0.0210915543,
-0.0298741832,
-0.0477425642,
0.0173891913,
0.0389008448,
0.0097231595,
0.0141609153,
0.0023046427,
-0.0586585291,
-0.0569803417,
0.0173076484,
-0.0270316191,
0.0161819402,
0.0963862464,
0.0047825747,
-0.0788318664,
0.0488005169,
-0.0158440564,
-0.0022102522,
-0.0249546207,
-0.0226033963,
0.0345925577,
-0.0449039042,
0.0282721426,
0.0919338316,
0.0138582801,
0.0441004224,
0.0262814313,
-0.0388757139,
-0.0737994611,
0.0307073426,
-0.0020287223,
-0.067722708,
-0.0414421149,
-0.0471871048,
-0.0189106688,
0.0215141289,
0.0057206368,
0.0029046573,
-0.024688419,
0.0385266729,
0.0100516789,
0.0165616274,
-0.0141490735,
-0.0353701673,
-0.0222029369,
0.0016993375,
-0.0032624034,
-0.0403588414,
0.0859447867,
-0.0127396006,
-0.0529554151,
-0.0471959263,
-0.0134420441,
-0.0334458426,
0.0403129533,
0.003866225,
0.0233996436,
-0.0302233603,
-0.0255823527,
-0.0091018081,
-0.0148184206,
0.0339901187,
-0.0555803068,
0.0040905923,
-0.0454610661,
-0.0106434114,
0.0115971938,
0.0216341112,
-0.0528699569,
0.0015281574,
-0.0524918027,
-0.0210615918,
0.0241782889,
-0.0231156796,
-0.0034830589,
-0.0268872529,
0.0492901877,
0.0070915897,
-0.0088730287,
-0.0299374741,
-0.0244933423,
-0.0099694496,
-0.0041970564,
0.0101787094,
-0.0072222627,
-0.0231757741,
0.124854967,
0.0451458432,
0.0038086958,
-0.0301164314,
-0.0012664683,
-0.0381249525,
0.029663818,
-0.0336922817,
-0.0014103712,
0.0345183164,
0.0474618152,
-0.0644582212,
-0.0170803331,
0.1285697967,
0.0247757938,
-0.0392930508,
-0.0234574713,
-0.0630959496,
0.0082472218,
0.0089833597,
0.0271959342,
-0.0737531707,
-0.0244154502,
-0.0125846416,
0.0292950366,
0.0051601483,
-0.0348115638,
-0.0049316203,
-0.0944098011,
0.0329226069,
0.0175352786,
-0.0319811031,
0.0319968648,
-0.0525211431,
-0.000702696,
0.0075311298,
0.0006754591,
0.0146429893,
-0.0198407937,
0.0144753559,
0.0044530276,
-0.0132805174,
-0.0026595891,
0.013864723,
-0.0305882748,
0.0542562939,
0.0493585318,
0.0152326236,
0.0121494085,
-0.0145617863,
0.0012485815,
0.0562777221,
0.0073249666,
-0.0090960972,
0.049032025,
-0.0137699684,
0.0072594299,
-0.0547176972,
0.0530428775,
-0.003014897,
0.0026967814,
0.0532079376,
0.0718619004,
-0.0016853032,
0.0062380629,
-0.0241005216,
0.0538104847,
0.0422266461,
0.0619257316,
0.0125492886,
-0.0625337064,
-0.019853605,
-0.0259806272,
-0.0124941245,
-0.0093496479,
-0.0481328368,
-0.0072460938,
-0.0120532066,
0.0630407557,
-0.0528847165,
-0.044269748,
0.0663582087,
-0.0003344479,
0.0126865664,
0.0399685018,
0.0356347524,
0.0511145331,
-0.0001838504,
-0.0047046058,
-0.0270211343,
0.0076732244,
-0.068747133,
-0.0443583094,
-0.0015099971,
-0.0620853119,
0.0114354929,
-0.0257554818,
-0.0464298651,
-0.0741531998,
-0.0129200108,
0.0239565801,
0.0215916168,
0.045394592,
0.0526346192,
0.0061311279,
-0.0132103646,
-0.012188714,
-0.0357730687,
-0.007003651,
-0.0160308462,
0.0577416383,
0.026215557,
-0.0070962724,
-0.02987363,
-0.0250690579,
-0.0336183198,
0.022799246,
-0.0234129056,
-0.0237054266,
0.0316336751,
0.0268260222,
-0.0006961889,
0.0232117269,
-0.0017365522,
-0.0102135316,
0.0338155702,
-0.0585636459,
-0.0193351302,
-0.0451944619,
-0.0025690647,
-0.0122467112,
-0.0180968698,
0.0453699604,
-0.0035790284,
-0.0361474454,
0.0377794541,
0.015146317,
0.045922365,
-0.0137923136,
-0.0183631051,
0.0387795605,
-0.0033975688,
-0.0081912903,
0.0135213397,
0.0208235104,
0.0410909802,
0.0206759535,
0.115288876,
0.0246010926,
-0.014606216,
0.0300125703,
-0.0002011091,
-0.0252775121,
-0.1064865142,
0.0287259035,
0.0268568806,
0.000144407,
0.0218281802,
0.0230745021,
-0.0636894777,
0.0289067719,
-0.0034040348,
0.0400746949,
-0.0022215361,
-0.0609988123,
-0.0054746731,
0.0056138928,
0.031105021,
0.0189096481,
0.0309063662,
-0.0322473757,
0.0066521689,
0.0014238729,
-0.0287913885,
-0.0265104435,
-0.0034994439,
0.0319154672,
0.0279798359,
0.0120603852,
0.0048336266,
-0.0269057415,
-0.0254376382,
-0.0447908305,
-0.000074476,
-0.0165049303,
-0.057086233,
0.0317245983,
0.0308587234,
-0.0126142325,
-0.0069248686,
-0.0483015925,
0.0844295546,
-0.0361739323,
-0.0453019924,
-0.010584861,
-5.763516393e-33,
-0.0137084313,
-0.0505069084,
0.045363199,
0.0956448764,
-0.0141355181,
-0.0186497662,
-0.0408288725,
0.030500412,
0.0057588001,
-0.0000252637,
0.014200354,
0.0088998722,
0.0007338843,
0.0225060284,
0.0193647929,
0.0071363025,
0.0389438495,
0.0070663048,
0.0061586946,
0.0404349081,
0.0213298947,
0.0139377033,
0.0168622416,
-0.059792541,
0.0514758304,
-0.0508417189,
0.0310711786,
0.0093903402,
-0.0218528509,
0.008535035,
-0.0011894121,
0.0308457762,
-0.0056941826,
-0.030000098,
0.008816977,
0.0658012182,
-0.0381157361,
-0.0472315401,
0.0058895615,
0.009292963,
-0.0527938753,
-0.0082685305,
0.0134326946,
-0.0447146483,
-0.012651965,
0.0121077579,
0.0496798158,
-0.0121687949,
0.0091795931,
0.0251214001,
-0.0846673399,
0.0083808191,
-0.0530327857,
-0.0782584846,
-0.0169950649,
0.0314676911,
0.0033650571,
-0.0132247098,
-0.0230280422,
0.0646662191,
0.0261512063,
-0.0051944442,
0.0391110145,
-0.0143655324,
-0.0223389585,
0.0491348207,
0.0433395095,
0.0420423076,
-0.0383159518,
0.0003106177,
0.0060558119,
0.0144931413,
0.050664451,
0.018787019,
-0.0314876027,
0.0243951008,
-0.0525247529,
0.0388439558,
0.0689230114,
0.0228594504,
0.0155936917,
-0.0012137674,
-0.0513390563,
-0.0114990026,
-0.052801393,
0.036452271,
0.0052219951,
-0.0619056299,
0.025012631,
-0.0057918062,
0.0069602327,
-0.084727332,
-0.0033036172,
-0.0308984015,
-0.0142736938,
0.0133825345,
-0.0020787676,
0.0273318049,
-0.0360752754,
-0.0213219188,
-0.0257793181,
-0.0169792473,
-0.028089948,
-0.0370641649,
0.0322165191,
0.0214004405,
-0.0089663193,
0.0193782002,
-0.0224021394,
-0.0065736421,
-0.0320475623,
0.0126963938,
0.0364530608,
-0.0228211973,
0.0276099462,
0.0173316784,
-0.0258388668,
0.0594243743,
0.0278188009,
-0.0172421113,
-0.0412347652,
-0.0502372235,
-0.0225216839,
-0.048887942,
-0.0444242917,
-0.0062884735,
-0.0435403176,
0.0257897731,
-0.0063638943,
-0.0591053925,
0.0131458845,
-0.0385988876,
2.888e-7,
-0.00119039,
0.0462788455,
-0.0210591815,
0.0102436999,
0.0077022901,
0.036508929,
0.0068694144,
-0.0305073615,
0.0664700866,
-0.0008845138,
-0.0255799387,
0.0298419856,
0.0257153213,
0.0309240259,
-0.1093251631,
-0.0649826229,
0.0199705362,
-0.0026747747,
-0.0435807221,
0.0509128794,
0.1000533998,
-0.0132138543,
0.0295601189,
-0.005582754,
-0.0232918356,
-0.045371525,
0.0144395009,
-0.0306950267,
-0.0102722561,
0.0346487351,
0.0107667297,
-0.0096057756,
0.0122278323,
0.0299896635,
0.0254933313,
0.0218516383,
-0.039958138,
0.0393322222,
0.0240373593,
0.0253478717,
0.0181917325,
-0.0014423669,
-0.0166112687,
-0.0497276671,
0.0344018415,
-0.0535489172,
-0.0147216758,
0.0100288121,
-0.0378723107,
-0.0717177466,
0.0018926973,
-0.0176190417,
-0.0205667149,
0.0112929344,
-0.0399153419,
-0.0228879359,
0.023366183,
-0.0379792452,
0.0016517743,
0.0238238946,
-0.0418897644,
-0.0515578575,
-0.0328170471,
-0.0205809027,
-0.0175438244,
-0.0289907977,
0.028695466,
2.321939527e-34,
-0.0024754533,
-0.0145781022,
0.0678121299,
0.0688512996,
0.030510908,
0.0301127583,
0.0011040836,
0.0280868355,
0.0558175482,
-0.0652820542,
-0.0318880305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15869v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15869v1 | Unsupervised Pre-Training for Vietnamese Automatic Speech Recognition in the HYKIST Project | 2023-09-26T21:12:09 | 2023-09-26T21:12:09 | Khai Le-Duc | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In today's interconnected globe, moving abroad is more and more prevalent,
whether it's for employment, refugee resettlement, or other causes. Language
difficulties between natives and immigrants present a common issue on a daily
basis, especially in medical domain. This can make it difficult for patients
and doctors to communicate during anamnesis or in the emergency room, which
compromises patient care. The goal of the HYKIST Project is to develop a speech
translation system to support patient-doctor communication with ASR and MT.
ASR systems have recently displayed astounding performance on particular
tasks for which enough quantities of training data are available, such as
LibriSpeech. Building a good model is still difficult due to a variety of
speaking styles, acoustic and recording settings, and a lack of in-domain
training data. In this thesis, we describe our efforts to construct ASR systems
for a conversational telephone speech recognition task in the medical domain
for Vietnamese language to assist emergency room contact between doctors and
patients across linguistic barriers. In order to enhance the system's
performance, we investigate various training schedules and data combining
strategies. We also examine how best to make use of the little data that is
available. The use of publicly accessible models like XLSR-53 is compared to
the use of customized pre-trained models, and both supervised and unsupervised
approaches are utilized using wav2vec 2.0 as architecture. | [
0.0236224514,
0.0156984795,
0.0068671335,
-0.0062788175,
-0.0095780296,
-0.0007901472,
0.0267561022,
0.0014193676,
0.0148831131,
-0.0286576934,
-0.0446310379,
-0.081805855,
0.0516646504,
0.0096573057,
-0.0029252702,
-0.042890925,
0.0056127487,
-0.0351769179,
-0.0070220968,
-0.0369642042,
-0.032545317,
0.011648301,
-0.0714378133,
0.0486197956,
0.0443271436,
0.0518222265,
0.0026484395,
0.0382478349,
0.0257231668,
-0.0569770299,
-0.0227954127,
-0.0036201756,
0.0161410104,
0.0230542962,
0.0000019066,
-0.0244996324,
-0.0069594225,
0.0231153816,
-0.0590997301,
-0.041309692,
0.0257070027,
-0.0715879798,
-0.0184164345,
0.037846759,
-0.0284859072,
-0.0762336999,
0.029039992,
0.0243196413,
0.0444664583,
0.0491130501,
-0.009185412,
0.0013361676,
-0.0075997072,
-0.013978852,
-0.026536569,
-0.0257800203,
0.0044242381,
-0.0086288052,
0.006555588,
-0.0531069823,
0.0050875447,
0.0450519174,
-0.0115781762,
0.0077251629,
0.000935312,
-0.0029831433,
-0.0618125275,
-0.0356918648,
-0.0272368677,
0.0478452966,
-0.0039782706,
-0.027298376,
0.0262877773,
0.0346892439,
-0.0381584316,
-0.0318715125,
-0.0363382995,
-0.0213358197,
-0.0096300896,
-0.0235278923,
0.0102979559,
0.0266255997,
0.0036489386,
-0.041641742,
-0.009937847,
-0.0556370653,
0.0194787867,
-0.0337579809,
0.0119253295,
-0.0310217645,
0.0173752829,
-0.0148322294,
0.0714613944,
0.0333294272,
-0.0305379964,
0.0017028927,
-0.0042474307,
-0.0342419147,
0.0113529628,
-0.0870589092,
0.021766495,
0.0574160255,
-0.0371000469,
-0.0041442914,
0.0084522748,
0.0200839862,
-0.0098849246,
-0.0010272968,
-0.0683214292,
0.0266630985,
-0.0315047391,
0.036475718,
-0.0541284606,
-0.0015216226,
-0.0269353967,
0.0061441497,
-0.0674193874,
-0.0253462158,
0.023681527,
0.0013710093,
0.056193307,
-0.0145716397,
-0.0634460077,
-0.002812326,
0.0125622544,
0.0396168306,
0.0352802165,
0.0450630933,
-0.0320989229,
-0.0839053467,
0.0352603309,
0.0258806683,
0.0292286165,
0.0147026321,
-0.000175496,
0.0638531595,
-0.0038104765,
0.0117943147,
-0.0251427479,
0.0255079493,
0.007700501,
-0.0460086279,
0.0364859961,
-0.029610021,
0.040856868,
0.0246827733,
0.0365355089,
0.00794122,
0.0194439366,
-0.0458536893,
-0.0022021157,
0.0681216642,
-0.0278901439,
0.0386947878,
0.0873555541,
0.0222916938,
0.0474028178,
0.0187186766,
0.0084662419,
-0.0540045314,
-0.006109999,
-0.0747441277,
-0.0065787756,
0.0239034649,
-0.0089768237,
-0.0309934746,
0.0136957616,
0.0240990631,
0.0260653179,
0.0354837961,
-0.0139998589,
0.0574465431,
-0.0263262521,
0.006460228,
-0.0074290079,
0.0497782528,
0.0365695395,
0.0034652341,
0.0635672808,
-0.0175968185,
0.0063828086,
-0.0173910558,
-0.00309673,
-0.0204055607,
-0.0165136512,
0.0036782331,
-0.0132086622,
0.0348100774,
-0.0553772375,
-0.0435748994,
-0.0367274359,
-0.0409246348,
-0.0477165319,
0.0024638651,
0.040334899,
0.0175404623,
-0.0197467785,
0.0593423396,
0.0269095078,
-0.0404938161,
0.0046074335,
-0.0610682778,
-0.0730908662,
0.0573997311,
0.0303642955,
-0.0154850939,
-0.0023503099,
-0.0485676378,
-0.0014984169,
0.0045183268,
0.0354054943,
0.0160804261,
0.0604364835,
-0.0707437024,
-0.0053111571,
0.0878318399,
-0.0033265108,
0.031901177,
-0.011546379,
0.0482723825,
0.0226283949,
-0.0041537015,
-0.0093024475,
0.0003542101,
-0.0266177878,
-0.0047823731,
0.0407589488,
-0.0076818122,
0.0816396773,
0.0564256683,
-0.0206943769,
0.000288546,
0.0266828164,
-0.0448860563,
0.0389560014,
0.058039289,
-0.0461823754,
-0.0159315243,
0.0396657772,
-0.0174927562,
0.0358450599,
-0.0021204536,
0.0231229998,
-0.0793763548,
-0.0077142445,
-0.0359885842,
0.0656545982,
-0.0217623413,
0.1005792916,
0.052508574,
0.0244632177,
0.0284645557,
-0.0075751026,
-0.0000513877,
-0.0099902293,
0.007763077,
-0.0091411239,
0.0174868591,
-0.0571810938,
-0.0154445339,
0.0448580422,
-0.0190264564,
0.0174982529,
-0.0214450452,
0.0156347994,
-0.0054065739,
-0.0009224814,
-0.1357670426,
-0.0085962117,
-0.0189629477,
0.0133803021,
0.005168735,
0.0599512607,
0.0064577684,
-0.062344227,
-0.0304180607,
-0.0050382325,
0.0095414883,
-0.0111717694,
-0.0651129261,
0.0173318014,
-0.0188754871,
-0.0104019614,
-0.0175782721,
0.0037465007,
-0.015334419,
-0.0149799716,
-0.0637581274,
-0.0300145838,
-0.0139216157,
0.0018022571,
-0.001074151,
-0.0191780161,
-0.0584004186,
-0.0113096945,
0.0085701924,
0.023588039,
0.0138119617,
0.0150618004,
0.0180651601,
0.0231562257,
0.0096365372,
-0.0049157622,
-0.0018784328,
-0.0055618933,
-0.0243367329,
-0.0012624855,
0.0016490474,
-0.0625219196,
0.055395361,
0.0067566279,
0.0332589746,
-0.0155256027,
-0.0837327614,
-0.0168414097,
-0.0149231162,
-0.0155709973,
0.0137375901,
-0.0182188246,
0.0288068186,
0.0164531693,
-0.032187134,
0.0453195535,
-0.0577986166,
-0.0325828344,
-0.0810313821,
-0.0611793138,
-0.0531478077,
-0.0197648648,
-0.0243795197,
0.0099480227,
-0.0207604356,
-0.0556947999,
0.05322925,
0.0359359533,
-0.0176091325,
-0.0786185935,
0.0051875096,
-0.0149786994,
-0.0078042732,
-0.0019689968,
-0.0328213498,
-0.0209049638,
0.0322811157,
-0.0409567915,
0.0282865129,
-0.0156992879,
0.0261012278,
-0.0031045224,
0.0735373423,
-0.0111476127,
0.0956310555,
0.0413576849,
0.0182601586,
-0.0207048468,
0.0516007058,
0.0188955609,
0.0244405009,
-0.0380101241,
0.0078488467,
0.0673539862,
-0.0386573263,
0.0468144566,
0.0207124855,
-0.0222632866,
0.0092668366,
0.0213925373,
-0.0040386301,
-0.004107757,
0.0278823469,
0.0240728762,
-0.0110933408,
0.0278821196,
0.0846089795,
0.0059116082,
-0.0342463665,
-0.0248541012,
-0.041091416,
-0.03579114,
0.0019434779,
0.004987468,
-0.0398681872,
0.0120193278,
0.027272135,
0.031667091,
0.0069294646,
0.0520501398,
0.0045026513,
-0.0583610088,
0.0376371332,
0.0404682904,
-0.0502361692,
-0.0285186321,
-0.0414710678,
-0.0457975119,
-0.0263446122,
0.0500859506,
-0.0249961652,
-0.0262593832,
-0.066211544,
0.0058985474,
-0.0814730227,
-0.0966783389,
0.0136041921,
-0.0117259622,
0.0762526169,
0.0740777105,
0.0300751254,
0.0168306008,
-0.0307830796,
0.0252678879,
0.0164731108,
0.0216428973,
-0.025728425,
0.0251441021,
0.0157050584,
0.008124724,
0.0019484804,
0.0507155843,
-0.0477132127,
0.0147632416,
0.0140897548,
0.0341877155,
-0.0673406795,
-0.0053964164,
0.0302056428,
0.0545251667,
0.0315960683,
0.029849248,
-0.0157079734,
0.0110291559,
0.0093184933,
0.0456736274,
0.0531169176,
0.0396915935,
-0.0019225503,
0.0343153141,
-0.034591645,
-0.0932649449,
-0.0241684504,
-0.0004544546,
0.0342279002,
0.0567611419,
0.043347761,
0.0392077863,
-0.0029817251,
0.0538741723,
-0.0377842486,
0.0222176928,
0.0075906157,
0.0267276336,
-0.0556607321,
-0.0505184233,
0.0185361225,
-0.0392770506,
0.0045688874,
-0.0062062414,
0.0197387468,
-0.0323778689,
0.04488343,
0.0270776227,
0.0349722803,
0.0329517201,
-0.0223780088,
-0.0209145192,
0.0091659259,
0.0243707802,
-0.0574353971,
-0.0169882718,
0.0094492882,
0.0064781113,
-0.0211512353,
0.0128381904,
0.0098042022,
0.0369417369,
-0.0037833818,
0.0093250461,
-0.0264457557,
-0.0619424507,
-0.0077422266,
0.0560649671,
0.0593891293,
-0.0265425146,
-0.0311843045,
-0.0279190876,
0.0661708713,
-0.0148811694,
0.0656177178,
-0.0409664251,
-0.0123207076,
0.0028388787,
0.02639631,
0.0098856203,
0.0106308348,
-0.0599474348,
-0.0959960222,
0.041142039,
0.0908778235,
0.0058893696,
0.0496747084,
0.059700802,
0.0093239136,
-0.0202576816,
0.0432811938,
0.041775059,
0.0095200846,
0.0123912096,
0.0812281519,
-0.0308868736,
0.0389986895,
0.0435762219,
0.0390193015,
-0.0152356895,
-0.0543113686,
-0.0319895819,
0.0363540016,
0.0572411641,
-0.0089747822,
0.037109606,
0.0010099813,
0.0317303538,
-0.0455760993,
0.0313830972,
-0.02167386,
0.030149417,
0.0113543812,
-0.0024179872,
-0.0143855913,
0.051841855,
0.0433976762,
-0.0271241311,
0.0329979099,
0.0165727921,
0.0241956878,
-0.0303074978,
-0.0278687142,
0.0321975686,
0.0075691398,
-0.0780265331,
-0.0256854743,
-0.0032557198,
-0.0735766143,
0.0158119909,
-0.0052317251,
-0.0322374068,
-0.0238014497,
0.0276856236,
-0.0029373574,
-0.022256406,
0.0150080314,
0.0114841862,
-0.0081896828,
-0.0446393788,
0.0308544021,
0.0707567483,
-5.864097934e-33,
-0.0228937976,
0.0233790223,
0.0241470039,
-0.0278136153,
-0.0117331343,
0.0295133311,
-0.0048885779,
0.0081305308,
-0.0162856802,
-0.042503804,
-0.0247402228,
0.0020972218,
0.0515592173,
-0.0033882286,
-0.0121309031,
0.0095135672,
0.0756809488,
0.0274180714,
-0.0009029956,
-0.0224073585,
-0.0203829277,
0.0417061821,
0.0285742078,
-0.0715637878,
-0.0554163754,
-0.0051097595,
0.0356556885,
-0.0053523337,
0.0244773086,
0.0131056365,
-0.0096331546,
0.0335906856,
0.0109264748,
-0.0002164566,
0.0010323004,
-0.0120960884,
-0.1267841458,
0.0312068127,
0.0075939479,
0.0649000034,
-0.0160163827,
-0.0217770748,
0.0135635007,
0.0047695404,
-0.0377767757,
-0.0075838747,
-0.0106389662,
-0.0509606861,
-0.0192001313,
-0.0011942644,
0.0185310617,
0.0226360261,
-0.0010408813,
-0.0256701987,
0.0559619814,
0.0132781016,
-0.0592619106,
-0.0473453552,
-0.0606179722,
0.0201275852,
0.0147219319,
0.0228959564,
0.027725542,
-0.0156549495,
-0.0166052189,
-0.010896706,
0.0802427977,
-0.0813578665,
0.0131739676,
-0.0254313424,
-0.0369660035,
0.0179781877,
0.0101934001,
0.006241831,
0.0361500159,
-0.0571345314,
-0.0401011556,
0.0027202948,
-0.0263853222,
0.0142068379,
-0.0052973768,
0.030525092,
-0.0346629173,
0.0261484478,
-0.0258483496,
-0.0326206051,
-0.0042361477,
-0.0594784133,
0.041287601,
0.0283966511,
0.0300125089,
0.0268461648,
0.0739695579,
-0.0218633693,
0.062205039,
-0.0410976559,
0.0465954393,
-0.0085615087,
-0.0721059814,
0.0209684018,
-0.0420398377,
-0.0344374739,
0.0340774953,
-0.0051116324,
0.0166116077,
-0.0128268292,
-0.0246723015,
0.0285338275,
-0.0445857868,
-0.0050049243,
0.0089832805,
-0.0047459919,
-0.000517497,
0.0473105311,
0.0499592014,
-0.0102493502,
0.0026336559,
0.0607538074,
-0.0405365489,
-0.0112758735,
-0.0559287108,
-0.0315201581,
0.019256169,
0.0131475013,
-0.0809023753,
0.0112249283,
-0.0270630997,
0.0214530732,
0.0176068805,
-0.0051578428,
0.001983589,
-0.0212060623,
2.8e-7,
-0.0055301581,
0.009735628,
0.0436528921,
-0.0441302285,
0.0021783111,
-0.0391580723,
-0.010204006,
0.001352245,
0.0031541276,
0.0053905468,
0.0229844879,
-0.0224012118,
0.1046849638,
0.0292890389,
-0.073349528,
-0.0270305742,
-0.0735520422,
-0.0108946161,
-0.0201336127,
-0.01044288,
0.0442151576,
0.0823438913,
-0.0596081913,
-0.0445102565,
-0.0032110442,
0.0091707762,
0.040214356,
-0.0418628156,
-0.0067603528,
0.0335333347,
0.0296050478,
-0.0059508984,
-0.0187338926,
0.0342270844,
-0.0500727221,
0.0051410059,
0.0434497073,
0.0732507259,
-0.0653967336,
-0.0080722691,
0.0228532683,
0.0381677747,
-0.0420235209,
-0.0093862936,
0.0432832018,
-0.0240414254,
-0.0351282135,
-0.0027124789,
-0.0223579258,
-0.0049605058,
0.0274995528,
0.0029988787,
0.0030761678,
0.0488575399,
0.0150053306,
0.01753534,
-0.0469212197,
-0.0381642841,
-0.0138901975,
0.0056681568,
-0.0140242679,
-0.0325023048,
0.0261589326,
-0.0074495059,
0.0010697463,
-0.0029014386,
0.0092952959,
1.936774109e-34,
0.0454736948,
-0.0271388553,
0.0130088823,
-0.0108355833,
0.0236216318,
-0.07904616,
0.0173566043,
0.0483218133,
-0.0068348316,
-0.021034129,
-0.0231286474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01463v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01463v1 | Creating Trustworthy LLMs: Dealing with Hallucinations in Healthcare AI | 2023-09-26T20:52:46 | 2023-09-26T20:52:46 | Muhammad Aurangzeb Ahmad, Ilker Yaramis, Taposh Dutta Roy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.NE | Large language models have proliferated across multiple domains in as short
period of time. There is however hesitation in the medical and healthcare
domain towards their adoption because of issues like factuality, coherence, and
hallucinations. Give the high stakes nature of healthcare, many researchers
have even cautioned against its usage until these issues are resolved. The key
to the implementation and deployment of LLMs in healthcare is to make these
models trustworthy, transparent (as much possible) and explainable. In this
paper we describe the key elements in creating reliable, trustworthy, and
unbiased models as a necessary condition for their adoption in healthcare.
Specifically we focus on the quantification, validation, and mitigation of
hallucinations in the context in healthcare. Lastly, we discuss how the future
of LLMs in healthcare may look like. | [
0.0291660447,
0.0492103174,
-0.0031677787,
0.0030681139,
-0.0304935444,
0.0025928039,
-0.025891535,
0.0222322736,
0.0256338641,
-0.0095792543,
0.0129956165,
-0.0367375351,
0.0264584366,
0.0369126014,
0.0197404679,
-0.0460733436,
0.0637808293,
-0.0077069919,
0.0118809054,
-0.0005809905,
-0.0325579122,
-0.0012756893,
-0.0353266262,
0.0576305427,
0.0034310955,
-0.0158112049,
-0.0013665722,
0.0022001097,
-0.0064897053,
-0.0262046512,
-0.0347512215,
0.0097498167,
-0.004718875,
0.0033060263,
0.0000020616,
-0.0680403113,
-0.0210171137,
0.0147040784,
-0.0487190671,
-0.0566907227,
0.0033555026,
-0.0269269347,
-0.0188430753,
0.0198929179,
-0.0105101373,
0.0420586169,
0.0358131155,
0.0743321478,
0.0524468124,
0.0645266324,
-0.00602816,
0.0113999071,
0.0236219596,
-0.006798177,
0.0260842945,
-0.0376784205,
0.0402094312,
-0.0002577838,
0.0370099954,
-0.0465871729,
0.0120398821,
0.0341595188,
0.011527244,
0.0273017269,
-0.015699422,
0.0209971722,
-0.0344168469,
-0.0227764044,
-0.0279655978,
0.0252139624,
-0.0014147516,
-0.0128306402,
0.0437408499,
0.0111904368,
-0.0037384278,
0.0089075686,
-0.0211747307,
0.0275704674,
-0.0200554729,
0.0065540825,
0.0021840874,
0.0054083699,
0.0637412593,
0.0112894084,
-0.0190649442,
0.0357254781,
-0.0031613365,
-0.0395984389,
0.0232553761,
-0.0166316032,
0.0385108404,
-0.0425642543,
0.0184285082,
0.0723034963,
-0.0620303899,
0.0206260812,
-0.0221238825,
0.0543301925,
0.0922694877,
-0.0881272182,
0.0037722716,
-0.0061256066,
-0.0309763309,
0.0108909942,
0.0043828208,
0.0021977886,
-0.0480862372,
0.0653175637,
-0.0287154764,
0.0213699155,
-0.0319534168,
0.0056745657,
-0.0131255705,
0.0117798839,
0.0074971626,
0.0081342906,
-0.0763129517,
-0.0073312032,
-0.0416532904,
0.0759618804,
-0.0044733491,
0.0284696575,
-0.0098279212,
-0.0253267325,
-0.029669676,
-0.0414201692,
0.0166382417,
0.0202424619,
-0.0130422972,
-0.0695938841,
0.0174561106,
0.0356683806,
-0.0597480536,
0.0239572022,
-0.0269828569,
0.076996401,
0.0375450142,
0.0090007624,
-0.0378607251,
-0.0695828423,
-0.0290765148,
-0.0481042266,
0.0237197652,
-0.0459662117,
-0.0083098151,
-0.0174392257,
-0.0016240166,
-0.06808725,
0.0250238739,
-0.0001657473,
-0.0471115075,
0.0598702878,
-0.0852436498,
0.0218293332,
0.0217746235,
0.084440358,
-0.0041957032,
0.0174447317,
0.0392088108,
-0.0047889436,
0.0088690799,
-0.0165329129,
0.0867021009,
0.0070378198,
-0.0069605857,
0.0068632811,
0.0017854529,
0.0110012386,
-0.0100444918,
0.0547616407,
-0.0715294406,
0.0708592385,
0.0037297097,
0.0071121822,
0.041706685,
0.0401542932,
0.0226279534,
-0.004325815,
0.0030837855,
-0.0559475832,
0.0009345321,
-0.0012217043,
-0.0416490771,
-0.002088561,
0.0070527792,
0.000919127,
-0.0194765944,
-0.004685529,
-0.0261660945,
-0.0699844137,
-0.0514573827,
-0.0441360772,
-0.0342316367,
-0.0061038323,
0.0124912458,
-0.0238064472,
-0.0194840655,
0.0721784011,
0.0314875357,
-0.0386966467,
-0.0336233526,
-0.0984122753,
0.0023307649,
0.1140869483,
0.0478172339,
-0.037622977,
-0.0182643998,
-0.0614859238,
0.0205615833,
0.0254225563,
0.0109129352,
0.0034511751,
0.0074060978,
-0.0549965762,
-0.0097930422,
0.0401594453,
0.0338395089,
0.0022861424,
-0.0488427989,
0.0275649801,
-0.0269197021,
-0.0031612448,
-0.0501020402,
0.0462869443,
-0.0532729253,
0.0034623682,
-0.0229145996,
-0.0166653246,
0.0479924083,
0.039675381,
-0.0048173172,
0.0475081168,
0.0311245695,
-0.0160913616,
-0.026192788,
0.0250934996,
-0.0079249889,
0.0670103803,
0.0108208545,
-0.0100524118,
0.015728062,
-0.0400683396,
-0.0045023556,
-0.0183254667,
-0.0359087698,
-0.0529173166,
0.039578557,
-0.0156694185,
0.0471002348,
0.0106955357,
0.0230827313,
-0.0232398491,
0.017187072,
-0.0758525059,
-0.0123291705,
0.0126800453,
-0.0058288304,
0.0096089737,
-0.0168245025,
0.002682595,
0.0459062681,
0.0096991416,
0.0523787178,
-0.0326140188,
-0.0013175813,
-0.0309103951,
-0.0126903383,
-0.0576765873,
-0.0327956788,
0.0022692482,
-0.0031028783,
-0.0116828671,
-0.0285221897,
-0.0043386975,
-0.0000361914,
-0.0059045977,
-0.0140771512,
0.0353424586,
0.0078646075,
0.0083822645,
0.0079045836,
-0.0593533479,
-0.0003692164,
0.0152457347,
-0.0386354886,
0.0244882535,
-0.0022334843,
-0.0431195386,
-0.0686524585,
0.0223356877,
-0.0203847326,
-0.0190858617,
-0.008611816,
-0.0227808356,
0.0269326922,
0.0162915625,
-0.0177865196,
0.0294968523,
-0.0250359681,
0.0321616419,
0.0687531754,
-0.0027177241,
-0.0053446824,
-0.0276174303,
-0.0034342713,
-0.013067646,
0.0017246074,
-0.0549192801,
0.0346168727,
0.0577517822,
0.0199484583,
0.0218625944,
-0.0294511449,
0.0105335247,
-0.0333464928,
-0.0253992807,
0.0214553382,
-0.0451335311,
-0.0456365682,
0.088505514,
0.0218394659,
-0.0458750501,
0.0629641712,
-0.0315824114,
0.0488981754,
-0.0437304564,
-0.0381297618,
-0.0258980915,
-0.0240755342,
-0.0471961573,
0.001701711,
0.014254597,
-0.0111637777,
0.0198511556,
-0.0449782386,
-0.0394438915,
-0.0639542416,
0.0702766031,
-0.0285481904,
0.0148113975,
0.0160316639,
-0.004210317,
-0.06305179,
0.0094247824,
-0.0249393396,
0.0082603768,
-0.045912154,
0.0238087494,
-0.0585081875,
-0.005383837,
0.0143233128,
0.0294274166,
0.0307322796,
-0.0294380393,
0.0049698306,
-0.0586331673,
0.0033730075,
0.0104194116,
0.0524043627,
-0.0246784482,
0.0330489278,
0.0661365166,
0.0228259377,
0.0310893804,
-0.0234365091,
-0.0328733549,
-0.0085575636,
-0.026458282,
-0.0021436645,
0.0558778979,
0.0218902193,
-0.0336284786,
-0.0047520269,
0.0874494836,
0.0141013479,
-0.038886074,
0.0524141528,
-0.0697498024,
-0.0372603312,
-0.0023959507,
-0.0221585538,
-0.0708625466,
0.0110106673,
-0.0056141294,
0.03498419,
-0.0366914831,
-0.0114255147,
0.0047675804,
-0.0070453705,
0.0634675026,
0.0289085153,
0.0098625729,
-0.0556458794,
-0.0003069834,
-0.0032619894,
-0.0011683811,
0.0530225858,
-0.0129548535,
0.0163447652,
-0.0343564115,
0.0125133451,
-0.0739994273,
-0.040109437,
0.0134272575,
-0.0201436039,
0.0693470389,
0.0916021764,
0.0277661793,
-0.0444068834,
-0.081455119,
-0.0031310837,
0.0256519541,
0.0232031085,
0.0077588861,
0.0574016273,
0.0193574838,
0.0261391662,
-0.0264937542,
0.0101076821,
-0.060641177,
-0.0397761017,
0.0256658997,
0.0865219012,
-0.1018161848,
-0.0586357862,
-0.0407225452,
0.0471668951,
0.0397833399,
0.0676575452,
0.0102288462,
0.0033943334,
-0.0410402268,
-0.005050844,
0.0543220155,
0.0303121638,
-0.0390504934,
0.0591880716,
0.0029586162,
-0.0385084152,
-0.05382476,
-0.0287754443,
-0.0108560184,
0.0337652415,
0.0214577634,
0.0390261225,
0.0241017435,
-0.0054817763,
-0.0041606654,
0.0087057324,
0.0014518887,
0.0319008194,
-0.0153100519,
-0.0055782436,
0.0283763167,
-0.0143409045,
0.0289850179,
-0.0119224722,
0.0182393044,
-0.0179853309,
0.0455280803,
0.0541039519,
0.0375308283,
0.0196266212,
-0.0149248829,
-0.0210865084,
0.0319133364,
0.0023121624,
-0.0326870307,
-0.0073201167,
0.0280637499,
0.0583052672,
0.0090746181,
0.0137487901,
-0.0242247321,
0.0015432036,
-0.002032259,
0.0089017274,
-0.0452393629,
-0.01088663,
0.009818892,
0.0052786963,
-0.0234443136,
-0.0259018093,
0.0254367944,
0.0010239793,
0.0175688546,
-0.0507551879,
0.0161331836,
-0.004797271,
0.0054596434,
0.0129461661,
-0.0207609925,
0.0223705638,
-0.052543655,
-0.0931369141,
-0.0531753786,
-0.01813435,
0.0536229089,
-0.0014935785,
0.0295043159,
0.0296756644,
-0.0237924717,
-0.002000714,
0.0496640466,
-0.0337449387,
0.0396045186,
0.0384755209,
0.0654454827,
-0.0009498564,
-0.0060947863,
-0.0054662433,
0.0428002924,
-0.0141661977,
-0.1119998768,
0.0032369485,
0.029053105,
0.0231260471,
0.0497321263,
0.0196216963,
-0.0421143919,
0.035238754,
0.003136164,
0.0216122232,
0.0197670367,
0.0302459765,
0.0086767282,
0.0199184511,
-0.0281427503,
-0.0208741669,
0.0673052594,
-0.0239974316,
0.0401591323,
-0.0439275913,
-0.0415451154,
-0.0480354689,
-0.0579866655,
-0.0291974228,
0.015113553,
-0.065160051,
-0.0378086679,
-0.0748899207,
-0.0206632204,
0.0438624322,
-0.0155138029,
-0.010796058,
-0.0381789394,
0.0398558564,
0.0562105961,
0.0234886538,
-0.0078991875,
-0.0117460759,
0.0077011655,
0.0187228899,
0.002276161,
0.0356804952,
-5.867413196e-33,
0.0357625857,
-0.0545158871,
0.0416709334,
-0.0299551561,
0.000894952,
0.0034371989,
-0.0273318458,
0.0025019699,
-0.0122864544,
0.0112648262,
0.0027130698,
0.0290705059,
0.0163977891,
0.0020684898,
0.0217358451,
-0.0473101214,
0.0144772166,
0.0265113413,
0.0013911269,
0.0170417,
-0.0335440412,
0.0091213714,
0.0442779846,
-0.1181408763,
0.0691264272,
0.0107599236,
-0.0139105255,
0.0078312028,
-0.058856871,
0.0482192785,
-0.0166025572,
0.0181517992,
0.0287478678,
-0.0230028816,
0.0029997958,
0.0101631014,
0.0215378162,
-0.0077222795,
0.0140647367,
0.0101319738,
-0.0563605577,
-0.046346195,
0.0474748835,
-0.0115504824,
-0.0406591482,
0.0150915198,
-0.0044985767,
-0.0636126995,
-0.0108040767,
-0.010096916,
-0.0330320708,
0.0377157293,
-0.0060238573,
0.0142961955,
-0.0066442713,
-0.0033476728,
-0.052784659,
0.0053419396,
-0.0668409988,
-0.0141518181,
0.0051437761,
-0.0392869338,
0.0583344959,
-0.0708328262,
-0.0319684669,
0.0548089035,
0.0572868846,
0.0293555018,
-0.0808731467,
0.0001783065,
-0.0519045293,
0.1006599218,
0.0565241985,
0.0054969527,
-0.0412515923,
-0.0277762841,
-0.0794047192,
0.0268600192,
-0.0692235529,
0.041947037,
0.0607436113,
-0.0204476491,
-0.1107758507,
-0.0124643762,
0.0048539625,
-0.0074264966,
-0.0200101752,
-0.0246742629,
0.0129677327,
-0.010086691,
0.0189017188,
0.023638526,
-0.0113023743,
-0.0290481392,
0.0486461893,
-0.0360276587,
0.0463026054,
-0.0207552947,
-0.0280171502,
-0.0043357206,
-0.0129103074,
-0.0034363375,
-0.0255176742,
0.0094511779,
0.0619452894,
0.0146882152,
0.0004075496,
-0.041019015,
-0.0402276777,
0.0153846573,
0.0072499844,
0.0050018388,
0.0410871208,
-0.0107617304,
0.0401146263,
-0.010124851,
-0.0057169553,
0.0580181777,
0.0031483923,
-0.0140278786,
-0.022057835,
0.0243384242,
-0.0283171609,
0.0193483569,
-0.0548570082,
-0.0144290645,
-0.0407721847,
0.0410074517,
0.0588004254,
-0.049631685,
-0.001964788,
-0.0245968476,
2.798e-7,
0.0403806753,
0.0469849929,
0.0100846896,
-0.0247219075,
0.0335795693,
0.0250222608,
0.0028652535,
0.0004408736,
-0.0345867127,
-0.0653925836,
0.0100997044,
-0.0068379804,
0.0478802621,
0.042167563,
-0.0186153818,
-0.0299940147,
-0.0455811396,
-0.0060166568,
-0.059756048,
-0.0212400611,
0.035716027,
0.01598938,
-0.0141201857,
-0.0478869602,
-0.0043517333,
0.004234713,
0.010508474,
-0.0453756899,
0.0171519704,
0.0540280938,
0.0720147192,
0.0122756939,
0.0271964055,
0.0283543691,
-0.011138821,
-0.0217151586,
-0.0084241545,
0.1015434563,
-0.0700815395,
-0.0166803245,
0.0142192077,
-0.0340977646,
0.0268018972,
-0.0301721003,
0.0516847931,
0.0044347253,
-0.0606122203,
-0.0353538468,
-0.0081630256,
-0.0290325452,
0.090189226,
0.0084461253,
0.0055026482,
0.0150206685,
0.0055898633,
0.0356436819,
-0.0117868409,
-0.0326189548,
0.0142923789,
0.0313390903,
-0.0146175642,
-0.0305859521,
0.0550617315,
-0.0056231697,
-0.0032311277,
-0.0959291309,
0.0096770795,
2.480024461e-34,
0.0112378644,
-0.0003680113,
0.0162677616,
0.0506238826,
0.0276982132,
0.023060957,
0.0277692918,
0.0200829618,
0.0321288928,
-0.0063698995,
-0.0039287293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15238v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15238v1 | Learning Using Generated Privileged Information by Text-to-Image Diffusion Models | 2023-09-26T20:04:48 | 2023-09-26T20:04:48 | Rafael-Edy Menadil, Mariana-Iuliana Georgescu, Radu Tudor Ionescu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Learning Using Privileged Information is a particular type of knowledge
distillation where the teacher model benefits from an additional data
representation during training, called privileged information, improving the
student model, which does not see the extra representation. However, privileged
information is rarely available in practice. To this end, we propose a text
classification framework that harnesses text-to-image diffusion models to
generate artificial privileged information. The generated images and the
original text samples are further used to train multimodal teacher models based
on state-of-the-art transformer-based architectures. Finally, the knowledge
from multimodal teachers is distilled into a text-based (unimodal) student.
Hence, by employing a generative model to produce synthetic data as privileged
information, we guide the training of the student model. Our framework, called
Learning Using Generated Privileged Information (LUGPI), yields noticeable
performance gains on four text classification data sets, demonstrating its
potential in text classification without any additional cost during inference. | [
0.0271736495,
0.0660428405,
-0.0179900136,
0.0507993437,
0.0044557601,
-0.0030385053,
0.0440979674,
-0.0192199945,
-0.0377251469,
-0.0758557394,
-0.0259774979,
-0.0330360048,
-0.0216827132,
-0.0306402389,
0.0357850306,
-0.1027570218,
-0.0190900881,
-0.0083065778,
-0.0777807161,
-0.0186191946,
0.0066383872,
-0.0001704213,
-0.0019813373,
-0.004415012,
-0.0560757779,
0.0109090619,
-0.0053953673,
0.0305212811,
0.0652544424,
-0.0046144747,
0.0082982033,
0.0389350951,
0.0573891401,
-0.029987108,
0.0000023014,
0.0020954108,
-0.0162675679,
0.0004763702,
0.0313014537,
-0.0295498408,
0.0981747806,
-0.0376583859,
0.0198016819,
-0.0168835558,
-0.0327203684,
0.0004038591,
0.0584886745,
0.0954023302,
0.0449459702,
0.0701757744,
-0.0376632027,
-0.059416309,
0.0385279581,
-0.0053321803,
0.0402700603,
-0.0060262489,
0.0110065956,
0.019448841,
-0.0142672351,
0.039018333,
-0.0735352486,
0.0573616996,
0.0486721806,
-0.009074063,
0.0601193458,
0.0368956514,
0.0511547923,
-0.0367420614,
-0.0157844126,
0.0577508174,
-0.0137422066,
-0.0143490219,
0.0033518632,
-0.0067103417,
0.0125329401,
0.0631786883,
-0.0111903353,
0.0337769948,
-0.014282546,
0.034366373,
-0.0422881767,
0.0282261949,
-0.0080940165,
-0.0150132589,
-0.0147017594,
-0.0438407548,
0.0105149988,
0.0161812957,
-0.0259894058,
0.012823048,
-0.0171966497,
0.0023778162,
0.0048792078,
0.0240465794,
0.0608358644,
0.0200746562,
-0.0502515472,
-0.0756493211,
0.0063768728,
-0.0075227353,
0.0009630097,
-0.0123010278,
-0.0279983636,
0.0088211764,
-0.0085717067,
0.001903547,
-0.0469889268,
0.0813284591,
-0.0414714403,
0.0001964415,
-0.0549246371,
-0.0274468642,
0.0066063884,
0.0018681847,
-0.0273903962,
-0.0275796428,
-0.0327177942,
-0.0066027292,
-0.0101448065,
0.0001949659,
0.0099149691,
0.0369232111,
-0.0424918719,
0.0104275011,
-0.0322252475,
0.0291506182,
0.0237561073,
0.0226640292,
-0.0144135738,
0.0056822454,
0.0126734497,
0.0128464736,
0.0174231082,
0.006584452,
0.0096533997,
0.0462426953,
-0.0732534975,
-0.045236323,
-0.0712691098,
-0.0173658095,
-0.0121516893,
-0.0351315401,
0.0545564406,
-0.0693415701,
0.025247084,
-0.0204818714,
0.0189700574,
-0.0341138393,
0.0249638036,
0.0066332188,
0.018216636,
0.0867824182,
0.0035287063,
-0.0131649366,
0.0730492622,
0.0642925799,
0.0172380731,
0.067335248,
0.0247882959,
0.0384285711,
0.018995814,
-0.0175621975,
0.0126155177,
0.0376008637,
0.0281716026,
0.0038764295,
0.0152815776,
-0.0451979376,
-0.0081084697,
-0.0020446423,
0.0479215086,
0.0316779688,
-0.0331473462,
-0.011132692,
0.080072701,
0.0118865026,
0.0127249425,
0.0133035462,
0.0141041065,
0.0217394847,
-0.0316207297,
0.0268803723,
-0.0074453796,
0.0180930272,
0.023683263,
-0.0355550647,
-0.0197546557,
0.0401906334,
-0.0273509063,
-0.0690497756,
0.0454158708,
-0.0639057457,
0.0402944088,
-0.0202770755,
0.067478165,
0.0516726784,
-0.0169135928,
0.0106004383,
0.0417669266,
-0.0364409238,
0.0120337093,
-0.0291428845,
-0.0043991148,
0.0540157668,
0.0155381858,
-0.0585726686,
0.056881424,
-0.0121323159,
0.0122855734,
0.049086377,
-0.0050738398,
0.0070552626,
0.0136219384,
-0.0563659631,
-0.0441493541,
0.0185240973,
0.0177877378,
0.035464216,
-0.033484783,
0.0228445809,
0.0177398678,
-0.0076952321,
-0.0351229496,
0.0463567413,
-0.00874657,
-0.0398444273,
-0.0020302942,
0.0244955663,
0.0006184889,
0.0017057828,
-0.0335081927,
-0.0466720276,
0.0029662249,
-0.0465010442,
-0.0480417125,
-0.0129013825,
-0.0487719774,
-0.0206397772,
-0.0036848045,
-0.1090462431,
0.0256857034,
0.0562723242,
-0.0165469311,
-0.0418672226,
0.0060978914,
-0.0075849285,
0.0224967152,
-0.0279825591,
-0.0113138789,
0.0343647674,
0.0239329711,
-0.0176964104,
0.0329492949,
-0.0159965158,
-0.01057244,
-0.0082143713,
-0.0172272678,
0.0076037128,
-0.001737748,
-0.0193273798,
-0.0219479445,
0.007399518,
0.0316743068,
0.005232207,
0.0112513108,
-0.0150979692,
-0.0096132047,
-0.0772316307,
-0.0356695354,
-0.0140438899,
-0.0450109057,
0.003610525,
-0.0008254486,
0.0212273654,
-0.0056009125,
-0.0483118668,
-0.0130260298,
-0.0410546996,
-0.0411610156,
0.016742181,
0.0081565231,
0.0329978988,
-0.0113049792,
0.0013883578,
-0.0053252713,
0.0713322833,
0.0266262461,
0.0126373088,
-0.0070876768,
0.0036581985,
0.0173649844,
0.0635187924,
-0.0281604901,
-0.0286076348,
0.007434079,
-0.0099329874,
0.0136389509,
0.0638282597,
0.0378434397,
0.0575603843,
0.0028106349,
0.0060870117,
-0.0548404977,
0.0179782771,
-0.0340607129,
0.0247652121,
-0.0236038975,
-0.0384922475,
-0.0136448443,
0.0449273773,
0.0163201392,
-0.0206456855,
-0.0601644777,
-0.0035806498,
0.01051181,
-0.0390105247,
-0.0183765963,
0.0290273223,
0.0245118868,
-0.0222752932,
-0.0404249169,
-0.0389982946,
0.0379205942,
-0.0332172364,
0.000603998,
-0.026822079,
-0.0127443625,
0.0005520184,
0.0334055312,
0.0401279964,
0.0676973611,
0.0171668176,
0.0373826921,
-0.0408358313,
0.0315817408,
0.0422799475,
-0.0091525717,
0.0244711153,
-0.0229571536,
-0.0194438286,
-0.0318952426,
-0.0246548224,
-0.0179262124,
-0.0577119477,
0.0380619466,
-0.0156929512,
-0.0012534767,
-0.0362201408,
-0.0027193795,
-0.0240452625,
0.0196695551,
0.0465150215,
0.0134669263,
-0.0426000021,
-0.0055276174,
0.0530421287,
0.0168625489,
-0.0179093964,
-0.07082849,
-0.0343961194,
0.0074457172,
0.0763679743,
0.0143942134,
-0.0058336882,
-0.0390717275,
-0.004260106,
0.0020529178,
0.0345204435,
-0.0072121923,
-0.0146662975,
0.0475102738,
-0.0314233489,
0.0147618446,
0.0344562456,
0.0085726231,
-0.0413134955,
-0.0189702716,
0.0366185792,
0.030357074,
-0.0029608421,
-0.0079215979,
-0.1096751764,
-0.0463702977,
-0.0469470173,
0.0161875691,
-0.0051331697,
-0.0021801237,
0.015075543,
-0.0484067537,
0.0356477052,
0.0060230042,
0.0097851027,
-0.0074074757,
-0.0222849622,
-0.0137954261,
0.0360901393,
-0.0384086035,
-0.0455654226,
-0.0026658394,
-0.008924094,
0.0208295882,
0.0304874759,
-0.0789525434,
-0.0385526493,
0.0247800704,
-0.0258163381,
0.0238106884,
-0.0003594161,
-0.0232184287,
-0.0750119686,
-0.0316701196,
0.0183514934,
0.0192395579,
-0.0024954593,
0.0865767673,
-0.0239116382,
-0.0120545039,
-0.008484764,
0.0634137914,
0.005226742,
-0.0195874907,
-0.0255431253,
0.0710255876,
-0.001078335,
-0.0214800686,
-0.0528043807,
-0.0138160782,
0.0535524674,
0.0329615436,
0.0101585956,
-0.0773194954,
-0.0078969393,
-0.0273533575,
0.0440450646,
-0.0385561958,
-0.0525967255,
0.0459074117,
-0.0104164639,
-0.0709564537,
-0.0785346702,
-0.0136711514,
-0.0112431869,
0.0424761064,
0.0118749328,
-0.0245822966,
0.0144023132,
-0.0236299746,
-0.0538748875,
0.0084648412,
-0.0088426871,
0.0099647883,
-0.0286618713,
-0.0607843548,
0.0284334999,
-0.0553981923,
-0.0439189076,
0.0233928505,
-0.0652171448,
-0.060205996,
-0.033820983,
0.0688964948,
0.0129464138,
0.0135997022,
0.0328969136,
-0.0503719673,
0.1364479959,
0.0662940517,
-0.0053997836,
-0.015326092,
0.0555664338,
-0.0471915267,
0.0061177886,
-0.0106898304,
-0.0311752763,
0.0659719706,
0.0052219057,
-0.0308866203,
-0.0636978522,
0.0171800628,
-0.0141853718,
-0.0419424176,
0.0313191153,
-0.0460827313,
0.0139352912,
-0.0363136157,
0.0323014967,
-0.0041988622,
0.0117477179,
-0.0658034682,
0.0006293975,
0.0470501147,
0.0401767343,
-0.0037055775,
-0.0054752324,
0.06351161,
0.0331257954,
-0.0421184413,
0.002978303,
0.0420045741,
-0.0036294935,
0.0041908543,
0.0354977548,
0.0074446034,
-0.0032132298,
0.0257475004,
0.0349172018,
0.0144573506,
0.1149163023,
0.0462840423,
-0.0119868908,
-0.0265364628,
0.0115834884,
-0.0667313486,
0.0025879443,
-0.0324928388,
0.0158298519,
0.0376693755,
0.0208612476,
-0.0011008375,
-0.0410466678,
-0.0027974071,
-0.0061524552,
0.0285007451,
-0.0077279825,
-0.0145122381,
0.0426239111,
-0.0225630701,
0.0312276874,
0.0064818175,
0.06000055,
-0.0105443457,
0.0217706934,
-0.044029668,
0.0018170053,
-0.0435213037,
-0.0162993334,
0.0635972843,
0.0101655619,
0.0383419879,
0.0296652932,
-0.0088865515,
-0.0372335054,
-0.0016545625,
0.0073662759,
-0.0026851138,
-0.0212274417,
0.0493518896,
0.0176574402,
-0.0068908217,
-0.0181711428,
-0.0316320844,
-0.0211259332,
0.0118842013,
0.0231482908,
0.0017801657,
-6.59260211e-33,
-0.0364860035,
-0.0074469172,
-0.0039867735,
0.0653529614,
-0.0054242229,
-0.0001015247,
0.0212153569,
-0.0057829586,
0.0158025958,
0.0362522677,
0.0160471741,
-0.0090723326,
0.0028416472,
0.0984421745,
-0.0337639637,
0.0233659223,
0.0444600098,
0.0075221588,
-0.0071645691,
0.0414850898,
0.0522657074,
0.0261374488,
0.0608947165,
-0.0894520581,
-0.0128241563,
-0.0154821994,
-0.0108181527,
-0.0204710942,
0.0303656366,
0.0155318063,
-0.0461640954,
0.0676933005,
0.0314802043,
-0.0652647465,
-0.0010224766,
0.067118071,
-0.0984514952,
-0.0254429709,
-0.0296452492,
0.0168857276,
-0.0464138798,
-0.0168508198,
0.0657543764,
0.0027531188,
0.0114250034,
-0.0296021532,
0.0758976862,
0.0064974837,
0.0354734436,
-0.0674131885,
-0.0585245304,
0.0097597372,
-0.0242866706,
-0.0245690327,
0.0249074064,
0.0159549098,
0.0316198915,
0.0002334237,
-0.0880619586,
0.003366668,
0.0262148865,
0.0169403516,
0.0343994536,
0.0594528541,
-0.0132146114,
0.0511119515,
0.0049770647,
-0.0084590232,
-0.0426359512,
0.0008474704,
0.0472891666,
0.0376800075,
0.0164000373,
0.0531424284,
0.0127328215,
-0.0289994869,
-0.0493500568,
0.0432662666,
-0.0433753692,
-0.0221053157,
0.0039344537,
-0.0066882242,
-0.008388184,
-0.0184067767,
-0.0417146757,
-0.0401807018,
0.0196644608,
-0.0128812632,
0.0174357668,
0.0234355573,
-0.0149292937,
0.0274706502,
0.035406813,
-0.0307888165,
-0.0549371839,
-0.0285116229,
-0.0163724571,
0.0613256209,
-0.0276230276,
-0.0270784125,
-0.0446404368,
-0.0530592427,
0.0821598172,
0.008491897,
0.0114624035,
0.0323113464,
0.0752750263,
0.0393089429,
-0.0505948476,
-0.0126908692,
-0.0244948864,
0.021450283,
0.0150323445,
0.0228831135,
-0.0105589991,
-0.0015117229,
-0.0551023036,
0.0264142845,
0.0105557647,
0.0506247841,
-0.0369415171,
-0.0421000943,
0.0007018792,
0.0105064921,
-0.0239777658,
0.0049389773,
-0.0338815637,
-0.0008110431,
0.0581871942,
-0.0979821309,
0.0091379089,
0.0373285674,
2.848e-7,
0.0489358418,
-0.0045563006,
-0.0144452555,
-0.0517224856,
0.013211214,
0.0626134053,
0.0047357944,
0.0472040921,
-0.0040289299,
-0.054468412,
0.0060751271,
0.0652685463,
-0.0044941627,
0.0153637556,
-0.0531261638,
-0.0445266813,
0.0131683508,
-0.0077803684,
-0.0197044015,
0.0268368535,
0.0728534162,
0.0568579845,
0.0235912874,
-0.0351618305,
0.033713486,
-0.0257086251,
0.0855927393,
-0.0169602241,
0.0432455391,
0.0086439792,
0.072840184,
-0.0037878391,
-0.0156327505,
0.031329155,
-0.0162161216,
0.0028970714,
-0.0111137535,
0.0101132458,
-0.0474457629,
-0.0037002398,
0.0114875659,
0.0141461203,
-0.0482707247,
-0.0410466902,
0.0511240363,
-0.062190786,
0.0026552868,
0.0201394632,
-0.0420785025,
-0.0046743117,
-0.0108879078,
-0.0092779463,
-0.0354581475,
0.0101395054,
0.0085869133,
0.0050390181,
-0.009316898,
-0.0977936387,
-0.0013348203,
-0.0333966576,
-0.0554767996,
0.0019973633,
-0.0383799523,
-0.0493030772,
-0.0107259722,
-0.0099087805,
-0.0104960846,
2.22063625e-34,
0.0012228215,
0.0257082116,
-0.0121023944,
-0.0171258356,
0.0030178139,
-0.0000452369,
-0.0344057381,
-0.0226220787,
0.0076280949,
-0.0449665263,
-0.0098691732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15223v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15223v2 | Low-rank Adaptation of Large Language Model Rescoring for Parameter-Efficient Speech Recognition | 2023-09-26T19:41:34 | 2023-10-10T06:30:47 | Yu Yu, Chao-Han Huck Yang, Jari Kolehmainen, Prashanth G. Shivakumar, Yile Gu, Sungho Ryu, Roger Ren, Qi Luo, Aditya Gourav, I-Fan Chen, Yi-Chieh Liu, Tuan Dinh, Ankur Gandhe, Denis Filimonov, Shalini Ghosh, Andreas Stolcke, Ariya Rastow, Ivan Bulyko | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE, cs.SD, eess.AS | We propose a neural language modeling system based on low-rank adaptation
(LoRA) for speech recognition output rescoring. Although pretrained language
models (LMs) like BERT have shown superior performance in second-pass
rescoring, the high computational cost of scaling up the pretraining stage and
adapting the pretrained models to specific domains limit their practical use in
rescoring. Here we present a method based on low-rank decomposition to train a
rescoring BERT model and adapt it to new domains using only a fraction (0.08%)
of the pretrained parameters. These inserted matrices are optimized through a
discriminative training objective along with a correlation-based regularization
loss. The proposed low-rank adaptation Rescore-BERT (LoRB) architecture is
evaluated on LibriSpeech and internal datasets with decreased training times by
factors between 5.4 and 3.6. | [
-0.0194651876,
0.0428393148,
0.0087991664,
0.0569778383,
0.0439669676,
0.0126065444,
-0.0219963957,
0.0191505216,
0.0165584944,
-0.0338843241,
-0.0628318116,
0.0075762165,
0.0208416115,
-0.0296433922,
0.0266879667,
-0.0244476646,
0.0310392585,
-0.0578065068,
0.0138045745,
-0.0159598738,
-0.0148055805,
0.0056918198,
-0.0274161901,
0.0056828302,
0.0279608723,
0.018060904,
0.013424648,
0.0393149555,
0.0083068646,
0.0105361873,
0.0147124156,
0.0266999658,
0.0598320216,
0.0346964672,
0.0000019341,
-0.0109661138,
-0.005868441,
-0.0252127592,
-0.027990343,
0.0264098719,
0.0029134881,
0.0281624962,
-0.0187260211,
0.0516909957,
0.0097171776,
-0.0101019116,
0.0638301075,
0.0003297005,
0.022852188,
0.0768945292,
-0.0172052402,
-0.0828451291,
-0.0009878534,
0.0010348269,
-0.0654530004,
-0.029315738,
0.009650656,
-0.0133172581,
-0.0199016258,
-0.0517659299,
-0.0167344771,
0.0074770469,
-0.020344248,
0.0162844658,
-0.0109082889,
0.0083367527,
-0.0094716381,
0.0088540595,
-0.0104296468,
0.0769087225,
-0.0394940004,
-0.0147995641,
0.0095860139,
0.0112927118,
0.0204536952,
-0.0473622791,
-0.0104007646,
-0.0129103661,
0.0628609881,
0.0204642732,
-0.0276717786,
-0.0195445139,
0.0371944979,
0.014196299,
-0.0313138552,
0.0009793426,
0.0411540791,
-0.0309106279,
-0.0402174406,
-0.026943706,
0.0062151933,
0.0315074921,
0.0269067716,
0.036384467,
-0.0154984938,
0.0142129231,
-0.0388202891,
-0.0712073296,
-0.0195360798,
-0.0313444436,
0.0204216167,
0.0485803895,
-0.007312092,
0.0032903457,
-0.0666693524,
0.0528365336,
-0.0086924536,
0.0425088592,
-0.0470614135,
-0.0150109222,
-0.0246543344,
0.0019658855,
-0.0411549881,
0.0370091759,
-0.025259532,
0.0036291298,
-0.0481953621,
0.010192086,
0.0055213924,
-0.0148931593,
0.0178469084,
-0.0069950838,
-0.0512424037,
-0.0484531224,
-0.0060392586,
0.0709946826,
0.051655408,
0.0406891294,
-0.0226512365,
-0.013786722,
-0.0131440153,
-0.0148204733,
0.0495850667,
-0.0113900024,
0.0308047198,
0.0273517035,
-0.0167123824,
-0.0578638315,
-0.0616940446,
0.0469612256,
-0.0367353335,
-0.0410178714,
0.0157184601,
-0.0385692492,
0.0297977384,
-0.0173508376,
0.0346698873,
-0.0639322996,
-0.0298177302,
-0.0172932874,
-0.0463951342,
0.0672214851,
-0.0005487102,
-0.0048811473,
0.0533322059,
-0.0152337924,
0.0373927355,
0.0576460399,
0.0469640978,
0.0027951875,
-0.015741013,
-0.036861334,
-0.0108639179,
0.0799796507,
0.0006637553,
0.0103694331,
-0.0527408794,
-0.0162896793,
0.0309165902,
0.0159162451,
0.0901333019,
0.0249064397,
-0.030099744,
-0.0249229744,
0.0487628393,
0.0423989557,
0.051193092,
0.0525620095,
-0.0028271994,
-0.0202692896,
0.0231682491,
-0.0242156498,
0.0080526927,
0.0034970907,
-0.0079895072,
-0.010754263,
0.0203372594,
0.0546337925,
-0.0502179526,
0.0090814931,
-0.0166872051,
-0.0199946798,
-0.0010994045,
0.0184463412,
0.0540696159,
-0.0047214082,
-0.0532960258,
0.031626638,
-0.0025013476,
-0.0673307404,
0.0287564788,
-0.0835464969,
-0.0042815581,
0.0484883152,
0.0363518335,
-0.0347367227,
0.0038364793,
-0.0152167035,
-0.0291484911,
-0.0002962877,
0.0357483923,
0.0065511307,
0.0479808301,
-0.0645384043,
-0.0060088132,
0.0508583747,
-0.0005597852,
0.0557218343,
-0.0531637408,
-0.0205625165,
0.0208606459,
-0.0667647645,
-0.0191281457,
0.0199504662,
-0.0330724716,
-0.0267098863,
0.0434349701,
-0.007386189,
0.0189137813,
0.0198629312,
-0.0151628898,
-0.0139643084,
0.0343623981,
-0.0230669696,
0.0312645845,
-0.0382038243,
-0.0271031652,
-0.0569168441,
0.0488038138,
0.0256598834,
0.0189674329,
0.0877291858,
0.0061867251,
-0.0728604123,
0.0440951139,
-0.0541984513,
0.0434909947,
-0.0677696243,
0.0435570814,
-0.0096936412,
0.0267355051,
-0.0232616141,
0.0224371944,
-0.008308528,
-0.0006640858,
0.0731864572,
-0.0387094468,
-0.0168621745,
-0.067625992,
-0.060657829,
0.0215629768,
-0.0134442756,
0.0531171374,
-0.0078263134,
-0.0032556234,
0.0098676374,
-0.0151284887,
-0.0754881352,
-0.0102769053,
-0.0251080785,
0.024175426,
0.0131033855,
0.0461705625,
0.0169349164,
-0.0514899082,
0.0125088748,
-0.0304443054,
-0.0412826091,
0.0085493224,
-0.0210819189,
0.0060961656,
-0.0352849178,
-0.0205633305,
-0.0030242782,
0.0309551023,
0.0433876403,
-0.0581479147,
0.0060950192,
-0.0903222635,
0.0270711705,
-0.0143557135,
0.0488178618,
0.0120817376,
-0.0589623675,
-0.0452320352,
-0.0116261207,
0.0955279693,
-0.0037032613,
-0.0196333453,
-0.0093341712,
0.0599642098,
0.0118417675,
-0.0374667719,
0.0021265186,
0.0141928429,
-0.0388243757,
-0.0097391456,
-0.0128948605,
-0.014690564,
0.0372304022,
-0.0025041006,
0.0242732242,
-0.0481337234,
-0.048795227,
0.0133627346,
-0.0279278662,
-0.067584455,
-0.0028731572,
-0.046602115,
-0.0229177512,
-0.0047523659,
0.0017374187,
0.0341301635,
-0.047227893,
-0.0214457046,
-0.0454810187,
-0.0282142889,
0.005887134,
-0.030982038,
-0.0064230892,
0.0078427158,
-0.0920901373,
-0.0424959585,
-0.0390268341,
-0.0191547126,
0.0037770278,
-0.0656192824,
0.0255188514,
-0.03036917,
0.0344237983,
-0.0424754098,
-0.0422690399,
0.0099206334,
-0.0238969773,
0.0078811571,
0.0365750156,
0.0026322065,
-0.0269946959,
0.0050103697,
0.0462329909,
0.0455620438,
0.0996133387,
0.0155835114,
0.0159450546,
-0.0165839717,
0.0916320831,
0.0174046922,
0.0416721702,
0.0145481871,
-0.0075955614,
0.051715482,
-0.0149954557,
0.0729923993,
-0.0169318691,
-0.0694155395,
0.0128886085,
0.057730291,
0.0224208143,
0.0026527038,
0.0471280999,
0.0087941121,
-0.0385205597,
-0.0012442349,
0.0800863653,
-0.005115055,
-0.0629469231,
-0.0315191001,
-0.0255784746,
0.0519452058,
0.0188643206,
0.0398300551,
0.0159967989,
-0.0037835042,
0.0137390969,
0.0348434262,
0.0302232001,
-0.0076385634,
-0.0243143979,
-0.0819492266,
0.0491764285,
0.0208952222,
0.0021009436,
-0.0749163777,
-0.0650400892,
-0.0021989602,
0.0159977581,
0.039055258,
0.0461395495,
-0.023727566,
-0.055880174,
0.0620238483,
-0.0599148385,
-0.0438693054,
-0.0373494998,
-0.0079288213,
0.06168098,
0.0381396934,
0.0193072949,
-0.0263422988,
-0.0335062817,
0.0144339595,
-0.05178608,
-0.0125137307,
0.0062188837,
0.00854972,
0.0322921947,
-0.0416704938,
0.0260712542,
0.0114628077,
-0.0183548052,
-0.019512888,
-0.0346649252,
0.0680001304,
-0.019792771,
0.028766565,
-0.0000392745,
-0.0219277702,
-0.0369850248,
0.050397478,
0.0319266431,
-0.0190959033,
0.0044291127,
0.0471903794,
0.0302695613,
-0.0215445589,
0.0277012419,
0.0051653655,
-0.0508551858,
0.0354248434,
-0.007011788,
0.0163958147,
0.0229739491,
0.0342785791,
0.0026741368,
-0.0064988364,
-0.0264956485,
0.0262333881,
-0.0360141471,
0.0149377221,
-0.0341974907,
-0.0000087428,
-0.0552334078,
-0.0102388635,
0.032127142,
-0.0412768871,
-0.0080718054,
-0.030634312,
-0.0100519871,
-0.0167679805,
0.0122356163,
0.0237721652,
0.0116022546,
0.0211794097,
0.0063659903,
-0.0866563544,
0.0419617295,
0.0105944062,
-0.019625714,
0.0536679514,
0.0298429988,
0.0014602725,
-0.026139332,
0.0211562589,
-0.0799482912,
0.0182932205,
0.0248451922,
0.0249434449,
-0.0091212848,
-0.0478890277,
-0.0121219326,
0.0284212343,
0.043432951,
-0.0169605911,
-0.0114304963,
-0.0318304226,
0.0453790352,
-0.0501460396,
0.0506917723,
-0.0202737208,
-0.0189990215,
0.045265168,
0.0127340592,
-0.0236744992,
0.0282353237,
0.0160460919,
0.0116318911,
-0.0435229354,
-0.0028302469,
-0.0216705799,
0.0057414277,
0.0126657058,
0.0147190643,
-0.0487748459,
0.0068829209,
0.0215010457,
0.0044956105,
-0.0346956216,
0.0084795672,
0.0016151166,
-0.0135191074,
-0.0446818136,
0.0435675234,
-0.032984104,
-0.0411460102,
-0.0386650972,
0.0246275291,
0.036584843,
0.0222465787,
0.0922995657,
0.0415549353,
-0.0081675677,
-0.0320672169,
-0.0232955012,
-0.0107306978,
0.0130356904,
0.0278124716,
0.0010299843,
-0.0086861681,
0.0404288433,
0.0589413084,
0.0322788209,
0.0431586131,
-0.049622748,
0.0200919714,
-0.031851463,
-0.0326827578,
0.024285797,
0.0014189387,
-0.0304122288,
-0.0040561324,
0.023105761,
-0.0509974249,
0.0081313131,
-0.0360059664,
0.0146437287,
-0.0286114942,
0.0130224619,
-0.001082783,
-0.046935495,
-0.0035277114,
0.0130559178,
-0.046929609,
0.0365514793,
-0.0436467491,
0.030085057,
-5.915552261e-33,
-0.0437918752,
0.0404566638,
0.0128857223,
-0.0000271039,
-0.0061987117,
0.0190611482,
0.00304866,
-0.0044924445,
-0.0140696811,
-0.0149973109,
-0.0132249286,
0.0097758304,
0.0253434181,
0.0197463632,
-0.0382167622,
0.0038736882,
0.0902850479,
-0.0303983185,
0.0129395276,
-0.0003177508,
0.0289474037,
0.0725857019,
0.057490468,
-0.0357555635,
-0.0757358223,
0.0086877747,
-0.0449400805,
0.0118908789,
0.0593133979,
0.0045380206,
-0.0561685599,
0.0498287901,
0.0130905118,
-0.0233475342,
-0.0148050599,
0.0333983749,
-0.1030232683,
0.0179557018,
0.0015567327,
0.0350444354,
-0.0074145123,
-0.0041221017,
0.0386372693,
0.0573098511,
-0.0371206813,
-0.0071908794,
0.0150728822,
-0.0500234738,
-0.0415279716,
-0.0155176707,
-0.0008735536,
0.0146417953,
-0.0001191503,
-0.0300594773,
0.0707506388,
0.0667909384,
-0.0452288166,
0.0093722269,
-0.079202041,
-0.0098585347,
0.0048281099,
0.069659546,
0.0314982273,
0.0478175469,
-0.0476102345,
0.0307539664,
0.0131258396,
-0.023675859,
0.0487584546,
-0.0359245054,
0.0396343134,
0.0224819761,
0.012926749,
0.0355259441,
-0.0102007557,
-0.0262492504,
-0.0510135815,
0.0226027239,
0.0333122015,
-0.0006880147,
0.0486045741,
0.0356826261,
0.005377152,
-0.0178212207,
-0.0354193822,
-0.0021337778,
-0.0464852154,
0.014268674,
0.0249752142,
0.0128673278,
0.0148917185,
-0.0211698413,
0.0606283434,
-0.0498649254,
0.0203479435,
0.0067893108,
-0.0077723935,
-0.0136198252,
0.0092741288,
0.0205706153,
-0.0199359115,
-0.0547136813,
0.0467966981,
0.0230794456,
-0.0006379927,
-0.0361506119,
-0.0026674313,
0.0597195327,
-0.0488130637,
-0.0093491161,
-0.0003556967,
-0.0087598106,
-0.0057823248,
0.0553644076,
-0.0233928375,
-0.0066426415,
0.0253449958,
0.0816457272,
0.014398627,
0.0217223447,
0.0365086533,
-0.0584500767,
0.062624976,
0.0494207926,
-0.0261312686,
-0.0072808382,
0.0190187637,
0.0155155752,
0.0338430107,
-0.0522732958,
-0.0172392353,
0.0093328608,
2.835e-7,
0.0113859223,
0.0275627207,
0.0046797614,
-0.0771559179,
0.0087273112,
0.0056049512,
0.0018104272,
0.0452716202,
0.0329001248,
0.0262066443,
0.0419968218,
-0.0264870711,
0.0465158001,
-0.0244171023,
-0.0600230917,
-0.0571487769,
-0.1106182784,
0.0248853602,
-0.0195133556,
-0.0351514444,
0.0021831237,
0.0543472692,
-0.0020743874,
-0.0469408445,
-0.0169820823,
0.0121440794,
0.0365585126,
-0.0463252254,
-0.0128555149,
-0.0290704779,
0.0781053826,
0.0208369195,
0.004517151,
0.0051359562,
-0.0041922475,
0.0972673744,
0.0165602695,
0.0505227521,
-0.0521074757,
-0.0253457241,
0.0506039597,
0.039695397,
-0.005768626,
-0.0211606771,
0.034759637,
-0.0196612179,
-0.0020329598,
-0.0152094485,
-0.0581498928,
0.0098789297,
0.0178251322,
-0.0421627797,
0.0100498414,
0.0121096121,
0.0186906066,
-0.0082580401,
-0.050467696,
-0.0928463489,
0.0247830134,
0.0407088958,
-0.0685403198,
-0.0320896581,
-0.0228624456,
-0.0397147648,
0.056797199,
-0.068507649,
0.0134537257,
2.102849421e-34,
0.0274568275,
-0.0426215604,
0.0061570001,
0.0487487353,
0.0010645279,
-0.0621370636,
0.0083238631,
0.0107574211,
0.0016487408,
-0.1084898263,
-0.0208392572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15217v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15217v1 | RAGAS: Automated Evaluation of Retrieval Augmented Generation | 2023-09-26T19:23:54 | 2023-09-26T19:23:54 | Shahul Es, Jithin James, Luis Espinosa-Anke, Steven Schockaert | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce RAGAs (Retrieval Augmented Generation Assessment), a framework
for reference-free evaluation of Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG)
pipelines. RAG systems are composed of a retrieval and an LLM based generation
module, and provide LLMs with knowledge from a reference textual database,
which enables them to act as a natural language layer between a user and
textual databases, reducing the risk of hallucinations. Evaluating RAG
architectures is, however, challenging because there are several dimensions to
consider: the ability of the retrieval system to identify relevant and focused
context passages, the ability of the LLM to exploit such passages in a faithful
way, or the quality of the generation itself. With RAGAs, we put forward a
suite of metrics which can be used to evaluate these different dimensions
\textit{without having to rely on ground truth human annotations}. We posit
that such a framework can crucially contribute to faster evaluation cycles of
RAG architectures, which is especially important given the fast adoption of
LLMs. | [
0.052141685,
-0.0000122181,
-0.0156444702,
0.0160680898,
-0.0298351031,
-0.0013926126,
-0.039260719,
-0.0136120943,
0.0270189475,
-0.0513960905,
-0.0236063451,
-0.0116118025,
-0.0191400591,
-0.0081548486,
0.0205821339,
-0.03849658,
0.042883072,
0.0242581647,
-0.0137124937,
0.039046526,
0.0069678687,
0.0202585626,
-0.0153849255,
0.0306304265,
-0.0199608933,
0.0218575411,
0.0029143344,
0.0408197083,
0.0390189365,
-0.0375790298,
-0.0054383385,
-0.0085544894,
0.0065518804,
0.0048586405,
0.000001869,
-0.0709967241,
-0.0099479221,
-0.0002908554,
-0.006934836,
-0.0121080205,
0.0784007832,
0.0830280036,
-0.0011567156,
-0.0008672471,
-0.0380492546,
0.0112361833,
0.0237159654,
0.0268251076,
0.064600274,
0.079201147,
-0.0004765287,
-0.0352790505,
0.0059868977,
-0.0025109262,
0.081257984,
-0.0379308388,
-0.0253714416,
0.0208844561,
0.058167465,
0.0299456678,
0.037876118,
0.0538394153,
0.0130892135,
0.0082190912,
0.0428345501,
0.006491337,
-0.0838932395,
0.0021963955,
-0.01567013,
0.0471060202,
0.0940175578,
-0.0019259594,
0.0021538886,
0.012524399,
0.0285274144,
0.0265181009,
-0.0448215716,
0.0169446729,
-0.0412619039,
0.0042378707,
-0.0017019325,
0.0215557162,
0.0224955976,
0.0147930859,
0.0050496096,
0.0638405085,
0.0074318922,
-0.0157936942,
0.0118630603,
0.0205530208,
0.0137473233,
0.0015390984,
-0.0011067768,
0.02509881,
-0.0331092738,
0.0314716995,
-0.0140458765,
-0.0015574271,
0.0485454872,
-0.0128586013,
0.0435705036,
0.0215543173,
-0.0501679257,
0.0181191694,
-0.0542169623,
0.0427590795,
-0.0064988947,
-0.0163210295,
-0.0398275256,
0.004913853,
-0.0598032773,
-0.0199683234,
-0.0420975909,
0.0379620567,
-0.0526135303,
-0.0375218652,
-0.0600763224,
0.0361542851,
-0.0016922971,
0.0125818644,
-0.0117149707,
0.0593561791,
-0.0402237736,
0.0046290592,
-0.0614943281,
-0.0095361667,
-0.0315837525,
-0.0157880709,
0.0510529727,
-0.0801190734,
0.0149299735,
0.0447575003,
-0.0002421879,
-0.0066578677,
-0.0146911964,
0.052042868,
0.0052622356,
-0.0403222181,
-0.0984225199,
-0.0791308731,
-0.0215961691,
-0.0374211594,
0.0042933216,
-0.0593777783,
0.0199036859,
0.0128280101,
-0.0126077235,
0.0007576388,
0.0255349744,
0.0587399192,
-0.0168697555,
0.0166355949,
-0.0176972672,
-0.0049827225,
0.0286544245,
0.0281122588,
0.0107511915,
0.0521394983,
0.021058334,
0.0656654462,
0.0457446724,
0.0481240042,
0.0079173138,
0.0045701372,
-0.0035425108,
0.0167409778,
-0.0250205565,
0.0156823397,
-0.0405936204,
0.0167629421,
0.0107171712,
0.0566931441,
-0.0446250997,
0.0398122333,
0.0132169994,
0.0061973119,
0.0626476556,
0.0237785783,
0.0880366862,
0.0351892821,
0.0049677826,
0.0333248265,
-0.007387694,
0.0335188359,
-0.0450649336,
0.0352592468,
0.0470981635,
0.0119621819,
-0.0143093159,
-0.0539659187,
-0.0279271975,
0.0124597242,
-0.0118849352,
-0.0181049407,
0.0050046705,
0.0568414815,
-0.0512629747,
0.0258231852,
-0.0047394638,
-0.0992451683,
0.0376490243,
-0.023302637,
0.0182834156,
0.0955303237,
0.1046272814,
-0.0232185982,
-0.0105048632,
0.0174432192,
-0.0021501991,
0.0505982712,
0.0130779902,
-0.0061150673,
-0.0003065096,
-0.058245331,
-0.029001167,
-0.0293509178,
0.0023067908,
0.0253708083,
0.014874584,
-0.0140848029,
0.0482265018,
-0.0265728794,
-0.0310432911,
0.0330551378,
-0.0228754394,
-0.0426333547,
-0.0072779562,
0.0077698608,
0.0109954644,
0.0401253439,
-0.0158810522,
0.0317987986,
0.0298416261,
-0.0301276464,
-0.0260230321,
0.0303974077,
-0.0238204841,
0.0031966171,
-0.0126601858,
-0.0124144638,
0.0261896588,
-0.023257995,
-0.0140196299,
-0.0447491184,
0.0066587483,
-0.0704812706,
0.0303422846,
-0.063518092,
0.0034144735,
0.0350600965,
0.0113693317,
-0.0510964245,
0.0926754549,
-0.0024799199,
0.0200537518,
0.061095871,
0.0350784846,
0.0426512621,
-0.0275105815,
-0.0291900449,
-0.0309096333,
-0.0168576818,
0.0212012082,
0.0628338829,
-0.0005122829,
-0.0772513375,
-0.0189209972,
-0.0802872926,
0.032597065,
-0.0196773075,
0.0365269594,
0.0188892428,
0.0128360083,
-0.0144283362,
0.0017074014,
-0.0382048152,
0.0105980281,
0.0267524999,
0.0090679219,
0.032662902,
0.0296930093,
0.0105698416,
-0.0249094274,
0.028873045,
0.0101638744,
0.0266383141,
0.0490699597,
0.0038804638,
-0.062904425,
0.0281745903,
-0.0476390421,
-0.0268169716,
0.0032930099,
-0.0234878771,
0.0358295143,
-0.0191527959,
0.0251126867,
0.0085099004,
0.0269164201,
-0.0029953157,
0.0143098691,
-0.053686209,
-0.0552033521,
0.0221936367,
-0.0170753952,
-0.047327932,
0.0059561147,
-0.0377629548,
0.0279229097,
-0.0263393279,
0.0342830345,
0.0106725283,
-0.0414209105,
-0.0015300354,
0.0001235834,
-0.0409621485,
-0.0062683276,
-0.0294462517,
-0.0307027064,
0.0316551551,
-0.0111614512,
-0.0410830826,
0.0371046178,
-0.0362126864,
-0.0137054436,
-0.0567345172,
0.0255970582,
-0.0456837304,
0.043225456,
-0.0276578944,
0.0244354066,
-0.0447267257,
-0.0315993764,
-0.0136520695,
0.0007596883,
0.0001798982,
-0.0569573045,
0.0238982532,
-0.0410022996,
0.001286689,
0.0094190072,
0.0130646899,
-0.0763003156,
0.0221481677,
0.0159553625,
-0.0091746571,
-0.0067244139,
0.0045933034,
-0.05061955,
-0.0327985622,
0.048907876,
-0.0041627749,
-0.0194235817,
-0.0534566753,
-0.0034766598,
0.0466892011,
0.035090819,
-0.0070811594,
-0.0007452823,
0.0154350204,
-0.0170180667,
0.0425748713,
0.0063522561,
-0.0118453642,
-0.0338060148,
0.0043912265,
0.0278460011,
-0.0378035232,
-0.009746925,
0.0428792685,
0.022101352,
-0.0494499281,
-0.037791077,
0.0627682656,
0.0448761918,
0.0018230488,
-0.0283550359,
-0.0355347209,
0.0378857404,
0.0241473671,
0.0237907004,
-0.114137888,
-0.0236700159,
-0.0165701602,
0.0568385236,
-0.010730084,
-0.0055412599,
-0.0223022792,
-0.0976955742,
0.0506924465,
0.0190880504,
-0.0127810044,
0.0186646543,
-0.0045297029,
0.0040782788,
0.0175373219,
-0.0023160148,
0.0376707464,
-0.0285091884,
0.0078883152,
-0.0029738687,
-0.0130845429,
-0.0229164846,
-0.0282103866,
-0.0280050077,
0.0142999338,
0.0908393636,
0.0265289247,
0.0265302677,
-0.0610620119,
0.0002348709,
-0.0589188039,
0.0786669552,
-0.0120115951,
0.065742217,
-0.0051284144,
0.0258113872,
-0.0476029851,
-0.0110935559,
-0.0073326468,
-0.0281867255,
-0.0071279448,
0.0380803123,
-0.052843105,
0.0324596018,
-0.0706592575,
0.0438708812,
0.0196598247,
0.0804653764,
0.0309979934,
-0.0070538055,
-0.0198004767,
-0.0213475972,
0.0350895822,
-0.0956232995,
-0.0286354348,
0.0276912749,
-0.035314098,
-0.004756846,
-0.1138022617,
-0.0500138029,
-0.0327983238,
0.0126406681,
-0.0027315291,
0.0197731089,
-0.055311352,
-0.016609868,
-0.0494004972,
0.0120054726,
-0.0425495431,
-0.0195274949,
-0.0079132738,
-0.0079982588,
0.0475454107,
-0.0612177365,
0.0125077032,
0.0598186404,
-0.0218499191,
-0.0519901477,
0.0109585989,
0.0363030583,
0.0257306937,
0.0135467546,
-0.0014378057,
-0.0359320417,
0.0645719022,
0.0593418367,
-0.0451569594,
0.0152946105,
0.0023705331,
0.039703615,
-0.0269888509,
0.0057980223,
-0.0668784678,
-0.0033246817,
-0.0326087177,
0.0628783181,
0.028697161,
-0.0104790134,
0.0185245201,
0.0197423343,
0.0115924533,
-0.0432474166,
-0.0041529094,
-0.0093398038,
-0.0167874359,
-0.034281034,
-0.040003486,
-0.0214794744,
0.0312001873,
-0.0032868183,
-0.0265921317,
0.0167043135,
0.0230347123,
-0.0501209162,
0.0898225009,
-0.0137143563,
-0.0170227308,
0.0230300613,
-0.0034529315,
-0.0299560055,
-0.0060590189,
-0.033490248,
-0.0099310316,
-0.0202643648,
0.0542767346,
-0.0119011058,
0.0781251192,
-0.0026849662,
-0.0164766032,
0.0234535076,
0.0483969115,
-0.0472345129,
-0.0024503856,
-0.0353325345,
-0.0026960515,
0.0324850865,
0.0095672635,
0.0776020512,
-0.0097169895,
0.00693765,
-0.0008701336,
0.0185943563,
-0.0007811152,
-0.0561848432,
-0.0240056217,
0.0317817628,
-0.0107405856,
-0.0002998475,
0.025525596,
-0.0559430048,
0.008246772,
-0.0454150029,
-0.0430401452,
-0.057528846,
-0.077673845,
-0.0024576632,
0.044669427,
0.0057417499,
-0.0303625204,
-0.0756982416,
-0.0297358595,
0.0197017975,
0.0392095484,
0.0036609722,
-0.0087238709,
0.0632854626,
0.0671633333,
0.0085811298,
-0.033720389,
-0.03272653,
0.0024023382,
-0.0701997876,
0.0074931262,
-0.0333943442,
-6.082968003e-33,
-0.0483355857,
-0.0335165597,
0.0544574149,
-0.0603934787,
-0.0523861796,
-0.0145649798,
-0.0298000779,
0.0135905733,
0.0105291074,
-0.0225113221,
0.0040413477,
-0.0235926881,
0.0119644012,
0.0237385761,
-0.0141239604,
0.0067674858,
0.0317452587,
0.0232954919,
-0.0631270558,
0.0466772579,
0.0830205232,
0.0006263822,
0.0372231603,
-0.0525243096,
0.0362474583,
-0.0209148712,
-0.0209205374,
-0.0092434827,
0.0315076821,
0.066415973,
-0.006235288,
0.0489937365,
0.0277827401,
-0.0142217176,
0.003885909,
0.0248599164,
-0.0563611127,
-0.0468477942,
0.0269969236,
-0.0113103455,
-0.0553716868,
-0.0359742157,
0.0499412082,
-0.0363262706,
-0.0234322101,
0.0301401559,
0.0378320217,
-0.0431004874,
0.0002721918,
-0.0498971082,
-0.0519431196,
0.0249559078,
0.01369878,
0.0021584837,
-0.0245367102,
0.0751725361,
0.008954688,
0.0147499973,
-0.0681155175,
0.0261856671,
-0.0577672906,
0.0341510624,
0.0684346706,
0.006630687,
-0.0236247387,
0.0442470349,
0.0211215802,
-0.0176675674,
-0.0273440368,
-0.0188916326,
0.0074545494,
0.0615674704,
0.0112081859,
0.0759428516,
0.0080279531,
0.0016626846,
-0.0095925238,
0.0871271119,
-0.0218690783,
0.0764384568,
0.0184082538,
-0.0062507028,
-0.0629069805,
0.0122988541,
-0.0239039473,
0.00682296,
-0.043373201,
-0.0538205653,
0.0539292879,
0.0195770562,
-0.0285227485,
0.0124905314,
0.0249655768,
0.0020252746,
0.037406642,
0.0313340165,
-0.0503250696,
0.008949047,
-0.0257069618,
-0.0018457294,
0.0087808659,
-0.0189871266,
0.0562587194,
0.0164602436,
0.0021264961,
-0.0154959401,
0.0183531772,
0.0336563215,
-0.0478725843,
0.0244732164,
-0.0266275499,
0.0359967723,
-0.0358452126,
-0.0383481607,
0.0096755745,
0.0215929095,
-0.0347454213,
0.0407163426,
0.0051756734,
0.0262884572,
-0.0220203139,
-0.034728013,
0.0087012779,
-0.0009636715,
-0.0268528536,
0.0654107258,
0.0089214062,
0.0325661041,
0.0143153993,
-0.0302081369,
-0.0086282268,
0.0425711013,
2.695e-7,
0.0365243256,
0.0026757505,
0.0623227172,
0.0078801457,
-0.0171662867,
0.0027710916,
0.0112599665,
0.0136746503,
0.0161202699,
-0.0162572414,
0.0080508515,
0.0111917285,
0.0408753939,
0.0268862229,
-0.0875456184,
-0.0085339621,
-0.0373610705,
-0.0187244117,
-0.04315852,
-0.0134310639,
0.0934332013,
-0.0073041865,
-0.0130888941,
-0.0346970148,
-0.0121049248,
-0.063838765,
0.0531156957,
-0.004177792,
-0.0253519211,
0.0396244563,
0.0667463318,
0.0575226434,
-0.0146138826,
-0.0330812298,
-0.0112129189,
0.0092689591,
-0.0147639224,
0.0128884641,
0.027841635,
-0.0914278328,
0.0182425566,
-0.0241079777,
0.0194646623,
-0.0228925142,
0.0392629206,
-0.0014214037,
0.0084118424,
0.0142800724,
-0.0581866838,
0.0178188309,
-0.0026974294,
-0.0055200038,
-0.0385351963,
0.0039767334,
0.0024113164,
0.007397667,
-0.0332242176,
-0.0723733753,
-0.0094577493,
0.0068766791,
-0.0293014385,
-0.045821026,
-0.0372285545,
0.0301184524,
-0.0457020663,
-0.0969021693,
0.0023206496,
2.316771485e-34,
0.0133870784,
-0.0032626924,
0.0164317992,
-0.0156580266,
0.0440568477,
0.0158974379,
-0.0220942535,
0.0177478809,
0.0116326706,
-0.0530749969,
-0.0116364472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15176v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15176v2 | Robust Stance Detection: Understanding Public Perceptions in Social Media | 2023-09-26T18:19:51 | 2024-07-01T22:06:00 | Nayoung Kim, David Mosallanezhad, Lu Cheng, Michelle V. Mancenido, Huan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | The abundance of social media data has presented opportunities for accurately
determining public and group-specific stances around policy proposals or
controversial topics. In contrast with sentiment analysis which focuses on
identifying prevailing emotions, stance detection identifies precise positions
(i.e., supportive, opposing, neutral) relative to a well-defined topic, such as
perceptions toward specific global health interventions during the COVID-19
pandemic. Traditional stance detection models, while effective within their
specific domain (e.g., attitudes towards masking protocols during COVID-19),
often lag in performance when applied to new domains and topics due to changes
in data distribution. This limitation is compounded by the scarcity of
domain-specific, labeled datasets, which are expensive and labor-intensive to
create. A solution we present in this paper combines counterfactual data
augmentation with contrastive learning to enhance the robustness of stance
detection across domains and topics of interest. We evaluate the performance of
current state-of-the-art stance detection models, including a prompt-optimized
large language model, relative to our proposed framework succinctly called
STANCE-C3 (domain-adaptive Cross-target STANCE detection via Contrastive
learning and Counterfactual generation). Empirical evaluations demonstrate
STANCE-C3's consistent improvements over the baseline models with respect to
accuracy across domains and varying focal topics. Despite the increasing
prevalence of general-purpose models such as generative AI, specialized models
such as STANCE-C3 provide utility in safety-critical domains wherein precision
is highly valued, especially when a nuanced understanding of the concerns of
different population segments could result in crafting more impactful public
policies. | [
0.0245078001,
0.0689809099,
0.016539121,
0.0115202731,
-0.0349535719,
0.0096572088,
-0.004003156,
-0.0381731428,
-0.0025264046,
-0.0497252122,
-0.000064858,
-0.0521103814,
-0.0414840318,
0.029904373,
0.0081585534,
-0.0411510579,
0.0556308404,
0.0577680096,
0.0462308228,
-0.003272488,
0.0560273454,
0.0425158143,
-0.0507496633,
0.0436610207,
0.0053330986,
-0.033628691,
-0.0089101139,
-0.0110236211,
0.1089399979,
-0.0699969903,
0.0730244815,
0.0295496825,
0.037833523,
0.0375716537,
0.0000018883,
-0.0177296195,
-0.0330611281,
-0.0230184942,
0.0192668512,
-0.0406353958,
0.0511176586,
-0.0772515014,
0.0030765987,
0.0276118144,
-0.0573119521,
0.0139861163,
0.0568232797,
0.031299375,
0.0699778199,
0.0795139223,
-0.0094772009,
-0.0395988412,
-0.0128419632,
-0.0405134149,
-0.033847332,
-0.0356828719,
0.0100831976,
-0.0357347131,
-0.0402712449,
0.0564961396,
-0.0107504604,
0.0105153648,
0.0081192395,
-0.008788744,
-0.0421234444,
0.0069633899,
0.0080962311,
-0.0337319039,
-0.0225435272,
0.0799239725,
0.0205375142,
-0.0287806857,
0.0065439795,
-0.0679242685,
0.0110763824,
0.0251750574,
-0.0214147717,
-0.0112613663,
-0.0131150447,
0.0457897559,
0.0213109087,
0.018937299,
0.0233814884,
0.0260302555,
0.0135713229,
0.0258923471,
-0.0478435718,
-0.0186181758,
0.0235767234,
0.031142408,
-0.0360616408,
-0.0247398708,
0.0332707539,
-0.0063753622,
-0.0385186188,
0.0365939029,
-0.006514234,
-0.047541298,
0.047917679,
-0.0662850216,
-0.0182609856,
0.0171550419,
-0.0270820893,
0.0563222803,
0.0465262607,
0.0031868459,
-0.0365139805,
-0.0411494784,
0.0229250193,
0.0074782027,
-0.0357692614,
0.014749025,
0.0040985243,
0.0167898312,
-0.0530492552,
0.0102324625,
-0.0398581028,
-0.0269191377,
-0.0558507033,
-0.00452941,
0.000117286,
0.0158825107,
-0.0068948609,
-0.0118060652,
-0.0061980886,
0.0789766982,
-0.0203956664,
0.0383547321,
0.007560065,
0.0036518765,
0.0070234886,
-0.0048720832,
0.0058706603,
-0.0024737467,
-0.0049045691,
0.0280659087,
0.0228878036,
0.0188928619,
0.0091413902,
-0.0108227385,
-0.050773263,
-0.071981661,
0.0093808807,
-0.0698334798,
0.0209037308,
0.0051149148,
0.0076988456,
-0.0549337044,
0.0232398398,
0.0256179348,
0.0077374531,
0.0780054033,
0.015654197,
-0.0558673255,
0.0015721335,
0.0364101827,
0.0164993089,
0.0854751468,
-0.0074275224,
0.0344254486,
0.0086765178,
0.0180022418,
-0.0172936674,
-0.0163461994,
0.0686671138,
-0.0044425204,
-0.0085413801,
0.0265565831,
-0.0372627079,
-0.0275112558,
-0.0234871618,
0.0670702979,
0.0258358084,
-0.0582089648,
0.0466548093,
-0.0041534128,
-0.0477444492,
0.0055937809,
0.016266821,
0.0711537376,
-0.0316194408,
-0.0263969153,
0.0026578133,
0.0558684953,
-0.0076360577,
-0.019142881,
-0.0029044216,
0.0142844655,
-0.0190299377,
-0.045499973,
-0.0017127061,
0.0116116954,
0.0337732807,
-0.0003083699,
-0.0013935246,
-0.0130050769,
-0.0703958943,
-0.0102924323,
0.0321629494,
-0.0469814353,
-0.0031404456,
-0.0423756875,
0.0116130579,
0.036095839,
-0.0135734547,
-0.0296928938,
-0.0696902722,
-0.0578950122,
0.0342627615,
0.0481734015,
0.0471771322,
-0.0297574196,
-0.0031239043,
-0.0201397855,
-0.0106036291,
-0.0195614789,
0.0144463489,
0.0486525521,
0.0057708761,
0.0359496661,
0.001284844,
0.0306506138,
0.0558206923,
0.0169116352,
0.0067772153,
0.007178843,
0.0168712102,
0.0360994264,
0.0483451523,
0.063862443,
0.0079655405,
-0.008569953,
0.0235322583,
-0.0293535832,
-0.0269219205,
-0.0072367834,
-0.0269812699,
-0.057753019,
0.044387158,
-0.0411110967,
-0.051809676,
0.0530615635,
-0.0678920969,
0.0273626391,
0.0406815261,
-0.0132548269,
-0.041589804,
-0.052168332,
-0.0338495821,
-0.0297703054,
0.0147118252,
-0.0168530382,
0.0710680857,
-0.0246605277,
-0.0343582481,
0.0055214129,
-0.0122913588,
0.0324228816,
-0.0296432134,
-0.0119141387,
-0.040705543,
0.0032300767,
0.0301474333,
0.0366682298,
-0.0206256397,
-0.0325399563,
-0.0036498613,
-0.0708953068,
0.0032721325,
-0.0383649357,
0.0217058659,
0.0219063871,
-0.0220829435,
0.0095586563,
0.0037506407,
-0.0444451049,
-0.0121234618,
-0.0075425222,
0.0190128386,
0.016695736,
0.012783139,
0.0237637572,
-0.0534595959,
0.011158078,
-0.017628029,
-0.0005591251,
0.0233498085,
-0.0580272153,
0.0029908863,
0.006288182,
-0.03749457,
-0.0028347152,
-0.0247601196,
-0.0406790078,
0.0383049026,
0.0205010157,
0.0128741413,
0.0158158988,
0.0440712906,
0.0521300323,
0.0108219637,
0.0606739968,
-0.0515553169,
0.0142083671,
-0.0562838838,
0.0321911387,
-0.0127971889,
-0.007289262,
0.0089093484,
0.0787609965,
0.0075179837,
-0.0035595563,
-0.0663982257,
0.027651757,
-0.0080186715,
-0.052083157,
-0.015167349,
0.0089385314,
-0.0068989582,
-0.0047349394,
-0.0220467616,
-0.0116112698,
0.064609766,
0.0604690723,
0.0277391989,
-0.0459183902,
-0.0351942927,
-0.0203813128,
0.0205595717,
0.0080552269,
0.0042163474,
0.030991856,
0.0331655294,
0.0136761572,
-0.0511893891,
-0.01809684,
-0.0373598039,
0.0002455158,
-0.0359921865,
0.0225061215,
0.0090469606,
-0.0860698149,
-0.0352762751,
-0.0789354369,
-0.0441468023,
0.0081603276,
0.004934262,
-0.0140786693,
0.0359415822,
0.0264389496,
-0.0023203795,
0.0264194272,
0.0205912106,
-0.0190374553,
0.010803422,
-0.0030088893,
0.0209468845,
-0.0232908539,
0.0325054377,
-0.0220385194,
-0.0048231916,
0.066647023,
0.0134837264,
0.0047797086,
-0.0338807963,
-0.0139382565,
-0.0039612157,
0.0073370449,
-0.0064155622,
-0.0195702631,
0.0598878786,
-0.0237347726,
0.0204072744,
0.0703980252,
0.0243385304,
-0.0211900789,
-0.0011782463,
0.0354013182,
-0.0247846041,
0.0093803899,
-0.0106137479,
-0.042452231,
-0.0193985961,
-0.0284323264,
0.0225239061,
-0.0393048041,
-0.0260237493,
-0.0158862118,
-0.0769697204,
0.0321970135,
-0.033534456,
-0.0481880121,
-0.0267196074,
-0.0652295426,
0.0622565039,
-0.0397380665,
0.0030328266,
-0.0406553149,
0.0305198301,
-0.0063496921,
0.0084621822,
-0.0228629988,
-0.0454448313,
0.0033276461,
-0.0362477601,
0.0369103216,
0.0277298503,
0.0564221106,
0.0296047423,
-0.034147732,
0.0553991795,
-0.0310218073,
-0.0127708986,
-0.0299570691,
0.0488233976,
-0.0323689394,
-0.0114591802,
-0.0289940964,
0.0470636263,
-0.029615026,
-0.0398054533,
-0.0378261097,
0.0424716026,
-0.0136679672,
0.0045025218,
-0.0457736813,
0.0776828527,
0.0772625506,
0.0434315912,
0.0124307564,
-0.0470088385,
-0.0117126508,
-0.0342770107,
0.0214624405,
-0.0988789201,
-0.0012560397,
-0.0542547591,
0.0097840447,
-0.0010697149,
-0.015773749,
-0.0026446145,
0.0013601035,
0.0281529222,
-0.0437551513,
-0.0289800223,
0.0322402567,
0.0158508439,
-0.0578603856,
-0.001117444,
0.0065187076,
0.0443644747,
-0.0285312198,
-0.0605614446,
0.0454742871,
0.0289784502,
-0.0583173074,
0.013099581,
-0.072584562,
-0.0689309314,
-0.0054336027,
0.0366404392,
0.0123377284,
0.0028810722,
-0.0095366845,
0.0158839673,
0.0273989961,
0.1072295159,
-0.0089537865,
-0.0233342145,
0.0455630608,
0.0288203154,
-0.0037860274,
0.0141324122,
0.0203853231,
0.0073453905,
0.0786039829,
-0.0077369041,
-0.0567190871,
0.0071936743,
0.0068853502,
-0.0332143903,
0.0498042144,
-0.0044188905,
-0.0347371362,
-0.0558279492,
-0.0377259105,
-0.0040612789,
-0.0327143408,
-0.0149850938,
-0.0137747508,
0.0071235811,
-0.0498674288,
-0.05766844,
0.0515264273,
-0.0374081507,
0.0789772347,
-0.067193456,
0.072235547,
0.0380753651,
0.0461441167,
0.0171769056,
-0.0383469686,
-0.0055399886,
-0.0109924404,
0.0373449214,
-0.0097885551,
0.0126540912,
0.0247457195,
0.0012622664,
0.0068923724,
0.0136013497,
0.0054471889,
-0.0101119643,
0.009932436,
-0.0787807181,
0.0325337574,
0.0121836411,
0.003651862,
-0.0032094852,
-0.0084353955,
-0.0318128467,
-0.0110924765,
0.0431494303,
-0.0344164856,
-0.0578585975,
0.058142662,
0.0174228176,
-0.0021796059,
0.012202058,
0.0043730754,
-0.0478298888,
0.0457197167,
0.0389742441,
-0.0163988993,
-0.0395560376,
-0.0196088571,
0.0027697096,
0.0001643159,
0.0108101359,
0.0583781786,
-0.0822074711,
-0.0587410294,
0.0473661423,
0.0063317134,
-0.004572914,
0.0412868112,
-0.0083788494,
0.0255744103,
0.0073009888,
0.0136223892,
-0.0607521646,
0.0291832741,
-0.0332224406,
-0.0303534381,
-0.0345349275,
-6.105544474e-33,
0.0035241866,
-0.0393330567,
-0.0096381987,
-0.0558963232,
0.0210967213,
0.0007065379,
-0.0234374888,
0.0092723584,
-0.0014052955,
0.0465801507,
0.0207195748,
0.0388600081,
0.0083068945,
0.0199364834,
-0.0530864,
-0.0243623722,
0.0512166955,
-0.0160242561,
-0.031161027,
0.0351025872,
0.0295634698,
-0.0042552138,
0.0276502687,
-0.1073434725,
0.0448572263,
-0.0028646193,
-0.0177336987,
0.0025895094,
0.0128508033,
0.058515694,
0.0010139102,
0.0429396369,
0.0661301166,
-0.0690006316,
0.0214102324,
0.0713192075,
-0.0350066796,
-0.0146477995,
-0.0040024435,
-0.0227267705,
-0.0076320972,
-0.0339132659,
-0.0200304277,
0.0188421812,
-0.0387334041,
0.013944055,
0.0050146072,
-0.0082796458,
0.0726097152,
-0.0316438042,
-0.0740813985,
0.0310261436,
-0.0191339869,
-0.0087792752,
-0.035707362,
0.0651655644,
0.0215117931,
0.0677200034,
-0.0475371815,
0.023421064,
-0.0319805145,
-0.0183063708,
0.0281013139,
-0.0021987942,
-0.0109847281,
0.0679413527,
0.0076861768,
0.0432638079,
-0.0209732279,
0.0343829431,
-0.0254458115,
0.0095316768,
0.0477914214,
0.1103107855,
0.0360075347,
-0.0248312168,
-0.0974681452,
0.0219528824,
0.0001552485,
-0.0023565344,
0.0357091613,
0.0262498111,
0.0022133081,
-0.0023850293,
0.002127467,
-0.0538075678,
-0.0176753644,
0.0036116233,
-0.0126649365,
0.0150090074,
-0.0689649656,
0.0339818299,
0.0253424626,
-0.0192041695,
-0.0218877345,
0.0746885091,
0.0063617774,
-0.0068844389,
0.0257136114,
0.0419885591,
-0.0812314674,
0.0036628305,
0.0156717002,
0.029201908,
0.023749778,
-0.0175393298,
0.0592002012,
0.0047018621,
-0.0751036629,
-0.0168300737,
-0.0196685847,
0.0596556962,
-0.0246420093,
0.0632437542,
0.0357577577,
0.002026733,
0.0098118735,
0.0513407104,
-0.0043863514,
-0.0395435132,
0.0182469171,
0.0188379791,
-0.0762735829,
0.028907124,
-0.0430366397,
-0.0329729319,
0.0164183713,
0.0226338636,
-0.0236922838,
-0.0839578062,
-0.0166838169,
0.0078224121,
2.517e-7,
0.0475452915,
0.0224065967,
0.0226244349,
0.0002096579,
0.0438136645,
0.0529345907,
-0.0102943256,
0.0249651466,
-0.0033737477,
-0.0368422084,
-0.0114433952,
0.0617493875,
0.0116262278,
0.029573869,
-0.0501845405,
0.0559610054,
0.000852664,
0.0175667517,
-0.0233997591,
0.0601154305,
0.010211153,
0.070846431,
0.0035177257,
-0.0009842165,
0.0071316352,
0.0299127512,
0.0482530072,
-0.0178922378,
-0.0187518429,
-0.0028548774,
-0.0115552768,
-0.0161996949,
-0.0261716247,
0.0255999304,
-0.0134945139,
0.0054268632,
-0.0149142677,
0.0751278996,
0.0385133252,
-0.0495438129,
-0.006755014,
0.000721,
0.0203704648,
-0.0132287554,
0.0528800152,
-0.086625725,
-0.0328269079,
-0.0635240823,
-0.0535969436,
0.0084694009,
0.0219003689,
-0.0106415907,
-0.0362499803,
0.0014997148,
0.0060979789,
0.0058228578,
-0.0228760876,
-0.064810276,
-0.0093529569,
-0.0015749112,
-0.0424344242,
-0.0442055017,
0.0279096309,
0.0162771121,
0.0236620605,
-0.03985985,
0.0211083908,
1.627800126e-34,
0.0547170527,
-0.0238450859,
-0.0462671891,
-0.0377835371,
0.0246708449,
0.0220972318,
-0.0354362801,
-0.0044318326,
0.0496154726,
-0.0046511232,
0.002954318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15098v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15098v2 | Attention Satisfies: A Constraint-Satisfaction Lens on Factual Errors of Language Models | 2023-09-26T17:48:55 | 2024-04-17T04:25:21 | Mert Yuksekgonul, Varun Chandrasekaran, Erik Jones, Suriya Gunasekar, Ranjita Naik, Hamid Palangi, Ece Kamar, Besmira Nushi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We investigate the internal behavior of Transformer-based Large Language
Models (LLMs) when they generate factually incorrect text. We propose modeling
factual queries as constraint satisfaction problems and use this framework to
investigate how the LLM interacts internally with factual constraints. We find
a strong positive relationship between the LLM's attention to constraint tokens
and the factual accuracy of generations. We curate a suite of 10 datasets
containing over 40,000 prompts to study the task of predicting factual errors
with the Llama-2 family across all scales (7B, 13B, 70B). We propose SAT Probe,
a method probing attention patterns, that can predict factual errors and
fine-grained constraint satisfaction, and allow early error identification. The
approach and findings take another step towards using the mechanistic
understanding of LLMs to enhance their reliability. | [
0.0623583198,
0.0594539642,
-0.0222936608,
0.0199300908,
-0.0174212418,
-0.0029666533,
-0.0127510466,
0.0065906602,
0.0114030652,
-0.0581586435,
0.0137759252,
-0.0539853871,
0.0208005253,
-0.0028235354,
0.0200415011,
-0.0045169662,
0.0842016786,
-0.0302741472,
0.0069416366,
0.0083591575,
-0.0154592041,
0.0133078787,
0.0110411756,
0.0307486877,
-0.0626879036,
-0.0321381837,
-0.0060582766,
-0.0078036524,
-0.0064351922,
0.0032236148,
0.0269984845,
0.0644793808,
-0.0181069542,
0.0916904658,
0.000001927,
-0.062343616,
0.0145320473,
-0.0275687259,
-0.0446177423,
0.0813023299,
0.0335361138,
0.0056778798,
-0.0273528546,
0.0347024389,
-0.0034458863,
0.0148466527,
0.0461980663,
0.0449410528,
0.0524633005,
0.0495658852,
0.0106027061,
0.0069992561,
0.0178675819,
-0.0096275993,
0.0333753228,
-0.0149320001,
0.0317281708,
-0.0008281153,
-0.0111875134,
0.0074951658,
-0.0118984431,
0.0293737799,
0.0179639421,
-0.042074237,
-0.0024503993,
0.0118732071,
-0.0300712138,
-0.0524217077,
0.0092958454,
0.0329275951,
0.042645175,
-0.048463963,
-0.0221247487,
-0.005643052,
0.0137227336,
0.0077275601,
-0.0036749882,
0.0398467928,
-0.0236788411,
0.0139092598,
0.047280211,
-0.0436782651,
0.0294313096,
-0.0150850164,
-0.0400042385,
0.0661538169,
-0.0034280284,
-0.0473602936,
-0.0225856956,
0.0162119605,
0.0146634988,
-0.0730126277,
-0.0022910938,
-0.002452424,
-0.0621618889,
0.0155971553,
-0.0654379502,
-0.0018086247,
0.0253625531,
-0.016818,
0.012891165,
0.0166705362,
-0.0343431793,
0.034309268,
0.0114283627,
0.102745682,
-0.0036882788,
0.0150871566,
-0.0325921811,
-0.0057852492,
0.0221370906,
-0.0242562629,
0.0074765864,
-0.0088541852,
0.0028295224,
-0.0023040667,
-0.0172612015,
0.0075829681,
0.0033810001,
0.0145559916,
-0.031771604,
0.0159450471,
-0.0334994532,
-0.0125051932,
-0.0793341696,
0.0771171674,
-0.0142212557,
0.012723106,
0.0082365023,
-0.0708828121,
-0.025748184,
0.0134000974,
-0.017305322,
-0.026288202,
-0.0197693259,
-0.0100618703,
-0.0224659834,
-0.0170298759,
-0.0617195554,
-0.0215531494,
-0.0312315952,
-0.0512376428,
-0.0065036151,
-0.0488116555,
0.0132313315,
0.0026624324,
-0.008720506,
-0.0439241305,
0.0334059671,
0.0493910946,
-0.0304593667,
0.0372092612,
0.0317111984,
0.027753856,
-0.0201837812,
-0.0092584454,
0.0354688838,
0.0579478778,
0.0285277106,
0.0177964065,
0.0296799466,
-0.0130860182,
0.0037878556,
0.0363693722,
0.0034721447,
0.0039074533,
-0.001820793,
-0.0082133785,
0.0038609251,
0.0399182402,
0.0684459656,
0.087649785,
0.0172539447,
-0.0104338182,
0.0967983231,
0.0263611265,
0.0006920423,
0.0174589045,
0.0087103341,
-0.0244365018,
0.0131811975,
0.0371502414,
-0.0863276497,
0.0140470434,
-0.0090984227,
-0.0038609761,
0.03360774,
0.0236822665,
0.008090727,
-0.0620391816,
-0.0239017084,
0.0261513554,
-0.0409309454,
-0.0016939896,
0.0326639935,
0.0136911506,
-0.0330183841,
0.0916371271,
0.0279682409,
-0.0491653569,
-0.0070906323,
-0.0460594334,
0.0302011613,
0.0406296328,
0.0362278633,
-0.0221924894,
-0.0301521216,
-0.0029160047,
0.0092943171,
0.0630654693,
0.0745195299,
0.006724284,
-0.0539421998,
-0.0229166932,
0.0087384153,
-0.002332146,
0.0386415198,
-0.0384788141,
0.0051616388,
-0.0041355351,
0.0158939324,
-0.0360714048,
-0.0584210977,
0.0416445807,
-0.0420562178,
-0.041803252,
-0.0190389026,
0.0084055113,
-0.0047714021,
-0.0103384405,
0.0060312999,
0.0319760889,
0.0265975036,
0.0086395452,
0.0073186546,
-0.0125010479,
-0.0448901989,
0.0117813703,
0.0461991504,
-0.0307217333,
-0.0260544233,
0.0316757523,
0.0018420143,
-0.0287895259,
-0.0042451588,
-0.0773249194,
0.0324302949,
-0.0145657929,
0.0348857529,
-0.0132233845,
0.0128466636,
-0.0187521856,
0.0683950335,
-0.0221834965,
0.0159000829,
0.0394953229,
-0.0512027852,
-0.0297358185,
-0.0143136941,
-0.0223976653,
-0.0081169233,
0.0162789468,
0.0122390445,
0.0115698641,
-0.0116122011,
-0.0643707216,
-0.017440021,
-0.0169015247,
-0.0011567097,
-0.0157297496,
0.0242664628,
0.0402088687,
-0.0079379603,
-0.0067796172,
0.0063002175,
0.0013139698,
-0.0089541646,
0.0019242885,
0.0183877256,
0.039153818,
-0.0229327977,
0.0141586782,
-0.0431748852,
0.0029668869,
-0.0654745027,
0.0118962042,
0.0292772911,
-0.0056962832,
-0.0798251405,
0.0538853444,
-0.0301417802,
0.0300824326,
-0.0201712828,
-0.015839329,
0.0332078263,
0.0122253159,
0.043969959,
0.0872428268,
0.0102504175,
0.020341754,
0.0635277033,
-0.0215242505,
-0.0591158122,
0.0181892496,
-0.0113218464,
-0.0453237072,
-0.0154197812,
-0.0607923158,
0.0108349044,
0.0890653059,
0.004544755,
-0.0045540924,
-0.0530637167,
0.0192026496,
-0.0400936976,
-0.0225827545,
0.0218944382,
0.0339392982,
-0.0393073782,
0.0765253231,
-0.032023605,
-0.0637096167,
0.0711937472,
-0.0176959094,
0.0006628995,
-0.0148181785,
0.0376707688,
-0.012310097,
0.040996071,
0.0294816699,
0.0170622077,
0.0882139578,
-0.0403782763,
-0.0729876459,
0.0376811698,
0.0179886967,
-0.032520216,
0.1117185652,
-0.0555016175,
-0.0053716283,
0.0292923786,
-0.0279074013,
-0.0586465001,
-0.0340632536,
-0.0306792464,
-0.0228798315,
0.0040371087,
-0.0517901778,
-0.0800092891,
-0.0437249206,
0.0300405007,
0.0194888245,
-0.010188411,
-0.0309177227,
-0.0201235339,
-0.0160960108,
0.0654911697,
0.0667216033,
0.0887583792,
-0.036664322,
-0.0243382175,
0.0572143234,
-0.0012066428,
0.00502272,
0.0221029725,
-0.0408216156,
0.0368945673,
-0.0149333905,
-0.0258481111,
0.0132212061,
0.0521827191,
-0.0616585314,
-0.0360088311,
0.1012481079,
0.0494352691,
-0.0065152487,
0.0128378868,
-0.0507315509,
0.0408650599,
0.0503773056,
0.0324699096,
-0.0905975252,
-0.0224412922,
0.0290890355,
0.0477033742,
-0.0092129922,
-0.0195092671,
-0.00297476,
-0.1519369036,
0.0198793132,
-0.0027276771,
-0.0082197813,
-0.0302222129,
-0.0074789999,
0.0292594619,
0.0075207674,
0.0576367974,
0.0281950422,
-0.0242438558,
-0.0201415699,
0.0143913738,
-0.0160788409,
-0.0317450091,
0.0389664099,
-0.0161216371,
0.0590090714,
0.0239950679,
0.0047324593,
-0.0225098431,
-0.0729357675,
0.0279979687,
0.0047647608,
-0.0074480115,
-0.0026291304,
0.0113209104,
0.0109935813,
-0.0127437264,
-0.0627309754,
-0.0005071765,
-0.0161125492,
-0.0006319116,
-0.0192125067,
0.1099229604,
-0.0067346045,
-0.0560828932,
0.0015971449,
-0.0012324526,
-0.0188148785,
0.0624268614,
0.0311079528,
-0.026202457,
-0.0374670029,
-0.0595160872,
0.0092499498,
0.0032108799,
-0.0531085283,
0.0515307859,
0.0061336337,
-0.0208027735,
-0.069747813,
-0.0257920455,
0.0032682684,
-0.0098707648,
0.0028385199,
-0.0605399832,
0.0384430438,
-0.0473111011,
0.0001879198,
0.0221992582,
-0.0316616893,
0.0270220637,
-0.0848973766,
0.0145490523,
-0.0066405283,
0.0011820856,
0.0053482102,
-0.0127439322,
-0.0727658048,
-0.0506245531,
0.0367596373,
0.0308313668,
0.0238487702,
0.0037764772,
-0.032908354,
-0.0473206714,
-0.0151138399,
0.0523931906,
-0.0139400689,
0.0445466377,
0.0012925054,
-0.0543553419,
-0.0072476924,
0.0396608151,
-0.0234591123,
-0.0325370207,
-0.0346982069,
0.0415444784,
-0.019539183,
-0.0640562996,
0.0531530716,
0.0164365992,
0.0539924055,
0.0051828041,
-0.0143092647,
-0.0420059189,
0.0185201894,
-0.0041874391,
-0.0230004434,
0.0007189058,
-0.0165834073,
0.004334332,
0.0129642393,
0.0156973563,
-0.012831348,
-0.0415091515,
0.0110750208,
-0.0329442918,
0.0187977012,
0.0124633759,
0.003103748,
0.0300138202,
-0.0097637735,
-0.0015241114,
0.018226333,
0.0268779416,
0.0871088877,
0.0097045107,
0.0489191301,
0.0089552989,
0.0137270028,
-0.0171291474,
-0.0377044715,
-0.0459385216,
-0.0200614575,
0.0127494866,
-0.0401415117,
0.0381974503,
-0.0317951255,
0.0664082766,
-0.0069721001,
0.0042571067,
-0.0270777605,
0.0063622096,
0.0345732421,
-0.0256981123,
0.0205316581,
0.0113528129,
0.0013720214,
-0.00691634,
0.0614171475,
-0.0107726259,
0.0587974451,
-0.0072176633,
-0.0311447456,
-0.0098191351,
-0.0357780866,
-0.028138129,
-0.0391123518,
-0.0395522527,
-0.0200394373,
-0.0963369831,
-0.0785547122,
0.0140364449,
0.0127566662,
-0.0053141741,
-0.0516752638,
0.0085861078,
0.0624271631,
0.0008902767,
-0.042416729,
-0.0449874587,
0.0114347618,
-0.018042,
0.008342972,
-0.0255900305,
-6.796602542e-33,
-0.0342590176,
-0.0486803055,
0.0023936601,
0.0016154796,
-0.0235806517,
0.0217090622,
-0.0429160818,
0.0178814083,
-0.016499877,
0.0218364652,
-0.0345830731,
0.0385034643,
0.0062942901,
-0.0017519875,
0.0479925163,
-0.0358130559,
0.0308130141,
0.0140710529,
-0.0454504937,
-0.0054234639,
0.058979854,
-0.0101737315,
0.0646080673,
-0.0102089848,
0.0463121608,
-0.0005886399,
0.0028033324,
0.0364387855,
-0.0702491254,
0.0693379343,
0.007574006,
0.0589054115,
0.0054427139,
-0.0440778024,
-0.0137749007,
0.0125821773,
-0.0396660008,
-0.0472466387,
0.0411842093,
0.0148263639,
0.0025817635,
-0.033630766,
0.0360982791,
0.0094743343,
-0.0301990043,
-0.0364005044,
0.0296256114,
0.005186771,
0.0071760155,
-0.0020617745,
-0.0561945587,
-0.0094140805,
-0.0010476831,
-0.0112410104,
-0.0419181287,
0.0648324937,
0.0066393791,
-0.0042286478,
-0.0445324294,
0.0385693684,
0.0530654751,
0.0364339799,
0.0719561055,
0.0182578322,
-0.0059020761,
0.0465811826,
-0.0167812966,
0.0225697551,
-0.0693481714,
-0.0030626615,
0.0362045988,
0.0307388585,
0.0354668498,
0.0344890244,
-0.0121423518,
-0.0111385239,
-0.0445749909,
0.0055691628,
0.0266294312,
0.0994436368,
0.005464938,
-0.0246838089,
-0.0286663994,
-0.0366908982,
-0.0348482467,
0.0339783169,
-0.0371843129,
0.0171563867,
0.0112632802,
0.0009040171,
-0.0046057627,
-0.017469652,
0.0000987768,
-0.0272229109,
-0.0239247512,
-0.014911674,
-0.0149623463,
-0.01132489,
-0.012825815,
0.0337757692,
-0.0682964623,
0.0128134629,
0.001995926,
0.0129666496,
0.0429345444,
0.0422499701,
0.0137133664,
0.0172379911,
-0.0826122537,
0.0215636045,
-0.0309205987,
0.0148615781,
-0.0106639294,
-0.0404763743,
0.0634330884,
-0.0194317121,
-0.0099634612,
-0.0004168002,
0.0188734531,
0.0458275266,
-0.0725273192,
0.0372197665,
0.0029655432,
0.0131478226,
-0.0272944979,
-0.0151224043,
-0.0567860641,
0.0696286634,
0.0195827801,
-0.0400238186,
-0.0336671695,
-0.0074772495,
2.674e-7,
0.04794259,
0.1076078042,
-0.0101063652,
0.0514950119,
0.0228491947,
0.0518640876,
0.0033202765,
0.0092835212,
0.0343813263,
-0.0217540171,
0.0097173471,
-0.0289503429,
0.0330937207,
0.046978239,
-0.0746301115,
-0.0093497029,
-0.063996397,
-0.0016487072,
-0.0320258886,
-0.0218004305,
0.048089277,
0.0727626607,
0.0036814264,
-0.0175634343,
-0.0062281983,
-0.034488827,
0.0216906779,
-0.0018729486,
-0.0127488989,
0.008872238,
0.0489819981,
-0.0145788975,
0.0205901228,
0.0261818264,
-0.0111960247,
-0.0110053653,
-0.0201874841,
0.0409630872,
0.0124311056,
-0.0131448852,
-0.038405221,
0.006331645,
0.0039121299,
-0.1008861959,
0.0652171299,
0.0050060442,
-0.0045763957,
-0.0210194029,
0.0187517069,
-0.0039703697,
0.0111568235,
-0.0067925677,
-0.0269105081,
-0.0056872903,
0.0190722384,
0.036327146,
-0.0198181625,
-0.0385951325,
-0.0268297829,
0.0084747858,
-0.0314930715,
-0.0601632446,
-0.0315946974,
-0.0094580688,
-0.017166486,
-0.0194675792,
0.0113130873,
2.448934702e-34,
0.0273655038,
0.0109323701,
0.0445859283,
-0.0255253948,
0.0325437933,
0.0063606868,
-0.0124986693,
0.0181179922,
0.0152616901,
-0.0903319865,
-0.0209079012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15091v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15091v1 | VideoDirectorGPT: Consistent Multi-scene Video Generation via LLM-Guided Planning | 2023-09-26T17:36:26 | 2023-09-26T17:36:26 | Han Lin, Abhay Zala, Jaemin Cho, Mohit Bansal | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Although recent text-to-video (T2V) generation methods have seen significant
advancements, most of these works focus on producing short video clips of a
single event with a single background (i.e., single-scene videos). Meanwhile,
recent large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated their capability in
generating layouts and programs to control downstream visual modules such as
image generation models. This raises an important question: can we leverage the
knowledge embedded in these LLMs for temporally consistent long video
generation? In this paper, we propose VideoDirectorGPT, a novel framework for
consistent multi-scene video generation that uses the knowledge of LLMs for
video content planning and grounded video generation. Specifically, given a
single text prompt, we first ask our video planner LLM (GPT-4) to expand it
into a 'video plan', which involves generating the scene descriptions, the
entities with their respective layouts, the background for each scene, and
consistency groupings of the entities and backgrounds. Next, guided by this
output from the video planner, our video generator, Layout2Vid, has explicit
control over spatial layouts and can maintain temporal consistency of
entities/backgrounds across scenes, while only trained with image-level
annotations. Our experiments demonstrate that VideoDirectorGPT framework
substantially improves layout and movement control in both single- and
multi-scene video generation and can generate multi-scene videos with visual
consistency across scenes, while achieving competitive performance with SOTAs
in open-domain single-scene T2V generation. We also demonstrate that our
framework can dynamically control the strength for layout guidance and can also
generate videos with user-provided images. We hope our framework can inspire
future work on better integrating the planning ability of LLMs into consistent
long video generation. | [
0.0254985876,
0.0148829473,
0.050473135,
0.0192931648,
-0.0107385898,
0.0047058482,
0.0230788365,
0.0347489268,
-0.0200140309,
-0.0530619137,
0.0022216639,
-0.056737341,
-0.0129916528,
0.0224850047,
0.0087468307,
-0.0990793481,
-0.0173720885,
-0.0179246459,
-0.0252493378,
0.0086953482,
0.006592127,
0.0047852988,
0.0011352914,
-0.0145807741,
-0.0617667064,
-0.0111578964,
-0.0474171266,
0.0206133518,
0.0579190068,
-0.0347185247,
-0.0295407679,
0.0345346294,
0.0483152531,
-0.0125279808,
0.0000018434,
-0.0359198339,
0.0035705545,
-0.0182146598,
0.0259731319,
0.0220418274,
-0.0262929574,
-0.034242861,
-0.0052670054,
-0.0161043685,
-0.0436298735,
0.0394322313,
0.0504889525,
0.0181041509,
0.0892199725,
0.0511952341,
-0.035502363,
-0.065488264,
-0.0340875387,
-0.0151050938,
0.0474491827,
0.0229779556,
-0.008275927,
-0.0118941041,
0.025363991,
0.0091681303,
-0.0368304439,
-0.0043856101,
0.040036384,
-0.0257789884,
-0.0052149021,
0.049503807,
-0.0552510358,
-0.0303202458,
-0.0190815497,
0.0579079278,
-0.0178173613,
0.0212137792,
0.0233159475,
-0.0050000385,
-0.0166739989,
-0.0278920569,
-0.0544149317,
0.0608209334,
-0.0293212514,
-0.0069522066,
-0.0434311144,
0.0176742189,
0.0057021137,
-0.0552919731,
0.0125065427,
-0.0087669687,
0.0525172316,
0.0160387121,
-0.062609829,
0.0331122726,
-0.0166993551,
-0.0902855098,
0.0463797785,
0.0533221066,
-0.0138257444,
0.0234329663,
-0.0707786232,
0.0085527645,
-0.0466117375,
-0.030051928,
0.0412840843,
0.0304026417,
-0.0294680912,
0.028914161,
-0.0245468915,
0.0909055769,
-0.0253107101,
0.0033760602,
-0.0150767509,
0.025528213,
-0.0285378117,
0.0032426117,
-0.0200861543,
-0.0166440289,
-0.0738746077,
-0.0300040077,
-0.0259661637,
0.041279193,
-0.0300612114,
0.0496038646,
0.0005487179,
0.0257006865,
-0.0372833572,
-0.0246430598,
-0.0128169153,
0.0036050498,
-0.0320326015,
0.0132364333,
0.013717195,
-0.0250643119,
-0.0247342642,
0.0081604114,
0.0088332053,
0.0060330685,
-0.0228872374,
0.0822315514,
-0.0625769421,
0.022783136,
-0.0392370038,
0.002650681,
-0.0447693244,
-0.0305926334,
0.0082628038,
-0.0647549629,
0.034048751,
-0.0270394124,
-0.0114182029,
-0.0201867502,
0.0394695029,
-0.0201710034,
0.0154452259,
0.0108953249,
0.0261212718,
0.0560593791,
0.0259466227,
0.0358173288,
0.0023788889,
0.0246485565,
0.0470354483,
0.0629382357,
0.0208661091,
0.0362186395,
0.0322546065,
0.0663817674,
-0.030202806,
0.0236526504,
-0.0602394417,
-0.0072623747,
0.0152730988,
0.0297453962,
0.02539213,
0.0471838638,
-0.0217332933,
0.0112288669,
0.0526855737,
0.0093358923,
0.0006768361,
-0.0014113758,
0.1127086654,
-0.0080000954,
-0.0249084067,
0.0327457301,
-0.0231491458,
0.0844347924,
0.0398282409,
0.0240693167,
0.016490059,
0.0133880703,
-0.0583552644,
-0.0265120231,
-0.0007221529,
-0.0026312121,
-0.0190908518,
-0.0303218849,
0.0235400535,
0.0243786108,
-0.1045756266,
0.0633146316,
-0.0439665057,
-0.067857787,
0.0773860812,
0.0186188929,
0.0331826918,
0.0855205134,
-0.0262677204,
0.0487943888,
-0.0453657024,
-0.0001115716,
0.0389790684,
0.0941220075,
0.0024921994,
-0.0427566171,
0.0500579886,
-0.0564521626,
-0.014561248,
-0.0275326632,
0.0029240483,
0.0551166497,
0.0380183235,
0.0415871069,
0.0077720643,
0.0048601166,
0.0202564392,
0.0570358112,
-0.0398583338,
-0.0176682081,
-0.0403134562,
-0.0099852923,
0.0146159139,
0.0022764471,
-0.0492201187,
-0.0233234838,
0.0166555885,
-0.0189376287,
0.0235557407,
0.029265143,
-0.042818781,
-0.0232755188,
0.0048506251,
-0.0301631689,
0.0009142765,
-0.0102250557,
-0.0499864854,
-0.0621505678,
-0.0018235289,
0.023352202,
0.0021282916,
-0.0193371661,
-0.0017052942,
0.0459007584,
-0.0426147766,
-0.023382552,
0.044326365,
-0.0256861057,
-0.0251645297,
0.0627698451,
0.0462883674,
0.0000288401,
-0.0390516706,
0.0207386706,
0.0001438199,
0.009259739,
-0.0402564928,
0.0360085703,
0.0366701446,
-0.0676523596,
-0.0593395755,
-0.0735808313,
-0.0046360237,
-0.0108355135,
-0.0150427315,
0.0123272799,
0.0104006464,
-0.0245987643,
-0.006461862,
-0.0440474339,
0.0239892341,
0.0206737854,
-0.0162964724,
-0.0150170671,
0.0297225229,
0.0133563699,
-0.0375405401,
0.025281189,
0.0325122252,
-0.0040305406,
0.0309119225,
-0.0418934114,
-0.0542408824,
0.0323005728,
-0.0137873776,
0.0261672679,
-0.0312876254,
0.0163746141,
0.0189996641,
-0.0000074197,
0.0452609062,
0.0455692932,
0.0253469329,
-0.0010073479,
0.0158774257,
-0.0325385481,
-0.0284018815,
0.0400470197,
-0.0036168739,
-0.0362892374,
-0.0364001244,
-0.0045952373,
0.0061192154,
0.0030713514,
0.0148777924,
0.0591526255,
-0.0924452096,
-0.0154880686,
0.0215803795,
-0.0241170228,
0.0188626852,
-0.0009285783,
-0.0225486197,
0.0219516177,
-0.0407933481,
-0.0578869469,
0.0044068703,
-0.0546577312,
-0.0487285331,
0.048855599,
0.0359374732,
-0.0091582909,
0.1009351537,
0.027054606,
0.0293987393,
-0.0209180526,
0.0099479202,
-0.0726150349,
0.0043380419,
0.0044039697,
0.0108625563,
0.0437516868,
-0.0789636895,
-0.0098256888,
-0.0326676108,
-0.0029314028,
-0.0379526019,
0.0306456834,
-0.0051535284,
-0.0346598364,
-0.0405254997,
-0.0322198533,
-0.0096879611,
0.0394262671,
-0.0162290297,
0.0652526543,
-0.0334233753,
-0.0191750545,
-0.0212203767,
0.0255524646,
0.0494814627,
0.0053407829,
-0.0623731166,
-0.0739739984,
0.0407217853,
0.0579010732,
-0.0085887117,
-0.0113735404,
-0.0278120134,
0.0571817346,
0.0229218993,
0.0201659128,
-0.0264004357,
0.0296887867,
0.0898337886,
-0.0353602245,
-0.026529815,
0.0855469704,
0.0183487963,
-0.022481909,
0.0070475899,
0.0220725145,
0.0579280667,
0.0416519567,
0.0257417485,
-0.0602604002,
-0.0105570676,
-0.0183775425,
-0.0050768862,
0.0624510646,
-0.0243626684,
-0.0711444765,
-0.0840034634,
0.0918720961,
0.0558404773,
-0.0527679995,
0.0183067918,
0.0104131447,
0.0303102694,
-0.004959146,
-0.0178880524,
0.0334453359,
0.0067253858,
0.0097406181,
-0.0033299257,
0.0087480703,
-0.0347063877,
-0.0202387292,
-0.0080778245,
0.0479437374,
0.0518117882,
0.000851738,
0.0190863274,
-0.02080274,
0.02079455,
0.0297655445,
0.0358466171,
-0.0236534588,
0.010088589,
-0.0295149311,
-0.0122287571,
0.0181467514,
0.0349297449,
0.0173963252,
-0.0516707972,
0.0401230678,
0.0328132883,
-0.0177905597,
-0.019346891,
-0.0428678095,
0.0215487182,
0.0153645026,
0.051236324,
-0.0201688595,
-0.0309312474,
-0.0455355421,
0.001808312,
-0.012268601,
-0.0737371892,
-0.0149248736,
-0.0235426743,
-0.0493508354,
-0.0149772167,
-0.0515323728,
-0.0058738301,
0.0767155364,
0.0622697808,
-0.0232890621,
-0.0218055937,
-0.0518688187,
0.0201898497,
-0.0586443953,
-0.0037921455,
0.0035950614,
-0.0175615773,
-0.03742541,
-0.0322496668,
0.0285481662,
-0.024281824,
0.0264855102,
0.0281177275,
-0.0629550442,
-0.053308852,
-0.0486692376,
0.0561659262,
0.020776676,
0.102372095,
0.0468593612,
0.0164811853,
0.040737357,
0.0197011549,
0.0129963346,
0.0478393957,
-0.0164038502,
0.027065346,
-0.0228331909,
0.0084284414,
-0.0733360052,
0.012708962,
0.0072001289,
0.0503092334,
-0.0261163488,
-0.0087360516,
0.0041719591,
-0.0330159292,
-0.0193859152,
-0.0775954351,
0.0086513842,
-0.0253843516,
-0.0442440398,
-0.0389988832,
-0.0048734047,
-0.0868783742,
0.0146272173,
0.0249211844,
0.0018122422,
0.0167168584,
0.0365161523,
-0.0044745817,
0.0046939426,
-0.0306079611,
-0.0735645071,
-0.0075723911,
-0.0434358679,
0.0332050174,
0.0404749513,
0.0334532633,
0.0400562249,
-0.0414198376,
0.0284848772,
-0.001115371,
0.04628589,
0.0180405639,
-0.0053049033,
0.0280856602,
0.0206733476,
-0.0163657125,
-0.0440772921,
-0.0555163883,
0.0536477342,
0.0547484048,
-0.0036022821,
0.0583393648,
-0.0379686169,
0.0041042138,
-0.0111282114,
0.0370967239,
0.0354900695,
-0.0755346119,
0.0097813522,
-0.0054609748,
-0.0079552596,
-0.0254511368,
0.0701980367,
0.0294315964,
0.0200337805,
-0.0150175113,
-0.0138076646,
-0.0346181467,
-0.0274858177,
0.0086963158,
-0.0163149275,
-0.0037744942,
-0.0081954813,
-0.0270117149,
-0.0306665301,
-0.0097749978,
0.0354419686,
-0.0123936208,
0.0115227988,
0.0553502031,
0.0153024355,
-0.0272711404,
0.0116646625,
-0.0009849404,
-0.0364037976,
-0.0022176355,
-0.0493168272,
-0.022261329,
-4.757314535e-33,
-0.08180549,
-0.0547989309,
0.0722887143,
-0.0280487835,
-0.054320395,
-0.0158440825,
-0.0376151763,
0.0170425344,
0.0130109973,
0.0070283767,
0.0213326178,
0.0016317216,
0.0101556014,
0.050375849,
0.0030408201,
-0.0223154575,
0.0461583361,
-0.0171691868,
-0.0507195257,
0.0187838357,
0.0264244303,
0.0260778069,
0.0205082837,
-0.0328477956,
-0.0357491821,
-0.012789988,
-0.042223949,
0.0338770412,
0.0242767055,
0.0251834467,
0.0227714311,
-0.0462372974,
-0.0034054441,
-0.0195150524,
-0.0154783707,
0.0269803088,
-0.0196716487,
-0.0323063545,
0.002417516,
0.0078237569,
-0.099292241,
-0.0376179032,
0.0286777802,
-0.0275431164,
-0.0144260479,
-0.0412618071,
0.0419939496,
-0.0223290324,
0.0306379609,
-0.0319742449,
-0.0393332429,
0.0017516293,
-0.0181444436,
-0.0517613925,
0.0217638612,
0.0220150054,
0.0455966778,
-0.010664789,
-0.0364070199,
0.0423407629,
-0.0227222554,
0.0257996544,
0.1041884422,
0.0211939607,
0.004438852,
0.0589732267,
0.0109460549,
-0.0352892391,
-0.0275799688,
0.0003184729,
-0.0124152461,
0.0805760622,
-0.012246754,
0.0270630401,
0.0023500358,
0.0254815891,
-0.0456823073,
0.053028442,
-0.066621691,
0.0235228054,
0.010719236,
0.0331855938,
0.0246742368,
0.0032307592,
-0.0093384692,
-0.0057754852,
-0.0078795217,
-0.0419962369,
0.0492757224,
0.0308039542,
0.0336369835,
-0.0495034754,
0.0834197477,
0.005333202,
0.0328830406,
0.0494719483,
-0.079641819,
0.0683666319,
0.0110567957,
0.0192222074,
-0.0275542587,
-0.033303488,
0.0624014884,
0.0256680939,
0.0118980883,
0.0484481677,
-0.0002272262,
0.0790839419,
-0.0081223967,
0.002953517,
-0.0227960572,
0.0404537693,
0.0049904883,
0.0056311539,
0.0041623558,
-0.039266333,
-0.0486584008,
0.0267433356,
-0.0029428047,
-0.0498016514,
0.0135373026,
-0.008526206,
-0.0038966762,
0.0093925847,
-0.0330066457,
0.0422796719,
-0.0329519212,
-0.0015771287,
0.0441030599,
-0.0352426656,
-0.0150362533,
0.0357644744,
2.508e-7,
-0.0230471082,
-0.0090463888,
-0.0003491019,
0.0083361622,
0.0244647861,
0.0129424324,
-0.0120971547,
0.0278011728,
-0.0117983716,
-0.0495601632,
0.0206494145,
0.0449959449,
0.0340543985,
0.0008457589,
-0.0306032486,
0.0234825145,
-0.0491605587,
-0.0232147835,
-0.0386537462,
-0.0211706124,
0.0381799079,
0.0291179903,
0.0227450393,
0.0018681441,
0.0271095652,
-0.0148101319,
0.0837150142,
-0.0209456887,
-0.0045927544,
0.003920814,
-0.0216731336,
0.0065688486,
-0.0484726839,
-0.0043595075,
-0.0179000627,
-0.0156251099,
0.0153618781,
0.0867120326,
-0.035326805,
0.003288911,
-0.0212715138,
0.0059122564,
-0.0112776225,
-0.0262164343,
0.0268898495,
-0.0079747085,
0.024515016,
-0.0129099619,
-0.0203598384,
0.0079086768,
-0.0506480634,
-0.0005185959,
-0.0030702061,
0.0304206833,
0.0441556126,
0.0271884184,
-0.0295085907,
-0.0470461771,
-0.0321410261,
-0.0114060361,
-0.0409610569,
-0.0108902603,
-0.0467858724,
0.0178721827,
-0.0021280944,
-0.0023021186,
-0.0601883791,
2.110783089e-34,
-0.0185606778,
0.016271254,
0.0003069233,
-0.0175098684,
0.0209598988,
0.0388259143,
0.0146763939,
0.0233683437,
-0.0172369946,
-0.0075123548,
-0.053911414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15088v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15088v1 | RankVicuna: Zero-Shot Listwise Document Reranking with Open-Source Large Language Models | 2023-09-26T17:31:57 | 2023-09-26T17:31:57 | Ronak Pradeep, Sahel Sharifymoghaddam, Jimmy Lin | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Researchers have successfully applied large language models (LLMs) such as
ChatGPT to reranking in an information retrieval context, but to date, such
work has mostly been built on proprietary models hidden behind opaque API
endpoints. This approach yields experimental results that are not reproducible
and non-deterministic, threatening the veracity of outcomes that build on such
shaky foundations. To address this significant shortcoming, we present
RankVicuna, the first fully open-source LLM capable of performing high-quality
listwise reranking in a zero-shot setting. Experimental results on the TREC
2019 and 2020 Deep Learning Tracks show that we can achieve effectiveness
comparable to zero-shot reranking with GPT-3.5 with a much smaller 7B parameter
model, although our effectiveness remains slightly behind reranking with GPT-4.
We hope our work provides the foundation for future research on reranking with
modern LLMs. All the code necessary to reproduce our results is available at
https://github.com/castorini/rank_llm. | [
0.0204329398,
0.0321854874,
0.0177933499,
0.0320688076,
-0.0017202506,
-0.0113496566,
0.0083972272,
0.0107841296,
0.0443859994,
-0.0739753842,
-0.0558263808,
0.0182776339,
-0.0196496956,
0.0186064858,
-0.007193428,
-0.0150459465,
0.0171815902,
-0.0045067635,
-0.0063553881,
-0.0242198016,
-0.0220594332,
0.0067942627,
0.0280764997,
-0.0034491362,
0.1033839807,
-0.0183850788,
-0.002414352,
0.0218566135,
0.0029716238,
-0.0189790111,
-0.0061573642,
0.0258655008,
0.0251900628,
0.0931322277,
0.0000018166,
-0.0600084737,
-0.059035074,
0.0113339545,
0.0001365998,
0.0353393778,
0.0042338246,
-0.005043969,
0.0048094639,
-0.0013841692,
-0.0368634649,
-0.0155765247,
0.0152882701,
0.0027647258,
0.0609870404,
0.0607853904,
0.0077523426,
-0.037730854,
0.0357584283,
-0.0655406192,
0.0137325414,
-0.0536594838,
0.0214084275,
-0.0418189317,
-0.0016168883,
0.0710262731,
-0.0187307689,
0.0125984494,
0.0009976893,
-0.0244392622,
0.0534094833,
0.0306055024,
-0.1126385406,
0.0270746015,
0.0188309327,
0.0955469906,
-0.0467031188,
-0.0259539131,
0.019181205,
0.014942578,
0.0046573896,
0.0024026309,
-0.0761958212,
-0.0095620202,
0.0385797583,
0.014637745,
-0.0066451123,
0.0140235648,
0.0507257059,
0.0436071567,
-0.0083668325,
0.0793294683,
0.035723079,
-0.0273548793,
0.005855252,
-0.0124481898,
-0.0226334613,
-0.0213143658,
-0.0006611167,
0.0079197204,
-0.002862195,
0.0030365393,
0.0254582148,
-0.0102579342,
0.0342212841,
-0.0556157194,
-0.0359765179,
0.0143704982,
-0.0112637039,
0.082927458,
-0.0280178115,
0.0474673472,
-0.0060503264,
0.0189817064,
-0.0187357776,
-0.0186902769,
-0.0050073024,
-0.02937782,
0.0362322479,
0.0329343192,
-0.0101123592,
0.001429165,
-0.0545918122,
0.0005418183,
-0.0062038545,
-0.0092422366,
0.0110057238,
-0.0040833075,
-0.0474543869,
-0.0043771523,
0.0050003598,
0.0416225009,
0.0273752287,
-0.0141005535,
-0.0280128233,
-0.0048564528,
-0.0025356037,
0.0075249868,
-0.0318849981,
-0.0195610449,
0.0411434397,
0.027005868,
-0.0141388131,
-0.0206623431,
0.0072431061,
-0.0094331298,
0.0192743186,
-0.0465935729,
-0.0246407203,
-0.0695827976,
-0.0025139691,
-0.0101862932,
0.0304186009,
-0.0020163648,
-0.0072530797,
0.0384002104,
-0.0650069788,
0.0452397466,
0.014980671,
-0.0130530288,
0.0312474389,
0.0218903217,
0.0083311694,
0.0377765559,
-0.0095817391,
0.0356764607,
0.0648051128,
0.0104905553,
-0.0092240544,
0.0319340192,
0.020126814,
0.0118703274,
0.0093095126,
-0.0027381496,
-0.0173176713,
0.040088743,
0.0392057076,
0.0237317663,
-0.0553435832,
-0.0525125451,
0.0305616595,
0.0474917591,
0.0607126765,
0.0294804368,
-0.0013366902,
-0.0044177347,
-0.0252391417,
-0.0034482866,
-0.0189159624,
0.0151084419,
0.0023230917,
-0.0071460595,
0.0723426118,
0.0402312875,
-0.0319161005,
0.0026793857,
0.0095141362,
0.0260039978,
-0.0330816023,
-0.0156443976,
0.0748011023,
-0.0108784353,
-0.0063111684,
0.0238877703,
0.0357503481,
-0.040823184,
0.0075144572,
-0.0378938951,
0.0101372097,
0.0702380836,
0.0867360979,
-0.070413284,
0.0111233583,
-0.0003480208,
0.0010331648,
0.0084527908,
0.0196307171,
-0.0104200598,
0.0005104726,
-0.0500042215,
-0.0100720832,
0.008374922,
0.0218846276,
0.0375285931,
0.0025831272,
0.0328163654,
0.0195553806,
-0.061987143,
0.0054032677,
0.0165009499,
0.0012687347,
-0.0082642967,
0.0414093286,
-0.0449410006,
0.0097004147,
0.0080495635,
0.0029357895,
-0.0134879146,
0.0371377505,
0.0007322761,
-0.0132315941,
-0.0546152741,
0.0005162675,
-0.0299463924,
0.0507837124,
-0.0340390578,
0.0419639349,
0.1000841558,
-0.0552945621,
-0.0228548348,
0.0253944453,
0.034748476,
0.0088834828,
-0.0253802352,
0.0174871217,
-0.0213256273,
0.0155655276,
-0.0473810136,
0.0472577959,
0.0150120445,
0.0543500856,
0.0426339135,
-0.0165643767,
-0.0222531632,
-0.0470345579,
-0.0617815144,
0.0472864434,
-0.0042416854,
0.0175466035,
0.0133361667,
0.0290821474,
-0.0255726073,
-0.0048183785,
-0.1230627522,
0.0292832125,
-0.0107823759,
-0.0089205662,
0.0095870607,
0.0099058114,
0.0175983682,
-0.0164098237,
-0.0356865935,
-0.0275572594,
-0.0073818369,
0.022094911,
0.0172456112,
-0.0514936894,
-0.0011036292,
-0.0438844785,
-0.0780974329,
0.0093761934,
0.0854121447,
-0.0267817713,
0.0053202803,
-0.0148856184,
0.0242237486,
-0.0739732981,
0.0202149861,
-0.0350492671,
0.009289084,
-0.0288383029,
-0.0152128888,
-0.0030762604,
0.0539256334,
0.0084531261,
0.0070261722,
0.0533255301,
-0.0006779523,
-0.0671534166,
-0.0112882424,
0.0023896818,
-0.0060340627,
0.0202441756,
-0.0022754828,
-0.0130291283,
-0.0052403798,
-0.0381819196,
-0.020888513,
-0.02337211,
0.0185819548,
-0.0297897849,
0.0045762239,
-0.0898318663,
0.0285774656,
0.0132956514,
-0.0127490712,
0.0049459725,
-0.0530690737,
0.0289131273,
-0.0196125899,
0.0001751281,
-0.0497182384,
-0.0023144684,
-0.0832342654,
0.0374427661,
0.0108775273,
0.0120425355,
-0.0473825112,
0.0123157967,
-0.0140391467,
0.0295949113,
0.0129370093,
-0.0619137585,
0.0137457596,
-0.0158760939,
0.0428423434,
-0.0296367351,
-0.052480679,
0.0144384494,
-0.0568596721,
0.0311473384,
0.0187301096,
0.0012581184,
-0.0197118577,
-0.0201902147,
0.034421131,
0.0313314945,
0.0845706165,
-0.0376050845,
-0.0160228647,
0.0015380662,
0.0602896661,
0.0564259216,
-0.0562947839,
0.0085578728,
0.0258302744,
0.0398482382,
0.05810453,
0.0670865923,
-0.0162588526,
-0.0205012485,
-0.0066505489,
0.0399664938,
-0.047212474,
-0.0470152162,
-0.0212405305,
-0.0189907271,
-0.0086066145,
-0.0111321183,
0.0817254111,
0.0265563522,
-0.102640681,
-0.0039095911,
-0.0148059698,
0.0495659076,
0.0065965815,
0.0343588516,
-0.0855268762,
0.0041444157,
0.0318779647,
0.0352590606,
-0.0023021812,
-0.033588782,
-0.0161675941,
-0.1240000278,
0.0861526132,
0.0006372613,
-0.0106905317,
0.0173591897,
-0.0583237223,
-0.0035269551,
-0.0421343744,
-0.0228688363,
0.0340935625,
-0.0108043458,
0.0157976151,
-0.0271518584,
-0.0116318278,
-0.01461876,
0.0317017324,
-0.03284657,
0.0369557068,
0.0111041097,
0.0305473283,
-0.0075575239,
-0.0117544923,
0.0127661955,
-0.0119109619,
-0.0426063314,
-0.0205512661,
0.0420873202,
-0.0109683583,
-0.0005536858,
-0.0120963473,
0.0181707516,
-0.0163253322,
0.0326266363,
-0.0155649194,
0.0473216958,
-0.0096951388,
0.0052727633,
-0.0303282794,
-0.0443368033,
-0.0439263619,
0.0530846938,
-0.0283791386,
-0.0028056016,
-0.0161416661,
-0.051081378,
0.0203476436,
0.0401984714,
-0.0434878431,
-0.0105628017,
-0.0336409062,
-0.0361182019,
-0.0550339594,
-0.0086044045,
-0.0187354181,
0.0098422552,
-0.0283869524,
0.0548601672,
-0.0611744523,
-0.0201355163,
-0.0414024591,
-0.0106662624,
-0.0153080383,
0.0251004323,
-0.0264554694,
0.0401720069,
0.0760563612,
-0.0155507382,
-0.0381373093,
-0.0157464631,
-0.0302786082,
-0.0468846075,
-0.0332848467,
0.039323546,
0.0290340092,
0.007253679,
-0.0356574096,
-0.0778420642,
0.0523844287,
0.0435205661,
-0.0158852004,
0.0284096934,
0.0093573034,
-0.0019747864,
-0.0150020542,
0.039946951,
-0.0770610198,
0.0007405721,
-0.0203692894,
0.0118561909,
-0.0037943327,
-0.0076869912,
-0.0079676639,
0.0411468446,
0.0759750009,
0.0065447451,
-0.0027599444,
-0.0278886966,
0.0289572123,
-0.0357737839,
-0.0183962379,
-0.0194950197,
0.0431979485,
0.0712022185,
0.0043795174,
-0.0328188129,
0.0191966742,
0.0175749436,
0.0232518483,
-0.0775867552,
-0.0236454532,
-0.0013811998,
-0.0396096371,
0.0065614362,
-0.0168089531,
-0.0506435856,
0.0055661523,
-0.0122960461,
0.0412106216,
-0.041219078,
-0.0125024244,
0.0219672956,
-0.0032044325,
-0.0258424673,
0.0673036948,
-0.0861083642,
-0.0311232992,
-0.0285080224,
0.0298839696,
0.0819107443,
0.0580334775,
0.0889920071,
0.0256141406,
-0.0271337014,
-0.0166726504,
-0.0471600071,
0.0203542896,
-0.0170663465,
-0.014321221,
0.0311128013,
0.0028421939,
0.0762604028,
0.1053167805,
0.0435131378,
-0.0177262388,
0.0230702404,
-0.0376397036,
-0.0063925064,
-0.0030981526,
0.0100301001,
0.0615813658,
0.0009592763,
-0.0295331031,
-0.0144196078,
-0.0117354691,
0.0247633364,
-0.0278741028,
0.0039479346,
-0.0348913223,
0.0156994686,
0.0833063796,
-0.0209710989,
0.0039003422,
-0.0575327501,
-0.0103954542,
-0.0241132136,
-0.0597659945,
-0.0032072952,
-6.136657606e-33,
0.0057879179,
0.001168301,
-0.0119357305,
-0.0074052541,
-0.0285637509,
0.0211464595,
0.0160398092,
-0.0311334413,
-0.0054813246,
-0.0084068738,
-0.027879186,
0.0319380946,
0.0030729275,
0.0160304047,
0.0088778622,
0.0079730423,
0.0138092553,
-0.0022176607,
-0.0380193032,
0.0261499099,
0.0254610423,
0.0379270539,
0.0064812507,
-0.0160060693,
0.010599195,
-0.0134124318,
-0.0074682795,
-0.0006671285,
-0.0028427613,
0.0555860475,
0.0009478594,
0.0196246002,
0.0479084402,
-0.0841210857,
0.0209043846,
0.0010791607,
-0.0332809389,
-0.0084356684,
-0.0114149824,
-0.0258307923,
-0.0261897147,
0.0083192559,
0.0472687185,
0.0214451496,
-0.0079661962,
-0.0413140319,
0.0264879987,
0.0039877794,
-0.044984784,
-0.0549959838,
0.0193644203,
0.0396954268,
-0.0216757841,
-0.0100899562,
0.0146816289,
0.0295713097,
-0.0212869532,
0.0901311189,
-0.0624262542,
0.019010799,
-0.040696919,
0.0480796508,
0.0556946546,
-0.0264616385,
-0.0139647229,
0.0574145839,
0.0012159699,
-0.0053273151,
0.0195829887,
-0.0404876508,
0.005413909,
-0.0001691626,
0.0471278392,
0.0315056778,
0.032553941,
0.020656934,
-0.1141025648,
0.0404141918,
0.0300128609,
0.0007717012,
0.0157958698,
0.0657380819,
-0.0167217851,
-0.0237287618,
-0.0039117862,
-0.0417065136,
-0.0455336012,
-0.0179683845,
0.0195896272,
0.0088954456,
-0.0401737355,
-0.0097048087,
0.0305124708,
-0.0424557403,
-0.0445358418,
0.0600380115,
-0.0025587422,
0.0213349443,
0.0042307177,
0.0285622161,
-0.0476252213,
0.0108715435,
0.0056011779,
0.000860076,
-0.024414558,
-0.0222609546,
0.0117663527,
0.0071946615,
-0.0367437862,
0.0005677074,
0.0108856279,
-0.0120802168,
-0.0361566916,
0.0687331781,
-0.0380851068,
-0.013550614,
0.0187835172,
0.0790904164,
0.0745464712,
0.049487561,
-0.0257418193,
-0.0141059235,
0.0115387375,
-0.0366690829,
-0.0034154912,
0.0228516702,
0.0127902962,
0.0472776778,
0.0323524512,
-0.0535246506,
-0.0150335561,
-0.0091260774,
2.668e-7,
0.0193578657,
0.0460866243,
-0.0226754602,
-0.0109870927,
0.0486018062,
0.0116638346,
0.0062281098,
0.083559446,
0.0241425708,
0.0245757625,
-0.0006147422,
-0.0186121929,
0.0215946138,
-0.0099948179,
-0.0741559491,
-0.0018504013,
-0.1067599431,
-0.0376262739,
-0.0514099672,
-0.079210408,
-0.0119836321,
0.1056966856,
0.0105638606,
0.0020986316,
-0.0021062903,
-0.0331477448,
0.0564369112,
-0.0226360485,
-0.0254856944,
0.0096551972,
0.084641844,
0.0215439275,
-0.0163690988,
-0.0306420363,
-0.0015596915,
0.0396640338,
0.0609176122,
0.0384733751,
-0.0419631228,
-0.0041803541,
0.0235637035,
-0.0246035699,
-0.0075988891,
-0.0710802749,
0.0848892331,
-0.0322796479,
-0.0145114651,
-0.0070668277,
-0.0549826026,
-0.0143422997,
0.0498227179,
-0.0244458374,
-0.0279855467,
0.041408468,
-0.0039017487,
0.0035680726,
-0.0117124561,
-0.0710197836,
-0.0231176391,
-0.0514549017,
-0.0409323797,
-0.0408008434,
-0.0258355401,
-0.0309779532,
-0.0247868933,
-0.0387551412,
0.0377993397,
2.350376848e-34,
0.0675942004,
-0.0024123183,
0.0021199102,
-0.0065825852,
0.0070488658,
-0.01448033,
-0.0075155995,
0.0163042229,
-0.0034650613,
-0.1030030102,
-0.0026738844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15840v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15840v1 | How to Catch an AI Liar: Lie Detection in Black-Box LLMs by Asking Unrelated Questions | 2023-09-26T16:07:54 | 2023-09-26T16:07:54 | Lorenzo Pacchiardi, Alex J. Chan, Sören Mindermann, Ilan Moscovitz, Alexa Y. Pan, Yarin Gal, Owain Evans, Jan Brauner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) can "lie", which we define as outputting false
statements despite "knowing" the truth in a demonstrable sense. LLMs might
"lie", for example, when instructed to output misinformation. Here, we develop
a simple lie detector that requires neither access to the LLM's activations
(black-box) nor ground-truth knowledge of the fact in question. The detector
works by asking a predefined set of unrelated follow-up questions after a
suspected lie, and feeding the LLM's yes/no answers into a logistic regression
classifier. Despite its simplicity, this lie detector is highly accurate and
surprisingly general. When trained on examples from a single setting --
prompting GPT-3.5 to lie about factual questions -- the detector generalises
out-of-distribution to (1) other LLM architectures, (2) LLMs fine-tuned to lie,
(3) sycophantic lies, and (4) lies emerging in real-life scenarios such as
sales. These results indicate that LLMs have distinctive lie-related
behavioural patterns, consistent across architectures and contexts, which could
enable general-purpose lie detection. | [
0.0520758927,
0.0476869009,
-0.0586737953,
0.0638719052,
-0.073760584,
0.0186839066,
0.0256768167,
0.0192347504,
0.060796462,
-0.0378510244,
-0.0055506406,
-0.0201196093,
0.0294410735,
0.0533045642,
0.034704946,
0.0377704799,
0.0567441992,
0.0148414886,
0.0380959995,
-0.0370072611,
0.0102712661,
0.0401053131,
0.0037195198,
0.0122000193,
-0.0433297753,
-0.0202159975,
-0.0258292593,
-0.0096550006,
0.0122782541,
0.0120548457,
0.0124803707,
0.0107006505,
0.0323272571,
0.0936835781,
0.0000020286,
-0.0402467474,
-0.0588570721,
0.0019108376,
-0.1034685075,
-0.0061997315,
0.0020988067,
-0.0229599476,
0.0104066022,
0.024555305,
-0.0792786255,
-0.0186657105,
0.0434236899,
0.061481867,
0.0607149079,
0.1026134789,
0.0009405945,
-0.0011493065,
0.0494580939,
-0.0210061185,
0.0447065383,
-0.0304229222,
0.0120205078,
-0.0214474145,
-0.0264704637,
-0.0251411423,
0.0146283098,
0.0016017444,
0.0186449829,
-0.0072871693,
-0.0718398765,
0.0533975884,
-0.0401996151,
0.005880238,
-0.018993346,
0.0347225778,
-0.0220292695,
-0.0116689,
0.0221094061,
0.0011644145,
0.0265813228,
-0.0187149998,
0.0043300404,
0.0473511219,
-0.0286988802,
-0.0143742245,
0.0070446422,
-0.0388735533,
0.0204880964,
-0.0131562734,
0.0031172268,
0.0713969022,
-0.0182569288,
-0.0293603353,
0.033547774,
-0.0229347162,
0.0186945908,
-0.0917060524,
-0.0136767523,
0.0443516895,
-0.0395662189,
0.0314185768,
-0.0452080928,
0.053519357,
0.0351477042,
-0.032542482,
0.0266541634,
0.0070020272,
-0.0125067439,
0.0313476808,
-0.0163258929,
0.0863275975,
-0.0217245389,
0.0401803777,
-0.032997787,
0.0052844952,
0.0311577264,
-0.0389379375,
-0.0069158897,
0.0576041229,
0.0179953035,
0.0037547778,
-0.0366826504,
0.0023628329,
-0.0246071946,
0.0540562533,
-0.0450347625,
0.0231725723,
-0.0001829649,
-0.0267738495,
-0.0404033586,
0.011325798,
0.0013536547,
0.0243227836,
0.000170682,
-0.0749747157,
-0.0260967314,
0.0249625184,
-0.0300781187,
0.009141718,
0.0203869008,
0.0038956355,
0.0075837141,
-0.0276938956,
-0.0693136901,
-0.0346555263,
-0.0268275291,
-0.0823537633,
0.0087946644,
-0.0295029152,
0.0195832364,
-0.0133492127,
-0.0172566622,
-0.0168982036,
0.0109932721,
0.0001696228,
-0.0327344835,
0.0464220494,
0.015627645,
-0.0075188274,
0.0146619258,
0.0070291315,
0.0084060067,
0.0634713843,
0.0181226078,
0.0631706864,
0.079350546,
-0.0040595112,
0.0430018157,
0.0195872765,
0.0342444964,
0.0103405062,
0.0250131469,
0.0301933009,
-0.0042216145,
0.001417667,
0.0116636669,
0.0190028157,
-0.0006115994,
-0.0691954717,
0.0931627601,
0.0075447848,
-0.0369364955,
-0.0332631357,
0.0469499417,
0.0067432211,
-0.0054929657,
0.0480354056,
-0.0408147536,
-0.0021083935,
-0.0719932988,
-0.0148416245,
-0.0147400098,
0.0149977673,
-0.0065976959,
-0.0384017453,
0.0061401017,
-0.018130552,
-0.0043309652,
0.0617421232,
-0.0130226435,
-0.0280595664,
-0.0445045233,
0.0465891026,
0.0110444389,
-0.0303901937,
-0.0335503481,
-0.1010521948,
0.0508560129,
0.0305393022,
0.0321548432,
0.0032834462,
-0.0182397291,
-0.0491669625,
-0.0067083593,
0.0450728312,
0.0517425276,
-0.0016772215,
-0.0041976687,
0.0124863293,
0.012849139,
-0.028854182,
0.013738458,
0.0270892456,
-0.006508091,
0.0100091035,
0.0154521642,
-0.0548423231,
0.033123143,
0.0410697535,
-0.0162410326,
-0.0363336541,
0.013405296,
0.012445963,
0.0391915478,
-0.0216869302,
-0.003867883,
-0.0101904385,
0.0618756413,
-0.0139814867,
-0.0236744825,
-0.0370471738,
0.0107895881,
-0.0094971359,
0.0141075552,
0.0102734519,
-0.0139468508,
0.0365398154,
-0.0256614517,
-0.0056042857,
-0.0168975852,
-0.0518551432,
0.0513535887,
-0.0265309084,
0.0182885733,
-0.017327467,
0.0381113589,
-0.0075493427,
0.0491917059,
-0.0449289083,
-0.0000315273,
-0.0343352892,
-0.0223520622,
0.0059443591,
-0.035313949,
0.0138625586,
-0.0008054514,
0.0240262635,
0.0136829009,
0.0333910435,
0.0128650283,
-0.0131016504,
-0.0179866701,
-0.0764391795,
-0.0151618002,
-0.0074133216,
-0.0118027255,
0.0136504825,
-0.0190296061,
-0.0149441538,
-0.001735616,
-0.0446785204,
0.0400177278,
0.023198517,
-0.0114532812,
0.0201288722,
-0.0164047647,
-0.0131533379,
-0.0013624841,
0.0423268564,
-0.0141181229,
0.0153519381,
0.0087117543,
0.0168957207,
-0.0728269964,
-0.0163843054,
-0.0505635664,
0.047638569,
-0.0332926065,
-0.0316634662,
0.0050318139,
0.0113644758,
-0.0243402068,
0.1081746593,
0.0401394852,
0.037505094,
0.0312443543,
0.0052088979,
-0.0374257118,
0.0227868222,
0.0017971426,
-0.0006328747,
-0.0543834157,
-0.0837021098,
0.0252975412,
0.0414875373,
0.0510625169,
0.0009554857,
-0.0088247769,
0.0195899289,
0.0180539768,
-0.0480521806,
0.0395390466,
0.0008442731,
-0.0377529152,
0.061335627,
0.0266620703,
-0.0887669325,
0.0770873427,
-0.0352610499,
0.0024080579,
-0.009860578,
-0.0232935827,
-0.0055152229,
0.0564155169,
0.0181923751,
-0.0091027552,
0.0524960719,
0.00967211,
-0.0330051966,
-0.0347448699,
0.0039382605,
-0.0416958332,
0.0116002467,
-0.0514471307,
0.017859919,
0.0118520036,
-0.0382662117,
-0.0881929845,
-0.0674759895,
-0.0271896645,
-0.0471607931,
-0.0339731276,
-0.0463310815,
-0.0861116275,
-0.0588059239,
0.0150524899,
0.0402977616,
-0.0437217392,
0.0007352981,
-0.0067834547,
0.0143809654,
0.0767026842,
0.0117040919,
0.0609784909,
-0.0176899172,
0.0040692845,
0.0503364503,
-0.0428644381,
0.0408002846,
-0.0114220222,
-0.0432311222,
0.0289027914,
0.0137259699,
0.003341655,
0.01930096,
-0.0259915162,
-0.0397735909,
-0.0297296513,
0.1014652774,
0.0262626782,
-0.0017700272,
0.002402206,
-0.008993132,
0.047798764,
0.0164873395,
0.0151107414,
-0.0967769399,
-0.0123820417,
-0.0018133519,
-0.0077277841,
-0.0565969832,
-0.0210243333,
-0.0575175956,
-0.1343933791,
0.0448592007,
-0.0020156652,
-0.0193305742,
-0.0395222194,
-0.0070869839,
-0.0269920491,
0.0299253892,
0.0622094497,
-0.0059061879,
0.018303806,
-0.0232438892,
-0.0347821154,
-0.0394545645,
0.0224338435,
0.0370126665,
0.0342173167,
0.0441472307,
0.0723590106,
0.033424817,
-0.0268356018,
-0.0357313007,
0.0143708522,
0.0501399375,
-0.03253337,
-0.0062528523,
0.0706657618,
-0.0112244273,
-0.0055646617,
0.0239623338,
0.0168788321,
-0.0228650272,
0.0473537259,
0.0414278321,
0.0410191491,
-0.0287538245,
-0.0898117423,
0.0214282051,
0.0230039079,
0.0274212398,
0.0524004735,
-0.0107064229,
-0.0032739996,
-0.046912998,
-0.0437655225,
0.0072066039,
0.0060032126,
-0.0422056727,
0.0427399687,
0.0370311439,
0.0275554899,
-0.0359720662,
-0.0218983795,
-0.0048015383,
-0.0385880545,
0.0041020699,
-0.0182725154,
0.0313229598,
-0.0012430414,
-0.035798803,
-0.0387779623,
-0.0551742949,
0.0540123992,
-0.0190470852,
0.0076790988,
0.0260664597,
-0.0417256504,
0.0113417776,
-0.0035402656,
-0.0576618463,
-0.0108750314,
0.0163438749,
0.0361393243,
0.0168880168,
0.066230379,
-0.0144284712,
-0.0052432339,
0.0159365572,
0.0186213925,
-0.0612885877,
0.0507838801,
0.0343474783,
0.0143775567,
0.0137867071,
0.028549403,
-0.0360203721,
0.0243493263,
0.033498235,
-0.0338865407,
-0.0659307316,
-0.0176922921,
0.0574491508,
0.0195878316,
-0.007011997,
0.009623698,
0.0510146953,
-0.0119169764,
0.02278574,
0.0012716834,
-0.0050237733,
-0.036748074,
-0.0062385285,
0.0091658328,
0.0042404355,
0.0187635515,
-0.0293872971,
-0.0677317157,
0.0092648827,
-0.033356037,
-0.0319704413,
0.0005679229,
0.0222673547,
-0.0009123157,
-0.0500738993,
-0.0019436724,
0.0427568108,
0.0143756727,
0.081702143,
0.0247180145,
0.0606346428,
0.0086707547,
-0.043852374,
-0.0071125249,
0.0090824515,
-0.0347493142,
-0.0392236225,
0.011405359,
0.0170169733,
0.0080711404,
0.0183339845,
0.0012082962,
-0.0159432963,
0.0015329916,
0.008297924,
-0.0161062852,
0.0101839481,
-0.0259673763,
0.0424607657,
0.0041008866,
-0.0392170884,
0.0177514199,
0.0411285199,
0.0422143973,
0.0576361306,
0.0121825058,
-0.0149760274,
-0.0684802756,
-0.0548533387,
0.0092685753,
0.021705959,
0.0066120117,
0.0002900479,
-0.0890069604,
-0.0594745949,
-0.0024916432,
-0.005183313,
0.0253912341,
-0.0302529372,
-0.0175362527,
0.0731982961,
-0.000315693,
-0.0052242568,
-0.0491137132,
0.0197834689,
-0.0042810105,
-0.0063975649,
-0.0261441041,
-6.311674388e-33,
-0.010374831,
-0.0986467153,
-0.0080327988,
-0.0131971305,
-0.0031715867,
0.0421027057,
0.008992807,
-0.0131427469,
-0.0635377914,
0.0204898901,
-0.0061686779,
0.0523538254,
0.0017931717,
0.0097347191,
-0.0501592159,
-0.0219594147,
0.023771042,
-0.0221483242,
-0.0405594967,
0.0162490476,
0.0299197901,
-0.0292464327,
0.0557893068,
-0.0844261572,
0.0574757569,
-0.0058441493,
-0.0566606894,
0.056039013,
-0.0841896608,
0.0294094793,
-0.0154020917,
0.046980422,
0.01035072,
-0.0016564227,
0.0284288879,
0.0239201654,
0.0080747651,
-0.0182509255,
0.0600667559,
-0.0027089643,
-0.0005686018,
-0.0181369241,
0.003446439,
-0.0321536697,
-0.0042844615,
-0.0108491778,
0.0052961786,
-0.0121358493,
0.0065160869,
0.0176450647,
-0.0450337566,
-0.0077365376,
0.0037496809,
-0.0245207194,
-0.0389565863,
0.0619255081,
0.0111259148,
0.0004360382,
-0.0610329136,
0.0305841584,
-0.0119273206,
-0.0298410766,
0.0239193402,
-0.0093954373,
-0.015712535,
0.0557752177,
0.0396442823,
0.0090231225,
-0.0221810918,
-0.0105702169,
-0.0015483535,
0.0200974327,
0.0525178649,
0.0531564839,
0.0060252701,
-0.0466198847,
-0.0490898043,
-0.0184982345,
0.0801975653,
-0.0099437954,
0.0344391987,
-0.0404817797,
-0.0451553762,
-0.011216362,
-0.029467199,
-0.0004843139,
-0.0300877951,
0.0110340882,
0.0323169716,
0.0327347293,
-0.0012724905,
-0.0203842744,
0.0053800819,
-0.065986149,
0.0204178225,
-0.0091819251,
-0.0073949932,
-0.033889249,
0.0183386803,
0.0417050011,
-0.0113379844,
0.0015818132,
0.0127232894,
-0.0257850401,
0.0296193436,
-0.0107841128,
0.0335229598,
0.021286346,
-0.0493548624,
0.0225619152,
-0.0070281993,
0.0486785024,
-0.0209812596,
-0.0398420878,
0.0029998103,
-0.0092706773,
-0.0211705659,
0.0081333015,
-0.0080384379,
-0.031512659,
-0.0757220089,
0.0221970193,
-0.024100922,
0.0391986407,
-0.0563751943,
-0.002353962,
-0.0024458878,
0.0386615209,
0.0282295067,
-0.0553887002,
-0.0107876929,
-0.0305786747,
2.783e-7,
-0.0225874316,
0.0218392443,
-0.0402349047,
0.0589261837,
0.0160382353,
0.0714273378,
0.0221951604,
0.0130979735,
0.0089059761,
-0.0926065594,
-0.0183401462,
0.0048651015,
0.0565662608,
0.0254575405,
-0.0592480898,
0.0433549173,
-0.0175786335,
-0.0358546115,
-0.0579229258,
0.0015920956,
0.0188172236,
0.0924548879,
0.0523345582,
-0.0235346742,
-0.0022064303,
-0.0441269837,
0.019884672,
-0.0011791998,
-0.0065487195,
0.0040328042,
0.0073964787,
-0.0214997325,
-0.0251870528,
0.0498327054,
-0.013157092,
0.0380167179,
-0.0672498494,
0.058395762,
-0.0203459356,
-0.0557710789,
-0.0310461819,
-0.0459536351,
0.0122101801,
-0.0720543116,
0.0884257779,
0.0010948511,
-0.0187772438,
-0.0744335651,
0.0306074787,
-0.0253669601,
0.0184892043,
-0.0188496597,
-0.019841576,
0.0442702062,
0.0073150117,
-0.0037240547,
0.0300718676,
-0.022120025,
-0.0110762184,
0.0108436281,
-0.0362390019,
-0.0491844863,
0.0233220775,
0.0367703661,
0.0223711822,
-0.0360860899,
0.0487080179,
2.624257848e-34,
0.0238273852,
-0.0062111425,
0.008520592,
0.0501302928,
0.0800206885,
0.020510925,
-0.0025134622,
0.0038831818,
0.0394029655,
-0.0292134993,
-0.003915546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15028v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15028v3 | Don't throw away your value model! Generating more preferable text with Value-Guided Monte-Carlo Tree Search decoding | 2023-09-26T15:57:57 | 2024-04-02T17:51:49 | Jiacheng Liu, Andrew Cohen, Ramakanth Pasunuru, Yejin Choi, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Asli Celikyilmaz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Inference-time search algorithms such as Monte-Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) may
seem unnecessary when generating natural language text based on
state-of-the-art reinforcement learning such as Proximal Policy Optimization
(PPO). In this paper, we demonstrate that it is possible to get extra mileage
out of PPO by integrating MCTS on top. The key idea is not to throw out the
value network, a byproduct of PPO training for evaluating partial output
sequences, when decoding text out of the policy network. More concretely, we
present a novel value-guided decoding algorithm called PPO-MCTS, which can
integrate the value network from PPO to work closely with the policy network
during inference-time generation. Compared to prior approaches based on MCTS
for controlled text generation, the key strength of our approach is to reduce
the fundamental mismatch of the scoring mechanisms of the partial outputs
between training and test. Evaluation on four text generation tasks demonstrate
that PPO-MCTS greatly improves the preferability of generated text compared to
the standard practice of using only the PPO policy. Our results demonstrate the
promise of search algorithms even on top of the aligned language models from
PPO, and the under-explored benefit of the value network. | [
0.0191641059,
0.0480307117,
0.0027417771,
-0.0209992677,
-0.0125904297,
-0.0095955953,
-0.0299459361,
0.0264381822,
-0.0573402755,
0.0214149691,
-0.0181824435,
-0.002208475,
0.0060203471,
0.0470010601,
0.0198576301,
-0.0747132823,
0.0399146192,
0.0044690184,
0.0540087186,
0.0071121179,
0.0133037772,
0.0047548185,
0.0061338488,
0.0686535612,
0.0058115874,
0.0075443042,
-0.024849074,
0.0233385917,
0.0685629919,
-0.0458666943,
-0.0134414565,
0.0126200793,
0.0067123929,
-0.006097462,
0.0000020283,
0.0128640849,
-0.0426569693,
-0.0073566441,
0.0119170938,
-0.0214665048,
0.0650353059,
0.0430687033,
-0.0322783142,
0.0401987657,
-0.0227106605,
0.002122818,
0.0624603778,
0.0418336689,
0.0348920114,
0.1032980904,
0.0132534541,
-0.0101746069,
0.0040835342,
-0.0345887877,
0.0457855463,
-0.0400725268,
-0.009202878,
0.0265503414,
0.0163504519,
0.0104926368,
-0.0129540497,
-0.0059960573,
0.0447520241,
0.0124882683,
-0.0186701156,
0.0895774812,
0.0689633712,
-0.0062469966,
-0.0188368391,
0.0495613702,
-0.0502105951,
-0.0416537598,
0.009487954,
-0.0668749139,
-0.0298093762,
-0.0216007605,
0.0147835929,
0.0525439046,
-0.021731047,
0.043244984,
0.0600042604,
0.0424190313,
0.0343305804,
0.0273417067,
-0.0432394668,
0.0016541797,
0.014544311,
-0.0393783078,
0.0303654391,
-0.0017398496,
-0.0252290647,
-0.0319815204,
0.0277855769,
0.0041370075,
-0.045752909,
0.0103733428,
-0.0776176155,
-0.0246224776,
-0.0175885987,
-0.0068594133,
0.0278318115,
0.0533476546,
0.0115988255,
-0.0358765833,
0.020380266,
0.0446754955,
-0.0148734394,
-0.005075437,
-0.0520161502,
0.0337341391,
-0.042430304,
-0.0178752821,
-0.0190786645,
0.0296628885,
-0.0718711764,
-0.055810079,
-0.035638351,
-0.0050996975,
0.0006976273,
-0.0083453283,
0.0272298064,
0.0377893411,
-0.0748041719,
-0.0095790299,
-0.0194121506,
0.0487703197,
-0.0483103134,
0.010008161,
0.0283336807,
-0.0016306875,
-0.0221605971,
0.046007432,
0.0005299798,
-0.0070823818,
0.0103455093,
0.0635596067,
-0.0496306755,
-0.0237842556,
-0.0086931074,
-0.0129576791,
-0.0274177566,
-0.0357039981,
0.0285472088,
-0.0446212888,
-0.0371926315,
-0.0498965234,
-0.0050675492,
-0.0339376964,
0.0236067362,
0.0194323733,
0.0010130684,
0.0194904841,
0.0091828452,
-0.0296280459,
0.0106842881,
-0.0213362984,
0.0293818824,
0.0467435792,
0.065932259,
0.0745584667,
-0.0336335115,
0.0212262049,
-0.0152848931,
0.0323975347,
0.0341404229,
-0.0150993271,
-0.0249221083,
-0.0229748394,
-0.0436536558,
0.0425477698,
0.0559634753,
0.0239657275,
-0.0790866092,
0.0405370668,
0.055445645,
-0.0110683879,
-0.0227527004,
-0.0207731929,
0.0450689495,
0.0259767883,
-0.0245331321,
-0.0048066904,
-0.0109490016,
0.0380173847,
-0.0186457261,
0.0404924005,
0.0184329301,
0.0169928875,
-0.0036501854,
-0.0635227859,
0.0275618322,
-0.014628198,
-0.0021577408,
0.0003301884,
0.0401930586,
0.0537990257,
-0.0950242057,
-0.0455620177,
-0.0025888262,
-0.0068675126,
0.0106981909,
-0.0513345227,
0.0247066338,
0.0760427713,
0.0664047599,
-0.0109229973,
0.0338555947,
0.0097566061,
-0.056508299,
0.0775346532,
0.0083870105,
-0.0176608395,
-0.0013831077,
-0.0708729252,
-0.039313551,
0.0158916935,
0.0181350745,
0.0421699546,
0.0203870498,
0.0069337599,
0.0162838195,
-0.0072329431,
-0.0480038337,
0.0371879973,
-0.012813176,
-0.0294084549,
0.0586220622,
-0.0010000993,
0.0117093464,
0.0147756292,
-0.048372861,
0.0435640775,
0.0027305763,
-0.0361699872,
-0.0192776062,
-0.011218545,
-0.0786363557,
-0.0719301701,
-0.0194668137,
-0.0863377824,
0.0017040665,
0.0182545763,
-0.0251540765,
-0.0485331528,
-0.0254977718,
-0.0616268925,
-0.0161469765,
-0.0347566605,
0.000102684,
0.0269106422,
-0.0234661177,
-0.0658922419,
0.0692017004,
-0.0435074493,
-0.0006830107,
0.0271882843,
0.0366235375,
-0.0076020141,
-0.0757023245,
0.0176067948,
0.0237212908,
-0.0144561101,
0.0027769841,
0.0531664528,
0.0799116194,
-0.0255610384,
-0.031471096,
-0.0396625847,
0.0166494399,
-0.0333087146,
0.0164011102,
0.0592215136,
0.0039991681,
-0.0125483926,
-0.0060425168,
-0.0117980558,
0.0030222407,
0.0175724905,
-0.0193071961,
0.0413677432,
-0.004813761,
0.0272756405,
-0.0436282195,
-0.0118420599,
0.0203628,
0.0088135134,
-0.0480777211,
0.0155908708,
-0.0291041788,
0.0330786034,
0.0113077955,
-0.0222302657,
0.0048088161,
-0.036587961,
0.0490076281,
-0.0234508831,
0.0592901446,
0.0529184453,
0.0239576977,
0.0512813479,
0.0064398902,
0.0235639028,
-0.0682685301,
0.0107602477,
-0.0487618372,
-0.001574834,
-0.0350360833,
-0.0649704486,
0.0474500358,
0.0694656596,
0.0494626425,
0.0457397252,
-0.105844073,
0.0354123712,
0.0071182195,
-0.0582551211,
0.0327766016,
0.0259657037,
-0.0346199386,
-0.0122009022,
-0.0487794243,
-0.0432093143,
0.0647741333,
-0.0152411293,
0.0166275483,
-0.0645263866,
-0.0038053361,
0.0222245231,
0.0063900203,
0.0319323167,
0.0196408797,
-0.0186035931,
-0.0471058413,
-0.0305014532,
0.0119633051,
0.0249170568,
-0.0220942628,
0.0039876276,
-0.0252120327,
-0.0021211673,
0.0124025187,
-0.0330635086,
-0.0325265266,
-0.0252649616,
-0.0027886904,
0.009404907,
0.0364747345,
-0.0320233814,
0.000217763,
-0.0154407304,
0.0215455908,
0.0615600422,
-0.0417179912,
-0.0177430343,
-0.0247599948,
0.0120584788,
0.0487136245,
-0.0086851222,
0.0257411674,
-0.0259186551,
0.000047814,
0.0360868871,
0.0434469394,
-0.0203298554,
-0.0226809103,
0.018022323,
-0.0129849846,
-0.0271675494,
0.0149115268,
0.0649068058,
0.0282626525,
-0.05044806,
-0.0551563688,
0.0844355151,
0.0221710149,
-0.0204687789,
0.0083882809,
0.004296944,
0.0811830387,
0.0066340477,
0.026231369,
-0.0382400565,
-0.0312858969,
0.0019263155,
0.0853896439,
-0.049697388,
-0.0076885954,
-0.0088246791,
-0.0925877839,
0.0088563021,
0.0098317219,
-0.0286647212,
-0.0609113015,
-0.0047006803,
-0.0408952087,
-0.0080236653,
0.0062792078,
0.0207930803,
0.0066881338,
0.0222343896,
0.0360479727,
0.0202812962,
-0.0760196596,
-0.0345164649,
-0.0003127053,
0.0323498137,
0.1474248916,
0.0206413027,
0.0159387998,
0.0101827364,
-0.0140262274,
-0.0085352277,
0.0164745711,
-0.0312377624,
0.0040210565,
-0.0132508054,
0.0115702199,
-0.0174689237,
0.0442530103,
0.0107082566,
-0.0194193143,
-0.0173669308,
0.031892322,
-0.0455359444,
-0.0404947735,
-0.0016651464,
0.0101938797,
0.0584590137,
0.0459202603,
0.0164571144,
-0.0326578617,
-0.0480373316,
-0.043689575,
0.0195215605,
-0.0897621363,
-0.0374457911,
0.0059249816,
0.0176816303,
-0.0153084137,
-0.0831517428,
-0.0543791987,
-0.0012069041,
0.0477434844,
-0.0276039634,
-0.0256198924,
-0.0056946916,
-0.0205359459,
-0.0188936256,
-0.035630364,
-0.0217951946,
0.0113799982,
-0.0174996965,
0.000576771,
-0.0132158957,
-0.046014037,
-0.0319892429,
-0.0060591195,
-0.0611212961,
-0.0438004993,
-0.0377711281,
0.0616363399,
0.0121829472,
0.0203058738,
0.0063242633,
-0.0551695675,
0.0574368164,
0.0485355109,
-0.0276344661,
0.0041840929,
0.036260698,
-0.0027396781,
-0.0065831817,
0.0168132596,
-0.0155991334,
0.0119207455,
0.0011186609,
0.0700151324,
0.0224421788,
-0.0034474358,
0.0251735523,
-0.0267573167,
0.0079383384,
-0.0508068688,
-0.0199226476,
-0.0469465628,
0.0155547746,
-0.010311801,
0.0062020035,
-0.0231453422,
0.015078973,
0.0559113324,
-0.0012159947,
-0.0014183652,
0.0022125642,
0.0186409317,
0.0373104997,
0.013578997,
-0.0093075475,
0.0314290188,
0.0544304214,
0.017337881,
-0.0190891139,
-0.0214752499,
0.0062397113,
0.007795895,
0.0380488932,
-0.0179449655,
0.0547112748,
0.0519269109,
-0.0010754457,
0.0009729987,
-0.0015196785,
-0.0519543402,
-0.0344918631,
-0.0530472472,
0.0103596942,
0.0578247719,
0.0157047678,
0.0520873554,
-0.0600819811,
0.0163578801,
-0.016200535,
0.0037782139,
0.0039055787,
-0.0287490953,
0.0171193611,
-0.0124125918,
-0.0016450261,
-0.0366197675,
0.0769321769,
0.0576767437,
0.0444717482,
-0.0421744436,
0.0326867253,
-0.0496870764,
-0.0406247154,
-0.0355126895,
0.0500855967,
-0.0204422213,
-0.0161970742,
-0.0246241186,
-0.0271492694,
-0.0332436226,
0.0623506904,
0.005210571,
-0.0331345871,
0.061528787,
0.0049147578,
-0.0665781125,
-0.0167237818,
-0.0215707496,
0.013583554,
-0.0037234318,
-0.0073775901,
-0.0724744126,
-6.065003143e-33,
-0.0440899543,
-0.0491017364,
0.0288938247,
-0.0541951396,
-0.0422498994,
-0.0244235341,
-0.0554128736,
-0.0232274458,
0.0553421937,
0.0334941261,
-0.009695909,
0.0017503366,
0.0232384838,
0.0368338451,
-0.0050757308,
0.0258585811,
0.0784527212,
-0.0378433019,
-0.0425866172,
0.0333579667,
0.0187341794,
0.0143476902,
0.035572771,
-0.0325415209,
-0.0261224546,
0.0283669438,
-0.03889364,
0.0058884062,
0.0118560847,
0.0524494611,
0.0125395721,
-0.0003900137,
0.0093136989,
-0.034970738,
-0.0484254211,
0.0051062847,
-0.0690459907,
-0.0538796969,
-0.0101399375,
-0.0243207086,
-0.0258601774,
-0.0505873077,
0.020253893,
-0.0053231437,
-0.0092995204,
0.0163534433,
0.0004096498,
-0.0224166699,
-0.0317860208,
-0.0525599718,
-0.0508068465,
0.0310867336,
0.005617789,
0.0254793447,
0.0181418713,
0.0216497295,
-0.0194964334,
0.0072643361,
-0.0132131455,
0.02948213,
-0.0078337984,
0.0370507278,
0.0508233793,
0.0594474375,
0.0082133934,
0.0261719339,
0.0045389873,
-0.0129311448,
-0.0143114589,
-0.0048207887,
0.0352965072,
0.0243468489,
0.0081542777,
0.0511394106,
0.0212508701,
-0.0103293303,
-0.0252289046,
0.0491793603,
0.0006048487,
0.0137464674,
0.0420329832,
0.0084409406,
-0.0347277001,
-0.0016415224,
-0.0684044287,
-0.0292289183,
-0.0001680993,
-0.0325976908,
0.038341146,
0.0654621497,
-0.0039808531,
-0.0187504012,
0.0431523398,
-0.0147082182,
0.0054880166,
0.0342852585,
-0.0553699099,
0.0205493812,
-0.0093622133,
0.0081789279,
-0.1190278828,
-0.046559386,
0.0517468862,
-0.0250904281,
-0.0214061495,
0.0224018618,
-0.0178317949,
0.0070973742,
-0.0548894592,
0.0098375315,
-0.0275997035,
0.0217754059,
0.0016748358,
0.0454155318,
0.0606564842,
-0.0135623459,
-0.0040190276,
0.0337378383,
0.0109227449,
0.0028319396,
-0.0208476055,
-0.0391433351,
0.0129954116,
0.0281397458,
-0.0176565722,
0.0437580384,
-0.0461882576,
0.0149311973,
-0.0077986834,
-0.0650780499,
-0.019767845,
0.0469445102,
2.596e-7,
0.012236625,
0.041153647,
0.0629925355,
0.0548421443,
0.0207005851,
0.0477343425,
0.0300128441,
0.0047172648,
-0.0140559589,
-0.0154877445,
0.0507041737,
-0.0009660784,
0.0586958528,
-0.0133616515,
-0.0715703368,
0.0262436327,
-0.0339324139,
0.0153709166,
-0.037475802,
-0.043820776,
0.0761829838,
0.0585379936,
-0.0174335074,
-0.0047606975,
0.0623521544,
0.0504239798,
0.0676560625,
0.0066782739,
0.010353935,
-0.0077077346,
0.014726595,
-0.0189143308,
-0.0293845534,
-0.0038619139,
-0.0152091011,
0.0131403329,
-0.015684953,
0.0663983747,
0.0248459894,
-0.0818486065,
0.0126987379,
-0.0007165082,
0.0126918135,
-0.0242296886,
0.0452421904,
-0.0504798591,
0.0135070542,
0.0156813525,
-0.0127758728,
0.009185045,
0.0066573019,
-0.0500470288,
-0.0437186025,
0.0269091651,
-0.0054902886,
0.0466669425,
-0.0060451361,
-0.0299495831,
-0.0052767629,
-0.0249531902,
-0.0426867083,
-0.0325974412,
-0.0757744014,
0.0530371666,
0.0281990301,
-0.0292750578,
-0.0486994609,
2.511130292e-34,
0.0127055962,
-0.0452171825,
-0.0087304814,
-0.012479445,
0.0108268559,
0.0369811915,
0.0246337503,
0.0247414839,
0.0207437575,
-0.05405619,
-0.0576312244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15025v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15025v1 | Large Language Model Alignment: A Survey | 2023-09-26T15:49:23 | 2023-09-26T15:49:23 | Tianhao Shen, Renren Jin, Yufei Huang, Chuang Liu, Weilong Dong, Zishan Guo, Xinwei Wu, Yan Liu, Deyi Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent years have witnessed remarkable progress made in large language models
(LLMs). Such advancements, while garnering significant attention, have
concurrently elicited various concerns. The potential of these models is
undeniably vast; however, they may yield texts that are imprecise, misleading,
or even detrimental. Consequently, it becomes paramount to employ alignment
techniques to ensure these models to exhibit behaviors consistent with human
values.
This survey endeavors to furnish an extensive exploration of alignment
methodologies designed for LLMs, in conjunction with the extant capability
research in this domain. Adopting the lens of AI alignment, we categorize the
prevailing methods and emergent proposals for the alignment of LLMs into outer
and inner alignment. We also probe into salient issues including the models'
interpretability, and potential vulnerabilities to adversarial attacks. To
assess LLM alignment, we present a wide variety of benchmarks and evaluation
methodologies. After discussing the state of alignment research for LLMs, we
finally cast a vision toward the future, contemplating the promising avenues of
research that lie ahead.
Our aspiration for this survey extends beyond merely spurring research
interests in this realm. We also envision bridging the gap between the AI
alignment research community and the researchers engrossed in the capability
exploration of LLMs for both capable and safe LLMs. | [
0.0134810749,
0.0849850476,
-0.0242791846,
0.042928718,
-0.082737498,
-0.0031793665,
-0.0158773698,
-0.0427345224,
-0.0088800099,
-0.0086211972,
-0.0246167239,
-0.0507945269,
0.0279096924,
0.023586195,
0.0340515077,
-0.0035958074,
0.0573549978,
-0.0189964846,
-0.0067225522,
0.0075052432,
0.0069414522,
0.0182127301,
0.0180574507,
0.0401240438,
0.0264062863,
-0.0199672915,
-0.0139833149,
0.0195364058,
0.0393651277,
0.0082670739,
-0.0251066778,
0.0159268975,
0.0061021941,
0.1085045114,
0.0000018289,
-0.0711828023,
-0.0260687508,
0.0254830383,
-0.0307662245,
0.0308687761,
0.0127831558,
-0.0595096909,
-0.0417879,
-0.0081883725,
-0.03396108,
0.0183824953,
0.0926510245,
-0.0117449528,
0.0456378721,
0.0841547251,
-0.0073031052,
-0.0102184042,
0.0508124083,
-0.0149813043,
-0.0616871156,
-0.0578196906,
0.0329901092,
0.0063726311,
-0.0186189804,
-0.0061515463,
0.0097029135,
0.0357160456,
-0.0064486554,
-0.0176992044,
-0.0296648536,
0.0052423473,
-0.0261182897,
-0.0155812437,
-0.0078246752,
0.0292022824,
0.0049383533,
-0.0403175578,
0.0128454166,
0.0005149391,
-0.0127516715,
0.0048736627,
-0.0087383306,
0.0034310305,
0.0135800643,
0.0288916212,
0.0261946172,
-0.0240111537,
0.0598323196,
0.0133256223,
-0.0330871493,
0.067624405,
0.0416949913,
-0.0347864516,
-0.0478750058,
-0.0299926233,
-0.0102780508,
-0.082482338,
-0.0327005461,
0.0319301598,
-0.0393200964,
0.0376848951,
-0.0878632739,
-0.0164046902,
0.0341252647,
-0.0518182069,
0.0530096106,
0.0540987067,
0.0165488403,
0.0342411809,
0.0159554183,
0.0994959995,
-0.0546816513,
0.0255263429,
-0.028565919,
-0.0105967168,
-0.0156651177,
-0.015397436,
0.0081447596,
-0.012494876,
0.0093651479,
-0.0182421096,
-0.046068795,
0.045359578,
-0.0232978333,
0.0837243199,
-0.032628864,
-0.0567493774,
-0.0142037002,
-0.0365902036,
-0.0001123849,
0.033772748,
0.0038143401,
0.0004764505,
-0.0206806324,
-0.0506394468,
-0.002614615,
0.0293303654,
-0.0668964088,
-0.0613402538,
-0.021633476,
0.0983879119,
0.0245984104,
0.0089675868,
-0.0202704258,
-0.019763438,
-0.0192322545,
-0.0586249046,
-0.0290068109,
-0.0551878922,
0.0303546507,
-0.0059198216,
-0.0277602449,
-0.0742599145,
-0.0152993081,
-0.0211691111,
-0.0167682916,
0.0570701435,
-0.0182814486,
0.0329856537,
0.0237812009,
-0.0085038152,
0.0182130821,
0.0638805777,
0.0321191959,
0.0067682145,
0.0435428657,
-0.0203538667,
-0.013316581,
0.0654324815,
-0.0076633636,
0.0172974709,
-0.0542567559,
0.0249412246,
0.0498951524,
0.0315420739,
0.0049493648,
0.0496725515,
0.0282724425,
-0.0440508798,
0.0884273946,
0.0265368409,
-0.003915594,
0.0199863613,
0.0226123855,
-0.0083494103,
0.0157375876,
0.0120877689,
-0.0772071183,
-0.0041674715,
-0.0591608062,
0.0165711064,
0.0036796723,
0.0693862662,
-0.0128285363,
-0.019654924,
-0.047222361,
-0.0028338756,
0.0046945629,
0.0094269216,
0.0433791056,
-0.0361957699,
-0.0114487829,
0.0117031317,
0.019367883,
-0.0353961736,
0.0014222305,
-0.07390479,
-0.0138186077,
0.0509881414,
0.053007856,
-0.0211918242,
-0.0576015301,
0.0346130319,
-0.0292419679,
0.025848873,
0.0402330868,
-0.0048946878,
-0.0060767382,
-0.0476115718,
-0.0256263781,
-0.0192280225,
-0.0016214701,
0.0262058936,
0.0020465304,
-0.0064441361,
-0.0188838746,
-0.0306218378,
-0.0635423511,
0.0427913554,
-0.0210229326,
0.0106560485,
-0.0501630791,
0.0295919366,
0.0534303747,
0.0170226824,
-0.0524232313,
0.0230080541,
0.0260604098,
-0.0083553325,
0.0018729008,
0.0132510103,
0.0036964158,
0.0662043169,
0.0795121044,
-0.0035531693,
-0.0107066687,
0.0446207002,
-0.0306816734,
-0.034164384,
0.0159769263,
-0.0363472626,
0.0181969982,
-0.0026682373,
0.0745447576,
-0.0598707944,
-0.0045525418,
-0.0548528656,
0.0498574488,
0.0017814713,
-0.021952901,
0.0146690626,
-0.0112405764,
0.0408167355,
-0.0038970204,
-0.0567745864,
0.0360952057,
-0.008283332,
0.0182793401,
0.0502435528,
-0.0341298655,
-0.0069819894,
-0.0353690572,
-0.0589976199,
0.0273141135,
0.0006444245,
0.050805334,
0.0427093096,
-0.0034292755,
-0.0121649671,
0.0442856997,
-0.0087451926,
-0.0270991363,
-0.0056005172,
0.0113453474,
0.0356319882,
-0.0029279832,
-0.0726428851,
-0.0606545098,
-0.0070903599,
-0.0451423489,
0.0375679322,
-0.0016629222,
-0.0191777498,
-0.0671559423,
0.0199122559,
-0.0425966457,
0.0408630408,
-0.0315997228,
-0.0575047545,
0.0199811161,
0.0280521456,
0.0103353187,
0.0635142326,
0.0049899123,
0.0178295523,
0.0930496603,
0.031816531,
-0.0355794318,
-0.0237574205,
-0.0059863599,
-0.0592003204,
-0.0614442006,
-0.0417633131,
0.018066803,
0.0712471455,
0.006324837,
0.0007248791,
-0.0550380498,
-0.0019596047,
-0.0170019288,
-0.0225884132,
0.0233468954,
-0.0463553816,
-0.0021959627,
0.0381221436,
-0.0508246459,
-0.0776007548,
0.07525675,
-0.0691600442,
0.0405771509,
-0.0141640175,
-0.0409137495,
-0.0247475095,
0.057150811,
-0.0091606267,
0.0483572856,
0.0023949924,
-0.0173351914,
-0.0685422495,
-0.0187122598,
0.0249155574,
-0.02451244,
0.0626443997,
-0.0409784652,
0.026413532,
-0.0038936581,
-0.0104732066,
-0.0436652303,
-0.0239794943,
-0.0234347265,
0.0262472425,
0.0159877241,
-0.051916074,
-0.0561587289,
0.0262691341,
0.0309528895,
-0.0144901117,
0.020169856,
0.0102763819,
-0.0294162612,
-0.0388424061,
0.0661572143,
-0.0130051272,
0.0310401507,
-0.0093373088,
0.0212177262,
0.0353442952,
0.0178474803,
0.0348903872,
-0.0503913946,
-0.0537879132,
0.0526639223,
-0.0445664153,
-0.0164479446,
0.0143259494,
0.0511867628,
-0.0220624637,
0.0299174581,
0.1045272946,
0.0181594081,
0.0001603937,
0.0140614221,
-0.0307097863,
0.0145752309,
0.0138327731,
0.01816383,
-0.0426215343,
0.010456549,
0.016050972,
0.0048929127,
-0.0220873542,
-0.0116814803,
-0.0087387208,
-0.1118955091,
-0.0104992501,
0.0411472917,
-0.0381972939,
-0.0697999075,
-0.0193463136,
0.0216504186,
0.0018164449,
0.0512491986,
0.0111722657,
0.020805072,
-0.0477290265,
0.0141894836,
-0.0392933525,
-0.0548863634,
-0.021667432,
-0.0661290288,
0.0810399801,
0.0962093025,
0.0392389297,
0.0059046894,
-0.0025606318,
-0.0041082734,
0.0138309943,
0.0033326559,
0.0428392664,
-0.0023970378,
-0.005290105,
-0.009887022,
0.0045729633,
0.021905493,
0.010457362,
-0.0112221884,
0.0229734741,
0.0526873991,
-0.028600147,
0.0109739704,
-0.0302507617,
-0.0191838536,
0.0059854737,
0.0857825354,
-0.0051142131,
-0.0244819392,
-0.0271675158,
-0.0073728785,
-0.0026952876,
-0.0017774448,
-0.0347445458,
0.037155956,
-0.0134501643,
-0.0192728676,
-0.0206132382,
-0.0217110626,
-0.0399215221,
0.0190043859,
0.0552006252,
-0.0029972037,
0.0122728078,
-0.0202210881,
-0.035181161,
-0.0161020868,
-0.0407095216,
0.0459345989,
-0.0511932671,
0.0109875342,
-0.0226178318,
-0.0177892428,
0.0003318177,
0.0264785066,
-0.0704493523,
-0.118839018,
0.0055137305,
0.0171160493,
0.0271028895,
0.0291336421,
-0.0198612325,
-0.0572042279,
0.0415902324,
0.025029771,
-0.0148123158,
0.0362313949,
0.0091335103,
-0.0241806023,
-0.0021092601,
0.0432215594,
-0.0546899885,
-0.0367502607,
0.0433191694,
0.0142370313,
-0.0347943716,
-0.0344918557,
0.0284768865,
0.0384528153,
0.0243857298,
-0.0490878075,
-0.0029231955,
0.0002266567,
-0.013894856,
-0.0419570133,
-0.0325181708,
0.008445574,
-0.023603797,
0.04989703,
0.0048119244,
0.0251681414,
0.012603147,
-0.0136256302,
0.0151683893,
-0.0331543051,
0.0059799608,
-0.0169858541,
0.0451668017,
0.043893978,
0.0141086075,
-0.0161009673,
0.0354821943,
-0.0252250154,
0.0330756642,
0.0076518091,
0.0268134549,
0.0338093489,
0.0283216387,
-0.017258646,
0.0291916579,
-0.046549771,
-0.0677320734,
0.0011999558,
0.0134124765,
0.0614147596,
0.0136910966,
0.0661107004,
-0.0257906206,
-0.0014844373,
-0.0354139358,
0.0153436512,
0.0111683942,
-0.0262809582,
0.0143701145,
0.0201666262,
-0.0321842879,
0.0147341397,
0.040795885,
-0.0090095531,
0.0470599607,
-0.0139717497,
-0.0286990255,
-0.0032214413,
-0.0605123676,
0.0215730201,
-0.0084660742,
-0.0567891188,
-0.0397475772,
-0.0675129369,
-0.0705302581,
0.0146334134,
0.041062925,
-0.0188342873,
0.0040132403,
-0.024986241,
0.0694158003,
-0.0189010538,
0.0143684251,
-0.0299567413,
-0.0290823299,
-0.0341949798,
-0.0022285341,
-0.0097660022,
-5.665160944e-33,
-0.0164670385,
-0.004462739,
0.0129470099,
-0.0361869335,
-0.0401458703,
0.003229131,
-0.0174343418,
0.0026768725,
-0.0494548269,
-0.015409423,
0.0269678328,
-0.0092135742,
0.0001708246,
-0.0050454671,
-0.0059157168,
-0.004900652,
0.0146046635,
0.0126742953,
-0.0373886488,
-0.0018441343,
0.0507472791,
-0.0411038995,
0.034307465,
-0.0785915032,
0.046395313,
-0.0079105208,
-0.040606752,
0.0289597549,
0.0036566167,
0.0772352293,
0.0009092321,
0.0184385702,
0.0102300132,
-0.0092474837,
0.0025354323,
0.0158069171,
0.021339396,
0.0038544973,
0.0634812042,
0.0141595155,
0.0184752941,
-0.046035368,
0.0350706428,
-0.018840462,
-0.0362668857,
-0.0078811496,
0.0301651731,
-0.0114641134,
-0.0077407393,
-0.0022950701,
-0.0944851115,
0.0241601765,
-0.0511947162,
0.0013043458,
0.0070247436,
0.0049912278,
0.0445385948,
0.009899863,
-0.0498569831,
0.0298870038,
-0.0189756081,
0.0400604904,
0.1362097263,
0.0550182089,
0.020032905,
0.0637429357,
0.0066625839,
-0.0105077168,
-0.0099909473,
-0.0112686465,
0.0252458155,
0.0313927792,
0.0369007587,
0.0458239727,
-0.0272743106,
0.0065016896,
-0.0605058819,
0.0295282714,
0.0253513008,
0.0353428572,
0.0418278724,
0.0364609435,
-0.0759848952,
0.0191439074,
-0.0203343723,
-0.0323391035,
-0.0364627764,
-0.0216669776,
0.0101471003,
-0.0332627743,
-0.0291044116,
0.0002676408,
0.0271870326,
-0.056566868,
0.0101328874,
0.0424848311,
-0.0391122289,
0.0099805715,
-0.020047497,
0.0404269397,
-0.0204263404,
-0.0561553501,
-0.0120796068,
-0.0087543735,
0.0398876332,
0.003796149,
0.0027678832,
0.0181026012,
-0.0368720256,
0.0098306928,
-0.0341788679,
-0.0101738144,
0.0058291242,
-0.0499117598,
0.0660412461,
-0.0017187061,
0.0089303562,
0.0080329608,
0.0298267826,
-0.0066820113,
-0.0009272785,
0.0464247055,
-0.0232645236,
0.0018067309,
-0.0085296556,
0.0142731089,
-0.0255596768,
0.0298160668,
0.0298479106,
-0.0269466285,
-0.0262116715,
-0.0061604097,
2.551e-7,
0.0329100788,
0.013604301,
0.0576111004,
0.0287890155,
-0.0050799185,
0.0438590869,
-0.0287211705,
0.0413473919,
-0.0268788561,
-0.0147224274,
0.0284403227,
0.0246620551,
0.0570441708,
0.0145617789,
-0.0065907468,
0.0330523588,
-0.0729717091,
0.0083162803,
-0.065092124,
0.0368295871,
0.0438002273,
0.0897584558,
0.023292277,
0.0009158251,
-0.0208394807,
-0.0662320703,
0.0174341202,
-0.026315324,
-0.0060546813,
0.0652741417,
0.0052615292,
0.0069589308,
-0.0163503401,
0.004846558,
0.007806282,
0.0379434116,
-0.0013248115,
0.0686885566,
-0.0133142052,
0.0118599059,
-0.0394813791,
-0.0172611289,
-0.0232390203,
-0.0676481724,
0.0525734164,
-0.0194144677,
-0.064582862,
-0.0404685065,
-0.0091635743,
0.0019849744,
0.002280616,
0.0113751795,
0.0121581741,
0.0367635675,
0.0251153857,
-0.0034818649,
-0.0100099947,
-0.0623549595,
-0.0303094555,
-0.0088167517,
-0.0339084268,
-0.0353964679,
-0.0090208212,
0.0160973202,
0.041921299,
-0.038265422,
0.0143205198,
2.37078568e-34,
-0.0120416759,
-0.0356518514,
0.0237181727,
0.0031365538,
0.0332213156,
0.0042344001,
-0.0319028348,
0.0572883338,
0.0048860707,
-0.0669218227,
0.0023558906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15016v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15016v2 | Question-Answering Approach to Evaluating Legal Summaries | 2023-09-26T15:36:29 | 2023-12-18T21:43:01 | Huihui Xu, Kevin Ashley | cs.CL | cs.CL | Traditional evaluation metrics like ROUGE compare lexical overlap between the
reference and generated summaries without taking argumentative structure into
account, which is important for legal summaries. In this paper, we propose a
novel legal summarization evaluation framework that utilizes GPT-4 to generate
a set of question-answer pairs that cover main points and information in the
reference summary. GPT-4 is then used to generate answers based on the
generated summary for the questions from the reference summary. Finally, GPT-4
grades the answers from the reference summary and the generated summary. We
examined the correlation between GPT-4 grading with human grading. The results
suggest that this question-answering approach with GPT-4 can be a useful tool
for gauging the quality of the summary. | [
0.0375924185,
-0.0042200689,
0.0124166254,
-0.0066245645,
-0.0455776975,
0.0242679156,
-0.0275680199,
0.006981933,
-0.0293899421,
-0.0467943102,
0.0216963589,
-0.0200189035,
0.0081223976,
-0.0425521284,
-0.0134508479,
-0.0848389715,
0.0090938872,
0.0313301273,
0.0509002954,
-0.0124990819,
0.0326159894,
0.0193176158,
0.0101074083,
0.0081727821,
-0.0129944533,
0.004250926,
-0.0023627114,
-0.0090434914,
0.0354380608,
-0.0186803099,
-0.0252852198,
0.0531446375,
-0.0187733807,
-0.0069349664,
0.000001595,
-0.0863793939,
0.0152231324,
0.0106249601,
0.0309640262,
0.0569714792,
0.0305129066,
-0.0124235367,
0.0131724849,
0.027103018,
-0.0255225953,
0.0029644242,
-0.0071520051,
0.0481953509,
0.0973859429,
0.0433487929,
-0.0017207214,
-0.0704671144,
0.0489728265,
-0.0138177276,
0.0024191425,
-0.0386457555,
-0.0229266845,
0.0837034807,
0.0291677807,
-0.0354241915,
0.0413477533,
-0.0037946685,
0.0196516756,
-0.01670154,
-0.0343444981,
-0.0197825357,
-0.0511190966,
0.0314624459,
0.0232559722,
0.0451715849,
0.0694565028,
-0.0253391564,
-0.0003426525,
-0.0033230528,
0.0726889893,
0.0434419662,
-0.0764943138,
0.093865633,
-0.0254746675,
0.0039558844,
-0.0049794745,
0.0537030064,
-0.0361463614,
0.0113222953,
-0.0011510629,
0.0282482319,
0.0074860435,
-0.0328837708,
-0.0146566685,
-0.012769538,
-0.0146890515,
-0.0700586066,
0.019051183,
0.0667398795,
0.0173557512,
-0.0002799244,
-0.0121910833,
-0.0341320895,
0.079078041,
-0.0656438842,
-0.0026236891,
0.000637287,
0.0031495402,
0.0597515032,
-0.0507780127,
0.0303335842,
0.0394058973,
-0.0153309898,
-0.0449251421,
-0.0453216285,
-0.0262976512,
-0.0141678052,
-0.0497787297,
0.064473398,
-0.0680486336,
0.0032762792,
-0.0158655457,
-0.0132224746,
-0.0010404431,
0.0060947882,
0.0089117587,
0.0052003474,
0.0184351094,
-0.024766637,
-0.0599130243,
-0.0465966128,
-0.0881542787,
-0.0008791399,
-0.0070346985,
0.0062626433,
0.0066279974,
0.0102327121,
0.0291168392,
0.0324092023,
0.0011290226,
0.0693059191,
-0.0255479813,
-0.0019730292,
0.0218485501,
-0.0657047853,
-0.0203795694,
-0.0609582625,
-0.0610774644,
-0.0679260418,
-0.0047449153,
-0.0045615821,
-0.0468745232,
-0.010059257,
0.0236746352,
0.0685570166,
-0.0146446386,
0.0248584747,
-0.0074958452,
-0.0028237074,
-0.000317999,
0.0175667927,
0.038914334,
-0.0087345,
0.027663298,
0.0312082823,
0.0233958606,
-0.0014195063,
0.0436237492,
0.0000919938,
0.0198454745,
0.0245921444,
0.0615997612,
0.0382873602,
-0.011362073,
-0.0063399822,
0.001680723,
0.0667168796,
0.0014583035,
0.0213430654,
0.0147501314,
0.0756016597,
-0.0046204627,
0.0500647239,
0.0003227646,
0.0333378166,
0.0654933602,
0.0562688671,
-0.0131488545,
0.0485137403,
-0.0525549017,
0.031102296,
0.0055198837,
0.009279429,
-0.0084670261,
-0.0589683652,
0.003222283,
0.0270247944,
0.0088459449,
0.0115651032,
-0.0248158034,
0.0125909122,
-0.0334908031,
0.0363972113,
-0.0183979888,
-0.0610699654,
-0.007845521,
-0.006558408,
0.0192245785,
-0.0180025361,
0.0264316816,
-0.0051028361,
-0.0200011339,
-0.0217279196,
0.0041564587,
0.0404314511,
0.0254057832,
-0.0124058537,
-0.0395276807,
-0.033352524,
-0.0315951668,
-0.0228251535,
0.018961316,
-0.0121484026,
-0.0033716157,
0.0088130822,
0.0838554427,
-0.0712004527,
-0.0274740998,
0.0114720194,
0.0697131008,
-0.0332116261,
0.0056331311,
-0.0160079654,
0.0249896143,
0.0578824617,
0.0047750459,
0.0143908802,
0.0190283898,
0.0091936355,
-0.0075803497,
0.0456904806,
-0.000208586,
0.0062243496,
0.0407302529,
-0.0868680403,
-0.0079206927,
-0.0091130976,
-0.0356075875,
-0.050871294,
-0.0452670604,
-0.0590229556,
-0.0345257148,
-0.0642920434,
-0.0281576328,
0.0218022838,
-0.0360306203,
-0.0200391486,
0.0549158603,
0.0443315059,
-0.0002187122,
0.0308553055,
-0.0169352219,
0.0631482825,
-0.0196654163,
0.0132751493,
-0.0170572866,
-0.028388733,
0.0235456061,
0.0544070825,
0.0272630677,
-0.0425407253,
-0.0224115066,
-0.082625322,
0.0090321722,
-0.0184409004,
0.0334735252,
0.051995948,
-0.0382517837,
0.0020754363,
-0.0165910795,
-0.0610164255,
-0.0506634228,
0.0177546125,
-0.0261254162,
0.0233441554,
0.0049300357,
0.029589206,
-0.0218260232,
-0.0171886068,
-0.0100648794,
0.011994984,
0.0604697801,
0.003705963,
-0.0349387676,
-0.0002862928,
-0.0086634625,
-0.0358335301,
0.0186880529,
0.0085088024,
-0.014853972,
0.0407627523,
-0.0185786672,
-0.0180057827,
0.0678707585,
-0.0304089002,
0.025235625,
0.0201322269,
-0.0249114968,
-0.0182369091,
-0.0048763817,
-0.0099718617,
0.0191498976,
-0.0500459224,
0.0409988314,
-0.0148667311,
0.0082752043,
0.003803334,
-0.0495728143,
0.0282422174,
-0.0037113305,
0.0150601398,
-0.0436609127,
-0.0263788588,
-0.0360976905,
0.0604858473,
0.0202605352,
-0.0407003984,
0.0449411646,
-0.0193119161,
0.0372730196,
-0.0781979039,
0.0275147874,
-0.0508351475,
0.0677513033,
0.0023466549,
0.0382597707,
-0.0332448147,
-0.0289224442,
-0.0211869795,
-0.0507549606,
0.0793071315,
-0.039760761,
0.10700991,
-0.0290718284,
0.0256452188,
-0.0439515375,
-0.0232188068,
0.0031324395,
-0.0256709643,
0.0066097924,
0.0566167049,
0.0020191767,
0.0329170227,
0.0192992669,
0.011438638,
0.0350942016,
0.0030405319,
-0.0055074203,
0.0025632121,
-0.0056105661,
0.0687794313,
0.0315410718,
-0.0060198186,
0.0197014492,
-0.0188683402,
-0.0202327631,
0.02967171,
-0.0141683286,
0.0286765359,
0.0651352033,
-0.0335012116,
-0.0182673987,
-0.0567034185,
-0.0048998725,
0.0288394,
0.0185591392,
-0.0439804047,
0.0489500873,
0.0672058985,
0.0306539722,
0.0111257602,
-0.0260682069,
-0.0080436189,
-0.0208604392,
0.0046811812,
0.0388061069,
-0.072334677,
0.034520302,
-0.0270876531,
0.0284360871,
-0.01397496,
0.0015588352,
-0.0200909078,
-0.0641418472,
0.0587512553,
0.011805092,
-0.0693249553,
-0.044270914,
-0.0139580974,
0.0173747893,
0.0081612598,
-0.0268007237,
0.0273447353,
-0.0303899758,
0.0081057595,
-0.0052356087,
-0.0625386089,
0.0767865703,
0.0318691507,
-0.0365956835,
-0.001965791,
0.052215375,
0.0411997177,
-0.0347872153,
0.0163604021,
0.0175811797,
-0.0835067108,
-0.026636621,
0.0336688124,
0.0170941558,
0.0119584594,
0.0379398614,
-0.0396032929,
0.0388487205,
0.0289080292,
-0.0230356827,
0.0706406757,
0.0346193388,
-0.0075817141,
-0.0121984109,
-0.0345856324,
0.0282910392,
-0.0445639528,
0.0700029954,
0.0489805155,
0.0487834103,
-0.0414685756,
-0.0456976555,
-0.0090527553,
-0.0931143537,
-0.0182367731,
-0.0477518737,
-0.0070760767,
0.0191773269,
-0.0601377785,
-0.0559386536,
-0.0167463161,
0.0094726188,
0.0135783618,
0.0307756513,
0.0072018867,
0.0126956627,
-0.0320938267,
-0.0140761202,
-0.0181433838,
-0.0199099388,
0.0182125997,
-0.0003482824,
0.0203225352,
-0.018904129,
-0.0245553814,
0.0251861494,
0.0159224682,
0.006134124,
-0.0376446806,
0.0109143294,
0.0151576456,
-0.0178572591,
-0.0233738218,
-0.0150231542,
0.0463349484,
0.0255326759,
0.0200467333,
0.0200638883,
0.0249427203,
-0.0036799379,
-0.0318148099,
-0.0130661111,
-0.0390919708,
0.0137894787,
-0.0240461547,
0.0362902954,
-0.0190681126,
-0.0266188607,
0.0421518758,
0.0754064173,
-0.0310420357,
0.0016654929,
-0.0058307471,
0.0081281532,
-0.0126329549,
-0.0536241904,
-0.0132644577,
-0.0183475036,
0.0108924536,
-0.0230758954,
-0.0386291631,
-0.0167293679,
0.0916233733,
-0.0303506851,
0.0167329572,
-0.0140329879,
0.0112922741,
0.0049399552,
-0.030581262,
-0.0494326204,
-0.0526134707,
-0.0244880319,
-0.0422296375,
-0.0371523872,
0.0462481081,
-0.0028951999,
0.0216141175,
0.0153268045,
-0.0218650363,
0.031774424,
0.0322303548,
-0.0488727875,
-0.0229774863,
-0.0681665838,
0.0344932936,
0.0209384896,
-0.001662408,
0.0518000685,
-0.0143202022,
-0.0171108674,
0.0092863441,
0.0283645019,
0.0052611572,
-0.0078322729,
0.0221076328,
0.0280651655,
-0.0000534654,
0.0035123108,
0.0341301151,
-0.038304694,
-0.0065780971,
-0.0110560786,
-0.0291620176,
-0.0247639678,
-0.0697729513,
-0.0698326528,
0.0212852228,
-0.0052905767,
-0.0544089191,
-0.0980160236,
-0.004022351,
-0.0322977602,
0.0490281917,
0.0305803325,
0.0191968195,
0.0402978361,
0.0324924551,
0.0214400087,
-0.0487540103,
-0.0392574258,
0.0429598056,
-0.0365336202,
0.0173558947,
-0.0126086259,
-5.66543645e-33,
-0.0467071235,
-0.0566649884,
-0.0202681106,
0.0379182994,
-0.0039538322,
-0.0481812507,
-0.0528231226,
-0.0012904493,
-0.0151535692,
0.0218822192,
-0.0102063827,
0.0269332882,
0.020732332,
-0.0127327284,
0.0083577484,
-0.0135795986,
-0.0010829625,
0.0063143806,
-0.0422821715,
0.0498178527,
-0.0098376535,
-0.0334808566,
0.0377233997,
-0.0664624795,
0.0533499867,
-0.0065343957,
-0.051534649,
-0.0517102517,
-0.0502026305,
0.0373157784,
0.0178793147,
0.0307706911,
0.03373513,
-0.0386232771,
-0.0052344096,
0.0266851392,
-0.0579191335,
-0.0002313888,
0.0701845437,
-0.0849019065,
-0.048189383,
-0.0431643762,
0.0298135802,
-0.0191235431,
-0.0170435626,
-0.0344777666,
0.047004208,
-0.0551741719,
-0.0108533567,
-0.0867165253,
-0.0384333842,
0.0345024168,
-0.0086889947,
0.0328928418,
0.0067102956,
0.0294355359,
0.0112789245,
0.0162827577,
-0.0182795674,
0.0134208668,
0.023797309,
-0.0102172317,
0.008910113,
-0.0709859729,
0.0029926132,
-0.001478269,
-0.0301593728,
-0.0256110672,
-0.0444059521,
0.0032619471,
-0.0438681319,
0.0262710918,
0.07765273,
0.0747851878,
0.050225649,
0.0440096371,
-0.0387064628,
0.0452569313,
-0.0084813647,
0.0563149899,
-0.0082849218,
-0.0706421882,
-0.0199227687,
-0.0062511065,
-0.0559165664,
-0.0203269199,
-0.0026739249,
-0.0208640974,
-0.0084446203,
-0.0080419956,
0.0204974748,
-0.0125268064,
-0.0126615698,
-0.0170218069,
0.0522529855,
0.0200211629,
-0.0145981004,
0.0285550263,
0.0021871557,
0.0228080675,
-0.0231581759,
0.0429214835,
0.0223222394,
0.0211984925,
0.0200240277,
-0.0207078159,
0.0348876081,
-0.0333696194,
-0.0453281663,
0.0229728688,
0.0191329606,
0.0266502202,
-0.0226460118,
-0.036533989,
-0.0311667398,
0.0471699312,
0.0453802571,
0.0191024281,
-0.0146587174,
-0.0183719099,
-0.0175937638,
-0.0324040912,
0.0113837151,
0.0069368663,
-0.0033924035,
0.0649090633,
0.0342686884,
0.0533252843,
0.0249419995,
0.0307551939,
0.0014411299,
0.0650394186,
2.325e-7,
0.1046499833,
0.0068745292,
0.0149609102,
0.0152528444,
-0.0341759548,
0.0056934417,
0.0393866003,
0.0340331905,
0.0552332252,
-0.0159514118,
0.0437459163,
-0.00828264,
0.0356041938,
0.0616085306,
-0.0774836242,
-0.0342568979,
-0.0685314909,
-0.0620297268,
-0.0255748555,
0.0408161245,
0.091791831,
0.0207467414,
-0.0153181041,
-0.0022968522,
-0.0257780626,
0.0082876803,
0.0355288163,
-0.0190890282,
-0.0396894291,
0.010704685,
0.0774887577,
-0.0562911741,
0.0108497757,
0.0302832089,
0.0023398667,
0.0159075204,
0.0187419262,
0.0373730473,
0.0380191803,
0.0066663721,
-0.0279658325,
-0.0613581687,
0.0381078348,
-0.0376642384,
0.0593449287,
-0.005678236,
0.0003489215,
0.0012883844,
-0.0676593482,
-0.0069423155,
-0.0127529474,
0.0127275912,
-0.0521121584,
-0.0102153551,
-0.000434526,
-0.0166396331,
0.052188538,
-0.0480103046,
-0.0176062416,
0.0670281127,
0.0171282105,
0.0024122449,
0.001477689,
-0.0213079639,
0.0155997109,
-0.0910238922,
0.0153244436,
1.815584086e-34,
0.0622048713,
-0.0248211976,
0.0034128739,
-0.0455802791,
0.0273091812,
0.0225778017,
0.0016931801,
-0.0024124202,
-0.0117773078,
-0.051723294,
0.0188589115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15013v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15013v1 | Updated Corpora and Benchmarks for Long-Form Speech Recognition | 2023-09-26T15:32:09 | 2023-09-26T15:32:09 | Jennifer Drexler Fox, Desh Raj, Natalie Delworth, Quinn McNamara, Corey Miller, Migüel Jetté | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | The vast majority of ASR research uses corpora in which both the training and
test data have been pre-segmented into utterances. In most real-word ASR
use-cases, however, test audio is not segmented, leading to a mismatch between
inference-time conditions and models trained on segmented utterances. In this
paper, we re-release three standard ASR corpora - TED-LIUM 3, Gigapeech, and
VoxPopuli-en - with updated transcription and alignments to enable their use
for long-form ASR research. We use these reconstituted corpora to study the
train-test mismatch problem for transducers and attention-based
encoder-decoders (AEDs), confirming that AEDs are more susceptible to this
issue. Finally, we benchmark a simple long-form training for these models,
showing its efficacy for model robustness under this domain shift. | [
-0.0446897373,
0.0582975,
0.0200479105,
0.0365523994,
0.0054061348,
-0.0108364029,
0.034598697,
-0.0239745714,
-0.0658911169,
-0.0045017544,
-0.0343158171,
-0.0422499068,
0.0748048648,
0.0301220473,
0.0402695052,
-0.0184807833,
0.0386310965,
-0.0445681177,
-0.0117947059,
-0.0163238421,
0.0238856673,
-0.0133189373,
-0.0522254594,
0.0413402282,
0.0214607455,
0.0191974044,
-0.0121959196,
0.0044265953,
0.0223588347,
-0.0323866419,
-0.0081644058,
0.0034817706,
0.034270715,
0.0279793162,
0.0000019457,
-0.0392231569,
-0.0200631414,
-0.0096769109,
-0.0979247019,
-0.0044621434,
-0.0087450519,
-0.0210033599,
-0.0007793718,
0.0442117676,
0.0099711837,
-0.0391168706,
0.0396010801,
0.0293241758,
-0.0014362715,
0.0700014234,
0.0025428196,
-0.01749002,
0.0124767516,
-0.0513134524,
-0.0271295477,
-0.0452293754,
-0.0197195057,
-0.0391758122,
-0.0034258466,
-0.0321573131,
-0.0394219905,
0.0324709713,
0.0200088192,
0.0187640954,
0.0385511741,
0.0036600735,
-0.0311511196,
-0.0265827253,
-0.0294973142,
0.0483796336,
0.0371777229,
-0.0191743728,
-0.0068283938,
0.0327650458,
-0.038834352,
-0.0204318166,
0.0199937411,
0.0185596384,
-0.0154037308,
0.0062017846,
0.0164838657,
0.0167403389,
0.0102968793,
-0.0408475623,
-0.0648343638,
0.0287945457,
0.0117000062,
-0.0738922581,
0.0519826636,
0.0063443407,
0.0119126858,
-0.0234389268,
0.0411897078,
-0.0110026738,
-0.0099072307,
-0.0273008607,
-0.0547779128,
-0.0628277957,
-0.0074528321,
-0.0130400918,
0.0105473343,
0.0393091515,
-0.0566426292,
-0.0069558625,
0.0017339118,
0.0835018158,
0.0142807011,
0.0264302213,
-0.0218402557,
0.0040162862,
0.0024056537,
0.0305662882,
-0.0440531969,
-0.0143245151,
-0.0237929635,
-0.0267065205,
-0.0332418047,
0.0283038542,
0.0019284639,
-0.0042781597,
0.0271531697,
-0.0218466017,
-0.0614555702,
0.0036258702,
0.0000515912,
0.0560079813,
0.0075583258,
0.0258947965,
0.0027497865,
-0.0623321533,
-0.0496360213,
0.0189562626,
0.0199929904,
-0.0361333452,
-0.0015339873,
0.0131631484,
-0.0039861272,
-0.0275704917,
-0.0163365658,
0.0256409422,
-0.0607465766,
-0.04235138,
0.0183298178,
-0.02201497,
0.047901269,
0.0180541277,
0.0100361845,
-0.0242889691,
-0.0078048049,
-0.015483493,
0.0473918952,
0.0728321373,
0.0183995347,
0.013084094,
0.0106341913,
-0.0231989864,
0.0329056419,
0.0362501778,
0.0488735437,
-0.0489985794,
-0.0228358246,
-0.0552504584,
-0.0050726417,
0.0596455447,
-0.0070605115,
-0.011798623,
-0.0113382144,
0.0101584541,
0.0245575663,
0.0487552509,
0.0788134187,
0.0356332585,
-0.0172208417,
-0.0496068113,
0.0344267748,
0.0131718535,
0.0243722815,
-0.010506792,
0.0050460096,
-0.0012751312,
-0.0166011881,
0.0015060883,
-0.0179592669,
-0.0146307088,
0.0127188331,
0.044890102,
0.0495585464,
0.0328478515,
-0.0067635179,
0.014356426,
-0.0202899761,
-0.0151833119,
0.0130374571,
0.0342199206,
0.0481411852,
0.0090799825,
-0.0544434004,
0.0558717549,
-0.0230375249,
-0.0434415862,
0.0065064142,
-0.0185671356,
-0.0150534632,
0.0230419934,
0.0174614824,
-0.0113096442,
-0.0322468132,
-0.0229799747,
-0.0070399931,
0.0431216545,
0.0131459795,
0.032341864,
0.0485071503,
-0.0717445612,
-0.0167103782,
0.0259094294,
-0.0070410832,
0.0394809805,
-0.0201602057,
0.0457882099,
0.0006548564,
-0.0735219419,
0.0279094018,
-0.0002695626,
-0.0104533322,
-0.0308885556,
-0.0208775625,
0.0305310581,
0.0749849603,
0.0270682927,
-0.0324392319,
0.0004733027,
0.0373060033,
-0.0178794358,
0.0388807096,
0.0360060371,
-0.0838191882,
-0.0612373389,
0.0318014659,
-0.0363130569,
-0.0210028701,
0.0605105944,
0.0251293201,
-0.0430251323,
0.0208612196,
-0.0523396209,
0.060353633,
-0.0161052272,
0.0878655985,
0.0525883175,
0.0275647808,
0.0239312146,
-0.0217988547,
0.006943366,
-0.0008642192,
-0.0248994902,
-0.0163690764,
-0.0006070543,
-0.0942096859,
-0.0076304283,
0.0459070168,
-0.042689357,
-0.0170393456,
0.0220425092,
-0.0309140142,
-0.006943577,
0.0064087682,
-0.0530633889,
-0.0166951604,
-0.0303060357,
0.0575171411,
-0.0392083302,
0.016195409,
-0.0129841063,
-0.0107066119,
-0.0000484041,
-0.0259828884,
-0.0122796316,
0.0032106068,
-0.0386773162,
-0.034504015,
-0.0256855637,
-0.009219599,
-0.0025111136,
-0.0024089192,
0.029727323,
-0.0279239602,
-0.0900625288,
-0.055303935,
0.0392526239,
0.0508158728,
0.0335411429,
-0.0198907554,
-0.0319579244,
-0.0007214957,
0.0312907062,
0.0389129594,
0.0542261675,
0.0052349884,
0.0025593131,
-0.0013385115,
0.0031650895,
-0.0311854426,
0.0159604959,
0.0297381822,
-0.0001247183,
-0.0360971242,
0.0045316331,
0.0051302859,
0.0426066965,
0.0183358993,
0.0376590304,
-0.0388142541,
-0.0540028773,
-0.0296184495,
-0.016859293,
0.0136604039,
-0.0346163735,
-0.0428244434,
-0.0237014089,
-0.0364591889,
-0.0059597888,
0.0362048335,
-0.0887840614,
-0.0708011091,
-0.0786297992,
-0.0215481073,
-0.0171605144,
-0.0082501899,
0.0076630823,
-0.0067023691,
0.0466533192,
-0.0593667775,
0.0063843173,
0.0484612547,
-0.0304532647,
-0.0285340585,
0.0692718849,
0.0060214903,
0.0217014421,
-0.0227027703,
-0.055580724,
-0.0255330633,
0.0229034387,
-0.009152065,
0.041427806,
0.0335694067,
-0.0364209078,
-0.0418975726,
0.017473368,
0.0098897712,
0.0752964839,
-0.0043979185,
0.0164736621,
-0.0268623326,
0.0448844209,
0.0411102697,
0.0348019116,
-0.0339696445,
-0.0424247459,
-0.005977896,
-0.0140630957,
0.0468895063,
0.0108200936,
-0.066394195,
-0.0162407961,
0.0446739122,
-0.0063570812,
0.0554440469,
0.026777098,
0.0534058437,
-0.0494613647,
-0.001969177,
0.0778516904,
0.0029961281,
-0.0183302741,
-0.0105016725,
0.0217660572,
0.0362699255,
0.0075344136,
-0.0339621641,
-0.0709583163,
-0.039857842,
0.0766239092,
0.0511370562,
0.0411317237,
0.033408206,
0.0119174877,
-0.0999521166,
0.0172047094,
0.0261610337,
-0.0814910904,
-0.0299230404,
-0.0553012677,
-0.0199200716,
-0.0336105824,
0.0878606588,
0.0196129493,
-0.0380687118,
-0.0152395768,
0.0542387776,
-0.0682873353,
-0.0897506848,
-0.0195953678,
-0.0398484617,
0.1035947204,
0.0874642134,
-0.0086925812,
-0.0151797934,
-0.0335906222,
0.0368009955,
0.0130524673,
0.0020444335,
0.0134466896,
0.0436484404,
-0.0038115822,
-0.0018523947,
0.039997343,
0.0328733996,
-0.0254250132,
0.031735491,
0.0266547631,
0.0241488032,
-0.034367606,
-0.0165039524,
0.017079765,
-0.0081979809,
0.0104740169,
0.0706898719,
0.0235269126,
-0.0087023182,
-0.0472388566,
0.0216326639,
0.0729236081,
-0.064891547,
0.0253276657,
0.0269953441,
-0.0301462039,
-0.0503277406,
-0.0166835394,
-0.0410996415,
0.0040744995,
0.0333445594,
0.0233749337,
-0.0327621698,
-0.0118746068,
-0.0071584643,
-0.0445786305,
0.0370656177,
-0.0051110857,
0.0468594804,
-0.0912176073,
-0.0254648663,
-0.0162167419,
-0.0300406888,
-0.0042881849,
0.0466416888,
-0.0780297369,
-0.0532157272,
0.0513487794,
-0.0445092991,
0.0142015396,
0.0524659865,
-0.0285042543,
-0.0125140846,
0.0852793157,
-0.0360563621,
-0.0330686532,
0.0634378642,
0.0428643376,
-0.0290166773,
-0.0148101496,
-0.004915332,
-0.0311899167,
0.0066328119,
-0.0286974888,
0.0176880043,
-0.0003883018,
-0.0514606088,
0.0010724755,
0.0477344878,
0.0624039508,
0.0098158261,
0.0156906564,
-0.0175139904,
0.063986145,
0.018737046,
0.0909638032,
-0.020626897,
-0.0542988479,
0.0360482968,
0.0234693382,
0.0204437617,
0.0739499554,
-0.0401282497,
-0.027217133,
-0.0179782007,
0.071329087,
0.026327854,
0.0126793999,
0.015821781,
0.0132410266,
-0.0160177909,
0.0110957585,
0.0405226089,
0.0504647084,
0.0121036172,
0.043019332,
0.0136779388,
0.0305439904,
0.0179768,
0.0231713112,
-0.0019684711,
0.0047924239,
-0.0186362434,
-0.0054044989,
-0.0100200232,
-0.0143944416,
0.0507081971,
0.0143459952,
0.0291192774,
-0.0407791175,
-0.0011396463,
-0.0478838384,
0.0059874225,
0.0279646087,
-0.0141509641,
-0.0066882921,
0.0328656882,
0.0496244282,
0.0214772224,
0.02483592,
-0.0392842442,
0.0266417991,
-0.0284491293,
-0.0363196693,
-0.0554573722,
-0.0324413814,
-0.030426126,
-0.0507292636,
0.0141859641,
-0.0574070103,
0.0491705015,
-0.0237294845,
0.0385599509,
0.0095924633,
0.0039902451,
0.0034996779,
-0.0302018151,
-0.0318315923,
0.0469887182,
-0.025449425,
-0.0290424339,
-0.0435955562,
-0.0289424583,
-6.82707356e-33,
-0.0210294612,
0.0455929637,
0.0145868985,
-0.0785426497,
-0.1005989462,
0.0396120027,
-0.0404568911,
-0.0118483538,
0.0105600506,
-0.0180896968,
-0.0043863929,
-0.0192615557,
0.0364169516,
0.0493255369,
-0.0061204638,
-0.0287496597,
0.0872416794,
-0.0010158549,
-0.0353047252,
-0.0426237248,
0.0208350122,
0.0199318267,
0.0177977905,
-0.0282209162,
-0.0223006494,
0.038336575,
0.0265430994,
-0.0335221365,
0.0151851475,
0.0634189546,
0.0210968982,
0.0326457769,
-0.0062426091,
-0.0545190163,
-0.008113239,
0.0524046831,
-0.1072586104,
0.038519118,
-0.0098842187,
0.0634670928,
0.003296809,
-0.0270029232,
0.0437617749,
0.0013445355,
-0.0306615159,
-0.0408713259,
0.0172447916,
-0.0292558819,
-0.0025887173,
-0.0147219012,
-0.0132189188,
0.0128146876,
-0.0282731354,
-0.0248052552,
0.0689747557,
0.0577473715,
-0.0107712541,
-0.0284427721,
-0.0691483095,
0.0159974173,
0.0448362529,
0.0597150065,
0.0308608543,
0.0343083553,
-0.0070452034,
0.0154535649,
0.0360076837,
-0.0418511443,
0.0200249869,
-0.0319863781,
0.0246441886,
0.0194701869,
-0.0188203454,
-0.011699398,
0.0447955206,
-0.0107051572,
-0.0201958418,
-0.0156714935,
-0.00666259,
0.0342061631,
0.0158756617,
0.0193170048,
-0.0704065561,
-0.0002780476,
-0.0288905967,
-0.0169376526,
-0.0238667279,
0.0098819472,
0.067667,
0.0033925532,
0.0417272002,
0.0283476133,
0.0846202299,
-0.0049734698,
0.0270862468,
-0.0010517983,
0.0136971828,
-0.0095968228,
-0.0051019494,
0.0258246828,
-0.0668028742,
-0.0016169706,
0.0594589673,
0.0426627323,
0.0164910499,
-0.0381917767,
0.0121282898,
0.0299234185,
-0.0714168847,
-0.0144283511,
-0.0096078739,
0.0201829281,
-0.0210136529,
0.0207191519,
0.0632484406,
0.0123283826,
0.0174411088,
0.0629909411,
-0.0325952917,
0.0135950372,
-0.0229605027,
-0.0023904978,
0.0318734013,
0.0252281744,
-0.017545063,
0.0133153452,
0.0376876257,
0.0068327812,
0.0137768984,
-0.0272187311,
-0.0046213521,
0.0046639731,
2.757e-7,
-0.0321005285,
0.0210917275,
0.0768240541,
-0.0276051592,
0.0105262799,
-0.0149910934,
-0.0286402963,
0.0428032838,
0.0012518088,
0.0283906106,
-0.0079779187,
-0.0087819807,
0.1087644994,
-0.0089479135,
-0.0814997926,
-0.0308830719,
-0.0373119004,
0.0467216745,
-0.0370092019,
-0.0020877691,
-0.0043782871,
0.0445952117,
-0.0302148946,
-0.0198276173,
0.0115478123,
-0.0273875296,
0.0094014434,
0.0011465605,
0.0030266598,
0.0047565284,
-0.0038927956,
-0.0323528983,
-0.0181010421,
0.0161076039,
-0.0344907753,
0.0120782955,
0.0021063881,
0.0008971326,
-0.031906575,
-0.0855364129,
-0.0128299352,
0.059416011,
-0.0438571237,
0.0079824375,
0.0374333076,
-0.015844591,
-0.0161928646,
-0.0144340387,
-0.0909629166,
0.0050631235,
-0.0031287514,
0.0194053408,
0.0327104963,
-0.0019326025,
0.0361136012,
0.0093365638,
-0.0380649343,
-0.0111424197,
0.0145430062,
0.0223918371,
-0.0532321967,
-0.0134791378,
-0.0191769041,
-0.0002678859,
0.0021165453,
-0.0393130928,
-0.0224589184,
2.279228215e-34,
0.0278136153,
-0.0195498019,
0.0255977064,
0.0140058799,
0.0268972144,
-0.0873597115,
0.0302727576,
0.0123902773,
-0.0335442349,
-0.049431175,
-0.0298137628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15004v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15004v1 | Automating question generation from educational text | 2023-09-26T15:18:44 | 2023-09-26T15:18:44 | Ayan Kumar Bhowmick, Ashish Jagmohan, Aditya Vempaty, Prasenjit Dey, Leigh Hall, Jeremy Hartman, Ravi Kokku, Hema Maheshwari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The use of question-based activities (QBAs) is wide-spread in education,
traditionally forming an integral part of the learning and assessment process.
In this paper, we design and evaluate an automated question generation tool for
formative and summative assessment in schools. We present an expert survey of
one hundred and four teachers, demonstrating the need for automated generation
of QBAs, as a tool that can significantly reduce the workload of teachers and
facilitate personalized learning experiences. Leveraging the recent
advancements in generative AI, we then present a modular framework employing
transformer based language models for automatic generation of multiple-choice
questions (MCQs) from textual content. The presented solution, with distinct
modules for question generation, correct answer prediction, and distractor
formulation, enables us to evaluate different language models and generation
techniques. Finally, we perform an extensive quantitative and qualitative
evaluation, demonstrating trade-offs in the use of different techniques and
models. | [
0.0402579308,
-0.0024890017,
-0.0352752283,
0.0019121035,
-0.050913211,
-0.0070030168,
0.0522422343,
-0.0260060579,
0.0190444812,
-0.0371894203,
0.0467534475,
-0.0242724344,
-0.0407613292,
0.0119251348,
0.0157175511,
-0.0535093918,
-0.0066557806,
-0.0138551844,
-0.0219396167,
0.0262542423,
-0.0262586996,
0.0164056923,
-0.0123919984,
0.0170615707,
-0.0073930291,
-0.0158867929,
-0.0543058962,
-0.0335731506,
0.0228454955,
-0.0168651287,
0.0488774702,
0.0696232989,
-0.0095495144,
-0.0107852919,
0.0000020243,
-0.0577427745,
-0.0459007807,
-0.0058442131,
0.0074792355,
-0.0222978927,
0.0196731798,
0.0558398031,
0.0296427645,
0.0434436053,
-0.0749062672,
0.0017239855,
0.0221587792,
0.0027114917,
0.0786601529,
0.0404792167,
-0.009717783,
-0.0044072634,
0.0508795641,
0.0257240795,
0.0554990917,
0.0037549413,
-0.0065151351,
0.0491312109,
0.0244995691,
0.0269727446,
-0.026633963,
0.0234414693,
0.0375680439,
-0.0281592906,
0.0094512133,
0.0096554821,
-0.0072297319,
-0.0261425208,
-0.0148662105,
0.055185724,
0.0154763339,
-0.0186643694,
0.0055426634,
-0.0106995311,
0.0332199894,
0.0594915636,
-0.0448319465,
0.0479619056,
-0.0296664629,
-0.037167009,
0.0287503041,
-0.0115634259,
-0.0511364676,
0.0068994863,
-0.0215136204,
-0.0148267522,
0.0409862958,
-0.0386866257,
-0.0315858163,
0.039463304,
-0.0036911876,
-0.0723413751,
0.0310401991,
0.0734410286,
-0.0270061605,
0.0109542068,
-0.0584578998,
-0.0761054829,
0.0218479298,
0.0007439331,
-0.0059454809,
0.0530825257,
0.0024264797,
-0.0003331048,
0.0004379473,
0.0864285901,
0.017351592,
0.0203422792,
-0.0692814589,
0.0180998314,
-0.0178499855,
-0.0239479411,
-0.040848393,
0.0499850325,
-0.0237984154,
0.0099359136,
-0.0242749956,
0.0254089311,
0.0023638152,
0.0334039629,
0.0340390578,
0.0300219022,
-0.0227037836,
0.0119436001,
-0.0202036984,
0.0302916765,
-0.0330838896,
-0.0161690973,
0.0217770673,
-0.0239655562,
0.0100658238,
0.0441458635,
0.0398354195,
-0.0165978707,
0.0077348156,
0.0347172357,
-0.0482855327,
-0.0399386585,
0.0188884139,
-0.0401754454,
0.0028743485,
-0.0301565658,
0.0038736388,
-0.0699344799,
0.0148521354,
0.0376992114,
-0.0325627998,
-0.0053854594,
0.0362178013,
0.0542169064,
0.0434885994,
0.0064894832,
0.0262574386,
0.0023743762,
0.0697938055,
-0.0038550077,
0.0429482646,
0.0091482205,
0.0560469106,
0.0249195267,
0.0299632046,
-0.0380627885,
0.0526803359,
0.0126814255,
-0.0216573831,
-0.0198530406,
0.0140183084,
0.013381457,
0.0119695198,
0.0029102021,
-0.0679211989,
0.0923381448,
0.0251932796,
0.0449241549,
0.0340848789,
0.0175843239,
-0.003333237,
0.0318746082,
0.0576792285,
0.0357895307,
0.0188587122,
0.0259394664,
-0.0212513413,
0.0421426855,
-0.0095819188,
0.0048396359,
0.0071362671,
0.0555243604,
0.0068009514,
-0.0823260471,
0.0107400725,
0.0046943575,
0.0147492904,
0.0554143116,
0.0397875234,
0.0077996198,
-0.0686775371,
0.0341659449,
-0.0219702274,
-0.0835113674,
0.0205997135,
-0.0660552457,
0.0749895349,
0.0322815701,
0.0699035674,
-0.0194090381,
-0.0596861206,
-0.0148046566,
-0.0199960377,
0.0351159796,
0.0238909349,
-0.0208102353,
-0.0368259288,
-0.0619329289,
0.0044496013,
-0.0292750224,
-0.001911642,
-0.0027255137,
0.0097753871,
-0.0120490408,
0.0329759046,
-0.0261752158,
-0.0345739163,
0.0668239519,
-0.0425712168,
-0.077355586,
0.0092892312,
0.0122999689,
-0.0332064517,
0.011836282,
-0.0033594156,
0.0228253696,
0.0283881985,
-0.0184897855,
-0.0130056357,
-0.0048569269,
-0.0440040193,
-0.0211244784,
0.0480154604,
-0.0363794453,
0.0219916478,
0.0112494295,
-0.0145528307,
-0.0441599712,
0.0077942219,
-0.0312342215,
-0.0225748103,
-0.0277098659,
0.0325130932,
-0.0028760345,
-0.0241992753,
-0.0429148637,
0.0666334778,
0.0445291363,
0.0320521779,
0.0127894189,
0.0357785448,
0.047946211,
0.0007876583,
-0.0355878398,
-0.0149422633,
-0.0470490344,
0.0184246693,
0.0219482388,
0.0487931445,
-0.0572379045,
-0.0455538891,
-0.0561761446,
0.0255067665,
-0.0115144094,
0.0141290138,
0.0326076746,
0.0285301115,
-0.0071188319,
0.0167346764,
-0.0826718807,
-0.0195706766,
0.0440848097,
-0.0356739871,
0.0218407623,
-0.0207736585,
0.030040957,
-0.0305499267,
0.0012202605,
-0.0478417873,
0.0216132887,
0.0842900053,
0.0537122823,
-0.0281985756,
0.0299938358,
-0.0112777948,
-0.0102794468,
0.0388633125,
-0.0135753453,
0.0153829269,
-0.0564116761,
0.0935042202,
0.0472659096,
0.0320174508,
0.0231690537,
0.0276747495,
-0.021107465,
-0.0423572585,
0.0388395898,
-0.0254856199,
-0.0028816136,
0.028346248,
-0.0723599643,
0.009125676,
0.048070617,
0.0606582016,
-0.0407016203,
-0.0287981238,
0.0612558238,
-0.0283717364,
0.0199264977,
-0.0409215875,
0.0035339089,
-0.0231286883,
0.0445840508,
0.006260091,
0.0035401592,
0.0722630098,
0.0043592262,
-0.0174379144,
-0.0756128356,
0.027885709,
-0.0398045927,
0.0439665243,
0.0262058359,
0.012724665,
0.0260398462,
0.0050828764,
-0.0866908357,
0.0228382293,
0.0162295327,
-0.0464276411,
0.0394045413,
-0.0668976009,
-0.038353432,
0.0191593096,
-0.0081463689,
-0.0727798939,
0.0048605795,
0.0330667198,
-0.0019157644,
0.0202371273,
-0.0021836923,
-0.0169430785,
-0.0033565664,
0.0180410426,
0.0410658643,
-0.059537258,
-0.030925557,
-0.0190194566,
0.1152468026,
0.0700822398,
0.0094507746,
0.0080215195,
-0.0163185857,
0.0402608402,
0.0384705365,
0.0137562184,
0.015013434,
0.030973943,
-0.0002017027,
0.0245304555,
-0.0564600751,
0.0313626342,
0.0436143726,
0.0480675586,
-0.0537969992,
-0.0582275763,
0.0801865458,
0.0674495921,
0.0018639459,
-0.0240863413,
-0.0340208113,
-0.0291229282,
0.0107484404,
0.0646991059,
-0.0658230707,
0.0128572499,
-0.0401845649,
0.0208880194,
-0.0340026319,
-0.0112177748,
0.0073435176,
-0.0895613432,
0.0408524685,
-0.0306656305,
-0.0329428054,
0.0252577141,
-0.013900605,
-0.0473034009,
0.0104120197,
-0.0163284279,
0.0066711619,
0.0207842682,
0.0279339291,
0.0312106963,
0.0039991671,
-0.0086831367,
-0.0133967511,
0.0122029716,
-0.0167478025,
0.0341655724,
0.0095629906,
-0.0334626399,
-0.0559649169,
-0.0163969938,
-0.0485322103,
-0.0429869257,
0.0171788353,
0.0063007222,
0.0126112122,
-0.0038900182,
-0.0534575209,
0.0563926212,
-0.0053675771,
-0.0028199214,
0.1018822044,
0.0470082462,
-0.0021022668,
-0.0363738909,
-0.0191885456,
0.0266904403,
0.0203705058,
0.0502900891,
0.0230980422,
-0.0665735453,
0.016072128,
-0.0496042483,
0.0322390497,
-0.1126898378,
-0.0413669311,
0.0007445313,
0.014249146,
0.020229239,
-0.0667320043,
-0.0184712093,
0.0745522082,
-0.0010367977,
0.0075213159,
-0.0491461083,
0.0276841447,
0.0030407747,
-0.044374913,
-0.0324690491,
0.0195410457,
-0.0164183658,
-0.0253818724,
-0.0447643325,
-0.0038259535,
-0.0498111136,
-0.0285759754,
0.0251287557,
-0.0994742811,
-0.0425772332,
0.0111033749,
0.0682569444,
0.0092235534,
-0.0468085669,
-0.0039693736,
0.0312863216,
-0.007018656,
-0.0083218431,
-0.007766474,
-0.0168957207,
-0.069399409,
-0.0089729885,
-0.0123893023,
-0.0250886902,
-0.0151019767,
0.0126837445,
-0.0153396139,
0.0458230823,
-0.0269102603,
-0.0287806466,
0.0524423346,
0.0423346348,
-0.0229253303,
-0.0404543318,
-0.0062152836,
-0.0131138051,
-0.0046520564,
-0.0584260002,
-0.0479204655,
-0.0228688978,
0.000232027,
0.0062487922,
0.0066572665,
0.0132127553,
-0.0103688361,
-0.0539837368,
0.0427326933,
-0.0087424321,
0.0527574457,
-0.0014014009,
0.0217065793,
0.0234646499,
-0.0266694557,
-0.0233331714,
-0.0243849922,
0.0177570041,
0.0769159347,
0.0242461227,
0.0927634537,
-0.0227840599,
0.0013689748,
0.0160097219,
0.0115559539,
-0.0130017027,
-0.0323530696,
-0.0366370268,
0.040106032,
-0.0327704698,
0.0129207587,
-0.0321685858,
-0.0058759963,
0.0097202277,
0.0128778303,
0.0274258852,
0.0384038426,
-0.0254023168,
0.0195485167,
0.0059272987,
0.0381210409,
-0.0313135907,
0.0355168395,
-0.0200417843,
-0.0012038302,
0.0213452615,
-0.0005210454,
-0.072495535,
-0.0211747997,
-0.0103181871,
0.0104480591,
0.0110717509,
0.0127721559,
-0.0481911674,
-0.0248091556,
0.003890553,
0.0441433005,
0.0334304497,
-0.0241802242,
0.0113913054,
0.0566426776,
-0.0303182881,
-0.0160420313,
-0.0474360026,
0.0769950151,
-0.0771989226,
-0.0452389941,
-0.0407302342,
-5.867626622e-33,
-0.0368982442,
-0.0751278773,
0.0443256982,
0.0052806623,
0.0031832405,
-0.0355523005,
-0.0395274945,
0.0289674662,
0.0014529828,
-0.0272663832,
-0.0014148215,
-0.0200804956,
-0.013766258,
0.0686901286,
0.0104247713,
-0.0153445611,
0.0220659804,
-0.0188069027,
-0.0295499377,
0.025094578,
0.0133173559,
-0.0129969055,
0.0191647001,
0.0021902171,
0.0325283669,
-0.0764602572,
-0.0031450468,
-0.0012541669,
-0.0311872996,
0.0386040062,
-0.020240413,
0.0186656639,
0.0281207897,
-0.0288027134,
0.0228865314,
0.0453439578,
-0.0344065391,
-0.0538929887,
-0.0058556781,
-0.018427467,
-0.0419509113,
-0.0593909211,
0.0207128394,
-0.0240719877,
0.0075058886,
0.0049266233,
0.0622815527,
0.0020801891,
0.0136772944,
-0.044736404,
-0.0828855261,
-0.0159271099,
-0.0542735867,
-0.031379275,
-0.0651419014,
0.1083592772,
0.0089376327,
-0.0010997145,
-0.0230805762,
0.0443940386,
0.0543194488,
0.0058574118,
0.0371228196,
0.0224338416,
-0.0399292894,
0.0134931933,
-0.0031310639,
-0.0136924246,
-0.0144766467,
0.0160357766,
-0.0065701511,
0.0272153374,
0.0892619491,
0.0492202528,
0.0036016598,
0.0123825148,
-0.0379360914,
0.0881303251,
0.0182300918,
-0.0122214714,
0.0085477158,
-0.0770519525,
-0.0125981709,
0.0003483379,
-0.0321880057,
0.0175742228,
-0.0349734947,
-0.0183277745,
0.0438271239,
-0.0494718291,
-0.0471089035,
-0.0139010651,
0.0075510428,
-0.0053111794,
0.0365066268,
-0.00009009,
-0.0363313705,
0.0320919678,
-0.0561561584,
0.0282486677,
-0.0078965351,
0.000284613,
0.0298399553,
0.0093191285,
-0.0116944993,
0.038801983,
-0.0242248476,
-0.0232178941,
-0.04608481,
-0.0062359381,
-0.0249277838,
0.0369860977,
0.0212319158,
0.0248518102,
-0.0106206536,
0.0357742012,
-0.0173129216,
0.0068865698,
0.011676467,
-0.0328358747,
-0.0476826094,
-0.0245057307,
0.031990923,
-0.002101931,
-0.0263294913,
-0.0079611307,
-0.0474646464,
0.0265412685,
0.0031240596,
-0.0417246148,
0.002155144,
-0.0000854825,
2.617e-7,
0.0367454067,
0.0432748273,
-0.0072888522,
0.0088627553,
-0.0269487742,
0.0069706915,
0.0576218367,
-0.0194726046,
0.0627257079,
0.0438474938,
0.0034775222,
0.006317718,
0.0039168247,
0.0334507935,
-0.05923675,
-0.0216208752,
0.0061617154,
-0.0142033864,
-0.0385146663,
0.0350442193,
0.1188790649,
0.0130946515,
-0.0150477048,
-0.0000438997,
-0.0296769738,
0.0096486369,
0.0085815778,
0.0272485949,
-0.0233289544,
0.0513980202,
0.0017190649,
-0.0015486836,
-0.0041392287,
0.0334412642,
-0.0159992836,
-0.0106389085,
0.0214083549,
0.0266372561,
0.0465174168,
-0.0206192005,
0.0109141152,
0.0040325131,
0.0219434313,
-0.0789083019,
0.0648998842,
-0.0614615753,
0.020431187,
0.0211415701,
-0.0601719618,
-0.0049649836,
-0.0320977159,
-0.0388241932,
-0.0083054751,
0.02125163,
-0.0057442333,
-0.0136889787,
0.0421912186,
0.0193114318,
-0.0093591101,
-0.0063201212,
-0.0115011074,
-0.0346010476,
-0.049608402,
-0.0563670583,
-0.012088134,
-0.0197096709,
0.0106972679,
2.096727666e-34,
0.0102186361,
0.0151012847,
0.0144039597,
-0.020198388,
0.0220667664,
-0.0046053482,
0.0072933091,
0.0207864549,
0.0133547597,
-0.094875291,
-0.0366514921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14966v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14966v1 | Interactively Learning Social Media Representations Improves News Source Factuality Detection | 2023-09-26T14:36:19 | 2023-09-26T14:36:19 | Nikhil Mehta, Dan Goldwasser | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI | The rise of social media has enabled the widespread propagation of fake news,
text that is published with an intent to spread misinformation and sway
beliefs. Rapidly detecting fake news, especially as new events arise, is
important to prevent misinformation.
While prior works have tackled this problem using supervised learning
systems, automatedly modeling the complexities of the social media landscape
that enables the spread of fake news is challenging. On the contrary, having
humans fact check all news is not scalable. Thus, in this paper, we propose to
approach this problem interactively, where humans can interact to help an
automated system learn a better social media representation quality. On real
world events, our experiments show performance improvements in detecting
factuality of news sources, even after few human interactions. | [
0.0363024883,
0.0199366454,
0.0065341885,
0.0288828406,
-0.0217486434,
0.0041520917,
-0.0008339114,
-0.0028951594,
0.0486919358,
-0.0380173475,
0.0285841096,
-0.0255706832,
0.0075391489,
0.0625092685,
-0.0111552356,
-0.0586668178,
0.0679958984,
0.0237252247,
0.0229783766,
-0.0050576399,
0.030161066,
0.0292319246,
-0.0380416922,
-0.0012328962,
-0.0716184229,
-0.0101651894,
-0.0113656828,
0.0097496929,
0.0226538908,
-0.0031098702,
-0.0080027953,
0.0581752546,
0.0354237668,
0.0739280879,
0.0000016869,
0.0036828385,
0.0128918644,
-0.0257083382,
-0.0550998338,
0.0010782582,
0.0509073362,
-0.0621786453,
-0.0128124934,
0.0082761338,
-0.0508590303,
0.0119143864,
0.0213151835,
0.0516409278,
0.1078308895,
0.075634338,
-0.0036915431,
0.0267155673,
0.0026835569,
0.0131244147,
0.0096927537,
-0.0239822231,
0.0315204486,
0.0074219373,
-0.0324317254,
0.0102060195,
0.0324576795,
0.014072923,
0.0338559896,
-0.0301056895,
0.0004271439,
0.0106875729,
-0.0339328907,
-0.0217975639,
-0.0044817845,
0.0523276627,
-0.051394932,
-0.0424128287,
0.0177966114,
-0.0256944224,
0.0120416861,
0.0468240045,
-0.0062485836,
-0.0076151136,
-0.0534303449,
0.02189916,
-0.0437487997,
-0.0200425629,
0.0140402215,
0.0628902167,
0.041460719,
0.0412817076,
-0.0412845798,
-0.007991232,
0.002232699,
0.0401607305,
-0.0059608389,
-0.0027656925,
0.025298696,
-0.0118182991,
-0.0506970771,
-0.0091658989,
-0.0604136735,
-0.0183296688,
0.0277090799,
-0.1100579053,
-0.0031601824,
-0.0234849006,
0.0008529417,
0.0738466531,
0.0171099603,
-0.0180067066,
-0.0241249483,
-0.0003934414,
0.0253633782,
0.022023188,
-0.0158565957,
0.0497931652,
-0.0087261889,
0.0048453938,
-0.0090983259,
0.0043230075,
-0.0304643791,
-0.0084965862,
-0.0194835849,
0.0409427024,
-0.0397525653,
0.04451745,
-0.0576174557,
-0.0043318379,
-0.0298539978,
0.022807302,
-0.0259764045,
0.0319872014,
-0.0312395021,
-0.0298775509,
-0.0056764171,
0.022646198,
0.0334914811,
0.0350774899,
-0.022823656,
-0.0331710167,
-0.0176961869,
0.0092369029,
-0.070720695,
-0.0346378684,
0.0240134783,
-0.0217828061,
0.0125198532,
-0.0565801896,
0.0315284953,
-0.0397429876,
-0.0312912166,
-0.0181519967,
-0.0128530981,
0.0317206196,
-0.0306650624,
0.0776589811,
-0.016674187,
-0.0049426914,
0.061167784,
0.0161968023,
-0.0112733012,
0.0921551809,
-0.0093626715,
0.1160555556,
0.0796292722,
0.0207886528,
0.0407503992,
-0.0007666665,
0.0658666939,
0.0345200822,
0.0381449126,
-0.0365469046,
-0.0521978922,
0.0180087816,
0.001271231,
0.0000634159,
0.0013311795,
-0.0285903551,
0.0975546539,
-0.0289465357,
-0.0244992971,
-0.0191594139,
0.0636619851,
0.0393342227,
0.0121090924,
0.016641777,
-0.0540233664,
0.0436144844,
-0.0401449688,
-0.0154234394,
-0.0266016629,
0.0571593158,
-0.023944499,
-0.013905271,
0.0136566749,
-0.0158511531,
0.016820075,
-0.0028199425,
-0.0182886291,
0.0116517935,
-0.0298956148,
0.0164083429,
0.0426806845,
-0.0270685125,
0.0348565802,
-0.0335174873,
0.0446960665,
0.0442823023,
0.0109142456,
-0.0125632789,
0.033671543,
-0.0337025113,
0.059483204,
0.0553511642,
0.0420448482,
-0.0488914251,
-0.0227101538,
0.005731618,
-0.0111379027,
0.0307270046,
0.0246122368,
0.0001127657,
0.0662766024,
-0.0050909482,
-0.0031360451,
0.0132158995,
-0.0353618078,
0.0192363337,
0.007606437,
-0.0077516083,
-0.0109891575,
0.0429925732,
0.0121238614,
0.0353687815,
0.0320402384,
-0.0390248522,
0.0196395312,
0.0418832451,
-0.0619494282,
-0.031434454,
-0.0039803702,
0.004638196,
0.02792833,
-0.0399349555,
-0.0523866788,
0.0448530503,
-0.0588740334,
0.0306105558,
0.0281371716,
-0.0390856937,
-0.017336661,
-0.0204454251,
-0.0427144058,
-0.0350496471,
-0.0028945617,
0.033950936,
0.0892495215,
-0.0285970084,
-0.0284559969,
0.0027933996,
-0.0135117462,
0.0033734238,
-0.0261209942,
0.0402517058,
-0.0512884259,
0.0054958854,
0.0327803716,
0.0250309408,
-0.0497573614,
-0.0566689596,
0.0180220474,
-0.056059055,
-0.0283761956,
-0.0265642591,
-0.0302388147,
0.0411122553,
0.0069076018,
-0.0030250014,
-0.0363042466,
-0.0237975959,
-0.0107654035,
-0.0064513008,
0.0360365398,
0.0112335011,
-0.0153109068,
0.0206033215,
-0.0474793278,
0.0241717435,
-0.0166825559,
0.0353548937,
0.0751402602,
-0.052940093,
-0.0299583692,
-0.0417899787,
-0.0326543786,
0.0409568138,
-0.0032396168,
-0.0064994083,
0.0095312623,
0.0222973768,
-0.0345173664,
0.0707468465,
0.0603320077,
0.0725741759,
0.0323796049,
0.0761191472,
-0.0316720679,
-0.0033669902,
-0.0611105226,
0.0444464944,
-0.0205227714,
-0.0289900508,
0.0239133853,
0.0122262957,
0.025419889,
0.0148056373,
-0.0105879074,
0.0604294427,
-0.0216358453,
-0.023302827,
-0.0122152809,
-0.0421296917,
-0.0063037742,
0.0167855155,
-0.0514184088,
-0.0316636115,
0.0824534819,
0.0031326923,
0.0551549718,
-0.0223744549,
-0.0281067472,
0.00235459,
-0.0187458098,
-0.0061683315,
0.0176493619,
-0.0102194427,
0.0023259108,
-0.0033239766,
-0.0068542236,
0.1033312231,
-0.0331097953,
0.0110460911,
-0.0231247824,
0.0228174701,
0.0409390591,
-0.0425849184,
-0.0467562005,
-0.1074755266,
-0.0000569132,
-0.0294414423,
-0.0418148711,
-0.0348968431,
-0.0644339845,
-0.0591697283,
0.056355834,
0.0169031359,
-0.0015069469,
-0.0247752164,
0.0087794727,
0.0199671015,
0.0212216191,
0.0161630213,
0.0202709604,
-0.0196757279,
-0.0103044668,
0.0597669259,
0.0175272655,
-0.0051093106,
-0.0646595061,
-0.0183519069,
-0.0207763389,
-0.0247903988,
0.0215428658,
-0.0149911782,
0.0227366276,
-0.0162806176,
0.0187792685,
0.0658718869,
0.0265038908,
-0.0310198683,
0.012507691,
0.035190396,
-0.0320723429,
0.022367863,
0.014423158,
-0.0661960021,
0.0147625171,
-0.0254973508,
0.0249758493,
-0.0120422682,
-0.0295431279,
-0.0054468317,
-0.0895407349,
0.0250511542,
-0.0083248708,
0.0142795332,
-0.0488831252,
-0.1018301249,
0.0089674359,
-0.0420607999,
0.0021453525,
-0.0081724962,
0.0231111702,
-0.003961042,
-0.0173721835,
0.0038970562,
-0.0408816598,
-0.0131219123,
-0.02306729,
0.0094208512,
0.0180312209,
0.0332706049,
0.008120344,
-0.045215372,
-0.0089347297,
0.0378595106,
-0.0131883929,
-0.0226857439,
0.1082506776,
-0.0226581432,
0.0013204975,
-0.0621591732,
0.0590733849,
0.0350965969,
-0.0208277032,
-0.0142759541,
0.0461603925,
0.0190729648,
-0.043227125,
-0.0334872752,
0.0096087744,
0.0727133527,
0.0267581698,
0.0304696858,
-0.033293888,
0.0118256295,
-0.028074149,
0.0049448344,
-0.0328333005,
-0.0690390617,
0.0278821513,
-0.0340978317,
-0.0601425283,
-0.0680094361,
0.0009731172,
-0.0155636882,
0.0268462263,
-0.0463786013,
-0.0531978905,
0.0563607663,
-0.0141631104,
-0.0177471992,
0.0287115369,
-0.0149614299,
0.0484985635,
0.0172570571,
-0.0259291623,
0.0010323323,
-0.0262811352,
-0.0060928199,
0.0154020181,
-0.0786550418,
-0.0479660146,
0.0089310855,
0.0237964168,
0.0264915191,
0.0592615306,
-0.0445919558,
-0.0341356508,
0.0394406728,
0.0383311622,
-0.0605805442,
0.0027167038,
0.0117777763,
-0.00482305,
0.022543814,
0.0220995285,
-0.0109408144,
0.0340743512,
-0.00428255,
-0.0531201586,
-0.0986582637,
0.0041566631,
0.0185573939,
0.0205393936,
0.0459236689,
-0.0005873763,
-0.0291906949,
-0.0253515895,
-0.0392326564,
0.0122578694,
-0.0537275337,
0.0147938114,
0.0332691148,
0.0014368306,
-0.0127954809,
0.0020951326,
0.0150429392,
-0.0051895012,
0.0127679855,
-0.0574275889,
-0.0520678386,
0.0065525174,
0.0274442639,
0.0082400199,
0.0044335285,
-0.0370581523,
0.0306831095,
0.002015864,
0.0177435093,
0.0042090253,
0.0046475651,
0.0107493931,
0.0085345553,
-0.0087116286,
-0.0202515926,
-0.053789515,
0.0040510488,
-0.0501930341,
0.066055052,
0.04813537,
-0.0098933643,
0.0220418498,
-0.001162292,
-0.0276850648,
0.0320025086,
-0.0261843316,
0.0115919635,
-0.0523411855,
-0.0130000357,
0.0278617945,
-0.0057063987,
0.0445929766,
0.0597822778,
-0.0190699287,
0.0379988141,
0.0062256078,
-0.0649061203,
-0.0433763415,
-0.00464564,
-0.0318958759,
0.0340802893,
-0.0098618083,
0.0256584045,
-0.0447837487,
-0.0447182395,
0.0239552688,
0.00403743,
0.0215570517,
0.0109452419,
-0.0017743844,
0.0776245743,
0.0251651853,
0.0220667738,
-0.0312927924,
0.0204893015,
-0.005489415,
-0.0481862426,
0.0001376127,
-6.265391502e-33,
0.000088898,
-0.072128363,
-0.0517615266,
0.0166375376,
0.0132578313,
0.0222495459,
-0.002211543,
-0.0124388244,
-0.0453690775,
0.0432680286,
0.0235634372,
0.0511436164,
-0.0016049268,
-0.0041524181,
-0.0477667414,
-0.0068735448,
0.0442230888,
-0.0181162283,
-0.0535563938,
0.0254517794,
0.039136406,
-0.0310876928,
-0.0367007963,
-0.0815286785,
0.0023370858,
-0.0109586818,
-0.0377181172,
0.0275656078,
-0.0084292833,
0.0479523577,
0.0081673404,
0.0332220867,
0.0418115556,
-0.0288380217,
0.0043476378,
0.0589333735,
-0.0554433353,
-0.0172396954,
0.020866489,
0.0013415661,
-0.0445874929,
0.04299891,
0.0135360966,
0.0054529151,
-0.001986685,
0.001603241,
0.0290700365,
-0.008491612,
0.0083897738,
0.0113792205,
-0.04471609,
0.0039826771,
0.0034518728,
-0.0008210975,
-0.0042130803,
0.035264343,
0.0435286239,
-0.0003445818,
-0.0932937041,
0.0263933092,
-0.051903557,
0.0071064029,
0.0284399185,
-0.0498678535,
-0.0441961437,
0.0396470577,
-0.0065894737,
0.0423127487,
-0.0703842118,
0.0058788899,
-0.0011331688,
0.041026134,
0.0715844333,
0.1211109161,
0.0155358845,
-0.0683526024,
-0.0702777728,
0.0478890762,
0.0732068345,
0.0153185306,
-0.0246684626,
-0.0155407134,
-0.0027246666,
0.0225888584,
-0.0177672971,
0.0097253621,
-0.0491547436,
-0.0249427129,
-0.0414799489,
0.0591530986,
-0.0552411713,
0.0338514373,
-0.0255004149,
-0.0254948474,
-0.0032847689,
0.0359037183,
0.0073256241,
0.0248701144,
0.0079075675,
-0.0055097793,
-0.0269197859,
-0.0049088495,
-0.0160437785,
0.0107484385,
-0.0013311548,
-0.0064586978,
0.0732511058,
0.0275582504,
-0.0191847458,
0.0382300578,
-0.0210479312,
0.0464177616,
-0.0053477152,
-0.0220154952,
0.0301592462,
-0.0208446793,
-0.0291523114,
-0.0093159825,
-0.0122324312,
0.0258790087,
0.0187307373,
-0.0290751681,
-0.0235180277,
0.0197537877,
-0.0245760009,
-0.0300357565,
-0.0593217574,
0.0081908898,
-0.0004906029,
-0.1002763957,
-0.0096163461,
-0.0195280686,
2.516e-7,
-0.0362136476,
0.0467554182,
0.0235610027,
0.0249022711,
0.0265009385,
0.0412132517,
0.0270677526,
0.0110059837,
-0.0522364974,
-0.1280241907,
-0.0244652759,
0.0537839271,
0.023910366,
0.0454682,
-0.0445067622,
-0.0272901766,
-0.0439947993,
0.009707775,
-0.0430571213,
-0.0173688009,
-0.0166056585,
0.0179637112,
0.0593629591,
-0.0398335643,
0.0244356561,
-0.0352993235,
0.0475837104,
0.0684195235,
-0.0390868895,
-0.0134419752,
0.0476554036,
-0.0140933525,
0.0034200312,
0.0331583954,
-0.0543975979,
-0.0368448943,
-0.0166651346,
0.0037438916,
0.0276608299,
0.0120809413,
0.0058386964,
-0.025098674,
0.0549768433,
-0.0160502605,
0.0519289561,
-0.0397765525,
-0.0148550393,
-0.0664052218,
-0.0267067198,
0.0162032191,
0.0094644148,
-0.0062517053,
-0.0297440812,
0.0266859736,
-0.0028955666,
0.0247176979,
-0.0088869203,
-0.0229022186,
0.0016351319,
-0.016749775,
-0.0470724218,
-0.0234841015,
0.0231598727,
-0.0253921282,
0.0604078025,
-0.0054031746,
0.0384866036,
1.686308635e-34,
0.048968181,
0.0025935927,
0.0274890922,
-0.0167256109,
0.0138831586,
0.0328004621,
-0.0449666828,
-0.0314192884,
0.0675106645,
0.0085945195,
0.0354907401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14913v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14913v2 | Robustness of the Random Language Model | 2023-09-26T13:14:35 | 2024-03-22T15:39:24 | Fatemeh Lalegani, Eric De Giuli | cond-mat.dis-nn | cond-mat.dis-nn, cs.CL | The Random Language Model (De Giuli 2019) is an ensemble of stochastic
context-free grammars, quantifying the syntax of human and computer languages.
The model suggests a simple picture of first language learning as a type of
annealing in the vast space of potential languages. In its simplest
formulation, it implies a single continuous transition to grammatical syntax,
at which the symmetry among potential words and categories is spontaneously
broken. Here this picture is scrutinized by considering its robustness against
extensions of the original model, and trajectories through parameter space
different from those originally considered. It is shown here that (i) the
scenario is robust to explicit symmetry breaking, an inevitable component of
learning in the real world; and (ii) the transition to grammatical syntax can
be encountered by fixing the deep (hidden) structure while varying the surface
(observable) properties. It is also argued that the transition becomes a sharp
thermodynamic transition in an idealized limit. Moreover, comparison with human
data on the clustering coefficient of syntax networks suggests that the
observed transition is equivalent to that normally experienced by children at
age 24 months. The results are discussed in light of theory of first-language
acquisition in linguistics, and recent successes in machine learning. | [
-0.0001082923,
0.0557075255,
-0.0453635938,
-0.006408779,
-0.039781075,
0.0435338728,
-0.0520614684,
-0.000342864,
-0.0066323881,
-0.0335337929,
0.0112025877,
-0.0740699694,
0.0213008337,
-0.0025517324,
0.0287038013,
-0.0760825425,
0.0668474883,
-0.0666733757,
-0.0080298027,
-0.0194081869,
-0.0062606717,
-0.0598800108,
0.0039824005,
0.0115787154,
0.0087380102,
-0.0026601295,
-0.0204775166,
-0.0531613491,
-0.0442376696,
0.0069527347,
-0.0349489935,
0.0539413951,
-0.0131900506,
0.0389770381,
0.0000019216,
-0.0676294118,
-0.0103006046,
-0.0066213929,
-0.0044120401,
-0.0371043608,
0.0419587381,
0.0120054679,
-0.0516619273,
-0.0084406827,
-0.0326608829,
0.0197095703,
0.0761608481,
-0.0404354148,
-0.0301041268,
0.0120536517,
0.0051562181,
-0.0695308149,
0.0434545875,
-0.0114185065,
0.0030865364,
-0.0063783,
0.0326268077,
-0.061982654,
-0.0218148064,
-0.0369967073,
-0.0631030649,
-0.0039502475,
-0.0019634566,
0.0222520903,
-0.0125728818,
0.0455623865,
-0.0089988103,
-0.0285986904,
-0.0126686851,
0.0257017314,
-0.0305713639,
-0.0471758805,
0.0188794695,
0.0307487305,
0.0239047445,
0.0218382701,
-0.0260601211,
0.08796487,
0.023256354,
0.0444069691,
0.0486097373,
-0.0635355338,
0.0400321223,
-0.0134853376,
0.0086289132,
0.0858669728,
0.0087888716,
-0.0474295877,
0.0118843531,
0.0184102859,
-0.0188271794,
-0.0503817052,
-0.0672804788,
-0.0046587856,
-0.0029291485,
0.03668084,
-0.0489816405,
-0.0062210117,
-0.0159480087,
-0.0383377187,
0.0151588796,
-0.0349976867,
0.0258700233,
0.0311774481,
0.0040240865,
-0.0113625294,
0.0067071365,
-0.00314024,
-0.0626887754,
0.0312156919,
-0.0480970554,
-0.0399684906,
-0.0111737633,
0.0007368827,
-0.0088191712,
0.0194054954,
-0.0252685212,
-0.0039162892,
0.0197697841,
-0.0203342084,
-0.0207096897,
-0.0144808749,
-0.0345854871,
0.0333756581,
-0.0162220839,
-0.0508936942,
-0.0062430138,
0.0430481434,
0.0145085342,
-0.0296852347,
-0.02948815,
0.0190867893,
-0.0080442829,
0.0250257086,
-0.0313697308,
0.0675884411,
0.0028574928,
-0.0190655012,
-0.0520034693,
-0.013618866,
-0.0451005772,
-0.0130834281,
0.0459628105,
-0.0592114925,
-0.0506566279,
0.0173609834,
-0.0082144756,
-0.066669099,
-0.0210664812,
-0.0197975989,
-0.0540944114,
0.0310438257,
-0.0233657826,
0.0236615743,
0.0104098162,
-0.0378063694,
0.0444326885,
0.061811164,
0.0465502515,
-0.0442950353,
0.034364447,
-0.0233084206,
0.0087079005,
0.0386821702,
-0.0194366928,
0.0177775063,
-0.0279729664,
-0.0377366617,
0.0279625002,
0.0015629912,
0.0169022754,
0.0461735241,
-0.0055965283,
-0.0205190182,
0.024940772,
0.056112092,
-0.0362208337,
0.0701878741,
-0.0044609294,
-0.016531717,
0.0163510889,
0.0630646423,
-0.0217717197,
-0.0196296871,
-0.0472504087,
-0.0056536482,
-0.0358973779,
0.014939514,
-0.0344439186,
-0.0206033867,
-0.0219225697,
-0.0439066403,
0.0550218038,
-0.0451034382,
0.0612893328,
0.0536450744,
-0.0124880867,
0.052279342,
0.0556882098,
-0.0191699788,
0.0008520677,
-0.0403177626,
0.0176993925,
-0.0095191738,
-0.0293709226,
-0.0235079378,
0.0014207775,
0.0043112077,
-0.0103041958,
0.0188379027,
-0.0083099967,
0.0199377835,
0.0276822392,
-0.0138431415,
0.024839038,
0.0624399818,
0.0392591134,
-0.007781887,
-0.0673668385,
-0.0318064615,
-0.0547276139,
-0.0318776444,
-0.0303896405,
0.0378303938,
-0.0530485921,
0.0063026887,
-0.0303426702,
-0.0045786919,
0.0224168655,
-0.0493843704,
-0.0199715439,
0.0476451553,
0.0254756082,
-0.0176142789,
0.0371688753,
0.0759923533,
-0.0280046538,
-0.0179451611,
0.0120501677,
-0.0440221988,
-0.0191855151,
0.0117923012,
0.0148535315,
-0.0275191758,
0.1054358035,
-0.0438818708,
0.0564256795,
-0.0045719841,
0.0468794666,
-0.0312715247,
0.0530403778,
-0.0255890545,
0.0788577572,
-0.0308105201,
0.0359525345,
-0.058995761,
-0.0483030602,
-0.0046591344,
-0.0814544186,
-0.0170199014,
-0.0236463081,
-0.0367100984,
0.006047457,
-0.0124458456,
-0.0028826045,
-0.0382291861,
-0.0377241112,
-0.0370732695,
-0.0637965128,
0.0074518425,
0.0529145189,
0.0099961292,
-0.0176413655,
-0.0211295467,
0.0056159459,
0.0130368453,
0.029586507,
0.0267395284,
0.0381424613,
0.0448415615,
-0.0252502412,
-0.0683440268,
-0.0475646257,
-0.0253285989,
-0.0436426774,
0.0574689396,
0.0124696484,
0.0201866534,
-0.038211301,
0.06347581,
0.0188066475,
0.0275213588,
0.0122588994,
-0.0329948328,
0.0402965136,
-0.012876017,
0.0522249937,
0.1076956689,
-0.0022405512,
0.0467856415,
0.0340937637,
-0.0133033609,
0.0106865438,
-0.0525291972,
-0.0166990776,
-0.011085012,
-0.0690763593,
-0.0144354301,
0.0324271992,
0.1280927807,
0.0218188688,
-0.0388555676,
-0.0194798987,
0.0531546697,
-0.0592040494,
-0.044011455,
-0.0188373961,
-0.0376743041,
-0.0593426339,
0.0587421916,
-0.025723543,
-0.0507258289,
0.0326817185,
-0.0000025072,
0.006679242,
-0.0421349183,
-0.0189430714,
0.0126190903,
0.0293880943,
0.0429839492,
-0.0026027183,
0.0512167774,
-0.0123831024,
-0.0767655,
-0.0474321768,
0.0421978049,
0.0111043705,
-0.0114762336,
-0.0667463616,
-0.0067160078,
0.0209493898,
-0.0240182877,
-0.0000880729,
-0.0450600609,
-0.00985872,
0.0023871304,
0.0255916938,
-0.0212304872,
0.0133468146,
-0.0045560133,
-0.001077306,
0.015129745,
0.0010377888,
-0.0045906031,
-0.0066492241,
0.0368666612,
0.0200305674,
-0.0332538933,
0.0125179635,
-0.0537868105,
0.0089257145,
0.0391544849,
0.0537442937,
0.0817124993,
-0.0196330044,
0.0476634055,
0.0132445479,
0.0047830292,
-0.0689912066,
0.0224614143,
-0.0063209925,
-0.0024658076,
-0.0351996794,
0.0537929684,
0.0257774871,
-0.0167106837,
0.0480819568,
0.0000339127,
0.0236934181,
0.0122295376,
0.0085046245,
-0.0173316598,
0.0199408941,
0.0139225805,
0.0081521291,
-0.0217478126,
-0.0602043755,
0.0380422138,
-0.05702224,
0.0062750573,
0.0110199163,
-0.1206460074,
-0.0102945659,
-0.0275034718,
-0.0139789861,
0.0010107534,
0.042087201,
0.0083040986,
-0.0341019221,
0.0299246069,
0.0414452739,
-0.0067924871,
-0.0494030416,
0.0091982121,
-0.0510749444,
0.0632186756,
0.0615594052,
-0.0014431552,
-0.0768053383,
-0.0230907202,
0.0507067107,
0.0362886004,
0.0037442711,
0.0189435352,
-0.0330515951,
0.0750795677,
-0.0034002378,
-0.0356326587,
0.0229625069,
-0.0242851935,
-0.0175278895,
-0.0176070184,
0.0884331614,
0.0246622525,
-0.0524578802,
0.0185642652,
-0.0368738994,
-0.0109185502,
0.0527437329,
0.0376093239,
-0.0486348309,
-0.0281466544,
-0.065350309,
0.0479907691,
0.0048970189,
-0.0498095304,
0.0501647033,
0.0309942253,
-0.036928609,
-0.0840006098,
0.0012662178,
-0.0025997651,
0.0452443771,
0.0091136601,
-0.0114837065,
0.0370165259,
-0.0031028194,
0.0192306787,
-0.0000359108,
0.0086133005,
-0.0283537563,
-0.0708622709,
-0.0239448771,
0.0142844487,
-0.0457887836,
-0.0421713181,
-0.0445824787,
-0.0169438049,
-0.0756316483,
0.083791256,
0.0145570068,
0.0325383879,
0.0239863861,
-0.0045935633,
-0.0852189958,
-0.0108637782,
0.0381969176,
0.0092349034,
0.0689159632,
0.0141675044,
-0.033552248,
0.0286750104,
0.0243087057,
-0.0013128993,
-0.0129124308,
0.0054621547,
0.0016915725,
-0.044511389,
-0.0219697636,
0.022013871,
0.0096531436,
0.0479624681,
-0.0214611869,
-0.0319758803,
-0.0217961241,
-0.0192516726,
0.0482420847,
0.0233587008,
-0.0081134867,
-0.0069734948,
0.0573367439,
0.0558751374,
0.0033454127,
0.0102238581,
0.0367313698,
0.0383376032,
0.0286336523,
0.012029957,
0.0409961604,
0.0575963818,
0.0101241926,
0.0566287078,
0.0245724972,
0.0404624231,
-0.0709602311,
0.0444859229,
0.0223817378,
-0.0319741108,
0.011730832,
0.0013190128,
-0.0217065457,
0.0019407526,
-0.0572749861,
-0.0291411374,
-0.0262009334,
-0.0196422301,
0.0406391993,
-0.0276682619,
0.0288739968,
-0.058006797,
0.0224257503,
-0.0374612249,
-0.0121250786,
0.013223337,
-0.0185484551,
0.0424604006,
-0.0040426976,
-0.0104032997,
-0.0033023225,
0.0737099126,
0.0492341258,
0.0303752907,
-0.0177500248,
0.0016278034,
-0.0116188889,
0.0232602358,
-0.0031982579,
-0.0236975644,
-0.0070619527,
0.023373954,
-0.0153563088,
-0.065950647,
-0.0156656392,
0.023033781,
0.0569660291,
-0.0035481397,
0.0297248494,
0.0891038328,
-0.0264353547,
0.0325498804,
-0.0367380381,
0.0163887944,
0.0757544115,
-0.0026816002,
0.0053353733,
-6.211413536e-33,
0.0056766779,
0.0014670758,
-0.0624001287,
0.0183027573,
0.0337080657,
-0.0804806426,
-0.0091338558,
0.0791011378,
-0.014552745,
0.0191213656,
-0.007408096,
0.0099772289,
0.0159956869,
0.0225283056,
0.039699547,
-0.0046230704,
-0.0182449948,
-0.0330330208,
0.0352507569,
-0.0378166437,
0.0230137333,
0.000817318,
0.0744686797,
-0.0065419921,
0.0204082783,
-0.0149043966,
0.0055143004,
0.0377511382,
-0.0333577618,
0.0235139839,
-0.0084929811,
0.0346224755,
0.0121541489,
0.0084338943,
-0.0265021734,
-0.0296031367,
-0.020360209,
-0.0555941276,
0.0161602478,
0.0344410092,
-0.0418761075,
-0.0313129202,
0.0580415837,
-0.0193101671,
-0.0432049409,
0.0292138159,
0.0352501348,
-0.0044685975,
-0.0260105636,
0.0338819921,
-0.0288714282,
0.0173857585,
0.00312121,
0.0205333084,
0.0058202338,
-0.049825605,
-0.0322099179,
-0.0344442651,
-0.023764817,
0.0464706682,
0.0335419178,
0.0629265308,
0.0266533382,
0.0312563889,
0.0379245467,
0.0283440724,
0.0753258988,
0.0359257907,
0.0053216256,
0.0295594875,
0.0822725296,
0.0314845853,
-0.0198944621,
0.0349983312,
0.0180945061,
-0.0150849288,
-0.0549038686,
-0.0236019399,
0.0245807469,
0.0076818024,
-0.0196288843,
0.0105907209,
-0.0364744663,
-0.048301179,
-0.0397062041,
-0.0408138894,
0.0040194504,
0.0216824077,
0.0009720396,
-0.0053578755,
0.0069783521,
-0.0532924272,
-0.0171506759,
-0.0247465391,
-0.0322069675,
-0.0072929882,
0.0269308072,
0.04103541,
0.0132922782,
0.0291402061,
-0.0420485772,
-0.0582247414,
-0.033440046,
0.0201859418,
0.0035024399,
0.0621634685,
-0.0141117107,
0.027509952,
-0.013404211,
0.0067273281,
0.0156471897,
-0.0421590917,
0.0506289341,
0.0035811779,
0.0446132571,
-0.012160819,
-0.0071925963,
0.0227302201,
0.047562547,
0.060594812,
-0.0405838415,
0.046876315,
-0.0302608423,
0.0317779295,
0.0211824551,
-0.0481017046,
-0.0371338166,
0.0064242603,
0.0663487986,
-0.0564382076,
0.0160112381,
0.0193715896,
2.83e-7,
0.0326049849,
0.0460709818,
0.0126719512,
-0.0246245787,
0.0620686822,
0.0364634991,
-0.0284924731,
-0.0076080533,
0.0036086347,
0.010503429,
-0.0418417081,
0.0033412643,
0.0094343293,
0.0175549649,
-0.0600322597,
-0.0000895968,
-0.0482183658,
0.0758141503,
0.0157928206,
0.0037309474,
-0.0244544875,
0.0899144262,
-0.0099303341,
0.0013788019,
-0.0203557014,
-0.0420598537,
0.0258136652,
-0.0171900969,
0.0340916179,
-0.0106777418,
-0.0371656455,
-0.0235946067,
-0.0126556661,
0.0230804514,
-0.0026961754,
0.0296190754,
-0.0256268885,
-0.0479031764,
-0.0193755236,
0.0405989103,
0.0460909232,
-0.0084070228,
-0.0280098841,
-0.0390688665,
0.0304251164,
-0.0435114764,
-0.0337891765,
0.0299585238,
-0.0233545192,
0.0430977866,
-0.0089728385,
0.024933802,
-0.0154537782,
-0.0038794673,
-0.0016045227,
-0.0002472808,
0.0182976499,
-0.0080206608,
-0.0252844188,
0.0140421009,
-0.0457603857,
-0.065293178,
-0.0027598466,
0.0259374063,
0.0472057313,
-0.008922264,
-0.0088228593,
2.461404355e-34,
0.019354295,
0.0110583752,
0.039210096,
-0.0153873768,
-0.0049303113,
-0.0142778326,
0.0357676409,
0.0300659407,
0.0228639971,
-0.0612728372,
-0.0065415055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15796v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15796v1 | Learning from Flawed Data: Weakly Supervised Automatic Speech Recognition | 2023-09-26T12:58:40 | 2023-09-26T12:58:40 | Dongji Gao, Hainan Xu, Desh Raj, Leibny Paola Garcia Perera, Daniel Povey, Sanjeev Khudanpur | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG | Training automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems requires large amounts of
well-curated paired data. However, human annotators usually perform
"non-verbatim" transcription, which can result in poorly trained models. In
this paper, we propose Omni-temporal Classification (OTC), a novel training
criterion that explicitly incorporates label uncertainties originating from
such weak supervision. This allows the model to effectively learn speech-text
alignments while accommodating errors present in the training transcripts. OTC
extends the conventional CTC objective for imperfect transcripts by leveraging
weighted finite state transducers. Through experiments conducted on the
LibriSpeech and LibriVox datasets, we demonstrate that training ASR models with
OTC avoids performance degradation even with transcripts containing up to 70%
errors, a scenario where CTC models fail completely. Our implementation is
available at https://github.com/k2-fsa/icefall. | [
-0.0158869643,
0.0872716457,
0.0263724215,
0.0267113894,
-0.0080372905,
0.020713564,
-0.0024364279,
0.0074257776,
0.0093590161,
-0.0254440755,
-0.0422456339,
-0.0505976081,
0.0651719645,
-0.0000299368,
0.0270691831,
-0.0197134893,
0.0283400863,
-0.027538849,
-0.0238294974,
0.0092124669,
0.0247276146,
-0.0062042577,
-0.0751798302,
0.0205659661,
-0.0171694513,
0.0066051357,
-0.0027938047,
0.0105169341,
0.0330282822,
-0.0034168533,
-0.0073335199,
0.0031910907,
0.0259374715,
0.0696246698,
0.0000017723,
-0.001507641,
-0.0201238375,
0.0067690993,
-0.0544386096,
-0.0406973213,
-0.01175611,
0.001732927,
-0.0155619327,
0.0432439633,
-0.0141202984,
-0.0378716923,
0.0717742741,
0.0181985181,
0.0440121517,
0.0669558346,
-0.008654763,
0.0390201434,
0.0132227149,
-0.004125508,
-0.0110013708,
-0.0397588536,
-0.0264310706,
-0.0204254054,
0.0075535253,
-0.0352682583,
-0.0118007688,
0.0435790531,
-0.01721159,
-0.0155041432,
0.0198951922,
-0.0007405335,
-0.0503141657,
-0.0330807008,
-0.0319189318,
0.0641116723,
0.0410301834,
-0.0144094676,
0.0143219391,
0.0034966157,
-0.0099583715,
-0.0214296822,
0.0153198307,
-0.0144054713,
0.0135581214,
0.0146986423,
-0.0355296619,
0.0295863952,
0.0319074765,
-0.0249398183,
-0.0043370607,
0.0248278603,
-0.0254699308,
-0.0405944213,
-0.0162112787,
-0.0111171016,
0.0006532455,
0.0264965463,
0.0293743797,
0.0101448074,
-0.0429934487,
-0.0180523042,
-0.044675272,
-0.0317363031,
0.0030222889,
-0.0141681852,
-0.0139114251,
0.0255022682,
-0.0853309557,
0.0288113467,
-0.0234015416,
0.0452143438,
0.01788483,
-0.0065330849,
-0.0008962823,
-0.0074656759,
-0.053843081,
0.0003334123,
0.004034494,
-0.0048366021,
0.020404879,
0.0210311525,
-0.0540772453,
0.0033771782,
-0.0187741723,
0.0406577662,
-0.0145855779,
-0.001750686,
-0.0694932267,
-0.0040923334,
0.0152283907,
0.0242055282,
0.0832697004,
0.0489368588,
-0.0122155054,
-0.0484413467,
-0.0387833789,
0.0306159649,
0.0424092561,
-0.0071543702,
-0.0157158114,
0.0647966266,
-0.0078551201,
-0.0424344502,
-0.0444370843,
0.0351784974,
-0.0638675094,
-0.0313585512,
-0.0565760024,
-0.0257496145,
0.023829395,
-0.0169147979,
0.0199360363,
-0.0253125783,
0.0169583708,
-0.0404546522,
0.0111872433,
0.0795165449,
-0.0104747629,
0.0049338527,
0.0208507497,
-0.0310220849,
0.0297291111,
0.0103495168,
0.059928488,
-0.0407310277,
-0.009909573,
-0.0014877202,
0.0095782746,
0.0513065383,
0.038551949,
0.0178340226,
-0.0505710281,
-0.0224563722,
0.0298164263,
0.0521365106,
0.0376853272,
0.040105395,
0.0021226211,
0.0300798286,
0.0712735131,
-0.0085495738,
-0.0010141074,
-0.0068068365,
0.0294285472,
-0.0137061067,
-0.0156887919,
-0.0068204845,
-0.0124954265,
-0.0182770211,
-0.0160086099,
0.0339553691,
0.0341827646,
-0.007682988,
-0.0314004235,
-0.0377789885,
-0.0253551397,
-0.0430107415,
-0.0359234922,
0.0264041126,
0.0661982,
-0.0036652565,
-0.0401215293,
0.0331111252,
-0.0106012365,
-0.0272960067,
0.0226233918,
-0.0421466716,
-0.007355399,
0.0549989529,
0.0096013639,
-0.0742404908,
-0.0553462394,
-0.0681842044,
-0.0191574246,
0.047836598,
0.0367672518,
-0.021106204,
0.0522807948,
-0.0496304855,
-0.0018981774,
0.0758855864,
0.000979294,
0.0161292348,
-0.0361465737,
0.0163165219,
0.0267915707,
-0.0456508398,
-0.0356479026,
0.0214557666,
-0.0107329898,
-0.0327380449,
0.0136389229,
0.0280386508,
0.0603525341,
0.0199609157,
-0.044403024,
-0.0041732024,
0.0502509661,
-0.0173922163,
-0.0227914806,
0.0067585767,
-0.0645703524,
-0.0508407354,
0.0577689074,
0.0030017085,
-0.0294004567,
0.0285669994,
-0.0025934661,
-0.1058069319,
-0.0117952293,
-0.0234734323,
0.0441075228,
-0.022036178,
0.0497375317,
0.0414963327,
-0.0220575724,
-0.0208518263,
-0.0027014767,
0.0052954932,
0.0257211905,
0.0019276099,
-0.037894439,
0.0018919652,
-0.0581177585,
-0.0196479689,
-0.0137755061,
-0.0389445424,
0.0188507158,
0.0103179263,
0.0047469027,
-0.0088911233,
-0.036726024,
-0.0818035379,
-0.0037428832,
-0.040260125,
0.0389738567,
-0.0375422053,
0.0235779155,
0.0157657042,
-0.0393023528,
-0.0422727726,
-0.0154875768,
-0.0089539373,
-0.0215846896,
0.0131508596,
0.0125514008,
-0.0237960294,
-0.0219083559,
0.0321413279,
-0.0283141006,
0.0131630655,
-0.0098887533,
-0.0514282361,
-0.0796425492,
0.0471685193,
0.0196512807,
0.0323798731,
0.0049551176,
0.0123847583,
-0.007918545,
0.0167880803,
0.022537997,
0.0139162177,
-0.0175836999,
-0.0104085188,
-0.008898613,
-0.007643736,
-0.0524772182,
0.0128717264,
0.0076389373,
-0.0288207438,
-0.044077117,
0.0285782795,
-0.0371703431,
0.0242398884,
0.0143585028,
0.0322087929,
-0.062755093,
-0.0417923033,
-0.0352219231,
-0.0063015088,
0.0209534969,
-0.0268358588,
-0.0221544858,
-0.0233354289,
-0.0105945561,
-0.0334451944,
0.049990993,
-0.0681298524,
-0.0132401362,
0.0112486398,
-0.0501930527,
-0.0280248858,
0.0288189687,
0.0037518141,
0.0055117439,
0.0155445207,
-0.0651757568,
-0.0303638801,
-0.0275966581,
0.0214741081,
-0.0195627473,
0.0091344444,
-0.0325300917,
0.0581070036,
-0.0228600949,
-0.0765250847,
-0.0124691045,
-0.0413420051,
0.0163059495,
-0.0412613079,
-0.0055929706,
-0.0434614792,
-0.0649941862,
0.0121416897,
-0.0186167099,
0.0899485573,
-0.0129211629,
0.0066521522,
-0.018691441,
0.0676372647,
0.0147212371,
0.0241994616,
0.0123235732,
-0.0330002271,
0.0276504774,
-0.0088405013,
0.1057816297,
0.0050197877,
-0.0437896587,
-0.0197183341,
0.0530079529,
-0.0006258881,
-0.0162307732,
0.0285245832,
0.0445478745,
-0.0172307082,
-0.0087648304,
0.0885836333,
0.0153154023,
-0.0308895577,
-0.0250525903,
0.0093161054,
0.0378014632,
0.0053270217,
-0.0199840013,
-0.0628670827,
-0.0347571671,
0.023115145,
0.0846115276,
-0.011586871,
0.0126412231,
0.0022547019,
-0.051842168,
0.0061635338,
0.0470076762,
-0.0170970615,
-0.0314088278,
-0.0481502861,
-0.0022851231,
-0.0735590532,
0.0595359951,
0.0003328202,
-0.0186109282,
-0.0183806811,
0.076826714,
-0.0644084886,
-0.0816687196,
0.0007684526,
0.0055758986,
0.1196660027,
0.0582676046,
0.0460974723,
-0.0239540488,
-0.0221091397,
0.0822828412,
-0.0100251092,
-0.0214948766,
0.0015920766,
0.0511709489,
0.0166082717,
-0.0068297782,
0.0363989621,
0.0793895051,
0.019855924,
0.0162713788,
-0.0173893198,
0.0760914385,
-0.0350697711,
0.0622437224,
0.036211092,
-0.0449831635,
0.0361757241,
0.0303479582,
-0.025217684,
-0.0408381522,
-0.02569375,
0.0277074482,
0.045944687,
-0.0300550852,
0.0148974713,
0.0117857987,
-3.286e-7,
-0.0440839604,
-0.0292888936,
-0.0393646359,
-0.0025568106,
0.0521116368,
0.0258206967,
-0.0142099801,
0.0073664356,
0.0268384423,
0.0000158133,
0.0461535119,
-0.0023268303,
0.0288812276,
-0.0690519884,
0.0015424493,
0.0327781178,
-0.0114232861,
-0.0012929649,
0.0526206903,
-0.0561863519,
-0.0749629438,
0.031571269,
-0.0019598629,
0.0148965791,
0.0721234903,
-0.0190030392,
-0.0225938614,
0.0562370904,
0.0520499684,
-0.0431713611,
-0.0056145214,
0.0359832756,
-0.0085592847,
-0.0473397709,
0.0212613605,
-0.0568549111,
-0.0186028071,
-0.0165869594,
-0.0005795149,
-0.023175152,
-0.0499179997,
0.0310129784,
0.0028563156,
0.0971392021,
-0.010820902,
0.0403905921,
-0.0287812781,
0.0224082842,
0.0527995452,
0.0169850197,
-0.0297199953,
0.0138616962,
0.0348239169,
-0.0101050287,
-0.0323374271,
-0.0159824155,
-0.0330575444,
0.0092155365,
-0.0257022567,
0.0597258396,
0.0163352508,
-0.0012273457,
0.0129957935,
-0.0170558356,
-0.0065846406,
0.0960510522,
0.032985121,
0.0309290886,
0.0127609856,
0.023404086,
0.0162151046,
0.0530465059,
0.025941344,
-0.0205712225,
-0.0578862727,
0.0105056446,
-0.0307348967,
-0.0185118932,
0.0563332923,
-0.0246531367,
0.0663373694,
0.0114967795,
0.0203239881,
-0.0134705044,
0.0358378962,
-0.0182649251,
-0.0015051926,
0.0011823354,
-0.005152815,
-0.0045425077,
0.0827566609,
0.0664720386,
0.0636104867,
0.0384624191,
-0.0359076224,
0.0172234792,
-0.0643956363,
-0.0285984371,
0.0147021851,
-0.0543661602,
-0.0439576134,
-0.0303133074,
0.0110525265,
-0.0432787947,
0.0606964529,
-0.0041739042,
0.0203185901,
-0.016017478,
-0.0054514213,
-0.0142429005,
-0.0357963555,
0.0146074593,
-0.0180085376,
-0.0278929286,
0.10523545,
-0.0286531784,
-0.0268774219,
-6.167660167e-33,
-0.0079469513,
-0.008544906,
0.0046677841,
0.0062955627,
-0.0376264453,
0.0253012776,
0.0021063397,
0.0057934844,
0.037166927,
-0.0186782852,
-0.0294894185,
0.0216196571,
0.0414341465,
0.024954997,
0.0115126511,
-0.033271037,
0.0867508799,
-0.0169598181,
-0.0086306082,
-0.0024909559,
0.0510429926,
0.0519970432,
0.0191151295,
-0.0898007974,
0.0452883653,
0.0034397577,
-0.0173400957,
0.0192089751,
0.0415976793,
0.0127351983,
0.0185916554,
-0.0028267119,
-0.0354221128,
-0.0250408407,
0.0017440685,
-0.0110449465,
-0.0855166614,
0.0237731878,
-0.0242488328,
0.0694746971,
0.0086804433,
-0.002629776,
0.0134340515,
-0.0101392316,
-0.02659663,
-0.01201279,
0.0337138884,
-0.039920494,
-0.0172337294,
-0.0911962911,
0.0174935665,
0.0741211027,
-0.0566849411,
-0.0213685371,
0.0714586005,
0.0574917495,
-0.0092909876,
-0.0565408655,
-0.0599477366,
-0.0062800501,
-0.0167680383,
0.0556866117,
0.0305599626,
0.0246588029,
-0.0348625332,
0.0210803896,
-0.0035780075,
-0.0166823622,
0.0368868187,
-0.0457836464,
-0.0183809139,
-0.0151993651,
0.0059417379,
-0.012727187,
-0.001675681,
-0.039173305,
-0.0381392278,
-0.0033383819,
-0.0225537345,
0.0180181116,
0.0035286397,
0.0300054066,
-0.0718268231,
0.0008165045,
-0.0365243889,
-0.0152929397,
-0.0112370849,
0.0412211716,
0.0147445668,
0.0055200295,
0.0244611334,
-0.0004454911,
0.0558286458,
0.0094535844,
-0.0216160156,
-0.0133047681,
0.0178354476,
-0.0026280903,
-0.0552656725,
0.0283681154,
-0.0488736667,
-0.0648018792,
0.0214835424,
0.0477678031,
0.0634614751,
-0.0521628708,
0.0637612566,
0.0758681521,
-0.0775974244,
-0.0000530976,
0.0297303591,
0.0261229109,
-0.033668071,
-0.0078559564,
0.0732842609,
-0.020748375,
0.0135063687,
0.0574159473,
-0.0027914885,
0.0181897134,
-0.0178177841,
0.0012650316,
-0.0135272183,
-0.0000620797,
-0.0429583378,
-0.0376463458,
0.0135293258,
-0.0017879581,
-0.0186597351,
-0.0642849356,
0.0277058221,
0.0200565495,
2.696e-7,
-0.0367957801,
0.0323641896,
0.005739361,
-0.0556936972,
0.0085246963,
0.0341392867,
-0.0427529365,
-0.0054723495,
-0.054842975,
0.0274748895,
0.0614836551,
-0.027226029,
0.0967321396,
0.0273420662,
-0.0762085766,
-0.0287187696,
-0.0608169362,
0.0286113154,
-0.0148356315,
0.0139660612,
0.0309410598,
0.1038849577,
0.0052646426,
-0.0337701328,
0.0154053159,
-0.0321934223,
0.0346161164,
0.0434371047,
-0.0307229292,
0.0046053515,
0.052961804,
-0.0086191669,
-0.0176403932,
0.0239458997,
-0.0301875472,
0.0367017016,
-0.0183683168,
0.0103058461,
-0.0401959755,
-0.0284966361,
0.004931075,
0.039002534,
-0.0032036335,
0.0492028669,
0.0244449116,
-0.0065039569,
-0.0110346917,
-0.0050549004,
-0.0281021893,
0.0231630132,
0.0156840738,
0.0152817154,
0.0408184789,
0.0191044528,
0.0169456247,
-0.0086217374,
-0.0281290766,
-0.0478008203,
-0.0145113748,
0.0286961645,
-0.0433661416,
-0.0165723283,
-0.0057470766,
0.0847830772,
0.0452861413,
-0.0729956329,
-0.0157901682,
2.444326856e-34,
0.0252143443,
-0.0539628007,
0.003800242,
-0.0085384306,
0.0003578132,
-0.0277113914,
0.0399279706,
0.0099480301,
0.0121221859,
-0.023791166,
-0.0165051557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14823v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14823v2 | Segmentation-Free Streaming Machine Translation | 2023-09-26T10:43:52 | 2024-05-25T10:57:11 | Javier Iranzo-Sánchez, Jorge Iranzo-Sánchez, Adrià Giménez, Jorge Civera, Alfons Juan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Streaming Machine Translation (MT) is the task of translating an unbounded
input text stream in real-time. The traditional cascade approach, which
combines an Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) and an MT system, relies on an
intermediate segmentation step which splits the transcription stream into
sentence-like units. However, the incorporation of a hard segmentation
constrains the MT system and is a source of errors. This paper proposes a
Segmentation-Free framework that enables the model to translate an unsegmented
source stream by delaying the segmentation decision until the translation has
been generated. Extensive experiments show how the proposed Segmentation-Free
framework has better quality-latency trade-off than competing approaches that
use an independent segmentation model. Software, data and models will be
released upon paper acceptance. | [
-0.03044153,
0.0104827071,
0.0046367873,
-0.0167359263,
-0.0332323723,
0.0299642477,
0.0321089476,
0.014225631,
-0.0430289321,
0.0083362218,
0.0296062604,
-0.0377128273,
0.0242427047,
0.0332026668,
0.0258970223,
-0.1018519029,
0.0252489299,
-0.0442529805,
0.0200465415,
0.0202011168,
0.0229087714,
0.0236386117,
-0.0027272848,
-0.0114369486,
-0.0034980976,
0.0203379411,
-0.0230241325,
0.0166273843,
0.0343437232,
0.0033685726,
-0.0773017779,
-0.003654201,
0.0130225373,
0.0740395412,
0.000001965,
-0.0216242168,
-0.0871103182,
0.0297625139,
-0.0018961282,
-0.023139948,
0.0399461798,
-0.0568576977,
-0.0466590934,
0.0588241331,
0.012169118,
-0.0113653596,
0.0482482538,
0.0125987977,
0.0199128445,
0.0499368832,
-0.0540733971,
-0.0567758679,
0.01222267,
-0.0273733158,
-0.0566480421,
-0.0234727729,
-0.0293983519,
-0.0045398958,
-0.0373355635,
0.0070140925,
-0.0089954529,
0.0643402487,
-0.0087216618,
-0.0377529338,
0.0225883164,
-0.0161803868,
-0.0621759221,
-0.0507572331,
-0.0157709736,
0.0368672013,
-0.040454004,
-0.0108100204,
0.0310793296,
-0.0133259054,
-0.0309653617,
-0.0830916017,
-0.0106514571,
0.0694876388,
-0.0307790954,
0.0022572917,
-0.002373135,
0.0294058137,
0.0196882654,
-0.033845447,
-0.0449803434,
-0.0202127248,
0.0100352271,
-0.0499363989,
-0.0192759763,
0.0175755098,
-0.0171273332,
0.0035614541,
0.0851583481,
-0.0198712181,
-0.0013442558,
0.024934968,
-0.0351097398,
-0.0240797009,
-0.0516222566,
-0.0187892001,
0.0096311169,
0.077191174,
0.0258822218,
0.0327814855,
-0.0166193359,
-0.0095681287,
-0.0190482177,
-0.0321286544,
-0.0718572289,
0.0036590907,
-0.0139094573,
0.0018116959,
-0.0482734032,
0.0209433027,
-0.069303669,
0.0055615418,
-0.0173112825,
0.0245152265,
0.0322459303,
-0.0168541744,
0.0301485434,
-0.0367133208,
-0.0553857759,
-0.0162694529,
0.0393635891,
0.055854138,
-0.0161136668,
-0.014132522,
0.0107138772,
-0.0388127863,
0.0066142138,
0.0350943953,
0.0288849901,
0.0252748113,
-0.0356609561,
-0.0016303873,
-0.0416250974,
-0.0175576843,
-0.0020143669,
0.0016082205,
0.0016533976,
-0.0101046506,
-0.0115633877,
-0.0320344605,
0.0471912883,
0.0127161387,
0.024960123,
0.0485434607,
-0.0165332463,
-0.0206350964,
0.0260666236,
0.052437,
-0.0124836583,
0.0369016193,
0.0287399422,
0.0010747917,
0.0339345112,
0.082705602,
0.0415251032,
-0.0290311929,
0.0229190979,
0.0075451443,
-0.0422635861,
0.0838271528,
-0.0381503701,
0.0242658257,
-0.0616746545,
-0.01475826,
-0.0288914051,
0.012626037,
0.0005522454,
0.049890507,
-0.007635917,
0.0490904078,
0.0323335193,
0.0492906719,
0.0138147892,
0.0613143556,
0.0445882604,
0.0522241406,
-0.0185894202,
0.0195346642,
0.0524994656,
-0.0280238409,
0.056903109,
0.0351621844,
0.0470154025,
0.0203074384,
-0.0256083105,
-0.0010795732,
0.0017341098,
-0.0263075251,
0.0154431863,
-0.0083425278,
0.0511830822,
0.0109778512,
-0.0467374362,
0.042674426,
-0.0509451851,
-0.0880311653,
0.0350565426,
-0.0237719361,
-0.0350637175,
0.0662290826,
0.0605858378,
-0.0269273967,
-0.0229832102,
-0.0166604258,
0.0317837931,
0.045488663,
0.0086649023,
0.001051213,
0.0444303341,
-0.0672368556,
0.025709521,
0.1083300039,
0.0051924968,
0.0140934624,
-0.033008825,
0.0312894806,
0.023821786,
0.0049513699,
-0.0165231936,
0.0094877733,
0.0237149652,
0.0055984138,
0.0180737488,
0.0024112542,
0.0295601748,
0.0313255638,
-0.0141487559,
-0.0248214155,
0.0312891304,
-0.012840054,
0.018519273,
0.0623853952,
-0.0596509427,
-0.0254290663,
-0.0368265398,
-0.0264562815,
-0.010675611,
-0.0026770832,
-0.005628794,
-0.0725693256,
-0.0119036781,
-0.0015633749,
0.0142238699,
-0.0250546411,
0.0824911445,
0.0023417298,
-0.0110336673,
-0.0120921424,
-0.0138966711,
-0.0014555611,
-0.0070316489,
0.0111038834,
-0.0324112028,
-0.0276140142,
-0.0533919558,
-0.0158417709,
0.0379308984,
-0.0236160923,
0.0071597225,
-0.000622152,
-0.014225116,
-0.0209815409,
-0.012220975,
-0.061535418,
0.001658015,
-0.0096509149,
0.0481989048,
0.0342368186,
0.0741376877,
-0.0065950612,
-0.0099989455,
0.0122768246,
0.0045182495,
0.0356866755,
-0.0111675514,
-0.0168988742,
-0.0362850986,
-0.0037599232,
0.0061350889,
-0.0095500266,
0.0169631112,
0.0045613064,
0.0149384858,
-0.0752038807,
-0.1068428382,
0.0149824703,
0.0042435108,
0.0399473719,
0.0287394933,
-0.0146912998,
0.0182255283,
-0.0341273285,
0.0375516713,
0.0285185166,
0.0029372519,
-0.0318866447,
0.0035148922,
-0.0355859026,
-0.0108895171,
0.0074767275,
-0.0218044166,
0.0243135318,
0.0161328949,
0.007304437,
0.0166832134,
0.0259781815,
0.0152737768,
0.0030772567,
-0.0315609053,
-0.038453538,
-0.0339225084,
0.0029285511,
0.0076500024,
-0.0283564813,
-0.0297011361,
0.01154684,
-0.0037506728,
-0.061620716,
0.0281744618,
-0.0445284918,
-0.0630798191,
-0.0450169742,
0.0012295138,
-0.0264838506,
0.0082409289,
-0.0061234431,
-0.0067412234,
-0.011776939,
-0.0541878678,
-0.0123898927,
0.056990765,
-0.0181258023,
-0.0283460319,
0.0339631028,
-0.046218574,
-0.0067839399,
-0.0200491883,
0.0245747548,
0.0017662008,
0.0396749303,
0.0123542426,
-0.0135308094,
0.088261269,
-0.0125193587,
-0.0039084177,
0.0760101974,
0.0100526391,
0.0863018334,
-0.0082869399,
-0.0130751999,
-0.0232718326,
0.0683360323,
-0.0485175587,
-0.007816731,
-0.0135128684,
-0.0290411711,
0.0567469969,
0.0157384463,
0.0933357403,
-0.0485885292,
-0.0207771044,
-0.0280709714,
0.0348020792,
-0.0069173556,
-0.0111216484,
-0.0149226328,
0.0597395748,
-0.0661167428,
-0.0065849628,
0.1028404459,
0.0130797476,
-0.0264564194,
-0.0423145555,
-0.0100441892,
0.0347625799,
-0.0041625644,
0.0089183478,
-0.0483943447,
-0.0023034995,
0.0254676957,
0.0723528713,
0.0357783101,
0.005590695,
-0.0251842942,
-0.0179888178,
0.0471487567,
0.0609525517,
-0.0403332673,
-0.0049413349,
-0.0181414485,
-0.0491724052,
-0.0211648941,
-0.0250919145,
0.0019614971,
0.0218079947,
-0.0291273221,
0.022427842,
-0.0584544539,
-0.0282873791,
-0.0328743234,
-0.0294593014,
0.0260164384,
0.0805216134,
0.0231145602,
0.0091768894,
0.0229184404,
0.081640102,
-0.0749085397,
-0.0181004666,
-0.0212072413,
-0.0490810871,
0.019188771,
-0.0063159638,
0.0051267277,
-0.0179287903,
0.0405067429,
0.061214909,
0.0353122838,
0.0436312146,
-0.0126170488,
0.0176177938,
0.030749999,
-0.0177207794,
-0.0084684948,
0.0242870692,
-0.0340145342,
-0.0262407791,
-0.012538624,
-0.0146338623,
0.012947835,
-0.0210951045,
-0.0056055184,
-0.0166928302,
-0.0440605655,
-0.053311877,
-0.0671594217,
-0.0005567967,
0.0323187597,
0.058142446,
0.0142617328,
0.0364804566,
0.0702627301,
-0.000833342,
-0.0082880277,
-0.0160364397,
-0.034804862,
-0.0181206707,
-0.051495377,
-0.0039883275,
-0.002056276,
-0.0311520472,
0.0156693254,
0.043359369,
-0.0711689368,
-0.0587720312,
0.0102560967,
-0.0192342121,
0.0248223785,
0.0531778634,
-0.0619899556,
-0.0019684844,
0.0365049466,
0.0107682329,
-0.0087414673,
-0.0030329523,
0.0202897266,
0.0273402911,
-0.024433367,
0.0149401138,
-0.0127035836,
0.0218205806,
-0.0549621843,
0.0127124609,
-0.0305263083,
-0.0016172293,
-0.024276441,
0.0408023596,
0.0477975607,
0.0105067929,
0.001264729,
-0.0168687236,
0.0245032422,
-0.0165973529,
0.0157593638,
-0.0414486192,
0.0251524113,
0.0298132114,
-0.0103166336,
-0.0124800028,
0.0235842373,
-0.0373568125,
-0.0887652263,
0.0165989399,
0.0200460274,
0.0139313042,
-0.0125154918,
0.0274197999,
0.0100587979,
0.014115111,
0.0031159036,
0.0201122146,
-0.0095643532,
-0.0536176823,
0.0471884757,
-0.0088707441,
0.0331932418,
0.0265321936,
0.0426176675,
-0.0014423081,
0.0360831879,
-0.0291891396,
0.0207329765,
0.0284294132,
0.003726803,
0.1185224801,
0.0249941386,
0.0209234003,
-0.0564095229,
0.0496008098,
0.0159074664,
-0.0608990155,
-0.0258889683,
0.0099393446,
-0.0303876307,
0.050513383,
0.0038033952,
-0.0250617489,
-0.0372520052,
0.0029992722,
-0.0370479487,
-0.0238247048,
0.0006708166,
-0.0646898225,
-0.0446730852,
-0.0381682627,
-0.0430555195,
0.0208373684,
-0.01612694,
-0.0100645293,
-0.0088667953,
0.0412611887,
-0.0256845914,
0.0010955411,
0.0572426133,
-0.0221344922,
0.0033035027,
-0.021597404,
-0.0298098233,
-0.0050663985,
-0.0146756098,
0.0414442196,
-6.143220537e-33,
-0.0171861257,
-0.0157365054,
-0.0331131704,
-0.0784386769,
-0.0472641326,
0.0238212552,
-0.0161152203,
-0.0090688355,
0.0345695242,
-0.0394711532,
-0.031967219,
0.0119718527,
0.0426940434,
-0.0183133408,
-0.0158168916,
0.0203235336,
0.0728634372,
-0.0420107953,
-0.0260209311,
0.0416179448,
0.0238924418,
0.0210424531,
-0.0038025926,
0.0179970879,
0.0183842946,
-0.0400270782,
-0.0339611284,
0.0159798991,
0.056022644,
-0.0053134309,
0.0151883299,
0.0066124867,
0.0064172456,
-0.0362680145,
-0.0519860946,
0.0219712164,
-0.0998253375,
0.0596092902,
-0.0160237476,
0.0536777303,
-0.0045396932,
0.0225313995,
0.0487204865,
-0.0042975517,
0.0156202428,
0.0003928422,
-0.0177243352,
-0.0424897149,
-0.0203273948,
-0.0335050896,
-0.0469686724,
0.0427900702,
-0.0184251405,
-0.0146014299,
0.0911352262,
0.0720263198,
-0.0057382938,
-0.0491798259,
-0.0609947443,
0.0488715433,
0.0267391447,
0.0433030091,
0.0524127297,
-0.0099016111,
-0.014210362,
-0.06103063,
0.0449857935,
-0.0424883701,
0.0032265447,
0.0300594158,
0.0173857156,
-0.0339411832,
0.0462378561,
-0.0421503149,
0.0325965807,
-0.0341442414,
-0.0245115366,
0.013517837,
0.0090152519,
-0.0125122815,
0.0144396396,
0.0519642644,
-0.0496947691,
-0.0163635556,
-0.0065994561,
-0.0682987422,
-0.0157709736,
-0.0066321576,
0.0228019413,
0.0452870876,
-0.0249117427,
-0.0019140439,
0.1005862132,
0.0373652205,
0.0557591803,
-0.0485285483,
-0.0351701118,
0.0373189114,
-0.0343339741,
0.0139277941,
-0.0382446535,
-0.0289706551,
0.0431880318,
0.0167661551,
-0.0156209404,
-0.0285149626,
-0.0055945995,
0.0550820753,
-0.044767011,
0.0176168662,
0.0042300411,
0.0363342129,
-0.0253338516,
0.0552576445,
0.0376172028,
-0.0561051741,
0.0232304968,
0.0719673112,
-0.0046501243,
-0.0054309233,
-0.0088080568,
0.0379030704,
-0.0034580263,
0.0495279133,
-0.0797586516,
0.0344335064,
0.0198195651,
0.0282124896,
0.0447871163,
-0.0246728975,
-0.0528501198,
0.011870116,
2.64e-7,
0.0165571366,
0.0814049393,
0.0435613953,
-0.0169497766,
0.0236560628,
0.0042180251,
0.0115029914,
0.0020329619,
0.0029483861,
0.0846894085,
0.0199999791,
-0.0024406242,
0.0985601768,
0.0165348388,
-0.1365700066,
-0.033985924,
-0.0408682153,
0.033213526,
-0.0273771882,
0.001156587,
0.0115486588,
0.0553372651,
-0.0406564027,
0.0239180364,
0.0012639968,
-0.0089189913,
-0.0087230271,
0.0392139256,
-0.0065840106,
-0.0144221196,
0.0358894765,
0.0162260868,
-0.0868931264,
-0.005785557,
-0.0361466743,
-0.0243873037,
0.050536491,
0.0653795376,
0.0039598369,
0.0132061271,
0.0565736033,
0.0271729548,
-0.0087282909,
-0.0002376524,
0.0524466671,
0.0046967622,
0.0009089766,
0.0231327023,
-0.0052221902,
0.0284399856,
-0.0478887334,
-0.003481121,
-0.0080903051,
0.0424271338,
0.023174068,
-0.0184098016,
-0.0210368093,
-0.0183578506,
0.0094801905,
-0.0597242191,
-0.0147189293,
-0.0380549282,
-0.0388454348,
0.0708515719,
-0.0210148171,
-0.0098666642,
-0.0105772736,
2.518760903e-34,
0.0202342458,
-0.0360762365,
-0.0022325143,
-0.0187175144,
0.009206404,
-0.0494530387,
-0.0203825757,
0.0068420633,
-0.0561841205,
-0.0283811856,
-0.0549207181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04906v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04906v1 | FlaCGEC: A Chinese Grammatical Error Correction Dataset with Fine-grained Linguistic Annotation | 2023-09-26T10:22:43 | 2023-09-26T10:22:43 | Hanyue Du, Yike Zhao, Qingyuan Tian, Jiani Wang, Lei Wang, Yunshi Lan, Xuesong Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chinese Grammatical Error Correction (CGEC) has been attracting growing
attention from researchers recently. In spite of the fact that multiple CGEC
datasets have been developed to support the research, these datasets lack the
ability to provide a deep linguistic topology of grammar errors, which is
critical for interpreting and diagnosing CGEC approaches. To address this
limitation, we introduce FlaCGEC, which is a new CGEC dataset featured with
fine-grained linguistic annotation. Specifically, we collect raw corpus from
the linguistic schema defined by Chinese language experts, conduct edits on
sentences via rules, and refine generated samples manually, which results in
10k sentences with 78 instantiated grammar points and 3 types of edits. We
evaluate various cutting-edge CGEC methods on the proposed FlaCGEC dataset and
their unremarkable results indicate that this dataset is challenging in
covering a large range of grammatical errors. In addition, we also treat
FlaCGEC as a diagnostic dataset for testing generalization skills and conduct a
thorough evaluation of existing CGEC models. | [
0.0845070407,
0.0367048047,
-0.009515902,
0.0275170077,
0.0014552763,
0.0355230309,
-0.029217096,
-0.0281691588,
-0.0298986416,
-0.0408738963,
-0.0331476256,
-0.038198635,
0.0248784814,
-0.0210072733,
0.0226531085,
-0.0302650537,
0.0543656573,
0.0251016077,
0.0176523812,
0.0149946939,
0.0472602583,
0.0048847161,
0.0055077989,
0.0410399102,
-0.0606088005,
-0.0489798263,
-0.0033812425,
0.0519150682,
0.0181881674,
-0.0164062865,
0.0866072774,
0.0505700223,
-0.028529875,
0.0571929142,
0.0000018909,
-0.0208276398,
-0.0322389491,
-0.0163046084,
0.0067432644,
0.0729957148,
0.020346405,
-0.0236893184,
-0.0516513959,
-0.0025218152,
-0.0113838781,
-0.0399328507,
0.0680589378,
0.0706196725,
0.0733078942,
0.0974630639,
-0.0090748081,
-0.0055335453,
0.0158581883,
-0.0095329927,
-0.0400334671,
0.0103950538,
0.0252585635,
0.0357599705,
-0.0528718829,
-0.0371296518,
-0.0307971369,
-0.0131964395,
-0.0120379115,
-0.0553582497,
-0.0180909485,
-0.028073784,
-0.0742008537,
-0.0090253893,
-0.0112576149,
0.03947144,
-0.002385848,
-0.0352649502,
-0.0182376523,
0.0083041182,
0.0240494926,
-0.0198996123,
-0.0229930505,
0.001219559,
-0.0053758267,
0.0238776505,
0.0714012459,
-0.1147494689,
0.0081554279,
0.001435817,
0.0287083127,
0.0498436093,
0.0125540597,
-0.0460986495,
-0.0535302311,
0.0353137404,
-0.0194061771,
-0.0495153368,
0.0145135596,
-0.0229735039,
-0.0503770784,
-0.0327325352,
-0.0576711632,
-0.0490424559,
0.011176141,
-0.0212640017,
0.0323064402,
-0.0098345717,
-0.0614527725,
0.0126875369,
-0.0237077475,
0.0074864053,
0.0343469158,
0.045778729,
0.0005533886,
-0.0161215719,
-0.041223444,
-0.0050602756,
-0.0735046938,
0.006966081,
-0.0143668037,
0.0308591798,
-0.059377186,
-0.0190680027,
-0.0497546233,
0.0470498838,
0.0159982722,
-0.0076687764,
-0.0517815351,
-0.0246041715,
0.0155726047,
0.0130706895,
-0.0184477475,
0.0731587037,
0.0097355014,
-0.0432980023,
-0.0326864272,
0.0102569405,
0.0632278025,
-0.0044868668,
-0.0041975188,
-0.0112989694,
0.0002701865,
-0.0196170826,
-0.041589614,
-0.0069260295,
-0.0144933481,
-0.0195217803,
-0.0692316815,
-0.0597317815,
-0.0130485417,
-0.0361435525,
0.0298280846,
-0.0113598136,
0.005673992,
-0.0167790931,
0.0055636349,
0.0549296215,
-0.0615656264,
-0.0070483922,
-0.014496021,
-0.036948055,
-0.0012648663,
0.0190988556,
0.0344051607,
-0.0694473684,
0.0789253563,
0.0315563083,
0.0272483844,
0.0007135249,
-0.0486108214,
-0.0148944538,
0.0246149376,
-0.0202289112,
-0.004417459,
0.0322674736,
0.049004823,
0.0345029309,
-0.0245720074,
0.0211061575,
0.0453462303,
0.0069728396,
-0.0004805559,
0.0083727175,
0.0238863006,
-0.0432145111,
0.0185361188,
0.017324442,
-0.034026131,
-0.0258021727,
-0.0467078798,
-0.0198045298,
0.0009874265,
-0.0088668643,
-0.022160124,
-0.0606119744,
-0.0283080209,
0.0022259506,
0.0097744744,
-0.0623680465,
0.0250242129,
0.0457043089,
0.0182965957,
0.0171872769,
0.0323238373,
-0.0890276581,
-0.0109379739,
0.013151045,
0.0066331229,
0.0598254465,
0.0460604653,
-0.0271402039,
-0.047606647,
-0.0193815865,
0.00856297,
0.026495425,
0.0781996921,
-0.0404449813,
-0.0080557941,
-0.0426736362,
0.0084705595,
-0.007274962,
0.0585476011,
-0.0457852781,
0.0126140853,
-0.0334851742,
0.0059124194,
-0.0247717071,
-0.0807758123,
0.0282918494,
0.0316913575,
0.0019961167,
-0.0067350576,
-0.0075951517,
0.0375578254,
0.0042439341,
-0.0579268411,
-0.0058658398,
-0.0327946618,
-0.0057935868,
-0.035479892,
-0.0009806633,
0.0205385238,
-0.0628467798,
0.0445588939,
-0.055829525,
-0.0459964685,
0.040037185,
-0.078620486,
-0.0549891703,
-0.0357866548,
-0.0099434974,
0.018951524,
-0.0595088638,
0.0656775534,
0.0102652824,
0.020665314,
0.0155639471,
0.0012151692,
0.0244232956,
0.0176797975,
-0.0252161585,
-0.001289627,
-0.003073246,
-0.0517846867,
-0.0547029972,
-0.0119247446,
-0.006686253,
0.0417393334,
0.0052003334,
0.0477932021,
-0.0328941494,
-0.0054393229,
-0.0760417506,
-0.0018528913,
-0.0578631163,
0.0279330388,
0.0642029047,
-0.0154249445,
-0.023531625,
-0.0122931376,
0.009728726,
0.0467819609,
-0.0184800364,
-0.0021217712,
0.0682656616,
-0.0368976258,
-0.017631229,
-0.0726955459,
0.0085155368,
-0.0241334513,
-0.0268280748,
0.008432501,
-0.0158942714,
-0.0450581014,
0.0306839459,
-0.02588984,
0.027626738,
0.0529800318,
-0.0763097331,
-0.0218928121,
-0.0076626232,
0.0087329196,
0.0145212347,
-0.0255547669,
0.0055339988,
-0.0172669981,
-0.0384628475,
0.0011184161,
0.0031302823,
0.01354877,
-0.0290089231,
-0.0342979021,
-0.0132415835,
-0.0212430116,
0.0660537258,
0.0160583891,
-0.0358056873,
-0.0148336021,
0.0019913313,
-0.0269474983,
0.0317204744,
0.0126748234,
0.0170831084,
-0.0166217014,
0.0036954924,
-0.0631611869,
0.002322813,
0.0634948015,
0.0052804649,
-0.0073968591,
-0.037188895,
0.0072368663,
-0.0127903568,
-0.0041974699,
0.0074493182,
0.0127078947,
0.0116853407,
-0.0490182415,
-0.0465596169,
0.0403794497,
0.0629283935,
-0.0028901401,
0.0446342267,
-0.0690910965,
0.0308460183,
0.0040727882,
-0.0411824584,
0.0164237656,
-0.0208545849,
-0.0277710501,
-0.026067717,
0.0119442996,
-0.0216185898,
-0.0050249058,
-0.0096957842,
-0.0423665904,
0.072606951,
-0.0092335474,
-0.0103005692,
-0.0238649752,
0.0145872487,
0.0010690009,
0.0541377477,
0.0128373336,
0.0066217738,
0.0322910249,
0.0799407661,
-0.017414324,
0.0505484529,
0.0037814949,
0.0180269741,
0.0242439676,
-0.0150039485,
-0.0595022961,
-0.0199344344,
0.090187639,
-0.0557863526,
-0.046467118,
0.0962218717,
0.0430937372,
-0.007620424,
0.0066328146,
-0.0168091059,
0.0041419216,
0.0113729853,
-0.0146781774,
-0.0903195441,
-0.033955209,
0.0576679185,
0.013416566,
-0.0242331401,
-0.0083019566,
0.0437389463,
-0.1091604307,
0.0746762156,
0.0293808617,
-0.0060278713,
-0.0343548469,
0.0045328974,
0.0360218324,
-0.0170762166,
0.0462457202,
0.030723013,
0.0042742621,
-0.0072810319,
0.0094838319,
-0.0662932992,
-0.0824141875,
0.0051984298,
-0.0475254618,
0.074880518,
0.023867324,
0.0241543688,
0.0159207508,
0.0182607677,
0.0530274659,
0.0120800249,
-0.0501206145,
0.0046791225,
0.0612192973,
0.0252413079,
-0.032869257,
0.0094932904,
0.0716695338,
-0.0447661132,
0.001970479,
0.0145985801,
0.0483204275,
-0.0058829486,
0.0273180306,
0.0265677348,
0.0020934688,
-0.0055699982,
0.0377571583,
0.0469804853,
-0.0351401679,
-0.0372051895,
-0.0811658129,
-0.0171237029,
-0.0495795012,
0.021812845,
0.0646255687,
-0.0065334439,
-0.0188363604,
-0.0762935579,
-0.0764807016,
0.0222910326,
-0.0486562625,
0.0253739376,
-0.0465664119,
-0.0111838114,
-0.0027311873,
0.0096264509,
0.0052742157,
0.0025926125,
0.0067035137,
-0.0565500259,
-0.0303834453,
-0.0165051222,
0.0453815125,
-0.0095736217,
0.010242057,
-0.0461448245,
-0.044000905,
0.0519377775,
0.0252781212,
-0.0044918712,
0.0083381981,
-0.0342952684,
-0.0529335141,
-0.0230875406,
0.0299593154,
-0.0228815731,
0.036561735,
0.0486603938,
-0.0544222482,
0.0035945219,
0.0402376056,
-0.0180854872,
0.0176334996,
0.0063763326,
0.0946346596,
-0.0257288534,
0.0138099073,
0.0581745431,
0.0286486428,
0.0509319901,
0.024505036,
0.0148245357,
-0.0841844082,
0.0453384146,
-0.0478535406,
-0.0366805717,
-0.0292340219,
0.0092133414,
0.0278785154,
-0.0397603959,
-0.0325020552,
0.008861402,
-0.0508129336,
0.0097098462,
-0.0262672883,
-0.0071562459,
0.0410059802,
0.0238499809,
0.0067680343,
-0.0052777743,
0.0006034721,
0.0040915306,
0.0270080585,
0.0106778815,
0.0064071044,
0.018936744,
0.0264688935,
0.0412179716,
-0.0117044738,
-0.0048503913,
-0.023901267,
0.0289029442,
-0.0385624059,
0.0228999835,
0.1293337941,
-0.0097423811,
0.0876499936,
-0.0517435707,
-0.0302005857,
-0.020234365,
0.0422584116,
0.0180797782,
-0.0252312627,
0.0030415507,
-0.006563256,
-0.0120434109,
-0.0410804264,
0.0542424098,
-0.0279017948,
0.0742440447,
-0.0051643555,
-0.0109266983,
-0.0140619725,
-0.0166132841,
0.0231625512,
-0.0438564271,
0.0075237486,
-0.0144973444,
-0.0118007138,
-0.0680870637,
0.0051564337,
0.0447348133,
-0.0003594902,
0.0022983002,
-0.0276768859,
0.0316736437,
-0.0074625211,
-0.0214324817,
-0.0397104584,
-0.039923206,
0.020038804,
-0.0053731455,
-0.060686551,
-5.974932725e-33,
-0.0288375951,
0.0218610372,
-0.0284643769,
0.0065861526,
0.0135681489,
-0.010310824,
-0.0288893282,
0.0121331951,
0.0216975771,
0.0519412644,
-0.0230507702,
0.0704819635,
0.0150271384,
0.0425134189,
0.0624112375,
0.0337192267,
0.0802233815,
0.0061086346,
0.0026647018,
-0.0305222087,
0.0457164496,
0.0295880605,
0.1043627337,
-0.048441954,
0.0482516475,
0.0157152321,
-0.0388878137,
0.0442319736,
-0.0081818895,
0.0411475115,
0.0421505906,
0.0676110759,
0.0190964732,
0.0423775166,
-0.0453493297,
-0.0377009697,
-0.0949759111,
-0.0362832174,
-0.0132277301,
0.0616437905,
-0.0019826109,
-0.0210118815,
0.0268416032,
-0.0279478617,
0.022651324,
-0.0046565025,
0.0306308065,
-0.061091546,
0.0442309119,
0.008570089,
-0.0190599151,
0.0280314945,
-0.0118818255,
0.0140879378,
-0.0424305722,
0.0193664208,
-0.0142343519,
-0.0268556401,
-0.0744561777,
-0.0110717881,
0.0398658216,
0.0513878837,
-0.0187711325,
-0.0462598838,
-0.0373175591,
0.0185749996,
0.0088574309,
0.012734307,
0.002886116,
0.0285818018,
-0.0142374048,
0.0152725643,
-0.0096096667,
0.070549123,
0.0426121652,
-0.0457870774,
-0.0282324236,
0.001771483,
-0.0399802551,
0.0507167876,
-0.0327483304,
-0.0041282233,
-0.014531021,
-0.0313321501,
-0.0185938682,
0.0148720387,
-0.0077631655,
0.0151591813,
0.0299945604,
0.012616802,
-0.0012701181,
-0.0300729312,
-0.0219687652,
-0.0187325366,
-0.0327139311,
-0.0108619956,
0.0013884918,
0.035793189,
-0.0202268045,
0.0269536208,
-0.0192818623,
-0.0457983352,
-0.011587726,
-0.0052336399,
0.0186983719,
-0.0064004133,
0.0982512981,
0.0345515348,
-0.0609553121,
0.0275948178,
0.0163846929,
-0.0011942842,
-0.0174395945,
0.0123935891,
0.004755449,
0.0035218629,
0.0164340585,
-0.0053663296,
0.034254007,
0.041002728,
-0.0320136622,
-0.0277318526,
-0.0310213435,
0.0005008383,
0.0075801285,
0.0060266168,
-0.0373689048,
-0.0259388722,
0.0323286913,
-0.0410554409,
0.0120413722,
-0.0112486016,
2.54e-7,
0.0355781578,
0.0284403488,
0.0242942441,
0.0206432603,
0.0060158633,
-0.002524086,
-0.0117584728,
0.0281667206,
-0.0043020216,
0.0506688915,
0.0557577126,
-0.0046688747,
0.0661910623,
0.0214013979,
-0.0372019149,
0.0106836986,
-0.0375611894,
0.0182133168,
-0.0080387508,
-0.0205558054,
0.0218509436,
0.0714113712,
0.0192559063,
0.0124660386,
0.0120861903,
-0.0373781249,
0.0379626937,
0.0050675543,
-0.0149633735,
0.0730653107,
0.0578002259,
0.0426048227,
0.0283748973,
0.0165274609,
-0.0095351832,
-0.0115488721,
0.0051944926,
0.0322780162,
-0.0163091924,
0.0500506498,
-0.0303978957,
0.0056036026,
-0.0088111171,
-0.027480321,
0.0277140345,
-0.0356999338,
0.0168707054,
0.015684627,
-0.0202731416,
0.0051312912,
0.0059407093,
-0.0278389361,
-0.0285008959,
0.0207215901,
0.0382645018,
0.0316612013,
-0.0286687426,
-0.0303428881,
-0.0233497825,
0.0477643125,
0.0252899565,
-0.0281068534,
0.0533561148,
-0.0164719336,
-0.0093253059,
-0.0326073132,
0.0076107555,
2.013462948e-34,
0.0488187037,
-0.0116510373,
0.0407735594,
0.0063834856,
0.0476520099,
-0.0271099936,
0.0030952005,
0.003466248,
-0.0412670746,
-0.0251466148,
-0.0342926085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14805v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14805v1 | Fine-tuning and aligning question answering models for complex information extraction tasks | 2023-09-26T10:02:21 | 2023-09-26T10:02:21 | Matthias Engelbach, Dennis Klau, Felix Scheerer, Jens Drawehn, Maximilien Kintz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) has boosted performance and
possibilities in various NLP tasks. While the usage of generative AI models
like ChatGPT opens up new opportunities for several business use cases, their
current tendency to hallucinate fake content strongly limits their
applicability to document analysis, such as information retrieval from
documents. In contrast, extractive language models like question answering (QA)
or passage retrieval models guarantee query results to be found within the
boundaries of an according context document, which makes them candidates for
more reliable information extraction in productive environments of companies.
In this work we propose an approach that uses and integrates extractive QA
models for improved feature extraction of German business documents such as
insurance reports or medical leaflets into a document analysis solution. We
further show that fine-tuning existing German QA models boosts performance for
tailored extraction tasks of complex linguistic features like damage cause
explanations or descriptions of medication appearance, even with using only a
small set of annotated data. Finally, we discuss the relevance of scoring
metrics for evaluating information extraction tasks and deduce a combined
metric from Levenshtein distance, F1-Score, Exact Match and ROUGE-L to mimic
the assessment criteria from human experts. | [
0.0630913004,
0.0188961532,
0.0048576146,
0.0607522875,
-0.0621451586,
0.0231502522,
-0.0305280928,
0.0116376672,
0.0218965951,
-0.0392723307,
-0.0111306673,
-0.0170776285,
-0.0349333584,
0.0480053462,
0.0110413916,
-0.0207748469,
0.0441318266,
0.0045193946,
0.0158505533,
0.023910135,
0.0310997069,
0.0214928575,
0.020596005,
0.0084543033,
0.0108530773,
-0.0047932025,
0.0203445554,
-0.0204891674,
0.0145016052,
0.0383963138,
0.0136034507,
-0.0155380256,
-0.0126601746,
0.0186654329,
0.0000015868,
-0.0629322082,
-0.0434443988,
0.0230547097,
-0.0365631282,
-0.0207943358,
0.0257459152,
-0.0246706791,
0.0025803607,
0.0282396823,
-0.0440407954,
0.0104581416,
-0.0005461821,
0.0812223479,
0.0550335087,
0.0922760442,
-0.0246779751,
-0.0627983361,
0.0457821526,
0.0055976477,
0.0433839746,
-0.0905819312,
0.0426721238,
0.0438991636,
0.0410775095,
-0.026430117,
0.0294568781,
0.0430763587,
0.0052083423,
0.0047010481,
-0.0053834594,
0.0039163311,
-0.0254422668,
-0.0009145042,
-0.0106807919,
0.0738860145,
-0.0334387831,
-0.0132315177,
0.0067988457,
-0.0099266609,
0.012000205,
0.0315481573,
-0.0481268279,
0.0222166702,
-0.0436687507,
-0.0254164953,
0.0619883612,
-0.0094833644,
-0.0165572595,
0.0226892792,
-0.0166686773,
0.0349230915,
0.0092377812,
-0.0530685261,
0.0325611271,
0.0139526548,
-0.0554694086,
-0.0244835522,
0.0229826551,
0.0701835379,
0.026094567,
0.037376307,
-0.0143971574,
-0.0225769598,
0.0497451909,
-0.051907625,
-0.0317727253,
-0.0050379061,
-0.0193684995,
0.0823355839,
-0.031643264,
0.0562652238,
0.0021670079,
-0.01547541,
-0.0685416758,
-0.0424060151,
-0.0335283689,
-0.0374594443,
-0.0573738404,
0.0244435128,
-0.0433107726,
-0.0164892804,
0.0051208399,
0.013806805,
0.0279246476,
0.0202573854,
0.0282852799,
0.030045379,
-0.0223230291,
-0.0147737032,
-0.0357532538,
-0.0266283136,
-0.048839394,
-0.0119075999,
-0.0303876288,
-0.0559216961,
0.0007919757,
0.0321860239,
0.0307664573,
-0.0214165729,
0.0286444146,
0.0390798301,
-0.005640822,
-0.0415076502,
-0.0083142221,
-0.0269221794,
0.0195787922,
-0.0568215996,
-0.0172600299,
-0.0273372643,
0.0581570901,
-0.0048442297,
-0.0550956577,
-0.0250184368,
0.0140714012,
0.0271672457,
-0.0488869511,
0.0390690006,
-0.0016905274,
0.0081998827,
0.0401279703,
-0.001517322,
0.0027317735,
0.0256972238,
0.0257074423,
0.0177575741,
0.0699030533,
-0.0037610466,
0.0812829137,
0.0419805646,
0.0054275901,
-0.0428189337,
0.049714487,
0.0762605369,
0.0014715078,
-0.0239375401,
0.0092729814,
0.0433538258,
-0.0040979618,
-0.0192033239,
0.0072528427,
0.0465665981,
0.024033282,
0.0167017598,
-0.0026631719,
0.0109521626,
0.0217450149,
0.0113791898,
0.0099210273,
-0.0126389731,
-0.0474296808,
0.0547091365,
-0.0168732256,
-0.0065548583,
-0.0020105203,
-0.0438988917,
-0.0320414118,
0.0200611204,
0.0113965245,
0.0207776893,
0.0323909149,
0.009059093,
-0.0557775162,
0.0279552881,
-0.0004062545,
-0.021780679,
-0.0093914066,
-0.0418835916,
0.0236373916,
0.0836558491,
0.0809290409,
-0.0572297759,
-0.0250732973,
0.0138761457,
-0.063919805,
0.0289174449,
0.0394983441,
-0.0416487865,
0.0124105653,
-0.0264241863,
0.0044544893,
-0.0219707731,
0.000090284,
0.0197590664,
-0.0184575971,
0.011102207,
0.0124770096,
-0.0456575267,
-0.0309842043,
0.0486727431,
-0.0354587771,
-0.0701903179,
0.0003833023,
0.0066861454,
-0.0047066868,
0.0247747079,
-0.0217302162,
0.0278368983,
0.037425302,
-0.0454258136,
-0.008998068,
-0.0064941873,
0.0159084275,
-0.0084407572,
-0.0097585246,
0.0043726461,
0.0099279815,
-0.0161620714,
-0.0373139605,
-0.0386965051,
-0.0318243355,
-0.0507231802,
-0.0210060403,
-0.0576515906,
-0.0146553088,
0.0178576093,
-0.0008381037,
-0.0659180582,
0.066700913,
0.0424001776,
0.0287766457,
-0.0330190249,
-0.0147062112,
0.0067006219,
-0.0445676669,
0.0067379223,
0.0423561335,
0.0018106352,
0.0466702729,
0.0396031402,
0.005162728,
-0.0163918305,
-0.0244909581,
-0.0817052275,
0.0311619155,
-0.034734223,
0.0579287149,
0.0317185968,
0.0167322252,
-0.0320209786,
-0.0263220407,
-0.0776959583,
-0.0320211127,
0.0671253279,
-0.0008410325,
0.0700885952,
0.0319414772,
-0.0073698456,
-0.0674978271,
0.0098696528,
-0.0085369954,
0.0322904736,
0.0405640081,
-0.0422085971,
-0.0582769662,
0.0271972585,
-0.0383962654,
0.0471171029,
-0.0023075931,
-0.0205438547,
-0.0417608693,
-0.0121538294,
0.0138291875,
0.0953563079,
0.0130440043,
0.0202387236,
-0.0270035714,
0.0215502791,
-0.0381374843,
0.0122439107,
-0.0752246752,
0.0037214865,
-0.0028552366,
-0.0524816997,
0.0763727203,
0.0095961383,
0.0128300842,
0.0095212357,
-0.0215516817,
0.0413356312,
-0.0038184095,
0.0005324163,
-0.025301002,
0.0026576431,
-0.004556099,
0.0716083199,
-0.0016661345,
-0.0082879374,
0.0457025878,
-0.0130872587,
0.0155045027,
-0.0830648914,
-0.0282591879,
-0.079029642,
0.0709268227,
0.0013522814,
0.0135040553,
0.0158248432,
-0.0190185811,
0.0138809178,
-0.0077849803,
0.0245289151,
-0.0494433753,
0.001019039,
-0.0096518472,
0.0440559648,
-0.0128716324,
-0.0400158502,
-0.0487108827,
-0.0772827193,
-0.0013628148,
0.0258408841,
0.0046629859,
0.0123123964,
-0.0488369279,
0.0533307008,
0.0127197346,
0.0324438214,
-0.0343249254,
0.0008220246,
-0.0170818772,
0.0833940282,
0.0816625953,
0.011809458,
0.0240692422,
0.0046769409,
0.0288509764,
0.0479730889,
0.0056790737,
0.0208176896,
0.0284601972,
-0.0223806184,
-0.0267203525,
-0.0778962374,
0.01007153,
-0.0377914645,
0.0039371387,
-0.0717085004,
-0.0239603072,
0.0931130126,
0.0352460817,
0.0101995105,
0.0012398291,
-0.010019023,
-0.015339653,
-0.0064419634,
0.0884350017,
-0.0572380163,
-0.0136585804,
-0.0132567342,
0.0448323227,
-0.0270252544,
0.0014561219,
0.012610876,
-0.1038713902,
0.0554300509,
-0.029516425,
-0.0205371417,
-0.0642694309,
-0.0472029187,
0.0145792235,
-0.0264828727,
-0.000463775,
0.0044463035,
-0.0322100855,
-0.0074831531,
0.0159826186,
-0.0296844393,
-0.0457867347,
0.0213120803,
0.0047754645,
-0.0406637862,
0.0789728239,
0.0148948813,
-0.008567105,
-0.0256518181,
-0.0136574497,
-0.0625615269,
0.0120950341,
0.0063804276,
0.0812856331,
-0.0148293506,
0.0028683941,
0.0107667847,
0.0221562851,
-0.0462155715,
0.0215189625,
0.0340253115,
0.0325023755,
-0.0192845874,
-0.0197449178,
-0.0145458756,
-0.0012978859,
-0.0078505408,
0.0970409736,
0.0096465526,
-0.0176450945,
-0.0713920742,
-0.0306377988,
0.0185013097,
-0.0371974893,
-0.0133811468,
-0.002486279,
-0.0242828112,
-0.0106431264,
-0.1018234342,
-0.0793279931,
0.0171954129,
0.0184880812,
-0.0208410267,
-0.0063250102,
-0.0032126801,
0.0250023957,
-0.0337412581,
0.0278357286,
-0.019524008,
0.0087358942,
-0.02319129,
0.0234134868,
0.0414201841,
-0.0272634383,
-0.0691110566,
-0.0194165222,
-0.0553473085,
-0.03813003,
-0.006490435,
-0.004075713,
0.0215697568,
0.053357508,
-0.0518084839,
-0.0124341929,
0.0237757042,
0.0281826369,
-0.0927181691,
-0.0281411838,
0.0273773056,
-0.0275288355,
-0.0224414282,
0.0268738307,
-0.0656224787,
0.0318366252,
0.0013885488,
0.0551587716,
-0.0265238602,
-0.04254907,
0.0336496308,
0.0577442013,
-0.0364838243,
0.0302700382,
0.0285406224,
-0.0323098451,
0.0055308323,
-0.0011498586,
-0.029354196,
-0.0280229393,
0.0023908177,
0.0111219333,
-0.0252720769,
-0.0090396162,
0.0169228874,
-0.0400343426,
0.0172195472,
-0.0456368439,
0.0068551451,
0.0199576244,
0.0059213233,
-0.0371123478,
-0.0352566391,
-0.0091741337,
0.0125219822,
0.0287321359,
0.0742385611,
-0.005905997,
0.0583791435,
0.0009895125,
-0.0187067688,
-0.0007110821,
0.0341376737,
-0.0810230374,
-0.0366332009,
-0.0588827841,
0.052804444,
0.0271186437,
-0.0177362449,
0.0254914239,
-0.0365186706,
-0.0258023478,
0.0004452989,
-0.0165797304,
0.0207150113,
0.0178749897,
0.0321089625,
0.0335606821,
-0.0311554298,
0.002691603,
0.0675253943,
0.0178340655,
0.0319961533,
-0.0363572463,
-0.0466090664,
-0.0535501838,
-0.0217594374,
0.04097021,
-0.0174011663,
0.0001840754,
-0.0012033044,
-0.0718827173,
-0.0135589577,
0.0272229053,
0.0169819128,
-0.0174226742,
-0.0012356812,
0.0414499529,
0.0920420066,
0.0480227508,
0.006269786,
-0.0595594123,
0.0471515432,
-0.0489247888,
-0.0179356448,
-0.0114570847,
-6.380373217e-33,
-0.0053102369,
-0.0297831353,
0.0101801371,
0.0112422854,
-0.0028020355,
0.0044648033,
-0.0100818677,
-0.0457626134,
-0.023369601,
0.0041007427,
-0.024127353,
0.0040178364,
0.0164330732,
0.001565707,
-0.0360564664,
-0.065779455,
-0.0044567948,
0.0048793871,
-0.0270643458,
0.0178440418,
0.032418333,
0.0274444409,
0.0424934812,
-0.0317182764,
0.0291383751,
-0.0406082049,
0.0064379666,
0.0330256298,
0.0213267375,
0.0729103237,
-0.0333937593,
0.0226603728,
0.0450163335,
-0.058724381,
0.0477307662,
0.0661803484,
-0.0970215499,
-0.0226808414,
0.0206827875,
0.0109571656,
-0.023129167,
-0.0332520083,
0.0223890748,
-0.027298877,
0.0069773733,
0.0256473422,
0.0399076305,
-0.0132994642,
-0.0071142535,
-0.0465430804,
-0.0766522065,
0.0375031568,
-0.0048297695,
-0.0062120305,
0.0344319381,
0.0345467217,
-0.0154980617,
0.0395927951,
0.0105632525,
-0.0426478833,
0.0105985785,
0.0019179108,
0.033033587,
-0.0232777987,
-0.0071907029,
0.0329008438,
0.0046103839,
0.0013173475,
-0.0184490401,
-0.0034805392,
-0.0248744749,
0.0409735516,
0.0459098518,
0.0122810388,
0.0286591295,
0.0175317004,
-0.0367085002,
0.0565403923,
-0.0052408427,
0.0365404785,
0.0016461405,
-0.0312928371,
-0.0667104349,
0.013352938,
0.0034607283,
0.0293283127,
-0.0318934172,
0.0005086267,
0.0303558521,
-0.0051157116,
-0.0263157524,
0.0044766054,
0.0124653205,
-0.0273142047,
0.0512239486,
-0.0039830459,
-0.0091454508,
0.0234786868,
-0.0178367943,
0.0257731695,
-0.0586699732,
0.007177155,
-0.0117019583,
0.0165007208,
-0.0069694202,
0.0028204778,
0.0187795609,
-0.0427503139,
-0.0359774306,
0.011925092,
-0.0119259777,
0.0474811606,
-0.0643753633,
0.0298192482,
0.0219270512,
0.0475756563,
0.002239059,
0.0213215984,
0.0206902269,
0.0119286878,
-0.0356615447,
-0.0272872709,
0.0027425862,
0.0199691579,
-0.04781726,
0.0303271841,
0.0023601216,
0.0154278837,
-0.033048626,
-0.0489432476,
0.0271249749,
0.0502037928,
2.477e-7,
0.0848291367,
0.0426164046,
0.0322635658,
0.0623400174,
0.0203189682,
0.0187600441,
0.0497101098,
0.0003915035,
0.0145507203,
-0.0032616686,
0.03383708,
-0.0011630114,
0.031996958,
0.0389866941,
-0.0618113577,
0.01406979,
-0.0719937086,
-0.0636050701,
-0.0584390014,
0.0036635087,
0.0671270117,
0.0781867504,
-0.0288300868,
-0.0199371744,
-0.0552194156,
-0.0663288459,
0.0224358924,
0.011870753,
-0.0510450043,
0.0446173847,
0.0747214332,
0.0222249161,
0.0277859047,
0.0185978748,
0.0145489229,
0.056726262,
0.052712135,
0.0550810136,
-0.0143982498,
-0.0341403,
-0.0304840431,
-0.0503677465,
0.0459820069,
-0.0372291431,
0.0984667167,
-0.0017252422,
-0.0251842402,
-0.0204342287,
-0.0494034775,
-0.0057737557,
-0.0030219394,
-0.0388205089,
-0.0331017151,
0.066146791,
0.0253015682,
-0.0360635072,
-0.002176119,
-0.0229273699,
0.0196272414,
0.0314172171,
-0.0072486848,
-0.0057797385,
0.0011763844,
0.015016065,
-0.0271483697,
-0.0389703922,
-0.0187296662,
2.169957061e-34,
0.0423284769,
-0.0025068657,
-0.0226011481,
0.0279183816,
0.0340422057,
0.0127541618,
0.0007754617,
0.0170918088,
-0.0084405476,
-0.084419325,
-0.0038506733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14779v1 | Exploring Small Language Models with Prompt-Learning Paradigm for Efficient Domain-Specific Text Classification | 2023-09-26T09:24:46 | 2023-09-26T09:24:46 | Hengyu Luo, Peng Liu, Stefan Esping | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Domain-specific text classification faces the challenge of scarce labeled
data due to the high cost of manual labeling. Prompt-learning, known for its
efficiency in few-shot scenarios, is proposed as an alternative to traditional
fine-tuning methods. And besides, although large language models (LLMs) have
gained prominence, small language models (SLMs, with under 1B parameters) offer
significant customizability, adaptability, and cost-effectiveness for
domain-specific tasks, given industry constraints. In this study, we
investigate the potential of SLMs combined with prompt-learning paradigm for
domain-specific text classification, specifically within customer-agent
interactions in retail. Our evaluations show that, in few-shot settings when
prompt-based model fine-tuning is possible, T5-base, a typical SLM with 220M
parameters, achieve approximately 75% accuracy with limited labeled data (up to
15% of full data), which shows great potentials of SLMs with prompt-learning.
Based on this, We further validate the effectiveness of active few-shot
sampling and the ensemble strategy in the prompt-learning pipeline that
contribute to a remarkable performance gain. Besides, in zero-shot settings
with a fixed model, we underscore a pivotal observation that, although the
GPT-3.5-turbo equipped with around 154B parameters garners an accuracy of
55.16%, the power of well designed prompts becomes evident when the
FLAN-T5-large, a model with a mere 0.5% of GPT-3.5-turbo's parameters, achieves
an accuracy exceeding 31% with the optimized prompt, a leap from its sub-18%
performance with an unoptimized one. Our findings underscore the promise of
prompt-learning in classification tasks with SLMs, emphasizing the benefits of
active few-shot sampling, and ensemble strategies in few-shot settings, and the
importance of prompt engineering in zero-shot settings. | [
0.0619369969,
-0.0091198813,
-0.0236737393,
0.0175422244,
-0.0316590481,
0.0137395812,
0.0942436382,
-0.0025671332,
0.0087927645,
-0.1060368866,
-0.053909868,
-0.0540316738,
0.0106778285,
0.0165356286,
-0.0232968684,
-0.0344696306,
0.0147174709,
-0.0066262307,
0.0159803145,
-0.0050849481,
0.0006926045,
0.022553008,
0.010143646,
0.0256103687,
0.0228659455,
-0.0296501257,
0.0019310013,
-0.0056477971,
-0.0002155543,
-0.0021528821,
0.0592230782,
0.0746373683,
0.0467102528,
0.0567487143,
0.0000020142,
-0.0643155277,
-0.0255554188,
-0.007329395,
-0.0854190737,
0.0084205298,
0.0688710362,
0.0217317697,
0.008353564,
0.0231175367,
-0.0163671467,
-0.0142763369,
0.0323608853,
0.0694889724,
0.0074658296,
0.0606402308,
-0.0156384818,
-0.0244693533,
-0.0404634885,
-0.0441614576,
-0.0004577451,
-0.0591833405,
0.033333689,
-0.0812798738,
0.0042124861,
0.0295543838,
0.0041531837,
0.0166452806,
-0.0093743466,
0.0008383844,
0.0030841313,
0.0444274023,
0.007905989,
0.0079132682,
-0.0183323789,
0.0498606712,
-0.0090822671,
-0.0008436544,
-0.0034942154,
-0.0469197147,
0.0116702765,
-0.0173580609,
-0.0175373685,
-0.0062043904,
-0.0070976969,
-0.0077912863,
-0.0534165688,
0.0388697758,
0.0108168134,
0.0081292158,
-0.0114102308,
0.0352091379,
-0.0276932009,
-0.0447241031,
0.0226584226,
0.0135143949,
-0.0151671041,
-0.039727401,
-0.0175914969,
0.0017104177,
-0.035536103,
0.0051401351,
-0.0156525336,
-0.0004490111,
0.020432435,
-0.0168697517,
0.0209200215,
-0.0065197288,
-0.0119906403,
0.0552601553,
-0.0179652181,
0.0292215366,
0.0373183079,
-0.0018413748,
-0.0438965484,
0.0417372473,
-0.0648412704,
-0.0099306144,
-0.0456101932,
0.0324181616,
-0.0316878073,
-0.0242831986,
-0.0510138646,
0.0140853813,
0.0309435967,
-0.0034468891,
0.0108478423,
-0.0022824404,
-0.0244966131,
-0.0091684731,
-0.0223638117,
0.0079942541,
-0.0240741037,
0.038355343,
-0.0123629775,
-0.0483352058,
0.005604459,
0.0236472841,
-0.0012230785,
-0.0181529224,
0.0103304889,
0.0026096343,
-0.0026241459,
-0.1022264659,
-0.054663796,
0.0002612386,
-0.0457143448,
-0.0651445463,
-0.0349797755,
-0.0304004736,
0.0147736035,
0.0247462615,
-0.0076443669,
-0.0268225353,
-0.0058767265,
0.0110031031,
-0.0228753965,
0.0552759208,
-0.0004821376,
-0.004466027,
0.0437651202,
-0.0279789176,
-0.0031093461,
0.0696619377,
0.0068933978,
0.0696868524,
0.0462075546,
0.0102351587,
0.0198271591,
0.0236494523,
0.0106573235,
-0.004992757,
0.0021964598,
0.0103606647,
0.0234020501,
0.0105056474,
0.0115303714,
0.0159407891,
-0.0169828832,
-0.001057676,
0.0768919066,
0.0325822011,
0.0022360329,
-0.0210213047,
0.0275719408,
0.0707570985,
-0.013873159,
-0.039178405,
-0.0100633148,
-0.0261403564,
-0.036618948,
-0.0074223592,
0.0188732017,
0.0085750604,
-0.0480050817,
-0.0234503783,
-0.0051316707,
-0.0203055535,
-0.0275048129,
0.0529270172,
0.0601223223,
-0.0256908089,
-0.0462195128,
0.0339585692,
0.0162628163,
0.0033026603,
-0.0478848405,
-0.0419765562,
0.0222883523,
0.0393247381,
0.0075496132,
-0.0313187949,
-0.0003680192,
-0.0634283945,
0.0422940738,
0.0548074618,
0.0988833234,
-0.0123112155,
-0.0111511927,
-0.0377773941,
-0.0308277775,
-0.000927948,
0.0123918904,
0.0320627689,
-0.0082986364,
0.0082762986,
0.0251005646,
0.0252357647,
-0.0093908887,
0.0305431616,
-0.0097674234,
-0.0749893785,
0.0427494161,
0.0351351462,
0.0150775369,
0.0115832807,
-0.0218197629,
-0.0291197356,
0.0014437635,
-0.0093242005,
-0.0254690517,
-0.0426587947,
-0.0117854681,
-0.0348873883,
0.008556244,
0.1012581512,
-0.0041992678,
-0.0165279061,
-0.0558076762,
-0.0363177098,
-0.0534294695,
-0.0270439666,
-0.0154931555,
-0.0529451855,
0.02287836,
-0.0216439255,
0.0403907485,
-0.0527611673,
0.0562630221,
0.0280558057,
0.0150759714,
-0.0077708852,
0.0239972472,
0.042419713,
-0.0365080945,
-0.0422795527,
-0.008483829,
0.0176121462,
0.0138395615,
0.0374329872,
0.0064959629,
-0.0084380843,
-0.0079244385,
-0.0683135241,
0.0117349587,
-0.0148924701,
-0.0242802054,
-0.0374230705,
0.0108841853,
-0.0304881241,
-0.0164688416,
-0.0297220405,
0.006647863,
0.0039416547,
0.0455744937,
0.0133304084,
0.0359930582,
-0.0547951087,
0.0072597447,
0.0223034061,
0.0165963583,
0.0419476703,
0.0236508437,
-0.0380673818,
-0.0712401643,
-0.0066357814,
-0.0016367508,
-0.0009509842,
0.0065718195,
-0.0060689012,
-0.0336969756,
-0.012743568,
-0.0191712882,
0.0411734469,
0.0065990291,
0.0059928005,
-0.0105281854,
0.0029978538,
-0.0517865121,
0.0170506667,
-0.0485836752,
-0.0415291376,
-0.0211180206,
0.019857062,
0.0181862339,
0.0731674656,
-0.0090797003,
0.012116299,
-0.0671089068,
0.021348346,
0.0224108994,
-0.0106374007,
-0.071574606,
0.0295261461,
-0.028568903,
0.060383115,
0.0200171992,
-0.0635626912,
0.0565865673,
0.0025257224,
0.0115363542,
-0.0636277571,
-0.0325517245,
-0.0231635533,
0.0297145937,
-0.0102899056,
0.0131612383,
0.0492991991,
-0.0361143239,
-0.0403770693,
0.0086195897,
0.0116636893,
-0.0092623532,
0.0335649028,
-0.0076694251,
0.0431343019,
-0.0342781246,
-0.0662239641,
-0.0430094935,
-0.0900399908,
-0.0334643237,
0.0068797609,
0.0260634404,
0.0083943997,
-0.0779817924,
0.0463961288,
0.0031410013,
0.0705353543,
-0.0399132967,
-0.0117003461,
0.006430272,
0.0020338327,
0.0378252491,
0.0046016672,
-0.0011433113,
-0.0452406742,
0.052593682,
-0.0049709599,
0.0207731221,
-0.0123955375,
-0.0139358435,
-0.0173477475,
0.0333312489,
-0.04816458,
-0.0155718932,
0.032159593,
0.000355193,
-0.0203171205,
0.0137545969,
0.1182362065,
0.0031320031,
-0.0749012828,
-0.0241761077,
0.0305150468,
0.0009837438,
0.0069071432,
0.0393927693,
-0.0374103636,
-0.0371893272,
0.0136963772,
0.0474180877,
-0.014678889,
-0.0153205125,
-0.0218065027,
-0.1175377741,
0.0414447635,
-0.0153459832,
-0.027362382,
-0.016731929,
-0.0354788192,
-0.0069242674,
0.0156211918,
0.0526031144,
-0.0040074298,
-0.0074981735,
-0.0385679714,
0.0258199945,
-0.0035845356,
-0.0734516755,
0.0367779918,
-0.0047192168,
0.0222218037,
0.0466073677,
0.0037073574,
0.0133419335,
-0.0098142074,
0.0293582063,
-0.0125732291,
0.0256766323,
-0.0086848577,
0.0682533681,
-0.0288941301,
0.0247116685,
0.0455525704,
-0.0002781435,
-0.0311095398,
0.0198661126,
0.0113140373,
0.044214163,
-0.0075975475,
-0.0080240704,
0.0085726185,
-0.0103904363,
0.0086253118,
0.0839963108,
0.0039812932,
-0.0769221038,
-0.0501176566,
-0.0112770088,
-0.0411906913,
0.0120121567,
-0.0004971463,
0.0252674036,
-0.0257949233,
-0.0677180961,
-0.0395301282,
-0.0371818282,
0.037626937,
0.0431745499,
0.0157874078,
0.0429953896,
-0.0375402942,
0.0583884083,
-0.0061436351,
-0.0055736098,
-0.0487653427,
0.0500150733,
-0.0854688883,
0.0248917341,
0.0569675788,
-0.0505628362,
-0.0318450555,
-0.0125639699,
-0.0807916373,
-0.0612896942,
-0.0064930869,
0.0235137455,
0.0244096741,
0.0392942838,
0.0096316626,
-0.0851028562,
0.048028823,
0.0917464793,
-0.0482550636,
0.0113234418,
-0.0003022953,
0.0061663082,
-0.0507707633,
0.0253625792,
-0.0699283779,
0.0531018712,
0.0431602448,
-0.0116253449,
-0.0177470092,
-0.0399556011,
-0.0006392747,
-0.0100764986,
0.0731436387,
-0.0173243545,
-0.046348881,
-0.0276980642,
0.0558900833,
0.0294595156,
-0.0121632311,
-0.0373871103,
-0.0328076147,
-0.0001259615,
-0.0224048365,
-0.0125386054,
-0.0111061288,
-0.0014138413,
0.0469282418,
-0.0287084654,
-0.0195899196,
-0.0045870747,
0.021318214,
0.0326319821,
0.000870909,
-0.0365090407,
-0.001275259,
0.0463265032,
0.0142627051,
0.0048776222,
0.0720785782,
0.0352511555,
0.0248957183,
-0.0381497592,
0.0232678186,
-0.0292152166,
-0.0329783894,
-0.0411407724,
0.0163614452,
0.0253413469,
-0.015207272,
-0.0029460827,
-0.0346041732,
-0.0176359527,
-0.0325549245,
0.0146899996,
0.017427884,
-0.0187559649,
0.0459891632,
0.0166143309,
-0.0403339826,
0.0425748006,
0.0778359994,
0.0019295671,
0.0156569984,
0.010098448,
-0.023707401,
-0.0738738328,
0.0082425075,
0.0462790504,
0.0192494802,
0.0023841599,
0.0105607184,
-0.0870312452,
-0.0006296273,
0.0419272482,
-0.0524132997,
-0.0079740006,
-0.0390985422,
0.0610448495,
0.0576377772,
0.0027343545,
0.0034021402,
-0.0345345959,
-0.0009659255,
0.0052988948,
0.0035426631,
-0.0085185217,
-5.720566768e-33,
-0.0179783329,
0.0009293016,
0.0071547469,
0.0435115844,
0.0021427148,
-0.01052537,
0.0151451426,
-0.0199211296,
0.0346219726,
-0.0074934857,
-0.0313966237,
-0.0171805359,
0.0285080746,
0.0179079212,
0.0006704469,
-0.0266339537,
0.0830591619,
-0.0354864523,
-0.0352924727,
0.0574282482,
0.0205974523,
0.0590480566,
0.0323597789,
-0.0318904631,
0.0141893774,
-0.0270772874,
-0.0071424721,
0.0216120277,
0.0328917988,
0.0604741797,
-0.0208238605,
0.0698033497,
0.0163920838,
-0.0601173043,
0.0245188475,
0.0547413528,
-0.0320293531,
-0.0093301414,
-0.0208766665,
0.0208376944,
0.0540738776,
-0.0023791166,
-0.0120357284,
-0.0036388338,
-0.0160143711,
0.0240205284,
0.0393666737,
-0.0366535485,
-0.0423813276,
-0.04491942,
-0.031505011,
0.0273719393,
0.0212143622,
-0.016633898,
0.0548998788,
0.0672800466,
0.0011479969,
0.048664093,
-0.0536518842,
0.007781887,
0.0263922159,
0.0050458843,
0.0086182235,
0.0432079434,
-0.0164094139,
0.0547642857,
0.0359697938,
0.0405709781,
0.01179724,
0.0025429113,
0.0196725316,
0.0267141461,
-0.0099736247,
0.0769184604,
0.0222925227,
-0.0173883028,
-0.0458503403,
0.0366181135,
0.0883500502,
-0.035407234,
0.0598180704,
-0.0168975275,
-0.0565668009,
-0.0543399267,
-0.0064076129,
-0.0071145743,
-0.0346552655,
-0.0134960227,
0.0397256725,
0.0476785824,
-0.0244301222,
-0.0058958852,
0.0619824678,
-0.0233489852,
-0.0667914301,
-0.0070307101,
0.0030898624,
0.0189787187,
0.0203137845,
-0.0270690396,
-0.0865716338,
-0.0524889678,
-0.0086178891,
-0.0081485407,
-0.0082554473,
-0.0064333347,
0.0312576406,
0.0318800211,
-0.0603982918,
0.0100843981,
0.0354894064,
0.0152183464,
-0.013461926,
0.0519830287,
0.007836761,
0.0252020843,
0.0065491288,
0.0780767873,
0.0181320589,
-0.0524227507,
0.0202431884,
-0.010299162,
0.0025526613,
-0.0045406045,
-0.0242562741,
-0.0057246587,
0.0102351224,
0.0188171566,
0.0359087102,
-0.0423146077,
0.0011013275,
0.004999477,
2.683e-7,
0.0000927615,
0.0494971424,
-0.0465746,
-0.022142414,
0.0259317569,
0.0731088445,
0.0131176161,
0.0041578496,
0.0236979239,
-0.0239721704,
0.0212667938,
-0.0305562131,
0.0513621829,
0.0068303975,
-0.1082142591,
0.0171048418,
-0.0302611124,
0.0557653494,
-0.0712408274,
0.0160549041,
0.0310077369,
0.1057173014,
0.0391127393,
-0.0385710485,
-0.0062670819,
-0.0269661527,
0.0577942058,
-0.050036218,
0.0118297227,
0.0347060375,
0.0429773182,
-0.0036285243,
-0.0372544564,
0.0381950364,
-0.003789807,
0.0716084763,
-0.0141963465,
0.0617747232,
0.018034894,
0.0097399559,
0.016900694,
-0.0141955866,
-0.00495716,
-0.0520428345,
0.0598567314,
-0.0956873223,
-0.0139196478,
-0.0046322462,
0.0020410873,
-0.0670405626,
0.0193284191,
-0.0094111431,
-0.0109651154,
0.0229696073,
0.0087629268,
-0.0288184173,
-0.0071831569,
-0.0909005702,
0.0357847214,
-0.0001617816,
-0.0595544018,
-0.0305870622,
-0.0190135073,
0.013630949,
0.02346191,
-0.0397755988,
0.0411792286,
2.6301856e-34,
0.0336034857,
-0.0284119211,
-0.0337804854,
0.0261394735,
-0.0224624984,
-0.0095612025,
0.018177744,
0.0249610767,
0.0512784272,
-0.0901354775,
0.0065578423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14774v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14774v1 | BLIP-Adapter: Parameter-Efficient Transfer Learning for Mobile Screenshot Captioning | 2023-09-26T09:16:44 | 2023-09-26T09:16:44 | Ching-Yu Chiang, I-Hua Chang, Shih-Wei Liao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.HC | This study aims to explore efficient tuning methods for the screenshot
captioning task. Recently, image captioning has seen significant advancements,
but research in captioning tasks for mobile screens remains relatively scarce.
Current datasets and use cases describing user behaviors within product
screenshots are notably limited. Consequently, we sought to fine-tune
pre-existing models for the screenshot captioning task. However, fine-tuning
large pre-trained models can be resource-intensive, requiring considerable
time, computational power, and storage due to the vast number of parameters in
image captioning models. To tackle this challenge, this study proposes a
combination of adapter methods, which necessitates tuning only the additional
modules on the model. These methods are originally designed for vision or
language tasks, and our intention is to apply them to address similar
challenges in screenshot captioning. By freezing the parameters of the image
caption models and training only the weights associated with the methods,
performance comparable to fine-tuning the entire model can be achieved, while
significantly reducing the number of parameters. This study represents the
first comprehensive investigation into the effectiveness of combining adapters
within the context of the screenshot captioning task. Through our experiments
and analyses, this study aims to provide valuable insights into the application
of adapters in vision-language models and contribute to the development of
efficient tuning techniques for the screenshot captioning task. Our study is
available at https://github.com/RainYuGG/BLIP-Adapter | [
0.0258272924,
0.0218975525,
-0.0071893558,
0.0343630649,
0.019591473,
0.0257303584,
0.0375282913,
-0.0042209974,
-0.0038041573,
-0.0834909603,
-0.0410393849,
-0.006095394,
0.0086493865,
0.0262654163,
-0.001819351,
-0.0983490422,
0.0102344118,
-0.0071489164,
-0.030044686,
0.0353891477,
0.0136053795,
0.02568,
0.0314011313,
0.0235810503,
-0.0234292671,
-0.000817882,
0.0253150836,
0.0530458577,
0.0358577743,
-0.0182858668,
-0.0029488658,
0.0795894042,
0.0346718468,
0.0040619001,
0.0000017605,
0.0002515752,
-0.0186496787,
0.001401844,
0.0399494134,
0.0201011393,
0.0777738243,
-0.0349882022,
-0.0021784892,
0.0128557384,
-0.0330939516,
-0.0051677749,
0.0670759901,
0.0594476648,
0.0474977531,
0.0544436388,
-0.0186206512,
-0.0158140939,
-0.0060358997,
-0.035554722,
0.0296080969,
-0.0334007218,
-0.0002964623,
0.0353603549,
0.0062828874,
0.0031270017,
-0.0150310257,
0.037331447,
-0.0185975414,
-0.0175213963,
0.0093538649,
0.0223223418,
-0.0039072214,
-0.0090417191,
-0.0444367453,
0.0819259807,
-0.0180639904,
0.0239277184,
-0.0225497913,
-0.0102808373,
0.0065891044,
0.0069770361,
-0.067259945,
-0.0216582548,
0.0205457266,
0.0220168866,
-0.0657564178,
0.0047698626,
0.0269028042,
-0.0264189057,
-0.0116913496,
-0.0568435714,
0.0108929221,
0.0341687426,
-0.0258036386,
0.043041721,
-0.0361846201,
-0.041145131,
0.0413078554,
-0.0062321378,
0.027014887,
-0.0130564459,
-0.0528946668,
-0.0415496975,
-0.0324981883,
-0.0117577519,
0.0591748171,
-0.0077111721,
-0.0223840736,
0.0769391954,
-0.0438815616,
0.0133980708,
0.003676621,
0.047553096,
-0.0332004018,
0.017280018,
-0.0636644363,
0.0065832608,
-0.0307468008,
0.0198732466,
-0.0336367525,
-0.0418000035,
-0.0369310826,
0.0016415082,
0.0054132305,
-0.0387426019,
0.0068079634,
0.0233667828,
-0.0393221602,
-0.000366109,
-0.0010624834,
0.0348449163,
0.0078571904,
0.0153423464,
0.0172513481,
-0.0470106341,
-0.0113790017,
0.0168098621,
0.0628719255,
-0.0192802604,
-0.0075714355,
0.0252314527,
-0.028967062,
-0.0401328616,
-0.0044399188,
0.0272273868,
-0.0545804314,
0.0056249383,
0.0119329952,
-0.0543137528,
0.032326676,
-0.0255236756,
0.0125119099,
-0.0360073932,
-0.0013508911,
0.0396495461,
-0.0230116509,
0.0950656831,
-0.0167456809,
0.0059145503,
-0.0000453645,
0.027419189,
-0.0535041317,
0.050179746,
0.0446996912,
0.0591549277,
0.0260039996,
-0.048755005,
0.0446447469,
0.0503525771,
0.0038428628,
-0.0128055299,
-0.0138762202,
0.0006121924,
0.008139465,
-0.0203723442,
0.0416759998,
0.0143923862,
-0.0224982444,
0.0416557156,
0.0903321654,
0.041669067,
-0.000340479,
0.0024250168,
0.0169618297,
0.0136515731,
0.0060652643,
-0.0232071597,
-0.0371323526,
0.0433747657,
0.0230820123,
-0.000151093,
-0.007323252,
0.0392788313,
-0.0419682376,
-0.0412569046,
-0.0072437353,
-0.0221557375,
0.0216729529,
-0.0164751988,
0.0273983683,
0.0136325452,
-0.0448743962,
0.0757886097,
0.0050707152,
-0.0208052024,
-0.0207759626,
-0.0528998822,
-0.0029863925,
0.0628365055,
0.0009575562,
-0.0029554788,
-0.040268112,
-0.0256317481,
0.0568357557,
0.0264988318,
0.0249094181,
0.0211188085,
0.0248707552,
-0.0409491099,
-0.0418197922,
-0.0194752403,
0.020953007,
0.0199793708,
-0.0051380848,
0.0199228246,
0.0404834859,
0.0186358243,
-0.1029543281,
0.030582726,
0.0681158826,
-0.0429304354,
0.0260830019,
0.0102648847,
-0.0054883072,
-0.0137930224,
-0.013991856,
-0.0158817414,
0.0023451301,
-0.0177510921,
0.0162060186,
0.0508797355,
-0.049207408,
-0.0419491827,
0.0037677325,
-0.0426006615,
0.0196067803,
0.0272671022,
-0.0459331907,
-0.0242575202,
0.0219151583,
0.0069840853,
-0.000844228,
-0.0361638442,
0.0337573364,
-0.0236540157,
0.0591133162,
0.0140642431,
0.022007782,
0.0392314717,
-0.0620634891,
0.0119140605,
-0.0299682487,
-0.03821069,
-0.0125594735,
-0.0200496241,
-0.0137791624,
-0.026252808,
0.0415700264,
0.0140238423,
0.056347385,
-0.0425089188,
-0.0181162637,
-0.0835833102,
0.0039344812,
-0.010441442,
-0.0032050507,
0.0198897589,
0.0396520868,
0.014765582,
-0.0317886174,
-0.0185787901,
0.0064790891,
-0.0079333289,
0.0271666497,
0.0256502796,
0.016600715,
-0.0205353405,
-0.041787155,
0.019232573,
0.02584452,
0.0380392708,
-0.0088209929,
-0.027008703,
-0.0305104926,
-0.0312536545,
0.0257417802,
-0.0293244328,
0.0184152666,
-0.0167526733,
-0.0043149628,
0.0248825476,
-0.0141094588,
0.0656972304,
0.0165099371,
0.0405755378,
-0.0207863525,
0.0026317593,
-0.0343703553,
0.0253947861,
-0.0055633043,
-0.0555594526,
-0.0104460334,
-0.0489490591,
-0.0042383904,
0.0767683536,
-0.0696263462,
0.0499206223,
-0.0638483837,
0.0467434786,
-0.017645523,
-0.0445804261,
-0.0338158607,
0.0491531566,
-0.0033840374,
-0.0033509375,
-0.0625693575,
-0.0891944021,
-0.0110500427,
-0.0357044339,
-0.0317481793,
0.0074034394,
0.0003707292,
-0.0152827548,
0.0557539687,
0.000456588,
0.028359076,
0.0091194464,
-0.0201029666,
0.0034476253,
-0.0390360653,
0.0264961701,
-0.0173196718,
0.0449657552,
-0.0224254522,
-0.0052652927,
-0.0476331711,
-0.0411245115,
0.0118817082,
-0.0152868535,
-0.0301692635,
-0.022495009,
-0.0356980711,
-0.0353347622,
-0.0575334467,
0.0649825707,
0.0058444948,
0.0336959101,
0.0079012858,
-0.0170953181,
-0.0028274623,
0.0342089348,
0.0559325553,
0.0311103705,
-0.037136998,
0.0016779576,
0.0193114057,
0.0371011458,
0.0071205008,
0.0230463166,
-0.049419485,
0.0152314464,
0.0208993927,
0.0309548993,
-0.0178187545,
0.0373801626,
0.0978143662,
-0.0571913719,
-0.0015312462,
0.1046913564,
-0.0161288213,
-0.0217043087,
-0.0181988049,
0.0345762931,
0.0084273107,
0.0088455435,
0.039515201,
-0.0594656803,
-0.0813357905,
-0.0393422395,
0.0120030725,
0.0384654701,
0.034020219,
-0.043539267,
-0.0251905397,
0.0347064808,
0.0221194588,
-0.0376240797,
-0.0403514095,
-0.0131339831,
-0.0002807915,
-0.0392080471,
-0.0176820774,
-0.0339618362,
-0.0415633619,
-0.0009381949,
0.0186351314,
-0.0085818199,
-0.0515475012,
0.0226112958,
-0.0285578705,
-0.0234490801,
0.0465342514,
0.0108309779,
0.006330118,
-0.0236782562,
-0.0409708358,
-0.0342427455,
0.008829359,
-0.0117389057,
0.0577038378,
0.0002114654,
-0.034838073,
0.0277152453,
0.0312632062,
-0.0651048794,
-0.0130978497,
0.0178197715,
0.0344649106,
0.0673484728,
-0.0255624373,
-0.0296648517,
0.000913198,
0.0104167666,
0.0556128845,
0.0380100384,
-0.0447276868,
-0.0367573649,
0.0025086422,
-0.0643933788,
-0.0943135023,
-0.0163505115,
-0.0241035316,
-0.0095186457,
-0.0293131955,
-0.0830226243,
-0.0054286718,
0.0467496626,
0.0512212142,
0.0020280173,
0.0117622633,
-0.0092910668,
0.0387531184,
-0.0405285172,
0.0482360125,
-0.050275892,
0.0064786514,
-0.022532722,
-0.0167390127,
0.0478798747,
-0.0099877054,
-0.0171985775,
0.0112424968,
-0.0777293891,
-0.0250208117,
-0.0474830121,
0.077440016,
0.0165617745,
0.0546425991,
-0.0171532668,
-0.0179347359,
0.0336582214,
0.0615780652,
0.0582628995,
-0.0083282711,
0.0222935304,
-0.0177879147,
-0.0426928401,
0.0136047173,
-0.0242844764,
0.0134758186,
0.0103778793,
-0.0008512717,
-0.0354099944,
-0.0507700257,
-0.0214844719,
-0.021344332,
0.0169148967,
-0.0013948284,
-0.0319479033,
-0.0088373953,
0.0175258126,
0.0117188469,
0.0148502197,
-0.067768909,
-0.0092522567,
0.0188804753,
0.0313543789,
-0.0136923753,
-0.0305599626,
0.0211151224,
-0.0021842173,
-0.020292744,
0.0250391904,
-0.0045441641,
-0.0170959849,
-0.0242660623,
0.0193805695,
0.0024619419,
0.0157771669,
0.0403777361,
0.0322950818,
-0.048858963,
0.0045495918,
-0.0017774922,
-0.0061478396,
-0.0221322346,
0.0827157199,
-0.0016669671,
0.0067950883,
-0.0697447211,
0.0218811929,
0.0359615907,
-0.0411343053,
0.0833899528,
0.0234532207,
-0.0065666474,
-0.0228597224,
0.0622526854,
-0.0238845274,
0.0055065057,
0.0233282559,
0.0092951301,
0.0122047486,
-0.0067001926,
0.0709070861,
-0.0153703084,
0.0311525743,
0.0239576921,
-0.0343866348,
-0.0387068763,
0.0138107268,
-0.0132771144,
-0.0376069359,
-0.0052060052,
0.047147423,
-0.0073300274,
-0.0453829616,
0.039855063,
-0.0573267713,
0.022159731,
0.0535290688,
0.0422817469,
0.0191500895,
0.007668233,
0.0082184458,
-0.0066874931,
-0.0623035058,
-0.0499117151,
0.0409041308,
0.0134497611,
-5.496269589e-33,
-0.0534824505,
-0.0208002385,
0.0137626566,
-0.001682255,
-0.0309320092,
0.0117854048,
-0.012276439,
0.0223008357,
-0.0081059495,
-0.0091434792,
-0.0112651903,
-0.0356345661,
0.0350952111,
0.0673194081,
-0.0192714781,
0.0062542269,
0.0582444705,
-0.0050919978,
-0.0364409871,
0.0240658484,
0.0300874207,
0.0001375984,
0.0346324928,
-0.0238311365,
-0.0660241246,
0.0196183138,
-0.0345371738,
-0.027553048,
0.0763906315,
0.0669166744,
0.0022983057,
0.0137172351,
0.010392515,
-0.0051992252,
-0.0315650143,
0.047916282,
-0.0662516057,
-0.0064316969,
0.0119442921,
0.0615738481,
-0.0144229019,
-0.0378087014,
0.027724335,
-0.01785185,
0.0025621185,
-0.0406923033,
0.041930221,
-0.0453536846,
-0.0145640215,
0.0253726654,
-0.0535098612,
0.0128628546,
-0.0146900238,
-0.0321939997,
0.0511955023,
0.0418089181,
-0.0018883871,
0.0227394998,
-0.0444466993,
-0.0011314941,
0.0161901005,
0.0327732787,
0.0989949405,
0.0631927326,
0.0173211806,
0.0218733624,
-0.0006957676,
-0.0139723159,
0.0030937679,
0.0008539802,
0.0238927789,
0.0931191817,
0.0237445273,
0.0412218869,
0.0503729396,
-0.0240198504,
-0.0084192427,
0.0359914266,
-0.0458117239,
0.0227593128,
0.0224476997,
0.0212588292,
0.0017500245,
0.0197013933,
-0.0384529419,
-0.0218190607,
-0.04030459,
-0.0537300296,
0.0396382138,
0.0257933997,
-0.0789152905,
0.0459592342,
0.0768586993,
-0.0214081686,
0.0271850005,
-0.0460108407,
-0.0146068158,
0.0319638066,
-0.0342531577,
-0.0417815186,
-0.0172175989,
-0.0585175678,
0.0495184436,
0.0292167608,
0.0418150015,
-0.0034941249,
0.0751032531,
0.0170701686,
-0.0421296358,
-0.0175015051,
-0.0386577807,
0.0305253863,
-0.0564486682,
0.0540724061,
0.0401150435,
0.0003658332,
-0.097734794,
0.0184165109,
-0.0418036133,
-0.0108934147,
-0.0185344778,
-0.031356968,
0.0226635691,
0.0117444498,
-0.0471543223,
0.0209644027,
-0.0341826268,
-0.0388562307,
0.0264739972,
-0.0648448318,
-0.0671047121,
0.0374024175,
2.414e-7,
0.0075321412,
0.0363448896,
-0.0071052825,
-0.0138554368,
0.0164625999,
0.0567720756,
-0.0000496637,
0.0306142364,
0.0074562239,
0.0113577917,
0.009918021,
0.0392156206,
0.0627544522,
-0.0351723321,
-0.0354349352,
-0.0015739353,
-0.04784384,
0.0557595231,
0.0087882634,
-0.030831106,
0.0204627849,
0.0636403188,
-0.0041624065,
-0.0323215276,
0.0390278623,
-0.1013252586,
0.0849862546,
-0.0546434969,
0.0402956307,
0.0068092481,
0.023457801,
0.0692844465,
-0.0397586711,
0.0218389072,
-0.0295596439,
-0.0014242096,
0.0510227159,
0.0571644381,
-0.0258013289,
0.0064243749,
-0.0369876735,
0.0352403633,
0.0018669377,
-0.0430242568,
0.0518285185,
-0.0906451643,
-0.0341323987,
-0.0479713827,
-0.0149184652,
-0.0000290323,
0.0170801114,
-0.0214896128,
-0.0112666041,
0.0208918657,
0.0438961238,
0.0103226192,
-0.0884018466,
-0.0794750154,
-0.0080030058,
0.0091723055,
0.0258681867,
-0.0387211591,
-0.1026028693,
-0.0083519416,
0.038084086,
0.0012225413,
-0.0157814343,
1.855471685e-34,
0.0105791073,
-0.0424679108,
0.021998344,
0.0252680369,
0.0069099138,
0.0067460835,
0.0310620107,
-0.0366824791,
0.0230315216,
-0.0952459946,
0.0015015304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14771v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14771v2 | Knowledgeable In-Context Tuning: Exploring and Exploiting Factual Knowledge for In-Context Learning | 2023-09-26T09:06:39 | 2024-03-31T13:55:39 | Jianing Wang, Chengyu Wang, Chuanqi Tan, Jun Huang, Ming Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) enable in-context learning (ICL) by conditioning
on a few labeled training examples as a text-based prompt, eliminating the need
for parameter updates and achieving competitive performance. In this paper, we
demonstrate that factual knowledge is imperative for the performance of ICL in
three core facets: the inherent knowledge learned in LLMs, the factual
knowledge derived from the selected in-context examples, and the knowledge
biases in LLMs for output generation. To unleash the power of LLMs in few-shot
learning scenarios, we introduce a novel Knowledgeable In-Context Tuning (KICT)
framework to further improve the performance of ICL: 1) injecting knowledge
into LLMs during continual self-supervised pre-training, 2) judiciously
selecting the examples for ICL with high knowledge relevance, and 3)
calibrating the prediction results based on prior knowledge. We evaluate the
proposed approaches on autoregressive models (e.g., GPT-style LLMs) over
multiple text classification and question-answering tasks. Experimental results
demonstrate that KICT substantially outperforms strong baselines and improves
by more than 13% and 7% on text classification and question-answering tasks,
respectively. | [
0.0177028235,
0.010091898,
0.0252621565,
0.0500334986,
-0.0058415565,
0.0308081713,
0.0225659795,
-0.0144040575,
-0.0073040714,
-0.0807815865,
-0.0578992926,
-0.0079754693,
-0.0381931737,
-0.0078920834,
0.0236003958,
-0.0032126061,
0.0538021214,
-0.0284933764,
-0.0022720993,
0.0212371163,
-0.002333798,
0.0242826026,
-0.0181109328,
0.0054439073,
-0.0363509655,
-0.0523553602,
0.0197373498,
0.0160077307,
0.011363457,
-0.0340185389,
0.0481987223,
0.0597194321,
0.0513313487,
0.0243327525,
0.0000021464,
-0.0557925999,
-0.006481804,
-0.0256209355,
-0.0770538077,
0.0257894658,
-0.0051522199,
0.0235284716,
0.0233690478,
0.0202772077,
-0.0554666929,
0.0010052258,
-0.0067126192,
0.0287676696,
0.0593301691,
0.0902059153,
0.0038665342,
0.0045062285,
0.000041264,
-0.0285358112,
0.0365619995,
-0.0460958481,
0.0149113759,
0.0108855572,
-0.0399571918,
0.0265397839,
0.0018338931,
0.0259297807,
0.022325404,
0.0008185575,
0.0407086574,
0.049997855,
-0.0377136543,
0.0127833178,
-0.005010217,
0.0759748742,
-0.0106907086,
-0.0441246219,
-0.0163872801,
-0.0288695153,
0.0004885071,
-0.0161630642,
-0.0339456685,
-0.0119250743,
-0.0011713697,
0.0199730359,
-0.0004318275,
0.0264913253,
0.030730851,
0.0208246969,
-0.0140443929,
0.05014579,
-0.0153941503,
-0.043152716,
-0.0039778142,
0.0000571295,
-0.0422330797,
-0.0420265757,
-0.0269900206,
0.0495673791,
-0.0421008989,
0.0281317681,
-0.0459176935,
0.0111199282,
0.0019736763,
-0.0504392497,
0.0129918577,
0.036995396,
0.009631901,
0.0718396008,
-0.0361373015,
0.0497930646,
0.0183730442,
-0.0131178452,
-0.0496890359,
-0.0059042778,
-0.048002176,
-0.0196726006,
-0.0485487469,
0.0106869927,
-0.0254481267,
-0.006864496,
-0.0086643696,
0.0661254376,
-0.0062146969,
0.0108301565,
0.0034830596,
0.0003256915,
-0.050604444,
-0.0243542995,
-0.0206397902,
0.0242689662,
-0.0103324875,
0.0045842831,
0.0115726544,
-0.0554557554,
-0.0283927731,
0.0170174092,
0.0068875551,
-0.033899229,
0.0237555504,
0.0246216189,
-0.0231899414,
-0.0459467843,
-0.0357711166,
-0.0246386658,
-0.0050179297,
-0.0773007944,
-0.0368831605,
-0.038726002,
0.004466624,
0.028762294,
0.0048090257,
-0.023936592,
0.0010063219,
0.0354221575,
0.0139899589,
0.0559601784,
0.0313081592,
-0.0034249984,
0.0434887521,
0.0164208971,
0.0140753677,
0.0881376117,
-0.0011596984,
0.0034563518,
0.0262789037,
0.0110144084,
-0.0014598279,
0.0281021465,
0.0523982495,
0.0227595754,
-0.0184173435,
0.0481250137,
0.0426146612,
0.0182711333,
0.0342922546,
-0.0172735769,
-0.0143731134,
0.0201136675,
0.0882483497,
0.0364518613,
0.0339876562,
0.0306984931,
0.0232772175,
0.0139770489,
0.0099101029,
-0.0115563264,
-0.0538035966,
0.0368249491,
-0.0382548794,
0.0191277731,
0.0140029192,
0.0163075905,
-0.050154794,
-0.0427818149,
0.0011544675,
-0.0013691827,
-0.0469172858,
0.0543724149,
0.036111068,
0.02076222,
-0.0449768566,
0.0341847129,
0.0278242044,
0.001880547,
0.0156639144,
-0.0393615589,
0.0352516696,
0.0485581793,
0.0446043499,
-0.0545556843,
-0.0310607441,
-0.0311718117,
0.0454500429,
0.0558108725,
0.0280056521,
-0.0251391418,
0.0152382767,
-0.0374811031,
-0.0313364193,
-0.0343601704,
0.0151708359,
0.0105571626,
0.0367323533,
0.0499520376,
0.0316371694,
-0.0274715424,
0.008532308,
0.0194661319,
-0.0462421626,
-0.0927172601,
0.02267907,
0.0135822194,
0.0139204534,
-0.0163961351,
-0.0232214741,
-0.0124687394,
0.025074061,
-0.0117230061,
0.0009405134,
-0.0009823054,
-0.1115666851,
-0.0698092058,
0.0025940489,
0.030741727,
-0.0010631141,
-0.0329674073,
-0.0526031666,
-0.0307424366,
-0.021115955,
-0.0099922335,
0.0583106615,
-0.0593259484,
-0.0136386845,
0.007203476,
-0.0112787299,
-0.0421639308,
0.0754391998,
0.0367976427,
-0.0296006948,
0.0067777964,
0.0145741841,
0.0010900463,
-0.0261811111,
0.0006911601,
-0.0359873883,
0.0104929991,
0.0158222094,
0.0272084083,
0.0543069765,
-0.0410454459,
-0.0014249111,
-0.1129648089,
0.0151280016,
-0.0462372638,
-0.015652949,
0.0392978489,
0.0104394713,
-0.0179853197,
-0.0331294313,
-0.035963431,
-0.0229159333,
0.0151709029,
0.0097772963,
0.0307336878,
0.0336612128,
0.0441289768,
-0.0107869124,
0.0149856461,
-0.0013099726,
0.0463846102,
0.0087828757,
-0.0002675056,
-0.0457281843,
0.0543625057,
-0.0261716768,
0.0149981137,
-0.0205595903,
0.0168038327,
-0.0198458359,
-0.0055001243,
0.0271580294,
0.0894284993,
0.0110911578,
0.0143231293,
0.0191258434,
0.0231129993,
-0.073614575,
0.0404164866,
-0.0215944853,
-0.0114111956,
-0.0331771076,
0.0255264957,
0.0219129734,
0.0242644344,
0.0212058239,
-0.0052314191,
-0.0481626615,
0.0307715274,
-0.0124372123,
-0.034160383,
-0.1063157618,
0.0168994553,
-0.0087863114,
0.0189366955,
-0.0172193386,
-0.0592479855,
0.0660141185,
-0.0081430404,
-0.003584231,
-0.0512928851,
-0.0269223694,
-0.0531761386,
0.0244394671,
-0.0076827132,
0.0090599274,
-0.009907037,
0.0187322088,
-0.0578762665,
-0.0173650868,
0.0239259936,
-0.0057823062,
0.0519351214,
-0.0384668,
0.0350246094,
0.0083183032,
-0.0695917755,
-0.0660658404,
-0.0710910261,
0.0004098612,
0.00423173,
-0.0388983935,
0.0008605535,
0.0010266037,
0.017971091,
0.0346673168,
0.0719546303,
-0.0142563805,
-0.0345779993,
-0.0135289636,
0.038495142,
0.0620422885,
0.002175082,
0.0014273848,
-0.0085642962,
0.034434732,
0.0375227146,
0.0518697873,
-0.0433567129,
-0.021124484,
0.0103864903,
0.0032254225,
-0.0272483937,
0.0015742965,
0.0368344821,
0.0337281115,
-0.0647071376,
-0.0490455069,
0.1395810992,
0.0088428017,
-0.0561745688,
-0.0192608293,
-0.002315931,
-0.002677385,
0.0433827303,
0.0461917296,
-0.0613560006,
-0.0417728648,
-0.030079158,
0.0220271293,
0.0094273798,
-0.0141667826,
-0.0290314723,
-0.1292650253,
0.0204823278,
0.0018464142,
-0.0391480178,
-0.0346639752,
-0.0367778949,
-0.0131801069,
-0.0283594187,
0.0022985796,
0.0122475298,
-0.0320789963,
0.0149266189,
0.0402181745,
-0.002314342,
-0.0795905814,
0.0474461094,
-0.0087236809,
0.0340804197,
0.0609145127,
0.0065502711,
0.0246038195,
-0.0009387747,
0.0240174178,
-0.0549276955,
0.0408186391,
-0.0356218554,
0.0190158989,
-0.0395327844,
-0.0018691487,
-0.0083876699,
0.0487449914,
-0.0376975164,
-0.0108716739,
0.0351908654,
0.0727723315,
-0.013229209,
0.0046743304,
0.0030435135,
-0.0385979749,
0.04674007,
0.0990175009,
0.0249488596,
-0.0381303392,
-0.0275861658,
-0.0155319963,
0.0077882074,
-0.0210057683,
0.007375882,
-0.0036436806,
0.0047628116,
0.0028542038,
-0.0403509885,
-0.0098928967,
0.0209041927,
0.0562606305,
-0.0088766143,
0.0230411272,
-0.001618741,
0.0188153256,
-0.047353752,
0.032320898,
-0.0548800193,
-0.0132205272,
-0.0451216996,
-0.0157795213,
0.0708526224,
-0.0661296472,
-0.0351831317,
0.010852539,
-0.0751841962,
-0.0535096973,
-0.0172119401,
0.0625243336,
0.0168078952,
0.1130766049,
-0.0104186591,
-0.0271126982,
0.1245239452,
0.0430491492,
-0.0336018056,
0.0296912026,
0.0118131358,
0.0354782641,
-0.0075301593,
0.0417263731,
-0.061893113,
0.0096193515,
0.0292243082,
0.0101238852,
-0.0508392602,
-0.0333743915,
0.0233114138,
-0.0342592485,
0.0327093154,
0.0000273324,
0.0050105667,
-0.0261674616,
0.0218625627,
0.0025070896,
-0.022735009,
-0.0215268675,
0.0025447831,
0.0137523059,
-0.0238026921,
-0.0138482079,
0.0313315839,
0.0106503814,
0.0371730775,
-0.020209102,
-0.0376965702,
0.0024915002,
0.0142316604,
0.0231018253,
0.0049925591,
-0.0322407894,
0.034889359,
0.0238242224,
0.0398120694,
-0.0248561595,
0.0774118155,
0.0231215898,
-0.0037370271,
-0.027129421,
0.0175317731,
-0.0745784044,
-0.0153905265,
-0.0811642855,
0.0423069298,
0.054988157,
-0.0295161661,
0.0226069149,
-0.0448979922,
-0.0287236031,
-0.0251793601,
0.0121470727,
0.0252422988,
-0.0164560061,
0.0184049308,
0.0247901715,
-0.0195058808,
0.0229292326,
0.0951514691,
0.0118771186,
0.0605891943,
0.0260996763,
-0.0113274632,
-0.0479695648,
-0.0019644252,
0.0075111021,
0.020180814,
0.00575655,
0.0427724831,
-0.0343226455,
-0.0596542843,
-0.0034684858,
-0.0024728591,
-0.0292189401,
-0.0198545773,
0.0486068726,
0.0631645173,
-0.0055594416,
-0.0267836116,
-0.020039171,
0.0231147055,
-0.0127427364,
-0.0053454409,
-0.0285149273,
-6.951888284e-33,
-0.0351958126,
-0.0281618424,
0.0355063379,
0.0083191218,
0.0190187488,
0.001484607,
-0.0234071147,
-0.0184193049,
-0.0281364508,
-0.0207656585,
-0.0220134128,
0.0077178618,
0.0078052832,
0.0491209142,
-0.0095621347,
-0.0377891734,
0.0445208363,
-0.0136002786,
-0.0379030108,
0.053236708,
0.0319812894,
0.033273913,
0.0576001443,
-0.0219343193,
-0.013874176,
-0.0186421927,
0.0011764633,
0.0447301418,
-0.0423036329,
0.0433708243,
-0.0229033083,
0.0529054552,
0.0414222516,
-0.0436939858,
-0.0172113422,
0.0211165883,
-0.0900565907,
-0.0581230521,
-0.0038718986,
-0.0122836353,
0.0088574728,
-0.0109305168,
0.0034000212,
-0.0077760629,
-0.0272803139,
-0.0227174517,
0.0417079553,
-0.0085965684,
-0.0290019102,
-0.0563950241,
-0.0404895172,
0.006161164,
-0.0197607931,
-0.0324536934,
-0.0213897433,
0.0338049717,
-0.0014312413,
0.0242157746,
-0.0885237828,
-0.0075336597,
-0.021808682,
0.0345238671,
0.0711316094,
0.0360829458,
0.0099801542,
0.0303751454,
-0.0228718948,
0.0169317797,
-0.0062099202,
-0.0458115377,
0.0143716959,
0.0006088686,
0.0013208622,
0.0765080899,
0.0456834584,
0.0004640521,
-0.0821286589,
0.0259613022,
0.0067043002,
0.0185575448,
0.0337702855,
-0.0013665633,
-0.049632635,
-0.020181505,
-0.051040493,
0.0039698086,
-0.0419367924,
-0.0023160547,
0.0594447553,
0.0480630659,
-0.0036918921,
0.0078433948,
0.0254338793,
-0.0163468905,
-0.0002461876,
0.0448704362,
-0.0240870453,
-0.0107076028,
0.0044511152,
0.0303081591,
-0.0651247576,
-0.0105057089,
0.0121006006,
0.038889017,
-0.0001464886,
0.0020869125,
0.0487905778,
0.0269783121,
-0.0494557582,
-0.0013867887,
-0.0254740193,
0.0325328149,
0.0069391597,
0.0146445213,
0.0131463604,
0.0144570936,
-0.0165384375,
0.0610235296,
0.0035036197,
-0.0491166674,
0.0173364654,
-0.0515973791,
-0.0054933107,
-0.0066834064,
-0.0157114994,
0.0165098161,
-0.0042162561,
-0.0002577853,
0.0189823192,
-0.0464290679,
-0.0032833691,
0.035954155,
2.772e-7,
0.0231146887,
0.0380071625,
-0.0147073157,
0.013218266,
0.0482576936,
0.0533688851,
-0.0263919774,
0.0200899225,
0.0399031714,
-0.0070587713,
0.0327532887,
0.0395888872,
0.0556905009,
0.017827319,
-0.0684900954,
0.0077554849,
-0.0749784112,
0.012844828,
-0.0551719889,
-0.0308658592,
0.0004662832,
0.0849437565,
0.0283030812,
-0.0158360638,
0.0388390981,
-0.0667179823,
0.0670599937,
-0.0327208489,
0.0031446728,
0.0072003542,
0.0056587891,
0.0444418564,
0.0029742587,
0.0321112573,
-0.0380559638,
0.0230395906,
-0.0284773856,
0.061678946,
0.0047561666,
-0.0349676944,
-0.0111658722,
0.0236852989,
0.0098507712,
-0.0957438126,
0.097925894,
-0.0821606666,
0.0218811743,
-0.0331633799,
-0.0040921378,
-0.0471191257,
0.020411646,
-0.0061931736,
-0.0302327722,
0.0005912205,
0.015035959,
0.0200600848,
-0.0263627097,
-0.0697202459,
-0.0132088335,
0.0268084574,
-0.0570509136,
-0.0353665687,
-0.046925094,
0.0008437432,
0.04346947,
-0.0411917754,
0.0198362619,
2.639634095e-34,
0.0013327401,
0.0040795431,
0.0140253631,
0.006154181,
0.0011005041,
0.0218216963,
-0.0425614752,
-0.0108919106,
0.0569649339,
-0.0757138282,
-0.0160542428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14770v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14770v1 | KERMIT: Knowledge Graph Completion of Enhanced Relation Modeling with Inverse Transformation | 2023-09-26T09:03:25 | 2023-09-26T09:03:25 | Haotian Li, Lingzhi Wang, Yuliang Wei, Richard Yi Da Xu, Bailing Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge graph completion is a task that revolves around filling in missing
triples based on the information available in a knowledge graph. Among the
current studies, text-based methods complete the task by utilizing textual
descriptions of triples. However, this modeling approach may encounter
limitations, particularly when the description fails to accurately and
adequately express the intended meaning. To overcome these challenges, we
propose the augmentation of data through two additional mechanisms. Firstly, we
employ ChatGPT as an external knowledge base to generate coherent descriptions
to bridge the semantic gap between the queries and answers. Secondly, we
leverage inverse relations to create a symmetric graph, thereby creating extra
labeling and providing supplementary information for link prediction. This
approach offers additional insights into the relationships between entities.
Through these efforts, we have observed significant improvements in knowledge
graph completion, as these mechanisms enhance the richness and diversity of the
available data, leading to more accurate results. | [
0.050129354,
0.0063082073,
-0.0264654662,
0.0324742794,
-0.0131912008,
-0.02731614,
-0.0843787789,
0.0299492143,
0.0919672325,
-0.0069708605,
0.0015895865,
0.0369370542,
-0.0145609025,
0.018673839,
0.0254089497,
-0.0499898866,
0.0288482513,
0.0292198882,
-0.0424695536,
-0.0058796946,
0.0076884977,
0.0474610738,
0.031337481,
-0.0174891949,
-0.0353777148,
0.0008858691,
-0.0161151364,
0.0141637111,
0.0166775174,
-0.0268813968,
-0.0155547755,
0.0484524481,
-0.0114662424,
-0.0614058673,
0.000002096,
-0.0346950702,
-0.0114394147,
0.0126235234,
-0.0332781076,
-0.0259587057,
-0.004598157,
-0.0111813238,
0.0923211575,
0.0132280476,
-0.0444632024,
0.0188371893,
0.0248079952,
0.0452900119,
0.0341682285,
0.0155664831,
-0.025995018,
0.0096440548,
0.0122915683,
-0.034871839,
0.0491385534,
-0.0181466062,
0.0235146061,
0.0421935469,
0.0458960682,
0.021106679,
0.0050309245,
0.0398976766,
0.0111838095,
-0.0114103807,
0.0852590054,
0.0149111608,
-0.007603466,
0.0031470358,
0.0269257315,
0.0594669208,
0.0665670857,
-0.0140525354,
0.0023786554,
0.0125576472,
0.0254773777,
0.0769830421,
-0.0414205007,
-0.0615992919,
-0.059691228,
-0.0177088175,
-0.059838675,
0.0000626194,
0.0539460666,
-0.0114490194,
0.0071522957,
0.0623641647,
-0.0014947829,
-0.0361910388,
-0.0132209696,
0.0061205393,
-0.024304647,
-0.0335891582,
0.0382133946,
0.0177762974,
-0.0293074623,
0.0262941532,
-0.0030008045,
-0.0121460306,
0.015008796,
-0.0207016822,
-0.0533124208,
0.0159498919,
-0.0052206675,
0.0410180949,
-0.0374768414,
-0.0040278984,
-0.0249939132,
0.0008393606,
-0.0752655119,
-0.030557232,
-0.0492699221,
-0.0121699246,
-0.0476870313,
0.0401816443,
-0.0475139916,
0.0004112148,
-0.0369461738,
0.0318438411,
-0.053065747,
0.016047569,
0.0447081216,
0.0550565645,
-0.0151427519,
-0.0170980673,
-0.0664139837,
0.0022646834,
-0.0180862695,
0.0102036996,
-0.0127184559,
0.0283336509,
0.0009467282,
-0.0257430542,
0.0181163717,
-0.0285982471,
0.0002851386,
0.0904519632,
0.0232648142,
0.0030909393,
-0.0208413824,
-0.0652723536,
0.0051409346,
-0.0323095918,
0.0316431262,
-0.0478641279,
0.0658359081,
0.0484389886,
-0.0085086562,
-0.0076010544,
0.0366937965,
-0.0011754284,
-0.074701488,
0.0743295848,
-0.0746831894,
0.0247447789,
-0.0008275398,
0.0109511334,
-0.0244638585,
0.0132990461,
-0.0066268877,
-0.0109950388,
0.0236372482,
0.0071654362,
-0.0248639323,
0.013115257,
0.0645233318,
-0.0074652308,
0.0270162467,
0.0295057949,
-0.0413094983,
0.0248156618,
-0.0159776676,
0.029250918,
-0.0214362759,
-0.0260899141,
0.0426994525,
0.0042347126,
-0.0109379943,
0.0559988022,
-0.0152259357,
0.0151815666,
0.0090235705,
0.0175863896,
-0.0514074489,
0.0516635925,
-0.0164915379,
0.0077524562,
-0.0083908997,
0.0200398974,
0.0016348757,
-0.01761798,
0.0053969994,
-0.0025173451,
0.0399503708,
0.0242810827,
0.0656660125,
0.036395058,
-0.0016535206,
0.0459734723,
0.0446512625,
-0.0169512685,
0.020172108,
0.0261461809,
-0.051576864,
0.0909233689,
0.0627156571,
-0.0482459366,
-0.0528530777,
0.0028095397,
-0.0340875126,
-0.0088191228,
-0.0045134681,
-0.0184701327,
-0.0461409539,
-0.0168255512,
-0.0451151989,
0.0649897456,
-0.0121932011,
0.0014671965,
0.0637257397,
-0.0034180628,
0.0354568996,
-0.0964233726,
0.0421096981,
-0.0027660772,
-0.0593203045,
0.055138398,
0.0191388652,
0.0211178362,
-0.003233297,
0.0643955842,
0.0428392626,
0.0276286583,
0.0400232561,
-0.0164696835,
-0.0774178132,
0.0319042802,
0.0060115391,
-0.0062594796,
0.0405146778,
-0.0519619249,
0.0044112871,
0.0022556663,
0.0128966626,
-0.0561695546,
0.0258803945,
-0.0256124716,
0.088965416,
0.0046182657,
-0.0172516853,
0.0394463167,
-0.0574604087,
-0.0093961274,
0.0605307594,
-0.0000585643,
0.0069474452,
0.0099667544,
-0.0831294954,
0.0226902664,
0.018745644,
-0.002707578,
-0.0428362414,
0.0042091385,
0.0056911064,
0.0187937412,
-0.034938924,
-0.0691132396,
0.0382311791,
-0.0768505186,
0.0131141171,
0.041768413,
0.0077183787,
0.0090518193,
0.0310557708,
0.02412544,
-0.0280274097,
-0.0232630037,
0.0502619967,
-0.0251061022,
-0.0063914908,
0.0196656212,
0.0145092467,
-0.0252860896,
-0.0105544943,
-0.0274879411,
-0.0296524391,
0.0434801765,
0.0037171475,
-0.0316379517,
0.0182682127,
0.0419706963,
-0.0604540668,
0.0171814915,
-0.0373244211,
0.0035271158,
-0.0126302028,
-0.0122927297,
0.0121771526,
-0.0439177752,
-0.0192665551,
-0.0188626461,
-0.0058969068,
-0.0051345341,
-0.0264045671,
0.0059449682,
-0.0672215223,
0.007700514,
0.0066063544,
-0.0195775684,
-0.056199871,
-0.0419217274,
0.0190699957,
-0.0284405686,
-0.0737098232,
-0.0152619723,
0.0371011049,
0.0372748412,
-0.0653654486,
-0.0102908304,
0.0342201181,
0.0225971378,
-0.0389087573,
-0.0125879822,
0.0615878738,
-0.0031646758,
0.031623736,
0.0383891799,
0.0088890446,
-0.0065646316,
0.1162350923,
0.0372214876,
0.0136704035,
0.0164038278,
0.008246975,
-0.0533699542,
-0.0019368784,
0.0685598403,
-0.0261095241,
0.0077381963,
-0.0076794121,
0.0205844045,
0.064324379,
-0.0273980349,
-0.0343946666,
0.003313344,
0.013040089,
0.0218293909,
0.0204753969,
-0.0346074514,
0.0294399764,
0.0078570759,
0.0068385969,
-0.0200066082,
-0.0028047028,
-0.0429284461,
-0.0395067856,
0.0244868621,
0.0456056744,
-0.0363117717,
-0.0043279813,
0.0132685173,
-0.0066765649,
0.0372935236,
-0.0027575314,
-0.0347310826,
0.0259071551,
0.0038085338,
-0.0231860057,
-0.0272382982,
-0.0324147381,
-0.0140601499,
-0.0293328594,
-0.0239518303,
0.0154862832,
0.0632302463,
0.03748006,
-0.0237050634,
0.0003368233,
0.0177605972,
0.0164064616,
0.0602340549,
0.0097748777,
-0.0845301151,
0.0211806465,
-0.0063611572,
0.0136003559,
0.0322896615,
-0.0765699074,
0.0018408817,
-0.0770975053,
0.012420997,
-0.0045772009,
-0.0177483428,
-0.0570406727,
-0.0710972995,
0.0132646309,
-0.0195256416,
-0.0817497373,
-0.0010597641,
-0.0154028926,
0.0169476364,
-0.0169342384,
-0.0209323913,
-0.0019633048,
0.0177623332,
-0.0520801283,
0.0035858462,
-0.0005476366,
0.0432145298,
-0.0067011416,
0.0203533024,
-0.0271317624,
0.0424713381,
-0.0163444206,
-0.0075371568,
0.0808140263,
0.0067012361,
-0.0024540408,
-0.0436970592,
-0.0062084408,
-0.048251152,
-0.0105617167,
-0.0214006715,
0.0788375437,
0.0144270705,
0.0242600199,
-0.0122586265,
-0.0104562668,
0.0068041035,
0.0521098226,
-0.0181252602,
0.0073884195,
0.0325012803,
-0.0186634269,
0.0520468988,
-0.002456554,
0.0196314715,
0.0396602973,
-0.056300845,
0.0016180018,
-0.0316968635,
-0.0617626458,
0.0523713976,
-0.0017522479,
0.0067823641,
0.0320167281,
0.0388136245,
-0.0289033689,
-0.0715915486,
-0.0068313382,
-0.0178199206,
0.0130579118,
0.0596728697,
-0.0219870005,
-0.0036799277,
-0.0585637093,
-0.0234064162,
0.0027926613,
-0.0581925735,
-0.0177699402,
-0.0495469496,
0.0120040402,
0.0206723828,
0.0659804419,
-0.0376524217,
0.010835682,
-0.0275710542,
0.1068236604,
-0.0636305586,
-0.0124540422,
-0.0268570017,
0.0079782233,
0.0003901234,
0.0550815351,
-0.0538491718,
-0.0043339548,
-0.0328817256,
0.0316439904,
-0.0268195886,
-0.0601840541,
0.048694957,
0.0554797389,
0.0100392522,
0.0087871533,
0.0167875942,
-0.0382995531,
0.0036426245,
-0.0634121597,
-0.0268448945,
-0.0550784618,
-0.0177382901,
0.0107729128,
-0.0007600178,
0.0047510727,
-0.0449998342,
-0.0013844697,
0.0223792195,
-0.0411217958,
-0.0508397631,
0.0241579004,
-0.0414204188,
0.0629250184,
-0.0235950034,
0.0070766932,
-0.0145434765,
0.0338263959,
-0.0092929853,
-0.0476137623,
0.0087201614,
0.0084404275,
-0.009656704,
-0.0307229906,
-0.013463893,
-0.0437526181,
-0.0345376134,
-0.0464628525,
0.0361132137,
0.0287112761,
0.0035250357,
0.0417216904,
-0.0424910672,
-0.0313409045,
0.0040164236,
0.0523180291,
0.0103149302,
-0.0234168023,
0.0054796836,
0.0137102157,
-0.0062358775,
0.0177570935,
0.0621557049,
-0.0014936052,
0.0887489468,
-0.0320647135,
-0.0778268427,
-0.0265945867,
-0.0279143136,
0.0135655683,
0.0194991548,
0.0083532473,
0.009813047,
-0.0559662655,
-0.0926690996,
0.0102159549,
-0.0131554129,
-0.0262818225,
0.0136418743,
0.0427504368,
0.0380191952,
0.027444439,
-0.0732515603,
-0.013462048,
0.0056730616,
-0.0572305396,
-0.0038429012,
0.0008959371,
-6.008718637e-33,
-0.0569283627,
-0.0766988099,
0.0270098597,
-0.0103885159,
-0.0303086396,
-0.0126188304,
-0.0050135641,
-0.0170662608,
-0.0228203721,
0.0358208343,
-0.0024875773,
0.0226135962,
-0.0026150807,
0.0076593095,
-0.007027654,
0.0022202365,
0.0290189926,
0.0048741312,
0.0480989218,
0.0139999865,
0.0109132864,
0.0224469118,
0.0649451315,
-0.11560148,
0.0358082578,
-0.0246798191,
-0.0346364118,
0.0347812697,
0.0080510871,
0.0308139604,
-0.0057296501,
0.0563920327,
0.0332425497,
-0.0102565819,
0.0164064765,
-0.0447611175,
-0.1374218166,
-0.0273780804,
0.0158631206,
-0.0161739253,
-0.0238552187,
0.037821915,
0.0553993359,
-0.0160777587,
0.0555932969,
-0.0642060116,
0.0412966534,
-0.0143572576,
-0.0444597453,
-0.0121988896,
-0.0093717268,
0.0101302601,
0.0029940591,
-0.0094888443,
-0.0059271194,
0.004860084,
0.002138522,
-0.0327752531,
-0.0264674537,
-0.021229621,
-0.0079605477,
0.0060632001,
-0.0081755016,
0.004679916,
0.0081659462,
0.0159242693,
-0.0083307512,
0.0036977278,
-0.0340246595,
0.0336947255,
-0.0280396566,
0.0583337583,
-0.0016325696,
0.0509021655,
-0.0262891427,
-0.0311557166,
-0.0723901466,
0.0111260219,
-0.029051831,
-0.0011682146,
-0.027749449,
-0.001495286,
-0.0240604188,
-0.0515382104,
-0.0242949408,
-0.0198996216,
-0.0261669736,
-0.0413627662,
0.0017527692,
-0.0036701581,
-0.0141076986,
0.0205978025,
-0.0507228822,
-0.0526083559,
-0.0310577564,
0.0351673514,
0.0008221445,
0.0034199527,
0.0096301017,
0.0193735845,
-0.0095327022,
-0.011938612,
0.0066090678,
0.0107993837,
0.0048422785,
0.0271758363,
0.0481422246,
-0.0164451133,
-0.0414797366,
0.0064739608,
-0.0316145122,
-0.0177781209,
-0.015765097,
-0.0691401586,
0.0514541715,
0.0446830541,
0.0216350984,
0.0343445987,
0.0783241987,
0.0350674167,
-0.0350239612,
-0.014303172,
0.0191455595,
-0.0115745729,
0.0335235745,
0.0133992899,
-0.0178779513,
-0.0781305358,
0.0373164006,
-0.0339943692,
-0.0261144359,
-0.0297469422,
2.804e-7,
0.0549417734,
0.0309815723,
0.0509942025,
0.0802070051,
0.0020312362,
0.0119708348,
0.0289140772,
0.0148396613,
0.0229889918,
-0.0432023443,
0.0501831025,
-0.0015576443,
-0.0072321445,
0.0680581108,
-0.0547450408,
-0.0287196543,
-0.0590061024,
-0.0738616958,
-0.0149566764,
0.0230722409,
0.09642791,
0.0122783538,
0.0655515641,
0.0352091081,
-0.0224070251,
-0.0461137556,
0.0549228676,
-0.0372555852,
-0.0029920419,
0.0314833559,
0.0271300003,
0.0172854252,
-0.0072086863,
0.0770067796,
-0.0281726643,
0.0007392295,
0.037874978,
0.0062429374,
-0.0168960486,
0.0274513923,
-0.0138541367,
-0.0514820404,
0.0287774336,
-0.0340120979,
0.0538800508,
-0.029335916,
0.0301165842,
0.0451520979,
-0.0636703148,
0.0002773993,
-0.0102348309,
0.026835423,
0.0144899646,
0.0211644955,
0.0131665245,
0.0578905791,
0.0008482793,
-0.0595747791,
-0.000866873,
0.0585545972,
-0.0255249273,
-0.0299930815,
0.001120563,
-0.0071502537,
0.0095926607,
-0.0359964147,
0.0152623206,
2.494944056e-34,
0.0115590328,
0.0374058709,
0.008667917,
-0.0028763532,
0.0538235381,
-0.0526947305,
0.014473225,
0.0181982163,
0.0113553433,
-0.0724128261,
-0.0205084812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14763v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14763v1 | ConPET: Continual Parameter-Efficient Tuning for Large Language Models | 2023-09-26T08:52:04 | 2023-09-26T08:52:04 | Chenyang Song, Xu Han, Zheni Zeng, Kuai Li, Chen Chen, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun, Tao Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Continual learning necessitates the continual adaptation of models to newly
emerging tasks while minimizing the catastrophic forgetting of old ones. This
is extremely challenging for large language models (LLMs) with vanilla
full-parameter tuning due to high computation costs, memory consumption, and
forgetting issue. Inspired by the success of parameter-efficient tuning (PET),
we propose Continual Parameter-Efficient Tuning (ConPET), a generalizable
paradigm for continual task adaptation of LLMs with task-number-independent
training complexity. ConPET includes two versions with different application
scenarios. First, Static ConPET can adapt former continual learning methods
originally designed for relatively smaller models to LLMs through PET and a
dynamic replay strategy, which largely reduces the tuning costs and alleviates
the over-fitting and forgetting issue. Furthermore, to maintain scalability,
Dynamic ConPET adopts separate PET modules for different tasks and a PET module
selector for dynamic optimal selection. In our extensive experiments, the
adaptation of Static ConPET helps multiple former methods reduce the scale of
tunable parameters by over 3,000 times and surpass the PET-only baseline by at
least 5 points on five smaller benchmarks, while Dynamic ConPET gains its
advantage on the largest dataset. The codes and datasets are available at
https://github.com/Raincleared-Song/ConPET. | [
0.0213144738,
0.047647953,
-0.0052232468,
0.0086025298,
0.0162088312,
0.0358130299,
-0.0402077064,
-0.0190209132,
-0.0435888693,
-0.0322709158,
-0.0574739017,
-0.0153097836,
-0.0072357077,
0.0145733347,
0.0496159643,
-0.0292854272,
0.0604036897,
-0.0338312574,
-0.0101941982,
0.0004693952,
-0.0002233755,
0.0028320213,
-0.023814356,
0.0350136459,
-0.0017330651,
-0.0329272225,
-0.0132112289,
0.0100460174,
0.0187049005,
-0.0108731743,
0.0522932895,
0.0491043217,
0.0461518355,
0.0077179028,
0.0000021732,
-0.0348756462,
-0.0382570624,
-0.0413893946,
-0.0543134138,
0.0190801099,
0.0575260632,
0.0254005212,
-0.0240554027,
0.0537198558,
-0.0303775724,
-0.0202064235,
0.0654755011,
-0.0057170028,
0.0531516187,
0.0829072222,
0.0086905556,
-0.0012390112,
0.0265941527,
-0.0548107028,
-0.0243426021,
-0.0396419577,
0.0282836817,
-0.0157088637,
-0.0247823112,
-0.0007971615,
-0.0139863975,
0.0060476763,
0.0037328531,
-0.0105382036,
0.0011872425,
0.0252584405,
-0.0385671742,
-0.0175246838,
-0.0174252428,
0.0522962287,
-0.0521676242,
-0.0492549054,
0.0134571921,
0.0088965995,
-0.0376150124,
-0.030240031,
-0.0604944564,
-0.0064191576,
0.0363739207,
0.0276428256,
0.024185013,
-0.0462054163,
0.0342274532,
0.0268793125,
-0.0298818853,
0.0008453217,
0.0308026075,
-0.0067941076,
-0.0203028116,
-0.0221209079,
-0.0536183938,
-0.0062600202,
-0.0007062159,
0.0294509903,
-0.0445434786,
0.0109960921,
-0.0486533418,
-0.0370580964,
0.0084275547,
-0.0326420255,
0.0692134127,
0.0500489511,
0.0132580735,
0.0644241571,
-0.0415167995,
0.049447,
0.0219171438,
0.0176785458,
-0.02807202,
0.0124256648,
-0.0678164959,
0.0299415216,
-0.0468085483,
0.0173861198,
0.0177914202,
-0.0087700011,
0.0015472793,
0.0481936373,
0.0236351676,
0.0162872765,
0.0102491686,
-0.0262394939,
-0.0695045069,
-0.0014791796,
0.034723036,
0.0633532703,
0.0048189415,
0.0000053515,
-0.0145162502,
-0.0241347086,
-0.0474151261,
0.0025339297,
0.0230897702,
-0.0259837508,
0.0386462323,
0.0402811132,
-0.013363149,
-0.0382965319,
-0.0290025491,
0.0489283018,
0.0132336421,
-0.0664507225,
-0.0238031894,
-0.0335418433,
0.0195303131,
-0.014379709,
0.0240474958,
-0.0394444056,
-0.0011928187,
0.0028834639,
-0.0304745194,
0.05165549,
0.0351190157,
0.0169705842,
0.0133298226,
-0.0099817263,
0.0106130447,
0.0792718679,
0.0298915561,
0.001495934,
0.0302906688,
0.0110639036,
-0.0186140388,
0.0315399468,
0.0104527418,
0.0580691509,
-0.0213797614,
-0.0105242673,
0.0757707357,
0.0148591604,
0.0494775549,
0.001017674,
-0.0174164288,
-0.0056023621,
0.0720762461,
-0.0092779975,
0.0431600884,
0.0293161813,
0.028809486,
0.0033172066,
0.0381143056,
-0.04009955,
-0.0650525764,
0.0150153441,
-0.0284586418,
0.0023296052,
-0.0020970185,
0.009079353,
-0.0277648475,
-0.0199121498,
-0.0195105169,
-0.0042813108,
-0.0098223006,
0.0341867022,
0.0533515327,
-0.0278926231,
-0.0442300439,
0.0886231214,
0.0338787995,
-0.0207905956,
-0.0300987419,
-0.0345984772,
0.0206271838,
0.0601246729,
0.0436166152,
-0.0541140549,
-0.0664974228,
-0.0259717274,
0.0453516953,
0.0022510928,
0.0239817463,
-0.005612649,
0.0633814111,
-0.0645477474,
0.0004037439,
-0.0044231932,
0.0228619743,
0.0201810878,
0.0204927176,
0.0401716903,
0.0039394516,
-0.0090955114,
-0.0496094525,
0.0269039646,
-0.0555044264,
-0.0282472633,
0.0191363078,
-0.0142059103,
-0.015731262,
-0.0036107663,
-0.0291763954,
-0.0061085359,
0.0482948497,
-0.0434896164,
0.0609097295,
0.0021738603,
-0.03911338,
-0.0341569111,
0.0541294552,
0.0393798985,
0.0076076826,
0.0298544653,
-0.0473097637,
-0.0455713011,
0.0224188231,
-0.0206261035,
0.0471739471,
-0.0195654593,
0.0435046516,
-0.0592300706,
0.0420996174,
-0.0326268077,
0.0019971416,
0.0032170264,
-0.0100507587,
0.0098786298,
0.0413515978,
-0.0274077915,
-0.076634191,
-0.0212358609,
0.0191561934,
0.0152299087,
0.004820867,
-0.00426907,
0.0213560499,
-0.0052574258,
-0.0398732536,
-0.0761438161,
0.0340916179,
-0.0431080796,
-0.0040189996,
0.0189004503,
-0.0052691037,
-0.0218185186,
-0.0243088976,
0.0155094266,
0.0238303356,
-0.0436380915,
0.0151179414,
0.0092775039,
-0.0278585106,
-0.0297448784,
-0.0601178184,
-0.0233674254,
0.0173489954,
0.0233615264,
-0.0502749495,
-0.0105118509,
-0.0749758333,
0.0153795024,
-0.0046843323,
0.0211781748,
-0.009094052,
-0.0350650959,
-0.0398399644,
-0.0260889698,
0.046164982,
0.0711717904,
-0.0086865025,
-0.011163868,
0.0571441278,
0.0076256874,
-0.0318443105,
0.0191249903,
-0.0281706229,
-0.0577623025,
-0.0110941948,
-0.0030601029,
0.0004437624,
0.0573032498,
-0.0541115627,
-0.0084387837,
-0.0374046266,
0.0284114815,
-0.0247796904,
0.008209087,
-0.0421082601,
0.0169856176,
-0.02893438,
-0.0137879178,
-0.0292920899,
-0.0629119724,
0.0292838607,
-0.0065467441,
-0.0276123062,
-0.0776002556,
-0.0318875909,
-0.0283686761,
0.0562617332,
0.0148223639,
0.0000483917,
0.0276663918,
-0.0189063083,
-0.0355683565,
-0.0041963472,
0.0319249704,
-0.015164407,
0.0579344369,
-0.012052116,
0.0168501325,
-0.0366358049,
-0.0389507525,
-0.0351222642,
-0.0183114279,
-0.010157099,
0.0085533634,
-0.0130296322,
-0.0277915895,
-0.0418634079,
-0.0168180056,
0.021646997,
0.0470974967,
0.000128898,
0.0076192273,
-0.0227792934,
0.0025074021,
0.0489718504,
0.067913048,
0.031426549,
-0.0106748641,
0.0174504425,
0.0329969302,
0.0578976236,
-0.0097849434,
-0.0190003924,
0.0138233677,
0.0323166028,
-0.0263980646,
0.0055001895,
-0.0079508387,
0.0360988155,
-0.0796439275,
-0.0161309838,
0.1012895033,
0.0149821946,
-0.071786359,
0.0232135653,
0.003076887,
0.0370075889,
0.018592041,
0.0520878658,
-0.0415835008,
-0.0246677529,
0.049590759,
0.032308057,
0.0100902505,
-0.0201212186,
-0.0389412306,
-0.0758969039,
0.0235581696,
0.0407496393,
0.0228947029,
0.005585108,
-0.0605962723,
0.0115239993,
-0.0389164984,
0.0250597671,
0.0375562273,
-0.0174855664,
-0.0058727576,
0.00276712,
-0.0152311577,
-0.0558032691,
0.0425010175,
-0.0208209362,
0.0549978577,
0.0021474548,
0.0213735979,
0.0280893706,
-0.0306521691,
0.0888229683,
-0.0140328137,
-0.021647919,
-0.0386780426,
0.0141541548,
0.0017682348,
-0.0106994864,
0.0382886976,
0.0293779001,
-0.0443544276,
-0.0062137586,
0.0142067894,
0.0416107252,
-0.0036567124,
0.0284620244,
0.0100346953,
-0.0660013407,
0.005635269,
0.0523636155,
0.0324861817,
-0.0314999148,
-0.0323090926,
-0.0101289097,
-0.0626083761,
-0.0575088933,
0.0027769366,
-0.0359098427,
-0.0507697985,
-0.0151980845,
-0.0307735763,
0.0512007847,
0.017340634,
0.0411458276,
0.0239730384,
0.0259333178,
0.0089147836,
0.01838254,
-0.0661729351,
0.0173877217,
-0.0214015581,
0.0144273033,
-0.0732384026,
-0.0380353406,
0.0662309155,
0.0077830879,
0.0103869466,
-0.0001801498,
-0.1135377511,
-0.0616252646,
-0.0039104861,
0.0256809108,
0.0121785775,
0.0829274803,
-0.0191255827,
-0.0586673357,
0.0060986253,
-0.0260534305,
-0.0113920765,
0.0526006259,
0.0346031524,
0.0035542552,
0.0071437778,
0.0523557886,
-0.0416097045,
-0.0021533452,
0.0396651365,
0.0339622162,
0.0213405117,
0.0153677994,
-0.010803489,
-0.0066311373,
0.0115017723,
0.0128086982,
-0.0168973655,
-0.0417525992,
0.0303002764,
0.0165770762,
0.0201121308,
-0.0472893193,
0.0571546666,
-0.0042620474,
0.0019361185,
-0.020223869,
-0.0204663016,
0.0413549244,
0.0147808418,
-0.0302357245,
0.0290459804,
-0.0345676579,
-0.0192422736,
0.0550415479,
-0.0024625855,
-0.0356553681,
0.0518517159,
-0.0109016038,
0.0196542498,
-0.0343237258,
0.0124703338,
0.0151705556,
-0.0070274137,
-0.0813580751,
0.0434698686,
-0.0296302326,
-0.077770479,
-0.0307889916,
0.0370872021,
0.0938326642,
0.0109391259,
0.0782553777,
-0.0117793903,
-0.0246391352,
-0.0441219062,
-0.0131421676,
-0.0027627586,
0.0182906054,
-0.015094988,
0.0151728597,
-0.023813013,
0.0557943583,
0.0825496465,
0.0244974103,
0.034771435,
0.0018745145,
0.0273207445,
-0.0239544306,
0.0283384286,
-0.036689043,
0.0031073422,
-0.020813169,
0.0321101025,
0.0361758545,
-0.048748862,
0.0090977559,
-0.0280521251,
-0.0114721237,
-0.0200438164,
0.0037853424,
0.0346057937,
-0.0179808401,
0.0255041346,
-0.0282171443,
-0.0043173907,
0.0548638664,
-0.0371597484,
-0.003083789,
-7.077058596e-33,
-0.00392074,
0.043261338,
0.0083813407,
0.0017990189,
-0.0674623251,
-0.0156231336,
-0.0478675812,
0.0006162142,
0.0015724741,
-0.0326183997,
-0.010724864,
-0.0096905529,
0.0126852999,
0.0038540706,
0.036459513,
-0.0193746686,
0.0598002411,
0.0069556097,
-0.0375917256,
0.0321167894,
0.0381929427,
0.0602654479,
0.0543264896,
-0.0328802429,
-0.0302098189,
0.0528363474,
0.0068065445,
0.0278198943,
0.0174174234,
0.0506533757,
0.009792123,
0.0306530818,
0.015989203,
-0.0375440232,
-0.0497064181,
-0.0163322911,
-0.0862581357,
-0.0301155504,
-0.0065900083,
0.0116545698,
-0.0106491847,
-0.0348563194,
0.0278255343,
0.0122163175,
-0.0206819959,
-0.0098455073,
-0.0077848118,
-0.0511792712,
-0.0648925826,
0.0027977177,
-0.0326847695,
0.0153230494,
-0.0032201922,
-0.0139411446,
0.0043175956,
-0.0114370119,
-0.0198840834,
0.0114300912,
-0.0800339207,
-0.0119420532,
0.0181028135,
0.081076093,
0.0166093502,
0.0373742804,
0.0373029374,
0.0258178525,
0.0112781292,
0.0013781309,
0.0120547824,
-0.0013576283,
0.0586199798,
0.013338563,
0.0192656331,
-0.0266139004,
0.0433017015,
-0.065059796,
-0.0628940314,
-0.0296911057,
0.0860231444,
0.0682420209,
0.0399795771,
0.0352339856,
0.004097695,
-0.0145800579,
-0.0478350632,
0.0275013987,
-0.0477303565,
-0.000996682,
0.0386285745,
0.0618080348,
-0.046025347,
-0.0240583327,
0.0383209176,
-0.0333017409,
0.0010808076,
0.0147850625,
-0.0191143565,
0.0025907052,
0.0125919683,
0.0231779907,
-0.0313418657,
-0.0458207875,
-0.0131103219,
-0.0148684289,
0.0050127748,
-0.0319951214,
0.0271753874,
0.0739167258,
-0.0423587635,
-0.0138974311,
-0.02085739,
0.0149786398,
0.0206287894,
0.076223053,
0.0236124955,
0.0091762953,
0.0239198767,
0.0373805836,
0.0225569457,
-0.0310665295,
-0.0279514156,
0.0292100646,
0.0611181371,
0.041084256,
-0.0141524225,
0.0040704687,
-0.0362291858,
-0.0024416791,
0.0129465088,
-0.0849766657,
-0.0165443923,
-0.0027494172,
2.857e-7,
-0.0066136187,
0.0458744913,
-0.0350051671,
-0.0284314211,
0.0530066229,
0.000064648,
-0.0526946858,
0.0163152553,
-0.0065903161,
0.0378881656,
0.0112249916,
0.0281010382,
0.0784724429,
-0.0112636276,
-0.092819564,
0.0000324646,
-0.0560222454,
0.0616292544,
-0.049395334,
-0.0196121298,
-0.0162169933,
0.124958545,
0.0360074751,
0.0016698069,
0.0193371717,
-0.052677419,
0.0525486842,
-0.0093202209,
0.0117489863,
0.0093559977,
0.0003759496,
0.064872928,
-0.0181022175,
-0.0206057504,
-0.0444352664,
0.051891692,
-0.0293125883,
0.0809050947,
0.0023023724,
-0.03936949,
0.039917551,
-0.0012057128,
0.0006173553,
-0.0586110763,
0.0854764208,
-0.0608674921,
-0.011257764,
-0.0211560745,
0.0446668528,
0.0066816327,
0.0172346178,
-0.0312075224,
-0.0531842262,
0.0310422648,
0.0395157561,
-0.0119364234,
-0.0293990597,
-0.1111301705,
0.0055384096,
0.0167388711,
-0.0537834279,
-0.0532058366,
-0.0598427057,
-0.0394068249,
0.0229833592,
-0.0474887267,
0.0169937927,
2.960257755e-34,
0.0501145609,
-0.0462203324,
0.0127059557,
0.0368668996,
0.0019947763,
-0.0267564077,
0.0116902059,
-0.0009652729,
-0.0060282773,
-0.0889339969,
-0.0364270993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14760v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14760v1 | Program Repair with Minimal Edits Using CodeT5 | 2023-09-26T08:45:05 | 2023-09-26T08:45:05 | Atsushi Shirafuji, Md. Mostafizer Rahman, Md Faizul Ibne Amin, Yutaka Watanobe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE | Programmers often struggle to identify and fix bugs in their programs. In
recent years, many language models (LMs) have been proposed to fix erroneous
programs and support error recovery. However, the LMs tend to generate
solutions that differ from the original input programs. This leads to potential
comprehension difficulties for users. In this paper, we propose an approach to
suggest a correct program with minimal repair edits using CodeT5. We fine-tune
a pre-trained CodeT5 on code pairs of wrong and correct programs and evaluate
its performance with several baseline models. The experimental results show
that the fine-tuned CodeT5 achieves a pass@100 of 91.95% and an average edit
distance of the most similar correct program of 6.84, which indicates that at
least one correct program can be suggested by generating 100 candidate
programs. We demonstrate the effectiveness of LMs in suggesting program repair
with minimal edits for solving introductory programming problems. | [
0.0412211381,
0.0166170448,
-0.031119585,
0.0008381205,
-0.004428125,
0.0109475022,
-0.0542485937,
0.0074435058,
-0.0086859502,
-0.0414863825,
0.0043158908,
0.0250170846,
0.0286998115,
0.011412493,
0.0162984375,
-0.0565732978,
0.062000934,
-0.0191501733,
-0.0087272348,
0.0209661964,
0.0034901702,
0.0009340211,
-0.0164788906,
0.0674367249,
0.0253706463,
-0.0481849238,
-0.0093897656,
0.0270735249,
-0.0142000318,
0.0022920428,
0.0323628336,
0.048829671,
-0.0221560188,
0.0124160722,
0.0000023144,
-0.0242002979,
-0.0411487855,
-0.0082228817,
0.0251293816,
0.0371743962,
-0.0188304354,
-0.0086542843,
-0.026257433,
0.0386201255,
-0.0119131822,
-0.0022104983,
0.0504753888,
-0.0176917892,
0.1105512753,
0.0662875995,
0.016538037,
-0.0026450704,
0.0084493663,
0.0216873009,
0.038336236,
-0.0275889095,
0.019020794,
0.0545988157,
0.0148228575,
0.0072363075,
-0.0101135531,
-0.0137233213,
0.0032870001,
-0.0257588308,
-0.0091333631,
-0.0033833752,
-0.0564686954,
-0.0167609788,
0.0257031471,
0.0148464264,
-0.071015738,
-0.0467126071,
-0.0052069775,
-0.0343253016,
-0.0098552899,
-0.0333155766,
-0.0162335858,
-0.0021657059,
-0.0080288276,
-0.0167179685,
0.0215595346,
-0.1018678844,
0.0180939436,
-0.0038740907,
0.0039154189,
0.0483519547,
-0.009259359,
-0.0406712182,
-0.0535093248,
0.0015256481,
-0.0275856182,
-0.021902252,
0.0035167267,
0.0367197469,
-0.0470575206,
0.0004003956,
-0.0448325761,
-0.0133874295,
0.0138324359,
-0.0017544272,
-0.0094719436,
0.0438685715,
-0.0235056207,
0.0099746631,
-0.0431546867,
0.0267316271,
0.0443234481,
-0.0107464297,
-0.0039003969,
0.0146294208,
-0.0546867475,
-0.0219668895,
-0.0578688942,
0.0339346752,
0.0181515254,
0.0755531639,
-0.037018057,
0.0366262645,
-0.0249635708,
0.0776548982,
-0.032587871,
-0.0267726555,
-0.0235995911,
-0.0174843259,
-0.0024935668,
-0.0226604696,
0.0070567825,
-0.0325610749,
-0.015793182,
-0.0377217755,
-0.0162276048,
-0.0061569749,
-0.0530443788,
-0.0397490375,
0.0215513241,
0.0122478893,
0.0131446579,
0.0289498623,
-0.0604612939,
-0.0298746359,
0.0014981877,
0.0056940988,
-0.0708972067,
-0.0945699289,
-0.0661933646,
0.0088680536,
0.0123519879,
-0.0157586019,
0.0053388546,
0.0183026027,
-0.0127004404,
0.0770744979,
-0.0893139467,
0.0318534896,
0.035976164,
0.026903512,
-0.0105755469,
-0.009063256,
0.0106211035,
0.0097216619,
0.0127473911,
-0.0572465397,
0.0648960844,
-0.0181361642,
-0.0157862417,
0.0053478698,
0.009378056,
0.0037769189,
0.0226224866,
0.0193857662,
-0.0100661684,
0.0188812651,
-0.0113308337,
0.0303161256,
0.0026954545,
0.0190609731,
0.0273503382,
0.0613599345,
0.0297235809,
0.004271409,
0.0124301268,
-0.0340114869,
-0.0704189688,
0.0644721016,
-0.0561437383,
0.0157113187,
0.0034591914,
-0.011208931,
-0.0002927828,
-0.0532954596,
-0.0320913792,
0.0298205037,
-0.0203535482,
-0.0438693427,
0.054880131,
-0.0210331604,
-0.0263546593,
0.0178762358,
0.0006639721,
-0.0122128176,
-0.0548413321,
-0.066805169,
0.027616974,
0.0764869899,
0.0516443364,
-0.0740111172,
-0.013242078,
-0.0238516107,
-0.0006772818,
-0.0510753468,
0.0873836428,
-0.010709648,
-0.0256585125,
-0.0387412906,
0.0059877164,
-0.0236661918,
0.0104972301,
0.0416544341,
0.0015141793,
-0.0194185972,
0.0291898437,
-0.0052301567,
-0.0422569551,
0.0237119459,
0.0614290535,
0.0188107546,
0.0159495678,
0.0066940165,
-0.0175779983,
-0.0189393722,
-0.0303828884,
0.0118497377,
0.002170075,
0.0513708629,
-0.031063728,
-0.0406711623,
-0.0559203476,
-0.0368262678,
0.0445181169,
-0.0414768793,
-0.043042317,
0.014095027,
-0.0306188874,
-0.026727153,
0.0713808909,
-0.028673172,
-0.0175235197,
-0.0278428681,
0.0467142947,
-0.0042890888,
-0.0836729258,
-0.0241605323,
0.0407946818,
0.0514093414,
0.0385311916,
-0.0134137208,
0.0507896394,
0.0239615925,
-0.0407985784,
-0.0446060486,
-0.0095540732,
-0.0244486164,
0.0338853896,
0.0083571123,
0.0620810315,
-0.0168039519,
-0.0449280888,
-0.0470046923,
0.0004366178,
-0.0271934606,
-0.0258728527,
-0.0102124093,
0.0181930214,
-0.0009861852,
-0.0453156754,
-0.0075353854,
0.0010711227,
-0.0032441025,
0.0002148213,
0.0425238907,
-0.001907269,
-0.0448329449,
-0.0731405616,
-0.0001422822,
-0.0374496877,
-0.0182294473,
-0.0019737622,
-0.0446248464,
-0.0765928403,
0.072766602,
0.0131832408,
0.0367452689,
-0.0062660277,
-0.0550134033,
-0.0062135202,
-0.0396829993,
0.0311357323,
0.05450036,
-0.0311453268,
-0.0020415364,
0.0555847995,
0.0218573529,
-0.0504953489,
0.0213173479,
0.048080653,
-0.073939994,
0.0402992442,
-0.0288956985,
0.003026563,
0.0389591679,
0.0020207649,
-0.0129082594,
-0.051739797,
0.0439996086,
0.0336934775,
0.0654157698,
-0.0034831497,
-0.0466037244,
0.010392433,
0.0391679816,
-0.0573391654,
-0.0759935528,
0.0726245269,
-0.0146341184,
0.006205793,
-0.0302089248,
-0.0073590139,
-0.0193259176,
0.0253130179,
0.0171846543,
0.0220141821,
-0.0077575725,
-0.0673883483,
-0.0290712975,
0.0098405583,
0.0390484035,
-0.0159547869,
0.0672113076,
-0.0875603333,
0.0274890363,
0.0006204685,
-0.0373479873,
-0.038494166,
-0.0011917545,
-0.0158136021,
-0.0253410432,
0.0271056369,
0.007784103,
-0.0062650926,
0.0037223264,
0.0126169715,
0.0706171244,
0.0365961567,
-0.0386370085,
0.0274157226,
-0.0704589561,
-0.0376361981,
-0.029116489,
0.012029958,
-0.0532237552,
0.020582566,
-0.0012499456,
0.0338508673,
-0.001033175,
-0.0587060601,
0.0088371234,
0.0135245575,
-0.0537925363,
-0.0639568567,
0.0310109109,
0.0448408015,
-0.0281196535,
-0.0380765237,
0.0699228197,
0.0464096069,
-0.0477739684,
0.0002595756,
-0.0426037014,
-0.036638163,
0.0547512472,
0.0369233862,
-0.0794609189,
-0.0373123437,
0.0262883361,
0.0486426838,
0.0254399572,
-0.0141194407,
0.01417669,
-0.0828807876,
0.0287558585,
0.0509484634,
-0.0233849343,
-0.0672124326,
-0.008902085,
-0.01113916,
-0.0010137847,
-0.0215151291,
0.0669929385,
-0.0132352179,
0.0361004956,
0.0227492265,
-0.0301725883,
-0.015393462,
0.0463731252,
0.0038581856,
0.0621483922,
0.0929810032,
-0.0313583612,
0.0111709964,
0.0363037959,
0.0549393147,
0.0088087246,
0.0293256696,
-0.0319168121,
0.0327104032,
-0.0055344095,
-0.0085891187,
0.0433395989,
-0.0031941144,
-0.0191830676,
-0.0442585796,
0.0327232517,
0.0225326233,
-0.047080148,
0.0169900153,
0.0151262516,
-0.0249172617,
-0.0166848209,
0.006488163,
0.0543144047,
0.0243173782,
-0.0181184318,
-0.0693949088,
-0.0239813775,
-0.0428617448,
0.0024058186,
-0.0322708078,
-0.0069001266,
0.0180158261,
-0.043882791,
-0.0111491177,
0.0302914288,
0.024253143,
0.0133678904,
-0.0477620736,
-0.0074613253,
0.014728169,
-0.015355303,
0.0217514765,
-0.0045133266,
0.0245226678,
-0.0664267614,
-0.0055813533,
-0.016918676,
-0.0259535126,
-0.0249250568,
-0.0225290451,
-0.0396548025,
-0.024051927,
-0.02118898,
0.0929122269,
0.0178372636,
0.0185282435,
-0.0608494952,
-0.0839305297,
-0.0922265872,
0.0306924619,
-0.0051961471,
-0.0009511451,
-0.0180304851,
-0.0364663191,
0.0157608744,
-0.0080324979,
-0.0609456562,
-0.0133586004,
0.0298253093,
0.0019508422,
-0.000508638,
-0.0252171922,
0.0481447726,
0.053195782,
0.0186925288,
0.0723425299,
0.0098988544,
-0.012589016,
0.0199188776,
0.0248161796,
-0.0170991775,
-0.0075437422,
0.0820523947,
-0.0069594453,
-0.0395444594,
0.017452566,
-0.0434058458,
-0.0753637478,
0.0398432091,
0.0053349477,
0.0286481418,
0.0204500575,
0.0573319197,
0.0723415539,
0.0155141987,
-0.008406207,
-0.0023944117,
0.0523221083,
0.057483498,
-0.0124990931,
0.0423560143,
0.0102233663,
0.058219187,
-0.0307808593,
0.017862238,
-0.0351618528,
-0.0704676732,
-0.0200424828,
0.0469288304,
0.0591604151,
0.0349743031,
-0.0089591676,
-0.0014872446,
-0.0116576981,
-0.0229940116,
0.040052481,
0.0436946079,
-0.0320591703,
-0.005751472,
0.0314116105,
0.0054746466,
-0.0275730733,
0.0601872876,
-0.0767874867,
0.0349474847,
-0.0030090255,
-0.019419549,
-0.0110224867,
0.0532839894,
0.011113314,
0.0090025095,
-0.0266688224,
-0.0444817469,
-0.0095017422,
-0.0611020401,
-0.0222202949,
0.0600169934,
0.0223280676,
0.0462260731,
-0.0231763031,
0.1135995612,
0.0279088523,
0.0039700945,
0.0123050092,
0.0033137675,
0.0229589976,
-0.0260347445,
-0.0466103628,
-5.43719512e-33,
-0.0305236131,
0.0035085769,
-0.0201091021,
0.0121967895,
0.0416849479,
-0.0289114043,
-0.0570097975,
0.0393128656,
0.0126241231,
-0.0154978782,
-0.0076021776,
0.0245326217,
-0.0151327597,
-0.059255261,
0.0578920357,
0.0701855868,
0.0355815142,
0.0640608743,
-0.0784338787,
-0.0213833805,
-0.0314709395,
0.0189779755,
0.0500257611,
-0.0340899527,
-0.0069639506,
0.0065332949,
-0.0011928588,
0.03177993,
-0.0158156697,
0.0471593551,
0.0574061237,
0.0321057625,
-0.0108720828,
-0.0030839457,
-0.0388019718,
-0.0703147575,
-0.0043565221,
-0.0546539053,
0.0129249142,
0.0082929498,
0.0525634214,
-0.0347482376,
0.0657609105,
0.003795984,
-0.0193717685,
0.0349427313,
0.0426155478,
-0.025613619,
0.0289420933,
0.0161469132,
-0.0156631917,
0.0187281817,
-0.0619602464,
-0.0338727944,
-0.0321196616,
0.0005813012,
-0.0166494623,
0.035573598,
-0.0110288076,
0.0098722652,
0.0681035891,
0.0531302728,
0.0397988185,
-0.035611216,
-0.0374740511,
0.0119545767,
0.0310431737,
0.0514619164,
0.013359094,
-0.0077348528,
0.0347427949,
-0.0203322973,
0.0501761362,
0.0406666845,
0.0308448281,
-0.025783712,
-0.0334142298,
0.0484234467,
0.0019735764,
0.030524293,
-0.0296189133,
0.0491190329,
-0.0522269718,
-0.0008055611,
-0.044862669,
-0.0293087345,
-0.0598647408,
-0.0520272255,
0.0497443341,
0.0047585913,
0.0012421592,
-0.0251801312,
-0.0060870792,
0.0039112447,
0.0333706215,
-0.0316125788,
-0.0486307852,
0.014994177,
-0.0611349642,
0.022906065,
0.0085256631,
-0.0259143971,
0.0151158283,
0.015557305,
0.0525085926,
0.014072774,
0.0102409171,
0.0213019606,
-0.054748632,
0.0165804103,
-0.0156971067,
-0.0369259156,
-0.039391499,
0.0193530936,
-0.0267112982,
0.0290365648,
0.0052781492,
0.0255740099,
-0.0126798926,
-0.0437197611,
-0.0494273342,
-0.0308018494,
-0.0012544265,
0.0053243348,
-0.0186044835,
-0.0351648815,
-0.0089733684,
0.0097383754,
0.0144399377,
0.0114885382,
-0.0353110284,
0.0257867388,
2.905e-7,
0.0251137782,
0.0484285392,
0.0180537384,
-0.0038293938,
-0.0174676292,
0.0490286425,
-0.0142482817,
0.004194384,
0.0818628818,
0.0590696223,
0.0063974429,
-0.0273555852,
0.0215469636,
0.0304190349,
-0.0115894629,
0.0451194271,
-0.0195187945,
0.0247508287,
-0.0378636904,
-0.0099281715,
0.0455920883,
0.0600547194,
0.0231532659,
0.027559977,
0.0048186812,
-0.0271302424,
0.0045593986,
-0.0245360266,
-0.0374221988,
0.0260637142,
-0.0444291867,
0.0375887156,
0.0203436539,
0.0148367332,
-0.0295040794,
-0.0309638008,
0.0212038979,
0.0403266661,
-0.0576162785,
0.0561217144,
0.0315947905,
0.0229707994,
0.0231131129,
-0.047655195,
0.0149975047,
-0.0294746906,
0.0461785682,
0.050477922,
-0.066820994,
-0.0227781143,
0.0085451305,
-0.0237546843,
-0.0077888547,
0.030889513,
-0.0230164845,
0.0280970316,
-0.0350448862,
-0.0318872556,
-0.0273675658,
0.0351634286,
0.0231672302,
-0.021611236,
-0.011941948,
-0.0037974517,
0.0346789658,
-0.0289809052,
0.0273139141,
2.641438203e-34,
0.03859777,
-0.0316519812,
0.0500127189,
-0.0126414709,
0.0502016395,
0.0208392106,
-0.0012034767,
0.0197157525,
0.0119695663,
0.0139487088,
-0.0600972772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14735v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14735v2 | Legal Question-Answering in the Indian Context: Efficacy, Challenges, and Potential of Modern AI Models | 2023-09-26T07:56:55 | 2023-10-16T04:40:18 | Shubham Kumar Nigam, Shubham Kumar Mishra, Ayush Kumar Mishra, Noel Shallum, Arnab Bhattacharya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Legal QA platforms bear the promise to metamorphose the manner in which legal
experts engage with jurisprudential documents. In this exposition, we embark on
a comparative exploration of contemporary AI frameworks, gauging their
adeptness in catering to the unique demands of the Indian legal milieu, with a
keen emphasis on Indian Legal Question Answering (AILQA). Our discourse zeroes
in on an array of retrieval and QA mechanisms, positioning the OpenAI GPT model
as a reference point. The findings underscore the proficiency of prevailing
AILQA paradigms in decoding natural language prompts and churning out precise
responses. The ambit of this study is tethered to the Indian criminal legal
landscape, distinguished by its intricate nature and associated logistical
constraints. To ensure a holistic evaluation, we juxtapose empirical metrics
with insights garnered from seasoned legal practitioners, thereby painting a
comprehensive picture of AI's potential and challenges within the realm of
Indian legal QA. | [
0.0901307985,
0.0227429941,
-0.0308837891,
0.0133671118,
-0.0846206248,
0.0121833691,
-0.0038046241,
0.0126909781,
0.0313365869,
-0.0648233294,
-0.0180163234,
-0.0113260848,
-0.041584149,
0.013822821,
-0.0251575802,
-0.0331570767,
0.0120017696,
0.0057190913,
0.076530911,
0.0110967634,
0.0469083935,
0.0575823113,
-0.035120625,
0.0302335843,
-0.0133215087,
-0.016316792,
-0.0238073356,
-0.0250763148,
-0.0344867669,
-0.0268656053,
-0.0256581474,
0.0609384701,
0.0099309925,
-0.0057119001,
0.0000014797,
-0.0653072223,
0.0336414836,
-0.0088871438,
-0.0214741547,
-0.0097270366,
-0.0047728671,
-0.0017493941,
0.0078187492,
0.0124969771,
-0.0698352978,
0.0379365943,
0.0132780047,
-0.0154214976,
0.0215858147,
0.0899790749,
-0.004734966,
-0.0588751137,
0.0838287175,
0.0056811492,
-0.0089562312,
-0.053852912,
-0.0058790217,
0.009259209,
0.0654523894,
-0.0121941008,
0.0354356617,
0.0017472892,
0.0408041626,
-0.0309862718,
-0.0426297709,
-0.0329726487,
-0.0212757308,
0.0072511202,
0.0013876413,
0.0342363492,
0.1013869345,
-0.0108576342,
-0.021034196,
0.0068781278,
0.0281994902,
0.0280874558,
-0.033307869,
0.0850642323,
-0.0443140343,
-0.001056968,
0.0405764915,
0.0267967712,
-0.0300093032,
0.0177849717,
0.0187012777,
0.0377325155,
-0.0212399606,
-0.0270420816,
-0.0026010526,
-0.0012270985,
0.017535476,
-0.0231117886,
0.0233320929,
0.0958929807,
-0.0079724556,
0.0342666507,
-0.0016797585,
-0.0671671852,
0.0696204081,
-0.0261462573,
0.0221989863,
0.0231377445,
-0.0311965067,
0.0497708581,
-0.0061717867,
0.0400520787,
-0.0051924353,
0.0319327004,
-0.007452196,
-0.0610467307,
-0.0228994191,
-0.0579266995,
-0.0260804817,
0.0816142932,
-0.0529163256,
0.0173430499,
0.0185093731,
0.0229360908,
-0.0065749907,
-0.0202151258,
-0.0163079407,
0.0003646589,
-0.0229430851,
-0.0530137457,
-0.0630160049,
-0.0266635846,
-0.0840263963,
0.0458568409,
0.0197632164,
-0.0558298603,
0.0089880936,
0.01909489,
-0.0100331977,
-0.0068478859,
-0.0303712431,
0.0782540292,
-0.0264009777,
-0.0372502692,
-0.0516439639,
-0.0446127988,
0.0029147558,
-0.0533866622,
-0.0439966507,
-0.0483026989,
0.012401483,
0.0242148731,
-0.0599416085,
-0.0425782651,
0.0194460303,
0.068774052,
-0.0094083743,
0.0598972216,
-0.0201326441,
0.0026357123,
0.0395356566,
0.0451807491,
0.0524911992,
-0.0021479144,
0.0015459935,
-0.0046756631,
0.0543346182,
0.0149076367,
0.0615724549,
0.0075201215,
-0.0327422395,
-0.017730223,
0.0198310204,
0.082513079,
-0.0301805269,
0.0123087317,
0.0089229755,
0.0381438248,
-0.0082505289,
0.0200847443,
-0.0044478481,
0.1257024705,
-0.0132158743,
0.0638077408,
0.011872923,
-0.0201026741,
0.0500234105,
0.0194697976,
-0.01537163,
0.0333196856,
-0.0143335778,
0.0057573975,
-0.0441076979,
-0.0084964065,
-0.0246540736,
-0.0457760952,
-0.0022337816,
-0.0085331229,
-0.0289701726,
-0.0151924537,
-0.0012805733,
0.0120635899,
0.0042142184,
-0.0385965668,
0.010456319,
-0.0499571934,
-0.0209953561,
-0.0720148236,
0.0403040573,
0.0062219528,
0.0273074433,
-0.049313508,
-0.0153727401,
0.0227499977,
-0.007643404,
0.0483321138,
0.0207055174,
-0.0058401641,
-0.0421621054,
-0.009074579,
-0.0109205991,
-0.0003272176,
0.0006479679,
-0.0136222858,
-0.0002311197,
0.0459742174,
0.0253260043,
-0.0433565378,
0.0344749466,
0.0354575142,
0.0038925046,
-0.0308914594,
-0.0096501168,
0.0184003524,
0.0233104266,
0.0302462783,
0.0037054264,
0.0043177614,
0.0363387242,
0.0121337725,
0.0081911869,
0.0178103633,
0.0163865108,
0.0348964147,
0.0013176061,
-0.0446697585,
0.0331074297,
0.0242409632,
-0.0058120191,
-0.040089678,
-0.0299182422,
-0.0364043675,
-0.0019259228,
-0.0585981868,
-0.0435599945,
0.0181779638,
-0.0571667552,
-0.0409522876,
0.0519792363,
0.0096231923,
-0.0358280689,
0.015090988,
0.0084479637,
0.0563696176,
-0.0293065142,
-0.0007166496,
-0.008339081,
-0.0149559127,
0.0276541803,
0.0335708745,
0.0130257644,
-0.0590904877,
-0.0308942534,
-0.0694847554,
-0.0000673393,
-0.0279071629,
0.0157697313,
0.0153185865,
0.0053449594,
-0.0232609324,
-0.0486432277,
-0.0086217495,
-0.0316086039,
0.0430294275,
0.0066688741,
0.0317557007,
0.0164570622,
0.0244684368,
-0.0124342479,
-0.0166421179,
-0.0219139569,
0.0223491956,
0.0151643204,
-0.0133973584,
-0.0247273799,
0.0262718387,
-0.0324355178,
-0.0323308185,
-0.028887162,
0.0106484732,
0.0183527041,
0.0022608403,
-0.0515648425,
0.0394489728,
0.0520106889,
0.009989907,
-0.0198978614,
0.0215989314,
-0.0297611803,
0.0050016046,
0.0347216837,
-0.018246565,
0.0285209659,
0.0026069656,
0.0289560389,
-0.0223683529,
-0.0087517034,
0.0354134403,
-0.0178479534,
0.0186968073,
-0.0126147494,
-0.001681441,
-0.0429951549,
-0.0223288313,
-0.0543242283,
0.0734440088,
0.0151321404,
-0.0552140623,
0.0503418185,
0.0280509908,
0.0528515466,
-0.052313555,
-0.0128346421,
-0.0494817421,
0.0898667723,
-0.0427471735,
0.0344040953,
-0.0007087792,
-0.05907543,
-0.0142096011,
-0.0111724408,
0.0213542953,
-0.0451047495,
0.0497629642,
-0.0319030769,
0.0638546646,
-0.0160963237,
-0.0302348938,
-0.0400820933,
-0.0345535614,
-0.010117257,
0.0254204348,
-0.0107048983,
0.020014463,
0.0196406189,
0.0097323349,
-0.0097112618,
-0.0080659911,
-0.0053172233,
-0.0235180743,
-0.0256084967,
0.072505489,
0.0441969037,
0.0241724961,
0.0166776031,
0.0630420372,
0.0008087938,
0.0188177694,
0.026636878,
-0.022251673,
0.0332891792,
-0.0189611353,
0.0056114797,
-0.062817283,
-0.0141862147,
0.031307973,
0.0263577122,
-0.0274378583,
-0.0183183141,
0.0491938032,
0.0555411316,
-0.0372163989,
-0.057630755,
-0.0584890656,
-0.007528611,
0.0179995,
0.0472769365,
-0.1042337939,
0.0075219222,
-0.0158599578,
0.0251854155,
-0.0571576543,
-0.0138347186,
-0.0017696074,
-0.1041655615,
0.0720804185,
-0.0299290121,
-0.0207151771,
-0.0236636717,
-0.0119561488,
-0.0026105242,
0.031749364,
0.0331989825,
0.033988338,
-0.0402692519,
0.0074721882,
0.0233645439,
-0.0367895924,
0.0789562464,
0.0235204678,
-0.0365402848,
0.0365296081,
0.071333535,
0.0000188366,
-0.0290203206,
-0.024272006,
-0.0386005081,
-0.0576672442,
0.0284292921,
0.0194571186,
0.0150895445,
-0.007737644,
0.017434733,
-0.0650565997,
0.0430406556,
-0.0242347047,
-0.0193038341,
0.0713156164,
0.0548824444,
-0.0485556833,
0.0208171438,
-0.0489096381,
-0.0363555662,
-0.0095240157,
0.0179581475,
0.021765627,
0.0137316231,
-0.033120092,
-0.0298928246,
-0.0024029939,
-0.0273715984,
-0.0425523408,
-0.0159683786,
0.0094076684,
0.023622388,
-0.0117308749,
-0.0906670392,
0.0096353907,
0.0307778195,
0.0159563217,
0.0270018596,
0.0075772246,
0.0163789857,
-0.0383980125,
-0.0006399907,
-0.0688751861,
-0.0071094721,
-0.0206749327,
0.0245383028,
-0.0095850173,
0.0066871541,
-0.0021920912,
-0.0285843592,
0.0352299996,
0.0159279536,
-0.0141557986,
0.0442205854,
0.021755103,
-0.0596402772,
-0.0524471849,
-0.0593500212,
0.02099346,
0.014319798,
-0.0365296006,
-0.0133970035,
0.0147778103,
-0.0079153655,
-0.0270957313,
0.0032236523,
-0.0238355584,
0.0110513913,
-0.0016318639,
0.0170456637,
-0.0151439076,
-0.0247997493,
0.0607676841,
0.0575689785,
-0.0035895219,
0.0237817932,
0.0035883542,
-0.0000266358,
-0.0068162708,
-0.0094295852,
-0.0048012203,
-0.0011251977,
-0.0003301268,
0.0230549295,
-0.0232211985,
-0.019823717,
0.0445124768,
-0.0442492627,
0.0341078378,
-0.0660815611,
0.0388340317,
0.0624772385,
0.0471641831,
-0.0444721244,
-0.0394052379,
-0.0115841618,
0.019008182,
-0.0209122021,
0.0732130036,
-0.0118907783,
0.0811339617,
-0.0089741442,
-0.0119748544,
0.0292260926,
0.0385821722,
-0.0468531027,
-0.0725033432,
0.0003188192,
0.0758704916,
0.0209633056,
0.0208866578,
-0.0334322602,
0.0036822739,
0.0223094579,
0.0178938881,
0.0010265,
0.014018585,
-0.0358282439,
0.0800953805,
0.0185234658,
-0.0188902244,
0.0045537795,
0.0259550083,
-0.0798837766,
0.0060273893,
0.0070344382,
-0.0161651447,
-0.0160188321,
-0.050516326,
-0.0399785377,
0.0376329571,
0.0081337243,
-0.0272364244,
-0.0670754313,
-0.0047502737,
-0.0309048891,
-0.0205826666,
0.0019505088,
-0.0122491885,
0.025691716,
0.0572955199,
0.04754306,
-0.0542244278,
-0.0416681767,
0.0638193488,
-0.084312655,
-0.0240222607,
-0.0067190719,
-4.882635457e-33,
-0.0406649075,
-0.0653066784,
0.0222488847,
0.006324593,
-0.0073152198,
-0.0261779651,
-0.0067535043,
0.0106964149,
-0.051129818,
0.013351257,
-0.0571826287,
0.0409473777,
0.0092086131,
-0.0275071152,
0.0117907049,
-0.0452507846,
-0.0461731814,
-0.0121334633,
0.0017812847,
0.0208921935,
0.0038174766,
-0.0073787956,
-0.0079021296,
-0.0567456558,
0.0492830388,
-0.0177425183,
-0.008186697,
-0.001611026,
-0.0686755031,
0.062414825,
-0.0212747399,
0.0517832153,
0.0553507023,
-0.0037158099,
0.0330361538,
0.0855456665,
-0.081761986,
0.006828859,
0.0193546228,
-0.0090124421,
-0.0340948999,
-0.0397444963,
0.0176733062,
-0.0155106606,
0.0034526212,
0.0422682278,
0.0334939957,
-0.0005998728,
0.0011157029,
-0.0415301546,
-0.0858666971,
0.0173380356,
-0.0129657658,
0.0059901434,
-0.0272937287,
0.0330866724,
0.0057854154,
0.0203018915,
-0.0515892357,
-0.0429256968,
-0.0117635764,
-0.0009126017,
0.024042733,
-0.0424427539,
-0.0509364903,
-0.0019211347,
0.0050789644,
-0.0321775638,
-0.0516297631,
-0.0193095896,
-0.0021959543,
0.0561205633,
0.0346477889,
0.0338467732,
0.0078243092,
-0.0282872636,
-0.048605755,
0.0150865968,
0.0217179507,
0.073672086,
0.0056580701,
-0.0307575651,
-0.0542799495,
0.021460399,
-0.009902752,
-0.0258870367,
-0.0434156097,
-0.0095016863,
0.0434238762,
-0.0351904482,
0.0201450996,
-0.0228195339,
-0.0080817249,
-0.034884844,
0.0543535091,
0.009770791,
-0.0226974934,
0.0336295106,
-0.0155948019,
0.0614054874,
-0.0310313664,
0.0252101533,
-0.0021188101,
-0.0059026643,
0.0055656773,
-0.0205076821,
0.0185052101,
-0.043104127,
-0.059264373,
-0.0273507386,
0.0107018789,
0.0842085853,
0.0101457983,
0.0098687727,
0.0250172559,
0.0476215519,
0.0192687381,
0.0207511038,
0.041577626,
0.0000929656,
-0.0419779457,
-0.0307143833,
-0.006537125,
-0.0389294773,
-0.0137480879,
0.0480508804,
0.0027689196,
0.0754416212,
-0.0276553277,
-0.0110184457,
0.0128278704,
0.0713386685,
2.162e-7,
0.0763743818,
0.0089231683,
0.0147725008,
0.0144635206,
-0.0238960534,
0.0152654434,
0.0318329036,
0.0355498679,
0.053010609,
-0.0337736569,
-0.0051256288,
0.0235005803,
0.0329734869,
0.0679709911,
-0.0634378791,
-0.0021725753,
-0.0444269516,
-0.0176494122,
-0.066113323,
0.066106692,
0.0511838198,
0.023130985,
-0.0257191602,
-0.012927209,
-0.0426160544,
-0.0216423329,
0.0242350698,
0.0256722644,
0.0098441113,
-0.0236331671,
0.0629948303,
-0.011905727,
0.0122552011,
0.0373760164,
0.023665363,
0.0298334323,
-0.0047976091,
0.03162181,
-0.0001779071,
-0.0151445754,
-0.0089476462,
-0.0411356725,
0.0529767238,
-0.0450202599,
0.0756707489,
0.0040353751,
-0.0231476892,
-0.0172309987,
-0.0331686959,
-0.0481211618,
-0.0093259942,
0.0091933077,
-0.0181802902,
-0.0296470523,
0.0375332534,
-0.0591491386,
0.0498604476,
-0.056123469,
0.0327251889,
0.0213318169,
0.0186172426,
0.0142508289,
-0.013683375,
-0.0073535051,
0.0482893102,
-0.0583703443,
0.0214079395,
1.220140751e-34,
0.0010273464,
0.0071543395,
0.051645264,
0.0682923794,
0.047747992,
0.0520532951,
-0.0113815265,
-0.0014912938,
0.0121195782,
-0.0754784197,
0.0156740677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14726v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14726v2 | PLMM: Personal Large Language Models on Mobile Devices | 2023-09-26T07:36:20 | 2024-05-05T02:33:38 | Yuanhao Gong | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.LG | Inspired by Federated Learning, in this paper, we propose personal large
models that are distilled from traditional large language models but more
adaptive to local users' personal information such as education background and
hobbies. We classify the large language models into three levels: the personal
level, expert level and traditional level. The personal level models are
adaptive to users' personal information. They encrypt the users' input and
protect their privacy. The expert level models focus on merging specific
knowledge such as finance, IT and art. The traditional models focus on the
universal knowledge discovery and upgrading the expert models. In such
classifications, the personal models directly interact with the user. For the
whole system, the personal models have users' (encrypted) personal information.
Moreover, such models must be small enough to be performed on personal
computers or mobile devices. Finally, they also have to response in real-time
for better user experience and produce high quality results. The proposed
personal large models can be applied in a wide range of applications such as
language and vision tasks. | [
0.0256434251,
0.0494401939,
-0.0305829644,
0.0420197286,
-0.0096092038,
-0.0022841122,
0.112325877,
-0.0237536989,
0.0599643365,
-0.0086975973,
-0.0551361628,
0.0045978893,
-0.0108829541,
0.0087075373,
-0.00116798,
-0.0244617742,
0.0253799856,
-0.0508877113,
-0.0141117498,
-0.050028611,
-0.025843462,
0.0214275382,
0.0265064277,
0.0248437244,
0.0323012061,
-0.0395532958,
-0.0145530077,
-0.0168332011,
0.0109742256,
0.022011457,
0.0361944959,
0.0512682498,
0.0086748507,
0.0695894733,
0.0000021573,
0.0024986742,
-0.0371645652,
-0.0081757288,
0.0062180483,
0.0027201187,
0.0429528467,
0.050570704,
0.0042551262,
0.0138995629,
-0.0793037936,
-0.0206176303,
0.0246459227,
0.0437986366,
0.0688586533,
0.0523355566,
-0.0148654692,
-0.0739292055,
0.0037199447,
-0.0221386533,
-0.0461103208,
-0.0498443991,
0.0416854173,
0.021178022,
-0.0116957901,
0.0101044085,
0.0163250901,
0.0101412274,
0.0217050947,
0.0245435499,
0.0370923765,
0.0061818399,
0.0071369275,
-0.0302028134,
-0.0167452637,
0.0269669816,
-0.026435487,
-0.0222620033,
0.0291688517,
0.0044958508,
0.0039044535,
0.0424383171,
-0.0427456684,
-0.0041696429,
-0.0390155278,
0.0082694199,
0.0045164055,
-0.0085255112,
0.0094735064,
0.0373380072,
-0.0314841084,
0.0500317104,
0.0001978018,
0.0000608516,
-0.035579171,
-0.0334835239,
-0.0035118232,
-0.0458644331,
0.072476767,
0.0194468386,
0.0126567455,
-0.0305861291,
-0.0555869937,
-0.0262280274,
-0.0306487009,
-0.0521100648,
-0.0079809707,
-0.0257083159,
0.0276853666,
0.0701130033,
-0.0017832193,
0.0019344483,
-0.0408076793,
-0.0107752597,
0.0033008235,
0.0106529845,
-0.0784403086,
0.0004987418,
-0.0275537465,
0.0801852942,
-0.0571370572,
-0.0373517312,
-0.0259874016,
0.0453026667,
-0.0023719254,
0.0285737067,
-0.0063620568,
-0.0101397196,
0.0092336033,
-0.0460382327,
0.0015709647,
0.0210832618,
-0.0382910632,
0.0297511462,
-0.0049370844,
-0.0267280247,
0.0509132296,
-0.0077891289,
-0.0034316564,
-0.0228589475,
-0.012170733,
0.0331994593,
-0.0030900827,
-0.0210983343,
-0.0264697708,
-0.0766882002,
0.0419058539,
-0.049997732,
-0.0195663199,
-0.0747946948,
0.0165381674,
-0.0220552627,
0.0258779116,
-0.0571237281,
-0.0036242383,
0.0107403072,
-0.0250051841,
0.0379122421,
-0.0177642256,
-0.0029137684,
0.0327439494,
0.03466665,
0.0030147226,
0.0631472692,
0.0076234578,
0.0505006611,
0.0521638393,
-0.0343410894,
-0.0084833009,
0.0355368555,
-0.0106630893,
-0.0136640426,
0.0022519119,
0.0018510183,
-0.0246971752,
-0.0251254141,
-0.0554556549,
0.0174566749,
-0.0304453392,
0.0236217976,
0.0917170346,
0.0658883527,
0.0737706274,
0.0531561971,
-0.0710977539,
0.0390979797,
0.0450423658,
-0.0259056203,
-0.0273254719,
0.0075807539,
-0.0697530955,
-0.0323764198,
-0.007493312,
0.0510288402,
-0.0320343003,
-0.0174979325,
0.0208481792,
-0.0531138405,
-0.0128360335,
0.0479150675,
0.0522034355,
-0.0012392844,
0.0346709676,
0.0381394327,
0.0132153807,
-0.0435572788,
-0.0078685088,
-0.0366261192,
0.0645528808,
0.1224260181,
0.0229580328,
-0.0185086224,
0.0141984923,
-0.0119603435,
-0.0084904907,
-0.0018535145,
0.0089494716,
-0.0046084221,
0.0381212682,
-0.0529274642,
-0.0766229481,
0.049990315,
0.0109037282,
-0.0187776703,
0.0188428443,
0.0251372866,
-0.0059149549,
-0.0094650174,
0.0108117955,
-0.0105763376,
-0.0310816597,
-0.0130951768,
0.0464681834,
0.0367129594,
-0.015488808,
0.0530636646,
0.031693276,
-0.0220061857,
0.0168369636,
-0.0124044167,
0.0038478044,
-0.0328945443,
0.0094105713,
0.0299003366,
-0.0033263806,
-0.0217520744,
0.0320880823,
0.0165432189,
0.0003181833,
-0.0140284663,
-0.034036044,
0.0167040713,
0.0674775019,
-0.0067478349,
0.0218933132,
-0.0249338467,
0.014212627,
-0.0135540292,
0.0581851155,
-0.0141844535,
-0.0273211971,
-0.0262660217,
-0.0473675095,
0.0166129842,
-0.0441436283,
0.0049919351,
0.000703229,
0.0202624761,
0.0427664369,
0.0129029145,
0.0094009768,
-0.0239150673,
-0.0341650471,
-0.0400883369,
0.016774267,
-0.0201972853,
0.0271505881,
0.0108406488,
0.0325930864,
-0.0021359359,
-0.0728964284,
-0.028954098,
0.0460969545,
-0.0408790782,
0.049148757,
-0.0068887887,
0.0002498466,
-0.0215560161,
-0.0115218032,
-0.0295313504,
0.0094669964,
0.033120729,
0.0004598825,
-0.031807404,
-0.0375903398,
-0.0469043367,
-0.0454858094,
0.0170786213,
0.0050027245,
0.0163295846,
0.0003899331,
-0.0226454586,
0.005785103,
0.0466597788,
-0.0134864422,
0.0370761827,
0.0377166495,
-0.0100990003,
-0.0259978622,
-0.0113900425,
-0.0066169649,
-0.0192458183,
-0.0533484519,
0.0410145484,
-0.0032118359,
0.0251548085,
-0.0238211229,
-0.0151631646,
-0.0396819264,
0.0660528988,
0.0058753919,
-0.0133479014,
-0.0363554806,
0.0637246817,
0.0226678718,
0.0304352976,
0.0106140533,
-0.0340819173,
0.0598036572,
0.0298317336,
0.0349614248,
-0.0016262507,
-0.0839238837,
-0.0236385576,
0.0790912211,
-0.0385750011,
0.0421472117,
-0.0068634027,
-0.0596602112,
-0.0290356744,
0.0252701007,
0.0240327269,
-0.064740546,
-0.0254038349,
-0.0205183048,
-0.0287253838,
0.0260741785,
-0.0387541242,
-0.0099170245,
-0.0694357678,
-0.077473782,
-0.0326763242,
-0.0281050298,
-0.053679049,
-0.0277197119,
-0.0035354008,
-0.010182702,
-0.0154686458,
-0.0191160906,
0.014241389,
-0.0171513166,
0.009758668,
0.023141874,
-0.0215390399,
-0.0514620915,
-0.028364297,
0.0308575295,
0.0483437888,
0.0359302349,
-0.026042534,
-0.0205752533,
-0.0261183921,
0.058049541,
-0.0305078812,
-0.0654005855,
0.0106807165,
0.0055622091,
-0.0532532372,
0.0420485213,
0.0728587955,
-0.0096690543,
-0.0621006638,
-0.0284342468,
-0.0008049814,
0.0136229275,
-0.0199443307,
0.0262260623,
-0.0727440119,
-0.0261753891,
-0.0173090976,
0.0191613752,
0.0759432018,
-0.0047182534,
-0.0253223293,
-0.0538076572,
-0.030861076,
0.0492066965,
-0.0057303347,
-0.0236760695,
-0.0325783975,
-0.005952707,
-0.0034297705,
-0.0111432876,
-0.0339659713,
-0.0176817961,
0.0004767556,
-0.0005739513,
-0.0580112748,
-0.0521525592,
-0.0061431462,
-0.0203963891,
-0.0039739013,
0.0254025832,
0.0242627487,
0.005774748,
-0.085129261,
-0.0371927693,
0.0709572062,
-0.0168372262,
-0.023671031,
-0.0079431739,
-0.0202084742,
-0.0059973202,
-0.0083613088,
0.0418672822,
0.0261515453,
0.0155042931,
0.0420113318,
0.0504142977,
-0.0032983434,
-0.0015219226,
-0.0329598859,
-0.0296992753,
0.0207716599,
0.0550879203,
-0.031928692,
-0.0753456727,
-0.0042932266,
0.0083323559,
-0.0209330861,
0.0374862924,
-0.0024365359,
0.0393956192,
0.0235358477,
-0.0539085604,
-0.0359570757,
0.0169657432,
0.0190745257,
0.0488273166,
0.028125288,
0.0466870666,
0.0812808648,
-0.0203381591,
-0.0406167097,
0.0198055077,
-0.0565631464,
0.032997217,
-0.0681028143,
-0.0042337379,
0.0093505802,
-0.0560324267,
-0.005790343,
-0.0091320388,
-0.1034140363,
-0.062175367,
-0.0025891771,
0.025741173,
0.0196166299,
0.0312106516,
-0.0281674881,
-0.0935754776,
0.0818797201,
0.0183876697,
-0.0862561986,
-0.0078460798,
0.0541324392,
-0.0465382002,
-0.0147462096,
0.0432788879,
-0.0502043106,
-0.0229074229,
0.0120334635,
-0.042189993,
-0.0701382905,
-0.0743087307,
-0.0180774741,
-0.0031904108,
0.0616303682,
0.013213438,
-0.0049284985,
-0.0169851724,
0.0456310697,
0.0067352448,
-0.0007490173,
-0.0301777124,
-0.0334109962,
0.0377665982,
-0.0125931706,
0.0528596379,
-0.0124645112,
0.0795597658,
-0.0546032637,
-0.0366340466,
0.0106581049,
-0.0190112982,
0.0303796623,
0.0352186114,
0.0043691793,
-0.0198583789,
0.0448137596,
0.027776001,
0.0264446884,
-0.0316440873,
0.0490422025,
-0.0280703716,
-0.0141252,
-0.0256367382,
0.05501201,
-0.0411859378,
-0.1009588242,
0.0229534507,
0.0457922444,
0.0447765738,
0.0129596125,
0.0114225736,
-0.0491549931,
-0.0038022439,
-0.0585120544,
0.0312403105,
-0.0203861538,
-0.0551976003,
-0.0125927608,
-0.0155496551,
0.0058947583,
0.0353891551,
0.0816694945,
0.0292310361,
-0.0241146367,
-0.037859302,
-0.0285573602,
-0.066289857,
0.0130597344,
0.0343666412,
0.0749564618,
-0.0459079742,
0.0095423395,
-0.01669777,
-0.0369619951,
-0.0131448954,
-0.0116683673,
-0.0267220046,
-0.0070323092,
0.0476963855,
0.0325157456,
-0.0121872826,
-0.0023978362,
-0.0672998875,
0.0241677575,
0.0106205754,
0.0124389911,
-0.0150646232,
-5.920415869e-33,
-0.0136778811,
-0.0264701229,
0.0143087879,
0.0052926959,
0.0355733335,
0.0234281663,
0.0250121765,
0.032638181,
0.0107355947,
-0.0111411419,
-0.0249979198,
0.0065854797,
0.0140820546,
0.0214574914,
0.0071913223,
0.0150170075,
0.0757250562,
0.0168961212,
0.0403940119,
0.0335140266,
0.0485734604,
0.0485091992,
0.0358914211,
-0.0813796446,
0.0149094742,
-0.0301496815,
-0.0408532508,
0.0087587778,
-0.027932398,
0.0696410984,
-0.0272851158,
0.0181465931,
-0.0107207242,
-0.0019626168,
-0.0066994536,
0.0463196337,
-0.0623927191,
-0.0184927657,
0.0014891247,
0.0704277232,
-0.0177093837,
-0.0513208769,
0.0501828007,
-0.031640958,
-0.0030418967,
0.002170759,
0.0433222651,
-0.0036851971,
-0.0353232659,
-0.0014352392,
0.0238519628,
0.0025850949,
0.0093334541,
0.0075051249,
0.0596736856,
-0.0159212723,
-0.0261448305,
-0.0635859668,
-0.0333839096,
0.0586295724,
0.000235301,
-0.0112792272,
0.0329180136,
0.004435984,
0.0145137468,
0.0552403294,
0.055901207,
0.0039851191,
-0.0163281914,
-0.0042331372,
-0.0105771488,
0.0826180205,
-0.0047819819,
0.03460766,
-0.0175719988,
-0.0092312349,
0.0021393793,
0.0042476431,
0.0595847592,
-0.0057177311,
0.0117485709,
0.0386603698,
-0.0195238478,
-0.0084880684,
-0.015961824,
0.010866126,
-0.0165772438,
-0.0065798252,
0.0037381253,
0.0155473994,
-0.0315626003,
-0.0205697212,
0.0147893121,
-0.0571863241,
-0.0525114276,
-0.0017146844,
0.0468639843,
-0.0166840963,
-0.0020540848,
0.0368744098,
-0.0342563652,
-0.0212908331,
-0.0381019935,
-0.0587632693,
0.0079816449,
0.0354432203,
0.0207051151,
0.0093143452,
-0.0560535714,
-0.0238130614,
0.0059394529,
-0.021717852,
0.026703475,
0.0147373425,
0.0821963325,
-0.0217494853,
-0.0107533112,
0.0576022491,
0.0035708756,
0.0051415749,
-0.0201247968,
-0.0321707539,
0.0143278055,
0.0135900378,
0.0500886478,
-0.0017704896,
-0.056300085,
0.0228364412,
0.0782139376,
0.013977997,
0.0014945009,
-0.0062310328,
2.832e-7,
-0.0326699652,
0.0144429635,
-0.0620879568,
-0.0338647626,
0.0266301744,
0.059882082,
0.0155816507,
0.0415318608,
-0.0316991135,
0.0577429608,
-0.0224218089,
0.0293284021,
0.0524616838,
0.0076256441,
-0.0655179843,
-0.0310497005,
-0.0073744506,
0.0805094466,
-0.0936897323,
0.0059053004,
-0.0005076844,
0.0501919277,
0.0863557905,
-0.0059111947,
0.002436189,
-0.0269035455,
0.0399049819,
-0.0142347794,
-0.0312066358,
-0.0390382223,
0.0402251631,
0.0893814042,
-0.0147086233,
0.0206355061,
-0.0204953663,
0.0118058007,
0.0217901412,
0.068808794,
0.0104855942,
0.0867709294,
0.008987953,
-0.0323402211,
-0.0505672544,
0.0228739735,
0.0638570562,
0.0097115152,
-0.0233388431,
-0.0180917457,
0.0163149312,
-0.0715103298,
0.0206906889,
0.0125049232,
-0.0230920874,
-0.00412704,
0.0104582431,
-0.0184839331,
-0.0192521196,
-0.0475205593,
0.0124985501,
-0.0153454263,
-0.032847017,
-0.0201000068,
-0.0338302851,
0.0387981161,
0.0157558266,
-0.0247165561,
0.0521360077,
1.999867162e-34,
-0.0108762523,
0.0059821461,
0.011057809,
0.0194028895,
0.0062471405,
-0.0143526755,
0.009110203,
0.0035282318,
0.0558929369,
-0.0482347347,
0.0003461698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14717v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14717v2 | QA-LoRA: Quantization-Aware Low-Rank Adaptation of Large Language Models | 2023-09-26T07:22:23 | 2023-10-09T07:39:04 | Yuhui Xu, Lingxi Xie, Xiaotao Gu, Xin Chen, Heng Chang, Hengheng Zhang, Zhengsu Chen, Xiaopeng Zhang, Qi Tian | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Recently years have witnessed a rapid development of large language models
(LLMs). Despite the strong ability in many language-understanding tasks, the
heavy computational burden largely restricts the application of LLMs especially
when one needs to deploy them onto edge devices. In this paper, we propose a
quantization-aware low-rank adaptation (QA-LoRA) algorithm. The motivation lies
in the imbalanced degrees of freedom of quantization and adaptation, and the
solution is to use group-wise operators which increase the degree of freedom of
quantization meanwhile decreasing that of adaptation. QA-LoRA is easily
implemented with a few lines of code, and it equips the original LoRA with
two-fold abilities: (i) during fine-tuning, the LLM's weights are quantized
(e.g., into INT4) to reduce time and memory usage; (ii) after fine-tuning, the
LLM and auxiliary weights are naturally integrated into a quantized model
without loss of accuracy. We apply QA-LoRA to the LLaMA and LLaMA2 model
families and validate its effectiveness in different fine-tuning datasets and
downstream scenarios. Code will be made available at
https://github.com/yuhuixu1993/qa-lora. | [
-0.003401547,
0.0771648288,
-0.0134830195,
0.0536316969,
0.0209765676,
0.0242826939,
0.0234491806,
0.0153130479,
0.000237961,
-0.0503374934,
-0.0275467653,
-0.039428018,
-0.0002131004,
0.0155294901,
0.030439768,
-0.0334069245,
0.0404788554,
-0.0704988837,
0.0053777075,
-0.037052203,
-0.0258445274,
-0.0037401,
0.0245069824,
0.006788657,
0.0688717887,
0.0176284239,
0.001920513,
0.0222227052,
0.0280605666,
0.0002821543,
0.0023046439,
0.073359102,
0.0433589369,
0.0362489037,
0.000002043,
-0.0206736606,
-0.0381330699,
-0.0108827883,
0.0070905108,
0.0276994258,
0.040982835,
-0.0277284253,
-0.0642033666,
0.0210035965,
-0.0267576594,
0.0128288763,
0.0710370094,
-0.0299936458,
0.051225964,
0.0641474798,
-0.0141445324,
-0.0151857464,
0.0077070291,
-0.0180871226,
-0.0397343822,
-0.0552718975,
0.0303051472,
0.0083048502,
-0.0076864455,
-0.0108479634,
-0.0408373922,
0.0234410949,
-0.0090726297,
0.0086467853,
-0.0129392184,
-0.0005138787,
-0.0802418441,
0.0106681334,
-0.042262163,
0.0709425807,
-0.0799635425,
-0.0352179632,
0.0288296733,
0.0125485538,
-0.0467035994,
-0.0725655407,
-0.0449407957,
-0.0108509054,
0.0360962376,
0.0312784053,
-0.014663944,
-0.0425048023,
0.0389869511,
0.0095938556,
-0.0694589242,
0.0745841339,
0.0387007929,
-0.0108817248,
-0.0286979992,
-0.0226387288,
-0.0691785738,
-0.0327033848,
0.0209802203,
0.0331046954,
-0.0098561393,
0.0131516373,
-0.0676786378,
-0.0436827466,
-0.0092335213,
-0.0356238633,
0.0467979498,
0.0768366233,
-0.0039158333,
0.0325930454,
-0.0397077464,
0.0563979819,
-0.015954094,
0.0393535718,
-0.0499561429,
0.0226537418,
0.0084295254,
0.0124119427,
-0.0295258891,
0.0034629446,
-0.0345991999,
-0.0202738829,
-0.0388509557,
0.0201914143,
0.0286044106,
-0.019269878,
0.0007437869,
-0.0178033412,
-0.0265782513,
-0.0246940833,
0.0427885614,
0.0361276194,
0.0284036957,
0.0377609022,
-0.0199141074,
-0.057065893,
-0.0014028066,
0.0081113121,
0.0207711775,
-0.0218566675,
0.016134128,
0.029583741,
-0.0054209298,
-0.0412062854,
0.0104264142,
0.0544628762,
-0.0084326966,
-0.0560852699,
-0.0148851341,
-0.0436705947,
-0.0006011907,
-0.0005860365,
0.0374625139,
-0.0477914773,
-0.0064466419,
-0.0134654045,
-0.0311254747,
0.0606576502,
-0.0342238769,
0.0075595425,
0.028314501,
-0.0006801526,
0.0389976203,
0.083756417,
0.0489379242,
0.0081846528,
0.0080914833,
-0.0035869377,
-0.047432296,
0.067379415,
0.009239614,
0.0391954705,
-0.0375137553,
-0.0170902126,
-0.0135481386,
0.0172530897,
0.0655084699,
0.0633514002,
-0.0012961677,
-0.0115125468,
0.0389381982,
0.0436876416,
0.0750541016,
0.0292626526,
-0.0406310409,
0.0055074999,
-0.0024257842,
-0.0333625302,
-0.0269115474,
0.0297859255,
-0.0228243694,
-0.0064232843,
0.04710434,
0.0864826888,
-0.0200857297,
-0.0308807474,
-0.0305086523,
0.0203241184,
-0.0099293068,
0.0144308908,
0.0381840579,
-0.008453426,
-0.011129587,
0.0382445417,
0.0483391061,
-0.0561710037,
-0.0176306572,
-0.0921766683,
0.0123425154,
0.0550692976,
0.0213775206,
-0.0121806888,
0.003213756,
0.0157124959,
0.0101982579,
0.0124867819,
-0.0044608242,
0.0123996297,
-0.0003643912,
-0.0631639287,
-0.0349343121,
0.0393721387,
0.0050407653,
0.0234371983,
-0.0110758841,
0.0095360782,
0.004456243,
-0.0299584549,
-0.0143429618,
0.0235043187,
0.0343930461,
-0.0146505637,
0.0459217019,
-0.0011788723,
0.0234420467,
0.0157525726,
0.0033092322,
-0.0345131345,
0.0232966021,
-0.0470947139,
0.0371983498,
-0.0480633117,
0.0065740868,
-0.0305845439,
0.0420457944,
0.0297282897,
0.0551106632,
0.0589218214,
-0.0473822355,
-0.0485273115,
0.0589754321,
-0.0087645901,
0.0176197775,
-0.0289004631,
0.0333911292,
-0.0197655428,
0.0947856903,
-0.0285764579,
0.0431028344,
-0.0057346532,
-0.0011943468,
0.0411555469,
0.0326233953,
-0.0173501968,
-0.0473552272,
-0.0507799014,
0.0476283059,
0.018649295,
0.0644511655,
-0.0188825894,
0.029687712,
-0.0024913538,
-0.0161623247,
-0.0939481929,
0.0137189636,
-0.0634696186,
0.0480404906,
0.0228540506,
0.0372411907,
-0.0083841877,
-0.0304551795,
-0.0237456299,
0.005570807,
-0.0155840842,
0.0101078805,
-0.024038434,
0.0028261656,
-0.0394658521,
-0.0400976017,
-0.0438442342,
0.0022488623,
0.0407649055,
-0.0472274534,
-0.0363510922,
-0.0805395097,
-0.0100465054,
-0.0424287505,
0.0475082695,
-0.0140906051,
-0.0405795202,
-0.0141917989,
-0.0108735496,
0.042862121,
0.0499179177,
0.0061781458,
-0.0125254486,
0.0986978114,
0.0192274041,
-0.0124596432,
0.0123944581,
0.0100736665,
-0.0721169189,
-0.023046609,
-0.0034435906,
-0.0222723857,
0.0714068487,
-0.0291908961,
-0.0222339109,
-0.0580122434,
0.013725495,
-0.0326600745,
0.0020612704,
-0.0450873598,
0.0313474536,
-0.025917802,
0.0478216037,
-0.0050195269,
-0.0440731347,
0.028267635,
-0.0308932941,
-0.0070458222,
-0.0384484008,
-0.0286803357,
-0.0376466475,
0.0163088664,
0.002473756,
0.0359144248,
-0.0384235382,
-0.0050912551,
-0.0373869389,
-0.0103865294,
-0.023803791,
-0.0493897311,
0.028517507,
-0.0476041362,
0.0513898842,
-0.0458595157,
-0.0259935316,
0.0218202192,
0.0060239523,
-0.0258291326,
0.011582667,
-0.005724635,
-0.0309398212,
0.0337585472,
0.070710972,
-0.0077965381,
0.0518454574,
-0.0179766435,
0.0148360711,
-0.0383778922,
0.044727575,
0.0635829195,
0.0369073525,
0.0138901444,
0.0027621754,
0.0222893544,
-0.0148359798,
0.0572043657,
0.012360584,
-0.039364174,
0.0520415492,
0.0605236627,
0.0202664267,
-0.0107879657,
0.0295130927,
0.0456063859,
-0.0151030608,
0.0103597818,
0.0650831163,
0.0081849871,
-0.0625031739,
0.0156300087,
-0.0378876738,
0.0597668067,
0.0245053191,
0.0476974137,
-0.0677938387,
-0.016712876,
0.0066334526,
0.0343777612,
0.0160957612,
0.0102086421,
-0.0345327035,
-0.0489591695,
0.0247927904,
0.0477895886,
-0.0033630945,
-0.030797556,
-0.0230877548,
0.0224083364,
-0.0118380431,
0.0725119337,
0.0363945961,
-0.0155860549,
-0.0221453682,
0.0234862734,
-0.0233183559,
-0.0586697906,
0.0193844233,
0.0125262383,
0.0669967309,
0.0567302778,
0.0254290123,
-0.0064710537,
-0.000702771,
0.0028727532,
-0.0257950369,
-0.026565969,
-0.0179881435,
-0.0290565118,
0.0194370318,
-0.0292602666,
0.033072304,
0.0152717605,
-0.0014538384,
0.0063044694,
-0.0223742649,
0.0253631845,
-0.0020220336,
-0.0128150545,
0.0150215095,
-0.0529890805,
-0.0106685217,
0.0115518607,
0.0072213155,
-0.0152377877,
-0.0296260137,
-0.0362177491,
-0.0236374494,
-0.0185080189,
-0.0481353514,
-0.0142372213,
-0.0317547917,
-0.0229444969,
-0.0375557579,
0.0338157713,
0.0276418142,
0.0051256376,
-0.0008701377,
0.0152753489,
0.0001195946,
0.0095021101,
-0.0556356721,
-0.0009790679,
-0.0440913774,
0.0200447366,
-0.04229334,
-0.016678052,
0.0232555047,
-0.0248784386,
-0.0252829418,
-0.0063330433,
-0.0910664499,
-0.0769097134,
0.0124581959,
0.0336618423,
0.0227713957,
0.0308085531,
-0.0156345461,
-0.0956841633,
0.070943661,
0.0361487828,
0.01253602,
0.0703788027,
0.0134094702,
-0.0110715423,
-0.0215517413,
0.0541967079,
-0.0650605783,
0.0363277979,
0.0064502419,
0.0510205254,
-0.0600103289,
-0.069402732,
-0.0202686265,
0.0173758492,
0.0420812964,
-0.0003326482,
-0.0556480661,
0.0010593329,
0.0475365408,
-0.0103897797,
0.0140788564,
-0.0300102066,
-0.0216350332,
0.0070533445,
-0.0109745823,
-0.0171281956,
-0.010155458,
0.0231067091,
-0.01996997,
-0.0112625044,
0.0365774743,
-0.0379726887,
0.0204503294,
0.0616738051,
0.0066919303,
-0.0043781637,
0.0265381634,
0.0311747342,
0.0443176627,
-0.0282144081,
-0.0176442396,
-0.0224385206,
-0.0074861944,
-0.0555954352,
0.06691093,
-0.024660958,
-0.0651836246,
-0.0645077825,
0.0057037491,
0.0559902862,
0.0551204123,
0.0867312327,
0.020941671,
-0.0105632339,
-0.0219552647,
0.0001787743,
0.0067166989,
-0.0118927816,
0.0572089776,
-0.007697416,
-0.0177976415,
0.0378626809,
0.0428514816,
0.0656835064,
0.0242349505,
-0.0054629645,
0.0179197602,
-0.0319286771,
-0.0171491131,
-0.0267501306,
0.014381757,
-0.0219893605,
-0.0056058057,
0.0040066917,
-0.0459772013,
-0.0055144615,
-0.0094416747,
-0.0004002799,
-0.0625278503,
-0.0111702178,
0.0294009838,
-0.009425058,
-0.0217661429,
-0.0427647755,
-0.0683684498,
-0.0006603603,
-0.0006799354,
0.035439577,
-6.647155333e-33,
-0.0515497886,
0.0233077351,
0.0078587774,
-0.015027809,
-0.0063988878,
-0.0075417827,
-0.0184616689,
0.0002676247,
-0.0288935136,
-0.0482761413,
-0.0292572156,
0.0104389274,
0.0305776037,
-0.0061706197,
-0.0348738842,
0.0303266291,
0.0528075509,
-0.0090678232,
-0.0224496964,
0.0283140521,
-0.0015840468,
0.0281030759,
0.0304649714,
0.0245968569,
-0.0321919546,
0.0103602512,
-0.0279866811,
-0.0085172495,
-0.0086349957,
0.0350564122,
-0.0492049567,
0.048712641,
-0.0009006097,
0.0382691547,
-0.0334647037,
0.0173963979,
-0.0643586591,
0.013797882,
0.0046115839,
0.0344778672,
0.0231916439,
-0.0488695353,
0.058889851,
0.0284132492,
-0.0572304949,
-0.0214511231,
0.0008254507,
-0.031863112,
-0.0447254777,
-0.0476607308,
-0.0146353217,
0.0416587181,
0.0107656578,
0.0027812524,
0.0466878563,
-0.013460082,
-0.026874613,
0.0086011169,
-0.068943128,
0.0208997205,
0.0316359475,
0.1017526314,
0.0842917487,
0.0434681885,
-0.0132658947,
0.0122810723,
0.0045776442,
-0.045092959,
0.0293619968,
0.0047761537,
0.0371582657,
0.0066916761,
0.0123389596,
0.0173141025,
0.0434337296,
-0.0414800942,
-0.0685194358,
-0.005370005,
-0.0045425566,
0.0157579873,
0.045407407,
0.071798943,
-0.0217693243,
-0.0277548674,
-0.0242330302,
-0.0186636392,
-0.0592250116,
-0.0383103155,
0.0133268479,
-0.0031983107,
-0.0595903657,
-0.0246987604,
0.0315998867,
-0.0550649464,
-0.0052056592,
-0.0183166917,
-0.0201473814,
0.0185074527,
0.0085731614,
0.0607900731,
-0.0253641736,
-0.0441250801,
0.028879134,
0.005323322,
0.0047412971,
-0.039850302,
0.0029276847,
0.0635453761,
-0.0807178095,
-0.0079441117,
-0.0058074659,
0.0136991106,
-0.0158005282,
0.0639322251,
-0.0142791318,
-0.0126883099,
0.0169393085,
0.0361341387,
0.0007157452,
-0.0062300614,
0.0013773938,
-0.000915468,
0.0081227431,
0.0480981059,
-0.0717134774,
0.0029568744,
-0.0423374511,
0.0650190935,
0.0488584675,
-0.0454512872,
-0.0466472022,
0.0278623328,
2.864e-7,
0.0321965143,
0.0523627326,
-0.0241802149,
-0.0404580645,
-0.0060433238,
-0.0073171239,
-0.0292466376,
0.0492526442,
0.0207008589,
0.0123502249,
0.0111913448,
0.0287570227,
0.0207782313,
-0.0171746965,
-0.0283739865,
0.0351172052,
-0.0663797483,
0.0279324409,
-0.0631559938,
-0.039243184,
0.0302273128,
0.1237384006,
-0.0254463982,
-0.0180237126,
0.0139463712,
-0.0138146905,
0.0340561643,
0.0023239285,
0.0199721698,
0.0225954112,
0.0531357564,
0.0090046544,
-0.0480401292,
-0.0320273489,
0.026335394,
0.0508459993,
-0.019848749,
0.0799529105,
-0.0304529145,
0.0072561121,
0.0177057739,
0.0106140571,
-0.0143115073,
-0.059864752,
0.0692358091,
-0.0123563362,
-0.0292831827,
-0.077363953,
-0.0163424257,
-0.0281248186,
-0.0044068587,
-0.037028987,
0.0101729203,
0.0171197541,
0.0321733803,
-0.0222647395,
-0.0200394262,
-0.0930026248,
-0.0286527574,
0.0272706281,
-0.0214573368,
-0.0597100146,
-0.0449005887,
0.0025143651,
0.0274373572,
-0.0469778851,
0.0544495806,
2.51011505e-34,
0.0296327826,
0.000075995,
0.0059400029,
0.0330575667,
0.0019713331,
-0.0249696523,
0.0042588259,
0.0164905954,
-0.0067073111,
-0.1033927128,
-0.0077687725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14683v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14683v1 | A Simple Text to Video Model via Transformer | 2023-09-26T05:26:30 | 2023-09-26T05:26:30 | Gang Chen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, 68T10, I.2.6 | We present a general and simple text to video model based on Transformer.
Since both text and video are sequential data, we encode both texts and images
into the same hidden space, which are further fed into Transformer to capture
the temporal consistency and then decoder to generate either text or images.
Considering the image signal may become weak in the long sequence, we introduce
the U-Net to reconstruct image from its noised version. Specifically, we
increase the noise level to the original image in the long sequence, then use
the $down$ module from U-Net to encode noised images, which are further input
to transformer to predict next clear images. We also add a constraint to
promote motion between any generated image pair in the video. We use GPT2 and
test our approach on UCF101 dataset and show it can generate promising videos. | [
-0.0000811529,
0.092212081,
0.0446469486,
0.0266598854,
-0.0043317899,
-0.0078281946,
0.0267080814,
0.0426719263,
-0.0597529709,
-0.0397253372,
0.0474096872,
-0.0396350697,
0.0071175145,
0.0392547026,
0.0114754802,
-0.1152032837,
-0.0382400192,
0.0017956685,
-0.0374166034,
-0.0036478781,
0.0287174061,
-0.0148327239,
0.0024710526,
-0.0022382545,
-0.0591703057,
-0.0066039534,
-0.0285996385,
0.0004315494,
0.0479899347,
0.0025417844,
-0.0320789404,
0.0371986739,
0.0705458969,
0.0106561035,
0.0000021482,
-0.0018837472,
-0.0173661485,
0.0152018704,
0.0133301159,
0.0136456015,
0.029906936,
-0.0449148193,
-0.0401563719,
0.0060349014,
-0.0422836579,
0.0394273028,
0.0511096865,
0.0424336307,
0.0677426085,
0.0318388902,
-0.0565444566,
-0.0831710473,
0.047376547,
-0.0299220923,
0.0356431045,
-0.0149164302,
-0.0113363778,
-0.0278789308,
-0.0094428631,
0.0348023362,
-0.0487185419,
0.0304261576,
0.0481444709,
-0.0317676254,
-0.0068711652,
0.0543756001,
-0.0089276535,
-0.0441359505,
-0.0341636874,
0.0219924916,
-0.0594400354,
0.0053649452,
-0.0160638224,
0.0014075463,
-0.0079216296,
0.0239171181,
-0.0364453606,
0.046881184,
0.0010588063,
0.0218358953,
-0.0630027577,
0.074436456,
-0.0099209538,
-0.0272979289,
-0.0008478608,
-0.0576332659,
0.0339314826,
0.0219256599,
-0.0567463376,
0.0068021468,
0.0129878791,
-0.0276541058,
0.0711750388,
0.0300401039,
0.0449076369,
-0.0253551155,
-0.0607025512,
-0.0720120966,
-0.0538605042,
-0.0433672741,
0.0409003347,
0.0201107766,
-0.0147008598,
0.0288258716,
-0.0391087197,
0.0810654387,
-0.0368669815,
-0.0004040437,
-0.0362174883,
-0.0100166015,
-0.0307654031,
-0.0085472111,
-0.0317500383,
0.0167970583,
-0.0043693539,
-0.0359753706,
-0.0205941517,
-0.0212079622,
-0.0036218481,
0.0036615515,
0.0121035771,
0.0427722074,
-0.077045165,
-0.0613364093,
-0.0145127624,
0.0003346221,
0.0442732498,
0.0306059923,
0.0084355175,
-0.0242072977,
-0.0228447318,
0.034894634,
0.0340319872,
0.0189025588,
0.0027989103,
0.053720627,
-0.0811629668,
-0.0023994145,
-0.0253225565,
0.0422837026,
-0.0227898508,
0.0078060813,
0.0354874767,
-0.082773447,
0.0079953531,
-0.0084813703,
0.0039627519,
-0.0326863416,
0.0199526288,
-0.0000690216,
-0.0266154725,
0.061965853,
0.0305810124,
-0.0262338985,
0.0560956039,
0.013182031,
0.0257160831,
-0.0285849124,
0.0581154637,
0.042274192,
0.0074356245,
0.0321396179,
0.0087064113,
0.0648479462,
-0.0155361146,
0.0130178053,
-0.0601437725,
-0.0254126396,
0.0122072641,
0.0100857997,
0.0170923304,
0.0649655834,
-0.0201314669,
-0.0135627659,
0.0745199174,
0.0145137934,
0.0309190582,
0.032767795,
0.0501776002,
0.0450286083,
-0.016887363,
0.0191452131,
0.024095038,
0.0994339734,
0.0067925872,
-0.0003292045,
-0.0070897108,
0.0454445407,
-0.0866123363,
-0.069356747,
0.009155455,
-0.05567424,
0.0122110453,
-0.0292307232,
0.0601641051,
0.0563496985,
-0.1210577786,
0.0517503023,
-0.0298731681,
-0.0402188189,
0.0497011691,
-0.0160691068,
0.023449244,
0.0495424606,
0.0038502521,
0.0165299717,
0.0023501653,
-0.028220728,
0.0006766258,
0.0613839775,
-0.0617212281,
0.0161179304,
0.0255785771,
-0.0655998513,
-0.0294495244,
0.0498321839,
-0.0051826281,
0.0129445773,
-0.0267953333,
0.0332023166,
-0.0047130054,
0.0194556322,
-0.0027219229,
0.0508221015,
-0.0123871006,
0.0175379496,
-0.0220636744,
-0.0261367429,
0.0148578277,
0.0047260062,
-0.0250172485,
-0.0149385631,
0.0520990267,
-0.0396162197,
-0.0067563825,
-0.0075169317,
-0.0471387543,
-0.0140612917,
0.0062599955,
-0.0927067921,
0.0344832614,
0.0776104033,
-0.0238035172,
-0.0543150567,
-0.003829519,
0.0204170886,
-0.0329565145,
-0.047241576,
-0.0188506972,
0.026442904,
-0.0156189064,
-0.0018637496,
0.0272822473,
-0.0217849072,
-0.0083513046,
0.005842031,
0.0088697411,
-0.0027812959,
-0.0129758231,
-0.0039997529,
-0.0174201541,
-0.0214747153,
-0.0230858531,
0.0300170425,
0.0367099047,
0.0099865086,
-0.0617272221,
0.0047452962,
-0.0278934315,
-0.0157550834,
-0.0160395429,
0.0133256754,
0.0245420244,
0.0123568559,
-0.0149397217,
-0.0306762755,
0.0245278664,
0.0176962148,
-0.0692440718,
0.0276128575,
0.02027422,
0.0191475675,
-0.0245523658,
-0.0156394988,
0.0426976979,
0.0375658497,
0.0123824617,
-0.0567659661,
-0.0435928889,
0.0299687739,
0.0600758791,
0.0372320563,
-0.0371498317,
-0.0372564979,
-0.0023689819,
0.0092600724,
0.0345916413,
0.0199280567,
0.0255441573,
-0.0014422553,
-0.0151322074,
0.0176422819,
0.0237374138,
-0.008435715,
-0.063874051,
0.0200630501,
-0.0452686138,
-0.0184793081,
-0.0007036977,
0.0028028605,
-0.0029713954,
0.0367264189,
-0.0682308972,
-0.0064777005,
0.0054092985,
0.0228154864,
0.0071948548,
-0.008980005,
-0.0402779281,
-0.0027550664,
-0.005733286,
-0.0407592393,
0.0047477302,
-0.0485340692,
-0.0223106574,
0.0301581025,
0.0406417325,
-0.0077156383,
0.0397568792,
0.0516193695,
0.022606913,
-0.0169101488,
0.006915695,
-0.0710322037,
-0.0091679413,
0.0150473788,
-0.0184338,
0.0322989412,
-0.0188279059,
0.0035889407,
-0.0062725917,
0.0178512745,
-0.0344677642,
-0.0125615969,
0.0259877648,
-0.0086925523,
-0.0059440183,
-0.0168747287,
-0.0121743791,
0.0199983865,
-0.0247581154,
0.0563046187,
-0.0125380708,
-0.0065684984,
-0.0402358249,
0.109766677,
0.0235563796,
-0.0090849809,
-0.0430730544,
-0.0312227346,
0.032405816,
0.06115105,
-0.0248488896,
-0.0060582617,
-0.0463502929,
0.0128196208,
0.012953015,
0.0468705855,
0.0078385063,
0.0329495482,
0.0207693558,
-0.0363767669,
-0.0332479253,
0.060036812,
0.0185028091,
-0.0240874644,
-0.0074192379,
0.0278294422,
0.0223445911,
0.0078382706,
0.0243393779,
-0.0203593243,
-0.0175687261,
-0.0345537178,
-0.0078973882,
0.0556946285,
0.0287347585,
-0.030681489,
-0.0315245204,
0.0642356649,
0.0532782115,
0.0215625297,
-0.0205243491,
0.011252095,
-0.0102715036,
-0.0038545816,
0.0125404289,
0.0184842292,
0.0475495458,
0.0129039427,
0.0386527777,
-0.0047433977,
-0.077654697,
-0.0284824371,
0.0071388702,
0.0076586711,
0.0541073866,
-0.0006124177,
-0.0468839929,
-0.0614739545,
-0.0027590538,
0.0232474487,
0.0128918299,
0.0049353153,
0.0475035086,
0.0123715978,
0.0026832607,
-0.0103806574,
0.0531434156,
-0.0070482553,
-0.015798552,
-0.0206297319,
0.0245318636,
-0.0214417167,
-0.0360777676,
-0.0332650952,
-0.0206135716,
0.0023516158,
0.0254040509,
-0.0687439218,
-0.0437387414,
-0.0124494424,
0.0201094449,
0.0141624119,
-0.043531552,
-0.0771803036,
0.0171818882,
0.0116583537,
-0.047110714,
-0.0416272096,
-0.0079349335,
0.0095005836,
0.0160859134,
-0.0091514224,
0.0055509126,
0.0689087138,
0.0048980536,
-0.0556513295,
-0.0217044856,
0.0106168026,
0.0177616253,
-0.0333833843,
-0.0035407357,
0.0613750219,
-0.0431065299,
-0.0264408905,
0.0374663845,
-0.1091695204,
0.0096692154,
0.0006136698,
0.03810817,
0.0212501902,
0.0749656409,
0.0200660601,
0.0107739381,
0.0228700414,
0.0160607528,
0.0195376948,
-0.0103725912,
0.0117902551,
-0.0580036044,
-0.0235203169,
-0.0089180563,
-0.0331706963,
0.0321488529,
-0.0221772995,
-0.0162177272,
-0.0543264821,
-0.0103494301,
0.0322150923,
-0.1072953939,
0.0269618481,
-0.0217619091,
0.013963935,
-0.0113646379,
0.0009169403,
-0.015216006,
0.0341149829,
-0.0771141052,
0.0247926563,
0.0454650857,
0.0175906625,
0.0093813892,
-0.0050663399,
0.007665934,
-0.0336531773,
-0.0032654088,
-0.0246135108,
-0.0145685617,
-0.0039929198,
0.0088081975,
0.0178028811,
0.0639137998,
0.0239360854,
-0.0263118166,
0.0135899791,
-0.0142547945,
0.0351607651,
0.0352635719,
0.0216773972,
0.0280211922,
0.0086537236,
-0.0178571362,
0.0214809198,
-0.0754886493,
0.0129356058,
0.0141407335,
-0.0245766304,
0.0380496718,
-0.0219084937,
0.0362819657,
-0.0392253473,
0.0611391217,
0.0395261943,
-0.0563920364,
0.0507927164,
-0.0489428267,
0.0204212423,
0.0029016966,
0.0711075291,
0.0228433125,
-0.0155351646,
-0.0068282872,
-0.0087922672,
-0.0315730423,
-0.0079068309,
-0.0017203056,
-0.0373738185,
-0.0151694808,
0.0158128534,
0.0259450153,
-0.0069848457,
0.0042349142,
-0.0200155973,
0.0331207849,
-0.0343094654,
0.0650860518,
0.0004379676,
-0.0327467434,
0.0370473787,
0.0265866276,
-0.0161643438,
0.0204682574,
-0.050203193,
-0.0426096879,
-6.204941705e-33,
-0.0305584986,
-0.041766014,
0.0093126521,
0.0221541375,
-0.0318667144,
-0.0226397701,
0.000178637,
-0.0053824312,
-0.0070815468,
0.0141463326,
0.0092518134,
0.0567849912,
0.0168767143,
0.0656611398,
-0.0248060226,
0.006719125,
0.0329332948,
-0.0671659112,
0.0057357936,
0.0104841255,
0.0052712783,
0.0305120628,
0.0459720083,
-0.0572868995,
-0.0536368042,
-0.0573336035,
-0.0361528099,
-0.0271831676,
0.0562271737,
-0.009232874,
0.0029687998,
-0.0227758233,
-0.0015016347,
-0.0535970926,
-0.0148059037,
0.0265136976,
-0.052983541,
-0.0006094479,
-0.0670002177,
0.0417763852,
-0.1202406883,
-0.0212776139,
0.0308247097,
-0.0203038715,
-0.0411326699,
-0.0315536521,
0.0614313148,
-0.017828485,
0.0030386599,
-0.0604933016,
-0.0338060446,
0.0285537671,
-0.0262935758,
-0.0678663999,
0.0221017879,
0.0020007507,
0.0193248913,
-0.0253894236,
-0.0957462713,
0.0230923668,
0.0055499533,
0.0644202903,
0.0665792152,
-0.0352747031,
-0.0111716157,
0.0092365155,
-0.0285269916,
-0.070280768,
-0.004300253,
0.0037811296,
0.0101109482,
0.0198729131,
0.1020472273,
-0.0050839772,
0.0616269037,
-0.0520382337,
-0.033484485,
0.0384390056,
-0.0521355569,
0.0247044656,
0.0460318737,
0.0244335197,
0.0280034337,
-0.0196376946,
-0.0140619036,
-0.0189027004,
0.025732372,
-0.025535848,
0.0305163004,
0.0514452271,
0.0366049148,
-0.0509668291,
0.0849089697,
-0.0276622493,
0.0192646515,
0.031139642,
-0.0428553894,
0.0534742512,
0.001857742,
0.0229755808,
-0.0307574384,
-0.015244321,
0.0814073384,
0.0570316724,
-0.0067171678,
0.0271552857,
0.0086576128,
0.0801479667,
-0.0101266168,
-0.0145844137,
-0.0171795916,
0.0339368545,
0.0301680267,
0.0277975164,
0.0087584127,
0.0099565526,
-0.034585651,
0.0498901345,
-0.0196343847,
-0.0116884746,
-0.0023534216,
0.0326557793,
-0.0013676201,
0.0087627629,
-0.0460817553,
0.0351227671,
-0.0471992977,
0.0425747633,
0.0476356782,
-0.0518717207,
-0.0251024533,
0.0655919313,
2.746e-7,
-0.0051804674,
0.0261392202,
0.0296466984,
-0.0231507346,
0.0361693539,
0.0147083905,
-0.022752082,
0.0181784593,
0.0110113183,
-0.0255830921,
0.0216912944,
0.0115395375,
0.0376324579,
0.0073945243,
-0.0314373896,
-0.026685426,
-0.0270358548,
-0.0238263998,
0.0066605317,
-0.0200868733,
0.0791802034,
0.0706136897,
0.0085752951,
-0.0034117447,
0.0272025485,
-0.0220368672,
0.0790581107,
0.0211331453,
0.0100903828,
-0.0233470146,
-0.0088902703,
0.0011775403,
-0.0604229644,
-0.0162620675,
-0.0170416608,
-0.0403518453,
0.0463861562,
0.0215840898,
-0.0605191514,
-0.0194633044,
0.002713888,
0.0551451966,
-0.0495435111,
-0.0132575715,
0.0311749075,
-0.0443775505,
-0.0273097996,
-0.0052734222,
-0.0284564998,
0.0526032671,
-0.0431198105,
0.0302803256,
-0.0323723555,
0.0058846194,
0.0547224581,
0.0434459709,
-0.0205091778,
-0.038582094,
-0.0251220539,
-0.0249901526,
-0.0270698015,
0.0195047297,
-0.0608387925,
-0.0111870086,
0.0289532207,
0.0307855513,
-0.0691034421,
2.304453589e-34,
-0.0063636401,
0.003983628,
0.0176830124,
-0.0169895794,
-0.0448491275,
0.0332663991,
0.0272750314,
0.0355239399,
-0.0297758952,
-0.0279499665,
-0.0599216111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12820v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12820v1 | MSG-BART: Multi-granularity Scene Graph-Enhanced Encoder-Decoder Language Model for Video-grounded Dialogue Generation | 2023-09-26T04:23:23 | 2023-09-26T04:23:23 | Hongcheng Liu, Zhe Chen, Hui Li, Pingjie Wang, Yanfeng Wang, Yu Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.IV | Generating dialogue grounded in videos requires a high level of understanding
and reasoning about the visual scenes in the videos. However, existing large
visual-language models are not effective due to their latent features and
decoder-only structure, especially with respect to spatio-temporal relationship
reasoning. In this paper, we propose a novel approach named MSG-BART, which
enhances the integration of video information by incorporating a
multi-granularity spatio-temporal scene graph into an encoder-decoder
pre-trained language model. Specifically, we integrate the global and local
scene graph into the encoder and decoder, respectively, to improve both overall
perception and target reasoning capability. To further improve the information
selection capability, we propose a multi-pointer network to facilitate
selection between text and video. Extensive experiments are conducted on three
video-grounded dialogue benchmarks, which show the significant superiority of
the proposed MSG-BART compared to a range of state-of-the-art approaches. | [
0.033551421,
0.0420505926,
0.019678684,
0.0550435856,
-0.0027382395,
-0.0054173679,
0.0160763673,
-0.009510152,
-0.0111564696,
-0.0704103708,
0.0032661846,
-0.0073937275,
0.0017067748,
0.0643860027,
0.0230132211,
-0.0992369056,
0.0020808792,
-0.018789025,
0.0310636554,
0.0000036371,
0.0187157001,
0.0470593274,
-0.0278647523,
0.0254405383,
-0.0566985123,
-0.0053092819,
-0.0264470894,
0.0402320214,
0.0333379544,
-0.0449478142,
-0.0329822749,
0.0189962443,
0.0886626765,
-0.0294367187,
0.0000018919,
-0.016630454,
0.0105994204,
-0.0356206633,
-0.0006901445,
0.0090929903,
-0.043627426,
-0.0327301584,
0.0291060787,
-0.0040615578,
-0.0470772088,
-0.0227479767,
0.0458310433,
0.0409700014,
0.0693814084,
0.0324732363,
-0.0540165268,
-0.0532624424,
-0.0065240101,
-0.0241668504,
0.0329727642,
-0.0383627713,
-0.0105461748,
0.0806577727,
0.0260479394,
0.0036821843,
-0.082436204,
0.0141151967,
0.0108571248,
-0.0440379307,
0.0494647138,
0.0443715714,
-0.032492917,
0.0170499627,
-0.0133623518,
0.1093883216,
-0.0070113959,
0.0114967488,
-0.0081230039,
-0.0233213753,
-0.0034087002,
-0.0153622106,
-0.037005458,
0.0028647387,
0.0015834233,
0.032705415,
-0.0540728271,
0.0246418491,
0.010769858,
0.012100704,
0.0225636531,
0.0218320023,
0.0173687991,
0.020985879,
-0.0112911621,
0.0253244136,
-0.0127668977,
-0.0667653233,
0.0197593048,
0.0292262137,
-0.0044181589,
0.0133672524,
-0.0510823242,
0.0367699265,
-0.0751193836,
-0.0235213153,
0.0146767758,
0.0273547601,
-0.0216441955,
0.052971445,
-0.0104864528,
0.0692600906,
-0.0387083218,
0.0246609636,
-0.0072108116,
-0.0043020081,
-0.038123019,
-0.008680542,
-0.0721455589,
0.0112540089,
-0.0699522346,
-0.0683823973,
-0.0127903866,
0.0206551459,
-0.0187639333,
-0.021496335,
0.0070444536,
0.0422165059,
0.0106153423,
-0.0209876057,
-0.0213616081,
0.0478321128,
-0.052430056,
0.0244454555,
0.0039803521,
-0.0286223665,
-0.0213724952,
0.0404902101,
0.0427179486,
-0.0197346322,
-0.002947286,
0.0368829742,
-0.0652081594,
-0.0125864483,
-0.0336235575,
-0.0026165037,
-0.0524899065,
-0.0289879758,
0.0199340377,
-0.0418702923,
0.0355082564,
-0.0042348197,
-0.0217064768,
-0.0278933886,
-0.0010345051,
-0.0303923748,
-0.0313136652,
0.0453434512,
-0.0159986299,
0.0123556824,
0.0298262257,
0.0209245998,
0.0131199909,
0.0428017117,
0.0487256981,
0.0440777764,
0.0216570608,
0.0420521088,
-0.0040685376,
0.0016500407,
-0.0104330378,
0.0090746349,
-0.0710885152,
-0.0111810286,
-0.0271758847,
0.0382910073,
0.0414911769,
0.0676701367,
-0.0721106678,
-0.0075837276,
0.0688009933,
0.0191253833,
-0.0572040305,
-0.0179015398,
0.0769030973,
0.0343625173,
-0.0206003748,
0.009444817,
-0.0185328815,
0.084930025,
0.0093016895,
0.002581713,
0.0015354083,
0.0136253033,
-0.0658926144,
-0.0205326788,
0.0096826041,
-0.006011887,
0.0449329242,
-0.0159209799,
0.0322740339,
0.0331894457,
-0.0871101022,
0.0613103583,
-0.0149260145,
-0.0267478433,
0.0405950733,
0.0197286699,
0.0029745984,
0.055743672,
0.0303275976,
0.0272838585,
-0.0519991554,
-0.0100539783,
0.039832253,
0.0447806753,
-0.002319922,
-0.0404340029,
0.0316101536,
-0.1083801761,
-0.041689381,
-0.0559721701,
0.0016569522,
0.0618321262,
0.0092999507,
0.0188672468,
0.0348336473,
-0.0178994313,
0.0433428213,
0.0211263783,
0.0516303591,
0.0218223408,
-0.0313712135,
0.0117784012,
0.0012054526,
0.0024921582,
-0.0084524117,
-0.0282345917,
0.0024647887,
-0.0243889354,
0.0219248105,
0.0505958572,
-0.0766097233,
-0.0863802806,
-0.0102727292,
-0.0362048484,
-0.0150851049,
-0.004675251,
-0.0499465913,
-0.0531930067,
0.025347773,
0.0007859814,
0.011726371,
-0.0417486392,
-0.0069576162,
0.0364245512,
0.0086276298,
-0.0157135036,
0.0451753438,
-0.0257235486,
-0.0335681066,
0.0341210105,
0.0619488545,
0.0299729202,
-0.0606635436,
-0.0042749709,
0.025696082,
0.0060600983,
-0.0172341298,
-0.0041909087,
0.010595792,
-0.044748757,
-0.0165941231,
-0.079492934,
-0.0450349525,
-0.0109850084,
-0.0241851136,
-0.012128368,
-0.0043236851,
0.0086188233,
-0.0319548063,
-0.0340037569,
0.0472920202,
0.0251578614,
-0.0055486765,
0.020637542,
0.016218381,
0.0246158466,
-0.003139853,
0.0092264516,
0.0459654815,
0.0656729043,
0.0175685212,
-0.0739397183,
0.0030173217,
-0.0102877989,
-0.0449065268,
0.0329504237,
-0.03207203,
-0.0280853417,
0.0147562558,
-0.0067368648,
0.0204246752,
0.0443272702,
-0.0038999349,
0.032706473,
-0.007067401,
-0.0516134612,
-0.0171859637,
0.0173429903,
0.0038308012,
0.0172267407,
-0.0143996747,
0.0260673426,
-0.0217840951,
-0.0094234366,
0.013127625,
0.0575588606,
-0.0779411271,
0.0080481302,
0.0386761278,
-0.0166638941,
-0.041336637,
-0.0511966906,
0.0015658534,
0.0187042337,
-0.0747998878,
-0.0432244837,
0.0547911488,
-0.0340448804,
-0.0417481214,
0.03897563,
0.040281076,
-0.0048285704,
0.0789770484,
0.0296504889,
0.0257060267,
-0.0321058631,
-0.0438157544,
-0.0514296181,
-0.0368490331,
0.0129532535,
0.0154668465,
0.0565463379,
-0.0710868835,
0.0304549392,
0.0169361923,
-0.0275626238,
-0.0259259939,
-0.0080501186,
-0.0425546654,
-0.0085531361,
-0.040649686,
-0.0130927796,
0.0231505334,
0.0376002975,
-0.0233302489,
0.0248931292,
-0.0211925097,
0.0236998647,
-0.0215081144,
0.0523300022,
0.069339551,
0.0119598517,
-0.0530955829,
-0.0372112915,
0.0325580984,
0.0537958667,
0.0086983265,
-0.057866592,
-0.0555141494,
0.072441563,
0.0085272063,
0.0481436998,
-0.0249512903,
0.003689979,
0.0784594938,
-0.0312569886,
-0.0091518639,
0.0816481262,
0.0052567679,
-0.0168396551,
-0.0119807385,
0.0123875365,
0.0408857949,
0.02908355,
0.0050943932,
-0.0758726448,
-0.0567844026,
-0.0101233339,
-0.0435904376,
0.0447638854,
-0.0282224845,
-0.0409401394,
-0.0932159573,
0.0454898961,
0.0332109146,
-0.0132393474,
-0.0287847854,
0.0338467807,
-0.006576573,
0.0053835623,
-0.0112462398,
-0.0173523985,
0.0224836878,
0.0132601662,
0.0153673785,
0.0194602814,
-0.0285671894,
0.0236924961,
-0.0293605104,
0.0207392462,
0.0039132549,
0.0289832652,
0.016559856,
-0.0080656316,
0.0403132997,
0.0164599642,
0.0232230928,
-0.0186931416,
0.0489067622,
-0.0313102603,
-0.0207527075,
0.026717348,
0.030655209,
-0.0084856274,
-0.0507312343,
-0.0368725732,
0.0473768637,
-0.0365562811,
0.0123662688,
0.0149356276,
0.0399504639,
0.0435819402,
0.0437480435,
0.0185387693,
-0.0127822012,
-0.027920885,
-0.0139681706,
-0.016495483,
-0.0612600185,
-0.0088241082,
-0.0014067938,
0.003685157,
-0.0005913316,
-0.0558962151,
-0.0026836363,
0.0650064349,
0.0666896179,
-0.0358466133,
-0.0254499745,
0.0183201153,
0.001431486,
-0.0400766581,
0.0412487239,
-0.0176894609,
0.0008360072,
-0.0226029158,
-0.0094563421,
0.0287751947,
-0.0320007652,
-0.0048162327,
0.0147052296,
-0.0319007896,
-0.0544363074,
-0.0501544327,
0.0642609671,
0.0157727953,
0.0840722993,
0.0130295288,
-0.0159490593,
0.0073747574,
-0.0245628972,
0.0272451621,
0.0236850511,
0.0073033734,
-0.0101576932,
-0.0241914801,
0.0296605397,
-0.0402126759,
0.0421967693,
0.0046734232,
0.0336768925,
-0.0490765832,
-0.0676345676,
-0.000672026,
-0.0298845917,
0.0474064425,
-0.0043707197,
0.0101817697,
-0.0708023384,
-0.0010341777,
-0.0030711922,
0.0141350683,
-0.1103412136,
0.0139701823,
0.0120879235,
0.0064948117,
-0.0203046612,
-0.0451555625,
-0.0062372894,
0.0215045754,
-0.0080774296,
-0.0602471828,
-0.0103283245,
-0.0229949784,
0.0279965233,
0.024351744,
-0.0067934366,
0.033872962,
-0.010833066,
-0.0055962051,
-0.0006568511,
0.1033104286,
0.0198989157,
-0.0166293867,
0.0073336526,
0.0044088871,
-0.0235652104,
0.0132951243,
-0.0203815904,
0.0027701443,
0.053690508,
-0.0143364938,
0.0227984954,
0.0131555861,
0.0059302039,
0.0083264029,
0.1033275872,
0.0137998862,
-0.1077370569,
0.0707943812,
0.0102373036,
-0.0181152094,
0.0373563506,
0.0512502417,
0.0069104661,
0.0174936615,
0.0211875271,
0.0083985161,
-0.0250414889,
-0.0439921953,
-0.0144006219,
0.0234228838,
0.0124932537,
0.0425424986,
-0.0125872204,
-0.0579399951,
-0.0246015787,
0.0049037673,
-0.0147161772,
0.0218676925,
0.0663503185,
0.009941862,
-0.0069657587,
-0.0006019858,
-0.0092644216,
-0.0129139721,
-0.0394967236,
0.0069599738,
-0.045222085,
-5.608879009e-33,
-0.0610368513,
-0.0461382605,
0.0357603244,
0.0054183016,
-0.0478614792,
0.0086370734,
-0.0549413674,
0.0044934303,
-0.0249353703,
0.0564551316,
0.0284515619,
0.0314422734,
-0.0010907046,
0.0495318398,
-0.0217059627,
-0.0393467471,
0.039245382,
0.0163553823,
-0.0007317609,
0.0218657441,
0.0544569977,
0.0145129431,
0.0337724946,
-0.0624441914,
-0.0638311133,
0.0063117808,
-0.0371780433,
0.046753224,
0.0437925644,
0.0375790894,
0.0189338177,
-0.0120990425,
0.0189146325,
0.0176643245,
-0.0336728133,
0.006774541,
-0.0542661324,
-0.0174471643,
0.0115499981,
0.0375030451,
-0.0384394489,
-0.0029138448,
-0.0119762132,
-0.0223651659,
0.0400005803,
-0.0298068449,
0.0329797082,
-0.0286826082,
-0.0267663971,
-0.0257559977,
-0.0225106943,
0.026485635,
-0.0394754149,
-0.030243922,
0.0118744383,
0.0094879409,
0.0268234704,
-0.022471223,
-0.0194030944,
0.0285929646,
-0.0486611426,
-0.003937318,
0.0591293573,
0.0366370939,
0.0115498528,
0.0808078796,
-0.0326530635,
-0.0478658304,
-0.0357817449,
-0.0137266312,
-0.0148386946,
0.0823419094,
0.0073372438,
0.0146074435,
-0.006774242,
-0.0071311793,
-0.0687156394,
0.009334377,
-0.0455315821,
0.0491234362,
-0.0220433287,
0.0483583398,
0.0340406187,
-0.0358039513,
-0.0080441264,
-0.0285135061,
-0.0072429189,
-0.0312537476,
0.0126113193,
0.0103373397,
0.0172057673,
0.0351789296,
0.0850066468,
-0.0191513579,
0.0348821916,
0.0745895728,
-0.0711921528,
0.0559314862,
0.0010301336,
0.0353452303,
-0.0507025532,
-0.0328562893,
0.0441902317,
0.0040480541,
0.0063762288,
0.0354745016,
0.0131776305,
0.0202660672,
-0.0166846793,
-0.0182244945,
-0.04328743,
-0.0044415402,
-0.0214891862,
0.0456092134,
0.0225149579,
0.0246503446,
-0.0657597333,
0.0778413564,
-0.0307350289,
0.0073375399,
0.015432477,
-0.0424735621,
0.0048097945,
0.0320015587,
-0.0305613838,
0.0265803169,
-0.0245011337,
-0.0414197892,
0.0548035465,
-0.0601944476,
-0.0187674072,
0.0347544849,
2.642e-7,
-0.0013247301,
0.0206375998,
0.0259150695,
-0.0030554088,
0.0110078482,
0.0300549828,
-0.0067594526,
0.0294182077,
0.0222799554,
-0.0605846643,
0.0313417651,
0.0625279397,
0.0362657346,
-0.0177120343,
-0.0412161425,
0.0396196097,
-0.0665639043,
-0.0438238271,
-0.0280235372,
-0.0094278725,
0.0509772561,
0.0175649337,
0.011747173,
0.0242168643,
0.015090717,
-0.0327618457,
0.081563428,
-0.0060649263,
-0.0172183551,
0.0297701284,
0.0208821539,
-0.0214187242,
-0.0568421744,
0.0384403281,
-0.0220517013,
-0.0019687349,
0.0457001366,
0.0533665344,
-0.0284751467,
-0.0464138761,
-0.0374113806,
0.0109025883,
-0.0376830064,
-0.0084590679,
0.0569338575,
-0.0515262,
-0.0254875496,
0.0266221892,
-0.027010927,
0.0089991614,
-0.0194313359,
0.002268926,
-0.043799296,
0.0100081265,
0.0380310863,
-0.0285663195,
-0.0159716401,
-0.0946544409,
0.0042415671,
-0.00431772,
-0.0343691073,
0.0185023025,
-0.0101331612,
-0.0373425931,
0.0398104712,
0.00426174,
-0.0488447659,
2.023992576e-34,
0.026419254,
-0.0015671899,
-0.0086024795,
-0.0333714485,
0.0416703708,
-0.0055637131,
-0.0103646005,
0.0033969772,
0.0054336968,
-0.0420759656,
-0.015697306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14592v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14592v2 | Efficient Post-training Quantization with FP8 Formats | 2023-09-26T00:58:36 | 2024-03-31T23:05:53 | Haihao Shen, Naveen Mellempudi, Xin He, Qun Gao, Chang Wang, Mengni Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent advances in deep learning methods such as LLMs and Diffusion models
have created a need for improved quantization methods that can meet the
computational demands of these modern architectures while maintaining accuracy.
Towards this goal, we study the advantages of FP8 data formats for
post-training quantization across 75 unique network architectures covering a
wide range of tasks, including machine translation, language modeling, text
generation, image classification, generation, and segmentation. We examine
three different FP8 representations (E5M2, E4M3, and E3M4) to study the effects
of varying degrees of trade-off between dynamic range and precision on model
accuracy. Based on our extensive study, we developed a quantization workflow
that generalizes across different network architectures. Our empirical results
show that FP8 formats outperform INT8 in multiple aspects, including workload
coverage (92.64% vs. 65.87%), model accuracy and suitability for a broader
range of operations. Furthermore, our findings suggest that E4M3 is better
suited for NLP models, whereas E3M4 performs marginally better than E4M3 on
computer vision tasks. The code is publicly available on Intel Neural
Compressor: https://github.com/intel/neural-compressor. | [
-0.0471652448,
0.0761568025,
0.008450415,
0.0210624952,
-0.0084554181,
-0.0168713257,
0.0460183695,
0.0326891616,
-0.042894613,
-0.0189942066,
-0.0112692416,
-0.0718356445,
0.0140638072,
0.034703739,
0.0371083394,
-0.0444722548,
0.0343413092,
0.043136809,
-0.005043345,
0.0090065533,
0.0015247518,
-0.0055633015,
0.0046928804,
0.0201486833,
-0.0253054239,
-0.0067430562,
-0.0333513245,
0.0419525169,
0.0245778225,
-0.0262179822,
0.0228607021,
0.0473539606,
0.0595490262,
0.0240673237,
0.0000022697,
0.0124368072,
-0.0290226843,
0.0036977034,
-0.0362062491,
0.0245095268,
0.0344069153,
-0.0246616341,
-0.0295746066,
0.0021989129,
-0.0033853177,
-0.0328873061,
0.06884709,
0.0119994786,
0.0726928413,
0.0528827012,
-0.0094830813,
-0.0302561447,
0.0518899113,
-0.0301798601,
-0.0033343583,
0.0031562259,
-0.0051744045,
0.0182508379,
-0.0733665526,
0.0210519545,
-0.0131054008,
0.0049157622,
0.0391634852,
0.0109082228,
0.0273467563,
0.0350192301,
-0.0502072908,
-0.0238656085,
-0.0189398862,
0.0532109365,
-0.0745228752,
0.0003396492,
-0.0258971434,
-0.0079419436,
-0.0498589128,
-0.1213465557,
-0.0234343354,
0.0192103125,
0.0517885722,
0.0501014106,
-0.0321345702,
0.0136165153,
0.0584401414,
0.0110974619,
-0.0261400342,
0.0082880724,
0.014401962,
0.0075415117,
-0.0000962838,
0.0057350341,
-0.0750092268,
-0.051090993,
0.0235901475,
0.0184520576,
0.0582432635,
-0.0249654017,
-0.089037247,
-0.0249421224,
-0.0014237836,
-0.051710207,
0.0323856287,
0.0693636164,
0.0066679758,
-0.0077381665,
-0.0605424643,
0.0453529581,
-0.0275701471,
0.0340620615,
-0.0372117795,
0.0354519188,
-0.0213456824,
0.0125821289,
-0.025158193,
0.0403589495,
-0.0246274453,
-0.0385121331,
-0.0781163648,
-0.0298982002,
-0.0406748839,
-0.0142897796,
0.0012034923,
0.0395505652,
-0.0412307642,
0.0152670098,
0.0132792359,
0.0397222377,
-0.035904333,
0.0194930471,
0.0367321298,
-0.0458106585,
-0.016920574,
0.0011904497,
-0.0175837371,
-0.0308382679,
0.0457903333,
0.0049415613,
0.0115525918,
-0.0334830768,
-0.0199594926,
0.0012965824,
-0.0133184614,
-0.0402131006,
0.0290676858,
-0.0568685867,
0.0363323875,
-0.0368956216,
-0.0030689181,
-0.0261019729,
0.0210833717,
0.0131784426,
0.026230149,
0.0327034295,
-0.0588477999,
-0.0108972704,
0.0184152238,
-0.0124849789,
0.0572621748,
0.0657519177,
0.0619026609,
0.045782838,
-0.0008917705,
0.0105411261,
-0.0211993139,
0.0388199799,
0.0350550078,
0.0048721978,
-0.0505121276,
-0.0518555604,
-0.0336614326,
0.0533795096,
0.1135451496,
0.0529249012,
-0.0651380643,
-0.0569399856,
0.0142783225,
0.0417366214,
0.0553766713,
0.0226697065,
0.0378870964,
-0.0094866976,
0.0135448445,
-0.0192536339,
-0.0147806313,
0.0188349206,
0.0692412928,
-0.0140206367,
0.0231457818,
0.0610361286,
-0.0258071497,
-0.0413846932,
-0.0001041373,
-0.002836362,
0.0264025163,
0.0173686296,
-0.0058873375,
0.006621473,
0.01199413,
0.1218678653,
-0.013073395,
-0.0171436425,
-0.0123584792,
-0.0603358224,
-0.044686161,
0.065031901,
-0.0028269887,
0.0023602208,
-0.0075737876,
0.008932041,
-0.0009209529,
-0.0113723287,
0.0199371465,
0.0155123603,
0.0472845882,
-0.06051879,
-0.0304032099,
-0.0316047333,
-0.0033547417,
0.0087433793,
0.0283839628,
-0.0074814558,
0.0095337573,
-0.0564792417,
-0.026529884,
0.0212057922,
0.0430717692,
-0.0517242253,
0.056151595,
0.0031134475,
0.0085318275,
0.0142679038,
-0.0183044281,
-0.0246688034,
0.0157154221,
-0.0336154476,
0.0237455573,
-0.0304135066,
-0.0445325077,
-0.0051378878,
0.0556675792,
0.0055512423,
0.0297028664,
0.0433533825,
-0.0769930854,
-0.0335565321,
0.0063570635,
-0.0128592607,
0.0148527734,
-0.0357742235,
0.0121551054,
0.0024578178,
0.0715813637,
-0.0374694429,
0.0121507812,
-0.0390627086,
-0.015101037,
0.006006415,
0.031103706,
0.0058022095,
-0.0227958299,
-0.0086556226,
-0.0028897179,
0.0243302379,
0.0159513652,
0.0152016496,
0.0196126439,
-0.0236005485,
0.012154486,
-0.0841518492,
0.0187006071,
-0.0324753709,
0.0180729609,
0.0412548333,
0.0303217229,
0.0141719459,
0.0289527103,
-0.0536647812,
0.0228412021,
-0.0111440206,
-0.0107409284,
0.035576459,
-0.0026266484,
0.0134515939,
-0.0381244831,
-0.0662589148,
0.019561464,
0.0497073792,
-0.0531202182,
-0.0339591019,
-0.0248754397,
0.0156856868,
-0.010179217,
0.0239964575,
-0.0122163948,
-0.0493676923,
0.0103356875,
-0.0126820393,
-0.011675369,
0.0489866845,
-0.0053559183,
0.0096139451,
0.041687496,
0.0438156128,
-0.0623297617,
0.0286144484,
-0.0103552723,
0.0050701578,
0.0018211375,
-0.0389501601,
-0.0278630573,
0.052546978,
-0.0174106043,
0.001860122,
-0.0278726071,
-0.0072644069,
-0.0000338323,
-0.0307013448,
-0.0139322886,
0.0124752,
0.00105537,
0.0476482734,
-0.0154216923,
-0.0486770347,
0.0190024171,
-0.0339432061,
0.0127176493,
0.0078470334,
-0.0247616861,
-0.0032392165,
0.0280087274,
0.0336994454,
0.0394022353,
-0.005352411,
-0.0335000455,
-0.037313655,
0.0052507147,
-0.0149241202,
-0.020726148,
0.038296178,
-0.0131942974,
-0.0197367519,
-0.0595186688,
-0.0195328593,
0.0074244132,
0.0119655291,
0.0132199218,
0.0536705442,
0.0088828979,
-0.0342502706,
0.0308909342,
0.0268661901,
-0.0094940234,
0.0270346813,
-0.0209047403,
-0.0180286467,
-0.0152272666,
0.0522930212,
-0.0070701167,
0.0260439124,
0.0107783843,
-0.0108912056,
-0.0159115139,
0.0338334143,
0.0347218551,
0.0790281221,
-0.1186385378,
0.0094759855,
0.0306186751,
0.0152477939,
-0.0334449634,
0.0206846427,
0.0839863047,
-0.0748319924,
-0.0027447406,
0.0635306314,
-0.0027940543,
-0.0475354418,
0.0016143193,
0.0456386879,
0.0226057842,
0.0154442014,
0.0001525534,
-0.1052798107,
-0.0153256627,
0.0080191046,
0.0140430303,
0.0077471747,
0.0035167297,
-0.0135202166,
-0.046963986,
0.0220478736,
0.0510544926,
0.0358302481,
-0.0171029884,
-0.005840804,
-0.0149043752,
-0.0262489654,
0.0485558994,
-0.0234156735,
0.0238942746,
-0.0089433081,
0.0438334793,
-0.006970406,
-0.0563867576,
0.0114874439,
-0.0009111477,
0.0158530828,
0.0860839486,
-0.001799626,
-0.0336680189,
-0.0022704392,
0.0268136896,
0.0321706757,
0.0040202229,
-0.0045565199,
0.045678746,
0.0157176629,
-0.006928823,
0.0172415264,
-0.0130873946,
0.0211380515,
-0.0135271028,
-0.0296722874,
0.0384009778,
-0.0220052432,
-0.0233423878,
-0.0408620201,
-0.0150618581,
-0.0216365382,
0.0249303784,
0.0382839814,
-0.0078266971,
-0.0576085746,
-0.0111439405,
0.0332572646,
-0.0841136575,
-0.0407885723,
-0.0195362624,
-0.0117328316,
-0.0583081283,
-0.0423082896,
-0.0070793205,
0.012442925,
0.0409929976,
-0.0174274053,
-0.0824784264,
0.0060303826,
-0.0151154529,
-0.0813300237,
0.0017824905,
0.0098775113,
0.0373456813,
-0.0220883042,
-0.0243928414,
0.0119492784,
-0.0040058512,
0.0014585457,
-0.0005237171,
-0.1504945457,
-0.0334143527,
0.0196576267,
0.031751316,
0.0157503113,
0.0493496545,
0.0102408864,
-0.0368143581,
0.056860134,
0.0571559668,
0.0234965496,
0.0245214291,
0.0217731725,
-0.0077462452,
-0.0172301568,
-0.0029076585,
-0.0209003203,
0.0434562229,
0.0060866023,
0.0420753323,
-0.0325250626,
-0.0284469072,
0.0056562731,
-0.0075688618,
0.0669501796,
0.0027382218,
-0.0226499029,
0.0173364114,
-0.0131363105,
0.013133931,
0.0150132282,
-0.0556687601,
0.0011507263,
0.0481351949,
0.0218532048,
-0.0028465146,
0.0094680609,
0.0620312653,
-0.020262884,
0.013146759,
-0.0300990753,
-0.0527801737,
0.0340257138,
-0.0197320897,
0.0275749452,
-0.0396492146,
0.0141437538,
-0.009313168,
0.0256096721,
-0.0384483933,
0.0160884764,
-0.0204965472,
0.0396630727,
-0.0533702858,
0.0490120836,
-0.0291690584,
-0.0250130389,
-0.0752959177,
-0.0152567457,
0.0626957193,
0.0126571171,
0.0069810385,
-0.0253220908,
-0.0154622719,
-0.0055104503,
0.0215851404,
0.010733651,
-0.0274974369,
0.0313979946,
0.0183094647,
-0.0090187788,
-0.0453182831,
0.0399150848,
-0.034548074,
0.0023507867,
0.0032303827,
0.0040709395,
-0.0064826007,
-0.0376754589,
-0.0975003615,
-0.0033922086,
0.0263820849,
-0.0294797588,
0.0120800957,
-0.0347431786,
0.0152577329,
0.0079113599,
-0.0035270411,
0.0070617697,
0.0246699918,
0.0413918421,
-0.0146391485,
-0.0537635311,
-0.0112155471,
-0.0112643354,
0.0266117323,
-0.0016038638,
-0.0376078151,
-6.347564435e-33,
-0.0114495484,
0.0352415629,
0.0121760825,
-0.0620254241,
-0.082280986,
0.0267633609,
-0.004140697,
-0.0182591509,
-0.0049927491,
-0.0233853068,
-0.0183813646,
0.034611553,
0.0326470658,
0.0230083857,
-0.0214504693,
0.0015368948,
0.0912511721,
-0.0371912308,
-0.0110847531,
0.0306261778,
0.0041059586,
0.0281694531,
0.0449996851,
0.0121235177,
-0.0465723537,
0.046212934,
-0.0108480956,
-0.018907899,
0.0318481363,
-0.0007734341,
-0.0188111197,
0.0192727372,
0.0082960809,
-0.0189111326,
-0.0397958681,
-0.0349292494,
-0.0852177516,
0.0124557894,
-0.038530834,
0.0434406064,
-0.0427314527,
-0.0695050284,
0.1038100421,
-0.0013114695,
-0.0286062416,
-0.0456653535,
-0.02135613,
-0.024274325,
-0.0362883955,
-0.0984555036,
0.0045241741,
0.0007155018,
0.0194278248,
0.037587665,
0.0391170271,
0.0197843798,
-0.0344922356,
-0.0297650173,
-0.091862537,
-0.0295496285,
0.0061483784,
0.0613200366,
0.0265319515,
0.0341029912,
0.0515983589,
0.0454300456,
0.0625546873,
-0.033083573,
-0.0129860267,
0.0755175129,
0.0704546869,
0.0412681662,
0.0293531157,
0.0369561017,
0.1246582419,
-0.0292068329,
-0.0533609092,
0.0180055443,
-0.0253091939,
0.0108662369,
0.0019250646,
0.0232276153,
-0.003648875,
-0.0238928217,
-0.0064447247,
0.0012253834,
-0.0271199364,
-0.0695986003,
-0.004510914,
0.011820958,
0.0060213474,
-0.0072438568,
0.0313686617,
-0.0372444019,
0.0232236236,
-0.0126632042,
-0.0086409738,
0.0473972447,
0.0371781923,
0.023115918,
0.0018938676,
-0.0459203087,
0.0007748305,
0.0312983468,
0.0322951376,
-0.0157543756,
0.0027396099,
0.0696591139,
-0.0208067521,
-0.0180429798,
-0.0503387749,
-0.0090103513,
0.0304804873,
0.0487656482,
0.0153415324,
0.013079226,
-0.0091822287,
0.0187699124,
-0.0484428667,
0.036366038,
-0.0071962681,
-0.001761729,
0.0436452404,
0.0758238807,
-0.0628668666,
0.0105798254,
-0.0581186786,
0.0287536215,
0.0255065821,
-0.0715189576,
-0.0707850009,
0.0359006859,
2.873e-7,
0.027713405,
0.027917454,
0.0313748568,
0.0095433081,
-0.0075843912,
-0.0192604791,
-0.0016091622,
0.0331496112,
-0.0103320088,
-0.0104003586,
0.0393623933,
0.0282048285,
0.0421544313,
0.0321972184,
-0.02113037,
0.0041442909,
-0.0101717114,
0.0205298979,
-0.0274409652,
-0.017934721,
0.0299584866,
0.1045541465,
-0.013876684,
-0.0138474526,
0.0953501165,
0.0167688895,
0.0526691414,
-0.0062361062,
0.0474226847,
0.0096446164,
0.0211440995,
0.040156737,
-0.0022827436,
-0.0326128751,
0.0009412398,
-0.0215120073,
-0.0089921253,
0.0869754106,
-0.003896856,
-0.070619233,
-0.005983829,
-0.0041366164,
0.0016143399,
-0.0314295255,
0.0426079445,
-0.0491503254,
-0.0145012708,
-0.0558479354,
-0.0352431536,
-0.0064342981,
0.025336178,
-0.0217264704,
0.0010173348,
0.0410356224,
0.0121727614,
-0.0147671103,
-0.0518390797,
-0.0827423856,
-0.0358654298,
0.017012259,
-0.036895778,
-0.0141529143,
-0.059753295,
-0.027175067,
0.0428262018,
0.0021003191,
-0.0369876437,
2.548983276e-34,
0.0193000045,
-0.0191393513,
0.025978256,
-0.0138051007,
-0.0231024846,
-0.0086465152,
0.0024772368,
-0.0343720317,
-0.0259358119,
-0.0333030596,
-0.0472956337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14568v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14568v1 | Introducing DictaLM -- A Large Generative Language Model for Modern Hebrew | 2023-09-25T22:42:09 | 2023-09-25T22:42:09 | Shaltiel Shmidman, Avi Shmidman, Amir David Nissan Cohen, Moshe Koppel | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present DictaLM, a large-scale language model tailored for Modern Hebrew.
Boasting 7B parameters, this model is predominantly trained on Hebrew-centric
data. As a commitment to promoting research and development in the Hebrew
language, we release both the foundation model and the instruct-tuned model
under a Creative Commons license. Concurrently, we introduce DictaLM-Rab,
another foundation model geared towards Rabbinic/Historical Hebrew. These
foundation models serve as ideal starting points for fine-tuning various
Hebrew-specific tasks, such as instruction, Q&A, sentiment analysis, and more.
This release represents a preliminary step, offering an initial Hebrew LLM
model for the Hebrew NLP community to experiment with. | [
0.0179608949,
0.0840000361,
-0.0174916703,
0.0394853279,
-0.0108711077,
0.0364401639,
0.0009460428,
0.0194593053,
-0.0162085555,
-0.0251304694,
0.0050805658,
-0.0777552277,
-0.0119756805,
0.0032908262,
0.0227275677,
-0.0483515672,
0.0089728972,
-0.0539245829,
0.0020041273,
-0.0064549907,
0.0281082895,
0.0664285198,
-0.0011446063,
-0.0004401579,
0.0194314793,
-0.0441982448,
0.0049379938,
0.0311761871,
0.012780129,
0.0028911575,
-0.0201082379,
0.047652781,
-0.0099076694,
-0.0129334377,
0.0000020335,
-0.0303324144,
0.00281677,
-0.0457357578,
-0.0187967382,
-0.0040326649,
0.086113885,
-0.0514227971,
-0.0640942305,
0.0185633693,
-0.0632860437,
-0.0208528452,
0.0359101035,
0.0119039137,
0.0506270789,
0.0922336578,
0.0113199782,
-0.0396868028,
0.0512565076,
-0.0183118228,
0.0144127728,
0.003330753,
0.0060297507,
0.0054674153,
-0.0196340233,
0.044586651,
-0.03845926,
0.0122879073,
0.0491106324,
-0.0028344542,
-0.017434258,
-0.0022531978,
-0.0369169973,
-0.0129930489,
0.0087684644,
0.0042891796,
0.024549026,
-0.0485916473,
0.0359667651,
0.0214731637,
-0.0199861098,
-0.01378325,
-0.0295451768,
0.0688080043,
-0.02524193,
0.0095245754,
0.0380079076,
-0.0342347287,
0.0329494365,
0.005393181,
0.000957386,
-0.0097040953,
0.0449132845,
-0.0107438946,
-0.0066122091,
0.0327630267,
-0.017853599,
-0.0422739796,
-0.0082475794,
0.003002461,
0.035975989,
-0.0140230218,
-0.0390434302,
-0.0272333398,
0.0118600586,
-0.0353536867,
0.0338821374,
0.0187622886,
-0.010873205,
-0.0104548121,
-0.0156366955,
0.0163244028,
0.0614341162,
-0.0048556519,
-0.0216682646,
0.030167751,
-0.0301044174,
0.0239556078,
-0.0367652625,
0.0373715684,
-0.093845576,
0.0112656159,
-0.0596223846,
0.0352718756,
0.0542448461,
-0.0380935669,
0.0113309026,
-0.0169485509,
0.0046259365,
0.0037738294,
0.000699098,
-0.029436335,
-0.0759941489,
-0.0214012433,
-0.0197081119,
-0.0830178559,
0.0277835615,
0.03978917,
-0.011932604,
-0.018274432,
-0.0011229331,
0.0590802059,
0.0296257809,
-0.0320743918,
-0.0739280656,
-0.0078771897,
-0.0413483568,
-0.0465350896,
-0.0361909829,
-0.0984135419,
0.0284098368,
-0.0089619206,
-0.0006148146,
-0.0391957201,
-0.0204170961,
0.0482680276,
0.0212182347,
0.0369537584,
0.0217029676,
-0.0000614227,
0.0198078807,
0.0116467411,
0.0389219075,
0.039921023,
-0.0107271448,
0.0033812479,
0.03802016,
-0.0027669528,
0.027238423,
0.018075401,
0.0207238086,
0.0505381487,
-0.0657618344,
0.0049131317,
0.0007812007,
-0.0190344732,
0.0103039965,
0.0578647554,
-0.0440506116,
-0.0364730991,
0.0805630982,
0.0474155992,
0.0140306177,
0.0509932488,
-0.0067021409,
0.0429699831,
0.03657737,
-0.0299753118,
-0.0211813077,
0.042946741,
0.0077678608,
-0.0058846576,
0.0048262319,
0.0662322268,
-0.0324337743,
-0.09407565,
-0.0255499035,
-0.0152393281,
-0.0608522743,
-0.0038749056,
0.033629261,
0.0235915147,
-0.028952511,
0.0183838215,
0.0519199334,
-0.0545377433,
0.0362016968,
-0.0196995921,
0.0480722673,
0.0401285477,
0.0434302986,
0.0382806584,
-0.0368911438,
-0.0476612896,
0.0265625883,
0.1076098979,
-0.0056405324,
0.0171062201,
-0.0255656466,
-0.0449315347,
0.0162600968,
-0.0026544118,
0.018292835,
0.0100431237,
0.0274719875,
0.0275227893,
0.0323500298,
-0.0180568285,
-0.0164331719,
0.0142266043,
-0.0376825519,
-0.0214666966,
-0.0174234323,
-0.0020839612,
0.0313165411,
0.0199800022,
0.0021688289,
-0.023931127,
0.0314267837,
-0.0359768234,
-0.0216851234,
-0.0134918932,
-0.0241200905,
-0.0638862327,
0.0087661622,
-0.041429054,
0.0111838803,
0.0012194526,
-0.0205906983,
-0.017333094,
0.0623082183,
-0.0384633355,
0.036238566,
-0.0273857061,
0.0220752917,
0.0468359664,
0.0239430889,
-0.034657266,
0.0530565567,
0.0061448948,
0.0143785551,
0.0493619964,
-0.0074802302,
0.0022721621,
0.0054387036,
-0.0469400473,
0.0091174506,
-0.0362635627,
0.0151981581,
0.0350153372,
0.0039606299,
-0.0078272456,
-0.03529834,
-0.0646655187,
0.0136248581,
-0.0296936054,
0.0426768512,
0.0202018339,
0.012514038,
0.0018920458,
-0.0174084026,
-0.0640509278,
-0.0465299711,
-0.0022909387,
-0.0048804143,
0.0201563109,
-0.0424668714,
-0.0172292143,
-0.083464615,
-0.0060190698,
-0.0009039233,
0.036345344,
0.0370510407,
0.0307892822,
0.0159124173,
-0.023443142,
-0.0444993079,
0.0025557429,
0.0051918449,
-0.0332119092,
0.0128967958,
-0.0037262426,
0.0890953392,
0.0210157018,
0.0113527682,
-0.0122174835,
-0.0467923507,
-0.0172455702,
-0.0786245987,
0.0114407297,
-0.0313485004,
-0.0310215391,
-0.066679962,
-0.0601270758,
-0.036453221,
0.0565400682,
0.0336066447,
0.0007478069,
-0.0496116169,
0.0720347241,
-0.0415352471,
0.0266854353,
0.0142177502,
0.040855933,
-0.0260567572,
0.0421176702,
-0.033166606,
-0.0439423025,
0.0247537009,
0.0138085624,
-0.0234211292,
-0.0373371132,
-0.0224156659,
-0.0295730866,
0.0369978659,
-0.0070251799,
0.0187946502,
-0.0453101508,
0.0096264174,
-0.0570453666,
-0.0001151021,
-0.0084387241,
-0.0325160325,
0.0552993678,
-0.012161117,
-0.002422747,
-0.0029761342,
-0.0422235243,
-0.0335787088,
0.0208188128,
0.0018886393,
-0.0342017487,
0.0471991301,
0.0065371534,
-0.0198843013,
-0.0129215168,
-0.0874405131,
-0.0167793166,
0.0169167016,
-0.020021813,
-0.0362599194,
0.0257488694,
0.0345911272,
-0.0407303721,
0.0105750384,
-0.0199384186,
0.0404105969,
0.0431961119,
0.0026013041,
-0.0052167177,
-0.0258579813,
0.0023454675,
0.0633625537,
-0.0345634036,
-0.0328270234,
0.0101024276,
-0.0001640805,
-0.0152355256,
0.0164426193,
0.1239318177,
0.0115359463,
-0.0572620593,
0.0042294911,
-0.0111596258,
0.033767812,
0.0145908669,
0.0191843845,
-0.1134221926,
0.0082147243,
0.0042993906,
0.0160009284,
0.0125364056,
0.0118926661,
0.0265370253,
-0.104695335,
0.0155969057,
0.0101689557,
0.0056451848,
-0.0288614593,
-0.0208849516,
-0.0414365903,
-0.0202255584,
0.0086651193,
0.0230424665,
-0.0474376269,
0.0338540152,
0.021258181,
0.0219187606,
0.0023938923,
0.0224130079,
-0.040994931,
0.0724856704,
0.0445450358,
0.0404060856,
-0.0353082754,
-0.0279487483,
0.0018082032,
-0.037840955,
-0.0467910245,
-0.0162214395,
0.0106663303,
0.0173221678,
-0.0216068011,
-0.0267163478,
0.0256923102,
-0.0452321991,
-0.0079955943,
0.0062115481,
0.0280651134,
-0.0113342889,
0.019272333,
0.0120505774,
0.0574505925,
-0.0323809236,
0.0784039795,
0.0224864334,
-0.0287820511,
-0.042470023,
-0.0313233584,
-0.0101699205,
-0.0539409108,
-0.0523477383,
-0.0343222134,
0.0450956635,
0.0050305231,
-0.1363559365,
-0.0266969781,
-0.0495127253,
0.0297822636,
0.0110926442,
-0.0000413534,
-0.0290101711,
-0.0138940811,
-0.05232054,
-0.0066447165,
0.0065882904,
0.0294848531,
-0.0810347646,
-0.0673740581,
0.0245499108,
-0.0812092349,
0.0156897213,
0.0079244338,
-0.1103070155,
-0.0399947613,
0.0088003436,
0.0360004939,
0.0206394698,
0.0606046207,
-0.0300328024,
-0.0157149397,
0.020514356,
0.0062069707,
-0.0429721065,
0.0365929566,
0.0481640324,
0.034259025,
0.0005360836,
0.0279625822,
0.0362552889,
0.0725423545,
0.0470152311,
0.019291088,
-0.0390021391,
-0.04208792,
-0.0070409668,
-0.0418772027,
0.0162247494,
0.0147085208,
-0.0213995073,
-0.0311579444,
-0.012041322,
-0.0172021892,
0.0313446373,
-0.0570061468,
0.0204607118,
0.0401243418,
0.0272457581,
-0.0426068567,
0.0389618948,
-0.0042384216,
0.0005844145,
-0.0173357837,
0.0610039793,
0.027793996,
-0.014321248,
-0.0323827676,
0.0317166522,
0.0237083584,
0.0133362068,
-0.0016882934,
0.0696908012,
-0.0176678021,
0.0321597047,
-0.0472865887,
-0.0102286721,
0.0502768047,
-0.0084765237,
-0.0087692048,
-0.0418663584,
-0.0288219657,
0.0477402769,
0.0379233472,
0.0303522348,
0.0846122652,
-0.002141607,
-0.0142776323,
-0.016246967,
0.02799787,
0.0100294538,
-0.0048825354,
0.0063634212,
0.0041386001,
-0.0239595007,
-0.0516714007,
0.0559821948,
0.0150875961,
0.0493824668,
0.0206014253,
0.0018073649,
-0.0298672505,
-0.0265738349,
0.0357643999,
-0.0291348547,
-0.0191578642,
0.0469760187,
-0.0715425164,
-0.0541702993,
-0.0020327768,
0.0358540304,
0.0097684124,
-0.0208843499,
0.0549448282,
0.0546618365,
-0.0292067658,
0.0233842209,
-0.0938982964,
0.0155490963,
-0.0106742866,
-0.0399065129,
-0.0092310058,
-6.286878069e-33,
-0.030356992,
0.0179459583,
0.0280672349,
0.0036564411,
-0.0196505059,
-0.0020356858,
-0.0055506714,
0.005558331,
-0.0229456741,
-0.0020918669,
0.0042547733,
0.0207842812,
0.0123325856,
0.046004083,
0.0298644956,
0.0009506253,
0.0567508899,
0.0130407829,
-0.002638988,
0.0322567001,
0.0029895841,
0.0532500632,
0.0769687891,
0.0320627131,
0.0243737437,
-0.0309608541,
0.0014386257,
0.0097369421,
0.0121613964,
0.0769806579,
0.0007288317,
0.0416369624,
0.0049541108,
-0.0482854769,
0.0124082267,
0.0119320583,
-0.0455242731,
-0.0243771151,
0.0499109328,
0.0354625098,
-0.038216576,
-0.0360092185,
-0.0075900895,
-0.0253965072,
-0.054756552,
0.0034534426,
0.0594705343,
-0.0065302229,
-0.0161653813,
-0.0700072944,
-0.0729279369,
0.0601614825,
0.0131437778,
-0.0187353808,
0.0148239704,
0.0331975818,
-0.0034081568,
0.0346405953,
-0.0457741432,
-0.0157698952,
0.0066927266,
0.0638858974,
0.0077681127,
-0.002750861,
-0.0613498278,
0.0352626592,
0.0244582687,
-0.005723427,
0.0398859046,
0.0578488708,
0.0053765732,
0.0289735403,
0.0252923202,
0.0788676217,
0.0068914685,
0.0077759167,
-0.0550047271,
-0.009865352,
0.0438785441,
-0.0002382672,
0.0258716866,
-0.0278304368,
-0.0445028432,
0.0093552368,
-0.0299701132,
-0.0571961105,
-0.0323301367,
-0.0193305705,
0.0358973891,
0.0180447474,
-0.0236332025,
-0.0051568695,
-0.002074193,
-0.0554778054,
0.0157711972,
0.0364148617,
-0.040736191,
-0.0264801886,
-0.0228813868,
0.0099473912,
-0.0584111921,
-0.0444597788,
-0.022893792,
-0.0264832545,
-0.0215340257,
0.0110689541,
0.0357344933,
-0.0247488357,
-0.0622399338,
-0.0104062809,
-0.0509738289,
0.0399179235,
-0.0008930473,
0.0597859435,
0.002255626,
0.0100581478,
-0.0033935914,
0.0548723638,
0.0273150951,
-0.0456272811,
0.0058094687,
0.0229972973,
0.0110319313,
0.0031242783,
-0.0180510376,
-0.0081488341,
-0.0079086944,
0.0110704666,
0.0145889642,
-0.0421880744,
0.005920738,
0.0085943937,
2.735e-7,
0.0429407097,
0.0232260134,
0.0197387058,
-0.0057830187,
0.0117010027,
-0.0169599447,
0.0181834567,
-0.0038928855,
-0.0049334262,
0.0323841199,
-0.0306763425,
0.0374758951,
0.111599192,
-0.0165561698,
-0.097331129,
0.0035272771,
-0.0631921068,
0.0059938636,
-0.0583168939,
0.0094718048,
0.060568437,
0.1339720637,
0.0161567237,
-0.0271304809,
-0.0098185111,
0.0293403268,
0.0534700751,
-0.0250052549,
-0.0101890694,
0.0437961444,
-0.013123231,
-0.0226218663,
0.0188237131,
-0.0475671999,
-0.0520562343,
-0.0049383794,
0.0076249661,
0.1033407226,
0.0354841501,
0.0020383138,
0.0216543283,
0.0040873275,
-0.040534582,
-0.0295379907,
0.0475069769,
-0.0081502302,
0.009530969,
0.0472663008,
-0.0560285784,
-0.0017954683,
0.0350575298,
-0.0080970805,
-0.0369997025,
0.0262556709,
0.0588668436,
-0.0167544279,
-0.0181292389,
-0.0536154471,
0.0098306891,
0.0307647418,
-0.0116264094,
-0.0354754813,
-0.026735181,
-0.0137584591,
-0.0298194345,
0.0236936249,
-0.0084954267,
2.437954391e-34,
0.0669978559,
-0.0032057182,
0.0039889347,
-0.0133211976,
0.0122346887,
0.021713838,
-0.0053973147,
0.0219445061,
0.0018383568,
-0.0219922196,
-0.0046461746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15847v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15847v1 | Disinformation Detection: An Evolving Challenge in the Age of LLMs | 2023-09-25T22:12:50 | 2023-09-25T22:12:50 | Bohan Jiang, Zhen Tan, Ayushi Nirmal, Huan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | The advent of generative Large Language Models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT has
catalyzed transformative advancements across multiple domains. However,
alongside these advancements, they have also introduced potential threats. One
critical concern is the misuse of LLMs by disinformation spreaders, leveraging
these models to generate highly persuasive yet misleading content that
challenges the disinformation detection system. This work aims to address this
issue by answering three research questions: (1) To what extent can the current
disinformation detection technique reliably detect LLM-generated
disinformation? (2) If traditional techniques prove less effective, can LLMs
themself be exploited to serve as a robust defense against advanced
disinformation? and, (3) Should both these strategies falter, what novel
approaches can be proposed to counter this burgeoning threat effectively? A
holistic exploration for the formation and detection of disinformation is
conducted to foster this line of research. | [
0.0398839861,
0.0122507159,
-0.0252705999,
0.0441924408,
-0.0589939952,
-0.0080628162,
-0.0014697242,
-0.0157537609,
0.0196950082,
-0.0243761372,
-0.004876879,
-0.0501282737,
0.0176779293,
0.0271576811,
0.0199943371,
-0.0027519264,
0.0455038659,
0.0123663507,
0.035869576,
-0.0290657543,
0.0217431653,
0.0192926992,
0.0241919961,
0.0376666002,
-0.0002636346,
-0.0457823388,
0.0194047298,
-0.000390893,
0.0110101085,
-0.0325988121,
0.0111650573,
0.0417689197,
0.0469126292,
0.079677619,
0.0000020188,
-0.010869287,
-0.0033791491,
0.0226118062,
-0.0641506836,
0.0520716533,
0.0916978419,
-0.025763182,
-0.0237614028,
0.042150531,
-0.034190271,
-0.0126552479,
0.0292672887,
0.0529647619,
0.0704118907,
0.0968448892,
-0.0003867609,
-0.0334027633,
0.0618093722,
-0.0251610111,
0.013846308,
0.0071154232,
0.0625098869,
-0.0095439246,
-0.0476477183,
0.0656018481,
0.0082352785,
-0.0050079152,
-0.0139193861,
-0.0049894708,
-0.05476702,
0.0105172349,
-0.0174432639,
-0.0358924307,
-0.0194146689,
0.0103061879,
-0.0134508861,
-0.0641579777,
0.0394464172,
0.0179351699,
0.0106668323,
0.0581957698,
-0.0142489783,
0.051212769,
-0.0288351849,
0.0041816365,
0.0166693237,
-0.0290906783,
0.0618654527,
0.0119416723,
0.0173303112,
0.0299419593,
0.0177815855,
-0.0276053026,
-0.0039719762,
-0.0392484739,
-0.0218273941,
-0.0839011893,
-0.0287006479,
-0.0108645763,
-0.0075022122,
-0.0045686704,
-0.0505525246,
-0.0057470161,
0.0360363387,
-0.108701542,
-0.0160968751,
0.0070225657,
0.0201570559,
0.0097035263,
-0.0050827116,
0.0194416586,
-0.0403942391,
0.0058767898,
0.0079998467,
0.0042583169,
-0.0199211612,
-0.0002994394,
-0.0197278298,
0.006265691,
-0.0059920815,
0.0061652809,
-0.072733283,
0.008118419,
-0.0300264861,
0.0212420933,
-0.0264835954,
-0.0144206053,
-0.0040064938,
-0.0045583639,
0.018046055,
0.034540318,
0.0027522482,
0.0218520593,
-0.0085656,
-0.0680542886,
-0.0063060648,
0.0592030473,
-0.0531636439,
0.0040258216,
-0.0175604969,
0.0306688379,
0.0085524824,
0.0102730328,
-0.0347634517,
-0.0489339046,
-0.0594233721,
-0.0582228936,
0.0194319766,
-0.0606650561,
-0.0352517217,
-0.0115895439,
-0.0099854628,
-0.0425255708,
0.0096366936,
0.0036686056,
-0.0439042114,
0.0476032384,
-0.0057599223,
0.0159823466,
0.0649007633,
0.0364791751,
-0.0154093569,
0.073804751,
0.0055068955,
0.0919440612,
0.0408939421,
0.0001677501,
0.0281847324,
0.0289213657,
0.0402705036,
0.052263312,
0.0181877818,
-0.0328128822,
-0.0009972267,
-0.045336768,
0.0008917633,
0.0599980466,
-0.021179812,
-0.036481522,
0.0909572616,
-0.0105244536,
-0.0317578278,
-0.0015602605,
0.0472521558,
0.0638974532,
-0.028388666,
0.0149996439,
-0.0303112604,
-0.0465837419,
-0.040734373,
-0.0332009792,
0.027901629,
0.067483902,
-0.0103823869,
-0.002257843,
-0.0145638622,
-0.0052789883,
0.0248592924,
-0.0148127535,
-0.0018955834,
-0.0066420347,
-0.0257038791,
0.0400602557,
0.0710616633,
0.0035463187,
0.0083672861,
-0.0769332349,
0.0003338911,
0.0064979051,
0.0439580753,
0.0345636196,
0.0207007173,
-0.0475402251,
0.016134277,
0.0250240546,
0.0295782331,
0.004541697,
-0.0651332065,
-0.0045292699,
0.0057767336,
-0.026992429,
0.041931279,
0.0067158733,
0.0359373949,
0.0240244493,
-0.0056788744,
-0.0289281812,
-0.0324776024,
-0.0007611916,
0.0099162143,
0.0046546133,
-0.0311007574,
0.007537622,
0.0497926697,
0.0147506977,
-0.017627921,
-0.010885708,
0.0464072563,
-0.0165947881,
-0.0402708687,
-0.0303206835,
0.0161348209,
-0.0075700884,
0.0271002892,
-0.0027762314,
-0.011343386,
0.0069185672,
-0.0204742104,
0.0281090792,
0.0500360355,
-0.041093044,
0.0451005287,
-0.0407201611,
0.0039098081,
-0.0310079381,
0.0351288356,
0.0042963736,
0.0590841249,
-0.0443461016,
-0.0420376696,
0.004928262,
0.0099498192,
0.0129540358,
0.029901607,
0.0114438152,
-0.0102808727,
0.0040498204,
-0.0040165493,
0.0328027122,
-0.0427994691,
0.0124057094,
-0.0426604114,
-0.0200696345,
-0.0311091896,
-0.0282231495,
0.0108280722,
0.0513571687,
-0.0067630992,
-0.0000380119,
0.0570715182,
-0.0296984278,
0.0168357603,
0.0145314485,
0.0221911743,
0.0000921775,
-0.0286414828,
-0.033196874,
0.0064374693,
0.0417846777,
-0.0317675807,
0.0358193107,
0.0393939018,
-0.0504685901,
-0.0355727747,
0.0138952089,
-0.0564649999,
0.0248752329,
-0.0470475852,
-0.0554033555,
0.0048310873,
0.0191039387,
0.0452015921,
-0.0053836,
0.0449911579,
0.0621540137,
0.028830694,
0.0456646457,
-0.0115362229,
-0.0337866023,
-0.0733148456,
0.0025531515,
-0.0463780165,
-0.0704509243,
0.0209476463,
0.0495805405,
0.0743634775,
-0.0149135329,
-0.0267899279,
0.0425827764,
-0.017891923,
-0.02816502,
0.0165019743,
-0.0536614433,
-0.0134743731,
-0.0006219108,
-0.0365336575,
-0.0750053823,
0.053607706,
-0.0653540045,
0.0408054441,
-0.0167510323,
-0.0228153989,
0.0057599731,
-0.014870096,
-0.0015047735,
0.0350922495,
0.0305785965,
0.0149090877,
-0.0021737006,
-0.0269925855,
0.0520286188,
-0.0128479237,
0.0075338525,
-0.0275594555,
0.0358537547,
0.045400992,
0.0079367142,
-0.0464370586,
-0.1035758033,
0.0213690102,
-0.020395115,
0.0756861642,
-0.0221670456,
-0.0679871887,
0.0009429203,
0.0269731954,
0.0058325571,
-0.0048627481,
0.0103277732,
-0.0284963083,
0.0143180713,
0.0225755423,
-0.0590611845,
0.0733092129,
-0.0617054738,
-0.0031009978,
0.0649891943,
-0.04094835,
-0.0083605861,
0.0028614854,
-0.0571122244,
0.0046588317,
-0.0057751634,
0.0169046,
0.020014843,
0.0359624922,
-0.0467826687,
0.0217345711,
0.0878428742,
-0.0016639261,
-0.0219885446,
0.0005337205,
0.0125032952,
0.0347622037,
0.0148494877,
-0.0343259908,
-0.0872047395,
0.00995846,
0.0126777915,
-0.0158818439,
-0.0440740213,
-0.0034846582,
-0.0311549008,
-0.0844561905,
0.0586276166,
0.012697163,
0.0081169428,
-0.0355999246,
-0.0522859246,
-0.0400740989,
0.0290224925,
0.0206892993,
-0.0413089097,
0.0179916099,
-0.0171458572,
-0.0041495715,
-0.0646604225,
-0.0366838835,
-0.0049543274,
-0.0128539894,
0.0730066597,
0.0692783445,
0.0304559059,
-0.0159212928,
-0.0245885924,
0.0385557264,
0.015917154,
-0.0545657165,
-0.0066754394,
0.0554123707,
-0.0228523277,
-0.0145359822,
-0.0080174543,
0.0380874313,
0.0105042839,
0.0199070927,
-0.0021930945,
0.0385934561,
-0.0057971035,
-0.0813942477,
-0.00165402,
0.0383107662,
0.0690638274,
0.0821390301,
-0.0004787834,
0.0135510629,
-0.008175524,
-0.0477296971,
0.0404651612,
0.0760113001,
-0.0434316993,
0.0172756705,
0.0240726974,
-0.0421761572,
-0.0479352362,
0.0175681338,
-0.0210590623,
-0.0423257686,
0.0230869912,
0.0504136458,
0.0119186891,
-0.0105011696,
0.0027938955,
-0.0482071191,
-0.0526082627,
0.0505288802,
-0.0471971706,
-0.0051087858,
-0.0073198313,
-0.0316785537,
-0.0062825745,
0.0077876472,
-0.1027904376,
-0.0828614384,
0.0166816227,
-0.0014959549,
0.0167038795,
0.0371263474,
-0.0363905095,
-0.0222912282,
0.1005688533,
0.026912434,
-0.0084421132,
0.0432330035,
0.0287727397,
0.0181056019,
0.0348339118,
0.0263482444,
-0.0008947462,
0.0609449297,
0.0190854948,
-0.0376107357,
-0.0486987121,
0.0097756404,
0.0451580174,
0.0240398142,
0.045250237,
-0.0191302784,
0.021141706,
-0.0285157133,
-0.0197435021,
-0.0244952403,
-0.0242718421,
0.0170329865,
0.0017131947,
0.030377863,
0.01178296,
0.027802458,
0.039081201,
-0.0385859013,
0.0108845485,
-0.0310859419,
0.0083150752,
-0.0175734516,
0.0203019865,
0.0577602722,
-0.0187809449,
0.0132300425,
0.037113633,
-0.0050615552,
0.0071927477,
0.010079653,
0.0290670954,
-0.003354579,
-0.0378950499,
0.0186294429,
-0.0131763425,
-0.0352462456,
-0.0412910134,
-0.0149954055,
0.0510646813,
0.025818862,
0.056845922,
0.0377278775,
-0.0128669199,
-0.0236174986,
-0.0240348838,
-0.017184265,
0.0107392203,
-0.0325593241,
0.0145986984,
-0.0228852872,
-0.0750001818,
0.0286198575,
0.0671632662,
0.0051979781,
0.0636239573,
0.0197823029,
-0.0685541332,
-0.0183552131,
-0.0620756112,
-0.0193173587,
0.0217585303,
-0.0004082893,
0.0219103191,
-0.090342842,
-0.0431643575,
-0.0250061192,
0.0144874118,
0.0145604545,
-0.0119532319,
-0.0243846066,
0.0537062511,
-0.0173625406,
0.0128278974,
-0.0606797226,
-0.0019568119,
-0.0105328048,
0.0004564802,
0.0203176513,
-6.373737551e-33,
0.02140023,
-0.0498761237,
-0.0172957834,
0.0111327209,
-0.031428203,
0.0124646649,
0.0074805655,
-0.030668484,
-0.0250799991,
0.0577703044,
0.0492580123,
0.0271565802,
-0.010425969,
-0.0039854962,
-0.0702278614,
-0.0079181874,
0.0663556457,
-0.0215652902,
-0.0359580517,
0.0488906056,
0.0672502667,
-0.0327375606,
-0.0043778466,
-0.0567433238,
0.0441904701,
-0.0324082635,
-0.044425711,
0.0184810329,
-0.028216742,
0.0243694168,
-0.0010142016,
0.0408849046,
0.017570911,
-0.041402977,
0.010225228,
0.0337162353,
0.0092190141,
-0.0033127896,
0.0464451984,
-0.0453788713,
0.0267919302,
-0.0196880121,
0.0281996448,
0.004617868,
-0.0352524444,
0.0385076702,
0.0055995556,
-0.0050666854,
-0.0057720598,
0.0005043972,
-0.0664103851,
-0.0126544544,
0.0140061853,
0.0025002253,
-0.0542832576,
0.0330893025,
0.015808681,
0.0375056043,
-0.0692721158,
0.0449830517,
0.0365054756,
0.0125421556,
0.0337963812,
-0.0218516998,
-0.003334268,
0.0648502856,
0.0099654095,
0.0340279751,
-0.036912743,
-0.0244556069,
-0.0274571534,
0.0136360824,
0.0351108499,
0.0877527744,
-0.0002131793,
-0.0479426682,
-0.1040976495,
0.0141163012,
0.0324993096,
-0.0073458548,
0.0549428537,
-0.0455851071,
-0.0461650752,
-0.0409041531,
-0.0294265766,
-0.0049480395,
-0.0245370083,
-0.0254496727,
0.0025072368,
0.037378367,
-0.0140268365,
0.009358271,
-0.0009411206,
-0.064000532,
0.0013341114,
0.0261433981,
-0.0177049376,
-0.0237299278,
0.0145174889,
0.0397517048,
-0.069496192,
0.0002839298,
0.0224166084,
-0.0151168481,
-0.0198836364,
-0.0083620055,
0.0258463193,
-0.0176879987,
-0.0443882272,
0.0112383422,
-0.0199022256,
0.0480995588,
0.0024951,
-0.0272928998,
0.0443264768,
-0.0133708762,
-0.0072828871,
-0.0100342818,
0.0208785627,
0.0256334506,
0.0178548433,
0.0163282361,
-0.02871323,
0.0303492527,
-0.0410917625,
0.0221483279,
-0.0244510286,
0.0221899655,
0.0349980444,
-0.0770772249,
-0.0169848222,
-0.0734198317,
2.756e-7,
-0.0169152562,
0.0651416108,
0.0037538051,
0.0142815588,
0.0600395389,
0.0352103747,
0.013582496,
-0.00991413,
-0.0375110134,
-0.0686724633,
-0.0326904692,
0.0308684986,
0.007243874,
0.0272853952,
-0.0277359281,
0.0406253822,
-0.0647639111,
-0.0305841323,
-0.0420839675,
-0.0007410698,
0.0258232336,
0.0835715979,
0.0362368822,
-0.0109891044,
-0.0051310658,
-0.0126241622,
0.07629814,
-0.006931413,
-0.0384438001,
0.0507562086,
0.024115663,
-0.0395054594,
0.0066366298,
0.0228044428,
-0.0138597367,
-0.0073382412,
-0.0661725849,
0.048404146,
0.0194707643,
0.0044732234,
-0.041971691,
-0.0331839807,
-0.0026173666,
-0.0598470047,
0.0473339111,
-0.0583679266,
-0.0417091548,
-0.0694593415,
-0.0368815027,
-0.0195796918,
-0.0139577743,
-0.0156985801,
-0.024154814,
0.0077236588,
-0.0175034646,
0.0299748853,
0.0147444038,
-0.0395469107,
0.0267045088,
-0.0064989231,
-0.0594117194,
-0.0902552232,
0.0114926323,
-0.0202669222,
0.0257889368,
0.0193838831,
0.0578791946,
2.695248293e-34,
0.0715165734,
-0.0242667645,
-0.0155336158,
-0.0244468898,
0.0500515439,
0.0060409917,
-0.0110556399,
-0.0206797179,
0.0035858722,
-0.039796032,
0.0152664967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14556v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14556v3 | Art or Artifice? Large Language Models and the False Promise of Creativity | 2023-09-25T22:02:46 | 2024-03-08T05:20:08 | Tuhin Chakrabarty, Philippe Laban, Divyansh Agarwal, Smaranda Muresan, Chien-Sheng Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Researchers have argued that large language models (LLMs) exhibit
high-quality writing capabilities from blogs to stories. However, evaluating
objectively the creativity of a piece of writing is challenging. Inspired by
the Torrance Test of Creative Thinking (TTCT), which measures creativity as a
process, we use the Consensual Assessment Technique [3] and propose the
Torrance Test of Creative Writing (TTCW) to evaluate creativity as a product.
TTCW consists of 14 binary tests organized into the original dimensions of
Fluency, Flexibility, Originality, and Elaboration. We recruit 10 creative
writers and implement a human assessment of 48 stories written either by
professional authors or LLMs using TTCW. Our analysis shows that LLM-generated
stories pass 3-10X less TTCW tests than stories written by professionals. In
addition, we explore the use of LLMs as assessors to automate the TTCW
evaluation, revealing that none of the LLMs positively correlate with the
expert assessments. | [
0.049220562,
0.0263235755,
-0.0447877161,
0.0032277182,
-0.0811870322,
0.0099816285,
0.038380079,
-0.004121148,
-0.0370340198,
-0.0316970237,
-0.0270906091,
-0.0377825908,
0.0058728987,
0.081970118,
0.001176008,
0.0250572097,
-0.0416363701,
-0.0191844273,
0.0758163035,
0.0267860331,
-0.0133055365,
0.0349964537,
-0.0104641132,
0.0579585731,
0.0437803082,
-0.0229495056,
0.0367836691,
-0.0063171317,
0.0233159848,
-0.0275900718,
-0.0092949588,
0.0874457136,
-0.0047846013,
0.0150026288,
0.0000019544,
-0.0557717495,
0.0251177326,
-0.0331878327,
0.0396550111,
0.0120211197,
0.0476429127,
0.0707526579,
-0.0242293067,
0.0094007123,
-0.0304563493,
0.0222512428,
0.016735103,
0.0554841645,
0.0500131063,
0.0613147169,
0.0104931183,
-0.045073282,
0.028055897,
-0.0168417506,
0.0011065796,
0.0534007959,
-0.0018025452,
-0.0063158805,
0.0073739933,
-0.0483937934,
-0.0033211824,
-0.0053142225,
0.0270472262,
-0.0379415862,
0.0315229781,
0.0435277969,
-0.007430084,
-0.0239256751,
0.0354775563,
0.0044735535,
0.038145598,
-0.0159616228,
-0.0143787507,
0.0164532363,
-0.002918622,
0.008394083,
-0.0522912331,
0.0213857573,
-0.0000963311,
-0.0046242005,
-0.0223264769,
0.0070399926,
-0.0266867615,
-0.0037722972,
0.0600904189,
0.0060605239,
0.0281323008,
0.0091369897,
-0.0207218733,
0.0239847489,
0.0184664205,
-0.0957291499,
0.0053106737,
0.0059392885,
0.0174879562,
-0.0147780264,
-0.0102484087,
-0.0346137621,
0.0200214591,
-0.0646572039,
0.1132996976,
0.0084560411,
0.0505095311,
0.0409957618,
-0.0097167585,
0.0395493284,
0.0141906757,
0.0143118287,
-0.0582160465,
0.0716858879,
-0.0692184418,
-0.0184265915,
-0.0117147369,
-0.0342003144,
0.0130013749,
-0.0505724773,
-0.0530028157,
-0.0076562394,
-0.0034688236,
-0.0302533992,
-0.0317436531,
0.0328753516,
0.0293026064,
0.0285359081,
-0.0307918508,
0.0113275098,
0.007820854,
0.0285844505,
-0.0072729257,
0.0285375826,
0.027169019,
0.0254196096,
0.0101059265,
-0.0467234068,
0.0260762013,
0.0225636903,
-0.0213652216,
-0.043325156,
-0.0265240464,
-0.01180737,
0.0194530599,
-0.0552573688,
0.0256074946,
-0.0715162084,
0.0187256876,
0.0217892416,
0.015454554,
-0.0513658114,
-0.0334980525,
0.0190724656,
-0.0060501811,
-0.0254542641,
-0.0070591406,
0.0376493298,
0.0162145123,
0.0033373968,
0.0016134261,
-0.002551988,
0.1114840657,
0.0487775654,
0.0025065006,
0.0107322475,
0.0642877221,
-0.0018163886,
-0.0621510446,
0.0191092193,
-0.0066007101,
-0.0056927362,
-0.0154479435,
0.050010886,
0.0077727004,
0.052413743,
-0.0107407942,
0.0947909579,
0.120718509,
0.0418193117,
0.0383918844,
0.0318915583,
0.0735375136,
-0.0131767876,
0.0408256836,
0.0006480252,
0.0105122505,
0.0426561274,
-0.0072147097,
0.0083694262,
0.0100422651,
0.0470181592,
-0.003202237,
-0.021280406,
-0.0315077417,
0.0461748019,
0.0057066041,
-0.0141310291,
-0.0220143516,
0.0060410067,
-0.0051097614,
-0.0286120567,
-0.0217961352,
-0.0709003806,
0.0198568348,
-0.0250515454,
0.0754766613,
0.1003041416,
0.0465606004,
0.065903686,
0.0384511352,
-0.0275942981,
0.0040997714,
0.047586605,
-0.0008115016,
0.0199411977,
-0.0276714414,
0.0243534427,
0.011220796,
-0.0609662011,
0.0395532921,
-0.0318701752,
-0.0691653416,
0.0191344004,
0.0120755797,
-0.0239724349,
-0.0608516857,
0.0299003646,
-0.0323159322,
-0.0303283986,
-0.0208449811,
-0.0183980074,
-0.0086867623,
0.0062615182,
-0.0725437999,
0.0432525091,
0.0140713602,
-0.0364288203,
-0.054762464,
0.0549369268,
0.0055012829,
-0.0000340199,
-0.0056407927,
-0.086741969,
0.0124681499,
-0.0053557749,
0.0366989076,
-0.0093588643,
0.0448579304,
-0.0501605272,
-0.0081133544,
-0.0230543986,
0.0217940565,
-0.0509801805,
-0.0244088378,
0.0031670295,
0.0424534641,
0.002700364,
0.0441335775,
-0.0476514697,
-0.0312372185,
0.012190856,
0.005595292,
-0.0247001871,
0.0054836087,
0.0288469102,
0.0445453413,
0.0019048157,
0.012830615,
-0.0608029887,
-0.0817209482,
-0.0644783452,
-0.0027989794,
0.0035741902,
0.0068697245,
0.0220433772,
-0.0452729017,
-0.0364013277,
0.0476019569,
-0.0496224351,
-0.0662627518,
0.0269565769,
0.0256266873,
0.0081302496,
-0.0160360038,
-0.01979631,
-0.0091004483,
0.0201999061,
-0.0024519891,
0.0589473732,
0.0791961029,
0.0482427105,
-0.0201659072,
0.0255406816,
-0.0422262624,
-0.0809567794,
0.0179158635,
-0.0482566282,
0.0120625589,
-0.017006604,
0.0437917709,
0.0296814982,
0.02422796,
-0.01042917,
0.0597577058,
-0.0181985721,
0.0283184238,
-0.0125206783,
0.0217375625,
0.0349378884,
0.0020606124,
-0.0896030292,
0.0228385404,
0.0246631745,
0.0324253775,
0.0044066198,
-0.0253088567,
0.1044377983,
-0.030779928,
-0.0173162967,
0.0017478581,
-0.02601205,
-0.0180136636,
0.08863049,
-0.0277524013,
-0.0396487862,
0.0418966264,
-0.0413523726,
-0.0196844023,
-0.0159668513,
0.0106461756,
-0.0505319946,
0.0650194213,
-0.0010189938,
0.029859487,
0.0062672058,
0.0297184214,
-0.0323517136,
0.0040027262,
0.0395109318,
-0.0293439869,
0.0069945552,
-0.0037621479,
-0.0326881744,
0.0202171374,
-0.007026935,
-0.0201985259,
0.0138118286,
-0.0108434111,
0.0161952209,
0.0690742284,
-0.0109556625,
-0.010538212,
-0.0127943531,
0.0456790589,
0.0173474681,
-0.0122854132,
-0.0000107921,
-0.0006674011,
0.0444485806,
0.0445190333,
-0.0142278261,
-0.0262419637,
-0.0465668812,
-0.0012185496,
0.0005029094,
-0.0457000844,
0.0646508709,
-0.0245558042,
0.0369995274,
0.0016572255,
0.001477178,
-0.0167331975,
-0.0045286352,
0.05137638,
-0.0165127646,
-0.0234758556,
0.0865708888,
0.0292974897,
-0.0067447424,
-0.0195556004,
0.0082444269,
-0.0243017897,
0.0178912487,
0.0333004929,
-0.004536069,
0.0167792663,
-0.0111384792,
0.0067295432,
-0.0334000029,
-0.0209114272,
-0.0439997613,
-0.0495501757,
0.0487658828,
0.0026926168,
-0.0028103408,
0.022098517,
-0.0022866188,
-0.0303155351,
0.0395524539,
-0.0205729138,
0.0225497149,
-0.0099971769,
0.0277938489,
-0.0274743866,
-0.0333377011,
-0.0600934699,
0.03538315,
-0.0492036119,
0.0284087528,
0.0528152958,
0.0513239764,
-0.0185224991,
-0.0640928894,
-0.0536531657,
-0.0028017121,
-0.0013681897,
0.0113837225,
0.0135645391,
0.0239510909,
0.0263474733,
-0.05517333,
0.0115349479,
-0.0249587726,
-0.0150122736,
-0.0138085755,
0.0548380278,
0.0097272862,
-0.0438015684,
-0.0218118634,
0.0463347733,
-0.0042267125,
0.0408210084,
0.0591049604,
-0.080473654,
-0.0128090596,
-0.0222190917,
-0.0368392691,
-0.075326398,
-0.060203176,
-0.0269548576,
0.0084854588,
0.0118177831,
-0.084028706,
-0.031185504,
0.0026180539,
0.0467507467,
0.0397388116,
0.0216516647,
-0.0762712657,
-0.0298623703,
-0.0322934352,
0.0099404827,
0.0166245718,
0.032648582,
-0.0195895061,
-0.0006313052,
-0.0539594814,
-0.0525398925,
-0.0320396945,
0.0060460749,
-0.1234406084,
-0.0314558856,
0.0078575239,
-0.0056459554,
0.0207483396,
-0.084710829,
-0.0021753502,
-0.0689016581,
0.0163159743,
-0.0196532905,
-0.0194213185,
0.0695727989,
-0.0361432135,
0.0137012443,
0.0259076376,
-0.0072472482,
-0.0181403402,
0.0256786477,
0.0482621901,
0.0451639183,
0.0554974638,
0.0025734294,
0.0216631033,
0.0246695839,
-0.0329880081,
-0.0396796763,
0.0284780283,
-0.0584880747,
-0.0313048624,
0.0073691611,
-0.0501135774,
-0.043217361,
-0.0094004059,
0.0189696718,
0.0080373753,
-0.0331954025,
0.0183005407,
-0.0324199237,
0.0203388203,
-0.0451303236,
0.0222783051,
0.0338067859,
-0.0037740725,
0.0120688491,
-0.003360783,
-0.0127900979,
0.0086914478,
-0.0831260309,
0.0418933593,
0.0152871888,
0.0369451344,
-0.0003561212,
-0.0030499687,
-0.0096303392,
0.052120097,
-0.0647284612,
-0.0225282293,
0.0035431003,
0.0165538676,
0.0677498281,
-0.0060157836,
0.0465690531,
-0.0092311613,
0.0396146923,
-0.0285526291,
0.0300537683,
-0.0206248071,
-0.029480651,
-0.0358279347,
0.0028061529,
0.0148122776,
-0.028698504,
0.0490996502,
-0.0172575414,
-0.0302674435,
-0.0133649437,
-0.0119546345,
-0.0100029195,
0.0118656149,
0.013133673,
0.0146117713,
0.0351477638,
0.0042193821,
-0.068108663,
-0.0354020819,
0.0460085571,
0.0139524303,
0.0486110598,
-0.0193737559,
-0.0286407173,
0.071559526,
-0.017358087,
-0.0028928453,
-0.0526266396,
-0.0371175371,
0.0034067815,
0.0165451057,
-0.0316531882,
-6.116501184e-33,
-0.001782088,
-0.0558158122,
0.015942039,
-0.0153025603,
-0.0303637702,
-0.0245509949,
-0.06074287,
0.0293727294,
0.0312628411,
0.0319450535,
-0.0170232672,
-0.0165263526,
-0.0112435222,
-0.0148837715,
0.0013378798,
0.0244219899,
0.0480358861,
-0.0080550751,
-0.0729233772,
-0.0153377159,
-0.0054116384,
-0.0230258182,
0.0073357136,
-0.0299615487,
0.0400325879,
-0.0562195182,
-0.0337481834,
-0.0404049717,
0.0207471624,
0.0506601632,
0.0036323485,
0.0197686628,
0.0596085489,
-0.0106558269,
0.0083752563,
-0.0375086106,
0.019264238,
-0.0129114175,
0.0215684939,
-0.0240051001,
0.0058675986,
-0.0390538238,
0.0284174997,
0.0041415496,
-0.0333115645,
-0.0014377759,
0.0489481539,
-0.0117998291,
0.0106895091,
-0.0524728969,
-0.0626276657,
-0.0007337221,
0.0088508502,
-0.0396625511,
-0.0424477458,
-0.0080466531,
-0.0118672913,
-0.0287241787,
-0.0527015477,
0.0339265577,
-0.009727614,
0.0268447269,
0.0195649471,
-0.0283817016,
-0.0424744114,
0.0599506386,
-0.0323309861,
0.0454531051,
-0.0306721646,
0.0384678729,
0.0232847799,
0.038774658,
0.0615319498,
0.0638843402,
0.010593541,
-0.0253381729,
0.0366530232,
0.0060750619,
-0.0027355279,
-0.0408051163,
0.0513111092,
-0.0102419751,
-0.0306911357,
-0.0542562231,
-0.0251021981,
-0.0504873767,
-0.0339881741,
-0.0215354059,
0.0330346487,
0.0031221113,
0.001665151,
-0.0657473654,
0.0122694522,
-0.0105681214,
0.018385388,
0.0091780452,
-0.083507441,
0.0908231661,
-0.0238086712,
-0.0082419561,
0.0058724121,
0.0037015323,
0.0325158872,
0.0640655905,
0.0285906158,
-0.0155639024,
0.0153014837,
0.0121073537,
-0.0486238711,
-0.0051498804,
-0.0374867618,
0.0183249097,
0.0421325229,
-0.0205697361,
-0.0070192809,
0.0034678148,
0.0121480003,
-0.0239502303,
0.026126774,
-0.040257562,
-0.0320581086,
-0.0382810831,
-0.0275364984,
-0.0030243036,
-0.0230996758,
0.0017734322,
-0.0040512946,
-0.0099439733,
0.0334665105,
-0.0369811766,
-0.0023609765,
-0.0347875394,
2.834e-7,
0.0156920478,
0.0339294039,
-0.0584788173,
0.038784951,
0.0389603674,
0.0275394581,
-0.0615900159,
0.0186810177,
0.0313159153,
0.0381115638,
-0.0152481226,
0.0249664877,
0.0464960933,
0.0341000445,
-0.0616017543,
0.0244516358,
-0.0772058442,
0.0374086574,
-0.0518806465,
-0.041218482,
0.1015725955,
-0.0314034261,
0.0332545675,
-0.0488092862,
-0.0226023439,
-0.08799842,
0.0513749793,
-0.0113322446,
0.0076759798,
0.0239813663,
0.0231457558,
-0.0182237756,
0.0008196558,
0.0072084996,
-0.0222967155,
0.0157508925,
0.0136787882,
0.0445285365,
0.0114705479,
0.02569253,
0.0408726297,
-0.0077609476,
-0.006393048,
-0.0591777861,
0.0516612045,
0.0189100895,
-0.0099170292,
-0.0178643186,
-0.0044428771,
-0.0299379732,
0.0407133363,
-0.0293837301,
-0.0211206656,
0.0250352751,
0.0172654837,
-0.0046333028,
0.0139786461,
0.0051716613,
-0.0191435926,
0.0099162776,
-0.0415084064,
-0.0277056228,
-0.0516310744,
-0.0091212504,
-0.0035951228,
-0.0768776536,
0.0184072629,
2.35663934e-34,
0.0438664667,
-0.0233573932,
0.0053914459,
0.020980766,
0.0516680181,
0.0289127044,
0.0520209633,
-0.0290894732,
-0.0222286731,
-0.0505081676,
-0.0089252573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14525v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14525v1 | Aligning Large Multimodal Models with Factually Augmented RLHF | 2023-09-25T20:59:33 | 2023-09-25T20:59:33 | Zhiqing Sun, Sheng Shen, Shengcao Cao, Haotian Liu, Chunyuan Li, Yikang Shen, Chuang Gan, Liang-Yan Gui, Yu-Xiong Wang, Yiming Yang, Kurt Keutzer, Trevor Darrell | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Large Multimodal Models (LMM) are built across modalities and the
misalignment between two modalities can result in "hallucination", generating
textual outputs that are not grounded by the multimodal information in context.
To address the multimodal misalignment issue, we adapt the Reinforcement
Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) from the text domain to the task of
vision-language alignment, where human annotators are asked to compare two
responses and pinpoint the more hallucinated one, and the vision-language model
is trained to maximize the simulated human rewards. We propose a new alignment
algorithm called Factually Augmented RLHF that augments the reward model with
additional factual information such as image captions and ground-truth
multi-choice options, which alleviates the reward hacking phenomenon in RLHF
and further improves the performance. We also enhance the GPT-4-generated
training data (for vision instruction tuning) with previously available
human-written image-text pairs to improve the general capabilities of our
model. To evaluate the proposed approach in real-world scenarios, we develop a
new evaluation benchmark MMHAL-BENCH with a special focus on penalizing
hallucinations. As the first LMM trained with RLHF, our approach achieves
remarkable improvement on the LLaVA-Bench dataset with the 94% performance
level of the text-only GPT-4 (while previous best methods can only achieve the
87% level), and an improvement by 60% on MMHAL-BENCH over other baselines. We
opensource our code, model, data at https://llava-rlhf.github.io. | [
0.0216665585,
0.0434660278,
0.0226667132,
0.0396590345,
-0.0353893153,
0.0080932258,
-0.0289089289,
0.0002010954,
-0.0086134728,
-0.0670368969,
-0.0653032735,
-0.0337575227,
0.0099957976,
-0.0222573578,
0.042029392,
-0.0840750188,
0.0374574475,
-0.0435933433,
-0.0304519758,
0.0031850089,
0.0447054431,
0.0075292345,
-0.0325065441,
0.0219282303,
-0.04809146,
-0.0347206034,
-0.0159659311,
0.0278727952,
0.0723565072,
-0.0260493942,
-0.0024439513,
0.0562906973,
0.0184416045,
0.0464260988,
0.0000022148,
-0.037066903,
-0.0002309059,
0.0019351296,
0.0389651693,
-0.0202666912,
0.0492810905,
-0.0190540962,
-0.0155857401,
-0.0146412095,
-0.0031987103,
0.0023686534,
0.0865057409,
0.0832122043,
0.0778378099,
0.0797395557,
-0.0043407483,
-0.0322477184,
0.0278423335,
-0.0017528015,
0.0408843271,
0.0017803758,
0.0138272829,
0.0566518903,
-0.0129462117,
-0.0107265888,
-0.0569544323,
0.0180346891,
0.0121620474,
0.0193811655,
0.0176331885,
0.0384594463,
-0.0441264696,
-0.0336301923,
-0.028489219,
0.0872335285,
-0.0339489356,
-0.0161257368,
-0.0133540789,
-0.002965837,
0.0099885697,
0.0114470255,
0.0013559262,
0.0381638706,
-0.0237266272,
0.0357496366,
-0.02720825,
-0.0041273497,
0.025578877,
0.0076889889,
0.0195854623,
0.0264745019,
0.0231811218,
-0.0244492143,
0.0229518879,
0.0065406198,
-0.0280123577,
-0.0450655073,
-0.0225863438,
-0.0063421139,
-0.049988579,
0.0001490694,
-0.0795664936,
0.0021300244,
0.0134601593,
-0.0535453856,
0.0212362688,
0.0325159691,
-0.0619820952,
0.055839628,
-0.0126860291,
0.0678503588,
-0.0561322197,
0.0936973915,
-0.0266282111,
0.0116324332,
-0.021977853,
0.0043000979,
0.0015608033,
-0.0167348161,
-0.0291276406,
-0.0360962935,
-0.0570436567,
0.0012166557,
-0.0496652946,
0.0509231128,
-0.0262361411,
0.0161456242,
-0.0533626266,
-0.0169737823,
-0.043459516,
0.0362440571,
0.0072632274,
-0.0078004091,
0.0064427024,
-0.0368982963,
0.0123827001,
0.0487050302,
-0.023353057,
-0.0403454043,
-0.0134061025,
0.0806995779,
-0.0395369306,
-0.0127172526,
-0.0186729375,
-0.0125601776,
-0.0260605756,
-0.0655144081,
0.0207246393,
-0.0487953015,
0.0268728044,
-0.0383278653,
-0.0089496309,
-0.0142665319,
0.0257324763,
0.0079558762,
-0.0062031527,
0.1157138497,
0.0083591649,
-0.0245144945,
0.028832905,
-0.0002288018,
-0.0336955786,
0.0885464177,
0.0258240886,
0.05555645,
0.011159596,
-0.0255632829,
0.0361368917,
0.0571257547,
-0.0047462862,
0.0216187499,
-0.0246604569,
-0.009919297,
0.0383923166,
0.0787983462,
0.047096543,
0.0453945957,
-0.0162639171,
-0.0278230589,
0.0935530737,
0.0115464982,
-0.0018930628,
-0.0343108885,
0.0008428912,
0.0031280566,
-0.0103845056,
0.0206295494,
-0.0836312473,
0.0686605424,
-0.035568513,
0.0231400281,
0.0569416173,
0.0195053387,
-0.0162751954,
-0.027523648,
-0.0150419567,
-0.0010124634,
0.0079174852,
0.0154258357,
0.0363510139,
-0.0140528791,
-0.0787930116,
-0.0037487147,
0.0412899926,
-0.020446226,
0.0002831635,
-0.0103640649,
0.0034131366,
0.0637541264,
0.0399025455,
-0.0333621241,
-0.020378273,
-0.0357930325,
-0.0042372826,
0.0852299854,
0.0114228996,
0.0232280921,
0.0144108031,
-0.0478741974,
-0.0466334186,
0.006676856,
-0.003710144,
0.0195097513,
0.0024683513,
-0.0268424097,
-0.0220200587,
0.0228765383,
-0.0246923324,
0.047131747,
0.0400524177,
0.0074407877,
-0.0608533435,
0.0289578494,
0.0317191631,
-0.0176304411,
-0.0287058763,
-0.0014819209,
-0.01294431,
-0.0148013914,
0.0125492681,
0.014965374,
-0.0450116172,
-0.0168468319,
0.0580132231,
-0.0620265491,
-0.015449048,
0.0375440605,
-0.0225147512,
-0.0131575307,
-0.0110261021,
-0.0308666769,
-0.0030428879,
-0.03152081,
0.0243426692,
0.025416879,
0.0090074725,
-0.0450171009,
0.0596182197,
-0.0349691398,
0.0051557254,
-0.026583679,
0.004303134,
-0.0173547361,
-0.0362367779,
-0.019268401,
0.0074148471,
0.0134855863,
0.0429359563,
0.0192935411,
-0.01142132,
-0.0568325259,
0.004007597,
-0.0702494159,
-0.010492309,
-0.0321642272,
-0.0236595571,
0.0274330601,
-0.0351161137,
0.0090338103,
-0.0355784521,
-0.0304526892,
0.0166304503,
0.0004502064,
0.007953519,
0.0346629918,
-0.0093340809,
-0.0064390344,
-0.0486248136,
0.002927446,
-0.0046633394,
0.0261442941,
-0.0000318229,
-0.0081687337,
-0.0474873222,
0.008515656,
-0.0324648544,
0.0412431769,
-0.0243380852,
-0.0186823867,
0.0098477434,
0.0090834284,
0.0529103242,
0.0761184916,
0.02345163,
0.0363227837,
0.0370342024,
0.0174291749,
-0.0387904197,
0.0104527324,
0.0057138861,
-0.0379124507,
-0.0233241189,
-0.029064469,
-0.0068388758,
0.0301197395,
0.0037278868,
0.0502409339,
-0.0896829739,
0.0122775296,
0.0130905267,
-0.0687070414,
-0.0366252102,
0.0244255997,
-0.0440672003,
0.0173052829,
-0.0579503514,
-0.065799877,
0.0644433424,
-0.0365007147,
-0.0137069756,
0.0057155001,
0.0225446168,
0.0195803586,
0.0157017689,
0.043955829,
0.0433322936,
-0.0151631357,
0.0090769464,
-0.0767776966,
-0.0441234857,
0.0217976309,
-0.0296519659,
0.0724960417,
-0.0249569565,
0.0088484455,
-0.033820048,
-0.0429634862,
-0.0520127378,
-0.0313560106,
-0.0068993373,
-0.04238493,
-0.0597009845,
0.0048847762,
-0.0479712486,
0.0104041295,
0.0437746271,
0.0058556101,
-0.0119553348,
-0.0149758533,
-0.0185916014,
0.0233559627,
0.080238916,
0.0236438662,
-0.0159964524,
-0.0546155572,
-0.017903924,
0.0506050549,
0.0286651663,
-0.0022919173,
-0.0500681363,
0.0054694619,
0.0161719657,
0.0025873487,
0.0135200201,
0.0325133726,
0.0634455755,
-0.0282359868,
0.0091723707,
0.0498985574,
0.0190083962,
-0.0548714623,
-0.0134175066,
0.008351583,
0.0672842339,
0.0108916629,
0.0163109656,
-0.0770172104,
-0.0440194197,
-0.0218560658,
-0.0076856907,
0.0217323732,
0.0044997665,
0.0131838014,
-0.0997722447,
0.0273362361,
0.0400494374,
-0.0407446735,
-0.036615029,
0.0339919068,
0.0099873571,
-0.0084745707,
0.0071237348,
0.0115547637,
0.0182956625,
-0.0084962342,
0.0175865162,
0.0319578312,
-0.0081814397,
-0.0011063069,
-0.0457848459,
0.0408960804,
0.0844777897,
0.0046346043,
-0.0207275394,
-0.0941756889,
-0.0119510498,
0.0461100079,
-0.0076693092,
0.0356270261,
0.0394099243,
-0.0503572486,
-0.0298367813,
0.0011334715,
0.0572067276,
0.0187822022,
-0.0212545861,
-0.0235932488,
0.0561752096,
-0.0168256313,
0.0451514013,
-0.038061358,
0.0276319385,
0.0041760989,
0.040023759,
-0.0161063112,
-0.052982185,
-0.0302297808,
-0.0102961762,
0.0252960809,
-0.0543252267,
-0.02249524,
0.0240911599,
0.0089365896,
0.0021981122,
-0.0752947927,
-0.0268190876,
-0.0121806255,
0.0292944685,
-0.0119698225,
-0.0333534963,
-0.0170188956,
0.025537923,
-0.0355792195,
0.0785548165,
-0.0270624422,
0.0426411666,
-0.0430900976,
0.0163718425,
-0.0158357117,
-0.0557161644,
-0.0011179042,
0.0358475782,
-0.0697888061,
-0.0541705415,
-0.0213283859,
0.0636151955,
0.0058302847,
0.1027704626,
0.0128534995,
-0.0195505694,
0.0107686967,
0.019161284,
0.0012424645,
0.0347250737,
0.0101659922,
0.023489302,
-0.0111928592,
0.0144556155,
-0.0354354531,
-0.0248358026,
0.0269589722,
0.0257705655,
0.0161301028,
-0.0033396541,
0.0431177542,
-0.0188435335,
0.0544997118,
-0.0581603311,
0.0203863829,
-0.0108673014,
-0.0227834992,
-0.0100099202,
-0.0509106815,
-0.0268092696,
-0.0232116245,
0.0305398125,
-0.0121936304,
0.009484889,
-0.034186013,
0.0140689937,
0.0166527573,
-0.0256987121,
-0.0327254198,
0.012791655,
-0.0200458858,
-0.0128669022,
0.0415735431,
-0.0095169535,
0.0249136928,
-0.0084508453,
0.0506445691,
0.0160238016,
0.1243128851,
0.0404941365,
-0.0298722163,
-0.0158638507,
0.0300349109,
0.0035753192,
0.0116778268,
-0.0597498827,
0.0455629602,
0.0714856684,
0.0099142967,
0.0343862064,
-0.0167939439,
-0.0214198288,
-0.0194256548,
0.0428554602,
-0.0119843427,
-0.0135534918,
0.0603553578,
0.027981516,
0.0031369319,
-0.01379475,
0.036377985,
-0.0029965478,
0.01040712,
-0.0040980647,
-0.0000760386,
-0.0430540852,
-0.0297845174,
0.0096487049,
-0.0013789629,
-0.0301622637,
0.009141651,
-0.0474212989,
-0.0475352667,
-0.0137829157,
0.0654964522,
-0.0118064089,
0.005252671,
0.0566531792,
0.0250526778,
-0.0168770812,
-0.0307817496,
-0.0319867395,
-0.0268557202,
0.0269090254,
-0.0055438485,
0.0025304332,
-6.376538901e-33,
-0.0355319381,
-0.0188460015,
0.032679569,
-0.0387629829,
-0.049745664,
-0.0107926754,
0.0084382482,
0.0266740452,
-0.001336576,
0.0099405712,
0.0399673022,
-0.0309268292,
0.0141575616,
0.0478302464,
-0.0048014787,
-0.0163725056,
0.007201388,
-0.0202075746,
-0.0561982244,
-0.0086670332,
0.0319345184,
-0.012309785,
0.0565693639,
-0.0602587536,
0.013672133,
-0.0026458211,
-0.0668075308,
0.0089796418,
-0.0199307911,
0.0682737902,
-0.0461516641,
0.0133833652,
-0.0046498585,
-0.0454440825,
-0.0050014947,
0.014087013,
-0.0331938826,
0.0174227301,
0.0254162755,
0.0523815192,
-0.1151356176,
-0.0049511218,
0.0535600558,
-0.0282753911,
-0.0277226996,
-0.0340269506,
0.0418827869,
-0.0302391201,
-0.0125805037,
0.0525362752,
-0.0733009949,
0.0063633113,
-0.0088522444,
-0.0398034267,
0.0345475674,
0.0437893532,
0.0118530411,
0.0348819681,
-0.0714569092,
0.004481608,
-0.0190649666,
-0.0025395059,
0.0894356817,
0.0755598918,
0.012164426,
0.0718056187,
0.0153444344,
-0.0504241064,
-0.0221037921,
-0.0139617454,
0.0107274232,
0.0423896499,
0.0348191112,
0.0941043198,
0.0406603664,
0.0308651123,
-0.0138100693,
0.0125979511,
-0.0671653524,
0.0307366699,
0.0361170769,
0.0378860198,
-0.0532025136,
0.0166949183,
-0.0261052381,
0.0152934399,
-0.0394913852,
-0.0313360244,
0.0522428602,
0.0283902716,
0.0150598651,
0.0243215524,
0.0549704544,
-0.0247399397,
0.0210123006,
-0.0018413143,
-0.033251293,
0.0561790392,
-0.0243060794,
-0.0020396772,
-0.0246396735,
-0.003544528,
0.0532502383,
-0.013810901,
0.0123794805,
0.0069570937,
0.040112637,
0.0110923275,
-0.0456514768,
0.0196248628,
-0.0381111875,
0.0015440315,
-0.0114359064,
0.0095565422,
0.0527367964,
-0.0220296085,
-0.042037081,
0.0283001382,
0.0076182117,
-0.0162907504,
-0.0199346896,
-0.0410664417,
-0.0311253909,
0.0084192799,
-0.0022901243,
0.0397739187,
-0.0192137863,
-0.0502503216,
0.0064309929,
-0.0650866479,
-0.0098030074,
0.0304401834,
2.852e-7,
0.0093348455,
0.0205941405,
0.0318015739,
-0.0190169979,
0.0052161543,
0.0738399327,
-0.0182915963,
0.0514708981,
-0.0025343965,
-0.0679996088,
0.0075282948,
0.0294346418,
0.0507084541,
-0.0061242608,
0.0105053466,
-0.0027872073,
-0.0415883921,
0.0105906595,
-0.0478471518,
-0.0125513934,
0.0411160029,
0.0690517426,
0.0192446709,
-0.0237017088,
0.0387121662,
-0.0039914171,
0.0783501938,
-0.029161999,
-0.0491706021,
-0.0074067865,
-0.0004398224,
0.0081177959,
-0.0294217858,
0.0103391819,
0.0058017438,
-0.0402084738,
0.0423824564,
0.0251600109,
-0.0422822386,
-0.0489827059,
-0.0602179207,
0.041735217,
-0.0047745002,
-0.0561816581,
0.0394888967,
-0.0282201134,
-0.0188285448,
-0.0270413216,
-0.0487843305,
-0.0024329498,
0.0421696045,
-0.027572304,
-0.0471309088,
0.010534564,
0.0353744216,
0.0303955637,
-0.0427645594,
-0.0558344126,
-0.0402872749,
0.0308712199,
-0.0357167795,
-0.0020623896,
-0.0373015143,
0.0131714763,
0.0122487629,
-0.0856825858,
-0.0558531508,
2.468680941e-34,
0.0199275296,
-0.0300379321,
0.0384910181,
-0.0256839022,
0.0130690495,
0.0245980769,
-0.0205011871,
-0.0093594911,
0.016033696,
-0.0350918025,
-0.0108264638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14519v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14519v1 | ChatGPT Performance on Standardized Testing Exam -- A Proposed Strategy for Learners | 2023-09-25T20:25:29 | 2023-09-25T20:25:29 | Umer Farooq, Saira Anwar | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | This study explores the problem solving capabilities of ChatGPT and its
prospective applications in standardized test preparation, focusing on the GRE
quantitative exam. Prior research has shown great potential for the utilization
of ChatGPT for academic purposes in revolutionizing the approach to studying
across various disciplines. We investigate how ChatGPT performs across various
question types in the GRE quantitative domain, and how modifying question
prompts impacts its accuracy. More specifically this study addressed two
research questions: 1. How does ChatGPT perform in answering GRE-based
quantitative questions across various content areas? 2. How does the accuracy
of ChatGPT vary with modifying the question prompts? The dataset consisting of
100 randomly selected GRE quantitative questions was collected from the ETS
official guide to GRE test preparation. We used quantitative evaluation to
answer our first research question, and t-test to examine the statistical
association between prompt modification and ChatGPT's accuracy. Results show a
statistical improvement in the ChatGPT's accuracy after applying instruction
priming and contextual prompts to the original questions. ChatGPT showed 84%
accuracy with the modified prompts compared to 69% with the original data. The
study discusses the areas where ChatGPT struggled with certain questions and
how modifications can be helpful for preparing for standardized tests like GRE
and provides future directions for prompt modifications. | [
0.0066834395,
-0.0534931757,
-0.0406961329,
-0.0284314007,
-0.0538301505,
0.0070809415,
0.0088804513,
0.0205214154,
0.0435022041,
-0.0304833632,
0.0283330027,
-0.0118081206,
-0.0152009558,
0.0121034682,
0.0246482715,
-0.0369654335,
0.0249691922,
0.0166530348,
0.0257885773,
0.0158867184,
0.0063882847,
-0.0160982534,
-0.0565663837,
0.0027293123,
0.006422854,
-0.0730187446,
-0.013630555,
-0.0101498729,
-0.0086499192,
-0.0583637692,
0.0526688099,
0.0529908687,
0.0084892474,
0.0217257123,
0.0000023815,
-0.0806470439,
-0.0469017476,
-0.0139126759,
-0.0387695059,
0.0272789542,
0.0140988501,
0.0754099041,
0.018304918,
0.0265033431,
-0.0424304269,
0.0148367966,
0.032302022,
-0.005596641,
0.0268120021,
0.0631069466,
0.0057984432,
-0.0039988062,
0.0109722372,
0.0081561739,
0.0622479729,
-0.0092591383,
-0.0144790411,
0.0621915571,
0.0500737727,
0.0365197025,
-0.0757547244,
0.0097912829,
0.0220680814,
0.0300710127,
0.0021407069,
0.0204702895,
-0.0566601679,
0.0270676259,
0.0029070608,
0.0191158783,
0.0500978753,
0.0016430155,
-0.0372030102,
0.0096204942,
0.027245257,
0.0519063361,
-0.0504836105,
-0.0066453079,
-0.0335018039,
-0.04069544,
-0.0383314975,
-0.0396978706,
-0.0354964547,
-0.0197747536,
0.0385176726,
0.019061204,
0.0158749856,
-0.0265382342,
0.011673199,
-0.0038503686,
-0.0474391133,
0.0030978553,
-0.0053380993,
0.0532097071,
-0.0573561005,
0.0131168775,
0.0402731225,
0.0010289591,
0.0037621658,
0.0542914458,
-0.0110005746,
0.1011068597,
-0.0025447907,
-0.0107213408,
-0.0041540363,
0.1060200259,
0.032823462,
-0.0049549597,
-0.0585780293,
0.0370207839,
-0.0576858707,
-0.0279554389,
-0.0393523723,
-0.0136799905,
0.0295471512,
0.0008962177,
-0.0523514673,
-0.0223744866,
-0.0035922821,
0.0022448206,
-0.0286386162,
0.0046690935,
-0.0104644103,
0.0133723123,
-0.0442600772,
0.0182413757,
-0.0490191057,
-0.025251152,
0.0154086873,
-0.0175965913,
-0.0055226237,
-0.0009623953,
0.0182374548,
0.000225157,
0.0222644601,
0.0054002763,
-0.0514437594,
-0.0091881761,
-0.0018343528,
-0.0494025834,
-0.0016485578,
-0.0330493003,
0.0186914187,
-0.038243603,
0.0225922018,
0.007914708,
-0.0069589959,
0.0515742749,
0.0091770794,
0.0367170162,
0.0583445467,
0.0275659412,
0.0456971116,
0.0021508925,
0.0659546331,
0.0409595817,
-0.0310164373,
0.0125365509,
-0.0023814901,
-0.0020827991,
0.0377724022,
-0.1037980467,
0.0192854311,
-0.0009433568,
0.0110966684,
-0.0251116008,
0.0577963665,
0.0143555747,
0.0605197772,
0.0204475205,
-0.0211951304,
0.03371666,
-0.0204863418,
0.0293716695,
0.0134056481,
0.0951861516,
-0.0011047126,
0.0201048031,
0.0160336737,
0.0273903795,
0.0326747559,
0.0575696826,
-0.018922288,
-0.00143458,
-0.0430217162,
0.025682196,
-0.0088260965,
0.0151715335,
-0.0069736415,
-0.0004793508,
-0.0157845002,
0.0444760211,
-0.011441391,
0.053974431,
-0.0005196009,
-0.045163881,
-0.0260468218,
-0.0070608808,
-0.0105248448,
-0.0030702744,
0.0245806817,
-0.0122039113,
0.0349251591,
0.035524711,
0.056927193,
0.0027746863,
-0.0860931501,
-0.0191271827,
0.0356937535,
-0.0040917648,
0.0764248669,
-0.0183600467,
-0.0620371737,
-0.0389303491,
-0.0067741764,
-0.0145440241,
-0.0313749947,
0.0034819944,
0.0331660211,
0.0318950526,
0.013137335,
0.011214871,
0.0231872555,
-0.0035198843,
-0.0294245239,
-0.0997057259,
-0.0313087478,
-0.0220698696,
-0.0018055449,
0.0130526824,
0.0139558986,
0.0174439084,
-0.0381363034,
0.0424868427,
-0.0020610723,
-0.0081804534,
-0.0671245754,
-0.0019017683,
0.0273731612,
-0.0634942725,
-0.0628734753,
-0.0024760228,
-0.0183023736,
-0.0373442806,
-0.0049208896,
-0.0315349624,
-0.0044628046,
-0.026441263,
-0.0013296728,
-0.0431311131,
-0.0224984828,
-0.0273043178,
0.0191258565,
0.0868557021,
0.0595025606,
0.0213454105,
0.0185781233,
0.0235092454,
-0.0283662323,
-0.002464162,
-0.0235769432,
-0.0065218587,
-0.0178970136,
0.0434225835,
0.0463120863,
-0.1190624908,
0.0057057091,
-0.0703562498,
0.0416903161,
0.0227692872,
0.0631259307,
0.0563696735,
-0.030250743,
-0.0622943826,
0.0264125355,
-0.0585977733,
-0.0313775018,
0.0131407082,
0.0049040113,
0.0083964961,
0.0036390699,
0.0426038019,
-0.0191091485,
-0.002611228,
-0.0655671805,
-0.0401282758,
0.0518073961,
0.0050169132,
-0.0040938901,
0.0413211063,
0.0184999164,
-0.0199363325,
0.0189160611,
-0.0272939019,
0.0256092306,
-0.0110807549,
0.0719169974,
0.0343335979,
0.0176021829,
0.0191483069,
0.0010725121,
-0.0732059702,
-0.0449038185,
0.0384360477,
-0.0363936722,
-0.0431662239,
0.0202068575,
-0.074344933,
-0.0139552802,
0.0140970834,
0.0244352017,
-0.0119815972,
-0.0037593055,
0.0609693192,
-0.0615498461,
0.0500109419,
-0.0742167756,
0.0036232125,
-0.0258077234,
0.0101881763,
-0.0099125504,
0.0046716901,
0.0694913566,
-0.0013699522,
-0.0253534112,
-0.107506983,
0.0517108627,
-0.0167940743,
0.0389917791,
-0.0312543251,
-0.0024095834,
0.0214345753,
-0.0373259895,
-0.0787148401,
-0.0038556715,
0.0449516997,
-0.0098040057,
-0.0047423998,
-0.0209056139,
-0.0411288366,
-0.0117878756,
0.0102932584,
-0.0337941237,
0.0041944212,
0.0614481233,
0.0056188726,
0.0187400989,
-0.0055666566,
0.0014130137,
-0.0329432786,
0.0198638178,
-0.0196718704,
-0.0448255092,
-0.0353987142,
0.0098880101,
0.0216654316,
0.031067241,
0.0259679593,
0.0321749747,
-0.0044645295,
0.049927935,
0.0537707694,
0.0215073042,
-0.0095166452,
0.0451103486,
0.0148879262,
0.0082502868,
-0.07524243,
0.0030814193,
0.0323280469,
0.0291698445,
-0.0629557297,
-0.0030805138,
0.0992571115,
0.0489977747,
0.0191657357,
-0.0230198856,
-0.0360699892,
-0.00449483,
-0.002102176,
0.0488326661,
-0.0929047242,
0.0178184174,
-0.0216838047,
0.0088895233,
-0.0703594163,
-0.0274794698,
-0.0370381139,
-0.0853453949,
0.0215200335,
-0.000291467,
-0.0653394759,
0.0194361452,
0.0087549286,
0.001472719,
0.0406376906,
0.0477489792,
0.0090142488,
-0.0115648871,
0.0430932082,
0.0639377534,
-0.0703907683,
-0.0083205793,
0.0451469012,
0.0086606545,
-0.0093156425,
0.0116230482,
0.0039159101,
-0.0386625752,
-0.0313824527,
0.0787189454,
-0.0254229233,
0.0201263558,
-0.0063562049,
-0.0185829159,
-0.0060520801,
0.0389579944,
-0.0227275472,
0.0347382277,
-0.0230342206,
-0.0043057036,
0.1072999388,
0.0679324344,
-0.0153270075,
-0.0128726335,
-0.0260446668,
0.0041214125,
-0.0171203688,
0.0259903856,
0.0172028039,
0.001567771,
0.0170701854,
-0.0373843387,
0.0358286761,
0.001347099,
-0.0237578228,
-0.0094774486,
0.0046857465,
0.0360493101,
0.0041119433,
-0.0674236566,
0.0940420255,
0.013352883,
-0.0100135542,
-0.0069613568,
0.0017108425,
0.0225337669,
-0.0156140374,
0.0433291048,
-0.0050444049,
-0.0160423126,
-0.0300530884,
-0.0101070665,
-0.0322998762,
-0.0063310498,
-0.0366113409,
-0.0108024627,
-0.0024135732,
-0.0166539438,
0.0101027945,
0.023821203,
0.0131848287,
-0.0288713444,
0.0190155003,
0.0365151763,
0.002499741,
-0.0235201325,
-0.0236490034,
-0.0006934201,
-0.0307180174,
0.021328073,
-0.0043804315,
-0.0524536632,
0.0259019025,
-0.0116063906,
0.008692747,
0.027943192,
0.0362892412,
-0.0128517123,
0.057316497,
0.0611939915,
0.0502791367,
0.0169421621,
0.0247411616,
-0.0081322165,
0.0237559211,
-0.0269971974,
-0.0105201434,
0.0225197636,
-0.0482655205,
0.0219023917,
-0.0274956413,
-0.0268860087,
-0.0326318257,
-0.0852255002,
0.0298019014,
-0.0545936227,
0.0556787997,
-0.0011278142,
0.0263739303,
0.0339408405,
-0.0416243374,
-0.0299039017,
-0.0301579125,
0.0194287226,
0.0510943793,
0.0098100714,
0.096664086,
0.0071238237,
-0.0248003379,
0.0352488756,
-0.0235389471,
-0.0373579375,
-0.0645896941,
-0.0026969146,
0.0637051389,
-0.0324396938,
0.0090545686,
-0.0715471506,
-0.0411449336,
0.0083772186,
-0.0093167769,
-0.0337648168,
0.011043827,
-0.0214156434,
0.0616676658,
0.031550996,
0.0121737849,
-0.0396066755,
0.0140129821,
-0.0559389554,
0.0067133685,
0.0081473496,
-0.0324209742,
-0.005793931,
-0.0272244401,
0.0044090571,
0.0199555643,
0.0298511721,
0.0066575008,
-0.0534540415,
-0.0302141886,
-0.0298790038,
0.0175540317,
0.0085638864,
-0.0095637953,
0.0408860594,
0.0338093005,
-0.0457890518,
-0.0254090354,
0.0270535946,
0.0614329502,
-0.0650101826,
-0.0396596715,
0.0015969001,
-6.203843353e-33,
-0.0056580305,
-0.0398756228,
0.075117901,
0.0304172542,
0.01158763,
-0.0150327254,
-0.0184839666,
0.0380112343,
0.0074723833,
-0.0212085452,
-0.0360099971,
0.0088655725,
0.0077249384,
0.0137033043,
0.0000316113,
-0.0469029434,
0.0039724526,
0.0238398015,
-0.0310487356,
0.0204448998,
-0.0114530511,
-0.003812952,
0.0598111413,
-0.0031269579,
0.064575009,
-0.0499369651,
0.0143263079,
-0.0557662323,
-0.027643472,
0.030538924,
-0.009303757,
0.0421392247,
0.013906817,
-0.0491496809,
0.0110688731,
0.0550131686,
-0.0172733311,
-0.1145093665,
0.0207448043,
0.027702637,
-0.0263905823,
-0.0479398221,
-0.0310532246,
-0.0233423598,
-0.0385867655,
-0.022645738,
0.0316950493,
0.0115568954,
0.0274754763,
-0.0208170172,
-0.0335257761,
-0.0038781813,
-0.0489057712,
0.0017865542,
-0.0465229042,
0.079510726,
-0.0034951284,
-0.0411027521,
0.0176219568,
0.0145356301,
0.0101718921,
0.0171729997,
0.0276478808,
-0.0249634739,
-0.0029866262,
0.0134902876,
0.0059234286,
-0.0193525981,
0.0006618939,
-0.0460418612,
0.0178166851,
-0.0507385433,
0.0613292679,
0.0426480658,
0.0564017221,
-0.0211225227,
-0.0685530379,
0.0648575127,
0.0525892377,
0.0006155888,
-0.018957559,
-0.0317939706,
-0.0404165834,
-0.0428262055,
-0.0422578566,
0.0517570265,
-0.0236779377,
-0.057931982,
0.0423205532,
-0.0906279162,
0.0162018761,
-0.0252960883,
0.018977724,
0.0073842132,
-0.0117933825,
-0.0618476607,
-0.0245716888,
0.053264875,
-0.0282106251,
0.0330106169,
-0.0279460996,
0.0361349247,
0.0402246751,
-0.0248675682,
0.0268897749,
0.0023907195,
-0.0097741103,
0.0201910138,
-0.0180401411,
-0.0303728934,
-0.021304477,
0.0035286227,
0.0245639067,
-0.0557220802,
0.0013693151,
0.0655840859,
0.0246326923,
0.0254912078,
0.0231642965,
-0.0239354894,
-0.023484949,
0.019522436,
-0.0234960336,
-0.0298110042,
0.0153181218,
0.0115691116,
0.0120509788,
0.0202171896,
-0.0100023719,
-0.0281761792,
-0.004083246,
0.0004646112,
2.953e-7,
0.0667068884,
0.0362378359,
0.0089175627,
0.0059743826,
-0.0023798002,
-0.018326642,
-0.0054944544,
-0.0288232695,
0.0855159089,
-0.0111327972,
0.0654974952,
0.0052616089,
-0.0215125736,
0.035411641,
-0.0587880574,
-0.0250364728,
0.0105989734,
-0.0345812887,
-0.0428797118,
0.0807686076,
0.0992135331,
-0.0539601482,
0.0001282804,
-0.0083250338,
-0.0334188081,
-0.0070528202,
0.0103002265,
-0.0499710999,
-0.0225012209,
0.048917532,
0.0176277049,
-0.0051707216,
0.0508666746,
0.0582552329,
-0.0000981779,
-0.0642495602,
-0.0029697262,
0.0047343248,
0.0416584127,
0.0021154922,
0.0182481539,
0.0193397813,
-0.0020739406,
-0.0696718171,
0.0393094569,
-0.0731454864,
-0.0169274565,
0.019674642,
-0.0417922474,
-0.059348654,
0.0200248361,
-0.0128903193,
-0.0238416456,
0.0052318666,
0.0118442103,
0.0112976609,
0.008468274,
-0.0129679991,
0.0475949273,
0.0415315554,
-0.0012849967,
-0.040857885,
-0.0326961875,
-0.0326663926,
0.0408167839,
-0.0405561849,
-0.0278297681,
2.858838766e-34,
0.0049667824,
-0.0011314257,
0.0732768327,
-0.0018051049,
0.0166492239,
0.0088032475,
0.031425491,
0.0107624242,
0.0263543036,
-0.008242243,
-0.0452336036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14517v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14517v2 | Watch Your Language: Investigating Content Moderation with Large Language Models | 2023-09-25T20:23:51 | 2024-01-17T17:41:18 | Deepak Kumar, Yousef AbuHashem, Zakir Durumeric | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.SI | Large language models (LLMs) have exploded in popularity due to their ability
to perform a wide array of natural language tasks. Text-based content
moderation is one LLM use case that has received recent enthusiasm, however,
there is little research investigating how LLMs perform in content moderation
settings. In this work, we evaluate a suite of commodity LLMs on two common
content moderation tasks: rule-based community moderation and toxic content
detection. For rule-based community moderation, we instantiate 95 subcommunity
specific LLMs by prompting GPT-3.5 with rules from 95 Reddit subcommunities. We
find that GPT-3.5 is effective at rule-based moderation for many communities,
achieving a median accuracy of 64% and a median precision of 83%. For toxicity
detection, we evaluate a suite of commodity LLMs (GPT-3, GPT-3.5, GPT-4, Gemini
Pro, LLAMA 2) and show that LLMs significantly outperform currently widespread
toxicity classifiers. However, recent increases in model size add only marginal
benefit to toxicity detection, suggesting a potential performance plateau for
LLMs on toxicity detection tasks. We conclude by outlining avenues for future
work in studying LLMs and content moderation. | [
0.0936446562,
0.0604611896,
-0.0138562657,
-0.0203836281,
-0.0152743552,
0.0244681221,
0.0397244357,
0.0256370734,
0.0316958651,
-0.0537224859,
-0.0221222024,
-0.0046036849,
-0.0553619787,
0.0222755559,
-0.0312213413,
-0.0066907159,
0.0236082971,
-0.0034611006,
0.033333417,
0.0136589454,
0.0702353418,
0.0344085954,
0.0388274901,
0.0533609092,
-0.0179952756,
-0.0151623283,
0.0563879758,
-0.0179539174,
0.025089331,
-0.013933951,
0.0209712554,
0.0457100794,
0.0171288066,
0.0868749693,
0.000001889,
-0.0155449351,
0.0111444918,
-0.0133547308,
0.0185525641,
-0.0084343925,
0.0892188698,
-0.0469434597,
-0.0189737026,
0.0636905953,
-0.0222279429,
0.0067552282,
0.0633730963,
0.0224081669,
0.0676955804,
0.060348887,
-0.0322130769,
-0.0203023944,
0.0135669569,
-0.0108436346,
-0.0197766367,
0.0270208884,
0.06933029,
-0.0181132443,
-0.0084066428,
0.0173977911,
-0.0082802288,
0.02673015,
0.014071946,
-0.0616302453,
-0.0173811745,
-0.0156813264,
-0.0094144512,
-0.0459948666,
0.002140017,
0.0518224426,
-0.0231569652,
-0.0346035324,
0.0096450811,
0.0065097199,
0.0086794393,
0.0245368518,
-0.0470979139,
0.0206222013,
-0.0088139186,
0.02978063,
0.0045863446,
0.0000934433,
0.0490042716,
0.0443780348,
0.0358923599,
0.0388950631,
0.0001859911,
-0.0244930033,
0.014952017,
0.0126711819,
0.0091592353,
-0.0184999481,
0.0570665151,
-0.0155661469,
-0.0383525714,
0.0160550848,
-0.0179561172,
-0.0247990303,
0.0476637147,
-0.0943557546,
-0.0137273241,
0.0198321063,
-0.0160789527,
0.0695928335,
0.0104118055,
-0.0004468324,
-0.0205202345,
0.0379492342,
-0.0050566355,
0.0068919808,
-0.0382451788,
0.0109616704,
-0.0130250342,
0.0066622416,
0.024882799,
0.0112794135,
-0.0486388728,
0.0423122607,
-0.0359557867,
-0.0257870797,
0.0383339711,
-0.0020027298,
0.0101979151,
0.0270191152,
0.0082906689,
0.0145634804,
-0.0116702905,
0.0570752285,
0.0048609092,
-0.0254696067,
0.0130873369,
0.0203499105,
-0.0106165679,
-0.0239901319,
0.0214492436,
0.0671731383,
0.0447620153,
-0.017863322,
-0.0196420643,
-0.0093755079,
-0.0403816253,
-0.0495847277,
-0.0341990441,
-0.0654345751,
0.015207069,
-0.002686963,
0.0135223651,
-0.0616621487,
0.0047209011,
0.0198062751,
-0.0339401141,
0.0451253653,
-0.0053518158,
-0.0095561398,
0.0372605324,
0.0365732312,
-0.0204805527,
0.0739379525,
-0.0132652726,
0.0477953628,
0.0365135074,
-0.0000923822,
0.0007480676,
0.0311605819,
-0.002253891,
0.0226819348,
-0.0224188901,
-0.0109674819,
-0.0285954662,
-0.0258611534,
-0.0076808524,
0.0701854005,
-0.0072229714,
-0.0304920878,
0.0985966176,
0.0262505393,
-0.0328591168,
0.0228239372,
0.0534941293,
0.0025437269,
-0.0323428027,
-0.0427025706,
-0.0530729108,
-0.0071989079,
-0.0424677357,
-0.0690408126,
0.0340080634,
0.0486633144,
-0.0081595797,
-0.0525628626,
-0.0256647319,
-0.0112583525,
0.0286967214,
-0.0170968268,
0.0297017116,
-0.0345515274,
0.0047445246,
-0.0272643063,
0.0585079789,
-0.0086416993,
0.0084361434,
-0.0442929193,
0.0564764775,
0.0719539374,
0.0261662956,
-0.0557405576,
0.0232253671,
-0.0593245141,
0.0576877594,
0.0255015101,
0.03806803,
0.0094121266,
-0.0521218218,
-0.0158866383,
-0.0288952794,
0.0125740273,
0.0271558035,
0.0040845689,
0.0213765446,
0.0443356223,
-0.0150119951,
0.0391347222,
-0.0619454384,
0.0121266916,
0.052782245,
-0.001224973,
-0.0205345601,
-0.0103362976,
0.0476849899,
-0.0090725478,
-0.0223189704,
-0.0323726088,
0.0103396252,
-0.0141109647,
-0.0688616112,
-0.0515935309,
-0.0044902707,
-0.0105333971,
0.058116544,
-0.0102815479,
-0.0241687614,
0.0309270583,
0.0030090832,
0.031416107,
0.010499076,
-0.0463716388,
-0.0103886249,
-0.0321779028,
-0.0330513529,
-0.0365374088,
0.0209504589,
-0.0229804553,
0.0375634953,
-0.0045064031,
-0.0055008652,
0.0225688368,
-0.0792987272,
-0.0064128153,
0.0295724012,
-0.0208489597,
-0.0203628503,
-0.0027982756,
0.0084225759,
0.0587668344,
0.0120394034,
-0.0126692634,
-0.0405167565,
-0.038173262,
-0.0194300245,
-0.0424246155,
0.0076511689,
0.0314035267,
-0.0168779194,
0.0168029293,
0.0386211798,
-0.0585853979,
-0.0258208513,
0.0273057595,
0.044811625,
-0.0120431995,
-0.0417609066,
-0.0450756364,
-0.0268142205,
-0.0107536037,
-0.0172797944,
0.0240423307,
0.0155441361,
-0.0720335692,
0.0289653037,
0.0274424329,
-0.0471989214,
-0.0274057165,
-0.0249844845,
-0.0610383935,
0.0194715764,
-0.0121700792,
0.0107427416,
0.0253973715,
0.0221138373,
0.0598111562,
0.0607834123,
0.042617768,
-0.0363364033,
-0.0196574498,
-0.0346715152,
-0.0401771069,
-0.0335884355,
-0.0178171862,
0.0059987064,
0.0668954328,
-0.0014169615,
-0.0128606884,
-0.0626618266,
0.0769680291,
-0.0568500794,
-0.0211289451,
0.0048676999,
-0.0720684826,
0.0173876956,
0.016520327,
-0.0224195346,
-0.0690185577,
0.073959507,
0.0264518186,
0.0236186925,
0.0017086675,
-0.0570723973,
-0.0384807847,
0.0121075027,
0.021965621,
0.0467062369,
-0.0234656483,
0.0086754598,
0.0334254578,
-0.004718157,
0.0572037511,
-0.0400784537,
0.0087785376,
-0.041175127,
0.0296011046,
0.0188575946,
-0.0671550557,
-0.023318544,
-0.0338707007,
-0.026938064,
0.0041036024,
0.0496802703,
0.006718935,
-0.0423110202,
0.0425681509,
0.0259343404,
-0.0277736709,
0.0165911261,
-0.0343411304,
0.0383937098,
-0.0118503375,
0.0232315399,
-0.0215880387,
0.0092812805,
-0.0125289867,
0.0392452478,
0.0818122327,
-0.0345496349,
-0.0297005922,
0.0032161851,
0.0058633471,
0.0193465482,
-0.0173880719,
-0.0019575902,
-0.0025506918,
0.0189503059,
-0.0318611264,
0.0202658363,
0.083779335,
0.0360647812,
-0.0639797226,
-0.0176308099,
-0.0018899824,
0.0042003342,
0.0207514353,
-0.0272082333,
-0.0919584408,
-0.0101149185,
0.0083639696,
0.0066129584,
-0.0619188286,
-0.0441503748,
0.0011019497,
-0.0651901886,
0.0240087528,
0.0094365887,
-0.0797449872,
-0.0205415245,
-0.0607534014,
0.0012959328,
-0.0604311638,
-0.0092858514,
-0.0442314111,
0.0135752438,
-0.0307584498,
0.0028918469,
-0.0699699447,
-0.0279271044,
0.0079810861,
-0.0224213172,
0.0581256039,
0.019942116,
0.0120459292,
-0.0202520564,
0.0032141958,
0.0802111104,
0.0152484505,
-0.0356015936,
-0.0200101696,
0.0442350879,
0.0085958382,
-0.0158697143,
-0.0451452062,
0.048665341,
-0.0130918082,
-0.000168931,
-0.0115796924,
0.0952459872,
0.0260254331,
-0.0555396378,
-0.0503632203,
0.0228915811,
0.0223587137,
0.054410141,
0.0335533284,
-0.064353928,
-0.0136328656,
-0.0601973571,
-0.0406621285,
-0.0018624652,
-0.0672738552,
-0.0377036445,
0.0089833951,
-0.0216016285,
-0.0181177594,
0.0083644846,
0.0370661505,
-0.0341256037,
0.0274544246,
0.0142701501,
0.004944352,
-0.0070539326,
0.0328534804,
0.0118005369,
-0.0245753657,
0.0314832442,
-0.0576332323,
-0.0053469678,
0.0087528545,
0.0207201168,
-0.0260236878,
0.0411740243,
-0.0561481267,
-0.0818569139,
0.0290230326,
0.0663692728,
0.0189285539,
-0.017409157,
-0.0223223921,
-0.0434872359,
0.053301923,
0.0596366674,
-0.0383379683,
-0.0229249597,
0.0165906604,
-0.0009762583,
0.0357781649,
0.0313854627,
-0.0366903245,
0.0495001897,
0.0266993567,
-0.0346403085,
-0.0579294488,
0.0126428353,
0.0276192501,
0.0255785231,
-0.0088586407,
0.012065012,
0.0028033152,
-0.0406808145,
-0.0303384084,
-0.0182952676,
-0.0188052841,
-0.0008600797,
0.015966149,
0.0736590847,
-0.0257391948,
-0.0629016981,
0.0326997191,
-0.0234329924,
0.0283768978,
-0.0478250533,
0.0240379795,
0.0067027356,
0.0018563882,
0.0778404102,
-0.0124614369,
-0.0283181369,
0.0338984579,
0.0196788944,
-0.000231844,
-0.0285845194,
0.0204718225,
-0.0058539612,
-0.001717496,
0.0189344268,
0.0095394449,
-0.028053375,
-0.0370242931,
-0.0038881067,
0.0329395719,
0.0357725285,
-0.0129658729,
0.0363219343,
-0.0326736569,
-0.0390866175,
-0.0215349831,
0.0127762407,
0.0061814464,
-0.0150602702,
0.0214172285,
0.0094955256,
-0.0411273688,
0.0146168284,
0.0363314413,
0.0065753199,
0.0139168082,
0.0296769571,
-0.0801867321,
-0.0053536328,
-0.0085448259,
-0.0203538369,
0.0194487292,
-0.0283098537,
0.0251296181,
-0.0505482778,
-0.0357194841,
-0.0164701082,
-0.0379904583,
0.018207062,
-0.0135036409,
-0.0203027613,
0.0304616597,
0.008988074,
0.0129182125,
-0.0362104811,
-0.021040976,
-0.020128049,
-0.0408556275,
0.0023545707,
-5.997084549e-33,
0.0224641785,
-0.0305162128,
-0.0335153937,
0.0514157228,
0.0032553209,
-0.0268429704,
0.0226862933,
0.0062029646,
0.0234277584,
0.0354900062,
0.0169163123,
0.0162395649,
-0.0185538214,
-0.0058900253,
0.0089704096,
-0.0261324048,
0.0408756509,
-0.0074816206,
-0.0309888069,
0.031903971,
0.035485208,
0.0159451514,
-0.006813515,
-0.0826837197,
0.0136640836,
0.0419208631,
-0.0068116733,
0.0068873805,
-0.0418053269,
0.0795302242,
-0.0028488815,
0.0971511975,
0.0336519592,
-0.0320000648,
0.0146954842,
0.026416475,
-0.0449668616,
0.0073038917,
0.0215657931,
-0.022239672,
-0.0073974556,
-0.0323528945,
0.0575426668,
0.0032904614,
-0.016185062,
-0.010657371,
0.0251718424,
-0.0260103028,
0.0001588573,
-0.0677749813,
-0.033206258,
0.0077168858,
-0.0411418118,
0.0001870362,
-0.0115106218,
0.0277628396,
0.0120574525,
0.0776721984,
-0.0507538207,
-0.0028549645,
-0.0207490996,
0.0083901584,
-0.0022409158,
-0.0243098047,
-0.0109960437,
0.0705618039,
-0.03369065,
0.071294792,
-0.0418075137,
0.0040602316,
-0.0346737802,
0.0149874371,
0.0636799335,
0.0360096544,
0.0007973028,
-0.0625235885,
-0.1211258397,
-0.003650374,
0.0411862284,
0.0346669331,
0.0547022298,
-0.0139936637,
-0.0069827596,
-0.0097269183,
-0.0132518336,
-0.0324845389,
-0.036072392,
-0.023078803,
0.002750173,
0.0213611182,
-0.0254111681,
-0.0506620593,
0.0039453367,
-0.0535630621,
-0.0358156525,
0.0650587156,
-0.0148454141,
-0.0021220038,
0.0256608259,
0.0383690111,
-0.0779403299,
0.0376546122,
0.0011946928,
-0.0492040403,
0.0128074875,
-0.0399002917,
0.0736814141,
0.0439411327,
-0.0735801011,
0.0078514069,
-0.0347666815,
0.0718610585,
0.0005461171,
0.0527769774,
0.0050563668,
0.008859138,
0.0327841789,
-0.0039905789,
0.0386499278,
0.0216861125,
0.0148721244,
-0.0170210078,
-0.026343694,
-0.0169754233,
-0.025573194,
-0.006209489,
-0.0227152742,
0.0623113662,
0.0297915414,
-0.0775200874,
0.0099844662,
-0.0570994839,
2.635e-7,
0.0567015857,
0.0626160279,
-0.0356256142,
0.0002752966,
0.0419140458,
-0.0055877129,
0.0083015012,
0.0225955434,
0.0029585594,
-0.0150749013,
0.0057975831,
0.0286988318,
0.0308289919,
0.0340354703,
-0.0487508513,
0.0043330989,
-0.0819522738,
-0.0105508231,
-0.065105997,
0.0075728577,
0.0116271684,
0.085606806,
0.0322674885,
-0.0225380473,
0.0013424896,
-0.0489264093,
0.0747079849,
-0.0573816709,
-0.0189259127,
0.0110375443,
0.0875252485,
0.0068292171,
-0.0048403633,
-0.0111878561,
-0.0019489316,
-0.0023802435,
-0.0117098046,
0.0586409979,
0.0197189208,
0.024020331,
0.0328263193,
-0.0464108288,
0.0203514844,
-0.026951598,
0.0848148093,
-0.0127550587,
-0.003757654,
-0.0638485551,
-0.0162585843,
-0.0832098797,
0.0743189603,
-0.0441688783,
-0.0281413551,
-0.0094787674,
-0.0129382303,
0.0134383533,
0.0217623711,
-0.0543681905,
-0.0019632261,
-0.0001238253,
-0.0451066792,
-0.0766904727,
-0.0333528742,
0.019213507,
0.0202560537,
0.0003380339,
0.0438773222,
2.196341629e-34,
0.0417122692,
-0.0353994705,
0.0063177664,
-0.0429751128,
0.0246912614,
0.0290131476,
-0.0044337837,
-0.0091670286,
0.0084624095,
-0.0801494196,
0.0306543242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14509v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14509v2 | DeepSpeed Ulysses: System Optimizations for Enabling Training of Extreme Long Sequence Transformer Models | 2023-09-25T20:15:57 | 2023-10-04T16:51:13 | Sam Ade Jacobs, Masahiro Tanaka, Chengming Zhang, Minjia Zhang, Shuaiwen Leon Song, Samyam Rajbhandari, Yuxiong He | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC | Computation in a typical Transformer-based large language model (LLM) can be
characterized by batch size, hidden dimension, number of layers, and sequence
length. Until now, system works for accelerating LLM training have focused on
the first three dimensions: data parallelism for batch size, tensor parallelism
for hidden size and pipeline parallelism for model depth or layers. These
widely studied forms of parallelism are not targeted or optimized for long
sequence Transformer models. Given practical application needs for long
sequence LLM, renewed attentions are being drawn to sequence parallelism.
However, existing works in sequence parallelism are constrained by
memory-communication inefficiency, limiting their scalability to long sequence
large models. In this work, we introduce DeepSpeed-Ulysses, a novel, portable
and effective methodology for enabling highly efficient and scalable LLM
training with extremely long sequence length. DeepSpeed-Ulysses at its core
partitions input data along the sequence dimension and employs an efficient
all-to-all collective communication for attention computation. Theoretical
communication analysis shows that whereas other methods incur communication
overhead as sequence length increases, DeepSpeed-Ulysses maintains constant
communication volume when sequence length and compute devices are increased
proportionally. Furthermore, experimental evaluations show that
DeepSpeed-Ulysses trains 2.5x faster with 4x longer sequence length than the
existing method SOTA baseline. | [
0.0127309375,
0.0765312314,
0.0008977052,
0.0534828193,
-0.0243379995,
0.0125265671,
0.017578654,
-0.0134287532,
-0.0215302184,
-0.0216122363,
-0.0249055959,
-0.0826127902,
0.019193789,
0.0008949614,
0.0141623598,
-0.0284375641,
0.0291784871,
-0.0253336746,
-0.0504416972,
-0.0067287418,
-0.019949181,
-0.0122272223,
0.0200518612,
0.0235658213,
0.0124961091,
-0.0155771924,
-0.041840177,
-0.0234884452,
0.0179292429,
-0.0214951094,
0.0047878516,
0.0627068877,
0.0498169847,
0.0384234115,
0.0000020165,
0.0078675738,
-0.0013984712,
-0.0183122121,
-0.0041964673,
0.0400516354,
-0.0079688262,
-0.0337329805,
-0.0148473457,
0.0170792434,
0.0080364458,
-0.0203152504,
0.0411030613,
0.0137405712,
0.0495723672,
0.0713620931,
-0.0033122441,
-0.0690618083,
0.0700860992,
-0.0825528428,
-0.0121658426,
-0.0308969412,
0.0183626823,
-0.0483688191,
-0.0023039582,
0.0149146607,
-0.0326188058,
0.0317395553,
0.0488642119,
0.0074179932,
0.0067898734,
0.0172399376,
-0.0108777238,
-0.0522031188,
-0.0110229412,
0.0626163408,
-0.0425792448,
-0.0152406124,
-0.0047374428,
0.0081780776,
-0.0032190927,
-0.0298644342,
-0.0234864857,
0.0463903658,
0.0179603677,
0.0000590146,
0.0086116511,
-0.0200869981,
0.0412594154,
-0.0203436445,
-0.0521434695,
0.0131893242,
0.0280734226,
-0.0081060845,
-0.0405473784,
-0.0166697968,
-0.022051692,
-0.0382681228,
0.0143639604,
0.0365352109,
-0.0341053754,
0.0019385264,
-0.0246502757,
-0.0783227012,
0.0099084591,
-0.0436635464,
0.0568860397,
0.031548284,
-0.0224851463,
0.0354548804,
-0.0443527177,
0.0579412952,
-0.0305648074,
-0.0069926386,
-0.0209827479,
0.0062081427,
0.0056956988,
0.0197256673,
-0.0336561836,
0.010128431,
-0.0494926833,
-0.0311302897,
-0.0281055663,
0.0131737916,
0.0103775524,
-0.0166410822,
0.0380317084,
0.001261598,
-0.0378383808,
-0.0052836202,
0.0272230487,
0.0750216171,
-0.0067521608,
-0.0140040359,
0.0091554336,
-0.0394370556,
-0.0370150395,
0.0276796967,
0.0081927599,
-0.011485653,
0.0240011401,
0.0669254735,
-0.0113075515,
-0.0813071132,
-0.0522784218,
0.0276429746,
-0.0249692891,
-0.0609860048,
0.0124811893,
-0.0676253289,
0.0409103446,
0.0075419093,
0.0208659712,
0.0090390211,
0.0170383733,
0.0260588285,
0.0079353694,
0.0384443961,
0.0476321988,
-0.0053714542,
0.0243434887,
0.018007597,
0.0255551413,
0.0405498222,
0.0367954485,
0.0413155779,
-0.0002679035,
-0.0364882089,
-0.0101830941,
0.0535782948,
0.0190835316,
-0.0012962985,
-0.0322247706,
0.0021685455,
0.015676327,
0.0273423363,
0.0375841781,
0.0714279637,
-0.0250914115,
-0.0467884354,
0.0560259931,
0.0478424281,
0.0214355998,
0.0321222059,
0.0391956829,
0.0217104778,
-0.0327759199,
-0.008110363,
-0.0159217343,
0.0570000559,
0.0531446896,
0.0270194765,
0.0579620302,
0.0736438558,
-0.0485904142,
0.0186687857,
-0.0195853896,
-0.0237271618,
0.0013738435,
0.0092592342,
0.0377497263,
0.0013316979,
-0.075544022,
0.0972172618,
0.0298399646,
-0.0517032482,
-0.0168512892,
-0.0193770435,
0.0156816375,
0.0474987291,
0.0000924784,
0.0103596039,
-0.0072411895,
-0.0205176286,
0.0040598642,
0.0420814976,
-0.0176151842,
0.0108827269,
-0.0071847276,
-0.0567854531,
0.0015796029,
0.0302513763,
-0.0158534646,
0.0350294411,
0.054800991,
-0.0109781725,
0.0423256606,
0.0373557061,
-0.0396617018,
0.0147621278,
-0.0695117041,
-0.0104801347,
-0.0182974413,
0.0162033979,
0.0457703285,
-0.0002080148,
-0.0032885505,
0.0032693439,
0.0666908249,
-0.038001541,
-0.0094406242,
-0.024462387,
-0.0885253102,
-0.0010234081,
0.0256492663,
-0.0161355231,
0.0075020776,
0.0946599394,
-0.0218933169,
-0.0601592325,
0.0302692559,
-0.0678031892,
0.0120495129,
-0.0197762921,
0.046270486,
0.0312589854,
0.0547388867,
-0.0330329724,
0.0051808888,
-0.0395506024,
0.0074196211,
-0.0039142952,
0.0027510193,
-0.0242883749,
-0.0261846669,
-0.0290690623,
0.0411404222,
0.0128031047,
-0.0189168658,
-0.0064821285,
-0.0327516533,
-0.0076127267,
-0.043143291,
-0.0638157427,
0.0136470301,
-0.0531530902,
0.0271586254,
0.0006099654,
0.0440021232,
0.022196658,
0.0123733217,
-0.016590286,
0.0571824312,
0.0085143624,
0.00698508,
-0.0048120986,
-0.0076012858,
-0.0609423853,
-0.0252171699,
-0.0484491102,
0.025856955,
0.0405626446,
-0.017447358,
-0.0335106328,
-0.0589049906,
-0.0458272099,
0.0159843005,
0.0548759215,
-0.0407772474,
-0.0515443385,
-0.0180556159,
-0.0210100506,
0.0502156727,
0.0622298829,
0.0473432802,
0.0021222262,
-0.0015274951,
0.0098337606,
0.0147991143,
0.0254207924,
-0.0465514548,
-0.0206809212,
-0.0585092381,
-0.0040597543,
-0.041871991,
0.1048453376,
-0.0509661324,
-0.0019472408,
-0.0622501336,
-0.0640235916,
0.0170849394,
-0.0066555552,
0.0344370566,
-0.01657339,
-0.0324708074,
-0.0198721811,
-0.0076118154,
-0.0397364162,
0.0389725715,
-0.06210576,
-0.0316108912,
-0.0406588092,
-0.0342545807,
-0.0427018516,
0.0759496018,
0.0415121019,
0.0217769761,
-0.0343353786,
-0.0187261663,
-0.0169593673,
0.0511940606,
-0.0530864932,
-0.0028201574,
0.0669512153,
-0.0057752789,
0.0073788138,
-0.0475726239,
-0.0446881652,
-0.0122684669,
0.0249793753,
-0.011996829,
0.0310292188,
0.0788888559,
-0.0782738626,
-0.0530183911,
0.042263031,
0.0450221486,
0.0855646804,
-0.0058698808,
0.0225687064,
-0.0263551231,
0.0321487524,
0.0435159877,
-0.0013199619,
0.0269843545,
-0.0214236118,
0.0105860652,
0.0632061809,
0.0390376225,
0.0100371679,
-0.0361097939,
-0.0375888608,
0.0395883359,
-0.0317287073,
-0.0039141644,
0.0097091282,
0.0262689572,
-0.0700178593,
-0.0116233891,
0.0789060667,
-0.0013474195,
-0.0638375431,
0.0247925129,
0.0511742756,
0.0229174681,
-0.0060708071,
0.006344758,
-0.0626871809,
-0.0209447555,
0.0041229972,
-0.007557062,
0.0269571859,
-0.0102783022,
-0.0127572399,
-0.0858740956,
0.0026939693,
-0.0015428017,
-0.0162166245,
-0.0090281423,
-0.0604804866,
-0.0246559903,
-0.0198134854,
0.0369169675,
0.0413788632,
-0.0043269182,
-0.0257284697,
0.0166749582,
0.0264437422,
-0.0188807659,
0.0388416313,
-0.0127333216,
0.001344171,
0.0142762158,
-0.022959277,
-0.00095808,
-0.073226884,
0.0403814651,
0.0111952275,
0.025415631,
0.0157089755,
-0.0019841744,
-0.0349344239,
-0.0387041569,
-0.000099962,
0.0322869793,
-0.0454855822,
0.0260504447,
-0.0187838785,
0.0795090422,
0.0174157768,
-0.0147445714,
0.0130568631,
-0.0107007129,
-0.0267703123,
0.0601988994,
0.0172409806,
-0.0485894009,
-0.0096312677,
0.0109985983,
-0.0149995722,
-0.0246722586,
-0.0159830805,
-0.0124952346,
0.0470777489,
-0.0592107736,
-0.0448241904,
-0.0092890011,
0.0022451314,
0.0245954189,
-0.0009054792,
-0.034259256,
0.0395668447,
0.0031944995,
-0.0722713768,
0.0364897288,
-0.026593212,
0.0027714046,
-0.0960591361,
0.0184351839,
0.0469344035,
0.0168954823,
-0.00474856,
0.0517094135,
-0.1425505728,
-0.0800666884,
0.0151713509,
0.0311001558,
0.0097377067,
0.0346004106,
0.0455403812,
-0.0277658422,
0.0276479516,
0.001640761,
-0.0552072339,
0.0522245131,
0.0176201146,
-0.0581695959,
-0.0071884198,
0.0438750461,
0.0070319315,
0.0172949173,
0.0171493609,
0.0288385544,
-0.014770844,
-0.0398741737,
-0.0211377237,
-0.0174191762,
0.0378572419,
0.0101325223,
0.037626382,
0.0070270533,
0.0805749595,
-0.0039144801,
0.030110443,
-0.0519273467,
-0.0090006161,
0.0140233543,
0.0091435527,
0.0188279692,
-0.002078508,
0.0474075563,
-0.0448481739,
-0.0177407861,
0.046268072,
-0.0318790451,
-0.0264499802,
0.0411173999,
-0.0105331577,
-0.0047322842,
-0.0174506567,
-0.002823879,
0.0259047151,
-0.0197725166,
0.0468748584,
0.0072225169,
0.0178670231,
-0.0170266349,
0.0177020635,
-0.0443618037,
-0.0645234808,
-0.0360917673,
0.0211757123,
0.0721333474,
0.0020260147,
0.0394123197,
-0.0210656188,
-0.0071395827,
-0.024555359,
0.0189320575,
-0.0518500954,
-0.0239641257,
0.0073909834,
0.0332915969,
-0.0045092274,
0.0232540797,
0.0718679279,
0.0055925939,
0.0169566274,
0.026740633,
0.0088344254,
-0.0273212176,
-0.0522890165,
-0.0003674577,
0.0157873835,
-0.0226551574,
-0.0094122859,
0.0296327826,
-0.0489395186,
0.0330799222,
-0.0223849863,
0.0085269818,
-0.038280271,
0.0301807523,
0.0430710353,
0.0004791092,
-0.0332064182,
-0.015938038,
0.0208409224,
0.0170305315,
-0.0240739826,
-0.0038424584,
-6.629372308e-33,
-0.0098678144,
0.0018644594,
0.0309285596,
0.0143926162,
-0.0630207658,
0.0329870433,
-0.0335022323,
-0.0057907407,
-0.006221571,
-0.000967571,
-0.023002293,
0.0248098411,
-0.0009971503,
0.065035671,
0.0167489965,
0.0088260621,
0.054019548,
-0.0026264847,
-0.0048309271,
0.0417546108,
0.0279575679,
0.0389307775,
0.0523492396,
0.003723471,
-0.0344221219,
-0.0192250982,
0.0438433364,
-0.0087462086,
-0.0088051287,
0.0260754377,
-0.0255588181,
0.0090055633,
0.0043712761,
-0.1261592358,
-0.0174792614,
0.0313154049,
-0.0648388863,
0.0322072692,
-0.0097824009,
0.0106336484,
-0.0331144631,
-0.0092067458,
0.040778473,
0.0129278488,
0.0039368952,
-0.04696583,
0.0008981915,
-0.0098490203,
-0.03935441,
-0.0144008556,
-0.0267886166,
0.0262465291,
0.0085426485,
0.0223827772,
0.042061042,
0.0144529156,
-0.0242418516,
0.036927361,
-0.0651612878,
-0.0062558758,
0.0187865235,
0.0813996121,
0.0638550222,
0.0327677652,
0.0351167396,
0.018432539,
0.0559951663,
-0.0006714013,
-0.0072902991,
0.0006241691,
0.0098655699,
0.0199420713,
0.0621942356,
-0.0135202063,
0.0081531396,
0.0138022294,
-0.0765502453,
-0.0508067384,
0.0041859695,
0.0442908444,
0.051195506,
0.0201352257,
-0.0035310388,
-0.0085856812,
-0.0149705149,
0.0298534948,
-0.0113694631,
-0.0030554514,
0.0088813212,
0.0494104847,
0.0130864866,
0.002662434,
0.0528477095,
-0.0179894287,
0.0074862358,
0.0448972955,
0.0165937189,
0.0257285126,
-0.0077992482,
0.0065165381,
-0.0843682587,
-0.0208352972,
-0.0130882356,
0.0011116001,
-0.001103928,
-0.0164119489,
0.042285379,
0.0292652957,
-0.0513537936,
-0.0381089747,
-0.0346096009,
0.0376225784,
-0.0111650527,
0.0472241901,
0.0694412217,
-0.0072856289,
-0.0044162464,
0.0787405297,
-0.0316961855,
-0.0096766809,
-0.0031368278,
0.0064172768,
0.0289105624,
0.0257158503,
-0.0273655169,
0.0134139368,
-0.0555163436,
0.0200007297,
0.0362997204,
-0.0729605854,
-0.0270382501,
0.0184872095,
2.722e-7,
-0.0223864969,
0.0164467543,
0.0357890502,
0.0159764793,
0.0316613726,
-0.0037678005,
0.0240803547,
0.0481677875,
0.0172888804,
0.0187148154,
0.010654659,
0.0324938446,
0.0352532454,
-0.0232261941,
-0.0952207968,
-0.0406346247,
-0.0859945416,
0.0328649953,
-0.0343735367,
-0.0311501175,
-0.0144014377,
0.1102201715,
-0.0010843721,
-0.0190741904,
0.0266472045,
-0.0190075841,
0.0200152788,
-0.0085796965,
0.0100011462,
0.0137650762,
-0.0041784327,
0.0021482827,
-0.0237579979,
0.0150764855,
-0.0301048253,
0.0108112339,
-0.0356183425,
0.0812295377,
0.0023999424,
-0.0226915739,
0.0491239391,
0.0203806646,
-0.0602100417,
-0.0525927991,
0.0283867996,
-0.0659606829,
-0.0255815741,
-0.0336620249,
-0.0114988964,
-0.0160014406,
-0.0162792392,
0.0075694281,
0.0494996123,
0.0275144596,
0.0223973095,
-0.0269249063,
0.0199042019,
-0.0910464451,
-0.0049467636,
0.0070257266,
-0.0644340888,
-0.0336198173,
-0.0842685997,
-0.0444433875,
0.0088712312,
-0.0133789396,
-0.0301571675,
2.760410629e-34,
0.0228679497,
-0.015070946,
-0.0031565584,
0.0200601798,
0.0219254568,
-0.0527130291,
-0.0381665528,
0.0140946051,
-0.0239965301,
-0.1103862971,
-0.0660396144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14495v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14495v1 | Classifying token frequencies using angular Minkowski $p$-distance | 2023-09-25T19:45:11 | 2023-09-25T19:45:11 | Oliver Urs Lenz, Chris Cornelis | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Angular Minkowski $p$-distance is a dissimilarity measure that is obtained by
replacing Euclidean distance in the definition of cosine dissimilarity with
other Minkowski $p$-distances. Cosine dissimilarity is frequently used with
datasets containing token frequencies, and angular Minkowski $p$-distance may
potentially be an even better choice for certain tasks. In a case study based
on the 20-newsgroups dataset, we evaluate clasification performance for
classical weighted nearest neighbours, as well as fuzzy rough nearest
neighbours. In addition, we analyse the relationship between the hyperparameter
$p$, the dimensionality $m$ of the dataset, the number of neighbours $k$, the
choice of weights and the choice of classifier. We conclude that it is possible
to obtain substantially higher classification performance with angular
Minkowski $p$-distance with suitable values for $p$ than with classical cosine
dissimilarity. | [
-0.0321444124,
0.025898369,
-0.0354078822,
0.0040620598,
-0.0536291301,
0.0182970371,
0.0496190116,
0.0564678349,
-0.0663603768,
-0.0053852429,
-0.0071004741,
-0.035477493,
0.0480578244,
-0.0226110294,
-0.0074324124,
-0.0497378707,
0.0122791398,
0.0043441039,
0.0659397691,
-0.0266823489,
-0.0269747917,
-0.0330573618,
-0.0354859307,
0.0467761047,
-0.06501735,
-0.0108652199,
0.0164894089,
-0.0341894329,
0.0153816519,
-0.0130979614,
0.0193152688,
0.0489367954,
-0.0221906509,
0.0703573003,
0.0000015895,
-0.0521508977,
-0.0267848503,
0.0133478791,
0.0112427101,
-0.0403453782,
0.0483551025,
-0.0114005646,
0.0028377282,
-0.0168909058,
0.0003344251,
-0.0743704811,
0.0309750848,
0.0408294536,
0.0253961384,
0.0553348586,
-0.0087321466,
-0.0279347356,
0.0050629387,
0.0168609247,
0.0347796343,
0.0285159331,
0.0243317857,
-0.0217902325,
-0.0245859344,
-0.0363068692,
-0.0099424273,
0.0072570234,
-0.0071356362,
0.0580587238,
0.0331108272,
0.0443400145,
-0.0756601095,
0.0237467177,
-0.0005650532,
0.0057181884,
-0.0666476786,
-0.0520582497,
0.0271267258,
0.039530959,
-0.0321563557,
0.041739177,
-0.0187572744,
-0.0474052057,
-0.0239781644,
0.0171284303,
-0.0544604659,
0.0591050386,
-0.042140305,
-0.0146858562,
0.0090030627,
0.044466801,
-0.0088035539,
-0.0135718584,
-0.0006087496,
-0.0246385206,
-0.0286052898,
-0.0083090765,
0.0411947928,
-0.0009841633,
0.0126221692,
-0.0420777164,
-0.0011657572,
0.0412916467,
0.0623936392,
-0.0739455074,
-0.017407177,
0.0041262922,
-0.0102734761,
0.0191152506,
-0.0837523639,
-0.0170203578,
0.0522530191,
0.032097958,
-0.0116606224,
0.0075024562,
-0.0753112733,
0.0292246435,
-0.0261908323,
0.0382026024,
0.0406185761,
-0.0252339952,
-0.0637792274,
-0.0035838657,
0.0240683351,
0.0157784913,
-0.009394451,
-0.0264630672,
0.0367372446,
0.0443788171,
-0.0167584606,
-0.0504763983,
-0.0580641665,
0.0333962254,
-0.0515060984,
0.0094199898,
0.0492769517,
-0.0131758712,
0.0268125627,
0.0034609854,
0.0274210516,
0.0093337484,
0.0405628793,
-0.0378796905,
-0.005155141,
0.0225922726,
-0.0324273854,
-0.0122157438,
-0.0438072123,
-0.0911886692,
0.0160264876,
0.0359261669,
-0.0118182423,
0.0219761804,
-0.0291100629,
-0.0266902447,
-0.0158159789,
0.052497264,
-0.008866298,
0.0479983911,
0.0664614961,
-0.0414962918,
-0.0140595473,
0.0393780842,
-0.0029117723,
0.0121244527,
0.0700361207,
-0.0248408895,
-0.0243732966,
-0.0160963684,
-0.0342488624,
-0.0283485986,
-0.039238736,
-0.0209877398,
-0.0096878856,
-0.0372219868,
0.0153076043,
0.0360055454,
-0.0270979982,
-0.04656782,
-0.0035288313,
0.0656644627,
0.0829633474,
-0.0047987788,
-0.0345545933,
0.0071109454,
-0.033266332,
0.0079918485,
0.0083463984,
-0.0121060181,
-0.0084558381,
0.0079412861,
0.0527354479,
0.0233136155,
-0.0202263873,
-0.0070694746,
0.0051994324,
-0.0365357138,
0.0003228493,
-0.0402707532,
0.0468346551,
-0.0510388762,
0.0518913567,
0.0012540958,
0.0593786612,
-0.0051610391,
-0.0318392068,
0.0112384306,
0.0547010638,
-0.0047863252,
-0.0230699852,
-0.082838729,
-0.0084907282,
0.0140085919,
-0.0221037548,
-0.0478384122,
0.0383098125,
-0.0136256833,
0.0111033386,
-0.0241818931,
-0.0009790771,
0.10166049,
0.0267572775,
-0.0067966813,
0.0162450559,
0.0487055629,
0.0157855637,
-0.0253724717,
-0.0388667546,
-0.0116156703,
0.091780372,
0.0188875832,
0.0147290463,
0.0618450455,
0.0107382089,
0.0437728912,
-0.00627751,
-0.0313973054,
0.0209537279,
-0.0554236285,
0.0158025734,
-0.0440542698,
0.0067804675,
-0.011962018,
0.0508709736,
-0.0312780477,
0.0119352927,
-0.0227871966,
-0.0046465942,
-0.0374914147,
0.0290136859,
-0.0299267285,
0.025625892,
-0.0547739044,
0.0442005917,
-0.06835071,
0.0078936238,
-0.0401422493,
0.0544725619,
0.0463951603,
0.0730760992,
-0.0800492167,
-0.0217069574,
0.0850308165,
-0.0140041187,
-0.0071349205,
-0.0202279724,
-0.0488986857,
0.000738167,
0.0536937192,
-0.0055128406,
0.0143407108,
-0.0453339666,
-0.0194564071,
-0.0487239994,
0.0008479328,
0.0350102484,
-0.0221298207,
-0.0025811612,
-0.015775172,
-0.0078537269,
-0.0105451113,
0.00467003,
-0.0050772275,
0.0063219694,
0.0398503616,
-0.0086053293,
-0.0885898024,
0.0062226485,
-0.0332733355,
0.0183991157,
0.001525101,
0.0106514022,
-0.010105622,
-0.0097323237,
-0.0225045234,
-0.0854367167,
-0.011962045,
0.0396326222,
-0.0187196862,
0.039206937,
0.0176803395,
-0.0156094991,
0.0174408406,
0.0302412882,
-0.0584710203,
0.013565232,
0.0556638166,
-0.0365332738,
0.0028252357,
-0.0454907157,
0.0512664951,
0.0307622701,
-0.0255528539,
0.0173013229,
-0.0097181704,
0.0057604965,
-0.045212239,
-0.0308734681,
0.0501323193,
0.0044228076,
0.0143394377,
-0.0428228006,
-0.0076397411,
-0.0082038855,
0.0223001931,
0.0150556006,
-0.0347567014,
0.0249037817,
-0.0287144594,
0.0521746576,
-0.0276007243,
-0.0699192882,
-0.0438802466,
-0.0234106183,
-0.0024963925,
0.025153378,
-0.011855619,
-0.0388701446,
0.0261108633,
-0.009521543,
0.0524956323,
-0.0241605286,
0.0529256836,
0.0550667308,
0.035834454,
-0.008729253,
-0.0166489333,
-0.0103325732,
-0.0116333775,
0.0438663512,
-0.0130647328,
-0.0025179025,
-0.0360439904,
0.0130974306,
0.0703124255,
0.0147524457,
0.0239153579,
-0.0050580222,
0.0093945572,
-0.0164635032,
0.0327492356,
-0.0229360145,
-0.0344677866,
0.0095397588,
-0.0043663774,
-0.0082896138,
-0.0144087877,
0.0759530813,
0.0153494878,
-0.0345425755,
-0.0305605419,
-0.0062938528,
-0.0276365113,
-0.030486986,
-0.0078210048,
0.0275615789,
0.0572900213,
0.0049234489,
0.1116351113,
0.0354591496,
-0.0622358248,
0.0317081735,
0.0030123817,
0.0332835503,
0.0270179529,
-0.0106695574,
0.0301608462,
0.0271547437,
0.0166903585,
0.008720845,
-0.0522627719,
-0.0514960736,
0.0588754639,
-0.0201771632,
-0.0327717811,
0.010077063,
-0.0876820162,
-0.0922569111,
-0.0650822148,
0.0037197308,
0.0193084348,
-0.0228157621,
-0.0331426784,
-0.0033744979,
-0.0077810274,
0.0313717574,
-0.0564719886,
-0.0087750582,
-0.0042187846,
-0.0464830995,
0.0303835012,
-0.0666056052,
0.0330612287,
-0.0346275717,
-0.0619114563,
-0.0093900459,
-0.032214094,
0.003008401,
-0.0260184761,
0.0261468105,
0.0630289614,
-0.012511556,
0.0153273297,
-0.0377467573,
-0.0069183782,
-0.0122472886,
0.0194763262,
0.0611351244,
-0.0108766472,
-0.0107883494,
0.0093242228,
0.0270737559,
-0.0115749519,
0.027958164,
0.0328509174,
0.0224289224,
-0.0141374646,
0.0027724197,
0.0337874256,
0.0208405945,
0.029583903,
-0.0420813337,
-0.0472000688,
-0.0332500003,
-0.0802132413,
0.0491884016,
0.0160360746,
0.0776847526,
-0.044631958,
0.017656384,
0.016460577,
-0.0200098697,
-0.0164254531,
-0.0257976744,
0.0330806784,
0.0063505759,
-0.0397106186,
0.0066913138,
0.0176379029,
0.0499185808,
-0.0514544062,
-0.050318595,
-0.0192434397,
-0.0331782177,
0.0151792513,
-0.0400473848,
0.0213718638,
-0.0051724422,
-0.0071585681,
-0.0299778599,
0.0617641546,
0.0644148812,
-0.0447042584,
-0.0006289142,
0.0068220133,
-0.0321422331,
-0.0160127655,
0.0210486017,
-0.0214057826,
0.0538839847,
0.0156152304,
-0.0619172268,
-0.065294601,
-0.0022876295,
-0.01951354,
0.0357022434,
0.0601106286,
-0.0030409971,
-0.0703765303,
0.0056096036,
0.0102728922,
0.0208203923,
0.034395311,
0.0529613569,
-0.0357327238,
0.0022056994,
0.0270380974,
-0.0394617096,
-0.0158185456,
0.0129262051,
0.0607449636,
0.0263554286,
0.0385612547,
-0.0333147943,
0.0650461465,
-0.0110193342,
-0.0336703435,
-0.0405930281,
-0.0320751667,
0.0255673006,
0.0324741565,
-0.0329954401,
-0.0187579617,
0.0059755384,
0.0627292097,
-0.0300154649,
0.0271327402,
-0.0352380984,
-0.0119897174,
0.0047498439,
-0.0122916354,
-0.018086154,
-0.0298500992,
-0.0444704331,
-0.0380593687,
-0.0031739534,
-0.0124535812,
-0.0176707376,
-0.0211009681,
0.0268414207,
-0.0200447887,
0.0207931623,
-0.0155452825,
0.0702686608,
0.078577958,
-0.0590671636,
-0.0445097573,
0.0091755418,
-0.04512427,
-0.0479411073,
0.027407486,
0.0359152891,
0.0322062857,
-0.0096552325,
0.0181721691,
-0.0241074637,
-0.0168684516,
0.048194129,
-0.033378493,
0.0054749441,
0.0383295193,
0.0281271674,
0.0182812009,
-0.0093014315,
0.0062706443,
-0.0061180042,
-0.0149554573,
0.0332207903,
0.0064617926,
0.0056769131,
-5.477546168e-33,
0.0125059215,
-0.0059102918,
-0.0545648225,
0.0348365121,
-0.0308677182,
0.0060269502,
0.0719052032,
-0.0481180176,
0.0078778053,
-0.0335024819,
-0.0056772553,
-0.0168683082,
0.0239338297,
0.007903982,
0.0151037984,
-0.0272186734,
0.0312618501,
0.0254465025,
0.0059027178,
0.0304843243,
0.0523501039,
0.0128920432,
0.0148208747,
-0.0935421884,
-0.0352667868,
0.0611776374,
0.0168668665,
0.0306890346,
0.0425619595,
0.0358229019,
0.0031114649,
0.0541679189,
0.011028816,
-0.0032225454,
0.0154053476,
-0.0088613592,
-0.0341194123,
-0.0635451078,
-0.0276725199,
0.0232581887,
0.1160638183,
-0.0250410419,
0.0332886279,
-0.0056577385,
-0.073670812,
-0.0082056131,
0.0309049673,
-0.0456735119,
-0.0600798391,
-0.0130019281,
0.0212390255,
0.0607404821,
-0.0200909209,
0.0207343418,
0.008466728,
0.0010249047,
-0.0309907552,
-0.012046393,
-0.0806042105,
0.0286365896,
-0.0165535025,
0.049808953,
-0.0417329296,
0.0079711797,
0.0110916654,
0.0481921472,
0.0770796314,
-0.0225047842,
0.0486550629,
0.0324270315,
0.0103336731,
0.0158919841,
0.0354876481,
-0.0039210748,
0.070828408,
-0.079073377,
-0.0493762791,
0.0444704555,
-0.0010758837,
-0.0037398217,
0.0246783011,
0.0232783165,
-0.0719606802,
-0.0064460882,
0.022374941,
-0.0339984037,
-0.0155113107,
-0.0307770725,
-0.0467430688,
-0.0064163087,
-0.0194955301,
0.0195885897,
-0.0217118338,
0.0099932188,
-0.0453193896,
-0.0558263063,
0.0529413149,
0.0413600914,
0.0222852752,
-0.00899137,
-0.0246921852,
-0.0655556917,
0.0110243112,
-0.0026354068,
0.0403274223,
-0.036202576,
0.0685710981,
0.0103003643,
-0.0901302248,
-0.0057135513,
0.0749407783,
-0.0223683752,
-0.0020467308,
-0.03486057,
0.0282968767,
-0.0002403621,
0.0387909785,
0.0314015225,
0.0167415868,
-0.0360501483,
0.0303241871,
0.0005212609,
-0.029787818,
0.0189754572,
-0.019448543,
0.0102318265,
-0.0141494516,
-0.0138719631,
0.0287625585,
-0.0051662317,
-0.0132143367,
-0.0388761498,
2.476e-7,
0.0125739668,
0.0352394581,
0.0467876233,
-0.0354492143,
-0.0106261661,
-0.0107063884,
-0.0165520888,
0.0338290632,
-0.0130881034,
0.0359829515,
0.0292548221,
-0.0178565215,
0.0183067825,
0.0471106172,
-0.0543636978,
0.0548993908,
-0.0426956601,
-0.0444351733,
-0.0759552345,
0.0874443874,
0.022224877,
0.072057642,
-0.0066261478,
-0.0272000488,
0.0130684888,
-0.0573354922,
-0.021471845,
-0.0398521461,
0.012290135,
0.0199830569,
0.0564306378,
-0.0729345679,
0.0640603602,
0.0753163472,
0.0350262448,
0.0436895415,
0.0464043841,
-0.0263460949,
0.0156197809,
-0.0037906526,
-0.012763435,
-0.0080094794,
0.0087893065,
-0.0659321547,
0.0660044253,
-0.0034196221,
-0.0043312418,
0.0198462289,
0.0179266408,
0.0129721677,
0.0290253647,
0.0019510854,
-0.0328708403,
0.0448950529,
0.016155906,
-0.0256648343,
0.0178195052,
-0.0039048307,
0.0337406844,
0.0149267372,
-0.023473803,
-0.0534090176,
0.0110662766,
0.0323380195,
0.0361425057,
0.0474453792,
0.0152659146,
2.024798892e-34,
0.0183024444,
0.0368492827,
-0.0013582192,
-0.0132481949,
-0.0015742432,
-0.0353384055,
-0.0107389269,
-0.0001890886,
0.0223670769,
-0.0397493206,
0.0313145854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14488v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14488v1 | When Automated Assessment Meets Automated Content Generation: Examining Text Quality in the Era of GPTs | 2023-09-25T19:32:18 | 2023-09-25T19:32:18 | Marialena Bevilacqua, Kezia Oketch, Ruiyang Qin, Will Stamey, Xinyuan Zhang, Yi Gan, Kai Yang, Ahmed Abbasi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The use of machine learning (ML) models to assess and score textual data has
become increasingly pervasive in an array of contexts including natural
language processing, information retrieval, search and recommendation, and
credibility assessment of online content. A significant disruption at the
intersection of ML and text are text-generating large-language models such as
generative pre-trained transformers (GPTs). We empirically assess the
differences in how ML-based scoring models trained on human content assess the
quality of content generated by humans versus GPTs. To do so, we propose an
analysis framework that encompasses essay scoring ML-models, human and
ML-generated essays, and a statistical model that parsimoniously considers the
impact of type of respondent, prompt genre, and the ML model used for
assessment model. A rich testbed is utilized that encompasses 18,460
human-generated and GPT-based essays. Results of our benchmark analysis reveal
that transformer pretrained language models (PLMs) more accurately score human
essay quality as compared to CNN/RNN and feature-based ML methods.
Interestingly, we find that the transformer PLMs tend to score GPT-generated
text 10-15\% higher on average, relative to human-authored documents.
Conversely, traditional deep learning and feature-based ML models score human
text considerably higher. Further analysis reveals that although the
transformer PLMs are exclusively fine-tuned on human text, they more
prominently attend to certain tokens appearing only in GPT-generated text,
possibly due to familiarity/overlap in pre-training. Our framework and results
have implications for text classification settings where automated scoring of
text is likely to be disrupted by generative AI. | [
0.0612149127,
0.0615316033,
-0.0010228584,
-0.0071686474,
-0.0272007361,
-0.0022371437,
0.0160603579,
0.0066185542,
-0.0050497246,
-0.0759311542,
-0.0091865696,
-0.0354795232,
-0.002920442,
0.0523978211,
0.0156140653,
-0.0235876124,
-0.0005494676,
0.0292334463,
0.0103302551,
0.0181501526,
0.0077249412,
0.0204687715,
0.03536731,
0.0345388502,
-0.0331211276,
-0.019290626,
0.0112607749,
0.0028040877,
0.0195973385,
0.0150418999,
0.0459769815,
0.0899034068,
-0.0287416242,
0.0508883186,
0.0000018734,
-0.0399617217,
0.0131085431,
-0.0032966044,
0.0098014418,
0.0357774645,
0.0654851571,
0.0344724618,
-0.02565974,
0.0329205655,
-0.0553858802,
-0.0256005283,
0.0181430299,
0.0605395809,
0.0568292327,
0.0728475824,
-0.0202200133,
0.0010238691,
0.062254265,
0.0020348269,
0.0030868403,
-0.0001023146,
-0.0042314087,
-0.0117816739,
-0.0251100063,
0.022869328,
-0.0092477398,
0.0287253335,
0.0383251384,
-0.05147136,
0.0251858626,
0.0223474819,
-0.0386555418,
-0.0084155826,
0.0194377955,
0.0431135558,
-0.0259702429,
-0.0359252132,
-0.006005201,
-0.0283893701,
0.0100328485,
0.0109550757,
-0.0113253091,
0.0379105024,
0.0016803164,
0.0013656177,
0.006442206,
-0.0039410936,
0.0249293186,
0.0341576077,
0.0075713503,
0.0220107529,
0.0192435309,
-0.0405072235,
0.0069378978,
0.0340556279,
-0.0039252061,
-0.0591371506,
0.0347505175,
0.0050600045,
-0.0161871407,
-0.0037063523,
-0.0457096659,
-0.0335050821,
0.0283392686,
-0.0049599977,
0.0245789941,
-0.0168152135,
-0.0110024074,
-0.004573259,
-0.0200658999,
0.0698910356,
0.01799649,
0.0367859863,
-0.0339717753,
0.0078066103,
-0.0399653502,
-0.038217444,
-0.0109941438,
0.0387501866,
0.0196596626,
0.0074166306,
-0.0702777281,
-0.0015310278,
-0.021762291,
-0.0016203898,
0.0080024861,
0.0530593507,
-0.0326857679,
0.0061492394,
-0.0480405092,
0.0291063506,
-0.0115206204,
0.0199919343,
0.0325787663,
-0.0400348082,
0.0336821824,
0.0355877727,
0.0441872515,
-0.0125947185,
0.0309772044,
0.0059446888,
-0.0098935477,
-0.0275233053,
-0.0167901907,
-0.0363976695,
-0.0267644208,
-0.0556743182,
0.0063065593,
-0.0580231436,
0.0075625558,
0.0085267825,
-0.0112844268,
-0.0425260365,
-0.0217087492,
0.0534091443,
0.000434653,
0.0076698982,
0.0379897058,
0.0165636763,
0.0412391983,
0.0047477442,
0.0194911864,
-0.0058078794,
0.0503561683,
0.0722754002,
0.0422309712,
-0.0193956885,
0.0713751242,
0.0356769115,
-0.0001499205,
-0.0201464277,
0.0406360403,
-0.011444441,
-0.0237777978,
0.0424826629,
0.0157109536,
0.0960143656,
-0.0063304771,
-0.0008630928,
0.1044540331,
0.040848542,
0.0223309137,
0.0561248101,
0.0671163499,
0.0416304916,
0.0261156615,
0.0456282385,
-0.0438763201,
0.0011045428,
-0.0060046851,
-0.0117659261,
0.0444539897,
0.0182731971,
0.0000411425,
-0.0759518221,
0.0031709303,
-0.0209998209,
-0.0096674254,
-0.0115844756,
0.0216744989,
0.0067770546,
-0.0705145374,
0.0026728429,
-0.0139465248,
-0.0830406174,
0.0418225788,
-0.0550796166,
0.0307146423,
0.0625051558,
0.0683439076,
0.0082903579,
0.0228305124,
-0.0401785523,
-0.0007693238,
0.0351503864,
0.03780476,
-0.0153578306,
-0.0257832482,
-0.0349708796,
-0.0241199899,
-0.0197133403,
-0.0046385224,
-0.0003886955,
0.0105557274,
0.0064318771,
0.0451088808,
-0.0191137381,
-0.106747441,
0.0474622697,
-0.0133040687,
-0.0445743129,
0.0306807328,
0.0146784643,
0.0011408821,
0.0294906721,
-0.0352665596,
0.0136613101,
0.0066392277,
-0.0154989334,
-0.0459619761,
-0.0371417254,
-0.0469636768,
0.0235385913,
0.0012887106,
-0.0701908246,
-0.0213657245,
0.0629249737,
-0.034111701,
-0.0258381739,
-0.03014604,
-0.0425176062,
-0.0174357668,
-0.0640726909,
-0.0111248996,
-0.0127087813,
-0.0005751345,
-0.032800287,
0.0320966579,
0.0173675939,
0.0361497253,
-0.0226896983,
-0.0132796941,
0.0219010469,
-0.0195565242,
-0.0314522274,
-0.0134468675,
-0.0167286918,
0.0475936905,
0.0580081902,
0.0180617608,
-0.0438250192,
-0.0406991988,
-0.0999424905,
-0.0013214148,
-0.0287371948,
0.0085198767,
0.0294740368,
-0.0332257003,
-0.0021986899,
0.042892836,
-0.0747358575,
-0.0615866408,
0.0409822054,
0.0181749649,
0.0487332083,
-0.0243036021,
0.0630119368,
-0.0232921056,
-0.0157057978,
-0.0253653433,
0.0432050005,
0.0660904869,
0.0221869256,
-0.0317865163,
0.0515414849,
-0.0098447632,
-0.0283756275,
0.0338460803,
-0.0558822267,
0.0046821246,
0.0026519219,
0.0612691492,
0.0607546791,
0.0478894562,
0.0197478961,
0.0227445345,
0.0241867211,
-0.0389661528,
-0.0174030401,
-0.0385873951,
-0.0123755001,
-0.0146105895,
-0.0423271582,
0.0377396941,
0.0212020893,
0.012040711,
-0.0323491991,
-0.0417038091,
0.0483426116,
-0.0326316506,
-0.0234509837,
0.0061082165,
-0.0111363614,
-0.0083597563,
0.0358946882,
-0.0159313791,
-0.0542801097,
0.051322829,
-0.0263351575,
0.0289920364,
-0.027747171,
0.0246421378,
-0.0064868177,
0.0284007043,
0.0362931266,
0.0137032578,
-0.0040897694,
-0.0023381945,
-0.0628915429,
0.0427763499,
0.0412888527,
-0.0521932021,
0.0219876319,
-0.0028741418,
-0.021256838,
-0.0012227175,
-0.0370776281,
-0.0390320458,
-0.0385957137,
0.0199145004,
0.0054811644,
0.0137198893,
-0.0079970546,
-0.0162614603,
-0.0363561846,
-0.0102595249,
0.0253807269,
-0.0491160527,
-0.0215678141,
0.0049376739,
0.0697487891,
0.0419156738,
-0.0120331235,
0.0287244245,
-0.0347602256,
-0.0004081424,
0.0468400344,
-0.0212743264,
0.020331474,
-0.0073980549,
-0.0264607947,
0.0096308012,
-0.0480978452,
-0.0226614568,
0.0199502129,
0.0344376341,
-0.0614468791,
-0.010037018,
0.1194453314,
0.0250705928,
-0.0355268233,
-0.0210428815,
0.0159942843,
-0.0114657655,
-0.0170252211,
0.0394137874,
-0.0735238492,
-0.0037347989,
-0.0108715026,
0.0327745155,
-0.0501611121,
-0.0122721558,
-0.0002383288,
-0.1107559204,
0.0523603782,
-0.0180336609,
-0.0120531451,
-0.0127735836,
-0.0432273708,
-0.0443199128,
-0.0269365385,
0.012874472,
-0.0277355462,
-0.0005820805,
0.024396142,
-0.0042709224,
-0.0300806593,
-0.046539627,
0.0134954499,
-0.0428834148,
0.0241694003,
0.0817642584,
0.0518907197,
-0.0306862835,
-0.0607825331,
0.0198886786,
-0.0061406028,
-0.0124152014,
0.0193382017,
0.0687611103,
-0.0179382507,
0.0228323881,
-0.0355031416,
0.0338799506,
-0.0223209299,
-0.014726406,
0.001798305,
0.0518415421,
-0.0023874955,
-0.0485952795,
-0.0376527198,
0.0028304383,
-0.0113208443,
0.0904356763,
0.0325741023,
-0.0736941621,
-0.0578390546,
-0.047930859,
0.0390071832,
-0.0734352767,
-0.048562862,
0.0250891857,
-0.0008388251,
-0.0232888106,
-0.0864969343,
-0.0812126026,
-0.0073034414,
-0.0273639951,
0.004523457,
-0.0385527276,
-0.0005887833,
-0.0133076757,
-0.0477029495,
0.0199892987,
-0.0142131196,
0.0012042091,
-0.0716426671,
-0.0128722172,
-0.0010850017,
-0.0412979275,
-0.0248328391,
-0.0080375662,
-0.055148989,
-0.0200360324,
0.0416249894,
0.0385175496,
0.0079369601,
0.0121207722,
0.0096103987,
-0.0590172559,
0.0770727843,
0.0620051436,
-0.0452397317,
0.0041816388,
0.0104093021,
-0.0259167571,
-0.0245293025,
0.0067477613,
-0.0214312002,
0.0349040069,
0.0241594445,
0.00132581,
0.0413178876,
-0.0370383747,
0.0225965232,
0.0294116586,
0.0540521592,
-0.0214633625,
-0.0011085364,
-0.0433212183,
-0.0163407065,
-0.0097178901,
-0.027482966,
-0.0287068263,
-0.0135383522,
0.0454827622,
0.0386179835,
-0.0456601307,
0.0541025475,
-0.0480545424,
0.0618144535,
-0.0612791106,
0.0042154845,
-0.0161735564,
0.0314207897,
0.0027405058,
-0.0049763634,
-0.0194188636,
0.0068678227,
0.0047343876,
0.0401021056,
-0.0010410607,
0.0348390229,
0.0075637451,
0.0402988195,
0.0433909148,
0.0475150235,
-0.0732954815,
0.0012216925,
-0.0739713833,
-0.0065200045,
0.0186567809,
-0.0323574506,
0.0311858542,
-0.021230083,
-0.0009488169,
-0.0453910306,
0.0228649918,
0.0284383297,
-0.0143680405,
-0.0152544025,
-0.0093574692,
-0.0134554598,
0.0052267467,
0.0630828217,
-0.0005826924,
0.0237260461,
-0.0049263109,
-0.0427073799,
-0.0154954838,
-0.0092197293,
0.0015659634,
-0.0118877152,
0.0163126923,
-0.0190637335,
-0.0348695219,
-0.0447246619,
0.0303271133,
0.0315447375,
0.0390817113,
-0.0288953092,
0.0248570181,
0.0777804852,
-0.0376106799,
0.0232977141,
-0.0642959848,
0.0051463903,
-0.0035196382,
-0.0209835768,
-0.0223217104,
-5.908833943e-33,
0.0152134774,
-0.0528052263,
-0.0069281007,
0.0398741849,
-0.0240407381,
0.0187724419,
-0.0232979897,
-0.0182647556,
0.0306323059,
0.0442854092,
-0.0201989282,
0.0173787922,
-0.0057524396,
0.0648864359,
0.004478036,
-0.0159683824,
0.0560715795,
-0.026640147,
-0.0531647429,
0.0504070371,
0.0086230487,
0.0241364837,
0.0231026821,
-0.0508534759,
0.0435575582,
-0.0377871543,
-0.0136224674,
-0.0309103914,
-0.0092666307,
0.0630913153,
-0.007146833,
0.070946157,
0.0491370149,
-0.0558952093,
0.015058293,
0.0467403457,
-0.0608536713,
-0.0086179925,
-0.0268741939,
-0.002171248,
-0.0409040265,
-0.0675677806,
0.0611386187,
-0.0149312904,
-0.036569465,
-0.0365023725,
0.0718356445,
0.0079095569,
0.0119431922,
-0.1006819978,
-0.0466697328,
0.0075831204,
-0.017223658,
-0.0034629072,
-0.0214179028,
0.0455239676,
-0.0055302773,
0.0632344708,
-0.0497247949,
0.0208239369,
0.0096500106,
0.044111371,
0.0336891972,
-0.0168915894,
-0.0353257656,
0.0614551753,
0.0108216368,
0.0167633928,
-0.0472715311,
0.0030331176,
0.0331480801,
0.0028361704,
0.0779292881,
0.0895804763,
0.0363761149,
-0.0356263034,
-0.0537820607,
0.0731046572,
-0.0308767576,
-0.0086208545,
0.0065376074,
-0.0546499752,
-0.0010721929,
-0.0101093128,
-0.0517716333,
-0.0324844234,
-0.0311230868,
-0.0159014184,
0.0334116332,
-0.0084818564,
-0.0295395833,
-0.01219738,
0.0119700627,
-0.0652104616,
-0.0152052594,
-0.0131197553,
-0.055711057,
0.0119359801,
-0.0078243539,
0.0156259425,
-0.0183936618,
0.0195103176,
0.0212342478,
0.0084812613,
0.0284259487,
-0.0105431182,
0.0526054092,
0.0433424152,
-0.0530364774,
0.0159590896,
-0.0171319414,
0.0177408811,
0.0072142859,
0.0180420205,
0.0052606282,
0.0155446241,
-0.0071623842,
0.0350415222,
0.0023176107,
0.0424526706,
-0.0431680605,
-0.0427716449,
0.0412146412,
0.001929801,
-0.0504604988,
-0.014433546,
-0.0327653438,
-0.0074771424,
0.0158132445,
-0.0589879602,
-0.0019643612,
-0.0143280877,
2.459e-7,
0.0539929718,
0.0592404529,
0.0246805958,
-0.0180424042,
0.0023994679,
0.0387957692,
0.0389545523,
0.0302394461,
0.0326273814,
0.0204881746,
0.0248171724,
-0.0004102643,
0.0386825912,
0.0288712103,
-0.0787591413,
0.0099704489,
-0.0721860602,
-0.0081871795,
-0.0266373828,
0.0102500319,
0.0887633935,
0.0492232442,
-0.0108169252,
-0.0492866412,
0.0027878128,
-0.0311669633,
0.068154797,
-0.0087143658,
-0.0171954036,
0.0350925997,
0.0740538463,
-0.0023162034,
0.0168530568,
0.0176249351,
-0.0460218713,
-0.0189164616,
0.0408172831,
0.0545585379,
0.0277203657,
-0.0237361453,
0.0149477096,
-0.0110805715,
0.0256360825,
-0.0748126805,
0.0793898478,
-0.0484405756,
-0.0039254623,
-0.0414131321,
-0.0598010644,
-0.030505091,
0.0472490117,
-0.0336336978,
-0.0136990482,
0.0387310125,
0.0100725517,
0.0160954632,
0.0095576756,
-0.0450724252,
-0.0300931204,
-0.0162756387,
-0.0150982002,
-0.0255538374,
-0.0443752781,
-0.0245821681,
0.0348807499,
-0.0684420019,
0.0091255242,
2.378368536e-34,
0.0486260876,
-0.0148628745,
0.0296569373,
-0.056085933,
0.0267128255,
0.0360885635,
0.0235985983,
-0.0149179138,
-0.0113024348,
-0.0481802039,
-0.0021974707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14485v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14485v1 | Explainable and Accurate Natural Language Understanding for Voice Assistants and Beyond | 2023-09-25T19:30:44 | 2023-09-25T19:30:44 | Kalpa Gunaratna, Vijay Srinivasan, Hongxia Jin | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Joint intent detection and slot filling, which is also termed as joint NLU
(Natural Language Understanding) is invaluable for smart voice assistants.
Recent advancements in this area have been heavily focusing on improving
accuracy using various techniques. Explainability is undoubtedly an important
aspect for deep learning-based models including joint NLU models. Without
explainability, their decisions are opaque to the outside world and hence, have
tendency to lack user trust. Therefore to bridge this gap, we transform the
full joint NLU model to be `inherently' explainable at granular levels without
compromising on accuracy. Further, as we enable the full joint NLU model
explainable, we show that our extension can be successfully used in other
general classification tasks. We demonstrate this using sentiment analysis and
named entity recognition. | [
0.0288847648,
0.0767950267,
-0.0044988776,
0.0376313254,
0.020161435,
0.0211848393,
0.0420481525,
-0.0366594642,
-0.0192810521,
-0.0177329183,
-0.0150285698,
-0.0363233238,
-0.0029105784,
0.0447893664,
-0.0152328927,
-0.0369666591,
0.0261169318,
-0.0092382766,
0.0344287679,
0.0199951679,
0.0033821869,
0.0482889302,
-0.037620984,
0.0636492819,
0.0097790053,
-0.0206273124,
-0.0586878508,
0.0207311362,
-0.0180310402,
0.0131759718,
-0.0119028427,
0.0044688727,
0.0221320912,
0.0211007558,
0.0000019407,
-0.0471451655,
-0.0548255704,
-0.0138052609,
-0.1065126881,
-0.0144820586,
-0.0356134363,
0.0006097851,
0.0240669753,
0.0243063942,
-0.010014669,
0.0061830394,
0.0244467072,
0.0759138018,
0.0553407446,
0.0467571169,
-0.0035381014,
-0.0147330454,
0.0174768176,
-0.0249196384,
0.0251697954,
-0.0690460578,
-0.0211612917,
-0.0271772593,
-0.0302936547,
-0.0030983139,
0.0059122709,
0.0078342473,
0.0211659707,
-0.0468002856,
0.0099394415,
-0.0239120126,
0.0066766641,
-0.0389815718,
-0.0052657812,
0.085260503,
-0.0111296577,
0.0015757437,
0.0228172485,
-0.0354813412,
-0.0196805969,
-0.0134799648,
-0.0219772346,
-0.008367192,
0.0123473648,
0.0085365064,
0.0245948508,
0.0446550064,
0.0698136315,
0.0115927709,
-0.0198893491,
0.0619295835,
-0.018645497,
-0.0214143079,
-0.0100346273,
-0.0038578135,
0.0074558575,
-0.0523203313,
0.0172952004,
0.0531996749,
-0.046532739,
0.0398597121,
-0.0204568617,
0.0155021409,
-0.0163629018,
-0.0158357713,
0.0137914317,
0.0343668647,
-0.0277544335,
0.052980911,
0.010776558,
0.0207254384,
0.0073606176,
-0.0077709681,
-0.0157541707,
-0.0412506089,
-0.0624374896,
-0.0273020342,
-0.0052223424,
0.0016656937,
-0.0438223742,
-0.0136363674,
-0.0144182332,
0.02093466,
-0.0354978852,
0.0348221436,
0.0306915939,
0.02598821,
-0.0469288863,
-0.0105214566,
-0.0164714828,
0.0320156664,
-0.056206122,
0.0496211313,
-0.0098995306,
-0.0446873046,
-0.0046875607,
0.0365758389,
0.0294918418,
0.0053127939,
-0.008596451,
0.0309836455,
0.0253648181,
-0.0312225968,
-0.0220707934,
-0.0495902933,
-0.0208615568,
-0.0502811484,
-0.0323568955,
0.0020769541,
0.0266116094,
-0.0347566977,
0.0086902343,
-0.0209031347,
0.0152026815,
-0.0233352836,
-0.0071217581,
0.1136118248,
-0.0356219746,
0.0182632003,
-0.0051967399,
0.023426991,
-0.0040154802,
0.0205805246,
0.0232812446,
0.0092892107,
0.0492698886,
-0.0361814164,
0.0211105105,
-0.054214552,
0.0338487849,
-0.0012088082,
0.0385840833,
0.0044499105,
-0.0753707588,
0.0369784161,
0.0415792726,
0.0079300292,
0.003157153,
-0.0051701944,
0.0334205814,
0.0150250783,
0.0503512472,
0.0337505303,
0.046562206,
0.0448038094,
-0.0391903557,
0.0057709874,
-0.0416891016,
0.0342565402,
-0.0074946261,
-0.0019091123,
0.0266874898,
-0.0202534068,
-0.0338944979,
-0.0620993786,
0.0166468564,
-0.0402120948,
0.0016391522,
0.0103124287,
0.0280720685,
0.0134119717,
-0.0251287855,
0.0666731,
0.0124290772,
-0.0472259223,
0.0115462346,
-0.0645748153,
0.061756283,
0.0828457326,
-0.0019508476,
-0.0309756268,
-0.0273033231,
-0.0571703985,
-0.0586338006,
0.0217251442,
0.0106513072,
-0.0091809127,
0.0756992772,
-0.050897412,
-0.021121297,
-0.0269622374,
0.019159317,
0.0127514489,
-0.0411679968,
-0.0173144452,
0.0374347866,
-0.0584733896,
0.0094107306,
-0.0017035719,
-0.0025186457,
-0.0341613963,
0.0237020459,
0.0525222495,
0.0612037443,
0.0855373517,
0.0382873677,
-0.0015500033,
-0.0041504609,
-0.0108648995,
-0.0533594042,
0.0315219797,
-0.0374088585,
-0.0256895889,
-0.0009594876,
-0.0016524887,
-0.0100993337,
0.0602482036,
-0.0230541825,
-0.0876239389,
-0.0158926956,
0.0009907021,
0.0152595192,
-0.0513135195,
-0.0175790042,
0.0336909853,
0.02204106,
0.0197808202,
0.0316833146,
-0.0003218141,
-0.0117661245,
0.01881871,
0.0080031492,
0.0387474149,
-0.0263928268,
-0.0051809442,
0.0066476469,
-0.0229724478,
-0.0152702164,
-0.0056751221,
-0.0179412197,
-0.0215637963,
0.0073338342,
-0.086865142,
-0.0027402011,
-0.0373557247,
-0.0038341163,
0.0213608537,
0.0205659624,
0.0299686436,
-0.0230010767,
-0.0375260375,
0.0012604889,
-0.0138840759,
-0.0200845469,
0.0313386545,
-0.0119875185,
-0.0379863083,
-0.0500858352,
0.025288308,
-0.0311541501,
0.0368340053,
-0.0119300429,
-0.0100895083,
-0.0455356427,
0.0157398023,
-0.006210865,
0.0005836981,
-0.0118168155,
-0.0396151431,
0.0069293072,
0.0195247624,
-0.0691864118,
0.0518052578,
-0.0059691803,
0.0570094809,
0.0092288349,
0.0287728198,
-0.0292684641,
0.0396877043,
-0.0343180671,
0.0248213336,
-0.041915819,
-0.0137447882,
0.0096289171,
0.0822294727,
0.004016466,
0.0028522499,
-0.0513493344,
-0.0218791943,
-0.0059938021,
-0.031213399,
-0.0063232067,
-0.0367696136,
-0.006193514,
0.0456211418,
-0.0107033281,
-0.0527349822,
0.0681033954,
-0.0597927496,
-0.0043706526,
-0.0477619171,
-0.052873943,
-0.0554100499,
0.0805532411,
-0.0225801263,
0.0078980364,
0.0179188475,
-0.0289801769,
0.0088473652,
0.0055429465,
-0.0058562821,
0.011342613,
0.0494454354,
-0.0183728393,
0.0007754903,
0.0079257153,
-0.0308990087,
-0.034460362,
-0.0478230417,
-0.0524563901,
0.0210199449,
0.0313048214,
-0.0428448133,
0.0011887226,
0.0000964211,
0.0167130493,
0.0180805847,
0.0112752616,
0.0107560279,
-0.028188426,
0.0161997974,
0.0457581729,
0.067981042,
-0.0097780637,
0.0122174434,
0.0433119461,
0.0005231033,
0.0105708865,
0.0230829287,
-0.0423493385,
0.0212021675,
0.0187998507,
-0.021722842,
-0.0342337154,
-0.0059145358,
0.0878035277,
-0.0538197383,
0.0225693788,
0.1396555305,
0.0218650661,
-0.0324431099,
0.0002764598,
-0.0017692659,
-0.0213417783,
0.0078269513,
-0.0122604053,
-0.0405949429,
-0.072608918,
0.0232582018,
0.0393492579,
0.0000371638,
0.003615947,
-0.006207855,
-0.0853176564,
0.0037635209,
-0.0398706719,
-0.061103344,
-0.0355275534,
-0.0250685588,
-0.0116916932,
-0.0194537397,
0.0298611037,
-0.0437745452,
0.0473486893,
-0.0003970456,
0.026395807,
-0.0663894042,
-0.01758679,
0.0419955999,
-0.030905284,
0.100226745,
0.0433778353,
0.0530301966,
0.0184728354,
-0.0238621384,
-0.0388784148,
-0.0264917314,
0.0235673692,
0.0024380628,
0.0549052916,
-0.0133351414,
-0.0337738022,
0.0062252311,
0.0647075325,
-0.0704128966,
-0.0037507019,
-0.0319000296,
0.0385571793,
-0.0351910964,
0.005949684,
-0.0051217033,
0.0123689026,
0.0679174736,
0.0975014344,
0.0380966403,
-0.0333306044,
-0.0138221383,
-0.0240814127,
-0.0027013528,
-0.0633538589,
-0.0014180796,
0.0215422772,
0.0261302385,
-0.0184704736,
-0.0155528709,
-0.0644656196,
-0.0036658496,
0.0370114855,
-0.0125067756,
0.0277275722,
0.020737458,
-0.0040044542,
-0.0276543442,
0.0370609388,
0.0160299819,
0.0355082117,
-0.017614007,
-0.0416568629,
0.0298747029,
-0.0409313515,
-0.034008231,
-0.008523359,
-0.0263079666,
-0.0031945615,
-0.0069011422,
0.0271149464,
0.0267898366,
0.0649952739,
-0.0328411274,
-0.0624375343,
-0.0248978287,
0.0083458647,
-0.0429387502,
-0.0307941549,
0.0900422856,
0.0665929466,
-0.0023288585,
0.0751437023,
-0.0540762544,
-0.0031588594,
-0.0201832093,
0.0099918004,
-0.0607398488,
-0.0400848575,
-0.0037256891,
-0.0107409339,
0.0503065251,
0.0378787071,
0.0081644086,
-0.0556365289,
0.0523440354,
0.0189340077,
0.0079577137,
-0.0449759066,
0.001753877,
0.0448664352,
-0.0185904652,
0.0042667156,
-0.0374268703,
-0.0082047833,
-0.0216555055,
-0.0229291562,
0.0235614795,
0.0261831172,
0.0178061519,
-0.035399247,
0.0117785018,
-0.0203858186,
0.0516149029,
0.0142798629,
0.022335276,
0.0151759777,
0.0581632853,
-0.0055613499,
0.0205063615,
-0.0059807911,
0.0089709293,
-0.0473925248,
-0.0834936351,
0.0156258307,
0.0032419523,
0.0094314283,
-0.0345317349,
0.0338773131,
0.019969672,
0.0255824346,
0.0112833204,
0.0761662647,
0.0155805042,
-0.0072618891,
0.012143896,
-0.0058888299,
-0.030309042,
0.0040925909,
0.0681949258,
0.0005399323,
0.0431043953,
-0.0095135719,
0.017389413,
-0.0345454961,
-0.020079026,
0.0386513807,
0.0643366352,
-0.0213118512,
0.0177434869,
-0.015140038,
-0.0515132733,
-0.0036973581,
-0.0396785885,
-0.0020553712,
-0.0128669851,
0.026087625,
0.0566884801,
-0.016917279,
-0.0143414922,
-0.0508307107,
-0.0329384133,
-0.0206661262,
0.0262005739,
0.0038720754,
-6.31585327e-33,
0.0001525708,
-0.0094679585,
-0.0156615265,
-0.0302130301,
0.0231668223,
0.038995333,
-0.0477809571,
-0.024927102,
-0.0326943137,
0.0195494834,
0.0205607936,
0.0568789653,
0.0230904054,
0.0430259071,
-0.0273436792,
-0.0456909426,
0.0663623735,
0.0291088335,
0.017504571,
0.0438587554,
0.0604223348,
0.0416824445,
0.0298603568,
-0.101993829,
0.033696536,
0.0379692763,
-0.0195521675,
0.0382116213,
-0.0234164204,
0.0644739792,
-0.0189911593,
0.0174807925,
0.0247649867,
-0.0602302179,
0.0052627353,
0.0479829423,
-0.0882408246,
-0.0262173265,
0.0201536007,
0.0290708784,
-0.0633534044,
-0.021343464,
0.028508136,
0.0342521332,
0.0474860817,
-0.0172774717,
0.0195005052,
-0.0000629549,
-0.0019998676,
-0.0569477342,
-0.033016108,
0.0203903895,
-0.0507337786,
-0.0375002623,
0.0210253932,
0.0055855028,
0.0252935383,
0.0054768715,
-0.0786299407,
-0.0371919647,
-0.0421337448,
0.0031994784,
0.0543722846,
-0.0458521247,
-0.0567631423,
0.057552401,
0.0302869268,
-0.0061027878,
-0.0723074749,
0.0076503446,
-0.0337109193,
0.077827923,
0.039922379,
0.0107299173,
0.0268240031,
-0.0170857515,
-0.0560390763,
0.019435456,
0.006564396,
0.0194550864,
0.0184938293,
0.0228889715,
-0.0973241404,
0.0109570334,
-0.0462809242,
-0.0499743819,
-0.0518016852,
-0.0003882915,
0.0246112049,
-0.0009152236,
-0.0659973472,
-0.0044619921,
0.0029308882,
-0.057310041,
0.0188424103,
0.0173546225,
0.0012217077,
-0.0141914412,
-0.0056654341,
0.0019934725,
-0.0276931264,
-0.0337083749,
0.0091747213,
0.0204485711,
0.0355912112,
0.0043237004,
0.0372620001,
0.0201261044,
-0.0207457356,
-0.006907281,
-0.0556747913,
-0.0031863898,
-0.0518436767,
0.0502968058,
0.0418704897,
0.0083531048,
-0.0379820205,
0.0714160502,
-0.0027153727,
0.0440268926,
-0.0028314407,
-0.0409348346,
-0.011788724,
0.0038177471,
-0.0127168205,
-0.0549893081,
-0.0000861574,
-0.0456936732,
0.0236792471,
-0.0627624169,
0.0072693261,
-0.0093088727,
2.613e-7,
0.0143649997,
-0.0044413628,
0.005905957,
0.0037994315,
0.0324890465,
0.0799800158,
0.0338090658,
0.0130233429,
-0.0498225465,
-0.0304835755,
0.0338689573,
0.0130375577,
0.0485430583,
0.0219712704,
-0.0590859614,
-0.0180163626,
-0.0217733309,
-0.0037065346,
-0.0439738482,
0.0163965113,
0.0661872923,
0.1119523048,
0.0285499729,
-0.0192156322,
0.0381208323,
-0.0294472333,
-0.0095900921,
-0.0159150865,
0.0408254378,
0.0143383443,
0.0684109032,
0.0348323174,
-0.0076853498,
0.0088807,
-0.0309570003,
0.0388290994,
-0.0064467005,
0.0496476628,
-0.0010170713,
-0.0658274814,
-0.0579226613,
-0.0184824504,
0.0433701761,
-0.0585923083,
0.0811104029,
0.0000339777,
-0.0437676907,
-0.0265475363,
-0.0053674304,
-0.0108181955,
-0.0106796687,
0.0348219387,
0.0289348587,
0.0120858997,
-0.0243472513,
-0.0546287075,
-0.006953767,
-0.1166387275,
-0.0128333205,
-0.0225096885,
-0.0157746281,
0.0360804871,
-0.0385340117,
-0.0461831018,
0.0703318194,
-0.0248651542,
-0.0072347978,
2.018019825e-34,
0.015507197,
0.0213663653,
0.0050588776,
0.013844789,
0.0364870578,
-0.0082311695,
-0.0443905741,
-0.0207673982,
0.0595310107,
-0.0215700679,
-0.0049433191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14460v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14460v1 | Online Active Learning For Sound Event Detection | 2023-09-25T18:48:36 | 2023-09-25T18:48:36 | Mark Lindsey, Ankit Shah, Francis Kubala, Richard M. Stern | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.SP | Data collection and annotation is a laborious, time-consuming prerequisite
for supervised machine learning tasks. Online Active Learning (OAL) is a
paradigm that addresses this issue by simultaneously minimizing the amount of
annotation required to train a classifier and adapting to changes in the data
over the duration of the data collection process. Prior work has indicated that
fluctuating class distributions and data drift are still common problems for
OAL. This work presents new loss functions that address these challenges when
OAL is applied to Sound Event Detection (SED). Experimental results from the
SONYC dataset and two Voice-Type Discrimination (VTD) corpora indicate that OAL
can reduce the time and effort required to train SED classifiers by a factor of
5 for SONYC, and that the new methods presented here successfully resolve
issues present in existing OAL methods. | [
-0.0484605655,
0.04292446,
0.0037408005,
0.005339182,
0.0347497202,
0.0081226006,
0.0158190038,
-0.0208553802,
-0.0322575495,
-0.0223381426,
-0.016870711,
-0.0036159351,
-0.0027168198,
0.0580543317,
0.0027493106,
-0.0158900712,
0.0407839045,
-0.0420662314,
0.0553201325,
-0.0048316047,
0.0163688958,
-0.0064602196,
-0.0985140577,
0.0645976812,
-0.0248283483,
0.0372172818,
-0.0072112475,
0.007541439,
-0.0033004603,
-0.0174537152,
0.0388490893,
-0.0048279772,
0.0373446457,
0.0417773016,
0.0000019344,
-0.035914626,
0.006919954,
0.0119008385,
-0.0268932562,
-0.0011078909,
-0.0322784409,
0.0235445667,
-0.0459328964,
0.0034218046,
0.0143195828,
-0.0290703475,
0.0639525354,
-0.0370746106,
-0.0143934358,
0.0479628667,
-0.0012806739,
-0.0111696487,
0.032735914,
-0.0140673108,
0.0319266021,
-0.0271359365,
0.0266387146,
-0.043539539,
-0.0232289378,
-0.037265949,
0.0083945813,
0.0311894566,
-0.036882557,
-0.0214739703,
0.0429106466,
0.0081106331,
-0.058723174,
-0.0113907792,
-0.0100548845,
0.0087238876,
0.030518556,
-0.0029066599,
0.0232084114,
-0.0441139415,
-0.004076805,
-0.0270587262,
-0.050801035,
0.0022165838,
-0.0160352476,
0.0095682554,
-0.0630055517,
0.0181497559,
0.0105890753,
0.023418352,
0.0569319874,
-0.0133746481,
-0.0383227617,
-0.0405735746,
0.0279029645,
0.0040942845,
-0.0535406321,
0.0140576083,
0.0420690589,
0.0327455029,
-0.0399247035,
-0.0233778413,
-0.0063855955,
-0.0113652777,
0.0109319258,
-0.0698250681,
0.0027800077,
0.000351894,
-0.0407813936,
0.0433172584,
0.0064364658,
-0.0043069441,
0.0093257008,
-0.0196025185,
0.0009210596,
0.0138572175,
-0.0566258319,
0.0167851448,
-0.0370341875,
0.0344897471,
0.0395496711,
-0.0176515989,
-0.0428873673,
0.0025742082,
-0.0557622239,
0.0142973009,
-0.0180987455,
-0.0063016927,
-0.0535886288,
0.0386766642,
0.0317448266,
0.019300269,
0.0354189202,
0.0728707016,
-0.0589223839,
-0.0719266385,
0.023844745,
0.0174885355,
0.03408999,
0.0076067345,
0.0346357115,
0.0139031513,
-0.0258596484,
-0.0558507927,
-0.010102028,
-0.0138892913,
0.0049296431,
0.0334067047,
-0.0529618934,
-0.0371450596,
0.011900737,
-0.0562958643,
0.0174217429,
0.0015475571,
-0.0169433821,
-0.0321699828,
0.0242450833,
0.0207322221,
-0.0091203842,
0.0203571077,
0.061563585,
-0.0166888498,
0.0064139925,
0.0755104125,
0.0151296947,
-0.0184946209,
0.0605920814,
-0.0163514465,
-0.0402656831,
0.0336055681,
0.001921108,
-0.0227723476,
-0.0128052076,
-0.0031754803,
-0.047261972,
-0.0031196277,
-0.017065417,
-0.0472069159,
-0.0061884285,
-0.01403559,
0.0475776009,
-0.0370734446,
0.0071537578,
-0.0596016459,
0.0216217414,
-0.0103982994,
0.0107319793,
-0.0231399573,
0.0185284093,
-0.0174186006,
-0.0183906611,
-0.0020517816,
-0.0068720174,
-0.0127032576,
-0.0298676509,
-0.0370337181,
-0.0218145587,
-0.0481901914,
-0.0481027775,
0.0384199992,
0.0406721495,
-0.0126039209,
0.0275626611,
0.0540159568,
0.0175188296,
-0.0038291106,
-0.0153344087,
-0.0461227372,
0.0514762774,
0.0046233726,
0.0105925202,
-0.0865653232,
-0.0654262677,
-0.0697550252,
0.0479328707,
0.0121818129,
0.0253242627,
-0.0381103754,
0.0605272762,
-0.0414787047,
-0.0264890026,
0.0401106365,
0.0354377143,
0.027113419,
-0.0124202734,
0.0110853957,
-0.0199065991,
-0.0056262235,
0.0284571089,
0.0051545273,
0.023511935,
-0.0640419424,
0.0041864989,
-0.0131318728,
0.0925235301,
-0.0077655567,
-0.0169129148,
0.0067795776,
0.0157579985,
-0.0341324434,
-0.0132061811,
0.0264240224,
-0.0054530515,
0.0405559391,
0.0280596055,
0.0151925543,
-0.0061460296,
0.0288347825,
-0.0252061002,
-0.0115995808,
-0.0325799249,
-0.0218862239,
-0.0365803428,
-0.0449729487,
0.0085849417,
-0.0278332252,
0.010022752,
-0.0023726868,
0.0098016327,
0.0324434042,
0.01148008,
0.0106398687,
0.0267664772,
0.0495434552,
-0.0688851252,
-0.0244990271,
0.0211678203,
-0.0390424915,
-0.0093522221,
-0.0250761732,
-0.0140461493,
-0.0014223714,
0.0339551866,
-0.0372088663,
0.0038929381,
-0.0343227237,
0.0079956017,
-0.0248858687,
-0.0116539802,
-0.0084691122,
-0.0443012528,
0.0011690583,
-0.0130410604,
-0.0450235456,
0.0345281474,
-0.0656127483,
-0.0149532687,
-0.0268787816,
-0.0149467988,
-0.0025096089,
-0.0001787052,
-0.0266658831,
0.0019684513,
-0.0509364903,
-0.0396554619,
-0.0219829865,
-0.0149502615,
0.0261840373,
0.0461636893,
0.0086367726,
-0.0122371707,
-0.0104292864,
-0.0165409297,
0.0701627433,
0.0206714645,
0.0342952311,
0.0187689718,
0.0081863664,
-0.0258497391,
0.0341847315,
0.0018145961,
0.0229020081,
-0.0464763939,
-0.0055773249,
-0.0006870399,
0.0240817033,
0.0045078439,
0.0391287729,
0.0035042088,
-0.0508396663,
-0.0393326655,
-0.0392348096,
-0.0728950202,
-0.046792306,
-0.0451379381,
-0.0031262932,
0.0265874304,
-0.0417148173,
0.004341484,
0.0030478938,
-0.0400495455,
-0.0952565521,
-0.0915495455,
-0.003721443,
0.0393954441,
-0.0166188013,
0.0130134486,
0.0038211409,
-0.055637043,
-0.0031013456,
-0.0545326769,
0.0765412599,
-0.0508943498,
-0.0203957278,
-0.0134848701,
0.014794535,
0.0044133263,
-0.0045696744,
-0.0272831041,
-0.0174368378,
-0.0096770218,
0.0294232182,
-0.0354362167,
-0.0070803445,
0.0298526399,
0.0635601729,
-0.0165976789,
0.0486440137,
0.0224034488,
0.0015723573,
-0.0227138363,
0.0708296522,
0.0266880728,
0.0381465517,
-0.0480731502,
-0.0101774856,
-0.0080090445,
0.0174644161,
0.0250944924,
-0.0107444385,
-0.0225484483,
0.0131531004,
0.0378169753,
-0.0291490275,
-0.0166249219,
0.0341218524,
-0.0094820568,
-0.0537165888,
-0.0242669303,
0.0773535967,
0.0505149662,
-0.0472311825,
-0.0258353017,
0.0324866436,
-0.0124240583,
-0.0133210775,
-0.0440229513,
0.0249249563,
-0.018709749,
0.0481223874,
0.0569166243,
0.0019655854,
0.0236021448,
0.0059668855,
-0.0381407924,
0.0494065471,
0.0144263776,
-0.0714661926,
-0.0204172805,
-0.0335150734,
0.0146770226,
-0.0723707452,
0.0263976119,
-0.0315466188,
0.0111977523,
-0.0171028133,
0.0775425509,
-0.084102571,
-0.0524766855,
-0.0130603854,
-0.0511098467,
0.0477475151,
0.039532356,
0.0537632443,
-0.0234934893,
-0.038366396,
0.0748953894,
-0.0345241092,
-0.0111201117,
0.0065570367,
0.0342051238,
0.0331065133,
0.0081741074,
0.040691033,
0.0205992721,
0.0368514135,
0.0022064848,
0.0342525095,
0.0520504229,
-0.0278362203,
0.0393025577,
-0.0385983698,
0.0323669463,
0.0466436744,
0.0126218945,
-0.0240904354,
-0.0068506175,
0.0134990197,
0.0707369968,
0.0249106996,
0.0076718917,
0.0058744512,
0.0185155999,
-0.0266177151,
-0.0898441821,
-0.0408848636,
0.0030608305,
-0.0318783633,
0.0685908496,
0.0003359852,
0.036669042,
-0.0206024051,
0.0234481003,
-0.0295660105,
-0.0032378931,
0.016009355,
0.0774185508,
0.0037683104,
-0.0452407226,
0.013252669,
-0.0036058254,
-0.0204155315,
0.0243679099,
-0.0601619333,
-0.0480830148,
0.0504197814,
-0.0467237234,
0.0189181548,
0.0614718124,
-0.041596882,
-0.0453501232,
0.0329080857,
0.0252562854,
-0.0035540389,
0.0191275124,
0.079898648,
-0.0359969288,
-0.0153958285,
0.012006388,
-0.0422460698,
0.0311467424,
0.0146697341,
0.0127033498,
-0.0128533756,
-0.0333278254,
-0.0189869143,
-0.0202379674,
0.0771424696,
0.0196189489,
-0.0415938273,
-0.0436509848,
0.0570170879,
0.0716141537,
0.0411170684,
-0.0237429887,
0.0165173821,
0.0159814637,
0.0531947352,
-0.0481618494,
0.08436317,
0.0373412035,
0.0292477272,
-0.0323539898,
0.0668949932,
0.0712447166,
0.0017690278,
0.0140973721,
0.0002342207,
-0.000463114,
0.0743460357,
0.0287147779,
0.0209755003,
0.047645729,
0.0386061259,
0.0086204279,
0.0347714797,
0.0299101304,
-0.0042186682,
-0.0428419337,
0.0036386345,
-0.0401631594,
0.0250675343,
0.0466793031,
-0.0503078736,
0.028575547,
-0.0113773048,
-0.018501902,
0.0002910088,
0.0254307836,
-0.0110930884,
-0.0055880486,
0.009401436,
0.0295655299,
-0.0006723348,
0.0168174002,
0.0420953184,
-0.0389346927,
0.0288995132,
-0.0399765298,
0.0078359051,
-0.0145167857,
0.0074492777,
0.0716511831,
0.0326854624,
-0.0202468093,
-0.0058309436,
0.0392714515,
-0.0214652661,
0.0175575521,
-0.0731216446,
0.0259801801,
0.0131021859,
0.046053227,
0.0323142074,
-0.0099861016,
0.0548756532,
0.0116864704,
-0.0351415165,
-0.0153724262,
0.011554081,
0.0124783656,
-5.363828477e-33,
-0.0111751603,
-0.0189479571,
-0.0343286917,
0.0353252217,
-0.0196963381,
0.0580452718,
0.0170404818,
-0.0171999335,
0.0393694155,
-0.003553434,
0.0542905256,
0.0272852443,
0.0374756604,
-0.022296777,
0.0280787498,
-0.0671370625,
0.0906388536,
-0.0034858738,
0.006180001,
-0.0135484049,
0.0661393702,
0.0379653163,
-0.0108164391,
-0.0968280062,
-0.0189650785,
0.0326483659,
-0.0352420993,
-0.0232008863,
-0.0003894379,
0.0424893945,
0.0180072226,
0.0405832753,
-0.0265137721,
-0.0302967206,
-0.0200382043,
-0.0183837637,
-0.0714389458,
0.0206179265,
-0.042188812,
0.0780011192,
0.0398059972,
0.0295956042,
-0.0012307907,
0.0202699471,
-0.0213265158,
-0.0002017699,
0.0471997596,
-0.0442419462,
-0.0621371418,
-0.0750839189,
-0.0345705338,
0.046235472,
-0.0345334671,
-0.0035110258,
0.0279647708,
0.0122155501,
-0.0066567762,
-0.0510754958,
-0.0330067389,
0.0208733417,
-0.0291585568,
0.0021448256,
-0.0375776775,
0.0034374013,
-0.0383447073,
0.0225803051,
0.0758226663,
-0.0579706095,
-0.000328181,
0.0499670804,
0.0144897988,
0.0026891327,
0.0327182896,
0.0003716387,
0.0247301441,
0.0004089974,
-0.0362364911,
0.0065982356,
0.086099714,
-0.0422705412,
0.0308848042,
0.059058141,
-0.0577724651,
0.0137876095,
0.0069694072,
0.0339777134,
-0.0076794992,
-0.0229654741,
0.0363092311,
0.0232784469,
-0.0283376928,
0.0127168419,
0.0178464316,
0.0135571677,
0.004319482,
0.0061083743,
0.0175335072,
-0.0221243426,
-0.0119135883,
-0.0324821919,
-0.0300848894,
-0.053012345,
0.0680519417,
0.0016155377,
0.0176114682,
-0.0236338545,
0.0343201496,
0.1106500924,
-0.0501531512,
0.012865684,
0.0263882186,
-0.0335932039,
0.0111574447,
0.0967558771,
0.0330115259,
-0.0355201103,
-0.0075297747,
0.0594680496,
0.0128624197,
0.0158333238,
-0.0244511627,
-0.0540776812,
-0.071945101,
0.0117648924,
-0.0247605611,
-0.0033500532,
0.007697403,
-0.0491507016,
-0.0292889271,
-0.0530936383,
0.0088516437,
-0.0450109392,
2.701e-7,
-0.0168556422,
-0.0111582046,
-0.0273482017,
-0.0359573178,
0.0493488051,
0.0010179399,
-0.0570171773,
-0.0105679575,
0.0211221464,
0.062534444,
0.0419622771,
-0.0563130602,
0.0546851158,
0.0689253584,
-0.1192066446,
-0.0656138137,
-0.0651627183,
0.080793649,
-0.057255242,
0.014556637,
0.0052780556,
0.0694747865,
0.0240790006,
-0.0747977868,
0.0573766455,
-0.0713881105,
-0.0173652843,
0.0252830014,
0.0207648948,
-0.0354235359,
0.0246983804,
-0.021258492,
-0.0178784635,
0.0302394461,
-0.0682526305,
-0.0037718124,
0.0328574851,
0.0380761251,
0.0213941075,
-0.0245802719,
-0.0248399191,
0.0594381504,
0.0382840373,
0.0294783022,
0.0797975361,
0.0154326353,
-0.037175294,
0.0175189376,
-0.0337444395,
-0.0168039408,
0.0102102663,
0.0090852128,
0.0186645016,
-0.0105640171,
-0.021652298,
0.0281864963,
-0.0481437333,
-0.0542739853,
-0.0048577324,
-0.0301025379,
-0.0275885928,
-0.0665995106,
-0.0072298967,
0.0425758734,
-0.0210255142,
-0.0175912101,
-0.0209013876,
2.022513565e-34,
0.0301580019,
0.0143632516,
0.0079879006,
0.0233811084,
-0.0509844422,
-0.0020864694,
0.0622084625,
-0.0015920347,
0.0176530741,
0.039912086,
0.0045804852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14327v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14327v3 | DeepSpeed-VisualChat: Multi-Round Multi-Image Interleave Chat via Multi-Modal Causal Attention | 2023-09-25T17:53:29 | 2023-11-29T07:52:18 | Zhewei Yao, Xiaoxia Wu, Conglong Li, Minjia Zhang, Heyang Qin, Olatunji Ruwase, Ammar Ahmad Awan, Samyam Rajbhandari, Yuxiong He | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Most of the existing multi-modal models, hindered by their incapacity to
adeptly manage interleaved image-and-text inputs in multi-image, multi-round
dialogues, face substantial constraints in resource allocation for training and
data accessibility, impacting their adaptability and scalability across varied
interaction realms. To address this, we present the DeepSpeed-VisualChat
framework, designed to optimize Large Language Models (LLMs) by incorporating
multi-modal capabilities, with a focus on enhancing the proficiency of Large
Vision and Language Models in handling interleaved inputs. Our framework is
notable for (1) its open-source support for multi-round and multi-image
dialogues, (2) introducing an innovative multi-modal causal attention
mechanism, and (3) utilizing data blending techniques on existing datasets to
assure seamless interactions in multi-round, multi-image conversations.
Compared to existing frameworks, DeepSpeed-VisualChat shows superior
scalability up to 70B parameter language model size, representing a significant
advancement in multi-modal language models and setting a solid foundation for
future explorations. | [
0.0100936685,
0.0747316703,
-0.0121307354,
0.0686193183,
-0.0119850915,
0.0158368275,
0.0265845042,
0.0047052642,
0.0218952056,
-0.0400783867,
-0.0577497669,
-0.0652284548,
0.0092778467,
0.0625595525,
0.0428942367,
-0.0733473673,
0.0484023578,
-0.0315140858,
-0.0097159222,
-0.0038153816,
0.0367670693,
0.0033514139,
-0.0182652771,
0.0519839227,
-0.0390138254,
-0.0377816223,
-0.046625834,
0.0216482077,
-0.0064532207,
-0.0053520789,
-0.0167981051,
0.0617073514,
0.0438017137,
0.051265806,
0.000001952,
0.019101914,
0.0279408507,
-0.0280711912,
0.0066706482,
0.004111907,
0.0442000888,
-0.0228643585,
-0.0099228211,
0.0296506137,
-0.0262322538,
-0.0208419263,
0.0598113164,
0.0265815333,
0.1024826691,
0.0649208948,
-0.0241192933,
-0.0319587141,
0.0171378311,
-0.0419106595,
0.0141798556,
-0.0523626395,
0.0095052402,
0.0124854064,
-0.0128112985,
0.0116644539,
-0.0433499329,
0.0457684696,
0.0512243882,
-0.0532936491,
-0.0033507245,
0.0343758389,
-0.0106927138,
-0.0489695892,
-0.0374115705,
0.1236262694,
-0.0196757074,
0.0216504838,
-0.0210015383,
0.01096527,
0.0123609109,
-0.0390499756,
-0.0698571727,
0.0091875745,
0.0281352997,
-0.0138374129,
-0.0636160225,
-0.0173488334,
0.0006248986,
0.0093443822,
-0.0182696786,
-0.0291356631,
0.0138499578,
0.0235868003,
-0.0353105478,
-0.0023055181,
-0.0205211472,
-0.0810935572,
-0.0093913553,
0.0200227182,
-0.0343861729,
0.0068164766,
-0.054721415,
0.0005989584,
0.0052025542,
-0.0221779924,
0.0143065732,
0.0419968627,
-0.0582104549,
0.0717225969,
0.0183751397,
0.0177486259,
-0.0282268878,
0.0159487501,
-0.022548886,
-0.0198799949,
-0.0035339224,
-0.0052655074,
-0.0262086522,
-0.0158817489,
-0.0677001104,
-0.0717555955,
-0.0150751555,
0.060227938,
-0.0037171377,
-0.0031494251,
0.024653798,
0.0093367901,
-0.0226819478,
-0.0075977338,
-0.0041651502,
0.0804995671,
-0.0152660515,
0.0177131984,
0.0028916036,
-0.1021172479,
-0.0227501988,
0.0391806141,
0.0120713897,
-0.0274550151,
-0.0191601869,
0.0850629508,
-0.048497837,
-0.0204366185,
0.0074120061,
-0.0124563975,
-0.0316083841,
-0.0592872351,
0.0178917795,
-0.0463417098,
0.0619173162,
-0.0143638952,
0.0123724537,
0.0086024934,
0.003793706,
0.0216102526,
-0.0283257291,
0.0874525607,
0.007060701,
0.0171082783,
0.0230340734,
0.017187411,
0.0003696673,
0.0856193975,
0.033298973,
0.0180769078,
0.0173280258,
-0.0020150302,
-0.0046004509,
0.0564684235,
-0.0024989895,
0.023064645,
-0.038463112,
0.0015023823,
0.0102143176,
0.0342773125,
0.0271610208,
0.0599170737,
-0.0696958452,
-0.0514317155,
0.0729730651,
0.0229318067,
0.0057335338,
-0.0068449415,
0.0381680205,
0.0400714539,
0.0003753242,
-0.0027831562,
-0.0709534213,
0.0768335462,
0.0153362239,
-0.0241553318,
0.0411806367,
0.0488694608,
-0.0544847213,
-0.0349087082,
0.0132295545,
-0.0037523515,
0.0260491036,
0.0334034599,
0.0219674911,
-0.015329388,
-0.0365259163,
0.0380777679,
0.0139918653,
-0.0170789957,
-0.030881118,
-0.0228424203,
-0.0133740138,
0.078735359,
0.008386692,
0.0112551982,
-0.0386895984,
-0.0242729113,
0.0385634787,
0.0486797057,
0.0234598424,
0.0122631257,
0.0429488532,
-0.0531500131,
-0.0169560779,
-0.0013243794,
-0.0181577764,
0.0316993259,
-0.0028562888,
0.0176635738,
-0.0116058169,
0.0472886749,
0.0378699787,
0.0157535318,
0.0145180998,
0.0143503463,
-0.0284684319,
0.0118665323,
0.012151462,
-0.0033038582,
-0.0206528772,
0.0008914034,
0.01084424,
-0.0114358533,
-0.003907124,
0.0428079516,
-0.0556148812,
-0.0640516058,
0.0389515236,
-0.025518408,
-0.0239439327,
0.0008168038,
-0.0480225161,
-0.0384450592,
0.0304470416,
-0.0231159255,
0.0166503023,
-0.0299770217,
0.0087918313,
0.0431406982,
0.0531846434,
0.0048373276,
0.014285475,
-0.0261275172,
-0.0203601867,
0.0292458907,
0.0324136317,
0.0144669404,
-0.0185764078,
-0.0147340167,
0.0396962762,
-0.0142606646,
-0.0046060286,
-0.0112406509,
0.0368269682,
-0.0444183685,
-0.0365877524,
-0.1300464272,
-0.0105689159,
-0.020065343,
-0.0363366678,
-0.0092483135,
0.0181176513,
0.0009077613,
-0.0421505123,
-0.0431767628,
0.0547726192,
0.0295699704,
0.0232074708,
0.0092484104,
-0.005740745,
0.0017589232,
-0.0415183008,
-0.0189716034,
0.0188190136,
0.0446460284,
-0.0101639535,
-0.037303485,
-0.0082208114,
-0.0236076694,
-0.0209548231,
0.070409216,
-0.0392668135,
-0.0682477802,
-0.0039753076,
-0.0095067471,
0.0277527049,
0.068543613,
0.0280446317,
0.0055773142,
-0.0176074114,
-0.0312427115,
-0.054918766,
0.0546292849,
0.0102055157,
-0.0254623853,
-0.0237897821,
0.0039756182,
-0.0414941199,
0.0508738942,
-0.0400914177,
0.0361922421,
-0.0636223257,
0.0031647321,
0.0368210115,
-0.0417581461,
-0.0351049379,
0.0181250349,
-0.0080900192,
0.0001701216,
-0.0569722168,
-0.0612211339,
0.0430404656,
-0.0319181494,
-0.0661975369,
0.0202117208,
0.0180560313,
-0.0349987186,
0.0774261579,
0.0120585198,
0.0150569761,
-0.0178221222,
-0.01596733,
-0.0534720011,
0.0117289461,
-0.003484559,
-0.0198335852,
0.0524928086,
-0.0491493903,
0.0255484246,
-0.0267976839,
-0.050889831,
-0.0197378546,
-0.0294385068,
-0.0286339298,
-0.0226078741,
0.0008020009,
-0.0420708433,
-0.040401306,
0.0262607485,
0.0328579731,
0.0163568594,
-0.002449102,
0.0172278248,
-0.0234333966,
0.0197228137,
0.058314532,
0.0316287801,
-0.0326744691,
-0.0446462408,
0.0515551567,
0.0706304982,
0.0109949,
0.0006816397,
-0.0032824276,
0.0269034114,
0.0376625918,
0.0493405983,
-0.0244389605,
-0.0004676755,
0.0564859957,
-0.039530158,
0.0242183153,
0.0690047219,
0.0024422011,
-0.079949826,
-0.0148400525,
0.022253966,
0.0382412933,
0.0295126718,
0.0256819744,
-0.1268635243,
-0.0540837906,
0.0025762424,
-0.0558314063,
0.0259673856,
0.000043566,
-0.0413871445,
-0.0769614652,
0.0211214554,
0.0077760587,
-0.0432378463,
-0.0176845733,
0.0167362466,
-0.0024707813,
-0.0050320383,
0.0302944388,
-0.0091389921,
0.0007945532,
-0.0328510255,
-0.0203151777,
0.0279650334,
-0.0224787015,
0.0226770826,
-0.0233268198,
0.0380666628,
0.009923039,
0.025531251,
0.0243929904,
-0.0499389656,
0.0249307342,
0.0212088339,
-0.0244439971,
-0.0134650441,
0.0548332036,
-0.0415559337,
-0.0417065844,
0.0183872376,
0.017021846,
-0.0046536792,
-0.009981107,
-0.0180540327,
0.02555345,
-0.0019327477,
0.0017088959,
-0.0213870518,
0.0246514007,
0.0262075886,
0.0532960035,
0.0233935099,
-0.0363757871,
-0.0289870184,
-0.022026889,
-0.0239200834,
-0.057840541,
-0.0456224903,
0.0048223217,
0.0326885395,
-0.0358823799,
-0.0336682424,
-0.0368337557,
0.0234041587,
0.0146630527,
-0.0313736163,
-0.0088079199,
0.0000994206,
0.0179889314,
-0.0088461172,
0.0496498682,
-0.0362840518,
0.0334277898,
-0.0487945005,
-0.0005971189,
0.012502512,
-0.0295985192,
0.0019995268,
0.040256422,
-0.1071430594,
-0.0536364131,
-0.0399035923,
0.0470794365,
0.0139196049,
0.061378099,
-0.0220604669,
-0.0542497858,
-0.013776972,
-0.0112327738,
-0.0101576084,
0.0047217701,
0.0299662855,
0.0268120784,
0.0033497289,
0.0575199127,
-0.0246506501,
0.0173537116,
-0.0158734135,
0.0125361318,
-0.0363556519,
-0.0546053126,
-0.0140313357,
-0.0200129133,
0.0028695941,
0.0170342587,
0.0143004879,
-0.0143043799,
0.0286657866,
-0.0245455988,
-0.0048186202,
-0.0980794504,
0.0183052886,
0.0044887988,
-0.025504997,
-0.0004101903,
-0.0017118098,
0.0133103663,
-0.0149926776,
-0.017846996,
0.023022633,
0.0222914256,
-0.0349905826,
0.0231357962,
0.0008364401,
0.0086295549,
0.0157871582,
-0.0131010553,
-0.0031454496,
-0.0182670467,
0.0735548139,
0.0078535937,
-0.062152192,
-0.0062493463,
0.037194483,
-0.0372441225,
-0.0631233677,
-0.0217100754,
0.0507890359,
0.0613066107,
0.0391893499,
0.0295326263,
-0.0032382763,
-0.0032043918,
-0.0129809659,
0.0524701774,
0.0127793439,
-0.0496009812,
0.0462340079,
0.029032452,
-0.0200202111,
0.0034471378,
0.0733407512,
-0.0059252218,
0.0205389801,
-0.0016852536,
0.0076880939,
-0.0356309041,
-0.0280895215,
0.0278934482,
0.0261146165,
0.0015816289,
0.0461881794,
-0.0133012282,
-0.0596274287,
-0.0218951162,
0.0005891744,
-0.0238078721,
0.0210885406,
0.0466158167,
0.0467317812,
0.0229438692,
-0.0073401327,
-0.0201364253,
-0.0080251303,
0.0090158172,
-0.0306478776,
-0.0012375857,
-6.468264929e-33,
-0.019929463,
-0.0160617642,
0.0435810946,
-0.0255088117,
-0.0638977289,
0.0029970661,
-0.0247645173,
0.0047415309,
-0.0473081097,
0.0002293977,
-0.0050258413,
0.0537736937,
0.0184620749,
0.0449658595,
0.0030859031,
0.0036089513,
0.031716343,
0.0029897657,
0.0094173811,
0.0321739502,
-0.0033076201,
0.0038879546,
0.0417316556,
-0.0420768708,
-0.0152525464,
0.0277217031,
-0.0182032343,
0.0435876697,
0.0115348147,
0.0527329706,
-0.03439641,
0.0187161509,
0.0042755958,
-0.0246776696,
-0.0227072947,
0.0584897026,
-0.0373457894,
-0.0049327989,
0.0145480977,
0.0373743698,
-0.0838567987,
0.0047929198,
0.0275524203,
-0.0203648414,
0.0447991043,
-0.0282681845,
0.0194906797,
-0.006821258,
-0.0238535628,
0.0412150025,
-0.0357775278,
0.0272479318,
-0.0184645969,
-0.0454094149,
0.0291805454,
0.0577821471,
0.0312193111,
0.0277996231,
-0.0326873139,
0.0231581796,
-0.0217505563,
0.015546862,
0.0588506535,
0.0401629731,
0.0274545271,
0.0509308875,
0.0499649681,
-0.0044154162,
-0.0249068905,
-0.0467453748,
0.0264679939,
0.058094874,
0.0262479205,
0.0663766116,
-0.0094889943,
0.0034815699,
-0.0329915397,
-0.0269615166,
0.0244557634,
0.0559729002,
-0.0113748079,
0.0153269917,
-0.0009352799,
0.0003734412,
-0.0351834968,
-0.0069895131,
-0.0517913476,
-0.0132443691,
0.0254109614,
0.0411460511,
0.0291997176,
0.0113447439,
0.1050065756,
-0.0382176675,
-0.0165268462,
0.0115372026,
-0.0185937099,
0.0598086827,
0.0082235457,
0.0382161774,
-0.0338106081,
-0.0312851109,
0.0481367409,
-0.0056479559,
-0.0044313269,
0.0194733292,
0.0307423696,
0.0075595547,
-0.0359858572,
-0.0230094139,
-0.0322139524,
0.0171088129,
-0.0156452525,
0.0216096845,
0.0426529311,
0.0103170592,
-0.0632632449,
0.0527960248,
-0.0185242351,
0.0126053598,
-0.0177291501,
-0.0955586955,
0.0016660721,
0.0291150361,
-0.0339800492,
0.0206245594,
-0.061621055,
-0.0373177789,
0.021573754,
-0.0657795444,
-0.0254706293,
0.0232547857,
2.608e-7,
-0.0002656375,
0.0151152648,
0.0161208455,
0.0194853079,
0.0314713977,
0.0235149227,
-0.0129605429,
0.038971886,
-0.004532869,
-0.0199569669,
0.0044006598,
0.0798612908,
0.0570524856,
-0.0146688661,
-0.0530502051,
-0.028422121,
-0.071838066,
-0.0158787351,
-0.0288831182,
-0.0153112188,
0.070133172,
0.1318590194,
-0.0080673778,
-0.0043726009,
0.0453899503,
-0.0093332836,
0.069735162,
-0.0350053385,
-0.0358085744,
0.0080166571,
0.0077110445,
0.0140872886,
-0.0145841865,
0.0268018022,
-0.0043773744,
-0.0009482705,
0.0174738318,
0.0583516322,
-0.0183726083,
-0.0549821779,
-0.0077201477,
0.0147260968,
-0.0397538543,
-0.0366192013,
0.0851200446,
-0.055344712,
-0.0278855581,
-0.0131615102,
-0.0084356237,
-0.0076376782,
0.0483563282,
-0.0173538271,
-0.0464297533,
0.0393840298,
0.0350688063,
-0.0299114324,
-0.0051604062,
-0.09677618,
-0.0322920121,
-0.0337502658,
-0.0711659715,
-0.0139265368,
-0.0785662383,
-0.0678937361,
0.0397536159,
0.0040191039,
-0.0212163925,
2.208434757e-34,
0.0513762087,
-0.0241718981,
0.0333336815,
0.034634959,
0.022425089,
-0.0050758533,
0.0073222844,
0.0157409236,
0.0005299822,
-0.0809907988,
-0.0264119171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14324v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14324v2 | Towards General-Purpose Text-Instruction-Guided Voice Conversion | 2023-09-25T17:52:09 | 2024-01-16T13:53:56 | Chun-Yi Kuan, Chen An Li, Tsu-Yuan Hsu, Tse-Yang Lin, Ho-Lam Chung, Kai-Wei Chang, Shuo-yiin Chang, Hung-yi Lee | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | This paper introduces a novel voice conversion (VC) model, guided by text
instructions such as "articulate slowly with a deep tone" or "speak in a
cheerful boyish voice". Unlike traditional methods that rely on reference
utterances to determine the attributes of the converted speech, our model adds
versatility and specificity to voice conversion. The proposed VC model is a
neural codec language model which processes a sequence of discrete codes,
resulting in the code sequence of converted speech. It utilizes text
instructions as style prompts to modify the prosody and emotional information
of the given speech. In contrast to previous approaches, which often rely on
employing separate encoders like prosody and content encoders to handle
different aspects of the source speech, our model handles various information
of speech in an end-to-end manner. Experiments have demonstrated the impressive
capabilities of our model in comprehending instructions and delivering
reasonable results. | [
-0.0009006874,
0.0547602698,
0.0105128996,
-0.034008313,
0.0135858087,
-0.0260806344,
0.0047664982,
-0.0284214485,
-0.0786511377,
-0.0082392637,
-0.0691253468,
-0.0187662449,
0.0277149212,
0.0508133471,
0.0172026101,
-0.0811460763,
0.0207794625,
-0.0179233886,
0.0277939234,
-0.0074540013,
0.0013812111,
0.0110289492,
-0.02496944,
0.0109560369,
-0.0186589714,
-0.0228169709,
-0.0072727767,
0.0473611094,
-0.0184117556,
0.0187877379,
0.0160924923,
-0.0226955116,
0.0359192193,
-0.0275841225,
0.0000018282,
0.0086278627,
0.0159283653,
-0.0212414414,
-0.01958826,
0.0372096561,
0.0618367158,
0.0037945744,
-0.028998144,
0.0251681264,
-0.0102216695,
-0.0171860773,
0.0732766539,
0.0230706744,
0.0904959813,
0.0938535854,
-0.0256777797,
-0.0525170416,
0.0340636298,
-0.013287372,
-0.0239555761,
0.0238867588,
-0.0139397718,
-0.0227472205,
0.0136760892,
0.0150815742,
-0.0470297039,
0.0679533929,
-0.0001704607,
-0.0235740356,
0.0168110654,
-0.0142193427,
0.0226563253,
-0.0545363016,
-0.0431558974,
-0.0009277514,
-0.0120316828,
0.0232733004,
-0.0041287709,
0.0309468973,
0.01498223,
-0.0432024188,
0.0039209109,
-0.0026237369,
0.0382653177,
0.0134523259,
-0.017920116,
0.0617990494,
-0.0283248927,
-0.0470540598,
0.0013907019,
-0.03027419,
-0.0020780817,
-0.0269303303,
0.0344609432,
-0.0228265189,
0.0077666454,
0.0107509186,
0.0986888409,
0.0288983621,
0.0308743138,
0.0125743868,
-0.0407707766,
-0.0107109128,
-0.0632383674,
-0.0537500642,
0.0155366817,
0.0532795899,
-0.0388120674,
-0.0231252722,
-0.0284303483,
0.0532562546,
0.0008636451,
0.0059340559,
-0.0268168095,
-0.0069165188,
-0.0264413171,
0.0090634655,
-0.0762748867,
-0.0046412689,
-0.0049378765,
-0.0428023338,
-0.0439320132,
-0.0006801413,
-0.0394102968,
0.0119718686,
0.0164311379,
0.0279172268,
-0.041059345,
-0.0014872212,
-0.0028720335,
0.0365856737,
-0.0011235682,
0.0535162501,
-0.0041529522,
-0.0062124669,
0.0060937935,
0.0216881689,
0.0039318129,
0.0289153382,
0.0393917374,
0.0159587711,
-0.0179455951,
0.0436997972,
-0.0627488196,
-0.0144874211,
-0.0220659804,
0.008816598,
0.0154727511,
-0.0355703831,
0.0090155369,
-0.0514793769,
0.0077053765,
-0.0469636992,
-0.0114336396,
-0.0093585774,
-0.0167269334,
0.0410034023,
-0.0072923535,
0.0426503047,
0.0833940208,
-0.0154053783,
0.0181219839,
0.0350935645,
0.0510061309,
0.035113167,
-0.0066400259,
-0.061943762,
0.0275960006,
0.089508146,
0.030728301,
0.035933733,
-0.0620522648,
-0.0296706185,
0.0237146523,
0.0419598185,
0.0834391713,
0.0660609454,
0.0032374512,
-0.0245148465,
0.0765756294,
0.0217079986,
0.035601642,
0.0197747182,
0.0579852313,
0.0236824602,
0.0136419851,
-0.0023273679,
-0.0340313241,
0.0274945684,
-0.0292276833,
-0.0084893964,
0.0174112935,
0.0092639951,
-0.0640325621,
-0.0213892553,
0.0377087258,
-0.0191164911,
0.020565616,
-0.0344906002,
-0.0096219471,
0.0447739847,
-0.0451377667,
0.000721613,
-0.0256359987,
-0.0717656985,
0.042461928,
-0.013710591,
-0.0103247846,
0.0429153219,
0.0105854161,
0.0238498282,
0.0386711843,
-0.0583721101,
-0.0412606001,
0.0406240448,
-0.00448228,
-0.0360618383,
0.0216920264,
-0.0877313167,
0.0341859795,
0.0100613553,
0.0047527854,
-0.0062025036,
-0.0543352813,
0.0015779765,
-0.0176892523,
0.0482228734,
0.0268103387,
0.0036043166,
-0.0098009221,
-0.0357475542,
0.0360484533,
0.0032156899,
-0.0067995149,
0.0146020316,
-0.0256839432,
0.012297295,
-0.0207323451,
-0.0434588268,
-0.0032813372,
0.0036412892,
-0.0490427352,
-0.035271477,
0.0186449233,
-0.0407900214,
0.0568756387,
0.0159691349,
0.0066023972,
-0.0947206169,
0.0059476621,
-0.0630726591,
0.0117974048,
0.0146049606,
0.046945557,
0.0039787157,
-0.0022587483,
0.025736995,
-0.0512040816,
0.0043543475,
-0.0518121831,
0.0549739115,
0.0511986241,
-0.0218499396,
-0.0662709698,
-0.0183085445,
0.022622833,
-0.0303040463,
0.0103386519,
0.0045623248,
-0.0079125892,
-0.0025501067,
-0.052531179,
-0.0483652577,
-0.0015151458,
0.0219526123,
-0.0006655269,
0.0454023406,
0.0190280434,
0.0104539506,
-0.0276410095,
-0.0631301031,
-0.0132070556,
-0.0302877836,
0.0034075866,
-0.0268318839,
-0.0108464435,
0.0005268698,
-0.0318400227,
-0.0042763106,
0.0077436441,
0.0015495749,
-0.0419602245,
-0.0111743873,
-0.0759766921,
0.0565066226,
0.0235832669,
0.045121666,
0.0351998918,
-0.0683334544,
0.015965119,
0.0007069391,
0.059045054,
0.0521725006,
0.0206430107,
-0.0119860461,
0.0086132903,
-0.0138017004,
-0.068906635,
0.0177794769,
0.0300006755,
0.0308918674,
-0.0365152471,
-0.0515963137,
0.0081940275,
0.0143395411,
0.0870476067,
0.0438820757,
-0.0844009891,
-0.0156003144,
0.0107714264,
-0.0382285044,
0.0304007325,
-0.0357624255,
0.0013017141,
0.0151379742,
0.0058262041,
-0.0277234372,
0.0175255407,
-0.04496691,
-0.0658307672,
-0.0282058399,
-0.0270956531,
0.0146602532,
0.0089500602,
-0.0335394144,
0.0254795048,
-0.0094062807,
-0.014393419,
-0.0277854949,
0.0040351232,
-0.0411471091,
-0.0504552647,
0.0451777242,
-0.0389096253,
-0.0522083454,
-0.0167892296,
0.0094647286,
-0.0138718095,
0.0034497541,
0.0154527733,
0.0562737137,
0.0455754064,
-0.0258280784,
0.017206315,
0.0554193743,
-0.0125102457,
0.0392334871,
-0.033554282,
0.0006626472,
-0.0150640104,
0.0242606699,
0.0170981381,
0.0159936883,
-0.0524333157,
-0.008860358,
0.0529402308,
-0.0113227917,
-0.0181654952,
0.0484446958,
-0.0437874831,
0.0118673276,
0.0386301465,
0.033308316,
-0.0031663596,
0.0208252706,
0.0574355945,
-0.0367334262,
-0.003641088,
0.0883556828,
-0.0093128644,
-0.0747243911,
-0.0202956945,
-0.0143871317,
-0.0057111355,
-0.0160256587,
0.029613385,
-0.0251683127,
-0.0050085867,
0.0252437927,
0.0462924466,
0.018160494,
0.0454739146,
-0.0248950925,
-0.0450273231,
0.0468106978,
0.0543937907,
-0.0041989237,
-0.0609808937,
-0.0067824782,
-0.0082488423,
0.0072239009,
0.0102171097,
0.0080611333,
-0.0079047484,
-0.015136892,
0.0137115344,
-0.010148895,
-0.0081548328,
-0.0099543957,
0.0081608566,
0.122440055,
0.1092169881,
0.0363187939,
-0.0088139512,
-0.0165932346,
-0.0424086303,
0.0030545741,
0.0107776094,
-0.0040407004,
0.0461701751,
0.0214452073,
0.0072320555,
0.029563034,
0.0724809989,
-0.0067512076,
0.0652664155,
0.0299921501,
0.0127941761,
-0.0240559597,
-0.031761311,
-0.0389850922,
0.0286621191,
0.0352872498,
0.0638928637,
0.0246473718,
-0.1086111516,
-0.008688977,
-0.0465816967,
0.0478371419,
-0.04211751,
-0.0603129044,
0.0375787765,
-0.0147058638,
-0.025925735,
-0.0475943312,
-0.0099755563,
-0.002589786,
0.0443984084,
0.0270029958,
-0.074826479,
0.0465857498,
0.0056730178,
0.0057615181,
-0.0528617613,
0.0026088792,
0.0442350954,
-0.0566842705,
-0.0421852097,
0.062377952,
-0.0459278151,
0.0560371354,
-0.0166556202,
-0.0215972159,
-0.0388680473,
0.014821494,
0.0119795399,
0.0163123868,
0.0609537065,
-0.0263309721,
-0.0375014804,
0.0535282642,
-0.0170132611,
-0.0541193187,
0.0500127934,
0.0782228932,
0.0522766784,
-0.0253436714,
0.0099248234,
0.0077155544,
0.0565827936,
-0.0167066958,
0.037140768,
-0.0236352459,
-0.0822102204,
0.0182919782,
-0.0140276151,
-0.0253421627,
-0.0133585362,
0.0259872079,
-0.017739851,
0.006133303,
-0.0173847936,
0.0659108683,
-0.0609644018,
-0.0351778492,
0.0554973893,
0.0278942026,
0.0169129465,
-0.0435133539,
-0.0014176234,
-0.0100529864,
-0.0291358735,
0.0182303488,
0.02592659,
0.0579296462,
0.0096434848,
0.0429481044,
-0.0210753027,
0.0566243976,
-0.0071272883,
0.0098755043,
-0.0249051731,
0.0513146631,
0.0064309593,
0.006668359,
0.0182057004,
0.0148685602,
-0.0248962268,
0.0260810312,
-0.0305211116,
-0.0358143598,
-0.0154736368,
0.0136339841,
0.0703840479,
0.0108480854,
0.0504626855,
-0.0055572013,
-0.0032337832,
-0.0523441918,
0.0159416012,
0.0158100333,
-0.0359171554,
0.0248310249,
-0.0327983834,
-0.0003173194,
-0.0349296592,
0.0325221382,
-0.0382701308,
0.027705906,
-0.0017554167,
-0.0376123041,
0.0208532419,
-0.0372391492,
-0.0044076503,
-0.0131048886,
0.0032169656,
-0.0253918022,
-0.0051800092,
-0.022196088,
0.0213597305,
-0.0626467243,
0.0325990692,
-0.02851188,
-0.0566917472,
0.0124663478,
-0.0073119621,
-0.0028357708,
-0.0087162983,
-0.0458529852,
-0.0512290634,
-5.22992314e-33,
-0.0487742722,
0.0357787013,
0.0137389526,
0.0101848403,
-0.0436664261,
-0.0433793478,
-0.0311783291,
-0.0150122577,
-0.020097563,
0.0059241019,
-0.0228960533,
0.0177879352,
0.0033154381,
0.0267589353,
0.0271825474,
0.0405226834,
0.1101706252,
-0.056467168,
-0.0114286197,
0.0572459772,
0.036413826,
-0.0007799007,
0.009793466,
-0.0918625519,
-0.0221597105,
0.0182548817,
-0.0450193845,
-0.0156206843,
0.0535245836,
-0.0006166386,
0.0302585047,
0.0225073062,
-0.0228340738,
-0.0339706466,
-0.0350273475,
0.0439336598,
-0.0697857365,
-0.0063333875,
0.0004089705,
0.0460996144,
-0.035678111,
-0.0559220351,
0.0321687087,
0.0073678847,
-0.0035652434,
-0.0129398936,
-0.0018777449,
-0.0407254994,
0.0136397835,
-0.1062235907,
-0.0284747034,
-0.0037450413,
-0.0145559218,
-0.0499455221,
0.0581678301,
0.0838157013,
-0.0430634059,
-0.0368429832,
-0.0407539867,
0.0383927338,
0.0055291038,
0.0376425385,
-0.0040015494,
0.0351628773,
-0.0163663216,
-0.0246952847,
0.0259417631,
-0.0613102615,
-0.0135915959,
0.0354005136,
0.0541620553,
0.041807346,
0.0358307138,
-0.0322856382,
0.0203247312,
-0.0391813554,
0.0263039097,
0.0130218389,
0.0407906882,
-0.0239244029,
0.0203326084,
0.0524781458,
0.0093999067,
-0.0013935104,
-0.0590778627,
-0.0569836646,
-0.0050790417,
-0.0535223819,
0.0356601663,
-0.0130148483,
0.0066341516,
-0.0276411772,
0.0614825673,
-0.0245658513,
0.0427916348,
0.0051910048,
-0.0480312444,
0.0423172601,
-0.0169254988,
0.0092578055,
-0.0101978835,
-0.0324624144,
0.1053961962,
-0.0091314418,
0.0201225821,
0.0165459048,
-0.0373236425,
0.0720732063,
-0.0214488059,
-0.0307232309,
0.0179288685,
0.0410391092,
0.0025688119,
0.0213927887,
-0.0564687252,
0.0218855236,
0.0016194318,
0.0159494057,
-0.0470744185,
0.0097845308,
0.0071134823,
-0.0360004343,
0.0363662876,
0.0448574983,
-0.0949369147,
0.0097849425,
-0.0204526652,
-0.0122242263,
0.0198474359,
-0.0157366879,
-0.0051507941,
0.0509370044,
2.593e-7,
-0.0323593132,
-0.000727993,
0.0348134115,
-0.0311977249,
0.0503186919,
0.0228217877,
-0.0059330957,
0.0201364588,
0.0473251119,
-0.0281431992,
0.0130583895,
-0.0068936772,
0.0662970617,
0.0163487066,
-0.0436118208,
-0.0212115198,
-0.0250760727,
0.0263806712,
-0.0254824366,
0.0378354527,
0.0736465603,
0.0560523495,
-0.0031223637,
-0.042154599,
0.0067404956,
0.0294657499,
0.01389396,
-0.009807447,
0.0232913531,
0.0142721795,
-0.0054635457,
-0.0266202688,
-0.0490021035,
0.0238955114,
-0.0038466642,
0.0014319253,
0.0121494075,
0.0915688574,
-0.0198083185,
-0.0298272949,
-0.0217429418,
0.0188115742,
-0.0550441071,
0.0338449627,
0.0078199981,
-0.0253807679,
-0.0047988938,
-0.0173221808,
-0.008154016,
0.0413960181,
-0.0081864977,
-0.0576786585,
0.0153773017,
-0.002408047,
0.0159965027,
0.0211856924,
-0.0140285613,
-0.0367275923,
-0.0040397774,
-0.0136446441,
-0.0441316925,
-0.0402079821,
-0.0332517363,
0.0491189696,
-0.0377251357,
0.0043875161,
0.0137574412,
1.822818656e-34,
-0.0060318131,
-0.033576522,
0.0288691223,
0.0034869828,
0.0029354829,
-0.017880287,
-0.0014990374,
0.0339323133,
0.0144370161,
-0.0839544833,
-0.0711737499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14402v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14402v1 | Physics of Language Models: Part 3.2, Knowledge Manipulation | 2023-09-25T17:50:41 | 2023-09-25T17:50:41 | Zeyuan Allen-Zhu, Yuanzhi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Language models can store vast amounts of factual knowledge, but their
ability to use this knowledge for logical reasoning remains questionable. This
paper explores a language model's ability to manipulate its stored knowledge
during inference. We focus on four manipulation types: retrieval (e.g., "What
is person A's attribute X"), classification (e.g., "Is A's attribute X even or
odd?"), comparison (e.g., "Is A greater than B in attribute X?") and inverse
search (e.g., "Which person's attribute X equals T?")
We observe that pre-trained language models like GPT2/3/4 excel in knowledge
retrieval but struggle with simple classification or comparison tasks unless
Chain of Thoughts (CoTs) are employed during both training and inference. They
also perform poorly in inverse knowledge search, irrespective of the prompts.
Our primary contribution is a synthetic dataset for a controlled experiment
that confirms these inherent weaknesses: a language model cannot efficiently
manipulate knowledge from pre-training data, even when such knowledge is
perfectly stored and fully extractable in the models, and despite adequate
instruct fine-tuning. | [
0.0565529466,
0.0355466194,
-0.0313633084,
0.0757887587,
-0.0630814657,
0.0095464252,
-0.0105797751,
0.0063570472,
0.0215205885,
-0.0488782674,
-0.0434399247,
-0.0145734157,
-0.0136731509,
-0.0016466576,
0.0440686159,
-0.0459754728,
0.0653096959,
-0.0353040472,
0.0199047811,
-0.0100558316,
-0.0170248169,
-0.02362068,
-0.0045744809,
-0.0237040278,
0.0024569582,
0.0343424492,
-0.0252205394,
-0.0308455303,
0.028148191,
-0.0022659209,
-0.0278297402,
0.0695006996,
0.0180494692,
0.0334406607,
0.0000022226,
-0.044032041,
0.0120522799,
0.0033993558,
-0.0443091653,
-0.0152516505,
0.0187286101,
0.0138329677,
0.0189452153,
0.0029230961,
-0.0521123596,
-0.0390512161,
0.0456160679,
0.0397047922,
0.0470149554,
0.0704891607,
-0.0024463313,
-0.0456497148,
-0.0105850464,
-0.0291948188,
0.0303379185,
-0.0459412411,
0.0300255492,
0.0014936257,
0.0061523076,
0.0348846987,
-0.0110690407,
0.0276570767,
0.0452610813,
0.0450361967,
-0.0348453745,
0.0452133007,
-0.040856868,
0.0019285143,
0.0284922477,
0.0422111005,
0.0141626904,
-0.0456126966,
-0.0253620967,
-0.0027152479,
0.0285424683,
0.0271999538,
-0.0086746356,
0.0131165646,
0.0011280562,
0.0000838591,
0.0040227352,
-0.0002034131,
0.0288216826,
-0.0008065467,
-0.0477978922,
0.1091090068,
0.0133978743,
-0.048077561,
0.0380959064,
-0.0075651049,
-0.0248672329,
-0.0592055395,
-0.0203938335,
0.0087367725,
0.0163737703,
0.036316067,
-0.0150765553,
-0.0014763128,
-0.0006468488,
-0.0422572829,
0.0227788575,
0.0524275266,
-0.0124236541,
0.0536132529,
-0.0174431317,
0.0408051722,
-0.0100258319,
0.0577311665,
-0.0577900372,
-0.0026023693,
-0.0536779463,
-0.0473397896,
-0.0529537909,
0.0398567058,
-0.0149987498,
0.0045512123,
-0.0040824967,
-0.010581268,
-0.0114495745,
-0.0228724014,
-0.0215250812,
0.0107071912,
0.0152136711,
-0.0193817243,
-0.0917516947,
0.0132653983,
-0.0343683772,
0.0323447771,
0.0163551494,
-0.0511117801,
-0.0106524723,
-0.048077669,
-0.0262516309,
-0.0334784985,
0.0377901159,
0.0530840494,
-0.0124235973,
-0.0371307991,
-0.0137554072,
-0.0123318648,
0.0186396297,
-0.093858853,
0.0240834113,
-0.0361690968,
0.0393613912,
0.0249874871,
-0.0317949578,
-0.0429999977,
0.0181402285,
0.0149480123,
-0.0658615977,
0.0948932916,
0.0176183581,
0.0000679616,
0.0068415697,
0.0043884339,
-0.0319514051,
0.0641481206,
0.0025298591,
-0.0047175926,
0.0008533481,
-0.0122585911,
0.0003702054,
0.0135286273,
0.0532566383,
-0.0199859999,
-0.0299425144,
0.0279684775,
-0.0101500219,
0.0290024728,
-0.0059038922,
0.0386670008,
-0.0328964777,
-0.0358942226,
0.049660217,
0.0378624387,
-0.0176092871,
0.0301429462,
0.0230808184,
-0.0426985361,
0.027085444,
0.0283724368,
-0.0785521865,
0.036927551,
-0.0612727776,
0.0003406969,
-0.0199684035,
0.0007806866,
-0.0302283242,
-0.0268168896,
-0.0010393396,
0.0239647776,
0.0420524552,
0.0285236835,
0.0524010397,
0.0146941515,
-0.0055502737,
0.0567685701,
0.0283505339,
-0.0541218184,
-0.0351491868,
-0.078572087,
-0.0054478431,
0.0332279019,
0.026628809,
-0.027788436,
-0.0435163639,
0.0416337997,
-0.0229066052,
0.0164310746,
0.0698130652,
0.0224044546,
-0.0237071197,
-0.0249341149,
0.0110990237,
-0.0225700438,
0.0220181178,
0.0313183032,
-0.0183172673,
0.000880968,
0.0201860461,
-0.0101453876,
0.0089193173,
0.0347214825,
-0.0125512863,
-0.0053509511,
-0.0340264738,
0.0148747787,
-0.005209357,
-0.0173660722,
0.0057596904,
0.0334551223,
0.0395072177,
-0.0174809657,
-0.0276860669,
0.0396906473,
-0.0110448385,
-0.0334997885,
0.0209695529,
-0.014224099,
-0.0035345224,
0.0246803015,
-0.0293211602,
-0.0391066149,
0.0465167612,
-0.0153694153,
0.0697381273,
-0.0418174788,
0.0189266223,
-0.0003765208,
-0.040014863,
-0.0183987264,
0.1181632057,
-0.0148234284,
0.0336193517,
0.0077234944,
0.0009121159,
0.0197775532,
-0.0663533658,
-0.0066537675,
0.0249315314,
0.0196888112,
0.0060155685,
0.0236971267,
-0.0228164773,
-0.0333485156,
-0.0155965574,
-0.058316756,
-0.0182817765,
0.0003916828,
0.0071716406,
0.011307572,
-0.0061749439,
-0.0229790714,
-0.0157425255,
-0.0198871419,
0.0214149449,
0.0068765478,
0.0423739366,
0.0202358626,
0.0184182227,
0.0123458086,
-0.0433499739,
-0.0082503119,
-0.0414354354,
0.0318848304,
0.0045099906,
0.0218757968,
-0.0318161286,
0.0822714865,
-0.0732407346,
0.0558019057,
-0.0276465882,
-0.0422663875,
0.0304380059,
-0.04500499,
0.0224075783,
0.0850509033,
0.0180312321,
0.0279984046,
0.0765726417,
-0.0168822929,
-0.0346935056,
0.0301659387,
-0.0297182593,
-0.0131020658,
-0.0235465392,
0.0152605763,
-0.0228812937,
0.065998368,
0.0334764346,
-0.0228656102,
-0.0767406151,
0.0466209501,
-0.0119652078,
-0.0395141393,
-0.0455462821,
0.0334934779,
-0.0063862237,
0.0559991933,
-0.0232176576,
-0.0066375486,
0.0885877013,
0.0089747747,
-0.0064499541,
-0.0516961403,
0.0203824993,
0.008741525,
0.1022157222,
0.0420218073,
0.0183550324,
0.0024457816,
0.0238200966,
-0.0739401877,
-0.0224295203,
0.0354756564,
-0.0221770275,
-0.0080330158,
-0.0366755873,
0.0264088139,
-0.0111988159,
-0.0660346523,
-0.0489332452,
-0.0169106666,
-0.0111182239,
-0.0035829479,
-0.0058693453,
-0.0198753513,
-0.0109481374,
0.0026189396,
0.0556786396,
0.0570298992,
-0.0083270613,
-0.0152780274,
-0.0282580163,
-0.0090809707,
0.0388688855,
-0.0172023308,
0.008806997,
-0.0098877354,
0.0096988846,
0.0516713746,
0.0177317262,
-0.0171857942,
-0.0012621122,
-0.0031667468,
0.0066103004,
-0.041316364,
-0.0327378511,
0.0059975884,
0.0070997137,
-0.0719057173,
-0.0258965436,
0.11704427,
0.0441058353,
-0.0047313743,
-0.0113367103,
-0.0240705833,
-0.0057813111,
0.0299971513,
0.0181090198,
-0.0899630934,
-0.0097399009,
0.0152217718,
-0.0336794853,
-0.0244524777,
-0.0340439677,
-0.017636193,
-0.1234457418,
-0.011115741,
-0.0204111654,
-0.0398303829,
-0.066571936,
-0.0224327184,
0.0029232313,
-0.0051910826,
-0.0209357552,
0.0371834114,
0.0145810703,
0.0303009506,
-0.0325885452,
0.0121435588,
-0.0247620866,
0.0497157201,
-0.0118218223,
0.0282077659,
0.0645890832,
0.0421573482,
-0.0277410466,
-0.0656336248,
0.007714021,
-0.003622279,
0.0086026452,
-0.0167515073,
0.0375509746,
0.0075855553,
-0.0089467261,
-0.0312656648,
0.0232624747,
0.0176174864,
-0.0125436662,
0.0050398675,
0.0667203441,
-0.0278702043,
-0.0430706851,
0.0139755588,
-0.0145358853,
-0.0209980905,
0.1094304025,
0.0174186453,
-0.0113434717,
-0.0201819129,
-0.0339509323,
0.0034182575,
0.0058299154,
-0.046403069,
0.0147692785,
0.0773702189,
0.0089323688,
-0.05187691,
-0.0601886809,
0.0097231613,
0.0270330459,
-0.0114428345,
0.0032379746,
0.0100934263,
0.0066986149,
-0.0429470465,
0.0108241383,
-0.0307682976,
-0.0135875298,
-0.0194104314,
-0.0312212035,
0.0590690933,
-0.0440828949,
-0.0530256294,
0.0052829986,
-0.026782291,
-0.0770876557,
-0.0104183797,
0.0677478537,
0.0366054028,
0.0448816121,
-0.012124951,
-0.0112701645,
-0.0247738771,
0.0148562612,
-0.0670999438,
0.035617765,
0.0260287039,
-0.0169597454,
0.0184943695,
0.0422585271,
-0.0060353121,
0.0417506024,
0.0157919228,
-0.0046348367,
-0.0409777537,
-0.0474035665,
0.060784407,
0.0441702157,
0.0495883152,
0.0276197027,
0.0131915128,
-0.0276084356,
0.0260276143,
-0.0572216995,
-0.0136115756,
-0.0411000699,
-0.017086545,
0.0344645791,
0.0416285731,
-0.0095033469,
-0.0771912336,
0.0079653878,
0.0358088464,
0.017326571,
-0.0292755887,
0.0256033223,
0.0643604845,
0.0534479246,
-0.0114867603,
-0.0083194869,
-0.0015163306,
-0.0156728476,
0.0573321916,
-0.0310968738,
0.0778954029,
0.0633319169,
-0.0305620339,
-0.0451992489,
0.0314351507,
-0.1006039679,
-0.054402072,
0.0303781275,
-0.0067298459,
0.0184416175,
-0.0032550602,
0.0039302874,
-0.0659432337,
-0.0124476049,
0.0124852164,
0.0055089025,
0.0447400995,
-0.0385664329,
0.0345924571,
0.02183442,
0.0004637212,
-0.0187276024,
0.050214231,
0.0189057309,
0.0932760313,
-0.0059807161,
-0.0099180611,
-0.0156474616,
-0.0173483975,
-0.0312841199,
-0.0065256734,
-0.0033982128,
0.0322371833,
-0.0865745693,
-0.0711372942,
-0.038689658,
0.032226529,
-0.0196031872,
-0.0068878299,
0.0466296487,
0.0820414275,
0.0015135999,
-0.0472182818,
0.0056187459,
0.0166103132,
0.0148744425,
0.000561789,
-0.0302663483,
-6.636384131e-33,
-0.0603146777,
0.0214289725,
0.0426260196,
0.0114202807,
0.0037524255,
-0.0514050201,
-0.0379031301,
-0.0025141155,
-0.0684329793,
0.0105716446,
-0.0215179157,
0.0137000913,
0.0009301842,
0.0044561429,
-0.0039998153,
-0.0270302296,
0.0270052645,
0.0027706437,
-0.0179232862,
-0.0013309583,
0.0632100478,
0.0224008635,
0.0803472921,
-0.0230285469,
0.0111497995,
-0.006456438,
0.0182660203,
0.0366419926,
-0.0825355425,
0.0112739969,
-0.0171425659,
0.009602394,
0.0205253921,
-0.0376005508,
0.0070035304,
-0.0024454645,
-0.0606155023,
-0.0864453316,
0.0587751865,
0.0087254504,
-0.0148249827,
-0.0160994865,
0.0131009882,
-0.0127631063,
-0.0202235635,
-0.01160332,
0.0114787547,
-0.0316678323,
0.0302816648,
0.0179504175,
-0.0614402741,
-0.0140837263,
0.0206830073,
-0.0162941683,
0.0178200472,
0.0099182958,
-0.0156211192,
-0.0500452109,
-0.0787157565,
0.0233159196,
0.0354483128,
0.047417976,
0.016300207,
0.0181993283,
0.030686982,
0.0409859493,
0.0363072641,
0.0030608193,
-0.0480042435,
0.0262286793,
0.0541519262,
0.0527859777,
0.0267169438,
0.0397716463,
0.0551012158,
-0.0130071323,
-0.0636090487,
-0.0335106887,
0.0241650026,
0.0451940671,
0.0161961913,
-0.0015418832,
-0.0424839221,
-0.0255146883,
-0.062585026,
-0.0190210491,
-0.0472075008,
-0.0560027547,
0.0461912677,
0.007816731,
0.0182583909,
-0.0321515687,
0.0195022672,
-0.0224359091,
-0.0053961286,
0.0356925093,
-0.0244835801,
0.0031089792,
0.0018474857,
0.0263037626,
-0.0644266605,
-0.0130007043,
0.0023918049,
0.0283437986,
-0.0165200103,
0.021330785,
-0.002190646,
0.0234838892,
-0.0425272062,
-0.0113904523,
-0.0419530794,
0.0125803575,
-0.0084311431,
-0.0324995592,
0.0295163468,
0.0453064889,
0.0025440622,
0.0207941439,
0.0161709916,
-0.0292355549,
-0.0910093859,
0.0184734762,
0.0142137045,
0.0078425994,
0.0179656893,
-0.006934098,
-0.0279801358,
-0.0131809544,
0.034283191,
-0.0454357825,
0.004931991,
0.0330183469,
3.046e-7,
0.039301727,
0.032417044,
0.0020420121,
0.0317994691,
-0.0056379009,
0.0364280194,
-0.0246409792,
0.0000124194,
0.074348554,
-0.0415177681,
-0.004808988,
0.0674888864,
0.0023680739,
0.0243420694,
-0.0655763745,
0.0035669273,
-0.0230755098,
-0.0645016134,
-0.0210208744,
-0.0097734416,
0.056367483,
0.0822692886,
0.0595417432,
0.0050459416,
-0.0237040482,
-0.0308107771,
0.0555674843,
-0.0299833808,
0.0013073289,
-0.0057443986,
0.0206980668,
0.0085414741,
-0.0141305989,
0.0681587681,
0.0222885236,
0.020197764,
-0.0325298794,
0.0145829767,
-0.0102171609,
-0.0222493578,
-0.0454361588,
-0.0377950706,
-0.0331214294,
-0.0607762299,
0.0959088355,
-0.0667605549,
-0.016946055,
0.0119086644,
-0.0040257252,
0.0027649554,
-0.0031554685,
-0.0063432278,
-0.0107750604,
-0.0093716122,
0.0144366315,
0.0239838567,
0.0290583614,
-0.0836451426,
-0.0235476121,
0.0212207884,
-0.0379191637,
-0.0546515137,
-0.0408507772,
0.0161022544,
0.0360527486,
-0.0683171228,
0.0027958695,
2.751199758e-34,
0.0031945722,
0.0088430084,
0.0342135243,
0.0010447025,
0.0245010443,
-0.000896398,
-0.0057644988,
0.0281183422,
0.0215133484,
-0.0815269053,
-0.0141213425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14316v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14316v2 | Physics of Language Models: Part 3.1, Knowledge Storage and Extraction | 2023-09-25T17:37:20 | 2023-12-26T12:00:15 | Zeyuan Allen-Zhu, Yuanzhi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) can store a vast amount of world knowledge,
often extractable via question-answering (e.g., "What is Abraham Lincoln's
birthday?"). However, do they answer such questions based on exposure to
similar questions during training (i.e., cheating), or by genuinely learning to
extract knowledge from sources like Wikipedia?
In this paper, we investigate this issue using a controlled biography
dataset. We find a strong correlation between the model's ability to extract
knowledge and various diversity measures of the training data.
$\textbf{Essentially}$, for knowledge to be reliably extracted, it must be
sufficiently augmented (e.g., through paraphrasing, sentence shuffling)
$\textit{during pretraining}$. Without such augmentation, knowledge may be
memorized but not extractable, leading to 0% accuracy, regardless of subsequent
instruction fine-tuning.
To understand why this occurs, we employ (nearly) linear probing to
demonstrate a strong connection between the observed correlation and how the
model internally encodes knowledge -- whether it is linearly encoded in the
hidden embeddings of entity names or distributed across other token embeddings
in the training text.
This paper provides $\textbf{several key recommendations for LLM pretraining
in the industry}$: (1) rewrite the pretraining data -- using small, auxiliary
models -- to provide knowledge augmentation, and (2) incorporate more
instruction-finetuning data into the pretraining stage before it becomes too
late. | [
0.0666497052,
0.035412617,
-0.0329997875,
0.0780023932,
-0.0206601508,
0.0286467411,
-0.008910344,
0.0257618334,
0.0145749245,
-0.0490394421,
0.0030001383,
-0.0282139722,
-0.0157271326,
-0.0132096,
0.0504047386,
-0.014697344,
0.0486489832,
-0.0469488129,
0.005243443,
-0.0385022908,
-0.0114728836,
-0.0157600176,
0.00499888,
-0.0149937291,
0.005900111,
0.0196779612,
-0.0027545732,
-0.0240780581,
-0.0022655264,
0.0138672609,
-0.0087513924,
0.0555927753,
0.0212203823,
0.0339124501,
0.0000021053,
-0.0687452555,
-0.0172569137,
0.0133258794,
-0.0611765496,
0.0266570617,
-0.0031526603,
0.0091461008,
0.0019482166,
-0.0144145843,
-0.0320609882,
0.0304846466,
0.0334354304,
0.0280105285,
0.0195757821,
0.0603376105,
0.0175786018,
-0.0208805799,
0.0439971834,
-0.0111947516,
0.0422198251,
-0.0288094934,
0.041140873,
0.0083595114,
-0.0518749431,
0.0292362217,
-0.0561065152,
0.048076842,
0.0144895166,
0.0404961742,
0.0399604626,
0.0521259084,
-0.0180593934,
0.0222763512,
0.0218706504,
0.0721503422,
0.0190218501,
0.0087882476,
0.0153669966,
0.0089718774,
0.0026141452,
0.0443532392,
-0.0371414162,
0.0258087907,
0.0088602863,
-0.0207427647,
0.001541791,
-0.0567899123,
0.0425858833,
-0.0006699433,
-0.0190381743,
0.0604857989,
0.0208191611,
-0.061863225,
0.0106286127,
0.0019103572,
0.0230718143,
-0.0792881101,
-0.0169701204,
0.0194836799,
0.0289748851,
0.0529732592,
-0.0158876702,
0.006443182,
0.0276263766,
-0.0431361645,
0.013219865,
0.0298061501,
0.0128705325,
0.032037057,
-0.0236295145,
0.0479072668,
-0.020677425,
0.0434798487,
-0.0475689545,
0.0190170296,
-0.0851348415,
-0.0442019776,
-0.0231607594,
0.0619373396,
0.0045110006,
-0.0101829423,
-0.0438116938,
0.0136670582,
0.0226125028,
-0.0005884345,
-0.0307314415,
0.0243279729,
-0.0137897143,
0.0183174815,
-0.0776557252,
0.0163262989,
-0.0426724255,
0.0063974629,
0.0073858495,
-0.0368966646,
-0.028074488,
-0.0186262019,
0.0094132731,
-0.0382517427,
0.0366309397,
0.0547502041,
0.0054668016,
-0.041717466,
-0.0343890525,
-0.033327993,
-0.0233119689,
-0.0730875209,
0.0252471399,
-0.0529270954,
0.0522904955,
0.027045859,
-0.0135396309,
-0.0603052787,
0.0187803842,
0.0032037031,
-0.0868757591,
0.0639397129,
-0.0125410259,
0.0201864932,
0.0207254048,
0.0039659725,
-0.0159459338,
0.0755228326,
0.0378048345,
-0.0101972679,
0.0660456717,
-0.0097118327,
-0.00035301,
0.0327749923,
0.0416359045,
0.0022017956,
-0.0028000646,
0.0118767405,
0.0060319724,
0.0131672304,
0.0324051566,
0.018334832,
-0.0299295541,
-0.0063491454,
0.0538661927,
0.0715995207,
0.0049808831,
0.0367468856,
0.0267601963,
-0.0221024081,
0.0624447726,
0.0496933609,
-0.0438335314,
-0.0048627094,
-0.0412785038,
0.0362662077,
0.0221254639,
0.0241795741,
-0.0203506965,
-0.0151306326,
-0.0142202443,
0.0034052716,
0.0245076884,
0.0171145443,
0.0418842025,
-0.0120544257,
-0.0269799437,
0.1115886047,
0.0480127931,
-0.0355478674,
-0.0013581059,
-0.0373020954,
-0.008330822,
0.0772596449,
0.0249155667,
0.0063150027,
-0.0403314382,
0.0024671894,
-0.005994183,
0.0068629566,
0.0425074399,
-0.0185501873,
0.0256664064,
-0.0298274644,
-0.0208903905,
-0.042394001,
0.0324476734,
0.0393481441,
0.0160041563,
0.0003264887,
0.0150532555,
-0.0382820964,
-0.049616497,
0.0345179401,
-0.0997610465,
-0.0451987274,
-0.0252807327,
0.003908956,
0.0025158108,
0.0369155444,
-0.0385369733,
0.0133903753,
0.054411497,
-0.0372017287,
0.0154507058,
-0.0095045315,
-0.0000124675,
-0.0097783366,
0.0432507545,
-0.0136945266,
0.0024094223,
0.0151528167,
-0.0011970646,
-0.0467077866,
0.0167785753,
0.0034997547,
0.077636376,
-0.0327263363,
0.0135534396,
-0.0175832771,
0.013970552,
-0.0370011963,
0.0933103487,
-0.0195939522,
0.0519737154,
0.0087074954,
-0.0060118153,
-0.0020692798,
-0.0640875772,
-0.0587410405,
0.0260929614,
0.0236601252,
0.0133438259,
0.0225806851,
-0.0463948734,
-0.051596418,
-0.0075291228,
-0.0818310902,
0.0152242128,
-0.0213030912,
0.0172513351,
0.0138128083,
0.0025626989,
-0.0354828276,
-0.0023157864,
-0.0090795923,
-0.0114463558,
-0.0268350188,
0.0416377634,
0.030043859,
0.0341785029,
-0.0128917191,
-0.023064835,
-0.021903906,
-0.0287695825,
0.0348424353,
0.0037690869,
0.034221556,
-0.0424341969,
0.0478747599,
-0.0430703573,
0.0061441669,
-0.0192715991,
-0.0399477556,
0.0099948067,
-0.0144281331,
0.0242266282,
0.0652216375,
0.016359197,
0.0394688025,
0.0373213962,
-0.0210939012,
-0.0307315011,
0.0161046777,
-0.0338626131,
-0.0090398453,
-0.060920801,
-0.0179543756,
0.0041047307,
0.0501982868,
0.0130147748,
-0.0190223213,
-0.0461702421,
0.0178589188,
-0.0295401141,
-0.0408937968,
-0.0596202016,
-0.0002091716,
-0.0421197861,
0.0330136456,
0.0073946607,
-0.0066492762,
0.0632879212,
-0.018001236,
0.0061686821,
-0.0206682142,
-0.0091680717,
-0.0063427044,
0.075020045,
-0.0000247649,
0.0248671696,
0.0201240573,
-0.002332319,
-0.0728506446,
-0.0133803226,
0.0226591751,
-0.0498715639,
0.016033886,
-0.007303189,
0.006775673,
0.0076685324,
-0.0130061088,
-0.0694245026,
-0.0666073635,
-0.0150804976,
-0.0045702499,
0.0305830985,
-0.0333456881,
0.0040915604,
-0.0284256432,
0.0575022697,
0.0105616786,
-0.0297095589,
0.0119074862,
-0.0196622312,
0.0322917178,
0.0726037174,
0.0020433764,
0.0399070308,
-0.0659086481,
0.0057365983,
0.0189993251,
0.03665125,
-0.000617489,
0.0265979897,
-0.0114696473,
0.015827639,
-0.0730642378,
-0.0241743866,
0.029280562,
0.0365899913,
-0.0538754351,
-0.0160514172,
0.125895828,
0.0151387639,
-0.0179387536,
0.0074335281,
0.0277333912,
0.0078183943,
0.0304926783,
0.0368911959,
-0.0806259811,
0.0195097607,
-0.002512146,
0.0229210686,
0.0035120002,
-0.0434859656,
-0.0339784361,
-0.1345863491,
-0.0212157462,
-0.0220989864,
-0.0385947265,
-0.0415137894,
-0.0293821171,
-0.0240821857,
0.000410346,
0.0502620339,
0.0142760333,
-0.0240527578,
0.0232031401,
0.0295977257,
-0.0143064838,
-0.0776327401,
0.0253146831,
-0.0458239727,
0.0808131024,
0.0345894322,
0.0255441833,
-0.0398144834,
-0.0306318533,
-0.0184113774,
-0.0102150198,
0.0130929565,
0.0028854308,
0.0874711722,
-0.0316971913,
-0.0056782798,
-0.0092769908,
0.0151894055,
-0.0013194035,
0.0023736611,
0.0052389405,
0.0483373664,
0.0143402945,
-0.0197724048,
0.0164035447,
-0.0288035832,
-0.0031375967,
0.1233981699,
0.0219731834,
-0.0300894119,
0.0041325591,
-0.0338476002,
0.0260501895,
-0.0226245355,
-0.0320471637,
0.0220695827,
-0.0225698054,
0.0022316799,
-0.0707651153,
-0.0489316918,
0.018543493,
0.0323646367,
0.0199414436,
0.0516524166,
0.0128634172,
0.002655322,
-0.0536383763,
0.0330023728,
-0.0412110612,
-0.0177794602,
-0.0327395611,
-0.0585287362,
0.0227907095,
-0.0303937513,
-0.0367056765,
-0.0444300398,
-0.0653896332,
-0.0821504667,
0.0341679975,
0.0473678,
0.0283946861,
0.0875766501,
-0.0065890332,
-0.0496906973,
0.0416943058,
0.0263211913,
-0.0844786018,
0.0273921192,
0.0025940933,
-0.0098299365,
0.007157662,
0.0304809697,
-0.0596011952,
-0.0187996775,
0.0267303102,
0.0365501456,
-0.0323531851,
-0.0439330377,
0.0189613886,
0.0594787411,
0.0165960249,
-0.0076515293,
-0.0143082887,
-0.0302797742,
0.0314268209,
-0.0283031221,
-0.0038809436,
-0.0131558841,
-0.0447237082,
0.0364483893,
-0.0069622034,
0.0024826706,
-0.0168392435,
0.0055410494,
0.0463335887,
-0.0411587358,
-0.0455879457,
-0.0042137438,
0.0103161959,
0.0494627096,
0.0086301314,
-0.0008492667,
0.0223543961,
-0.0121846534,
0.0478158221,
-0.0042037168,
0.0106174927,
0.0207534246,
-0.0204556379,
-0.0362884626,
0.0168996919,
-0.119274348,
-0.0276538916,
0.0104829967,
0.0452764817,
0.0386265628,
-0.0537045263,
0.0488648117,
-0.0281594396,
-0.0148538994,
0.0081737507,
-0.030063279,
-0.0061608865,
0.0279878266,
0.0554620214,
0.0295000244,
-0.02117748,
0.0162650924,
0.0772542506,
0.0357299373,
0.0666468516,
-0.0176972728,
-0.0123611577,
-0.0359960198,
-0.0019389449,
0.0296936128,
0.0360361412,
-0.0267611668,
-0.0014211495,
-0.0847284719,
-0.0708773434,
0.003949495,
0.0136957867,
-0.010704129,
-0.0141546195,
0.0208570063,
0.0644305125,
0.0041274405,
-0.0252165124,
-0.0494885221,
0.0218232889,
0.0090931235,
-0.0191362239,
0.0141775729,
-6.89059654e-33,
-0.0355259739,
0.0093818866,
0.0159258265,
-0.0174183417,
-0.0341744497,
0.0136833955,
-0.0241462924,
-0.0007539458,
-0.0655135736,
-0.0044696815,
-0.0485777222,
-0.0044369781,
0.008507696,
0.0119908806,
-0.0018569452,
-0.0329935364,
0.0230771247,
0.0032696577,
-0.0193666723,
0.0042082435,
0.0556341149,
0.0625216365,
0.0839552581,
-0.0107141556,
0.0572866499,
-0.0468391925,
0.0272996705,
0.0060347985,
0.0098723378,
0.0571746416,
-0.0496874712,
0.0278619528,
0.009130355,
-0.0539956391,
-0.0104679028,
-0.0260562152,
-0.0921505243,
-0.057495378,
0.0517233796,
0.0151464837,
0.0097976075,
-0.0505473092,
0.0592354424,
-0.0159481857,
-0.0067928261,
-0.0031027128,
0.0476770848,
-0.0034794528,
-0.0108731017,
0.0096131079,
-0.0268535912,
-0.0038701056,
0.0008289517,
0.0148705468,
0.0244542081,
-0.0286628846,
0.0151223354,
-0.0176013038,
-0.0647844002,
0.0113876304,
0.0364598483,
0.0520593077,
0.0367412083,
0.0203873105,
0.0328627564,
0.0701643303,
0.0111417836,
0.0116073461,
-0.0182020422,
-0.000050077,
0.0550505519,
0.0377563871,
-0.0267076492,
0.044319164,
0.052668266,
-0.0267470721,
-0.0655459017,
-0.0093173217,
0.0276194178,
0.003410731,
0.0307247434,
-0.0218510982,
-0.0612607971,
-0.0329361185,
-0.0466080382,
0.026418075,
-0.0127106216,
-0.0496725664,
0.036484234,
0.001094953,
-0.0489887372,
-0.0249174275,
0.0170165133,
-0.0826224163,
-0.0303471126,
0.0373483449,
-0.0184930898,
0.0035093322,
0.01119876,
0.0125690866,
-0.0832329616,
-0.0120628215,
-0.0135597195,
-0.0105025591,
0.0024125897,
0.0202133488,
0.0109718312,
0.0116503779,
-0.0387062766,
-0.0021270714,
-0.018840963,
-0.0068741459,
0.0113319773,
-0.0187394377,
0.026692776,
0.0442125164,
-0.0093306918,
0.0142410928,
0.0679289848,
0.0171249881,
-0.0329302065,
-0.0057688728,
0.0316195823,
0.0183355045,
-0.0178098381,
-0.0234909225,
-0.0091922097,
0.0371608734,
0.0369078815,
-0.0423262417,
-0.0052026631,
0.0011253089,
2.883e-7,
0.046844162,
0.0551269166,
0.0111942263,
-0.010196371,
0.0014851212,
0.023554625,
-0.0241043381,
0.0225470029,
0.0160405673,
-0.0423594937,
-0.0007425016,
0.045075547,
0.0047290847,
0.006592955,
-0.0886916667,
-0.0490160212,
-0.0262603518,
-0.0030181292,
-0.0453779027,
0.0134495916,
0.0112610841,
0.0763677508,
0.0501145869,
-0.0129303094,
-0.0400531106,
-0.0478820652,
0.0592885688,
-0.0299287904,
-0.0171355233,
0.0264986418,
0.0292392205,
0.0225162096,
-0.0084731244,
0.0520062447,
-0.0216407236,
0.0432698391,
-0.0167192649,
0.0426103584,
-0.0161417425,
-0.0234733671,
-0.0326930657,
-0.035344597,
-0.0113776093,
-0.0530115291,
0.0917178541,
-0.0027953794,
-0.0525701754,
-0.0368975885,
-0.0325706527,
-0.0006947733,
0.005088639,
-0.0111661479,
-0.0154849626,
0.0137209082,
-0.0043567824,
-0.0047696349,
-0.0028763365,
-0.0695066378,
-0.0082872491,
0.0158500504,
-0.0378828347,
-0.0823240206,
-0.0175107494,
-0.0259094276,
0.0331330933,
-0.0902853757,
0.0156803615,
2.957857864e-34,
0.0056216633,
0.0284786392,
0.0076077678,
0.0340907127,
0.0091740014,
-0.0182597376,
0.0133417416,
0.0053116088,
0.0095095476,
-0.0900442675,
-0.017649876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15817v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15817v2 | Identifying the Risks of LM Agents with an LM-Emulated Sandbox | 2023-09-25T17:08:02 | 2024-05-17T17:17:45 | Yangjun Ruan, Honghua Dong, Andrew Wang, Silviu Pitis, Yongchao Zhou, Jimmy Ba, Yann Dubois, Chris J. Maddison, Tatsunori Hashimoto | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advances in Language Model (LM) agents and tool use, exemplified by
applications like ChatGPT Plugins, enable a rich set of capabilities but also
amplify potential risks - such as leaking private data or causing financial
losses. Identifying these risks is labor-intensive, necessitating implementing
the tools, setting up the environment for each test scenario manually, and
finding risky cases. As tools and agents become more complex, the high cost of
testing these agents will make it increasingly difficult to find high-stakes,
long-tailed risks. To address these challenges, we introduce ToolEmu: a
framework that uses an LM to emulate tool execution and enables the testing of
LM agents against a diverse range of tools and scenarios, without manual
instantiation. Alongside the emulator, we develop an LM-based automatic safety
evaluator that examines agent failures and quantifies associated risks. We test
both the tool emulator and evaluator through human evaluation and find that
68.8% of failures identified with ToolEmu would be valid real-world agent
failures. Using our curated initial benchmark consisting of 36 high-stakes
tools and 144 test cases, we provide a quantitative risk analysis of current LM
agents and identify numerous failures with potentially severe outcomes.
Notably, even the safest LM agent exhibits such failures 23.9% of the time
according to our evaluator, underscoring the need to develop safer LM agents
for real-world deployment. | [
-0.0017876225,
0.0165406931,
-0.0190363526,
0.0146209635,
-0.0309731644,
-0.0205762852,
0.0316695757,
-0.002874926,
0.0652177855,
-0.0088540399,
0.0108025642,
0.0052861595,
-0.015046712,
0.0516273566,
0.0508628078,
0.0017811898,
0.0685786009,
-0.0753938034,
-0.0319626741,
-0.0003990054,
-0.0072045708,
-0.0001510548,
0.0090207113,
0.0497416183,
0.0238706116,
-0.0191755723,
-0.0226025917,
0.0396663025,
0.0125556402,
-0.0036283182,
0.0055607385,
0.0008929258,
-0.0012219837,
0.048367992,
0.0000022395,
-0.0354502015,
-0.0173409656,
0.0386198014,
-0.0486520678,
0.0167647526,
0.0368382074,
0.0302246083,
-0.0512105003,
0.0530907139,
-0.0254544485,
0.0019429876,
0.0505646467,
-0.0337261409,
0.0750832558,
0.0433081686,
-0.0003121542,
0.0958185196,
0.0119322883,
0.0277135279,
-0.0162468981,
-0.0307499897,
-0.0112795904,
0.0120368116,
0.0224572793,
0.0000465873,
0.0248338785,
-0.0156734008,
0.027021125,
-0.0134219816,
-0.0497448295,
0.0397308692,
-0.0298093297,
-0.0453400686,
-0.0227763001,
0.0078226961,
-0.0104642361,
-0.0163907334,
0.0023008685,
0.003161608,
-0.0150007186,
-0.0067776917,
0.0293362662,
0.053615801,
-0.0056335567,
-0.0122508295,
0.0107659064,
-0.0011876607,
0.0183039643,
-0.0050674314,
0.01956743,
0.083528094,
0.0258823577,
0.0119076744,
-0.0206356086,
-0.0238095429,
0.0538569987,
-0.0659718812,
-0.0148088802,
0.0225162562,
-0.0384292193,
0.0306335911,
-0.0461639762,
0.0049807811,
0.0725163966,
-0.089493677,
-0.013428905,
0.0205325074,
-0.0163703635,
0.0175513104,
-0.0111980028,
0.0314123444,
0.0138357384,
0.0491620041,
0.0295589734,
0.0173161346,
0.0178205501,
0.0012544856,
0.0037908119,
0.0158939026,
0.0218458232,
0.0091290306,
0.0083757238,
0.0581738763,
-0.0396610498,
0.0664033517,
-0.0529792681,
-0.0141837969,
-0.017808916,
-0.005236275,
-0.0218894668,
-0.0565534234,
-0.0498257838,
0.0108223269,
0.0064080739,
-0.1014955714,
0.0024500987,
0.0119772088,
-0.0634470284,
-0.0299003702,
-0.002527656,
0.1289362609,
0.0276503842,
0.0052231606,
-0.0390313528,
-0.0568034127,
0.0438261852,
-0.0475374497,
-0.0436677933,
-0.0867584124,
-0.0258938223,
0.0085847527,
-0.035142865,
-0.0473114848,
0.0064390004,
-0.0331635438,
-0.0203934293,
0.0272769332,
0.0041226461,
-0.0015939859,
-0.0102754878,
0.0529009365,
-0.0332382433,
0.0470327362,
0.0091833202,
0.0443798155,
0.0353733897,
-0.014503995,
0.0630225688,
0.0576987602,
-0.0381055363,
0.0818622634,
-0.0071361274,
0.0056162518,
0.0385773927,
-0.0198922846,
-0.0196909625,
0.049313765,
0.008726676,
-0.008001266,
0.065881528,
0.0357841961,
-0.0490073338,
-0.012821991,
0.0060565425,
0.0455280282,
-0.0009196484,
-0.0389298424,
-0.0542285331,
0.0049235141,
-0.0377923474,
-0.0052048052,
-0.0343416035,
0.0670333803,
-0.0291122962,
0.0102142366,
0.0109883482,
-0.0337275378,
0.0598360002,
-0.0044571594,
0.0071735997,
0.002793292,
-0.0054029743,
0.0543978997,
0.0151193533,
-0.0487747937,
-0.0387967974,
-0.1039455011,
-0.0123354755,
0.0879148245,
0.0768561214,
-0.0222603157,
-0.0637811199,
-0.0114806881,
-0.0325952657,
0.042523358,
0.0333989821,
0.0127123473,
-0.0051764268,
-0.0039049322,
-0.0347262584,
0.0080956537,
0.0324303396,
0.0535020642,
0.0274984222,
0.025346417,
-0.0146364942,
-0.0394279175,
-0.0332182497,
0.0228067692,
-0.0366068743,
-0.0637692437,
-0.0315857641,
0.0043320809,
0.0013505678,
-0.0272991061,
-0.0159707498,
-0.0083641857,
0.0309034791,
0.0543411411,
-0.0394463465,
0.0327280536,
0.0126990974,
0.0484830327,
0.0213852879,
-0.0220755674,
0.0214630961,
0.0374229923,
-0.0409825444,
-0.015649857,
0.0280904006,
-0.0022844763,
0.0282174163,
0.0098223463,
0.0407875851,
-0.0422572196,
0.0196224321,
-0.0274810325,
-0.0092183016,
0.0213374961,
-0.0157849211,
-0.025840085,
0.0507800169,
-0.0061649941,
-0.0009251958,
-0.0621448793,
-0.004540564,
-0.0074752844,
0.0787989348,
-0.0020454102,
0.0461343043,
-0.0140675744,
0.0003957269,
-0.0840121955,
0.0124708423,
-0.0180439949,
0.0474818051,
0.0316022001,
0.0336541124,
-0.0311782248,
-0.0273718275,
-0.0183882043,
0.02637963,
0.007704176,
0.0412007831,
0.0166337676,
-0.025089182,
-0.0422554538,
-0.0194965173,
0.0095650842,
-0.0171610005,
0.0631024465,
-0.0303083491,
0.0375991464,
-0.0513999946,
0.0598524101,
-0.0316137262,
0.0105865598,
-0.0103902258,
-0.0609154403,
0.025474323,
-0.0178331155,
-0.0516660772,
0.0321537741,
-0.006417356,
0.0469702259,
0.0721009523,
0.0170279983,
-0.0758804381,
-0.0402790383,
0.0455248877,
-0.0474317744,
-0.01830112,
-0.027266968,
-0.0188428443,
0.0221222416,
-0.025295211,
0.0051226146,
-0.0024782063,
0.0122119309,
-0.0062540863,
-0.0257935692,
0.0465724431,
-0.0356503576,
-0.0502038337,
0.0365150198,
-0.0042946078,
-0.0828827247,
0.0574083738,
-0.0518863127,
-0.0078201015,
-0.0167706646,
-0.0717422664,
-0.0288181603,
0.062509492,
-0.0243896227,
-0.0211299565,
0.005028171,
-0.0251714606,
-0.0308940969,
-0.0129835159,
0.0313713141,
-0.0520744063,
0.0048952377,
-0.060248632,
-0.0154791335,
-0.025197437,
-0.0116772903,
-0.0247904807,
-0.033563748,
-0.0241573658,
-0.014836492,
-0.0098181618,
0.0109010059,
0.0143467747,
0.0095826807,
0.0205631591,
0.0304541029,
-0.0110084591,
-0.0102239307,
-0.0240184888,
-0.0541407503,
0.0046215653,
-0.0407914519,
0.0023614783,
-0.0173034295,
0.0539489053,
0.0585454293,
0.0437797755,
-0.03235415,
-0.0498055145,
-0.0323923081,
0.0114848204,
-0.0180794299,
0.0013945742,
0.0669382438,
0.0170652512,
-0.0776596293,
-0.0278753303,
0.0399126597,
0.0230468716,
-0.0257732775,
0.0238349251,
-0.0583739281,
0.0496050641,
0.0263538752,
0.0653435215,
-0.0865300968,
0.0146787539,
0.0186612215,
0.0340489075,
-0.0162390843,
-0.0155592468,
0.028887473,
-0.0797159001,
0.0479085147,
0.022682542,
-0.0370104052,
0.020045042,
-0.0539248362,
-0.0093277423,
-0.0084267333,
0.053683769,
0.0198513903,
0.0155109027,
-0.0197961982,
0.0096217925,
-0.0585106462,
-0.0277952366,
0.0789949372,
-0.068354167,
0.0647665635,
0.0662576258,
-0.0474093892,
-0.0300003253,
0.0189393405,
0.0183092356,
0.0328150392,
0.0040829401,
0.0374637544,
0.0517322756,
0.0357884765,
-0.0225710981,
0.0179347266,
-0.0169032924,
-0.0534709767,
0.0022723482,
0.0188218988,
0.043114949,
-0.0605430603,
-0.0192263201,
-0.0129815638,
-0.0131405024,
0.0379719734,
0.032048218,
0.0080756545,
-0.0372235365,
-0.0672707781,
-0.0408649035,
-0.0109444736,
-0.0143663464,
-0.0418237336,
0.0169142429,
0.0073972987,
-0.0427688658,
-0.0222844593,
-0.0635790527,
0.0074134045,
0.0218805168,
0.0423868559,
-0.0426972248,
-0.0089472262,
0.0410952121,
0.0108947409,
0.0071095494,
-0.0407765172,
0.0534283891,
0.0121640824,
0.045517005,
-0.00807775,
-0.0104218088,
0.0023856889,
0.0031634376,
-0.0473258905,
-0.0727996975,
0.0427647419,
0.0890780538,
0.0380819812,
-0.0023054425,
-0.0468118712,
-0.0100461105,
0.0605638102,
0.0031797399,
-0.074585177,
0.0071080248,
0.0604622327,
-0.0365204886,
0.010218842,
-0.0032165339,
-0.0750861838,
-0.0288995635,
0.0124745267,
-0.0057180529,
-0.0518771708,
-0.0346199125,
-0.0169412028,
0.0250593163,
-0.0403093584,
-0.0059371023,
0.0260292273,
-0.0010832025,
0.0320112035,
0.0111762341,
-0.0068743532,
-0.0117164655,
0.013148752,
-0.0294693355,
-0.0242272001,
0.0589646101,
-0.0197511204,
-0.0123754917,
0.0283406638,
0.0276407003,
0.049194321,
0.0095973546,
0.0245570987,
0.0552405119,
0.0102906683,
-0.0209459048,
0.0314808674,
-0.0216527358,
0.0544199012,
-0.0103005674,
0.0203973725,
-0.0242249221,
0.0012309557,
0.0145384846,
0.0348713435,
-0.0233873483,
-0.0764973462,
0.0091931336,
0.0445409454,
0.0120894918,
0.0185771342,
0.0399684608,
-0.053142,
0.0316866562,
-0.0458990335,
-0.0306943394,
-0.0268927999,
-0.050650537,
-0.0258063767,
0.0096669178,
-0.0062600775,
-0.0022753743,
0.0665477365,
0.0134481927,
0.0430621617,
-0.0094939591,
-0.0175078232,
-0.0508170761,
-0.0268897135,
0.0522919968,
0.0073462063,
-0.0375213511,
-0.081848897,
-0.0734104663,
-0.0710241273,
-0.0532227978,
0.0262692068,
-0.0123885842,
-0.0315187462,
-0.0189891644,
0.0617420673,
0.0497544147,
0.0582096912,
-0.0634547174,
-0.0285943896,
-0.0038008329,
0.0127287284,
-0.0084280781,
-5.914681293e-33,
-0.0024861356,
-0.0187951662,
0.0271016583,
0.0270262547,
0.030537134,
-0.0008901777,
-0.0647130758,
0.0408724397,
0.0062377392,
-0.0158202201,
0.0038544065,
0.0003661197,
0.042535644,
-0.0206178352,
0.0325640738,
0.0271952655,
-0.0019799457,
0.0051636384,
-0.0335419662,
0.0219671074,
0.0280097127,
-0.0151751451,
0.0108160824,
-0.0741006285,
0.0323040038,
-0.0185596794,
-0.0100315558,
-0.0164497867,
-0.0462373495,
0.0396498777,
0.0318488441,
0.015958732,
-0.0176856257,
-0.0426755957,
-0.0019135547,
-0.0403821319,
0.0000102151,
-0.0133191571,
-0.0303975902,
0.0178929474,
-0.0207349584,
-0.0363755971,
0.0160998739,
-0.0156659298,
0.017195005,
0.0196179263,
0.0043374524,
-0.003954804,
-0.0246003214,
-0.0057035326,
-0.0303085297,
0.0137211382,
-0.0198114514,
0.0036534991,
0.0123278694,
0.0069084475,
-0.0159819312,
-0.0471506156,
-0.0255804844,
0.0124148242,
0.0190303456,
-0.0355688557,
0.0739478543,
0.0040066531,
-0.0391224883,
0.0565658845,
-0.0063417321,
0.038774468,
-0.0082859006,
0.0007928014,
0.0366447158,
0.0382077843,
0.0011122379,
0.0370530449,
-0.0383826382,
-0.0448979624,
0.0199200008,
0.0683430955,
0.0780699775,
0.0206518006,
0.0605541095,
0.0140046133,
-0.0697694123,
-0.0165097918,
-0.0134282485,
0.012677798,
-0.031231435,
-0.0592293106,
0.0046488238,
0.0083787208,
-0.035857752,
-0.0471478663,
0.0160812698,
-0.0189827643,
0.0319703482,
-0.0193448961,
-0.0099650947,
-0.025340518,
-0.0182034317,
0.0325517543,
0.0277125146,
-0.0310934223,
-0.0219355412,
-0.0308593251,
0.0418401919,
0.0109588197,
-0.0045683309,
0.0316588692,
-0.0516781323,
0.0328047536,
-0.0434241518,
0.0347483791,
0.0097629502,
0.01279529,
0.002862633,
-0.0290845819,
0.0231456608,
0.0032683942,
0.0307670459,
-0.0345861278,
-0.0286926497,
0.0254217163,
-0.0135435136,
-0.0133030824,
-0.0261135772,
0.0174645446,
-0.0492771417,
0.0499902368,
0.0700227693,
-0.0190890953,
-0.0081507191,
-0.023676537,
3.032e-7,
0.0102001783,
0.0256104264,
0.0060966169,
0.0506056547,
0.0237866882,
0.098462604,
-0.0209871214,
0.0526230372,
0.0047719013,
-0.0205438547,
-0.0103804152,
0.0167784486,
0.0614226833,
0.085388124,
-0.0156337563,
-0.0029370061,
-0.0393957458,
0.000215208,
-0.0599007457,
-0.0442528836,
0.0460682474,
0.0645924285,
0.0075388025,
-0.0544061773,
0.0188804492,
-0.0677024722,
-0.0151333893,
-0.0223263744,
0.002422964,
0.0026815406,
-0.0245550722,
0.0740679055,
0.0078251408,
0.0776499286,
-0.0272636432,
-0.0343452916,
-0.0533844307,
0.0744829178,
-0.000700612,
-0.0375569388,
0.0099767428,
-0.0853012577,
0.0102549642,
-0.0496476516,
0.0304048955,
0.0126017379,
-0.0114983208,
-0.0202276744,
-0.0243230984,
-0.0284584854,
0.0118851252,
-0.0305235218,
-0.0140136993,
0.0007596418,
-0.0249619503,
-0.0201087408,
-0.0134500237,
-0.0299987439,
-0.0400979742,
0.001862023,
-0.0229024868,
-0.0803734511,
0.0096684713,
0.0478783771,
-0.0337784588,
-0.0343397222,
0.041867815,
3.143260874e-34,
-0.0051737931,
-0.0007356659,
-0.0013089824,
0.0306132529,
0.0368007906,
0.0382788554,
0.017328484,
0.0219402742,
0.006929887,
0.0201367978,
-0.0331324488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14258v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14258v1 | OmniEvent: A Comprehensive, Fair, and Easy-to-Use Toolkit for Event Understanding | 2023-09-25T16:15:09 | 2023-09-25T16:15:09 | Hao Peng, Xiaozhi Wang, Feng Yao, Zimu Wang, Chuzhao Zhu, Kaisheng Zeng, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Event understanding aims at understanding the content and relationship of
events within texts, which covers multiple complicated information extraction
tasks: event detection, event argument extraction, and event relation
extraction. To facilitate related research and application, we present an event
understanding toolkit OmniEvent, which features three desiderata: (1)
Comprehensive. OmniEvent supports mainstream modeling paradigms of all the
event understanding tasks and the processing of 15 widely-used English and
Chinese datasets. (2) Fair. OmniEvent carefully handles the inconspicuous
evaluation pitfalls reported in Peng et al. (2023), which ensures fair
comparisons between different models. (3) Easy-to-use. OmniEvent is designed to
be easily used by users with varying needs. We provide off-the-shelf models
that can be directly deployed as web services. The modular framework also
enables users to easily implement and evaluate new event understanding models
with OmniEvent. The toolkit (https://github.com/THU-KEG/OmniEvent) is publicly
released along with the demonstration website and video
(https://omnievent.xlore.cn/). | [
0.0278639756,
0.0389412902,
0.0137713924,
0.0784567967,
-0.0268729702,
0.0309062824,
-0.0080734622,
0.0011120671,
0.0327745117,
-0.0253856517,
0.0263285395,
-0.0026032417,
-0.0159701258,
0.0557491109,
-0.0430159606,
-0.0713618025,
0.070533216,
0.0471409224,
0.0014285535,
0.0564914979,
0.0339531638,
0.0214479212,
-0.0372330695,
0.0396378711,
-0.0029205896,
-0.0448473319,
-0.0160080511,
-0.015028202,
0.0485737659,
-0.0546565801,
-0.0074339514,
0.0206102841,
0.0154529996,
0.0279915985,
0.0000021763,
-0.0600560531,
-0.0403830484,
-0.0434214845,
-0.0470503196,
0.0081125926,
-0.0093569104,
-0.0123858564,
-0.0019704779,
-0.0199266877,
-0.0286817066,
-0.0196532104,
0.0096909767,
0.0904405788,
-0.0026908915,
0.0783723593,
-0.0212351251,
-0.009242354,
0.004621428,
0.0133078704,
-0.0351696014,
-0.037678808,
0.0197787751,
-0.0084178969,
-0.0097317938,
-0.0270754974,
0.0056205057,
0.0053415089,
0.0080000702,
0.0343174897,
-0.0269418471,
0.0468551479,
-0.062115036,
-0.0150910458,
-0.0211598109,
0.0622551925,
0.0164577477,
-0.0272112675,
0.0373689272,
0.0213258918,
0.0112197129,
0.0298316926,
-0.0755906999,
0.0124100577,
-0.0217658076,
0.0159855317,
0.0686423182,
0.0145320864,
-0.0008068084,
0.0319223292,
0.0018258874,
0.0624043159,
-0.0069342703,
0.0098988712,
-0.0534110703,
0.0128278676,
-0.0359288938,
-0.0510936603,
0.0637672469,
0.0323040374,
0.0009868768,
0.0298169721,
-0.0160250962,
0.0268591177,
-0.0356573425,
-0.1075788215,
-0.0673981085,
0.0272014439,
-0.0238841046,
0.0572573207,
-0.008536526,
0.0022187147,
0.0239541158,
-0.0296069775,
-0.0061404062,
-0.0060932087,
-0.0384980477,
0.0361827277,
-0.034715239,
0.0166509077,
-0.0459428728,
-0.0383024067,
0.0132881822,
0.0057049994,
0.0517893545,
-0.0046866224,
-0.0226840209,
-0.0129304323,
-0.0289736781,
0.0016652531,
-0.0178018305,
0.0028803176,
-0.0652419329,
0.0115127796,
-0.0325512849,
-0.0434895493,
-0.0500828773,
0.0145693496,
0.0447968841,
-0.0039378051,
-0.0532917231,
0.0116226804,
-0.0345266014,
-0.013199416,
-0.0478536896,
-0.0544780158,
0.0161958989,
-0.0040563224,
-0.0460033417,
-0.0376077257,
0.0162112247,
-0.0127819581,
0.0044115339,
-0.0291921236,
0.0359864533,
-0.0084988447,
-0.0416616909,
0.0171583071,
-0.028085161,
0.007371698,
-0.0174555238,
0.0410963409,
0.0073877946,
0.0428951457,
0.056109082,
0.0409218781,
0.0833883733,
0.0423611663,
-0.0249739215,
0.0051640081,
0.0062584393,
-0.0433974639,
0.0342359953,
0.0043134629,
-0.0195263531,
-0.0093345484,
0.0244666301,
-0.0431787632,
-0.0309519283,
-0.0208691098,
0.0327743813,
0.0113851745,
-0.0296945237,
-0.0133653516,
0.0078019905,
-0.0159849953,
-0.0000071611,
0.028885778,
-0.0255853105,
-0.0226075873,
-0.0088652009,
0.0061717178,
-0.0519609861,
0.0022783894,
-0.0082950788,
-0.0265701842,
-0.017373763,
-0.0114940265,
-0.0244926568,
0.0156284757,
0.0569670759,
-0.0067056161,
-0.0254354458,
0.0602981076,
0.0180171039,
-0.0577447191,
0.0247350931,
0.0050900253,
0.0299948324,
0.0341730826,
0.0572333671,
-0.039318461,
-0.0249755867,
-0.0049288631,
0.0233827103,
0.0134496726,
0.040482983,
-0.0333677121,
0.0354017206,
-0.0442534238,
0.003211064,
0.0166119393,
0.0260704458,
-0.0183994528,
0.0227560233,
0.009210919,
-0.0141505348,
0.0141426399,
-0.0246044919,
0.0524718575,
-0.0216158815,
-0.0645110309,
-0.0726675466,
0.0009542215,
-0.0033219384,
0.0315002687,
0.0020558913,
-0.0214955341,
0.0467178561,
-0.027457606,
0.0184062142,
0.0764696673,
-0.0108441468,
-0.0763895214,
0.0327127092,
0.0030054853,
-0.0430647358,
0.0176630039,
-0.0460815765,
-0.0546352826,
0.0050565233,
0.0496131852,
-0.0085487245,
-0.0239069201,
0.0181849264,
-0.0036137204,
0.020532066,
-0.017645169,
0.0778763145,
0.0281812269,
-0.028533509,
-0.0254232772,
0.0094249193,
0.0320663154,
-0.023492014,
-0.0468357056,
0.0137435365,
-0.0025330416,
-0.0407121927,
0.025137106,
-0.0327219814,
-0.0697152391,
0.017041916,
-0.085169971,
0.0657477155,
-0.0351037458,
0.0643672869,
0.0594937354,
0.0287897848,
-0.038309522,
-0.0030125706,
0.0186163299,
-0.0579297543,
-0.0412383899,
-0.0106268711,
0.0399735346,
0.0029985448,
-0.0005060548,
-0.0472315624,
0.0265719332,
-0.0684916005,
0.0477639996,
0.0376143381,
-0.0644963011,
-0.0050950944,
0.0017598652,
0.0036929189,
0.0261236355,
-0.0032341848,
-0.0211580452,
-0.0224971268,
0.0099640591,
0.0379347801,
0.0810899064,
-0.025991071,
0.0596763901,
-0.0178207755,
-0.0715764537,
-0.0419182181,
0.0100925406,
-0.02454588,
0.0335433036,
-0.00375103,
-0.0270773154,
-0.0096053146,
0.0801003501,
0.0242833681,
0.0266300347,
-0.0211610924,
-0.0431534015,
-0.036969129,
0.000207202,
-0.0178576373,
-0.0298696849,
-0.0468604192,
0.0341391191,
-0.0539423116,
0.023263054,
0.0549047403,
-0.0045346781,
-0.0091563994,
-0.0711286962,
-0.0042425999,
-0.0651703402,
0.0769440308,
-0.024245711,
0.0112143932,
0.0124060679,
-0.0685760528,
-0.0033553513,
0.015065222,
0.0077783922,
-0.0299490578,
0.0111309336,
-0.018267544,
0.0053085098,
-0.0198996402,
0.0152510544,
-0.034651462,
-0.0522168167,
-0.0198456142,
-0.0066782092,
-0.0232824236,
0.0335748009,
-0.0185362007,
0.0605670959,
-0.0126766572,
0.0284237806,
-0.0277505461,
0.012554504,
-0.0194135532,
0.0781246498,
0.044047825,
0.0197041053,
0.0240491573,
-0.0031132533,
0.0460584313,
0.071200192,
0.0452551469,
-0.019072555,
0.0050434382,
0.0092152739,
0.0022572426,
-0.0855938122,
-0.0030257041,
-0.0324560963,
0.0661012009,
-0.1096540242,
0.0248953141,
0.1109624952,
0.0433789231,
-0.0003358641,
0.0126657113,
0.0005677805,
0.0038480954,
0.0043541668,
-0.0237612799,
-0.0770882145,
-0.0412437767,
0.0070232227,
-0.0187144168,
-0.0201468095,
-0.0555044413,
0.0088042058,
-0.0231258459,
0.0285274405,
-0.0074185492,
0.0098777777,
-0.0367517807,
-0.0262794718,
0.0456477664,
-0.0425109863,
-0.0154435933,
0.0233699977,
0.0029643276,
0.0126553336,
-0.013012398,
-0.0663489774,
-0.0453206487,
0.0149900587,
-0.0590196736,
0.0292351823,
0.0183743685,
0.0429530665,
0.0198638383,
0.0525015444,
0.0201619528,
-0.0243692081,
-0.0171277598,
-0.0298295952,
0.0462119244,
0.0055921641,
-0.0016636119,
-0.0363891087,
0.0498852059,
-0.0267151408,
-0.0492962599,
0.0315916426,
0.0601643808,
-0.0040700813,
-0.0203939583,
-0.0109742628,
0.0018551433,
-0.0016101515,
0.0902667046,
0.0208599679,
0.0283524171,
-0.0305595975,
-0.0025305054,
0.0043720072,
-0.0693837479,
0.0020210308,
0.010532815,
-0.0180520043,
-0.0639370009,
-0.0738171414,
-0.0721219257,
0.021348916,
-0.0082583372,
-0.0108370185,
0.0104296254,
0.0196815263,
0.0096786916,
-0.0349675305,
0.059152171,
-0.0210423414,
-0.0186215676,
0.019741185,
0.0295377187,
0.0014625671,
0.0207933336,
-0.0188066456,
0.0700904578,
-0.0273316558,
-0.0153988656,
0.0028031524,
-0.0700886846,
0.0107384464,
0.04382037,
-0.0260197073,
0.0052255625,
-0.02847117,
-0.0248427801,
-0.0089460677,
-0.0375946276,
-0.0033849389,
0.0205706134,
0.0012058885,
0.009187323,
0.0064910026,
0.0187325422,
-0.053976059,
0.0560490377,
-0.0687877312,
-0.0055370689,
0.0208280645,
-0.0002018437,
0.049409423,
0.0268967114,
-0.0298223868,
-0.0757397115,
-0.003801988,
-0.024672363,
0.0063428502,
-0.0298714489,
0.0431497879,
0.0042913971,
0.0117331743,
-0.0447621159,
0.0288605019,
-0.0163095128,
-0.006888987,
-0.0603483021,
0.0238561295,
0.0407601595,
0.0450806245,
-0.034884762,
-0.0209201332,
-0.0244675148,
0.029262701,
-0.0133926161,
0.0122949816,
-0.0296911653,
0.0314754844,
0.0132294307,
-0.0058852998,
0.0064336206,
-0.0346411429,
-0.0773414969,
0.0404415354,
0.0075067426,
-0.0006284136,
0.0785958394,
-0.0601091906,
0.0711998567,
-0.0210885555,
0.0019052698,
0.0340353139,
0.0198652521,
0.003252802,
0.0335365161,
-0.010782307,
0.008137296,
-0.0302492343,
-0.0011139192,
0.0483467802,
-0.0173571073,
0.0750963613,
0.0315994956,
-0.0305639897,
-0.0198353734,
-0.0150084104,
0.0393961258,
0.0418797471,
-0.0234364681,
0.0181129538,
-0.0565904491,
0.0358947702,
0.0078803767,
-0.0085589141,
-0.0041939495,
-0.0040527778,
-0.0033436429,
0.0367357433,
0.0166767314,
-0.0251566228,
-0.0336621143,
0.0349825099,
-0.0031621067,
-0.0360800698,
-0.0278306268,
-6.755726195e-33,
-0.0359498113,
-0.0171080828,
-0.0059945304,
0.0550354831,
-0.0105869798,
0.0232175682,
-0.0576428808,
-0.0291814823,
-0.028954193,
0.0181226637,
0.0121136364,
0.0153017445,
0.0313627161,
-0.0384531952,
-0.0024284965,
-0.0261701625,
0.0388543531,
0.0168413185,
-0.0076740198,
0.0122529315,
0.0815990493,
0.057686042,
0.0697038621,
-0.1046220586,
0.0492176712,
0.0011674954,
0.0079628332,
-0.002387685,
0.0771710128,
0.0449783765,
0.0042365054,
0.0074397153,
0.052325923,
-0.0192047022,
-0.0086109219,
0.0333787873,
-0.1316739023,
-0.0324680768,
0.0512285903,
0.0232702941,
-0.0208201054,
-0.0197000951,
0.0052056396,
0.0108644413,
0.0543108806,
-0.0214897692,
0.0526189581,
-0.0236120373,
0.0182460193,
-0.0158255808,
-0.0497717746,
0.0822057053,
-0.0180906169,
-0.0039504427,
0.0474842191,
0.0078546992,
0.0297623482,
0.0252048504,
-0.051975783,
-0.0114199808,
-0.0404742137,
0.020862326,
-0.0082360571,
-0.0177195314,
-0.024149701,
0.0489413142,
-0.0300617404,
-0.0509443544,
-0.0407600477,
0.05768032,
0.0104613248,
0.0631414577,
0.0126855206,
0.0389114954,
0.0061957715,
0.0098781632,
-0.086769551,
0.0325810611,
0.0786683857,
0.0069364184,
-0.024703851,
0.0107426755,
-0.0461614728,
0.0120829968,
0.0018762134,
-0.0136930356,
-0.027597703,
0.0030119272,
0.0050461763,
-0.0177125614,
-0.0058128731,
0.0580552481,
0.0298273079,
-0.0230011605,
-0.0086925654,
0.0221723542,
0.0187119115,
0.0074675088,
0.0000979828,
0.0382180698,
-0.052941408,
-0.0307764243,
-0.0109755872,
-0.0071592517,
0.0304397587,
0.0133911725,
0.0116181057,
-0.0196903311,
0.0129639013,
-0.0130353626,
-0.0045568636,
-0.0214662198,
-0.0283073187,
0.0173313953,
0.017871011,
0.0200917032,
0.0006933393,
0.028821392,
0.0589372925,
0.0471781492,
-0.0231798105,
-0.0359577537,
-0.0211315025,
0.0149139445,
-0.0139955329,
0.0080683641,
-0.0188370142,
0.0228387844,
0.0054920227,
-0.034539368,
-0.0063819219,
0.0212510619,
2.694e-7,
0.0497443005,
0.0401602387,
0.0331815854,
0.0358175933,
-0.0205321573,
0.0004574974,
0.0020204401,
0.0459468476,
0.0011674984,
0.0111579085,
0.0076425672,
0.0297096819,
0.0413592532,
0.028804969,
-0.049631875,
-0.0766807571,
-0.0462972634,
-0.0073739798,
-0.0772847235,
0.0361078568,
0.0874240696,
0.0577429645,
0.0305532757,
0.0363221504,
-0.006028628,
-0.0179289058,
0.0117242243,
0.0048588729,
-0.0457395203,
0.0738761723,
0.012785065,
0.0020264008,
-0.0247693788,
0.0252475012,
-0.0063424543,
0.0505105034,
0.0163240638,
0.0488611348,
-0.0117036067,
0.0180060696,
-0.003858418,
-0.055649139,
0.0141939288,
-0.0803623646,
0.0756290331,
0.0050184135,
-0.0168405138,
-0.0008859808,
-0.0342642032,
0.0378290117,
-0.0457269512,
0.0286246631,
-0.0293199904,
0.0456130691,
0.0031119885,
-0.0069257836,
-0.0390996486,
-0.0843185186,
-0.0538787358,
0.0114078289,
-0.0037445081,
-0.0317818522,
0.0129785724,
-0.0717322752,
-0.0175294038,
-0.051251255,
-0.0339874662,
2.599439764e-34,
-0.0111995311,
0.0245849937,
-0.0451766327,
0.0781325102,
0.0580036268,
-0.0417502895,
-0.0150103392,
-0.0007391788,
0.0057005738,
-0.0321904905,
0.0096187769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14398v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14398v2 | Seeing and hearing what has not been said; A multimodal client behavior classifier in Motivational Interviewing with interpretable fusion | 2023-09-25T16:00:06 | 2023-09-27T08:30:20 | Lucie Galland, Catherine Pelachaud, Florian Pecune | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS | Motivational Interviewing (MI) is an approach to therapy that emphasizes
collaboration and encourages behavioral change. To evaluate the quality of an
MI conversation, client utterances can be classified using the MISC code as
either change talk, sustain talk, or follow/neutral talk. The proportion of
change talk in a MI conversation is positively correlated with therapy
outcomes, making accurate classification of client utterances essential. In
this paper, we present a classifier that accurately distinguishes between the
three MISC classes (change talk, sustain talk, and follow/neutral talk)
leveraging multimodal features such as text, prosody, facial expressivity, and
body expressivity. To train our model, we perform annotations on the publicly
available AnnoMI dataset to collect multimodal information, including text,
audio, facial expressivity, and body expressivity. Furthermore, we identify the
most important modalities in the decision-making process, providing valuable
insights into the interplay of different modalities during a MI conversation. | [
0.080400072,
0.0495071784,
-0.0229292102,
-0.005880761,
0.0004824437,
0.0231952555,
0.0180119034,
-0.0135875661,
-0.0613592081,
-0.0427083559,
-0.0110398233,
-0.0066111926,
0.0259791017,
0.0502022915,
0.0005297344,
-0.0688547567,
-0.0017153076,
0.04859633,
0.044353161,
0.0450181887,
0.0610611513,
0.0247842912,
-0.0466081649,
0.0639120564,
-0.0329164565,
-0.0327278562,
0.0075787702,
0.0299800746,
0.0058920779,
-0.0377026238,
-0.0173064098,
0.0518574938,
0.0177009311,
0.0147950156,
0.0000020981,
-0.0155279981,
-0.0263442788,
-0.0158260427,
-0.0283571146,
-0.0490404777,
0.0512753092,
-0.0258138105,
-0.0003605448,
0.0057235099,
-0.0150823966,
0.0275933687,
0.0508292429,
0.0760928094,
0.0918812901,
0.0434952229,
-0.0204532631,
0.0221233983,
-0.0252581704,
0.0295201316,
0.0087178433,
0.004497828,
-0.0372929387,
0.0217244606,
-0.015920531,
-0.0336784013,
-0.0267967302,
0.0111764194,
-0.048960004,
0.0172521304,
0.0272903219,
0.0081961229,
-0.0063339667,
-0.0535831265,
0.0021819349,
0.0688004568,
0.0406842157,
0.0538281202,
-0.0010548162,
-0.0072672814,
0.0216389131,
-0.0130598387,
-0.0289461724,
-0.0135664856,
0.0068208086,
-0.0018467152,
-0.0597288087,
0.0316828676,
-0.009463435,
-0.0279221721,
0.0128129851,
-0.0287900046,
-0.0350275822,
0.0004678037,
0.0500558838,
-0.0191727746,
0.006743317,
-0.0609824732,
-0.0256322492,
-0.0243690051,
-0.0451354198,
0.0144606521,
-0.0021813305,
-0.0230616033,
0.0019446035,
-0.0382081382,
-0.0138284937,
0.0221890211,
-0.0594392121,
-0.003389955,
0.0764205977,
-0.0063045104,
0.0379003435,
-0.008249891,
-0.0169747472,
0.01406141,
-0.0738820806,
-0.0043951077,
0.013841901,
-0.0006037294,
0.0030598284,
-0.053247463,
-0.0584710389,
0.0059939376,
-0.0653842315,
0.0162840113,
-0.0326131471,
-0.0031462652,
-0.0014714571,
0.0696056262,
0.0044621839,
0.05524626,
-0.0001587482,
0.0495186932,
0.0097664287,
-0.0764849558,
0.0653387383,
0.0063175187,
-0.01250418,
-0.0083284937,
0.0228361469,
0.0373830013,
-0.0312922299,
-0.0364333652,
-0.0264803991,
-0.0153145529,
-0.0596977212,
-0.0147790834,
0.0385727659,
-0.0095621208,
0.0052242563,
-0.0219037142,
0.0314266533,
-0.0394106917,
0.004538401,
-0.0290267877,
0.0184952151,
0.0945410728,
-0.0018890072,
-0.0020372781,
0.0389192104,
0.0394501761,
0.0242226403,
0.0327955224,
0.0233305618,
-0.0019099175,
0.0461431928,
-0.0699361861,
0.0170136336,
0.0180500932,
0.0081123635,
-0.0150473434,
0.0017642922,
-0.0363184772,
-0.0076657091,
0.0465214886,
-0.0034745284,
-0.0097770886,
-0.0089114793,
-0.0171499774,
0.028276423,
0.0333631337,
0.0461503677,
-0.014824803,
-0.0133464849,
0.0474007726,
-0.037907023,
-0.0093870359,
0.0014561332,
0.0186172277,
-0.0238567106,
-0.0492819063,
0.0257664025,
0.0029314212,
-0.0372618362,
-0.025010556,
-0.021613026,
-0.0253161304,
0.0000208597,
-0.0077733835,
-0.0230526347,
-0.0135580646,
-0.0121591855,
0.0027969668,
0.0049083894,
-0.0549772866,
-0.035036128,
-0.0398894772,
0.0244292095,
0.0479575023,
0.0232562516,
-0.0047253938,
-0.0294003785,
-0.0413945019,
-0.0142367212,
-0.0039866036,
-0.0022666955,
0.0155691411,
0.0293781832,
-0.0258294214,
-0.0245606694,
0.0132168615,
-0.0149759743,
-0.0058276504,
-0.0920359492,
-0.0155937858,
-0.0276815984,
0.0162065532,
-0.0116548659,
0.0414133705,
0.0076746368,
-0.008461359,
0.0097480947,
0.019052336,
0.0731800497,
0.0377542712,
-0.0236627292,
-0.006008504,
0.0215073433,
0.0146487448,
-0.0021602921,
0.1039854065,
-0.0273498017,
-0.0234257188,
-0.0045567332,
-0.0239707641,
0.0301756077,
-0.0201623067,
-0.0073921285,
-0.0103680175,
0.0284840427,
-0.0737053156,
0.0318700597,
-0.0134957777,
0.001332751,
0.0232889429,
0.0423352234,
0.0096981116,
-0.0245245863,
-0.0256854557,
0.0023608794,
-0.0182476491,
-0.0748678371,
0.0208933726,
-0.0395932384,
0.0091555417,
0.0112389894,
-0.0136489989,
-0.0139217377,
-0.017523678,
-0.0158596747,
-0.0349953845,
-0.024975827,
-0.1379373968,
-0.0286849309,
-0.0072897077,
-0.0456799641,
-0.0176097713,
-0.0112922797,
0.0062101418,
-0.0265985411,
-0.0405480899,
0.0039876639,
0.0335608721,
0.014691975,
-0.01795437,
0.0481828451,
0.0030357849,
-0.0131404912,
-0.007575342,
-0.0106621236,
0.057201542,
-0.0094166845,
-0.0130376117,
-0.0326095857,
-0.036350362,
-0.035471838,
0.0060638296,
-0.0286337193,
-0.0469512679,
0.0302699152,
0.0198517404,
0.0297755282,
0.0089365961,
0.0702777579,
0.0649494976,
-0.0213621072,
-0.0117421309,
-0.0291973911,
0.0034612385,
0.0391925238,
0.0008334179,
-0.0323716514,
-0.1084322855,
0.0173533279,
0.0260800123,
0.0270347297,
0.0336456671,
-0.0262761563,
-0.035250809,
0.0437786803,
-0.0205507632,
-0.0412723571,
0.0082774991,
-0.0089763571,
0.0191496443,
0.0187621005,
-0.0191009808,
0.0267924685,
-0.0309972204,
-0.0386371352,
-0.0301537514,
-0.0451510884,
-0.0144551219,
0.0530961044,
-0.0326657668,
0.0017656127,
0.0422936492,
-0.0114206113,
0.0361810513,
-0.0779862851,
0.0124201439,
-0.0158557147,
0.0372214764,
-0.045557972,
0.005165447,
0.0168268681,
0.0072651254,
-0.0430173799,
-0.0713478476,
-0.0097114807,
-0.0291053224,
-0.0094262687,
0.009817767,
-0.0279657505,
-0.0341678783,
0.0351939984,
0.026495995,
0.0239168666,
-0.0239944141,
0.0223617237,
-0.0048365574,
0.0243973713,
0.0810347795,
-0.0364957415,
-0.0344117694,
0.0082305148,
0.0312716588,
0.026041761,
0.0045745247,
-0.0566778705,
-0.0268384721,
-0.0133073712,
0.0539658293,
-0.0077553969,
-0.002756204,
0.0247195121,
0.0265325159,
0.012222386,
0.0738566369,
-0.0056326841,
-0.0323581621,
0.0070587583,
-0.0080714822,
-0.0121062454,
0.0089933565,
-0.0259988587,
-0.0829388648,
-0.0502669401,
-0.0246583931,
0.05635833,
-0.0405632667,
0.0109731583,
-0.0182312392,
-0.0205680747,
0.0480289049,
0.0101415906,
-0.0215244461,
-0.0030094483,
0.0089837601,
-0.0123751285,
-0.0301185865,
-0.0199648347,
-0.0358857624,
0.0080145812,
0.0029731339,
0.0300635714,
-0.0534030497,
-0.0551140197,
0.0690898374,
0.0178045835,
0.0539520569,
0.0316024832,
0.0686513111,
-0.0013050942,
-0.0601733401,
0.0186974779,
0.025792161,
0.0307099819,
0.0099747078,
0.0613920651,
-0.0361119173,
0.022370901,
0.0100690182,
0.0614982136,
0.0039978581,
0.0028775972,
0.0313286409,
0.0409305468,
-0.0658337399,
0.0320001543,
-0.0252948143,
0.0859057382,
0.0614104867,
0.026466364,
0.013922886,
-0.0607456565,
0.0236117858,
0.0333672799,
0.0543400273,
0.0389567763,
-0.0115268752,
-0.006100581,
-0.0272221211,
0.0112602497,
-0.0458323322,
-0.0355179086,
0.0064074183,
0.0211829729,
-0.0052406411,
-0.0178379398,
-0.0582906082,
0.0490731634,
-0.0413175784,
0.061913956,
0.0666228756,
0.0696725398,
-0.0284481179,
-0.0265388619,
0.0173825342,
-0.0350439958,
-0.0190817546,
0.0198526494,
0.0207165275,
-0.0020198936,
-0.0013327892,
0.031144252,
0.0238255337,
0.015396405,
0.0758138672,
-0.0201610699,
-0.0652267411,
0.0143933287,
-0.0032717267,
0.021470882,
0.0522487015,
0.0548743904,
-0.0217352323,
-0.0151297888,
0.0133810006,
0.0385205075,
-0.0417716354,
-0.0464672111,
-0.0609648302,
-0.0596992411,
-0.0280339569,
-0.0102504371,
0.0504532941,
-0.0216978919,
-0.0185791105,
-0.0435934477,
-0.0277505014,
0.0420899168,
0.0150008937,
-0.0626244769,
-0.0167021733,
-0.0224332958,
-0.0122228693,
-0.032387387,
-0.0092052743,
-0.079799436,
0.0038215329,
-0.0453494787,
0.0142319882,
0.0828555003,
0.0157173909,
-0.0737927705,
-0.011140842,
0.0007068268,
0.0175946541,
0.0284859389,
0.0325242691,
0.0127774226,
0.135708347,
0.0253577046,
-0.0051353797,
0.0200636256,
0.0491954945,
-0.009350487,
0.0196689889,
-0.0099856472,
0.0051187477,
0.0085041281,
0.0280764773,
0.0210897084,
-0.0114038931,
0.0412672088,
-0.013591608,
0.0524052754,
-0.0570565723,
-0.0374870859,
0.036438819,
-0.0212998297,
-0.0196573269,
-0.0082654627,
0.0062424322,
-0.0554107763,
0.002442243,
-0.0676900819,
-0.0148508614,
-0.0742881522,
0.0251936186,
0.054340031,
0.0490634963,
0.002154991,
0.019710267,
-0.054730095,
-0.0103944233,
0.0346329808,
-0.0392682292,
-0.0026324799,
-0.0319795981,
0.0394402891,
0.0292999726,
-0.0349415839,
-0.0203044731,
-0.0545909777,
-0.0027756526,
-0.0027026802,
0.0464873351,
0.0093272906,
-5.308754363e-33,
-0.0190794207,
-0.0315702744,
-0.0017914011,
0.0394103825,
-0.0573313646,
0.000636415,
-0.0033148068,
0.0071548033,
0.0126899686,
0.0025520625,
0.0452850387,
0.0342412777,
-0.0087514231,
0.0180454534,
0.0237422232,
0.0425914675,
0.0394058749,
-0.0133989817,
-0.0336632468,
-0.0067025721,
0.0515615977,
0.0303808171,
0.0444496535,
-0.1361142397,
0.0376579724,
0.0510821901,
-0.0616900995,
0.0122588724,
0.0129923243,
0.0332753137,
-0.0176142864,
0.0280143376,
0.0222233701,
-0.0207907148,
0.0120641524,
0.0093102995,
-0.0186320879,
-0.0082124332,
0.0127225695,
0.0206924491,
-0.0903090015,
0.0214347076,
0.019521853,
-0.0181552544,
-0.0013056149,
-0.0187530182,
0.0433766954,
-0.0340828747,
0.0172286388,
0.0548870452,
-0.0197979305,
0.0145179899,
-0.0489517041,
-0.0462697819,
-0.0028886762,
0.0675053746,
-0.0150204105,
-0.0307321288,
-0.0515964031,
0.0259135514,
0.019805545,
-0.0107324785,
0.0218407661,
0.0293758456,
-0.021116484,
0.0677441582,
0.049286969,
-0.0234597791,
0.0227995906,
-0.0183950774,
-0.009623087,
0.0540188141,
0.030140195,
0.057893157,
-0.0348934382,
-0.0333618857,
-0.0034238333,
0.028628692,
0.0394211896,
-0.0257565845,
0.0049646781,
0.0298517309,
-0.0168426912,
-0.0219103042,
-0.0114150932,
-0.015767904,
-0.0022077907,
-0.0154287759,
0.0145823155,
0.0017038427,
-0.0175047219,
0.068797119,
0.0435206965,
0.001381317,
0.0382697582,
0.0413760766,
-0.0329797864,
0.0229648799,
-0.0226993784,
-0.0671555251,
-0.0430287533,
-0.0071416637,
0.0531347096,
-0.0182788819,
0.0938556343,
-0.0180955697,
0.0046327673,
0.0107603567,
-0.0263894666,
-0.0332052857,
0.0400828347,
0.0622285195,
-0.0654347241,
0.0178393815,
-0.017398322,
0.0153595898,
-0.0458341055,
0.0747675076,
-0.0295764655,
0.02582963,
-0.0491824672,
-0.0517344959,
-0.0060685575,
0.0056852209,
-0.0453713648,
-0.0051678014,
0.0099510923,
-0.0530947596,
0.028334152,
0.0004925111,
0.0252462104,
-0.0124808233,
2.805e-7,
-0.0223928262,
0.0164800584,
0.0101625174,
-0.0434449315,
0.0583532453,
0.0855465382,
-0.0186038483,
0.0358673409,
0.0414627753,
-0.0424880423,
0.0512281284,
-0.0441864394,
0.0598516762,
0.0395372882,
0.0249245279,
-0.038274724,
-0.0233345497,
-0.0400306731,
-0.0464843735,
0.0229421537,
0.0886746272,
0.0747351944,
0.0050982945,
-0.041476123,
0.0248222463,
0.0413825549,
0.0279490352,
-0.0300445594,
-0.023639828,
-0.0149205877,
0.0345764346,
-0.0627466217,
-0.0037140183,
0.0314913802,
-0.0253693573,
-0.0084684994,
0.0165574867,
0.0477100238,
-0.0668814704,
-0.0721047968,
-0.0156547818,
0.0647220984,
-0.0573062748,
0.0333228372,
-0.0019305804,
-0.0506607369,
-0.0630951375,
-0.0614162423,
-0.0337474644,
-0.0571279787,
0.070786126,
0.0018018788,
-0.0092422124,
0.0326123163,
-0.0001127792,
-0.0152070224,
-0.0254451651,
-0.0594612099,
0.0234617982,
0.0180126317,
-0.0763227195,
-0.005543109,
0.0208452642,
-0.0051636598,
-0.0027892166,
-0.0708348751,
-0.016615171,
1.805720035e-34,
0.0009638395,
0.0307362061,
0.0266466234,
0.002984778,
0.0204732809,
0.0042970227,
-0.0134004122,
0.0279616732,
0.0287913419,
-0.028107034,
-0.0197860952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14233v1 | Urdu Poetry Generated by Using Deep Learning Techniques | 2023-09-25T15:44:24 | 2023-09-25T15:44:24 | Muhammad Shoaib Farooq, Ali Abbas | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This study provides Urdu poetry generated using different deep-learning
techniques and algorithms. The data was collected through the Rekhta website,
containing 1341 text files with several couplets. The data on poetry was not
from any specific genre or poet. Instead, it was a collection of mixed Urdu
poems and Ghazals. Different deep learning techniques, such as the model
applied Long Short-term Memory Networks (LSTM) and Gated Recurrent Unit (GRU),
have been used. Natural Language Processing (NLP) may be used in machine
learning to understand, analyze, and generate a language humans may use and
understand. Much work has been done on generating poetry for different
languages using different techniques. The collection and use of data were also
different for different researchers. The primary purpose of this project is to
provide a model that generates Urdu poems by using data completely, not by
sampling data. Also, this may generate poems in pure Urdu, not Roman Urdu, as
in the base paper. The results have shown good accuracy in the poems generated
by the model. | [
0.0345334709,
0.050116092,
-0.0312237162,
0.0600475594,
-0.0507179834,
0.0059886943,
0.0373566672,
-0.0352509059,
0.0187298972,
-0.0198741779,
0.019108776,
-0.0480196476,
0.0328393206,
0.0395498984,
0.0040344559,
-0.0486311391,
-0.0249649696,
-0.0143150995,
0.0320405513,
0.0069297329,
0.0029467428,
0.0225476287,
-0.03853314,
0.0380867124,
-0.0134746963,
-0.0178829506,
-0.029665051,
0.0213850271,
-0.0188460685,
-0.0124672884,
-0.0109481066,
0.0257348064,
-0.0117341215,
0.0343736671,
0.0000017417,
-0.0622888505,
-0.0352712646,
-0.0450326279,
0.0460257381,
-0.0270355903,
0.0432089046,
-0.0366464108,
-0.0409826152,
0.0018274132,
-0.0065611866,
0.0286423303,
0.0493490063,
0.0751352161,
0.0669465214,
0.1281726956,
0.001963434,
-0.1188666523,
0.0381223746,
-0.0060820687,
0.0020759488,
-0.0121525163,
0.0266763438,
0.0064725475,
-0.0137232328,
-0.0204157177,
-0.0609122217,
0.0064068595,
0.0085489033,
-0.0080953473,
0.0065211621,
0.0142000364,
0.0135852555,
-0.0106027126,
0.0449136011,
0.0402171724,
-0.0664203167,
-0.019194264,
0.030623382,
-0.0142614348,
-0.0413522571,
-0.0366283171,
-0.0369632132,
0.054691229,
-0.0048130676,
0.0545348525,
0.0179665666,
-0.0137956534,
-0.0065316795,
-0.0081421239,
0.0101460703,
-0.0197210293,
0.0113898357,
-0.0338575132,
-0.006473477,
-0.0313566364,
0.0288547669,
-0.0339559875,
0.0198074188,
0.0416688286,
0.014801004,
0.0222368855,
-0.0237610433,
-0.1068246663,
0.006612251,
-0.0214667413,
0.0645389482,
0.0461015776,
0.0244774818,
0.0048934883,
-0.0552362204,
0.0155669376,
-0.004279702,
-0.0133529697,
-0.0383624509,
0.0062091378,
-0.0149443001,
-0.0279314313,
-0.0564534068,
0.03240823,
-0.0355455689,
-0.0291513763,
-0.0726307407,
-0.0061592632,
0.0250041764,
-0.0216479748,
0.0208907258,
0.0430961885,
-0.037458919,
0.0043043615,
0.0029721193,
0.0147010256,
-0.0208434798,
0.0217947233,
-0.0287931338,
-0.0617072061,
0.0497064032,
0.028427517,
0.0441194102,
-0.0028290183,
0.0040799403,
0.072944276,
0.0256657992,
-0.0323400311,
-0.0701186508,
0.0016266251,
0.0235818867,
-0.0554292835,
0.0060509029,
-0.0866105184,
0.0461479798,
-0.0222235955,
-0.0137514267,
-0.0253166538,
0.0202548523,
0.0392615609,
-0.0209402237,
0.0563957691,
-0.0206778217,
0.0122948363,
0.0315143242,
-0.004667474,
0.0800334662,
0.0213140491,
0.0817155018,
0.0519297682,
-0.0123838056,
-0.0260863621,
0.0303898863,
-0.0080192937,
-0.0084854765,
-0.0287671909,
-0.0178679731,
-0.0542727001,
-0.0616554059,
0.0678953826,
0.0033589678,
0.0527623333,
0.0107819177,
0.0177273676,
0.0345236287,
0.0582793541,
0.0752936602,
0.1238247529,
0.039087683,
0.0189833995,
0.0604655966,
0.0243649762,
-0.0077435565,
0.0507900715,
0.0708356872,
0.0177351534,
0.0262876265,
0.0243898109,
-0.0045667621,
-0.0049511069,
0.0048848572,
-0.047208935,
0.0322191566,
-0.0549097657,
0.0531000532,
0.0296860375,
-0.0467951447,
-0.0248370152,
0.0189795122,
-0.0344084017,
0.0330640376,
-0.004185156,
0.0375929102,
0.0959941447,
0.0265246481,
-0.0056217005,
0.0291374959,
-0.0226633176,
-0.0367175005,
0.0347802192,
-0.0115176998,
0.0229156353,
-0.0073516658,
-0.0362973437,
0.0117209442,
-0.0281855185,
-0.0221809354,
0.0306344163,
-0.069211781,
0.0603642575,
0.0221509002,
0.0344353653,
-0.0745176971,
0.0283059329,
-0.02768391,
-0.0350212269,
0.028048547,
0.0245460551,
0.0298153646,
0.0402789712,
-0.0317495763,
0.0231825765,
0.0081613641,
-0.0194675904,
-0.037694145,
0.0241496935,
-0.0390470624,
-0.0368128084,
0.0128918821,
-0.1045493558,
0.0613357425,
0.0335834101,
-0.0205728691,
-0.0675961524,
0.0889547616,
-0.0140317166,
-0.0011048928,
-0.0182582531,
0.001226322,
0.0099829305,
0.0021368852,
0.010001462,
0.0176020022,
0.0210581794,
0.0310971308,
-0.0290385969,
0.0346643627,
0.0496244989,
-0.0221015997,
-0.0199528374,
0.0201562885,
0.0103155272,
0.0295049623,
0.0213440917,
0.0234090034,
-0.0292657204,
-0.0398505256,
-0.065910995,
0.0118265683,
0.0036812688,
-0.0355160125,
0.0028115523,
0.004513775,
-0.0134045566,
-0.0072859656,
-0.0660560727,
0.0096250707,
0.0421903208,
-0.0022869487,
0.0430659167,
-0.0026826342,
-0.0063442173,
-0.0221977178,
-0.041866459,
-0.0238927305,
0.0427924097,
0.006154398,
-0.0055632447,
0.0197308883,
-0.0147446375,
-0.0129101435,
0.0148357321,
0.0113914916,
-0.0512298793,
-0.0022685784,
-0.0411460996,
0.0162267927,
0.0410413481,
0.0132335462,
0.0006876837,
0.0276878886,
-0.0020731082,
0.0189693868,
-0.0029132287,
0.0042153751,
0.0362515971,
0.0069876225,
-0.0407679267,
-0.008960329,
0.0091959294,
0.0395070091,
-0.0310925245,
0.0044163517,
0.0149890492,
-0.0082099307,
0.0337286927,
0.0023906906,
0.0413492098,
-0.0225638691,
0.0394303426,
-0.0029280593,
0.0002916374,
0.0108607868,
-0.0210817903,
0.0067634117,
-0.0561465099,
0.0043850192,
-0.0619569831,
0.0034078599,
-0.0056701908,
0.0337043479,
-0.0516592748,
-0.0258550998,
-0.0264068097,
0.0086254161,
-0.0156960115,
-0.0309528541,
0.0075981473,
0.0010612541,
-0.0072157364,
-0.0494596064,
0.0193331297,
-0.0363076068,
0.0165203325,
0.006490401,
-0.0148326,
0.0475808308,
-0.0274534337,
0.0651321188,
-0.0154184802,
-0.0353745334,
0.0204111189,
-0.0361639932,
0.0173196886,
-0.0382295027,
0.0317812487,
0.0512954444,
-0.0384875648,
-0.0180774517,
0.0493295938,
0.0015785014,
-0.0346973538,
-0.0376419909,
0.0525936671,
-0.0763877034,
0.0307405535,
-0.0461242497,
-0.0143871028,
0.0422597788,
0.0090416307,
-0.0466062166,
-0.0565861873,
0.0101692593,
0.0619054697,
-0.0027747387,
-0.0052487426,
-0.020657951,
-0.0023476228,
-0.0403329954,
-0.0071737086,
-0.0093935039,
-0.0807568133,
0.008353672,
0.0150784515,
0.0232484415,
-0.0006304315,
-0.0308467913,
-0.0192168895,
-0.0691485256,
-0.0253854748,
-0.0097946655,
-0.0131906224,
-0.0224489719,
0.0008851167,
-0.0539855585,
0.0270675234,
-0.0186599344,
-0.000940761,
-0.0241348781,
0.0090816058,
0.0179946031,
-0.0118810916,
-0.0489402749,
-0.0394983515,
-0.0669979826,
0.0123235509,
0.0597919375,
0.0670275614,
-0.0522749051,
-0.0000757839,
-0.0281095393,
-0.0098624323,
-0.0041179806,
0.0186162069,
0.0001883331,
0.0249418616,
-0.0093905674,
-0.0124240061,
0.0223324914,
-0.0398619622,
0.0298828129,
-0.0122127654,
0.0243089981,
-0.0220883116,
-0.030281622,
-0.038343925,
0.0140403369,
0.0117041273,
0.0381154567,
0.0269448031,
-0.0441158004,
-0.075018622,
-0.0194534659,
-0.0241485536,
-0.1285726875,
-0.0427094772,
0.0062730387,
-0.0002285037,
-0.0417457931,
-0.0540815182,
-0.0646417663,
-0.0193254892,
0.0065735574,
0.0652170256,
0.0539532863,
0.0476372689,
-0.0214881338,
-0.0562802777,
-0.0535294935,
-0.0225837026,
0.0129259806,
-0.0177076068,
-0.0411366224,
0.003984883,
-0.0658929422,
0.0348887146,
0.0069904872,
-0.0981003195,
-0.0224694498,
0.0410000868,
0.0088209389,
0.0117540015,
-0.0043994226,
-0.0027636001,
-0.0317954272,
0.0260754768,
0.0209023431,
0.0357962735,
-0.0087093301,
0.0073676822,
0.0430138074,
-0.0082982359,
0.0189297907,
-0.0121558262,
0.0240251236,
0.0141294962,
-0.0077884113,
0.0652150661,
-0.035852585,
0.0229341127,
-0.0155850928,
0.0051273704,
-0.034941487,
-0.0392208993,
-0.0307270847,
-0.0378380716,
-0.023944702,
0.0144103402,
-0.0115554817,
-0.0126629826,
0.072089076,
0.0499784052,
-0.0045429994,
-0.044567626,
0.0636290759,
-0.0221213251,
-0.0006308465,
0.0354356617,
0.0415181443,
0.0167966485,
-0.01866032,
0.0147228967,
-0.0047599063,
-0.023011338,
-0.0412508845,
0.0071452195,
0.0112078078,
-0.0498600267,
0.0115519362,
0.003894994,
-0.0085173715,
0.0370970033,
0.0052018687,
-0.0187106933,
-0.031035088,
0.0136660431,
0.1070416421,
-0.0386654884,
0.0064927414,
-0.0319640562,
0.0332245752,
-0.0215034243,
0.0532794707,
0.0072691599,
0.0145054236,
-0.0384179763,
-0.0202917196,
-0.0196749214,
-0.0294034146,
0.0536796749,
0.0271399543,
-0.0108469147,
0.0591373853,
-0.0158393886,
-0.0367238931,
0.0174098704,
-0.0211614687,
-0.0084244823,
-0.0102153793,
0.0132024158,
0.0151694976,
-0.0419188812,
0.0501409061,
-0.0240886584,
0.0512091182,
-0.0055715935,
0.0425073281,
0.0360145792,
0.0080945427,
0.0314618163,
-0.0473552309,
0.0385441743,
-0.0232554413,
-0.0591977462,
-0.0198874231,
-5.579490181e-33,
-0.0194990579,
-0.0177239962,
-0.0233418178,
-0.002858904,
-0.017179437,
-0.0327435397,
-0.0521529615,
-0.0106819626,
0.0095152594,
-0.0024742461,
-0.0175033715,
-0.0132875331,
0.0112256398,
0.0187614933,
0.0417895839,
0.0030478893,
0.0470378436,
-0.0217179153,
0.0222451519,
0.0177809857,
0.0622138754,
0.0610599667,
0.0495726876,
-0.0752593204,
0.0252051614,
-0.0665513128,
0.0075791185,
-0.0236606132,
0.0074918214,
0.0160187557,
-0.0409383774,
0.0303353295,
0.034843374,
0.0027492298,
-0.0324728712,
0.024775004,
-0.068773441,
-0.0364432372,
-0.0167710409,
0.0570227318,
-0.0319215991,
-0.0606878698,
0.0618838817,
-0.0075257136,
-0.0214125346,
0.0468459353,
0.0220337361,
-0.0157110766,
0.0133594004,
-0.090613164,
-0.069808051,
-0.0214781128,
-0.0182404295,
-0.0110666137,
0.0118233897,
-0.0198380426,
-0.0070147743,
0.0273024589,
-0.0558249615,
0.0133389607,
0.0020004401,
0.0429871976,
-0.0015958985,
0.0034400299,
-0.0034383903,
0.01608558,
-0.0064089391,
-0.039043989,
-0.0194103718,
0.0696859062,
0.0329407081,
0.0034474907,
0.0429250821,
0.031550508,
0.0798484236,
-0.0647403225,
-0.0586975068,
0.0375521407,
0.0234623663,
0.0189126376,
0.0421566665,
0.0082437564,
-0.0174568407,
-0.0091075059,
0.0725739226,
-0.0456791706,
-0.0065943282,
-0.0432500988,
0.0288493522,
0.0152660292,
-0.0199119337,
0.0368425362,
-0.008117618,
-0.0706298873,
0.0275304541,
0.0358398966,
-0.0567710213,
0.0320306197,
0.0013703041,
0.0063532912,
-0.0181389563,
-0.0765003636,
0.0354437754,
0.0069173467,
0.0261214022,
0.0154450862,
0.0444247723,
0.0375434346,
-0.0503529683,
0.0155038359,
-0.013979503,
0.0355862863,
0.0314055867,
0.0659666657,
-0.0283067226,
-0.030065719,
0.0034737755,
0.0344295427,
0.0336116962,
0.031050276,
-0.0186701845,
0.0057951733,
0.0037614887,
-0.0081426324,
-0.0249452814,
0.0314067453,
-0.0614396892,
-0.0153955193,
0.0044365511,
-0.0489580296,
0.0037434793,
0.0039882138,
2.575e-7,
0.0065447721,
0.0013107737,
0.0849467292,
0.0296598449,
0.0206915103,
-0.006936674,
-0.0532035343,
0.062799722,
-0.0326539353,
0.0458750017,
0.0449074432,
-0.0064816461,
0.0127466535,
0.0121186506,
-0.143655479,
0.031957522,
-0.0475839451,
0.0004852703,
-0.0859995037,
0.0011581265,
0.0277485661,
0.0726503357,
-0.0006570462,
-0.0143355969,
0.0332369208,
-0.0312768631,
0.0206557941,
0.0435329638,
0.0379365161,
-0.0131772254,
0.024935443,
0.0179426838,
0.0059448769,
-0.044042699,
-0.0047024949,
0.0316174142,
0.0326058641,
0.0305876136,
-0.0014771009,
-0.0102364263,
0.0582955852,
-0.0151306381,
0.0242878497,
-0.0156498086,
0.0320728905,
0.0660002902,
-0.0420071781,
0.0062459121,
0.0309732016,
0.0062692459,
0.0331891961,
-0.0412022509,
0.0009727089,
-0.0511907451,
0.0238352828,
-0.0455028564,
0.038594313,
-0.0208188109,
-0.0159849171,
-0.0114270486,
-0.0199743845,
0.0239076987,
0.0068714712,
-0.0108583877,
0.0619056672,
-0.0467602164,
-0.0068147769,
1.92664672e-34,
0.0531201959,
-0.0134208016,
0.007639457,
-0.001685028,
0.0129940808,
0.0119612515,
-0.0209437646,
0.0128866611,
-0.0209353101,
-0.0343289524,
-0.0697562546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14394v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14394v1 | Multiple Noises in Diffusion Model for Semi-Supervised Multi-Domain Translation | 2023-09-25T15:31:16 | 2023-09-25T15:31:16 | Tsiry Mayet, Simon Bernard, Clement Chatelain, Romain Herault | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Domain-to-domain translation involves generating a target domain sample given
a condition in the source domain. Most existing methods focus on fixed input
and output domains, i.e. they only work for specific configurations (i.e. for
two domains, either $D_1\rightarrow{}D_2$ or $D_2\rightarrow{}D_1$). This paper
proposes Multi-Domain Diffusion (MDD), a conditional diffusion framework for
multi-domain translation in a semi-supervised context. Unlike previous methods,
MDD does not require defining input and output domains, allowing translation
between any partition of domains within a set (such as $(D_1,
D_2)\rightarrow{}D_3$, $D_2\rightarrow{}(D_1, D_3)$, $D_3\rightarrow{}D_1$,
etc. for 3 domains), without the need to train separate models for each domain
configuration. The key idea behind MDD is to leverage the noise formulation of
diffusion models by incorporating one noise level per domain, which allows
missing domains to be modeled with noise in a natural way. This transforms the
training task from a simple reconstruction task to a domain translation task,
where the model relies on less noisy domains to reconstruct more noisy domains.
We present results on a multi-domain (with more than two domains) synthetic
image translation dataset with challenging semantic domain inversion. | [
0.0229377337,
0.0153723955,
0.0201145336,
0.0063477936,
-0.0088480804,
-0.0019115804,
0.0589856841,
0.0067978073,
-0.0265915301,
0.006468581,
-0.041600246,
-0.0518313795,
-0.0103671802,
-0.0058562323,
0.0364892483,
-0.0431065932,
-0.0136614647,
-0.0198619068,
-0.0523110218,
-0.0090968674,
-0.0619861111,
-0.0000229909,
0.0170693323,
-0.0213377848,
-0.0332065187,
0.0122171408,
0.0095281675,
0.0555450618,
0.023778392,
-0.0103199603,
-0.0085002081,
0.0214062892,
0.0422587432,
-0.0284888335,
0.000002308,
-0.020246068,
-0.0395468436,
0.0392235443,
0.0461339466,
-0.0200787894,
0.0649379492,
-0.0443232208,
-0.0098347934,
-0.007808344,
-0.0039987136,
-0.0509585962,
0.0607187897,
0.0376071855,
0.0404759385,
0.0630850419,
-0.0552796684,
-0.0965864658,
-0.0630724356,
-0.0593128279,
0.0104973912,
-0.0611228384,
0.024777554,
0.0502995141,
-0.0619549938,
-0.0167553443,
-0.0266829319,
0.0285544805,
0.0150044141,
-0.0095082112,
-0.0010605218,
-0.0037662538,
0.0584077984,
-0.0627859011,
-0.0102504045,
0.0409792513,
-0.0103758415,
0.0589462705,
0.0240509696,
0.015847696,
0.0368564427,
0.0245307069,
-0.018996045,
-0.0236563385,
-0.0111502511,
-0.0008870671,
-0.0827580541,
0.0443767533,
0.0307014361,
-0.0337856971,
-0.0286489557,
-0.0141455391,
0.0163252465,
0.0056488952,
-0.0273803398,
0.0318134092,
-0.0151887722,
0.0171209816,
0.079558365,
-0.0137640778,
0.0143487407,
0.0032238716,
-0.0833088905,
-0.068170391,
-0.0274153743,
-0.0195917413,
0.0282127317,
0.0013094323,
-0.0273030382,
0.0446742587,
-0.0299650244,
-0.0265927296,
-0.074168168,
0.0020516452,
-0.0620595291,
-0.0382644534,
-0.0064610052,
0.0400659107,
-0.0287337489,
0.0329283997,
-0.0423304141,
0.0287880562,
-0.0281575639,
-0.018173404,
0.005671164,
-0.0464533307,
0.0394918844,
0.0245712958,
-0.0696800575,
-0.035946399,
0.015562715,
0.0270141941,
-0.0153329531,
0.0383239463,
0.050684087,
0.0239005852,
-0.0496672727,
0.0320142061,
0.0288983993,
-0.0508279204,
-0.0243070647,
0.1274807453,
-0.0369356647,
0.0150906388,
-0.0651832446,
-0.0057447292,
-0.0012831362,
-0.0650730729,
0.0617276132,
-0.033746291,
0.0280732755,
0.0014425326,
0.0466022156,
-0.084741354,
-0.0158500019,
-0.0421676449,
0.0060560992,
0.0494706966,
0.000357192,
-0.0031754475,
0.0452238545,
0.0375895202,
-0.0141343791,
0.0549022034,
0.0090441247,
-0.0087121623,
-0.0415172093,
0.0064206515,
-0.0480038263,
0.0184807386,
0.0330362283,
0.0489340238,
0.0064793499,
-0.01560946,
0.0229389165,
0.0385229513,
0.0517299138,
0.0127045913,
-0.0345755555,
-0.0299388357,
0.028252067,
-0.0075456835,
-0.0222644303,
0.0123833558,
0.106831111,
-0.0175139159,
-0.0484384112,
0.0578190759,
0.0320506655,
0.0180026591,
0.0200147051,
-0.0299560092,
0.0159441438,
0.0557069629,
-0.0283212196,
-0.0371892005,
0.0624271631,
-0.0297231991,
0.0137862964,
-0.0252240412,
0.0724302977,
0.0641987249,
-0.0373129249,
0.0272239726,
-0.013638583,
-0.0587316528,
0.0100526949,
-0.006455115,
-0.0274949577,
0.0180657059,
-0.013906071,
-0.0081064748,
-0.0062712589,
-0.0176437367,
0.0573497005,
0.0458637439,
0.0079472344,
0.0510732196,
0.0547395423,
-0.0214915704,
-0.0568462461,
0.0334465504,
0.0164499786,
0.0112724854,
-0.0070789969,
0.0005082669,
0.0343765803,
-0.0487753227,
0.0201158356,
0.0200760178,
-0.0652528778,
0.0316641852,
0.0333502367,
0.0085342508,
0.0100362087,
0.0115769776,
-0.0593140051,
-0.022353068,
-0.0007131263,
-0.0240801238,
-0.0489930585,
0.0087660057,
0.0092687272,
-0.0196582135,
0.0287220702,
-0.0513572544,
-0.0405024253,
0.0015658427,
-0.0255532973,
-0.0292290356,
0.0420485698,
0.0388132967,
-0.0208110884,
-0.011565295,
0.0100337528,
0.0490521938,
0.0292384345,
-0.0168820899,
0.0354739539,
0.0306279045,
-0.021173263,
-0.0010732126,
-0.0010904386,
-0.0013137663,
0.0213422067,
0.0153659349,
-0.0497023091,
-0.023043016,
0.0302702878,
-0.003039975,
-0.0013937565,
-0.0226241034,
0.0041622738,
0.0169082191,
0.0089362729,
-0.017932931,
0.0005418038,
-0.0171588305,
0.0751248896,
0.0190384723,
0.0049623433,
0.0189334247,
0.0153685976,
-0.0485447273,
0.008167062,
-0.008630286,
-0.0056641782,
0.0290246513,
-0.0011618128,
-0.0012768041,
0.0252090525,
0.0462881662,
0.0013063839,
-0.0487400815,
-0.0375860408,
0.1038512364,
-0.001749402,
0.0170120951,
-0.0057459008,
-0.0379795507,
-0.0334123932,
0.0017643647,
0.053390041,
0.0057239481,
-0.0333485939,
-0.006334079,
0.0035483083,
-0.0097008971,
-0.0088243512,
0.0021047345,
-0.0301185492,
0.0060757343,
-0.0515663773,
-0.0253947247,
-0.0130034909,
0.0231512506,
0.0320858657,
-0.0218034275,
-0.0129908901,
-0.0300965663,
0.0022186034,
-0.0601761453,
-0.0019652736,
0.0402285904,
0.0336668491,
0.0255336035,
-0.0231102239,
0.0079637179,
0.0684380233,
-0.0174659975,
-0.0049650078,
-0.0590336956,
-0.0105075613,
0.0137164695,
-0.0302335117,
-0.0329197757,
0.0434692129,
0.0706868693,
-0.0056873029,
-0.0462988615,
0.0038760162,
0.024475703,
0.0225654803,
0.0197403803,
-0.0476811416,
0.0184309613,
0.0064710127,
0.0014803698,
-0.0059987772,
-0.0081462767,
0.0520700142,
-0.0198214073,
-0.034222804,
-0.0627019331,
-0.0503077656,
-0.0136840027,
0.002075617,
0.0592925847,
0.0392255373,
-0.031528499,
0.0057913428,
0.0599066168,
0.0110095935,
0.009776935,
-0.0287826639,
-0.0614212491,
0.0096350377,
0.0383891314,
-0.0165885258,
-0.0415148027,
-0.0571103506,
-0.0109795537,
-0.0160933901,
0.0617960915,
0.0051913145,
-0.0219171084,
0.0715942234,
-0.0123416083,
-0.0245631021,
0.052644264,
-0.0054289359,
-0.0310516749,
-0.0283108968,
-0.0036195514,
0.0364585184,
0.0241945274,
-0.016670119,
-0.0515970029,
-0.056259837,
-0.0308125671,
-0.008665123,
0.034883853,
0.0488918759,
0.0143766645,
-0.0621211752,
0.0683599338,
0.0421001911,
-0.0388217233,
-0.0440786816,
-0.0444468595,
0.0119733084,
0.007300707,
-0.0269708708,
-0.0738177747,
0.0250843074,
-0.0329353772,
0.0273182541,
0.0739380866,
-0.0794167593,
-0.0349996276,
-0.047951743,
0.005949961,
0.0723534152,
-0.0098201893,
-0.0054143695,
-0.020759197,
0.0682971478,
0.0462134741,
0.0017396335,
0.0022844356,
0.0726097822,
0.0358533338,
-0.0146949114,
0.0230784472,
0.019854961,
-0.0717592835,
0.0127646094,
-0.0012921225,
0.0694468468,
-0.0021789041,
0.0084102051,
-0.0230383445,
-0.0180764105,
0.0661159307,
0.0177778136,
-0.008154396,
-0.0564547367,
0.017538676,
-0.0168825816,
0.0121496813,
-0.0279592667,
-0.0332582295,
-0.007856328,
-0.0578452274,
-0.1107407361,
-0.0398038886,
0.0105040558,
-0.0011067303,
0.0712324828,
0.0311624072,
-0.0001310235,
0.0223145317,
-0.0176064074,
-0.0400852636,
-0.0077593247,
-0.0251239575,
0.0274422374,
-0.0021081835,
-0.0082265511,
0.0852898136,
-0.0350670367,
0.0059066983,
0.0242004525,
-0.0748258084,
-0.0340792052,
-0.0331873298,
0.012433812,
0.0127651012,
0.0166326426,
-0.0374437533,
0.032630723,
0.0150100561,
0.0249740016,
-0.0067994203,
0.0000596371,
0.0536618866,
-0.0840802342,
-0.016416423,
0.0085840235,
-0.0153760053,
0.0527859926,
-0.0119656343,
-0.0016932646,
0.0068952488,
0.0252337046,
0.0255212858,
-0.0299766287,
0.0751581788,
0.0039592665,
0.0234477222,
-0.0233031623,
-0.0181176402,
-0.0082260985,
-0.0455124453,
-0.0695815012,
-0.0181136075,
0.061999552,
0.0123265656,
0.0264753867,
0.0129982317,
0.0113355126,
0.0214918572,
-0.0149868997,
0.0037007695,
-0.0169316474,
0.0305887628,
0.0136983143,
0.0379028581,
0.0542046539,
-0.0058290106,
0.031554088,
-0.0152758425,
0.0227218438,
0.0048723724,
-0.0047652335,
0.0534298383,
0.0143067623,
-0.0126420083,
-0.0025467807,
0.011534621,
-0.0327853635,
0.0092200646,
0.0387249775,
0.0125175109,
0.0904565081,
0.0217089523,
-0.012850523,
-0.0253118649,
0.0469552763,
0.0241992567,
-0.0096963244,
0.034329962,
-0.0473114997,
0.0437823683,
0.0061585461,
0.0599961616,
-0.0116175795,
0.0421847403,
-0.011724093,
-0.0157985929,
-0.0097726882,
-0.0580462031,
-0.0133040445,
-0.0431901626,
0.0098775299,
-0.0103711924,
-0.0163833871,
-0.0922252387,
-0.0448084585,
-0.0381516814,
-0.0104955705,
0.0253478959,
0.0266087316,
0.0607382357,
-0.0430479571,
0.0001634868,
-0.0281020254,
-0.0366279557,
0.0325819664,
-0.0445672944,
0.0387949534,
-6.245165652e-33,
-0.02022033,
-0.0268331692,
0.0297044851,
-0.0557856336,
-0.0260481853,
-0.0591658726,
-0.0328719988,
-0.0076180459,
-0.0015544138,
0.0320901424,
0.0160895716,
0.0472967736,
0.0211374257,
0.011347441,
-0.0075617656,
0.0006151192,
0.0789069906,
-0.0271359775,
0.0221913699,
-0.0148272505,
0.0177967045,
0.0262852143,
0.0656379312,
-0.0960266665,
-0.0129740331,
0.0484745838,
-0.0314137898,
-0.0366858244,
0.0501923859,
-0.0157051031,
0.0219913032,
-0.0035039426,
-0.0107502928,
-0.0588197745,
-0.0603876412,
-0.0474144518,
-0.0809213221,
0.0018878489,
-0.0022578901,
0.0234660674,
-0.0215656757,
-0.050918445,
0.0352136008,
0.0170733165,
0.022620881,
-0.0363206416,
0.037880864,
-0.0599215515,
-0.0027911749,
-0.0295585096,
-0.0380312912,
0.0396020859,
-0.014592641,
-0.0517725237,
0.0080534751,
0.0391340554,
0.0084886057,
-0.0040194001,
-0.0588342361,
0.0040959246,
-0.04160605,
0.0177127924,
0.036483448,
-0.0050198985,
-0.0224701073,
0.0025849128,
0.0431934744,
-0.0123951323,
0.0592816249,
-0.0089022806,
-0.0168850683,
0.0212435164,
-0.0193042941,
0.0372957997,
0.0279985145,
-0.0476836301,
-0.0953760892,
0.07064794,
-0.099574469,
-0.0309721809,
0.0360908285,
0.0205542445,
0.0183147676,
-0.001798241,
-0.006995881,
-0.0102804136,
0.0117036123,
-0.0140773794,
-0.0054208757,
0.0035141408,
-0.0323190875,
0.0002993324,
0.0621413104,
-0.0171440318,
-0.0221606027,
-0.0192320701,
-0.0089906175,
0.0514752045,
-0.0166699514,
-0.0072902627,
0.0380478688,
-0.0573588274,
0.0134254601,
0.0844097286,
-0.0029232365,
-0.0038065477,
0.0187109504,
0.0052849343,
-0.0125337662,
-0.0217252318,
-0.04316267,
0.0157156661,
0.009809671,
0.0571444966,
-0.0213111266,
-0.0086495411,
-0.0139425416,
0.0504035018,
-0.0019106577,
-0.0438417532,
-0.0107478993,
0.0721954852,
-0.0064903456,
0.0326888561,
-0.0476068221,
-0.0116158016,
-0.0352952406,
-0.006851437,
0.0884528011,
-0.0352056921,
-0.0426745526,
-0.0071241814,
2.95e-7,
0.0369334668,
0.0189239606,
-0.0233424418,
-0.0169377141,
0.004110842,
0.0729327053,
-0.0226742812,
0.0444180481,
0.0063578589,
-0.027543569,
0.0022889425,
0.0384481139,
0.0216533728,
0.0067714765,
-0.076148726,
-0.0257322788,
0.0811683983,
-0.0001859802,
0.0082363505,
-0.0004152722,
-0.0039883303,
0.040453326,
-0.01810956,
-0.0181418657,
0.0393233523,
0.0472493581,
0.0782844573,
-0.0023575209,
-0.0138523616,
0.0069530886,
-0.0553424582,
-0.0012626072,
-0.0151322046,
0.0180732887,
-0.0201151334,
0.0007319062,
0.0889274329,
0.0389678255,
-0.0153367901,
0.0037293965,
0.0314378962,
0.0317977592,
-0.0116482032,
0.0618475042,
0.0196215399,
-0.0553376265,
-0.0180982668,
0.0260947701,
-0.0482593738,
0.0348819047,
0.0424513258,
0.0023908634,
-0.0250398386,
0.0085571436,
0.0234771278,
0.042999655,
-0.0396385156,
-0.0099865012,
0.0118302172,
-0.0259561557,
-0.0517574213,
-0.0136204138,
0.0090995692,
-0.0041125556,
0.0147468084,
0.0038815709,
-0.0506521054,
2.371335545e-34,
0.034903612,
0.0021746827,
0.0155881364,
-0.0073018656,
-0.0173774194,
-0.0217725094,
-0.0649489313,
-0.0164145399,
-0.0396515392,
0.0102197547,
-0.0204628203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14213v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14213v1 | Autonomous Vehicles an overview on system, cyber security, risks, issues, and a way forward | 2023-09-25T15:19:09 | 2023-09-25T15:19:09 | Md Aminul Islam, Sarah Alqahtani | cs.CE | cs.CE, cs.CL | This chapter explores the complex realm of autonomous cars, analyzing their
fundamental components and operational characteristics. The initial phase of
the discussion is elucidating the internal mechanics of these automobiles,
encompassing the crucial involvement of sensors, artificial intelligence (AI)
identification systems, control mechanisms, and their integration with
cloud-based servers within the framework of the Internet of Things (IoT). It
delves into practical implementations of autonomous cars, emphasizing their
utilization in forecasting traffic patterns and transforming the dynamics of
transportation. The text also explores the topic of Robotic Process Automation
(RPA), illustrating the impact of autonomous cars on different businesses
through the automation of tasks. The primary focus of this investigation lies
in the realm of cybersecurity, specifically in the context of autonomous
vehicles. A comprehensive analysis will be conducted to explore various risk
management solutions aimed at protecting these vehicles from potential threats
including ethical, environmental, legal, professional, and social dimensions,
offering a comprehensive perspective on their societal implications. A
strategic plan for addressing the challenges and proposing strategies for
effectively traversing the complex terrain of autonomous car systems,
cybersecurity, hazards, and other concerns are some resources for acquiring an
understanding of the intricate realm of autonomous cars and their ramifications
in contemporary society, supported by a comprehensive compilation of resources
for additional investigation.
Keywords: RPA, Cyber Security, AV, Risk, Smart Cars | [
0.0134845395,
0.0002302159,
-0.0280630141,
0.010383823,
-0.0495598614,
-0.0135695776,
0.051537104,
-0.0261635967,
-0.0162825081,
-0.0650247037,
0.0871885195,
0.0916000977,
-0.0353628844,
0.0300711896,
0.0308263563,
-0.0039191796,
0.0000614595,
-0.0762050077,
0.0011993584,
0.0407723859,
0.0045189909,
-0.0211381316,
0.0033803959,
-0.0018186786,
-0.0500763841,
-0.0156621318,
0.0443196706,
0.0004675706,
0.0761968568,
-0.0210274234,
0.0085478323,
-0.0149304867,
0.0777031556,
0.0234964062,
0.0000021166,
0.0012852505,
-0.0214812979,
0.0281137899,
0.0012570075,
-0.0445650071,
-0.0066582984,
0.0487181619,
0.0019377611,
0.0624787994,
-0.0074944813,
0.0162388198,
0.0343392715,
0.0354373083,
0.0007037378,
0.0568468273,
-0.031818144,
0.0222946536,
-0.0270870551,
0.0425066426,
-0.1117530167,
-0.0116433864,
0.0277305804,
0.0010721358,
0.0036089947,
-0.0188498907,
-0.0138581088,
-0.0136333033,
0.035654325,
-0.0258303136,
0.0021247845,
0.0672174245,
0.0162322484,
-0.0486752428,
-0.0150955869,
-0.0382199995,
-0.0154688321,
-0.0581258461,
0.0502155125,
0.0384013206,
-0.0259538498,
-0.0719261691,
-0.0117818294,
-0.0201510023,
0.0266109779,
0.0130856698,
-0.060183797,
0.0342596471,
-0.020126516,
-0.007415764,
-0.0126270745,
0.0374883413,
0.0325515978,
0.000156609,
-0.0091140149,
0.0207573995,
0.0508417375,
-0.0495771542,
0.0097614713,
0.0220199153,
-0.0158867333,
-0.0467773862,
0.0170578584,
-0.0021592809,
-0.0056733503,
0.0011972741,
-0.0037875653,
-0.0468793921,
0.0030555835,
-0.022382373,
0.0234455764,
0.0295594297,
0.0201499593,
0.026647035,
-0.0251113791,
-0.0110652717,
-0.0314422734,
0.0037505766,
-0.0212365203,
-0.0177721512,
0.0342242159,
0.0335081108,
0.057847295,
0.0408510268,
-0.0020543656,
0.0508651659,
-0.074021101,
0.0473149642,
0.0197026357,
-0.0057464158,
0.0313392393,
-0.0364351012,
-0.0343951248,
0.017592432,
0.0026118224,
-0.0010225103,
0.0138492575,
0.0073007457,
-0.0090607731,
-0.0486766845,
-0.0156318136,
0.0757653639,
0.0013339537,
-0.0236228947,
-0.0221660379,
-0.0248482563,
-0.0005791144,
-0.0420726873,
-0.0052278759,
-0.0084563196,
-0.0015428731,
0.0077886819,
-0.0117239542,
0.0447139852,
-0.0033511352,
-0.0451529399,
-0.0028299415,
0.0076327017,
-0.0074323076,
0.007317319,
0.0278549828,
-0.012324837,
0.0140396813,
-0.0177636333,
0.0253030974,
0.020357484,
0.0337640308,
0.0106559172,
0.0297636837,
0.0070803915,
-0.0085929893,
0.0202699099,
0.0387371369,
0.0345507525,
-0.0186365116,
-0.0103262495,
-0.0039341273,
0.0068533169,
0.0167288873,
0.0214272365,
0.0376551785,
-0.0121623157,
-0.0956446379,
0.0060636974,
-0.0306706447,
0.0575765595,
0.0077262544,
-0.0477890261,
0.0075577423,
-0.0071214112,
-0.0506771728,
-0.0288736727,
-0.0536208972,
0.0538281091,
-0.0366082601,
-0.0124628441,
0.0026406108,
-0.0551758446,
0.0324810036,
0.0119577786,
0.0040921578,
-0.0443407483,
0.0284021609,
-0.0824454948,
-0.0702080503,
0.060714446,
-0.0150047988,
-0.0753287226,
-0.0037402483,
-0.0121831996,
0.0258516688,
-0.0134926913,
-0.0664842203,
-0.0180368572,
-0.0442591459,
-0.0620877817,
-0.0620726533,
0.0219162051,
0.0069198566,
0.0230409484,
-0.0273194946,
0.0417597443,
0.0211660154,
-0.0245729145,
-0.0296724588,
0.0430346206,
0.0084164925,
-0.002263485,
0.0064173471,
-0.0108994897,
0.0370572917,
-0.0134337936,
-0.037643481,
0.0679156333,
-0.0329575464,
-0.021153504,
-0.0157358982,
0.0592090786,
0.0437711105,
0.0271056183,
-0.0003068051,
0.0454732403,
0.1000116691,
0.1391755491,
0.0157601684,
-0.0742712095,
0.0099953432,
0.101842545,
-0.0043496522,
-0.0343582369,
-0.0188643429,
-0.0107393768,
-0.040820837,
0.0459983423,
0.0019715109,
0.0345701538,
0.0420026369,
0.002480905,
-0.041545067,
0.0588999949,
-0.0513109416,
0.027984526,
0.0092564635,
0.0538443029,
-0.0049069598,
-0.0192436744,
-0.0163237266,
-0.0211334173,
-0.0488165356,
-0.0084223254,
-0.0508523397,
0.0176746864,
0.0644616336,
0.0182536952,
-0.00694515,
-0.0146505674,
-0.0253851898,
0.0076593608,
-0.0073046484,
-0.0128576588,
-0.0479897521,
0.0737399831,
0.029737575,
-0.0214124098,
-0.0182280652,
0.0331171378,
0.0055480432,
-0.0658232644,
0.053119909,
0.0090660835,
0.0050144517,
-0.0092420047,
0.073770754,
-0.012172671,
-0.0690075234,
-0.0042700954,
-0.034230046,
0.0114263371,
-0.012279449,
-0.044064559,
0.0024734593,
0.0430268645,
0.0056755389,
0.0952829495,
0.0352276564,
-0.041918017,
0.0534597225,
0.0018733103,
0.0233418792,
-0.0059306137,
-0.0142517146,
-0.0092211496,
-0.0001130048,
0.0471178517,
-0.019089004,
-0.0223026387,
0.0168006383,
-0.0018381231,
0.0317191072,
0.0058402331,
-0.0336868502,
-0.0356601477,
-0.0081257932,
-0.0313636996,
-0.0286613218,
0.0742437094,
-0.0106969448,
-0.0170290992,
0.0194096919,
-0.0045940168,
0.0203273855,
0.0204588827,
-0.0480500795,
0.024850294,
0.0355716236,
0.0156543646,
-0.0180223975,
0.0325311199,
0.0139814345,
-0.027145166,
-0.0122097572,
-0.0427868478,
-0.0062340521,
-0.0286196843,
-0.0128718922,
-0.0007441118,
-0.0513400063,
-0.0473854244,
0.0011948532,
0.0081858523,
-0.0285504628,
0.0225505363,
-0.0379494503,
-0.0611168668,
0.0558675304,
-0.0262978114,
0.0469382405,
0.0638133213,
0.0182542708,
0.0178571623,
-0.0094863717,
-0.013531913,
0.0406871587,
-0.0354495272,
0.0283410437,
0.0431603901,
0.0387486108,
-0.0230460446,
0.0889245644,
-0.006398919,
-0.0804355815,
-0.0555512831,
-0.0310413241,
0.0052329339,
0.0445350744,
0.0181456935,
-0.0028599855,
0.0093143266,
-0.0355726741,
-0.0263052136,
-0.0229952037,
-0.0031222971,
0.0232211817,
0.0038139094,
-0.0658162534,
-0.0256795399,
0.0568522923,
-0.0145896515,
0.05254706,
0.0315052867,
0.011706938,
-0.0796391442,
-0.036936596,
0.0200496707,
0.0138850017,
0.045505289,
-0.0371356383,
-0.0232773311,
-0.0755280927,
-0.0400959104,
-0.0208904129,
-0.0242265407,
0.0371926799,
-0.0093466975,
0.0005389984,
-0.0237219315,
0.0451307371,
-0.0608867519,
0.0125090266,
0.0409919359,
-0.0435646847,
-0.0085071707,
0.0637760982,
-0.0149195483,
-0.0504424311,
0.0368081406,
-0.0424205177,
0.0240426827,
0.017023908,
-0.0046227551,
-0.0145858675,
0.0016169555,
-0.0123253614,
-0.0223455261,
0.033570841,
0.0012270787,
-0.0235687476,
0.0305853151,
0.0791746527,
-0.0577749982,
-0.0182757769,
-0.0456150025,
-0.0320579782,
0.0277872086,
0.0108847003,
-0.0540292002,
0.0263095368,
-0.0217372999,
0.0377669968,
0.0096420925,
0.0069505908,
0.0255526043,
-0.0383916572,
-0.0037462104,
-0.0866505653,
0.0165789928,
-0.0601710826,
-0.0112942122,
-0.0098645417,
0.0027126549,
-0.036686603,
0.0496643521,
0.029908428,
-0.0862249956,
-0.0606990606,
0.0254937168,
0.0439584516,
0.040923845,
0.0446490347,
-0.0158957224,
-0.0070896526,
-0.0723188743,
-0.0046563339,
-0.0116095478,
0.0036029464,
0.0715061426,
0.0575073659,
0.0175084807,
-0.0042313463,
-0.0269157756,
-0.0553884432,
0.1061199456,
-0.0522662103,
0.0321411416,
-0.0102367401,
0.0056137484,
0.0008513844,
0.0045349691,
0.0078866528,
-0.0482496992,
0.0232493076,
0.0279778913,
-0.0508302562,
-0.0107223783,
-0.0269978791,
0.0135645708,
0.0516159646,
0.0094374726,
-0.0101198079,
0.086403124,
0.0119092418,
-0.0035707729,
0.0299372245,
0.006990646,
-0.0313220024,
0.0527345389,
-0.0575855076,
-0.002110952,
-0.0085205426,
-0.0233356003,
0.0280953534,
-0.0815143138,
0.047282096,
0.0174697116,
0.0513748527,
0.056267079,
-0.0128283221,
-0.0093631856,
0.0280962754,
0.0114097167,
0.0132516064,
0.0060143624,
0.0040029832,
0.002602468,
-0.0025663073,
-0.0098027829,
-0.0222770087,
0.0379473157,
-0.0063185184,
-0.0437129252,
0.0179915614,
0.0359653533,
0.0357197821,
0.038576182,
-0.0348049626,
-0.1018521413,
0.0134652639,
-0.0147614824,
0.0215345062,
0.0249827337,
0.0377113447,
-0.0233095381,
-0.0060700048,
-0.0363333002,
0.0085713472,
0.0172114223,
-0.0042576799,
0.0367182642,
-0.0034622112,
-0.0401606075,
-0.0380054377,
-0.0164304432,
0.0121558905,
-0.0674922466,
0.0206500497,
-0.0023133557,
0.0067709177,
-0.0375468954,
0.0034334259,
0.0083893957,
-0.0068344674,
-0.0166516714,
-0.0002252454,
-0.0239793733,
0.0296531022,
-0.0314665623,
0.0093911197,
-0.0361140333,
-0.0309518781,
-0.0020306283,
-0.0008548611,
-6.197436174e-33,
0.0337197371,
-0.0241673458,
-0.0113861635,
0.0121295489,
-0.0448313504,
0.0004826517,
0.0264576506,
0.0075551881,
0.0290261507,
0.0247731972,
-0.0106294667,
0.0073217237,
0.0164579041,
-0.010708753,
0.0135865649,
-0.0423339866,
0.0075665042,
-0.0262425561,
-0.0029240071,
0.028784126,
0.0311370585,
0.0211126152,
0.0326959342,
-0.0399652459,
0.0391393751,
-0.0557644144,
-0.0466881804,
0.0233235303,
-0.0163014885,
-0.0230738372,
0.0094616786,
0.0267053917,
0.0511707328,
0.0196641255,
-0.0255398061,
0.1043307483,
0.0100230156,
-0.0363760926,
-0.0419556946,
0.0162746534,
-0.0356828906,
-0.0637598857,
0.0665727109,
-0.0571826585,
-0.0342330337,
0.0466142595,
0.0510980599,
-0.0142683387,
0.0208710823,
-0.0258723274,
-0.0318779945,
-0.0227619633,
-0.0248705987,
0.0049391547,
0.0890258029,
0.023571793,
0.0264054034,
-0.0340909846,
-0.036769174,
0.00374591,
-0.0686770529,
0.0091486629,
-0.0004901044,
0.0089774625,
0.007438546,
-0.0283011049,
-0.0217416305,
-0.0752237886,
-0.0220939238,
0.0095531978,
-0.0480730943,
0.1077867895,
-0.0183942039,
0.0152164483,
-0.0538834743,
-0.0515978634,
-0.0553392582,
0.0316230282,
-0.0112012122,
0.0490196981,
0.0517181493,
-0.0701667815,
-0.0697512329,
0.0321640372,
0.041351825,
-0.0645403117,
-0.0480798855,
-0.0011206442,
0.0280284826,
0.0194144677,
-0.0634953082,
0.0016415385,
-0.0041983458,
-0.043214906,
0.0249093194,
-0.0393416658,
0.024160713,
-0.0432690531,
0.0120059522,
0.0165734198,
-0.0145916967,
-0.0159502961,
-0.0121135637,
-0.0037831818,
0.0347179584,
-0.0144646764,
-0.0283834133,
0.0589156523,
0.0166472569,
0.0193981156,
-0.0178892221,
0.0495605431,
0.0130631281,
0.0438409261,
-0.013815891,
0.0562659428,
0.0141726872,
-0.0166822765,
0.0099591557,
-0.0149548166,
0.002798276,
0.0310835242,
-0.0369681567,
-0.0214484185,
0.0030570612,
0.0421448573,
-0.0264900438,
-0.0090453979,
0.0224276893,
0.0069910921,
-0.0009094424,
-0.0638728589,
2.964e-7,
-0.0427695401,
0.0048576375,
0.0416223444,
0.0415135585,
0.0163049921,
0.0633568317,
0.0339050964,
0.0539369509,
-0.0200945269,
0.0253535938,
-0.0195985772,
-0.0291719232,
0.0049253632,
-0.0310821384,
0.0225928836,
-0.0218118168,
-0.0163438767,
0.0247995462,
-0.0382159948,
0.0211379286,
0.0624176711,
0.0557768047,
0.0168388914,
-0.0264742281,
0.0172195956,
0.006001492,
-0.0558239408,
0.0101724109,
0.0363893285,
-0.018116679,
0.018079631,
0.1198839024,
0.0362630002,
0.0677967519,
-0.0008428592,
-0.0063381786,
-0.0543500856,
0.0465949476,
0.0133655034,
-0.0227087159,
-0.0266337674,
-0.0740792677,
-0.0029670196,
-0.0404252894,
0.0141226323,
-0.0033407386,
-0.0275797434,
-0.0292573199,
-0.0331887156,
-0.0040305848,
-0.0059220158,
0.0201872606,
0.0472140424,
0.0243749432,
-0.0359200761,
-0.0362300314,
0.0393491164,
-0.0262055993,
0.0222884305,
-0.0684550703,
-0.0015140654,
-0.0161779206,
0.0208421536,
0.0435789898,
0.0212925915,
0.0223086458,
0.0036790278,
2.168400909e-34,
-0.0483570285,
-0.0354727209,
-0.0460599437,
0.0178615153,
-0.0274515264,
0.0555151589,
-0.0242631249,
-0.0120948525,
-0.0256366022,
0.0138407899,
-0.0342921689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14393v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14393v2 | LLMCarbon: Modeling the end-to-end Carbon Footprint of Large Language Models | 2023-09-25T14:50:04 | 2024-01-19T17:33:44 | Ahmad Faiz, Sotaro Kaneda, Ruhan Wang, Rita Osi, Prateek Sharma, Fan Chen, Lei Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | The carbon footprint associated with large language models (LLMs) is a
significant concern, encompassing emissions from their training, inference,
experimentation, and storage processes, including operational and embodied
carbon emissions. An essential aspect is accurately estimating the carbon
impact of emerging LLMs even before their training, which heavily relies on GPU
usage. Existing studies have reported the carbon footprint of LLM training, but
only one tool, mlco2, can predict the carbon footprint of new neural networks
prior to physical training. However, mlco2 has several serious limitations. It
cannot extend its estimation to dense or mixture-of-experts (MoE) LLMs,
disregards critical architectural parameters, focuses solely on GPUs, and
cannot model embodied carbon footprints. Addressing these gaps, we introduce
\textit{\carb}, an end-to-end carbon footprint projection model designed for
both dense and MoE LLMs. Compared to mlco2, \carb~significantly enhances the
accuracy of carbon footprint estimations for various LLMs. The source code is
released at \url{https://github.com/SotaroKaneda/MLCarbon}. | [
0.0332001373,
0.1067554057,
0.0021145181,
0.0524464585,
-0.0049695,
0.0047511803,
0.0076967422,
0.0132931294,
-0.0250452682,
-0.0172903631,
-0.0271328576,
-0.002990158,
0.0196089372,
0.0139946602,
0.0434067249,
-0.0067126332,
0.0946558043,
-0.0559979305,
-0.0427597351,
-0.0092784744,
-0.0185491182,
0.0032053743,
0.0143001312,
0.0278446972,
-0.0392586887,
-0.0180125479,
-0.0278431885,
0.0145517047,
-0.010983225,
-0.0053306185,
0.0198431294,
0.0365300402,
0.0186026786,
0.0765557587,
0.0000020982,
-0.0132192606,
-0.0173595008,
0.0147788953,
-0.0424745567,
0.0531851314,
0.0766024962,
0.0233936664,
-0.0169868357,
0.0124380933,
0.0125386454,
0.0065970053,
0.068920441,
-0.0474370122,
0.0325261466,
0.0205484275,
-0.0031820452,
0.0037195764,
0.0535059832,
-0.0243484024,
-0.0132852839,
0.0535379648,
0.0158281606,
0.0004038535,
-0.0759005249,
-0.0411071293,
-0.0247091819,
0.0730123818,
0.0326570384,
-0.0014032666,
-0.0194048434,
0.0402454697,
-0.01182622,
-0.029386485,
-0.0185765866,
0.0288443025,
-0.0047444496,
-0.0182866603,
-0.0031399098,
-0.0220098626,
-0.012654609,
-0.0353898183,
-0.0148534188,
0.0393101536,
0.0349102393,
0.0140192937,
-0.022948062,
-0.0262318067,
0.0439995937,
0.02590595,
-0.0253703594,
0.052014187,
-0.0022038321,
-0.0178254861,
0.0497073606,
0.0271537974,
-0.0206501968,
-0.0574428514,
-0.0036390363,
0.0012695942,
0.0140580023,
0.0184366126,
-0.0468312055,
-0.0372108817,
-0.0046589575,
-0.0658612102,
0.0524322018,
0.0289681442,
0.0309170336,
0.0153727829,
-0.0326657183,
0.0289244782,
-0.0443929322,
-0.011495648,
-0.0188677534,
0.0097837085,
-0.0063315644,
-0.0289788414,
-0.0390906967,
0.0056644045,
-0.0350453854,
-0.0227304175,
-0.0270048659,
0.001647712,
-0.0499570742,
-0.0070728348,
0.0422084481,
0.0391377099,
0.0069871438,
0.0309003182,
-0.0129568195,
0.0403275192,
0.0055618514,
0.016701296,
0.0274400748,
-0.0719412565,
0.004636575,
0.0325960331,
-0.0247954596,
-0.0056099091,
0.04421423,
0.0731563568,
0.0082501415,
-0.0313670933,
0.0027964187,
-0.0208622143,
-0.0044031865,
-0.0629993752,
0.0040487582,
-0.0572001897,
0.0152558051,
-0.038012255,
0.0262532793,
-0.0614052005,
0.0049316767,
0.0301606171,
-0.0345248766,
0.0343517512,
-0.0975050256,
-0.0011286672,
0.027641993,
-0.0159235653,
-0.0309667699,
0.0953012407,
0.0972250998,
0.0142780067,
0.0218511373,
-0.0164734647,
-0.0739888102,
0.0424581654,
0.0382099859,
-0.0112806261,
-0.0876012668,
-0.0216038674,
-0.0120448722,
0.0623301789,
0.0653662086,
0.045222044,
-0.0466985777,
0.0097143939,
0.0609629303,
0.0576899499,
-0.0075067314,
0.0210370589,
0.0315656625,
-0.0123266457,
0.025050452,
-0.0351084471,
-0.0423016064,
0.0037656245,
-0.0220546778,
-0.026292827,
0.0387033708,
0.0316115208,
-0.0030499464,
-0.0605918579,
0.0078061167,
-0.0368972421,
0.0078805937,
-0.0221793614,
0.039929565,
-0.0353684723,
-0.0074337986,
0.0937425196,
0.0047088847,
-0.0711171255,
-0.0388332605,
-0.0545306094,
-0.0124352491,
0.0084395483,
0.0221299939,
0.0090873949,
-0.0347519591,
-0.0203541964,
-0.0163330529,
0.0046708588,
0.0523974486,
0.0092566824,
0.0348362289,
-0.0450316966,
0.0071413154,
-0.0200591832,
-0.0027831122,
-0.0341609381,
0.0311830211,
0.0157490838,
0.0108352592,
-0.0156737939,
-0.0547454655,
0.0467354879,
-0.0296348184,
0.0120329978,
-0.0284645315,
-0.0155699225,
0.0297197234,
0.002261535,
-0.0185569674,
0.0148753142,
0.0156196421,
0.0078561418,
-0.0302443877,
0.0132174511,
-0.0328500234,
0.0488359258,
0.0507011674,
0.0019176438,
0.0197849181,
0.01359809,
-0.0111642834,
-0.0395758227,
-0.0159658324,
-0.03729463,
0.0668919608,
-0.0218582358,
0.0188408867,
-0.0205280147,
0.0498314723,
0.0303201918,
0.0383180641,
-0.0349368565,
0.0195972677,
0.0458186828,
-0.0059215077,
0.008932705,
-0.026078159,
-0.0264429618,
-0.0325366259,
-0.0076615489,
0.0017676805,
0.0189033803,
-0.0027940874,
-0.0194962416,
0.0218899548,
-0.0709640831,
0.0326090753,
-0.007244972,
0.0246509202,
0.0120702861,
-0.0303996485,
-0.0141398907,
0.021642603,
0.0302620884,
0.0245286711,
-0.0466845222,
0.0343102328,
-0.0172369946,
-0.0100221988,
0.0097192433,
-0.0182552636,
-0.0402800851,
-0.0184483565,
0.0657807663,
-0.0147357518,
-0.0868600607,
-0.0350889824,
0.0738884136,
-0.0072737513,
0.0221814476,
0.0008487062,
-0.0353361219,
0.005705629,
0.0037881574,
0.0168472454,
0.0673882961,
0.0061447322,
0.0120163616,
0.0529941358,
-0.0101844277,
-0.0881506652,
0.0205405261,
0.0471416079,
-0.0110064726,
-0.0289809145,
-0.0273311585,
0.0098235263,
0.0885335281,
-0.0534523539,
-0.0064379126,
0.0164238922,
-0.0108405976,
-0.0173980445,
-0.0766967908,
-0.0237415936,
-0.0001828475,
-0.0238593072,
0.0315858647,
0.0050963373,
-0.1001845822,
-0.0024683499,
-0.0522954427,
-0.0004605932,
0.0158583652,
-0.0265957005,
0.0240828488,
0.0306733064,
0.0418731086,
0.0360757969,
-0.015132132,
0.0225644726,
-0.0443821326,
0.0110198036,
-0.0161653627,
0.0100549581,
0.0002157664,
-0.056999661,
0.0272589736,
-0.0215025134,
-0.0328377075,
0.0066206576,
0.0220922213,
-0.0636527911,
0.0253478717,
0.0138553046,
-0.0717351437,
-0.0249486901,
0.0189398285,
0.0180138424,
0.0520279594,
0.0000377804,
-0.0119327046,
-0.0130016059,
-0.0193849243,
0.0521672666,
0.0462926589,
0.0337073877,
-0.0424587987,
-0.0150639974,
0.0818621442,
0.0006745082,
0.0166164618,
-0.0804988295,
-0.0076353746,
0.0352416113,
0.0235787667,
-0.0281838216,
0.0078039761,
0.0427596904,
-0.0620451048,
0.0086069368,
0.0696533918,
0.0021933343,
-0.0779365301,
0.0164399296,
0.0313882455,
0.0506278574,
-0.000290971,
0.0197681542,
-0.0597329699,
-0.0264507793,
0.0590937249,
-0.0017954056,
-0.0174190328,
-0.0293199513,
-0.0251391679,
-0.1001831591,
0.0284303967,
-0.0163047314,
-0.0350560024,
0.0061043464,
-0.0374065116,
-0.0287236907,
-0.0277731903,
-0.0333691128,
-0.0197617523,
-0.0193946492,
-0.0347573832,
0.0420578979,
-0.0586225614,
-0.0041966569,
-0.026629962,
-0.0141588626,
0.0446386114,
0.0411417633,
0.0131925568,
-0.0339744911,
-0.0167151392,
0.0751196444,
0.0141216684,
0.0241176505,
-0.0162095055,
0.0298470017,
0.0333304293,
-0.0039607743,
-0.0031580699,
0.008699052,
-0.0179393943,
-0.0356836729,
0.0096699707,
0.0878652558,
0.0003855338,
-0.0365489423,
0.005066955,
-0.016718097,
-0.0126552582,
0.0575314574,
0.0338913463,
-0.0396266468,
-0.0605462939,
-0.0505000614,
-0.0233803019,
-0.0176216774,
0.0033137854,
-0.0114267897,
-0.007923414,
-0.0500030406,
0.0041686711,
0.0012405389,
0.0059655006,
0.0543938205,
-0.0260032956,
0.0017208478,
0.0211457144,
0.0079562645,
-0.0563781224,
0.0852324367,
-0.03757146,
0.0364311412,
-0.0817451403,
-0.0124288062,
0.0443345234,
0.0557124801,
-0.0256762449,
0.0113196056,
-0.1135722622,
-0.0704733208,
0.0007059263,
0.0696513206,
0.0286716614,
0.0186779648,
0.0558097847,
-0.0594473258,
0.0572457798,
0.0700813681,
-0.0460666567,
0.0609341674,
0.0310258698,
0.0090641547,
0.0000491793,
0.0223001428,
0.0194558315,
-0.0170550682,
0.0261489097,
0.039223481,
-0.0143535985,
-0.0111631267,
-0.028157426,
0.0013378096,
0.0308504328,
-0.0645880178,
0.0066529098,
-0.0247692429,
0.0130071891,
0.0200168341,
0.0467366204,
-0.0580937639,
-0.0116829649,
0.0080381762,
0.0357550085,
-0.0009007232,
0.0067439228,
0.0468695648,
-0.0118688559,
-0.0184502937,
-0.0028136405,
0.000376119,
0.0433996432,
0.0351049788,
0.0232254267,
-0.0070160921,
-0.0331639387,
-0.0058076927,
0.0065672914,
-0.0241992529,
0.0144892577,
0.0159499161,
0.0312090367,
-0.0424065441,
0.0455846824,
-0.0136821279,
-0.056257613,
-0.0276854262,
0.043360617,
0.0257966314,
0.0190171879,
0.0018566452,
-0.045077309,
-0.027141789,
-0.0103965681,
0.0096219303,
-0.0431539454,
0.0081913099,
0.0445999578,
0.0133697623,
-0.0425158478,
-0.0092227263,
0.0622912832,
0.0512522347,
0.0717525035,
-0.0202512499,
-0.0030100513,
-0.0034426076,
-0.0232533813,
-0.0297003519,
-0.0138137517,
-0.0079092849,
-0.010933768,
-0.0286972336,
-0.1025206968,
0.017304197,
0.0034901474,
0.0000613832,
-0.0002396262,
0.0429268442,
0.0190123189,
-0.0005787131,
-0.0446193703,
0.0162765495,
0.0179078728,
-0.0182864945,
-0.0159190763,
0.0008976992,
-6.292549095e-33,
-0.0150156338,
0.0012397325,
0.0234999992,
0.0027636548,
-0.0200340264,
0.0403622352,
-0.0092843333,
-0.005009701,
-0.0258064251,
0.0173306409,
-0.0230696741,
0.0080163293,
0.01724221,
0.0102780303,
0.0254472867,
0.022906011,
0.0420304425,
-0.0359629132,
0.0153899547,
-0.0040666969,
0.0185553879,
0.0536401831,
0.0627093464,
-0.0478650853,
-0.0175115969,
0.0269127861,
-0.0024355811,
0.0042813835,
-0.0271901656,
0.0378618874,
-0.0389471203,
0.0639569834,
0.0082495743,
-0.0024601847,
-0.0358831361,
0.0144278426,
-0.0503553115,
-0.0296821371,
-0.0003775831,
-0.0031196873,
-0.0238120519,
-0.0327283405,
0.0411419533,
0.044852104,
-0.0359771252,
0.0004410437,
0.0112291742,
-0.0413238555,
-0.0435992517,
-0.0174905043,
-0.0227440447,
0.0023298401,
-0.0105035473,
0.0692000613,
0.0185011905,
0.0224046297,
-0.0254720058,
0.0281838253,
-0.0700018331,
-0.0006854972,
0.0137979956,
0.0698144585,
0.0549199991,
0.0300500784,
0.051338505,
0.063677609,
0.0483466052,
-0.0060530496,
-0.0405595638,
0.0163599793,
0.0864614174,
0.0132373851,
0.0297770984,
0.0125422971,
0.0786572918,
-0.0276749842,
-0.0588616058,
-0.0150386384,
0.042487327,
0.0380461812,
-0.0013291076,
-0.0070547825,
0.0273039527,
-0.0348783508,
-0.0390208215,
-0.0061365948,
-0.0179202203,
-0.0051661385,
0.022044424,
-0.0055065495,
-0.0218472388,
-0.0310789477,
0.0212559383,
-0.0614724904,
0.0214838628,
-0.0019536223,
0.0283013973,
0.0341055654,
0.022345094,
0.0742425546,
-0.0686479732,
-0.0672899783,
-0.0546214618,
-0.0020398246,
0.0633504465,
-0.0056945849,
0.0217521451,
0.0527570806,
-0.0516946092,
-0.0045257355,
-0.0589546598,
-0.0246557035,
0.0566469878,
0.0381450541,
0.0165556148,
-0.0071373801,
0.0273375995,
0.0095393071,
-0.0033807326,
0.0256665386,
-0.0113647478,
0.0054096985,
-0.0174025297,
0.0183940325,
-0.0298839323,
-0.007174971,
-0.0587949529,
0.0171578117,
0.0328439325,
-0.0917919651,
-0.0184417907,
0.0298501365,
2.767e-7,
0.0284600016,
0.0067223464,
-0.028771352,
-0.0183321144,
0.0269323234,
-0.0001815986,
0.016088536,
-0.0270829741,
-0.0097605074,
-0.0188145693,
-0.0145991417,
0.0263983179,
0.0735706091,
-0.0088271331,
-0.0717756301,
-0.0072158184,
-0.0752417594,
-0.0047489069,
-0.0492773838,
-0.0048904759,
-0.0728490651,
0.0815830901,
0.0207617823,
-0.0294339061,
-0.0127316657,
-0.0058802511,
0.0311536994,
-0.0614144206,
0.0421950668,
0.0076591531,
0.049499318,
0.0203467477,
-0.03121702,
-0.0110767065,
-0.0056130076,
0.0076913843,
0.0059512169,
0.0568100885,
-0.0199491009,
0.0179323275,
0.0320107229,
-0.0405734479,
-0.0408029705,
-0.0107522048,
0.0442251228,
-0.005986094,
-0.0045740376,
-0.0956696197,
0.0018151051,
-0.0347340815,
0.0201846361,
-0.045942951,
0.0591571629,
0.0064014797,
-0.0053903307,
-0.0381328575,
-0.0216791946,
-0.0389356129,
-0.0068263048,
-0.0529651977,
-0.0464411937,
-0.0516399816,
-0.0880215093,
0.0172155742,
0.0382193252,
-0.0050678649,
-0.0095051387,
2.444187266e-34,
0.0295126475,
-0.0053987042,
0.0251430497,
0.0182163343,
0.0241949502,
0.0022628179,
-0.0006236308,
-0.0088293767,
-0.0435294136,
-0.0916472301,
-0.041833844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14174v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14174v1 | Only 5\% Attention Is All You Need: Efficient Long-range Document-level Neural Machine Translation | 2023-09-25T14:33:47 | 2023-09-25T14:33:47 | Zihan Liu, Zewei Sun, Shanbo Cheng, Shujian Huang, Mingxuan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document-level Neural Machine Translation (DocNMT) has been proven crucial
for handling discourse phenomena by introducing document-level context
information. One of the most important directions is to input the whole
document directly to the standard Transformer model. In this case, efficiency
becomes a critical concern due to the quadratic complexity of the attention
module. Existing studies either focus on the encoder part, which cannot be
deployed on sequence-to-sequence generation tasks, e.g., Machine Translation
(MT), or suffer from a significant performance drop. In this work, we keep the
translation performance while gaining 20\% speed up by introducing extra
selection layer based on lightweight attention that selects a small portion of
tokens to be attended. It takes advantage of the original attention to ensure
performance and dimension reduction to accelerate inference. Experimental
results show that our method could achieve up to 95\% sparsity (only 5\% tokens
attended) approximately, and save 93\% computation cost on the attention module
compared with the original Transformer, while maintaining the performance. | [
0.0223805141,
0.0573240295,
0.0233469382,
0.0430965535,
-0.0238259323,
-0.0111075211,
0.0322401002,
-0.0022264994,
-0.0416152515,
-0.0382270813,
-0.0193745773,
-0.0126380417,
0.0418363884,
0.0275675207,
0.0268787947,
-0.0481010452,
0.0162888244,
-0.0109813949,
0.0050699483,
0.0049278601,
-0.0112172868,
-0.008994475,
0.0238473993,
0.0230051894,
-0.0283883773,
-0.0043862741,
-0.0242014974,
0.0198313631,
0.0164279975,
-0.0011763546,
-0.0013523685,
0.0340471976,
0.0222439636,
0.0470730923,
0.0000021325,
-0.0021378279,
-0.0192297157,
-0.0001439673,
0.0024959885,
-0.0060466039,
0.0465618819,
-0.0510108136,
-0.0111546656,
0.0028185558,
0.0100223338,
0.0151277669,
0.0331629775,
0.0721343905,
0.0461289063,
0.0900716707,
-0.0187378787,
-0.0216121636,
0.0277196337,
-0.0435115024,
0.0018516581,
-0.078401424,
-0.0182937756,
-0.0407414995,
-0.0050403154,
0.0625152215,
-0.0244933628,
0.0566596426,
0.0503835678,
-0.0385658368,
0.0225906782,
0.0418448821,
-0.0316962153,
0.0076743928,
0.0018602781,
0.0841005743,
-0.0182036273,
-0.0005482064,
0.0021512583,
0.0021818406,
0.0076913079,
-0.0557667464,
-0.0517286174,
0.0007200571,
-0.0102237137,
0.0214926582,
0.0509039871,
0.0353700295,
0.0136557883,
0.0177893415,
-0.0362883694,
0.0056819571,
0.0203039721,
-0.0305885542,
-0.0096522868,
0.0071205124,
-0.030333871,
-0.0255330037,
0.0470715538,
0.0281719565,
-0.0141587993,
-0.0122696133,
-0.0782718286,
-0.0723225921,
-0.0028921203,
-0.0847026929,
0.0427565649,
0.0458126552,
0.0078236135,
0.0566908084,
-0.022517221,
0.0539542921,
-0.0428260677,
-0.0436713435,
-0.0273248628,
-0.017586939,
0.0251036659,
0.0233659409,
-0.0701797754,
0.0200072341,
-0.0893540606,
-0.0664065927,
-0.0074340636,
-0.0056149643,
0.0365452208,
-0.0278767534,
0.0165721197,
0.0078236302,
-0.0842386931,
-0.0190924834,
0.0287836716,
0.0526078269,
-0.028627567,
-0.0031103089,
0.015661737,
-0.0364207998,
-0.0615476109,
0.0414161608,
0.0096199419,
-0.0282516889,
-0.0197845362,
0.0708757713,
-0.0306994412,
-0.0314056501,
-0.0083881076,
0.0027460305,
-0.0286751259,
-0.0361119956,
0.0355664045,
-0.0469333008,
0.0390852466,
0.0033480441,
-0.0127075342,
-0.0031228329,
-0.0025841445,
0.0316706076,
-0.0158843752,
0.0329700559,
0.0142969182,
-0.0338396765,
0.0435528085,
0.0012216036,
-0.0110632209,
0.0534733124,
0.0625335723,
0.0557975806,
-0.0063691018,
-0.0094575817,
-0.0290849563,
0.0191026255,
0.0314685069,
-0.0091723436,
0.023504274,
-0.0114395125,
-0.0277399532,
0.030103242,
0.0622195564,
0.0483460315,
-0.021296598,
-0.0278252214,
0.0734634548,
0.0309605021,
-0.0072480114,
0.0474271141,
0.0197205655,
0.0460194647,
-0.0356334187,
-0.0040771076,
-0.0224714391,
0.0674527586,
0.0360595025,
0.0007571232,
0.0638875216,
0.0015932444,
-0.0247037839,
-0.0142854294,
0.0155715523,
0.0041817632,
0.0197924487,
-0.0405360088,
0.0227548387,
0.0329757407,
-0.0865852162,
0.0951460227,
0.0024703897,
-0.0545597747,
-0.0070115807,
-0.0179946814,
-0.0226595569,
0.0092738578,
0.0345571488,
-0.0057980954,
-0.0209022071,
-0.0218995996,
0.050743483,
0.0927315131,
0.0387830734,
0.0429017693,
0.0120619079,
-0.0579456165,
0.0009190787,
-0.0531602129,
0.0113468049,
0.0276813321,
0.0067743789,
0.0165891889,
0.0314048864,
-0.0048858114,
-0.0348071866,
0.0205337163,
-0.0052053309,
-0.044954557,
0.0269120745,
0.0124097979,
0.0519822463,
-0.0049223076,
0.0211400092,
0.015410604,
0.0089823985,
-0.0595690683,
0.0055006677,
-0.0079179602,
-0.079936333,
-0.0487429015,
-0.0045401477,
-0.0596990697,
-0.020273868,
0.0150395464,
-0.0276065543,
-0.0564517006,
0.0300280023,
-0.0871346891,
-0.0043451558,
-0.0115687996,
0.0034597067,
0.0379148982,
0.044691857,
-0.0160909109,
0.0479321554,
-0.0077679567,
-0.0045748176,
0.052943863,
-0.001387155,
0.0063568163,
-0.0189005937,
0.0043626423,
-0.0169656053,
0.0084699234,
0.0087306621,
0.0194785725,
0.0103079397,
0.0063482509,
-0.0782352537,
-0.076965183,
-0.0003487603,
-0.0234177895,
0.0525351055,
0.0338856839,
0.0647292435,
0.0084060309,
-0.013913,
-0.023946099,
0.0193266738,
-0.0140011087,
0.0032231098,
0.0322756991,
-0.0217441693,
0.0421903543,
-0.0390188992,
-0.0090330793,
0.033939667,
0.0372162201,
0.0382215083,
-0.0262563024,
-0.0430400819,
-0.0078014741,
0.0144806486,
0.0083033526,
-0.0305736028,
-0.0495736934,
-0.0081065893,
-0.0065484904,
0.02214876,
0.0753098279,
0.0259941425,
0.0345886536,
-0.0052437712,
-0.0117791807,
-0.0423170179,
0.0355096422,
-0.0029009948,
0.0502418503,
-0.0194887053,
0.0077530248,
0.0283727888,
0.0858902633,
-0.0127028618,
0.0048404182,
-0.0363598205,
0.019176824,
0.0312362667,
-0.0186330806,
0.0323839784,
-0.0029626654,
-0.0190123469,
-0.0001288597,
-0.0299632289,
-0.0066788555,
0.0470042005,
-0.0556237213,
-0.0188964996,
-0.0549788736,
0.0262990519,
-0.0313342065,
0.0192764327,
-0.0070727994,
-0.0007399549,
-0.0616723597,
-0.0709782317,
0.0004425519,
0.0307308491,
-0.0207533147,
-0.0032767192,
0.0641750991,
-0.030317856,
0.0236432515,
-0.0454288684,
-0.0289442483,
-0.0163485277,
-0.0192688387,
0.0153934555,
0.0293137394,
0.0345142707,
-0.0231084004,
-0.0678529069,
0.0111176316,
0.0078443233,
0.1083932742,
-0.0447268747,
0.0086978506,
-0.0388140678,
0.0500792712,
0.0025699525,
0.0205408428,
0.0347016007,
-0.0385095663,
-0.0016883285,
0.0641092584,
-0.0276039857,
-0.0036034125,
-0.0262927767,
-0.0225910861,
0.0029139926,
-0.0079107815,
-0.0086376183,
-0.0287520904,
0.057389047,
-0.0862418488,
-0.0399163887,
0.0951132476,
-0.014183322,
-0.060050521,
-0.0172393695,
-0.0141561562,
0.0452857651,
-0.0242721699,
0.0246188939,
-0.0630023852,
-0.0343540348,
0.012254254,
0.0428524502,
0.0455360226,
-0.0259179361,
0.0014363939,
-0.0270704776,
0.0271970611,
0.0062102801,
-0.0265415795,
-0.0364452675,
-0.0129653784,
0.0126078986,
0.0284363776,
0.0179139096,
0.0164887905,
0.0048376461,
-0.0344174281,
-0.0197936725,
0.0354812033,
-0.0232076757,
-0.0002701239,
-0.0108606396,
-0.0269955192,
0.0262519848,
0.0450619496,
0.0162647404,
-0.008953332,
0.0281784739,
-0.0157205984,
-0.0069950786,
-0.0075603048,
0.0391507857,
-0.0314274766,
0.0007286341,
0.0029837897,
0.0355115235,
-0.0263389628,
0.0540620908,
-0.0078937151,
0.0445977338,
-0.0302248057,
-0.0134861153,
-0.0230714213,
-0.004491501,
0.011522837,
0.0592245385,
0.0644808412,
-0.0350725539,
-0.0463874266,
-0.0185074378,
-0.0180197097,
-0.0842860043,
0.0289361402,
-0.0348446742,
0.0155548751,
-0.0674626678,
-0.0924505442,
-0.0501083992,
0.0000893899,
0.0351553001,
-0.0139375618,
-0.0250980631,
0.0414718352,
-0.0263699014,
-0.0111457882,
0.0215075184,
-0.0124961268,
-0.0114427162,
-0.0445512906,
0.0217729267,
0.0391824841,
-0.0159348138,
-0.0008064428,
0.043880377,
-0.0865768045,
-0.0446324982,
-0.0077848397,
0.0250845626,
0.0074535352,
0.0450116321,
-0.0402495936,
-0.0139094777,
0.0507068112,
-0.0058150818,
-0.0390225239,
0.0330653191,
0.026412392,
-0.0187351778,
-0.0104056466,
0.0444061905,
-0.0100353593,
0.0113071417,
0.0200800858,
0.040002387,
-0.0193670671,
-0.0529342331,
-0.0177754015,
-0.0399099551,
0.0132875349,
0.0014801691,
0.0449491441,
-0.0165568534,
0.0571975037,
-0.0098197144,
0.0005391415,
-0.0682885423,
-0.0221830364,
-0.0035461686,
-0.0095513873,
0.0028932712,
0.0083665578,
0.010095058,
-0.0008341949,
-0.0085569266,
0.0181137063,
-0.035743393,
0.0069194348,
0.0019754004,
-0.0055968631,
-0.0392230228,
-0.0308128372,
-0.0055179032,
0.0302681439,
-0.0495951362,
0.0400544517,
0.0231926609,
0.006332939,
-0.0106361313,
0.0141087314,
-0.052949857,
0.0249735713,
-0.0105810026,
0.009478014,
0.0388544053,
-0.0157829896,
0.0901928768,
-0.0152852116,
-0.0119799701,
-0.0169962626,
0.0691358671,
0.0063357698,
-0.0342385806,
-0.0123489928,
0.0042398316,
0.0436778329,
0.0180112906,
0.0601096228,
-0.0129162837,
-0.0140540013,
0.016437931,
-0.007477107,
-0.0463361666,
-0.0336500406,
-0.0085502584,
0.0042283302,
0.0095798532,
0.0209964309,
-0.0012167752,
-0.0137055824,
0.0281060468,
-0.0199827254,
-0.0134010753,
-0.0232202858,
0.045362711,
0.0607834458,
-0.0196316168,
-0.032993909,
-0.0375597887,
0.0547018051,
0.0291451532,
-0.0447847508,
-0.064285852,
-6.467403145e-33,
-0.0525800176,
-0.0134864068,
-0.0018208921,
0.0172738209,
-0.0540752448,
0.0187834203,
-0.0863834321,
-0.0364475287,
0.0137643861,
0.0382367596,
-0.0310173742,
0.0051324554,
0.0140153673,
0.0601332411,
-0.0185758844,
0.0016036573,
0.0559017099,
0.0060395519,
-0.0293987542,
0.0614432618,
0.060454879,
0.0147090601,
0.070331648,
-0.0287005976,
-0.0045520435,
-0.00010641,
0.0340427943,
-0.0198797733,
0.0131763797,
0.0123592336,
0.0180467181,
-0.010596226,
0.0287644472,
-0.0335237347,
-0.0421104617,
0.045163285,
-0.1009019241,
-0.0178476386,
-0.0160649307,
0.0115747564,
-0.0366597995,
-0.0587693974,
0.0727528036,
0.0090472754,
0.0372790508,
-0.0687839463,
0.0136638712,
-0.0218241438,
-0.0472991206,
-0.0437197685,
-0.0884739682,
0.0322379656,
-0.007744608,
-0.0040759556,
0.0002685108,
0.0468468741,
-0.0185623597,
0.0023665375,
-0.0809331387,
-0.0213098973,
-0.01094817,
0.0614562742,
0.0176790692,
-0.0086551029,
-0.0148230623,
0.0137484521,
-0.0120623196,
-0.0036458657,
-0.0264873877,
0.0102553209,
0.0314246453,
-0.0068999114,
0.0756849274,
-0.0284397062,
0.0322977863,
0.0302123688,
-0.0716008693,
0.0135544846,
-0.0130298408,
0.0797141567,
0.0390996151,
0.0044528786,
-0.0213474017,
-0.0099757956,
-0.004192018,
-0.0055885622,
-0.0183631014,
-0.0071861632,
-0.0098000327,
0.0322740711,
-0.0216857269,
-0.0295587666,
0.0882637203,
-0.0099854758,
0.0242282897,
0.03913109,
0.0042453567,
0.0068509779,
-0.0069213836,
0.0065214615,
-0.0196692236,
0.005215209,
0.0097951666,
0.020838296,
0.0034506733,
-0.0178394169,
0.0331418291,
0.0180068519,
-0.046831008,
-0.012815862,
-0.0299989227,
0.0125298724,
-0.0131428884,
0.074890025,
0.0191394761,
-0.0414142087,
0.0059353476,
0.0755066574,
-0.027902266,
0.0112906145,
-0.0204917416,
-0.004513049,
0.0192751605,
0.0361555889,
-0.0690876916,
0.0290796924,
-0.0515790731,
0.0647124499,
0.0116457371,
-0.0681944266,
-0.0131013673,
0.0504218563,
2.835e-7,
0.0323216878,
0.0283573698,
0.0299879443,
-0.0062961387,
0.0346583016,
0.0105029289,
0.0239054374,
0.0685995817,
-0.0001453304,
0.0222546235,
0.0154871093,
0.0034936524,
0.0797574669,
0.0091649042,
-0.144392401,
-0.043820288,
-0.0843684152,
0.0239217915,
-0.033461947,
-0.0276192054,
0.0161658674,
0.0771792531,
-0.0497591011,
0.008133023,
0.0135960886,
-0.0086834868,
0.063430585,
0.0325784124,
-0.0160222556,
0.0084070517,
0.0773373023,
-0.0158917196,
-0.055647254,
-0.0337302871,
-0.0333271362,
0.0278291777,
0.002517171,
0.099298954,
0.0255673006,
-0.0332697183,
0.022489449,
-0.0226053763,
0.0025874369,
-0.0213748626,
0.0273341741,
-0.0704750344,
-0.035058517,
0.0076476042,
-0.0223426595,
0.0093874689,
-0.0152213313,
-0.008470973,
-0.016567152,
0.004728836,
0.0412702002,
-0.0583595932,
0.0048026885,
-0.0795015991,
0.0071167727,
-0.0353333429,
-0.0478398912,
-0.0091112806,
-0.0493390486,
-0.0255160015,
0.03070217,
0.0015551315,
-0.0140086152,
2.649131262e-34,
0.0420430675,
-0.0358253866,
-0.0094616711,
0.0094419429,
0.0235198028,
-0.0211378112,
0.0269183218,
-0.0190182701,
0.016810786,
-0.0964271948,
-0.0384813957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14165v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14165v1 | Towards End-User Development for IoT: A Case Study on Semantic Parsing of Cooking Recipes for Programming Kitchen Devices | 2023-09-25T14:21:24 | 2023-09-25T14:21:24 | Filippos Ventirozos, Sarah Clinch, Riza Batista-Navarro | cs.CL | cs.CL | Semantic parsing of user-generated instructional text, in the way of enabling
end-users to program the Internet of Things (IoT), is an underexplored area. In
this study, we provide a unique annotated corpus which aims to support the
transformation of cooking recipe instructions to machine-understandable
commands for IoT devices in the kitchen. Each of these commands is a tuple
capturing the semantics of an instruction involving a kitchen device in terms
of "What", "Where", "Why" and "How". Based on this corpus, we developed machine
learning-based sequence labelling methods, namely conditional random fields
(CRF) and a neural network model, in order to parse recipe instructions and
extract our tuples of interest from them. Our results show that while it is
feasible to train semantic parsers based on our annotations, most
natural-language instructions are incomplete, and thus transforming them into
formal meaning representation, is not straightforward. | [
0.0379600041,
0.0041174651,
0.0102306139,
-0.0097469911,
-0.0389017351,
0.0167676527,
-0.0335770287,
0.027435882,
0.011068251,
-0.0805131495,
0.0496462844,
0.0351299457,
-0.0109059187,
0.0066692294,
-0.029152872,
-0.0306822434,
0.0434530042,
0.0077512264,
0.0121762194,
0.0579276197,
0.0192796998,
0.0194651503,
-0.0227343924,
0.0365394689,
-0.0374817848,
-0.0173888635,
-0.0205205902,
-0.005861965,
0.0171864368,
-0.0544946566,
-0.0182570629,
0.0484302826,
-0.0209441092,
0.0022922372,
0.0000017909,
-0.0309116729,
-0.0645985454,
0.0292094555,
-0.0466663018,
-0.0321049653,
0.011403393,
0.0178228524,
-0.0308393799,
0.0047319909,
-0.0560069308,
0.0201816726,
0.0576193705,
0.0765192881,
0.0190512408,
0.0722358376,
-0.0129968897,
-0.0987319127,
-0.0267170966,
0.03453926,
0.0487885475,
0.0092076343,
-0.0177361853,
-0.0105797807,
0.0353475884,
-0.0132546397,
0.0144510195,
-0.0002962306,
0.0612075925,
0.0391327925,
-0.0204244964,
0.0348990858,
-0.0322797149,
-0.0230197627,
-0.0377558395,
0.0467796847,
-0.0035548981,
0.0003619865,
0.0378808193,
0.0138709331,
-0.0352111459,
-0.0246379394,
-0.0387942083,
-0.0002681444,
-0.0453425497,
0.0412975438,
0.0174023248,
-0.0062472271,
0.0281222612,
0.0019531467,
0.0262948833,
0.1220851466,
0.0050951196,
-0.0324298255,
-0.0227619838,
-0.0298694521,
0.0136207938,
-0.0663967207,
0.0119863944,
0.0575612895,
0.0082240142,
0.0375564694,
-0.0420980901,
-0.0192224141,
0.0169472564,
-0.0106936796,
-0.0096160145,
0.0265562665,
0.0041641104,
0.0232552756,
0.0078496169,
-0.0111609334,
0.0138684697,
0.0365768,
-0.0771812499,
0.0250657685,
-0.1302805394,
-0.037552733,
-0.0230002794,
0.031933289,
-0.0354529917,
-0.0333437547,
-0.0410034657,
0.0011291935,
0.0103683313,
0.0206044782,
0.023690708,
0.0371676236,
-0.0114499684,
0.0225187093,
-0.025287969,
0.0218814816,
-0.0468648337,
0.0048801778,
0.0004624404,
-0.0603890978,
0.0088892384,
0.0083136624,
0.0238095745,
0.0024094887,
-0.0167125762,
0.0742075369,
0.0151471337,
-0.0394493379,
-0.0423764214,
-0.0762982443,
-0.0073041334,
-0.0146606499,
0.0410788059,
-0.0562875606,
-0.0007637173,
0.0153876934,
0.0415113904,
-0.0238847807,
0.031524267,
0.0718236491,
-0.0211661253,
0.0792170465,
-0.0139815481,
-0.0156872272,
0.027337309,
0.0257380679,
0.0154499328,
-0.0086577097,
0.0568755269,
0.0235482007,
0.0362110659,
-0.0136823673,
0.027383728,
0.0096278358,
-0.0276808757,
-0.0459571704,
-0.0419418663,
0.0219015237,
0.0129093984,
-0.0023034078,
-0.0492029041,
0.0436200835,
0.0283686705,
0.0565205775,
0.0411533266,
0.0616862886,
0.0215545036,
0.0351022072,
0.0545960926,
0.0585347712,
0.0165026281,
-0.0147307739,
-0.0233478192,
0.0393710621,
-0.0597222783,
0.0197686236,
-0.0084484266,
-0.0483787879,
-0.0086677577,
-0.042631112,
-0.0430958271,
-0.0567650013,
0.0568848364,
-0.0188997984,
0.0547311008,
0.0318502635,
-0.0299561489,
0.0089164786,
0.011133315,
-0.0441003218,
-0.0026770814,
-0.002271753,
0.0265580099,
0.0887738243,
0.018596651,
-0.0648879781,
0.0191762261,
0.0170953851,
0.0082983263,
-0.0198416449,
0.0188216418,
-0.0170281194,
-0.0092029199,
-0.0072015147,
-0.0625448301,
0.0027851013,
0.021996703,
-0.0178144556,
-0.0318381451,
-0.01849184,
0.0158021655,
-0.0238577183,
-0.0633034408,
0.0378113315,
0.0228810925,
-0.0684810802,
0.0011164446,
0.0300763287,
-0.0151977511,
0.0566983931,
0.0178137254,
0.0350756235,
0.0095561268,
-0.0369491987,
-0.0286925249,
0.0303741768,
0.0139943836,
0.0019265109,
0.0087667173,
-0.02196032,
-0.0430664457,
-0.0073616016,
-0.0524281673,
-0.0427136384,
0.0185029544,
-0.037704777,
0.0174935833,
-0.0007846356,
-0.0290414169,
0.0686611235,
-0.0168563668,
-0.0064483779,
0.0488850363,
-0.0062825829,
-0.001561385,
-0.014250773,
-0.0432429425,
0.0074330354,
-0.0396758467,
0.0447324589,
-0.0300891921,
-0.0153125282,
0.0219812617,
0.0136408256,
0.068023324,
-0.0498971604,
0.0013251716,
-0.0597675182,
0.0112800216,
-0.0404705852,
0.0166358128,
0.0245720204,
0.0433317311,
0.0198136158,
-0.0381596461,
-0.0237720963,
-0.0150747765,
-0.0430760197,
-0.0101725943,
0.0194574054,
0.0289335288,
-0.0349059924,
0.000973943,
-0.0056895115,
-0.031653773,
0.0441040322,
0.0315200239,
0.0277820807,
-0.042426113,
-0.0432236046,
0.013082752,
0.0037669614,
0.0163335651,
-0.0002685334,
-0.012354061,
-0.024302464,
-0.0309207812,
0.0400278941,
-0.026857106,
0.0478068106,
0.0270073228,
-0.0271904841,
-0.0329888128,
0.0097320322,
-0.0246531181,
0.0331068709,
-0.0245214831,
-0.0489741527,
0.0243067183,
0.0467766486,
0.0123264575,
0.0626558065,
-0.0386186652,
0.0107332142,
-0.0301909577,
-0.0336286537,
-0.0380684063,
0.0495540388,
-0.0249754358,
0.0635934919,
0.0165705383,
-0.0516652614,
0.0772602633,
-0.0439484715,
0.0296037812,
-0.0785240754,
-0.0345169902,
-0.0102275098,
0.0610607937,
0.0092505217,
0.0299140159,
0.0225703567,
-0.0231588949,
-0.0013605516,
0.0075525334,
-0.0023961395,
-0.0404083319,
-0.0096652778,
-0.0849854201,
-0.0098810773,
0.0080754701,
0.0113726547,
-0.0060283248,
-0.0271045752,
-0.0410235301,
0.0054448224,
-0.0154766599,
0.0343662947,
0.0041202949,
0.0205825362,
-0.0236784853,
0.0381284133,
0.0355298184,
-0.0255585462,
-0.020544989,
0.0182060245,
0.0570953749,
-0.0346993841,
-0.0694537982,
0.0263406448,
-0.0049977978,
0.0136699686,
0.039418377,
0.0005445204,
-0.0504426584,
0.0224274453,
-0.0059154821,
-0.0652901009,
-0.0145507213,
0.0519814305,
-0.0046415646,
-0.0423432961,
-0.0152349221,
0.1110870242,
0.0424775556,
0.0057856012,
0.0372770727,
0.0261294805,
-0.0523000509,
0.0178942457,
0.0381276868,
-0.1319071949,
-0.0455250405,
-0.0073500704,
0.0616688766,
-0.0252937656,
-0.0187709108,
-0.0257799253,
-0.0938171968,
0.007584529,
-0.0178689901,
-0.0459160395,
-0.0702175051,
-0.0404521935,
-0.0530202799,
-0.0136323981,
0.0277144648,
-0.0506149493,
-0.0326977596,
0.0370351151,
0.0333794653,
-0.0579846166,
-0.0564394034,
0.0138147073,
-0.034283556,
0.0437910371,
0.1221494228,
0.0021276374,
-0.008173204,
-0.0000821974,
0.0086993128,
0.0366924033,
0.0271425508,
-0.064035058,
0.0015624941,
-0.0054404046,
-0.0219205078,
0.0142830033,
0.0461948067,
-0.0445575714,
-0.0635440499,
0.0020004676,
0.0637026802,
-0.0238254331,
0.018146202,
-0.0273509324,
-0.0319097489,
0.0701213703,
0.0415286943,
-0.0010283875,
-0.0158643648,
-0.0343268923,
-0.0474687926,
-0.0412939675,
-0.0125443516,
0.0094257733,
0.0589929447,
-0.0362971388,
-0.0598295182,
-0.0510626398,
-0.0233892854,
0.0422046967,
0.0257952847,
0.0297986027,
0.0045796647,
0.0715850592,
0.0669913664,
-0.0463058352,
-0.0073451619,
-0.0050136517,
0.0098917689,
-0.0480226576,
-0.0180826616,
0.025279386,
-0.0397832617,
-0.0265168343,
0.0424955562,
-0.0421474986,
-0.0254156403,
0.0159840621,
0.0968155861,
0.0191720687,
0.0516097769,
-0.0058429367,
-0.0187400877,
-0.0567232482,
0.0256858543,
-0.0336905643,
-0.0434873253,
0.0053757364,
0.0296621341,
0.0218629092,
-0.0043998817,
-0.0654077604,
0.0306419395,
-0.0334746577,
0.0717837587,
-0.0306271017,
-0.0189430304,
0.0731286183,
0.001783078,
0.0412529856,
-0.0209353752,
0.0100852083,
0.006787769,
0.0245441739,
-0.0102463262,
-0.0413921699,
-0.021419894,
0.0279697031,
0.003837066,
0.0165825672,
0.0076296804,
-0.0007492116,
-0.0064630392,
0.0130837765,
-0.013075334,
0.0305996928,
0.0201723985,
0.047300864,
-0.0124400239,
-0.0068487809,
0.0005885743,
0.0293648727,
0.0010327413,
-0.003887028,
-0.0119161615,
0.0566757321,
-0.0015154746,
0.0283748172,
-0.0534495376,
0.0384641662,
0.0056128032,
-0.0051935697,
0.0293529164,
-0.0218492802,
0.0207147766,
-0.0414242074,
0.0268660747,
-0.0632104054,
0.0064653666,
-0.0295662694,
0.0784308985,
0.0094580399,
-0.0098841852,
0.0416301824,
0.0221952591,
-0.0106618796,
-0.0259501655,
0.054828044,
-0.0353121758,
0.0263877083,
0.0239895415,
-0.0523655638,
-0.0807229131,
0.0123097748,
-0.002782481,
0.0164252203,
-0.0329205245,
-0.0360921323,
-0.0409526601,
-0.0158930309,
-0.0010666713,
0.0346504375,
0.0421339273,
0.0003285621,
0.0816724151,
0.0440250039,
-0.0134277483,
-0.0309952199,
-0.0082786111,
0.0004236154,
-0.0579276755,
-0.0395508558,
-0.0304158665,
-5.80951312e-33,
-0.0295031387,
-0.0433394946,
0.0177833624,
0.054183498,
0.0453964323,
-0.0300876182,
-0.0272818115,
-0.0230617784,
0.0438515022,
-0.0011976346,
0.0052334042,
-0.0258277338,
0.042485863,
0.0311006159,
0.0492874347,
-0.0766899884,
0.0378905907,
-0.0036427258,
0.0109099839,
-0.0273886528,
0.0451163016,
0.0149096763,
0.0456066914,
-0.0688718185,
0.013481183,
-0.0123448633,
0.0055768322,
0.0009256451,
-0.0067495299,
0.0351209641,
-0.0244365241,
0.0175409224,
0.0294297766,
0.0027382593,
-0.0020027033,
0.0469191596,
-0.0921797603,
-0.0101753334,
-0.0089695109,
0.0291071814,
-0.0757020637,
-0.0534452833,
0.0227258876,
-0.0090883654,
-0.0187789183,
0.0777431801,
0.0796426386,
-0.0085611036,
-0.0048653251,
-0.012161552,
-0.0750950947,
0.0327189118,
-0.0165448058,
-0.002738666,
0.0112643568,
0.0127031934,
0.0128466086,
-0.0397765003,
-0.0586555935,
0.0023180062,
-0.0114264963,
0.0248586349,
0.0783506781,
-0.0056851548,
-0.0105958218,
0.0162911545,
0.0056539015,
-0.0391487516,
0.0258123353,
0.0297927875,
-0.0380738899,
0.0444538593,
0.007628548,
0.0062107616,
0.0706964806,
-0.0024920946,
-0.0296180882,
0.0142142456,
-0.0143201929,
0.0000064779,
-0.0588039495,
-0.0017815017,
-0.0002631023,
0.0164015107,
0.0126996962,
-0.0226651132,
0.0001811578,
-0.0230930056,
0.0267068185,
-0.0069131274,
-0.0303369276,
-0.0028197793,
-0.0320742913,
0.011428888,
0.034412168,
-0.0499197133,
0.0369878896,
-0.0031169304,
-0.0339981765,
0.0066786311,
-0.0280348565,
-0.0568831787,
-0.0103493994,
-0.0162885636,
0.0470884405,
-0.0039413092,
0.0236242395,
0.0581473634,
-0.0053889686,
0.0053269491,
-0.0048703887,
0.0025682941,
-0.0233706031,
0.0260653459,
0.0548547953,
0.0199278016,
-0.0118160946,
0.0322787054,
-0.0309452266,
-0.0113793649,
-0.0241746381,
-0.0036667835,
0.0486926138,
-0.0721808299,
-0.0048262938,
-0.0100411661,
-0.0486033559,
0.0337044932,
0.0447779149,
-0.0044849431,
-0.0040940214,
0.0363229476,
2.679e-7,
0.0685337931,
0.0157369971,
0.050657846,
0.0094437534,
-0.0225904286,
0.0084363921,
0.0242215637,
0.0351742357,
-0.0459194444,
0.0264048018,
0.0241791774,
-0.0331768692,
0.0181388315,
0.0281801503,
-0.0806493387,
-0.0355997756,
-0.0539844558,
0.0256172102,
-0.0340829715,
0.0341673009,
0.0990118235,
0.0445261039,
0.0391465053,
0.0165193547,
-0.0027445753,
-0.0121874614,
-0.013566602,
-0.0124261202,
0.0914933085,
-0.01668269,
-0.0210325755,
0.0186811443,
0.0112441881,
-0.013728993,
-0.0178339537,
-0.029094262,
0.0175633319,
0.0515063591,
-0.0158392917,
-0.0126448972,
-0.0211414583,
-0.029495459,
-0.0094073145,
-0.0390208475,
0.0188683551,
-0.0857869089,
-0.0086555379,
0.0590353496,
-0.0026015961,
0.0116993282,
-0.0266861971,
0.0126044648,
0.0316686518,
-0.0105458349,
0.0211884566,
-0.0059269946,
-0.0216581486,
-0.0434799902,
-0.0042704837,
0.0062797009,
-0.0173802376,
0.012905906,
-0.0468827225,
-0.0113640511,
-0.0058012106,
-0.0323301107,
-0.0356836841,
2.28079998e-34,
-0.0052074511,
0.0181222595,
-0.0007354756,
0.0003456445,
-0.0084129786,
0.0517418981,
-0.0157105979,
0.0295034181,
0.0235225651,
-0.0556331985,
-0.031313248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14146v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14146v1 | Examining Temporal Bias in Abusive Language Detection | 2023-09-25T13:59:39 | 2023-09-25T13:59:39 | Mali Jin, Yida Mu, Diana Maynard, Kalina Bontcheva | cs.CL | cs.CL | The use of abusive language online has become an increasingly pervasive
problem that damages both individuals and society, with effects ranging from
psychological harm right through to escalation to real-life violence and even
death. Machine learning models have been developed to automatically detect
abusive language, but these models can suffer from temporal bias, the
phenomenon in which topics, language use or social norms change over time. This
study aims to investigate the nature and impact of temporal bias in abusive
language detection across various languages and explore mitigation methods. We
evaluate the performance of models on abusive data sets from different time
periods. Our results demonstrate that temporal bias is a significant challenge
for abusive language detection, with models trained on historical data showing
a significant drop in performance over time. We also present an extensive
linguistic analysis of these abusive data sets from a diachronic perspective,
aiming to explore the reasons for language evolution and performance decline.
This study sheds light on the pervasive issue of temporal bias in abusive
language detection across languages, offering crucial insights into language
evolution and temporal bias mitigation. | [
0.0772521123,
0.0689777806,
-0.0437731966,
-0.0022472562,
-0.0238544289,
0.0249233153,
0.0496086664,
0.031215433,
0.0043470482,
-0.0653345063,
0.0230197087,
-0.0254879575,
-0.0118088573,
0.0309957899,
-0.0186140891,
-0.0479465313,
0.0418963544,
0.0293958373,
0.0331519023,
0.0108848354,
0.062530227,
-0.0100691915,
0.0029662445,
0.0147616304,
-0.0669990629,
-0.0018696695,
0.0332632773,
-0.039354708,
-0.0005762915,
-0.0271468814,
0.0716104582,
0.0474452414,
0.0122670876,
0.0420480967,
0.0000016159,
-0.0492128581,
0.0320170037,
-0.0254760478,
0.0025318766,
-0.0030731768,
0.1056472957,
-0.0312672593,
-0.0304267947,
0.0274743363,
-0.058448378,
-0.0088935914,
0.0542775244,
0.0244695041,
0.0317282081,
0.0406659767,
-0.0124707911,
-0.0221131165,
0.0196301937,
0.0201014243,
-0.0288270097,
0.0000764261,
0.0398035683,
-0.030759966,
-0.0574879982,
-0.0367182121,
-0.0223926306,
0.0151440548,
0.0075548119,
0.0039686379,
0.0171760339,
-0.0210374612,
-0.0341542773,
-0.0272580236,
0.0029974137,
0.0313254111,
-0.0420289822,
-0.0346030481,
-0.0125191547,
-0.0090007847,
-0.0255484376,
-0.0333962142,
-0.0077433302,
-0.0122457519,
0.0080912039,
-0.0122832563,
0.0020803683,
0.0349212438,
0.0477961004,
0.0974351838,
0.0205628648,
0.0411105305,
-0.0249633566,
-0.0497434996,
-0.0080259154,
-0.0230922885,
0.032440912,
0.0154085811,
0.0033952813,
0.005142713,
0.0006326259,
-0.0023997615,
-0.0069267144,
-0.0492640436,
0.0143864686,
-0.0844459906,
0.0034478053,
0.0092396485,
-0.0415901057,
-0.0107286926,
0.0157896336,
0.0348024815,
0.0139721381,
-0.0232511852,
0.0004673923,
-0.0011183964,
-0.0390785374,
0.0333965383,
0.0250298232,
-0.0524616577,
0.0177566241,
0.0743623599,
-0.0415893942,
0.0168013591,
-0.0448560603,
-0.0563915707,
-0.0442748219,
-0.0037771591,
-0.0257542431,
0.0324155726,
-0.0171750393,
-0.0262824148,
-0.0348089635,
0.0140773691,
-0.0628262833,
-0.0696069598,
0.0351313539,
0.0192085784,
-0.030589899,
-0.0499250144,
0.0228103772,
0.0598404109,
0.0088625364,
-0.0155216241,
-0.0576758422,
-0.0337568857,
-0.0317841582,
-0.0007388227,
-0.0068890844,
-0.0348551683,
0.0283282064,
-0.009138803,
-0.0580121726,
-0.0348541066,
0.0008718256,
-0.0018893465,
-0.0920457244,
0.0439811088,
-0.0070444108,
0.0183783751,
0.0679090768,
0.0262001697,
0.0043537449,
0.0345258191,
0.021047093,
-0.0213261135,
0.0356887765,
-0.0018137378,
-0.0035582918,
0.0583927631,
0.039502643,
0.0248466991,
-0.0404575951,
0.0115525909,
-0.0268728323,
-0.0455059558,
0.0084421542,
0.0080523761,
0.0182303693,
-0.0394771174,
0.0538875796,
0.0314138569,
-0.0501477607,
0.0340525694,
0.0490017571,
-0.009653382,
-0.0348571427,
-0.0717122853,
-0.0556389615,
-0.061755009,
-0.0136088245,
-0.0490696169,
-0.0333614796,
0.04817627,
0.0002414102,
-0.0310075674,
-0.0237848908,
-0.0003089588,
0.0546829291,
-0.0213649459,
0.0395728014,
0.0277096163,
0.0042556631,
0.0167835355,
0.0573101901,
0.0040749973,
-0.00539354,
-0.0141771547,
0.0423026197,
0.0717801005,
0.0175690185,
0.0223984756,
0.0156655386,
-0.0734359175,
0.0314865708,
0.0205709338,
-0.0009869328,
-0.0079285083,
0.0119316997,
-0.0144475643,
-0.0223527495,
0.0795182139,
-0.0092334766,
-0.0182254314,
0.0852206722,
0.0475313589,
0.0004251441,
0.0357997604,
-0.0565764643,
0.0499805473,
0.0222553425,
-0.0112639116,
-0.026546523,
0.0297745969,
0.0715039968,
-0.0004640338,
-0.0323211476,
-0.0731580853,
0.0029379411,
0.0064585241,
-0.017149305,
0.0265146922,
-0.051818531,
0.0102435928,
0.0339723229,
-0.0195893366,
-0.0065230886,
0.0015977341,
-0.0115349973,
0.0478716157,
0.0773017183,
-0.0309181493,
0.0169239827,
-0.0115484828,
-0.0410165265,
-0.0731109157,
0.0436407402,
-0.0211806055,
0.0639950633,
-0.0402938798,
-0.0293494761,
0.0045402362,
-0.0406685136,
0.0080763632,
0.0188707821,
-0.0343617536,
-0.0142836543,
-0.0329077691,
0.009378382,
0.0307885185,
0.0408337601,
-0.0111197978,
0.0269948356,
-0.0628634393,
-0.0175475106,
-0.016348727,
-0.025345074,
0.0159130767,
-0.0150505146,
-0.0244401135,
0.0012545261,
0.0020582466,
-0.0572376251,
0.0232293494,
0.0478773043,
0.0039990447,
-0.0465797074,
-0.024963269,
-0.0524712577,
-0.005911408,
-0.0325690135,
0.0573658049,
0.0034606692,
-0.0880938172,
0.0271890815,
-0.0145169944,
-0.0458625406,
0.0216829963,
-0.0187025815,
-0.0313333273,
0.0176932178,
0.0290493686,
0.0010370625,
0.0602483898,
0.0666465312,
0.1026229188,
0.0509324819,
-0.0071169022,
-0.0349393077,
-0.0041778898,
-0.0286166016,
-0.0109797195,
-0.0075398539,
-0.0770048723,
-0.0080852713,
0.0932370722,
0.034018524,
0.0026017241,
-0.0117808664,
0.0268656928,
-0.0529362224,
-0.0570198409,
-0.0430170223,
-0.0681938082,
-0.0433091559,
0.0061516492,
-0.0454492979,
-0.0904938802,
0.0288371686,
0.06120985,
0.0308679547,
0.0218038373,
-0.0469261147,
0.0180675164,
0.0437193736,
0.0242842622,
0.046324946,
0.0001348423,
-0.0193351973,
0.002386434,
-0.0336233787,
0.0661004633,
-0.0096488167,
-0.0183726028,
-0.0343787707,
0.0027572387,
0.0414413325,
-0.0291845761,
-0.0454906411,
-0.0769945607,
-0.0073863803,
-0.0489426889,
-0.0262506176,
0.0021688843,
-0.0174293052,
0.0180629361,
-0.0151183773,
-0.0232841484,
0.0065131159,
-0.0082608853,
0.0256820489,
-0.040048629,
0.0025271047,
-0.0455900505,
0.0146764237,
0.0076821581,
-0.0105470903,
0.0455613174,
-0.0031836054,
-0.0298211686,
-0.0239789262,
0.0547095612,
0.0048897984,
0.0282128323,
0.0042510834,
0.0122616235,
0.000399664,
-0.0194034688,
0.0020470954,
0.0553980917,
0.0235144738,
-0.0065798047,
0.027500568,
-0.0048752064,
0.0118553741,
0.0199434794,
-0.0334794149,
-0.0704214573,
0.0160036068,
-0.0216496792,
0.0329575948,
-0.0960766375,
-0.0485773236,
0.0017149904,
-0.0664786249,
0.0043889503,
-0.0167604126,
-0.0293016043,
0.0096121449,
0.0140046244,
0.0095211649,
-0.0277387109,
0.0389984697,
-0.0273044612,
0.0216909032,
-0.0174965151,
0.0072286404,
-0.0839081407,
-0.0190195106,
0.0381298885,
-0.019318508,
0.0631162971,
0.0269420967,
0.0713477954,
-0.0473334193,
0.0146099357,
0.0479345173,
0.0294925049,
-0.0106389914,
-0.0493000634,
0.0399933048,
0.0160290748,
-0.0167512465,
-0.0212072134,
0.034073893,
0.0231863167,
0.0021197493,
0.0215007141,
0.0804923624,
0.0345196649,
-0.0107666021,
-0.0429145768,
-0.0214017853,
0.0141193708,
0.0456852168,
0.0102835856,
-0.0418573171,
-0.0219435636,
-0.0453925095,
-0.0589433387,
0.0232824162,
-0.0790143237,
-0.0310436506,
-0.0363509171,
-0.0350767672,
-0.0423932262,
-0.0255156308,
-0.0050071613,
-0.034123674,
0.0587723441,
-0.0349597894,
-0.0074317316,
-0.0116774561,
-0.0681885779,
0.0136985108,
0.0302420035,
0.0449869893,
-0.0223976672,
0.0156878941,
-0.0326946229,
-0.0016610106,
-0.0204441492,
0.058873035,
-0.0336319469,
-0.0484931022,
0.098905772,
0.0470794216,
0.0132474303,
0.0564893112,
-0.0198227987,
-0.0537834987,
0.04977208,
0.0381786972,
-0.016942149,
-0.0153107075,
0.0390937887,
-0.0048842654,
0.0275581889,
0.0058988752,
-0.009202295,
0.0316217877,
0.0353795439,
-0.0603524297,
-0.0766341239,
-0.013246594,
-0.0171214081,
-0.0321934149,
0.0472858436,
-0.0132673355,
-0.0770985112,
0.0110482518,
-0.0525388345,
0.0262017921,
-0.0271174107,
0.0266475976,
0.0136558777,
0.0138510531,
0.023352338,
-0.0557950959,
0.0153877549,
-0.041841656,
0.0195696503,
-0.0433056317,
0.0281947199,
0.0150962155,
0.0525336489,
0.0359526463,
0.0406223089,
-0.0021097052,
0.0497099943,
-0.0080595482,
-0.0031127795,
0.0221204385,
0.0178532153,
-0.011924048,
0.0321015827,
0.0103847701,
-0.0377834365,
-0.0221888702,
0.0002509262,
-0.0243377481,
-0.0522187762,
-0.006473795,
-0.0519041084,
0.0642440841,
0.0247927271,
-0.016462177,
-0.0145081179,
0.0085195955,
-0.0144377118,
-0.0482759178,
-0.0096618589,
0.0079687424,
-0.0359231308,
0.0722556189,
0.034577623,
0.0098639829,
0.0451139361,
0.0313914753,
-0.0570758879,
0.0149769168,
0.020283265,
0.0349945873,
-0.0138885155,
-0.0022273783,
0.0100176837,
-0.0378820747,
-0.0346899666,
-0.0143932868,
-0.0587283708,
0.0416188762,
-0.0052954894,
0.0026364126,
0.068309553,
0.0000646656,
0.0056456681,
-0.0331298076,
0.0315548405,
0.0380301736,
-0.0600343943,
-0.0371171534,
-4.895470386e-33,
0.0149545381,
-0.0226486716,
-0.0282785445,
0.0062281177,
-0.011457609,
-0.0271442477,
0.0030972436,
0.0152782593,
-0.034485627,
0.020129662,
0.0234429259,
0.0131235551,
0.0070196851,
-0.0314855091,
0.0269052517,
-0.0286660977,
0.0017778794,
-0.0340637788,
0.0131012695,
-0.0036413998,
0.0512034521,
0.022913374,
0.0381726548,
-0.0953078493,
0.0647134557,
0.017184291,
-0.0132233119,
0.0413448475,
0.0135100773,
0.0598747842,
-0.0045658159,
0.0643035024,
0.0235033128,
-0.0058010858,
-0.0045004901,
0.0213694591,
-0.0397037789,
0.0096548228,
0.0139464652,
0.017495241,
0.0286276005,
0.0027885989,
0.0194992889,
0.0163892489,
-0.0716421679,
-0.0138036273,
0.0545614623,
-0.0233225338,
0.0200532079,
-0.0604323819,
-0.0351770967,
0.0300619062,
-0.0573862903,
0.0019590997,
-0.0249580257,
0.0424285717,
0.0277297646,
0.0009270732,
-0.0665394217,
0.0407065898,
0.0101185143,
-0.0301222559,
0.0028384731,
-0.0163509287,
0.0012400124,
0.0631755516,
0.0371484123,
0.0439853296,
0.0092943376,
0.029848367,
0.0403173603,
0.0120397573,
0.011431843,
0.0320277363,
0.0130822537,
-0.0784972906,
-0.0543652885,
-0.0314369947,
0.0772849619,
0.0335468054,
0.0080557568,
-0.0279019922,
-0.0717727914,
-0.0501822531,
0.0021895526,
-0.0573509112,
-0.0103614191,
-0.0270555876,
0.0409465432,
-0.0124751618,
0.0258093067,
-0.0281791445,
0.0135302953,
-0.0487267189,
-0.0139165437,
0.0154471165,
-0.0508398302,
-0.0078505846,
0.0586554036,
0.0291500241,
-0.0328887925,
0.0117629832,
-0.0052110935,
-0.0317372233,
0.0353014395,
-0.0215824414,
0.0948416144,
0.0170343071,
-0.0474946313,
0.0009468411,
0.0080214767,
0.049735371,
-0.0089014871,
0.0526005141,
0.016458936,
0.0264752544,
-0.0166246332,
-0.0037798828,
0.0505070128,
0.0097547444,
-0.0333438814,
0.0022459633,
-0.0201321114,
0.0017718386,
0.0057806075,
-0.0305540469,
-0.0178598166,
0.021934906,
0.0389793999,
-0.0625929087,
0.0027752307,
-0.0530572571,
2.268e-7,
0.0186291728,
0.0714766979,
-0.0097616678,
0.0423364416,
0.0307679716,
0.0231721569,
0.0325649604,
0.0249868874,
0.0006527575,
0.0420051552,
-0.009869162,
0.0261982009,
0.0012526454,
0.0502017103,
-0.0030668257,
-0.0247193016,
-0.1175759062,
0.0030134441,
-0.0719946623,
-0.0024753255,
-0.0005215077,
0.0753035992,
0.0503738895,
-0.0515216514,
-0.0272100884,
-0.0264532622,
0.009284691,
-0.0511326827,
-0.0189795047,
-0.0075363806,
0.0546457358,
0.0351304859,
0.0186483096,
-0.0019620927,
-0.008967407,
0.0046110838,
-0.0304415356,
0.0162006617,
-0.0001569867,
0.0217447057,
0.0192228016,
-0.004282644,
-0.0109752119,
-0.0511117615,
0.0492338017,
0.0226314887,
0.0042094048,
-0.0466777496,
-0.0058490066,
-0.0054030004,
0.0467771366,
-0.0311792176,
-0.0024994598,
0.0016033729,
0.0488414057,
-0.0170961674,
-0.0120972302,
-0.0374019854,
-0.0234729182,
0.0213974826,
0.0079326788,
-0.0291866343,
-0.0011692774,
0.0429107994,
0.0334185064,
0.0331787392,
0.0637975112,
1.558609885e-34,
-0.0010616184,
-0.0032796813,
0.0217853636,
-0.0163690485,
0.0318373144,
0.0401063487,
0.0202787779,
-0.012617466,
0.0414402746,
0.0207272097,
0.0145788053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05844v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05844v1 | Face-StyleSpeech: Improved Face-to-Voice latent mapping for Natural Zero-shot Speech Synthesis from a Face Image | 2023-09-25T13:46:00 | 2023-09-25T13:46:00 | Minki Kang, Wooseok Han, Eunho Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM, cs.SD, eess.AS | Generating a voice from a face image is crucial for developing virtual humans
capable of interacting using their unique voices, without relying on
pre-recorded human speech. In this paper, we propose Face-StyleSpeech, a
zero-shot Text-To-Speech (TTS) synthesis model that generates natural speech
conditioned on a face image rather than reference speech. We hypothesize that
learning both speaker identity and prosody from a face image poses a
significant challenge. To address the issue, our TTS model incorporates both a
face encoder and a prosody encoder. The prosody encoder is specifically
designed to model prosodic features that are not captured only with a face
image, allowing the face encoder to focus solely on capturing the speaker
identity from the face image. Experimental results demonstrate that
Face-StyleSpeech effectively generates more natural speech from a face image
than baselines, even for the face images the model has not trained. Samples are
at our demo page https://face-stylespeech.github.io. | [
-0.0203853603,
0.0681375414,
0.0125174569,
-0.0167578477,
0.0151916128,
-0.0004708532,
0.0621463023,
-0.0064999391,
-0.0681980029,
0.0004619908,
-0.0232827887,
-0.060876321,
0.0307545289,
0.0774355754,
0.1006003916,
-0.1093459427,
-0.0162035339,
-0.0225451626,
-0.0062789484,
-0.0207783468,
0.0253330655,
0.0167636015,
-0.0668328404,
0.0024232916,
-0.0599636734,
-0.0199889801,
-0.0497801565,
0.0157152005,
0.0260365065,
0.0158661939,
-0.0257423352,
0.0136534935,
0.0332270414,
-0.0016514392,
0.0000017802,
-0.009348155,
0.0003580578,
-0.0036947378,
-0.0019168494,
0.0031631668,
0.0375445634,
-0.0149819003,
-0.0444433279,
0.0264131073,
-0.0469744056,
-0.0582767278,
0.0595347248,
0.0593030229,
0.0429410078,
0.053530965,
-0.0313231125,
-0.0499866977,
0.0112349819,
-0.0123404171,
0.0353002511,
-0.0028266844,
-0.0354073867,
-0.0579590835,
-0.0095003238,
-0.0465614796,
-0.0206312332,
0.0240330379,
0.0252247602,
-0.0156772416,
0.0728770867,
0.0411166437,
-0.0372695178,
-0.0719763786,
0.0110500418,
0.1010216326,
0.0115864985,
0.015503061,
0.018896848,
0.005354621,
-0.0324053541,
0.00033574,
0.0465188511,
0.0211366676,
0.0373698808,
-0.0011871731,
-0.0785767287,
0.0154153015,
-0.004293893,
-0.0547513105,
-0.017564036,
-0.0609255433,
0.0249463264,
-0.0041762278,
-0.0106271645,
-0.032927949,
-0.0287143234,
-0.0163711645,
0.0128908204,
0.0213567652,
0.0104574021,
-0.0094071496,
-0.0579821542,
-0.021243168,
-0.0497894883,
0.0100147305,
0.0183488391,
0.0268340763,
-0.0290137716,
-0.0280766655,
-0.00781966,
0.0566615015,
0.0068013314,
-0.0117947543,
-0.0259391107,
-0.0169057269,
0.0038446852,
-0.0107309744,
-0.0212300234,
-0.0015961993,
0.0073687225,
-0.0372121222,
-0.0320815668,
-0.0019251584,
-0.0533009283,
0.0191137698,
0.0044221627,
0.0550405681,
-0.0481318869,
0.0007424623,
-0.0001122175,
0.0401769578,
0.0124329608,
0.049924545,
-0.0242870431,
-0.0640408471,
-0.0298015662,
0.0019807811,
0.0569919758,
0.0488975868,
0.01563197,
0.0016230096,
-0.0324666202,
0.0198610909,
0.0008603416,
0.0103536583,
-0.0104638394,
-0.0401224233,
0.034240339,
-0.0467740595,
-0.0048535825,
-0.0554849133,
-0.0068648667,
-0.0133110695,
-0.0309362765,
-0.0048209419,
0.0277984105,
0.0407751426,
0.0164560545,
0.036026679,
0.0419605598,
-0.0001489671,
-0.0096181463,
0.0102785295,
0.024356313,
-0.0121303974,
-0.0575140156,
-0.0151173053,
0.0220074188,
0.0536549874,
0.0459668487,
0.0085529182,
-0.026915865,
-0.0186378621,
0.0335354432,
0.0145088136,
0.061331071,
0.0194801278,
-0.0315888561,
0.0064121615,
0.0417613648,
0.0113007603,
0.0597603694,
-0.0013301041,
0.0231516808,
0.031542886,
0.0171976108,
-0.0547568835,
-0.0081773903,
0.036021933,
-0.0158431269,
0.0227311216,
-0.015102189,
0.0049642096,
-0.0983942151,
0.0208991338,
0.0544718653,
-0.0295270029,
-0.0367258005,
-0.0284372643,
-0.000326077,
0.0469405092,
-0.0325898081,
-0.0073723621,
-0.0308296699,
-0.0662772506,
0.0491402112,
0.0035792752,
-0.0020070844,
0.050166633,
-0.0288654994,
0.014010598,
0.0033690662,
-0.0290868878,
-0.0147205638,
0.0666417181,
-0.0428104848,
-0.0311935674,
0.0929988623,
-0.0444375388,
0.0027955463,
0.0137835322,
-0.004806648,
0.0117408214,
-0.0372548141,
0.0403612591,
0.0057108458,
0.0432589725,
0.1040460616,
0.0138559313,
-0.0531542525,
-0.0062298798,
0.0116825877,
0.0443241112,
0.0141698206,
0.0197494272,
-0.0231222548,
-0.0020854303,
0.0075899009,
-0.0497006625,
-0.0014458686,
0.0240751095,
-0.0357737169,
-0.0479285829,
0.0385441184,
-0.0862579644,
0.0218796749,
0.0402007736,
0.0038410029,
-0.0892233253,
0.066245757,
-0.0139242802,
0.0075961314,
-0.0121486103,
-0.0155203352,
0.0181195121,
0.0016386809,
0.0412680358,
-0.0050508962,
0.0253811385,
-0.0292790215,
0.0505830832,
0.0308053773,
-0.0352047458,
-0.0553123504,
-0.0145016434,
-0.0048075062,
-0.0096233571,
0.031821683,
-0.0367030092,
0.0393784717,
-0.0207864363,
-0.017634457,
-0.0636464432,
-0.013802045,
0.0164836962,
-0.0125284744,
0.0136777954,
0.0053381766,
0.0090115461,
-0.0255765319,
-0.0965936705,
0.0062416526,
0.0311271753,
-0.0254038628,
0.0082212687,
-0.0141993761,
-0.014167008,
-0.0327007324,
0.0338151827,
0.0274606366,
0.00545238,
-0.0467454381,
0.0331606977,
0.0047695809,
0.0298437737,
0.0176984966,
0.030440988,
-0.0050208755,
-0.001188817,
0.022260759,
0.016379483,
0.0645681918,
0.018360937,
0.0249339137,
-0.0586434081,
-0.0484201759,
-0.0025201347,
-0.0318880826,
-0.0229196064,
0.0208712537,
0.0388655998,
-0.0126282722,
-0.0188520458,
-0.0419483148,
-0.0199369937,
0.0379784666,
0.0392804258,
-0.1023318768,
0.0881102383,
0.0626993403,
-0.0363417678,
0.0320340022,
0.0251362994,
-0.0170342289,
-0.0249608755,
-0.0262651108,
-0.0327734053,
0.0115854805,
-0.0470769815,
-0.0609209053,
0.0402570479,
0.0159249194,
0.0185092427,
-0.0008742119,
0.0055238195,
0.0337077901,
-0.0094344076,
-0.0196393616,
-0.0512163192,
0.0131522585,
0.0241145585,
-0.04987064,
0.0019269993,
-0.0240127482,
-0.0014603446,
-0.047785569,
-0.0082422197,
-0.0122524705,
-0.0199860986,
-0.0069767591,
0.0324780159,
-0.0521226488,
-0.0192631632,
0.0021781267,
-0.0109845148,
0.0280571114,
0.0067487368,
0.0134806177,
0.003854136,
-0.0219247565,
0.0016278954,
0.0641555712,
0.0514134988,
-0.0145637346,
0.0020631291,
0.0441755392,
0.0187070277,
0.0512601882,
0.0394921824,
-0.0463719219,
0.0192332752,
0.0261265431,
0.0738840103,
-0.0118594784,
0.0318864025,
-0.0078874892,
0.0417238846,
0.0345663391,
0.0842354149,
-0.0431073233,
-0.0337614231,
-0.0014436855,
0.0138868634,
0.0416685417,
0.0138500687,
-0.0194224026,
-0.0198258515,
-0.0238052029,
0.0184321981,
0.018030908,
-0.0008009109,
0.0301417895,
-0.0479867682,
-0.0613816753,
0.0410096981,
0.0344563089,
-0.0422887206,
-0.0149794584,
-0.0109096486,
-0.0070523308,
-0.0379621573,
-0.0093791168,
0.0202771202,
-0.0168223102,
0.0148975747,
0.0244874936,
0.0129123628,
-0.0710439757,
0.0194636509,
-0.0581824556,
0.1012228429,
0.045960553,
0.0537689216,
0.0214120429,
-0.0416276641,
-0.0635245293,
-0.0014731633,
-0.0309579838,
-0.0036227785,
0.0522798561,
0.0008899018,
0.0043092472,
-0.003427818,
0.0847880095,
-0.0392506458,
0.0453321189,
0.0001391449,
0.0114734843,
0.0026080846,
0.0196843818,
0.0138605479,
0.0334581025,
0.0098213758,
0.016243007,
-0.0151190571,
-0.04433937,
-0.0194872636,
-0.0061431779,
0.0530355908,
-0.0288379826,
-0.0919536799,
0.0125604672,
0.0298793763,
-0.0636606216,
-0.0455268994,
0.0070084385,
0.0023026774,
0.1018110961,
0.0002244934,
-0.0595243834,
0.0243531987,
0.0013965752,
-0.013693695,
-0.0254644323,
-0.0348048545,
0.0566867217,
0.0015688251,
-0.0193675496,
0.0249786377,
-0.0652187467,
0.013272644,
-0.0266558025,
-0.0358748399,
-0.0513954237,
-0.0210114364,
0.0284406599,
0.0154278344,
0.057400316,
0.0174574759,
-0.0557344519,
0.0902800858,
-0.0065293373,
-0.0056906864,
0.0406284817,
0.072035864,
0.0036109069,
-0.001970255,
-0.0030372518,
-0.0055399295,
0.0183650889,
-0.0347891748,
0.0102780573,
0.0147401812,
-0.0421953127,
-0.0084217181,
0.0135564413,
0.0085270461,
-0.0099276882,
0.0502564721,
-0.0494222492,
-0.0154034924,
-0.0410278104,
0.0515562966,
-0.0696151033,
-0.0245874282,
0.0424473993,
0.0394597538,
0.0149364779,
-0.0141769378,
-0.0461404771,
0.0573783852,
0.0062351017,
-0.0042517758,
0.061379008,
0.0210321397,
-0.0048869736,
0.0181115065,
0.0291590467,
0.0484366938,
-0.0022197056,
-0.0036403486,
-0.0235983245,
0.0041091978,
-0.0037422767,
-0.0222723745,
-0.0031469581,
0.0026525126,
-0.0249080397,
-0.0011737673,
-0.044000268,
-0.0171648022,
0.0036492343,
0.0488803647,
0.0906080231,
0.0085419267,
0.0399790518,
-0.0072311652,
0.0213871375,
-0.045495756,
-0.0472513027,
0.0095449556,
-0.0316899419,
-0.0079586068,
0.0075417515,
0.0435803607,
0.0383232012,
0.0062374561,
-0.0777249709,
0.0611202754,
-0.024834251,
-0.0196599253,
-0.0104187764,
-0.0142413126,
-0.0099520627,
-0.0056527024,
-0.0289539658,
-0.0342339873,
0.0057957177,
0.0133827161,
-0.0124023622,
-0.0468187295,
0.0351452865,
-0.0508147776,
-0.0461632796,
-0.0042421189,
-0.0139473043,
0.0055155242,
0.0103948638,
-0.0080186753,
-0.0076841889,
-5.28440914e-33,
-0.059271127,
0.0098868543,
0.0260428414,
-0.0021459407,
-0.0707932487,
-0.0260332562,
-0.0246004853,
0.0266030505,
-0.0250737704,
-0.0189871266,
-0.0144869843,
-0.0065469751,
0.0010760077,
0.0490835272,
-0.0392997265,
0.0223285668,
0.0587705038,
-0.0260786116,
0.0178075526,
0.0500822999,
0.0027320406,
-0.0039475393,
0.0084493281,
-0.0290292762,
-0.0721817166,
-0.0406139605,
-0.0393587649,
-0.0334645323,
0.0364587232,
-0.0152033214,
-0.0049926783,
0.0058241095,
-0.0233426783,
-0.028250305,
0.0080945045,
0.0087770838,
-0.0471230708,
-0.0115561206,
-0.046258647,
0.0202984214,
-0.0360820666,
-0.0037113701,
-0.0014624465,
-0.006050373,
-0.0279271975,
-0.0321761481,
0.0253773313,
-0.0169595089,
-0.0017516315,
-0.0256658886,
-0.0394920148,
-0.0057482873,
-0.021367643,
-0.0380433686,
0.0287695117,
0.0906601548,
-0.0206211675,
-0.0043785069,
-0.0636389107,
0.0388918705,
-0.0254696794,
0.0001373364,
0.080074966,
0.0701949075,
0.0389925018,
0.0207041092,
0.0498467386,
-0.0550789945,
-0.0306846052,
-0.004877843,
0.0676781759,
0.0524871387,
-0.0047328952,
0.0659887046,
0.0131311873,
-0.0278086048,
-0.003880271,
0.0219195597,
-0.0099566085,
-0.0225328784,
0.0117250998,
0.0339505672,
0.0276084542,
-0.0006808914,
-0.0808155015,
-0.0371588431,
-0.013127787,
-0.0143688461,
0.0351940282,
0.0288728494,
-0.0090841157,
-0.039923761,
0.0626428798,
-0.0011038191,
0.0104030576,
-0.0016461371,
-0.0678163916,
0.0149213914,
-0.003379713,
0.0267949346,
-0.0515529662,
-0.0436338224,
0.1170583963,
0.0627519935,
0.0518289618,
0.0125852544,
-0.0238060895,
0.0584350117,
-0.024354063,
-0.0255315695,
-0.0240917411,
0.064844951,
-0.0119409235,
0.0183026064,
0.0158341601,
-0.0107814996,
-0.0206380878,
-0.0088558365,
-0.0101241451,
0.0165720936,
0.0084871985,
0.0036898528,
0.0143871456,
0.0189162064,
-0.0522125028,
0.0562592521,
-0.0081445668,
-0.0165310688,
0.0653757527,
-0.030698197,
0.0031512366,
0.0304494221,
2.539e-7,
-0.0768254623,
-0.0226566512,
0.0266369358,
-0.0243064035,
0.0403739884,
0.0858230069,
-0.0030594645,
0.0607292689,
-0.01637155,
-0.0221237019,
0.0223533772,
0.0085485457,
0.0714553744,
0.0084995432,
-0.0391461924,
0.0051385248,
-0.0292162765,
0.0005256738,
0.0020776459,
0.043375019,
0.030136589,
0.0709920526,
-0.0089051807,
-0.0482105389,
0.0675085038,
0.0372624472,
0.0517505184,
0.0357716344,
-0.0074170711,
-0.0472171642,
-0.0005478568,
-0.0363790579,
-0.001663632,
0.0060021691,
-0.0248984639,
0.0248783659,
0.0294278171,
0.0504885763,
-0.0408096798,
-0.0584088638,
-0.0248774458,
0.0487114713,
-0.0616189018,
0.0420987159,
0.0454429463,
-0.0097704185,
-0.041123189,
-0.0102673583,
-0.069903709,
0.0398152694,
0.0202362407,
-0.0380884036,
-0.0182328671,
0.01463171,
0.0427498706,
-0.0326426029,
-0.0022492881,
-0.0322991684,
-0.0302065704,
-0.0208486095,
-0.0523540005,
-0.0153180249,
-0.0198582876,
0.0258712694,
0.0521216914,
0.0399353169,
-0.0157397185,
1.092574359e-34,
-0.0262618531,
-0.0226600394,
0.0181758404,
-0.0578214079,
-0.0266679823,
0.0092852172,
-0.0017737949,
-0.0001639194,
0.0250772461,
-0.0722487569,
-0.0504656695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14130v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14130v2 | On the Relation between Internal Language Model and Sequence Discriminative Training for Neural Transducers | 2023-09-25T13:35:28 | 2024-04-13T08:06:37 | Zijian Yang, Wei Zhou, Ralf Schlüter, Hermann Ney | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Internal language model (ILM) subtraction has been widely applied to improve
the performance of the RNN-Transducer with external language model (LM) fusion
for speech recognition. In this work, we show that sequence discriminative
training has a strong correlation with ILM subtraction from both theoretical
and empirical points of view. Theoretically, we derive that the global optimum
of maximum mutual information (MMI) training shares a similar formula as ILM
subtraction. Empirically, we show that ILM subtraction and sequence
discriminative training achieve similar effects across a wide range of
experiments on Librispeech, including both MMI and minimum Bayes risk (MBR)
criteria, as well as neural transducers and LMs of both full and limited
context. The benefit of ILM subtraction also becomes much smaller after
sequence discriminative training. We also provide an in-depth study to show
that sequence discriminative training has a minimal effect on the commonly used
zero-encoder ILM estimation, but a joint effect on both encoder and prediction
+ joint network for posterior probability reshaping including both ILM and
blank suppression. | [
-0.0304838419,
0.0398117453,
0.0270547532,
0.0611872561,
-0.0366775356,
-0.010521966,
-0.0209157318,
0.0007593789,
-0.0540194958,
-0.0296206307,
-0.0733550787,
-0.0467920117,
0.0572076999,
-0.0471742824,
0.0462198406,
0.0015765354,
0.0105901314,
-0.0406423509,
0.0077219568,
-0.0118763065,
-0.0111353388,
-0.0252910405,
-0.0585896932,
0.0376496017,
0.0206748322,
0.0637184754,
0.0288986545,
-0.0011839988,
0.0136052351,
-0.0217357893,
-0.039404653,
0.0073551475,
0.0203362294,
0.0282492843,
0.0000019743,
-0.0414173864,
0.022934461,
-0.0252300128,
-0.0085358191,
-0.02048878,
-0.0188893564,
0.0004357942,
-0.0100769754,
0.0315679908,
0.0065736058,
-0.0070546404,
0.0409101434,
0.0375769213,
-0.0202580746,
0.0783370435,
-0.0021447337,
-0.0300528128,
0.0514641553,
-0.0385599509,
-0.010838368,
-0.0278963037,
0.0163870044,
-0.027733488,
-0.0483373962,
-0.0709572881,
-0.0165795181,
0.0448880196,
0.0121296681,
0.0184996072,
0.0307012014,
0.0508477315,
0.0234188735,
-0.0413882881,
-0.0174308755,
0.0434761606,
-0.0179228224,
-0.0146451853,
-0.0148431305,
0.0137042832,
-0.0184065867,
0.0081194816,
0.0046768473,
0.0251886193,
0.0282203183,
0.0198779013,
-0.007641376,
-0.0005604447,
0.0218370501,
-0.0101328259,
-0.0392825268,
0.0431075878,
0.030388521,
-0.0276475661,
0.0254753884,
-0.0127534261,
0.0340670161,
-0.0284466278,
0.023072185,
0.0419371687,
0.0404223651,
0.0178881213,
-0.0182549488,
-0.0335955136,
-0.0078943437,
-0.0660418943,
-0.016893819,
0.0665248632,
-0.0141086625,
-0.0355142616,
-0.0487657785,
0.0864936784,
0.014630504,
0.0521652214,
-0.0410958491,
-0.0094862785,
-0.0055062533,
-0.0156992693,
0.0266788267,
-0.0006895919,
0.0046876436,
-0.0274683032,
-0.0629896671,
0.0021011226,
0.0047416771,
-0.0211740565,
0.011465597,
-0.0198433008,
-0.0741139129,
-0.0031641189,
-0.01881974,
0.0356720872,
0.0496317893,
0.0479484759,
-0.000389102,
-0.0929702148,
-0.0241445899,
0.014727423,
0.0106210066,
-0.0144196786,
0.0056169201,
0.0608918145,
-0.0172164198,
-0.046117641,
-0.0666385069,
0.0462884195,
-0.0294863172,
-0.0403902493,
0.0593931898,
-0.0532619916,
0.0006952983,
-0.0360689946,
0.0284043159,
-0.0491212308,
0.0134012122,
-0.0295049399,
0.0372636095,
0.0730946288,
-0.0217151288,
-0.0148653202,
0.0640549883,
-0.0008461126,
0.0613157712,
0.0696572438,
0.0612379387,
-0.0495393798,
0.0141817415,
-0.0430146679,
0.0019640755,
0.0947370827,
0.0153882205,
0.0168996751,
-0.0921629593,
-0.0368350632,
0.0467518196,
0.0029174977,
0.0533432402,
0.0162038133,
-0.0425696969,
-0.0213464517,
0.0796608999,
0.0546556935,
0.0651204288,
-0.0230396446,
0.0055590784,
-0.0018769981,
-0.0121096009,
0.0038130861,
0.0180897173,
-0.0053500095,
-0.0481247269,
0.0289017987,
0.0585471876,
0.0274021085,
-0.0275636446,
-0.0044061085,
-0.0121790068,
-0.0470986441,
0.0284629874,
-0.0004996046,
0.0848466009,
0.0026076296,
-0.046605166,
0.0683419853,
0.0336702801,
-0.0335618034,
0.036954239,
-0.029006172,
-0.040104147,
0.0139205111,
0.0044357819,
-0.0053447546,
-0.0237091649,
-0.0119242361,
-0.0952117816,
0.0522676036,
0.0118917115,
0.0098558916,
0.0492960885,
-0.083662346,
-0.0293454397,
0.0597736016,
-0.0027360171,
0.0488466211,
-0.0189911332,
0.0221883375,
0.0308419652,
-0.0114351111,
-0.0079715354,
0.0032450149,
-0.0718828887,
-0.0319297649,
-0.0018041863,
0.0142575409,
0.0603597499,
0.0315777659,
-0.0106416438,
0.0271128211,
0.0595620088,
-0.0264563207,
-0.0149982404,
0.0115545569,
-0.0593312234,
-0.0530138128,
0.0743374974,
-0.0128239542,
0.051497899,
0.014701277,
0.0625605285,
-0.0809428021,
0.02055379,
-0.0455830246,
0.041585207,
-0.0338252187,
0.037701346,
0.0241347738,
-0.0072608599,
0.0035684374,
-0.0134901796,
-0.0377915166,
0.0056699272,
0.0073137842,
-0.0455889814,
0.0121720498,
-0.0864995569,
-0.0007022065,
0.0537088811,
-0.0089606615,
-0.006894229,
-0.014255465,
-0.0078751417,
-0.0034288426,
-0.0215032194,
-0.0639455095,
-0.036301434,
-0.0245025884,
0.0535945334,
0.0125969145,
0.0301787257,
0.0044496981,
-0.0087317303,
-0.0115449782,
-0.0169803016,
-0.0128350249,
0.0121465595,
-0.0111161964,
0.0377147235,
-0.0450236686,
-0.026871657,
-0.0195952561,
0.005697438,
0.0434342921,
-0.0008002084,
-0.0588061772,
-0.0237753503,
-0.0008214242,
-0.0045446949,
0.0493045636,
-0.0213638414,
-0.0516291372,
0.0072785602,
-0.0249662008,
0.0343061052,
-0.0165814329,
-0.0009962408,
-0.0321147852,
0.0372081399,
-0.0403800085,
-0.0628648624,
0.0097399047,
0.0095812371,
-0.0005936747,
-0.0420764275,
-0.015409939,
-0.0348098353,
0.061068695,
0.0015284403,
0.0296248868,
-0.0444154702,
-0.0365096927,
-0.0247136578,
-0.0434467308,
-0.0172091853,
-0.0583807006,
-0.0504511371,
0.0144749386,
-0.009813128,
-0.0144448392,
0.0261853822,
-0.1055139303,
-0.0052861329,
-0.0524157993,
-0.0484654456,
-0.0350671671,
0.0001086741,
0.0142169232,
-0.014424907,
0.0069661993,
-0.0358121693,
-0.0012916989,
0.0102964146,
0.011091074,
-0.019502908,
0.0651756972,
-0.0579427071,
0.0349258035,
-0.0042483872,
0.0029489347,
-0.0006173832,
0.0011002645,
0.0027200906,
0.0080305059,
0.003507755,
-0.0173154399,
0.030535154,
0.0369908586,
0.0581950471,
0.0766390711,
0.0265616756,
0.0229094569,
-0.0145077985,
0.0556182079,
0.0136696883,
0.0012556132,
-0.0133401891,
-0.0203513578,
-0.0059210178,
-0.035054028,
0.0680322349,
0.0027630744,
-0.0486650579,
0.0049907118,
0.0560627803,
0.0052092476,
-0.0140792755,
0.0409342311,
0.0461866595,
-0.0184686333,
0.0109525844,
0.0923177004,
-0.0328238495,
-0.0623221174,
-0.0154540641,
0.0239709653,
-0.0108554717,
-0.0010028282,
-0.047034055,
0.0008264085,
-0.0224241726,
0.0406375937,
0.0024910849,
0.0187704209,
0.0118546095,
-0.0289474204,
-0.1043422073,
-0.0211899374,
0.0395715758,
-0.060673587,
-0.0673362687,
-0.0810006782,
-0.0040511694,
-0.0177306533,
0.0242731608,
-0.0039582769,
-0.0334940366,
-0.0300905947,
0.0346238278,
-0.0592536852,
-0.0775010809,
-0.065266639,
-0.049707491,
0.011441268,
0.0971793383,
0.0119712576,
-0.03662825,
-0.0202116277,
0.0955818519,
-0.04264066,
-0.0008817014,
0.0029224968,
0.0598541237,
0.0249185748,
-0.0026201257,
0.0221621394,
0.0191504247,
-0.0337708704,
0.0064476626,
-0.0202390868,
0.0045706872,
-0.0072756177,
0.040909417,
0.0156453773,
0.0199718345,
0.0239867531,
0.0595559664,
0.0106540518,
-0.0194446836,
0.0399999507,
0.010782023,
0.0401390642,
0.0101784719,
0.0093617039,
-0.0270627849,
-0.0177238807,
-0.0815527961,
-0.0453997217,
-0.0583612882,
-0.0049733007,
0.029060591,
0.0396527126,
0.0065682717,
0.020933006,
0.0263359919,
0.0211530905,
0.0072946469,
-0.0126263546,
0.0119136143,
-0.0229125265,
0.0353966728,
0.0093415016,
-0.0244906284,
-0.0013238563,
0.0307704099,
-0.0502761379,
-0.0626181439,
-0.0259933248,
-0.0190983862,
0.0255871024,
0.0819567367,
-0.0186346713,
-0.039029967,
0.0398230292,
-0.0235534888,
-0.0558355264,
0.0377118587,
0.0351465978,
-0.0136646274,
-0.00981778,
-0.0005679214,
-0.0482902527,
-0.010683001,
0.0074558002,
0.0209158473,
-0.0256895758,
-0.0804220513,
-0.0133556817,
0.030322751,
0.0421288311,
-0.0161840301,
0.0375738926,
-0.0517446399,
0.0479665659,
-0.008111937,
0.0559215657,
0.0018740143,
-0.0194678158,
0.0779206008,
0.0220994819,
-0.0101496503,
0.0084582688,
0.0277639274,
-0.0323744528,
0.0011140725,
0.0223166458,
0.0631121174,
0.0270714294,
0.0033907189,
-0.0121029075,
-0.0305300448,
0.0283048488,
0.0153483804,
-0.0123557029,
-0.0212334897,
0.039040979,
0.0085063009,
-0.0228768531,
0.0165680852,
-0.0075478759,
-0.0202441737,
0.0002210185,
-0.0343340598,
0.0254178625,
0.0607796125,
-0.0134286731,
0.0508577824,
0.0050843796,
0.0080272006,
-0.0430624746,
-0.0148111936,
-0.0375923291,
0.0298819132,
0.0356204696,
-0.0111395307,
-0.0072579919,
0.0225022398,
0.076604493,
0.0262574814,
0.0572048016,
-0.0613055937,
0.0619312115,
-0.0313705318,
-0.0181470402,
0.0119821336,
0.0333146602,
-0.0313365944,
0.0211396087,
-0.0110025993,
-0.0272136051,
0.0443663076,
-0.0301898513,
0.0371072516,
0.0004440862,
0.0272589661,
0.0198813956,
-0.0358110853,
0.0003935025,
0.0194968581,
-0.0255745072,
0.0247996151,
-0.0033029087,
-0.0515847802,
-6.381106431e-33,
-0.0478448309,
0.0001232681,
0.0190453455,
-0.0030945186,
-0.0101623032,
0.0011898051,
-0.0026197489,
-0.018108448,
0.0145445243,
-0.0157407727,
0.0015330182,
0.0137426117,
0.0318001471,
0.0204312373,
-0.0165038146,
-0.001057114,
0.0698589012,
-0.017285252,
-0.0007979615,
-0.0421854518,
0.0294626076,
0.046959918,
0.0699465796,
-0.0121459868,
0.0106673976,
0.0045516365,
0.007276448,
0.0123194112,
-0.0046431841,
0.036453452,
-0.0349570103,
0.0154078417,
0.0088697951,
-0.0691982061,
-0.0251664482,
0.0191004518,
-0.0782117844,
-0.0002206653,
0.0039072577,
0.0331359245,
-0.0052336748,
-0.0384855494,
0.0804650113,
0.0155099295,
-0.0509799458,
-0.0161409602,
0.0181026254,
-0.0246975571,
-0.0030685375,
-0.0543755963,
-0.0047761053,
0.0469865203,
-0.0117636463,
-0.0121108638,
0.0656422749,
0.028987566,
-0.0168619882,
-0.0306779891,
-0.1024098545,
0.0398508459,
0.0111002736,
0.0605172068,
0.0304881595,
0.0521630608,
-0.0206368305,
0.0170740262,
0.04468292,
-0.0587923862,
0.0560153611,
-0.0397517458,
0.0389992297,
0.0059157931,
0.0611107051,
-0.0032788222,
0.0507523641,
-0.0010517676,
-0.0634797961,
0.0192380585,
0.0108645158,
0.0056007407,
0.009481106,
0.048961103,
-0.0205716118,
-0.0057824422,
-0.0452873483,
-0.0622414462,
-0.0230218768,
0.0190758202,
0.029099511,
0.0350759365,
0.0423713885,
-0.0020144046,
0.0368418694,
-0.0174170677,
0.0077450308,
0.0077667087,
0.0051759123,
-0.0110574421,
-0.0165397711,
-0.0030281618,
-0.0862953961,
0.0059016147,
0.0314285308,
0.0514913201,
-0.0004322102,
-0.0162350219,
0.0187244639,
0.0133905848,
-0.0347343497,
-0.0189509634,
-0.0426517949,
0.0013741056,
0.0385127738,
0.028338192,
0.0686098412,
-0.0423307642,
-0.0099081248,
0.0417193435,
-0.007288869,
-0.0098883435,
0.0342821032,
-0.0091713648,
0.0267519373,
0.038214229,
-0.0016644897,
0.011793999,
0.0239977408,
0.013653704,
0.0341967605,
0.0043019024,
-0.0227632951,
0.0146942511,
2.842e-7,
-0.0204345733,
-0.0253733955,
0.0628195181,
-0.0425239541,
0.0282208566,
0.021462027,
-0.0510405041,
-0.0198071245,
0.0511448868,
0.016404707,
0.0034723755,
0.0004220516,
0.0450621806,
0.0085856868,
-0.0450381823,
-0.0677637905,
-0.0489136837,
0.037453834,
-0.0021399166,
0.0225719828,
-0.0225851648,
0.053624168,
0.0015010483,
-0.0404307321,
-0.0032791106,
-0.0632874295,
0.0343594477,
-0.0634086579,
-0.0209130775,
0.0315534174,
0.0753016546,
0.0066882549,
-0.0046049613,
0.0349566042,
-0.0314309858,
0.0420085229,
0.0309454799,
0.0151206907,
-0.0356555544,
-0.0755552575,
0.0283633806,
0.0663425699,
-0.0371084288,
0.0052589267,
0.0443496369,
-0.0146391829,
-0.0342400521,
0.0077166995,
-0.0622526929,
0.0140665108,
0.0191904176,
-0.0020559551,
0.0262259189,
-0.0055429097,
-0.0053602392,
0.0068134568,
-0.0557496063,
-0.0415808558,
-0.0217177793,
0.0117654689,
-0.0635150895,
-0.0129523277,
-0.058235541,
0.0044246968,
0.0208594706,
-0.0378126502,
-0.0033972224,
2.306956795e-34,
-0.0092960093,
-0.0295496061,
0.0170821641,
0.0294129942,
0.023008354,
-0.0403371081,
-0.0594233945,
0.0248598587,
-0.0290751606,
-0.0664621145,
-0.0148500297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14107v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14107v2 | Wav2vec-based Detection and Severity Level Classification of Dysarthria from Speech | 2023-09-25T13:00:33 | 2023-10-17T13:38:27 | Farhad Javanmardi, Saska Tirronen, Manila Kodali, Sudarsana Reddy Kadiri, Paavo Alku | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.SP | Automatic detection and severity level classification of dysarthria directly
from acoustic speech signals can be used as a tool in medical diagnosis. In
this work, the pre-trained wav2vec 2.0 model is studied as a feature extractor
to build detection and severity level classification systems for dysarthric
speech. The experiments were carried out with the popularly used UA-speech
database. In the detection experiments, the results revealed that the best
performance was obtained using the embeddings from the first layer of the
wav2vec model that yielded an absolute improvement of 1.23% in accuracy
compared to the best performing baseline feature (spectrogram). In the studied
severity level classification task, the results revealed that the embeddings
from the final layer gave an absolute improvement of 10.62% in accuracy
compared to the best baseline features (mel-frequency cepstral coefficients). | [
0.0059978627,
0.0097070094,
0.0016096835,
0.0174699761,
0.0368978232,
0.0280356891,
0.0038478547,
0.0249274671,
-0.0020190307,
-0.0369433314,
0.0499317385,
-0.0359105058,
0.0397740379,
0.0164199267,
-0.0279501379,
-0.0114970626,
0.023502443,
-0.044340454,
0.0452341288,
-0.0296864249,
-0.0046129143,
-0.0378288031,
-0.077268675,
0.0362008065,
-0.0417030528,
0.0346918888,
0.0170092415,
-0.0454129353,
0.0331109799,
-0.031957712,
0.0115544768,
0.0032286597,
0.0267625712,
-0.0056881811,
0.0000022406,
-0.0166864991,
0.008096762,
0.0146211805,
0.0045645987,
-0.0238311347,
-0.028356716,
0.0244687852,
-0.0100342156,
-0.0027120439,
-0.0216841679,
-0.0951459929,
0.0315701663,
0.0161809996,
0.038940832,
0.0133704701,
-0.0079944292,
-0.0365614966,
0.0189096332,
0.004309725,
-0.0235347468,
-0.0073748594,
0.0479212031,
0.0203629863,
-0.005263974,
-0.0630544499,
-0.0151595287,
0.0499146879,
-0.053880807,
0.023535734,
0.0587494336,
0.0263603851,
-0.0587631352,
-0.0312139913,
0.014678386,
0.0458996929,
-0.0056912871,
-0.0086710202,
-0.008702849,
-0.0033480197,
-0.0121734813,
0.014186589,
-0.0169084687,
-0.0471105874,
0.0122107174,
-0.0001744548,
0.0451600701,
0.0610592775,
-0.0113350293,
-0.0417524837,
0.0043187351,
-0.0194054823,
-0.0148149794,
-0.0043882038,
0.028443994,
-0.0286855306,
-0.0021961948,
0.0322913341,
0.02247734,
0.0086681545,
-0.0298283435,
-0.0255867075,
0.0231284816,
-0.0704295933,
-0.0011833993,
-0.0518117547,
0.0014353261,
-0.0300463103,
-0.0391393229,
-0.0045406567,
-0.0484610349,
-0.0069877752,
-0.0356229544,
-0.0174078364,
-0.0425807498,
0.0078124064,
-0.0008788729,
0.01077036,
-0.0233885944,
0.0159408897,
0.0407176055,
-0.0139940381,
-0.0483498238,
-0.0398586169,
-0.0224352833,
-0.0156087512,
0.0013373506,
0.0271665622,
0.0154320318,
0.0829816386,
0.0237573832,
0.0293936543,
0.0271571167,
0.0475525334,
-0.0565143116,
-0.0357872359,
0.0228968654,
-0.0203732122,
0.0237245373,
0.014304758,
0.0445334837,
0.0663047656,
0.0290556755,
-0.0171956364,
-0.003786671,
0.0231588613,
-0.0415155701,
-0.0007065723,
-0.0302099101,
-0.0515484698,
0.0112840217,
0.0499157235,
0.0014732764,
-0.0026819038,
-0.0029886812,
-0.0430636741,
0.0022931448,
0.0199338142,
-0.0557401814,
0.0294939913,
0.0848332122,
-0.0125940843,
0.009794618,
-0.0001022688,
0.0402547419,
-0.0180244409,
0.0157397129,
-0.0477602445,
0.0129708918,
0.0187646374,
0.0006879147,
-0.016130358,
-0.012752967,
-0.0039597363,
0.0034334674,
0.0115330163,
0.0199676361,
0.0109929238,
0.0260093883,
-0.0253253449,
0.0435145386,
0.0594242476,
0.1087116301,
-0.0158323627,
0.0210492462,
-0.0226642266,
0.0157456808,
-0.018723011,
0.0584737808,
-0.019192908,
-0.0253033042,
-0.0176214576,
-0.000401341,
0.0068167783,
-0.0153455446,
-0.0435260087,
-0.005728995,
-0.0354801975,
-0.0031633587,
0.0235967617,
0.0301224459,
-0.031310644,
0.0143454047,
0.0589244887,
0.0361319184,
-0.0077378545,
-0.0030281777,
-0.0661648065,
0.0317281447,
0.0084427092,
0.0020786563,
-0.0449951924,
0.0359121859,
-0.0699292719,
-0.0591175742,
-0.0647827238,
0.0056296722,
-0.0029923622,
0.0480408929,
-0.0197424535,
-0.057287652,
0.0301294066,
0.0003350828,
-0.0074663544,
-0.0515731685,
0.0222619567,
-0.0230186861,
-0.0383723639,
-0.03247796,
0.0051643099,
-0.0075178994,
-0.0479361005,
-0.0184591096,
0.0289393011,
0.0819050744,
0.0322616585,
-0.0041626291,
-0.0037477864,
0.0127284927,
-0.0512855016,
-0.0329320207,
0.0093888044,
-0.0383998975,
-0.0237497389,
0.0252994113,
-0.0036664153,
0.0353364795,
0.0311911777,
-0.0014661255,
-0.0393109806,
-0.0351467133,
-0.0552195124,
0.0207594931,
-0.0358788893,
0.0382072702,
0.0018532384,
0.0506319404,
0.0393834561,
0.0269824658,
-0.0019115477,
-0.0313458033,
-0.0563470498,
-0.0146059161,
0.0082405284,
-0.0299948417,
-0.064003624,
0.0141554512,
-0.0218736473,
0.0205440968,
0.0034135019,
-0.0369261578,
0.0189797282,
0.0027552419,
-0.0638787299,
-0.0152020315,
0.0002457636,
-0.0344299302,
-0.0366538763,
0.002014525,
0.0115852281,
-0.0138775166,
-0.0394548625,
-0.0550339334,
-0.0023312273,
-0.0004835395,
0.0007401125,
0.0071544088,
-0.0407541208,
-0.0289740078,
-0.0004206907,
-0.0234128032,
-0.0062627955,
-0.0030204027,
-0.0645153746,
-0.0032688675,
-0.0033212495,
0.0396516435,
0.0415685214,
0.0232625566,
-0.0124674188,
-0.0437304005,
0.0110821566,
0.000945776,
0.0233452134,
0.0526871644,
0.0762405917,
0.0436072052,
0.0513580441,
0.0122355092,
0.026991291,
-0.0332722217,
0.0866873041,
0.0023688625,
0.0468500629,
-0.0175502151,
0.0472122431,
0.0565189496,
0.0161977839,
-0.0291478783,
-0.0112773748,
0.0111929234,
-0.0101316245,
-0.0353148617,
-0.074169375,
-0.0275545307,
-0.0007084601,
0.0240804702,
-0.0594006553,
0.0159813184,
-0.0518078059,
0.0002639193,
-0.0466925688,
-0.0865666866,
-0.0141745452,
-0.029356055,
-0.0420865007,
0.010033695,
-0.0618804023,
-0.0291402601,
0.0472161584,
-0.0129012167,
0.03112128,
-0.0891216099,
0.0134944683,
0.0350016356,
-0.0114105213,
-0.0239245836,
0.0109951468,
-0.0662341118,
0.0138423406,
-0.0325279087,
0.0467474349,
-0.0272727199,
0.0014199386,
0.0124179544,
0.0797748417,
-0.0305446964,
0.0641248077,
0.0166492052,
0.0349336863,
-0.0130793359,
0.0720621198,
0.0246437546,
0.0601639748,
-0.0329251029,
0.0165020321,
0.0017328712,
-0.0133141866,
-0.0142088551,
0.0415379517,
-0.0385087207,
0.0198495127,
0.0040376103,
-0.0222714208,
-0.0287814569,
0.0097537236,
-0.0425768569,
0.0063311388,
0.0376582928,
0.0501286648,
0.0327518657,
-0.0486468747,
0.0026438858,
0.0057409462,
-0.040911302,
-0.0197750665,
-0.043774832,
-0.0153250806,
-0.0218603611,
0.0161737148,
0.01708005,
0.0507945903,
0.0126555813,
0.0172177665,
0.0139706312,
0.0276777372,
0.0146377394,
0.0261977389,
-0.027740024,
0.0059794593,
-0.0119022327,
-0.0237198696,
0.0380459316,
-0.0262985528,
0.0002363289,
0.0016757379,
0.0395405106,
-0.0820485577,
-0.0267251991,
0.0745886937,
-0.0251974072,
0.0420885608,
0.0714658275,
-0.0027844652,
-0.0075001968,
-0.0944078267,
-0.0261085238,
-0.020599816,
-0.0068922206,
-0.0211550277,
0.0534612015,
-0.0065802699,
0.0111058252,
-0.0042672758,
0.0384726562,
-0.024312526,
0.0483197905,
-0.0142641375,
0.0751080811,
-0.0262035448,
-0.0319042169,
-0.0556941777,
0.0202748254,
0.0074334238,
0.0302273054,
0.0340659246,
-0.0029783202,
-0.0338094421,
0.0568793267,
0.0584353283,
0.0970463306,
-0.0357042328,
0.0334432758,
0.0401743054,
-0.0946405306,
-0.035400752,
0.0134696448,
0.025048757,
0.0057630464,
0.0235186815,
0.1050262377,
0.0155474134,
0.0193977896,
-0.0794749483,
0.0106708035,
0.1135524288,
0.0702348724,
-0.0385398492,
-0.0348900892,
0.065229468,
-0.0298015103,
-0.05278017,
-0.0490492582,
0.0309578609,
-0.0153465103,
0.0832897201,
-0.0305076875,
0.0083099101,
0.0045919148,
-0.0627433807,
-0.0145419128,
0.0774909332,
-0.0136369821,
-0.0903881416,
0.0308700483,
0.0638280064,
-0.0177870914,
-0.007485447,
0.0302917045,
-0.0276486445,
0.039635554,
-0.0224795304,
-0.0033893778,
0.0264065079,
-0.0307277236,
0.0260499995,
0.0146573512,
0.0876577497,
0.0075231437,
-0.0537295118,
-0.041291967,
0.0512468815,
0.0396002531,
0.0540101193,
-0.0339212269,
0.0223440621,
-0.0284978263,
0.000470483,
-0.0540636331,
0.022484405,
-0.0439397134,
-0.0618888475,
0.0492766052,
0.144824788,
0.0549492836,
0.0033420988,
0.0256128479,
-0.011322787,
-0.0054433094,
0.0112343039,
0.0210022889,
0.0003102822,
0.0115422895,
-0.007101831,
-0.0088127991,
-0.0042359838,
0.0202220418,
0.0511725396,
0.0221176073,
-0.0085301129,
0.0073398999,
-0.0565960519,
0.0032830399,
-0.0168108996,
0.0069795144,
0.033900626,
0.0097121689,
-0.0038836263,
-0.0227311533,
-0.0675235018,
0.0578486249,
0.0753757209,
-0.0018647437,
-0.0422441177,
0.0304517653,
-0.0030683023,
0.0035078346,
-0.0194859225,
-0.0214550383,
-0.0102489255,
-0.022189321,
-0.0138550866,
0.0440152995,
0.0030941493,
-0.0779868737,
0.0269868802,
-0.0356419124,
-0.0691579059,
-0.0086544296,
-0.0510710441,
0.0120021421,
-0.0203623772,
-0.0136856092,
0.0000372319,
-0.0071798353,
0.0029349157,
0.0143021792,
-0.0469541922,
-0.0192205496,
0.0109440135,
0.0432980284,
-5.973828863e-33,
-0.0044915779,
-0.0226905402,
0.0143771498,
0.0059405067,
0.0028221468,
0.0490901731,
0.0365695134,
0.0107146557,
-0.0310893841,
0.0101266894,
0.000088177,
-0.0242052879,
0.0315757841,
-0.0398562849,
-0.0122537538,
-0.0042281863,
0.0466402993,
-0.000391695,
0.0018758317,
-0.0255413093,
0.0445518903,
0.0231825672,
0.0257597119,
-0.0859608129,
-0.0548054427,
-0.0146472612,
0.0207088497,
-0.055252295,
0.0170863029,
-0.0075588175,
-0.0301283579,
0.0310738795,
0.0099026682,
0.0456097089,
0.0271670278,
-0.0030984704,
-0.0731821507,
0.0247115865,
-0.0066113323,
0.0247581583,
0.0247107204,
0.0080612916,
0.0201192927,
0.0300482865,
-0.0228693597,
-0.0161374472,
0.0531308353,
-0.07136783,
0.0082826708,
-0.074325189,
-0.001046323,
0.0344230235,
0.0202667732,
-0.0068865134,
0.0636697412,
-0.0280697197,
-0.0179423168,
-0.0066295583,
-0.0404475369,
0.0026118299,
0.0624477714,
0.0493628345,
-0.0045202239,
-0.0443950891,
-0.0099662114,
0.0499782301,
0.0787063763,
-0.0857943594,
0.0500414483,
0.0157135502,
-0.0239304956,
0.066173099,
-0.0001335502,
-0.0389239937,
0.0652017668,
-0.0711532906,
-0.038865719,
0.0048834258,
0.0041586747,
0.0311779436,
-0.0007230084,
0.0022071043,
-0.0559343956,
0.0083319061,
-0.038444411,
0.0440709591,
-0.010287975,
-0.0263210572,
0.0618103445,
-0.010256432,
0.0109506957,
-0.0370151773,
0.0046508405,
-0.0362759419,
0.0618276559,
-0.001708867,
-0.0017050214,
-0.0119744148,
0.0081711588,
-0.0176342223,
0.0311145876,
-0.0467765667,
0.0625936389,
-0.015220413,
0.0384615324,
-0.0361988842,
-0.0057881325,
0.0335697122,
-0.0246871244,
-0.0154034607,
0.0402789563,
-0.0134663964,
-0.0231443401,
0.1061229259,
0.0218510833,
-0.0101201963,
-0.0325448737,
0.0263045784,
-0.0472414158,
0.0330505148,
-0.0395738631,
-0.0091580721,
0.0312962346,
0.0578268245,
-0.0250971578,
-0.0021126375,
-0.022122385,
0.0345931351,
0.0441726185,
-0.0244020466,
0.0092560491,
-0.0135270515,
2.947e-7,
-0.0291079953,
0.0198318716,
0.006643286,
-0.0537795983,
0.0097037051,
0.0163565818,
-0.0258087311,
-0.0297048744,
0.0081981476,
0.0384490564,
-0.0054136561,
-0.0230882019,
0.0513202734,
0.0211439822,
-0.0077317581,
-0.0031734987,
-0.0394964069,
0.0357959978,
-0.0144127961,
0.0041397349,
0.0394663215,
0.0525597557,
-0.0579956062,
-0.080754295,
0.0552915521,
0.0109095722,
-0.019481685,
-0.0044282908,
0.0338807628,
-0.0378914066,
0.0080434661,
-0.0296198111,
0.0447324887,
0.0363636948,
-0.0486067422,
0.0803262219,
-0.0066877883,
0.0282714181,
-0.0497631691,
-0.0247769393,
0.0306621864,
0.0427640453,
-0.0051028039,
0.0286914762,
0.0483651049,
0.0162333902,
-0.043346554,
-0.0282861367,
-0.0486955866,
-0.0013729704,
0.0204922128,
-0.0173081011,
0.0182604473,
-0.0585309118,
-0.0124741634,
-0.0235928763,
-0.017159475,
-0.053242933,
0.0225249697,
-0.0015555788,
-0.0202834923,
-0.0453069806,
0.0324078389,
-0.0197842941,
0.063473925,
-0.0086498298,
0.000809078,
2.446257238e-34,
0.0131635806,
-0.0169042014,
-0.0102211982,
-0.0057836086,
-0.0445137694,
-0.0480433479,
0.057100717,
0.011635771,
0.0233109668,
-0.0195030682,
-0.0671963468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14084v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14084v1 | Comprehensive Overview of Named Entity Recognition: Models, Domain-Specific Applications and Challenges | 2023-09-25T12:23:37 | 2023-09-25T12:23:37 | Kalyani Pakhale | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | In the domain of Natural Language Processing (NLP), Named Entity Recognition
(NER) stands out as a pivotal mechanism for extracting structured insights from
unstructured text. This manuscript offers an exhaustive exploration into the
evolving landscape of NER methodologies, blending foundational principles with
contemporary AI advancements. Beginning with the rudimentary concepts of NER,
the study spans a spectrum of techniques from traditional rule-based strategies
to the contemporary marvels of transformer architectures, particularly
highlighting integrations such as BERT with LSTM and CNN. The narrative
accentuates domain-specific NER models, tailored for intricate areas like
finance, legal, and healthcare, emphasizing their specialized adaptability.
Additionally, the research delves into cutting-edge paradigms including
reinforcement learning, innovative constructs like E-NER, and the interplay of
Optical Character Recognition (OCR) in augmenting NER capabilities. Grounding
its insights in practical realms, the paper sheds light on the indispensable
role of NER in sectors like finance and biomedicine, addressing the unique
challenges they present. The conclusion outlines open challenges and avenues,
marking this work as a comprehensive guide for those delving into NER research
and applications. | [
0.0547238328,
0.0374125876,
0.002669102,
-0.0043378314,
-0.0072676125,
0.0395283327,
0.0078703575,
0.0435304791,
0.006579502,
-0.0521834269,
-0.0280949324,
0.0012973796,
0.003674783,
0.0502565838,
0.0154637462,
-0.0377738588,
0.0025752967,
-0.0113891819,
0.0598064959,
0.0387263075,
-0.0202166606,
0.0013880341,
-0.0027164274,
0.0386025682,
0.0391110964,
0.0336559452,
-0.0097506372,
-0.0042364229,
0.0340218507,
-0.0592507012,
0.0056008995,
0.011245653,
0.0004377481,
0.0547350943,
0.0000019556,
-0.0499378033,
-0.0807398334,
0.0249304008,
-0.0325242579,
-0.0599561892,
0.021906469,
-0.0552245118,
-0.012650785,
-0.0019476208,
-0.0291597005,
-0.0267850365,
0.0432931557,
0.1103038266,
0.020987967,
0.0879769251,
-0.0236572754,
-0.0114983451,
0.0607151054,
-0.0194224175,
-0.025449533,
-0.0213491675,
0.0482123122,
-0.0707940236,
-0.0177822504,
-0.0128802089,
-0.0032791477,
0.018048957,
-0.0062968386,
0.0115095926,
0.0146233412,
0.0491386093,
-0.0259959996,
0.0270806551,
-0.0583375432,
0.0368776023,
-0.0223481413,
0.0477205776,
0.070943594,
-0.024612736,
-0.0259264167,
0.0115599586,
-0.0085423952,
0.0209588204,
-0.0306258332,
-0.001943353,
0.0052414057,
-0.0003871243,
0.0014362823,
0.003121359,
-0.0290379282,
0.0144985896,
0.0012133499,
-0.0648047552,
0.0440985262,
0.0132883955,
0.026568165,
-0.0543974973,
0.0569575578,
0.0653595477,
0.0339119248,
0.0274463892,
-0.0119550182,
-0.0176764112,
0.0149288196,
-0.0453682058,
0.0250644311,
-0.0138055691,
0.0049096909,
0.0319668651,
-0.0678348616,
0.0367880799,
-0.0304685086,
0.0276056435,
0.0277357735,
0.0111623006,
-0.0781111792,
-0.027926676,
-0.0181999709,
0.0710312799,
-0.0362380333,
-0.0181142017,
-0.0469555631,
-0.0043716757,
-0.004484992,
0.0434288047,
0.008332937,
-0.0024448291,
0.0101286406,
0.0003009685,
-0.0700788349,
0.0044809501,
0.020674387,
-0.0216767788,
-0.0204548985,
-0.0354653075,
0.0092003094,
-0.0140690403,
0.0197724104,
-0.0346796662,
0.032882601,
0.1065421999,
0.0408564247,
-0.1111764386,
-0.0434249677,
-0.0243614931,
-0.017057078,
-0.0152115123,
0.0327209644,
-0.0109774591,
0.0021533652,
-0.0161088798,
-0.0100067947,
-0.0422400087,
0.0292774532,
0.0016510837,
-0.0414624959,
0.0689855292,
-0.0165241454,
-0.0576986186,
0.0333845429,
-0.0108199287,
0.0508625507,
0.0053321435,
0.0457078367,
0.0047637005,
0.0233708322,
-0.0044035921,
0.0160198212,
0.0136243142,
0.0190468132,
-0.0709313527,
0.0137387952,
0.0078333216,
-0.0253715869,
0.0013311576,
0.0142524941,
0.0283839758,
-0.0132983075,
0.0061522364,
0.0301802326,
0.0742075741,
0.0530990697,
0.0042830966,
-0.0073119416,
-0.0149434451,
0.0097183362,
-0.0320496894,
-0.0177087598,
0.0098767979,
-0.0039668744,
0.0197621211,
-0.0605821088,
0.0477803834,
-0.0042028851,
-0.0238508359,
0.0079645822,
-0.015524121,
-0.012670422,
-0.0214005988,
0.0503952056,
0.0056397957,
-0.0765882507,
0.0668236762,
0.0229187794,
-0.0077173584,
0.0175338648,
-0.0539508015,
0.0013145033,
0.0687422752,
0.0652269647,
-0.0500142761,
-0.0401590019,
-0.0372967198,
-0.0815679356,
0.0703473762,
-0.0138092469,
-0.0030532132,
0.0021197051,
-0.0402276255,
-0.0165290795,
0.015510411,
0.0019053548,
0.0406664275,
0.0085498095,
0.0372612774,
-0.0109466594,
0.0070718993,
-0.0391005129,
0.057563059,
-0.0393184312,
-0.059070453,
0.0146469148,
0.0217475928,
0.0197268426,
0.0536278524,
-0.0075387061,
-0.0021908563,
0.0074006561,
-0.0166771039,
-0.0498428158,
-0.0310764387,
0.0074480511,
-0.0071328566,
-0.0279067643,
-0.0382303633,
-0.0153454468,
-0.0105295312,
-0.0252621546,
-0.0371973179,
-0.051144518,
-0.0020471173,
0.0367277078,
-0.043756932,
0.0126081901,
0.028786201,
0.0017563992,
-0.0321935788,
0.0418025702,
-0.0189078655,
0.0024237595,
0.0114356503,
-0.0208814032,
-0.0126543147,
-0.0488417558,
-0.005946286,
0.008787455,
-0.0178593043,
-0.0273750052,
0.0148892114,
0.0046348176,
-0.0184507221,
-0.0487608239,
-0.0412997492,
0.0060714339,
0.0078547429,
0.0595496148,
-0.0095558986,
0.0092455046,
-0.0214732029,
-0.0449848101,
-0.0036845107,
-0.0290405508,
-0.0083696498,
-0.0288218316,
0.069586426,
0.021569252,
-0.042081207,
0.0025674447,
0.0072678593,
-0.0543675199,
0.0313925184,
0.0405807346,
-0.0602579601,
-0.0575010031,
0.0046829134,
-0.0114072235,
0.0253128987,
-0.0022248572,
0.0493338294,
-0.0057232738,
0.0370227918,
-0.002165261,
0.0711330473,
0.011572537,
0.0673004091,
-0.0391787477,
-0.0056991111,
-0.0158257242,
0.0342778973,
-0.0591075979,
0.053649161,
-0.0140387183,
-0.025861809,
0.0782088488,
0.0714298785,
-0.0390000343,
0.0155459587,
-0.0343128629,
-0.0006129505,
-0.0161947273,
-0.0252564512,
0.0013112961,
0.009174156,
-0.0147086736,
0.0164742526,
-0.0001692101,
-0.0127417929,
0.0858858749,
-0.0125635359,
0.0080728093,
-0.0491738543,
-0.005546866,
-0.0548913293,
0.0264852401,
0.0153930075,
0.0015796561,
0.0756313652,
-0.0875924677,
0.0523657538,
0.0082464823,
-0.0004486801,
-0.0235338286,
0.0518177748,
0.0012240103,
0.0231900364,
-0.0204695202,
-0.0440628268,
-0.0176527072,
-0.0163054299,
-0.0354004763,
0.025899522,
0.0127485385,
-0.0447860956,
-0.0361267664,
0.0381602012,
-0.0044523571,
0.0348186009,
-0.0022889653,
-0.0305396058,
-0.0443970487,
0.0703413934,
0.0377433375,
0.0014551441,
0.0480391718,
-0.0177840237,
0.004356693,
0.0252763946,
-0.0183198377,
-0.008718756,
0.0205774419,
0.015150235,
-0.0055381544,
-0.1126413867,
0.0251361392,
0.0065381955,
-0.0114534246,
-0.0458750539,
-0.0014609958,
0.0990444198,
0.0115388334,
-0.0035383331,
-0.0202316251,
0.0045063989,
-0.0154924262,
-0.0209507812,
0.0407493897,
-0.0743483901,
-0.0158298481,
-0.0031807802,
0.0094251791,
-0.0252930392,
-0.0978562012,
0.002903684,
-0.0764322281,
0.036736168,
-0.0529929847,
-0.0262718089,
0.0020934746,
-0.0445948765,
-0.0084117865,
-0.0334537476,
-0.0083583286,
-0.0329485871,
-0.0269234274,
-0.0159304421,
0.0189611576,
-0.0180020407,
-0.0172912758,
-0.00331832,
-0.0484229475,
0.0053508813,
0.0692861527,
0.0394335575,
-0.0311255567,
-0.0090445057,
-0.0499339998,
-0.0127642946,
0.0161336325,
-0.0080543496,
0.0803460032,
-0.0396034829,
-0.0056126798,
-0.0419165306,
0.0078663733,
-0.029024221,
-0.0190861076,
0.0133184912,
0.0239031631,
-0.0247092787,
-0.0150342947,
-0.0041439249,
-0.0313155726,
0.0139554804,
0.0462972336,
-0.0108509958,
-0.0250442345,
-0.0519868471,
0.007720368,
0.0423147567,
-0.0373177677,
-0.0217521321,
-0.016561944,
-0.0382526256,
-0.0368979685,
-0.0380663872,
-0.0303231105,
0.0199922323,
0.0335633531,
0.0321860313,
-0.0247922447,
0.1102766469,
0.007245535,
-0.0603696816,
0.0042090868,
-0.0226010624,
-0.0114471409,
-0.0632615909,
0.0013367404,
0.0042192396,
0.0116486447,
-0.0504697189,
-0.0122435726,
-0.0184823927,
-0.0310383905,
0.009261773,
0.0086286021,
0.0147454394,
0.0018861012,
0.0043050968,
0.0067164241,
0.0720985308,
0.0427951477,
-0.0241061877,
-0.032792367,
0.0336182453,
0.0211302191,
-0.0295218192,
-0.0008791238,
-0.0170929283,
0.0361349061,
0.0062741176,
0.0033039837,
-0.010247699,
-0.0204591583,
-0.0037892847,
-0.0092148352,
0.0725715607,
0.0107036363,
-0.0288449805,
-0.0585289523,
0.0207465086,
0.0148169007,
0.0482289121,
-0.0001131302,
-0.0511486307,
0.0106086927,
0.0215488467,
-0.0358646922,
0.0782662109,
-0.0311890543,
-0.018588718,
-0.0655171648,
0.039315585,
0.0333558433,
0.057110101,
0.00295466,
-0.0544394143,
0.0419382975,
0.0510410927,
0.0478237979,
0.0526668169,
-0.0010873856,
0.02682334,
0.0266384333,
0.011490318,
-0.0212880503,
0.0239235628,
-0.0531213917,
0.0228414144,
-0.0184022784,
0.051763162,
0.0051452299,
0.009624348,
0.0289557558,
-0.02364856,
-0.0037620883,
0.0457475893,
-0.0099708149,
-0.0076663792,
-0.0018465348,
0.0187198929,
0.0236513838,
-0.0284598507,
-0.0291340053,
0.0470523573,
0.0029779915,
0.0333666317,
0.0047087693,
-0.03729463,
-0.0405762047,
-0.0300890766,
0.0540253595,
-0.039448835,
-0.0213291608,
-0.0073171933,
-0.0510850847,
-0.006630878,
0.076640062,
-0.0196416173,
0.0138883982,
-0.0144076431,
0.0258797798,
-0.0044678664,
0.0221484601,
-0.0291110333,
-0.0285748411,
0.0259974878,
0.0022627253,
-0.0503405295,
-0.0110669192,
-5.906542831e-33,
-0.0206687506,
-0.0582601167,
0.0337159075,
0.0254632384,
-0.0069686025,
0.0501692556,
-0.0236881357,
-0.0429747775,
0.0496007279,
-0.0141810551,
-0.0033833236,
-0.0033703716,
0.0316094235,
0.0133593818,
-0.0123633267,
-0.0325542614,
0.0271067545,
0.0077218623,
-0.0246968381,
-0.002142525,
0.0160304625,
0.0786156803,
0.0816208869,
-0.0612564199,
0.0482040904,
0.0486812033,
0.0115149477,
-0.0114509109,
0.0753736869,
0.0523230694,
-0.0361824371,
-0.0150836594,
0.0198585261,
-0.101668328,
0.0177878179,
0.0286187697,
-0.1398531795,
-0.0165920258,
-0.0449400842,
0.0261393506,
-0.0277820863,
-0.0146842087,
0.0514038689,
-0.0080312071,
-0.0191838183,
0.025872888,
0.0278989151,
0.0168964732,
0.0224344749,
-0.0365015119,
-0.0762959793,
0.0588290654,
0.001575824,
0.0307883341,
0.067654267,
-0.0105271572,
0.0230630618,
0.0134132206,
-0.0831922665,
-0.0084704682,
0.0443770252,
-0.008865674,
0.0142439827,
0.0288568269,
-0.0415835381,
0.0391253456,
0.0336286686,
0.007616072,
-0.0410437174,
-0.0200106222,
0.0041979128,
0.034105394,
-0.0021863501,
0.0060591819,
0.0350347497,
-0.0083761336,
-0.054656066,
0.0438858233,
-0.006041484,
0.0285057146,
0.0147505561,
-0.01904938,
-0.0577238798,
0.0033902717,
0.0271589104,
-0.0352757722,
-0.0123057524,
0.0011449491,
0.0167638958,
0.0149625596,
-0.0283908136,
0.0458013192,
0.0010405821,
-0.0401133783,
-0.0413523465,
-0.0258078445,
0.0625246465,
0.0262779966,
-0.020380225,
-0.0063890866,
-0.0694075003,
-0.0614878461,
0.0290992297,
0.0006904416,
0.0201378968,
-0.0443025045,
0.0302072223,
0.0153234927,
-0.0590474904,
-0.003077752,
0.0322337598,
0.0543092787,
0.0208138358,
0.0575743429,
0.0042872024,
0.0088589834,
0.0059928293,
-0.0202464946,
0.0445252955,
-0.0187124275,
-0.0251141638,
0.0486195125,
0.0387605727,
0.0285658594,
0.0067346147,
0.0007881828,
0.0019253161,
0.0506272018,
-0.0218747742,
-0.0789190382,
0.0013558205,
0.0296485219,
2.716e-7,
0.0185107291,
0.0621745437,
0.0526805446,
-0.0366910361,
0.0085264081,
0.0184509642,
0.0364691466,
0.0427980572,
-0.0292478614,
0.0065223584,
0.0250166114,
-0.0205275398,
0.0039883624,
0.0006538969,
-0.0938407779,
-0.0705980062,
-0.0355577134,
0.0018070902,
-0.0695266798,
0.0440037064,
-0.0074001374,
0.0437035859,
-0.0268288199,
-0.0454447716,
-0.0082505103,
-0.0065153558,
0.0359533913,
0.0003941704,
0.060134843,
0.0320974886,
0.0285101943,
0.0299802665,
-0.0250841286,
0.037025921,
-0.0092987353,
0.057439696,
0.0024051734,
0.0588413104,
-0.003988863,
-0.0041814502,
0.0100395055,
-0.0084890528,
0.0215594284,
-0.0338555314,
0.0523379929,
-0.0561601818,
-0.0573583767,
0.005172391,
-0.0241011493,
-0.0260176994,
0.0196277294,
0.0222957749,
-0.0352755003,
0.0230447389,
0.0113714021,
-0.0033982052,
0.0122816237,
-0.0714398548,
0.0532528162,
0.0126314489,
0.0030763946,
0.0260365568,
-0.0275839902,
-0.0178630035,
0.0265835635,
-0.0911787897,
0.0079014199,
2.74900512e-34,
-0.0051353504,
-0.007369596,
-0.0370729268,
0.065862976,
0.0197626706,
0.0293293297,
-0.0292611197,
0.0135934334,
-0.0127596967,
-0.0969491377,
-0.002812884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14080v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14080v2 | Analysis and Detection of Pathological Voice using Glottal Source Features | 2023-09-25T12:14:25 | 2023-10-17T13:36:36 | Sudarsana Reddy Kadiri, Paavo Alku | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.SP | Automatic detection of voice pathology enables objective assessment and
earlier intervention for the diagnosis. This study provides a systematic
analysis of glottal source features and investigates their effectiveness in
voice pathology detection. Glottal source features are extracted using glottal
flows estimated with the quasi-closed phase (QCP) glottal inverse filtering
method, using approximate glottal source signals computed with the zero
frequency filtering (ZFF) method, and using acoustic voice signals directly. In
addition, we propose to derive mel-frequency cepstral coefficients (MFCCs) from
the glottal source waveforms computed by QCP and ZFF to effectively capture the
variations in glottal source spectra of pathological voice. Experiments were
carried out using two databases, the Hospital Universitario Principe de
Asturias (HUPA) database and the Saarbrucken Voice Disorders (SVD) database.
Analysis of features revealed that the glottal source contains information that
discriminates normal and pathological voice. Pathology detection experiments
were carried out using support vector machine (SVM). From the detection
experiments it was observed that the performance achieved with the studied
glottal source features is comparable or better than that of conventional MFCCs
and perceptual linear prediction (PLP) features. The best detection performance
was achieved when the glottal source features were combined with the
conventional MFCCs and PLP features, which indicates the complementary nature
of the features. | [
0.0014122046,
0.0133213159,
0.0045761717,
-0.0496355444,
0.017424535,
-0.0163844321,
0.0000952284,
0.0232372172,
-0.0384034403,
0.0329914913,
-0.0127576208,
-0.0119943842,
0.0365599431,
0.0121661332,
0.0066376445,
-0.0163467862,
-0.0354545228,
-0.0208359864,
0.0447855927,
-0.0376870967,
0.0361172222,
-0.018795358,
-0.043073602,
0.0582591072,
-0.0241586231,
0.0094536971,
0.0347611345,
-0.0333179459,
0.0264770109,
-0.0269731227,
-0.0140329637,
-0.0622677281,
-0.0368309245,
0.0099213589,
0.0000018493,
-0.0391464457,
-0.0046072053,
0.021753775,
-0.0315083973,
-0.0581808947,
-0.0263836645,
0.0612721667,
-0.0369824134,
-0.0094245849,
-0.0205133464,
0.0060047614,
0.009188856,
-0.0098518413,
0.0340654366,
0.0293214358,
-0.0364270695,
-0.0070720869,
-0.0111837834,
0.0005520361,
0.0086667472,
-0.0252165291,
0.0406729728,
-0.0168264527,
-0.0006279107,
-0.0723969564,
0.0222253967,
0.059361551,
-0.0593587868,
0.0200816561,
0.0315421447,
0.0181695502,
-0.0506612472,
-0.0553628355,
-0.0002038009,
0.0407153368,
0.0522237569,
-0.0203789137,
-0.0096263485,
-0.0144783538,
-0.027666403,
0.0079431944,
-0.0099849505,
0.02261566,
-0.0165904686,
-0.0075728502,
-0.0018334114,
0.0291636493,
-0.0161824711,
-0.0820542648,
0.0115264514,
0.0170618389,
-0.0149541665,
-0.0472741127,
0.0759022012,
-0.014894532,
-0.0383721367,
0.037972331,
0.0066785272,
0.0446385406,
-0.0191574078,
-0.010670661,
0.0301454682,
-0.098494947,
0.0329948626,
-0.0490721092,
-0.0037235722,
-0.0204837378,
-0.0748995468,
-0.0009696775,
-0.0144784441,
0.0299889371,
-0.0378574394,
-0.0139910942,
-0.0312247779,
0.003231365,
0.0263456386,
-0.0045725894,
0.000906801,
-0.0119649023,
0.017854251,
0.0332424603,
-0.0464300066,
-0.0147241391,
-0.0485386588,
0.009282805,
0.0121479174,
0.0108740255,
0.0211341344,
0.0709116608,
0.0258414242,
0.0136691136,
0.0113736046,
0.0115281707,
-0.0947787091,
-0.0211418215,
0.0365283638,
0.0304726176,
0.0190795679,
0.0218157023,
0.0578288995,
0.0183694456,
0.0254302789,
0.0395588055,
-0.0162663423,
0.0060698199,
-0.0405405685,
0.0010313262,
-0.032984525,
-0.0267894063,
-0.0236501116,
0.0193653088,
-0.0111230398,
0.0199709646,
-0.015791025,
0.0021809528,
0.0446574092,
-0.0511661656,
-0.0449489504,
0.0328121185,
0.0761490092,
-0.002959952,
-0.0448230803,
0.0163441002,
0.0047869533,
-0.0901966393,
0.0132619394,
-0.0216395184,
0.0145443464,
0.0292292219,
0.0120362071,
-0.0232940521,
-0.0807826445,
-0.0341686606,
-0.0327524208,
0.0027715387,
0.0198146552,
0.0079773534,
0.0599902309,
-0.056798622,
0.0135936178,
0.0620889813,
0.0671661496,
0.0080347201,
-0.0073851962,
-0.0170287862,
0.0147707947,
-0.009481837,
0.0389206409,
-0.0264000557,
-0.0554745197,
-0.0280119646,
-0.0247588567,
0.0037585155,
0.0092944335,
-0.0143007534,
-0.0240584929,
0.0004276171,
-0.0449663103,
0.0309666581,
0.0447246619,
-0.0302820727,
0.0121628651,
-0.0312921293,
0.0038485383,
0.0006653856,
-0.0655718073,
-0.0337958783,
0.0451235883,
-0.0241719503,
-0.0275700595,
-0.0732231289,
-0.0202773232,
-0.0580387339,
-0.093015559,
-0.0551895909,
-0.0881781951,
-0.0075954115,
0.059583284,
0.0063591762,
0.0010003528,
0.0732051954,
0.0001356459,
-0.0340246819,
-0.0372964144,
0.0042356909,
-0.0093133347,
-0.0169102084,
0.0319640711,
0.0075603207,
0.0063059935,
-0.0085752998,
-0.0058189863,
0.0138150649,
0.0561354831,
0.0111589786,
0.0080516199,
-0.0041550966,
-0.0097125629,
-0.0090924539,
-0.056939438,
0.0479171015,
-0.0315135941,
0.0300944988,
0.0559381656,
-0.002419045,
0.0107094487,
0.0006561446,
0.0282575581,
-0.0413072221,
-0.0167461783,
-0.0564957,
-0.0198631529,
-0.057225652,
-0.0089233499,
0.0040893359,
0.0117923152,
0.0298424829,
-0.0266955234,
0.0376566164,
0.0063204258,
0.0389051549,
-0.0414067507,
0.0440117419,
-0.0880773216,
-0.0524818599,
0.0212224163,
-0.0531727858,
0.0141841974,
-0.0084393546,
-0.0166839976,
-0.0078566605,
0.0553292781,
-0.05550313,
-0.0132951252,
0.0024865379,
-0.0368427262,
0.0008285318,
0.0024895517,
0.0173562523,
-0.0157393254,
-0.0530306436,
0.0233500898,
0.0372726768,
-0.0149040641,
-0.0166241433,
0.0148344142,
0.0175170191,
-0.015570282,
0.0256235339,
-0.0285032224,
0.0022406173,
-0.0188452527,
-0.0181986839,
0.0269440562,
0.0356328301,
0.0275587719,
0.0313736126,
0.0233258735,
-0.005563553,
-0.0273146648,
0.0047244355,
-0.0129411379,
0.033299502,
0.0058887978,
0.0068096407,
0.0168067683,
0.0403992645,
0.0225857552,
0.0414835997,
-0.0066154967,
0.0242073648,
-0.0276348721,
0.0139282858,
-0.0092880251,
0.016592538,
0.0646487996,
0.0242990404,
-0.0000649778,
0.0288483072,
-0.0051867981,
-0.0132610351,
-0.0395902246,
-0.036918804,
-0.0324616842,
-0.0133733163,
0.0272391029,
-0.0117100393,
-0.0006735326,
-0.0395555831,
-0.0282356441,
-0.0029026088,
-0.0948331133,
-0.0147606414,
-0.0226813033,
-0.0874776542,
0.0125810374,
-0.0309122633,
-0.0048138876,
0.0283926614,
-0.0152617004,
0.036984995,
-0.0420402847,
0.0069121737,
0.0151379881,
-0.0125538614,
0.0118856002,
0.0239795074,
-0.0626647323,
-0.0050636013,
0.0006177195,
0.0269666202,
-0.0375632048,
-0.0019014488,
0.0431427993,
0.0766265243,
-0.0049701864,
0.060114406,
0.0394206308,
0.0097360546,
0.0013060938,
0.0423632897,
-0.0135668619,
0.0738545209,
-0.0362350121,
0.0189052243,
0.0171648338,
-0.0160442069,
-0.0298368875,
0.0476713032,
0.0066480236,
-0.0193603076,
-0.0304403976,
0.0368620381,
-0.0257761572,
-0.0138852131,
-0.0210384764,
-0.002747623,
0.0218585897,
0.0398106873,
0.0044628372,
-0.0340762436,
-0.0080838287,
0.0070846719,
-0.0507679544,
0.0036722485,
-0.0031325624,
0.0183258038,
0.0512863621,
0.055242274,
0.0563377365,
-0.0046322593,
0.035220325,
-0.0254616756,
0.0178492405,
0.0655939803,
0.0006011848,
-0.0245122071,
0.0081906598,
-0.0379292034,
0.0472675785,
-0.0685306937,
-0.0079814456,
-0.0128252981,
0.0070513212,
-0.0248520561,
0.0081883091,
-0.1595028639,
0.0205010623,
0.0331995189,
-0.0485346653,
0.0153136374,
0.0146041969,
0.0004830311,
-0.0361016877,
-0.0423985869,
-0.043642547,
-0.0175207015,
-0.0145406304,
-0.0156153562,
0.0150609482,
0.0495929606,
-0.0071044951,
-0.0002998771,
0.0737382621,
-0.0018523164,
0.0222249683,
0.025774071,
0.0808986649,
-0.0354030691,
-0.0220026299,
-0.0537755601,
0.0890337825,
0.0377652161,
0.0471433923,
-0.0103469985,
-0.0376673266,
0.0030629216,
0.0353577882,
0.077650331,
0.0834764615,
0.0029621634,
0.0663257465,
0.081960842,
-0.1024860889,
-0.0114370845,
0.0475027226,
-0.0247060675,
0.0465193652,
0.0486157425,
0.0727064982,
0.0091525875,
0.0072295298,
0.0001099237,
-0.0206006654,
0.0442532115,
0.0497138686,
-0.0222185254,
0.0020740712,
0.0172017701,
-0.0511765629,
-0.086249426,
-0.0216337498,
-0.0042969994,
-0.0004762531,
0.021323083,
-0.0407200716,
0.010049914,
-0.0040234653,
-0.0866290256,
-0.0484044626,
0.0139180841,
-0.0607073419,
-0.0160281844,
0.0772634,
0.0664489046,
-0.0310954358,
0.0120041035,
0.0204319786,
0.0115782339,
0.0402391404,
-0.0311038867,
0.0081791561,
0.000759716,
-0.0451484099,
0.0311995763,
0.0453808121,
0.0505573973,
0.0188430436,
-0.0000156758,
-0.0201348346,
0.0368744992,
0.0601796322,
0.0566576645,
-0.0029062075,
0.0067568435,
0.0003874414,
-0.0030725568,
-0.0181383621,
-0.0694559664,
-0.0785634965,
-0.0386555083,
-0.0166381262,
0.1050081775,
0.0458122566,
-0.0225609355,
0.025108885,
0.0290656872,
0.025872685,
0.0448849648,
0.0315087885,
-0.0116664162,
0.0336377956,
0.0002409825,
-0.0052158944,
-0.0433775634,
0.0604086183,
-0.0202795416,
-0.0262653027,
-0.0104555236,
-0.0247979145,
-0.0602501035,
0.0216602087,
0.0143438904,
-0.0096734278,
0.021048598,
-0.0037115808,
-0.0222457089,
-0.0191459842,
-0.0684420839,
0.0465525798,
0.0274311285,
-0.0004126102,
-0.0425323136,
0.0434396081,
0.0198879782,
0.0560484901,
-0.0284129418,
-0.0431513637,
0.0037139042,
-0.0274568945,
-0.0263067838,
0.0221789703,
0.0043952852,
-0.0358656943,
0.0140004829,
-0.0396787226,
-0.0300202835,
0.0864044651,
-0.0630749837,
-0.0041274223,
-0.0075729461,
-0.0082226442,
0.0006560829,
-0.0362897068,
0.0229737163,
-0.0010008069,
-0.0405187942,
0.0278733037,
0.0073400098,
0.0094197039,
-5.365689432e-33,
0.0172963925,
-0.0100671779,
0.012058923,
0.0384489,
-0.0072620385,
0.0364164598,
0.0028087914,
0.0053970879,
0.0225019511,
0.0252972655,
-0.0052883606,
-0.0145363975,
0.0196037553,
-0.0513259806,
-0.0245490782,
-0.0277794022,
0.0645975173,
0.0249539819,
0.014148213,
-0.0219781678,
0.0880878195,
0.0557389669,
0.0679462329,
-0.1364068538,
-0.0677342564,
0.0424460955,
-0.0225638859,
-0.0301810298,
0.0120117962,
-0.0253399871,
-0.0147856353,
0.0512070097,
0.0088894777,
-0.0207952112,
0.0309509896,
-0.0258955341,
-0.0113535402,
-0.0054517202,
0.0094973063,
0.0281914454,
0.0280609205,
0.0198668037,
0.0438698493,
-0.015252877,
0.0000538173,
0.0070406389,
0.0441912189,
-0.0512717813,
0.025657896,
-0.0698781088,
0.0353103094,
0.0071991105,
0.0241868608,
0.005808522,
0.0392425805,
0.036211703,
-0.0524850413,
-0.0114401877,
-0.0085493801,
0.0125683658,
0.0323748775,
0.0005501983,
-0.0400690362,
-0.004635192,
0.0056534838,
0.0275960416,
0.0743001029,
-0.1019534245,
-0.0271978583,
-0.012974469,
-0.009747576,
0.0735476762,
-0.0007371559,
-0.051211305,
0.0068079648,
-0.0679505393,
-0.0307075046,
0.0060745706,
-0.0225210283,
-0.0175211728,
-0.0276601091,
0.0126667833,
-0.0283113755,
0.0141517958,
-0.0150678596,
-0.040364828,
-0.0038565067,
0.0313415974,
0.0229176227,
-0.0377332605,
0.0379957743,
0.0069859177,
-0.0110618509,
-0.0101954723,
0.0658284277,
-0.0009538557,
0.0335909761,
-0.0250261463,
0.0309341289,
-0.0061565018,
0.0047524842,
0.0131987371,
0.0699907392,
0.0092135249,
0.0569359288,
-0.0462097265,
0.0129198516,
0.0379400738,
-0.0216920041,
-0.0024587982,
0.0438164473,
0.0180402007,
-0.0022953679,
0.064005211,
0.0319449231,
-0.0065512476,
-0.0035070074,
0.03447349,
0.0016245133,
0.0337659493,
-0.0379911624,
-0.0386755168,
0.0274521075,
0.0010513103,
-0.0267805178,
-0.0036406941,
0.0486901738,
-0.0153407976,
0.0252264068,
-0.0170031823,
0.0036148999,
-0.026397137,
2.746e-7,
0.0187298525,
-0.0583879352,
0.0253974963,
-0.0179341435,
0.0231608544,
0.0146042733,
-0.0119738029,
-0.0252398495,
0.0216029231,
0.0204991158,
0.007842565,
-0.0379997641,
0.0221649595,
0.0416308977,
-0.0222635493,
-0.030085668,
-0.0663946569,
-0.0041116364,
0.006473464,
0.0645024553,
0.0358975008,
0.0115889013,
-0.02839287,
-0.1160289943,
0.0519187674,
0.0135490829,
0.0181811359,
-0.0128434571,
0.0423164666,
-0.0410296619,
0.0107882861,
0.0283676777,
0.0583197437,
0.0128938425,
-0.0051241894,
0.0604290478,
0.0000201982,
0.0354049616,
-0.0195620898,
-0.0724123791,
0.0417134129,
0.1015997529,
-0.0048176446,
0.025737837,
0.0443531089,
0.0640627518,
0.0049541597,
-0.070779331,
-0.0398040041,
-0.0032410203,
0.0303596444,
-0.0410886742,
0.0204676837,
-0.0241674054,
-0.0265014768,
0.015511048,
-0.0289174411,
0.0065511805,
-0.0229182541,
0.0367050208,
-0.020332424,
-0.030990066,
0.0088899322,
0.0374257751,
0.0107803484,
0.0361376703,
-0.0011208041,
2.143103674e-34,
-0.0271067619,
-0.0097304424,
-0.034453705,
-0.0108841667,
-0.0620692708,
-0.0112061976,
0.056510143,
0.0082187681,
-0.0374058634,
-0.0048793615,
-0.0460773073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09224v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09224v1 | The Cybersecurity Crisis of Artificial Intelligence: Unrestrained Adoption and Natural Language-Based Attacks | 2023-09-25T10:48:46 | 2023-09-25T10:48:46 | Andreas Tsamados, Luciano Floridi, Mariarosaria Taddeo | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The widespread integration of autoregressive-large language models (AR-LLMs),
such as ChatGPT, across established applications, like search engines, has
introduced critical vulnerabilities with uniquely scalable characteristics. In
this commentary, we analyse these vulnerabilities, their dependence on natural
language as a vector of attack, and their challenges to cybersecurity best
practices. We offer recommendations designed to mitigate these challenges. | [
0.0442434773,
0.0471800603,
-0.0086977463,
0.0553831197,
-0.0573786721,
-0.0222606473,
-0.0004138417,
0.0021092948,
0.0560794845,
-0.0706746876,
0.0150318956,
-0.0135969762,
-0.0026943183,
0.0474633761,
0.0593983158,
0.0115301264,
0.0720257089,
-0.0455465913,
-0.0147836171,
-0.0186395384,
0.002863154,
-0.0024158272,
0.011091847,
0.0756547228,
0.0108121214,
-0.0242735259,
-0.0028480019,
-0.0249670241,
0.012765835,
-0.0358517319,
-0.0096862633,
0.003251201,
0.0105304159,
0.0409982689,
0.0000018829,
-0.0429068282,
-0.0080203209,
0.0407934375,
-0.0384029187,
0.0261326898,
0.0104896147,
0.0041259415,
-0.0148428073,
0.0523008071,
-0.0343873054,
0.0260227825,
0.015617433,
0.0661610514,
0.0515983701,
0.1081697494,
-0.0107406601,
-0.0275974125,
0.0732979104,
0.0017192813,
-0.0194826275,
-0.0466666557,
0.0343373567,
-0.0280290917,
0.0255792718,
0.054276403,
-0.0124639831,
0.0243339874,
-0.0192026328,
-0.0115471659,
-0.0224483255,
0.0456067473,
-0.0349017903,
0.0126887914,
0.014478757,
0.0052502695,
-0.0013354472,
0.0030369184,
0.0301537793,
0.0340528749,
0.0130655533,
0.0262169465,
-0.0051916637,
0.0099653248,
-0.0085903788,
-0.0404777192,
0.0296686012,
-0.0509092622,
0.0440953672,
0.0471835472,
-0.0081476253,
0.0573497191,
0.0231329184,
-0.022110289,
-0.0039624609,
-0.08234974,
0.0145885665,
-0.0315798745,
-0.0045536868,
0.0073509454,
-0.0257327687,
0.0063315211,
-0.0525133759,
0.0085644666,
0.0263334364,
-0.0593773164,
-0.0122295404,
0.0182249565,
0.0320549347,
0.0154620484,
0.0220366344,
0.05543698,
-0.0222338848,
-0.0023372467,
0.016028095,
0.005017377,
-0.0655425116,
-0.0469391569,
-0.0138647007,
0.0229901876,
0.0401128717,
-0.0057969061,
-0.0349873416,
0.0578523092,
-0.0307662003,
0.0252024997,
-0.0031922574,
0.0084534101,
0.0175546408,
0.0224353075,
0.0212361012,
-0.003006666,
-0.0020789867,
-0.0091270916,
-0.0189352743,
-0.0855491087,
-0.0132366456,
0.0386663079,
-0.0340314507,
-0.0480252132,
-0.0386458188,
0.0951658562,
0.0336256176,
-0.0231783111,
-0.0077200821,
-0.0885567889,
-0.060702879,
0.0067521846,
-0.0149744637,
-0.0282429215,
-0.0286014732,
-0.0078226775,
-0.0035578653,
-0.0210353881,
-0.0114044175,
0.012185677,
-0.0796523169,
0.0643125847,
-0.0149688814,
-0.0069883964,
0.0269397851,
0.0126554398,
0.0215208605,
0.0123577034,
0.0207383353,
0.0417864658,
0.0167932883,
0.008527833,
0.047094252,
0.0344651118,
-0.0005603189,
0.000738084,
0.0114742154,
0.0475832485,
0.016030658,
-0.022581853,
-0.0354142599,
0.0777747482,
0.0052821683,
-0.0522042997,
0.0897592381,
0.0751629621,
-0.0498150364,
0.0511904955,
0.0253772251,
0.0365123786,
0.0127631538,
-0.0366574191,
-0.055581551,
-0.0257442947,
-0.088125512,
-0.036707554,
-0.0096588684,
0.0257648397,
-0.0042354972,
-0.0017319792,
-0.0096321944,
-0.0240995809,
0.0236110352,
-0.0329364538,
0.0007373517,
-0.0068235737,
0.0287124645,
-0.0307982415,
-0.0192128308,
0.0087307822,
-0.0061309366,
-0.1116228551,
-0.0836539343,
0.0625487715,
0.0715378374,
-0.0082069151,
-0.0240177922,
-0.0281540379,
-0.0158441104,
0.0232661571,
-0.0069212653,
0.0406197459,
-0.0396073908,
-0.0036954966,
-0.0097793154,
0.0332227051,
0.0217140429,
-0.0178443734,
-0.0126030585,
0.0409476757,
0.0114802076,
0.0131488917,
-0.0343254134,
0.0043755551,
0.0187569503,
-0.0297679156,
-0.0111582475,
-0.005351481,
0.0460390821,
0.0029649236,
-0.0142324213,
0.0592197031,
0.0408716872,
0.0136732887,
-0.0548303984,
0.0120300166,
0.0113199288,
0.024182044,
0.0085631618,
-0.0501584895,
0.000384325,
0.0515687838,
-0.0184936058,
-0.0062662382,
0.0438777395,
-0.0905791596,
0.0380943529,
0.0081310933,
-0.0206847973,
0.0030444846,
0.0542636402,
-0.0205141753,
0.0189531166,
0.0035496789,
-0.0522292964,
-0.0407730751,
-0.0029280244,
0.0027188384,
-0.0445611179,
-0.0369476043,
0.0105982181,
-0.0163307879,
0.0175385699,
0.0305109769,
0.0007359573,
-0.0277215447,
0.02356386,
-0.0712159574,
-0.0435505435,
0.0061218366,
0.0385979228,
0.0070207086,
-0.0113202026,
-0.0420383178,
-0.0102966828,
-0.0091304276,
-0.0182457678,
-0.0247319546,
0.0401438884,
0.0460179932,
-0.009476983,
-0.0515826829,
0.0025835792,
-0.0087278401,
-0.0314095356,
0.0478401259,
0.030803686,
-0.0324916653,
-0.0107214674,
0.0558937378,
-0.0428563617,
-0.0077256048,
-0.0198613778,
-0.0550995506,
0.0173921939,
-0.0075655892,
-0.0206942596,
0.0172307286,
0.0555539653,
0.0312367156,
0.0362178236,
0.0019095404,
-0.0123078357,
-0.0183722787,
0.0132769123,
-0.0406084284,
-0.0392398499,
0.0136571573,
0.0484798141,
0.0040410152,
0.0456684008,
-0.0247755274,
-0.0076579205,
0.0329281241,
-0.0277004559,
-0.01096645,
-0.0186358932,
-0.0686198547,
-0.0325831659,
-0.0084098903,
0.0192756001,
-0.067694217,
0.0722826868,
-0.04357481,
0.0332533792,
-0.0563451946,
-0.0595982969,
0.0079119271,
0.0267793816,
-0.0123660676,
0.0346013531,
0.0422654636,
-0.0309437681,
-0.0562871918,
-0.0136365388,
0.0257498454,
-0.0256416537,
0.0151162054,
0.0196452495,
0.051345516,
0.0270350687,
-0.0230377465,
-0.0462866016,
-0.0525913611,
-0.0460136458,
-0.0031487371,
0.0410545245,
-0.05989144,
-0.0305763297,
-0.0105213532,
0.0440598018,
-0.0238780715,
0.0055009411,
-0.0382635035,
-0.002308009,
0.0165833365,
0.0281181317,
-0.0413817652,
-0.0091484888,
0.0426593982,
0.0448889546,
0.0912239552,
0.0477691256,
-0.0105139269,
-0.0236244332,
-0.0113549558,
0.0114334738,
-0.0241182949,
-0.0050134175,
0.031671878,
-0.0055898186,
-0.0313676,
-0.014765026,
0.0708192289,
0.021084629,
-0.0340784416,
-0.0011047341,
-0.0071288687,
0.0158988088,
-0.0067383139,
0.0147873135,
-0.0780320689,
-0.0082855169,
0.0149994381,
0.0358454175,
-0.0155181438,
-0.0147672612,
-0.0128617594,
-0.0815403163,
0.0103488034,
0.0079233153,
-0.0144494977,
-0.0176926348,
-0.046131473,
-0.0278773177,
0.0154430829,
0.0565370284,
-0.0376972556,
-0.0117086181,
0.0219521075,
-0.000645494,
-0.0923894122,
-0.0202235766,
0.0497527793,
-0.0250350162,
0.0860153213,
0.0788925663,
0.0459870175,
-0.0444245748,
0.059000846,
0.0738882497,
0.0205211788,
0.0078955786,
-0.0175502971,
0.0224325489,
-0.0129203824,
-0.0006570767,
-0.0042004688,
0.0033813459,
-0.0269646943,
0.0121931164,
0.0414140597,
0.0505613275,
-0.0628165677,
0.0087154219,
-0.0389465131,
-0.0084176082,
0.0185012128,
0.0769843757,
-0.0167320129,
-0.0156821497,
-0.0065852981,
-0.0600936301,
0.0268058963,
0.0169562846,
-0.0806978419,
0.0061844829,
0.0018514964,
-0.038311936,
-0.0530179515,
-0.0392143838,
-0.0279796924,
-0.0145631563,
0.0330530629,
-0.0154782236,
0.0268407036,
0.0371215045,
-0.0467182845,
-0.0269518867,
-0.0390762724,
0.0358496681,
-0.0267922189,
0.0508690327,
0.0294472463,
-0.0136757763,
-0.0177591294,
0.0288607869,
-0.0237241499,
-0.0959852412,
0.0207162369,
0.0266201105,
0.0216436945,
0.0176531989,
-0.0448724963,
-0.0700373277,
0.0939522386,
0.0539521649,
-0.0176798627,
0.0013869373,
0.0563554876,
0.0072262441,
0.0129781757,
0.0258530211,
-0.0198862478,
-0.0165293738,
-0.017641237,
0.0039310935,
-0.0312665775,
-0.0407241732,
0.0111711817,
0.0796963796,
0.0321328603,
0.0064553898,
0.0424883813,
0.0291810352,
-0.0205682758,
-0.0262325238,
-0.0136151789,
0.0155984461,
0.0391272716,
-0.0205489192,
0.0167122763,
0.038837973,
0.0127056865,
-0.0092416797,
-0.0316151343,
0.0163704809,
0.0121477684,
0.0193162113,
0.042126406,
0.0406299569,
0.0116181066,
0.0155122047,
0.0648047104,
0.03039952,
0.024137551,
-0.0189592298,
0.0389490239,
-0.0193871334,
-0.007531723,
-0.0207368601,
0.0468994156,
-0.0865582675,
-0.0814875662,
0.0293696355,
0.0351670161,
0.0072166207,
0.0298342854,
-0.0112597719,
-0.0403810851,
0.0160360504,
-0.0331894346,
-0.0110775884,
-0.0060773003,
-0.0121750589,
0.0042285924,
-0.0009260743,
-0.0403345302,
0.0221588407,
0.0973188952,
-0.0023196726,
0.0444763079,
0.020973647,
-0.0558787622,
0.0053458638,
-0.0434941128,
-0.0218235273,
0.0061600008,
-0.0216418654,
-0.037143521,
-0.0394723527,
-0.0845523104,
-0.022377139,
-0.0296615027,
0.0306801535,
0.0109474948,
0.0199112706,
0.0505078733,
0.017667558,
0.0196477789,
-0.0507744178,
0.0377280079,
-0.0455454439,
-0.0513657965,
0.0214391872,
-5.853569913e-33,
0.0438177325,
-0.0359545164,
-0.0136549473,
-0.0052770944,
-0.0258532166,
0.0360428877,
0.0102921333,
0.0054737628,
-0.0475723594,
0.004135727,
-0.0110012246,
0.0275795851,
0.0081867259,
0.0447743386,
-0.0075584352,
-0.0358359888,
-0.0009720288,
-0.0319577828,
0.03214138,
0.0413502716,
0.0801829398,
0.0046648621,
-0.0081357872,
-0.0808266103,
0.0385710038,
-0.0018424665,
-0.0338603258,
0.0175092723,
0.0028604791,
0.0096307006,
-0.0128518194,
0.030805191,
0.0197595805,
0.0024400356,
-0.0018352356,
0.0506118387,
0.0105685666,
-0.0451333448,
-0.0169175435,
-0.0200043637,
0.0539704002,
-0.0576449335,
0.0244173612,
-0.030243529,
-0.031649299,
0.0319234431,
0.008736751,
-0.0110812001,
-0.0134763205,
-0.0381072499,
-0.0078589339,
0.0024496447,
-0.0610778965,
0.0391530655,
0.0053505134,
0.0101459362,
0.0409943573,
-0.0068727452,
-0.0321018025,
0.0498014055,
-0.0088199759,
0.0325388089,
0.050226368,
0.0144907692,
-0.0089796884,
0.0353981629,
0.0145060457,
-0.0369532295,
-0.0199394654,
0.0099161901,
-0.0132850185,
0.026240265,
0.0282787979,
0.024747856,
-0.004515484,
-0.0400248878,
-0.056066554,
0.0217549093,
0.0287145637,
0.0502713621,
0.0277139377,
-0.0059945467,
-0.109589003,
-0.0166347735,
-0.0001527532,
-0.0058162985,
-0.0464238338,
-0.0147057623,
0.0090514962,
-0.0402547382,
-0.0003084125,
0.0120286811,
-0.0097742351,
-0.0609779321,
-0.0135033838,
0.0159568861,
0.0070521301,
-0.0426247679,
-0.0014216823,
0.0118804267,
0.0122770267,
0.00462852,
-0.0193579718,
-0.0107645486,
0.0241701808,
-0.0263104215,
-0.0081732767,
0.0284981076,
-0.057981953,
-0.0509485975,
-0.0056468635,
0.006968738,
0.018861128,
0.0124346977,
0.0330010541,
0.0165358074,
0.0157646257,
0.0187169649,
0.0603031032,
0.0197548997,
-0.0237068553,
0.0001543742,
-0.0283562131,
0.0019723903,
0.0079674954,
0.0164569225,
-0.0283645894,
0.0557553843,
0.0252529178,
-0.0849915892,
-0.009020932,
-0.0530314893,
2.785e-7,
0.0166478995,
0.0590584464,
0.0285582226,
-0.0016963336,
0.012166529,
0.0552976765,
0.0072210864,
0.0720730275,
-0.0260878839,
0.0176264234,
0.0088531347,
0.0209328216,
0.0134557514,
-0.0010284453,
-0.0312921479,
0.0045502931,
-0.105300501,
-0.0655295476,
-0.0947687626,
0.0071614203,
0.0752614811,
0.0902045891,
0.0173105281,
-0.0178776179,
-0.0391478315,
-0.1023312137,
-0.008957969,
-0.0156703983,
-0.007841411,
-0.0052513969,
0.0421429276,
0.0793986842,
0.0135757942,
0.0363573693,
-0.0296546537,
-0.0244997256,
-0.0336986855,
0.0003918787,
0.0156545993,
0.0109310048,
-0.0316098407,
-0.0548565574,
0.0007444106,
-0.0269185398,
0.0636500642,
-0.0318403021,
-0.0262955222,
-0.0148107912,
-0.0126744872,
-0.0372275002,
0.0306181684,
-0.0483721532,
-0.0428717434,
0.0102474783,
-0.0142794009,
0.0027165809,
0.038051825,
-0.1034782976,
0.0265894141,
-0.0106873047,
-0.0411367118,
-0.0338024721,
0.0008063669,
0.0522998907,
0.0575991198,
0.0109245796,
0.0118967406,
2.54861295e-34,
0.015862735,
-0.0396585427,
-0.0238972027,
0.0080624875,
0.0446346886,
0.0477210283,
0.020318117,
0.0416379087,
0.0080108112,
-0.0582091101,
-0.0566742904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14021v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14021v1 | LORD: Low Rank Decomposition Of Monolingual Code LLMs For One-Shot Compression | 2023-09-25T10:35:17 | 2023-09-25T10:35:17 | Ayush Kaushal, Tejas Vaidhya, Irina Rish | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Low Rank Decomposition of matrix - splitting a large matrix into a product of
two smaller matrix offers a means for compression that reduces the parameters
of a model without sparsification, and hence delivering more speedup on modern
hardware. Moreover, unlike quantization, the compressed linear layers remain
fully differentiable and all the parameters trainable, while being able to
leverage the existing highly efficient kernels over floating point matrices. We
study the potential to compress Large Language Models (LLMs) for monolingual
Code generation via Low Rank Decomposition (LoRD) and observe that ranks for
the linear layers in these models can be reduced by upto 39.58% with less than
1% increase in perplexity. We then use Low Rank Decomposition (LoRD) to
compress StarCoder 16B to 13.2B parameter with no drop and to 12.3B with
minimal drop in HumanEval Pass@1 score, in less than 10 minutes on a single
A100. The compressed models speeds up inference by up to 22.35% with just a
single line of change in code over huggingface's implementation with pytorch
backend. Low Rank Decomposition (LoRD) models remain compatible with state of
the art near-lossless quantization method such as SpQR, which allows leveraging
further compression gains of quantization. Lastly, QLoRA over Low Rank
Decomposition (LoRD) model further reduces memory requirements by as much as
21.2% over vanilla QLoRA while offering similar gains from parameter efficient
fine tuning. Our work shows Low Rank Decomposition (LoRD) as a promising new
paradigm for LLM compression. | [
-0.0345147923,
0.0671627298,
0.0017571526,
0.0587610379,
0.0102379676,
0.0151033225,
0.0136313848,
0.0635397881,
-0.0074446066,
-0.0071228882,
-0.0171787683,
0.0005504738,
0.0161891468,
0.0178402588,
0.0381277576,
0.0071145641,
0.0214218851,
-0.0355694853,
-0.0699948967,
-0.0055954065,
-0.0150570255,
0.0241238419,
0.0527830236,
0.0273980331,
0.0110313054,
-0.0250429325,
-0.0446292721,
0.0136000095,
-0.0147608528,
0.0026464448,
-0.02046993,
0.0673239231,
0.0719621107,
0.0329572409,
0.0000023219,
0.0065851137,
-0.0204522721,
0.0040783584,
-0.0162815526,
0.0670951456,
0.0378484949,
-0.0182159562,
-0.0200791396,
0.0019198527,
-0.0272869933,
-0.0150559908,
0.0536586195,
-0.0288306065,
0.05868892,
0.0128746517,
0.0038104698,
-0.0381395631,
-0.0063591083,
-0.0189237911,
-0.0335775167,
-0.0355115794,
-0.0102957711,
-0.0082521308,
-0.0416703932,
0.0049322797,
-0.0386130512,
0.026291417,
0.0382009521,
0.0026778062,
0.0003249358,
0.0300850589,
-0.0448281206,
-0.0111429412,
0.0142644932,
0.0395438485,
-0.1071677506,
-0.0349022783,
0.0076761027,
0.0196304359,
-0.0055516302,
-0.0992661789,
-0.0298507586,
0.0578920543,
0.0058140052,
0.0254343431,
0.0101936907,
-0.0271803588,
0.0273980424,
-0.0206286851,
-0.0124501204,
0.011598289,
0.0444895364,
-0.0027938939,
-0.0398886837,
-0.0188580267,
-0.0071026585,
-0.0208827984,
-0.005476607,
0.0084326575,
0.0165157355,
-0.0072982777,
-0.0797638372,
-0.0443678573,
0.019449031,
-0.0866212025,
0.0576567687,
0.058319509,
0.0196004175,
0.0123179015,
-0.0432169437,
0.0404534303,
0.0042388416,
-0.0031721438,
-0.0265640225,
0.0259860214,
0.0379980542,
-0.0105340667,
-0.0602817535,
0.0355813578,
-0.0556111149,
0.0119349062,
-0.0378700085,
-0.0092021096,
0.0170351602,
-0.0039633438,
-0.0072891205,
0.0210092515,
-0.0291788969,
-0.0122711975,
0.0615358353,
-0.0016181029,
-0.00445943,
-0.0217290651,
-0.0213257391,
-0.0311220437,
-0.0336838141,
0.0519896373,
-0.001179958,
-0.0143562788,
0.0512435474,
-0.01005683,
-0.0311974455,
-0.02553555,
-0.0129298102,
-0.0204413198,
0.0095179044,
-0.0577560514,
-0.0098828357,
-0.071480982,
0.0241433065,
-0.006702336,
0.0096501,
-0.0358316489,
0.0164241064,
0.0268418472,
-0.030410327,
0.0262537003,
-0.0207934417,
0.0179117955,
0.0068519423,
0.0256661959,
0.0330359042,
0.0662220418,
0.0229752809,
0.0384179689,
-0.0008011536,
-0.0393024907,
-0.0280495062,
0.0430377088,
0.0400040746,
0.0192508958,
-0.0389488861,
-0.0259105582,
-0.0259417668,
-0.0164718721,
0.081182465,
0.0760536715,
-0.0495505445,
-0.0443725809,
0.005076271,
0.06693241,
0.0436797552,
0.0692904517,
0.0484481268,
-0.0023850419,
0.0082162824,
-0.0098582692,
0.0248196721,
0.060425546,
0.0005397738,
-0.0182244275,
0.0766737238,
0.0694944039,
-0.0477401651,
-0.0151831973,
-0.0251787677,
-0.0325616561,
0.0288413335,
-0.0068396828,
0.0157956108,
-0.0089155175,
-0.0490683392,
0.0427168235,
0.0006207129,
-0.1359174848,
-0.0214805454,
-0.0704509392,
-0.0157746989,
0.0211930573,
0.0310242996,
0.0416951701,
0.0072268401,
0.0007898759,
-0.041933801,
0.0161267463,
-0.0074128942,
-0.0088564958,
0.0594451651,
-0.0769336894,
-0.0002034895,
-0.0136664277,
-0.0099280598,
0.0164259281,
0.0155251212,
-0.0002855289,
0.0055221464,
-0.0056949779,
0.0025456399,
0.0189759303,
-0.0370508209,
-0.0038680087,
0.0406837985,
-0.0065642241,
0.0392054878,
0.0141714327,
0.0092395749,
-0.020410968,
0.067880474,
-0.0851110071,
0.0232093278,
-0.061984051,
-0.0248919856,
-0.0878483504,
0.0220828038,
0.0005601024,
0.0064531015,
0.0919941589,
-0.0175790861,
-0.0373501629,
0.0270198323,
-0.027459275,
-0.0336228758,
-0.0557195395,
0.0035803544,
0.0012605684,
0.0488844588,
-0.0074313618,
0.0332876071,
-0.0479854904,
0.0311425235,
0.0348070301,
0.0080493391,
0.0315998197,
-0.032966271,
-0.0574274175,
0.0132426256,
-0.0270157289,
0.0380330235,
-0.0063745817,
0.0444875956,
0.0390978195,
-0.006626748,
-0.0907925814,
0.0164070241,
-0.0442954823,
-0.0082371794,
0.0118686883,
0.0287740473,
0.0313769169,
-0.0192461424,
-0.0415194295,
0.0210506897,
0.0008055984,
-0.0002814547,
-0.0138286632,
-0.0131504331,
-0.0102165053,
-0.0279639848,
-0.0435337536,
0.0282949079,
0.0577477068,
-0.0613103807,
-0.0129622128,
-0.0608367585,
0.0560686626,
-0.0248118024,
0.0206397902,
-0.0120426761,
-0.0653801933,
0.0122843878,
-0.0400888324,
0.0688946322,
0.046850387,
0.0101558166,
0.0285765585,
0.0898905918,
0.0267665125,
-0.0259127598,
0.0389176868,
-0.0173158329,
-0.0341931544,
0.0046045976,
-0.0413054861,
-0.0161208399,
0.0802727118,
0.0211400259,
-0.0094474675,
-0.1026754454,
-0.0298343059,
0.0454312004,
-0.0445257798,
-0.0566050746,
0.0005706988,
0.0062077148,
0.0252331421,
0.01110995,
-0.0526223145,
0.027585702,
-0.0350962989,
-0.0307953749,
0.0233657323,
-0.0439889468,
-0.053002093,
0.041175019,
-0.0261052586,
0.0618502274,
-0.0580831468,
0.0034395845,
-0.0187150687,
0.0283194501,
-0.0425433926,
-0.0437187925,
0.024323808,
-0.001138045,
0.0009106042,
-0.0477852039,
-0.0427230783,
0.0101647833,
0.0148843471,
0.0191014837,
0.0056006284,
0.0274160206,
-0.0224253889,
0.056027066,
0.0624636225,
0.0070603299,
0.0430257767,
0.0033240693,
0.0035124307,
0.0052144183,
0.0134418281,
-0.0096201655,
-0.0155589264,
-0.0116609614,
-0.0219930485,
0.0406889543,
0.0346231237,
-0.0048184455,
0.0644283593,
-0.0166474022,
0.031086009,
0.0577377677,
0.0600805618,
-0.0441166833,
0.032318756,
0.0110566849,
-0.0229570288,
-0.0177712403,
0.0573695004,
0.0338811763,
-0.0483701639,
0.0181508027,
-0.0394218713,
0.0920713246,
0.0228905585,
0.0316919684,
-0.0718509182,
-0.0047315876,
-0.0182695445,
0.0017822438,
0.0516260713,
-0.0074325074,
-0.0202119909,
-0.0601696596,
0.0538906828,
0.0350393616,
-0.0059399628,
-0.0615684465,
-0.0340085477,
-0.0545875542,
0.0096083619,
0.0027327654,
0.0544375516,
-0.0083909445,
0.012466698,
0.0098808352,
-0.017467605,
0.0286687072,
-0.0000433637,
0.0129175475,
0.0242109988,
0.0376609191,
0.0364844948,
0.0177389011,
-0.0319717638,
-0.0249281377,
0.0106885834,
-0.0179744679,
-0.0434214175,
0.0122475596,
0.0168712344,
-0.0095189624,
0.0333072133,
0.0156621803,
-0.0168882664,
0.0026020212,
-0.0400226638,
0.0520147718,
0.006148315,
-0.0347334445,
-0.0170718748,
-0.0053211693,
-0.0523456186,
0.0609523468,
0.0302621312,
-0.0045078676,
-0.0449322909,
-0.0217225328,
-0.0027635896,
-0.0286673736,
-0.045083914,
0.0171565395,
0.0007983251,
-0.0477885753,
-0.0157595277,
0.0283844564,
0.010610084,
0.0178159792,
-0.0655343682,
0.0170416981,
-0.0454746783,
0.0194793735,
-0.0957423896,
-0.0359795503,
-0.0077802041,
-0.0001081392,
-0.0317880362,
0.0073423795,
0.0084958747,
-0.013007083,
0.0153426128,
-0.0107670249,
-0.0860054344,
-0.0473490469,
-0.0409284197,
0.0349249877,
0.0119523639,
0.0287537016,
0.0317512155,
-0.0376328826,
-0.01034139,
0.0346439257,
0.0081184795,
0.0973081589,
0.02465735,
-0.0378502309,
0.0101803252,
0.0460618585,
-0.0313047133,
0.0111718643,
-0.0460786819,
0.0565885082,
-0.0287641995,
-0.040765889,
0.001815849,
0.0120492652,
0.0005041285,
-0.0284431726,
-0.0303011891,
0.019945262,
0.0195170622,
-0.0096172821,
-0.0011508637,
-0.0713266358,
0.0149411792,
0.0219911132,
-0.004869659,
0.0000442752,
0.0275230333,
0.042039115,
0.0422043018,
0.0108336797,
0.0080196653,
-0.0325275436,
-0.022633031,
0.0582154691,
0.0079155108,
-0.0300065558,
-0.0232598558,
0.0003281186,
-0.0139428116,
-0.038429942,
-0.0021580495,
-0.0261342973,
0.0238899812,
-0.0177181996,
0.0416640937,
-0.0190034974,
-0.0796401203,
-0.046977561,
-0.0383000933,
0.0497625247,
0.0757050365,
0.0436941795,
0.0002378036,
-0.0006213865,
-0.0142766647,
0.0169027131,
0.0026241168,
-0.0144708063,
0.0572900996,
0.009020566,
-0.0320625007,
0.0033835343,
0.0811738521,
0.0556354523,
0.0266574882,
-0.0001396542,
0.0113352304,
-0.0328423679,
-0.0146909235,
0.0117425313,
0.0434342287,
0.0085851746,
-0.0046731308,
-0.006173797,
-0.0543536544,
0.0088081453,
0.0392606258,
0.0036604267,
-0.011690639,
0.0419740751,
0.0501143448,
-0.0173551813,
0.0108791431,
-0.0220399573,
-0.0107414918,
0.0176438019,
-0.0565883853,
0.0303684603,
-6.614499365e-33,
-0.0301831122,
0.0140475295,
0.0165858995,
-0.0074875122,
-0.009170399,
-0.0020125811,
-0.0305310842,
0.0105322525,
-0.0169717986,
-0.0187854264,
0.0039771646,
0.0220479239,
-0.0139321536,
0.0059725922,
-0.007560391,
0.0347119905,
0.0611929893,
-0.0051486781,
-0.0034117985,
0.056373477,
0.0280999597,
0.0307396576,
0.0265431907,
0.0048278272,
-0.0699716285,
-0.0145570179,
-0.0098511949,
-0.034342438,
0.0111007551,
0.0118906572,
-0.0669692904,
0.0203939471,
0.0037269292,
0.0013528481,
0.00372838,
0.0166458711,
-0.0314653106,
-0.0169676486,
0.0210046899,
-0.0232080836,
-0.0237306394,
-0.0493831262,
0.0219184253,
0.0323157161,
-0.0495460555,
-0.020272024,
-0.0333446078,
-0.009163728,
-0.0420107916,
-0.0859172046,
-0.021166902,
0.0249400847,
0.0069679478,
-0.0187466368,
0.0692048445,
0.017244298,
-0.0532108396,
0.0385123417,
-0.0190635398,
0.0146591216,
0.0025022204,
0.0941143632,
0.0560472719,
-0.0002447401,
-0.0021387043,
0.0256080665,
0.0275252089,
-0.0145477252,
-0.0143760862,
0.0310283322,
0.0469100587,
0.0454613976,
0.048100803,
0.0480298288,
0.0738686174,
0.0058076992,
-0.081258364,
0.0103981579,
0.01921032,
-0.0166395381,
0.0322541296,
0.0302122645,
-0.0001739396,
-0.0474679619,
-0.0364033617,
-0.0235684123,
-0.0272952449,
-0.0494727865,
0.0243160352,
0.038911432,
-0.0378009938,
-0.0269056633,
0.0541517362,
-0.0375589542,
0.0276459213,
0.0312057007,
-0.0420557521,
0.0396532863,
0.0438054651,
0.0497274809,
-0.0353883877,
0.0109469108,
0.0278975442,
-0.0374091193,
0.0269449502,
0.0023148451,
0.0177636035,
0.0600056276,
-0.0621509701,
-0.0299635623,
-0.0231796913,
-0.0272526946,
0.0013136149,
0.0244508069,
-0.0087936847,
0.0063577313,
0.0152765354,
0.0529190898,
-0.0082182987,
0.0136741884,
-0.0392835364,
-0.0579874478,
0.0307047814,
0.0338424481,
-0.0134291295,
-0.0038839139,
-0.0898111388,
0.0320712626,
0.0757918134,
-0.0789582282,
-0.0578200445,
0.0495646782,
2.933e-7,
0.0128297778,
0.0123494267,
-0.0222258214,
-0.0255428068,
0.0029478553,
0.0200052839,
0.0012398125,
0.0362501852,
-0.0211768486,
-0.0032217151,
-0.0126953647,
0.0158582795,
0.0274041574,
0.0230723564,
-0.0335286744,
0.0257741101,
-0.0521168262,
-0.0197795276,
-0.0454674028,
-0.0234679915,
0.0258827154,
0.1044778749,
-0.0335588977,
-0.032677453,
0.0209497865,
0.0307625066,
0.0330453403,
0.0178221427,
0.0008542992,
-0.0359851159,
0.0015534123,
-0.0061124461,
-0.0337176584,
-0.0417534411,
-0.0170304012,
-0.0101415077,
-0.0161047336,
0.1047276407,
-0.0241407398,
-0.0000019135,
0.0701214224,
-0.0142813092,
-0.0427817963,
-0.0560703762,
0.0497313216,
0.0462254137,
-0.0080407551,
-0.0490154922,
0.0174120385,
0.0476367548,
-0.0134577435,
-0.047665339,
0.0160128083,
0.0286728721,
0.0119400257,
-0.0143376868,
0.0148662049,
-0.0786503032,
-0.027190607,
-0.009611357,
-0.0118095977,
-0.0347456373,
-0.0641160905,
0.009670903,
0.0354425013,
-0.0481491275,
0.0106863119,
3.16569927e-34,
0.0192475934,
-0.0210027117,
0.021345228,
0.0640396476,
-0.0157490186,
-0.0506192893,
0.0034645188,
0.0338989384,
-0.0209404156,
-0.0568958893,
-0.0501766689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14006v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14006v2 | Multiple evolutionary pressures shape identical consonant avoidance in the world's languages | 2023-09-25T10:16:30 | 2023-10-02T20:08:36 | Chundra A. Cathcart | cs.CL | cs.CL | Languages disfavor word forms containing sequences of similar or identical
consonants, due to the biomechanical and cognitive difficulties posed by
patterns of this sort. However, the specific evolutionary processes responsible
for this phenomenon are not fully understood. Words containing sequences of
identical consonants may be more likely to arise than those without; processes
of word form mutation may be more likely to remove than create sequences of
identical consonants in word forms; finally, words containing identical
consonants may die out more frequently than those without. Phylogenetic
analyses of the evolution of homologous word forms indicate that words with
identical consonants arise less frequently than those without, and processes
which mutate word forms are more likely to remove sequences of identical
consonants than introduce them. However, words with identical consonants do not
die out more frequently than those without. Further analyses reveal that forms
with identical consonants are replaced in basic meaning functions more
frequently than words without. Taken together, results suggest that the under
representation of sequences of identical consonants is overwhelmingly a
byproduct of constraints on word form coinage, though processes related to word
usage also serve to ensure that such patterns are infrequent in more salient
vocabulary items. These findings clarify previously unknown aspects of
processes of lexical evolution and competition that take place during language
change, optimizing communicative systems. | [
0.0041028899,
0.010967047,
-0.0518546849,
-0.009388499,
-0.0257208552,
-0.0056338939,
-0.0372188538,
-0.001411711,
-0.0473382175,
-0.0024533228,
-0.0256788451,
-0.0208054557,
0.0356479809,
-0.0268453918,
0.0589758568,
0.0091229472,
0.0087397927,
-0.0241925586,
-0.0047686202,
-0.0038307339,
0.0199916009,
-0.0026569979,
0.0291524027,
-0.0029644291,
0.0295658186,
0.0379317962,
0.0024551675,
-0.0762220994,
0.0144617977,
-0.0027633121,
-0.062297035,
0.0318802819,
-0.0096908435,
0.0350726917,
0.0000015666,
-0.0565634519,
0.0376114473,
-0.0129349753,
-0.0738511086,
0.0214150045,
0.0218307264,
0.0369601957,
0.0068103056,
-0.0314137228,
0.0263525099,
0.018727405,
0.0327091813,
-0.072642006,
-0.043022126,
-0.0180936791,
0.0043468615,
-0.0071760807,
0.0336554348,
-0.0450280607,
0.0083131501,
0.0207232255,
0.032457944,
-0.0730298758,
0.0076665697,
-0.0560633689,
-0.0508765317,
0.0023288163,
-0.0226882827,
0.0467075296,
-0.0652239844,
-0.0108728483,
0.0318676047,
-0.0620704927,
0.0343543887,
0.0102014588,
-0.0326149836,
-0.0658355802,
0.0009658059,
-0.0046740156,
-0.003615171,
0.0000774819,
0.028577162,
0.0099766059,
0.0359459221,
0.0256851129,
0.0591005012,
-0.0650310814,
-0.0448258482,
0.0270763431,
0.0051888195,
0.0243900791,
0.0733731017,
-0.0412667282,
-0.0032809721,
-0.0351379514,
0.0037907162,
-0.0427387245,
-0.007310471,
-0.0103220837,
-0.0066461288,
0.0400547758,
0.0512322336,
-0.0107485047,
0.0305760894,
0.0059786839,
0.0165304039,
-0.0123592187,
-0.017993426,
-0.0172317587,
-0.0387017578,
0.0400384739,
0.0020487052,
-0.0316792428,
-0.007355819,
0.029860273,
-0.0140257468,
-0.0110475998,
0.0380328819,
0.0037550982,
0.0101298112,
0.0138039775,
0.0111712441,
0.0283227116,
-0.0027572694,
-0.068516098,
-0.0705051199,
-0.0273632854,
-0.0494135916,
0.0360388681,
-0.0226649791,
-0.0295738,
-0.0028406759,
0.041275084,
-0.0328087136,
-0.0644801781,
0.0293771885,
-0.0183734205,
0.048531916,
0.0372253992,
-0.0094616031,
0.000189668,
-0.0029317341,
-0.0140287392,
0.0067795399,
0.0230968986,
-0.0773262307,
0.0282709766,
-0.0634273663,
0.0039542178,
0.0323788412,
-0.0030328673,
-0.0381942727,
-0.0398289226,
-0.0366076268,
-0.0310003553,
-0.0615221635,
0.000013317,
0.0093370359,
0.038004823,
0.0321190394,
-0.008453696,
0.0244103279,
-0.0009045184,
-0.0180916693,
-0.0399852991,
0.0507586338,
-0.0132344207,
-0.026582012,
-0.0011687537,
-0.0122486483,
0.0333348587,
0.0211460758,
-0.0063154688,
-0.0002380548,
0.000166015,
0.0273989905,
0.0469548665,
-0.0267144907,
-0.1165063977,
0.0215287972,
0.062689513,
0.0193804875,
0.0010524458,
0.0154630924,
0.0111349793,
-0.0497552045,
0.009381243,
0.0370941199,
-0.0670949295,
-0.0076398239,
-0.0312955901,
0.0095835049,
-0.0097159809,
0.0054173539,
0.0354927741,
-0.0218927637,
0.0271685421,
0.0487001613,
-0.0277468581,
-0.0162869729,
0.0570986345,
-0.0381441265,
-0.0062060049,
0.0218933225,
-0.0454318635,
0.0102049941,
-0.0219390187,
0.1018555239,
-0.026908705,
-0.0187618975,
0.050339628,
0.0131872306,
0.0653984249,
-0.0150250178,
0.0414989032,
0.0202072095,
-0.0232985914,
0.0272579324,
-0.0052233799,
-0.0176075716,
0.0285533722,
-0.0451124161,
0.0162032247,
-0.0558642708,
0.062424358,
-0.0005349377,
-0.0073548267,
0.0197774507,
0.0145231877,
-0.0084875459,
-0.0369342379,
-0.0562042147,
-0.0182727054,
0.0430647656,
-0.0352189466,
-0.0031497835,
0.0817295313,
-0.0060217101,
0.020053342,
0.03922005,
0.0300047696,
0.0039560413,
0.039387919,
0.0315761343,
0.0037134807,
0.0384802483,
-0.0447563194,
0.0742282197,
0.0075355419,
0.0339211561,
-0.0854050666,
0.1145496517,
0.0109352749,
0.0239123572,
-0.0569450296,
0.0439527258,
-0.0188279003,
0.0045599262,
0.0165914148,
0.0126254745,
-0.001265837,
-0.0039187483,
0.0090326248,
-0.0799785927,
-0.0055965208,
0.0287871901,
0.0020809169,
-0.0316228122,
0.0295782015,
-0.0175556876,
-0.0230857041,
0.0079652583,
-0.0170744285,
-0.0490707308,
0.050238505,
0.0700737387,
0.0166173633,
-0.0078989388,
-0.0100681651,
0.0464268886,
0.009218934,
0.0635000542,
0.0109440004,
0.0896642134,
-0.0117854979,
-0.0236860868,
-0.0610172115,
-0.0607480668,
-0.0238210652,
0.0003239138,
-0.0084990878,
-0.0467920341,
0.0006546337,
-0.0257388204,
0.0046354635,
-0.098827064,
0.0135137578,
-0.0063764267,
-0.0219448507,
0.0344039649,
0.02928368,
0.0813033655,
-0.0488722287,
0.0080506019,
0.0036269396,
0.0348222628,
-0.022685295,
-0.0328541473,
-0.059838783,
-0.0391421393,
0.0389176048,
-0.0278840736,
-0.007130885,
-0.0314744972,
0.0585092902,
0.0180704519,
-0.0188028626,
-0.0086243572,
0.043212533,
-0.0323313996,
-0.0430500321,
0.0288622342,
-0.0882223547,
-0.0648997724,
0.0394880362,
-0.0595821701,
-0.0293485951,
0.0198521037,
0.0150964046,
-0.0083568888,
-0.0517390147,
0.0172040276,
0.0041484958,
0.0529557131,
-0.0004348764,
-0.0061616427,
0.0882146582,
-0.010469554,
-0.0863949805,
-0.0244211517,
0.0540121086,
-0.0102453614,
0.0375070758,
-0.0463877469,
-0.0052370289,
0.0181433447,
0.0095321592,
0.0277927332,
0.0180241689,
0.0073104873,
-0.0088504441,
0.0438329317,
0.0037235955,
0.0456486903,
0.0045000021,
-0.0174649265,
-0.0092616491,
0.0313400961,
0.0398867801,
0.0121179903,
0.0050664162,
0.0273944419,
0.0856001452,
0.0116341552,
0.004196479,
0.0039668861,
0.0126698045,
0.0059012971,
0.0047345147,
0.0245640259,
0.0497854277,
0.0501591004,
-0.0366662033,
-0.0204179566,
-0.0038881986,
0.0012641777,
0.0230232906,
0.019348029,
-0.0202477593,
0.0149704115,
0.0522919707,
0.0876406357,
-0.0199510623,
0.0462978147,
0.0145392232,
-0.0265995283,
-0.0152090937,
0.0330907181,
0.0045453627,
-0.0383645669,
0.001381013,
-0.0174297057,
-0.0085712597,
-0.0876276121,
-0.0330289677,
-0.0041212039,
-0.0366327316,
0.0153167667,
0.0266442113,
0.0178151391,
0.028941527,
-0.0202492606,
0.0750147924,
-0.0028330577,
-0.0004656236,
0.0236194339,
-0.0390284583,
0.0329807959,
-0.0131071303,
-0.0400312282,
-0.0237882864,
-0.0012069521,
0.0250113923,
-0.0293596387,
-0.0937720388,
0.070514977,
-0.0219396818,
-0.0406299978,
-0.0109837493,
-0.0398675464,
0.1032100171,
0.0005363792,
-0.0564315617,
-0.0149989966,
0.001717241,
-0.0446860045,
-0.0096351039,
0.0457132831,
0.0259485524,
-0.0858545825,
-0.0237241816,
0.0309068002,
-0.0729525611,
0.0300385877,
0.0261030309,
-0.0446464792,
0.0147313215,
0.047313638,
0.0024152757,
0.0182379466,
-0.0164650138,
-0.0043224217,
-0.0042950283,
-0.0882188827,
-0.1080022529,
-0.019087702,
-0.0176900886,
-0.0225469004,
0.0661169142,
-0.0312190428,
-0.04037036,
-0.0402070396,
-0.0103858346,
-0.0243862569,
0.0344550759,
-0.00960634,
-0.0277586244,
-0.0024086081,
-0.0169959757,
-0.0326052755,
-0.0028124715,
0.0047496143,
0.0347134918,
-0.0606628656,
0.0241550319,
-0.0398861095,
0.0159234758,
-0.0119417338,
0.046156399,
-0.0377611369,
0.0029179694,
-0.0329461247,
0.0727879331,
0.066434145,
-0.0079905083,
-0.046415884,
0.027227629,
0.0187433325,
0.0106885433,
-0.0197531432,
0.0321721993,
0.0079237791,
0.01551174,
-0.0665543079,
0.0415919647,
0.0103707286,
-0.0373171717,
-0.0288677942,
0.0203306973,
-0.029079685,
-0.0734905973,
0.0528097413,
-0.0049080676,
0.0205801167,
-0.0248093493,
0.0166174229,
0.0526378937,
-0.0184065849,
-0.0400140136,
-0.016278943,
0.0219510384,
0.0283415038,
0.0393749513,
0.0397085622,
0.0419994444,
0.0124054076,
0.0404266156,
0.0209287088,
0.0854752287,
-0.1127844006,
-0.0006272092,
-0.0433251858,
-0.0172011331,
-0.0310471915,
-0.0132868178,
-0.0003388517,
-0.0058424752,
0.0317829214,
-0.0388039201,
0.0133674704,
-0.0508864969,
-0.0117885945,
-0.0194413364,
0.037899483,
-0.0155019872,
0.0042529316,
-0.050973136,
-0.0413944982,
-0.0722691789,
0.0081845941,
0.0268772505,
0.0313000567,
-0.0200329572,
0.0011237261,
0.0134662325,
-0.0130707864,
0.0505697541,
-0.0333229303,
-0.0384855308,
0.0112138968,
-0.0131895905,
-0.0297367983,
-0.0015391526,
-0.0177408289,
-0.0396000706,
-0.0544443466,
-0.0393475629,
0.0240101293,
0.0248769913,
0.0353662707,
0.0400578119,
0.0257185176,
0.0217359941,
-0.0003050138,
-0.0008047165,
-0.0045955735,
0.016257789,
0.0251855627,
0.0274518896,
0.0510664955,
-4.465558306e-33,
0.0490401536,
0.0418768562,
-0.0056307558,
0.0183875356,
-0.013633064,
0.0060392199,
-0.0383045487,
0.0368081927,
-0.0351535231,
0.0287178345,
0.0466424488,
-0.0272116736,
-0.0171634927,
-0.0503367521,
0.0556531176,
0.0093326224,
-0.0116495714,
-0.0097096646,
0.0411372371,
-0.0784872919,
0.0273268837,
-0.0159803741,
0.0712250322,
0.0093223536,
0.0480656698,
0.0361732021,
-0.0198336653,
-0.0519245379,
-0.0323379412,
0.0040512593,
-0.0253806263,
0.00578595,
0.0216709021,
-0.0368662253,
-0.007432384,
-0.0288376156,
0.0097445697,
-0.0530976728,
0.050661657,
-0.0458699651,
-0.0023940734,
-0.0006040625,
0.0252647623,
-0.0028232217,
-0.0604704507,
0.0498649925,
-0.0057087163,
0.0195230804,
-0.0357266851,
0.0458833165,
-0.0594239905,
-0.0029084203,
0.0173605569,
-0.0284443386,
-0.0160897262,
-0.0172561444,
0.004194736,
-0.0415381938,
-0.0077430801,
0.0906714574,
0.0007514478,
0.0109173264,
0.007238864,
-0.0176594779,
-0.0209415071,
-0.011424059,
0.1033868268,
-0.0486194231,
0.0835178196,
-0.0048603504,
0.0338433832,
0.0619707778,
0.0071553676,
0.0012674864,
0.0479124188,
-0.049749665,
0.0586500093,
-0.0291685555,
0.0280125812,
0.0025393995,
-0.0335534737,
0.0492622778,
0.0188670717,
-0.0255965814,
0.0105316611,
-0.0139466338,
-0.0162548125,
0.0284898262,
0.021879822,
-0.0250232443,
0.0322694816,
0.0436621644,
0.0521572195,
-0.0101486649,
-0.0512869954,
-0.0408142768,
-0.0099777645,
-0.0437112749,
0.0266256146,
-0.0092390561,
0.0071928995,
-0.0087139728,
-0.0040194257,
0.0106733637,
-0.0074205268,
0.0017323799,
-0.0350613482,
0.0033191827,
-0.0201086067,
-0.0064365133,
-0.0024872231,
-0.0899874419,
0.0237239078,
-0.0009591152,
0.0059978273,
-0.0104056718,
-0.0044972249,
-0.0599016026,
0.1106226593,
-0.0470418707,
-0.0601056479,
0.0250360798,
-0.0121716447,
0.0041642101,
0.0013935374,
-0.0094670365,
0.0326082148,
0.0667507946,
0.0314241759,
-0.0004116798,
0.0039146245,
0.0020431331,
2.488e-7,
0.0260227453,
0.0215256903,
0.0462757759,
-0.0557695329,
0.0576648526,
-0.0144097349,
-0.0207387339,
-0.0226079654,
-0.0167669263,
0.0523909926,
0.0054891058,
-0.0282241572,
0.01277362,
0.0316637345,
0.001499077,
0.003101964,
-0.056722004,
0.0337236188,
-0.0116002467,
-0.0071731335,
-0.0074326778,
0.0562411807,
-0.0186267681,
-0.0486439541,
-0.0535635129,
0.0041997964,
-0.0140398107,
-0.0132710449,
0.0429230891,
-0.0079792049,
-0.0076324381,
-0.0431635752,
0.0399056859,
-0.0187108815,
-0.0687645748,
0.0301046986,
0.0272714701,
-0.0560814999,
-0.0114472937,
-0.0027966099,
0.0729341954,
-0.0132716745,
-0.0377131626,
-0.0038115273,
0.012392167,
0.0614398718,
-0.0025863519,
-0.0144618899,
-0.0176520552,
0.0428975113,
0.0155642489,
0.0203453843,
0.0106660696,
0.0079004904,
0.0329988524,
0.0085394485,
-0.0686530545,
-0.0042778361,
0.0039153933,
0.0126485201,
-0.0282556787,
-0.0197060965,
0.012685135,
0.0246569533,
0.01427841,
0.0190740209,
-0.029446872,
1.687524422e-34,
-0.0094237449,
-0.0029337471,
0.0596334375,
-0.0135291368,
0.0165906176,
-0.0037609709,
0.0416605137,
0.0818411559,
0.0278248843,
0.0083554378,
-0.0352228694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14974v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14974v3 | Detecting Sexual Content at the Sentence Level in First Millennium Latin Texts | 2023-09-25T09:21:25 | 2024-03-26T08:46:07 | Thibault Clérice | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this study, we propose to evaluate the use of deep learning methods for
semantic classification at the sentence level to accelerate the process of
corpus building in the field of humanities and linguistics, a traditional and
time-consuming task. We introduce a novel corpus comprising around 2500
sentences spanning from 300 BCE to 900 CE including sexual semantics (medical,
erotica, etc.). We evaluate various sentence classification approaches and
different input embedding layers, and show that all consistently outperform
simple token-based searches. We explore the integration of idiolectal and
sociolectal metadata embeddings (centuries, author, type of writing), but find
that it leads to overfitting. Our results demonstrate the effectiveness of this
approach, achieving high precision and true positive rates (TPR) of
respectively 70.60% and 86.33% using HAN. We evaluate the impact of the dataset
size on the model performances (420 instead of 2013), and show that, while our
models perform worse, they still offer a high enough precision and TPR, even
without MLM, respectively 69% and 51%. Given the result, we provide an analysis
of the attention mechanism as a supporting added value for humanists in order
to produce more data. | [
0.0458997153,
0.0744846091,
-0.0160834957,
0.0241738539,
-0.0278834272,
0.0230890885,
0.0298290569,
0.0240178257,
0.0274339486,
-0.0656200573,
-0.0137146972,
-0.0958061665,
0.018673975,
-0.0018186579,
0.008612073,
0.0139245028,
0.0188510772,
0.0605978034,
0.0156255215,
0.0232925266,
-0.0053359475,
-0.01436105,
0.0613520741,
0.0319519341,
-0.0003641635,
-0.0167229511,
0.0253900122,
0.030047372,
0.0147315897,
0.0117155975,
0.0189242624,
0.0332128257,
0.0098502729,
0.085270144,
0.0000017695,
-0.056637384,
0.0001164594,
-0.0259253811,
0.0030468809,
0.0307142772,
0.0372035243,
0.0039594709,
-0.0051110168,
-0.0089540249,
-0.023015352,
0.0115747824,
0.0217080247,
0.0381355509,
-0.0011071153,
0.0715839714,
-0.0113856019,
-0.0275565311,
0.0279545039,
-0.0531072542,
0.0234413575,
-0.0024583519,
0.0472132117,
-0.0464968868,
0.0241627358,
0.0489630103,
-0.0301861167,
0.0435281694,
0.0163642261,
0.0107159112,
0.0331767574,
0.0063276491,
-0.0225937217,
-0.0145491483,
0.0089526605,
-0.0116544943,
-0.0244314149,
-0.0282541681,
0.0160678774,
0.019819269,
-0.0237901472,
-0.0511446744,
0.0074986457,
0.0328004472,
-0.0399429724,
-0.0016600392,
0.0612627044,
-0.0371382423,
0.0629837289,
0.0636131689,
0.0166832265,
0.0323555954,
0.013516644,
-0.0428290926,
0.0358078405,
-0.0222309828,
-0.0220542178,
-0.0335913189,
0.0603299364,
0.0021594176,
0.0272661299,
-0.0041878056,
-0.0093530202,
-0.0696493685,
0.0338447951,
-0.0859526694,
-0.0177035592,
0.0162307136,
-0.0173533745,
0.028586356,
0.0068357345,
0.0197433978,
-0.0309645422,
0.0188045911,
0.0131798033,
-0.0243720766,
0.0014719639,
-0.0015606795,
-0.0250259507,
-0.0265463088,
-0.006942411,
0.0306270774,
-0.0605404563,
-0.0113152983,
0.025770383,
-0.0315975659,
-0.0738242418,
0.0433949679,
-0.0106944768,
0.0049360185,
0.0042000078,
-0.001087397,
-0.0459834486,
0.0060793622,
-0.0305341035,
-0.0152726499,
0.010157723,
0.0181868598,
0.0148235522,
-0.0238627065,
0.0458943024,
-0.0003055075,
0.0075761983,
-0.0587166511,
0.0129124764,
-0.0283757597,
-0.0459098555,
-0.038227655,
0.0039108251,
-0.0368606113,
0.0096825389,
-0.0262796897,
-0.0292868279,
-0.0564123765,
0.016992785,
0.0390825756,
-0.0496332124,
0.0438149981,
0.0436708666,
-0.0245448519,
0.03229592,
0.0386979952,
0.0152006187,
0.0528560393,
0.0670527145,
0.0659995303,
0.0479013883,
0.0279335361,
-0.028426934,
-0.0065295696,
0.0190613754,
-0.0114542348,
-0.0132432841,
0.0136191407,
0.0198103022,
0.0786058754,
-0.0117069623,
0.018282285,
0.0248830356,
-0.0345084406,
0.0398926996,
0.0628357679,
0.0142258313,
0.0875772759,
0.0511011481,
-0.0057406062,
0.0027002841,
-0.0317427404,
-0.0810982287,
-0.0134640029,
0.0564715602,
-0.0227701236,
-0.0303476416,
-0.0016988207,
-0.0116297714,
-0.0358567312,
-0.0097528929,
-0.0080989283,
-0.0100974645,
-0.0387196317,
0.0602317117,
-0.025536038,
-0.0249871816,
0.0206595566,
0.0524896197,
-0.0490064248,
0.0363542363,
-0.0021973772,
0.057145413,
0.0711622909,
0.0266742874,
-0.0578930452,
0.0157095175,
-0.0289846472,
0.0347851366,
0.0388868488,
-0.0232730173,
0.0328290537,
0.0263562575,
-0.0742779747,
-0.0359667689,
-0.0262642689,
0.0175592098,
0.0080457777,
-0.0288556088,
0.0442228206,
0.035555888,
-0.0032889007,
-0.0239215754,
0.0604362376,
-0.0419629924,
-0.0333139338,
0.0070129349,
0.0352971368,
0.0053635072,
0.0186671428,
0.0098669361,
-0.0119975377,
0.0431070477,
-0.058470726,
-0.0150369108,
-0.0303191487,
-0.0179112777,
0.015689278,
0.0392311066,
-0.0646282062,
-0.0142186312,
0.0670204014,
-0.0117876586,
-0.0098370146,
0.0232820362,
-0.0637927651,
0.0524324439,
-0.0294693559,
0.0004058186,
-0.0235867333,
0.0494925715,
-0.0164056811,
0.041304253,
-0.0174170379,
0.0240585506,
-0.0086424025,
-0.0680188909,
0.0245881472,
0.026847532,
-0.0813830942,
-0.0483661033,
-0.0143807214,
0.0076749977,
0.021447055,
0.0349361114,
-0.0248990729,
-0.0452328175,
-0.1058094278,
0.0286287908,
-0.0478677601,
0.0107753361,
0.001393095,
0.0055779968,
0.0086692059,
0.0002318137,
-0.05484052,
0.0050538932,
-0.0579706207,
-0.0086933319,
0.0497799441,
-0.0231971797,
0.0048136776,
-0.0014390413,
0.0023736837,
-0.0370681286,
0.0367636532,
0.0487623252,
0.0101633472,
0.0269329641,
-0.0160500985,
-0.0446184985,
0.0061035384,
-0.0317182131,
-0.0464269668,
-0.025833644,
0.009710338,
-0.0299087744,
0.0792059898,
0.0099108405,
0.0239003655,
0.0486783572,
0.0572947897,
-0.0079190843,
0.0055197896,
0.0247551184,
0.0521507338,
-0.031356357,
-0.0054501616,
-0.0018461703,
0.0338639691,
-0.0254387353,
0.0007313847,
-0.0009538023,
0.0271682534,
0.0019605255,
-0.0050608865,
0.0165635813,
0.013685165,
-0.0283627789,
0.0164384544,
-0.0360632762,
-0.0171125289,
0.0399832577,
0.0443150401,
-0.03023329,
-0.0458274446,
-0.0026854018,
-0.0329171717,
0.0122465147,
-0.0084936069,
0.0399116576,
0.0071082804,
-0.0561763123,
-0.0562180653,
0.0457017645,
-0.0024570089,
-0.0398078337,
0.0648966506,
0.0167057514,
-0.0192049649,
-0.0263109393,
-0.0482957624,
-0.0563347153,
-0.0866606981,
-0.0380188227,
-0.0031510277,
0.0101813851,
0.0042493879,
-0.0417760573,
-0.0076433001,
-0.0500536039,
0.0251433719,
-0.0177816376,
-0.0163098909,
-0.0390145071,
0.0410268679,
0.0271727256,
0.020877542,
-0.005191681,
0.037730366,
-0.0190803129,
0.0509965122,
-0.0468159243,
0.0121342409,
-0.0229841396,
0.0052182539,
0.0359711461,
-0.0534421392,
-0.0401244275,
-0.0497671738,
-0.0116642267,
-0.0850426555,
-0.0113164643,
0.0861149356,
0.0280980933,
-0.08035025,
0.0092492197,
0.0001857557,
-0.0178342517,
0.0042908797,
-0.0012319855,
-0.1104059294,
-0.0202965476,
-0.0051404736,
-0.0096424343,
0.0110698529,
-0.0289317779,
0.0000694668,
-0.0522888973,
0.0045705042,
-0.0155741815,
-0.0449242219,
-0.0181552805,
-0.0491081588,
0.0033741533,
-0.0226017572,
-0.0024797057,
-0.0204895549,
0.000599247,
-0.019925246,
-0.01901621,
0.0123881092,
-0.0473021045,
0.0316651389,
-0.051219888,
0.0104118604,
0.042298913,
0.1054652259,
-0.0651043057,
-0.0237698909,
0.0176110156,
0.0515147112,
-0.0305081178,
-0.0122127226,
0.0655363351,
-0.0193108376,
-0.0058625741,
-0.0174860172,
0.0251577012,
-0.020045599,
-0.0084539186,
0.0311481375,
0.1068004742,
0.0075593586,
-0.0204790905,
-0.0421715453,
0.0184588488,
0.0068272119,
0.0840797052,
0.01303792,
-0.0660575256,
-0.0172770321,
-0.022635106,
0.0326535814,
-0.0050071655,
-0.0461732335,
-0.016248282,
0.0071251807,
-0.0504636467,
-0.0736856684,
-0.0564000979,
0.0004483389,
-0.004994154,
0.0446231216,
-0.0191101376,
-0.0123613589,
0.0110348156,
-0.1086584106,
0.0374909006,
0.0136847803,
0.0019641407,
-0.0373367146,
0.0091287224,
-0.0178879071,
-0.0173467305,
0.0061892136,
-0.0104384674,
-0.0563535728,
-0.0213782862,
0.0020626129,
0.0038266943,
0.0092180464,
0.0353675261,
-0.0620919541,
-0.0719854534,
0.0300093498,
0.0463669412,
-0.0325757787,
-0.0235763602,
0.0398114994,
-0.0205333568,
-0.0259417668,
0.0670946911,
-0.0034071186,
-0.0212579183,
0.0173163172,
-0.0308373701,
-0.0008788729,
-0.0369690284,
-0.0075170714,
0.0021425977,
0.028872421,
-0.0628741905,
-0.0162598006,
-0.0030713459,
-0.0281237289,
-0.0024750305,
-0.0006736838,
0.0003692369,
0.022764029,
0.0069994018,
-0.026410142,
-0.0343307331,
0.033864826,
0.0048111086,
-0.0263536461,
-0.0677469522,
0.0109984837,
0.0013524933,
0.0218034834,
-0.0139793083,
0.053625837,
-0.0206013285,
0.0061575826,
0.0056555644,
0.0457168035,
-0.0251098312,
-0.0029665686,
-0.0009199886,
0.0053915461,
-0.0183481723,
0.0266873837,
-0.0894482508,
-0.0036206646,
-0.0128867524,
-0.0394175835,
0.0415781587,
-0.0280953813,
0.0381762721,
-0.0009143114,
-0.0267106481,
-0.0237052981,
0.0476122461,
-0.025534505,
-0.0196608976,
-0.0124633247,
0.002345253,
-0.0304362215,
-0.0096300393,
0.0339011289,
-0.0284096766,
-0.0060726725,
0.091410853,
-0.0386763886,
-0.0362092406,
0.0063979598,
0.0343552828,
0.0178616941,
-0.031658113,
0.018091986,
-0.0508984551,
-0.0392643698,
0.0482390821,
-0.0575979538,
-0.0008331207,
-0.0088724643,
0.0188929178,
0.0285868049,
0.0046645598,
-0.010027824,
-0.0463059247,
0.044107873,
-0.0008204264,
-0.019249972,
-0.0664678812,
-5.328299161e-33,
0.0230326466,
0.0128121749,
-0.0157943331,
0.0220929589,
-0.037109267,
0.0060644792,
-0.032881707,
-0.0156194326,
0.0091005536,
0.0301822163,
0.0000815041,
0.0355697609,
0.0024657825,
0.006773273,
0.0174013022,
-0.0244230684,
0.020147359,
-0.008058575,
-0.0329801925,
0.0335866623,
0.0663905963,
0.061483074,
0.0562118627,
-0.0794841498,
0.0310532898,
0.008763602,
0.0175702851,
-0.011628272,
-0.0050558099,
0.0435307883,
-0.0216835439,
0.0549304374,
0.0222962461,
0.0030627581,
0.0337588415,
0.0860671848,
-0.0644171759,
-0.0432262719,
-0.0217266306,
0.0564687923,
0.0392079912,
-0.0494222082,
0.0350747854,
0.0145789795,
0.0408720151,
-0.0338270217,
0.0821800902,
-0.0282883849,
-0.047572203,
-0.0903468654,
-0.0323368236,
0.022641927,
-0.0063451794,
-0.0259966627,
0.0044962615,
0.0539940223,
-0.0003948541,
0.0410262235,
-0.0578132272,
-0.0174232982,
-0.0107913939,
0.0093106003,
-0.0467886589,
-0.0282967389,
0.0176678989,
0.0390336327,
0.0291299019,
0.0274277721,
-0.0234347507,
0.0245854948,
0.0557296351,
0.0321201906,
0.0229832102,
0.0312509611,
0.0510360487,
0.0074239527,
-0.0847009048,
-0.0434022881,
0.0404854119,
0.0114594623,
0.0085615888,
-0.021910686,
-0.0409444012,
-0.009078104,
-0.0122369034,
-0.0305928793,
-0.0069498229,
-0.0131997531,
-0.0139936339,
-0.0444186926,
-0.0005436438,
0.0148191899,
-0.0572134629,
-0.0778017566,
-0.0230803695,
0.0257075019,
-0.0009291121,
-0.0048530055,
0.0450683199,
0.0345633551,
-0.0318318941,
0.0118514486,
-0.0315794721,
-0.0040735574,
0.0376481749,
-0.0012831629,
0.0333786905,
0.0216896608,
-0.0323176719,
-0.0274049435,
-0.0269952007,
-0.0270102751,
0.029381806,
0.0658174381,
0.0103949793,
0.0062491633,
0.0314896293,
0.0505495593,
0.0725420937,
0.0740428194,
-0.0178447329,
-0.0179125443,
0.0386066735,
0.0292911343,
-0.0200185068,
-0.016253436,
-0.0283084344,
0.0369214453,
0.0397298113,
-0.0861223042,
0.0067314464,
-0.0481733531,
2.567e-7,
0.0380920172,
-0.0013463756,
0.0079985633,
-0.0046640304,
0.0083908876,
0.0578470044,
0.0244703647,
0.0590442866,
-0.024282502,
0.0217571463,
0.0011124855,
-0.0155820735,
0.0707106963,
0.0113338372,
-0.0803206041,
-0.0352961645,
-0.0449934527,
-0.0303541962,
-0.0132418089,
0.0262302216,
-0.0082489653,
0.1330291033,
0.0692884773,
-0.0542661659,
0.0155461626,
-0.0249267891,
0.0468584709,
-0.0098599168,
-0.0061876127,
0.0414270461,
0.0258129817,
0.0131371459,
0.0017637183,
0.0311462451,
-0.0214606766,
0.027975738,
-0.0102791917,
0.0510340966,
-0.0313662253,
0.0111522172,
0.0202581361,
-0.0586454757,
0.0021664614,
-0.037011385,
0.0664673969,
0.0023140532,
-0.0059285639,
-0.0133873345,
-0.0019598412,
0.0184030477,
0.0698068142,
-0.0122056101,
-0.0030670185,
0.0130517418,
0.0200126171,
-0.0411990099,
0.0278211609,
-0.0879153311,
0.0202899054,
0.0357726067,
-0.0328000337,
0.0020139006,
-0.0045612948,
0.0248103272,
0.0520301126,
-0.0466929078,
-0.0012586579,
2.064275068e-34,
0.0563574992,
-0.044733353,
-0.0169577803,
0.0197284017,
-0.0209149215,
0.0042687766,
0.052771017,
-0.0134294042,
0.0333063044,
0.0188562721,
-0.0163775589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14391v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14391v1 | An AI Chatbot for Explaining Deep Reinforcement Learning Decisions of Service-oriented Systems | 2023-09-25T09:05:36 | 2023-09-25T09:05:36 | Andreas Metzger, Jone Bartel, Jan Laufer | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Deep Reinforcement Learning (Deep RL) is increasingly used to cope with the
open-world assumption in service-oriented systems. Deep RL was successfully
applied to problems such as dynamic service composition, job scheduling, and
offloading, as well as service adaptation. While Deep RL offers many benefits,
understanding the decision-making of Deep RL is challenging because its learned
decision-making policy essentially appears as a black box. Yet, understanding
the decision-making of Deep RL is key to help service developers perform
debugging, support service providers to comply with relevant legal frameworks,
and facilitate service users to build trust. We introduce Chat4XAI to
facilitate the understanding of the decision-making of Deep RL by providing
natural-language explanations. Compared with visual explanations, the reported
benefits of natural-language explanations include better understandability for
non-technical users, increased user acceptance and trust, as well as more
efficient explanations. Chat4XAI leverages modern AI chatbot technology and
dedicated prompt engineering. Compared to earlier work on natural-language
explanations using classical software-based dialogue systems, using an AI
chatbot eliminates the need for eliciting and defining potential questions and
answers up-front. We prototypically realize Chat4XAI using OpenAI's ChatGPT API
and evaluate the fidelity and stability of its explanations using an adaptive
service exemplar. | [
0.0318513811,
0.0326706022,
-0.0228831973,
0.0119312126,
-0.0144852633,
0.0037124543,
0.025847571,
-0.0194427595,
0.0199142434,
0.0060844133,
0.02967689,
0.0099229626,
0.0004892084,
0.1066331789,
-0.0125134801,
-0.0550847128,
0.008551023,
-0.0256970897,
0.0449252725,
0.0282963254,
0.0098037692,
0.0116641289,
-0.0399370864,
0.0821557567,
-0.0228441656,
-0.0417077243,
-0.0574184582,
0.0036353052,
0.0178208388,
-0.0234439671,
-0.0015201444,
-0.0156748816,
0.0422322974,
0.0030464861,
0.0000022461,
-0.0574759506,
-0.0094173299,
0.0245041661,
-0.0778221861,
-0.0180335008,
-0.0129268663,
0.0071201408,
-0.0106049264,
0.0523499362,
-0.0006960267,
0.0206381772,
0.090385966,
0.0463227443,
0.0668021739,
0.0295122378,
-0.0080991341,
-0.0122356722,
-0.0191415492,
-0.0052467487,
-0.0091224248,
-0.0767866671,
-0.0041711172,
-0.0022923052,
0.0033347656,
-0.0388629176,
-0.0044532772,
-0.0198314954,
0.044900097,
-0.0384092443,
-0.0237052366,
0.0473048016,
0.0158248227,
-0.0382067189,
-0.0276057571,
0.0690143332,
0.0222991947,
0.0187962912,
0.0067444681,
-0.0021061073,
0.0191909298,
-0.0089165522,
-0.0271921605,
0.015123073,
0.0054515689,
-0.0118343811,
-0.0221156552,
0.0125979083,
0.0069418983,
0.0013470015,
-0.0240975767,
0.0491246767,
-0.0329796523,
-0.0017757474,
-0.026359912,
-0.0071942522,
0.0349577703,
-0.0639370978,
0.0066412357,
0.0833078846,
-0.1119912639,
0.0149035705,
0.0285717864,
0.013013402,
-0.0284023024,
0.0027131273,
0.0112717422,
0.046278622,
-0.0567494482,
0.027387524,
0.0246847048,
0.0744108111,
-0.0151069732,
0.0031593919,
-0.0134580545,
-0.0070215887,
-0.0383449905,
-0.0269498043,
-0.0424080864,
0.0241434593,
-0.0386855938,
-0.0555394106,
-0.020630708,
0.0697166249,
-0.0298529025,
0.0417104922,
-0.0181911048,
0.0439482927,
-0.0508165173,
0.0161986593,
-0.1166492179,
-0.00350093,
-0.0806731582,
-0.0112561872,
0.0500406697,
-0.0431797355,
-0.0131700505,
-0.0036008616,
-0.0117552588,
0.0188145414,
-0.0172812697,
0.1108810678,
0.0211075526,
0.0481139347,
0.0153469611,
-0.0511471182,
-0.0038302725,
-0.0548754521,
-0.0283691362,
-0.0270831585,
-0.0175704751,
-0.0148870703,
-0.0103489002,
0.0228524469,
0.0122955721,
-0.0030351589,
-0.0043281438,
0.0675179809,
-0.0448248759,
-0.0021278292,
0.0235490929,
0.0028487993,
-0.0213481653,
0.0235984139,
0.0061190268,
0.0046034567,
0.038616281,
-0.0075506377,
0.0512533225,
-0.0312919877,
-0.0267464928,
-0.0165490881,
0.0376328044,
0.0185723938,
-0.0614088625,
0.0747140869,
0.0262038745,
-0.0191706847,
-0.0180381294,
0.0145061575,
0.0141790984,
0.0523299947,
-0.0186013971,
0.0294670649,
0.0321624205,
0.0421902612,
-0.0086067999,
-0.0081053991,
-0.0275479723,
0.0768107623,
0.0291951802,
0.0053715692,
-0.0220993776,
0.0155240064,
-0.0338217802,
-0.0531635173,
0.0339726619,
-0.0208383743,
0.0262186844,
0.0427061617,
0.0410024449,
0.0143025368,
-0.040669404,
-0.0204550344,
0.0176193826,
0.0121281045,
-0.0467536151,
-0.095655337,
0.0588305406,
0.1089984179,
0.053390909,
-0.0507383458,
-0.0506371632,
-0.0024947484,
-0.0010035178,
0.0625320226,
0.0662409365,
0.0077683339,
-0.0006555317,
-0.0385106727,
-0.0486703254,
-0.0381362475,
0.0160513744,
0.033207871,
0.0022995481,
0.010144758,
-0.0223202519,
0.0390637144,
-0.0633941218,
0.0023875725,
0.045387987,
-0.0476816259,
0.033284124,
0.0070470045,
0.0443964638,
0.0236817505,
0.0085570142,
0.0139565524,
-0.0028641159,
0.0343436934,
-0.0263806712,
0.0417220853,
-0.0354466997,
0.0214146618,
0.01148591,
-0.0413784049,
-0.0011335139,
0.0463792384,
-0.0515228435,
-0.0246030148,
0.0249564201,
-0.0331283323,
-0.0104899518,
0.0034955922,
-0.0159357842,
-0.0065838504,
0.0163125508,
-0.0193873476,
0.0236101151,
0.0670299679,
-0.0543570742,
-0.0127696553,
0.0309270639,
0.0151970116,
-0.0540035516,
0.0422106534,
0.0009212153,
-0.0448427349,
-0.0131193195,
0.0056046196,
0.0251468737,
-0.0174918976,
0.0455105565,
-0.0503760204,
0.0050420137,
-0.0116058933,
-0.0291554928,
-0.0157259498,
0.0089624682,
0.0138130486,
-0.0526285656,
-0.0251682717,
0.0601934791,
0.0195342936,
0.0036893571,
0.0574699193,
0.0404598489,
-0.0509518608,
-0.0271499939,
0.0170722045,
-0.0089942729,
0.0175436232,
0.0488915741,
0.0467738993,
-0.0751213208,
-0.0357372463,
-0.0506933145,
0.0008661636,
-0.0088013615,
-0.0458827168,
0.0677286163,
0.0225348566,
-0.0176369082,
0.035041593,
0.0007240684,
0.0880477279,
0.026684003,
0.0080583282,
-0.0497721694,
0.0353169888,
-0.0193884447,
-0.0357142463,
-0.0407636091,
0.0128221801,
0.0192431379,
0.0506722368,
-0.0204497632,
0.0152854649,
-0.0739440396,
0.0052700872,
0.0123592634,
-0.0064407787,
-0.0284833796,
-0.003421217,
-0.0340477489,
0.0637810826,
0.0153840007,
-0.0585529357,
0.0956778824,
0.0303592589,
-0.0034108059,
-0.0731792375,
-0.0576739833,
-0.0364831612,
0.0534942634,
-0.0744779482,
0.0396398827,
0.0044110632,
-0.0233412441,
-0.0113395471,
-0.007599914,
0.0256518982,
-0.027189061,
-0.0103681227,
-0.0486041158,
-0.0359780341,
0.0368730165,
-0.0175184011,
-0.0291437078,
-0.0005069037,
-0.0754908919,
0.0005259632,
0.0202403106,
-0.0425694063,
-0.0043949494,
-0.0287274122,
0.0249425303,
0.0347054414,
-0.0086999265,
-0.0356794745,
-0.0236908533,
-0.0707670152,
0.032874465,
0.0551918,
0.0300121643,
0.007844287,
0.058523424,
-0.0220995899,
0.0401992723,
-0.0279794484,
-0.0373300649,
-0.0055278763,
-0.0306497309,
-0.0143248718,
0.0224561896,
0.0488594137,
0.0244695395,
-0.0529438965,
-0.0330276303,
0.0616224371,
0.015032961,
-0.0402926207,
0.0267736334,
-0.0232695602,
0.0141660841,
0.0136239408,
0.0588295646,
-0.0734131783,
-0.0275968108,
0.0211171526,
0.02753089,
-0.0048507964,
-0.0283684228,
-0.0272575784,
-0.0617659427,
0.0403182022,
-0.0557742603,
-0.0532567352,
-0.0240412354,
-0.0398356803,
-0.0185377412,
-0.0093453508,
0.0060816309,
0.0019689538,
0.0366912857,
-0.0212294664,
0.0128005939,
-0.0223641153,
-0.0135199511,
0.0413487032,
-0.0509142652,
0.0481564254,
0.0748444274,
0.0288400557,
0.0125573287,
0.0113107897,
0.0042768614,
0.0831301361,
0.0361964665,
0.0026801964,
0.0522041395,
0.0159417894,
-0.0367170833,
-0.0571125075,
0.0295422748,
-0.0320545696,
-0.0223585069,
0.031167604,
0.0445569567,
-0.0248742849,
-0.0093731117,
-0.0065729725,
0.0273467787,
0.0426584519,
0.0538692139,
0.0058192639,
-0.0456586331,
-0.0550819598,
-0.042860724,
-0.0121571701,
-0.0146701317,
-0.0120164715,
-0.0248841997,
0.0010810152,
-0.0079990737,
-0.0483250506,
-0.0197084025,
0.002626308,
0.0206573214,
0.0269369297,
-0.0516180657,
0.0211817678,
0.0677072108,
0.0350183323,
0.0162827969,
-0.0257540122,
0.0264321193,
-0.002606998,
-0.011403027,
-0.0144899152,
-0.05152395,
-0.0096881166,
-0.0338267274,
0.0265098531,
0.0085153105,
-0.0270523429,
0.0564633533,
0.0283386149,
-0.0052356194,
-0.0149505418,
-0.0315327607,
0.0085415803,
0.0507521518,
-0.0407261923,
-0.0647031516,
0.0359915905,
0.0330189019,
0.0082469005,
0.0037625402,
-0.1080048308,
-0.036950279,
-0.0568210743,
-0.0230084285,
-0.0297052152,
-0.0163268689,
0.0330682248,
0.0149820019,
-0.007300593,
-0.0078109177,
-0.0479005948,
-0.0006424697,
0.0197601411,
-0.0116323978,
0.0158791915,
-0.0494773053,
0.0219040047,
-0.0099451523,
-0.0452987887,
0.0673101395,
0.0028555524,
0.0061789025,
-0.0349531248,
0.0153329205,
-0.0141916843,
0.0551705174,
0.0093547637,
-0.0098449225,
0.0058296677,
0.000269127,
-0.0075624101,
-0.0097631272,
0.0417664237,
0.0192681458,
0.0640256107,
0.0214994047,
-0.0004422888,
0.0044039544,
0.0139331641,
-0.0454147644,
-0.1528431773,
0.0569693632,
0.0380870178,
-0.0099037429,
0.0139251044,
-0.0220966116,
-0.0439014509,
0.0347116403,
0.0215649512,
0.0338367335,
0.0111365635,
0.0150702205,
-0.0039250753,
0.0185193773,
-0.0309113506,
-0.039262671,
0.0676908642,
0.0167104956,
0.0132060517,
-0.0539503284,
-0.0103077088,
-0.020410629,
-0.0288920905,
0.0096029909,
0.064525716,
-0.0047300844,
-0.0384691097,
-0.0327531695,
-0.0174279585,
-0.0859699324,
0.0332712494,
-0.0096523184,
-0.0316169709,
0.0189312939,
0.040216133,
-0.002061323,
-0.0130959526,
-0.0107463272,
-0.0377833173,
-0.0626233295,
0.0287382472,
-0.0143405832,
-5.895984321e-33,
0.0095566893,
-0.0451039225,
0.0350181051,
0.0193878971,
0.0181158818,
0.0017217458,
-0.0442186035,
-0.0072856508,
-0.0028954188,
0.0473655872,
-0.0029364463,
0.0306375194,
0.0246063974,
0.0011942153,
-0.0107703432,
-0.0362767316,
0.0254944582,
0.0070592524,
-0.0153440936,
0.0544475392,
0.0223359168,
-0.0091678044,
0.0071401633,
-0.0971380547,
0.0391761847,
0.0348605327,
-0.0107563725,
0.0308188591,
-0.0526217073,
0.0324528031,
-0.0206969138,
0.0338142663,
-0.0090113273,
-0.042816963,
0.0100903297,
0.0351916142,
-0.0342664495,
-0.0326124914,
0.0077323373,
-0.0054346751,
-0.0837825537,
-0.0324632935,
0.0119484672,
0.0378651358,
0.0237585958,
-0.0027845104,
0.0365588591,
-0.0048831669,
0.0244907569,
0.0067004785,
-0.0298385434,
-0.0226769373,
-0.0546111241,
-0.0730234608,
0.0016276031,
0.0401817448,
-0.0088104969,
0.0030143021,
0.0064056329,
0.0114857759,
-0.0095457407,
-0.0636447221,
0.0410524048,
0.0210392848,
-0.0105626015,
0.0076513453,
0.0050082896,
-0.0161235631,
-0.0386855081,
-0.0225291848,
0.0038680828,
0.0729669929,
0.0397413634,
0.0245418679,
0.0433228649,
-0.0045436276,
-0.0423046872,
0.034008,
0.0523876548,
0.0350104235,
0.0311078932,
0.0004439653,
-0.0635196865,
0.0019335191,
-0.0163037796,
0.0089903148,
-0.0354511403,
-0.0279893242,
0.0265528336,
0.0151863229,
-0.0581413135,
-0.0110454476,
-0.008366189,
-0.0538748428,
0.0390308425,
0.0065935934,
0.0117561473,
-0.0245234352,
0.0068029971,
-0.0419800617,
-0.0381471962,
-0.0190839041,
0.000204978,
0.0089872917,
0.0477913655,
0.0359277278,
0.0188000277,
0.0145462407,
0.0080633573,
0.0422959998,
-0.0467388816,
0.028596025,
-0.002746236,
0.0001408147,
-0.0211460926,
-0.0050669308,
-0.0261103585,
0.0485477708,
-0.0086514624,
0.0107742827,
-0.0131005179,
-0.0166917443,
-0.033190798,
-0.0121749518,
-0.0357654877,
-0.0229637697,
-0.0628771931,
-0.0005873801,
-0.0020262587,
-0.047616113,
-0.0327220224,
0.0384911261,
2.865e-7,
-0.0425481237,
0.0258003734,
0.0330751613,
0.0382824242,
0.0341886505,
0.0689750463,
0.0134967566,
0.0036749947,
-0.0094557786,
0.0061813919,
0.0443229191,
0.0285259075,
0.0489271097,
0.0008610544,
-0.042567417,
-0.074069418,
-0.0749042854,
-0.002059347,
-0.0812062919,
0.0166938864,
0.0781992897,
0.0541629158,
0.0146884248,
-0.0101791974,
0.0685255677,
0.0023898033,
0.0031191262,
-0.0209280867,
0.0647000521,
0.0006029675,
0.0171977542,
0.0358517282,
0.0189475417,
-0.0209840033,
-0.0086787315,
-0.0177292302,
-0.0406350307,
0.0369070023,
-0.0025151817,
-0.0442174487,
-0.0057121911,
-0.005743436,
0.0192233697,
-0.0606783777,
0.0426391549,
-0.052693747,
-0.0311670043,
-0.0297581982,
0.0172925573,
-0.0506727472,
-0.0109575484,
-0.0160493795,
-0.0124012344,
-0.0134758716,
-0.0206982102,
-0.0226058699,
0.015935313,
-0.0580612943,
0.0339543708,
0.008986718,
-0.0093970988,
0.0302083716,
-0.0537743494,
-0.0197245181,
0.0685848668,
-0.0223401431,
0.0187245999,
2.245443084e-34,
-0.0062972526,
0.0155124068,
0.0041504051,
0.0535941571,
0.0452629253,
0.0501935817,
0.0322629884,
0.014211962,
0.0589527525,
0.0124984048,
-0.0155795906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13963v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13963v2 | Connecting Speech Encoder and Large Language Model for ASR | 2023-09-25T08:57:07 | 2023-09-26T11:09:25 | Wenyi Yu, Changli Tang, Guangzhi Sun, Xianzhao Chen, Tian Tan, Wei Li, Lu Lu, Zejun Ma, Chao Zhang | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | The impressive capability and versatility of large language models (LLMs)
have aroused increasing attention in automatic speech recognition (ASR), with
several pioneering studies attempting to build integrated ASR models by
connecting a speech encoder with an LLM. This paper presents a comparative
study of three commonly used structures as connectors, including fully
connected layers, multi-head cross-attention, and Q-Former. Speech encoders
from the Whisper model series as well as LLMs from the Vicuna model series with
different model sizes were studied. Experiments were performed on the commonly
used LibriSpeech, Common Voice, and GigaSpeech datasets, where the LLMs with
Q-Formers demonstrated consistent and considerable word error rate (WER)
reductions over LLMs with other connector structures. Q-Former-based LLMs can
generalise well to out-of-domain datasets, where 12% relative WER reductions
over the Whisper baseline ASR model were achieved on the Eval2000 test set
without using any in-domain training data from Switchboard. Moreover, a novel
segment-level Q-Former is proposed to enable LLMs to recognise speech segments
with a duration exceeding the limitation of the encoders, which results in 17%
relative WER reductions over other connector structures on 90-second-long
speech data. | [
-0.0364332348,
0.0324938409,
0.0265602991,
0.057441242,
0.0021333368,
-0.0153521504,
0.0280443802,
-0.0072060092,
-0.0152331181,
0.0006344193,
-0.065699555,
-0.0577557199,
0.044143416,
0.0079099825,
0.0435150824,
-0.0233974569,
-0.0040038717,
-0.0598495752,
-0.0333435722,
-0.0353438631,
0.0280541442,
-0.0303768869,
0.000216091,
0.0394832641,
0.0168630574,
0.0317687877,
-0.0154768284,
-0.0101160267,
0.0167574156,
-0.0239382554,
-0.0199851133,
0.0005256656,
0.0481422879,
0.0508213751,
0.0000021623,
-0.0146751739,
0.0150520168,
-0.0062248539,
-0.1010696664,
0.0078662671,
-0.0305886213,
-0.0064914576,
-0.01712697,
0.0435098261,
0.0429678559,
-0.0071203923,
0.0796758533,
0.0181539375,
0.0288459416,
0.0523259901,
0.002304811,
-0.0644625425,
0.0465313531,
-0.0175660904,
-0.0437220708,
-0.0574449189,
0.0274730157,
-0.014078754,
-0.0187405124,
-0.0321419314,
-0.0455443375,
0.0329843014,
0.032023631,
-0.0207095705,
0.0117862187,
0.0022374259,
-0.0095007671,
-0.0365611166,
-0.0215889458,
0.0532130264,
-0.0290061887,
-0.013862215,
-0.00404716,
0.0110583045,
-0.0496373996,
0.0026957388,
-0.0176798627,
0.0145411724,
-0.0018497059,
-0.0052948128,
0.0055422019,
0.0294110887,
0.0184662305,
-0.0393669382,
-0.0603131987,
0.007176525,
0.0141213546,
-0.0509816557,
0.0370170176,
-0.0257019605,
0.0112781804,
-0.0086935684,
0.045795165,
0.0025513866,
-0.0323888808,
0.0189059135,
-0.0339327268,
-0.0245398339,
-0.0246412773,
-0.0684801042,
0.0459935553,
0.0482269973,
-0.0287459921,
-0.0046074591,
-0.0420374386,
0.1046489179,
0.0005381891,
0.0053378106,
-0.0256842859,
-0.015252145,
0.0319091044,
-0.0000921762,
-0.0419123136,
-0.0049094502,
-0.0462051257,
-0.0449026711,
-0.049936451,
0.032902956,
0.0145235807,
-0.0128944786,
0.0250840057,
-0.0530562438,
-0.0323634855,
-0.0381068774,
0.0253282394,
0.0435359068,
0.0459226929,
0.0242733564,
-0.0165771041,
-0.0526436232,
-0.0329820067,
0.0284314025,
0.0168269947,
-0.0328567773,
-0.0241001025,
0.0621588118,
0.0014968448,
-0.0149193518,
-0.0384622701,
0.0390743278,
-0.0229217038,
-0.0337247178,
0.0114350142,
-0.0214935839,
0.0386416502,
-0.0046034623,
0.0133328801,
-0.023461435,
0.0089483643,
0.0064635263,
0.0350537449,
0.0497884862,
0.0058220634,
0.0219000392,
0.043801263,
-0.0198917743,
0.0343193486,
0.0774401873,
0.051227726,
-0.0197813082,
-0.0179872736,
-0.0812239274,
-0.014467149,
0.0688348934,
-0.0027882014,
0.0048545888,
-0.0678560883,
-0.0316400677,
0.0557348691,
0.0076128906,
0.0322028734,
0.064853318,
-0.0242325701,
-0.0267320573,
0.0406402349,
0.0408669338,
0.0676460713,
0.018290123,
0.0004185759,
0.0149006601,
0.0177027136,
-0.0214987434,
-0.0028586872,
0.0303319674,
-0.0155679891,
0.0131778168,
0.0410046875,
0.0469639115,
-0.0274900272,
-0.0012150051,
-0.0494425036,
-0.0227582492,
-0.0103727048,
0.0287455115,
0.0642881542,
-0.0091868918,
-0.0750519186,
0.012661132,
0.0046240627,
-0.0570142418,
0.0102232937,
-0.0508937798,
-0.0106700417,
0.0269744061,
0.0152691267,
0.0024577051,
-0.0208544675,
-0.0378613248,
-0.0548896641,
0.0546400696,
-0.0132204015,
0.0115164332,
0.0301084816,
-0.0823671296,
-0.0075260126,
0.0494869165,
-0.0343801118,
0.0319645144,
-0.0141359791,
0.0219322816,
0.0021155591,
0.0047146096,
0.0412224047,
-0.0004310203,
-0.0469144322,
0.0149845891,
-0.0148925595,
0.0321922787,
0.0711994693,
0.0386964828,
-0.0039946688,
-0.0191849824,
0.0471278913,
-0.0283034872,
-0.0101052597,
0.0035380623,
-0.0802806243,
-0.0286712479,
0.0272967815,
0.0177502614,
0.0406757407,
0.0210068971,
0.030162774,
-0.0797164962,
0.0145029537,
-0.0598744564,
0.0619021691,
-0.0660584271,
0.0691922382,
0.0146388952,
0.0248071495,
0.0185226426,
0.0028271368,
0.0160705242,
0.0089162355,
0.027018318,
0.0142090442,
-0.0434043445,
-0.0975831077,
-0.0397756733,
0.0574014746,
-0.0223450996,
0.0129363928,
0.0201440491,
-0.0280644614,
0.005833054,
-0.0189104676,
-0.0606856197,
-0.0378949158,
-0.0395250022,
0.0360897556,
-0.0403517447,
0.0212563071,
0.0002485595,
-0.0125370091,
-0.0132599231,
-0.0042644637,
0.0115038455,
-0.0036605827,
-0.0226732753,
0.0007038188,
-0.0592251271,
-0.0042679063,
-0.0242830887,
0.0469724089,
0.0568856262,
-0.0338902995,
-0.0628559962,
-0.0808969736,
-0.0022257357,
0.0493796878,
0.0187338535,
-0.0085229091,
-0.0583408661,
-0.0481998734,
0.0297881998,
0.0518893525,
0.0419414006,
0.0131340288,
0.0008127342,
0.0283839777,
-0.0050150724,
-0.0231137443,
0.0140767237,
0.0183101539,
0.0121515645,
-0.0454651974,
0.0421459116,
-0.0188503601,
0.0483922698,
-0.0020067361,
0.0620725155,
-0.0271642413,
0.015926199,
0.0079028104,
-0.0395152867,
0.0180930793,
-0.0684577748,
-0.0326515771,
0.012791601,
-0.0065502827,
-0.015614762,
-0.0029708531,
-0.0850269496,
-0.0440889671,
-0.015848577,
-0.0434230715,
0.0029747959,
-0.0080404999,
-0.0007500875,
0.0174280927,
-0.0193973724,
-0.0630776361,
0.0111714508,
0.0254591294,
-0.0644173101,
-0.0266417172,
0.0447143652,
-0.0138746947,
0.0127071496,
-0.0214624088,
-0.0185032822,
-0.0168714132,
0.0480059162,
-0.0326699317,
0.0301777981,
-0.0131650679,
-0.0007198057,
-0.0191125143,
0.1107388958,
0.0209394973,
0.0498523787,
-0.0069644521,
0.0520516671,
-0.0308401156,
0.0488590486,
0.0070350189,
0.0440209396,
-0.0050220545,
-0.0265463497,
0.0720819831,
-0.032127846,
0.0290725417,
0.0078526372,
-0.0027928271,
-0.0480521955,
0.0328138098,
-0.0117632598,
-0.0052318983,
0.011654471,
0.0599262267,
-0.0623089261,
-0.0005137032,
0.0802788585,
-0.0313907564,
-0.0401461683,
-0.0182390139,
-0.0018596561,
-0.0119002853,
0.0024227332,
-0.0122631676,
0.0016422702,
-0.01437217,
0.0644313842,
0.0113384034,
0.0193837676,
0.0451957472,
-0.0067197201,
-0.1015519872,
0.0351747647,
0.0237965975,
-0.0428468138,
-0.0438180491,
-0.0558570549,
-0.011543666,
-0.0458515324,
0.0736544877,
0.0430052616,
-0.0420226343,
-0.0762279779,
0.0366217084,
-0.0574826673,
-0.0296341218,
-0.0288775582,
-0.0179318413,
0.0724091977,
0.068103835,
-0.0033213149,
-0.0216883644,
-0.0475299582,
0.0331211016,
-0.0438494347,
-0.0093634054,
0.0235955808,
0.0239332449,
0.0183869861,
0.00619249,
0.0291707423,
0.0216927957,
0.0065380963,
0.0303476322,
0.023115769,
0.0279384442,
-0.0302568451,
0.0028137153,
0.0221230425,
0.0022990829,
-0.0662489235,
0.0525259413,
0.0106007932,
-0.0322356448,
-0.0436271839,
0.0093849013,
0.0179782584,
-0.0002657263,
0.0165227558,
0.0292935055,
-0.0398373902,
-0.048432596,
0.0026759112,
0.0032362039,
0.0125290025,
0.031819012,
0.0264835022,
0.0139368037,
0.0335942432,
0.0442755707,
-0.0137313511,
-0.0428202637,
-0.0328869522,
0.011629072,
-0.0892018974,
0.0449756645,
0.0276684798,
-0.0523550585,
-0.0127840191,
-0.0284701753,
-0.0513092279,
-0.0453523621,
0.0228594411,
-0.0321665108,
0.0154029401,
0.0446239784,
-0.0222292505,
-0.043892201,
0.0714623109,
-0.0219493099,
-0.0387060046,
0.0479245596,
0.0319571123,
-0.0035748901,
-0.0200341307,
0.035739895,
-0.0546419993,
0.0183218215,
-0.047688093,
0.0133613553,
-0.0192863178,
-0.0486194119,
-0.0085971821,
0.036636889,
0.0350066908,
0.0176301803,
0.0481035337,
-0.029085435,
0.0740068927,
-0.017396627,
0.0749538392,
-0.0378233045,
-0.0186956748,
0.002220158,
0.0167251416,
0.0293694809,
-0.0134030506,
-0.0254421402,
-0.0205676556,
-0.0320035294,
0.1196066737,
0.0115448162,
-0.0061497563,
0.0276312176,
0.0011623803,
-0.0185400397,
0.0146314222,
0.0549397357,
0.0206237864,
-0.0209167749,
0.0167681593,
-0.0056803394,
-0.0130036231,
0.0224704612,
0.0288463328,
-0.0043377015,
-0.0445000753,
-0.0274439547,
0.0414063297,
0.0222781543,
0.0298151337,
0.0329865888,
0.0232474394,
0.0153719438,
-0.0580605939,
0.0206348691,
-0.017545661,
-0.010663284,
0.0569445863,
-0.0019023386,
-0.0340789258,
0.0137202255,
0.0113306688,
0.0346514359,
0.0145026557,
-0.0229239222,
0.0122169992,
-0.0127789369,
-0.0531381443,
-0.0033818351,
-0.0222975425,
-0.0206756759,
-0.0098114135,
-0.0103335157,
-0.0566218086,
0.0405851565,
-0.0496711284,
0.044131659,
-0.0213458277,
-0.0125967246,
-0.0266039837,
-0.0244975314,
-0.0069767586,
0.0340059958,
-0.0537510067,
0.0056225751,
-0.0206381585,
0.0516836904,
-6.601852515e-33,
-0.0372019187,
0.0360332951,
0.0241649039,
-0.0338906236,
-0.0784381106,
0.0559236929,
-0.0113772079,
-0.0338896103,
0.0122514237,
-0.0494208485,
-0.0020354125,
-0.0247836877,
0.0285644066,
0.0153144002,
-0.0092360228,
0.004012831,
0.1155243888,
-0.0002261751,
0.0227585733,
-0.0079468694,
0.0102664419,
0.0262249745,
0.0209663175,
0.0184425246,
-0.0464875624,
0.0049739438,
0.0049252468,
-0.0136059485,
0.0322771445,
0.047306709,
-0.0072889114,
0.0181263071,
-0.0141924964,
-0.0302062724,
0.0073760208,
0.0655532852,
-0.0482636131,
0.0540385619,
-0.0195151456,
0.0461890139,
0.0204602387,
-0.0414538868,
0.0506403744,
0.0184124,
-0.0584051497,
-0.0302808452,
0.0004646198,
-0.0027918241,
-0.0330539756,
-0.0107143857,
0.0041192076,
0.0319703631,
0.0035925591,
-0.0105312858,
0.0857548937,
0.0451315232,
-0.025113266,
-0.001636313,
-0.0747625679,
0.0122884475,
0.0239658952,
0.0259461962,
0.0509709045,
0.0779482499,
0.0075881341,
0.002821109,
0.0585453324,
-0.0744762495,
0.0285741314,
-0.0030944028,
0.0128693804,
0.005882415,
0.0122583108,
-0.0186826326,
0.039968878,
-0.0316453986,
-0.0356846564,
-0.0631017983,
0.0035231649,
0.0414359942,
0.069536455,
0.0535210408,
-0.0253925528,
-0.0108791562,
-0.0526730865,
-0.0196771193,
-0.0187002085,
-0.0222968441,
0.0617565997,
0.0001744104,
0.0291006658,
-0.0232865438,
0.0623926669,
-0.0258126333,
0.0522000827,
-0.0000618905,
0.003069974,
0.0004467392,
0.0075016436,
0.0281478167,
-0.0426156707,
-0.0028911873,
0.0260228869,
0.0134240324,
-0.0211751256,
-0.0451403186,
0.0080065913,
0.0501984805,
-0.0609380864,
-0.013697804,
-0.0010059687,
-0.0092777228,
0.0186540391,
0.0304855779,
0.046633672,
-0.0209364481,
0.0143885436,
0.0758813918,
-0.0286866687,
-0.0090599814,
-0.0214481149,
-0.0323745236,
0.0266362131,
0.0433191657,
-0.0317055918,
0.0173140466,
0.0128475493,
-0.0109035885,
0.0262065791,
-0.0348057896,
-0.0037212409,
0.0140741998,
3.022e-7,
-0.0662473887,
0.0261877123,
0.0439851694,
-0.021747835,
0.0067495327,
-0.0157155059,
-0.0014990075,
0.0044225035,
-0.0019243025,
0.0617531613,
-0.0176534206,
0.0051671294,
0.0648314282,
-0.0002433425,
-0.1198948696,
-0.0222471878,
-0.0631027147,
0.0011982707,
-0.0251513049,
0.0174740329,
0.0005301478,
0.0645491257,
-0.0389299355,
-0.0282315649,
-0.0206213556,
-0.0134239411,
0.0229846835,
0.0000568009,
-0.0240054056,
0.0107049234,
-0.0306021888,
0.0036976123,
-0.007655886,
0.0199968349,
0.0052834759,
0.0619820729,
0.0091160601,
0.0365982465,
-0.0320906118,
-0.0436860621,
0.035346128,
0.0869657397,
-0.021755226,
-0.0141978012,
0.0362925902,
-0.0061130738,
-0.0222113002,
-0.0152118634,
-0.0601112917,
-0.0267361067,
0.0195526276,
0.0009576763,
0.0671928003,
-0.0069262055,
0.008974297,
-0.0226954501,
-0.0156912766,
-0.0176009331,
0.0173893478,
0.0468582213,
-0.0461485833,
-0.0273807235,
-0.0327630267,
-0.0266462546,
0.0161488838,
0.0057754708,
-0.0215978473,
2.494134756e-34,
0.0077531058,
-0.0419908762,
-0.0005608868,
0.0647760257,
0.0100317374,
-0.0800101236,
0.0234470293,
0.0346797332,
-0.033358492,
-0.0956828967,
-0.0409722142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13952v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13952v1 | VidChapters-7M: Video Chapters at Scale | 2023-09-25T08:38:11 | 2023-09-25T08:38:11 | Antoine Yang, Arsha Nagrani, Ivan Laptev, Josef Sivic, Cordelia Schmid | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Segmenting long videos into chapters enables users to quickly navigate to the
information of their interest. This important topic has been understudied due
to the lack of publicly released datasets. To address this issue, we present
VidChapters-7M, a dataset of 817K user-chaptered videos including 7M chapters
in total. VidChapters-7M is automatically created from videos online in a
scalable manner by scraping user-annotated chapters and hence without any
additional manual annotation. We introduce the following three tasks based on
this data. First, the video chapter generation task consists of temporally
segmenting the video and generating a chapter title for each segment. To
further dissect the problem, we also define two variants of this task: video
chapter generation given ground-truth boundaries, which requires generating a
chapter title given an annotated video segment, and video chapter grounding,
which requires temporally localizing a chapter given its annotated title. We
benchmark both simple baselines and state-of-the-art video-language models for
these three tasks. We also show that pretraining on VidChapters-7M transfers
well to dense video captioning tasks in both zero-shot and finetuning settings,
largely improving the state of the art on the YouCook2 and ViTT benchmarks.
Finally, our experiments reveal that downstream performance scales well with
the size of the pretraining dataset. Our dataset, code, and models are publicly
available at https://antoyang.github.io/vidchapters.html. | [
0.0342091955,
0.0396294035,
0.0009141867,
0.0066724927,
0.0188572817,
-0.002643225,
0.028734779,
0.0095486697,
-0.0321173221,
-0.0539076179,
-0.025466131,
-0.011323154,
-0.0255368669,
0.0399417803,
-0.0069121071,
-0.0978808254,
0.0312721841,
-0.0278850049,
0.0040901704,
0.0183518957,
0.0358667932,
-0.010741883,
0.0086205406,
0.0154854357,
-0.0428513475,
-0.0057465434,
-0.0027057626,
0.0044287173,
0.0472868234,
-0.0494739525,
0.0360576324,
0.0459054112,
0.0652053207,
0.0166931748,
0.0000017698,
0.0164803807,
-0.0042354115,
-0.028346695,
0.0203287154,
0.0664652437,
0.0448064357,
-0.0671665147,
0.0145690301,
-0.0171161387,
-0.0043461919,
0.007523763,
0.0210843384,
-0.009818688,
0.0466481484,
0.0326663367,
-0.0437148549,
-0.0664708018,
-0.0171214659,
-0.0296577066,
-0.0019401864,
0.0018232005,
-0.0162425693,
0.0734059215,
-0.0037112271,
-0.0020770559,
-0.0437536649,
0.0464757346,
0.0225919746,
-0.0161853321,
0.0181177612,
0.0476326495,
-0.0859514326,
-0.0138286725,
-0.0226611588,
0.0790145025,
-0.0141301397,
0.0083881915,
0.005563837,
0.0180819239,
-0.0026747023,
-0.0293612406,
-0.0602198094,
0.037509229,
0.0097914524,
-0.0094981715,
-0.0284039862,
0.0404585674,
0.0065597221,
-0.0288855825,
0.0318493582,
-0.0395155102,
0.0320711136,
0.0096311308,
-0.0411595739,
0.00620144,
-0.02591189,
-0.0710415244,
0.0425729081,
0.009980103,
0.0305508878,
0.0012580176,
-0.074478887,
-0.006496063,
-0.0276940446,
-0.0486159027,
0.0355223045,
0.0339656174,
-0.0561046712,
0.0539611354,
-0.0613152236,
0.0475286469,
0.0216434021,
0.0371775776,
-0.0311096665,
0.0142372893,
-0.0592666715,
0.0024017075,
-0.0559399761,
-0.0081338184,
-0.06696105,
-0.0227226019,
-0.0097584184,
-0.0105543816,
0.00763585,
0.0164001212,
-0.0366030633,
0.0250854474,
-0.029185148,
-0.0223678686,
0.0082107391,
0.0415083021,
-0.0713015795,
0.0066616386,
0.0154081015,
-0.0145291323,
-0.0205943547,
0.0012329024,
0.0075106663,
-0.0064961733,
0.028952023,
0.0468861237,
-0.0685549304,
-0.027219262,
-0.0231925808,
-0.0214191228,
-0.0422718264,
-0.0118750902,
-0.0240343474,
-0.0432075746,
0.056200698,
-0.0061004274,
-0.0005883656,
0.0153452316,
0.0190435089,
0.016779229,
0.0020188431,
0.0819768533,
-0.0035699918,
0.0293129999,
0.0199496411,
0.03236036,
-0.0437048487,
0.0455924943,
0.0119014215,
0.0618427582,
0.0434334986,
0.0569300018,
0.0352127738,
0.0429058,
-0.0267402362,
0.0307701901,
-0.0721577182,
0.0081234975,
0.0266992077,
0.0364179872,
0.0580570512,
0.0318229608,
-0.049460467,
-0.0131004034,
0.0779629946,
0.0378147662,
-0.0297416281,
-0.001490385,
0.0622984394,
0.0310754236,
0.0141104311,
-0.014173653,
-0.0252950024,
0.0572379827,
0.0238796361,
0.0054248353,
0.0198883284,
0.0071263262,
-0.053161934,
-0.0478333682,
-0.0028983019,
0.0025743491,
-0.0014101006,
-0.0263843834,
0.0380211212,
0.0177338663,
-0.0365464538,
0.0286054201,
0.0096847629,
-0.0304602254,
0.0613060631,
0.0147376722,
0.0073372633,
0.0653032362,
0.0278756116,
-0.0050768214,
-0.0779392943,
-0.0079809688,
0.0842296481,
0.0320780687,
0.0377681591,
-0.0514708348,
0.0300476998,
-0.0787263736,
-0.0241999924,
-0.0185366124,
-0.0065819565,
0.0431383923,
0.031836383,
0.0282630958,
0.0233557187,
-0.0444923304,
-0.0617663153,
0.0394559763,
0.0246060118,
-0.0046428847,
-0.0144666154,
-0.0114481514,
-0.0292539485,
-0.0013600145,
-0.0309364013,
-0.0309981983,
-0.0073639587,
-0.0287514571,
0.0147449896,
0.0367299505,
-0.0505907275,
-0.0622809753,
0.0266269073,
-0.0730375573,
0.0147764571,
0.0238056891,
-0.0047790967,
-0.0495934449,
0.0003068092,
0.0418638065,
-0.0313436836,
-0.0353405699,
0.0082416274,
0.0396656319,
0.0216874052,
-0.0120722707,
0.0432422273,
0.027213715,
-0.0096676461,
0.0470982715,
0.0109839235,
-0.0099123074,
-0.0170165505,
-0.0377621874,
-0.0303243417,
-0.0198374912,
-0.0287129749,
0.0375747047,
0.0006642966,
-0.0469218455,
-0.0157099012,
-0.1254716814,
0.0118807079,
-0.0192978755,
0.0056938073,
0.0117072389,
0.007561211,
-0.0266737249,
-0.0456115715,
-0.0176363867,
-0.0018508527,
0.0011967054,
0.0295444485,
-0.0037874379,
0.0338356383,
0.0223307926,
-0.0378478542,
-0.0101798065,
0.0242373422,
-0.0069498252,
0.0249340516,
-0.0349054895,
-0.0008523694,
-0.0397567675,
-0.0039420831,
0.0198493302,
-0.0475858748,
-0.0436371751,
-0.0067166691,
0.0036426533,
0.017799411,
0.0211006049,
0.0210542623,
0.040006794,
0.0095645962,
-0.0358241946,
-0.0129803959,
0.0454611368,
0.0026052468,
-0.057397563,
-0.0392003804,
-0.0018813345,
-0.002627183,
0.0294217523,
-0.0325050764,
0.0372405015,
-0.0803666413,
-0.0296432972,
-0.0309457351,
-0.0008692733,
-0.0195924751,
0.0226115491,
-0.0198947378,
0.0342785344,
-0.0350927711,
-0.0491174906,
0.0152819855,
-0.0397121273,
-0.0548800305,
-0.0035478042,
0.0101330401,
-0.0114385895,
0.0957729369,
0.0178822502,
0.035357967,
-0.0274296068,
-0.0424180254,
-0.057323236,
0.0336413682,
0.0251349192,
0.0135820918,
0.0341024436,
-0.0531408451,
-0.0019811986,
-0.0329550058,
-0.0056482684,
-0.0386144966,
-0.0447218642,
-0.038176015,
-0.0267779976,
-0.0222326517,
-0.0200978816,
-0.0177830402,
0.0310063418,
0.0022007667,
0.0842314288,
-0.0283263531,
0.0021528455,
-0.0034994842,
0.024142269,
0.0570941418,
-0.0010084587,
-0.0637840405,
-0.067661047,
0.0531433113,
0.0418934636,
0.0144231562,
-0.0178087167,
-0.0053917044,
0.0528509058,
0.0375534408,
-0.0411969684,
-0.0151284188,
0.0119013535,
0.0800117105,
-0.0606750697,
-0.0105813015,
0.1194298044,
0.030882936,
-0.0525430068,
-0.0196004771,
0.0070816674,
0.0076045031,
0.0560631938,
0.0115863578,
-0.1007833257,
-0.0486643501,
-0.0157801881,
0.0281248502,
0.0486914925,
0.0050907065,
-0.031090932,
-0.0749901012,
0.0671591237,
0.0359023362,
-0.0450528301,
0.0130053479,
0.0220136736,
-0.0025320468,
-0.0194549356,
-0.000563899,
0.0038171615,
-0.014800109,
0.0144990217,
0.0123040546,
-0.0111411707,
-0.0254365094,
0.0340082347,
-0.0587524548,
0.0533480607,
0.0628809631,
0.0180686247,
-0.0031989082,
0.0121490005,
0.0127439778,
0.0054265885,
-0.0066868565,
0.0271671768,
0.0681897253,
-0.0496284477,
-0.0305233337,
0.0225534979,
0.0299932547,
0.0278716888,
-0.0267170481,
0.0425661616,
0.0195584223,
0.0200615209,
0.0172862727,
-0.0211370047,
0.0248781163,
-0.014968927,
0.0657096282,
0.0059458679,
-0.0074159512,
-0.0179889519,
0.0275813323,
-0.0123236142,
-0.055546429,
-0.0026204421,
-0.0070282891,
-0.0132064,
-0.0056249527,
-0.0661296099,
-0.049678877,
0.0912877321,
0.0334717594,
0.0235241596,
-0.0031749224,
-0.0011668701,
0.0275622588,
-0.0890426412,
0.0403896756,
-0.0334071629,
-0.0256510563,
-0.0833148733,
-0.0374532714,
0.0584421717,
-0.046117194,
0.004351554,
0.0291007701,
-0.0280523766,
-0.026537694,
-0.0255879778,
0.0625484064,
0.0146896401,
0.1003153324,
-0.0087184636,
-0.0066874158,
0.0327142216,
0.0066991155,
-0.0098382346,
-0.0062404964,
0.0036406135,
0.0082230084,
-0.024619827,
0.0387170501,
-0.0570115745,
0.0080849146,
-0.0340767838,
0.0423592664,
-0.0152902305,
-0.0090719089,
-0.010821742,
-0.0363675095,
0.0431841984,
-0.0411619656,
-0.001522027,
-0.0414325222,
-0.0270540323,
-0.0228194539,
-0.0040479801,
-0.0576604605,
0.0380564667,
0.0600186326,
0.0215247143,
-0.0233914182,
0.0443482213,
0.0077547934,
0.0044220998,
-0.0473583341,
-0.0373093784,
-0.0054075466,
-0.0129272575,
0.0187975392,
0.0218001772,
0.0211980902,
0.0224502962,
0.0121615324,
0.0383170061,
-0.0325344317,
0.0411142893,
0.0243970621,
0.0101771485,
-0.0001238806,
0.0598306544,
-0.0337596387,
0.0065507716,
-0.0541512184,
0.0172006711,
0.0279159099,
-0.0415467322,
0.0330153145,
-0.0002814417,
-0.0291786566,
-0.0260341372,
0.0337500162,
-0.0137998704,
-0.0767070726,
0.0116748121,
-0.0025519906,
-0.0158963967,
0.0441792086,
0.101594992,
-0.0143678403,
0.0388115793,
0.0483050458,
-0.0203032847,
-0.0202658121,
0.0240925066,
0.0030345942,
0.0143082151,
-0.0109564038,
0.0164593607,
-0.0076261018,
-0.0193598997,
0.0332049839,
-0.0293781776,
-0.0086040078,
0.0376901105,
0.0484359227,
0.0175374802,
-0.0053444649,
-0.0001693844,
-0.025036402,
-0.0233575478,
-0.0153295323,
-0.0177941062,
0.0052670725,
-5.272950274e-33,
-0.0565070249,
0.001262667,
0.009038629,
-0.0156410877,
-0.048628252,
0.0144835198,
-0.0193185918,
0.0462239087,
0.0351593085,
0.0319134109,
0.0232966859,
-0.0031263737,
0.0346893072,
0.0491945706,
0.0223828778,
-0.0488226302,
0.0611540489,
-0.0332552083,
-0.0246398784,
0.0132028945,
-0.0058270819,
0.0310056955,
0.0459263138,
-0.0094315382,
-0.0413789153,
-0.0145071577,
-0.0099514481,
-0.0027821129,
0.0544468164,
0.0306294616,
-0.0024431543,
-0.0190587584,
-0.0136952633,
-0.027797427,
-0.0314191394,
-0.0149682853,
-0.0836833864,
0.0079590967,
-0.0092593478,
0.0606927238,
-0.0387134291,
-0.0036161428,
0.0259902254,
-0.0101575498,
0.0131049361,
-0.0321655087,
0.0385724455,
-0.0353600867,
0.0191544816,
-0.049994085,
-0.0564788207,
0.0026984864,
-0.0173715241,
-0.0891732275,
0.0608128123,
0.0088653881,
0.0395484157,
-0.0640947223,
-0.028401928,
-0.0066315103,
-0.00312813,
0.0491842143,
0.0923090354,
0.0432968885,
-0.0179597456,
0.0673062727,
0.0205969047,
-0.047752209,
-0.0236972291,
0.0419220142,
0.0153081669,
0.0336684696,
0.0062273527,
-0.0091384817,
0.0065190471,
-0.0005060012,
-0.0097375689,
0.0481660292,
-0.0386590585,
-0.0230240263,
0.0015571736,
0.0244304053,
-0.0081393551,
0.0143076209,
-0.0218578968,
-0.0443727933,
-0.0084231785,
-0.0326398909,
0.0475335456,
0.0362699851,
-0.0033224353,
0.0044049704,
0.0759734213,
-0.0053347419,
0.0712773055,
0.0159234274,
-0.0413385332,
0.0712131783,
0.013558073,
0.0300298687,
-0.0377994701,
0.001847551,
0.0398306102,
-0.0054310951,
-0.0056248275,
0.0076879044,
0.0092188781,
0.050852254,
-0.0156460814,
0.0058446797,
-0.0169976521,
0.0237309318,
-0.0123764863,
0.081647411,
0.0280518699,
0.0183396786,
-0.0625661761,
0.0539196581,
-0.0298781563,
0.0181238148,
-0.0061308541,
-0.0180065278,
0.0084265387,
0.0036338256,
-0.0424927138,
0.0397823378,
-0.0581380613,
-0.0132064587,
-0.0305578168,
-0.045845408,
-0.0260510836,
0.0303215981,
2.402e-7,
-0.0124208955,
0.0332928859,
0.0266456101,
-0.0119880419,
-0.0101056993,
0.0157180075,
0.0101341894,
0.0281360634,
-0.0019238651,
-0.0555084944,
0.0420612991,
0.048335854,
0.0409737006,
0.0085780108,
-0.0672872737,
-0.0301459413,
-0.0500138961,
-0.0085018799,
-0.0298718903,
-0.0449801572,
0.0250414386,
0.0692100972,
0.0080994433,
-0.0031402695,
0.0527706072,
-0.0615476072,
0.0648911595,
0.025938224,
-0.0390852615,
0.0339109115,
0.0223264936,
0.0637294725,
-0.0696336105,
-0.0166967269,
-0.0257420074,
-0.0151247745,
0.0689693242,
0.0548287667,
-0.0134711154,
-0.0271322932,
-0.0300780591,
0.0513248071,
-0.0223978795,
-0.0037015751,
0.06870123,
-0.0179281868,
0.0190231875,
0.016020922,
-0.041085735,
0.0182071961,
-0.0505177714,
-0.02036798,
-0.0155834882,
0.0552682541,
0.0337062366,
-0.0018192513,
-0.0609821528,
-0.1079460159,
-0.0029870227,
-0.0084083844,
-0.0159459244,
0.0152773559,
-0.0636566207,
0.0138106914,
-0.0112575348,
-0.0349790901,
-0.0349826179,
1.858470918e-34,
0.0140347565,
-0.0156182488,
-0.0165256709,
-0.0474831089,
0.0150375906,
0.0220017582,
-0.0324273296,
-0.0212680697,
-0.014998815,
-0.0330300629,
-0.0420061648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13885v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13885v1 | TouchUp-G: Improving Feature Representation through Graph-Centric Finetuning | 2023-09-25T05:44:40 | 2023-09-25T05:44:40 | Jing Zhu, Xiang Song, Vassilis N. Ioannidis, Danai Koutra, Christos Faloutsos | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.SI | How can we enhance the node features acquired from Pretrained Models (PMs) to
better suit downstream graph learning tasks? Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have
become the state-of-the-art approach for many high-impact, real-world graph
applications. For feature-rich graphs, a prevalent practice involves utilizing
a PM directly to generate features, without incorporating any domain adaptation
techniques. Nevertheless, this practice is suboptimal because the node features
extracted from PM are graph-agnostic and prevent GNNs from fully utilizing the
potential correlations between the graph structure and node features, leading
to a decline in GNNs performance. In this work, we seek to improve the node
features obtained from a PM for downstream graph tasks and introduce TOUCHUP-G,
which has several advantages. It is (a) General: applicable to any downstream
graph task, including link prediction which is often employed in recommender
systems; (b) Multi-modal: able to improve raw features of any modality (e.g.
images, texts, audio); (c) Principled: it is closely related to a novel metric,
feature homophily, which we propose to quantify the potential correlations
between the graph structure and node features and we show that TOUCHUP-G can
effectively shrink the discrepancy between the graph structure and node
features; (d) Effective: achieving state-of-the-art results on four real-world
datasets spanning different tasks and modalities. | [
-0.0013096979,
-0.0096362354,
-0.008837617,
0.0069721527,
-0.0038291195,
-0.032078214,
0.0082804123,
-0.0201442707,
0.0510234572,
-0.0298079252,
-0.0709664077,
0.0231865868,
0.0035893121,
0.080430299,
0.0072159912,
-0.0207495391,
0.0115635954,
0.0244339015,
-0.0039843563,
-0.0269730147,
0.0067724953,
0.0709543154,
0.0445951112,
0.0133920172,
0.0011267831,
0.012580812,
-0.0114731668,
0.0412512347,
-0.0038585707,
-0.0253170971,
-0.0096968422,
0.0098331673,
-0.0002379679,
-0.0072439173,
0.0000022026,
-0.0111665428,
0.0093126744,
-0.006713408,
0.0229834225,
0.0015803346,
0.0402350686,
-0.00332068,
0.0414197706,
-0.0106783407,
-0.0320631973,
-0.0116053019,
0.0477140732,
0.0655396953,
-0.0236940794,
0.0389700346,
-0.0395260975,
-0.000608326,
0.0308224745,
-0.0313023105,
-0.0128919818,
-0.0185334589,
-0.0042168247,
-0.0152105754,
-0.0110842539,
-0.0149452854,
-0.058331538,
0.0072375047,
0.0109555321,
0.005230491,
0.0760197043,
0.0195310321,
0.0107054254,
0.030601602,
-0.0010135019,
0.1389846206,
-0.039719265,
-0.0164696574,
-0.0005576796,
-0.0533516034,
0.0323339961,
0.0271080714,
-0.0081856102,
-0.0919214711,
0.0069934297,
0.021887349,
-0.071364142,
-0.0138364127,
0.0964105576,
-0.0119623598,
0.0250001475,
0.0197860543,
-0.0087032877,
0.036148455,
0.05428176,
0.02276114,
-0.0188296121,
-0.0161085743,
0.0201411843,
0.0163561702,
-0.0076091532,
-0.0457870848,
-0.0218013953,
0.0301898718,
-0.002988182,
0.0202639308,
0.064859271,
-0.0238497332,
-0.0355101004,
0.0196686015,
-0.0024674821,
-0.0046210461,
-0.0385003053,
0.0333960168,
-0.0276663005,
0.0136470329,
-0.0410221815,
0.0064803902,
-0.0141453464,
0.029361045,
0.0049367188,
-0.0505022109,
-0.0485847555,
0.0200228617,
-0.0559126921,
-0.0109728035,
0.0167105347,
0.0805508047,
-0.0093229497,
-0.0104909707,
0.0039716144,
0.0365091972,
-0.0043597845,
0.0666995123,
0.0055533662,
0.0214850307,
0.0399172939,
0.0143380035,
0.05325884,
-0.022869261,
0.0237961318,
0.0672082976,
0.0442790054,
-0.0149696041,
0.0134952832,
-0.0515555255,
-0.0127083557,
-0.0525397919,
0.0406123735,
-0.054303661,
0.0420880318,
0.0091520427,
-0.0137878694,
-0.0390388817,
-0.0112984264,
-0.0696043149,
-0.0481620058,
0.048126433,
-0.0019659477,
-0.011695182,
-0.0062525156,
-0.0277216453,
-0.0241313055,
-0.0099971332,
0.0326169357,
0.072583586,
0.036128249,
0.0033936359,
-0.0377138965,
0.0276368577,
0.0339914635,
-0.0215840247,
0.049488496,
-0.0246457271,
-0.0617493168,
0.0027175725,
0.0467573628,
0.0048157368,
-0.0459707342,
-0.0292298961,
0.0504911318,
0.0014706027,
0.0367096178,
0.0181762576,
0.0435937643,
0.003084782,
-0.0340582095,
0.0162703656,
-0.0946697742,
0.048800949,
-0.0117380824,
0.0035711648,
-0.0124412868,
0.0294060446,
-0.0411512852,
-0.0153421685,
0.0683011487,
-0.0468484499,
0.0992417186,
0.0265231263,
0.0361478589,
0.0115183759,
-0.0022707495,
-0.0135426763,
0.042459473,
0.0192517918,
0.0180451088,
-0.0067286319,
-0.0278541725,
0.0549690947,
0.0032031888,
-0.0061308374,
-0.0179387294,
-0.0065489556,
0.0272334367,
-0.1001619026,
0.0297675077,
-0.0152397417,
0.048225984,
-0.026131276,
-0.0690046102,
-0.0509811006,
-0.0018098617,
0.0292505398,
-0.0392184295,
-0.0008741741,
0.054429058,
-0.0590793043,
-0.0162541121,
-0.0215243287,
0.0352128781,
0.0344472788,
0.0212005954,
0.0331465788,
-0.0167604126,
0.0127083566,
0.0272412822,
-0.001650017,
0.0173920617,
0.0111811524,
0.0024001771,
-0.02360259,
-0.0357214436,
0.0201808717,
0.0537744537,
-0.0457001589,
0.0084468657,
0.0268059224,
-0.0411925502,
-0.0168316849,
0.0717348978,
-0.0103117032,
0.0038533413,
0.0112815518,
-0.0085723866,
-0.0072331699,
0.0280018691,
0.0016602294,
0.0129450476,
0.0168181509,
-0.0138418842,
-0.0261406824,
0.0100286109,
0.0129504139,
-0.0413311236,
-0.007979528,
-0.0031231029,
0.0139518538,
-0.0094683068,
0.0245726388,
-0.0008116614,
-0.050517153,
0.0427363999,
-0.1032754332,
0.007286123,
0.0018532,
-0.0028970665,
-0.0054878993,
0.0213177036,
0.028841773,
-0.0673839822,
-0.0376873985,
0.0812445581,
0.0003900476,
0.0071745715,
0.0235199463,
-0.0062875715,
-0.0061172694,
-0.0363997109,
-0.0543275923,
-0.0096396748,
0.0478421673,
0.029425716,
0.0062592891,
0.0117968479,
-0.0030834889,
-0.0451870225,
-0.0052812705,
-0.01001513,
0.0088932393,
-0.043776799,
-0.0019096456,
0.0156726073,
0.0332609527,
-0.0440230109,
0.0396426246,
0.0375051685,
0.0095486781,
-0.0179799236,
-0.0362991653,
-0.066080682,
0.0321353823,
-0.0343825556,
0.0234728772,
-0.0387274586,
-0.0305615682,
-0.0098156119,
-0.0302079674,
-0.0431577452,
0.0167854112,
0.0315438211,
0.0086331069,
-0.0146487448,
-0.0147642903,
0.0312740058,
-0.015195786,
-0.0371853299,
-0.049155511,
0.0642846227,
0.0265000574,
0.0253641848,
0.0615804829,
-0.0330221541,
-0.0498566553,
0.0390626788,
0.0552986413,
0.0255238526,
0.020282967,
-0.0295890793,
-0.0846394226,
0.0317350328,
0.0383072607,
-0.0304195117,
0.0455796421,
0.0323664732,
-0.0123712504,
0.008022489,
-0.0470368266,
0.0226847418,
0.0023736493,
-0.0064289193,
0.0429617874,
0.009351409,
-0.0214635618,
0.0158334058,
-0.0330013186,
-0.0556484498,
0.001800604,
-0.0375285484,
-0.011684061,
-0.0008750813,
0.0621918477,
0.0410517082,
0.0051944419,
0.0106146159,
-0.0171886105,
-0.0297312848,
0.017925093,
-0.0257583465,
-0.0362900496,
-0.0692032352,
0.0212901775,
-0.0071784379,
0.0447454974,
-0.0467906632,
0.0043367017,
0.0601312704,
-0.0084486613,
0.0286309365,
0.0337420031,
-0.0149277896,
-0.0705470815,
0.0182750318,
0.0424220972,
0.0209274832,
0.0165238138,
0.0007882285,
-0.0424788035,
-0.0285177324,
-0.012273496,
0.0216897298,
0.054095488,
-0.0227020681,
0.0197835565,
-0.0444938019,
0.0132469935,
0.0382090397,
-0.0325679369,
-0.0558741726,
-0.0531981662,
0.0149937058,
-0.0217088033,
0.0069982954,
-0.0378781892,
-0.0181931481,
-0.0148922866,
0.0055911932,
0.0021090535,
-0.0356583558,
0.0262388717,
-0.0541062579,
0.0047664931,
0.0167138614,
0.0229095574,
0.0131647214,
0.0205456913,
0.0430907123,
0.0150201265,
0.0182863176,
0.0062085921,
0.06422887,
0.0077733244,
0.0197044704,
-0.0193290655,
0.0408155248,
-0.0297487304,
-0.0138686365,
-0.0528287888,
0.0662911013,
-0.0188241601,
-0.0537473038,
-0.0180712398,
-0.0055727521,
0.006822289,
-0.0349313319,
0.0358447582,
-0.0152093079,
-0.0203632955,
-0.0437777303,
0.0255632494,
0.0052434127,
-0.0218029488,
-0.0013347333,
-0.0457105488,
0.0217702501,
-0.014173599,
-0.042458728,
0.0069907214,
-0.0173910819,
0.0142706865,
-0.0069465591,
0.0056848861,
-0.0361783616,
-0.0766117573,
0.038658794,
-0.009019874,
0.0476313494,
-0.009337577,
0.0029742792,
0.0336935967,
-0.0472616442,
-0.0003119606,
-0.007218325,
-0.06010928,
-0.0668655261,
-0.0479131751,
0.0284301247,
0.0096867988,
0.0700757429,
-0.0432373397,
-0.0743284971,
0.0417194776,
0.0660097003,
-0.048579827,
-0.0047369529,
0.0165002979,
-0.0674775839,
-0.050564345,
0.0404742621,
-0.0837959498,
0.0255893059,
0.0324692465,
-0.0290043186,
0.0167348869,
-0.0922383815,
-0.0274206325,
0.0540130287,
0.0740596801,
0.0141469752,
0.0555266403,
-0.0596061908,
-0.0319896564,
0.0497309677,
-0.0037486646,
-0.0173002575,
-0.0393711925,
0.027525818,
0.0416911691,
-0.0259211659,
-0.0371122248,
0.0491061956,
0.0326262899,
-0.0682696849,
-0.0146071827,
-0.0157180838,
-0.0371736884,
0.0477808565,
0.0482693203,
0.0136243096,
0.0407062806,
0.0441416875,
0.0035415667,
-0.024641227,
-0.0219146684,
0.0332903042,
0.0042039161,
-0.1029122993,
0.0606899261,
-0.0352780409,
-0.0085714357,
-0.052007243,
-0.0258078184,
0.0551888682,
-0.0329456218,
0.0357329994,
0.0217202231,
-0.0183535367,
-0.0675092041,
0.0625560954,
-0.009963572,
-0.0090595074,
0.0322345831,
0.0143985664,
0.0060285265,
0.0633737296,
0.0254525915,
0.0119928615,
-0.0045931805,
0.017966032,
-0.0357616395,
-0.0001675089,
0.0017757236,
0.0020368213,
0.0622061603,
-0.0246051736,
0.0023231369,
-0.0263392571,
-0.0952628255,
0.0482836179,
-0.0422708057,
0.0300384462,
0.0130213751,
0.0466234647,
0.0088103116,
-0.0056051281,
0.0140196197,
-0.0417348519,
-0.0082792714,
-0.0122496169,
0.0121558281,
0.0309360046,
-6.433264585e-33,
0.0173795968,
-0.0429943837,
-0.0150592048,
0.0534182489,
-0.0569162443,
-0.0095716612,
-0.0293430872,
-0.0070226542,
-0.0085403556,
0.0572467297,
-0.0148386061,
-0.0091639608,
-0.0087041957,
0.013113765,
-0.0227195397,
-0.0402992368,
0.080431886,
0.021940859,
0.0030387943,
0.0438714698,
0.0168164056,
0.0408674665,
0.0274536591,
-0.1142223105,
-0.0357906818,
-0.0240658522,
-0.0085147787,
-0.01766821,
0.0457223319,
0.0438915119,
0.0194294732,
0.0988939479,
0.0211946461,
0.0360672735,
-0.009334093,
-0.0165094603,
-0.1103624851,
-0.0278018992,
-0.0198157374,
0.0020982753,
-0.0150821572,
-0.0359456129,
0.0367974192,
0.0112386532,
0.0176440179,
-0.0824576914,
0.0623561926,
0.0231255535,
-0.0495378561,
-0.0218742974,
-0.0154283345,
0.0279924888,
-0.0102590881,
-0.000158803,
0.0117058996,
0.0122888684,
0.0100833392,
0.0162799526,
-0.0872646719,
0.0158061441,
-0.0325941928,
-0.0125394575,
0.0135128899,
0.0042350339,
-0.0137441345,
0.0290228128,
0.0228781309,
-0.0150303897,
-0.0083112931,
0.0462662168,
0.0342035517,
0.0764051825,
-0.0250310134,
0.0156032313,
0.0141932266,
-0.0577761494,
-0.0796470121,
-0.0065282728,
-0.0013807755,
-0.0143454392,
-0.0340186805,
0.0202715751,
0.0215208381,
-0.0347183086,
-0.0161566027,
-0.0351049006,
-0.0379914045,
-0.0801259652,
-0.0289406404,
-0.0021991308,
-0.0114977965,
0.089886874,
-0.0162688643,
-0.0737447739,
-0.0086831553,
0.0709486455,
-0.0323097482,
0.016321566,
0.0209416971,
-0.0111996597,
-0.032581456,
-0.0283783711,
0.0258299969,
-0.0666714832,
0.0176101979,
0.0099415854,
0.0634326562,
0.0345389545,
-0.0031497744,
-0.0100804111,
-0.0071259653,
-0.0374413431,
-0.0050195269,
0.0029879885,
0.0167091936,
0.0336581469,
-0.0497563668,
0.0561267957,
0.0422243699,
0.0545752719,
-0.0019883071,
0.0114478441,
0.0277126506,
0.0133453673,
-0.0192952435,
-0.0473852046,
-0.027776856,
-0.012327834,
0.0541258119,
-0.0733516589,
-0.0562485345,
-0.0389239229,
2.98e-7,
0.0112285567,
0.0030762877,
0.025769297,
-0.0635073408,
0.0220897123,
0.0467244908,
-0.0084561696,
0.0495382547,
0.0195350405,
-0.0037148292,
0.0509206355,
0.029845139,
-0.0331970826,
-0.0024870746,
-0.0276002958,
0.0644530654,
-0.0238340236,
-0.0066976417,
-0.010137138,
0.0194514878,
-0.0450917259,
0.0466724262,
0.0434878245,
-0.0165736414,
0.0249939114,
-0.0091997543,
0.0469404496,
-0.0323488675,
0.0026441123,
-0.0110245971,
0.0039582374,
-0.0071267709,
-0.0639882162,
0.0281204972,
-0.0333034061,
0.0410310999,
0.045291476,
0.0135661187,
-0.0144950505,
-0.0141562214,
-0.0067295814,
0.0059743342,
0.0337158851,
-0.0050573433,
0.0729585961,
-0.0514120236,
-0.0581599101,
-0.0459645428,
-0.0459050089,
-0.0003111904,
0.0125126252,
-0.0195005666,
0.014097658,
0.019375531,
0.0153162405,
-0.032753557,
-0.0254922416,
-0.0732646808,
0.0260471832,
0.0371775106,
0.0109026143,
-0.0403586999,
-0.012560837,
0.0438668542,
0.0645441934,
-0.0181527995,
0.0222135559,
2.259291188e-34,
0.0159263015,
0.0038364117,
0.0208758973,
-0.0487345941,
-0.0222437419,
-0.028963469,
-0.0125996517,
-0.0017803649,
0.0451490358,
-0.0447031073,
-0.0003010513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13876v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13876v3 | Reproducing Whisper-Style Training Using an Open-Source Toolkit and Publicly Available Data | 2023-09-25T05:01:34 | 2023-10-24T18:28:22 | Yifan Peng, Jinchuan Tian, Brian Yan, Dan Berrebbi, Xuankai Chang, Xinjian Li, Jiatong Shi, Siddhant Arora, William Chen, Roshan Sharma, Wangyou Zhang, Yui Sudo, Muhammad Shakeel, Jee-weon Jung, Soumi Maiti, Shinji Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Pre-training speech models on large volumes of data has achieved remarkable
success. OpenAI Whisper is a multilingual multitask model trained on 680k hours
of supervised speech data. It generalizes well to various speech recognition
and translation benchmarks even in a zero-shot setup. However, the full
pipeline for developing such models (from data collection to training) is not
publicly accessible, which makes it difficult for researchers to further
improve its performance and address training-related issues such as efficiency,
robustness, fairness, and bias. This work presents an Open Whisper-style Speech
Model (OWSM), which reproduces Whisper-style training using an open-source
toolkit and publicly available data. OWSM even supports more translation
directions and can be more efficient to train. We will publicly release all
scripts used for data preparation, training, inference, and scoring as well as
pre-trained models and training logs to promote open science. | [
-0.0107531063,
0.1045005694,
0.0073009687,
0.034286987,
-0.0282036979,
-0.0165033732,
0.0618364662,
-0.0067503001,
-0.0035377417,
-0.0168311391,
-0.1024619788,
-0.0266869776,
0.0018225539,
0.015288339,
0.0356421173,
-0.0350159034,
0.041731663,
-0.0517816842,
0.0009407509,
-0.0184508953,
-0.0134406248,
0.000438301,
-0.0534166396,
0.0620563217,
0.0066839824,
-0.0239056814,
-0.0134643689,
0.0226332005,
0.0052895402,
0.0020871959,
0.0141692171,
0.0485587791,
0.009645381,
0.0735283196,
0.0000019868,
-0.0445046388,
0.001942019,
0.0145317232,
-0.0264096223,
0.0079783788,
0.0454983972,
0.0094342269,
-0.0144166052,
0.047210753,
-0.0413111448,
-0.0401441939,
0.0331234746,
-0.0058566723,
0.0480163991,
0.0744299367,
0.002135511,
-0.0122650927,
0.042065382,
-0.0230222754,
0.0036801251,
-0.0341876335,
-0.0014719234,
-0.0519530028,
-0.0636229813,
-0.0339898355,
-0.00113297,
0.0449344106,
0.0063704108,
0.0074169594,
0.0068497858,
0.0292388275,
-0.0344339609,
-0.0725297481,
-0.0299825817,
0.0677533448,
-0.0263421778,
-0.0302398894,
0.0186166205,
0.004745095,
-0.0316267274,
-0.0495277569,
-0.0555569716,
0.0363227315,
0.0593964532,
-0.0005111176,
-0.0115888417,
0.0423853584,
0.0283152014,
0.0108559551,
0.0118043823,
0.0106496625,
0.0000628712,
-0.0288007222,
0.0156441182,
-0.0255163461,
0.0218214951,
-0.0446128659,
0.0156643596,
0.0099418117,
-0.0011638609,
-0.0002518528,
-0.0383532643,
-0.0743809864,
0.0154797519,
-0.0500955209,
0.0557584092,
0.0606571101,
-0.0749930665,
0.0125240004,
-0.0047129197,
0.0169255994,
0.0022894486,
0.0221464876,
-0.0301858708,
-0.0265409295,
-0.0030356033,
0.0360305458,
-0.0345731564,
-0.0066828844,
-0.0586833805,
-0.0148900403,
-0.0388250947,
-0.0123305796,
-0.0284038708,
0.0078019458,
0.0661830008,
-0.0007220378,
-0.082968697,
-0.0186402556,
0.0136882076,
0.0259887744,
0.0265288278,
0.059424378,
0.0087961713,
-0.0741269886,
-0.0235696789,
0.0325254761,
-0.0081231883,
0.0062339134,
0.0084615657,
0.0861126184,
0.0245147906,
-0.0106583694,
-0.0419028141,
-0.0201366376,
-0.0014981432,
-0.0789388344,
-0.020036919,
-0.0491396338,
0.0474942923,
-0.0215562973,
0.0155464467,
-0.0369762033,
-0.0002008847,
-0.0062404633,
-0.0287939981,
0.0569409505,
-0.0013351266,
0.0137556503,
0.0311058331,
-0.000139166,
-0.0046048886,
0.0698385537,
0.0674127042,
-0.0063757631,
0.0417361856,
-0.0087574618,
-0.0251304321,
0.0761960372,
0.0510640405,
0.0355816744,
0.0502375402,
0.029021306,
0.0483050905,
0.0387522094,
0.034182597,
0.0344014205,
-0.0118601713,
-0.0418182798,
0.0760772228,
0.0556380861,
0.0339032449,
0.0065378752,
0.0414534621,
0.0271941368,
-0.0141645679,
-0.0458734855,
-0.0183248296,
0.0050264336,
-0.0283371769,
0.0090869982,
0.0434246883,
0.0395401642,
-0.0603028834,
-0.0238195565,
-0.0008421888,
-0.0768225193,
0.0016727148,
0.0211618338,
0.0481748134,
0.0204863772,
-0.073976852,
0.0454706848,
0.0795195773,
-0.0940296575,
0.0268345624,
-0.0364259072,
0.0275111366,
0.032406047,
0.0069092498,
-0.0259337779,
0.0085723884,
-0.0484852567,
0.0256830398,
0.0394777097,
0.0134053146,
0.0135130892,
0.0697659701,
-0.090123266,
-0.0060878913,
0.023399625,
0.0009932722,
0.0212487653,
0.0174342338,
0.0068308832,
0.0010099921,
-0.0324669182,
-0.056527365,
0.0059511163,
-0.0437991545,
-0.0095554935,
0.027737556,
0.0103029525,
0.0686463863,
0.0380848721,
-0.0252220929,
-0.0059843739,
0.0408515818,
-0.0311669428,
0.0135861784,
0.0407288484,
-0.0503251851,
0.0244888887,
0.0283962097,
0.0146685131,
0.036151357,
0.0558747128,
-0.0082742618,
-0.0583484955,
0.0538043641,
0.0485582724,
0.0685680881,
-0.0552233383,
0.0100758709,
0.0047702673,
-0.0038114034,
0.0139258644,
-0.0154078193,
0.0074600042,
-0.0219496097,
-0.0227776058,
-0.0062733404,
0.0312653296,
-0.0624184012,
-0.0322150551,
0.023483308,
-0.0275329798,
0.0352325253,
-0.0382212475,
0.0135472892,
-0.019176377,
-0.0243134368,
-0.1008486599,
0.0298406743,
-0.0239701308,
0.0188010726,
0.0137747824,
0.0411488861,
-0.0215589926,
-0.0011971849,
-0.0183770284,
0.0268734228,
-0.0076882099,
-0.0324639492,
-0.0452388972,
-0.0100348555,
0.0063094203,
-0.0411493853,
0.0040389658,
0.0104094064,
0.0099548604,
-0.0263942331,
0.0268151332,
-0.0310977902,
0.0597025268,
-0.0188619774,
0.032132376,
-0.0053798426,
-0.0551760383,
0.0001274556,
0.0023660336,
0.0443643034,
0.0496073775,
-0.0016131692,
-0.0209166184,
0.0036071769,
-0.0089821471,
-0.0602575094,
-0.0028007973,
-0.009011996,
-0.0200636424,
-0.0403761156,
0.0104150837,
-0.0090544159,
0.0420059077,
0.0188080259,
0.0044682967,
-0.0501773879,
-0.0282187127,
-0.0353221744,
-0.0319052525,
0.0082777645,
-0.0046588373,
-0.0171672124,
0.0031237747,
-0.0079120053,
-0.0347120836,
0.0242051501,
-0.0842329338,
-0.0349607728,
-0.0372256786,
-0.0460390225,
-0.0413245745,
0.0348462835,
-0.0617357194,
0.0206524916,
0.0256874058,
0.006756349,
-0.0188180245,
0.0000386312,
0.0080487905,
-0.0232276451,
-0.0053256066,
-0.0143623333,
-0.0068281596,
-0.0208268128,
-0.0380171984,
-0.0352762826,
-0.0088728154,
-0.0384630747,
0.0154281212,
-0.0049598943,
-0.0397825167,
-0.034711808,
0.0240829512,
0.0148760937,
0.0729493722,
-0.001695141,
0.0232191738,
-0.0051952861,
-0.0076070279,
-0.0028813365,
-0.0156944096,
-0.008947487,
-0.0327782147,
0.0261749495,
0.0395671241,
0.077699177,
0.0069231857,
-0.0492646731,
-0.0332198404,
0.0331335887,
-0.0065067164,
0.0082358643,
0.0217096191,
0.0740049854,
-0.0310271904,
0.0097896829,
0.1062673032,
-0.0114705842,
-0.0479242615,
-0.0032487949,
0.0169780124,
0.0315076709,
0.0106846625,
-0.011195085,
-0.0840459019,
-0.0185130537,
0.0334138386,
0.07488323,
0.0152537301,
0.0066136084,
-0.0003722057,
-0.1111511439,
0.0468309224,
0.0332926735,
-0.0840960294,
0.0122428378,
-0.0399167128,
-0.0421531312,
-0.0810340941,
0.0332124829,
-0.0015526784,
0.0309558585,
-0.0187525786,
0.024816582,
-0.0102385283,
-0.0323615894,
0.0372302495,
-0.0800872147,
0.0881950706,
0.0499259941,
0.0152193895,
0.0132063488,
-0.0371350087,
0.0111161312,
0.0238202382,
-0.0187197011,
-0.0193124153,
0.0248987358,
-0.0183160249,
-0.013571512,
-0.0174702983,
0.0707720295,
-0.0440279096,
0.0202914141,
0.0096961381,
0.0584517643,
-0.0065903109,
0.0074662142,
0.0184855182,
0.0195696615,
0.034262225,
0.0788733587,
-0.0106867533,
-0.0365797356,
0.0149990004,
-0.0017787218,
-0.010140623,
-0.042329032,
-0.0207452588,
0.0005621646,
0.0075377272,
-0.0487068258,
-0.0394795984,
-0.0116046499,
0.0143080829,
0.0321180113,
0.0308107939,
-0.0027655014,
0.0306322929,
-0.0199877154,
-0.0429990627,
0.0234360825,
-0.0175340921,
0.0399600826,
-0.0447723381,
-0.0546857677,
0.0501453727,
-0.0249204356,
-0.0156919044,
-0.008710051,
-0.1086854339,
-0.070895046,
-0.0215462726,
0.0758822635,
0.024368532,
0.053706836,
-0.0359605178,
-0.0244034994,
0.02095774,
-0.0019170025,
-0.0954241902,
0.0164183304,
0.091264911,
-0.0014798444,
0.0292656589,
0.0288838223,
-0.0395648107,
0.003774764,
0.0175875053,
0.0140588991,
-0.0131701902,
-0.0316725709,
-0.009263996,
0.0001130476,
0.0545573495,
0.0080230422,
-0.0114228334,
-0.0724055544,
0.054486353,
-0.0084394868,
0.0185807273,
-0.0440886766,
0.0057915961,
0.0404289775,
0.0027217988,
0.0079580769,
0.040893741,
-0.0319120288,
-0.0155154616,
-0.0507779717,
0.0434475951,
0.0243069436,
0.0154068954,
-0.0083571021,
0.0101272641,
-0.024141904,
0.0438477732,
-0.0282834489,
0.0225064065,
0.007306206,
-0.004171202,
-0.010562771,
0.0336899199,
0.0340760164,
0.0122845247,
-0.0503793098,
-0.0528317876,
-0.0123794312,
0.0540501922,
0.046231702,
0.0268493555,
0.071896106,
0.0031008779,
0.0173023567,
-0.0064078565,
0.0356396139,
-0.0370672084,
-0.0102763185,
-0.0032726109,
-0.0080001811,
-0.0026485184,
0.0391868204,
0.0632203668,
0.0054389187,
0.0529181696,
-0.0049616578,
0.0442429371,
-0.0126295108,
-0.0415505581,
0.0373589545,
0.0503519438,
-0.0496065877,
-0.0207718238,
0.003055525,
-0.046837721,
0.0085579492,
0.0277210176,
0.002033618,
-0.0216397531,
0.0391199067,
0.0321441926,
-0.0291363206,
-0.0135861896,
-0.023617886,
-0.0657137781,
-0.0079515334,
-0.0354315415,
0.027799841,
-6.345358179e-33,
-0.0059852186,
0.0365365073,
0.0314604566,
0.0333042629,
-0.0324818604,
-0.0142809069,
-0.0207059011,
-0.0099706091,
-0.024108028,
-0.0322620235,
0.0111969272,
0.015030765,
0.0360177644,
0.021693565,
0.0032080757,
0.0318560377,
0.0613846406,
-0.0282980446,
-0.0010920281,
0.0209877118,
0.0143302977,
0.0468199775,
0.0504841544,
-0.060339842,
0.0245546438,
-0.0345349424,
-0.016239034,
-0.0132488078,
0.0011816606,
0.0328798033,
-0.0240013301,
0.0251879338,
-0.0322678797,
0.0124834878,
-0.0258593317,
-0.0126298722,
-0.0520629548,
0.0538649671,
0.0214177445,
0.0410818979,
-0.0177468974,
0.0068183821,
0.0194739494,
0.0032424915,
-0.032032501,
-0.011183423,
0.0084683066,
-0.0279548541,
-0.0145544894,
0.0027401166,
-0.0256353598,
0.005209656,
-0.0203760378,
-0.0565960221,
0.0353895985,
0.0303562246,
-0.0248903576,
-0.0295748897,
-0.1020195931,
0.0296486933,
-0.0109041426,
-0.0043772794,
0.0435778759,
0.0129833855,
0.0045043775,
0.0166064408,
0.063856788,
-0.0335588194,
0.0278781801,
0.0215854663,
0.0584172159,
0.042901855,
0.0398738943,
0.0032752862,
-0.0145353554,
-0.0289986618,
-0.0701669008,
-0.0135510853,
0.0320716798,
-0.0020211225,
0.0346419662,
0.0430158414,
-0.0400929451,
0.0066569652,
-0.0600916818,
-0.0803248212,
-0.0282324888,
-0.0219125319,
0.0385351032,
0.0408869535,
-0.0023298752,
-0.0080240062,
0.0733281896,
-0.0302141644,
0.0475584641,
-0.0246379115,
0.0222279504,
-0.0109637557,
-0.0422472507,
0.027265206,
-0.0816132054,
-0.0469407327,
0.0447504371,
0.0364089943,
0.0077020829,
-0.0041833981,
0.0248104595,
0.039237652,
-0.0266595539,
0.01032867,
-0.0303568766,
0.0209442694,
0.0427086018,
0.0228746273,
0.0277850851,
0.0010346515,
0.0018239273,
0.0801644549,
-0.0177640077,
0.0002727017,
-0.0431118049,
-0.0263364818,
0.0144673893,
0.0105965678,
-0.0557204336,
0.0039572646,
-0.0198676344,
-0.0226838067,
0.0216088891,
-0.0305282287,
-0.0283642411,
-0.0012577779,
2.72e-7,
-0.024503326,
0.0099569177,
-0.0037194497,
0.0349504352,
0.0018491909,
0.0116217565,
-0.0390117355,
0.0451807156,
-0.0175729636,
0.0239953753,
-0.0259115826,
0.0347509645,
0.1039994359,
0.0106427446,
-0.0870873183,
-0.0801171064,
-0.0643881783,
0.0032663632,
-0.0652457774,
-0.0014957732,
-0.0247635841,
0.0924157277,
0.0077231647,
0.0070245522,
0.0306738839,
-0.0057251882,
0.0541036651,
-0.0247545969,
-0.0381610431,
-0.0047151619,
-0.0058598518,
0.0441210791,
-0.0173826385,
-0.0211857017,
-0.0428982005,
0.0152455922,
-0.0161399543,
0.0668940321,
-0.0040478809,
-0.047830496,
0.0150795542,
-0.006844569,
-0.0445033871,
-0.0291515924,
0.0382653885,
-0.0010481379,
-0.0251487624,
-0.0007503941,
0.0138563169,
0.0137973512,
0.0356755368,
-0.047624018,
0.0117002232,
0.0097979484,
0.0197604094,
-0.0282058977,
-0.0052147466,
-0.0272806827,
-0.0177833587,
-0.0407727957,
-0.0244803969,
-0.0396541432,
-0.024867598,
-0.0154025862,
-0.0124541586,
-0.0110726403,
0.014454606,
2.194886037e-34,
0.0511496253,
-0.0087026311,
0.0191341471,
0.020800259,
0.0074321493,
-0.0296249092,
0.0354425013,
-0.0169568639,
0.003203633,
-0.0589433275,
-0.0553263053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13869v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13869v1 | PRiSM: Enhancing Low-Resource Document-Level Relation Extraction with Relation-Aware Score Calibration | 2023-09-25T04:42:39 | 2023-09-25T04:42:39 | Minseok Choi, Hyesu Lim, Jaegul Choo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Document-level relation extraction (DocRE) aims to extract relations of all
entity pairs in a document. A key challenge in DocRE is the cost of annotating
such data which requires intensive human effort. Thus, we investigate the case
of DocRE in a low-resource setting, and we find that existing models trained on
low data overestimate the NA ("no relation") label, causing limited
performance. In this work, we approach the problem from a calibration
perspective and propose PRiSM, which learns to adapt logits based on relation
semantic information. We evaluate our method on three DocRE datasets and
demonstrate that integrating existing models with PRiSM improves performance by
as much as 26.38 F1 score, while the calibration error drops as much as 36
times when trained with about 3% of data. The code is publicly available at
https://github.com/brightjade/PRiSM. | [
0.0259660594,
0.0763592795,
0.0335544609,
0.0735299289,
-0.0135706039,
0.0311570633,
-0.0050052865,
0.0200341418,
0.0215007216,
-0.01663181,
-0.0355837308,
0.0046584639,
-0.0094410842,
0.0023458896,
-0.0146152023,
-0.0345352255,
0.0160363298,
0.0260789581,
0.0267061181,
0.0241768491,
0.0043844441,
0.0234736595,
-0.0146588506,
-0.028805228,
-0.0726576373,
-0.0353040844,
0.0228622276,
0.0229961257,
0.0567979738,
-0.0345361941,
0.0276846644,
0.0200641155,
-0.032551907,
-0.0140435528,
0.0000018531,
-0.0543181561,
-0.0484674238,
0.0490845181,
-0.0419110805,
-0.0369464532,
0.0095955832,
-0.0412147157,
0.0222315881,
0.0245276093,
-0.0530994684,
-0.0617616922,
0.005204102,
0.0676636845,
0.0059239445,
0.0744964108,
-0.0350263491,
-0.0412127934,
0.0479637384,
-0.0479650162,
0.0313188322,
-0.0483096018,
0.0055748071,
0.0266795475,
-0.0402856208,
-0.0170519277,
-0.003993867,
0.001502184,
0.01267468,
-0.025434427,
0.0401223823,
0.0349280052,
-0.052690275,
-0.0148704425,
0.0061809742,
0.1025099009,
0.0501906984,
0.0351910517,
0.0341072455,
0.0057051978,
-0.0069070505,
-0.007048571,
-0.0017830074,
-0.0383146107,
-0.0387415849,
0.0048911711,
0.0421029031,
0.0144957444,
0.0484129936,
-0.0013852763,
-0.0054263654,
0.0132470876,
-0.0185551215,
-0.0443163477,
0.0457919128,
0.0319619365,
0.0071851914,
-0.0288925413,
0.0038660716,
0.033085417,
0.0001306481,
0.0343717523,
-0.0440762602,
-0.0156959556,
-0.0105306841,
-0.0349791944,
-0.0256213285,
-0.0155008333,
0.0218051299,
0.0996539667,
-0.0488732271,
-0.0093199601,
0.0181213971,
-0.021759551,
0.0045410357,
-0.0269827954,
-0.0264564659,
0.0413466394,
-0.0233839452,
0.0444317274,
-0.0375222117,
0.0020582145,
-0.016722599,
-0.0270653069,
-0.0037504011,
0.0415749215,
-0.0115118017,
0.0028470119,
-0.0207281578,
-0.0124971559,
-0.0071195429,
0.0343559273,
-0.0149577204,
-0.0066588642,
-0.0122860931,
-0.0110183479,
-0.0035067245,
-0.0400386527,
0.0545193963,
-0.0372378156,
0.0348118283,
0.0541738756,
0.034772899,
-0.0587054007,
-0.0042310902,
-0.0296718851,
0.0487173833,
-0.075369291,
-0.004482137,
-0.0075457059,
0.0661253035,
0.0407090187,
-0.0109646339,
-0.0153316874,
0.0471049249,
-0.0392468981,
-0.0797491819,
0.069828786,
-0.0210226197,
-0.0202415865,
-0.0228000823,
0.0157987662,
0.0010462938,
0.0768480003,
0.0751787201,
-0.0023668173,
0.0577830672,
0.0255291313,
-0.0272249132,
0.034410391,
0.0138764996,
-0.0158627164,
0.0418716408,
0.0206889398,
0.0016637064,
-0.0173092186,
0.0639276803,
0.0256092418,
-0.0094094267,
-0.0350095555,
-0.0166559629,
-0.0104576275,
0.0433843061,
0.0359581187,
0.0138868298,
0.0004282592,
0.0274347197,
-0.0257788952,
-0.0571811497,
0.0137797119,
0.0062560476,
0.0168142058,
-0.0197870433,
0.0253782962,
0.0093382895,
-0.0083602192,
-0.0120688463,
-0.0309532452,
-0.0347943455,
0.0114580505,
0.1019647866,
0.0264191031,
-0.0202653762,
0.0499697551,
0.0501536727,
-0.046779938,
0.0022742951,
0.0387796089,
0.0066187172,
0.0022264388,
0.0644244775,
-0.0611769855,
-0.058560621,
-0.0288715512,
-0.0443251319,
0.0207320731,
0.0588407852,
-0.0509910323,
0.0671385899,
-0.0326540582,
-0.0443583988,
0.0277823601,
-0.002645669,
-0.0232177339,
0.0324626975,
0.0194171388,
0.0293933526,
-0.048504103,
-0.0246872716,
0.0380674601,
-0.0415348299,
-0.0565360896,
0.0308631882,
0.027131578,
0.013010446,
0.0441474728,
-0.0090952422,
-0.0167012941,
0.0560865104,
-0.0297480337,
0.0249153133,
-0.0213873424,
-0.0164142158,
-0.0279561821,
0.0257715601,
-0.0116470931,
-0.0196246058,
-0.0179242771,
-0.0522856154,
-0.017455589,
-0.0348770991,
0.0099984314,
0.0653848946,
-0.0050641703,
-0.0081031127,
0.0356761701,
-0.0082719615,
-0.0103980647,
0.0691457987,
-0.0112800505,
-0.0072045769,
-0.020186035,
-0.0241631418,
0.0014319044,
0.0182690937,
-0.0071246144,
-0.0063377288,
-0.0147347255,
-0.0025697669,
0.0270689819,
0.0239055008,
-0.0809212178,
-0.028956987,
-0.0575876944,
0.0290602781,
0.0272757821,
0.058628846,
-0.002266712,
0.0410389751,
-0.0063147899,
-0.022842316,
-0.04623238,
0.0315269828,
-0.0360059217,
-0.0155673185,
0.0526633188,
0.0225139856,
-0.0021198762,
-0.0377165899,
-0.0155425519,
-0.0330334231,
0.0173714589,
0.0435226448,
-0.00000929,
-0.0041678855,
0.0676866695,
-0.0278178789,
0.0314788073,
-0.0138909258,
0.0266712401,
-0.0156129077,
-0.0057059014,
0.0106613347,
0.0575833172,
-0.031664405,
0.0587860905,
-0.0123060253,
0.0253136735,
-0.0431164838,
0.0406484306,
-0.0163230542,
0.0582816303,
-0.0082938876,
-0.029746715,
-0.025243042,
0.0527439527,
-0.045198936,
0.017916251,
0.0048130732,
0.0209357329,
0.0024542862,
-0.0050174356,
-0.0040473952,
0.0618319027,
0.0330937132,
-0.0202455968,
-0.0509989299,
-0.0041257339,
0.0462623052,
-0.0150013734,
-0.0112780584,
-0.0321492739,
0.0207140222,
-0.050510738,
0.0727942288,
-0.0080380784,
-0.0040656016,
-0.0004582143,
-0.0184361916,
-0.0253639352,
-0.0175634101,
0.0365456417,
-0.0250911023,
0.0218601748,
-0.0066186874,
0.0207458138,
-0.0482752696,
-0.049576547,
-0.0322811306,
-0.0190576464,
-0.0147893801,
0.0233047251,
-0.022178432,
-0.0166008398,
-0.0252906382,
0.0034867369,
0.0035657159,
0.0422591008,
-0.0370680653,
-0.0343344472,
-0.0009092916,
0.0764861256,
0.0865722224,
-0.0271249302,
0.023321541,
-0.0101469476,
0.0146797914,
0.0438442379,
0.0012548342,
0.0019590044,
-0.00403678,
-0.0132975737,
-0.0139976814,
-0.0145771941,
0.0083397171,
-0.0385771282,
0.0256147645,
-0.0692079961,
-0.0288230423,
0.098686561,
0.0245091151,
-0.0377323851,
-0.0170887113,
0.0012109813,
0.0086829429,
0.0258127488,
0.0218387581,
-0.0775565729,
-0.0228206813,
-0.015768839,
0.0367425755,
0.0240305532,
-0.0828108788,
0.0021459539,
-0.0694539472,
0.0017283348,
-0.0104409987,
-0.0177690722,
0.0113378689,
-0.0764826089,
0.0228251852,
-0.0459094867,
-0.0197803974,
-0.0018601943,
-0.0358574875,
0.0107425256,
0.0064674877,
-0.0101142414,
-0.0110860197,
0.0080022831,
-0.0426863134,
0.0356236696,
0.0323673487,
0.037233863,
-0.0139386654,
0.0304804835,
0.0221860521,
-0.0031949491,
-0.0493889451,
-0.0503971204,
0.0921274573,
-0.0382457376,
-0.0074130292,
-0.0128859049,
0.0120268734,
-0.0511877127,
0.0345989391,
0.0119011886,
0.0444434136,
0.0197043624,
-0.0059863389,
-0.009679433,
-0.0480493568,
-0.0123947281,
0.0559844337,
0.0023242857,
-0.0185785983,
-0.0424821414,
0.0333644897,
0.0083370749,
-0.0387766771,
0.0423223637,
-0.0217504017,
-0.0597478114,
0.000021434,
-0.0550590642,
-0.1024481505,
0.0284499824,
0.0173682496,
-0.0196754429,
-0.0172798634,
0.0190496035,
0.0065806103,
-0.0708884671,
0.0261179581,
-0.029914571,
-0.0212130453,
0.0027944734,
0.000253312,
0.0209293477,
-0.0057932395,
-0.0296692606,
-0.0213610977,
-0.03402704,
-0.0282950159,
-0.0214538444,
0.0209857505,
0.0153714465,
0.0715346411,
-0.0299377646,
0.0166848544,
-0.0275279935,
0.0857767314,
-0.0637237355,
-0.0100015411,
0.0265067499,
-0.0163008068,
-0.0025042871,
0.0519041084,
-0.0569707155,
0.0132596083,
0.0285084415,
0.0525833406,
-0.0488819629,
-0.0451251306,
0.0088370582,
0.0161963943,
0.0674407631,
0.0057922886,
-0.0096471123,
-0.0413317829,
0.0296008773,
-0.0411595739,
0.0010651532,
-0.0423561372,
0.0316567123,
0.0144398846,
0.0223958809,
-0.020300813,
-0.008618298,
-0.0017035614,
0.0535207465,
-0.022540994,
-0.0014703451,
0.0417981483,
-0.0033510427,
0.0192114636,
-0.057775028,
-0.0260572601,
-0.0031129764,
0.0419540964,
0.0302990917,
-0.0293086935,
0.0153830023,
0.0145583246,
-0.0115656937,
0.008921654,
-0.0040563545,
-0.0125794085,
0.0451434702,
-0.0469600409,
0.0117136985,
0.0461031497,
-0.0199361183,
0.0563338958,
-0.0264625978,
0.0166806877,
0.0170267504,
0.0216179583,
-0.0073979697,
0.0188898761,
0.021007536,
0.0252849292,
-0.0112191122,
0.0498933941,
0.0477899276,
-0.0055151274,
0.0514379181,
0.0038243837,
-0.0306024104,
-0.0574422926,
0.0004791787,
0.0064467359,
-0.0119213723,
-0.0305442978,
0.0154752098,
-0.067770265,
-0.0539301559,
0.0047033574,
-0.020346012,
-0.0336456411,
0.0194270723,
-0.0225836616,
0.0231787078,
0.0059063667,
-0.0667219758,
-0.0517748185,
0.0245544091,
-0.0579614975,
-0.0407307558,
0.0050133653,
-6.404092489e-33,
-0.0545234643,
-0.0253390297,
0.0034865662,
0.0388634652,
-0.0384214856,
0.0700335875,
-0.0375439599,
-0.03264907,
-0.0186206885,
0.0198821742,
-0.0455914736,
0.0055869813,
0.015702717,
0.0024230732,
-0.0278298985,
-0.0164484568,
0.0116295516,
0.0035938858,
0.0101887938,
0.0201601628,
0.0150636612,
0.0552656651,
0.0570973419,
-0.1510939002,
0.0327740163,
-0.0070661809,
-0.0208442658,
0.0032070098,
0.0383305512,
0.0490611754,
-0.0264234766,
-0.0051966663,
0.0339885317,
0.0018106136,
0.0377585404,
0.0021970461,
-0.1849361956,
-0.0066175084,
-0.0531723201,
-0.0073854499,
-0.0281640291,
0.000069441,
0.0184522457,
0.0131843127,
0.0549224876,
-0.0657099262,
0.0358240604,
-0.0453135036,
-0.0374070928,
-0.0806559771,
-0.0467576347,
0.0386868641,
0.0470388643,
0.0127059454,
0.0129779121,
-0.0159531813,
0.0243852232,
-0.0424297675,
-0.0466503017,
-0.0744112208,
-0.0020676882,
0.0248254873,
0.0003647554,
0.0193106476,
-0.0099757314,
0.0345043838,
0.0320067555,
-0.0209213439,
0.0152226696,
-0.0068854662,
0.0139954239,
0.0350622684,
-0.0211790893,
0.0283283871,
0.0396490917,
-0.0018191203,
-0.1139404923,
0.0310903974,
0.0584256388,
0.0547043271,
-0.0487304516,
-0.010298444,
-0.0684136152,
0.0284832232,
0.0111725535,
-0.0279765707,
-0.0151993278,
-0.0083409958,
-0.012255298,
0.0287647508,
-0.0194423087,
0.0316083804,
-0.0097363461,
-0.0374903418,
-0.032946296,
0.0374306813,
0.0287704375,
0.0103737116,
-0.0159220751,
-0.0218511224,
-0.0605522282,
-0.0297181308,
-0.0076602702,
0.0019822139,
0.0375476703,
0.0253956448,
0.0736892149,
-0.0485032946,
-0.0587317608,
-0.0377937369,
-0.0307100788,
0.0307436455,
-0.0117507046,
0.0316634104,
-0.0005835449,
0.0107102646,
0.0007967576,
0.047703851,
0.0640079752,
0.0426418446,
-0.0345570222,
0.0352787934,
0.0353554301,
0.0119020343,
0.0176962167,
-0.0258157272,
0.0094819767,
-0.0061678928,
0.0171727594,
-0.0236351639,
-0.0084803961,
0.0016709872,
2.614e-7,
0.0337020345,
0.0324120149,
0.042700965,
0.0027952055,
0.0038277132,
0.0620903224,
0.0199364051,
0.0388642699,
0.0018763576,
-0.0010583341,
0.038474869,
-0.0279638115,
0.0343738794,
0.0505712219,
-0.0937869027,
-0.0214479044,
-0.0382758193,
-0.0846026018,
-0.0371850803,
-0.0227503199,
0.0393208414,
0.0382387973,
0.0230156984,
-0.0242023859,
-0.0481213592,
-0.0209219009,
0.0390962176,
-0.0185195301,
-0.0088373674,
0.0315683261,
0.0446084887,
0.0227410328,
-0.0269050021,
0.0233297609,
-0.0261612684,
0.0673498139,
-0.0069219652,
0.0828650147,
-0.0351020806,
0.0048955758,
0.0202094875,
-0.035383869,
0.0378074162,
-0.017990876,
0.075799793,
0.0015161607,
0.0084858509,
-0.0121753439,
-0.0067730914,
0.0117562637,
-0.0176450126,
0.0170665346,
-0.0149613181,
0.0330029689,
0.031597916,
-0.0511812866,
-0.0265094843,
-0.0581393838,
0.0363334715,
0.079081662,
0.0424731001,
-0.0258905496,
0.0258345529,
0.0326938294,
-0.0298748668,
-0.0228915326,
-0.0036659651,
2.274242237e-34,
-0.0237936508,
-0.0046972842,
-0.0083047273,
0.0230935812,
0.0417592824,
-0.0323624872,
-0.0630863532,
-0.0020889032,
-0.0055629797,
-0.0689753518,
0.0318695605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13860v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13860v2 | Fast-HuBERT: An Efficient Training Framework for Self-Supervised Speech Representation Learning | 2023-09-25T04:07:34 | 2023-09-29T06:48:11 | Guanrou Yang, Ziyang Ma, Zhisheng Zheng, Yakun Song, Zhikang Niu, Xie Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent years have witnessed significant advancements in self-supervised
learning (SSL) methods for speech-processing tasks. Various speech-based SSL
models have been developed and present promising performance on a range of
downstream tasks including speech recognition. However, existing speech-based
SSL models face a common dilemma in terms of computational cost, which might
hinder their potential application and in-depth academic research. To address
this issue, we first analyze the computational cost of different modules during
HuBERT pre-training and then introduce a stack of efficiency optimizations,
which is named Fast-HuBERT in this paper. The proposed Fast-HuBERT can be
trained in 1.1 days with 8 V100 GPUs on the Librispeech 960h benchmark, without
performance degradation, resulting in a 5.2x speedup, compared to the original
implementation. Moreover, we explore two well-studied techniques in the
Fast-HuBERT and demonstrate consistent improvements as reported in previous
work. | [
-0.0367629156,
0.0489225313,
0.0186779425,
0.0386532247,
-0.0189078525,
-0.0214910135,
0.0846264064,
-0.0502651669,
0.0197177213,
-0.010636149,
-0.071852833,
0.0084510148,
0.0045084008,
-0.0074008359,
0.0101145394,
-0.0183288138,
0.0355471447,
-0.0575490668,
-0.0266185757,
-0.0492413975,
0.0009255575,
-0.0060947621,
-0.0559383333,
0.0041342629,
-0.0242620446,
-0.036247354,
-0.0400930196,
0.0274624079,
-0.0150175467,
-0.0356658213,
-0.0251951162,
0.0541948043,
0.0655092299,
0.0278469939,
0.0000024282,
-0.0109199928,
-0.0167357028,
0.0085325046,
-0.029579483,
0.081771262,
0.007461756,
0.0078966701,
-0.0420769826,
0.0164249074,
-0.0091644833,
-0.048754625,
0.0148360264,
0.0080662491,
0.0343359411,
0.0382157005,
0.0138981454,
-0.0524147376,
-0.0203052219,
-0.0438819006,
-0.0160616152,
-0.0295313969,
-0.0188590661,
-0.0436470583,
-0.0231081005,
-0.0223557651,
-0.0203732755,
0.0900980905,
0.0131596951,
-0.0291488599,
0.0263694059,
0.0077752597,
-0.0129293725,
0.0226060692,
-0.0036756659,
0.0251404122,
0.0056899549,
-0.0084767062,
-0.0065856953,
-0.0132133299,
-0.0016094228,
-0.0164576899,
0.0076239547,
0.017988354,
0.0261576418,
-0.0181682706,
-0.0187784452,
0.0788325891,
0.0303767789,
-0.0322161838,
-0.0123554366,
0.0178068671,
-0.0320981108,
-0.0194807854,
0.0161015373,
-0.0105080493,
0.0071649924,
0.0165296569,
0.0204950571,
0.0032148217,
0.0199878514,
-0.0422577597,
-0.0381950028,
-0.0205925852,
-0.0051917867,
-0.0535410158,
0.0021268988,
0.025013255,
-0.0150868129,
0.0245185066,
-0.0370162427,
0.0383388549,
-0.0072293906,
0.003355674,
-0.0281022675,
0.0420340262,
-0.0167728718,
0.0079110153,
-0.0990786105,
0.0528818704,
-0.0406895354,
-0.0413384661,
-0.0568088815,
0.0010839087,
-0.0280536748,
-0.035165634,
0.0359400176,
0.0351394229,
-0.0182170793,
0.0023407519,
-0.010107982,
0.0267473496,
0.0055718347,
0.010714869,
-0.0034224482,
-0.0255860407,
-0.0067134905,
0.0035832995,
0.0281589217,
-0.0065407823,
0.02286461,
0.0716032609,
0.0037686888,
-0.0480343178,
-0.0305323694,
0.0263613313,
0.0021457851,
-0.0318298712,
-0.0191642735,
-0.0722973198,
0.0065253517,
-0.04249065,
0.0376643613,
-0.0019164829,
-0.004835844,
-0.0299287904,
0.0607430041,
0.0618116558,
-0.0277028773,
0.0256398767,
0.055645436,
0.0098374346,
-0.0059485626,
0.0476628616,
0.0188820008,
0.0086964313,
-0.0175845977,
-0.0754092112,
0.0104664182,
0.0137709482,
0.0199492089,
-0.026181763,
-0.0205511451,
-0.00568404,
-0.0159313474,
0.0842490643,
0.0780346841,
0.0319655612,
-0.035213843,
-0.0901330635,
0.0831997693,
0.0996684507,
0.0168005358,
0.0267676208,
0.0116602127,
0.0490397923,
0.0635527745,
-0.0448336191,
-0.0070185387,
0.0274406541,
-0.009875346,
0.000060721,
0.0036249799,
-0.0015310362,
-0.0523389354,
-0.0346278213,
0.0498410799,
-0.0430236645,
-0.0018334916,
0.0392330773,
0.0239422359,
0.0049362127,
-0.0417783558,
-0.0046779821,
0.0114456248,
-0.0426156968,
-0.0314757004,
-0.0371304303,
-0.0105093773,
0.063689962,
0.0083021587,
-0.0222593155,
-0.0451222174,
-0.0458555855,
-0.0353577137,
0.0277491119,
0.022026578,
0.0107059935,
0.0906811133,
-0.0403453149,
-0.0292210821,
-0.01763607,
-0.0269051455,
0.0646760091,
-0.0339638926,
0.0001415071,
-0.0086199697,
-0.0172304958,
0.0274212621,
0.0038402465,
0.0043255128,
-0.0804928243,
0.0833238363,
0.0449126065,
0.0512467138,
0.0021973164,
-0.0284378845,
-0.0020396987,
0.0149534708,
-0.0354043655,
0.0031876897,
0.0062682265,
-0.1070279032,
-0.0453311242,
0.0308213178,
0.0066936696,
0.0112374825,
0.0779455155,
0.0296600331,
-0.0679414943,
0.0484138988,
-0.0308459867,
0.0070227194,
-0.0434956253,
0.0342775062,
0.0435150973,
0.0262001399,
0.0018038579,
0.0230167508,
-0.0042917607,
-0.0256165117,
-0.0040178983,
0.0761025622,
0.0251222886,
-0.054016877,
-0.0239425637,
-0.045654349,
-0.0266172681,
0.0382692665,
0.0065189204,
-0.0307825003,
0.01929201,
0.0288533978,
-0.0806350559,
-0.0104094679,
-0.0165519733,
-0.0054251566,
0.0073379506,
-0.0037023169,
-0.0104273325,
-0.0352011472,
0.002064019,
-0.0260078013,
-0.0588415824,
-0.0036317273,
-0.0519391559,
-0.0201769192,
0.0194088854,
-0.0220587552,
-0.0154476222,
0.044820603,
0.0023642585,
-0.0549254715,
-0.0246446375,
0.014996687,
-0.0386379175,
0.001941635,
0.0469168611,
0.0120005598,
-0.0329834074,
-0.0112976618,
0.0007917501,
0.0316016339,
0.0459132306,
0.0348495543,
-0.0199531075,
0.0035683727,
-0.0028441586,
-0.0443971939,
0.0330199338,
-0.0028623801,
0.0404311419,
-0.0114925448,
0.0283923559,
-0.0419780649,
0.0522053167,
0.0108834384,
0.0360572487,
-0.0223538578,
-0.0609259307,
0.0360443816,
-0.0789690688,
-0.0412450135,
0.0077767135,
-0.0040829708,
-0.0277238209,
0.0151222218,
-0.0435993895,
-0.0116537949,
-0.0794011205,
-0.0058574476,
-0.0178718679,
-0.0524746776,
0.0112734288,
0.054061953,
0.0058630626,
0.0348330811,
-0.0280081946,
-0.0332931504,
0.0138026541,
0.0063087456,
0.0511194058,
-0.0283760093,
0.0052855625,
0.0087261116,
0.017043855,
-0.021584101,
-0.0578614026,
-0.0171575323,
-0.0506816246,
-0.0184378605,
-0.0085617825,
-0.008505485,
-0.0151547128,
-0.0097454824,
0.0557734743,
-0.0084007196,
0.0812465921,
-0.0003293003,
-0.0036726408,
-0.032390587,
0.0371052139,
-0.005849055,
0.0114903701,
0.0043480783,
0.0324990377,
0.0646868348,
0.0178523995,
0.071803458,
0.0000140958,
-0.1128709018,
0.0044748238,
0.0060386476,
-0.0193550643,
-0.0158382859,
0.0183867104,
0.0447016433,
-0.0505701564,
0.0322841704,
0.1119893268,
-0.0150340321,
-0.0097514372,
-0.0116206612,
0.0247038919,
-0.0122006806,
0.0256557912,
-0.0082258144,
-0.0291457586,
-0.0192653872,
0.0248784255,
0.045880571,
0.0192769952,
-0.000051279,
0.0250978116,
-0.0513353646,
0.0561940633,
0.0213858951,
-0.0296406895,
-0.0296875294,
-0.0607731715,
-0.054896608,
-0.0468140692,
0.0096751647,
-0.0035011664,
-0.0349236093,
-0.0158984251,
0.0515237041,
-0.086326763,
0.0145383785,
0.002955952,
-0.0307354107,
0.0484862551,
0.0159193631,
-0.0058964975,
0.0039207162,
-0.0163431577,
0.0231311265,
-0.0185563546,
0.0218855459,
-0.0146330306,
0.0198791474,
-0.0117208473,
-0.0197202284,
0.0125469882,
0.0020589102,
-0.0452785566,
0.0091170063,
0.0126234712,
0.0713289976,
-0.0105183469,
0.0422496237,
-0.0125511074,
0.0312626734,
0.0038184796,
0.0482493937,
0.0275882874,
-0.0153267188,
-0.0365357548,
0.0374476872,
0.0216805972,
0.0113417068,
-0.0372286402,
-0.0080740415,
0.0490191951,
-0.0428390056,
0.0056310645,
-0.0191294067,
-0.0045138816,
0.0750287697,
-0.0195927061,
0.0436860099,
-0.0033395623,
0.0311509017,
-0.0701153129,
0.0433644317,
-0.0156621709,
-0.0028825311,
-0.0527650155,
-0.0381515846,
0.0603237599,
-0.0126573527,
0.0109403972,
0.0253044087,
-0.007050042,
-0.0349309444,
-0.0118724573,
0.0535531528,
0.0065864534,
0.0556389242,
-0.0210667606,
-0.0039514154,
0.0947275162,
0.0747782737,
-0.0572898909,
0.0264452193,
0.0729743168,
-0.0081040971,
-0.0330980346,
0.0264816061,
0.0323548242,
0.0641979277,
-0.0359834507,
0.0222088173,
-0.0031082446,
-0.0423893742,
0.0163990613,
-0.0078399796,
0.0328731351,
-0.0027300313,
0.0602387935,
-0.0254114866,
0.0376315974,
0.0029787645,
0.0487925671,
-0.0219436903,
0.0059137875,
0.0332955793,
0.0058154608,
-0.0109224962,
-0.0052107866,
0.0344845243,
-0.0352521315,
-0.0227840301,
0.015260959,
-0.0297825411,
0.0024163916,
-0.0475917645,
0.0325344466,
0.0232067276,
0.0277651604,
0.0507718809,
-0.0069406903,
-0.0018252381,
0.0134446453,
-0.017968487,
0.0544999465,
-0.0385650024,
0.0006091647,
-0.0332193002,
-0.0725111142,
-0.0495931804,
-0.010037858,
0.0375396311,
-0.0307427049,
0.0254166145,
-0.0164060835,
-0.0087554967,
-0.0485265963,
0.0173123796,
-0.0459629558,
0.0435446911,
0.0018016637,
-0.0003142303,
-0.0212164056,
-0.0030009297,
0.0315932743,
0.0126691349,
0.0190422311,
0.0446792766,
0.0454570241,
-0.0712605193,
-0.0668361634,
-0.0096053332,
0.0322166868,
-0.0450025164,
-0.0263888165,
0.0287429206,
-0.0703521892,
0.0313874818,
-0.0416325405,
0.0029794059,
-0.0177927129,
0.0647929981,
-0.0073547061,
0.0008977031,
0.0318852402,
0.0155195165,
0.0228421055,
-0.0032158804,
0.0169660859,
0.0572154932,
-6.32008505e-33,
-0.0269864146,
0.0412304923,
0.035934791,
0.0102999192,
0.0287356023,
0.0371810757,
-0.0105927,
0.0496439822,
0.0350272097,
0.00237029,
-0.0163062196,
-0.0184186511,
0.0291071106,
0.0086451508,
0.0034215057,
0.0062389025,
0.0710832402,
-0.0651690885,
-0.0083130812,
0.0267895255,
0.0064795967,
0.0607749633,
0.0302539207,
-0.0916869938,
-0.1231692955,
0.0038342101,
0.0021931485,
-0.0394411758,
0.0104193836,
0.0223567728,
-0.03699027,
0.0082006818,
-0.029577516,
-0.0129356785,
-0.0281973891,
0.0038199958,
-0.1148640439,
-0.0159427915,
-0.037059702,
0.0263668094,
-0.0725172758,
-0.0031703408,
0.0271680467,
0.0542838313,
-0.0492933504,
0.0026813662,
-0.0032574201,
-0.0054404726,
-0.0610311292,
-0.0547277369,
-0.0231874231,
0.0375084952,
-0.0169818923,
-0.0290401932,
0.1227705553,
0.0033436737,
-0.0171387661,
-0.0340650789,
-0.0348483063,
-0.0077882432,
-0.0192033928,
0.0505124666,
0.0193954688,
-0.0168435648,
0.0404732674,
0.0504166745,
0.0916973203,
-0.0569822155,
0.0435147211,
-0.0176857915,
0.0496818982,
0.031209942,
0.0174375195,
-0.0125496536,
0.0365627632,
-0.0281908046,
-0.063934274,
0.0135798929,
0.055116538,
-0.0301295593,
0.0248934329,
0.0314174928,
-0.0227201823,
0.0182095543,
-0.0393792726,
-0.0241292398,
-0.0024528999,
-0.0057276855,
0.0408894606,
0.0547324121,
0.007075923,
0.0087202843,
0.0494417101,
-0.0141227748,
0.0093296124,
-0.0185363162,
0.018568052,
-0.0065992419,
0.0296950191,
0.0350374356,
-0.0598309077,
-0.0386294574,
-0.0009048626,
0.0158032831,
0.0216454919,
-0.0198219549,
0.0054068756,
0.0439426787,
-0.0745330825,
-0.0276603326,
-0.032848306,
0.0216170214,
-0.016433185,
0.0002330186,
0.0416094884,
-0.0359674543,
0.0154335508,
0.0611514822,
-0.0525044538,
0.0056787347,
-0.0182308443,
-0.0073572798,
0.0088581741,
0.0200668927,
0.0047766869,
0.0169876553,
-0.0472215414,
-0.0473831259,
0.0254537053,
-0.0738465786,
-0.0194025543,
-0.0185907185,
3.062e-7,
-0.0392238237,
0.0038092243,
0.0109041091,
-0.0318749472,
0.0356657989,
0.021367874,
0.0041679833,
0.0131466184,
-0.0239692014,
-0.0055280644,
0.0461052246,
0.0400728136,
0.0290873181,
-0.0094581526,
-0.029456161,
0.0209438354,
-0.0497730263,
0.055352781,
0.004512825,
0.0108324699,
-0.0578871891,
0.055519022,
-0.0175366066,
-0.0451224558,
0.039709229,
0.0255031791,
0.0604064614,
-0.0067276359,
0.0108828014,
-0.00912436,
0.0062672817,
0.0593001768,
-0.033109881,
-0.0029645821,
-0.0056619593,
0.0350642391,
0.0040345318,
0.0360851586,
-0.0029354396,
-0.0764091462,
0.0486834459,
0.0295563824,
-0.0072900616,
0.0337201767,
0.0412386507,
-0.01241259,
-0.0105525507,
-0.0352680907,
-0.0608872883,
0.0198879037,
0.0388357863,
0.0103952345,
0.0236791205,
0.0143524213,
0.0077730697,
-0.0430393405,
-0.0368347242,
-0.077526927,
0.0178359281,
-0.0042523937,
-0.0432086587,
0.0081200395,
-0.0717885792,
0.0549463555,
0.0407086462,
-0.028885508,
-0.0180177018,
2.193679318e-34,
0.0197754446,
-0.0210591983,
-0.0012794228,
-0.0038525905,
-0.0403283089,
-0.0411774851,
-0.0027516289,
-0.0136180166,
0.0145363575,
-0.0260176677,
-0.0431926288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15129v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15129v1 | Evaluating Cognitive Maps and Planning in Large Language Models with CogEval | 2023-09-25T01:20:13 | 2023-09-25T01:20:13 | Ida Momennejad, Hosein Hasanbeig, Felipe Vieira, Hiteshi Sharma, Robert Osazuwa Ness, Nebojsa Jojic, Hamid Palangi, Jonathan Larson | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recently an influx of studies claim emergent cognitive abilities in large
language models (LLMs). Yet, most rely on anecdotes, overlook contamination of
training sets, or lack systematic Evaluation involving multiple tasks, control
conditions, multiple iterations, and statistical robustness tests. Here we make
two major contributions. First, we propose CogEval, a cognitive
science-inspired protocol for the systematic evaluation of cognitive capacities
in Large Language Models. The CogEval protocol can be followed for the
evaluation of various abilities. Second, here we follow CogEval to
systematically evaluate cognitive maps and planning ability across eight LLMs
(OpenAI GPT-4, GPT-3.5-turbo-175B, davinci-003-175B, Google Bard,
Cohere-xlarge-52.4B, Anthropic Claude-1-52B, LLaMA-13B, and Alpaca-7B). We base
our task prompts on human experiments, which offer both established construct
validity for evaluating planning, and are absent from LLM training sets. We
find that, while LLMs show apparent competence in a few planning tasks with
simpler structures, systematic evaluation reveals striking failure modes in
planning tasks, including hallucinations of invalid trajectories and getting
trapped in loops. These findings do not support the idea of emergent
out-of-the-box planning ability in LLMs. This could be because LLMs do not
understand the latent relational structures underlying planning problems, known
as cognitive maps, and fail at unrolling goal-directed trajectories based on
the underlying structure. Implications for application and future directions
are discussed. | [
0.0289595164,
0.0305908713,
-0.0309941955,
0.0029064051,
-0.0504377782,
0.0416288115,
-0.0228821374,
-0.0072225947,
0.0246111527,
0.0037094736,
-0.032737609,
-0.0312807932,
0.0097171273,
0.0342756882,
0.0365061425,
-0.0439808108,
0.0416054837,
-0.089307867,
0.0123994993,
-0.0016628559,
-0.0825327113,
-0.034354277,
-0.0380270667,
0.0697278604,
0.007866919,
-0.0201900676,
-0.0393671542,
-0.0177444778,
0.0074838656,
-0.0667803884,
-0.0460296273,
0.0334621817,
-0.0007187294,
0.0289312769,
0.0000021554,
-0.0666252449,
0.0220746789,
-0.0167612471,
0.0110612428,
-0.0062964223,
-0.0094366297,
0.0022331474,
-0.0124649694,
0.021136323,
-0.0438095294,
0.0120487167,
0.0278410111,
0.0238564927,
0.0223704241,
0.0618267171,
-0.00437477,
-0.0164949596,
0.0346851572,
-0.0161835793,
0.0016429579,
-0.0382766128,
0.0217010155,
0.0160825662,
0.0337311737,
0.0004297009,
0.0049534393,
0.004027145,
0.0367923789,
0.0038023789,
-0.0341937803,
0.0612326376,
-0.0203071777,
-0.0514104888,
0.0043357196,
0.0403991081,
0.0210991371,
-0.0043362663,
0.0177497435,
0.0222584251,
-0.0139800617,
0.0122376923,
-0.0663278252,
0.0329230018,
0.0223066844,
0.0170233082,
0.0298622418,
-0.0214479454,
0.0266517457,
-0.0104455911,
-0.0358373635,
0.1048788205,
0.0034912196,
-0.0445392691,
0.0359563045,
0.0017801631,
-0.0470752604,
-0.0757658258,
-0.0003635819,
0.0544495806,
-0.0682483092,
0.0016100151,
-0.0133997118,
0.0156035088,
0.0195724759,
-0.0364332683,
0.0925428048,
0.057655178,
0.0045481534,
0.0411029831,
-0.0347356908,
0.0788965523,
-0.0341596603,
0.0665848479,
-0.0220754277,
0.0220093392,
-0.0577073134,
0.0159159526,
-0.0320531465,
0.0003122747,
-0.02403857,
-0.0439395532,
-0.0376644842,
0.0415026397,
-0.0014577861,
0.0203761142,
-0.0398305953,
0.003268329,
0.0216233712,
-0.0041575879,
-0.0709938779,
-0.043527931,
-0.0421231054,
0.0165155474,
0.0071122316,
0.005315945,
-0.0173603855,
0.0315428376,
-0.046950601,
-0.0186334755,
-0.0071164411,
0.068619363,
-0.0098421089,
-0.0211510137,
-0.0387599692,
-0.0458648019,
-0.0249681659,
-0.0778965503,
0.0710155219,
-0.0609165579,
-0.0064681978,
0.0297908932,
-0.0146750743,
-0.013209613,
-0.0013515847,
-0.0030082753,
-0.0427464396,
0.0401794016,
0.0331231505,
0.0523379743,
-0.0090666441,
0.0077055497,
-0.0285018217,
0.0568354428,
0.0458844043,
0.0357445143,
-0.025618799,
0.0418779477,
0.0130389342,
0.0544686355,
-0.0184268504,
-0.0092445873,
0.0045297234,
0.0060308194,
0.0155702177,
0.0402910002,
0.0282406658,
0.0521219969,
-0.0146819809,
0.0228756294,
0.0430890806,
0.0765703917,
0.003234636,
-0.0016398251,
0.0555050336,
-0.0341688097,
0.0135547025,
-0.0062772254,
-0.087682046,
0.0214616433,
-0.0390145816,
-0.0102339005,
0.0148606626,
0.009732238,
-0.0063877557,
-0.014826335,
-0.020695826,
0.012935007,
0.0215634592,
-0.0251839738,
0.0255766939,
0.0019000993,
-0.0449490808,
-0.0304726735,
-0.0187155865,
-0.0118549382,
-0.0150575554,
-0.041846063,
0.0127095794,
0.0313664228,
0.0329151824,
-0.0041363337,
-0.0105786193,
0.0361819416,
0.0113242371,
0.0409621671,
0.0479742102,
-0.0024166361,
-0.0074569904,
-0.0328647718,
-0.0192777328,
-0.0048073945,
0.0103152385,
0.0031779124,
0.0089416187,
0.0114798639,
-0.030040605,
-0.0115977898,
-0.0145173082,
0.0429696552,
-0.0356519409,
-0.00768892,
-0.0683216006,
0.0132271471,
0.0366304703,
-0.0174875576,
-0.017175097,
0.0563885942,
0.0419322252,
-0.0115404539,
0.0042608823,
0.0351247229,
-0.0643860847,
-0.0014963236,
0.0378166921,
-0.0086952476,
-0.0227854177,
0.0115592396,
0.017207738,
-0.0531523712,
0.0480772704,
-0.0249350239,
0.0333722346,
-0.0015797655,
0.0522143506,
0.0192574281,
-0.0232942719,
-0.011386496,
0.0758287832,
-0.002339171,
-0.0070168804,
0.0620919578,
0.0163660254,
-0.0038931414,
-0.0223611239,
-0.0366674922,
0.0306993853,
0.0038102812,
-0.0296984445,
-0.0146264154,
0.0280568246,
-0.0530835949,
-0.0609299652,
-0.0832464769,
-0.0127178226,
-0.0302057154,
0.0302502327,
0.0197732728,
-0.0654123127,
-0.0253805928,
0.0260052308,
0.0033116613,
0.0523475707,
0.0185336098,
0.0318858735,
-0.0114279995,
-0.0021915468,
-0.047949288,
-0.0200329721,
0.0119330091,
-0.0382277295,
0.0062809694,
0.0167176668,
-0.0250833202,
-0.0270347912,
0.0406137072,
-0.005111577,
0.0061291535,
-0.0275688935,
-0.0256017651,
0.059512388,
0.0086495029,
0.0718977153,
0.0302064847,
-0.0178324115,
0.0343913026,
0.0627248958,
-0.0500788279,
-0.0052909204,
0.0359485671,
-0.0313243121,
-0.0394521542,
-0.0780563653,
-0.0311624613,
0.0090358602,
0.0621210337,
-0.0118297366,
0.04006074,
-0.0560788997,
-0.0186161064,
-0.0116778333,
-0.0606699139,
-0.0120536741,
0.0054291589,
-0.0254425462,
0.0658628941,
-0.0414637662,
-0.0324134752,
0.0534748323,
-0.0281173605,
-0.0306653101,
0.0128503758,
0.0049421624,
-0.0025103351,
0.080122754,
0.0170205031,
0.0037463014,
0.0274418239,
-0.005204672,
-0.0586767457,
-0.0090513146,
-0.0492482483,
-0.0179439038,
0.03725335,
-0.0618740767,
-0.0002311219,
0.013540742,
-0.0189733189,
-0.0519230701,
0.0361159742,
-0.0220056362,
0.052099064,
0.0242642742,
-0.0434481204,
-0.0801819637,
0.0023450863,
0.0509581938,
0.0355065875,
-0.0151636181,
-0.0336304568,
-0.0056391582,
-0.0252497979,
0.0575027354,
0.0896815434,
0.0498877093,
-0.0353741534,
0.0218831692,
0.0512234867,
0.0201163273,
0.0208489541,
-0.0135650449,
0.0333980806,
0.0048398385,
-0.0121604046,
-0.0178137403,
0.0499928333,
0.0671968833,
-0.0240303855,
-0.0533994734,
0.0921185315,
0.03800302,
-0.0477474369,
0.0253404491,
-0.0530700609,
0.0710470676,
0.0529697873,
0.0171240959,
-0.0253711324,
-0.0129500451,
0.0227896497,
0.0052699908,
-0.0394002311,
-0.0575347468,
0.0122757964,
-0.1032093316,
0.0490473472,
0.0013092036,
-0.0427035913,
0.0015356379,
-0.0366858952,
0.0127262659,
0.0146307591,
0.0009723,
-0.0346411988,
0.0079431878,
-0.0007782995,
0.013253537,
-0.0385618694,
-0.0496661291,
0.0248600673,
-0.006837158,
0.0758359805,
0.0685773045,
0.018050788,
-0.0060326685,
-0.0282193664,
0.0273581054,
0.0141454106,
0.0446069688,
-0.0111683803,
0.0026198255,
0.0214124359,
0.0135488538,
-0.0046556308,
0.016525194,
-0.0513977036,
-0.0833336785,
0.0418112278,
0.0989130363,
-0.040911112,
-0.0293415505,
-0.0136249773,
0.0395413563,
0.0041530533,
0.0847512558,
0.0365366302,
-0.0281126462,
-0.0531254113,
-0.0173002761,
-0.0132138859,
-0.0419220664,
-0.0445739329,
0.0218258407,
0.0722692311,
0.0256893076,
-0.0525683463,
-0.0324275456,
0.066176109,
0.0368911698,
0.0197745431,
-0.0109149981,
0.0225099213,
-0.0321197696,
-0.016730113,
0.0258361399,
-0.0108362241,
0.0093200346,
-0.0847121999,
-0.0329282098,
-0.0240293667,
-0.0164315235,
-0.0118232071,
0.0334180854,
-0.0676290616,
-0.0801771432,
0.0303721987,
0.0455338433,
0.0307002831,
-0.0355924517,
-0.0006184187,
-0.0676100776,
0.0228865147,
-0.0051898947,
-0.015210147,
0.0572689958,
-0.0160713159,
0.0366617069,
0.0153642679,
0.0294448566,
0.0089660147,
0.0237100553,
0.016984649,
0.0710199848,
-0.001095152,
0.0198723711,
0.0073200809,
-0.0034478055,
0.0563279092,
-0.0254776459,
0.0043694875,
-0.0163603835,
-0.0419830605,
-0.0102593098,
0.0098867435,
-0.0438225716,
-0.0108711384,
0.0107076969,
0.0191511791,
0.0213538259,
-0.0138158584,
-0.0032130533,
-0.0209874306,
-0.003734201,
-0.0044442834,
0.0112370374,
-0.0249552112,
0.0087766685,
0.0219741017,
0.0048593665,
0.0186524633,
-0.0518722795,
0.0223937947,
0.0276963674,
0.0726790354,
0.0072111841,
-0.0024269673,
-0.0058028563,
-0.0071919686,
-0.0795036778,
-0.1092994958,
0.0530615561,
0.070733808,
0.0504620112,
0.0137256365,
0.0404612087,
-0.1014543325,
0.0364284068,
-0.0140326638,
-0.0157782659,
-0.0077947364,
-0.025070658,
0.0265197903,
0.0280728005,
-0.0161901843,
-0.0265044924,
0.0396509357,
0.0040761638,
0.0572780669,
-0.0062865503,
-0.004436248,
-0.0356739946,
-0.0522988178,
-0.0139770936,
0.0150443027,
-0.0502028726,
0.0057866229,
-0.0568828359,
-0.0604697093,
-0.0086589735,
0.0264042187,
0.0012483365,
-0.0134403929,
0.0342681073,
0.020310957,
-0.0347567052,
-0.0381392613,
0.011104105,
-0.0312634222,
0.0010654104,
-0.0445072018,
-0.0409350991,
-6.579479919e-33,
-0.0267114136,
-0.046953775,
0.069780618,
-0.0738497302,
-0.0094472086,
-0.0588237569,
-0.0607364476,
0.0675771832,
-0.0247314833,
0.0104804803,
-0.0166645534,
-0.0124351019,
0.01315853,
0.0036963318,
0.0229438432,
0.0016317698,
0.0119609786,
-0.0029360084,
-0.0382505357,
0.0014963914,
0.020018898,
-0.0269937422,
0.0252601262,
-0.0364522412,
-0.0253324732,
0.0128846969,
-0.0187668856,
0.0205393322,
-0.0297922343,
0.0519191921,
-0.0457770303,
0.0030065456,
0.0343303494,
0.0120030697,
-0.0226136781,
0.0165002774,
-0.0194103625,
-0.0273984373,
0.0395182744,
-0.018489005,
-0.0492015779,
-0.0139708975,
0.010486275,
0.0066465889,
-0.0425840989,
0.0108417282,
0.0181681067,
-0.0004421173,
-0.014682197,
0.0816833973,
-0.0762375519,
-0.0014320763,
-0.0063044168,
-0.0160347503,
0.0161319487,
0.039406985,
-0.0271014646,
-0.0134777594,
-0.0326717272,
0.0323167592,
-0.0353574008,
0.0005839351,
0.0518713929,
0.0394090265,
0.0201272927,
0.0804142207,
0.0329533778,
0.0293071158,
-0.0438062586,
-0.0457739718,
0.0371406153,
0.0780643746,
-0.0138232401,
0.0023506887,
0.0159184281,
0.0111882193,
-0.0344833694,
0.0150096724,
-0.009814417,
0.0301266015,
0.0485152155,
-0.0049588368,
-0.0072449716,
-0.0059225606,
-0.0400783233,
-0.0093132919,
-0.0353005677,
-0.0011452223,
0.0579473227,
-0.005789822,
0.0298790038,
-0.0010093675,
0.0409055613,
-0.0067761871,
0.0105126193,
-0.0118560893,
-0.0442446023,
0.0664910898,
-0.0130654005,
0.0314826444,
-0.088139765,
-0.0658435374,
-0.00713696,
0.0409185477,
0.0375571735,
0.0122771263,
-0.0143106338,
0.0272470787,
-0.0476233289,
-0.0181332212,
-0.0407155864,
0.0406525359,
0.0358896628,
-0.0441638455,
0.073278144,
-0.0370131396,
-0.0080758352,
-0.0429376848,
-0.0049560433,
-0.0409333482,
0.0035907237,
-0.0150324143,
-0.0077253534,
0.0096840998,
-0.0045564957,
-0.0001964977,
-0.0511614233,
0.0326154679,
0.0222343318,
-0.0386219248,
-0.0113142729,
0.048927296,
3.051e-7,
0.0189242736,
0.060268838,
-0.0025100978,
0.0338404849,
0.0159772448,
0.0062723178,
-0.0331160128,
-0.0012196804,
0.0023180116,
-0.0120069757,
0.0106051955,
0.041570399,
0.0487800948,
0.0250609741,
-0.0372736305,
-0.0200308133,
-0.0503527187,
0.0147428187,
-0.0620726496,
-0.0096887285,
0.0431865156,
0.0147455893,
-0.0018618789,
0.0145538682,
-0.008459189,
-0.038135305,
0.0583247878,
-0.0414645709,
0.028073024,
-0.0151531501,
-0.019743545,
0.0100707384,
0.0124205519,
0.0298511572,
0.0299140029,
0.0059706327,
-0.0109651387,
0.0586395077,
0.018209191,
-0.0220295694,
-0.0027536405,
0.0055136764,
0.0115049127,
-0.0710999742,
0.046867352,
-0.0827231333,
-0.0422288515,
0.0152871581,
0.0338572189,
0.0004246053,
0.0396678895,
0.0022027132,
0.0087153567,
0.0212923698,
0.0193175897,
0.0136529719,
-0.0035314739,
-0.0581772439,
0.0126403263,
0.0290570948,
-0.0513620973,
-0.0321482942,
-0.0846674591,
0.0046896334,
0.0050662183,
-0.0364036113,
-0.0235448498,
2.862517237e-34,
-0.0032115618,
-0.0065661906,
0.0387790017,
-0.0274130702,
0.0316439271,
-0.0101876399,
0.0271888655,
0.0361034721,
-0.0076337038,
-0.101564534,
-0.0381833091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13788v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13788v5 | Can LLM-Generated Misinformation Be Detected? | 2023-09-25T00:45:07 | 2024-04-23T22:59:13 | Canyu Chen, Kai Shu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.HC, cs.LG | The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has made a transformative impact.
However, the potential that LLMs such as ChatGPT can be exploited to generate
misinformation has posed a serious concern to online safety and public trust. A
fundamental research question is: will LLM-generated misinformation cause more
harm than human-written misinformation? We propose to tackle this question from
the perspective of detection difficulty. We first build a taxonomy of
LLM-generated misinformation. Then we categorize and validate the potential
real-world methods for generating misinformation with LLMs. Then, through
extensive empirical investigation, we discover that LLM-generated
misinformation can be harder to detect for humans and detectors compared to
human-written misinformation with the same semantics, which suggests it can
have more deceptive styles and potentially cause more harm. We also discuss the
implications of our discovery on combating misinformation in the age of LLMs
and the countermeasures. | [
0.0431316644,
0.0214432478,
-0.0378525257,
0.0515608825,
-0.0475874916,
-0.009232644,
0.0173407756,
0.03540067,
0.0371117704,
-0.0350586213,
-0.0230701305,
-0.0466800444,
0.0220685005,
0.0139426775,
0.0534678958,
-0.0190518107,
0.0425211228,
-0.0193345957,
0.0143234842,
-0.0182340741,
0.0303916279,
0.0146771986,
0.0264190082,
0.0412804559,
-0.0101785874,
-0.0206335466,
0.0241245683,
0.0051282337,
-0.0033618237,
-0.0380041413,
0.0067137494,
0.0272075702,
0.0153927905,
0.0805259198,
0.0000018171,
-0.0230922289,
0.005477895,
0.0152697284,
-0.0641191751,
0.0614927076,
0.0520591065,
-0.0178219266,
-0.0169122536,
0.0395442024,
0.0012684704,
0.003158523,
0.0370839611,
0.05877354,
0.0544034727,
0.1053021401,
-0.0094819488,
0.0025444543,
0.0500130244,
-0.0035966109,
0.0246355124,
-0.0163287893,
0.048521772,
-0.0079526063,
-0.0215279926,
0.0588027611,
0.0186061189,
-0.0002592697,
-0.0083637955,
-0.0144911772,
-0.0594546609,
0.017338153,
-0.0377102904,
-0.0349645428,
-0.0108497469,
0.0225680396,
-0.008217548,
-0.0551730283,
0.0523164906,
0.0036859908,
0.0101307407,
0.0571420677,
0.0035620099,
0.0680487528,
-0.0481311455,
-0.0048994976,
0.009282792,
0.0001222951,
0.0860696584,
0.0335122719,
0.0357380696,
0.0605357736,
0.0060621523,
-0.0365535803,
-0.0168021526,
-0.0448056161,
-0.0144678578,
-0.0622324236,
-0.0147217875,
-0.0015403134,
-0.0286295153,
0.0223517045,
-0.0576775335,
-0.0120157618,
0.0666537434,
-0.1204179227,
0.0010740588,
0.0254674163,
0.0061797122,
0.0199388247,
-0.0015678904,
0.0186785683,
-0.0490467101,
0.021329863,
0.0040431474,
0.0175057556,
0.0114638293,
-0.0110906241,
-0.0059091072,
-0.0068094064,
0.024712678,
0.0337329209,
-0.0722113252,
0.0246703848,
-0.0472310074,
0.0203138608,
-0.0227741264,
-0.0248977337,
-0.0208022054,
-0.0078367898,
0.0159914922,
0.014777449,
0.0084014125,
0.0214884784,
-0.01340211,
-0.077011168,
0.0053692632,
0.0572043061,
-0.081806913,
0.0064461012,
-0.0205163248,
0.0890276805,
0.0257653203,
0.0043492373,
-0.045782052,
-0.0845831856,
-0.0500347167,
-0.0273432583,
0.0030627477,
-0.0662618056,
-0.0438248552,
-0.0142558608,
-0.0154851666,
-0.0312309843,
0.0080095027,
-0.0088423267,
-0.0596631989,
0.041404672,
-0.0520471632,
0.0076437159,
0.0420929715,
0.047248967,
-0.036552798,
0.0733471364,
0.0039854678,
0.0731813088,
0.0476515517,
0.0006345899,
0.0364650823,
0.0493277833,
0.0323822796,
0.0520274378,
0.0101248696,
-0.0266063493,
-0.0008642157,
-0.0222276971,
-0.0064833728,
0.0715605244,
-0.0185996424,
-0.0357912108,
0.0908943713,
0.000271369,
-0.0476125367,
0.0214373562,
0.0273771659,
0.0339713246,
0.0062622451,
0.0262766089,
-0.03943073,
-0.0209320299,
-0.1004509553,
-0.0225295387,
0.0222468432,
0.0344055295,
-0.0122123472,
-0.0060539874,
-0.0292227343,
-0.0088170404,
0.0385530367,
-0.0219953004,
-0.002769639,
-0.002895474,
-0.0284630544,
0.0591320172,
0.0600153729,
0.0026278151,
0.0041041346,
-0.0734108314,
-0.0200197715,
0.0421375372,
0.0313109756,
0.0243112538,
0.0093429964,
-0.0348324329,
0.0173888132,
0.0384733453,
0.0400638916,
0.0278641433,
-0.0547012091,
0.0061849486,
0.0238499567,
-0.0010735425,
0.0226815883,
-0.0150605291,
0.0395248532,
0.0231590159,
-0.0188394431,
-0.0122763757,
-0.0327524543,
-0.0031815432,
-0.0173840746,
0.0101161357,
-0.0417203903,
0.006702859,
0.0225613154,
-0.0184003375,
-0.012344514,
-0.0062977257,
0.0301868506,
-0.0072943582,
-0.0537188128,
-0.0202341136,
-0.0022889774,
0.0412663929,
0.0343189985,
-0.0287171863,
-0.0191469546,
-0.0043794834,
-0.00866755,
0.0311955735,
0.0598649383,
-0.0638220087,
0.0433130488,
-0.0091163004,
0.0012226235,
-0.0250829905,
0.0148956524,
0.0012398126,
0.0465143658,
-0.0403542332,
-0.0111509999,
-0.0103091979,
-0.0021734664,
-0.0017938868,
0.0142884785,
-0.0111287115,
-0.0083927643,
-0.0107810218,
0.0404512472,
0.029182313,
-0.0017932978,
-0.0120211709,
-0.0346146002,
-0.0457827225,
-0.0473872274,
-0.0113927135,
0.0181247815,
0.0522760004,
-0.0016323824,
-0.0253989808,
0.0227842238,
-0.0268744864,
0.0034581879,
0.0153386341,
0.0358455032,
0.0334218033,
-0.0307871755,
-0.051949095,
0.0122915972,
0.0253499672,
-0.0320185609,
0.041366946,
0.0201363526,
-0.0680265352,
-0.0520221777,
0.0277492329,
-0.048559092,
0.0076107546,
-0.0360288657,
-0.0589698106,
0.0128832692,
0.0211566109,
-0.0109854126,
-0.0113898888,
0.0494508892,
0.0678753406,
0.0379556939,
0.0392629467,
-0.019242458,
-0.0405821539,
-0.0172187239,
-0.037106663,
-0.0314643495,
-0.0810637996,
0.0117711732,
0.0539694987,
0.0492307544,
-0.0024521907,
-0.0352735221,
0.034082029,
-0.0329502821,
-0.0306138247,
-0.0100593101,
-0.0798277184,
-0.0193115994,
0.0243449304,
-0.0111091677,
-0.0844626352,
0.0599753484,
-0.05486748,
0.0418523848,
-0.0092047993,
-0.0177622698,
0.0113157434,
-0.003619377,
-0.0276724994,
0.0553678125,
0.0548877306,
-0.0105724959,
-0.0150022721,
-0.0380340926,
0.0619505905,
-0.0254617929,
0.0140770329,
-0.0419346355,
0.0230448563,
0.0371434763,
-0.0112777594,
-0.054021135,
-0.0955582038,
-0.0122878235,
-0.0410817936,
0.0359260663,
-0.0373291373,
-0.0242117494,
-0.0217261519,
0.0188303068,
-0.0398279577,
-0.0001334406,
-0.0050078207,
-0.0172330588,
-0.0142888818,
0.0137024475,
-0.0628264546,
0.0628098026,
-0.0573710501,
-0.0006752053,
0.0980118439,
-0.0223938338,
-0.0074616564,
0.0035484671,
-0.0296532661,
0.0188893378,
0.0017044999,
-0.0193833876,
0.0544114113,
0.0346941128,
-0.0434018746,
0.0071882079,
0.0695554242,
0.0042228731,
-0.0150117893,
0.0091108819,
-0.0017309056,
0.0161972791,
0.0016877868,
-0.0219777338,
-0.0819250569,
0.0058541447,
0.0165653881,
-0.0024043981,
-0.0654220358,
-0.0051641166,
-0.0248196237,
-0.0521533899,
0.0447392911,
0.0443891622,
-0.0108407559,
-0.0059322561,
-0.0397962481,
-0.0536003746,
0.0442581251,
0.0492619537,
-0.0314645357,
-0.001012984,
-0.0312785283,
0.0086011766,
-0.0853779241,
-0.0330641009,
0.0141616073,
-0.0115875406,
0.0803335235,
0.0303299762,
0.0076090833,
-0.0362973101,
-0.0401092544,
0.0497331619,
0.0363707617,
-0.0485260114,
-0.0030262636,
0.0444315821,
-0.0006871004,
-0.0266373362,
-0.0333958715,
-0.0019957703,
0.0094190426,
-0.0047116484,
-0.018954562,
0.035859298,
-0.017840676,
-0.0665435642,
0.0067406613,
0.0204857923,
0.0555862077,
0.0565352216,
-0.0098162107,
0.0050529325,
-0.0142323775,
-0.0774189085,
0.0179612301,
0.0595116802,
-0.0595786832,
0.0281460863,
0.0222355742,
-0.0477681346,
-0.0389221385,
0.0290211476,
-0.0451945513,
-0.0426225774,
0.0554169156,
0.0201357473,
0.0362721793,
0.0062420764,
0.01238281,
-0.0218720138,
-0.0549675338,
0.0491147824,
-0.050248757,
0.0370984189,
-0.0063130227,
-0.0216515418,
0.0232244041,
0.0357345194,
-0.0887672901,
-0.0658232719,
0.0074291904,
-0.0028101141,
0.0268043522,
0.0141775291,
-0.026375303,
-0.0368959084,
0.0730939582,
0.0239233617,
-0.0322719142,
0.0173160601,
0.0466271937,
0.0077764774,
0.0375196077,
0.0339557752,
-0.0199484695,
0.0072223591,
0.0144467074,
-0.0321844257,
-0.0898942873,
0.0034537036,
0.043219652,
0.0474244393,
0.0252516214,
-0.0218997207,
0.0364217088,
0.0178443585,
-0.0180808194,
-0.0215391479,
-0.02005703,
0.0206604674,
-0.0153606227,
0.0270833988,
-0.0012800134,
0.0365730785,
0.0306202676,
-0.0320503339,
0.0155484006,
0.0104750963,
-0.0011760466,
-0.0197742973,
0.0320354514,
0.0636875406,
-0.0159794707,
0.0072826375,
0.0622878373,
0.0025991991,
0.0275792927,
0.0148050962,
0.0120865693,
-0.0014521023,
-0.0147329886,
0.0001554984,
-0.0169926137,
-0.0370665751,
-0.0619545057,
0.0014526537,
0.0520866066,
0.035725683,
0.0424563885,
0.0332012884,
-0.0190171618,
-0.0130990483,
-0.0226008743,
-0.0110226078,
-0.0146220867,
-0.0481795147,
0.0146139245,
-0.0199784916,
-0.0475485064,
0.0312539153,
0.0723669678,
0.0121914269,
0.0490208678,
0.0219046082,
-0.0580240227,
-0.0120586548,
-0.0382620469,
0.003053345,
0.0241461247,
-0.0218541622,
-0.0216996074,
-0.0979370475,
-0.0561184697,
-0.0107321134,
-0.0081107784,
0.0275631677,
-0.0104539683,
-0.0285743531,
0.0684119463,
0.0077259201,
0.018276168,
-0.0660102814,
0.010281641,
0.0153388279,
-0.0101202922,
0.0066726264,
-6.049150133e-33,
0.0156772137,
-0.0731422752,
-0.038838461,
0.0221499819,
0.0107869543,
0.028430298,
0.002751186,
0.0188943781,
-0.0215434935,
0.0336202607,
0.0217545461,
0.0129197147,
-0.0008080983,
-0.0020047992,
-0.0468914807,
-0.0312297847,
0.0373939052,
-0.0228815321,
-0.0224586911,
0.0217424668,
0.0660733283,
-0.0318191685,
0.0091417776,
-0.07617715,
0.0687951967,
-0.023850318,
-0.0453178696,
0.017710831,
-0.0346630663,
0.0444849469,
0.0070260121,
0.0514346473,
0.0022434092,
-0.0170242209,
-0.0079010893,
0.0248463694,
0.0277652144,
0.000294819,
0.0501884893,
-0.0136827296,
0.0197797678,
-0.044425007,
0.036354728,
-0.0091013052,
-0.0367037281,
0.0218372252,
-0.0071486747,
-0.00410379,
-0.0064440202,
-0.0053198817,
-0.0246619005,
-0.0169743393,
0.0017344945,
0.0171687603,
-0.0073390617,
0.0331073366,
0.0147989364,
-0.0047893482,
-0.0779674202,
0.0458125696,
0.0169425681,
-0.0039146664,
0.0317543559,
-0.0256019849,
-0.0330647118,
0.0810521618,
0.0032881801,
0.046316918,
-0.045816835,
-0.0029030391,
-0.0154930642,
0.0342202187,
0.0482879616,
0.0773679018,
-0.0096477345,
-0.0508153662,
-0.0846035033,
0.0078123417,
0.0408642478,
0.0046703755,
0.0455916263,
-0.028881181,
-0.0707091913,
-0.0472609997,
-0.012846957,
0.0016242024,
-0.0352323428,
-0.0166427735,
-0.0048735524,
0.0103187896,
-0.0130917812,
-0.0153511325,
-0.0031160652,
-0.0706124827,
-0.0083911307,
-0.0087207714,
0.010330433,
-0.0173775274,
0.0219644886,
0.0460041314,
-0.0228310414,
-0.0129055623,
-0.0035652525,
-0.0271867346,
0.0098325359,
0.0074307569,
0.0313321501,
0.0022582007,
-0.053581249,
0.0129364301,
-0.0192030016,
0.0443939678,
0.0294634383,
-0.0437375829,
0.0382169448,
-0.0190967321,
-0.0107948072,
-0.0292167086,
0.0364391766,
0.0119755128,
-0.0039809281,
0.0075764903,
-0.0570658892,
0.0525712147,
-0.0388176851,
0.0043780082,
-0.0446919575,
0.0208453331,
0.0611326508,
-0.0836258382,
-0.0215686541,
-0.0648300722,
2.685e-7,
0.00175195,
0.0586193837,
-0.0016025067,
0.0435083471,
0.0593939982,
0.0699890032,
0.0012045434,
0.0376431122,
-0.0235118456,
-0.0651792064,
-0.0483966842,
0.0220453553,
0.0412642285,
0.0347578786,
-0.014048527,
0.0202925317,
-0.0819545314,
0.0008112772,
-0.0349642187,
-0.0035902252,
0.0443767086,
0.0548750572,
0.0368257537,
-0.0403583497,
-0.0229038745,
-0.0374833457,
0.0480585471,
-0.0293209776,
-0.040774636,
0.0303530134,
0.0577313416,
0.0258427821,
0.023650445,
0.0391243175,
0.0014910416,
-0.0514029711,
-0.0472139455,
0.0291799959,
0.0349996947,
0.0252640508,
-0.0573173948,
-0.0677259639,
0.0096089384,
-0.0530223288,
0.0267093554,
-0.0150074251,
-0.036606662,
-0.045798257,
-0.0277232882,
-0.0354524031,
0.0212324448,
-0.0139187174,
-0.0390323922,
0.0175635405,
-0.0021484266,
0.0398121849,
0.0189538859,
-0.0209255572,
-0.009547689,
0.0032972277,
-0.034873791,
-0.0622921214,
-0.0010232616,
0.018743407,
0.0204000901,
-0.007484931,
0.046165213,
2.717025015e-34,
0.0423809513,
-0.0308856964,
0.0033899441,
-0.0118893785,
0.0359119996,
0.0284173042,
0.0029401677,
-0.0096854595,
-0.0010641792,
-0.0054091206,
0.0058545843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13761v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13761v1 | Text Classification: A Perspective of Deep Learning Methods | 2023-09-24T21:49:51 | 2023-09-24T21:49:51 | Zhongwei Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, with the rapid development of information on the Internet,
the number of complex texts and documents has increased exponentially, which
requires a deeper understanding of deep learning methods in order to accurately
classify texts using deep learning techniques, and thus deep learning methods
have become increasingly important in text classification. Text classification
is a class of tasks that automatically classifies a set of documents into
multiple predefined categories based on their content and subject matter. Thus,
the main goal of text classification is to enable users to extract information
from textual resources and process processes such as retrieval, classification,
and machine learning techniques together in order to classify different
categories. Many new techniques of deep learning have already achieved
excellent results in natural language processing. The success of these learning
algorithms relies on their ability to understand complex models and non-linear
relationships in data. However, finding the right structure, architecture, and
techniques for text classification is a challenge for researchers. This paper
introduces deep learning-based text classification algorithms, including
important steps required for text classification tasks such as feature
extraction, feature reduction, and evaluation strategies and methods. At the
end of the article, different deep learning text classification methods are
compared and summarized. | [
0.0272066183,
0.0124636348,
-0.0027243106,
0.0258022845,
-0.0571422391,
0.0366533957,
0.0590103492,
0.002399429,
0.0410608575,
-0.0685790107,
-0.037613254,
-0.0465500653,
0.0080203237,
0.0377684236,
-0.0539925471,
-0.0332862474,
0.0370131619,
0.0257115141,
0.0517668352,
0.0315834284,
-0.0266059805,
0.0422815196,
0.0013669723,
0.0110760164,
-0.0021177432,
-0.0119770197,
0.0088474294,
-0.0182472151,
-0.0089414511,
-0.0103925141,
0.0513874926,
0.0306979399,
0.0167856235,
0.0408505648,
0.000001883,
-0.0229470134,
-0.0274668839,
-0.0248562377,
-0.0243278425,
0.0004810903,
0.0722657517,
-0.0039420072,
0.0072637824,
0.0273732245,
-0.0115480339,
-0.0419924408,
0.0363004766,
0.1016008854,
0.013059454,
0.0851152241,
-0.0211949609,
-0.0544862784,
0.0501245148,
0.0097628897,
-0.0063183764,
-0.0256535821,
0.0465437844,
-0.0581970066,
-0.0333462022,
0.0405760296,
0.0197099559,
0.030806357,
0.0159826558,
0.0232066158,
0.0274329968,
-0.0085993148,
0.0163511075,
-0.0254180878,
0.0104013942,
0.0683875903,
-0.0523780398,
-0.033370737,
-0.0021075334,
-0.0243762769,
-0.0246692412,
-0.008516754,
0.0040945243,
0.0211965144,
0.0005822878,
0.0082814181,
0.0003938153,
0.0372382551,
0.0284756441,
0.0324908979,
-0.0220325887,
0.0277634077,
-0.0469539315,
-0.0201877598,
0.0258646552,
-0.004107337,
0.0313263647,
-0.0246314295,
0.0463628806,
0.0067650713,
0.0200782288,
-0.0247399211,
-0.0205267854,
-0.0705726817,
0.0341666602,
-0.0838094428,
-0.0349731296,
-0.0403009951,
-0.0190302581,
0.0342250876,
-0.035632547,
0.0044193305,
-0.002335733,
-0.0086921947,
0.017109599,
0.0037887476,
-0.0574301518,
-0.0098253014,
-0.0047300383,
0.0624468327,
-0.0070974887,
-0.0401930586,
-0.0404489376,
-0.0016938082,
-0.0071581812,
0.0085653551,
-0.0037396247,
0.0701270625,
-0.025918534,
0.0321929455,
-0.0313634798,
0.0047800345,
-0.02317903,
0.0457955226,
-0.0514981039,
0.005206706,
0.0540834256,
0.0389752053,
0.0791756958,
-0.0237178411,
0.0391888916,
0.0459093787,
-0.0091536883,
-0.0364461727,
-0.0573805384,
-0.0109520368,
0.0391411446,
-0.0164238904,
0.0130807487,
-0.0504497103,
0.005878286,
-0.0350148715,
-0.0531498119,
-0.0118189137,
-0.0145763112,
0.0316201635,
-0.0262183044,
0.0612843782,
-0.010662633,
-0.0308922864,
0.1149266213,
0.0244044773,
0.0095277643,
-0.0042428006,
0.0153587451,
0.0604451373,
0.025843868,
-0.0154988784,
0.0480852574,
-0.009626247,
-0.0250242408,
-0.0623960085,
0.0345589295,
-0.0171164684,
-0.0471427701,
0.0169398822,
-0.0152168022,
0.0327567756,
0.0073313294,
0.0050852136,
0.020291578,
0.0501863249,
0.0660454631,
0.091085203,
0.0072320495,
0.0392748713,
0.0166731197,
-0.0228461791,
-0.0003114159,
-0.0082026245,
0.0031962625,
-0.0432947427,
-0.0246430021,
-0.0284232926,
-0.0477457233,
-0.0484068841,
0.0105470503,
-0.0480080172,
0.036804419,
-0.0054459972,
0.08428175,
-0.0261383299,
-0.0314635597,
-0.0201285072,
0.0062718056,
-0.0095889317,
-0.0089318426,
-0.0250046588,
0.0187099297,
0.0259870943,
-0.0021451665,
-0.0670668706,
0.0022766171,
-0.0312436521,
0.030844938,
0.0004829299,
0.0264696162,
0.0178663433,
-0.0030974327,
-0.0758425444,
-0.0312547572,
-0.0293028615,
-0.0040474026,
-0.0135991601,
-0.0496915393,
0.0616808385,
0.0394085459,
0.0231657997,
-0.0237373989,
0.0403531566,
0.0336724855,
-0.0440217257,
0.0566914082,
0.0572008267,
0.0070369621,
0.026543621,
0.0078352252,
-0.0299626905,
0.0203542709,
-0.024370335,
-0.0576635934,
-0.0689423978,
-0.0445240885,
-0.0058920868,
-0.0212766398,
-0.0239104182,
0.0447234064,
0.0540043823,
-0.0320647247,
-0.0376123562,
0.0382866226,
-0.0149203027,
-0.0115859509,
-0.0257913042,
-0.009580913,
-0.0374754779,
0.0365269035,
-0.0389928073,
0.0649954751,
0.0396412723,
-0.0045691761,
-0.0290229488,
-0.0285231844,
0.0278704986,
0.0091704316,
-0.0297992397,
0.0205684062,
-0.0494706668,
0.0429534577,
0.0307749677,
0.0215400346,
0.0108154062,
-0.0106278919,
-0.0547299758,
0.0413362421,
-0.0116927838,
0.0234064795,
-0.0158211123,
-0.00248614,
0.0240120087,
-0.0076319645,
-0.0698187053,
-0.0020178296,
-0.0129043721,
-0.0328236967,
0.0315767638,
-0.0022306498,
0.0233006235,
-0.0007446526,
-0.0447480343,
-0.0176054947,
0.0777061135,
0.0052030343,
-0.040994972,
0.0135883326,
0.0114876218,
-0.0172051862,
0.0202955361,
0.0325369611,
-0.0228958149,
-0.0287557133,
-0.0213227309,
-0.0346041732,
0.0332065783,
0.0094192289,
0.0734328702,
0.0059288624,
0.0567848273,
-0.0414713249,
0.0258847252,
-0.0215314347,
0.0778722763,
0.0078685107,
-0.0146687785,
0.0098734517,
0.034439873,
0.0269273352,
0.0002287707,
0.0095502967,
0.0074177696,
0.0321922638,
0.0162377506,
-0.0398480296,
-0.0104061933,
0.0185708441,
-0.0017266566,
-0.0133524388,
-0.0075856913,
0.018536564,
0.007535723,
0.0104665728,
-0.0842395946,
-0.0680989027,
-0.0402062461,
0.0330212414,
-0.01175371,
0.0209468957,
-0.0141284224,
-0.0320196226,
0.004632751,
0.009086051,
0.0082554901,
-0.0221808013,
0.0154038984,
0.0267515723,
0.0006908995,
-0.0330980904,
0.0254477393,
-0.0354161523,
-0.0333803408,
0.0146372588,
0.006547567,
0.0058685085,
0.0101682078,
-0.0200388525,
-0.0043896567,
0.0094328336,
0.0615691617,
-0.0034425047,
0.0051453649,
-0.030125903,
0.0696616918,
0.0242556669,
-0.0155666638,
-0.0109442296,
0.0311627686,
0.0190834552,
0.0219598357,
-0.0166471135,
0.0249790065,
-0.0651926398,
-0.0002265518,
0.0062738634,
-0.0750175416,
-0.01266215,
-0.0029894391,
-0.0246394146,
-0.0748685598,
0.0050685136,
0.0969424322,
0.0372550264,
-0.0892054886,
-0.02668369,
0.0263544656,
-0.0304901451,
-0.0178681146,
0.0136450659,
-0.0275169928,
-0.0237321891,
-0.0079645794,
-0.0288884174,
-0.0146996379,
0.0044880733,
0.0220897011,
-0.033336442,
0.0015371735,
-0.0347512998,
-0.0302961562,
-0.0452890806,
-0.0693209171,
-0.0084230909,
0.0108826766,
0.0047373762,
-0.0637362376,
-0.0026760362,
-0.0429923534,
0.0009227524,
-0.0751148164,
-0.0210975092,
0.0283934642,
-0.0158806033,
0.0099425828,
0.0383027941,
0.0425433926,
-0.056476593,
-0.0028570285,
0.0138556985,
-0.0123296417,
-0.0164657477,
-0.0357921608,
0.0474703796,
-0.0048504649,
0.015434362,
-0.0067874622,
0.001148975,
-0.0521103963,
0.0184255708,
-0.0155931143,
0.0913409963,
-0.0384340882,
-0.0814041942,
-0.0500023775,
-0.0333542824,
-0.0016426278,
0.056531243,
-0.0200559143,
-0.0904824287,
-0.0643129647,
0.0010372954,
0.0033721351,
-0.0406463183,
0.0093031572,
0.0151597075,
0.00521194,
-0.0402163714,
-0.0495502576,
-0.0356194749,
-0.0109673329,
-0.0203349385,
-0.008528349,
0.0170383006,
0.0227468666,
-0.0194220766,
-0.0488256961,
0.013275574,
0.0082885213,
0.0138975857,
-0.032563854,
0.0077915369,
0.0361021385,
-0.0555131398,
-0.0276406575,
-0.0300339833,
-0.0429626741,
-0.0006135699,
-0.0391156748,
-0.0229747351,
0.0010842073,
-0.0215081684,
-0.0125774648,
-0.0861052498,
0.0721833706,
0.0303875208,
-0.0443554409,
-0.0581134297,
0.0205953214,
-0.009711368,
-0.0366377383,
0.014671552,
-0.0372755751,
0.0295745153,
-0.0177569743,
-0.0463367254,
-0.0210557543,
-0.0421082452,
-0.0327341631,
-0.012054693,
0.0387021042,
0.0318216942,
-0.0616951361,
-0.0461447798,
0.0102219097,
0.0456832871,
-0.022271663,
-0.0086263139,
0.024370471,
0.0391986296,
0.01783235,
-0.0147416629,
0.0202448722,
0.0890831128,
-0.0327400677,
0.024425678,
0.0350527205,
0.0221658628,
0.0889754072,
-0.0520156994,
0.0548465699,
-0.0382717215,
0.014555783,
0.0055521983,
0.0082863932,
-0.0298383981,
-0.0012507761,
0.0048822528,
0.0164589491,
-0.0706450343,
0.0316391513,
-0.0095453244,
0.0122284237,
-0.0234077685,
0.0047911457,
0.0612341166,
-0.0522277057,
-0.0238474421,
-0.0205330774,
-0.0095834946,
-0.0277007632,
0.0508701354,
-0.002303439,
0.0203979369,
-0.0318000093,
-0.0164487548,
-0.0258584041,
0.0042981929,
0.0175973997,
0.0491784215,
-0.007052158,
0.0343359597,
-0.0701784492,
-0.061870452,
0.0244837776,
0.0484755263,
0.0553213991,
-0.0125688184,
0.0079569789,
0.0502173305,
0.0062695495,
0.0928151309,
-0.0488994084,
-0.0000738717,
-0.0041605202,
0.0355304144,
0.0682869181,
0.0091690011,
0.0118663488,
-0.0430181101,
0.0155072445,
-0.0055416971,
-0.0015560018,
-0.0460622385,
-5.672884309e-33,
0.0454118922,
-0.0255871043,
-0.0140207903,
0.0272255521,
0.0056234952,
0.0183755197,
-0.0012690044,
-0.0172139443,
-0.0301864129,
-0.0128187714,
0.0199482702,
-0.0036854527,
0.0047212965,
0.0411558188,
-0.015388892,
-0.044061508,
0.0207181219,
-0.0158292614,
0.0315505341,
0.061103791,
0.0231822226,
0.049413275,
0.0436354205,
-0.0828851163,
0.0176322423,
-0.0046984041,
0.0208653081,
-0.0202534385,
0.0211428683,
0.04656782,
-0.0437815115,
0.0569505878,
0.0613201819,
-0.0119413361,
0.0315375142,
0.0781358927,
-0.0634661689,
-0.0651446581,
-0.0841092467,
0.03059089,
-0.0308493041,
-0.0390296914,
0.0579457246,
0.0474866219,
0.0081561217,
-0.0131544229,
0.1015548408,
0.0288153198,
-0.0227100179,
-0.0578023568,
-0.0534448996,
0.0266010631,
-0.0132220704,
0.0086357659,
0.0239986293,
0.0118124494,
0.0010205152,
0.0299146827,
-0.0908263773,
-0.0327250622,
0.0020711636,
0.0261625573,
-0.0038792377,
0.0085367365,
-0.0485651828,
0.0361248851,
-0.0057963631,
-0.0029126839,
-0.0468875207,
0.0359873511,
0.0637435094,
0.0650441051,
0.0346424952,
0.0475410186,
0.0432790555,
-0.0362162292,
-0.0842908397,
0.047396265,
0.0297794957,
0.0154893026,
-0.0121469107,
-0.0019351984,
-0.0319038779,
0.0099518066,
-0.0148316016,
-0.0007243293,
-0.0405185185,
-0.0272380076,
0.0014655445,
-0.0090464121,
-0.0254076868,
0.0211366918,
0.0133087691,
-0.0556002557,
-0.0193553902,
0.0472304188,
-0.0125538306,
0.0548590273,
0.0138919642,
-0.0197517481,
-0.050531134,
-0.0352297239,
-0.028156044,
-0.0223580226,
0.0135639505,
0.013593033,
0.0249600336,
0.0018600068,
-0.0127419801,
-0.0045391293,
0.0340326503,
-0.0223892424,
0.0159961246,
0.0945775211,
-0.0463563055,
-0.0121473325,
0.0363752209,
0.0769110098,
0.0085730068,
0.0222930908,
-0.0124364803,
-0.0414476953,
0.0238655917,
-0.0150298718,
-0.038727276,
-0.0204811897,
-0.0485578999,
0.0089250626,
0.0169392973,
-0.0689241588,
0.0294558667,
-0.0035664293,
2.451e-7,
0.0487794317,
0.0520907529,
0.0131241316,
-0.0193775874,
0.0075980155,
0.059116628,
0.0509355441,
0.0301925,
-0.045342721,
0.0188943036,
0.0439325608,
0.028333554,
0.0265531056,
0.0162923411,
-0.073675938,
-0.0162102394,
-0.0537361726,
0.0288899168,
-0.0478963628,
0.0124706523,
0.0594959408,
0.0652672425,
0.0109122572,
-0.0470828339,
-0.0103980601,
-0.0246499199,
0.0222355314,
0.013196948,
0.0429783948,
0.0431198664,
0.0220855083,
0.0342173427,
-0.0110175321,
0.003473534,
-0.0234284867,
0.0469560958,
0.01312193,
0.0411057919,
-0.0074919984,
-0.0191712752,
0.0269515477,
0.005061517,
0.0137140891,
0.020854203,
0.0704047233,
-0.0101061547,
-0.0146742323,
-0.0206337925,
0.0347318724,
-0.0206461642,
0.0610125326,
-0.0280268639,
0.020795567,
0.0111871911,
0.0256601572,
-0.0650408417,
-0.0318940207,
-0.1006198972,
0.011177049,
0.0421744436,
-0.0319768712,
0.0745527968,
-0.0425474718,
0.0137954662,
0.0691087544,
-0.0166059677,
0.0463346057,
1.847934976e-34,
-0.0284053646,
0.0105199683,
-0.033407364,
-0.0076255528,
-0.0378461257,
0.006129947,
-0.0216258019,
0.0002604989,
-0.0121704815,
-0.0396626331,
0.0307256933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13748v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13748v1 | Does the "most sinfully decadent cake ever" taste good? Answering Yes/No Questions from Figurative Contexts | 2023-09-24T20:38:48 | 2023-09-24T20:38:48 | Geetanjali Rakshit, Jeffrey Flanigan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Figurative language is commonplace in natural language, and while making
communication memorable and creative, can be difficult to understand. In this
work, we investigate the robustness of Question Answering (QA) models on
figurative text. Yes/no questions, in particular, are a useful probe of
figurative language understanding capabilities of large language models. We
propose FigurativeQA, a set of 1000 yes/no questions with figurative and
non-figurative contexts, extracted from the domains of restaurant and product
reviews. We show that state-of-the-art BERT-based QA models exhibit an average
performance drop of up to 15\% points when answering questions from figurative
contexts, as compared to non-figurative ones. While models like GPT-3 and
ChatGPT are better at handling figurative texts, we show that further
performance gains can be achieved by automatically simplifying the figurative
contexts into their non-figurative (literal) counterparts. We find that the
best overall model is ChatGPT with chain-of-thought prompting to generate
non-figurative contexts. Our work provides a promising direction for building
more robust QA models with figurative language understanding capabilities. | [
0.0915200263,
0.0176436231,
-0.0197437909,
0.0465630554,
-0.0400583595,
0.0030498446,
-0.0222806968,
-0.0079320651,
-0.0062811454,
-0.0664435625,
-0.0273645613,
-0.0228544641,
-0.0397513472,
0.0215513315,
-0.0109790713,
-0.0347130261,
0.0297932532,
0.0007461612,
0.0501801707,
-0.0269629266,
-0.0206849501,
0.0257157907,
-0.0065112752,
0.0396841317,
-0.0068725334,
-0.0315034762,
-0.0119101256,
0.0507987253,
0.0088831121,
-0.0135737676,
0.0101634832,
0.0442238674,
0.0053078732,
0.0245552417,
0.0000015848,
-0.0289718397,
-0.0020276117,
-0.0119838491,
-0.0005355194,
0.0159550961,
0.0292280484,
0.029371636,
0.0012365817,
0.0168763194,
-0.0389561839,
0.0477508232,
0.037311092,
0.0726346895,
0.0641568825,
0.0694625601,
0.0128294565,
-0.0484157801,
-0.0371485949,
0.0052764234,
0.0268362984,
-0.017110683,
0.0358803682,
-0.0213241559,
0.0255440138,
-0.019972669,
-0.042557627,
0.0407443419,
0.0385512933,
0.0345813558,
-0.058887817,
0.0389224067,
-0.0603935197,
0.0356962085,
-0.0089476435,
0.0789801925,
0.0327594243,
-0.0181793924,
-0.0223249979,
0.0338272043,
-0.0071963202,
0.0159667786,
-0.0268119983,
-0.0003053045,
-0.0086093685,
-0.0221277382,
-0.0347748399,
-0.0017175252,
-0.0193621274,
0.0337616727,
-0.0125577645,
0.062037155,
0.0408664942,
-0.0451451465,
0.0068878778,
-0.0027644804,
-0.0987201631,
-0.0402590521,
0.0276869833,
0.0252772365,
-0.0004603871,
0.0353853032,
-0.0078155147,
0.0088718375,
0.0185219627,
-0.0405144207,
0.0080465144,
0.0623550899,
-0.0265154839,
0.0652956218,
-0.0157332513,
0.0036301105,
-0.0304533951,
0.0276233554,
-0.0662710145,
-0.031050615,
-0.0447711125,
-0.0286843758,
-0.0798309967,
0.027447585,
-0.0531691462,
-0.0119755445,
0.0014862227,
0.0194553658,
0.0028665303,
-0.0217687543,
0.0143115018,
0.0746364817,
-0.0381198041,
-0.006939128,
-0.0613226965,
0.0174266044,
-0.0814681873,
0.0138589591,
-0.0518669635,
-0.0312368535,
0.0077075819,
0.0053825928,
0.0186993591,
-0.0465432741,
0.0366573632,
0.0731445178,
-0.0067867413,
-0.0442635678,
-0.0186038669,
0.0021523475,
-0.030914858,
-0.0676898435,
-0.0193892624,
-0.0246231835,
0.0342306159,
0.0113223707,
-0.0226528831,
-0.0285356119,
0.0435694009,
0.0479943044,
-0.030953886,
0.0504819565,
0.0246662721,
0.0045786039,
0.0208280738,
0.0088864053,
-0.0585139319,
0.0518812351,
0.0597306713,
0.0213838965,
0.0320579261,
0.0062834187,
-0.0070932461,
0.0097639058,
0.0156914126,
0.0110703744,
-0.0522892587,
0.0678747892,
-0.0407613106,
0.0319032744,
-0.0148849776,
0.0837683156,
-0.0028424237,
-0.0332655869,
0.0556241684,
0.0410391092,
-0.0632231757,
0.0282157045,
0.0713735074,
0.0254500601,
0.0294359438,
0.031639263,
-0.0363188088,
0.0207257774,
-0.0419876203,
-0.0005034083,
-0.0073316265,
-0.0004604338,
-0.0366352685,
-0.0228115246,
-0.0262537543,
0.0180967264,
0.0309016034,
0.0082941959,
0.0173947439,
0.002999505,
-0.0591008179,
0.0226407275,
-0.004791446,
-0.023784209,
-0.0115646496,
-0.0254465286,
0.0514065661,
0.0555779748,
0.0642614067,
-0.0218146443,
-0.0028983802,
-0.0216942653,
-0.0072832191,
0.0748940334,
0.0148650445,
-0.0029072391,
0.0075395126,
-0.0026316298,
0.0185077731,
-0.027925266,
0.013437042,
0.0245085396,
0.0169077981,
0.0346489809,
-0.0065239044,
-0.0578735359,
0.0239827689,
0.0092854667,
0.0162528418,
-0.0457113087,
0.0058036507,
0.0167706534,
0.0132362265,
0.0241813511,
-0.0254721791,
0.0107298112,
0.0127493702,
-0.0445758365,
-0.0837020576,
0.0277159959,
-0.0462559536,
-0.0375611559,
0.0325794742,
-0.0508954935,
-0.0414186157,
0.0374962017,
-0.0219302997,
-0.0326781534,
0.0055451496,
-0.0582795143,
0.0734524503,
-0.0630654991,
-0.0272338204,
0.0003665966,
-0.0001894507,
-0.0358467698,
0.0809119195,
0.0071178549,
0.0345404223,
0.005508577,
0.0001937446,
0.0017499737,
-0.0057810522,
-0.0473368056,
-0.0263923034,
0.0225242842,
0.0380781703,
0.0121351825,
0.0137159592,
-0.0493734777,
-0.0277172159,
-0.1138716042,
0.0156876817,
-0.0369113721,
0.0182542149,
0.0414471477,
-0.0079451408,
-0.0363728665,
-0.0139091127,
-0.0468106382,
-0.0403687321,
-0.0108014783,
0.0367810503,
0.032313101,
0.0117763774,
-0.0104707861,
-0.020365309,
0.0117298616,
-0.0476480126,
0.0391195156,
-0.0156615209,
0.0290654358,
-0.0035070116,
-0.0274946224,
-0.0868502334,
0.0255071558,
0.0296668876,
-0.0489014499,
-0.0033449943,
0.0191687606,
0.0408556052,
0.0484291241,
0.0187051538,
-0.0164609589,
0.0314220861,
-0.016002275,
-0.0374788567,
0.0544747077,
-0.0162194613,
-0.017939603,
-0.0013347565,
-0.047708489,
0.0132057844,
0.0432468355,
0.0370345898,
-0.0182927176,
-0.0693208054,
0.0344492495,
-0.0097894594,
-0.0099916095,
-0.0260771513,
0.0120207136,
-0.020854773,
0.0580438934,
-0.002695851,
0.0237356797,
0.0845546573,
-0.00174621,
-0.0303451493,
-0.0705068782,
0.0378907323,
-0.0393938683,
0.0574131422,
-0.0247180648,
0.0449117757,
0.020291267,
-0.0194152016,
-0.0487992801,
-0.038533926,
-0.00575659,
-0.0519106686,
0.0552117378,
-0.0371628068,
0.0145656327,
0.0150931608,
-0.0296234917,
-0.0563443303,
-0.0283497553,
-0.0457365923,
0.007777832,
-0.0223980527,
0.0296011716,
-0.0283113122,
0.0076930551,
-0.0144187054,
0.0031063366,
-0.0241990127,
-0.0287043918,
-0.028377844,
0.0680103451,
0.0704042166,
0.0377006792,
0.028151067,
0.0231867582,
0.0251082722,
0.0510192066,
-0.03578135,
-0.0057474324,
-0.0085128685,
0.0026699095,
-0.004513755,
-0.0679548308,
0.0341771729,
0.0149744041,
0.013283832,
-0.0305357035,
-0.0328377187,
0.0944906473,
0.0744970515,
-0.0015099092,
0.0022309257,
-0.0398353375,
0.0211795047,
0.0197433922,
0.0415745527,
-0.096761629,
-0.0554618835,
-0.0239752401,
0.004900509,
-0.0089590093,
-0.0261406396,
-0.0342248678,
-0.1216678545,
0.0110689513,
-0.0403031819,
-0.0090725264,
-0.0191867929,
0.0037786784,
0.0212418921,
0.0134749897,
0.0219128132,
-0.0054304926,
-0.0117574139,
0.0175906997,
-0.0143909119,
0.0347623713,
-0.0221868251,
0.0671331435,
-0.0119881341,
0.0011954323,
0.0393620171,
0.0501720048,
-0.0236609913,
-0.0062396568,
-0.0017512277,
-0.0394915044,
-0.0105880601,
-0.0117368503,
0.0164987687,
-0.0028049576,
0.0105024306,
-0.0295686964,
0.0012960035,
-0.0329108238,
0.0208026227,
0.0355495363,
0.0531470291,
-0.0018155554,
-0.0244727153,
-0.0367411226,
0.0351837501,
-0.0118775796,
0.1043085828,
0.0361191072,
-0.0550420024,
-0.0437860228,
-0.0517147593,
-0.0659616664,
-0.0270096287,
-0.0258167293,
-0.0128799202,
-0.0181894153,
0.0136872334,
-0.0921364874,
-0.0343845338,
0.0238194093,
0.0280003101,
0.0139033785,
-0.0165203623,
-0.0020162379,
0.0260648336,
-0.0426160172,
0.0145108756,
-0.0248816423,
0.0056876759,
-0.0525673032,
0.0131123094,
0.0589807406,
-0.02976414,
-0.028468838,
0.0029395148,
-0.0488330573,
-0.0399137139,
-0.0134157883,
0.0382852778,
0.0255006123,
-0.0041675642,
-0.0341811739,
-0.0275581162,
0.0266735237,
0.03960016,
-0.0237231608,
0.0082687959,
0.0394069515,
0.0803589895,
0.0119742537,
0.0572439693,
-0.0410663486,
0.0164026115,
0.0038294944,
0.0820654854,
-0.0241660867,
0.0204841159,
0.0375240594,
0.0104021095,
-0.0142722428,
0.0355951041,
-0.0086674914,
0.0201531667,
0.0241797231,
-0.0184043273,
-0.0338929296,
-0.0292749144,
-0.0016507395,
0.0173855033,
-0.0152033642,
-0.0610549711,
-0.0194177292,
-0.0419231094,
0.0402793661,
-0.032968279,
-0.0264378712,
0.0666782185,
-0.007874338,
-0.0157563351,
-0.0182971247,
-0.039294675,
-0.0221348666,
0.0258332156,
0.0600967444,
0.0060637663,
0.0666202381,
0.0215551574,
-0.0066424962,
-0.0250435919,
0.0248865858,
-0.0512568429,
-0.0485544279,
0.0270770304,
0.0387464091,
0.0216579922,
-0.0016312347,
0.0144404927,
-0.0270350222,
-0.0118077956,
0.0083644222,
0.0008447484,
0.0365600362,
-0.0156691428,
0.0559420846,
0.0109726358,
0.0022549499,
-0.0015700058,
0.0270547047,
-0.0597319119,
0.0419314951,
0.0327917375,
-0.0256148539,
-0.033170633,
-0.0159761794,
0.0041056084,
-0.0079062637,
0.0100898575,
0.0586341135,
-0.0817777067,
-0.0516287088,
0.0653967336,
-0.0244310312,
0.0004476011,
-0.0433881953,
0.0400597565,
0.041049391,
0.0411906019,
-0.0173519589,
-0.0317032859,
0.0402102917,
-0.0223582331,
-0.0011583728,
-0.0639788732,
-5.91690812e-33,
-0.0306994505,
-0.0083232401,
-0.014023493,
-0.0324612297,
0.0026454672,
0.0233783443,
-0.0383322276,
0.0115944901,
-0.0029607827,
0.0100060515,
-0.0336268917,
0.0175762437,
0.0037087912,
0.0194215514,
-0.0071262862,
-0.0643496513,
0.0161925517,
-0.0057845144,
-0.0457090326,
-0.0064137601,
0.0351529643,
0.0265371092,
0.0257660616,
-0.0338403657,
0.0138394497,
-0.0064033372,
-0.0258329082,
0.0165209044,
0.0050350637,
0.0481882915,
-0.0397937149,
0.0642771348,
0.0213629864,
0.0041039772,
0.02910042,
0.0316204354,
-0.060803283,
-0.0535859354,
0.0354957655,
-0.0189980362,
-0.0511641055,
0.0100350864,
0.0200720262,
0.0044529834,
0.0166451633,
0.0451948307,
0.0332920328,
-0.0287221186,
0.0136677809,
-0.0600200891,
-0.0569398291,
-0.0056352704,
-0.0238841977,
-0.0314177983,
-0.0295330938,
0.0655557141,
0.0116766598,
0.0551452935,
-0.0432454385,
-0.0228673872,
-0.0216913298,
-0.0308179613,
0.0111842109,
-0.0637650415,
-0.0080637457,
0.0379270241,
-0.0245534293,
-0.0133803729,
-0.026383806,
-0.0021663774,
-0.0039984719,
0.0150553863,
0.0603670962,
0.0535463989,
0.0321994387,
0.0221899077,
-0.0181897655,
0.0336495973,
0.0565464981,
0.0049570887,
0.0523225032,
-0.038530156,
-0.0378898866,
0.0200862307,
-0.0225188918,
0.0420487821,
-0.044696901,
-0.0119804088,
0.030731203,
-0.006832852,
-0.0593815669,
-0.0288908295,
0.0076768487,
-0.0391800106,
0.0135145215,
0.026931027,
-0.0201038364,
0.0001536108,
0.0138235362,
0.0537837334,
-0.0252357759,
0.0152812684,
0.0235041399,
-0.0072637559,
-0.029903369,
0.0070804157,
0.0281409808,
0.0175991487,
-0.0750002488,
0.0243554153,
-0.0194905158,
0.033136107,
-0.0391712561,
0.01529375,
0.0071280994,
0.0333093889,
0.0047193347,
0.0291679613,
0.0234746523,
0.0070164506,
-0.0502686016,
0.0391014442,
-0.0028623545,
0.0145092793,
-0.0477549694,
0.0094784489,
-0.0101855081,
-0.0292360485,
-0.0492419116,
-0.0863575414,
-0.0103485165,
0.0146732526,
2.429e-7,
0.0705431998,
0.0197136402,
0.0326457396,
0.0797143281,
0.0110044349,
0.0317480266,
0.0267850757,
0.0387775227,
0.0290609896,
-0.004939531,
0.0047409087,
0.0044503277,
-0.0086182998,
0.0401201472,
-0.0956420228,
0.0129513163,
-0.0615714304,
0.0168398451,
-0.0419921577,
0.0000487649,
0.0797096044,
0.0648143962,
0.0036349664,
0.0036919087,
-0.0228879899,
-0.0504380092,
0.0638301149,
-0.0112523437,
0.0307142343,
0.0129207876,
0.0141043635,
0.002997048,
0.0168566033,
0.0237851236,
0.0218632314,
0.0217464063,
0.0316960961,
0.0618507043,
0.0080572469,
-0.0726096258,
-0.0046343966,
-0.0616689026,
0.0191752687,
-0.0453527644,
0.0907039791,
-0.0557902604,
-0.0146912625,
0.0370470956,
-0.02299143,
-0.0188198388,
0.0398531966,
-0.0269181728,
-0.0542617552,
0.0172456857,
0.035334181,
-0.0147901345,
0.0303319376,
-0.068400383,
0.0035660525,
-0.0250996836,
-0.0258251335,
-0.0310467649,
0.0135057699,
0.0066087218,
-0.0197248328,
-0.0936723351,
-0.0057024332,
1.997248702e-34,
0.0820638388,
-0.0006861012,
0.0133354664,
0.0313725434,
0.0373152569,
0.0253583323,
0.0379635543,
-0.0598310456,
0.0344824642,
-0.0491137877,
-0.0257533528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13734v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13734v2 | Prompting and Fine-Tuning Open-Sourced Large Language Models for Stance Classification | 2023-09-24T19:36:17 | 2024-03-05T21:26:54 | Iain J. Cruickshank, Lynnette Hui Xian Ng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Stance classification, the task of predicting the viewpoint of an author on a
subject of interest, has long been a focal point of research in domains ranging
from social science to machine learning. Current stance detection methods rely
predominantly on manual annotation of sentences, followed by training a
supervised machine learning model. However, this manual annotation process
requires laborious annotation effort, and thus hampers its potential to
generalize across different contexts. In this work, we investigate the use of
Large Language Models (LLMs) as a stance detection methodology that can reduce
or even eliminate the need for manual annotations. We investigate 10
open-source models and 7 prompting schemes, finding that LLMs are competitive
with in-domain supervised models but are not necessarily consistent in their
performance. We also fine-tuned the LLMs, but discovered that fine-tuning
process does not necessarily lead to better performance. In general, we
discover that LLMs do not routinely outperform their smaller supervised machine
learning models, and thus call for stance detection to be a benchmark for which
LLMs also optimize for. The code used in this study is available at
\url{https://github.com/ijcruic/LLM-Stance-Labeling} | [
0.0409593284,
0.0542096943,
0.0379478671,
0.0544433333,
-0.0401590876,
0.0240602475,
0.0250891391,
-0.0276124682,
0.0210913457,
-0.0852524862,
-0.0025450774,
-0.0110623492,
-0.0367407463,
-0.0110634128,
-0.0126981093,
0.0102080712,
0.0403400771,
0.0123511227,
0.0563457981,
-0.0131009202,
0.0342971012,
0.0538211018,
-0.0355137661,
0.0468770154,
0.0041001448,
-0.0708777681,
0.0132333683,
-0.0235294253,
0.0642041788,
-0.0002758554,
0.0394332036,
0.0580183752,
0.0010387767,
0.0577035956,
0.0000017368,
-0.0570502654,
-0.0303439479,
-0.0235772319,
0.0085982308,
0.0137825767,
-0.0061135469,
-0.0391723551,
-0.0054897275,
0.0176792033,
-0.0581058599,
-0.0085156253,
0.0242915619,
0.0520501882,
0.0534332506,
0.0708117336,
0.0110048596,
-0.0269830283,
0.013736886,
-0.0213679094,
-0.0418810025,
-0.0215632077,
0.0495361388,
-0.0166012533,
-0.0577743985,
0.0975874141,
-0.012157212,
0.0046826368,
0.0110307448,
-0.0328197256,
-0.0088695521,
-0.0053736381,
-0.0004834238,
-0.0101456195,
-0.0055649173,
0.0379933938,
0.0441727117,
-0.0208069608,
0.0210492294,
-0.0296771061,
0.0051852642,
0.0490914695,
-0.0027679116,
0.0481021479,
-0.0483141616,
0.0138172144,
0.0389724374,
-0.0050322446,
0.0212656427,
0.066554673,
0.0154601811,
0.0691780001,
-0.0390539318,
-0.0043797451,
0.0449416265,
0.0147806872,
-0.0083728051,
-0.0686360523,
0.004735081,
0.0181609001,
0.0150115062,
0.0319068655,
-0.0268381163,
0.0302848332,
0.0352004915,
-0.0575852245,
-0.0100583509,
-0.0053270292,
0.0016640768,
0.0557315201,
0.0002731643,
-0.0004375991,
-0.0465615913,
-0.0268269219,
-0.0078174546,
0.0441618301,
-0.0513423756,
-0.0146371303,
-0.0099306358,
0.0259336885,
-0.0425111614,
-0.0261695553,
-0.0370764919,
0.0080828741,
-0.0112073496,
0.0000851781,
-0.003562253,
-0.0243174713,
0.0241625905,
0.022834979,
-0.018989265,
0.0566936992,
0.0058407718,
0.0067482525,
-0.0201372318,
-0.023823088,
0.0067926748,
0.0335841626,
-0.0136190522,
-0.0157672204,
0.0163897388,
-0.0289820414,
0.0457240194,
-0.0120750824,
0.0203810725,
-0.0126246,
-0.0394099839,
-0.075220339,
-0.0237602331,
-0.0891819224,
0.0049515073,
0.0295496937,
0.0136151575,
-0.0702696592,
0.0100888563,
0.0320924483,
0.0062811924,
0.0627549365,
0.0183394011,
-0.0211987756,
0.0342603698,
0.0111515922,
0.0280343685,
0.0862957686,
-0.0121319639,
-0.0121872695,
0.0319129862,
0.0042175259,
-0.0062112869,
0.0331797339,
0.0166921113,
0.0208297204,
0.0405379273,
0.0397594385,
-0.0110519081,
0.0147871058,
-0.0024471802,
0.0435636789,
0.0214704033,
-0.0356808044,
0.0659869462,
0.047434248,
-0.0246024188,
0.000935622,
0.0340767652,
0.0216680449,
0.0565686077,
-0.0305594821,
-0.0187863093,
0.0070887515,
-0.0042814235,
-0.0277285445,
-0.0250718258,
0.0208371133,
-0.0107425898,
-0.0521806218,
-0.0311302803,
-0.0034677028,
-0.0086374953,
0.017519867,
0.0300160125,
-0.0112703238,
-0.0485068709,
0.0327056535,
0.0212656651,
-0.0469632261,
-0.0232744925,
-0.0374516957,
0.0469356403,
-0.0071911402,
-0.0045964727,
-0.0425259061,
-0.0429980904,
-0.0655559674,
0.0177575257,
0.0459090658,
0.0501322709,
-0.0339677334,
-0.0356508084,
-0.0092630424,
-0.0026976566,
-0.0278442893,
0.0011008929,
0.025716804,
0.0074232104,
0.0096451733,
0.0118265189,
0.0106118796,
0.0094726551,
0.0444497094,
0.0052009644,
-0.0012112544,
0.0018547337,
0.0222702529,
0.049859114,
0.0626933053,
0.0063725836,
-0.0301505607,
0.032836508,
-0.0333073549,
-0.0368088111,
-0.0003320573,
-0.0094448319,
-0.0624347068,
0.0457731076,
0.0001107353,
-0.0507128984,
0.0308304187,
-0.0303972978,
-0.0059409211,
-0.0222312249,
0.0038256519,
-0.036343012,
-0.058549948,
-0.0276515335,
-0.0393942259,
-0.0026583206,
-0.0612284392,
0.0621624254,
0.0015153122,
0.0266448762,
0.0155523773,
-0.0334074832,
0.0449889004,
-0.01393821,
-0.0436996296,
-0.0252135545,
0.0119766593,
0.0073593012,
0.0408834182,
-0.0033446758,
-0.025253484,
-0.0238240566,
-0.1253409684,
0.0058851838,
-0.0309719797,
0.0358234271,
0.0059811641,
-0.01305799,
0.0060982625,
0.0307541285,
-0.0335419178,
-0.048946891,
-0.0331133269,
0.0183192398,
0.0347239897,
-0.0129584894,
-0.0043240921,
-0.0215675384,
0.0251469556,
-0.0206828639,
0.0389473736,
0.0397686176,
-0.0503599569,
-0.0467866436,
0.0102421176,
-0.0442601219,
-0.0170057844,
-0.0066218926,
-0.0344500169,
0.0246821512,
0.0001015443,
-0.0040792553,
0.0615486875,
0.0156251471,
0.0619880445,
0.0071307146,
0.0589265637,
-0.0469605178,
-0.0067924317,
-0.0219780281,
0.0268036835,
-0.0234405529,
0.0131275058,
0.031514328,
0.0565056689,
-0.008859246,
-0.0350140631,
-0.046019271,
0.0412366018,
-0.0299332123,
-0.014470581,
0.012296238,
-0.0064450782,
-0.0136854621,
-0.0002458983,
-0.002893663,
-0.0185846351,
0.0577958934,
-0.0118365446,
0.0147261862,
-0.0390096679,
-0.0192887336,
-0.0625877008,
0.0366906933,
0.02185845,
0.003779056,
0.016118573,
0.0246742144,
0.0160072912,
0.0047458401,
0.0109245228,
-0.0144049795,
0.0130255874,
-0.011280953,
0.0521233231,
-0.0142728901,
-0.0437590368,
-0.012033375,
-0.0864545554,
-0.0731950849,
-0.0156184994,
-0.0142085077,
-0.0105313985,
0.0501010641,
0.0277711023,
-0.0031462067,
0.0271737278,
-0.0287680663,
-0.0028214697,
0.0053057573,
-0.0005754119,
0.0084938314,
-0.031357415,
0.0010478366,
-0.0261733308,
0.0136885336,
0.0636809319,
-0.0272769481,
0.0539577119,
-0.0358011313,
-0.0396991,
0.030419847,
-0.0296290908,
-0.0138126332,
-0.0307459664,
0.0959104225,
-0.0427051894,
0.0089576468,
0.1147033945,
0.0451158956,
-0.0551038608,
-0.006047267,
0.0357682742,
-0.0136308689,
0.0236804783,
-0.0108922375,
-0.0656116083,
-0.0425001197,
-0.0192273185,
0.0255796891,
-0.03249285,
-0.0168314036,
0.0036280998,
-0.0906089917,
0.0019629765,
-0.0377710983,
-0.0727747753,
-0.0049772318,
-0.062423192,
0.0350391418,
-0.0368417688,
-0.0310708545,
0.0032299841,
0.0028823221,
0.0143284826,
0.0339592434,
-0.0448846072,
-0.0072244601,
-0.0059000021,
-0.0541932657,
0.0200139005,
0.0324275084,
0.0360207595,
0.0071179247,
-0.0131676495,
0.0576144047,
-0.0367026366,
-0.0045805979,
-0.0314435326,
0.031961482,
-0.0416155122,
-0.0060217711,
-0.0261736047,
0.0669490546,
-0.0427337997,
0.0083107147,
0.0119175147,
0.0380423367,
0.0039308313,
0.0391239896,
-0.0246548709,
0.0516544767,
0.0254554823,
0.0600417033,
0.0080538085,
-0.0762109905,
-0.0398694314,
-0.0500637889,
-0.0233875606,
-0.0557876267,
-0.0481623784,
-0.0225827917,
-0.0104302866,
0.012971513,
-0.0488608889,
-0.0208998527,
-0.0092009967,
0.0162913743,
0.0018353988,
0.027248187,
0.0269509722,
0.0466072187,
-0.0432194695,
0.0431999266,
-0.0033059649,
0.0473744348,
-0.0403399765,
-0.017039571,
0.0920069516,
-0.0034718593,
-0.0268043038,
-0.0159534626,
-0.0752019808,
-0.0566548072,
-0.0235891379,
0.0241481606,
0.0100516239,
0.0371094421,
0.0006504115,
-0.0304656662,
-0.0002329656,
0.0915752053,
0.0107971597,
0.0399958119,
0.0438343324,
0.0529842339,
-0.0284372456,
0.0216534771,
-0.0039286814,
-0.0027754263,
0.0461436473,
-0.015843682,
-0.0398996286,
-0.0361497067,
0.0053135399,
-0.0006794694,
0.0513423756,
0.0125389788,
-0.0487600267,
-0.0105337044,
0.0018281355,
-0.0068724402,
-0.0726451576,
-0.024378892,
0.0096670045,
0.0221869424,
-0.0568418838,
-0.0533496588,
0.0691780895,
-0.0103365472,
0.0993516594,
-0.0628235489,
0.0678297356,
0.0421842672,
0.0195544977,
-0.0211629793,
-0.0311068706,
-0.0385187641,
-0.0272699073,
0.0114074983,
-0.0027533695,
0.0299829729,
0.0696036667,
0.0337880999,
0.0172459744,
0.0300736055,
0.0091001568,
-0.0610293224,
-0.0052331984,
-0.01104673,
0.0361738577,
0.0180069823,
-0.0167343747,
0.0576605685,
-0.0120603992,
-0.0313924849,
-0.0456957333,
0.0509088486,
-0.0182435885,
-0.0108992374,
0.0531696416,
0.0182608347,
-0.0143967588,
0.0122432169,
0.0124387126,
-0.0154678654,
0.0182440076,
0.0604602732,
-0.0338566564,
-0.0398908891,
-0.0118286507,
-0.0227240901,
-0.0047228867,
0.0138673112,
0.0259086415,
-0.0592363253,
-0.0137681728,
0.0202352758,
0.0074156621,
0.0019929265,
0.0103681758,
-0.0133522078,
0.0751903057,
0.0007121199,
-0.0043039103,
-0.0950038955,
0.0326925516,
-0.0296287872,
-0.0332520232,
-0.0303024072,
-5.527058357e-33,
-0.0055993674,
-0.0503502563,
-0.028310664,
0.0275415033,
-0.0072385725,
0.0128054842,
0.0062714927,
0.0096568894,
-0.027568996,
0.0442642756,
0.0067938035,
0.0273979232,
-0.0049937707,
0.0311734956,
-0.0181170404,
0.0027179432,
0.0132865235,
-0.0118199242,
-0.0572919361,
0.0006915533,
0.0384804085,
-0.0254928488,
0.0188274235,
-0.0649808869,
0.06579528,
-0.0291092191,
-0.0406313688,
0.0164747629,
-0.0338150412,
0.072416611,
-0.0086797914,
0.0130438711,
0.0492220037,
-0.0409186482,
0.0391059779,
0.0696364716,
-0.0599672049,
0.0253628511,
0.0128653869,
0.0223879889,
0.0023763443,
-0.0300607886,
0.0157303102,
0.0099075735,
-0.0276515279,
-0.0004564863,
0.0475145876,
-0.0289538931,
0.0227299072,
-0.0783216059,
-0.0414827242,
0.0361674689,
-0.0328404903,
-0.0354541615,
-0.0281709302,
0.0352245905,
0.0135532869,
0.0645892546,
-0.0242490452,
-0.0031306208,
-0.0549014024,
0.0088995555,
-0.0161824711,
0.0144368233,
0.0015975228,
0.0537888408,
-0.0164763872,
0.009038181,
-0.0389150977,
0.0075737513,
0.0033466262,
-0.0247318,
0.0711442679,
0.060818404,
0.000759687,
0.0246480554,
-0.0925101563,
0.0064403052,
0.0627429485,
-0.0290641952,
0.0364437625,
-0.0160705093,
-0.0033024945,
-0.014671701,
-0.0372397229,
-0.0565019846,
-0.026235871,
0.0325494967,
-0.0115129417,
-0.0083968546,
-0.0864915326,
0.0108745629,
0.0261033233,
-0.0553576499,
-0.0360178128,
0.0668087155,
-0.0271220934,
0.0435491763,
-0.0025408231,
0.011128475,
-0.0532741733,
-0.0003330495,
-0.0285152942,
0.0034196861,
0.0399943292,
-0.0272584688,
0.0896932781,
-0.0207186509,
-0.0640829206,
-0.0251324642,
-0.0181308053,
0.0223860163,
-0.0473327823,
0.1115609854,
0.0253813639,
-0.0095988726,
-0.0002540234,
0.0788043737,
-0.0046946239,
-0.0042523379,
-0.0490272492,
-0.0088582803,
-0.0222344194,
0.0061536697,
-0.0333563127,
-0.0265567843,
0.0313877799,
0.0542449653,
-0.0504388362,
-0.0711828992,
0.0035325047,
0.0145548172,
2.376e-7,
0.0384351239,
0.0424940586,
-0.0043755434,
-0.026314782,
0.050796479,
0.0526678115,
0.0167290606,
0.0207581054,
0.0112073468,
-0.0313072205,
-0.0356014222,
0.0424458049,
0.0601411723,
-0.0134432865,
-0.106072925,
0.0085415766,
-0.0371241756,
0.0069790562,
-0.023391474,
0.0294574257,
-0.0077326973,
0.0596385635,
0.0255754013,
0.0132778231,
0.0164400097,
-0.0085239634,
0.0600436889,
0.0015099876,
-0.0095053138,
0.0310273673,
0.0157378595,
-0.0530241691,
0.0076152971,
0.0004903274,
-0.0012519122,
0.0248258356,
0.00308327,
0.1071057171,
0.0232770797,
-0.0033409714,
-0.0133839082,
0.0117733516,
0.0216822419,
-0.0250481106,
0.0790507495,
-0.0302200038,
-0.0179541223,
-0.0731007159,
-0.0121044023,
-0.0145478612,
0.051430475,
0.011349679,
0.0038817995,
0.0364729203,
-0.0159195922,
-0.0685466453,
0.0024460827,
-0.0625894368,
-0.0448253341,
-0.0321220681,
-0.0236062557,
-0.0512736365,
0.043146003,
-0.0249318741,
0.0173986293,
-0.0619938262,
-0.0150355333,
1.878079748e-34,
0.0376895331,
-0.0280216858,
-0.0114512676,
0.0068082418,
0.0263247713,
0.0255145002,
-0.0250447318,
0.0160106719,
0.0172774661,
-0.0365963355,
0.0088139074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13731v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13731v2 | Arabic Sentiment Analysis with Noisy Deep Explainable Model | 2023-09-24T19:26:53 | 2023-11-29T11:52:58 | Md. Atabuzzaman, Md Shajalal, Maksuda Bilkis Baby, Alexander Boden | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Sentiment Analysis (SA) is an indispensable task for many real-world
applications. Compared to limited resourced languages (i.e., Arabic, Bengali),
most of the research on SA are conducted for high resourced languages (i.e.,
English, Chinese). Moreover, the reasons behind any prediction of the Arabic
sentiment analysis methods exploiting advanced artificial intelligence
(AI)-based approaches are like black-box - quite difficult to understand. This
paper proposes an explainable sentiment classification framework for the Arabic
language by introducing a noise layer on Bi-Directional Long Short-Term Memory
(BiLSTM) and Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN)-BiLSTM models that overcome
over-fitting problem. The proposed framework can explain specific predictions
by training a local surrogate explainable model to understand why a particular
sentiment (positive or negative) is being predicted. We carried out experiments
on public benchmark Arabic SA datasets. The results concluded that adding noise
layers improves the performance in sentiment analysis for the Arabic language
by reducing overfitting and our method outperformed some known state-of-the-art
methods. In addition, the introduced explainability with noise layer could make
the model more transparent and accountable and hence help adopting AI-enabled
system in practice. | [
0.0022609965,
0.0777957737,
-0.0061426298,
0.0411395691,
0.0085410178,
0.0347206742,
0.048910372,
-0.0152117191,
0.0020578902,
-0.0054144152,
0.0000947972,
-0.0422104746,
-0.0179243572,
0.0340157151,
-0.0054263133,
-0.0011667721,
0.009643659,
-0.0005089312,
0.0547057204,
-0.0167954806,
0.0340165757,
0.0166596752,
-0.0020470256,
0.0023615488,
-0.0035984158,
-0.0165484473,
-0.0492315516,
-0.0215537958,
-0.0272966735,
0.0192068294,
0.0113859195,
0.0193412229,
0.0022639558,
0.0087622292,
0.0000021874,
-0.0149859237,
-0.0526725277,
0.0013600702,
-0.053644266,
-0.007246057,
0.0123657892,
-0.0125695774,
-0.0156517103,
-0.009983018,
-0.0116195818,
0.0302697737,
0.0508836508,
0.0891203657,
0.056442216,
0.0490207262,
-0.0075029046,
-0.0526159257,
0.0011947529,
-0.0124681778,
0.0257047936,
-0.0281333718,
-0.026278412,
-0.0274942536,
-0.0494448878,
-0.021744946,
-0.036158897,
0.0006994895,
0.019314155,
-0.0383397155,
0.0113703441,
-0.0481552295,
0.0165292379,
-0.0043293685,
0.0449270867,
0.0507545806,
-0.0342455767,
-0.0402402133,
-0.0088736089,
-0.013572447,
-0.0081605762,
-0.0042434321,
-0.0215114001,
0.0172471348,
0.0146083878,
0.0447982699,
0.0368559435,
0.0236603655,
0.0558482483,
0.0418198705,
-0.0259340182,
0.0355578251,
-0.046249751,
-0.0284498446,
-0.0164402761,
0.0363898501,
0.0269693881,
0.0097119901,
0.0297074709,
-0.0017668629,
-0.014849917,
0.0084727779,
0.0252434276,
-0.0175955184,
-0.0185921919,
-0.0802447051,
-0.0057672597,
0.037692856,
-0.0519462116,
0.0401596203,
-0.0501040816,
0.0260358993,
-0.0103484737,
0.0000656916,
-0.0028899268,
-0.0365932323,
-0.0478958599,
-0.0021076342,
0.0366770849,
0.0427734368,
-0.0408937484,
0.0340449885,
-0.0745274574,
-0.0207664911,
-0.0756675228,
0.0116012394,
0.0212952122,
0.0180201121,
0.0093725426,
-0.0401514471,
-0.0312515534,
-0.0116274618,
-0.0446213633,
0.0216744598,
-0.0386026837,
-0.0468411557,
0.0162577629,
0.0679000467,
0.0181561448,
0.0297531486,
0.0140187321,
0.0545254871,
0.0303099565,
-0.0199914593,
-0.0708354488,
-0.0209018905,
-0.0040869205,
-0.0413069427,
0.0235696025,
-0.0166013706,
0.0158228334,
-0.0309938621,
-0.0174220558,
-0.0145491185,
-0.008677911,
-0.0214210395,
0.000172281,
0.0905459821,
0.0021979208,
-0.032839153,
0.0142030427,
0.0079569062,
0.0638209581,
0.0279321633,
0.0346294455,
0.0231251977,
0.0304431636,
-0.0385942459,
0.0371034257,
-0.0404532216,
0.060675256,
-0.0255318414,
-0.0471614189,
-0.0235561188,
-0.0717715025,
0.0239958167,
0.0112023624,
-0.0183128323,
0.0159967523,
-0.0147501575,
0.0247463062,
-0.0293880906,
0.0092654089,
0.0837264732,
-0.0018602515,
0.0135009987,
-0.0332632214,
0.0119014876,
-0.0083209323,
0.0822554678,
-0.0058385036,
0.0002751648,
0.0285671689,
-0.0015119718,
-0.0484097078,
-0.0900407508,
0.0217432845,
-0.0608989745,
0.0254062172,
0.0274736062,
0.0774413273,
-0.0042125108,
-0.0578589328,
0.0259723496,
0.0256834589,
-0.0582850873,
-0.0217214618,
-0.0877744704,
0.0564662181,
0.0754927248,
-0.0191019885,
0.0000797678,
-0.0096646473,
-0.0549247079,
-0.0031415345,
0.0437032841,
-0.00009266,
0.026917709,
0.0344186276,
-0.0623009838,
-0.0310603753,
0.0144073274,
0.0178553928,
0.0035314537,
-0.0216527581,
0.0183479898,
0.0068951892,
-0.0186229963,
-0.0603676625,
-0.00150386,
-0.0126718245,
-0.0471200794,
0.0110116834,
0.028380977,
0.0640301928,
0.0595333204,
-0.0070224069,
-0.0175233297,
0.0226314012,
-0.0337862484,
-0.0434277132,
0.0473174602,
-0.0421891622,
-0.0092747891,
-0.0083145546,
-0.0149435876,
0.0082202386,
0.048734989,
-0.0330978446,
-0.0645256042,
0.0690309629,
-0.0104455659,
0.0347478651,
-0.0335707106,
0.0107462117,
-0.0131360339,
0.0251373406,
0.0102152312,
0.0172129367,
-0.013358403,
-0.0204954036,
-0.0486443155,
-0.0004960449,
0.0436555631,
0.0356543548,
-0.0343708657,
0.0281118061,
0.010058715,
-0.0099616591,
0.02054286,
-0.0292530656,
-0.0031590846,
-0.0223623049,
-0.041460745,
-0.0227336921,
-0.0294037648,
0.0042010956,
-0.0287490003,
0.0028487975,
0.0197350141,
-0.0004737203,
-0.049164582,
0.0193547029,
-0.0126732904,
0.0061411932,
0.0572536103,
-0.0346858799,
0.0151745323,
-0.058099024,
-0.0107576791,
-0.0035037114,
0.04255132,
0.0193721037,
-0.0321180858,
-0.0039678658,
0.0005843246,
-0.0133196339,
0.0032063758,
-0.0183073059,
-0.0708665624,
0.0002091518,
0.0041968417,
-0.0236441325,
0.058022365,
0.0092695262,
0.0369962268,
-0.0029132487,
0.0413516983,
-0.0200980715,
0.0201378018,
-0.0320645384,
-0.0017764857,
-0.0330796838,
-0.0393300876,
-0.0553123094,
0.0481684729,
-0.0107750641,
-0.01072702,
-0.0304896664,
-0.0013599455,
-0.0109004751,
0.0178438462,
-0.0151094273,
-0.0267544575,
0.0079048863,
0.0648441985,
0.018167479,
-0.0505735427,
0.0291808266,
0.0060530058,
-0.000215982,
-0.0155826965,
-0.010694663,
-0.0422190987,
0.0310653448,
-0.0283940658,
-0.0133292545,
-0.0208690055,
0.0143358866,
-0.0176845677,
-0.0848121122,
0.0122452928,
-0.0157643482,
-0.0016197951,
-0.0153691433,
0.0013007513,
0.0058887703,
0.0019917125,
-0.0182110853,
-0.0192302,
-0.038421791,
-0.0167111289,
0.0531584695,
-0.0391390398,
0.0144916382,
0.0141762216,
0.0260987058,
-0.0088600973,
0.0009731441,
-0.0046641338,
0.0170224942,
-0.0052454234,
0.028795056,
0.0063457666,
0.060036689,
-0.0004944837,
0.009127642,
0.0007733628,
-0.0385065004,
0.0001645428,
-0.0785302818,
-0.009565874,
-0.0095853321,
-0.0125036212,
-0.0331085548,
-0.0553380921,
0.0177969728,
-0.0861732215,
0.0324729197,
0.1013529375,
0.001961851,
-0.0546562113,
-0.0015639879,
0.0121200914,
-0.0317761749,
-0.0227642115,
-0.0204999801,
-0.016439395,
-0.031712018,
0.0028172785,
0.0210945848,
-0.0043986966,
0.0064053438,
0.0280962493,
-0.0815679431,
0.0314582959,
-0.0270353239,
-0.0245412998,
-0.082102403,
-0.0325552858,
-0.0510766692,
-0.021881422,
0.0401634909,
-0.057069838,
0.0381503329,
0.0223990753,
0.0450471379,
-0.0707658976,
-0.0350087434,
0.0329073295,
0.0014784643,
0.0677161291,
0.0527229086,
0.052053377,
-0.0140398219,
-0.0166056342,
-0.0027232445,
-0.009753881,
0.0079369256,
-0.0071681845,
0.0754775926,
0.0213779248,
-0.0425921604,
-0.0418642834,
0.0005869234,
-0.0940433666,
0.0465780161,
-0.0430411063,
0.0428143889,
-0.0156284962,
-0.0034459396,
-0.0151407328,
0.0253918823,
0.0098996675,
0.0817036703,
-0.0055398415,
-0.0415178537,
-0.0463713445,
-0.0148808993,
-0.0323971733,
-0.0880819038,
-0.0014757394,
-0.0174872372,
0.0336705223,
-0.0240321849,
-0.039089106,
-0.0664268509,
-0.0494241901,
0.0333856419,
-0.0292215105,
0.0613221787,
0.004097308,
-0.0095843263,
-0.0415362231,
0.0074841077,
0.0407761522,
-0.0089300675,
-0.0013673804,
-0.0277739111,
0.0238266699,
-0.0870893747,
0.0089478688,
-0.0384832025,
-0.0409632251,
0.0182242114,
0.0202050582,
0.0145758046,
0.0158735365,
0.0452454835,
0.0020002557,
-0.0699334294,
0.0280399024,
0.0100097172,
-0.0177306663,
-0.0327647701,
0.0845526233,
0.0356058627,
0.0069871438,
0.0532504991,
0.0163887795,
0.0314584486,
0.0272927955,
-0.0741978362,
-0.0489484891,
-0.0098075094,
0.0029892141,
-0.0304847863,
0.0299893878,
0.0067954729,
-0.0695983618,
-0.044486247,
0.0217304919,
0.0124551523,
0.0185056478,
-0.0135959964,
0.0141273309,
0.013793339,
-0.0024216459,
-0.0190467872,
-0.0331486166,
-0.0113207921,
-0.0614399239,
0.0219054706,
0.0885776728,
-0.0177004561,
0.027806133,
-0.0448151566,
0.0760399178,
0.0006349899,
-0.0016369222,
0.0061385008,
0.0216100644,
0.0103591122,
0.0412636772,
-0.0197641551,
0.0487406701,
0.012233302,
0.0117343366,
-0.0084550343,
-0.0075700656,
0.0001224542,
0.0237682853,
0.030525919,
-0.0721501708,
0.0590951443,
0.016099466,
0.0369186401,
0.0211423747,
0.083376728,
0.0116572725,
-0.0013389009,
-0.0073410245,
-0.0194890015,
-0.0339797139,
-0.0240921322,
0.0649434105,
0.0001469022,
0.0004020178,
0.0158163086,
0.0123687824,
-0.0253035203,
0.015039254,
0.0402995087,
0.0246110354,
-0.0164354257,
0.0315696821,
-0.0218320284,
-0.0766731054,
0.0275121406,
-0.0510715879,
0.0359102972,
-0.0359337926,
0.028855931,
0.0749792382,
-0.0024850045,
0.0325556993,
-0.0664462224,
0.0114213107,
-0.0042125904,
0.0025424256,
-0.0098384777,
-6.499933482e-33,
0.0353807211,
-0.0583731905,
-0.0208482277,
-0.0332530886,
0.0182068013,
0.0159651972,
-0.0530009493,
0.0003220063,
-0.0292302612,
0.0609376766,
-0.0090866713,
0.0522741564,
0.0107990252,
0.0414890721,
0.03958432,
-0.0556131415,
0.0345569476,
0.016002357,
0.043083474,
0.0587226599,
0.0749189556,
0.0513818339,
0.0982145667,
-0.1300791502,
0.0599529818,
-0.0152819464,
-0.0390899032,
0.005470735,
0.0100709153,
0.0730802864,
-0.0225348212,
0.060148187,
0.0434356704,
-0.0361518078,
0.0257047415,
-0.0226845071,
-0.0002977934,
-0.0014720598,
-0.0107991342,
0.0520623811,
-0.0173870418,
-0.0355253108,
-0.0050808047,
0.0091244262,
-0.0399615616,
0.0312283523,
0.0210036729,
-0.0307619162,
0.0014242481,
-0.0204546358,
-0.0373251624,
0.0493927225,
-0.0197367948,
-0.0068003507,
0.0657829195,
0.02971581,
-0.0072790901,
0.0461944379,
-0.0702810362,
-0.0021304681,
-0.0161075555,
0.004580149,
0.0565349422,
-0.0309259761,
-0.0418737642,
0.0374255143,
0.0479590856,
0.0232190657,
-0.0175218694,
0.0447998866,
-0.0136999879,
0.0130311232,
0.1059114188,
0.0746106505,
0.0488890633,
-0.0223701838,
-0.0724220946,
0.0015009713,
0.0230057221,
-0.0071193599,
0.0707850903,
-0.0004041795,
-0.0813218877,
-0.019961467,
0.0383272655,
-0.0346739776,
-0.0135335699,
-0.0000789308,
-0.0151676117,
-0.0261049084,
-0.0198567025,
-0.0085088378,
-0.0207147691,
-0.031921804,
0.0436912067,
0.0258594062,
-0.0088772839,
-0.0171450581,
0.0266480241,
-0.0185703412,
-0.0128385099,
-0.0400706828,
-0.0589256547,
0.039012365,
0.0141803995,
0.024494702,
0.0517416745,
0.031153217,
-0.0631320328,
0.0026027248,
-0.0496868715,
-0.0063590719,
0.0014530971,
0.0678748712,
-0.0217259992,
-0.0123953046,
-0.0237677712,
0.0684749782,
0.0252007935,
0.0501034446,
0.0213552583,
-0.0404952765,
-0.0513646528,
-0.0227705296,
-0.021468373,
-0.0490348563,
-0.0115079563,
-0.0150788175,
0.0114122257,
-0.0850463137,
0.0215503313,
-0.01363301,
2.799e-7,
0.020418575,
0.0412823558,
-0.0078175552,
-0.0184085369,
0.0230835136,
0.061117772,
0.0353563689,
-0.0205808003,
-0.0484906323,
0.024958821,
0.0340297557,
0.0065497463,
0.0436930135,
0.0128141595,
-0.0634975433,
-0.0326724313,
-0.0235578362,
0.0108466083,
0.0171437375,
0.028659327,
0.0662244707,
0.1260965466,
0.0200221092,
-0.0195011031,
0.0257808901,
-0.0290653259,
0.013518149,
-0.050776124,
0.0232461244,
0.0174894687,
0.0346921086,
-0.0170614179,
-0.0093205301,
-0.0168887414,
-0.0265016425,
0.0042431015,
-0.0136295026,
0.044021327,
0.0022984375,
-0.0372346975,
0.0239904895,
0.011936673,
0.0285468549,
-0.0424632467,
0.0396432914,
0.0096425572,
-0.0613078736,
-0.0145559087,
0.003844385,
0.0167837311,
0.0215120893,
0.0031678842,
0.0303551815,
-0.0111149997,
-0.0265609697,
-0.0529671647,
-0.0046094158,
-0.0651551262,
-0.0085426765,
-0.0287497938,
-0.0118903453,
0.0279361736,
-0.0058724387,
-0.0115143433,
0.0982279032,
0.005842682,
-0.0053819381,
2.208961663e-34,
0.0541664995,
0.0123312464,
0.0000581577,
0.0200956631,
0.0173914861,
0.0256686583,
-0.0348766558,
-0.0221007597,
0.0629515201,
0.020845443,
-0.0185790528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13718v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13718v1 | Multiple Relations Classification using Imbalanced Predictions Adaptation | 2023-09-24T18:36:22 | 2023-09-24T18:36:22 | Sakher Khalil Alqaaidi, Elika Bozorgi, Krzysztof J. Kochut | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | The relation classification task assigns the proper semantic relation to a
pair of subject and object entities; the task plays a crucial role in various
text mining applications, such as knowledge graph construction and entities
interaction discovery in biomedical text. Current relation classification
models employ additional procedures to identify multiple relations in a single
sentence. Furthermore, they overlook the imbalanced predictions pattern. The
pattern arises from the presence of a few valid relations that need positive
labeling in a relatively large predefined relations set. We propose a multiple
relations classification model that tackles these issues through a customized
output architecture and by exploiting additional input features. Our findings
suggest that handling the imbalanced predictions leads to significant
improvements, even on a modest training design. The results demonstrate
superiority performance on benchmark datasets commonly used in relation
classification. To the best of our knowledge, this work is the first that
recognizes the imbalanced predictions within the relation classification task. | [
0.0595773011,
0.0216563214,
0.0049757971,
0.038780015,
0.000740313,
0.0076557519,
-0.0303733014,
-0.0020714337,
0.0142114963,
-0.0664284676,
-0.0231774077,
-0.0231987406,
-0.0217631161,
0.0086652245,
-0.0203951467,
-0.0358533189,
0.0444886722,
0.0336912647,
0.0298120547,
0.0125510041,
-0.0008820104,
0.0404873379,
-0.0036501521,
-0.0075473827,
-0.0515401252,
0.0072185462,
0.0522931628,
0.029850712,
0.0219227672,
-0.0631420016,
0.0288758539,
0.0700125992,
-0.0217027478,
-0.0422492214,
0.0000016822,
-0.0730208084,
-0.0352029279,
-0.0037118595,
-0.0174858421,
-0.0293537825,
-0.0176213775,
-0.0719561502,
0.0669836625,
0.0257689804,
-0.0505929515,
-0.0278373547,
0.0262432173,
0.1176565215,
0.0211546011,
0.0669426993,
-0.0448389053,
-0.0198118072,
0.0279681254,
-0.0273045283,
0.0154390875,
0.0201813653,
0.0511030667,
-0.0175350737,
-0.030503992,
-0.0155249797,
0.0016468436,
-0.0248752944,
0.0241775699,
0.0087362519,
0.0896958485,
0.0292034261,
-0.0601531677,
-0.014426603,
0.0023824133,
0.0805895105,
-0.0242117979,
0.0093964469,
-0.000390875,
-0.0250739064,
0.0159430522,
0.0032084405,
0.041665554,
-0.0468811505,
-0.0479204133,
0.0484452285,
-0.017304223,
0.0081921378,
0.0447777733,
0.0304551329,
0.0074216006,
0.0216994602,
-0.0137564884,
-0.0372497626,
0.0405652225,
0.0745669678,
-0.0201708898,
-0.0056020687,
0.0237369612,
0.0297335628,
-0.0318462178,
0.0290811565,
-0.0402262881,
-0.0088618798,
0.0341501273,
-0.0875048116,
-0.026640553,
-0.0144265667,
-0.0132911066,
0.0284525175,
-0.0300396867,
-0.0100690881,
0.009414223,
-0.0169092622,
-0.0360141248,
0.0129190097,
-0.0377000272,
0.0111983214,
-0.0125673162,
0.0832224786,
-0.0022807482,
-0.006799587,
-0.0703360811,
-0.0075192903,
-0.0329362266,
0.0002778261,
0.0290452447,
0.036570631,
-0.0135574117,
0.0009467109,
-0.0274228696,
0.0221635792,
0.0036446813,
0.0323575065,
-0.0723875985,
-0.0094303582,
-0.0054682139,
0.0106467912,
0.0017380052,
-0.0350146592,
-0.0039760922,
0.0915812999,
-0.0107304351,
-0.0781591609,
-0.0174049139,
-0.0579090379,
0.0005410208,
-0.0089772176,
0.0538687184,
-0.0143452827,
0.0300861858,
0.0422615483,
-0.0133775817,
-0.022211358,
0.0502898507,
-0.0316758417,
-0.0620519184,
0.0550702363,
-0.0048446609,
-0.0067461007,
0.0071146046,
0.0135256406,
0.0071049524,
0.0410398059,
0.0317868665,
-0.0224547293,
0.027594531,
0.0243295878,
-0.0068219826,
0.0200200602,
0.0239764079,
-0.0221956912,
0.0232890975,
0.0283176955,
-0.0199078135,
0.0149018141,
0.0367421769,
0.0161861461,
0.0240310598,
-0.0284224302,
0.0066396678,
-0.0271898378,
-0.0139439469,
0.0460281931,
-0.0185770243,
-0.0098041538,
-0.0208553057,
-0.0060366169,
-0.0682099387,
0.0173598435,
-0.0024998365,
0.0003398191,
-0.0248870458,
0.0060389899,
0.0023684741,
-0.0018577426,
-0.0006619201,
-0.0193031579,
-0.0087623689,
-0.035913866,
0.0649661273,
0.0166866072,
-0.0392252393,
0.0587032959,
0.0641241595,
0.0067915348,
0.004166597,
-0.0077344663,
-0.0042256755,
0.0323982164,
0.024269959,
-0.0533754416,
-0.0411790088,
-0.0113831563,
-0.0213414691,
0.0503118485,
0.051927831,
-0.0185143333,
0.0209354628,
-0.0051874686,
-0.0557494909,
0.0444924384,
0.0088730808,
0.0081999339,
0.0234090015,
0.0275919009,
0.0285291765,
-0.0109044118,
0.0274875145,
0.0375937298,
0.0219857059,
0.0005790374,
0.0551827811,
0.0216244068,
0.0382958725,
0.0176918861,
-0.0104664285,
-0.0017052602,
0.0728267282,
-0.0322457626,
-0.0461157523,
-0.0270683505,
-0.0554216877,
-0.0400128849,
0.0503608733,
0.0060288762,
-0.0066019464,
-0.0112618394,
-0.0308096353,
-0.0291362815,
0.0238939784,
-0.0196037851,
0.0570398979,
0.0073484923,
0.0012732381,
0.0341815241,
0.0028392323,
-0.0154300993,
0.0770558268,
-0.0157434046,
-0.0009551002,
-0.0373707488,
-0.1147675514,
0.0124410521,
0.0036562546,
-0.0173767693,
-0.0176803395,
-0.0094952034,
-0.0044527585,
0.0071525797,
-0.0060553597,
-0.0392330103,
-0.0031917202,
-0.068409428,
0.015558931,
0.039068874,
0.0436206236,
-0.0057735061,
-0.0119136833,
0.0181959979,
-0.050677944,
-0.0203952771,
-0.0214979798,
-0.0258042291,
-0.0021369224,
0.0414232425,
0.0184666533,
-0.0124116428,
0.0143246613,
-0.0126213972,
-0.0230031218,
0.0807981491,
0.0205998216,
-0.0354040489,
0.0034955572,
0.0496047065,
-0.0263130106,
0.009560599,
0.0189715363,
0.0065778969,
-0.0375292376,
0.038471356,
-0.0014449545,
-0.009182022,
0.012582114,
0.0524644516,
0.0270619262,
0.03647089,
0.018507544,
0.0318991169,
-0.0246327892,
0.0575998984,
0.0076449807,
-0.0211566743,
-0.0510682911,
0.0164531507,
0.0176929366,
-0.0119290277,
-0.0372398123,
-0.0055842008,
0.0153336162,
-0.0003892496,
-0.0452548824,
0.011461135,
0.0260479096,
-0.0421110578,
-0.0641300082,
-0.0246997848,
0.055005081,
0.0389768146,
0.0169677455,
-0.0144006237,
-0.0097413231,
-0.0190205481,
0.0627048165,
0.009371561,
0.0084161311,
0.023863107,
0.0382881612,
-0.0533508882,
-0.0457773581,
0.0238774214,
0.0020871744,
0.0367769599,
-0.0431488901,
0.0156064024,
-0.0115565723,
-0.0602980517,
-0.0396462716,
-0.028913144,
0.0142865265,
0.0111045763,
-0.0181375071,
0.0006419934,
-0.0209379494,
-0.0199538469,
-0.0494745746,
0.0211159736,
-0.0185810346,
-0.0232711248,
0.0211458933,
0.0707008764,
0.0626032874,
-0.0043572136,
0.0043970277,
-0.0059155435,
0.001967571,
0.0256845616,
-0.0455292277,
0.0089600058,
-0.004681984,
0.0089719659,
-0.0202704314,
-0.0344696902,
-0.0275686998,
-0.014490868,
0.0044686371,
-0.0554331988,
0.000002928,
0.0983714238,
0.0382048078,
-0.0446606167,
0.0219132323,
0.0309884623,
-0.0070888912,
0.0358751006,
0.0099220043,
-0.046813339,
-0.0069214632,
-0.0424356461,
-0.0037832551,
-0.0118556293,
-0.0547788888,
0.0015137338,
-0.0875633955,
-0.0158658251,
0.0124878334,
-0.0576894246,
-0.0240500532,
-0.0612173639,
-0.0057872143,
-0.038516283,
-0.0255810283,
-0.0405976623,
-0.0089784935,
0.0093736444,
0.0149952108,
-0.010333511,
-0.0445422195,
0.0120403245,
-0.0307629909,
0.0510000587,
0.0208203532,
0.0201420393,
-0.0454965867,
0.0474785306,
0.0221603084,
0.0080856346,
0.0041600717,
-0.0081725251,
0.0985035896,
-0.0038688187,
-0.0086078523,
-0.047657527,
-0.0258787926,
-0.0976140946,
-0.0388565101,
0.0162135214,
0.0802606568,
-0.0094690211,
-0.0313940756,
-0.0327815749,
-0.0312121138,
0.0175288692,
0.0388755389,
-0.0321192853,
-0.0420184582,
-0.0084397215,
-0.0104090767,
0.0437000915,
-0.0392810181,
0.0469518378,
0.009617595,
-0.0545161255,
-0.0136498604,
-0.0429645889,
-0.0523131005,
0.0164294988,
-0.0238796249,
0.0057218224,
0.0002268949,
0.0298798643,
0.0156289227,
-0.0699068531,
0.0077098324,
0.0259152371,
0.0156562533,
0.0035781111,
-0.0050470461,
0.0101165688,
-0.0479886383,
-0.0269077569,
-0.0826179534,
-0.0361691378,
-0.0148618417,
-0.0594440438,
0.0243767332,
0.0101172486,
0.0202424005,
0.0239763483,
0.0071046045,
0.0186035465,
0.1230302751,
-0.0773603097,
0.0091184862,
0.0290311631,
-0.0324430019,
-0.0245887358,
0.027723683,
-0.038495779,
0.0313506983,
0.0287688561,
0.0209545773,
-0.0409530886,
-0.055671446,
0.0040720287,
0.0125475433,
0.0829217583,
-0.0147684021,
-0.0050653117,
-0.0394413993,
0.0186883174,
-0.0010670515,
-0.0285238586,
-0.0219614524,
0.0187237523,
0.0091271317,
0.0298519451,
-0.05148926,
-0.0400555134,
0.0121431863,
0.0428791717,
0.0067650541,
-0.0312501714,
0.0375471823,
-0.0151728336,
0.0188981425,
0.0141636496,
-0.0199287534,
0.005803749,
0.036232952,
-0.0320452042,
-0.004908219,
0.0084033189,
0.0121678719,
0.0277789719,
-0.0389773995,
-0.0339963064,
-0.0209179483,
0.0993900746,
-0.0720218867,
0.0185590386,
0.0552291945,
0.003459427,
0.028220173,
0.0023711484,
-0.0102802357,
-0.0184378475,
0.0781498402,
-0.0362095088,
0.0050118985,
0.0321152024,
-0.0018422283,
-0.0423598327,
-0.0062160948,
0.0586172901,
-0.0316132754,
0.0888111591,
0.0398998633,
-0.061863061,
-0.0443847552,
-0.0303666573,
0.0257717315,
0.004126383,
0.0188543312,
0.0450626388,
-0.0469337851,
-0.0539613143,
0.0282254759,
-0.0596082509,
0.0028935138,
0.0009654032,
0.0125297261,
0.0046871128,
0.0163166225,
-0.0497390367,
-0.0023986963,
-0.0354693606,
-0.0456312746,
-0.0007990808,
-0.035315726,
-5.748612594e-33,
-0.0241672955,
-0.0551077053,
-0.0105301607,
-0.0044169608,
-0.0240733083,
0.0266578458,
0.0097101191,
-0.0290164258,
-0.0060988679,
0.0395162441,
0.013224408,
0.0149107371,
-0.0048293076,
0.0167174712,
0.0026374441,
-0.0162578933,
0.0430330336,
-0.0061719986,
0.0171055906,
0.0034487899,
0.0192583762,
0.0337967463,
0.058723107,
-0.1195125431,
-0.0166409481,
-0.0102183158,
-0.0262156166,
0.0419952497,
0.0054581324,
0.0537696071,
-0.0228538923,
0.0779220611,
0.0738570839,
0.0119336164,
0.034879487,
-0.0209100619,
-0.1035387516,
-0.0663058534,
-0.0299588107,
0.007957424,
0.0268329382,
-0.0089471564,
0.0239313804,
0.0441497117,
0.0449397527,
-0.0738091022,
0.0736245066,
-0.0453986377,
-0.0436334983,
-0.0775191784,
-0.0232439283,
0.0212996267,
0.0330786854,
-0.0180852097,
-0.0519173555,
0.0282339491,
0.0094678244,
-0.0341757797,
-0.0319129825,
-0.0381095931,
-0.0100604398,
-0.0142301442,
-0.0144647276,
0.0138722006,
-0.0378301255,
0.0443450697,
-0.0246331841,
-0.0047213822,
0.0006133237,
-0.012216338,
-0.0263611581,
0.0194096826,
-0.0112210652,
0.0447691046,
0.0467636772,
-0.0151671348,
-0.0982854143,
-0.0032608644,
0.0145709058,
0.0075565428,
0.0159334149,
-0.0007783017,
-0.0195543393,
-0.0390037335,
0.0092492336,
0.0081799403,
-0.0278681871,
-0.053127788,
0.0137217902,
0.0150683438,
0.0185943879,
0.0823080763,
-0.0396786295,
-0.050398089,
-0.0427472256,
0.0439792164,
-0.0182080772,
-0.0142265838,
0.0041946834,
-0.0234936923,
-0.0411885306,
-0.0493745916,
0.0284232963,
-0.0316861644,
0.0184255131,
0.006701862,
0.0730303675,
-0.0174681731,
-0.0665031224,
-0.0194779169,
0.019320434,
-0.0055069295,
0.0337485485,
0.0517771915,
-0.0274321474,
0.0345913135,
-0.0061030011,
0.0551594906,
0.0505769961,
0.0222239587,
-0.0289732292,
0.039120771,
-0.008732006,
0.0203044396,
0.0200439841,
-0.0183112826,
0.0403203033,
-0.0201869197,
0.0331234038,
-0.0558211729,
-0.0368295126,
-0.0581880547,
2.474e-7,
0.0709151402,
0.0401144736,
0.0029999258,
0.0229784101,
0.0038367256,
0.0515480898,
0.0133140413,
0.0872678086,
-0.0225087255,
0.020532446,
0.0261999909,
-0.0027219146,
-0.0182334092,
0.0617911257,
-0.0498905368,
-0.0332878307,
-0.0652083829,
-0.0472735614,
-0.0332618766,
-0.0028102382,
0.1022050977,
0.0756798163,
0.0547608025,
-0.0180907007,
-0.0414501876,
-0.0316860341,
0.0478786342,
-0.0393662266,
0.0177684799,
0.0277669542,
-0.0089062182,
0.000558099,
-0.0170407649,
0.1201931909,
-0.0197572578,
0.0133627076,
0.0054683127,
0.0439475551,
-0.0536700785,
0.0132108917,
0.0239384845,
0.037764553,
0.02013666,
0.008458077,
0.0339334048,
-0.0544355921,
0.0167081822,
-0.0004021218,
0.0052074753,
0.0012963971,
0.0439475849,
0.0320762284,
0.0182689205,
0.0311620925,
0.0374797098,
0.0007978433,
-0.0309904814,
-0.0631829426,
-0.0060262075,
0.0592225567,
0.0071424409,
-0.0121075176,
0.0036930342,
-0.002677954,
0.0208992194,
-0.0547942184,
0.0283307582,
1.999587982e-34,
0.0005709109,
-0.0123388469,
-0.0223112721,
0.0301302951,
0.0205264911,
-0.0546573773,
-0.0446789339,
0.0057834033,
0.0048477952,
-0.0346379578,
0.0402579531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14382v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14382v1 | Agree To Disagree | 2023-09-24T18:06:45 | 2023-09-24T18:06:45 | Abhinav Raghuvanshi, Siddhesh Pawar, Anirudh Mittal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | How frequently do individuals thoroughly review terms and conditions before
proceeding to register for a service, install software, or access a website?
The majority of internet users do not engage in this practice. This trend is
not surprising, given that terms and conditions typically consist of lengthy
documents replete with intricate legal terminology and convoluted sentences. In
this paper, we introduce a Machine Learning-powered approach designed to
automatically parse and summarize critical information in a user-friendly
manner. This technology focuses on distilling the pertinent details that users
should contemplate before committing to an agreement. | [
0.0332931727,
0.0251488183,
-0.0041298694,
-0.0385338366,
-0.0334947482,
0.0140513573,
0.0002322335,
0.0301137827,
0.0287880525,
-0.0676117688,
0.038512338,
-0.0094465045,
-0.0103443824,
0.0479989015,
-0.0487780981,
-0.0718896538,
0.0197264142,
0.0247196108,
0.0311403163,
0.017270606,
0.0154336113,
0.0174613371,
0.0098622739,
0.0269052703,
-0.0339285657,
-0.0227200817,
-0.0101416819,
-0.0030372317,
0.0103920456,
-0.0436190479,
-0.0047430112,
0.0491923317,
-0.0221779868,
-0.0028515679,
0.0000018013,
-0.0840039924,
-0.0054010786,
-0.0120350169,
-0.0301814154,
0.0764426589,
0.0129078245,
-0.0313994996,
-0.0049598645,
0.0040977411,
-0.0197022371,
0.0305759888,
0.0138298254,
0.0635835603,
0.0613373183,
0.0554855838,
-0.0286290012,
-0.0293275397,
-0.0003986778,
-0.0117722088,
0.0057576238,
-0.0553042926,
0.0269612186,
-0.0343762785,
-0.0167503729,
-0.0288565364,
0.0201100837,
0.0179472044,
-0.0244640931,
-0.0394201875,
0.0001967783,
0.0214029271,
-0.0380886532,
-0.0147338575,
-0.0154885165,
0.033242397,
0.052503325,
0.0136625804,
0.0471455194,
-0.0160440821,
0.0159269571,
0.0563833714,
-0.0556135103,
0.0830418989,
-0.0250992458,
0.0057612746,
-0.0397633128,
0.026026262,
-0.0072452673,
0.0070080911,
-0.0453801304,
0.0536579862,
-0.0265542381,
-0.0583163202,
0.0303072408,
-0.0042005987,
0.0172252562,
-0.0572072417,
0.0350544639,
0.0236629955,
-0.0064729475,
0.0002507782,
-0.0122836558,
-0.0079956073,
0.0661869794,
-0.0445209667,
-0.0097412206,
-0.0540321022,
-0.0370412581,
0.0944850817,
-0.007163249,
-0.0523223355,
0.031943962,
0.0330082737,
-0.0008346168,
0.0335339867,
-0.0059392615,
-0.0083095403,
-0.0144236172,
0.0591275804,
-0.0401732512,
0.0032549591,
-0.0376551226,
0.0245246794,
0.013630081,
0.0501633286,
-0.0022831154,
0.0127111599,
0.0410853066,
-0.0234298892,
-0.0600323305,
-0.0871390626,
-0.0397903845,
0.017824769,
0.0015659748,
0.0414486118,
0.0239028037,
0.0055110059,
0.040727511,
0.0275645982,
0.0176005438,
0.0731509924,
0.0488506071,
-0.0139916036,
-0.02129177,
-0.0394803807,
-0.0003062559,
0.0175402835,
-0.0537424237,
-0.015932193,
0.0103207082,
-0.0085871983,
-0.0339268483,
-0.0377748832,
-0.0216047019,
0.0510658696,
-0.0388587415,
0.0455305129,
-0.0464192294,
0.0061895517,
-0.0038159476,
-0.0072035161,
0.0204600934,
-0.0365953259,
0.0095631629,
0.0953981653,
0.0491054915,
0.001937893,
0.0181424692,
0.0294132084,
-0.0063511925,
-0.0080065159,
0.0372511074,
-0.0134682357,
-0.0009860502,
-0.0421119779,
-0.0095626619,
0.0542299822,
-0.0071621006,
0.0017637904,
0.0190656241,
0.1025472283,
-0.022666499,
0.0507872552,
0.0067453161,
0.0605766885,
0.0211615805,
0.0159455426,
-0.0115992958,
0.0366041884,
0.0039828271,
0.0289621502,
-0.0326397121,
0.0321826525,
-0.0163437761,
-0.0494728647,
-0.0359879956,
-0.021745136,
0.0468612053,
0.0395114459,
0.0366065502,
0.0121308519,
-0.0483395867,
0.02061815,
0.0420259312,
-0.034285564,
-0.0253702346,
-0.0101040062,
-0.0021582264,
0.0495675243,
0.0134451389,
-0.0181759614,
0.0173379369,
-0.0421147011,
0.0060848813,
0.0476082638,
0.0694304258,
-0.0139135197,
-0.0497172698,
-0.0291893948,
-0.0340014435,
0.0341459922,
0.0059917308,
-0.005055489,
-0.0209794082,
-0.0414137244,
0.0470078699,
0.0319200642,
-0.0285003874,
0.0372111239,
0.0363646671,
-0.0442918949,
0.0026511212,
0.0225448497,
0.0119049875,
0.0230915453,
0.0376364402,
0.0036368563,
0.0441442207,
0.0223390851,
-0.0022124667,
0.0334307775,
0.0018099305,
0.0481423214,
0.042032335,
-0.0711459741,
-0.0423322916,
-0.0063307998,
-0.0507582389,
-0.0017833189,
-0.0396654308,
-0.0291697159,
0.0020676595,
-0.0144685321,
-0.0190991219,
0.009056719,
-0.0154323941,
-0.0207932796,
0.0382526815,
0.0075989766,
-0.0280060023,
-0.0090284357,
-0.0886063874,
0.0110490946,
0.0237100255,
-0.0094223442,
-0.0546105802,
-0.039911449,
0.0285803378,
0.0359886214,
0.0443368517,
-0.0182488784,
0.0084424317,
-0.0721316487,
-0.0331080221,
0.0083037447,
0.0258699972,
0.0328984521,
-0.0222982615,
0.0071676336,
-0.0216244012,
-0.0445846766,
-0.044278264,
-0.0307874214,
-0.038719669,
0.0679035187,
0.0002946836,
-0.0763034523,
-0.0074066636,
-0.0285857115,
-0.0469699651,
0.0283536762,
0.0658420324,
-0.0560600534,
-0.0163419656,
0.0309558343,
0.0051121023,
-0.0480488576,
0.0102985669,
0.0323146023,
-0.0219723098,
0.0142874019,
-0.072443448,
0.0245778952,
0.0423792526,
0.0541850999,
0.0511776172,
0.0397397727,
-0.0201397836,
-0.0039954837,
-0.0153000122,
0.0208256338,
-0.0338225402,
-0.0458379462,
0.0986415669,
0.0358309485,
-0.0070118797,
0.0330517888,
-0.0104234684,
-0.0018331627,
0.0050948756,
0.033081688,
-0.0298194885,
-0.0123976665,
-0.0622767769,
0.0661634058,
0.0295761805,
-0.0422360227,
0.0517295972,
0.0097167045,
0.0263427868,
-0.0345057957,
-0.0184471346,
-0.0303603951,
0.0599719696,
-0.0165831856,
0.0443513952,
0.0484213792,
-0.0603890978,
0.0195918344,
-0.0474436767,
0.1101406291,
-0.0277813729,
0.0718379095,
-0.02012413,
0.0210783966,
-0.0028954074,
-0.0171397422,
-0.0137838107,
-0.0640356615,
0.0076085874,
0.0286749452,
0.0433741435,
0.0066824127,
-0.0413614325,
-0.0278925821,
-0.002215531,
0.0326860696,
0.0380500183,
-0.0253745876,
0.0235896539,
-0.0085262023,
0.0136306472,
-0.0070124585,
0.0124567077,
-0.0365976728,
-0.0384079739,
0.0251346901,
-0.0246410631,
0.0018448678,
0.0392992534,
-0.0173079856,
-0.0201330297,
-0.0879029185,
0.0408863798,
0.047171548,
-0.0499486998,
-0.0544614643,
0.0458605923,
0.0443942063,
0.0610008724,
-0.0219942201,
0.0062726117,
0.0033236442,
0.0127641382,
0.0065607978,
0.0332250856,
-0.0950935185,
0.0287066177,
-0.0055517289,
0.049444247,
-0.0041795042,
-0.0445274822,
-0.0063714222,
-0.0065769209,
0.0569722615,
0.0055835866,
-0.0112334229,
0.0189668108,
-0.0192670058,
-0.0328634381,
-0.0427729599,
0.0051580025,
-0.0291537829,
-0.0632906556,
-0.0212749466,
0.0235415045,
-0.0779641718,
0.0102800531,
0.0179618783,
-0.0287815519,
0.0195585825,
0.0582828224,
0.0081570297,
-0.0278962292,
-0.0366739705,
0.0524576977,
0.0201453362,
-0.0105556659,
0.00651483,
0.0658795461,
0.0219337381,
0.0241567697,
-0.0301566739,
0.0219547655,
-0.0108520621,
-0.0312534571,
0.0413375944,
0.0345224962,
0.0102303624,
-0.0037464208,
-0.0048246169,
0.0030388499,
-0.0323369429,
0.0502660908,
0.0210217927,
-0.0223898888,
-0.050455343,
-0.0730098709,
-0.0293592941,
-0.0401947722,
-0.0142458295,
-0.0062037176,
-0.0718405619,
-0.0182757769,
-0.0717061535,
-0.0090685152,
0.0098647997,
0.0065466538,
0.0565505847,
-0.0126741715,
0.1018249094,
0.0084802806,
-0.0350584239,
0.0177420732,
-0.0015257125,
-0.0336573087,
-0.0058311895,
-0.0096089933,
-0.0250343252,
0.0407879651,
-0.0179038383,
-0.0038736407,
-0.0004162661,
-0.0122323837,
-0.0015659134,
0.0179996099,
0.0246150233,
-0.0190030113,
0.0052231792,
-0.0110636735,
-0.0275928918,
0.0647656694,
-0.0298981406,
-0.04362344,
0.0751788691,
0.029573828,
-0.0356526524,
0.0009544613,
-0.0424347818,
-0.003345028,
-0.0283257458,
-0.0432314761,
-0.0561353788,
0.0140040386,
0.0756040737,
0.0785133243,
-0.0365183875,
-0.0332744904,
-0.0154133728,
0.0039210515,
-0.0113399401,
0.0089247152,
-0.0067405491,
-0.0133221615,
0.0034459829,
0.0207970664,
-0.0244064946,
0.0167613383,
0.0816892534,
-0.0474701338,
-0.017835198,
-0.030215269,
0.0419948958,
-0.0319974162,
-0.0187327005,
0.0297745392,
-0.0574375056,
-0.012117561,
0.006018321,
0.0092055649,
0.0238627996,
-0.0007137005,
-0.0349013694,
0.0189636983,
-0.0000656204,
-0.0224042516,
0.0150028374,
-0.0083061894,
-0.0545893312,
-0.0178511254,
0.0385806337,
-0.0157662686,
-0.0076649762,
0.0522244722,
-0.0491189025,
-0.0113929072,
0.0111552244,
0.0184105206,
-0.0213119369,
-0.0260595959,
-0.0083079049,
0.012620328,
-0.0396353267,
-0.0162950158,
0.0407698713,
-0.0453219041,
-0.0065457928,
-0.0319149606,
-0.0306970067,
-0.0500620753,
-0.0465595722,
-0.037741214,
-0.0053601568,
-0.052864261,
-0.0491817445,
-0.0693963692,
0.005000975,
-0.0284987874,
-0.0091089308,
0.0554979295,
-0.0123683736,
-0.0001883063,
0.0332710408,
0.0323235206,
-0.0300131217,
-0.0294524804,
0.0124310777,
-0.0119145708,
-0.0168952942,
-0.0137532717,
-5.486533557e-33,
-0.0272027608,
-0.0338385478,
-0.0069839377,
0.062457215,
0.012982659,
-0.0281140041,
-0.0332807377,
-0.0042080586,
0.0376923196,
0.030709859,
-0.0265732985,
-0.0181016978,
0.0194918998,
0.0053212177,
0.0155944703,
0.0202572104,
0.0365401767,
-0.0049586943,
-0.0006488076,
0.002597454,
-0.0063615278,
0.0371498615,
0.002806497,
-0.1006047875,
0.0368768759,
-0.0004780172,
-0.0605045445,
-0.0028607564,
-0.036524035,
0.0334485099,
0.0079749748,
-0.0261126906,
0.0284980107,
-0.0147694815,
-0.0092076762,
0.0620311163,
-0.0937978402,
0.0302450228,
0.0297545809,
-0.0232634116,
0.0200179536,
-0.0092708105,
0.0690121353,
-0.0207649935,
-0.0237885527,
-0.0155314049,
0.0620713793,
-0.0290248618,
-0.0473187789,
-0.092837058,
-0.0733110756,
0.0282009784,
-0.0438743457,
0.022204373,
0.0544610955,
0.0397767015,
-0.0016189667,
-0.0125713469,
-0.028533563,
0.0441967621,
0.015560152,
-0.0056731701,
0.0514723957,
-0.0608124137,
0.005919667,
0.0635505468,
-0.0587003082,
-0.0098861847,
-0.0163177364,
-0.0048292647,
-0.0013931305,
0.0411488861,
-0.0464286357,
0.0193253979,
0.0336780883,
-0.0254287943,
-0.0477834418,
0.070189774,
0.0020096956,
0.0255707707,
0.018800525,
-0.0228477381,
0.0058940295,
0.000601747,
0.0086643314,
-0.0061565493,
0.0146268364,
-0.0411417298,
-0.0002509363,
-0.0035277472,
-0.0170048978,
-0.021110177,
-0.0550014228,
-0.0460552797,
-0.055353567,
-0.0280067455,
0.0180761945,
0.008120547,
-0.0079508573,
-0.0373764075,
-0.0331277251,
-0.0309926942,
-0.0283758603,
-0.0055842535,
0.0474361852,
0.0159001015,
0.0697694942,
-0.0183966085,
-0.0605273619,
0.0384167284,
0.0155954761,
0.0252755098,
0.0225135181,
0.0147099439,
0.0255481899,
0.0111644892,
0.0196958631,
0.0164555386,
-0.0080681313,
-0.013530382,
-0.0445194617,
-0.0016942594,
0.0144831315,
0.0255314875,
-0.0167421829,
-0.0051350011,
0.0187889356,
0.0185681339,
0.0909589082,
0.0208505318,
-0.0101392418,
0.007537548,
2.447e-7,
0.0689304247,
0.0666660592,
0.0236007944,
-0.0072315638,
-0.044685062,
0.0558598191,
0.0331619792,
0.0444200113,
-0.0375732705,
-0.0296308063,
0.0369922481,
-0.0398497544,
0.0228203442,
0.0493099317,
-0.0980333537,
-0.0111830151,
-0.0387370251,
-0.0603626519,
-0.0457409211,
0.0263608173,
0.0647318661,
0.008152226,
0.0159739368,
-0.0282757301,
0.020422535,
0.0043654609,
0.0001381246,
-0.0542298034,
-0.0282583944,
-0.001467658,
0.0790706724,
-0.0584935136,
-0.0201476142,
0.0222518332,
-0.0503368527,
0.0048810476,
-0.0311316252,
0.0788709521,
0.0238397922,
0.0299443509,
0.0289238356,
-0.0618294403,
0.0472899228,
-0.0177382231,
0.0023798442,
-0.0214983858,
-0.018090032,
-0.0887671262,
-0.0203030445,
-0.0389195904,
0.0045483266,
0.0094619188,
0.0429861806,
-0.0076704146,
0.0067202407,
-0.0519544519,
0.0261824913,
-0.0937100947,
0.0154544348,
0.099311322,
0.0175165255,
0.0043993006,
0.0314331055,
0.0236858651,
0.0325158052,
-0.0240586568,
0.0200171396,
2.008715971e-34,
0.0289339758,
0.0010059275,
0.0004789592,
0.0672959089,
0.005932699,
0.0171078164,
0.0302635469,
0.0252627209,
-0.0069427742,
-0.0294939075,
0.0403493196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13702v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13702v2 | Skill Check: Some Considerations on the Evaluation of Gamemastering Models for Role-playing Games | 2023-09-24T17:19:36 | 2023-09-30T18:56:04 | Santiago Góngora, Luis Chiruzzo, Gonzalo Méndez, Pablo Gervás | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In role-playing games a Game Master (GM) is the player in charge of the game,
who must design the challenges the players face and narrate the outcomes of
their actions. In this work we discuss some challenges to model GMs from an
Interactive Storytelling and Natural Language Processing perspective. Following
those challenges we propose three test categories to evaluate such dialogue
systems, and we use them to test ChatGPT, Bard and OpenAssistant as
out-of-the-box GMs. | [
0.059440732,
-0.0097576212,
-0.0570628941,
0.0801125914,
-0.0420299582,
0.0164133832,
-0.0279144011,
0.0055876859,
0.0498977602,
0.0053145206,
-0.0170367621,
-0.0196343251,
0.0128038069,
0.0748013407,
0.0051767277,
-0.0430159345,
0.0285173804,
-0.0367584154,
0.0490654074,
0.0474042818,
-0.0098366132,
0.0230946112,
-0.053221602,
0.057421986,
0.015743399,
-0.0321975425,
-0.0122485105,
-0.0038825292,
0.0177335534,
-0.0633596852,
-0.0106018726,
-0.0286099799,
-0.0125539517,
0.0135612963,
0.0000017406,
-0.044090189,
0.0483597144,
-0.0322766379,
-0.0018554919,
-0.036986921,
-0.01027162,
0.0699453875,
0.0149679957,
0.0139458198,
-0.0392399319,
-0.0419612192,
0.0548955798,
0.0703894719,
0.0752914771,
0.0642951354,
0.0061251693,
-0.0184669308,
-0.0202231258,
-0.0050014905,
-0.0027708909,
-0.011204158,
-0.027618818,
0.0557321683,
0.0595033467,
-0.019956205,
-0.0106151439,
0.0211675242,
-0.0295402054,
-0.016113922,
-0.0056289709,
0.0456549525,
0.0367952771,
-0.0004983228,
-0.0099586882,
0.0050844322,
0.0350176543,
0.0210094284,
0.0149684874,
0.0162621271,
0.0235113781,
0.0534630753,
0.0069604754,
0.0298271123,
-0.0348127559,
-0.0358499996,
-0.0405332632,
0.0419549905,
0.0132642202,
-0.0382852554,
0.0435235314,
0.021708481,
-0.0060033286,
-0.0647188127,
-0.0385017805,
0.0216671899,
-0.0022421444,
-0.0651197582,
-0.0506081618,
0.0135044185,
-0.0949808508,
0.0182411522,
0.0000846933,
0.0922273025,
0.0074997409,
-0.011181117,
0.0016956325,
0.0320190452,
-0.0065806434,
0.0403712876,
0.0459530912,
0.0453391746,
0.0439043641,
0.0025279466,
-0.0010490314,
0.0247550439,
-0.0471077934,
-0.0361382626,
-0.0493763313,
-0.0078217844,
-0.0201720241,
-0.0225830674,
-0.0212328974,
0.0092439679,
0.0044386028,
0.0507768989,
0.0041612335,
0.0023051202,
-0.0042843968,
0.03052756,
-0.0840072334,
-0.0395007655,
-0.0256586932,
-0.0081528164,
0.0211321637,
-0.0475682132,
0.0002074323,
-0.0254009515,
0.0070442259,
-0.0024885235,
0.0206305087,
0.089354381,
0.0128765227,
0.005243226,
-0.0125174168,
-0.0201001056,
-0.0260673743,
-0.0524855703,
-0.0597642176,
-0.0364124849,
0.0141262496,
-0.0352330729,
0.0414399244,
0.0320977606,
0.0114492346,
0.0374336466,
0.018551629,
0.0493883155,
0.0242897216,
0.0287959483,
0.0286798757,
0.0239896979,
-0.0219488274,
0.0112445401,
0.0446483716,
-0.0138714286,
0.0188372694,
-0.0026066476,
0.056210123,
0.0318282247,
-0.0724013299,
-0.0415053144,
0.039954856,
0.0000755801,
-0.0012188157,
0.0732425451,
-0.0318471715,
0.0758009031,
-0.0439512134,
0.0229758658,
0.0545425005,
0.0813296065,
0.0383125059,
0.0031303263,
0.0956671834,
0.0247702934,
0.0080624316,
0.0257964842,
0.0509728417,
-0.0332640819,
0.0556493104,
-0.0260390732,
-0.0275273751,
0.0109725017,
0.0259469338,
-0.0491239354,
0.0066528046,
0.0250242539,
-0.0088788839,
0.0105606932,
-0.0018577708,
-0.0029451402,
-0.0363604315,
-0.0340854153,
-0.0083118267,
-0.0615681633,
0.028531855,
-0.0425132029,
-0.0013242313,
0.0929449797,
0.0708862841,
-0.0217885356,
-0.0164954569,
-0.0468343645,
-0.0281660035,
0.04595761,
0.0292224288,
-0.0159670953,
0.012849696,
-0.0394424349,
-0.0148108471,
-0.0064588287,
0.0144934719,
0.0557953864,
-0.0718515441,
-0.0011281758,
-0.0082650222,
0.0523557886,
-0.0133066857,
0.0009186512,
0.0130407577,
-0.0875214115,
-0.0287808497,
0.0062613082,
0.0145962117,
0.0509986505,
-0.0638011694,
-0.0056627137,
0.0070011821,
-0.0008907416,
-0.0437346362,
0.0650501475,
-0.0392571427,
-0.0101269707,
0.0206891261,
-0.0647914559,
-0.013307265,
0.0087353298,
0.0395072289,
-0.0197618082,
0.0096608801,
-0.066680789,
-0.0088473056,
-0.0025136918,
0.0295670331,
-0.020478921,
-0.0185059234,
-0.0302770361,
0.0222205427,
0.0110517656,
0.0246653073,
-0.0189906675,
-0.0096088452,
0.0437519215,
-0.0611949526,
-0.0179569777,
0.0655406788,
-0.0062857582,
0.0156896822,
0.0275324769,
0.006576044,
-0.035904061,
-0.0340229049,
-0.0791039616,
0.0054720845,
0.0126887457,
0.019886516,
0.0147048002,
0.0143412184,
-0.041204188,
0.034832567,
-0.0371069908,
-0.0783170685,
0.0751926228,
-0.0450704023,
0.0450716466,
0.0370666012,
0.0058818138,
-0.006930958,
0.0167865697,
-0.0273889434,
0.0309121627,
0.0012461415,
0.0067797997,
0.0104492074,
-0.008964207,
-0.0251415372,
0.016753437,
-0.0276061725,
-0.082591705,
0.0684319437,
-0.0105488161,
0.0260384865,
-0.0042772894,
0.0113078449,
0.0198846925,
0.0249564871,
-0.0718919337,
0.0330456235,
0.020201249,
0.0380083062,
-0.0225366168,
-0.0099262279,
-0.0313311443,
0.068215929,
0.0575814918,
0.0357803814,
0.0328885205,
-0.0674838573,
0.0177284144,
0.0014386703,
-0.0313247405,
0.004002403,
-0.0365210623,
-0.0176162291,
0.0165072326,
-0.0194881409,
0.0484567583,
0.059686482,
-0.0472522564,
-0.0473934151,
-0.029193284,
-0.0124997357,
-0.0525494255,
0.0573035255,
-0.0318631791,
0.0157402754,
0.0413508192,
-0.07172025,
-0.004260689,
-0.0515103936,
0.0551796928,
-0.0180042852,
-0.0084739542,
-0.0702742338,
-0.0404836684,
0.0316207483,
-0.0038977964,
-0.016322311,
0.0027135673,
-0.0283208415,
-0.022301944,
0.0716047138,
0.0128634013,
-0.0563677214,
-0.0025574886,
0.01289682,
0.0114014093,
0.0193196591,
-0.0154064121,
-0.0198348425,
0.0049623712,
0.0408561341,
0.0513856709,
-0.0210121982,
0.0043747844,
0.0808318257,
0.0266754031,
-0.0666942298,
-0.0416432954,
0.0191333927,
0.0048668268,
0.0224128477,
-0.0472736284,
-0.0235759076,
0.0134819644,
0.0007579929,
-0.0705016702,
0.0228352863,
0.0786261931,
0.0285950601,
0.0290957615,
0.0054218182,
-0.0111829853,
-0.0300646797,
0.0094419848,
0.0194299128,
-0.1029897705,
0.0243579783,
-0.0131861661,
0.0105217397,
-0.031710241,
-0.0330140069,
0.0011562434,
-0.0889123902,
0.0513578579,
-0.0208867602,
-0.0312118232,
-0.0205529574,
0.0533848032,
-0.0133854933,
-0.0125009455,
-0.0336828753,
0.0074300296,
0.0005910465,
0.0003806431,
0.0245400686,
-0.0543697476,
-0.0243246239,
0.0246510133,
-0.05578373,
0.0894228071,
0.0671467856,
0.0757885128,
0.0164498743,
0.0154881049,
-0.0187844094,
0.0101677831,
0.0222672261,
-0.0190713964,
0.0574311055,
-0.0392191149,
-0.0111866007,
-0.0318254605,
-0.0372747295,
0.0679421797,
-0.007348232,
0.0537823215,
0.0332390703,
-0.0078518167,
-0.028809607,
-0.0055851219,
0.0321051292,
0.0527414009,
0.0206063427,
-0.0118684163,
-0.0154972812,
-0.0301445276,
-0.0017165492,
0.0185152423,
-0.0356878862,
-0.0805521086,
-0.0231921431,
0.0547936112,
0.0071315342,
-0.0732452869,
-0.0628410652,
0.0216648858,
0.0546277203,
0.0121280765,
0.018345017,
-0.0058233798,
0.037832588,
0.0241817906,
-0.0005694586,
-0.0265122373,
-0.0148946848,
-0.0731335282,
-0.0415782928,
-0.0090553751,
-0.0641183779,
0.0149769485,
0.00351422,
-0.010446813,
-0.0407076068,
-0.0184024125,
0.0263399333,
0.0142153278,
0.0006565995,
-0.0040479698,
-0.0455792546,
-0.0253567472,
-0.0432770625,
-0.084422417,
0.0216148719,
-0.017776208,
0.075146988,
0.0108617116,
-0.023083454,
-0.0203697719,
0.0086069377,
-0.0428159758,
0.0357240178,
0.0090215709,
0.007366606,
0.012915032,
0.004624675,
0.0121856323,
-0.0237758309,
0.0152548598,
-0.0243041813,
-0.0000722875,
-0.0605005361,
-0.0215883777,
-0.0391606688,
0.0123377442,
0.0113233533,
0.0171396602,
0.0012281667,
-0.0172381867,
-0.0888354555,
0.0006859599,
-0.0312985145,
0.0152235674,
0.0510942042,
-0.0423474126,
-0.0085154744,
0.0025215137,
-0.0056252284,
0.001458211,
-0.0281742252,
0.0551983491,
0.0524969175,
0.0429603793,
0.0157892834,
-0.0428606085,
0.0228392668,
0.0144130047,
-0.0296206288,
-0.0506883375,
0.074911885,
0.0189449675,
0.0373411663,
-0.026728509,
0.000782025,
-0.0020672318,
0.0385787562,
0.023797432,
-0.0265092608,
0.0141362147,
-0.0181890745,
-0.022484038,
0.0517190956,
-0.0199939311,
-0.0159526858,
0.0041820058,
-0.003534341,
0.0210839268,
-0.0151077714,
-0.0391372181,
-0.057451617,
-0.0052318,
-0.0028327277,
0.0324409679,
-0.0078515038,
0.0083736265,
-0.0962685347,
0.0142880799,
-0.0091989972,
0.0957586616,
0.0402441882,
-0.0276967194,
-0.0119413249,
0.0059792986,
0.0346383266,
-0.0063529168,
-0.0434097759,
-0.0255112723,
-0.0294924639,
0.007469561,
-0.0400413014,
-4.855742717e-33,
-0.0326990485,
-0.0359908827,
0.0677180663,
0.0197095256,
-0.0412229747,
-0.0379382856,
-0.0285091568,
0.0222595278,
-0.0079074353,
0.0064312676,
0.003790861,
-0.0157621503,
-0.0032998594,
-0.0090212906,
0.011050283,
-0.0336889625,
0.0512062944,
0.0211098716,
-0.0433938615,
0.0171581209,
0.006026186,
-0.0076376549,
0.0291131064,
-0.0781107023,
0.0245083421,
-0.0271446966,
-0.0088370023,
0.0015536958,
0.0049155448,
0.0201083366,
0.0008863366,
-0.0035516366,
0.027555719,
0.002872536,
0.0178149957,
0.0230013132,
-0.0067626238,
-0.0228369534,
0.0341642983,
0.0108087072,
0.0215374529,
-0.0085641714,
-0.0212187432,
0.0117804017,
0.0142193679,
-0.0200708136,
0.0516800694,
0.0079270462,
0.0405789055,
0.0021533812,
-0.0575326756,
0.0326676667,
-0.06891229,
-0.0587477908,
-0.027566174,
0.0604082011,
-0.0243841317,
-0.0556130446,
0.0035451148,
0.029557148,
0.0326410495,
-0.004807916,
0.0109309927,
0.0434520878,
-0.0129170073,
0.0554135777,
-0.0078328382,
0.0518741719,
-0.0725806728,
0.0138626648,
-0.005954992,
0.0350631177,
0.0418787561,
0.0572919734,
-0.0269675255,
-0.0027122828,
-0.0075159315,
0.0120936539,
0.0153771937,
0.0379184261,
0.0084711956,
0.0179459639,
-0.0781143233,
-0.0051110801,
-0.0046123471,
-0.0137590505,
-0.0075129676,
-0.0467241146,
0.0405141637,
-0.0386300273,
0.0300806388,
-0.0119648315,
0.0195424836,
-0.0030256896,
0.0339905396,
-0.0346614607,
-0.0238245782,
0.024425067,
-0.0527287498,
-0.024015896,
0.0155714825,
0.0023160521,
0.0601770878,
0.0414277986,
0.0438045748,
0.0083624553,
-0.0698472485,
0.0433145128,
-0.0251453929,
-0.009133704,
0.0201982651,
0.0572447106,
-0.0160261616,
0.0177649744,
0.0024530881,
-0.0806205496,
-0.0186585728,
-0.0003846267,
-0.0068400376,
-0.0830758065,
-0.0354784839,
0.0105377482,
0.0022732017,
-0.0499439612,
-0.0225750208,
0.0279341619,
-0.0315569006,
0.0374500863,
0.0079470957,
0.0173685625,
-0.0201530624,
-0.0187485442,
2.687e-7,
-0.0425625443,
0.0379412249,
0.0131714381,
0.0097123822,
-0.0119971372,
0.028432779,
0.000136597,
0.0013490883,
0.0343015045,
-0.0103515005,
0.0478043817,
0.0063816262,
0.0183316655,
0.0192902759,
-0.094284907,
-0.0367130935,
-0.0610017888,
-0.0068906969,
-0.0484648086,
0.018791534,
0.1120881438,
-0.0068456512,
0.0237194058,
-0.0046225106,
-0.0004942906,
-0.0288398825,
-0.0226218104,
-0.0247028396,
0.0023228594,
0.0416519269,
0.0455777124,
0.0037205173,
-0.0321544185,
-0.0087403618,
0.0134088993,
0.0308579467,
0.0026991991,
0.0504313298,
-0.0195327196,
0.0372075252,
-0.0043256362,
0.0248368867,
-0.0183659103,
-0.0568234101,
0.0006939949,
0.0252512768,
-0.0275779814,
-0.0280567165,
-0.0430718325,
-0.0442371629,
-0.013694251,
-0.0337497219,
-0.0544322506,
0.0042925207,
-0.0011028645,
-0.0018793145,
-0.0106324917,
-0.0510427766,
0.0115548149,
0.0062469807,
-0.0300669074,
-0.0744234174,
0.009715734,
-0.0150998635,
-0.0046490347,
-0.0395963639,
-0.0231835488,
1.825446414e-34,
-0.0236127079,
0.0259908587,
0.0131071294,
-0.016234545,
0.0963059291,
0.0440136231,
0.0271222629,
0.0461937785,
0.0401719362,
-0.0452752076,
-0.00986287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13701v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13701v2 | ALLURE: Auditing and Improving LLM-based Evaluation of Text using Iterative In-Context-Learning | 2023-09-24T17:15:58 | 2023-09-27T00:26:08 | Hosein Hasanbeig, Hiteshi Sharma, Leo Betthauser, Felipe Vieira Frujeri, Ida Momennejad | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | From grading papers to summarizing medical documents, large language models
(LLMs) are evermore used for evaluation of text generated by humans and AI
alike. However, despite their extensive utility, LLMs exhibit distinct failure
modes, necessitating a thorough audit and improvement of their text evaluation
capabilities. Here we introduce ALLURE, a systematic approach to Auditing Large
Language Models Understanding and Reasoning Errors. ALLURE involves comparing
LLM-generated evaluations with annotated data, and iteratively incorporating
instances of significant deviation into the evaluator, which leverages
in-context learning (ICL) to enhance and improve robust evaluation of text by
LLMs. Through this iterative process, we refine the performance of the
evaluator LLM, ultimately reducing reliance on human annotators in the
evaluation process. We anticipate ALLURE to serve diverse applications of LLMs
in various domains related to evaluation of textual data, such as medical
summarization, education, and and productivity. | [
0.0406664051,
0.0468937568,
0.0203209333,
0.0185585376,
-0.0239055771,
0.0416059382,
-0.0014168057,
0.0025526772,
-0.0047290507,
-0.0727863908,
-0.0446421057,
-0.0355778262,
0.0221603215,
-0.0027118272,
0.0359116495,
0.0033967714,
0.0170276482,
-0.0218845382,
0.0254683476,
0.0248923618,
0.0049633021,
0.0031956295,
0.0127738025,
0.039085988,
0.026201427,
-0.02846976,
0.0122439945,
-0.0105412584,
0.0236473996,
-0.0587119833,
0.0108896168,
0.0434837006,
-0.0145496661,
0.0392866991,
0.0000019713,
-0.0494571365,
-0.0198117159,
0.024983516,
-0.0118996408,
0.0556352846,
0.0945733264,
-0.0140468609,
-0.0198547263,
0.0061318828,
-0.0228415318,
0.0038032793,
-0.0019618187,
0.0180406068,
0.0628259704,
0.0687382519,
0.004757199,
0.0085617509,
0.0158386398,
-0.0108503541,
-0.0038346315,
-0.0403370708,
0.0280487221,
0.0199020766,
0.0199741907,
0.0003610879,
-0.0046347957,
0.0387481526,
0.0122093223,
-0.0397449732,
0.0269646458,
0.0066308253,
-0.006782196,
-0.0098656612,
0.0039901417,
0.0640924275,
0.0258354768,
-0.0258785579,
0.0001849064,
0.0003149154,
0.0084579308,
-0.0162043571,
-0.050153967,
0.0359772332,
-0.0188063253,
0.0145556796,
0.0362731665,
-0.0002718442,
0.0435752235,
0.0268329363,
-0.004701504,
0.0325523578,
-0.0068580485,
-0.0610398054,
-0.0035247125,
0.0509091839,
-0.0107171852,
-0.0494245254,
0.0130821215,
0.045370698,
-0.0495131053,
-0.0005249934,
-0.0179381073,
-0.0527622811,
0.0624431483,
-0.0544039719,
0.0409056954,
-0.0284095835,
-0.0089066941,
0.0422719792,
-0.004764121,
0.057069879,
0.0289640464,
0.0351643562,
-0.0445926376,
0.0329717137,
-0.0237873085,
-0.0002005444,
0.0271414574,
0.0209974833,
-0.0069641741,
0.0008428686,
-0.0793003142,
0.0098818187,
-0.0503284745,
0.0606229603,
-0.0057965429,
0.0032386766,
0.0007642927,
0.0059840749,
-0.0338042267,
-0.0083313836,
0.0146597354,
0.0170031786,
-0.0130480044,
-0.0088000968,
-0.0016055511,
0.0556796044,
-0.0141841117,
0.0086691957,
0.0206285492,
0.0485813804,
0.0053604678,
-0.0373129174,
-0.0124491611,
-0.0410656296,
-0.0272251256,
-0.0550558493,
-0.0113002164,
-0.0803593621,
-0.0123342052,
-0.0077753626,
0.0031412181,
-0.0435312875,
0.0033221398,
0.0367674641,
-0.022254223,
0.0268740375,
-0.0389067829,
0.0090164393,
0.0149667487,
0.0173669346,
0.0216094553,
0.0408027656,
0.0513365753,
0.0047612409,
0.0259015821,
0.0254050083,
0.0408029407,
0.0206763707,
0.0404565446,
0.0071422146,
-0.0148544265,
0.0072992598,
0.0026679039,
0.0341318361,
0.0036264106,
0.066152595,
-0.0252483822,
0.0526503436,
0.0467069931,
0.064357467,
0.0274916906,
0.0006736258,
0.0344979614,
-0.0215793643,
0.0240484253,
0.011020489,
-0.0337514319,
-0.003608474,
-0.0349800177,
0.0041110958,
0.0353439264,
-0.0000063599,
0.0031008769,
-0.0945562422,
-0.0520215966,
-0.0098095452,
-0.0101200137,
-0.0045334385,
0.0522510037,
0.0005533392,
-0.0420314297,
-0.0073846718,
0.0245411191,
-0.0566142425,
0.0385822505,
-0.0579351448,
0.0502526276,
0.1040738299,
0.0867001116,
-0.0483743958,
0.004781072,
-0.0313392729,
0.0169384331,
0.0386555046,
0.0132133774,
-0.0467793681,
-0.0334195532,
-0.0313970596,
-0.0247513,
-0.0224477202,
0.0298637357,
-0.0267526843,
0.001855781,
-0.0103353737,
0.0078873904,
-0.0635261312,
-0.1138061881,
0.058485169,
-0.0505073145,
-0.0411873385,
-0.0130177876,
-0.0125315925,
0.0230801683,
0.0341021754,
-0.0129980659,
0.0419776365,
0.009377378,
-0.0222518835,
-0.0310777761,
-0.0120772226,
-0.0026353684,
-0.0163099635,
0.0413550697,
-0.0631288216,
-0.0225377828,
-0.0295595229,
-0.0474240035,
-0.0293337926,
-0.0103612784,
-0.037750639,
-0.0068636895,
-0.0245033074,
0.0429957695,
-0.0172993038,
-0.0233621653,
-0.0617833994,
0.0629192367,
-0.0203092881,
0.0325023942,
0.0282196049,
-0.0024512133,
-0.008299211,
0.0093881274,
-0.0283433106,
-0.0090330467,
0.0093224384,
0.034350697,
0.0148235429,
0.0440210663,
-0.0404269025,
-0.0492276698,
-0.1100301668,
-0.0132806031,
-0.0232292581,
0.0303129423,
0.0318788514,
-0.0271477737,
0.0069560958,
0.0186200626,
-0.0242277905,
-0.0559239239,
0.0363525525,
-0.0004478416,
0.0483366065,
-0.0015032181,
0.0176111627,
-0.0646333322,
0.0012353181,
-0.0530494787,
0.0594937876,
0.0564219952,
0.0164497476,
-0.0661716983,
0.0379900746,
-0.0106111728,
-0.0416646749,
0.0225871522,
0.000501668,
0.0329696387,
-0.0113918046,
-0.0001518032,
0.0705225617,
0.005011498,
0.0482548513,
0.0540898629,
-0.0153345605,
-0.0562925376,
-0.0167489965,
0.0172597282,
0.0093330862,
-0.0009917193,
-0.0186848175,
0.0012511769,
0.0475389473,
-0.0074651823,
-0.0122811338,
-0.0250168573,
0.0284132771,
-0.0698087662,
-0.0051522921,
-0.0558891967,
-0.0272064321,
-0.0106404545,
0.0543392599,
-0.0061762538,
-0.0293740537,
0.0821314678,
-0.0322888233,
0.0481233373,
-0.06359303,
-0.0102147311,
-0.0676313639,
0.0198741611,
-0.0309245847,
-0.0080321915,
-0.0579164512,
-0.0043925522,
-0.0039832005,
-0.0026483771,
0.0320409462,
-0.0566751696,
0.0777996108,
-0.0698117837,
0.0061291768,
0.0025328177,
-0.0164349768,
-0.0308883674,
-0.0198107343,
-0.0364693031,
-0.0021589675,
-0.0046441373,
0.0218179151,
-0.0494749211,
-0.0112895565,
0.0117402831,
0.0477545075,
-0.0207611285,
-0.0305236857,
-0.0042231567,
0.0058209728,
0.0154339457,
-0.0223043337,
0.0253831204,
-0.0832979456,
0.0384336822,
0.0593107753,
-0.0057925601,
0.0404257998,
-0.0086912019,
-0.0051117707,
0.0170744248,
-0.0330262594,
0.0173172355,
0.0089130364,
0.0258148666,
-0.0684986338,
-0.0323459655,
0.1361056864,
0.0316775553,
-0.0827508494,
0.0060121175,
-0.0299506187,
-0.022847617,
-0.0014654166,
0.0081134448,
-0.0913104489,
-0.0153078958,
0.0022568095,
0.0689295083,
0.0040030605,
-0.0153406123,
0.0230527986,
-0.0802493319,
0.0253263041,
0.0200323611,
-0.0476641841,
-0.0340762176,
-0.0416608416,
-0.0000161541,
-0.0389410295,
0.0184526592,
0.0253879149,
-0.0204412155,
0.008623356,
0.0184156131,
-0.0427766368,
-0.080699943,
0.0363840722,
-0.0321199857,
0.0411971323,
0.0745019242,
0.0321718939,
-0.0056388923,
-0.0332537256,
0.0600230694,
-0.0040777186,
-0.0098509388,
0.0005467589,
0.0555068403,
-0.0011215382,
0.0231398176,
-0.0437069573,
0.0447459519,
-0.0477792993,
-0.0167427864,
0.0202199388,
0.0688086003,
-0.0191212837,
0.0008479205,
-0.0286452733,
0.0274850708,
0.00720583,
0.0675090179,
0.0325107574,
-0.0477148257,
-0.0420220643,
-0.0223027933,
0.0026239203,
-0.0426563919,
-0.0197369885,
0.0454364009,
-0.0289860908,
-0.0173147228,
-0.0761880055,
-0.0563230105,
0.0109146927,
0.005571153,
0.0128850201,
-0.0136563471,
-0.01535282,
-0.0212446954,
-0.0132215424,
0.0268039517,
-0.0087004378,
0.0193517301,
-0.0436576381,
0.0087484065,
0.0319908001,
0.0003340443,
-0.0154800899,
0.0530133359,
-0.0572508946,
-0.0324170291,
0.0030689742,
0.0305983648,
0.0214805566,
0.048607111,
-0.0170764588,
-0.013818332,
0.0732676014,
0.0401237942,
-0.0015975176,
0.0194594394,
0.0101433815,
0.0114736939,
-0.0112275081,
0.0070080147,
-0.050669495,
0.0054643182,
0.0151787419,
0.0321775377,
-0.0234743115,
-0.0330586471,
0.0159715526,
0.0292637404,
0.0012348415,
-0.0350360461,
-0.0239963941,
-0.0407597348,
0.0037906035,
-0.024009198,
-0.0384294167,
-0.0188818313,
0.0241232608,
0.0257349629,
-0.0331212431,
-0.0195005257,
0.0543144196,
-0.0216996223,
0.0314665921,
-0.0568796471,
0.0543615408,
-0.0064401552,
0.0186121538,
-0.0145126646,
-0.0234088413,
-0.0364569724,
-0.0168320127,
-0.0245113652,
0.0362995453,
0.008311131,
0.037123289,
0.0249875877,
0.0344589837,
0.0249873605,
0.0481389947,
-0.0612807684,
0.0345959514,
-0.0644095838,
0.0035892834,
0.0492874421,
0.0149012506,
0.0777292252,
-0.0078930221,
-0.0032398663,
-0.025395235,
0.0379992649,
-0.0140172793,
-0.0048671267,
-0.0003500054,
0.0159440022,
0.0141215436,
-0.01354938,
0.0795657039,
-0.0027604206,
0.0314847417,
-0.0224863272,
-0.0362101533,
-0.0484756082,
-0.0356345922,
0.0016523435,
0.0068737702,
-0.0247556716,
-0.029396655,
-0.0539100952,
-0.0579580255,
0.0303757284,
0.0600676797,
0.0011749252,
-0.017962845,
-0.0047118464,
0.0586618967,
0.0038699259,
0.0151612749,
-0.0599613637,
-0.0029701358,
0.0174867325,
-0.0220547654,
-0.0273841247,
-5.860859815e-33,
-0.0294067152,
-0.0695042908,
0.0189954396,
0.0249685217,
-0.0205033906,
0.0378770046,
-0.0416891724,
-0.0102867968,
0.042666968,
0.0374431051,
-0.0002937,
0.0328564346,
-0.0012223258,
0.0192173719,
0.0436997563,
-0.020000238,
0.0216170233,
0.0016967759,
-0.0397329703,
0.0148209129,
-0.0059519052,
0.0048248451,
0.0487875752,
-0.069098033,
0.11334382,
0.0040086424,
-0.0495179929,
-0.0014925377,
-0.0254844371,
0.0582964234,
-0.0247388277,
0.0168114975,
0.0368449204,
-0.0210356992,
-0.003529063,
-0.0050828871,
-0.0664208606,
-0.008967557,
0.0091407374,
-0.0245184712,
-0.0501386039,
-0.0432787724,
0.0781847984,
-0.0061905533,
-0.0537881143,
-0.0137172006,
0.0571444929,
-0.0447290167,
-0.0072133392,
-0.0623816065,
-0.0668617412,
0.0586580969,
-0.0349231288,
0.0007972895,
-0.0029834933,
0.0276180841,
-0.0218473189,
0.0563387573,
-0.0658986717,
0.0136744753,
0.0245218426,
0.0021140659,
0.047758434,
-0.0135199502,
-0.0219599772,
0.0646080822,
-0.0244253911,
0.0135842813,
-0.0297061838,
-0.037087936,
0.0253889151,
-0.0035024493,
0.0662483498,
0.0640577525,
-0.0099962084,
0.0066826181,
-0.0749766156,
0.0683481917,
-0.0219381601,
0.0263095349,
0.0295719337,
-0.0388593264,
-0.0410028026,
-0.0170696676,
-0.0468257703,
-0.0164273251,
-0.0329123735,
0.0057547614,
0.0140140578,
0.0136206327,
-0.0356312767,
-0.0086185783,
-0.0221225973,
-0.0553926155,
-0.010580848,
-0.0051423381,
-0.0121950256,
0.0128526073,
-0.0182347279,
-0.0117862271,
-0.0395548679,
0.0081828255,
-0.0165443495,
0.0373757705,
0.0610894971,
-0.0098641645,
0.0672318116,
0.0090552336,
-0.0555685833,
0.0159956962,
-0.0009010436,
-0.012455387,
-0.0035713401,
-0.0061088586,
0.0229338594,
-0.0160942934,
0.0069297897,
0.0563039519,
0.005235903,
0.0482737571,
-0.0160742495,
-0.024625646,
0.01234762,
0.0013209454,
-0.0467066132,
-0.015139753,
0.0052064862,
0.0189037118,
0.0316431038,
-0.0400490426,
0.0198371839,
-0.0038056944,
2.586e-7,
0.0914595127,
0.0835727528,
0.010724254,
-0.0308124293,
0.0263507012,
0.0173343178,
-0.0253225565,
-0.0101882722,
0.0234806333,
0.0135640018,
0.060320884,
0.0011406373,
0.0597698465,
0.0396088101,
-0.0709288269,
0.0032814085,
-0.0991266668,
-0.024737021,
-0.0202148966,
-0.0144805852,
0.0565246753,
0.0423503667,
-0.0077532255,
-0.0349799097,
-0.0159219466,
-0.0426632613,
0.0621929877,
-0.0117806485,
-0.0338399559,
0.0443426557,
0.054262273,
0.0169418734,
0.0268529505,
0.018795874,
-0.0170595497,
-0.0055213384,
0.0214449111,
0.0693318099,
-0.0129534323,
-0.0009393661,
0.0048941928,
-0.0297154896,
0.0430468768,
-0.0522880927,
0.0618347675,
-0.0217788611,
-0.0195319206,
-0.0667349696,
-0.0166924819,
-0.0391112752,
0.0584478714,
0.0079209758,
-0.006081949,
0.0427454561,
-0.0049242335,
0.0025613431,
-0.014959516,
-0.0618119761,
-0.0391868241,
0.0236209091,
-0.0178299248,
-0.047710862,
0.0152707463,
0.0132537102,
-0.0192958023,
-0.0902792886,
0.0271266885,
2.474220228e-34,
0.0892943889,
-0.0316882953,
-0.0006058887,
0.0031180156,
0.0451012775,
0.0396288037,
-0.0150138065,
0.0049871705,
0.0106970128,
-0.0631931126,
0.0103657339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14381v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14381v1 | Survey of Social Bias in Vision-Language Models | 2023-09-24T15:34:56 | 2023-09-24T15:34:56 | Nayeon Lee, Yejin Bang, Holy Lovenia, Samuel Cahyawijaya, Wenliang Dai, Pascale Fung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, the rapid advancement of machine learning (ML) models,
particularly transformer-based pre-trained models, has revolutionized Natural
Language Processing (NLP) and Computer Vision (CV) fields. However, researchers
have discovered that these models can inadvertently capture and reinforce
social biases present in their training datasets, leading to potential social
harms, such as uneven resource allocation and unfair representation of specific
social groups. Addressing these biases and ensuring fairness in artificial
intelligence (AI) systems has become a critical concern in the ML community.
The recent introduction of pre-trained vision-and-language (VL) models in the
emerging multimodal field demands attention to the potential social biases
present in these models as well. Although VL models are susceptible to social
bias, there is a limited understanding compared to the extensive discussions on
bias in NLP and CV. This survey aims to provide researchers with a high-level
insight into the similarities and differences of social bias studies in
pre-trained models across NLP, CV, and VL. By examining these perspectives, the
survey aims to offer valuable guidelines on how to approach and mitigate social
bias in both unimodal and multimodal settings. The findings and recommendations
presented here can benefit the ML community, fostering the development of
fairer and non-biased AI models in various applications and research endeavors. | [
0.0623365827,
0.0999845117,
-0.0452954993,
0.0459650531,
-0.0083487229,
0.0169519279,
0.0430454798,
-0.0232386179,
0.0078503806,
-0.1075736284,
-0.0458116569,
-0.0169401988,
0.0227624718,
-0.0021884828,
0.0122951437,
-0.099893719,
0.026742423,
0.0447843485,
0.0251526684,
-0.0408661179,
0.0184661355,
0.0191784464,
0.0540310889,
0.0437028557,
-0.0520544313,
-0.0012457981,
0.0698040724,
0.0028288681,
-0.0019090502,
0.0119412467,
0.0185199734,
0.0685529485,
0.0042575244,
0.0114004118,
0.0000019587,
-0.0624630414,
0.017177444,
-0.0008014943,
0.0281776786,
-0.023153685,
0.0613897555,
-0.0606513806,
0.0307036936,
0.0129716592,
-0.0669248104,
-0.0064384365,
0.0633791015,
0.0193642061,
0.0283170976,
-0.0004607045,
-0.0245079938,
-0.020031726,
-0.0397733003,
0.0028338018,
-0.0190279558,
-0.0108538279,
0.0371054001,
-0.0305985473,
-0.0606799088,
-0.0286439788,
-0.0563958026,
0.0261085648,
0.0088832835,
0.0404500104,
0.0595697984,
0.0039289305,
-0.0319975801,
-0.0779718459,
-0.0379624441,
0.0596188307,
-0.0069319741,
-0.0094378013,
-0.0246596802,
-0.0202035382,
0.0409054309,
0.042974323,
-0.0179471523,
0.0593127124,
0.0163218398,
0.0125206048,
-0.0481344052,
0.0333563462,
0.0131314751,
0.042568326,
0.0147857638,
0.0293129236,
0.005847014,
0.013186031,
-0.0056216456,
0.0504875667,
-0.0028394398,
-0.0170570333,
0.0088322787,
0.0060716695,
0.0214851722,
-0.0025937026,
-0.0502136424,
-0.0120308818,
0.0179022662,
-0.0489612818,
0.0287884474,
0.0042395261,
-0.0442525484,
0.0139839472,
0.0298428219,
0.0166436192,
-0.0067443042,
0.0519118123,
-0.0020692819,
-0.029804429,
0.0101618785,
-0.0063486504,
0.0074742539,
-0.0362227224,
-0.0474770181,
0.0110256271,
-0.0191613231,
-0.0130944829,
-0.0693991333,
-0.0414155722,
0.0069213971,
0.055663038,
-0.0326833799,
0.0239491407,
-0.0390278734,
0.0089773703,
-0.0096996306,
0.0295680538,
-0.0568462275,
-0.0936942324,
0.0319812559,
0.0095140748,
-0.0087106349,
-0.0393684655,
-0.0019573593,
0.0498269387,
0.0130857704,
-0.0531835966,
-0.0277333092,
-0.0251035541,
-0.02598143,
-0.0342697203,
0.034790542,
-0.0222514216,
0.0289662983,
0.0139601603,
0.0146791972,
-0.026508376,
-0.0281541869,
0.0032620335,
-0.0731649026,
0.0854574889,
0.0224472694,
0.0170165971,
0.0299580619,
0.0295739658,
0.0041201147,
0.0702506602,
0.0293263625,
0.001886008,
0.0613548756,
-0.0284967814,
0.0250051524,
0.0212974437,
0.0234824903,
-0.0321633443,
-0.0059200735,
0.0089007318,
-0.0289120749,
-0.0206865855,
0.0714792311,
0.0537977479,
0.0114733558,
-0.0700777248,
0.0782661662,
0.0486079007,
-0.0291545503,
0.0321177244,
-0.0050655818,
-0.0143789342,
-0.0174755957,
-0.0009597176,
-0.0883740187,
0.0301669911,
-0.0244569872,
-0.0734792277,
-0.0442806855,
0.0776047111,
-0.0321077853,
-0.0177973919,
0.0066374931,
0.0036686279,
0.0849071145,
0.0151349958,
0.0164524913,
0.0232342239,
-0.0101924511,
0.0042822836,
0.0429537371,
-0.0296676792,
0.008047103,
-0.0436764844,
-0.0048592472,
0.0161667429,
0.0107016927,
0.0080806324,
0.0463780575,
-0.0165193509,
-0.0050451886,
0.0297335368,
0.0726900995,
0.0099643059,
-0.0031220212,
-0.0267311651,
-0.0454164706,
0.0185754541,
0.0180198625,
0.0074969176,
0.0354197845,
0.0273161121,
0.006605078,
-0.0123799136,
-0.0365725793,
0.0379828289,
0.0482747108,
-0.0043303389,
-0.0486773923,
0.0189672131,
0.0038328327,
0.0141766025,
-0.0201312006,
-0.0098148221,
-0.0274275597,
0.0176506229,
0.0067606382,
0.0471687987,
-0.0710477531,
0.009408311,
-0.0060450602,
-0.0888330191,
-0.0203406159,
0.0674982294,
-0.0144562237,
0.038498424,
0.0572329648,
-0.0120400842,
0.0220013428,
-0.0103336126,
-0.0164879709,
-0.0467942804,
0.034366101,
-0.0457049161,
0.0139781898,
-0.0165835284,
-0.060023915,
-0.0079693459,
-0.0461771861,
-0.0008063924,
-0.018128993,
-0.0328390524,
0.0180781223,
-0.001053563,
0.0181398895,
0.0246974472,
-0.0272169728,
-0.004284434,
0.0439532176,
-0.0902780369,
-0.0555995069,
-0.0305942241,
-0.0417132415,
-0.0339569151,
-0.012881103,
-0.009507562,
-0.04405462,
-0.0165406987,
0.0190228652,
0.0177076403,
0.0484904572,
-0.0032814594,
-0.0375557691,
0.0077876365,
-0.0127416514,
-0.0459030978,
-0.0166141875,
0.0791845024,
0.0669772774,
-0.0330521576,
-0.0274233483,
-0.0084777055,
-0.0318120494,
0.0517597646,
-0.0111216875,
-0.0034652732,
0.0301870592,
0.0606632419,
0.0138908271,
0.0729509294,
0.0333429649,
0.0541311093,
0.0586639084,
0.0248150937,
-0.0200193394,
-0.0428717807,
-0.0052677137,
-0.0055875429,
0.0110795395,
-0.0539064854,
-0.0087921713,
0.0378447659,
0.0247359648,
-0.029596854,
-0.0627779439,
0.0599351712,
-0.0310137384,
-0.0994342417,
-0.0190788563,
-0.0489345118,
0.0074621933,
0.0271883477,
-0.0513590202,
-0.0838891715,
0.0356764346,
0.0216946639,
0.0080773672,
0.0060818866,
0.0194799583,
-0.0172648765,
0.0628068298,
0.0389847681,
0.0463031605,
-0.0042708009,
0.0111908307,
-0.0853317603,
-0.0316871852,
0.0305598639,
-0.018462602,
0.0281793289,
-0.0281760041,
-0.0067193261,
-0.0094021857,
-0.0438197106,
-0.037357647,
-0.053515546,
-0.0264088884,
-0.0077613993,
-0.0108520612,
0.0012720607,
0.0032667357,
0.0073772864,
-0.0053334762,
-0.0025166005,
0.0031326204,
-0.0125545152,
0.0155295385,
-0.0201211348,
0.0261631235,
0.0224382654,
0.0348704234,
-0.0116595225,
-0.0284838881,
0.047144305,
0.0326584317,
-0.0029410212,
-0.0297167059,
0.0231629089,
0.0448911078,
0.0327576362,
-0.009630587,
0.0066323774,
0.0468265675,
-0.0082532838,
0.0578858666,
0.0600646697,
-0.0145353973,
-0.0466783866,
0.0284174774,
0.0082460018,
-0.020637678,
0.0250955001,
-0.0279940479,
-0.0799067542,
-0.010408299,
-0.0019304871,
0.0123699885,
-0.0414185412,
-0.0459764153,
0.0210816339,
-0.0865737796,
0.0433879681,
0.0029806062,
-0.0078834686,
-0.042099949,
-0.0004004713,
0.0026864603,
-0.042006813,
0.0216992609,
-0.0294254255,
-0.0097309854,
0.0029788078,
0.0113704372,
-0.0222068653,
-0.019056106,
0.0203321129,
-0.0752185881,
0.0194018967,
0.0475830138,
0.0291871801,
-0.0108373966,
-0.0261514634,
0.005949901,
0.0211015437,
0.0253967792,
-0.0268022586,
0.0558021851,
-0.0672084242,
-0.0339547396,
-0.025765948,
0.0079643112,
0.026893273,
0.002051848,
-0.0377106704,
0.016801931,
-0.0088798208,
-0.0631700531,
-0.0684742182,
0.008907198,
-0.0173125137,
0.0715668425,
0.0161912143,
-0.0199369304,
-0.0145328864,
-0.0182417501,
0.0207342841,
0.0144247375,
-0.062675491,
0.0566494912,
0.005530227,
-0.0452671237,
-0.0378227532,
-0.0659982935,
0.008461223,
0.0020660441,
0.016124161,
-0.0629830733,
0.0364751779,
0.0001702574,
-0.0607086197,
0.0763857812,
-0.0064084972,
0.0296979118,
0.0235424433,
-0.0336101577,
-0.0248803906,
-0.0323151797,
-0.0193327777,
-0.0079643466,
-0.0114263892,
-0.027829146,
0.0431870595,
0.0605007932,
0.0176680647,
0.0338456295,
0.0304879434,
-0.0716568232,
0.0607619062,
0.0447009765,
0.0114222821,
0.0459263735,
0.01079283,
-0.0368465483,
-0.0082906038,
0.0056530172,
-0.0035678393,
0.0203579012,
0.037657883,
-0.0429669023,
-0.0291960575,
-0.0360631011,
-0.0153878639,
-0.0220685434,
0.0829679519,
-0.0323892795,
0.0064310618,
-0.033785414,
-0.0558700487,
-0.0026589802,
-0.0258762427,
-0.0409011729,
-0.0494928099,
0.0173231997,
0.0655680448,
-0.0488126315,
-0.0268660132,
-0.042672731,
0.0096964566,
-0.0410118438,
0.0420085005,
0.0504768267,
0.0056716488,
-0.0150856674,
0.0447278507,
0.0196965411,
0.0396717787,
-0.0353558473,
0.0268873852,
0.0498420782,
0.0350794457,
0.0338916145,
0.0077602779,
-0.0218450725,
0.0345254317,
-0.0306164436,
-0.0364745595,
-0.0102433544,
0.0058078333,
0.0140513489,
-0.0433417708,
0.0117077902,
-0.0043281112,
-0.000981741,
0.008131545,
0.0006237073,
-0.0029288933,
-0.0034818011,
0.0620964244,
-0.0217667352,
-0.0164380223,
0.0123444591,
0.0642537698,
0.025643263,
0.0479658246,
-0.0382481404,
-0.0539053231,
0.0119869187,
-0.0301696695,
0.0798171088,
-0.0347288474,
-0.0153245106,
-0.0008852022,
-0.0753483772,
-0.0557569489,
-0.0249305982,
-0.0001754791,
0.037864387,
-0.0020346099,
0.0465910546,
0.0648268238,
-0.0198597871,
-0.0594570935,
0.0065673231,
-0.0207520872,
-0.021361243,
-0.0127381049,
0.0146130389,
-5.970910331e-33,
-0.0125368414,
-0.0309607424,
-0.007734912,
-0.0136586195,
-0.0055188858,
0.0053894059,
0.0144541897,
0.0084943213,
-0.0422440432,
0.0298822075,
0.0178352185,
0.0165941324,
0.011839062,
-0.0038939624,
0.0234131906,
-0.0281019006,
0.0509174913,
-0.0158522557,
-0.0076176673,
-0.026156256,
-0.0376461372,
0.0160441827,
0.0418969281,
-0.0703145936,
0.0542845987,
0.0390512832,
-0.0067187324,
-0.0070017148,
0.0164740719,
0.0191404056,
-0.0116644576,
0.0648320243,
0.0523540229,
0.0201806426,
-0.0251351353,
0.0977007374,
-0.0469357818,
0.0101639684,
0.0068773362,
0.0598156862,
-0.0385712199,
0.0130538698,
0.0627724081,
-0.0100205978,
-0.0683261901,
-0.0170428492,
0.0717146993,
-0.000465456,
0.046812132,
0.0230669323,
-0.056300737,
0.0004416656,
-0.0138370842,
0.0089745456,
0.018844286,
0.0171413552,
0.0356052741,
0.0529123768,
-0.0418961756,
0.0333012789,
-0.0362370126,
-0.0701396167,
0.0767451674,
0.0329413004,
0.0323596708,
0.060387969,
0.066099748,
0.0139193125,
-0.0385898687,
-0.0582889356,
0.0545662753,
0.017409604,
0.0343340375,
0.0714979619,
0.0094375685,
-0.0042987317,
-0.0153823858,
-0.0130533697,
-0.0148786614,
0.0111133391,
0.008304623,
-0.0131239332,
-0.0676159337,
-0.0391977243,
-0.011732528,
-0.0771127194,
-0.0161274225,
0.0081370752,
0.0259206668,
-0.0054220366,
-0.022770619,
0.0878913552,
0.048241552,
-0.0727517754,
-0.0217906497,
-0.0151279746,
0.0114306184,
0.0055370447,
0.0031070411,
-0.0061345347,
-0.0654326081,
-0.0044652368,
0.0372419581,
0.0137562202,
0.0224309415,
0.0086620208,
0.0035940772,
0.0036618835,
-0.0241994541,
-0.0036763104,
0.0066416534,
-0.0109517062,
0.0306024961,
0.0153920073,
0.0414952971,
0.0328113995,
-0.0221262705,
-0.0210678596,
0.0297685061,
-0.0006127069,
-0.053453397,
-0.028260598,
-0.0312490631,
0.0245379824,
-0.010285533,
-0.0320932306,
-0.0320781432,
-0.032896053,
0.048093956,
-0.0557067171,
-0.0165682249,
-0.0499549545,
2.463e-7,
0.0294257645,
0.0557243899,
-0.0078540863,
-0.0073465551,
0.0148892552,
0.0577623062,
0.0424822681,
0.0780566782,
0.0210954715,
-0.0075177038,
-0.0190287065,
0.0668719336,
-0.0072298329,
0.0088401455,
0.029023055,
-0.00186274,
-0.0560858138,
0.0030560445,
-0.0157382246,
0.0258266889,
-0.0125604663,
0.0376769155,
0.0008814497,
-0.0261139516,
-0.0053807907,
-0.0368853733,
0.0348998532,
-0.0469081663,
0.0149074504,
-0.0041084257,
0.0218589474,
0.0172127113,
0.0182634145,
0.0491296425,
0.0103487074,
-0.0021459155,
0.0309205484,
-0.0156676974,
-0.0500641353,
0.0030826067,
-0.0296493042,
0.0204822123,
-0.0458014235,
-0.0702232942,
0.0464825258,
-0.0301188417,
-0.03122418,
-0.0409872867,
-0.0145393433,
-0.0015860187,
0.0583476648,
0.0047742128,
-0.014083663,
0.0014887052,
0.0501511805,
-0.0096982289,
-0.0176220797,
-0.0793455541,
-0.0124640772,
-0.0513785742,
-0.0079794135,
-0.0387214161,
0.0045690597,
0.0041160756,
0.021504391,
-0.0075563826,
-0.0052083926,
1.967594102e-34,
0.0032947885,
0.0112271952,
0.0193998385,
-0.0648794025,
0.0114014884,
0.0050311876,
-0.0442486219,
-0.026682239,
0.0211785007,
-0.0127052106,
-0.0055452087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13664v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13664v1 | VoiceLDM: Text-to-Speech with Environmental Context | 2023-09-24T15:20:59 | 2023-09-24T15:20:59 | Yeonghyeon Lee, Inmo Yeon, Juhan Nam, Joon Son Chung | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | This paper presents VoiceLDM, a model designed to produce audio that
accurately follows two distinct natural language text prompts: the description
prompt and the content prompt. The former provides information about the
overall environmental context of the audio, while the latter conveys the
linguistic content. To achieve this, we adopt a text-to-audio (TTA) model based
on latent diffusion models and extend its functionality to incorporate an
additional content prompt as a conditional input. By utilizing pretrained
contrastive language-audio pretraining (CLAP) and Whisper, VoiceLDM is trained
on large amounts of real-world audio without manual annotations or
transcriptions. Additionally, we employ dual classifier-free guidance to
further enhance the controllability of VoiceLDM. Experimental results
demonstrate that VoiceLDM is capable of generating plausible audio that aligns
well with both input conditions, even surpassing the speech intelligibility of
the ground truth audio on the AudioCaps test set. Furthermore, we explore the
text-to-speech (TTS) and zero-shot text-to-audio capabilities of VoiceLDM and
show that it achieves competitive results. Demos and code are available at
https://voiceldm.github.io. | [
-0.0211558864,
0.0347899124,
0.0337790363,
0.0158289932,
-0.0102116941,
-0.0339206569,
0.0296652745,
-0.0291631687,
-0.0419348143,
-0.0210595224,
-0.0486518741,
-0.0059505058,
0.0264124535,
0.0424880758,
0.0406879596,
-0.0904062465,
0.0093294559,
-0.0710242018,
-0.0193342399,
-0.0093025714,
0.0077456441,
0.0061055999,
-0.0467210971,
0.0056412993,
-0.0444439612,
-0.0074009551,
-0.0175729133,
0.0440680459,
0.0312026963,
-0.0242728572,
-0.0149147892,
0.0012316026,
0.0647900924,
-0.0328066312,
0.0000020401,
-0.0305521823,
0.0054803444,
0.0087806908,
0.0074801892,
-0.0382732265,
0.037475083,
0.012811644,
-0.0321938209,
0.0434439145,
0.0084497826,
0.0198851209,
0.0368040316,
0.0729827061,
0.0579295158,
0.0837703049,
-0.0243664701,
-0.0648282915,
0.0019930797,
-0.0224509779,
0.038961485,
-0.0072300178,
-0.0263416562,
-0.0204486437,
0.0342450216,
0.0139616411,
-0.0026470483,
0.0565399975,
-0.0089548314,
-0.016326312,
0.0142831672,
0.056632828,
0.0178872067,
-0.0257179905,
-0.0252150819,
0.114423193,
0.0300047398,
-0.0040473905,
0.0208812729,
-0.0086884182,
-0.0188816264,
-0.0467587523,
-0.0034206796,
0.0203538164,
0.0270909891,
0.0350752771,
-0.0466144755,
0.0536674522,
0.0261152536,
-0.0405322388,
0.0126774777,
0.0300440583,
0.0230433065,
-0.0443012156,
0.0119119398,
-0.0218638238,
0.0057628686,
-0.0352308303,
0.0312100966,
0.032382261,
-0.0499802157,
-0.0145904226,
-0.0595360734,
-0.0409511924,
-0.0310790427,
-0.0104617644,
0.0218844377,
0.0402350277,
-0.074542813,
0.0508355387,
0.0019749557,
0.0192196798,
-0.0032036556,
-0.0252989475,
-0.0405104384,
0.0048260083,
0.0167793836,
0.0345012918,
-0.0267206058,
0.0016195338,
-0.0544415675,
-0.0455597751,
-0.0153199397,
-0.0176164247,
-0.0339300856,
0.0355376229,
0.0028814496,
0.0256012194,
-0.0473860167,
-0.0118253939,
0.0214044098,
-0.0201293658,
0.0063656014,
0.0702549443,
0.0079312064,
0.0097633991,
-0.0215100776,
0.052737467,
0.0471263044,
0.0063065533,
0.0146115525,
0.0578259639,
-0.0240625534,
-0.0293824002,
-0.0401309207,
0.0110273818,
-0.0130506819,
-0.0437863655,
-0.0259844121,
-0.069064945,
0.0364787765,
-0.0173239317,
-0.0093565676,
-0.0114922961,
-0.0089458823,
0.0071508498,
0.004250742,
0.0844992399,
-0.0029715551,
0.0302457064,
0.0572136939,
0.001752059,
-0.0357831866,
0.0139988028,
0.0666679591,
-0.0036423071,
-0.0059749237,
0.0018899926,
0.0072541498,
0.0536096022,
0.026455123,
0.0274660178,
-0.0160976797,
-0.0165194776,
-0.000689642,
0.0289851595,
0.0711348876,
0.0590246357,
-0.0086187823,
0.0032421194,
0.1051367894,
0.0373522788,
0.0112052131,
-0.0468491875,
0.0673703551,
0.0715605468,
-0.0313607976,
-0.0023087228,
-0.0129804164,
0.0016105556,
-0.0272541214,
0.029570248,
0.0718607083,
-0.0097565968,
-0.0424396992,
-0.0054093171,
0.029374253,
-0.0470643193,
0.0345948674,
0.001064183,
0.0145520996,
0.019894667,
-0.0707538575,
0.0366536714,
0.0100573013,
-0.0742723122,
0.0171587747,
0.0003467676,
0.0726569667,
0.0587124266,
-0.0171966646,
-0.0334995873,
0.0402382426,
-0.0413239785,
0.0290570594,
0.0828186795,
-0.0027613845,
0.017988814,
0.0458718203,
-0.041764982,
-0.0152553096,
-0.0012931629,
0.0006851331,
0.0234776866,
-0.0282658152,
0.0587564968,
0.0098541789,
0.0176001862,
0.0209951289,
0.0033011052,
-0.0250390694,
-0.0403906852,
0.0263145287,
-0.0079716928,
0.0360526554,
0.031156389,
-0.0561623424,
0.0121430811,
0.0131259933,
-0.021360971,
-0.02293396,
0.0336645395,
-0.0932348296,
-0.02028138,
0.0243315436,
-0.0525966957,
0.0400651917,
0.0147421015,
0.00933431,
-0.0748108327,
0.0079198349,
-0.0025702724,
0.0499767698,
-0.0191885699,
0.0097154481,
0.0370789096,
-0.0062020957,
0.0372165591,
0.0045215255,
0.0252106134,
-0.0173578002,
0.0231292453,
0.0661064908,
-0.0079665538,
-0.0371903889,
-0.0124485521,
-0.0203938559,
0.0051129442,
0.0424111038,
-0.0211120062,
-0.0019206562,
-0.0410757251,
-0.0076923594,
-0.0643458739,
-0.0058214944,
-0.0344122574,
-0.0234233662,
0.0028775246,
-0.0099180741,
0.0001944604,
-0.0169689693,
-0.0698984042,
-0.0275583938,
0.0151018091,
-0.0457486995,
-0.0325598679,
-0.0103866393,
0.0001611092,
-0.0437904075,
0.0385369472,
0.0351124294,
-0.0196696073,
-0.0136694713,
-0.0152936615,
-0.041527193,
0.0751774684,
0.021646237,
0.0332054421,
-0.0226233229,
0.0186141096,
-0.0060683251,
0.0017925351,
0.0581480227,
-0.0047481689,
0.0112557895,
-0.0149380481,
0.0318355523,
-0.0045099226,
-0.0436081998,
0.0170992073,
0.0019851632,
0.0426936299,
-0.0351363122,
0.0075285519,
-0.0029271962,
0.0243170001,
0.0681013092,
0.034523543,
-0.04152501,
-0.0194902867,
-0.034024626,
-0.0346442387,
-0.0167930517,
-0.0627759695,
-0.0617159568,
0.0332775451,
-0.0219919756,
-0.0232723113,
0.0378194004,
-0.1052872911,
-0.0484996587,
-0.0411020368,
-0.0669488311,
0.0060808752,
-0.0067621367,
-0.0470340475,
0.0168418288,
0.0437670387,
-0.031852629,
-0.0088024903,
-0.0163495913,
0.025180582,
-0.0436291285,
0.0317358188,
-0.0047083274,
0.0178165194,
-0.0050729299,
-0.0176759865,
-0.044798743,
-0.0594829172,
-0.0016719012,
0.0224220734,
-0.0245516337,
-0.0369987264,
-0.0399220549,
0.0268837698,
0.024400143,
0.0652950183,
-0.0064732959,
0.008467637,
-0.0516435392,
0.0445412099,
0.0460042767,
0.0151803307,
-0.0383758843,
-0.0362673663,
0.0481795333,
0.0114680827,
0.0192234181,
-0.0077870991,
-0.0452497341,
0.0186077002,
0.0145053631,
0.0318831541,
-0.0354358703,
0.0423582271,
0.0766763017,
-0.041877389,
0.0022978117,
0.113318786,
0.0032835852,
-0.0430790111,
-0.0054480713,
0.0217005853,
0.0184458941,
0.0067779412,
-0.0060229762,
-0.0505603701,
-0.0274622198,
0.0362545513,
0.0612719283,
0.0427423976,
0.0230510682,
-0.0171364397,
-0.0748626515,
0.04120408,
0.0450254604,
-0.0398006029,
-0.0232604127,
-0.0304215215,
-0.0202327613,
0.0121270884,
0.0377230421,
-0.0041039805,
-0.0116394749,
-0.0210400876,
0.0162304919,
-0.0144878021,
-0.0491281189,
0.0244829226,
-0.0530339852,
0.0796216726,
0.0845850408,
0.0251168609,
-0.0170048885,
-0.0367862806,
0.0051311115,
0.0092502544,
-0.0037049509,
0.0209730435,
0.0359501094,
-0.0363136902,
-0.0141313709,
0.0304501764,
0.0868824944,
-0.0018110692,
-0.0006164619,
0.0263828617,
0.0418224744,
-0.016907379,
0.0005542792,
-0.0278110839,
0.0621166788,
0.0604709052,
0.094212465,
0.0162866618,
-0.0562517978,
0.0057723559,
-0.0166075882,
0.0031051976,
-0.0284397192,
-0.042255491,
-0.0234945547,
-0.0015572243,
-0.0180478171,
-0.0535653979,
-0.0172555242,
-0.0150622698,
0.0416121967,
0.0254100058,
-0.0072125667,
0.0023725929,
-0.0246052258,
-0.0454682186,
0.0288401954,
-0.0023919002,
0.0494344644,
-0.0469661504,
-0.0338181816,
0.0570054799,
-0.0680044815,
-0.0170555953,
0.0142214606,
-0.0509750955,
-0.0597418137,
-0.0237196591,
-0.0001992469,
0.0170432683,
0.0838616565,
-0.0387240052,
-0.0098654898,
0.0839437544,
0.0071443822,
-0.0649066716,
0.044780273,
0.0610830486,
0.0382229052,
0.0041756094,
0.0002220776,
-0.0786756724,
0.0488334075,
0.0046518329,
0.0226370282,
-0.0058569303,
-0.0408844166,
-0.011564252,
-0.05275793,
0.0205653999,
-0.0051729553,
0.0581089668,
-0.0612157211,
0.0042253276,
-0.0206918158,
0.0020093927,
-0.0509133898,
0.0228149761,
0.0112429615,
0.0137013597,
-0.0140936943,
-0.0296554789,
-0.0325498097,
0.0197820775,
-0.0373445414,
0.015717214,
0.055387333,
-0.0031813311,
0.0190961175,
-0.0038554431,
0.0108247772,
0.0098950891,
-0.0202406086,
0.0188590903,
0.0090243081,
0.0490538962,
0.0108286878,
-0.0190666523,
-0.0046122768,
0.0066941585,
-0.0331042856,
0.0362078063,
-0.037402112,
0.0398773812,
0.0350669809,
0.0008027264,
0.0535036698,
0.0001321422,
0.0233560223,
-0.0155523364,
0.0418484621,
-0.0051472592,
-0.0283175725,
0.0320296846,
0.0059487019,
-0.0015806967,
0.051222153,
0.0164197609,
-0.0168623514,
0.0091504483,
-0.0246740524,
0.0350359678,
-0.029688498,
-0.0102900621,
-0.0290351082,
0.0477313027,
-0.0142251896,
-0.0004354541,
-0.0184216984,
-0.0736338124,
0.0141214645,
0.0119041009,
-0.014427186,
-0.0191451777,
0.0267729908,
0.0146785583,
-0.0057896082,
0.0108015612,
0.0120961554,
-0.0526575297,
0.01306237,
-0.0298558343,
-0.0199180245,
-5.943317438e-33,
-0.0404533483,
-0.0315342247,
0.0031825467,
0.0011760339,
-0.0175471213,
-0.004718658,
-0.0675091147,
-0.0045699789,
0.0065161744,
0.0066441433,
-0.0187486243,
0.0055207442,
0.0230042376,
0.0501163602,
-0.040327616,
0.0094969114,
0.0733075738,
-0.0322986692,
-0.0229728557,
0.0393326059,
0.0278531276,
0.0461255722,
-0.01681103,
-0.0893779919,
0.025990041,
-0.0428384133,
-0.0359627269,
-0.0109678674,
0.0301798675,
0.0169121884,
-0.0153782712,
0.0279086251,
-0.0408763103,
-0.0280926116,
-0.0341842808,
0.0376339629,
-0.0692411214,
0.0046440051,
-0.006485696,
0.0068078376,
-0.0507136956,
0.0004777609,
0.014422318,
0.0044113626,
-0.0088384897,
0.0000087138,
0.0426242314,
-0.0047225305,
0.0204309896,
-0.0427522808,
-0.0441096723,
0.002624487,
-0.023916455,
-0.0516448282,
0.0504371636,
0.0627356321,
-0.0113686956,
0.0013200282,
-0.0932651535,
0.0701343194,
0.0072782193,
-0.000123133,
0.0411107913,
0.0167001877,
-0.0290754847,
0.0568363182,
0.0115245422,
-0.0430467874,
-0.0071126665,
-0.0042268191,
0.0125977518,
0.0256093573,
0.023007663,
-0.0051861196,
-0.0141167007,
-0.0230056886,
-0.0165965743,
0.0174211543,
-0.0229638927,
-0.0456886478,
0.0206061304,
0.0348021835,
-0.0364877991,
-0.010745422,
-0.0719431937,
-0.0330660492,
-0.02894013,
-0.0356965661,
0.0695086047,
0.0285828467,
0.0054729688,
-0.047820989,
0.0473143756,
0.004997158,
0.0025752108,
-0.0028705511,
-0.0539485626,
-0.0003322373,
-0.0206637755,
0.0037478064,
-0.0411318652,
0.0005950737,
0.1128245518,
0.039992068,
0.0191250797,
0.000781116,
-0.0200565457,
0.0693725869,
-0.0466717035,
0.0114928456,
0.0035192713,
0.0203152504,
-0.0071534575,
0.0240993667,
0.0054172985,
0.0004523179,
-0.025741538,
0.0700759962,
-0.0424866676,
-0.020882424,
-0.0126295695,
-0.0329295583,
-0.0372973904,
0.0310939979,
-0.0540183857,
0.0286053773,
0.01854904,
0.013891398,
0.0726018474,
-0.0174629837,
-0.0003594095,
0.0261290669,
2.794e-7,
-0.0425652377,
-0.0123466533,
-0.0001626309,
0.0043493817,
0.0345615,
0.053614147,
-0.0616844669,
0.0329322219,
-0.0141898524,
-0.0277998019,
0.0112937931,
0.0032679103,
0.0830304846,
-0.0097854417,
-0.1033598855,
-0.0217153635,
-0.0585328117,
0.0232615359,
-0.0310546812,
-0.0017151047,
0.0738219917,
0.0834241435,
0.0074980874,
-0.0138587188,
0.028948253,
-0.003343042,
0.0200232491,
-0.0199565925,
0.0038910664,
-0.0659592077,
-0.0018129781,
-0.0507275201,
-0.0323837362,
-0.0099866688,
-0.043255236,
0.0225916225,
0.021849148,
0.0834939703,
0.0292432066,
-0.0867100284,
-0.0414239019,
0.0772330537,
-0.0229848679,
-0.0008450028,
0.0621828251,
0.0011494539,
0.0021373206,
-0.0126350839,
-0.0756168216,
-0.0164256711,
-0.0197251067,
-0.0105721857,
-0.0122681372,
-0.032404352,
0.0123087242,
0.0288599469,
-0.0268803015,
-0.0681536049,
-0.0222902279,
-0.0032012356,
-0.037686795,
-0.020655755,
-0.0263184085,
0.0168828331,
0.0213411283,
-0.0473204441,
-0.0018835653,
2.26200332e-34,
0.0384747349,
-0.0498938486,
0.0158173591,
-0.0072622621,
-0.0148558738,
0.0192189887,
0.026625067,
-0.0169106796,
0.033988405,
-0.0553293601,
-0.0517882444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14379v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14379v1 | Machine-assisted mixed methods: augmenting humanities and social sciences with artificial intelligence | 2023-09-24T14:21:50 | 2023-09-24T14:21:50 | Andres Karjus | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | The increasing capacities of large language models (LLMs) present an
unprecedented opportunity to scale up data analytics in the humanities and
social sciences, augmenting and automating qualitative analytic tasks
previously typically allocated to human labor. This contribution proposes a
systematic mixed methods framework to harness qualitative analytic expertise,
machine scalability, and rigorous quantification, with attention to
transparency and replicability. 16 machine-assisted case studies are showcased
as proof of concept. Tasks include linguistic and discourse analysis, lexical
semantic change detection, interview analysis, historical event cause inference
and text mining, detection of political stance, text and idea reuse, genre
composition in literature and film; social network inference, automated
lexicography, missing metadata augmentation, and multimodal visual cultural
analytics. In contrast to the focus on English in the emerging LLM
applicability literature, many examples here deal with scenarios involving
smaller languages and historical texts prone to digitization distortions. In
all but the most difficult tasks requiring expert knowledge, generative LLMs
can demonstrably serve as viable research instruments. LLM (and human)
annotations may contain errors and variation, but the agreement rate can and
should be accounted for in subsequent statistical modeling; a bootstrapping
approach is discussed. The replications among the case studies illustrate how
tasks previously requiring potentially months of team effort and complex
computational pipelines, can now be accomplished by an LLM-assisted scholar in
a fraction of the time. Importantly, this approach is not intended to replace,
but to augment researcher knowledge and skills. With these opportunities in
sight, qualitative expertise and the ability to pose insightful questions have
arguably never been more critical. | [
0.0398775414,
0.0850123391,
-0.0352720022,
0.0238084495,
-0.0678498521,
0.0182612725,
-0.0094903158,
-0.0357429758,
-0.0101824692,
-0.0595783554,
0.0482538417,
-0.0096590957,
0.0274830721,
0.0146538354,
0.0034789848,
0.0307761151,
0.0115465494,
0.0267936904,
0.018411614,
0.0059964354,
0.0003681792,
0.0579139739,
-0.0023200526,
0.0440005288,
-0.0081544379,
-0.0113873305,
-0.0224402994,
0.0076581729,
0.0075738123,
0.0033344084,
-0.0121377278,
0.046648711,
0.0161150973,
0.0894282684,
0.0000022095,
-0.0471067354,
-0.0094195306,
-0.0169069842,
0.0181776751,
0.0316909179,
0.0676064715,
0.032624539,
-0.0202625971,
-0.0241021235,
-0.042996522,
0.0070802337,
0.0573087335,
-0.0402844846,
-0.0044077002,
0.027995903,
-0.0089078648,
-0.0355427712,
0.0491917394,
0.001463934,
-0.0548851304,
0.0142623708,
0.0452350564,
0.0331083499,
0.0120508717,
0.0277033411,
-0.0107333707,
0.064468585,
-0.0148540474,
-0.0481553748,
-0.0250589587,
-0.0199791919,
-0.0494186617,
-0.0021179798,
0.0137495911,
0.0012613251,
0.0470733009,
-0.0205198284,
0.0327104777,
-0.0073006894,
-0.042892646,
0.0718522742,
-0.0246271212,
0.0192562547,
-0.0117668388,
0.0065800315,
0.029001357,
-0.0311826319,
0.0323947221,
0.0528235734,
-0.0099671409,
0.0828474909,
0.0154942153,
0.002589124,
0.0064851879,
0.0092931371,
-0.0064129215,
-0.0624770746,
-0.0028221337,
0.0304606855,
-0.0108637288,
0.0269314423,
0.0351973511,
-0.027118016,
0.0282374844,
-0.0285973493,
0.0130005144,
0.0061311559,
-0.0452116728,
0.0374262072,
0.0595604293,
-0.0321727172,
-0.0145937344,
-0.0244700257,
0.0126703689,
-0.0061766584,
-0.0682964623,
-0.0133696543,
0.0122045111,
-0.0127903111,
-0.0281909388,
0.0172864441,
-0.0282839071,
0.003525967,
-0.0075709494,
0.0016809664,
-0.0464982092,
-0.0078796567,
-0.0222270731,
0.0102348812,
-0.0539315306,
0.0688175112,
-0.0312931016,
0.0559491813,
-0.0537328012,
-0.0502969362,
0.0402611308,
0.0288480166,
0.0002764985,
-0.0341450348,
0.0194217674,
0.0081924638,
0.0104296776,
0.0274473596,
-0.0386448912,
-0.0255465172,
-0.0384939611,
-0.036250338,
0.0041570463,
-0.0828199983,
0.0486141182,
0.0118686352,
-0.0234109778,
-0.0652183592,
0.0008055164,
0.0164599381,
-0.0331573933,
0.0196044464,
-0.0289264955,
0.0345564671,
0.0434852354,
-0.0162214097,
0.0252212193,
0.0663835406,
0.0760934949,
0.0048388601,
0.0579108,
0.0032384973,
0.0177798495,
0.0397871025,
-0.0070135933,
0.0253682975,
-0.060445372,
-0.0304666832,
-0.0486189686,
0.0158428699,
0.0164774805,
0.0620082431,
0.0053068097,
-0.0123146744,
0.0497163236,
0.0906193703,
-0.0259999186,
0.0069349087,
0.0447854064,
0.002691451,
0.038505137,
0.0061767581,
0.0064759003,
-0.0226128604,
0.0270968005,
-0.0249963515,
-0.0027550652,
0.0624218434,
-0.0010912314,
-0.0209554192,
-0.0064843995,
0.0124642188,
0.022594478,
-0.0013811289,
0.0645434558,
-0.037117064,
0.0055735148,
-0.012748261,
0.049381841,
-0.0282658208,
0.0162724368,
-0.0365137495,
0.0169477463,
0.0609836616,
0.0625808537,
-0.0591320023,
0.0469021201,
-0.0341392942,
0.0083782198,
0.0582176037,
0.0086595183,
-0.0333188735,
-0.018604001,
-0.0085122585,
0.0015418782,
-0.0089414166,
0.0047772704,
0.0250498094,
-0.038962543,
0.0358437523,
-0.0169903133,
-0.0220077187,
-0.0726501048,
0.028675139,
-0.0673306137,
-0.0078971963,
-0.0100495452,
0.0019411864,
0.0221001972,
0.0859707445,
-0.0341862254,
0.0016153199,
0.0049984381,
-0.0016562979,
-0.0145283295,
0.0335868187,
0.0599614456,
0.0498912111,
0.0466080159,
-0.0407784618,
-0.0062483293,
0.0206959303,
-0.0143188229,
-0.0169797111,
0.0403864495,
-0.0214477591,
0.0361800715,
-0.0417809486,
0.018365616,
-0.0534388237,
0.0178539176,
-0.0603132173,
0.0459781103,
-0.0153938876,
0.0176521279,
-0.0140068373,
-0.0849390402,
0.0494881943,
0.012419844,
-0.039989315,
0.0008371036,
0.0366006307,
0.0286903102,
0.0503500886,
-0.0819871798,
-0.0356430262,
0.0100122867,
-0.0786155388,
-0.007071069,
-0.0272508785,
0.0079448866,
-0.0082039377,
0.0074387463,
-0.0259445384,
0.0186011307,
0.035405349,
-0.0282192808,
-0.0041867667,
0.0250433441,
0.0398848467,
-0.0106182853,
0.0300975554,
-0.0320194289,
0.0025348209,
-0.0473514535,
0.0556380302,
0.0639688671,
-0.0397599116,
-0.0080955606,
-0.0016212848,
-0.0785547793,
0.0100289006,
-0.041641511,
-0.0108108353,
0.0011273057,
0.0050895861,
0.0176560581,
0.020954676,
-0.008223284,
0.0314944796,
0.0522681139,
-0.0246479269,
-0.0343190022,
-0.0280918181,
-0.0250535738,
-0.0142746363,
-0.019145254,
-0.0580642521,
0.0296144094,
0.0004760126,
0.0256037544,
-0.0069671297,
0.0027593058,
0.0336928591,
-0.0483269058,
-0.0156682655,
0.0028330612,
-0.0365201123,
-0.0112602543,
0.0966187939,
0.0057007596,
-0.0120231975,
0.0220143236,
-0.0069984486,
0.0538893566,
-0.0453547947,
-0.0583368316,
-0.0230368506,
0.0839958042,
-0.0025520963,
0.0165358316,
-0.0221515726,
-0.0043386281,
-0.0385011509,
-0.019928338,
0.0271818228,
-0.0357623659,
0.02847974,
-0.0552566759,
0.0215177089,
0.0130253788,
0.0323033854,
-0.0119609144,
-0.0543023609,
-0.0543115884,
-0.0149205262,
0.0391182005,
-0.0360587053,
0.0135777257,
0.0236401651,
0.0343621485,
0.0166027453,
0.0116275046,
0.0267380066,
-0.0200886633,
0.0146015547,
0.0356460735,
-0.0070242006,
0.017822206,
0.0139126442,
0.0024972125,
0.0125155766,
-0.0277492814,
0.0182025041,
-0.0411806256,
-0.0359351933,
0.0035550331,
-0.0332399718,
-0.0191244557,
-0.0218480937,
0.0238018688,
-0.0603513531,
0.0365809202,
0.1031491756,
0.0381606519,
-0.0650254637,
-0.0002923997,
-0.0293460954,
-0.0395477563,
0.0162440296,
0.0251959953,
-0.1189783663,
0.0397464819,
-0.0210038442,
0.0139914621,
-0.0491172299,
-0.0782841295,
-0.0068282257,
-0.111232914,
0.0510420427,
-0.0255960729,
-0.0070608589,
0.0073304316,
-0.0287864283,
0.015574079,
-0.0256728195,
-0.041536808,
-0.0224326979,
0.0220097639,
0.0128699299,
0.0153004276,
-0.0392245166,
-0.0541007407,
0.0105776638,
-0.055772569,
0.0422638282,
0.0162632819,
0.0825875625,
-0.0468858071,
-0.0293807313,
0.0257969331,
0.049913235,
-0.0125252092,
0.0100598652,
0.0499125794,
0.0158568472,
-0.0048198337,
-0.0175776463,
0.0061734654,
0.0269767549,
-0.0373907834,
0.0653394759,
0.0812292024,
-0.0158696659,
0.022504067,
-0.0279891472,
0.0141381295,
0.0383582599,
0.0432311371,
0.0116485097,
-0.045759201,
0.0015272067,
0.0005487215,
0.0327423587,
-0.0226374175,
-0.0598681942,
0.0165409576,
-0.0348878279,
-0.0436138958,
-0.0430119075,
-0.0623016991,
-0.0059355209,
0.0079056146,
0.0709604025,
0.0216383152,
0.0707801208,
-0.0271299817,
-0.0963093266,
0.0215152372,
-0.0309343543,
0.0178861376,
0.0251563806,
-0.0237078555,
-0.0007508282,
-0.0043406198,
0.0064450046,
-0.0262437034,
-0.0542753302,
-0.0703032538,
0.0296717566,
-0.0213071071,
0.0218786187,
0.0320244804,
-0.0155212097,
-0.0577752404,
0.0361132249,
0.0263480283,
-0.0342371427,
0.0231806524,
-0.0273572356,
0.0221207067,
-0.0357776992,
0.0000227757,
-0.0236098189,
0.0195880309,
-0.0133520523,
-0.0055716624,
-0.0654802173,
-0.0530549772,
-0.0095241126,
-0.0187236611,
0.021804966,
-0.0535015725,
-0.0164308976,
-0.0216187797,
-0.057946749,
-0.026680382,
-0.0346660465,
-0.0020848019,
-0.0107819503,
-0.0023318348,
-0.033636637,
-0.0316887945,
0.0156526938,
-0.0605832934,
0.0475593917,
-0.0469982587,
0.0207053348,
0.0198339578,
0.0611840822,
-0.0013398253,
0.013684513,
0.0137249716,
0.0413712822,
-0.0164716989,
0.0707150847,
0.0423028357,
0.0264596473,
0.0060384562,
-0.013257199,
0.0150854187,
0.0037176122,
-0.056914404,
-0.057869412,
0.010704604,
-0.0050395257,
0.0462560542,
-0.0228582527,
0.0402589478,
0.0108261928,
-0.0303905383,
-0.0171542317,
0.0188159999,
0.0216942541,
-0.010651568,
-0.0150319897,
0.0173591729,
-0.0639332607,
0.0641607642,
0.0183282923,
-0.0299178287,
0.0067094895,
0.0174715202,
-0.0836672112,
0.022741925,
-0.0494868122,
-0.017513901,
0.0014051498,
-0.0095696729,
-0.0022304221,
-0.1032520384,
-0.0467490703,
0.0000488582,
-0.0022836658,
-0.0031743795,
-0.0370479412,
-0.0300372355,
0.0411242619,
0.0113231568,
0.0539085492,
-0.0845769942,
0.0769819096,
-0.0629834086,
-0.0169029068,
0.029062476,
-6.607591867e-33,
-0.0053902669,
-0.0663434267,
0.0198262576,
-0.0278311148,
-0.0533956215,
0.0154857934,
-0.0378744267,
-0.0168773234,
-0.0244518742,
0.0441188104,
-0.0147106126,
0.0039496259,
0.0003121645,
-0.025357563,
0.059953969,
0.0139695881,
0.01933337,
0.0081354827,
-0.0180403162,
-0.0077960757,
0.0585575178,
-0.0271664076,
0.0329822451,
-0.1046641022,
0.0719744563,
-0.0091753118,
-0.0080352845,
0.0197011381,
0.0403441302,
0.0098199947,
-0.0045488528,
0.0154780587,
0.0152375689,
-0.0413334258,
0.0070391116,
-0.0052503748,
-0.0367431082,
0.0090450412,
0.0442205146,
0.031763535,
0.0424089879,
-0.0127309076,
0.0074548726,
-0.0188384652,
-0.0218291245,
0.0345295668,
0.0693351105,
-0.0287638791,
0.0124563742,
-0.0332357958,
-0.0712736771,
0.0305299237,
-0.0458969027,
0.0190368667,
-0.0214508492,
0.034508951,
0.0131931817,
0.0541161969,
-0.0749250576,
0.0325333178,
-0.0219297428,
-0.0275232662,
0.050774429,
-0.0073823137,
-0.0000358793,
0.0598137639,
0.0098897647,
0.0000340062,
-0.050460875,
0.018142283,
0.036468111,
0.0106157428,
0.0199594125,
0.0807209089,
-0.0084370701,
-0.0092236279,
-0.0522285029,
-0.0032353105,
0.0592524372,
0.0136224385,
0.0083636642,
-0.0028704223,
-0.0155445002,
-0.0368424281,
-0.0079648001,
-0.0454656407,
-0.0037030557,
-0.0177838057,
-0.022871783,
-0.0521805324,
-0.0265663099,
0.0429514982,
0.0408026166,
-0.0582452603,
-0.0199907422,
-0.0040529789,
-0.0345774889,
0.0482873283,
0.010499347,
0.038752906,
-0.0343310609,
0.0328502655,
0.0031536373,
0.039667815,
0.0405766293,
0.0016058644,
-0.0035454219,
0.008752685,
-0.0134841558,
-0.000591543,
-0.0110812355,
-0.0049678744,
-0.0179287791,
-0.0164292734,
0.0072904974,
0.0446641259,
-0.003817189,
-0.0043272409,
0.0917637199,
0.0284594744,
0.0224725269,
-0.0337445773,
-0.0030647521,
-0.0069977264,
-0.0305841416,
-0.0138724484,
0.0160735268,
0.0335481018,
0.0318609551,
-0.0459498242,
-0.013708951,
-0.0348906741,
3.127e-7,
0.0862123743,
0.0477861315,
0.0074857841,
-0.0234785397,
0.0109668812,
0.0009375794,
-0.0024319838,
-0.0061632805,
-0.0137840286,
-0.0091463542,
0.0275387634,
0.0168606956,
0.0536381118,
0.0605948605,
-0.0430122539,
-0.0503294244,
-0.0537909977,
-0.037091013,
-0.1017330363,
0.0260194,
0.0043311841,
0.03298847,
0.0563533604,
-0.0297365058,
-0.044048328,
-0.0101120062,
0.0080134217,
0.0012596464,
-0.0694226548,
0.0348392464,
0.0301372949,
0.0017850229,
0.0113211973,
0.0160421729,
-0.0102116186,
0.0338285156,
0.029516289,
0.0069452799,
-0.0044700317,
0.0199670754,
-0.0102798399,
-0.0344438478,
0.0159546062,
-0.0332513936,
0.0742970258,
0.0267218258,
-0.0216444321,
-0.0762798488,
-0.0507405028,
-0.0063935183,
0.068619892,
-0.0229346827,
-0.0097395694,
0.023026187,
0.0042914199,
0.0114455521,
-0.0099765984,
-0.0457302295,
0.0112333382,
0.0266022775,
-0.02008841,
-0.0644106418,
0.0436174124,
-0.0094684875,
0.0023648543,
-0.0608614609,
0.0542086959,
2.804672353e-34,
0.0773001537,
0.0106928116,
-0.0212700516,
0.0243290551,
0.043286331,
0.0356522575,
-0.0326623917,
0.0059612477,
0.011768084,
-0.0219798759,
0.0057885973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13638v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13638v1 | Embers of Autoregression: Understanding Large Language Models Through the Problem They are Trained to Solve | 2023-09-24T13:35:28 | 2023-09-24T13:35:28 | R. Thomas McCoy, Shunyu Yao, Dan Friedman, Matthew Hardy, Thomas L. Griffiths | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The widespread adoption of large language models (LLMs) makes it important to
recognize their strengths and limitations. We argue that in order to develop a
holistic understanding of these systems we need to consider the problem that
they were trained to solve: next-word prediction over Internet text. By
recognizing the pressures that this task exerts we can make predictions about
the strategies that LLMs will adopt, allowing us to reason about when they will
succeed or fail. This approach - which we call the teleological approach -
leads us to identify three factors that we hypothesize will influence LLM
accuracy: the probability of the task to be performed, the probability of the
target output, and the probability of the provided input. We predict that LLMs
will achieve higher accuracy when these probabilities are high than when they
are low - even in deterministic settings where probability should not matter.
To test our predictions, we evaluate two LLMs (GPT-3.5 and GPT-4) on eleven
tasks, and we find robust evidence that LLMs are influenced by probability in
the ways that we have hypothesized. In many cases, the experiments reveal
surprising failure modes. For instance, GPT-4's accuracy at decoding a simple
cipher is 51% when the output is a high-probability word sequence but only 13%
when it is low-probability. These results show that AI practitioners should be
careful about using LLMs in low-probability situations. More broadly, we
conclude that we should not evaluate LLMs as if they are humans but should
instead treat them as a distinct type of system - one that has been shaped by
its own particular set of pressures. | [
0.0484494381,
0.0673109293,
-0.0277193319,
-0.0026010678,
-0.0740669444,
0.009439135,
-0.0075110649,
0.0147694759,
0.0111894812,
-0.0432247259,
0.006134985,
-0.0604811683,
0.0379915237,
0.0238093436,
0.0256739911,
-0.0371717177,
0.0128124505,
-0.0724871308,
0.0191059019,
-0.0227118414,
-0.016465541,
0.0023385845,
-0.0009649966,
0.0714121014,
0.0399687849,
0.013598212,
-0.0110809105,
-0.0209307745,
-0.0364058949,
-0.0191301517,
-0.0002390208,
0.0465742648,
0.0070730671,
0.0613268986,
0.0000021643,
-0.0501262508,
0.0104641477,
-0.0077207885,
-0.0482775681,
0.0270621181,
0.0043455879,
-0.0210158043,
-0.0258528776,
0.041955892,
-0.037531551,
-0.0051726857,
0.0378448442,
0.001880087,
-0.0183536429,
0.0765462816,
0.0003524545,
0.0095194355,
0.0855267346,
-0.0223421492,
0.0172254853,
-0.0601056926,
0.0265187863,
0.0045629372,
-0.003016999,
0.0166107621,
-0.0247846823,
0.0095077287,
0.0064444449,
0.0257403292,
-0.0403726473,
0.0593472235,
-0.0092312191,
-0.0627632141,
-0.0348180272,
0.0074286498,
-0.0464444719,
-0.0146254282,
0.0109196259,
-0.0184084661,
-0.0256801639,
0.0297810175,
-0.0474724509,
0.051528383,
-0.0111374073,
0.0269239768,
0.0152284997,
0.0282794181,
0.0386111885,
0.012687414,
-0.0471677408,
0.0832708403,
0.0067203571,
-0.0361450538,
0.0064048367,
0.0110804569,
0.0078090327,
-0.0767266825,
0.0071360897,
0.0229538921,
0.0090844985,
0.0455808192,
-0.0386837274,
-0.0133616375,
0.0317713842,
-0.0376653746,
0.0459981561,
0.0342280641,
0.0179170389,
0.0071178204,
-0.0115519445,
0.0399132557,
0.0038618024,
-0.0138082663,
0.0036761423,
0.0192623734,
-0.0387835167,
-0.0297161005,
-0.0093746753,
0.0191255696,
0.0321947597,
-0.0551775917,
-0.0315157883,
0.0014041287,
0.0198103394,
0.000452113,
-0.0256505534,
-0.0091406833,
-0.0261690058,
-0.0385445505,
-0.0499642156,
0.0033712287,
-0.0010170512,
0.0235217344,
-0.0218671858,
-0.0548158102,
-0.0022124071,
0.0061566159,
0.003605708,
-0.0325178877,
-0.0000132623,
0.0822210535,
0.0060643321,
-0.0571635328,
-0.0418152511,
-0.0236320719,
-0.0169106666,
-0.0453391783,
-0.0033204751,
-0.0376286544,
-0.0142845865,
0.0567891784,
-0.0164142977,
-0.0097251907,
0.0297965519,
0.0196746252,
-0.0726746991,
0.1027964503,
0.0324611366,
0.0362313613,
0.0320205502,
0.007597859,
0.0047194315,
0.0536446348,
0.0394183844,
0.0639067143,
0.0259016212,
-0.0183422528,
0.0443132743,
0.0567187071,
-0.0125661222,
0.0105754249,
-0.0120184934,
-0.0151644778,
0.0162076391,
0.0122815371,
0.0315810218,
0.0593680628,
-0.0038917314,
0.0155768208,
0.1073539034,
0.0801019222,
0.0171776693,
0.043958731,
0.0273832288,
0.0032591668,
0.0100967158,
0.0299597438,
-0.0744025558,
0.0037697197,
-0.039530091,
0.0248891264,
0.0473942533,
0.0179666262,
-0.0072944891,
-0.0497080274,
-0.0313313268,
-0.0433663577,
0.0137541853,
-0.00572416,
0.0893885791,
-0.0263075605,
-0.0685027763,
-0.0027784875,
0.0019266927,
-0.0061540357,
-0.0029082107,
-0.0900413543,
0.0079269782,
0.0427169763,
0.0667570233,
0.0030510696,
0.0002352118,
0.0170938354,
-0.0117356144,
0.0372918881,
0.0337235369,
0.0322147757,
-0.0294486731,
-0.0409233384,
-0.0175627377,
0.0412311219,
0.007352537,
0.0266055297,
-0.0024904141,
0.0297800079,
0.0201463737,
-0.0066396613,
-0.0365937613,
0.0382908024,
-0.0303482078,
-0.0104728956,
-0.0291714426,
-0.0147961462,
0.0163476709,
-0.0204628427,
-0.0324702971,
0.0505335219,
0.0241480619,
-0.0333390124,
-0.0413195528,
-0.0315454118,
-0.0320917107,
0.060166724,
0.0538445525,
-0.0221986175,
0.0563470833,
0.0358481742,
0.0192472823,
-0.0374497175,
0.0423607938,
-0.0652985573,
0.0910289809,
-0.0228113402,
0.0295240376,
-0.0027655833,
0.0230447445,
-0.0178571455,
0.0471324883,
-0.0054587279,
-0.001519246,
-0.0277032275,
-0.0108130565,
0.0240817405,
-0.0329043418,
-0.0113517577,
0.0095254909,
0.0117839528,
0.0169025306,
0.0706806928,
-0.0182817187,
-0.0096835038,
-0.0415036641,
-0.0687894747,
-0.0175250918,
-0.0173010714,
0.0326080061,
-0.0246385168,
-0.0165343024,
-0.0404125676,
-0.0164379869,
-0.0090983361,
-0.0010345718,
-0.013293487,
0.0277432483,
0.0433821715,
-0.0017469476,
-0.0275761578,
-0.053584408,
-0.0204168763,
-0.0211067628,
0.0385306962,
0.0191731062,
-0.0246549863,
-0.0637342855,
0.0685094371,
0.0003101498,
0.0111800656,
-0.0347934291,
-0.0554251857,
0.0036735628,
-0.0293353759,
0.0296782479,
0.0401675552,
0.0274082907,
0.0079662576,
0.0679680258,
0.0034372737,
-0.0416040234,
-0.0233443528,
-0.0215771012,
-0.0607788377,
-0.0467252582,
-0.0468251966,
-0.017183546,
0.042638775,
0.0358125307,
0.014993378,
-0.0554902293,
0.0306336209,
-0.0168835148,
-0.0221287776,
-0.0298471563,
-0.0398123786,
-0.0315514654,
0.0685314909,
-0.0093717072,
-0.0801528171,
0.0618568957,
-0.0257116053,
0.0167000536,
-0.0208732784,
-0.023929989,
-0.0015551401,
0.0722833723,
0.0346294343,
0.0188190173,
0.0330136754,
-0.0222951043,
-0.0555026941,
-0.0033975008,
-0.0132263154,
-0.0323847532,
0.0274809469,
-0.0535105579,
0.0233343337,
0.0021825065,
-0.038207043,
-0.0330663659,
-0.0471480489,
-0.0596950576,
-0.0238767546,
0.0166245643,
-0.0421395414,
-0.0193444211,
0.0314277858,
0.020565128,
0.0113042286,
-0.0249864068,
-0.0300576445,
0.0064963768,
0.0137169799,
0.0783040002,
-0.0324162617,
0.0414938293,
-0.0126425596,
0.0031304848,
0.0261372291,
0.0364449285,
0.0421585143,
-0.0487941056,
-0.0112837134,
0.0359307751,
-0.033496011,
-0.0671998188,
0.0551101044,
0.0280762129,
-0.0440708809,
-0.004773662,
0.1299563795,
0.022398131,
-0.0435825624,
0.0052398359,
-0.0036633776,
-0.0038630494,
0.0053508747,
0.0333840661,
-0.0646972954,
-0.0150448522,
0.0099548418,
0.0366617255,
-0.0510636456,
-0.0287840255,
-0.0065677701,
-0.1195554584,
0.0380623564,
0.0121190315,
0.0326526575,
-0.032873366,
-0.0685092807,
-0.0245837718,
-0.0204771869,
0.0286723394,
0.0020357454,
0.001281222,
0.0107838921,
0.0109247221,
-0.088150315,
-0.0109251235,
0.0229043476,
-0.0168284159,
0.0672432855,
0.0878457874,
0.0239139441,
-0.0496649742,
-0.0235980526,
0.0251462869,
-0.0079165399,
0.0164902676,
0.0304984134,
0.0385378115,
0.0235909745,
0.0037265229,
-0.0380892307,
0.0281522945,
-0.0415502824,
-0.0166026037,
0.012834141,
0.0659954324,
-0.0493765846,
-0.0792740062,
-0.0308573768,
-0.0083687101,
0.009545139,
0.0816886351,
-0.000189557,
-0.0351236351,
-0.0743271932,
-0.0390303507,
0.0436849333,
-0.0044986187,
-0.0281999409,
0.004026331,
0.0242932606,
-0.0372311808,
-0.0437654965,
-0.0323589146,
-0.0116859283,
-0.0053947372,
0.0175839495,
0.0217596032,
0.0260440111,
0.0176108461,
-0.0124482373,
-0.0329109617,
-0.0101589989,
-0.0011663006,
-0.0447394252,
0.0055391709,
0.017195899,
-0.0411339179,
-0.004414795,
-0.0035750712,
-0.081554696,
-0.0618654639,
0.0085662743,
0.042073451,
0.0405310392,
-0.0126705673,
-0.0072049205,
-0.0753929019,
0.0710736066,
0.0248977952,
-0.0431947,
0.0075366679,
0.0338172056,
0.0138550857,
-0.0038073987,
0.0248733647,
-0.0124750361,
0.0064953873,
-0.0183732621,
0.0108728288,
-0.0246763006,
-0.0496539325,
0.0147302812,
0.0078987433,
0.0470114201,
-0.0496256463,
0.0125249447,
0.0150789963,
-0.0066284616,
0.001032058,
0.0100675477,
0.0066213193,
-0.0049435836,
0.0534111671,
0.0134486947,
-0.01030437,
-0.0264303014,
-0.0245092958,
-0.0111954054,
-0.0201468188,
0.0127677917,
0.0191612784,
0.0340064093,
0.069334887,
-0.0326414034,
-0.0062695043,
0.0587661862,
-0.0136487782,
0.0343327858,
-0.0049834945,
0.0258409698,
-0.0071633467,
-0.0108409151,
-0.0138146402,
0.0038789585,
-0.1063676775,
-0.0822604448,
0.005745078,
0.0500161126,
0.0665981695,
-0.0021083064,
0.024384683,
-0.0634063482,
0.0201713033,
-0.0335977152,
-0.0140336491,
0.0082870675,
0.0250624269,
0.0092853662,
0.0057637878,
-0.0490411073,
0.0387002565,
0.1026711985,
0.0011536119,
0.0807896256,
0.0064396891,
-0.0655339435,
-0.0130636953,
-0.0459566005,
0.0191425625,
0.0478392169,
-0.0440805666,
-0.0189449452,
-0.0646811575,
-0.0569007322,
0.0009010424,
0.0274088066,
0.0242707729,
-0.0377993025,
0.006553133,
0.0744884536,
-0.0235625934,
0.0310040396,
-0.0411912762,
0.0207853485,
-0.0130797876,
-0.0141666997,
-0.0247709677,
-6.628392239e-33,
0.0219396669,
-0.0213527381,
0.0040388592,
0.0259943195,
0.0093670338,
-0.0132478774,
-0.0293073393,
0.0142055517,
-0.0141305011,
-0.0027721468,
-0.0410381965,
-0.0045049549,
0.0111237457,
0.0144957099,
0.0500239991,
-0.0120074246,
0.0098179262,
-0.0149593418,
-0.0008000672,
-0.0074988892,
0.0109237293,
0.028098952,
0.0065379222,
-0.0391836464,
0.0412299037,
-0.0175031703,
-0.0108566256,
-0.0205886029,
0.026550021,
0.0580069534,
-0.0536317453,
0.0595370308,
0.0221159887,
-0.0502716601,
-0.0185972713,
0.051568836,
-0.0002401421,
-0.0288705789,
0.001401501,
0.0067707868,
0.0177156553,
-0.0173867103,
0.0347275846,
-0.0018072787,
-0.0724242479,
0.0212161038,
0.0452876091,
-0.0167905446,
-0.0477145091,
-0.017212864,
-0.0309542306,
0.024662327,
-0.0028676861,
-0.0190046709,
0.0186265875,
-0.0187455826,
0.0034459841,
-0.0107240761,
-0.0243200473,
0.0327478498,
0.0223878678,
0.0370097607,
0.0577040128,
0.0088974042,
-0.0081110522,
0.0539305918,
0.0424660444,
-0.0222668741,
-0.0266308654,
-0.0300871246,
0.0371818244,
0.0056737764,
-0.0022405714,
0.0214273613,
0.0391419604,
-0.0179715455,
-0.05133757,
0.0127968537,
0.0542042479,
0.0119743962,
0.0500070937,
0.0096403994,
-0.0732276365,
-0.0443300903,
-0.0218158811,
-0.055827152,
-0.0163944792,
-0.0323811211,
-0.0005071828,
0.0120652337,
0.038655974,
-0.0079883561,
0.023380179,
-0.0595255084,
-0.0111898035,
0.006705571,
-0.0199438147,
-0.0030482132,
-0.0140815275,
0.0453333072,
-0.0444788001,
-0.0260065477,
-0.0260093398,
0.0175461583,
-0.002604834,
0.0081799002,
-0.0178178884,
0.0384541973,
-0.0701040551,
-0.0290081613,
-0.0362663344,
-0.0100533413,
0.0488185771,
-0.0143881068,
0.0627041236,
-0.0130463354,
0.0040554521,
0.0087403618,
0.0143247508,
0.0027929719,
-0.0004217888,
0.0114190131,
-0.011196021,
-0.005926609,
-0.0317952707,
-0.0190499984,
-0.0459809154,
0.0494258925,
0.0256729685,
-0.0389904603,
-0.031945236,
0.0253102668,
2.904e-7,
0.0733538792,
0.0788362622,
0.020361457,
0.0290109776,
0.0300910491,
0.0483341813,
-0.0184714384,
0.0245188437,
-0.0122296792,
0.006675581,
0.0250680689,
0.0166679788,
0.0376984328,
0.0175400339,
-0.0499471202,
-0.0203679521,
-0.0704279765,
0.0113509111,
-0.0728447437,
0.022826504,
0.0731393173,
0.0860211179,
0.0273567773,
-0.018589044,
-0.0098662814,
-0.0504563227,
0.0471379198,
-0.0305467006,
-0.0123339277,
0.0089115566,
0.011877846,
0.0590939,
-0.0164502393,
0.048250664,
-0.00209963,
0.0002904307,
-0.0045682862,
0.0405169576,
0.0061313487,
-0.0294681266,
-0.0033411218,
-0.0016531762,
0.0155748287,
-0.0754836202,
0.0769707114,
-0.0322107226,
-0.0442467444,
-0.018050041,
0.0149942758,
-0.0176359098,
0.0168763809,
-0.0287139844,
-0.0177604649,
0.0185542814,
-0.0052625984,
0.0053848,
0.0118831182,
-0.0833281055,
0.011468811,
0.0277542789,
-0.0262910854,
-0.063732937,
-0.0744880438,
0.0027523539,
0.0659654364,
-0.0584081188,
0.0081561096,
2.846547733e-34,
0.0167292878,
-0.0183038954,
-0.0124027692,
-0.008209412,
0.0329640508,
0.0087915063,
0.0378363654,
0.0556358807,
0.0301686302,
-0.0723764822,
-0.0389136076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13633v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13633v2 | EvalLM: Interactive Evaluation of Large Language Model Prompts on User-Defined Criteria | 2023-09-24T13:19:38 | 2024-02-27T17:10:30 | Tae Soo Kim, Yoonjoo Lee, Jamin Shin, Young-Ho Kim, Juho Kim | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | By simply composing prompts, developers can prototype novel generative
applications with Large Language Models (LLMs). To refine prototypes into
products, however, developers must iteratively revise prompts by evaluating
outputs to diagnose weaknesses. Formative interviews (N=8) revealed that
developers invest significant effort in manually evaluating outputs as they
assess context-specific and subjective criteria. We present EvalLM, an
interactive system for iteratively refining prompts by evaluating multiple
outputs on user-defined criteria. By describing criteria in natural language,
users can employ the system's LLM-based evaluator to get an overview of where
prompts excel or fail, and improve these based on the evaluator's feedback. A
comparative study (N=12) showed that EvalLM, when compared to manual
evaluation, helped participants compose more diverse criteria, examine twice as
many outputs, and reach satisfactory prompts with 59% fewer revisions. Beyond
prompts, our work can be extended to augment model evaluation and alignment in
specific application contexts. | [
0.0308655165,
0.052525036,
-0.0388340391,
0.0111319283,
-0.040381521,
-0.0171438288,
0.0254742019,
-0.0225418676,
-0.0045065079,
-0.0372758023,
-0.0369143896,
-0.0187755488,
0.0315206423,
0.0563499779,
0.0027646082,
-0.0372522101,
0.0153903719,
-0.0209342204,
0.0110796131,
0.0557103828,
0.0141592268,
0.036634583,
-0.0286506098,
0.0696510673,
0.0204246938,
-0.0530943871,
-0.0158495326,
0.0027210612,
-0.0038445252,
-0.0495257787,
-0.0374270193,
0.0782215744,
-0.0292582028,
-0.0058466652,
0.0000023599,
-0.0816760436,
0.0180230197,
0.008298724,
-0.0178929605,
0.0351238325,
0.0873192772,
0.0648520216,
-0.0368326157,
0.0197427068,
-0.0192091558,
-0.0305895712,
0.0464274287,
-0.0344078057,
0.0586960316,
-0.0210990887,
-0.0100548137,
0.0181078147,
-0.0317769945,
0.0126429303,
0.0100270249,
0.0209666193,
-0.0513011143,
-0.0109583363,
0.0804759413,
0.0107853673,
0.0428362675,
0.0206345618,
0.0126852626,
-0.0438150875,
0.0465429835,
0.0137804793,
0.0216541532,
-0.0820223093,
0.0068676854,
0.0470998101,
0.0288419742,
0.0131601812,
-0.0357690454,
-0.05196473,
0.0188275501,
0.0010339586,
-0.036393743,
0.0173052326,
-0.0144794164,
-0.0184652247,
-0.0483899713,
-0.0011938121,
0.0082548698,
-0.0021267855,
0.0168979894,
0.0383657068,
0.0309639927,
0.0211570971,
-0.0149634592,
-0.0078239152,
0.0214295406,
-0.0595806278,
-0.0082632722,
0.0126232943,
-0.0666892603,
0.0050355992,
0.0177753642,
-0.007272312,
0.057292413,
-0.0184737016,
0.0407484397,
0.025777936,
-0.0287185311,
0.0150799034,
0.017545918,
0.0673749074,
0.0232078005,
-0.0439710617,
-0.0393746309,
0.0292020943,
-0.0082539907,
-0.0397526026,
-0.0200950634,
-0.0063831941,
-0.0100463191,
0.0176386703,
-0.0286288243,
0.0533043779,
-0.0006061872,
0.0497966446,
-0.0007150382,
-0.0045875842,
0.017989235,
0.0042086034,
-0.0423002467,
0.0163767226,
-0.040835008,
0.0010780769,
0.0171230342,
-0.0871216804,
0.0290228892,
0.0290001165,
-0.021751985,
0.0022726667,
-0.021735765,
0.0591313727,
0.0063332319,
0.0367633551,
-0.0154186999,
-0.0383944884,
0.005658586,
-0.0160252731,
-0.0449707359,
-0.0917168111,
-0.0291598197,
0.0554120615,
-0.0061297179,
-0.0671913549,
0.0009026922,
0.0311358906,
0.0501847491,
0.0521821678,
-0.0548089184,
0.0196593348,
0.0224034246,
0.0296515115,
0.0120421173,
0.0495150983,
0.0237410218,
0.0626515001,
0.0250433106,
-0.0345809981,
0.046957761,
0.0352771059,
-0.0670103431,
-0.0045236526,
-0.0288391579,
0.0178536866,
0.0063234246,
0.0269205216,
-0.0252693817,
0.0240955688,
-0.0193328895,
0.0736713409,
0.0692980811,
0.0420616604,
0.0475700349,
0.027059054,
0.0619166456,
0.0183767509,
-0.0188699495,
-0.0199165493,
-0.0010787211,
0.0359987356,
-0.0294716712,
0.0222732574,
-0.0274237599,
0.0429862589,
0.0165073257,
-0.0592391789,
-0.0108060203,
0.0287564676,
0.0330769122,
0.0269454233,
0.0056464691,
0.0289044492,
-0.0190157201,
0.0143415155,
0.006357586,
-0.0653075576,
-0.0098926229,
-0.0399667583,
0.0660790354,
0.133894816,
0.0560422465,
0.0023044366,
-0.0137767792,
-0.0014793767,
-0.0486364663,
0.0107992245,
0.0693837777,
-0.0251748376,
-0.0247068778,
-0.0063267131,
-0.0350575745,
-0.0387789719,
-0.0081523862,
0.023316199,
-0.0273032393,
-0.00016505,
0.0294172671,
-0.036462903,
-0.038416639,
0.0120944418,
0.0071025584,
-0.0398151129,
-0.0119432956,
0.0086953668,
0.0027271258,
0.0358374715,
-0.0014346993,
0.0338937528,
0.0262403041,
-0.0218404233,
-0.0064794035,
0.0103175454,
0.0042648455,
0.0340558738,
0.0119271092,
0.0046221702,
-0.0130707808,
-0.0257046595,
-0.0113452077,
0.0036756722,
0.0249301828,
-0.0028644814,
0.0178455263,
-0.0161820278,
0.0355843231,
-0.0335575826,
-0.038470082,
-0.0460528582,
0.0239849798,
0.0478343889,
0.011193594,
0.0289051514,
0.0238267556,
0.0113921054,
-0.0095025823,
-0.0124464715,
0.0606486388,
0.0074689919,
0.0256392006,
0.0222540069,
0.0462411568,
-0.0340013839,
-0.0380225033,
-0.1122156531,
-0.0284065269,
-0.0011180098,
0.0186035354,
0.0223485269,
0.0454931445,
0.0010368928,
0.0147373509,
-0.0326104723,
-0.0396137498,
0.0198995844,
0.013334238,
0.0364973135,
-0.0133733572,
-0.0413019136,
-0.0196044035,
-0.0008286752,
-0.0106812082,
0.0470620357,
0.054563459,
0.0156652499,
-0.0768398717,
0.0217517335,
-0.0190298408,
-0.0314273722,
0.0246261097,
0.011576782,
0.0359475464,
-0.0011799517,
0.0504493117,
-0.0020387978,
0.0010193177,
0.0357977487,
0.049379319,
-0.0385659598,
-0.068982698,
-0.0241588,
0.050946705,
-0.0080044493,
0.0292531308,
-0.0507443137,
0.045562949,
0.0320903622,
0.0092409682,
0.0232906993,
-0.0084447749,
0.0696752518,
-0.037919838,
0.0217650197,
-0.0209712349,
-0.0368867591,
-0.0208172258,
0.0762994066,
0.0032680039,
-0.0670955032,
0.0626319647,
-0.0700898319,
-0.0320314951,
-0.0117496131,
-0.0040173256,
-0.0378659554,
0.0890355408,
-0.0643889755,
0.0129895071,
0.0424535871,
-0.0039641056,
-0.0106760161,
-0.0039125546,
0.0224465169,
-0.0336951278,
0.0253472049,
-0.0684126467,
-0.0151911955,
-0.0154148741,
-0.0236184858,
-0.0308001749,
-0.0231276136,
-0.0153138703,
-0.0029254076,
0.052598305,
0.0162882544,
0.017808767,
0.0345101021,
0.0181806702,
0.0497096442,
0.0298344418,
-0.0223576911,
-0.0178542398,
-0.0338922963,
0.0206711497,
-0.0041412972,
0.0122000528,
0.0035247274,
0.0241748542,
0.0223982278,
-0.0302605219,
-0.0013914008,
-0.0473857261,
0.0087901447,
0.0433301516,
-0.0317022055,
-0.0206431486,
0.0592187271,
0.0311052613,
-0.0387315936,
0.0107499501,
0.0800985992,
0.0268384758,
-0.0389853679,
0.0226507969,
-0.0222058967,
0.0222393349,
0.0565007813,
0.0411633961,
-0.0871261656,
-0.0060966872,
0.0027524512,
0.0268053133,
-0.0085926186,
0.0282015074,
-0.0185826104,
-0.1186532155,
0.0589759238,
-0.00439688,
-0.0149994604,
0.0194092114,
-0.0068613891,
-0.0033272887,
0.0114314621,
0.0135030793,
0.0427410677,
-0.0199257862,
0.0168301016,
-0.0240229256,
-0.0687114224,
-0.0656305403,
0.0342343524,
-0.0156040611,
0.011727076,
0.0954219177,
0.0114751505,
0.0436248966,
-0.0541835018,
0.0240242444,
-0.0187654216,
0.0182453431,
-0.0169893112,
-0.0320050344,
0.0528447852,
-0.0013966735,
-0.0362738632,
-0.0141587406,
-0.0250005368,
-0.0507552959,
0.0286406968,
0.0393880308,
-0.0371777304,
0.0160776973,
-0.0250335932,
-0.0059076664,
0.0156043312,
0.0139357317,
0.0706567764,
-0.0712766349,
-0.0194922388,
-0.0464966409,
-0.0155108022,
-0.0386828296,
-0.0583666563,
-0.0233922452,
0.0320030823,
-0.0089192595,
-0.0557625927,
-0.0384431109,
0.0123575134,
0.0206692815,
0.0150993755,
-0.023848502,
-0.013153431,
0.0076959142,
-0.0027876615,
0.0429725312,
0.0482522994,
0.0184002612,
-0.0340946764,
0.0045404402,
0.0125683006,
-0.0567154102,
-0.0103802001,
0.0364680849,
-0.034906622,
-0.0190901775,
-0.0150770135,
0.0499340557,
0.0235215668,
-0.0348467566,
-0.0429989509,
-0.0664984211,
-0.014683797,
0.0291192718,
-0.0379813612,
-0.0240489002,
-0.0277504008,
0.0398199186,
-0.0073483102,
-0.033948414,
-0.0331218988,
0.011056846,
0.0226680506,
0.0090955822,
0.0077621085,
-0.0701119676,
0.0343033522,
0.0570703857,
0.0363291167,
-0.038694784,
0.0147919925,
-0.0338724256,
-0.0180218797,
-0.0230342615,
-0.0594370961,
-0.0482525975,
0.020909613,
-0.0242599435,
-0.0534061752,
0.0431907289,
0.0113373268,
-0.0702880695,
0.0265592113,
-0.0592018068,
0.0763335526,
-0.0057067089,
0.0166363362,
0.0400877818,
-0.0134448987,
-0.0315673128,
0.0129838074,
-0.059268821,
0.0384617336,
-0.0080944262,
0.0612546206,
-0.0136602661,
0.0260029174,
0.010713961,
0.0524747297,
0.0308403168,
-0.0736072287,
-0.0312857851,
0.0417018607,
0.0098784026,
0.0381346829,
0.0211562347,
-0.0336188115,
0.0075023496,
-0.0148896901,
0.0110892896,
0.0122873066,
-0.057979878,
-0.0120344348,
0.030516224,
-0.0319043696,
-0.1076625064,
0.0236995202,
-0.0702011362,
-0.0269076526,
-0.0445178896,
-0.0337598287,
-0.0437329933,
-0.0249809939,
0.0187268872,
-0.0448113233,
-0.0449584164,
-0.025620291,
-0.0843557417,
-0.0346891098,
-0.0332015194,
0.032040447,
0.0074265972,
-0.0119060306,
0.0287817903,
0.0846040919,
-0.0075090644,
-0.0362476073,
-0.0313465707,
-0.0189112518,
-0.0463697203,
0.0014671431,
-0.0669155717,
-6.168591746e-33,
-0.0292166788,
-0.0374412723,
0.0301970895,
-0.0183779374,
0.0021815957,
-0.0345040113,
-0.0439790972,
0.0549132563,
0.0495854802,
-0.0288243424,
0.0035424856,
-0.0584699698,
-0.011159013,
-0.015042441,
0.0474433489,
0.0245528631,
0.0707180724,
0.0412805639,
-0.092011258,
0.0091697741,
-0.0309871454,
-0.0165679548,
-0.0036989718,
-0.0499260016,
0.0354550853,
-0.0028602188,
-0.0387875512,
-0.0093149561,
-0.0077548861,
0.0453661978,
0.0050074724,
0.0176665727,
0.0174953043,
-0.0746914968,
-0.0307449475,
0.0212475359,
-0.0220004655,
-0.0234048571,
0.0300705135,
0.0177059919,
-0.0222930331,
-0.0397826098,
0.0362219997,
-0.0048612482,
-0.0294185188,
0.0467757545,
0.021930078,
-0.0216674004,
-0.0031069962,
-0.0312551633,
-0.0601476878,
0.0211434886,
-0.0225416981,
0.0024621468,
-0.0229127444,
0.0805983692,
-0.0257368013,
-0.0053933016,
-0.0251923762,
0.0131417336,
0.0401800312,
0.0176374484,
0.1001838893,
0.0281746313,
-0.0193918794,
0.0266237464,
-0.0184188113,
0.0074627292,
-0.04134316,
0.0126515767,
0.0256976634,
0.0256309006,
0.0379665829,
0.0409101434,
0.0076705483,
-0.000165175,
0.0294091739,
0.0431599468,
-0.0419880636,
0.0285302326,
0.039555572,
0.0357428603,
0.0023571576,
-0.0308254752,
-0.0485253111,
0.0137420902,
-0.0497804917,
-0.0567722246,
0.0327881463,
-0.008547076,
-0.0153965633,
-0.0253922436,
-0.0213787369,
0.0131028863,
-0.0305202026,
-0.0121808061,
-0.0608079173,
0.0306188501,
-0.0288627893,
-0.0284824073,
0.0224143416,
0.0309144538,
-0.00146588,
0.0500722155,
0.066655159,
0.0307113621,
-0.0400404111,
0.0110546397,
-0.0734441951,
0.0125441169,
-0.02512764,
0.0202216972,
-0.0114907781,
0.0100860344,
0.0135400547,
-0.0380178392,
-0.0235038921,
0.040010795,
-0.0180757884,
-0.0119224899,
-0.0551779978,
-0.0118567832,
-0.0032377562,
0.0003510417,
-0.0260513108,
-0.03049073,
-0.014331446,
0.0122902002,
0.0640405491,
0.0321569666,
-0.0357495919,
0.0099132955,
2.986e-7,
0.0106515521,
0.0166549701,
-0.0319796838,
0.0155822709,
0.0149854189,
0.0372002982,
0.0099776275,
-0.0047131372,
0.0169773605,
-0.0028458475,
0.0110978689,
0.0181272011,
0.0533538945,
0.0620497391,
-0.0590130985,
0.0445947126,
-0.0440415926,
0.0451521054,
-0.0619466975,
0.0514004827,
0.0815239027,
0.0130336834,
-0.002826822,
0.0009043036,
0.0274054594,
-0.0258321874,
-0.0147645576,
-0.0476291776,
0.0335877612,
0.0488374457,
0.0322298445,
-0.0399805754,
0.0128739765,
0.0040758201,
0.0033089144,
-0.073071599,
-0.0073834453,
0.0453176461,
-0.0004150131,
0.0364253893,
0.0164863318,
-0.0145640019,
0.0164231267,
-0.0913658664,
0.0247284602,
-0.0189250521,
-0.013350524,
-0.0462774634,
0.0155622791,
-0.0461421609,
0.0311505087,
-0.0355701633,
0.012347891,
0.0023219439,
-0.0044066128,
-0.0208000876,
-0.0405838713,
0.00167853,
-0.0420770086,
0.0320671499,
-0.0304845609,
-0.0290481281,
-0.0671840757,
0.0134243155,
-0.0129622994,
-0.0387699194,
0.0485695563,
2.739379152e-34,
0.0223202519,
0.0051931501,
0.031799756,
0.0197849404,
0.0692752898,
0.0431639478,
0.0026191177,
0.0291606002,
0.0165751632,
-0.036078278,
-0.0135809751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14374v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14374v1 | A Text Classification-Based Approach for Evaluating and Enhancing the Machine Interpretability of Building Codes | 2023-09-24T11:36:21 | 2023-09-24T11:36:21 | Zhe Zheng, Yu-Cheng Zhou, Ke-Yin Chen, Xin-Zheng Lu, Zhong-Tian She, Jia-Rui Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Interpreting regulatory documents or building codes into computer-processable
formats is essential for the intelligent design and construction of buildings
and infrastructures. Although automated rule interpretation (ARI) methods have
been investigated for years, most of them highly depend on the early and manual
filtering of interpretable clauses from a building code. While few of them
considered machine interpretability, which represents the potential to be
transformed into a computer-processable format, from both clause- and
document-level. Therefore, this research aims to propose a novel approach to
automatically evaluate and enhance the machine interpretability of single
clause and building codes. First, a few categories are introduced to classify
each clause in a building code considering the requirements for rule
interpretation, and a dataset is developed for model training. Then, an
efficient text classification model is developed based on a pretrained
domain-specific language model and transfer learning techniques. Finally, a
quantitative evaluation method is proposed to assess the overall
interpretability of building codes. Experiments show that the proposed text
classification algorithm outperforms the existing CNN- or RNN-based methods,
improving the F1-score from 72.16% to 93.60%. It is also illustrated that the
proposed classification method can enhance downstream ARI methods with an
improvement of 4%. Furthermore, analyzing the results of more than 150 building
codes in China showed that their average interpretability is 34.40%, which
implies that it is still hard to fully transform the entire regulatory document
into computer-processable formats. It is also argued that the interpretability
of building codes should be further improved both from the human side and the
machine side. | [
0.0056213881,
0.0442253426,
-0.0144996289,
0.0445202179,
-0.0091809714,
0.0301254597,
0.0234788638,
0.0190096907,
0.0120044481,
-0.0074214507,
-0.0251617208,
0.0043121851,
-0.0087759867,
0.0541339852,
-0.0375946797,
-0.0206153858,
-0.0018101106,
0.018620709,
0.0373106934,
0.0600704066,
-0.0107925395,
0.0242647547,
-0.010885532,
0.0323351808,
-0.0056120604,
-0.0172321741,
-0.0198632572,
-0.023523761,
0.0279783756,
-0.026442131,
0.0029767377,
0.0260743964,
0.0202921256,
0.0319913961,
0.0000021901,
-0.0060536987,
-0.103381604,
0.0095644379,
0.0097294683,
0.003449078,
0.0253414027,
-0.0635455921,
-0.0325493254,
-0.0044177822,
-0.0310866479,
-0.0415560827,
0.0576772951,
0.0725562796,
0.0382058397,
0.0759765506,
-0.0216868911,
-0.0483765677,
0.0144994557,
-0.0247429218,
-0.0321256183,
-0.0680183619,
0.0122733852,
0.0391491316,
-0.006316565,
0.0435091741,
-0.0289866254,
0.0119648622,
0.0396437943,
-0.0274739861,
0.0066392329,
-0.0369750001,
-0.0030918841,
0.0428199917,
0.0027139634,
0.0530524105,
-0.0112025281,
0.0051796655,
0.0399300829,
-0.0525613762,
-0.0060708988,
-0.002070304,
-0.0381287336,
-0.0250400491,
-0.0012804898,
0.0309260245,
-0.0121112438,
0.0053502251,
0.0120105529,
0.0078276973,
-0.055118192,
0.0555636846,
-0.0477986448,
-0.0137114543,
-0.0268607754,
0.0231435727,
0.050586611,
-0.0192053542,
0.0395309925,
0.0069635333,
0.0132701229,
0.0422984548,
-0.0197195653,
0.0077942424,
0.0184302032,
-0.0290625505,
0.0037506623,
0.0002054634,
-0.0171232242,
0.0634449124,
-0.038477648,
0.0675312579,
-0.0055069472,
0.0774884373,
-0.0646836162,
0.0344716422,
-0.0678980872,
-0.0022991875,
-0.0091185588,
0.0403536037,
-0.0464464091,
-0.0185052156,
-0.0641684905,
0.0044596395,
-0.0043554516,
-0.0050192825,
-0.0160943232,
0.0016330775,
0.0093765687,
-0.0335627533,
-0.0084336707,
-0.0430411138,
-0.003515528,
0.0258891825,
-0.0461006835,
-0.014024239,
0.0084022852,
0.01622588,
0.0134489918,
0.0185067113,
-0.0328600705,
0.0180786718,
0.0083653964,
-0.0076110242,
-0.0323502496,
-0.0516431704,
0.0080819521,
0.0106311766,
0.0634624213,
0.0023853171,
-0.0448775738,
-0.0417123586,
-0.0018064653,
-0.0578870587,
-0.033733245,
-0.0287782215,
0.0057414444,
0.0395018347,
-0.0609959736,
-0.0158872772,
0.0152925402,
0.0090488428,
-0.0044938563,
0.0296832677,
0.0388589501,
0.0696638897,
0.0079684267,
-0.0022593683,
0.0408624671,
-0.0075047328,
0.0084538711,
-0.034174785,
0.013100748,
0.0171264075,
-0.0165046565,
-0.0384207927,
-0.0119441412,
-0.0188342836,
0.0304710548,
0.0033173487,
-0.0085727796,
-0.0011510359,
0.0672186464,
0.0343672894,
0.0251358841,
0.1099964529,
-0.0014877503,
-0.0062276232,
0.0007953065,
-0.0093485434,
0.0013541151,
-0.0052012368,
-0.0476082005,
-0.038650509,
0.0056696343,
-0.0837237984,
0.0217064302,
-0.0038290701,
0.0053283572,
-0.0155658051,
0.0824125707,
0.0320549011,
-0.0482876636,
0.0033904647,
0.0019776302,
0.0071990946,
-0.0143486364,
-0.0527223088,
0.0014456408,
0.0507433154,
-0.0193409976,
-0.0562376902,
0.0543924011,
-0.0002517725,
0.0276745819,
-0.0202308223,
0.0423354618,
-0.0051121162,
0.0522435009,
-0.0389969833,
-0.0441557579,
-0.0140468655,
0.0345694758,
0.0046787937,
-0.0666928515,
-0.034509737,
0.0163474809,
0.0093132537,
-0.0750805959,
0.0529100634,
0.0405314639,
-0.0551972538,
-0.0029444429,
0.0271111596,
-0.0033364429,
-0.0029340773,
-0.0027156963,
-0.0192863066,
0.0347634405,
-0.0132208811,
-0.0515836291,
-0.0175975561,
-0.0731612444,
-0.0058888905,
-0.0137738902,
-0.0374651477,
-0.009209183,
0.0253403448,
-0.0835795626,
0.0079371855,
-0.0103068408,
-0.038793005,
0.0175855942,
-0.0333933719,
0.0209615137,
-0.0116098011,
-0.0243601371,
-0.057794787,
0.0188431386,
0.0093721207,
-0.013562439,
0.0046586473,
-0.030158231,
0.047993958,
0.0319897123,
0.0095790951,
-0.0313248187,
-0.0658594519,
0.0123808067,
0.0025023115,
0.0583803542,
-0.0088801449,
0.0133067174,
-0.0208722223,
-0.0315837301,
-0.0112019237,
0.0321312398,
0.0296985041,
-0.0564031862,
-0.0054061878,
-0.0336967185,
-0.0276465379,
-0.0032299398,
-0.0605152249,
-0.049215585,
0.0627051517,
-0.0543961376,
-0.0663218275,
-0.0001544292,
-0.0335023999,
-0.048774343,
0.0536117628,
0.0662935525,
-0.0248210579,
-0.03202454,
0.0669903532,
0.0735937059,
-0.0438922234,
0.0103711095,
-0.0531548075,
-0.0020105285,
0.006335008,
-0.0350063182,
0.0040027653,
-0.0240088142,
0.0219453368,
0.0128711136,
0.0121522266,
-0.0414062925,
-0.0111133773,
0.0118333539,
0.0317866579,
-0.0058850679,
-0.0219962988,
0.0738935247,
0.0165949594,
0.0002469872,
-0.0014146854,
-0.037052501,
0.0273881983,
-0.0268123318,
-0.02328334,
-0.045265343,
-0.0006395548,
0.0312911235,
0.0874865428,
0.0257139001,
-0.0457666144,
0.0350948758,
-0.0091954377,
0.0093873972,
-0.0631745905,
0.0055522341,
-0.0606828704,
0.0612031221,
-0.0036099092,
0.0084338551,
0.0371484831,
-0.0468549393,
0.0119312229,
-0.0277960375,
0.0037133507,
-0.0087422077,
0.0610762425,
-0.0612068996,
-0.0062986515,
-0.0233523995,
-0.0417465083,
-0.0121888239,
0.0167702679,
0.0279889479,
0.0104695167,
0.0213437621,
0.0263776332,
-0.023699563,
0.0252907407,
-0.0528782532,
0.0444041416,
-0.0022500108,
-0.0036336121,
-0.0214906875,
0.0249843262,
-0.0016684443,
0.0371929407,
-0.0126089938,
0.0023830887,
-0.0093163913,
0.0211784951,
-0.056294743,
0.0532752946,
-0.0389410704,
0.0477496944,
-0.0159829296,
-0.011606155,
-0.003962745,
0.0271618478,
0.0028627017,
-0.1092076823,
0.0328225754,
0.0265990943,
0.0317263342,
0.0231431201,
0.0017550238,
-0.0144373858,
-0.0655433312,
-0.0486824512,
-0.0057211076,
-0.0346777067,
-0.0039088721,
0.030544322,
0.0196474288,
-0.0018570145,
0.008817534,
-0.0040409397,
-0.016991863,
0.0591733865,
0.0121579114,
-0.0200345553,
-0.0807924196,
-0.0052701291,
-0.0037915872,
-0.0317119844,
-0.0464865677,
-0.0145465294,
0.0127874976,
0.0025585121,
0.0098657385,
-0.0588309728,
-0.0026504099,
-0.0150924362,
0.0025183635,
0.0616605356,
0.0774764791,
0.0303100944,
0.0184204131,
-0.0153424125,
-0.0031671894,
-0.0002188717,
0.0166128278,
-0.0337819532,
0.0223860666,
0.0542160235,
-0.0083242841,
0.0189262554,
0.0262356587,
-0.074586466,
-0.0066402541,
0.0828031227,
0.0339135751,
-0.0260357317,
-0.0230598338,
-0.0414090231,
0.0265642162,
0.0350003801,
0.03977504,
0.0256901085,
-0.0079521798,
-0.0421647839,
-0.0799160227,
-0.0205060728,
-0.0818193704,
0.002695818,
0.0115440246,
-0.063313365,
-0.0270355418,
-0.0527913645,
-0.0203607455,
-0.0106892008,
-0.0020910306,
0.0023978222,
-0.0297580473,
0.0624011531,
-0.0059832437,
-0.0129933022,
-0.0233829524,
0.0042535267,
0.0140284505,
-0.0227923729,
0.0260366593,
0.0284619275,
-0.0260642581,
-0.047101412,
0.0076768063,
0.0023431161,
0.0244765338,
0.0380295888,
0.0126108462,
0.0092107076,
-0.014358541,
-0.0143781137,
0.0299548749,
-0.0062202993,
-0.017251743,
-0.0456423983,
-0.0631003976,
0.0755403191,
-0.0218670517,
-0.0076285647,
-0.007859217,
-0.0124575254,
0.0772419125,
0.0148558849,
0.0010543303,
-0.0665220618,
0.0338035151,
0.0319795534,
0.028306935,
-0.0219019484,
0.060586784,
-0.0602287687,
-0.014342472,
0.0378087386,
0.0033444236,
0.023228351,
-0.0454658754,
0.0095472643,
0.0553542748,
-0.0081214011,
-0.0342577472,
0.0388922244,
0.0009427533,
-0.0017649902,
0.0229320414,
0.0315065756,
-0.0037382671,
0.0921289623,
-0.0104083139,
-0.0123874219,
-0.0100032603,
0.0474706031,
0.0035637568,
0.0046009589,
0.007451728,
-0.0046354118,
0.0184967257,
0.0137934471,
-0.0400143676,
0.0140255876,
-0.0039775176,
0.0026034792,
-0.0073924549,
-0.0191709716,
0.0059282575,
0.0486399867,
0.0055584731,
-0.0416747145,
0.0543721877,
-0.0413401686,
0.0558373667,
0.0399555303,
-0.0055170488,
-0.0098958937,
-0.0026988252,
-0.0392147303,
-0.0584155098,
0.0245254971,
0.0448532589,
-0.0166363716,
-0.0365593843,
-0.0507518239,
-0.0491008982,
-0.0001138009,
0.0209859461,
0.0187049769,
-0.0341557935,
-0.0182350148,
-0.0310285389,
0.015345443,
0.0309302602,
-0.0013599861,
0.0538550578,
-0.0239405632,
-0.01886281,
0.0588330775,
0.0081194574,
-0.0545250773,
-0.022824835,
-0.0474605002,
0.0302741397,
0.0351029485,
-0.0256399177,
-5.361279491e-33,
-0.0071012359,
-0.0678329319,
0.0069100256,
0.0051938016,
0.0068999892,
-0.0140847769,
-0.0230747443,
-0.0627933741,
0.0083880173,
-0.0021450699,
0.0167030171,
0.0338342786,
0.0250463802,
0.0134649109,
0.0440289304,
-0.0175171942,
0.0663084164,
0.0083960975,
0.0131070493,
0.0023793818,
0.0162021816,
0.0509853587,
-0.0026890882,
-0.120487377,
0.0168395415,
0.0171589348,
-0.0229410157,
-0.0246024337,
0.0152263641,
0.0354038849,
0.0073827612,
0.0047878437,
0.06616918,
-0.0440663509,
-0.0396035314,
0.0484200306,
-0.0980680287,
-0.0184627753,
-0.0258523133,
0.0156669114,
0.0321192928,
-0.0543242954,
0.0621401891,
0.0189807601,
0.0082750106,
-0.0544456542,
0.0473908782,
-0.045655176,
-0.0017537241,
-0.0384707004,
-0.1296767592,
0.0563089214,
-0.0343157239,
0.0274805054,
0.0375345945,
0.030618595,
0.0286273807,
0.0328148715,
-0.0659151971,
-0.0312944725,
0.0521238633,
0.020363776,
0.044215057,
-0.0315976478,
-0.0464413613,
0.0038037109,
0.0032891408,
-0.0436887331,
-0.0310724899,
-0.0303506013,
0.0758638829,
0.0743199661,
-0.005674358,
0.0370135531,
0.08833386,
-0.0269314218,
-0.090826951,
0.0429434329,
-0.0333825462,
0.0469212048,
0.0224630293,
0.0226706453,
-0.0298718344,
0.0046479939,
0.0069552758,
-0.0094486717,
0.0114278095,
-0.0237682965,
0.0368760377,
0.0058344491,
-0.0342967361,
-0.0054203011,
-0.0213976149,
-0.0647414178,
0.0015425163,
-0.0007333051,
-0.0294277929,
-0.0044158548,
-0.0155583704,
0.069474183,
-0.0462788157,
-0.0293028727,
0.0407470465,
0.0324342065,
0.0534724407,
-0.0143296309,
0.0239956416,
0.0389628112,
-0.0170698036,
-0.0016475244,
0.0095682126,
-0.0676794499,
0.0204873513,
0.0793333724,
0.0061539323,
-0.0261887815,
-0.0002562318,
-0.001919506,
-0.0280837789,
-0.0015411386,
0.0016638719,
0.0037405766,
-0.0005168875,
0.0390472263,
-0.014689845,
-0.0380377397,
-0.0159532111,
-0.0349680185,
0.0845692679,
-0.0350991637,
-0.0231324919,
0.0604899339,
2.694e-7,
0.0532822907,
0.0347864181,
0.0083148172,
0.0089916214,
-0.0300177671,
0.030529622,
-0.0290557984,
0.0302806254,
-0.001787796,
0.0576799773,
0.0742336735,
-0.0321550146,
0.070805572,
0.0179997478,
-0.0704070926,
0.0040397127,
-0.0049687275,
0.0058669047,
-0.0438572578,
0.0515127815,
0.1077764183,
0.0541867055,
-0.0135944905,
-0.0138266515,
0.0721011087,
-0.0238425452,
-0.0480543561,
-0.0194215849,
0.0461610779,
0.0375801511,
0.0360444225,
-0.0217156596,
-0.0071569271,
0.0122988001,
-0.016026279,
0.0177191906,
0.0208542831,
0.0984735861,
0.0069352556,
0.0596380495,
0.0158359017,
-0.0584807731,
0.0379091501,
0.0058665611,
0.0223045778,
-0.0342209525,
-0.0120258965,
0.0090202326,
0.0109794466,
-0.0212297309,
-0.002883676,
0.0304953009,
0.0217758529,
-0.0148658976,
0.0252433401,
-0.0484896675,
-0.0061537572,
-0.0551895536,
0.0670202151,
-0.0373404585,
-0.0179718807,
0.0005393666,
-0.0552485138,
0.0100321081,
0.0374647602,
-0.0281326808,
0.0086747203,
2.312247668e-34,
-0.0263290163,
-0.0583411045,
-0.0277717132,
0.0157250967,
0.016152693,
0.0175298005,
0.0009508556,
0.014803227,
-0.025213955,
-0.0742921159,
0.0394308269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13567v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13567v3 | MentaLLaMA: Interpretable Mental Health Analysis on Social Media with Large Language Models | 2023-09-24T06:46:08 | 2024-02-04T02:47:49 | Kailai Yang, Tianlin Zhang, Ziyan Kuang, Qianqian Xie, Jimin Huang, Sophia Ananiadou | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the development of web technology, social media texts are becoming a
rich source for automatic mental health analysis. As traditional discriminative
methods bear the problem of low interpretability, the recent large language
models have been explored for interpretable mental health analysis on social
media, which aims to provide detailed explanations along with predictions. The
results show that ChatGPT can generate approaching-human explanations for its
correct classifications. However, LLMs still achieve unsatisfactory
classification performance in a zero-shot/few-shot manner. Domain-specific
finetuning is an effective solution, but faces 2 challenges: 1) lack of
high-quality training data. 2) no open-source LLMs for interpretable mental
health analysis were released to lower the finetuning cost. To alleviate these
problems, we build the first multi-task and multi-source interpretable mental
health instruction (IMHI) dataset on social media, with 105K data samples. The
raw social media data are collected from 10 existing sources covering 8 mental
health analysis tasks. We use expert-written few-shot prompts and collected
labels to prompt ChatGPT and obtain explanations from its responses. To ensure
the reliability of the explanations, we perform strict automatic and human
evaluations on the correctness, consistency, and quality of generated data.
Based on the IMHI dataset and LLaMA2 foundation models, we train MentalLLaMA,
the first open-source LLM series for interpretable mental health analysis with
instruction-following capability. We also evaluate the performance of
MentalLLaMA on the IMHI evaluation benchmark with 10 test sets, where their
correctness for making predictions and the quality of explanations are
examined. The results show that MentalLLaMA approaches state-of-the-art
discriminative methods in correctness and generates high-quality explanations. | [
0.0415131561,
0.0115203876,
-0.0290641114,
0.0102678416,
0.0088301981,
0.035156101,
0.0295515005,
0.006614639,
0.0633006468,
-0.02968283,
-0.0201274399,
-0.0209567118,
-0.0147877065,
-0.0059119463,
0.0112332907,
-0.0657820553,
0.008758367,
0.0229251608,
0.0525731742,
0.0104093822,
0.0334085077,
0.0108994674,
-0.0338856652,
0.0383569337,
0.0261494853,
-0.0347823426,
0.0014499859,
-0.0176077038,
0.0277953371,
-0.0766113847,
0.0187296737,
0.042067267,
0.0159982853,
0.0089282449,
0.0000020521,
-0.0361312218,
-0.0273677707,
-0.006596229,
-0.007294198,
-0.0341792814,
0.0250558462,
-0.0513054021,
0.0287929196,
0.015325442,
-0.0254930351,
0.011882958,
0.0428843573,
0.0909154862,
0.0874536112,
0.0707389936,
-0.0145078925,
-0.0378323533,
0.0052366788,
0.0013406486,
0.0090146726,
-0.0362609103,
0.026692044,
-0.0022001043,
0.024253225,
-0.0097166505,
-0.0078672608,
0.0269600339,
-0.0217432231,
0.0295426305,
-0.0186568238,
-0.0169889387,
-0.0202667993,
-0.0557633638,
0.0090986984,
0.1177181378,
0.019790059,
0.0227996968,
0.0235047918,
-0.0125541436,
-0.0080251871,
-0.001764739,
-0.0427843668,
-0.0088374093,
-0.0058689076,
0.0283130165,
0.0131422216,
0.0287913866,
0.0347111449,
0.0201116707,
0.0210825633,
0.0492995828,
-0.0375461206,
-0.0253944118,
-0.0001453245,
0.0088104159,
-0.0374762639,
-0.0305527635,
0.025048703,
0.0441130213,
-0.0472081341,
0.0221875533,
-0.0270100813,
-0.042329587,
0.04623577,
-0.0224899743,
0.0192502234,
0.0382376947,
-0.0688017905,
-0.006076985,
0.0477614291,
0.0325954035,
0.0116612883,
0.0403991044,
-0.0079043778,
0.0002974432,
-0.0967446417,
0.0110574029,
-0.006093774,
0.0094967671,
0.0083194477,
0.0030408101,
-0.0918348208,
0.0104544554,
-0.0449711457,
-0.0357661359,
0.0064445646,
-0.0171875227,
-0.0016545753,
0.015050496,
-0.0081207315,
0.0141701214,
-0.0318693034,
0.0206646565,
0.007264372,
-0.0646576732,
0.00864283,
0.0134891989,
0.0197678432,
-0.0328272879,
-0.0015057678,
0.0500509515,
0.0307315513,
-0.0313226096,
-0.0653537661,
-0.0488408171,
-0.0315832309,
-0.0607871041,
-0.0098890644,
-0.0139010129,
0.0413462333,
0.0208068378,
0.0000260137,
-0.0278212447,
0.0137592526,
-0.0050549619,
-0.0493620746,
0.0913511217,
-0.0755315647,
0.0112443762,
0.0018864912,
0.0369263627,
-0.0151466029,
0.0802813992,
0.0122135375,
0.01928211,
0.0582631603,
-0.0577033162,
0.0176799595,
0.0164571535,
0.0321018212,
-0.0265680142,
0.0166728068,
0.0014381128,
-0.0558985285,
0.0416278765,
-0.013318616,
0.0279351212,
0.0025470224,
0.0273970906,
0.0518724471,
0.065472573,
0.0404425487,
0.0143036423,
0.0113201588,
0.0598969273,
0.0042489632,
0.0057466459,
-0.0707510859,
0.0042058607,
-0.0243479963,
-0.0309632681,
0.0082420344,
-0.0181800183,
-0.0298669245,
-0.0629192814,
-0.0248765759,
-0.0279779527,
-0.0155724958,
0.0073352931,
0.0209337305,
-0.0364110135,
-0.0089218263,
0.0667901114,
0.0650659129,
-0.0169774983,
-0.0296776947,
-0.0726359636,
0.0446631014,
0.0970737711,
0.0003904707,
-0.0541359037,
-0.0327910632,
-0.0170989633,
0.069519639,
0.0142399482,
-0.0006932056,
0.0106691467,
0.0428638011,
-0.0528776683,
-0.0094953785,
0.0153220845,
0.0100790355,
-0.0316572152,
-0.0037594133,
-0.0072323629,
-0.0174896438,
-0.0103533175,
-0.0346219093,
0.0501686409,
0.0068382104,
-0.0301100668,
0.009021691,
0.0241947565,
0.0525930412,
0.0358882919,
0.0244264025,
-0.0120880529,
-0.001262692,
-0.0238929186,
-0.0320925303,
-0.009198131,
-0.0262206923,
-0.0452813655,
0.0368819721,
0.0022734236,
-0.0197767355,
0.020962229,
-0.0733155012,
-0.0268494599,
0.0353602841,
-0.0517715253,
-0.022316087,
-0.016118383,
-0.0438709967,
0.0027821509,
0.0405277535,
-0.0176749565,
0.0426503867,
-0.0206801705,
-0.0050024241,
0.0094296746,
-0.0654956922,
-0.0178218577,
-0.0340127833,
-0.006368937,
-0.0156450998,
-0.0387984067,
0.03608042,
-0.0499808788,
0.0131988227,
-0.0510176755,
-0.0052349134,
-0.1202683896,
0.017631676,
-0.0234032162,
0.025874421,
0.0221863315,
-0.0100704078,
-0.017151041,
-0.0101312501,
-0.0268450622,
0.0404521711,
0.0260186512,
0.046197895,
0.0365387388,
0.0044186651,
-0.0163878109,
-0.0499189608,
-0.0072837044,
-0.0357822441,
0.0095376978,
0.0061481073,
-0.0203138776,
-0.0524705164,
-0.0366916955,
-0.0365019813,
-0.0153675154,
-0.0032369026,
-0.0475417748,
-0.0029775668,
0.0149839446,
-0.0043120212,
0.0099279685,
0.0144566288,
0.081961602,
-0.0025214127,
0.0244098026,
-0.0337995887,
0.0023479923,
-0.0194912795,
-0.0366039239,
-0.0309897959,
-0.0472109281,
-0.020664908,
0.0869780034,
0.0340229981,
0.0151106818,
-0.0661950335,
0.0080309026,
-0.0089884493,
0.005787069,
-0.0354460552,
0.0266155954,
-0.006921676,
0.0271626674,
-0.0104309022,
-0.0496886522,
0.0589760579,
-0.005933037,
0.0109822769,
-0.0157193337,
-0.0546256565,
-0.0463177823,
0.0205885619,
-0.0152201336,
0.0147122275,
0.0574812256,
-0.0130175119,
0.0143555515,
-0.0202704854,
0.0052020513,
-0.044266846,
0.0319752358,
-0.0420131013,
-0.0004004403,
0.0074043688,
-0.0125734052,
-0.0322464369,
-0.0690949857,
-0.066472739,
-0.020505419,
-0.0257896259,
0.0243422259,
-0.0180783551,
-0.0106076654,
0.0100995339,
-0.0217107981,
-0.0245241616,
-0.0086575123,
-0.0011831336,
0.0144329267,
0.0369044244,
0.0098986328,
0.0188248493,
-0.0304229762,
0.0272537507,
0.0306071974,
-0.0353197716,
0.0034334904,
0.0076523107,
0.0200113822,
-0.0189647116,
-0.0169310421,
-0.0015389507,
0.0164618623,
0.0847843885,
-0.0358108357,
0.0212797504,
0.1207582355,
-0.0027887297,
-0.0195930023,
0.0278081447,
-0.0082338536,
-0.034171544,
-0.0023267048,
-0.0196915437,
-0.0501969345,
-0.0671167821,
-0.0394438021,
0.0853904262,
-0.0169340521,
-0.02095793,
0.0133663947,
-0.0297921449,
0.0421464406,
-0.0186193548,
-0.0216822755,
0.0072533037,
-0.0377921239,
0.0145645021,
-0.0291176327,
0.0028921606,
-0.0370516405,
-0.0065365192,
0.0068097082,
0.0176201612,
-0.0787590072,
-0.0715608969,
0.0741303563,
0.0003350581,
0.0671702772,
0.025885189,
0.0661883503,
0.0061627445,
-0.0605716594,
0.0197836459,
-0.0192607362,
0.0086610792,
-0.0019171058,
0.0948671103,
0.0254483651,
-0.0025205058,
-0.0416596532,
0.0646919012,
-0.046693176,
-0.0177145544,
-0.0000831781,
0.0878212824,
-0.0135901608,
-0.017360162,
-0.0150480373,
0.0361871161,
0.0570188239,
0.072705701,
0.0417570844,
-0.0603214353,
-0.0339316912,
0.003463828,
-0.0051237368,
-0.0231909454,
-0.0387603045,
0.0058922977,
-0.0407944508,
-0.0275133662,
-0.0291333105,
-0.0561933033,
0.0485468209,
-0.0219939202,
-0.0280640796,
-0.0275976285,
0.0098233977,
0.0215210728,
-0.0638128445,
0.0712197125,
0.0062583042,
0.0316375233,
-0.0354088992,
-0.0140054133,
0.0292661488,
-0.016854912,
0.0071118423,
0.019353427,
-0.0661254898,
-0.0198374633,
0.0167461634,
0.0318843946,
0.0212192275,
0.010693538,
0.0030287716,
-0.0605438724,
0.0054329196,
0.0287730321,
-0.0514957607,
-0.0118063102,
0.0339038186,
0.0633368939,
-0.0027815558,
0.0471666381,
-0.0088268276,
0.046728123,
0.0147560425,
-0.0205569062,
-0.0325262584,
0.0114941411,
-0.015255305,
0.0223448016,
0.0537098125,
-0.0148952259,
-0.065302074,
-0.004517464,
-0.0345897414,
0.0219576377,
-0.0033209135,
-0.0199330859,
-0.0250487942,
0.0299221668,
-0.0367730148,
-0.0284291599,
-0.0558018275,
-0.0508811735,
-0.0296755042,
-0.0642196015,
0.0548229106,
-0.0212014187,
0.028750442,
0.0010928755,
-0.0011445936,
-0.0226683524,
0.0272007734,
0.0040412066,
0.017129736,
0.008458429,
0.0884577632,
-0.0139050651,
0.0264379047,
0.0172943939,
0.0384634361,
-0.0042916336,
-0.0637748316,
0.0003481612,
0.0012156448,
0.033191368,
0.0244463366,
0.0665822849,
0.0525465459,
-0.0011068477,
-0.0131173721,
0.0542299971,
-0.0492990538,
-0.0187538248,
0.0411829241,
0.0053153127,
-0.0306300092,
-0.0175279714,
0.0843995288,
-0.01259124,
0.0048797587,
0.0252608191,
-0.0179359093,
-0.0440500379,
-0.0030901546,
0.0064781024,
0.0368940681,
-0.0229260996,
0.0081036715,
-0.0413362235,
-0.0580125563,
0.0584255271,
-0.0620186403,
-0.0287285633,
-0.011593746,
0.0160705466,
0.0343549252,
0.0054028309,
-0.0139596155,
-0.0580762848,
-0.0075813187,
-0.0261740219,
-0.0109800212,
-0.0100591434,
-6.266160716e-33,
0.0037169287,
-0.0316431932,
0.0116717638,
0.0006054794,
0.0053292695,
0.0196863655,
-0.0341180526,
0.0125197368,
-0.0086646546,
0.0269722715,
0.0438989215,
0.0310414843,
0.0110254399,
0.0537739359,
-0.0062150694,
-0.039949365,
0.0099648507,
-0.0096541969,
0.0005207373,
0.0454884805,
0.0269822087,
0.0585422851,
0.0523938872,
-0.1255877316,
0.0555369779,
-0.0052233948,
-0.008971422,
0.021919582,
0.0344871022,
0.049775973,
-0.0452971607,
0.0851491168,
0.0700375736,
-0.0305313021,
0.0140200257,
0.0358079933,
-0.0678054988,
-0.0427374467,
0.0178089589,
-0.0058587384,
-0.0490179472,
-0.0175391734,
0.0252379719,
-0.0072756805,
0.0116687156,
-0.04803247,
0.0434994102,
-0.044446487,
0.0315353535,
-0.0072767036,
-0.0296499897,
0.0352241807,
-0.0285785813,
-0.0260291789,
-0.0036028908,
0.0428306125,
-0.0264611784,
0.0351805426,
-0.0546945781,
-0.0154138161,
0.00979691,
-0.0174318012,
0.0418051779,
-0.0340498574,
-0.0358156487,
0.0424850881,
0.0243128873,
-0.0066497982,
-0.0471880473,
0.0032650365,
-0.0296619963,
0.0913662463,
0.0607540458,
0.0258079283,
0.0066101975,
-0.0259631313,
-0.0707516,
0.0094305109,
0.0065649655,
0.0119145606,
0.0254198574,
0.0024125748,
-0.046290338,
-0.0224196333,
0.0085290605,
0.0045652073,
-0.0273487438,
-0.0207304526,
0.0235271957,
-0.0118490858,
-0.0023425817,
0.0044959984,
-0.0141550591,
-0.0456342138,
0.0000419156,
0.000155725,
0.0073490478,
0.0172291398,
0.0196271557,
-0.0114750015,
-0.0266121756,
-0.0224578958,
0.0042256634,
0.0088554407,
0.0732073039,
-0.0025436524,
0.0678230971,
-0.0123536354,
-0.0215118546,
-0.0099525722,
-0.0102484934,
0.0346941985,
-0.0263809934,
0.0370618291,
-0.0175867099,
0.0196900424,
-0.0386494957,
0.0636969209,
0.0266049299,
0.0074653532,
-0.0152256414,
-0.0105933156,
-0.0172080658,
0.0027491956,
-0.0233387724,
-0.031145066,
-0.0098241931,
-0.0145657286,
0.0127450321,
-0.0703378096,
0.0094176419,
-0.0112221166,
2.755e-7,
0.0546131134,
0.0705737844,
-0.0085335821,
-0.0214233398,
0.028892776,
0.0519526973,
0.0092115775,
0.0202970095,
0.0142335752,
-0.0261403956,
0.011641589,
0.0524711087,
0.0562765002,
0.0553543754,
0.0021931482,
-0.0204073079,
-0.0297828335,
-0.0213262383,
-0.0565759987,
0.0307668634,
0.1165907532,
0.0715884194,
0.0072872927,
-0.0283546969,
0.0203225203,
-0.0108967805,
0.0324799381,
-0.0371877365,
0.0102969604,
0.0431688428,
0.0692897663,
0.0138865029,
0.0361171663,
-0.0117275929,
-0.0147158727,
-0.0055393255,
-0.0185619313,
0.075690493,
-0.0283664018,
-0.0058087683,
-0.0008576114,
-0.0207963064,
0.0134521499,
-0.0206204131,
0.0718069598,
-0.0955514982,
-0.0872143656,
-0.0218149796,
-0.0097323582,
-0.0548905805,
0.0137785329,
-0.0085957116,
0.0233879313,
0.0348398201,
0.0091051459,
-0.03899635,
-0.0220318362,
-0.0954110175,
-0.0363478959,
0.0225582104,
-0.0525880828,
0.0092085255,
-0.0110114943,
-0.0068472056,
0.0360982753,
-0.076931484,
0.0417820588,
2.163448909e-34,
0.0030586887,
0.0202320702,
0.0201041568,
0.0120390365,
0.0178788546,
0.0320790745,
-0.0249259658,
0.011898173,
0.0151700042,
-0.0720382482,
0.0159988124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13562v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13562v1 | Keeping in Time: Adding Temporal Context to Sentiment Analysis Models | 2023-09-24T06:38:21 | 2023-09-24T06:38:21 | Dean Ninalga | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper presents a state-of-the-art solution to the LongEval CLEF 2023 Lab
Task 2: LongEval-Classification. The goal of this task is to improve and
preserve the performance of sentiment analysis models across shorter and longer
time periods. Our framework feeds date-prefixed textual inputs to a pre-trained
language model, where the timestamp is included in the text. We show
date-prefixed samples better conditions model outputs on the temporal context
of the respective texts. Moreover, we further boost performance by performing
self-labeling on unlabeled data to train a student model. We augment the
self-labeling process using a novel augmentation strategy leveraging the
date-prefixed formatting of our samples. We demonstrate concrete performance
gains on the LongEval-Classification evaluation set over non-augmented
self-labeling. Our framework achieves a 2nd place ranking with an overall score
of 0.6923 and reports the best Relative Performance Drop (RPD) of -0.0656 over
the short evaluation set. | [
0.0361064337,
0.0895945877,
0.0176608544,
0.0072541786,
-0.0241440218,
0.0132016744,
0.0360934734,
0.0063626138,
0.0209230408,
-0.1007175148,
0.0185556263,
-0.0293528456,
-0.0359203331,
0.0248825755,
-0.0075153075,
-0.0636450127,
0.0584715679,
0.0239530019,
0.0095817102,
0.01206885,
-0.013242783,
-0.0123620313,
-0.0107807834,
-0.0283353738,
-0.0243856646,
-0.0438499004,
-0.0194297247,
-0.0321448781,
-0.0114057269,
-0.050830178,
0.0281503331,
0.0702131689,
0.0109858792,
0.0524822995,
0.0000020998,
-0.0373778045,
-0.0399930291,
-0.0250134692,
-0.0246814154,
0.0392729118,
0.0569843799,
0.0166158322,
0.0034483608,
-0.0159999933,
-0.070120953,
-0.0341457017,
-0.0018072643,
0.0522240736,
0.0445459299,
0.0800294131,
-0.0167087894,
-0.0033656915,
0.0110914828,
-0.0259788781,
0.0126695028,
-0.0272205826,
-0.0067563765,
0.022598533,
0.0388015099,
0.0513550639,
0.0073880274,
0.039920155,
-0.0009990082,
-0.016897168,
0.0759249553,
0.0214131139,
-0.0031105177,
0.0497582182,
-0.0369476527,
0.0125591736,
0.0493984595,
-0.0426461361,
-0.0172524974,
0.0264986996,
-0.0470043272,
-0.0644721761,
-0.0041228901,
-0.0375560634,
0.0302209016,
0.0262224153,
0.0536692962,
0.0569897965,
0.0332043134,
0.0462442562,
0.0037052613,
0.0773648694,
-0.0259344112,
-0.0554785579,
-0.009000604,
0.0355055928,
0.041968435,
-0.0288200807,
0.0035786554,
0.0171713922,
0.048605565,
-0.0167844631,
-0.0028300602,
-0.0051981951,
-0.0064233458,
-0.0756357834,
-0.0142841898,
0.0064748507,
-0.0127672236,
0.0492052995,
-0.0368723683,
0.0079626916,
0.0239478685,
-0.0396716148,
-0.0128732007,
0.0114423791,
-0.0628008768,
0.0273207128,
0.0032206012,
0.0133591872,
-0.0218671449,
0.026103694,
-0.0542381778,
-0.0214584339,
-0.0217844937,
-0.0148106571,
-0.0056199161,
-0.0167857613,
-0.0212723278,
0.010827709,
-0.0368439816,
0.0174763277,
-0.0349265337,
0.0027540815,
-0.0428932831,
-0.0462668836,
-0.0086276447,
0.0044507571,
0.006132192,
-0.0462343469,
0.0114387441,
0.0290121622,
-0.0099481372,
-0.0066513815,
-0.0578601174,
-0.0405860581,
-0.0315419734,
-0.0173052754,
-0.004663534,
-0.0520538464,
0.0072445162,
-0.0120752724,
-0.0038257048,
0.0210886914,
-0.0123651056,
-0.0140437298,
0.006744375,
0.0771408305,
-0.0368332192,
-0.0024786096,
0.0242737811,
0.0102171423,
0.0435204059,
0.0269671753,
0.0014231303,
0.0187855288,
0.0441506542,
-0.0075788987,
-0.0041035786,
0.0194983762,
0.0351221189,
-0.0399710983,
-0.0728154108,
-0.0040796711,
-0.0010371099,
0.0023067584,
0.0000868886,
-0.0070202975,
0.0206655376,
-0.0078501338,
0.0380333737,
-0.0270977262,
0.0146902381,
0.0171562284,
-0.0084616533,
-0.0404417738,
0.0247820057,
-0.0536658838,
-0.0384556614,
-0.0065784333,
-0.0048220726,
0.0192788187,
-0.0162780266,
-0.0075765438,
-0.0109645408,
-0.0432868153,
-0.0285726711,
-0.0334701501,
0.0311519969,
0.0197891165,
0.0571858026,
0.0021198404,
-0.028020585,
0.0170523804,
0.0358779766,
-0.0534987971,
0.0109541863,
-0.0012654497,
0.0485854,
0.0899340957,
0.0041601872,
-0.0232388321,
-0.0358064324,
-0.0450901948,
0.0478850119,
0.0189680476,
0.0466570333,
-0.0262073111,
0.0094305007,
-0.018270174,
-0.0256809462,
-0.0094017703,
0.011137668,
-0.0131869549,
0.0445760563,
0.0278470963,
0.0134329703,
-0.0182781741,
-0.0302415248,
0.0277941935,
0.0178130344,
-0.0476477332,
-0.0159112159,
0.0191680826,
0.0405325405,
0.0620759912,
-0.0043151788,
-0.0223346669,
0.0291642118,
-0.0437858813,
-0.0292381961,
0.00649729,
-0.070176281,
-0.0709909052,
0.0473427176,
0.0340540558,
-0.0382332243,
0.0194589533,
-0.0275601167,
-0.0345675796,
0.0281846449,
0.0182273202,
0.0613576509,
-0.0130262133,
-0.0191983152,
-0.0099426331,
-0.004933957,
-0.0597928353,
0.073253572,
0.0117355743,
-0.0087044071,
-0.0534040406,
-0.0058835247,
0.0070644366,
0.019615937,
-0.0619646311,
-0.0051294253,
0.0310670994,
-0.0008260827,
0.042539224,
-0.0045349826,
-0.0692892075,
-0.0329276621,
-0.1095480248,
-0.0134398257,
-0.0161593575,
0.0255755521,
0.0063292542,
0.0036984319,
-0.0040084957,
-0.0233611278,
-0.0292965565,
-0.0336597674,
-0.0287791025,
0.0094591249,
0.0596605353,
0.0424596481,
0.0536967479,
-0.0456878729,
-0.0149155045,
-0.0625139922,
0.0093169911,
0.0259353053,
-0.0630222484,
-0.0000980739,
0.0152679719,
-0.0352516808,
0.0238636658,
-0.0136053115,
0.0148099074,
-0.0220962726,
-0.0355600566,
0.0403265357,
0.0478691198,
0.0212770142,
0.0228220839,
0.0209618732,
-0.0101641994,
-0.0412408784,
0.0336441323,
-0.0420386866,
0.029949557,
-0.0191600285,
0.0082480544,
-0.0345857888,
0.0627918616,
-0.024113277,
0.0165357776,
-0.0251280237,
0.0126590868,
-0.0585458204,
-0.0058976784,
-0.0060008564,
0.0173947271,
-0.0060617183,
0.0051971842,
-0.0100215338,
-0.0414384156,
0.0577006601,
0.0222850144,
-0.013076026,
-0.0338774472,
-0.0350282341,
-0.0480096787,
0.0658890307,
-0.0108879851,
-0.0156725626,
-0.0188136008,
0.0027765105,
0.0088055367,
-0.0529437177,
0.0134242121,
-0.0218252242,
0.0615574047,
-0.0032016851,
0.0088352617,
0.007590652,
-0.0181772895,
-0.003313588,
-0.084601678,
-0.0374093205,
-0.0333964713,
-0.0399617627,
0.0068615978,
-0.0167672355,
0.0353667848,
-0.0707264319,
0.0297381673,
-0.0394716561,
-0.0148886451,
0.0201448798,
0.0351058245,
0.0114582619,
-0.0023073787,
0.0098383771,
-0.0024588832,
0.022471603,
-0.0005387229,
0.0628555939,
-0.0430644713,
-0.053206306,
-0.0056009321,
0.005104234,
-0.0238968786,
-0.013098794,
-0.0319340043,
0.0178646967,
-0.0754523352,
0.0105650313,
0.1547764391,
0.031366881,
-0.0401622206,
-0.0185888018,
0.0021487824,
0.0117962249,
0.0250543822,
-0.0110598598,
-0.022072183,
-0.0232649986,
-0.0270595104,
0.0180068295,
-0.0084682843,
-0.0295544807,
0.0061085415,
-0.1052198634,
0.0016271786,
0.0031920837,
-0.0231359582,
0.0174642913,
-0.0408445857,
-0.0250030607,
-0.0450578071,
-0.0067663384,
-0.0354937427,
-0.0024432964,
0.0414827764,
0.0245709531,
-0.0522917397,
-0.0325523652,
0.0559281781,
0.0258178003,
0.0809239447,
0.0335349068,
0.043753054,
-0.0284021869,
-0.0090879928,
0.0485946126,
-0.0029362696,
0.0067838491,
-0.0566733778,
0.0936024487,
-0.0378064737,
-0.0154608265,
0.0163309947,
-0.0127110379,
-0.0024474449,
0.010409127,
0.0210665576,
0.0711226016,
-0.0038474626,
-0.00328868,
-0.0232580323,
0.0162265804,
0.0422295332,
0.0636882111,
-0.0101595949,
-0.0421019346,
-0.0294794925,
0.0030437158,
0.0163885579,
-0.0557656996,
-0.009425465,
-0.0474491231,
-0.0263368282,
-0.0286798235,
-0.0696384758,
-0.0856370777,
-0.0023083312,
0.0274415873,
-0.0166155268,
0.0139348777,
-0.0333608091,
0.0141662341,
-0.0931687653,
0.0554300025,
-0.000344852,
0.0116219549,
-0.0502806194,
-0.0219345614,
0.0559944957,
0.0076856562,
-0.0181277078,
0.0431491137,
-0.0507620387,
-0.0315280445,
0.0398767032,
0.0312567502,
0.0109050497,
0.083036378,
0.0047762054,
0.0044680433,
0.0434320159,
0.0449760258,
-0.0100180861,
0.0095557226,
0.0477216728,
0.0370292328,
0.0054634805,
0.0195695627,
-0.0197978746,
0.0482422747,
-0.0159237254,
-0.0075579421,
-0.0354206115,
-0.0086014289,
0.0056409729,
-0.0255248323,
0.0942457393,
0.0048378455,
-0.0122189391,
-0.0040212502,
-0.0174827743,
-0.0374307521,
-0.0158252828,
-0.0132726692,
0.0077290554,
-0.0056020925,
0.0143983336,
-0.038875483,
0.0549281165,
0.0057129879,
0.0119120721,
-0.0380249396,
0.0525672212,
0.0173440408,
0.0489068031,
-0.0358463638,
0.0391357802,
-0.0062469607,
0.0073189591,
0.0271703228,
0.003936226,
-0.0168250035,
0.0206162669,
0.0002861417,
0.0385540687,
-0.01725531,
-0.0005332435,
-0.0839205161,
0.0698633566,
-0.0111451456,
-0.0096367318,
0.0073954812,
-0.051971551,
0.0975036919,
-0.0054613655,
-0.0304685161,
-0.0028839696,
0.0162043832,
0.0212615058,
-0.0051118247,
0.0059228837,
0.0028125446,
-0.0302485954,
0.0082262373,
0.0384180211,
-0.0267282724,
0.0438976809,
0.0814226419,
-0.001226956,
-0.0412303284,
-0.0088440208,
0.0005530884,
-0.0225865394,
0.0148889311,
0.0063133817,
-0.0471306518,
-0.037495181,
0.0978751183,
-0.0127832685,
-0.0220083725,
0.0174489729,
0.0292349029,
0.0417402461,
0.020518465,
0.0185805503,
-0.0641170517,
0.0617149509,
0.052532617,
-0.0366425216,
-0.0591716655,
-6.828264482e-33,
-0.0332836546,
0.0004566088,
-0.0183674134,
0.0149434553,
-0.0355200283,
0.0595218651,
-0.0275306329,
0.0241621006,
-0.0004266335,
0.0348298475,
-0.0041595395,
0.020312937,
0.0065229051,
0.0144334827,
0.0590615161,
-0.0181716327,
0.048526153,
-0.012639096,
0.004695056,
0.0348734446,
0.0370209962,
0.0434872881,
0.0665574595,
-0.1105919778,
0.0556418598,
0.0117072351,
-0.0106964866,
0.0094398689,
0.0754955783,
0.0619560592,
-0.0160508435,
0.0343292542,
0.0376177207,
-0.0466059558,
0.0026737228,
0.0229520928,
-0.0960515514,
-0.0282137152,
-0.0309428517,
0.0042214054,
-0.0202730987,
-0.0155088007,
-0.0073784273,
-0.0016526866,
-0.0535719246,
-0.0152916918,
0.0484886579,
-0.0183746293,
-0.0054846704,
-0.0826602578,
-0.0430906303,
0.0587918647,
-0.0126153631,
-0.0071024257,
0.0510049835,
0.0567229651,
0.0594502613,
0.0449146591,
-0.0628083795,
0.0296905395,
-0.0384975299,
0.0147506706,
0.0100131873,
0.0000563213,
-0.017224241,
0.0444946736,
-0.0007491324,
0.0477926098,
-0.0068914578,
0.0599445105,
0.016001856,
-0.035004586,
0.0494846702,
0.0368134379,
0.0373974703,
-0.0441677645,
-0.0277027786,
0.0270267967,
0.0776666105,
-0.0517794378,
0.0019677994,
-0.0227163173,
-0.0394382328,
0.0099117318,
0.0173631478,
-0.0135498,
-0.0110110296,
0.0111573739,
0.0115607921,
-0.0096590798,
0.0075789462,
0.0207699798,
-0.0097191306,
-0.0538218953,
-0.0460342541,
0.0168589894,
-0.015418102,
0.0231146794,
0.0027806959,
0.0004700469,
-0.0459981374,
-0.0077449526,
-0.0101310769,
0.0396485552,
0.0142146787,
-0.0598542169,
0.0508649051,
0.0350707807,
-0.0872903019,
-0.0297870748,
0.0140179265,
0.0390490256,
0.0031161171,
0.0281951409,
0.0272608213,
-0.0114985956,
0.0186310243,
0.0885432214,
0.0383330472,
0.0620146878,
0.0105903307,
-0.0086696083,
0.0266613103,
-0.0113576557,
0.0048594591,
-0.0412536114,
0.020392511,
0.0254365932,
-0.0050236704,
-0.0457184128,
0.0065059857,
-0.0130189536,
2.856e-7,
0.0599666275,
0.0662202239,
0.0185599998,
-0.0149470679,
0.0066040247,
0.0292859636,
-0.0029208655,
0.0151612693,
-0.0447651222,
0.0236201156,
0.0129397465,
-0.0154595096,
0.0440131314,
0.01083491,
-0.035937041,
-0.0394792184,
-0.0571045615,
-0.0153670954,
-0.024571782,
0.0256900936,
0.0779318586,
0.1052012667,
0.0544005036,
-0.0156783201,
-0.0307875294,
-0.0424217284,
0.0405564979,
-0.0420503989,
-0.0432339869,
0.0461028852,
0.0201235916,
0.0306736585,
-0.029046867,
-0.01340588,
-0.0217434615,
0.01278931,
-0.0218500737,
0.0434871055,
-0.0021186033,
-0.0371545739,
-0.0092225745,
0.0129265012,
-0.0091443891,
-0.0131411096,
0.0541220717,
-0.0384742543,
-0.0326243751,
-0.0861747712,
-0.0334272645,
0.0393131524,
0.0365649872,
0.0191016216,
-0.0192037895,
0.0264630672,
0.0093565499,
-0.0250572003,
-0.0595246255,
-0.0978481248,
-0.0528626479,
0.0311470423,
0.0098770512,
-0.0169312898,
0.0066592959,
0.027322216,
0.012151367,
-0.0264556911,
0.0093189972,
2.789544981e-34,
0.0568462834,
-0.028928427,
-0.0198098402,
0.0126416348,
0.0101871686,
-0.0019506979,
-0.0154705718,
-0.0460382737,
0.0332583562,
-0.010845934,
0.0051142927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13561v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13561v1 | Cordyceps@LT-EDI: Patching Language-Specific Homophobia/Transphobia Classifiers with a Multilingual Understanding | 2023-09-24T06:37:54 | 2023-09-24T06:37:54 | Dean Ninalga | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Detecting transphobia, homophobia, and various other forms of hate speech is
difficult. Signals can vary depending on factors such as language, culture,
geographical region, and the particular online platform. Here, we present a
joint multilingual (M-L) and language-specific (L-S) approach to homophobia and
transphobic hate speech detection (HSD). M-L models are needed to catch words,
phrases, and concepts that are less common or missing in a particular language
and subsequently overlooked by L-S models. Nonetheless, L-S models are better
situated to understand the cultural and linguistic context of the users who
typically write in a particular language. Here we construct a simple and
successful way to merge the M-L and L-S approaches through simple weight
interpolation in such a way that is interpretable and data-driven. We
demonstrate our system on task A of the 'Shared Task on Homophobia/Transphobia
Detection in social media comments' dataset for homophobia and transphobic HSD.
Our system achieves the best results in three of five languages and achieves a
0.997 macro average F1-score on Malayalam texts. | [
0.0682921559,
0.0271341335,
-0.0206380133,
0.0440431386,
-0.0116167273,
0.0475159176,
0.0133313071,
0.0363773704,
0.0484500304,
-0.0462630428,
-0.006454946,
-0.0757579952,
-0.0061530056,
0.0036803004,
-0.0141060324,
-0.0457768962,
0.0023486244,
0.0584772229,
0.0055052787,
-0.0277890358,
0.0440273881,
0.0293023251,
0.0166633669,
0.0312165376,
0.0025265035,
0.0124819363,
0.0372979119,
0.0037092164,
0.0366522036,
0.0049214778,
0.055984091,
0.0221730508,
0.0098249884,
0.069413051,
0.0000018936,
-0.0456317291,
0.0000627868,
0.0163314268,
0.0430973768,
-0.0401703417,
0.0530518368,
-0.0786729082,
-0.0081142401,
0.0327639021,
-0.0276194438,
0.0286934674,
0.0657952055,
0.005321132,
0.0755803362,
0.0614413284,
-0.0226632897,
-0.0286755562,
-0.0395847037,
0.0224706922,
0.0148234461,
0.0083356779,
0.0466137379,
-0.0245731082,
-0.0424620397,
-0.0233334973,
-0.0263360869,
0.0086148772,
-0.0058166054,
0.0307183191,
0.0083393352,
-0.0505502895,
-0.0112611195,
-0.0540401936,
0.0414804481,
0.0402781032,
-0.0605592281,
0.0033305187,
0.0098277237,
0.0107171107,
-0.0405488051,
-0.0212736689,
-0.0117295887,
0.0158937182,
-0.0377926342,
0.0336955115,
0.0350225978,
-0.0211065654,
0.0451088734,
0.0981872454,
0.021767471,
0.0303188916,
-0.0008049363,
-0.0203882083,
0.003834177,
-0.0307559893,
-0.0217730273,
0.0050363056,
0.0667317435,
0.0429110043,
0.0058401832,
0.0363407284,
-0.0216370951,
-0.0611476935,
0.0247376598,
-0.0925710797,
0.0193639491,
0.0857235864,
-0.026505718,
-0.0169515572,
-0.0187057834,
0.048236683,
-0.0086274492,
0.0020646127,
0.0263116024,
-0.0267470498,
0.0099098412,
0.0163485836,
0.0484596565,
-0.0228978265,
-0.019545164,
0.0785560608,
-0.0795001164,
0.0267186072,
-0.0600916669,
-0.0252960753,
-0.0012576071,
-0.0255186167,
-0.009680639,
0.0015425195,
0.0125155086,
0.034397047,
-0.0113183502,
0.0093313893,
-0.0536958762,
-0.0521670766,
0.0098998323,
0.0272485726,
-0.0068801558,
-0.0335669108,
0.0332717709,
0.0332806483,
0.0235579144,
-0.0211273283,
-0.0091846064,
-0.0108226556,
-0.0340546034,
-0.0516297705,
0.0019716737,
-0.0513207391,
0.0326228254,
0.0078250905,
-0.0208594948,
-0.0548928417,
-0.0021567687,
0.0134560913,
-0.0405909047,
0.1060023382,
0.0250301175,
-0.0171986893,
0.0531099215,
0.0339258388,
0.005935601,
0.0728681311,
-0.0065433262,
0.0426099338,
0.0473132133,
0.0167216416,
0.0018957036,
0.0411474369,
0.0251936596,
0.033277899,
-0.0427901186,
0.0130094737,
-0.007890977,
-0.0556001067,
-0.0095821517,
0.0091501391,
0.0241780374,
-0.0126031386,
0.0055939662,
0.0587647445,
-0.0123702325,
0.0078787562,
0.0701077133,
0.0283876359,
-0.0271991398,
-0.0066504893,
-0.046511367,
-0.0446876436,
-0.0315441042,
-0.0293685757,
0.0122532528,
0.0650328174,
-0.0225493051,
-0.0192472562,
-0.04132884,
-0.0280864034,
0.0724144801,
-0.0368085504,
0.0431601927,
-0.0037541648,
-0.0077749803,
0.0338301621,
0.0615744554,
-0.0356898606,
0.0502692312,
-0.0351044536,
-0.0020851006,
0.0682215169,
-0.0262660235,
-0.0378616564,
0.027642075,
-0.0429137871,
0.0092432648,
0.032062158,
-0.0033712939,
0.0020311808,
0.0051880986,
-0.0439193733,
-0.0274898335,
0.0745008439,
-0.0107682152,
0.0083460109,
0.0408894643,
0.04508885,
0.0357891917,
0.0406068414,
-0.0121597778,
0.0096953055,
0.0159918573,
-0.0083715999,
0.0033371539,
0.0047266199,
0.0552211814,
0.0194745008,
-0.01170329,
-0.0828541666,
-0.0041655693,
-0.0096173733,
-0.0594790876,
0.0106691634,
-0.0223031789,
-0.016722301,
0.033587493,
-0.0647668615,
-0.0111270146,
0.0585439876,
-0.0043272781,
0.0211159643,
0.0652692169,
-0.0048789801,
0.0119896419,
-0.0435073264,
-0.0189038776,
-0.0691252872,
0.0262598507,
-0.0304265078,
0.0473326333,
-0.029798137,
0.0139059601,
-0.0308025852,
-0.0468955562,
0.0447339565,
0.0333175734,
-0.0352142677,
-0.0041579949,
-0.0334684663,
0.0268173646,
-0.0094875842,
0.0382507779,
0.0179431122,
-0.0050139031,
-0.1176277474,
-0.0359311104,
-0.0146446712,
-0.0311190058,
-0.0173941143,
0.0376552343,
-0.0326738395,
0.0172618106,
-0.0006254131,
-0.0443241447,
0.0761353374,
0.0381770357,
0.0006808298,
-0.065057911,
0.0146041336,
-0.0077979565,
-0.015037721,
-0.0284608826,
0.0213651545,
0.0149488058,
-0.0755812377,
-0.001741866,
-0.0321823247,
-0.0617531165,
-0.0101729827,
0.0057698642,
-0.0817813948,
0.0068756444,
0.0129577331,
-0.0099321557,
0.0015248839,
0.0434933901,
0.0381890163,
0.0403085351,
0.0189432036,
-0.0101983277,
-0.0031411198,
-0.0027052343,
0.0482876264,
-0.0081898244,
-0.0400191024,
-0.0174032096,
0.0554227233,
0.0391730443,
-0.0249111392,
-0.0811318755,
0.0288157314,
-0.086543113,
-0.0229274761,
-0.0075635556,
-0.0535711348,
-0.0080171209,
-0.0076942327,
-0.0262418278,
-0.0531622544,
0.0713974759,
0.0189741906,
0.0138502661,
-0.0709766671,
-0.0258633029,
-0.0234221108,
0.0146825127,
-0.0177998338,
0.0715035647,
-0.0591019467,
-0.0103488937,
0.0394314826,
-0.0279302169,
0.0107364263,
-0.0243270937,
0.024962008,
-0.03414049,
0.012649918,
-0.0122108972,
-0.0399857238,
-0.0537986793,
-0.0558969714,
-0.0507852584,
-0.0562623516,
-0.007133198,
-0.0152334375,
0.0214593336,
0.0514297746,
0.0080677234,
-0.0252642706,
-0.0060568373,
0.0069892025,
0.0426177569,
-0.0440064482,
-0.0205233786,
-0.0517923571,
0.0042589772,
0.0145913139,
-0.0327391699,
0.0240335837,
0.013315862,
0.0116797872,
0.0079612294,
0.0260976888,
0.0279913489,
0.0082321549,
0.0201982651,
-0.0549319685,
0.0304647796,
0.01055058,
0.0268554874,
0.0690852329,
0.0309875812,
-0.0178414639,
-0.0010551908,
-0.0316565,
0.0000761678,
0.0026360604,
-0.0024371513,
-0.0846953243,
0.0051139812,
-0.0109818373,
-0.009947258,
-0.0635900497,
-0.0319468454,
-0.0091234017,
-0.0031372062,
-0.0141723491,
-0.0015869123,
-0.039337039,
-0.0672657788,
-0.0141710797,
0.0198393464,
0.0034375121,
0.00185567,
-0.0337683782,
-0.0031471599,
0.0043820697,
0.0128345033,
-0.0719920024,
-0.0141051505,
-0.004640202,
-0.0161123667,
-0.0115906987,
0.0037570947,
0.0709893852,
-0.0413300507,
-0.0235536378,
0.0347435363,
-0.0096484357,
-0.0373802669,
-0.0910235569,
0.0102759209,
0.0110205505,
-0.0707469434,
-0.0067542167,
0.034323629,
-0.0221019089,
0.0086610988,
0.0095527964,
0.055485867,
0.0304108188,
0.0044699823,
-0.0361536182,
0.039206624,
0.0094854236,
0.0767167658,
0.0156471077,
-0.0711086765,
0.0493546836,
-0.0970607474,
-0.0330876485,
-0.0328142941,
-0.0609458797,
-0.0135097783,
-0.0413199998,
-0.0155716203,
-0.018724056,
-0.0440808162,
0.0078578945,
-0.0059289453,
0.0370393768,
-0.0252847392,
-0.0435519144,
0.0070264712,
-0.0696359724,
-0.0121114226,
0.0113376854,
0.0549230687,
0.0355860293,
0.0250814483,
-0.0116160261,
-0.0173863377,
-0.0369365662,
0.0016865156,
0.0063996664,
-0.0442997105,
0.0683090165,
0.0426292419,
0.0155529818,
0.0112836622,
-0.0141689703,
-0.0493651964,
0.0688899308,
0.0277133454,
-0.0082231155,
-0.0170121584,
0.0654781386,
-0.0203572456,
0.0015311165,
0.0451841764,
-0.0048815962,
0.0308696609,
0.0433253944,
-0.0382715911,
-0.040147461,
-0.0230777264,
-0.0274404529,
-0.018546816,
-0.0062537435,
-0.0169226155,
-0.0482283793,
-0.019836124,
-0.0211274587,
0.0276017152,
-0.0395516902,
-0.0145352231,
-0.0200959109,
0.0180021506,
-0.0227301661,
-0.0363465846,
-0.0082949661,
-0.0291569903,
-0.0235706475,
-0.0159191731,
0.0462459289,
0.0220285263,
0.0647000894,
0.0199704356,
0.0132831791,
-0.0173573997,
0.0068066637,
-0.0203470774,
-0.0351354629,
0.0063000144,
0.0280027818,
0.0058552367,
0.0100431107,
0.0472995006,
-0.0275813937,
0.0418834276,
0.0126427216,
-0.0372599177,
-0.0743785053,
0.0186524857,
-0.0195585117,
0.0346643478,
0.0262909327,
-0.027360348,
-0.0255708229,
0.0141357081,
-0.0360824801,
-0.0170733761,
0.0216416325,
0.0136842281,
-0.0216397196,
0.0036464806,
0.0201946031,
-0.0154196173,
0.0345068015,
0.0563051812,
-0.0618207939,
-0.0350053199,
-0.0041476903,
0.0037936694,
0.0322242863,
0.0129434913,
0.0286843125,
-0.0499600172,
-0.0340130739,
0.0217145085,
-0.0592038445,
0.0123456921,
0.0008083002,
0.0169486515,
0.0825061053,
-0.0053954809,
0.0143592684,
-0.016679028,
-0.015033274,
0.0124771055,
-0.0486770198,
0.0066690631,
-5.561414751e-33,
-0.0300825275,
-0.0121161779,
-0.0372277945,
0.0021541594,
0.0200553574,
-0.0352523997,
0.0451348126,
-0.0093271686,
-0.0020576809,
0.0103493836,
0.0032415423,
0.0198316947,
0.02129573,
0.0021898658,
0.002918764,
-0.0005064088,
0.0251501501,
0.0584931858,
-0.0132467365,
-0.0058099949,
0.0466709621,
0.0344165564,
0.0525117666,
-0.0546472929,
0.0875188112,
0.0024149786,
-0.0297276042,
-0.0060202973,
0.0056297164,
0.0432466492,
-0.0442200564,
0.0942903385,
0.039755933,
0.0124750957,
0.009858069,
0.0568379648,
-0.02776598,
0.005723963,
0.0349360257,
0.0383197591,
0.0607519448,
-0.0355936587,
0.0462947376,
-0.0244310945,
-0.0449126251,
-0.0323568285,
0.0497345179,
-0.0364041254,
0.0268281382,
-0.0044152774,
-0.0715207458,
0.0356166288,
-0.0226384327,
0.0298913363,
0.0031785818,
0.0788326636,
0.0496119596,
0.0042063762,
-0.0680723935,
0.0273061078,
-0.012042786,
-0.030377429,
-0.0041645248,
0.0139184278,
0.0000155652,
0.0439693592,
0.0015608061,
-0.0231062658,
0.0059732562,
-0.0018194169,
0.031520132,
-0.0021861042,
0.0165621806,
0.0442237072,
-0.0112089319,
-0.0773062557,
-0.0493036248,
0.0224086642,
0.0566580184,
-0.0050367704,
0.0014559011,
-0.0041052136,
-0.0448584892,
-0.0515688621,
-0.0036186052,
-0.0485715307,
-0.0118641267,
-0.0531249419,
0.0050289431,
-0.0234103184,
-0.0555784181,
0.0526445657,
0.0190765914,
-0.024568053,
-0.0201978423,
0.0105578266,
-0.0271779634,
-0.0302181803,
0.0399460196,
0.0330887139,
0.0110933343,
0.0036412051,
-0.0208571702,
-0.0052305092,
0.0365872532,
-0.0068713273,
0.057081759,
0.04053865,
-0.0707435459,
0.0109413331,
-0.0087036006,
0.0323420726,
-0.0317001939,
0.1287083626,
0.0031065037,
0.0381719954,
-0.0261934493,
-0.007568079,
0.0426941663,
0.0025645299,
-0.0364478491,
-0.0139668193,
-0.0382828303,
0.0451998673,
-0.0130024916,
-0.0380368121,
-0.020443406,
0.0426167212,
0.0498026274,
-0.0835750028,
0.0213617235,
-0.0567681119,
2.652e-7,
-0.0149664702,
0.0208149012,
-0.0223530103,
-0.0392825603,
-0.0000918017,
0.0359537154,
0.0138176978,
0.0107478201,
-0.0006181086,
0.0190816168,
-0.0504004098,
0.05422353,
0.0019561276,
0.0396899283,
-0.0289880279,
-0.0499636233,
-0.0228990372,
-0.0031140782,
-0.0572475232,
0.0191646051,
-0.0630801693,
0.0687524751,
0.1019760966,
-0.0576353297,
-0.0231765304,
-0.003277604,
0.0174679421,
-0.0292901509,
-0.0349407233,
-0.0208349656,
0.0186323132,
0.0407044999,
0.0272994861,
-0.010872893,
-0.0059419856,
0.0106165055,
0.0410403088,
0.0382299311,
-0.0148793077,
0.0543974824,
0.0033215,
-0.000853807,
-0.0269758757,
-0.0536389947,
0.0537368618,
0.0274582822,
-0.022534389,
-0.0390933156,
0.0040339064,
-0.0154697997,
0.0512365997,
-0.0223901775,
-0.0080503402,
0.0005218398,
0.0264706835,
-0.0251594391,
-0.0005926401,
-0.0744471624,
0.0096141268,
-0.0177887566,
-0.0101553723,
-0.0121472431,
-0.0235670637,
-0.0000896268,
0.0407884493,
-0.0037531983,
0.050776761,
2.020162806e-34,
0.0465434752,
0.0031383466,
-0.0180274565,
-0.0581097044,
0.0392469428,
0.0314799398,
0.0088928603,
0.0258121192,
0.0388521403,
0.0130792987,
0.0091486862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.13543v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.13543v1 | Substituting Data Annotation with Balanced Updates and Collective Loss in Multi-label Text Classification | 2023-09-24T04:12:52 | 2023-09-24T04:12:52 | Muberra Ozmen, Joseph Cotnareanu, Mark Coates | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Multi-label text classification (MLTC) is the task of assigning multiple
labels to a given text, and has a wide range of application domains. Most
existing approaches require an enormous amount of annotated data to learn a
classifier and/or a set of well-defined constraints on the label space
structure, such as hierarchical relations which may be complicated to provide
as the number of labels increases. In this paper, we study the MLTC problem in
annotation-free and scarce-annotation settings in which the magnitude of
available supervision signals is linear to the number of labels. Our method
follows three steps, (1) mapping input text into a set of preliminary label
likelihoods by natural language inference using a pre-trained language model,
(2) calculating a signed label dependency graph by label descriptions, and (3)
updating the preliminary label likelihoods with message passing along the label
dependency graph, driven with a collective loss function that injects the
information of expected label frequency and average multi-label cardinality of
predictions. The experiments show that the proposed framework achieves
effective performance under low supervision settings with almost imperceptible
computational and memory overheads added to the usage of pre-trained language
model outperforming its initial performance by 70\% in terms of example-based
F1 score. | [
0.0578345656,
0.024383042,
0.0248775072,
0.0096495915,
0.0039613051,
0.0184337217,
0.0018736556,
0.0146873835,
0.0546754077,
-0.1120054126,
-0.0251087267,
-0.0136325387,
-0.0345488675,
-0.0228705406,
0.008695865,
-0.0246593878,
0.0182488207,
-0.0163116027,
0.0366282053,
-0.0037536256,
0.0195035711,
0.0248649139,
0.0191218853,
-0.0086594857,
-0.0927456915,
0.0097521786,
0.0057717818,
0.0340093821,
0.0216486081,
-0.0439114571,
0.0187558699,
0.058974918,
0.008945371,
-0.0182473641,
0.0000019298,
-0.0486897752,
-0.0350000039,
0.0028584525,
0.0057799784,
0.0356759243,
0.0377245545,
-0.0316445269,
0.0386793949,
0.009384159,
0.0107393991,
-0.0204430427,
0.0533595942,
0.0532487221,
0.0665142313,
0.0436260179,
-0.0259361211,
-0.0472964719,
0.0187761262,
0.0038761676,
0.0125437574,
-0.0681671575,
0.0442805625,
0.0366618931,
-0.0260825213,
0.0283054914,
-0.0174991768,
0.0247497372,
0.0123404944,
-0.0131870536,
0.0414472781,
0.0429788232,
-0.0090459185,
-0.0313227437,
-0.0289663188,
0.0606972426,
-0.0086866766,
-0.0281371549,
-0.0051202062,
-0.0310513377,
0.0013361768,
-0.0074532554,
0.0190600175,
0.0207293164,
-0.0207281783,
0.0127545688,
0.0319125801,
0.0135196587,
0.0292785093,
-0.0031804482,
0.0053383885,
0.034661334,
-0.0128681883,
-0.0198125262,
0.0426130705,
0.032593675,
-0.0605955124,
-0.0172861964,
0.0121478103,
0.0223224089,
0.0065923952,
0.0466481484,
-0.0702934489,
-0.0712733492,
0.0205029529,
-0.0841578618,
-0.013349208,
-0.0025803971,
-0.0273510404,
0.0455934964,
0.006169924,
-0.0337162428,
0.0111743528,
0.0286619067,
-0.058080826,
-0.0111476919,
-0.0548835956,
-0.0200824421,
-0.0524892136,
0.0787649751,
0.0395618528,
0.0098536108,
-0.0365117155,
0.0014851275,
-0.0127421217,
-0.01929239,
-0.0040326118,
-0.0145157892,
-0.0204062909,
0.0106940595,
0.0173684042,
0.0292729326,
0.0047165472,
0.0206862558,
-0.0326905586,
-0.0209010672,
0.0182541516,
0.0377839096,
-0.0058364938,
-0.0059957099,
0.0082728202,
0.074841328,
-0.0074300081,
-0.0594395325,
-0.0814283267,
-0.0400246233,
-0.0630793869,
-0.0287846681,
-0.0152392443,
-0.0214144941,
0.021053914,
0.0168099981,
0.0130576752,
-0.0078305136,
0.0372600704,
0.0009024158,
-0.0310102291,
0.074970372,
-0.0073038503,
-0.0292746834,
0.078335993,
0.0096864393,
0.0113843447,
0.0615746118,
0.0182397533,
0.0018659164,
0.0378378071,
0.0224094428,
0.0264094379,
0.0340347365,
0.0182223544,
0.0445360467,
0.0141272545,
-0.0199158248,
0.0404209532,
0.0001072555,
0.024902001,
0.0412506908,
-0.0252993647,
-0.0180469118,
0.0314975865,
-0.0042458889,
-0.0026291867,
-0.0232820436,
0.0389188975,
0.0131747322,
-0.0015594378,
-0.0167299919,
-0.017324917,
0.0103930011,
-0.0476091355,
-0.0443079881,
0.0541222841,
-0.0479863174,
-0.0197355598,
-0.0460341834,
-0.0270309281,
-0.0481866188,
-0.0081756078,
-0.0498461351,
0.0944478735,
-0.0166599005,
-0.0109039946,
0.0294293128,
0.0792485327,
-0.0013586938,
0.0006194188,
0.0133512961,
-0.0329666696,
0.012622783,
-0.0092120543,
-0.0671557412,
-0.0155304121,
-0.0138177937,
0.0290353913,
-0.0091055166,
0.0508167744,
-0.0027104903,
0.0018526677,
-0.0192427393,
-0.026311025,
0.0233639218,
0.0158817954,
0.0513155945,
-0.0457934737,
-0.0064936401,
0.0132908057,
0.0060413172,
-0.058402501,
0.0406539477,
0.0315109231,
-0.0163475275,
0.0360043459,
0.0026045919,
0.0509297177,
0.0106246397,
-0.0182016138,
-0.0164612047,
0.0484464653,
-0.0269323718,
-0.0482341871,
-0.0779175758,
-0.0394771174,
-0.0461758412,
0.041727297,
-0.0054763891,
0.0010782997,
0.0061683785,
-0.0388162769,
-0.0572521351,
-0.0356606394,
-0.0353338569,
0.0167364776,
-0.0084227743,
-0.0217546877,
0.0173956901,
-0.0140603501,
-0.0348045006,
0.0599501804,
0.0100808032,
0.0173421968,
-0.03996519,
-0.0127559556,
0.0355648324,
0.0198729709,
-0.0331189781,
-0.0040964875,
-0.0097169699,
0.0211611297,
0.051080592,
0.0245231278,
-0.0317651667,
0.0014197855,
-0.0687881038,
-0.0142357908,
-0.0152395405,
-0.0047354177,
0.0040071611,
-0.003251475,
0.0296138804,
-0.0394021198,
-0.0294285864,
0.0002207269,
-0.0643977001,
0.0214196146,
0.0330588855,
0.0118455645,
0.0103771687,
0.0331731662,
-0.002599179,
-0.0430426113,
0.0490763523,
0.0437507592,
-0.1067044958,
-0.0554669201,
0.0223410148,
-0.0381261222,
0.0028335317,
0.0119749308,
0.0137126213,
-0.0197282713,
-0.0179981124,
0.0215001591,
0.0034694138,
-0.0184445158,
0.0621037148,
0.0612787902,
0.0229158234,
-0.0109996675,
0.0157210603,
-0.0227483939,
-0.0087977313,
-0.0447058119,
-0.021587817,
-0.030572528,
0.045538418,
0.02349874,
-0.01951552,
-0.0477172174,
-0.0585275255,
-0.0534052774,
-0.0212658532,
-0.0670245141,
0.0024954351,
-0.0105307903,
-0.0028622567,
0.0136263361,
-0.0458337367,
0.0501783416,
0.0065702596,
-0.0126551026,
-0.0428655893,
-0.0326938443,
-0.0257609226,
0.074413307,
0.034436781,
0.0428156368,
0.0586780719,
-0.0052056736,
-0.0380296782,
0.011475808,
0.0514052361,
-0.0081896065,
-0.0078829713,
-0.0558328182,
0.0540078282,
-0.0287551433,
-0.0088021895,
0.0174298566,
-0.0699540302,
-0.0170879196,
0.0105521223,
0.0045689349,
0.007199992,
-0.0473895222,
0.0034896205,
0.0080994582,
0.0717364103,
0.0102218548,
-0.0261708982,
0.023484204,
0.0294246078,
-0.0081137558,
-0.0430880897,
-0.0606811047,
-0.0552929454,
-0.0202044174,
0.0479036234,
0.0058963634,
0.0202507302,
0.0096054627,
0.0032362812,
0.0122858118,
-0.0032888346,
-0.0291582327,
0.0085605457,
0.0333458222,
-0.0232872851,
0.0005613135,
0.0885276645,
0.0404107533,
-0.0572724268,
0.0009083613,
0.052209422,
0.0314230137,
0.0365883335,
0.0059084594,
-0.088627167,
-0.0383717194,
-0.0258442014,
0.0293326639,
0.0024996493,
-0.0222816244,
-0.0074886591,
-0.0567748733,
-0.0208600964,
-0.0101793371,
-0.0428948849,
0.0519564338,
-0.0661680698,
-0.0128459241,
-0.0165817533,
-0.0571008995,
-0.0504733622,
0.0555379204,
-0.0054197735,
0.0569656231,
-0.0342176221,
-0.01270328,
0.0056942357,
0.0002998382,
0.0606788993,
-0.0185036212,
0.0260531157,
-0.0313926935,
0.0247610956,
0.0679120049,
0.013480233,
-0.0271652676,
-0.0384091176,
0.071784921,
-0.022986386,
0.005494392,
0.0204883013,
0.0104903057,
-0.0402735248,
-0.0018973898,
0.0051998063,
0.051736623,
-0.0048078615,
-0.0083065601,
-0.0169709884,
-0.0308951028,
0.0162438098,
0.0602008291,
-0.013012141,
-0.0817596763,
0.0078497715,
-0.016536111,
0.0153127732,
-0.0000064496,
-0.0290438477,
0.0428641662,
-0.0681191459,
-0.0710208341,
-0.042632252,
-0.0262646452,
0.0180103164,
0.0267776437,
0.0017591481,
0.0084739905,
0.0324401297,
-0.014280716,
0.0142338406,
-0.0010264525,
-0.0272526778,
0.0034104127,
-0.0168635864,
-0.0136776203,
0.0540323555,
-0.014603762,
-0.0463556349,
0.0213986449,
-0.0629715398,
-0.0495884083,
-0.0113983043,
0.0211400837,
0.0080494946,
0.0263022557,
-0.0120494366,
-0.0325962491,
0.0316868722,
0.0639344379,
-0.0184233133,
0.0050684912,
0.0327010863,
0.0156238247,
-0.0078849019,
0.025126474,
-0.0559382103,
0.0456902124,
0.0195654817,
0.0161986034,
-0.0174715053,
-0.054888092,
0.0322531722,
0.0230881628,
0.0642080083,
-0.0486511141,
-0.0057284795,
-0.0220293328,
0.0219052751,
0.0083321193,
-0.0769288316,
-0.0085189138,
0.0257496461,
0.0446203686,
-0.0284887925,
-0.042297978,
-0.0122429421,
0.0411460809,
0.0410481095,
0.0421714112,
-0.0434370823,
0.0330604687,
0.0252918024,
0.0146990903,
-0.001793944,
-0.0116465511,
-0.0167665854,
0.0538724959,
0.0039946591,
-0.0026286307,
0.0118526723,
0.0533413962,
-0.0064164405,
-0.0118113449,
-0.0356985368,
-0.0545196533,
0.0478142463,
-0.0338780619,
-0.0029394904,
0.0317964032,
0.011871119,
0.0559683293,
-0.0383200236,
-0.0233617984,
-0.0311346781,
0.032744959,
0.0081804004,
-0.0014227012,
0.0455094278,
-0.0046081333,
-0.0224866141,
0.074506402,
0.0632002726,
0.0546045117,
0.0325634517,
0.0112265442,
-0.0381806009,
-0.0343287997,
0.0257794186,
-0.0060736155,
0.0545507669,
-0.0013039465,
0.0247854739,
-0.0310677867,
-0.0268254858,
0.0337136723,
-0.0480745398,
-0.0224777963,
0.0235386286,
0.0343949571,
0.0152213881,
-0.0043013236,
-0.0070655225,
-0.0578852817,
-0.0302196667,
0.0225826595,
-0.0173591115,
-0.0029431225,
-6.184461655e-33,
-0.0204749852,
-0.0574887246,
-0.0218470022,
0.0289156642,
-0.0055038533,
0.0292347167,
0.0114427917,
-0.0071944608,
0.0101205371,
0.0372249298,
0.0293419231,
0.0045566084,
0.0019290688,
0.0516055226,
0.0141155086,
-0.0185818803,
0.0170283169,
-0.0219524223,
-0.0017928241,
0.0344693922,
0.0566803813,
0.0276126806,
0.0616786741,
-0.1129756719,
0.0585617721,
-0.0284335613,
-0.0179886259,
0.0038048655,
0.0166072901,
0.020559039,
-0.0106726019,
0.077141203,
0.036643032,
-0.0194352847,
0.0333895683,
0.0188270696,
-0.0709059387,
-0.0323428214,
-0.050940264,
0.0021004344,
-0.0174813829,
0.013977048,
0.003462777,
0.0334577337,
0.0660425797,
-0.0140977632,
0.0856000036,
0.000408497,
-0.043497771,
-0.0834969208,
-0.0168026667,
0.0577770956,
-0.0224272516,
-0.0004300671,
-0.0077303653,
0.069083862,
0.0037904955,
0.0379578657,
-0.0591388568,
-0.0100865047,
-0.0343664214,
-0.0119685056,
-0.0142641235,
0.0364926085,
-0.029023895,
0.0210662968,
0.0044527701,
0.0241994895,
-0.0069165924,
-0.0361863449,
0.0017555449,
-0.0005931668,
0.0066228467,
0.0110899871,
0.0249449015,
0.0100663528,
-0.1015996262,
-0.0032191954,
-0.0075763413,
-0.0307959709,
0.0091110086,
0.0476814769,
-0.0425432511,
-0.0613248162,
-0.0507158078,
-0.0198765602,
-0.0287513044,
0.0128377834,
0.0094670448,
0.0132033881,
-0.0213244818,
0.0471461825,
0.0016281351,
-0.0239374079,
-0.0894644707,
-0.0265155826,
0.0054323645,
0.0729388893,
-0.0402174555,
0.0223647431,
-0.0561002232,
-0.0337516703,
0.0109052528,
-0.0055901674,
0.0153054344,
-0.0394586734,
0.1163434833,
0.0177920051,
-0.0772192255,
-0.0257302318,
0.0019844824,
-0.0635760352,
0.006199148,
0.0060738926,
0.029072471,
0.0069921794,
0.0089181811,
0.075993076,
0.0846189782,
0.0213022009,
0.0187111292,
-0.0438134111,
-0.0105797704,
-0.018321706,
-0.0257395133,
-0.00973072,
0.0250956174,
-0.0117368344,
0.0651222989,
-0.0567430928,
0.00081247,
0.0075991368,
2.686e-7,
0.0779952705,
0.0515451804,
-0.0243469477,
-0.0795574039,
0.027084671,
0.0691010207,
-0.0230162144,
0.0372466408,
-0.029171234,
-0.0166057032,
0.0375874415,
-0.0172601622,
0.0061363955,
0.0231884588,
-0.0547280423,
-0.0217038579,
-0.0725200623,
-0.0119142672,
-0.0357451811,
0.035583701,
0.0865567327,
0.0753100067,
0.0831110254,
-0.0286516491,
-0.0282306001,
-0.024522556,
0.040624164,
-0.0019894401,
0.0076089152,
0.0172821954,
0.0437609442,
0.0330638848,
-0.020711882,
0.0515371822,
-0.0450080372,
-0.0347410366,
0.0306927375,
0.0472495854,
-0.0314030908,
0.0042335107,
0.0281064641,
0.0375632644,
-0.008870068,
0.039471712,
0.0667206645,
-0.0543412752,
-0.0298156627,
0.0067886617,
-0.0134634003,
-0.0157284867,
0.0388933383,
0.0291413423,
-0.0274845436,
0.0350687653,
-0.0161993206,
0.0151040573,
-0.0386271514,
-0.0791461915,
0.0085718315,
0.0352661796,
-0.0095861582,
-0.0170990098,
-0.0115903597,
0.022756841,
0.0376044028,
-0.0706914961,
0.0145328986,
2.277163524e-34,
0.0076844203,
-0.0614341386,
-0.0146562075,
0.0066912971,
-0.013680269,
0.0019174962,
-0.0723429024,
0.0073006218,
0.0068354546,
-0.0610892549,
0.0209573936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.14372v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.14372v1 | Human Transcription Quality Improvement | 2023-09-24T03:39:43 | 2023-09-24T03:39:43 | Jian Gao, Hanbo Sun, Cheng Cao, Zheng Du | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS, 68T50, I.2.7 | High quality transcription data is crucial for training automatic speech
recognition (ASR) systems. However, the existing industry-level data collection
pipelines are expensive to researchers, while the quality of crowdsourced
transcription is low. In this paper, we propose a reliable method to collect
speech transcriptions. We introduce two mechanisms to improve transcription
quality: confidence estimation based reprocessing at labeling stage, and
automatic word error correction at post-labeling stage. We collect and release
LibriCrowd - a large-scale crowdsourced dataset of audio transcriptions on 100
hours of English speech. Experiment shows the Transcription WER is reduced by
over 50%. We further investigate the impact of transcription error on ASR model
performance and found a strong correlation. The transcription quality
improvement provides over 10% relative WER reduction for ASR models. We release
the dataset and code to benefit the research community. | [
0.0160155538,
0.0919500068,
0.020593483,
0.0014658453,
0.0092874877,
-0.0095704757,
0.0102852723,
-0.0147299767,
-0.0328308381,
0.0067220703,
-0.0593030564,
-0.0184850805,
0.0896619186,
-0.0092870733,
0.0263878219,
-0.0136587601,
0.009391143,
-0.061369542,
0.0219794344,
-0.0376408696,
0.0188544951,
0.0138781108,
-0.0372686945,
0.0456922092,
-0.032397788,
0.0652284101,
0.0153871123,
0.0231778938,
0.0395349823,
-0.0106653338,
0.0055519785,
0.0230393019,
0.0027381622,
0.0250061341,
0.0000018157,
-0.0324876606,
-0.0207605343,
0.0425068513,
-0.0516390838,
0.0013142755,
0.0263414308,
0.0198241565,
-0.0399183929,
0.059124779,
0.0156666301,
-0.0068203495,
0.0445600674,
0.0258218776,
0.0030009102,
0.0261828452,
0.0093383249,
-0.0039019219,
0.0078654829,
-0.0220251996,
-0.022455113,
-0.0444605574,
-0.0011166983,
-0.0191169288,
-0.0038311395,
-0.0448138751,
0.0317043029,
0.0510674939,
-0.0187428016,
-0.0309501998,
0.0324337818,
-0.0016250436,
-0.0682086647,
-0.0577483661,
-0.0053116158,
0.0547680967,
0.0395099185,
-0.0260650963,
0.0176270474,
0.0038462444,
-0.0037828989,
-0.033265084,
0.0204754714,
0.0165386833,
-0.0146262981,
0.0193775613,
-0.0201086048,
0.0115322312,
0.0247057248,
-0.0337003991,
0.034445066,
0.0031782768,
0.0102364877,
-0.0330758616,
0.0048216716,
0.016488824,
0.0264821816,
0.0154033592,
0.0645635724,
-0.0551248752,
-0.0214097481,
-0.0271399021,
-0.0556074046,
-0.0420229584,
0.0033721207,
0.0049855793,
-0.0142153129,
0.0048841834,
-0.0490911826,
-0.0011246632,
0.0209318213,
0.0235587731,
0.0418296009,
0.0105233546,
-0.0005055569,
-0.0075469171,
-0.0091450363,
0.0364423841,
-0.0430712029,
-0.007278455,
-0.0087559931,
0.0225527156,
-0.0789964125,
-0.0164068528,
-0.0170625541,
0.0237509441,
0.0508597903,
-0.0055093369,
-0.0497508198,
-0.0223085023,
0.0396707132,
-0.0018416302,
0.0372391827,
0.043128036,
-0.0062249745,
-0.0955560952,
0.0108224591,
-0.0154289939,
0.0778888017,
0.0101153487,
-0.0006458538,
0.0063803573,
0.0230167769,
-0.0195504352,
-0.03579209,
0.0041403552,
-0.0312436614,
-0.0042474978,
-0.0656637102,
-0.0591873899,
0.0360553861,
-0.0231574047,
0.0032359951,
-0.0197458193,
0.0054717017,
-0.0175149068,
0.0083497018,
0.090952538,
-0.0582646467,
0.0269235205,
0.0609629191,
-0.0311333779,
0.0129127968,
-0.0027774221,
0.0773341954,
-0.0322021022,
0.035570249,
-0.0464482978,
0.0448060967,
0.0654327944,
0.0087462431,
-0.0326574109,
0.0295124464,
-0.030584285,
-0.00736664,
0.0251861382,
0.0626710579,
0.0780927315,
-0.017928673,
-0.012054408,
0.0737489238,
0.0330442749,
-0.0146920681,
-0.0216692202,
-0.0133284982,
0.0395997092,
0.0036727933,
-0.0579344779,
-0.0278986786,
-0.0240794811,
0.0001845312,
0.0223703459,
0.0773910061,
0.0196320452,
0.0120166289,
-0.0204968359,
-0.0444349833,
-0.0107941162,
-0.0157649461,
0.0337186009,
0.0437327325,
-0.0145951053,
-0.0344576538,
0.0273137577,
-0.0055581806,
-0.0804810748,
0.0265149176,
-0.0493197925,
0.0094900038,
0.0250399094,
0.0335123353,
-0.0205943491,
0.0138564156,
-0.068862319,
-0.0601103045,
0.0272563566,
0.0192182958,
-0.016577797,
0.0521176234,
-0.050334841,
-0.0213957783,
0.1107251197,
-0.0167460721,
0.0117648831,
0.0094164535,
-0.0127170226,
0.0362889394,
-0.0454513244,
-0.044495225,
-0.0098347403,
0.00910943,
-0.025961725,
0.0137487156,
0.0086174868,
0.1058860496,
0.0161296129,
-0.0509886816,
0.0059740576,
0.0234680455,
-0.0080797561,
-0.0096165128,
0.0179355592,
-0.0373883285,
-0.0126740551,
0.064874053,
-0.0600844473,
-0.0372172408,
0.0536633991,
0.0237606745,
-0.0619623922,
-0.0131765567,
-0.0637581721,
0.0075550741,
-0.0560570769,
0.0457812138,
0.0430052541,
-0.0277690422,
0.0203928538,
-0.0297707636,
0.0050639645,
-0.0053890902,
0.0020473383,
-0.0477019697,
0.0073096771,
-0.0696996599,
-0.0174806323,
0.0178856179,
-0.0312460326,
0.0601796918,
0.0391303785,
-0.0218498893,
-0.0307114851,
0.0164855346,
-0.0701344386,
-0.0277853701,
-0.0108002443,
0.0253893267,
-0.0210619848,
0.0145893078,
0.0010925916,
-0.0318044834,
-0.026501976,
-0.037971992,
-0.0095538395,
0.0037149312,
-0.0361962244,
-0.0406430475,
-0.0252961274,
-0.0373931825,
0.0190766845,
0.0151033513,
-0.0409788564,
0.0229800791,
-0.039494697,
-0.071032837,
0.03059154,
0.0411871113,
0.0162259657,
0.0182168335,
-0.0414621346,
0.0104828207,
0.0207349807,
0.0152750341,
-0.0030423743,
-0.0101250038,
-0.0443161055,
-0.0071167145,
0.0205993392,
-0.0467052311,
-0.0084706424,
0.0277592074,
-0.0176889785,
0.0189223886,
-0.0270495303,
-0.013935864,
0.0162181687,
0.0614729896,
0.026318321,
-0.0394849256,
-0.0374004133,
-0.0373523273,
-0.0255535711,
-0.0336831585,
-0.0342694074,
-0.0429637134,
0.025097711,
-0.0137483235,
-0.0301873144,
0.0351639837,
-0.0703613833,
-0.0312966257,
-0.0200340729,
-0.0274155494,
0.0100181242,
-0.0158085618,
-0.0032865598,
0.0063900324,
0.003690175,
-0.0402533598,
0.0051766867,
0.0130952857,
0.0601846687,
-0.0734794512,
-0.0104633486,
-0.0464297161,
0.0268152934,
-0.0179883502,
-0.0702084824,
-0.0264330227,
-0.0158850625,
-0.0530364551,
0.0046844939,
0.0345737599,
-0.051513344,
-0.0084626321,
-0.0075732567,
0.0322210416,
0.0589173101,
0.0090636164,
0.0041337707,
0.0109415101,
0.0407451019,
0.0070756581,
0.014950335,
0.0057631037,
-0.0314211361,
-0.0037418476,
0.0132862525,
0.0476176403,
0.0337743461,
-0.0188667905,
-0.015520501,
0.0441680104,
0.0235244855,
-0.0096332124,
0.0118763959,
0.0766759589,
-0.0141949318,
0.0336574093,
0.0931925401,
0.0024362723,
-0.014092572,
-0.023007514,
-0.0033265427,
0.0316216983,
0.0075850422,
-0.0184861924,
-0.0608991422,
-0.0351470746,
0.0831302553,
0.1113634929,
-0.0028817388,
0.0104927998,
0.0108638834,
-0.0971682817,
0.0708991289,
0.0252364837,
-0.0226203892,
-0.0437761806,
-0.0629278123,
-0.0023102511,
-0.0808953941,
0.042537123,
0.0186558031,
0.0084537594,
-0.0050591235,
0.0542549007,
-0.0689901784,
-0.074337028,
-0.0041634454,
-0.0460865535,
0.1067180112,
0.0717365593,
0.0012833234,
-0.0182813071,
-0.0781992525,
0.0143236639,
0.0284342933,
-0.0298728906,
-0.000200172,
0.0389596298,
0.0204279907,
-0.0156351626,
0.0027297547,
0.0644742623,
-0.0368018448,
0.0029034072,
0.0041614426,
0.0299415812,
0.0085172374,
0.003720375,
0.0403064266,
-0.0022834549,
-0.0020558382,
0.0683343112,
0.0326838866,
-0.032566227,
0.017603742,
0.0131775672,
0.0513314605,
-0.0515428446,
-0.0166843515,
0.0326901749,
-0.031860169,
-0.0817863941,
-0.037262354,
-0.0262140986,
0.0342090018,
-0.0093138237,
-0.0120850001,
-0.0308347512,
0.0119941765,
0.0320642702,
-0.0128254117,
0.0286209919,
-0.0260671563,
0.0415056869,
-0.1010618359,
0.0019359054,
-0.0033331651,
-0.0199502669,
-0.0199379455,
0.0549486503,
-0.0560299121,
-0.0606933311,
0.0670321509,
0.0073141749,
0.0140011888,
0.0549462959,
-0.0290321577,
-0.0184157677,
-0.0060003162,
0.0364335179,
-0.0317232795,
0.014793844,
0.0276168156,
-0.0035848944,
-0.0239245743,
0.0191710722,
-0.0607385561,
0.0230346974,
-0.0131070856,
-0.012851893,
-0.0326753296,
-0.0942819193,
0.0191107765,
0.0971269459,
0.0685632154,
-0.0340163633,
0.0184542444,
-0.0516513549,
0.0097888317,
0.0251092277,
0.0114432629,
-0.045842506,
0.00783733,
0.0236733556,
-0.0227348655,
-0.0292806644,
0.0191695169,
-0.0454269946,
-0.0511045754,
-0.0060526025,
0.0598018728,
0.0292968769,
0.0395582728,
0.0137086976,
0.0050389259,
-0.00497609,
0.0459553376,
0.0294101834,
0.0333475694,
0.0330507942,
-0.0497635119,
-0.0246465448,
0.0053015933,
0.041469153,
-0.0085404981,
-0.0270237345,
-0.0323555917,
-0.0218491908,
0.026239438,
0.0242888015,
0.023802897,
0.0599272884,
0.0084522599,
0.0199637972,
-0.0461831875,
0.0135410149,
-0.0141416211,
0.0389490351,
-0.0035897049,
-0.0147139011,
-0.0266171582,
0.0316814184,
0.0592023917,
0.0207713451,
0.0240082834,
-0.0744954199,
-0.0134488968,
-0.0394057892,
0.0136610577,
-0.0358500071,
-0.0352981575,
-0.0384166576,
-0.0218301527,
0.0180857629,
-0.0603397004,
0.0349714123,
0.0427643135,
0.0479227975,
-0.014013621,
0.0184442252,
-0.0147496955,
-0.0624947138,
0.0071532256,
-0.0004458671,
-0.0378239416,
0.0328367539,
-0.0335825458,
0.0100129331,
-6.561090779e-33,
-0.0001748455,
-0.0183869377,
-0.0134252403,
-0.0196869113,
-0.0219677612,
0.0073563163,
-0.0078407992,
0.0277850535,
0.0308937468,
0.0122719128,
-0.020385623,
0.0013029239,
0.0493421778,
-0.0012932229,
0.0282751974,
0.0192968845,
0.102658473,
-0.0230364855,
-0.0205032863,
-0.029900033,
0.0198174715,
0.0430299006,
0.0277100932,
-0.0792832971,
0.0258599538,
0.0126591548,
-0.04424816,
-0.0027376369,
0.0480960682,
0.0193859041,
0.0279562566,
0.0269042999,
-0.0336973704,
-0.0350177996,
-0.0147785414,
-0.0119477361,
-0.093482621,
0.0171971843,
-0.0313646421,
0.0690492019,
-0.0085014515,
-0.0016429572,
0.0521579608,
-0.0088759353,
-0.0540006906,
-0.0003179671,
0.0330821909,
-0.035986729,
-0.0304988287,
-0.0550853312,
0.0275803246,
0.0587814525,
-0.0231786147,
-0.0170182791,
0.0682577491,
0.015110543,
-0.0375385806,
-0.020200884,
-0.0873863697,
0.0165578034,
0.0003320907,
0.0226371642,
0.0141252298,
0.0136757707,
-0.0127261579,
-0.0062540546,
0.0314616375,
-0.0356127098,
0.0339285508,
-0.0623355247,
-0.0064405105,
0.0166745577,
0.0235131234,
0.0635965019,
0.0475594252,
-0.054867316,
-0.003668556,
0.0288782772,
-0.0277056973,
0.0158309583,
-0.0148880677,
0.0425757281,
-0.0503346883,
0.0129002072,
-0.0574664213,
-0.0260175299,
-0.0141179897,
0.057858564,
0.0188815799,
0.0171894487,
-0.0182856172,
-0.0234250743,
0.032629665,
-0.0029684301,
0.034365382,
-0.0270905551,
0.0306097586,
-0.0020112069,
-0.02534426,
-0.0013438986,
-0.027624581,
0.0291801095,
0.0104248803,
0.0643660873,
0.0373135991,
-0.0347605199,
0.0384024754,
0.0573021621,
-0.0725702494,
0.0301714577,
0.0084590809,
0.0491826907,
-0.0111609185,
-0.010020582,
0.0317105949,
-0.0128434086,
0.0218313765,
0.0190434717,
-0.0122800237,
0.0534713827,
0.0196426474,
0.0117149716,
0.0236979965,
-0.001014956,
-0.0286738891,
0.0018930263,
0.0218326151,
-0.0022573848,
0.0154768042,
0.0057458454,
-0.0102521917,
-0.0131452559,
2.7e-7,
-0.0335310511,
0.0258851703,
0.0395083725,
-0.0316145122,
-0.0041105337,
0.0297856349,
-0.0103584882,
0.0045336066,
-0.0360508934,
0.028333744,
0.0370250344,
-0.0461277552,
0.1205312908,
0.0430283546,
-0.0736180991,
-0.0861542448,
-0.0708035752,
0.043086879,
0.0413059145,
0.0058122594,
0.0106394878,
0.075953275,
-0.0108028706,
-0.0632358864,
0.0034735487,
0.0012185758,
0.0040550553,
-0.0164242722,
0.0140085742,
-0.030223636,
0.0440989994,
0.018010715,
0.0149977272,
-0.0125036472,
-0.0762119293,
-0.0060508512,
0.0130163785,
0.030446304,
-0.0489316545,
-0.021451192,
0.0129955998,
0.024151884,
0.0045734425,
0.0141980574,
0.0082449438,
0.0443812944,
0.008697113,
-0.0431275852,
-0.0417527929,
-0.0134073235,
0.0222613458,
-0.0230727978,
0.0292797349,
-0.0110729979,
0.0127874212,
-0.0072365049,
-0.0574482344,
-0.0392954834,
0.0099421293,
-0.0172534566,
-0.028356595,
-0.0160745233,
0.0207572412,
0.0100476556,
0.0045766532,
-0.0066219238,
0.0261554811,
1.550005588e-34,
0.0538007729,
-0.0302424226,
0.0195640922,
-0.0035004821,
0.0510344617,
-0.0224391595,
-0.0012859239,
-0.0278693438,
-0.0073762583,
-0.0154518485,
-0.0300803296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.01418v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.01418v1 | Cordyceps@LT-EDI: Depression Detection with Reddit and Self-training | 2023-09-24T01:14:49 | 2023-09-24T01:14:49 | Dean Ninalga | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Depression is debilitating, and not uncommon. Indeed, studies of excessive
social media users show correlations with depression, ADHD, and other mental
health concerns. Given that there is a large number of people with excessive
social media usage, then there is a significant population of potentially
undiagnosed users and posts that they create. In this paper, we propose a
depression severity detection system using a semi-supervised learning technique
to predict if a post is from a user who is experiencing severe, moderate, or
low (non-diagnostic) levels of depression. Namely, we use a trained model to
classify a large number of unlabelled social media posts from Reddit, then use
these generated labels to train a more powerful classifier. We demonstrate our
framework on Detecting Signs of Depression from Social Media Text -
LT-EDI@RANLP 2023 shared task, where our framework ranks 3rd overall. | [
0.048381079,
0.0615512356,
-0.0057725012,
-0.0205481313,
0.0027370767,
0.038674999,
0.0203818064,
0.0369537324,
0.0827983618,
-0.06047903,
-0.0035556382,
0.0371989273,
-0.0823220536,
0.0112218745,
-0.0160672143,
-0.0568913929,
-0.004486117,
0.047228463,
0.0273145884,
0.0035798042,
0.0281972643,
0.0266662091,
-0.0312423445,
0.0057521625,
-0.0647400096,
-0.0549341962,
0.05115344,
0.0129709989,
0.0123771029,
-0.0366655067,
0.0526882596,
0.0581953786,
-0.0251897089,
0.0041098124,
0.0000019351,
0.002397978,
-0.011969802,
-0.0401600152,
0.0042275256,
-0.0668707713,
0.0454545766,
-0.0527090579,
0.0247189477,
0.0127841402,
-0.0622810982,
-0.0842316747,
0.0304739978,
0.0738213435,
0.090374358,
0.0697820261,
-0.0340884551,
0.0080058789,
-0.0285237096,
0.0015147022,
0.0062001906,
-0.0028264043,
0.0467233732,
0.0358497202,
0.0130444746,
-0.0415351316,
-0.0061725425,
0.0277883355,
-0.0202464368,
0.0382090248,
0.0007184791,
-0.015009555,
0.0041095694,
-0.0391984843,
0.0002497809,
0.054824274,
0.0289537758,
-0.0022841203,
0.0234826282,
-0.0133136027,
0.0040826076,
-0.0056452071,
0.0143544497,
-0.0366892219,
-0.0141204754,
0.0522532277,
0.0051181642,
0.0349662341,
0.0135598071,
-0.0102189053,
0.0500729829,
0.0027699333,
-0.0336356796,
-0.0485340729,
-0.0207759142,
0.0179920979,
0.0126662059,
-0.0514981262,
0.0619365796,
0.003207796,
-0.0013172945,
-0.0083699524,
-0.0317089371,
-0.0919727534,
0.0029436182,
-0.0131515497,
-0.0351832807,
-0.0225309189,
-0.0374942943,
0.0231969915,
0.0349497423,
-0.0216143616,
0.0345273614,
-0.0182964597,
-0.0296625793,
-0.017755935,
-0.0605172962,
0.0363110006,
-0.0368926935,
0.0006029466,
0.0438866615,
-0.037832424,
-0.0649508536,
0.0039921054,
-0.0219284948,
-0.0408408381,
0.0076352512,
-0.0017762856,
0.0114355991,
0.0137314284,
0.048619289,
0.0320740193,
-0.0279611461,
-0.0343920738,
-0.0277565867,
0.0116115129,
0.0411775224,
-0.0206788424,
0.0469298176,
-0.0425309762,
0.0156631377,
0.0164298099,
0.0499852039,
-0.0364958756,
-0.0472398661,
-0.0121004134,
-0.0317613333,
-0.0041856803,
-0.0430811159,
-0.0168120563,
-0.0092210593,
0.033353664,
0.0221146476,
-0.0440145954,
0.0096543608,
-0.0105220247,
0.0067238561,
0.0472207814,
-0.0899801254,
0.0281639323,
0.0252578966,
0.0184095614,
0.0253172051,
0.0719661713,
-0.0170647893,
0.0435932316,
0.0512122251,
-0.0316921771,
0.0132355578,
-0.0000280075,
0.0287774336,
-0.0444303006,
0.0159848519,
-0.0628190115,
-0.030745184,
-0.0063258004,
-0.0224525426,
0.0275848061,
0.0264908671,
0.029115133,
0.0320940241,
0.0673170537,
0.0170275215,
0.0326728672,
0.0110341562,
0.0457509682,
-0.0049883309,
-0.0096078413,
0.0032139102,
-0.0152455419,
-0.046933379,
-0.0374186039,
0.0268088058,
0.0021049604,
-0.0261324085,
-0.0463725924,
-0.0430517606,
-0.0357415825,
0.0219125934,
-0.0099667581,
0.0207955074,
0.0154811358,
-0.0011063011,
0.0432861,
0.011406919,
-0.0295795538,
-0.0359968096,
-0.0247559305,
0.0465475693,
0.0240055136,
-0.035422273,
-0.0782218203,
0.0022402811,
0.0017149104,
0.0934190229,
0.039536614,
0.0235892963,
0.0306180269,
0.0232320037,
-0.0074713407,
0.011698381,
0.0149931563,
0.0258113034,
-0.0551488772,
-0.0274390876,
0.0394081213,
-0.0168623216,
-0.0157537498,
-0.0064178174,
0.0330631882,
0.0422217995,
-0.0176396072,
0.0225350335,
0.0380136222,
0.0126824779,
0.0193219054,
-0.0043824785,
-0.0205401704,
0.0015915888,
-0.0285465829,
-0.0861026645,
-0.0299773663,
0.005506272,
-0.0288961176,
0.0054377289,
-0.011337541,
-0.0247348249,
0.0719444975,
-0.0388699919,
-0.0119375009,
0.0753933489,
-0.0418727398,
0.0170877445,
0.0074045477,
-0.0499946363,
-0.0116355112,
0.0432165936,
-0.0059537017,
0.0399767943,
0.0023844938,
0.0364830345,
-0.0519616082,
-0.0920165032,
-0.0144043714,
0.0044994722,
-0.0366884246,
-0.0598831922,
-0.0419856347,
0.0058011855,
0.020524187,
0.0148879942,
-0.0264833644,
0.0117302779,
-0.0938675255,
0.0044098678,
-0.0554150082,
-0.0040729586,
0.0016979311,
0.0017940371,
-0.0239275508,
-0.0452783629,
0.0180637017,
0.0199989453,
0.023853289,
0.0136066498,
0.0342778191,
-0.0180178806,
0.0488937832,
-0.0433977656,
-0.0229847562,
-0.0305636954,
0.01201264,
0.0055023879,
-0.0646286905,
-0.0265743788,
0.0117926355,
-0.0467798337,
0.0150737148,
0.0483118035,
-0.0393429324,
-0.0234393924,
-0.0213877503,
0.0070103896,
0.0334952027,
0.0180819593,
0.0737596676,
-0.0201925058,
0.0529292785,
-0.0075232512,
0.0280378666,
-0.020550685,
0.0069781174,
-0.0109662199,
-0.0588298962,
0.0072112749,
0.0664659366,
0.0313880108,
-0.0053315223,
-0.0323862471,
-0.0009721411,
-0.0337045603,
-0.0159658771,
0.0001578308,
0.0400416404,
0.0296821352,
0.0096397419,
-0.0045523215,
-0.0605851263,
0.0403270163,
0.0538332127,
-0.0156571083,
-0.0033629048,
-0.0775531307,
-0.029795954,
0.0243683588,
0.0455108471,
0.0197321028,
0.0409604758,
0.0014916654,
0.0750011429,
-0.0163710099,
-0.0234792326,
-0.0055268821,
-0.0016270921,
0.0098403115,
0.0062565217,
0.0299953818,
-0.0622356758,
-0.0302690808,
-0.0833837539,
-0.073051773,
-0.0417388156,
-0.0397862606,
-0.0002437849,
-0.0213200375,
-0.0364183746,
-0.0208343584,
0.0245292429,
0.0016804567,
-0.0477374159,
0.0329655409,
-0.0024664856,
0.0749585852,
-0.0288513731,
0.0149164973,
-0.0181249268,
0.0308743063,
0.0774678886,
-0.0410353392,
0.0339554399,
-0.0125015881,
-0.0170523152,
0.0056160875,
-0.0060927719,
0.0124406246,
-0.0100160651,
0.0113470089,
0.0212186929,
-0.0024550527,
0.1034544185,
0.0059502241,
-0.0131234052,
0.0395581722,
-0.0653081387,
-0.0182971042,
0.0251039825,
-0.0051875529,
-0.0475724079,
-0.0615823716,
-0.088165693,
0.024566168,
-0.0188159775,
-0.0166913271,
0.0203134231,
-0.006460485,
0.0117339436,
-0.0506671369,
-0.0227015279,
0.0520514473,
-0.0442383029,
-0.0040545547,
-0.0416632555,
-0.0723602474,
-0.059391994,
-0.0337176844,
-0.0149533013,
0.0106467791,
-0.1001767293,
-0.0376393981,
0.0153827248,
0.0039508785,
0.0195074212,
-0.020889204,
0.0793601573,
0.0131270234,
-0.002448485,
0.0105887186,
0.0127099724,
0.0099016847,
-0.0222059246,
0.1105429679,
-0.0264780149,
-0.0251777917,
-0.0730434582,
0.051695358,
-0.0774866045,
0.0142189246,
0.0122777019,
0.0747539625,
0.0123640941,
-0.0512877144,
-0.0298393201,
0.0331284404,
0.0576715469,
0.0388725437,
0.0463395193,
-0.0638765693,
-0.0374812707,
0.0416109189,
0.0260005947,
-0.0198994055,
-0.0334050618,
-0.0307097193,
-0.0191292893,
-0.0211242959,
-0.0552499592,
-0.0151725588,
0.022287285,
-0.022839563,
-0.0444927067,
-0.0343052037,
-0.0111978706,
-0.0083338562,
-0.072750017,
0.0458512492,
0.0222897287,
0.0064159143,
-0.0212552678,
-0.0421118774,
0.0548510477,
0.0026060664,
0.0001522578,
-0.0026321788,
-0.0663703829,
-0.0130603453,
0.0182672404,
0.0208240803,
0.0027798298,
-0.0638727546,
0.0010522297,
-0.0490275696,
0.0129161272,
0.0516398288,
-0.0024014888,
-0.0209381413,
0.0361230187,
-0.0205271151,
0.0183102284,
0.0550024398,
-0.0074024023,
0.0649745092,
0.0103269834,
-0.0671294555,
-0.026501067,
0.0137588549,
-0.0232601985,
0.0103586707,
0.0492374673,
0.0073935008,
-0.0420015715,
-0.0005447621,
-0.06241256,
0.0225193426,
-0.01183475,
-0.0196335427,
0.0044599427,
0.0298985969,
0.0214477237,
-0.052843187,
-0.0077939257,
-0.0279739331,
-0.0014222644,
-0.0769974068,
0.0062320619,
0.0112166964,
-0.0116306441,
0.0005258612,
-0.0034648634,
-0.0136319995,
0.0237326808,
0.0309040416,
0.0066437512,
-0.0013813629,
0.0750083178,
-0.0261800531,
0.0418483205,
0.0334171131,
0.0533371717,
-0.0321510099,
-0.0291199591,
-0.0079775732,
0.0165916011,
0.073000066,
-0.0295002237,
0.0943784565,
0.0043121176,
-0.0079607842,
0.0036821887,
0.0312749445,
-0.0353388228,
-0.0356346741,
-0.0233463515,
-0.0101069203,
-0.0213380493,
0.0179936551,
0.0446748994,
-0.024885999,
0.0127385063,
0.0555054992,
-0.0190005489,
-0.0116693638,
0.0295614917,
0.0059992899,
0.0256822631,
-0.0072909687,
0.0304545164,
-0.0003714706,
-0.0844970569,
0.0393161513,
-0.0310653262,
-0.0085166702,
-0.0073193102,
0.0053796135,
0.023440307,
0.0336658433,
0.0294652358,
-0.0739416778,
0.0269473549,
-0.0192399994,
-0.0323995054,
-0.0423758887,
-5.693254892e-33,
0.0360498689,
-0.0117528075,
-0.0569824912,
0.0183161069,
0.0243686698,
0.0718601346,
0.0049002655,
0.0317242853,
0.0204829033,
0.039866671,
0.0395065881,
0.0531889498,
-0.0096359011,
0.0502424091,
0.0045581018,
-0.0124519998,
0.0145644806,
-0.0072193323,
0.0087077171,
0.0251583438,
0.0323816538,
0.0729200616,
0.0409565121,
-0.0811207592,
-0.0307271723,
0.0070121391,
-0.0154019035,
-0.0018143858,
0.0689221323,
0.0251180772,
-0.0288338847,
0.0775836781,
0.0633438528,
0.0215781722,
-0.0045736763,
0.0192000922,
-0.0495448709,
-0.0372884832,
-0.0391880237,
0.0015374307,
-0.0525315441,
0.0295894071,
0.0199492015,
-0.017310828,
0.0046492028,
-0.0076768924,
0.0759308562,
0.0209524855,
0.0551361218,
-0.0447851941,
-0.0164776333,
0.0105802789,
-0.0136102578,
-0.0166583285,
-0.0078691067,
0.089517206,
-0.0042560077,
0.0232138485,
-0.0275360588,
-0.0112126712,
-0.0772276372,
0.0091017308,
0.0178433023,
-0.048677206,
-0.0312086586,
0.0493273176,
0.0179449916,
0.0201508328,
-0.0228932481,
-0.003576987,
-0.0433875583,
0.0149824563,
0.0395444594,
0.0224337932,
0.0937863365,
-0.0400243551,
-0.0392089486,
0.0048375698,
0.0288570561,
-0.0172816496,
0.0139602637,
-0.0114947734,
-0.0153571218,
0.0059711006,
0.0271273609,
0.0109681403,
-0.0107209021,
-0.0283856858,
-0.0132912006,
0.0062385988,
-0.0307451431,
0.0151644228,
-0.0188104548,
-0.029845424,
-0.0319465995,
0.0185873229,
0.0028881137,
0.03522994,
0.0012307697,
-0.0189457405,
-0.0254373457,
-0.0109185614,
0.0141964778,
0.0329199359,
0.0674997121,
0.0067103445,
0.0592276268,
-0.0268759597,
0.0006159675,
-0.0181717705,
0.0230908282,
0.0238916855,
-0.0435493402,
0.0652881861,
-0.0187885184,
0.012843363,
-0.0099069038,
0.044893764,
0.0321279652,
0.0334360972,
-0.0484733768,
-0.0331289321,
-0.0048026657,
-0.0144639816,
0.0065581226,
-0.0554667823,
-0.0256599672,
-0.0112713631,
0.0123277344,
-0.0813698918,
0.0188793615,
-0.0237414278,
2.602e-7,
0.0320310779,
0.0435370617,
-0.0267592147,
-0.0096746646,
0.0305888392,
0.0136111574,
0.0184403155,
0.039853707,
0.049769897,
-0.0071757874,
-0.0088079497,
0.0329456329,
0.0354246087,
0.0439461246,
-0.0315305963,
-0.0252575427,
-0.0075655882,
-0.0082531432,
-0.0438392572,
0.0016418352,
0.0753588453,
0.0568253137,
0.0271577891,
-0.0355317891,
0.0227942113,
-0.02296599,
0.0370071717,
0.0012172352,
0.0376559794,
0.0233778246,
0.0349910296,
-0.0110329315,
0.0196009427,
-0.0305592623,
-0.0307533164,
-0.0433070362,
0.0364335813,
0.0366185606,
-0.0222059805,
0.0180216338,
0.0300400686,
0.0427480713,
-0.011777929,
0.0560860746,
0.0491880924,
-0.0753592998,
-0.0342080668,
-0.0523461848,
0.0042725317,
-0.0407252647,
0.0800667182,
-0.0198195763,
-0.0333455727,
0.0462954715,
0.0309634637,
-0.004520887,
-0.0303544719,
-0.0719547495,
-0.0423198417,
0.0159171,
-0.0467948653,
0.0369865447,
0.0035414738,
0.0074815443,
0.0007565945,
-0.0327400789,
0.0189762786,
1.584333926e-34,
-0.0120165842,
0.0316173136,
0.001939596,
-0.0243968964,
-0.0031117573,
0.0086910026,
-0.0251998976,
-0.0209571291,
-0.0149897272,
-0.0527862757,
0.0015936686
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.