id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17234v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.17234v2 | Cooperation, Competition, and Maliciousness: LLM-Stakeholders Interactive Negotiation | 2023-09-29T13:33:06 | 2024-06-10T14:43:34 | Sahar Abdelnabi, Amr Gomaa, Sarath Sivaprasad, Lea Schönherr, Mario Fritz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | There is an growing interest in using Large Language Models (LLMs) in
multi-agent systems to tackle interactive real-world tasks that require
effective collaboration and assessing complex situations. Yet, we still have a
limited understanding of LLMs' communication and decision-making abilities in
multi-agent setups. The fundamental task of negotiation spans many key features
of communication, such as cooperation, competition, and manipulation
potentials. Thus, we propose using scorable negotiation to evaluate LLMs. We
create a testbed of complex multi-agent, multi-issue, and semantically rich
negotiation games. To reach an agreement, agents must have strong arithmetic,
inference, exploration, and planning capabilities while integrating them in a
dynamic and multi-turn setup. We propose multiple metrics to rigorously
quantify agents' performance and alignment with the assigned role. We provide
procedures to create new games and increase games' difficulty to have an
evolving benchmark. Importantly, we evaluate critical safety aspects such as
the interaction dynamics between agents influenced by greedy and adversarial
players. Our benchmark is highly challenging; GPT-3.5 and small models mostly
fail, and GPT-4 and SoTA large models (e.g., Llama-3 70b) still underperform. | [
0.0481087901,
0.0368273519,
-0.0252044667,
0.0396732613,
-0.0685470402,
-0.0338959545,
-0.010722178,
-0.008061626,
-0.0173102133,
-0.0202280153,
-0.0398686491,
-0.0455258861,
0.0123170894,
0.0228802804,
0.0164064299,
-0.0279757101,
0.0287519544,
-0.0484700315,
0.0295479149,
-0.0151099777,
0.0028289817,
-0.0506099537,
-0.0101655191,
0.0287659373,
-0.0314508341,
0.0028983182,
-0.0398340449,
-0.040802259,
0.0347905383,
-0.0044873673,
-0.0372936986,
0.0390758514,
0.0250772648,
0.0507361665,
0.0000022369,
-0.0841967836,
-0.0357745029,
-0.0162015874,
-0.0086682681,
0.00203055,
0.0766696632,
-0.0365745462,
-0.0158193614,
0.0074046152,
-0.0875542238,
0.0108600147,
0.0120584499,
0.0375570469,
0.0791601539,
0.0740554109,
0.0150956903,
0.0165329557,
0.0208905842,
-0.03265246,
-0.0287422873,
-0.0754970461,
0.0261435229,
-0.0215447433,
0.0011057708,
0.0096860137,
0.0036050456,
0.0160898659,
0.0303880554,
-0.0323993452,
-0.0556161776,
0.042587392,
-0.0376325548,
-0.0180214904,
-0.0004211152,
0.0603402853,
0.0108348606,
0.0423581973,
0.007011997,
-0.0171663575,
-0.0052791401,
-0.0302862935,
-0.0256528482,
0.0245722514,
0.0236358345,
-0.0003455053,
-0.0125846192,
0.0223380923,
0.0367091931,
0.0105391815,
-0.0079991948,
0.0928903297,
-0.0170845818,
-0.0021766336,
0.0021879342,
-0.0289245751,
-0.0364456773,
-0.0726076066,
-0.0353482738,
0.0333521962,
-0.0885128379,
0.0206129663,
-0.0141019626,
0.0195205994,
0.0230071023,
-0.0642793402,
0.0176691413,
-0.0144731011,
0.0435763635,
0.060045287,
0.045568455,
0.0241680667,
-0.0291544385,
0.0324670263,
0.0152904382,
-0.0035829833,
0.0047549848,
-0.0118013015,
-0.030749971,
0.0245218519,
-0.0221978743,
-0.0080566648,
-0.0022195992,
0.0354519598,
-0.0785017908,
0.0645748153,
-0.0040962743,
-0.0015260242,
0.0263445154,
-0.0122704459,
-0.0666850433,
-0.0357386991,
-0.0385850407,
0.0192774441,
0.0022563061,
-0.0447419696,
-0.0115976678,
-0.002008172,
-0.0388690904,
-0.0435973667,
-0.0028718936,
0.1157343686,
-0.0043092272,
0.009875997,
0.0358908512,
-0.03409734,
-0.0005202206,
-0.0837726295,
-0.0309184454,
-0.0498984419,
0.0445944183,
-0.0287522599,
-0.03457563,
-0.0554973111,
0.0110940738,
-0.0275457352,
-0.0164715163,
0.0728048757,
0.0384378955,
0.0248046312,
-0.0010786272,
0.0388156436,
-0.0392172895,
0.0712107867,
0.0743066669,
0.0389307365,
0.0536307245,
0.0450760946,
0.0185832847,
0.0796496868,
0.0108969137,
0.0352418162,
0.0508313999,
0.0105349002,
0.0039601,
0.0517778844,
-0.0499147698,
0.055690676,
-0.0381183773,
-0.0942520276,
0.1078390926,
0.0382265523,
-0.0101868194,
0.0007768917,
-0.0254271515,
0.0532858446,
-0.005742203,
-0.0414456166,
-0.0394507088,
0.054442782,
-0.0280885864,
-0.0173113868,
0.0032434941,
0.0172902606,
-0.0086240303,
-0.0298814215,
0.0169313457,
0.0027835898,
0.0510194711,
0.0201461557,
0.0246823933,
-0.0369320996,
-0.0587451756,
-0.0219729729,
0.0007882007,
-0.0186803676,
-0.0066866232,
-0.0641956776,
0.0249754637,
0.0178640112,
0.0749320164,
-0.0298976321,
-0.0301591177,
-0.0200961679,
-0.0519296527,
0.0620988049,
0.0463708602,
-0.0182516668,
0.0121054854,
-0.0322834253,
-0.0267136544,
-0.0004992177,
0.0033670331,
0.0343068764,
0.0020932979,
-0.0000683963,
-0.0227936804,
0.0118387407,
0.0316077583,
0.0106434328,
0.0174221173,
0.0084042093,
-0.0337931998,
0.0254152119,
0.0811290443,
-0.0018243319,
-0.0357850194,
0.0116668493,
0.0289996974,
-0.0088091129,
-0.0266200621,
0.0146755949,
0.007465288,
0.031203432,
0.0233826861,
-0.0026326869,
0.0017820715,
0.008997215,
-0.0126531376,
-0.0003395507,
0.0463794172,
0.0021119826,
-0.0182514694,
-0.0198835768,
-0.0130402809,
-0.0164580047,
0.0094516203,
-0.0236270614,
0.0261650663,
0.0155708622,
-0.0461180694,
-0.0025545955,
-0.0034614604,
0.0411898643,
-0.0300909244,
-0.0109767644,
0.0570413582,
0.011341338,
0.0091644861,
0.0482837968,
-0.005412587,
-0.0050038197,
-0.0583217219,
-0.0560291596,
-0.009595097,
-0.012729737,
0.0159941968,
0.0079648886,
-0.0468900949,
0.0020102016,
0.0715386495,
-0.0224397965,
0.0587898381,
0.0113619938,
0.0265697688,
0.0225645993,
0.0355551355,
-0.0517899729,
-0.0441597402,
0.0198802073,
-0.0054906937,
0.0294815209,
0.0246034805,
0.0056142202,
-0.0063924897,
0.0315905176,
-0.0524451509,
0.0409675166,
-0.0387726463,
-0.071311228,
0.0511480384,
0.0074122832,
-0.0355583057,
0.0428053364,
0.0136751365,
0.0850943625,
0.0373769253,
-0.0570734181,
-0.0681798533,
0.0335421264,
-0.0430867486,
-0.0068394812,
-0.1070822626,
-0.0293856356,
-0.0048071803,
0.0911558196,
-0.0135254692,
-0.0154923629,
-0.0143157374,
0.0145333176,
0.002310354,
-0.0419010669,
0.0062474692,
-0.0214206874,
-0.013562711,
0.0490109175,
-0.0275364276,
0.0017047579,
0.0790852457,
-0.0349369347,
-0.0046724803,
0.0107557261,
0.0225349851,
-0.0330018774,
0.1047938168,
-0.0165695082,
-0.017555058,
0.0041594543,
0.0234428141,
-0.0781045333,
-0.0480356254,
0.0783534721,
-0.025034003,
0.0255819727,
-0.0540735051,
0.0114998352,
-0.0176469237,
-0.0240320992,
-0.0062430515,
-0.0222012531,
-0.011494589,
0.0485630929,
0.0510049686,
-0.0342476219,
-0.0625023618,
0.0202136822,
0.0432701148,
0.0119518125,
0.029209394,
0.0009714541,
-0.0494302511,
-0.0443927087,
0.0453293063,
0.057028763,
0.027626045,
-0.0382400751,
0.043354895,
0.0594648719,
0.0067496635,
-0.020539647,
0.0130630927,
-0.0243817158,
-0.0011637486,
-0.0070940605,
0.0188459065,
0.0033550607,
0.001892444,
-0.0344514661,
0.0153374812,
0.049945306,
0.0223702006,
0.0010017639,
0.0252059754,
-0.0322608165,
0.0272865742,
0.0019379428,
0.0100616245,
-0.0749453828,
0.0075805648,
-0.00717826,
-0.0128841791,
-0.0331356637,
-0.0752412677,
-0.0034330736,
-0.086872302,
0.0136043653,
-0.0095815007,
-0.0325482227,
0.0328642093,
-0.0143622234,
-0.000972086,
-0.0384061448,
0.0102603212,
-0.0092921816,
0.0766322091,
-0.0303053372,
-0.0299982317,
0.0123051386,
0.0151029555,
0.0272759888,
-0.0364731289,
0.0477968641,
0.0629859939,
0.0402541496,
-0.0138928136,
0.015723113,
0.0214214772,
0.0267465841,
-0.0322592892,
0.0232419595,
0.022119686,
-0.0187380221,
0.0061439099,
0.0059360787,
-0.0175168496,
0.0079989536,
-0.0164183248,
0.0372391529,
0.0537525378,
-0.0019468276,
-0.02291568,
0.0293713715,
0.0088806683,
0.0331352875,
0.0560721681,
-0.020031048,
-0.0454467759,
-0.0467185564,
-0.0349367484,
-0.0336870924,
-0.0306914598,
-0.0485360213,
0.010646618,
0.0377240591,
-0.0366808213,
-0.0406408757,
-0.0810297728,
0.0176856779,
0.0282612909,
-0.0005900735,
0.0143503593,
0.0621300116,
0.0266618785,
0.0125004081,
-0.0161427613,
0.0046051955,
0.038989041,
-0.0082337251,
0.0064292401,
0.0066108252,
-0.0338915251,
-0.0302306991,
0.0124717318,
-0.06663578,
-0.0749915764,
-0.0226178896,
0.0526134744,
0.0301596001,
-0.0287353676,
-0.0306568202,
-0.0417728089,
0.0007592506,
-0.0016703339,
-0.0133986184,
0.0201481245,
0.0257597826,
0.0049659763,
0.0248208549,
0.0493057705,
-0.0381373651,
-0.011374345,
0.0454825684,
0.0459860861,
-0.0580174811,
-0.045775421,
0.017771516,
-0.0142064663,
-0.0222348981,
0.0128314104,
-0.0328235514,
-0.0037792379,
0.0128433546,
-0.0406227373,
-0.0161458906,
-0.0349840783,
-0.0407402143,
-0.001699702,
-0.0016777886,
0.041734118,
0.0524802022,
0.0190713219,
0.010848864,
0.038159389,
0.0066965693,
0.0107787987,
-0.0199489966,
0.0341371,
0.0085321767,
0.0315890424,
0.0070256307,
-0.0271132793,
0.023529347,
0.0400511175,
0.0451447628,
0.0189816356,
-0.0508440249,
0.0146524766,
0.0330915041,
-0.0404611789,
-0.0666333064,
0.060871195,
0.0754806697,
0.0401575826,
0.0542796105,
0.0194451772,
-0.0723565742,
0.0255076606,
-0.011864786,
-0.0088464767,
-0.0256224237,
-0.0748314783,
0.0420091599,
0.0195267871,
0.0012611431,
0.0231924746,
0.0494441874,
-0.0137970466,
0.0363754481,
-0.0221225787,
0.0084188432,
-0.0155659448,
-0.0442713089,
0.0039437795,
0.0054441942,
-0.0249448977,
0.015998926,
-0.0797850117,
-0.0078037493,
-0.011643542,
0.0383905768,
-0.0134825772,
-0.0011709882,
0.0145744579,
0.0346393809,
-0.026906237,
-0.0014151178,
-0.0442562923,
-0.0079296082,
-0.024597045,
-0.0222539492,
-0.0035983706,
-6.685034904e-33,
-0.0007691975,
-0.054990977,
0.0515660346,
-0.0232674442,
-0.0516454838,
-0.054260768,
-0.0267963149,
0.0068560708,
-0.0686833933,
0.0090235667,
-0.0060296962,
-0.0125605958,
0.0187331606,
-0.0117788762,
-0.0210225843,
-0.032095287,
-0.0128943846,
-0.0241282433,
-0.0510599129,
-0.0104198018,
0.0014910749,
-0.0425110683,
0.0285187345,
-0.0599602982,
0.0228301901,
0.006030899,
-0.0503641181,
0.040123947,
-0.0424439833,
0.0425565131,
0.0071988162,
0.0023002925,
0.0105845975,
-0.0451682545,
0.0168631747,
-0.008546073,
0.0073666549,
-0.0020029549,
0.0215461086,
-0.0049506407,
-0.0261613186,
-0.0184941664,
-0.0000391237,
0.0197376572,
-0.045714505,
-0.018883843,
-0.0049361521,
-0.0194699671,
-0.0110964756,
0.0202162974,
-0.0373897813,
0.0284925699,
-0.0352648236,
-0.0133588267,
0.0249837954,
-0.0320764445,
0.0191606097,
-0.0055067604,
-0.0649589524,
0.0583912097,
-0.0247668289,
-0.0120746214,
0.0568556339,
0.0060758558,
0.0367757753,
0.0794249028,
-0.003861676,
0.0472042114,
-0.0163238514,
-0.0764519498,
-0.0065818722,
0.0678551719,
0.0323297046,
0.1054224521,
-0.0650419891,
-0.0052014901,
-0.0556949526,
0.0156850684,
0.0631683841,
0.050720647,
0.0374714844,
0.0130537087,
0.0023064853,
-0.0147717362,
-0.0384685323,
0.0138854124,
-0.0195836201,
-0.0444381088,
0.018385062,
0.0082197944,
0.0368191265,
0.0028134775,
0.0388535485,
-0.0439469293,
-0.0309223142,
0.0277877767,
0.0370504484,
0.0540785529,
-0.0027129448,
-0.0046207919,
-0.0413107164,
-0.0298458543,
-0.0286697764,
-0.0305384733,
0.0228038002,
0.0279133189,
-0.0289587639,
0.0066428203,
0.010622452,
-0.0027008886,
-0.0166828819,
0.0283737276,
0.0168482177,
-0.0115345977,
0.0312796794,
-0.0343322828,
-0.0094692316,
-0.0314497985,
-0.0078633605,
-0.0380113497,
-0.0140386866,
0.0441042371,
-0.0297075827,
0.0055079348,
0.0059488174,
0.0048877788,
-0.031269785,
0.0035308741,
-0.0050862208,
-0.0091504669,
-0.0122199515,
-0.0649590939,
2.981e-7,
-0.0082608974,
0.0534595065,
-0.0012409937,
0.0461536087,
0.021412164,
0.0971018001,
-0.0405046567,
0.0539523587,
-0.0531131104,
-0.0573753156,
0.0389611199,
0.0271407031,
0.0446183905,
0.0482309684,
-0.0285223629,
0.0008768506,
-0.0323278271,
-0.0491128042,
-0.0429090075,
-0.0357241891,
0.074753195,
0.0514119565,
0.0338503458,
0.028535068,
-0.0059260558,
-0.0536027662,
0.0279467739,
-0.0876732394,
-0.013823268,
0.0617697723,
-0.0089021884,
-0.0567367636,
-0.0009864726,
0.007340306,
0.0283462983,
0.0247437656,
-0.0293910541,
0.0586099029,
0.0133032463,
-0.0576008111,
-0.0246728845,
-0.0477317236,
-0.0093228277,
-0.0713877976,
0.0313208923,
-0.0417318568,
-0.0541489683,
0.0166440345,
0.0264718905,
-0.0234000273,
0.0027090667,
-0.0098049045,
0.0120777152,
-0.0193389058,
-0.0104589714,
-0.0076760594,
0.0461858287,
-0.0331917964,
-0.0074861166,
-0.0081173172,
-0.0385628901,
-0.0640003681,
-0.0032537461,
0.040352907,
0.0172316581,
-0.0013632526,
-0.0044485973,
2.461520757e-34,
0.0405851081,
-0.0139922639,
0.0019679961,
0.0341152251,
0.0586758405,
0.0271004587,
-0.033317145,
0.0218445398,
0.0344153605,
-0.0327757336,
-0.0182854515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17224v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.17224v1 | Training and inference of large language models using 8-bit floating point | 2023-09-29T13:24:33 | 2023-09-29T13:24:33 | Sergio P. Perez, Yan Zhang, James Briggs, Charlie Blake, Josh Levy-Kramer, Paul Balanca, Carlo Luschi, Stephen Barlow, Andrew William Fitzgibbon | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AR, cs.CL, cs.ET, cs.PF, I.2.7; B.2.4 | FP8 formats are gaining popularity to boost the computational efficiency for
training and inference of large deep learning models. Their main challenge is
that a careful choice of scaling is needed to prevent degradation due to the
reduced dynamic range compared to higher-precision formats. Although there
exists ample literature about selecting such scalings for INT formats, this
critical aspect has yet to be addressed for FP8. This paper presents a
methodology to select the scalings for FP8 linear layers, based on dynamically
updating per-tensor scales for the weights, gradients and activations. We apply
this methodology to train and validate large language models of the type of GPT
and Llama 2 using FP8, for model sizes ranging from 111M to 70B. To facilitate
the understanding of the FP8 dynamics, our results are accompanied by plots of
the per-tensor scale distribution for weights, activations and gradients during
both training and inference. | [
-0.0488769151,
0.0547357127,
-0.022516327,
0.0292382799,
-0.0054538748,
0.0062025548,
0.0473618172,
0.0098515991,
-0.0353078805,
-0.0142859584,
-0.033251062,
-0.0787529126,
0.0156451985,
0.0309329294,
0.0343242884,
-0.0518839508,
0.0192277264,
-0.0328453444,
-0.0170435756,
-0.0173241664,
0.0281759724,
0.0034876871,
-0.0172344279,
0.0133674731,
-0.0141316829,
-0.0173112545,
-0.0091454051,
0.0007594997,
0.012130795,
-0.0171016455,
-0.0037336424,
0.0154994065,
0.0703479722,
0.0405923314,
0.0000020824,
0.0019137531,
-0.0123984097,
0.0226682387,
-0.0009304477,
0.0517851412,
0.0746162087,
-0.0242530294,
-0.0413997248,
0.0258342568,
-0.0041353847,
-0.0696081072,
0.0521970801,
0.0203816928,
0.0355477184,
0.0621899627,
-0.0033590584,
-0.0609197691,
0.0509933308,
-0.0182508845,
-0.041391965,
-0.0221096743,
0.0266714413,
0.0143840257,
-0.0427176692,
0.0329061896,
0.0071866242,
-0.0348155759,
0.0338991508,
0.0052936231,
-0.0429322869,
0.0468136519,
-0.0231693164,
-0.0159276593,
-0.0039596902,
0.0618458204,
-0.018535018,
-0.0454808697,
-0.0098308101,
-0.025356425,
-0.0494175926,
-0.0515709184,
-0.0487618074,
0.0369545221,
0.0533629842,
0.0554638878,
0.0232566316,
-0.0200432036,
0.0674039721,
0.0049424111,
-0.0385611765,
0.046271652,
0.0225420538,
0.0142007554,
-0.0131952874,
-0.0256891809,
-0.0810329467,
-0.0109260185,
0.0152484057,
0.0395825058,
0.0381382518,
-0.0001438892,
-0.0542403199,
-0.0425565653,
0.0227631424,
-0.1009005457,
0.0831421316,
0.0507434383,
-0.0193567518,
0.0246065278,
-0.0483006686,
0.0562912673,
-0.0612129606,
0.020766722,
-0.0126172565,
0.022883052,
0.0109350728,
0.0106083043,
-0.0280038789,
0.0178849697,
-0.0381449386,
-0.0277574789,
-0.0472148173,
-0.0195083171,
-0.0004687899,
-0.023528086,
-0.0137534086,
-0.0093513718,
-0.0395015366,
-0.0088540297,
-0.0135865174,
0.0616971068,
-0.0252564661,
0.0208780617,
-0.0272285733,
-0.0433722921,
-0.0147430012,
0.0130972816,
-0.0136315618,
-0.0245153215,
0.0636640787,
0.030562995,
0.0244786236,
-0.0423333123,
-0.0510545261,
0.0239017885,
-0.0026461077,
-0.0589606464,
0.0272701252,
-0.0490497164,
0.0083063859,
-0.0282687042,
-0.0166087281,
-0.0081177037,
0.0265629999,
0.040654704,
0.0138395596,
0.0738042668,
-0.0210191812,
-0.0005163874,
0.0163126383,
-0.0411551185,
0.0438530669,
0.0852578506,
0.0680343881,
-0.0023438632,
0.0116319489,
-0.0086820126,
-0.0274194907,
0.0439031906,
0.0426564813,
0.0307592731,
-0.0523513407,
-0.0199762452,
0.0266818441,
0.0278497469,
0.0578794666,
0.080866158,
-0.0398674533,
-0.0611017421,
0.0197675824,
0.0264353044,
0.0327205844,
0.0637544394,
0.0433731861,
-0.0570035167,
0.0273213815,
-0.0097348858,
-0.0414493904,
-0.000032202,
0.0439702421,
-0.0078117386,
0.0307096522,
0.0667629093,
-0.0339042693,
-0.0283752028,
-0.0341411829,
-0.004346631,
0.0116066877,
-0.0076085678,
0.0369654559,
-0.0146537032,
-0.0077203531,
0.0708982944,
0.0208507739,
-0.0183593743,
-0.0196914002,
-0.0459411815,
0.0070673372,
0.0234970544,
-0.0218478423,
-0.0246465281,
-0.0039308351,
-0.0013719482,
0.0143903187,
0.0045638164,
0.0311562363,
0.0108192395,
0.0260346252,
-0.0711179301,
0.0242548008,
-0.0050466573,
0.0101534342,
-0.0112567274,
0.0241447873,
0.0214083195,
-0.0044113132,
-0.0856599733,
-0.029535329,
0.0398991704,
0.0102346661,
-0.0456069224,
0.0297015589,
-0.0171356443,
0.0088011008,
0.0287585557,
-0.0088017955,
-0.0366269946,
0.0381526463,
-0.0505032092,
0.0019220391,
-0.0222572386,
-0.0420903042,
0.0565193929,
0.0658748969,
0.0180250183,
0.0503664501,
0.0149466321,
-0.0512108654,
-0.0426323973,
0.0453275666,
0.0028508138,
0.0323917493,
-0.0391509943,
0.0030546391,
-0.0245516784,
0.0834733397,
-0.0340850987,
0.0239908155,
-0.0335262902,
0.0055387132,
0.013422396,
0.0474498607,
0.0433245525,
-0.0403388701,
-0.0274767671,
0.0261123609,
0.0309176352,
0.0053242184,
-0.0039420943,
0.0105168857,
0.0219357498,
0.0194001049,
-0.0874262229,
0.0011121709,
-0.0447380878,
0.0486813858,
0.0542209446,
0.0282674786,
-0.0044936584,
0.0055203214,
-0.0294051785,
0.0226347577,
-0.0208251309,
0.0073250048,
0.0465528406,
-0.00948817,
0.0009994443,
-0.0443486273,
-0.0653342605,
-0.0258195102,
0.0589394607,
-0.0005809703,
0.0210382473,
-0.0325801186,
-0.0008629084,
-0.0096340189,
0.061539121,
-0.0107443491,
-0.0493469909,
0.0210322309,
-0.0286149867,
0.0199574959,
0.045083642,
-0.0175154377,
0.0340033807,
0.0556159802,
0.0626376346,
-0.033419475,
0.0188463498,
-0.0252801832,
-0.0013370059,
-0.0026184234,
-0.0319255292,
-0.0442856401,
0.0646116585,
-0.0581318736,
0.0002507333,
-0.0250163041,
-0.0326312482,
-0.0262714326,
0.0201251302,
0.0397945158,
0.0442908145,
-0.0129929967,
0.0380173214,
0.0287862159,
-0.0548399873,
0.0229932275,
-0.0368718877,
-0.0027921065,
-0.0372523926,
-0.0310285091,
-0.0458954647,
0.0698479414,
0.0169962551,
0.0154110314,
-0.0292135384,
-0.0125539908,
-0.0234771818,
-0.013739923,
0.0220920164,
-0.0249184798,
0.0431444049,
-0.0394510105,
0.0391324274,
-0.0336723961,
-0.0358628556,
0.0033934237,
0.0287806075,
-0.0374866687,
0.0230208803,
-0.0168795083,
-0.0700456798,
0.0102367895,
0.0209163688,
0.0106348796,
0.0275544282,
-0.0332579836,
0.0101469578,
-0.0073576299,
0.0436525606,
0.0172798503,
0.0108098332,
0.0308433976,
-0.0429211482,
-0.0168803409,
-0.0067239008,
0.0285483003,
0.067130737,
-0.1406273991,
-0.0196344294,
0.0423994213,
0.0175088476,
-0.0238960497,
0.024891939,
0.0585927665,
-0.0432993136,
-0.0006770174,
0.0501509495,
-0.0009689862,
-0.0698350146,
0.022296736,
0.0250871032,
0.0183098912,
0.000335099,
0.0345505476,
-0.0840519369,
-0.0140672252,
0.0117146308,
-0.0227522831,
0.0008742901,
-0.005423699,
-0.0037250465,
-0.075289011,
-0.003696993,
0.0076595386,
0.0085277157,
-0.0435630754,
-0.0929628164,
0.020804232,
-0.0389697291,
0.077267535,
-0.010408584,
-0.0170427673,
-0.0004763768,
0.0291246548,
0.0082587097,
-0.0329904482,
0.0099971779,
-0.0128413718,
0.0596735924,
0.0603676103,
-0.0129887098,
-0.0509244539,
-0.0490860119,
0.0536890738,
0.0030690029,
-0.0205868725,
-0.0088632125,
0.0119657656,
0.0345351361,
-0.0056982199,
-0.0027628553,
0.0296529867,
0.0019685084,
0.0074538183,
-0.0361388177,
0.0528442562,
-0.0039771721,
-0.0578542501,
-0.0397662409,
-0.0141205126,
-0.0235310905,
0.0268530864,
0.0203845128,
-0.038397219,
-0.0648148805,
-0.0270373486,
-0.0007862064,
-0.0113723418,
-0.0309892353,
0.0041102781,
0.0378019474,
0.0229584109,
-0.0210517291,
0.0340595692,
0.0005223739,
0.0344793759,
0.0062017236,
-0.0633447394,
0.0057691401,
0.0044180593,
-0.0465242937,
0.0146731576,
-0.0010523079,
0.0560378581,
-0.0500523187,
-0.0053639244,
0.0445226431,
-0.010497936,
-0.0054111434,
0.0293097924,
-0.1312206388,
-0.0419437364,
0.0103370491,
0.0092126066,
0.018100787,
0.000314475,
0.0142768575,
-0.0575785935,
0.0329676084,
0.0321555063,
-0.00275991,
0.0223390162,
0.0093281493,
-0.0475214273,
0.0025086205,
0.0153658856,
-0.0093008745,
0.0430580936,
-0.0008789569,
0.03561325,
-0.0125855636,
-0.0250224844,
0.0109474314,
-0.0043005268,
0.0422221459,
0.0299314391,
-0.0459137373,
-0.0127465762,
0.0035238583,
0.0148109971,
0.0420849696,
-0.0307680741,
0.0349882767,
0.0123565234,
0.0325778425,
-0.0097261677,
-0.0567653552,
0.0419185013,
0.0126482071,
0.0134548619,
0.008427239,
-0.0079476554,
0.0332526267,
-0.0019390968,
-0.0002102069,
-0.0336727723,
0.0280649923,
-0.0318766795,
0.0489026569,
-0.0160265248,
0.0315587334,
0.0060820966,
0.0097614396,
-0.0423824564,
0.0289739408,
-0.020900365,
-0.0665279105,
-0.0650940388,
-0.019105969,
0.0428247377,
0.0218379535,
-0.0038335207,
-0.0539024472,
-0.0018276958,
0.0099232057,
0.0057651461,
-0.0053597116,
0.0056312368,
0.0602584593,
0.02300415,
-0.0110129267,
0.0182469636,
0.0357464105,
-0.0024498201,
0.0196431465,
0.0333807804,
0.0331376828,
0.0146890022,
-0.0374829322,
-0.0806616023,
0.031560272,
-0.0284914151,
-0.0266734455,
-0.0037315965,
-0.0593121685,
-0.0155485813,
0.0318295583,
0.0001043589,
-0.0348902605,
0.0365190096,
0.0581281967,
-0.0164695997,
-0.0111119431,
0.0024780382,
-0.015745854,
0.0266044214,
-0.0186623037,
-0.0249633119,
-5.995992074e-33,
0.0035315612,
0.0567921735,
0.0222751144,
-0.0146813141,
-0.0407487229,
0.0124296565,
0.0110616451,
-0.0198975876,
-0.0413878821,
0.0055993795,
-0.0216815621,
0.0343502536,
0.0067489846,
0.0273875184,
-0.0324914157,
-0.0189124756,
0.0689622685,
-0.0312236827,
0.0028844799,
0.0636674836,
-0.0026827755,
0.0145293316,
0.0654537454,
-0.0348684192,
-0.0339458957,
0.0404255204,
-0.0236374121,
0.017184766,
-0.0091179013,
0.0324450433,
-0.0627902821,
0.0491132326,
0.0003061598,
-0.0625274032,
0.0024976998,
-0.0547598526,
-0.0776312426,
-0.001674754,
0.0222452153,
0.0406672098,
-0.0035847593,
-0.0153726647,
0.0599584728,
0.0037199976,
-0.040340025,
-0.0205444247,
-0.0011605866,
0.0022435838,
0.0047898497,
-0.0020632471,
-0.0221098047,
0.0156086935,
0.0524005629,
0.0516540632,
0.0399575643,
-0.0322147384,
-0.049009528,
-0.0216118265,
-0.0406671911,
-0.0089086173,
0.0385486223,
0.0340287536,
0.0025626495,
0.0429085977,
0.0412926264,
0.0398637913,
0.0147852646,
-0.0298928339,
-0.0507956743,
-0.0036082577,
0.0762506276,
0.0167244859,
0.02000737,
0.0370088406,
0.1062748581,
-0.0033898798,
-0.0782359317,
-0.0268732514,
0.0817377567,
0.0080231037,
0.0154114747,
0.0051959604,
-0.0142127899,
-0.0188056976,
-0.0241107978,
-0.0130587425,
-0.0243144911,
-0.0650917515,
-0.0106587308,
-0.0083860401,
0.009864456,
0.0091580227,
0.0026335719,
-0.0378187895,
-0.0168378633,
-0.0266276468,
-0.0087250266,
0.040156655,
0.0236178543,
0.030992562,
-0.030147586,
-0.0500039048,
-0.0273702797,
-0.005103224,
0.0400837883,
0.020982556,
-0.0013483677,
0.0601039641,
-0.0375750698,
-0.0263450667,
-0.0410999507,
-0.026814118,
0.0452398844,
0.0690654069,
0.0208916087,
0.011102316,
0.0131939147,
0.0180834252,
-0.0030812121,
0.0475827381,
-0.0084913811,
-0.0105738724,
0.0160484742,
0.0802938268,
-0.0750237405,
-0.0313180536,
-0.0551182367,
0.0570721328,
-0.0108892675,
-0.1077738181,
-0.0473328866,
0.0570561662,
2.76e-7,
0.0228665154,
0.0184649043,
0.0313049294,
0.0145414658,
-0.0069173374,
0.0024325051,
0.0323659852,
0.0441825204,
-0.0119893029,
-0.0279680882,
0.0157341696,
0.0157066006,
0.0154375359,
0.0268420875,
-0.0316677764,
-0.0130799152,
-0.0322036259,
-0.0005934195,
-0.0355937816,
-0.0462358966,
-0.0462245867,
0.1321707219,
0.0148196248,
-0.0156981051,
0.0505384132,
0.0039663399,
0.0635584071,
-0.0211807247,
0.070233278,
-0.0286677014,
-0.0134488782,
0.024360612,
-0.0313533247,
0.0034647083,
0.0274073984,
0.0265368279,
-0.0247756056,
0.0430806354,
-0.006298454,
0.006746883,
-0.0166763365,
-0.021651784,
-0.0246450752,
-0.0959586352,
0.0642389283,
-0.014551945,
-0.0168509223,
-0.0548175983,
-0.0129202167,
-0.0261200797,
0.0063790455,
-0.0210175347,
0.0146679366,
0.0582525842,
0.0128118312,
-0.0296327844,
-0.0234887321,
-0.0841459185,
-0.0063522235,
0.0082904799,
-0.036598023,
-0.0091149788,
-0.0712598935,
-0.0397533737,
0.0293192677,
-0.0313657634,
0.0127601875,
2.628525903e-34,
0.024432851,
-0.0360746197,
0.0114747938,
-0.0092747938,
-0.0241872761,
-0.0133434907,
0.0317081809,
-0.0178303998,
-0.0091434708,
-0.0749259517,
-0.0326835588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17179v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.17179v2 | Alphazero-like Tree-Search can Guide Large Language Model Decoding and Training | 2023-09-29T12:20:19 | 2024-02-09T00:13:46 | Xidong Feng, Ziyu Wan, Muning Wen, Stephen Marcus McAleer, Ying Wen, Weinan Zhang, Jun Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent works like Tree-of-Thought (ToT) and Reasoning via Planning (RAP) aim
to augment the reasoning capabilities of LLMs by using tree-search algorithms
to guide multi-step reasoning. These methods rely on prompting a pre-trained
model to serve as a value function and focus on problems with low search depth.
As a result, these methods will not work in domains where the pre-trained LLM
does not have enough knowledge to serve as an effective value function or in
domains that require long-horizon planning. To address these limitations, we
present an AlphaZero-like tree-search learning framework for LLMs (termed
TS-LLM), systematically illustrating how tree-search with a learned value
function can guide LLM decoding. TS-LLM distinguishes itself in two key ways.
(1) Leveraging a learned value function and AlphaZero-like algorithms, our
approach can be generally adaptable to a wide range of tasks, language models
of any size, and tasks of varying search depths. (2) Our approach can guide
LLMs during both inference and training, iteratively improving the LLM.
Empirical results across reasoning, planning, alignment, and decision-making
tasks show that TS-LLM outperforms existing approaches and can handle trees
with a depth of 64. | [
0.0270050298,
0.0670914054,
0.0119745992,
0.0523058213,
-0.0367245376,
0.0279404931,
-0.055350747,
-0.0027322595,
-0.0432745554,
-0.0146081485,
-0.011409658,
-0.0108055864,
-0.0093590291,
0.0354468524,
-0.0088840816,
-0.0215941556,
0.0454195887,
-0.0293726176,
0.0334752277,
-0.0010518444,
-0.0207548682,
0.0370606482,
-0.0057162307,
0.0345177315,
-0.006478047,
-0.0111085037,
-0.0433768779,
0.0224870015,
0.0141566684,
-0.0331023075,
-0.0135746272,
-0.0073703658,
0.042931404,
0.044077009,
0.0000018313,
-0.0233787782,
-0.0686144978,
-0.0249142777,
-0.0777196735,
-0.0277382508,
0.0063451272,
-0.0233459827,
-0.0033558768,
0.0046061161,
-0.0509461425,
0.0098048355,
0.0356635712,
0.010392677,
0.0455367751,
0.0987803414,
0.0098248888,
-0.048533719,
0.0330453143,
-0.0066547515,
0.0113274753,
-0.076236926,
-0.0108737489,
-0.0074332189,
0.0026516474,
0.0222170129,
-0.0094128605,
0.0272249561,
0.0145699587,
0.0169661809,
-0.007850321,
0.0532523505,
0.0313847438,
-0.0209589414,
-0.0290119778,
0.0545695834,
-0.0291781109,
-0.0188983008,
-0.0161376763,
-0.0245626457,
-0.0504703186,
-0.0452050045,
-0.019128222,
0.0556211323,
-0.0059560193,
0.0438192599,
0.0663442686,
-0.0134119997,
0.0526520312,
0.0230173115,
-0.0734289587,
0.0979374722,
-0.0017149687,
-0.0426877774,
0.04228843,
-0.0067340904,
-0.0044095223,
-0.0542123467,
-0.002379853,
0.0640741736,
-0.0597092286,
0.0548211746,
0.0089307642,
0.0090300627,
-0.0052702869,
-0.0017726045,
0.0269395113,
0.0789802745,
-0.014303254,
0.0392110869,
-0.0147740534,
0.0333208963,
-0.0371204652,
0.0419709496,
-0.0495829694,
-0.0171605293,
-0.0366367437,
-0.0204921439,
-0.0315894112,
0.024518989,
-0.027215356,
-0.0165644027,
-0.0156391654,
0.0241174698,
0.032040704,
0.0179727823,
0.0256995801,
0.0028459798,
-0.0128734699,
-0.0623752587,
-0.0201678779,
0.0618149228,
-0.0185842849,
0.0099200401,
0.0062243827,
0.0002118631,
-0.0223881695,
0.0192135666,
0.0004019628,
-0.0219262633,
0.0248308759,
0.0663237199,
-0.0091309482,
-0.0195116531,
-0.0470633656,
-0.006199121,
-0.0201444421,
-0.0602710284,
0.0344863459,
-0.0531665683,
0.0037654098,
-0.0171519853,
0.0134991873,
-0.0212283209,
0.0188011657,
0.0127077596,
0.0049016047,
0.0714376122,
-0.0079444675,
0.0040703234,
-0.0174049232,
-0.0097979587,
-0.0117073674,
0.0790675655,
0.0484948941,
0.0363218226,
-0.020970311,
0.0330497324,
-0.0416982844,
0.0397575311,
0.0202606469,
-0.0068064057,
0.0309729557,
0.0194205511,
-0.0445903912,
0.0328220837,
0.0091053862,
0.011431545,
-0.0424644537,
-0.0277455095,
0.0091499584,
0.0483014807,
0.0088387132,
-0.0090638399,
0.0309230797,
-0.0208893921,
-0.0248503834,
-0.0314211212,
-0.0387331732,
0.013936583,
-0.0709200427,
0.010673902,
-0.057927303,
0.0054409369,
0.0046181958,
-0.0384860486,
-0.0283136796,
0.0034557721,
0.0042907307,
0.0327674821,
0.0501469709,
0.0347697139,
-0.0552508943,
0.0187966675,
-0.0178661402,
-0.007566249,
-0.0175968222,
-0.0557761528,
0.0424123667,
0.0375848003,
0.0399475321,
-0.0297480375,
-0.0217532832,
0.0315986089,
-0.0062239524,
0.0580235347,
-0.0081930785,
-0.0351805873,
0.0171049573,
-0.0540241376,
-0.0465144292,
-0.0119204503,
0.0086643565,
0.0284521338,
0.012744843,
-0.0248291716,
-0.0111933565,
-0.0236678384,
0.0130424667,
0.0300118513,
-0.038371589,
-0.025877405,
0.005848858,
0.0324098952,
0.0355974473,
0.0007754973,
0.0004950594,
0.0290677808,
0.0097665535,
-0.0282458421,
-0.0353912711,
-0.0229790956,
-0.0633858442,
-0.0622056611,
0.0484899245,
-0.0176756307,
-0.0455025807,
0.0136253415,
-0.047807049,
-0.024859732,
0.0068250163,
-0.049376227,
0.0490618497,
-0.0337511785,
0.0233537965,
0.0182580575,
-0.0632140487,
-0.0391373411,
0.0954445228,
-0.0307323504,
-0.0385139473,
0.0322285742,
-0.0171960928,
0.0209740046,
-0.0168650076,
0.0246273167,
0.0416368358,
-0.0220701601,
-0.019659305,
0.0077539058,
0.0373151302,
-0.0461730547,
-0.0171464738,
-0.0554252006,
0.0321953669,
-0.008397446,
0.0337366909,
0.0132684652,
0.0007270696,
0.0188004747,
0.0094964504,
-0.0279458165,
0.0234356876,
0.0108258771,
-0.0170104746,
0.0239931699,
0.0012969532,
-0.0227035955,
-0.0265306253,
-0.0260261912,
-0.0464689955,
0.0152617199,
-0.0368393399,
-0.0452198721,
-0.0394625105,
0.0473224409,
-0.0256487262,
0.0045835469,
0.0019762139,
-0.0041270121,
0.0253533851,
-0.060007859,
0.0028685052,
0.0554628186,
-0.01214997,
0.0084425593,
0.0595669635,
-0.0224118643,
-0.0649541467,
0.0290016253,
-0.0277686436,
-0.0321966447,
-0.0680721626,
-0.0232398435,
0.0401324444,
0.0967774689,
-0.0115989037,
0.0291126892,
-0.0852596387,
-0.0060639754,
0.0089631863,
-0.0254676323,
0.0115684569,
-0.0054803118,
0.0146527626,
0.060168419,
-0.0281788893,
-0.0302251577,
0.1053717509,
-0.020513732,
-0.0146032954,
-0.0259766839,
0.0089012478,
-0.0671696439,
0.0646337494,
-0.0126011223,
0.0165402945,
-0.0041016391,
-0.0521704853,
-0.0386128277,
0.0071645952,
-0.0020403725,
-0.0146119511,
0.0575772747,
-0.0388651416,
0.0168033224,
-0.0105425129,
-0.0537279099,
-0.0287792776,
0.0088728545,
-0.063567698,
0.023646906,
0.0126599949,
-0.033436276,
-0.0161745455,
-0.0435901582,
-0.0060226135,
0.0177212842,
0.0161415581,
-0.01527174,
-0.0333717577,
0.0045250449,
0.0350942537,
0.0082283542,
0.0593718849,
-0.0278173182,
0.0426236652,
0.0387541242,
0.0359469205,
-0.0165190306,
-0.032143157,
0.0312423073,
0.0385059305,
-0.0058808099,
0.0118548544,
0.0141149033,
0.0316344649,
-0.0640013069,
-0.0152461743,
0.0892399997,
0.0411070772,
-0.0502039902,
-0.0054536876,
-0.0828316882,
0.056004528,
0.0205712449,
0.0320137143,
-0.0888723359,
-0.0501838364,
0.018422436,
0.0143245915,
-0.018139232,
-0.0374483839,
-0.0177517105,
-0.1141126081,
0.018715946,
0.0287756901,
0.0056897728,
-0.0237899981,
-0.0082208337,
-0.0239562169,
-0.0096081803,
-0.00874878,
0.0484810546,
-0.009476942,
-0.0103335958,
0.0109611014,
-0.0212668665,
-0.0213950593,
0.0386447012,
-0.0110290674,
0.0334501415,
0.0909597352,
0.0390746742,
0.0451459438,
0.0083154961,
-0.0229180269,
0.0062134978,
-0.0022029765,
-0.0428955443,
-0.0301512517,
-0.0283445772,
0.0156165296,
0.0283374637,
0.040783342,
-0.042395249,
-0.0079910224,
-0.0024444405,
0.1025572941,
-0.0514016785,
-0.0191613976,
0.0113740219,
-0.0029096527,
-0.0072890916,
0.0635706782,
0.0041584503,
0.0294737332,
-0.0598759428,
-0.0648835003,
-0.0139883906,
-0.046553921,
-0.0412175208,
0.0496284366,
0.0300017279,
0.0343757458,
-0.0443519428,
-0.0185714997,
0.0576691255,
0.0088333953,
0.0036007331,
-0.0229238868,
-0.0069457334,
0.0022727288,
-0.0358882993,
-0.0004990926,
-0.0601910055,
0.0374263227,
-0.0098396717,
0.0288600326,
0.0193123668,
-0.0056759743,
-0.0060252286,
0.0466963537,
-0.0665736496,
-0.0485567562,
-0.042499274,
0.0400805175,
0.0212512165,
0.0553732626,
-0.0254772455,
-0.0206996091,
0.0228143744,
-0.0135226054,
-0.0117437076,
-0.0033833371,
0.0535370484,
0.0144229578,
0.0196608137,
0.0684423149,
-0.0597704314,
-0.0074557811,
-0.0066806781,
0.0832654834,
-0.0424416028,
0.010720443,
0.0617841296,
0.0079365578,
-0.0033639711,
-0.0249510352,
-0.0305635612,
-0.0098907156,
0.049854517,
-0.0307080206,
-0.011266904,
-0.0454519875,
0.0185970049,
0.0376108997,
-0.0477917902,
0.0176266339,
-0.0294446051,
0.0166701414,
0.0162112918,
0.0286611002,
0.0171304028,
0.0580645949,
0.0012410718,
0.0303082746,
-0.0180958565,
-0.0057436163,
0.0159792099,
-0.0038709645,
0.0480673052,
-0.0072576581,
0.0518370755,
0.0512242131,
-0.0186274145,
-0.0433538556,
-0.0356324352,
-0.0520427041,
-0.0969403014,
0.0061972486,
-0.0328477696,
0.0585185848,
0.0293586999,
0.0109915268,
-0.0585486926,
0.001536775,
0.0250584129,
-0.0049086493,
-0.0182712469,
-0.0483976789,
0.0461002886,
0.0213871207,
-0.0102985846,
-0.017690666,
0.0390066989,
0.0615172237,
0.0777746886,
-0.0034724621,
0.0016011624,
-0.0440993942,
-0.0538214818,
-0.0219036918,
0.0523390882,
-0.0287332293,
0.0130174616,
-0.0518496111,
-0.0540683717,
-0.00036211,
0.0103817889,
-0.018424347,
-0.0069465181,
0.030308878,
0.0372387208,
-0.0252405684,
-0.0509278439,
-0.0088803833,
-0.0199514516,
-0.0065228897,
-0.0272889175,
-0.0369813852,
-5.723742072e-33,
-0.0294109005,
-0.0145479077,
0.0735585093,
-0.0144091295,
-0.0242207926,
-0.0014069999,
-0.0538822487,
-0.0158941355,
-0.0209043324,
0.0320990644,
-0.015400867,
0.0165337399,
0.0051578288,
0.0341003127,
0.0255983584,
-0.0040373732,
0.0289818179,
-0.0231148526,
-0.0101992656,
-0.0093973139,
0.0252152123,
0.0236996748,
0.0593392737,
-0.0178457759,
-0.0188065432,
0.0336178504,
-0.0238125101,
0.0890652314,
-0.0223088432,
0.0364540704,
-0.0127376951,
-0.0190885719,
0.007267239,
-0.018969927,
-0.031250529,
0.0014783512,
-0.0936246142,
-0.0049940245,
0.0374248959,
-0.0022132832,
-0.0444168113,
-0.0392886288,
-0.0028728822,
0.001280245,
0.0318603218,
-0.0418196693,
-0.0170714892,
-0.0419667549,
-0.0082902601,
-0.0339354947,
-0.0460010767,
0.0357000455,
-0.0117795765,
-0.0211628694,
0.0778752193,
0.057339076,
0.0067993104,
0.0413254797,
0.0152061675,
0.0322758593,
-0.027224835,
0.0142991813,
0.0756545514,
0.0302897282,
-0.0193648823,
0.0585976727,
0.0071580028,
-0.0265633129,
-0.0475592129,
-0.0000450823,
0.0124325752,
0.1013730317,
0.0095250569,
0.0026370471,
0.0267617088,
0.0498862937,
-0.0719383433,
-0.0015330142,
0.0126524195,
0.0626668707,
0.0085716425,
0.0377400257,
-0.0171073414,
0.000696471,
-0.0330021158,
0.0076541295,
-0.0415737517,
-0.0137667712,
0.0136833107,
0.0345349163,
-0.0024449953,
0.0030992061,
0.051648844,
-0.0513204522,
0.0209713578,
0.0774267614,
0.0017509488,
0.0237033553,
-0.0085843503,
0.0618628785,
-0.0538380109,
-0.0119914953,
0.0043994416,
-0.0423067436,
0.0025618372,
0.0068583922,
-0.0045675933,
0.0283796471,
-0.0310283341,
-0.0205157604,
-0.055360347,
-0.0062374379,
-0.0297444873,
0.0205100551,
0.0500053279,
0.0207521655,
0.003755813,
0.0252848398,
0.0031495253,
0.0169505309,
-0.0180929452,
-0.0138361054,
-0.0141111389,
0.0141519215,
-0.0061910548,
-0.0268148985,
-0.0382001437,
-0.0175377466,
0.0038552361,
-0.0632403344,
0.0046360693,
0.0507744923,
2.565e-7,
0.0344168134,
0.0489433631,
0.0278465655,
0.0512172207,
0.0139363715,
0.0162138846,
-0.01331532,
-0.0306740254,
0.0005886441,
-0.0809298977,
0.0422756411,
0.033064276,
0.0732709318,
0.033905372,
-0.083886452,
-0.0006444292,
-0.0143402247,
-0.0209143758,
-0.0590645932,
-0.0419573635,
0.0531978719,
0.111177735,
0.0034701589,
-0.0241123736,
0.0386162437,
-0.0004417736,
0.0570263229,
-0.00929623,
0.0141386949,
0.0006771362,
0.0238120351,
-0.0346304365,
0.0161438826,
-0.0000279851,
0.0109478002,
0.0589390881,
-0.023630878,
0.0882811695,
-0.0015091631,
-0.0609443635,
-0.0236961376,
-0.0277074091,
-0.0124108335,
-0.0151021797,
0.0592827052,
-0.0477743857,
-0.0276648812,
-0.0291664414,
-0.002070003,
-0.0101196533,
-0.0284580253,
-0.0120846983,
0.003757488,
0.0292106625,
-0.0059250495,
-0.0174481235,
0.0039282967,
-0.0842252076,
-0.0144189307,
0.0155751342,
-0.0275110416,
-0.0091552343,
-0.0231189765,
0.0405020267,
0.0203925539,
-0.0712741464,
-0.0285494495,
2.490934978e-34,
0.0475578308,
-0.0417930931,
-0.0143846525,
0.0829192251,
0.043268986,
0.0105135739,
0.0064522098,
0.0278092679,
0.0411202312,
-0.0780091435,
-0.0159999002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17176v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.17176v3 | AdaRefiner: Refining Decisions of Language Models with Adaptive Feedback | 2023-09-29T12:16:19 | 2024-05-03T08:24:12 | Wanpeng Zhang, Zongqing Lu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated significant success across
various domains. However, their application in complex decision-making tasks
frequently necessitates intricate prompt engineering or fine-tuning, leading to
challenges in unseen downstream tasks and heavy demands on computational
resources. Meanwhile, Reinforcement Learning (RL) has been recognized as
effective in decision-making problems but struggles in environments with sparse
rewards, such as open-world games. To overcome these challenges, we introduce
AdaRefiner, a novel framework designed to enhance the synergy between LLMs and
RL feedback. The key component of AdaRefiner is a lightweight Adapter Language
Model (LM), which automatically refines task comprehension based on feedback
from RL agents. This method mitigates the need for intricate prompt engineering
and intensive LLM fine-tuning while maintaining the LLMs' generalization
abilities and enhancing their decision-making capabilities in downstream tasks.
Empirical evaluations of AdaRefiner on 22 diverse tasks within the open-world
game Crafter have demonstrated its superior effectiveness, especially in
guiding agents towards higher-level and common-sense skills. Our work makes
contributions to the automatic self-refinement of LLMs with RL feedback,
offering a more adaptable and efficient solution for complex decision-making
problems. | [
0.0209987648,
0.0215123612,
-0.0322580971,
0.0239992905,
-0.0166899115,
-0.0012487848,
-0.0397983454,
-0.0133533888,
0.0062290528,
-0.0034540752,
-0.0454690605,
0.0175993778,
-0.0066175419,
0.0441039689,
-0.0081552668,
-0.0249411464,
0.0090066586,
-0.0766072273,
0.02973588,
0.0015197619,
-0.0455956273,
-0.000171426,
-0.0004391326,
0.0966873989,
0.0802078545,
-0.0028661112,
-0.0207191296,
0.0132558784,
0.0184535906,
-0.015166631,
0.008750461,
-0.0022628191,
0.0328485891,
0.0093298899,
0.0000025293,
-0.0398631506,
-0.0233604684,
-0.038824942,
0.0016487106,
-0.0249448847,
0.0083234627,
0.004100014,
-0.0099845808,
0.0267679673,
-0.0494995937,
-0.0457100272,
0.062872,
0.0391955338,
0.052892305,
0.0249857958,
0.014299795,
0.0090125483,
-0.0157376956,
-0.0005401818,
-0.0034890536,
-0.0598597154,
-0.0082250563,
0.0053125988,
0.0286077745,
-0.0100894906,
-0.0465959534,
0.0209587701,
0.0091132559,
-0.0093756514,
-0.030581167,
0.0360148102,
0.0261282902,
-0.0088265212,
-0.014497946,
0.0419303887,
-0.0212267879,
-0.0284553394,
-0.0039405553,
-0.0127697997,
0.0187065322,
0.0305095017,
-0.0313071571,
0.0380731151,
-0.0182883646,
0.0120059755,
-0.0144584905,
-0.0221407898,
0.027000105,
0.0006806173,
-0.0343308784,
0.1062339097,
-0.0262228884,
-0.0227079038,
-0.0171046965,
-0.0034403417,
0.0013757278,
-0.0601025298,
-0.0169340372,
0.0549745671,
-0.0947620943,
0.0219642445,
-0.0283354241,
0.014895902,
-0.0295990985,
-0.0368067212,
0.0735903904,
0.0432540439,
-0.0217683818,
0.0709556043,
-0.0463594086,
0.049596224,
0.0145301018,
0.0100660538,
-0.0428052321,
0.0000200134,
-0.0398591533,
-0.0205563456,
-0.0502578653,
0.0025246337,
-0.0521567017,
-0.0191320498,
-0.0025090245,
0.0457531624,
-0.0435159653,
0.0551091097,
0.0013685009,
0.0043338411,
-0.0198469777,
-0.0203870256,
-0.0876543,
0.0253873263,
-0.0224299338,
0.0093638254,
0.0174239874,
-0.0081485501,
0.0162812676,
-0.0015200103,
-0.0046666525,
-0.00028584,
0.0096480334,
0.1023076102,
-0.0067639779,
0.0026318606,
-0.0174615718,
-0.014979545,
0.0141475564,
-0.0422577187,
-0.0543619357,
-0.0679005831,
-0.0195629243,
-0.0013153667,
-0.0064578396,
-0.070987843,
0.0046532424,
0.0019721796,
-0.016953513,
0.0789382309,
0.0240676142,
0.0274252091,
0.020161489,
-0.0044449614,
0.0014716953,
0.0835482404,
0.0758254379,
0.0466838814,
0.0046460717,
-0.0018114048,
0.0207752977,
0.0298216771,
-0.0401432812,
-0.0168539155,
-0.034570612,
-0.0078174928,
0.0147640957,
0.048025541,
0.0217993818,
0.0201964732,
-0.0189104509,
0.0228360351,
0.0701263919,
-0.0001010153,
0.0448510535,
-0.0107559888,
0.0788394436,
0.0258298516,
-0.0405134223,
-0.0127162822,
-0.0275049452,
0.0373510532,
-0.0127247144,
0.0140258996,
-0.0175412428,
0.0290021002,
0.0038331819,
-0.0801574588,
0.030913977,
0.0047097229,
0.0691200271,
0.0575741306,
0.0619074069,
0.0214052778,
-0.0781140029,
-0.0236486252,
0.0374925621,
-0.0152325351,
0.0027111573,
-0.0827805251,
0.0697181597,
0.0763855353,
0.0584162548,
-0.040413335,
-0.0362300687,
-0.0412746482,
-0.0188711323,
0.0440717936,
0.0353721306,
-0.018407505,
-0.0011010219,
-0.0239059757,
-0.0690371692,
-0.004489501,
0.0054772063,
0.0695491582,
-0.0016915537,
-0.0054982295,
-0.0271390043,
-0.0090864319,
-0.0603002794,
0.0156318638,
0.0096323788,
-0.06566111,
0.0268278457,
0.0025095874,
0.008590918,
-0.0159337875,
-0.016651554,
-0.0050070789,
0.0280413162,
-0.0311566517,
-0.0365576483,
0.036842946,
-0.0292448644,
-0.000982689,
0.0381461456,
0.021782225,
0.0102687748,
-0.0120795788,
-0.0018332271,
-0.0207603145,
0.0623259582,
0.0132562434,
0.0539372265,
0.0095477859,
0.038571991,
-0.0439238623,
-0.0184810366,
-0.0629177615,
0.0124535812,
0.0156889725,
-0.0364671946,
-0.0325326584,
0.004689889,
0.0009098831,
-0.0270329323,
0.0125226313,
0.0174137615,
0.0092673013,
0.0165591557,
0.0534748584,
0.0407898165,
-0.0192039888,
-0.0515364036,
-0.0282529742,
-0.0283912215,
-0.0225754306,
-0.0118283443,
-0.0254594143,
0.0013707179,
-0.0038434069,
-0.0215365794,
0.0078788092,
0.0525715426,
0.0220008325,
0.0009982049,
0.0164738782,
0.0387386791,
-0.009855831,
-0.0139499344,
-0.0032502927,
0.0023795597,
0.008244562,
0.0143191339,
0.0394500308,
-0.0835364088,
-0.0048933472,
-0.0375892185,
0.0382638425,
-0.0539693311,
-0.0261702463,
0.0225362498,
-0.0349926949,
0.04509997,
0.0629008114,
-0.0106895342,
0.0326683931,
0.0969523191,
-0.0086293193,
-0.061783988,
0.0432497859,
-0.0094712852,
-0.0578740276,
-0.0477734283,
0.0098720249,
0.0403235182,
0.094923079,
-0.0212479588,
-0.0011108215,
-0.0704581439,
0.0370311551,
-0.0192144718,
-0.0543980487,
-0.0409265794,
-0.0086314231,
-0.0170676541,
0.0468187742,
-0.0184190031,
-0.0304664392,
0.0969350934,
0.000384243,
-0.0020624246,
-0.02722474,
-0.0251344629,
-0.0492142066,
0.0439404026,
0.0031130512,
0.0244235341,
0.0195674133,
-0.0095786871,
-0.0409392118,
-0.0391154997,
0.0409734733,
-0.0259488989,
0.0820329413,
-0.0767074451,
-0.0111194113,
0.012635963,
-0.047254771,
-0.0243674666,
0.0584760606,
-0.0335259959,
0.0061587011,
-0.0074142469,
-0.027195517,
-0.0651981086,
0.025666723,
0.0547119826,
0.0431217775,
-0.007657133,
-0.0371862501,
-0.0259466767,
-0.0328498073,
0.0847958773,
0.0506587885,
0.0072856704,
-0.0435865372,
0.0355501063,
0.0099845696,
0.016585853,
-0.070362784,
-0.0167506412,
0.0197178312,
0.0512608476,
-0.0375444107,
0.036407873,
0.0490551703,
0.0314760096,
-0.0821385458,
-0.020479802,
0.0848836005,
0.0203020219,
-0.0248926431,
0.0010996284,
-0.0561905429,
0.0384350494,
0.0270449743,
0.0441906899,
-0.0460454002,
-0.0366125666,
-0.0060385689,
0.0148422569,
0.0084647182,
-0.0355092399,
0.0096516702,
-0.1078148484,
0.0232174806,
-0.0030129913,
-0.0757697672,
-0.0273166113,
0.0158433821,
-0.0019635609,
-0.0184077565,
0.0058035916,
0.0260376278,
0.0013114585,
-0.0042001712,
0.0044559664,
-0.0133416364,
-0.003704512,
-0.0034406516,
-0.0650901422,
0.0756077766,
0.0620145276,
0.0147773549,
0.0199631751,
-0.0054633203,
0.0144410059,
0.0351032391,
0.0239824224,
-0.039400626,
-0.0211443566,
0.0135721639,
-0.0144433621,
0.0257656295,
-0.0239342246,
0.0004345218,
-0.0208710264,
0.0496247038,
0.0740989223,
0.0044270102,
-0.0223354828,
0.0060829669,
-0.0224214811,
0.0296963435,
0.0476288795,
-0.001632483,
-0.0504218526,
-0.0617059395,
-0.0482720733,
-0.0678843558,
-0.0708526522,
-0.0314853974,
-0.0215431005,
0.0030691426,
-0.0002161069,
-0.0749071762,
-0.026610421,
0.0535310842,
0.0106521724,
0.0092333416,
0.0152255753,
-0.0014588126,
0.0155021483,
-0.0441271476,
0.006165809,
-0.047018446,
0.0198436342,
-0.064767018,
-0.0290999487,
0.0014105818,
-0.0862360969,
0.0096745156,
0.0507320352,
0.0030309402,
-0.0367357954,
0.0007786923,
0.0854935646,
0.0142513895,
0.0254567713,
-0.0114719607,
-0.0560909286,
0.0220546536,
0.0190916136,
-0.0270447973,
0.0258607473,
0.0154997576,
0.0382219553,
0.0144692715,
0.0273384657,
-0.0623054579,
-0.0033619043,
0.0353014395,
0.0521821529,
0.0345753208,
-0.0448245592,
0.0304689724,
-0.0151475072,
-0.0084715793,
-0.0310950335,
-0.0132723786,
-0.026588928,
0.0176381674,
-0.0074046371,
-0.0319149755,
-0.0479729064,
0.0131472368,
0.0127003063,
-0.0230387468,
0.042161379,
0.0096706506,
-0.0164390504,
0.0093514798,
-0.0522902086,
0.0512796119,
0.0141527774,
0.0270630401,
0.0437574312,
0.0388581268,
0.0220140871,
0.0051171607,
-0.0038545853,
0.0616045818,
0.0266792439,
0.0521361753,
0.011867675,
-0.0141523406,
-0.0398934931,
0.0260888077,
-0.0180719458,
-0.0668710023,
0.0330241993,
0.0654709935,
0.0318077579,
0.0308086239,
0.0399936438,
-0.0279280823,
0.0036283948,
-0.0103942109,
-0.0276741982,
0.0171505958,
-0.0484053306,
0.0212059915,
0.0605024062,
-0.0078221727,
-0.0109846871,
0.0353186652,
-0.0131653231,
0.0458488166,
-0.0292767268,
-0.002706914,
-0.0499490909,
-0.0051506436,
0.0313123353,
0.0033427456,
-0.0534330122,
0.0138669098,
-0.0768642873,
-0.0189401209,
-0.0334508866,
0.091027841,
0.0034421054,
-0.0386337712,
-0.0077910693,
0.0315166041,
0.014844995,
-0.0341890305,
-0.0741796494,
-0.0084404228,
-0.0436751842,
0.0132942684,
-0.0315900818,
-6.274472931e-33,
-0.032406345,
-0.0153358709,
0.0695101023,
-0.0203975942,
-0.0000381028,
-0.0314985067,
-0.0428458042,
-0.008372467,
0.0052334447,
0.0054115043,
-0.0094068041,
-0.0105160056,
-0.00425458,
-0.0039490955,
0.0446395762,
-0.0112023912,
0.0636382923,
0.0470876358,
-0.0791958496,
0.016819926,
0.0211736746,
-0.0078943912,
0.0439766869,
-0.0589460991,
0.0039523942,
0.0474169888,
-0.0221635345,
0.0167163592,
0.0254062954,
0.0607992597,
0.0140927918,
0.0293370727,
0.0109321661,
-0.0470644832,
-0.0211515892,
-0.0100625344,
-0.0751658008,
-0.0264365207,
-0.0051906765,
-0.0052659302,
-0.0126609122,
-0.0321590565,
0.0308778584,
0.0248268116,
-0.0262178704,
0.0251878705,
0.0355804414,
-0.0404027514,
-0.0284575187,
0.0485267155,
-0.0817355812,
0.0112407329,
-0.0216313731,
-0.041365616,
0.0031948101,
0.0332836099,
-0.0286386814,
-0.0002860721,
-0.0365856551,
0.0484231561,
0.0407027863,
0.0028812215,
0.0725509301,
0.0641994402,
0.0162809193,
0.0125029692,
0.0070509803,
0.016110044,
-0.0286425278,
-0.0089635514,
0.0293529723,
0.0486697704,
0.0009517252,
0.0581970066,
0.0141224116,
0.0142637519,
0.00266301,
0.057837639,
0.0243484545,
0.0964580253,
0.0497046895,
0.0476525277,
-0.0233338177,
-0.0244506467,
-0.0481818542,
0.0221877601,
-0.0156678334,
-0.0348542854,
0.034993466,
0.0253019538,
-0.0241751913,
-0.04844933,
0.0156634711,
-0.0218241699,
0.0143589759,
-0.006148784,
-0.033318188,
0.0090470184,
-0.0224676207,
-0.0034200083,
-0.0147968335,
-0.0320687294,
0.0138046211,
0.0012795965,
0.0019645963,
0.0179549735,
-0.0311905704,
0.0655462071,
-0.0548817813,
0.024220055,
-0.0287749376,
0.0171524379,
0.0098861139,
0.0156649817,
0.0175917465,
-0.0468013659,
-0.0213142857,
0.0065862066,
-0.0083311722,
-0.1018653661,
0.0004792338,
-0.0129242698,
-0.0220742654,
0.0099031953,
-0.0326897353,
-0.0069806753,
-0.048997961,
0.0429470018,
0.010496188,
-0.0495693684,
-0.0107080201,
0.0109910937,
3.28e-7,
-0.0262480676,
0.0474910289,
-0.0179234706,
0.0137997419,
-0.0269724466,
0.0574926995,
-0.0237864554,
0.0100152213,
0.0123555716,
0.0310589261,
0.0261304546,
0.0641557276,
0.0108512128,
-0.0216821525,
-0.0653053597,
0.0258698165,
-0.02853751,
0.0167334247,
-0.0423823893,
-0.0054481342,
0.0117861014,
0.0417859294,
0.00570706,
-0.0054591587,
0.029932892,
-0.0361332335,
0.0095630828,
-0.0641637817,
0.0201000609,
0.0087985732,
0.0091008609,
0.0081948871,
-0.0266415402,
-0.0378829986,
0.0067596016,
0.0321183912,
-0.0299997348,
0.0662880242,
0.0021498571,
0.0097204102,
-0.0027593845,
0.0007424309,
0.0163176898,
-0.0766359195,
0.0404407196,
-0.0396901704,
-0.0249708947,
-0.0276953597,
0.0346921906,
-0.022078665,
-0.0284050014,
-0.0334718712,
-0.0346908234,
-0.033541102,
0.0040076342,
0.0119011011,
-0.0043013501,
-0.063838914,
-0.0146971326,
0.0224333294,
-0.0192026943,
-0.0311213564,
-0.0445750095,
0.0116353836,
-0.0223232526,
-0.065086484,
0.0151057784,
2.913728383e-34,
0.0015960757,
-0.000696338,
-0.0115073072,
0.0059554959,
0.0415260196,
0.0189681351,
-0.0230608713,
0.050502006,
0.0645781979,
-0.0614763089,
-0.012573747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17171v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.17171v1 | Comparative Analysis of Named Entity Recognition in the Dungeons and Dragons Domain | 2023-09-29T12:09:36 | 2023-09-29T12:09:36 | Gayashan Weerasundara, Nisansa de Silva | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Many NLP tasks, although well-resolved for general English, face challenges
in specific domains like fantasy literature. This is evident in Named Entity
Recognition (NER), which detects and categorizes entities in text. We analyzed
10 NER models on 7 Dungeons and Dragons (D&D) adventure books to assess
domain-specific performance. Using open-source Large Language Models, we
annotated named entities in these books and evaluated each model's precision.
Our findings indicate that, without modifications, Flair, Trankit, and Spacy
outperform others in identifying named entities in the D&D context. | [
0.0409119949,
0.0052258009,
-0.0149855465,
0.0691410229,
0.0085283509,
0.0330361873,
-0.0063171587,
-0.0129091581,
0.0157323107,
-0.0684081763,
0.0118660582,
0.0089334976,
0.0491445586,
-0.0251651853,
0.0153921219,
-0.0401450396,
0.0382915027,
-0.0536211766,
-0.0077332603,
0.0290036704,
-0.0164270792,
0.0377712622,
-0.0326401666,
0.0451056808,
0.0280031916,
-0.0423959829,
-0.0172081217,
0.028379431,
0.0496078543,
-0.0942824408,
0.0205735508,
-0.0093235606,
-0.0250575878,
0.0545460358,
0.000001824,
-0.0537656769,
-0.0009999976,
-0.0087279873,
-0.0020612429,
-0.0020344362,
0.0130737629,
0.0179043431,
0.0036576989,
-0.0590454079,
0.022926081,
-0.0566785894,
0.0683893412,
0.0710288733,
0.0260013528,
0.0357839987,
0.017074056,
-0.0702665001,
0.0005242003,
0.027071774,
-0.0143661657,
-0.0149240177,
0.0063019525,
0.021278929,
0.0037390492,
0.0155996904,
0.0114668291,
0.0280958638,
-0.0514421947,
0.0407731868,
0.0110387066,
0.0489427671,
0.0019746069,
0.035027314,
-0.0181662813,
0.0563841611,
0.0005577528,
-0.0076185265,
0.0161230918,
-0.0000807935,
-0.0412016846,
0.0332761221,
0.0164722987,
-0.0388064198,
-0.0412817746,
-0.0271055978,
0.0143879224,
0.023343185,
0.0419943221,
-0.0097043365,
-0.0407091863,
0.0190486908,
0.0004979894,
-0.0301124845,
-0.0013567241,
0.0184182357,
-0.0368455872,
-0.0458265021,
-0.0138061419,
0.0251382906,
0.0068609174,
0.0062082913,
-0.0106867058,
0.0003467107,
0.023770446,
-0.0046121287,
-0.0130027849,
0.0116820345,
-0.0028717669,
0.029069772,
-0.0219604466,
0.0206384752,
0.0525416732,
0.0060464619,
0.0356028154,
-0.0005859266,
-0.0590484738,
0.0035525172,
-0.0470479503,
0.038118273,
-0.0351352803,
-0.0280287731,
-0.0546962097,
-0.062084619,
0.0269562826,
0.0246539935,
0.0554968454,
0.0202914905,
0.0278068762,
0.0054494687,
-0.0669514686,
-0.017553702,
-0.0204588398,
-0.0045495117,
-0.0412576385,
-0.0087923938,
0.0278786235,
-0.0549977794,
0.0554147922,
-0.075763531,
0.0520921797,
0.0689017773,
0.0417896435,
-0.0849252939,
-0.0532325245,
-0.007421711,
0.0006760036,
-0.0203185678,
-0.036545027,
-0.0316148102,
0.0276239887,
-0.0112364283,
0.0764040649,
-0.0186856836,
0.0322492681,
0.0212177038,
-0.0511175804,
0.0897523612,
-0.0620990023,
0.0318638235,
0.0290292818,
-0.0140126254,
0.0102517596,
0.0057081794,
0.0438503027,
-0.0212831125,
0.0397081003,
-0.0015460356,
-0.0207675286,
0.0164041407,
-0.044475913,
-0.0610605516,
0.0037419163,
0.0020298075,
-0.0381895006,
0.0154168578,
-0.0030723989,
0.0362776369,
-0.0089287926,
-0.0461242907,
0.0768762231,
0.0860630199,
0.0564647391,
-0.0003907205,
0.0334202908,
0.0134576187,
0.0218660589,
-0.0274910554,
-0.0122970818,
-0.0196418092,
0.026682334,
0.0090478072,
-0.0366486683,
0.0693752542,
0.0460544713,
0.0099552497,
-0.0378191695,
0.0010117233,
-0.0009589686,
0.0104393363,
0.0501773059,
-0.0190173872,
-0.0607698299,
0.0331934802,
0.0255777799,
-0.0274087209,
0.0089663556,
0.0162490215,
0.0079148198,
0.0968193561,
0.0615271814,
-0.0367532112,
-0.0285124909,
-0.0495854765,
-0.0413102098,
0.0575795956,
-0.031870231,
-0.0330169611,
0.0476450399,
-0.031368617,
0.0073247249,
-0.0081636962,
0.0160430726,
0.0545806214,
0.0205002315,
0.0566605441,
0.003284724,
-0.0102199893,
-0.0558627173,
0.0591763593,
-0.0306685083,
-0.0507140756,
-0.0395179465,
0.0507749654,
-0.0488672554,
0.0553940982,
-0.0474484004,
-0.046446193,
0.0042002886,
-0.0390379988,
-0.0115710534,
-0.0006049268,
0.0337115042,
-0.0162337236,
0.0645234063,
-0.0512778983,
-0.0220804866,
-0.0160672218,
0.0472731479,
-0.0108970394,
-0.023977479,
-0.0164641328,
0.0089359311,
0.0066842814,
0.0397174172,
-0.0084128529,
0.0061924527,
-0.0586984456,
0.0786978826,
0.0106790168,
0.024251949,
-0.0066400133,
-0.0281984806,
0.0121632004,
-0.0126570035,
-0.03572594,
0.0135443667,
0.003493546,
-0.0152799962,
0.0172652304,
-0.0250590425,
-0.0023895281,
-0.0413438454,
-0.0320161469,
0.0202331115,
0.023596067,
0.0625364184,
-0.0144297294,
-0.0022229895,
-0.0400562361,
0.0389104225,
-0.0057505034,
-0.0289966874,
-0.0194982123,
-0.00390726,
0.0330284387,
0.0092770904,
-0.0309158452,
0.0126677612,
0.0305200852,
-0.0248765256,
0.0339739434,
0.0112245893,
-0.0616321489,
-0.0269186851,
0.000721949,
-0.0569211096,
-0.0231585633,
0.0068258746,
-0.0397670493,
-0.0032497533,
0.0041799406,
0.0099920034,
-0.0104251523,
-0.0203402769,
-0.0027425871,
-0.0008476027,
-0.0634283572,
-0.0148073379,
0.0160539262,
0.0152116055,
0.0163811687,
0.006731106,
-0.048925668,
0.0651154965,
0.0942069143,
-0.0280194115,
0.0073988833,
-0.0382349528,
0.0155076655,
0.0024449194,
-0.0115892747,
-0.0291805994,
0.0130129466,
-0.0025708543,
0.0078176176,
-0.0108948322,
0.0194141921,
0.0302854721,
-0.0290249493,
-0.0136969807,
-0.0067575173,
0.0174102411,
-0.052211035,
0.0297630932,
-0.0074235299,
0.038458541,
0.0724571794,
-0.1220753714,
0.0245309155,
0.0511358827,
0.0337206088,
-0.0185547434,
0.0616090819,
-0.0131321391,
-0.0106000099,
-0.0090305544,
0.0439244136,
-0.0070056403,
0.0126286885,
-0.0668155327,
-0.0349884704,
-0.0221099835,
-0.0339866057,
-0.0260214657,
0.0321947038,
-0.0095424,
-0.0164016429,
0.0061591011,
-0.02448567,
-0.0127240149,
0.0277455971,
0.0278962478,
0.0080346353,
0.0085794739,
-0.0342427455,
0.0043064924,
-0.0007314393,
-0.0839625597,
-0.0488351695,
-0.0056460099,
0.0138241174,
0.037043307,
-0.0829150528,
-0.0122845415,
-0.0131252371,
-0.0197747145,
-0.0553739704,
0.034178067,
0.0870050937,
0.03363581,
0.0188267305,
0.0038479019,
0.0255180672,
-0.0200393442,
0.031828206,
-0.031093318,
-0.1044406667,
-0.0467630699,
0.0317865126,
0.0184537601,
0.0020863307,
-0.071775265,
0.0116722221,
-0.0852692574,
-0.0190228261,
-0.0246212613,
-0.0550462976,
-0.0061263782,
0.007385741,
0.0009849933,
-0.0286495779,
-0.0414458252,
-0.0374117941,
-0.0269821975,
0.0051049921,
0.008054113,
0.0117794005,
-0.0113502247,
0.0153190913,
-0.0517494492,
0.02350045,
0.0576837063,
0.0956113115,
0.0052633421,
-0.0210735556,
-0.0457201898,
-0.0262347516,
0.0029917152,
-0.0104642613,
0.0727045462,
-0.0246933904,
-0.0120917605,
-0.0210835189,
-0.0290604085,
-0.0271371473,
-0.0369600207,
0.032414183,
0.0290146824,
0.048719313,
-0.0250159521,
-0.0146204196,
-0.0063744965,
0.0424794443,
0.0600098372,
-0.0201878697,
0.0172240362,
-0.0247459672,
0.005979728,
0.022003375,
0.0027027382,
-0.0804400146,
-0.0000593995,
0.007252262,
0.0106851785,
-0.072557345,
-0.0296113212,
0.0327930078,
0.0395915471,
0.0587317869,
0.0557454526,
-0.0198007412,
0.0575404242,
-0.0144300601,
0.0188511591,
-0.028414689,
-0.002547428,
-0.0760829523,
-0.0144928508,
0.0352458768,
-0.0032850569,
-0.0093873134,
0.0346944071,
-0.0222175885,
-0.0380973667,
0.0059848065,
0.0038887875,
0.0146593181,
-0.0031609109,
-0.016455587,
-0.0450991541,
0.0132907219,
0.0645154491,
-0.0503654443,
-0.032570947,
-0.0470855385,
0.0537822247,
-0.0202198438,
0.0021556956,
-0.0111732902,
0.0330868959,
-0.0083924579,
0.0305023212,
-0.0221203025,
-0.0722300187,
-0.0152306342,
0.0207949802,
0.038297426,
-0.0591440983,
-0.0409429222,
-0.0239767917,
0.0100395875,
-0.0068512992,
0.0011582051,
0.0113956779,
-0.0188205782,
0.0167104006,
0.0030262319,
-0.0349326506,
0.0547154993,
0.0170198809,
0.0261197537,
-0.0772868097,
0.0157737732,
0.0490866788,
0.0377978235,
0.0030976844,
0.0022049118,
0.0224171504,
0.0042414423,
0.0039164154,
0.062357448,
0.0076534944,
0.0200187396,
-0.003580997,
-0.0269131865,
-0.0175650995,
-0.0247458015,
-0.0171495676,
0.0096510714,
0.0131249866,
0.0191648845,
0.0522862226,
0.0028904835,
0.0444279574,
-0.0023485173,
-0.017917376,
0.0381519571,
0.0260921549,
0.0058312267,
0.0204023942,
-0.019753838,
0.0374364853,
-0.028178446,
-0.0013387495,
0.0193826836,
0.007477113,
0.0270481259,
0.0530671552,
-0.071604453,
-0.0351376571,
-0.0111119701,
-0.0099432906,
0.0141224554,
-0.0281935371,
0.0614578351,
-0.1001820639,
-0.0132012973,
0.0429440886,
-0.0061390433,
0.0158401486,
-0.007677705,
-0.004548307,
-0.0215761662,
0.034825433,
-0.0090851989,
-0.0296886172,
-0.0079791388,
-0.0489960425,
-0.0173529349,
-0.0346213803,
-5.088267255e-33,
-0.046068307,
-0.0115065882,
0.01837961,
-0.0124896569,
-0.0156351514,
0.0037324696,
-0.0173304621,
0.0231611691,
0.0348931924,
0.0344625488,
0.0047802017,
-0.0461258553,
0.021750275,
-0.019334849,
-0.0078301029,
-0.0392302498,
0.0163259879,
0.0352464132,
-0.0147946291,
-0.0147622656,
0.071471408,
0.0533264279,
0.0773334429,
-0.1051297709,
0.0268859565,
0.0202120282,
0.0209808331,
-0.02769861,
0.0884407237,
0.0313560069,
-0.0443486683,
-0.024517931,
0.0024034434,
-0.0125036901,
0.020400634,
-0.0056577991,
-0.1135803983,
0.0234267358,
-0.0020244734,
0.0349632688,
0.0815362185,
-0.032192912,
0.0130689302,
0.0222878493,
0.0049307179,
-0.00819059,
0.0748212039,
-0.0049523031,
-0.0004057373,
-0.039219752,
-0.0889226124,
0.0440099277,
-0.0303492546,
0.0075781965,
0.0446332656,
0.0063045984,
0.0301454011,
0.0314948484,
-0.0635323673,
-0.026797235,
0.0443847142,
-0.0560641401,
-0.0026275464,
0.0462240614,
-0.0068460382,
0.0970864743,
0.0357561558,
0.01287595,
-0.0466902852,
0.0596575029,
0.014791159,
-0.0015551151,
0.0203915779,
0.0702816769,
0.0355085246,
0.003419687,
-0.0488285832,
0.0272581279,
-0.0093247285,
-0.0050311154,
0.032074742,
-0.0320584886,
-0.0712351128,
-0.0050080782,
-0.0182495546,
0.0014960776,
-0.0139051843,
-0.0192769282,
0.0197368376,
-0.0319204889,
-0.0492684096,
0.0300046224,
0.0029542947,
-0.0375385769,
-0.078851454,
0.0099002756,
0.0429388657,
0.0210242402,
-0.0474154763,
-0.0091863507,
-0.0222458132,
-0.0163339972,
0.0335155874,
0.0081824614,
0.0547420345,
-0.0198248364,
-0.0207471382,
0.0040926137,
-0.0745135173,
-0.0127362097,
0.013515654,
0.032973934,
-0.0279180724,
0.0795046762,
0.0516667813,
-0.081682153,
-0.00314943,
-0.0165643673,
0.0341046192,
-0.0468148217,
0.0054394929,
0.0330547616,
0.0171435513,
-0.0131930653,
-0.0075218729,
0.0109608294,
-0.0190356914,
-0.0327577591,
0.0179522038,
-0.0374525227,
-0.0048760492,
-0.0237355996,
2.504e-7,
-0.0104963835,
0.0088634444,
0.0147621464,
0.0228210576,
-0.0234124139,
0.0308681205,
0.0008514608,
0.0105183031,
0.0171086751,
-0.0223738644,
-0.0236725137,
-0.0282003265,
0.0506204553,
0.0423720703,
-0.1197277531,
-0.0286291037,
0.0102924109,
0.0335294195,
-0.0350332111,
0.0262106806,
-0.0128087085,
0.0164788198,
0.0210445486,
-0.033112213,
-0.001097603,
-0.0242074654,
0.0122205392,
-0.0304468926,
0.0493942238,
0.0595274754,
0.0383189507,
0.0359497555,
-0.0178301409,
-0.0048247003,
0.009568355,
0.0508257635,
0.0416634306,
0.0210081749,
-0.0239940826,
0.0645155832,
-0.0274129715,
-0.0738810822,
0.0093901055,
-0.0434759185,
0.0676061288,
0.0158776008,
-0.0158750378,
0.0143100284,
-0.0524403714,
-0.0268767867,
-0.0208243094,
-0.0244538244,
-0.0141933011,
0.033570759,
0.0231942274,
-0.030197639,
0.0136625012,
-0.0850681067,
0.0219929237,
0.0278301891,
0.0085706301,
-0.014336938,
-0.0018651565,
0.0044556647,
-0.0336715356,
-0.0491440892,
-0.0149584273,
2.035956216e-34,
-0.0642714873,
0.0168203115,
-0.0540807657,
0.0536842346,
0.0530471578,
-0.0196855478,
0.0322604664,
-0.0136287967,
0.0032063522,
-0.0332932137,
0.0225702971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17169v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.17169v2 | An evaluation of GPT models for phenotype concept recognition | 2023-09-29T12:06:55 | 2023-11-23T02:06:20 | Tudor Groza, Harry Caufield, Dylan Gration, Gareth Baynam, Melissa A Haendel, Peter N Robinson, Christopher J Mungall, Justin T Reese | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Objective: Clinical deep phenotyping and phenotype annotation play a critical
role in both the diagnosis of patients with rare disorders as well as in
building computationally-tractable knowledge in the rare disorders field. These
processes rely on using ontology concepts, often from the Human Phenotype
Ontology, in conjunction with a phenotype concept recognition task (supported
usually by machine learning methods) to curate patient profiles or existing
scientific literature. With the significant shift in the use of large language
models (LLMs) for most NLP tasks, we examine the performance of the latest
Generative Pre-trained Transformer (GPT) models underpinning ChatGPT as a
foundation for the tasks of clinical phenotyping and phenotype annotation.
Materials and Methods: The experimental setup of the study included seven
prompts of various levels of specificity, two GPT models (gpt-3.5-turbo and
gpt-4.0) and two established gold standard corpora for phenotype recognition,
one consisting of publication abstracts and the other clinical observations.
Results: Our results show that, with an appropriate setup, these models can
achieve state of the art performance. The best run, using few-shot learning,
achieved 0.58 macro F1 score on publication abstracts and 0.75 macro F1 score
on clinical observations, the former being comparable with the state of the
art, while the latter surpassing the current best in class tool. Conclusion:
While the results are promising, the non-deterministic nature of the outcomes,
the high cost and the lack of concordance between different runs using the same
prompt and input make the use of these LLMs challenging for this particular
task. | [
-0.0000116868,
0.0459793285,
0.0137754353,
-0.0438772179,
0.0071529127,
0.0314981379,
-0.0012652489,
0.0335603878,
-0.0323376171,
-0.0385640748,
-0.0259896237,
-0.043825876,
-0.026066443,
0.0468979254,
-0.0126096942,
-0.0540448353,
0.0381185077,
0.0181500148,
-0.0124262124,
0.0076172026,
-0.0419631898,
0.0083319433,
0.0242664777,
0.0481068976,
0.0080230525,
-0.0419326834,
0.0470774584,
-0.0226721372,
0.0310271103,
-0.0426735878,
-0.0141836647,
0.0793010518,
-0.0032695304,
0.0506678857,
0.0000022844,
-0.0427888259,
-0.0384075791,
0.0460166149,
-0.0102444747,
-0.0184980184,
0.0172745939,
-0.0436585695,
-0.003579047,
-0.0100287599,
-0.0259712022,
-0.1090691537,
0.053421177,
0.0923800841,
0.0067687999,
0.0508549139,
-0.0153190941,
-0.0308838375,
0.1024184301,
-0.0431544483,
0.0601834804,
-0.0565514453,
0.045977246,
-0.0116405431,
-0.0118045323,
0.025068121,
0.0323389284,
0.0365280956,
-0.0206525568,
0.0219819583,
0.0065735108,
0.0474259518,
-0.0294782054,
-0.0437891856,
0.0143777793,
0.0692403689,
-0.0362907909,
-0.0140334563,
0.0068791318,
-0.0121722305,
-0.0195779372,
0.0308208782,
-0.0155755589,
0.0253774561,
-0.0143204704,
0.0037150395,
0.0237401109,
0.0158545468,
0.0343353823,
-0.0327632427,
-0.0251041278,
-0.0126406625,
0.0113893012,
0.005005559,
0.0000140681,
0.0122250887,
-0.0573771074,
-0.0523218997,
-0.0122099947,
0.0046252701,
-0.0287912041,
0.0064563286,
-0.0087312693,
-0.0255998056,
0.0564676709,
-0.0103087239,
0.0201835148,
0.0140470676,
-0.0602960214,
0.0298884828,
-0.0367969051,
0.0288970768,
-0.0491873547,
0.0287073422,
0.0082280934,
-0.0122797163,
-0.0716091245,
-0.0092100315,
-0.02543143,
0.0224906281,
0.0307261609,
-0.0056376546,
-0.0712095648,
-0.0179211795,
0.0037275758,
-0.0097785927,
0.045944307,
0.0303058885,
-0.0299362037,
0.0043577519,
-0.0179752652,
0.0288860612,
0.0326358899,
-0.0112606958,
-0.0208658278,
-0.0887611061,
0.0439873412,
-0.009536027,
0.0013491086,
-0.0171258338,
0.0466626324,
0.0639765859,
0.030451607,
-0.055865027,
-0.0024838913,
-0.0165729597,
-0.041317936,
-0.0363821313,
0.0081080338,
-0.0577836968,
0.0263078474,
0.0206737183,
0.0169119611,
-0.0441659801,
-0.0134165492,
-0.0174062587,
-0.0176092722,
0.0709361956,
-0.0310334582,
-0.0246041641,
0.0218219701,
0.0265928265,
-0.0311493985,
0.0306256078,
0.0154673858,
-0.0359770693,
0.0045808218,
-0.0529384762,
0.0401416868,
0.0004721221,
-0.0053023309,
-0.0510366634,
0.0297388751,
-0.0096744997,
0.0209234171,
0.0688717738,
0.0271818843,
0.0437679179,
0.0127641791,
-0.0214773789,
0.0367403105,
0.0728489012,
0.0646975636,
0.0659738556,
0.0386388004,
0.0019601879,
-0.0175675321,
-0.0326173753,
0.0131242508,
0.0135772387,
-0.0015702704,
0.0217119996,
-0.0240612403,
0.0416183136,
-0.0159615129,
-0.0198530871,
-0.0333670713,
0.0046104803,
-0.071317032,
-0.0048468402,
0.0316281021,
-0.0155873662,
-0.0141241876,
0.0419674367,
0.0428269431,
0.011717529,
-0.0140200229,
-0.0745606497,
-0.0302825011,
0.0165089257,
0.0383019969,
-0.0405947603,
-0.0400967114,
-0.0289521459,
-0.0463965051,
0.0068536093,
0.0352856964,
0.0048967153,
-0.0184075795,
-0.011565567,
0.0155901583,
0.0156719293,
0.0271201897,
0.0056630592,
0.0018578828,
0.0385930724,
-0.0194311161,
-0.0495827049,
0.0056539061,
0.0277836248,
-0.0515604205,
-0.0521734767,
0.0203833207,
-0.0218432024,
0.0349025764,
0.0050659678,
-0.0345226489,
0.0006913322,
-0.0084649911,
-0.0155833689,
-0.0647135228,
0.0111749033,
-0.049880825,
-0.0293012708,
0.0082202675,
-0.0481925122,
-0.0281029753,
0.0038446337,
-0.0374829359,
-0.0145198163,
-0.046353735,
-0.0190696009,
0.0213296898,
-0.030176688,
0.0289230626,
0.0213021077,
0.0147712575,
-0.0318711959,
0.0419520587,
0.0012671427,
-0.0107949525,
-0.0035656877,
-0.0713616982,
0.0094515262,
-0.0209145024,
-0.0344180912,
0.017216878,
-0.0002166276,
0.0013694284,
-0.0297758933,
0.0032039094,
0.0045831557,
-0.0062675094,
-0.0705025345,
0.0458148494,
0.0255667418,
0.009540543,
0.0176515952,
0.0179877467,
0.0009749389,
-0.0008577785,
-0.0384384468,
0.0074948859,
0.0391198881,
0.0100130346,
0.0541317239,
0.0200578757,
0.0171762928,
-0.0378157198,
0.0019692448,
-0.0506937392,
0.0439659171,
0.0173836146,
-0.0076360842,
0.0069333566,
0.0492960699,
-0.0375712402,
0.0336062312,
0.0126460446,
-0.0155694773,
0.0146126291,
-0.0114271156,
0.0282179881,
0.037939474,
-0.0085609192,
0.0536022969,
0.0384180546,
0.0452187881,
-0.0127515504,
0.0016340842,
-0.0387947746,
-0.0499349833,
0.0082665598,
-0.0180067644,
0.016850777,
0.0923217162,
0.006749602,
-0.0157232229,
-0.057130456,
-0.0057585775,
-0.0152144693,
0.0302504785,
-0.0065870686,
0.0391263776,
-0.031048853,
0.0190935638,
0.0096793594,
-0.0207618289,
0.0860994682,
-0.0255934615,
0.0261107311,
-0.0368841402,
-0.0034809222,
-0.0343580544,
0.0339138061,
0.015461727,
0.0113810198,
0.0459063984,
-0.028916901,
-0.016695261,
0.0199862812,
0.0021503833,
-0.0524634346,
0.0563746504,
-0.0167192332,
0.0316050239,
-0.0143135302,
-0.0303173214,
-0.0254670698,
0.0135998903,
-0.0216105059,
0.0265081115,
0.0350448787,
-0.0257992856,
-0.0565296113,
0.042821385,
-0.0130364895,
0.0914976075,
0.0310278591,
-0.0297936425,
-0.0192455258,
0.0320512876,
0.0304665528,
-0.0213711951,
0.0105852317,
-0.0089040091,
0.0298896935,
0.039844729,
-0.0770111084,
0.0416096635,
-0.023422258,
0.0073637152,
0.012822248,
-0.0754484162,
-0.0492214188,
0.010699369,
0.0290072504,
-0.0496465936,
-0.0032345483,
0.1212438941,
0.021399837,
-0.0866698176,
0.0154585307,
0.0241124034,
-0.0261749104,
-0.0251285359,
0.0247304607,
-0.1122635752,
-0.0374354906,
-0.0109604048,
-0.0132136149,
-0.0301745348,
-0.062256813,
0.0165371001,
-0.0395043753,
0.052828379,
-0.0114821512,
-0.0424843431,
-0.0136603657,
-0.0391624868,
0.0208866019,
-0.0410265885,
-0.0034808267,
-0.0484482162,
-0.0215301272,
-0.0002720784,
-0.002717837,
-0.0794539824,
-0.0863394588,
0.0743202865,
-0.0273650009,
0.045994252,
0.0536558479,
0.0050009312,
-0.0123167746,
-0.0134053277,
0.0001526639,
0.0096046217,
0.0127386553,
-0.0045389552,
0.0830141082,
-0.0105384616,
-0.0091735665,
-0.0500460714,
0.0136078205,
-0.0254856311,
-0.0182655398,
-0.0512824506,
0.0973629579,
-0.0244693048,
-0.0702559873,
-0.0430819243,
-0.0111089312,
-0.0039806599,
0.0671430603,
-0.0130978171,
-0.0042692954,
-0.0336747468,
0.0185712334,
0.0580932759,
0.0087401923,
-0.044922445,
0.0547756664,
-0.0190730803,
-0.0597039238,
-0.0415547006,
-0.0107176881,
0.0477344543,
-0.0303154979,
-0.0076199472,
-0.0165360272,
0.0008293226,
0.0096215392,
-0.0532841012,
0.0933709145,
0.0009709221,
-0.0258279908,
-0.0769706592,
-0.0428725891,
0.1177376807,
0.0031883467,
-0.0242049862,
0.0061815716,
-0.0364784785,
-0.0142285312,
-0.0143511035,
-0.0013032702,
0.023242319,
-0.0155678792,
0.0044770292,
-0.0243268721,
0.0797039866,
0.0546657331,
-0.0173528399,
-0.0479681082,
-0.0173848178,
-0.0405101739,
-0.0230342112,
0.0105855707,
-0.0041380264,
0.0506597124,
0.0037646589,
0.0035224282,
-0.0025985464,
-0.0245485399,
0.0253584906,
0.0176285189,
0.0624582022,
-0.0371589512,
-0.0208457857,
-0.0269331746,
-0.0326358266,
0.0115806144,
0.0477834232,
-0.0268338565,
-0.0194553081,
0.0610031933,
0.0179445911,
-0.0479965843,
0.0233403072,
-0.0486279838,
-0.0027546745,
-0.0767543092,
0.0464726388,
0.0295082722,
-0.0079158973,
0.0471552163,
-0.024920091,
-0.0100982143,
0.0019576109,
-0.0145319272,
0.0043336782,
-0.0274860468,
0.0467376113,
0.0065345545,
0.0655679777,
-0.0136329485,
0.0426133834,
-0.0275296438,
-0.0434334539,
-0.0573185273,
0.0202818606,
0.0631189719,
-0.0068652947,
0.0197669268,
-0.0226231404,
-0.0170940235,
-0.0254854932,
0.0281898566,
-0.0337222144,
0.0144983279,
0.0325134359,
0.0104080504,
-0.0157219879,
-0.0540634766,
0.0753090829,
0.0270652566,
0.0606144145,
0.0113138482,
-0.0329994261,
-0.0249725841,
0.0009206276,
0.0236351509,
-0.0457840897,
-0.0433889143,
0.0019660096,
-0.0448984988,
-0.0542715155,
0.0553461388,
-0.0110940076,
-0.0423085243,
0.0264991932,
0.0244172253,
0.0397830606,
0.010718598,
-0.0697856396,
-0.0047475118,
0.0055556921,
-0.0235496741,
-0.015226922,
-0.0057536303,
-6.282711677e-33,
-0.0169425942,
-0.0072583384,
0.0179913901,
-0.0214555096,
-0.0176615454,
0.0173105132,
-0.019717345,
-0.0142613845,
0.0006389027,
0.0418400094,
-0.0337436832,
-0.0141028985,
-0.0016385942,
0.0297856499,
-0.008788038,
-0.0324373245,
0.0566967689,
0.0078109903,
-0.0055588139,
0.0433810987,
-0.0216743127,
0.0285186917,
0.0624078065,
-0.0308627002,
-0.0227548927,
0.0272638816,
0.0426158011,
-0.006686585,
0.0106983976,
0.0482185744,
-0.0388994962,
0.0319542438,
0.0445157886,
-0.0436009616,
0.002023896,
-0.0102403723,
-0.0698522404,
0.0032690917,
-0.0215429105,
0.0060666823,
0.003606081,
-0.0293440856,
0.0430759527,
-0.0191748049,
-0.0082170693,
-0.0552238971,
0.035176266,
-0.0123171853,
-0.0060842582,
-0.0742867067,
-0.0434773229,
0.0450380705,
0.0115113221,
0.0177893601,
0.0153444437,
-0.0370845124,
-0.0143285235,
0.0271559469,
-0.0334202088,
0.0022854416,
0.0584395416,
0.0028430338,
0.0150951827,
-0.0107386187,
0.0077072661,
0.0504571833,
0.0000631059,
-0.0186077189,
-0.0155489864,
0.023034038,
-0.0015915567,
0.0543330275,
0.0158788767,
0.0280072019,
0.0435413532,
0.0020077699,
-0.0610257685,
0.0459247418,
-0.0393081643,
0.0103773214,
0.0236497577,
-0.0124604534,
-0.0088301282,
0.0105304578,
-0.0411406308,
0.0115695782,
-0.0102893384,
-0.03184646,
0.027721988,
-0.0362700969,
0.0056176954,
0.0195303764,
0.0500287488,
-0.0387978144,
-0.0292578023,
-0.0308000669,
0.0243928544,
0.0389854945,
-0.0468910821,
0.0345457494,
-0.0284184664,
-0.0509210974,
0.0499496274,
-0.004852843,
0.0438722782,
0.0250469167,
0.0292666275,
-0.0213424917,
-0.0570909418,
-0.0054967403,
0.0229114257,
-0.0017840433,
-0.0068530422,
0.0662945211,
0.0133306859,
0.0166110266,
0.0020850848,
0.0489155576,
0.018572554,
0.0178452004,
-0.0217942446,
0.0302258898,
-0.0056500058,
0.0037718122,
-0.0316237845,
0.0148796523,
-0.0375191234,
0.0027808268,
0.0437116697,
-0.0549722463,
-0.007989171,
-0.0115556149,
3.027e-7,
0.0955581143,
0.0552651249,
-0.0025296111,
-0.0084243286,
0.0248223431,
-0.0038586047,
0.0349118523,
0.0206467696,
0.0134245008,
-0.004375679,
0.0601637773,
0.045741532,
0.0082112476,
0.0349293426,
-0.0624154396,
-0.0210344847,
-0.0627570823,
0.008940191,
-0.0316213779,
0.0099760592,
0.0352536924,
0.0996276066,
-0.0450888798,
-0.0207431484,
0.0694237575,
0.01809627,
0.0556889512,
-0.0490329489,
0.012217747,
0.0803133175,
0.0235091671,
0.0415923111,
0.0326828845,
0.0382972993,
0.0034017283,
-0.0202990621,
-0.0093301507,
0.0653891414,
-0.0418012068,
-0.0009507029,
0.0100950962,
0.0125256293,
0.0432253219,
-0.06798926,
0.0573819987,
-0.1079352722,
-0.0551996715,
-0.0276233573,
-0.0459831469,
-0.0335957184,
0.0347504541,
-0.0351689234,
-0.0048521031,
0.048443269,
0.0358325876,
0.0266828276,
-0.0303294659,
-0.0548582375,
0.0133694438,
0.0648968518,
-0.0570742972,
-0.024236016,
0.0039571058,
-0.064475283,
0.03232136,
-0.0595067404,
0.0070317127,
3.015087449e-34,
0.0193772558,
0.0393837206,
0.0162681937,
-0.0165336989,
0.0097829737,
0.004594828,
0.0419674926,
-0.0150335571,
-0.0177139379,
-0.0815717354,
-0.0006342143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17167v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.17167v3 | DyVal: Dynamic Evaluation of Large Language Models for Reasoning Tasks | 2023-09-29T12:04:14 | 2024-03-14T09:52:16 | Kaijie Zhu, Jiaao Chen, Jindong Wang, Neil Zhenqiang Gong, Diyi Yang, Xing Xie | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable performance in various
evaluation benchmarks. However, concerns are raised about potential data
contamination in their considerable volume of training corpus. Moreover, the
static nature and fixed complexity of current benchmarks may inadequately gauge
the advancing capabilities of LLMs. In this paper, we introduce DyVal, a
general and flexible protocol for dynamic evaluation of LLMs. Based on our
framework, we build graph-informed DyVal by leveraging the structural advantage
of directed acyclic graphs to dynamically generate evaluation samples with
controllable complexities. DyVal generates challenging evaluation sets on
reasoning tasks including mathematics, logical reasoning, and algorithm
problems. We evaluate various LLMs ranging from Flan-T5-large to GPT-3.5-Turbo
and GPT-4. Experiments show that LLMs perform worse in DyVal-generated
evaluation samples with different complexities, highlighting the significance
of dynamic evaluation. We also analyze the failure cases and results of
different prompting methods. Moreover, DyVal-generated samples are not only
evaluation sets, but also helpful data for fine-tuning to improve the
performance of LLMs on existing benchmarks. We hope that DyVal can shed light
on future evaluation research of LLMs. Code is available at:
https://github.com/microsoft/promptbench. | [
0.0108891558,
0.0257693529,
-0.0083300769,
0.0345719904,
-0.0727349445,
0.0174258184,
0.0206707828,
-0.0187532566,
0.0212627891,
-0.0247230064,
-0.0140884928,
-0.0358618498,
0.0135792755,
0.0405149944,
0.0112969307,
-0.031677939,
0.0429458022,
-0.0890136287,
0.0187197067,
-0.0251864512,
-0.0167855788,
-0.0111261345,
-0.0211031567,
0.019770924,
0.0190522615,
-0.0444450192,
-0.0126294922,
-0.0179452598,
0.0110855699,
-0.0344232321,
-0.0390733741,
0.0543938652,
0.0129420543,
0.0440831371,
0.000002271,
-0.0374239534,
-0.0058080363,
0.001953382,
-0.0645182207,
0.0260298811,
0.0349362083,
0.0269756708,
0.0115943309,
0.0203453768,
-0.0336943045,
-0.0551348515,
0.0126398215,
-0.0018376912,
0.0774840191,
0.0656238124,
0.0110277971,
-0.0046951585,
0.0139965257,
-0.0225331206,
-0.0219094586,
-0.0453486182,
0.0121756727,
0.0416784063,
0.0618976764,
-0.0179486629,
-0.0175083354,
0.0183829051,
0.05456651,
-0.0109905954,
-0.0149238128,
0.0359479897,
-0.0615063235,
-0.0080431402,
-0.0051375772,
0.1001761705,
-0.0123929502,
-0.0142732356,
-0.0279976465,
-0.0098734694,
-0.0172265545,
0.0262710787,
-0.0504681244,
0.0291950889,
-0.0033250893,
0.0067433673,
0.0253725741,
-0.0145489881,
0.0494662747,
0.0049769222,
-0.0385861322,
0.1288008988,
0.0226292703,
-0.0218624175,
0.0328654349,
-0.015540068,
-0.0519249216,
-0.0716966838,
-0.0082645966,
0.0405331962,
-0.061526522,
0.0120719289,
-0.0233877692,
0.009113661,
0.0208985303,
-0.0126825813,
0.0706188977,
0.0337424949,
-0.0140297357,
0.0542987697,
-0.0346823931,
0.1056028157,
-0.0134071913,
0.0548945852,
-0.031266287,
0.0069510737,
-0.0418146588,
0.017309105,
-0.0348114073,
0.0385048464,
0.0000363078,
-0.0176251978,
-0.0444056988,
0.0406513363,
-0.0213261228,
0.0413928106,
-0.0069131223,
-0.0387995727,
0.0252422877,
-0.0140861301,
-0.0267617591,
0.0024016683,
-0.0449016169,
0.0174931046,
0.0130034583,
-0.0471339673,
-0.0024701892,
0.0078621777,
0.0044626906,
-0.0409591496,
0.0368887,
0.0865975991,
0.0348479003,
-0.0450483486,
-0.0113594867,
-0.0157224145,
-0.0019107617,
-0.0962744355,
-0.0027884815,
-0.0836398527,
0.0033264284,
0.0108634187,
-0.0152335623,
0.0060243416,
0.0054066158,
0.019482974,
0.0036227284,
0.0700471327,
0.0363181122,
0.033404205,
-0.0154350316,
-0.0187057611,
-0.0442156158,
0.0532239787,
0.0320157669,
0.024716638,
0.0396578982,
-0.0035959897,
-0.0087064495,
0.0363780856,
0.0107374834,
0.025075119,
-0.0308491495,
0.0368041322,
-0.0079898946,
0.0225436818,
-0.0389388762,
0.0771267638,
-0.0300633162,
-0.0220490284,
0.036400307,
0.0331369415,
0.0108444886,
-0.027649425,
0.050619904,
-0.0190244615,
0.0128755905,
0.0035458233,
-0.08982113,
-0.0038570329,
-0.038497787,
0.0343454182,
0.0003265932,
0.0110274777,
-0.0164317843,
-0.0401543453,
-0.020418385,
0.0046198056,
0.0342894532,
0.0386778153,
0.0606216975,
-0.005527385,
-0.0247826353,
0.0065353476,
0.0171706118,
-0.0383714885,
-0.0348034091,
-0.0574258715,
0.0289677642,
0.0528833047,
0.0594940893,
-0.0082005989,
-0.0431899913,
0.0015809672,
-0.0146787688,
0.0222532712,
0.0325059928,
-0.0110254064,
-0.0025048137,
-0.0498498417,
-0.0296705719,
-0.0164993536,
0.0046934909,
0.0238728225,
0.0360281281,
-0.0007065511,
0.0028111283,
-0.078125298,
-0.0348230824,
0.0149498926,
0.0020412342,
-0.0144011863,
-0.0064717438,
0.008262624,
0.020344479,
0.0214555115,
-0.0206194725,
0.0370922089,
0.0337302499,
-0.0239897873,
-0.006139603,
-0.0130448388,
-0.0627878904,
-0.0495001227,
0.0565798394,
-0.0214941893,
-0.0381771885,
0.0261723269,
-0.0582035296,
-0.0631967932,
0.0347318947,
-0.0243217796,
-0.01214357,
-0.0234783199,
0.0262814816,
-0.0055135009,
0.0129262619,
-0.0005817619,
0.0825343281,
-0.0118263429,
0.0433200337,
0.0205190275,
0.072842136,
0.0153686376,
-0.0746069103,
-0.0325620398,
0.033865042,
-0.0008076815,
-0.0100151096,
0.0095124207,
0.0181226414,
-0.0442747213,
-0.0113931717,
-0.0566926859,
0.0159145687,
-0.0358924977,
0.0336429216,
0.004072858,
0.0028817656,
-0.0081145158,
0.0154846059,
-0.0637374446,
0.0083853053,
0.0253445599,
0.0377544612,
0.0214664452,
-0.0018422566,
-0.0583278015,
-0.0105223041,
-0.0547973439,
-0.0278335828,
0.0689294562,
0.0133395111,
0.0186866075,
-0.0060172016,
0.0218038987,
-0.0279409196,
0.0192584042,
-0.0164502896,
-0.0101932567,
0.0243097227,
-0.0207291488,
0.0592006445,
0.0780690759,
-0.0243763085,
-0.0070832334,
0.0436157919,
-0.0160710812,
-0.0510946065,
0.0072594555,
-0.0093596177,
-0.0129058994,
-0.0188475084,
-0.0324612595,
-0.0328575075,
0.0450490378,
-0.0116170933,
-0.0171778519,
-0.0536401272,
-0.0162667297,
-0.0266480539,
0.0235443357,
-0.0319646262,
-0.0197204184,
-0.0041880356,
0.0326893367,
-0.0315670185,
-0.054340519,
0.0951290056,
-0.0366703644,
-0.0011994325,
-0.0323902965,
-0.0220147073,
-0.0629649684,
0.0752737001,
0.0207399037,
-0.0046425853,
0.0107439598,
-0.0243046451,
-0.0397731178,
-0.0210619681,
0.0314676128,
-0.0543813221,
0.0737230629,
-0.0366194807,
0.0327909403,
-0.0009596646,
-0.0368596166,
-0.0395002775,
0.0130334739,
-0.0396631919,
0.0610353574,
-0.0175502002,
-0.0325641595,
-0.0127565488,
0.002193898,
-0.0068669119,
0.0389334485,
-0.0132013848,
0.0239574648,
-0.0232182201,
0.0154465009,
0.0246111434,
0.0000364974,
0.0289510638,
-0.0451973379,
0.0465873964,
0.021474082,
0.0884722024,
-0.0092226742,
-0.0298663322,
0.0418388955,
0.0006134341,
-0.0234452412,
-0.0130272619,
0.0140781347,
0.0258684307,
-0.0675057471,
-0.0229980703,
0.1152581498,
0.0265618395,
-0.0361128971,
0.013544769,
-0.0070729759,
0.0512705147,
0.0299275685,
0.0054420591,
-0.1200732812,
-0.0392132923,
0.0136113102,
0.0275692772,
-0.0158559438,
-0.0417026617,
0.0137372268,
-0.1565879434,
0.0128667001,
0.0056921537,
0.0034860261,
-0.011202273,
-0.0446844287,
-0.0105594974,
-0.0097044138,
0.0068814396,
0.0299442671,
0.0078100646,
0.003429675,
0.0030370795,
-0.0117685422,
-0.0356569476,
0.0962410942,
-0.0092503382,
0.0401407741,
0.0362127312,
0.0053137694,
-0.0109132612,
-0.0498776771,
0.066352427,
0.0024802501,
-0.0292553771,
-0.0109709054,
0.0017386067,
0.0157663822,
-0.0017673448,
-0.0012094998,
0.0349129997,
-0.0337078162,
-0.0153149944,
0.0126321753,
0.0988727957,
-0.0016096889,
-0.0144050494,
0.0023701964,
0.0007025609,
-0.0170924868,
0.0646158531,
0.0413223989,
-0.0034339007,
-0.0732834712,
-0.0410040952,
-0.0335765518,
-0.0339442082,
-0.015726909,
0.0535094664,
0.0145364143,
-0.0006980469,
-0.0401996337,
-0.0137568265,
0.0361944884,
0.0388871804,
-0.0249740575,
-0.0164165907,
-0.0097075142,
0.0026547194,
-0.0390431955,
0.0398012176,
-0.0190818794,
0.0655184835,
-0.0712790936,
0.01133704,
0.0010690975,
0.0023111275,
-0.0307784602,
0.0520758703,
-0.0886589214,
-0.0912563056,
0.0095924484,
0.0073740697,
0.0333194956,
0.0469777472,
-0.0374128409,
-0.0227997992,
0.0371111371,
-0.0186233167,
-0.0088445591,
-0.0072718556,
0.0227621663,
-0.0069963001,
0.0171651766,
0.0422195345,
-0.0409514904,
0.0242372788,
0.0142433411,
0.0607543327,
0.0069461297,
-0.0172153208,
0.0232115779,
0.0917218477,
0.0040461286,
0.00578376,
-0.0136938486,
-0.015471451,
0.0213378351,
-0.0281024799,
-0.0328068808,
-0.0469509214,
0.0310440194,
0.0179282185,
-0.0417377762,
0.0011519465,
-0.0518892184,
-0.0000267203,
0.0418867841,
-0.0117638921,
0.0353610106,
0.0220244378,
0.0014956255,
0.0545511842,
-0.0421547517,
-0.0253352765,
0.0093070501,
-0.0135992058,
0.0583420545,
-0.0154215526,
0.0593646914,
0.0263470747,
-0.0069974591,
-0.0352029204,
0.0070871413,
-0.0696766824,
-0.0501381159,
0.007778849,
0.0546244048,
0.0239482317,
0.0258573461,
0.0058159432,
-0.0520250238,
0.0103902975,
-0.0222655293,
0.0148319248,
0.0206417441,
-0.0572070889,
0.0541328602,
0.0482663848,
0.0117321499,
0.0006498757,
0.0548557155,
-0.0036443479,
0.0359357782,
0.011718371,
0.0169541333,
-0.0616965815,
-0.0350636393,
-0.046128694,
0.0015752453,
-0.0176410098,
0.0323559828,
-0.0648622289,
-0.1076065004,
0.0112383561,
0.0444839709,
0.0279899742,
-0.0139547512,
0.022194026,
0.0490448326,
0.0209579486,
-0.0327422805,
-0.0314722471,
0.0245649908,
-0.00293261,
-0.0232560486,
-0.0213034973,
-6.797773628e-33,
-0.0165884513,
-0.0270910002,
0.0315344036,
-0.0178488418,
-0.0304542519,
0.0002015214,
-0.0326694809,
0.0050953142,
-0.0322565585,
0.0116933119,
-0.0105846738,
0.0316079631,
0.0126359463,
0.0197712705,
-0.0230668187,
-0.0226871148,
-0.0108658662,
-0.0048419586,
-0.053194128,
0.0306771453,
0.0307700709,
-0.0185729377,
0.0235890485,
-0.0339399204,
0.0175585914,
-0.0116435736,
-0.0041484977,
0.0381916016,
-0.0506678373,
0.0625586063,
-0.00207248,
0.0349916145,
0.0157201495,
-0.0290392134,
-0.0025835531,
0.0205252208,
-0.0609593913,
-0.0332263634,
0.0283748247,
0.0019730739,
-0.0451737009,
-0.0269473307,
0.0204267167,
0.0038152677,
-0.0115316464,
-0.0307816025,
-0.0081242369,
-0.0255628917,
-0.0290651675,
0.0056362459,
0.0079115927,
0.058748994,
-0.0196868107,
-0.0066320729,
0.0062393253,
0.0342114531,
-0.0250071716,
0.0122628482,
-0.0093499981,
0.0308003258,
0.0374484435,
0.0112389475,
0.0455159917,
0.0185624603,
0.0133329174,
0.0249670949,
0.0133376019,
-0.0086923623,
0.0059063509,
0.0177228302,
0.0248317681,
0.083804369,
0.0322843678,
0.0132266842,
0.0200037956,
0.0192955714,
-0.0900496617,
-0.0116134221,
0.0457830876,
0.0462340526,
0.0221172068,
-0.0180271715,
-0.0521063879,
-0.0238445643,
-0.0676249713,
0.0083286641,
-0.0590221807,
-0.0089821722,
0.0348964147,
-0.0222935323,
-0.01994933,
-0.0252998844,
0.0107958717,
-0.0490870625,
-0.021421032,
0.0489806533,
-0.018727107,
0.036331784,
-0.0093069477,
0.0590002611,
-0.0232973099,
-0.0250118803,
-0.0120970411,
0.014145026,
0.0130363181,
-0.0073294621,
0.0103926938,
0.0441459194,
-0.0604009368,
-0.0198026635,
-0.0435317419,
0.0174222961,
-0.0045025512,
0.0162508152,
0.0606916659,
0.0121134482,
-0.0062439535,
0.044366274,
-0.0030826966,
-0.000045728,
-0.0214282498,
0.0207803492,
0.0136052109,
0.0499497429,
-0.0256319717,
0.0052444837,
-0.0342006646,
0.004509504,
0.0280198287,
-0.0335804559,
0.0088314358,
0.0299237482,
2.998e-7,
0.0324994512,
0.041646976,
0.0351132341,
0.0669337809,
-0.0017131448,
0.0284118913,
-0.0549865365,
-0.0106779356,
0.0230728053,
-0.0198792256,
-0.0096933618,
0.040694233,
0.0414038338,
0.043376144,
-0.0395503081,
0.0322150961,
-0.0672483966,
-0.0155592198,
-0.0381217413,
0.0130618447,
0.0546921603,
0.0850353166,
-0.0013182408,
-0.0147105483,
-0.0046108169,
-0.0784380957,
0.035063155,
0.000939475,
-0.0102229137,
-0.0019878172,
0.0205854122,
-0.0079535721,
0.0211192705,
0.0431137532,
0.0123277055,
0.0323171318,
-0.0110987546,
0.06335444,
0.0192797221,
-0.0196250156,
-0.0097881677,
-0.0687794834,
-0.001526185,
-0.0522600822,
0.0951353684,
-0.0454887114,
-0.0537083633,
-0.0258031487,
-0.0379949436,
-0.0400468037,
0.0238501783,
-0.0081343027,
-0.0136641786,
0.0408215746,
0.011788195,
-0.0419715494,
0.0213590525,
-0.0694048703,
-0.0342687517,
0.0100920638,
-0.0405764058,
-0.051348675,
-0.0412600301,
-0.0050003668,
0.0047208495,
-0.0372399613,
-0.0096223895,
3.180335093e-34,
0.0683807954,
-0.0188530739,
0.0106814988,
0.0164090879,
0.0338325724,
-0.0263267402,
-0.027949784,
0.0138988746,
0.0215093251,
-0.11260809,
-0.0265514087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17157v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.17157v5 | LatticeGen: A Cooperative Framework which Hides Generated Text in a Lattice for Privacy-Aware Generation on Cloud | 2023-09-29T11:46:07 | 2024-04-05T16:18:14 | Mengke Zhang, Tianxing He, Tianle Wang, Lu Mi, Fatemehsadat Mireshghallah, Binyi Chen, Hao Wang, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the current user-server interaction paradigm of prompted generation with
large language models (LLM) on cloud, the server fully controls the generation
process, which leaves zero options for users who want to keep the generated
text to themselves. We propose LatticeGen, a cooperative framework in which the
server still handles most of the computation while the user controls the
sampling operation. The key idea is that the true generated sequence is mixed
with noise tokens by the user and hidden in a noised lattice. Considering
potential attacks from a hypothetically malicious server and how the user can
defend against it, we propose the repeated beam-search attack and the mixing
noise scheme. In our experiments we apply LatticeGen to protect both prompt and
generation. It is shown that while the noised lattice degrades generation
quality, LatticeGen successfully protects the true generation to a remarkable
degree under strong attacks (more than 50% of the semantic remains hidden as
measured by BERTScore). | [
0.0258601476,
0.0694825947,
-0.0221577715,
0.0576242283,
-0.0538006574,
-0.0205003265,
0.0609002225,
0.0052045505,
-0.0074480311,
0.0041263737,
0.0178400613,
-0.0402272418,
-0.0022571131,
-0.0087438449,
0.0330941714,
-0.0001934933,
0.0179670881,
-0.004513165,
-0.0153357815,
-0.0636497959,
-0.0360218398,
-0.0080595231,
0.0152429175,
0.0073842839,
0.0215290878,
-0.0203466732,
-0.0347351991,
0.0253291763,
-0.0026941588,
-0.0165461302,
-0.0502353013,
0.0268797781,
-0.0280240774,
0.0838218704,
0.0000021265,
-0.0358001776,
-0.0373108536,
0.0292885154,
-0.0637286007,
0.0324103013,
0.0158458967,
0.0182588566,
-0.0472871549,
0.0196652152,
-0.0134167662,
0.0381125845,
0.043222066,
0.0150719555,
0.0785035267,
0.0560657978,
0.0114385597,
0.0060829017,
-0.011232907,
-0.0052097454,
0.0321670584,
-0.0361741371,
-0.0199908875,
-0.0892952085,
0.004079714,
0.0422584713,
0.0099305855,
0.025237307,
0.0171954148,
-0.0261738412,
-0.0242999736,
0.0531477816,
-0.034869045,
-0.0467257276,
-0.0401444994,
0.0138962232,
0.0178213026,
-0.0002388813,
0.0442902632,
0.0038599619,
0.0154634127,
0.0488427505,
0.0050013261,
0.048838757,
-0.0344203934,
-0.0116191832,
-0.0016994515,
-0.0269021355,
0.0374120772,
-0.0040718201,
0.0493070036,
0.0590179674,
0.0530045778,
-0.0149201816,
-0.0766395181,
-0.0375084989,
-0.0064458326,
-0.0670322701,
0.0300414767,
0.0327301137,
-0.0054821586,
0.0127116004,
-0.0766063333,
-0.0613256618,
0.0287768617,
-0.0016182541,
-0.0006050842,
-0.000654353,
0.0357339494,
-0.0073131938,
-0.0230081789,
-0.0036534024,
-0.0036365876,
-0.0021785428,
0.0431003273,
0.0167790223,
0.0256551802,
0.0090312073,
-0.0251944512,
0.052394785,
-0.0555532724,
-0.0161763951,
-0.0377736166,
0.0574076176,
0.0096462937,
0.0537393987,
-0.0221395418,
0.0030183068,
-0.0147900404,
0.0368949845,
0.0417218432,
-0.0723324642,
-0.0185898095,
-0.0461806357,
0.02044742,
-0.1169392467,
-0.0251534879,
-0.0026292994,
-0.025199594,
0.0262529571,
-0.031388469,
0.0701965541,
0.0010869454,
-0.0144212283,
0.0432764925,
-0.1172402203,
-0.0109754922,
-0.0132793933,
-0.0298453476,
-0.0806262866,
-0.013797692,
0.0031882497,
-0.0247821882,
-0.018908143,
0.0192971081,
0.017071221,
-0.0034567062,
0.0126778111,
-0.0344198011,
-0.0252627041,
-0.0014151235,
0.0491730608,
0.0080232741,
-0.008523454,
0.0151118282,
0.026408134,
0.0321685225,
0.0137947705,
0.0695711523,
0.0087087946,
0.0409852937,
0.0404646769,
-0.0034094376,
-0.0056872461,
0.0494266264,
0.0028251929,
-0.0201935023,
0.0589626245,
-0.0076217302,
-0.0368136093,
0.0643132105,
0.0465802401,
0.0083884308,
0.0451771989,
0.0007273232,
0.0620803796,
-0.0202942528,
0.0296186302,
-0.0073979022,
0.0110093122,
-0.0880788639,
-0.0243069753,
0.0343437791,
-0.0010854879,
0.0044174078,
0.0316850357,
0.0198040679,
-0.0410826579,
-0.0212877747,
0.0048825098,
-0.0130632045,
0.0599140078,
0.0015548224,
0.0404173434,
0.0125300027,
-0.0726518333,
0.0016477554,
-0.0467878692,
0.0445140041,
0.0582385808,
0.074363701,
0.0495207608,
0.0107338484,
0.0033089186,
-0.0485909097,
0.0426016375,
-0.0037212444,
0.0324696116,
0.0337450728,
-0.0267646462,
-0.0291707776,
0.032423012,
0.0001486985,
-0.0027079757,
-0.0017475551,
-0.0205123331,
0.01932019,
0.0065383716,
0.0080592148,
0.0047759237,
-0.00331372,
-0.0265991036,
0.0212332122,
0.0030936177,
0.0529622547,
0.0201933868,
-0.0167408232,
0.0374139622,
0.0399533659,
0.0417861044,
-0.0138426516,
0.0031403205,
-0.0432669483,
-0.0542448796,
-0.0376649313,
0.027325416,
0.0200476963,
-0.01723749,
-0.0130577423,
-0.0042006122,
0.0485148355,
-0.0730661377,
0.017171381,
-0.0286528412,
0.011313742,
0.005250833,
0.0245294403,
-0.0132922614,
0.0205948129,
-0.026097551,
0.0200549364,
0.0024533509,
0.0616203845,
0.0089580631,
-0.0716385171,
-0.0186440013,
0.0041002305,
-0.0354287773,
0.0061484994,
0.0183792096,
0.0288704988,
-0.0039780443,
-0.0402519852,
-0.0370544866,
-0.003103968,
-0.0147043262,
0.0145840244,
0.0213420335,
0.0501409359,
-0.0273052286,
-0.0421703272,
-0.030524224,
-0.0114373043,
-0.0031142579,
0.0109071657,
0.0171869081,
0.010579831,
-0.0539963841,
0.0250745155,
-0.0011263444,
0.0117989248,
0.0396714509,
-0.0026914321,
0.0035325596,
-0.038391348,
0.0528311096,
-0.0615598671,
-0.0020838883,
0.0190267079,
-0.012190843,
0.0267004278,
-0.0276956409,
0.039326556,
0.0179327633,
0.0528883599,
-0.0104103619,
0.0045410693,
-0.0001709751,
-0.0431453027,
-0.0108161783,
-0.0252723936,
0.0067237816,
-0.0236311648,
-0.0117650712,
0.0471302122,
0.0167782847,
0.068388328,
-0.0242330283,
-0.0176807381,
0.0507566184,
0.0204959717,
-0.0165820364,
-0.0327913873,
-0.0141310534,
-0.0247834381,
0.0224155933,
0.0044432809,
-0.0509135425,
0.053508047,
-0.0423426963,
0.020091014,
-0.0332435146,
-0.0054012365,
0.0284948014,
0.013274584,
-0.0015528357,
0.0479609892,
-0.0165285282,
-0.0226653442,
-0.0198878776,
-0.0060771555,
0.0587575212,
-0.0404771008,
-0.0544310547,
-0.0105619626,
-0.0425816104,
0.0125277992,
-0.0222560223,
-0.0498504713,
-0.0488294102,
0.0265228506,
-0.0199113786,
0.0205441527,
-0.0233511422,
0.0345093235,
-0.0380883925,
0.0351400115,
0.0007970012,
-0.0016904715,
-0.0049895952,
-0.0411230288,
0.062487375,
-0.0126269441,
-0.0264589768,
0.0048329895,
-0.0025452285,
0.0078852726,
0.0915122479,
0.1075902283,
0.0114801787,
0.0371783674,
-0.0209306274,
0.0185665675,
-0.0023354215,
-0.0439173244,
0.0631916076,
0.0505571999,
-0.0039772657,
-0.0116107529,
0.0406288318,
0.0014267016,
0.00339679,
0.011406241,
0.011971904,
0.0288765021,
-0.00390502,
0.0083801635,
-0.0697153434,
0.0078055449,
0.0166512504,
0.0588693172,
-0.0364951566,
-0.0050182017,
-0.0396780111,
-0.0971348584,
0.0396764204,
-0.0113111222,
0.050469365,
0.0271217637,
-0.0426046327,
-0.000527416,
0.0867575258,
-0.0339740701,
-0.0095165055,
0.0301414523,
0.0142374225,
0.0132055683,
0.006020274,
-0.0254954807,
-0.0164103545,
-0.0466511287,
0.07697092,
0.0718708113,
0.0220032185,
-0.0065073417,
-0.0650402009,
0.0195629448,
0.0306759421,
-0.0122759473,
-0.0029833983,
-0.0177209787,
0.048933953,
-0.0363090709,
-0.0248078424,
0.0097424602,
0.0416392758,
-0.0096605932,
0.0087528471,
0.0071666394,
-0.019380495,
-0.0272303987,
0.0164847821,
0.028370684,
0.0665233508,
0.0430515558,
0.0050327866,
-0.0264073443,
-0.0305394623,
-0.057090126,
0.0335720554,
-0.0603812858,
0.0010979067,
-0.0147792241,
0.0093946662,
-0.0452848375,
-0.0837719366,
0.0055382443,
-0.0506078675,
0.0347147882,
0.0307094883,
0.0125435265,
0.0189727321,
0.0079861404,
-0.0149339177,
-0.0820785537,
-0.0693977401,
0.0239340607,
-0.0315553658,
-0.0032404361,
-0.0126097081,
-0.0577189922,
-0.0374625735,
0.0442692116,
-0.0648535043,
-0.0643721744,
0.041163303,
0.0632395893,
0.0205778331,
0.0264888573,
-0.0422498919,
-0.0415443145,
0.1410647184,
0.0635998845,
-0.0773107037,
0.0158460997,
0.0240831859,
-0.0255198926,
0.0087019838,
0.0104913739,
-0.0304075833,
-0.0184203982,
0.0577445105,
-0.000178674,
-0.0311596952,
-0.0569791794,
-0.0205319878,
0.0652038082,
-0.0001501408,
-0.0343424603,
0.047630433,
-0.0009428585,
0.0492708459,
-0.0213221814,
0.004994906,
-0.00542115,
-0.0142587246,
-0.041516155,
-0.0381014235,
0.0563240461,
0.0355900973,
0.0184420887,
0.0135680605,
-0.0078886552,
0.0311598536,
-0.0001813318,
0.0316864513,
0.0593884885,
-0.0040359898,
-0.0097115487,
0.0696775019,
0.0385879315,
0.0170075633,
-0.0104971211,
0.0068007647,
0.0052233352,
-0.0073871147,
0.0425103903,
0.0400082134,
-0.0633626729,
-0.072620444,
0.0062718093,
0.0191614721,
-0.0251501128,
0.0801643133,
-0.0004015338,
-0.035693381,
0.0085030412,
-0.0420191884,
0.0076565351,
-0.0011372687,
-0.0846712515,
-0.0248618554,
-0.0215924531,
0.0015005422,
0.0261934064,
0.0643671453,
-0.0208872538,
0.0456945933,
-0.0138056651,
-0.0099874754,
-0.0751129538,
-0.0102957515,
-0.0345694795,
0.0202695262,
-0.0496818721,
-0.017382713,
-0.011724038,
-0.0336200111,
-0.0002682046,
-0.0062860502,
0.0468062982,
-0.0146584911,
0.0246044807,
0.0300283358,
-0.0234290734,
0.0093067875,
-0.0901390687,
0.0577606857,
0.0159033854,
-0.0396007784,
0.0135007501,
-5.882452177e-33,
-0.0176275093,
-0.0490310639,
-0.0161548909,
0.0383884385,
0.0397793949,
0.0049494873,
-0.0350463614,
-0.0096120369,
0.0125320656,
-0.0288280156,
-0.015170238,
0.0122871092,
0.031756945,
0.043060746,
-0.0415352881,
-0.0215928331,
0.0570356771,
-0.0173564777,
-0.0247937664,
0.0623579621,
0.0498187765,
-0.0002803401,
-0.007331938,
-0.0527712554,
0.0236577168,
-0.044033654,
-0.0397052169,
-0.0428609997,
-0.0599166714,
0.0154663734,
-0.0024469979,
-0.0037034666,
-0.0337470919,
-0.0304284822,
-0.0232801158,
0.0441339612,
0.0192603562,
-0.0229700785,
-0.0112642674,
-0.0122099705,
-0.0427413732,
-0.0734002739,
0.0028791463,
-0.0116513753,
-0.0565103851,
0.0767507777,
-0.0171728916,
0.0353147686,
-0.043357946,
-0.0810780823,
0.0157874394,
0.0105618034,
-0.0028748757,
-0.0060019018,
-0.015436545,
-0.0185960289,
0.0065730936,
-0.0235488191,
-0.0566181839,
0.0787295401,
0.0311316699,
0.0291102789,
0.0088807959,
-0.0141053684,
-0.0023234498,
0.0032821752,
0.0672320649,
-0.0262136739,
-0.0139826592,
0.0113507286,
-0.0271710008,
0.0045667705,
0.0245680977,
0.0418313742,
0.0176391564,
-0.0373775214,
-0.0014873004,
0.0258694645,
0.0275222696,
-0.0071680392,
0.0733621195,
-0.0329485908,
-0.0237167869,
-0.0025540739,
-0.025971761,
-0.0477748699,
-0.0301453061,
0.002702629,
-0.0089095486,
0.0419604443,
-0.0475718118,
-0.0370537415,
0.0191516895,
-0.0322788022,
-0.027021857,
0.0352021828,
0.011856813,
-0.0499394275,
-0.010531377,
-0.0049977587,
0.0135311848,
-0.0063178856,
0.0147176227,
-0.0612974502,
0.0057309917,
-0.0013829219,
0.0335169807,
0.0144876633,
-0.0736165047,
-0.0071126223,
-0.0372118987,
0.0691335648,
0.0140966671,
-0.0182893407,
0.0417038463,
-0.0404310152,
-0.0146118086,
-0.0342313498,
0.0329087004,
0.0091888411,
-0.0466691181,
0.0309330765,
-0.0156226354,
0.0032040388,
-0.0035140524,
0.0493493266,
-0.0370447077,
0.0243350528,
0.0607908182,
0.012150066,
-0.0017362622,
-0.0341400206,
3.072e-7,
-0.0300627351,
0.0092376387,
0.0262209699,
0.0131456051,
0.0527925044,
0.0583573319,
0.00946269,
0.0664250255,
-0.0404066294,
0.0266006459,
-0.064059861,
-0.0285329055,
0.0576298162,
0.013376426,
-0.0943862051,
0.035261482,
-0.0840148553,
0.0241876952,
-0.0445918143,
0.0061031575,
0.0316412449,
0.0514737777,
-0.0009884399,
-0.0329932831,
0.0089092432,
-0.0391996764,
0.0242987275,
0.0217674933,
-0.0263972227,
-0.0098754019,
0.0043357513,
0.0257118493,
0.0330453292,
-0.0129089011,
-0.0614570044,
-0.0396406464,
-0.0536085144,
0.0356925391,
0.0632099584,
-0.0189640727,
0.0220928527,
-0.057121858,
-0.0107850609,
0.0253956597,
0.0159944184,
0.0724922419,
-0.0085861171,
0.0278515145,
0.0070936335,
-0.0751821548,
0.0234146379,
-0.033795163,
-0.023550801,
-0.0230084341,
-0.0017032746,
-0.0036425279,
0.0228859428,
-0.0183557682,
-0.0599563345,
-0.0823217779,
-0.044184234,
-0.038046211,
-0.0140470359,
0.0318823345,
0.0190274585,
0.010098258,
0.0217436384,
2.891719547e-34,
-0.0191059224,
-0.0068719974,
-0.0275584422,
0.0192758441,
-0.0018046795,
-0.0041466751,
0.0059125633,
0.015125487,
0.0464270078,
-0.0029572337,
-0.0474797972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17147v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.17147v2 | Using Large Language Models for Qualitative Analysis can Introduce Serious Bias | 2023-09-29T11:19:15 | 2023-10-05T12:25:18 | Julian Ashwin, Aditya Chhabra, Vijayendra Rao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, econ.GN, q-fin.EC | Large Language Models (LLMs) are quickly becoming ubiquitous, but the
implications for social science research are not yet well understood. This
paper asks whether LLMs can help us analyse large-N qualitative data from
open-ended interviews, with an application to transcripts of interviews with
Rohingya refugees in Cox's Bazaar, Bangladesh. We find that a great deal of
caution is needed in using LLMs to annotate text as there is a risk of
introducing biases that can lead to misleading inferences. We here mean bias in
the technical sense, that the errors that LLMs make in annotating interview
transcripts are not random with respect to the characteristics of the interview
subjects. Training simpler supervised models on high-quality human annotations
with flexible coding leads to less measurement error and bias than LLM
annotations. Therefore, given that some high quality annotations are necessary
in order to asses whether an LLM introduces bias, we argue that it is probably
preferable to train a bespoke model on these annotations than it is to use an
LLM for annotation. | [
0.0354562961,
0.0599717721,
-0.0271114595,
0.0080908118,
0.0055708308,
0.0461669713,
0.0275860783,
-0.0452508032,
0.0405955277,
-0.0560616553,
0.042566441,
-0.0438820086,
0.0163679235,
-0.0240774248,
0.0108492048,
-0.017279746,
0.0247326624,
-0.0129647767,
0.0450973772,
0.0184520651,
-0.0015441617,
0.0311801191,
0.012871922,
0.0455703177,
-0.0246054102,
0.0028059036,
-0.0246623941,
-0.0013226283,
-0.0144064287,
-0.0247104783,
-0.0085524945,
0.0474877022,
0.0100842947,
0.0340158716,
0.0000020261,
-0.0169185307,
0.001737175,
0.0243261233,
-0.0452683493,
0.0127116218,
0.0169769358,
-0.0426432155,
-0.0154406279,
0.016371537,
-0.0263507906,
-0.056144204,
0.069368884,
0.0419452675,
0.0484784096,
0.0319057554,
0.0168714281,
-0.0498632155,
-0.010954353,
-0.0013091204,
-0.0074725696,
0.0115050627,
0.0470491201,
0.0069721621,
-0.0044096839,
0.026755238,
-0.0089093223,
0.0474200845,
0.0111497566,
-0.0411878489,
0.004009739,
-0.0250874776,
-0.0601977706,
-0.0409933031,
0.0264499709,
0.0287533607,
0.014093413,
0.0232384242,
0.0123849902,
-0.0011662557,
0.0172570068,
0.005906756,
-0.029470792,
0.0739192218,
-0.0214071516,
0.0031160822,
0.005329554,
0.0246556122,
0.0112357661,
-0.0030369274,
-0.0193387158,
0.0220741499,
-0.0210285429,
0.0044286796,
-0.0115647828,
0.0062805591,
-0.0127049247,
-0.0259251148,
-0.0360405259,
-0.0051059155,
-0.0190304741,
0.0303469729,
0.020505568,
0.0087393541,
0.0305749048,
-0.0864309818,
-0.0119114006,
0.0255663712,
-0.0429111607,
0.0117191505,
0.0341207385,
-0.0138662551,
0.0106687704,
-0.0112981116,
-0.0351294614,
0.0079752188,
-0.0401810072,
-0.0036403902,
-0.0143314349,
0.0139899701,
-0.0312786251,
0.0170048811,
-0.0730503649,
0.0181592219,
0.0246945694,
0.0252240766,
-0.0325817801,
-0.0553139113,
-0.0284566823,
0.0324201174,
-0.0125910435,
0.0274725277,
-0.0010138009,
0.0549359396,
-0.0224823821,
-0.1113503501,
0.0589806288,
0.0478073396,
-0.0119562596,
-0.0256664902,
-0.0489871018,
0.0236193277,
0.0267443173,
0.0219822749,
-0.0337613747,
-0.003811945,
-0.0249069612,
-0.0377067477,
-0.0144447722,
-0.0405386016,
0.024229249,
0.0367891453,
0.0000500607,
-0.0670552105,
0.033826299,
0.0114719654,
-0.0377890803,
0.053096287,
-0.0040281122,
0.0183624662,
0.0572818071,
0.0187676866,
0.0584288202,
0.0570347607,
0.0473648235,
-0.0201632828,
0.0353063382,
-0.0560771488,
0.0197431352,
0.0437759273,
-0.0209436659,
0.0241941717,
-0.0280130934,
0.0283277817,
0.0246457141,
0.01984163,
0.0322944261,
0.0665214658,
-0.0149043147,
0.0215897821,
0.0483072251,
0.0886785835,
-0.0058954433,
0.0212656818,
0.0125512714,
0.0533170477,
0.0024503688,
0.0099074403,
-0.0279074218,
-0.0027067058,
0.0373322032,
-0.0218867585,
0.0563127771,
-0.0218961276,
-0.0175042879,
-0.039922405,
-0.0204342213,
0.0026526959,
0.0152722299,
0.0313405618,
0.0176239293,
-0.0267617106,
0.0327891037,
0.0365949944,
0.0532848202,
-0.0539599434,
-0.0118901199,
-0.0649857298,
0.0226413626,
-0.0116297184,
-0.0291991625,
-0.0162441712,
0.0424796119,
-0.0654658303,
0.0183862541,
0.0466029458,
0.0593216494,
-0.00460683,
-0.0186436661,
-0.0004811479,
0.025046695,
0.0245836377,
0.019991193,
-0.0105702374,
-0.0269349776,
-0.0105504803,
0.0178663339,
-0.0129721714,
-0.1057635322,
0.0424605459,
-0.0146236392,
-0.0426405147,
-0.0063463929,
-0.0311228614,
0.0219220761,
0.0302020758,
-0.0157092996,
0.0019586536,
0.0034332972,
-0.0292497966,
0.0152201597,
0.0340610556,
-0.0109198289,
0.0103628626,
0.0053373254,
-0.0188346375,
-0.0269388855,
-0.0024907214,
-0.0225785729,
-0.0019264937,
0.0270359926,
0.0120048933,
0.0611361712,
-0.0155143626,
0.0254546534,
-0.0300057009,
0.0028578469,
-0.0660099089,
0.0435163081,
0.0067821979,
-0.004017483,
-0.0604178421,
-0.0452538431,
0.0606549978,
-0.03826648,
-0.0111386105,
0.0255318638,
0.0210444406,
0.0255555958,
0.019417569,
-0.037546359,
-0.013624859,
-0.0413396209,
-0.1221571341,
0.0209539942,
-0.0185492225,
0.0040547387,
-0.0103771593,
0.0376587734,
-0.0133793196,
0.0036421965,
-0.0315608531,
-0.073915042,
0.0211280771,
0.0350676402,
-0.0093114404,
0.0220150892,
0.0317015126,
-0.0415944196,
-0.0064917165,
-0.0347671285,
0.0603229627,
0.0608114712,
-0.0620282553,
-0.0328435861,
-0.0053994469,
-0.0329565033,
-0.0157217532,
-0.0069748284,
-0.0439281538,
0.0243887324,
0.0271404479,
-0.026727194,
0.0332531817,
-0.0016394786,
0.0163006354,
0.0164406393,
0.0223272555,
-0.0149475653,
-0.015315068,
0.0121015497,
-0.0487076752,
-0.0385975279,
-0.062067192,
-0.0209155567,
0.0331384093,
0.0139736673,
-0.0148344375,
-0.0167368911,
0.0071620508,
-0.0567665063,
-0.015187013,
-0.0312449709,
-0.0328339264,
-0.0150117557,
0.0572169907,
0.0086591505,
-0.0091610588,
-0.0294014383,
0.001834915,
0.0295923967,
-0.0192070771,
-0.0038450898,
-0.0759867206,
0.0461332463,
-0.0023021351,
0.0061233277,
-0.0270482022,
0.0066266558,
-0.0147383753,
-0.0298674777,
-0.0047971527,
-0.0460503101,
0.0007744203,
-0.0756222159,
0.0377920233,
-0.0338697806,
-0.0383690447,
-0.0337695926,
-0.0814851895,
-0.0274975244,
-0.0015841873,
0.0173245892,
0.0324943699,
0.0070027281,
0.0397228636,
0.0511407517,
0.0108572645,
0.0022684929,
0.0157540683,
-0.0182250794,
0.0021327625,
0.0132684559,
-0.0256756693,
0.0564473122,
-0.0216507372,
0.0462692082,
0.0093994252,
-0.0068357582,
0.0508929566,
0.0074469317,
-0.0387211479,
0.0244480167,
-0.0031351328,
-0.0418583453,
0.0255371556,
0.0578292385,
-0.0378064401,
0.0275187325,
0.0965336636,
0.0161181539,
-0.023649089,
0.0253885575,
-0.0436817966,
-0.016025817,
0.0261045173,
0.022235943,
-0.1158072203,
0.0173934884,
-0.0125858355,
-0.003074781,
-0.0531014614,
-0.0294800997,
-0.0042033452,
-0.0979339853,
0.0224623214,
0.0082038008,
-0.0371975265,
-0.0231110454,
-0.0136899343,
0.0149911856,
-0.0127534997,
0.0262738224,
0.0108450018,
-0.0127361845,
0.0072031394,
0.0568075851,
-0.0913030505,
-0.0544564873,
-0.0167718604,
-0.0480589159,
0.0838636234,
0.0330184437,
0.013962727,
-0.0343431979,
0.041710075,
0.0544201955,
-0.021324601,
-0.0679379106,
0.0345636122,
0.0198915061,
-0.0054934798,
-0.0332649872,
-0.0039444268,
0.0379197225,
-0.0246881861,
0.0169446971,
0.0449885167,
0.0396817625,
-0.0244761202,
0.0216927994,
0.0253193583,
0.0027412656,
0.043813318,
0.0269378573,
0.0100619281,
-0.0473601408,
0.0174358785,
-0.0718359649,
-0.041476842,
0.0091103828,
-0.0943412185,
0.0699492171,
-0.0253335647,
-0.0026796649,
-0.0103955688,
-0.0737966299,
0.0223648455,
0.0019220377,
0.0180303268,
0.0262210555,
0.0717759505,
-0.025186874,
-0.0071699861,
0.0528216064,
-0.0399510339,
0.0116043314,
0.0031022094,
0.0039145495,
0.0110259429,
-0.0049884911,
0.0113178277,
-0.005305185,
-0.0611463599,
-0.0289931409,
0.0518431813,
-0.0146649433,
0.0186648611,
0.0209373124,
0.0320151411,
-0.0667035133,
-0.0263814963,
-0.0020731937,
-0.0270662867,
0.0198445395,
-0.0304650832,
0.0567434877,
-0.0234170835,
0.0293888934,
-0.0082065938,
0.0203742534,
0.0188581832,
-0.0119958567,
-0.0844754726,
-0.0652872398,
-0.0152181135,
-0.0495714396,
0.0396554098,
-0.0072344248,
-0.030195985,
-0.0438494273,
-0.0482688844,
-0.0320746489,
-0.044956889,
-0.0248944256,
-0.0159222241,
0.0110522918,
0.0297860373,
-0.0393402129,
-0.015769789,
-0.0566590689,
0.0639536381,
-0.0476844124,
0.0819712281,
-0.0142407278,
-0.0115333516,
-0.0202324521,
0.0083572119,
-0.0033310074,
0.0483880155,
-0.0338812172,
0.0480439737,
0.0159647707,
0.0185691379,
-0.0144107044,
0.0229997523,
0.0713705868,
-0.008341725,
-0.0007497743,
-0.0740917921,
-0.0111803235,
-0.011158146,
0.0245316681,
-0.0387919992,
0.0245496184,
0.0001712554,
-0.0000327139,
-0.0381790325,
0.011097081,
0.002431754,
-0.0202475842,
0.0411414653,
-0.0010728069,
-0.0646816045,
0.0311845932,
0.0396375097,
0.0423985384,
0.0138481651,
-0.0160695203,
-0.0186406486,
-0.0139242718,
-0.044384487,
0.0465535037,
-0.0032402852,
-0.0096785193,
0.0135901328,
-0.0790621415,
-0.0569715835,
-0.0281433854,
-0.0169751104,
-0.0114420578,
-0.0205758102,
-0.0177306831,
0.0192686692,
0.0028869982,
-0.0020138593,
-0.0918567404,
0.0044013392,
-0.0554939918,
0.0094264261,
0.0420843922,
-5.971548404e-33,
-0.0230035689,
-0.0374616869,
-0.0098770307,
-0.0555880331,
-0.0207441058,
0.0142717101,
0.0189014431,
0.0060858098,
-0.0506256856,
-0.0021044777,
-0.0211469457,
0.0059332629,
0.0191826615,
0.0147229088,
0.0539549515,
0.0183572099,
0.0334944837,
0.0344682261,
-0.0013566811,
-0.0204997025,
-0.0091527468,
-0.0334610902,
0.0395889319,
-0.0841414407,
0.0827852637,
-0.0433869734,
0.0066282274,
0.0134108737,
0.0421112068,
0.025878055,
-0.0477389731,
0.0261871126,
0.0018649398,
-0.0267268121,
0.0149463639,
0.035355106,
-0.0302504711,
0.0432816334,
0.0471116304,
0.0659938902,
0.0063818167,
-0.0623500831,
0.0161627233,
-0.0289200675,
-0.024074968,
0.0323151425,
0.0092847459,
-0.0439544842,
-0.0031036227,
0.0043262518,
-0.052227892,
0.0630063638,
-0.0383927226,
0.0470268726,
-0.0320178978,
0.0483303405,
-0.0125374198,
0.007428016,
-0.0675300211,
-0.0128539028,
0.0124650393,
0.0373694152,
0.0125244847,
0.0387002453,
-0.0043185274,
0.0405788347,
0.0078685265,
-0.0103164567,
0.0172463655,
-0.007971555,
-0.0056010126,
-0.0566728152,
0.0096901041,
0.1132216677,
0.0183252636,
-0.0240797121,
-0.0787994936,
-0.0306389332,
-0.009135752,
0.0337955616,
0.0569102503,
0.0172359478,
-0.0308786891,
-0.0410061367,
-0.060957104,
-0.0296228882,
-0.0028564942,
0.0070244949,
0.0059042796,
-0.0093905125,
-0.0127876066,
0.0499426462,
0.0785454661,
-0.0113717075,
0.0111797415,
-0.0243385322,
-0.0322973654,
0.0247804597,
-0.0349616148,
0.0525200963,
-0.0494471975,
-0.0089011611,
0.0141743952,
0.0111555606,
0.0644273087,
0.0341127515,
0.0443016291,
-0.0083778361,
-0.0714153275,
-0.0061070397,
0.0031177194,
0.0219941195,
-0.023506511,
0.0151860109,
0.0236208793,
0.0050476198,
0.0082741128,
0.0202392358,
0.0179477539,
-0.0023607491,
0.0159602929,
-0.0480868928,
-0.0153297493,
-0.0415120237,
-0.058780048,
0.0074574556,
0.0162047539,
0.0818783417,
0.0275956821,
-0.0332366303,
0.0043580323,
0.0141478386,
2.685e-7,
0.0411013253,
0.0767056271,
-0.0163068585,
-0.0504218563,
0.0193252303,
0.013492805,
0.0376316644,
0.0021688829,
0.0082411775,
-0.0116303768,
-0.0063477741,
0.0274303462,
0.0795232803,
0.0388732143,
-0.0794087127,
-0.0429913066,
-0.0530852452,
0.0059849662,
-0.0719323829,
0.007618282,
0.0352915674,
0.1198261008,
-0.0098373042,
0.0175226014,
-0.0461803786,
-0.0098223528,
0.0471971333,
-0.0101903277,
-0.0593753867,
0.0551191866,
0.0420128778,
0.0288024638,
0.0046094079,
0.0145940855,
0.0084097357,
0.0068842964,
0.031110201,
0.0812968388,
0.0038920508,
0.0300085135,
-0.0023168735,
-0.0044874591,
0.0049854456,
-0.0661877692,
0.0813967809,
-0.0095429709,
-0.0637008622,
-0.0774039477,
0.0043709343,
-0.0174283367,
0.0497505739,
-0.0020187083,
0.0030141606,
0.0283792391,
0.0242956206,
-0.0473071486,
-0.0070003555,
-0.0212347079,
-0.0554361939,
-0.0003184289,
-0.0243366566,
-0.0746223778,
0.0251013339,
0.0163225513,
-0.003185781,
-0.0329740122,
0.0751859322,
2.24597022e-34,
0.0679630041,
0.0326325297,
0.0052441461,
-0.0025817386,
0.0811014846,
0.0378986001,
-0.0020363485,
0.0018845455,
0.0347954184,
-0.0485555641,
0.0420510098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17134v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.17134v1 | Promoting Generalized Cross-lingual Question Answering in Few-resource Scenarios via Self-knowledge Distillation | 2023-09-29T10:54:59 | 2023-09-29T10:54:59 | Casimiro Pio Carrino, Carlos Escolano, José A. R. Fonollosa | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite substantial progress in multilingual extractive Question Answering
(QA), models with high and uniformly distributed performance across languages
remain challenging, especially for languages with limited resources. We study
cross-lingual transfer mainly focusing on the Generalized Cross-Lingual
Transfer (G-XLT) task, where the question language differs from the context
language - a challenge that has received limited attention thus far. Our
approach seeks to enhance cross-lingual QA transfer using a high-performing
multilingual model trained on a large-scale dataset, complemented by a few
thousand aligned QA examples across languages. Our proposed strategy combines
cross-lingual sampling and advanced self-distillation training in generations
to tackle the previous challenge. Notably, we introduce the novel mAP@k
coefficients to fine-tune self-knowledge distillation loss, dynamically
regulating the teacher's model knowledge to perform a balanced and effective
knowledge transfer. We extensively evaluate our approach to assess XLT and
G-XLT capabilities in extractive QA. Results reveal that our self-knowledge
distillation approach outperforms standard cross-entropy fine-tuning by a
significant margin. Importantly, when compared to a strong baseline that
leverages a sizeable volume of machine-translated data, our approach shows
competitive results despite the considerable challenge of operating within
resource-constrained settings, even in zero-shot scenarios. Beyond performance
improvements, we offer valuable insights through comprehensive analyses and an
ablation study, further substantiating the benefits and constraints of our
approach. In essence, we propose a practical solution to improve cross-lingual
QA transfer by leveraging a few data resources in an efficient way. | [
0.0057487232,
0.010644353,
-0.0096661579,
0.0545261241,
-0.0059892111,
0.0166324191,
-0.0053739296,
-0.0187027641,
-0.004501252,
-0.0148174204,
-0.0606239401,
-0.0124302888,
-0.0443240963,
-0.0323399082,
0.0090592792,
-0.0368612483,
0.0438428186,
-0.0584576577,
-0.028752733,
-0.04280499,
-0.0207424071,
0.0000597005,
0.0120872306,
-0.0392638147,
0.0257609021,
-0.0425295532,
0.0030895178,
-0.0201369561,
0.0233986508,
0.0033086883,
0.017808143,
0.0484067015,
0.0161512941,
0.0129284812,
0.0000021731,
-0.0296570007,
-0.0187310241,
0.0103104375,
-0.0378767364,
0.0241640341,
-0.0221109223,
-0.0165887587,
0.0185645744,
-0.022140177,
-0.0415107049,
0.0001271309,
0.0308302194,
0.0058513372,
0.0652350783,
0.0247613844,
0.01986151,
-0.0176270902,
0.0251616277,
-0.0148872044,
0.0304650292,
-0.0496995002,
0.0144725945,
0.0447596237,
-0.0136350421,
0.0028011322,
-0.0509238914,
0.058680594,
0.058863312,
0.01072725,
-0.0203760229,
0.0236872248,
-0.0355244502,
0.0251810569,
-0.0212743431,
0.0820061415,
-0.0053969934,
0.01800045,
-0.0158021655,
0.0121470382,
0.0024977373,
-0.017548671,
-0.0768600181,
-0.0052405973,
0.0194804389,
-0.0010297741,
0.0213681236,
0.0270614661,
-0.0006699871,
0.0116490759,
-0.0313684233,
0.0344133675,
0.0183613282,
-0.0320061781,
0.0322716534,
0.0259349253,
-0.0077149994,
-0.0169107653,
-0.0268803872,
0.0325377434,
0.0277608801,
0.020847477,
-0.0035223835,
-0.0483860709,
0.0303920303,
-0.0118795596,
0.0101345787,
0.0225597676,
-0.0196135882,
0.0405755341,
-0.0313206241,
0.0488621518,
-0.0115354452,
0.0459472537,
-0.0254837573,
-0.0475989357,
-0.0561796166,
-0.0179904178,
-0.0372679569,
0.0348412097,
-0.0341624431,
0.0361370705,
-0.0302997362,
-0.0120862927,
-0.0227429699,
-0.0466908962,
0.029794516,
0.0082867639,
-0.0518613122,
-0.0132463863,
-0.0305324197,
0.0907066837,
-0.0542727374,
-0.0209212825,
0.0211283974,
-0.0736146495,
-0.0653323382,
-0.008685464,
0.008698687,
-0.0576424189,
0.0061435294,
0.0627994835,
-0.0485438891,
-0.0060848114,
-0.0294353273,
-0.0079004597,
-0.0257889982,
-0.0904660746,
0.0241300613,
-0.074770309,
0.0651704371,
-0.0016403494,
0.0075455639,
-0.0224350095,
0.0072652292,
-0.0129511133,
0.0026553557,
0.0424695984,
0.0077446369,
0.0099980794,
0.0149790244,
0.0071004387,
0.0130487354,
0.1192233488,
0.0043543158,
-0.016006751,
0.0590383075,
-0.0120574869,
-0.0237192977,
0.0257885493,
0.0575026311,
0.0349582173,
0.0089599891,
0.0450143926,
0.0059151286,
0.0007899404,
0.0811415985,
0.0115993693,
-0.0369285867,
-0.0069199693,
0.047410477,
0.0341033451,
0.0192443803,
0.0526098572,
0.016933376,
0.0046900446,
-0.0172181353,
0.0286448114,
-0.020798238,
0.0513575338,
0.045080103,
-0.0023863211,
0.0474129468,
0.0805671811,
-0.04778805,
-0.0296256617,
0.0359349735,
0.0207911581,
-0.0036734457,
0.050602559,
0.0460921638,
0.060818363,
0.0288055949,
0.0960414335,
0.0586871281,
-0.0487747863,
0.0431060828,
-0.0177317895,
0.0230738632,
0.0141979102,
-0.0058104289,
-0.0082158484,
-0.0208165701,
-0.0122470241,
0.027024297,
0.0000719551,
0.0534529164,
-0.0348495841,
0.0823847726,
-0.0230005551,
-0.0362053365,
-0.0384542644,
-0.0117518585,
0.0292300936,
0.0173845701,
0.0614385121,
0.0274427515,
-0.0913609043,
0.0143573331,
0.0024904232,
-0.078964211,
-0.0887905806,
0.0215870254,
0.0362994373,
0.0044389027,
0.0419829451,
-0.0048326799,
-0.0234916694,
0.02401926,
-0.0562605783,
-0.0251135789,
0.0042305971,
-0.0545305386,
-0.0799116939,
0.0288596265,
-0.0185114909,
-0.030168727,
0.0166003965,
-0.048558712,
-0.0454766862,
0.0334854163,
0.0056823897,
0.0212657154,
-0.0494465567,
-0.0285498127,
0.0268542245,
0.0278091859,
-0.0155800357,
0.0491543449,
0.0349516235,
-0.0086551476,
-0.0064566513,
-0.0448734351,
0.0371716656,
-0.0219855551,
0.0075308741,
0.0301724318,
-0.0301592909,
0.0329648778,
0.0379063115,
0.022248745,
-0.0498169139,
-0.0067438548,
-0.0327175632,
0.0298972167,
-0.0296933334,
0.0527711436,
0.0374045037,
0.0628402084,
0.0009574054,
-0.0257246662,
-0.075899303,
-0.0152319102,
0.0206629355,
0.0301928893,
0.0285309702,
0.0343676358,
0.0644868687,
-0.0132398959,
-0.026964562,
0.0222844966,
0.0186434276,
-0.047897175,
0.0503253937,
-0.0075918892,
0.0013448193,
-0.0443522818,
0.0156149166,
-0.0001879854,
-0.0555532016,
-0.036837399,
-0.0233892929,
0.0074980878,
0.0391709432,
-0.0329454578,
-0.0604731739,
0.0411623083,
-0.0483001769,
-0.0677928627,
0.0556654371,
-0.0182199087,
-0.0317843184,
-0.0039695236,
0.0015971502,
-0.0133760404,
0.04594405,
-0.0134434188,
-0.0352981798,
-0.0540713333,
-0.0329284333,
-0.0151181696,
-0.0371072069,
-0.0532921441,
0.0730740204,
0.008764429,
0.0203275718,
-0.0339189582,
0.0070214765,
0.0607391708,
0.013479081,
-0.0342625864,
-0.0596758313,
0.0021352738,
-0.0541229658,
0.0395231321,
-0.0558891036,
0.004137137,
0.0035959699,
0.0169223454,
-0.0822102204,
-0.0378333032,
0.030275356,
-0.0045691137,
0.0224942081,
-0.041834563,
-0.0022425193,
-0.0191574525,
-0.0786070675,
-0.0207790583,
-0.0216669627,
0.0287548751,
0.0066273361,
-0.007594659,
0.0199384969,
0.0113461073,
-0.0081029767,
0.0436340459,
0.0155038107,
-0.0398638509,
-0.0041615609,
-0.009609201,
0.0756319761,
0.0510380119,
0.0384944901,
0.0114389537,
-0.0116134007,
0.057978712,
0.0460190363,
0.0648604184,
-0.0257747266,
0.019268794,
0.02259898,
0.0408427678,
-0.0138395801,
-0.0063946783,
-0.0191477537,
0.0947641879,
-0.069298856,
-0.0171279777,
0.0403816029,
-0.0217754208,
0.0092260828,
-0.0211342331,
-0.0570119396,
0.0347709507,
0.0032394656,
0.0557488427,
-0.0882114023,
-0.0355944633,
-0.0396326371,
0.0227263253,
0.0300266277,
-0.0101009309,
0.0158872604,
-0.1325048357,
0.0067219585,
0.0026736089,
-0.0785982981,
-0.0471891202,
-0.0192250665,
0.0040275268,
-0.0394473784,
0.0372276418,
-0.0276366603,
-0.0283500738,
0.0068790307,
0.0306132697,
0.0286339298,
-0.0370781198,
0.033217568,
-0.0239743404,
-0.0102477809,
0.033762686,
0.0422948971,
-0.0113265561,
-0.0281191375,
-0.0226428378,
-0.0904159993,
-0.0254005939,
0.0068305247,
0.0674847662,
0.0010180771,
-0.0171560906,
0.0405399092,
0.0318828709,
-0.0156874396,
0.0143275587,
0.0375555605,
0.0758911371,
0.0561560765,
-0.0285588577,
0.0090723699,
-0.0266704578,
0.0263017565,
0.0641957074,
0.0293633137,
-0.0015267604,
-0.0388823934,
0.001255812,
-0.0019909379,
-0.0798918828,
-0.0013754312,
0.0188536998,
-0.0273040067,
-0.0069838669,
-0.0621197075,
-0.063251771,
0.0240060445,
0.0231362022,
-0.0179912485,
0.0369487032,
-0.0302502401,
0.0412892923,
-0.0237977803,
0.0153524093,
-0.0594148189,
-0.0259599108,
-0.0052774516,
-0.0089518121,
-0.013315551,
-0.0288767293,
-0.0080994368,
0.0198672786,
-0.0813877881,
-0.0696660429,
-0.0200288631,
0.0881937295,
0.0039249389,
0.0705454946,
-0.0017153524,
-0.0326822102,
0.0885554776,
0.0011570367,
-0.0333574377,
-0.0179854967,
0.056403894,
0.0022577548,
0.0055222115,
0.074983649,
-0.035671521,
0.0160217956,
0.005964404,
0.0537480563,
-0.040452607,
-0.0169452727,
0.0214217231,
0.0093325749,
-0.013363516,
0.0144768897,
0.0092587592,
-0.0171950925,
0.0261844043,
-0.010624012,
-0.0087708095,
-0.0328879468,
-0.0010133111,
0.0208297204,
-0.0577967912,
0.014674102,
0.0390239879,
0.0230136253,
-0.0030723785,
-0.0423195772,
-0.0017541056,
0.0182967279,
0.0075738798,
-0.0053663142,
0.0251380801,
0.0071209772,
-0.0136463391,
0.0488601662,
0.0556046329,
-0.0273255296,
0.0216173176,
0.0165944006,
-0.0090006106,
0.0157957505,
-0.0004611491,
-0.0697243139,
-0.0527987108,
-0.000424953,
-0.0259629171,
0.0439573638,
-0.0050376393,
0.0717632696,
0.0174625404,
-0.0508789308,
0.0064401366,
-0.0165794659,
-0.0180856939,
0.0477599204,
0.0377762206,
0.0216063969,
-0.0051238406,
0.0071953684,
0.0639756471,
-0.0269547291,
0.0591567084,
-0.0019770737,
0.0280687455,
-0.0301229004,
-0.0266769789,
0.0084219351,
-0.0192202274,
0.0162900854,
0.0224624239,
-0.0343093425,
-0.0793643296,
-0.013415887,
-0.0008093342,
-0.0423006676,
-0.0201439988,
0.0331575796,
0.0619945899,
0.0031263379,
-0.0539337844,
-0.0302469786,
0.0172727033,
-0.0065695606,
-0.004030766,
0.0313949659,
-6.812362248e-33,
-0.0045983912,
0.0522791371,
0.0306224395,
-0.0198922418,
-0.0229614917,
0.0024174217,
-0.0241005104,
-0.0119140279,
-0.064834699,
0.0275450051,
-0.0327604711,
-0.0042790864,
0.0153801264,
0.046515692,
0.02565003,
-0.0151124103,
0.0362236276,
-0.0015694296,
-0.0292493254,
0.0414774381,
0.0382245742,
0.0384958088,
0.0863393545,
-0.0070673116,
0.0169643704,
-0.0011764283,
0.0240404904,
0.0162728801,
0.0164555535,
0.0276744813,
-0.0258192234,
0.0573998578,
0.0137230959,
-0.0618546344,
-0.0131750824,
0.0143651441,
-0.1344628185,
-0.0816034302,
0.0075094053,
-0.0226371791,
-0.0300827418,
-0.0561542474,
-0.0018039789,
-0.0122242738,
0.0475319177,
-0.0380515531,
0.002198142,
-0.0047697253,
0.0024436126,
-0.0185311101,
-0.0415047742,
0.0038281432,
-0.0239946116,
-0.034409374,
0.0368169695,
0.0641784817,
-0.0031912185,
0.006464479,
-0.0420034453,
0.0060502314,
0.0013695293,
0.0506319553,
0.072561726,
-0.0124902427,
0.0010835952,
0.0049595102,
-0.0037759033,
-0.0021378682,
0.0232586525,
-0.0319217704,
-0.0009955759,
0.0236401018,
0.0070583513,
0.0980441719,
0.0625117868,
0.0003799298,
-0.0696762353,
0.0370245166,
-0.0105149718,
0.0412322357,
-0.0321109183,
-0.0227002129,
0.0041304571,
-0.0152056133,
-0.0481326506,
-0.0141195655,
-0.0016048428,
-0.0400275029,
0.034661103,
-0.0118362168,
-0.041283004,
0.0043570343,
0.0325906761,
-0.0464759618,
-0.0127650155,
0.0261652209,
-0.0197651442,
-0.0145428795,
0.028852459,
0.0279027168,
-0.0623673387,
0.010825376,
-0.0125225084,
-0.0062225945,
0.0041440297,
0.0167278722,
0.0530061424,
-0.0022208143,
-0.0478875563,
-0.0007046166,
-0.0526006855,
0.0384823307,
-0.0016917416,
0.0143286604,
-0.0147367232,
0.0370452367,
-0.0201981552,
0.0115621714,
0.0534656532,
-0.0026874705,
0.0062471461,
0.0064404877,
0.0206062458,
0.0212453473,
0.003801353,
0.0032288621,
-0.0404377617,
-0.0025603285,
-0.0034548582,
-0.043269325,
-0.0191481244,
0.0233676806,
2.794e-7,
0.0564053804,
-0.015563461,
0.0206542108,
-0.0260088593,
-0.0081194183,
0.0298006069,
-0.0137613565,
0.0046508973,
0.0029075814,
-0.0320903808,
-0.008278464,
0.0780620873,
0.0689636022,
0.0400651172,
-0.0621225499,
0.0038984534,
-0.0136596048,
-0.0139008239,
-0.0126009425,
-0.0509328432,
-0.0030833222,
0.0431896597,
0.0013593589,
-0.0249968041,
-0.019034788,
-0.0237624049,
0.0634208024,
-0.0097012492,
-0.0059216167,
0.0317969285,
-0.0147766173,
-0.0039694016,
-0.0065494739,
0.008360873,
-0.0426491611,
0.0344011597,
0.0040576593,
0.0541447438,
0.0119902389,
-0.0614605434,
-0.0086035477,
-0.0020880434,
0.0023635717,
-0.0759052858,
0.0833436549,
-0.0746932924,
-0.0142639177,
-0.00769446,
-0.0300593022,
0.0163059421,
0.0729352906,
-0.0299556758,
-0.0304253642,
0.0442097969,
0.0293094311,
0.0036531007,
-0.0324550122,
-0.0324468501,
0.0156532489,
0.0141552519,
-0.0088544646,
-0.0340736844,
-0.0154401837,
-0.0349520668,
-0.0272782259,
-0.0219375174,
0.0373755731,
2.103477805e-34,
-0.008819011,
-0.0162716527,
0.0149522731,
0.00804256,
0.009222297,
-0.023751229,
-0.0342431664,
-0.0160014369,
0.0075344658,
-0.0273293145,
-0.0067128194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17133v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.17133v2 | Fine-grained Late-interaction Multi-modal Retrieval for Retrieval Augmented Visual Question Answering | 2023-09-29T10:54:10 | 2023-10-28T16:03:35 | Weizhe Lin, Jinghong Chen, Jingbiao Mei, Alexandru Coca, Bill Byrne | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Knowledge-based Visual Question Answering (KB-VQA) requires VQA systems to
utilize knowledge from external knowledge bases to answer visually-grounded
questions. Retrieval-Augmented Visual Question Answering (RA-VQA), a strong
framework to tackle KB-VQA, first retrieves related documents with Dense
Passage Retrieval (DPR) and then uses them to answer questions. This paper
proposes Fine-grained Late-interaction Multi-modal Retrieval (FLMR) which
significantly improves knowledge retrieval in RA-VQA. FLMR addresses two major
limitations in RA-VQA's retriever: (1) the image representations obtained via
image-to-text transforms can be incomplete and inaccurate and (2) relevance
scores between queries and documents are computed with one-dimensional
embeddings, which can be insensitive to finer-grained relevance. FLMR overcomes
these limitations by obtaining image representations that complement those from
the image-to-text transforms using a vision model aligned with an existing
text-based retriever through a simple alignment network. FLMR also encodes
images and questions using multi-dimensional embeddings to capture
finer-grained relevance between queries and documents. FLMR significantly
improves the original RA-VQA retriever's PRRecall@5 by approximately 8\%.
Finally, we equipped RA-VQA with two state-of-the-art large
multi-modal/language models to achieve $\sim61\%$ VQA score in the OK-VQA
dataset. | [
0.0327079743,
0.0326635689,
-0.0048647975,
0.0382255912,
-0.0029353953,
-0.0152683202,
-0.023438571,
0.0224252194,
0.0208148006,
-0.0528701469,
-0.0186683778,
0.0027317086,
-0.0231430624,
0.0650822744,
0.0469586104,
-0.0399316736,
0.0546470918,
0.0103246076,
0.0176448114,
0.0087776352,
0.0624380782,
0.0137150837,
0.0205270927,
0.036195226,
-0.0180931333,
-0.0053915912,
-0.0363413095,
0.0179548115,
0.0436156243,
0.0022367903,
0.0185050759,
0.0100848628,
0.0899570063,
-0.0393508077,
0.0000018076,
0.0125789326,
-0.0029135272,
0.0217254814,
0.0182804838,
-0.0195142739,
0.007817965,
-0.0147073995,
0.0791597813,
-0.0112047186,
-0.0552706867,
-0.0317394696,
0.054869812,
0.0538250506,
0.0601026006,
0.0348146409,
-0.0307604633,
-0.0243442953,
0.0276317745,
-0.0067704017,
0.0447827131,
-0.0536191091,
-0.0119391195,
0.046797134,
0.0240021888,
0.0547386557,
-0.0360759236,
0.0545316972,
-0.0055537256,
-0.0014849307,
0.0118621653,
0.0271105524,
-0.0201327559,
0.026113579,
0.0025974317,
0.0875160843,
0.0231140256,
0.002791472,
-0.0296428055,
0.0097036092,
0.0028781774,
0.0388374999,
-0.0562092736,
-0.0159729421,
-0.0077771051,
-0.0108890738,
-0.0777676329,
0.0024987455,
-0.0107220914,
0.0111860102,
0.0043067173,
-0.0495141447,
0.0207186919,
-0.0004868634,
-0.0291001312,
0.0126143908,
-0.0510830097,
-0.0082157552,
-0.0402547978,
0.0599702746,
0.0042274208,
-0.0118988017,
-0.0095533477,
-0.0205187611,
0.0041889464,
-0.022934841,
0.0180921499,
0.0300588384,
-0.0623386838,
0.0774477422,
-0.0223947056,
0.0713961795,
-0.0190038756,
0.0164313819,
-0.0548419096,
-0.0300517455,
-0.032021787,
-0.0165258721,
-0.0652078912,
0.0298422202,
-0.0545907691,
-0.051482778,
0.0053495402,
0.0308825932,
0.0041735279,
-0.0159557331,
-0.0109903514,
0.0670137405,
-0.0329921134,
-0.0081216078,
-0.0587880947,
0.0805561692,
-0.0386829339,
0.0243480541,
-0.0021772247,
-0.0109959515,
-0.0064923586,
0.0026054094,
0.0326054879,
-0.0474483594,
0.0101258485,
0.0198851991,
-0.0533776358,
-0.0358109139,
0.0031195458,
-0.0416672565,
-0.0121922158,
-0.0231140256,
0.0103297327,
-0.0292737372,
0.051040791,
0.0004823234,
-0.0461823046,
0.0059230207,
-0.0034267816,
0.0421774238,
-0.0595482215,
0.0660246164,
0.0163741838,
-0.0266740602,
0.0237682555,
0.0253690369,
0.0293305609,
0.0599714518,
-0.0074980021,
0.038934242,
0.0446848162,
-0.0056769075,
0.0041628103,
0.0073850341,
-0.0026882701,
-0.0077613154,
-0.0254812073,
0.0445023738,
-0.0049642595,
0.0093390532,
0.0179508347,
0.0318160281,
-0.0481228977,
-0.0277566332,
0.0431260467,
0.011842736,
0.0423712917,
-0.0183649063,
-0.0107495412,
0.0055817808,
-0.0004655196,
-0.0171071067,
-0.0547700301,
0.1014102846,
-0.0239349753,
0.0016903555,
0.0172022916,
0.027056979,
-0.0360087641,
-0.0196075216,
0.0349315442,
0.0125676915,
0.0024587158,
0.053882204,
0.0419625156,
-0.0064207208,
-0.0474219546,
0.0100932596,
0.009746464,
-0.0161157344,
0.0071798121,
-0.0143626807,
0.0334119499,
0.0374733284,
0.0516943783,
-0.0304037984,
-0.0001963508,
0.0241621379,
0.0213328563,
0.0008284381,
-0.0024509397,
-0.0151801156,
0.01451765,
-0.0700768083,
-0.0625045374,
-0.0393490307,
-0.0256534889,
0.0021673946,
0.0189411733,
0.0148815913,
0.0165293589,
-0.0484605059,
0.0524851866,
0.0380638167,
0.0539716743,
0.0070998492,
-0.0371194221,
0.0419799425,
-0.0352484137,
0.0000489316,
-0.0158578455,
0.01485941,
0.0311478432,
-0.0361618958,
0.0124769295,
-0.0238527898,
-0.0255540721,
-0.0455975309,
0.0121385539,
-0.0072244648,
0.00291277,
0.019674316,
-0.0395040661,
-0.0170708485,
0.018089382,
-0.0069419597,
-0.0118542686,
-0.0444502607,
-0.0370440185,
0.0321691409,
0.021682201,
-0.0571177639,
0.0438016914,
-0.0218264833,
0.0318261236,
-0.0011793671,
-0.0053195409,
0.0314567313,
-0.0115574235,
-0.0286813099,
-0.0061984402,
-0.0163858365,
0.0241486561,
0.029713612,
0.0104359053,
-0.0514130071,
-0.0117248418,
-0.0833629593,
-0.0250991303,
-0.0059806178,
-0.0259269159,
-0.0007355133,
0.0226134174,
0.0299961381,
-0.0587585717,
-0.044679556,
0.0481498241,
0.0165794101,
0.0312102903,
0.0318245031,
0.0504613593,
0.0242838115,
-0.0476608872,
-0.0035125201,
0.0287555754,
0.0848864615,
-0.0092397984,
-0.0011062702,
-0.0203672852,
-0.0290877372,
-0.0708524883,
0.0561170503,
-0.0268460847,
-0.012995299,
0.004797,
-0.0717031807,
0.0289109889,
0.0559171773,
-0.0041576619,
-0.007194615,
-0.020136958,
-0.0294707175,
-0.0789911672,
0.0298467856,
-0.0172496475,
-0.0453894883,
0.0061988691,
-0.0050375969,
-0.0331873149,
-0.0179926436,
-0.0084471274,
-0.0163743496,
-0.0382731706,
0.0326294899,
0.0675061196,
-0.0122788828,
-0.0816521496,
0.01188247,
0.0325239338,
0.0257553719,
-0.0627114177,
-0.0340079516,
0.0561889298,
-0.0004803603,
-0.0247527193,
0.0379416235,
0.0083936332,
-0.0265121851,
0.1009613499,
0.0035378239,
0.0134297181,
-0.0122432318,
-0.0112942997,
-0.0648002923,
-0.0283290744,
0.0265324861,
-0.0358501337,
0.0799648687,
-0.0143889282,
0.0460423678,
-0.0440441966,
-0.0468543693,
-0.022374792,
-0.0422157049,
0.004510799,
0.0024682761,
-0.0509577952,
0.0051513999,
-0.0277140848,
0.049036704,
0.0404996499,
-0.0146379191,
-0.0136597706,
-0.0217509978,
-0.0070689889,
0.0959336087,
0.0830609277,
0.0528945699,
-0.044116322,
-0.0126105947,
0.0038710719,
0.0658542439,
0.0049432227,
-0.0360169932,
-0.0123009887,
0.0158757642,
0.0293363687,
0.0457399301,
-0.002137647,
0.0245528594,
0.045803424,
-0.0571379028,
-0.0353190899,
0.0476286896,
-0.0008078507,
-0.0132784033,
-0.0497380085,
-0.0170838013,
0.0366234593,
0.0386507325,
0.0624521263,
-0.0777961388,
-0.0393073745,
-0.0301400255,
0.0109528098,
0.0333359502,
0.0096051712,
-0.0053118956,
-0.0674738958,
0.0394211449,
-0.0160468705,
-0.0004107727,
-0.0496391915,
0.0019909635,
-0.0047497386,
0.0087161371,
-0.0191687886,
-0.0030353088,
-0.0078526353,
0.0023059649,
-0.0216821339,
0.0672158152,
0.0163702667,
0.0273556784,
-0.0466621444,
-0.0337711051,
0.0304682776,
0.0045978543,
-0.0283535346,
-0.0565800108,
-0.0156228198,
-0.0324183144,
0.0169760082,
0.0252688862,
0.0430281833,
-0.0282669719,
-0.0374810509,
-0.0150959082,
-0.0088232933,
0.0185028911,
-0.0182581674,
-0.0339643024,
0.0402303673,
-0.006621039,
0.0106792822,
-0.0452270396,
0.0016511907,
-0.0118832579,
0.0126565369,
0.0055165673,
-0.0038644816,
-0.0387407467,
0.0019478878,
0.0211965404,
-0.0245109424,
-0.0303494278,
-0.0055193058,
0.0213027559,
0.0389760882,
-0.0771773234,
-0.0140907997,
0.0336084738,
0.0477687158,
-0.0373758972,
0.006602562,
-0.0288774353,
0.016216388,
-0.0620735958,
0.072415635,
-0.0338854529,
0.0286355428,
-0.0064654769,
0.0366453156,
0.0144235501,
-0.0444990024,
-0.0384433344,
-0.0108013349,
-0.0414854623,
-0.0096738217,
-0.0436594374,
0.0681774542,
0.000794285,
0.0230424106,
0.0266409032,
-0.0349795148,
0.0228182841,
0.0348138623,
-0.0165649224,
0.0065149106,
-0.0274026245,
-0.0386328883,
-0.019592464,
0.0020050092,
-0.093880415,
-0.0153449383,
-0.006476915,
0.0489929728,
0.0090414584,
-0.0752341822,
0.0135565847,
0.0233397242,
0.0236392766,
0.0459065586,
0.0212228,
-0.0311540253,
0.0044896887,
0.0128552951,
-0.028424643,
-0.0666426197,
-0.0011840593,
-0.0031538426,
-0.0226664878,
0.0083631864,
0.0218283832,
0.0356561989,
0.0689770281,
-0.0488383248,
-0.0174127948,
0.0340138301,
-0.0060297078,
0.0147851026,
0.0142031526,
-0.0216202252,
0.0180632304,
-0.0110951113,
0.0523880087,
-0.0380972624,
0.0804832205,
0.0385883413,
-0.0263386406,
-0.0646966994,
0.0403597467,
-0.0491753221,
-0.0246160533,
-0.0392496586,
0.010850329,
0.0223293267,
0.0073076016,
-0.0236117821,
0.033204753,
-0.0377380736,
-0.0147914579,
0.0125510721,
-0.0112906937,
-0.0436890759,
0.0822653472,
0.0521469191,
0.0106488736,
0.0224480387,
0.0403840579,
-0.0298321582,
0.0316298306,
-0.0334158055,
-0.0296543185,
-0.0196273234,
-0.0218665339,
0.0514362827,
0.0316250138,
-0.0049212007,
0.0260125846,
-0.0105493553,
-0.0525022484,
0.0157451332,
0.0230592228,
-0.0670678243,
0.0220114738,
0.0324315764,
0.0582522079,
0.0630830377,
-0.0419603065,
-0.0231773034,
0.0123191401,
-0.041495394,
-0.0071742563,
-0.0098374952,
-5.928989998e-33,
-0.046024926,
-0.0096143372,
0.0384814925,
-0.0360699184,
-0.0530491211,
0.0069121453,
-0.0074555399,
0.000583709,
-0.0691572279,
-0.0041523981,
0.016909007,
-0.0302955881,
-0.0177417044,
0.0396564491,
-0.0138747031,
-0.0047600409,
0.0116537362,
0.0014496904,
0.0049349931,
0.0168384574,
0.0274625681,
0.0248480793,
0.0207011197,
-0.0173924509,
-0.0072975163,
-0.0154573983,
-0.0113060428,
0.0313380696,
0.008249783,
0.0572539419,
-0.0262429193,
-0.0016550069,
0.0299560707,
0.0091491248,
-0.0025550716,
0.0153740533,
-0.1052480042,
-0.0069179968,
0.0156168062,
-0.0058487328,
-0.0664114133,
0.0263247844,
0.024215728,
-0.0524685271,
0.0587855838,
-0.0506253429,
0.0529151931,
-0.0025329266,
-0.013515451,
-0.0117105218,
-0.0085409125,
-0.0041046925,
-0.0171966795,
-0.0347481407,
-0.003533758,
0.0552064143,
0.0667525828,
0.0413140319,
-0.0442392454,
-0.0116799492,
-0.0488976687,
0.0172965657,
0.0213958211,
0.0529638939,
-0.0092214532,
0.0424081795,
0.0067941681,
-0.056981381,
-0.0507685877,
-0.0345975757,
0.0220383648,
0.0521134473,
0.0426248014,
0.0790369287,
0.0048723989,
0.0295801442,
-0.0650444478,
0.0221912619,
-0.0605019219,
0.0903735086,
-0.0161830038,
0.0301553383,
-0.0084076729,
-0.0124510797,
-0.0631461591,
0.0367122181,
-0.0710494891,
-0.0006169021,
0.0647094324,
0.054424461,
0.0230191443,
0.0365386717,
0.0816297382,
-0.0449834578,
0.0231302083,
0.0516856462,
-0.042153988,
0.028062053,
0.0034835134,
0.034657307,
-0.0099138152,
0.0076600527,
0.0717358887,
-0.0619171225,
-0.0409984104,
0.0121444874,
0.0295556579,
0.0217098538,
-0.0471797399,
-0.0101517234,
-0.0320048444,
-0.0219056271,
-0.0326652117,
0.0251512323,
0.0070373304,
0.0183759965,
-0.0417428538,
0.0247527994,
-0.0106891785,
0.027725039,
-0.0195588507,
-0.066920273,
0.0252622999,
0.0062241466,
0.0016891349,
0.0415069014,
-0.0407805182,
-0.0353209674,
-0.0127355941,
-0.02750808,
-0.013696935,
0.0752819031,
2.5e-7,
0.044325728,
-0.0079914071,
0.0247665066,
0.0210531671,
-0.0185034666,
0.0487290397,
-0.0202538818,
0.037654765,
0.0443646871,
-0.0301667657,
0.0114558525,
0.049108997,
0.0071350597,
-0.0068961349,
-0.0108243693,
0.0436018407,
-0.0288201664,
-0.0518135726,
-0.0244056545,
-0.0374201536,
0.0728639439,
0.0705246925,
-0.0164746735,
-0.0026665982,
0.0221595429,
-0.0945471227,
0.1102668494,
0.0116505204,
-0.0144154839,
-0.0110963527,
0.002764584,
0.0391496345,
-0.0061449409,
-0.0013499361,
0.0127251726,
0.01667119,
0.0515022315,
0.0304471329,
-0.0190722719,
-0.0465096869,
-0.042765107,
0.020881379,
0.0006665458,
-0.0429497622,
0.0924043208,
-0.0504646078,
-0.0054754531,
-0.0066557927,
-0.0508498587,
-0.0058850567,
0.0061771832,
0.0102916826,
-0.0405464768,
0.0124639068,
0.0539138354,
-0.0185315553,
-0.0141074937,
-0.11355111,
-0.0018732434,
0.0191767458,
-0.0454289727,
0.0030292624,
-0.0392474644,
-0.0212260149,
0.0169731006,
-0.0319754034,
-0.0603955165,
1.777478094e-34,
0.0228237677,
-0.0099437609,
0.0051966398,
0.0079746414,
0.0295323338,
-0.0158134568,
-0.009119764,
-0.0153366253,
0.0119640855,
-0.1119930372,
-0.0105474973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17122v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.17122v1 | Benchmarking the Abilities of Large Language Models for RDF Knowledge Graph Creation and Comprehension: How Well Do LLMs Speak Turtle? | 2023-09-29T10:36:04 | 2023-09-29T10:36:04 | Johannes Frey, Lars-Peter Meyer, Natanael Arndt, Felix Brei, Kirill Bulert | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DB | Large Language Models (LLMs) are advancing at a rapid pace, with significant
improvements at natural language processing and coding tasks. Yet, their
ability to work with formal languages representing data, specifically within
the realm of knowledge graph engineering, remains under-investigated. To
evaluate the proficiency of various LLMs, we created a set of five tasks that
probe their ability to parse, understand, analyze, and create knowledge graphs
serialized in Turtle syntax. These tasks, each embodying distinct degrees of
complexity and being able to scale with the size of the problem, have been
integrated into our automated evaluation system, the LLM-KG-Bench. The
evaluation encompassed four commercially available LLMs - GPT-3.5, GPT-4,
Claude 1.3, and Claude 2.0, as well as two freely accessible offline models,
GPT4All Vicuna and GPT4All Falcon 13B. This analysis offers an in-depth
understanding of the strengths and shortcomings of LLMs in relation to their
application within RDF knowledge graph engineering workflows utilizing Turtle
representation. While our findings show that the latest commercial models
outperform their forerunners in terms of proficiency with the Turtle language,
they also reveal an apparent weakness. These models fall short when it comes to
adhering strictly to the output formatting constraints, a crucial requirement
in this context. | [
0.0503278263,
0.0452461392,
-0.017567819,
0.0492987931,
-0.0371472724,
0.0081914039,
-0.0742962584,
0.0223670248,
-0.0042447578,
-0.0788140371,
-0.0156080788,
0.0474262238,
-0.0278652944,
0.0574393049,
-0.0303111393,
-0.0432743803,
0.0090062926,
-0.0268332716,
-0.0046542888,
0.0179098994,
-0.0111235995,
0.0206430089,
0.0127698854,
0.0101010716,
-0.0052340371,
-0.0176728535,
-0.0176191777,
0.0036766615,
-0.030348707,
-0.0428758822,
-0.0407514572,
0.063670285,
-0.0069503924,
0.0659384057,
0.0000021789,
-0.0351939127,
-0.0192978252,
0.0506269895,
-0.0368156768,
0.0017575439,
-0.0009590066,
-0.0303168464,
0.0166832376,
0.017380977,
-0.0054215887,
-0.0617763251,
0.0322035737,
0.0234643891,
0.0493686348,
0.0449850336,
-0.0263036229,
-0.0185386799,
0.018785052,
-0.0033334389,
0.0269775726,
-0.0192961227,
0.0117015969,
0.0467760563,
0.035647396,
0.0182761606,
0.0131336087,
-0.0030838142,
0.0039855419,
-0.0348225608,
0.0228411015,
0.0026294712,
-0.0121446466,
-0.0192217398,
-0.0206714459,
0.0770913735,
0.0484444946,
0.0395809673,
-0.0044234283,
0.0336425379,
-0.0295792837,
0.029905254,
-0.0408831425,
0.0155209173,
-0.0268234517,
-0.0200021192,
-0.0364543274,
-0.0427409075,
0.0351448767,
-0.012480922,
-0.0511059761,
0.1004529595,
0.0053441869,
-0.0185278133,
-0.0066626994,
-0.0313593969,
0.0179748926,
-0.0512914136,
0.0167361312,
0.0289164558,
-0.0466152281,
0.0396309011,
0.0097726816,
0.0414978452,
0.0593635999,
-0.0129051888,
0.0093279975,
0.0195333585,
0.0000681553,
0.061665006,
0.0114959693,
0.0356091335,
-0.0081062354,
0.0037405607,
-0.0156388264,
-0.0217515957,
-0.1087397411,
-0.000677922,
-0.0285199322,
-0.0020742049,
-0.0229864884,
-0.0173598547,
0.001201189,
0.0693404153,
-0.0075633819,
0.0805019066,
0.0658775494,
-0.0376558527,
0.0228929371,
0.0185530372,
-0.0633390024,
0.017976366,
-0.000535476,
-0.0395749025,
-0.0047177779,
-0.0259898957,
0.0244672112,
0.003370564,
0.010211397,
-0.0411336534,
-0.0110841617,
0.1151786149,
0.0533718355,
0.0231712274,
0.0266677253,
-0.0890862942,
-0.0026970797,
-0.0285715181,
0.0355043672,
-0.079490006,
0.0432142206,
0.0550003797,
0.0214942228,
-0.0455730595,
0.0097298268,
0.0067238826,
-0.0474586375,
0.0506821796,
-0.0839347094,
0.0542390496,
-0.0169959012,
0.0046522287,
-0.0358735509,
0.0558376946,
0.0208911188,
0.0025539002,
0.0328444727,
-0.0369609483,
-0.0508223139,
0.0247263126,
-0.004692608,
0.0133497426,
-0.0176050905,
0.0598447658,
0.0063494146,
0.0524958298,
-0.0027199858,
0.0471482947,
-0.0059696212,
-0.0011248949,
0.0357816219,
0.0031974148,
0.036254175,
0.0112142982,
0.0257340316,
0.0393453315,
0.0172830727,
-0.0243167933,
-0.0494120158,
0.0015759491,
-0.0172388665,
0.0188799836,
-0.0371753722,
-0.0048137088,
-0.0015512342,
-0.0210085139,
-0.031846974,
0.0209888946,
0.0036027117,
-0.018783588,
0.042494148,
0.0127758011,
-0.0171990413,
0.0341423713,
0.0183447134,
-0.0338453874,
-0.0022985034,
-0.0064706611,
-0.021798389,
0.090418309,
0.0660649389,
-0.0505101159,
-0.0651061758,
0.0065017086,
-0.0000065845,
0.0478905886,
0.0377586372,
-0.01691816,
-0.0459244065,
-0.021416815,
-0.0596574247,
0.0151338158,
-0.0064654374,
-0.0204321854,
0.0314195119,
0.0073503042,
0.0082040047,
-0.1266775578,
-0.0197310913,
0.0272568017,
0.0394343473,
0.0326766595,
-0.0477789566,
0.0017434525,
0.0201842431,
0.0447231308,
-0.0095532211,
0.0367135443,
0.0466300957,
-0.0146000348,
-0.0166632142,
0.0050950036,
0.0198808648,
-0.027977718,
0.0614809357,
-0.00526398,
-0.0216014292,
0.0046204394,
-0.0367954448,
-0.0254956651,
-0.0076734787,
0.0134937074,
0.0455327369,
0.0169250481,
0.0112615321,
-0.0018647219,
-0.0652741641,
-0.0090472326,
0.0468788035,
0.0049355491,
0.0216726903,
-0.0184898265,
-0.0733886883,
0.026785003,
-0.0417212285,
-0.0017184441,
0.013313177,
-0.0035103068,
0.0222159661,
0.0030683612,
0.0312380977,
-0.0562143996,
-0.0228576381,
-0.0177655593,
0.0130746597,
0.0109361717,
0.0483529568,
-0.0154825207,
-0.0009141619,
0.0010825465,
0.0079855658,
-0.0387485698,
0.0327017903,
-0.00798955,
0.0367295519,
0.0327345319,
-0.001728716,
-0.0431377068,
0.0024194757,
-0.0312163606,
-0.0176846031,
0.0578974597,
0.0095536103,
-0.002258894,
0.0004306292,
0.0450275578,
-0.0759928003,
-0.0328513123,
0.0279439166,
0.0151989656,
0.0230085049,
-0.0257255621,
0.024427589,
-0.0394428223,
-0.0357862227,
0.0393534973,
0.0396844782,
-0.0056433207,
-0.0336353928,
-0.0203653146,
-0.0069879624,
-0.0110629722,
-0.0569952503,
-0.0289890915,
0.0073930067,
0.0187344477,
-0.0459263772,
0.0138634974,
-0.0193969812,
0.0186408795,
-0.0075135943,
0.0233737268,
-0.0549463704,
-0.0123513741,
0.0595564805,
0.0545966886,
-0.0407976285,
-0.0122294379,
0.0529662594,
-0.032085456,
0.0359403715,
0.0085220374,
0.0157877821,
-0.0719863102,
0.1339879334,
0.0435256027,
0.0283557139,
-0.0189341903,
-0.0351734459,
-0.0046930909,
0.0028113339,
0.0364505574,
-0.0327593088,
-0.0071555022,
0.0167033225,
0.0033209843,
-0.0155705586,
0.0145378681,
-0.0156970751,
0.0328468867,
-0.0420782045,
0.0490937978,
0.025301652,
-0.026321033,
0.0154875312,
0.0261648763,
-0.0059897238,
-0.0126353214,
0.0342493169,
-0.0326980278,
-0.0333751217,
0.0235519744,
0.0120850829,
-0.0324562043,
0.0091834813,
-0.0019789136,
0.0658152774,
0.0588580929,
0.0160585232,
-0.0577721596,
-0.0208343547,
-0.0038665072,
-0.0136817275,
-0.0573055558,
-0.0074940883,
0.0031396763,
-0.0071873637,
-0.0614458136,
-0.0135525987,
0.0962745622,
0.0495320335,
-0.0294276848,
0.0260280743,
-0.0061916662,
0.0437365845,
0.0322279334,
0.0195985548,
-0.1192664355,
0.0031856908,
-0.0012372062,
0.0159010515,
0.0519118719,
-0.0733535662,
0.0109482761,
-0.1057993621,
0.0616396405,
-0.0080981962,
-0.0643127635,
-0.0069105355,
-0.0720566437,
-0.0191245731,
0.013917557,
0.0011010807,
0.0367340967,
-0.0280608051,
-0.0116675673,
-0.0066393502,
-0.0400223546,
-0.0280644204,
0.0494273119,
-0.0450589508,
0.042432677,
-0.0165907517,
0.0478013605,
0.0004075963,
0.0093929283,
0.0013407037,
0.062927179,
0.0099399118,
-0.0534517206,
0.0174260475,
0.0323975794,
-0.0279455874,
-0.0290676989,
-0.0306745674,
-0.0859300941,
0.006585143,
0.0301754773,
0.1184216812,
-0.0357741006,
-0.0036146692,
-0.0257768445,
-0.0542074107,
0.0070248842,
0.0839214176,
0.0278615095,
0.0301922783,
-0.051413957,
-0.040896751,
-0.0022991435,
-0.0421976149,
0.006276119,
0.0493249483,
-0.0180926789,
-0.0388147123,
-0.0512108207,
-0.0261867307,
0.0689089373,
-0.0024081566,
0.0090996157,
-0.0072691087,
0.035885971,
0.0085895751,
-0.0713915452,
0.0031561235,
-0.0488552898,
0.0106651075,
-0.03264644,
-0.0032579866,
-0.0017902425,
-0.0139854373,
-0.0116954418,
-0.0313614048,
-0.0112048415,
-0.0233286843,
-0.0032370405,
0.0218862481,
0.0278431457,
0.015115995,
0.0180613361,
-0.0055841114,
-0.0446374752,
0.0402257703,
-0.0479449071,
-0.0460052863,
0.0124062961,
0.0178873092,
0.0079192044,
0.0332775675,
-0.0764640272,
0.0140516115,
-0.0503644012,
0.0704574585,
-0.0455067344,
-0.0697467923,
0.0519926585,
0.0918011814,
-0.0345035754,
0.0367529094,
0.0095573841,
0.0019238907,
0.0039004455,
-0.0763040856,
-0.0240717661,
-0.0304392036,
-0.0083312122,
-0.0067222742,
-0.0173741858,
0.0294245128,
-0.0022511703,
0.0164364073,
0.0429051034,
-0.0489818491,
0.0287052356,
0.0406746157,
-0.030840138,
0.0430456884,
-0.0238615852,
-0.0253945887,
0.0066350061,
-0.0144234328,
-0.0045923549,
-0.0253963321,
0.0225311369,
0.019297801,
-0.0357799344,
-0.0441347882,
-0.0016187353,
-0.01352676,
-0.0545602478,
0.0584214553,
0.0127921999,
0.0587075502,
0.0329336673,
0.0514488779,
-0.0523909554,
-0.0228094645,
-0.0114046894,
0.0191032179,
0.0097741317,
-0.0346639007,
0.0268083028,
0.0284209736,
-0.0103781857,
-0.0273092277,
0.0735316947,
0.0544378385,
0.0431415476,
0.0208639372,
-0.0788331553,
-0.037992768,
-0.0324414857,
-0.0130358925,
0.0316896252,
-0.0191400182,
-0.0287102461,
-0.0477617532,
-0.0755204931,
0.0014374703,
0.0175262447,
-0.0215687491,
-0.0009568171,
0.016902769,
0.025631588,
0.0640160516,
-0.0344070159,
-0.0167700015,
0.0066465326,
-0.0496192649,
-0.0190788079,
0.0276759565,
-6.063632223e-33,
-0.0011085778,
-0.0580135658,
0.0337050855,
0.0283606537,
-0.0169597678,
-0.0084793046,
-0.0549961738,
-0.0271503031,
-0.0243628882,
0.0339454338,
-0.0094385138,
-0.0202832706,
0.0147010572,
0.0031209865,
0.0232294761,
0.0009995789,
0.0379660577,
0.0090886308,
0.0301792938,
-0.0071986862,
0.0426614657,
0.001092873,
-0.0046704202,
-0.0366949923,
0.0364126898,
-0.0125228334,
-0.0111110341,
0.0540376157,
-0.0042167273,
0.0605246052,
-0.0121957315,
0.0482796878,
0.0220212415,
0.0092049176,
-0.0125025036,
-0.0513149761,
-0.1046163142,
-0.0257097147,
-0.0103032803,
0.0048707761,
-0.0493624024,
0.0121717108,
0.0433649831,
0.0061154035,
0.0269209892,
-0.0329492688,
0.0001206868,
-0.0193675384,
-0.065474622,
-0.0259978324,
-0.0432558246,
0.025976019,
0.0152581045,
-0.0098282415,
0.0437883586,
-0.0488254279,
0.0265028775,
-0.0206091702,
-0.079273276,
0.0224340074,
-0.0259348918,
-0.0110216271,
0.0537045747,
0.0007138014,
0.0128893517,
0.026938796,
0.0017318121,
0.041425366,
0.0122144232,
0.0798757151,
-0.0309222098,
0.0882569849,
0.0077955043,
-0.0146141872,
-0.0206629522,
0.001266703,
-0.0662284791,
0.0064654304,
-0.0195303541,
0.0191251747,
-0.0289104711,
0.0233961958,
-0.027121095,
-0.0190626588,
-0.0518894978,
0.026793031,
-0.0470619202,
-0.0157331396,
0.0215915442,
-0.033374656,
-0.0211532339,
0.0007794596,
0.0132936807,
-0.0284329914,
-0.0260497089,
0.0408495478,
-0.0063911257,
0.025283454,
-0.0366542675,
0.0238689315,
-0.0151707614,
-0.041117724,
-0.0039103581,
-0.0257720333,
0.0139015857,
0.0258964505,
0.0199989248,
0.0231097732,
-0.0597654581,
0.0100484863,
-0.0443731137,
-0.0125984438,
-0.0294288658,
0.0038444756,
0.0377571583,
0.018994242,
0.0223408025,
0.0075120698,
0.0577654243,
-0.0196885392,
-0.0121647995,
0.0433307849,
0.0054326374,
-0.0137286773,
0.0060053868,
-0.0314793251,
-0.0233910102,
-0.0272972025,
0.0537235774,
0.0206298325,
-0.0135001773,
-0.0142587516,
2.918e-7,
0.0616804175,
0.0582224503,
0.0485838242,
0.0964728445,
0.0322695076,
-0.009000917,
-0.0011669934,
-0.0185934827,
-0.010176586,
-0.0289293285,
0.0219430346,
0.0398696922,
0.0110101718,
0.0712841377,
-0.0589035302,
-0.0301416405,
-0.0555975698,
-0.0592188425,
-0.0524413064,
0.034029074,
0.0562271364,
0.0199267454,
0.0064526801,
-0.0065066968,
-0.0450622812,
-0.0585996099,
-0.0068785641,
-0.0280176699,
0.0205431711,
0.0406597853,
0.0351624563,
0.020653611,
0.00289824,
0.0494582243,
0.0100862114,
-0.042196881,
-0.0086147608,
0.0399577133,
-0.0390050821,
0.0611436367,
0.0147714252,
-0.0661236718,
0.0200044662,
-0.0523326024,
0.0414923169,
0.0027600983,
-0.0315217748,
0.0203225184,
-0.0361305885,
-0.0505087003,
-0.0299555119,
-0.0217116661,
0.0207191724,
0.0127853556,
-0.0196064375,
0.0105227558,
-0.0115302755,
-0.0260061827,
-0.0131317563,
-0.0016516449,
-0.0171038117,
-0.0278806072,
-0.043752037,
0.0042984081,
0.0186204091,
-0.0161555968,
-0.0166418012,
2.899414213e-34,
0.0209527072,
0.0052722348,
0.0049137552,
0.0061928304,
0.0335831977,
-0.0126948338,
0.0141770644,
0.0069447281,
-0.0161879994,
-0.0706921816,
0.0161369592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17061v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.17061v1 | SCALE: Synergized Collaboration of Asymmetric Language Translation Engines | 2023-09-29T08:46:38 | 2023-09-29T08:46:38 | Xin Cheng, Xun Wang, Tao Ge, Si-Qing Chen, Furu Wei, Dongyan Zhao, Rui Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this paper, we introduce SCALE, a collaborative framework that connects
compact Specialized Translation Models (STMs) and general-purpose Large
Language Models (LLMs) as one unified translation engine. By introducing
translation from STM into the triplet in-context demonstrations, SCALE unlocks
refinement and pivoting ability of LLM, thus mitigating language bias of LLM
and parallel data bias of STM, enhancing LLM speciality without sacrificing
generality, and facilitating continual learning without expensive LLM
fine-tuning. Our comprehensive experiments show that SCALE significantly
outperforms both few-shot LLMs (GPT-4) and specialized models (NLLB) in
challenging low-resource settings. Moreover, in Xhosa to English translation,
SCALE experiences consistent improvement by a 4 BLEURT score without tuning LLM
and surpasses few-shot GPT-4 by 2.5 COMET score and 3.8 BLEURT score when
equipped with a compact model consisting of merely 600M parameters. SCALE could
also effectively exploit the existing language bias of LLMs by using an
English-centric STM as a pivot for translation between any language pairs,
outperforming few-shot GPT-4 by an average of 6 COMET points across eight
translation directions. Furthermore we provide an in-depth analysis of SCALE's
robustness, translation characteristics, and latency costs, providing solid
foundation for future studies exploring the potential synergy between LLMs and
more specialized, task-specific models. | [
0.0182595216,
0.0048698676,
-0.0140049383,
0.0297472253,
-0.044245407,
0.0382851362,
0.0558958352,
0.0014166244,
-0.0428419076,
-0.0077948859,
-0.0641171932,
-0.0514292158,
0.0295429658,
0.0066395993,
0.0313977674,
-0.0612688661,
0.0373169854,
-0.0169911701,
-0.0503406376,
-0.011689486,
-0.0073032626,
0.0293039773,
0.0325842276,
0.0306228381,
0.0212749075,
0.0036692882,
0.0068470719,
0.0637543574,
0.0521462746,
-0.021322405,
-0.0219616629,
0.0349697396,
0.0368447341,
0.0825502798,
0.0000023746,
-0.0435934924,
-0.043636255,
0.0099539431,
0.0208955221,
0.0359144658,
0.056816645,
-0.0481583998,
-0.0097652413,
0.0389466099,
-0.0277515501,
-0.0133939758,
0.0582788028,
-0.0214361418,
0.040336363,
0.0742874369,
-0.0070323898,
-0.0573160835,
-0.0196954329,
-0.0756550655,
-0.0388837159,
-0.0456472673,
-0.0272557512,
0.0170904659,
-0.0437566414,
0.0357853286,
-0.0049338657,
0.0563490316,
0.0300756227,
-0.0045649968,
-0.0099931471,
0.0168214198,
-0.0520931371,
-0.045125518,
-0.0262531862,
0.066388078,
-0.0587637201,
-0.0140305897,
-0.0240407288,
-0.0137642995,
-0.0193977207,
-0.0139966132,
-0.071160771,
0.0189217478,
0.0006428979,
-0.0016471023,
0.0146552231,
0.0122426534,
0.0417687446,
-0.0179569852,
-0.0329373218,
-0.0290715992,
0.0486501902,
-0.001261204,
-0.0350853167,
0.0196402874,
-0.0356788598,
-0.0037384159,
0.0656058267,
-0.0068012653,
-0.0192975067,
0.0194756538,
-0.0154252416,
-0.0568477102,
0.0339966416,
-0.0560550503,
0.0523260571,
0.0589549243,
-0.008977293,
0.0480694696,
-0.0262419097,
0.0578306504,
-0.0190192685,
0.0128197288,
-0.0721386075,
-0.0101138959,
-0.0168798175,
0.0316593386,
-0.0428507328,
-0.0039317431,
-0.0732849166,
-0.0187051855,
-0.0100883516,
0.0243562404,
0.0254499689,
0.0019982606,
0.0791304037,
-0.0172707457,
-0.0884393007,
-0.0450543314,
0.0696830228,
0.0917910933,
-0.026509013,
-0.0268548466,
0.0103145437,
-0.059179455,
-0.0142598404,
0.0085808095,
-0.032773748,
-0.0420702621,
-0.0068503735,
0.0990803689,
-0.0223047547,
-0.0238944888,
0.0009848156,
0.014174494,
-0.011681783,
-0.0794700831,
-0.0364446379,
-0.0678040385,
0.0728213862,
0.0414841659,
0.0299556609,
-0.0238424055,
0.0027195683,
-0.0143079739,
-0.0067352057,
0.0524390414,
0.0138461571,
0.0209644455,
0.0356447808,
0.0274186227,
0.0115644895,
0.1032514423,
0.0282308031,
0.0303718522,
0.0338807181,
0.0038184773,
-0.044709783,
0.0539750308,
0.0022065919,
0.0496545024,
-0.0331365839,
0.0051224013,
0.0416703597,
0.0517660901,
0.0020128503,
0.0525876805,
-0.0252912622,
0.0046775532,
0.0822356418,
0.0209712945,
0.0137274247,
0.0559156723,
0.0284935012,
0.0119405165,
-0.0236273892,
-0.0145120844,
-0.0309370477,
0.0294279307,
0.0099816313,
-0.0116356052,
0.0412934162,
0.0918441415,
-0.0181110259,
-0.0140513703,
-0.0253143124,
-0.0009749237,
-0.0278970115,
-0.0076505169,
0.0387999415,
-0.0005763309,
-0.0409516282,
0.0479250699,
0.0111162076,
-0.062640205,
0.0253000613,
-0.0107363518,
-0.0528442152,
0.0430462733,
0.0543887503,
0.0145245437,
-0.039093826,
0.0027226841,
0.0032261708,
0.070883058,
0.0842024535,
0.0137252016,
0.0154873775,
-0.0672604591,
-0.0302333999,
0.017089026,
-0.0018212242,
0.0279418491,
0.035282813,
0.044585567,
0.0397455618,
-0.0429307297,
-0.0295590702,
0.0203049909,
-0.0250295345,
-0.0040401015,
0.0067987498,
-0.0015963473,
0.0007486372,
0.0265629366,
-0.0139335152,
-0.0234805569,
0.0086175241,
-0.0433952585,
-0.0032874474,
0.0476945899,
-0.0207341518,
-0.0389504768,
0.0224170517,
0.0161454044,
0.0211180095,
0.0126254261,
-0.0394262075,
-0.0560334437,
0.0131443376,
0.0103753079,
0.0150236888,
-0.0230941083,
0.0416919813,
0.0083536413,
0.0126217455,
-0.0506622605,
0.0234910809,
0.0143224373,
-0.0222192425,
-0.0021315848,
-0.0051861228,
0.0058591319,
-0.0192495603,
-0.0183956213,
0.0614125952,
0.0380921289,
0.0143332584,
0.0177844446,
0.0098435581,
-0.0327245854,
-0.030619612,
-0.0761259496,
0.0397763625,
-0.0292359181,
0.0463433638,
0.0645168126,
0.0503297783,
0.0075553032,
0.010145016,
-0.0271571558,
0.0169258639,
0.0014415171,
0.0184887853,
-0.018584922,
0.008703569,
0.0007318828,
-0.0208313465,
-0.012971865,
0.0320570506,
0.0307166837,
0.0252291225,
-0.008500563,
-0.0550825819,
0.0324703269,
-0.0377401561,
-0.0170158427,
0.0113329655,
-0.0608989261,
-0.0056949505,
-0.034457203,
0.0191935487,
0.0279916804,
-0.0076598381,
-0.0226859357,
0.0372893736,
-0.0177413486,
-0.0801804513,
0.0091004837,
-0.0215474404,
-0.0562556274,
-0.0281050522,
-0.0314657427,
-0.0189717449,
0.0388733409,
0.0056428825,
0.0034942245,
-0.070935756,
-0.0131080877,
-0.0067710769,
-0.0027926585,
0.0045059971,
0.0352980755,
0.0021059634,
-0.0008485718,
-0.0384637229,
-0.0442708954,
0.0416900478,
-0.0351696648,
-0.0254397504,
-0.0558033437,
0.0163715109,
-0.0558513217,
0.0585887544,
-0.0405027121,
0.0242227018,
-0.0516397133,
0.0047377255,
-0.0208658259,
0.0318544693,
-0.0106260302,
-0.0153831085,
0.0160340704,
-0.0766386241,
-0.005055082,
-0.04357161,
-0.0248215552,
0.0003500682,
0.0307041816,
-0.0116511881,
0.0073063178,
0.0149972029,
-0.0439035818,
-0.0292641763,
0.0196962263,
0.0162724033,
0.0803976357,
-0.0302173644,
-0.0069951634,
-0.0051478762,
0.0072088293,
-0.0026059225,
0.0082276426,
0.0159468744,
-0.0466341376,
0.0218916759,
0.0345951617,
0.0339612067,
-0.0827240199,
-0.0182875823,
-0.0367555767,
0.0413921922,
-0.010418239,
-0.0347510055,
-0.0231406726,
0.0536615402,
-0.0628222451,
-0.0151624158,
0.1068203524,
0.0082399892,
-0.0686953366,
-0.0075945896,
-0.0133834202,
0.0387585275,
0.0267151147,
0.0097788759,
-0.0846757814,
-0.0256436095,
0.0000737732,
0.030710768,
0.066081509,
0.0076598683,
-0.008005661,
-0.101286985,
0.0358919948,
0.0567905828,
-0.0544424132,
0.0008998454,
-0.0297951046,
-0.0166606735,
-0.0345611721,
0.0412440933,
-0.0059247357,
0.004544836,
0.0084055094,
0.0064927503,
0.0382299572,
-0.0505523644,
0.0045416597,
-0.0508377217,
0.0462195352,
0.0291054212,
0.019809667,
0.0037173915,
-0.0005164309,
0.0425791815,
-0.0013682726,
0.0091092866,
-0.0399818309,
-0.0131138833,
0.0132662104,
-0.0167085323,
0.0337263756,
-0.0149352783,
-0.0405574962,
0.0286388043,
0.0192840565,
0.0559956655,
-0.0224296656,
-0.0054075471,
0.0170445591,
-0.0407771245,
0.0005394112,
0.0609009415,
0.0003593186,
-0.0234553237,
-0.0291651785,
-0.0026186975,
-0.0157727059,
-0.0566830635,
-0.0376266949,
-0.0042147925,
-0.0113329682,
-0.0581861511,
-0.0805747956,
-0.0337252766,
0.0103254728,
0.0621476732,
0.0122254519,
0.0410173498,
-0.0451797508,
0.006038595,
-0.0152650438,
0.0136594968,
-0.0562496148,
0.0122766132,
-0.0727730915,
0.0273824744,
0.0120568583,
-0.0349796526,
0.0155798635,
0.0248667952,
-0.0835111141,
-0.0931779593,
-0.0064355666,
0.0379191972,
0.0251662284,
0.0189821161,
-0.0143831987,
-0.0457630865,
0.0038700129,
0.0268294588,
-0.0288333874,
0.0224274881,
0.0150809893,
-0.008570509,
-0.0230029039,
0.0653055832,
-0.0090126442,
0.0045222994,
-0.0099424431,
0.0907327086,
-0.0141045852,
-0.0696487129,
-0.009041843,
0.0190544762,
0.0491440743,
-0.0464124344,
-0.0198310446,
-0.0101634255,
0.0244457368,
-0.0329763331,
0.0141955074,
-0.0513292477,
-0.0060091475,
0.0474287942,
0.0052169836,
0.0197359379,
0.0343015231,
0.009409735,
-0.0320940278,
-0.0361723192,
0.017380422,
-0.0525580756,
-0.0160976648,
0.0174135361,
0.0339994021,
-0.0162599795,
-0.0064314906,
-0.0015161678,
0.0090799294,
-0.0368942134,
0.0473001078,
0.0118844481,
0.0004491605,
0.0125238523,
0.0581236593,
-0.0296092425,
-0.0427397899,
-0.0344085991,
0.0004723486,
0.0742981955,
0.0447873063,
0.1231546476,
-0.0151824132,
-0.0276301112,
-0.030901935,
0.0284158234,
-0.0104305223,
-0.0217589289,
0.005937764,
-0.0179122165,
-0.0005575416,
0.038340833,
0.064428851,
-0.0240362119,
0.0276588574,
0.0190661252,
0.0041120672,
0.002965678,
-0.0395530462,
0.0039725704,
-0.0232749712,
-0.0236576498,
-0.0264400486,
-0.034572199,
-0.0540781319,
-0.0266354643,
0.0299470164,
-0.0302290693,
-0.0219102073,
0.0015435051,
0.0756462961,
-0.0411647595,
-0.0117420377,
-0.0252106581,
0.0116859572,
0.0011447823,
-0.0009183448,
0.0025150829,
-6.985877704e-33,
-0.0164613705,
0.0208678693,
0.0165595505,
-0.0414338969,
-0.0309583452,
0.006635014,
-0.0316598266,
-0.0009694922,
-0.0145196514,
-0.0107034603,
-0.0087881507,
-0.0027490638,
0.0274266191,
-0.0074912063,
0.0362918526,
0.0342737623,
0.0689140484,
0.0128730107,
-0.0313305594,
0.0442905761,
0.0213831738,
0.0223872103,
0.0970649496,
-0.0729509294,
-0.0022266877,
-0.0165669173,
-0.014716967,
0.0304530282,
0.0008727078,
0.0055328002,
0.0220534671,
0.0178334881,
0.005459819,
-0.0442728102,
-0.0415818095,
-0.0487256907,
-0.0853855386,
0.0065951049,
0.0441732556,
0.0366331078,
0.0107977251,
-0.028317593,
0.0335843377,
-0.0346098542,
-0.0278485417,
-0.0428238437,
-0.0238010604,
-0.0379076786,
-0.0329400487,
-0.0060553532,
-0.0498790629,
0.0207781326,
0.0123397764,
0.009851682,
0.0229837745,
0.0153493946,
-0.0249855649,
-0.0021841512,
-0.0341083072,
-0.0038317034,
-0.0185894351,
0.0402011387,
0.1083793789,
0.0198631622,
-0.0174906254,
0.0102314316,
0.0359046124,
0.0091447243,
0.0281994604,
-0.012960989,
0.0495582931,
0.01376851,
0.0584116988,
0.074047558,
0.0087489635,
-0.0031324159,
-0.0442045033,
0.0454088524,
0.0120886732,
0.004741569,
0.0296909679,
0.0510167889,
-0.0345146433,
-0.0051325425,
-0.015172964,
0.0032828182,
-0.0327522643,
-0.0509285778,
0.0166198201,
0.0252550915,
-0.0252738819,
0.0326079614,
0.0662899688,
-0.0198298655,
0.0110949436,
0.0359301493,
-0.0143307904,
0.0108119119,
-0.0321137644,
0.039796982,
-0.0316178389,
-0.0518408753,
0.004780923,
0.0337203927,
-0.0017317341,
-0.0201696139,
0.0125926035,
0.0198781416,
-0.0449363403,
0.0112173166,
-0.0535394512,
-0.0084787579,
-0.0054883086,
0.0025359981,
0.0279572383,
-0.0203150809,
-0.0167579148,
0.0399257652,
0.0279453043,
-0.0209069941,
-0.0355910696,
0.012246835,
0.0028879109,
0.0182467811,
-0.0505708344,
0.0382264517,
-0.0283414125,
-0.0177351572,
0.0538018346,
-0.0459266976,
-0.0567101166,
0.0042945347,
3.082e-7,
0.0556642823,
0.0697535425,
-0.0015198333,
-0.0005243856,
0.0036454997,
0.0158896763,
-0.0221728645,
0.0402483121,
0.0318064578,
0.0462906249,
0.0244357735,
0.0550784133,
0.075860709,
0.0274539813,
-0.0445867181,
-0.0161498301,
-0.0602697134,
0.0371696949,
-0.0552410744,
-0.0085649462,
0.0088770213,
0.0916599631,
0.0077580069,
-0.0110205729,
-0.0101462286,
-0.0312785693,
0.0651182532,
-0.0508003011,
-0.0048310724,
0.0175710693,
-0.0173731968,
0.0442706384,
-0.0513353683,
-0.0116339,
-0.0164383203,
0.0014690146,
0.0284470785,
0.0866591707,
-0.0199517664,
-0.0038619721,
0.0389170907,
-0.0474297218,
-0.0177837331,
-0.0805760175,
0.0562484898,
-0.0102829253,
0.0096202921,
0.0311055183,
-0.0074967341,
-0.0023906892,
0.0199294426,
-0.038962137,
-0.0159323998,
0.0336440466,
0.030822264,
-0.0168618616,
-0.0310279559,
-0.0449928641,
-0.0562678799,
0.0205372982,
-0.0400553495,
-0.027888542,
-0.045149345,
-0.0115822982,
-0.0422415361,
-0.0117029259,
0.0067032296,
3.007944944e-34,
0.0464390889,
-0.0124408687,
0.0123027153,
-0.0132630626,
0.0181285515,
-0.0340152532,
-0.0115140546,
0.0057114828,
-0.0106960256,
-0.0529844426,
-0.0337839909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17050v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.17050v1 | Interpretable Long-Form Legal Question Answering with Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models | 2023-09-29T08:23:19 | 2023-09-29T08:23:19 | Antoine Louis, Gijs van Dijck, Gerasimos Spanakis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many individuals are likely to face a legal dispute at some point in their
lives, but their lack of understanding of how to navigate these complex issues
often renders them vulnerable. The advancement of natural language processing
opens new avenues for bridging this legal literacy gap through the development
of automated legal aid systems. However, existing legal question answering
(LQA) approaches often suffer from a narrow scope, being either confined to
specific legal domains or limited to brief, uninformative responses. In this
work, we propose an end-to-end methodology designed to generate long-form
answers to any statutory law questions, utilizing a "retrieve-then-read"
pipeline. To support this approach, we introduce and release the Long-form
Legal Question Answering (LLeQA) dataset, comprising 1,868 expert-annotated
legal questions in the French language, complete with detailed answers rooted
in pertinent legal provisions. Our experimental results demonstrate promising
performance on automatic evaluation metrics, but a qualitative analysis
uncovers areas for refinement. As one of the only comprehensive,
expert-annotated long-form LQA dataset, LLeQA has the potential to not only
accelerate research towards resolving a significant real-world issue, but also
act as a rigorous benchmark for evaluating NLP models in specialized domains.
We publicly release our code, data, and models. | [
0.0634322464,
0.0665279999,
0.0021061106,
0.0501195528,
-0.0540082119,
0.0117737884,
0.0148124788,
0.0095387744,
0.0306203831,
-0.0892344117,
0.0079190135,
-0.0262448564,
-0.0520247631,
0.0259247757,
0.0004804308,
-0.0134116961,
0.0056193015,
-0.0026722776,
0.0609212779,
-0.0046740118,
0.0315225981,
0.0402859524,
0.0071533914,
0.0217304602,
-0.0013238351,
-0.0075553991,
0.000594805,
-0.0011057855,
-0.01492693,
0.0090545155,
0.0105518773,
0.0812348425,
0.0262318142,
0.0097359056,
0.0000017323,
-0.0594736934,
0.004161472,
0.0127674891,
-0.0290952735,
0.0150084998,
0.0250168741,
-0.0474972725,
0.012331781,
0.0041048317,
-0.0433584936,
0.0219030846,
-0.0134027246,
0.0184781365,
0.0654429048,
0.080414623,
0.0107618552,
-0.062935777,
0.0605297312,
-0.0385665931,
0.0121726394,
-0.0509912409,
0.0171344057,
0.0356753469,
0.0296323076,
-0.0066685355,
0.0087066581,
0.0279448498,
0.0343472809,
-0.0392083302,
-0.0122514004,
-0.024065027,
-0.02435931,
0.0092997942,
0.0035001244,
0.0699926391,
0.0533849709,
-0.0186986718,
-0.0021174054,
0.0058733113,
0.0317846425,
0.0354375765,
-0.0320998095,
0.0722639337,
0.0141453501,
-0.006334356,
0.0142260203,
0.0195434969,
-0.0088735037,
0.0133347763,
-0.0225885976,
0.0344884917,
-0.0054847836,
-0.0371232182,
0.0138810249,
0.010055705,
0.000066955,
-0.0582180396,
0.0388383865,
0.0609670915,
-0.0063151359,
0.0265574511,
0.0009829786,
-0.0305073094,
0.0844115019,
-0.0540176071,
0.0102143856,
0.0070655681,
-0.0345186032,
0.0813310966,
-0.056136895,
0.0187623706,
-0.0090739504,
-0.0235644579,
-0.0138262575,
-0.0576332733,
-0.055532489,
-0.0325848162,
-0.0268899575,
0.031603761,
-0.1084557101,
0.0020248247,
0.0199333783,
-0.0102948472,
-0.0104314117,
0.0085863657,
0.0196755026,
0.0165327024,
-0.0076508615,
-0.0313127451,
-0.0689656511,
-0.0029867627,
-0.0666357651,
0.0419470184,
0.0068193274,
-0.0474499092,
0.0061409241,
-0.0180324242,
0.0008927773,
-0.0079106903,
0.0158114713,
0.0903030634,
-0.0326423347,
-0.019822685,
-0.0079552811,
-0.0807390139,
-0.0319370329,
-0.0697635338,
-0.0359903425,
-0.080731824,
0.0385034867,
0.0022238081,
-0.0334335379,
-0.0662932992,
0.0252555106,
0.0569301397,
-0.0226478036,
0.0401613489,
0.0187387541,
-0.0087688286,
0.0002682249,
0.0259243809,
0.0345423147,
0.0202237107,
0.0165476184,
-0.011478222,
0.0440247543,
-0.0129466504,
0.0170227848,
0.0338843241,
0.0289064553,
0.0161845647,
0.0140192043,
0.0503308959,
-0.0357934646,
0.0306503233,
0.0446174517,
0.0388241671,
0.0106904032,
-0.045598302,
0.0015043727,
0.07277859,
0.0116169723,
0.0490266383,
0.0144124916,
0.0206197146,
0.0231970772,
-0.0229866095,
-0.053000953,
0.0311562382,
-0.0298517887,
0.0104199359,
-0.0471686013,
0.0110289687,
-0.0128742987,
-0.041240897,
0.0122458981,
0.0126797119,
-0.000112311,
0.0232244674,
0.0353515744,
0.0317657441,
-0.016860269,
0.0378772691,
-0.0016417919,
-0.0614448413,
-0.014128725,
-0.0122737652,
0.0215141624,
0.050648082,
0.0348200761,
-0.0149374325,
-0.0144695509,
-0.0327661186,
-0.0007585194,
0.0439494066,
0.0021623636,
-0.0054894793,
0.0074587697,
-0.022324549,
-0.0317121036,
0.0022594125,
0.015671907,
-0.0043012435,
0.0193057843,
0.0065480415,
0.0475246869,
-0.0585268885,
-0.0179263428,
0.0279675331,
-0.0407311693,
-0.0543897189,
0.0069216206,
-0.0049066665,
0.0107026026,
0.0399694331,
-0.0057657268,
0.0062640673,
0.0474425107,
-0.0306902379,
-0.013091539,
-0.0151286349,
0.0053876583,
-0.0150335338,
0.0308856815,
-0.0297101494,
-0.0222629048,
0.0188517869,
-0.0471789241,
-0.0153971286,
-0.0431167372,
-0.026206946,
-0.0242910553,
-0.0680048913,
-0.0440741368,
0.0326882452,
-0.0276938137,
-0.0496131554,
0.0677397773,
0.006455353,
0.0121899797,
0.0025032735,
-0.002790811,
0.0283516422,
-0.0458970144,
-0.0184606221,
-0.0364916921,
-0.0170052368,
0.0172842909,
0.0420805328,
0.0091123907,
-0.05249938,
-0.0299337935,
-0.0734554008,
0.0147556551,
-0.0265321601,
0.024104083,
0.0171885286,
-0.0243716277,
0.0008589323,
-0.0286984015,
-0.0554805361,
-0.0266981851,
0.0314474143,
-0.0059398138,
0.0206250213,
0.0029111484,
-0.0216429662,
-0.0170869343,
-0.0311140791,
-0.0067694075,
0.0553228594,
0.0209906623,
-0.0009172795,
-0.0159523264,
0.0347830541,
-0.0031100791,
-0.0020664989,
-0.018626852,
-0.006496402,
-0.0351910405,
0.0069587235,
-0.0366352871,
0.0468111858,
0.0518122204,
0.0099334242,
-0.0222301017,
0.0134350853,
-0.0763312802,
-0.0052098124,
-0.0112907821,
-0.0283163264,
-0.0509491377,
-0.0366330147,
0.017025888,
0.0154196285,
-0.0008720576,
-0.0047080028,
0.0021489135,
0.0187752824,
0.0042592823,
-0.0233119,
-0.0500610918,
0.0082929824,
-0.0066815079,
0.0543061756,
0.011681308,
-0.0382663459,
0.0566474348,
0.0086051868,
0.0282687116,
-0.0342605673,
-0.0072878515,
-0.0707524419,
0.1191976145,
-0.012671574,
0.0221632477,
-0.0470254458,
-0.0428875983,
0.0138027752,
-0.0198367927,
0.0336233713,
-0.0592287183,
0.0952922329,
-0.025417516,
0.0530565679,
-0.0285636541,
-0.0535148457,
-0.0264851376,
-0.0593556426,
-0.0172871631,
0.0256944727,
0.0002477971,
0.0113795148,
-0.0186586548,
-0.0252896156,
0.0184515268,
-0.0056638718,
0.0032050582,
-0.0159153007,
-0.0353751667,
0.0700171217,
0.0227240678,
0.0175446011,
-0.0008463435,
-0.0054277182,
0.0060377065,
0.044697538,
-0.0173910931,
0.0188049395,
0.007887423,
-0.0049260366,
0.0095045408,
-0.0602267906,
-0.0009923298,
0.0183460098,
0.0372241288,
-0.0931655616,
-0.0010558242,
0.0871174857,
0.0310175661,
0.0019776796,
-0.0132256653,
-0.013618974,
0.0191255976,
0.0296056271,
0.0376751274,
-0.1027415618,
-0.0248836521,
-0.0223737936,
0.0211255662,
-0.0248196665,
-0.0115767634,
0.0013986535,
-0.1001204774,
0.0803350508,
-0.0158744026,
-0.0177560505,
-0.0438041985,
-0.00610111,
-0.0073448666,
-0.0091915959,
0.0227884147,
0.0228631273,
-0.0366639011,
0.0049063433,
0.0072388211,
-0.0294565689,
0.0187760592,
0.0564154573,
-0.0341306105,
0.0579376556,
0.0555091947,
0.0301317498,
-0.0262592454,
0.001046151,
-0.0043741972,
-0.032919962,
-0.0036309573,
0.0340782739,
0.0346597806,
0.0186349116,
0.0150112463,
-0.0494448952,
0.0654699057,
-0.0285739638,
-0.0096755046,
0.0711964518,
0.0373084135,
-0.0346796215,
0.0125657171,
-0.0252805967,
-0.0112074353,
0.0055192984,
0.0926883966,
0.019661583,
-0.001441668,
-0.069633916,
-0.0291101784,
-0.0329517461,
-0.0600929782,
-0.0622717701,
0.0006257656,
0.011197607,
0.0343544409,
-0.0450302251,
-0.0477253348,
0.0195319336,
0.032418143,
0.0032020553,
0.0157291926,
0.0237555113,
-0.013643695,
-0.0652957931,
0.0656474754,
-0.0470853448,
0.0018808707,
-0.0239689704,
0.0072688055,
0.0084054181,
-0.0102713816,
-0.040810626,
-0.0050907573,
-0.0300077591,
0.0035582054,
-0.0151608689,
-0.001175876,
0.016593799,
0.0090450058,
-0.0310634691,
-0.0595962107,
0.0408143401,
0.0289202072,
-0.0355160609,
-0.0099783866,
0.0206293035,
0.0048228796,
-0.0303145088,
0.0260956138,
-0.0371849611,
0.0173146911,
-0.0048181573,
0.0558949001,
-0.0048099519,
-0.0367969573,
0.0289463513,
0.048537448,
-0.0104871793,
0.0337782837,
-0.0050324826,
-0.0279021207,
-0.0150509663,
-0.0357726924,
-0.0058400822,
-0.0330196954,
0.0180127863,
0.0334797464,
-0.0397783183,
-0.0190552864,
0.0348034091,
-0.0070017404,
0.0100579327,
-0.0658993796,
0.0377298892,
0.0374644548,
-0.0249135382,
0.0067089205,
-0.0396202318,
-0.0230925027,
0.0347105265,
-0.0296081342,
0.0768482909,
0.0001854884,
0.0581831932,
0.0245642103,
-0.0109667033,
-0.0180046558,
0.0053339154,
-0.0427780747,
-0.0693240166,
-0.012210832,
0.0400950722,
0.0403061286,
-0.0087450473,
0.0047935671,
-0.0142097101,
-0.0077003473,
-0.010506805,
0.0139533244,
0.0105483914,
-0.0337595008,
0.0439815111,
0.0227097999,
-0.0209494717,
0.0146126505,
0.0545956045,
0.0076681403,
0.0116049573,
0.0118921315,
-0.0102024125,
-0.0179095436,
-0.0518907234,
-0.0353986286,
0.0107165128,
-0.0300072189,
-0.0315050557,
-0.0707535073,
-0.0283009876,
-0.0250062011,
-0.0030247981,
-0.0168505181,
0.0223535001,
0.0211667698,
0.0520030148,
0.0293846931,
-0.045586329,
-0.0640440211,
0.0747527778,
-0.0441475138,
-0.0252415352,
-0.0296976808,
-5.726276732e-33,
-0.0068014343,
-0.0721372366,
0.0115262046,
-0.0250114091,
-0.002590759,
-0.0021183782,
-0.0188392904,
-0.0230144896,
-0.0249982271,
0.0350670964,
-0.0040034018,
0.0189419817,
0.007894828,
0.04326047,
0.0113738598,
-0.0422336422,
-0.0131328264,
0.021383103,
-0.0050072535,
0.0264328662,
0.029534243,
0.0314575695,
-0.0115694078,
-0.0813532025,
0.0507219508,
0.0132558513,
0.0193955079,
0.008759791,
-0.0629412234,
0.0781728253,
-0.0107335029,
0.0504640825,
0.033686161,
-0.0730283856,
0.0051090987,
0.0786452889,
-0.1063131839,
0.0315482803,
0.0149314245,
-0.0315346606,
-0.0355723053,
-0.023445515,
0.0456138551,
0.0110167321,
0.0014029921,
-0.0207853448,
0.044786986,
-0.0335468873,
-0.0001657865,
-0.0699731708,
-0.068818368,
0.0381878391,
-0.0291477814,
0.0129693486,
0.0128690572,
0.033230029,
0.0107892528,
0.0535894446,
-0.0613733679,
-0.0404386707,
-0.0250004847,
0.008485822,
0.03912545,
-0.0650007501,
-0.0197009742,
0.0429465882,
-0.0194769409,
-0.022430785,
-0.0659406856,
-0.0194178056,
-0.0000858611,
0.0517639667,
0.0468333922,
0.0653037503,
0.0266449898,
0.0030835851,
-0.0738360509,
-0.0163363218,
0.009048095,
0.0456586517,
0.0202263631,
-0.0363403521,
-0.0294901971,
0.0085454201,
-0.0699837431,
-0.0107158218,
-0.0113219842,
0.0017992817,
0.0457268208,
0.0061755655,
0.0437012389,
-0.0274137538,
0.0126187233,
-0.0317493752,
0.0129869487,
0.0488675311,
-0.0090024779,
0.0105625633,
-0.0017690591,
0.0824439302,
-0.0402116068,
0.0243476294,
0.020904256,
-0.0387521237,
0.0022191587,
-0.0126645649,
0.0373119861,
-0.0525537431,
-0.0547448918,
-0.009857866,
0.0042821397,
0.0551975444,
-0.0119313728,
0.0417004935,
0.0138956755,
0.0330095738,
0.0195577443,
0.0567153096,
0.0094101904,
0.0051676459,
-0.0226826351,
-0.0238327626,
0.0152193708,
-0.0110993683,
-0.0307881627,
0.0461111143,
-0.0136684934,
0.0463510565,
0.0084656952,
0.0132022975,
0.023672916,
0.0617648251,
2.335e-7,
0.1085978821,
0.0202106331,
0.0195458308,
0.0277931094,
-0.008219026,
0.0290648695,
0.0385240354,
0.0479718931,
0.0414546318,
-0.0358112529,
-0.0236545131,
0.0194637366,
0.0436939858,
0.0340427309,
-0.0735412091,
-0.018009156,
-0.0399699919,
-0.0092391837,
-0.070865348,
0.0373005569,
0.0783239082,
0.0826981217,
-0.007395207,
0.0036450173,
-0.0016216061,
-0.0281476602,
0.0525691323,
-0.0281265136,
-0.0229753684,
-0.0034623207,
0.0977423936,
-0.0340444967,
0.0382599384,
0.0258968007,
-0.0098080523,
0.0440685041,
-0.0335723311,
0.0761536211,
0.004399294,
-0.0024549733,
-0.0356175639,
-0.0641958117,
0.0276127886,
-0.0401880555,
0.061205864,
-0.0396973528,
-0.0049530617,
-0.0178772286,
-0.0541339107,
-0.0398654193,
-0.0147233251,
0.0185971651,
-0.0021307161,
-0.0070353667,
0.047651384,
-0.0307862703,
0.0350780971,
-0.080661796,
-0.0023234079,
0.0399172008,
-0.0210687481,
0.0228021629,
-0.0058870604,
-0.0022771244,
0.028493166,
-0.0806839913,
0.0141437864,
1.972333502e-34,
0.0051396145,
0.0226105396,
0.0162133947,
0.037864659,
0.0532136597,
0.0170154609,
-0.0309570134,
-0.001291525,
-0.0155044422,
-0.0896449536,
0.0225097556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17035v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.17035v1 | Contextualising Levels of Language Resourcedness affecting Digital Processing of Text | 2023-09-29T07:48:24 | 2023-09-29T07:48:24 | C. Maria Keet, Langa Khumalo | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Application domains such as digital humanities and tool like chatbots involve
some form of processing natural language, from digitising hardcopies to speech
generation. The language of the content is typically characterised as either a
low resource language (LRL) or high resource language (HRL), also known as
resource-scarce and well-resourced languages, respectively. African languages
have been characterized as resource-scarce languages (Bosch et al. 2007;
Pretorius & Bosch 2003; Keet & Khumalo 2014) and English is by far the most
well-resourced language. Varied language resources are used to develop software
systems for these languages to accomplish a wide range of tasks. In this paper
we argue that the dichotomous typology LRL and HRL for all languages is
problematic. Through a clear understanding of language resources situated in a
society, a matrix is developed that characterizes languages as Very LRL, LRL,
RL, HRL and Very HRL. The characterization is based on the typology of
contextual features for each category, rather than counting tools, and
motivation is provided for each feature and each characterization. The
contextualisation of resourcedness, with a focus on African languages in this
paper, and an increased understanding of where on the scale the language used
in a project is, may assist in, among others, better planning of research and
implementation projects. We thus argue in this paper that the characterization
of language resources within a given scale in a project is an indispensable
component particularly in the context of low-resourced languages. | [
0.0762021691,
-0.0012742054,
-0.062704131,
0.0407529175,
-0.0342283472,
0.0314897634,
0.0303739216,
-0.0099779321,
-0.0251245499,
-0.031892702,
-0.003305326,
-0.013164524,
0.0652877316,
-0.0179653689,
-0.0172461625,
-0.0599079579,
-0.0068411063,
0.0113034248,
-0.0100816842,
0.0213957708,
0.0243252236,
0.0561490692,
0.0277652554,
0.0548973754,
-0.0449153557,
-0.0272371192,
-0.0146564972,
-0.0115488414,
0.0077972407,
0.018149728,
-0.0341320932,
0.026148323,
-0.0124699883,
0.0109397694,
0.0000021049,
-0.0765965059,
-0.0199098065,
-0.0068913694,
-0.0329825766,
0.0431334898,
0.112950325,
-0.0053911861,
-0.0468124747,
-0.0065543074,
-0.0262429658,
0.0409568623,
0.0601125546,
-0.0442727469,
-0.021046171,
0.0031403669,
-0.0051417672,
0.0093753459,
0.0084265238,
0.0408993103,
-0.0126073016,
0.0109141869,
-0.0170561336,
0.0834652111,
0.0928598344,
0.0401720628,
-0.0093611404,
0.0460991934,
0.0310549103,
-0.035162095,
-0.0522959195,
-0.007610864,
-0.0340614282,
-0.0648017004,
0.0205965936,
0.005346172,
0.0560455024,
0.0338099115,
-0.0035883582,
0.0098371236,
-0.0042291703,
0.0018742175,
-0.0334577784,
0.0612107292,
-0.0225077216,
0.0110805174,
0.0243141241,
0.0159225184,
-0.0087604998,
0.0110377632,
0.0184803475,
0.0419255905,
-0.0213515889,
0.016250331,
-0.0293316282,
0.000209604,
0.0425897278,
-0.0228576753,
-0.0016966768,
0.0325723104,
0.0182289276,
0.0208778363,
0.0295043997,
-0.0471355841,
0.0479293838,
-0.032526359,
0.0029389525,
-0.0116288457,
-0.028877439,
0.015804274,
0.0339282677,
0.0360958613,
-0.0229641981,
-0.031610921,
0.0083374148,
-0.0156279039,
-0.0171426944,
-0.0348428078,
-0.0306825619,
-0.0262082312,
-0.0515356399,
0.025608981,
-0.0373658724,
0.0421638452,
0.0127691031,
0.0172888506,
-0.0218469203,
-0.026056638,
-0.035233926,
-0.0219622329,
-0.005070359,
-0.0009733216,
-0.0191769842,
0.0054178159,
-0.0601750091,
-0.1013035029,
0.0973404422,
0.0037288575,
-0.0155348536,
-0.0193542317,
-0.0092488052,
0.0897806659,
0.0072585884,
0.017317012,
-0.0835963264,
-0.0259143561,
0.0072119241,
-0.0406921655,
-0.0356438123,
-0.0827026293,
-0.0481135808,
0.0865666419,
0.0205117073,
0.0070487373,
-0.0138622662,
0.0125332549,
-0.0034908245,
0.036718443,
-0.0460319594,
-0.0014103107,
0.0657511055,
0.0131528853,
0.0254124906,
0.0647566691,
0.0493276566,
-0.0021890763,
0.0487340353,
0.0165557303,
-0.021042902,
0.0290501323,
-0.0677175745,
-0.0143489838,
-0.0108186482,
-0.0075003933,
0.0109534897,
-0.0541618988,
0.0157840811,
0.0362234674,
-0.0040687122,
0.0459496677,
0.0257118139,
0.0763632953,
0.034499567,
0.0467972904,
0.004751646,
0.0199283846,
-0.0227743965,
0.0047210846,
0.0378738604,
0.0181890856,
0.0513505526,
-0.0209312942,
0.0104737515,
0.0506625213,
0.0120386351,
-0.0470797122,
-0.0080295131,
-0.0166070778,
0.0339432508,
-0.015086649,
0.0288417526,
0.0000834012,
0.0104695642,
-0.0129184267,
0.0081711952,
-0.040626891,
-0.0075076092,
-0.017091319,
0.0016102918,
0.0700255185,
-0.0061907885,
-0.0277506858,
0.0761386603,
0.0071322494,
-0.0061680693,
0.0672971979,
0.0183612444,
-0.0167834815,
-0.0033526162,
-0.0317388475,
-0.0019343896,
-0.0275655389,
-0.0209306777,
0.0318720154,
-0.0376657397,
0.0783881098,
0.013903942,
-0.0078531094,
-0.0682675987,
-0.0082532326,
-0.0342133939,
-0.0012383192,
-0.0280300472,
0.0399655178,
0.030379856,
0.0459321737,
-0.0348722786,
0.0117416847,
-0.047700882,
-0.0335785598,
0.0098987017,
0.0321538672,
0.0107736513,
0.0623296611,
0.0178883541,
-0.0362291895,
0.0286673363,
0.0252373256,
0.0593706816,
0.002994803,
0.0827862471,
-0.0334673598,
0.1003886908,
0.0160291158,
0.0305536222,
-0.067199789,
-0.0115350299,
-0.0303660911,
0.0314892419,
0.0195918661,
0.0039430056,
0.0090441238,
-0.00792679,
0.0764723793,
0.00831604,
-0.0224616136,
0.0633215308,
-0.0065283221,
0.0211807098,
0.052229289,
0.0157853179,
-0.0262876637,
0.0145316217,
-0.0900874361,
-0.0474464595,
-0.0121176355,
0.0069187712,
-0.0038867728,
0.0313796736,
0.0029279583,
-0.0130450279,
0.0286929756,
-0.0065933792,
-0.0271860622,
0.021066539,
0.0066015539,
0.0053793183,
-0.0151698254,
-0.0112262201,
0.0102020185,
0.0494427234,
0.0393437259,
0.0551266149,
-0.0219270103,
-0.0228853635,
0.0345493592,
-0.0053799315,
-0.0468506105,
0.0050283386,
-0.0345007479,
0.0341460891,
0.0127680618,
0.0073516089,
-0.0168154985,
-0.0318138972,
0.0403613262,
0.0418471619,
-0.0299799033,
-0.0106894607,
-0.0187410656,
0.0298621356,
-0.0050053815,
0.0272064507,
-0.0591518544,
0.0237551462,
0.0118180597,
0.0300680678,
0.0256353244,
-0.0010682626,
-0.0097951349,
-0.078873992,
-0.0190622453,
-0.0125006186,
-0.0186065603,
-0.0296098553,
0.0803378299,
-0.0165376682,
-0.0454453826,
0.0241767019,
-0.0183251984,
-0.0137246074,
-0.0550962538,
-0.0452676751,
-0.0343836322,
0.0306350552,
-0.050927043,
0.0292771365,
-0.0279746838,
-0.0425367318,
-0.0098002069,
0.0158883333,
0.0813893452,
-0.006905518,
0.0055209524,
-0.0273617357,
0.003345985,
-0.0343398042,
-0.0163145382,
-0.0002032577,
0.047099974,
-0.0219661947,
-0.0008060155,
0.0673266873,
-0.0162499622,
-0.0111115593,
0.0269821137,
0.0662895143,
0.0478383787,
0.0355336256,
-0.0200767852,
0.0151921082,
0.0234243236,
-0.0457420498,
-0.0043261675,
0.0319289938,
0.0232846364,
0.0137557872,
-0.0167568922,
-0.0306275189,
-0.038220048,
-0.0065214876,
-0.0218659882,
0.0248552859,
-0.011830112,
-0.087461628,
0.049331136,
0.0372778624,
-0.0149103282,
0.0133260116,
0.045787245,
0.025081072,
-0.0436298996,
0.0146954712,
-0.0737465099,
-0.0468749478,
0.0232314039,
0.0381070748,
-0.0700722411,
0.0394097418,
-0.0224450622,
-0.0019745387,
-0.045047015,
-0.0069673886,
-0.0262916423,
-0.0373360179,
0.0388646647,
0.0048930091,
-0.0552066825,
-0.0120260492,
0.0068181176,
-0.0277392603,
0.0260868445,
0.0167496651,
-0.0173832197,
-0.0042202985,
-0.0027079282,
0.0351950191,
-0.0594412796,
-0.0303258505,
-0.032087449,
0.0077078464,
0.040902596,
0.0534819104,
0.0307326484,
-0.0197221283,
0.0091180168,
0.014114432,
-0.0028358249,
0.0117369751,
-0.0047693951,
-0.0329736769,
0.0614974275,
-0.0248952042,
-0.0407460332,
-0.038448751,
-0.0192230251,
-0.056800317,
0.0028105276,
0.0574219674,
-0.0189790651,
-0.0025132457,
-0.0332813263,
-0.0432690158,
0.0094212489,
-0.0041893413,
0.0257369876,
-0.0257806927,
-0.0272225775,
-0.0319493562,
0.0031964912,
-0.0177423693,
-0.0579320192,
0.0478687175,
-0.0468272939,
-0.0440019891,
-0.0315335952,
-0.0861606598,
-0.0003796788,
0.0101096304,
0.0118514067,
0.0172444209,
0.0336674936,
0.0046131872,
-0.0539417677,
-0.033414185,
0.0194729194,
0.0169750247,
-0.019526897,
-0.0322380811,
-0.0267396774,
-0.0346080214,
0.0269853342,
-0.0429601669,
-0.0044437051,
-0.0354695916,
0.0188886467,
-0.0166367739,
0.0265709683,
-0.0549526475,
0.0518635474,
-0.0969920531,
0.0057124873,
0.0089936424,
-0.0325575992,
0.023921432,
0.0142879309,
0.0411891192,
-0.0106879016,
0.0128576737,
-0.0383806787,
0.0263768416,
0.0127098421,
-0.0082295043,
-0.083202146,
0.0021581056,
-0.0028554879,
-0.0079654306,
-0.0303690992,
-0.0556844212,
-0.0319711231,
-0.0214429293,
-0.0288369861,
0.0117327441,
-0.0087898588,
-0.0121611021,
-0.0403734222,
-0.0244593415,
0.0214217622,
0.008217467,
0.0023250736,
-0.0279458351,
-0.0020777853,
0.01730684,
0.0902632475,
0.0789964125,
0.0347574614,
0.0119459378,
0.0663307756,
-0.0082653891,
0.0334480926,
-0.0524292365,
0.0401563868,
0.0131554436,
0.0562941581,
-0.0234058201,
-0.0117573263,
0.0254761912,
0.0031408719,
0.0286648013,
-0.0422131829,
0.0142981615,
-0.0054700947,
0.041165147,
-0.0194126982,
0.0329765566,
-0.0158537999,
0.023090696,
-0.0193687268,
0.0216561314,
-0.0137721784,
-0.0565635748,
-0.0405789986,
0.0115097603,
-0.0332958438,
0.0154122803,
0.0599908978,
-0.0272987243,
-0.0285383034,
-0.0074761198,
-0.0397741571,
-0.0086883996,
-0.0151421092,
0.0347802192,
-0.0133188181,
-0.0151309296,
0.0403288342,
-0.1064334884,
-0.0839940682,
-0.0299138185,
-0.0058326996,
-0.0064472617,
-0.0076826597,
0.0042502424,
0.0340376906,
0.0194189157,
-0.0083155939,
-0.0489246957,
0.0177859385,
-0.0882877558,
0.0113091785,
0.0275528077,
-5.54944528e-33,
0.0136359157,
-0.0731991604,
0.0341853462,
-0.0154310595,
0.0337056443,
0.0505415536,
-0.0180050656,
0.0289888419,
-0.0464654677,
0.00354941,
-0.029791005,
-0.0388548635,
0.0089924671,
-0.0059206504,
0.0543397889,
0.0821299776,
0.0047375946,
0.011048479,
0.0006778017,
-0.0024022488,
0.0364267565,
-0.0152311232,
0.0599060282,
-0.0926562548,
0.0532808937,
-0.0381531119,
-0.0044089877,
-0.0212760083,
0.0731392726,
0.0455549955,
-0.0328528658,
0.0405775122,
0.0353126787,
-0.0641338229,
-0.0100790551,
0.060182143,
-0.0221651401,
-0.0486120954,
0.0362566486,
0.0717828795,
0.0195678081,
-0.0559953339,
0.0167998895,
-0.0153681152,
-0.0375802815,
0.0609198138,
0.0397271253,
-0.0245305672,
-0.0149354981,
-0.015077142,
-0.0933097899,
0.0348292366,
-0.0382684134,
0.0397556983,
-0.0078259986,
0.0478467345,
-0.0474329703,
-0.0409827828,
-0.0752867311,
0.022088645,
0.0055656531,
0.0097073419,
0.086022526,
0.0303589292,
-0.0425996259,
0.0102062365,
-0.0058646328,
-0.0041176593,
0.0258679241,
0.0007891248,
0.0279771425,
-0.0170823243,
-0.0045542722,
0.0587109737,
-0.0224368721,
-0.0335407779,
0.009417926,
-0.0081008133,
0.068352215,
0.0158018395,
-0.0176888388,
0.0105915545,
-0.0359176211,
-0.0407340899,
0.0111329053,
-0.0038601614,
-0.0137503706,
-0.050470449,
0.0296030678,
-0.0621924847,
0.0127874222,
0.0196786858,
0.0081650969,
-0.0420667008,
-0.03076539,
0.0112628676,
-0.0205478836,
0.0055174981,
0.0199899524,
0.0143909138,
-0.037417043,
0.0142429937,
-0.021820765,
0.0288055595,
0.0281763896,
0.0138853388,
-0.030434588,
0.0051317811,
-0.0453757644,
0.009276866,
-0.0077327071,
0.0504304096,
0.0150072109,
0.0319848992,
0.0002750754,
-0.046239309,
-0.0022324827,
-0.0291826651,
0.0324267112,
-0.056089066,
0.0093493219,
-0.0067394716,
-0.0582216345,
-0.0471151322,
-0.0817951486,
-0.0293698907,
-0.0399544016,
0.0985458046,
0.0632888079,
0.0093755173,
-0.0058769067,
-0.0043867361,
2.85e-7,
0.0180264432,
0.0066083018,
0.0079240352,
-0.0383827798,
0.0204024967,
0.022653887,
0.0206132382,
0.0111466898,
-0.0397202186,
0.0064033475,
-0.0054239663,
-0.0278962664,
0.0449056514,
0.0652847812,
-0.0593241341,
-0.0453304835,
-0.0230732709,
-0.0009893688,
-0.0679442585,
0.0409970507,
-0.0057819244,
0.0338652804,
-0.0094066216,
-0.0449648984,
-0.0933739766,
-0.0444038287,
-0.0277652983,
-0.0428394377,
0.0448867008,
-0.0167295802,
-0.0127418125,
0.0497982353,
0.0142523693,
0.0094425632,
0.0041575613,
-0.0190593135,
-0.0048761577,
0.0376301333,
-0.0044226199,
0.0340428278,
0.0370888971,
-0.0266642105,
-0.0490887351,
-0.0533774309,
0.0309587847,
0.057886675,
-0.0156494472,
0.0003102271,
0.0151269995,
-0.0059887436,
0.0027481511,
-0.0397157967,
0.0086009987,
0.0192538649,
0.0111975046,
-0.0830480829,
-0.0165322497,
-0.0270623937,
0.0263334233,
0.0275841597,
0.0075733955,
-0.0362804756,
-0.0480336919,
0.0260945074,
0.0497462377,
-0.0078744646,
0.0840644985,
2.239847547e-34,
-0.004644515,
-0.0424689278,
0.0498473756,
0.0237317663,
-0.0060322806,
0.0491111949,
0.0104728406,
0.0310867261,
0.0132100023,
0.0118930554,
-0.0140855368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.01430v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.01430v1 | Sarcasm in Sight and Sound: Benchmarking and Expansion to Improve Multimodal Sarcasm Detection | 2023-09-29T07:00:41 | 2023-09-29T07:00:41 | Swapnil Bhosale, Abhra Chaudhuri, Alex Lee Robert Williams, Divyank Tiwari, Anjan Dutta, Xiatian Zhu, Pushpak Bhattacharyya, Diptesh Kanojia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The introduction of the MUStARD dataset, and its emotion recognition
extension MUStARD++, have identified sarcasm to be a multi-modal phenomenon --
expressed not only in natural language text, but also through manners of speech
(like tonality and intonation) and visual cues (facial expression). With this
work, we aim to perform a rigorous benchmarking of the MUStARD++ dataset by
considering state-of-the-art language, speech, and visual encoders, for fully
utilizing the totality of the multi-modal richness that it has to offer,
achieving a 2\% improvement in macro-F1 over the existing benchmark.
Additionally, to cure the imbalance in the `sarcasm type' category in
MUStARD++, we propose an extension, which we call \emph{MUStARD++ Balanced},
benchmarking the same with instances from the extension split across both train
and test sets, achieving a further 2.4\% macro-F1 boost. The new clips were
taken from a novel source -- the TV show, House MD, which adds to the diversity
of the dataset, and were manually annotated by multiple annotators with
substantial inter-annotator agreement in terms of Cohen's kappa and
Krippendorf's alpha. Our code, extended data, and SOTA benchmark models are
made public. | [
0.0355573818,
0.0313153304,
-0.0396999083,
0.0357635543,
-0.0148332752,
0.0261687003,
0.0135477548,
0.0363476984,
-0.0174534209,
-0.0466289073,
-0.0521041155,
0.0416459888,
-0.0378190391,
0.0675120577,
0.0034372874,
-0.0598519407,
0.0031653235,
0.0399738066,
-0.0068814927,
-0.0281696469,
0.0379167907,
0.0048806737,
-0.0391451679,
0.0472578518,
-0.0476446673,
-0.0071657612,
-0.0016559453,
0.0776630342,
0.0535042994,
-0.0545824878,
0.0390286073,
0.0496067144,
0.014242948,
-0.0039287256,
0.0000018697,
-0.0070204106,
0.0106600365,
-0.000661793,
-0.0336927846,
-0.0141807292,
0.0959474221,
-0.0552866235,
-0.0157482103,
0.0291535705,
-0.0264935698,
-0.0015043691,
0.0520705022,
-0.0142102158,
0.0539192334,
0.0676537454,
-0.0208747797,
-0.0202344656,
-0.0072137211,
-0.0015232157,
-0.010513545,
-0.0400598943,
0.0189698655,
-0.0039868499,
-0.0406794548,
-0.0054712645,
-0.0699258447,
0.0110037681,
-0.0198051929,
0.0216984637,
-0.0132711129,
0.001576898,
-0.0348091722,
-0.0031421415,
-0.0298077315,
0.0621934012,
0.039890036,
0.0283505619,
-0.0298028905,
0.024502648,
-0.0151112434,
-0.0464544632,
-0.0012083492,
-0.0106131267,
-0.0072029587,
-0.0029787654,
-0.0122621022,
0.0394234955,
-0.019560976,
0.0143661248,
0.0655374378,
0.0049401545,
0.0077333814,
-0.0068521663,
-0.0029163344,
-0.0147717772,
-0.0459156856,
0.0011433432,
0.010938948,
0.0039687678,
0.0381807163,
-0.0021530984,
-0.0333172381,
-0.0509652272,
0.0287776552,
-0.0340903141,
-0.0309556406,
0.0069624777,
-0.0633380562,
0.0520410314,
0.0232970472,
0.009165369,
0.0006861346,
0.0384385288,
-0.0322784148,
-0.0333873741,
-0.0676009208,
0.0389356241,
-0.0122104902,
-0.0149805471,
-0.0116285998,
-0.0184209384,
-0.0768583193,
0.0048047705,
-0.0450997837,
0.0113822883,
0.0177694689,
-0.0009378926,
0.0090607023,
-0.0198446177,
-0.0019971253,
0.0707643107,
-0.0239546765,
0.0416569114,
-0.0470328815,
-0.08066535,
-0.0054753926,
0.0308455992,
0.0065635992,
-0.0095591452,
0.056509044,
0.0378528796,
0.0179224219,
-0.0652113557,
-0.0536535904,
0.0147855822,
-0.0828235671,
-0.0132696629,
0.0194946658,
-0.0211486761,
0.0367629454,
0.0004878918,
-0.0158534534,
0.0114137232,
-0.0128722424,
-0.0230460558,
0.0177890491,
0.0603547506,
-0.0448491499,
-0.0269683804,
0.0246251412,
0.0055716257,
-0.0904135406,
0.0525822937,
0.0115859127,
0.0072176466,
0.0516771227,
0.0149240112,
0.0011301194,
0.0277374052,
0.0078249266,
0.0099429898,
-0.0514819697,
-0.0060759601,
-0.0420374162,
0.0148406262,
0.025552718,
0.0092727756,
-0.0460431203,
-0.0251844954,
0.0228098221,
-0.0111132264,
-0.0342969969,
0.0223087147,
0.0335376039,
0.0188831016,
0.0079146344,
-0.0252354313,
0.0015188124,
0.0302939173,
-0.0717054307,
-0.036686644,
-0.032458663,
0.0268992484,
-0.0446874462,
-0.0148767252,
-0.0258999132,
-0.03396485,
0.0149820661,
-0.0294046365,
0.0436239205,
0.0111504337,
-0.0373995565,
-0.0144974645,
0.0240485594,
-0.0313420221,
-0.0473800488,
-0.016298743,
-0.0095759518,
0.0540498681,
0.0138963778,
-0.0420901515,
-0.029411396,
-0.0197378099,
-0.0379597247,
-0.0016173804,
-0.0040685907,
-0.0112687163,
0.0387044437,
-0.0535324067,
0.0053068926,
-0.0442170277,
0.0145980893,
0.0362127759,
-0.0424553342,
0.067737557,
-0.0297310874,
-0.0085592121,
0.0996406302,
0.0061859521,
0.0098184496,
-0.0133379065,
-0.0156332795,
0.0451025292,
0.0586172231,
-0.0116997221,
-0.0111092841,
-0.061336372,
0.0037841501,
-0.0474051274,
-0.0312122423,
0.0510491654,
0.0112795187,
-0.1159963757,
0.0207527354,
-0.0831159726,
-0.0167358238,
0.0439436883,
-0.0495989248,
-0.007382906,
0.0338471346,
-0.0095205521,
0.0024864837,
-0.0658132434,
-0.0301200002,
-0.0447804965,
0.0632386729,
0.0234926455,
0.0452783108,
0.0064992676,
-0.0397104695,
-0.0263605323,
0.0340668187,
0.0150878932,
0.0461631715,
-0.0346140712,
-0.0004667124,
0.005264807,
0.0122908512,
-0.0189463533,
-0.0093363291,
-0.0463283584,
-0.0637359843,
-0.1104996949,
0.0008516706,
0.0033996359,
-0.0041674003,
-0.0000626684,
-0.0245447159,
-0.0085666804,
0.0114321783,
0.00106079,
0.0121459961,
-0.0345789343,
0.0171536095,
0.0009121338,
-0.0232942477,
0.013202277,
-0.011797647,
0.003166168,
0.0009613282,
0.0306917578,
-0.0428604409,
0.0060385442,
0.0374412052,
-0.018580731,
-0.0357015543,
-0.0041815806,
-0.0110368682,
-0.0868142322,
-0.0014816839,
0.0067769592,
-0.0163299795,
0.0452418067,
0.0603277273,
0.0419767126,
-0.0172862969,
0.0176786445,
-0.0096944552,
0.0341373123,
0.0229660608,
0.0235825125,
-0.0384258926,
-0.0090544708,
-0.0467890762,
0.0213088375,
-0.0060351393,
0.0416607894,
-0.0490158871,
0.0172950942,
0.031088965,
-0.0124974623,
0.0195139479,
-0.026285965,
-0.0297833364,
-0.0404307432,
0.0104381396,
-0.0041337013,
0.0356270224,
0.0025381621,
-0.0653816536,
-0.0191353653,
-0.0067026103,
-0.0171608236,
0.0870479643,
-0.0407207832,
0.0298695453,
0.0188848507,
0.0046974714,
0.0036346337,
-0.0331886373,
0.0346344635,
-0.0342653058,
0.0299596991,
0.0280278903,
-0.0352761,
0.0054795174,
-0.0320736095,
-0.0361576118,
-0.0522917286,
-0.0909689367,
-0.0200419053,
-0.0236228853,
0.0204630066,
-0.0243174136,
-0.0141982613,
-0.0030803669,
-0.0149380891,
-0.0260154605,
0.005854425,
0.0057757241,
0.0112983156,
0.0316944979,
0.0023852326,
0.0069134478,
0.0000559192,
0.0056359763,
0.0451002643,
-0.0499083064,
-0.0003509459,
-0.0252724402,
0.0149351675,
0.0082200738,
0.044740241,
0.0116651691,
-0.0292688608,
0.0081477147,
0.0173926242,
0.0274738111,
0.0977764949,
-0.0011000878,
-0.0363466591,
0.0221069586,
-0.00716274,
-0.0118381875,
0.0612676516,
-0.0144017907,
-0.0606594868,
-0.0791049674,
0.0045901085,
0.0194576941,
-0.0142193073,
0.0048189764,
-0.0340686999,
-0.0821687579,
0.0291941129,
-0.0129036112,
-0.0104754474,
0.0373718776,
0.0355680175,
0.0074699488,
-0.0299578384,
-0.0022911082,
-0.0406654328,
0.044440724,
-0.0089098057,
0.0185208004,
-0.0166746248,
-0.0681166649,
0.0363005325,
-0.0139639871,
0.062675789,
-0.0102327503,
0.0615999177,
-0.0157126971,
-0.0566364154,
-0.0180184487,
-0.0385681503,
0.001862119,
-0.0169710368,
0.1177672297,
-0.0441068932,
-0.0019532959,
0.0044142744,
0.0023888543,
-0.0317233242,
0.043888811,
0.0020903754,
0.016814379,
-0.0040917299,
0.003732132,
-0.0614972934,
0.0155893629,
0.0153369373,
0.0372963063,
0.0099011548,
-0.0498878285,
0.0262389947,
0.015244131,
-0.0073444359,
-0.0377954841,
0.0189674199,
0.0272371043,
-0.0113790501,
-0.010353188,
-0.0505560227,
0.0022890791,
-0.0007759961,
0.0598021224,
-0.0605197772,
-0.0527509637,
-0.0515550748,
0.0202076007,
-0.015234217,
0.004674355,
0.0412007347,
0.0114266751,
-0.0032545272,
0.0112178996,
0.036386095,
-0.0537716895,
-0.0391532928,
0.0228594318,
-0.0317556448,
-0.0284674857,
0.0344350412,
0.0714289993,
0.0078195212,
0.0019902608,
0.0072584767,
-0.0036660628,
0.0317451283,
0.0515685305,
0.0142205479,
0.04587375,
0.0603105016,
-0.0062990375,
-0.010025329,
0.0437848344,
-0.0356396437,
0.0820537284,
0.0031052304,
0.0052929809,
0.0043152357,
-0.0368620269,
-0.0178619381,
0.0034650145,
0.0552067198,
-0.0152894417,
-0.0693410486,
0.0317418799,
0.0129270358,
-0.0097009595,
0.0016995971,
-0.0531014241,
-0.0119327679,
-0.0082217185,
-0.0046012616,
-0.0581436567,
-0.019899277,
-0.0020168049,
0.0020863384,
0.0137839429,
0.0364484228,
0.0605125166,
0.0100927576,
-0.0321770348,
0.0664657876,
-0.037527252,
-0.0210193247,
0.0348558389,
-0.0361202359,
-0.0096388003,
0.0549892075,
0.0234894585,
0.0094524529,
-0.0095831733,
0.0523897745,
0.0098140435,
0.0745173395,
0.0280920248,
-0.0062477128,
0.044256974,
0.0041392394,
0.0419638008,
-0.0243460536,
-0.0005957053,
-0.011420601,
0.0290729553,
-0.0789112896,
-0.0699635074,
0.0458748303,
0.0024174424,
-0.0084330216,
-0.0069645154,
0.0207671728,
-0.1096604168,
0.0431547388,
0.0062151402,
-0.0053936988,
-0.035331022,
0.0236947425,
0.0258686785,
-0.0152760288,
0.0285356324,
0.0129330279,
-0.0537906401,
-0.0406659395,
0.0800688788,
-0.0404209904,
0.0032940228,
0.0143935941,
0.0423888601,
0.0196571536,
0.0020687482,
0.0024834711,
0.0167822577,
0.0123099508,
-0.0634479523,
0.0328058898,
0.0327147432,
-5.601680576e-33,
-0.0236186236,
0.0168402363,
-0.0533827245,
0.0226100776,
-0.0151463561,
0.0692371428,
-0.0238561425,
-0.0098208999,
-0.0237633791,
0.0256197881,
0.0181281995,
0.0095792236,
-0.0103602763,
0.0028984845,
0.0111338217,
-0.0317030847,
0.0319694281,
-0.0070837038,
-0.0211239178,
-0.022445526,
0.0305613596,
0.0382191204,
0.0752954632,
-0.0847263634,
-0.0517541468,
0.0010254045,
-0.0717224479,
0.0024263274,
0.0625960007,
0.0921641439,
0.0240445789,
0.0841132253,
-0.0068961014,
0.0177516714,
0.0054913755,
-0.0264629759,
-0.0069076009,
0.0059438767,
-0.0212513953,
0.0021156413,
-0.0355728194,
-0.0164521262,
0.0337552838,
0.02728137,
-0.0448819958,
-0.0153948497,
0.0299833417,
-0.0365086161,
0.0381944366,
-0.0376468413,
-0.0522463396,
0.0096776811,
-0.0239382777,
-0.0265155919,
-0.0003774838,
0.031938564,
0.0451036617,
-0.000307911,
-0.0176815931,
0.0416989587,
-0.0686974674,
-0.0401320867,
-0.0063407053,
-0.0089004496,
0.0209192187,
0.0831059664,
0.0388189591,
0.0127674174,
0.0315436497,
-0.0152555862,
0.053319376,
0.0501904711,
0.0518768728,
0.1196818501,
0.0266801268,
-0.0548896603,
-0.0225516334,
0.0165525395,
0.0445613712,
-0.0063012014,
0.0099565824,
-0.0080775302,
-0.0375546366,
0.0287472308,
0.0009276062,
0.0269481782,
-0.01070063,
-0.0327546485,
0.0055769198,
0.0225773863,
0.0240756292,
0.0336909853,
0.0263671018,
-0.0353498384,
0.0379090905,
0.043448206,
-0.0446093157,
0.0659762323,
0.0187648498,
0.0379115008,
-0.0011456069,
-0.0096966019,
0.0610885471,
0.0310525205,
0.0239623152,
-0.0076255254,
0.0713803545,
0.0615115762,
-0.0421521328,
-0.0037941199,
0.0046574497,
0.0124740051,
-0.0444994196,
0.0175978672,
-0.0156824552,
0.0280952975,
-0.0307446923,
0.0202583261,
-0.0010736689,
0.0424768962,
-0.0440017581,
-0.0547362976,
0.0378467888,
0.0271920227,
-0.0448890366,
-0.0031578455,
0.0217381455,
-0.1315606385,
-0.0047129802,
-0.0544786975,
0.002921605,
-0.0272423699,
2.677e-7,
0.0216381066,
0.0585460849,
0.0045263893,
-0.0314120315,
0.0596126691,
0.0755068138,
-0.0415193699,
0.0425103121,
-0.0111505408,
0.007413195,
0.0561045296,
-0.0016709503,
0.0226200242,
0.0315392986,
-0.0151023818,
0.0441700071,
-0.032552138,
0.0257240608,
0.0023833478,
0.020001743,
0.0632199571,
0.0593634769,
0.0368247107,
-0.0367766432,
0.0181398299,
-0.0161819048,
0.056588605,
0.0138166817,
0.0170444474,
-0.0278111119,
-0.0157033838,
0.0006346862,
-0.0003116022,
0.0182580147,
-0.0096589793,
-0.0237618927,
0.0028139616,
0.0566862188,
-0.0312797166,
-0.0667736903,
0.0128137842,
0.0495574102,
-0.0357088298,
-0.0085312985,
0.0380369015,
0.0312737599,
-0.0257593337,
-0.0490934663,
-0.069625929,
-0.0033966149,
0.0512910709,
0.0062501472,
-0.0121228844,
0.0225212146,
0.0307784043,
-0.0352060981,
-0.0427042246,
-0.092396602,
0.01008105,
0.0162134077,
-0.0565003976,
-0.0217947308,
0.0185495168,
0.0384902097,
0.0475225225,
-0.0722124428,
0.0049894708,
1.808906382e-34,
0.024426138,
-0.026187839,
0.0276847929,
-0.0289768912,
-0.020479843,
0.0234969631,
-0.0241151229,
-0.0484026633,
0.0294161011,
-0.0154220313,
-0.0217242576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.17012v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.17012v1 | Benchmarking Cognitive Biases in Large Language Models as Evaluators | 2023-09-29T06:53:10 | 2023-09-29T06:53:10 | Ryan Koo, Minhwa Lee, Vipul Raheja, Jong Inn Park, Zae Myung Kim, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently been shown to be effective as
automatic evaluators with simple prompting and in-context learning. In this
work, we assemble 15 LLMs of four different size ranges and evaluate their
output responses by preference ranking from the other LLMs as evaluators, such
as System Star is better than System Square. We then evaluate the quality of
ranking outputs introducing the Cognitive Bias Benchmark for LLMs as Evaluators
(CoBBLEr), a benchmark to measure six different cognitive biases in LLM
evaluation outputs, such as the Egocentric bias where a model prefers to rank
its own outputs highly in evaluation. We find that LLMs are biased text quality
evaluators, exhibiting strong indications on our bias benchmark (average of 40%
of comparisons across all models) within each of their evaluations that
question their robustness as evaluators. Furthermore, we examine the
correlation between human and machine preferences and calculate the average
Rank-Biased Overlap (RBO) score to be 49.6%, indicating that machine
preferences are misaligned with humans. According to our findings, LLMs may
still be unable to be utilized for automatic annotation aligned with human
preferences. Our project page is at: https://minnesotanlp.github.io/cobbler. | [
0.0447278433,
0.0567712076,
-0.0076288413,
0.0369675905,
-0.0221324731,
0.0338895917,
0.0156785622,
-0.0126741016,
0.0318261385,
-0.0868583918,
-0.0763211995,
-0.0378219485,
0.003316086,
-0.0082295118,
0.0377127826,
-0.0442024767,
0.0281246509,
-0.0075356662,
0.0660196021,
-0.0149982451,
0.0149433659,
0.0032295135,
0.0284435768,
0.0447896346,
0.016197376,
-0.0213706084,
0.0547261946,
-0.0069088023,
0.0165315419,
-0.0308408234,
-0.0020374213,
0.0675423965,
-0.0097495262,
0.0534803867,
0.0000020152,
-0.0577064864,
-0.007900632,
-0.0060530487,
0.0044419612,
0.0488585532,
0.0626646504,
0.0188744627,
-0.0284081511,
0.0041809101,
-0.0297213662,
0.0135867586,
0.0198019613,
0.0250156652,
0.058153674,
0.0543464422,
0.0080960775,
0.0145186596,
-0.0124582006,
-0.0262070298,
-0.0294284821,
-0.0415809602,
0.0411223136,
0.0012803549,
-0.0361065418,
0.0180672742,
0.0096374322,
0.016045915,
-0.0046940707,
-0.0137611721,
0.031147087,
0.0259205997,
-0.0555635244,
-0.0263666455,
-0.0139723076,
0.0818513036,
0.0010194125,
-0.0165991019,
-0.0188108217,
-0.0377097651,
0.03690942,
-0.0397494622,
-0.0328374915,
0.0425234698,
0.0155584402,
0.0175623652,
0.009451176,
0.0350253247,
0.0266110264,
0.0341244303,
-0.017254103,
0.069943957,
0.0128608374,
-0.044312194,
0.0367023386,
0.0213212501,
-0.0204022117,
-0.0565371141,
-0.0057358993,
-0.0051197857,
-0.0449383706,
0.0107696913,
-0.0350986049,
-0.0047704754,
0.0198607519,
-0.0644251257,
0.0597703308,
0.0182678346,
0.0061535267,
0.0338484086,
-0.0096277269,
0.0680947751,
-0.0063695954,
0.0279983822,
-0.0247772988,
0.0140550071,
-0.0087431017,
0.0038171809,
0.020292446,
0.0170853436,
0.0138134845,
0.0166134741,
-0.0612141155,
0.0147328535,
-0.0512662753,
0.0130038531,
0.0047382414,
0.0075678071,
0.0073098377,
0.0019237039,
-0.0613026135,
0.0184517987,
-0.0218233075,
0.0184506476,
-0.000718735,
-0.0355247967,
0.0268477984,
0.0352327079,
-0.0243039411,
-0.048243992,
0.0093582645,
0.0485119484,
-0.00150796,
-0.0118776122,
0.0117992684,
0.0001217381,
-0.028673457,
-0.0621534586,
-0.0426207185,
-0.0561606437,
-0.0125586297,
0.0329620913,
0.0084149754,
-0.0477882586,
0.0009923858,
0.0245452598,
-0.0405348316,
0.0174209885,
0.0163093116,
0.0096277418,
0.0203727167,
0.0084759565,
-0.0153685529,
0.0584716685,
0.0435348675,
0.0402551331,
0.0405668728,
0.0079179071,
0.0113835866,
0.0497746952,
-0.0115469536,
-0.0187893342,
-0.0417951532,
0.0123527171,
-0.0158569738,
0.0432919711,
0.0473335646,
0.0944731161,
-0.0117047951,
0.0017680525,
0.0758223608,
0.026065832,
0.0148557816,
0.0114066042,
0.0322285704,
0.0323823206,
0.0174941048,
0.0254241135,
-0.0566707812,
0.030671075,
-0.0095466431,
-0.0149268666,
0.0685234442,
0.0186528675,
0.0021034507,
-0.0743851513,
-0.0239362828,
0.0087545896,
-0.0113663655,
-0.0029150019,
0.0330065638,
-0.0083857514,
-0.018118294,
0.0124875056,
0.0183069631,
-0.048517637,
-0.0032097541,
-0.0583911426,
0.0240290835,
0.0841859877,
0.034252964,
-0.018692391,
0.0313127525,
0.0040540467,
-0.0425341614,
0.0286136065,
0.0902693421,
-0.041982118,
-0.028003512,
-0.0399370305,
-0.0246770158,
-0.0041777515,
0.0321217552,
0.0084419148,
0.0161294378,
-0.0045510232,
0.0162210818,
-0.0445943438,
-0.1066522449,
0.0450346731,
0.0160046108,
-0.027798688,
-0.0117340172,
0.0076828017,
0.0306278933,
0.0083346944,
-0.0299100298,
0.0336247422,
0.0073663555,
-0.0083618844,
-0.004938635,
-0.0048362706,
-0.0674038827,
-0.018298883,
0.0229149982,
-0.0232278258,
-0.0338708982,
0.0252278689,
-0.027313849,
-0.0217420906,
-0.0059025236,
-0.0240326952,
0.014091366,
-0.0307312496,
0.0260066856,
-0.0361055657,
-0.0257725753,
-0.0622137412,
0.0728227124,
0.0021886746,
0.0244620964,
0.0304808617,
-0.0062043793,
0.0197546426,
-0.0235595349,
-0.0562361367,
0.0007127238,
-0.0016179834,
0.0286465976,
0.0446202792,
0.0006290828,
-0.0507808886,
-0.0388585888,
-0.105395712,
-0.0190493613,
-0.0298949741,
-0.0055243359,
0.0161393601,
-0.0265366174,
-0.0028760226,
0.0015029435,
-0.039470423,
-0.0383138359,
-0.0057781492,
0.050743755,
0.0272530094,
-0.0078635514,
0.0343811512,
-0.0601478107,
-0.0160479229,
-0.0303531922,
0.0500674956,
0.0252597556,
0.0153468084,
-0.0601697192,
0.0397538766,
-0.0354621336,
-0.0031864983,
0.0009689273,
-0.0177780744,
0.0242801923,
-0.0071028667,
0.0317271426,
0.0928048417,
0.031586159,
0.0150109977,
0.1075703278,
0.0252282042,
-0.0805404857,
-0.0290469937,
0.0207045898,
0.0050660307,
-0.0165123437,
-0.0392893441,
0.005037847,
0.0693631545,
0.0022559194,
-0.0013819761,
-0.0382507853,
0.0598803237,
-0.0507345274,
-0.037808001,
-0.038556464,
-0.0187266693,
-0.030865835,
0.0640426725,
-0.0143521624,
-0.054935053,
0.0978041813,
-0.0124527682,
0.0220531411,
-0.0279465243,
0.0179431885,
-0.0490106046,
0.0204661731,
0.0023206586,
0.0276813451,
-0.0085817948,
-0.0034474416,
-0.0855046585,
-0.0013168255,
0.0310921054,
-0.0427108854,
0.018545378,
-0.053530205,
-0.0049089892,
-0.0072194459,
-0.053477779,
-0.0513152592,
-0.0331825614,
-0.0428201742,
0.0013179714,
0.0385513641,
0.0051399507,
-0.0100842938,
0.0017612365,
0.016061157,
0.023261942,
-0.0311660003,
-0.0096608736,
0.0163471065,
0.0176337436,
0.0500722453,
0.0050744186,
0.0386730023,
-0.0105281761,
0.0308079571,
0.0374563448,
0.0404023491,
0.018994756,
-0.0136973783,
-0.0124493269,
0.0490351729,
-0.0188474841,
-0.029634079,
0.0195694976,
0.057807412,
-0.0364900827,
0.0008954582,
0.1305343509,
0.0263843499,
-0.0771448016,
0.0084024863,
-0.0012587087,
0.0462498739,
0.0427429266,
0.0159486383,
-0.0604301542,
-0.0082412455,
0.0089520272,
0.0341974534,
-0.032752499,
-0.0147387413,
-0.0022038331,
-0.1472918689,
0.0175379347,
0.0009425381,
-0.017798759,
0.0118313655,
-0.0214007925,
-0.0012331157,
-0.0511422567,
0.009882167,
0.0339147858,
-0.0158578567,
0.0068686269,
0.0138797089,
-0.0284778289,
-0.0794433802,
0.0472675078,
-0.0351673216,
0.070613578,
0.0555194281,
0.0495569743,
0.0051290849,
-0.0528694093,
0.0436287671,
-0.0310562961,
-0.0043550283,
-0.0017813856,
0.057186652,
-0.0383015536,
0.0134499688,
-0.0396688208,
0.0016848475,
0.0400716588,
0.0236513596,
-0.0076398617,
0.0349786207,
0.0158760156,
-0.017373465,
-0.0216648318,
0.0009940738,
-0.0172485355,
0.0879011676,
0.0341996662,
-0.0722064525,
-0.0295790117,
-0.0421065651,
-0.0240811054,
-0.017708879,
-0.0674024224,
0.0400899611,
0.0015406122,
-0.0223908871,
-0.076716207,
-0.0485889688,
-0.0059218109,
0.0165055729,
0.025045855,
-0.006545173,
-0.0358474106,
0.0067594736,
-0.0040452695,
0.0220801923,
-0.0169313047,
0.019023858,
-0.0527912192,
0.0148412688,
0.0159765016,
-0.0169275068,
-0.0308251847,
0.0033171989,
-0.0354974531,
-0.067181997,
-0.0081966892,
0.051726535,
0.0252091754,
0.0578365549,
-0.0163230915,
-0.0864706635,
0.0311989896,
0.0174515713,
-0.0376089849,
0.0102508143,
0.0155618489,
0.0058757146,
-0.0106851161,
0.0431735516,
-0.0626945496,
0.0358107351,
0.0134154074,
0.0344062522,
-0.0049720872,
-0.0582649373,
0.0300732665,
0.0310156234,
0.0314407647,
-0.0445577614,
0.0128487013,
-0.0331410877,
-0.0165640209,
-0.0261180941,
-0.0630849227,
-0.0080749877,
0.0088313641,
0.0425752215,
-0.0023920799,
-0.0308031775,
0.01025989,
0.0034140518,
0.0387755558,
-0.0289241038,
0.0074845944,
0.0128461309,
0.0174685009,
0.007923332,
0.0052152183,
-0.0497063473,
0.0030851762,
0.0009932076,
0.0575955808,
0.0021782268,
0.0393332914,
0.0226587821,
-0.0089439508,
0.0065500173,
0.0493008122,
-0.0637076721,
-0.0205500424,
-0.0281990692,
0.0102878958,
0.046186544,
-0.0256426092,
0.0827229023,
0.0157094616,
-0.0088200001,
-0.0202514343,
-0.0149225229,
0.0113538662,
-0.0242924299,
0.0220955126,
0.0091720205,
-0.0348496772,
0.0270891376,
0.0662511364,
0.0187345147,
0.0137268966,
-0.0256097596,
-0.02931609,
-0.0540185124,
-0.0041866577,
-0.0165580623,
0.0216977559,
-0.0185138732,
-0.0101879258,
-0.0832922533,
-0.0577492155,
-0.0173950363,
0.0228008479,
0.017055247,
-0.0535880178,
0.0031221071,
0.0715048537,
-0.0380990095,
-0.0041248216,
-0.0559175946,
-0.0317721851,
-0.0233580936,
-0.0071855569,
-0.0566184558,
-6.415805555e-33,
-0.0208221897,
-0.0109633403,
-0.0251510143,
-0.007548382,
-0.0074044112,
-0.0124138724,
-0.0144509589,
0.0179134775,
-0.0355599076,
0.0005355793,
-0.0158821903,
-0.0108076921,
0.0054819332,
-0.023474874,
0.0376707911,
0.0023025468,
0.0497540608,
-0.0146767944,
-0.0759993494,
0.0008421676,
0.0005092234,
-0.0138744209,
0.0146454489,
-0.0549074002,
0.0675328821,
0.0216912609,
-0.0187742878,
0.0061926139,
-0.0106871426,
0.0534372814,
-0.0171301588,
0.0495997593,
0.0353514403,
-0.0162269957,
-0.0135396058,
0.0254891664,
-0.031817086,
-0.0137524214,
0.0257459786,
-0.00850002,
0.0022364452,
-0.0449212082,
0.0544228815,
-0.0135572329,
-0.0831553712,
0.0139117017,
0.0643394366,
-0.0262299161,
-0.005300093,
-0.0091079092,
-0.0602153353,
0.0335358232,
-0.0160946492,
0.006074809,
0.0090027452,
0.0503064953,
0.0001871265,
0.0817390531,
-0.0477826893,
0.0356787629,
-0.0087662861,
0.0366394967,
0.0659273118,
0.0093039889,
-0.027027458,
0.0777382776,
0.0100649577,
0.0425083451,
0.009672082,
-0.0504944064,
0.0222412832,
0.0181900561,
0.0573630519,
0.0767631754,
0.0092419293,
-0.0125615699,
-0.040629074,
0.0412441157,
0.0199657027,
-0.0045551616,
0.0499903448,
0.0209784899,
-0.0563234724,
-0.0360017493,
-0.0642183051,
-0.047338672,
-0.0556559265,
-0.0011620936,
0.0260670092,
0.0036110852,
-0.0037343816,
-0.024429759,
0.0080145039,
-0.0465890504,
-0.0371226221,
0.0028464107,
-0.0516628027,
0.0151860891,
0.0095043769,
0.0170869268,
-0.0891791806,
0.0210408363,
0.0011990704,
0.0514403433,
0.0134152984,
-0.001452632,
0.047900334,
-0.0134910205,
-0.0635750741,
0.0070095873,
-0.036118824,
-0.0235199388,
-0.0082120914,
-0.0140568214,
0.0329758376,
-0.0073272628,
-0.0275299978,
0.0233096182,
-0.0023088024,
0.0233945213,
-0.0258389786,
-0.0328407027,
0.0083956085,
0.0189174656,
-0.0417855382,
-0.0105933016,
-0.015140417,
0.0153166503,
0.02053863,
-0.0300437063,
-0.0184541382,
-0.015205713,
2.627e-7,
0.0345932133,
0.0905071869,
-0.0142351482,
-0.0185839143,
0.0286305677,
0.0592184886,
-0.0263844244,
0.0177385751,
0.039162416,
-0.0035504438,
-0.0015681355,
-0.0037552838,
0.0532582588,
0.0141272908,
-0.0624176376,
0.0149934581,
-0.091913186,
0.0144292284,
-0.0284482576,
-0.0217124671,
0.0588480867,
0.0675974041,
0.0046432223,
0.0110383844,
-0.0180682763,
-0.0362853333,
0.0635088161,
-0.0321631543,
0.012190558,
0.0271701515,
0.0502508171,
0.0300515033,
-0.0012527385,
0.0207866132,
0.003745225,
0.0075620851,
0.0321134701,
0.0726297274,
0.0004971385,
-0.0142713236,
0.0011958523,
0.0149703575,
0.0073434929,
-0.1072890982,
0.0736336634,
-0.0420680493,
-0.0408780091,
-0.0587879904,
-0.0171127077,
-0.0071164402,
0.0417997278,
-0.0059140264,
-0.0082769133,
0.0013910187,
-0.0015806485,
0.0076761101,
-0.007913596,
-0.0587995015,
-0.0571582653,
-0.0073527764,
-0.010597459,
-0.0844432339,
-0.0282009412,
0.0169713106,
0.005336185,
-0.059945628,
0.0211015642,
2.201400617e-34,
0.0665711612,
-0.0187310185,
0.0334504433,
-0.009639889,
0.0358461589,
0.0288043823,
-0.0300858933,
0.0033866388,
0.01684816,
-0.0668788254,
0.0111373784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16938v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16938v2 | "I'd Like to Have an Argument, Please": Argumentative Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2023-09-29T02:41:38 | 2024-06-10T12:39:29 | Adrian de Wynter, Tangming Yuan | cs.CL | cs.CL | We evaluate two large language models (LLMs) ability to perform argumentative
reasoning. We experiment with argument mining (AM) and argument pair extraction
(APE), and evaluate the LLMs' ability to recognize arguments under
progressively more abstract input and output (I/O) representations (e.g.,
arbitrary label sets, graphs, etc.). Unlike the well-known evaluation of prompt
phrasings, abstraction evaluation retains the prompt's phrasing but tests
reasoning capabilities. We find that scoring-wise the LLMs match or surpass the
SOTA in AM and APE, and under certain I/O abstractions LLMs perform well, even
beating chain-of-thought--we call this symbolic prompting. However, statistical
analysis on the LLMs outputs when subject to small, yet still human-readable,
alterations in the I/O representations (e.g., asking for BIO tags as opposed to
line numbers) showed that the models are not performing reasoning. This
suggests that LLM applications to some tasks, such as data labelling and paper
reviewing, must be done with care. | [
0.0448120162,
0.0149501367,
0.0008836662,
0.0533519126,
-0.0459022857,
0.0456581786,
0.0180739854,
0.0029838742,
0.0317584537,
-0.0668930113,
-0.0139807081,
-0.0224440079,
-0.0086596608,
-0.015017773,
0.0035702032,
-0.0659295917,
0.0222984403,
-0.0490719825,
0.1054209396,
-0.0110480646,
0.0053976267,
0.0007957417,
-0.0040617059,
0.0302282814,
0.0345014557,
-0.0594147667,
0.0010269162,
-0.0285507757,
-0.0052421251,
-0.0334818661,
-0.0448297113,
0.0279883333,
-0.0094290515,
0.028060602,
0.0000020973,
-0.0670804903,
0.0057747238,
-0.0008328744,
-0.0675057098,
0.025079539,
0.0445380211,
0.0216321778,
-0.0062520923,
0.0153387152,
-0.0283819064,
-0.0347353853,
0.0168315042,
0.0968748778,
0.0508132242,
0.0600505546,
0.005687709,
-0.0298243538,
0.0302622989,
-0.0016294891,
-0.0259272642,
0.0272208545,
0.0307818986,
0.0224363208,
0.0261566341,
0.0518863127,
0.0218190085,
0.0382732823,
0.0168592222,
-0.0296708029,
-0.0297014639,
0.0491496921,
-0.0173956435,
-0.0119312555,
0.0003275248,
0.0320805423,
-0.0194242541,
-0.0238378718,
0.009726095,
-0.0064950767,
0.0095383786,
-0.0145613709,
-0.0654243231,
0.0751321614,
-0.0231896713,
0.0296256598,
0.0958526433,
0.009657843,
0.0229550116,
0.0153536834,
-0.017349707,
0.0700695738,
-0.0263216849,
-0.0423176847,
0.0587191321,
-0.0029725563,
-0.0458453633,
-0.0833745375,
0.0023701426,
0.0447573438,
0.0136768641,
0.0510161892,
-0.0024455204,
0.0163159017,
0.0437951684,
-0.0672010332,
0.0536007099,
-0.0098330323,
0.009048298,
0.0805172771,
-0.0302928463,
0.0030950704,
-0.0241269171,
0.0360068753,
0.0136586213,
-0.0234064925,
-0.0659056455,
-0.0296015348,
-0.0146393087,
0.0483609252,
-0.0166218691,
-0.0075764386,
0.0316199847,
0.0124291554,
-0.0237102564,
0.0270259902,
0.0170943718,
-0.0219973978,
0.0481971838,
-0.0346156359,
-0.0669406652,
-0.0230637714,
-0.0245875902,
0.0093876645,
0.0220951661,
-0.0456079096,
-0.0059579364,
0.0165602192,
0.0006718112,
-0.033429537,
-0.0031343219,
0.0498134084,
-0.0314439274,
0.0045826784,
-0.0409099869,
-0.0618229657,
-0.0075635416,
-0.0466526859,
0.0072779497,
-0.0590349101,
0.0291530527,
0.010490695,
-0.0054181903,
-0.0455975458,
0.0067362362,
0.020176176,
-0.0373578705,
0.0397079587,
0.014416025,
-0.0031602117,
0.0491719507,
0.0141407931,
-0.0572999157,
0.0259697754,
0.0320886001,
0.0021320973,
0.0302807167,
0.0151986843,
0.0065697692,
0.0091153895,
-0.0016187994,
0.0092160897,
0.0375940092,
0.0153663242,
-0.0337881558,
0.0141771724,
-0.0029526437,
0.0923791826,
-0.0438954271,
-0.0566979572,
0.0380352549,
0.0614076033,
0.0175715312,
0.0082783634,
0.0372657515,
-0.0134254051,
0.037405163,
0.008093344,
-0.0070731463,
-0.0021182436,
-0.0105489073,
-0.0059842239,
0.0081809098,
-0.0427266508,
-0.0085505629,
-0.0652304366,
-0.0276892595,
0.0060338322,
0.0031666493,
-0.0150075136,
0.0318441726,
0.0215941817,
-0.0235364567,
-0.0059793126,
0.0197589491,
-0.0269109812,
-0.0460526384,
-0.0532837249,
0.0804428011,
0.0028117117,
0.0302812122,
-0.0007801842,
0.0240947455,
-0.0231298879,
0.0671831444,
0.0494919159,
0.0819851458,
-0.0307807364,
-0.0145938676,
-0.0166894458,
-0.004173846,
-0.0179200433,
0.0066257254,
0.0076914458,
-0.0061981967,
-0.0017256864,
0.0125763584,
-0.0119559001,
-0.0786629915,
0.0339223072,
-0.0116128856,
-0.005130047,
-0.0039622006,
0.0070282128,
0.0258310884,
0.0290320273,
-0.0242328346,
0.04978453,
0.0251913648,
-0.0502779074,
-0.0164123476,
0.0106979581,
-0.0291385725,
0.0024170785,
0.0381427109,
-0.0004233477,
-0.0118156942,
-0.0405787453,
-0.0008541967,
-0.0198638886,
0.0089603756,
-0.0417570919,
0.0181222651,
-0.0039107548,
0.0266686063,
0.0132670691,
-0.023978373,
-0.024686126,
0.0725442246,
0.0232284386,
0.0164467711,
0.0006135153,
0.0521617271,
0.0098012136,
-0.0612878241,
-0.0235722102,
0.0278153364,
0.03754678,
-0.0161381755,
0.0166170914,
-0.0515626743,
-0.0422143079,
-0.022038551,
-0.0960780382,
0.0019242277,
0.0067433855,
0.0466331355,
0.0187232923,
-0.0695927814,
0.0161798615,
0.0200467128,
-0.0474868417,
-0.0365411378,
-0.021552505,
0.0373534895,
0.0535571203,
-0.0169387423,
0.0079522645,
-0.0122651923,
-0.0024622532,
-0.0438845642,
0.0525334515,
0.0295195915,
-0.0092104943,
-0.0520169325,
0.0295582321,
-0.0258972943,
-0.0008134152,
-0.0145613151,
0.00025608,
0.0428659879,
-0.0168221295,
0.0417202301,
0.1063944921,
0.0208560843,
0.0156640913,
0.0568471178,
0.0021878656,
-0.0594433174,
-0.004915352,
0.0070722052,
0.0332785435,
-0.0094315028,
-0.0271552484,
0.0125117181,
0.0889329165,
-0.0089153284,
0.0434941873,
-0.0307059847,
0.0566360056,
-0.0033544847,
0.0035313219,
-0.0168125276,
-0.0453436337,
0.0088267429,
0.0599943735,
-0.0409036204,
-0.0013409557,
0.0654160902,
-0.0533183627,
-0.0085360063,
-0.0333208814,
-0.0312424265,
-0.0221527088,
0.0665765256,
-0.028660858,
-0.0071097645,
0.0387731604,
-0.0001293931,
-0.0005075788,
-0.0398762412,
0.0052887457,
-0.0426442064,
0.0209629424,
-0.0530339144,
0.0099011874,
0.0064075962,
-0.035231486,
-0.0195329469,
0.005036213,
-0.0696945116,
0.0001684063,
-0.0087545756,
0.0061899303,
0.0063940971,
0.0188775659,
0.0336862318,
0.0234295726,
-0.0031811346,
-0.0041422523,
-0.0142120635,
0.0133129628,
0.0131130144,
0.018251026,
0.0216498189,
-0.0221178234,
0.0891841054,
0.0592834838,
-0.0200376902,
-0.0228576697,
-0.0487995632,
-0.0244876184,
-0.0215667915,
-0.0262383819,
-0.0564919375,
-0.0321212672,
0.0270836223,
-0.0920660496,
0.0153477741,
0.0948038176,
0.0412284397,
-0.023250645,
-0.0059500029,
-0.0458536297,
0.007775641,
0.0007670437,
0.0181820206,
-0.0705489665,
-0.0260117501,
0.0079893684,
-0.0079543665,
-0.0624662973,
-0.0498804227,
-0.0111519666,
-0.1206510961,
0.0588032939,
0.0080705239,
0.0278805234,
-0.0054638898,
-0.0328286625,
-0.0077864155,
0.0080821533,
-0.0437243022,
0.0356178842,
-0.0054986826,
0.0065481691,
0.033352986,
-0.0138767725,
0.0222774446,
0.0368417092,
-0.0062252828,
0.0459434465,
-0.0031402009,
0.05846636,
0.0149198584,
-0.050497476,
0.067970261,
-0.0312813707,
-0.011661374,
-0.0364477523,
0.0208464228,
0.009822364,
0.0041840067,
-0.0318386853,
0.0273079313,
0.0049319402,
-0.0203913432,
0.0497290716,
0.0926162973,
-0.053208638,
-0.0355119519,
-0.0002867285,
0.0082524056,
-0.0404231511,
0.0738774166,
0.0613704138,
0.0081826923,
-0.0649714842,
-0.057853736,
-0.0303232968,
-0.0402420685,
-0.0172307137,
-0.002065097,
-0.0084351851,
-0.0038806519,
-0.090808481,
-0.0450800881,
0.0288677942,
0.0345325693,
-0.0070511242,
0.0000919387,
0.0376422219,
0.0035362421,
-0.0173138566,
-0.0063618198,
-0.0289155226,
-0.0049305325,
-0.038866099,
0.00818503,
0.0317453332,
-0.0129367271,
-0.036393974,
0.0060519464,
0.0125390645,
-0.0872544497,
-0.0323506705,
0.0344884954,
0.0249106046,
0.0399314947,
-0.0123045929,
-0.0527888723,
0.0291903391,
0.0147172529,
0.0457576178,
-0.0076297512,
0.0355141759,
0.0200276505,
0.0157948751,
0.0205315594,
0.011320143,
0.0590158664,
0.0015484743,
0.0149570368,
-0.0644249246,
0.0333756246,
0.0037082916,
0.0650363639,
0.0355199687,
0.0558970496,
-0.0537328124,
-0.0297317039,
0.0129130976,
-0.0559583791,
-0.0329002254,
-0.0209986493,
0.0319714546,
-0.0174448173,
-0.022964213,
-0.0063610477,
-0.0361798704,
-0.0115696806,
0.0484268367,
0.0143641848,
0.022347698,
0.0041013514,
0.0408733152,
-0.0099503193,
-0.0194037352,
-0.0374292322,
0.0240910314,
0.0126139224,
0.0630812198,
-0.0089516398,
0.0711908713,
0.0304603074,
0.001368829,
-0.0052517145,
0.0164671112,
-0.0846040919,
-0.0743611827,
0.0499435253,
0.0051308973,
0.0051909811,
-0.0162212327,
0.0742488429,
-0.0365833119,
-0.0112682395,
-0.0096050175,
0.0226451121,
0.0333546884,
-0.0120087145,
0.0575436316,
0.0353970677,
-0.0359517038,
-0.0138785373,
0.0344602019,
-0.057421498,
0.0252195988,
0.0183250401,
-0.0275474954,
-0.0368957408,
-0.0378935188,
-0.0439088754,
0.0023514477,
-0.0016016428,
-0.0094132693,
-0.0287177842,
-0.0306964312,
-0.0425024033,
0.0382807106,
0.0042067193,
-0.0244564395,
0.0109036909,
0.0456777476,
0.0025847829,
-0.0117232101,
-0.0709911585,
0.0228481349,
-0.005497227,
-0.0053246655,
-0.0276415311,
-6.285668045e-33,
-0.0161462408,
-0.0245810095,
0.0048845573,
0.0559310094,
0.0196443796,
0.0064045433,
-0.0709156469,
0.027576033,
-0.0337209962,
0.0680587962,
-0.009016281,
0.0051246029,
0.0104460623,
-0.0262624826,
-0.0072976188,
-0.014995046,
0.0200675614,
-0.0148747629,
-0.0270095058,
0.0142034935,
0.0662916228,
-0.0273540914,
-0.007174666,
-0.0857345685,
0.0560924895,
0.01636439,
0.0158069395,
0.0011217996,
-0.0348164812,
0.0709271356,
0.00351259,
0.0371134728,
0.0403681137,
-0.0176205263,
0.0054505118,
0.0520227142,
-0.0864253715,
-0.0287137777,
0.0519470572,
-0.0494407266,
-0.0451276563,
-0.0596149452,
0.0359819978,
0.0287678782,
-0.0298539829,
-0.0177107062,
0.014454673,
-0.0356834307,
0.0085810181,
0.0005250053,
-0.0237249359,
0.0346481875,
-0.0108655347,
-0.0096929222,
0.0253210627,
0.0098831793,
-0.0202188957,
0.0762034059,
-0.0447741747,
0.0209185518,
0.0180246346,
0.0003533018,
0.0233716611,
-0.0369456448,
-0.0005922997,
0.067541033,
0.0030583323,
0.0061717741,
-0.0219762735,
0.0501255244,
-0.0194043387,
0.0313099958,
0.0520952456,
-0.015552626,
0.0101573076,
0.0090230703,
-0.0554454401,
-0.0400065407,
0.0588617474,
0.0296382532,
0.0448021442,
-0.0106054517,
-0.032052625,
-0.0138989985,
-0.0334917642,
-0.060899891,
-0.0352659263,
-0.0428084582,
0.00746101,
-0.0126987929,
0.0006410364,
-0.0011518046,
-0.0023422868,
-0.0161877759,
-0.0242620204,
-0.0112826964,
-0.0101902299,
0.0152386529,
-0.0059895548,
0.0028804482,
-0.0575381778,
-0.0230795294,
0.0053884275,
0.0045843609,
0.0304865111,
0.0116019379,
0.0224817488,
-0.0448085405,
-0.0756933242,
-0.015130505,
-0.0505887084,
0.0214189291,
-0.0177221317,
0.0415976383,
0.0250116959,
0.0328237861,
0.015156677,
0.0430331267,
-0.0164922811,
-0.0160008091,
-0.059615016,
-0.0066833636,
-0.0242838152,
-0.00564782,
-0.032873787,
-0.0128424121,
-0.0027773709,
0.0321236625,
0.0332335569,
-0.0567356274,
0.0087773893,
0.004652089,
2.726e-7,
0.0477158092,
0.0758309737,
0.0198927708,
0.0033892398,
0.0304314699,
0.0297349393,
-0.0252282303,
-0.0076097343,
0.0224496666,
-0.0518343411,
-0.0418714881,
0.0305664819,
0.0386046432,
0.0522504412,
-0.0854984447,
-0.0304808766,
-0.0910697281,
-0.0395906568,
-0.0406761579,
0.008451459,
0.0842105895,
0.0596383959,
0.0133111468,
0.0201914441,
-0.0239250995,
-0.0427566878,
0.0421726741,
-0.0107497163,
0.0061968178,
0.0044734217,
0.0525816716,
-0.0224993583,
0.0146567672,
0.0501695499,
0.0106846821,
0.0060134674,
-0.0147257429,
0.0766069293,
0.0021313054,
0.0084710857,
-0.00409002,
-0.0295624211,
0.0087009529,
-0.0689260885,
0.0748518631,
-0.0576712266,
-0.0570797659,
-0.0271453764,
-0.0140179629,
-0.0286238436,
-0.0196999405,
0.0024478948,
-0.026191663,
0.0085098315,
-0.0161944795,
-0.0252372548,
0.048521962,
-0.0651035011,
-0.0243028216,
0.0034136975,
-0.0134148486,
-0.0660505891,
-0.0112452265,
0.0011111322,
0.020817237,
-0.0830260888,
-0.0290407818,
2.372531932e-34,
0.0385346599,
-0.0109905284,
0.0235831402,
0.0394649059,
0.0463405736,
0.0343935303,
-0.0257127564,
0.0041533709,
0.0321204253,
-0.0749529302,
-0.0046532219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16937v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16937v2 | SSHR: Leveraging Self-supervised Hierarchical Representations for Multilingual Automatic Speech Recognition | 2023-09-29T02:35:36 | 2024-04-27T13:03:27 | Hongfei Xue, Qijie Shao, Kaixun Huang, Peikun Chen, Jie Liu, Lei Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Multilingual automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems have garnered
attention for their potential to extend language coverage globally. While
self-supervised learning (SSL) models, like MMS, have demonstrated their
effectiveness in multilingual ASR, it is worth noting that various layers'
representations potentially contain distinct information that has not been
fully leveraged. In this study, we propose a novel method that leverages
self-supervised hierarchical representations (SSHR) to fine-tune the MMS model.
We first analyze the different layers of MMS and show that the middle layers
capture language-related information, and the high layers encode
content-related information, which gradually decreases in the final layers.
Then, we extract a language-related frame from correlated middle layers and
guide specific language extraction through self-attention mechanisms.
Additionally, we steer the model toward acquiring more content-related
information in the final layers using our proposed Cross-CTC. We evaluate SSHR
on two multilingual datasets, Common Voice and ML-SUPERB, and the experimental
results demonstrate that our method achieves state-of-the-art performance. | [
-0.0394090861,
0.0194766279,
-0.0007777115,
0.0734197423,
-0.0086351717,
0.0128775267,
0.0380567946,
-0.0512935258,
0.0379906781,
-0.0043436801,
-0.1147575155,
-0.0024651121,
-0.0108417636,
-0.000001589,
0.0085785519,
-0.0289450083,
0.0340057015,
-0.0656709224,
-0.0046970309,
-0.0272685792,
-0.0298120603,
0.0219786558,
0.0156781953,
-0.0145973135,
-0.0150069753,
-0.0389401242,
0.0108530372,
0.016712524,
0.0307091773,
-0.0099669443,
-0.0049624383,
0.0234730989,
0.0360249765,
0.0457592458,
0.0000021277,
-0.0264325663,
-0.0274667144,
-0.0274100918,
-0.0379733257,
0.0011759975,
0.0119569665,
-0.0111053661,
-0.0467512198,
-0.0166189652,
-0.0187917333,
0.0162886418,
0.0216825474,
0.0208259467,
0.0291968361,
0.0389105044,
-0.0141517958,
-0.0385963172,
-0.0318112224,
-0.0184576437,
-0.0288644768,
-0.0501156561,
-0.0095703714,
0.0276241004,
-0.032835111,
-0.0113431131,
-0.0227408353,
0.0479866639,
0.0091609135,
-0.0008150885,
-0.0100370012,
0.0247403327,
0.005752,
-0.0307614319,
-0.0006345996,
0.0574089102,
-0.0317600816,
-0.0177253075,
-0.0020714817,
-0.0098530846,
-0.0210036598,
-0.0411942266,
-0.0126659526,
0.0206939559,
-0.0112602254,
0.0328998007,
0.0468989164,
0.0725539327,
0.0173816159,
0.004899167,
-0.0478894226,
0.0439461134,
-0.0299740806,
-0.0287787281,
0.0267429557,
-0.0165783949,
0.0914728269,
0.0313208327,
0.0710544735,
-0.0299662594,
0.0381734222,
-0.0023789825,
0.001293386,
-0.0402133688,
-0.0047001606,
-0.0796640813,
-0.0015467197,
0.0395880789,
-0.0810183287,
0.0748270676,
-0.0064054988,
0.0243331697,
-0.0420827009,
0.0287805535,
-0.0186350811,
-0.0241583306,
-0.0240371432,
0.0104239704,
-0.0447846502,
0.0343460999,
-0.0112945186,
-0.0096553313,
-0.0290007684,
0.0159299932,
-0.0222881772,
0.000094582,
-0.0080578802,
-0.0062649557,
-0.0486526638,
-0.0337009355,
0.0687055811,
0.0543126985,
-0.0292985663,
-0.0228858609,
0.0036801696,
-0.0426345207,
-0.0433058254,
0.0620622821,
0.036401663,
-0.0147037562,
0.0292989947,
0.0566465631,
-0.0095943948,
-0.0388187431,
-0.035769172,
0.0297997613,
-0.0588728227,
-0.0571512543,
0.0032149097,
-0.0519440435,
0.0550811216,
-0.0034210489,
0.0172437169,
-0.0360490158,
-0.0195322316,
-0.0585875846,
0.0002133263,
0.0470103845,
0.0101207932,
-0.012356787,
0.0590000674,
-0.0014212927,
-0.0022635316,
0.0819382221,
0.0207877308,
0.0351656526,
0.0513063669,
-0.0287765972,
0.0073796329,
0.0598550849,
-0.0182163827,
-0.0072322423,
-0.0469910614,
0.0137395309,
-0.004508649,
0.0082868729,
0.0985321552,
-0.0060469555,
-0.0106375013,
-0.0308443438,
0.0391958244,
0.0312039331,
0.0285094324,
0.0342018381,
0.0387237519,
0.0272845794,
0.0148397135,
0.0436194502,
-0.0008102724,
0.0509194396,
0.001880393,
0.0100941621,
0.0336441137,
0.0498069339,
-0.0621871091,
-0.0252762549,
0.0222957227,
-0.0318673886,
-0.026632838,
0.052094575,
0.0583959483,
0.0210793428,
0.0081268093,
0.0471231639,
0.05236049,
-0.0580546893,
0.0417151004,
-0.0159352999,
-0.0099659953,
0.0288393497,
-0.0288385283,
-0.0436939895,
-0.0318766572,
-0.0076009789,
-0.0045929961,
0.0487543568,
0.0124602485,
0.0205899812,
0.0893890113,
-0.0684324428,
-0.0120046902,
-0.0054959748,
-0.0371231996,
0.0670803934,
-0.0749627501,
0.0127034709,
0.0022670862,
-0.019511506,
0.0108129457,
-0.0148898466,
-0.0147652701,
-0.0148530193,
0.0395994373,
0.0504716672,
0.0520283654,
0.0633939728,
-0.0183335934,
-0.0165754035,
0.0295150112,
-0.0390982553,
-0.0247297585,
0.020194564,
-0.1206423342,
-0.0551989451,
0.0047279252,
-0.0242680926,
-0.0256792977,
0.0107024871,
0.0048019593,
-0.0499972366,
0.0572449639,
-0.0046958514,
-0.0004271056,
-0.0472259708,
0.0216529015,
0.0283635389,
0.0596931353,
0.0267666113,
0.0221325718,
0.0155863147,
-0.0401277058,
0.0368248634,
0.0061427671,
0.0089690397,
-0.0484904349,
-0.0077307466,
0.0545770712,
-0.0145417005,
0.0007506182,
0.0213555824,
0.0231505577,
-0.0198419299,
-0.006807378,
-0.0615599938,
-0.0080982288,
-0.0368804261,
0.0366419703,
0.0002014711,
0.0307432096,
-0.0125734285,
-0.0638539568,
-0.0141555015,
-0.0432903245,
-0.017558841,
-0.0110767595,
-0.0164839458,
-0.0123836333,
0.0317000523,
-0.0449137501,
-0.0109072542,
0.0202189535,
0.0298994184,
-0.0556206256,
-0.0684823468,
-0.0186728314,
-0.0668435171,
-0.0087856082,
0.0366203077,
-0.0082599809,
-0.0274155736,
-0.0381743312,
-0.0260358527,
-0.0200880095,
0.0758866072,
0.0009153194,
0.0065806354,
0.0495912619,
-0.0303331055,
-0.0422367156,
0.0444052964,
0.0059299576,
0.0392168686,
-0.0096651204,
0.0330671221,
-0.0202794448,
0.0896816552,
0.0309929531,
0.0343636088,
-0.0422895513,
-0.0475795008,
0.0064539304,
-0.0299773775,
0.0079642097,
0.0352993198,
-0.0329715796,
0.0166727733,
0.0104048066,
-0.0342293717,
0.0764754042,
-0.0728430003,
-0.0831848979,
-0.034380123,
-0.020998707,
-0.0452109873,
0.0264453292,
-0.0245752223,
0.0395308957,
-0.0118219303,
-0.077962935,
-0.0131920287,
0.014644471,
0.0313306861,
-0.0203480627,
0.0069396687,
0.0109704938,
-0.0213635005,
0.0109666847,
-0.0428288803,
-0.0120101543,
0.025440108,
-0.030223351,
0.0058077006,
-0.0159930587,
0.0159938745,
-0.0417917967,
-0.0070695421,
0.0459939167,
0.0713530779,
-0.005572909,
0.0233071502,
-0.0157652758,
0.0716587007,
-0.001036052,
0.0536498837,
0.0190439988,
0.0192887597,
0.078069292,
0.0231803674,
0.0047639101,
-0.003696241,
-0.0332378745,
0.0185649935,
0.0527727678,
-0.0081725139,
0.0029222346,
-0.0225682016,
0.0266871825,
-0.0649928004,
0.0280874688,
0.0785575956,
-0.0155644426,
-0.056735713,
-0.025593603,
-0.0404812694,
-0.0308369473,
0.0263726972,
0.0019498478,
-0.0419974066,
-0.0237929113,
0.0079539167,
0.0298495442,
0.0454501547,
0.0105791837,
0.0191187281,
-0.0665538758,
0.0415705964,
0.0251191985,
-0.046356976,
-0.0392633006,
-0.0468149781,
-0.012221246,
-0.0271912981,
0.0347906314,
-0.0083931312,
-0.0063076462,
-0.0762904659,
0.0044852761,
-0.0633229986,
-0.0471113026,
0.0554420091,
-0.0312145874,
0.0442766659,
0.0150318053,
0.0403487533,
-0.0084978407,
-0.0074353479,
-0.0079108896,
-0.0567928776,
-0.0049601151,
-0.0302828699,
0.0018673317,
-0.0379803218,
-0.0148790823,
0.0499649681,
0.0187706985,
-0.0011406875,
0.0285083205,
0.0254241601,
0.0898990408,
-0.0068099778,
-0.0213863607,
0.0237943269,
0.0285086911,
-0.0042257109,
0.0672975034,
0.0284917746,
-0.0181930736,
0.0043498892,
0.0098555218,
0.0335174166,
-0.0143180322,
0.0038814922,
0.0598590784,
0.0001767262,
-0.0436692461,
-0.0089896573,
-0.0738004446,
0.0072924066,
0.0033564717,
-0.010925143,
-0.0004071302,
-0.0185155477,
0.0139010288,
-0.0135546671,
0.0318122208,
-0.052137915,
-0.0411984921,
-0.054777883,
-0.0096583636,
0.0156736113,
-0.0788251087,
-0.0042372253,
0.0067839236,
-0.0318410769,
-0.0728779286,
-0.0115363635,
0.0394993797,
-0.0016016826,
0.0947825834,
-0.0294333808,
-0.058822535,
0.0409537926,
-0.0114420848,
-0.0718134567,
-0.0252232756,
0.0819161981,
-0.0118467398,
-0.0474484526,
0.0289491061,
-0.0370105691,
0.0668597668,
-0.0154480804,
0.0205890797,
-0.0082542719,
-0.0272944923,
0.0058363727,
-0.0212156344,
0.0655021667,
-0.0373215973,
0.0453164801,
-0.0505366325,
0.0332144871,
-0.0099738464,
0.007799305,
-0.0126053756,
0.006831177,
0.011504286,
-0.0327696912,
0.0214305054,
0.01896137,
-0.0323820375,
-0.0527738295,
-0.0169890933,
0.080554992,
-0.0444613993,
0.0148262354,
-0.0212733895,
-0.0087027075,
-0.0089383908,
0.046567671,
0.0454095043,
0.0147495633,
-0.0216858871,
0.0339340307,
-0.0065491856,
-0.0011725175,
-0.0014531304,
0.0414604992,
-0.0200102683,
-0.0158020519,
0.0021944069,
-0.01258347,
0.0956493914,
-0.0319109224,
0.0684242994,
0.0195835494,
0.0035187425,
-0.0215322059,
0.0062454375,
-0.0007734266,
-0.0037207881,
-0.006707326,
-0.0116021875,
-0.0220563728,
0.032934092,
0.035166055,
-0.0050049811,
-0.0288588479,
0.0216354821,
0.0342283174,
-0.0485826656,
-0.0126218572,
0.0010640572,
0.0264103804,
-0.0621228777,
-0.0125370109,
-0.0036441344,
-0.0646112189,
0.0624332316,
-0.0069880919,
-0.0229874197,
0.0013958127,
0.0198029745,
0.0529608279,
-0.0121434219,
-0.0049306229,
-0.0088114329,
-0.0077933543,
0.0263548642,
0.008069355,
0.0329388753,
-6.645818943e-33,
-0.0048881024,
0.0234162528,
-0.0231961571,
0.0354367867,
0.0052728713,
0.0131773716,
-0.0379668847,
0.0271066017,
0.0035449141,
-0.02156494,
-0.0294087585,
-0.031592302,
0.0371126086,
0.0468560904,
0.0173426941,
0.0015661455,
0.0710094795,
-0.0075968485,
-0.0005507117,
0.0244743004,
0.015290509,
0.0600435063,
0.122473225,
-0.0467669517,
-0.0078417975,
-0.0182108581,
0.0182674974,
-0.0195023417,
0.0472206101,
0.0722852498,
-0.0025982207,
0.0290068146,
0.0196680948,
-0.0260057077,
-0.0110009108,
0.0222184919,
-0.1205988377,
-0.0199762881,
-0.0443955176,
0.0260924343,
-0.0405352786,
-0.0293029752,
0.0238169134,
-0.0043177144,
0.0064609423,
-0.0421758145,
0.0286161005,
-0.0051951082,
-0.0354604982,
-0.0363105312,
-0.0423334911,
0.0612870716,
-0.0277366638,
0.008253186,
0.1045290828,
0.0580190942,
-0.0075700656,
0.0529696979,
-0.0760123879,
-0.0034274531,
-0.0646724924,
0.0253396109,
0.0796797127,
0.0193782467,
-0.0184370726,
0.0077686473,
0.0521193892,
-0.0264221132,
-0.0039286073,
-0.0484789461,
0.0372170582,
0.022640612,
-0.0061779502,
0.011675301,
-0.0101483241,
-0.0104840938,
-0.0323743895,
-0.0249537416,
0.0181320142,
0.0379168317,
0.0024428614,
0.0092248218,
-0.0365329124,
0.0242032968,
-0.0339096114,
-0.0445642732,
-0.0204152502,
-0.0298684109,
0.0298997536,
-0.0031489772,
-0.0158905722,
0.0131834392,
0.0876160786,
0.0009370132,
-0.0023624846,
0.0106318882,
-0.0035362921,
-0.026672652,
0.0186638683,
0.0658544302,
-0.0530482419,
-0.011058677,
-0.0427709185,
-0.0371922068,
0.0146597354,
-0.0034858314,
0.0287851579,
0.0311768912,
-0.0546260104,
0.0011495635,
-0.0064839404,
0.0018320972,
-0.0161326248,
0.0356219709,
0.0460004844,
-0.0128587671,
-0.0056834528,
0.0472685955,
0.0239924062,
0.0229217745,
-0.0365157239,
0.0144441044,
0.0079111019,
0.035815917,
-0.0068041449,
0.0010974043,
-0.0336876772,
-0.0275820177,
0.034553919,
-0.0539525747,
-0.0092586018,
0.0203308035,
2.863e-7,
-0.0211442113,
0.026375981,
0.0083053438,
-0.018675806,
0.0202105939,
0.0328011587,
-0.028572334,
-0.0138485506,
-0.0051017455,
-0.0058982475,
-0.006567555,
0.0205836445,
0.0699274465,
0.0345336609,
-0.0857983679,
0.0239591878,
-0.0524145924,
0.0085422052,
-0.0123079792,
-0.0107057188,
-0.0060447822,
0.1031227261,
-0.0145224715,
0.0033268607,
-0.0105089536,
-0.0211358983,
0.055083964,
-0.0003314964,
-0.0080929846,
-0.0027980239,
-0.0148298517,
0.0133716865,
-0.0690575019,
-0.0025664954,
-0.0268909875,
0.074536711,
0.0226001814,
0.0409636199,
-0.005162939,
-0.0510704741,
0.015893802,
0.0264117233,
-0.0299622603,
-0.0577906594,
0.0488139726,
-0.0443120003,
-0.0083634695,
-0.043405015,
-0.0091071213,
0.0452049822,
0.0557585582,
-0.019352043,
-0.0235484447,
0.0353935249,
0.0235742815,
-0.0265525747,
-0.0317578577,
-0.0752508044,
0.016509857,
0.0051862458,
-0.0396402143,
0.0422192812,
-0.0123886811,
-0.021912856,
0.0403890461,
-0.0000457177,
0.0172387976,
1.783975341e-34,
0.0110376291,
-0.0344193392,
0.0018927919,
-0.0233543459,
-0.0172560755,
-0.0613307357,
-0.0464110225,
0.0097146491,
-0.0106932847,
-0.0157278515,
-0.0169183314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16905v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16905v1 | Towards a Unified Framework for Adaptable Problematic Content Detection via Continual Learning | 2023-09-29T00:14:38 | 2023-09-29T00:14:38 | Ali Omrani, Alireza S. Ziabari, Preni Golazizian, Jeffrey Sorensen, Morteza Dehghani | cs.CL | cs.CL | Detecting problematic content, such as hate speech, is a multifaceted and
ever-changing task, influenced by social dynamics, user populations, diversity
of sources, and evolving language. There has been significant efforts, both in
academia and in industry, to develop annotated resources that capture various
aspects of problematic content. Due to researchers' diverse objectives, the
annotations are inconsistent and hence, reports of progress on detection of
problematic content are fragmented. This pattern is expected to persist unless
we consolidate resources considering the dynamic nature of the problem. We
propose integrating the available resources, and leveraging their dynamic
nature to break this pattern. In this paper, we introduce a continual learning
benchmark and framework for problematic content detection comprising over 84
related tasks encompassing 15 annotation schemas from 8 sources. Our benchmark
creates a novel measure of progress: prioritizing the adaptability of
classifiers to evolving tasks over excelling in specific tasks. To ensure the
continuous relevance of our framework, we designed it so that new tasks can
easily be integrated into the benchmark. Our baseline results demonstrate the
potential of continual learning in capturing the evolving content and adapting
to novel manifestations of problematic content. | [
0.0966491029,
0.0554008372,
-0.0272973012,
-0.0012339639,
-0.013433232,
0.0567089021,
-0.0247201677,
0.0158971529,
0.0128548397,
-0.0686304495,
0.0104329493,
0.0015696173,
-0.0477851145,
0.0367259681,
-0.0255260654,
-0.0362758711,
0.0323619917,
0.0522643626,
0.0138427811,
0.0126383817,
0.0583110936,
0.002557395,
-0.0070044911,
-0.0001110672,
-0.0779064968,
-0.0219879001,
0.0522775427,
-0.011378211,
0.0470534749,
-0.032074552,
0.0593700297,
0.0369480029,
0.0160792992,
0.0578680784,
0.0000019764,
-0.0273301862,
-0.0136319576,
-0.0133314524,
-0.0182159636,
-0.0610739738,
0.0871044397,
-0.0112470258,
-0.0220972169,
0.0251511112,
-0.0506616235,
0.0339015685,
0.0647214204,
0.0421816222,
0.0915898681,
0.0505308881,
-0.0193105489,
-0.001546327,
0.022796059,
0.0159603897,
-0.0234800596,
0.011777075,
0.053339459,
-0.0036144834,
-0.040945258,
-0.0084058978,
-0.0315186903,
0.0195927341,
0.0282477643,
-0.0195944905,
0.0406088457,
-0.0536827631,
0.0024406642,
-0.0404070765,
0.0160642192,
0.0573251285,
-0.0256868433,
0.0011009615,
0.0145213334,
-0.0083096977,
-0.0141922403,
-0.0147510152,
-0.0099374512,
0.0002914659,
-0.021529898,
0.0055785519,
0.0142052574,
-0.0024394682,
0.0368939489,
0.0846151188,
0.0350065082,
0.0002924206,
-0.0557589866,
-0.0181518439,
0.0238574333,
-0.0314769745,
-0.0154182063,
0.017160628,
0.042025324,
0.0050717006,
-0.0190631486,
0.0404930562,
-0.052968055,
-0.0558196902,
0.02425538,
-0.076020211,
0.0429711118,
0.0402223691,
-0.043190591,
0.0288236439,
0.0315673463,
0.0299618412,
-0.0080378,
0.0015101145,
-0.0196268689,
0.0243725199,
-0.0443583354,
0.0162952524,
0.01324437,
0.033202,
0.0347067565,
0.013675632,
-0.0264949333,
0.0190667361,
-0.0769453272,
0.0142879467,
-0.0651980191,
0.0239953492,
-0.0230047982,
0.028219305,
-0.0187497102,
-0.0002563329,
-0.040722914,
0.0324491672,
-0.0174677446,
-0.03081562,
0.0176386125,
0.03481194,
-0.016540952,
-0.0038361782,
0.0358142294,
0.0336194076,
0.027507456,
-0.0089773862,
-0.0336104035,
-0.0217303168,
-0.0327042453,
-0.008974595,
0.0198073909,
-0.0468961224,
0.0198630877,
-0.0277378764,
-0.0379090458,
-0.0622512735,
0.0003306357,
0.0239622742,
-0.0365180038,
0.073371008,
0.0145722767,
-0.0554388873,
0.0673132166,
0.0493972413,
-0.0033151582,
0.0626857877,
-0.0057976153,
0.0308231898,
0.0518943332,
0.0003568737,
-0.0219679326,
0.036328014,
0.0304657761,
0.0347694233,
-0.0257284828,
0.0337800719,
0.0012585574,
-0.0266603157,
-0.0249675754,
0.0184011646,
0.0000076345,
-0.0783691704,
0.0451803468,
0.0408049189,
-0.0447621793,
0.0229104962,
0.0439090692,
0.0144823696,
-0.0255185422,
-0.0131623521,
-0.0698771626,
0.0049605947,
-0.0253208764,
-0.0588445626,
-0.0165909827,
0.0507714376,
-0.0031187693,
-0.0584645346,
-0.0365242176,
-0.0069019445,
0.0431729741,
-0.044721894,
0.0068828575,
0.0365805887,
-0.0016702699,
0.001828856,
0.0608529896,
-0.0115021234,
-0.0039432012,
-0.0366832837,
0.0681098029,
0.0755612925,
0.0308909137,
-0.051203575,
-0.0279306527,
-0.0867092013,
0.0369034931,
0.0100056157,
-0.0056045931,
-0.0286096558,
0.0065162745,
0.0036911764,
-0.0275025573,
0.0264948159,
0.0001368404,
0.0056928596,
0.0671496317,
0.0121670412,
0.0024246974,
0.0485758707,
-0.0601535738,
0.0509451441,
-0.0053736302,
0.0132187512,
0.0041483957,
0.0012773365,
0.0639598444,
0.0146978972,
-0.0203649756,
-0.0613230206,
0.021980796,
-0.024049541,
-0.0447351485,
0.0058736773,
-0.0188692696,
0.0423458815,
0.0549223907,
-0.0365787446,
-0.0220223125,
0.0214827489,
-0.0097566377,
0.0476235002,
0.0430911109,
-0.024565503,
-0.0266056601,
-0.0422015525,
-0.045767393,
-0.0562413596,
0.0279132463,
-0.0149055859,
0.0811512917,
-0.0432589613,
-0.0110986037,
0.0300245676,
-0.0663652048,
0.0036623564,
0.0256709605,
-0.0243834127,
-0.0355659649,
-0.038334664,
0.0206641518,
0.0169510301,
0.0257792063,
-0.028611457,
-0.0219340343,
-0.0515940823,
-0.0126328776,
-0.0286150277,
-0.0155267119,
0.0124337729,
-0.0330397263,
-0.0166917648,
-0.0010610626,
-0.0032146894,
-0.0462278016,
0.0112187965,
0.0426212102,
0.006838053,
-0.0281534661,
0.0122441705,
-0.0453114361,
0.0057466072,
-0.0070479992,
0.0049464144,
-0.0057011605,
-0.0706768408,
0.0098259328,
-0.0216478463,
-0.0521582514,
0.0006467701,
-0.0110573182,
-0.0279114749,
0.0202373471,
0.0293193609,
-0.0065026777,
0.0431115963,
0.0651242137,
0.1109616011,
0.0143803181,
0.02191508,
-0.0205947626,
0.0094064241,
-0.0168665908,
0.0462063514,
-0.0185669344,
-0.0417664722,
0.0120685538,
0.0263533536,
0.0008013683,
-0.0230724141,
-0.0441876426,
0.0524263009,
-0.0978631526,
-0.0390808322,
-0.0284103528,
-0.0557905361,
-0.008548067,
-0.04408402,
-0.0440075062,
-0.056515485,
0.0709699243,
0.0500012301,
0.048947189,
-0.0033138038,
-0.0285981465,
0.0056268806,
0.0280756056,
-0.0255409684,
0.0431323647,
-0.0143223032,
-0.0086805029,
0.0094771069,
-0.0125957849,
0.0623861216,
-0.0236303322,
0.0045196046,
-0.0374001451,
0.0157473423,
0.0232075732,
-0.0645845085,
-0.0532263182,
-0.0413070135,
-0.0092355004,
-0.0322588347,
-0.0267075114,
-0.0061521903,
-0.0236591231,
-0.0128364768,
0.0210177023,
0.0017805805,
0.01247318,
-0.0248632897,
0.042885147,
-0.0321246684,
-0.0007226781,
0.0403053947,
0.0270656478,
0.0127300713,
0.0000572193,
0.0759665892,
-0.0079050427,
-0.0002349697,
0.008286221,
0.0352947414,
-0.0134445643,
0.0124692181,
0.0336306877,
-0.0182156377,
-0.0068750367,
-0.0116730528,
-0.0086214617,
0.0555944666,
0.0226785019,
-0.0056711263,
0.0018447862,
-0.0101791248,
-0.0104658995,
0.03042363,
-0.0127783073,
-0.0984219611,
0.0127188098,
-0.0372690819,
0.0491126366,
-0.0789133832,
-0.0748302862,
-0.0010378036,
-0.0305392761,
0.0232394654,
-0.0087127062,
-0.0214580726,
0.0211943723,
-0.0211892258,
0.0120048011,
-0.0222360864,
0.0074734427,
-0.034749724,
0.0322908536,
-0.0302497186,
0.0137970401,
-0.080980882,
-0.0282472204,
0.0110851349,
0.0281816293,
0.0433628,
0.0196271725,
0.0468651019,
0.0043292306,
0.0153058218,
0.0630260408,
0.0035455909,
-0.0161448773,
-0.0659462139,
0.0507431924,
-0.0071226545,
-0.0488987863,
-0.0171856824,
0.0611546971,
0.007920024,
-0.0233755745,
0.0069406726,
0.0783743113,
0.0489516258,
0.0369575843,
-0.070233047,
-0.000026044,
0.0377751067,
0.0496041402,
0.0029718487,
-0.0678966641,
0.0435273424,
-0.0352539234,
-0.0003680034,
-0.0099201715,
-0.0216779988,
-0.0090448828,
-0.0369353369,
0.0213358141,
-0.04709059,
-0.0206779297,
0.0012119651,
0.0039766063,
0.0285339467,
-0.0319205076,
-0.0128100477,
0.0018994154,
-0.0681825653,
-0.0177997295,
0.0306590963,
0.0339819416,
-0.0123810079,
-0.0254016463,
-0.0345090218,
0.0011634311,
-0.0243955124,
0.0318495706,
-0.0773555264,
-0.0292828139,
0.1016494855,
0.0581793487,
0.0113798575,
0.0310132299,
-0.0175709128,
-0.0478769802,
0.0253525693,
0.0535966679,
-0.0311251525,
-0.0012811653,
0.0415637791,
0.008808299,
0.0126434099,
0.0301568732,
-0.0050812531,
0.0311424453,
0.043376103,
-0.055672437,
-0.0394664034,
0.0297305956,
-0.0102725578,
-0.023333244,
-0.0366386659,
-0.0087734405,
-0.0679503679,
-0.0193199199,
-0.0388930924,
0.0186630785,
-0.0604445525,
0.0019195452,
0.0220350567,
0.0277887564,
-0.0259514898,
-0.0503085442,
0.048257757,
-0.0241536777,
0.0589755736,
-0.0519278646,
0.0082726628,
0.0308327936,
-0.0027210675,
0.0159013942,
0.0296346862,
-0.0304968115,
0.0342149027,
-0.0224451758,
0.022554297,
-0.0127180507,
0.0269447304,
0.0117165111,
0.0044796932,
0.0540542938,
-0.0185692552,
-0.0086767673,
-0.0180416275,
-0.0495526418,
0.0208189003,
-0.0189291481,
-0.0151097169,
0.019873932,
0.0080285156,
-0.0300356764,
-0.00537901,
-0.0391337052,
-0.0353365503,
-0.0743353739,
-0.0243112445,
0.0331373997,
-0.0061824699,
0.0418401174,
0.0088698426,
-0.049958609,
0.0186878145,
0.0405844003,
-0.0258756019,
-0.0413719192,
0.0202891305,
-0.0011587858,
0.0422978885,
0.0152606787,
0.0516522937,
-0.0245904438,
-0.0141342394,
0.0390775688,
-0.0830147564,
0.0236851349,
0.0045406395,
-0.00136567,
0.0627684221,
0.0217907764,
0.0317868181,
0.0152838994,
-0.0002807591,
0.0178506579,
-0.0325136706,
0.0137477303,
-6.067009198e-33,
-0.0054714559,
-0.0215852764,
-0.0334024131,
-0.0043664537,
-0.0239899829,
-0.0025341862,
0.0430004261,
-0.004394568,
-0.0174929909,
0.0091002779,
0.0078472327,
0.0370637365,
-0.0168016925,
0.0019018945,
0.0054466063,
-0.0383323468,
0.0182161108,
-0.0159916691,
-0.0469799191,
0.0088174939,
0.070792228,
0.0136820218,
0.0294536483,
-0.1166116074,
0.0380390175,
0.0275558773,
-0.028291313,
0.0347326621,
0.0361284725,
0.0775552318,
-0.023984326,
0.0566242225,
0.0523798652,
-0.0213634428,
0.0077896193,
-0.0058190003,
-0.0641887933,
-0.0111948559,
0.0078707403,
0.0059415367,
-0.0029175298,
-0.0081468681,
0.0361031331,
-0.0024198405,
-0.0235213879,
-0.0454640053,
0.0241347123,
-0.0604399145,
-0.0060416665,
-0.0320424698,
-0.0677720234,
0.0206735525,
-0.0398645811,
0.0213501621,
-0.0453240015,
0.0391433947,
0.0202821419,
-0.0069274018,
-0.096170485,
-0.01325648,
-0.0205874648,
-0.0308386348,
-0.0293432251,
-0.0406545922,
0.0136339236,
0.0664412603,
-0.004511016,
0.0582174212,
-0.0162836593,
-0.001766623,
0.0162225366,
0.0120786373,
0.0405635498,
0.0188622847,
0.0276076142,
-0.075751394,
-0.0354573242,
-0.0145421205,
0.0697882846,
0.0061222725,
0.0017403855,
-0.0394359976,
-0.0331776477,
-0.0204951782,
-0.0249124505,
-0.0143611785,
-0.0318002962,
-0.0069199298,
0.0261699185,
0.0076295328,
-0.0581128895,
-0.0054251351,
-0.0245631672,
-0.0371947661,
0.0198002476,
0.0206742715,
-0.0214227438,
0.0026794027,
0.0548025891,
0.0411993451,
-0.0487812012,
0.0055922633,
0.0059574712,
-0.0539767221,
0.0337615535,
-0.0320474096,
0.1120563596,
0.0716794729,
-0.0612217747,
0.0038873113,
0.0240715351,
0.0956948623,
-0.0173734669,
0.0537902862,
0.0029268062,
0.045663707,
-0.0030354573,
-0.0175930522,
0.0609266683,
0.0185721368,
-0.0441269726,
0.0306461845,
-0.0061150482,
-0.001848745,
-0.0050735301,
-0.0488777645,
0.0149168754,
0.0354025289,
-0.002990219,
-0.1217514798,
0.0305418223,
-0.0373297334,
2.663e-7,
0.0063677593,
0.0392424725,
0.0045120385,
-0.0270606652,
0.0533754714,
0.0010220333,
0.0370969921,
0.0344315842,
-0.0099714845,
-0.0111438185,
-0.01239709,
0.0450484529,
0.0054106219,
0.0642466918,
0.0114524066,
-0.0478080511,
-0.0620613396,
0.0130529655,
-0.0666394979,
0.0312493425,
-0.0080784922,
0.0685073659,
0.0612149052,
-0.0397403017,
-0.0109298872,
-0.0418218635,
0.0326388031,
-0.0301637948,
0.0329663903,
-0.0507267602,
0.0443051271,
0.0600600317,
0.0027865458,
-0.0184360389,
-0.0185900964,
0.0234950315,
-0.0201292373,
0.0185836535,
0.015665805,
-0.0158904083,
0.016247496,
0.001086126,
0.0112914238,
-0.0180515312,
0.0476243533,
-0.0325684771,
0.0025331434,
-0.0625587478,
-0.0079180896,
-0.0187121257,
0.0419152007,
-0.0022755521,
-0.0003476591,
0.0038922881,
0.0229713507,
0.008954172,
0.0170186907,
-0.0678503513,
0.0129662622,
-0.0337719657,
-0.0389237963,
-0.0108009744,
-0.0333289355,
-0.0014985746,
0.0200332124,
0.0207423959,
0.0565865561,
1.965938308e-34,
0.0245659668,
-0.0419721007,
0.011775407,
-0.0253605023,
0.00042729,
0.0264808107,
-0.014893746,
-0.0228176676,
0.0335130543,
-0.0096786106,
0.005083146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16898v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16898v1 | A Sign Language Recognition System with Pepper, Lightweight-Transformer, and LLM | 2023-09-28T23:54:41 | 2023-09-28T23:54:41 | JongYoon Lim, Inkyu Sa, Bruce MacDonald, Ho Seok Ahn | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.HC | This research explores using lightweight deep neural network architectures to
enable the humanoid robot Pepper to understand American Sign Language (ASL) and
facilitate non-verbal human-robot interaction. First, we introduce a
lightweight and efficient model for ASL understanding optimized for embedded
systems, ensuring rapid sign recognition while conserving computational
resources. Building upon this, we employ large language models (LLMs) for
intelligent robot interactions. Through intricate prompt engineering, we tailor
interactions to allow the Pepper Robot to generate natural Co-Speech Gesture
responses, laying the foundation for more organic and intuitive humanoid-robot
dialogues. Finally, we present an integrated software pipeline, embodying
advancements in a socially aware AI interaction model. Leveraging the Pepper
Robot's capabilities, we demonstrate the practicality and effectiveness of our
approach in real-world scenarios. The results highlight a profound potential
for enhancing human-robot interaction through non-verbal interactions, bridging
communication gaps, and making technology more accessible and understandable. | [
-0.0227397233,
0.0460266247,
-0.0148413209,
0.0379582606,
0.0109547572,
0.0140209878,
0.0389491096,
-0.0222082902,
0.0390654244,
-0.015727859,
-0.0428194404,
0.008805682,
-0.0138280103,
0.0429492295,
-0.0005026748,
-0.0303744487,
0.0291701853,
-0.0142839234,
-0.0150037427,
-0.0091327513,
-0.00685082,
-0.0206129756,
-0.0416767411,
0.0591691732,
-0.0737783238,
0.0089527639,
-0.0639312565,
0.0013523579,
0.0261117388,
-0.0102807572,
-0.043234542,
0.0175926406,
0.0467623286,
0.0410720259,
0.0000019936,
-0.007433163,
0.031315662,
0.0162082091,
-0.0120498734,
-0.0287471954,
0.0306718871,
-0.0234588254,
-0.0354119577,
0.0228508338,
-0.0365700759,
-0.0359809548,
0.0389608182,
0.1122390479,
0.0275699813,
0.0158883631,
0.0016188879,
-0.013443674,
0.0180581082,
-0.0185616054,
-0.0043267352,
-0.0258388575,
0.0139409415,
-0.0455085784,
0.0440032929,
0.005711162,
-0.0320214592,
0.0339013264,
0.0630797371,
-0.0467307344,
-0.0271255989,
0.0332868099,
-0.0257335939,
-0.0279386751,
-0.0066236188,
0.0504174531,
-0.0201724768,
0.0100388955,
0.02568537,
0.0119524598,
0.0410156026,
-0.0223908573,
0.0073620528,
0.023030106,
0.0177147426,
-0.0004286932,
-0.0260686073,
-0.0189672895,
0.0279119276,
0.0335645229,
0.0089353267,
0.1066594422,
0.0036875699,
0.0100895232,
-0.0078722211,
-0.0304521509,
0.0402429029,
-0.0362004749,
0.0536289252,
0.0580193475,
-0.0209019277,
0.0007469934,
-0.0384484343,
0.0036766876,
-0.0177398119,
-0.0351417512,
-0.0869524553,
0.0391032249,
-0.0220482983,
0.0199110154,
0.0196875986,
0.028224919,
-0.012097571,
0.0426863804,
0.0157483239,
0.0145957554,
-0.0122394115,
0.0140682757,
-0.0493364297,
0.0147900376,
-0.0101813646,
-0.0513163544,
0.0147589715,
0.0431280099,
-0.0029513871,
-0.0179587416,
-0.0067188041,
0.0571928173,
0.0130576165,
0.0028996011,
-0.0173186827,
0.0339497812,
-0.0204940569,
0.0312747322,
0.0196410604,
-0.0940564945,
-0.0211449675,
0.0319846347,
-0.0025764175,
0.0035373662,
0.0138443243,
0.081307888,
-0.0046894196,
-0.0451195762,
0.0238444563,
0.0303187706,
0.012394622,
-0.0313222371,
0.0145283788,
-0.0338744447,
0.020794265,
-0.0082871309,
0.0113600027,
-0.0787055418,
0.029634634,
-0.0158702265,
0.021592848,
0.0595575348,
0.0196684208,
-0.0038385333,
0.0644610897,
0.0109002953,
0.0068806359,
0.004513233,
0.0773791149,
0.0411261097,
-0.0139630949,
-0.0198167916,
-0.0056943437,
0.0351168588,
-0.0834035203,
-0.0373324491,
0.0347141325,
-0.0545619242,
-0.0165973566,
0.0633913055,
-0.0037800823,
0.0551484525,
-0.0134500982,
-0.0239427686,
0.0473757312,
0.0774610937,
-0.0538124256,
0.0414582342,
0.0287102498,
0.0287289228,
0.0108728157,
-0.0589372776,
-0.0428382568,
0.0360029638,
-0.0280413888,
-0.0412086695,
-0.0576229729,
0.0409978889,
-0.066580072,
-0.0346911624,
0.0193839781,
-0.0377414227,
0.0748533979,
0.0459555574,
0.063554585,
-0.0002157976,
-0.0346728042,
0.0198751334,
-0.0175238047,
-0.0468660481,
-0.0052191908,
-0.0226186533,
-0.0066042459,
0.0330319107,
-0.0025473628,
-0.0349570923,
0.0176691953,
0.0039422382,
-0.0301077161,
0.0814685374,
0.0219492726,
0.0093148015,
0.0185800064,
-0.0097135035,
-0.0019234741,
0.0466618873,
0.0060120816,
0.0614644215,
-0.0338790491,
0.0257307645,
0.024802912,
0.0392391346,
0.0018625429,
0.0261643827,
-0.0150449127,
-0.0152451061,
0.0270640254,
0.0168255176,
0.0419032164,
0.033120539,
0.0115697235,
-0.0282926206,
0.0594241805,
-0.0288229194,
-0.0357173495,
0.0608294792,
-0.039603103,
0.0090415506,
0.0508288667,
-0.032476671,
-0.0268436167,
0.0380063541,
-0.0023553132,
-0.0572512746,
0.053552568,
-0.0651537329,
0.0582798161,
-0.0303670242,
0.0374582112,
0.008589128,
0.0351179168,
-0.0245509818,
-0.0183630511,
-0.0115423379,
-0.0517637581,
0.0085242977,
0.0095356144,
0.0086249439,
-0.0687652603,
-0.0416433103,
0.0190930404,
-0.0201026443,
-0.0033794309,
0.0081050014,
0.0358402617,
-0.0258243494,
-0.0165753104,
-0.0950457454,
-0.0306952205,
-0.0056706611,
-0.0298929717,
-0.0160516948,
0.0148870088,
0.0220858399,
-0.0338204913,
-0.0103509072,
0.0513091385,
0.0065514464,
-0.0404064544,
0.0260078721,
0.0133548351,
-0.04904598,
-0.0027116418,
0.0060616643,
0.0030256214,
0.0052521452,
-0.0032439395,
-0.0231671445,
-0.0354857855,
0.0116110789,
-0.0017369598,
0.0817144439,
-0.0277270582,
-0.0527564883,
0.0461638384,
0.0012263234,
0.0031068418,
0.0663171336,
0.0038023405,
0.0349360369,
0.0729540735,
0.0083767381,
-0.0356265008,
0.0270179342,
0.0156152556,
0.0529231429,
-0.0437996835,
-0.006881706,
-0.016968986,
0.0603520237,
-0.0171338059,
0.0275805742,
-0.0506704077,
-0.054866869,
0.0501019396,
-0.0893104523,
0.0140901273,
0.028470384,
-0.0375868902,
-0.0282304827,
0.004460474,
-0.0469789356,
0.0366669893,
-0.0691326112,
-0.0389058925,
0.0356759168,
-0.0288218763,
-0.0181635562,
0.0441007614,
0.0314288214,
0.0136306165,
-0.0061750915,
-0.0256053731,
-0.0056915041,
0.0710479096,
-0.0513639301,
-0.0229076985,
0.0396355875,
-0.0589357205,
0.0024071832,
-0.0072154324,
-0.0219786763,
-0.0346228071,
0.0337450579,
-0.0702961534,
0.0517481938,
0.0201703161,
-0.0669177398,
-0.0286675654,
0.0129202353,
0.0235060006,
0.0646921843,
0.0207233578,
0.0098576425,
-0.0449613817,
-0.0657023266,
0.0398760885,
0.06299036,
0.0040748501,
0.0245686397,
0.0312747769,
0.0045138332,
0.0330383591,
-0.0224788468,
-0.0653031915,
-0.0008889391,
0.0453591645,
0.0202517901,
-0.0079404432,
0.0315926112,
0.0227194075,
-0.0137529681,
-0.0138134398,
0.0877183527,
0.0021623217,
-0.0674114078,
0.0149141997,
-0.0078760106,
-0.0200984385,
0.0088548595,
0.0193913821,
-0.0474556126,
-0.0447543375,
0.0150761725,
-0.0170937255,
0.0068090637,
-0.031723801,
-0.0288169831,
-0.0932801291,
-0.0180330221,
-0.0137198698,
-0.0233767852,
-0.0539336167,
-0.0077821515,
0.0069873948,
0.0167696923,
0.0223639365,
0.0027100914,
-0.0113029648,
-0.0452925526,
0.0007093698,
-0.0208921041,
-0.0377788953,
0.034122102,
0.0009574557,
0.0224128738,
0.0525844619,
0.025615789,
-0.0303756054,
-0.0465167947,
0.0012225662,
0.0342997834,
0.0387051217,
-0.0333722532,
-0.0356118642,
-0.0059288177,
-0.0365470201,
0.018303372,
0.0393755734,
-0.0992467552,
-0.0046259705,
-0.0112033673,
0.0582587123,
-0.0638564676,
0.0014540316,
0.0035418719,
-0.0232613496,
-0.0035802829,
0.0495349541,
0.004872527,
-0.0525375865,
-0.0288253073,
-0.0215822104,
-0.037633568,
0.0690062046,
-0.0265841838,
-0.0085926233,
-0.0182400923,
-0.0964300036,
-0.0257309005,
-0.0520435087,
0.0307312422,
0.020931717,
0.0072135958,
-0.0329935998,
0.0418734029,
0.0553495139,
-0.0201070067,
0.0511874668,
-0.011787327,
0.0343541354,
-0.0610487238,
-0.0005444402,
0.0070289886,
-0.0699213669,
0.0019922846,
0.0113919117,
-0.0479484126,
-0.0467614643,
0.046093192,
0.0426391922,
0.0216597132,
0.0031608958,
-0.0299569126,
-0.0651236102,
-0.0329864323,
0.0611766763,
0.0027221434,
0.0254198276,
0.0312024467,
-0.0246820785,
0.0140732015,
0.0262609124,
-0.0336195119,
0.0133628724,
-0.0140245548,
-0.0117447842,
-0.0878157094,
-0.1016766876,
0.0017290103,
0.0225699637,
0.0283543393,
0.009214838,
-0.0001934521,
-0.0119676581,
0.0111336932,
-0.0203702766,
0.0344563574,
-0.0740072951,
-0.0264395922,
-0.0068746852,
0.0301446803,
0.0347463898,
0.041217342,
0.013212882,
0.0218513664,
0.0399932899,
0.041108042,
0.0097995633,
0.0456417724,
-0.0127663305,
0.0175565295,
0.017990632,
0.0153459879,
-0.0097494898,
0.0211938061,
0.006816213,
0.0682941973,
-0.0029997332,
-0.0002517009,
-0.0184484702,
0.064129442,
-0.024720503,
-0.1096376106,
0.0137458574,
0.0532989092,
0.014298534,
0.0184760932,
0.0217148568,
-0.0651466772,
0.020936694,
-0.031283211,
0.0464908667,
0.0059175268,
-0.0415715463,
0.0645851716,
0.0124392398,
-0.0064936779,
0.0251441523,
0.0240255371,
-0.058400996,
0.0045438926,
0.014228235,
0.0180774629,
-0.0263345856,
-0.0040089502,
0.0125555145,
-0.0212030429,
-0.0228716098,
-0.027859157,
-0.0099703399,
-0.0462884344,
-0.0119708646,
0.0058759428,
0.0276110787,
-0.0322759934,
0.0528742112,
0.0070941509,
-0.0141447857,
-0.0206731223,
-0.0041787056,
-0.001020959,
-0.0038768244,
-0.0361110754,
-0.037664149,
-5.694421937e-33,
-0.0383424088,
-0.0599902421,
-0.0090047792,
0.0100572249,
-0.0221651886,
-0.0003079409,
-0.0656087771,
0.0112587558,
-0.0394788869,
0.0016807563,
-0.0265767146,
0.0239225551,
0.01613966,
0.0001205806,
0.0016372544,
-0.0231358614,
0.0598384626,
0.0045730961,
0.0310971625,
0.014164797,
0.0042695003,
0.0180968139,
0.0058368947,
-0.1051849574,
-0.0107368836,
0.0050691753,
-0.0261594914,
-0.0015265407,
-0.0202735178,
-0.0131400255,
-0.0287943445,
0.0198694766,
-0.0071619214,
0.0110444203,
0.0025781258,
0.0612387322,
-0.0690267533,
0.0124717504,
-0.0470521003,
0.06239409,
-0.0109465979,
-0.0353725068,
0.0358277597,
0.001675519,
-0.0464158654,
0.0232581347,
0.0327900238,
-0.0356414951,
0.0052647088,
-0.0512315556,
-0.0110028535,
0.0156809073,
-0.010796885,
-0.0514018536,
0.0187599137,
0.0183759965,
-0.0368022397,
0.0320680887,
-0.0102898777,
0.0140718287,
-0.0089365458,
-0.030896211,
0.076459989,
-0.0137485852,
0.0672831982,
0.03492672,
0.0310600139,
-0.0400034413,
0.0122240176,
-0.0514828749,
0.060184896,
0.0566217676,
0.0238547772,
0.043024946,
0.0261179097,
-0.0231877062,
-0.0462018028,
0.0066033388,
0.0819875672,
0.0607751608,
-0.0385625176,
0.0322713666,
-0.0260900445,
0.0070966799,
-0.0160276238,
-0.0228928626,
0.0004428922,
-0.0636865422,
0.0107249888,
0.017688619,
0.0122664226,
-0.0411119014,
0.030676512,
-0.0376689509,
0.0223165173,
0.0071519725,
0.0149224959,
0.0181846656,
0.0170487873,
-0.0005630112,
-0.030066153,
-0.0514513403,
0.0200819355,
-0.0115229422,
0.035204865,
0.0229475982,
-0.0160757396,
0.090584971,
-0.0080160331,
-0.0310114957,
-0.0355295651,
0.0126341879,
0.0487856232,
0.0323697738,
0.020195784,
-0.028142143,
-0.0283726081,
0.0704566464,
-0.0384213552,
0.014852385,
-0.0387373939,
0.0219411682,
-0.0030100693,
-0.0122852623,
-0.0522632599,
-0.0198622383,
-0.0114035392,
0.0370360948,
0.0470919982,
-0.0859777406,
-0.0027415904,
-0.0102489963,
2.824e-7,
-0.039897643,
0.0310895331,
0.0110742245,
0.0368010961,
0.0304631889,
0.0513664968,
0.0109252958,
0.0721895397,
-0.0099172508,
-0.0077639143,
0.0037180532,
0.0271460935,
0.0358446166,
-0.0016003643,
-0.0838763118,
-0.0284694098,
-0.0214023776,
-0.0297232755,
0.0129684582,
0.00766603,
0.014770736,
0.0772900432,
0.0096047679,
-0.0142573211,
0.0410960764,
-0.0285168495,
0.0283580553,
-0.0694991127,
0.0332129486,
-0.0276886784,
0.0317490436,
-0.0219175238,
0.000786918,
-0.0022758527,
0.007669989,
0.0182890873,
-0.021903282,
0.0517131612,
-0.0639355853,
-0.0314601287,
0.0323707052,
0.0076413183,
-0.0384668894,
0.0007931367,
0.0331804082,
-0.0594490618,
-0.0144311776,
-0.0094686076,
0.016965935,
-0.0319186673,
-0.0355550535,
0.0076081804,
0.0223316438,
0.0062511843,
-0.0151646994,
-0.0933380425,
0.0177096874,
-0.0421516597,
0.0104422802,
-0.017998578,
-0.1071611494,
-0.0317993648,
-0.0478284247,
-0.0395112187,
0.0051601171,
0.0067737703,
-0.0219261255,
1.942463318e-34,
0.0091336276,
0.007127264,
-0.0126556205,
0.0571691394,
0.0122251017,
-0.0006394273,
0.0215374921,
0.0404690877,
0.0353343114,
-0.0747418702,
-0.0353652686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16844v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16844v2 | DeBERTinha: A Multistep Approach to Adapt DebertaV3 XSmall for Brazilian Portuguese Natural Language Processing Task | 2023-09-28T20:53:25 | 2023-10-31T00:14:18 | Israel Campiotti, Matheus Rodrigues, Yuri Albuquerque, Rafael Azevedo, Alyson Andrade | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents an approach for adapting the DebertaV3 XSmall model
pre-trained in English for Brazilian Portuguese natural language processing
(NLP) tasks. A key aspect of the methodology involves a multistep training
process to ensure the model is effectively tuned for the Portuguese language.
Initial datasets from Carolina and BrWac are preprocessed to address issues
like emojis, HTML tags, and encodings. A Portuguese-specific vocabulary of
50,000 tokens is created using SentencePiece. Rather than training from
scratch, the weights of the pre-trained English model are used to initialize
most of the network, with random embeddings, recognizing the expensive cost of
training from scratch. The model is fine-tuned using the replaced token
detection task in the same format of DebertaV3 training. The adapted model,
called DeBERTinha, demonstrates effectiveness on downstream tasks like named
entity recognition, sentiment analysis, and determining sentence relatedness,
outperforming BERTimbau-Large in two tasks despite having only 40M parameters. | [
0.0410542004,
0.0317498296,
0.0115596373,
0.040591605,
-0.0072959336,
0.041701477,
-0.0469116382,
-0.0153056029,
0.0002043694,
-0.0620012879,
-0.0214671381,
-0.0063754087,
-0.035931848,
0.0238704104,
0.0208387617,
-0.0007151325,
0.0814348385,
0.0260873996,
-0.0069043725,
-0.0093172751,
0.0262127928,
0.0045303917,
0.0049803043,
0.0229566023,
-0.0334250405,
0.0176280253,
-0.0217113197,
-0.0070019099,
-0.0147202732,
-0.0286640543,
0.0299212132,
0.0412072688,
-0.0210028384,
0.0489529632,
0.0000020659,
-0.0533845723,
-0.0510289408,
-0.0287025385,
0.0196178667,
-0.0640278012,
0.0487074442,
0.0112842126,
-0.021549318,
0.0335279256,
-0.0820334777,
-0.0371978953,
0.0416546911,
0.0457400344,
0.0516327657,
0.1016780585,
-0.0200517569,
-0.0416281447,
-0.0060076644,
-0.0114418175,
-0.0209885892,
0.0075823949,
0.0167226996,
-0.0325143039,
-0.0111643597,
0.0283642206,
0.0151699279,
0.0127340201,
0.0037979847,
-0.0063987421,
0.038783513,
-0.0087186303,
-0.0551622026,
-0.0266046021,
-0.0322299711,
0.0519447215,
-0.0564611815,
-0.0289473757,
-0.0123064332,
0.0228950698,
0.0064245793,
-0.0486508831,
-0.0191636514,
-0.0467227213,
-0.0025928717,
0.0356176198,
0.0684063658,
-0.003019999,
0.0174175985,
0.0295596886,
-0.0015400574,
0.0257272515,
0.0060894755,
-0.026306048,
0.0349498168,
0.0108822025,
-0.0344256647,
-0.0434390455,
0.0369575061,
0.0018586867,
0.0039674649,
0.0244641621,
-0.0108616967,
-0.0350880437,
0.0413583554,
-0.0723995641,
-0.0323928967,
0.024840666,
0.0029039637,
0.0245247055,
-0.0811830312,
0.0209649578,
-0.0315926559,
0.0143023692,
-0.0137652028,
-0.041112747,
-0.0539346039,
-0.0175587274,
-0.0741510764,
0.0745000392,
-0.059562061,
0.0182619672,
-0.042841401,
0.0074436297,
0.0067842212,
-0.042584952,
0.0064959698,
0.0150534725,
-0.0241724551,
0.0383979268,
-0.025356885,
0.0523132794,
-0.0336125754,
0.0228791907,
-0.0060576322,
-0.0654439554,
0.0165848266,
-0.0090164784,
-0.0225873068,
-0.0304471832,
0.0419379137,
0.0376011357,
-0.0143733099,
-0.038669683,
-0.0386843681,
-0.0140024712,
-0.0052500777,
-0.0688430369,
0.0057358108,
-0.0742238835,
-0.0235181339,
0.013243475,
0.0289605614,
-0.0071782749,
0.0117642507,
0.0121493256,
-0.0193756875,
0.0620641336,
-0.0407677926,
-0.0256399363,
-0.0293779578,
-0.0092490893,
0.0214660577,
0.0798791349,
-0.0069626821,
0.0325582474,
0.0317940153,
0.0218883026,
-0.0189005211,
0.0344902575,
0.0142250927,
-0.0010212775,
-0.039081201,
0.0419521481,
0.0034821483,
0.0080655003,
0.049866911,
0.0255395696,
-0.023333095,
0.0270874295,
0.0136327092,
0.0418217927,
-0.0093796896,
0.0499123409,
0.0436239652,
-0.0300365929,
0.0079570767,
-0.0154723935,
-0.0164367277,
-0.0106477272,
0.0215994678,
0.0095455498,
-0.036709629,
0.0385145955,
-0.0270159543,
-0.0226689558,
0.0248948503,
-0.0173255373,
0.0026378357,
-0.0630673766,
0.0574293099,
0.0100735743,
-0.0454420336,
0.0412537642,
0.0187155139,
-0.057802286,
-0.024685476,
-0.0728653446,
0.0271575097,
0.0453987569,
0.0234307311,
-0.0293211229,
-0.0046005384,
-0.0209479239,
0.0333488062,
0.0491166934,
0.0034350015,
-0.0147780105,
0.0052009616,
-0.0500322506,
-0.0201246608,
-0.0216448791,
0.0262013674,
0.0461480916,
-0.0051881503,
0.0535398386,
0.0020545921,
-0.0153959105,
-0.0123004988,
0.0576738603,
-0.0082310103,
-0.0186624248,
0.0017648177,
0.0139822233,
0.0522215813,
0.0363149643,
0.0030642333,
-0.0221512131,
0.0132301114,
-0.0316040032,
-0.0047131339,
0.0177381728,
-0.0090692583,
-0.0297085997,
0.028354032,
-0.0499566905,
-0.013231298,
0.0741610155,
-0.0384171642,
-0.0274721552,
0.0171570051,
-0.0475619063,
0.0487077422,
-0.0336209312,
-0.0037793026,
-0.0493801944,
0.0375169516,
0.0024696162,
0.0649300367,
-0.0099551398,
0.0004911897,
-0.002780112,
-0.0269522369,
0.0552936867,
0.0082983905,
-0.0470947437,
-0.0033166576,
-0.0172599554,
-0.0139201656,
0.0136495642,
0.0581238307,
-0.0311326832,
-0.032448791,
-0.13493523,
0.0172313061,
-0.0279745758,
0.0204783734,
0.0400749519,
0.0249590725,
-0.0183335245,
-0.0465630926,
-0.013518203,
-0.0251371935,
0.0015794799,
-0.0106321145,
0.0282749496,
-0.0186877809,
-0.0117792422,
-0.0241543502,
-0.00136026,
-0.0141183706,
0.0377216525,
0.017998809,
-0.0873551145,
-0.0110863028,
0.032330215,
-0.0277288165,
0.034943901,
0.0233957209,
-0.0711430088,
-0.0121687632,
0.0523025952,
0.0586665533,
0.0567586273,
-0.0073823868,
0.0180485602,
0.0050397255,
0.0059679919,
-0.0355767012,
0.0121053075,
-0.0363157466,
0.0240459125,
-0.0611534826,
-0.0194564816,
0.0443598814,
0.0613489188,
-0.0250507463,
-0.0164592657,
-0.0160767604,
-0.0026800479,
-0.0136914738,
-0.0401995629,
0.0005064323,
-0.0008202581,
-0.0164197274,
-0.0253285766,
-0.0050442829,
-0.0451139137,
0.045069728,
-0.0171839539,
0.0128353853,
-0.1541340798,
-0.0038540068,
-0.011673769,
0.0139113413,
-0.0002234658,
0.0188227072,
-0.0190387703,
-0.0122225797,
-0.0311615299,
0.0126484167,
-0.0015792331,
-0.0122162635,
-0.0085416958,
0.0121896369,
0.0299013518,
0.0086430795,
-0.0357381105,
-0.0182605125,
-0.0567642562,
-0.0406183675,
0.028680712,
0.0533119403,
0.0220665317,
-0.0499077328,
0.0220300294,
-0.0051593175,
0.0579374246,
-0.0304715242,
-0.0097488826,
-0.0143802408,
0.0451990254,
0.0026357162,
-0.0282416698,
0.0422857702,
-0.0153449913,
0.0253023021,
0.0291203074,
0.032671351,
-0.0470747352,
-0.0527847856,
0.0351307616,
0.0029844365,
-0.0321402699,
-0.021004945,
-0.061069902,
0.0366266482,
-0.0254683793,
-0.0202772636,
0.0790445879,
0.0110982182,
-0.0442943387,
-0.0096204598,
-0.0127657568,
-0.0003925925,
0.0429040827,
0.0253136083,
-0.0713499114,
-0.0528016463,
0.0116257016,
-0.0156242438,
-0.0262682401,
0.0050322143,
0.0052254009,
-0.1385532469,
-0.0066233566,
-0.0336607136,
-0.0368790813,
-0.011717665,
-0.0528780185,
-0.0164965931,
-0.0578818657,
0.024912443,
-0.0227917302,
-0.0046110814,
0.0276872572,
0.0432789214,
0.0236452781,
-0.0701036528,
-0.0223160628,
-0.0379937626,
0.0156075507,
0.0692531317,
0.0234814435,
-0.0208326969,
-0.0056230226,
0.0629657954,
-0.0119869821,
0.0022993907,
-0.0413650312,
0.0290649962,
-0.0126833105,
-0.0104101421,
-0.0501464903,
0.0280469526,
-0.0016182987,
0.0237723235,
0.0045169089,
0.0799637511,
0.0144976201,
0.025382638,
-0.0555171669,
-0.0269358475,
-0.0149799865,
0.0372916199,
0.0111476565,
-0.060805779,
-0.0345437489,
0.0204736404,
-0.0190324262,
-0.0146060269,
0.0276221,
0.0032767188,
-0.0553999133,
-0.0149902124,
-0.0672408789,
-0.0309184976,
0.0363183096,
0.0569160134,
-0.005149398,
0.024888847,
-0.0304201543,
0.0036281287,
-0.0498247929,
0.0584005602,
0.0482347012,
0.0196004156,
-0.0331724994,
0.0034838184,
0.01081842,
0.0408057757,
-0.0521684065,
-0.0490784496,
-0.0597319491,
-0.0462417938,
0.0031280278,
0.0595338456,
0.0217471961,
0.0341349728,
-0.0390385613,
-0.0611178875,
0.0478144288,
0.0388397276,
-0.0617070049,
-0.0167947933,
0.0098004304,
-0.0053119338,
0.002430405,
0.0368978456,
0.0226172023,
0.0070290794,
0.035489805,
0.0367599167,
0.0090063028,
0.0487999581,
-0.0138790263,
0.0064578671,
0.0481586307,
-0.0078439247,
-0.0009919826,
-0.0510370396,
0.0211687721,
0.0231044982,
0.0273290668,
-0.0382157639,
0.0369150788,
0.0023289716,
0.0010457546,
-0.0274963025,
0.0129352119,
-0.0185984652,
-0.0146865761,
-0.002392468,
0.0394910425,
-0.001468625,
0.0435909443,
-0.0068807411,
0.0220883228,
0.0053566713,
0.0160263181,
0.0236967951,
-0.0101799509,
-0.0548426472,
0.030243855,
0.0226297006,
-0.0287601706,
0.0039113397,
0.0463198572,
0.0099221775,
0.0426522866,
-0.0632491633,
0.0304264501,
0.0604277141,
-0.0367158949,
0.0420530923,
-0.0071652192,
-0.0126349218,
0.0083193267,
0.0027500379,
-0.019222185,
0.0163357705,
0.0249053128,
-0.0198787004,
-0.0599568337,
-0.0191447623,
0.056477651,
-0.0042616851,
0.0260551944,
0.0343860425,
0.0012399848,
-0.0218261611,
0.0209454913,
0.0924401432,
0.0018744585,
-0.0450427197,
0.005113503,
-0.0052137561,
-0.0675122216,
-0.0124355759,
-0.0145873204,
-0.0185821131,
0.0275281258,
0.060018979,
0.0589909367,
0.0274418555,
0.0022533801,
-0.000731789,
-0.0047066151,
-0.0138548296,
-0.022111278,
0.0026716667,
-5.864011242e-33,
0.0135728745,
-0.0140315173,
0.0032980912,
-0.0465623811,
0.0026134206,
0.0105784265,
-0.0261999015,
-0.0006545905,
-0.0103389323,
0.0346205905,
0.0211583395,
0.0413720906,
0.0237929262,
0.0121059874,
-0.0044058203,
0.0116832796,
0.0449219421,
-0.0206377208,
-0.0046651168,
0.0185174029,
0.0421764776,
0.05957257,
0.0839365944,
-0.0187673029,
-0.016498331,
0.022645859,
-0.0079187145,
0.0563686043,
0.0342486203,
0.0533826835,
-0.01917696,
0.0147115523,
0.0131313019,
-0.0498302877,
-0.0062259887,
0.0248431135,
-0.0751834363,
-0.0499138832,
0.0272568949,
0.0529899113,
0.0151792187,
-0.0135730896,
0.0499180146,
0.0046752123,
-0.0161533486,
0.0429172851,
0.0405584648,
-0.0237480588,
0.0083310269,
-0.0310986731,
-0.0568579249,
0.0478976667,
0.0275276806,
0.03273632,
0.0373839401,
0.0681014806,
-0.0018238929,
-0.0478134453,
-0.0029753358,
-0.0206471868,
-0.0476190262,
0.0153675005,
0.007077565,
-0.0189359616,
0.0275724232,
0.0619676784,
0.0602489449,
-0.0283624716,
0.0021620612,
0.0293344259,
0.0724018663,
0.0281982236,
0.0569185913,
0.0439226255,
0.038958773,
-0.015924925,
-0.1283167154,
-0.0019846417,
-0.0042449157,
0.0520239919,
0.010538755,
-0.0320012011,
-0.0101592522,
0.0305582453,
-0.0180166326,
0.0029152166,
-0.0303552784,
-0.0389922075,
0.0170472208,
-0.0134179965,
-0.0523616374,
-0.0248527955,
0.008350051,
-0.0461245961,
-0.0364153124,
0.0086144917,
-0.0039246408,
0.0127817616,
0.0125510283,
0.0442132764,
-0.0465268083,
-0.0383681357,
-0.0408558249,
0.0267090872,
0.0129937325,
-0.0103765475,
0.0639813393,
-0.0331062451,
-0.0699310228,
0.0186605807,
-0.0120126065,
0.0510007814,
-0.0195457507,
0.1236221865,
0.0216914564,
-0.0038791136,
-0.0108754206,
-0.013933084,
0.0223899074,
0.0181276537,
-0.0275959112,
-0.020110203,
0.0232970994,
0.053231433,
-0.0472091138,
-0.0193498768,
-0.043841891,
0.0511059314,
-0.0102054384,
-0.0657098889,
-0.0048981248,
0.0126635702,
2.819e-7,
0.0106595038,
0.0473330691,
0.0095679555,
-0.054638572,
-0.0001203343,
0.0153852487,
-0.006261921,
0.0342326835,
-0.0258235987,
0.0153578641,
-0.0200907905,
-0.0084804809,
0.0483041592,
0.0606871694,
-0.1047095284,
0.0137685519,
-0.0333575681,
-0.0013028617,
-0.0550529025,
0.0338108651,
-0.0545948744,
0.1266323775,
0.0248101763,
-0.0184856933,
-0.0407922901,
-0.0151772648,
0.0302568134,
0.0174752399,
0.0155427307,
-0.0064664045,
0.0411752276,
0.0727647617,
0.0022669493,
0.0139480419,
-0.017296657,
0.0638715476,
-0.0244823527,
0.0445354208,
-0.0313221663,
0.0510666594,
0.0573751889,
-0.0456392169,
-0.0208982676,
-0.0672261268,
0.037578769,
-0.0549399815,
-0.0282278806,
-0.0582566932,
-0.0031067051,
-0.022087466,
0.0338970944,
-0.014872998,
-0.0396344885,
0.0502379723,
0.037433587,
-0.0346641801,
-0.0280947369,
-0.0546416715,
0.0095507735,
0.0259037148,
-0.0140739158,
-0.0362580493,
-0.0444994159,
0.0682691783,
0.0423165038,
-0.0258756988,
0.0580918528,
2.534414264e-34,
0.0277213696,
-0.0444740094,
-0.0080539295,
0.0292715821,
0.0338980481,
-0.0224763844,
-0.0118267667,
-0.0190617926,
0.0073226462,
-0.0357113294,
0.0190450251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16804v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16804v1 | Curriculum-Driven Edubot: A Framework for Developing Language Learning Chatbots Through Synthesizing Conversational Data | 2023-09-28T19:14:18 | 2023-09-28T19:14:18 | Yu Li, Shang Qu, Jili Shen, Shangchao Min, Zhou Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Chatbots have become popular in educational settings, revolutionizing how
students interact with material and how teachers teach. We present
Curriculum-Driven EduBot, a framework for developing a chatbot that combines
the interactive features of chatbots with the systematic material of English
textbooks to assist students in enhancing their conversational skills. We begin
by extracting pertinent topics from textbooks and then using large language
models to generate dialogues related to these topics. We then fine-tune an
open-source LLM using our generated conversational data to create our
curriculum-driven chatbot. User studies demonstrate that our chatbot
outperforms ChatGPT in leading curriculum-based dialogues and adapting its
dialogue to match the user's English proficiency level. By combining
traditional textbook methodologies with conversational AI, our approach offers
learners an interactive tool that aligns with their curriculum and provides
user-tailored conversation practice. This facilitates meaningful student-bot
dialogues and enriches the overall learning experience within the curriculum's
pedagogical framework. | [
0.0460404642,
-0.0290724188,
-0.0441597514,
0.0116787599,
-0.0355763398,
0.0100426497,
0.0050951117,
-0.0437427759,
0.0545221642,
-0.0427855328,
-0.0095710894,
0.0392958559,
-0.018007569,
0.0358026139,
0.009012985,
-0.0703440979,
0.0192189384,
-0.0116656944,
0.0004976597,
0.0048457147,
0.0330224708,
0.0198732354,
-0.0555924177,
0.0529649742,
-0.0208780728,
-0.0308004301,
-0.0722407401,
0.0086877383,
-0.0065924884,
0.0207479447,
0.0636980832,
0.0267485343,
0.0180916674,
-0.0050183497,
0.0000018914,
-0.0379887596,
-0.0242985319,
-0.0486448258,
-0.0401253477,
-0.0289605539,
0.0701891929,
0.0768906996,
-0.0178342946,
0.0173616502,
-0.0468358323,
0.0828481317,
0.0436017886,
0.0270468742,
0.0769308954,
0.0671956241,
0.0140031232,
-0.0036804045,
0.0323256142,
0.0516911335,
0.0443033502,
-0.0120888567,
-0.0230802819,
0.0931843147,
0.0799361244,
0.0388493575,
-0.0358465686,
0.0269347634,
0.0359146334,
-0.0670932978,
0.0348518193,
0.0118885441,
-0.0308301654,
-0.0316117592,
-0.0102539361,
0.0838593468,
0.0402080975,
-0.0293369517,
-0.0021430161,
0.0198111106,
0.0506398231,
-0.0101644797,
-0.0793418214,
0.006606516,
0.0024005566,
0.017977085,
0.0030229762,
-0.0651055127,
-0.0243189018,
0.0263518374,
0.0018753387,
-0.0018314007,
-0.0110780615,
-0.0092613054,
-0.0114597268,
0.0005425308,
0.0085048722,
-0.0414955392,
0.0087663159,
0.0719960183,
-0.0379686132,
0.0420893617,
-0.0299442913,
-0.013846782,
-0.0098098079,
0.0182514749,
-0.0524107851,
0.0794690549,
-0.0202743951,
0.0197971128,
0.0278296322,
0.0543187819,
0.0396470428,
0.0509911887,
-0.0081027327,
-0.0194026362,
-0.0547014549,
-0.0175664984,
-0.0381733403,
0.0470456779,
0.0000166491,
-0.0068719303,
-0.0417004861,
0.0496118702,
-0.0024689641,
0.0490453504,
-0.0048820903,
0.0134741766,
-0.0308679882,
-0.0057156165,
-0.041751951,
0.0001584291,
-0.0166840479,
-0.016832212,
0.008913517,
-0.0639117882,
0.0141196875,
0.0139457406,
-0.0080595994,
-0.0051238555,
-0.0147838816,
0.041960299,
-0.0136032514,
-0.0397927575,
0.0044722147,
-0.0188644081,
0.0017638016,
-0.0333456993,
-0.0077305031,
-0.0597925149,
0.0094064288,
0.0001829305,
0.0128506208,
-0.0228752624,
0.0010225883,
0.0175765567,
0.008207228,
0.0472910963,
-0.0535033569,
-0.0144040398,
0.0715557486,
0.0349348038,
-0.0063107042,
0.0451469608,
0.0359519161,
-0.012576662,
0.0387568213,
-0.019230891,
0.0098002255,
0.0371131785,
-0.0033672361,
-0.025860576,
0.0182850249,
-0.0050417995,
0.0145833958,
0.0272643976,
-0.0174367204,
0.0176086314,
-0.0289438535,
0.0292027351,
0.0246373955,
0.0565914884,
-0.0453417525,
0.0485747792,
0.0146155069,
0.0482594371,
0.0579733066,
0.0563307926,
-0.0080011124,
0.0026846633,
-0.0087849125,
-0.0421193466,
0.043912109,
-0.0100390958,
0.0192098729,
-0.0711413994,
0.0195631478,
-0.0229105093,
0.0248804595,
0.0106128296,
0.0220989771,
0.0068451124,
0.0135045107,
0.0021117525,
0.0485060476,
-0.0572570078,
-0.0104768435,
-0.038007874,
0.026840549,
0.0878484845,
0.080556266,
-0.0590906963,
-0.0773820207,
0.0066533126,
0.0250598229,
0.0495070294,
0.0389994197,
-0.0494386517,
-0.0077973898,
-0.0301122982,
0.0095720282,
-0.0364827737,
-0.005039006,
-0.0274131987,
0.0141689386,
0.0157282092,
-0.0113565577,
-0.0072027915,
-0.043185655,
0.0231407844,
-0.0749191046,
-0.0151553163,
-0.0194696356,
0.0108732227,
-0.0092303017,
0.0389731191,
0.0183774829,
-0.0066656792,
0.0088624964,
0.0082685165,
0.0026145049,
0.025549788,
-0.0261577461,
-0.0429347903,
0.0780287981,
-0.0371832699,
-0.0315042064,
0.0066674994,
-0.0069753644,
-0.0262865238,
0.0181592107,
-0.0433632545,
0.0528556444,
-0.0071904878,
0.0314219706,
-0.0207891222,
0.0145068578,
-0.0329712629,
-0.0084134359,
0.0608154647,
-0.008031548,
0.0640305132,
0.0300729144,
-0.0096778162,
-0.0182247255,
0.0139334733,
0.0268336404,
0.0152786989,
-0.0017787979,
0.0271066297,
0.028963102,
-0.1202098206,
-0.0323358066,
-0.0926813558,
-0.0048017292,
0.0162893683,
-0.0264281128,
0.0214917101,
-0.003793682,
-0.0165881552,
-0.021418741,
-0.0588001199,
0.0279013887,
0.013136127,
-0.0212123115,
0.0428378657,
-0.019691484,
-0.0314285904,
-0.0693565235,
0.017763691,
-0.0172593929,
-0.005752732,
0.0599524304,
0.0190514624,
-0.039841827,
0.0291985124,
-0.0143170264,
0.0262688175,
-0.0055995961,
-0.0460089147,
0.0340247415,
-0.0414484963,
0.0636483133,
0.0491804332,
0.0206554756,
0.0735045522,
0.0288031995,
-0.0684517026,
-0.0804528818,
0.0353721008,
0.0060192146,
-0.0192924701,
-0.037170954,
-0.0358008333,
-0.0189482458,
-0.0216035247,
0.0113573307,
-0.0195476841,
-0.0547598675,
0.0475399271,
0.0519800372,
0.0015999149,
-0.0447118618,
0.0040333853,
-0.0331753455,
0.0028302523,
-0.0002688994,
-0.0046896474,
0.0591286607,
-0.0067750136,
-0.0078688711,
-0.0710685328,
-0.0063604605,
-0.0083999643,
0.0250707678,
-0.0107316673,
0.0032821447,
-0.0185107682,
-0.0184761845,
-0.0413290821,
0.0275385305,
0.0307905152,
-0.0560559295,
0.0092334617,
-0.0668936893,
-0.0249545481,
0.0306912381,
0.0053372835,
-0.0705104694,
0.0234609265,
-0.0235073119,
-0.0104634371,
0.0147878006,
-0.0313993953,
-0.0517777093,
-0.060656514,
0.0044799633,
0.0053540259,
-0.0299139787,
-0.0231187288,
0.0033391786,
-0.0103737675,
0.0268524103,
0.0350917652,
-0.0170416553,
-0.0059091966,
0.1168441176,
0.0342676453,
0.0066296002,
-0.0124356486,
0.0009274568,
-0.0160393994,
0.0429292135,
-0.0270091202,
-0.0037974541,
0.0034444253,
0.0293089002,
-0.0638858825,
-0.0278304629,
0.1338488758,
-0.0040679001,
-0.0450768769,
-0.0091819772,
-0.0687777624,
0.0259731356,
-0.0062369662,
0.0395347401,
-0.0811994895,
-0.014453236,
-0.0056661409,
0.0065041156,
-0.0257399082,
-0.0379727371,
-0.0324635319,
-0.081169419,
0.016301401,
0.0155849839,
-0.0004405313,
0.0020619025,
-0.0269963592,
-0.0032801211,
0.0047908141,
0.0531315766,
-0.0120321652,
-0.012258104,
0.0113205509,
-0.0088824732,
-0.0098088924,
-0.0013288505,
0.0087744519,
0.0031381147,
0.0551696643,
0.0195935443,
0.0604717992,
0.0077769649,
0.0187264495,
0.0218982771,
0.0564253405,
-0.0342155248,
0.0003650735,
0.0420092791,
-0.0366580002,
-0.0104820384,
-0.0437903963,
0.0393737815,
0.0136132194,
-0.0341206007,
0.0641338006,
0.0167131126,
-0.0442433842,
0.0319085047,
-0.0328505188,
0.0450032242,
0.0103706922,
0.0507082492,
0.0360003971,
-0.0589749701,
-0.001865876,
-0.0475133322,
-0.0167939998,
-0.0060117366,
-0.0527347997,
0.0149926255,
-0.0167712998,
-0.0040264092,
-0.0724688023,
-0.0554968454,
0.0606247336,
-0.0018800634,
0.0418807454,
0.020877311,
0.0235537142,
0.0361770019,
0.0170115884,
-0.0163907688,
-0.0490744002,
-0.0177008249,
-0.0768074691,
-0.0517936647,
0.0029252833,
-0.0686574206,
0.0145618962,
-0.0001768634,
-0.0394581035,
-0.0694200993,
0.0085366853,
0.0076831481,
0.0125621315,
0.0512430519,
0.0233844686,
-0.0290080737,
-0.0142257484,
0.0167823173,
-0.0185872372,
-0.0200778581,
0.0079640392,
0.0571317598,
0.0120313726,
0.0203700103,
-0.0293818787,
-0.0128252758,
-0.0268920008,
-0.0063896254,
-0.0297597311,
-0.0683265626,
0.0472135469,
0.0343263857,
0.0115246084,
0.0075276634,
-0.0349358208,
-0.0311066508,
0.0274252016,
-0.0422587916,
-0.0389517508,
-0.0209714323,
0.0139355194,
-0.0120336451,
-0.0346696563,
0.0160977375,
-0.000010377,
-0.0421465896,
0.040436428,
0.0178453438,
0.0307550915,
-0.0182932448,
-0.0053322082,
0.0178104769,
-0.0130411768,
-0.0005761505,
0.0148896016,
0.0351468027,
0.0528303906,
0.0247776434,
0.087217994,
0.0112745455,
-0.0420239307,
0.0731192976,
0.0128533319,
-0.0369472913,
-0.0347082056,
0.016653413,
0.0395138077,
0.0075309044,
0.0326618962,
0.0273877401,
-0.0701186433,
0.0137436725,
-0.007440316,
0.0383450054,
-0.0094176326,
-0.0238602664,
0.0141440639,
-0.0093031162,
0.013923821,
-0.005440115,
0.0259332862,
-0.0204666425,
0.0264225248,
0.023528887,
-0.0048194905,
-0.0351621769,
-0.0329046436,
0.03506089,
0.0154802278,
0.0368587375,
0.0222901143,
0.0097735059,
-0.0424446277,
-0.0341389701,
0.0402169302,
-0.0443182513,
-0.0229587182,
0.0424224846,
0.0403209589,
-0.0510402024,
0.0182337295,
-0.0458880253,
0.0604701675,
-0.0282264948,
-0.0582957715,
-0.0097784372,
-5.484955456e-33,
-0.0581690259,
-0.060730461,
0.0333586298,
0.0836520419,
-0.0293733496,
-0.0344919227,
-0.0341104753,
0.0378354006,
-0.0110017909,
0.008905177,
-0.0279533733,
0.0547343455,
-0.0073935939,
0.024640929,
0.0050181774,
-0.0173959322,
0.0368793868,
0.0146943368,
0.00789141,
0.0489168726,
0.0424888432,
0.010226449,
0.0380497873,
-0.0438500009,
0.0585595146,
-0.0465096198,
-0.0072475835,
0.0019280318,
-0.0114328694,
0.0266406443,
-0.0190664083,
0.0566175729,
0.0007395187,
0.0182228107,
-0.0171478558,
0.0174341258,
-0.0444191992,
-0.0637027696,
0.0135172969,
0.0107877869,
-0.0157689825,
-0.0780294091,
0.0270278808,
-0.0224955231,
-0.0019413378,
0.0081059271,
0.0608348288,
-0.0196186975,
0.0300972071,
0.0482596941,
-0.0699199811,
0.0134848161,
-0.0776742101,
-0.0602525286,
0.0006372017,
0.0562662072,
0.0415826775,
-0.0350514092,
-0.0000360393,
0.0704688206,
0.009211529,
0.0013508658,
0.051836323,
-0.0183822569,
-0.0006944767,
0.0768587217,
0.0299358983,
0.0301382188,
-0.0145577388,
-0.0102004427,
0.0291606132,
0.0327344537,
0.0199626535,
0.0658920556,
-0.0370481834,
-0.0206193309,
-0.0379581377,
0.0653249994,
0.0806809068,
0.0054710372,
-0.0355818644,
-0.0210064407,
-0.0521444194,
-0.0013294618,
-0.0246493015,
0.0371928439,
0.0127759352,
-0.0427459478,
0.0008944157,
-0.0400988087,
-0.0005784943,
-0.0824591219,
-0.0334306173,
-0.0501853935,
-0.0187666509,
0.0247395597,
-0.0537592657,
-0.0173850264,
-0.0302691143,
0.0057891798,
-0.0013759229,
-0.03263795,
0.0243048612,
-0.0243643373,
0.0178417321,
0.0413892828,
-0.0137843005,
0.0342154801,
-0.0016529481,
-0.0160980523,
-0.0448249206,
0.0407286845,
-0.0049414784,
-0.0040130625,
-0.0159552079,
0.0232560635,
-0.0345964395,
0.0582493208,
0.0224908013,
-0.0165037923,
-0.0451959185,
-0.0443671644,
0.0056257881,
-0.0436360948,
-0.0527267419,
-0.0175056141,
-0.0347874798,
0.032578785,
0.0070508998,
-0.0669014677,
0.0097133275,
-0.0213160161,
2.512e-7,
0.0214710794,
0.0387241505,
0.008329099,
0.0048430599,
0.0067754188,
0.0239358172,
-0.0144458581,
-0.0230863541,
0.0332360677,
-0.0285869353,
-0.0031282839,
0.0401459597,
0.0378114581,
0.0100901201,
-0.0975393206,
-0.0400768779,
-0.0073002954,
-0.0408218689,
-0.0230416209,
0.0144346887,
0.0911643729,
0.0138772307,
0.0317838453,
-0.0061434,
-0.0236967541,
0.0262962617,
-0.0156344585,
-0.0495658107,
-0.0162352864,
0.0556897409,
0.0134423254,
0.0292896349,
0.0196055081,
-0.0115920585,
0.0092000198,
0.006998355,
-0.0067216735,
0.0553275235,
0.0210488699,
-0.0479759946,
0.0379770473,
0.0174764786,
-0.0126864687,
-0.0298788212,
0.0415973738,
-0.0146250613,
-0.006477423,
0.0182083007,
0.0032767374,
-0.0361667946,
0.0041549508,
-0.0526174046,
-0.0280440152,
0.0139286527,
-0.0312009621,
-0.0374660827,
0.0394795313,
-0.032634031,
0.0145130586,
-0.0190122742,
-0.0736655518,
-0.0380504504,
-0.0159399845,
-0.028185036,
-0.0191643797,
-0.011857911,
0.0364084207,
1.665793159e-34,
-0.0002905975,
-0.010632555,
0.0312681086,
0.0510194302,
0.0360181667,
0.0044758688,
0.0697059557,
0.0339844674,
0.0452297591,
-0.0296031535,
-0.0489651971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16797v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16797v1 | Promptbreeder: Self-Referential Self-Improvement Via Prompt Evolution | 2023-09-28T19:01:07 | 2023-09-28T19:01:07 | Chrisantha Fernando, Dylan Banarse, Henryk Michalewski, Simon Osindero, Tim Rocktäschel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE | Popular prompt strategies like Chain-of-Thought Prompting can dramatically
improve the reasoning abilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) in various
domains. However, such hand-crafted prompt-strategies are often sub-optimal. In
this paper, we present Promptbreeder, a general-purpose self-referential
self-improvement mechanism that evolves and adapts prompts for a given domain.
Driven by an LLM, Promptbreeder mutates a population of task-prompts, and
subsequently evaluates them for fitness on a training set. Crucially, the
mutation of these task-prompts is governed by mutation-prompts that the LLM
generates and improves throughout evolution in a self-referential way. That is,
Promptbreeder is not just improving task-prompts, but it is also improving the
mutationprompts that improve these task-prompts. Promptbreeder outperforms
state-of-the-art prompt strategies such as Chain-of-Thought and Plan-and-Solve
Prompting on commonly used arithmetic and commonsense reasoning benchmarks.
Furthermore, Promptbreeder is able to evolve intricate task-prompts for the
challenging problem of hate speech classification. | [
0.0548980571,
0.0667258948,
-0.0292385649,
0.0218978524,
-0.0379450656,
0.0214993022,
0.0140736895,
-0.0114318673,
0.0060368385,
-0.0417651199,
-0.0598459207,
0.0206712019,
-0.0226300191,
0.0340189077,
0.0220637806,
-0.024861129,
0.0776983574,
-0.054262381,
0.0118318321,
-0.0369258039,
-0.0144565748,
-0.0095222238,
-0.0016407853,
-0.0087092724,
-0.0182093978,
-0.0021555016,
-0.0013971964,
-0.0324854963,
-0.0022820358,
0.0002570737,
0.0177523009,
0.0734302849,
0.0144397821,
0.0522771105,
0.0000021029,
-0.0884593725,
-0.0079889623,
-0.0300242193,
-0.0585558601,
-0.0180761591,
0.0560106896,
0.0282831453,
-0.0308293924,
0.0121579701,
-0.0384429134,
0.0196650885,
0.0031925491,
0.0374221765,
0.0826324895,
0.0801384673,
0.0400108844,
-0.0321330056,
0.0316034257,
-0.0332853496,
0.0343199335,
-0.0046766461,
0.0206331369,
-0.0355522744,
0.0061346758,
0.0400135778,
-0.0196513999,
0.0211680811,
0.0404288396,
-0.0506789312,
0.0086375326,
-0.0075455136,
0.0112029668,
-0.0194806699,
-0.0141844302,
0.0351592936,
-0.0127400877,
-0.0371037722,
-0.0087381052,
0.0083226273,
0.0511401668,
-0.0144294966,
-0.0128706163,
0.0044154539,
0.0118009746,
0.007294415,
0.0462811291,
-0.0066377926,
0.0223508291,
0.0271132402,
-0.0011960365,
0.080258809,
0.0016313787,
-0.0401379839,
0.0040208562,
-0.0231398735,
-0.0042310674,
-0.0719851255,
-0.0144047709,
0.0190521255,
-0.0300311353,
0.0287167244,
-0.0496282391,
-0.017399339,
0.0155694112,
0.0086982381,
0.0574694611,
0.0388979875,
-0.0209132992,
0.0441367626,
-0.044677414,
0.0375130661,
-0.0194078628,
0.0143851051,
-0.0371172465,
0.0182024799,
-0.0340778418,
-0.0186927225,
-0.0428126194,
0.038556125,
0.0055938768,
0.0186516065,
-0.016255198,
0.0310752019,
-0.0198738109,
-0.0150077986,
-0.0105087925,
-0.0076971874,
0.0082859872,
-0.015813658,
-0.0757307708,
-0.0155349728,
-0.0446943641,
-0.0237217322,
0.001844264,
-0.0259417053,
-0.025256684,
-0.0141319828,
-0.0124174254,
-0.0113841305,
0.0126995612,
0.0493842065,
-0.0155756176,
-0.0428069383,
-0.0351635963,
0.0018790262,
-0.0521861836,
-0.0365577936,
-0.0110273445,
-0.0268556383,
0.0178436209,
-0.0163933206,
-0.0378326178,
-0.0436586067,
0.0211923588,
-0.0112296417,
-0.024578562,
0.0922875106,
-0.0173104759,
0.0091015799,
0.0412148051,
0.0080449404,
-0.0032166308,
0.0591596998,
0.014317533,
-0.0122246658,
0.0238155369,
-0.0145711955,
-0.0046399259,
0.0270255972,
0.0285210013,
0.006127777,
0.0296174735,
0.0312959738,
0.002659936,
0.0198724326,
0.014519549,
0.0381416939,
-0.0168913286,
-0.0309279896,
0.0368968025,
0.05192196,
0.0242962521,
0.0296619926,
0.0651501268,
0.0047910698,
-0.0443802066,
0.0055516358,
-0.0734730139,
0.0231174547,
-0.0595081486,
-0.018241033,
0.0208896007,
0.0028241742,
-0.0097065186,
-0.0846319944,
-0.0230495222,
0.0177802593,
0.0018927194,
0.0041489112,
0.0208834279,
0.0614672974,
-0.0143412827,
0.0195026323,
0.0342204794,
-0.04338146,
-0.0217409395,
-0.1051201671,
0.0711769387,
0.0757049173,
0.0254600048,
-0.0150691289,
-0.0588101409,
-0.0237495638,
0.0205084942,
0.0526617654,
0.0661279634,
-0.0223360918,
-0.0316612497,
-0.0163729899,
-0.0370778181,
-0.0297343545,
0.0202252809,
0.0064464174,
0.0099985963,
-0.0136301601,
0.0223809853,
0.0226681232,
0.0050076474,
0.0447071381,
-0.0191200152,
-0.0291835181,
0.0159370936,
-0.0031664153,
0.0409168489,
-0.0026846149,
-0.0153336972,
0.013958835,
-0.0061379694,
-0.0179301277,
-0.0507300124,
0.0340425149,
-0.0664158314,
-0.0288400743,
0.0449210145,
0.0283445697,
-0.0409815051,
-0.0191195514,
-0.0057164538,
-0.0239123367,
0.0383038744,
-0.0513818115,
0.0151742846,
-0.0473801643,
0.0469227284,
-0.058969155,
-0.0104814135,
-0.0142350215,
0.0736500323,
-0.014076611,
-0.0247102398,
0.0381769277,
0.037314117,
0.0234882552,
-0.0324915126,
-0.014827068,
-0.0480504446,
-0.0054483493,
0.0007805049,
0.0244346447,
0.0313297361,
-0.0451300591,
-0.05224967,
-0.0409429744,
0.0156931337,
-0.0156973135,
0.0112638548,
0.0161143038,
-0.0083386665,
-0.0167006124,
-0.0141148996,
-0.0067566927,
0.00602681,
0.0442644283,
0.0138954949,
0.0327095948,
-0.0205890369,
-0.0132603878,
-0.0292916838,
-0.0178324729,
-0.0359934643,
0.0131356036,
-0.0082679493,
0.0463527329,
-0.0599742979,
0.0190829001,
-0.0408089384,
0.0165672656,
-0.0009765268,
-0.0228440892,
0.0329301879,
0.0068949261,
0.0785663724,
0.0639156997,
0.0512262322,
-0.0004118737,
0.0417855009,
0.0046728137,
-0.064500019,
0.0262958705,
-0.0192950442,
0.00628467,
-0.0093556,
-0.0185407754,
0.0220207144,
0.0900319442,
-0.0112355668,
-0.0528864935,
-0.07752157,
0.0723156407,
-0.0118365921,
-0.0615747795,
-0.0222414304,
-0.0524853282,
-0.0168776233,
0.0116307773,
-0.050144393,
-0.0523388796,
0.0985807851,
0.003279614,
0.0215613283,
-0.0539410561,
0.0143688777,
-0.0329987928,
0.0890755653,
0.0182096921,
-0.0005851597,
0.0449269712,
0.0243319664,
-0.0307561234,
0.0000318141,
0.0078335823,
-0.014034071,
0.0307851546,
-0.0475422256,
0.0227351822,
0.0318822637,
-0.0759696811,
-0.0690417737,
-0.0190358143,
-0.0173875839,
-0.0137963435,
-0.00435055,
0.0091527561,
0.0103634959,
-0.0103440136,
0.0219618529,
0.0318411142,
-0.0249813311,
-0.0049948175,
0.000120045,
-0.0278678034,
0.0474674888,
0.0794784874,
0.0623280443,
-0.0069908039,
0.0390585177,
0.0201026015,
0.0144064594,
0.0168897733,
-0.012029754,
0.0384849943,
0.0031379173,
-0.0421275683,
-0.0362798013,
0.0014586309,
0.0448181592,
-0.0512660444,
-0.0063789501,
0.0993414372,
0.0257726219,
0.0030692283,
0.0101427976,
-0.0617588535,
0.0259393454,
0.0372151732,
0.0406206846,
-0.0880908221,
-0.0308623947,
0.0098128645,
0.0029605632,
-0.0294113494,
-0.0619131699,
0.0074431985,
-0.1298723668,
0.0315406099,
-0.0079530226,
-0.0139027173,
0.0237699002,
-0.0338034034,
0.0002013406,
0.0129552279,
-0.0101606809,
0.0309363734,
0.009933793,
0.0172899961,
-0.0013514598,
-0.0113171609,
-0.03470359,
0.0313730687,
-0.0297765937,
0.0606418811,
0.0857823268,
0.0052280403,
0.0316406004,
-0.0575175099,
0.0718929693,
-0.0334537625,
0.0082414374,
-0.0445124693,
0.0060429922,
-0.0056916359,
-0.0108583048,
-0.0077774771,
0.0601268224,
-0.0086820796,
-0.0021841296,
0.0321271755,
0.0773324445,
0.0023822102,
-0.0521166399,
-0.0487472191,
-0.0038259726,
-0.0243807957,
0.072901845,
0.0431011468,
-0.0777607262,
0.0046175187,
-0.0381536745,
-0.0144307343,
-0.0535708629,
-0.0818562061,
0.001630634,
0.0095060403,
0.0064963456,
-0.0646350458,
-0.029436877,
0.0264766198,
0.0238430109,
0.010673983,
-0.0389782637,
-0.0334431045,
-0.0154960016,
-0.042387519,
0.0097339442,
-0.0405755043,
-0.026616171,
-0.0702973902,
-0.0086085061,
0.0474744253,
-0.0202707369,
-0.0186482817,
0.0176829416,
-0.0567746274,
-0.0441919565,
0.0164581407,
0.106107071,
0.0205895957,
0.0450225472,
-0.0190450121,
-0.0594108105,
0.0674550831,
0.0261740759,
-0.01253796,
0.0122659476,
0.0095452312,
0.0169453062,
0.0025560101,
0.0354661644,
-0.010917115,
0.0558451191,
0.0337723605,
0.0414965115,
-0.0032887165,
-0.0097438404,
0.0270432848,
0.0263678432,
0.0088422019,
-0.0052633556,
-0.0189382471,
-0.0274324473,
0.0128032044,
0.0162586216,
-0.0634259284,
-0.0069923769,
0.0263598841,
-0.0062586516,
-0.0279426891,
0.003801527,
-0.0377162695,
-0.0303598009,
0.0399513617,
-0.012531573,
0.0174415503,
0.0394057333,
0.0320689492,
0.0191343091,
-0.0093906028,
0.0211699922,
0.0619408153,
0.0203934964,
0.0091243451,
-0.0163903832,
0.0636401996,
0.0113448231,
-0.00378168,
0.0162248127,
0.0378557444,
-0.0402998142,
-0.0200559963,
0.005622589,
0.0140746888,
0.0036781861,
0.038411282,
0.014456966,
0.0081967162,
-0.038187284,
0.0042121606,
-0.0137054985,
0.0101972995,
-0.0384957194,
0.034919776,
0.0250293259,
-0.0173251946,
-0.0144974235,
-0.0013752409,
-0.0475719795,
0.054821603,
0.0252876747,
0.024797041,
-0.0575082712,
-0.0314121693,
-0.0612789132,
-0.0207262952,
0.0073083676,
0.0179516319,
-0.0574568324,
-0.0581125394,
0.0157484896,
0.0616199747,
0.0128330365,
-0.0060909595,
0.0365127772,
0.0607118197,
-0.0296748821,
-0.0410599001,
-0.0046447101,
0.0317122154,
0.0137274517,
-0.0197369568,
0.0136426687,
-6.032618274e-33,
-0.0372712836,
-0.0043940903,
0.0388759896,
-0.0155970957,
-0.0006272158,
-0.030239448,
-0.0372128896,
0.031331107,
-0.0184405837,
-0.0055256998,
-0.0148125254,
0.0062433486,
-0.0075857206,
-0.0120297335,
0.0180477966,
-0.0040673786,
0.0451645479,
-0.0436409526,
-0.0389460996,
0.0123164095,
-0.0056397393,
0.0216507688,
0.0053920778,
-0.0224293582,
0.0207525492,
0.0319164358,
-0.0070779617,
0.0652297661,
-0.0277531836,
0.063473098,
-0.0127964178,
0.0358447172,
0.0211666562,
-0.039694313,
-0.0081940191,
0.0132295899,
-0.0775640011,
-0.0612825416,
0.0067341845,
-0.036806576,
-0.0447996929,
-0.0491308272,
0.0499477386,
0.0138099985,
-0.0724799633,
0.0087675368,
0.006616761,
-0.0226091892,
0.031200869,
0.0193191916,
-0.0615529381,
0.0114129176,
-0.0065984786,
-0.0559955798,
-0.0211461727,
-0.0144870728,
0.0111137712,
-0.0390361138,
-0.032022506,
0.0647950247,
0.037900079,
-0.0070193619,
0.0427368656,
-0.0317096934,
0.0198890157,
0.0121851191,
0.0430862568,
0.0364974439,
-0.0042906222,
-0.0282539707,
0.0431699641,
0.0305836778,
0.0658781454,
0.0232626889,
0.0008262948,
-0.029287355,
-0.0020701648,
-0.0035505835,
0.0631480217,
-0.0070467154,
-0.0131943328,
0.0050791246,
0.0143875657,
-0.0256426595,
-0.0608688369,
-0.0333564915,
-0.0279648546,
-0.0355095603,
0.0210661143,
0.0329848751,
-0.0339516401,
-0.029644886,
-0.0007350961,
-0.0081657106,
-0.0124978041,
0.0202683304,
-0.0322941095,
-0.010261328,
0.0229886211,
0.0472712554,
-0.0554648526,
-0.004236544,
0.0051924405,
0.0037896403,
0.0229931213,
0.0079509486,
0.0203910004,
0.0223461334,
-0.0953649879,
0.0154245887,
-0.0117109045,
0.0679349974,
-0.0230020359,
0.0040318444,
0.0104796393,
0.0455383174,
0.0194297843,
0.0106186131,
0.0646608025,
-0.0315307602,
-0.0793773383,
0.1169959754,
-0.0151282949,
0.0274561848,
-0.0041447119,
0.0049850284,
0.0046497933,
0.0764202774,
-0.0336005129,
-0.1015918702,
-0.0054721669,
0.0017052683,
2.744e-7,
0.0075941929,
0.0705053881,
-0.0068026162,
-0.0062907804,
0.0466585048,
0.0479122587,
0.0047575962,
0.017271189,
0.0331070088,
-0.0346257202,
-0.0199168827,
0.0477817319,
0.0132614197,
0.0245261099,
-0.0576337427,
0.0139503507,
-0.058895506,
0.0333624147,
-0.0421075448,
0.0211794358,
-0.0074399123,
0.0862201974,
0.0466471985,
-0.0210799351,
-0.0201728791,
-0.0354362801,
0.0307950824,
-0.0049122465,
-0.0041322005,
0.0314848237,
-0.0095300963,
0.0049971347,
-0.0232382435,
-0.0004660854,
0.0071397885,
0.0528552756,
-0.0486787818,
0.0275059026,
0.0357368886,
-0.0099417064,
0.0008515081,
0.0319955982,
-0.0034674953,
-0.0385536738,
0.0938902572,
-0.047007829,
-0.0184601806,
-0.0705071762,
0.0093169669,
-0.0194686893,
-0.0126923388,
-0.0251424909,
-0.0338185169,
0.0041823173,
0.034754768,
0.017918041,
0.0035138242,
-0.1032704189,
-0.0017566419,
-0.0241309758,
-0.0549330935,
-0.0451104194,
-0.050247632,
0.0394039415,
0.008981456,
-0.0401502103,
0.0131838396,
2.448456928e-34,
0.0288454276,
-0.0199941136,
0.0384841599,
-0.0380616151,
0.0434298106,
0.0186760258,
-0.0165542718,
-0.0078407843,
0.0849538147,
-0.0563593097,
-0.0484957844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16781v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16781v1 | Hallucination Reduction in Long Input Text Summarization | 2023-09-28T18:22:16 | 2023-09-28T18:22:16 | Tohida Rehman, Ronit Mandal, Abhishek Agarwal, Debarshi Kumar Sanyal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Hallucination in text summarization refers to the phenomenon where the model
generates information that is not supported by the input source document.
Hallucination poses significant obstacles to the accuracy and reliability of
the generated summaries. In this paper, we aim to reduce hallucinated outputs
or hallucinations in summaries of long-form text documents. We have used the
PubMed dataset, which contains long scientific research documents and their
abstracts. We have incorporated the techniques of data filtering and joint
entity and summary generation (JAENS) in the fine-tuning of the Longformer
Encoder-Decoder (LED) model to minimize hallucinations and thereby improve the
quality of the generated summary. We have used the following metrics to measure
factual consistency at the entity level: precision-source, and F1-target. Our
experiments show that the fine-tuned LED model performs well in generating the
paper abstract. Data filtering techniques based on some preprocessing steps
reduce entity-level hallucinations in the generated summaries in terms of some
of the factual consistency metrics. | [
0.0187007897,
0.0159601122,
0.0262619648,
-0.0048490684,
-0.0006124456,
0.0224666875,
-0.0437868014,
0.0223151892,
-0.0416157506,
-0.035700582,
0.0359358303,
-0.0251804795,
0.0453438349,
0.0116575966,
0.018133726,
-0.082581684,
0.0241090264,
0.0160590112,
-0.0033540709,
-0.0196286906,
0.0234881025,
-0.004571544,
0.0166583527,
0.0101072025,
0.0205610488,
-0.0263672099,
0.0143969385,
-0.0062265112,
0.0337084308,
-0.0270499811,
-0.0139473043,
0.0172651075,
-0.0157887097,
0.0329810902,
0.0000022371,
-0.0769290924,
-0.0561300814,
0.0401008427,
0.0113150021,
0.0215948857,
0.0281656552,
-0.0654576123,
-0.0009356448,
0.0097031668,
0.0229412839,
-0.0066802939,
-0.0063303094,
0.0879574046,
0.0522256196,
0.0588567741,
-0.0146293314,
-0.066561915,
0.0729633942,
0.0104077458,
-0.0029011171,
0.0443630591,
0.0359747633,
0.0316265374,
0.010195801,
-0.0313883349,
-0.0007144398,
0.0088812998,
0.0006940364,
0.0049121892,
0.036580693,
0.0263394061,
-0.053697899,
-0.0078346971,
0.0524193011,
0.0503717251,
-0.0175169576,
-0.0269813072,
0.0679388642,
0.002760564,
-0.009637408,
-0.0047626654,
-0.0502354912,
0.0344493501,
-0.045518294,
0.0135744866,
0.0340807252,
0.0253733806,
-0.0344434418,
0.0019930748,
-0.0851775408,
0.0203460418,
0.0013318181,
-0.0552140884,
-0.0149643226,
0.000199963,
0.0117623331,
-0.0558510683,
0.0391667522,
0.0369080603,
-0.0047711846,
-0.0412058271,
-0.0563521124,
-0.0889325663,
0.0490560234,
-0.0794747323,
-0.0683690906,
-0.002906207,
0.0146188801,
0.0293400045,
-0.0132340351,
-0.0057899887,
-0.0035024085,
0.0427813157,
-0.0174460895,
-0.0141773429,
0.0078638149,
0.0174474902,
-0.0368427336,
0.0617995784,
-0.0480438247,
-0.0426874161,
-0.0515066646,
-0.0253484901,
0.0050777178,
0.027646916,
-0.0078904955,
-0.0141007071,
-0.0123952944,
-0.0324099436,
0.0056558414,
0.0344636664,
-0.0190336406,
-0.0410143733,
0.0209100433,
-0.0017453635,
-0.0036704978,
0.0169819985,
0.0407459624,
0.022965122,
-0.0056894924,
-0.0116395317,
0.0088619888,
0.0131545411,
-0.0021636251,
-0.0604469702,
-0.0036338649,
-0.0476783775,
0.0101330448,
-0.0501493216,
0.0121012134,
0.0142771527,
-0.0149690667,
-0.0281159598,
0.0127881086,
0.0107452748,
-0.0370397978,
0.020815162,
-0.1028043032,
-0.0076212143,
0.0639399737,
0.0190704986,
0.0114766071,
0.0392602123,
0.039960701,
0.0207345504,
0.0145474579,
-0.0098226154,
0.0368594341,
-0.0019610524,
0.0360904299,
-0.0149402069,
0.0134522133,
-0.0033620566,
-0.0129841808,
-0.017391976,
0.0141546139,
0.0664711893,
-0.0329867303,
0.0418700166,
0.0352915674,
0.0003939744,
0.032471586,
0.0207767058,
-0.0195308644,
0.0266602747,
0.0235102177,
0.0747497231,
0.0189461354,
0.0318841338,
-0.0094475001,
0.0504995286,
0.11609862,
0.0219231211,
-0.017399665,
-0.0229865927,
0.0154730724,
0.0191285852,
-0.0040979055,
-0.0288297664,
0.0347658843,
0.0311666932,
-0.0674734339,
0.0493168011,
0.0114741754,
-0.0393850096,
0.0435560308,
-0.0042135264,
-0.0096654454,
0.0579133369,
0.0879747793,
-0.0150153693,
0.0133275427,
-0.0398270264,
-0.004538367,
0.0352592841,
-0.0061155139,
-0.0039677508,
-0.032946188,
-0.0586111397,
-0.0258157551,
0.0316243395,
0.0114844311,
-0.0298501123,
-0.0518386476,
0.0207169428,
0.0435466319,
0.000202339,
-0.0428210199,
0.0213608462,
-0.010173006,
0.0163252614,
-0.0464298278,
-0.0196208116,
0.0309368987,
0.0210628044,
-0.0212110374,
0.0545517318,
0.0250165369,
-0.0182827916,
-0.0291830041,
-0.0119380876,
-0.0006054832,
-0.0164567605,
0.0024433651,
-0.0748524517,
0.0275477488,
-0.0027237744,
0.0155611355,
-0.0606316291,
-0.0426237397,
-0.0646038204,
-0.0065876753,
-0.0233602524,
0.0557122603,
0.0031665899,
0.0368804149,
0.0031923663,
0.0655616075,
-0.0215862226,
0.0193655007,
0.0480571315,
-0.0381567143,
-0.0162329022,
-0.0462493077,
0.0060775275,
0.0384944864,
-0.001767576,
-0.0196457524,
0.0531171672,
-0.0453523844,
-0.0213168561,
-0.0561204143,
-0.0515818596,
0.0072910618,
-0.0011051616,
0.0150054432,
0.0494821779,
-0.0129071716,
-0.0028632444,
0.0152958333,
0.0026505885,
-0.041948311,
0.0225713924,
-0.0054905275,
0.0293583758,
0.0232943147,
-0.0049273679,
-0.0037787049,
-0.0164895039,
-0.0060440409,
0.049761612,
0.0126124592,
-0.0762315392,
-0.0936585069,
0.051827848,
-0.0115109449,
-0.0355785266,
0.0252448879,
0.0105260182,
-0.0229741503,
0.013587188,
0.0690880269,
0.050163433,
0.0636202544,
0.0032967662,
0.0448502265,
-0.0239590444,
-0.010690677,
-0.0230734721,
-0.058774557,
0.0982937738,
0.030201098,
-0.0342408717,
0.0517898984,
-0.0091255149,
0.0326814279,
0.0182783417,
-0.0275499485,
0.0081188427,
-0.0263715629,
-0.019733943,
0.0028052167,
-0.0360028371,
-0.0270448923,
0.0332864635,
-0.0114171067,
0.0166431163,
0.0399682447,
-0.035496667,
0.0265021008,
-0.0472027361,
0.0428951792,
-0.0305514634,
-0.0547918379,
0.0137935299,
0.0250312537,
-0.029209001,
-0.0234275907,
-0.0105560366,
0.0196404438,
-0.0038635975,
-0.0599185824,
0.029754553,
0.003660046,
0.0032401376,
-0.0288269762,
0.0228412263,
-0.0028081273,
0.0024778689,
0.0286336746,
0.0026215245,
0.0335588045,
0.0143085141,
-0.0657998696,
0.0358298942,
0.0272480901,
0.0610166751,
-0.0382618234,
-0.0277154204,
-0.0183266792,
0.0197762195,
0.058074832,
-0.0540208332,
0.0530089326,
-0.0586768873,
0.0433677174,
0.0737999082,
0.0073732096,
0.0202934016,
0.0308705382,
-0.0586376786,
-0.0309099928,
-0.0621702969,
-0.0213432331,
0.0114167733,
0.020341143,
-0.0498683527,
0.0207228009,
0.1001936942,
0.0157734435,
-0.0242166854,
-0.004698907,
-0.014204558,
0.0329690836,
-0.0256091375,
-0.012566424,
-0.0442518294,
0.0404553525,
-0.0044170055,
0.0360253602,
-0.0148901874,
-0.0289204773,
0.0049987971,
-0.0473591313,
0.0287133735,
0.0433063954,
-0.0622509792,
-0.0746929348,
-0.0313972309,
-0.0080712559,
0.0092498669,
0.0176889542,
0.0439492688,
-0.0021969562,
-0.0217736512,
0.017454857,
-0.0779050812,
-0.0133685153,
-0.0641578212,
-0.0249810312,
0.0256257076,
0.0639256611,
0.0406784452,
0.0003620387,
-0.000765648,
0.0016089767,
-0.050528869,
-0.0419939011,
-0.0029595688,
0.0921956003,
0.0022572353,
0.0292091798,
-0.0026205441,
0.0490411036,
0.0189303588,
-0.0152162742,
0.000341552,
0.0306770131,
-0.0420955159,
-0.0448134877,
-0.0467423163,
0.0463545918,
-0.0198731795,
0.0664469004,
0.0240180809,
0.0186852906,
-0.0428876467,
-0.0180643722,
0.0267261416,
-0.0538758375,
-0.0050283256,
0.0194476824,
-0.0257334374,
-0.0454801954,
-0.0771394745,
-0.0504832193,
0.0153099857,
-0.0135968616,
-0.0037783538,
0.0579915941,
0.0315847993,
-0.013249062,
-0.0230337698,
-0.0282037631,
-0.0051814443,
-0.0176340211,
-0.0172283575,
0.004395749,
0.0502711125,
0.0093663223,
0.0000473225,
0.0122192241,
-0.0153957093,
-0.0451453254,
0.0006108898,
0.002676487,
0.0260738637,
0.0600814745,
-0.0001586138,
-0.0003294463,
0.061120972,
0.0305115301,
0.0268801227,
0.019607285,
-0.0235949047,
-0.0051401244,
-0.0231294185,
-0.0354298092,
-0.0484248288,
0.018882405,
-0.0384275578,
0.0187524874,
-0.0159053337,
-0.0307075977,
0.0427753218,
0.0603685156,
-0.0359691232,
-0.0363359451,
0.0131158531,
-0.0049469657,
0.0049222126,
-0.0642711073,
0.0039013063,
-0.0226987116,
0.0505073071,
-0.0034348588,
-0.0074446006,
0.026832385,
0.0996315405,
-0.0312377419,
-0.0559893586,
-0.0629127845,
-0.0079057086,
-0.0727554038,
0.0027999077,
0.0253485572,
-0.0274269301,
-0.030885905,
-0.0381868146,
-0.0049274694,
0.0148064997,
-0.0217969865,
0.0246633328,
0.0426088534,
0.0157175697,
-0.0049950755,
0.0182350595,
-0.071249038,
0.0238070451,
-0.1013284847,
0.0211757533,
0.0154407173,
0.0133379763,
0.0755340606,
-0.0326879509,
0.0212515127,
-0.0289823916,
0.0492936336,
0.0640470758,
0.0128836939,
-0.0410658307,
0.0174567215,
-0.0113554318,
-0.0322318189,
0.0858086348,
-0.0305219721,
0.0076629058,
0.018085843,
-0.0434234478,
-0.0458578244,
-0.0580034554,
-0.0559722818,
-0.0124382917,
-0.019056797,
-0.0489245467,
-0.0337684453,
0.02600196,
0.0299581494,
0.0233210996,
0.0116381552,
-0.0125727197,
0.0287489276,
0.0097436244,
-0.0234452691,
-0.0164376069,
-0.0044958079,
0.0150277829,
0.00550221,
-0.0130454348,
0.0311339591,
-6.262033262e-33,
-0.0133121908,
-0.0307857692,
-0.024924254,
-0.0213346798,
-0.0390106514,
-0.0218471382,
-0.0633611158,
-0.0507351793,
0.0503495857,
0.0059475568,
0.0008134443,
0.0155353956,
0.0162193235,
0.0060285954,
-0.0238522775,
0.0247205235,
0.0532002635,
0.0011025503,
-0.0323621407,
0.0509518869,
0.0280542858,
0.0180578716,
0.0012122934,
-0.0586265102,
0.0304733068,
-0.0296336282,
-0.0293179583,
-0.0348093249,
0.0383886173,
0.010411174,
-0.0051438357,
-0.0209513791,
0.0155611327,
-0.0768126324,
-0.066039376,
0.0017671786,
-0.0852615535,
0.029650297,
-0.0143549414,
-0.008100572,
-0.0353845544,
-0.0476336628,
0.0626412854,
-0.0345361643,
0.0062751244,
-0.0247578714,
0.0577761047,
-0.0724806488,
-0.0508652069,
-0.0786047503,
-0.0398444682,
0.0401989184,
-0.0156125948,
0.0095853293,
-0.001599122,
0.028405251,
0.006580086,
0.0044042054,
-0.0561653525,
0.0250937305,
0.0620551035,
0.0215025302,
-0.0049575209,
-0.0351248868,
0.0387317389,
0.0566707924,
0.0178897828,
0.0267466828,
-0.0314517394,
0.0172236823,
-0.0044850316,
0.0188779384,
0.036054749,
-0.0023902073,
0.1262823045,
0.0089258607,
-0.0568770766,
0.0955170766,
-0.1230245084,
0.0157919675,
0.0448395088,
-0.0158224963,
-0.0101795457,
-0.0152754458,
0.0192947555,
0.0278792884,
-0.00233295,
-0.0193932876,
-0.0105670318,
0.0103225801,
-0.0691917986,
-0.0096729277,
0.0078893704,
-0.0381295383,
0.0251618549,
0.030697953,
-0.0240086,
0.0223719236,
-0.0159844421,
-0.0474249832,
0.0189431924,
-0.0008521212,
0.059669435,
0.0114948265,
-0.0031930897,
0.0177533124,
0.0303688236,
-0.0354371965,
-0.0366202518,
-0.0046906671,
0.0281416848,
-0.0088455267,
0.0120237498,
-0.004457992,
0.0038248335,
0.0018210426,
0.0180858858,
0.0093191899,
0.0068631726,
0.0323554948,
0.0149737773,
0.0339280143,
0.038273029,
0.0551027544,
-0.0101311207,
0.0164617598,
-0.0218975544,
-0.0142481001,
0.0434325375,
-0.0390587635,
-0.0319416486,
-0.0100562768,
2.851e-7,
0.0282918829,
0.0508906655,
0.0704351217,
-0.0082313819,
0.0161166843,
-0.0332163945,
0.0129012605,
0.0325425602,
0.0150116058,
-0.0306862481,
0.0287112296,
0.0020642974,
0.0579129644,
0.0406106785,
-0.0849073306,
-0.0522884764,
-0.0627151877,
-0.0357709825,
-0.0300359633,
-0.0088760983,
0.0508838333,
0.0153269982,
-0.0526298061,
0.0015759415,
0.0103510004,
0.0042675524,
0.0329800732,
0.0324989222,
0.0169019848,
0.0594243258,
0.0522493124,
-0.0244368427,
0.0158441793,
0.0110185323,
-0.0411942191,
-0.0325034447,
0.0317064933,
0.036868982,
0.0101056974,
0.0095673194,
0.0667738244,
-0.0005468847,
0.0156402513,
0.009610639,
0.0465891622,
-0.0564059056,
-0.0241233613,
0.0094449678,
-0.0653062463,
0.0106982244,
0.009846163,
0.0168985222,
-0.0152233103,
0.0339154266,
-0.0076096561,
0.0139392884,
0.0189559087,
-0.0341888666,
-0.0124001326,
0.0249475185,
0.0027449077,
-0.0426464342,
0.0173629094,
-0.0398272313,
0.0008702984,
-0.0876931399,
-0.0117062861,
3.179540946e-34,
0.0630809367,
-0.0172276665,
-0.033392109,
-0.0043451805,
0.0187319946,
-0.0561807752,
0.0132822329,
0.0262788031,
-0.0059904647,
-0.0609010831,
-0.0117517104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16777v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16777v1 | How many words does ChatGPT know? The answer is ChatWords | 2023-09-28T18:13:02 | 2023-09-28T18:13:02 | Gonzalo Martínez, Javier Conde, Pedro Reviriego, Elena Merino-Gómez, José Alberto Hernández, Fabrizio Lombardi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The introduction of ChatGPT has put Artificial Intelligence (AI) Natural
Language Processing (NLP) in the spotlight. ChatGPT adoption has been
exponential with millions of users experimenting with it in a myriad of tasks
and application domains with impressive results. However, ChatGPT has
limitations and suffers hallucinations, for example producing answers that look
plausible but they are completely wrong. Evaluating the performance of ChatGPT
and similar AI tools is a complex issue that is being explored from different
perspectives. In this work, we contribute to those efforts with ChatWords, an
automated test system, to evaluate ChatGPT knowledge of an arbitrary set of
words. ChatWords is designed to be extensible, easy to use, and adaptable to
evaluate also other NLP AI tools. ChatWords is publicly available and its main
goal is to facilitate research on the lexical knowledge of AI tools. The
benefits of ChatWords are illustrated with two case studies: evaluating the
knowledge that ChatGPT has of the Spanish lexicon (taken from the official
dictionary of the "Real Academia Espa\~nola") and of the words that appear in
the Quixote, the well-known novel written by Miguel de Cervantes. The results
show that ChatGPT is only able to recognize approximately 80% of the words in
the dictionary and 90% of the words in the Quixote, in some cases with an
incorrect meaning. The implications of the lexical knowledge of NLP AI tools
and potential applications of ChatWords are also discussed providing directions
for further work on the study of the lexical knowledge of AI tools. | [
0.0410027914,
0.013280794,
-0.0231901407,
0.0674416125,
-0.0848349705,
0.0020319899,
-0.0435846485,
0.0312709063,
0.0653483868,
-0.0440928303,
-0.0154298227,
0.029307751,
0.0170103777,
0.0167217162,
-0.0023698085,
0.0073632668,
0.0512478501,
0.0065478156,
0.0092946813,
0.0029999178,
0.0040179072,
0.0235424563,
-0.0371794291,
0.0385201164,
-0.010310567,
-0.0277309306,
0.0115604252,
-0.0576253198,
-0.0112622622,
-0.0034525986,
-0.0063992501,
0.0448754579,
-0.032445915,
0.0957024395,
0.0000017913,
-0.0678650364,
-0.033543434,
-0.0145501513,
-0.0056218598,
-0.0277966559,
0.0808344036,
0.0414936133,
0.0043663369,
-0.0048243087,
-0.07959003,
0.0176904779,
0.0299829673,
-0.0002441802,
0.0175850745,
0.0528309047,
-0.0066374564,
-0.0146178687,
0.0297071226,
0.0283870809,
0.0523074716,
-0.0576272123,
0.0005574485,
0.0002161066,
0.0580643676,
-0.0133247506,
-0.0071693338,
0.0579917245,
-0.0097067673,
0.0077848495,
-0.0392770283,
0.014389934,
-0.0836068392,
-0.003357819,
-0.0292110182,
-0.007401132,
-0.0152631653,
-0.0216237344,
0.0102765635,
0.0202682652,
-0.0172560103,
0.023884017,
-0.0053695985,
-0.000079225,
-0.0619155988,
-0.0216127355,
0.0462049395,
0.0158925168,
0.0065793833,
0.009207367,
0.0054643885,
0.0665672868,
-0.0030373307,
-0.01990024,
0.0561367944,
0.0130619043,
-0.0237305164,
-0.0566568896,
0.0194159225,
0.02941975,
-0.0054663923,
0.0423096716,
0.0169482399,
-0.0203461833,
0.0429736897,
-0.0890344381,
-0.0533170924,
0.0314829759,
-0.0239238087,
0.0472563542,
0.0051472052,
0.0399252772,
0.0552804507,
0.005133328,
-0.0271901488,
-0.0205729771,
-0.086041294,
-0.0337074026,
-0.0570380427,
0.021988444,
0.0053386637,
-0.0190890394,
-0.0242653731,
-0.0131073026,
0.0101098232,
0.0236319378,
-0.0127743268,
0.0346256085,
-0.010172287,
0.0058484026,
-0.0557310358,
-0.0050593852,
-0.0407802835,
-0.0170489959,
-0.0271542426,
-0.0748017579,
0.0105009973,
-0.0193226505,
0.0038882536,
-0.0441535302,
0.0313444398,
0.0944960564,
-0.0069742985,
-0.0694646537,
0.0069371564,
-0.0406587347,
-0.0169463474,
-0.0842024907,
0.0047867424,
-0.0670598894,
0.0453903191,
0.0210573599,
0.0045381994,
-0.0071990024,
0.0109702069,
0.0461403057,
-0.0218576342,
0.0929506123,
0.0061176666,
-0.0128096892,
0.0406578332,
0.0143577876,
-0.0479844771,
0.0634297207,
0.0269495267,
0.0252810046,
0.0646822751,
0.010937091,
0.035575673,
0.0196600389,
-0.0348980762,
-0.0475191288,
0.0314943194,
-0.0209923014,
-0.0126948971,
0.0382273383,
-0.0358923376,
0.0671942681,
0.0036106834,
-0.0064133829,
0.0212617908,
0.1190365478,
0.0021313953,
0.0482457913,
0.0534501076,
0.0201601833,
0.0779369548,
0.0241107084,
-0.0431705788,
-0.0323416628,
-0.050070893,
0.004515341,
-0.0222387537,
0.0161670279,
0.0303767305,
-0.0326646231,
-0.0235219896,
0.0370262004,
0.02900148,
-0.0582349747,
0.0543967523,
0.0082538053,
-0.0257874373,
-0.0275283735,
0.0202011783,
-0.0164951663,
-0.0156714506,
-0.065077737,
-0.0096778199,
0.07149975,
0.0998355225,
-0.0565750971,
-0.0065739425,
0.0264393296,
-0.0461667739,
0.040546719,
0.025998706,
-0.0111052757,
-0.0087956907,
-0.025377512,
0.0221224055,
0.0105071878,
0.0218178649,
0.0232000723,
0.0370619334,
0.0409679152,
-0.0264485609,
-0.0298270881,
-0.0396569967,
0.0319468603,
-0.0283101331,
-0.0636876673,
-0.0338363871,
-0.0164511353,
0.0100136269,
0.0355329327,
-0.0293693114,
-0.0021013625,
0.0057199728,
-0.0013849289,
-0.0414308459,
0.0255910903,
0.0012741197,
-0.0107396049,
0.0392625406,
-0.0784157291,
-0.0036431937,
0.0085946508,
-0.0120382756,
-0.0104109785,
0.0071956716,
-0.0662052557,
0.0678118616,
-0.047749646,
0.0255162474,
-0.0276520699,
0.0142007479,
-0.0177340414,
0.0664630085,
0.0160478186,
0.0482810289,
-0.0209131017,
-0.0174627565,
0.026888011,
-0.0167920962,
-0.0545862764,
-0.0058634644,
0.0118903732,
0.0298478827,
0.0258335043,
0.0243358538,
-0.0362607799,
-0.0264904145,
-0.1098402441,
0.0234996043,
0.0075151147,
0.0062266239,
0.031205358,
-0.0313335843,
-0.0261673257,
0.012823021,
-0.0101955254,
0.0208998807,
0.0268613864,
-0.0033957739,
0.0389084443,
-0.0006517043,
0.0018339995,
-0.0266886931,
0.0452146046,
-0.0424038544,
0.0241442528,
0.0542566814,
-0.0673418641,
0.0056441962,
0.008996889,
-0.0333239697,
0.0166788977,
0.0034786812,
-0.0547052547,
0.0115704024,
0.0165634565,
-0.0231814943,
0.0352757238,
0.0055884798,
0.0149199814,
0.0447458886,
-0.0402215458,
0.0023676511,
-0.001269865,
-0.0115811592,
-0.0547015406,
-0.0088657727,
-0.0385893583,
0.0104754455,
0.051897157,
0.0377298892,
0.0090740724,
-0.0283104889,
0.0438394882,
-0.0433873981,
-0.0193139818,
-0.0345348269,
0.032043159,
-0.0203276128,
0.0376606807,
-0.0169224385,
-0.0309864506,
0.0482294261,
-0.0316436663,
0.0057084551,
-0.117073819,
0.0161526743,
-0.0180984829,
0.0797688141,
0.0207570493,
0.0357899219,
0.0071828621,
-0.0204839148,
-0.0137402583,
-0.0019387667,
0.0242269486,
-0.0612959713,
0.0078045046,
-0.0689851567,
0.0112952972,
0.0121028405,
-0.0043436107,
-0.0435125493,
0.0006419034,
-0.0439150259,
-0.0099444399,
0.0715630725,
-0.0260803625,
0.0170815941,
-0.002096416,
0.009991358,
0.0453195274,
0.0191479661,
-0.0367739834,
-0.0027659053,
0.0037016424,
0.0002203054,
0.007603867,
0.0322672203,
0.0185302682,
0.00228781,
0.0240053684,
-0.0124371713,
-0.0140403295,
-0.0224326979,
0.0001601768,
-0.0115336394,
-0.0332620479,
-0.0081067896,
-0.0075440239,
0.0131441224,
-0.0435030386,
-0.0048213429,
0.1003984511,
0.0572853647,
-0.0511478931,
-0.0025498422,
-0.0086350515,
-0.051304508,
0.0113103259,
0.0464575402,
-0.1100276858,
-0.009670211,
-0.016985245,
0.0023204391,
-0.0317119844,
-0.0255051162,
-0.0675540715,
-0.1122853607,
0.026681073,
-0.0200083442,
-0.0259191617,
-0.0000136093,
-0.0017391799,
-0.0274968781,
-0.0434626825,
-0.0173869077,
-0.0034184495,
-0.0289219022,
0.0013368927,
-0.0031891384,
-0.0507945269,
0.0039185956,
0.0657077879,
-0.0169015471,
0.0333618335,
0.0554097258,
0.0672290027,
-0.0334918462,
0.0052487883,
0.0017036792,
0.0044773966,
0.0111084646,
-0.0149734123,
0.0720957816,
0.0087583307,
0.0169062,
-0.0041281651,
-0.007825437,
-0.0346828848,
0.0025824031,
0.069266893,
0.0576520637,
-0.0283904299,
-0.0063225841,
0.0033393328,
0.0152485073,
-0.0078139575,
0.0432125442,
0.005031778,
0.0027752363,
-0.0382165052,
-0.0199914854,
0.0029099586,
-0.0265730284,
-0.0825825855,
0.0023874675,
-0.0176081583,
-0.0416203849,
-0.0978268161,
-0.0582180172,
0.0151268225,
0.030874148,
0.040637251,
0.0189263932,
0.0164004397,
0.0385094695,
-0.0326469727,
0.0019210095,
0.0063873464,
-0.012167518,
-0.006181472,
-0.016334625,
-0.0064387699,
-0.0194833912,
-0.0275290329,
0.0289529078,
-0.0806735754,
-0.0423879027,
0.0362034775,
0.0088326037,
0.0371681005,
0.0032166555,
-0.0826168507,
-0.0072746607,
0.029995922,
0.0499078929,
-0.0405968502,
0.0111018829,
0.0069441115,
0.0499916822,
-0.0122007094,
0.0235496964,
0.0100766663,
-0.0023766069,
-0.0317967348,
-0.0000350648,
-0.0159013849,
-0.0212128758,
0.037428543,
0.0253697596,
0.047863055,
-0.0376298726,
0.0394545272,
-0.016438799,
-0.0386250541,
-0.0073971273,
-0.0225854199,
0.0090863556,
-0.0026493357,
0.0034860841,
-0.0222477876,
-0.0303321742,
0.0022825853,
-0.0565652736,
0.0245920178,
-0.009067513,
0.0043222182,
0.0444132239,
0.0000052578,
-0.0197958034,
0.0108011225,
0.0164705701,
0.0373339914,
-0.0242550783,
0.0660849437,
-0.0161795318,
0.0695639104,
0.0063041952,
-0.0197390392,
-0.0028423269,
0.0481036901,
-0.0418518521,
-0.056413684,
-0.0101759695,
0.0857431963,
0.0694563389,
-0.033952944,
0.0044978359,
-0.0551460907,
0.002047362,
-0.0027359654,
-0.0116272233,
0.0208714753,
0.0172988102,
-0.0147904102,
-0.0004498811,
-0.0189770292,
-0.0341845192,
0.0644832104,
-0.0586621463,
0.0230993312,
0.0514822602,
-0.067788817,
-0.0241467394,
-0.0483279563,
-0.0099104773,
-0.0157798845,
0.0178682562,
0.0210857522,
-0.0757383034,
-0.0581471696,
0.0117988437,
0.0039461856,
0.035592366,
-0.0017307381,
0.0380613543,
0.091813609,
-0.0039692363,
-0.0113663664,
-0.0516833588,
0.0258198045,
-0.0506863669,
-0.0060177576,
-0.0033966415,
-5.700478304e-33,
-0.0239227358,
-0.0748005211,
0.0483609065,
0.0435152613,
0.0242990702,
0.0082663428,
-0.0161451623,
-0.0140529685,
0.0069684749,
0.0184417237,
-0.0496785454,
0.0116599323,
0.0162377134,
-0.0530038439,
0.0183556508,
-0.004983326,
-0.0187207777,
-0.0120041976,
-0.0403222665,
-0.0363972671,
0.0521247126,
0.0187713783,
0.0799653903,
-0.0637927949,
0.0446101725,
0.0187680088,
0.0099252732,
0.0052172458,
0.0176314488,
0.0222743917,
-0.0471369438,
0.0315045901,
0.0266673677,
-0.0216341782,
0.0093599344,
0.0198126361,
-0.0409855209,
-0.0823707059,
0.0501204841,
0.0291031972,
0.0317655206,
-0.0034567809,
0.0156234,
-0.0327794626,
-0.0396747924,
0.0458921455,
0.0445269495,
-0.0314221308,
0.0027421813,
0.0092909615,
-0.0538672842,
0.0349606089,
0.0103918789,
-0.034002047,
0.011297184,
0.0048851073,
-0.0114348698,
-0.0661897883,
-0.0236349218,
0.0044496614,
-0.003487668,
0.0182330254,
0.038590122,
-0.019489333,
-0.0051490967,
0.0759081393,
0.0331227072,
-0.0137752052,
0.0003239692,
0.0376112163,
0.0227072742,
0.0036081895,
0.0319512635,
0.0794051066,
0.0432579108,
-0.0106520196,
0.0286556538,
0.0172689352,
0.0479430929,
0.0221496001,
0.0231159795,
-0.028022306,
-0.0813142285,
-0.0061865766,
-0.0113834981,
0.0163776316,
-0.0139499251,
-0.0337473974,
0.0001178149,
-0.028117951,
-0.0030876594,
-0.0084519284,
-0.0205667112,
-0.033491075,
0.0055720326,
-0.0121749053,
-0.0122790709,
-0.0001460412,
0.0027094553,
0.0441596285,
-0.0365624577,
-0.0038047608,
-0.0152281336,
0.0605495609,
0.0277641565,
-0.0173615497,
0.0000531716,
0.0144819357,
-0.0298269652,
-0.00227609,
-0.043258246,
0.0323344916,
-0.0074239518,
-0.028398525,
0.0133001283,
0.0269731767,
-0.0025794674,
0.0081289699,
0.0435378365,
0.0035589682,
-0.0286669265,
-0.0030911346,
-0.0264379214,
-0.015663974,
-0.0526010096,
0.0118758054,
-0.0106495582,
0.0057295975,
-0.0170563199,
-0.0310925972,
0.0066465889,
-0.017807506,
2.733e-7,
0.062522091,
0.0564951487,
0.0194790531,
0.046869196,
-0.0020346059,
0.004968687,
-0.0160801467,
0.0343048684,
-0.0487677418,
-0.009074227,
0.005007206,
0.0328711905,
0.0299367402,
0.0875985697,
-0.0645869076,
-0.0453353487,
-0.0197223201,
-0.0461350232,
-0.0731012821,
0.0269885287,
0.0660422966,
0.045138739,
0.0339755639,
-0.0192621835,
-0.0372524671,
-0.0862266645,
0.0035209262,
0.0024322697,
-0.0357001573,
0.0246528964,
0.0560339317,
0.0446370617,
0.0182237588,
0.0401336066,
0.0101091368,
0.0225269236,
0.0282254871,
0.0248748232,
-0.0180967543,
0.011018537,
0.0159433298,
-0.0792731568,
-0.0099221589,
-0.0333551206,
0.0548062958,
-0.0059997607,
0.0017793116,
-0.0448673107,
0.0386467613,
-0.0167060383,
0.017713014,
-0.0119739836,
-0.0559838153,
0.0158558562,
0.0105687929,
-0.0124013359,
-0.0038634688,
-0.0718232021,
0.0299774259,
0.0343413129,
-0.0134409824,
-0.0539755374,
-0.0114711104,
-0.0026527559,
0.0006109397,
-0.0651277676,
0.0237512868,
2.033880274e-34,
0.0169954672,
-0.0271788873,
-0.0140979746,
-0.0001276734,
0.0874586478,
0.0162162483,
0.0693198964,
0.0146986851,
-0.0049468339,
-0.0197069775,
0.013217424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16770v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16770v2 | Persona-Coded Poly-Encoder: Persona-Guided Multi-Stream Conversational Sentence Scoring | 2023-09-28T18:07:01 | 2023-12-01T18:45:12 | Junfeng Liu, Christopher Symons, Ranga Raju Vatsavai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent advances in machine learning and deep learning have led to the
widespread use of Conversational AI in many practical applications. However, it
is still very challenging to leverage auxiliary information that can provide
conversational context or personalized tuning to improve the quality of
conversations. For example, there has only been limited research on using an
individuals persona information to improve conversation quality, and even
state-of-the-art conversational AI techniques are unable to effectively
leverage signals from heterogeneous sources of auxiliary data, such as
multi-modal interaction data, demographics, SDOH data, etc. In this paper, we
present a novel Persona-Coded Poly-Encoder method that leverages persona
information in a multi-stream encoding scheme to improve the quality of
response generation for conversations. To show the efficacy of the proposed
method, we evaluate our method on two different persona-based conversational
datasets, and compared against two state-of-the-art methods. Our experimental
results and analysis demonstrate that our method can improve conversation
quality over the baseline method Poly-Encoder by 3.32% and 2.94% in terms of
BLEU score and HR@1, respectively. More significantly, our method offers a path
to better utilization of multi-modal data in conversational tasks. Lastly, our
study outlines several challenges and future research directions for advancing
personalized conversational AI technology. | [
0.0332787558,
0.0581347048,
-0.0316608436,
-0.0197707824,
-0.003469028,
-0.0016049944,
0.0355819836,
-0.0300464407,
-0.0145394448,
-0.0121984668,
-0.0298478622,
-0.0579161756,
0.0450616553,
0.0796119422,
0.0204172079,
-0.0793374628,
0.0149189755,
0.009069385,
0.045780357,
0.0082456777,
0.0183963887,
0.0106950048,
-0.0235369466,
0.0524576269,
-0.0488288216,
-0.0068228506,
-0.0255239643,
0.011799993,
0.0364196934,
-0.0016577228,
0.0377199799,
0.0429741479,
0.0171703473,
-0.0152802458,
0.0000018778,
-0.0160255786,
-0.003069849,
-0.0384290926,
-0.0060100877,
-0.0264986139,
0.0182332136,
0.0174341835,
-0.0114545692,
0.0574602559,
-0.0434811972,
-0.0016044328,
0.034597531,
0.047310099,
0.0794632062,
0.0804716498,
-0.0277024787,
-0.0327028409,
0.0309352782,
-0.0179383978,
-0.0001543626,
-0.0169585403,
-0.0273794327,
0.0020257875,
-0.0049204254,
0.0101778721,
-0.0097494386,
0.0250903759,
0.0386657044,
-0.0283156075,
0.0501148328,
0.0255676564,
-0.0026244135,
-0.0209158342,
-0.007374756,
0.1082212627,
0.0318520665,
0.03221187,
-0.0192059986,
0.0163114611,
0.0373685509,
-0.0566237085,
-0.0266232323,
-0.0167279672,
0.0316170044,
-0.0127057806,
-0.060802862,
0.0438501611,
-0.0069370698,
-0.0160393864,
0.0024866688,
0.0038589376,
0.0001227352,
-0.028268097,
-0.0000100163,
0.0077277711,
0.0426502712,
-0.0355062596,
0.0457748622,
0.0147679206,
-0.0490056649,
0.0103485016,
-0.0662881061,
-0.0011623326,
-0.0263239853,
0.000113577,
0.0115159443,
0.0457471162,
-0.0012728613,
-0.035414014,
0.0313950628,
0.0375466868,
0.020342892,
-0.0439929813,
0.0074008219,
-0.0266196057,
-0.0494296364,
-0.0119617665,
-0.0125899091,
0.0290243216,
-0.0335553698,
-0.0351814292,
-0.0791275054,
0.0399373546,
-0.0253758356,
0.0002934464,
-0.008454184,
0.0359980725,
-0.0378286913,
0.0273444317,
-0.0243969969,
0.0633690357,
-0.0520695932,
0.0145373261,
0.0273423065,
-0.0707532689,
-0.0016309118,
0.0397367775,
0.0452588461,
0.0048352559,
-0.0169276614,
-0.0203925464,
-0.038720157,
-0.0270558484,
0.0220407825,
-0.0302939042,
-0.0347097926,
-0.0682858005,
-0.0195861068,
-0.0320407413,
0.0510631725,
-0.01746976,
-0.0159297809,
-0.0277821086,
0.00808476,
-0.0041229324,
0.0075560152,
0.0335526653,
-0.0089926692,
0.0241061933,
0.0297341142,
0.0132814944,
0.0186904147,
0.0366993025,
0.0571575761,
0.0089384923,
0.0258415435,
-0.03655589,
0.0625824481,
0.0284943208,
0.0148717966,
-0.0259003472,
0.0430435464,
-0.0209769513,
-0.0195707381,
0.0441788435,
0.0621380992,
0.0478283726,
-0.0497601889,
-0.0074026366,
0.0691857859,
0.0297722537,
-0.0011339699,
0.0404146276,
0.0345312059,
0.0557624623,
-0.0021075255,
0.0112634962,
-0.0123182638,
0.0305616837,
-0.0195437707,
-0.0202283543,
0.0452160835,
0.0115193296,
-0.0430434868,
-0.0617444552,
0.0495106988,
-0.0270277597,
0.0125538893,
0.0011296143,
-0.0191593394,
-0.0041126027,
-0.0466730744,
0.0355957709,
-0.0083770528,
-0.0755621418,
0.0029917129,
0.0085241245,
-0.0308364183,
0.1010210663,
0.0193583574,
0.020849267,
-0.0144684166,
-0.0292248596,
-0.0231358688,
0.0436770506,
0.0182351973,
-0.0182444379,
0.078736864,
-0.0709889829,
-0.0114475777,
-0.0253472328,
-0.0348938033,
0.0431254506,
0.0035653766,
0.0060164081,
0.0181238353,
0.0458579622,
0.0269054305,
-0.0115530817,
-0.0409499593,
0.0119427918,
0.054999195,
0.0242023803,
0.0219801422,
0.0662495568,
0.005033467,
-0.0237070583,
0.0196471158,
-0.0284478273,
-0.0146542983,
0.0372926779,
-0.0522000119,
-0.0603613555,
0.0061352733,
-0.0484635942,
-0.0278182551,
0.0580313616,
0.0031122232,
-0.0611746535,
0.039115008,
-0.0780414939,
0.003452538,
-0.0229607597,
0.0039515509,
0.030153513,
0.0790777802,
0.0181949381,
0.0190118812,
-0.0164209548,
-0.0248602368,
0.0058606188,
0.035173215,
-0.0082965093,
-0.0823702216,
-0.0031309924,
-0.0020370008,
-0.0012123308,
-0.0012220921,
0.0360050797,
-0.0026258596,
-0.0617514625,
-0.0214743484,
-0.1456917524,
0.0064984132,
-0.007106002,
-0.018033443,
-0.005660757,
0.0468458906,
-0.0219867323,
-0.0241419002,
-0.0863965973,
0.0006720904,
0.0303742811,
-0.003485997,
0.0401138924,
0.0100895436,
-0.020689629,
-0.0197414383,
0.0071999286,
0.0222109258,
0.0389555134,
-0.0264990907,
-0.0077465782,
-0.0187870618,
-0.0190465655,
-0.0326065235,
0.0261492115,
0.0031061193,
-0.0448331609,
0.0287004225,
0.0329640657,
0.0823666155,
0.0581821352,
0.0432064794,
0.0349797383,
-0.0200810824,
-0.0172956623,
-0.0664926916,
0.0438046977,
-0.0222919472,
0.0414418355,
-0.048250258,
-0.0346553996,
0.025142258,
-0.0275256019,
0.0254891422,
0.0505634621,
-0.0727394223,
0.026856238,
0.050892435,
-0.0866449401,
0.0164853819,
-0.005486853,
-0.0228201989,
0.0243533291,
0.0028877943,
-0.0257392153,
0.0494282059,
-0.0029402543,
-0.0365004316,
-0.0064613386,
0.0025048556,
-0.0117035126,
0.0308963936,
-0.0304367337,
0.0213929862,
-0.0295054018,
-0.0486638397,
-0.0123258345,
0.0009150603,
-0.0398092382,
-0.0299192257,
0.0184108522,
-0.0190537479,
-0.0359223038,
0.0256501101,
-0.0613025129,
-0.04677945,
-0.0140678389,
0.0052605839,
-0.0017183212,
0.0265794862,
-0.0091919117,
-0.0547376238,
-0.0116907386,
-0.0184347294,
-0.0092071015,
-0.0455696806,
0.0109428735,
-0.0074797939,
0.0409638621,
0.0430435874,
0.0532191582,
0.0218952075,
-0.0361303613,
0.0516585074,
0.0122705828,
-0.007814941,
0.0062213098,
-0.0043004476,
-0.0017031103,
0.0176210217,
0.0096717607,
-0.0246436577,
0.0220726244,
0.0876679569,
-0.0234899577,
-0.0125779193,
0.1403761953,
0.0243370067,
-0.0516214035,
-0.0058348263,
-0.0062546972,
0.0656290874,
-0.0113282688,
0.0268615056,
-0.0398963839,
-0.0391557775,
0.0018141539,
0.0328092352,
-0.0439231507,
-0.0259408373,
-0.0325356573,
-0.0938686877,
0.020437425,
0.0101109268,
-0.0344440527,
-0.0309214815,
-0.0225114692,
0.0043695406,
0.0003679908,
0.041867312,
-0.0356617905,
0.0360682048,
-0.0155973081,
-0.0051428676,
-0.0590715706,
-0.0730930269,
0.0029467684,
-0.0258719362,
0.0920814276,
0.0682330057,
0.0842665359,
0.0114030438,
-0.0086857099,
-0.0222955626,
0.0357953422,
0.010140609,
-0.0027858333,
0.0731979385,
-0.0444225557,
0.015840238,
-0.0311765429,
0.0322718807,
-0.0259979665,
0.0074576,
0.0071162172,
-0.0115975868,
-0.0611392185,
0.013570196,
-0.0158256441,
0.0315634757,
0.0392421857,
0.0618791841,
0.0118962983,
-0.0680434257,
-0.0208728239,
-0.0058524385,
0.013947634,
-0.0653627366,
0.0087427124,
-0.0158064347,
0.0207121465,
-0.0517437495,
-0.0614209436,
-0.0904701799,
0.0203526616,
0.0074570007,
-0.0313985348,
-0.0309316944,
0.0211592726,
0.0370912589,
-0.021211613,
-0.0154667338,
-0.0256541353,
0.0178731643,
-0.0442282818,
-0.0295717325,
0.0037577709,
-0.0428491347,
0.0360355377,
0.0169886593,
-0.0706279576,
-0.024911467,
-0.01174084,
0.0339938253,
0.0148342215,
0.0879220888,
0.0013043303,
-0.0649048313,
-0.0055426755,
0.0102087446,
-0.0421397649,
0.0221227296,
0.0433198474,
0.0341545753,
-0.0186369345,
0.0363865644,
-0.0138208466,
0.0161169767,
-0.0346931405,
0.0234790184,
-0.0250509046,
-0.0830961019,
-0.0076061273,
0.0016406816,
0.0041267313,
0.0036535629,
-0.0263183191,
0.0030024194,
-0.0153226601,
-0.0563660152,
0.0053619598,
-0.0545577072,
-0.0288333315,
0.0100812316,
0.0167061556,
0.0060642934,
0.005026239,
-0.0374520496,
-0.0109737385,
-0.0365276486,
-0.0219304971,
0.0144887129,
-0.0199538525,
-0.0209331326,
-0.0074057439,
-0.0117511712,
0.0280787032,
0.0352224894,
0.0262289178,
-0.0047446787,
0.0426109619,
-0.0184399784,
-0.0238204896,
0.0175446831,
0.0615483671,
-0.0600085519,
0.0289474409,
-0.005626854,
0.0226944219,
0.0063345046,
0.043319501,
0.0436023697,
0.0070783217,
0.029591186,
-0.0319598168,
0.0375540406,
-0.0162113141,
-0.0313270725,
0.0068101315,
-0.022881791,
-0.0428377502,
0.0076256092,
0.047138907,
-0.0305965766,
-0.0000771745,
-0.0388127193,
-0.0048064031,
-0.0664026216,
-0.0293772481,
0.011210327,
0.0430507846,
0.0050946302,
0.0053025652,
-0.0378178395,
-0.0136021916,
0.0101840207,
-0.0191107336,
-0.0057763215,
-0.0042187544,
0.0382043906,
0.0292687956,
-0.047704082,
-0.0123292422,
-0.0505711101,
-0.0182153489,
-0.0313656889,
-0.0260190312,
-0.0070208944,
-5.640060833e-33,
-0.052976165,
-0.0197536666,
-0.0019208117,
-0.022470098,
-0.0592068881,
-0.0109648779,
-0.051312346,
0.0056171878,
-0.0026300934,
-0.0160349887,
-0.009643916,
0.0228406787,
0.0096403724,
0.0407125875,
-0.0351408161,
-0.005024598,
0.0731362924,
0.0010074254,
-0.0313104801,
0.067489855,
0.0321200825,
0.0244086087,
-0.005358397,
-0.0610261559,
0.0125104645,
-0.0111954985,
-0.0338028297,
0.0090028327,
0.061798811,
0.0588394813,
-0.0068044378,
0.0379765518,
0.0038263886,
0.0010128202,
-0.0072064684,
0.0781059787,
-0.054684367,
-0.0340174548,
-0.0152024236,
0.0187102333,
-0.0492307581,
-0.06037689,
0.035656888,
0.0124034379,
-0.0089291036,
-0.0027234494,
0.033988189,
-0.0069179414,
0.0211707484,
-0.0463877842,
-0.0384202935,
0.0032540972,
-0.0464846902,
-0.0414586142,
-0.0084768385,
0.0946023762,
0.0106237531,
-0.0241839886,
-0.056139823,
0.0556376316,
-0.0234505609,
-0.0208110213,
0.026680287,
0.0333915874,
0.0104820244,
0.0436496027,
0.0549678095,
0.0100299325,
-0.0195302628,
-0.011340905,
0.0354242623,
0.0177302342,
0.0138061913,
0.0681954622,
-0.0260135476,
-0.0314974226,
-0.0320070647,
0.0620870031,
0.0437826253,
-0.0165558942,
0.0075721098,
0.001898339,
-0.0504439846,
-0.017730251,
-0.0225126967,
0.001391968,
-0.0022742604,
-0.030487828,
0.0185518395,
0.0040370813,
-0.0102924267,
-0.0158084668,
0.0370826051,
-0.0562422387,
0.0200727303,
0.0315762125,
-0.0450278111,
0.0344020687,
0.015055744,
-0.0105136745,
-0.0307767056,
0.0016030966,
0.0970597491,
0.0089981379,
0.0174111966,
-0.0094007719,
-0.0041168379,
0.0326385014,
-0.0394117348,
-0.0199887026,
-0.0081405882,
0.0599941723,
-0.0200629588,
0.0316339321,
-0.0028284055,
0.019871559,
-0.0534217842,
0.0680850297,
-0.0071468279,
0.052742213,
-0.0393729098,
-0.0592606664,
0.0428891033,
-0.0033467535,
-0.0502221137,
0.0029323187,
-0.0266834218,
-0.0513888784,
0.0331819244,
-0.0409024321,
-0.0160069801,
-0.0007392944,
2.525e-7,
-0.0359921269,
0.0537327714,
0.0236763712,
-0.0099453758,
0.0411848761,
0.0565830171,
0.0224853642,
0.0393233858,
0.0134432605,
-0.014230419,
0.0442551225,
0.0210174359,
0.0671151057,
0.0106562497,
-0.095255129,
-0.0212820023,
-0.0060259034,
-0.0178103093,
-0.0205261093,
0.0106623517,
0.1039396301,
0.0599220432,
0.0095894476,
-0.0169204306,
0.02557314,
0.0705460012,
0.060125526,
-0.0043053101,
-0.0593212768,
0.0104671437,
0.0268072579,
-0.0106426505,
0.0096175829,
0.0377590694,
0.0004832678,
0.0346564241,
0.0015582427,
0.0716177374,
-0.0139150247,
-0.0916773975,
-0.0076003773,
0.0538085848,
-0.0106206201,
0.005196861,
0.0551384166,
-0.0066489982,
-0.0588303097,
-0.0072808457,
-0.024423724,
0.0219100378,
0.0258577354,
-0.0078673782,
-0.052744478,
0.0263140071,
0.0215239134,
-0.0227176882,
0.0026832258,
-0.0580200553,
0.0146085797,
-0.0361451916,
-0.0372614749,
-0.0442666709,
-0.0192360952,
-0.0123332422,
0.0319442861,
-0.0439595282,
0.0248727426,
1.901566102e-34,
0.0249814671,
0.0113719441,
0.0122811366,
-0.0016567697,
0.035231486,
-0.0255427696,
0.0143767782,
-0.0138557516,
0.0548060983,
-0.050839711,
-0.008435824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16671v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16671v4 | Demystifying CLIP Data | 2023-09-28T17:59:56 | 2024-04-07T17:22:46 | Hu Xu, Saining Xie, Xiaoqing Ellen Tan, Po-Yao Huang, Russell Howes, Vasu Sharma, Shang-Wen Li, Gargi Ghosh, Luke Zettlemoyer, Christoph Feichtenhofer | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Contrastive Language-Image Pre-training (CLIP) is an approach that has
advanced research and applications in computer vision, fueling modern
recognition systems and generative models. We believe that the main ingredient
to the success of CLIP is its data and not the model architecture or
pre-training objective. However, CLIP only provides very limited information
about its data and how it has been collected, leading to works that aim to
reproduce CLIP's data by filtering with its model parameters. In this work, we
intend to reveal CLIP's data curation approach and in our pursuit of making it
open to the community introduce Metadata-Curated Language-Image Pre-training
(MetaCLIP). MetaCLIP takes a raw data pool and metadata (derived from CLIP's
concepts) and yields a balanced subset over the metadata distribution. Our
experimental study rigorously isolates the model and training settings,
concentrating solely on data. MetaCLIP applied to CommonCrawl with 400M
image-text data pairs outperforms CLIP's data on multiple standard benchmarks.
In zero-shot ImageNet classification, MetaCLIP achieves 70.8% accuracy,
surpassing CLIP's 68.3% on ViT-B models. Scaling to 1B data, while maintaining
the same training budget, attains 72.4%. Our observations hold across various
model sizes, exemplified by ViT-H achieving 80.5%, without any
bells-and-whistles. Curation code and training data distribution on metadata is
made available at https://github.com/facebookresearch/MetaCLIP. | [
0.003509881,
0.0639103651,
0.0204630941,
0.050274983,
-0.012558328,
0.0102205742,
0.0112009514,
0.0157493036,
-0.0619065948,
-0.0530716255,
-0.0592410527,
-0.0068261819,
0.0094949193,
0.0284181535,
-0.0068281437,
-0.0880752727,
-0.0026609022,
-0.0031099059,
-0.0240668692,
-0.0039567933,
0.0167253148,
0.0204989184,
0.011389723,
0.0049809637,
-0.0156500433,
0.0037836279,
0.0106913503,
0.0545256399,
0.031819012,
-0.0183776617,
0.018040007,
0.0691713691,
0.0251620673,
0.0294537004,
0.0000021389,
-0.0287902784,
0.0084315762,
0.0089278044,
-0.0208866987,
-0.0176263154,
0.0694549382,
-0.0196637344,
-0.0005363487,
-0.0064679109,
-0.0223875232,
-0.0513205342,
0.0692223608,
0.0491527095,
0.0618433654,
0.0564415418,
-0.0381809995,
-0.0368310101,
-0.0078127366,
-0.0256907549,
0.0208054204,
0.0291607026,
0.0004519023,
0.0257238224,
-0.008796135,
0.0192051064,
-0.0272139069,
0.0376556702,
0.0389572345,
0.035130702,
0.0126547059,
0.0823193043,
-0.0853178874,
-0.0309743769,
0.0240475032,
0.0881801397,
-0.0223890077,
-0.0423647352,
-0.0189080574,
-0.0341168754,
-0.0111522926,
-0.0010806109,
-0.0213062353,
0.0332616046,
0.0248468593,
0.0504011177,
-0.033880908,
0.0292984564,
0.0226817653,
0.0217052642,
-0.0171486977,
-0.0052148271,
0.0072243358,
0.0224562977,
0.0155915665,
0.0233408362,
-0.0237972084,
-0.0420773588,
-0.022258861,
-0.0047476767,
0.036377795,
-0.0107705547,
-0.0640783086,
-0.0914444551,
0.0204720479,
-0.0116687594,
0.0388497487,
0.0085379975,
-0.0949737057,
0.056389939,
-0.0123662176,
-0.0119840903,
0.0165857952,
0.056405481,
-0.0293394141,
-0.0250688717,
-0.0083933873,
0.0116466628,
-0.0554197803,
-0.0019228205,
-0.0232223067,
-0.0124907633,
-0.0199720636,
-0.0289519913,
-0.0150378654,
-0.0111901006,
0.0196977407,
0.0058099735,
-0.0510949343,
-0.0135642448,
0.0132904984,
-0.0242054462,
-0.0154801337,
0.0341958888,
-0.0184409786,
-0.0811837912,
-0.0158372093,
0.0444764197,
0.02230037,
-0.0447412878,
0.0470344611,
0.041579809,
-0.0145487674,
-0.0723751709,
-0.0394308493,
0.0004044449,
-0.0210249629,
-0.0687430128,
0.0169331376,
-0.0990267769,
0.0193831474,
-0.0197259821,
0.0109105334,
-0.0229402091,
-0.0238689799,
0.0110505279,
-0.0276323035,
0.1171584949,
-0.0369484797,
-0.0316771828,
-0.0019322407,
0.0281041898,
-0.0056406721,
0.0674829409,
0.0129772052,
0.0263135526,
0.0312988684,
0.0175845232,
-0.0042787609,
0.0420309007,
0.0498258807,
0.0130000534,
-0.0591517501,
0.0076428745,
0.0144717731,
-0.0273040868,
0.0539329797,
0.0131399967,
-0.0516030416,
-0.0469114631,
0.0435674004,
0.065363057,
-0.0016319888,
0.0236886218,
0.0336780064,
0.0215015542,
0.0180979483,
-0.0158405323,
-0.053705968,
0.018000884,
-0.0109021077,
-0.0159544311,
-0.0146075515,
0.0372079313,
-0.0771747679,
-0.0144814476,
0.0026852505,
-0.03849921,
0.0072127464,
0.0017173373,
0.0605368093,
0.0255884342,
0.0028042416,
0.0339201279,
0.0549469478,
-0.0359577462,
0.0068354942,
-0.0554084443,
-0.0008694773,
0.0294981282,
0.021317387,
-0.0419791788,
-0.0008018613,
0.0243835151,
0.0348765366,
0.0318487063,
0.0157417133,
0.0035771041,
0.0399509743,
-0.0548988879,
-0.0579276383,
-0.0318955146,
-0.0145394206,
0.0366448015,
0.0094688395,
0.0266283602,
0.0313007645,
-0.0127198575,
-0.0425950587,
0.0374238603,
0.0149103729,
-0.0113204475,
0.0050804461,
0.0049852761,
0.0156757198,
0.0091635818,
-0.038072899,
-0.0337745398,
0.0194236469,
-0.010731671,
0.034207873,
0.0232466795,
-0.0328780487,
-0.0488010496,
0.0327936523,
-0.0697936043,
-0.0013743088,
0.0409355313,
-0.0642386675,
-0.0414746888,
-0.0030821858,
0.0173418913,
0.0396761671,
-0.0389926136,
-0.022611931,
0.0129799796,
0.0380829275,
0.0074500139,
0.0406900682,
-0.00410312,
-0.0178295802,
0.0178357624,
-0.0077907061,
0.028082693,
-0.0073525072,
-0.0424855016,
0.0202640984,
-0.0118972352,
0.0272365548,
0.0157285538,
0.0538566932,
-0.0558767766,
0.0380036943,
-0.0758751929,
-0.0229660217,
-0.0465418622,
-0.0129412413,
0.0316659324,
-0.0022005113,
-0.0173974913,
-0.0506075174,
-0.0337127857,
0.0109610064,
-0.0057926616,
0.0038600969,
0.0172150154,
0.0425154939,
0.0429337211,
-0.023656657,
-0.0354942381,
0.0498986058,
0.0518609025,
-0.0003700997,
-0.0241278876,
-0.0044122296,
0.0535557494,
-0.019916784,
0.0293020755,
-0.0220111329,
-0.0411130078,
0.0006513154,
-0.0492714196,
0.0027248077,
0.0442763753,
-0.0126901986,
-0.0012517305,
0.0271063149,
0.0161605515,
-0.0487542674,
-0.0141957598,
-0.006750735,
0.0140287373,
-0.0020160305,
-0.0122616868,
-0.0422342941,
0.0214429796,
-0.040081244,
0.0218918249,
-0.0515028797,
0.0173876043,
-0.0101631097,
-0.0216473266,
-0.0401417054,
0.0334198251,
0.0015472628,
0.0350934416,
-0.0354556628,
-0.0689425841,
0.0329300836,
-0.021714855,
-0.0275786482,
-0.0025093514,
-0.0205761027,
-0.0115796775,
0.0498707928,
0.0361649245,
0.0287433732,
0.0151707977,
0.0102287475,
-0.0668819994,
-0.0512554981,
0.0096155051,
-0.0129938219,
0.0305221695,
-0.023427302,
0.0220339857,
-0.0354438387,
-0.0361089781,
-0.0444010086,
-0.0243036486,
-0.0249220151,
0.0166214611,
-0.0254863445,
-0.0193257611,
0.0024493064,
0.0070707737,
-0.0148528516,
0.0897092968,
0.0015657933,
-0.0078112502,
0.0064228312,
0.0506254211,
0.0264953971,
-0.0370295793,
0.0241727214,
-0.0147176189,
-0.0207067858,
0.0614690147,
0.0336938202,
-0.0124384714,
-0.0465422757,
0.0219092388,
0.0388826765,
0.0216033328,
0.002866182,
0.021594001,
0.0350886248,
-0.024561869,
-0.0150959101,
0.0790456906,
0.0114482483,
-0.0677352101,
-0.0433129445,
0.0234552603,
0.0267986543,
0.0186163187,
-0.0079266038,
-0.0636336505,
-0.0425048582,
-0.0221322142,
0.0228254553,
0.0192770548,
-0.0035199178,
-0.0492684059,
-0.0824696422,
0.0588704571,
0.0098744351,
-0.0372058898,
-0.0010019511,
-0.0037005306,
0.0020952381,
-0.0634704381,
-0.0039475313,
-0.0333612561,
-0.014989675,
0.0030889346,
0.0106967334,
0.0257644076,
-0.066982083,
0.0279372577,
-0.0336421393,
0.0078142602,
0.0501423851,
0.0099001387,
-0.0289418902,
-0.0219035633,
0.0545536205,
-0.0284299143,
-0.0163229294,
-0.0352297537,
0.1122530103,
-0.0326013528,
-0.0169401355,
0.0159113724,
0.0406816043,
-0.0215954836,
-0.0378463417,
-0.0388223156,
0.0279968027,
-0.0134024518,
-0.0141972909,
-0.0409036316,
-0.005751295,
0.0277598482,
0.0663198233,
0.0336010307,
-0.0308991037,
0.0006719446,
0.0138272401,
-0.0131624853,
-0.0775502324,
-0.0342297666,
0.0153182913,
0.012102114,
-0.0225323811,
-0.043523211,
-0.0498796999,
0.0121465996,
0.0323415771,
-0.035827063,
-0.0421091765,
-0.0187727269,
0.0176933073,
-0.0701259896,
0.0697008371,
-0.0499028228,
0.0032092433,
-0.0542398654,
-0.048255682,
0.033613123,
-0.0607596301,
-0.0405725017,
0.0026250866,
-0.0869804174,
-0.0248173829,
0.0010685754,
0.0892957225,
0.0198222753,
0.0665209815,
-0.0052744979,
-0.0326719508,
0.07017418,
0.0656041801,
0.0095717749,
-0.0267880242,
0.0586182028,
-0.0797532275,
-0.0034268466,
0.0210201461,
-0.0360493176,
0.0689141452,
0.0450605266,
-0.0535012744,
-0.0151845561,
-0.01421824,
-0.0080184489,
-0.0070850574,
0.0756076351,
-0.0475267619,
0.0275918469,
-0.0496277735,
-0.019963732,
0.0105875861,
-0.0050731706,
-0.0556272306,
0.0209285673,
0.0013218942,
-0.007796485,
-0.0240162611,
0.0303528886,
-0.0265564732,
0.0368215702,
-0.0287498422,
0.0204331577,
-0.0040225284,
0.0067766276,
0.042098809,
0.0048995172,
0.0078088348,
0.0298241302,
-0.0101480242,
0.0380413234,
-0.0164470319,
0.0400876664,
0.0364007093,
0.0126935598,
-0.0079104062,
0.0508543029,
-0.0462218076,
-0.0311631542,
-0.0655723363,
0.0082192915,
0.04475962,
-0.05098892,
0.0358087681,
-0.0491168126,
-0.0134523772,
-0.0248057712,
0.0108874757,
0.0310366023,
-0.0180361066,
0.0378770754,
0.0077577913,
-0.0018843798,
0.0177045409,
0.0776057616,
-0.0288192667,
0.0246217456,
0.034139391,
0.0001549924,
-0.0091658663,
-0.0264268219,
0.0200921688,
0.0055768443,
-0.0375183411,
0.0199081544,
-0.0180519633,
-0.0681974068,
-0.0091412328,
-0.0048321947,
0.0031229195,
0.0564802848,
0.0557827912,
0.0179245472,
0.0112283994,
0.0071145892,
0.0071551548,
-0.0151322158,
-0.0071251355,
0.0052155135,
0.0361067131,
-6.8022552e-33,
-0.0057877009,
0.0142796841,
0.0179598536,
0.0035188887,
0.0163600203,
0.0274111964,
-0.0171894338,
-0.0203708056,
-0.033006575,
0.0185637157,
-0.0035799509,
0.022562528,
0.0326390676,
0.0534001216,
-0.0269276369,
0.0127637181,
0.0478840768,
-0.0186251365,
-0.0083787423,
0.0399881043,
0.0102387732,
0.0162551925,
0.0816116482,
-0.0535435602,
-0.0238699019,
-0.0173002649,
-0.0215299856,
0.001555738,
0.036941912,
0.0491923913,
-0.0093267718,
0.016890524,
0.0080806343,
-0.0265715439,
-0.0465678163,
0.0029794683,
-0.0843342692,
-0.0255527664,
-0.011207372,
0.0689396039,
-0.0476191752,
-0.0036989332,
0.0114627033,
-0.0294645783,
0.0194262452,
-0.036520239,
0.0568593144,
-0.0157042593,
-0.0055726683,
-0.0402590819,
-0.0225150958,
0.0456409641,
-0.0061881808,
-0.0206326116,
0.0888019502,
0.0358952731,
0.0277029555,
0.049403023,
-0.0998966768,
0.0189835001,
0.0209640507,
0.0000128607,
0.0553871207,
0.0683662295,
0.0150562283,
0.0562204309,
-0.0119658355,
-0.0162311587,
0.0474601388,
-0.0154690016,
0.0338186398,
0.0505867004,
0.0202587061,
0.0374225862,
0.0739509985,
-0.0016751512,
-0.0602522679,
0.0135196019,
-0.0505633131,
0.0147778643,
0.0054484126,
0.0185684133,
-0.0073066577,
0.0031944434,
-0.0061488505,
-0.0940044597,
-0.0414167829,
-0.0309180915,
0.0074923732,
0.0308981612,
-0.0322970375,
0.0254720282,
0.0636743009,
-0.0372011997,
-0.0145779634,
0.0420621708,
-0.0462740697,
0.0196676906,
-0.0064628436,
0.0137884384,
-0.0723848194,
-0.0221928358,
0.0570304804,
0.0019372015,
0.0035884664,
0.038722191,
0.115702942,
0.029411599,
-0.0327363946,
-0.0000413526,
-0.0241498463,
0.0048765666,
0.0253155064,
0.040843334,
0.0216454677,
0.0362040959,
-0.0269788932,
0.0420348383,
0.0303903688,
-0.0085650561,
-0.0195871461,
-0.0389383174,
0.012823916,
0.0035069566,
0.0041984539,
0.0002463685,
-0.0464423001,
0.0085906098,
0.0627175048,
-0.0280514341,
-0.0237358399,
0.0139587736,
2.774e-7,
0.035984043,
-0.0135750938,
0.0031656101,
0.0055943108,
0.0155655583,
0.0475320555,
-0.028612975,
0.0202928949,
-0.0212604422,
-0.0177914314,
0.028791517,
0.0673671588,
0.0360817648,
0.0301065706,
-0.026034167,
0.0099488394,
-0.0583980903,
-0.0350475498,
-0.0249241237,
-0.0361561589,
0.0544450693,
0.1042604819,
0.0164354444,
-0.0380455144,
0.0457174145,
-0.0167242941,
0.0664581507,
-0.0570300557,
0.0388365276,
-0.0149409054,
-0.0090473508,
0.0540726036,
-0.0397995487,
-0.0058910679,
-0.0380298197,
-0.0184357315,
0.0192964636,
0.047608275,
-0.0177135989,
0.0040905988,
0.0051260306,
0.0235923063,
-0.0102531491,
-0.050742507,
0.0851682797,
-0.0556363501,
-0.0104949689,
-0.0397341251,
-0.0491585843,
-0.0101319198,
0.0464835651,
-0.0238058027,
-0.0088861566,
0.0425593816,
0.0200354513,
-0.0269463826,
-0.0640875995,
-0.1332346052,
-0.0182389989,
0.0236462113,
-0.0043039327,
-0.0190128963,
-0.0437016636,
-0.0226440616,
0.0256634243,
-0.0289141033,
0.0001370482,
2.158455125e-34,
0.0286726747,
0.0144708892,
0.0047952873,
-0.0240023304,
-0.0244540982,
0.0113906683,
-0.0097428327,
-0.0228320826,
-0.0138516435,
-0.0424977429,
-0.0139683904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16639v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16639v2 | MindShift: Leveraging Large Language Models for Mental-States-Based Problematic Smartphone Use Intervention | 2023-09-28T17:49:03 | 2024-02-28T04:45:17 | Ruolan Wu, Chun Yu, Xiaole Pan, Yujia Liu, Ningning Zhang, Yue Fu, Yuhan Wang, Zhi Zheng, Li Chen, Qiaolei Jiang, Xuhai Xu, Yuanchun Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, 68U35, H.5.2; I.2.7 | Problematic smartphone use negatively affects physical and mental health.
Despite the wide range of prior research, existing persuasive techniques are
not flexible enough to provide dynamic persuasion content based on users'
physical contexts and mental states. We first conducted a Wizard-of-Oz study
(N=12) and an interview study (N=10) to summarize the mental states behind
problematic smartphone use: boredom, stress, and inertia. This informs our
design of four persuasion strategies: understanding, comforting, evoking, and
scaffolding habits. We leveraged large language models (LLMs) to enable the
automatic and dynamic generation of effective persuasion content. We developed
MindShift, a novel LLM-powered problematic smartphone use intervention
technique. MindShift takes users' in-the-moment app usage behaviors, physical
contexts, mental states, goals \& habits as input, and generates personalized
and dynamic persuasive content with appropriate persuasion strategies. We
conducted a 5-week field experiment (N=25) to compare MindShift with its
simplified version (remove mental states) and baseline techniques (fixed
reminder). The results show that MindShift improves intervention acceptance
rates by 4.7-22.5% and reduces smartphone usage duration by 7.4-9.8%. Moreover,
users have a significant drop in smartphone addiction scale scores and a rise
in self-efficacy scale scores. Our study sheds light on the potential of
leveraging LLMs for context-aware persuasion in other behavior change domains. | [
0.0655629411,
0.0237903036,
-0.0142394984,
-0.0308018886,
0.0083253551,
0.0064959503,
0.0325257108,
-0.0183500536,
0.0425406359,
-0.0459954813,
0.0173882861,
-0.0052281134,
0.0247132424,
0.0000060776,
0.0064313021,
-0.0451025069,
-0.0250894949,
-0.0144117502,
0.0472108014,
0.0359825268,
0.0535192043,
0.0175123923,
0.0221735444,
0.0461975597,
0.0028892187,
-0.0742355362,
0.037958622,
0.05173821,
0.0026014419,
-0.1261750162,
0.0372428074,
0.0498953015,
0.0183779076,
-0.0199652109,
0.0000021115,
-0.0348425619,
0.0129552428,
-0.0008596244,
0.0010361194,
-0.0035979887,
0.0765896812,
0.0023420511,
-0.0144182537,
0.024161445,
-0.0374579914,
0.0433881097,
0.0259775314,
0.048375681,
0.0377873927,
0.0518629216,
-0.0501277186,
0.0186321139,
-0.0138160707,
0.0113116736,
0.0131693333,
0.0169309974,
0.0045953244,
-0.0064179217,
0.0369342566,
-0.0348467007,
0.0404801816,
0.0036545941,
-0.0105216401,
0.0064311712,
-0.0007126649,
-0.00182331,
0.0360259674,
-0.012368381,
0.002704483,
0.0724689439,
0.0084815575,
-0.0141313877,
0.0287624337,
-0.0115181794,
0.023798896,
0.0484816842,
-0.0453612953,
-0.0035163562,
0.0047691753,
0.0139296986,
0.0079207188,
0.0089929374,
0.0576658472,
-0.0035051843,
0.0085108848,
0.0029556784,
-0.0071376911,
-0.0620108247,
0.0232637785,
-0.0228665695,
0.0197229944,
-0.0481582657,
0.0020060788,
-0.0135528706,
-0.0499250367,
0.0383015461,
-0.0011033715,
-0.0182617065,
0.0283676405,
-0.068266809,
0.0271713641,
0.0365499519,
0.0095265312,
-0.0314823203,
0.055507984,
-0.0327246338,
0.0171199497,
-0.0202473812,
-0.004744574,
0.063399367,
-0.0543213002,
0.0066744741,
-0.0303701982,
-0.0180974714,
0.0093421107,
-0.062740244,
-0.0599221811,
0.0396386161,
-0.0472290479,
-0.0127507653,
-0.0542603359,
0.0193301588,
0.0207446143,
0.0105674528,
0.0148235066,
0.0590897463,
-0.0174029693,
0.0452651344,
0.0274692252,
-0.0121801663,
0.0517615303,
-0.0086994823,
-0.0168960765,
-0.0047591119,
-0.0012968017,
-0.0088586286,
-0.0049005253,
0.001657525,
-0.0614885055,
-0.0236670412,
-0.0435598418,
-0.0226370133,
-0.0319156572,
-0.0664829016,
-0.031107055,
0.0002286237,
0.0486703962,
-0.0570250899,
0.0314482488,
0.0191899464,
-0.0190472174,
0.0372612849,
-0.0328826234,
0.0110273687,
0.0301063173,
0.0516178571,
0.0199557282,
0.0349513441,
0.0466395915,
0.0426601022,
0.0217456724,
-0.0315517783,
0.0205078516,
0.0168843064,
-0.013993985,
-0.0054597412,
-0.0004133712,
-0.0552454554,
-0.0346464701,
-0.0020412679,
-0.0809492543,
0.0343390666,
-0.0062011187,
0.1274000108,
0.1105204895,
0.0876597315,
0.0078128371,
0.0127423732,
-0.0413562134,
0.0161194429,
-0.003484831,
-0.0555590428,
-0.0404165909,
-0.0140941497,
-0.0373545289,
0.0057350253,
0.0339278392,
0.013761295,
-0.0491661429,
-0.0492720082,
-0.0620692,
-0.0290247183,
0.045762632,
0.0345916674,
-0.0139912488,
0.0180172939,
0.0118707186,
0.0124020772,
0.0055022887,
-0.0161156505,
-0.0341476277,
-0.0311113559,
0.0929027572,
0.0737275034,
0.0269849952,
-0.0014241206,
-0.0085179303,
-0.0420045778,
0.0435107015,
0.0158817917,
0.0028527225,
0.0036215978,
-0.0265485067,
-0.0103115737,
-0.0188821517,
-0.001130202,
0.0010712396,
-0.0338513553,
-0.0196343325,
0.033890076,
0.0249311477,
0.0137799168,
-0.0570310988,
0.0095349662,
0.007589445,
-0.0321277454,
0.0120074013,
0.0293331072,
0.0341987573,
0.0416354537,
0.0290673543,
0.0027486871,
0.0136308856,
-0.0130960857,
0.0123737957,
0.0267678518,
0.0225395691,
0.0437193066,
0.0270378999,
-0.0068105157,
0.0347543545,
-0.0296993479,
0.0303471163,
0.0131815355,
0.0301325489,
-0.0265327878,
0.0860293135,
0.025219325,
0.0172286946,
0.0134349903,
0.0065540629,
0.0099902162,
0.0064184237,
0.0351475291,
-0.0393047035,
0.0123211769,
-0.0546827652,
-0.0264220312,
-0.0193413347,
0.0174029619,
0.004702799,
-0.0019360937,
0.0227963999,
0.0336707793,
0.0177619047,
-0.0494213067,
-0.03366163,
-0.0921245217,
-0.0287282504,
-0.0114714177,
-0.0202411953,
0.0280882791,
0.0326531641,
-0.0163013153,
0.0004733788,
-0.0375573672,
-0.0291647464,
0.032395646,
0.0470123515,
-0.0142060556,
-0.0216794219,
-0.0091009084,
0.0123024769,
0.006480963,
-0.046912834,
0.036139708,
0.0111142192,
-0.0198988225,
-0.0220560115,
-0.0242317822,
-0.0280231442,
-0.0465580113,
0.01209589,
-0.0123979347,
0.040448036,
0.0023713249,
0.0891404226,
0.0284462366,
0.0167315044,
0.0084047569,
0.026778046,
-0.0246530734,
-0.0632271841,
-0.0406814143,
0.0074020978,
-0.0050760577,
-0.020315228,
-0.0981226861,
0.0390976071,
0.0069294628,
0.0271119531,
0.0570360385,
-0.0101314345,
0.0504924655,
0.0066783912,
-0.0097469771,
-0.0043953117,
-0.000407919,
-0.0192215871,
0.035275057,
-0.0149872368,
-0.0666766688,
0.0294026453,
0.0248556361,
0.0205858052,
-0.0020589954,
-0.0240950789,
0.0257130787,
-0.0054556173,
-0.0295761134,
0.0316432305,
0.0946798027,
0.0052619181,
0.0736897141,
-0.1054189727,
-0.0326146297,
-0.0378289558,
0.0148180556,
-0.067209512,
-0.0168092269,
0.0550626926,
-0.0417016335,
-0.0218187328,
-0.0539641567,
-0.0495975055,
-0.0561148971,
-0.0176147576,
-0.0037387307,
-0.0419017859,
-0.0183674153,
0.0391204767,
0.0326832458,
0.0082059884,
-0.0169510301,
0.0324083529,
-0.0237717126,
0.0602653809,
-0.0025807468,
0.0114978142,
0.0021592153,
0.0655319914,
0.0322806761,
-0.0135629494,
-0.0125797326,
-0.0113474652,
0.0070208008,
-0.0011293737,
-0.0043806573,
0.0161442328,
0.0497079082,
0.0549438633,
0.0026510193,
0.0009707388,
0.0703135133,
0.0115479399,
-0.0500470474,
0.0464681834,
-0.0262182802,
-0.0186093822,
-0.0073443674,
0.0115004899,
-0.0726308823,
-0.0342820846,
-0.0177720059,
0.0231002364,
-0.0326233022,
0.0665287748,
0.0017912707,
-0.0242321473,
-0.0185012538,
0.0529572442,
0.0615602136,
0.0574477762,
-0.017873168,
-0.0085986266,
-0.0246247314,
-0.0171036869,
-0.045418717,
-0.0249642693,
0.0015286473,
-0.009332017,
-0.0759871081,
-0.0600542016,
0.016295258,
0.0043256395,
0.0282153543,
0.0410254933,
0.0413246751,
0.0036617438,
-0.0671269819,
0.0317728929,
0.0431964472,
-0.0018585852,
-0.0271333698,
-0.0099869808,
0.0038355249,
0.0369593911,
-0.0541532636,
0.104312554,
-0.0510905348,
-0.0666551143,
0.0323692113,
0.1004345417,
0.0324517302,
-0.0050293664,
-0.0161665399,
-0.0057289847,
0.0589797162,
0.0174325462,
0.0182843078,
-0.0827635452,
0.0225214344,
-0.0302604921,
-0.0406317748,
0.0363384113,
-0.0398490094,
-0.050893262,
0.0347148031,
-0.0009325962,
-0.0258546472,
-0.027735671,
0.0041170977,
-0.005062602,
0.0468053706,
0.0141560258,
0.0358247086,
0.034054812,
-0.002713223,
0.0276714806,
0.0062407795,
0.0380210206,
-0.0658861026,
-0.0015224352,
-0.0224216115,
-0.0264123585,
0.0356126279,
-0.0084439088,
0.0118128201,
-0.0395704135,
-0.0108435107,
0.0246166792,
0.0171364527,
0.0006231654,
0.0126475468,
-0.0316160098,
-0.0094206939,
0.0391808338,
-0.047988683,
0.0006345449,
0.0191557929,
0.0553543419,
0.0095512671,
-0.0120941596,
0.0186018627,
0.02030899,
0.0150804101,
0.0029564318,
-0.0707060024,
-0.0117065469,
0.0438584313,
0.029615365,
0.0265782736,
-0.0322059467,
-0.0162301008,
0.0046213288,
-0.0549743883,
-0.0121329604,
-0.0427700505,
0.0058947201,
0.0012135027,
-0.0209908318,
-0.0009686064,
0.0003262628,
-0.0232260358,
-0.072384268,
-0.0410102196,
-0.0165356118,
0.0444231704,
-0.0547778159,
0.0435862504,
-0.0234996062,
-0.0069949641,
-0.0099252639,
0.0542654134,
-0.0375063196,
0.007063881,
-0.0223885532,
0.0745891333,
-0.0251201205,
-0.0159148574,
-0.0118492236,
0.0451001823,
-0.0187708661,
-0.0363426432,
0.0295716766,
-0.0280372594,
0.0034124518,
-0.0139663676,
0.0524881259,
-0.0201308932,
-0.0153246438,
-0.0399444923,
0.0405838154,
-0.0365744866,
-0.0240975823,
-0.0043525132,
-0.0088719055,
-0.0428730063,
-0.0303271282,
-0.0149963461,
-0.0654770881,
-0.0252650119,
0.0398344621,
-0.0413164049,
-0.0556941479,
0.002545316,
0.0054911538,
0.0585145988,
-0.0656895936,
0.011828633,
-0.0698200986,
-0.0381020755,
-0.0121603413,
-0.0263623148,
0.0016787114,
-0.0485960916,
-0.0009453262,
0.0136158401,
-0.0080619706,
-0.0130173378,
-0.0502252467,
-0.0042021009,
-0.0203701071,
-0.014751005,
-0.0580378994,
-5.523726198e-33,
0.0424902141,
-0.00868118,
-0.0011462551,
0.0034452858,
-0.0035088698,
-0.0418955833,
-0.0314934663,
0.0624664202,
0.0329593495,
0.0327565186,
-0.0216843206,
-0.0200274829,
-0.0167244691,
-0.0098418705,
0.0009578492,
0.0414411947,
0.0428402051,
0.013458468,
-0.0552063212,
0.0348074511,
0.0212241933,
0.0219120495,
0.0158556979,
-0.0915447325,
0.0776173994,
0.0086665964,
-0.0127930138,
-0.0532680973,
-0.005603292,
0.0251677241,
-0.0315310434,
0.0381263159,
0.0179569032,
0.0023923973,
0.0010819238,
0.1040850729,
0.011319465,
-0.040665105,
0.0639015213,
-0.0355574302,
0.0023611111,
-0.062787801,
0.0184553973,
-0.0197335389,
-0.0409270748,
0.0322920904,
0.0450919308,
-0.0454485901,
-0.0246451255,
0.0177959446,
-0.0527845249,
-0.0271918084,
-0.0232323799,
-0.0239599999,
-0.0484517328,
0.0594339669,
-0.0975058079,
0.022979252,
-0.0559300743,
0.0610441081,
-0.000204784,
-0.0003882881,
0.0260125026,
-0.0278088413,
0.0343981646,
0.0546216667,
-0.0174264275,
-0.0201834496,
-0.0372806117,
0.010153017,
-0.001668471,
0.0145897428,
0.0179771185,
-0.0002803426,
0.0586151481,
-0.0755296722,
-0.046051994,
-0.0054428834,
0.0387039185,
-0.023459401,
0.0549318194,
0.0187479462,
-0.0330953561,
-0.0427898504,
-0.0059636049,
0.0035527323,
-0.020023331,
-0.0711082071,
0.0254986398,
-0.027184017,
-0.0188215096,
0.0051838323,
-0.0305043217,
-0.028047435,
-0.0481904931,
0.0087407967,
0.0483844951,
-0.0010688609,
-0.009710893,
-0.0423055701,
-0.0510001555,
0.0236853622,
-0.0408933461,
0.0845478326,
0.0590435192,
0.0180914793,
0.0229960848,
-0.0062930109,
-0.0385233797,
-0.0228209775,
-0.002424713,
0.0416574478,
0.0083336784,
0.0042082015,
0.0141683109,
0.0529135913,
-0.0085812081,
0.0645024478,
-0.0315435678,
-0.0592608154,
-0.0566974133,
-0.0026884882,
-0.0018728619,
0.0224592201,
-0.0183019191,
-0.0277059153,
-0.0682366341,
0.0254103355,
0.0770028606,
-0.033300072,
-0.0152631849,
-0.0147342309,
2.778e-7,
-0.0469533056,
0.02262857,
-0.0532334298,
0.0080079278,
0.0121870385,
0.0488635227,
-0.0168696661,
-0.0110943234,
0.011539367,
-0.0116753988,
-0.0022871683,
0.0199365448,
0.0311013591,
0.0030251048,
-0.0024476943,
0.0088181198,
-0.0081593217,
0.0201905686,
-0.0581920408,
0.0795925334,
0.0657908469,
0.0303710308,
0.0385200791,
-0.0238625277,
0.002549361,
0.0301203281,
0.030338224,
-0.0611666404,
0.0222068019,
0.0058138082,
0.0071561313,
-0.0305301547,
0.0105608907,
-0.0210271757,
0.0063793277,
-0.0330152549,
-0.0589114502,
0.0522860214,
-0.005180283,
0.0044964501,
-0.0171443559,
0.019890679,
-0.0010533353,
-0.0113558797,
0.0218420438,
-0.0885239169,
-0.0584994592,
-0.023388477,
-0.0017778337,
-0.0250690002,
0.0263524782,
-0.017687602,
-0.0523331985,
-0.0178097691,
0.0216335393,
0.0249595214,
0.0055827689,
-0.0405150093,
0.0069851507,
0.0362967178,
0.0129552847,
-0.0262504742,
-0.0567878038,
0.0430452228,
-0.0411159731,
-0.0513473041,
0.0488328896,
1.949798679e-34,
0.0163151398,
0.0233667735,
0.0320436954,
0.0115292287,
0.0205078684,
0.033011876,
0.0371056721,
0.00479862,
0.0544370711,
-0.0949592888,
-0.0029638095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16621v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16621v1 | Stress Testing Chain-of-Thought Prompting for Large Language Models | 2023-09-28T17:21:33 | 2023-09-28T17:21:33 | Aayush Mishra, Karan Thakkar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This report examines the effectiveness of Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting in
improving the multi-step reasoning abilities of large language models (LLMs).
Inspired by previous studies \cite{Min2022RethinkingWork}, we analyze the
impact of three types of CoT prompt perturbations, namely CoT order, CoT
values, and CoT operators on the performance of GPT-3 on various tasks. Our
findings show that incorrect CoT prompting leads to poor performance on
accuracy metrics. Correct values in the CoT is crucial for predicting correct
answers. Moreover, incorrect demonstrations, where the CoT operators or the CoT
order are wrong, do not affect the performance as drastically when compared to
the value based perturbations. This research deepens our understanding of CoT
prompting and opens some new questions regarding the capability of LLMs to
learn reasoning in context. | [
0.0035553332,
0.0162609573,
-0.0175864119,
0.0306691863,
-0.0650554672,
0.0183927193,
0.0405075289,
0.0032169293,
-0.001657817,
-0.038634222,
-0.0158834681,
-0.037147712,
0.0053379568,
-0.0274669863,
0.0356028229,
-0.048441276,
0.0588667877,
-0.101564832,
0.0063416664,
-0.0271205436,
-0.0384366326,
-0.0025113968,
-0.0431270078,
0.0215283595,
-0.0028236734,
-0.0438022241,
-0.0443991758,
-0.0055147558,
0.0231225546,
-0.0572918952,
-0.028734304,
0.083070457,
0.039982371,
0.0610107444,
0.0000022026,
-0.062670745,
0.0090247178,
-0.0019646173,
-0.0419407934,
0.0290451981,
-0.0265120994,
0.0286711883,
-0.0061600809,
0.0407994948,
-0.0234896913,
0.0038003011,
0.0047497055,
0.0336875692,
0.0393550396,
0.0470358692,
0.0090108048,
0.0116402367,
-0.0000113806,
-0.0151129775,
0.0496882312,
-0.0537332334,
0.0193503108,
0.0281789675,
0.0510186255,
0.0139415078,
-0.0176308826,
0.0033745482,
0.0665891692,
0.0212341361,
-0.0748987347,
0.0536562987,
-0.0196866598,
-0.0139346868,
-0.0226352457,
0.0331841223,
0.0144015765,
-0.0115083465,
-0.0450891443,
0.0028188454,
0.0180799793,
0.0105818175,
-0.0465916246,
0.0366042443,
-0.0148136877,
0.0074698646,
0.0165292919,
-0.0002545461,
0.0166985728,
0.0030438858,
-0.0351578966,
0.089023307,
-0.0026447175,
-0.0670196787,
0.0488411374,
0.0305480361,
-0.0272281822,
-0.0591873862,
-0.0227474142,
0.0323636569,
-0.048403725,
0.0243643839,
0.012367174,
-0.0104521224,
0.0050921696,
-0.0030065556,
0.0140720606,
0.0634072721,
-0.028783273,
0.03876324,
-0.0324952193,
0.069302395,
-0.0105345352,
0.0296827815,
-0.0267898962,
0.0292344149,
-0.0470120236,
-0.0256632324,
-0.0281140301,
0.0447062328,
-0.0111554554,
-0.0091528744,
-0.0198133737,
0.0063171154,
0.005681437,
-0.0005604829,
0.0119701773,
-0.01627535,
0.0175261423,
-0.0064633191,
-0.0579416975,
0.0350172929,
-0.0532519743,
0.0335613266,
0.0402786694,
-0.0543334037,
-0.0322144553,
-0.0207428653,
-0.030394746,
-0.0233492125,
0.0292418804,
0.0492998064,
-0.0395184867,
-0.0373844095,
-0.0347723849,
-0.0154151348,
-0.0026418932,
-0.0994851887,
0.0455410779,
-0.0592433102,
0.0236227475,
0.0180567335,
-0.0084147351,
0.0285324324,
0.0196093526,
0.0361981615,
-0.0102573996,
0.0570881441,
0.02584555,
0.0181893259,
-0.0109458426,
0.0311243664,
-0.0543269292,
0.0587059371,
0.0174221713,
0.0087769749,
-0.0148055656,
-0.0201815311,
-0.0092401141,
0.0407764502,
0.0067304638,
0.0195312947,
0.0203695875,
0.0108082024,
0.020731898,
0.0494964682,
0.0060861977,
0.0636688098,
-0.0477862135,
0.052135624,
0.0611384697,
0.0584164336,
-0.0166470986,
0.0132697262,
0.0625347719,
-0.0224978309,
0.0331183076,
0.0321222693,
-0.0954297781,
0.0169150606,
-0.0526390933,
0.0278034303,
0.006382308,
0.0287992451,
-0.0278967246,
-0.0210667942,
-0.0063443771,
0.0399348512,
0.0139269847,
0.0441929512,
0.0321549885,
-0.0200940464,
-0.0438010916,
0.0158482064,
-0.0091302209,
-0.0348963179,
-0.0158267356,
-0.0785732418,
0.0200237241,
0.0434173979,
0.0165781546,
-0.0023908836,
-0.0357291587,
-0.0063299942,
0.0379267298,
0.0220445003,
0.0307541229,
0.0135507658,
-0.0320104696,
-0.0300727338,
-0.0208206344,
-0.0154068116,
-0.0015862311,
0.0170776825,
0.026905084,
0.0164814238,
-0.0002914044,
-0.0128318686,
0.0356822722,
0.0083572948,
-0.0257475749,
-0.0492683798,
-0.0280784797,
-0.0008849956,
0.0027999219,
0.0068899617,
0.0062959413,
0.0098656537,
0.0215982366,
-0.001584921,
-0.0077917078,
-0.0071285362,
-0.0846864358,
-0.0418590792,
0.0228639524,
0.0142815644,
-0.0409714654,
-0.0124021061,
-0.0334407203,
-0.0528018139,
0.0032247605,
-0.0132510234,
0.0388108529,
-0.0214893334,
0.0263255648,
0.0073990431,
-0.0221844912,
-0.0227209516,
0.0954777896,
-0.0180204324,
0.0267208349,
0.0379870422,
0.0522667691,
0.0108929398,
-0.029430829,
-0.0135256797,
0.0197432507,
0.0074328533,
-0.0030745666,
-0.0095934849,
0.0444517769,
-0.0689350516,
-0.0184664354,
-0.0910156369,
-0.0062505328,
-0.0181230027,
0.0285510216,
-0.002412773,
-0.0265356302,
-0.0317454077,
0.0124807581,
-0.0435423069,
-0.0066396701,
0.0090364479,
0.0348268785,
-0.0151869468,
-0.0027720395,
-0.0292952321,
0.0206896104,
-0.0129728513,
-0.0457186438,
0.041738417,
0.0016049637,
-0.0064939843,
-0.0357966572,
0.0438175984,
-0.0376815051,
0.0296957362,
-0.0154342465,
0.0068226424,
0.0719429031,
-0.0096595129,
0.0836447626,
0.0654510483,
-0.0155214537,
0.0168300383,
0.0695591047,
-0.0127915936,
-0.0298377704,
0.0349467918,
0.01005123,
-0.0589197539,
-0.0123771215,
-0.0135569545,
-0.0504739545,
0.0474028438,
0.0157492608,
0.0085446732,
-0.0730124563,
0.0002654147,
-0.0149431983,
-0.0177069269,
-0.0298111849,
-0.0304515362,
-0.0396685116,
0.0583092049,
-0.0021296586,
-0.0199413374,
0.0787487701,
-0.0233681463,
-0.0059958701,
-0.0496603586,
0.0350939445,
-0.0023070078,
0.0781892091,
-0.0158179551,
-0.0084470231,
0.0134905837,
-0.0095198061,
-0.0768263862,
-0.0226062704,
-0.002133948,
-0.0348364189,
0.0403604582,
-0.0649828538,
-0.0004356476,
-0.012886825,
-0.0692029148,
-0.0494313128,
0.0194773637,
-0.044576142,
0.0266399421,
-0.0279192775,
-0.0107753538,
0.0114895655,
-0.0416076705,
0.0795922354,
0.0225451011,
-0.0292857103,
-0.0242724046,
-0.0234198868,
0.0031682651,
0.0213480815,
0.0171447862,
0.0584351867,
-0.0486970134,
0.0444653109,
0.0430933163,
0.0698817521,
0.0059377956,
-0.0239674058,
0.0224616621,
0.0061706477,
0.0007475056,
-0.0251796842,
0.0435151234,
0.0233329907,
-0.058973711,
-0.0158243962,
0.1036922559,
0.0268728994,
-0.0570826717,
0.0128360726,
-0.0551977046,
0.0564848892,
0.0251083095,
0.017875718,
-0.0891213343,
-0.019070942,
0.0273501016,
-0.0066546644,
-0.031593293,
-0.0259575788,
0.0039368435,
-0.1387638301,
0.0124839405,
-0.0120746698,
-0.0261814147,
0.0037985777,
-0.0232731961,
0.0103917215,
0.0484042652,
0.0387376212,
0.0436050035,
-0.0052082106,
0.0023169022,
0.0343921185,
0.012464663,
-0.0491204932,
0.0823067278,
-0.0031602555,
0.0147049138,
0.0306338742,
-0.0312670544,
-0.0189339444,
-0.0789941251,
0.0670478493,
-0.021352319,
0.0188044347,
-0.0136057064,
-0.0104766488,
0.0153665077,
0.0115199648,
-0.0409775861,
0.0411195122,
-0.0020755392,
-0.0253140479,
0.024953017,
0.11553175,
-0.0262412168,
-0.0344393365,
-0.0023929223,
0.0072470792,
-0.010070256,
0.0614927076,
0.02721975,
-0.0459785946,
-0.0159450509,
-0.0275357012,
-0.0532986037,
0.0071946341,
-0.0482539199,
0.0204215143,
0.0479639508,
0.0465686619,
-0.0117309168,
-0.0407838039,
0.0519767366,
0.0745726377,
-0.0023834193,
0.0353381485,
-0.0366264246,
0.0351140164,
0.0253140833,
0.0322859325,
-0.012490795,
0.0245194118,
-0.0368150808,
0.0372848362,
0.0118124699,
-0.0315624103,
-0.0203364938,
0.0185803398,
-0.0777219832,
-0.0420199148,
-0.0062937727,
0.0347292013,
0.0368322432,
0.0151032601,
0.0134057831,
-0.0249421671,
0.0185870342,
-0.0094050616,
-0.0054405895,
0.033020433,
0.0196673945,
0.028249016,
0.0125722792,
0.0191750769,
-0.0218274314,
-0.0049229227,
-0.0020987417,
0.0531006046,
-0.0089765517,
-0.0101620043,
0.0349009745,
0.0309834834,
0.0527972542,
-0.0143548436,
-0.0005506104,
-0.0186871551,
0.052262608,
-0.0337989628,
-0.008014122,
-0.0105070267,
-0.0057561384,
0.0134085258,
-0.0006827296,
-0.0023599558,
-0.0845878869,
0.0250718649,
-0.0032817731,
0.0056276983,
0.0009723462,
0.0037115808,
0.0347041339,
0.0496081971,
-0.0134701412,
-0.0319732763,
0.0013505387,
-0.0010631582,
0.0379476063,
-0.0056309686,
0.1322970092,
0.0507938191,
-0.0258282181,
-0.0023096099,
0.0152086038,
-0.0762408152,
-0.0724970996,
0.0204848032,
0.0115033984,
0.0179830417,
0.0086875288,
0.0093381293,
-0.0746422634,
0.0055091716,
0.0081509491,
-0.0032536406,
0.0134381726,
-0.0351056121,
0.0371349119,
0.0292142741,
0.0215937514,
0.0028949475,
0.0370013416,
0.0037659814,
0.0266839024,
0.0127653861,
0.0258295313,
-0.013247801,
-0.0371874832,
-0.0457273684,
-0.0178008433,
-0.0138136027,
0.001643038,
-0.0901678279,
-0.0826949105,
-0.0489422195,
0.0329210982,
0.0059468327,
-0.0354608484,
0.0542672165,
0.0784074515,
-0.0180905219,
-0.0472393408,
0.0161615536,
-0.0048663784,
0.0074174865,
-0.0295251906,
-0.0252468754,
-6.62591415e-33,
-0.0251808744,
-0.0281546488,
0.0732088834,
0.0144845368,
-0.0287617818,
-0.0211855769,
-0.0444735475,
0.0382327437,
-0.0196153838,
-0.0005891401,
-0.0384830013,
-0.0094307587,
0.0108096665,
-0.0018424802,
0.0137687605,
-0.0244325306,
-0.0072012991,
-0.0019480364,
-0.0294594429,
0.0038220822,
0.0096648633,
-0.0207911581,
0.0501766913,
-0.0472598039,
0.0299966559,
-0.0127331764,
-0.0167792346,
0.0221901089,
-0.1067142412,
0.034757182,
-0.008970229,
0.0271483902,
0.0202933364,
-0.0484206304,
0.0057896548,
0.0248848591,
-0.0384768918,
-0.0513280295,
0.0538567267,
-0.018092148,
-0.0641791299,
-0.0140870279,
-0.0118075851,
-0.0000181402,
-0.0298625883,
-0.023458926,
-0.0190371312,
-0.0058552809,
-0.0273845177,
0.0153981289,
-0.0450043529,
-0.0119049847,
-0.0028043608,
-0.0203659851,
0.0129517289,
0.0682826713,
-0.0333472528,
-0.0260447077,
-0.0160193518,
0.0004793782,
0.0485759079,
-0.0051291552,
0.0681181401,
0.0208343752,
0.0001370554,
0.0360345915,
0.0025111025,
-0.0009938997,
-0.0455254652,
-0.0367684923,
0.0292233769,
0.0283060223,
0.0755841509,
0.0113321599,
0.0085241208,
0.0310729872,
-0.0826433003,
-0.0157809053,
0.0338271223,
0.0306513272,
0.0373170488,
-0.0250807479,
-0.0401048288,
-0.0316857956,
-0.0566028543,
0.012900806,
-0.0335394368,
-0.0444121249,
0.0520337485,
-0.0128937392,
0.0126613658,
-0.0252948143,
0.0373420976,
0.0103951106,
-0.0063997461,
0.0147185074,
-0.0296580326,
0.0520221554,
-0.024857996,
0.0460294373,
-0.0552405529,
-0.0166340228,
-0.0012013252,
0.0287631582,
0.0274452213,
0.0047233696,
0.031012632,
0.0167288687,
-0.050424654,
-0.0108460067,
-0.0542994179,
0.0400579013,
0.0220068656,
-0.0297664236,
0.0590026118,
-0.0003275068,
0.0023981731,
0.0138199907,
0.001495912,
-0.0480063669,
-0.0365580246,
0.0470425524,
-0.0387388393,
0.0128012467,
-0.0159605555,
0.0064842096,
-0.0202195663,
0.0198733173,
0.0240573715,
-0.048908446,
-0.0172918774,
0.0467097536,
2.94e-7,
0.0089565702,
0.0402277447,
-0.0119107086,
0.0416075215,
0.0089408243,
0.0270555709,
-0.0324064381,
-0.0089543294,
0.0513949767,
-0.0532235764,
0.0003143518,
0.056870807,
0.0417739898,
0.0371381715,
-0.0628364384,
-0.0307787433,
-0.0368263014,
-0.0062463107,
-0.0573124364,
0.0253754947,
0.0568987392,
0.0435368083,
-0.0011931726,
-0.0104037579,
0.0047446759,
-0.001352185,
0.0458966941,
-0.020109674,
0.0173809975,
-0.0363556519,
-0.0042229947,
-0.0193091463,
0.0190558825,
0.0788110867,
0.0295237675,
0.0052776616,
-0.0176499262,
0.029576974,
0.0266782064,
-0.0252689049,
-0.0096868342,
-0.0262929462,
0.0081573222,
-0.0984989256,
0.0929522589,
-0.0405455716,
-0.0019155579,
0.0352431759,
0.0199026819,
-0.0522415824,
0.0153477388,
-0.0029655944,
-0.0019580328,
0.0108812731,
-0.0105244759,
0.0071850941,
0.0093148882,
-0.0558146425,
-0.0068954122,
0.0422576927,
-0.0375879817,
-0.0580011904,
-0.0401734188,
0.0102754841,
0.0084414426,
-0.0464722179,
-0.0335348658,
2.827193402e-34,
0.0147725251,
-0.0535713844,
0.0789267048,
0.0223695971,
0.0294405334,
0.0051429118,
-0.0071818195,
0.0079374127,
0.0274616051,
-0.0935264602,
-0.0343337208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16609v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16609v1 | Qwen Technical Report | 2023-09-28T17:07:49 | 2023-09-28T17:07:49 | Jinze Bai, Shuai Bai, Yunfei Chu, Zeyu Cui, Kai Dang, Xiaodong Deng, Yang Fan, Wenbin Ge, Yu Han, Fei Huang, Binyuan Hui, Luo Ji, Mei Li, Junyang Lin, Runji Lin, Dayiheng Liu, Gao Liu, Chengqiang Lu, Keming Lu, Jianxin Ma, Rui Men, Xingzhang Ren, Xuancheng Ren, Chuanqi Tan, Sinan Tan, Jianhong Tu, Peng Wang, Shijie Wang, Wei Wang, Shengguang Wu, Benfeng Xu, Jin Xu, An Yang, Hao Yang, Jian Yang, Shusheng Yang, Yang Yao, Bowen Yu, Hongyi Yuan, Zheng Yuan, Jianwei Zhang, Xingxuan Zhang, Yichang Zhang, Zhenru Zhang, Chang Zhou, Jingren Zhou, Xiaohuan Zhou, Tianhang Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized the field of artificial
intelligence, enabling natural language processing tasks that were previously
thought to be exclusive to humans. In this work, we introduce Qwen, the first
installment of our large language model series. Qwen is a comprehensive
language model series that encompasses distinct models with varying parameter
counts. It includes Qwen, the base pretrained language models, and Qwen-Chat,
the chat models finetuned with human alignment techniques. The base language
models consistently demonstrate superior performance across a multitude of
downstream tasks, and the chat models, particularly those trained using
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF), are highly competitive. The
chat models possess advanced tool-use and planning capabilities for creating
agent applications, showcasing impressive performance even when compared to
bigger models on complex tasks like utilizing a code interpreter. Furthermore,
we have developed coding-specialized models, Code-Qwen and Code-Qwen-Chat, as
well as mathematics-focused models, Math-Qwen-Chat, which are built upon base
language models. These models demonstrate significantly improved performance in
comparison with open-source models, and slightly fall behind the proprietary
models. | [
0.047468137,
0.0513287336,
-0.0139266215,
0.0223257467,
-0.0444756858,
0.0231560376,
-0.0153751113,
-0.004711403,
0.0315440632,
-0.0328619108,
-0.0602386072,
-0.0120896883,
0.0009283407,
0.059126664,
0.0234838966,
-0.030828096,
0.0506535955,
-0.0276135374,
0.0100489277,
0.0063431854,
0.0036822835,
0.0071271104,
-0.0093024978,
0.0615375601,
-0.0097167417,
-0.0286460686,
-0.0308104176,
-0.0215060636,
-0.0142399771,
0.0112179527,
0.0157919191,
0.0603417531,
0.0136788702,
0.0566462949,
0.0000019947,
-0.0463497229,
0.0234765913,
-0.0232284106,
-0.0524905398,
0.0081131179,
0.0474313311,
-0.0256990232,
-0.0173845328,
0.0308673568,
-0.0602037571,
-0.0185573623,
0.0812609643,
0.0027961549,
0.0873864293,
0.1042473987,
0.0051020361,
-0.0110843861,
0.0438307412,
-0.0188958142,
0.021132458,
-0.0807467401,
0.0305565391,
0.0365254842,
0.0365083888,
0.0136134792,
-0.0187314209,
0.0103539042,
0.0453047752,
-0.0188531075,
-0.0060039004,
0.0319960564,
-0.030716354,
-0.03226256,
-0.0511397645,
0.067386888,
-0.0438343547,
-0.0168833621,
0.0163108855,
-0.0034701838,
0.0101909712,
-0.0376135595,
-0.031255167,
0.0264410842,
0.0234430954,
0.0021949767,
0.0085788639,
-0.0209414959,
0.0222508516,
0.0312786847,
-0.0334259607,
0.033592917,
-0.0048975609,
-0.0206870884,
-0.0098224469,
0.0130602103,
-0.0233252011,
-0.0719437525,
0.0065416801,
0.0379260071,
-0.0379696675,
0.0235640965,
-0.046269428,
-0.0115460623,
0.0037434567,
-0.0745237172,
-0.0000846056,
0.0720193982,
0.024055751,
0.0359162092,
0.0013389441,
0.0606095269,
-0.0002614337,
0.0225028656,
-0.0132790143,
0.0075250082,
-0.0523242988,
-0.0255964473,
-0.0440813266,
0.0446530059,
-0.0192197748,
-0.053995207,
-0.0470359623,
0.0596539341,
0.0016862786,
0.0427856632,
0.0260049254,
0.0004225701,
-0.0588560328,
-0.0110495733,
-0.016132012,
0.0026947765,
-0.0301002599,
0.0043391939,
0.0147197405,
-0.0728745535,
-0.004083035,
0.0139339427,
-0.005511811,
-0.0307405945,
-0.0036251578,
0.1042410359,
0.0085842079,
-0.0117882667,
0.0160766449,
-0.0041221292,
-0.005588809,
-0.0537043959,
-0.0277952049,
-0.0729537085,
0.0281353127,
-0.0074720769,
-0.026778562,
-0.0500964373,
0.0208377931,
0.0169420503,
-0.0074477601,
0.0781789422,
0.0041951076,
0.0046064234,
0.0341585167,
-0.0274487678,
-0.0298991241,
0.0641544759,
0.052298557,
0.0099500716,
0.0158129018,
-0.0034106099,
0.0274161566,
0.0679937601,
-0.0239285361,
-0.0158503205,
-0.0002443703,
-0.0017451893,
0.0102200061,
0.0526476093,
0.0202316828,
0.0411836803,
-0.0313202254,
-0.0064607495,
0.035607595,
0.0651866496,
0.0149361994,
0.0128558455,
0.039896287,
0.0555501394,
0.0119190244,
-0.0452840887,
-0.0473215878,
0.036135938,
-0.013374785,
0.0233315229,
-0.0093014194,
-0.0037544931,
-0.0184978507,
-0.070305869,
-0.0062146629,
-0.0202609114,
0.0439534746,
-0.0075136875,
0.068577148,
-0.0021221398,
-0.0424722433,
-0.002817068,
0.0411507897,
-0.0273000821,
-0.0204133969,
-0.0697685853,
0.0135457553,
0.0810131803,
0.050463967,
-0.0292189401,
-0.0288205203,
-0.0157202072,
-0.0386325829,
0.0631652474,
0.053880956,
-0.0007447173,
-0.022635838,
-0.0427677147,
-0.0158355627,
-0.0111625865,
0.0028318525,
0.0138403168,
0.0508390404,
-0.0206154343,
-0.0071891844,
0.0352120847,
-0.0482482761,
0.0485046357,
-0.0390725136,
-0.0164307356,
-0.0156547111,
0.0004003508,
0.0342595987,
-0.009304733,
-0.0200898517,
0.0304881614,
0.0049171126,
-0.001352675,
-0.0214506723,
-0.0076506399,
-0.0555966683,
-0.0752275959,
0.0600175895,
0.0125006409,
-0.007733806,
0.0479884408,
-0.0251580104,
-0.0084469933,
0.044370044,
-0.0494556949,
0.0353667103,
-0.0167291705,
0.032197915,
-0.0130634606,
-0.0234208945,
-0.0124922106,
0.0524249412,
-0.0039160196,
-0.003491174,
0.0011252327,
0.0299230982,
-0.0165394917,
-0.0290716197,
-0.0047670472,
0.008451866,
-0.0130971884,
0.0440770537,
0.0266654715,
0.0489702113,
-0.0177129619,
-0.0321816318,
-0.0901859477,
0.0088328458,
-0.0303014703,
-0.002103922,
0.0093767457,
0.0124700628,
-0.0160719827,
-0.027183339,
-0.0245663077,
0.0014833368,
-0.0013317657,
0.0017997561,
0.0397442058,
-0.0160423722,
-0.0404565595,
-0.0843604952,
-0.0328773186,
-0.0325036198,
0.0253470466,
-0.0010315228,
-0.0167163182,
-0.0444340631,
0.0259858929,
-0.0217588246,
0.0280116443,
0.0079435091,
-0.0651514605,
0.0146669317,
-0.0277964473,
0.0361811668,
0.0847861916,
0.0086176461,
0.0488034971,
0.002335615,
-0.0002528513,
-0.0790660232,
0.0305140838,
-0.0375508107,
-0.0635146275,
-0.0354435854,
-0.0161576308,
0.0122165438,
0.1119599566,
-0.0059363102,
0.0138140814,
-0.0732345283,
0.0364676565,
0.0106873391,
-0.0440972112,
-0.0169772822,
-0.0142486403,
-0.0519080199,
0.029789649,
-0.0596300103,
-0.0623761602,
0.0815809369,
0.0041764244,
-0.0216046274,
-0.0693998113,
-0.0091832373,
-0.0355416089,
0.047648821,
0.0227283668,
0.0174513496,
-0.0364648886,
-0.0441565104,
-0.0334696062,
0.0041019223,
-0.0120848762,
-0.034508314,
0.0113214208,
-0.0292420667,
0.0156144891,
0.0069650086,
-0.0343187004,
-0.0578501262,
0.0004116482,
-0.0401450247,
0.0220506638,
0.009432083,
-0.0268636495,
-0.0109526152,
0.0200714488,
0.0099746799,
0.0478295907,
0.0049385694,
-0.0063403477,
-0.0452406481,
-0.0283058751,
0.0386428908,
-0.0107655898,
-0.0030024892,
-0.0402804166,
0.0506764576,
0.0121806115,
0.020933833,
0.0144736618,
-0.0135766827,
0.010515837,
0.0208392236,
-0.0467058308,
-0.0127649615,
0.0527366325,
0.0204126947,
-0.0700237975,
-0.0216005407,
0.1218076125,
0.0476050228,
-0.0356911756,
0.0098047806,
-0.0226271972,
0.018322669,
0.0264052395,
0.0440077223,
-0.0773632154,
-0.0417379253,
0.0039337911,
-0.0269920733,
0.0223558526,
-0.0029013993,
0.0003672496,
-0.1254511923,
0.0317248814,
0.0225567389,
-0.0256549362,
-0.0346694365,
-0.0188574288,
0.0023655605,
-0.0228971262,
0.003283218,
0.0341582261,
0.0099945972,
-0.020801682,
0.0003257818,
-0.0130575588,
-0.0038499448,
0.037111517,
-0.0536111109,
0.0597808883,
0.1089162901,
0.019650301,
-0.0158023015,
-0.0046890872,
0.0127719082,
0.0451533012,
0.0008044342,
0.0107336035,
0.0133468853,
-0.035454601,
-0.0134588229,
-0.0055784173,
0.051792264,
-0.0598134473,
-0.0084324144,
-0.0004967775,
0.0666910559,
-0.0239079148,
-0.0094372947,
-0.0042221681,
0.0255462006,
-0.0066741444,
0.0522145703,
0.0129418755,
-0.0713470802,
-0.0807930678,
-0.0414758846,
-0.0341912657,
-0.0357906073,
-0.044870507,
-0.0207513664,
0.0069533377,
-0.0428982601,
-0.0724511445,
-0.0603932962,
0.0203010589,
-0.0047049355,
0.0070906854,
-0.0407976173,
0.0572270043,
0.0026890903,
-0.0111428685,
0.0263536181,
-0.0224751104,
0.0394098572,
-0.0614420474,
0.0034581351,
0.0104986774,
-0.0450309105,
-0.0221411884,
-0.0066789822,
-0.1029652134,
-0.0691571906,
-0.0046537672,
0.0526056401,
0.0197778754,
0.0403950512,
-0.0464060605,
-0.0037389502,
-0.0241139736,
0.0105895875,
-0.0722664818,
0.0163534712,
0.0382043533,
0.0348997898,
0.0069037061,
0.037642803,
-0.0331880599,
0.0191163346,
-0.0084834229,
0.0382341966,
-0.0422866344,
-0.0406798534,
0.0268603116,
-0.0246430859,
-0.0060884194,
0.0240924265,
-0.0213562623,
-0.0155292843,
0.0010400403,
-0.0199478399,
-0.0267478451,
-0.0403053388,
-0.0225057863,
0.0243137646,
0.0189731494,
0.0163040161,
-0.0058380929,
0.0010702502,
0.0216312613,
0.0187183451,
0.0329084694,
0.0119390283,
0.0233123433,
0.0220901296,
0.008619654,
-0.0142323896,
0.0297871195,
-0.0242931489,
0.0351141319,
-0.0136873974,
0.0657724589,
0.0007423228,
-0.0117755672,
-0.0136064682,
-0.0024923091,
-0.0522079617,
-0.0815087929,
-0.0022694364,
0.0549860187,
0.058783859,
0.0364930779,
0.0297496524,
-0.0483733565,
-0.0003252919,
-0.0130523397,
0.0353793092,
-0.0206801724,
-0.0135033503,
0.0099983299,
0.0276301391,
-0.0249589495,
-0.0315216705,
0.0609716661,
0.0042690225,
0.0441281386,
-0.0115953544,
-0.0048942948,
-0.0301719531,
-0.0067415717,
0.0495332181,
0.0195089541,
-0.0132164937,
0.0149335777,
-0.0213522781,
-0.060343232,
-0.0149784982,
0.0274480078,
-0.0113072032,
-0.0030979773,
0.0717788711,
0.0646745414,
-0.0333278589,
-0.0178617854,
-0.040020816,
0.0107743181,
-0.0052651754,
-0.0386316217,
-0.0220817383,
-5.862599914e-33,
-0.0273895897,
-0.0078054038,
0.0322848335,
0.0114992922,
-0.025436461,
-0.0292294472,
-0.0388459638,
-0.004853826,
-0.0233939383,
-0.0030997798,
0.008358839,
0.0472669825,
0.0082893958,
0.009601579,
0.0457814671,
0.0040467554,
0.0349245444,
-0.0325961672,
-0.0143926069,
-0.0085159969,
-0.0103540774,
0.0269622803,
0.034066055,
-0.0271961503,
0.0210053194,
0.0091836443,
0.0061293477,
0.0269266162,
0.0042818799,
0.0734429657,
-0.0350074619,
0.004530312,
0.0055005965,
-0.0171068367,
-0.035691943,
0.0632051378,
-0.0409023464,
-0.0234381538,
0.0127784964,
0.0346854739,
-0.0341065675,
-0.0471225157,
0.0689006075,
-0.0290437136,
-0.0370087586,
0.0064049968,
0.0321097672,
-0.008450279,
0.0010176966,
0.0276679248,
-0.0876301602,
0.0291937608,
-0.0260899793,
-0.0397719294,
0.0093564186,
0.0221109204,
-0.0283830687,
0.0155266523,
-0.0399711318,
0.0189227741,
0.0082816882,
0.0380575471,
0.057509765,
0.0262533743,
0.0378364101,
0.0509550795,
0.0403652713,
-0.0053065619,
-0.0178584065,
0.0146892658,
0.0413396172,
0.0374454819,
0.0343545526,
0.0333952419,
0.0097624408,
0.0049370769,
-0.0460245609,
-0.0140033243,
0.0350345634,
0.0572742186,
0.0285108294,
0.0216855295,
-0.0840990245,
-0.0086193411,
-0.035206642,
0.0128851673,
-0.0352061056,
-0.0680579171,
0.0350512788,
0.0095503051,
0.0088317804,
-0.0378751084,
0.0292746946,
-0.0578132756,
0.019842511,
0.0105241891,
-0.029170325,
0.040613804,
-0.019207133,
0.0269212257,
-0.077402778,
-0.0123289973,
0.0105041135,
0.0007358318,
0.0180420149,
0.0221347772,
-0.0015194935,
0.0359404981,
-0.056993939,
-0.0027778156,
-0.0402190387,
-0.0038688714,
0.0329646654,
0.0498242117,
0.0360460468,
0.0091113709,
-0.0162231289,
0.0617944039,
-0.0059218463,
-0.0349527411,
-0.0398538932,
-0.04333435,
-0.0226804726,
0.011843279,
-0.031121837,
0.0017804571,
-0.0650414526,
0.052474618,
0.0069925385,
-0.0511459559,
-0.0140930451,
0.0154618546,
2.752e-7,
0.030565504,
0.0529067852,
0.0499248058,
0.0459145755,
0.004687889,
0.0379263051,
-0.0151566118,
0.035768833,
-0.0067092963,
0.0232962016,
0.0133657679,
0.0606880859,
0.0373363122,
-0.0101879407,
-0.0781787634,
-0.0138422018,
-0.0783811584,
-0.0120517686,
-0.063564226,
-0.0192219354,
0.052093517,
0.1316411346,
0.0222379696,
0.0072028269,
-0.0067918357,
-0.0406667925,
0.0578038171,
-0.0152788991,
-0.0262928624,
0.0535100363,
-0.0366983116,
0.0368701518,
0.0041633477,
-0.0037739747,
0.0146614704,
0.0450647064,
0.0056941281,
0.0925478563,
-0.0156184807,
0.0169268493,
-0.0014294059,
-0.0121961515,
-0.0005451232,
-0.0355304107,
0.0362824872,
-0.0588782914,
-0.0151515817,
-0.0350903459,
0.0232361834,
-0.0016734098,
0.0023379209,
-0.0296744034,
0.000329428,
0.0090725217,
0.0257838275,
-0.0056787352,
0.0067257807,
-0.0636938587,
-0.0381975472,
0.0090907412,
-0.0448761396,
-0.0362423137,
-0.0496019907,
0.0147743272,
0.0321007408,
-0.0343704447,
0.0061305445,
2.599100432e-34,
0.0254488681,
-0.0163521282,
0.0056111398,
0.0734845176,
0.0501779206,
0.0125406124,
0.0005374391,
0.0409292541,
0.058344394,
-0.0566932335,
-0.0307143554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16599v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16599v1 | Unlikelihood Tuning on Negative Samples Amazingly Improves Zero-Shot Translation | 2023-09-28T17:02:36 | 2023-09-28T17:02:36 | Changtong Zan, Liang Ding, Li Shen, Yibin Lei, Yibing Zhan, Weifeng Liu, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Zero-shot translation (ZST), which is generally based on a multilingual
neural machine translation model, aims to translate between unseen language
pairs in training data. The common practice to guide the zero-shot language
mapping during inference is to deliberately insert the source and target
language IDs, e.g., <EN> for English and <DE> for German. Recent studies have
shown that language IDs sometimes fail to navigate the ZST task, making them
suffer from the off-target problem (non-target language words exist in the
generated translation) and, therefore, difficult to apply the current
multilingual translation model to a broad range of zero-shot language
scenarios. To understand when and why the navigation capabilities of language
IDs are weakened, we compare two extreme decoder input cases in the ZST
directions: Off-Target (OFF) and On-Target (ON) cases. By contrastively
visualizing the contextual word representations (CWRs) of these cases with
teacher forcing, we show that 1) the CWRs of different languages are
effectively distributed in separate regions when the sentence and ID are
matched (ON setting), and 2) if the sentence and ID are unmatched (OFF
setting), the CWRs of different languages are chaotically distributed. Our
analyses suggest that although they work well in ideal ON settings, language
IDs become fragile and lose their navigation ability when faced with off-target
tokens, which commonly exist during inference but are rare in training
scenarios. In response, we employ unlikelihood tuning on the negative (OFF)
samples to minimize their probability such that the language IDs can
discriminate between the on- and off-target tokens during training. Experiments
spanning 40 ZST directions show that our method reduces the off-target ratio by
-48.0% on average, leading to a +9.1 BLEU improvement with only an extra +0.3%
tuning cost. | [
0.0084847044,
0.0124999173,
-0.017144125,
0.0490566976,
-0.0442944095,
0.0355106555,
0.0263999812,
0.0027312411,
-0.0889829323,
-0.0231382344,
-0.0498644635,
-0.0565091521,
0.00680744,
-0.029817054,
0.038646739,
-0.0254425518,
0.0485029332,
-0.016950909,
-0.0280311387,
0.0105250012,
-0.0168561526,
0.0151335821,
-0.0097105596,
0.0322749838,
-0.0181290805,
0.0083143292,
0.0118677458,
0.0652563944,
0.0518075861,
-0.0211527254,
-0.0404436737,
0.0178526007,
0.0021167158,
0.1025214642,
0.000001984,
-0.0262801945,
-0.0068774959,
-0.014057423,
-0.0214708634,
-0.0268402696,
0.0564060956,
-0.075378187,
-0.0216996782,
0.0024696544,
-0.0148676168,
-0.0272895079,
0.0844789892,
0.0354787745,
0.0052331188,
0.0830083042,
-0.0125008887,
-0.0628547221,
-0.0110261254,
-0.0327375382,
0.036635153,
-0.0270513874,
-0.0136434622,
-0.0513181202,
-0.0477757491,
0.0123511199,
-0.0317398272,
0.0337962359,
0.0289657544,
0.0209097378,
-0.018291764,
0.0296717789,
-0.0267129354,
-0.0562460199,
-0.0030326927,
0.0801181793,
-0.0685404837,
-0.043075867,
-0.0215808228,
-0.0316951573,
-0.0139397681,
-0.006422807,
-0.0319924764,
0.0435019173,
0.0236988589,
0.0446074903,
0.0418728329,
0.0651814565,
0.0147946486,
-0.0113351652,
-0.0254914314,
0.0000294434,
0.0261216722,
-0.0175010096,
-0.0105193043,
0.0069460603,
-0.0458107851,
-0.0156528149,
0.019104043,
-0.0031894681,
0.0132225109,
0.0285583083,
-0.0532147586,
-0.0553723536,
0.0149647277,
-0.061692249,
0.0401717275,
0.0856190771,
0.0077829468,
0.0407247618,
-0.0195058305,
0.0544541217,
-0.0122164628,
0.0445583239,
-0.0600057878,
-0.0200499948,
-0.0355587825,
0.0179899,
-0.0218576044,
-0.0039331759,
-0.0448978618,
-0.0274499487,
-0.0090274932,
-0.007361351,
-0.0131337829,
-0.0149365291,
-0.018585518,
0.0054024891,
-0.0519907586,
-0.0026485624,
0.0266353209,
0.0650707483,
-0.0385204926,
-0.0301341936,
-0.0037380557,
-0.0573891737,
-0.0463189371,
0.0289193187,
0.009384593,
-0.0306875277,
-0.0265964959,
0.098715283,
-0.0248761047,
-0.0195490774,
-0.0522837192,
-0.0148744043,
-0.0106114242,
-0.0327244624,
0.0356364883,
-0.0432656147,
0.0360898264,
0.0267637912,
0.0076392842,
-0.029295668,
0.0071139252,
0.0158134028,
-0.0241221897,
0.0535968617,
0.0010903758,
-0.0150692826,
-0.0136775542,
0.003670508,
0.0037818281,
0.073754929,
0.0199820437,
-0.0130368257,
0.0151275489,
0.014553654,
0.0125894966,
0.0304579865,
0.0344943106,
0.0196200758,
-0.0642701909,
-0.0293350872,
0.0534045584,
0.0238222964,
0.0886855498,
0.0029115852,
-0.0542044751,
-0.015779594,
0.0396257788,
0.0393960811,
-0.0170697235,
0.0308949575,
0.0297186133,
0.0100228954,
-0.075542286,
0.023893401,
-0.0425853208,
0.0748131722,
-0.0317208022,
-0.0035423408,
0.0035060209,
0.0193494484,
-0.0294482056,
-0.0132820047,
-0.0245479476,
-0.01871893,
0.0095924726,
-0.0545212626,
0.0186525416,
0.022628827,
-0.0254937056,
0.0288407318,
0.0385862142,
-0.0335294008,
0.0183884706,
0.0089945151,
-0.04996939,
0.067070134,
0.0297309123,
-0.0053723836,
-0.0799153,
-0.0084744645,
0.0153401,
0.1055316627,
0.0547360443,
0.0310469475,
0.0524504781,
-0.0773474202,
-0.0150622418,
-0.0078550112,
0.0072780689,
0.0248146206,
-0.0299616661,
0.0518091843,
0.0087096058,
-0.0249198265,
-0.0384513661,
0.0365922116,
-0.0446077995,
-0.01982609,
0.0192682631,
0.0177973043,
-0.0047003594,
0.0026687924,
-0.0185735915,
0.0002928964,
-0.0003210125,
-0.0594222061,
-0.0210198872,
0.0421921276,
-0.072301127,
-0.0536667258,
0.0118329497,
-0.0343176164,
0.0018071895,
0.0105441231,
-0.0195987914,
-0.0396106839,
0.0541264042,
-0.0043948763,
0.0204946324,
0.0012848818,
0.0283586569,
0.0067861048,
0.0182015635,
-0.0176030081,
0.0395725071,
-0.0026579543,
0.0184846763,
0.0049445061,
0.003851623,
0.0400151722,
-0.0132840397,
-0.0208123457,
0.010278808,
-0.0092970245,
-0.0020885614,
0.0145036327,
0.0019996152,
-0.0198277775,
-0.0098946979,
-0.024591947,
0.0195671488,
-0.0238529537,
0.0145576298,
0.0565602593,
0.0007585945,
0.008153894,
-0.0250681881,
-0.0114676012,
0.0372210816,
-0.0106493197,
-0.002338686,
0.0249721073,
-0.0125277312,
0.0005314716,
-0.0012128206,
0.0112598641,
-0.0122526735,
0.0479455702,
-0.0008014839,
-0.0114163477,
-0.050202392,
0.0569733642,
-0.0287642591,
-0.0077508609,
-0.0064844657,
-0.0557863452,
0.0160081126,
0.0125035569,
0.022452388,
0.0408513844,
-0.0394397154,
-0.0113394558,
0.0402270444,
-0.003384023,
-0.0696945041,
-0.0293237492,
0.0104053672,
-0.0093784649,
-0.0072741555,
-0.0399061777,
-0.0277038515,
0.0371728763,
0.0329694226,
-0.007067041,
-0.0927671194,
0.0339728929,
-0.0204073116,
-0.0456976965,
-0.0097464118,
0.0520927683,
-0.0024776224,
0.0352015309,
-0.0307535715,
-0.004855467,
0.0457272567,
-0.0025931529,
-0.0246480387,
-0.045155745,
0.0377560444,
-0.0053556077,
0.0168851633,
-0.0196405221,
0.0360134803,
0.010067435,
-0.0012690966,
-0.021985827,
-0.0085500432,
0.0056165834,
0.0067360299,
-0.015014749,
-0.0544236489,
-0.0146001689,
-0.0480016135,
-0.0068708351,
-0.0160311535,
-0.0419088118,
0.0440975726,
0.016918743,
-0.002619287,
0.001655708,
-0.0209262874,
0.0003473374,
0.0292209834,
0.0780400261,
-0.0301375948,
-0.0029227089,
-0.0242626611,
0.0284959227,
0.0160585865,
-0.0106620826,
0.0302569941,
-0.0360003412,
0.0118783731,
0.00463431,
0.0416640267,
-0.0051904628,
-0.020134531,
-0.0065946938,
0.0313120037,
-0.003705106,
-0.0290581491,
0.0027549004,
0.0415090099,
-0.0209718924,
-0.0300794691,
0.1020062417,
0.0395486243,
-0.0674883276,
0.0163206942,
-0.0296531375,
0.0331049524,
0.0283012204,
-0.0023164484,
-0.0885515362,
-0.0286298636,
-0.0181276817,
0.0130099403,
0.0044938335,
0.003437612,
-0.0087089157,
-0.12907134,
0.0091339024,
0.061309766,
-0.0856237561,
-0.0474127233,
0.016108539,
-0.0112172533,
-0.0400628857,
0.057992965,
-0.0194132421,
0.0170412678,
-0.0174637213,
0.0011417767,
0.1019652411,
-0.0787297115,
-0.0000185953,
-0.0811990052,
0.0805920288,
0.0520344377,
0.0137075121,
-0.0052034408,
-0.0116653936,
-0.0029070743,
-0.0055371341,
0.0262735374,
-0.0148972673,
0.0138643887,
0.0266498476,
-0.0025249105,
0.0042533292,
-0.010846463,
-0.0399158634,
-0.0044472492,
-0.0426713452,
0.0698616281,
-0.0194587819,
-0.0239184853,
0.0121796736,
-0.0067590661,
0.0111149307,
0.0651530549,
0.0211421065,
-0.043377433,
-0.0161414985,
-0.014788243,
0.0504483394,
-0.0889389217,
-0.0112382332,
-0.0030804588,
-0.0067026694,
-0.0803730264,
-0.0795257837,
-0.0569214262,
0.0151942968,
0.0703348145,
0.0118371053,
0.0048592621,
-0.0127203064,
-0.0389022231,
0.024613848,
0.0193952359,
-0.0455869697,
0.022911353,
-0.0211159326,
0.0000391631,
0.0159326661,
-0.0192016959,
0.0174261034,
0.0163558386,
-0.0533326976,
-0.0904725417,
-0.0048197173,
0.0358735248,
0.019431442,
0.0430519022,
-0.02754445,
-0.0662702397,
0.0054878802,
0.0326979533,
0.0037203182,
0.016509654,
0.0383346491,
0.0292515531,
0.0017297475,
0.0692773908,
0.0041617462,
-0.0122327423,
0.0662580729,
0.0533732735,
-0.032624945,
0.0106706293,
0.0080757923,
-0.0226047914,
0.0378989093,
-0.0149009172,
-0.0200487617,
-0.0201732256,
0.0016902303,
-0.0265383665,
-0.0000023854,
-0.0136253657,
-0.0290357955,
0.0566151254,
-0.0084997667,
-0.0109181665,
0.0121124052,
-0.0202072114,
-0.0005879523,
-0.0126663139,
-0.00983644,
0.0068934052,
0.0352796093,
-0.0181148387,
0.045152314,
-0.0205997545,
0.0467357598,
-0.0053941691,
0.0127013503,
-0.044781182,
0.0670517236,
0.0116962707,
0.0076398482,
-0.0169838741,
0.0177538469,
-0.031040553,
0.0319371857,
-0.0095615545,
-0.0028467025,
0.0659137815,
-0.0080531966,
0.0826105028,
0.00483739,
-0.0052500162,
0.0096067237,
0.0044654938,
-0.0162221249,
-0.0337016247,
0.0006381383,
0.0020364583,
0.0181740187,
-0.0094630662,
0.0786385983,
0.0009574371,
0.0076741017,
-0.0015710869,
0.0354263596,
-0.0023027277,
0.0311129969,
0.0600963607,
0.0205933228,
-0.0133158807,
0.0000204943,
-0.0503563061,
-0.0661568046,
0.0162979309,
-0.0124097681,
-0.0068356339,
0.0121210208,
0.0276504736,
0.0373763479,
-0.0577321611,
-0.0018715331,
-0.0141114732,
0.011723401,
0.0308568794,
-0.008607937,
-0.0781007782,
-6.445970944e-33,
-0.0301778968,
0.006954832,
0.0145713044,
-0.0528080128,
-0.0110976063,
-0.054416094,
-0.0226792712,
0.005882543,
-0.0436580218,
0.0111826248,
0.0150666768,
-0.004852247,
0.0222309735,
0.012389631,
0.0184578244,
-0.0441283844,
0.0528525934,
0.0016568963,
-0.0141784688,
0.0133685311,
0.0707254112,
0.0012863176,
0.1086816788,
-0.0266077891,
0.021135712,
-0.0292216148,
0.0294061452,
0.0283368304,
0.0091611017,
0.0035195709,
-0.0009959597,
0.0353126302,
0.0210452322,
-0.0425119027,
-0.0286113266,
-0.0519293994,
-0.0606907047,
-0.0719911754,
0.0218552351,
0.0609472468,
0.0457889549,
-0.0915211663,
0.0806824043,
-0.0469564013,
-0.0472249165,
0.0205664374,
-0.0031955687,
-0.0070254323,
-0.0282519031,
0.0312501602,
-0.119491823,
0.0103517547,
0.0212872177,
-0.0174278915,
0.0043179132,
0.0323285908,
-0.0173598677,
0.0071064443,
-0.1114629656,
-0.0110374885,
-0.0372541808,
0.0045506028,
0.0659781322,
0.0269318521,
-0.0074618254,
0.0157175995,
0.0566120334,
0.0039157155,
0.0217261892,
-0.0217154305,
0.0570153557,
-0.0236826707,
0.0680616871,
0.0698563978,
0.0819299817,
-0.0136011438,
-0.0422170609,
0.0040673036,
-0.0277784169,
-0.0194936562,
0.0512198955,
0.0290096644,
-0.0435818955,
-0.0169033129,
-0.0101262704,
-0.0812214762,
-0.0553428084,
-0.0172083899,
0.0201359987,
0.0008405516,
-0.0107050948,
0.01047167,
0.0883559659,
0.0003025868,
0.0290531758,
0.0352575928,
0.0163688548,
0.0338361524,
-0.0057212561,
0.0251101237,
-0.0571684428,
-0.0514475815,
0.0387071222,
0.0110969953,
0.0059274384,
0.0118602719,
0.0632571056,
0.0068573216,
-0.0424666665,
-0.0077859755,
-0.0417479761,
0.0039589936,
0.0193945169,
-0.0045944322,
0.0221888889,
0.0065293401,
-0.0071981698,
0.0080708209,
0.0716451183,
-0.00639081,
0.0019668958,
0.0238949917,
-0.0394374877,
-0.0071350988,
-0.032144215,
0.0129832644,
-0.0213974491,
-0.0039767036,
0.0212532133,
-0.0743963718,
-0.0388768204,
0.0328436978,
2.803e-7,
0.0481262915,
0.0492193028,
-0.0034675894,
0.0127372164,
0.0171561595,
0.0410583317,
-0.0516719744,
0.0295068063,
0.0047601033,
0.0332242399,
-0.0096823489,
0.0185886584,
0.0232567191,
0.0486236736,
-0.0541179813,
0.014474907,
-0.0070212516,
0.03004569,
-0.0426717661,
0.0100053474,
0.0376831107,
0.096147567,
-0.0098047564,
0.0148561532,
0.02035309,
-0.0169412177,
0.0487974733,
0.0144682201,
-0.0055845757,
-0.0454229675,
-0.0221565347,
-0.0100505874,
-0.0109336851,
0.0249662045,
-0.001018826,
0.0296692681,
-0.0031709955,
0.0239481442,
-0.0467892326,
-0.0548417866,
-0.0222065803,
-0.0462752022,
-0.0156215513,
-0.0542013049,
0.0693511218,
-0.0664366186,
-0.018728286,
0.0243440755,
-0.0166451838,
0.0645703375,
0.0405016877,
-0.0416572727,
-0.0508460887,
0.0151207279,
0.0584487021,
0.0323299654,
-0.0457824618,
-0.0042564017,
-0.0280508175,
-0.0297116898,
-0.0145894913,
-0.0160619207,
-0.0301769916,
0.0284896325,
0.0252602976,
-0.0125051448,
-0.0086487569,
2.4697033e-34,
0.0376221463,
0.0089292834,
0.0249673296,
-0.0400442146,
0.0135245016,
-0.0093903868,
-0.0403114967,
0.0261212382,
0.0122831613,
-0.0271614715,
-0.0293056369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16583v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16583v6 | GPT-Fathom: Benchmarking Large Language Models to Decipher the Evolutionary Path towards GPT-4 and Beyond | 2023-09-28T16:43:35 | 2024-04-02T01:51:38 | Shen Zheng, Yuyu Zhang, Yijie Zhu, Chenguang Xi, Pengyang Gao, Xun Zhou, Kevin Chen-Chuan Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the rapid advancement of large language models (LLMs), there is a
pressing need for a comprehensive evaluation suite to assess their capabilities
and limitations. Existing LLM leaderboards often reference scores reported in
other papers without consistent settings and prompts, which may inadvertently
encourage cherry-picking favored settings and prompts for better results. In
this work, we introduce GPT-Fathom, an open-source and reproducible LLM
evaluation suite built on top of OpenAI Evals. We systematically evaluate 10+
leading LLMs as well as OpenAI's legacy models on 20+ curated benchmarks across
7 capability categories, all under aligned settings. Our retrospective study on
OpenAI's earlier models offers valuable insights into the evolutionary path
from GPT-3 to GPT-4. Currently, the community is eager to know how GPT-3
progressively improves to GPT-4, including technical details like whether
adding code data improves LLM's reasoning capability, which aspects of LLM
capability can be improved by SFT and RLHF, how much is the alignment tax, etc.
Our analysis sheds light on many of these questions, aiming to improve the
transparency of advanced LLMs. | [
-0.0177768208,
0.0815376043,
-0.0134205529,
0.0351793244,
-0.0580857508,
0.0082718143,
-0.0068149501,
-0.0059013418,
0.0091876667,
-0.0208160952,
-0.047508385,
-0.0393896177,
0.0093730493,
0.026755847,
0.0163490716,
-0.0167141557,
0.0607916936,
-0.0590054393,
0.0005559074,
0.0159068462,
-0.0202068053,
-0.0043267603,
0.0031013237,
0.0512687862,
0.0192274377,
-0.0247976687,
-0.0123178232,
-0.012656359,
0.0252748355,
-0.0155707579,
-0.0178655218,
0.0359856486,
-0.0006521287,
0.1010855287,
0.0000019854,
-0.0551619828,
-0.003923703,
0.040543694,
0.0070887185,
0.0721012875,
0.0149370199,
0.0006725852,
-0.0318462849,
0.0223379489,
-0.018272683,
-0.0322975256,
0.0629139766,
-0.0058728498,
0.0434199609,
0.0849303454,
-0.0128867086,
-0.0506287515,
0.0683013126,
-0.0475153252,
-0.0135076633,
-0.0550461076,
0.0045752907,
0.0058734748,
0.0082235346,
-0.0263983291,
-0.0053560692,
0.0301401988,
0.04969671,
0.0044082282,
-0.0506026931,
0.0454383343,
-0.071113579,
-0.0013865066,
0.0078058941,
0.0510725565,
-0.0189749412,
-0.0079770153,
-0.0287484843,
-0.0188812576,
-0.0444510356,
-0.028615633,
-0.0325174481,
0.0407669172,
0.0100709945,
0.0348804705,
0.0454479605,
-0.0028043729,
0.0590993278,
0.0222910717,
-0.0389538556,
0.103267096,
0.0542815253,
-0.0177031439,
0.0033027213,
-0.0020520592,
-0.0478827208,
-0.0452748351,
-0.0334873386,
0.0259168129,
-0.0224270131,
0.0191937014,
-0.0308004804,
0.0100039197,
0.0392428264,
-0.021306254,
0.0608130395,
0.0766716301,
-0.0355473347,
0.0378052704,
-0.0248223003,
0.0946005136,
-0.0379968062,
0.0184813142,
-0.0101120351,
-0.0135028437,
-0.0288057774,
-0.0043493365,
-0.0217061266,
0.0062103714,
-0.0230546854,
-0.0242314469,
-0.0328690484,
0.0209664069,
-0.0064030499,
0.0239666961,
0.0541183911,
-0.0604697615,
-0.0367093161,
-0.0086557213,
-0.0195270348,
0.0355927013,
-0.0259914771,
-0.0115550961,
0.0074481289,
-0.0672468692,
-0.0033312899,
0.0230098683,
-0.050594043,
-0.0535223782,
0.0093928128,
0.04670766,
0.0191399101,
-0.0173373912,
-0.0341726616,
0.0211919453,
-0.0200087875,
-0.1110132113,
0.0063117612,
-0.0547515415,
0.0153217847,
0.0080842096,
-0.0122365188,
-0.0282978714,
-0.0056770178,
0.003172332,
0.0086283013,
0.0362024494,
-0.0143876104,
-0.0013796591,
0.0089528617,
0.0144109363,
-0.003887631,
0.088811174,
0.0339056328,
0.0059629306,
0.0149740903,
-0.0123114223,
-0.010786348,
0.0599371418,
-0.0120057389,
0.0144889764,
-0.0212840419,
0.0506358147,
0.0180913452,
0.0251745377,
0.0068700262,
0.060200762,
0.0045295833,
0.0038605093,
0.051647041,
0.0375090986,
0.0160437394,
0.0141264275,
0.052320689,
-0.0306714717,
0.0102781616,
-0.0060311179,
-0.0611428469,
0.0147987399,
-0.0137306489,
0.046481818,
0.0218054131,
0.0431352742,
-0.0125188725,
-0.0411463566,
-0.0387058668,
0.0028815616,
-0.0153724607,
0.0007976613,
0.060136538,
-0.0328368098,
-0.0409448072,
0.0444616899,
0.0031644129,
-0.0863302127,
-0.0227863919,
-0.0718362331,
0.0216155257,
0.0211914796,
0.0598148629,
-0.0314190388,
-0.0563030317,
0.0356940925,
-0.0227523092,
0.0478572212,
0.0729788914,
0.0229483787,
0.0151537629,
-0.0558236539,
0.0138700018,
-0.0332697332,
0.0343781337,
0.0268857256,
0.0414417647,
0.0087986188,
0.024058586,
-0.0381796248,
-0.0257319361,
0.0248341393,
-0.0028055171,
0.0025547671,
-0.0305777267,
-0.0010284056,
0.0663197637,
0.0075370483,
-0.0254124943,
0.0268462561,
0.0261023287,
-0.0075477799,
0.0063993931,
-0.0096075637,
-0.0130769992,
0.0113859735,
0.0633156598,
0.0135811185,
-0.0255589113,
0.0594103821,
-0.0364825763,
-0.0435184054,
0.0344329402,
0.0111268023,
0.0222376771,
-0.0543600135,
0.0390245393,
-0.027529018,
-0.0075836764,
-0.0094797248,
0.090623267,
0.0094287982,
0.022066487,
0.0239681117,
0.0249147266,
0.0450501591,
-0.0156004047,
-0.069041349,
0.0489673018,
-0.0035695073,
0.0033363185,
-0.0050822916,
0.0274803974,
-0.0508105159,
-0.0271307826,
-0.1121519953,
0.0408654176,
-0.0385640748,
0.0433093235,
0.02673259,
-0.0036097553,
-0.0070381723,
0.0455357023,
-0.023467483,
-0.0124843745,
-0.000859744,
0.0168291926,
0.0171719473,
-0.0076939682,
-0.0447063632,
-0.0540715009,
-0.0183884297,
-0.0357206799,
0.0272527523,
-0.0254378896,
0.015447855,
-0.0310204178,
0.036266502,
-0.0574664138,
0.0391236246,
-0.021697104,
-0.031578023,
0.0370296389,
-0.0343706012,
0.0284568071,
0.0348042473,
-0.0304395594,
0.0101855556,
0.0644681752,
-0.0151660834,
-0.0212648548,
0.0456528962,
0.0120695103,
-0.0410945304,
-0.0240721684,
-0.0102478769,
-0.007399742,
0.0554445833,
-0.0161020719,
-0.0157312099,
-0.075516738,
-0.0195876788,
-0.033296492,
0.0151065914,
0.0021171139,
-0.0055932775,
-0.0277923066,
0.032037437,
-0.0383623168,
-0.0833083987,
0.0466186777,
-0.0669238344,
-0.0092785303,
-0.0472115986,
0.017860448,
-0.0783886686,
0.0974908695,
0.0045504654,
-0.0002257132,
-0.0177938212,
-0.0182194691,
-0.0409907587,
0.0040902556,
-0.0161320083,
-0.0211224277,
0.0740710273,
-0.0686885938,
0.0367631912,
-0.0320992433,
-0.0259160064,
-0.003772266,
0.0079624169,
-0.0343884826,
0.0454302244,
0.0045490791,
-0.0442898422,
-0.0036299035,
0.0304521546,
-0.0095824879,
0.0494455621,
-0.0101876184,
0.0113479206,
-0.0207908787,
0.0086285472,
0.0486086681,
-0.0107663181,
0.0109895421,
-0.0105537092,
0.0219492968,
0.0358801298,
0.0535229258,
0.0081731733,
-0.0628529191,
-0.0030074292,
0.0288935732,
-0.0395933948,
-0.01896815,
0.0315960683,
0.050747253,
-0.0498603955,
-0.0068657803,
0.1181831434,
0.0342415012,
-0.0285196397,
0.0045156553,
-0.0054085013,
0.0741309077,
0.0268653408,
0.0236769021,
-0.08406014,
-0.0254134275,
0.0052399272,
-0.0059440737,
0.006884852,
-0.0131122246,
-0.008209385,
-0.130751282,
0.0411103591,
0.0138002168,
-0.0682019219,
-0.0149088027,
-0.0099816145,
0.0001770964,
-0.0089785904,
0.0301916301,
0.035087578,
0.0128776683,
-0.0068259621,
-0.0243834164,
-0.0230332036,
-0.0331200324,
0.0591994487,
-0.0351827145,
0.0538951941,
0.0779903233,
0.020417396,
-0.0060139545,
-0.0432853065,
0.0535286739,
-0.0474225357,
0.0066704126,
-0.0036725979,
0.0122726271,
0.012753495,
-0.0182177685,
0.0103328824,
-0.001071234,
-0.0299093667,
-0.0011747667,
0.0199427977,
0.0907248408,
-0.0081737759,
-0.0204176642,
0.0148204789,
-0.0355039276,
-0.0393709391,
0.0634917542,
0.0242503006,
0.0035447567,
-0.0569882691,
-0.0196897872,
-0.0098923538,
-0.0314897187,
-0.0115734199,
0.0130789429,
0.0168264508,
-0.0403247401,
-0.0151643977,
-0.0321500041,
0.0278960578,
0.0051008686,
0.0116304355,
0.0116399145,
-0.0201448873,
0.0100338841,
-0.0334278867,
0.0371773317,
-0.028636435,
0.0334767476,
-0.0737770796,
0.009424625,
0.0303294994,
0.0065419595,
-0.0163724646,
0.0425922796,
-0.0858597979,
-0.0785227045,
-0.0249939132,
0.0461661257,
0.033544708,
0.0001687471,
-0.0258171521,
-0.0308349524,
-0.0352665894,
-0.0148520069,
-0.0265303738,
0.0172527004,
0.0212827623,
-0.025963923,
0.0181182045,
0.0496758297,
-0.0263625029,
-0.0153573025,
-0.02015974,
0.0597533658,
0.0199286155,
-0.0157448091,
0.0090165166,
0.0232539047,
0.0410918146,
-0.0201863535,
-0.0100180758,
-0.0104045477,
0.0177316312,
-0.0427950174,
-0.0040695998,
-0.0381225571,
-0.0008374862,
0.0565552935,
0.0064548953,
-0.019708978,
0.0040591583,
0.0064134742,
0.0210206341,
-0.038490057,
0.0197620466,
0.0128720198,
0.0380490385,
0.021451788,
-0.0243203435,
-0.0371079817,
-0.0044846423,
-0.0339055024,
0.0309126209,
-0.022010684,
0.0743809566,
0.00435289,
0.0181892086,
0.0187629275,
0.0433445573,
-0.055285085,
-0.0761142746,
0.0031854846,
0.0298530702,
0.067093201,
0.0153792882,
0.0765237659,
-0.0267601516,
-0.0083679706,
-0.0333581939,
0.0226397999,
0.0172278564,
-0.0454915129,
0.0117155351,
0.0241722818,
-0.0190816876,
-0.0043641068,
0.0767026693,
-0.0003829143,
0.0374538377,
0.0337289907,
0.0041978033,
-0.0051562274,
-0.0716714039,
-0.0081049269,
0.0053604241,
-0.0354518406,
-0.028159691,
-0.063615486,
-0.0712526664,
-0.0203411728,
0.0445779711,
-0.0080524506,
0.0017521754,
0.0020645554,
0.0781506523,
-0.0105924467,
-0.0388585776,
-0.0156805776,
-0.0307842828,
-0.0439693034,
-0.0227830932,
-0.0139360391,
-6.23736037e-33,
-0.0300142653,
0.0185086448,
0.0381918438,
-0.0163197219,
-0.0458671786,
0.0053401985,
-0.0551693588,
0.0109009752,
-0.0444162935,
-0.0228633024,
-0.007859448,
0.0117060421,
0.0043863589,
0.0237277951,
0.0159674119,
-0.0214407444,
-0.0006878614,
0.0064458651,
-0.0356060602,
0.0103046354,
0.0071153054,
-0.0266526919,
0.0684698597,
-0.0221783314,
0.0099980701,
0.0019875772,
-0.0265438855,
0.0025429924,
-0.0577348359,
0.0554093421,
-0.0185774732,
0.0111186272,
0.0201255102,
-0.0405280069,
0.0033137377,
-0.0368218757,
-0.01759094,
-0.0252888892,
0.0635833591,
-0.0109539293,
-0.0336543135,
-0.0351195112,
0.0186034646,
0.0096611809,
-0.0427125506,
-0.0326801576,
-0.0087234722,
-0.0224151611,
0.0087253917,
0.0096433386,
-0.0581114478,
0.0401978567,
-0.0011365197,
0.0115648629,
0.0006179424,
-0.0083566811,
0.0074182511,
0.0361325406,
-0.0412792899,
0.005189701,
0.0110515729,
0.0483540222,
0.1016077399,
-0.0228382666,
-0.011461135,
0.0324703828,
0.0197449606,
-0.0156883169,
-0.0247654878,
-0.0115877474,
0.0220973119,
0.0689302683,
0.0619316101,
0.0075629139,
0.0303397235,
0.0151231103,
-0.0521164127,
0.0184926968,
0.0404688604,
0.0365120173,
0.0058595096,
0.0359738544,
-0.061222665,
0.0017702997,
-0.0306560751,
0.0003995381,
-0.0536832549,
-0.0318954699,
0.0561455376,
-0.039514672,
0.0011176241,
-0.003655205,
0.0382306203,
-0.0338258296,
0.011677199,
0.0388003066,
-0.03838237,
0.0480124876,
-0.0094131641,
0.0710321665,
-0.0395608544,
-0.0293508992,
0.0002151848,
0.0322981365,
0.0146895945,
-0.0159677118,
0.0089092851,
0.043497555,
-0.0544459186,
0.0021478788,
-0.0610718727,
0.0022891215,
-0.0147211039,
0.0287656896,
0.0347175114,
-0.0059968391,
0.014926347,
0.0274721198,
0.0006598362,
0.0098989401,
-0.0553575307,
0.0177340657,
0.0174355134,
-0.0131535726,
0.0111019202,
0.008441899,
-0.0125745432,
0.0059015886,
0.011676833,
-0.0255761892,
-0.0178667419,
0.0504855998,
2.657e-7,
0.0679835379,
0.0129511403,
0.0274363421,
0.0416245051,
0.008823812,
0.0104133869,
-0.0415810458,
-0.0099986214,
0.0131743178,
0.0348807201,
0.0058222767,
0.0206491798,
0.06183514,
0.0309651271,
-0.0396746732,
0.0075465809,
-0.0497765392,
-0.0190462936,
-0.0771916211,
-0.0007926081,
0.0252020173,
0.1054132953,
-0.001985997,
0.0025473014,
-0.0050659697,
-0.0386309698,
0.0458361991,
-0.0288709663,
-0.0003054987,
0.0370108671,
-0.0188574642,
0.017256055,
-0.021035945,
-0.0142741846,
0.0022618563,
0.0143670505,
0.0059495796,
0.0808830932,
-0.0008579477,
-0.0375173464,
0.012723716,
-0.0037389295,
-0.0106285121,
-0.1135076657,
0.0892210454,
0.0023636096,
-0.0533236675,
0.0046686237,
-0.0239799302,
0.0050246972,
0.0005067181,
-0.001843989,
-0.0010766208,
0.0371676013,
0.0134177059,
-0.0419415571,
-0.0368314609,
-0.0667648166,
-0.0615876466,
-0.0148483971,
-0.0476539992,
-0.0529375263,
-0.0630931258,
0.0161242019,
0.0157064255,
-0.0593109168,
-0.0128535666,
2.782058092e-34,
0.0430766828,
-0.041192662,
0.0326844901,
0.0020722155,
0.0429563858,
0.012271516,
-0.0054972279,
0.0192286819,
-0.0317449979,
-0.0785589516,
-0.0336237103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16575v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16575v2 | A Benchmark for Learning to Translate a New Language from One Grammar Book | 2023-09-28T16:32:28 | 2024-02-09T13:55:53 | Garrett Tanzer, Mirac Suzgun, Eline Visser, Dan Jurafsky, Luke Melas-Kyriazi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) can perform impressive feats with in-context
learning or lightweight finetuning. It is natural to wonder how well these
models adapt to genuinely new tasks, but how does one find tasks that are
unseen in internet-scale training sets? We turn to a field that is explicitly
motivated and bottlenecked by a scarcity of web data: low-resource languages.
In this paper, we introduce MTOB (Machine Translation from One Book), a
benchmark for learning to translate between English and Kalamang -- a language
with less than 200 speakers and therefore virtually no presence on the web --
using several hundred pages of field linguistics reference materials. This task
framing is novel in that it asks a model to learn a language from a single
human-readable book of grammar explanations, rather than a large mined corpus
of in-domain data, more akin to L2 learning than L1 acquisition. We demonstrate
that baselines using current LLMs are promising but fall short of human
performance, achieving 44.7 chrF on Kalamang to English translation and 45.8
chrF on English to Kalamang translation, compared to 51.6 and 57.0 chrF by a
human who learned Kalamang from the same reference materials. We hope that MTOB
will help measure LLM capabilities along a new dimension, and that the methods
developed to solve it could help expand access to language technology for
underserved communities by leveraging qualitatively different kinds of data
than traditional machine translation. | [
0.036732614,
0.0322472341,
-0.0154696982,
0.0307945199,
-0.0359109901,
0.0314136334,
0.0261441823,
-0.0130801974,
-0.0379634164,
-0.050141301,
-0.0315558687,
-0.049044963,
0.0288744122,
-0.0347523578,
0.0414383076,
-0.0416313298,
0.0279008504,
-0.0314949043,
-0.0417740606,
0.0109077394,
0.0280471891,
0.0548608564,
-0.011725584,
0.028093664,
0.0087641245,
0.0124160023,
-0.0010784407,
0.0359292105,
-0.001119314,
-0.0222421214,
0.0033077102,
0.0049499199,
0.0059829438,
0.0495132506,
0.0000020333,
-0.0504924096,
-0.0343904421,
-0.0101199457,
-0.0270713698,
0.0126561346,
0.0680397749,
-0.0500633121,
-0.0110244853,
0.0351191275,
-0.04290241,
-0.0017871583,
0.0464621074,
-0.0036603787,
0.0523259826,
0.1023023799,
0.0055465633,
-0.0205936134,
0.005527318,
-0.0200238973,
-0.0121073201,
-0.0447830297,
-0.0019100966,
-0.0114506753,
-0.0142531572,
-0.0192479063,
-0.0508834608,
0.0349999852,
-0.0088532725,
-0.0087726926,
-0.001063294,
-0.0003752742,
-0.0493036732,
-0.0470607691,
0.003842707,
0.0850344747,
-0.026226921,
-0.0224235617,
0.0263226368,
0.0324898139,
-0.0299869031,
0.004989285,
-0.032164339,
0.0420284979,
-0.0276681557,
0.0238354784,
0.0356663167,
-0.0266481917,
0.0460286625,
0.0250906907,
-0.0240842216,
0.0180304926,
0.0148793533,
0.0204034094,
0.009327828,
0.019335039,
-0.0216890723,
-0.0076249116,
0.0007025803,
0.0203828998,
-0.0286911596,
0.0143020591,
-0.0261029899,
-0.0166687742,
-0.0050179372,
-0.0047457088,
0.0563396215,
0.0577788316,
0.0075539728,
0.0559685826,
-0.0423769541,
0.0122621199,
0.0130157564,
0.0030785031,
-0.0463200323,
-0.0006010748,
-0.0342729799,
0.005601095,
-0.0518900976,
-0.0000200935,
-0.0686557591,
0.0224375762,
-0.0074871173,
-0.0067648171,
0.0078081368,
0.0203830022,
0.0013433876,
-0.0402655154,
-0.0841607377,
-0.0592908785,
0.0254293401,
0.058408387,
-0.0129035991,
0.0232268814,
0.0010359122,
-0.0936644673,
0.005959759,
-0.0010576436,
0.0168695096,
-0.0114220222,
-0.0086392649,
0.07437893,
-0.0080661261,
-0.0195415504,
-0.0395744294,
-0.0079253418,
-0.0090850266,
-0.058945775,
-0.0211579744,
-0.0527101494,
0.0399848111,
0.0333864167,
0.0236061737,
-0.0325847678,
0.0184097085,
0.0164717194,
0.0064519369,
0.0775977895,
0.0205908827,
0.0085669905,
0.0317246802,
0.002528236,
-0.0011959255,
0.0739641488,
0.0348287746,
0.0054483786,
0.0336004049,
-0.0089336121,
-0.02758958,
0.0559428185,
0.0019366519,
0.0299185906,
0.0022401253,
-0.0092043355,
0.0234387275,
0.0516897403,
0.044084236,
0.0568134524,
-0.0012736847,
0.049590908,
0.0879325718,
0.04568322,
0.0009842482,
0.0439146198,
0.0583443008,
0.0398050323,
-0.0246579945,
-0.0303480774,
-0.0320147537,
-0.0024579689,
-0.0495787971,
-0.0115417782,
0.0214948859,
0.0386002697,
-0.0169292036,
-0.033226572,
0.0005238973,
-0.0329635926,
-0.0046721352,
-0.0163689386,
0.0815469399,
0.0397790968,
-0.0248783939,
0.0502996594,
0.073007755,
-0.0402350537,
0.0588365979,
-0.0242520403,
0.0078195166,
0.0213288553,
0.0342475846,
0.0022854616,
-0.0138166919,
-0.0271650981,
0.0637088791,
0.0504396111,
0.0460587069,
-0.0212562103,
0.0023688416,
-0.0658909231,
0.0210558064,
0.0270870235,
0.0249616541,
0.0018313861,
0.0034500663,
0.0298204552,
0.028247837,
-0.0735848695,
-0.0592641197,
0.0425937176,
-0.0531231388,
-0.0344158076,
-0.0166308917,
0.0245284997,
0.0007120145,
0.0024655384,
0.0077609504,
-0.005498033,
0.0134865576,
-0.0529523529,
0.0138102453,
0.0123222936,
-0.013653188,
-0.0388873369,
0.0408618934,
-0.0497113205,
0.0091029685,
0.0225118622,
-0.045548588,
-0.0392622575,
0.0095815547,
-0.0254264753,
0.0313138291,
-0.0258441772,
0.0343527719,
0.0319807641,
-0.0091933962,
-0.0290557593,
0.0285161119,
0.0277271196,
0.025107339,
-0.0099572623,
-0.0397511162,
0.0328374505,
-0.0225694682,
-0.0133892763,
-0.0151724704,
-0.0221157726,
0.0222262386,
-0.0029514723,
0.0214274395,
-0.0637896731,
-0.0094539942,
-0.0815356225,
0.0112395668,
-0.0149989333,
0.0431676693,
0.0141996946,
0.020912692,
0.0198194496,
-0.0203111935,
-0.0317597277,
0.0319258682,
0.006917079,
0.0113568632,
0.0279190596,
-0.000383182,
-0.0052236393,
-0.0350299664,
-0.0099263117,
0.0109142689,
0.0302031096,
0.0214561652,
-0.006777273,
-0.039271988,
0.0064621591,
-0.0220096521,
-0.0085892631,
-0.0238755792,
-0.0710940883,
0.0037021572,
-0.0521350093,
0.0002399875,
0.0340595506,
-0.0033683379,
0.0120146936,
0.0227970965,
0.0175844822,
-0.068356894,
-0.0207259748,
-0.0113861607,
-0.0804092735,
-0.0650399178,
-0.0144182602,
-0.034316767,
0.0685240626,
-0.0148167508,
-0.0014859332,
-0.0603025667,
0.0210784934,
-0.0388797261,
0.0159586389,
-0.0572672337,
0.0469244346,
-0.0108458316,
0.0607487336,
-0.0586573444,
-0.0313762501,
0.0524585061,
-0.0169769954,
-0.021382302,
-0.0191364251,
0.0148438988,
-0.039371606,
0.0492099114,
-0.0063174833,
0.050797727,
-0.0082181981,
-0.0137707097,
-0.0665475354,
0.0457832329,
0.055914212,
-0.0181697924,
0.0265912358,
-0.0855107009,
0.0198131073,
-0.028357638,
-0.0537255183,
-0.0149606587,
-0.0275827609,
-0.0500638261,
-0.0188288502,
-0.020945115,
-0.0128891757,
-0.0150918597,
-0.0086176721,
0.0137364678,
0.0090750912,
0.0063416259,
-0.0224311687,
-0.0070731007,
0.0250128247,
0.0210924596,
0.0159962662,
0.0029470432,
-0.0605491474,
0.0165278502,
0.0348844118,
0.0215737354,
-0.0070551373,
0.024736166,
-0.0088651786,
0.0155257815,
-0.0059379884,
-0.0112605114,
0.0195580628,
0.0587367192,
-0.0421844982,
-0.0173168834,
0.1103491411,
0.0205360167,
-0.0131462729,
0.0079070684,
-0.0192729998,
0.0156534463,
0.0107930982,
0.0078677014,
-0.0993405804,
-0.0322385468,
0.0245742425,
0.0554082431,
0.0299257841,
-0.0173611939,
0.0039692679,
-0.1401356757,
-0.0173226409,
0.0359970741,
-0.0316663571,
-0.00787511,
-0.0385774374,
-0.025496643,
-0.0355945043,
-0.0097741839,
0.0235664155,
-0.0336193442,
0.0155037027,
0.0215216205,
-0.0030149191,
-0.0634852052,
0.0205261689,
-0.0646559596,
0.0543419719,
0.0395571887,
0.0294516943,
-0.0156242792,
0.0021555028,
0.0277072843,
-0.0199617147,
-0.0138115706,
-0.0187044814,
0.0321169309,
0.0291093271,
-0.0284427069,
0.0079546412,
0.0565866455,
-0.071146436,
0.0392541923,
0.0065920572,
0.0615021847,
0.0148480274,
-0.009319908,
0.0652778372,
-0.015332846,
0.0162322968,
0.0754737481,
0.0260667335,
-0.0572987311,
-0.0363591574,
-0.0500963628,
-0.024549393,
-0.0459590517,
-0.037673302,
0.0324795842,
-0.0330870934,
-0.015492565,
-0.1079952121,
-0.0511829555,
0.0438877121,
0.0392515361,
0.0345313512,
0.0082030026,
0.0362164043,
0.0011548678,
-0.0323650762,
0.0541422926,
-0.0634228885,
0.0211553201,
-0.0839969292,
-0.0042007244,
0.0421945713,
-0.0496439524,
-0.0008398453,
-0.0030838742,
-0.055227574,
-0.0769947693,
0.0371208154,
0.027749205,
0.0273624435,
0.0130296862,
-0.0360479541,
-0.02655668,
0.0277923234,
0.0331513919,
-0.0563386008,
0.035428416,
0.0479186326,
0.0250055753,
-0.0225924421,
0.0749881864,
-0.0326886326,
0.0142678162,
-0.001448678,
0.0389113799,
-0.0355997719,
0.0015156125,
0.0123307062,
0.0261565167,
0.0583489984,
-0.0484898947,
-0.0399922132,
-0.0168114435,
-0.0065672579,
0.0229551345,
-0.0161403008,
-0.0477076843,
-0.0561414622,
0.0609615408,
0.0220354293,
0.0015344347,
0.0160554014,
0.0286133196,
0.0314642675,
-0.0138502028,
0.0139903501,
0.0248183347,
0.0075032115,
0.0386497416,
0.0172389206,
-0.0120847374,
0.0250115097,
-0.0059309825,
0.0469003171,
-0.0383004174,
0.0393270515,
0.0240733922,
0.0360995494,
0.0221672449,
0.0051332964,
0.0202470347,
-0.0242461413,
-0.0174238738,
-0.0084366091,
0.0933745056,
-0.0049415361,
0.0925672948,
-0.0089706527,
-0.026162345,
-0.0464347638,
0.0575327352,
-0.0224928353,
-0.0227131695,
0.0288108941,
0.0037824702,
-0.0023818128,
0.0702993572,
0.0764597431,
-0.0000811784,
0.0534942262,
0.0249299761,
0.0291867591,
-0.0241307151,
-0.0084735379,
-0.0304926764,
-0.022451764,
0.0198320299,
0.0082084257,
-0.0467521623,
-0.070376128,
-0.0262538288,
0.0014444494,
-0.0270519145,
-0.0538070686,
0.0366371535,
0.0314088278,
-0.0163521543,
0.0311947353,
-0.081635043,
0.0160510316,
-0.026238,
-0.0238973536,
0.0047488655,
-6.871787895e-33,
-0.0379442535,
-0.0223878622,
0.0000316674,
-0.0248609614,
-0.0063714692,
-0.0233409591,
-0.0465056896,
0.0175436437,
-0.0040241731,
0.0144291483,
-0.0164720789,
-0.0072610294,
0.0071244403,
0.0369000547,
0.01843879,
0.0289174095,
0.0528068133,
0.002341147,
-0.0064406614,
0.0216259174,
0.0384205543,
0.0415396765,
0.0411492586,
-0.019672012,
0.032214012,
-0.0529888384,
-0.0293974113,
0.0285360049,
-0.0119899074,
0.0301309898,
0.0032009888,
0.018454168,
0.0129149463,
0.0121027082,
-0.0069171516,
-0.0226934589,
-0.1351463795,
0.0147635061,
0.0074006938,
0.0383509807,
-0.0056276703,
-0.0302547328,
0.0350173749,
-0.0154534904,
0.0117372386,
-0.015001134,
0.0025836604,
-0.0476849787,
-0.0319765434,
-0.0185978618,
-0.0733248517,
0.0219210517,
-0.0045848512,
-0.0234937053,
0.0409906954,
0.0501301438,
-0.0279764831,
-0.0377566665,
-0.0485783219,
0.0010947707,
-0.00178399,
0.0584435537,
0.098342672,
0.0217848048,
-0.0330426581,
0.0172581375,
0.0074296282,
-0.0388516672,
0.0245654341,
0.0293055791,
0.038431596,
0.0142883128,
0.0121349152,
0.075054571,
0.030137524,
-0.0158785395,
-0.0728469416,
0.0271804277,
0.0041650068,
0.0476420969,
-0.0011580831,
0.0016615591,
-0.0648174733,
-0.0411669835,
-0.0517761074,
-0.0221858881,
-0.0242602192,
-0.0135740079,
0.0302206799,
0.006831618,
-0.016866399,
-0.035367921,
0.0386521518,
-0.0295135826,
0.0018066722,
-0.0171961058,
-0.0056194845,
0.0005829929,
-0.0275006406,
0.0298932157,
-0.044093512,
-0.051103577,
-0.01268782,
0.0183682796,
0.0119945062,
0.00346293,
0.0601911359,
0.0172336008,
-0.0626894608,
0.0185592528,
-0.051597435,
0.0077586668,
-0.0080281654,
0.0744874403,
0.0380039997,
-0.0174704529,
-0.0291911699,
0.0392722264,
0.0216711089,
-0.0087420531,
0.0021922919,
0.0099529037,
-0.0184793323,
-0.0190832634,
-0.0552780516,
0.0059082122,
-0.0363478065,
0.0345811024,
0.0600486733,
-0.0445650332,
-0.0070952107,
0.0193033665,
2.949e-7,
0.0430603512,
0.0618326627,
-0.0106626609,
-0.0157167707,
0.001926257,
0.0272079557,
-0.0253977552,
0.0006679334,
-0.0220219251,
0.0268559419,
0.0171684474,
0.0342863351,
0.1148805767,
0.0089253495,
-0.096269466,
-0.0224018656,
-0.0396124832,
0.0351884849,
-0.0510513,
-0.0165839344,
0.0023081857,
0.092785053,
-0.0059812544,
-0.0110070016,
0.0054041361,
-0.0541584007,
0.0819723085,
-0.0328675136,
-0.0287463907,
0.0098675275,
0.0546949245,
0.0275138486,
-0.045322258,
-0.0433376841,
-0.0260288641,
0.0055667362,
0.0048276875,
0.0834716484,
0.0070193503,
0.000175204,
0.014150735,
-0.0144608421,
-0.0135964081,
-0.0352846161,
0.0568702258,
-0.0510478429,
-0.0177960023,
0.0461098216,
-0.0181647651,
-0.0098608434,
-0.0422200486,
-0.033110816,
-0.0212513022,
-0.0040435609,
0.0381356403,
-0.0563804694,
-0.026171647,
-0.0577639155,
-0.0131906373,
0.0319760516,
-0.0007499151,
-0.0668726414,
-0.0156078627,
0.0216947887,
-0.0174179338,
-0.0307804011,
0.022920683,
2.277434668e-34,
0.0240582004,
-0.0293171238,
0.0190136749,
-0.0178022869,
0.0206687227,
0.0015491926,
-0.0131528871,
-0.0216102879,
0.0102193439,
-0.0817945898,
0.0025254576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16573v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16573v2 | Language Models as a Service: Overview of a New Paradigm and its Challenges | 2023-09-28T16:29:52 | 2023-11-30T07:59:26 | Emanuele La Malfa, Aleksandar Petrov, Simon Frieder, Christoph Weinhuber, Ryan Burnell, Raza Nazar, Anthony G. Cohn, Nigel Shadbolt, Michael Wooldridge | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Some of the most powerful language models currently are proprietary systems,
accessible only via (typically restrictive) web or software programming
interfaces. This is the Language-Models-as-a-Service (LMaaS) paradigm. In
contrast with scenarios where full model access is available, as in the case of
open-source models, such closed-off language models present specific challenges
for evaluating, benchmarking, and testing them. This paper has two goals: on
the one hand, we delineate how the aforementioned challenges act as impediments
to the accessibility, replicability, reliability, and trustworthiness of LMaaS.
We systematically examine the issues that arise from a lack of information
about language models for each of these four aspects. We conduct a detailed
analysis of existing solutions and put forth a number of considered
recommendations, and highlight the directions for future advancements. On the
other hand, it serves as a comprehensive resource for existing knowledge on
current, major LMaaS, offering a synthesized overview of the licences and
capabilities their interfaces offer. | [
0.0206218287,
0.0749997869,
-0.031635683,
0.071465537,
-0.0668423027,
-0.0217870586,
0.0494931228,
0.0077337776,
0.0316052511,
-0.0381630659,
-0.0340184234,
-0.0359643884,
-0.009308855,
0.0637051836,
0.010029925,
0.0011651352,
0.0320292749,
-0.052649945,
-0.0025901161,
-0.0136557594,
0.0076594641,
0.0304837208,
0.0194382723,
0.0372027643,
0.0302140992,
-0.0164685082,
0.0107905706,
-0.021530021,
-0.0220936611,
-0.0037810206,
0.0007144809,
0.0309577212,
0.0015843761,
0.0518712774,
0.0000022349,
-0.0598572269,
-0.025103759,
0.0488604829,
-0.030189639,
0.0636132583,
0.0601471066,
0.0029939818,
-0.0366320461,
0.0248392019,
-0.0073039806,
0.0062787095,
0.0703309178,
-0.0716074705,
0.0431702845,
0.0090592038,
0.0046151271,
-0.0115151806,
-0.0141780982,
-0.0067797909,
-0.0882739201,
0.0122539569,
0.0200454518,
0.028512679,
0.0419086516,
0.0039167982,
0.0260666348,
0.0464204587,
0.0111622652,
-0.0248594955,
-0.0554469116,
0.0019819466,
-0.0426288731,
-0.0039021324,
-0.0214131363,
0.0038150344,
0.0098036537,
-0.0453398339,
0.0009196204,
0.003757816,
-0.0442265123,
0.0247260146,
-0.0430006161,
0.0608196408,
0.041488912,
0.0234331284,
0.0337339565,
-0.0125829168,
0.0066123488,
-0.0010528533,
0.0103714578,
0.0899934992,
0.051026307,
0.0174238048,
-0.0613722317,
-0.0244176928,
0.0321222059,
-0.0664973408,
0.0156640559,
0.0202435683,
0.0199511591,
0.0295924544,
-0.0280431379,
-0.0020490708,
0.0677580386,
-0.0631418452,
0.0358315222,
0.0086865639,
-0.0306313932,
0.0308077335,
0.0081390115,
0.0306636747,
-0.0012844187,
-0.0024041841,
0.0060737622,
-0.0063873874,
0.0105876867,
0.002892571,
-0.0331919901,
0.0341945328,
-0.0268796235,
0.0178821683,
-0.0003804844,
0.0564814843,
0.0017427694,
0.0773312747,
-0.0148736546,
-0.0456393473,
-0.0065877,
-0.0382730328,
-0.0041973977,
0.0173824187,
0.0394953191,
-0.0165691189,
-0.0244963802,
-0.1102453619,
0.0324650519,
-0.0188111663,
-0.0574158765,
0.0121425549,
0.0001119249,
0.1016359255,
0.0386093594,
0.0146775637,
-0.0289147459,
-0.0188588463,
0.0116657065,
-0.0351030193,
-0.047595825,
-0.1153680086,
-0.0133816143,
0.0572578944,
0.0081755761,
-0.0470957607,
0.0070003942,
-0.0096721137,
0.0018013197,
0.0080088004,
-0.0487632491,
0.0192942936,
0.0207181331,
0.0225856528,
0.0481598265,
0.0817789361,
0.0208329353,
-0.0185243282,
0.0625289232,
-0.0231708791,
0.0172060505,
0.0671853498,
-0.0458639599,
0.0491363443,
-0.0440050364,
0.0598012581,
0.018589139,
-0.0242392533,
-0.0440977439,
0.0717344806,
0.0129132224,
-0.0132926265,
0.0478896946,
0.0678622425,
-0.0122515252,
0.0229965746,
0.0262764152,
0.0241423361,
0.035379231,
-0.0668962449,
-0.0159291197,
-0.019732954,
0.0020125885,
0.0253565516,
-0.0559272282,
0.0502277948,
0.008663509,
-0.0319158174,
-0.0490173325,
-0.0640474856,
-0.0027884378,
-0.0099879606,
0.070508115,
-0.0153228017,
0.0258115791,
0.0787610635,
0.0358254351,
-0.0474955477,
-0.0189067982,
-0.0716283992,
0.0002767192,
0.0723262429,
0.0869102925,
-0.0302489474,
-0.0190005824,
-0.0017249574,
-0.0086947531,
0.0643338859,
0.0478486419,
-0.0160277411,
0.0005094112,
-0.0221854579,
0.0198997892,
0.0011726439,
0.0250123478,
0.0589681715,
-0.0215936229,
0.0172643233,
-0.0137173058,
-0.0420866609,
-0.040274024,
-0.006752729,
-0.0387494303,
0.0060432968,
-0.0490908287,
0.0070622922,
0.0124086738,
0.0173746198,
-0.0198350549,
0.0124682151,
0.0279607158,
0.0040049744,
0.0227273609,
-0.0020593533,
0.0234404448,
0.1034019664,
0.0563993938,
0.0130199371,
0.0404329412,
0.0513749309,
-0.0010196868,
-0.0041943961,
0.0694474056,
0.0000447156,
0.0489354804,
-0.0041071838,
0.0307789315,
-0.0574946776,
0.0091209896,
-0.0384725593,
-0.0275455322,
0.0014818829,
0.0299350582,
0.0111588696,
-0.025546331,
0.0539702699,
-0.0050855908,
-0.0557722375,
0.0281299837,
-0.0056895274,
0.0421083383,
-0.017993059,
0.0331140757,
0.0028538511,
-0.0073730899,
-0.058825098,
-0.007087477,
-0.0142261423,
0.049966041,
0.0264145434,
0.0333628207,
-0.0285375006,
-0.0093264868,
-0.0116349217,
-0.0099150417,
0.0099455379,
0.0102852434,
-0.0033149587,
-0.038761884,
-0.0848308802,
-0.0497619249,
-0.0158026423,
0.001212843,
0.0426446311,
-0.0441529863,
0.0234501772,
-0.0744792297,
-0.0116423722,
-0.0628822595,
0.046302367,
-0.0156130157,
-0.0347652622,
0.0163384564,
-0.0330539905,
-0.0006515303,
-0.0022398192,
-0.0373914577,
-0.0074740667,
0.066326797,
-0.0166924819,
-0.0515750274,
-0.0424384512,
0.0144736385,
-0.0412412807,
-0.029392302,
-0.0280236602,
0.0018665515,
0.0679956153,
-0.0116379065,
-0.0085203415,
-0.0114185978,
-0.005106017,
-0.0459031425,
0.0273685511,
0.009312598,
-0.0050227819,
-0.0263688713,
0.0187939964,
0.0105271237,
-0.072222054,
0.049849119,
-0.0929709375,
-0.0234231297,
-0.0329202041,
-0.0584308505,
-0.0678368136,
0.0613191985,
-0.0278888214,
0.0196847059,
0.024337966,
-0.0146169988,
-0.0049430435,
0.0261588879,
0.0208613072,
-0.0532337315,
0.0636391789,
-0.0622333139,
0.008596967,
-0.0127650434,
-0.0025622435,
0.0040523806,
0.0512375161,
-0.0743217841,
0.0130014401,
0.0036754045,
0.0168318879,
0.0432393476,
0.0606659129,
0.019883262,
0.0500357784,
0.0305433683,
0.0194565356,
-0.0221756678,
-0.0353374258,
-0.0227963086,
-0.011910296,
0.0030735761,
0.0074820207,
-0.009120116,
0.0061153336,
0.0337942503,
-0.0461195707,
-0.016465066,
-0.0273347478,
0.0782877579,
-0.0405665673,
-0.0456335396,
0.0358938463,
-0.0074119549,
-0.0694630295,
-0.0061338539,
0.077443108,
0.0321489088,
-0.0457413681,
0.0142066954,
-0.0418892428,
0.0169272739,
0.0447997414,
0.0566272885,
-0.0883515775,
0.0259764902,
-0.000100414,
0.0044976776,
0.018120015,
0.0317937136,
-0.0278228037,
-0.0528982207,
0.0591204353,
0.0115069374,
-0.0374905951,
0.0008668675,
-0.0346092284,
0.0108565576,
0.0030188074,
-0.0045569381,
0.0203889124,
-0.0006610783,
-0.0078034988,
-0.0072749001,
-0.0691882372,
-0.0441890694,
-0.0048039365,
-0.0261192918,
0.0708105862,
0.0720125362,
0.0020023647,
-0.0125353979,
-0.0326030329,
0.0343963616,
0.0081410836,
-0.0224799216,
-0.0160896834,
-0.0533608459,
0.0348824635,
-0.0365504771,
-0.0029191298,
-0.0044111027,
-0.0439610109,
-0.0115887616,
-0.022822747,
0.0542620905,
-0.0145173064,
0.0168154277,
-0.0009676309,
-0.0611526966,
0.0175944399,
0.0495412387,
-0.0020828054,
-0.0206762739,
-0.0225653071,
-0.0637589097,
-0.0333589837,
0.0300488491,
-0.0479052216,
0.0226476938,
0.0013283237,
-0.063973166,
-0.0186461136,
0.0003032561,
-0.026530331,
-0.0134552959,
0.0235599112,
0.0272331554,
0.0467091389,
-0.0365357213,
-0.0216140151,
-0.0320497528,
-0.0891193226,
0.0342514031,
-0.0748658255,
-0.0238586515,
-0.0015878404,
-0.007698426,
-0.0229572859,
-0.0264428183,
-0.0668365955,
-0.0785116926,
0.0311763864,
0.0635497943,
0.0294239633,
-0.041671142,
-0.0309821311,
-0.0539624952,
0.0108949607,
-0.0132945115,
-0.0359556675,
0.0106886877,
0.0256655421,
-0.0036574851,
0.0124738896,
0.0331010036,
-0.0559185073,
-0.0030070916,
0.00603492,
-0.013354674,
-0.0031805467,
-0.0308612473,
-0.0153477322,
0.0612210594,
-0.0110685555,
-0.015780272,
0.0005028532,
-0.0114205536,
0.0293786135,
-0.0593597591,
-0.0152535485,
-0.0355610065,
-0.0133084357,
-0.0192818847,
-0.0244866926,
0.0158339981,
-0.004961648,
-0.0324825309,
0.032153219,
0.0229089987,
0.0936693847,
0.0063513122,
0.0209830347,
0.0562275723,
0.0032555622,
-0.0170262102,
-0.0027796088,
-0.0646870434,
0.0301178396,
-0.0304826964,
0.0278020333,
-0.0179893132,
-0.0253565218,
0.0062040505,
0.0526585877,
0.01004647,
-0.0803651735,
-0.0092851669,
0.0235846862,
0.0362096392,
0.0581041463,
0.0719310865,
-0.0668063462,
0.018927617,
-0.0383514427,
0.0240630507,
0.0247165319,
-0.0434683301,
0.0001837455,
0.0013210597,
-0.0239087641,
0.0197805054,
0.067791611,
0.0193767138,
0.0113079716,
-0.0264268778,
-0.0069203046,
-0.0480950326,
-0.0123870671,
-0.0167700481,
-0.0074389544,
-0.0714500844,
-0.0552347936,
-0.0764252469,
-0.0579862297,
-0.0087483833,
0.0573698506,
-0.003867876,
-0.0208355691,
-0.0020213667,
0.063552171,
0.0574097931,
-0.0056792442,
-0.053105019,
0.0155748036,
-0.015812546,
-0.0246243831,
0.0155980149,
-5.993984183e-33,
-0.0048638694,
0.0216916427,
0.038050469,
0.0054946467,
0.0255185533,
0.0083394712,
-0.0344228633,
0.0129622696,
-0.0065316721,
-0.0218475219,
0.0204918832,
-0.015225701,
0.0251928642,
-0.0083721448,
0.0351288319,
0.0348353721,
-0.0047202483,
-0.0039083743,
-0.0186367352,
-0.0154775381,
0.0334599242,
-0.0314979777,
0.0790614411,
-0.0586155504,
0.0280853398,
-0.0413601995,
-0.0054298262,
-0.0077778138,
-0.0139075099,
0.048420731,
0.0056513902,
0.0316536203,
0.0033753179,
-0.029052319,
-0.0081546716,
-0.0454551689,
-0.0014818372,
0.0056708422,
0.0281245243,
0.033188697,
0.0115015991,
-0.007533289,
0.0223618783,
-0.0019958557,
-0.021376973,
0.0660657734,
-0.0112218494,
-0.0177260395,
-0.007611047,
0.0306757893,
-0.0262661949,
0.0097620562,
0.0055783936,
0.0315125845,
0.0242878068,
-0.0113070942,
-0.0201758873,
-0.0000064123,
0.0023177366,
0.0308181364,
0.0324411876,
0.0265561007,
0.0971075445,
-0.0058513945,
-0.0142450603,
-0.0000285112,
-0.00817715,
-0.0236936826,
0.0075388751,
0.0149955265,
0.0421002917,
0.0375118107,
0.0551835708,
0.010717663,
-0.0556352511,
-0.0211491548,
-0.0123930471,
-0.0047660233,
0.0329937227,
0.0028686472,
0.0066064969,
0.0194422547,
-0.0305626746,
-0.0088334456,
-0.0387543812,
-0.029243974,
-0.0437602401,
-0.0512335747,
0.0219182111,
-0.0204558913,
-0.0069410386,
-0.0070154448,
0.0181359537,
-0.0448862426,
-0.0741261318,
-0.0176062733,
-0.0096362075,
0.0321315154,
0.002989603,
0.0331636816,
-0.0618827157,
-0.0079964902,
-0.0486550592,
-0.013540986,
-0.0024102351,
0.0004881783,
-0.0246467311,
0.0317475684,
-0.0728734955,
0.061958909,
-0.027671326,
0.0313199274,
0.0249148179,
0.0099384757,
0.02841915,
-0.0559826158,
0.0345216952,
0.038442757,
0.0210210346,
-0.046005968,
-0.014059619,
0.0256668348,
0.0121831372,
-0.0072508669,
-0.0235038977,
0.0096434103,
-0.0501467213,
0.0574352033,
0.0571847744,
0.02730559,
-0.0090540564,
-0.0200773031,
2.913e-7,
0.0442376845,
0.0425880551,
0.0192201156,
0.0465048067,
0.0268271696,
0.0207172967,
-0.0129546179,
0.0180553347,
-0.0116775548,
0.0319142602,
-0.0728493407,
-0.0140848635,
0.0594017021,
0.0491602458,
-0.0386833623,
0.020730542,
-0.0300991964,
0.0371928997,
-0.053808555,
-0.0231589582,
0.0094176382,
0.0494148768,
0.0231278893,
0.00312616,
-0.0409685634,
-0.021752771,
-0.0074835098,
-0.0381458625,
-0.007933422,
0.0359365195,
0.0156174954,
0.0548256375,
0.0183611736,
-0.0008346088,
-0.0279990807,
0.0060913218,
-0.065564774,
0.0606917776,
-0.0159446988,
0.0138934394,
0.0449169353,
-0.0741603151,
-0.0285416134,
-0.0523899645,
0.0465495326,
0.032120388,
-0.0174233671,
-0.0308286306,
-0.0235836226,
0.0000027763,
-0.0481076241,
-0.0306700878,
-0.0279723965,
0.0237392113,
-0.0062747132,
-0.0562881418,
0.0049254061,
-0.0333238356,
-0.0441963747,
-0.0379472375,
0.0117349019,
-0.0072579421,
-0.0264809784,
-0.0081579685,
-0.0176861938,
-0.0164457597,
0.0465489402,
2.71136726e-34,
0.0124182673,
-0.0269646775,
0.0276745651,
0.0511641651,
0.0065908367,
-0.0036169561,
-0.0063082026,
0.0223877635,
-0.0462621115,
-0.0082097715,
-0.0138148973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16540v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16540v3 | Unsupervised Pretraining for Fact Verification by Language Model Distillation | 2023-09-28T15:53:44 | 2024-03-06T20:12:01 | Adrián Bazaga, Pietro Liò, Gos Micklem | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | Fact verification aims to verify a claim using evidence from a trustworthy
knowledge base. To address this challenge, algorithms must produce features for
every claim that are both semantically meaningful, and compact enough to find a
semantic alignment with the source information. In contrast to previous work,
which tackled the alignment problem by learning over annotated corpora of
claims and their corresponding labels, we propose SFAVEL (Self-supervised Fact
Verification via Language Model Distillation), a novel unsupervised pretraining
framework that leverages pre-trained language models to distil self-supervised
features into high-quality claim-fact alignments without the need for
annotations. This is enabled by a novel contrastive loss function that
encourages features to attain high-quality claim and evidence alignments whilst
preserving the semantic relationships across the corpora. Notably, we present
results that achieve a new state-of-the-art on FB15k-237 (+5.3% Hits@1) and
FEVER (+8% accuracy) with linear evaluation. | [
-0.0034221823,
0.0722560883,
0.0449927039,
0.0404785126,
-0.039159324,
-0.0075759236,
0.0117409201,
-0.0215096567,
0.0179389156,
-0.0199267864,
-0.0133741489,
-0.011588824,
0.0072305198,
0.0534756444,
0.0050778538,
-0.0287003387,
0.0474170074,
0.0183478668,
0.0615943335,
-0.0171998609,
0.0177658554,
0.0303863455,
-0.0376530215,
-0.0130118439,
-0.068507351,
-0.0367827751,
0.009277828,
-0.0167560987,
0.052397456,
-0.0234473553,
0.0099532483,
0.0640250966,
0.0292055458,
0.0589917414,
0.0000018963,
-0.0739230216,
-0.0129624167,
0.0431723781,
-0.0590472892,
0.042950023,
-0.0008100513,
0.0095119197,
0.0033970736,
0.010357677,
-0.024816161,
-0.0390387736,
0.0294820089,
0.0703089461,
0.0821106806,
0.098764658,
-0.0043996051,
-0.0564093702,
0.027509585,
-0.0249799099,
-0.0436666533,
-0.012026906,
0.0254905596,
0.0227275658,
-0.0526203588,
0.0114059309,
-0.000542237,
0.0555056445,
0.0006101605,
-0.0025410322,
-0.0142420055,
0.039586518,
-0.0701126233,
-0.0013630353,
0.0197648201,
0.0585442409,
-0.0123182191,
-0.0647693053,
-0.0070822588,
-0.0145568913,
-0.0087932013,
0.0240865387,
0.0156901237,
0.0525603816,
0.0072162561,
0.0305151828,
0.0280326679,
0.0349361897,
0.0505766273,
-0.0032233133,
-0.0065953694,
0.0420992002,
-0.0076615307,
-0.0556435436,
0.0334264413,
-0.0110596064,
0.0141061479,
-0.0870731995,
0.0060644415,
0.0003974283,
0.0147191668,
0.0023565702,
-0.0499542691,
-0.0122398902,
0.0386628732,
-0.0761789903,
-0.008948423,
-0.0002726237,
-0.0830719247,
0.0743956268,
-0.0291128624,
-0.0026012983,
0.0011717728,
0.0044280197,
0.0033053888,
-0.0045778356,
-0.0265055783,
0.0141570847,
-0.0251960326,
0.0354520939,
-0.0317980945,
0.0117585566,
-0.0319781415,
-0.0398172364,
-0.0200493466,
0.0340927914,
0.0185839366,
0.0019466854,
-0.0020804142,
-0.0440216288,
-0.0458586365,
0.0319489501,
-0.0041645467,
0.0157579705,
-0.0150930407,
-0.0250054523,
-0.0263359156,
0.0331195518,
0.0050874115,
-0.007098244,
0.0138377277,
0.006482888,
0.0117613385,
-0.0396877714,
-0.0597524457,
-0.0133575257,
-0.0297044385,
-0.0835162997,
-0.0320652984,
-0.0569096394,
0.0367996879,
-0.0401630551,
-0.0091317752,
-0.0441344455,
0.0019144836,
0.004430206,
-0.0127921067,
0.0467092693,
-0.0338411592,
-0.0166868232,
0.0031662683,
-0.0112406239,
0.0557576567,
0.0484199487,
0.0122786406,
0.0433335081,
0.0475194603,
0.0235433485,
-0.0006227035,
-0.0094485208,
0.0839072019,
0.0104002245,
0.0349528193,
0.0100509739,
0.0275931936,
-0.0016802712,
0.0418180972,
0.0337213017,
-0.0161999967,
-0.0599780791,
0.0674192309,
0.0128669282,
0.0289691854,
-0.0030714227,
0.0300502423,
0.0022635222,
0.0343511775,
0.0034298981,
-0.0627139807,
-0.0071042562,
-0.0346604586,
-0.0122440476,
0.0369510017,
0.0653359666,
-0.0265507493,
-0.0404766686,
0.0053061196,
-0.0196094383,
-0.0363541581,
0.0146942446,
0.0368721746,
0.0359479487,
0.0084674908,
0.0670162365,
0.0516506396,
-0.0430002622,
-0.0261681397,
-0.0198899843,
0.0215322357,
-0.0136349425,
0.0266461335,
-0.021636324,
0.0156351961,
-0.0167379119,
0.0156799797,
0.0442408137,
0.0582869425,
0.0040623103,
0.0401371494,
-0.0002904789,
-0.0286763795,
-0.0501455814,
0.0255215522,
-0.0165690053,
0.0282746032,
0.0481336005,
0.0430419557,
-0.0419688933,
-0.0479478762,
0.0257143453,
-0.0003881599,
-0.0433888584,
0.0125660077,
0.0272806901,
0.0255933125,
0.0339578539,
-0.0207672492,
-0.0152748525,
0.0176070798,
-0.0130697908,
0.0036687905,
0.0084019583,
0.0120701548,
-0.0684838817,
0.0557829812,
-0.0385849476,
-0.0277297851,
0.022734886,
-0.0522735864,
-0.0147287156,
-0.0411533155,
0.0033943518,
0.0031708833,
-0.0406951346,
-0.0054076021,
0.0115126856,
-0.0035211032,
-0.0011026942,
0.0496747717,
-0.0098080356,
-0.0315455683,
-0.0796152502,
-0.0341867246,
0.0594521575,
0.0118795298,
-0.0122321295,
0.014465523,
-0.0126399845,
0.0242061857,
0.0421122797,
-0.0437283739,
-0.0227940809,
0.0395218246,
-0.075810194,
0.0044116639,
-0.0290322639,
0.0206349567,
0.0192457978,
-0.0130508356,
-0.0039328211,
-0.0022338268,
-0.0486327186,
-0.0565429591,
-0.0012652637,
-0.0157045443,
0.0374174826,
-0.0199868623,
0.0285596754,
-0.0406883769,
-0.0048339469,
-0.0192825738,
0.0418301858,
0.0181157719,
-0.0210054703,
-0.0408241898,
-0.0083369492,
-0.0581631362,
0.0269695874,
-0.0065500527,
0.0061554476,
0.0043404163,
0.0246476103,
-0.0296117552,
0.0229863133,
0.032615751,
-0.0196617749,
0.0443435647,
0.03850675,
-0.0253847223,
0.0156992693,
-0.0381103642,
0.0417862833,
0.0007497054,
-0.0066814297,
0.0420954712,
0.0518874675,
0.0013524218,
-0.0154196266,
0.0027393207,
-0.0209072698,
0.0181286875,
-0.0296401978,
0.0162637066,
0.0137697021,
-0.0141425841,
0.0407619774,
-0.0164411049,
-0.0546534993,
0.0747257993,
-0.0735297278,
0.0230595861,
-0.0430972241,
-0.0133365914,
0.0006167232,
0.0529394709,
0.0107102999,
0.0209810324,
0.0186313838,
0.0140392818,
0.0027374357,
-0.0355505608,
0.0474944972,
-0.0138215031,
0.0102582397,
0.0003705653,
0.0417093933,
0.0103419311,
-0.0427338369,
-0.0516582467,
-0.1175521314,
0.0057149059,
-0.0067279544,
-0.0410027504,
-0.0101576904,
-0.0779273808,
-0.0204597786,
0.0245550424,
0.0644385144,
0.0127615333,
0.0189872459,
0.0025422033,
0.0366538316,
0.0342928544,
-0.004689706,
0.0298654716,
0.0126712527,
-0.0307699367,
0.0831303895,
-0.0308944248,
-0.0094734989,
-0.0387012661,
-0.0389126465,
-0.0187416729,
-0.0562189147,
0.0240826793,
-0.0277457777,
0.0447688997,
-0.0554125346,
0.0156975761,
0.0957040489,
0.0002538562,
0.0428060554,
0.0181349684,
0.0267279018,
0.0090210019,
0.0029566074,
0.0010089488,
-0.1034623682,
-0.0068060514,
-0.0375825129,
-0.0208572019,
0.0190344844,
0.0022737633,
-0.0311574694,
-0.0716651976,
0.0403887853,
0.0149716074,
0.0093741678,
-0.0378029346,
-0.0498121269,
-0.0045303004,
-0.0358155742,
-0.0078112767,
0.0118590258,
0.0075901658,
-0.0005879387,
0.0002328205,
-0.0358662009,
-0.0319491848,
0.0379121453,
-0.0565236509,
0.0467406698,
0.0372647382,
0.0060167341,
-0.0146587426,
-0.0542219579,
-0.0281826705,
-0.0176397003,
-0.043893896,
0.0285928715,
0.098368898,
-0.0592714138,
-0.009932301,
0.0305899307,
0.0220553819,
-0.0068623493,
-0.0334647186,
0.0010960448,
0.040122699,
-0.000298945,
-0.0271105617,
-0.0283430535,
0.0108006811,
0.0205124505,
0.0795990825,
-0.0045004454,
0.03033177,
-0.0073141437,
-0.0052472847,
-0.0352651142,
0.0003086039,
-0.0453783832,
0.0354536548,
-0.0072106542,
-0.0498763174,
-0.0650240555,
-0.0296498388,
-0.0194095299,
0.0550161861,
-0.0554289483,
-0.0357930809,
0.0173542555,
-0.0147903552,
-0.0638028085,
0.0847157314,
-0.0565402433,
0.0150650637,
-0.0093547767,
-0.0019696022,
0.0272046085,
-0.0157486722,
-0.0246631224,
0.0221959203,
-0.042341806,
-0.0574541204,
-0.0153715415,
0.0270702597,
0.0091858814,
0.1043997407,
-0.0579738654,
-0.0025693076,
0.0738333538,
0.0622207858,
-0.040137209,
-0.0020187884,
0.0355268419,
-0.0682438612,
0.0126703717,
0.0081831338,
-0.0001256427,
0.0484388247,
0.0166565869,
0.0202920791,
-0.0184862521,
-0.0480957776,
0.0567751043,
0.0380689502,
0.1034196168,
0.0056198235,
0.0417424776,
-0.0412229076,
0.0103028668,
-0.0156396851,
-0.0331342183,
-0.0212161932,
0.0327817909,
0.0099163931,
-0.0156132504,
0.0023747138,
0.0131508457,
-0.0433937758,
0.0037528472,
0.0018379324,
-0.0497301407,
-0.0133973202,
0.0495846234,
-0.0093142428,
-0.0158628207,
-0.0337490402,
0.0062562511,
0.013133375,
0.0332657509,
-0.0067280605,
0.0115387477,
0.0340602808,
0.0329676606,
-0.0249962453,
0.0068011824,
-0.0429971777,
-0.0130927879,
-0.0908050537,
0.0040637963,
0.040775191,
-0.0334427245,
0.0218906961,
-0.0267404076,
-0.0311243739,
-0.0226836428,
0.0110930605,
-0.0217849948,
0.0275250338,
0.0054458114,
0.0001957371,
-0.0611958615,
0.0153519949,
0.0469947308,
0.0143271284,
0.0465073958,
0.0140559357,
-0.0130075775,
-0.0273400582,
-0.0747225657,
-0.0387896486,
0.044293128,
-0.0238805097,
-0.0281017423,
-0.0439397357,
-0.067636162,
0.0191627685,
0.0368552133,
-0.0013488727,
0.0633865073,
0.0355664641,
0.0745720044,
-0.0042357771,
-0.0309621897,
-0.0045766481,
-0.0089761401,
0.0412125029,
-0.030914573,
0.0145781711,
-6.300950206e-33,
0.004406556,
-0.010863537,
0.0053960877,
0.0024432566,
-0.0150901889,
0.0194480121,
-0.0063950685,
-0.0243581738,
-0.0429495759,
0.0920329243,
0.0308718272,
0.0342802405,
0.0155083239,
0.014099597,
-0.0229476709,
0.0120549528,
0.0787017196,
0.0267680567,
-0.037286289,
0.0290405378,
0.0225015935,
0.0019105959,
0.0710386932,
-0.111410141,
0.0218251497,
0.0038247344,
-0.0321190767,
0.0089292517,
-0.0115325423,
0.0293099619,
-0.0199419484,
0.0353643522,
0.0016833382,
-0.0314684361,
0.0117666004,
-0.0285062101,
-0.0940536261,
-0.0128842555,
0.0472723208,
-0.0305982623,
-0.0418754853,
0.0362017229,
0.0379860252,
-0.0160764083,
0.0041790525,
-0.020740293,
0.0219186079,
-0.0209862608,
0.0061640237,
-0.0597653948,
-0.0527568161,
0.053541515,
0.0013730875,
-0.0103836218,
0.0172867328,
0.0020809006,
0.0083099538,
0.0221698061,
-0.0682473406,
0.0214881524,
-0.0190866478,
0.0178926438,
0.0368277282,
-0.0443871692,
-0.04971743,
0.0633809492,
-0.0325264148,
-0.0072676353,
-0.0161341038,
0.0349768512,
0.0089027844,
0.0608128719,
0.0079786414,
0.0906512663,
0.0311462004,
-0.0014219393,
-0.1086670011,
0.0312803946,
-0.0249268115,
-0.0245271269,
-0.0412269011,
-0.0111952191,
-0.0350540243,
0.006355247,
-0.035622105,
0.0058660815,
-0.0134537155,
0.006424054,
-0.0205457695,
0.022965638,
-0.0024315356,
0.0657018125,
-0.0174746886,
-0.0442113131,
0.0002692951,
0.0108286086,
-0.0166103095,
-0.0254592299,
0.0099171279,
0.0205015931,
-0.0675516576,
0.022907136,
-0.0062375586,
0.0197840407,
-0.0071201148,
0.0230870973,
0.0708879977,
-0.0129550602,
-0.0565978885,
0.0328072309,
-0.0104458341,
-0.0286881719,
0.0052287374,
-0.0157017242,
0.0288453661,
0.0065154294,
0.0001572847,
0.0435517989,
0.0147157898,
-0.005533752,
-0.0325451717,
0.0076399855,
0.0220816508,
0.0399700366,
0.0006724058,
-0.0113491248,
0.0167733654,
-0.0202885289,
0.0094457511,
-0.0829945579,
0.0353677385,
0.0129730869,
2.616e-7,
0.0375744179,
0.0258317422,
0.0088467589,
-0.0342394114,
-0.0127210021,
0.0436336473,
0.0059283357,
0.0288472064,
-0.0027600527,
-0.1036753654,
-0.0090904636,
0.0376045182,
0.0201540086,
0.0357446261,
-0.0455363356,
0.0116546489,
-0.0662133694,
-0.0518691875,
-0.0544390641,
-0.031376943,
0.014677288,
0.0657138899,
0.0659477711,
-0.0222098082,
0.0247965027,
-0.0141129987,
0.0630062595,
0.0409300514,
-0.0456971154,
0.0116332434,
0.0560835041,
-0.0134934885,
-0.0015065803,
0.0140992282,
-0.0415098928,
0.0416558273,
-0.0211628266,
0.0687366948,
-0.0059869811,
-0.0060921386,
-0.0435079709,
-0.0051006563,
0.0170849245,
-0.0383334048,
0.038376838,
-0.0321987309,
-0.0284030885,
-0.0613297224,
-0.0739263222,
0.0296061076,
0.0513437912,
0.0224095657,
0.0077743372,
0.0471881218,
0.0009121982,
0.0177335795,
-0.0412917137,
-0.069422543,
-0.0401732475,
0.0459377095,
-0.0126329521,
-0.0287540238,
0.0497436188,
-0.0298184063,
0.0503417403,
-0.0611164607,
0.0236809868,
2.242314938e-34,
0.034630768,
0.0097718118,
0.0003892547,
-0.0347827747,
0.0266778879,
0.0185797419,
-0.0177717395,
-0.0186429601,
-0.0011050025,
-0.0017727682,
0.0021632737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16535v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16535v1 | KLoB: a Benchmark for Assessing Knowledge Locating Methods in Language Models | 2023-09-28T15:47:03 | 2023-09-28T15:47:03 | Yiming Ju, Zheng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recently, Locate-Then-Edit paradigm has emerged as one of the main approaches
in changing factual knowledge stored in the Language models. However, there is
a lack of research on whether present locating methods can pinpoint the exact
parameters embedding the desired knowledge. Moreover, although many researchers
have questioned the validity of locality hypothesis of factual knowledge, no
method is provided to test the a hypothesis for more in-depth discussion and
research. Therefore, we introduce KLoB, a benchmark examining three essential
properties that a reliable knowledge locating method should satisfy. KLoB can
serve as a benchmark for evaluating existing locating methods in language
models, and can contributes a method to reassessing the validity of locality
hypothesis of factual knowledge. Our is publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/juyiming/KLoB}. | [
0.0661379248,
0.0071375817,
-0.0388490967,
0.0333182178,
-0.0584392361,
-0.0468377657,
-0.0175830107,
0.0212562885,
-0.0082861818,
-0.0333264172,
-0.0234483033,
-0.0182824675,
0.0281009693,
-0.0226027668,
0.0289461222,
-0.0179472957,
0.0660705045,
0.0311156102,
-0.0078464728,
0.0217679311,
-0.011195058,
-0.0218422823,
0.0022734024,
0.0235225204,
-0.0067843674,
-0.0004357058,
-0.0259742942,
-0.0039193924,
0.0262167007,
0.0204942189,
-0.0217163656,
0.036440976,
-0.0203016475,
0.0542686358,
0.0000019487,
-0.0298753977,
-0.061886739,
0.0022570305,
-0.0445890464,
0.0359038897,
-0.0131654385,
-0.0102345366,
-0.0235964246,
0.01417585,
0.0067869429,
-0.0234665088,
0.0369116925,
-0.0162304174,
0.0130029274,
0.086196661,
-0.018822588,
0.0042179185,
-0.0406342372,
0.0075470908,
0.0024511639,
-0.0210708175,
0.0086063193,
0.0597194694,
0.0238632597,
0.0337042063,
0.0055487198,
0.0951580629,
-0.0380137376,
-0.0316994339,
-0.0087023908,
0.0194697082,
-0.0198945794,
-0.009148974,
0.0482458211,
-0.0068717171,
0.0061702016,
-0.0392856561,
-0.0079303067,
0.0394732207,
0.0117524406,
0.0626473576,
-0.0234140381,
-0.0048205056,
0.0050944299,
-0.0120582841,
0.0037262524,
-0.0515908226,
0.0291821901,
-0.0196252856,
-0.0084010363,
0.1086664274,
0.0232567452,
-0.0539777279,
-0.0394587182,
-0.0318222009,
-0.0077668787,
-0.0619134791,
0.0391942263,
0.0278528184,
0.0219935849,
0.0521995611,
-0.0014983728,
0.0574761778,
0.0211133901,
-0.0758450776,
0.0178968832,
0.0331217535,
-0.0155348033,
0.0635153055,
-0.01151969,
0.0640361235,
-0.0152971754,
-0.041669257,
-0.0259638,
0.0154099641,
-0.0523997471,
-0.0329827964,
-0.0562490374,
0.0006755376,
-0.0228217542,
0.0017571768,
-0.0060269274,
0.0288313664,
0.0131107317,
0.0149856415,
-0.0423953868,
-0.0356635749,
0.0410853475,
0.0224126447,
-0.0074616987,
0.0360329747,
-0.0354731791,
-0.0041183387,
-0.053873986,
-0.0240417756,
0.0017447668,
0.0037677127,
0.0066053993,
-0.021120593,
-0.0053712297,
-0.0291261449,
0.0437113047,
-0.0314013176,
-0.0398321189,
-0.0275603179,
-0.0418393835,
-0.043550469,
-0.0254600942,
-0.0631848723,
-0.0115012676,
0.0188890211,
-0.0288281143,
-0.0529829264,
-0.0196334049,
0.0139683392,
-0.0035228813,
0.0501168557,
-0.0148994485,
0.0497064963,
0.0190833993,
0.0298258997,
-0.0059876624,
0.0162743069,
-0.0146055883,
-0.0084696338,
0.076943323,
-0.0006922998,
-0.0094220415,
0.0201483797,
0.0131216198,
0.0019185642,
0.0050434344,
0.0218314528,
0.009722203,
0.0284004994,
-0.039003361,
0.0167605467,
-0.0079275472,
-0.0019494588,
0.0636136383,
0.0376626626,
0.0555102974,
0.0157063231,
0.0184194446,
0.0208895337,
0.0138765397,
-0.0257214457,
0.0009565168,
-0.0052398224,
-0.0743017942,
0.0212061796,
0.0051121321,
0.0001725809,
0.0129991584,
-0.0108734081,
-0.0707024038,
0.0192910973,
-0.0430048369,
-0.0304345787,
0.0413075686,
-0.0170611292,
0.001983946,
0.0775737017,
0.0115904575,
-0.037632715,
-0.0125111276,
-0.0297730416,
0.0084861927,
0.0236080531,
0.0392499566,
-0.0654982477,
-0.0719003603,
0.041791562,
-0.0284316782,
0.009661817,
0.0463282019,
-0.0328813456,
-0.0180894248,
-0.0007168456,
0.0025458951,
-0.0365630724,
0.0194866955,
-0.0085306838,
0.0604287647,
0.045828633,
0.0033282004,
-0.0821705163,
0.0414416082,
0.027069686,
-0.0225693006,
0.0385155603,
-0.0678910613,
0.0203733705,
-0.0207765196,
0.0400785394,
-0.0249473024,
0.0097359382,
0.0470531248,
0.0157819558,
0.0132365935,
0.0430357046,
0.0133373467,
-0.029243432,
0.0807732791,
0.0335267857,
0.0068255607,
-0.0341485925,
0.030768631,
-0.0083070062,
0.0286135729,
-0.0260802656,
0.0582228079,
-0.0079263682,
0.086561814,
-0.0497096516,
-0.0561971664,
-0.0246499628,
0.0829065368,
-0.0066505652,
0.0576805808,
0.0352258049,
0.0080202688,
0.0542739592,
-0.0257099066,
-0.0533450656,
-0.0130135091,
-0.0270657558,
0.0276125837,
0.0302329604,
-0.0277029872,
-0.0197780542,
-0.0372439437,
-0.056790933,
0.0166988019,
-0.0187819134,
-0.0050098496,
0.0193309039,
0.0116364611,
-0.019558033,
0.0000382817,
0.0014656804,
-0.0428709425,
-0.031614691,
0.0299039222,
0.0069796084,
0.0199961457,
-0.0548403077,
-0.054996293,
0.0086504985,
-0.0003239588,
0.0227348823,
-0.0176957902,
-0.0251205042,
-0.0639506951,
0.0660216734,
-0.0744857863,
0.025607273,
0.0049804733,
-0.0151616959,
0.0096650897,
0.0070624785,
0.0405189022,
0.0315718018,
-0.0479639284,
0.0446264148,
0.0682779849,
-0.0048952103,
-0.0513028018,
-0.0209923461,
0.0178858079,
-0.0060827327,
-0.0270786304,
-0.0341750421,
-0.003421179,
0.0564341284,
0.0068898126,
-0.0463648289,
-0.0294906478,
0.0149740772,
-0.0449871719,
0.0016660059,
-0.0357382186,
0.0151248546,
-0.0198187362,
0.0421555303,
-0.048514992,
-0.0540576503,
0.006602102,
-0.0643679947,
0.0286598206,
-0.0244350024,
-0.04759112,
0.008891209,
0.0419019274,
-0.0187001023,
0.0486486889,
-0.0188237987,
-0.0002340594,
-0.0286577903,
0.0359459929,
0.0283156186,
-0.0221469104,
0.038613826,
-0.0045705792,
0.0185837876,
0.0270268526,
-0.0085813971,
-0.0407734104,
0.020207949,
0.0164802298,
0.002921907,
0.0119457226,
-0.0290628392,
-0.0128880339,
0.0457659699,
0.0330994204,
0.0812499076,
0.0487242043,
-0.002137678,
-0.0212835688,
-0.0067696143,
0.024007678,
-0.0102862874,
0.0489930697,
0.0311271884,
-0.0076231956,
0.0358840115,
0.0265599284,
-0.0409371182,
0.0010076207,
-0.0408958793,
0.0108345849,
-0.0882273018,
-0.0809029341,
-0.0257972479,
0.019044701,
-0.0257291123,
-0.0522029735,
0.1230598688,
0.0778886452,
-0.0180873703,
0.0181924086,
-0.0609662123,
-0.0077710743,
0.0632389635,
0.0038223139,
-0.0477940217,
0.0335885845,
0.0382972471,
-0.0114334393,
-0.0243166536,
0.0019216912,
-0.0052605113,
-0.0792633295,
0.000684874,
-0.0115090795,
-0.0181473251,
-0.0829521492,
-0.0214032792,
0.0066909096,
0.0212693736,
-0.0155011835,
0.0588786639,
-0.00026294,
0.0074799,
-0.0162357241,
-0.0455677845,
-0.0562126897,
0.0017456828,
-0.0999908373,
0.0496604331,
0.0071985391,
0.0611133091,
0.0188747942,
0.0011654572,
-0.0524193831,
0.0626713634,
-0.0003961538,
0.0063024634,
0.0157475993,
-0.0061461702,
0.0037504772,
-0.0000057353,
-0.0306245331,
-0.0094989948,
-0.0012051244,
0.0325484686,
0.0671257302,
-0.0041048522,
0.0110827247,
0.0233435947,
0.0005766765,
-0.0282338187,
0.0814638063,
0.0322552286,
0.0053615421,
0.0155865513,
-0.0231502336,
0.0388322547,
0.0472750999,
-0.0402534381,
0.0252282824,
-0.0107068177,
0.0069737448,
-0.0807692707,
-0.005486601,
0.040472094,
0.0895652771,
0.0214257799,
0.0423275009,
0.0119553041,
-0.0355583131,
-0.0611209236,
-0.0103799384,
-0.0400771834,
0.013991246,
-0.0376125909,
-0.0097305402,
0.036030069,
-0.0138498973,
-0.0240750909,
-0.0425459519,
-0.0313754603,
-0.0644599795,
0.0083986996,
0.0046711159,
0.0287440047,
0.0230103061,
-0.0308647007,
-0.0304489806,
0.0451762415,
-0.04751404,
-0.040095523,
0.0568166524,
0.0050623002,
-0.0483098179,
0.0107577825,
0.0207742099,
-0.0214889869,
-0.0321931243,
-0.0120332381,
0.0450527743,
-0.0263785906,
-0.0514813587,
0.0359746739,
0.0318891518,
0.0209323615,
0.0079440912,
-0.0143690398,
-0.0408330262,
-0.0137175014,
-0.0216032937,
-0.0250767171,
-0.0176741518,
-0.0255841166,
0.0591736697,
0.0354862325,
-0.0278338734,
-0.0134583218,
-0.0166222062,
0.034587469,
0.0190135613,
-0.0177488141,
0.0418952331,
0.026187066,
0.0541564524,
0.0191723797,
0.011889644,
0.0440335311,
-0.046970401,
0.0483996421,
-0.0291557163,
0.0150840888,
0.005103956,
-0.0458608828,
-0.0258512385,
0.0429724343,
-0.0336291008,
0.0057499167,
0.0195646677,
0.0326701291,
0.0895286798,
-0.0371085256,
0.0812886283,
-0.0479151011,
-0.0300359391,
0.0004361099,
0.0091534564,
0.009808558,
-0.0806707665,
-0.0229090136,
0.016761234,
-0.0267036296,
0.0473865569,
0.050167162,
0.0237651691,
0.0864203498,
-0.0177707635,
-0.0654783174,
-0.0051703816,
-0.0237192549,
0.0008411735,
-0.0109100789,
-0.0538863018,
0.0133965099,
-0.0958315283,
-0.0861950666,
0.0183531363,
-0.0029305979,
-0.0571217686,
-0.0111440765,
-0.0120479614,
0.0699556842,
0.0593188331,
-0.0134916836,
-0.0385074951,
-0.0046795448,
-0.0203949604,
0.0282149203,
0.0196753126,
-5.583830694e-33,
-0.0508647375,
-0.0149009246,
0.0229755379,
-0.0213450734,
0.0132456273,
0.0204149578,
-0.0306011122,
0.0533886068,
-0.0522551797,
0.0165640563,
-0.0137189636,
0.0249431822,
0.0097757867,
-0.0544959418,
-0.015687095,
0.0448610112,
0.0016632235,
0.0207513664,
-0.0285929535,
-0.0424960554,
0.0536879003,
0.0059585734,
0.0976817757,
-0.0357724242,
0.0322496034,
-0.00258806,
0.0158051383,
0.0579292215,
-0.0440429784,
0.0607978255,
0.0124113103,
0.0347537026,
0.0016393559,
-0.0305256899,
0.0010124323,
-0.0679079294,
-0.011299042,
-0.0364742726,
0.0461600833,
0.0334987789,
0.0141895767,
-0.0185579136,
0.0129782502,
-0.0168387294,
0.0084585315,
0.0149699654,
0.011685607,
-0.0174548998,
-0.0348626412,
0.024267558,
-0.0800342113,
0.0161165185,
0.0185780115,
0.0071659,
0.0229571033,
-0.0219222587,
0.0312510282,
-0.08726082,
-0.1001814678,
0.0166498609,
0.0212884527,
0.0650857091,
0.0361169986,
-0.0117213791,
0.0149975419,
0.0424980409,
0.0123058278,
0.0296987128,
0.0297872312,
0.0159847289,
0.0635184199,
0.0275270268,
0.0417529717,
0.0310250688,
-0.0317276679,
-0.000812276,
-0.0344100259,
-0.0100628873,
0.017375309,
0.0102860006,
0.0311807934,
0.028606588,
-0.0627372488,
-0.023896521,
-0.0455665588,
-0.0159908943,
-0.027352903,
-0.0362395868,
0.0460228212,
0.0268825628,
-0.0031528266,
-0.0218812581,
0.007665474,
-0.0398770571,
0.0201353282,
0.0351096913,
-0.0164901875,
0.0552626774,
-0.01755381,
0.0717985258,
-0.0606837086,
-0.0165703129,
-0.0271379352,
-0.013227866,
-0.0061240476,
0.022829948,
0.0026806756,
0.0236472748,
-0.0353886671,
0.0150762154,
-0.0045757699,
-0.018019516,
-0.0429290123,
-0.0465226658,
0.0164681636,
-0.0111702587,
0.0110975234,
0.0205723792,
0.1078786477,
0.0284774527,
-0.0131826922,
0.0257767458,
-0.001286046,
-0.0265017878,
-0.0079535423,
0.0085625956,
-0.0632270724,
0.0344979614,
0.0224860162,
-0.0238515064,
-0.0091794729,
-0.0301011186,
2.7e-7,
0.0652218089,
0.0344688259,
0.0240327213,
0.0269838274,
-0.0055051781,
0.0111794854,
-0.0276643485,
-0.0255030412,
0.0022977323,
-0.009898684,
0.0023587318,
-0.0024716426,
-0.0313981883,
0.0037302466,
-0.0900385901,
-0.0032932872,
-0.0359327309,
-0.0192390364,
-0.012962441,
0.0009711917,
-0.0746573657,
0.0580927953,
0.0185559858,
0.0357975848,
-0.0341673717,
-0.0818004534,
0.0207233392,
-0.0128374463,
-0.0042796335,
0.0547432974,
0.0723509192,
0.0328523777,
0.0144218281,
-0.0358224288,
0.0156411622,
0.0462591276,
0.0136519084,
0.0085668676,
0.0019568747,
0.0126768257,
-0.0204884913,
-0.0455380082,
-0.0269108489,
-0.0643613115,
0.0499257855,
0.0119051086,
-0.0078199217,
0.0121276043,
-0.0051857661,
0.0203807577,
-0.0174997225,
-0.0022736667,
0.0097576724,
-0.0127149001,
-0.0075080693,
-0.0037399733,
-0.0129671069,
-0.0684606954,
-0.0549927279,
0.045032233,
-0.0066277809,
-0.0203866847,
-0.0073860171,
-0.0484919958,
0.0068391217,
-0.0613534562,
0.0049165734,
2.567616698e-34,
-0.0335437097,
0.0125657655,
0.0328381881,
-0.0005399436,
0.0543664768,
-0.0229327157,
-0.0735023618,
-0.0123687629,
-0.0211948082,
-0.0433425419,
-0.0251493938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.01429v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.01429v1 | Chatmap : Large Language Model Interaction with Cartographic Data | 2023-09-28T15:32:36 | 2023-09-28T15:32:36 | Eren Unlu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The swift advancement and widespread availability of foundational Large
Language Models (LLMs), complemented by robust fine-tuning methodologies, have
catalyzed their adaptation for innovative and industrious applications.
Enabling LLMs to recognize and interpret geospatial data, while offering a
linguistic access to vast cartographic datasets, is of significant importance.
OpenStreetMap (OSM) is the most ambitious open-source global initiative
offering detailed urban and rural geographic data, curated by a community of
over 10 million contributors, which constitutes a great potential for LLM
applications. In this study, we demonstrate the proof of concept and details of
the process of fine-tuning a relatively small scale (1B parameters) LLM with a
relatively small artificial dataset curated by a more capable teacher model, in
order to provide a linguistic interface to the OSM data of an arbitrary urban
region. Through this interface, users can inquire about a location's
attributes, covering a wide spectrum of concepts, such as its touristic appeal
or the potential profitability of various businesses in that vicinity. The
study aims to provide an initial guideline for such generative artificial
intelligence (AI) adaptations and demonstrate early signs of useful emerging
abilities in this context even in minimal computational settings. The
embeddings of artificially curated prompts including OSM data are also
investigated in detail, which might be instrumental for potential geospatially
aware urban Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) applications. | [
0.0313432664,
0.0467801131,
-0.0287067872,
0.0402230881,
-0.0008090488,
-0.0013722414,
-0.0087228669,
-0.0244606584,
0.0374453515,
-0.029150974,
-0.0053230883,
0.0271688923,
-0.0053022648,
0.0309455264,
0.0141371619,
-0.0589520596,
0.0133974263,
-0.0245228037,
-0.0370474607,
0.0110183768,
-0.0136507787,
0.0231247395,
0.0150830727,
0.0559263714,
0.0143269133,
0.0142653128,
-0.0020809923,
0.021818772,
-0.0015771475,
-0.0355323963,
-0.0282205213,
0.0215055961,
0.0232667886,
0.0445872322,
0.0000019244,
-0.0288422927,
-0.0227496605,
0.0077293725,
0.0252926778,
-0.0195736233,
0.0462396219,
0.0364149846,
0.0059270449,
-0.0025784054,
-0.0398692489,
-0.0335937664,
0.0648365617,
0.00216205,
0.0662019253,
0.0541656949,
-0.0047565922,
-0.0780243278,
-0.0039998689,
0.0169473719,
0.0159577671,
0.0121928034,
0.0210700426,
-0.0213254802,
0.0392344743,
0.0848232433,
-0.0018491804,
0.0069817109,
0.0041435719,
-0.0193181057,
0.0047761444,
0.0448807329,
-0.052719593,
-0.0094985748,
0.0054054945,
0.060346622,
0.0187217463,
-0.0230687,
0.0279431064,
0.0174415912,
-0.0067538121,
0.0091850767,
-0.0790221542,
-0.0215972681,
0.0094426163,
0.0669116676,
-0.0182739664,
-0.0252618343,
0.0137653146,
0.06655287,
-0.0274292398,
0.0703009441,
-0.0003426542,
-0.0231740084,
-0.059302181,
0.0133053483,
-0.0227212496,
-0.0281962827,
-0.0048996867,
0.0745494515,
-0.0268800054,
0.0055592018,
0.0122122392,
0.0292738602,
0.0331726,
-0.0399253517,
0.0241472609,
0.0202855896,
-0.0555330962,
0.040932972,
0.0087812617,
0.0190935247,
0.0081912149,
0.0377020203,
-0.0197283253,
-0.0258340202,
-0.0517427847,
-0.0078906408,
-0.0501404554,
0.0129215196,
-0.0627048984,
0.0140607925,
-0.0082933437,
0.0386751331,
0.0043387092,
0.0172842592,
-0.0315086655,
0.0253635924,
-0.0076426137,
-0.0294745453,
-0.020931717,
-0.0087401355,
-0.0316872746,
-0.0111455405,
0.0228603482,
-0.0384656265,
0.0358787514,
0.015528623,
0.038486246,
0.0142377941,
-0.0380751453,
0.0191640649,
0.0316166617,
0.0108227842,
-0.0600289293,
-0.0138180954,
-0.0198516678,
-0.0232939702,
0.0075940527,
-0.0987279266,
-0.0121998005,
0.0192380548,
-0.0272268653,
-0.0364308953,
-0.0165856481,
0.03138192,
-0.0545933805,
0.0391003229,
-0.0504590869,
0.0363678597,
0.0746793523,
-0.0149235968,
0.0594216436,
0.0692540258,
0.0134252524,
0.0911643356,
0.0626965985,
0.0176909864,
0.0161842443,
0.0301806219,
-0.0008517271,
0.005559966,
-0.0306540914,
0.0141217448,
-0.0321824029,
0.0291637965,
-0.0127898529,
0.0741343796,
-0.0297440663,
0.0333935805,
0.0595390275,
0.039524354,
0.0096565699,
0.0251735728,
0.0750341117,
0.077499181,
-0.0211790092,
-0.0324580744,
-0.0259909164,
-0.0209026709,
-0.0271705594,
0.01757342,
0.0073754797,
0.0516165346,
-0.0014672225,
-0.0344802774,
-0.0179719571,
0.0093488814,
0.0329697728,
0.0059011658,
0.065648742,
-0.0206664931,
0.0166962966,
-0.0040514851,
0.0238028951,
-0.001648883,
0.0312964767,
-0.0517860949,
0.0288889874,
0.0496076494,
0.0156705882,
0.010059651,
0.0387587696,
0.0057191285,
0.0208701361,
0.0403063782,
0.0631259158,
-0.0151116652,
-0.030467052,
-0.0654274076,
-0.0160619803,
0.0339595377,
0.0189549625,
-0.0102112452,
0.0268438254,
0.008832722,
0.0574946143,
-0.0350247435,
-0.0394145548,
-0.0033885571,
0.0495331287,
-0.0368382148,
-0.0146422815,
0.0399822183,
-0.0400603227,
0.023647273,
-0.0155173708,
0.0171442218,
0.0234965049,
-0.0056461114,
0.0069538648,
0.0106711313,
-0.0139877759,
-0.000005385,
-0.0000117301,
0.0074163489,
0.002780837,
-0.0062861559,
-0.0500226729,
-0.037868619,
-0.023034798,
-0.0498162471,
0.0492082089,
-0.0455194563,
0.0230848324,
0.0045018508,
0.0175880101,
-0.0734401271,
0.0596311688,
0.0049000653,
-0.0065095634,
0.0372451507,
0.0603140555,
0.0352937281,
-0.014989214,
-0.0166543853,
-0.0211746357,
-0.0188974719,
0.0291945431,
0.0026556856,
0.0301434975,
-0.0232669059,
-0.0556663759,
-0.1152652279,
-0.0132212928,
-0.0061898818,
0.0102509437,
-0.0159682352,
-0.006927948,
-0.0280951578,
-0.0242301971,
-0.0138711184,
0.0498048216,
0.0274617895,
0.0173928253,
0.0329167433,
-0.0206530597,
0.0047252839,
0.0048379055,
0.0003346688,
-0.001376173,
0.0362434275,
0.0180798657,
-0.0195796769,
-0.0241502095,
-0.020468073,
-0.0378694683,
0.0089161424,
0.0269872509,
-0.0315110385,
0.0136229135,
-0.0417196862,
0.0457525142,
0.0102305962,
0.0033554777,
0.0052919271,
0.0206817482,
-0.0410421267,
-0.0731269717,
0.015474244,
-0.0459277891,
-0.051113598,
-0.0115200654,
-0.0248164814,
-0.0102789989,
0.0059324382,
-0.0270905066,
-0.0107760075,
-0.0124633461,
0.0439429097,
-0.0193225201,
0.003787593,
-0.0286332294,
0.0496798195,
0.0005693574,
0.0895311758,
-0.0573227257,
-0.0860094503,
0.0334236361,
-0.0326087847,
-0.006058313,
-0.0065362537,
0.0062887562,
-0.0528781042,
0.0743396133,
-0.0083451467,
0.0346899554,
0.017879419,
-0.0248355549,
0.0045586396,
-0.0161914434,
-0.0471590459,
-0.0380962938,
0.0087510794,
-0.0377040245,
0.0039386959,
-0.0014390037,
-0.0718666613,
-0.0350222103,
-0.0252598729,
-0.015026059,
0.0030576428,
0.0423997529,
-0.0106330225,
0.0250892751,
0.0610358827,
-0.01597213,
0.0410826392,
-0.0142601207,
-0.0226952489,
-0.0272314474,
0.0130176432,
0.064364545,
0.0999544114,
-0.0138566121,
0.0498878844,
-0.032420978,
-0.009166359,
-0.0119492188,
-0.0094584581,
-0.0114475787,
0.0361908153,
0.05353567,
-0.0220739171,
-0.0302101392,
0.0445632525,
0.0150528615,
-0.0517776161,
-0.0713439956,
0.0906838626,
0.048509758,
-0.0412150919,
-0.003442859,
-0.0389435478,
0.0142333452,
0.0314308442,
0.0753360912,
-0.0748131201,
0.0215484072,
-0.0063660387,
-0.0006909719,
-0.0197708327,
-0.0132023031,
-0.0077388203,
-0.148584038,
0.0866393223,
-0.0017498749,
-0.0498369113,
-0.0082338555,
-0.0550359786,
-0.0436451472,
0.0091089476,
-0.0393053778,
-0.0259832237,
-0.0085425396,
-0.0040215747,
0.0294376407,
-0.0234316625,
-0.04455778,
-0.0350858346,
-0.0713828206,
0.0750187039,
0.0309406817,
0.0766699761,
0.0048724907,
-0.0361515619,
-0.0224462803,
0.0570343509,
0.0446987227,
-0.0448092744,
-0.0103822639,
0.0147061059,
-0.0177446771,
-0.0192789473,
0.0000121161,
-0.0175928809,
-0.0140573047,
0.0176088363,
0.0448607057,
-0.0326182917,
0.0511626899,
-0.0521551594,
0.0366258211,
0.0299653262,
0.0050492934,
0.0241547935,
0.0039405739,
-0.022467522,
-0.0490399525,
-0.0226117987,
-0.0288565904,
-0.0208290443,
0.0304394029,
-0.0019070356,
-0.0440771915,
-0.0452732369,
-0.0407273881,
0.0081038205,
0.0325082988,
0.0109124556,
-0.0095693916,
0.0138149159,
-0.0190209206,
-0.0282296706,
0.0269265939,
-0.0383906439,
-0.0152748823,
-0.0402083583,
-0.0119254645,
0.0481888279,
-0.0854303017,
-0.0174612813,
0.018296415,
-0.0517863669,
-0.0605295375,
0.0173828825,
0.0415025689,
0.0201477073,
-0.0057366625,
-0.0499897636,
-0.0683141202,
0.0637489855,
0.04792355,
-0.0243010428,
-0.0438689403,
-0.0211442076,
0.0534631647,
0.0247143358,
0.0026485121,
-0.0490026809,
0.0553054363,
0.0110407341,
0.0052311779,
-0.0246589333,
0.0091237109,
0.0150983399,
0.0276091788,
0.094539538,
0.0002114827,
0.0058323424,
-0.0518491082,
-0.0231732875,
-0.024348719,
-0.0184157938,
-0.0055478476,
-0.0009048037,
0.0226322487,
0.0298467521,
-0.0091389073,
-0.0132821929,
0.0117009897,
0.0206051804,
-0.0308130924,
-0.0030610056,
-0.0102084791,
-0.001761641,
-0.0041026282,
0.0308862906,
-0.0368627124,
0.0432396606,
-0.0259278156,
0.0375410318,
-0.0125807701,
0.0317477062,
-0.0017304183,
0.0001625541,
-0.0223979,
0.0395560227,
-0.0077837761,
-0.0661337823,
-0.0209774766,
0.0648676306,
0.063718982,
0.0181250367,
0.0113359923,
-0.0098283933,
-0.0094396034,
-0.0217114519,
0.006471769,
0.0362542123,
-0.0934688821,
0.0020479762,
-0.0002644224,
-0.0465542749,
-0.0031320732,
0.0220716111,
0.0020217435,
-0.001370216,
-0.0032132443,
-0.0479286127,
-0.0134591209,
-0.0215853397,
0.0044318759,
0.0287645068,
-0.0196060278,
0.0071014012,
-0.036852397,
-0.0458958223,
-0.0166012254,
0.0210546013,
-0.0134772882,
0.0121743167,
0.0119841881,
0.0516833812,
-0.0080284504,
-0.0141048525,
-0.0609442219,
-0.0132197831,
-0.0725520402,
-0.010234993,
0.004525424,
-6.03455637e-33,
-0.0336857438,
-0.0625626147,
0.0843918473,
-0.0086391214,
-0.016409073,
-0.0177967735,
-0.0190588254,
-0.0208120495,
-0.0217523612,
-0.0290150158,
-0.0263420288,
-0.0419174992,
0.0219772793,
0.0456605516,
0.0075492845,
0.0277222563,
0.0360905379,
0.037524879,
-0.0191465095,
0.0152761526,
0.0357701257,
0.0024689701,
0.0127359247,
-0.0571518838,
-0.0083514601,
-0.0408823192,
-0.0352291465,
0.0474096164,
0.0095465118,
0.0951356813,
-0.0132551938,
0.0770652592,
0.0339897126,
-0.0216692369,
-0.0303383786,
0.0308503527,
-0.0480116941,
-0.02353031,
-0.0019775808,
0.0165368952,
0.0076245177,
-0.051012028,
0.0577029735,
-0.0101713352,
-0.0144457603,
0.0370340683,
0.0426696055,
-0.0249609556,
-0.0500206128,
-0.0003564944,
-0.0644452497,
0.0260389298,
0.0075944699,
0.0015175365,
0.0019375689,
-0.0060716933,
0.0022648065,
0.0226755049,
-0.0006075802,
0.0477792323,
0.0583666898,
0.0041135834,
0.0520785116,
0.0386648923,
0.0078360941,
0.0426653177,
0.0121304058,
-0.0091603631,
-0.0274348091,
-0.0292937662,
0.0545465797,
0.0627647415,
-0.0341013484,
0.0722325295,
-0.004915351,
-0.0443295613,
-0.0247338954,
0.0361580215,
0.0101309642,
0.0035424833,
0.0098102158,
0.0108339963,
-0.0450238176,
-0.0327010602,
-0.044576887,
-0.0349956602,
-0.0448819883,
-0.0370513499,
0.0424264558,
0.0160151068,
-0.012747217,
0.0642420575,
0.01721997,
-0.0572722293,
-0.0262398291,
-0.0220578108,
-0.0099853044,
-0.0081163282,
-0.0481767058,
0.0399289802,
-0.0562175177,
-0.0903755873,
0.0139363576,
-0.0020570669,
-0.0376976356,
0.0487433262,
-0.0127448775,
0.021893058,
-0.0381483398,
0.0135556459,
-0.0150580294,
-0.0234885886,
-0.015007752,
-0.0261479821,
0.0409449004,
-0.0287809446,
-0.0114525873,
0.0249534138,
0.0398711041,
0.0319839641,
0.0115526048,
-0.0873054191,
0.0058614002,
0.0026322964,
-0.0012276819,
0.0349154957,
0.0016565516,
-0.0179285295,
0.0109119546,
-0.027021829,
-0.0125030791,
0.0038021544,
2.799e-7,
0.0227563288,
0.096898675,
0.0041807801,
0.0086603425,
-0.0113363527,
-0.0115840724,
0.0316757932,
-0.0005852602,
-0.0215153005,
0.0620822124,
0.023375487,
0.0323798843,
0.0504667126,
0.0279364977,
-0.1034408361,
0.0698811337,
-0.0690546557,
-0.0098194703,
-0.1106048226,
0.0090845115,
0.0713208988,
0.0806662589,
0.006907424,
-0.0038117436,
0.0276428424,
-0.0198273472,
0.009461456,
-0.0529565774,
-0.014914888,
0.0371771716,
0.0170389377,
0.0439329334,
0.0210839882,
-0.0354306102,
0.0051575685,
-0.0031079175,
0.037136279,
0.0446199439,
-0.0019464002,
-0.003760322,
0.0339117646,
-0.0839768574,
-0.0024407413,
-0.1067115813,
0.0496937744,
-0.0557052009,
-0.0087814564,
-0.0002563638,
0.0071286093,
-0.0187018905,
0.0004878979,
-0.0466258936,
-0.0183769763,
-0.0289965421,
0.0146244029,
-0.0098557761,
0.0022018552,
-0.066616632,
0.0089233629,
-0.0032375134,
-0.0253451783,
-0.057229083,
-0.0414119661,
0.0101696709,
0.01286342,
-0.0045926771,
0.0207517743,
2.362165311e-34,
-0.0095339632,
0.0226944257,
-0.0188294202,
-0.0028161877,
0.0702648982,
0.0219192803,
0.0291837454,
0.0214767028,
-0.003270698,
-0.0663705021,
-0.0186332427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16511v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16511v1 | Toloka Visual Question Answering Benchmark | 2023-09-28T15:18:35 | 2023-09-28T15:18:35 | Dmitry Ustalov, Nikita Pavlichenko, Sergey Koshelev, Daniil Likhobaba, Alisa Smirnova | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, 68-11, C.4 | In this paper, we present Toloka Visual Question Answering, a new
crowdsourced dataset allowing comparing performance of machine learning systems
against human level of expertise in the grounding visual question answering
task. In this task, given an image and a textual question, one has to draw the
bounding box around the object correctly responding to that question. Every
image-question pair contains the response, with only one correct response per
image. Our dataset contains 45,199 pairs of images and questions in English,
provided with ground truth bounding boxes, split into train and two test
subsets. Besides describing the dataset and releasing it under a CC BY license,
we conducted a series of experiments on open source zero-shot baseline models
and organized a multi-phase competition at WSDM Cup that attracted 48
participants worldwide. However, by the time of paper submission, no machine
learning model outperformed the non-expert crowdsourcing baseline according to
the intersection over union evaluation score. | [
0.0131952874,
0.0451846458,
-0.0084068291,
0.0537835211,
-0.0110455081,
0.0080085164,
0.0109713608,
0.0188436527,
0.0065629808,
-0.0353214405,
-0.0353502259,
0.0054705311,
0.0096470211,
0.0218679458,
0.0341113508,
-0.0623265132,
0.0201366171,
-0.0052726837,
-0.0553628728,
-0.0107555706,
0.0224436224,
-0.0185899958,
0.0095635094,
0.0414255597,
-0.0221676212,
-0.0208451021,
-0.0028654605,
0.0021551449,
0.0332859047,
-0.0337838978,
0.0114367418,
0.0399969071,
0.0142540615,
0.0050908588,
0.0000019106,
-0.0190751124,
0.0263916515,
0.0029744303,
-0.0060269311,
-0.0009355558,
-0.0376787595,
-0.0342328772,
0.0309006497,
-0.0037994746,
-0.0666732788,
0.0228948891,
0.0474053062,
0.017932646,
0.1057962924,
0.03668347,
-0.0050986866,
0.0065989615,
0.0313695855,
-0.0042288764,
0.0454231463,
-0.0547357202,
0.0000325221,
0.0384162962,
-0.0028988395,
-0.0368825123,
-0.0455901064,
0.022552805,
0.0441871509,
0.0179878157,
-0.0003363041,
0.0191696044,
-0.0810591578,
-0.0179375466,
-0.0021796564,
0.1124341637,
0.0337183326,
-0.0284816585,
-0.0304003935,
0.0120816985,
-0.0053136093,
0.0008733263,
-0.0652860403,
0.0264407396,
-0.0143789193,
0.0204085577,
-0.081541948,
0.0177568458,
-0.0361313634,
0.0086945351,
0.0292835124,
0.0346923433,
0.0033669579,
0.0245887544,
-0.0039298893,
0.0459014662,
-0.0418634862,
-0.0597913153,
-0.0251956694,
0.0333029889,
-0.0104423622,
-0.0258000717,
-0.033297807,
-0.0469070673,
0.0038415554,
-0.0227318499,
0.0449265279,
-0.0003374995,
-0.0523731224,
0.08013767,
-0.03381823,
0.0327839255,
-0.01897249,
0.0587395802,
-0.0312282294,
-0.0292454325,
-0.0184577387,
-0.0120269023,
-0.0504217371,
0.0037474148,
-0.0667731091,
-0.0278388876,
-0.0007993553,
-0.0115990266,
-0.0390281603,
0.0007559426,
0.0058045704,
0.0868930072,
-0.0024961596,
-0.0236476865,
-0.0507045351,
0.0326532237,
-0.0842405707,
0.0189031176,
-0.0139331231,
-0.0608027354,
-0.0008920174,
0.0039894297,
0.0117716426,
-0.0017219697,
0.0258226711,
0.0290523302,
-0.0274171587,
-0.0109440945,
-0.0362548716,
-0.0080695767,
0.0342847817,
-0.0277350452,
0.0219374839,
-0.064533174,
0.0347885303,
-0.0112503916,
-0.0103907501,
-0.0061990176,
-0.0075040297,
0.0496399477,
-0.0177621357,
0.08951094,
-0.0341916084,
-0.0128814885,
0.0304499939,
0.0026365072,
-0.0076980209,
0.0717954561,
0.006249839,
0.0471927822,
0.0640448853,
-0.0012556894,
0.0510390811,
0.0288957767,
0.0243944712,
0.0132520059,
-0.0196400173,
0.0615606606,
-0.0254415534,
0.0120033985,
0.0197398197,
0.0236493368,
-0.0156561583,
-0.0759353489,
0.0620631538,
0.0463175066,
-0.0652567223,
-0.0051884926,
-0.0145078739,
0.0082578799,
0.0405217484,
-0.0188020542,
-0.0263362844,
0.0530005321,
-0.0286421701,
-0.0057502883,
-0.0158150289,
-0.0077078454,
-0.0414763354,
-0.0254693311,
0.0074705603,
0.01048283,
0.0010466652,
0.0370129608,
0.0624842159,
0.0307985246,
-0.0391161591,
0.0248819552,
-0.0052205482,
-0.0051510013,
-0.0200555325,
-0.0232115202,
0.084564127,
-0.0135509083,
0.0273878425,
-0.0268948581,
-0.0007801249,
0.0061007608,
0.0622117892,
0.0354959182,
-0.0205177888,
0.0019894701,
0.0249339342,
-0.0163563155,
-0.0310046747,
-0.0026422159,
-0.0201034341,
0.0166246723,
0.0413442776,
-0.0065105446,
0.0035313754,
-0.0476427414,
0.0250948556,
0.0436883308,
0.0432291366,
0.0094632367,
-0.0140721872,
0.0318327881,
0.00526912,
-0.0078730443,
-0.0219854042,
-0.0113034649,
0.0257780124,
-0.0273376666,
-0.0063592745,
-0.0251356903,
-0.0031255956,
-0.0041679949,
0.0287663136,
-0.1241290942,
-0.0395741016,
0.0835099667,
-0.0324973874,
-0.0010250969,
-0.0044115065,
0.0011657831,
-0.0360694006,
-0.0350404978,
-0.0485548899,
0.0144189512,
0.0143572791,
-0.0030469245,
0.0298016351,
-0.0051606284,
-0.0183015149,
-0.0036840558,
-0.0250174049,
0.0466288291,
-0.0507256128,
-0.0186711513,
-0.0345235541,
-0.0118753733,
0.0253831595,
-0.0076823705,
0.0219579581,
-0.0687894225,
0.0431565531,
-0.0930150896,
-0.0000196477,
-0.0081883669,
-0.0375345051,
0.018774556,
-0.0353637747,
-0.0082034776,
-0.0588190593,
-0.0579375178,
0.0265177302,
0.0200485513,
0.0086016282,
0.0615240633,
0.0181084014,
0.0365417898,
-0.0527650602,
-0.0237035211,
0.0114951851,
0.046715606,
0.0316117778,
0.0128898844,
0.0012635719,
0.0086986059,
-0.0432011411,
0.0625831187,
-0.0030538433,
-0.0443786867,
0.0272153877,
-0.0068059009,
-0.0256992318,
0.0782303587,
-0.0124203051,
-0.0249092504,
-0.0180488005,
0.01612016,
-0.0196441505,
-0.0031734463,
0.0330435112,
-0.0670072362,
0.0137060499,
-0.0256014783,
0.0094878478,
0.0032725767,
-0.0098505234,
-0.0118804257,
-0.0575433113,
0.0461616442,
0.0062600588,
-0.0136521328,
-0.1133705601,
0.0238962863,
0.0155692203,
0.0918643698,
-0.0679973811,
-0.074075453,
0.0451207012,
-0.0273230541,
-0.0102744298,
0.0337469876,
0.0296973828,
-0.0467124581,
0.0810647979,
0.0297579672,
0.0165717006,
-0.0361211151,
0.0304308645,
-0.0611259788,
-0.0096092839,
0.0289537515,
-0.0135630183,
0.0294267181,
-0.0251000691,
0.0097712623,
-0.0506147631,
-0.0466715917,
-0.0326817892,
-0.0555030294,
-0.0346131027,
-0.0118931998,
-0.026816003,
-0.0258881301,
-0.0031819346,
0.0028447264,
-0.0062229359,
-0.0104363821,
0.0023875365,
-0.0100035127,
-0.0006315752,
0.0635011196,
0.0754539669,
0.050527256,
-0.0009472223,
-0.0148652224,
0.0135679292,
0.0499867089,
0.048511371,
0.0139839808,
-0.0364261158,
0.0326827392,
0.0118981553,
0.0344950967,
0.0160012152,
0.0170027073,
0.0517843515,
-0.0279859193,
0.0199937597,
0.0527709462,
0.0212182906,
0.0026799897,
-0.0405789465,
-0.0281009711,
0.0047694389,
0.0548209772,
0.0351749957,
-0.0924229771,
-0.0383409634,
-0.0120814499,
0.0362907648,
0.0220891796,
-0.0228146501,
0.0252959449,
-0.1424330473,
0.0611056127,
-0.007084846,
-0.0582845844,
-0.0289329477,
-0.0069075809,
-0.0114158457,
-0.0206399113,
-0.0164469164,
-0.0297614411,
0.0078563625,
0.0149056781,
0.0020105604,
0.0086801685,
0.0016305868,
0.054372929,
-0.0610646307,
0.0185909346,
0.0336556919,
-0.0092400275,
-0.029387895,
-0.0923735276,
-0.019992888,
0.0023397086,
-0.0046891291,
0.024118837,
0.0922486261,
0.0005709097,
-0.0749398395,
-0.012956758,
0.0401036479,
-0.0273175985,
0.0075350176,
0.0100831743,
0.041105561,
0.0380678847,
-0.0009055379,
-0.0319998041,
0.0112336222,
-0.0289678928,
0.0324451029,
0.0434780568,
-0.0374972001,
-0.0606552474,
-0.0095776338,
-0.0016829842,
-0.0767638534,
-0.0295034647,
0.0313391611,
0.0362666734,
-0.0257860292,
-0.1050476953,
-0.0289107542,
0.0887853354,
0.0757211,
-0.024924973,
-0.025280185,
-0.0386544243,
0.0136078792,
-0.0498305261,
0.0798408091,
-0.0181781482,
0.0313374251,
-0.0709668994,
0.0063923048,
-0.0085371612,
-0.0168320667,
-0.0475260392,
0.0344119594,
-0.0597217716,
-0.0044247732,
-0.0245154407,
0.1029913425,
0.016977163,
0.0110098962,
0.0115265073,
-0.0324913487,
0.00453152,
0.0519422814,
0.0167008378,
0.0091069546,
-0.0057320818,
0.0019227352,
-0.0148216793,
0.0063876645,
-0.0335562564,
0.0093677863,
0.0199039467,
-0.0206460822,
-0.0211885404,
-0.0032042048,
0.0163829084,
0.0490221381,
0.0502155013,
0.0048647327,
0.0084539047,
0.0124712968,
0.0101368846,
0.0181972664,
-0.0122484844,
-0.0641716868,
-0.0335626677,
0.0280457009,
-0.0483039953,
0.0072713695,
0.0135831134,
0.004817958,
0.0241355635,
-0.0311274175,
-0.0038915533,
0.0679419562,
0.0413347483,
-0.0147274379,
0.0146948425,
0.0048382902,
-0.0301089846,
0.0052750995,
0.0745758712,
0.0311831217,
0.0533708856,
0.0210503414,
-0.0001020921,
-0.0284604449,
0.0240034834,
-0.0129212113,
-0.0568767451,
-0.0263988525,
0.0624185503,
0.0546281748,
0.0160352979,
-0.0261089336,
0.0273075998,
-0.0358683132,
0.0007103459,
-0.0134332515,
-0.0101649892,
-0.0280796476,
0.0522364564,
0.0344464593,
0.0114439595,
0.0056065838,
0.0700863376,
0.0315311663,
0.020108318,
-0.0046993466,
-0.0089406874,
-0.0300666466,
0.040394064,
0.032133732,
-0.0203784499,
0.037411496,
0.0494119823,
-0.0388556272,
-0.0607798249,
-0.0154360216,
0.0824846476,
0.0061118882,
0.0330868252,
0.0468494445,
0.0161510799,
0.0547799878,
0.0051770592,
-0.0154393055,
0.0190387294,
-0.0532758236,
-0.0013860767,
-0.025092965,
-6.33786881e-33,
-0.0494295098,
-0.0434438884,
0.0139187472,
-0.0287029296,
-0.0049534594,
0.00411645,
-0.0101436973,
-0.0006528102,
-0.0424046367,
0.0172824189,
-0.0278875623,
0.0009290736,
0.0037654603,
0.0239880625,
-0.0037953169,
-0.0455280095,
0.0103355777,
-0.0305433609,
-0.0159298368,
-0.0180611424,
-0.0124799749,
0.0072940844,
0.0176190101,
-0.0202508122,
-0.0079169599,
-0.025845537,
-0.0282342006,
0.0050854874,
-0.0037098138,
0.0418151207,
-0.0143907489,
0.0209709797,
0.0342109688,
0.0006854135,
-0.002079247,
0.0162236243,
-0.0867105201,
-0.0129861841,
0.0032436629,
0.0204079989,
-0.0937560871,
0.0503677726,
0.0318682902,
0.002464826,
0.0238163397,
-0.0239203908,
0.0497638509,
-0.0165669229,
-0.011180901,
0.0073349136,
0.0112681519,
-0.0013458999,
-0.0264393501,
-0.0589993335,
-0.0201843493,
0.0503124781,
0.009371832,
0.0278305206,
-0.0492855422,
-0.0131950984,
-0.0141055649,
-0.0042765299,
0.0746084303,
0.0406769365,
0.0112156486,
0.0510549918,
0.034300562,
-0.0135806473,
-0.0443082489,
-0.0308203828,
0.0013447239,
0.0615951307,
0.1028053015,
0.0855013058,
0.0478905253,
-0.0037918612,
-0.0402188972,
0.0791088641,
-0.0510066263,
0.0518632345,
-0.058651112,
-0.0097124251,
-0.0108904652,
0.0121156741,
-0.0484377593,
-0.0272407308,
-0.0523067154,
0.0145335067,
0.0715478435,
0.0051971199,
-0.0461407453,
-0.0090374229,
0.0211150534,
-0.0507887006,
0.0322452784,
0.0193523467,
-0.0157978442,
0.058887627,
0.0253759231,
0.024328962,
-0.0251140147,
0.0288405865,
0.0210155901,
0.0183488745,
0.0119211245,
0.0102726836,
0.0486351736,
-0.0006250867,
-0.0442874245,
0.0087059224,
-0.0350115448,
0.0260362495,
-0.032148622,
0.0144491829,
0.0238800868,
0.0108478097,
-0.0329940468,
-0.007549413,
-0.0432205983,
-0.0060566566,
-0.0091054989,
-0.0257350598,
-0.012484937,
-0.0069341874,
-0.0107830819,
0.0110679446,
-0.0345946178,
-0.0167077966,
0.0146441432,
-0.0314360447,
-0.0157336909,
0.0163556263,
2.472e-7,
0.0287423339,
0.0054217121,
0.0414376333,
0.050020352,
-0.0187872127,
0.0378200375,
-0.0411676019,
0.0251144841,
0.0144357085,
-0.0276291668,
-0.0108427471,
0.0250789877,
0.0379899293,
0.0061157877,
-0.0395823605,
0.0303565394,
-0.0473583713,
0.0102938339,
-0.0268304516,
-0.0148485424,
0.0437388904,
0.0480475947,
0.0010426907,
-0.0246659964,
0.0413876027,
-0.0729696676,
0.0702045336,
-0.0467367619,
0.0232735854,
-0.0423816554,
0.0126864994,
0.0324642323,
-0.0008952928,
0.0261507798,
-0.0059194895,
-0.0094476799,
0.0558672845,
-0.0126830591,
-0.0268269163,
-0.0298295952,
-0.0391995274,
0.0129503999,
0.0029871541,
-0.0466001183,
0.093293488,
-0.0380640514,
-0.0345622525,
-0.0297706556,
-0.0639541745,
-0.0188915934,
0.041428037,
-0.0090403492,
-0.027385857,
-0.0053284196,
0.0405358821,
-0.0498435237,
0.0012715126,
-0.0505520813,
-0.002212238,
-0.0265224688,
-0.0381814241,
0.0079174312,
-0.0575588346,
0.0143952919,
0.008877798,
0.017301973,
-0.0610561855,
1.387209378e-34,
0.0246804208,
-0.029400669,
0.0359428935,
0.0055462089,
0.0159570035,
-0.0108995754,
-0.0155087952,
-0.0460987054,
0.0198928062,
-0.0266239457,
0.0161142386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16459v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16459v1 | Augmenting LLMs with Knowledge: A survey on hallucination prevention | 2023-09-28T14:09:58 | 2023-09-28T14:09:58 | Konstantinos Andriopoulos, Johan Pouwelse | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large pre-trained language models have demonstrated their proficiency in
storing factual knowledge within their parameters and achieving remarkable
results when fine-tuned for downstream natural language processing tasks.
Nonetheless, their capacity to access and manipulate knowledge with precision
remains constrained, resulting in performance disparities on
knowledge-intensive tasks when compared to task-specific architectures.
Additionally, the challenges of providing provenance for model decisions and
maintaining up-to-date world knowledge persist as open research frontiers. To
address these limitations, the integration of pre-trained models with
differentiable access mechanisms to explicit non-parametric memory emerges as a
promising solution. This survey delves into the realm of language models (LMs)
augmented with the ability to tap into external knowledge sources, including
external knowledge bases and search engines. While adhering to the standard
objective of predicting missing tokens, these augmented LMs leverage diverse,
possibly non-parametric external modules to augment their contextual processing
capabilities, departing from the conventional language modeling paradigm.
Through an exploration of current advancements in augmenting large language
models with knowledge, this work concludes that this emerging research
direction holds the potential to address prevalent issues in traditional LMs,
such as hallucinations, un-grounded responses, and scalability challenges. | [
0.0485388637,
0.0559433959,
-0.0168595463,
0.0437134169,
-0.0245170034,
0.009028607,
-0.0196349751,
-0.0136993034,
0.0277144387,
-0.0661251619,
-0.0595161319,
-0.0472040921,
-0.0469901562,
0.019330468,
0.0323639959,
-0.012425622,
0.0773041993,
-0.0414557569,
-0.016293684,
-0.0112482086,
-0.029845586,
-0.0031237898,
0.0134252692,
0.0248718634,
-0.021886507,
-0.0074586938,
-0.0181124769,
0.0050382838,
-0.0125041977,
-0.0032706531,
0.006482569,
0.0549617968,
0.0092369532,
0.0716973841,
0.0000021494,
-0.0482655242,
-0.0266269166,
-0.0151271727,
-0.0500988588,
-0.0107853273,
-0.0060969568,
0.0380059704,
-0.0022914724,
-0.0144883143,
-0.0514483415,
-0.0163857173,
0.0423045419,
0.0214061495,
0.0323945247,
0.0562610254,
0.001866553,
-0.0143391797,
0.0474566184,
0.0051696156,
0.0680850223,
0.0143490639,
0.0440447927,
-0.0178781394,
-0.0089435261,
-0.034322165,
-0.0215959679,
0.066872254,
0.0330250598,
0.0064216792,
0.0036591999,
0.0482026637,
-0.0604876243,
-0.0150449621,
-0.0146713527,
0.0464201942,
-0.0438729115,
-0.0569571182,
-0.0059451843,
-0.0004459647,
-0.0065176627,
0.0041703302,
-0.0431737863,
0.0149155864,
0.0158730559,
0.0205577984,
0.0134453289,
-0.0032950598,
0.0630790889,
0.038528692,
-0.03207279,
0.0824908838,
0.0319149382,
-0.0346223935,
0.0181834567,
0.0256910603,
-0.0298864041,
-0.0480813049,
0.0370316617,
0.0337076187,
-0.0148012247,
0.0355023816,
-0.0369378291,
-0.0144566819,
0.0339922942,
-0.0667940378,
-0.0075723198,
0.024026705,
-0.0776752979,
0.0553579554,
-0.0734790117,
0.0104245301,
-0.0320905298,
0.0638218299,
0.0000024341,
-0.023869684,
-0.0160963461,
-0.0420614146,
-0.0163130816,
0.0554155856,
-0.0083705885,
-0.0107219638,
0.0005294274,
0.0376938246,
-0.0081076119,
0.0065350886,
-0.0002437925,
0.0265480857,
0.0158617646,
-0.0359519757,
-0.0501675755,
-0.00426534,
0.0102782017,
0.0084705418,
0.0070362245,
-0.0916275382,
-0.0177375749,
0.0060862997,
-0.0079604601,
-0.0302225221,
0.0311831255,
0.0543239787,
0.0333489738,
-0.0483413264,
-0.0576237068,
-0.0234664809,
-0.0149674555,
-0.0657864213,
0.0158847515,
-0.0391128063,
0.0279397629,
0.0031418558,
-0.0269713309,
-0.0413688682,
0.0268977489,
0.0317056961,
-0.0383939445,
0.0846442133,
-0.0340836868,
-0.0184448306,
0.0107677123,
0.0282377601,
0.0153676961,
0.0601184405,
-0.0087388186,
0.0235127974,
0.0472703986,
0.0040602339,
0.0288681109,
0.0257135443,
0.0394999571,
-0.0162563417,
-0.0566291399,
0.0259090718,
0.0176511873,
-0.0037050187,
0.0145104146,
0.0462200418,
-0.0079108123,
-0.0321358517,
0.0646222234,
0.0414665639,
-0.0043585515,
0.0163454972,
0.0623991266,
-0.0510802828,
0.0042688376,
-0.0044185207,
-0.090979144,
0.0209037624,
-0.0332255363,
-0.001979107,
0.0549960025,
0.0167104714,
-0.0230718311,
-0.0384948291,
0.0075923721,
-0.0228797235,
0.0064610839,
0.0333864838,
0.0460698903,
0.0029577995,
-0.0389088616,
0.0886745378,
0.0248059724,
-0.0224433094,
0.0270437542,
-0.0513226688,
0.0005105927,
0.090306662,
0.0615251623,
-0.0709880292,
-0.0280448012,
0.0042467485,
0.0139946463,
0.0639768541,
0.004362361,
0.0141433319,
0.031307783,
-0.0480211489,
-0.0048406436,
0.0112841427,
0.0356885046,
0.0185947176,
0.0279049911,
0.0358109251,
0.026012538,
-0.0385793075,
-0.0291995872,
0.0278068911,
-0.0552474931,
-0.0355740599,
-0.0286598951,
-0.01111764,
0.0025788923,
0.0178817809,
0.0137211718,
0.0382244736,
0.0552633479,
-0.0315383412,
-0.0399658643,
0.0034519313,
-0.0774996579,
-0.0171175878,
0.0324324034,
0.0427831933,
0.0238730069,
-0.0076838918,
0.003571166,
-0.0522044227,
0.0225766376,
-0.0203512833,
0.13307859,
-0.0909277797,
0.0249790065,
0.0184433889,
0.0247617681,
-0.0041877562,
0.0924198776,
-0.0444514044,
0.0189571362,
-0.0011974882,
0.0023094697,
-0.017194517,
-0.009293193,
-0.0539358072,
0.0129343327,
0.001740736,
0.0149305575,
-0.0268478338,
-0.0565862283,
-0.0820211396,
0.0093932664,
-0.0859223157,
0.0050831302,
-0.041944921,
-0.0088533228,
-0.0094577661,
0.0041502793,
-0.0223290641,
-0.0435744636,
-0.0041213618,
-0.0129788425,
0.0113542946,
0.053855259,
-0.0125242965,
0.038145218,
-0.0079800794,
-0.0199889317,
-0.0177174229,
0.0006687369,
0.0293130353,
-0.038939517,
-0.0347633697,
-0.0287187304,
0.0280143972,
-0.0626291186,
0.0496184602,
-0.0155029707,
0.0200208649,
-0.0083340295,
-0.0371546112,
0.0379721373,
0.0273533165,
-0.0172149427,
0.0013099835,
0.0586502627,
-0.0439626314,
-0.0297674481,
-0.0004264046,
-0.030041473,
-0.017194435,
-0.0042463974,
0.0227257255,
-0.0319384076,
0.033129707,
0.001361239,
-0.0168962423,
-0.0520600602,
0.0156133706,
-0.0171866268,
-0.06541875,
-0.022518767,
-0.0249692034,
-0.0411114655,
0.0387325175,
-0.0217141975,
-0.0600130744,
0.0698543936,
-0.0314413756,
-0.0012032145,
0.0072430158,
0.0033240695,
-0.0079084327,
0.0372339748,
0.0294118021,
-0.0046710088,
-0.0325083211,
-0.0387001708,
-0.0289433133,
0.001675793,
-0.0433440246,
-0.0677149072,
0.0238911975,
-0.0208791737,
0.0068077706,
0.0470073037,
-0.0043043965,
-0.0699869469,
-0.0274774563,
-0.0169650819,
-0.0072385841,
-0.0339032374,
0.0093610948,
-0.0250314418,
0.0048708343,
0.0081924209,
0.0542968921,
0.0075912764,
-0.006618998,
-0.0182010736,
-0.0012431272,
0.0407784767,
-0.004151382,
0.0565824918,
-0.0292805415,
0.0116800396,
0.0595236942,
0.044268284,
-0.0714269355,
0.0285469033,
-0.0016233268,
0.0224824082,
-0.0210338552,
-0.0412319712,
0.0146727851,
0.005365239,
-0.0701638907,
-0.0359970741,
0.1201802269,
0.0383186899,
-0.0659052506,
-0.0038289325,
-0.058039926,
0.0246553533,
0.0231634267,
-0.004228639,
-0.0464842133,
-0.0115181757,
0.0009794614,
0.0048590917,
-0.0283745229,
-0.0501440689,
-0.0166851021,
-0.099134706,
0.0146806724,
0.0065651978,
-0.0232290197,
-0.0188463591,
-0.0157824792,
0.0032376305,
0.0233276561,
0.031577684,
-0.0020907656,
0.009458215,
-0.0136377895,
0.0078783175,
-0.0391016938,
-0.0317342132,
0.0218794402,
-0.0301438011,
0.0435592048,
0.0539258644,
0.0007671353,
0.0136085395,
-0.0443877913,
0.0347357243,
-0.0084095616,
0.0326841623,
-0.0181965735,
0.0284323599,
-0.0285641421,
-0.0024252166,
-0.0174111146,
0.0216843858,
-0.0450828373,
-0.0456510857,
-0.0276404303,
0.0999345109,
-0.0438042879,
0.008011586,
-0.0059050228,
0.004174869,
0.0081153763,
0.0981451198,
0.0153831141,
-0.0268235877,
-0.0178910848,
-0.002714732,
0.0183380228,
0.0002173306,
-0.0340616144,
0.0151027311,
0.0159896854,
-0.0037363023,
-0.0422719643,
-0.0452594757,
0.0306505393,
0.0256711151,
-0.0067664208,
0.0606326908,
-0.0229583625,
-0.033437293,
-0.0423318483,
0.0308494419,
-0.0495826714,
-0.0178534798,
-0.0319848321,
0.0178355314,
0.0176095292,
-0.0328644402,
-0.0148843797,
0.014497119,
-0.060679052,
-0.0811666921,
0.0472280532,
0.0620717257,
0.0249786433,
0.0688676313,
-0.0164942071,
-0.0379862748,
0.0778588504,
0.0499833748,
-0.0339177102,
0.0296311174,
0.00968723,
0.0115417503,
0.0077421772,
0.0350457281,
-0.05064933,
-0.0176685229,
0.0348488726,
0.0219912343,
0.0009966884,
-0.0110851368,
0.0261079762,
-0.0138225453,
0.0683059692,
-0.0144689502,
0.0042680074,
-0.0183162428,
0.0368040428,
-0.0388077982,
-0.0114694368,
-0.0236099269,
-0.0041445838,
0.0325463861,
0.0012805553,
-0.0222867299,
-0.0163207073,
-0.0143988691,
0.0317573361,
-0.027453851,
-0.0224885978,
0.0266294312,
0.000324637,
0.0517692789,
-0.0012905707,
-0.0267504305,
0.0163329896,
0.0024798042,
0.0597341768,
-0.0328628793,
0.0486013889,
-0.0063794069,
-0.0311892666,
-0.0177700799,
0.0342579149,
-0.0659608096,
-0.0786463469,
-0.0369280279,
0.0344272852,
0.0376592092,
-0.0408522338,
0.0246539153,
-0.0453313217,
0.0028832841,
-0.0125322202,
-0.0228926744,
0.051639542,
-0.0310883056,
-0.0067348289,
0.0212704521,
-0.0363088474,
0.0262257662,
0.0523111932,
0.0099812662,
0.0805394575,
-0.0114655467,
-0.0110416533,
-0.0194412302,
-0.0328203402,
-0.0149411215,
0.0297876038,
-0.0488064699,
0.0041242619,
-0.0663463026,
-0.0871880054,
0.0010205249,
0.0024066812,
-0.0372738279,
0.0108160637,
0.013125211,
0.0497765765,
-0.0176606625,
-0.0029948917,
-0.0114517296,
0.0338816792,
0.0303459894,
-0.0019465758,
0.0180135109,
-6.849108201e-33,
-0.0233185571,
-0.0358535051,
0.0308722239,
-0.045529291,
-0.0057945419,
0.0104233334,
-0.0111197522,
0.0073241773,
-0.0003135438,
-0.0232381355,
-0.0195919555,
0.0411026143,
0.0261147767,
0.0290038306,
0.0033166895,
-0.0320736095,
0.0314168558,
0.012013156,
0.0151418839,
0.0306387302,
0.0715658516,
0.0584791042,
0.0771484077,
-0.0478553399,
0.0466095582,
-0.0206213612,
0.0039484808,
0.0398785397,
-0.0041180286,
0.0481374636,
-0.0578340106,
0.0510330833,
0.0105670486,
-0.0190456957,
-0.0468561277,
-0.004821355,
-0.061022304,
-0.0132526979,
0.0360957235,
0.0142601812,
0.0086179608,
-0.0168714542,
0.0487010516,
-0.0188614912,
0.0232664235,
0.037843097,
0.0117095392,
-0.0298080929,
-0.0282952096,
0.0151500134,
-0.0370879956,
0.013922642,
0.0370376706,
0.011310719,
0.0217901971,
0.0236342978,
0.0119865872,
0.0094994539,
-0.0918976441,
0.0080241598,
-0.0280785635,
0.0080537368,
0.0546800643,
0.0072464212,
0.009190917,
0.090023838,
0.0419067293,
-0.0164762251,
-0.0471961983,
-0.0215958357,
0.0560504422,
0.0389500037,
0.0189011917,
-0.0013739492,
0.0299226586,
0.0011113716,
-0.0222122204,
-0.0204478335,
-0.0434337743,
0.0280428864,
0.0619110353,
0.0174326636,
-0.0296766236,
-0.0196014214,
-0.01009659,
0.0195689369,
-0.0307553038,
-0.0169055685,
0.046154093,
0.0130074965,
-0.012972475,
0.004472753,
0.0390356444,
-0.0258678664,
0.0077404957,
0.0316466615,
0.0427550301,
-0.0011698788,
-0.0126742488,
0.0335937105,
-0.0358851887,
-0.0165293775,
0.0109872222,
-0.0389739983,
-0.0134425778,
-0.0003329068,
0.0138390483,
0.0287093669,
-0.0638154149,
0.0169543065,
-0.034990564,
0.0207049325,
0.023158906,
-0.0157349817,
0.0688201189,
0.0288416408,
-0.011977124,
0.0389770269,
0.0506353788,
0.0005187988,
0.00136673,
-0.0005169925,
0.0016142465,
0.0146896197,
-0.0225030109,
-0.022183504,
-0.0180194639,
-0.0095237158,
0.0419634767,
-0.0606721565,
0.0236253701,
0.0055973986,
2.924e-7,
0.0570962094,
0.0208909828,
0.0227653384,
-0.0327586345,
0.0198116116,
-0.0051631904,
0.008514272,
0.0099807391,
0.0174769443,
-0.0518158786,
0.0066406224,
0.0320804492,
0.0259187259,
0.025691282,
-0.0796605274,
-0.0105137313,
-0.0439944752,
-0.0159065053,
-0.0609863959,
-0.0190188643,
0.0127825774,
0.0989712551,
0.012678423,
-0.0258562621,
-0.0250813961,
-0.0814096928,
0.0605798662,
-0.0397838131,
-0.0150311776,
-0.0136635127,
0.0601884276,
0.0534539707,
0.0041949642,
0.03953344,
-0.0238147322,
0.0099663623,
0.0358682834,
0.02792757,
0.0086023901,
-0.0749542415,
-0.014118012,
-0.0041245776,
-0.0047443435,
-0.0674974918,
0.0947067067,
-0.007864058,
-0.0060185441,
0.0123381279,
-0.0338669531,
-0.0169816855,
0.0278469082,
-0.0082041863,
-0.0286836643,
0.0151200052,
0.0135890031,
0.0343852118,
-0.0152754625,
-0.1060646549,
-0.0373602845,
0.0133815566,
-0.0429683551,
-0.0380442142,
-0.0456586778,
-0.0143793039,
0.019879017,
-0.0897351205,
0.0100374026,
3.18382622e-34,
0.0355282985,
0.0214685984,
0.024056362,
0.0330324396,
0.0066558127,
-0.0021336176,
0.0319471583,
0.0260053668,
0.0085109985,
-0.1056643799,
-0.0272759646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16424v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16424v1 | Prompt-and-Align: Prompt-Based Social Alignment for Few-Shot Fake News Detection | 2023-09-28T13:19:43 | 2023-09-28T13:19:43 | Jiaying Wu, Shen Li, Ailin Deng, Miao Xiong, Bryan Hooi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI | Despite considerable advances in automated fake news detection, due to the
timely nature of news, it remains a critical open question how to effectively
predict the veracity of news articles based on limited fact-checks. Existing
approaches typically follow a "Train-from-Scratch" paradigm, which is
fundamentally bounded by the availability of large-scale annotated data. While
expressive pre-trained language models (PLMs) have been adapted in a
"Pre-Train-and-Fine-Tune" manner, the inconsistency between pre-training and
downstream objectives also requires costly task-specific supervision. In this
paper, we propose "Prompt-and-Align" (P&A), a novel prompt-based paradigm for
few-shot fake news detection that jointly leverages the pre-trained knowledge
in PLMs and the social context topology. Our approach mitigates label scarcity
by wrapping the news article in a task-related textual prompt, which is then
processed by the PLM to directly elicit task-specific knowledge. To supplement
the PLM with social context without inducing additional training overheads,
motivated by empirical observation on user veracity consistency (i.e., social
users tend to consume news of the same veracity type), we further construct a
news proximity graph among news articles to capture the veracity-consistent
signals in shared readerships, and align the prompting predictions along the
graph edges in a confidence-informed manner. Extensive experiments on three
real-world benchmarks demonstrate that P&A sets new states-of-the-art for
few-shot fake news detection performance by significant margins. | [
0.0731314719,
0.0063615823,
0.0101111727,
0.0480440743,
-0.0481444336,
0.0081190001,
-0.0030358837,
-0.0012755271,
0.0254972801,
-0.0274871532,
-0.0395267271,
-0.008367884,
-0.0037499883,
0.0530526079,
0.0111258859,
0.0111195641,
0.0771927908,
0.0246355981,
0.0677612424,
-0.0082440218,
0.0627810657,
0.0541877821,
0.0079609212,
-0.0025504306,
-0.0345808938,
-0.0057532946,
0.0044852304,
0.0405512154,
0.0350282043,
-0.0190261714,
0.0178331304,
0.0619882196,
0.0210085772,
0.0862080604,
0.0000016164,
-0.031519141,
-0.0160546489,
0.0033721139,
-0.0356809534,
-0.0127552794,
0.0304741394,
-0.0711456016,
0.0057146167,
-0.0019179035,
-0.0483752936,
-0.0228601489,
0.0116963806,
0.0495468602,
0.0749088228,
0.1241898239,
-0.0242733452,
0.0190404188,
-0.0022941662,
-0.0233336091,
0.0003154202,
-0.0651932657,
0.0466585867,
-0.0058922092,
-0.0184568148,
0.0623265505,
0.0164888818,
0.012679114,
0.0066596735,
-0.0232619122,
-0.0072894171,
0.0160418674,
-0.0150336837,
-0.025335867,
-0.0218034871,
0.0431025922,
-0.0311535336,
-0.0838114247,
0.0014309786,
-0.0307065826,
0.0022920596,
0.0516734123,
0.0062067145,
-0.0032148976,
-0.0304813664,
0.0172182005,
0.0026094462,
0.0064423177,
0.0219910555,
0.0436294749,
0.0537142754,
0.0539886802,
-0.0076683811,
-0.0303220637,
0.0099542188,
0.0259164516,
0.0000593338,
-0.0520648621,
0.0150255663,
0.0113105811,
-0.0242845062,
0.0012215569,
-0.0919419676,
-0.0053421217,
0.0391352996,
-0.0509044789,
-0.0118988976,
0.0002750292,
-0.0046430877,
0.06355194,
-0.0095086927,
0.0013679003,
-0.0265750978,
0.0246425215,
-0.0167157874,
0.0005273488,
0.0282889791,
0.0180609226,
-0.0154709015,
-0.0140856365,
-0.0134297134,
-0.0262728557,
-0.0304079112,
0.0222496018,
-0.0101432446,
0.0334600843,
-0.017985737,
0.0051425425,
-0.0332472846,
-0.0383450314,
0.0010503069,
0.0321416482,
-0.0080289301,
0.023501642,
-0.0182600711,
-0.0228916295,
-0.0265788082,
0.0149705615,
-0.0017746346,
-0.0018173796,
-0.0030830717,
-0.0333313383,
0.004035742,
-0.0105762808,
-0.0479847342,
-0.0238012336,
-0.0241041668,
-0.0520308279,
-0.0295049641,
-0.0548800826,
0.032018628,
-0.0077425037,
-0.0235317666,
-0.0050656525,
-0.0196534451,
0.0386379622,
-0.0457885601,
0.045204863,
-0.0201311205,
0.0181810372,
0.0411244296,
0.0205084905,
0.0112455841,
0.0789504945,
-0.0220755972,
0.0796849728,
0.0554683693,
0.0265597571,
-0.0053622629,
0.0104883481,
0.0659135208,
0.0119991032,
0.0349234045,
-0.0045523238,
0.0046293456,
0.0100038676,
0.015907988,
0.0299333986,
-0.0042332872,
-0.0610538013,
0.0897517279,
0.0018541955,
-0.0195467416,
-0.0381400324,
0.0635128021,
0.0282455254,
-0.0040140515,
0.0192923862,
-0.0730676576,
0.0140340775,
-0.0784784257,
0.0053953486,
-0.004420978,
0.0464593731,
-0.0192299262,
0.0184386186,
0.000892112,
-0.0028484373,
0.0043027834,
-0.0038709363,
-0.0008506176,
0.0189285409,
-0.0562637746,
0.0067966087,
0.0320993178,
0.0076299091,
0.0103544537,
-0.0204065274,
0.0498430505,
0.0214013681,
0.0219950266,
0.0085140551,
-0.0201950353,
-0.0132133635,
0.0530447029,
0.0258002244,
0.0472088605,
-0.029004775,
-0.0448266231,
-0.0096574202,
-0.0293321479,
-0.0186123922,
0.0017873704,
-0.001373598,
0.0665649027,
0.0239929557,
0.0161263291,
-0.0110173337,
-0.0405042805,
0.0160648301,
-0.0132156126,
0.0003465189,
-0.0323556662,
0.0346888788,
0.0112263774,
0.0376056582,
0.0183686372,
-0.0275467057,
0.0472688153,
0.0341746658,
-0.007005522,
-0.0363044254,
-0.0487845242,
-0.0458930768,
0.0079148263,
-0.0055292943,
-0.0561030395,
0.0459161364,
-0.0317028351,
-0.0055492688,
-0.0165467579,
-0.0216167457,
0.0056423373,
-0.0428205729,
-0.0200342555,
-0.0249476619,
0.0126873264,
0.013519167,
0.0665941164,
-0.0132992435,
0.0158382971,
0.0260308925,
0.0255901515,
-0.0094907014,
-0.0006876886,
-0.0139469597,
-0.0502221584,
0.0119750388,
-0.0050026951,
0.059059184,
-0.022339182,
-0.0166462474,
-0.0013423378,
-0.0871670097,
-0.0068228766,
-0.0383609384,
-0.0025079639,
0.050786864,
0.00149711,
-0.014914671,
-0.0351989344,
-0.0581963956,
0.0001393847,
0.0079947393,
0.0210321546,
0.0238094609,
-0.0242567081,
0.0292515084,
-0.0237519182,
0.0213388298,
-0.0193986222,
0.0410237536,
0.0373503789,
-0.0686828718,
-0.0443917513,
0.0032730978,
-0.03749438,
0.0259680208,
-0.0342225507,
0.0184130166,
-0.0045531499,
0.0261100661,
0.0202211421,
0.0558038391,
0.0462049022,
0.0226274598,
0.0091133611,
0.047218319,
-0.0450583994,
-0.0264283475,
-0.0586212575,
0.0133898538,
-0.0289302617,
-0.0532841086,
0.0337222144,
0.0260761734,
0.0193150602,
0.002658095,
-0.0330031663,
0.0101081794,
0.0145680495,
-0.0074190106,
0.0135538271,
-0.0626977831,
-0.0068015512,
-0.0023356944,
-0.0644815043,
-0.0349680297,
0.115306735,
-0.033321999,
0.056769684,
-0.004229126,
-0.0466009863,
-0.0128064398,
0.0245767683,
0.0112557486,
0.0213736687,
0.0124616204,
0.0048950934,
-0.0267967284,
-0.0094110183,
0.0633363426,
-0.0252461061,
0.0099872742,
-0.0030788623,
0.0454642437,
0.0276299231,
-0.0317741074,
-0.050945513,
-0.1330987066,
-0.0073745698,
-0.0372970961,
-0.0366048254,
-0.0234592929,
-0.0260797348,
-0.0209069848,
0.005454326,
0.0509811938,
-0.0382965133,
-0.0007148588,
0.0083582113,
0.0488028377,
0.0635025799,
-0.0312972926,
0.0203370247,
-0.0113762254,
-0.0198395923,
0.069836773,
-0.0002234939,
0.0131372865,
-0.0234382395,
-0.0430363491,
0.0122590382,
0.0054698321,
0.0153794689,
-0.0135068269,
0.0364813432,
-0.0135482866,
0.0091441143,
0.1000656486,
0.0085060345,
-0.0277182423,
-0.0158810895,
0.0375972018,
-0.0049472065,
0.01816318,
-0.0010441981,
-0.0782563612,
-0.0115886424,
-0.0135456156,
0.0000778703,
-0.0227739904,
-0.0183865707,
-0.0409876071,
-0.0900833383,
-0.0197863374,
-0.0006477552,
-0.0094157662,
-0.0123463757,
-0.0749934837,
0.0225764681,
0.0064874208,
0.0132333832,
-0.0036507642,
0.0232276451,
-0.0213579163,
-0.0013373481,
0.0181022249,
-0.0399233103,
0.0120743811,
-0.0259359255,
0.0746936351,
0.0021919138,
0.0207876768,
0.0134217152,
-0.0349397399,
-0.0071176374,
0.0331610404,
-0.0115523105,
-0.0041861376,
0.0457325354,
-0.0674130023,
0.0118300002,
-0.0362604298,
0.0524930432,
0.0157105811,
-0.0243672654,
-0.0236973558,
0.0422361083,
0.0202101208,
-0.0605556816,
-0.0465494208,
0.033344496,
0.0561253987,
0.0669127107,
0.0088026859,
-0.0025171451,
0.0076021194,
0.0218006056,
0.004846707,
0.0016440151,
-0.0527646393,
0.0241717696,
-0.035013631,
-0.0491090603,
-0.034511514,
-0.0205812249,
-0.014386069,
0.0301328991,
-0.0093190437,
-0.0266403295,
0.0443016812,
-0.0498622172,
-0.0562338717,
0.030443931,
-0.0391740613,
0.0446925461,
0.0055514746,
0.0271445774,
0.015579626,
-0.0096101463,
-0.0038509755,
0.0292638,
-0.1057654992,
-0.0668604076,
-0.0089557106,
0.0188711919,
0.0111446558,
0.0771678165,
-0.0298653021,
-0.0313540287,
0.0668521672,
0.0532897785,
-0.0477877632,
0.0328968689,
-0.0031466528,
-0.0273893718,
0.0288768858,
0.017467441,
-0.0308973622,
0.0244929399,
0.0485926867,
-0.0320041478,
-0.0524645969,
-0.0279374458,
0.0301218797,
0.003123455,
0.0661875159,
-0.0034974387,
0.0224058032,
-0.0518803746,
-0.0543735735,
-0.0241589881,
-0.0462760776,
0.0175568759,
0.0037527324,
0.0213387329,
-0.019867694,
-0.0199078284,
0.0047161113,
-0.0285938811,
0.054900229,
-0.0822122693,
-0.0645865053,
0.001849807,
0.0313646011,
0.0224884544,
-0.0060731811,
-0.0445330776,
0.0382991135,
0.0169318076,
0.0224002469,
0.0022766879,
0.0310140494,
0.0356860459,
-0.0227797627,
0.0394640677,
-0.0025737511,
-0.0598100051,
0.023429757,
-0.0609058551,
0.0283824261,
-0.003491194,
-0.03472111,
0.0129006421,
-0.0052014203,
-0.0185627136,
-0.0016250043,
-0.0102776708,
-0.0127159329,
-0.0495171882,
0.0101996353,
0.0208153315,
-0.0322733708,
0.0844107866,
0.0546128787,
-0.0203352161,
0.012206452,
0.0297594126,
-0.0809129775,
-0.0173790064,
-0.0113034016,
0.0196323842,
0.0613672771,
-0.0405461565,
-0.0309845451,
-0.0681695864,
-0.054681018,
0.0313183926,
0.0137596922,
-0.0023217183,
0.04978358,
-0.0009453704,
0.0991527885,
-0.0059914449,
0.011907964,
-0.0160631835,
0.0087155309,
0.0138670644,
-0.0449744128,
0.0036644347,
-6.110130004e-33,
0.0173373334,
-0.0517729446,
-0.0299846306,
-0.0283449143,
-0.0110494532,
0.0712133795,
-0.009476658,
-0.0298870709,
-0.0391598158,
0.0498102829,
0.022497043,
0.0537406392,
-0.009192965,
-0.0013859705,
-0.0721245036,
-0.0155129889,
0.0383118168,
-0.0030029728,
-0.0359392762,
0.0271750856,
0.047147572,
0.0011188085,
0.0161160231,
-0.0519048795,
0.0713535026,
-0.0475425646,
-0.0350658633,
0.0210409779,
0.0209094174,
0.0199851636,
-0.0052213585,
0.0489776768,
0.0320281647,
-0.0185037181,
0.0047283955,
0.0776728764,
-0.065726921,
-0.0407701693,
0.0549734049,
-0.0087878741,
-0.0433581099,
0.0441301465,
0.0389246009,
-0.0391078964,
-0.0020573693,
0.0101002455,
0.0134249339,
-0.0033999707,
-0.0029130285,
-0.0156301092,
-0.0514078364,
0.0188297108,
0.0158684719,
-0.0144634247,
-0.0293450616,
0.0473732688,
0.044081606,
0.0160768628,
-0.0870689675,
0.0247044936,
-0.0660387874,
-0.0001931866,
0.0268442854,
-0.0228760447,
-0.0304670036,
0.0539485663,
-0.006122984,
0.0512259901,
-0.040512301,
0.0178976208,
0.0105793728,
0.0019673747,
0.0357436202,
0.0897680148,
-0.0043304041,
-0.0442823693,
-0.0850839466,
0.0378661714,
0.0549637415,
-0.0479432642,
0.012486293,
-0.0179118104,
-0.0557645224,
-0.0038237588,
0.0033206826,
-0.0002970839,
-0.0330509581,
-0.0105012907,
-0.0117377844,
0.046457883,
-0.0391547047,
0.0642630309,
-0.0053144637,
-0.0419052355,
-0.0096893227,
0.0398016274,
-0.0387565903,
-0.019130161,
-0.0007908109,
0.0770965517,
-0.0447571203,
-0.0041271867,
0.0273944736,
0.0086649386,
-0.0300312918,
-0.0169093572,
0.0857716501,
0.0242374837,
-0.0495994985,
0.0172769614,
-0.0215896908,
0.0213458557,
-0.0172831938,
-0.0431768149,
0.0629021749,
0.0219546594,
-0.0231547747,
0.0417933017,
0.0128025142,
-0.0021787887,
0.004561062,
0.0089262836,
-0.0377525426,
0.0184308663,
-0.0039696116,
-0.0218348075,
-0.0001292879,
0.0236267764,
-0.0022873408,
-0.0703945607,
0.0157084521,
0.028731605,
2.508e-7,
-0.0086905537,
0.0206458345,
0.0178792626,
0.0142438179,
0.0067920894,
0.0359257199,
0.0492630191,
0.0588754229,
-0.0071151047,
-0.1002703756,
0.0059020808,
0.0421111882,
-0.0034355323,
0.0310745388,
-0.0715401024,
0.0235603712,
-0.0974188596,
-0.0121252267,
-0.0497917421,
0.0000343839,
-0.0046257754,
0.0596126057,
0.0666724741,
-0.0257999785,
-0.0006493926,
-0.0258360729,
0.0465665869,
0.0397328176,
-0.0534069985,
0.011182026,
0.0583767518,
-0.0326451324,
0.0016122434,
0.027681049,
-0.0263888352,
0.0188071635,
-0.0033884156,
0.027748283,
0.0183260925,
-0.0023277493,
-0.0320555493,
-0.0428287834,
0.0202791486,
-0.0533706732,
0.0707067326,
-0.0547478199,
-0.0258275438,
-0.0756205916,
-0.0467737205,
-0.0054735616,
0.0235331543,
0.0059319092,
-0.0180191807,
0.0375647806,
0.0214439351,
0.0200182498,
-0.019450726,
-0.0576112159,
0.0100477934,
-0.0023817923,
-0.0366988666,
-0.0195958447,
-0.0048089703,
-0.0220392644,
0.0606736764,
-0.0683809817,
0.0557925515,
2.052286633e-34,
0.0292280857,
-0.0192788392,
0.0088242544,
-0.0441594161,
-0.0066238455,
0.0229251012,
-0.0553286895,
-0.0123978499,
0.0582138523,
-0.0186583586,
-0.0035808387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16396v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16396v3 | A Comprehensive Survey of Document-level Relation Extraction (2016-2023) | 2023-09-28T12:43:32 | 2023-10-12T13:39:39 | Julien Delaunay, Hanh Thi Hong Tran, Carlos-Emiliano González-Gallardo, Georgeta Bordea, Nicolas Sidere, Antoine Doucet | cs.CL | cs.CL, A.1 | Document-level relation extraction (DocRE) is an active area of research in
natural language processing (NLP) concerned with identifying and extracting
relationships between entities beyond sentence boundaries. Compared to the more
traditional sentence-level relation extraction, DocRE provides a broader
context for analysis and is more challenging because it involves identifying
relationships that may span multiple sentences or paragraphs. This task has
gained increased interest as a viable solution to build and populate knowledge
bases automatically from unstructured large-scale documents (e.g., scientific
papers, legal contracts, or news articles), in order to have a better
understanding of relationships between entities. This paper aims to provide a
comprehensive overview of recent advances in this field, highlighting its
different applications in comparison to sentence-level relation extraction. | [
0.0501958765,
0.0630069673,
0.0067689726,
0.0520769767,
-0.049673412,
-0.0026592335,
0.0047111991,
0.0044487859,
0.0211687423,
-0.0294639356,
0.000880364,
0.0083685117,
-0.0171804335,
-0.006246902,
-0.0366409309,
-0.0738440454,
0.0121443728,
0.0311807431,
0.0629952848,
0.0320863351,
0.0092443042,
0.0323444344,
-0.0060351542,
-0.0086455895,
-0.0380958878,
-0.0422574915,
0.0268616714,
-0.0181512348,
0.0489967167,
-0.0381604247,
-0.0076003,
0.0100306468,
0.0133212321,
-0.0318876095,
0.000001463,
-0.0534853153,
-0.0678417012,
0.0199827142,
-0.0023837201,
-0.0308101252,
-0.0070818327,
-0.069107309,
0.0060095428,
-0.0107764881,
-0.0353588685,
-0.0135322297,
-0.0130322883,
0.0586294644,
-0.009775484,
0.0513428748,
-0.0557297617,
-0.0610598586,
0.0706608891,
-0.0055127791,
-0.0002167113,
-0.0314217173,
0.0183402989,
0.0027166738,
0.0134731559,
-0.0107989116,
0.0133252535,
-0.0124392137,
-0.0030394092,
-0.0549643561,
0.023007594,
0.0156164309,
-0.0343193673,
0.0077597243,
-0.0176378544,
0.0556969456,
0.0546331629,
0.02746341,
0.0680575371,
0.0056515564,
-0.0053997459,
0.0642769039,
-0.0061807497,
0.0152754402,
-0.049125012,
0.0019728206,
0.0508736745,
0.0110415258,
0.0158451665,
0.0129056042,
-0.01283623,
0.0605265982,
0.0057905614,
-0.0740149096,
0.0529424287,
0.0134389158,
0.026430387,
-0.030825913,
0.0682530701,
0.0374024659,
0.0286979899,
0.0436777696,
-0.0275236964,
-0.0233454108,
0.0146783162,
-0.0607143193,
-0.0330254547,
-0.0628089532,
-0.0098350355,
0.0863011628,
-0.0059728594,
-0.015137909,
-0.0257466212,
-0.0529795215,
0.0258781966,
-0.006438273,
-0.0211524703,
-0.0000560186,
-0.0155160176,
0.0422554724,
-0.0448357575,
0.0002663728,
-0.005551368,
0.0008911911,
0.0001973527,
0.0474351197,
-0.0036884788,
-0.0157624576,
-0.0133576356,
-0.0311139766,
-0.0210287217,
-0.0058084871,
-0.0048702951,
-0.0040161987,
-0.0373230763,
0.0194141008,
0.0054260511,
0.0023806377,
0.0758186355,
-0.0505957864,
0.0011868532,
0.060065154,
0.0189473908,
-0.0484741852,
0.0154714631,
-0.0611433126,
0.0388808362,
-0.065351285,
0.0073170378,
-0.0039534089,
0.055726964,
0.0018780401,
-0.031972561,
-0.0261655096,
0.0467049778,
0.0003454482,
-0.0582551397,
0.0176151525,
-0.0449145213,
-0.0178643744,
-0.0139296371,
0.0048766313,
0.0501740649,
0.0009201834,
0.0653500408,
0.0103133824,
0.073249869,
-0.0006492625,
-0.0033827836,
0.0060958252,
0.0010549015,
-0.0560918674,
0.0511038341,
0.0253190938,
0.0257073324,
-0.0212670807,
0.0180036016,
0.0058856304,
-0.0072272392,
-0.0088638207,
-0.0086228857,
0.020083515,
0.0030247818,
0.0176106654,
0.0285964925,
-0.005015695,
0.0524467528,
0.0282630697,
-0.0252082758,
-0.0236890502,
0.0293275695,
0.0213093217,
-0.0686513484,
0.0380662903,
0.038144853,
-0.0066684792,
-0.0077834399,
-0.006198429,
-0.0152671356,
-0.0204504989,
0.0993232056,
0.0069404957,
-0.0350009501,
0.0306229815,
0.0447065569,
-0.0265474431,
0.0074094622,
0.0501252003,
0.0007479276,
0.0036371686,
0.0650058836,
-0.0733316243,
-0.0419346169,
-0.0072953543,
-0.0124177272,
0.0629565567,
0.0128770936,
-0.0333591402,
0.021087084,
0.0004730419,
-0.0415318161,
0.0332198963,
-0.0021397062,
-0.029857453,
0.0232195426,
0.0173980575,
0.0087391827,
-0.0271796025,
0.0225141421,
0.0503124855,
-0.0236843061,
-0.0256074481,
0.0159673449,
0.0387840569,
0.0028986612,
0.0505325459,
-0.0064404877,
-0.0191233717,
0.07236702,
-0.0390288718,
0.0258507188,
0.0318772011,
-0.0240724962,
-0.0192406438,
-0.0014538318,
-0.0301047955,
-0.0379828662,
-0.0414449126,
-0.0213684663,
-0.0229325611,
-0.0086237956,
0.0370860137,
0.0485068001,
-0.0058666575,
-0.014767956,
0.0260072052,
-0.0035323719,
-0.0213448796,
0.087734744,
0.0242189821,
-0.0349363983,
-0.0003435135,
-0.0596556775,
-0.0121905981,
-0.0003015756,
0.0326533429,
-0.0035032535,
-0.0264179371,
-0.0442128889,
0.0331867933,
-0.0022780243,
-0.0386011042,
-0.0245832447,
-0.0164724793,
0.0477702618,
0.022534227,
0.0678184405,
-0.0089649493,
0.0141846808,
-0.0084963245,
-0.0124326991,
-0.0146147031,
0.0174332,
-0.0068486407,
-0.0473500341,
0.0720557198,
-0.0041797669,
-0.0209398773,
-0.0272514895,
-0.0136832139,
-0.0599935465,
0.0436835177,
0.0592639446,
-0.0334295407,
0.0115066124,
0.0477860086,
-0.0061619603,
0.0321256518,
-0.0164873991,
0.0311229285,
-0.0114710545,
0.0114726368,
0.0067012301,
0.0407862402,
0.0117428852,
0.0720882788,
-0.0047146883,
-0.0111478856,
0.0147388512,
0.0393644087,
-0.0386390239,
0.0789515302,
-0.0007800483,
0.0081327911,
0.0340059362,
0.0201267861,
-0.0106155407,
0.0084624887,
0.0217229351,
0.0038229229,
0.0248954613,
0.0152209233,
0.0183188617,
0.0017255386,
0.0274376031,
0.0070175054,
-0.0191784594,
-0.0089856116,
0.0242611654,
-0.0175668411,
0.0199797358,
-0.0429491885,
0.0106840348,
-0.0565612093,
0.0915902182,
0.0017790797,
0.0049327216,
-0.0071367011,
-0.050065048,
0.0348411165,
-0.0209940989,
0.0326624922,
0.0157067962,
-0.0001701879,
-0.0562811904,
0.0353837758,
-0.036228288,
-0.024926452,
-0.0439207703,
0.0057776077,
0.0086665461,
0.0402096808,
0.0021265431,
0.009143251,
-0.0016028457,
-0.0040753996,
0.0013582461,
-0.0010562665,
-0.0201029144,
-0.0178562086,
-0.0304087233,
0.1170780137,
0.0809608102,
-0.0429181457,
0.0087611759,
0.014340749,
0.0057952283,
0.0436852276,
-0.0356063172,
0.0014223048,
0.0194057692,
-0.0039289258,
-0.0431268252,
-0.0621801168,
0.0474551655,
-0.0424975343,
-0.0008373348,
-0.090972431,
-0.0169888679,
0.0670525581,
0.0291306321,
-0.0010037975,
-0.0091003999,
0.0351596996,
-0.0268649645,
-0.0008788067,
0.0264922958,
-0.0640615895,
0.0188819133,
-0.0296502598,
-0.0415366068,
-0.0072149765,
-0.0574087091,
-0.0302269552,
-0.0309399031,
0.0273206774,
-0.0331334658,
-0.0209575221,
-0.0026957423,
-0.0690476522,
-0.0057854503,
-0.0002789045,
-0.039980974,
-0.0004989682,
-0.0530056879,
-0.0352057479,
-0.0162664037,
-0.0381732322,
-0.0259742886,
-0.0000972568,
-0.0239270031,
-0.0383236818,
0.0190783069,
0.0508176163,
-0.0248485599,
0.0512020774,
-0.0010887766,
-0.0293738898,
-0.0318362415,
-0.0241801459,
0.0596318617,
-0.0435193889,
0.0083257956,
-0.0396961868,
0.0223832,
-0.0570611209,
0.0038059691,
0.0543763675,
0.0646697581,
0.0000532157,
-0.044578936,
-0.0158514753,
-0.0068703019,
0.0026804514,
0.049584724,
-0.0331830047,
0.0076767015,
-0.0750687942,
0.0175150186,
0.0280328095,
-0.0317850858,
0.0511182286,
-0.022188969,
-0.0761546493,
0.0063805464,
-0.0581510812,
-0.0630795583,
0.0300821662,
0.0078499839,
-0.0078173056,
0.0061443485,
0.0831450447,
-0.0184659138,
-0.0369010232,
-0.0092194658,
0.015499318,
-0.0170380119,
0.0150012989,
0.0002757456,
0.0256777965,
0.0044661937,
-0.0334657989,
-0.0503308922,
-0.0119488472,
-0.0178091507,
-0.011861546,
-0.0255487375,
0.0073246113,
0.0520173609,
-0.0088784257,
0.0229915287,
0.0237517338,
0.0539046563,
-0.0647142157,
-0.0392930284,
0.0144272009,
-0.0115896882,
-0.0256160907,
0.0270862523,
-0.0178082008,
0.0253948905,
0.0062628658,
0.0259061027,
-0.0276038796,
-0.0126300454,
0.0257946234,
-0.002632082,
0.034384273,
0.0242094621,
0.0186371319,
-0.0610566735,
0.0367323272,
-0.091324769,
-0.0005324397,
-0.0276245233,
0.0100274682,
-0.0352854431,
0.0232490636,
-0.0155355325,
-0.018392317,
-0.0411430746,
0.018271748,
0.020052189,
0.0389905125,
0.0567042567,
0.0035548136,
0.0163762718,
-0.0680848733,
0.0177410077,
-0.0072680009,
-0.0243236218,
0.0313752145,
-0.0306343511,
0.0000795591,
0.0075210151,
-0.0232002977,
-0.0080692656,
-0.0070511745,
-0.0468267202,
0.0600237362,
-0.0026628431,
0.0363164432,
0.028810367,
-0.0170966554,
0.0387966931,
-0.0271544736,
0.0004527215,
0.064182505,
0.0404770896,
-0.0060767452,
0.0067971963,
-0.0000283112,
0.0156120919,
-0.0360259302,
0.0526471697,
0.0450460576,
0.0084795849,
0.0422549509,
0.0312727205,
-0.0443185046,
-0.0459594987,
-0.0232392568,
0.0138398614,
0.0086423364,
-0.0149528896,
0.0041588624,
-0.0560000502,
0.0054863896,
0.0219619032,
-0.014416188,
-0.0118169822,
0.0174567346,
-0.0163476113,
0.0425326489,
0.0547637679,
-0.0795527548,
-0.0535938628,
0.0645023957,
-0.0735786334,
-0.0435535535,
-0.0004914912,
-5.385122925e-33,
-0.0419715345,
-0.055242274,
0.0033773342,
0.0550092794,
-0.0332466997,
0.0532374494,
-0.0382307544,
-0.0729643404,
0.0037475668,
0.0556211509,
-0.0495340489,
-0.0017179102,
0.0142840222,
-0.0074745137,
-0.0058311298,
0.0181787629,
0.0122500593,
-0.0099218627,
0.0385055691,
0.0131025976,
0.034691751,
0.0604774915,
0.0778628513,
-0.0891464353,
0.0372405611,
0.0044214698,
-0.0103254616,
0.003118465,
0.0356073119,
0.0244473815,
-0.049904447,
-0.0229750499,
0.0174989589,
-0.0008383314,
0.0415651686,
0.04066718,
-0.150893718,
-0.0035889151,
-0.0420110822,
-0.019593779,
-0.0382623076,
0.0039350861,
0.0217295773,
0.0030019893,
0.0339476392,
-0.0511868075,
0.0503000654,
-0.0307299141,
-0.0257199463,
-0.0877067149,
-0.0958449692,
0.048399251,
0.0193807539,
0.046726685,
0.0263730269,
-0.0317007937,
0.0169235431,
0.0281291008,
-0.0188320633,
-0.0299557876,
-0.0026908773,
0.0054110331,
-0.0151259657,
-0.0620088354,
0.0098810839,
0.024018975,
-0.010576684,
-0.0061050691,
0.0237125885,
0.0287575908,
-0.0200333558,
0.0575168394,
-0.0494349301,
0.0243743807,
0.0402476974,
0.0306590311,
-0.114402093,
0.0369811319,
0.0692819655,
0.0437369198,
-0.055310417,
-0.0193829127,
-0.0117649175,
0.0110899992,
0.0504455641,
-0.0408778153,
0.0243596472,
-0.0367541499,
-0.0164908916,
0.0003085352,
-0.0074003683,
0.027318025,
-0.0152923986,
-0.0265362337,
-0.0468971655,
0.0201258361,
0.0140026323,
0.0039058796,
-0.0013796705,
-0.0203268528,
-0.0569743067,
-0.0506879799,
-0.0174653996,
0.0095872162,
0.0303548034,
0.0106422231,
0.0383942686,
-0.0486533158,
-0.0270484183,
-0.0153425913,
-0.0021219619,
0.0173850376,
-0.0077387453,
0.0330714732,
-0.0018819231,
0.0361979268,
0.0176052321,
0.0293068234,
0.0499619208,
0.0423731394,
-0.0200684071,
0.0244184937,
-0.0126242628,
0.0299908742,
0.0282055214,
-0.0251218658,
-0.001842587,
0.0122355083,
0.0261571556,
-0.0323633514,
0.0170320086,
-0.0251489654,
2.247e-7,
0.024980709,
0.0425823331,
0.0616806671,
0.0110433837,
0.0208235625,
0.0073913606,
0.0391771197,
0.0432486571,
-0.0289695449,
0.0071221618,
0.0341425911,
-0.0595746115,
0.0093702925,
0.0543132685,
-0.0885392204,
-0.0105317831,
-0.0557263903,
-0.1113424823,
-0.084671475,
-0.030905474,
0.0330100693,
-0.002855924,
0.0182334017,
-0.0041144216,
-0.0700568855,
0.0041292049,
0.0295013878,
-0.0174627993,
-0.0306311771,
0.0439126752,
0.035206005,
-0.0466179848,
-0.0269854534,
0.0376690961,
-0.0400601663,
0.0793087259,
-0.013715636,
0.0499252491,
-0.0163177028,
0.0740552917,
0.0271197595,
-0.0493048355,
0.0267322045,
0.002127005,
0.0680550635,
-0.0157759767,
-0.0115055088,
-0.0531208701,
-0.0191194136,
-0.0155342035,
-0.026147021,
0.0296059605,
-0.0152196987,
0.0362814143,
0.0038910345,
-0.0259191636,
-0.0002415228,
-0.0618177429,
0.0502207242,
0.0814366937,
0.029898867,
0.0144612743,
0.0307233427,
0.0119978245,
0.0031577379,
-0.0479373373,
0.0123560214,
2.066880671e-34,
-0.0085180001,
0.0129407579,
-0.0233127028,
0.0319047421,
0.0392857902,
-0.0276801381,
-0.0568917952,
0.0110353502,
-0.0261114277,
-0.0847802088,
0.0459243953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16354v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16354v2 | Transformer-VQ: Linear-Time Transformers via Vector Quantization | 2023-09-28T11:26:52 | 2024-02-25T09:48:53 | Lucas D. Lingle | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | We introduce Transformer-VQ, a decoder-only transformer computing
softmax-based dense self-attention in linear time. Transformer-VQ's efficient
attention is enabled by vector-quantized keys and a novel caching mechanism. In
our large-scale experiments, Transformer-VQ is shown highly competitive in
quality, obtaining 0.99 bpb on Enwik8, 26.6 ppl on PG-19, and 3.16 bpb on
ImageNet64. In addition, the optimized implementation of Transformer-VQ is over
3x faster than a comparable quadratic-time transformer at sequence length 8k,
is over 12x faster at 32k, and can scale to 131k with similar throughput. Code
available: \url{https://github.com/transformer-vq/transformer_vq} | [
-0.02991849,
0.0680119619,
0.0380517654,
0.0448799841,
0.0139873959,
0.0147198103,
0.0485892333,
0.0226479005,
-0.0477238633,
0.0000816917,
0.0017002564,
-0.0054840408,
-0.0297317915,
0.0265508406,
-0.0086169429,
-0.0191090349,
0.0026768241,
0.0404913686,
-0.0020092388,
-0.020634843,
-0.0285046492,
-0.0178500302,
-0.0039793737,
0.0110151609,
-0.0102877291,
0.001450837,
-0.0355562046,
0.0186232086,
0.050307747,
-0.0248282664,
-0.0177883934,
0.0624849796,
0.009325047,
0.0014982746,
0.0000022237,
0.0267398003,
-0.0020997594,
-0.0170787778,
-0.0218940247,
0.058901459,
-0.0326259844,
-0.0452404581,
-0.0524681583,
-0.0450958908,
-0.0015969976,
-0.0374470092,
0.0746332407,
0.0422106273,
0.0612962209,
0.0335188806,
-0.0036342258,
-0.0419445969,
0.021524759,
-0.0218383912,
-0.001392363,
-0.0884910524,
-0.0026166968,
-0.0441788174,
-0.038955275,
0.0185264051,
-0.0313438289,
0.0723814368,
0.0370350853,
-0.0076193307,
0.0519480184,
0.0279849041,
-0.0281056333,
0.0031320052,
-0.022854967,
0.032254111,
-0.0776558295,
-0.0326069035,
-0.0001238873,
0.0212226417,
-0.0146578476,
-0.0737754181,
-0.0234409887,
0.0231563095,
0.0083676549,
0.0054753735,
-0.0609202608,
0.0348796323,
-0.002410644,
0.0089896107,
-0.0590384156,
-0.0413776413,
0.0157673061,
0.0066130338,
-0.0263242964,
0.0236859564,
-0.0475570634,
-0.0026580717,
0.0042541786,
0.0231223553,
0.0007059926,
-0.0503797494,
-0.0432497039,
-0.047772754,
-0.0261228029,
-0.0319730006,
0.0428921469,
0.0342057645,
-0.001356934,
0.0326836295,
-0.0199007895,
0.0652780831,
-0.0590291135,
0.0448549204,
-0.0237775818,
0.0055042799,
0.0061592637,
0.0131916907,
-0.0425300263,
0.0187019091,
0.0106327385,
-0.0081734126,
-0.0286825188,
-0.0280641112,
0.024791114,
-0.0269390009,
0.0156146055,
0.0358038098,
-0.0897378474,
-0.0433002599,
0.0369483754,
0.0596455,
-0.006770038,
-0.0420939773,
0.0016081055,
-0.0290757753,
-0.0569821149,
0.0199400857,
0.0369572826,
-0.0146570839,
0.007358091,
0.012853737,
-0.0631922707,
-0.0550200082,
0.0235700551,
0.0418056548,
-0.00534622,
-0.0090756575,
0.0204474572,
-0.0447806977,
-0.0193816032,
0.005493748,
0.0152630238,
0.0063855369,
0.0233943053,
0.0328896493,
0.0060541267,
0.0371528715,
0.009056543,
-0.0501535013,
0.0195997655,
0.0161263775,
0.0575221553,
0.0427510031,
-0.0124903154,
0.0300760828,
-0.0419888496,
-0.0081578847,
0.0232112221,
0.0135202669,
0.0139773581,
0.0121157924,
-0.0267852135,
-0.015994247,
-0.0191691853,
0.0051816432,
0.0824168548,
0.0434593447,
-0.0401830152,
-0.0594549924,
0.0285273939,
0.0199924931,
0.0581034794,
0.0418496653,
0.0029555738,
0.0280345343,
-0.0203380771,
-0.0257997811,
-0.0376268327,
0.1363440901,
0.0547873452,
-0.0272779521,
-0.0008746614,
0.04176737,
-0.0571804196,
-0.0095388619,
-0.0040718876,
-0.0005527638,
-0.0042701811,
-0.0224496666,
0.0306809451,
0.0557177812,
-0.0449275114,
0.0759566277,
-0.0250709727,
-0.0517687015,
-0.0405040421,
-0.0362036526,
-0.0224139001,
-0.0083227158,
0.0402355418,
0.0206161924,
-0.0118113244,
0.0111221652,
-0.0274218302,
-0.0003741583,
-0.0074785287,
0.0450628437,
0.0014331976,
-0.0429453291,
-0.0288401898,
0.0034346106,
-0.0155368689,
0.009267075,
0.0239348616,
0.0310488697,
-0.0349819995,
-0.0090218866,
0.0384768993,
-0.0014798904,
0.0442870259,
-0.0461355262,
0.0432442091,
0.0050751069,
0.0269842595,
0.0183711629,
-0.0033990813,
-0.0083291205,
0.0557461865,
-0.0609251931,
0.0065222383,
-0.0205173455,
-0.0783974826,
-0.0175091531,
0.0120493174,
-0.0345135331,
0.0012942774,
0.0886415541,
-0.0150801335,
-0.0065164468,
0.0341951549,
-0.0404094309,
-0.0359679684,
-0.0188771393,
0.0001696488,
0.018575523,
0.0419730209,
-0.02550558,
0.0280331001,
-0.004023267,
0.0002759215,
0.0178715102,
0.0264511816,
-0.0251520537,
-0.0102631142,
-0.0153963761,
0.0100852549,
-0.0317047387,
0.0107044801,
-0.0115030836,
-0.0004004492,
-0.0063748346,
0.0147275478,
-0.0056440718,
-0.0210280493,
-0.0590470545,
0.0008341583,
0.0143828969,
0.0165158864,
0.0484572463,
-0.0258491095,
-0.0145186624,
0.008043848,
-0.0331304148,
-0.0194729418,
-0.0072493088,
-0.0220848545,
0.005784878,
-0.0039470159,
-0.0542106554,
0.0427062325,
0.0304885823,
-0.0194019061,
-0.0224809945,
-0.0335610881,
-0.0503633134,
0.0463500172,
0.0101980017,
0.0126325982,
-0.0533491783,
-0.0042159064,
-0.0323617049,
0.0029207759,
0.0853439867,
0.0448901877,
-0.0154887037,
0.0039136615,
-0.0058006197,
0.0130055957,
0.0304772388,
-0.0120543763,
-0.0462543517,
-0.024654828,
0.0010885699,
-0.0060416032,
0.0794587657,
-0.0489421487,
0.017831251,
-0.0642174184,
-0.0094653638,
0.0196377225,
-0.0367764384,
0.0149238668,
0.0244044848,
-0.0318150334,
0.0218570959,
0.02395528,
-0.0121611021,
0.011170716,
0.0058424901,
-0.0283088367,
-0.0039090877,
0.0204075798,
-0.0032305638,
0.0191842336,
-0.0014340883,
0.0426708981,
-0.0263044182,
-0.0380919576,
0.0066492553,
0.0025547363,
-0.0139751425,
-0.0247327276,
0.0512589626,
0.0150462389,
0.0063800565,
-0.043306537,
-0.0177447721,
-0.0425358452,
0.0415140353,
-0.0156904534,
-0.0046828096,
0.021478042,
-0.0173566528,
-0.0163521003,
0.0642583817,
0.012610198,
0.0303568337,
-0.003670058,
-0.0089869807,
-0.0210702904,
0.0633434728,
-0.0242126938,
0.0613022186,
0.0361806452,
0.0246465784,
0.0261264313,
0.0707842633,
0.0113651473,
0.0300799776,
-0.0453958102,
0.0079628211,
0.0287429467,
0.0184760951,
0.0143440273,
0.0033292735,
0.06907662,
-0.0485273488,
-0.0392826796,
0.0325578041,
-0.0093562342,
-0.0850908011,
0.0126743885,
0.0221160818,
-0.0263597015,
0.0084537966,
-0.0004262603,
-0.0678945556,
-0.0492617972,
-0.001548104,
0.0195049886,
0.0432981215,
0.0001886678,
0.0074666161,
-0.0166392215,
0.0471833795,
0.0341696106,
0.055366002,
-0.0734857172,
0.0129468916,
-0.0200292915,
-0.0530137978,
0.0235589445,
0.0437342003,
0.0008775892,
-0.0160271972,
-0.0133306701,
0.067657724,
-0.0116274571,
0.0094919251,
-0.0104818409,
0.0038166917,
0.0538233779,
0.0026675495,
0.0080770487,
-0.0232245829,
-0.0413060337,
-0.0201971233,
-0.0083472161,
0.012477641,
0.0104955742,
-0.0130928848,
-0.0477173142,
-0.0071462975,
0.0269936658,
-0.0117429933,
0.0175477657,
-0.0258065369,
0.0152402027,
0.0168662462,
-0.0387099311,
-0.0101117324,
-0.0201554466,
-0.0650861934,
0.0206286199,
0.0126907658,
0.0242282636,
-0.021455029,
-0.0005166046,
0.0329285711,
-0.0676360428,
-0.131805867,
0.0370572656,
0.0206644479,
-0.1083187163,
-0.0176070891,
-0.002740962,
-0.0009567146,
0.011136272,
-0.0331895724,
-0.0867271274,
0.0517290942,
0.0153713571,
-0.1060238332,
-0.0118769286,
-0.0357184373,
-0.0132425539,
-0.0435532704,
0.0183961373,
0.0280366819,
0.0059178765,
0.0312415306,
0.0473799445,
-0.0923060998,
0.0032717995,
0.0324757434,
0.0266866554,
0.0026524058,
0.0275277495,
0.0207149629,
-0.0042744819,
0.0675626248,
0.0390537307,
-0.0185339954,
0.0551560633,
0.0223637819,
-0.057914041,
-0.0080840355,
0.0443469249,
-0.0172739215,
0.0526049733,
-0.0154569941,
0.0398830958,
-0.0611128435,
-0.0231910311,
0.0163564608,
-0.0513370298,
0.0510249697,
0.017771177,
0.0628445819,
0.0519704334,
0.0440790541,
0.0319929533,
0.024766814,
-0.0524555445,
-0.0013921327,
-0.0038217967,
-0.0333267897,
0.0132998778,
0.0291403569,
0.0424816608,
-0.0586257204,
0.0035994162,
0.0083141783,
-0.0672374517,
-0.0226314552,
0.010725243,
-0.0289221443,
0.0031504205,
-0.0139088705,
0.0497153588,
0.0334319957,
-0.0125622982,
0.0043869535,
0.010160001,
0.038163729,
0.0051433742,
0.0073483884,
0.0002631404,
-0.016491048,
-0.042486392,
-0.0671625286,
0.0662393719,
0.0013996972,
0.0510851815,
0.0003338562,
-0.0135718025,
-0.0233144518,
0.0318872072,
0.0070625874,
0.0055561922,
0.0093086259,
0.0048253518,
0.0257299002,
-0.0225499645,
0.0200170036,
-0.0354606062,
-0.0213539898,
0.0059581008,
0.0346127264,
-0.0368515588,
-0.0297207162,
-0.0667956769,
-0.0142141497,
0.0192393139,
-0.0095791053,
0.031517107,
-0.0291229747,
0.0169700235,
-0.0526522659,
-0.0227477588,
-0.0313127339,
0.0473397225,
-0.0270515122,
0.0107549969,
-0.0379947275,
0.0259212311,
0.0006555749,
0.0072848042,
-0.0262459219,
0.01908556,
-6.475431771e-33,
-0.0075543197,
0.0032425993,
0.00847473,
-0.0098032551,
-0.0127070034,
0.0396440141,
0.0035583135,
0.0020541803,
-0.0017964778,
-0.0056030005,
-0.0339919887,
0.0310524367,
0.0235166661,
0.0370253734,
0.0078279357,
-0.0143408785,
0.0712582916,
-0.048107855,
-0.0146028372,
0.0647682399,
-0.0291171726,
0.0045615723,
0.0650549531,
0.008362662,
-0.0866444036,
0.0318451189,
-0.0012662162,
-0.0512240268,
0.0375226587,
0.0152542992,
-0.0128421169,
-0.0195468068,
-0.0137133151,
-0.0849023387,
-0.0197628736,
-0.0245892741,
-0.0818302408,
0.0470166691,
-0.0899603516,
0.0346699096,
-0.0430268683,
-0.0374427401,
0.0205223188,
0.0194756147,
-0.0293819737,
-0.0824725702,
-0.0156749692,
0.0162489414,
-0.0185180549,
-0.0891101509,
0.0259495154,
0.0492507592,
-0.0360078327,
-0.0113401441,
0.0676278546,
-0.031532187,
-0.0508169979,
0.0170421675,
-0.0985336229,
-0.0022067379,
0.0145078162,
0.0751038194,
0.0395056754,
-0.0033934147,
0.0023876212,
-0.011283733,
0.0436566472,
-0.0429646112,
-0.0233425591,
0.0302289277,
0.0297343284,
0.0241683722,
0.0805152059,
-0.0102384826,
0.0812102035,
0.0028687625,
-0.027248634,
-0.002357299,
-0.0573374778,
0.0557848401,
0.0583432391,
0.023088336,
0.0441889763,
-0.0075355223,
0.0128441788,
0.0208758432,
-0.0213945825,
-0.0035305172,
0.0040402636,
0.064847447,
-0.0406227149,
0.0120212063,
0.0679422244,
-0.0393505245,
0.0407493934,
0.0135635808,
0.0009842643,
0.0505757108,
0.0106804296,
-0.0035820822,
-0.0163029339,
0.0344234258,
0.0513706617,
0.0097055314,
-0.0060346229,
-0.0056576319,
-0.002105433,
0.0678430349,
-0.0561361723,
-0.0508396588,
-0.0329798125,
0.0161852632,
0.0003797351,
0.0131746829,
0.0147485398,
-0.0160363894,
0.0093150977,
0.05684378,
-0.0624527894,
0.0173636787,
-0.0105554136,
0.0300125182,
0.0257360414,
0.0554877259,
-0.0306729935,
0.0288653597,
-0.1114619598,
0.0253399033,
0.0399369374,
-0.058804173,
-0.0423858799,
0.053945303,
2.825e-7,
0.0010947294,
0.0386076048,
0.0292392559,
-0.0095352782,
-0.0204849076,
0.0320814997,
0.0263540428,
0.0699478984,
-0.008788364,
-0.0068963808,
0.0226669423,
0.081448704,
-0.0126094976,
0.0020313249,
-0.050973922,
-0.0140425274,
-0.035328038,
0.0366922058,
-0.0132120196,
-0.0381485783,
-0.001224799,
0.0817965344,
-0.0505403616,
0.0013051567,
0.103444986,
0.043960128,
0.0031360157,
0.0693730265,
0.0256497264,
0.0118770683,
0.0136255827,
-0.015944574,
-0.022379363,
-0.0435359851,
0.010093987,
-0.0240930077,
-0.0157398805,
0.0581041649,
-0.0140576009,
-0.1066217497,
0.0022268833,
0.0211403333,
-0.0180838909,
0.0180887505,
0.0405381024,
-0.0598792359,
-0.0332038999,
-0.0155981267,
-0.0406745076,
0.0145555316,
-0.0349594578,
-0.0062641227,
0.0257631298,
0.0299493801,
0.0231336001,
0.0129368817,
-0.005080713,
-0.0646086037,
0.0098260539,
-0.0068167141,
-0.024281064,
0.0113768633,
-0.0806858987,
-0.0263325386,
0.0151251247,
0.0530962236,
-0.0362144746,
2.432968183e-34,
-0.0119980061,
0.0163814239,
0.0215124339,
0.0317795537,
-0.0124296807,
-0.0381646119,
-0.0296507273,
0.0368775278,
-0.0195690244,
-0.0528213121,
-0.0355964005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16349v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16349v2 | Human Feedback is not Gold Standard | 2023-09-28T11:18:20 | 2024-01-16T16:51:33 | Tom Hosking, Phil Blunsom, Max Bartolo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human feedback has become the de facto standard for evaluating the
performance of Large Language Models, and is increasingly being used as a
training objective. However, it is not clear which properties of a generated
output this single `preference' score captures. We hypothesise that preference
scores are subjective and open to undesirable biases. We critically analyse the
use of human feedback for both training and evaluation, to verify whether it
fully captures a range of crucial error criteria. We find that while preference
scores have fairly good coverage, they under-represent important aspects like
factuality. We further hypothesise that both preference scores and error
annotation may be affected by confounders, and leverage instruction-tuned
models to generate outputs that vary along two possible confounding dimensions:
assertiveness and complexity. We find that the assertiveness of an output skews
the perceived rate of factuality errors, indicating that human annotations are
not a fully reliable evaluation metric or training objective. Finally, we offer
preliminary evidence that using human feedback as a training objective
disproportionately increases the assertiveness of model outputs. We encourage
future work to carefully consider whether preference scores are well aligned
with the desired objective. | [
0.0446111187,
0.0556757785,
-0.0083862087,
0.0107700564,
-0.0156677552,
0.0295059402,
-0.0079700071,
-0.0242645834,
-0.0171275381,
-0.0589546748,
-0.0642296374,
-0.0520258658,
0.0328628197,
-0.0043846024,
0.0644073188,
-0.0481334515,
0.0560615249,
-0.0292016733,
0.0137795527,
0.0085219629,
-0.0032348537,
0.0103419134,
-0.0052968184,
0.0454987697,
-0.0381874107,
-0.0064118481,
0.0173226222,
-0.0032735462,
-0.0021156876,
-0.0182517339,
0.0107029919,
0.073515214,
-0.0114075486,
0.0436708517,
0.0000019863,
-0.0370159522,
0.0390286855,
0.0001127465,
-0.0493571982,
0.0676252171,
0.0444974825,
0.0154507291,
-0.0090245549,
0.0121721542,
-0.0075198254,
-0.0556031279,
0.0298015103,
0.0304444227,
0.0219014231,
0.0855607465,
0.0093266126,
-0.0061675343,
-0.0047934949,
-0.0328268372,
-0.0150766419,
-0.000733321,
0.0007149377,
-0.0041202935,
-0.0006248544,
0.0320943929,
-0.0064684874,
0.0131250182,
0.0172759499,
-0.0090794563,
0.0169174597,
0.0414654352,
-0.0084793158,
-0.0468194187,
-0.0047963485,
0.0411327891,
0.0178269707,
-0.019253511,
-0.0370604433,
-0.026891686,
0.0128731104,
-0.0139465006,
-0.0062326528,
0.0436742976,
-0.0012559198,
0.0152818216,
0.0304751676,
0.0042572245,
0.0252165645,
-0.0006864484,
0.0053918697,
0.0555989556,
0.0024727546,
-0.0405371189,
0.0307550654,
0.0543612428,
-0.0606237724,
-0.0607277304,
-0.0055917567,
-0.0330180451,
-0.0476818569,
0.0037535923,
-0.0549490005,
0.0010950859,
0.0248436164,
-0.0595619157,
0.0751069337,
0.0201525521,
-0.0329635292,
0.0075476733,
-0.0034173341,
0.0842735618,
0.0215344355,
0.0432480723,
-0.0374174267,
0.0206461623,
-0.016570203,
0.0023364485,
0.0155447321,
0.022411149,
0.0138408188,
0.0101286191,
-0.0503948517,
-0.0035941179,
-0.0088843545,
0.0137759056,
0.0069695222,
0.0152195347,
-0.036639303,
0.0120225139,
-0.0637610033,
0.0222836062,
-0.0376883261,
0.0193160865,
0.02232958,
-0.0764141902,
-0.0018263259,
0.0353887975,
-0.0340101123,
-0.0204450544,
-0.0029023481,
0.0204747673,
-0.0032607575,
-0.0251607466,
0.002541028,
-0.0110247247,
-0.0309088808,
-0.084046945,
-0.0200816132,
-0.0517179891,
-0.0096518947,
0.0191564336,
0.0002895241,
-0.0203681309,
0.0053396127,
0.0274194553,
-0.0206490587,
0.0281674117,
-0.010059176,
0.0079660527,
-0.0152785629,
-0.0067770495,
0.0133989025,
0.0383827798,
0.0502968356,
0.027270183,
0.0348359384,
-0.0058246884,
0.0242976695,
0.0153937703,
0.0081454217,
-0.0251584109,
-0.0071573006,
-0.0007198075,
-0.0196791384,
0.029446682,
0.0545801148,
0.0789213479,
-0.0319816582,
-0.0198029596,
0.098426722,
0.0103695374,
-0.0180247873,
-0.0003433502,
0.0444591939,
0.0183156468,
0.0130168665,
0.0546366349,
-0.0640987605,
0.0162632987,
-0.0152328946,
0.0099908272,
0.0237895269,
-0.0144745382,
-0.0095502334,
-0.087702021,
-0.0439494997,
-0.0053454847,
0.0176664311,
0.0201018192,
0.0455671027,
0.0099336253,
-0.0521197878,
0.0277739223,
0.029862415,
-0.0524382703,
0.0069867773,
-0.073841244,
0.0522828363,
0.062324781,
0.0338845961,
0.0220029596,
-0.0078222957,
0.0055954726,
-0.0007546847,
0.0618484542,
0.0986045972,
-0.0276705548,
-0.0028963319,
-0.0393605307,
-0.0040999427,
-0.0010083012,
0.0306738056,
0.0135389697,
0.0371021889,
-0.0423091426,
-0.0028925862,
-0.0298457071,
-0.0963702649,
0.0407963134,
0.0105425082,
-0.0366875269,
0.0009816255,
-0.0023810063,
0.0203571226,
0.0174061172,
-0.0246633701,
0.046456486,
0.0259614885,
0.0155787077,
-0.0123558836,
-0.008108574,
-0.0548428111,
-0.0162092801,
0.0089719407,
0.011843292,
-0.0238303784,
0.046840284,
-0.0019111154,
-0.0213721879,
0.0122799715,
-0.0752167255,
0.0117284562,
-0.0192473549,
0.0235304423,
-0.0102714542,
0.0012989109,
-0.0497323237,
0.031165041,
-0.0090596667,
0.0182391275,
-0.0031393692,
0.0023709242,
-0.0154845836,
-0.0277269166,
-0.0323393643,
0.00420606,
0.0030921001,
0.0146434773,
0.0494961701,
-0.0000766099,
-0.0385696255,
-0.0011515437,
-0.1127838567,
-0.0045207697,
-0.0328834169,
0.017568808,
0.0156327654,
-0.031363491,
-0.0005116998,
-0.0042381412,
-0.0135429911,
-0.0598015152,
-0.0291509349,
0.0232811216,
0.0462641232,
0.0069616241,
-0.000325446,
-0.0754669756,
-0.01746957,
-0.0220667571,
0.0122595951,
0.0051726722,
0.0316297486,
-0.0529843457,
0.045779977,
-0.0078977449,
0.0146816596,
-0.0018907205,
-0.0439391918,
0.0571500137,
0.0181579348,
0.0248977989,
0.0888019353,
0.0030146674,
0.0492722653,
0.0368768945,
0.0045031989,
-0.0538031422,
-0.0050547421,
-0.0443728492,
-0.0342205986,
-0.0204807464,
-0.0411360338,
-0.0186391734,
0.0665026009,
0.0510187708,
0.0135344435,
-0.0734764859,
-0.00232478,
-0.0628548563,
-0.0487646721,
0.0026202414,
-0.0216930956,
-0.0142962188,
0.0686371624,
-0.0350808986,
-0.0517065376,
0.1030938849,
-0.0308087636,
-0.0138422791,
-0.0365098044,
0.0007440615,
-0.0099683218,
0.0272280462,
0.0185132045,
-0.0184062198,
0.0347964838,
0.0080384659,
-0.0462891385,
-0.0358177982,
0.0359544568,
-0.032530196,
0.0360371619,
-0.0633329302,
-0.011627649,
0.0351642556,
-0.0557898954,
-0.0356478393,
-0.0492294356,
-0.0135547416,
0.0113027878,
0.0368401743,
-0.0252115373,
-0.0111132199,
-0.0095742568,
0.038280908,
0.0188808981,
-0.0251265671,
-0.0214630496,
0.013918547,
-0.0107414788,
0.0421670899,
0.0207990091,
0.060627576,
-0.0547594279,
-0.0179312732,
0.0556139164,
0.0291634109,
0.0473025478,
-0.0374742784,
0.0075175101,
0.035834115,
0.0033177384,
-0.0466479249,
0.0170320477,
0.0918218866,
-0.0622867905,
-0.0221349262,
0.1279676706,
0.0256859437,
0.0067075882,
0.0187369697,
0.0200901404,
0.0557122715,
0.0225172956,
0.0099240495,
-0.0401942022,
-0.0281977691,
0.0072843637,
0.0559493341,
-0.0248110313,
0.0141804228,
0.0033176378,
-0.1426082104,
0.0542115681,
-0.0004574159,
-0.0232839845,
-0.0150850648,
-0.0739906952,
0.0004550669,
-0.0483739562,
0.0203385279,
0.0232678466,
0.0110136643,
0.0106481398,
0.0649556071,
-0.0348709971,
-0.060351681,
0.059244711,
-0.0399618782,
0.0523271672,
0.0924948975,
0.0077503724,
0.0075260573,
-0.04271698,
0.0354698487,
0.0054378463,
0.007036902,
-0.0232169237,
0.0412101783,
-0.022198556,
-0.0090868529,
-0.0429553799,
0.01362288,
0.0001370116,
0.0047097388,
-0.044148609,
0.0429490171,
0.0027920012,
-0.0368116125,
-0.0226702541,
0.0206817966,
-0.0110994847,
0.0654880032,
0.0371190086,
-0.0719189644,
-0.026942689,
-0.022962315,
-0.0116818808,
-0.075906001,
-0.0652213022,
0.0128812846,
0.0083019678,
-0.0335474983,
-0.0642098412,
-0.088149555,
0.0038720742,
-0.000549941,
-0.0027741403,
-0.0523041971,
0.0026777771,
-0.0202178974,
-0.0081291581,
0.0528767966,
0.0059965365,
0.0245363843,
-0.0628593639,
-0.0285088476,
0.0373522565,
-0.0112461373,
-0.0110441102,
0.0165587664,
-0.0584632009,
-0.066888608,
-0.003196541,
0.0846901238,
0.0184323508,
0.0520619638,
-0.0033879394,
-0.0728121847,
0.0099479752,
0.0083851647,
-0.0182111096,
0.0255027283,
0.0465003103,
-0.0213845018,
-0.0069283298,
0.0401865505,
-0.0118005816,
0.0142122461,
0.0168515071,
0.0277635753,
-0.0095734885,
-0.0626340955,
0.038003955,
0.0120118205,
0.0713933483,
-0.0351477079,
-0.0198172629,
-0.032714799,
-0.0079360753,
-0.0264520664,
-0.029436186,
-0.0295146406,
-0.0083066588,
0.0164325368,
0.015404704,
-0.0401585214,
-0.015088818,
-0.0372979678,
0.0344387181,
-0.0435954332,
0.011542636,
0.0178603791,
0.0157560259,
0.0008862153,
0.0270497557,
-0.0555180833,
0.0111707374,
-0.0150067266,
0.0545336194,
0.0107133966,
0.0420279242,
-0.0006560117,
0.0094782757,
0.0409816392,
0.0095573515,
-0.0535412766,
0.0087261451,
-0.0517978407,
0.0018618987,
0.0353389606,
-0.029134348,
0.0968342125,
-0.0318904519,
0.0091968905,
-0.036582645,
0.0264763255,
-0.0091166608,
-0.0083544254,
0.0078326715,
0.0243856981,
-0.0161233712,
-0.0139918197,
0.0636043474,
0.022223169,
0.0425833836,
-0.0288020223,
-0.0108785592,
-0.0429043509,
-0.0307683516,
-0.0104567902,
0.0045197932,
-0.0361544378,
0.0118694967,
-0.0562821329,
-0.0635104552,
-0.0025925231,
0.0610871427,
0.0577072054,
-0.0360030606,
0.0388268381,
0.0592694618,
-0.0405921973,
-0.031209128,
-0.0600074492,
-0.0395220481,
-0.0168675873,
0.0234002005,
-0.0459140129,
-6.680502638e-33,
-0.0568384193,
-0.0249943603,
0.0018744757,
-0.0074202772,
-0.0052883853,
-0.0181699786,
-0.0316502936,
0.0549723729,
-0.0302082747,
0.026271252,
0.0097070141,
-0.0009580458,
0.016587263,
0.0080907736,
0.0391567424,
-0.003770835,
0.0512304418,
-0.0194960888,
-0.0483283065,
-0.0223012343,
0.0128081385,
-0.0217217896,
0.0638112426,
-0.081456095,
0.0717956126,
0.01357006,
-0.029982632,
0.0074340766,
-0.0672205314,
0.0770189241,
-0.011565337,
0.0657369271,
0.0066435942,
-0.0410911664,
-0.0194386598,
-0.0160754602,
-0.0337599963,
-0.0382455364,
0.0545978881,
0.0397812501,
-0.0270776134,
0.0141580505,
0.029731147,
-0.0157484226,
-0.052290719,
-0.0030660632,
0.0232381802,
0.0057807877,
-0.0202816352,
0.0417615213,
-0.0652428269,
0.0134693449,
-0.0077105789,
-0.0360555574,
0.0067196037,
0.0458779819,
-0.0298982784,
-0.0231627561,
-0.059391845,
0.025274368,
0.0069207875,
0.0545097031,
0.0608401783,
0.0245983172,
-0.0144981649,
0.0543480441,
0.0600740276,
0.0305213872,
-0.0151255876,
-0.0221725944,
0.0400981978,
0.0175641607,
0.073953405,
0.0316278152,
0.0087753609,
0.0035974956,
-0.0310125705,
-0.007738221,
0.0161343664,
0.0269461665,
0.0441128351,
0.027878046,
-0.0851717964,
-0.051598303,
-0.0410576351,
-0.0362010673,
-0.0360486731,
-0.009256334,
0.0300897136,
0.0145523036,
-0.0214404017,
-0.0022508928,
0.0026720965,
0.0061169835,
-0.019682195,
-0.0470177457,
-0.0533281043,
0.0329912193,
-0.0204318333,
-0.0111277308,
-0.0699400082,
0.0154534206,
0.0101202698,
0.0314880945,
0.0174875967,
0.015016702,
0.0277833808,
0.0341972262,
-0.0497829281,
-0.0084345052,
-0.0262427237,
0.0203162711,
0.0116846003,
0.0127829472,
0.0378772914,
0.0100451205,
-0.0304368045,
0.0589675084,
-0.0420033634,
0.0108331749,
-0.0453876592,
0.0036727733,
0.0149624776,
-0.0008796283,
-0.0250259209,
-0.0037154662,
-0.0155974841,
0.0097941766,
-0.0102410009,
-0.0218421221,
-0.0238910727,
0.0195620861,
2.521e-7,
0.0197084229,
0.076612018,
0.0183224808,
0.0419726446,
-0.0063665365,
0.0655801594,
-0.0179685969,
-0.0083126873,
0.0328313261,
-0.0054839621,
-0.0165733863,
0.01121643,
0.0839643553,
0.036827378,
-0.0536732264,
-0.0299941748,
-0.0540722013,
0.0262332167,
-0.0077709178,
-0.0082384227,
0.0577729605,
0.0791748315,
0.0229373313,
0.0083729103,
-0.0017801073,
0.0242859777,
0.0554738902,
-0.0291891322,
-0.022020366,
0.0027488011,
0.0233736169,
0.0405411422,
0.0012243828,
0.0432013161,
-0.0171152875,
-0.0256937761,
0.007580197,
0.074468635,
-0.005626976,
-0.0545054413,
0.0006297163,
0.0179931503,
0.0027014522,
-0.0583294742,
0.0418105647,
-0.0189446844,
-0.0294046719,
-0.0326547213,
0.03433102,
0.0177380722,
0.0378081538,
-0.0378980078,
-0.02983067,
-0.016407704,
0.0364297517,
0.0135455588,
-0.0360250957,
-0.0350941494,
-0.0377734303,
0.0218832996,
-0.0391957946,
-0.0618239157,
-0.0094073247,
0.0174784306,
-0.0068711201,
-0.0145490058,
-0.0182073582,
2.401223866e-34,
0.0635012612,
0.0077760601,
0.0374102853,
-0.0041140039,
0.0487532318,
0.0290074162,
0.0063962815,
-0.0061847544,
0.02732585,
-0.040965382,
-0.0391443856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16347v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16347v2 | Intrinsic Language-Guided Exploration for Complex Long-Horizon Robotic Manipulation Tasks | 2023-09-28T11:14:52 | 2024-03-07T17:53:35 | Eleftherios Triantafyllidis, Filippos Christianos, Zhibin Li | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.LG | Current reinforcement learning algorithms struggle in sparse and complex
environments, most notably in long-horizon manipulation tasks entailing a
plethora of different sequences. In this work, we propose the Intrinsically
Guided Exploration from Large Language Models (IGE-LLMs) framework. By
leveraging LLMs as an assistive intrinsic reward, IGE-LLMs guides the
exploratory process in reinforcement learning to address intricate long-horizon
with sparse rewards robotic manipulation tasks. We evaluate our framework and
related intrinsic learning methods in an environment challenged with
exploration, and a complex robotic manipulation task challenged by both
exploration and long-horizons. Results show IGE-LLMs (i) exhibit notably higher
performance over related intrinsic methods and the direct use of LLMs in
decision-making, (ii) can be combined and complement existing learning methods
highlighting its modularity, (iii) are fairly insensitive to different
intrinsic scaling parameters, and (iv) maintain robustness against increased
levels of uncertainty and horizons. | [
0.0252444595,
0.0482103936,
0.0118116764,
-0.0074901357,
-0.0329564959,
0.0081134392,
-0.0495621599,
0.0097916657,
-0.0478758253,
-0.0036268476,
-0.0256113857,
-0.0080673769,
-0.0177198127,
0.0217836685,
-0.0342134759,
-0.0455237105,
0.0441274121,
-0.0681699961,
0.0174285583,
0.0048753419,
-0.0327280797,
-0.0566605069,
-0.0097627128,
0.0425655358,
-0.0311534666,
0.0242342204,
-0.0553107075,
-0.022271676,
0.016278185,
-0.0714249238,
-0.0288058892,
0.026545953,
0.0973608866,
0.0945855752,
0.0000022457,
-0.0556311682,
-0.0166708492,
-0.0336253382,
-0.0191894956,
-0.0375839435,
0.0399189778,
0.0206160322,
-0.0188823249,
0.0188763514,
-0.0033547825,
-0.0177609697,
0.0444427915,
0.0274837613,
0.0219775699,
0.0378634892,
0.0038150374,
0.0340884328,
-0.0060116481,
-0.026657857,
0.022844594,
-0.040930327,
0.0521566197,
0.0130284866,
0.0624225736,
0.0261180177,
-0.0311605278,
-0.0132307829,
0.0509050861,
-0.0405202582,
0.012685773,
0.0755098164,
0.0214303862,
-0.0375948735,
0.0188074429,
0.0103679094,
-0.0362672694,
0.0065644379,
-0.0129359988,
0.0124063371,
0.0392348692,
0.0187584423,
-0.0700809732,
0.0383083746,
0.0322421491,
0.0094938381,
-0.0401591361,
-0.0145353153,
0.0115973726,
0.0210292637,
-0.0531300083,
0.0738200471,
-0.0017615439,
-0.000749453,
0.022373667,
-0.0079647833,
-0.0202720463,
-0.0437280908,
-0.0116710281,
0.058413174,
-0.0733563602,
0.0083359657,
-0.0292180516,
0.0125295436,
-0.0214149226,
0.0193734411,
0.0425631404,
0.0166828148,
0.0142944828,
0.0425787456,
-0.0341101214,
0.0002538672,
-0.0156267881,
0.0363325886,
-0.0192909613,
0.0216640346,
-0.0352232233,
0.0074971551,
-0.0174240842,
0.0493416414,
-0.0248351339,
-0.0517701991,
0.0010906992,
0.0359560698,
0.0064320434,
0.0227733366,
-0.0273324233,
0.0047649522,
-0.0126246922,
-0.0182713214,
-0.0713337064,
-0.0118346196,
-0.0483116657,
0.0584177189,
0.0411105491,
0.0692433417,
-0.0438306816,
0.013961372,
0.0066140471,
-0.0283560548,
0.0122678522,
0.1005795822,
-0.0092853541,
-0.0316079743,
-0.0265792999,
0.0054704561,
-0.0080214562,
-0.0284590516,
0.0174388513,
-0.0571983531,
-0.015260879,
-0.0220362879,
-0.0182107221,
-0.0087177996,
0.0284420829,
0.0103852646,
-0.0093538966,
0.0538266823,
0.066913031,
0.0283324271,
0.0103430906,
-0.0053655128,
-0.016143214,
0.0488809422,
0.0327171721,
0.0706501231,
-0.0214085542,
0.0229772087,
0.0190284215,
0.0405486822,
-0.029779505,
0.0155563392,
-0.0244157743,
-0.0474800579,
0.0520481467,
0.0719989687,
0.000476082,
0.0254478808,
-0.0452253222,
0.0338374153,
0.0506273508,
0.0618986562,
-0.0259704627,
-0.0093839923,
0.0048081041,
-0.0300685391,
-0.0567946844,
-0.05667926,
-0.0563577078,
0.0800794885,
0.0084975483,
-0.0100342706,
-0.0094145862,
-0.0091206683,
-0.0038972709,
-0.0274490807,
0.0121218646,
0.0133522898,
0.0451981723,
-0.0034859488,
0.0829457268,
-0.0146494238,
-0.0522712432,
-0.041018974,
0.0348831527,
-0.0029388245,
-0.0051679718,
-0.0188971013,
0.0258434098,
0.0055102874,
0.0218260214,
-0.0635245815,
-0.0297137089,
-0.0377103202,
-0.0367672816,
0.0705113858,
-0.0364858396,
-0.0145864785,
-0.0156600811,
-0.0005826866,
-0.0608659498,
0.00606733,
-0.0150039373,
0.0405485034,
0.0344202369,
0.0373629257,
-0.020966338,
-0.0178959426,
-0.0315613374,
0.031597279,
-0.0433493219,
-0.0229547769,
0.0396061651,
0.0005547837,
0.0103107225,
-0.0116341216,
0.0096226707,
0.0014917778,
0.0374308936,
-0.0258641616,
-0.0512043461,
-0.0231121927,
-0.0611140318,
0.0013913374,
0.0504441187,
-0.0348172262,
0.0160436463,
-0.0017460769,
0.0050884122,
-0.0485080145,
0.0300200433,
-0.0184091982,
0.0312040094,
0.0352293216,
0.0373024195,
-0.0066337213,
-0.032212317,
-0.0553067066,
0.0348349139,
-0.0199663229,
0.0071368064,
0.003951503,
-0.0046314602,
-0.0069168359,
-0.0582209453,
-0.0185466707,
0.022453621,
-0.0050084651,
-0.0140536726,
0.0518292859,
0.0225528367,
-0.0198722109,
-0.0470653325,
-0.0577914007,
-0.0402708575,
0.0163091868,
-0.0065248068,
-0.0022319146,
-0.0169343017,
-0.0183671527,
-0.0188257899,
0.0568128861,
0.0097973263,
-0.0087520871,
-0.0127212657,
0.0273396093,
0.0689573959,
-0.0290054325,
-0.0392511263,
-0.0200775918,
-0.0145181064,
-0.0056461915,
0.0233422723,
0.0394570567,
-0.0407292545,
0.0124232294,
-0.0346334986,
0.0284244865,
-0.0329885557,
-0.0226983149,
0.0224987268,
-0.0662942901,
0.0027332716,
0.0885488242,
-0.0111891981,
0.0280552339,
0.0618765019,
-0.0153937628,
-0.0459321924,
0.0134026166,
-0.042512916,
-0.0351926573,
-0.0212254953,
0.0329272486,
0.0512326807,
0.0750156417,
-0.0379308723,
-0.0025636004,
-0.051235348,
0.0085178129,
-0.04733878,
-0.0286642704,
-0.0460930169,
0.0121068805,
-0.0469053835,
-0.0209710859,
-0.058764372,
-0.0419944525,
0.0761683062,
0.0079085259,
0.009295525,
0.0188222509,
-0.0255344212,
-0.0301644951,
0.0900452286,
-0.0010932904,
0.0015818629,
0.0087677455,
-0.0425167345,
-0.0269166064,
0.0586910732,
0.0014152538,
0.0090744877,
0.0530546792,
-0.0498693213,
0.032984715,
0.0074404734,
-0.0519666635,
-0.0394930243,
0.0185300522,
0.0148405498,
0.0097091207,
-0.0003608881,
-0.0585357584,
-0.0314046629,
-0.0195611641,
0.0770576596,
0.0515687615,
-0.0196110103,
-0.0030380145,
-0.0384513997,
-0.0447383896,
0.0235595647,
0.0236435384,
-0.0215119999,
-0.0437944122,
0.0285476428,
0.0148099912,
0.0102708833,
-0.0632290691,
-0.0252029635,
0.0163314007,
0.0001802485,
-0.0233966168,
0.0267194472,
0.0227911193,
0.0232534632,
-0.03734231,
-0.0522438958,
0.070584774,
0.032869067,
-0.0532812588,
0.027550118,
-0.0505678393,
0.0638393536,
0.0423643067,
0.0226721521,
-0.0083000325,
-0.0095833037,
0.0141649665,
0.002394099,
-0.0004131045,
-0.051377371,
0.0435574688,
-0.1389460713,
0.0152166123,
0.0073081497,
-0.0569969676,
-0.0502913892,
-0.0281914957,
0.0168485083,
-0.0040246807,
-0.0245487522,
0.0442965291,
-0.0133994352,
-0.0024449471,
0.0027408747,
0.0402839929,
-0.0309899747,
0.0242178608,
-0.0108401831,
-0.0173452683,
0.0320200995,
0.0062470902,
-0.0462862886,
0.0393162817,
0.0243814681,
0.0531697609,
0.0178394206,
-0.0181027222,
-0.014641908,
0.0312430058,
-0.0101299435,
0.0057421001,
0.0871090218,
-0.011023486,
-0.0535611436,
-0.0110101355,
0.0832323581,
-0.0350795984,
0.0170197599,
-0.0006409974,
-0.079791382,
0.0226266459,
0.0525906384,
-0.0357456952,
-0.042169068,
-0.0258122217,
-0.0369184837,
-0.0708046407,
-0.0102372747,
-0.0214090198,
-0.0054331273,
0.0000460439,
0.0309155378,
-0.0738212615,
-0.0163362082,
0.0696519017,
0.0484141596,
-0.0043858103,
-0.000006799,
-0.0045599509,
0.0118948678,
-0.0191383325,
0.0138800004,
-0.0276831649,
0.0031923852,
-0.0737680122,
0.037121892,
0.0254003871,
-0.0226396043,
-0.0285112616,
-0.0062126634,
-0.0406380929,
-0.0665600225,
-0.0297593884,
0.0362438448,
0.0117786545,
0.0310021304,
-0.0087205349,
-0.0253662486,
0.0756983608,
-0.0013297681,
0.0007548085,
0.0264084227,
0.0005649245,
0.0680246949,
0.0132444575,
0.0261744373,
-0.0379066616,
0.0034851329,
-0.00040986,
0.0364820249,
0.0035946164,
0.0166551545,
0.0337930061,
-0.0279822666,
0.0520019345,
0.0031540026,
0.0102170557,
-0.0450870693,
0.0125413528,
-0.0168764424,
-0.025652837,
-0.0514006615,
0.0203684215,
0.0332555659,
0.0076465807,
0.0326215476,
0.0187232271,
0.0541566946,
0.026080057,
-0.0312184095,
0.0281188153,
-0.0049185832,
-0.0079347333,
0.0463663228,
0.0346101932,
0.0384884141,
-0.0168600995,
-0.0407564156,
0.0461612977,
0.0109804943,
0.0613871105,
0.0483852178,
0.0155832339,
-0.0411156379,
-0.0262487698,
-0.0406210423,
-0.0814190209,
-0.0017959259,
0.0116483392,
0.065572165,
-0.0068243006,
-0.0183005072,
-0.0749380738,
0.0066833389,
0.0087509593,
-0.0114468206,
-0.0156737659,
-0.0125349248,
0.032513883,
0.0429832675,
0.0192895494,
0.0396815166,
0.0537368543,
-0.0355590507,
0.0660079196,
-0.0173874013,
0.0158312358,
-0.0555918403,
-0.0189754236,
0.0508029871,
-0.0031648558,
-0.009690403,
0.0119011914,
0.003127049,
-0.0341128409,
-0.0450419895,
0.0325727016,
-0.0052446397,
-0.0156389177,
0.0421552099,
-0.0094253225,
-0.0399707444,
-0.0059837997,
-0.0024151583,
-0.0504653491,
0.0278024115,
-0.0249885581,
-0.0577773713,
-6.283211262e-33,
-0.0050728018,
-0.0146763846,
0.0344358496,
-0.0497992523,
-0.0450396053,
-0.0352518372,
-0.0186214224,
0.0444812775,
0.022770362,
0.0485232919,
-0.0041650836,
-0.0093304459,
-0.0145773804,
0.0393065028,
0.0561127961,
-0.0010030528,
0.0256880876,
0.0021245764,
-0.0554501861,
-0.0044389605,
0.0481936932,
0.0091837421,
0.030072825,
-0.0180485584,
-0.0041901837,
0.0561942235,
-0.007679747,
0.0655899793,
0.0233312603,
0.0237557683,
0.0040337206,
-0.0447772108,
-0.0022275962,
-0.0347352475,
-0.0305160191,
0.0155221149,
-0.0547257997,
-0.0521405861,
-0.0488857031,
-0.0190541036,
-0.0184405539,
-0.0301746223,
0.0284316614,
0.0021743628,
-0.0207125973,
0.0360448956,
-0.0000321431,
-0.0213976,
-0.0230160952,
0.0401060842,
-0.0122380415,
0.0143862786,
-0.0018036326,
-0.0358788222,
0.0289345607,
0.008319892,
-0.0043599638,
0.0008458497,
0.0092888391,
0.0052125598,
-0.0212990828,
0.0363431573,
0.0356487446,
0.0412540697,
0.0708016902,
0.0403447561,
-0.0645394549,
-0.0446780808,
-0.0051870905,
0.0056222389,
0.0337813944,
0.0423799604,
-0.0192300584,
-0.0060145222,
0.0267681926,
0.0736235231,
-0.0269575994,
0.0064026308,
-0.0288929399,
0.1141043305,
0.0387778804,
0.0502670407,
-0.0133236432,
0.0012435962,
-0.0423278213,
0.013782952,
-0.0076072742,
-0.006108935,
0.0517201535,
0.0689228326,
0.0134573495,
-0.0870476291,
0.0595934987,
-0.0186373945,
-0.0078083253,
0.0307766609,
-0.0211793464,
0.0559504852,
0.0024791926,
-0.0419325605,
-0.0524826013,
-0.0488114171,
-0.0050414251,
-0.0294537693,
-0.0127877844,
0.0084892036,
-0.0474483036,
0.058573883,
-0.0250293817,
0.0102026379,
-0.023460418,
0.0014862183,
0.0109002069,
-0.0051789149,
0.0880508274,
-0.025011586,
-0.0189191252,
0.0689044744,
0.0081250779,
-0.0202004146,
0.016999919,
-0.0112181781,
-0.0315476991,
-0.0107297571,
-0.0237211064,
-0.0158678237,
-0.0297114402,
-0.0200588778,
0.0202629752,
-0.0801446885,
0.0057699005,
0.0227068681,
2.948e-7,
-0.0391678065,
0.0705283806,
0.0128366053,
0.043846108,
0.0099827601,
0.0315037929,
-0.0202998109,
-0.0140082762,
-0.04357858,
-0.0098473309,
0.0389271714,
0.046535749,
0.0089934291,
-0.0424970575,
-0.0749145821,
-0.0254952181,
-0.0173976775,
-0.0239720345,
-0.0559118651,
-0.0273724701,
0.0276519619,
0.0925673917,
0.0190400966,
0.0255250018,
0.0338263027,
-0.0644242987,
0.0360328369,
-0.0534289666,
0.0468306206,
-0.015052828,
-0.0259663593,
0.0212904438,
-0.0058921296,
-0.0207890533,
-0.0051834635,
0.0608769655,
-0.0094182193,
0.0584823564,
-0.0161798466,
0.0082169278,
-0.0088938382,
0.0349991284,
0.015951857,
-0.0442567728,
0.025207486,
-0.0995103717,
0.0134644741,
-0.0005464163,
0.0174497627,
-0.0066834888,
-0.0119110374,
-0.0125685753,
0.007934751,
-0.0199530348,
0.0027249479,
0.0390704907,
0.0025278241,
-0.082171537,
-0.0052441927,
0.0505786613,
-0.0735160932,
-0.0051278872,
-0.0319992565,
-0.0018926235,
-0.0253287572,
-0.0399242155,
-0.014872063,
2.77102796e-34,
0.0118176807,
-0.052287519,
-0.0074047409,
0.0270428862,
0.0330987573,
0.0365926139,
-0.0039867088,
0.0352889448,
0.0678403378,
-0.0382752009,
-0.0368854664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16319v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16319v2 | Augmenting Transformers with Recursively Composed Multi-grained Representations | 2023-09-28T10:24:39 | 2024-03-12T03:43:57 | Xiang Hu, Qingyang Zhu, Kewei Tu, Wei Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present ReCAT, a recursive composition augmented Transformer that is able
to explicitly model hierarchical syntactic structures of raw texts without
relying on gold trees during both learning and inference. Existing research
along this line restricts data to follow a hierarchical tree structure and thus
lacks inter-span communications. To overcome the problem, we propose a novel
contextual inside-outside (CIO) layer that learns contextualized
representations of spans through bottom-up and top-down passes, where a
bottom-up pass forms representations of high-level spans by composing low-level
spans, while a top-down pass combines information inside and outside a span. By
stacking several CIO layers between the embedding layer and the attention
layers in Transformer, the ReCAT model can perform both deep intra-span and
deep inter-span interactions, and thus generate multi-grained representations
fully contextualized with other spans. Moreover, the CIO layers can be jointly
pre-trained with Transformers, making ReCAT enjoy scaling ability, strong
performance, and interpretability at the same time. We conduct experiments on
various sentence-level and span-level tasks. Evaluation results indicate that
ReCAT can significantly outperform vanilla Transformer models on all span-level
tasks and baselines that combine recursive networks with Transformers on
natural language inference tasks. More interestingly, the hierarchical
structures induced by ReCAT exhibit strong consistency with human-annotated
syntactic trees, indicating good interpretability brought by the CIO layers. | [
0.0124389641,
0.0036344209,
-0.0134341503,
0.0638841912,
0.0158794969,
0.0147894695,
-0.0251322947,
-0.0537574738,
0.0048547247,
-0.0351645127,
-0.0203604065,
-0.009960996,
0.0003372078,
0.0382634737,
0.0200833641,
-0.067722626,
0.0155293224,
0.0020549672,
-0.0016001383,
0.0232002698,
0.0116975475,
0.0180827733,
0.0183460712,
0.0353914909,
-0.0144186625,
-0.0266613457,
0.0032590288,
0.0130192842,
0.0232369434,
-0.025728453,
0.0557201579,
0.0171359517,
0.0509834364,
0.0565450825,
0.0000019539,
0.0050372621,
-0.0035196748,
-0.0036833829,
-0.0198492911,
-0.0185653064,
0.0364370123,
-0.0462074168,
0.0004251454,
-0.0228955057,
-0.0203507077,
-0.0004756277,
0.031733349,
0.088674143,
0.0627685562,
0.0419753827,
-0.0271558519,
-0.0764925182,
0.0376269296,
-0.0335279852,
-0.0029411423,
-0.0423444659,
-0.0083368048,
-0.0157047156,
-0.0122109866,
0.0432435423,
-0.0281326734,
0.0001363029,
0.0757577196,
-0.0374717303,
0.0174055845,
0.0321516283,
-0.0290907994,
0.020458512,
-0.0044931737,
0.0795644373,
-0.0344547406,
-0.0319987535,
-0.0298694298,
-0.019737944,
0.0053298655,
-0.0471618958,
-0.0239351802,
0.038039837,
-0.0085229054,
0.0193066355,
0.0028467018,
0.0288222544,
0.0355182327,
-0.0059451526,
-0.0206155404,
0.0529506505,
0.0100365095,
-0.0255129561,
0.0135676619,
0.0382649936,
0.0227440652,
-0.0430645011,
0.0214208644,
0.0270007979,
-0.0175586734,
0.0055514849,
-0.0274333209,
-0.0110079059,
-0.0190075859,
0.0080347294,
-0.0073475977,
0.0275639948,
-0.0462803021,
0.023360014,
-0.0427039377,
0.0231986772,
-0.0824675336,
0.013924269,
-0.0381344557,
-0.0300448686,
-0.0358427912,
-0.0425073728,
-0.0360882543,
0.0249464903,
-0.0487355962,
-0.0218894761,
-0.039504312,
0.0117243687,
-0.0156461634,
-0.0258687288,
-0.0175952055,
0.0258539673,
-0.051882904,
-0.0150976013,
0.0006060809,
0.0680838749,
-0.0339970961,
0.0312954709,
0.0169886295,
0.0020104435,
-0.0330526717,
0.0325244032,
0.0015781455,
-0.0297771636,
-0.0100299539,
0.0492874794,
-0.0071028909,
-0.0224386416,
-0.0127703492,
-0.0287660807,
-0.0381014086,
-0.0354664363,
0.0437890403,
-0.04867623,
0.0153769339,
-0.0311641693,
-0.0267537329,
0.038325835,
0.0036198013,
0.0420597829,
-0.014205155,
0.0546553954,
0.0253488831,
-0.0776344985,
-0.0316401906,
0.0021416957,
0.0473295785,
0.0448475666,
0.0375994369,
0.0592302084,
-0.0239260457,
0.0129539268,
-0.0089220004,
0.011856406,
-0.0049402416,
-0.0091625107,
-0.0234757848,
-0.0055215564,
-0.041246172,
0.0079301829,
0.0278667025,
-0.0051911529,
-0.0272003189,
-0.0274598487,
0.0407787897,
0.0113451583,
0.0393784419,
0.0317372605,
0.0669619292,
-0.0040800287,
-0.0232578069,
0.0283732153,
-0.054925587,
0.0478296578,
-0.0358394086,
-0.0045978352,
-0.033924669,
0.0057414453,
-0.0115915136,
-0.0169132873,
0.0174913388,
-0.0301376525,
0.0183168463,
0.0014577358,
0.0600677952,
0.0633862913,
-0.0319442824,
0.0488501005,
0.0377338603,
-0.0578303337,
-0.0017880534,
0.0088534746,
0.0039813975,
0.0536163673,
0.0191228092,
-0.0222941861,
-0.0078414334,
-0.0208421517,
0.0339245349,
0.0571717359,
-0.0011187904,
-0.0024404966,
0.0172908492,
-0.0348282754,
-0.0334072635,
-0.0288812052,
0.0149648404,
0.0218193308,
-0.0141057558,
-0.0385422595,
0.0194862392,
-0.0263413116,
0.0170626119,
0.0485006794,
0.008018842,
0.0140668061,
0.0016898076,
-0.0020125364,
0.004946148,
0.0120847011,
0.0238568205,
0.0149198305,
0.039198678,
-0.0453529246,
-0.0806604475,
0.0150304073,
-0.09906701,
-0.0796233118,
-0.0122401407,
-0.0794148222,
-0.042796094,
0.0184304062,
-0.0559098087,
-0.0242779646,
0.0097598415,
-0.0601111539,
0.0493913591,
-0.031502828,
-0.0128270956,
0.011594261,
0.022010671,
-0.0166821424,
0.0906715766,
-0.0105114896,
-0.0128583135,
-0.0054475642,
0.0012088662,
0.0306071937,
-0.002164518,
-0.0155815547,
-0.0136630358,
-0.0232671276,
-0.0386044122,
0.0222785044,
0.004566377,
-0.0382543989,
-0.029860707,
-0.0439477973,
0.0135735152,
-0.0220832657,
0.0094694048,
0.0352729522,
0.0119628273,
0.0378700085,
-0.0296564959,
-0.021864444,
0.0271699093,
-0.0278507136,
0.0181410201,
0.0561922304,
-0.0404309854,
0.0012065021,
-0.0065259095,
-0.041334644,
-0.0644075796,
0.0730698705,
-0.0045713945,
-0.0290236287,
-0.0185858104,
-0.0412249342,
0.0036814848,
0.0273812301,
-0.0233727787,
-0.0262467861,
0.0033037751,
-0.0187558141,
0.0489842817,
0.0713675097,
-0.0035452275,
0.0436419323,
0.0274826344,
0.0015895281,
-0.0144164907,
0.0354466215,
-0.0109759141,
0.0268258192,
-0.0306945555,
0.018089503,
-0.0056430944,
0.1073619649,
-0.0139753148,
0.0053723762,
-0.0373701192,
-0.0251343288,
0.0155021297,
-0.0216302238,
-0.0142332995,
-0.0474724099,
-0.0253918525,
0.017339604,
-0.0538230129,
-0.0017944248,
0.0686104447,
-0.0164088868,
-0.0480303466,
-0.0142505299,
0.0123090316,
-0.0692745447,
0.0757680833,
0.0406490229,
-0.0100251529,
0.0175480731,
-0.050184492,
-0.0454216823,
0.0337201878,
0.0316490084,
0.0025549068,
0.0249970183,
-0.0056879106,
0.014336884,
-0.0304407794,
-0.0232053306,
-0.0287080612,
-0.0241100062,
-0.0202041306,
0.0133772483,
-0.0159882326,
-0.006168426,
-0.070348911,
-0.0246883407,
0.0385638326,
0.050006289,
-0.0031376306,
-0.0074731177,
-0.0261513367,
0.0520261303,
0.0068501043,
0.0338129774,
0.0545916371,
-0.0142431473,
0.0148889562,
0.0594928078,
-0.0474662296,
0.0108870519,
-0.0400972776,
0.0398931205,
0.0078763878,
0.0100086825,
-0.0330866724,
0.0116031207,
0.0362153687,
-0.1001469195,
0.0008975046,
0.0727310777,
0.0292285755,
-0.065606989,
0.011897088,
-0.0131962486,
0.0096062971,
0.0480309464,
-0.0013574584,
-0.1204024404,
-0.0562929772,
0.0129936654,
-0.052315522,
0.046443332,
-0.0313662887,
0.0086841267,
-0.0954998955,
0.0367282331,
-0.0309408847,
-0.0442420691,
-0.0318122245,
-0.0058602924,
0.0023020522,
0.0215301383,
-0.0157182142,
0.00942057,
0.0019167146,
-0.0312316325,
-0.0099487277,
-0.0442996845,
-0.0247950666,
0.0561142005,
-0.0071292049,
-0.0267774519,
0.0625316873,
0.0392580368,
-0.0049937312,
-0.0275816042,
0.0210340861,
-0.0489722081,
-0.0078217024,
0.0238009132,
0.031593971,
-0.0023327568,
0.0054473737,
-0.0386661775,
0.0456209034,
-0.0559094325,
-0.0144546302,
-0.0320327096,
0.087240845,
0.013141619,
-0.036986921,
-0.011183382,
0.0031832806,
-0.0160089452,
0.0498415008,
0.0412445925,
-0.0152845578,
-0.0442917608,
-0.0345219485,
-0.0129355351,
-0.0468682945,
-0.0355926305,
0.0676473379,
0.032117147,
-0.0240164697,
-0.0444650762,
-0.0610748455,
0.0004988262,
0.00567486,
-0.0296345819,
-0.0049805134,
0.0067500984,
-0.0318537541,
-0.0348305218,
0.0193806943,
-0.0321872458,
0.0425557718,
0.0293713678,
0.0349425972,
0.0075847553,
-0.0275471117,
-0.0268271398,
0.0161229093,
-0.0678330064,
-0.0239637215,
-0.0183348041,
0.0115583017,
0.0100643253,
0.0466182753,
-0.0376704,
-0.0188328028,
0.040820051,
-0.0044942298,
-0.0409694724,
0.007560736,
0.03940171,
0.001014382,
0.0292224437,
0.052277822,
-0.0675927401,
0.0524716265,
-0.003874263,
0.0120473355,
0.0146350572,
-0.0128587466,
0.0281178169,
-0.0590845495,
0.0190775935,
0.0115978578,
0.0149872284,
-0.0017039169,
0.0443250984,
-0.0514438711,
-0.0304996707,
-0.0434913971,
0.0285113119,
0.0043189116,
0.0064614452,
0.0115283821,
0.0147392666,
0.0287330188,
0.033545021,
-0.0439322181,
0.0346575305,
0.0421860032,
0.0058122799,
0.002742768,
0.0446958318,
-0.0167628974,
-0.0193768237,
-0.0153983086,
0.0392808504,
-0.0017683438,
0.0352712497,
0.0342219472,
-0.014889067,
-0.0448840074,
0.0062480047,
-0.095098488,
0.0541873127,
-0.020436449,
-0.0375651568,
0.0219683796,
-0.0095165912,
0.0310380179,
-0.005831996,
-0.0022069612,
0.011180779,
0.0360823162,
-0.0160671361,
-0.0623728372,
0.0550228432,
0.0037908971,
-0.0071521765,
-0.0127709825,
0.0660743937,
-0.0106533132,
0.0386984684,
0.0038983864,
0.0299679432,
-0.0397225693,
-0.0319889672,
-0.0193825997,
0.060415715,
0.0085982122,
0.00276966,
-0.0293859821,
-0.0427887999,
0.0076612686,
-0.0194149502,
0.0152669204,
-0.0237989239,
0.0374758542,
0.0478455797,
0.0275600776,
-0.0276126899,
0.0096672652,
-0.0000734797,
0.0020186929,
-0.0085354792,
-0.0543267354,
-6.377952433e-33,
-0.0155679826,
-0.0439193547,
0.0016551659,
0.0213866625,
-0.0609197691,
0.0296736956,
-0.0837671608,
-0.0345036983,
-0.0090666814,
0.0612323284,
0.0227700379,
0.0333751179,
-0.0102630677,
0.049983006,
0.0287829116,
-0.0128739187,
0.0480372421,
0.0127007794,
0.000579401,
0.0086372234,
0.0374729261,
0.0268735997,
0.0897330195,
-0.0236272942,
0.0239698514,
-0.0240782052,
-0.0094075771,
0.0338130333,
0.0063228067,
0.043142844,
-0.0213350281,
0.0352711901,
0.0501771905,
-0.0293455776,
-0.0177313276,
0.0583135933,
-0.1030630171,
-0.0286471639,
-0.0114006978,
0.0067612021,
-0.0696759894,
-0.0217006374,
0.0567458123,
-0.0050809481,
0.069577992,
-0.0714667514,
0.0485104211,
-0.0028618271,
-0.000218416,
-0.0448702164,
-0.0770271569,
0.0045904336,
-0.0194614008,
-0.0129491594,
-0.0073602865,
0.0930054486,
0.0249235556,
0.093771264,
-0.0477328822,
-0.0049823481,
-0.0273061749,
0.0221832618,
0.0184015501,
-0.0216462445,
-0.021615142,
0.0364328884,
-0.0239710789,
0.0065110461,
-0.0667080134,
-0.0256938972,
0.0119454553,
0.0316642709,
0.0622733384,
0.0334902108,
0.0355255231,
0.0411550142,
-0.0721799582,
-0.0124260187,
0.0156093584,
0.055504743,
-0.001713404,
0.0305669662,
0.0160967521,
-0.0083091874,
-0.0178065561,
-0.0217243098,
-0.0287093129,
-0.0094700828,
0.0210770424,
0.006845938,
0.0368285142,
0.0581310503,
0.0133835478,
-0.0181507282,
0.0240969937,
0.0248263106,
-0.000546207,
0.0126800053,
0.0283670258,
0.0435096063,
-0.0275940076,
0.0033803019,
0.0482275151,
0.0136094047,
0.0078912079,
0.011928875,
0.1008758247,
0.0130995568,
-0.0559734553,
-0.0002496931,
-0.0336836241,
-0.0159556102,
-0.0307923649,
0.06639231,
0.0445863307,
0.0310188886,
-0.0358016156,
0.0687335432,
-0.0095130522,
0.0457457565,
-0.0333406217,
0.0109033501,
0.0013715469,
0.03192522,
-0.0015698604,
-0.0322492905,
-0.0210720953,
-0.006179187,
0.045423273,
-0.0628261492,
-0.0088774767,
0.0101479664,
2.615e-7,
0.0558931902,
0.0234732684,
0.0638976619,
-0.0223947354,
0.0582546704,
0.0293403789,
0.02538478,
0.0474115312,
-0.037455298,
-0.023429146,
-0.0050323275,
-0.0149214668,
0.0423496068,
0.0208535288,
-0.0888080001,
0.0316142514,
-0.0923236832,
-0.0420135744,
-0.0071788537,
-0.0299404189,
0.089008607,
0.0915943608,
-0.0177663732,
-0.0083057461,
0.0181862768,
0.0001408165,
0.070465751,
0.022590084,
0.0223207101,
-0.0336793177,
-0.0268603601,
0.0333563834,
-0.011157711,
0.0282970592,
-0.025656445,
0.0420400947,
-0.0170843378,
0.0228781402,
-0.03007905,
-0.0267076194,
0.0180729218,
-0.0212422293,
0.0163334962,
-0.0325655192,
0.0366958231,
-0.1173335239,
-0.0320084654,
-0.0107303616,
-0.0382679664,
0.0062722811,
0.0034854237,
0.0214342382,
0.0122303069,
0.0096579976,
0.0104435943,
-0.0415723249,
-0.0145593956,
-0.1267975569,
-0.0464713089,
0.0336634777,
-0.0526988693,
0.0327564478,
-0.0489908718,
-0.0273277648,
0.0649159923,
-0.0393006913,
0.0007690534,
2.501722434e-34,
0.0240742043,
-0.0353040285,
0.017875554,
0.0278818291,
0.0316961221,
-0.0053455974,
-0.0402744263,
0.0080237482,
0.0475616641,
-0.0657205731,
-0.017169537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16298v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16298v2 | At Which Training Stage Does Code Data Help LLMs Reasoning? | 2023-09-28T09:50:27 | 2023-09-30T07:01:13 | Yingwei Ma, Yue Liu, Yue Yu, Yuanliang Zhang, Yu Jiang, Changjian Wang, Shanshan Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable reasoning capabilities
and become the foundation of language technologies. Inspired by the great
success of code data in training LLMs, we naturally wonder at which training
stage introducing code data can really help LLMs reasoning. To this end, this
paper systematically explores the impact of code data on LLMs at different
stages. Concretely, we introduce the code data at the pre-training stage,
instruction-tuning stage, and both of them, respectively. Then, the reasoning
capability of LLMs is comprehensively and fairly evaluated via six reasoning
tasks in five domains. We critically analyze the experimental results and
provide conclusions with insights. First, pre-training LLMs with the mixture of
code and text can significantly enhance LLMs' general reasoning capability
almost without negative transfer on other tasks. Besides, at the
instruction-tuning stage, code data endows LLMs the task-specific reasoning
capability. Moreover, the dynamic mixing strategy of code and text data assists
LLMs to learn reasoning capability step-by-step during training. These insights
deepen the understanding of LLMs regarding reasoning ability for their
application, such as scientific question answering, legal support, etc. The
source code and model parameters are released at the
link:~\url{https://github.com/yingweima2022/CodeLLM}. | [
0.0334903412,
0.0236519128,
-0.013832883,
0.0460651033,
-0.0273116808,
0.0518075228,
-0.0116147147,
0.0130104218,
0.0010894445,
-0.0516745485,
-0.0275512878,
0.0013694942,
-0.0207866058,
-0.0062688757,
0.0505877361,
-0.0031876999,
0.0764271989,
-0.0554680191,
0.010195123,
-0.0115885222,
-0.0067902058,
0.0107593518,
-0.0071919626,
-0.0149164908,
0.023029536,
-0.0216719992,
0.0105485795,
-0.0050416836,
0.0081910733,
-0.0334932655,
-0.0171246491,
0.0314585492,
0.0502375737,
-0.0193073507,
0.0000020074,
-0.0609319732,
-0.0036307666,
-0.0015428059,
-0.0554876849,
-0.0006947412,
0.0013165292,
-0.0099729653,
0.0089988476,
0.0299044847,
-0.069254145,
0.0116440272,
0.0192854758,
0.0085594514,
0.0447847992,
0.0878983587,
0.0186644997,
-0.0545414835,
0.0301015731,
0.027132323,
0.0431812517,
-0.0330603421,
0.0132747898,
0.0665632039,
0.0482515544,
0.0445614494,
-0.004590671,
0.0285508167,
0.0441514663,
0.0282215141,
-0.0243475698,
0.042148985,
-0.0425671414,
0.004440546,
-0.0035091219,
0.0411997139,
0.0143354069,
-0.0326938443,
-0.0141094774,
0.0153547786,
-0.004110598,
-0.0276212487,
-0.0449229106,
0.0531829,
0.0005859015,
0.0324777365,
0.0351629741,
-0.0318514667,
0.0324647576,
0.0339612029,
-0.0493054241,
0.118693471,
-0.028781604,
-0.0497335605,
0.0234802663,
-0.016793184,
-0.0286207143,
-0.046699129,
-0.0196563639,
0.1014441252,
0.0019555467,
0.0572965443,
-0.0153701631,
0.0005604475,
0.0251198839,
-0.0386246257,
0.0226996671,
0.0397911705,
-0.0128413886,
0.0444767624,
-0.0711020529,
0.056943398,
0.000519776,
0.0592932105,
-0.02773319,
-0.0259204879,
-0.0760950744,
-0.0429570675,
-0.0201992914,
0.0739545077,
-0.0076249461,
0.0271431003,
-0.0195553955,
0.0428670719,
0.0275264401,
0.0220253561,
-0.0013843852,
-0.0209314153,
0.0014319546,
-0.0130255222,
-0.0671701431,
-0.0352048799,
-0.0354603231,
0.0201839656,
-0.003613828,
-0.0602188781,
-0.0108380793,
-0.0042986348,
-0.0238490831,
-0.0259285923,
0.0492855012,
0.0495845191,
0.0101667112,
-0.0095740613,
-0.0755383,
-0.0328648314,
0.0043711537,
-0.0884516314,
0.0292392317,
-0.0816931948,
0.0011988733,
0.0313383304,
-0.0189048331,
-0.0412710197,
0.0119623169,
0.0151379295,
-0.0314694494,
0.0912760347,
-0.0412202962,
0.0142705683,
0.005086374,
0.0205753129,
-0.0173578784,
0.0595192239,
0.0225860756,
-0.0267469268,
0.0090532517,
-0.0179163702,
-0.0101132272,
-0.012585477,
0.0006964505,
-0.0106915366,
-0.0180605967,
0.055986464,
-0.0023746539,
-0.0019553085,
0.002565186,
0.0188157205,
-0.0224807914,
-0.0026456397,
0.0151227266,
0.0429401807,
0.0265899785,
0.0164939091,
0.0371563956,
-0.017572213,
0.0272319093,
0.0013149708,
-0.0712439343,
0.0410281308,
-0.0284706224,
0.022296207,
-0.0182112511,
-0.0009099307,
-0.0355018191,
-0.0844498202,
-0.0284006968,
-0.0001471938,
0.0044365725,
0.0372385159,
0.0443334691,
0.0035604609,
-0.0118372338,
0.0506513156,
0.0409942083,
-0.040769197,
-0.0052877348,
-0.0624487773,
0.0271383841,
0.0327843875,
0.0279521029,
-0.0582258105,
-0.0516856611,
0.0142892338,
0.0287806746,
-0.0057809828,
0.0431503505,
0.0016855486,
-0.0109411841,
-0.049232088,
-0.0070987334,
-0.0550587773,
-0.0096642412,
-0.0080062635,
0.030087173,
0.0027180458,
0.0103048272,
-0.0246059932,
-0.0229176935,
0.0459226929,
-0.0417377055,
-0.0173672698,
-0.0539595224,
-0.0116706062,
0.0292038415,
-0.0047742822,
-0.0037828858,
0.025643982,
0.0350516513,
-0.0114563722,
-0.0032838422,
-0.0106434962,
-0.0420652926,
-0.0662817359,
0.0483725108,
-0.0191004705,
-0.0278532431,
0.0216903016,
-0.0272589605,
-0.0286281835,
0.0139577799,
-0.0375029258,
0.0167866014,
-0.0357021838,
0.0113096125,
-0.0034846726,
-0.0271543469,
-0.0338277556,
0.0939973146,
0.0015108542,
0.0237348359,
0.0098775318,
0.0710800439,
0.0017538973,
-0.0131824492,
-0.003863438,
0.020759806,
-0.0185243934,
-0.0066210483,
-0.020551715,
-0.0091850217,
-0.0724410266,
-0.0201369561,
-0.072390601,
0.0148868794,
-0.0148166399,
0.0167873614,
0.017839184,
-0.0208857618,
-0.0067081638,
0.0079789273,
-0.0444899313,
-0.005066108,
0.0036489032,
0.0037799089,
0.0574094914,
-0.0045173522,
-0.0294855274,
-0.0101096006,
0.0065694689,
-0.0502189472,
0.0156600624,
-0.0006949586,
0.0158206876,
-0.0720207021,
0.0710638762,
-0.0541985743,
0.0081924647,
-0.0247667842,
-0.0447919108,
0.0326872729,
-0.0193210617,
0.0142775895,
0.0768898278,
-0.0221382603,
-0.0014616887,
0.0635320246,
0.0010735436,
-0.0565074459,
0.041657038,
0.0061128787,
-0.0172984749,
-0.0593866967,
-0.0196326766,
-0.0046757846,
0.0460552908,
-0.0125796879,
-0.0148130357,
-0.0246981122,
0.0215188246,
0.0015742237,
0.0124070374,
0.0141541511,
0.00612139,
-0.0163031127,
0.055425249,
-0.0208888333,
-0.0826059058,
0.0788498372,
-0.0234945565,
-0.0280934442,
-0.0673025474,
-0.0170983449,
-0.0665752664,
0.0581944212,
-0.0167889688,
0.0105432244,
-0.0056414381,
-0.0203903317,
-0.0459306948,
-0.0227477085,
-0.0040035262,
-0.0328848399,
0.0472819284,
-0.0510634072,
0.0076256595,
-0.0061104135,
-0.0192455966,
-0.0517494716,
0.0122992611,
-0.0449196063,
0.0448856503,
0.0047250851,
0.0128238909,
0.0046761828,
-0.0448875576,
0.0326967686,
0.0022403605,
0.0060489569,
-0.0215024054,
-0.0338532962,
-0.0326011926,
0.0037191138,
0.0255265124,
0.0219035503,
-0.0154203987,
0.0138988039,
0.0217636544,
0.0437256582,
-0.0043584588,
-0.0444667041,
0.0405896157,
0.0220014267,
-0.0362070687,
-0.0270995796,
0.0433813706,
0.0658921376,
-0.0652201101,
-0.0054445504,
0.1168875769,
0.0485148728,
0.0016329695,
0.0053332709,
-0.0197074227,
-0.0011050105,
0.0742944106,
0.0435673296,
-0.0700997189,
-0.0417751595,
-0.0167724118,
0.0038537004,
-0.0120728612,
-0.011334355,
-0.0465165079,
-0.1026336029,
0.0272315536,
0.0090885134,
-0.015701782,
-0.0594286397,
-0.0377949029,
-0.012578764,
0.0183925964,
-0.0038940629,
0.0397435464,
-0.0182708576,
-0.0008456421,
0.0452178009,
-0.0093781855,
-0.0173385777,
0.0447388552,
-0.0269512851,
0.0500965789,
0.0678603649,
0.0253461618,
-0.012350291,
-0.0372018181,
0.0313056558,
0.003118044,
0.0456564277,
-0.0426508561,
0.0277753267,
-0.0016069172,
0.0016876508,
0.0055965423,
0.0349398963,
-0.0403582118,
-0.0251227412,
0.0380063839,
0.1016181558,
-0.0354799479,
-0.0307408459,
-0.0317767896,
0.0206339341,
-0.0607639626,
0.0592529811,
0.0273896083,
0.016280517,
-0.0409195162,
-0.040439859,
-0.0494508334,
-0.0203489047,
-0.0173950847,
0.0255407561,
0.0072367215,
0.0433788635,
-0.0425658487,
-0.0275554247,
0.043927528,
0.0400388911,
-0.0139707141,
0.0363983139,
-0.0091330586,
0.0106566316,
-0.0429061092,
0.0173974968,
-0.0674029812,
0.0263420381,
-0.0398755707,
-0.022664994,
0.0369980708,
-0.0361422896,
-0.0190165062,
-0.0513507947,
-0.0609421209,
-0.0599921979,
-0.0345583819,
0.0500085726,
0.0301259588,
0.0442371778,
-0.0111070201,
-0.0426552035,
-0.0097277351,
-0.0061193667,
-0.0497897603,
0.01500489,
0.0542521589,
0.0103000524,
0.0347545929,
0.01766783,
-0.0251735449,
0.0230344422,
0.0339002609,
0.0130851846,
-0.0362564139,
0.0247601289,
0.0271922406,
0.0470308959,
0.0206339527,
0.0502929538,
-0.0330494307,
-0.0026257813,
0.0446121804,
0.0071054045,
-0.0342065021,
-0.0325908326,
0.0150593612,
0.001987082,
-0.0135973664,
0.0117586879,
-0.0303442888,
-0.0139313471,
0.0212369151,
0.0073396363,
0.0626716167,
0.0381297395,
0.0417591855,
0.0291708466,
-0.0126185883,
-0.0243569482,
0.0143206874,
-0.0159162562,
0.0494487882,
-0.0018255401,
0.063567169,
0.0233398993,
-0.0005709479,
-0.0248578768,
-0.0213008896,
-0.0977204964,
-0.0652592108,
0.0417155847,
0.0023776486,
0.0356158912,
0.0128399292,
-0.0032334791,
-0.0246556308,
0.0202235319,
-0.0022410802,
0.0220457092,
0.0087105632,
-0.0202969033,
0.0745198131,
0.0403170958,
-0.0229189321,
-0.0274052266,
0.083726652,
0.0086673843,
0.0511368178,
-0.0193733443,
-0.0016358732,
-0.025696205,
-0.0042182617,
0.0323228613,
-0.0052779759,
-0.0065364134,
0.0297948811,
-0.0247728787,
-0.0868206769,
-0.004119847,
0.0026450506,
0.0179070905,
-0.0242948234,
0.0262585785,
0.0729145706,
0.0052763862,
-0.0455074646,
-0.0177080128,
0.015796084,
0.015109593,
-0.017455129,
-0.0260011479,
-5.977278204e-33,
-0.0255534761,
-0.0216423925,
0.0515346639,
0.0133708222,
0.0047794105,
-0.0082769422,
-0.0448678322,
-0.007805218,
-0.0630023181,
-0.0180937573,
0.0030976834,
0.0445579812,
-0.0097296312,
-0.0182404146,
-0.0045330008,
-0.0446201079,
-0.0141914571,
0.0043209018,
-0.0084396759,
-0.0115264971,
-0.0092607159,
0.016342802,
0.0391451046,
-0.040079318,
0.0280625112,
-0.0076717795,
0.0152102429,
0.0352004953,
-0.0718376786,
0.0716741085,
0.0197525043,
0.0056878836,
0.0331061669,
-0.0489007309,
-0.0258379877,
0.009418848,
-0.0544405319,
-0.039944455,
0.0671791956,
-0.0075949216,
-0.0196335241,
-0.0596903376,
0.0438072272,
-0.0076230047,
0.004882969,
-0.0346151926,
0.0290145278,
-0.046967838,
-0.006771327,
-0.0255415663,
-0.0444123372,
0.0357440822,
-0.0320570357,
0.0048160902,
0.0181930922,
0.0138708074,
-0.0119006289,
0.0448764041,
-0.0100968461,
0.0140365269,
0.0224711206,
0.0244591646,
0.0579517893,
-0.0022850183,
0.0043578232,
0.02770596,
0.0317935683,
-0.0065340544,
-0.0336491391,
0.011891298,
0.0442123301,
0.0777528435,
0.0455552191,
-0.0107774707,
0.0330522731,
0.0127642797,
-0.0936612785,
-0.0143302595,
0.001659802,
0.0457528606,
0.0288083684,
0.0270311516,
-0.0417038463,
-0.011094735,
-0.0472821482,
0.0433160737,
-0.0384408385,
-0.0320179388,
0.0397769921,
-0.0190364514,
-0.0197820477,
-0.0183612332,
-0.0040850262,
-0.0614290498,
-0.0017272448,
0.0303085744,
-0.0044729342,
0.0162575953,
-0.0109615754,
0.0469231084,
-0.0695414394,
-0.0250036959,
0.0207018517,
-0.0382588767,
0.0379498191,
0.0107531659,
0.059570536,
0.0058584698,
-0.0294635035,
-0.0399568751,
-0.0469760783,
-0.018293703,
0.0071234163,
0.0271544009,
0.021308545,
0.0479044691,
0.006814356,
0.0115803163,
-0.0075666541,
-0.0261059161,
-0.069490537,
0.0121757127,
-0.0162583031,
0.0273896754,
-0.0361135527,
-0.0298803803,
-0.0408926383,
0.0340036564,
-0.0184619371,
-0.0326864086,
-0.0177030992,
0.0659043863,
2.737e-7,
0.0552770942,
0.0439440273,
-0.0199147351,
0.0549877137,
-0.0025261862,
0.0135435853,
-0.0501960665,
-0.023707781,
0.0447411239,
-0.037939772,
-0.0206176341,
0.0707128569,
0.0486280024,
0.0505144708,
-0.0495597608,
-0.0100565273,
0.0103617655,
-0.0366774313,
-0.0430486612,
0.0331617966,
0.0658816993,
0.0878731608,
0.0103371814,
-0.0059238016,
0.01070817,
-0.0345430486,
0.0268508121,
-0.0120428912,
0.0369364917,
0.0190208927,
-0.0234021675,
0.0362965837,
-0.0005381042,
0.0466126278,
0.0048278719,
0.0207229685,
-0.0319933668,
0.0757535696,
-0.0116718914,
-0.0081839161,
0.0098084798,
-0.042470824,
0.0095224269,
-0.0601072162,
0.1082975864,
-0.038185291,
-0.0348578431,
-0.0051025748,
0.0168576986,
-0.0155842695,
-0.027801726,
0.0143467272,
0.0119464751,
0.0068808524,
0.0090622092,
-0.056632895,
-0.0036575871,
-0.1194448769,
-0.0272735693,
0.0295716971,
-0.0263612214,
-0.0638719723,
-0.0383851603,
0.0131014436,
0.0544681139,
-0.0626392365,
0.0059088366,
2.654741263e-34,
0.0104020881,
-0.0376345031,
0.0313129835,
0.0623175129,
0.0544242039,
0.0024686456,
-0.0050127381,
0.0191046912,
0.029431602,
-0.062259797,
-0.0098125534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16292v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16292v3 | DiLu: A Knowledge-Driven Approach to Autonomous Driving with Large Language Models | 2023-09-28T09:41:35 | 2024-02-22T03:24:26 | Licheng Wen, Daocheng Fu, Xin Li, Xinyu Cai, Tao Ma, Pinlong Cai, Min Dou, Botian Shi, Liang He, Yu Qiao | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL | Recent advancements in autonomous driving have relied on data-driven
approaches, which are widely adopted but face challenges including dataset
bias, overfitting, and uninterpretability. Drawing inspiration from the
knowledge-driven nature of human driving, we explore the question of how to
instill similar capabilities into autonomous driving systems and summarize a
paradigm that integrates an interactive environment, a driver agent, as well as
a memory component to address this question. Leveraging large language models
(LLMs) with emergent abilities, we propose the DiLu framework, which combines a
Reasoning and a Reflection module to enable the system to perform
decision-making based on common-sense knowledge and evolve continuously.
Extensive experiments prove DiLu's capability to accumulate experience and
demonstrate a significant advantage in generalization ability over
reinforcement learning-based methods. Moreover, DiLu is able to directly
acquire experiences from real-world datasets which highlights its potential to
be deployed on practical autonomous driving systems. To the best of our
knowledge, we are the first to leverage knowledge-driven capability in
decision-making for autonomous vehicles. Through the proposed DiLu framework,
LLM is strengthened to apply knowledge and to reason causally in the autonomous
driving domain. Project page: https://pjlab-adg.github.io/DiLu/ | [
0.0243768767,
0.0329220891,
-0.0105113117,
0.0593042411,
-0.0053482726,
0.0256948844,
0.0129186306,
-0.032252755,
0.023396384,
-0.0058621154,
0.0243004933,
0.0361053757,
-0.0392446965,
0.0406800732,
0.0270753372,
-0.0491129234,
0.0270332415,
-0.1231762171,
-0.011191532,
-0.0134534501,
-0.0102411574,
-0.0058867596,
0.0010527233,
0.0065375548,
-0.0489690676,
0.0128338346,
-0.0070031355,
-0.0035333347,
0.0363952294,
-0.0144008407,
-0.0334165916,
0.000995376,
0.1018791869,
0.0020755744,
0.0000022354,
-0.0426314622,
0.0287524667,
-0.0214627236,
-0.0200644471,
-0.0451749414,
0.022505885,
0.0252690017,
0.0147711746,
0.0370537788,
-0.0646178573,
-0.0082485378,
-0.0182058923,
-0.0056125503,
0.075939469,
0.0579514802,
0.0066487431,
-0.0327211581,
0.0026234486,
0.0037785736,
0.0267787818,
0.0003389776,
0.0453833267,
0.0509615391,
0.0165240914,
-0.022237448,
-0.0183545519,
-0.0001892654,
0.0677450672,
-0.0484456606,
0.0024480356,
0.0499436185,
0.0305501912,
-0.0315559581,
-0.0002468516,
0.0421794876,
-0.0004476123,
-0.0651301593,
-0.0040226826,
0.0209557079,
-0.0119533846,
-0.0374968871,
-0.0356377587,
0.0021116221,
-0.0152695039,
0.0189393368,
-0.0226764474,
0.0046455907,
0.0283367597,
0.0371545367,
-0.0718769357,
0.0890780166,
0.0060744598,
-0.0204087086,
0.0208779573,
0.0098921834,
0.0138083221,
-0.0459068082,
-0.044618912,
0.0786467716,
-0.0530322269,
0.0254619531,
0.0007157833,
0.0078755459,
-0.0231696051,
-0.03431217,
0.018230347,
0.0158130396,
-0.0271523744,
0.0532232001,
-0.0082841171,
0.0471335165,
0.0310097765,
0.0173094664,
-0.0241435524,
-0.048080124,
-0.0298862141,
-0.0004717714,
-0.0086760623,
0.0201471336,
-0.003289999,
0.0091310972,
0.0021925601,
0.0926782414,
-0.0209750552,
0.0763441175,
-0.042883575,
0.0361313894,
0.0122495312,
-0.0124787008,
-0.0419446155,
-0.0270368736,
-0.0252254326,
0.0370573103,
0.0031799618,
-0.020567406,
0.0495271161,
0.0253037289,
-0.0353167094,
-0.0257041436,
0.0282783471,
0.106852673,
-0.0136372363,
-0.0200223047,
-0.0214203838,
-0.0032595946,
-0.0179674495,
-0.0658747107,
-0.0163843036,
-0.0761561096,
0.0224473011,
0.0204968676,
-0.0451356806,
-0.0575269945,
0.0273872595,
-0.0225651562,
-0.010233013,
0.0736007243,
-0.0193548165,
0.0089884968,
0.0552396476,
0.0172904897,
0.0206503421,
0.0404831246,
0.0339445621,
0.0652806908,
-0.0093789035,
0.0381767936,
0.010058864,
-0.0120018814,
0.0090665845,
0.0267812721,
-0.0383098423,
0.0432656705,
-0.0203717053,
0.0380709469,
-0.0050235041,
0.0400186144,
-0.0423273109,
0.0138661452,
0.0571629889,
0.003050681,
-0.0265651103,
0.0306506343,
0.0433015563,
0.0188139826,
0.0015065287,
-0.066470556,
-0.0395679995,
0.0356360637,
-0.0064905919,
0.000668089,
0.000083432,
0.0270853862,
-0.0015649241,
-0.0556400232,
0.0142973773,
0.0070534991,
0.0259611271,
0.0283192415,
0.0330242813,
-0.0263919644,
0.0119100921,
-0.0118518574,
0.0217047334,
0.0221084338,
0.0026643372,
-0.0592758432,
0.0653405711,
0.0673057958,
0.015983142,
-0.0560888872,
-0.0521066189,
-0.0110779293,
-0.0098615354,
0.0163117182,
-0.0107107209,
-0.0275417864,
0.003074927,
-0.0136832213,
-0.0203051288,
0.0351342224,
-0.014333928,
-0.0021539512,
0.0071304361,
0.0334456153,
0.0116204685,
-0.0039183833,
-0.0267818775,
0.0285728034,
0.0175030548,
-0.0160087459,
-0.0422649644,
0.0084462371,
0.0220523477,
-0.0190111119,
-0.0158751272,
0.0109863989,
0.022908356,
0.0020977554,
-0.0369720571,
0.0364003405,
-0.0217374787,
-0.0007269447,
0.0644050911,
-0.0283589326,
-0.0008417856,
0.0180243813,
-0.0436527431,
-0.0406645983,
-0.0231840536,
-0.0266723242,
0.0461843349,
-0.0111681847,
-0.0262908973,
0.0181212518,
-0.0009453257,
-0.019883275,
0.0616035275,
-0.0011804309,
-0.0293702241,
0.0599620938,
0.0314268321,
0.0104001565,
-0.0165358372,
-0.0095711173,
-0.0034848007,
-0.0112199187,
-0.0079178363,
0.0201751553,
0.0087469108,
-0.0145595297,
-0.0119680967,
-0.043096602,
-0.0333109945,
-0.0177592598,
-0.0192621294,
-0.0234922282,
-0.0316261128,
0.0007718807,
-0.0309662782,
0.0432239547,
0.0467481539,
0.0315261595,
-0.0157464091,
0.0274036396,
0.0186943877,
-0.0177818369,
-0.0081814602,
0.0080448715,
-0.0344517007,
0.0153185753,
0.0121020535,
-0.0128029212,
-0.0384935699,
0.0065870984,
-0.0629358143,
0.0663920939,
-0.0276773628,
-0.0445661135,
0.0425126404,
0.0053686583,
0.0384532511,
0.0872576088,
0.0296964645,
-0.0116902273,
0.0478415079,
-0.0276154894,
-0.0426034741,
0.0361819305,
-0.0555864163,
-0.0108724376,
-0.0574608371,
0.0101096062,
-0.0339383334,
0.0304426122,
-0.0136433225,
-0.0094223488,
-0.0249864124,
0.0088441186,
-0.019863911,
-0.0794689953,
-0.0322111882,
-0.0065148277,
-0.0224110987,
0.0469600186,
-0.028935127,
-0.0593559779,
0.046542868,
-0.0252171606,
0.019866161,
-0.0160541721,
-0.0058406033,
-0.0181961264,
0.0737083554,
0.032426618,
-0.0024858122,
-0.0312471446,
0.0616247766,
0.0024773362,
-0.0146386093,
0.0000583597,
0.0007761198,
0.0880084932,
-0.0989355221,
0.0301796589,
0.0047761342,
-0.0870755985,
-0.0514635816,
0.003184112,
-0.0550279319,
0.00330018,
-0.0339034125,
-0.0400511138,
0.0167807844,
0.0028904255,
0.0616908483,
0.0809944123,
0.0121496068,
-0.0177760273,
-0.028643664,
-0.0662882105,
0.0725263581,
0.0247168764,
0.0097247716,
-0.0086881118,
0.0771636367,
0.0325421207,
0.0328423344,
-0.0157374255,
-0.0435731225,
0.0093562081,
0.0138477888,
-0.0013697764,
0.0234442726,
0.0647898838,
0.0025939199,
-0.0678813681,
-0.0662863255,
0.0843236223,
0.0091937715,
-0.0102427658,
-0.0007227499,
-0.0407809168,
0.0350161642,
0.0456556976,
0.0581611581,
-0.0575765185,
-0.0356612056,
0.0148165086,
-0.0144865094,
0.0109972702,
-0.0070594507,
0.0264519416,
-0.0871716663,
0.0183957908,
-0.0131149124,
-0.0471608788,
-0.0295767225,
-0.0119546009,
-0.036791645,
-0.0040344079,
-0.0118682077,
0.0130848186,
-0.0123559739,
-0.0186677761,
0.0236253198,
0.0101144472,
-0.0312190205,
0.015273382,
-0.0310890358,
0.035046123,
0.0674615502,
0.0154921766,
-0.0006925513,
-0.0234968439,
-0.0150893833,
0.0118587473,
0.017830288,
-0.0402962789,
0.0032350607,
-0.0378790908,
-0.0105789592,
-0.0215670038,
0.0341023207,
-0.0242767427,
-0.0287640169,
-0.0212945398,
0.0933527797,
-0.0744962245,
-0.0042390451,
-0.0291924719,
-0.0145286387,
0.0052304859,
0.035325408,
-0.0220459681,
-0.0150291948,
-0.0332435817,
-0.0067770262,
-0.0845670849,
-0.0063211648,
-0.0436910801,
-0.0259456486,
0.0173450168,
-0.001745488,
-0.0293419827,
-0.0226535257,
0.0154515617,
0.004884731,
0.0140685821,
-0.0107953399,
0.0392904282,
-0.0132811265,
-0.0477302521,
-0.0115460567,
-0.0073190713,
-0.0033913192,
-0.0097155906,
0.0088884737,
0.0197992027,
-0.0701345727,
-0.0662975013,
-0.0021016074,
-0.05070173,
-0.0459571555,
0.0575933903,
0.0749210864,
0.022280585,
0.0540401526,
-0.0381799713,
-0.0535810441,
0.0765977874,
-0.0139674051,
0.0035964586,
0.0091772433,
-0.002875604,
0.0057100495,
0.0329294689,
0.0493298732,
-0.0585174561,
0.0314471237,
0.0454247482,
-0.0682447776,
-0.0265934542,
-0.0154695017,
0.0182314608,
-0.0041719619,
0.0187130701,
-0.000461305,
0.0296053793,
-0.0456871092,
0.0383554772,
0.0155157819,
-0.0170988776,
-0.0467428677,
0.0411226377,
-0.0086937854,
0.04001683,
0.0086222263,
-0.0129473666,
0.0695676133,
-0.0293633305,
0.0109037803,
0.0093034292,
0.0825047195,
0.0031311405,
0.0391140729,
-0.0144276889,
0.0164664928,
0.014159102,
-0.0161980633,
0.038246274,
-0.02047709,
0.1010058448,
0.0486912578,
-0.0542986542,
0.0222452022,
-0.0004606112,
-0.0430254154,
-0.1074185595,
-0.0130182374,
0.0695105568,
0.0592575669,
0.0370703265,
0.0102688661,
-0.1040125266,
0.0116338758,
0.0042682667,
0.0164890587,
0.0301110502,
-0.0240668077,
0.0422141626,
-0.0023639626,
-0.0543210246,
0.0103116874,
0.0487045012,
0.0170419328,
0.0497373939,
0.0107760606,
-0.0222713221,
-0.0433345363,
-0.0297968946,
0.0265909005,
-0.0318672918,
-0.0302873123,
0.0190477874,
-0.0338896215,
-0.0562723987,
-0.0376240462,
0.064829953,
-0.0225178767,
-0.0155652147,
0.0074133552,
0.0174204111,
0.0229458231,
-0.0732888356,
0.0160642434,
0.009942716,
-0.0427670069,
-0.0051995232,
0.019856045,
-6.546619709e-33,
-0.0361541882,
0.0327545963,
0.0612234883,
-0.0424719267,
-0.018772481,
-0.0517217405,
-0.0241049826,
-0.0124937901,
-0.0057540559,
0.0226018783,
-0.0087657124,
0.0394845828,
0.0105800759,
0.0121616488,
0.0504639149,
-0.0432819054,
0.0204874612,
0.023919994,
-0.0283157229,
0.0335454866,
0.0419221856,
0.0178356562,
0.0016255472,
-0.0234276783,
-0.0160412397,
-0.0139791081,
0.0086459965,
0.0767417997,
-0.0630700365,
0.0168429129,
-0.0143274264,
0.010190824,
0.0173283461,
-0.0519351326,
-0.0303127263,
0.0015489691,
-0.0553553812,
-0.0097795241,
0.026999753,
0.0246732682,
-0.0570550337,
-0.0179402288,
0.0276376233,
0.0124170873,
0.0060954331,
0.0475944653,
0.0402741432,
-0.0287757143,
-0.0020480682,
-0.0114009995,
-0.0686153322,
0.0082334317,
0.0101707447,
-0.0324474908,
0.0142396148,
0.0055932784,
-0.0084080175,
-0.0090185758,
-0.0408884771,
-0.0160937309,
-0.0114628254,
0.018497292,
0.0933005363,
0.0068623209,
0.0146990381,
0.0164751224,
0.0018188816,
-0.0314374231,
-0.0454663709,
-0.0038669466,
-0.0134449303,
0.0692265555,
-0.0035298427,
0.0529633686,
-0.0304788779,
-0.0326078609,
-0.0927830264,
-0.00918274,
-0.0162972771,
0.0606210381,
0.0282569323,
-0.0044556339,
-0.0372811258,
0.0008680777,
-0.0313808732,
0.0536622666,
-0.0169874895,
-0.0200632699,
0.0465448461,
0.0254598837,
-0.0624094792,
-0.0345362946,
0.031121619,
-0.0666279718,
0.0105823185,
0.0090788091,
-0.0199409053,
-0.0085017607,
-0.02230745,
0.0159105286,
-0.1091712788,
-0.0548362955,
-0.0021176424,
-0.0161534529,
0.0111276731,
0.0049595358,
-0.0074449419,
0.0497318506,
-0.0138350856,
0.0195916556,
-0.092044048,
0.0016700069,
0.0614088252,
0.0103350505,
0.0512700193,
0.0511248112,
-0.0052856263,
-0.0042550052,
-0.0201582257,
-0.0450744629,
-0.0103200078,
-0.0328021534,
0.0032630812,
-0.010557062,
-0.0159674324,
0.0159889013,
-0.0465554073,
-0.0105234068,
-0.0097296266,
-0.0378824212,
0.0278556868,
0.0499897897,
2.87e-7,
-0.0068482128,
0.0361502916,
-0.017387351,
0.0310000051,
0.0401950553,
0.058050707,
-0.0086404169,
0.0143298516,
-0.0157626458,
0.0122832991,
0.0089405831,
0.0641401187,
0.0376564376,
0.0160088539,
-0.0498130545,
-0.0147143546,
-0.0231814105,
-0.0611085631,
-0.0625055209,
-0.0307845175,
0.0401394479,
0.09627828,
0.0093938829,
-0.0094845546,
0.0590738244,
-0.0198267363,
0.0406446978,
-0.0254100673,
0.0249525625,
-0.0034675535,
0.0291061383,
0.0485463403,
-0.0199970137,
0.0534130856,
0.0235637445,
0.0122779123,
-0.0487741493,
0.0454268605,
0.0145312306,
-0.0241446029,
-0.0248963293,
-0.0406104438,
0.013299319,
-0.0913824216,
0.066474922,
-0.0256836526,
0.0269402359,
-0.0307729151,
0.0343010649,
-0.0320040844,
-0.0279067326,
0.0091156187,
-0.0000638922,
-0.0185454749,
0.0117328055,
-0.0049236212,
0.0094949519,
-0.0843990371,
-0.0190201048,
0.0088848174,
-0.0339198373,
-0.0200870093,
-0.0521108881,
0.0385778509,
0.0330563858,
-0.0480287112,
-0.0256695095,
2.176245727e-34,
-0.0065351082,
0.0139053976,
-0.0325517356,
-0.0257036574,
0.0193608589,
0.0186750051,
-0.0376624577,
0.0135370949,
0.0069062696,
-0.039544832,
-0.0149557125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16289v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16289v1 | LawBench: Benchmarking Legal Knowledge of Large Language Models | 2023-09-28T09:35:59 | 2023-09-28T09:35:59 | Zhiwei Fei, Xiaoyu Shen, Dawei Zhu, Fengzhe Zhou, Zhuo Han, Songyang Zhang, Kai Chen, Zongwen Shen, Jidong Ge | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated strong capabilities in various
aspects. However, when applying them to the highly specialized, safe-critical
legal domain, it is unclear how much legal knowledge they possess and whether
they can reliably perform legal-related tasks. To address this gap, we propose
a comprehensive evaluation benchmark LawBench. LawBench has been meticulously
crafted to have precise assessment of the LLMs' legal capabilities from three
cognitive levels: (1) Legal knowledge memorization: whether LLMs can memorize
needed legal concepts, articles and facts; (2) Legal knowledge understanding:
whether LLMs can comprehend entities, events and relationships within legal
text; (3) Legal knowledge applying: whether LLMs can properly utilize their
legal knowledge and make necessary reasoning steps to solve realistic legal
tasks. LawBench contains 20 diverse tasks covering 5 task types: single-label
classification (SLC), multi-label classification (MLC), regression, extraction
and generation. We perform extensive evaluations of 51 LLMs on LawBench,
including 20 multilingual LLMs, 22 Chinese-oriented LLMs and 9 legal specific
LLMs. The results show that GPT-4 remains the best-performing LLM in the legal
domain, surpassing the others by a significant margin. While fine-tuning LLMs
on legal specific text brings certain improvements, we are still a long way
from obtaining usable and reliable LLMs in legal tasks. All data, model
predictions and evaluation code are released in
https://github.com/open-compass/LawBench/. We hope this benchmark provides
in-depth understanding of the LLMs' domain-specified capabilities and speed up
the development of LLMs in the legal domain. | [
0.0325163715,
0.044101961,
-0.0043263794,
0.0265359934,
-0.0588428676,
0.0399307534,
0.0411290117,
0.0382277779,
0.0393709801,
-0.0730469674,
-0.0197314192,
-0.0387300774,
-0.0359184332,
-0.0157315135,
0.0014645589,
-0.0356214233,
0.04531556,
-0.0015580771,
0.065642722,
-0.0175756197,
0.0126054529,
0.0098218881,
0.0219940003,
0.0066532628,
-0.0340065584,
-0.01182005,
0.0097328275,
-0.0016151002,
0.0137463538,
-0.015283972,
0.0135898683,
0.0753790885,
0.0054221759,
0.0462363511,
0.0000019808,
-0.0645297244,
-0.0010334606,
-0.0269360505,
0.0041218121,
0.046513278,
0.0301354975,
-0.0460244939,
-0.0400826596,
-0.0030592058,
-0.0435297415,
0.0180245358,
-0.0079519041,
0.0257168673,
0.0336310379,
0.0863592625,
-0.0018854759,
-0.0498929806,
0.0621182583,
-0.0499196015,
0.0001720075,
-0.0704043135,
0.0365054533,
0.052924443,
0.0120802,
-0.0252079014,
0.0117939152,
0.0168654919,
0.0583564006,
-0.0029376925,
-0.0363757052,
0.0196031965,
-0.0378939509,
0.0074053649,
-0.0026979405,
0.045472309,
0.0276963934,
-0.0321786627,
-0.007332752,
0.0015283901,
0.0458382703,
-0.0044037295,
-0.0313789472,
0.0898312107,
-0.0222152714,
0.0148440031,
0.0120417187,
0.0147316875,
0.0276487283,
0.0405457914,
-0.0174382441,
0.0705153644,
0.0053484095,
-0.034666013,
0.0287836958,
-0.0242003128,
0.0018715928,
-0.0450424068,
0.0403532609,
0.0408183746,
-0.005321187,
0.0465823486,
-0.0438473299,
-0.025993865,
0.073660709,
-0.0759978294,
0.0165474936,
0.0180012789,
-0.0130108651,
0.0809103996,
-0.0819276422,
0.0577306338,
0.0082534747,
0.0308254883,
0.0046098973,
-0.0473268516,
-0.0410263352,
-0.0298806336,
-0.0390155129,
0.0625544935,
-0.0595505647,
0.0120479111,
-0.0317736119,
-0.0056989579,
-0.0137118716,
0.0282990895,
-0.0003088714,
-0.0319484137,
-0.0073990989,
-0.0515474714,
-0.0541953743,
-0.0442962274,
-0.0468483008,
0.0326219015,
0.005733137,
-0.021187976,
0.0030872668,
-0.0023095116,
-0.0431493931,
-0.0106102247,
0.0118331574,
0.0992861688,
-0.0255072787,
-0.0257705189,
-0.0521121956,
-0.0562350489,
-0.021897871,
-0.1018731445,
-0.0262945425,
-0.067286849,
-0.00246806,
-0.0181750078,
-0.0057242652,
-0.0773452073,
0.0281702541,
0.0355064683,
-0.003597806,
0.0547051467,
0.0026747182,
-0.0220848434,
-0.0282825697,
0.054491818,
0.0200672168,
0.0385460481,
-0.0061754128,
0.0450014882,
0.0168631375,
-0.000603019,
0.0028428049,
0.0423991978,
-0.0001650078,
0.0166255254,
-0.0283373017,
0.0029183112,
0.0336152948,
0.0035784112,
0.0315999538,
0.0432390757,
0.0018491548,
-0.018772427,
0.0443125106,
0.0472613201,
0.0053737732,
0.0526319258,
0.0121983178,
-0.0253994577,
0.0462919958,
-0.0075517502,
-0.0760398954,
0.0352692455,
-0.0404421724,
0.0055207792,
-0.0600697361,
0.033426702,
-0.0304900799,
-0.031127939,
-0.0055846996,
-0.0091298036,
-0.0098120458,
-0.0084349979,
0.0335970074,
0.0043550669,
-0.0275977273,
0.0733321682,
0.0253984369,
-0.0552241839,
-0.0316997282,
-0.0103427153,
-0.0152342599,
0.0392326489,
0.0278100576,
-0.0374948382,
-0.0258145221,
-0.015231316,
0.0024833081,
0.0513603203,
0.0502924956,
-0.0059979358,
-0.0123017095,
-0.0552309938,
-0.0156928655,
0.0069269729,
0.0372451022,
0.0274489745,
0.0292808972,
0.0206042156,
0.056414295,
-0.0663943142,
-0.0072297412,
0.0386104882,
-0.033593297,
-0.0510627478,
0.0036286681,
-0.0083830692,
0.0290127881,
0.0310492273,
0.012106061,
-0.0316970646,
0.0293219257,
-0.0008414477,
-0.0005342381,
0.0159099866,
-0.0237402897,
-0.0176275894,
0.074078612,
0.0009225158,
-0.0126479845,
0.0139332581,
-0.0435213,
-0.0229127947,
-0.0333114527,
0.0091815349,
-0.0035144922,
-0.0723694488,
0.003011239,
-0.0075411508,
-0.0144142434,
-0.0124318842,
0.0716502815,
-0.00971625,
-0.017173307,
0.0162856113,
0.0116297174,
0.0493885092,
-0.0002579447,
-0.0326039456,
-0.0156588629,
-0.0390581898,
0.0301129799,
0.000442667,
0.0312775485,
-0.0487355813,
-0.0415929109,
-0.0568598993,
0.0385624766,
-0.0388099737,
0.0144296465,
0.0065260851,
-0.0494586192,
-0.0205898955,
-0.0129834246,
-0.0327725448,
0.0008701452,
-0.0266356654,
-0.0178480875,
-0.0150103802,
-0.0360299535,
-0.0292455722,
0.0114708636,
0.0003551092,
-0.0273441579,
0.0000271245,
0.0166199077,
-0.0189003926,
-0.0144391237,
0.0613103509,
-0.0244096573,
-0.0202194918,
-0.0286065359,
-0.008297395,
-0.0203697607,
0.0248570908,
0.0081445966,
0.0205570646,
0.0325912237,
0.0151899308,
0.0205045249,
-0.0155294267,
-0.057594981,
0.0049023335,
0.0251035746,
0.0010796458,
-0.064462781,
-0.0059673977,
-0.0169536695,
0.0350274183,
-0.0024353538,
0.0213923752,
-0.0253395382,
-0.0130997337,
-0.0173211321,
-0.0132898018,
-0.0494513884,
0.0200483762,
-0.039774362,
0.0197864771,
0.0027866052,
-0.0689313263,
0.0321774222,
0.0006905228,
0.0515896007,
-0.037853729,
-0.0000542841,
-0.0286816526,
0.0934020132,
-0.0069904909,
0.0259710532,
-0.0081565715,
-0.0607761592,
-0.0075140744,
-0.0013303787,
0.0427292101,
-0.0613981523,
0.0854384229,
-0.0372332931,
0.0432702526,
-0.0349592939,
-0.027155824,
-0.047808975,
-0.0210490525,
-0.0120170079,
0.0722568929,
-0.0115390848,
0.0128762377,
-0.0175379906,
0.0029531687,
0.0021186527,
-0.0020236408,
-0.0009618698,
0.0061083916,
-0.030284008,
0.0237980448,
0.0023943363,
-0.0322058424,
-0.0027914222,
-0.0246903449,
0.0238838922,
0.024327131,
-0.0079634832,
-0.0092958575,
0.0223604813,
0.0221437849,
0.0100504495,
-0.0567481443,
-0.0023434574,
0.0509705022,
0.0246472247,
-0.072031118,
0.0216584373,
0.1044673026,
0.0378013998,
-0.0319442041,
-0.0206946507,
0.0089779198,
0.0123913391,
0.0593018942,
-0.0048358324,
-0.1066412404,
0.0024503821,
0.0142371738,
-0.015196722,
-0.011015486,
-0.024309596,
-0.0130611956,
-0.0910864845,
0.0740082413,
0.0378044061,
-0.0606458448,
-0.0332928002,
-0.0103087183,
-0.0158593263,
0.0147478739,
0.034519352,
0.0151150599,
-0.0178298093,
-0.0401606672,
0.0091696195,
-0.0353265256,
0.0028988575,
0.0524163246,
-0.0367153287,
0.0811680183,
0.0255234037,
0.0375559591,
-0.028804617,
-0.0136312582,
0.0257831607,
-0.0013531642,
0.0007709255,
-0.0033633662,
0.0321287476,
0.0185080543,
0.0209485814,
-0.0312508009,
0.0371367522,
-0.0301449411,
-0.0448396318,
0.051902324,
0.0597482845,
-0.028238235,
-0.0280514676,
0.0030449259,
-0.0030044462,
-0.0301435851,
0.0701036975,
0.0216768142,
0.0084913867,
-0.0478334092,
-0.0394840837,
-0.0274422597,
-0.056530498,
-0.0151519543,
0.0274514891,
-0.0023444151,
-0.0261505302,
-0.0219044983,
-0.0266403314,
0.0027234016,
0.0279424004,
0.0144476146,
0.0605648682,
0.0162020661,
-0.02431559,
-0.0412724949,
0.0073273322,
-0.063591212,
0.0124020735,
-0.0233650021,
0.0089446874,
0.012662557,
0.0000131985,
-0.0188804045,
0.0065011764,
-0.0259560253,
-0.0144498758,
-0.0209861044,
0.0108151138,
0.015303771,
-0.0135045238,
-0.0459407382,
-0.0391870849,
0.037022002,
0.0329424627,
-0.017232215,
-0.0087969536,
0.0558995046,
-0.031253729,
-0.0192351751,
0.0125092659,
-0.0088984109,
0.0336329825,
0.0413108505,
0.019867925,
-0.0106709208,
-0.010538294,
0.0406525396,
0.0799149498,
-0.0098218573,
-0.0062035583,
-0.0173650328,
-0.0021475686,
0.0022737356,
-0.0224428773,
-0.021041669,
0.0043308684,
-0.0043534352,
0.0506005175,
-0.0288941506,
-0.0238320604,
0.0593788438,
0.0111589655,
0.0003220713,
-0.0321600959,
0.0041013225,
-0.0003454498,
0.0279824045,
0.0182019453,
-0.0391198695,
-0.0048343795,
0.0094687929,
-0.0128556415,
0.0434315875,
-0.0090949228,
0.0661891699,
-0.0033076778,
-0.0104858996,
-0.0105084078,
0.0094721653,
-0.0222361851,
-0.0209051892,
-0.0111357421,
0.0626654476,
0.091747731,
0.0083081918,
0.01440062,
-0.0560245067,
-0.0144288782,
-0.0222284272,
0.0003599326,
0.0025518686,
-0.0505846813,
0.0407764167,
0.0152750509,
-0.0220624674,
0.0233403258,
0.0580440611,
0.0142462151,
0.0224979147,
0.0132638719,
0.0076972088,
-0.0361742787,
-0.0330413356,
0.0057568965,
0.0126148704,
-0.0522141829,
-0.0220006313,
-0.095443435,
-0.050131686,
0.0062181982,
-0.0002571624,
-0.0129970945,
0.0106019806,
0.0105638197,
0.0712567344,
0.0034751126,
-0.0250000246,
-0.0247798096,
0.0198223908,
0.0048365453,
-0.0113535346,
-0.0034015838,
-5.847594728e-33,
-0.0359950326,
-0.0427336656,
0.0367890932,
0.0128343841,
-0.0077821864,
-0.0277133714,
-0.0271980576,
-0.0067494791,
-0.0189696625,
0.014130095,
-0.0045531876,
0.0180113893,
0.0116055375,
-0.0139725236,
0.0028094219,
-0.0291792415,
-0.0074800011,
0.000539885,
-0.0051236949,
0.0302756578,
0.0038954301,
0.035093572,
0.0334219337,
-0.0842168182,
0.0343259275,
0.0437666774,
-0.029089408,
-0.0422821604,
-0.0748187155,
0.0631739721,
-0.0113699008,
0.0545864217,
0.0320044868,
-0.0597869158,
-0.0111098951,
0.0237511043,
-0.0880566537,
0.0214589499,
0.017416941,
-0.0204734653,
0.0334693156,
-0.0632316247,
0.0326897763,
0.000695425,
-0.0151151167,
-0.0241987575,
0.0351980701,
-0.069430463,
-0.0522626936,
-0.0798560902,
-0.0854106918,
0.0560011119,
-0.0064192801,
0.0253673717,
0.0266977753,
0.003039378,
0.0049127815,
0.0678174868,
-0.0759525448,
-0.0033950289,
-0.0127802901,
-0.0045611551,
0.0591642708,
-0.0516285822,
-0.0053627673,
0.0652423054,
-0.0262282118,
0.0019736753,
-0.0294599794,
-0.0063602887,
0.0434804335,
0.1042665467,
0.0376494266,
0.0549960621,
0.016521465,
-0.0466906317,
-0.0783154294,
-0.0113357091,
0.0377029926,
0.0138983242,
0.0267265644,
-0.0028757483,
-0.0340304002,
-0.002675948,
-0.0354253836,
-0.0022151885,
-0.0162846223,
-0.0039257626,
0.0420567356,
0.0051878127,
0.0357867777,
-0.0428575464,
-0.007967609,
-0.0544755459,
-0.008752129,
0.0446699969,
-0.0073986012,
0.0111160791,
-0.0167824011,
0.0772637352,
-0.0771271065,
-0.0543878451,
0.0025103611,
-0.034226615,
0.0064106225,
-0.011338043,
0.0703574046,
-0.0101462826,
-0.0739067942,
-0.0018182016,
-0.0082226181,
0.0155893974,
0.0578702316,
0.0263443775,
-0.0009968651,
0.0244784206,
0.0376347639,
0.0255491957,
0.0386371277,
-0.04307108,
-0.0143257305,
-0.0027194438,
-0.0190312639,
0.0056661014,
-0.0070842607,
0.021548871,
-0.0051774597,
0.0376576781,
0.0448827967,
0.0058661588,
0.0158637539,
0.069728069,
2.629e-7,
0.0710847974,
0.0298131667,
-0.023235416,
0.0055016056,
-0.0163022336,
0.0472392328,
-0.0308244433,
0.0417863503,
0.0217651203,
-0.0430568792,
-0.0043039126,
0.0273393597,
0.0912138745,
0.0563815981,
-0.0671156272,
-0.0019635649,
-0.0367360711,
-0.0451405086,
-0.0571551844,
0.0514868945,
0.0359581262,
0.0862902924,
0.017535476,
-0.0250919908,
0.0184807312,
-0.0364943184,
0.0458133146,
-0.0284864381,
-0.0275425818,
0.0037490039,
0.069931224,
-0.0060578999,
-0.0135107711,
0.0609014556,
0.0082889609,
0.045690909,
-0.0186572913,
0.0966181755,
0.010899175,
0.039387539,
-0.029997468,
-0.0718120337,
0.0060625207,
-0.0513361692,
0.0670663118,
-0.0009745548,
-0.0102403685,
-0.0068432405,
-0.0322701111,
-0.0281758625,
0.0184499025,
0.0053747576,
-0.0061557554,
-0.0109387999,
0.0266243219,
-0.0233631711,
0.0065612644,
-0.0881785154,
-0.0181867816,
0.0324255377,
-0.0265562274,
-0.0122705093,
-0.018159356,
0.0089369463,
0.0515436791,
-0.0953753293,
0.0266287345,
2.156742852e-34,
0.0208592266,
-0.028620746,
0.0066773072,
0.0427035093,
0.0214953348,
0.0201541409,
-0.0349868797,
0.0170446411,
-0.041791603,
-0.0711474866,
0.0415880121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16283v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16283v1 | Self-supervised Cross-view Representation Reconstruction for Change Captioning | 2023-09-28T09:28:50 | 2023-09-28T09:28:50 | Yunbin Tu, Liang Li, Li Su, Zheng-Jun Zha, Chenggang Yan, Qingming Huang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Change captioning aims to describe the difference between a pair of similar
images. Its key challenge is how to learn a stable difference representation
under pseudo changes caused by viewpoint change. In this paper, we address this
by proposing a self-supervised cross-view representation reconstruction
(SCORER) network. Concretely, we first design a multi-head token-wise matching
to model relationships between cross-view features from similar/dissimilar
images. Then, by maximizing cross-view contrastive alignment of two similar
images, SCORER learns two view-invariant image representations in a
self-supervised way. Based on these, we reconstruct the representations of
unchanged objects by cross-attention, thus learning a stable difference
representation for caption generation. Further, we devise a cross-modal
backward reasoning to improve the quality of caption. This module reversely
models a ``hallucination'' representation with the caption and ``before''
representation. By pushing it closer to the ``after'' representation, we
enforce the caption to be informative about the difference in a self-supervised
manner. Extensive experiments show our method achieves the state-of-the-art
results on four datasets. The code is available at
https://github.com/tuyunbin/SCORER. | [
-0.0272288714,
0.0547178723,
0.0217337999,
0.0185870398,
-0.0227620639,
-0.0137092834,
-0.0165200494,
-0.001754166,
0.0167956334,
-0.0544717349,
-0.0399747938,
0.0129706617,
0.0065365792,
0.0264261849,
-0.0008374618,
-0.0909861624,
0.03369819,
0.0016360456,
-0.0360631943,
-0.0068052206,
0.0141553422,
-0.0010687495,
-0.0235154424,
0.0118761836,
-0.0407179222,
-0.0437088758,
-0.0153594092,
-0.0008169464,
0.0561259836,
-0.047887776,
0.0026355307,
0.0802069232,
0.0687165037,
0.0272131786,
0.0000022299,
-0.0202663131,
-0.0332986712,
0.0073461547,
0.0485271774,
0.0118839871,
0.0560804494,
-0.0424564891,
-0.0031603472,
-0.0455823988,
-0.015624078,
-0.0372991636,
0.0633670539,
0.0798203349,
0.0834001079,
0.0310058389,
-0.0099901045,
-0.0778936669,
-0.0068544596,
-0.042783767,
0.0606633872,
-0.0254462007,
-0.0085374815,
0.0557526015,
-0.0362027735,
-0.0013207097,
-0.0596878715,
0.0558885001,
-0.0046531199,
-0.0250108112,
-0.0176878497,
0.0670059398,
0.026251642,
0.0116700446,
-0.0543386713,
0.064749822,
0.0028216599,
0.0064746668,
-0.0175435897,
-0.0268363804,
0.0152935321,
0.0069651012,
-0.0399180576,
-0.0147190876,
0.0058306688,
0.0131594166,
-0.0349807627,
0.0429135449,
-0.0036023944,
-0.0237974953,
0.0006719377,
-0.0748635158,
0.0382105336,
0.0359587446,
-0.1029232368,
0.0107061854,
-0.0132310512,
-0.0539756268,
0.0391546302,
0.0083170226,
0.0136854248,
-0.0210564844,
-0.039755743,
-0.0324275233,
-0.0296242945,
-0.0405063927,
0.0379088223,
0.0035838254,
-0.0805967897,
0.0834558904,
-0.0622145385,
0.0540212095,
-0.0207723305,
0.0510494784,
-0.0279994532,
0.0147323636,
-0.0753939375,
-0.0077818003,
-0.0330123194,
0.0146375978,
-0.0148672452,
-0.0337439775,
-0.0390494876,
-0.019154286,
-0.0586343072,
0.0107054077,
0.0092436317,
0.0265115518,
-0.0650281832,
-0.005139323,
-0.0275614038,
0.0197489876,
-0.0006825292,
-0.0209959857,
-0.008199363,
-0.0208204258,
-0.0361286886,
0.0077126226,
0.0262003038,
0.0140248379,
-0.0226702802,
0.0659790263,
-0.0471793935,
0.0199896004,
-0.0121265482,
-0.0353988186,
-0.0628193021,
-0.0337345116,
0.0194900203,
-0.0314772017,
0.0443630032,
-0.0300685782,
-0.0007632436,
-0.0802619308,
0.0131955203,
-0.013328162,
0.0209421404,
0.1015748158,
0.0076527889,
-0.0105618956,
0.0393783785,
0.0084127281,
-0.0294568744,
0.0438843332,
0.0156338606,
0.0187980831,
0.0083608357,
0.012839105,
0.0259779915,
0.004138154,
0.0117377108,
0.0116512114,
-0.0749829337,
-0.011071546,
0.0479262248,
0.0442459472,
0.0090720747,
0.0009292226,
-0.0231883265,
-0.0160059258,
0.0529782921,
-0.0186435357,
0.0336808041,
0.0389532782,
0.0288259424,
0.0166127402,
-0.04233725,
0.0320396647,
0.0005349565,
0.091885291,
0.0304163191,
-0.015557236,
0.0136826122,
-0.0265234821,
-0.0723339319,
-0.0506741144,
0.0465707369,
-0.0042599193,
-0.0229839589,
-0.0394517481,
0.0344356522,
0.0221736692,
-0.0252573565,
0.0862043053,
0.0154380081,
-0.0514762513,
0.0041334853,
-0.0182017665,
0.0053827157,
0.0654860735,
0.0108581586,
-0.0284343008,
-0.0362075604,
-0.0027127266,
0.0118644619,
0.0445427038,
0.0655515864,
0.000528716,
-0.0102008414,
-0.0194949135,
-0.0203293189,
-0.0379267819,
0.0024424202,
0.0536892042,
-0.0165824369,
0.0388006419,
0.0528248884,
-0.0093201417,
-0.0320303999,
0.0419791043,
0.0404727198,
0.0013773704,
-0.0029895857,
0.0150832301,
-0.0058060153,
0.0176820308,
-0.0065733655,
-0.0020224303,
-0.0157734342,
-0.0088303788,
-0.017028885,
0.0795664117,
-0.0773944333,
-0.0623078421,
0.0289564729,
-0.0583735146,
-0.0090530422,
0.0169481505,
-0.0186526217,
-0.040807534,
0.0585959889,
-0.0285564139,
-0.0015154992,
-0.0616696142,
0.028502671,
0.0202982537,
0.0142636215,
-0.002512556,
0.0616862178,
-0.0061817472,
-0.009503019,
0.0015978401,
-0.0000096076,
0.0044687199,
-0.0148678422,
-0.011337297,
-0.0113270665,
0.0111278417,
0.008937804,
0.0186064132,
0.0021594421,
-0.033235725,
-0.0058223251,
-0.0507997014,
-0.0246682446,
-0.0087672388,
-0.0636270866,
0.0279446859,
0.0051546474,
0.0288202763,
-0.0548378006,
-0.0356483981,
0.0357042998,
0.0111275679,
-0.0056706122,
0.0591509417,
0.0352540985,
-0.0018850183,
-0.0222827308,
0.0336667672,
-0.0025339068,
0.0363452993,
0.0180499945,
-0.0204081293,
-0.0737532526,
-0.0108414143,
-0.0225145128,
0.0242471881,
0.0037983118,
0.0001129387,
0.0178731326,
-0.0047651683,
0.0257157627,
0.0369770974,
0.0484928675,
0.0116027808,
0.0446587428,
-0.0440711193,
-0.0689439774,
0.013360247,
0.0006057824,
-0.0297997966,
0.0198208913,
-0.0417362526,
-0.0281105824,
0.0268741194,
-0.0350321904,
0.0378546976,
-0.0784733072,
-0.0022698799,
0.0138403922,
-0.0701503754,
-0.0102557736,
0.0508587398,
0.0033455724,
-0.0184762273,
-0.0487294719,
-0.0244955905,
0.0517470315,
-0.0414081477,
0.0045143785,
0.0113988817,
0.057304997,
-0.0107865622,
0.0966906026,
0.0041983626,
0.0490213744,
0.0164545067,
-0.0132291913,
-0.010540897,
-0.0346080698,
0.0502510667,
0.0049567791,
0.0254010446,
-0.0607445613,
0.0109961051,
-0.0196757503,
0.0056321546,
-0.0044679409,
-0.0522375926,
0.0051249419,
-0.0186233614,
-0.0713171288,
0.0116150258,
-0.036361821,
0.0532816537,
-0.0158554539,
0.0604185574,
0.005334463,
-0.0054725567,
-0.0086162593,
0.0108755985,
0.0176081005,
0.02469703,
-0.0713376254,
-0.001626208,
0.0309162568,
0.0302526318,
0.026060557,
0.0191272516,
-0.0525580943,
0.0280807652,
-0.0084840804,
-0.0130186928,
0.0190865677,
-0.0087379972,
0.0614253618,
-0.0520742387,
-0.0202847198,
0.0815656111,
0.0039566988,
-0.0716936588,
-0.032601811,
0.0141823888,
-0.0248555932,
0.0121754212,
0.0149875833,
-0.0400923789,
-0.0457024164,
-0.0324269272,
-0.0298431236,
0.0556368418,
0.0130371796,
-0.0305660125,
-0.0547399372,
0.0429050066,
0.0416356847,
-0.0412711799,
-0.0444697291,
0.0137489475,
0.0225837398,
0.0050900453,
-0.0540730357,
-0.0094719408,
0.0048151971,
-0.0205566194,
0.0147182839,
0.0344353653,
-0.0135736419,
-0.0062553748,
-0.05651851,
0.0003414601,
0.0587100238,
0.0228528734,
0.021786131,
-0.072940506,
-0.0226735324,
-0.0208657309,
0.0243416931,
0.0071639949,
0.0801558793,
-0.0263462048,
-0.0523288175,
0.0383523665,
-0.0079921745,
0.0263875406,
-0.0317527764,
-0.0101079168,
0.0013767126,
0.0008922149,
0.0201086123,
-0.0330863371,
0.041962862,
0.0256727431,
0.0220910702,
0.0153166763,
-0.0127521288,
-0.0321072862,
0.0107466308,
0.0316832513,
-0.041318126,
-0.0289000943,
-0.0101225479,
-0.0069442871,
-0.0588589236,
-0.0531893522,
-0.0075972867,
0.015987223,
0.0272333752,
0.0353611931,
-0.0196576864,
-0.0350414738,
0.0393359661,
-0.0841998383,
0.0081497179,
-0.0597765855,
0.0031994088,
-0.0153873023,
-0.0101303365,
0.1054198369,
-0.0027860692,
-0.0181001835,
0.0085874917,
-0.0388076566,
-0.025683118,
-0.0022274656,
0.0455386899,
0.0040608742,
0.103165172,
0.0208261535,
0.0191426892,
0.0132369678,
0.0238015912,
0.0383422598,
0.0082564456,
0.0132465288,
-0.0047452254,
-0.0390413739,
0.0167878196,
-0.043502517,
0.0166977365,
0.005954395,
0.0293703713,
0.0083381329,
-0.0357663333,
0.0308844056,
-0.0312314294,
0.0205104761,
0.0024036842,
0.0236697439,
-0.0250653457,
-0.0077399458,
-0.0255098175,
-0.0085503245,
-0.025214823,
0.0020478712,
-0.0079453234,
-0.0189651474,
-0.0187902283,
0.0505851321,
-0.017230276,
0.0073034032,
-0.0676533505,
-0.0214238372,
0.0199275743,
0.0045939488,
-0.0501362979,
-0.0008336991,
-0.0076950537,
-0.0225292183,
0.0220415369,
0.0320956931,
-0.0369813442,
0.0220904946,
0.01146199,
-0.0037085786,
-0.0559823401,
0.0690345839,
-0.0319651663,
-0.0079110824,
-0.0639734343,
0.0513459407,
0.0364972837,
-0.0081785042,
0.0279469807,
0.0178922266,
-0.0025594397,
-0.0044867219,
0.0239368714,
-0.0120509509,
-0.0292244125,
0.0319630988,
0.0022626244,
0.0310447495,
-0.0027841036,
0.0673284978,
-0.0309602041,
0.0420220681,
-0.0154047236,
-0.0177504569,
-0.0481312349,
-0.0079147173,
-0.0073541561,
-0.0488424152,
0.0044868677,
-0.0104332622,
0.0129023176,
-0.031422209,
0.0446650274,
0.0010922912,
0.0200412385,
0.0678658932,
0.0514359176,
0.0445279926,
0.0214374848,
0.0177595187,
-0.0102599747,
0.0179250427,
0.0193584636,
0.0045861779,
-0.0072439574,
-6.163931646e-33,
-0.0536691733,
0.0008963172,
0.0040555643,
-0.0549488217,
-0.0699795857,
0.0042477194,
-0.0530261062,
0.0178610105,
0.0181889907,
0.0291939583,
0.0336990543,
0.0109609198,
0.0272597987,
0.0141785555,
0.0531537421,
-0.0129460506,
0.113179855,
-0.0115543474,
-0.0043668607,
0.0261078458,
0.0195748117,
-0.001235489,
0.0489846766,
-0.0595335364,
0.0119809518,
-0.0144792143,
-0.0177488346,
-0.0106807351,
0.0360748619,
0.0121711129,
0.0066477256,
-0.028184481,
0.0061094644,
-0.0189822763,
-0.0507875569,
-0.0224775895,
-0.0517304093,
-0.0247444082,
-0.0133963451,
0.0371574275,
-0.0233003069,
-0.0549420416,
0.0069808965,
-0.0383782238,
-0.0303678848,
-0.0260120071,
0.0360408127,
-0.0237299837,
0.0420924164,
0.0360071845,
-0.0328401253,
-0.0026600757,
-0.0497978777,
-0.0778538436,
0.0464464389,
0.0210852195,
0.0502351113,
0.0463137701,
-0.0546320155,
0.0436322317,
-0.0264424477,
0.0428952686,
0.0901281908,
0.0458293147,
0.0055049025,
0.0723264366,
0.0429067574,
-0.050684575,
0.0142677445,
-0.0201593507,
-0.0149745047,
0.0457532816,
0.0303756427,
0.0545666665,
0.0491572283,
-0.0249978341,
-0.0376232304,
0.0262169931,
-0.1046567932,
0.0335534997,
0.0351560004,
0.0496219173,
0.0166129675,
0.027594097,
-0.036446996,
-0.0599830933,
-0.0400724187,
-0.0258342046,
0.0238676406,
0.0375366695,
-0.058062844,
0.0427779481,
0.0468307473,
-0.0121090477,
0.0148669435,
-0.0223840773,
-0.000514615,
0.0266911723,
-0.0073414915,
-0.0136622908,
0.0093637099,
-0.0281059239,
0.0600070357,
0.0395816714,
0.0301235113,
-0.0071942317,
0.042677816,
0.0231825523,
-0.016681483,
-0.0167414285,
-0.0087527642,
-0.0292406306,
-0.052794829,
-0.0052892808,
0.0027626853,
0.0415446125,
-0.0744447559,
-0.0134803392,
-0.0143898223,
-0.0043583508,
-0.0137377586,
0.0028902248,
0.0065476191,
0.0666415393,
-0.0161173455,
0.0344744362,
-0.0272532199,
-0.0242073499,
0.0028973513,
-0.0517403297,
-0.0390116125,
0.0276003629,
2.949e-7,
-0.0123352548,
0.0153623307,
0.0663467348,
-0.0139963441,
0.0467161611,
0.035721086,
-0.0393163003,
0.0380412899,
0.0196108278,
-0.0392615832,
0.0339609347,
0.0454031825,
0.0262947157,
-0.0042530657,
-0.0106441416,
0.0041409382,
-0.0179033857,
0.0108062299,
-0.0242938269,
-0.0400367826,
0.0711285919,
0.0198705029,
-0.0176250134,
0.0165023413,
0.0275290608,
-0.0199220963,
0.1004208028,
-0.0425542966,
-0.0099553512,
-0.005539245,
-0.0364765152,
0.0443522185,
-0.0570514984,
0.0080019012,
-0.0178180542,
-0.016013585,
0.0599355623,
-0.0247951262,
-0.0427285954,
-0.0175786652,
-0.0445611663,
0.0906374976,
0.0165958554,
-0.0160317589,
0.0517556779,
-0.0853743181,
-0.0067699654,
-0.045907747,
-0.0466037095,
0.0252558365,
0.0571201816,
-0.0044361977,
-0.0541717671,
0.026539553,
0.0303504262,
0.0517754704,
-0.0519463308,
-0.073962763,
-0.0053336876,
-0.0210973602,
-0.0079517439,
0.0169841647,
-0.0519585013,
-0.0441937409,
0.0265248623,
-0.0150156291,
0.0019054842,
1.719361952e-34,
0.0193962064,
0.0259664617,
-0.0037227096,
-0.0459422469,
0.0022777794,
0.0100988643,
0.0120988032,
-0.0215697978,
-0.0040466804,
-0.0194418877,
-0.0353395939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16275v1 | UPB @ ACTI: Detecting Conspiracies using fine tuned Sentence Transformers | 2023-09-28T09:17:20 | 2023-09-28T09:17:20 | Andrei Paraschiv, Mihai Dascalu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Conspiracy theories have become a prominent and concerning aspect of online
discourse, posing challenges to information integrity and societal trust. As
such, we address conspiracy theory detection as proposed by the ACTI @ EVALITA
2023 shared task. The combination of pre-trained sentence Transformer models
and data augmentation techniques enabled us to secure first place in the final
leaderboard of both sub-tasks. Our methodology attained F1 scores of 85.71% in
the binary classification and 91.23% for the fine-grained conspiracy topic
classification, surpassing other competing systems. | [
0.0446155444,
0.0782616884,
-0.0124227833,
0.0358934477,
-0.0244365409,
-0.0019603635,
0.049667865,
-0.0013662889,
-0.0335512534,
-0.0338775031,
-0.0175745655,
-0.0024882806,
-0.0086966185,
0.0584626608,
0.0006373854,
-0.0184279047,
0.0365341231,
0.0048733312,
0.051582288,
0.0125202844,
0.0199745838,
0.0350101218,
-0.0352132507,
0.035635449,
-0.0248143189,
0.0232862495,
0.0579719171,
-0.0099101653,
0.0454502255,
0.0043744473,
0.0135396384,
0.0437694266,
0.0328281149,
0.0986963809,
0.0000019121,
-0.0081574786,
-0.0409011133,
-0.0209539607,
-0.0590723902,
0.0230496917,
0.0405877717,
-0.0316356756,
0.0064169504,
0.0326679945,
-0.0448061563,
0.0523350127,
0.0197697021,
0.061230205,
0.0666680709,
0.1348906606,
-0.0225052759,
-0.0096853385,
0.0605888367,
-0.0212836005,
-0.0251367334,
0.0014153062,
0.027590517,
-0.0219007228,
-0.0630582124,
0.0470358096,
0.0240357462,
-0.005229021,
0.0182932075,
-0.0177776571,
-0.0250994284,
0.0001128278,
-0.0523864776,
-0.0222678185,
0.0059488392,
0.0248701386,
0.015607059,
-0.0173606258,
-0.003525127,
0.0151652992,
0.00404474,
0.0333850607,
-0.0326465368,
0.0164735112,
-0.014582566,
-0.0085766818,
0.0567834489,
0.010073198,
0.0274037644,
0.0231820475,
0.0074027292,
0.0377768613,
0.0026597979,
-0.0324741602,
-0.0290582515,
-0.0174740069,
-0.033322271,
-0.0389306992,
0.0453614481,
-0.0014836979,
-0.0211093649,
-0.0144821722,
-0.0487901419,
-0.0547044389,
0.0154186441,
-0.0364714563,
0.0107709486,
-0.0134397391,
-0.0133321723,
0.0514964275,
0.0016141128,
0.0335786045,
-0.0291535165,
0.025593508,
-0.0235741511,
-0.0238581523,
-0.0020486105,
0.0038720535,
-0.0281161591,
0.0137160188,
-0.0608911328,
-0.0105006136,
-0.0490623936,
-0.0255578607,
-0.0133163994,
-0.026763685,
0.0178285334,
-0.0021393732,
-0.0443692207,
-0.0439378917,
0.0050505833,
0.0873254091,
-0.022205038,
0.0440876521,
-0.0127018159,
-0.0428184941,
-0.0394533202,
0.0370017216,
0.0138211297,
-0.0161747821,
-0.0154074356,
-0.0102964919,
-0.001244686,
-0.0352823958,
-0.0144714881,
-0.0152856363,
-0.0412966572,
-0.0102038169,
0.0268820226,
-0.0142934201,
-0.0097829215,
-0.0392415039,
0.0044137477,
-0.00287523,
-0.0040892111,
-0.007220095,
-0.0139899636,
0.0566480756,
0.0170719158,
-0.0373238958,
0.0426109247,
0.0219154879,
-0.0076140687,
0.0411137454,
0.0071072616,
0.1134166196,
0.0496596023,
-0.0005683628,
0.0679144189,
0.021434404,
0.0187649913,
0.0263215508,
0.0401939712,
0.0010321707,
-0.0544543862,
-0.0034957952,
-0.0241677742,
0.0011637489,
-0.0193093903,
-0.0241860114,
0.0439325869,
0.0119725764,
-0.0218446925,
-0.0146356151,
0.0268286448,
0.0051785647,
-0.0551762171,
-0.019608872,
-0.0228383504,
0.0191400815,
-0.0834862441,
-0.0584475845,
-0.0345467031,
0.0606253147,
-0.0078959949,
-0.0314559899,
-0.0164627526,
-0.0192505531,
0.0122773433,
-0.0262640659,
0.0158036742,
0.0224665422,
-0.0602925569,
-0.0231760424,
0.0192513373,
-0.0152774695,
-0.0004300147,
-0.0674375892,
0.0060317651,
0.0275147557,
0.0103345932,
0.016733814,
-0.0410616547,
-0.0641536862,
0.0886436775,
0.0669637695,
0.010639607,
-0.0054192138,
-0.0081193959,
-0.0361442305,
-0.0018908047,
-0.0540461317,
0.0334625654,
0.0314942077,
0.0121281659,
0.0192641784,
0.023184089,
-0.0260423236,
0.0089384215,
0.0215918738,
-0.0136147691,
-0.0200473852,
-0.0184197426,
0.0268597323,
0.0421229266,
-0.001845768,
-0.0160683561,
-0.006065357,
0.0356471576,
-0.0399764292,
-0.0479542129,
-0.0140664531,
0.0272575617,
0.0093886312,
-0.0148369363,
-0.0679914132,
-0.0089698965,
0.0658576488,
-0.0290744137,
-0.0052938974,
0.0612877347,
-0.0312221441,
-0.0246030688,
-0.0109970691,
-0.0043624127,
-0.0172542222,
0.0477782376,
-0.0223172363,
0.0460753441,
-0.0206097458,
-0.046316646,
0.0121040735,
-0.0326662399,
0.0259557068,
0.0520550571,
-0.0000116589,
0.0034608415,
-0.0097042462,
0.0138000175,
0.0743645355,
-0.0345448814,
-0.0143146096,
-0.0420553945,
-0.0576833077,
0.0042895451,
-0.0461059064,
0.0052432911,
0.0484188162,
0.0168498475,
0.0143415136,
0.0144939674,
-0.0188745707,
0.0196676236,
-0.0284099542,
0.0145862969,
0.0067913299,
-0.0320134237,
-0.0448035598,
-0.0352472477,
-0.0135428673,
-0.0234603211,
0.0400289148,
0.0249390323,
0.0026590743,
-0.0298132952,
-0.0185033623,
-0.0130163319,
0.0008477167,
-0.0307043977,
-0.0569539107,
0.0368633009,
0.0018235559,
0.0086698728,
0.0614611581,
0.0710805207,
0.0781654045,
-0.0097192414,
0.0157478247,
-0.0127804652,
-0.018171737,
-0.0372129753,
-0.0077117132,
-0.0655101165,
-0.0215436723,
0.0245940704,
0.0771912262,
0.0022542907,
0.006109274,
-0.0361431278,
0.0333249606,
-0.016099412,
-0.0291134231,
0.0457030274,
-0.0715661421,
-0.0100812679,
0.0307777319,
-0.016480878,
-0.019905461,
0.0721809715,
-0.0359876826,
0.0458647758,
-0.0581914708,
-0.0502737947,
-0.0055904891,
0.0482970774,
0.0181328412,
-0.0159235373,
0.0252247043,
0.0069356831,
-0.0332699008,
-0.0185295977,
0.0290033109,
0.000707684,
-0.0316725671,
-0.0158351585,
0.0066482676,
0.0211835597,
-0.0035942968,
-0.0629296154,
-0.1099769473,
-0.0380474664,
-0.0273601748,
0.033942204,
-0.0492945351,
-0.0876537859,
-0.0127077643,
0.0204945728,
0.0120684123,
-0.006611045,
0.0014326763,
0.0165365897,
0.0241596904,
0.0645613819,
-0.0147311157,
0.060117431,
-0.0006851709,
-0.0240811091,
0.0519479699,
-0.058846768,
-0.0200941004,
-0.0178086571,
-0.0375427678,
0.0174481012,
-0.0258864854,
-0.0134401098,
-0.0350901447,
0.0555053763,
-0.0427361876,
0.0141554428,
0.135268718,
0.0093590254,
0.0054186699,
-0.0002867433,
0.0542705841,
-0.0137994345,
0.0139475623,
-0.0115438914,
-0.0801301301,
0.0035525835,
-0.0191471297,
0.0043062232,
-0.0189738534,
-0.0422544256,
-0.0222514011,
-0.077569738,
0.025093399,
-0.000242915,
0.0089326575,
0.0080516906,
-0.0799485296,
-0.0070084445,
-0.0169161316,
0.0328946598,
-0.0494328998,
0.0263711065,
-0.0030195974,
-0.0226801764,
-0.0226480123,
-0.0194721743,
0.0003623205,
-0.0034610792,
0.0297460165,
0.0381592922,
0.0397568755,
-0.0123764817,
-0.0441530421,
0.02662641,
-0.0068649431,
-0.0186270382,
-0.0008517152,
0.0869155675,
-0.0283681545,
-0.0082147885,
0.0045587877,
0.0590540133,
-0.0440192372,
-0.0277653169,
-0.0037954468,
0.0438847318,
-0.0064796745,
-0.0367910676,
-0.010309739,
0.0204743724,
0.0150617631,
0.022985477,
0.0201545451,
-0.0090775862,
0.0125197154,
-0.0168002341,
0.0359479114,
-0.054667525,
-0.0025780157,
0.0211028941,
0.0222752299,
-0.0525773279,
-0.064459987,
-0.0652083978,
0.024421582,
0.0003692975,
-0.0204868466,
-0.0215189569,
-0.0177307185,
-0.0047338069,
-0.0247555636,
0.0075762118,
-0.0114296414,
0.0362608321,
-0.0090986863,
-0.008654763,
-0.009982626,
0.0148584349,
-0.0068333996,
0.0252423976,
-0.110708721,
-0.0340287574,
0.046828486,
0.0254531782,
0.0171324704,
0.0390251465,
-0.0611444525,
-0.0179371666,
0.0633655488,
0.0133644901,
-0.0655995756,
0.0159711186,
0.0348888971,
-0.0399385802,
0.0173707847,
0.0156552922,
-0.0098010143,
0.0633412451,
0.0039906693,
-0.0137113929,
-0.0926252529,
-0.0315358043,
0.0136767831,
0.0367238894,
0.1048851833,
-0.0175067112,
-0.0224476401,
-0.0241153985,
0.0040109376,
-0.0433098264,
-0.006576614,
-0.0000943559,
0.003533514,
0.0348729193,
0.0156723633,
-0.0202923063,
0.0301173124,
-0.0332178324,
0.0252968837,
-0.0351315327,
0.0147925708,
0.0161322728,
0.0451429933,
0.018882338,
0.0209120288,
-0.0284777265,
0.0566817448,
0.0261063501,
0.0399249047,
-0.002956629,
-0.0115813147,
0.0066646761,
0.0145627009,
-0.0039149132,
0.0305904187,
-0.0799621642,
-0.0195566788,
-0.0205048211,
0.0151963783,
0.0081438459,
-0.0048131561,
0.0598556213,
-0.0093077961,
-0.0031992563,
0.0259869937,
0.0320714861,
-0.0151560949,
0.0124957366,
0.0092161382,
0.0037585036,
-0.0497729667,
0.0430533141,
0.0439111441,
-0.0428898409,
0.0312955789,
0.0733616725,
-0.0160606652,
-0.0342868753,
-0.0340322554,
-0.0548208989,
0.0255517252,
0.0257279389,
0.0132659562,
-0.0340933241,
-0.020117579,
0.0345950387,
-0.0418222994,
-0.0023251446,
0.0103391297,
-0.0318329521,
0.0756503567,
-0.0279330052,
0.0127137462,
-0.0143680219,
-0.0252393167,
0.0275696013,
-0.0481490605,
0.0120585039,
-6.409426294e-33,
0.0166777112,
-0.0201074742,
-0.0031511723,
0.0304515921,
-0.0033023774,
0.0478307717,
0.0168916881,
-0.0091966763,
-0.0402819328,
0.0311430208,
0.0210278034,
0.0441128239,
0.0019360655,
0.0230488498,
-0.0645968467,
-0.0083060553,
0.0870692506,
0.0222654864,
-0.0285055619,
0.0036519845,
0.0716016218,
0.0213652421,
0.081071496,
-0.0930753499,
0.00929695,
0.0005608596,
-0.0421009026,
0.006741662,
0.0351364128,
0.0493740439,
0.0017609794,
0.037274044,
0.0136464275,
-0.0462921709,
0.012076092,
0.0074533103,
-0.010510291,
-0.0152649963,
0.0047070663,
0.0025852863,
0.0304366928,
-0.0533910468,
-0.0251038224,
-0.0175741222,
0.0174896773,
-0.0426169001,
0.0309923179,
-0.011229055,
0.0240676589,
-0.0185428914,
-0.0897912383,
0.0001479538,
-0.0252337754,
-0.0004287935,
-0.0414601266,
0.0352395587,
0.0371227041,
0.0266385339,
-0.0645523444,
0.0414188989,
-0.0102831563,
0.0176038258,
0.0156220719,
-0.0241773706,
-0.0588588268,
0.0455453433,
0.0143898856,
0.0418436565,
-0.0746405497,
0.0196882933,
0.0108168675,
0.0691890195,
0.0563409217,
0.1175831184,
0.0473676249,
-0.0362510048,
-0.0963954479,
0.0207624584,
0.011397399,
0.0287863966,
0.031980969,
-0.004358836,
-0.0226127952,
-0.0049331789,
-0.0202781539,
0.0179917756,
-0.0283678696,
-0.0125988256,
-0.0130178435,
0.0238746926,
-0.0563958809,
0.058817178,
0.0392495431,
-0.0477094017,
0.0629599094,
0.0472260378,
-0.0311921686,
-0.0157938804,
0.0042397366,
0.058031477,
-0.043040812,
0.0183175709,
0.0584429279,
0.0135493632,
0.0286606681,
-0.0083121276,
0.0604501404,
0.0139545072,
-0.053259626,
0.0093028136,
-0.0308031421,
0.0253529157,
-0.0148116769,
0.0130579993,
0.0070534586,
0.0410945043,
-0.0216962714,
-0.0026479047,
0.0210305639,
0.0285175554,
0.0269972794,
-0.007603229,
0.001405719,
0.0174951106,
-0.0360499807,
-0.0268952101,
0.0014144424,
-0.0085826702,
0.0209681001,
-0.1155926362,
-0.0081192907,
-0.0511133596,
2.691e-7,
0.0471649095,
0.0586257465,
0.024401186,
-0.0421101153,
-0.0270897523,
0.0172964353,
0.0557378605,
0.0194775257,
-0.006668149,
-0.0278282892,
0.0174764618,
0.0285083875,
0.0309954975,
0.0347344726,
-0.0298903398,
-0.0763084441,
-0.0389480442,
0.0075204778,
-0.0689807758,
-0.0134224268,
0.0417199694,
0.0907191932,
0.0557133071,
-0.0217472129,
-0.0250854082,
-0.0392461531,
0.0358088613,
-0.0347752608,
-0.0448533632,
0.0323596597,
0.0206575133,
0.002418285,
0.0045067612,
0.0191531777,
-0.0418094918,
0.0112869488,
-0.0263792966,
0.0218701735,
-0.0058294474,
-0.028298378,
-0.0080587938,
-0.0198566969,
-0.0100636249,
-0.0334449932,
0.0423690379,
-0.0556069016,
-0.0426870361,
0.0181413461,
-0.0933256075,
0.0296511278,
0.0326708443,
-0.0362655707,
-0.00163546,
0.0030627761,
0.0150695331,
0.0437482297,
0.0037619197,
-0.0568019897,
0.0272945315,
0.0238937326,
-0.0561328046,
-0.0310671628,
-0.0115200523,
-0.0448756665,
0.035873726,
0.0249308627,
0.0298988707,
2.603467899e-34,
0.032871373,
-0.0093703913,
-0.0137061998,
-0.0079293232,
0.0633154437,
-0.0089900065,
-0.0337624215,
-0.0200059637,
0.0142957224,
-0.0907892361,
-0.0124176126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16270v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16270v1 | Social Media Fashion Knowledge Extraction as Captioning | 2023-09-28T09:07:48 | 2023-09-28T09:07:48 | Yifei Yuan, Wenxuan Zhang, Yang Deng, Wai Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social media plays a significant role in boosting the fashion industry, where
a massive amount of fashion-related posts are generated every day. In order to
obtain the rich fashion information from the posts, we study the task of social
media fashion knowledge extraction. Fashion knowledge, which typically consists
of the occasion, person attributes, and fashion item information, can be
effectively represented as a set of tuples. Most previous studies on fashion
knowledge extraction are based on the fashion product images without
considering the rich text information in social media posts. Existing work on
fashion knowledge extraction in social media is classification-based and
requires to manually determine a set of fashion knowledge categories in
advance. In our work, we propose to cast the task as a captioning problem to
capture the interplay of the multimodal post information. Specifically, we
transform the fashion knowledge tuples into a natural language caption with a
sentence transformation method. Our framework then aims to generate the
sentence-based fashion knowledge directly from the social media post. Inspired
by the big success of pre-trained models, we build our model based on a
multimodal pre-trained generative model and design several auxiliary tasks for
enhancing the knowledge extraction. Since there is no existing dataset which
can be directly borrowed to our task, we introduce a dataset consisting of
social media posts with manual fashion knowledge annotation. Extensive
experiments are conducted to demonstrate the effectiveness of our model. | [
0.0408099443,
0.0905091986,
0.0155097526,
0.023888506,
0.0040555699,
-0.0030461175,
0.016753912,
0.0079220627,
-0.0143158995,
-0.085877113,
-0.0138877258,
0.0214315839,
-0.0153520675,
0.0559362285,
0.0396731906,
-0.0377414599,
-0.0261888001,
-0.0192269348,
0.0119317686,
0.0284637734,
0.0419363379,
0.0482489951,
-0.0257393867,
0.0019381255,
-0.0494401194,
-0.0224305764,
0.0223052483,
0.0121792257,
-0.0099404249,
0.0018868357,
0.0604500547,
0.0654671937,
0.0674429014,
-0.0563058816,
0.000001706,
0.0184822474,
0.0065947268,
-0.0428418443,
0.031687811,
-0.0351169407,
0.0613073595,
-0.006551865,
0.0399258733,
-0.0208298005,
-0.0440371744,
-0.021243887,
0.0546581559,
0.0713369846,
0.0429059379,
0.0531327203,
-0.0469894819,
-0.0733776763,
0.0205495786,
-0.0045195958,
0.0182009526,
-0.033915434,
-0.009163565,
0.0251169633,
-0.0137553439,
0.0052922899,
0.0164902657,
0.0514681116,
-0.0304633584,
-0.0124012064,
0.0232684333,
0.0218674764,
0.0096074231,
-0.0353438854,
-0.0324835591,
0.1075024754,
0.0125275636,
0.0027406332,
-0.0175294466,
0.0216960423,
0.0116112866,
0.025333412,
-0.0333498754,
0.0102085462,
-0.0180432014,
0.0077357502,
-0.0614029616,
0.0380086154,
-0.0153371887,
0.0060857204,
0.0072997161,
-0.0349169523,
0.0107136164,
0.0019708429,
-0.0502632037,
0.000444511,
-0.0633057803,
-0.0515040085,
0.000348261,
-0.0146818776,
0.0281594619,
0.0154804029,
-0.0174255203,
-0.0362363122,
0.0059065432,
-0.0465764441,
0.0207544994,
-0.0474763662,
-0.0370947719,
0.0403884947,
0.006366062,
0.008569642,
-0.0101828873,
0.0100793475,
-0.0441273078,
0.0084700547,
-0.0542943962,
-0.0222402792,
-0.0067980858,
0.0082269879,
-0.0697605237,
-0.0471237488,
-0.0034640492,
-0.0383542404,
0.0023197006,
0.0101740845,
-0.0154737793,
0.0418851227,
-0.0112159709,
0.0116304876,
-0.0051179533,
0.0369562171,
-0.0139131015,
0.0209221765,
-0.0105647231,
0.0020355331,
0.0313230567,
-0.0069583473,
0.0817119554,
-0.0188355856,
-0.003565517,
0.0331961252,
-0.0560887344,
-0.0183383878,
-0.0520866178,
-0.0561668761,
-0.0394267216,
-0.0417425595,
0.0397300199,
-0.0497816056,
0.0520382412,
-0.0121025341,
0.0068073529,
-0.0274042115,
-0.0055616079,
0.0146645186,
-0.0475880615,
0.0910411924,
-0.0023672243,
0.012471782,
0.0358552709,
0.0062834737,
0.0330854468,
0.0634145886,
-0.0000339912,
0.0668532923,
0.0657053143,
-0.0069572586,
0.0368690975,
0.0268105008,
0.0251790583,
-0.0593246929,
-0.0139966235,
0.0042639887,
0.0091974679,
0.0237174388,
0.0315996781,
0.0142707564,
-0.0003053545,
0.0729294866,
0.0924697593,
-0.0313279182,
0.0342728198,
0.0484920591,
0.0361765362,
0.0256639719,
-0.0037138441,
-0.0183220301,
-0.0472322851,
0.0378080942,
-0.0362695977,
0.005481841,
-0.0010212437,
0.0115238419,
-0.0280456375,
-0.0236821081,
0.0443317443,
-0.0257873964,
0.008622434,
0.0183365643,
0.0269735046,
0.0337638743,
-0.0399179608,
0.0258161947,
0.0228734594,
-0.0523224249,
-0.0208538435,
-0.000659031,
0.0066222148,
0.0596033484,
-0.0271613114,
0.0128154019,
-0.0008173719,
0.0139407758,
0.0312554389,
0.0376378,
-0.0019609279,
-0.0139134796,
0.0416381508,
-0.0090189073,
-0.0332908146,
-0.0525457412,
-0.0005593945,
-0.0143925715,
0.0010421315,
0.0204773806,
0.0308014639,
0.0050788084,
-0.0280187633,
0.0204806235,
0.0393995456,
-0.0296595022,
-0.0227191597,
0.0318671577,
-0.0529909469,
0.0348016545,
-0.0234046746,
-0.0045052487,
0.0059569529,
-0.045388829,
-0.0275175665,
0.0493169986,
-0.0302935541,
-0.0739976019,
0.0012707096,
-0.0581147596,
-0.0360882655,
-0.0079473034,
-0.0532265529,
-0.0417434946,
0.0417878665,
-0.0054027247,
0.0105324611,
-0.0269398689,
-0.0638454407,
0.0262859222,
0.0207015742,
-0.0021921524,
0.0759024695,
0.0327910297,
-0.0124334069,
-0.0359276012,
-0.0364869572,
-0.032214988,
0.0058533149,
-0.0290520564,
-0.0005942285,
0.017556455,
0.043339245,
0.0611777343,
0.0059171109,
-0.0237035435,
-0.0011825204,
-0.1082021967,
-0.0047721569,
0.0067869658,
-0.0176796652,
-0.0316310115,
-0.0083009563,
-0.014136197,
-0.0495970584,
-0.0564837679,
0.0282931607,
-0.0416538753,
-0.0028662987,
0.0353786759,
0.0529663414,
0.0078138281,
-0.0318316966,
0.0068439408,
0.037514247,
0.0960855931,
0.0462615713,
0.0072680316,
-0.0014317757,
-0.0048834225,
-0.0401225537,
0.028563546,
0.0379731432,
-0.0219520796,
-0.0072147888,
-0.0413918383,
0.0331726,
0.0044286367,
0.058708474,
0.0028688174,
-0.0358782187,
-0.03859495,
-0.0015980433,
0.006811271,
-0.0293927155,
-0.0285991784,
0.0016172304,
-0.0227402709,
0.0176651813,
0.0235610213,
-0.0053899824,
0.0089309858,
-0.015266614,
0.028608283,
0.0351126753,
-0.0197868552,
-0.0456903614,
0.0655290782,
0.0239706561,
0.0534504466,
-0.041843567,
-0.0426110104,
-0.006848983,
-0.009261095,
-0.0260454863,
0.0281851441,
-0.0146256313,
-0.0096364496,
0.0824853778,
0.0226875637,
0.0442692339,
-0.0071481382,
-0.0016726576,
0.0068143755,
-0.0149425054,
0.0250116456,
0.0068190857,
0.0027769175,
-0.0204671193,
0.0148856407,
-0.0155277662,
-0.0388958938,
-0.008272565,
-0.0558116958,
-0.0406159349,
-0.0459055416,
-0.0331589803,
-0.000364435,
0.027058458,
-0.0024226168,
-0.046986293,
0.0326934829,
-0.013409676,
-0.0125294039,
0.0124519179,
0.0728932992,
0.0724363551,
0.0233505797,
-0.0799633712,
-0.0050242953,
-0.0258490108,
0.0316333063,
-0.0537915789,
-0.0048562381,
-0.0583170913,
0.0095957043,
0.0139472969,
-0.0065567191,
0.0137044312,
0.012082085,
0.0580929182,
-0.0112263002,
0.0078933211,
0.093132019,
0.0038259295,
-0.0313161239,
0.0050224671,
0.0985187739,
-0.0261375513,
0.002107884,
0.0222176947,
-0.0821555108,
-0.0360321775,
-0.0459442288,
-0.0065050405,
0.0380697586,
0.012788957,
-0.0247545075,
-0.0801750198,
0.005991634,
-0.0040069078,
-0.0224695019,
-0.037070483,
0.0284666307,
-0.0169065576,
-0.0006095393,
0.0210972931,
-0.01273051,
-0.0290826373,
0.0138874333,
0.0019826971,
-0.0061614537,
-0.0524770878,
0.0437803566,
-0.0497452468,
0.0299440511,
0.0265452527,
0.0340004452,
-0.0233959984,
-0.0513598286,
-0.0243622176,
0.014789518,
0.0016036966,
0.002114177,
0.0667249188,
-0.040786311,
-0.0108479802,
0.0198501032,
0.0274345856,
-0.043426577,
0.0027585635,
0.0087864706,
-0.0254469886,
0.0128702624,
-0.0212015249,
-0.0228088778,
0.0010333286,
0.0186970476,
0.0526527278,
0.0405984223,
-0.0475095138,
-0.0062972098,
-0.034970738,
0.0220760517,
-0.0799034759,
-0.0100539187,
-0.0038297554,
-0.0261725169,
-0.0000218907,
-0.0906853452,
0.0048919539,
0.0558311269,
0.0285034031,
-0.0058904109,
-0.0386322029,
-0.018857494,
0.0614869334,
-0.0666948482,
0.0154280448,
-0.0155568495,
-0.0153275579,
0.0089904871,
-0.0260074772,
0.0363233611,
-0.0425909795,
-0.0118150245,
0.0244483501,
-0.0658033714,
-0.0173607618,
-0.0325754583,
0.0597431958,
0.007309387,
0.0126200691,
0.018594157,
-0.044952482,
0.0081490222,
0.0752026439,
-0.0059662582,
-0.0261141863,
0.0127447816,
-0.0172947068,
-0.0082728593,
0.0316419825,
-0.0300484058,
0.0587415658,
-0.0118543636,
0.0162181426,
0.0295230281,
-0.0469550602,
0.0141712287,
-0.0105680637,
0.0471161008,
-0.0397126563,
0.0172825567,
-0.0352137573,
-0.0394417234,
-0.0038052341,
-0.0256393924,
-0.080111973,
0.0214702152,
-0.0202133134,
0.0531721376,
-0.0345638432,
-0.0159495343,
0.0239739418,
0.0453278758,
-0.0720612556,
-0.0160271227,
0.0531526692,
-0.0102169299,
-0.0346245095,
0.0082359845,
0.0075425277,
0.022932088,
-0.0097905947,
-0.0069066463,
-0.0173904635,
0.0072115124,
0.0219381768,
-0.0042607812,
-0.0557477437,
0.0545806773,
0.0172185712,
0.0108114723,
-0.0681267306,
0.046610035,
0.0665344298,
-0.0440366901,
0.0177577212,
0.025682997,
-0.0205380376,
0.0228008516,
0.087698251,
-0.0095039727,
-0.0364921466,
0.0388960615,
-0.0009556852,
-0.0083276546,
-0.0226726476,
0.0798988864,
0.0015830073,
0.010672533,
0.0377086028,
-0.025654899,
-0.0463645458,
0.0303488187,
0.0020340153,
-0.0137956589,
0.019089967,
0.0493074805,
0.002666346,
-0.0653220117,
0.0267665051,
-0.0094740326,
-0.0198803749,
0.0745883584,
0.0483850464,
0.0681237727,
0.0486790314,
-0.0037829091,
-0.0367303304,
0.0076118452,
-0.0123453634,
0.0308881309,
0.0110811908,
-5.709481856e-33,
-0.0211000964,
-0.0329235122,
0.0060660262,
0.0179163851,
-0.0425786041,
0.0129467994,
-0.0423883088,
0.0036922875,
0.0112520605,
0.0218210854,
0.0228762534,
-0.059713278,
0.0037855129,
0.056402836,
0.0443416126,
-0.0009120112,
0.0395443514,
0.0093335183,
-0.0141418781,
0.0346379764,
0.0561910942,
0.0314166248,
0.0800824091,
-0.042972818,
0.005527107,
-0.0200722981,
-0.0261154044,
0.0279450584,
0.1044618562,
0.0221029315,
-0.0395059213,
0.0340839326,
0.0129424399,
-0.0486538224,
-0.0055532674,
0.0448993146,
-0.0904977769,
-0.005105617,
0.0113632074,
0.011253519,
-0.0227693208,
0.0012482271,
0.0216644835,
-0.0375719257,
0.0397090614,
-0.0047148806,
0.0692714676,
-0.0345645025,
0.0520702004,
-0.0431175567,
-0.0665511638,
-0.0050135097,
-0.0200795699,
-0.0357278101,
0.0537843816,
0.0136900675,
0.0242818613,
-0.003725111,
-0.0286036357,
0.0410868675,
0.0050682565,
-0.021894455,
0.0605808161,
0.0239704028,
-0.007910057,
0.0283004604,
-0.0312118884,
0.0064693205,
-0.0593996346,
0.073454313,
-0.0001106641,
0.0842127502,
-0.0141722336,
0.0432648286,
0.0734044611,
-0.0012948163,
-0.0285540782,
0.0285768993,
-0.0466660038,
0.0113956323,
-0.0339550003,
0.0263305288,
0.0193596799,
0.007183339,
-0.0228680037,
-0.0277311448,
-0.0525954179,
-0.0150134284,
-0.0096172635,
0.0315409862,
-0.0611013435,
0.0815840289,
0.0489797518,
-0.0155194029,
-0.026620809,
-0.0380804278,
-0.0158351324,
0.0147129111,
-0.0193979368,
-0.041222889,
-0.0313894339,
-0.0318090692,
0.0503216647,
0.01411625,
0.0012536533,
0.0064481092,
0.0509393178,
0.0456162728,
-0.0170914233,
-0.0143237552,
-0.010755796,
-0.0065940162,
-0.0520097688,
-0.0021118002,
0.0138191599,
0.0371815264,
-0.0949453935,
-0.0030338704,
0.0049076551,
0.0470566191,
-0.0316167548,
0.0015799667,
0.0300659463,
0.0181650203,
-0.0230001267,
-0.0097240405,
-0.021113595,
-0.0601702221,
-0.0056965617,
-0.0625050962,
-0.014429342,
0.0130860191,
2.315e-7,
0.0337754823,
0.0112530543,
0.0193888955,
0.0285491198,
0.0202672202,
0.0315639675,
0.0135301463,
0.0349649973,
-0.0187872183,
-0.0463590696,
0.0136839403,
0.0240648352,
0.0162625071,
-0.0100525934,
-0.0424357019,
-0.0501825213,
-0.0010579921,
0.0102123013,
-0.0597323067,
-0.0146340448,
0.0538461283,
0.0594436862,
0.0180696137,
-0.0405260138,
0.0067252978,
-0.0729216188,
0.0980067402,
0.0035804494,
-0.0027496191,
-0.0157922376,
0.0649857968,
0.0055407332,
-0.0415338911,
-0.0086413138,
-0.0326147191,
-0.0100208698,
0.0815605149,
0.0258486699,
0.0169869494,
0.0160432085,
-0.0319814794,
0.0540698953,
-0.0171012618,
-0.0159592722,
0.0695669875,
-0.0911781862,
-0.0388177112,
-0.0762477368,
-0.0475205705,
0.0413101204,
-0.012154771,
-0.0174528584,
-0.0456852652,
0.036107637,
0.0411897674,
-0.0118478732,
-0.0320807584,
-0.0889828578,
-0.0268316865,
0.0138301291,
-0.0336902253,
0.0241775885,
-0.0110599305,
-0.0428677239,
0.0140616409,
-0.0228550714,
0.0024048144,
1.342124463e-34,
0.0130706532,
0.0028791775,
-0.0296994206,
0.011776072,
0.0249792002,
-0.0084278565,
-0.0425151475,
-0.0191577282,
-0.0228167046,
-0.0695707053,
0.012610402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16254v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16254v1 | On the Challenges of Fully Incremental Neural Dependency Parsing | 2023-09-28T08:44:08 | 2023-09-28T08:44:08 | Ana Ezquerro, Carlos Gómez-Rodríguez, David Vilares | cs.CL | cs.CL | Since the popularization of BiLSTMs and Transformer-based bidirectional
encoders, state-of-the-art syntactic parsers have lacked incrementality,
requiring access to the whole sentence and deviating from human language
processing. This paper explores whether fully incremental dependency parsing
with modern architectures can be competitive. We build parsers combining
strictly left-to-right neural encoders with fully incremental sequence-labeling
and transition-based decoders. The results show that fully incremental parsing
with modern architectures considerably lags behind bidirectional parsing,
noting the challenges of psycholinguistically plausible parsing. | [
0.0063169072,
0.0986705124,
0.0058980393,
0.0350107476,
-0.037728902,
0.0185882337,
-0.0033158169,
-0.0245415457,
-0.015574825,
-0.0275738072,
0.0025380559,
0.0069764284,
-0.0223332662,
0.070572637,
0.0007550279,
-0.0459829234,
0.0419721939,
0.0241565499,
-0.001674808,
0.0173158776,
-0.0290643908,
-0.0155806337,
-0.0445146263,
0.0227274038,
-0.0163303744,
-0.0496952869,
-0.0088564111,
-0.0201068539,
-0.0100490237,
-0.0480161794,
0.0213524047,
0.0122012934,
0.0323739089,
-0.0085770842,
0.0000017597,
-0.0234184079,
0.0080797384,
-0.016143078,
-0.0427038968,
-0.0326884761,
-0.009265638,
-0.0791033655,
-0.0313203558,
-0.0401829295,
-0.0185464695,
-0.0311406534,
0.0009448066,
0.044355005,
0.0838498771,
0.0685538575,
-0.0087522985,
-0.0854257792,
0.064446412,
-0.0378914662,
-0.0329683162,
-0.002456645,
-0.0045896033,
-0.0112579949,
-0.0010815415,
-0.0107449098,
-0.0458695292,
0.0290574823,
0.0802570954,
0.0086291898,
0.0180665739,
0.0238695256,
0.0159120727,
0.0084142229,
-0.0232434738,
0.0270759389,
-0.0443253703,
0.0105595747,
-0.0195126571,
-0.0220987126,
-0.0188720897,
-0.0645627826,
-0.0215639733,
0.0569362268,
-0.0218714755,
0.0491185114,
0.04159436,
-0.0000608955,
-0.0139223943,
-0.0039917105,
0.0101511311,
0.109544158,
-0.0132180331,
-0.0661011711,
-0.0006090567,
0.0544948503,
0.0011672071,
-0.028660696,
0.0648598075,
-0.0032003131,
0.0280256364,
0.0132049983,
-0.0116008585,
-0.0293926671,
-0.0209436696,
-0.0501879975,
-0.0367689691,
0.0345753208,
-0.0600636788,
0.0182744022,
0.0121308742,
0.0333018415,
-0.0271595605,
-0.0237937011,
-0.0223468933,
0.047129225,
-0.0150213046,
-0.0154723646,
-0.0413263924,
0.0453795157,
-0.0662543997,
0.0022704657,
-0.0173818432,
0.0163319483,
0.0189348813,
0.0170534253,
0.0203999262,
0.0222306829,
-0.0510401092,
0.0073062372,
-0.003073724,
0.0434274599,
-0.0165095329,
-0.0291360784,
0.0008984054,
-0.0425121672,
-0.0421919189,
0.0432739891,
0.0041086366,
-0.0454262495,
-0.0316828415,
0.0227520317,
-0.0209873077,
-0.0508116782,
-0.050723061,
-0.0232606251,
-0.0052991146,
0.0017995589,
0.0541041568,
-0.0240185317,
0.0186924562,
0.0148248682,
0.010462624,
-0.0509055853,
-0.001709312,
0.0452259481,
0.013754311,
0.0522669517,
-0.0018218417,
-0.0625538826,
-0.0226131007,
-0.0333752371,
0.0227581989,
0.0671447068,
0.032189846,
-0.0119443676,
-0.0156118376,
0.0220707282,
-0.0031410507,
0.0070657432,
-0.0305225346,
-0.0318845212,
-0.0514775664,
-0.0202340204,
0.0057538678,
0.0188124757,
0.0880940259,
0.0260949451,
-0.0358139165,
-0.0109444717,
0.0117718726,
0.0021412307,
-0.0041349488,
0.0247100256,
0.0627364367,
0.0260851663,
-0.0200962089,
0.0464596897,
-0.0451776609,
0.0342896283,
0.0278901849,
0.0039544478,
-0.0404617302,
-0.000537778,
0.0033406634,
-0.0397222266,
0.0196377225,
-0.0328484774,
-0.0039259652,
-0.0585536808,
0.0188966133,
0.024853101,
-0.0391863436,
0.0562655777,
0.0000529687,
-0.0452995338,
0.0000032925,
-0.0012247697,
-0.0483586304,
0.0510128886,
0.0394741073,
-0.011161617,
-0.0202970114,
-0.0035528967,
-0.0256291516,
0.0926672295,
-0.0174435228,
0.0160045438,
0.039843712,
-0.0381112434,
-0.0011369055,
-0.0130911376,
0.0087688779,
0.0019699088,
-0.0642118007,
-0.0205780063,
-0.0122629227,
0.0526016392,
0.0342508666,
0.0321680196,
-0.0338354819,
0.0188581981,
0.0136860302,
-0.0100750634,
0.0305665042,
0.0097256927,
-0.0076088915,
0.0239939522,
0.0167191587,
-0.0798725188,
-0.0394391678,
0.0430188067,
-0.1025785506,
-0.0810679197,
0.0071096034,
0.0005042147,
-0.0325580724,
0.0151332868,
-0.0347837806,
-0.0260930751,
0.0241347738,
-0.0447709039,
0.0339360349,
0.0038408095,
0.0288588293,
0.0533812866,
0.0284124725,
-0.0131374821,
0.0770163685,
-0.0459515452,
0.0204631109,
-0.0367518216,
-0.0087982621,
-0.0132243279,
-0.0190417562,
-0.0318334065,
0.0497958995,
0.0146347508,
-0.0632922649,
-0.0176505521,
-0.00934985,
-0.0262621101,
-0.0065959995,
-0.0179965757,
-0.0148925297,
-0.0359935537,
0.0614715144,
0.0378083549,
0.0217518881,
0.0245949719,
-0.0327051952,
0.0092818625,
-0.0041048252,
-0.0106301308,
-0.0006117651,
0.0369092263,
0.0127862878,
-0.0237393677,
-0.0205216762,
-0.0473142974,
-0.0322864391,
0.020631155,
0.0040904721,
-0.054260429,
-0.0813007727,
-0.0197790544,
0.0084145777,
0.0444367304,
0.0114288842,
-0.0526783913,
0.0274257753,
-0.0037569252,
0.0245221611,
0.0436927266,
0.003240176,
-0.0039492762,
-0.0026750339,
-0.0524474569,
-0.015188274,
0.0470855571,
0.0382890292,
0.0296074469,
-0.034707237,
0.0021687283,
0.0058527603,
0.0835178718,
-0.0094476491,
0.0153982146,
-0.0355307199,
-0.0219553392,
-0.0328053907,
-0.0318028592,
0.0198478941,
-0.0472627617,
-0.0340066254,
-0.0169475116,
-0.0199938379,
0.0110199042,
0.0619743802,
0.0050522271,
-0.0530870333,
-0.058974836,
0.0364980102,
-0.0248024352,
0.0558945015,
0.0759019703,
-0.0158467945,
0.016490275,
-0.0678058937,
0.0157643519,
0.0163512342,
-0.0194203705,
0.0133070294,
0.0397787057,
-0.0706572905,
0.032732565,
-0.0156382173,
-0.0747286081,
-0.0369381122,
-0.0367252901,
-0.0160816554,
0.0197779518,
-0.0006194781,
0.0136106638,
-0.0001746639,
-0.0118115535,
-0.0010514366,
0.0712521225,
-0.0057354891,
-0.0139161348,
-0.045676142,
0.0157987904,
0.0116295498,
0.0149292303,
0.011743078,
0.035093382,
0.0124003375,
0.0541808084,
0.0267269369,
0.0141601143,
-0.044159025,
0.0326353684,
-0.0012272341,
-0.0290288441,
-0.0504186153,
-0.0248546191,
0.0073947064,
-0.0710259005,
-0.0369261727,
0.0902791098,
0.0385134779,
-0.0727400854,
0.0240392555,
-0.0243087225,
-0.0198968202,
0.0220694616,
0.0147294849,
-0.0646669045,
-0.0481029674,
0.0105248122,
0.0402295701,
-0.0083625596,
-0.0363490209,
0.0083297919,
-0.0835412592,
0.0067436551,
-0.0020003021,
0.0358681306,
0.0257039592,
-0.0215802416,
-0.0235574841,
-0.0271066874,
0.0212992411,
0.0416566506,
-0.003555432,
0.0051123719,
0.0146319913,
-0.0513688363,
-0.0293071307,
-0.0269432683,
-0.0104776425,
-0.0137198502,
0.0636833608,
-0.0182921626,
-0.0333055742,
0.0003515161,
0.0868040994,
-0.0509411506,
0.0379677229,
-0.0032671331,
0.0460908301,
-0.0213254318,
-0.034760844,
-0.0344034396,
-0.0031286208,
-0.0542084873,
-0.0163736306,
-0.0123299733,
0.0502127558,
-0.022156259,
0.0351164937,
0.0130135845,
-0.023475647,
-0.0065651792,
0.0317496508,
0.0175790973,
-0.0608376004,
-0.0350028053,
-0.0407324843,
0.0269985273,
-0.0555528365,
0.0193330552,
0.0176795889,
0.0125511931,
-0.0586917363,
-0.0752068534,
-0.0856622308,
-0.013291046,
-0.0104799578,
-0.0444982611,
-0.0398005508,
0.0849227011,
-0.0449383259,
-0.0175760407,
0.0070761493,
0.0183079094,
-0.0012674712,
-0.0620420761,
-0.0003243382,
0.0671792626,
0.0350363255,
-0.0138496105,
0.0054934788,
-0.0282660481,
-0.0189143848,
0.0579433739,
0.0447913408,
0.0083895633,
0.0396080874,
-0.0336397588,
-0.0272810571,
-0.0383846052,
0.0584119186,
-0.018192051,
0.0293181129,
0.0083905738,
-0.0091488129,
0.0133094182,
0.0274218619,
0.0206507295,
0.0083580166,
-0.0138619356,
0.0441445149,
-0.0266635846,
0.0302017611,
0.064676404,
0.0109219728,
0.0669359639,
0.0277344659,
0.0597124882,
-0.0142883612,
0.040789336,
-0.0510973632,
0.0031527577,
-0.0502970144,
0.016172694,
0.0094087692,
0.0096278815,
-0.0130925141,
0.0115665635,
-0.0055214972,
-0.0068501011,
-0.0109631009,
0.0219962895,
0.011332198,
0.0136638694,
-0.0268856566,
-0.0040807705,
-0.0231578592,
-0.0190922581,
0.0340873003,
0.0409353822,
-0.0246273484,
0.0370321609,
0.039092388,
-0.0048563089,
-0.0374427326,
0.0192339383,
-0.0164626725,
0.0251798779,
0.002119045,
-0.0305620022,
0.0657763779,
0.0150606297,
0.0942413509,
-0.0021105357,
0.0269527193,
0.0291640703,
0.0010045621,
-0.0016433221,
-0.0441482849,
0.0065889549,
0.0108022308,
0.0037319269,
-0.0124436067,
0.0605680458,
-0.0627051145,
0.0469663739,
-0.0203252826,
0.0136925504,
-0.0317341387,
-0.0387101062,
-0.0367760248,
0.0180842429,
0.0028049909,
0.0275714155,
-0.0020398288,
-0.0198865663,
0.0204108469,
0.0175002366,
0.0105659263,
-0.0352201909,
0.0592055768,
0.0215133447,
0.0185970329,
-0.0986212641,
0.0020817679,
0.053216476,
0.0161436535,
-0.0353479311,
-0.0341214165,
-5.731085973e-33,
-0.0435078256,
0.0481533334,
0.0087513393,
-0.001610834,
-0.0564000458,
-0.0187513251,
-0.0388878472,
0.0243927427,
0.0166244712,
0.0137856593,
-0.016522795,
0.0303065404,
0.0168298986,
0.0582332015,
0.0883372575,
-0.0474648513,
0.0378243923,
-0.0339204669,
-0.0010782446,
-0.0226893555,
0.0837434009,
0.0435983203,
0.0954557359,
-0.0293640103,
-0.0017925438,
0.0049053505,
0.0056919712,
0.0312089771,
-0.0234082025,
0.0272008386,
0.0056227189,
0.0009140343,
0.064417474,
-0.0307209119,
-0.0239938907,
-0.0228975844,
-0.0918649435,
-0.0102022598,
-0.0207607467,
0.0723344013,
-0.0642012432,
-0.0345438495,
0.1008971706,
0.0116726244,
-0.0023035994,
0.041592475,
0.0025574227,
-0.0402704403,
0.028265344,
0.0311175007,
-0.0427192859,
0.0045858026,
0.0011297126,
0.0231526978,
0.0102337943,
0.0617997013,
-0.0292625818,
-0.0314072818,
-0.0669657364,
-0.0424776301,
-0.0263636243,
0.053206373,
0.0188383237,
-0.0146461781,
0.0196074843,
0.027477676,
0.0444275662,
-0.0623570234,
-0.0069496981,
0.0482660346,
-0.0066619678,
-0.0085619306,
0.0174808037,
-0.0520993732,
0.070315659,
0.0400860943,
-0.0235896949,
-0.0208799876,
0.0975180268,
0.0786797926,
-0.0038439406,
0.0384667329,
-0.0158087071,
-0.0232881624,
0.0156922359,
-0.0445152968,
0.0051468699,
-0.0317204967,
0.0024740279,
-0.0064543132,
0.0253255852,
0.0374962911,
0.03251357,
0.0118804872,
-0.015351804,
-0.0182019435,
0.0038872394,
0.0456255376,
0.0153479204,
0.0009456848,
-0.0439132415,
0.0018238761,
-0.0297871958,
0.0106935157,
0.0367386751,
0.0000778244,
0.0358482748,
0.0111520803,
-0.0240863878,
0.0023501781,
-0.0278132167,
0.014863587,
-0.0042683482,
0.0590667464,
0.0426537879,
0.0079324367,
-0.0365488827,
0.0621379912,
-0.0096987877,
0.0058606905,
-0.0207954794,
-0.0014624379,
0.0339658037,
0.0547698587,
-0.0048412746,
-0.0305554438,
-0.0150840338,
0.040104948,
-0.0029097467,
-0.0809231997,
-0.0054402431,
0.0525318459,
2.56e-7,
0.0579830669,
0.0089507969,
0.0788086876,
-0.0282120798,
0.0642080754,
0.0054642269,
-0.0183357447,
0.0223109201,
-0.0085251899,
-0.0001990531,
-0.0395817831,
-0.0067401649,
0.0000450259,
0.0123701002,
-0.0679587051,
-0.0350030288,
-0.0395582058,
-0.0183349531,
-0.0358041376,
0.0065224161,
0.0840013996,
0.0482160449,
-0.0085641099,
0.0052736164,
0.0032943559,
0.0046565696,
0.0296807978,
0.045724079,
0.0044067292,
-0.010597785,
-0.0143619971,
-0.0053386926,
-0.0070506437,
0.0271212272,
0.0013745665,
0.0096134041,
-0.0194589328,
0.0216654353,
0.00126878,
-0.0017293087,
0.0254950952,
0.0551220104,
-0.0117496112,
0.0337861851,
0.071872972,
-0.0842339173,
-0.0472550392,
0.0345236026,
-0.0771156177,
0.0287478212,
-0.0274260342,
0.0266408231,
-0.0450006798,
0.0039980928,
0.0248534512,
0.0141575225,
-0.0541891493,
-0.0337551981,
-0.0122599863,
0.0201694649,
-0.0478107184,
0.0177402906,
-0.0530474931,
0.0342485607,
0.0377535634,
0.002055797,
-0.0578698479,
1.962170757e-34,
0.0138199832,
0.006619262,
0.0610493831,
-0.0006244823,
-0.0020150372,
0.0016023886,
-0.0425576605,
0.0469992869,
-0.0384044386,
-0.0759761408,
-0.018943239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16248v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16248v2 | Spider4SPARQL: A Complex Benchmark for Evaluating Knowledge Graph Question Answering Systems | 2023-09-28T08:41:08 | 2023-12-08T08:52:25 | Catherine Kosten, Philippe Cudré-Mauroux, Kurt Stockinger | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the recent spike in the number and availability of Large Language Models
(LLMs), it has become increasingly important to provide large and realistic
benchmarks for evaluating Knowledge Graph Question Answering (KGQA) systems. So
far the majority of benchmarks rely on pattern-based SPARQL query generation
approaches. The subsequent natural language (NL) question generation is
conducted through crowdsourcing or other automated methods, such as rule-based
paraphrasing or NL question templates. Although some of these datasets are of
considerable size, their pitfall lies in their pattern-based generation
approaches, which do not always generalize well to the vague and linguistically
diverse questions asked by humans in real-world contexts. In this paper, we
introduce Spider4SPARQL - a new SPARQL benchmark dataset featuring 9,693
previously existing manually generated NL questions and 4,721 unique, novel,
and complex SPARQL queries of varying complexity. In addition to the NL/SPARQL
pairs, we also provide their corresponding 166 knowledge graphs and ontologies,
which cover 138 different domains. Our complex benchmark enables novel ways of
evaluating the strengths and weaknesses of modern KGQA systems. We evaluate the
system with state-of-the-art KGQA systems as well as LLMs, which achieve only
up to 45\% execution accuracy, demonstrating that Spider4SPARQL is a
challenging benchmark for future research. | [
0.0765229389,
0.0300492849,
0.0005953785,
0.0695635006,
-0.0625329241,
-0.0008910453,
-0.0259533264,
-0.0055000177,
0.0126153091,
-0.0398197547,
-0.0112072853,
0.0041047614,
-0.0403294154,
0.0332797654,
0.0128972037,
0.0108764423,
0.0056136069,
-0.0101311905,
-0.0222887769,
-0.00270155,
0.0092295501,
0.0522120856,
-0.0058061839,
0.0071993568,
-0.0007895435,
0.0169106256,
-0.0146731893,
0.0321579427,
-0.0111133009,
-0.0287020672,
0.0449005961,
0.0383456759,
0.0163056403,
0.0158932898,
0.0000018811,
-0.054903131,
-0.0004286954,
0.0276214629,
-0.028543137,
-0.001770193,
0.0164845344,
0.0125349788,
0.0748493597,
0.046192728,
-0.0620230734,
-0.049090948,
-0.001294533,
0.0205047671,
0.0687926039,
0.048459895,
0.0009164576,
-0.0346645489,
-0.0011211172,
0.0077079339,
0.0060726474,
-0.0773692578,
0.0196680557,
0.0181204379,
0.057905294,
-0.0108499071,
-0.0201175194,
0.0131586781,
0.0148299495,
0.0136376452,
0.0092563489,
-0.0197202414,
-0.0572953634,
0.0139183765,
0.0019580771,
0.1148660928,
0.035927996,
-0.0174124632,
0.0393524766,
0.0252265073,
-0.0185803287,
0.0614450574,
-0.0162315872,
-0.0018787975,
-0.0240681935,
-0.0217848402,
-0.0259878673,
0.0066300477,
0.0192847569,
0.0160024595,
-0.0173875391,
0.1119775549,
0.0312759653,
-0.0160226244,
0.0063398783,
-0.0074550561,
-0.0202693921,
-0.0430852324,
0.0189217888,
0.0395751856,
-0.0648714304,
0.0376229137,
-0.0456055403,
0.0033161079,
0.0393897109,
0.0032173586,
0.0037766439,
0.0181565192,
0.029448688,
0.0687158406,
-0.0041028052,
0.0386227369,
0.0074990913,
0.0226970222,
-0.0752547234,
-0.0604810342,
-0.0547448285,
0.0006284435,
-0.0737355426,
0.0380419493,
-0.0317942463,
-0.0437348932,
-0.0221439973,
0.0530892834,
0.0177288968,
0.013673543,
0.0177521482,
0.0611568131,
0.0277256779,
-0.0073890686,
-0.0611184761,
0.0083375601,
-0.0503490977,
-0.0084416466,
0.0205935687,
-0.0459706262,
-0.0018280623,
-0.0012120922,
0.0521945991,
-0.0376422182,
0.0117281144,
0.0718185753,
0.0279349666,
-0.0283594914,
-0.0297053028,
-0.0794789419,
0.017267175,
-0.0226522982,
0.0001525603,
-0.0784956217,
0.04507358,
0.0372736305,
-0.0309694726,
-0.0213618968,
0.0373802148,
0.0498925447,
-0.0456404239,
0.0507061668,
-0.0347884372,
0.0078577828,
0.0081695048,
-0.0048295944,
-0.0471543409,
0.0548667349,
0.0106805936,
0.008494244,
0.0680045709,
0.0168067701,
-0.0291258991,
0.0068589868,
0.03610719,
0.0265775379,
0.0040045348,
0.0827084631,
-0.0321235731,
0.0420415588,
0.0025577936,
0.0728944689,
-0.0114330351,
-0.0424676873,
0.0369104892,
0.0466708019,
-0.0349752866,
-0.0110294027,
0.0313104652,
0.0340241455,
0.0100966934,
-0.0124236746,
-0.0220412947,
0.0049946913,
-0.0240447689,
0.0283090007,
0.018064579,
-0.0028184783,
-0.0159783829,
-0.0203989521,
-0.0328678191,
0.0317036025,
-0.0038219772,
0.052439671,
0.0273894705,
0.0191216692,
-0.0473576337,
0.0732848346,
0.0126095992,
-0.0168687738,
0.0159649663,
-0.0147311566,
0.0368466154,
0.0601496436,
0.0756892413,
-0.0213876646,
-0.0617558323,
0.0175300408,
-0.0076966817,
0.0251671616,
0.0286988243,
-0.0082017211,
0.0036779684,
-0.0491625033,
-0.0263276994,
-0.0190010481,
-0.0042710449,
-0.0269681197,
0.0705200061,
0.0089341886,
0.0314065479,
-0.0844110325,
-0.0266770106,
0.0135254292,
-0.0223245509,
0.00607245,
0.0086907856,
-0.014956872,
0.0030484968,
0.0138908019,
-0.0007185685,
0.0403755084,
0.0391169935,
-0.018842537,
-0.0729202256,
-0.0163140018,
-0.0269373097,
-0.0757835656,
0.0308968406,
-0.052503448,
-0.0076799649,
0.0429908372,
-0.0562518872,
-0.0403246731,
-0.0050775497,
-0.0580767691,
0.0206854027,
-0.0389036722,
-0.0113978665,
0.0370966047,
-0.0223032981,
-0.0319092311,
0.0295777526,
-0.002805176,
0.026931243,
-0.0164439287,
0.0110232467,
0.0319343098,
-0.0496593304,
-0.0316452421,
-0.0471803769,
-0.003887316,
0.0176337492,
0.0081115449,
0.0113236876,
-0.1061842069,
0.0070023965,
-0.0778080523,
0.0410171561,
-0.0249447003,
0.02002641,
0.0228421241,
0.0136767952,
0.0082802717,
-0.0006844393,
-0.0816947743,
0.0133087505,
0.0299297329,
0.0095237633,
0.0470261127,
0.0324783251,
-0.0024164347,
-0.0296995062,
-0.0068635694,
0.0059009511,
0.0547789261,
-0.0003857701,
0.0458617099,
-0.0052665095,
0.0334560722,
-0.0577860549,
0.0108488696,
0.0081649534,
0.0104619721,
-0.0046308292,
-0.0380338691,
0.0166544076,
0.0196294915,
0.0116312206,
-0.0256442875,
0.0046035419,
-0.003131615,
-0.0297888964,
0.0008419163,
-0.0229076575,
0.0221039634,
-0.0088902386,
-0.0425976552,
0.0442592427,
0.0036409541,
0.0154329203,
-0.0154875759,
-0.0446769185,
0.0497949608,
-0.0037081183,
0.0150795029,
-0.0686763376,
0.0106929131,
0.0188646354,
0.0233705882,
-0.0413589552,
-0.0035885088,
0.0676444396,
0.0060313079,
0.0183192901,
-0.0218431391,
0.0194547493,
-0.0660662651,
0.0790526792,
0.0277016591,
0.0511288568,
-0.0379290208,
-0.0137705188,
-0.0299302731,
-0.0095395809,
0.040300373,
-0.0507532284,
0.0144538516,
-0.0381128229,
0.024254268,
0.0211999249,
-0.0200610999,
-0.0235639513,
-0.0185967106,
-0.050894957,
0.0332811326,
0.0465361625,
-0.017279556,
0.0438213721,
-0.0016756961,
-0.0240730196,
-0.0083069103,
-0.0044343178,
-0.0232075732,
-0.0140121104,
0.0770038515,
0.0953994468,
0.0052127116,
0.0133345686,
0.0077656466,
-0.0158803668,
0.0473976061,
0.0484165922,
-0.0169253144,
-0.0064722938,
-0.0072440905,
0.0107066827,
-0.045121409,
0.0088586016,
-0.0139359981,
0.0216920357,
-0.0276942272,
-0.0138936695,
0.0978107527,
0.0382130481,
0.0328583047,
-0.0015483686,
-0.0237060897,
0.0461492315,
0.0268570986,
0.0251714755,
-0.1097737253,
-0.0575789176,
-0.0237319153,
0.0469576344,
0.0038304022,
-0.0697636306,
0.0000362963,
-0.1237657741,
0.0202718675,
-0.0402275324,
-0.0557388477,
-0.0204358492,
-0.0061387224,
-0.0216652937,
-0.015090148,
-0.0314629227,
0.0287949089,
-0.0244614668,
0.0320567451,
0.0134428255,
-0.0163215622,
-0.0171642955,
0.0560497157,
-0.0736406967,
0.0187277794,
0.008877418,
0.0238616318,
0.0164802521,
-0.03558743,
-0.0179757085,
-0.0045453808,
-0.0251570586,
-0.0196184888,
0.051405441,
0.0218706429,
-0.0312210992,
-0.0477825627,
0.0114258844,
-0.068806529,
0.0334639959,
0.0294632297,
0.0559482016,
-0.003446378,
-0.0145655815,
-0.0012820946,
0.0076322532,
-0.029855635,
0.0898910239,
0.0160934981,
0.0237353835,
-0.0742303953,
-0.0017129343,
-0.0059515717,
-0.0919317901,
-0.034071926,
0.0242225602,
-0.0101801194,
0.0325177424,
-0.0796709061,
-0.0328821465,
0.0535627156,
0.0147641227,
-0.020068571,
0.0011244554,
0.017134985,
0.0105775464,
-0.0705452785,
0.0304635782,
-0.0406265371,
0.0193253215,
-0.0476927944,
-0.0053462167,
0.0161509756,
-0.0242499225,
-0.0388881639,
0.0345558673,
-0.0855578929,
-0.0404070579,
-0.010271972,
0.012120503,
0.010781968,
0.0074303932,
-0.0225533806,
-0.0077081397,
0.0531237908,
0.0153582348,
-0.0405124128,
-0.0123776225,
-0.0049766605,
0.0071123224,
-0.0266560502,
0.0561135747,
-0.0858314037,
-0.0529417172,
-0.0186666604,
0.0798354596,
-0.016819153,
-0.0484895781,
0.0553868152,
0.070355244,
-0.0329576433,
0.0216175355,
0.0111259595,
-0.0027570189,
0.0120858336,
-0.0286537781,
-0.0245594718,
-0.0533433519,
-0.0048406827,
0.0085650394,
-0.0205523819,
0.0042902157,
0.0067911586,
-0.0062384736,
0.0433791541,
0.0009985922,
-0.0544695705,
0.0242407396,
-0.0085155265,
0.0526645258,
-0.032849852,
-0.0351971835,
0.0106586916,
-0.0204884093,
0.0568842441,
-0.0196866021,
0.0402372517,
0.0283135734,
-0.0252067838,
-0.0168904122,
0.0152813774,
-0.0472480878,
-0.0971432105,
0.0069003077,
-0.0126856277,
0.0485289358,
-0.0071002194,
0.0238552205,
-0.0260357391,
-0.0315054804,
-0.0125117302,
0.0068598827,
-0.0113866972,
0.0035782,
0.044660572,
0.0330993608,
0.0070418273,
0.0038544331,
0.0685262606,
0.0595373698,
0.0479920283,
0.019674588,
-0.0728337318,
-0.0395229533,
-0.0352150723,
0.0446927547,
0.0124089336,
-0.0183278583,
-0.0021161041,
-0.055232048,
-0.0662331209,
-0.0028777695,
0.0118615879,
-0.0034079798,
-0.011764898,
0.0883854181,
0.0469652638,
0.036810521,
-0.0279155895,
-0.0425093845,
0.0438149832,
-0.0552363545,
-0.0130427601,
-0.0032867491,
-6.453957694e-33,
0.0139919929,
-0.0420645885,
0.0371938869,
-0.0223197546,
-0.0244525205,
-0.0244860724,
-0.032639645,
-0.020885475,
-0.0129026677,
0.0152193531,
0.0081922049,
-0.0070301783,
-0.0122733805,
0.0364299417,
-0.0064592557,
-0.0520622544,
-0.0034966848,
-0.0138142174,
0.0183522124,
0.0147098545,
0.0521452241,
0.0373106152,
-0.0080674775,
0.0150949471,
-0.0137457205,
-0.0348591134,
0.0108936336,
0.0377356,
-0.0181581322,
0.0399040133,
0.0001898855,
0.0225806832,
0.0248977449,
0.0052077584,
0.0290344581,
-0.0476031452,
-0.0804760009,
-0.0203149151,
0.012177499,
0.0023872,
-0.0837513581,
0.0075650476,
0.0501958132,
-0.0063264072,
0.0553966537,
-0.0061940644,
0.0159169585,
0.0161641724,
-0.0267026257,
-0.0709788129,
-0.0101704672,
0.0194592886,
-0.0011611633,
-0.047228016,
-0.0707534403,
0.0302142315,
-0.0015620252,
0.0253719296,
-0.0548801608,
0.0070149349,
-0.0249130707,
0.0216721613,
0.0260130353,
0.0169901438,
-0.0009702766,
0.0064575952,
-0.0101485848,
-0.0068707308,
0.012703741,
0.0293556843,
-0.0338302664,
0.0710511282,
0.0328685753,
0.0331274569,
0.0243787225,
0.0431914441,
-0.0694456175,
0.0391716957,
-0.0319145806,
0.0208000001,
-0.0080851642,
-0.0298072007,
-0.037901178,
-0.0249210782,
-0.0621061251,
0.0614951104,
-0.0455183834,
0.0005341448,
0.0598491803,
-0.0076245414,
-0.0180234462,
-0.0324610174,
-0.0064801946,
-0.038449537,
0.0183389727,
0.0286244787,
-0.0238696709,
-0.0151314279,
-0.0123276794,
0.0608670041,
-0.0380232371,
0.024318479,
-0.0043889736,
-0.0139442077,
-0.0075159189,
0.0259568803,
-0.0073429653,
0.0134095997,
-0.0439421944,
0.0034977372,
-0.043247886,
0.0154870609,
-0.062136434,
-0.0345537886,
0.0168095417,
0.047544416,
-0.0166949276,
0.0131597286,
0.0285575949,
0.0181068145,
-0.0334206484,
0.0207135044,
0.023345314,
0.0048088897,
0.0028913636,
0.0317212194,
-0.0364948064,
0.0206409656,
-0.0254995003,
-0.0215925276,
0.0014141763,
0.00563198,
2.692e-7,
0.0626878515,
0.0253669526,
0.0062577459,
0.0976673961,
-0.0260551479,
0.0227668174,
0.012786652,
0.0431801267,
-0.0069855833,
-0.0138645014,
-0.0046102232,
0.0360124297,
-0.0109570101,
0.0412998945,
-0.095010072,
0.0054142927,
-0.0509984121,
-0.0466751382,
-0.021332344,
-0.0078797722,
0.0722377598,
0.0427072644,
0.0055518039,
-0.0242704302,
-0.0151755959,
-0.0705225095,
0.0628256723,
0.0175738297,
-0.0429729931,
0.0245099552,
0.0494386666,
-0.004180402,
-0.0006640804,
0.0296207312,
-0.0086985249,
0.0113614518,
0.0149755999,
0.0041023358,
-0.0020358418,
-0.0233967882,
-0.0224931967,
-0.0633840486,
0.0264840629,
-0.0615481436,
0.0814647749,
-0.0296669081,
0.017356785,
0.037565589,
-0.0438482389,
-0.01961747,
-0.0003223185,
-0.0268211607,
-0.0171603356,
-0.01230436,
0.0224381573,
-0.011975117,
0.0116679789,
-0.0308184531,
0.0160508193,
0.0078829555,
-0.0128485393,
-0.0419290513,
-0.0259593278,
0.0025334009,
-0.0286666863,
-0.0176192895,
0.009706812,
2.373290952e-34,
0.0422791466,
0.036775928,
-0.0024903053,
-0.0073734932,
0.0539798178,
-0.0127435569,
-0.0405626148,
-0.0197594203,
0.0151724648,
-0.0958878323,
0.0114977304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16235v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16235v1 | Language models in molecular discovery | 2023-09-28T08:19:54 | 2023-09-28T08:19:54 | Nikita Janakarajan, Tim Erdmann, Sarath Swaminathan, Teodoro Laino, Jannis Born | physics.chem-ph | physics.chem-ph, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.BM | The success of language models, especially transformer-based architectures,
has trickled into other domains giving rise to "scientific language models"
that operate on small molecules, proteins or polymers. In chemistry, language
models contribute to accelerating the molecule discovery cycle as evidenced by
promising recent findings in early-stage drug discovery. Here, we review the
role of language models in molecular discovery, underlining their strength in
de novo drug design, property prediction and reaction chemistry. We highlight
valuable open-source software assets thus lowering the entry barrier to the
field of scientific language modeling. Last, we sketch a vision for future
molecular design that combines a chatbot interface with access to computational
chemistry tools. Our contribution serves as a valuable resource for
researchers, chemists, and AI enthusiasts interested in understanding how
language models can and will be used to accelerate chemical discovery. | [
0.0353109017,
0.0767228827,
0.0035857407,
0.0093064429,
-0.0228968207,
-0.0142741501,
0.0536559783,
0.0280687008,
0.0683889389,
-0.0105635747,
-0.004846741,
0.0056166551,
-0.020113958,
0.0989967734,
0.0172086172,
-0.002678626,
0.002882957,
-0.0452133045,
-0.0046159178,
-0.0229178928,
0.0256272163,
0.0174179655,
-0.0050794012,
0.0265551098,
0.0222832114,
-0.0253047273,
-0.0140277501,
-0.0202031266,
0.0033022147,
-0.0059156055,
-0.0256133992,
0.0814902335,
-0.0189641807,
0.0628556237,
0.0000018582,
-0.0623656139,
-0.0091993883,
0.0364819542,
-0.0229040459,
-0.039945446,
0.0744004101,
-0.0210330114,
-0.0220262725,
-0.0066319737,
-0.0297400225,
0.0128002567,
0.0978395939,
-0.0122324871,
0.0118856672,
0.0232088789,
0.0114585124,
-0.0184444524,
0.0492751561,
0.0123293065,
0.0618025549,
0.0008140703,
0.048992604,
0.0354721434,
0.0717585981,
0.0017083683,
-0.0187647901,
0.0216909144,
-0.041936148,
-0.0715657845,
0.0302994959,
0.0020030211,
-0.0320425965,
-0.0747285262,
-0.0327254422,
0.061581403,
0.0007740485,
-0.0707845166,
-0.0586722158,
0.0306437407,
-0.0287058502,
0.0373672545,
-0.0423186421,
0.005920934,
0.0373876058,
-0.0002374407,
0.0321261585,
-0.0322389007,
0.0120091559,
-0.006926374,
0.0318081863,
0.0510754474,
0.0159618258,
0.006867093,
-0.0380699039,
-0.0113682449,
-0.0229696985,
-0.0384988151,
0.0225643329,
-0.0049118334,
0.0154022714,
0.0114787407,
0.0254859924,
-0.0274461322,
0.0409894809,
-0.0420490205,
0.0111412155,
0.0325693525,
0.0342681184,
0.0292636268,
-0.0033721316,
0.0123299258,
-0.0064705745,
0.0110992389,
-0.0371936485,
-0.0090151224,
-0.0565968305,
0.0051096217,
-0.0417022146,
0.0152588729,
-0.0078584449,
-0.0246428475,
-0.044545047,
0.0650856048,
0.0198997557,
-0.0190080516,
0.0277272034,
0.0189043395,
-0.0284031723,
0.0195211116,
-0.0085910801,
0.0130100008,
0.0150922975,
-0.0228055734,
-0.0021156671,
-0.084570013,
-0.0475091934,
0.002003764,
-0.0291068088,
-0.0137020359,
-0.0061107907,
0.126996085,
-0.0013276184,
-0.0163747631,
0.0814943612,
-0.0245514493,
0.0144694382,
-0.0201829337,
0.0155756893,
-0.0485972911,
0.0573309958,
0.042953182,
0.0087133422,
-0.0706318766,
0.019788105,
-0.0142507032,
-0.0376913399,
0.0956878215,
-0.037692029,
-0.0434381887,
0.0187336039,
0.007270393,
0.000253212,
-0.0097146071,
-0.0079928767,
-0.0265137348,
0.013941233,
0.0184618756,
0.0416035615,
0.0045802165,
-0.0253018551,
-0.0303938612,
0.024069909,
-0.0183908362,
0.0269572716,
0.0560986735,
-0.0591976866,
-0.0051720063,
0.0046610045,
-0.0156671423,
0.0316690579,
0.0569798574,
0.0167840403,
0.0618424714,
-0.0084470101,
0.0143860718,
0.0064847809,
-0.0560097136,
-0.0248243269,
0.056348633,
-0.0546348877,
-0.005224321,
0.0350598171,
0.0440690964,
0.0264240149,
0.0010776069,
-0.0156027824,
-0.0184582397,
0.0325682312,
-0.0448161475,
0.0423271768,
-0.0053976583,
-0.0585318655,
0.023656508,
0.0413757227,
-0.04696621,
-0.0379911363,
-0.0389287062,
0.0133770462,
0.0852476135,
0.0867764056,
-0.0548950769,
-0.0145137729,
0.0194419064,
-0.0469779149,
0.0617083125,
0.021046672,
0.0030266752,
-0.0168270878,
0.0091078738,
-0.0007945193,
-0.0016379285,
0.0324304774,
-0.0278036967,
-0.0115120197,
-0.000749416,
-0.0297662113,
-0.0148452753,
-0.0285782814,
0.0103403535,
-0.0087318718,
-0.0232176464,
0.0053616725,
-0.0182659738,
0.0107689537,
0.0182997137,
0.017024789,
0.049623888,
0.0616991594,
-0.0441278554,
-0.0137764709,
-0.0125577934,
0.0635375902,
-0.0250419211,
0.0385422111,
-0.0355190039,
0.0334349982,
-0.000316207,
-0.0285170805,
-0.012171546,
0.1068463549,
-0.0099769039,
0.0195970219,
-0.0115552191,
-0.0130342608,
-0.0225858465,
0.0788950846,
-0.0273737703,
0.007436275,
0.0364148952,
-0.0055065718,
0.0061794897,
-0.003737451,
0.0032614758,
-0.0322059728,
0.0034199811,
0.0179048032,
0.0509689935,
0.0325565897,
0.0321438983,
-0.0210093502,
0.0080790082,
-0.0158806033,
-0.0241640303,
-0.041624222,
0.0076134652,
-0.0004618799,
-0.0004967243,
0.0060641561,
-0.0034819259,
-0.0032758391,
-0.00087326,
-0.0189548284,
-0.0283870921,
-0.0201298334,
0.0255901553,
-0.0071025589,
-0.1152014285,
-0.0570882596,
-0.0485435128,
-0.0504212305,
0.0819818452,
0.0294850953,
-0.0499977954,
-0.0203297511,
-0.0037608636,
-0.0059562712,
0.0454888754,
0.0121168662,
-0.0194887295,
0.0236386694,
-0.0256721508,
0.0130296024,
0.0264674686,
-0.0184650328,
0.0329140052,
0.0914943144,
0.0176122803,
-0.0020544915,
-0.0053713396,
-0.0365580879,
-0.0052498402,
0.0690794736,
-0.0408171713,
-0.0056148889,
0.0734806582,
-0.0288088247,
0.0067004501,
-0.0333606713,
0.0377474092,
0.0332354978,
-0.0389701761,
0.0020520377,
-0.0074843168,
0.0160262492,
0.018202439,
0.0369054973,
-0.0602132566,
0.0887481421,
-0.0505896062,
0.0087677836,
-0.0613290071,
-0.0181594584,
0.0186604187,
0.0019526366,
0.001586628,
0.0219412241,
0.0424663685,
0.0426696092,
0.0179287288,
-0.0117877666,
0.021971412,
-0.0292223748,
0.0123117352,
-0.0380408801,
0.0060008587,
0.0161932725,
-0.0406128094,
-0.0054167989,
0.0356843248,
-0.0512124375,
0.0294250157,
0.0602785684,
-0.0621883571,
-0.0389048643,
0.0559682325,
0.0292916615,
-0.0064485278,
-0.0074808821,
0.0024651824,
-0.0235326104,
-0.0250963345,
-0.0089008305,
-0.0443161465,
0.0041777524,
-0.0125484811,
0.067041032,
0.0347043201,
-0.0175612066,
-0.0075928816,
-0.0122286063,
0.0000035408,
0.0316150859,
0.0181724783,
-0.0135989608,
0.0049447292,
-0.029570723,
-0.0085136779,
-0.0268401392,
0.075382039,
0.015673466,
-0.0356522314,
0.0243530143,
-0.0317535326,
-0.000869355,
-0.0120265055,
0.0732247531,
-0.1134445444,
-0.0272199176,
-0.0279298294,
0.0211724974,
-0.0160058532,
-0.0194604192,
-0.0229217932,
-0.0277759209,
0.0464285947,
0.0171835832,
-0.0661080107,
-0.032105837,
-0.0988388434,
-0.0264153183,
-0.033143349,
-0.0165593755,
0.0399535224,
0.012701367,
-0.0021772499,
-0.0258737188,
-0.0258012917,
-0.0527820587,
0.0042481553,
0.0227221735,
-0.00017351,
0.0683671087,
0.0481387787,
0.0299622901,
-0.0199722033,
-0.019237997,
0.0698155016,
0.0188125353,
-0.0333087184,
0.029806992,
0.0517102927,
-0.0353995822,
-0.059458252,
0.0086867167,
-0.0436723046,
-0.054069642,
-0.0797541216,
0.0940190256,
-0.0279354695,
-0.0079697901,
-0.0563214123,
0.0181170441,
0.0154585233,
0.0555907264,
-0.0042798622,
-0.0255943071,
-0.0846308991,
-0.0366346762,
0.0225893203,
-0.0274623744,
-0.0622387715,
-0.045223657,
-0.011271771,
-0.0477682538,
-0.0413304009,
0.011418256,
0.0370660387,
-0.0439058542,
-0.0057637128,
-0.0023822065,
0.0272457469,
-0.0192709453,
-0.0280805212,
-0.004800763,
0.0050493111,
0.0085032834,
-0.0469901264,
-0.0696694925,
0.0231022835,
-0.0330836661,
0.0021933843,
0.0707480609,
-0.0452312008,
-0.063778691,
-0.010420287,
0.0505028926,
0.0284345634,
-0.0142080588,
-0.0248081032,
-0.0545824356,
0.0038479452,
0.056025777,
0.0156732425,
-0.0215189531,
-0.0153941112,
-0.0046369489,
-0.0263358671,
-0.0068253321,
-0.0059463726,
0.0132999178,
-0.0337518975,
0.0025258046,
-0.0027609053,
-0.0440397672,
0.065032959,
0.0459270328,
0.0425339937,
0.0089998133,
0.0099935308,
-0.0047542783,
-0.0289394893,
-0.0145528615,
0.017012842,
-0.0420649573,
-0.0064164563,
0.02191725,
-0.0288051609,
0.0372405909,
0.0121712564,
-0.0447501838,
-0.0024814196,
0.0106753064,
0.0552343167,
-0.0026818358,
-0.0084160743,
0.0858854651,
0.0015942962,
0.0017214856,
0.0344357155,
-0.0534331799,
0.0426704548,
-0.025301354,
0.0064324415,
-0.0103214988,
0.0397587791,
0.001940408,
0.0255597308,
-0.0283065625,
-0.0782634094,
-0.0495912731,
0.0489810221,
0.0457632765,
0.0398654714,
0.0475105606,
-0.027144881,
-0.0077010025,
-0.034700498,
0.0165016837,
0.0212267581,
-0.0356043726,
0.0322319046,
0.0150205353,
-0.0181765612,
-0.0581932776,
0.0673184544,
0.0072512506,
0.0208377186,
-0.0186392851,
-0.0582651831,
-0.0143948356,
-0.0249427464,
-0.0300509743,
-0.005516435,
-0.027498506,
-0.015935516,
-0.0467555039,
-0.0381753743,
-0.0019880971,
0.0363432318,
-0.0254247189,
0.0179563444,
0.0349861458,
0.0590921491,
0.0309765432,
-0.0777313709,
-0.017398797,
0.0191974156,
-0.0151440725,
-0.0419784375,
-0.0116067408,
-5.593312893e-33,
0.0039733481,
-0.0070935525,
-0.0168430991,
0.0434941389,
0.035479553,
-0.0304198172,
-0.1057366878,
0.0058348021,
0.020361932,
0.0781892464,
0.0233148448,
-0.011686651,
0.0053875009,
-0.0436442383,
0.0038709687,
0.0450707823,
0.022020448,
0.0155141447,
-0.0007316845,
0.0246533919,
0.0599065199,
0.034345571,
0.0291051529,
-0.0302721672,
0.010120797,
0.0208797324,
0.0045014978,
-0.0143971993,
-0.055114761,
0.0487213992,
-0.0090118563,
0.0517608449,
-0.0515582822,
-0.0146647878,
-0.037149623,
-0.0004788538,
-0.0186465308,
0.0176692307,
0.0210784525,
0.0086987717,
0.0107467137,
-0.0062964619,
0.008122568,
-0.0070656501,
-0.0663452372,
0.0091248695,
0.0141830631,
-0.022977965,
-0.0042013037,
0.0111115156,
-0.0668871179,
-0.0013970123,
0.001623285,
-0.0012884793,
0.0253482051,
0.0045102634,
0.0076966803,
-0.0188569259,
0.0050607859,
0.0792795047,
0.0067473892,
0.0211197492,
0.0769117326,
0.0071403547,
0.0022124925,
0.0193261579,
0.0191101935,
0.0278447941,
0.0129975099,
0.0233468339,
0.031248698,
0.0515906811,
0.0696045458,
0.0097678406,
-0.0011381729,
0.0088206241,
-0.0753077567,
0.0014732623,
0.003675028,
-0.0004372902,
0.0041396348,
0.0638051331,
-0.0069028726,
-0.0412328318,
0.0048089004,
0.0277028456,
-0.0234894827,
-0.0365640037,
-0.0500134975,
-0.0418581665,
-0.0393140428,
-0.0246102158,
0.0135584194,
-0.0522579812,
-0.0354572833,
0.033954218,
-0.0048420415,
0.017745791,
-0.049950093,
-0.0188707896,
-0.0299029462,
-0.028453052,
0.0163701903,
-0.0266753174,
0.0116884653,
-0.0146938507,
-0.0367726199,
0.0253352262,
-0.0090922052,
0.011082124,
-0.069763869,
0.0215099696,
0.0515424162,
0.0183531512,
-0.0152719561,
0.0068783942,
0.003469452,
0.0174425319,
0.0192786232,
-0.0064554759,
0.0184986033,
0.0481940098,
0.0081702881,
0.0042783343,
-0.1044965833,
-0.0177819729,
-0.0731850192,
0.034112107,
0.0384453572,
-0.0744478256,
-0.0445800498,
-0.0243964083,
2.677e-7,
0.0714247748,
0.0740430579,
0.0348640494,
0.0177600142,
0.0163533185,
0.0253454838,
0.0201607477,
0.0461713448,
-0.0308618881,
-0.0200307518,
-0.0108499341,
0.0020612853,
0.0279302392,
-0.0152609497,
-0.0209432933,
0.0101125166,
-0.0558799878,
-0.0290016998,
-0.0729087964,
-0.0031336681,
-0.0080805058,
0.0723895654,
0.0298320446,
0.0031381953,
0.0066120722,
-0.0143063851,
-0.0077551287,
-0.0346997008,
0.0318820179,
0.0744306296,
-0.0356750898,
-0.0489682183,
-0.0020112162,
0.0544790253,
-0.041383937,
-0.0346190333,
0.0127007188,
0.0129110822,
-0.0427258722,
0.0073695597,
0.0584743917,
-0.0369384624,
-0.0136510395,
-0.0353332125,
-0.0206323024,
-0.0384685621,
-0.0312489178,
-0.0084407981,
-0.0086055249,
-0.0076621016,
0.0239913911,
-0.0178075377,
0.0083560813,
0.0273031071,
-0.0063829082,
0.0155374529,
0.0237790775,
-0.0047481125,
-0.0589194112,
-0.0210797433,
-0.0410874002,
0.0141376043,
-0.0404382795,
-0.0355582833,
0.0031083752,
0.0133452611,
0.0234700609,
2.535991768e-34,
0.0770395398,
0.0073211826,
0.0107999137,
0.0402824581,
0.0604020469,
-0.0083830068,
0.0479832701,
0.0156780556,
-0.0017278444,
-0.0804522261,
-0.0433441438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16234v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16234v1 | Analyzing Political Figures in Real-Time: Leveraging YouTube Metadata for Sentiment Analysis | 2023-09-28T08:15:55 | 2023-09-28T08:15:55 | Danendra Athallariq Harya Putra, Arief Purnama Muharram | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment analysis using big data from YouTube videos metadata can be
conducted to analyze public opinions on various political figures who represent
political parties. This is possible because YouTube has become one of the
platforms for people to express themselves, including their opinions on various
political figures. The resulting sentiment analysis can be useful for political
executives to gain an understanding of public sentiment and develop appropriate
and effective political strategies. This study aimed to build a sentiment
analysis system leveraging YouTube videos metadata. The sentiment analysis
system was built using Apache Kafka, Apache PySpark, and Hadoop for big data
handling; TensorFlow for deep learning handling; and FastAPI for deployment on
the server. The YouTube videos metadata used in this study is the video
description. The sentiment analysis model was built using LSTM algorithm and
produces two types of sentiments: positive and negative sentiments. The
sentiment analysis results are then visualized in the form a simple web-based
dashboard. | [
0.0265971292,
0.061558865,
-0.0199846793,
0.0178744569,
0.0101848627,
0.0180983562,
-0.0126256542,
0.0048408834,
-0.0069966023,
-0.0625957176,
0.0359853692,
-0.0273730978,
-0.0501191914,
0.0745085925,
-0.042749837,
-0.1012342796,
0.0444589518,
0.0589372329,
0.0457147844,
-0.0148915146,
0.0150069427,
0.0038801737,
-0.0011190278,
-0.0007529262,
-0.0451141708,
-0.0120781027,
-0.011525441,
-0.0166347902,
0.0441569313,
-0.0233465452,
-0.0218321364,
0.0042214356,
0.0147425896,
0.0473545603,
0.000002043,
0.0043385774,
0.0070792022,
-0.0288116504,
0.0346032567,
0.0048263613,
0.0813542232,
-0.0110343136,
-0.0152319223,
0.054287184,
-0.0577351041,
-0.0113925943,
0.0594172142,
0.0172917824,
0.091835916,
0.0346897505,
-0.0277941711,
-0.0704824477,
-0.0205336045,
0.0065002511,
0.0087213442,
0.0114299739,
0.0256007444,
-0.0255606342,
-0.0017121268,
-0.0026540181,
-0.0053740819,
0.0159879662,
0.0036782636,
-0.00514552,
0.0114433561,
-0.0262245964,
-0.0185557287,
-0.0241685268,
-0.0009302828,
0.0257686377,
0.0381744653,
0.0138386916,
0.0290463306,
0.0046186242,
-0.0289807003,
0.0082716197,
-0.0238475222,
0.0395042934,
0.0117086852,
0.0108654853,
0.0040166611,
0.0282743499,
-0.0132463612,
0.0127909295,
0.0185506381,
0.0337829962,
0.0095253363,
-0.020660188,
-0.0402808897,
-0.0217997022,
0.0307682715,
-0.0275362935,
0.0364721268,
-0.0107361944,
0.0103966361,
-0.0088126687,
-0.0163746439,
-0.0240377579,
0.0029381455,
-0.1199615076,
0.0106350314,
0.0212257206,
-0.0187847465,
0.0411533117,
0.0424246974,
-0.0064768232,
-0.0106990878,
-0.0110473903,
0.0288971849,
-0.0010986018,
-0.0386007465,
0.0410363041,
0.0606506132,
0.0433457568,
-0.0050120158,
-0.0074949083,
-0.0678271502,
0.0513248704,
-0.0420404524,
0.0434000343,
-0.0535068549,
0.0022845461,
0.0311113577,
0.0050776391,
-0.0816131979,
0.0715910643,
-0.0836270452,
0.0463026203,
-0.0468303859,
-0.0420905016,
0.0537512675,
0.0452045426,
0.0537725762,
0.0083018662,
0.0556131564,
0.0313218161,
0.0539372787,
0.0160620008,
-0.0420602039,
0.0014237058,
0.0285224002,
-0.0218948051,
-0.0149238994,
-0.0597726852,
0.0471581593,
-0.0028361336,
0.0040712971,
0.0321057178,
-0.0053747618,
-0.0026059859,
-0.00976694,
0.0333586782,
-0.0130385794,
0.0158410966,
0.0363485329,
0.0153539237,
0.0113741336,
0.050133314,
-0.0008020487,
0.0625406876,
0.028710315,
-0.0343351699,
0.0304196812,
-0.0114936978,
-0.0239940807,
0.0133153787,
-0.0876396298,
0.0431521572,
-0.0651626587,
0.0189477764,
-0.0081352424,
0.0334514305,
0.0175816286,
0.0192365237,
0.0355570056,
0.0328364447,
-0.045321539,
0.017525686,
-0.0203936249,
0.0618299879,
0.0233788844,
-0.0518957004,
0.0277029239,
0.0868578255,
0.0347582959,
-0.0118742334,
0.016352104,
0.0427849181,
-0.0318849906,
-0.0095590064,
0.0019580526,
-0.0299662575,
0.0073193028,
-0.0176489986,
0.0394649766,
-0.0404378138,
-0.0396977141,
0.0089390418,
0.0342364013,
-0.049494639,
0.0210069623,
-0.0285896994,
0.0309332479,
0.0553509779,
-0.0367909782,
-0.0155814514,
-0.036680866,
-0.057105232,
-0.016131036,
0.0277647544,
0.0351011306,
-0.0109184338,
-0.0549955629,
-0.0424403287,
0.0086998511,
0.0134187005,
0.0261339024,
0.0305092037,
-0.0234933384,
0.0883601159,
-0.0053216862,
0.0407147519,
0.0212854519,
-0.0131722074,
0.0691241324,
0.0026763331,
-0.0094619421,
0.036240425,
0.0777560696,
0.0500160567,
-0.0111257341,
-0.038791351,
0.0546168648,
-0.0103903841,
-0.0335247181,
0.0191320162,
0.0460451879,
0.0285535492,
0.0157677978,
-0.0640819594,
-0.0099882353,
0.0751980543,
-0.035434138,
-0.0439452454,
0.0966880471,
0.0021897478,
-0.0027632259,
-0.0110497475,
-0.0192204434,
-0.0281940065,
0.0350563973,
0.017823372,
0.0186875518,
0.0286836345,
-0.0030274389,
-0.0090952348,
0.0122326352,
0.0264049228,
-0.0031706269,
-0.0358940437,
0.0212691221,
-0.0229123179,
0.045187071,
0.0166136026,
-0.0431859456,
-0.0546388142,
0.0142658129,
-0.0394235104,
0.0087409643,
-0.0095440214,
0.0239354465,
0.0086528184,
0.0228381269,
-0.0172513165,
0.0061132163,
0.0083606727,
-0.0097756395,
-0.0454145558,
-0.0010812288,
0.0252037942,
0.0376669466,
-0.0289536715,
-0.0032630591,
-0.0057992381,
-0.0276357736,
0.0040872586,
0.0273509994,
-0.0447933562,
0.0761810243,
0.0041963439,
-0.0625926852,
0.0138297454,
0.0148148565,
-0.0696378648,
0.0013279313,
-0.0030146625,
0.0450962335,
0.0054102014,
0.0372663997,
0.0245956704,
-0.0130337002,
0.0036596125,
-0.0047167079,
0.0049992958,
-0.0502213649,
0.0020688633,
-0.0254265182,
0.0375915952,
-0.0208115056,
-0.0117966672,
0.0117353676,
0.019310439,
-0.0569076724,
0.0114921033,
-0.0174694844,
0.0407644436,
-0.0352339111,
0.0158181991,
-0.0057324772,
0.021976212,
0.0644462481,
0.0012856312,
0.0114904903,
0.0363531932,
0.0330388471,
-0.0215166695,
-0.0405603461,
-0.0544823296,
0.0704653338,
-0.0118670743,
0.016224619,
-0.0804696009,
0.0012588643,
0.0125355097,
-0.0218776111,
-0.0241331402,
-0.0489351265,
-0.0093505606,
-0.0020664341,
-0.0174929202,
-0.0163636543,
0.0104651349,
-0.0137759522,
-0.016839318,
-0.0826987326,
-0.0530262254,
-0.0015059299,
-0.027039554,
-0.0034833159,
-0.0013676283,
0.0149560384,
-0.038038224,
0.0106829163,
0.0303142294,
0.0369559266,
0.0141478758,
0.0545368306,
-0.0572087094,
-0.033864636,
0.029176522,
0.0262498725,
0.011676223,
0.0382215753,
-0.0046718833,
-0.0831222162,
-0.0309826303,
0.000975602,
-0.0324760228,
0.0033292961,
-0.0125055406,
-0.0283727385,
-0.0403005183,
0.0453360304,
0.0801963434,
-0.0015366644,
-0.0251723621,
-0.0214883089,
0.0211133156,
-0.0766260326,
0.0203557648,
0.0012644681,
-0.1221779585,
-0.0132316919,
-0.0095544355,
-0.0136416471,
-0.0356680155,
-0.013603366,
0.0075453152,
-0.0898123682,
0.0234948285,
-0.0129595259,
0.0300450753,
-0.0467538685,
-0.0697417036,
-0.0067453925,
-0.0322985165,
-0.0287403762,
-0.0413176306,
0.0223888345,
0.0288931336,
0.0019004173,
-0.0560104363,
-0.0501190089,
0.0472523309,
-0.049057167,
0.0418845676,
0.0161046125,
0.0769972801,
-0.0584818125,
-0.0550756864,
0.0048691304,
0.0233626738,
-0.0198474899,
-0.0089980718,
0.0371270925,
-0.0522314869,
-0.034181729,
-0.0261870474,
0.0096819466,
-0.0393526629,
0.0301223528,
-0.0293500423,
0.0904938132,
-0.0454454012,
-0.0254232492,
-0.0634262189,
0.0294250809,
0.0354658999,
0.0520810112,
-0.0024391999,
-0.0471689887,
-0.0043530306,
0.0209523514,
-0.0472112186,
-0.0300044678,
-0.0179716181,
-0.0399958044,
0.0200637802,
-0.0031746749,
-0.0039665345,
-0.025240453,
-0.010371699,
-0.0239676423,
-0.0148431771,
0.0406939611,
0.0430569947,
0.0000785665,
-0.0564545728,
0.0212057568,
0.0280841254,
0.0150311291,
0.0215633642,
-0.063161023,
0.0767687485,
0.0392764583,
-0.0252963696,
-0.0202739704,
-0.0191307105,
-0.0083710309,
0.0541014411,
0.0271443743,
0.0280765612,
-0.0008084702,
0.0133785969,
0.0075708502,
0.0357040204,
0.0951291695,
-0.0308807343,
-0.0314942896,
0.0234097615,
0.0697759315,
0.0117707569,
0.0010783598,
-0.0189977288,
0.0301413629,
-0.0308242477,
-0.0957670212,
-0.0267306715,
-0.0098975506,
-0.058465898,
0.0200736616,
0.0317236222,
0.0359470695,
-0.1005109623,
-0.0167727433,
-0.0344463401,
-0.0104333684,
-0.0120316949,
-0.0025038398,
0.0016963946,
0.0220933501,
-0.0061089457,
-0.067712836,
0.0061769309,
0.0150451977,
-0.0761244223,
-0.0183107611,
0.07171496,
0.0194121897,
0.0101599311,
0.0118535794,
0.006970258,
0.0024408225,
-0.0029097849,
0.020820424,
0.0006496453,
-0.0050952914,
-0.0167667717,
-0.0231607687,
0.0155304847,
0.0464519076,
0.0414802581,
-0.0164354797,
-0.0494957343,
-0.0019238349,
-0.0007625415,
0.0242011435,
-0.0113267992,
0.0104265045,
-0.0210318733,
0.0148300584,
0.0206124987,
0.0377823822,
-0.040340662,
-0.0059279711,
0.0417434759,
-0.0043558148,
-0.0656557232,
-0.0108593032,
0.02835319,
-0.033904478,
0.0097259935,
0.0522650369,
0.0030228316,
-0.0002439811,
0.0284552425,
-0.0058299811,
0.028696971,
-0.0051113856,
-0.0020644099,
-0.0189977791,
-0.0272047315,
0.0383274294,
-0.0550852306,
0.0266279858,
0.02159,
0.0236907974,
0.0008592337,
0.0189825725,
0.0654998124,
-0.0274850894,
0.0175061133,
-0.1073537171,
-0.0395048894,
-0.0029273424,
-6.912484244e-33,
0.0020986337,
-0.0177252796,
-0.0400056913,
0.017549783,
-0.0211413018,
-0.0203366783,
-0.0146542527,
0.0180632789,
-0.0120069878,
0.0136566432,
0.003056671,
0.0592293888,
0.0251903869,
0.0390160829,
0.0535968542,
-0.0381996371,
0.0160044041,
-0.0057590553,
0.0278547313,
0.0302918293,
0.050858479,
0.0348969772,
0.0412465632,
-0.0952625498,
-0.0106058493,
-0.0029811345,
-0.0369510539,
-0.0383455902,
0.0292410217,
0.0142888194,
-0.0279504396,
0.0326820575,
0.012126795,
-0.0569730178,
0.0093772747,
0.075174503,
0.0201057009,
0.0097593227,
-0.0260708071,
0.0261937249,
-0.0280382074,
-0.0014208924,
0.0198642816,
0.0341022164,
-0.0533378646,
0.0361352749,
0.0265907608,
-0.009973499,
0.0317122079,
-0.0377959274,
-0.0109061124,
0.0217082668,
-0.0288303867,
0.0321825445,
0.0206174515,
-0.0172769018,
0.0390306674,
0.0302319024,
-0.0947389528,
0.0231652427,
-0.073873058,
-0.0076709897,
0.0228812695,
-0.0278965756,
0.0029715667,
0.0605276264,
0.0316886492,
-0.020244725,
-0.012327712,
0.0239771362,
-0.0169220995,
0.0474344864,
0.0397168249,
0.0273262598,
0.0528262854,
-0.1185246184,
-0.0474582464,
0.0239815712,
0.044051934,
0.0045445901,
0.0337726548,
-0.0181074105,
-0.0037909076,
0.0165099502,
0.0237945933,
-0.0505019538,
-0.0355225243,
-0.0085829468,
-0.0145556601,
-0.0053928155,
-0.0098219076,
0.0149167655,
0.0100884726,
-0.0616387092,
0.0274257455,
0.0225650538,
-0.0567329153,
0.0256787613,
0.0105426619,
-0.0184892602,
-0.039530158,
-0.0354670174,
-0.043348074,
0.0250218194,
0.0044494481,
-0.0145472586,
-0.0073962458,
0.053838402,
-0.0638023391,
0.0073422184,
0.0144943725,
0.0125796124,
-0.0000030977,
0.0289313048,
0.0033131503,
0.0251536034,
-0.0074227671,
0.0502818301,
0.0208934043,
0.0814901069,
0.0215524547,
-0.0484054908,
-0.0295569319,
-0.0274664275,
-0.0272764154,
-0.0492470041,
-0.0646632537,
-0.0247917715,
-0.0061054337,
-0.0559374876,
-0.0069483691,
-0.060618259,
3.026e-7,
0.0010365777,
0.0745538175,
-0.0209908392,
-0.0191122387,
0.010185455,
0.0685216859,
0.0254689846,
0.0336167328,
-0.0302742235,
-0.0247356072,
0.0122752013,
-0.0027689352,
0.0166370738,
0.0088337045,
-0.0720300078,
-0.0358756855,
-0.0675920323,
0.0083272438,
-0.0542065203,
0.0661895126,
0.0261558592,
0.0943812951,
0.0672244877,
-0.015473281,
0.0105512841,
-0.0119570913,
0.021824453,
-0.0002617136,
-0.015721092,
0.0148446076,
-0.01919665,
0.008985539,
-0.0133488942,
-0.0062706764,
-0.0135065587,
0.005830931,
-0.0267720278,
0.0431285463,
0.0102616707,
-0.0147834793,
0.0021798431,
0.0231327545,
0.0122033814,
0.0027125797,
0.0491865017,
0.0031206235,
-0.0909554958,
-0.0812576786,
-0.0122138197,
0.0200903658,
0.0365005843,
0.0201026965,
-0.0035695734,
-0.0200798251,
-0.0211018175,
-0.0430386178,
-0.0562287867,
-0.0756561309,
0.0313494988,
-0.0362717099,
-0.0286636688,
-0.014815419,
0.0000636897,
0.0178535823,
0.0780736208,
0.0342670418,
-0.0051019103,
2.470201278e-34,
0.0396983996,
0.0031758577,
-0.0348848589,
-0.0371665955,
0.0079587651,
0.0225970261,
-0.0242967159,
-0.027316168,
-0.0236478616,
-0.0319950767,
-0.0110957213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16231v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16231v1 | Controllable Text Generation with Residual Memory Transformer | 2023-09-28T08:13:33 | 2023-09-28T08:13:33 | Hanqing Zhang, Sun Si, Haiming Wu, Dawei Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large-scale Causal Language Models (CLMs), e.g., GPT3 and ChatGPT, have
brought great success in text generation. However, it is still an open
challenge to control the generation process of CLM while balancing flexibility,
control granularity, and generation efficiency. In this paper, we provide a new
alternative for controllable text generation (CTG), by designing a
non-intrusive, lightweight control plugin to accompany the generation of CLM at
arbitrary time steps. The proposed control plugin, namely Residual Memory
Transformer (RMT), has an encoder-decoder setup, which can accept any types of
control conditions and cooperate with CLM through a residual learning paradigm,
to achieve a more flexible, general, and efficient CTG. Extensive experiments
are carried out on various control tasks, in the form of both automatic and
human evaluations. The results show the superiority of RMT over a range of
state-of-the-art approaches, proving the effectiveness and versatility of our
approach. | [
-0.0091158738,
0.0346002206,
-0.0046305554,
-0.0028053161,
-0.0252097938,
0.0066679013,
0.0034142183,
0.0046287798,
0.0216675121,
-0.0250418019,
0.0196178537,
-0.0233187154,
-0.0168878157,
0.0533123314,
0.0354295112,
-0.0344680101,
0.0189069547,
-0.0133107947,
0.002249751,
0.0064194226,
-0.0067992317,
-0.0103714662,
0.0093920445,
0.0498189479,
-0.0379813798,
0.0084501682,
-0.018667765,
0.0129976906,
0.0053938134,
-0.0048700976,
0.0120524913,
0.0522686243,
0.0351856574,
0.0393497571,
0.0000021722,
-0.0132134259,
-0.0300914142,
-0.0080597261,
0.0406028405,
0.0071549364,
0.0082757417,
0.0113988034,
-0.0363256261,
0.045332212,
-0.0355709381,
0.0289954562,
0.0573049188,
0.0339659825,
0.057911817,
0.0704985633,
-0.0260574017,
-0.0401484855,
0.0245125759,
-0.0273453239,
0.0379735678,
0.0005441506,
0.0013721461,
0.0135493251,
0.0051346468,
-0.0371699147,
-0.0290209353,
0.0208767857,
0.0484330244,
-0.0359094888,
-0.0021764881,
0.0272448156,
0.0330213085,
-0.0508523844,
-0.0330108628,
0.0461474881,
0.0038261989,
-0.0629270673,
0.0360166468,
-0.0038827895,
-0.032413926,
0.0100228032,
-0.041489359,
0.0666224957,
-0.0220474061,
0.0235330537,
0.0012955236,
0.0156187387,
0.0047359024,
-0.0051408727,
-0.0429585353,
0.017692877,
0.030605115,
-0.0384822078,
-0.0390666686,
0.0425148904,
0.0167970937,
-0.0452367701,
0.0361973718,
0.0610340536,
-0.0435361713,
0.0081456043,
-0.08264447,
-0.0695264414,
0.001730604,
-0.044377923,
-0.0166623294,
0.0529805683,
0.032590881,
-0.0112544298,
-0.0586072989,
0.0890735835,
-0.0366925485,
0.0301191192,
-0.0066967169,
0.0220188852,
-0.0259719249,
-0.0360181332,
-0.0671866313,
0.0274949949,
-0.0230649468,
-0.037896093,
-0.0482545905,
0.0546964779,
0.0080531472,
0.0010823683,
0.0300061442,
-0.0065384605,
-0.0599862114,
0.0059541101,
0.0094474871,
0.0015035049,
0.0085451184,
-0.031886857,
0.0145200873,
-0.0326387249,
-0.0162354652,
0.0280104559,
0.0076594912,
0.0060852803,
-0.0415059775,
0.0678731799,
-0.0674281195,
-0.0175691769,
-0.0250014272,
-0.0268264934,
0.0112935947,
-0.0370888747,
0.0011517768,
-0.0408092067,
-0.0072181839,
0.0164197795,
-0.0142638506,
-0.0404411964,
0.0275800359,
0.0227156766,
-0.0045520081,
-0.0011820713,
0.0224066228,
-0.0040462902,
0.0328051448,
0.0008021269,
0.0370843261,
0.0513084084,
0.0738354996,
0.068597801,
-0.0188747905,
-0.0017813271,
0.0290119629,
0.0469912142,
0.0439172015,
0.0098774331,
-0.0790472254,
-0.0405161306,
0.0055380608,
0.0175618827,
0.0223548971,
0.066079922,
-0.0319141746,
0.0590267591,
0.0640289709,
-0.0181726292,
-0.0052542351,
0.0422868878,
0.0963853225,
0.0057621161,
-0.0341858268,
0.0238495935,
-0.0160796084,
0.0459165387,
-0.0077016344,
0.0101180086,
0.0274242479,
0.0387806445,
-0.0232512224,
-0.01291689,
0.009633027,
-0.0071301102,
0.0254758,
-0.0282066353,
0.0561390072,
0.0377465189,
-0.1159834564,
0.0290751029,
0.0018693759,
-0.0871707574,
0.0235608947,
-0.0348911509,
0.0242903922,
0.0670814291,
0.0778212175,
0.007011849,
-0.007847609,
-0.0020219141,
-0.0294441991,
0.0788830966,
0.0302743316,
0.0266427882,
-0.0260441545,
-0.076134786,
-0.0157696996,
0.0295876171,
-0.00045317,
0.0449145958,
0.0193410031,
0.0285932198,
0.0340418778,
0.0569472946,
-0.0124599328,
0.0349713415,
-0.0306674466,
-0.0001650111,
-0.0158254784,
-0.0165406447,
0.0192990545,
-0.0171847399,
-0.0349920355,
0.0292029195,
0.0216845088,
-0.0355552807,
-0.0607201494,
0.0345837325,
-0.0665947795,
-0.0477469712,
-0.0143397693,
-0.0246484429,
0.016242139,
0.0217453204,
-0.0133773796,
-0.087105386,
0.0269351806,
-0.0413974896,
0.0559781753,
-0.0331880003,
0.020109484,
0.0104827574,
-0.014297788,
-0.0263261739,
0.0411597118,
-0.0104661975,
-0.0333229937,
0.0379187949,
0.0546097085,
-0.008442671,
-0.0332377255,
-0.015641978,
-0.0080925003,
-0.0114355274,
-0.0149410171,
0.0492994897,
0.0284237023,
0.0072993664,
-0.0551714227,
-0.0320298858,
0.0101675307,
-0.0331035443,
-0.007681319,
0.0333597623,
0.0086600455,
0.0162541829,
0.0098773483,
-0.0551934578,
0.0332981534,
0.0439322144,
-0.02050207,
0.0059065148,
-0.0143856667,
-0.0114483228,
-0.0164307579,
0.0006865775,
0.0156757478,
0.0180293173,
0.0249377359,
-0.0543329902,
-0.050145328,
0.0313120857,
-0.0088832676,
0.014139195,
-0.0105802994,
-0.0700460225,
0.0016996189,
-0.0196640119,
0.0803706273,
0.0212252922,
0.0301149748,
0.0423537195,
-0.0018145363,
-0.0035607333,
-0.0317375958,
0.0188532546,
-0.0548008382,
-0.0196344778,
-0.0014971572,
-0.0350271612,
0.0194065869,
0.0865699649,
0.0467810892,
0.036916323,
-0.1034303084,
-0.0004577813,
-0.0036415681,
-0.0262253415,
-0.0186970066,
-0.0253416151,
-0.0493935868,
0.005699547,
-0.0493113473,
-0.073708646,
0.0466143265,
-0.0346488617,
-0.007132051,
0.0073564313,
0.0232455172,
-0.0210539084,
0.0300561339,
0.0407785587,
0.0092423437,
0.0114163067,
-0.0212001912,
-0.029487459,
0.0371049084,
0.0129029723,
-0.0084715029,
0.0126877753,
-0.0367413238,
0.0327919386,
-0.0203975849,
-0.0228328407,
-0.0333640389,
-0.0148783289,
0.0299720392,
-0.0024410358,
0.0680366457,
-0.0189886894,
-0.015426062,
0.0406146012,
0.0323534794,
0.0630768687,
-0.0452294536,
0.0043816576,
-0.0379747413,
0.0146990409,
0.0321595706,
-0.0383744575,
-0.0076742456,
-0.056283351,
0.0056447107,
0.0403039344,
-0.0189234503,
-0.0219037291,
-0.0074284342,
0.0060229949,
0.0086729964,
0.0138404239,
-0.0088536218,
0.0186595824,
0.0450919457,
-0.0534754358,
-0.0391468517,
0.0944042131,
0.0186232142,
-0.0599573404,
0.0072150812,
0.0402249321,
0.0663053319,
0.0007112804,
0.0090755988,
-0.0634959415,
-0.0053518214,
0.0153881637,
0.0239036158,
-0.0315025151,
-0.002367334,
-0.0288483594,
-0.0666500404,
0.0386068821,
0.0170740169,
-0.0401301496,
0.0212557334,
0.0050660619,
-0.062361788,
0.0124345673,
-0.0264988355,
0.0456785038,
-0.0020913784,
0.0042565488,
0.0217605606,
-0.0047956435,
-0.0427891053,
-0.0562178418,
0.0132622588,
0.047966186,
0.0466088057,
-0.0006767799,
0.0107340897,
-0.0196871478,
0.0133843692,
-0.0129621802,
0.0075091221,
-0.0370623954,
0.0117289126,
0.0222256426,
-0.0241798405,
-0.0205203649,
0.0299825985,
-0.0070264041,
-0.004636683,
-0.0157249309,
0.0533898473,
-0.0410031416,
-0.0106850751,
0.0039050719,
-0.0156512689,
0.0428345948,
0.0519996211,
0.0181144904,
-0.035122063,
-0.0938261971,
-0.0317437947,
-0.0288806614,
-0.0903386027,
-0.0342753641,
-0.0571042523,
-0.0021673935,
-0.0600628741,
-0.0945511535,
0.0044916035,
0.0024153797,
0.0452194698,
0.0163282789,
-0.0202884804,
0.0087983888,
-0.0297479164,
-0.0738859102,
-0.0381633751,
-0.0235246252,
0.0091645429,
-0.0895931274,
-0.0535845794,
0.0101586236,
-0.0355154425,
0.0093674138,
0.0403120145,
-0.0626783073,
-0.0656326786,
-0.0155839324,
0.0647941828,
0.0219203159,
0.0172479246,
-0.0133472634,
-0.0470920131,
0.048542466,
0.0111679742,
-0.0258678626,
0.0204274412,
-0.0058255917,
0.0247625466,
-0.0114968987,
0.0121149383,
-0.0376002677,
0.025505526,
-0.0008305605,
0.0470428877,
0.0230515506,
0.0224615894,
0.0241053943,
-0.0137707042,
-0.0154783335,
-0.0528718792,
0.0542335957,
-0.0354412608,
-0.0057889712,
-0.0699281171,
0.0154564576,
-0.0773741901,
0.0339388698,
-0.0077366428,
0.0033284337,
0.006282039,
-0.033783745,
-0.0232539531,
0.0012411122,
-0.0302878022,
0.0179590266,
-0.0479614399,
0.028371416,
0.0597769022,
0.0037251043,
-0.0194026772,
0.0038294399,
0.0120115839,
-0.0068578278,
-0.0258532241,
0.0811374262,
0.0261361729,
0.0202021301,
0.0029262686,
0.0047514602,
-0.0396346077,
0.0111433882,
-0.0449695997,
0.024207022,
0.083529681,
0.040137101,
0.0916163996,
-0.0486671701,
0.0244411528,
-0.0064219371,
0.0591473617,
0.031686075,
-0.0356746726,
0.0026465321,
-0.0137604028,
-0.0163682532,
-0.0153106535,
0.0938859731,
0.0249831527,
0.0002130421,
-0.0268396474,
0.0036239855,
-0.0321747214,
-0.0331239551,
0.0152858626,
-0.0324430205,
0.001353353,
-0.0155866873,
-0.0573781468,
-0.0171307996,
-0.0062438408,
0.0101753827,
0.0095637981,
-0.0220850613,
0.05649627,
-0.0109336823,
-0.0375887714,
0.0085962238,
-0.0268097632,
0.0265538171,
-0.0277558602,
-0.0171690136,
-0.0488733761,
-6.703343963e-33,
-0.0448312126,
-0.0340933874,
0.0389451832,
-0.0049795634,
-0.0482015088,
-0.0044298861,
-0.0735373795,
-0.0048298552,
0.0671167895,
0.0058992198,
0.0060826945,
-0.0027294515,
0.0114065437,
0.0438428633,
-0.0011124255,
0.0205427874,
0.0657482818,
-0.0260313097,
-0.0469667688,
0.078822948,
0.0827954337,
0.0337807909,
0.0233312938,
-0.0250461996,
-0.0218135267,
-0.0266581699,
-0.0093663391,
-0.0122681279,
0.0142459543,
0.0165155623,
-0.0005654237,
0.0168178752,
0.0187910795,
-0.0517518111,
-0.0327378362,
0.0530056097,
-0.0175065231,
-0.0189321749,
-0.0055322419,
0.0073073306,
-0.0047066589,
-0.0439154357,
0.0361979678,
-0.0291588623,
-0.030507382,
0.038401287,
0.0085748266,
0.0101784412,
-0.0277606361,
-0.088021405,
-0.0800156668,
0.031091433,
-0.0029744019,
-0.0175042357,
-0.0092011988,
0.0338402912,
-0.026763266,
0.0105123091,
-0.0215405822,
0.0351980254,
0.0167945772,
0.0268891603,
0.0535611548,
0.0456025749,
0.0349727198,
0.0304333773,
-0.0314531736,
0.0303568263,
-0.0719762743,
0.0236761477,
0.0105623631,
0.0163833927,
0.0432209186,
0.0251134206,
0.0210040696,
-0.0614756644,
-0.0378970355,
0.0196388271,
0.0168186594,
0.0188451633,
0.0575281046,
0.0121335089,
-0.0051225745,
-0.0167594533,
-0.015202147,
0.0121172573,
-0.0025876556,
-0.0228312369,
0.0504423156,
0.0476082116,
-0.0119816475,
-0.0699345618,
0.0441726632,
0.0047969464,
0.0504476689,
0.0405100435,
-0.0568758883,
0.0340660289,
-0.0283039417,
-0.0069386922,
-0.0582685024,
-0.0608156808,
0.0443968661,
0.0096185626,
-0.0080029089,
0.0438384712,
-0.0058165402,
0.0430643298,
-0.0373762362,
0.020871494,
-0.0523319542,
0.0234941803,
0.0299395826,
-0.0238481909,
0.0091615012,
-0.0059661032,
-0.0149483727,
0.0422456264,
-0.0049752533,
-0.0066783787,
-0.0013933716,
-0.0272452217,
0.0408645421,
0.0481815897,
-0.0351578631,
0.0308419727,
-0.0530310348,
0.0540719815,
0.036289949,
-0.0780716762,
-0.0139603214,
0.0132915517,
2.831e-7,
-0.0185191315,
0.0473887362,
0.0580605976,
-0.0062931357,
0.0536856651,
-0.0147771239,
0.024081042,
0.0283635035,
0.0003853274,
0.0478279479,
0.000613889,
0.0028872988,
0.0772213861,
-0.0130989375,
-0.0695748255,
0.0013277981,
-0.0787563547,
0.0068202801,
-0.0313135795,
-0.0050369157,
0.0979473442,
0.021180246,
-0.0088726832,
0.0219985433,
0.0087266359,
0.0141609879,
0.0828286558,
0.0153707433,
0.0097742332,
-0.0029739905,
-0.0019257958,
0.0113796806,
-0.0416195393,
-0.0142930653,
-0.0293796342,
-0.011802352,
-0.0156215727,
0.0828271136,
0.0031166961,
-0.0344187431,
0.0357171074,
-0.01261908,
-0.0138498358,
-0.0443542115,
0.03526669,
-0.0686863139,
0.0002033158,
0.0528281108,
-0.0171242934,
0.0097363172,
-0.0403058007,
-0.0203586705,
-0.0309152286,
0.0215169974,
0.0171079207,
0.0324588791,
0.0104469135,
-0.0452896506,
-0.0242172647,
-0.0292312931,
-0.0546024814,
-0.0407142825,
-0.0779592097,
-0.0209528413,
-0.0098411264,
-0.000427223,
-0.0245890226,
2.951265683e-34,
0.0383146442,
-0.0529509038,
0.0015290262,
-0.0163498595,
0.0105998833,
0.0021909524,
0.0638842359,
0.0455722325,
0.034671329,
-0.0604024269,
-0.038205158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16228v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16228v1 | Brand Network Booster: A New System for Improving Brand Connectivity | 2023-09-28T08:09:33 | 2023-09-28T08:09:33 | J. Cancellieri, W. Didimo, A. Fronzetti Colladon, F. Montecchiani | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.SE, physics.soc-ph, F.2; H.4; H.5; I.2; D.2 | This paper presents a new decision support system offered for an in-depth
analysis of semantic networks, which can provide insights for a better
exploration of a brand's image and the improvement of its connectivity. In
terms of network analysis, we show that this goal is achieved by solving an
extended version of the Maximum Betweenness Improvement problem, which includes
the possibility of considering adversarial nodes, constrained budgets, and
weighted networks - where connectivity improvement can be obtained by adding
links or increasing the weight of existing connections. We present this new
system together with two case studies, also discussing its performance. Our
tool and approach are useful both for network scholars and for supporting the
strategic decision-making processes of marketing and communication managers. | [
0.0286889337,
0.0232820511,
-0.0258894563,
0.0226089284,
-0.0135554317,
-0.0628033951,
-0.0319493786,
-0.0232534446,
-0.0023546801,
-0.0430799797,
0.0367245674,
0.0257593133,
0.010988635,
0.058557611,
0.0239523966,
-0.0148437452,
-0.0218828563,
0.0264355876,
0.0169302337,
0.0100370869,
-0.0002798415,
-0.0120582916,
-0.0135082053,
-0.0153586147,
-0.0365138166,
-0.0091031427,
0.0008242143,
0.0116744004,
0.0550161228,
-0.1008164808,
0.0159438755,
0.012756831,
-0.0048425542,
-0.0031675315,
0.0000023381,
-0.0707455054,
-0.0047412305,
-0.0362126157,
-0.0224198774,
0.007658266,
0.0377699956,
0.0387775041,
0.0457334556,
0.0183756668,
-0.0440015383,
0.0466379784,
0.0433084592,
0.0330654196,
-0.0084585221,
0.0222604647,
-0.0441076085,
-0.0475276746,
-0.010601419,
-0.0245725047,
-0.0286326576,
-0.060935054,
0.0338559598,
0.0297603142,
-0.0267276224,
-0.0381285585,
-0.0019177835,
0.0372748598,
0.0051920637,
-0.0171203222,
0.0878649428,
0.0217892043,
0.0125875454,
-0.0064133648,
-0.0086923148,
0.0219765194,
0.0240398832,
0.0279861819,
-0.0017709283,
-0.0074098678,
0.0082880612,
0.0206588339,
0.0058258572,
-0.073725231,
-0.0154352477,
0.0322458744,
-0.0588278659,
0.0568894818,
0.039616935,
0.0183945503,
-0.0295095593,
0.0745874867,
-0.0110883238,
0.0197969005,
0.0353978127,
-0.0028863337,
-0.0089774588,
-0.0330725461,
0.0274444353,
-0.0466388501,
-0.0257396586,
-0.0000725305,
0.0461297557,
0.0245884862,
0.0311385058,
-0.0426300839,
0.0058051478,
-0.0484564938,
0.0492729768,
0.0037537685,
-0.0120010413,
-0.0444811247,
-0.0224612709,
-0.0114177847,
-0.0298867226,
0.0545630455,
-0.0487898253,
-0.0176490992,
-0.009131521,
0.0028048148,
-0.0699944943,
0.0061201663,
-0.073656179,
0.010670945,
-0.0505137928,
0.0054573123,
-0.0166101363,
0.0305190235,
0.0769181624,
-0.0251946542,
-0.0755518675,
-0.01154547,
-0.0632375851,
0.0342444442,
-0.0166639499,
0.0479907803,
0.0632339269,
0.0144715952,
-0.0199988522,
-0.0197581276,
-0.0138422791,
0.112603195,
-0.0085403826,
-0.0362976305,
-0.055936411,
-0.0266237948,
0.0163787324,
-0.0456330702,
-0.0358823985,
-0.0363772288,
-0.0272305887,
-0.0023742926,
-0.0312312953,
0.0023130279,
-0.005605964,
-0.0545395836,
-0.0513786376,
0.0307906084,
-0.0222425479,
0.0055028051,
0.048065152,
-0.0045759603,
0.0726705492,
-0.0290813949,
-0.0034725692,
0.0372084267,
0.0214589052,
0.0074325046,
-0.0972315222,
-0.0187718738,
-0.013201707,
-0.040364299,
0.01145944,
-0.0148328524,
-0.0061329231,
0.0072113727,
-0.0328069776,
-0.0253070965,
-0.058320038,
-0.0049610101,
0.0781880543,
-0.0680982694,
0.0760681853,
-0.0098090842,
-0.0320100263,
-0.0258802455,
-0.0410379618,
-0.0175665412,
-0.0221046768,
0.0090347603,
0.0062705646,
0.005293991,
0.0051726927,
0.0025839056,
-0.0355049931,
-0.0523813032,
0.0318664275,
0.011590993,
0.0613872446,
-0.0020548701,
0.0422181673,
-0.0429181121,
-0.0347224139,
-0.0254327524,
-0.0033239007,
0.0425364189,
0.0028482107,
0.0143987564,
-0.0020807208,
0.1006698906,
0.04959663,
-0.0341763794,
0.0342411883,
0.0093298946,
-0.0651503503,
0.0066011022,
-0.0083562434,
-0.0013034148,
-0.0125667667,
-0.0214482676,
-0.0007646969,
-0.0219223332,
0.0397980772,
0.0680439696,
-0.0567568094,
0.0599844046,
-0.0121063078,
-0.0080635138,
0.0392473303,
-0.0081003923,
0.0545448661,
0.0547407344,
0.0060840845,
0.0323123969,
-0.0029968678,
0.0831798241,
0.0038343328,
-0.0207253806,
0.024463838,
-0.087119326,
-0.0360805951,
-0.0247844756,
0.0640777647,
0.0797694102,
0.0086170975,
-0.0756624863,
-0.0126189338,
0.0335651599,
0.0102797793,
-0.0169020705,
0.0660783201,
-0.0021298504,
0.0175686479,
-0.0121204434,
-0.0312168766,
-0.0006704378,
0.0184479803,
-0.0038231732,
0.0434535556,
0.0160070509,
-0.0124354353,
-0.0396101177,
0.0129950708,
0.0156274065,
-0.01826296,
0.0662701651,
-0.0241144076,
-0.0103495056,
-0.0170946419,
0.0516044796,
-0.0196606666,
-0.0041284496,
-0.0047417437,
-0.0042687836,
0.0069360929,
0.0453901216,
0.0123247113,
-0.0035803204,
-0.0028013268,
0.0203264318,
0.0024817036,
0.0194918178,
0.082555756,
-0.0411394313,
-0.027934432,
0.0504961424,
0.0667473078,
-0.0553114749,
-0.0274717975,
-0.0199395549,
0.0205987822,
0.0531837828,
0.0722194687,
-0.1080463976,
-0.002362329,
-0.0112640979,
-0.0871534422,
-0.0604075789,
-0.001500873,
-0.0043485733,
-0.0382178128,
0.0567777343,
0.0123528317,
-0.035800118,
0.0352240317,
0.0116351265,
0.0403091274,
-0.0479260981,
-0.0167382285,
0.0029838448,
-0.0215804782,
0.0239186659,
-0.0402189903,
-0.018606117,
0.0021955948,
-0.0119664259,
-0.0047161905,
-0.0058089825,
0.0124387797,
0.0263051055,
0.0482580438,
0.006569522,
-0.0358714126,
-0.0190100223,
0.0034818642,
0.0720444694,
0.0269771144,
-0.031146897,
0.0256006196,
0.0363048799,
0.0781172588,
0.0260054618,
-0.0588643439,
0.0071869316,
-0.0101703238,
0.0387371331,
0.0235648602,
-0.0213076137,
-0.0232360624,
-0.0053307465,
-0.019703947,
0.0557164997,
-0.0045069349,
0.0011555569,
0.0533331223,
0.0202989634,
0.0058055203,
-0.0131906988,
-0.0450021327,
0.0295003131,
-0.0346976966,
-0.017880667,
0.0815208852,
0.0056258454,
-0.0258188602,
0.0292560365,
-0.0579184704,
-0.0139113991,
0.0351760611,
-0.0033588125,
0.0235660616,
0.0627874732,
-0.0160810035,
-0.0514436662,
0.0503328182,
0.0276516192,
0.0105129723,
-0.0243743304,
-0.0637209266,
-0.0444019884,
-0.049866654,
-0.0072756629,
-0.0524917468,
0.0148439249,
0.0256165341,
-0.0303651821,
-0.0107186744,
0.0125334049,
0.0754032657,
-0.0027445599,
0.0286873076,
0.0155105675,
0.0274601635,
0.045889575,
-0.0012036569,
0.0241605993,
0.0308605097,
-0.0726852939,
0.0183541626,
-0.0199846923,
0.014285096,
-0.041069001,
-0.0595390685,
-0.0315868855,
-0.0670613125,
0.00135862,
0.0071565839,
-0.0310034193,
0.0351816192,
-0.0073027839,
-0.0217905566,
-0.0321634077,
-0.0121865133,
-0.0406251438,
0.0270540435,
-0.0047162394,
-0.0171187427,
0.0354039557,
-0.0198564269,
-0.0334288552,
-0.0192439705,
0.0131787974,
-0.0315659158,
0.0176198911,
-0.0205074474,
-0.0255763102,
0.0383011587,
-0.0044537387,
0.0231683813,
0.0111495648,
0.0977884755,
0.0168755315,
-0.0053545996,
-0.0300546642,
-0.0198652055,
0.0170963537,
0.0003127535,
-0.0038961489,
-0.0029291033,
0.0507396087,
-0.0145123368,
-0.0173803046,
-0.0106084235,
-0.0113594402,
0.0105723999,
-0.0306787603,
-0.0356330462,
-0.0077534299,
-0.0265242849,
0.0112571092,
-0.0210408587,
-0.0104429917,
0.0263896994,
-0.0325871184,
-0.0410131253,
-0.0479086637,
0.0323172957,
-0.0217434242,
0.0189766269,
-0.0370032787,
0.0134969,
-0.0569093525,
0.0087315459,
-0.0199020915,
-0.0463524312,
0.0349998698,
0.0599267036,
-0.0038487061,
0.0367972814,
0.0220970903,
-0.0176211931,
-0.0210266672,
0.0146198254,
0.0419306792,
-0.0743772611,
-0.0203975402,
0.0406685807,
0.0302298851,
0.0271637738,
-0.0208304748,
-0.0588657483,
0.0111736367,
0.1108245924,
-0.0093680145,
-0.0051419009,
-0.008428066,
-0.0036729111,
-0.0285897888,
0.035029348,
-0.0233680308,
0.0238489676,
0.0076580001,
0.0010078868,
-0.0057047121,
0.0163816065,
0.0299749169,
0.0197580941,
0.0401686579,
0.0137542188,
0.0493287556,
-0.0257570148,
0.0375891775,
-0.01042163,
-0.0038506256,
-0.0019489969,
-0.0095653748,
-0.0190258734,
0.0172678754,
0.0110096708,
-0.0556074269,
0.0039654439,
0.0190843232,
0.0346392095,
0.0074897022,
0.0363459513,
0.048551701,
-0.0024451918,
0.0170027539,
0.0087487539,
-0.026768839,
0.0228297487,
0.0065161451,
-0.0249660537,
-0.0285230987,
0.0424142107,
-0.0221629776,
-0.0625589192,
0.0262316689,
0.0240274351,
-0.0187542327,
-0.0061328374,
0.0292189959,
0.0352178849,
0.034049198,
-0.0176259428,
-0.0236708969,
-0.0073826825,
-0.0252358783,
-0.0116104512,
-0.0057008406,
-0.0310494434,
0.0189087186,
0.0357748643,
0.031046072,
0.06648691,
0.0149910562,
-0.0098094195,
-0.0378876328,
-0.0644446611,
-0.0486404598,
-0.0392400064,
-0.0109097473,
0.0019390808,
0.0646344498,
-0.0116924085,
0.0210814066,
-0.0864592344,
-0.0620934628,
0.0024013217,
0.0123497751,
0.0233808402,
0.0530339777,
-0.0037825746,
-0.0119678834,
0.0291639585,
0.0132607454,
-0.0064661987,
0.0049171522,
-0.0968158841,
-0.0085861711,
0.0401781425,
-6.059440116e-33,
0.0291535072,
-0.0862219706,
-0.0152549911,
0.0106075956,
-0.0621522106,
0.0157136414,
-0.0014178263,
-0.0014235779,
0.0018829039,
0.0294649396,
0.0259610824,
-0.034363661,
0.0056290263,
0.0104345307,
0.0047384291,
-0.0047295056,
0.0404230319,
0.0334384218,
0.0029731973,
-0.0244788565,
-0.0006597726,
0.0244998969,
-0.0187161826,
-0.0893624425,
-0.009195595,
-0.0305867437,
-0.0293349903,
0.0512994565,
0.0785520747,
0.0260372106,
0.0298274495,
0.0466300994,
0.0230484921,
-0.0610097721,
0.0442106463,
0.0022280512,
-0.0666741952,
-0.0051951492,
0.0369753651,
-0.0364409238,
-0.0277521946,
0.0138633987,
-0.0284239165,
0.0020026271,
0.0167915095,
0.0233779177,
0.0285359696,
-0.0491768196,
-0.0372219905,
0.0234083794,
0.013692894,
0.0120932907,
-0.0445642062,
0.0636611953,
0.0251908712,
-0.0460920371,
-0.0225312263,
0.0202157348,
-0.0331608802,
0.0194990039,
-0.0582826845,
-0.0471319407,
0.0125295622,
0.0406702384,
0.0021973737,
0.0167731848,
-0.009701998,
-0.0220032204,
0.0717046857,
0.0528080426,
-0.0704679787,
0.0533699691,
0.0291522499,
0.0578876287,
-0.0207057428,
-0.0321733654,
-0.0813916475,
-0.0024025778,
0.0156050641,
-0.0367606804,
-0.0436919332,
0.051947359,
0.0360410996,
-0.0116019147,
0.0168190543,
-0.128041327,
-0.0469143838,
-0.0581497326,
0.0005306861,
0.0239817128,
-0.0607997365,
0.0669807643,
-0.0287127569,
-0.0408271961,
-0.0308075454,
0.0013446256,
0.0292315856,
-0.0057142172,
0.0061435895,
-0.0318751633,
0.0027009167,
0.0214201286,
-0.0483115017,
0.0355502814,
-0.0149012087,
-0.0439135656,
0.0197559074,
-0.0441862457,
0.0108335325,
0.0127408635,
0.0520327017,
0.0001889036,
-0.0245244559,
-0.0972418711,
-0.0229617786,
-0.0037009842,
-0.0018193499,
0.0363362432,
0.0654017106,
0.0398064218,
0.0208606254,
-0.0033846274,
-0.0218398198,
-0.0009149808,
0.0022908363,
0.0061584581,
0.0128355939,
0.0156489946,
0.0585623197,
-0.0625417084,
-0.0501481332,
-0.037633013,
2.907e-7,
0.025892809,
0.0525137223,
-0.0097559122,
-0.0321914516,
0.039722383,
0.0259844307,
0.0166581552,
0.0212685559,
-0.014198848,
-0.0788778588,
0.0285512339,
-0.0284899697,
-0.0566420034,
0.0317615941,
0.0051371688,
0.0423848182,
0.00292249,
-0.0669708401,
-0.0441909134,
0.0135449208,
0.0528820194,
-0.0136990733,
0.0423102118,
0.0224087667,
-0.0030745291,
-0.063860558,
0.0197490361,
-0.0331422091,
0.0249970704,
-0.0047454033,
0.006535063,
-0.0417995676,
-0.0431271531,
0.0401162207,
-0.0158152543,
0.0336834565,
0.0112503711,
-0.0314232446,
0.0301030781,
-0.0007182303,
0.001898351,
-0.0078315409,
0.0104865953,
-0.0045795501,
0.0143039841,
-0.0784398541,
-0.0422759913,
0.0508970134,
-0.0247875098,
-0.0017675332,
0.0370069966,
0.011373546,
0.0282053836,
0.0198585093,
-0.0533945225,
0.0102178492,
0.0491710082,
-0.0390691869,
0.0357301384,
0.037884783,
0.0007065408,
0.003726799,
0.033384569,
0.0463060103,
0.0782584101,
0.0138143906,
0.0085253185,
1.56371812e-34,
0.0491375364,
-0.0336266384,
0.0219653752,
-0.0092218304,
0.0246951263,
-0.0232584253,
-0.0635315701,
-0.0182256158,
0.0272351112,
-0.0689571202,
0.0064733061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16202v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16202v1 | Marathi-English Code-mixed Text Generation | 2023-09-28T06:51:26 | 2023-09-28T06:51:26 | Dhiraj Amin, Sharvari Govilkar, Sagar Kulkarni, Yash Shashikant Lalit, Arshi Ajaz Khwaja, Daries Xavier, Sahil Girijashankar Gupta | cs.CL | cs.CL | Code-mixing, the blending of linguistic elements from distinct languages to
form meaningful sentences, is common in multilingual settings, yielding hybrid
languages like Hinglish and Minglish. Marathi, India's third most spoken
language, often integrates English for precision and formality. Developing
code-mixed language systems, like Marathi-English (Minglish), faces resource
constraints. This research introduces a Marathi-English code-mixed text
generation algorithm, assessed with Code Mixing Index (CMI) and Degree of Code
Mixing (DCM) metrics. Across 2987 code-mixed questions, it achieved an average
CMI of 0.2 and an average DCM of 7.4, indicating effective and comprehensible
code-mixed sentences. These results offer potential for enhanced NLP tools,
bridging linguistic gaps in multilingual societies. | [
0.0052249315,
-0.0286557619,
-0.0369076692,
0.0266950093,
-0.0415267125,
0.0116513409,
-0.0413204879,
0.0190919954,
0.012204227,
-0.0316075981,
-0.0078578303,
-0.0368859358,
0.0469290242,
0.058073502,
0.0284407344,
-0.0235218778,
0.0112371296,
0.0015760717,
-0.0455636159,
0.0189757049,
0.0708501115,
0.0453607738,
0.0165992435,
0.0448440947,
-0.0134332208,
-0.0182172898,
-0.0132633327,
0.0008791326,
0.0461076088,
-0.0352635235,
0.0276611205,
0.02724359,
-0.0262360014,
0.0409535095,
0.0000017495,
-0.0497045815,
-0.0276068915,
-0.0103044454,
0.0438041016,
-0.0043540886,
0.0359289348,
-0.0085846186,
0.0118263746,
0.0648998544,
-0.037977878,
0.0186348632,
0.0713812783,
-0.0273493808,
0.049563311,
0.0749787465,
-0.0192711931,
-0.0135674113,
0.0220196303,
0.0478577279,
-0.0373638123,
0.0356663801,
-0.007731399,
0.0395559482,
0.0563921332,
-0.0085276831,
0.0223555323,
0.0138906026,
0.0173760355,
-0.0262396913,
0.0124842003,
0.0172549486,
-0.0362594388,
-0.010145165,
0.0271692071,
0.0361187197,
-0.0565772913,
-0.0529404916,
0.025227474,
-0.0507638939,
-0.0481346957,
-0.0627781376,
-0.0337043814,
0.0189890023,
-0.0380544998,
0.0490733422,
0.0566639565,
0.0071508405,
0.0018480894,
0.0116847903,
0.0377898291,
0.0183555558,
0.033506386,
-0.0062743495,
-0.0592655651,
-0.0017207547,
0.0508073755,
-0.0710988119,
0.0161073506,
0.0425055735,
-0.0367533751,
0.0353421234,
-0.0398599654,
-0.0866458118,
0.0601207986,
-0.0219237711,
-0.0089176521,
0.0429049097,
-0.0076953168,
-0.0251398981,
-0.0249244068,
-0.0003648657,
-0.0057815975,
-0.0120368274,
-0.00459034,
-0.0097815404,
-0.0092848865,
-0.0670907125,
0.0026222435,
0.0322932787,
-0.047504779,
0.0220864937,
-0.0566869751,
0.0292767808,
0.0055158557,
0.0014471414,
0.0310079977,
-0.0312280729,
-0.0299199782,
-0.0155272484,
0.0461277068,
-0.0257995371,
-0.0519938581,
0.0056317984,
0.036937315,
-0.0727956221,
0.0457768627,
0.0279320292,
-0.0090192938,
-0.0270477571,
-0.0542108305,
0.0231396072,
-0.0406795368,
-0.0046873158,
-0.0391244777,
-0.0237293914,
-0.0190920308,
-0.0102070319,
-0.0328486711,
-0.084141992,
0.0133555476,
0.0406543352,
0.0255354941,
-0.044727169,
0.026916571,
0.0257803816,
0.0142695643,
0.0019049811,
-0.082719624,
-0.0209386051,
0.0349760652,
0.0140397623,
0.0253295079,
0.0591890737,
0.0276579987,
-0.0352231041,
0.0211759266,
-0.0194637589,
0.0062590744,
0.0231230929,
-0.0332658179,
0.0072939089,
0.0098853065,
0.0135408463,
-0.0173381921,
0.0096828705,
-0.0151301865,
0.0603580438,
-0.0222476814,
0.0622362532,
-0.0237056892,
-0.0162693374,
0.0482933931,
0.0211335309,
0.0453831442,
0.0002720305,
0.0148540633,
0.0652323067,
0.0531170405,
0.0080014132,
-0.0614773519,
0.0094251744,
0.0609146282,
0.0575132258,
-0.0120484335,
-0.0347237028,
-0.0323365666,
-0.033287093,
0.0381928161,
-0.0395949595,
-0.0121669108,
0.0056428565,
-0.0401277952,
-0.053131599,
0.0236659367,
-0.0738980323,
0.0888385698,
0.0024513595,
0.0148118678,
0.0745576024,
0.0225019306,
-0.0217671972,
0.0247645285,
0.0080152815,
-0.026855072,
0.0151440147,
0.019300336,
0.0092432396,
-0.0224327724,
-0.051543396,
0.0173541307,
-0.0097113363,
-0.0235780329,
0.023679547,
-0.0094482508,
0.0489608385,
0.0376182124,
0.0334413648,
-0.0400420241,
0.0223127548,
-0.0175368488,
0.0485926382,
0.0044302237,
-0.0104644736,
0.0230462439,
0.017901063,
-0.0216066893,
0.04007769,
-0.0234771818,
-0.0161350947,
-0.0619477443,
0.0287515763,
0.013557666,
-0.0510133728,
-0.0188528616,
-0.0580781512,
0.0107646314,
-0.0334974751,
0.0297146663,
-0.0555341765,
0.0061815968,
-0.0410505272,
0.0338375717,
-0.0601125471,
0.0474547036,
0.0310323462,
-0.0242650136,
-0.0494108163,
0.0520545207,
0.0265064109,
0.0264477991,
-0.016535867,
0.0229625888,
0.0671959221,
-0.001242468,
0.0213684514,
0.0374086089,
0.007872765,
0.0126228333,
0.0231166277,
0.0452651791,
-0.0875544846,
-0.064261131,
-0.066238381,
-0.0167093091,
0.0009519199,
0.0078914855,
0.0183852557,
0.060320247,
0.0132750366,
0.0404367968,
-0.0452080369,
-0.0140119987,
0.0669820011,
0.0157965124,
0.0548334345,
0.0030764171,
0.0177520774,
-0.012697706,
-0.0033650114,
0.0015168756,
0.0267815962,
0.0009831265,
-0.0134461252,
-0.0587538183,
0.050837215,
-0.0226832032,
-0.0543642044,
0.0168732982,
-0.0621595383,
-0.0138896899,
-0.0025395036,
0.0937866271,
-0.0394315757,
0.0088144122,
-0.0491020046,
-0.0000869684,
-0.0319580398,
0.011575276,
-0.0377448127,
0.0484824367,
0.0117470641,
0.039258115,
-0.0333125554,
0.0518866293,
0.0209970996,
0.0060974392,
-0.0178869534,
-0.0641120896,
-0.0123617454,
-0.0590987876,
0.0164725818,
0.0038291996,
-0.0066038491,
-0.0305770356,
0.0929825976,
-0.0043343003,
-0.0401777588,
0.0518376604,
-0.0275023989,
-0.0068063391,
-0.0797891915,
0.0163265187,
-0.0665776134,
-0.0161022246,
-0.0568442568,
0.026242232,
-0.0196693651,
-0.0387671143,
-0.0795838311,
0.0033112038,
-0.0090382909,
-0.0018911802,
0.0184333324,
-0.0701952875,
0.0256531835,
-0.0298642647,
-0.0332445987,
-0.0187998861,
-0.0499369688,
0.0073677213,
-0.0114204818,
0.0835515559,
-0.0031239029,
0.094583042,
0.0193038061,
-0.0189420097,
-0.010860024,
-0.0371011235,
-0.0003081552,
0.0202958845,
0.0553648397,
0.0460473411,
-0.0188849233,
-0.0079276562,
0.0030087086,
0.0308921728,
-0.031838689,
0.0198040698,
0.0099819377,
0.0050952355,
0.0162333995,
0.0156523231,
-0.0225764662,
-0.0692356378,
0.0322470553,
0.045170527,
0.0195914339,
0.0015164823,
0.0622862428,
0.0554056056,
-0.0164071359,
-0.0072055282,
-0.0856740102,
0.0392970666,
0.0131652681,
0.049819164,
-0.0829067826,
0.0197339803,
0.0138128744,
-0.0342549942,
-0.0363182761,
0.0008588671,
-0.040798448,
-0.1079798341,
-0.0244737603,
0.0150310565,
-0.023182597,
-0.014653055,
0.0496440642,
-0.0610751063,
0.0779183879,
-0.0391141064,
0.0422495306,
-0.0372135639,
-0.0103235794,
0.0339960717,
-0.0365588218,
-0.0170708355,
-0.0375222303,
-0.0016831623,
0.0084643317,
0.0592938364,
-0.0052053099,
-0.0168653,
-0.0248364285,
0.0123185264,
-0.0345683843,
-0.0149094891,
-0.0344407521,
-0.0065536276,
-0.0249893516,
-0.0059074126,
-0.0051634805,
0.0307628158,
-0.0114225633,
-0.0362196192,
0.0204894058,
0.0458676368,
0.0162203517,
-0.0066890195,
-0.0215393454,
-0.0069901454,
0.0065082302,
-0.0089923674,
0.0425922126,
-0.0344470963,
-0.0104702767,
-0.0225380156,
0.0137391491,
-0.0635888427,
0.0262102857,
0.0339701362,
-0.0036499673,
-0.033236336,
-0.0528497323,
-0.0774886236,
0.0425448045,
0.0230087731,
0.0284660831,
0.0451386273,
-0.013370215,
-0.0128923543,
-0.0371271223,
-0.055774238,
0.0082644941,
0.0454203375,
-0.0809199139,
-0.0148140164,
-0.0236192197,
-0.03828834,
0.0099971443,
-0.0484744981,
-0.0380703025,
-0.0560217202,
-0.0127525693,
0.0168007165,
0.0148359938,
-0.0381339565,
-0.0276815612,
-0.0621673465,
-0.0404295251,
-0.0251313243,
-0.0374961719,
-0.0064593363,
0.0084416028,
0.0125298062,
0.012879258,
0.022653209,
-0.0638087839,
-0.0643212125,
-0.0403176248,
0.0022278556,
-0.0094134174,
0.0376672484,
0.0421725176,
0.0219428148,
-0.038570039,
-0.1027160287,
-0.0123074576,
-0.019039439,
-0.000912324,
-0.0399336107,
-0.043805737,
-0.0407996401,
-0.0238206889,
0.011345109,
0.0240645278,
-0.007746065,
0.013747571,
-0.0354302935,
0.0195001382,
0.0654602423,
0.0659190416,
0.0596647859,
0.0906240717,
0.0152876107,
0.0060268715,
-0.025505336,
-0.0049652238,
-0.0338286459,
0.0154773826,
-0.0095310342,
0.0298577454,
-0.0092242518,
0.0211052373,
0.0498218648,
0.0295334216,
0.0471244492,
0.0066220099,
0.0130366664,
-0.005824313,
0.0548497066,
0.0262135211,
0.0752007738,
0.0036738885,
0.0070991437,
-0.0033661805,
0.0524407141,
-0.000896404,
-0.0232325159,
0.0305266641,
-0.0032293124,
-0.0386611819,
-0.0550756343,
0.1063748077,
-0.0101665119,
-0.040502511,
-0.0165707096,
0.0133380806,
-0.023984272,
0.0236545522,
0.0410815217,
0.0487341322,
0.0379568823,
0.0002996669,
-0.075677976,
-0.041178897,
0.0148285236,
0.0000841561,
0.0383071043,
-0.0018660845,
0.0201915689,
0.0349939615,
0.0187084768,
0.0176570937,
-0.0591201112,
0.013958225,
0.0389986448,
-0.0366490521,
0.0300922263,
-5.779012347e-33,
-0.0212684944,
-0.0328902043,
-0.0197604448,
-0.0251918938,
0.0033710666,
0.0103176581,
-0.0302658901,
0.0006775805,
0.0469450131,
-0.0158760957,
0.0025094869,
-0.0003215175,
-0.0040048771,
0.0094118528,
0.0587221943,
0.003765353,
0.0094485916,
0.035898339,
0.011467671,
-0.0098054651,
0.0287687462,
-0.0069327098,
-0.0026018836,
0.0291474089,
0.0567696765,
-0.0478943214,
-0.0173475463,
-0.0296255667,
-0.0019559006,
0.0282342322,
-0.0224918779,
0.0096858693,
0.0375822484,
0.0567072183,
-0.0281167161,
0.0019589507,
0.0022423044,
-0.0095132617,
0.0448689237,
0.0311371516,
-0.0161927976,
-0.0651566163,
0.0241921078,
-0.0289819539,
-0.0187016595,
0.0187477972,
0.0189616792,
0.0294004586,
0.0122555606,
-0.0436061099,
-0.0848797634,
0.0632605329,
-0.0169839151,
0.0278768353,
-0.0237029027,
0.0481908768,
0.0023684092,
0.0297295935,
-0.0225113537,
-0.0045882203,
-0.0138819078,
0.0542190149,
0.0556521341,
0.0195246525,
-0.0482011065,
0.0155910589,
0.0342754833,
-0.0398717299,
0.0184938014,
0.0835636556,
-0.0100488998,
-0.0020334464,
0.0076452917,
0.0819776654,
0.025804244,
-0.0605001934,
-0.0222643446,
0.0438427553,
-0.0287652146,
-0.0227383692,
-0.0345865116,
0.0107913744,
-0.0163330771,
-0.0596039668,
0.0425852165,
0.0042367713,
-0.0216958486,
-0.0578245595,
0.0602555461,
-0.0451988503,
-0.0092292279,
0.001846993,
0.0046495604,
-0.0105895484,
0.0075325822,
-0.0169364549,
-0.0344945975,
0.0343667716,
-0.0169043709,
0.0976306647,
-0.0115283616,
-0.0436988212,
0.0187969487,
0.013545067,
0.020354718,
-0.0000396316,
0.0349861197,
-0.0021338256,
-0.0637512356,
-0.002478472,
-0.0121678868,
0.0729795843,
0.0184130911,
0.0278696902,
-0.013061964,
0.0070418995,
0.0051603043,
-0.0258061048,
0.0262773428,
0.005087324,
-0.0581718162,
-0.0398302861,
0.0066380124,
0.0395878591,
-0.0034271148,
0.0198885817,
-0.0382125676,
0.0126593849,
0.0337638631,
-0.0020402924,
-0.0143436957,
0.0142444782,
2.651e-7,
0.0174854267,
0.0348610096,
0.0169065446,
-0.0336259045,
-0.0288140476,
-0.022086801,
-0.0522781834,
0.0030870854,
-0.0021459709,
0.0495494418,
-0.0325611383,
-0.0302924309,
0.0536797568,
0.0380806625,
-0.0462425239,
0.0042962558,
-0.0175204128,
0.0011936558,
-0.0732718408,
0.0063195131,
0.0440949649,
0.0093166493,
0.0031324918,
0.0267993696,
-0.0223012026,
0.008116385,
0.0418376103,
0.0456612743,
0.006251249,
0.0162880719,
-0.0451875143,
-0.0058610127,
0.0016554216,
-0.0061433278,
-0.0258110519,
0.0054194415,
0.0441975333,
0.0301232468,
-0.0247632507,
0.0091621056,
0.0636498332,
-0.0170725156,
-0.0389683768,
-0.076817587,
0.0559573658,
0.0725646764,
-0.0109401029,
0.0249888562,
-0.0123349987,
-0.0269424729,
0.0159114767,
-0.0419196971,
-0.0496460572,
0.0253809411,
-0.0072671529,
-0.0562724955,
0.0003839827,
0.0053073782,
-0.0678102747,
0.011433091,
-0.0064683524,
-0.0443344191,
-0.0410240702,
0.0528029017,
0.0262683667,
-0.0177203491,
0.0023912939,
2.333102132e-34,
0.0583945476,
-0.0007860714,
0.0347834602,
0.0041641966,
0.0321405046,
-0.0152723081,
-0.0068295407,
0.0570650138,
0.0157715119,
-0.0051337914,
-0.0445731767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10723v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10723v1 | Large Language Models in Finance: A Survey | 2023-09-28T06:04:04 | 2023-09-28T06:04:04 | Yinheng Li, Shaofei Wang, Han Ding, Hang Chen | q-fin.GN | q-fin.GN, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have opened new possibilities
for artificial intelligence applications in finance. In this paper, we provide
a practical survey focused on two key aspects of utilizing LLMs for financial
tasks: existing solutions and guidance for adoption.
First, we review current approaches employing LLMs in finance, including
leveraging pretrained models via zero-shot or few-shot learning, fine-tuning on
domain-specific data, and training custom LLMs from scratch. We summarize key
models and evaluate their performance improvements on financial natural
language processing tasks.
Second, we propose a decision framework to guide financial professionals in
selecting the appropriate LLM solution based on their use case constraints
around data, compute, and performance needs. The framework provides a pathway
from lightweight experimentation to heavy investment in customized LLMs.
Lastly, we discuss limitations and challenges around leveraging LLMs in
financial applications. Overall, this survey aims to synthesize the
state-of-the-art and provide a roadmap for responsibly applying LLMs to advance
financial AI. | [
0.0146952467,
0.0698134825,
0.0032017352,
0.0184597205,
-0.0071377973,
0.0234219134,
0.0577819347,
0.0444641635,
-0.0028476489,
-0.0507287495,
-0.0505674072,
-0.04868754,
-0.0239451826,
0.044611454,
0.0411778614,
-0.0150565933,
0.0039814916,
-0.0267586168,
0.0450711064,
-0.0144851711,
0.0135679031,
0.0024339212,
0.0161110461,
0.0161605645,
0.0017821561,
-0.0224827845,
0.0009919691,
-0.0375732444,
-0.0181479231,
-0.002795103,
-0.0134067591,
0.014046615,
0.0310858469,
0.0736005232,
0.0000021264,
-0.0645739734,
-0.0188761726,
0.0121985218,
-0.0464175642,
0.0197418295,
0.0226479489,
-0.0513712205,
0.0354790762,
-0.0128651112,
-0.0562732108,
0.0114346771,
0.0644106492,
0.0565249175,
0.0565913022,
0.0965028033,
-0.0083124712,
-0.0758445635,
0.0227349009,
-0.076502949,
-0.0177283064,
-0.0878757834,
0.0364201963,
0.0200360324,
-0.0129498541,
-0.0130532309,
-0.0428238101,
0.036516089,
0.0048415614,
0.0029658207,
0.0205618758,
0.0099056289,
-0.0250962824,
-0.0005380256,
-0.0452934168,
0.0571334176,
-0.0105106821,
0.0483815372,
0.0174960047,
-0.0444704704,
-0.0315125063,
0.0081317443,
-0.0474491976,
0.0561051145,
0.0322722569,
-0.0046532885,
0.004484775,
-0.0055760923,
0.027522454,
0.0158079006,
-0.066094175,
0.0141488193,
-0.0065440154,
-0.0253940504,
0.0463293828,
0.0091865733,
-0.0182944778,
-0.04159097,
-0.0017015608,
0.0074688648,
0.0256564636,
0.0099305594,
-0.0065864869,
-0.0455687456,
-0.0171258226,
-0.0691811368,
0.054885,
0.0263301022,
0.0079881195,
0.075566791,
-0.061299257,
0.0456830263,
-0.0095558297,
-0.0604609214,
0.0124756042,
0.0012705665,
-0.0523501933,
-0.0098961703,
-0.0522314422,
0.092278704,
-0.0305085927,
-0.0687823147,
-0.0698015913,
-0.0242151096,
-0.0026227213,
0.0244837683,
0.0246362891,
-0.028427707,
-0.0004746666,
-0.0480195805,
-0.0170259941,
0.0119674355,
-0.0268462319,
0.0264902394,
-0.0286361855,
-0.0230396371,
0.0206241421,
0.0347429588,
-0.0444479659,
-0.0316083357,
0.0267450009,
0.073125571,
0.0586620942,
-0.0403139293,
-0.0425302833,
-0.0333559811,
-0.0127203045,
-0.0416753367,
-0.0327610709,
-0.0323649868,
0.0057407692,
-0.0187322535,
0.0013058619,
-0.0190295707,
0.0141314389,
-0.0093233744,
-0.02076713,
0.0925267041,
0.0149252461,
-0.0168383587,
-0.0045558177,
-0.059530884,
0.0262246523,
0.070739992,
0.012641252,
0.0287377927,
0.0232568774,
-0.0095576886,
-0.00707372,
0.0684332401,
-0.0042371806,
-0.0654790848,
-0.0270041022,
0.0133223226,
-0.0074664769,
-0.0091654006,
0.0543573312,
0.0259221271,
-0.0277686529,
0.0001658736,
0.0635318905,
0.0562144592,
0.066779606,
0.0123819076,
0.0158681441,
0.0485081784,
0.0237825383,
-0.0528245457,
0.0200882517,
-0.004558898,
-0.0191464555,
0.0186333656,
-0.0201031063,
0.0237732623,
-0.0296234488,
-0.019055346,
-0.008429369,
-0.041083809,
-0.0264932271,
0.015557847,
0.0562555119,
-0.0414500572,
-0.0341365337,
0.0450633429,
0.0372145809,
0.0029571552,
-0.0100013064,
-0.0306913275,
0.0367678367,
0.0833851174,
0.0293205138,
-0.0203713495,
0.0096839843,
-0.0311824847,
-0.0169443116,
0.0638386682,
0.0312854759,
0.0143700317,
-0.0260880608,
-0.0603352934,
0.0033746513,
0.0228878148,
0.0136163263,
0.0218970962,
-0.0076083997,
-0.0012489773,
0.0172351543,
-0.0020791744,
-0.0246340223,
0.0126895467,
-0.0046518017,
-0.0621874221,
0.0271841548,
-0.0215107948,
-0.0007513218,
0.0274553411,
-0.0191735364,
0.0043623401,
0.002803094,
-0.0077971942,
-0.0253090672,
-0.0150192659,
-0.0470255576,
0.0043840148,
0.0072653745,
0.0196864549,
0.0078483392,
-0.0192925911,
-0.0429856926,
-0.0175130498,
-0.0282134134,
-0.0160540007,
-0.0022364925,
-0.0643569231,
0.0053701536,
0.0176427793,
0.0310131554,
-0.0187830366,
0.0583837219,
0.0057838736,
0.0087111415,
-0.0134794777,
0.012815156,
-0.0021457809,
-0.0294945985,
0.0336489901,
-0.0133718336,
-0.0181008261,
0.0329597592,
0.0266786627,
0.00608757,
0.0129224239,
-0.0219519194,
-0.058574561,
-0.02183979,
-0.0089967065,
0.0267811138,
-0.0206767637,
0.0113416528,
-0.0146627128,
-0.0237966906,
-0.0143308928,
0.0094880387,
-0.0043966174,
-0.0240411665,
0.0474594943,
-0.001571557,
-0.0285547096,
-0.0472358055,
-0.0119609991,
0.0061209998,
0.0435354225,
0.0085114995,
-0.038862519,
-0.0122144166,
-0.0089311125,
0.0004751942,
0.0158394203,
-0.0012786111,
0.044390697,
-0.0038446011,
-0.0344700143,
0.0191781595,
0.0531517267,
0.0085589942,
0.0572716035,
-0.0545818061,
-0.0172259845,
-0.044954706,
0.0209492873,
0.0047388398,
-0.0103129717,
-0.0425174609,
0.0307358783,
0.0200314242,
0.0673494861,
-0.0311666001,
0.0006926147,
-0.0644880012,
0.0589236058,
-0.0008111632,
0.0049828887,
-0.0303450599,
0.0101799853,
-0.0148524074,
0.0386585481,
0.0165008008,
-0.0111888861,
0.0518208332,
-0.011910161,
-0.0184421316,
-0.014974134,
-0.0348002613,
-0.0900446996,
0.0493737571,
-0.0218266211,
0.0111792861,
0.0053153546,
-0.0347934067,
-0.006152025,
-0.0246813614,
0.0152925728,
0.0058770156,
0.0480048656,
-0.0324260034,
0.0500311628,
-0.0009281996,
-0.0081066275,
0.014073886,
-0.0944422483,
-0.0602422208,
0.0205677282,
0.029323576,
-0.0522205159,
-0.041441299,
0.0366632156,
-0.0277062468,
-0.008370419,
0.0067357533,
-0.000442466,
-0.005166159,
0.0190092139,
0.0906454027,
-0.0021275706,
0.0372150689,
-0.0316097997,
0.0786451623,
-0.0098378528,
0.0204805806,
0.0204058904,
-0.0173347518,
-0.0230581295,
0.0020200966,
-0.0698200315,
-0.0146891093,
0.0224369802,
-0.0322409272,
-0.0831783935,
0.0067469869,
0.1228221431,
0.0054035508,
0.0093488218,
0.0063013169,
0.0038472349,
-0.0129319038,
-0.0302935634,
0.0437470451,
-0.108537443,
-0.0386614315,
-0.0239640176,
-0.0132355439,
0.0319761559,
-0.0390963331,
-0.0063691298,
-0.1465723366,
0.0500717908,
-0.0113716116,
0.017843321,
-0.0168269798,
-0.0082723787,
-0.030012561,
-0.0524283126,
0.0269450936,
0.0261008758,
-0.0222991034,
0.0012601204,
0.0039102947,
-0.053492412,
-0.028360201,
0.0153496303,
-0.0260782763,
-0.0219375119,
0.0455495939,
-0.0046063312,
-0.0095260488,
0.0215163119,
-0.0445491299,
0.0096380496,
0.000849346,
-0.0114106117,
0.0167742297,
-0.010373055,
-0.0363265239,
0.0084461588,
0.0381892659,
-0.0095980773,
0.0435822867,
0.0019966855,
-0.0003441253,
-0.0396750085,
-0.0300300196,
0.0124918446,
0.0266982708,
-0.0317883641,
0.0636275411,
0.0252333488,
-0.0682016239,
-0.036404483,
-0.0114954272,
-0.0159355048,
-0.0574544258,
-0.01480038,
-0.0165623091,
0.0192397144,
-0.0023706304,
-0.0853954032,
-0.0537107177,
0.0384601541,
0.0171092413,
0.0054619997,
0.0262578186,
0.0704250857,
-0.0257431734,
-0.0414374769,
0.0221265685,
-0.0809693784,
0.0310045648,
-0.0557551421,
0.0572123453,
0.0337295681,
-0.0123649864,
-0.0493938923,
0.0339827314,
-0.073921524,
-0.0353681557,
-0.0014834886,
0.0199647322,
0.0124408938,
-0.0183713194,
-0.023539193,
-0.0137550794,
0.0397730544,
0.0473774187,
-0.0542771928,
-0.0126125365,
0.0344473124,
0.0024264564,
-0.0258133765,
0.0435574688,
-0.0155254938,
0.0346111692,
-0.0308224838,
0.0258878246,
-0.0508075766,
0.0020175169,
-0.0148710944,
0.0162174068,
0.0289607998,
0.0065592858,
-0.0138523178,
-0.01101356,
-0.0166600496,
-0.0144378124,
0.0065462482,
-0.0179801639,
-0.0429386757,
0.0477152728,
-0.013785651,
-0.0208365563,
0.023865018,
-0.0019130305,
-0.0299786609,
-0.0082386807,
0.0353004187,
-0.0138440197,
-0.0114709027,
0.0284992401,
-0.0363481008,
0.0388483033,
0.0344743393,
0.0489828773,
0.0057543223,
-0.0065124324,
0.0169556662,
0.003294033,
0.0161700696,
-0.0429687463,
-0.0363426507,
0.0153914038,
-0.0399221219,
0.0002257491,
0.0452877134,
0.0448038466,
-0.0390830301,
-0.0064230505,
-0.0495203696,
0.0057393564,
0.0005106583,
-0.0024618199,
0.0078155473,
-0.0265654698,
0.0157424118,
0.0114697069,
-0.0586802848,
-0.0097626988,
0.1091200635,
0.0412661843,
0.0300416015,
-0.0330802985,
0.0164066032,
-0.0573841445,
-0.0494264476,
0.0425202958,
0.0207882002,
-0.0282055456,
0.0286832806,
-0.0850840062,
-0.0325788446,
0.0215917137,
-0.0274686534,
-0.0057626059,
-0.0178437997,
0.036850445,
0.0378944799,
-0.0115293739,
0.0447234064,
-0.0069495249,
0.0208463985,
-0.0104860431,
-0.0259723756,
-0.0700126365,
-6.139888378e-33,
-0.0302689094,
-0.0097161476,
0.0559172332,
0.0028159285,
0.0173075236,
0.0127323,
-0.0018383124,
-0.0230797101,
0.0099473679,
-0.0035937205,
0.017317662,
0.025659116,
0.0164724533,
0.0241914615,
0.0174055286,
0.0232526734,
0.0478802472,
-0.0402448401,
0.0008340969,
-0.0323714837,
0.0055250493,
0.0615941249,
0.0483310036,
-0.0342776403,
0.00824307,
0.0099959103,
-0.0391401984,
-0.0029358689,
0.0397137962,
0.045969937,
-0.0178726483,
0.0250349101,
0.0146288434,
-0.092627205,
-0.0225672014,
0.0176037271,
-0.0177894421,
-0.0118691782,
0.0213160478,
0.0351682268,
0.0291532781,
-0.020120129,
0.0434691124,
-0.0163281672,
-0.0227587949,
0.0221007988,
0.0033421079,
-0.0118645029,
0.0181483869,
-0.0331314988,
-0.1001962721,
0.0460075364,
0.0094423452,
0.0184361171,
0.0662891343,
0.0303328726,
-0.0112568615,
0.0359866023,
-0.0172429103,
0.0141029498,
0.0082741072,
0.0206803959,
0.0389179215,
0.0147767831,
-0.0127322869,
0.0525794327,
0.0020803448,
-0.0121289995,
-0.0111059686,
0.0235314816,
0.0286678169,
0.0779573694,
0.0374464095,
0.0433198474,
0.0218403786,
-0.0151988212,
-0.0430206507,
-0.0083251279,
0.0094160503,
0.0449792594,
0.0273016859,
0.0255205315,
-0.037014164,
-0.0391885005,
-0.0242489446,
0.0173596181,
-0.0188177321,
0.0029568607,
0.0096029155,
0.0234510023,
-0.0069857431,
0.0441655293,
0.0334473029,
-0.04964545,
-0.0539751276,
-0.0025231484,
0.0134057477,
0.0143873179,
-0.0021216942,
0.0104334904,
-0.0612611137,
-0.0576669239,
-0.0031383322,
-0.0142295994,
-0.017749846,
-0.0276990216,
0.0359790809,
0.0000751881,
-0.0509022996,
-0.0275650397,
0.0142506175,
0.0045282361,
0.0291826166,
0.06194501,
0.0273501724,
0.042015329,
-0.0104558645,
0.04232632,
0.0166566707,
-0.0308291614,
0.0262481812,
-0.0157325361,
0.0116339466,
0.0369404182,
0.0241021905,
0.0227777939,
0.0064973314,
0.0393962003,
0.0422705933,
-0.0151249142,
-0.0288688242,
0.0554476753,
2.764e-7,
0.0472470969,
0.096374765,
0.0069674342,
0.0168022607,
0.0173530728,
0.0430393703,
-0.0194744747,
-0.0181257073,
-0.0222979635,
0.0235512815,
0.0312391296,
0.0341962837,
0.0774472803,
-0.0329184979,
-0.075049825,
-0.0377634056,
-0.0481447838,
0.0199947339,
-0.1105559766,
0.0123146251,
0.0108908108,
0.1073099077,
-0.0173637681,
-0.0499915965,
0.0157582685,
-0.0871400163,
0.0619856603,
-0.0279091243,
-0.0490727909,
0.0294847451,
-0.0157036763,
0.0396303385,
-0.0097739296,
0.032741636,
0.0170119293,
0.0476837941,
0.0281081628,
0.0558404736,
0.0139989834,
0.0248810723,
0.0108464528,
0.0130486721,
-0.0286211185,
-0.0211017858,
0.0459991731,
-0.0888688564,
-0.0416501611,
-0.053023506,
-0.0369611569,
0.0107563101,
0.0291633178,
-0.0042690728,
0.0027851972,
0.0062629594,
0.0215179976,
-0.0305759404,
0.0083416849,
-0.0383528396,
-0.0107926372,
0.025753513,
-0.0392263122,
0.0443400703,
-0.046524033,
-0.0050543854,
0.0348382406,
-0.0564888194,
0.0085168397,
2.420628247e-34,
0.0652730241,
-0.030201925,
-0.0373074561,
0.0708830804,
0.0667586476,
0.0285815392,
-0.0630362704,
0.0709526315,
-0.0009945654,
-0.1208459958,
0.0082444474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.01427v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.01427v1 | Attention Sorting Combats Recency Bias In Long Context Language Models | 2023-09-28T05:19:06 | 2023-09-28T05:19:06 | Alexander Peysakhovich, Adam Lerer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Current language models often fail to incorporate long contexts efficiently
during generation. We show that a major contributor to this issue are attention
priors that are likely learned during pre-training: relevant information
located earlier in context is attended to less on average. Yet even when models
fail to use the information from a relevant document in their response, they
still pay preferential attention to that document compared to an irrelevant
document at the same position. We leverage this fact to introduce ``attention
sorting'': perform one step of decoding, sort documents by the attention they
receive (highest attention going last), repeat the process, generate the answer
with the newly sorted context. We find that attention sorting improves
performance of long context models. Our findings highlight some challenges in
using off-the-shelf language models for retrieval augmented generation. | [
0.0372645482,
0.0408084802,
0.0068043922,
0.0304521304,
0.0139367785,
0.0078025959,
-0.004812689,
-0.0214937758,
-0.0337095894,
-0.0612141378,
0.007262181,
-0.0556802154,
0.0053635682,
0.0095131006,
0.0187552329,
-0.0430227071,
0.02918428,
-0.0246142969,
0.0242452044,
0.0146760419,
-0.0087473998,
-0.0169840883,
0.0103102187,
0.0431935042,
0.0026343823,
-0.0069058063,
-0.0147345457,
0.034985777,
-0.0097449357,
-0.0170816947,
0.016409602,
0.0502031446,
0.0240945127,
0.0356295817,
0.0000017554,
-0.0437423997,
-0.0380125232,
-0.0131834587,
0.0023743128,
0.0130986003,
0.0567447841,
0.0220872555,
-0.0148264794,
0.0172861479,
-0.0478015766,
-0.0043175607,
0.0377074033,
0.033653643,
0.0462884419,
0.0503275059,
0.0008561207,
0.0068384549,
0.0273684096,
-0.0602989495,
0.0587899052,
-0.0444390997,
-0.0096377041,
-0.0115325889,
0.0079231551,
0.0467535406,
-0.0034744954,
0.0415732451,
0.0402013175,
0.0199501123,
0.024003977,
0.0546287224,
-0.0100756092,
0.0152235944,
-0.0068827057,
0.0593054332,
-0.0032557698,
-0.0287714116,
-0.0147194434,
0.0058668582,
0.0278658587,
-0.0213497933,
-0.0611231327,
0.0622024313,
-0.0041861143,
-0.0007431212,
0.0732472092,
0.0154970875,
0.0126258414,
0.0122460481,
-0.0443949141,
0.0491275042,
0.0240323991,
-0.0399109535,
-0.0352054723,
0.0109936977,
0.000388234,
-0.0344005264,
0.0048176162,
0.0334227756,
0.0323003381,
0.0202818885,
-0.0440179743,
-0.0327495411,
0.0206068661,
-0.0315366201,
-0.0036770955,
0.0227794945,
-0.0400679745,
0.0225749593,
-0.0457122587,
0.0355477557,
-0.004075814,
-0.0307295937,
-0.0557877943,
0.0122402636,
-0.0012586619,
-0.0311073586,
-0.04704611,
0.0134828603,
-0.0519615524,
-0.0270903073,
-0.0292136632,
0.0294990782,
0.0101390621,
-0.0631735995,
0.0041717901,
0.0359444879,
-0.0536607802,
-0.0062496206,
0.0149380974,
0.0158300456,
-0.0350016393,
0.0136170555,
0.0295333304,
-0.0692887008,
-0.0271641091,
0.0167142749,
0.0066151624,
-0.0304397307,
-0.0322885625,
0.0311645027,
-0.0222593825,
-0.0405433178,
-0.0325357914,
-0.0534527712,
-0.0277325734,
-0.0221912377,
0.0133652687,
-0.0636696219,
0.0114603369,
0.0281877331,
-0.0049724625,
-0.0240147244,
-0.006327989,
0.0272408687,
-0.0478265025,
0.0139824292,
0.0381812714,
0.0331094153,
0.03838652,
0.0214528851,
0.0366889797,
0.0433244631,
0.0264679734,
0.0148115307,
0.0110645099,
0.0112727117,
0.0126000848,
0.0042940197,
0.0149214426,
0.0134787811,
-0.0100079849,
-0.0078313835,
-0.0140011841,
0.0075894403,
0.0734741911,
0.0327793546,
-0.05651116,
0.0023133792,
0.0362121761,
0.0113352342,
0.037491776,
-0.013707133,
0.0387343802,
-0.0038559705,
-0.0495556518,
0.0542878322,
-0.0526257493,
0.04915829,
-0.0154336039,
0.0278827138,
0.0574080497,
0.031608358,
-0.0297802351,
-0.0150774056,
0.0095752589,
-0.0029955546,
0.0141600585,
-0.003441019,
0.0188808274,
0.0518246591,
-0.0589202978,
0.0491984747,
-0.0008498143,
-0.0922936872,
0.0153546305,
-0.0491802134,
0.0266647451,
0.0607491918,
0.0593290254,
0.0033657467,
-0.0234866999,
0.0354613662,
0.0289517716,
0.025628807,
0.0306343567,
0.0200025216,
0.0092559075,
-0.0390401483,
-0.0175385922,
-0.0246552508,
0.0297320802,
0.0163870826,
0.0362068377,
0.0123653291,
0.0619091094,
-0.024803305,
-0.0139439097,
0.024561014,
-0.0409920029,
-0.0628420562,
-0.0293924231,
0.0082953302,
-0.0079740994,
-0.0095108561,
0.0061829174,
0.0615029074,
0.0387269668,
-0.0347439386,
0.0316588059,
0.0257040411,
-0.0864774659,
-0.0226311013,
-0.0010481623,
-0.013037744,
0.0278072692,
0.000665154,
-0.0116921691,
-0.0448096544,
0.0400685593,
-0.0116920611,
0.0875208229,
-0.0300352238,
0.0241439324,
0.0389549956,
0.0191844348,
-0.0492238216,
0.082439445,
-0.0219316706,
0.0141723789,
0.0665484145,
0.0421792828,
-0.0246574301,
-0.0671137199,
0.0180042908,
0.0139969261,
-0.0064492864,
-0.0121884216,
0.0459121987,
0.0079713902,
-0.0449567772,
-0.0279912725,
-0.0818483829,
-0.0251521561,
-0.0248892773,
-0.0006752657,
0.0343687832,
0.0290977918,
-0.0060161217,
-0.0002534315,
-0.0410635509,
-0.0064716828,
0.0096704578,
0.0571441948,
-0.0143486382,
0.0141162397,
0.0180109628,
-0.0701628178,
-0.0280694906,
0.0162550248,
0.0474164374,
0.0123566221,
-0.0032938595,
-0.0640707761,
0.0641963556,
-0.0325956978,
-0.0040825047,
-0.017220147,
-0.016246045,
0.0227269605,
-0.0456111804,
0.0737802759,
0.0732371733,
0.0299050864,
0.022383621,
0.0403376669,
-0.029859351,
-0.0597879216,
0.002222714,
-0.0356292017,
-0.0347435512,
0.0122877872,
-0.0495070368,
0.0006602619,
0.0691201463,
0.013805856,
0.0040840353,
-0.0463059619,
-0.0007186704,
-0.0326948613,
-0.0464133844,
-0.0302174203,
-0.033943966,
-0.0184548553,
0.0205723494,
-0.0398408547,
-0.0384259336,
0.0689787939,
-0.0158985648,
0.0073868781,
-0.03911753,
0.0414419547,
-0.0417732894,
0.0376288295,
0.0098070391,
0.0283549316,
-0.0421949849,
-0.0254203547,
-0.06052953,
0.0204381086,
0.0015232577,
-0.0427170545,
0.0527867898,
-0.0261035897,
0.0073712859,
-0.0217761956,
-0.0227189194,
-0.0639402047,
-0.0319334082,
0.0100121545,
-0.0070295641,
0.0197285432,
-0.0055667395,
-0.0274655633,
0.0173143893,
0.0626634359,
0.0473745987,
-0.0373151638,
-0.0048797471,
0.0035389552,
0.0828797668,
0.0565956458,
-0.0180614069,
0.0439834371,
-0.0488091744,
-0.0143929347,
0.0784237459,
0.0834703296,
-0.0127951149,
-0.0102495831,
-0.0227672905,
0.0312969759,
-0.0061560371,
-0.0360356569,
0.0259180199,
0.0321856886,
-0.0669981316,
-0.0415373072,
0.0883439034,
0.0338978469,
-0.0527352281,
0.0050696475,
-0.0259888507,
0.0749298409,
0.0044212192,
0.01282469,
-0.0719358027,
-0.0335016847,
0.0148245944,
0.0430617332,
0.0071399859,
-0.0128334099,
-0.0263751913,
-0.1178888232,
0.0240053926,
0.0499697439,
-0.0578985997,
-0.0058791079,
-0.0252948292,
-0.0123573188,
0.0355860665,
-0.0192152821,
0.091645062,
-0.0190745015,
0.0155458963,
0.015479763,
0.0309257433,
-0.0299406685,
-0.0060701948,
-0.0073944787,
0.0123334583,
0.0653213188,
-0.0059741144,
0.0353754908,
-0.012152384,
0.0224490985,
-0.0650617778,
0.022150021,
-0.0020645014,
0.0144404946,
-0.0389726758,
0.0334468856,
-0.0068412791,
0.023676835,
-0.047599867,
-0.0096658925,
-0.0051192697,
0.0326765031,
-0.0067456658,
-0.0251482818,
-0.0513364375,
0.0073279436,
0.0324222594,
0.0870951638,
0.0582206212,
-0.0168924816,
-0.0329833664,
-0.0491963923,
0.0566702709,
-0.0359399468,
0.0013719422,
-0.0141828209,
0.0252631977,
-0.0309286322,
-0.1067160442,
-0.0645200387,
-0.0202485342,
0.0121996729,
-0.0120439576,
0.0128659112,
-0.0443213657,
-0.0223695971,
-0.0513284542,
0.0358133577,
-0.013022868,
-0.0181389954,
-0.0744224191,
-0.0162170846,
0.0220314059,
-0.0558260642,
0.0017975167,
0.0477621481,
-0.068144761,
-0.0623660162,
0.0254532266,
0.0422817282,
0.0289589744,
0.0226268414,
0.0076647336,
-0.050111901,
-0.00393285,
0.0057576657,
-0.0400806479,
0.0497353114,
0.008966147,
-0.0153758246,
0.0055444757,
0.0238405578,
-0.0775168762,
0.0419788137,
-0.0217482802,
0.0607238747,
-0.0100159263,
-0.0348120593,
0.0243169852,
-0.0227519646,
-0.0022497138,
-0.0268005095,
-0.0032479113,
-0.0429582149,
0.0247212779,
-0.0191536676,
-0.0071673635,
-0.0222209822,
0.0261983406,
0.0025205219,
0.011049333,
0.0229103249,
-0.0021959119,
0.0015297652,
0.0493826158,
-0.0218742695,
-0.0084292833,
-0.0072334404,
0.003776768,
0.0191905703,
0.0110104503,
-0.0277212877,
0.0033247601,
-0.0530929156,
0.0541233383,
-0.0310024787,
0.045106791,
0.0049588238,
-0.0273062289,
-0.0093600703,
0.0323692933,
-0.1017272696,
-0.0155292358,
-0.0163577534,
-0.04831893,
0.0484477058,
-0.0384393483,
0.1118179932,
-0.0196839459,
0.0159419961,
-0.0146061024,
0.0125508318,
0.0363361873,
-0.043295864,
-0.01617104,
0.0345415771,
0.003081722,
0.0286148787,
0.1143817604,
0.0164311957,
0.0126343695,
-0.0066158762,
0.0079805739,
-0.0095732613,
-0.0323912911,
-0.018542476,
0.0429561473,
-0.0132527566,
0.0159902107,
-0.0500289872,
-0.0434411578,
-0.0089198072,
-0.0168063194,
0.0041343304,
-0.0301832277,
0.0479980037,
0.0861872137,
-0.0163203944,
-0.0199970696,
-0.0345313139,
0.0273914374,
-0.0321596973,
-0.0221568774,
-0.0558249913,
-6.249673673e-33,
-0.0368802436,
-0.0192176756,
0.0221960712,
-0.0555765033,
-0.0068647726,
0.0123167355,
-0.0602725111,
0.0016889329,
-0.0131894173,
-0.0254847724,
-0.0100714136,
0.0116466675,
0.0073544537,
0.0225204434,
-0.0124173518,
0.0228825156,
0.0308524258,
0.0145776086,
-0.0411789566,
0.0519045107,
0.0730469972,
0.0221591461,
0.0322381891,
-0.027998602,
-0.0019977991,
-0.0171171054,
0.0263548773,
-0.0126348101,
0.0087148137,
0.0624321029,
-0.0144534679,
0.0251326673,
0.0393959284,
-0.031782005,
-0.0379200056,
0.0443555899,
-0.0688963458,
0.0070246882,
0.000864551,
-0.0461496748,
-0.0418328755,
-0.0541258119,
0.0322557241,
0.0033314906,
-0.0078910971,
-0.0041254456,
0.0181489456,
-0.038687773,
-0.0682959482,
0.0092242919,
-0.0571947247,
0.0152287474,
0.0135469958,
-0.0147325937,
-0.0018204778,
0.0806466714,
-0.0092131337,
0.0510011017,
-0.0570919439,
0.0642048717,
0.0212173145,
0.0789357647,
0.0592219457,
0.0247393195,
-0.013530097,
0.0319933519,
0.0238588471,
0.0007827975,
0.0004490932,
-0.0509500653,
0.0176614318,
0.0202087872,
-0.0010350579,
0.0188619755,
0.046015691,
-0.0145105841,
-0.0329606682,
0.0267806929,
-0.0148011949,
0.045992367,
0.0661811382,
0.0026700222,
-0.0501162186,
-0.0321999975,
-0.0247021988,
0.0126236714,
-0.0402657948,
-0.021330012,
0.0504040644,
0.0558516942,
-0.019489713,
-0.0486463644,
0.0624166094,
-0.0010316405,
0.0068328464,
0.0838847533,
-0.0448437333,
0.0004949928,
-0.0132490899,
0.0328865312,
-0.0591894425,
0.0322201513,
0.0391923711,
-0.0015091425,
-0.0402446203,
0.0213206857,
0.0156181296,
0.012163084,
-0.046253968,
-0.001699832,
-0.0493846387,
0.028390089,
-0.0019947232,
-0.0178073552,
0.0354569927,
0.0081489338,
-0.0096446648,
0.0765767992,
0.0080190469,
0.0136956964,
-0.0366215147,
-0.0508146696,
-0.0047353948,
0.0157041419,
-0.0288174842,
0.0180176664,
-0.0246280376,
0.065006502,
0.0466485806,
-0.0495359972,
-0.0343708284,
0.0277828705,
2.515e-7,
0.0060886,
0.0142960111,
0.0303553585,
-0.0095931562,
0.0445367657,
-0.0001673118,
0.010716293,
0.0412603952,
0.0339991674,
0.0151725356,
-0.0220912062,
0.0385716558,
0.0428430326,
-0.0264911726,
-0.0562610626,
-0.0189015865,
-0.0772247389,
0.0259842016,
-0.0211502593,
-0.0677246004,
0.01551509,
0.0820605829,
-0.042009972,
-0.0027813315,
-0.0072014676,
-0.0343662687,
0.0718904808,
-0.0110196648,
-0.0166097675,
-0.0090021091,
0.0224806573,
0.0113695478,
0.0026063016,
-0.0504832976,
-0.0077929641,
-0.009605418,
0.0101720849,
0.0217968076,
0.0291862581,
-0.0890568569,
0.0186952837,
0.0039600665,
-0.0189699288,
-0.0482903756,
0.0395069122,
-0.0368131436,
0.0108039854,
-0.0106154308,
-0.049016647,
0.0192154087,
-0.0397572517,
-0.0060570906,
-0.0350628197,
-0.0017647219,
0.0045235404,
0.0101912431,
-0.0039508124,
-0.0770894215,
-0.0666459873,
0.0187375378,
-0.0355325192,
-0.0495846048,
-0.0404964387,
-0.0176997241,
0.0063831233,
-0.0413531922,
-0.006868002,
2.481434595e-34,
0.0434519798,
-0.0002242152,
0.0193776544,
0.0224289373,
0.0266324542,
-0.014440407,
0.0059224046,
0.0128516555,
0.0275889747,
-0.0867800117,
-0.0454526097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16175v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16175v1 | Using Weak Supervision and Data Augmentation in Question Answering | 2023-09-28T05:16:51 | 2023-09-28T05:16:51 | Chumki Basu, Himanshu Garg, Allen McIntosh, Sezai Sablak, John R. Wullert II | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The onset of the COVID-19 pandemic accentuated the need for access to
biomedical literature to answer timely and disease-specific questions. During
the early days of the pandemic, one of the biggest challenges we faced was the
lack of peer-reviewed biomedical articles on COVID-19 that could be used to
train machine learning models for question answering (QA). In this paper, we
explore the roles weak supervision and data augmentation play in training deep
neural network QA models. First, we investigate whether labels generated
automatically from the structured abstracts of scholarly papers using an
information retrieval algorithm, BM25, provide a weak supervision signal to
train an extractive QA model. We also curate new QA pairs using information
retrieval techniques, guided by the clinicaltrials.gov schema and the
structured abstracts of articles, in the absence of annotated data from
biomedical domain experts. Furthermore, we explore augmenting the training data
of a deep neural network model with linguistic features from external sources
such as lexical databases to account for variations in word morphology and
meaning. To better utilize our training data, we apply curriculum learning to
domain adaptation, fine-tuning our QA model in stages based on characteristics
of the QA pairs. We evaluate our methods in the context of QA models at the
core of a system to answer questions about COVID-19. | [
0.0565104261,
0.0364020057,
-0.0037139596,
-0.0114034265,
0.002659492,
0.0089023728,
-0.0142838489,
-0.021339085,
-0.0103552658,
-0.0097354669,
-0.0426138788,
-0.0236988869,
-0.0411184877,
0.0138131026,
0.0124450037,
-0.036341805,
0.0597476885,
0.0046391599,
0.036481794,
0.0064136703,
-0.0063257492,
0.0101599349,
-0.0119229686,
0.0165217239,
0.0274129696,
-0.0360555053,
0.0107790101,
-0.0127906725,
0.0270642899,
-0.0418649837,
0.0715950727,
0.0285344645,
0.0388991944,
0.0100327274,
0.0000016278,
-0.055499889,
-0.0266526602,
-0.0035904432,
-0.0196160898,
-0.0118921818,
0.013243814,
-0.0529210418,
0.0356385522,
0.0098601906,
-0.0626355261,
-0.0238711219,
0.030128587,
0.051835563,
0.0536300242,
0.0649071559,
0.0109104253,
-0.0188299399,
0.0497201197,
-0.0197372269,
0.0058720796,
-0.0633926317,
0.0617068596,
0.0261333063,
0.0454461016,
0.0557091758,
0.0033276782,
0.0455301479,
0.0164227244,
-0.0043653236,
0.0282144826,
0.0494031832,
-0.024196025,
-0.0055969907,
-0.0047975006,
0.0914245248,
0.0194585677,
-0.0219243951,
0.0297150686,
0.0025545286,
0.0112495609,
0.0207712036,
-0.0718744248,
-0.0290081855,
0.0019973421,
-0.0089958962,
0.0305487011,
0.0058556199,
0.0381741151,
0.0353711583,
0.0247542709,
0.0454043262,
-0.0123954881,
-0.0642780513,
-0.0020784338,
0.0186263062,
-0.0239270125,
-0.0308037456,
0.0292058289,
0.0636857226,
-0.0206807461,
0.0474980846,
0.0043725292,
-0.0624096692,
0.0675603673,
-0.0342149623,
-0.059059985,
-0.0214769039,
-0.0602204874,
0.0440065525,
0.0038827155,
-0.008458904,
-0.0506452508,
0.0554245077,
-0.0230354629,
-0.0144691849,
-0.055515714,
-0.0611417517,
-0.0157377515,
0.0489588194,
0.0113252765,
0.0114484709,
-0.033284463,
-0.0149859665,
-0.0027248252,
-0.0370228253,
0.0086409776,
0.0719829649,
-0.069385387,
0.0306071732,
-0.0336924978,
0.0384625159,
-0.0604353584,
0.0462179706,
0.0174987577,
-0.028722873,
-0.0209306292,
-0.02752674,
0.057636559,
-0.0130014829,
0.0339096785,
0.0386597179,
-0.0111790737,
-0.0026373074,
0.005049176,
-0.0414361097,
-0.0461275354,
-0.0254087485,
0.0305798594,
-0.0737264529,
0.0433632657,
-0.0116171632,
-0.0213090181,
-0.0447156131,
-0.0044366419,
0.0291982088,
-0.0554099642,
0.0400987081,
-0.0567317605,
0.0007013404,
0.0669042915,
0.0307570845,
0.0253557861,
0.0390741862,
-0.0025404051,
-0.0184478406,
0.0390381068,
0.0110316426,
0.0126768546,
-0.0133228982,
0.0510024577,
-0.0156670567,
0.0375473872,
0.0387401804,
-0.0060612266,
0.0623207018,
-0.0145813702,
0.0426207073,
-0.0104118446,
-0.0299657229,
0.0042907661,
0.0573416539,
-0.0252608992,
-0.0107652433,
0.0295020714,
0.0185021143,
0.0121964961,
0.0169676635,
-0.0010115728,
0.0136634735,
0.0284759961,
-0.0012240022,
-0.0035851507,
-0.0162774343,
-0.0475768037,
-0.0556467585,
0.0073169391,
0.0164065417,
-0.0403598286,
0.0065545938,
0.032601364,
0.0285787378,
0.0038899863,
0.0069563598,
0.0572117232,
0.0125318486,
0.0404118076,
-0.0368073955,
0.0067236689,
0.0290091783,
0.0390893482,
-0.0386352204,
-0.087967433,
-0.0164341331,
0.0632490292,
0.0177268665,
0.0251671467,
-0.036846891,
0.004532075,
-0.0387896672,
-0.0018820916,
-0.0252331253,
0.0263143461,
0.0036070438,
0.0076249,
0.0050174808,
0.0017360691,
-0.0525384694,
-0.0492705144,
0.0526085198,
-0.0526469499,
-0.0532962903,
0.0122447368,
0.005662255,
0.0160707142,
0.0157014802,
0.01964055,
0.0284764171,
0.072581701,
-0.026702961,
-0.0225071777,
-0.0261781793,
-0.0448022,
-0.0182264708,
0.0187051874,
-0.0294979103,
-0.0075092907,
0.0296480749,
-0.0548575148,
-0.038103044,
0.0177578777,
-0.0117183179,
-0.0363341421,
0.0023903474,
-0.0480447896,
0.0029830632,
0.0233360175,
-0.0394406356,
0.0343904868,
-0.0030033519,
0.0169489216,
0.0418199226,
-0.0276775789,
-0.0266640503,
-0.0417694785,
0.0084701981,
-0.0281212702,
-0.0262630433,
0.0056515704,
0.0039905985,
0.0039015794,
-0.0548624396,
0.0009389336,
-0.0728938654,
0.0138357133,
-0.0162887815,
0.0263875872,
0.0585905053,
0.004643721,
-0.0010584205,
-0.0279143136,
-0.0541437976,
-0.0250188056,
0.0017048508,
0.035278976,
0.0709704384,
0.0603071153,
0.02358214,
-0.072904326,
-0.0240030941,
-0.0623276383,
0.0067800265,
0.0215177275,
-0.0173937846,
-0.0059348373,
-0.0444736183,
-0.0428800993,
0.0142635927,
-0.017367579,
-0.0119950771,
0.0168175809,
-0.0026924103,
-0.0096463887,
0.064699322,
-0.0141199613,
0.0339886062,
0.0435160287,
0.0364302695,
-0.0569574423,
0.0419444703,
-0.0460392758,
-0.0291216578,
-0.0055146213,
-0.0137835955,
0.0273125414,
0.0391429514,
0.01025928,
-0.0061205723,
-0.0347398743,
0.0232734177,
-0.0159730352,
-0.0347930863,
-0.0403282829,
0.0086652255,
-0.0273652785,
0.0187524911,
-0.0183455739,
0.0103912577,
0.0776593238,
0.0264594201,
0.0189079177,
-0.0880680606,
-0.0180325229,
-0.0670088083,
-0.0037638147,
-0.0223567821,
-0.0060857395,
0.021543609,
-0.0218061693,
-0.0431247428,
-0.0156135252,
-0.0388648026,
-0.0253009498,
-0.0089424867,
-0.0394522995,
0.0159907434,
0.0198939275,
-0.0292748865,
-0.0457220338,
-0.0214497652,
-0.0211272221,
0.0386659428,
0.0173819847,
0.0211331323,
-0.0203122646,
-0.021273287,
0.020803934,
0.0603188537,
-0.0216944963,
-0.0077685448,
-0.031415794,
0.0562267378,
0.0965156406,
0.0064135743,
-0.0031380013,
-0.0215295423,
0.0287524089,
0.027744228,
0.0363110341,
-0.0126782283,
-0.0150757106,
-0.0004682529,
-0.0102917757,
-0.0352143459,
-0.000334482,
0.0167089235,
0.0288812369,
-0.060553588,
-0.0349602401,
0.0761349425,
0.0216579512,
-0.0440560058,
-0.0029390375,
-0.0497329645,
-0.0021141251,
0.0124398172,
0.0596509874,
-0.0417099297,
-0.0299742259,
-0.0408380367,
0.0442161635,
-0.0068365,
-0.0260123741,
0.0110320058,
-0.0439133048,
0.0104296627,
-0.0542294644,
-0.0380736105,
0.0165265817,
-0.0558707379,
0.0284523331,
0.000894104,
0.0274686832,
-0.02732273,
-0.0135190813,
-0.0100213392,
0.0569774993,
-0.0310317203,
-0.0659790859,
0.0205625612,
-0.0259109605,
0.0354205482,
0.0497027524,
0.0274572447,
-0.0372324027,
-0.0138331959,
0.0245284028,
-0.0489329509,
0.0023937384,
0.0070349961,
0.0862536803,
-0.019374853,
-0.0096085994,
-0.0029625713,
0.0613406748,
-0.0480640084,
0.0145466691,
0.0346714258,
0.091685757,
-0.0154904658,
-0.0373587944,
-0.0725339726,
0.0127397096,
0.0031510876,
0.0445219912,
0.0169587024,
-0.019390991,
-0.0164608434,
0.030105494,
0.0220868476,
-0.0461284928,
-0.0369436778,
-0.0045127459,
-0.0190482773,
-0.0231495835,
-0.0837611184,
-0.0507120527,
0.0517203473,
-0.0191933271,
-0.0034803823,
0.0173132513,
0.032674998,
0.0059805284,
-0.0469133668,
0.0365441181,
-0.0108180288,
-0.0248738043,
-0.058557108,
-0.021787161,
0.0665382966,
0.0192505028,
-0.0418604091,
-0.0047621536,
-0.0175508317,
-0.0420604236,
0.0023036639,
0.0263896696,
0.0152908843,
0.0344138518,
-0.026506044,
-0.0328275375,
0.0513770692,
0.0549314544,
-0.0237575173,
-0.0359509215,
0.0155159067,
-0.0401694477,
-0.0229957718,
0.0233238544,
-0.0640634,
0.0362509936,
-0.00379078,
0.0337506644,
-0.0320964791,
0.0188831594,
0.0269920006,
-0.0121270847,
0.0237550288,
0.0177335721,
-0.0127900774,
-0.0301286131,
-0.004193374,
0.0161659494,
-0.0063329325,
0.0195792299,
0.0170748122,
0.0108443117,
-0.0162702799,
-0.0239213854,
0.0175399985,
-0.0519992746,
0.0371768624,
-0.0566069484,
-0.0087634567,
0.0297452677,
0.0262235049,
-0.0053425659,
-0.0301022604,
-0.01803164,
0.0265332013,
0.0085549494,
0.0599031188,
-0.0023174637,
-0.027538538,
0.0196441878,
0.0237599276,
-0.0170943774,
0.0096955812,
-0.1204006895,
-0.0311448313,
-0.0422202684,
0.024710089,
0.0123903975,
-0.0187766626,
-0.0041458546,
0.0007876723,
-0.025299117,
-0.0138674518,
-0.023621561,
-0.011628448,
0.0071795941,
0.093167983,
0.0202609468,
-0.0028683098,
-0.0004417315,
0.0746081769,
0.0316778608,
0.0884541199,
0.0197792724,
-0.0184938572,
-0.0109782377,
-0.0120985396,
0.0200323742,
0.0342809521,
-0.0295594297,
0.0319354497,
-0.0019552729,
-0.0271145981,
0.0469072275,
-0.0269715358,
-0.0268344674,
-0.030526245,
0.0371368416,
0.045500461,
0.0254602507,
-0.0290573128,
-0.0171222705,
0.0528157204,
-0.030376276,
-0.0336113572,
-0.0253552049,
-6.659849937e-33,
0.0092787351,
-0.0150258411,
0.0164521802,
-0.0290795378,
0.0337896347,
0.060683541,
-0.0404189304,
-0.0214824043,
-0.0528576784,
0.0356575474,
-0.0389086641,
0.0340687744,
0.0045019691,
0.0296693966,
0.0232274383,
-0.0648424923,
0.0374539644,
-0.013155927,
0.0048316917,
0.0298466738,
0.0231155436,
0.0577105395,
0.0426119789,
-0.0584694445,
0.0537169538,
-0.0276705194,
0.0366767608,
0.0392993614,
0.0085387565,
0.0683903396,
-0.0193202607,
0.0450516827,
0.0685567707,
-0.0325086527,
0.0240285452,
0.0492557809,
-0.1175618842,
-0.0522701479,
0.0212349128,
-0.0335574001,
-0.0819584355,
-0.0721296296,
0.0601823628,
0.0131318932,
0.0383072048,
-0.0022972322,
0.0601047873,
-0.0236826409,
-0.0056015076,
-0.0633000135,
-0.0420105495,
0.0157337394,
-0.0033743409,
0.0049512233,
-0.0455377661,
0.0610724725,
-0.0375704616,
0.0626244023,
0.0047989059,
-0.0219944324,
0.0312262531,
0.0694214851,
0.03259385,
-0.0050820229,
-0.0294454638,
0.0309936535,
-0.0254604239,
0.0019202637,
-0.0156231495,
-0.0137485117,
0.0024978705,
0.0307394136,
0.0439960808,
0.0439320877,
0.0383583754,
0.0111384895,
-0.0823280066,
0.0367410667,
-0.029677866,
0.0654516295,
0.0075213066,
-0.0427786037,
-0.0056822756,
-0.0010188062,
-0.0364676453,
0.040045917,
-0.0315539576,
-0.0015574136,
0.0363369323,
-0.0109277098,
-0.0449192263,
0.0233840663,
-0.0363210365,
-0.0391718075,
0.0030918787,
0.0325925089,
0.0048016631,
-0.0140139749,
0.0124218594,
0.0407968499,
-0.0838119611,
-0.0002287853,
0.0261366256,
0.0057504098,
0.0279460717,
0.0305933319,
0.0498862341,
-0.0322297923,
-0.0149172172,
-0.0456327051,
0.0165037923,
0.0339277126,
-0.0434040241,
0.048365023,
0.0003811281,
0.0569259226,
-0.0053829825,
0.0225930363,
0.0347621068,
0.0295778997,
-0.0067261709,
-0.0523002185,
-0.0190204587,
0.0321178958,
-0.061310526,
-0.0002820747,
-0.0220700242,
0.0428259671,
-0.016036965,
-0.0972569808,
-0.012865345,
0.01264391,
2.603e-7,
0.1094982326,
0.0550522842,
0.0333194211,
-0.0090804724,
0.0290217753,
0.0048596072,
0.0001647339,
0.0216997806,
0.0236824248,
-0.0598533601,
0.0229841731,
0.0272758268,
-0.0055332081,
0.0225487631,
-0.0836932212,
-0.0377161093,
-0.0998157635,
0.008352641,
-0.037735533,
-0.0223279819,
0.0217605606,
0.059038192,
-0.0326102711,
-0.0306175761,
-0.0452345647,
-0.0095082717,
0.0304277092,
0.0191368274,
-0.0008984799,
0.0528347008,
0.0473590866,
0.0314218029,
0.0104254214,
0.0330239274,
-0.0185307451,
0.0208214577,
-0.0016235331,
0.0377663635,
-0.0223208945,
-0.0142947491,
0.0073007285,
-0.0074173319,
0.0361519605,
-0.0055361674,
0.0844668299,
-0.0985825807,
-0.0357059427,
-0.0134106399,
-0.0520678908,
0.0300830808,
0.0136659378,
-0.0348304398,
-0.0344107151,
0.0263599344,
0.0051390212,
-0.0004898568,
-0.0092224283,
-0.0622344427,
0.0286034588,
0.0407467857,
-0.0175701715,
-0.0157405324,
-0.0213650223,
-0.0130292894,
-0.0182944108,
-0.0836668313,
0.0425728485,
1.927787776e-34,
0.0562045947,
0.0090348236,
-0.0042950446,
0.028042471,
-0.0108200917,
0.0089658611,
-0.0064888163,
0.0062019336,
0.0191442706,
-0.064175874,
-0.0049805306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16167v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16167v1 | Large Language Model Soft Ideologization via AI-Self-Consciousness | 2023-09-28T04:47:58 | 2023-09-28T04:47:58 | Xiaotian Zhou, Qian Wang, Xiaofeng Wang, Haixu Tang, Xiaozhong Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated human-level performance on a
vast spectrum of natural language tasks. However, few studies have addressed
the LLM threat and vulnerability from an ideology perspective, especially when
they are increasingly being deployed in sensitive domains, e.g., elections and
education. In this study, we explore the implications of GPT soft
ideologization through the use of AI-self-consciousness. By utilizing GPT
self-conversations, AI can be granted a vision to "comprehend" the intended
ideology, and subsequently generate finetuning data for LLM ideology injection.
When compared to traditional government ideology manipulation techniques, such
as information censorship, LLM ideologization proves advantageous; it is easy
to implement, cost-effective, and powerful, thus brimming with risks. | [
0.0411548242,
0.0723084509,
-0.0223739557,
0.0284390114,
-0.05504236,
-0.008075648,
0.0202126782,
-0.0339397453,
0.0524443164,
-0.0597767606,
-0.006712134,
0.0037407482,
-0.0195875503,
0.01873032,
0.022604337,
-0.0267804023,
0.0474497862,
-0.0219783299,
0.0326427147,
-0.0389407314,
0.004113432,
0.0195650961,
0.0275375471,
0.0240839738,
-0.0139719788,
-0.0251502953,
-0.0047335834,
-0.0171066076,
0.0040611997,
0.0063014324,
-0.015486314,
0.0197466072,
0.0159459077,
0.0554090254,
0.000001794,
-0.0366926678,
-0.0177992303,
-0.0039687003,
-0.0030247322,
0.0324621387,
0.0316717103,
-0.0023765208,
-0.0262144208,
0.0010798869,
-0.0562108494,
0.0314254947,
0.0356513783,
0.0688011497,
0.0818540305,
0.0623147301,
-0.0043572062,
-0.0219793953,
0.0150517086,
-0.0181933343,
-0.0111111579,
-0.0241471156,
0.0539653897,
-0.017788209,
-0.0524009541,
0.0411701538,
-0.0081172446,
0.0448622927,
0.0047990941,
-0.009631142,
-0.0452057645,
-0.0077449488,
-0.0189179163,
-0.0095129898,
-0.0135684721,
0.0353698842,
0.0298945755,
-0.0125441765,
0.0528400689,
0.0163052417,
0.015905641,
0.0047424985,
-0.0171418507,
0.0226624683,
-0.002978022,
0.0314604528,
0.0910079554,
-0.0326462723,
0.0231553633,
0.0380846821,
-0.0481634289,
0.0951246545,
-0.0120590311,
-0.027064776,
0.0144452918,
-0.0507226586,
0.0024711245,
-0.0629997179,
0.0016890498,
-0.0013805002,
-0.0144117465,
0.0268028583,
-0.0737129822,
0.0039090649,
0.0077349939,
-0.0738068819,
0.0253994092,
0.0265660454,
0.0264397617,
0.0470319092,
0.0174551383,
0.0434491597,
-0.0266303439,
0.0611534901,
0.0022514397,
-0.024281688,
-0.0184478536,
-0.0306069274,
-0.0254351534,
0.0481351353,
0.0151630761,
0.0061331736,
-0.0336394906,
0.0167091414,
-0.0476228707,
0.0225969218,
-0.0492281169,
0.0039378288,
-0.0390167534,
-0.0525895245,
-0.0378462151,
0.0353924483,
-0.0234479997,
0.0024782,
-0.0231965315,
-0.0325425863,
0.0132021029,
0.0293241702,
-0.0305450186,
-0.0075923675,
-0.0058433092,
0.0512901619,
0.0082925912,
-0.0154929981,
-0.021304924,
-0.0397685729,
-0.0225539729,
-0.0556611009,
0.0051368438,
-0.0438891836,
-0.0161589254,
-0.0233211908,
-0.0027185965,
-0.1053752452,
0.0276446752,
-0.0064962925,
-0.025460599,
0.078189522,
0.014384741,
0.0129245175,
0.0444258451,
0.0262481943,
0.0389190242,
0.0947894976,
0.0179389566,
0.0620581135,
0.0262671001,
-0.0331122838,
0.0298299678,
0.0228150096,
0.0003807374,
0.0428700261,
-0.0708091557,
0.0126610743,
-0.0255127307,
0.0001951436,
0.0009784211,
0.066473946,
0.0411792882,
-0.0301940683,
0.081821166,
0.048645746,
-0.0369676538,
-0.0039483383,
0.0252114739,
0.0305344388,
-0.0041041332,
0.0442532338,
-0.0490645766,
0.0026045328,
-0.0268164873,
-0.0642734766,
0.0320534892,
0.0418689847,
-0.0241556019,
-0.0328138471,
0.0222231224,
-0.0173312817,
0.0142447846,
0.0128509281,
0.0153092658,
-0.0208801124,
-0.0025059115,
-0.0186725352,
0.0349383242,
0.0048402785,
-0.0009281861,
-0.0920348689,
-0.0056877937,
0.0422765724,
0.0423677005,
-0.039104715,
-0.0074892719,
-0.0386719033,
0.0398212411,
0.0727727413,
0.0798131824,
-0.0278567784,
-0.0598167405,
0.0080178557,
-0.0018771082,
-0.0108675417,
0.0432110541,
0.0606998205,
0.0106778303,
0.0081276875,
0.0009779732,
0.015188382,
-0.0454283245,
0.0272174682,
-0.0140796695,
-0.0726183429,
0.0082311723,
0.0131738717,
0.0313390903,
0.0244211666,
-0.0340853781,
-0.008041461,
0.0468504578,
0.0056008971,
-0.049784001,
-0.0203901548,
-0.0264510252,
0.0878573805,
0.0272689182,
-0.0255217068,
0.0004378435,
0.0367249623,
-0.0057709254,
-0.0202562157,
0.0815015435,
-0.021703193,
0.0017998017,
-0.0321087576,
0.0254535507,
-0.0510485955,
-0.0022669006,
-0.0409516878,
0.0171118602,
0.0300863143,
-0.0453850329,
0.0057569789,
-0.0290775243,
0.0284083299,
0.0000603188,
-0.0192699619,
0.0016054129,
0.0042151413,
0.0307235923,
0.0592510067,
-0.0573841818,
-0.0087300753,
-0.0588352606,
-0.040518716,
-0.0197331402,
-0.0002289315,
0.0007611831,
0.0229671802,
-0.0034714467,
-0.0098112226,
0.0367302522,
-0.0380132385,
-0.007149911,
-0.0210048724,
0.0190291218,
0.0322178155,
-0.0046573747,
-0.022553524,
-0.0048714746,
0.0328062922,
-0.0574448295,
-0.0030148081,
0.0366269797,
-0.0459369682,
-0.0265693702,
0.0100581944,
-0.0404082797,
0.0277712606,
-0.0389615148,
-0.0694929659,
0.012654867,
-0.0023914422,
0.0104240514,
0.0793918371,
0.0368712693,
0.0610511564,
0.0819835588,
0.0153729049,
-0.0550994463,
-0.0259765591,
-0.0260643456,
0.0006350584,
-0.0508859046,
-0.0070140348,
0.0142706344,
0.0465203747,
0.0547500104,
-0.0054953881,
-0.0399203748,
0.0892379284,
-0.0399740152,
-0.0605892278,
0.0058087478,
-0.0369135365,
-0.0118921166,
0.0095254052,
0.0135788061,
-0.0453837961,
0.0762344897,
-0.0023549814,
0.0542927496,
-0.0022229794,
-0.0353761539,
-0.017974738,
0.0411348417,
-0.0072305668,
0.0204356574,
0.0567315072,
-0.0073368461,
-0.0497122854,
-0.0218655635,
-0.0003851888,
-0.033089973,
0.0311589278,
-0.0434117056,
0.0009381933,
0.024494525,
-0.0272300709,
-0.0474689379,
-0.0707787722,
-0.0023522775,
-0.0120360041,
0.0448223613,
-0.0307594761,
-0.0176710244,
0.0123047885,
0.0693952516,
-0.0104389694,
-0.0169690866,
0.0070295581,
-0.0076180547,
-0.0489401333,
0.0358883366,
-0.0242466517,
0.0241743866,
0.0335310735,
0.0318144485,
0.0191273093,
0.0307689738,
0.0257290322,
-0.0079958718,
-0.0405178331,
-0.0034517394,
-0.0248048045,
-0.0055736783,
-0.008849225,
0.0326168276,
-0.0319967084,
0.0106400745,
0.1076348796,
0.0264531132,
-0.0517362878,
-0.0109449429,
0.0046898574,
-0.036982663,
0.0220606793,
0.0045243995,
-0.0831476077,
0.0092241438,
0.003789057,
0.0241284575,
-0.0578319393,
-0.0495347641,
-0.018641267,
-0.0889742076,
-0.007095682,
0.011898553,
0.0312699229,
-0.0334597565,
-0.0354805999,
0.0049946532,
0.0007128089,
-0.0186215267,
-0.0490322709,
0.0252290592,
-0.0039543519,
-0.0053270841,
-0.0456895009,
-0.0330784097,
0.003146501,
-0.0088196201,
0.0715993717,
0.0585958399,
0.0627269521,
-0.0241524577,
0.0146996835,
0.0570314042,
-0.0170903429,
-0.0549619161,
0.0114722131,
0.0444431528,
-0.015577333,
-0.033324264,
0.0232978258,
0.0537198596,
0.0176334903,
0.0401669741,
0.0324596614,
0.0441406704,
-0.0468013398,
-0.0469713435,
0.0040909313,
-0.0105062043,
0.0482417867,
0.0760914162,
0.0077375988,
-0.0558511131,
0.0080016032,
-0.0520160608,
0.0292141195,
-0.0009594893,
-0.0658583865,
-0.0250646714,
0.0137475291,
-0.0148322713,
-0.0465851501,
-0.0495212153,
0.0159262605,
0.0096118506,
0.0650188476,
0.0060740309,
0.0162841547,
-0.008621742,
0.0137345903,
-0.0392221659,
-0.0657432452,
0.0147759439,
-0.0349112749,
-0.0430845469,
0.0137991672,
0.0065069236,
0.0034325081,
0.045264326,
0.0066412226,
-0.0883375928,
0.0583175644,
-0.0189883597,
0.0252905469,
0.0512885749,
-0.0377363153,
-0.0261891335,
0.0945156813,
0.0541332513,
-0.0076234373,
0.0289759655,
0.020026898,
0.0058298968,
0.00563556,
0.0548345819,
-0.0169473439,
0.0203730557,
0.0342054889,
-0.0589468516,
-0.0705451965,
-0.0427343138,
0.0403801091,
0.054348018,
0.0256779566,
-0.0174497198,
0.0186553299,
-0.0118808532,
-0.0270400383,
-0.0565726496,
-0.0432919003,
0.0158746913,
-0.0116744759,
0.0600312017,
0.002601176,
0.0121449782,
-0.0175416246,
-0.0132846292,
0.0116565619,
-0.0027877281,
-0.0025334854,
-0.027647933,
0.0541563071,
0.0135948984,
0.0020302783,
0.0132453954,
0.0831422284,
0.0130824139,
0.0389592946,
-0.0167894121,
0.045101095,
0.0181933939,
-0.010876786,
0.0205888506,
0.0035798119,
-0.0264560953,
-0.0495335199,
0.0059316424,
0.0528348833,
0.0182832386,
0.015421316,
0.0251256358,
-0.0221398957,
-0.0162447263,
-0.0140906451,
-0.002690715,
0.0352749601,
-0.0330624729,
0.026983887,
-0.000769386,
-0.0524178371,
0.0269242227,
0.0354926549,
0.0133574978,
0.0814667791,
0.0406958051,
-0.0184391402,
-0.0399564691,
-0.0315498374,
0.010781276,
-0.0021836539,
-0.0208477546,
0.001397642,
-0.0616514422,
-0.0409423113,
0.0172124021,
0.0139731914,
-0.0108616818,
-0.0355874225,
0.0019396166,
0.0547311418,
-0.0023020876,
0.0380700864,
-0.0740515739,
0.0011211931,
-0.0425770134,
-0.0301460009,
0.0239536799,
-5.999122195e-33,
-0.0352058187,
-0.0231185034,
-0.0009942467,
0.0321463384,
-0.0053138281,
0.0012922228,
-0.0027815488,
0.0289263744,
-0.0116925854,
0.0187555756,
0.0028803267,
0.0216235165,
-0.0078398064,
0.0085157687,
-0.0282331556,
-0.0059443018,
0.0085347258,
-0.0306270383,
-0.0253866073,
0.0493562929,
0.0565551855,
-0.0378387831,
0.0068765138,
-0.1124473512,
0.0300465282,
0.0470723249,
-0.0349437706,
-0.012952663,
-0.0125580523,
0.025170451,
-0.0418774225,
0.0447455794,
0.002930166,
-0.0247423947,
0.0111215496,
0.0861498415,
0.0153213674,
-0.0296078846,
0.0147648919,
-0.0200310014,
0.0415570773,
-0.0630446821,
0.0124201216,
-0.0368624702,
-0.0309291463,
0.0312405098,
0.0295962337,
-0.0059226118,
0.0408632159,
0.0053794747,
-0.0688091815,
-0.000596825,
-0.0240505096,
0.0008842444,
-0.0011385275,
-0.0176901426,
0.0477243215,
0.0160640627,
-0.0403853729,
0.0453412607,
0.00117512,
0.0177900996,
0.0404161327,
-0.022853557,
0.0154635748,
0.0569441281,
0.0097168759,
0.0119439354,
-0.0499776118,
-0.0145024722,
0.0355719775,
-0.0245984271,
0.0631388277,
0.0565634109,
-0.023472691,
-0.0362104289,
-0.0528727211,
-0.0096821291,
0.0341582,
0.0014447817,
0.0339586735,
-0.0180891622,
-0.0519206747,
-0.0300026126,
-0.0552191548,
-0.0695918798,
-0.0222586878,
-0.012418679,
-0.0000081803,
-0.0131891184,
-0.0578621328,
0.0471520051,
0.0145661104,
-0.046787668,
-0.0157622267,
0.0080002928,
-0.0355058685,
-0.0202119499,
0.0014466731,
0.0252316631,
-0.0604576468,
0.0044564288,
-0.0079086795,
0.0033613504,
0.0410072431,
0.0113195758,
-0.0144158481,
0.0228514224,
-0.0819716081,
-0.026412461,
-0.013489903,
0.0149916364,
0.0114664957,
-0.0203775223,
0.0241570305,
0.0146834292,
0.0125691826,
-0.0309160631,
0.0524297096,
-0.0074272184,
-0.0109012881,
-0.0112327738,
-0.0460981838,
0.0182070266,
-0.0256023351,
0.0005133689,
-0.0522716194,
0.0417348482,
0.0375245474,
-0.0607711226,
-0.0073578893,
-0.0371836387,
2.632e-7,
-0.0049535367,
0.0707835555,
-0.0089628128,
0.005541875,
0.006035734,
0.0774813518,
0.0161610581,
0.0419804566,
-0.0129733067,
-0.0754396468,
-0.0213057436,
0.0300138835,
0.0167236961,
0.0193613172,
-0.0647797883,
0.0209643673,
0.0127401408,
0.0287744142,
-0.0818161517,
0.0316000469,
0.011265316,
0.0728608444,
0.0761883482,
0.0032664454,
-0.0420145504,
-0.0551207252,
0.0283287354,
0.0018764453,
-0.0319675729,
0.0540354401,
0.0200177785,
0.0378121771,
-0.0038536347,
0.0220254529,
0.0155216483,
-0.0054768897,
-0.038425006,
0.0571287125,
0.0051376228,
0.0127482805,
-0.0270224307,
-0.0089222519,
0.0017337158,
-0.0330334604,
0.0803238973,
-0.0923523009,
-0.0578600317,
-0.0465336442,
-0.011849965,
-0.028755758,
0.0190081187,
-0.0207109693,
-0.0389505588,
-0.0039256252,
-0.0187086724,
0.0113084046,
0.0351533368,
-0.0603996962,
0.0263616648,
-0.0591528378,
-0.0283038504,
-0.0261633135,
-0.0005671991,
0.0325892381,
-0.0085997246,
-0.0394533947,
0.044751361,
2.499827179e-34,
0.0231134612,
-0.0221869927,
-0.0133304847,
-0.0422632694,
0.0578700528,
0.0227319337,
-0.0302488022,
0.006667316,
0.006018749,
-0.081994243,
0.0005886164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16155v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16155v1 | The Trickle-down Impact of Reward (In-)consistency on RLHF | 2023-09-28T04:05:13 | 2023-09-28T04:05:13 | Lingfeng Shen, Sihao Chen, Linfeng Song, Lifeng Jin, Baolin Peng, Haitao Mi, Daniel Khashabi, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Standard practice within Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF)
involves optimizing against a Reward Model (RM), which itself is trained to
reflect human preferences for desirable generations. A notable subject that is
understudied is the (in-)consistency of RMs -- whether they can recognize the
semantic changes to different prompts and appropriately adapt their reward
assignments -- and their impact on the downstream RLHF model.
In this paper, we visit a series of research questions relevant to RM
inconsistency: (1) How can we measure the consistency of reward models? (2) How
consistent are the existing RMs and how can we improve them? (3) In what ways
does reward inconsistency influence the chatbots resulting from the RLHF model
training?
We propose Contrast Instructions -- a benchmarking strategy for the
consistency of RM. Each example in Contrast Instructions features a pair of
lexically similar instructions with different ground truth responses. A
consistent RM is expected to rank the corresponding instruction and response
higher than other combinations. We observe that current RMs trained with the
standard ranking objective fail miserably on Contrast Instructions compared to
average humans. To show that RM consistency can be improved efficiently without
using extra training budget, we propose two techniques ConvexDA and
RewardFusion, which enhance reward consistency through extrapolation during the
RM training and inference stage, respectively. We show that RLHF models trained
with a more consistent RM yield more useful responses, suggesting that reward
inconsistency exhibits a trickle-down effect on the downstream RLHF process. | [
0.0822382048,
0.0479494855,
-0.014437505,
-0.026618639,
-0.0366883986,
0.0250852481,
-0.0556416065,
0.016341662,
-0.0243662074,
-0.0143523086,
-0.047210604,
-0.0025236378,
0.014627371,
-0.0113959424,
-0.0269905906,
-0.0852822587,
0.0786434039,
-0.0298555624,
-0.0013266164,
-0.0281001367,
-0.014422222,
-0.0319565088,
-0.0069384207,
0.0533083007,
-0.0098910918,
-0.0019648264,
-0.0070009297,
-0.0067606857,
0.0478059985,
-0.0295760408,
0.0139061362,
0.0450671203,
0.0436206236,
0.0423472226,
0.000002229,
-0.0337299518,
-0.0061424035,
-0.0269185919,
-0.0431423709,
-0.0445670635,
0.0189108886,
0.0288858563,
-0.0170802735,
-0.0011396452,
-0.0153425839,
0.0290286038,
0.0228509214,
0.0430836454,
0.0589304939,
0.0475587733,
0.0337461941,
0.0073226136,
0.0188880973,
-0.0391341187,
0.0325948894,
-0.0569553971,
0.0032604279,
0.0386026502,
0.0205579791,
0.016545698,
-0.0459558405,
-0.020544488,
0.046250131,
0.0070855101,
0.0255025476,
0.0413900167,
0.0192229785,
-0.0183284692,
-0.0468398668,
0.0509681813,
0.0142012769,
0.0227224585,
-0.0069736908,
0.0081760623,
0.0370030291,
-0.0128540806,
0.0055993111,
0.0386094674,
-0.0267610624,
0.0171784963,
0.0013048108,
-0.0025416785,
0.0134801054,
0.0160870776,
0.0104914382,
0.0487971157,
-0.0153805017,
-0.0385926925,
0.0086599952,
0.0360274054,
-0.0336624943,
-0.0473360643,
-0.0179512985,
0.0121104447,
-0.0793337449,
0.0224578995,
-0.0122754322,
0.0173787288,
-0.0121433111,
-0.0125063229,
0.0217319056,
0.0493574701,
-0.0144853247,
0.0154162813,
-0.0068274201,
0.0890418217,
-0.0055266442,
0.0434396453,
-0.0176430885,
0.0260049868,
-0.044825878,
-0.0009145993,
-0.0058353562,
0.0603793263,
-0.0066868202,
-0.0205164291,
-0.0836561471,
0.0266128909,
-0.076734595,
0.0314089097,
-0.0077139791,
0.023544075,
-0.0638321117,
0.0478689447,
-0.1005780771,
-0.0023400958,
-0.0429548137,
-0.0042884271,
0.0495767072,
-0.0217161924,
-0.0026874607,
-0.028341556,
-0.0244419184,
0.014116317,
-0.0126744974,
0.0728607401,
-0.0135285603,
-0.0325720906,
0.0142047564,
-0.0101172915,
-0.0097443089,
-0.0540211946,
0.0194338672,
-0.0227768719,
0.0216243751,
-0.0364057012,
-0.0140604172,
0.0123325307,
0.0020040113,
-0.0191385988,
-0.0156391319,
0.0710638091,
0.021889884,
-0.0165679511,
0.0039049168,
0.0057997699,
-0.0684312433,
0.0296565648,
0.0236164499,
0.0289976038,
0.0066326433,
0.015361974,
0.004690174,
-0.012640507,
0.0077154255,
0.0073839519,
-0.0026925576,
-0.0089555671,
0.0053808787,
0.0531644523,
0.0622656383,
0.0427434482,
-0.0610211492,
-0.0093901576,
0.0567647666,
0.0391655788,
-0.0079136034,
-0.0498079173,
0.0332623795,
-0.0010815978,
0.0028542322,
0.0518792868,
-0.0537978522,
0.027714517,
0.0135361487,
-0.0228300672,
0.0283383988,
-0.0302247982,
-0.0282583479,
-0.0599754974,
0.0177176967,
-0.0030672071,
0.0277428087,
0.0230833497,
0.0381919444,
0.0087235542,
-0.0440087095,
-0.0559634157,
0.061380703,
-0.0105540836,
-0.0127712972,
-0.0799425468,
0.048563011,
0.0757733136,
0.0422386043,
-0.0084465779,
0.001678591,
-0.0027787001,
-0.0384820513,
0.0475616232,
0.029726997,
-0.0235796701,
0.0001411922,
-0.0077213007,
-0.0404007658,
0.0058624987,
0.0047220052,
0.0616398528,
0.0273226276,
-0.0255929474,
-0.0395837389,
0.0784846991,
-0.032241296,
0.0373356976,
0.0180811808,
0.0309183914,
0.005542296,
-0.0090338876,
0.0667287558,
-0.0272953212,
0.002234665,
0.0084725972,
0.0013607304,
0.0314885378,
-0.0230938513,
0.0250342321,
-0.0791087896,
-0.060860917,
-0.0154186003,
0.0002580695,
-0.0087678116,
0.0625241026,
-0.0137088643,
0.0268993806,
0.0285532773,
-0.0479244627,
0.058194682,
-0.0025078834,
0.0595718585,
-0.0202559847,
-0.0316081978,
-0.0402699523,
0.0357421488,
-0.0267551243,
-0.0153540531,
-0.0311164502,
0.0235539116,
-0.042719163,
-0.0980301201,
0.0244972035,
0.050124377,
-0.0052148909,
0.0087159611,
0.0383266434,
0.0250206403,
-0.0350604877,
-0.0193182528,
-0.0098367194,
-0.0375364535,
-0.0040688524,
-0.0172778461,
-0.0017883015,
-0.0307229329,
0.0269588102,
-0.0258788858,
0.0105407527,
0.0239613745,
0.0495034084,
0.0542089343,
0.0355816148,
0.0378073826,
-0.0046534329,
-0.0545309,
-0.0070826891,
0.0131146619,
-0.0039685252,
0.0045097908,
0.0452232175,
-0.0524785854,
0.0211768486,
-0.0583177954,
0.0397897512,
-0.0318428688,
-0.0149841309,
0.0630533844,
0.0293063223,
0.0346835218,
0.1185906976,
0.056851808,
0.0753155649,
0.0368430838,
0.0222525094,
-0.0828791112,
0.0035239253,
-0.0415927619,
-0.0632034913,
0.0005588252,
-0.0454876944,
0.0160410777,
0.0795975551,
-0.0001306138,
0.0350229703,
-0.0784746781,
0.0232655481,
-0.0134274708,
-0.0864903554,
-0.0488280654,
-0.0161452666,
-0.0416560918,
0.0228775386,
-0.0458186306,
-0.0730185211,
0.0967029035,
0.0262832828,
0.0210456066,
-0.0388068594,
-0.0111280214,
-0.0092722103,
-0.0112732574,
-0.0059230309,
0.0241488311,
-0.023241464,
-0.0216208529,
-0.0680551976,
-0.0484472103,
0.0395418294,
-0.0187268145,
0.0030514905,
-0.0158456881,
-0.0199766308,
-0.0018221894,
-0.0831583813,
-0.0661592558,
-0.0156194046,
0.0178836156,
-0.0013442548,
0.0286173057,
-0.0224277694,
-0.0076946742,
-0.0130096711,
0.0510994643,
0.000802868,
-0.0246541779,
-0.0326628275,
-0.0232440513,
-0.0336846784,
0.0530450046,
0.0183096416,
0.047101289,
-0.0714885816,
0.0133900931,
0.0330401473,
0.0399592295,
-0.011631757,
-0.0067016236,
0.0381021909,
-0.0016576833,
-0.0354129262,
-0.0012093822,
0.0402760245,
0.0215494912,
-0.0211526062,
-0.0170003641,
0.0478454195,
0.022001503,
-0.0415381677,
0.0342603959,
-0.0323908031,
0.0528305098,
-0.0045311451,
0.0031377897,
-0.0601467825,
-0.0045366343,
0.0134866694,
0.05621171,
-0.035986729,
-0.0175156109,
0.0311843678,
-0.0961373597,
0.0033603946,
-0.0157677513,
-0.0687425733,
-0.0016409976,
-0.0143819991,
-0.0004305467,
0.008214619,
0.0084203212,
0.0335340649,
-0.0019987654,
-0.0083755217,
0.0174583066,
0.0334036089,
0.0096739037,
0.0334213451,
-0.0652829632,
0.0475893654,
0.1085427627,
0.0191977657,
0.0154075874,
-0.0309956409,
-0.0276577864,
0.029430842,
-0.0113914302,
-0.0080539677,
0.0264658667,
-0.0333635136,
0.0053473921,
-0.0544388443,
-0.0027055212,
0.0622836724,
-0.0143646179,
-0.0189190861,
0.0192093235,
-0.0329121314,
-0.0242077056,
-0.0259137154,
0.0317196175,
0.0044632656,
0.0590637065,
-0.0136659592,
-0.0503512993,
-0.0299760401,
-0.0100467494,
-0.0224016085,
-0.0087574068,
-0.0204452276,
0.0163384508,
-0.038450487,
-0.0124603715,
-0.0867774263,
-0.0604131296,
-0.0622704551,
0.0019520572,
-0.005638191,
-0.0476494916,
-0.0348705463,
0.0327170193,
0.0325002968,
0.0264729448,
-0.0336615033,
-0.0021313163,
-0.0720993206,
-0.0074860784,
-0.0065095476,
-0.0621853545,
-0.0062752268,
-0.0352545157,
0.0009802615,
-0.0174788665,
0.0028744226,
0.0569076836,
0.0190685149,
0.0632197112,
0.0150193907,
0.01700636,
0.0329879001,
-0.0119757736,
-0.0009654573,
0.0459826887,
0.0455336161,
0.0569942519,
-0.021829512,
0.0080564087,
-0.0773771331,
0.0205450915,
0.0337423868,
0.0375278369,
0.0252067856,
-0.012134851,
0.0503366105,
-0.0089848302,
0.0132787442,
-0.0136789726,
-0.0323092826,
0.0065428033,
-0.0005684557,
0.0035035245,
-0.0188733023,
-0.0252509099,
-0.0025725449,
0.0211928543,
0.0490892492,
0.0118354959,
-0.0202390496,
0.0312420093,
0.0493213758,
-0.0029262509,
-0.0304809734,
0.0145075116,
0.0267199613,
-0.0098984949,
0.040891584,
-0.0015616198,
-0.0023006948,
-0.0135406675,
0.0394496694,
0.0371381007,
0.07835944,
0.0425964333,
-0.0318380706,
-0.0084268302,
0.0350104682,
-0.0904033929,
-0.035089314,
0.0004416353,
0.0003431862,
0.0480957627,
0.0469908454,
0.0151253277,
-0.0433500446,
0.0098783234,
-0.0201395527,
-0.0239901878,
-0.0165977012,
0.0002923072,
0.013365793,
0.0346475914,
0.0122740949,
0.0052706883,
0.0098721739,
0.007241895,
0.058526475,
-0.0715016946,
-0.004331266,
-0.0133904573,
-0.0064413655,
0.0321289711,
0.0228255484,
-0.0081737544,
0.0012451258,
-0.0580855906,
-0.0221078936,
-0.0401266888,
0.0694495663,
-0.0018671424,
-0.0124094076,
0.0514946431,
0.0143254939,
-0.0437056944,
-0.0522709414,
-0.056827575,
-0.0257700346,
-0.031372197,
0.0140592912,
-0.0312417559,
-6.230366178e-33,
-0.0411743857,
-0.0046718894,
0.0115221404,
-0.0021569266,
-0.0443390571,
-0.0052315178,
-0.0177535173,
-0.0083672646,
-0.0167786442,
0.0017929868,
-0.003700688,
-0.0050008958,
0.0126794539,
-0.0448152535,
0.0237341374,
-0.0396612585,
0.0340719149,
-0.0093390336,
-0.07025408,
0.011294907,
0.0271392632,
-0.0086422917,
0.0635664091,
-0.0418161973,
0.0269972812,
0.0328312442,
-0.0166180506,
0.029868653,
-0.0492747799,
0.0417797826,
0.0032186122,
0.0015303554,
0.0060258135,
-0.0808092952,
-0.0065875333,
0.0006759561,
-0.0551454127,
-0.0403538123,
0.006014084,
-0.0189878047,
-0.0888409317,
-0.023508111,
0.0374879017,
-0.0011100081,
-0.0731347948,
0.0177562013,
-0.0077464897,
-0.0078105624,
0.0067331055,
0.0439159013,
-0.0473709814,
-0.0075578899,
0.0078650527,
-0.0527426116,
-0.0226310864,
0.0852594078,
-0.0286898986,
0.0574281216,
-0.0457829051,
0.0579857975,
0.0248617735,
-0.0149128111,
0.0551679805,
0.0626106337,
0.0489343703,
0.047977712,
0.0417632535,
0.0263550226,
-0.0005473879,
-0.0465098061,
0.010035485,
0.0455517583,
0.0515142828,
0.0294302013,
0.0492752381,
0.0038591418,
-0.0154030304,
0.0232575368,
0.0235983375,
0.0541400611,
0.0034479804,
0.0317467973,
-0.0709471852,
-0.0102050919,
-0.0286448095,
-0.007098272,
-0.0070871981,
-0.062944591,
0.0328485742,
0.0419265255,
0.0102242008,
-0.0238088518,
0.0263368301,
-0.0189717058,
-0.0197844096,
-0.0122074494,
-0.0260274615,
0.0018117609,
0.0008209151,
-0.0176607165,
-0.080972515,
-0.0249130428,
0.0294407196,
-0.0178845711,
-0.0053259684,
0.0458894819,
0.002674137,
-0.0142641589,
-0.0045794854,
0.0058123525,
-0.0093813716,
0.0146991154,
0.0142458668,
-0.0334073901,
0.0431436561,
-0.0116445338,
-0.0190655552,
0.0349743627,
-0.002759126,
-0.0201041698,
-0.0592293888,
0.0333756916,
-0.0336379409,
0.0230441019,
0.0024174927,
0.0216193497,
-0.0576217845,
0.0330812596,
-0.0226274282,
-0.0422134809,
-0.0341677554,
-0.0048890249,
2.943e-7,
-0.0556408539,
0.0139729567,
0.0205943733,
0.0034404597,
0.0205766968,
0.0688342899,
-0.0244536959,
0.0257198103,
0.0218924023,
-0.0165342018,
0.0110575957,
0.044748418,
0.0271699298,
-0.0161484946,
-0.0135521926,
-0.0535095744,
-0.1097584069,
-0.0399753712,
0.0092470367,
-0.0148741947,
0.0230244789,
0.0241314732,
0.0239222795,
-0.0138175301,
0.0315833576,
0.0602456629,
0.043100439,
-0.0238975361,
-0.0059631425,
-0.0076289335,
-0.0176104084,
-0.020822892,
0.009318742,
0.0064021242,
0.0330690071,
-0.0019495665,
-0.0056710164,
0.0294489525,
-0.0324006863,
-0.0467994809,
-0.0340226553,
0.0519693941,
0.0072267102,
-0.0441455394,
0.0316349082,
-0.0641811118,
-0.0300046839,
-0.0324179158,
0.031202998,
-0.0067725223,
0.0345212035,
-0.0191894881,
-0.0291304886,
-0.0157945286,
-0.0015748851,
0.0824658722,
-0.0148145612,
-0.0480029993,
0.0279582366,
0.0315098725,
-0.0389343612,
-0.10110268,
-0.035596773,
0.078373678,
-0.0184254609,
-0.0527810454,
-0.033876583,
2.39653796e-34,
-0.0101668676,
-0.003352819,
0.0515628308,
0.0013671101,
0.0361110978,
0.0345820822,
-0.0072064991,
-0.002358872,
0.07445582,
-0.0092717661,
-0.0098132771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16150v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16150v1 | AE-GPT: Using Large Language Models to Extract Adverse Events from Surveillance Reports-A Use Case with Influenza Vaccine Adverse Events | 2023-09-28T03:53:21 | 2023-09-28T03:53:21 | Yiming Li, Jianfu Li, Jianping He, Cui Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Though Vaccines are instrumental in global health, mitigating infectious
diseases and pandemic outbreaks, they can occasionally lead to adverse events
(AEs). Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown promise in effectively
identifying and cataloging AEs within clinical reports. Utilizing data from the
Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) from 1990 to 2016, this study
particularly focuses on AEs to evaluate LLMs' capability for AE extraction. A
variety of prevalent LLMs, including GPT-2, GPT-3 variants, GPT-4, and Llama 2,
were evaluated using Influenza vaccine as a use case. The fine-tuned GPT 3.5
model (AE-GPT) stood out with a 0.704 averaged micro F1 score for strict match
and 0.816 for relaxed match. The encouraging performance of the AE-GPT
underscores LLMs' potential in processing medical data, indicating a
significant stride towards advanced AE detection, thus presumably generalizable
to other AE extraction tasks. | [
0.0277757719,
0.0601277985,
-0.0084296223,
-0.0090851979,
0.0004689511,
0.0338825807,
-0.0088728694,
0.0037006512,
0.0355347097,
-0.0109750265,
0.0447410084,
-0.0429278761,
-0.0000652877,
0.0625070259,
-0.009977404,
-0.0305785388,
0.0420449972,
0.0177546255,
0.0312147029,
0.0379525498,
-0.0069580385,
0.0451182909,
-0.0144945141,
0.0539933965,
0.0464280732,
0.0172023848,
0.0209616721,
-0.0286850762,
0.0441257991,
-0.0898514986,
0.0214682575,
-0.0433136672,
-0.0110226162,
0.0162010211,
0.0000018766,
-0.0363933481,
-0.0391215943,
0.0278870333,
-0.0016299821,
0.0001949789,
0.0419591479,
-0.0405937508,
-0.0084490404,
0.0228702873,
-0.0170289986,
-0.0770609155,
0.0546885803,
0.0106358966,
0.0191212427,
0.0486898459,
-0.0351953879,
-0.0368694142,
0.060836859,
-0.0108824447,
0.0062658726,
-0.0607689284,
0.0723741949,
-0.0384665094,
0.0297228303,
-0.0043584146,
0.0279540103,
0.0450233035,
-0.0172980428,
0.0060358224,
-0.0473182276,
0.0753647014,
-0.0289850812,
-0.0115162591,
-0.0148446569,
0.028503906,
-0.0035392467,
-0.0141575262,
0.0148571879,
-0.0320011675,
-0.0178793278,
-0.0038460139,
-0.009423729,
-0.0275455471,
-0.0405582897,
0.0326736383,
0.0583259575,
-0.0057571004,
0.0218219142,
-0.0195497274,
-0.0400645323,
0.0657359287,
-0.0107437614,
-0.0448336378,
-0.0069254851,
-0.0181141887,
-0.0059617544,
-0.0089351442,
0.0400477126,
0.0281988513,
-0.0260541253,
0.0162397604,
0.0119959088,
-0.0440003611,
0.0724884048,
-0.0903367922,
-0.0151791973,
-0.0145050148,
0.0000324946,
-0.0005710727,
0.0044717728,
0.0097242473,
-0.0120032681,
0.0041207271,
-0.0024271831,
0.0084374212,
-0.0382668525,
-0.0371375233,
-0.0347394757,
0.0389891155,
0.0085190525,
0.0500727892,
-0.0856790021,
-0.0321041457,
-0.0091912122,
-0.0035271337,
-0.0037889059,
-0.0099550067,
-0.0404184684,
0.022794731,
0.0256530102,
0.030246323,
0.0085756052,
0.0142312646,
-0.0157700907,
-0.0384109579,
0.0105692139,
-0.0128166499,
0.0411381871,
-0.019719705,
0.0126049714,
0.0455320999,
0.0336863026,
-0.0211271215,
0.0032056,
0.0008204712,
-0.044283133,
-0.0324399248,
-0.0688324794,
-0.0201220475,
0.0606299713,
0.0253694709,
-0.0022139999,
-0.0264221765,
-0.0244729202,
-0.0231978502,
-0.0836846977,
0.0219678972,
-0.0665509999,
0.0038240771,
0.0175565612,
-0.0095456233,
0.0422651283,
0.003484488,
0.0095854066,
0.0189969745,
0.0138360364,
-0.0224758592,
0.0508006588,
0.0293191168,
-0.0046233279,
-0.0084740277,
-0.0066612349,
0.0062363171,
0.0184962135,
-0.0074494616,
-0.0003171322,
0.0305467024,
0.0219283141,
-0.0229504555,
0.0551146865,
0.0532878414,
-0.0252448395,
-0.0401155353,
0.0181706268,
0.0051835338,
-0.0301810578,
-0.0250082947,
0.0259092674,
-0.0319508947,
-0.0277835149,
-0.0148947258,
0.0100122578,
0.0080214227,
-0.0207573213,
-0.0071230801,
-0.0458319895,
-0.0091983713,
-0.0263516083,
0.0058293818,
0.0366262794,
-0.0714129731,
-0.0455834344,
0.044942569,
0.0389211923,
-0.0117499512,
-0.0092656957,
-0.0774739385,
0.0075957789,
0.0832769871,
0.0206666477,
0.0027619998,
-0.0457028262,
-0.0277609657,
-0.0356671959,
-0.0210520588,
0.0237431731,
0.011800373,
0.0316829868,
-0.0042848093,
0.0199144389,
0.0291626062,
0.0476161093,
-0.0137581797,
-0.0137222186,
0.0313610993,
-0.0265443139,
0.0204179604,
-0.0541063026,
0.0350337476,
-0.00374371,
-0.0408049449,
-0.0040157014,
0.0041232314,
0.0581669062,
0.0071675326,
0.0284736846,
0.0271967147,
0.0633105561,
-0.0849003941,
-0.0260244757,
-0.0045432444,
0.0436754785,
0.0062344735,
-0.0010084771,
0.0129508516,
-0.0027912087,
-0.0036716275,
-0.0533256158,
0.011734359,
-0.0023707235,
-0.0079301512,
0.0570175573,
-0.0067859534,
0.0285045318,
0.0088050691,
0.0057243486,
-0.0372951776,
0.0090058716,
-0.0258011166,
-0.0014799084,
-0.036533501,
-0.1146449745,
0.0018182807,
-0.0570302904,
0.0136509072,
0.0411640964,
0.0099853585,
-0.0051011299,
-0.0094278408,
-0.0362254567,
0.0071435189,
-0.01026983,
-0.0749375448,
0.013309353,
0.0329691246,
0.0503358506,
0.0550102405,
0.018969385,
-0.0329684615,
0.0300763268,
-0.0161507186,
-0.0533619858,
0.0270317122,
0.0168152526,
0.0502811484,
0.0373688787,
-0.0413093418,
-0.0642384067,
-0.0134887686,
-0.0736348554,
0.0155733293,
0.0049323784,
-0.0812473297,
-0.0283842124,
-0.0172816515,
-0.0178629681,
0.0012621264,
-0.0096215447,
-0.038187407,
0.0066514472,
-0.0466040373,
0.0059025283,
0.0413235277,
-0.0124809276,
0.0328048766,
0.0529310815,
-0.0135010025,
-0.0216152184,
0.0332919843,
-0.0536997952,
-0.0319743268,
0.0172732174,
-0.0528603457,
0.0348215327,
0.0528085716,
0.0178650506,
0.0125961415,
-0.0279968809,
0.0061197258,
-0.0581814684,
0.0098305959,
-0.0231113043,
-0.0243859794,
-0.0416881926,
0.0104692113,
-0.0204604398,
-0.0418009833,
0.0326766148,
0.0112981675,
0.0377519093,
-0.0831695199,
-0.0091632176,
-0.0329582021,
-0.0509554967,
0.0167111587,
0.0158106592,
0.0054291314,
-0.0099070836,
0.0760424286,
-0.0183911286,
-0.0079472912,
-0.0649615377,
0.0302971881,
-0.0001473609,
0.0447436124,
0.0034862712,
-0.0034677139,
-0.0031077396,
-0.0199268162,
-0.0376375876,
-0.0071052737,
-0.00764998,
0.0271362923,
-0.0581979565,
0.106777668,
-0.0200718548,
0.0355072618,
-0.0019364732,
-0.0064969659,
0.0297099147,
-0.0024262452,
0.0249703936,
-0.0748696923,
0.0070292959,
-0.0088625196,
0.022451235,
0.0419360958,
0.008099474,
0.0594762303,
-0.010811761,
0.0368315279,
0.0011306325,
-0.0478557572,
-0.0345861986,
0.0555677786,
0.0308000818,
-0.0656471178,
0.0341007039,
0.0885004103,
0.0295257978,
-0.0534526967,
0.0154254222,
0.0017750543,
-0.0326283537,
-0.0437037162,
0.0149385007,
-0.0389895067,
-0.0151179377,
0.017760383,
0.0145424241,
-0.0451932997,
-0.0661043003,
0.0214724168,
-0.0187235344,
0.0535355993,
0.0142084109,
-0.0484857224,
-0.0699051768,
-0.0586038418,
0.0203511566,
-0.0449926779,
-0.0069465712,
0.0063705808,
-0.0000171986,
-0.0141334347,
-0.0080923755,
-0.0688096732,
-0.0812734514,
0.0134231728,
-0.0050032865,
0.004519016,
0.0611290969,
0.0173233543,
-0.0572299436,
0.0025174357,
0.0077357604,
-0.0194982309,
-0.0336202234,
-0.0174326245,
0.080589585,
0.0070799412,
-0.0044793575,
-0.0596534237,
-0.007024447,
-0.0411331132,
-0.0045306259,
0.0154879857,
0.106105417,
-0.0129829664,
-0.0452556759,
-0.0526164994,
-0.0100458208,
-0.00985533,
0.0463593565,
0.0248469338,
-0.0132134501,
-0.0200030096,
0.0180474501,
0.0197286177,
-0.06473957,
-0.0142883426,
0.0286458526,
-0.0165011249,
-0.0805496871,
-0.0208700541,
-0.0097972294,
0.036320217,
-0.0550593361,
-0.0162975267,
0.0102095837,
0.0206079297,
-0.0273868032,
-0.0123963272,
0.0096177114,
0.0340248793,
0.0308891833,
-0.0446646698,
-0.0135279084,
0.0468442477,
0.0809789598,
-0.018099336,
0.0841735527,
-0.0181045644,
-0.0571624339,
0.00404994,
0.0131291691,
0.0269174017,
-0.049208317,
0.021823585,
0.0289828591,
0.020072123,
0.0341540314,
0.0166621525,
-0.0581047125,
-0.0575148724,
-0.0459208377,
-0.0081513384,
-0.0256508738,
0.0113880979,
0.0140052969,
-0.0022250973,
0.0203602221,
-0.0057690097,
0.0069053369,
0.0573947988,
0.0279168654,
0.017810313,
-0.0024918262,
-0.0428695194,
-0.0695504621,
0.0195351969,
0.0086366236,
0.0202989262,
-0.0081566861,
-0.0044237277,
0.0106852651,
-0.0197915249,
-0.0716357976,
0.0126836998,
-0.0701783374,
0.0077711958,
-0.0798571184,
0.0582223684,
-0.0292318147,
0.0562097579,
0.0581698269,
-0.0379009619,
0.00252668,
0.0254200958,
0.001814662,
0.0122638028,
-0.0218209419,
0.0101439413,
-0.0283506252,
0.0403615609,
0.0075736768,
0.0717865452,
-0.0072364607,
-0.0087664314,
-0.0599999763,
-0.012842075,
0.0591689423,
0.0081467247,
0.0499646366,
-0.0142160673,
-0.0171239264,
-0.0413054451,
0.0543844476,
0.0140517959,
0.0440665781,
0.0305512417,
0.0152724795,
-0.0673298016,
-0.0746900812,
0.0692528486,
0.0331697762,
0.0952780992,
0.0083396481,
-0.0537023954,
-0.0045518386,
-0.0241283625,
0.0469025709,
-0.0114139887,
-0.0768168867,
0.0143235493,
-0.0771290138,
-0.0190953817,
0.0142719261,
-0.0295470543,
0.0147503559,
0.0105559016,
-0.0387424007,
0.0464237705,
0.0278408546,
-0.0254322868,
-0.0161718074,
0.0192644391,
-0.0223752316,
-0.0179189779,
-0.0075019356,
-5.53353276e-33,
-0.0040650321,
-0.0222798996,
-0.0214816146,
-0.0070608747,
0.002031605,
0.0173327066,
-0.0188059825,
-0.0253122486,
0.0195308998,
0.0216484182,
0.016958002,
-0.0127126472,
0.011208687,
-0.0038267605,
0.03060597,
0.0130656147,
0.0173134804,
0.0217880867,
0.0329952911,
0.0204795953,
-0.0053962693,
0.0218549054,
0.0465745293,
-0.0723129213,
0.0130108865,
-0.0025193517,
0.0229395945,
-0.0226409137,
-0.0124186436,
0.0975696817,
0.0054123607,
0.0243295878,
0.0460461639,
-0.0030463929,
0.0110045401,
-0.0313396975,
-0.0094910534,
0.010586787,
0.0085895183,
-0.0528969802,
0.0414304584,
-0.0768427551,
0.0599415526,
0.0167017151,
-0.0241891928,
0.0248806104,
0.0028348865,
-0.0202102959,
-0.0253998041,
-0.0314177349,
-0.0296443403,
0.0609794781,
-0.0229094978,
0.0538472123,
0.0249667149,
0.0041087721,
-0.0422516614,
0.1098015904,
0.0499250479,
0.0090436647,
0.0751422942,
0.0188410953,
0.0082002766,
-0.0281564128,
-0.0081299115,
0.0210679043,
0.0190843642,
-0.0303342342,
-0.0254397746,
0.006730631,
-0.0115089417,
0.0248457827,
0.0058143931,
0.010452955,
0.0333831534,
-0.0060806163,
-0.1134354919,
0.0657193139,
-0.0813428536,
0.0590051003,
0.0220897049,
0.0058331909,
-0.0330612175,
0.0014910009,
-0.0258803237,
-0.017583916,
-0.0259002931,
0.0039089695,
0.0439078137,
-0.0284931138,
-0.0282802992,
0.0344277509,
0.0192908142,
0.0177713595,
-0.0517001376,
-0.0149482721,
0.0263994597,
-0.0072569437,
-0.0264795851,
0.0329190083,
-0.0482961908,
-0.0395443477,
0.0143885277,
-0.013463595,
0.0290527306,
-0.0006681202,
0.009578743,
-0.0120107094,
-0.0512529202,
0.0048751612,
0.0058926302,
0.0332088582,
-0.0693660006,
0.069372274,
0.0328010581,
-0.0009886093,
0.0366006196,
0.0345648117,
0.0125518292,
-0.0261973776,
0.0038140651,
-0.0317729823,
-0.0153132994,
0.0394959375,
-0.0087700533,
0.0084944312,
-0.0046485835,
0.0360441282,
0.0159373321,
-0.0321970508,
-0.0058559175,
-0.0083387913,
2.636e-7,
0.1150022075,
0.0501714014,
0.0074287737,
0.016006358,
0.0229862165,
-0.0038536994,
-0.0302911662,
0.0048321006,
0.0040681916,
0.0432525277,
0.0520753562,
-0.0096228365,
0.0278795473,
0.0634953827,
-0.0314417407,
0.0322892517,
-0.0770193711,
0.0105120335,
-0.0631830841,
-0.0170911439,
0.0877060071,
0.0458528362,
-0.0264590774,
0.0099317189,
0.0281110965,
-0.0142398532,
0.0050264234,
-0.0393836275,
-0.0305874497,
0.0332304053,
-0.0119363526,
0.0304869339,
0.0074695805,
0.0606951863,
-0.0176458489,
-0.0016966742,
-0.0312565602,
0.107618019,
-0.050715521,
0.0027378143,
0.037438944,
-0.0434278287,
0.0212753471,
-0.0637417585,
0.0329180062,
-0.0097778337,
-0.0157128014,
0.0398911647,
-0.0485695042,
0.0262077469,
0.0469286814,
-0.0250902157,
-0.0245237872,
0.0534150787,
-0.0025077513,
0.009352101,
-0.0454026833,
-0.0393023305,
-0.0023164628,
0.0097154034,
-0.0229875054,
-0.0576878265,
0.0232662093,
-0.0150070889,
-0.0176512804,
-0.0369676165,
0.0579395294,
2.435505598e-34,
0.0494334958,
0.0070510781,
-0.024366213,
0.0358396098,
0.0350578353,
0.0084055318,
-0.0031058507,
0.0228281748,
-0.0338019691,
-0.0455971099,
0.0094466098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16145v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16145v1 | The Confidence-Competence Gap in Large Language Models: A Cognitive Study | 2023-09-28T03:50:09 | 2023-09-28T03:50:09 | Aniket Kumar Singh, Suman Devkota, Bishal Lamichhane, Uttam Dhakal, Chandra Dhakal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, ACM-class: I.2.0 | Large Language Models (LLMs) have acquired ubiquitous attention for their
performances across diverse domains. Our study here searches through LLMs'
cognitive abilities and confidence dynamics. We dive deep into understanding
the alignment between their self-assessed confidence and actual performance. We
exploit these models with diverse sets of questionnaires and real-world
scenarios and extract how LLMs exhibit confidence in their responses. Our
findings reveal intriguing instances where models demonstrate high confidence
even when they answer incorrectly. This is reminiscent of the Dunning-Kruger
effect observed in human psychology. In contrast, there are cases where models
exhibit low confidence with correct answers revealing potential underestimation
biases. Our results underscore the need for a deeper understanding of their
cognitive processes. By examining the nuances of LLMs' self-assessment
mechanism, this investigation provides noteworthy revelations that serve to
advance the functionalities and broaden the potential applications of these
formidable language models. | [
0.0387275741,
0.0885990411,
-0.033615388,
0.0170612931,
-0.0458430126,
0.0075575751,
0.0172607824,
-0.0332089029,
0.015097633,
-0.0349159166,
-0.0447625928,
-0.0520303287,
0.0139974104,
0.0298677795,
0.0377049334,
-0.0080902483,
0.0124926493,
-0.0525675453,
0.0367087163,
-0.048561845,
-0.0369553715,
-0.0095108328,
-0.0133511377,
0.0357132778,
0.0239872653,
-0.0263394285,
0.0250275731,
-0.0286182221,
-0.031631507,
-0.0441596322,
0.0158619117,
0.0715893731,
0.0129129263,
0.0426931046,
0.0000018833,
-0.0561826155,
0.018784659,
-0.0246221609,
-0.0347934365,
0.033098232,
0.0438655056,
0.0202473737,
-0.0018309413,
0.0154732224,
-0.0466382727,
-0.010774726,
0.0157174096,
0.0183835402,
0.0136882709,
0.0175044928,
0.01543226,
0.030312743,
-0.001345073,
-0.0113331415,
-0.0215816088,
-0.0605029128,
0.0470571406,
0.0288795903,
-0.0138701433,
-0.019675076,
-0.0197153464,
0.0336196013,
0.0053470936,
-0.0035053615,
-0.0145004578,
0.0247963704,
0.0094882883,
-0.0508421697,
-0.011718737,
0.0030006552,
0.0386210196,
-0.0226446856,
-0.027548695,
-0.0053146034,
0.0125961863,
0.0159363244,
-0.0625806525,
0.0414884165,
0.0253500398,
-0.014321899,
-0.0264180433,
0.0391567983,
0.0436852016,
0.007944013,
-0.0083424412,
0.0897432566,
0.0102684358,
-0.0237416904,
0.0123311263,
0.0220870171,
-0.0077683209,
-0.0804862976,
-0.0091849091,
0.0357575975,
-0.0252892282,
0.0393381603,
-0.0063140704,
0.033798825,
0.0257105399,
-0.025333466,
0.0285529457,
0.0249479376,
0.0049426612,
0.0345776528,
-0.0037931623,
0.0588942021,
0.001286673,
-0.0101337498,
0.0102549018,
-0.0049242433,
-0.0212930944,
-0.0240690876,
0.0137146944,
-0.0019823967,
0.0195134263,
-0.0088898763,
-0.0598442368,
0.007369732,
-0.0141878808,
0.0384203047,
-0.0067216451,
0.0335859768,
-0.0102499267,
-0.0431314148,
-0.0867214277,
0.0385489687,
0.0067150504,
0.0232455414,
-0.0058111972,
-0.0714906231,
0.027994588,
-0.0139449444,
-0.0312146172,
-0.0296308957,
0.007952854,
0.0743555799,
-0.0022585932,
-0.0209182408,
0.0059009036,
-0.0055789356,
-0.0345968306,
-0.0840270743,
-0.0196240861,
-0.0562037192,
-0.022374101,
0.0537338406,
0.0166691039,
-0.0518274345,
0.0236899108,
-0.0001276695,
-0.0461230315,
0.0640334487,
-0.0016646851,
0.0508912094,
0.0215357095,
0.0179600231,
-0.0006712051,
0.0531119928,
0.0382397659,
-0.0139693143,
0.0301873293,
-0.0128484787,
0.0355563611,
0.0276922602,
-0.0206929147,
0.0024019871,
-0.024003014,
0.0133206537,
0.0005980292,
0.0281944294,
0.0407638662,
0.0578640588,
-0.0040538958,
0.0140067562,
0.1253956556,
0.0489940681,
-0.0200566035,
0.0091969492,
0.0291855298,
-0.0017949188,
0.0400760733,
0.0072811861,
-0.0573381037,
0.0180377606,
-0.0213504024,
0.0045485198,
0.0111569753,
0.0270485114,
-0.0065604527,
-0.0302458834,
-0.0139207318,
0.0090650655,
-0.0049085263,
0.0520187356,
0.0348009057,
-0.0234898776,
-0.0198000688,
0.0001391744,
0.0006394867,
-0.0161095653,
-0.0019168016,
-0.0714740604,
0.0306340288,
0.0298639648,
0.0271118768,
0.0164809078,
0.0105894059,
-0.0038141892,
-0.006914184,
0.0582347289,
0.0909473673,
0.0046976283,
-0.0292826481,
-0.0214068498,
-0.0067274617,
-0.0316957794,
0.0402157642,
0.0119362762,
0.0258741155,
0.0248072762,
-0.0089728655,
-0.0371024385,
-0.0315086916,
0.0107531799,
-0.0654699728,
-0.0396773517,
-0.0416190773,
-0.0242273398,
0.0160514992,
-0.0202683378,
-0.0035237763,
0.0481854938,
0.0137788439,
0.0165509395,
-0.0472720191,
0.0022686839,
-0.0412249081,
0.031102689,
0.0432957262,
0.0093017463,
-0.0205343124,
-0.0174109954,
0.0218188465,
-0.0288202334,
0.0208336301,
-0.0148844505,
0.0313341282,
-0.0201554168,
0.0506831072,
-0.0528240353,
0.0194601454,
-0.0342420861,
0.0616839379,
0.0057560201,
0.044179298,
0.021181237,
0.0170196127,
0.0085602785,
-0.0368979685,
-0.0288589336,
-0.0051622312,
-0.0084342072,
0.0228422694,
0.0322769322,
-0.0415895544,
-0.0452088416,
-0.0303136036,
-0.0596683174,
-0.0047467696,
0.0126818381,
0.0010880183,
0.014410085,
-0.0525049604,
-0.032706622,
0.0022893692,
-0.0292101186,
-0.0056317295,
0.0314011686,
0.039654322,
0.0185761172,
-0.0148697328,
-0.0109664518,
-0.0530584604,
0.0078215767,
-0.025762517,
0.046218127,
0.025994407,
0.0329809338,
-0.0348739699,
0.0383364931,
-0.0536119044,
0.0310745332,
-0.0066625029,
-0.0359442569,
0.0332402512,
-0.0028103408,
-0.001706108,
0.066192247,
0.0098069003,
0.0124856131,
0.0903828517,
-0.0342189558,
-0.0395610929,
-0.0043278555,
-0.0167566352,
-0.0586819388,
-0.0529189147,
-0.0502118282,
-0.019591324,
0.086792618,
0.0410875864,
0.0025426592,
-0.0185511075,
0.0544603914,
-0.0477379486,
-0.0448775515,
-0.0106763458,
-0.0146687189,
-0.0118618459,
0.0919588581,
-0.0108023379,
-0.0596734881,
0.0669744983,
-0.0133407786,
0.0048408937,
0.0098388838,
-0.0034688932,
0.0171279665,
0.0813478753,
0.0150872376,
-0.0065077832,
0.034014836,
-0.0084964177,
-0.0685389489,
-0.0248638373,
0.0022050662,
-0.0698458403,
-0.0040954147,
-0.0695054755,
-0.020941779,
0.00952347,
-0.0396807529,
-0.0652248487,
-0.0143177193,
-0.0796182081,
0.0016745691,
0.0195599478,
-0.0415218174,
-0.0432932787,
-0.0165732391,
0.0502708182,
-0.0185965281,
-0.0388325006,
-0.0323831476,
-0.0111567285,
0.0019703696,
0.0658436641,
0.0174061116,
0.0924797803,
-0.046373345,
0.0385599434,
0.0348551124,
0.0241706576,
0.0563734956,
-0.0343331546,
-0.0228780415,
0.0379160307,
0.017604284,
-0.0163156409,
0.0728393793,
0.0519246273,
-0.02657938,
-0.0090518352,
0.1383124888,
0.0200076327,
-0.0089608058,
0.0132908132,
-0.0467957929,
0.0165360849,
0.0646822825,
0.0149692493,
-0.028004365,
0.0010722112,
0.0151284141,
0.0019911965,
-0.0587387793,
-0.0447460078,
-0.0231833868,
-0.1216301024,
0.0412353948,
-0.0016628837,
-0.0101786805,
0.0005069227,
-0.0271089375,
0.0191589892,
0.0079235407,
0.0492565185,
0.0087750303,
-0.0094982423,
0.0011327215,
0.0066966722,
-0.0485802852,
-0.0781530738,
0.0673873648,
-0.0165814366,
0.0958293527,
0.0263043232,
0.0289349072,
-0.0053942259,
-0.0409535803,
-0.0039852709,
-0.0252879765,
-0.0002599806,
0.0234358031,
0.0289140288,
-0.0015002192,
-0.0004852544,
-0.0168474633,
-0.0186115336,
-0.0312096365,
0.0024884725,
0.0122808991,
0.0588358492,
0.001703537,
-0.0635121763,
-0.0059177196,
0.0047776774,
0.0003098109,
0.0828413144,
0.0223799031,
-0.0436732434,
-0.0042661815,
-0.0335756727,
-0.0138124973,
0.0105263619,
-0.0774760172,
0.0566237532,
0.063426204,
0.0163639821,
-0.0283896439,
-0.0221814811,
0.0252423324,
-0.0111662745,
0.0127945831,
-0.0118974736,
0.0122244619,
-0.0162845124,
-0.0242443681,
0.0044946172,
-0.0514808595,
0.050816413,
-0.0563393533,
0.0569042861,
0.0248582717,
-0.0236181244,
-0.0071434579,
0.0041913083,
-0.0649427399,
-0.0747494176,
0.0079639331,
0.0413549356,
0.0361562073,
-0.0282903872,
-0.0042943717,
-0.0774782524,
0.0290420279,
-0.0079769557,
-0.0605448857,
0.0250101388,
0.0268737376,
0.0227692705,
-0.0032535247,
0.0475922637,
-0.0091049988,
0.0065358011,
0.0276061948,
0.0206257962,
-0.0109251402,
-0.0703053027,
0.0360024869,
-0.0061260695,
0.0487919003,
-0.0135069173,
0.0188356768,
-0.0090207327,
-0.0268928241,
-0.0252893548,
-0.0348599777,
0.0015436409,
-0.0425972342,
0.0524529032,
0.0063076098,
0.0034377661,
-0.0454554334,
-0.0106401015,
0.0232810285,
-0.018755747,
-0.0034788935,
0.0221069492,
-0.0044103591,
0.0355459191,
-0.0152321775,
-0.0147254504,
0.0001056362,
-0.0197315067,
0.0343123004,
0.054675974,
0.0571072735,
-0.026311744,
-0.0376919471,
-0.000634527,
-0.0310214795,
-0.0796036497,
-0.0857521445,
0.0275248159,
0.0174991507,
0.0234564319,
-0.0180115085,
0.0339882784,
-0.0501062535,
-0.0030734611,
-0.0275625065,
-0.0277752057,
0.0198761057,
-0.0204407275,
0.0614257678,
0.004373298,
-0.0273350496,
0.0147229144,
0.0745182857,
0.0104714893,
0.057028722,
-0.0363332257,
-0.0388776958,
-0.0264130328,
-0.0324061327,
0.0233106315,
0.040726874,
-0.0337365605,
0.0157349519,
-0.0773521438,
-0.0855459124,
-0.012478915,
0.0315739438,
-0.0075662062,
-0.0747132748,
-0.0271356516,
0.0685746968,
-0.0071726912,
0.0034404933,
-0.0376366489,
0.0240021702,
-0.0037702054,
0.0373118743,
-0.0429182872,
-6.502239655e-33,
-0.0123624559,
-0.0593590029,
0.0069012316,
-0.0381193645,
0.0219097305,
-0.014382951,
-0.0345597267,
0.048692815,
-0.0330885313,
0.0074080657,
-0.0265432298,
0.0040110578,
0.0140560428,
0.0025211086,
0.0532855913,
0.0300721899,
0.0431613959,
-0.0037045483,
-0.0257207509,
-0.0190131199,
0.0087750452,
-0.0109230382,
0.040376626,
-0.0849931613,
0.0684334338,
-0.0115613919,
-0.0128511554,
0.025045855,
-0.0279858019,
0.0518962257,
-0.054052081,
0.027736757,
0.0140877943,
-0.0358214453,
-0.0090425434,
0.0015842406,
-0.0026261844,
-0.0121408189,
0.0221811291,
0.0196686294,
-0.0019452978,
-0.0150256744,
0.0029919862,
-0.0170429721,
-0.0608833544,
-0.0007948249,
0.015859399,
-0.0388960764,
-0.0072183218,
0.0185160227,
-0.0543432236,
0.0045459829,
0.0063920086,
-0.0025076868,
-0.0270994958,
0.0245899521,
-0.0096978983,
-0.0182317439,
-0.0630588979,
0.0189618301,
0.0058561503,
0.0312241558,
0.0943402201,
0.0201584511,
0.0106878066,
0.0717906654,
0.0342065394,
0.0369074084,
0.0019857972,
-0.0053049475,
0.0328779556,
0.0172058605,
0.0487645678,
0.0623740591,
-0.0046411706,
-0.009173804,
-0.0353100747,
-0.0185419824,
0.0195039138,
0.0192594863,
0.0753174201,
0.0085006626,
-0.0353104062,
-0.0451954342,
-0.0749599114,
-0.039791286,
-0.0390817598,
-0.016320046,
0.0190154333,
0.0138162859,
0.0098731434,
-0.0114804413,
0.0095983706,
-0.0376900397,
-0.0715650246,
-0.0195977818,
-0.0252075624,
0.0281764269,
0.0047234148,
0.0627457574,
-0.0591868311,
-0.0055119875,
-0.0360755473,
0.0209724177,
-0.0055733966,
0.03389211,
-0.005166186,
0.0186906103,
-0.0751295164,
0.0031003396,
-0.0290591139,
0.0117223682,
0.0485359728,
-0.0082022063,
0.0396084525,
-0.0144869881,
-0.0239104647,
-0.0203501396,
-0.032260254,
-0.0342539027,
-0.0120882932,
0.0092686126,
-0.0185744427,
0.0095215514,
-0.0315599814,
-0.0355860703,
-0.0554734506,
0.018869102,
0.0336919054,
0.0001458653,
-0.0143301776,
-0.0234342832,
2.631e-7,
0.0230189636,
0.0532191917,
-0.0533462465,
0.0200647451,
0.0508710742,
0.0453983992,
-0.0265524648,
-0.0044953171,
0.0530396365,
-0.0630116016,
-0.0361666381,
0.0231800172,
0.0549249984,
0.0406609476,
-0.029539289,
-0.0228701774,
-0.0339715593,
0.0246673618,
-0.0251133516,
0.019466687,
0.0202732552,
0.0682703182,
0.0241804067,
-0.0044016014,
-0.0353111736,
-0.051726982,
0.0716876909,
-0.0206684992,
-0.0011325293,
0.0344257839,
0.0271158442,
0.0309484471,
0.011175069,
0.0628039613,
0.0099617345,
0.0193243418,
-0.0185082685,
0.0565132797,
0.0291064363,
0.0319875889,
-0.0113283508,
-0.0070026205,
0.0053166635,
-0.0711903274,
0.0663138032,
-0.0957988575,
-0.0536568649,
-0.0432988629,
0.0441804826,
-0.033293087,
0.0530127026,
-0.0231410787,
-0.0262687113,
0.0084523037,
0.023042731,
0.0199605245,
-0.0051875841,
-0.0319822617,
-0.0233560186,
-0.0121536991,
-0.0363778062,
-0.0749878287,
-0.0313584507,
0.0039946083,
0.0148420995,
-0.0621722639,
0.0495419353,
2.250593448e-34,
0.0459118858,
0.0422410294,
0.006114536,
-0.0185147952,
0.0662582889,
-0.0119208777,
0.0180348959,
0.0262420624,
0.0305985957,
-0.064340882,
-0.0150234262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16090v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16090v1 | TPE: Towards Better Compositional Reasoning over Conceptual Tools with Multi-persona Collaboration | 2023-09-28T01:18:53 | 2023-09-28T01:18:53 | Hongru Wang, Huimin Wang, Lingzhi Wang, Minda Hu, Rui Wang, Boyang Xue, Hongyuan Lu, Fei Mi, Kam-Fai Wong | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional performance in
planning the use of various functional tools, such as calculators and
retrievers, particularly in question-answering tasks. In this paper, we expand
the definition of these tools, centering on conceptual tools within the context
of dialogue systems. A conceptual tool specifies a cognitive concept that aids
systematic or investigative thought. These conceptual tools play important
roles in practice, such as multiple psychological or tutoring strategies being
dynamically applied in a single turn to compose helpful responses. To further
enhance the reasoning and planning capability of LLMs with these conceptual
tools, we introduce a multi-persona collaboration framework: Think-Plan-Execute
(TPE). This framework decouples the response generation process into three
distinct roles: Thinker, Planner, and Executor. Specifically, the Thinker
analyzes the internal status exhibited in the dialogue context, such as user
emotions and preferences, to formulate a global guideline. The Planner then
generates executable plans to call different conceptual tools (e.g., sources or
strategies), while the Executor compiles all intermediate results into a
coherent response. This structured approach not only enhances the
explainability and controllability of responses but also reduces token
redundancy. We demonstrate the effectiveness of TPE across various dialogue
response generation tasks, including multi-source (FoCus) and multi-strategy
interactions (CIMA and PsyQA). This reveals its potential to handle real-world
dialogue interactions that require more complicated tool learning beyond just
functional tools. The full code and data will be released for reproduction. | [
0.0791342184,
0.0366929136,
-0.0462202355,
0.0460411943,
-0.0513009354,
-0.0186945368,
0.0115142427,
-0.066371493,
-0.036093656,
-0.0209983457,
-0.0173461791,
-0.0302222949,
-0.0365653262,
0.0397874638,
0.0269562658,
-0.0900474414,
0.0171847325,
-0.0262927376,
0.0157744084,
0.0000371978,
0.015812749,
0.039152056,
-0.0410763398,
0.0869834721,
-0.0110128019,
-0.0189506523,
-0.0505556241,
-0.0067542852,
0.0067929188,
-0.0108808605,
0.0189232808,
0.0217822529,
0.0026203911,
0.000538195,
0.0000023403,
-0.0555806309,
-0.0111615844,
-0.0189793408,
0.0056977277,
-0.060542997,
-0.0023196116,
0.0427368097,
0.0225557424,
0.0193217974,
-0.0657307729,
0.026229132,
0.0162379276,
0.0338259637,
0.0802720487,
0.0361982323,
-0.0002599456,
-0.0584708527,
-0.0162366703,
0.0167123936,
-0.0037135372,
-0.0393133424,
0.0017035058,
-0.0095302584,
0.0307130311,
-0.026614761,
0.0143673932,
0.0070691365,
0.0277246591,
-0.0460108109,
0.0030543727,
0.0050327312,
-0.0061125597,
-0.0559446551,
0.0022083696,
0.0796078369,
0.0544464178,
0.0134454742,
0.0044605369,
0.0006156394,
0.0223762244,
0.0074783727,
-0.0462735966,
0.0159140807,
-0.0326912403,
-0.0268943291,
-0.0309908725,
-0.0158553291,
-0.0107292291,
0.034760084,
-0.0433868207,
0.0687618479,
-0.0216896459,
-0.0083010653,
0.001331508,
0.00660002,
-0.0104970355,
-0.0683141351,
0.0042790417,
0.1004495844,
-0.0861576423,
0.0264292676,
-0.0088788019,
0.0073901382,
-0.0074041532,
-0.0054998351,
0.0496641621,
0.0704138204,
0.0266801696,
0.0167526156,
0.0151163554,
0.0358277112,
-0.0321840681,
0.0272643156,
-0.0250132401,
-0.0128335608,
-0.0854032338,
-0.0378750637,
-0.0331717804,
0.056595102,
-0.0122539187,
-0.0332955718,
0.0054929303,
0.0684144422,
-0.0358559713,
0.0063012843,
-0.0032925124,
0.0186394267,
-0.0228266008,
-0.0143340658,
-0.0795038193,
0.0487985127,
-0.0517562442,
0.0041541872,
0.0179892518,
-0.0593498051,
-0.021663202,
0.0152831413,
-0.0177528579,
0.0134104816,
-0.0192315746,
0.0335766226,
-0.0493103936,
0.0177076887,
-0.0047589452,
-0.0992830992,
-0.0202351995,
-0.0708405375,
-0.010206732,
-0.0524893925,
0.0191911794,
0.0271468144,
-0.0432130396,
-0.0303934664,
0.0312752984,
0.0140948603,
-0.0073306859,
0.0427957885,
0.0278065372,
0.0276066419,
0.0238207877,
0.0322194211,
-0.0547287986,
0.0705889761,
0.032833647,
-0.0036061425,
-0.0079257013,
0.0087144226,
0.0008580502,
0.0067417668,
0.0111808879,
-0.0341303982,
0.0112266093,
0.0180356819,
-0.0211001299,
0.0087738466,
0.005235828,
0.045298662,
-0.0368249491,
0.0340509228,
0.0215798281,
0.0305658411,
0.0153248087,
0.0274001751,
0.0691404343,
0.0193337891,
-0.0078178588,
0.0230452865,
-0.0062803729,
0.056372378,
0.0056861681,
-0.0119420448,
0.013545312,
0.0074726236,
-0.0255969055,
-0.0388720036,
0.0157456435,
0.0247228555,
-0.0286018364,
0.0242120121,
-0.0062549911,
0.0137759009,
-0.0310510211,
0.0483381972,
-0.0330078714,
-0.0413438864,
-0.0214988384,
-0.0435207598,
0.0554958247,
0.0949546844,
0.0530854836,
-0.0139506906,
-0.0505057313,
-0.0137468707,
-0.0203471612,
0.0312013086,
0.0270525143,
-0.0351330079,
-0.0123310909,
-0.03137758,
-0.0122126425,
-0.0513119698,
-0.0324209891,
0.0289658271,
0.0311719421,
-0.0468699299,
-0.0031578506,
0.0592734739,
0.0831297413,
0.0000281658,
0.002764768,
0.0209231004,
-0.0154832713,
0.0216238219,
0.0660061538,
0.0249427166,
0.0054881019,
0.0423319973,
0.0227268599,
-0.0097537097,
-0.0444214344,
0.0428208746,
-0.0342888758,
-0.0163699426,
0.0358645581,
0.0111454111,
0.0077461731,
-0.0340467058,
0.0190075282,
-0.0529280826,
0.0523394272,
-0.037082877,
0.0264708716,
-0.0404590145,
0.0068745031,
0.0147550898,
-0.028769128,
-0.0154500445,
0.0423803627,
-0.0083882753,
-0.0147677418,
0.0430443808,
0.0134333773,
0.0054740552,
-0.0482996963,
0.0227440167,
0.009433181,
-0.0020103338,
-0.0166132431,
0.0001889109,
0.0066337427,
-0.0412070565,
-0.0535831414,
-0.0769369379,
-0.006664258,
-0.0173951536,
0.0038894031,
-0.0051984186,
0.0184073932,
0.0050632921,
-0.0106305731,
-0.0230756793,
0.0164505728,
0.0282279626,
0.0225060321,
0.0280503482,
0.0328495465,
-0.0099866781,
-0.0080813691,
0.0296953656,
-0.0275397319,
0.031110486,
-0.0058847954,
-0.0258856583,
-0.0344011262,
0.0091880085,
-0.0469981432,
0.0245346613,
-0.009410263,
-0.0329628326,
0.0725465566,
-0.0160847753,
0.0338633284,
0.0333565138,
0.007261422,
0.0417776927,
0.0320304111,
-0.0297539122,
-0.1031949669,
0.0712333545,
-0.0092667257,
-0.021665683,
-0.027075056,
-0.016843548,
-0.0049890662,
0.0367744304,
0.0060549369,
0.0191662963,
-0.0567227751,
0.0477811545,
0.0361267924,
-0.0502247177,
0.0023543525,
-0.0671951249,
-0.0214625094,
0.0331097692,
0.0078211362,
0.0075567127,
0.0954354703,
0.0096843448,
-0.0381804928,
-0.021876011,
0.0079764919,
-0.0535936691,
0.0547230467,
-0.0376380533,
0.0074812584,
-0.0085319681,
-0.0079669701,
-0.0401917472,
-0.0430051833,
0.0117273983,
-0.0249881633,
0.0259940773,
-0.0846735165,
-0.0110497614,
0.0091385813,
-0.0459623337,
-0.0628005639,
0.0048771952,
-0.0412260853,
0.0056483326,
0.0502674617,
-0.0213562362,
-0.0182518326,
-0.0102304267,
0.0639039129,
-0.0086478367,
0.0033121838,
-0.0098189386,
-0.022094721,
-0.002112739,
0.0277807806,
0.0404766463,
0.0168333594,
-0.0269316994,
0.0747799799,
0.0494736359,
0.0208262019,
-0.0324614793,
-0.0006976784,
-0.0160044152,
0.0221189745,
0.0102830203,
-0.0097640147,
0.0285040308,
0.0709586069,
-0.0467359722,
-0.0103555769,
0.1085524783,
0.0497868545,
-0.0418810397,
-0.0183401667,
-0.0522419587,
0.0469412804,
0.0301789101,
0.0514281243,
-0.0565071367,
-0.0097784465,
-0.0123674879,
0.0076389862,
-0.0389323905,
-0.0436910652,
-0.0340978354,
-0.1115829498,
0.034646105,
-0.0122221783,
-0.0102617266,
0.0383911505,
-0.0135731744,
0.0199126452,
0.027319219,
-0.0276272893,
0.013793394,
0.0237099081,
0.014633161,
0.0066363537,
-0.0376976877,
0.0115183201,
-0.0038570659,
0.0106164934,
0.0064070439,
0.0551570617,
0.0303634424,
0.0270405542,
-0.0280169174,
0.0132397767,
-0.0003116498,
0.0477997921,
-0.0182188116,
0.0332300439,
-0.0086024692,
0.0145648848,
-0.0357057378,
0.0431838818,
-0.0353838019,
-0.047578048,
0.0412108339,
0.0517906062,
-0.0496439077,
0.0103086624,
-0.0132144392,
0.0613457076,
0.0114019988,
0.0509064868,
0.0302048065,
-0.0427316241,
-0.0165464245,
0.0026049542,
-0.0239864308,
-0.1014420763,
-0.0118830306,
-0.0225734767,
0.0301665142,
0.050153017,
-0.0452636592,
-0.0590018556,
0.0709213465,
0.0538178906,
-0.0072719785,
-0.0445657633,
-0.0105741676,
0.0239563379,
0.0018757679,
-0.0108032636,
-0.0014940765,
0.0278761405,
-0.0177629329,
-0.0322615802,
-0.0003058783,
-0.0324214883,
0.0025749167,
0.0100172134,
-0.0282082539,
-0.0605045781,
-0.0400527306,
0.0736947581,
0.0266522113,
0.0235890895,
0.0215923768,
-0.048753079,
-0.0212023575,
-0.0052114087,
-0.0616844669,
-0.0182005744,
0.009593213,
0.0590643659,
0.0043382868,
0.0429363623,
-0.009729634,
0.0150766745,
-0.000251075,
0.0622576028,
-0.0531500503,
-0.0747100189,
0.0435244404,
0.0032138359,
-0.0083575556,
0.0066419272,
-0.0009108497,
-0.0101388302,
0.026212791,
-0.0241022315,
-0.0441543721,
-0.0574815832,
0.0068000853,
-0.0230375044,
-0.04071372,
0.0448477194,
-0.0550057553,
-0.0118749738,
0.017492475,
0.0212202407,
0.0076697436,
0.0422094613,
-0.0095953923,
0.0174581036,
0.0081848232,
-0.0218675286,
-0.0095760161,
0.0125003671,
0.0270592757,
0.0167115945,
0.1262858659,
0.0108827502,
-0.0287506096,
-0.007231541,
-0.0105318232,
-0.0705829859,
-0.090427503,
0.0428467505,
0.0159885902,
0.0131636532,
0.0525208488,
-0.0064383615,
-0.0450118333,
-0.000864769,
0.0102347117,
0.0355546288,
-0.0030948482,
-0.0427548662,
0.0363008268,
0.0262233317,
-0.0184676033,
-0.0482131653,
0.0439665243,
-0.0694507062,
0.0133928545,
-0.0290277507,
-0.0094821407,
-0.0598978885,
-0.0519014001,
0.0053881151,
0.0687099174,
-0.0071856622,
0.0253001284,
-0.0854938924,
-0.006710595,
-0.0114566227,
0.0027194258,
-0.0277583618,
-0.028503539,
0.042063009,
0.0572359525,
0.0061254115,
-0.0631136522,
-0.0470548347,
0.0426310971,
-0.0446704291,
-0.0091134263,
-0.0380439796,
-6.258785224e-33,
-0.0387495533,
-0.0564616695,
0.0668497458,
0.0419824235,
-0.0346763842,
-0.0227649156,
-0.045038987,
0.0357389338,
-0.0292289052,
0.0005932042,
-0.0020406027,
0.0002139531,
-0.0049827518,
0.0013006858,
-0.0103687802,
-0.0008642087,
0.0282378234,
0.0137023395,
-0.0243805293,
0.0244236011,
0.0510399118,
0.0005811465,
-0.0139248781,
-0.0694973543,
0.0043289857,
0.0168084297,
-0.0018565336,
0.0525702611,
-0.0207094625,
0.0642117187,
0.0041001034,
0.0200433098,
0.0141405435,
0.0003244442,
-0.0003320985,
0.0499325283,
-0.0028575461,
-0.0356616825,
0.0638683885,
0.0035534375,
-0.0582195334,
-0.060563419,
0.0152045758,
-0.0050555789,
0.0062994091,
-0.0109119313,
0.013367109,
0.0128201228,
-0.0013515867,
-0.0019927092,
-0.055620309,
-0.0056020473,
-0.0355586596,
-0.0452508368,
-0.0114165386,
0.0703047439,
-0.0039070975,
-0.0272315163,
-0.0335816853,
0.0258788392,
-0.0233771056,
-0.0265659839,
0.0485587604,
0.032042563,
-0.0021882008,
0.0484384149,
0.0203488581,
0.004409953,
-0.0706828237,
-0.0426416956,
-0.0231017936,
0.0747478083,
0.0204753093,
0.0555376783,
-0.0517045408,
0.0206033997,
-0.0161371045,
0.0204733945,
0.041121427,
0.0683219805,
0.0595148839,
0.0241443571,
-0.0105273919,
0.0120494803,
-0.0401574634,
0.0180715006,
-0.0300312079,
-0.0333131328,
0.0263342373,
0.004908002,
-0.013012127,
0.0125127388,
0.0167270843,
-0.0457918309,
0.0257101655,
0.0367151983,
-0.0271104313,
0.0509308577,
-0.0117926402,
0.0249887463,
-0.0178508181,
0.0082638673,
0.0338729694,
-0.0107923532,
0.0086173946,
0.0385519937,
-0.00288497,
0.0066746329,
-0.0255038682,
-0.0341751203,
-0.085812524,
0.0450662449,
-0.061447259,
-0.0096753985,
0.0093291765,
0.0295473784,
-0.0475908592,
-0.0115872193,
-0.0078670885,
-0.0470845588,
-0.041441109,
-0.0156814344,
0.0116281062,
-0.0036865806,
-0.0252606254,
0.0077051246,
0.0033270004,
-0.0149488961,
0.0139084058,
-0.0066093677,
-0.0202772524,
0.0167162418,
3.035e-7,
0.0269934684,
0.0133084506,
0.0035828403,
0.0475307591,
0.0132426322,
0.0250563696,
-0.0030732511,
-0.0054210429,
0.0482242554,
-0.0176209435,
0.0051851757,
0.0520803817,
0.0368546844,
0.0296072382,
-0.0822509527,
-0.0275470931,
0.0131116165,
-0.0291359145,
-0.0515564904,
0.0060884324,
0.096718207,
0.006209393,
0.0230736863,
0.0013614505,
-0.0153619694,
0.0044916081,
0.057620842,
-0.0137687009,
0.0017946458,
0.0343158469,
0.009237106,
-0.0320249051,
0.0478481464,
0.054694593,
0.0201654341,
0.0339087583,
-0.0254659895,
0.0728719011,
-0.0025611438,
-0.0549449995,
-0.0195858199,
-0.0288843513,
0.0239333231,
-0.0919142067,
0.0298440605,
-0.0683608875,
-0.0126879262,
0.0301816761,
-0.0000115622,
-0.0341347866,
-0.0261783861,
-0.0106922686,
0.0032403488,
0.0371181071,
0.006945218,
-0.0256475229,
0.0174485985,
-0.0588053241,
0.0008710809,
0.0042722533,
-0.0516454913,
-0.0289724935,
-0.0202193111,
-0.0215638801,
-0.0031831067,
-0.0415487438,
-0.0029346636,
2.726592896e-34,
-0.0135652805,
0.0162770972,
0.0395443663,
0.0807484984,
0.071965307,
0.0210435987,
-0.020133445,
0.0309749451,
0.0544749126,
-0.0793612525,
-0.0334857516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16082v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16082v1 | Forgetting Private Textual Sequences in Language Models via Leave-One-Out Ensemble | 2023-09-28T00:43:18 | 2023-09-28T00:43:18 | Zhe Liu, Ozlem Kalinli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent research has shown that language models have a tendency to memorize
rare or unique token sequences in the training corpus. After deploying a model,
practitioners might be asked to delete any personal information from the model
by individuals' requests. Re-training the underlying model every time
individuals would like to practice their rights to be forgotten is
computationally expensive. We employ a teacher-student framework and propose a
novel leave-one-out ensemble method to unlearn the targeted textual sequences
that need to be forgotten from the model. In our approach, multiple teachers
are trained on disjoint sets; for each targeted sequence to be removed, we
exclude the teacher trained on the set containing this sequence and aggregate
the predictions from remaining teachers to provide supervision during
fine-tuning. Experiments on LibriSpeech and WikiText-103 datasets show that the
proposed method achieves superior privacy-utility trade-offs than other
counterparts. | [
0.0501990467,
0.1053452343,
-0.0381474905,
0.0292964596,
-0.0717421249,
-0.0178835094,
0.0664169192,
-0.0193359926,
0.0131776165,
-0.0194090549,
0.0076472578,
-0.0656263828,
0.0062923501,
-0.0063905222,
0.0052886745,
-0.0072955545,
0.0328240469,
-0.0214697756,
-0.0095553156,
-0.0290920045,
-0.0221710969,
-0.0098367529,
0.0080897072,
0.0233769659,
0.0319222324,
-0.0172752384,
-0.0252857525,
-0.0489524119,
0.0158958994,
-0.0110717583,
0.0433744751,
0.0880525112,
-0.0036512439,
0.0602790788,
0.0000018724,
-0.0160468649,
-0.0822718218,
0.0093458705,
-0.0301815346,
0.0468444787,
-0.0254533626,
0.0527937748,
0.0256123748,
0.0192230586,
-0.0394466594,
0.0418759175,
0.0238151476,
0.0141535923,
0.0366942063,
0.0634173006,
0.0183480754,
0.0139398817,
-0.0209528152,
-0.0366487131,
0.0107818451,
-0.0389143676,
0.0156119438,
-0.0949731693,
-0.0322971679,
-0.0290589482,
-0.0037598321,
0.0446086153,
0.0116077466,
0.0081136823,
0.0378596932,
0.0412932374,
-0.0370473675,
-0.0457357205,
-0.0089350976,
0.0101978574,
0.0392926671,
-0.0214791652,
0.0581683218,
0.0084554777,
0.0310538728,
0.027009666,
-0.0049748225,
0.0270170067,
-0.0142594883,
0.0005550154,
-0.0228896253,
-0.0228585638,
0.0225978754,
0.0064034434,
0.0313002057,
0.0147900246,
0.0006062472,
0.0134937586,
-0.0342115015,
-0.003261491,
-0.0105758188,
-0.0732449815,
0.0651335567,
0.0149047887,
0.0270868409,
0.0270907469,
-0.038932398,
-0.0409125313,
0.0179970842,
0.0206451025,
0.0337570496,
-0.0090140896,
0.0296772737,
0.0304370094,
-0.0072789793,
0.0328560993,
0.0611220114,
0.0120129921,
0.0187089331,
0.03765646,
-0.0691319332,
-0.0082691619,
-0.0150438072,
0.0643246025,
-0.0251379572,
0.0285336021,
-0.0205901861,
-0.0113466354,
-0.0066373297,
0.0282583553,
-0.0063005551,
0.0259359572,
-0.0487651154,
-0.0130330902,
-0.0004852375,
-0.0365411267,
0.0166346356,
0.0005383186,
0.0308798924,
-0.0472384878,
-0.0282792132,
-0.0379269943,
0.0232253335,
-0.0066997148,
-0.0305959359,
0.0109579079,
0.0045226463,
-0.0551353507,
-0.013757579,
-0.0802570805,
0.0053270948,
-0.0372855701,
-0.0025319448,
-0.0532183424,
-0.0038063873,
-0.0327378735,
-0.0045745214,
-0.0849281773,
0.002249442,
0.034847308,
-0.0008130377,
0.029336663,
0.0106828855,
-0.0336693302,
0.0140016926,
0.0400698334,
0.0163554344,
0.0301775485,
-0.0081114862,
0.0337703042,
0.0384412855,
-0.022062337,
0.0308169574,
0.006441291,
0.0526702441,
-0.0133535462,
-0.0456154235,
0.0194388982,
0.0516978949,
-0.0487748757,
-0.0351272114,
0.0436198264,
-0.0270137601,
-0.0574621819,
0.0427183732,
0.0648475811,
-0.0141961696,
0.0251176301,
-0.0690027177,
0.008639236,
-0.0197266024,
0.0285920389,
-0.0323904529,
-0.0135654202,
-0.0629092604,
-0.0272772852,
0.009621961,
0.0137174893,
-0.0062882337,
-0.0076620369,
0.0105215143,
-0.0688965768,
0.0299824644,
0.0096460925,
0.0136623373,
0.0094748456,
-0.00544362,
0.0589110442,
0.031549409,
-0.0962025672,
0.0210443214,
-0.0268183779,
0.0111679845,
0.0716741607,
0.0463546775,
-0.0326509513,
0.0089739356,
-0.0477878265,
-0.0059634959,
-0.0101566846,
0.0009851739,
-0.0065461141,
0.0729637966,
-0.0693861097,
-0.058808364,
0.0581945255,
0.023140518,
0.0373413786,
0.0191312172,
-0.0267136078,
0.0230247527,
-0.0105783744,
-0.0041347411,
0.0471336171,
-0.0809864253,
-0.057534717,
0.0120380735,
0.0141195636,
0.0470669232,
0.0295657068,
-0.0029172038,
0.0142018897,
0.0436857492,
0.0124552594,
-0.0230078772,
-0.0443878956,
-0.0481602661,
-0.0421499312,
0.0088967914,
-0.0185772106,
0.0205392279,
0.0304981824,
-0.0007434413,
-0.0580836572,
-0.0026028974,
-0.0215505026,
0.0754466504,
-0.0301042348,
0.0221986528,
-0.0154474769,
0.0182827283,
-0.0249795988,
0.0232991166,
-0.055760175,
0.0043094493,
-0.0821493268,
-0.0337024853,
-0.0270527843,
-0.0654587373,
-0.0256200805,
-0.0022468872,
0.015322417,
0.0190126058,
0.0265437774,
-0.0274424925,
-0.046868246,
-0.0526228771,
-0.0403839499,
-0.001507465,
-0.0059044627,
0.0353395306,
-0.0174592659,
-0.0017662706,
-0.0038236228,
-0.0364350565,
-0.0401559249,
-0.0103629269,
-0.0486356616,
0.0239827149,
-0.0049684765,
0.0109672491,
-0.0425155982,
0.001559102,
-0.0208446681,
0.0115726618,
0.0385811068,
-0.0428903773,
-0.0138769401,
-0.0101284729,
0.0077226381,
-0.0474247411,
0.0546127185,
-0.00500185,
-0.0121266786,
-0.0246539805,
0.0156523883,
-0.0321053118,
0.0360617638,
-0.000339251,
0.0244229808,
0.0573566295,
0.001536142,
-0.0370766595,
-0.0103210425,
-0.0201466065,
-0.0094538601,
-0.0039127665,
0.0129872169,
-0.0288187042,
-0.0010941325,
0.0170113239,
-0.0286233798,
-0.0303288586,
0.0228952337,
-0.0011044887,
-0.0435915142,
-0.0110566951,
-0.0332649723,
-0.0204680711,
0.0171919521,
0.0033155971,
-0.0362432078,
0.059572529,
-0.0000670183,
0.0183051005,
-0.0268889833,
0.0033434872,
0.0108601302,
0.0488605946,
0.0183029119,
0.0286315195,
0.1002922133,
-0.0475115702,
-0.0178518407,
-0.0098009994,
0.0488867909,
-0.0611184351,
0.0003306866,
-0.0109030725,
-0.0156316198,
0.0139320223,
-0.0211186856,
-0.0425796919,
-0.0608243495,
0.000177435,
-0.0011928161,
-0.0077067269,
-0.0227116235,
-0.0577545948,
-0.0242438074,
0.0168558694,
0.0197138395,
0.018291384,
0.0268402863,
-0.0006270084,
0.011142645,
-0.0088884542,
-0.0340446159,
-0.0261011366,
-0.0446229316,
0.0072751092,
0.0790682212,
0.086451903,
0.0063450369,
0.051928822,
-0.0411630571,
0.0239183102,
-0.0452453494,
-0.0611171797,
0.0477199405,
0.0389835276,
-0.0503545776,
-0.0186164528,
0.0918855369,
0.0261993352,
-0.0510894991,
-0.0160003323,
0.04620976,
0.0625026301,
-0.0060965098,
-0.0244976822,
-0.0591750331,
0.0037121836,
0.0287405625,
0.0415633693,
-0.0201369077,
-0.0703771338,
-0.0264364369,
-0.1137943715,
-0.0408818312,
0.031587068,
-0.0212574098,
0.0236036312,
-0.0578769334,
-0.0030775913,
-0.0051482874,
0.0166726988,
0.00001866,
0.0025629324,
0.0046113087,
0.0283269566,
-0.0294068977,
-0.046630349,
-0.0100135868,
-0.0053666397,
0.0644784272,
0.0595098473,
0.0049303346,
-0.0057126204,
-0.038534347,
-0.0152806817,
-0.0029148459,
0.0327559449,
-0.0086716879,
0.078009598,
0.0126325004,
0.0091687813,
0.0024499814,
0.075907886,
-0.0197587311,
-0.0120383399,
0.0297202598,
0.0390366204,
-0.0030103524,
-0.0168366712,
0.0241840575,
-0.0359864086,
0.0197630432,
0.0680653676,
0.0042080088,
-0.0317631289,
0.0266690403,
-0.037576884,
0.0362827592,
0.0015135346,
0.0510811433,
0.0036646302,
0.0162165426,
-0.0504962169,
-0.0409467258,
-0.0250802543,
0.0284082051,
0.0393024273,
0.0313963629,
0.0392903164,
0.0301625393,
0.0080539305,
-0.0139832078,
-0.0089780875,
-0.0567972958,
-0.0117457369,
-0.0445787199,
-0.0144383013,
-0.0124992123,
0.0112414546,
-0.0135881165,
-0.0096258642,
-0.0516953655,
-0.1188287362,
0.0473943911,
0.0302709471,
0.0204817913,
0.0414714105,
0.0143041797,
-0.0935674235,
0.0858748108,
0.0793138221,
-0.016659772,
0.0120120049,
0.0416011699,
-0.0488490351,
-0.0169516094,
0.0413925089,
0.0041522826,
-0.0122109419,
0.0757607892,
-0.02057519,
-0.0301025342,
0.0096412795,
-0.0206574779,
0.0309491232,
0.0556900203,
-0.0112336008,
0.010159987,
-0.0213476066,
0.0439538881,
-0.0172611289,
-0.0017690486,
0.0072505339,
0.0113976169,
0.0210986026,
-0.0065688761,
0.0281213783,
-0.0191153809,
0.0199624356,
0.0253994465,
-0.0472762957,
0.0451697707,
0.0741730481,
0.0133916475,
0.0227980968,
0.0077629681,
-0.0151739437,
0.0418107323,
0.0151298223,
0.0270799901,
-0.0098013207,
0.0093418779,
0.0069179893,
0.0463024639,
-0.0020601524,
0.0018446061,
-0.0435583033,
-0.0033924878,
-0.0301837306,
0.0345260054,
-0.0095109483,
-0.001472566,
-0.0057068923,
0.0031866217,
0.0056539206,
-0.0237245485,
0.0201971121,
-0.0062573026,
-0.0328893512,
-0.0203687251,
0.0054702312,
-0.0331031457,
0.050832361,
0.0951200724,
0.0098670516,
0.0551232025,
0.0086376984,
0.0013757166,
-0.0770657659,
-0.0183502212,
0.0198672898,
0.0412453376,
-0.0167444665,
0.0077749714,
-0.014518898,
-0.0511134677,
0.0098624853,
-0.0076913307,
0.0351596549,
-0.0028948663,
0.023311479,
0.0044143298,
-0.0282166079,
0.0011901275,
-0.0547828563,
-0.0186948851,
0.0421141945,
-0.0221927334,
-0.021094121,
-5.839110965e-33,
-0.0125370519,
-0.00992072,
-0.0370776728,
0.0264393371,
0.0535462908,
0.0101678427,
-0.0172930527,
-0.0013616839,
0.0157255586,
-0.0359296724,
-0.0641441122,
-0.0084702093,
0.0107594905,
0.0202991813,
0.0155482963,
0.0177766122,
0.0794385821,
-0.024249116,
-0.0250983462,
0.0479158908,
0.0762074664,
0.0684791133,
0.0590709634,
-0.0318047665,
0.0537007414,
-0.0206829216,
-0.0385400467,
0.0067131054,
-0.0450511537,
0.0392986052,
-0.023258023,
-0.015467613,
-0.0055659725,
0.00661251,
-0.0318966806,
0.0003844106,
-0.0346728414,
-0.0387701094,
-0.0155869648,
-0.0226429701,
0.0461894497,
-0.0670017749,
0.049503848,
-0.0449174121,
-0.0242355336,
-0.000776597,
0.0287466925,
0.0000081854,
-0.062765792,
-0.0164291691,
0.0397766232,
0.0114663402,
-0.0285653695,
-0.0255979504,
0.0452776365,
0.0026404832,
-0.0052448269,
-0.0240993798,
-0.0600617118,
0.0203647986,
0.0702261031,
0.0400730073,
0.016463872,
0.006427424,
0.0306232404,
0.0684080869,
0.0621773265,
0.0008327796,
0.0169483218,
-0.0196169168,
0.0277301688,
0.0125305578,
0.0241973642,
0.0038705585,
0.0471150801,
-0.0612319969,
-0.0362508222,
0.0041528475,
-0.0178302005,
-0.0215243474,
0.0557231829,
0.0384232812,
-0.0465671904,
-0.0092542283,
-0.0372955017,
-0.0442172177,
-0.0214602221,
0.0244906545,
0.0023974471,
0.0032092037,
-0.0732916147,
-0.0195358694,
0.0253324006,
-0.0261798576,
-0.0701508522,
0.0311349984,
0.0549863428,
-0.0223892387,
-0.0065115485,
0.0022051253,
-0.0762274563,
-0.0248828251,
0.0162974223,
-0.0091491444,
-0.0008730355,
0.005017655,
0.0878096148,
0.0275914744,
-0.0887656957,
-0.017974779,
-0.040872477,
0.0477099679,
0.047922276,
0.0276596826,
0.0501727127,
-0.0230851285,
-0.0002256337,
0.0225497931,
0.017408818,
-0.0008953934,
-0.0649592355,
0.0311896671,
0.0022262335,
-0.0231086705,
0.0229539331,
-0.0385505743,
0.0313371345,
0.0062538763,
0.117058605,
0.0489788651,
0.0298025962,
-0.007187088,
2.527e-7,
-0.029943075,
0.0005094076,
0.0020311044,
-0.0819506869,
0.0099285394,
0.0613820814,
-0.0297146793,
0.0401263796,
0.0050883256,
0.007260859,
-0.0048572663,
0.0021048784,
0.0484130532,
0.0233499482,
-0.0543948039,
0.000894348,
-0.044939518,
0.0089922911,
-0.040896181,
-0.0177137963,
-0.0073011136,
0.0837643892,
0.0787029862,
-0.011524396,
-0.0283604972,
-0.0256159827,
0.0309719592,
-0.0434471332,
-0.0332779884,
-0.0032713823,
0.0607347116,
0.0414460339,
0.0000190988,
0.0028059958,
-0.0434178971,
0.027919516,
-0.0495473407,
0.0765793771,
-0.0029592288,
-0.0190640762,
0.0345038772,
-0.0026874444,
-0.0382243171,
0.0071223127,
0.0308958888,
0.008704314,
-0.0282979868,
0.0127600497,
0.0054408628,
-0.060329631,
0.0417627767,
0.0366022848,
0.0172206089,
0.0469437614,
-0.0244844779,
-0.0001615971,
0.0033233264,
-0.0729353577,
-0.037773136,
-0.0644533038,
-0.041736342,
-0.0312946215,
0.0281991921,
0.0151527561,
-0.0686358735,
-0.0528737865,
0.0443619452,
2.181562543e-34,
0.0024161676,
-0.0292059463,
-0.0145285325,
0.0234447699,
0.0239640512,
-0.0259907767,
0.0304971989,
0.0223128218,
0.0273748804,
-0.0458287857,
-0.0322563797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16058v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16058v1 | AnyMAL: An Efficient and Scalable Any-Modality Augmented Language Model | 2023-09-27T22:50:51 | 2023-09-27T22:50:51 | Seungwhan Moon, Andrea Madotto, Zhaojiang Lin, Tushar Nagarajan, Matt Smith, Shashank Jain, Chun-Fu Yeh, Prakash Murugesan, Peyman Heidari, Yue Liu, Kavya Srinet, Babak Damavandi, Anuj Kumar | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | We present Any-Modality Augmented Language Model (AnyMAL), a unified model
that reasons over diverse input modality signals (i.e. text, image, video,
audio, IMU motion sensor), and generates textual responses. AnyMAL inherits the
powerful text-based reasoning abilities of the state-of-the-art LLMs including
LLaMA-2 (70B), and converts modality-specific signals to the joint textual
space through a pre-trained aligner module. To further strengthen the
multimodal LLM's capabilities, we fine-tune the model with a multimodal
instruction set manually collected to cover diverse topics and tasks beyond
simple QAs. We conduct comprehensive empirical analysis comprising both human
and automatic evaluations, and demonstrate state-of-the-art performance on
various multimodal tasks. | [
0.0189881884,
0.0519796647,
-0.0017236386,
0.0501833074,
-0.0287118983,
0.0006400264,
0.0584907383,
-0.0224463549,
0.0040411269,
-0.0913051739,
-0.0412890352,
-0.0168185402,
0.0030329514,
0.010311977,
0.0504384823,
-0.0177460965,
0.0415755585,
-0.060380701,
0.0085649416,
0.0032791914,
0.0258707367,
0.0276930034,
-0.0573677272,
0.009162413,
-0.0249772687,
-0.0220426135,
-0.0453079008,
-0.0069132792,
0.0006378306,
-0.0199030507,
-0.0111219697,
0.0206660293,
0.0648173839,
-0.0197213776,
0.0000020022,
-0.0189151876,
0.0182353649,
-0.0150467558,
0.0042011319,
-0.0084229782,
0.0299884416,
0.0130661437,
-0.0035903985,
0.0244848784,
-0.0489585549,
0.0178917143,
0.0334750116,
0.0294745807,
0.0714019239,
0.0784110501,
-0.0175151341,
-0.0284839794,
0.0498148985,
0.0027267039,
0.0298722833,
-0.006013561,
-0.0127378963,
0.0060906401,
0.0662518889,
0.0181561615,
-0.0100683728,
0.0493521504,
0.0347179398,
-0.0108989673,
-0.000713137,
0.0235236418,
0.020927744,
-0.0127168549,
-0.0410500877,
0.0951003209,
0.0317714438,
-0.017309593,
-0.0106469616,
-0.0017819866,
0.003416189,
-0.0100935576,
-0.0516011752,
0.051728908,
0.0004320147,
0.0299252048,
-0.0151350973,
-0.0249436833,
0.0310707651,
0.0362420864,
-0.0101105385,
0.063613534,
0.0085504735,
0.0056001162,
0.0018099989,
-0.0126988403,
-0.0215341151,
-0.0524533913,
-0.004802268,
0.0966275632,
-0.029349139,
-0.0040592533,
-0.0500263013,
-0.0426224805,
0.0252357032,
-0.0336012468,
0.0245156121,
0.0583578162,
-0.044253435,
0.0599704608,
-0.0184461158,
0.0417030491,
-0.0285410006,
0.0600784943,
-0.0078189969,
-0.0135318832,
-0.0385843888,
-0.0216977559,
0.0130115878,
-0.0017451068,
-0.0793419108,
-0.021176517,
0.003138016,
0.0439770073,
0.0065020709,
-0.0020471849,
0.014015601,
0.0524590164,
-0.0148100099,
-0.0376111679,
-0.0415352061,
0.0641465634,
-0.0262135155,
0.0882426277,
0.0228712577,
-0.050841704,
0.0217192098,
0.0592423156,
0.0008724621,
-0.0119141722,
0.0128008258,
0.1100122556,
-0.089950785,
-0.0272952244,
-0.0267831292,
-0.0245459061,
-0.0295379404,
-0.0885578543,
0.0287343431,
-0.0643995553,
0.0400930233,
0.005258813,
-0.0403292961,
-0.0072061312,
0.0127622169,
0.0245342255,
-0.0026653651,
0.0818810984,
-0.0009973411,
0.0089563541,
0.0626320094,
0.0196665581,
0.0125492383,
0.0629310459,
0.0647370145,
0.031249376,
0.0160444863,
0.0177279655,
0.0129502574,
0.0420219228,
-0.0240641069,
-0.0043991297,
-0.0447104834,
0.0019431488,
-0.0221952051,
0.0327094272,
0.0201320909,
0.0432889052,
-0.0027619272,
-0.0374331921,
0.0478792191,
0.0316119492,
0.0249652378,
-0.0042278846,
-0.0031011726,
-0.0177061483,
0.0126827322,
-0.0116899665,
-0.0555423684,
0.0918980315,
-0.0315770209,
0.0067664003,
0.042310603,
0.024596313,
-0.0295071434,
-0.0437288061,
-0.0307807364,
0.0005209127,
0.0093228128,
0.007987137,
0.0288736876,
-0.0054391767,
-0.0547606088,
0.0362241231,
-0.0071774102,
-0.0681225583,
-0.0055630845,
-0.0320937857,
0.0526377819,
0.0325809903,
0.0304076318,
-0.0203483962,
-0.041990798,
-0.0156782046,
0.0211470537,
0.0721314624,
-0.0025913527,
0.0058519235,
0.01610112,
-0.081657283,
-0.0264595971,
-0.029369507,
0.0053462544,
0.0203420073,
-0.0334295444,
-0.0023077761,
-0.0087371003,
-0.0370058641,
0.0207980685,
0.032749597,
-0.0016864589,
-0.0182085223,
-0.0106077297,
-0.0034311654,
0.0014016146,
0.0074590053,
0.0104970215,
0.0197149366,
0.0478315949,
-0.0589820966,
-0.009487628,
0.0371891856,
-0.0555726252,
-0.0211152788,
0.0567095131,
-0.0505739525,
-0.0034322217,
0.0109003931,
-0.0357828364,
-0.0398770124,
0.0159944948,
-0.0260585491,
-0.0236553568,
-0.0483163744,
-0.0175471846,
0.0502856076,
0.0096845068,
-0.0300001856,
0.0613430887,
-0.0170346741,
-0.0260402989,
0.0301504154,
0.0269935634,
0.022553904,
-0.0166433547,
-0.0158970784,
0.0026706967,
-0.0199071411,
0.0327248797,
-0.0188557804,
-0.0028725923,
-0.0225029252,
-0.0454158001,
-0.1249829754,
0.0006082424,
-0.0055509782,
0.0224067941,
0.0301732197,
-0.0107953744,
0.0011818751,
-0.0105691198,
-0.0409662277,
0.0099036908,
0.034438096,
0.017474981,
0.0222713407,
-0.0088349236,
0.0085652554,
-0.0470298044,
0.00273312,
-0.0229231175,
0.0363308378,
0.0165215358,
0.0110743474,
-0.0335103348,
-0.0213243626,
-0.0525249504,
0.0298361238,
-0.0264852904,
-0.0436902046,
0.0564226508,
-0.0382712372,
0.0393905602,
0.0661337227,
0.0245265514,
-0.0243194811,
0.0757106766,
-0.016908383,
-0.0557261445,
0.034448646,
0.0211833138,
0.0150973964,
-0.0077415095,
-0.0195134114,
-0.0530723892,
0.0798476115,
0.0107887173,
0.0157554429,
-0.0238154549,
0.0000815707,
0.0323143564,
-0.0127805378,
-0.0463595614,
-0.009767836,
-0.0338097736,
0.0530559085,
-0.0306159928,
-0.0351572521,
0.0352784544,
-0.0567204691,
-0.0159984082,
-0.0118141891,
-0.0041461196,
-0.0440943427,
0.0499315038,
-0.0504914969,
-0.0112674925,
-0.0301032923,
0.0023348189,
-0.0455700196,
-0.0418700799,
0.0213928614,
-0.0333181582,
0.0624378994,
-0.0650744587,
0.0381356217,
-0.0276675262,
-0.0315703712,
-0.0342263021,
-0.0239591617,
-0.0544491038,
-0.0109465485,
-0.0639124662,
0.0026237171,
-0.0273938868,
0.004408285,
0.0343341604,
0.0172136202,
-0.0215778071,
0.0123315649,
-0.0513411611,
0.0380221084,
0.0329091586,
0.0770652592,
-0.0230223816,
-0.0375274718,
-0.0185507927,
0.0326450728,
0.0110456171,
-0.0061869309,
-0.065217562,
0.0280979909,
0.0147120226,
0.0385436527,
-0.0056816214,
0.0383463465,
0.0633659437,
-0.0654759482,
0.033673998,
0.0671227202,
0.0273219887,
-0.0229820479,
-0.0174116027,
-0.0170907546,
0.0326113403,
0.0145406965,
0.0117809735,
-0.0964777246,
-0.0872854814,
0.0020243428,
-0.0035428174,
0.0500022061,
0.0162068643,
-0.0062186313,
-0.0498899557,
0.0077046263,
0.0033467198,
-0.0125774341,
-0.0226859413,
-0.0065974426,
0.0050355,
0.006911715,
0.00165454,
0.0157638658,
-0.0051564663,
-0.0041239117,
0.0158680044,
0.0342641696,
-0.0232134499,
0.0108544426,
-0.008025758,
0.0514907911,
0.026579069,
0.0219716486,
-0.001642034,
-0.1150293574,
0.0493673161,
0.0397090875,
0.0433029793,
-0.0024689245,
-0.0067152204,
-0.015572696,
-0.0067880494,
-0.0336928219,
0.0428938679,
-0.0171680674,
-0.0204291698,
-0.0154810147,
0.0741962492,
-0.0318732597,
0.0511714891,
-0.0454842485,
-0.002692258,
-0.0210721139,
0.0426075645,
0.0187954437,
-0.0132386461,
-0.0585177951,
-0.0307849608,
-0.0255786981,
-0.0534828454,
-0.0223497152,
-0.0090628304,
0.002850757,
-0.0109275617,
-0.0642459095,
-0.0069994959,
-0.0034892184,
0.0385618024,
0.0023227644,
-0.0259250719,
-0.0126860784,
-0.0119536547,
-0.0476768091,
0.0646192804,
-0.0122810695,
0.0309524406,
-0.0380434766,
0.0345368981,
0.0242293943,
-0.0565465949,
0.0021498019,
0.0216290038,
-0.0789574087,
-0.0881339833,
-0.0379422456,
0.0620165393,
0.0179489944,
0.0293855909,
0.0076987469,
-0.0476508141,
-0.0002486187,
0.0499706976,
-0.0498076268,
0.0301742945,
0.0416702144,
0.0053600143,
0.0072266459,
0.0298257153,
-0.0297645386,
-0.0161236767,
-0.005601868,
0.0320352465,
-0.022937905,
-0.0454839952,
-0.0126200104,
-0.021020053,
0.0048056864,
-0.0144250104,
-0.0372395627,
-0.0244162362,
0.0308364201,
-0.0068515632,
0.0069682691,
-0.04003736,
0.0331923999,
-0.0201081969,
-0.0253456775,
0.0315502547,
0.0049413866,
-0.0020514978,
0.0457671061,
0.0161206312,
0.0627321228,
-0.00294651,
0.0009114963,
-0.0261143669,
0.0092075849,
-0.0132314526,
0.019824177,
-0.0171368811,
0.0287658367,
-0.0141280768,
0.0969247073,
0.0032130461,
-0.0147391744,
-0.0351006798,
0.0295140687,
-0.0304785352,
-0.0060053286,
0.0105292313,
0.0518408082,
0.0577854402,
0.0217482802,
0.0244400334,
0.0150739327,
-0.0054870965,
0.0117798913,
0.0695352107,
0.002045755,
-0.0072872564,
0.0679281577,
0.0232232045,
0.008771698,
-0.0023003744,
0.0419740938,
-0.0610245652,
0.0225460101,
0.0022037197,
0.0288374908,
-0.0496571064,
-0.0280501973,
0.041008845,
0.0351209305,
-0.0142148649,
0.0189509429,
-0.0176924057,
-0.0412220247,
-0.0119006913,
0.0329723284,
-0.0418354981,
-0.0194203928,
0.0229048394,
0.0557453111,
0.0185322128,
-0.023296196,
-0.0110412845,
0.0111942403,
-0.0110661825,
-0.0018806744,
-0.0215523671,
-6.632300758e-33,
-0.0312967449,
-0.0515228063,
0.0591501407,
-0.0476302393,
-0.0130320182,
-0.0033526034,
-0.0258924365,
0.0200348757,
-0.0197395012,
-0.0055139805,
-0.0068349498,
-0.008226933,
-0.0012367561,
0.0373401232,
-0.0008424698,
-0.0062690401,
-0.0053601032,
-0.0010226042,
-0.0236550588,
-0.0083822282,
0.0575909503,
-0.0059282281,
0.034239646,
-0.0435085148,
0.0197472367,
0.0056323428,
-0.0528556406,
0.0059572966,
-0.0549506918,
0.0748121217,
-0.0490120165,
0.0144763235,
0.0275225695,
-0.0041505792,
-0.0027469092,
0.066021584,
-0.0605691336,
-0.0189084504,
0.0462915637,
0.0009526689,
-0.0797574595,
-0.0317922495,
0.0473124757,
-0.0082389107,
-0.0030334443,
-0.0051244111,
0.0377431512,
-0.0117197027,
0.014939392,
0.0482498184,
-0.0234148055,
0.0055840896,
-0.0179073326,
-0.0365388729,
0.0038907703,
0.0301423818,
0.0098325126,
-0.0037969537,
-0.059245199,
0.0118830819,
-0.0032747374,
0.0155805182,
0.1001820192,
-0.0030571162,
-0.0266875252,
0.0479195602,
-0.0308860969,
-0.0629897341,
-0.068090342,
0.0065973415,
0.0106909703,
0.066949904,
0.0531561971,
0.0880064294,
0.0150054311,
0.0171205942,
-0.0424012952,
0.0379951857,
0.0246771518,
0.0642950162,
0.0228799172,
0.0417063497,
0.0052789501,
0.0132044442,
-0.0297145545,
0.0318204872,
-0.040857736,
-0.030256398,
0.0215663929,
0.0234846175,
-0.0223520864,
-0.0188839361,
0.0522442907,
-0.0143065611,
-0.0064391987,
0.0200594869,
-0.0163474623,
0.0327481963,
0.0189891923,
0.0178767592,
-0.0403792188,
0.0056821411,
0.0702433065,
-0.0130263288,
0.0300278794,
0.016014304,
-0.0024948004,
0.0434160456,
-0.0674156398,
-0.0058347033,
-0.0400210768,
0.0004867938,
-0.0027614185,
0.0233132597,
0.0269131456,
0.0124538671,
-0.0489930324,
0.0781646743,
-0.0648450851,
0.0138013791,
-0.0404079668,
-0.0574031286,
-0.0358552858,
0.0368833169,
-0.0373029597,
0.0374038406,
-0.0400492959,
-0.0432698242,
0.0024810683,
-0.0490029417,
-0.0040496406,
0.0767260715,
2.656e-7,
0.0322399512,
0.0084806327,
0.0156227695,
-0.0127834585,
0.0270970296,
0.0590735599,
-0.0282430146,
0.0238083936,
0.0138759399,
-0.0374531709,
-0.0344494246,
0.0554722436,
0.0312270895,
0.0140589336,
-0.0202859789,
0.016888598,
-0.0168999005,
-0.0000277957,
-0.0363702513,
0.0052484293,
0.0723368749,
0.0574653186,
-0.0108905314,
-0.0179086383,
-0.0084662288,
-0.0161652062,
0.0513842441,
0.0148824258,
-0.0247032829,
-0.0180758256,
0.0530956611,
-0.0095584719,
-0.0348517559,
0.0037958606,
0.0070035369,
-0.0111565357,
-0.0199520532,
0.0594815649,
-0.0200745426,
-0.0814405084,
0.0030250777,
-0.0066488022,
-0.0276927724,
-0.0463756435,
0.0945667028,
-0.0002309173,
-0.0258602239,
-0.031580098,
0.0092450809,
0.0215596724,
-0.0128150657,
-0.0154668558,
-0.0318369009,
-0.0196648873,
0.0160039645,
-0.045434989,
-0.0374524817,
-0.0897567645,
-0.0426422507,
-0.0258843955,
-0.0433922,
-0.0033328722,
-0.055556953,
-0.0074355467,
0.0521519221,
-0.120679535,
-0.0523804463,
2.092151504e-34,
0.0011755944,
-0.0059596384,
-0.0051962198,
0.0426496938,
0.0059886687,
0.0047251997,
-0.0307661407,
-0.0034628203,
0.0320000723,
-0.0818640143,
-0.0313755013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16042v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16042v2 | Towards Best Practices of Activation Patching in Language Models: Metrics and Methods | 2023-09-27T21:53:56 | 2024-01-17T04:07:06 | Fred Zhang, Neel Nanda | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Mechanistic interpretability seeks to understand the internal mechanisms of
machine learning models, where localization -- identifying the important model
components -- is a key step. Activation patching, also known as causal tracing
or interchange intervention, is a standard technique for this task (Vig et al.,
2020), but the literature contains many variants with little consensus on the
choice of hyperparameters or methodology. In this work, we systematically
examine the impact of methodological details in activation patching, including
evaluation metrics and corruption methods. In several settings of localization
and circuit discovery in language models, we find that varying these
hyperparameters could lead to disparate interpretability results. Backed by
empirical observations, we give conceptual arguments for why certain metrics or
methods may be preferred. Finally, we provide recommendations for the best
practices of activation patching going forwards. | [
-0.0140849603,
0.0562957078,
-0.0418789349,
0.0474436544,
-0.0234925132,
0.0082797995,
0.029555684,
-0.0213249736,
-0.0339525156,
-0.0052944431,
-0.0326690972,
-0.0149990581,
0.0328801833,
0.0464242324,
0.0387530513,
0.0049370639,
0.0656905994,
-0.0093669388,
-0.030927714,
0.005134746,
-0.0287564322,
-0.0028344472,
0.0120746326,
0.0661186501,
0.033678703,
-0.0106940968,
0.0038538335,
0.0097435601,
0.0216558892,
0.0394703932,
-0.0260558426,
0.0439459607,
-0.0238479935,
0.0811987892,
0.0000019509,
-0.030876467,
-0.029037036,
0.0248689484,
-0.0222627465,
0.0489567667,
-0.0183155723,
-0.0578874722,
-0.0133690005,
-0.008577507,
0.0140838977,
-0.0002219017,
0.0685594529,
0.0134818619,
-0.012443563,
0.0544292778,
-0.0088335527,
-0.0091385497,
0.0281897131,
-0.0149079775,
0.0272816047,
-0.0085680671,
0.0123806763,
0.007390684,
-0.0238807686,
-0.029728651,
-0.0620760769,
0.026628077,
0.0442183949,
-0.011432969,
-0.0039055783,
-0.016460266,
0.0042218757,
-0.0028946837,
0.0411320664,
0.0329362266,
-0.001836224,
-0.02536235,
0.0027197981,
0.0095160948,
-0.0053745969,
0.0226166006,
-0.011726927,
-0.0282719526,
0.0293345675,
0.0257181674,
0.0301223695,
-0.0333186723,
0.0818490535,
-0.0083773015,
-0.0367545001,
0.0813713595,
-0.0045323609,
-0.0056408863,
-0.029638825,
0.0170847587,
-0.0015482397,
-0.0042536189,
0.014847422,
-0.0273416825,
-0.0115458183,
0.0104835294,
-0.0206641778,
-0.0048542833,
-0.0116924113,
-0.032130681,
0.0594534241,
0.0388376899,
-0.0172683541,
0.0022100101,
-0.0631343871,
0.059349034,
-0.0362648629,
0.0672763065,
-0.0238921903,
0.0200913846,
-0.0466390662,
-0.0434627011,
0.019612994,
-0.0194282401,
-0.0221763644,
0.0057361876,
-0.0499579646,
0.0164866932,
-0.0473915935,
-0.0596990474,
-0.0439351611,
-0.0415020064,
-0.0281016231,
0.0285629537,
0.0219583176,
0.0282157473,
-0.0216152966,
0.0108514363,
-0.0276325382,
-0.0464748368,
-0.0483372286,
-0.001668698,
-0.0086417971,
-0.0337998532,
-0.0136243682,
0.0642096102,
0.0225853827,
-0.0217328239,
-0.0610421337,
-0.0347429179,
-0.0408099554,
-0.0490583442,
0.0207310393,
-0.0500162244,
-0.0109667676,
0.0129862325,
0.0084661925,
-0.0350049324,
-0.0095578237,
-0.0207920279,
-0.0459285378,
0.0767746493,
-0.003952832,
0.0166648347,
-0.0462025367,
-0.008373592,
0.0132070137,
0.0655657798,
0.0181307141,
0.001288863,
0.0421696343,
-0.0240194388,
-0.0028146622,
0.0134942299,
0.0280281976,
0.0049431697,
-0.0441055298,
-0.0597406067,
0.0117545156,
-0.0295803454,
0.0519944094,
-0.0062839049,
-0.0408940688,
-0.0054695243,
0.0458586589,
-0.0190820117,
0.0277828332,
0.0132607725,
0.0452806726,
-0.0330643393,
-0.025935106,
0.0081897564,
-0.0641713068,
-0.0136358244,
-0.0491303839,
-0.0029112739,
-0.0023271774,
-0.006866002,
0.0064565553,
-0.0508358143,
-0.027410347,
0.0078652604,
0.0224331059,
-0.0067955903,
0.0721352771,
0.0249471441,
-0.0069438517,
0.0467713736,
0.0147142727,
-0.0172004271,
0.0053808116,
-0.0693688914,
-0.0042860406,
0.0384483188,
0.0365042239,
-0.025420621,
0.0023162169,
0.0280004032,
-0.0263641719,
-0.0221034922,
-0.0185488649,
-0.0152714597,
0.0483162664,
0.0056381682,
-0.0125271548,
-0.0503259972,
0.0607872568,
0.0256574024,
-0.0170711298,
-0.0241508391,
-0.0072360025,
-0.0831901804,
-0.0393955521,
0.0243534558,
0.0089021381,
-0.0156001002,
-0.0025395898,
0.0183699727,
0.015550781,
0.0061188298,
-0.0223737787,
0.0015334883,
-0.0041353614,
-0.0182866063,
0.0145034222,
0.0553231165,
-0.0007537865,
-0.0198575165,
0.0242263637,
-0.0110284323,
0.0022674652,
0.0466603301,
-0.0018045626,
-0.0439733677,
0.0717887431,
-0.0410873853,
0.0406013876,
-0.0134271784,
0.0362734869,
-0.0441903174,
0.0174792893,
-0.0238751844,
0.0333839767,
-0.0202703644,
0.0046275519,
0.0198553428,
0.0091394018,
0.0289561339,
-0.007896401,
-0.0265817679,
0.0294169523,
-0.0199730992,
-0.0299055967,
0.0067279399,
-0.0312927216,
-0.011489274,
-0.0209771655,
-0.0510735884,
-0.0359981395,
-0.0367742069,
0.023455251,
0.0434417911,
-0.0035317065,
0.0084507894,
0.008267167,
0.031544257,
-0.0177154075,
-0.0165116452,
0.0481734946,
0.0086223874,
0.002037799,
-0.0535313971,
-0.0343359001,
-0.0385693051,
-0.0301562957,
0.0968105644,
-0.0157311186,
-0.0372600295,
-0.0915942192,
-0.0339169279,
0.0175838917,
-0.0006853507,
-0.0066567496,
-0.0650283769,
0.017463699,
0.0290869586,
0.0066712522,
0.0521754324,
-0.0754919797,
0.0896473452,
0.0528850257,
0.0018138414,
-0.0222274996,
-0.0313506722,
-0.0188133549,
0.0106628267,
-0.0493760705,
-0.07656461,
-0.0189392678,
0.0978622437,
0.0009496948,
-0.0242772382,
-0.033034537,
0.0179290734,
-0.0256228372,
-0.0571515933,
-0.0290170871,
-0.0396754369,
-0.0240616184,
0.0745383129,
-0.0379010923,
-0.0797424763,
0.0499519333,
-0.0144126965,
0.0024965527,
-0.0347604156,
-0.0100885099,
-0.0180749074,
0.0619416982,
0.0372904465,
0.0233645476,
0.0309087709,
-0.0539192706,
-0.0221309736,
0.0037058808,
0.0220331363,
0.0117020188,
0.0254079476,
-0.0417315364,
0.0063334364,
0.0096074771,
0.0021377543,
-0.0081931381,
-0.011008177,
0.0317698345,
0.0333748572,
0.0364577584,
-0.0317560658,
-0.0276955776,
0.0280445889,
0.0129979076,
0.0388041735,
-0.0285342261,
0.0010767159,
-0.0415644459,
-0.001936049,
-0.0045078243,
-0.0247426685,
0.0657904744,
-0.0265437979,
0.017628843,
0.024723703,
0.0020771609,
0.0136131989,
-0.0619081818,
0.0419992246,
0.0156966019,
-0.0071257954,
-0.0190771595,
-0.0116991056,
0.0767533183,
-0.075244844,
-0.0433025584,
0.0574720837,
0.0416449644,
-0.0337615423,
0.0580771267,
-0.0100787962,
0.0319758244,
0.0291760154,
0.0148675172,
-0.0478529036,
0.0099970447,
0.0457060784,
0.030028075,
-0.0327053368,
0.0192498527,
0.037790034,
-0.0598602593,
0.0571486503,
0.0227583013,
-0.0784984678,
-0.0595842116,
-0.0458369628,
-0.0057754023,
-0.0271970313,
0.0564737208,
0.0234818291,
0.00013348,
0.0236086696,
0.012264912,
-0.0053895456,
-0.07850191,
-0.0036835575,
0.0039532599,
0.0620105974,
0.0786102191,
-0.0168122426,
-0.0030520409,
-0.0038136684,
0.0428791568,
0.0381809212,
0.0345945731,
-0.0183347929,
0.0630597323,
0.0642075539,
-0.0358877555,
-0.0029805773,
0.0465320535,
-0.029802775,
-0.0432715937,
-0.0891252831,
0.0529311001,
-0.0265822131,
-0.0137570743,
0.0077911867,
-0.0126562174,
-0.0028147826,
0.0399721451,
0.0739159361,
-0.030693382,
-0.0538638011,
-0.0264837854,
0.0001895844,
-0.0634120107,
-0.0832743049,
0.0098052099,
0.0279215034,
-0.075679101,
-0.0275138877,
-0.0405766591,
0.0036946875,
0.0478076264,
0.0106400829,
-0.003899317,
-0.0440853536,
-0.0240652058,
-0.0289543383,
0.0874668583,
-0.01477239,
0.0281977523,
-0.0381435007,
-0.0385750346,
-0.0095504671,
-0.0330529325,
-0.0510635786,
0.0091127818,
-0.0317507647,
-0.0734247491,
0.0431103669,
0.0302503072,
0.0310753174,
0.0479610376,
-0.0247104168,
-0.0612000003,
-0.0110566197,
-0.0084599629,
-0.0023417256,
0.0442126095,
0.0617540404,
-0.056507688,
-0.0219811965,
0.0383885056,
-0.0056501129,
0.0160065331,
0.0525436103,
0.0498497374,
-0.0339345671,
0.0398916118,
0.0399388298,
-0.0061369287,
0.0903835148,
0.0095999883,
-0.0011981329,
-0.0386930257,
0.0050146398,
-0.0050294846,
0.0052634212,
-0.0378116481,
-0.0108935526,
0.0412942357,
0.0255804807,
-0.0195807852,
-0.0510955676,
-0.0107773542,
0.0042876727,
-0.0197543893,
0.0342322662,
0.004865543,
0.0557114109,
-0.0024746903,
0.0596347488,
0.005225949,
0.0809742436,
-0.0215322766,
0.0525704101,
0.0017306323,
0.0095077287,
0.0133570349,
0.0184707604,
-0.050930433,
0.0159266777,
-0.0818277225,
-0.0204757396,
0.0105856769,
-0.0203349739,
0.0461913012,
-0.0279661622,
0.0775616094,
0.0032807093,
-0.0282777473,
-0.012060632,
0.0276374891,
0.0360208154,
-0.004052355,
-0.0063251313,
0.0065993955,
-0.0228884872,
-0.0063259155,
0.0607243367,
0.0068313465,
0.0393215306,
-0.0350894928,
-0.0175583959,
0.0111789703,
-0.0317817442,
0.0087148985,
0.0196958575,
-0.0696761534,
-0.0344828293,
-0.0580705702,
-0.0741875991,
0.0012678718,
-0.0121122804,
0.0081529692,
-0.0206754711,
-0.0346064121,
0.063707076,
0.0125584537,
-0.0056740516,
-0.0437405184,
-0.0128123248,
0.0119982474,
-0.0044430094,
0.0145431533,
-6.306322215e-33,
-0.0089435708,
-0.0363827497,
-0.0235938635,
-0.0192215592,
-0.0049778405,
0.0448880196,
-0.0610467605,
0.0430642664,
-0.0037700487,
0.0299435165,
0.0180421211,
0.0119758286,
0.0180048775,
-0.0068336083,
-0.0160661899,
-0.0046033366,
0.0337030664,
0.0418685935,
-0.0130498605,
-0.0060356883,
0.0550816506,
0.015096412,
0.0795497522,
-0.0880012736,
0.0553590506,
0.0417035669,
-0.027178254,
0.0119459536,
-0.0548108481,
0.0648919418,
0.01406762,
0.0415791608,
0.0219284799,
-0.055286862,
-0.0262365416,
-0.0273120776,
-0.0468351096,
0.0106296819,
0.0534730889,
0.0610968322,
-0.0662831739,
-0.0748503953,
0.0446303226,
-0.0211440902,
-0.0131956646,
-0.0069025122,
0.011508611,
-0.032168705,
-0.0097466446,
0.0181062836,
-0.0907552615,
0.0155729465,
-0.0218390599,
0.0162755065,
0.0503085144,
0.0229970627,
-0.0075715231,
0.0401344597,
-0.0723521858,
-0.0095891133,
0.0311015155,
0.0326751173,
0.0663081184,
0.0596902184,
0.0300350729,
0.0613099746,
0.0627793074,
0.0422568209,
0.0183893573,
-0.0004618166,
0.0719734579,
0.0373174958,
0.0750727057,
0.0167658776,
0.049247995,
0.0172989797,
-0.0637700409,
-0.025581615,
-0.0074459845,
-0.0130116027,
0.0533734821,
0.0347073041,
-0.045896098,
-0.0063865148,
-0.0569326095,
-0.0703959689,
-0.0439570136,
-0.0395743325,
0.0136349509,
-0.0338737853,
-0.0381604545,
0.0039452254,
0.0433012694,
-0.0538313389,
0.0322793759,
0.0006049543,
-0.0065955692,
0.053704571,
-0.0069545759,
-0.0029267152,
-0.0292526577,
-0.0120395552,
-0.018925298,
0.006520567,
0.0425824821,
-0.0128633631,
0.0429678261,
0.0250584446,
-0.0130048906,
-0.0027624499,
-0.0407137945,
-0.0071621616,
-0.0167340208,
0.0493802838,
0.0443479903,
0.0033477324,
-0.0204884,
0.0124052688,
0.0613821149,
0.0618483275,
-0.0055538109,
0.0260736514,
-0.0363369994,
0.0256846454,
-0.0194679853,
-0.0437063798,
-0.0375083685,
0.0432559699,
0.0370186493,
-0.059043806,
-0.0305813141,
0.0043782429,
2.689e-7,
0.0752614513,
0.0247032121,
0.015890291,
0.0248325747,
0.0360483043,
-0.0027828056,
0.0143370163,
-0.0148690697,
0.0151425553,
-0.0066906097,
-0.0006324963,
0.0031671161,
0.0704702064,
0.0019494328,
-0.032780353,
0.0256026369,
-0.0484745689,
0.0355959758,
-0.0156214107,
-0.0007406038,
-0.0328010805,
0.0787370428,
-0.0010440503,
-0.0018127111,
0.0375953875,
-0.0180328581,
0.0290055722,
-0.049223464,
0.0200897008,
0.0425551236,
-0.0282561071,
-0.0096778292,
0.0218066182,
0.0293711256,
-0.0159518812,
0.0263032448,
-0.0163752772,
0.0149541758,
-0.0240265783,
-0.0224952791,
-0.0528059416,
-0.0120023312,
0.0105430977,
-0.078471221,
0.0616260022,
-0.029844407,
-0.079186447,
-0.0189815424,
0.009834189,
-0.0105415545,
0.0355805308,
0.0039596227,
0.0128325587,
0.0369370319,
0.0054026293,
-0.0111089172,
-0.0201263074,
-0.0400191471,
-0.0406431966,
0.0105024409,
-0.0204326361,
-0.0238836575,
-0.0287561957,
-0.0180000849,
0.0363713987,
-0.032850977,
-0.0362023637,
2.984778521e-34,
0.0232405905,
-0.0278732963,
0.0414243191,
0.0205347221,
0.0411112346,
-0.0164564922,
-0.0064967931,
0.005464917,
0.0103064431,
-0.0911128744,
-0.0238597356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16039v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16039v3 | Effective Long-Context Scaling of Foundation Models | 2023-09-27T21:41:49 | 2023-11-14T01:40:13 | Wenhan Xiong, Jingyu Liu, Igor Molybog, Hejia Zhang, Prajjwal Bhargava, Rui Hou, Louis Martin, Rashi Rungta, Karthik Abinav Sankararaman, Barlas Oguz, Madian Khabsa, Han Fang, Yashar Mehdad, Sharan Narang, Kshitiz Malik, Angela Fan, Shruti Bhosale, Sergey Edunov, Mike Lewis, Sinong Wang, Hao Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a series of long-context LLMs that support effective context
windows of up to 32,768 tokens. Our model series are built through continual
pretraining from Llama 2 with longer training sequences and on a dataset where
long texts are upsampled. We perform extensive evaluation on language modeling,
synthetic context probing tasks, and a wide range of research benchmarks. On
research benchmarks, our models achieve consistent improvements on most regular
tasks and significant improvements on long-context tasks over Llama 2. Notably,
with a cost-effective instruction tuning procedure that does not require
human-annotated long instruction data, the 70B variant can already surpass
gpt-3.5-turbo-16k's overall performance on a suite of long-context tasks.
Alongside these results, we provide an in-depth analysis on the individual
components of our method. We delve into Llama's position encodings and discuss
its limitation in modeling long dependencies. We also examine the impact of
various design choices in the pretraining process, including the data mix and
the training curriculum of sequence lengths -- our ablation experiments suggest
that having abundant long texts in the pretrain dataset is not the key to
achieving strong performance, and we empirically verify that long context
continual pretraining is more efficient and similarly effective compared to
pretraining from scratch with long sequences. | [
-0.0115884887,
0.043456614,
0.0018930082,
0.0328499451,
-0.0159781165,
0.0110686943,
0.0256688185,
0.0042427606,
-0.0657394826,
-0.0576369204,
-0.0387062468,
-0.079662092,
0.0102628162,
0.0049799569,
0.0276707727,
-0.0287672263,
0.0264190771,
-0.0389675051,
-0.0362708233,
0.0006441702,
0.0001480311,
-0.010991862,
-0.0024268054,
0.0361315608,
-0.0252498146,
-0.0255563688,
-0.0309098121,
0.0045278277,
0.0186820906,
-0.0570867322,
0.0076277344,
0.0509999543,
0.0547772981,
0.0222800206,
0.0000021488,
-0.0352715626,
-0.0002626863,
-0.0146883326,
-0.042495627,
0.0633950233,
0.0429677442,
-0.0105167385,
-0.0420355313,
0.035141293,
-0.0106447851,
0.0263998639,
0.0326336138,
0.0137142697,
0.0240636356,
0.0669408813,
-0.0009924604,
-0.055976335,
0.0334187038,
-0.0489537604,
0.0245817695,
-0.0283877775,
0.0128249936,
-0.0255715214,
-0.0080583608,
0.0272014644,
-0.0358900316,
0.0159106366,
0.0617610477,
0.0215349942,
-0.0129406676,
0.0510265678,
-0.0091794068,
0.0069589247,
-0.013079741,
0.0484003909,
-0.0141538652,
-0.0273568351,
-0.0113188466,
-0.0012424927,
-0.0229961425,
-0.0951628834,
-0.0448077694,
0.0411713533,
0.0149749303,
0.0350125246,
0.0449857861,
0.0069914539,
0.0407274589,
0.0075518643,
-0.0541494302,
0.0447966643,
0.0086128786,
-0.0270380378,
-0.0232946165,
0.0002987854,
-0.0080830893,
-0.0527886599,
-0.0128137274,
0.0243446548,
-0.0182921439,
0.041010987,
-0.0603140779,
0.0029665492,
0.0372650735,
-0.0249080062,
0.0044028834,
0.0685810372,
-0.0654189214,
0.0176233277,
-0.0520136245,
0.0379130132,
-0.0353829153,
0.0185137894,
-0.0376876518,
-0.0029908342,
-0.021311624,
0.0112437429,
-0.0359127484,
0.0110168317,
-0.0730280951,
-0.0319037586,
-0.0735995695,
0.0175415371,
0.0430553891,
-0.0156001709,
0.0148744425,
-0.0071993764,
-0.0683598146,
0.0185752977,
0.0106173884,
0.0129723689,
-0.0391644537,
0.0389481746,
0.0126144318,
-0.0643685162,
-0.0276106,
0.0359972864,
-0.0143317599,
-0.0356515571,
0.0359603353,
0.0478929803,
-0.0071774209,
-0.0822776482,
-0.0760770664,
-0.0030109687,
-0.0224301796,
-0.0572565012,
-0.0073286989,
-0.0640989617,
0.0037880621,
0.0093463268,
0.0162952244,
0.0167778935,
0.0099652205,
0.0260901265,
0.0296186954,
0.0809495449,
0.0149105843,
-0.0134346327,
0.0172115751,
0.016202271,
0.0146558387,
0.0861035511,
0.0200894549,
0.0304684695,
0.0257337224,
0.0111855771,
-0.0444030315,
0.0534442775,
0.0264204703,
0.0056033824,
-0.0141984718,
0.0089665949,
0.0316954777,
0.0397439525,
0.07240697,
0.0390195511,
-0.027232822,
-0.0325361677,
0.0421611778,
0.0812881812,
0.0400789641,
0.0057621039,
0.0433888324,
-0.0235587209,
-0.0101387557,
-0.0125379479,
-0.0715004206,
0.0077431831,
-0.0040372862,
0.0325221196,
0.0187722445,
0.0494218953,
-0.0301584732,
-0.0168569777,
-0.0296035111,
-0.0472226813,
-0.0185997691,
-0.005998326,
0.0349269323,
-0.0258146804,
-0.0620173551,
0.0724635124,
0.0063888156,
-0.0470399819,
-0.0185724813,
-0.04214935,
-0.0086588785,
0.0590072013,
0.0073264781,
-0.0098157795,
-0.0250709318,
-0.0018317825,
0.0504801832,
0.0404401347,
-0.0071546421,
0.0129464008,
0.0362906605,
-0.0553644188,
-0.0281004198,
-0.0062868595,
-0.000939279,
0.0292759072,
0.0491650216,
0.0406589955,
0.0262023639,
-0.0324948169,
0.0296773519,
0.0464146212,
-0.0432978906,
-0.0354285575,
-0.0224522948,
0.0116514377,
0.0313481577,
0.0397356115,
-0.0096751489,
0.0021170622,
0.0603245758,
-0.0656655207,
0.011959658,
-0.0191700738,
-0.125850305,
-0.0263020191,
0.0473260097,
0.0308725778,
0.0270518679,
-0.0034097903,
-0.0276871752,
-0.0597277582,
-0.0257876571,
-0.0184438154,
0.0612308569,
-0.0364682004,
0.0377405025,
0.0068658926,
0.0365556814,
-0.0420178249,
0.0433292314,
-0.0350168459,
-0.008969794,
0.0460196137,
0.0438891575,
0.016807802,
-0.0679886043,
-0.0198338237,
0.0330702327,
0.0201635212,
-0.0173248965,
-0.0339869745,
0.0268212259,
-0.0422107056,
-0.0199516304,
-0.1279387325,
0.0241204854,
-0.0428081974,
0.0478016324,
0.0361740664,
0.0157664698,
-0.0120055182,
0.0025097732,
-0.0413236432,
-0.006954887,
-0.0051283552,
0.0166691113,
0.0039580422,
0.0121595412,
-0.0548903458,
-0.0328182615,
-0.0245797224,
0.0128823305,
0.0091603231,
-0.0259721279,
-0.0335437953,
-0.0502687804,
0.0269138739,
0.0215598177,
0.0321852192,
-0.0280430093,
-0.0403741822,
0.0286620893,
-0.0131916767,
0.022422038,
0.0564827994,
0.0091918698,
0.0324681439,
0.035933394,
-0.004605711,
-0.0380468853,
0.0039795218,
0.0074767899,
-0.0176853314,
-0.047834374,
0.0131148528,
-0.0355851315,
0.0680892318,
-0.0240152664,
0.0235026926,
-0.0467457771,
-0.0545881651,
-0.0074934787,
-0.0186977778,
-0.0011579799,
-0.0073121767,
-0.0452123471,
0.0152830444,
-0.0201677047,
-0.0475713946,
0.0369458422,
-0.072753258,
-0.010113907,
-0.0273618083,
-0.0241333414,
-0.0619775467,
0.0559531078,
-0.0165120848,
-0.000588087,
-0.0234973822,
-0.029693285,
-0.0268132407,
0.0109080635,
-0.0473451428,
-0.0099201407,
0.0441192053,
-0.0330220386,
0.0281426031,
-0.0339715071,
-0.0427029394,
-0.0357763246,
0.0169480089,
-0.0148677267,
0.006767021,
0.0132689979,
-0.0117503675,
-0.0028575116,
0.0167621188,
0.0022928847,
0.0710796043,
-0.003058872,
0.0273886435,
-0.0359189585,
0.0206415113,
0.0104565276,
0.0103925159,
0.0120017789,
-0.0261624195,
0.0244570449,
0.0384301171,
0.0689211413,
-0.0181408152,
-0.0451095626,
0.0099997222,
0.0177740548,
-0.0332725458,
-0.0384060927,
0.0405024067,
0.072805807,
-0.0670503154,
-0.0126294028,
0.1045094058,
0.0153912082,
-0.0508274809,
0.0202667434,
0.0182430968,
0.0242977478,
0.0136893736,
-0.0174184367,
-0.1036241204,
-0.04706195,
0.0239357762,
0.0271577965,
0.015567584,
0.0111299194,
-0.0085089887,
-0.1022509784,
-0.0031535702,
0.0327074714,
-0.0547743998,
0.0046467264,
-0.0320735835,
-0.0130824009,
0.0166432988,
0.0498359688,
0.0438808501,
-0.0164988786,
-0.0156703126,
0.0275924094,
0.031291604,
-0.0675293878,
0.0422162414,
-0.0229350533,
0.0515951812,
0.0396262482,
-0.0194229912,
0.0187972896,
-0.0252628382,
0.0526178628,
-0.0352995843,
0.0421896577,
-0.0084293764,
0.0155424792,
-0.0247214362,
-0.00611324,
0.0265507288,
0.0341873802,
-0.0499880612,
-0.0190123506,
0.0160723124,
0.0474885702,
-0.0223251693,
0.0367774591,
-0.0219758358,
-0.0438455269,
-0.0041736392,
0.0605824776,
0.0354066528,
-0.0272744261,
-0.0359860659,
-0.0056854398,
-0.0170560982,
-0.0498608202,
0.0052796653,
0.0023164852,
-0.010087871,
0.005065232,
-0.0474000499,
-0.046601329,
0.0200593863,
0.0668136328,
-0.0105083995,
0.0243328474,
-0.0291406699,
0.0039154124,
-0.0791145936,
0.0323242731,
-0.0327865072,
0.0536805801,
-0.114110209,
0.0155660156,
0.0317914821,
-0.000880444,
0.0106709497,
0.0315024629,
-0.0876268223,
-0.0616363361,
0.0104635023,
0.023090221,
0.0249444321,
0.0657016858,
0.0121269627,
-0.0385386534,
0.0539451465,
0.0322247222,
-0.0350694731,
0.0740494654,
0.0222788304,
-0.0181629807,
0.0087104402,
0.0255824067,
-0.0441268161,
0.0175299719,
-0.0026046224,
0.0478444137,
0.0024299945,
0.001179777,
0.0045802896,
-0.008675795,
0.0270595644,
-0.0403165594,
0.0066073951,
0.0060803061,
0.0669194609,
-0.0481663309,
0.0417141579,
-0.0192883387,
0.0210961998,
0.0141257346,
-0.0117121339,
0.0304278918,
-0.0189022031,
0.0041680322,
0.0096793743,
-0.0168935657,
0.0565619171,
-0.0291666929,
0.0352881998,
0.027895581,
0.0173312854,
-0.0286361761,
-0.0145820659,
0.0025806914,
0.0259839799,
-0.0352865756,
0.0326589793,
-0.0046816431,
0.0167435426,
-0.0377658531,
0.0636237115,
-0.0423929356,
0.0087209484,
-0.0608148202,
0.0170878042,
0.0623384155,
-0.0004534871,
0.0355915017,
-0.0132979415,
-0.0071607456,
-0.0094399545,
0.0317529216,
-0.0033330612,
-0.0101918112,
0.0316724144,
0.0352713205,
-0.0023686264,
0.0209525321,
0.0679722056,
0.0418528505,
0.0604780205,
0.0143591156,
0.0137119479,
-0.0243061464,
-0.0371433757,
-0.0018594243,
0.0392920077,
-0.0073075797,
-0.0131737767,
-0.0293924287,
-0.0680660754,
0.0106892977,
-0.0065329676,
-0.0236971937,
-0.0258080922,
0.0527174212,
0.0366462953,
-0.0006691968,
-0.0242776126,
0.0131856892,
0.0108778076,
0.0162645765,
-0.0413165241,
0.0108052408,
-6.289804316e-33,
-0.0359950066,
0.0077899438,
0.0414849371,
-0.0342510007,
-0.0481704734,
0.0397686996,
-0.0145292236,
-0.00908833,
0.0055188187,
-0.0413494445,
-0.0313071944,
0.0104838684,
0.0277559794,
0.0378481857,
-0.0173153132,
0.0152552789,
0.0526487269,
-0.0169265922,
0.0121699497,
0.0229819473,
0.0325181372,
0.0358130522,
0.0533741824,
-0.0519416369,
-0.0154376533,
0.0069466974,
0.0001424118,
-0.0036793768,
-0.0047502187,
0.086775668,
-0.0303068887,
0.0463954993,
0.0157166086,
-0.0649013892,
-0.0255252589,
0.0202236343,
-0.0940236375,
-0.0063860216,
0.0036273936,
0.0113948593,
-0.0113104125,
-0.0518542118,
0.0492673144,
0.0113430042,
-0.0530712716,
0.0219270848,
-0.0064117038,
-0.0410550572,
-0.016189564,
-0.0127412509,
-0.0433893502,
0.0159778967,
0.0302567407,
0.0064478288,
0.0370736048,
-0.0289024282,
-0.0092012724,
0.0138800843,
-0.0434262045,
-0.00313509,
0.0429805778,
0.0659374744,
0.0621936209,
0.0530500449,
0.0217117984,
0.0311092157,
0.0047980691,
-0.0193167366,
0.0051438226,
-0.027799435,
0.0225504655,
0.0269244481,
0.018806627,
0.0311461277,
0.0549135953,
-0.0016476134,
-0.0909813046,
0.0048332317,
0.0334622785,
0.0262455251,
0.0144612333,
0.034152817,
-0.0249916725,
-0.0110246744,
-0.024558818,
-0.0067774272,
-0.018151436,
-0.0383852459,
0.0685563534,
0.0355483964,
0.0163138602,
-0.0132578602,
0.0459743924,
-0.017130658,
-0.0128922239,
0.0332216956,
-0.0170258433,
0.0238212273,
0.0094204564,
0.013380778,
-0.0484620333,
-0.0283313859,
0.0243940223,
-0.0028641869,
0.0276290774,
-0.0327196345,
0.0032853121,
0.0348883606,
-0.0635592192,
-0.0079651065,
-0.0407681093,
-0.0093858633,
0.0194059256,
0.0232708082,
0.0397166759,
-0.0197339933,
0.0104482276,
0.083257474,
-0.0116900345,
-0.0168257654,
-0.00819977,
-0.0658583641,
0.0218241718,
0.0557681918,
-0.0350063108,
0.0225670822,
-0.0173735376,
0.0216184426,
0.0401114635,
-0.0726021975,
-0.0286633372,
0.0215782151,
2.714e-7,
0.0306877494,
0.0319303758,
0.060422983,
-0.0118520437,
0.022499511,
0.0025477309,
-0.0068671978,
0.0322218239,
-0.023061255,
-0.0322585069,
0.005420919,
0.0255947448,
0.0150744654,
0.0056001903,
-0.0737902895,
0.0155453309,
-0.0472620912,
0.0355182923,
-0.0715086013,
-0.0043606716,
0.0245165285,
0.1315975189,
-0.0106855603,
-0.0285763554,
0.0222541634,
-0.0202258863,
0.0379775278,
-0.022882292,
0.0253532231,
-0.0184595566,
-0.0206745733,
0.0232255831,
-0.0248540044,
-0.017990334,
0.0067601539,
0.023570884,
-0.0201825146,
0.069046475,
-0.0051132832,
-0.0548724346,
0.0390736796,
0.0083424682,
-0.0290836357,
-0.0545115955,
0.072459206,
-0.028768057,
0.0015170885,
-0.0040777507,
-0.0119358348,
-0.0200227648,
-0.0118982857,
0.0055593448,
0.0258311071,
0.0209058747,
0.0033737982,
-0.007104516,
-0.0341695845,
-0.1039095148,
-0.0314098783,
0.0006941507,
-0.0475237072,
-0.03376491,
-0.089272812,
0.011060643,
0.0170242209,
-0.0364767872,
-0.0304980148,
3.004091067e-34,
0.0074498472,
-0.0425666198,
0.0238018129,
0.0346975625,
-0.0192983449,
-0.0079590697,
-0.0388781503,
0.021984214,
0.000826857,
-0.0888496935,
-0.0260030106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16035v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16035v2 | MKRAG: Medical Knowledge Retrieval Augmented Generation for Medical Question Answering | 2023-09-27T21:26:03 | 2024-06-28T16:21:45 | Yucheng Shi, Shaochen Xu, Tianze Yang, Zhengliang Liu, Tianming Liu, Xiang Li, Ninghao Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs), although powerful in general domains, often
perform poorly on domain-specific tasks like medical question answering (QA).
Moreover, they tend to function as "black-boxes," making it challenging to
modify their behavior. To address the problem, our study delves into retrieval
augmented generation (RAG), aiming to improve LLM responses without the need
for fine-tuning or retraining. Specifically, we propose a comprehensive
retrieval strategy to extract medical facts from an external knowledge base,
and then inject them into the query prompt for LLMs. Focusing on medical QA
using the MedQA-SMILE dataset, we evaluate the impact of different retrieval
models and the number of facts provided to the LLM. Notably, our
retrieval-augmented Vicuna-7B model exhibited an accuracy improvement from
44.46% to 48.54%. This work underscores the potential of RAG to enhance LLM
performance, offering a practical approach to mitigate the challenges of
black-box LLMs. | [
0.06014679,
0.0175422393,
0.0070576649,
-0.0266928226,
-0.001449415,
-0.00720884,
-0.0101830624,
0.0340103991,
0.0165664963,
-0.0251553077,
-0.0244219694,
-0.0407999493,
-0.0354269594,
0.0124211945,
0.0502546467,
-0.0225349218,
0.0488847867,
0.0330564752,
-0.002876176,
0.0101945717,
-0.0205192417,
0.0161946453,
-0.013895873,
0.0373822264,
0.0280587953,
0.0072368397,
0.0212213714,
0.0014798506,
0.0346999131,
-0.0564480908,
0.0122221196,
0.0164153557,
-0.0041275909,
-0.0086569684,
0.0000019368,
-0.055491969,
-0.0164893623,
0.0131343231,
-0.0503231622,
-0.0220573265,
0.0056342287,
-0.0035703829,
0.0320373885,
0.0309327282,
-0.04427398,
-0.0367736481,
-0.001724293,
0.0349265523,
0.0581935495,
0.0720777512,
0.0099942517,
0.002002876,
0.0239515956,
-0.0256889742,
0.0350696556,
-0.0294980332,
0.0365851969,
-0.0041512013,
0.0427327305,
0.028892003,
0.0334113203,
0.0447979532,
-0.0073893466,
0.0160699524,
0.0544176362,
0.0535695665,
-0.0538809337,
0.0058745923,
0.0148440888,
0.0781285837,
0.0412465744,
-0.0015795594,
0.0100690881,
0.0202996638,
0.0092908731,
0.0130953258,
-0.0535280406,
-0.004199544,
-0.0407201946,
-0.0165364556,
-0.0106040919,
-0.0150147779,
0.050811585,
0.0122911176,
-0.011595197,
0.0093918918,
0.0291441213,
-0.0180452745,
-0.001170363,
-0.012376559,
-0.0198817886,
-0.0125635182,
0.0137310037,
0.0783848763,
-0.0360399224,
0.0097478935,
-0.0032986288,
-0.0496399552,
0.0921938419,
-0.0268944856,
0.0137344506,
0.0320835225,
-0.0439915322,
0.0348990895,
-0.0350297466,
0.0238132905,
-0.0337924138,
0.0286952164,
-0.0645992234,
0.0048086476,
-0.0308997855,
-0.0532190539,
-0.0431600288,
0.0255420245,
-0.0157239717,
0.0173501913,
-0.0538957193,
-0.0013913409,
0.0096764788,
-0.0230329055,
0.0148080252,
0.063862972,
-0.0393791497,
-0.0081694555,
-0.0480499417,
0.0326820239,
-0.017643163,
0.0142737702,
0.031852264,
-0.0671301112,
-0.0145963691,
-0.0061807553,
0.0086829197,
-0.0218460169,
0.0404968187,
0.048908975,
-0.0137558104,
-0.0254756026,
-0.0214380082,
-0.0547462441,
-0.0161884483,
-0.0338319391,
0.0123453801,
-0.0503179505,
0.0267882887,
0.0016203634,
-0.0194680914,
-0.0103150466,
0.027646536,
0.0626899227,
-0.0320421793,
0.0388847589,
-0.0504276976,
0.0087561915,
0.0563350059,
0.0419882908,
0.0127026113,
0.032515306,
-0.0107923811,
-0.0404224284,
0.0091023808,
0.0124124726,
-0.00468974,
-0.0152459582,
0.0620547906,
-0.0167690534,
-0.0017941211,
0.0538807102,
0.0102473451,
0.074918583,
-0.0117035052,
0.07101354,
-0.0187766273,
-0.0195904821,
-0.0103647113,
0.0144767174,
0.0275220294,
-0.0066661499,
0.0226694196,
-0.0351112373,
0.0219478253,
-0.0198986288,
-0.0009039833,
0.0304814149,
-0.021273315,
0.0243506767,
-0.0018823419,
0.0553812571,
-0.0533981621,
-0.0345699377,
-0.0302339643,
0.0049587251,
-0.0264763366,
0.0156274363,
0.0361700505,
0.032695733,
-0.019674154,
0.0801708922,
0.0361362398,
-0.0443735719,
0.0140804257,
-0.0701924339,
0.0257375184,
0.0638849959,
0.0912609622,
-0.0273686107,
-0.0557326116,
0.0003643239,
0.0060581584,
0.0128803905,
0.022207763,
-0.0340612605,
-0.0089105433,
-0.0712189004,
-0.0041176891,
-0.005976914,
0.0070188055,
-0.0225257743,
0.0402805395,
0.0239630174,
0.0348036401,
-0.0353671461,
0.0220329072,
0.0350543857,
-0.0611815304,
-0.0393983573,
0.0137045495,
-0.0214300174,
0.0012113664,
0.0304759424,
0.0088011278,
0.0495790839,
0.0469542667,
-0.0433694832,
-0.0410345793,
-0.0209981259,
-0.0308607407,
-0.0520251915,
0.032364767,
0.0229748338,
0.016608417,
-0.0072084772,
-0.0359912738,
-0.0436600968,
-0.0420377143,
-0.0515409969,
0.0414426886,
-0.0388162099,
-0.0074697104,
0.0707642958,
-0.0018893563,
-0.0781820789,
0.0527341738,
-0.0250695255,
0.0148667591,
0.0424626656,
0.0003560153,
0.0161076169,
-0.0516992994,
-0.007793555,
0.009376714,
-0.0088919615,
0.0196565557,
0.0099174744,
0.0049844449,
-0.0672431216,
-0.0286077131,
-0.1094054133,
0.0099694049,
0.0098559288,
-0.0055349329,
0.0337656885,
0.064745672,
-0.0083463341,
-0.0321036205,
-0.0721491873,
-0.0017168915,
0.0413408428,
0.0342824236,
0.0425841436,
0.0741890892,
0.0203546938,
-0.0429155789,
-0.0107181212,
-0.0151159326,
0.0006278537,
-0.0027945857,
0.0208561718,
-0.0168634579,
0.0012170143,
-0.0832995325,
-0.0127677415,
-0.0139859384,
-0.0299804602,
0.006193046,
-0.0418769196,
0.0160143059,
0.0457718484,
0.0218393672,
-0.0318926238,
0.0467741899,
0.0101811411,
-0.0555719882,
0.0553722158,
-0.0451227352,
-0.0491559803,
0.0431655124,
-0.0247503184,
-0.0046062646,
0.037801072,
0.0129440855,
-0.0178516526,
-0.0331508666,
0.0161246378,
0.003941793,
0.0053250161,
-0.0786404088,
0.0160520449,
-0.0354014374,
0.0456411913,
-0.0078649307,
-0.0283556916,
0.0948518962,
0.0020913563,
0.0140149733,
-0.0601280779,
0.0066474038,
-0.0618525818,
0.0168861914,
-0.0259063933,
0.0217073113,
-0.0128387576,
-0.0125372494,
-0.0226778742,
0.0089151533,
-0.0299352519,
-0.1025679111,
0.0570631251,
-0.0003519776,
0.0378869921,
0.005731795,
-0.0459207781,
-0.0604771338,
-0.0314365961,
-0.0213479884,
-0.0068832044,
-0.0379793681,
0.0202070139,
-0.0282628424,
0.0048245303,
0.0351277925,
0.0288600344,
-0.0086445231,
-0.0162212439,
0.004781994,
0.0429603755,
0.0768146291,
0.0309292451,
-0.0185074005,
-0.0070588258,
0.0071732374,
0.0604801625,
0.0323154069,
-0.0137594556,
0.0280699097,
-0.0153052518,
0.0139495414,
-0.0086734304,
-0.0006685189,
0.0154468529,
0.0123504484,
-0.0609084517,
-0.0386003666,
0.0902368277,
0.0352719873,
-0.0076784827,
0.0044586551,
-0.042863626,
0.0333130099,
0.0056093945,
0.0631305575,
-0.0723367631,
-0.0407395773,
-0.010767689,
0.0616706423,
-0.0154100461,
0.0016640883,
0.0117860697,
-0.0862236917,
0.0145622296,
-0.0053631356,
-0.0258041155,
-0.0387101732,
-0.0210117623,
0.0107196057,
0.0066280477,
0.0046933652,
0.0378855802,
-0.023057647,
0.0091849668,
0.0195066165,
0.0089999596,
-0.0626972467,
0.0143246679,
-0.0018659041,
0.015493907,
0.0831388012,
0.0116698025,
0.0103994971,
-0.0473966449,
-0.0165770072,
-0.0088256495,
0.0318808071,
-0.0104646357,
0.0821107775,
0.0199542847,
-0.0047609783,
-0.0565352179,
0.0074881916,
-0.0225387234,
-0.0227595232,
-0.0049459585,
0.0632257834,
-0.0341738574,
0.0049753715,
-0.0665879771,
0.0191930886,
-0.0016906518,
0.0647421107,
-0.0060168905,
0.0178689137,
-0.0017067555,
0.0227693729,
0.0353953317,
-0.0233723596,
-0.0292096417,
0.0433524773,
-0.0154428417,
0.017742265,
-0.0795741007,
-0.0324744619,
0.016159581,
0.0203086417,
-0.0100184744,
0.0381017476,
-0.0252103247,
0.0109228678,
-0.0610754974,
0.0578333288,
-0.0164616071,
-0.0202736706,
-0.0204662737,
-0.0432195812,
0.0723090842,
-0.0422507264,
-0.0126264188,
0.0047281859,
-0.0076202452,
-0.0177821536,
-0.0297102779,
0.0536690392,
0.0208276827,
0.0161548406,
-0.0144052086,
-0.0141687682,
0.0645774677,
0.0575666875,
-0.0647938401,
-0.0024454836,
-0.0206795838,
-0.031921681,
-0.0232134741,
0.0305616781,
-0.0485845841,
-0.0171675272,
-0.0053347978,
0.0661696643,
-0.0028692693,
-0.0477392897,
0.0364835486,
0.0497734845,
0.0072558513,
-0.0169751197,
0.0091787046,
-0.0183238462,
0.025044905,
-0.0156018818,
-0.0047904528,
-0.0185028519,
0.0266734734,
0.0195931569,
-0.0443410464,
0.0098343315,
-0.0149149969,
-0.0456139259,
0.0389581919,
-0.037882477,
0.0012138382,
-0.0109357201,
-0.0111492788,
0.0422942862,
-0.0183768012,
-0.0240293052,
0.0079947794,
0.0169491023,
0.0284903552,
-0.0331633613,
0.0425005294,
-0.0007853479,
0.0152450679,
-0.0029069041,
0.0352252126,
-0.0747378618,
-0.0473867208,
-0.0384756289,
0.0098103713,
0.0269520655,
0.0130443107,
0.0244305227,
0.012556768,
-0.0274609122,
-0.0309013389,
-0.0209496226,
-0.0147783291,
-0.0004480232,
0.0722771287,
0.0278578456,
-0.0101244338,
-0.0240579639,
0.083779119,
-0.0398992039,
0.0703993514,
-0.0280469321,
-0.0149361845,
-0.0432216711,
-0.0324835777,
0.0256290548,
0.032429941,
-0.0446224362,
0.0123496978,
-0.0612995066,
-0.0493686087,
0.0163692515,
-0.014824586,
-0.0441682525,
-0.0217564479,
0.0754115134,
0.0673677921,
0.0193149578,
-0.0597057529,
-0.0349020511,
0.0638534576,
-0.0752215758,
0.0052156127,
0.0184948891,
-6.542412174e-33,
-0.0413329042,
0.011817432,
0.0633527637,
-0.0571073517,
-0.0137487147,
0.021638779,
-0.0427363068,
-0.0251865592,
-0.0322761908,
0.0086149788,
-0.0271537192,
-0.0003702313,
-0.0038714851,
0.0395057723,
-0.0005342716,
-0.038811706,
0.0313354246,
0.0101014748,
-0.0269048307,
0.0470081866,
0.0138715878,
0.069472,
-0.0030901849,
-0.0279422756,
-0.0092480071,
-0.0217564795,
0.0318103768,
0.020114392,
-0.03131596,
0.088397257,
-0.0295013003,
0.0436366275,
0.0418857671,
-0.0136036072,
0.0030412567,
-0.0080988146,
-0.0744976401,
-0.0060143261,
0.0007730775,
-0.0440769158,
-0.0602795519,
-0.0615911558,
0.0384284928,
-0.0441555902,
0.0042463792,
-0.0112418141,
0.0125937117,
-0.0457734577,
-0.0098850317,
-0.0471755564,
-0.0126610855,
0.0181545299,
0.0320884027,
-0.0167181809,
-0.0701127574,
0.0355029851,
-0.0264186468,
0.0649192706,
-0.0060431515,
0.0040545319,
0.0309033543,
0.0662888959,
0.0136387032,
0.0069818171,
-0.0251798835,
0.0348599963,
-0.0004456086,
-0.0446247868,
-0.0483764336,
0.0157877021,
-0.0466946661,
0.0189172924,
0.0507867411,
0.0459941551,
0.0080782017,
-0.0124582499,
-0.0868258253,
0.057120651,
-0.0426741131,
0.0593858883,
0.0102587715,
-0.0223360267,
-0.0250893719,
0.0087449178,
-0.0161769111,
0.0489314608,
-0.0278262757,
-0.0428765267,
0.058990784,
0.0269550886,
0.0052992771,
-0.0083892411,
-0.0094377194,
-0.0034729245,
0.0502042286,
0.0294116773,
0.011726154,
-0.025949806,
-0.0330967791,
0.0177240744,
-0.0413849391,
0.0109334271,
0.04713865,
-0.0188706871,
-0.0113794785,
0.042472031,
0.0080091348,
-0.0232715979,
-0.0552532971,
-0.0033263848,
-0.0102336006,
0.0241680853,
-0.018733995,
0.0011582333,
0.0091251163,
0.047728017,
-0.0089933975,
0.0583713092,
0.0086331284,
0.0227563381,
-0.0422158875,
-0.0642202273,
0.0174500942,
0.0140741374,
-0.0318262503,
0.0470004566,
-0.0169574562,
0.0663125515,
-0.01519439,
-0.042079635,
-0.0162069555,
0.027071625,
2.813e-7,
0.0957514867,
0.0172291826,
0.0056048138,
0.0066031185,
-0.0000279617,
0.0078360271,
-0.0019771527,
0.0034315228,
0.0354251266,
-0.0198724959,
-0.0020175679,
0.0222316645,
0.0216079243,
0.0214900952,
-0.0874227583,
0.0147165554,
-0.0871728659,
-0.0383797623,
-0.0094062798,
-0.0740347952,
0.0598972701,
0.0754091367,
-0.0572364219,
-0.0496666916,
0.0059452439,
-0.0508693457,
0.0686115623,
0.0092930738,
-0.0545115024,
0.0495226867,
0.0565220453,
0.0425168648,
0.0215222407,
0.0097536668,
-0.0299212113,
-0.0062216506,
0.0132941827,
0.0619577803,
-0.0174647644,
-0.0421741083,
0.0215115193,
0.0069848388,
0.0239111632,
-0.039297305,
0.0698126853,
-0.0252134092,
-0.0145940632,
-0.0078243604,
-0.0135346306,
0.0063769221,
0.0545503348,
-0.0427885838,
-0.0357572511,
0.0304636303,
0.0214469675,
0.0167349484,
-0.0207322035,
-0.0893577412,
-0.0279997252,
0.0244061872,
-0.0572059937,
-0.0662367195,
0.0065998724,
0.0124724088,
-0.0502596609,
-0.0705811381,
-0.0003995927,
2.382981204e-34,
0.0208561197,
0.0166767612,
0.0103053395,
0.0412820354,
0.0121498927,
-0.012160643,
-0.013180187,
0.001244072,
0.0216327831,
-0.0768662244,
-0.0158651415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15991v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15991v2 | Targeted Image Data Augmentation Increases Basic Skills Captioning Robustness | 2023-09-27T20:12:41 | 2023-11-17T15:47:35 | Valentin Barriere, Felipe del Rio, Andres Carvallo De Ferari, Carlos Aspillaga, Eugenio Herrera-Berg, Cristian Buc Calderon | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Artificial neural networks typically struggle in generalizing to
out-of-context examples. One reason for this limitation is caused by having
datasets that incorporate only partial information regarding the potential
correlational structure of the world. In this work, we propose TIDA (Targeted
Image-editing Data Augmentation), a targeted data augmentation method focused
on improving models' human-like abilities (e.g., gender recognition) by filling
the correlational structure gap using a text-to-image generative model. More
specifically, TIDA identifies specific skills in captions describing images
(e.g., the presence of a specific gender in the image), changes the caption
(e.g., "woman" to "man"), and then uses a text-to-image model to edit the image
in order to match the novel caption (e.g., uniquely changing a woman to a man
while maintaining the context identical). Based on the Flickr30K benchmark, we
show that, compared with the original data set, a TIDA-enhanced dataset related
to gender, color, and counting abilities induces better performance in several
image captioning metrics. Furthermore, on top of relying on the classical BLEU
metric, we conduct a fine-grained analysis of the improvements of our models
against the baseline in different ways. We compared text-to-image generative
models and found different behaviors of the image captioning models in terms of
encoding visual encoding and textual decoding. | [
0.049751617,
0.1024376675,
-0.0120336227,
0.0110246167,
0.0340004042,
0.0111533487,
0.0340048894,
-0.0136796581,
-0.0228688139,
-0.0621344112,
-0.0377198718,
-0.0441508591,
0.0265974123,
0.0592680946,
0.034273155,
-0.0752151459,
-0.018980043,
-0.0002402515,
-0.0116983969,
0.0065710419,
0.0117185051,
0.012503244,
0.0253510904,
0.0390751474,
-0.0037584365,
-0.0055194274,
0.0358994417,
0.040922828,
0.0019986585,
0.0136773903,
0.0010844099,
0.0862474963,
0.0328583829,
0.021558905,
0.0000018586,
-0.0290401448,
0.0217144098,
0.0112752216,
0.012258403,
-0.0019296139,
0.0727121159,
-0.0504233874,
-0.0118309781,
-0.0029561976,
-0.0128522916,
-0.0108751506,
0.084347032,
0.0398336612,
0.0607596114,
0.0426141359,
-0.0153659992,
-0.0193280615,
0.0231063254,
-0.0562697835,
0.0194589812,
-0.0135064628,
0.0020704048,
0.0467243865,
-0.0180252641,
0.0082050096,
-0.0518995188,
0.0481299944,
0.0001979444,
-0.0323028751,
0.0458003543,
0.0615090244,
-0.0030478952,
-0.0412709415,
0.0073114112,
0.0637877733,
0.0057315184,
0.0168015789,
-0.042480126,
0.0032733171,
0.0137545196,
0.010496146,
-0.059093032,
0.0010084916,
0.0276633594,
-0.0019236866,
-0.0576032363,
-0.0066328845,
0.0191466082,
0.0274708644,
0.0104591679,
-0.0084387166,
0.0157820731,
-0.0070498306,
-0.0469269603,
0.0017103211,
-0.0310404692,
-0.0710508227,
0.0096550016,
-0.0159862954,
0.0257241614,
-0.0084457798,
-0.0559597164,
-0.0581694543,
0.000067217,
-0.0455685854,
0.0237765517,
0.0190020204,
-0.0434328243,
0.0488295294,
-0.0264288466,
0.0622726716,
0.0117378663,
0.0327322148,
-0.0432050787,
-0.0148700047,
-0.0626899078,
-0.0273171514,
-0.0049953493,
-0.0069835023,
-0.0378062613,
-0.0312955305,
-0.0471186675,
-0.0007919093,
-0.0442169681,
-0.0048194481,
-0.0014180582,
0.0730269179,
-0.0592630133,
0.022927966,
-0.0389771536,
-0.0071377275,
0.0260106418,
0.0120529439,
-0.0179199409,
-0.0307479668,
0.0042834841,
-0.0088650631,
0.0447767973,
-0.0306766424,
0.0174458548,
0.0518828742,
-0.0465236343,
-0.044379048,
0.0019022386,
-0.0152545748,
-0.0349297002,
-0.0252569169,
0.0369955748,
-0.0444687232,
0.0368597694,
-0.026883835,
-0.0018115031,
-0.0863833576,
0.001240426,
0.0339115411,
-0.0166426823,
0.1109136865,
-0.0063503161,
-0.0010088709,
0.0488699079,
0.0248651784,
-0.0265592784,
0.0560428463,
0.0550132245,
0.0287598278,
0.0334497504,
0.0040410939,
0.0486274287,
0.0314165056,
0.0203093123,
0.0067595174,
-0.026406467,
0.0096710157,
0.0029554751,
0.0337500572,
0.1106456891,
-0.000687387,
-0.0190481674,
0.0029178995,
0.1080226228,
0.0449273288,
0.0166163053,
0.0347206332,
0.0365348645,
-0.0252021533,
-0.0030449503,
0.0040784935,
-0.0639711097,
0.0723566785,
0.0157548022,
-0.0120891267,
0.0072753835,
0.0172608905,
-0.0335828699,
-0.0341882519,
0.0171276592,
-0.0037951877,
0.0466730669,
-0.0136536397,
0.0108392471,
0.0336464867,
-0.0099383388,
0.004930743,
-0.0111547001,
-0.0479593538,
0.0060844617,
-0.0562503114,
-0.0378171057,
0.0824104324,
0.0365663916,
0.0101206573,
-0.0411895998,
-0.0301594436,
0.0246987697,
0.0494446196,
0.0012485599,
0.023983499,
0.0245471187,
-0.0365164652,
-0.02846759,
-0.0365102701,
0.025489416,
0.0253898222,
0.0205305032,
0.0040029269,
0.034828186,
0.0196952466,
-0.0963893235,
0.0428800248,
0.0153541435,
-0.0307819135,
0.0342620909,
0.0195951685,
-0.0079810275,
0.0152146844,
-0.0435757488,
-0.0089195892,
-0.0388957411,
-0.0175795127,
-0.0440557227,
0.0531616583,
-0.0275525022,
-0.0295137446,
0.029659519,
-0.0608407743,
-0.0565672517,
0.0297109727,
-0.0157128982,
-0.0338390134,
0.0629345328,
-0.0451116711,
-0.0340010859,
-0.0763243511,
0.0008281691,
0.0057081897,
0.0321185514,
0.0310462192,
0.0442012288,
-0.0216624178,
-0.0419362746,
0.01279038,
-0.0006228425,
-0.0326355845,
-0.0645270795,
-0.0370658375,
-0.0291727986,
0.0294255894,
0.0313443765,
0.0092960866,
0.0437286086,
-0.0191956684,
-0.0196367037,
-0.0573827811,
-0.0212798081,
-0.0072565293,
-0.0436831079,
0.0123066846,
0.0001280253,
0.0040525342,
-0.0414694361,
-0.0368749276,
-0.0276099183,
-0.0054157279,
0.0225647576,
0.0514321029,
0.0161933415,
-0.0139648775,
-0.0358412452,
-0.0076317391,
0.0123843541,
0.0734988004,
0.047511857,
-0.0199112352,
-0.0008118956,
0.0263466313,
0.0061333445,
0.0205217544,
-0.0085872784,
-0.0480473302,
-0.0039315056,
0.037586499,
0.0108569516,
0.0741327479,
0.0013131966,
-0.0060535087,
0.0095949396,
0.0038977277,
-0.0018463976,
-0.0030898466,
0.0231282655,
-0.0298895091,
0.0425208732,
-0.0829882473,
-0.0090469252,
-0.0002263321,
-0.01643789,
0.0028927349,
-0.0629079044,
0.0334741771,
-0.0061219046,
-0.0690310821,
-0.0550422519,
0.00867303,
0.0110492771,
0.0117752375,
-0.078456156,
-0.0609989241,
0.0215125401,
-0.0296074245,
-0.0478093401,
0.0119708236,
-0.0087427823,
-0.034835849,
0.0705099776,
0.0250465311,
0.0346799344,
-0.0321714059,
-0.0147287929,
-0.0313769653,
-0.0160291288,
0.0050684977,
-0.0293081366,
0.042103909,
-0.0413517393,
-0.0185379758,
-0.0223222282,
-0.0366710238,
-0.026603898,
0.0252467692,
0.0114795454,
0.0142663512,
-0.0134162093,
-0.0270577893,
-0.0090557672,
0.0109399576,
0.004913385,
0.0489518642,
-0.0289113373,
-0.012586832,
-0.0082518691,
0.022018142,
0.0477103554,
0.0475395918,
-0.0580257513,
-0.0324019082,
-0.0212013908,
0.0142563181,
-0.0381915122,
-0.0281874835,
-0.0614596978,
0.0198336504,
0.0066974969,
0.0196290072,
-0.0003258844,
-0.0028560741,
0.0510002784,
-0.0526740775,
-0.0167034175,
0.0805771127,
0.0111436779,
-0.0437952653,
-0.0193121564,
0.0306390822,
-0.0147100752,
0.0484444425,
0.0180852897,
-0.0417018943,
-0.0474077724,
-0.0087857665,
0.0109848669,
-0.0264756456,
0.0053217816,
-0.0550402664,
-0.0872949734,
0.0412847959,
0.0061007068,
-0.0392728671,
-0.0633604601,
0.0174411274,
-0.0015075231,
-0.0071516433,
0.0126323514,
-0.023185784,
0.0105505949,
0.0306661557,
0.0149437739,
-0.0127134547,
-0.0856801718,
0.005857321,
-0.0391282253,
0.0512086302,
0.0748351961,
0.0289469324,
-0.0293226559,
-0.0214093048,
-0.0075978572,
0.0394407958,
0.0323190987,
0.0100043491,
0.0965625942,
-0.0383681059,
-0.0181797072,
-0.0053325742,
0.060081128,
0.0333883688,
-0.0187055822,
0.0057179551,
-0.0009653874,
0.0259558,
0.0311369691,
-0.0585674196,
-0.0123181939,
-0.0043577161,
0.0486405492,
0.0411170051,
-0.0556334443,
-0.0183883794,
-0.0395173728,
-0.0123244869,
-0.0993265361,
-0.0155996429,
-0.0069125015,
0.0049524596,
-0.0433113873,
-0.0520645678,
-0.0280962456,
0.0444100872,
0.0069396347,
0.016681388,
-0.0185070317,
-0.0297477171,
0.0135767469,
-0.0704095587,
0.0330488421,
-0.0258398186,
0.013125984,
-0.0339151919,
-0.0296623707,
0.0187974069,
-0.0744453818,
-0.0284771547,
0.0444356911,
-0.0584361851,
-0.0138168484,
-0.0220518727,
0.0725854337,
0.0152566796,
0.0421633758,
0.012294258,
-0.072970137,
0.0099001173,
0.0918910354,
-0.0034102676,
0.0318683237,
0.0257651489,
-0.0057393061,
-0.0142133832,
0.0209756736,
-0.0323262215,
0.0165362842,
0.0244603641,
0.0032865803,
0.0026647071,
0.0115195205,
-0.0035736798,
0.0048342901,
0.0037226558,
-0.0468897186,
0.0149187632,
-0.0412584208,
-0.0003060474,
-0.0023521606,
0.0075698663,
-0.046476692,
-0.0184444729,
0.0456102751,
0.040927738,
-0.0058759432,
-0.0034629784,
0.0015337473,
0.0131658027,
-0.0513748489,
-0.0073536159,
0.0303475056,
0.0216339268,
-0.0152826542,
0.0292720776,
0.0090050185,
-0.0084226429,
-0.0066111186,
0.003207,
0.0014930315,
0.0120856408,
0.0220740568,
-0.0182275251,
-0.0560819805,
0.0592413582,
-0.0372996628,
0.0218516905,
-0.0587373115,
0.0368142352,
0.0424013138,
0.0062798513,
0.0260122921,
0.0025329459,
-0.0253635012,
0.0235298537,
0.0171061847,
0.0043603801,
-0.0116055943,
0.0255150814,
-0.0133270416,
0.0287121478,
-0.0154872565,
0.0501225404,
0.0075800526,
0.0341498964,
-0.0406782106,
-0.0631467029,
-0.0215990394,
0.0010143314,
0.0243627895,
-0.0061047468,
-0.0167388674,
0.0432034768,
-0.0399940833,
-0.06206147,
0.0102142887,
0.0041681109,
0.0183336623,
0.0511615463,
0.0338423289,
0.0100543415,
-0.0147529123,
-0.0067033656,
-0.0237566698,
-0.0245788619,
0.0188187901,
0.0348735563,
-0.0050907214,
-5.56981072e-33,
-0.048239585,
-0.0347182602,
0.0253015589,
-0.0011260052,
-0.0170025267,
0.0260726213,
-0.0262952037,
-0.0091952942,
0.0283751618,
0.0121432878,
-0.0018638526,
-0.0015452987,
0.0034446795,
0.0436622165,
0.0159677304,
0.0263120141,
0.0746265054,
0.0117067527,
-0.0168337971,
-0.0041021067,
0.0201181453,
0.0110897385,
0.0484536327,
-0.0625736713,
0.0265254322,
0.0062007247,
-0.0255499724,
-0.0079614408,
0.0568383038,
0.0423226133,
-0.0243734308,
0.0257753041,
0.0137708951,
-0.0488763563,
-0.0203113984,
0.0090126954,
-0.0874888301,
-0.0080448566,
0.0061651715,
0.0484136455,
-0.0329808965,
-0.0345980786,
0.0389927514,
-0.009345294,
-0.0320187025,
-0.0518748984,
0.0766728222,
-0.0305232275,
0.0530339591,
0.0207889043,
-0.0368755199,
0.0097834002,
-0.0279980525,
-0.0228141248,
0.0204218756,
0.0159755126,
-0.0048036198,
0.0003416833,
-0.106319055,
0.0164843593,
0.028267419,
0.0029270458,
0.0834540203,
0.0495589264,
0.0198773388,
0.0431615524,
0.0504120924,
0.0038326923,
-0.0318441764,
-0.0164087638,
0.0264163893,
0.0180382766,
0.0365379117,
0.0717420131,
0.0735653415,
-0.0126639064,
-0.0383059233,
0.0155676343,
-0.0575221889,
0.00295385,
0.0293341633,
0.0078833951,
-0.0373561457,
0.0117472596,
-0.0351072401,
-0.0362542458,
-0.0511436611,
-0.0391371138,
0.0389754474,
0.0249786209,
-0.0622950755,
0.0331855118,
0.0259196479,
-0.0533034392,
0.0070878319,
-0.0236427039,
-0.0342714339,
0.0354796238,
0.0182180088,
-0.0179846454,
0.0001744526,
-0.0299871266,
0.0802876577,
0.0554986559,
0.0387455299,
0.0005404331,
0.0860209987,
0.046281483,
-0.0450834148,
-0.0012011626,
-0.0418854989,
0.0084854923,
-0.0302582607,
-0.00916271,
0.009473227,
0.0216516964,
-0.0750287101,
-0.013427509,
0.0012176293,
0.0292679649,
-0.0399068594,
-0.0289261397,
0.0168368053,
0.0061263447,
-0.0316237435,
0.0236953404,
0.0096241422,
-0.0349157453,
0.0250563826,
-0.0516945161,
-0.0306154266,
0.0380910374,
2.553e-7,
0.0221927091,
0.0428057797,
0.0230869409,
0.0129403481,
0.0400326028,
0.0475255959,
-0.0459932387,
0.037257079,
0.0584933199,
0.0114898104,
0.0215322245,
0.0461348295,
-0.0024407357,
-0.0308013242,
-0.0063525797,
0.0058507207,
-0.0391683355,
0.0409410521,
0.0081080571,
-0.0356432348,
0.0129276095,
0.0745776966,
0.019689044,
-0.0413579382,
0.0279989652,
-0.0872813761,
0.0819320008,
-0.0148636745,
0.0240464509,
-0.0209377985,
-0.0179652758,
0.0564389527,
-0.0130594335,
0.0463953093,
-0.0260539874,
0.0048704892,
0.0793821663,
0.0212483183,
-0.0622863024,
0.0397188924,
-0.0260150414,
0.0533859506,
-0.0144592803,
-0.027766889,
0.0890944749,
-0.0449923277,
-0.0382960849,
-0.0440067127,
-0.0266821254,
0.0459244251,
0.0573286004,
-0.039853394,
-0.0429698415,
0.0137601215,
0.044152692,
0.0071890126,
-0.042365171,
-0.0707244575,
-0.0208655111,
-0.0142218489,
-0.0178001672,
-0.038279146,
-0.0945459008,
0.0083944155,
0.0318269357,
-0.0410607681,
-0.0140576512,
1.972691201e-34,
0.0065485523,
0.0248890352,
-0.0011398774,
-0.0318740718,
0.0040034004,
0.0003051426,
-0.0229750443,
-0.0264067501,
0.0268262066,
-0.0340290405,
-0.0209147576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15826v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15826v1 | Cross-Modal Multi-Tasking for Speech-to-Text Translation via Hard Parameter Sharing | 2023-09-27T17:48:14 | 2023-09-27T17:48:14 | Brian Yan, Xuankai Chang, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Yuya Fujita, Shinji Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent works in end-to-end speech-to-text translation (ST) have proposed
multi-tasking methods with soft parameter sharing which leverage machine
translation (MT) data via secondary encoders that map text inputs to an
eventual cross-modal representation. In this work, we instead propose a ST/MT
multi-tasking framework with hard parameter sharing in which all model
parameters are shared cross-modally. Our method reduces the speech-text
modality gap via a pre-processing stage which converts speech and text inputs
into two discrete token sequences of similar length -- this allows models to
indiscriminately process both modalities simply using a joint vocabulary. With
experiments on MuST-C, we demonstrate that our multi-tasking framework improves
attentional encoder-decoder, Connectionist Temporal Classification (CTC),
transducer, and joint CTC/attention models by an average of +0.5 BLEU without
any external MT data. Further, we show that this framework incorporates
external MT data, yielding +0.8 BLEU, and also improves transfer learning from
pre-trained textual models, yielding +1.8 BLEU. | [
-0.0244290475,
0.039265804,
-0.0023630559,
0.0183471199,
0.0163916443,
-0.0093591874,
0.0214570053,
-0.0343812741,
-0.070757091,
-0.0375170745,
-0.0662128851,
-0.0484990329,
0.0536055751,
0.033714354,
0.0157925766,
-0.0360127427,
0.0248627961,
-0.0180318691,
-0.0193959903,
0.0202709865,
-0.0062589152,
0.0176372658,
0.0047401031,
0.0187731646,
-0.0166279543,
0.0046239109,
-0.0235262886,
0.0167950355,
0.0411019549,
-0.0042357864,
-0.0086351754,
-0.0028926055,
0.0296875462,
0.0284854062,
0.0000021701,
-0.0039607654,
-0.0232894383,
0.000406826,
-0.0054781158,
0.008021771,
0.0584963374,
-0.0249646585,
0.0227705333,
0.0216533542,
0.0136107262,
-0.0032729814,
0.0520696416,
0.058123976,
0.0522562191,
0.0747822002,
-0.0247059129,
0.0190300662,
0.0316445194,
-0.046143949,
0.033678472,
-0.0232392345,
-0.0143070286,
-0.0185854789,
-0.001659628,
0.0142668057,
-0.0284099746,
0.0763647407,
0.0301699508,
0.0073356535,
-0.0184075255,
0.0225236006,
0.0327802375,
-0.019522842,
-0.0440785661,
0.0783768892,
-0.0186773092,
-0.0041192067,
0.0076808832,
0.0126271648,
-0.0091147861,
-0.0150801232,
-0.0273622852,
0.0048643467,
0.0091227097,
-0.0018583997,
0.0274504721,
0.043247804,
0.0062698117,
-0.04733897,
-0.0277758688,
-0.0365184285,
0.0118281674,
-0.0070976955,
0.0134923896,
0.0243071374,
-0.0106346495,
-0.0217680801,
0.0675981194,
0.0119630918,
-0.0169902723,
-0.0222497396,
-0.0843946263,
-0.0717829168,
-0.0325198695,
-0.0058153402,
0.0465070345,
0.0523228273,
-0.0588832274,
0.0161402859,
-0.0381643586,
0.0010754316,
-0.0377578661,
0.057013765,
-0.0313972756,
-0.0517235473,
-0.0354374349,
0.0095735546,
-0.0222746395,
-0.0027381892,
-0.0409007147,
-0.0263695624,
0.0041735512,
0.0141594363,
-0.0134039614,
-0.0308679305,
0.0611256212,
-0.0114374515,
-0.0974188969,
-0.0161164384,
0.0360754579,
0.0606378093,
0.0066478578,
0.0580927692,
-0.00067774,
-0.0401759744,
-0.0520524457,
0.01925206,
0.0447565839,
-0.0399193615,
-0.0125346137,
0.0569643266,
-0.0581085756,
0.0010048295,
-0.0228399429,
-0.0374673344,
-0.0513054132,
-0.0554902554,
0.0008165573,
-0.020935772,
0.0458601639,
0.004385347,
0.0201825388,
-0.012098738,
-0.0049066423,
-0.0102921221,
0.0084173428,
0.0952829421,
0.0503817461,
-0.0198873021,
0.0463304855,
0.0098504275,
-0.0093939202,
0.056883432,
0.0626842976,
0.0177707989,
-0.0358265191,
0.0138515709,
-0.026268376,
0.0251150113,
0.0373991765,
0.0142935272,
-0.012249114,
-0.0106963655,
0.060856808,
0.0261098575,
0.0393969715,
0.0494879074,
-0.0171437506,
0.0089011956,
0.0746791065,
-0.0330912806,
0.0388712175,
0.0413350463,
0.057724379,
0.0310306977,
-0.0545993075,
-0.0289748665,
-0.0213961825,
0.0559825487,
0.0176118407,
-0.0064032199,
0.0623422973,
0.0266697705,
-0.0303224977,
-0.0095582725,
0.0467390679,
-0.0433884971,
0.0516070239,
-0.0093176616,
0.0264038667,
0.0075179832,
-0.0821070671,
0.0528284274,
-0.005259139,
-0.0532177947,
0.0418752953,
0.0177575462,
-0.0254241079,
0.0203299858,
-0.0330829769,
-0.0099480869,
-0.0294674039,
-0.0561765879,
0.0417150557,
0.006379385,
0.0185933374,
0.0207586437,
0.0695099756,
-0.0635663718,
-0.0032441297,
-0.0349736325,
-0.0154256755,
0.0492383279,
-0.0638142303,
0.0795017183,
0.0330048129,
-0.0013242551,
0.0221436787,
-0.0100345099,
0.0086995466,
0.0118185002,
0.0194469243,
0.0170689169,
0.0365561284,
0.0069432328,
-0.0168391634,
0.0216999017,
0.0108593926,
-0.055101335,
0.0148458378,
0.0615389831,
-0.0986346751,
-0.0343942009,
0.023701448,
-0.0488917381,
0.0222261474,
0.0545141809,
0.0211700406,
-0.0800937563,
0.0034610908,
-0.0240376983,
0.0193830002,
-0.0079480661,
0.0225423891,
0.0264240671,
0.0325426646,
0.0557035431,
-0.0152764572,
0.0055204127,
-0.0252073314,
0.0435691215,
-0.0123660658,
-0.0093013775,
-0.0578843355,
-0.0208947845,
0.0327438973,
0.0187341403,
0.0178242475,
-0.0216313116,
0.0106797218,
-0.0082656592,
-0.0418522321,
-0.1161752716,
0.0018818087,
-0.0192140359,
0.0152136441,
0.0105204694,
0.0253795534,
0.0215127338,
0.0065104607,
-0.0305883326,
0.0238356739,
-0.012162949,
-0.0103585655,
-0.0274979267,
0.0054756729,
0.0126663838,
0.015480415,
0.0079581141,
0.0126024839,
0.0166432578,
-0.0061132722,
-0.0339731462,
-0.0469891615,
0.0097815366,
0.0439318307,
-0.0048581422,
-0.0073364009,
-0.0136256004,
-0.0241212826,
0.0089664459,
0.0387431346,
0.0567272641,
0.0209004451,
-0.0144579653,
0.0132220751,
-0.0633158982,
-0.0585763715,
0.0428221188,
0.0323418044,
0.0022636149,
-0.0264919028,
-0.0059458124,
-0.0176551547,
0.0647751763,
-0.004035519,
0.0033739689,
-0.0600359738,
-0.0281812996,
-0.0097939242,
-0.0591111481,
-0.0033826847,
0.023462614,
-0.0461154208,
-0.0137943756,
-0.0345875919,
-0.0032620239,
0.0410858877,
-0.0718408972,
-0.065935187,
-0.0409756303,
-0.0053657563,
-0.020321399,
0.0333408564,
-0.037091285,
0.0111492723,
0.0132051175,
-0.0508673936,
-0.0390394218,
0.0369865112,
0.0032330232,
-0.0196324419,
0.0503447689,
-0.0115129203,
-0.0084496168,
-0.0349961407,
-0.0239856336,
0.0154435905,
-0.0148688368,
-0.0042289337,
0.025226878,
0.0051344219,
-0.0359910838,
-0.0332075134,
0.0133763291,
0.0176434778,
0.0678682253,
-0.0072800624,
0.0128221903,
-0.036461141,
0.0473309234,
0.0053933263,
0.0541621856,
-0.0601616651,
-0.0500851274,
-0.0166485701,
0.0098646153,
0.0711777732,
0.0100209136,
-0.0070981206,
-0.0068007801,
0.0320087038,
0.0512265451,
-0.0223860145,
0.0098976567,
0.0675759315,
-0.0551583916,
-0.0099440459,
0.0860477239,
-0.0246656537,
-0.0540521257,
-0.0167980213,
0.0120242499,
-0.0218686163,
-0.0056610918,
-0.0090851327,
-0.0496097431,
-0.0578352474,
0.0284586959,
0.0108376741,
0.0480002165,
0.0160266571,
-0.0255711488,
-0.0513687432,
-0.0048425067,
0.0358617045,
-0.0198646039,
-0.0351216681,
0.0077314102,
-0.0174412522,
-0.0223766416,
0.026028363,
-0.0347053036,
0.0044104885,
-0.039123185,
0.0215707906,
0.0857441574,
-0.0186749995,
0.0255086664,
-0.0225367062,
0.0500674807,
-0.001292262,
0.0453771278,
0.0061661089,
-0.0440256745,
0.0409644321,
-0.0160457753,
-0.0174839888,
-0.0018722982,
-0.0035798003,
-0.0518159568,
-0.007294409,
0.0518799424,
0.0576229095,
-0.0216667932,
0.0166124199,
0.0087234536,
0.0611728467,
0.0093340613,
0.0089401063,
0.0243471637,
0.0032498771,
0.0434707515,
0.0584505871,
0.0142320096,
-0.0591578335,
-0.0091769053,
-0.0186006613,
-0.0214224495,
-0.0766352564,
-0.0284694973,
-0.0036237612,
-0.0133779487,
-0.0375583172,
-0.037074808,
-0.0195966195,
0.0149321919,
0.0371364988,
0.0294287708,
0.0114328628,
0.0111931898,
-0.0072987075,
-0.0364682451,
0.0235654954,
-0.0527398884,
0.0495094992,
-0.0556137525,
0.0032331604,
0.0187339373,
-0.0571309477,
0.0033872793,
0.0442607626,
-0.1109333336,
-0.0600817278,
-0.0398862921,
-0.0062231813,
0.0025920775,
0.0753162056,
-0.0223744996,
-0.005686956,
0.0579799414,
-0.0338580012,
-0.0755058005,
0.0178704336,
0.0732047483,
-0.0042373068,
0.0037750162,
0.023449542,
-0.0295462757,
-0.0223925337,
0.0254213922,
0.0268468894,
0.0079735992,
-0.0407236256,
-0.0093377316,
-0.0013984779,
0.0301456768,
0.0245398879,
0.0325847045,
-0.0393452309,
0.0509130619,
-0.0023516861,
0.0379468985,
-0.0656028166,
-0.0013103122,
0.0421141908,
0.0242727492,
0.0031014583,
0.0310319159,
0.056657929,
-0.0253978912,
-0.0188530795,
0.0602237843,
-0.0116714407,
0.02378265,
0.0141519867,
-0.0032121763,
-0.0080795595,
0.005093764,
0.0169831254,
0.0180287417,
-0.0390004478,
0.0367911719,
0.0015828368,
0.0005592743,
-0.0195174366,
0.0382966697,
-0.0058789696,
-0.0005385986,
-0.0422093235,
-0.0045570075,
0.0254380964,
0.0091985175,
0.1071824655,
0.0071379025,
0.0034371729,
-0.0289784521,
0.0548218638,
-0.0422171801,
-0.001425585,
0.0086401654,
-0.0329203531,
0.0056759724,
0.0190465413,
0.0619007945,
-0.0108099673,
0.0090426318,
-0.0021926234,
-0.0020642038,
-0.0306908432,
-0.0216855668,
-0.0021233419,
-0.036019709,
-0.0159143321,
-0.0273222644,
0.0358596519,
-0.0387835614,
0.0634649545,
-0.0431923196,
-0.0190177206,
0.000084084,
0.0131508289,
0.0254271608,
-0.0259027351,
-0.0065629031,
0.0026817825,
-0.028388124,
0.0847353041,
-0.0194884613,
-0.0225259811,
-6.531831256e-33,
-0.0368056297,
0.0238612276,
-0.013397567,
-0.0739749148,
-0.0417751186,
0.0358852744,
-0.0428842716,
-0.0138551351,
0.0201652925,
-0.025688557,
-0.0000090007,
0.0234564058,
0.034505751,
0.0303872246,
0.0289974473,
-0.0073390645,
0.0806902498,
-0.0155674014,
-0.0289054513,
0.0590934828,
0.0637482703,
0.0288779996,
0.0654512718,
-0.0454439372,
0.0194844995,
0.0355596952,
0.0037327027,
-0.0100006564,
0.0116895745,
0.0283725299,
0.0241038091,
0.0191836488,
0.0088910758,
-0.0730179846,
-0.0486264974,
0.0526842251,
-0.1068240553,
0.0111889848,
0.0093549946,
0.0123490402,
-0.0449177176,
-0.0686073527,
0.0175584294,
0.0096040787,
0.051806096,
-0.0523674823,
0.008938577,
-0.0280722957,
0.0015262067,
-0.0458731502,
-0.0463675335,
-0.016079383,
-0.043155618,
-0.0260423739,
0.0561579578,
0.0669456273,
0.0033751728,
-0.0238424558,
-0.0935262591,
0.0323774517,
-0.052686166,
0.0042127194,
0.0590139143,
0.0189821962,
-0.0165182743,
-0.0081093088,
-0.0158922374,
-0.0241968371,
-0.0119566405,
0.0055295923,
0.0176489335,
0.0256091915,
0.0001931511,
0.0407460779,
0.01782519,
-0.0297367088,
-0.0238892585,
0.0122961951,
0.0056133959,
0.0073534385,
0.0360758454,
0.0371006168,
0.007745076,
0.006687114,
-0.0367316306,
0.0052639842,
-0.0225662086,
-0.0031030399,
0.0370292515,
0.025195187,
-0.0209442284,
-0.0005233802,
0.118939124,
0.0058944514,
0.0151853468,
0.009599437,
0.0167125724,
0.0132797789,
-0.0393727012,
0.0206253342,
-0.0728599504,
-0.0373728946,
0.0830215886,
-0.0146863731,
0.023020871,
-0.0246314947,
0.0239347629,
0.0209509712,
-0.0433935933,
-0.0159384981,
-0.0216351207,
0.0259304792,
0.0030932489,
0.0714372471,
0.0658538789,
-0.027827071,
-0.0085277306,
0.0123072015,
-0.0124906246,
0.0081442464,
-0.0279439632,
-0.0363123901,
0.021973284,
0.0228780136,
-0.0283008609,
0.0259542726,
-0.0398593619,
-0.0547899269,
0.0574590191,
-0.0210051816,
-0.0164995342,
0.0206285007,
2.929e-7,
-0.0198845398,
-0.0174235199,
0.0125338249,
-0.0373869464,
0.023447603,
0.025524389,
-0.0101197539,
0.0546010099,
-0.0004324789,
-0.0006177802,
0.025141174,
0.0152473906,
0.1127745137,
0.0235136524,
-0.0683737025,
-0.0707423389,
-0.0184049699,
0.0468794592,
-0.0212010369,
-0.0083034877,
0.0246391445,
0.081891492,
-0.0124209933,
0.0218432304,
0.0014587382,
-0.0480935387,
0.0583385639,
-0.041780144,
-0.0059856703,
0.0003957359,
0.0147837056,
-0.0234565102,
-0.0771855861,
0.0219142623,
-0.024449192,
0.0102105653,
0.0406793579,
0.0383618772,
0.0169569924,
-0.0823842436,
-0.0196766984,
0.0232889447,
-0.0412604995,
0.0091098938,
0.0466093607,
-0.0742198974,
-0.0267895963,
0.0029581818,
0.002991342,
0.0191722158,
0.0048937513,
-0.0025360573,
0.0029966726,
-0.0123879118,
0.0227515344,
0.0164664835,
-0.0245890915,
-0.0528866351,
-0.0009522106,
0.0072682789,
-0.0681144893,
-0.0460267328,
-0.0588237308,
-0.0497244149,
0.0448034331,
-0.0719256997,
-0.0147542441,
2.530784236e-34,
0.0069899354,
-0.0531286485,
0.0356056765,
-0.0161760021,
0.0188297424,
-0.031096559,
-0.0014397831,
-0.0232457053,
-0.0100873699,
-0.0653270781,
-0.0761489645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15806v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15806v3 | Lyra: Orchestrating Dual Correction in Automated Theorem Proving | 2023-09-27T17:29:41 | 2023-10-07T07:54:19 | Chuanyang Zheng, Haiming Wang, Enze Xie, Zhengying Liu, Jiankai Sun, Huajian Xin, Jianhao Shen, Zhenguo Li, Yu Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) present an intriguing avenue for exploration in
the field of formal theorem proving. Nevertheless, their full potential,
particularly concerning the mitigation of hallucinations and refinement through
prover error messages, remains an area that has yet to be thoroughly
investigated. To enhance the effectiveness of LLMs in the field, we introduce
the Lyra, a new framework that employs two distinct correction mechanisms: Tool
Correction (TC) and Conjecture Correction (CC). To implement Tool Correction in
the post-processing of formal proofs, we leverage prior knowledge to utilize
predefined prover tools (e.g., Sledgehammer) for guiding the replacement of
incorrect tools. Tool Correction significantly contributes to mitigating
hallucinations, thereby improving the overall accuracy of the proof. In
addition, we introduce Conjecture Correction, an error feedback mechanism
designed to interact with prover to refine formal proof conjectures with prover
error messages. Compared to the previous refinement framework, the proposed
Conjecture Correction refines generation with instruction but does not collect
paired (generation, error & refinement) prompts. Our method has achieved
state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance on both miniF2F validation (48.0% -> 55.3%)
and test (45.5% -> 51.2%). We also present 3 IMO problems solved by Lyra. We
believe Tool Correction (post-process for hallucination mitigation) and
Conjecture Correction (subgoal adjustment from interaction with environment)
could provide a promising avenue for future research in this field. | [
0.0054046838,
0.0748224109,
-0.001824239,
0.0448282883,
-0.0654842705,
0.0083724856,
-0.0412916243,
-0.013307184,
-0.015257963,
-0.0122829704,
-0.0042364406,
0.0037569171,
0.0030427754,
-0.0229720026,
0.039855808,
-0.0241788253,
0.0560037382,
-0.0690478981,
-0.0029785817,
-0.0224767458,
-0.016594192,
-0.0222287104,
-0.0272469558,
0.0150812911,
-0.0499758609,
-0.0649054646,
-0.0010719021,
0.019760659,
-0.019308947,
-0.0190849025,
-0.02972815,
0.0792847723,
-0.0415537804,
0.0957082435,
0.0000024822,
-0.0584977306,
-0.0145838009,
0.068665728,
-0.0331827849,
0.0687370151,
-0.026158642,
-0.0055922247,
-0.0375604033,
0.0278492849,
-0.0197860636,
-0.0212290194,
0.0328246318,
0.0113583012,
0.073186703,
0.0644764528,
0.0098196557,
-0.0262125991,
0.066898562,
0.0117013855,
0.0175947417,
-0.0309961531,
0.0221267417,
0.0106589226,
0.0366588011,
-0.0474042408,
-0.0037310959,
0.0248413421,
0.0362299494,
-0.0261416193,
-0.041996967,
-0.013277634,
-0.0608262345,
-0.0372325107,
0.0095538953,
0.0184352174,
0.000507684,
-0.0621363893,
-0.0551478826,
0.0366805233,
0.0082668811,
-0.0082484894,
-0.0407355577,
0.0604996383,
-0.0270403232,
-0.0329588577,
0.0115354713,
-0.0784866512,
0.055357676,
-0.013221899,
-0.0575864129,
0.117993854,
0.0420772023,
-0.050229013,
-0.0429669209,
-0.0003766974,
-0.0591747425,
-0.0733900815,
0.0150855845,
0.033426825,
-0.0438410714,
-0.0108421445,
-0.0169541556,
0.0095290858,
0.0285855494,
-0.0153705394,
-0.0336887538,
0.0239934456,
-0.0436675325,
0.0078743324,
0.0036609801,
-0.0045701656,
0.0036737195,
0.0734191239,
0.0214254465,
0.0193569399,
0.0030908023,
0.0096465768,
-0.0241850112,
-0.0014247913,
0.0076049305,
0.0306631606,
0.0163431391,
0.0286881514,
-0.0731137097,
0.1102685556,
-0.07915847,
-0.0545391887,
0.0096152378,
-0.046179276,
0.013674085,
-0.0027949859,
-0.0094372798,
-0.0048912475,
0.018741291,
-0.0805739686,
-0.0324594751,
0.0169098005,
-0.0180605631,
0.042583067,
0.0077063427,
0.0481245071,
0.0204406008,
0.0334931985,
-0.0031114367,
-0.0516174398,
0.0144799408,
-0.0564180911,
-0.028223116,
-0.0729197785,
0.0066289832,
0.0291538648,
-0.0171235241,
-0.0204420816,
0.0042872676,
0.0011206996,
0.0521099493,
0.0405165218,
-0.0311343111,
0.0183764938,
0.0035246178,
0.0148520973,
-0.044014588,
-0.004546897,
0.0141398851,
-0.0109544359,
0.0208133645,
0.0042047431,
0.0378540419,
0.0235326458,
-0.0064870631,
-0.0149342269,
-0.0355634056,
0.0173507594,
0.0599727444,
0.0381812118,
-0.0560440831,
0.0787552968,
-0.0117546218,
0.0157945678,
-0.0027299556,
-0.0016912568,
0.0216607098,
0.0105804782,
0.0173141733,
-0.0198131837,
0.0435446724,
0.0409148112,
-0.0484968647,
0.0000739833,
-0.0579167381,
0.010522523,
0.0573692471,
0.0062683322,
-0.0161291063,
-0.0681547076,
-0.0447029807,
0.0518819764,
-0.0594128966,
0.0149590382,
0.0329726301,
0.0219104122,
-0.0079009263,
0.02343175,
0.0112002995,
-0.0629833564,
-0.0343980379,
-0.054467991,
0.0404044725,
0.0036292162,
0.0623532906,
-0.0491432101,
0.012854347,
-0.017253086,
0.0318383649,
0.0459967852,
0.0414504074,
-0.0063527669,
-0.0702176616,
-0.0027884657,
-0.0029482241,
-0.0240172911,
0.0356748812,
-0.0013247023,
0.0497548804,
-0.0210155714,
0.0142737767,
-0.001325295,
-0.0410571992,
0.0060242233,
0.0237653479,
-0.0482397415,
-0.031622801,
-0.0009204736,
-0.0045386865,
0.0012637418,
-0.0528757013,
0.0647385865,
0.0203832407,
0.0215899125,
0.0102780368,
-0.0020637917,
0.0003425986,
-0.0315447748,
0.0522301979,
0.0020504447,
-0.0229183789,
-0.0221518334,
-0.0374648981,
0.019341372,
0.0481828116,
-0.0418452919,
0.0297548994,
-0.0135917077,
0.0556602329,
-0.011845638,
-0.0075379522,
0.038245514,
-0.0220986605,
0.0036172327,
-0.0296227243,
0.0282744467,
0.0287552327,
-0.0355505273,
0.0093500111,
-0.0486297682,
0.0360281169,
0.0076819877,
0.0531694256,
0.0036082075,
-0.0218891185,
-0.0134260645,
-0.0246833805,
-0.0417640731,
0.0084304148,
-0.0244357996,
0.0349157229,
-0.0018857927,
-0.0097579844,
-0.014195852,
0.0041774893,
0.0169463158,
0.0040286784,
0.0038306585,
0.0225662757,
0.0092647402,
0.002981009,
-0.0698445365,
0.0133605096,
0.0081398087,
-0.0423437394,
0.0163176302,
0.0004222178,
-0.0214414895,
-0.0521553122,
0.046206478,
-0.0373761021,
0.0095569687,
-0.0116921989,
0.0457321368,
0.0444530174,
-0.0221180767,
0.0355662405,
0.0475426838,
0.0065672412,
0.0171189643,
0.0526848808,
-0.0159016084,
-0.0322296172,
0.0054662847,
0.0500992313,
-0.0680258051,
0.0289085936,
-0.0164376944,
0.0110334335,
0.0243957713,
-0.0327822603,
-0.0206342377,
0.0026342077,
0.0158990286,
-0.0225742646,
0.0004932408,
0.0594421066,
-0.0244184826,
-0.0111851459,
0.0169219505,
-0.0507522151,
-0.0745524019,
0.0643850937,
-0.0425608605,
0.0007452353,
-0.0170459915,
0.0351406261,
-0.0696050003,
0.034567222,
-0.0122658918,
-0.008234825,
-0.0173761211,
-0.0005505434,
0.0035358989,
-0.0610157549,
0.0380424,
-0.0412116349,
0.0237128492,
-0.0508721732,
-0.0104789548,
-0.0012514088,
-0.0383655727,
-0.0396819524,
0.0525438115,
-0.0335988142,
-0.008114581,
-0.0052482062,
-0.0152545376,
-0.0143744545,
0.0115055488,
0.0114166876,
0.032551717,
-0.0070759607,
-0.0073219347,
0.0044919048,
-0.0657281429,
-0.0529195331,
0.0047173197,
0.0314309299,
-0.058325097,
0.0138694355,
0.0687222779,
0.0264221765,
0.0352779031,
-0.0254268087,
-0.0094295414,
0.0024708114,
-0.0197193623,
-0.0092863468,
0.0061708898,
0.0086408006,
-0.062969856,
-0.0090943556,
0.0746607855,
0.0260541383,
-0.0196489114,
0.0287262611,
-0.0574255884,
0.046207536,
0.0142273484,
0.0345067345,
-0.143006593,
-0.0029944703,
0.0363206007,
-0.0062671965,
-0.0030903993,
0.0047563463,
-0.0056660301,
-0.1384533644,
0.0768094957,
0.060104873,
0.0282869842,
0.0146104982,
-0.0302888695,
0.0313013196,
0.0396042764,
0.0266217589,
0.0479021072,
0.0064741313,
-0.0105070127,
0.0385387093,
-0.0243190601,
-0.0516516194,
0.0076227142,
-0.0297744647,
0.002576028,
-0.0207817182,
-0.0183554441,
-0.0078063724,
-0.0568992607,
0.0731055513,
0.0954614878,
-0.0122207953,
-0.0209684446,
-0.0251079313,
0.0040300144,
0.0273503736,
0.0008565787,
0.0081201326,
0.0155017935,
-0.0529755615,
0.0244605038,
0.0792459771,
0.0128007652,
-0.0526875444,
-0.0154179716,
0.0113868406,
-0.0151293194,
-0.0030461478,
0.0092395525,
0.009954351,
-0.0137088867,
-0.0494074672,
-0.0422574431,
-0.0179971904,
-0.0135923121,
-0.0139999669,
0.0602419972,
-0.0314439349,
0.0084123835,
0.0029908016,
0.0397995785,
0.03110216,
0.0206577331,
-0.0170421675,
-0.0468064174,
0.0013080132,
-0.0581768937,
0.0343075357,
-0.050694041,
0.0436681136,
-0.0450941324,
0.028108824,
-0.0303151105,
0.0229187235,
-0.0136467814,
0.0527359545,
-0.0657783896,
-0.0621206947,
-0.0157593675,
0.0561766662,
0.0144225294,
0.0457610972,
-0.0088751288,
-0.0352417678,
-0.0038501194,
0.0724466443,
-0.007939918,
0.0140522262,
0.0369240791,
-0.0333942696,
0.0195771344,
0.0049865791,
0.0147389285,
-0.0140467491,
0.0097463783,
0.0661646947,
0.0548530854,
-0.0336630717,
0.0382347815,
0.099440217,
-0.0268022642,
0.0162299685,
-0.0079938704,
0.009783064,
0.0362510346,
-0.0148091614,
-0.0340947509,
-0.0084998989,
0.0401378982,
-0.025138719,
-0.0417167172,
0.0058588698,
-0.0059491158,
-0.0055711553,
-0.0086863367,
0.004085172,
0.0267184153,
-0.0206207186,
0.0266447775,
0.0710943341,
-0.0153227067,
-0.0115933456,
-0.0038405105,
0.0372380503,
0.0705356449,
-0.0146051701,
0.0065929852,
0.0333284065,
0.0193506964,
-0.061628446,
-0.0024748982,
-0.0153591959,
-0.087164022,
-0.0093126995,
0.0508707166,
0.0488416404,
0.032479573,
0.0163823124,
-0.0452532992,
-0.00493993,
-0.0175219122,
0.0237944033,
0.0038854817,
-0.05343052,
-0.0250480995,
0.0315655917,
0.022606045,
-0.0033217904,
-0.016119102,
-0.0502164438,
0.049702365,
-0.0077185198,
0.0049431482,
-0.025270639,
-0.035831023,
-0.0431648307,
-0.0181595441,
-0.0265680868,
-0.0482535772,
-0.0613982342,
-0.091409713,
0.0184149463,
0.0224539805,
0.001388594,
0.025156429,
-0.03135892,
0.0796828493,
0.0107264519,
-0.0670553818,
0.0194658469,
0.0046908045,
0.0369140618,
-0.0361312069,
0.0136515042,
-6.199786428e-33,
-0.0218968224,
-0.0008168384,
0.0342779197,
-0.0118341753,
0.0088565079,
-0.0490702055,
-0.0576109141,
0.0078759044,
0.0467820242,
0.0423687212,
-0.0342779756,
0.0229438562,
0.0091546476,
-0.0309079401,
-0.0158377308,
0.0267661344,
0.0307494793,
0.0462230146,
-0.066109322,
0.0068731611,
-0.010953459,
-0.0063597434,
0.0573343225,
-0.0308685768,
0.0368231274,
-0.0030993659,
-0.0214763004,
-0.0010979336,
-0.090470016,
0.0299719255,
0.0205357093,
0.044122126,
-0.0406887494,
0.0328997299,
-0.0304242838,
-0.0152823906,
-0.0201173127,
0.0008458007,
0.0222459082,
0.0209823269,
-0.0170725193,
-0.0354591161,
0.0352248996,
0.017275827,
-0.0513241999,
-0.0102910306,
-0.0199709125,
-0.0011504358,
-0.0141281355,
0.0470138043,
-0.0375861675,
0.0317273475,
-0.0143623678,
-0.0339609087,
-0.0053699608,
-0.0093932701,
-0.0091479681,
-0.1072591394,
-0.0217458811,
0.0327000916,
0.0427270532,
-0.0102970749,
0.049768433,
-0.0396256,
-0.0235783607,
0.0036391043,
0.0446588472,
0.0500489995,
-0.0127665652,
0.0051525179,
0.0008773791,
0.0614070222,
0.0246813837,
0.0039689434,
0.0174698047,
0.0057439264,
-0.0361770019,
-0.0082563888,
-0.0386889577,
0.0660864636,
0.0464062653,
-0.0030918575,
-0.0612146854,
-0.0248714909,
-0.0566704348,
0.0320631377,
-0.0367121957,
0.0197480898,
0.0178261194,
0.0135226706,
-0.0428750888,
0.0010655544,
-0.0108042359,
-0.0396186225,
-0.0426309891,
0.0059995428,
-0.0078159291,
0.0113046598,
-0.0329194665,
0.0333998576,
0.0314726122,
-0.0026463834,
-0.0199802797,
0.0118271261,
0.0316533148,
0.0211071894,
-0.0094490685,
0.0407244191,
-0.0426769219,
-0.0040564667,
-0.0667435974,
-0.0271609165,
0.0276445858,
-0.0135007827,
0.0488958247,
0.0229259208,
0.0257472098,
0.0070446758,
-0.0128122186,
-0.0017986026,
-0.0419320166,
0.0955316126,
0.0087418165,
0.0002000615,
0.0158234928,
-0.0056827432,
-0.0113879442,
-0.0150675057,
0.050079044,
-0.0514771715,
-0.0027413061,
-0.0281472225,
3.299e-7,
-0.0211398229,
0.0409627669,
0.0503323488,
0.0582472607,
-0.0048070224,
-0.0244156905,
-0.0199864395,
-0.0172304567,
0.0361647457,
0.0065297545,
-0.0029187547,
0.0643445328,
0.0243838336,
0.0232942495,
-0.032249406,
-0.0312260687,
-0.0373028778,
0.0153174493,
-0.0501160584,
-0.030881457,
0.0187567715,
0.0048910794,
0.0272307862,
-0.0105509097,
-0.0104777962,
-0.0559098087,
0.0500871725,
0.0272364039,
-0.0000619837,
0.0580136478,
0.0108573195,
-0.003821623,
0.0535330437,
0.0445363857,
-0.0015869279,
-0.0089903492,
-0.0354110673,
0.0443287455,
-0.0176101346,
0.0567888953,
-0.0359453969,
-0.0065719788,
0.001563848,
-0.0267465096,
0.0314098112,
0.0042842804,
-0.0168397948,
-0.0141205313,
-0.0002214034,
-0.0594863407,
0.0174969546,
-0.0088796373,
-0.0030994436,
0.0212433804,
0.0184917841,
0.0498624109,
-0.0264514945,
-0.0435027033,
-0.0280519612,
0.0382507779,
-0.0459861234,
-0.0669387206,
0.0169272162,
0.0066291979,
-0.0441946201,
-0.0414488241,
-0.0067928201,
3.479856105e-34,
0.0737601444,
0.0039958167,
0.0644298494,
0.0365195386,
0.0669896826,
0.0098538799,
0.0524521098,
0.0040051234,
0.0218616351,
-0.0497454144,
-0.0272780526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15800v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15800v1 | Exploring Speech Recognition, Translation, and Understanding with Discrete Speech Units: A Comparative Study | 2023-09-27T17:21:13 | 2023-09-27T17:21:13 | Xuankai Chang, Brian Yan, Kwanghee Choi, Jeeweon Jung, Yichen Lu, Soumi Maiti, Roshan Sharma, Jiatong Shi, Jinchuan Tian, Shinji Watanabe, Yuya Fujita, Takashi Maekaku, Pengcheng Guo, Yao-Fei Cheng, Pavel Denisov, Kohei Saijo, Hsiu-Hsuan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Speech signals, typically sampled at rates in the tens of thousands per
second, contain redundancies, evoking inefficiencies in sequence modeling.
High-dimensional speech features such as spectrograms are often used as the
input for the subsequent model. However, they can still be redundant. Recent
investigations proposed the use of discrete speech units derived from
self-supervised learning representations, which significantly compresses the
size of speech data. Applying various methods, such as de-duplication and
subword modeling, can further compress the speech sequence length. Hence,
training time is significantly reduced while retaining notable performance. In
this study, we undertake a comprehensive and systematic exploration into the
application of discrete units within end-to-end speech processing models.
Experiments on 12 automatic speech recognition, 3 speech translation, and 1
spoken language understanding corpora demonstrate that discrete units achieve
reasonably good results in almost all the settings. We intend to release our
configurations and trained models to foster future research efforts. | [
0.0134428423,
0.0429419763,
-0.0128603866,
0.0273275692,
-0.0430592857,
-0.0194746479,
0.1063563451,
0.0005506409,
-0.0500021242,
-0.023291219,
-0.0296436455,
-0.0533729047,
0.0403018631,
0.0035661741,
0.0113054747,
-0.0369886085,
0.0496151596,
-0.0534801707,
-0.0090873167,
-0.0071137948,
-0.0298480503,
-0.0070847925,
-0.0416549332,
0.0518853553,
-0.0353080407,
0.0007459172,
-0.0220783856,
0.0067553292,
-0.0060085366,
-0.0342264809,
-0.0288329776,
0.0381608941,
0.0818087682,
0.0518219098,
0.0000019674,
-0.0155001236,
-0.0100107053,
-0.0082445508,
-0.1027368605,
0.0103751421,
0.0412866957,
-0.0344708934,
-0.0029867599,
0.0186704025,
-0.0151664652,
-0.0156277418,
0.0206427407,
-0.0028772862,
0.0127251744,
0.0650777742,
-0.0201912597,
-0.0471408479,
-0.0299455766,
-0.0449486338,
-0.0503908917,
0.0250353795,
-0.0277403276,
-0.0025692252,
0.028045835,
0.0333804525,
-0.0074698851,
0.0153391398,
-0.0140229994,
0.0135135707,
0.0388007835,
0.002887161,
-0.0253019761,
-0.0571090244,
-0.0353703126,
0.0489715971,
-0.0204045512,
0.0118622389,
0.0354752094,
0.0127149913,
-0.0175210778,
-0.0116353612,
-0.0105078733,
-0.0168209746,
0.0276831184,
-0.0166785531,
-0.0178740565,
0.0522569567,
0.0067173499,
-0.0286303852,
-0.042216979,
0.0055258446,
-0.0135755045,
0.0043765623,
-0.0108101321,
-0.0687846392,
-0.0036268495,
-0.0061497125,
0.0368228219,
0.0255957581,
0.0299983192,
0.0110683469,
-0.0375960618,
-0.0366802439,
0.0097814053,
-0.0411047861,
0.0472296923,
0.0573471449,
-0.0171338692,
0.0296076182,
-0.0006351763,
0.0727343932,
0.0297108348,
-0.030590089,
-0.0590651184,
0.0295007862,
-0.0392385535,
0.0369666405,
-0.0695394129,
0.0584739223,
-0.0141025735,
-0.022801429,
-0.0189577602,
-0.0159189701,
0.0465878211,
0.0286132377,
-0.0021541535,
-0.0270315278,
-0.0539316721,
-0.0163173508,
0.0283423737,
0.0640319884,
-0.0092150653,
0.0003734857,
-0.0091799311,
-0.074493669,
-0.0246031862,
-0.0084285988,
0.013290301,
0.0086587109,
0.0139055112,
0.0728680417,
0.0211880654,
-0.0703396499,
-0.0021760508,
-0.0224992931,
-0.0360848904,
-0.0580457076,
-0.0307461228,
-0.0783578455,
0.0368570164,
0.0147579871,
0.0115785934,
-0.0178722013,
0.0304243658,
-0.0237210784,
0.0125274975,
0.0549030975,
0.0061230846,
0.0377470031,
0.0460800156,
0.0135763623,
0.0498527028,
0.0347074643,
0.0644238517,
0.000176158,
0.000091427,
-0.0686543584,
-0.0607301816,
0.0518297888,
0.0060931281,
-0.0023410772,
-0.0692037046,
-0.0123444414,
-0.0048700916,
0.0376070961,
0.0448039919,
0.0169631205,
-0.0388136953,
-0.036907699,
0.0512092821,
0.0955803394,
0.0075122681,
0.0726292133,
0.0447101332,
0.0389371887,
0.0107245855,
0.0040324014,
0.0086255036,
-0.0020078425,
0.0436974131,
-0.0100273518,
0.0256402679,
0.0201747939,
-0.0422956571,
-0.0205914825,
-0.0134403184,
-0.0157173667,
0.0167944785,
0.0003595232,
0.0512937792,
-0.0198525004,
-0.0399941728,
0.0342331864,
-0.0145826982,
-0.0285837837,
-0.0108285611,
-0.0009835699,
-0.0092631541,
0.0751314759,
0.038186986,
-0.0022365425,
-0.0141298007,
-0.0281278547,
-0.0250132512,
0.0178912431,
0.0358732194,
0.0137442946,
0.0488865785,
-0.0378968157,
-0.0168892238,
0.0261191707,
-0.0348379537,
0.0418389216,
-0.0477232002,
0.0083925165,
0.0281770807,
-0.029763516,
-0.0033068222,
-0.0009436958,
0.0013395761,
-0.056483306,
0.0507989749,
0.0058552455,
0.0753893778,
0.0268178564,
-0.0115246614,
-0.0052399053,
0.052559644,
-0.034535598,
0.0273714848,
0.0021136669,
-0.0672471598,
-0.0720593706,
0.0611799881,
0.011753954,
0.023173891,
0.0452286042,
-0.0119199017,
-0.0723475292,
0.0316108242,
-0.0641888753,
0.0093844617,
-0.0090503525,
0.0443470515,
0.0367225669,
0.0578112304,
0.0077975518,
-0.0098242154,
-0.003464754,
-0.0214835983,
0.0011523091,
-0.0058282795,
0.0602552854,
-0.0507328957,
-0.0047648004,
0.0103870919,
-0.0159534309,
0.0113110375,
0.0175255518,
-0.0419632643,
-0.0227237865,
0.0248839315,
-0.1259982437,
-0.0221673455,
0.0066336235,
0.032141611,
-0.0151762106,
0.0099308733,
0.0277437344,
-0.0402803198,
-0.0081514493,
-0.0225895103,
-0.0196093339,
-0.0255646389,
-0.0358440205,
0.0157674588,
-0.0513262972,
-0.0275075752,
-0.0244601127,
0.0093487762,
0.0401220806,
-0.0481474996,
-0.0404181741,
-0.0303153507,
0.0322318226,
0.0208358355,
0.0288799405,
-0.0181539189,
-0.0404042527,
0.0071160416,
-0.0102842934,
0.0664683059,
0.02321315,
0.0156677105,
0.0103630675,
0.0330864042,
-0.0254557561,
-0.0334931463,
0.0160526633,
-0.006643571,
0.0764928386,
-0.000782359,
0.0145015065,
-0.0178633053,
0.0357451476,
0.0584776439,
0.0297960658,
-0.021518141,
-0.0429912917,
-0.0006302384,
-0.0439968035,
-0.0388998538,
-0.0214815028,
0.01894271,
0.010551475,
0.0185268149,
-0.0300890598,
-0.0070017069,
-0.0777802914,
-0.0264293551,
-0.0457240827,
-0.0281287935,
0.015412366,
0.064562507,
0.0213503391,
0.027972348,
-0.0416857637,
0.0113004884,
-0.0162416492,
0.031309668,
-0.0122180833,
-0.0549510941,
0.0176918022,
-0.0601761863,
0.0168558806,
-0.023650771,
-0.0094360337,
-0.0412191525,
-0.0238747075,
-0.0199521352,
0.0246463455,
-0.0212723557,
-0.0228801835,
-0.0414303355,
0.0761374608,
0.0191347729,
0.0724720284,
0.0199032575,
0.0113844499,
0.0073044379,
0.0637814626,
-0.0019160378,
0.0404811166,
0.0063183713,
-0.0105216149,
0.0629870221,
0.0223599225,
0.0461258143,
0.0237861462,
-0.0694883466,
-0.0162426792,
-0.0041291984,
-0.0315170288,
-0.0465171896,
0.0394326448,
0.030108897,
-0.098919563,
-0.0102296975,
0.1038594767,
0.0021542932,
-0.0106440606,
0.0144987982,
0.0021744038,
-0.0105911558,
-0.0094184102,
-0.0104468614,
-0.0125781698,
-0.0337880291,
0.0128305731,
0.0070278728,
0.0214530658,
0.0270664766,
-0.0187827423,
-0.0729609206,
0.037689615,
0.0695344955,
-0.0130733838,
-0.0239714235,
-0.0263739582,
-0.0472648256,
-0.0152264498,
0.0092186229,
0.0050879223,
-0.0327102914,
-0.0271861758,
0.0515663363,
-0.0521470085,
-0.0347450711,
-0.0075257076,
0.0043087509,
0.054042194,
0.059835773,
0.0065879156,
0.0145026874,
0.0021902337,
0.0090636387,
0.0180447251,
0.0631961972,
-0.0089522069,
0.0225339122,
-0.007105337,
-0.0046412288,
0.0338698328,
0.0079533458,
-0.0423961766,
0.0111686746,
0.0075136609,
0.0375803821,
-0.0482881069,
0.0122933313,
-0.0344547406,
0.0084780008,
-0.0220326055,
0.0682325214,
0.0265938435,
-0.0261195917,
-0.0117935445,
0.0258788299,
0.03248474,
0.0133504402,
-0.0120898653,
0.0225687325,
0.0031547607,
-0.0382296517,
-0.0395773798,
-0.0189311355,
0.0050364546,
0.0397271588,
0.015703287,
0.04744526,
0.0292796772,
0.0365358479,
-0.041279912,
-0.0017396149,
-0.0096140699,
0.0018835209,
-0.0717264041,
-0.0231417753,
0.0018251425,
-0.0291521493,
0.0066074776,
0.0009815556,
-0.1105841324,
-0.0340827182,
0.0211897194,
-0.0184374005,
0.0206712149,
0.0422808751,
0.0064010662,
-0.0357550047,
0.0694307908,
-0.0268027429,
-0.0662269443,
0.0005366924,
0.03913939,
-0.0183439199,
-0.0503952354,
0.0094241882,
0.0212504715,
0.0783517435,
-0.0479894578,
0.0219438579,
-0.0450148173,
-0.0554068275,
0.0080135586,
0.0122671928,
0.0702665597,
-0.0102741886,
0.0479402579,
0.0221253056,
0.057794068,
0.0014660192,
0.0550046712,
-0.0444748811,
-0.0099816537,
0.0112773189,
0.0283332337,
-0.0036401232,
-0.0304274615,
-0.0253387112,
-0.0625720248,
0.0560715422,
0.0457672365,
-0.0175759587,
-0.0031536238,
-0.020811379,
-0.008839081,
-0.000524205,
0.0377589278,
0.0148552069,
-0.0162135679,
-0.0232100915,
0.0292957556,
0.0031977692,
0.038261164,
0.0004724007,
0.0344046578,
-0.0025535487,
-0.0406427905,
0.0072488319,
-0.033546757,
0.0053147567,
-0.0244771,
0.0142009398,
-0.0321739577,
0.0379223377,
-0.0553762503,
0.0354026556,
-0.0396591164,
0.0356853046,
0.0184646435,
0.0192031991,
-0.0132088345,
0.0468678139,
0.052602496,
0.0247707292,
0.0060977391,
0.0098291021,
0.0104408674,
-0.0434687845,
-0.0088320719,
-0.0326691568,
0.0026161717,
-0.0278213397,
-0.0278368164,
-0.0151714562,
-0.0366288647,
-0.0011469139,
-0.0257739201,
0.0445587523,
-0.0410995111,
0.06270428,
0.0018204718,
-0.0436091274,
0.0386667885,
0.0030040548,
-0.0132028908,
-0.0013713251,
-0.0386884473,
0.0035180408,
-6.019835508e-33,
-0.0257152747,
-0.0255601984,
0.0285567697,
-0.0101918112,
-0.0156190796,
-0.0182300266,
-0.0155855548,
0.0198133811,
0.0204610396,
-0.028410105,
-0.0330261067,
0.0007980923,
0.02408888,
-0.0077046119,
0.0268239453,
0.042853076,
0.1218697578,
-0.0413091592,
-0.00773485,
0.0068703988,
0.0281394999,
0.0596151799,
0.0229272302,
-0.060030859,
-0.053494513,
-0.0062851524,
0.0161049515,
-0.0500768535,
0.0225229785,
0.0172214862,
-0.0269747358,
0.0079151578,
-0.0039036968,
-0.0396384522,
-0.0326644853,
0.0247233845,
-0.0995974317,
-0.0032434822,
-0.0063245855,
0.0367077775,
0.0028030225,
-0.0239725225,
0.0395806544,
-0.0171768907,
-0.0228464976,
-0.0188754294,
0.0099864965,
-0.0408124812,
-0.0719067007,
-0.0235131979,
-0.0268550292,
0.0373882912,
-0.0144227156,
0.0017582348,
0.1065432876,
0.0558327474,
-0.0526903421,
-0.0551575981,
-0.0430907458,
0.0310578123,
0.0279479995,
0.0960082412,
0.017020192,
-0.0265691653,
0.0144333187,
0.0183438603,
0.0854706913,
-0.0847820863,
0.0371589698,
-0.0097747948,
0.0431068353,
0.0173899103,
0.0472504459,
-0.0052811988,
0.0777106062,
-0.0445469059,
-0.0740125179,
0.0035206056,
0.0369960964,
0.0132988887,
0.0386107378,
0.0104762474,
-0.0379275754,
0.0241394825,
-0.0218141396,
-0.0053813662,
-0.0041464609,
-0.0620071255,
0.0378091447,
0.0176724419,
0.0042219008,
-0.0209612306,
0.0852915496,
-0.0163330883,
-0.0020510231,
-0.0181488208,
-0.0009339027,
-0.0087346965,
0.02263177,
0.0151887927,
-0.0649144053,
-0.0569662713,
0.0309664812,
0.0066754082,
0.0079232985,
-0.0443498269,
-0.006839321,
0.0692658871,
-0.0523094013,
-0.0159479044,
-0.008734934,
-0.0006283862,
-0.0291565862,
0.0286948457,
0.0569114685,
-0.0139406258,
0.0016961171,
0.034056332,
-0.0575922765,
-0.0322438665,
-0.0272839051,
0.0227766577,
0.0216935948,
0.0306516886,
-0.0327907316,
-0.0068359734,
-0.0253902003,
0.0094113108,
0.0635278001,
0.0113298427,
-0.0269861296,
0.0168833714,
2.801e-7,
-0.046609126,
0.031015804,
-0.0037078387,
-0.0691852644,
0.0493098274,
0.0244581774,
-0.0471119545,
0.0040018745,
-0.0399918929,
0.0194275733,
0.0642832443,
0.0182621796,
0.0679917559,
-0.0108694658,
-0.0629165992,
-0.0349056907,
0.0139794992,
0.0393037684,
-0.0476441942,
0.0294233728,
0.0007448883,
0.0957277194,
-0.0252150409,
-0.011589081,
0.0159215275,
-0.0017421038,
0.060911566,
-0.0198814627,
0.0105673568,
-0.0248725377,
0.0148203541,
0.0420395322,
-0.0567455702,
0.0017844945,
-0.0197882727,
0.0549666956,
0.0018532074,
0.0732940063,
-0.0143361855,
-0.0338834338,
0.0454379581,
0.0283789877,
-0.024082819,
0.0047548255,
0.0121285273,
0.0062499875,
-0.0161234308,
-0.0044575953,
-0.0075328648,
0.0354983248,
-0.0189043023,
0.0310165603,
0.0020533756,
0.0049016746,
0.0252604354,
-0.0327605158,
0.0012128771,
-0.0375150293,
0.0339456759,
-0.0016074651,
-0.0532381125,
-0.0117307547,
-0.0772596896,
0.0184197407,
0.0195196196,
0.0231894087,
-0.0468700901,
2.209881855e-34,
-0.0010781895,
-0.0574796796,
-0.0081017036,
-0.0000945824,
-0.0319849774,
-0.068109028,
-0.0416317768,
0.0229026936,
0.03057326,
-0.0560897402,
-0.0492519364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15789v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15789v1 | Large Language Model Routing with Benchmark Datasets | 2023-09-27T17:08:40 | 2023-09-27T17:08:40 | Tal Shnitzer, Anthony Ou, Mírian Silva, Kate Soule, Yuekai Sun, Justin Solomon, Neil Thompson, Mikhail Yurochkin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7, I.2.6 | There is a rapidly growing number of open-source Large Language Models (LLMs)
and benchmark datasets to compare them. While some models dominate these
benchmarks, no single model typically achieves the best accuracy in all tasks
and use cases. In this work, we address the challenge of selecting the best LLM
out of a collection of models for new tasks. We propose a new formulation for
the problem, in which benchmark datasets are repurposed to learn a "router"
model for this LLM selection, and we show that this problem can be reduced to a
collection of binary classification tasks. We demonstrate the utility and
limitations of learning model routers from various benchmark datasets, where we
consistently improve performance upon using any single model for all tasks. | [
0.0118339239,
0.0988015011,
0.0101075135,
0.0553891994,
-0.053243991,
-0.0009646579,
0.0382301211,
-0.0077418,
0.0047790078,
-0.0561918505,
-0.0223113783,
-0.0244727936,
0.0077617518,
0.0198651832,
0.0545690693,
0.008844791,
0.0157615896,
-0.0408692472,
-0.0205423515,
0.0362827517,
-0.0181416292,
0.0263688844,
0.0145820705,
0.0702962205,
0.0018664147,
0.0074012619,
-0.002022089,
0.0249605943,
-0.0053608296,
-0.0227392167,
0.0319485478,
0.0181995947,
0.0381024517,
0.0455217287,
0.000001684,
-0.0355858654,
-0.0530418195,
-0.0026877283,
-0.0198996756,
0.0038188284,
0.0325000137,
0.0000676136,
-0.0135040144,
0.0677304491,
-0.0096262926,
-0.0146773029,
0.0810831413,
0.033905942,
0.0257060509,
0.0999689102,
-0.0041207699,
-0.0430491082,
0.0058107059,
-0.0421718732,
-0.0289681777,
-0.0319746956,
0.0338027067,
0.0097933048,
-0.0500244014,
0.0285609607,
-0.0268730968,
0.0053137923,
0.0032370861,
0.0335620344,
-0.0241603255,
0.0167277567,
-0.0401037298,
0.0138368206,
-0.0029291578,
0.1157227755,
-0.0702366903,
-0.0653634742,
0.0136348419,
0.0073440829,
-0.0605987459,
-0.0054418049,
-0.0164033826,
-0.016107643,
0.0022242058,
0.0306230877,
0.0399972461,
-0.0545237772,
0.0633494034,
0.0162782334,
-0.0334034637,
0.03160071,
0.0275541618,
-0.0022103172,
0.0158796068,
-0.007525654,
-0.0151267657,
-0.047731176,
0.0213499237,
0.0040381621,
-0.0170383155,
0.0362210721,
-0.0491463579,
0.0094858659,
0.0097360611,
-0.0602864176,
0.0603407547,
0.0193393659,
-0.0208508652,
0.0650206283,
-0.0494796783,
0.0202792417,
-0.0403700173,
0.0624031909,
-0.0489214994,
-0.0007620756,
-0.0181846414,
0.0351347364,
-0.0456151776,
-0.0002046522,
-0.0062881606,
-0.0395132154,
-0.0167965908,
0.0097784651,
0.0116747208,
0.0180143267,
0.0708089322,
-0.0546490885,
-0.0078178793,
-0.0253141243,
0.0413051248,
0.0047838259,
-0.0099349804,
0.0121415481,
-0.037943203,
-0.0220940281,
0.003132991,
0.03184852,
-0.0046217502,
-0.0210422613,
0.0212180987,
0.0662299469,
-0.0085876361,
-0.0411985181,
-0.0837230459,
-0.0031208484,
0.0101262731,
-0.057235986,
-0.0381045528,
-0.0725181028,
0.0280867219,
0.0485029332,
0.0263813008,
-0.0330592468,
-0.003593059,
0.0129659232,
-0.0405999869,
0.0359285362,
0.0338062122,
-0.0127695305,
0.0306007322,
-0.0126012824,
0.0110132573,
0.0594528429,
0.0307057872,
-0.016006317,
0.0302755889,
0.0045091594,
0.0009697611,
0.054459136,
0.0126366979,
0.0245439447,
-0.0098930113,
0.0268073454,
0.0450020842,
0.0359186344,
0.0199976843,
0.0416730978,
-0.0448693261,
-0.0378009379,
0.0276668817,
0.0201956164,
0.0522126742,
0.0015743034,
0.0245750267,
-0.0104285451,
-0.0190738793,
-0.0352870673,
-0.0472390726,
-0.0135535486,
-0.0186962429,
-0.0064852163,
0.0494552068,
0.0127169546,
-0.0364475884,
-0.0228069723,
-0.0154427011,
-0.0272489935,
0.0001449408,
0.0247669984,
0.0570564605,
-0.0385953821,
-0.0583551452,
0.0633399934,
0.0373416618,
-0.0248645786,
-0.0194440577,
-0.0391046144,
-0.0103546921,
0.029128246,
0.0391662493,
-0.0140648531,
-0.0313514583,
-0.0091103511,
0.0250164904,
-0.0253767576,
0.0245001223,
-0.0395342782,
0.0146600921,
-0.0823510215,
-0.0288600735,
0.0193118434,
0.0131695224,
0.0021249726,
0.0165554211,
0.0266846456,
0.0280717146,
-0.075698331,
-0.0439792909,
0.051648818,
-0.0313651413,
-0.0213434957,
0.0216808897,
0.0083970213,
0.0197019894,
-0.0182783045,
-0.0112647982,
-0.0260111559,
0.0198138002,
-0.01667016,
0.0054282695,
-0.0063734236,
-0.0122099007,
-0.0398035571,
0.0280210767,
-0.0083149914,
-0.0109365759,
0.0921251103,
-0.0767619759,
-0.0297772978,
0.0181290377,
-0.0203834083,
0.0257903393,
-0.0173022486,
0.0328595042,
0.001847855,
-0.024579661,
-0.0250535551,
0.0237909853,
0.0073951245,
0.0435640812,
-0.0232168306,
0.0063728858,
-0.003251387,
-0.0025383208,
-0.0327755027,
0.0264655892,
-0.0300938915,
0.0324369632,
0.0099847419,
0.0035470922,
-0.0094180061,
-0.0221613329,
-0.0969365388,
0.0162468068,
-0.0645759031,
0.0131609496,
0.027415473,
-0.0189709775,
0.0282649919,
-0.0207365975,
-0.040998511,
-0.0199119374,
-0.0164029337,
0.0136007508,
-0.0213349666,
-0.0125723463,
-0.0586519837,
-0.0742048398,
-0.0589132048,
0.0015272939,
0.0792789385,
-0.0428352654,
-0.0004353655,
-0.0734867454,
-0.0241091214,
-0.0169607438,
0.0467165411,
-0.0288722534,
-0.0313510895,
-0.0470296033,
-0.0118810795,
0.010056898,
0.0541329607,
-0.0039970712,
0.0164083596,
0.1019125581,
0.0367008261,
-0.0341507494,
-0.0133662326,
-0.0277801175,
-0.026837403,
-0.0746022537,
-0.0240201,
0.0072235446,
0.0513804518,
-0.010929795,
-0.0148301311,
-0.0211275648,
-0.0209008213,
-0.0345796719,
0.032119263,
-0.03423604,
-0.0027340325,
0.0083671799,
0.044985529,
-0.0099635664,
-0.0276540518,
0.0386433192,
-0.0398138463,
0.0180880558,
-0.0403501876,
-0.0471393988,
-0.0673227385,
0.0387017913,
0.0356475264,
0.0520922579,
-0.0213807207,
-0.0128431823,
-0.026230976,
-0.011034701,
0.0062957378,
-0.0191562809,
0.0730428398,
-0.0471835434,
0.0585303418,
-0.0064126495,
-0.0421015844,
-0.0194046237,
-0.0118810171,
-0.0463439263,
0.0096016517,
0.0281692576,
-0.0302239135,
-0.048534479,
0.0378693826,
-0.0469799414,
0.0971710905,
0.0218759589,
-0.000947454,
-0.0041531282,
0.0187709834,
0.051216919,
-0.0158596821,
0.0070008915,
-0.0177462623,
0.0034536584,
0.0276551358,
0.0547010787,
0.0006434288,
-0.0668466538,
-0.0028219125,
0.0485886,
-0.0209082905,
-0.0224538501,
0.005075065,
0.0212411061,
-0.036133945,
-0.0231226906,
0.1256017089,
0.0284807291,
-0.0451660566,
-0.0043109157,
0.0221152958,
0.029605411,
0.0173080545,
0.0236152224,
-0.0526477173,
-0.0303386431,
0.0222116224,
0.0196904987,
0.0013999736,
-0.0115561457,
0.0037921842,
-0.0936485752,
0.0399253592,
0.019475583,
-0.0260661189,
-0.0184625573,
-0.088198252,
-0.0030976895,
-0.0518235713,
0.0456414223,
-0.0059894314,
0.0243013315,
-0.0483094305,
0.0123249777,
-0.0177104622,
-0.054583177,
0.0351937078,
-0.0200483799,
0.0517329909,
-0.005467216,
0.0107097104,
0.0327190198,
0.0090217208,
0.0845632926,
-0.0082194852,
-0.0357954167,
-0.0344827808,
0.0772709325,
-0.0138975792,
-0.0005309602,
0.0336532779,
0.0098728603,
-0.0730809346,
0.0362200439,
-0.0012639822,
0.0597843006,
-0.0212336052,
0.0091511877,
0.0098426631,
-0.0340382345,
0.0053585852,
0.0606096201,
-0.01592681,
-0.0160445925,
-0.0385361388,
-0.0207431,
-0.0074138078,
-0.0170572065,
-0.0358585343,
0.0060337218,
-0.0454768464,
-0.0027611176,
-0.0728952289,
0.0164980162,
0.0530828238,
0.0547411367,
0.0161717348,
0.0163023584,
0.0244747046,
-0.0261502601,
-0.0651745126,
0.0224885847,
-0.0469431505,
0.0489095114,
-0.1057932824,
-0.0137206139,
0.058127515,
0.0075827152,
-0.033664953,
0.0386155434,
-0.1070547774,
-0.0873284116,
-0.0320904553,
0.0169400275,
0.0205495954,
0.0577811562,
-0.0130286878,
-0.0479056798,
0.0219407249,
-0.0354600437,
0.0000199498,
0.0018099223,
0.0309152473,
-0.0222621001,
-0.0236510765,
0.0401274599,
-0.0660736859,
-0.0076641501,
0.0352301262,
0.0279151239,
-0.0408424437,
-0.0313982889,
0.0089212395,
0.0038272454,
0.068029277,
0.0127014611,
0.0261597615,
-0.0214632154,
0.0685169101,
0.0078542028,
-0.0013763203,
-0.0103732673,
0.0103536779,
0.0596209094,
0.0111377807,
-0.0112926485,
-0.0014751744,
0.0200236384,
0.0070804418,
-0.0530499555,
0.0089842808,
0.0120810969,
0.0021970631,
0.0567953326,
0.0049222154,
-0.0183176007,
-0.0055469559,
0.025436148,
0.0311136786,
-0.026382247,
0.0230300203,
0.0153049184,
0.0328067057,
-0.0492932834,
0.0234644003,
-0.0602537729,
-0.0712860748,
-0.0265114494,
0.0365170613,
0.0767537057,
-0.0337337218,
0.0641072989,
-0.0265904739,
-0.0099927289,
-0.0381681025,
-0.0066324091,
-0.0098000439,
-0.0179206431,
0.0351810902,
0.0252103247,
-0.0133353164,
0.0545045584,
0.0797613859,
0.0540125407,
0.049488768,
0.0249332916,
-0.0149005409,
-0.0367103331,
0.0011986532,
0.0206776131,
-0.0161707494,
-0.0280513242,
0.0039145476,
0.0049553192,
-0.069191277,
-0.0050938232,
-0.0389216803,
0.0130978134,
0.0018787937,
0.0222082697,
0.0647739992,
0.022324251,
0.0092031686,
-0.0527894348,
-0.0468248352,
-0.0333780386,
-0.0414896272,
-0.0345470905,
-6.319919746e-33,
0.0305192843,
0.0233532004,
0.0181277767,
-0.0416244343,
-0.0012057206,
0.0064819148,
-0.0103387358,
0.0046753739,
-0.0587121062,
-0.0051794839,
0.0026631046,
-0.0032408112,
0.0091937967,
0.0644884631,
-0.0167982578,
0.0003038037,
0.0663190559,
0.0126743084,
-0.0262382869,
0.0091154194,
0.0381840244,
-0.0080488287,
0.0344175026,
-0.0638075098,
-0.0231329687,
0.0118623599,
-0.0236929748,
0.0495487936,
0.0010008886,
0.0682570264,
0.0068330751,
0.0451331921,
0.027401343,
-0.0155038834,
0.0062738969,
-0.0121395169,
-0.0448054709,
0.0003916114,
-0.0030522519,
0.030551184,
-0.0087513076,
-0.015004484,
0.007538897,
0.0043476829,
0.0126798647,
-0.0202656817,
0.0063918224,
0.0139207821,
-0.0503766201,
0.0096402206,
-0.0171309356,
0.019958321,
-0.0220089443,
-0.0403061323,
0.0337833092,
0.0173002612,
-0.0245818906,
0.0071302052,
-0.0585104376,
-0.0113702184,
0.012586562,
0.0717636272,
0.0545180179,
0.0566971041,
-0.0154574299,
0.037934117,
-0.0154819014,
0.0194704048,
0.0276934952,
-0.007069265,
0.0329751261,
0.0493073761,
0.0263435785,
-0.0197675154,
0.0127539281,
-0.0030290992,
-0.0775378048,
-0.0124734379,
0.0244434215,
-0.0083213374,
0.0391827859,
0.0410872512,
-0.0273298416,
-0.0164521933,
-0.0609241724,
-0.0022356785,
-0.0426633134,
-0.01179469,
0.0177627243,
0.0240381062,
-0.0191971194,
-0.0413391553,
0.0495233126,
-0.0276644267,
-0.0466760173,
0.0501550362,
-0.0095442226,
0.0253553707,
0.0011802121,
0.0457392372,
-0.0493282788,
-0.0460417755,
-0.0046772677,
-0.0106790233,
-0.0058713965,
-0.0457001477,
0.0336956345,
0.008263154,
-0.0755787864,
0.000682195,
-0.0219866838,
0.0113340747,
-0.0132221458,
0.0562936179,
0.039388597,
0.0101680327,
0.0055405339,
0.0612636805,
0.015339544,
-0.0172107574,
0.0159007069,
0.0334046632,
-0.0328994766,
0.0171534922,
-0.0417318456,
-0.0053992472,
-0.0461012758,
0.0176483896,
0.0516478941,
-0.0594559051,
-0.0142192086,
-0.0008688165,
2.411e-7,
0.0294212103,
0.0581551604,
-0.0133970799,
0.0573855229,
-0.0088406857,
0.0119899083,
-0.0289032478,
0.0011305475,
0.0253337752,
-0.0069307191,
0.0091955131,
0.0030027849,
0.0684008524,
-0.0054117329,
-0.066156134,
0.0352813974,
-0.0736753792,
0.0176849868,
-0.0348514542,
-0.0159068052,
0.0442129374,
0.1449515224,
0.0043198732,
-0.0039241756,
-0.0115616163,
-0.0287127905,
0.0343718752,
-0.019784214,
-0.004242904,
0.01961012,
-0.0158451665,
0.0207841191,
-0.0038406628,
0.0071236836,
-0.0330673903,
0.0092059104,
-0.0116672302,
0.0853601098,
-0.0069130058,
-0.0065658181,
-0.0018616467,
0.0214699544,
0.0090598343,
-0.0656878203,
0.0658620074,
-0.0316403396,
-0.0323732905,
-0.0173071306,
0.017991716,
-0.0058395765,
0.0385938138,
-0.0109631158,
-0.0257630479,
0.0356310979,
0.0194288138,
-0.0465006493,
0.0237236097,
-0.0843624994,
-0.0118376287,
0.0441387743,
-0.0135187563,
-0.0232504085,
-0.0020405818,
0.0137470542,
0.0363559984,
-0.0230077039,
0.0113060856,
2.192964608e-34,
0.060402289,
0.0006591712,
0.0024313927,
0.0242725369,
0.0340156257,
-0.0275578033,
-0.0133302836,
-0.0030025491,
-0.0166631564,
-0.0879884809,
0.0023185383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15779v1 | Question answering using deep learning in low resource Indian language Marathi | 2023-09-27T16:53:11 | 2023-09-27T16:53:11 | Dhiraj Amin, Sharvari Govilkar, Sagar Kulkarni | cs.CL | cs.CL | Precise answers are extracted from a text for a given input question in a
question answering system. Marathi question answering system is created in
recent studies by using ontology, rule base and machine learning based
approaches. Recently transformer models and transfer learning approaches are
used to solve question answering challenges. In this paper we investigate
different transformer models for creating a reading comprehension-based Marathi
question answering system. We have experimented on different pretrained Marathi
language multilingual and monolingual models like Multilingual Representations
for Indian Languages (MuRIL), MahaBERT, Indic Bidirectional Encoder
Representations from Transformers (IndicBERT) and fine-tuned it on a Marathi
reading comprehension-based data set. We got the best accuracy in a MuRIL
multilingual model with an EM score of 0.64 and F1 score of 0.74 by fine tuning
the model on the Marathi dataset. | [
0.0356134921,
-0.0184891876,
-0.0150852781,
0.0818297118,
-0.0347159766,
0.0074603348,
-0.015853826,
-0.0099931071,
-0.0538205951,
-0.0200334173,
-0.038789928,
-0.0194508508,
-0.0349078104,
0.0306615103,
-0.0203811862,
-0.0430373326,
0.023586018,
-0.026375385,
-0.0451312959,
-0.017645197,
0.0176562369,
0.049280569,
-0.0151778711,
0.0157380197,
-0.0378542542,
-0.0128528271,
0.0060611377,
-0.0178369079,
0.0256281123,
-0.0241014306,
0.0145277102,
0.0025979676,
-0.0195351727,
0.0021441958,
0.0000018937,
-0.0441638716,
-0.0569241121,
-0.0159300007,
-0.017281469,
-0.0589719974,
0.0087783076,
-0.0356837027,
0.0341917612,
0.0323785245,
-0.0405494981,
0.0052623642,
0.0444106869,
0.0432001092,
0.0661263689,
0.0769824237,
-0.0219411515,
-0.0829303488,
0.080930382,
0.0428640656,
-0.0192166325,
-0.0211365819,
0.0108655943,
0.0228497386,
-0.0219147112,
-0.0134839099,
-0.0478636585,
0.0293775592,
0.0356983207,
0.0049941852,
0.0080946572,
-0.0235908385,
0.0249682665,
-0.0102998791,
0.0082501052,
0.064002119,
-0.0426028967,
-0.0171430651,
-0.0519077182,
0.0023103594,
-0.0527569987,
0.0241209734,
-0.0096815331,
0.0010361945,
-0.030465778,
0.0369459204,
0.0298953615,
0.0098414235,
-0.0176064651,
-0.0070790011,
0.0024272033,
0.0543890819,
0.0174212065,
-0.0052632554,
-0.0275135487,
-0.0179032311,
0.0162298661,
-0.0087749166,
0.0355669558,
0.0602200031,
-0.0018599776,
0.032451123,
0.0052889935,
-0.0612176359,
0.0247949008,
-0.0263447966,
-0.0224767532,
0.0450197682,
-0.037834879,
0.0294305366,
-0.035513375,
0.044194039,
-0.0305018816,
0.0568509959,
-0.0322004035,
-0.1181489155,
0.0053714421,
-0.0739253238,
-0.0289196949,
0.0254116822,
-0.0600849874,
0.0278936625,
-0.0299492497,
0.0316538922,
0.0202042628,
-0.038717214,
0.0321706422,
0.0122643709,
-0.033610452,
-0.0357751809,
-0.0069930106,
0.0767088234,
-0.0597906113,
0.0188320298,
-0.0068185725,
-0.0931150168,
0.0158917923,
0.0011022784,
0.0038167443,
-0.0565181151,
-0.0091787074,
0.0750706717,
-0.0270467177,
-0.0403370075,
-0.040543545,
0.0243419446,
0.0040985076,
-0.0342777707,
-0.0148019865,
-0.0650519356,
0.022228796,
0.053251829,
0.0116734551,
-0.0354698114,
0.0004210579,
0.0219623093,
0.0062561464,
0.076955013,
-0.0064429091,
-0.0292411242,
0.0750606656,
0.0164133683,
0.0045395647,
0.0072501856,
0.0312331486,
-0.0214247815,
0.0350939855,
-0.0430203676,
0.0062912214,
0.0290063284,
-0.0241431221,
-0.0252900235,
0.0390451737,
0.0680776238,
-0.0535749272,
0.0178470686,
-0.0052962904,
0.0364077948,
0.0166473016,
0.0079722116,
0.0151676359,
0.0482007973,
0.0597822554,
0.0752763003,
0.0124892052,
0.0185767915,
0.0078224707,
0.0087290872,
0.0184504911,
0.0434822366,
-0.0328906104,
-0.0067368471,
-0.0090068877,
0.0262668151,
-0.0348784253,
-0.015085862,
0.0135040525,
-0.022890551,
-0.0292071532,
0.0066224402,
0.0700084195,
0.0259246249,
-0.0574951433,
0.0230456926,
0.0219553839,
-0.0356053263,
0.0417169817,
-0.0445366912,
0.0692203194,
0.0356459208,
0.0184162017,
-0.0236145351,
-0.0144819673,
0.0118568139,
-0.0166482013,
0.0310175568,
0.013226077,
-0.0166985691,
-0.0330184475,
-0.0456056967,
0.0185585152,
0.0180712715,
-0.0253783669,
0.024780402,
-0.0554997101,
0.0364065282,
0.0048838621,
-0.0081733027,
0.0205565188,
0.0404031575,
-0.0141933737,
0.0013778444,
0.0009154478,
0.0130725391,
0.0387990102,
0.0019262553,
0.0116324667,
-0.0283338018,
0.0528300852,
-0.0202755146,
-0.012322804,
0.0111295227,
-0.0371507891,
-0.043566715,
-0.0050759581,
-0.0891159549,
0.0352436528,
0.0901741013,
0.016899338,
-0.0553222932,
-0.0368470028,
-0.05168394,
0.0052556205,
-0.055308193,
0.029814953,
0.0001973593,
0.0339636318,
-0.0462942496,
0.0299217254,
0.0243443586,
0.0256240107,
0.0075763068,
0.0054340735,
0.0460580438,
-0.0172620267,
-0.0074266545,
0.0350266658,
-0.0047711381,
-0.001881474,
0.0285942182,
0.016759716,
-0.0268553626,
-0.0155747486,
-0.0520087071,
0.0066433987,
-0.0170448963,
0.0161315091,
0.0103385206,
0.0703868642,
0.0065954714,
-0.0284065697,
-0.0390295982,
0.0136355897,
0.0714776441,
-0.0117293308,
0.060986679,
-0.004797474,
0.0174698401,
-0.0301624164,
-0.038485121,
-0.0065710107,
0.0718085691,
-0.0222546626,
0.0138887111,
-0.0384041965,
-0.0423565432,
0.0055858269,
-0.0024839006,
-0.0099371076,
-0.0367172956,
-0.0263895802,
-0.0142633654,
0.0331636481,
-0.0092018638,
0.043683935,
0.033180166,
-0.0296532288,
0.0060055135,
-0.0508623496,
0.0121688824,
-0.009042412,
0.0101709366,
-0.0221969876,
-0.0117779505,
0.0154707124,
0.0294391271,
0.0061735171,
0.0033761789,
-0.0244127419,
-0.006656887,
-0.0138863325,
-0.0029576512,
-0.0033296843,
0.0415381603,
-0.0250420552,
0.0405360721,
-0.0132590504,
-0.0019518937,
0.0599562712,
-0.0126889441,
-0.035843458,
-0.104298979,
0.0123761008,
-0.0619904995,
0.0259285197,
-0.0195530262,
0.0257103406,
-0.0599240549,
-0.0340018496,
-0.0548119359,
0.0009420998,
0.0002294095,
-0.0464973226,
0.0427784547,
-0.0188880935,
0.0303049386,
-0.0366075598,
-0.0155595429,
-0.059300933,
-0.0262176637,
0.0034038757,
0.0160359479,
0.0607333407,
-0.005297333,
-0.0120687615,
0.0673218668,
0.0018540927,
0.0124190487,
0.0051453928,
-0.0295524299,
-0.009619534,
0.0790439397,
0.0885358676,
0.0603761747,
0.0405534953,
0.0261498857,
0.0671370775,
-0.0190286301,
-0.0289033242,
-0.0163782295,
0.0033895483,
0.0238999203,
0.0345836431,
-0.0433145128,
0.0112026175,
-0.0092516243,
0.0231641941,
-0.0133448727,
-0.0307785645,
0.0747526959,
0.0388846919,
-0.003519566,
-0.0192070995,
-0.0809419975,
-0.0463541672,
-0.0331957117,
0.065514341,
-0.086998865,
-0.0488406047,
-0.0386127792,
-0.0202628635,
0.0330752283,
0.008726907,
0.0102579724,
-0.0899391919,
-0.0417054929,
-0.064841643,
-0.0335975923,
-0.044053074,
-0.0167351123,
-0.0410309434,
-0.0130118504,
0.0309724584,
0.01717446,
-0.0250779279,
-0.0321772993,
0.0462406538,
0.0093331011,
0.0013101463,
0.0175417252,
-0.0260777045,
-0.0475866832,
0.0581848584,
0.0114814648,
-0.0511089116,
-0.0432078205,
-0.0382300951,
-0.0554586649,
-0.0302904323,
-0.0011278846,
0.0545833409,
-0.0164922103,
-0.0094559537,
-0.0291960929,
0.0183746703,
-0.0234319475,
0.0169415791,
0.0078608161,
0.0432196818,
-0.003857424,
-0.0383758843,
-0.0113172038,
-0.0236440897,
-0.0269532409,
0.0350680649,
-0.0296615399,
-0.0326852314,
-0.041154895,
-0.0334913582,
0.018526379,
-0.0715589225,
-0.0257075429,
0.0389705524,
0.0155635532,
-0.0130716637,
-0.0383402258,
-0.0423776619,
0.04412717,
0.001183092,
0.0341229737,
0.0066079274,
0.0291766655,
0.0345258117,
-0.0331688747,
0.0012623242,
-0.0305844825,
0.0280821007,
-0.0936161503,
-0.0048543983,
0.0634893775,
-0.0354381427,
-0.0276486538,
-0.0415594764,
0.0075138565,
0.0029950009,
-0.0021394824,
0.0474179015,
0.0173599795,
-0.0014571248,
-0.0372304879,
-0.0328031927,
0.058476571,
-0.0284324829,
-0.0690126866,
-0.0325109996,
0.0252492521,
-0.0177689753,
-0.0141298901,
0.0232744385,
-0.0386317968,
0.0204533711,
-0.0319672786,
0.0143664759,
-0.021235479,
-0.0353759527,
0.0496060215,
0.0137064643,
-0.0111395372,
0.0010450956,
-0.0151821887,
-0.0129168164,
0.0395562649,
0.0099471351,
0.009973241,
-0.0237253513,
-0.0145358099,
0.0493136533,
-0.0045317314,
-0.0195403919,
0.0261936877,
0.0154081369,
-0.0103518767,
-0.0001925677,
0.0679289997,
0.0654985085,
0.0496944077,
-0.0055156103,
0.0025286688,
-0.0062832306,
-0.0384385064,
0.0178104676,
0.0393340178,
0.0149378572,
0.0552802086,
0.0048694448,
-0.0001757888,
0.0237419233,
0.0259545408,
0.0182249043,
0.0014069303,
-0.0249738749,
0.0171519388,
0.0404397584,
0.0003128961,
0.0256240107,
0.0190557912,
0.0246281363,
-0.034036912,
0.0184917059,
-0.010800777,
0.0167518072,
0.088825129,
0.0027284238,
0.0196187049,
-0.0149277728,
0.0463860929,
-0.002968712,
0.0017041793,
0.0101840356,
-0.0156581029,
-0.0457655862,
0.010103615,
0.0314855576,
0.0182409827,
0.0156667549,
0.017022213,
-0.0185238384,
-0.0374059901,
0.0204249956,
-0.0400795043,
0.0170127098,
-0.0432286486,
0.0316522717,
0.0383215472,
0.0461561196,
-0.041656144,
-0.0420115665,
0.0492258295,
-0.0416815355,
0.0020264012,
-0.0128672402,
-6.156218566e-33,
-0.0206727944,
-0.0081817294,
0.0016347648,
0.0198888127,
0.0108914459,
-0.0273694508,
-0.0196999907,
-0.0234340373,
-0.0647650436,
-0.0117745679,
-0.0156282466,
-0.0026478854,
0.0052828547,
0.0677725822,
0.0045378618,
-0.0541251674,
0.0294263605,
0.0223324448,
0.0160128716,
0.0059467801,
0.0500208288,
0.0525090285,
0.0513522699,
0.0126395756,
-0.0006042729,
-0.0696229935,
0.0101493923,
0.0051301117,
-0.017445799,
0.0616897456,
-0.0577057637,
0.0462192371,
0.0474996865,
-0.0583136939,
0.0112833958,
0.0527521521,
-0.1229987666,
-0.0103009986,
0.0142476764,
0.0904260129,
-0.0439107902,
-0.0324469991,
0.044564642,
0.0119712874,
0.0328791179,
0.0057569696,
0.0636778995,
0.0064745103,
0.0007505776,
-0.016955005,
-0.0752334297,
0.0251173079,
-0.0155503238,
-0.0388935134,
0.0071839127,
0.0847152248,
0.0052646394,
0.0018914193,
-0.0515611246,
-0.046379149,
0.0157633461,
0.0229979325,
0.0465836748,
0.0595425293,
-0.0551582277,
-0.0191577934,
-0.0153685194,
-0.0983056128,
0.0274640359,
0.0403156765,
-0.0006507848,
0.0336780585,
0.0251814388,
0.0352277234,
0.0438979231,
-0.0296745878,
-0.0458222851,
0.0258895252,
-0.0412372127,
0.062650606,
0.0174676664,
-0.0352561884,
-0.0154359313,
-0.0020497185,
0.0184362773,
0.0516397245,
-0.0235827379,
-0.0471036956,
0.0609103702,
-0.0531224012,
-0.02723125,
0.0542938821,
0.0475273691,
-0.0419897325,
0.0329537168,
0.015129325,
-0.0151683036,
0.0249063093,
-0.0184401181,
0.0577076338,
-0.0155972634,
-0.0126180444,
-0.0146762663,
-0.022862833,
-0.0227739364,
0.0121990656,
0.0271183662,
-0.0194573291,
-0.0556976646,
-0.0030497175,
-0.0062859124,
0.0315078162,
-0.0244328603,
0.1260870546,
-0.0297958069,
0.0184617303,
-0.0320702866,
0.0013167042,
-0.0137782805,
0.0137727233,
-0.0313081034,
-0.0388115495,
0.0429961085,
0.0057729445,
-0.037262395,
0.0044398503,
-0.0746403858,
0.0163917281,
-0.0329569317,
-0.0617185012,
0.0090789394,
0.0630517229,
2.554e-7,
0.0590085909,
0.0069492343,
0.0562079735,
-0.0266780928,
-0.0300026052,
-0.0042800782,
0.0311103482,
0.0220985916,
0.0242743604,
0.0456701219,
-0.0030512749,
0.0150773013,
0.0273195989,
0.0257955957,
-0.1036977619,
-0.0416197367,
-0.0419160798,
0.0086347526,
-0.0258426163,
0.0267942455,
0.0638381168,
0.0802890286,
-0.0008133944,
-0.0260222051,
-0.0411120504,
-0.006755935,
0.0517777279,
0.0270990636,
0.0230487864,
0.0377584659,
0.0255748127,
0.0018757719,
-0.0134808905,
0.025213981,
-0.0048732925,
0.0396542586,
0.038368348,
0.0083419243,
-0.0128500117,
-0.0490471646,
0.0191020761,
0.0062681455,
0.0082531366,
-0.0382648967,
0.0792938024,
-0.0173289496,
-0.0261588376,
0.054760918,
-0.0564363748,
-0.0034116544,
0.000181318,
-0.0108804284,
-0.0318813212,
-0.0093900701,
0.0557392612,
-0.0798205584,
0.0048589823,
-0.0132594351,
0.0294192061,
0.0247920156,
-0.0216574278,
-0.0063767126,
-0.0328045115,
-0.0291193929,
0.0401835814,
-0.0359887481,
0.0230547693,
1.755116151e-34,
0.0192288607,
0.0091558388,
-0.0002092248,
0.0240700524,
-0.0021147355,
-0.0070745354,
0.0230853278,
-0.0041344776,
0.0224837903,
-0.0865840837,
-0.0243886486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.01425v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.01425v2 | Borges and AI | 2023-09-27T16:15:34 | 2023-10-04T18:10:30 | Léon Bottou, Bernhard Schölkopf | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Many believe that Large Language Models (LLMs) open the era of Artificial
Intelligence (AI). Some see opportunities while others see dangers. Yet both
proponents and opponents grasp AI through the imagery popularised by science
fiction. Will the machine become sentient and rebel against its creators? Will
we experience a paperclip apocalypse? Before answering such questions, we
should first ask whether this mental imagery provides a good description of the
phenomenon at hand. Understanding weather patterns through the moods of the
gods only goes so far. The present paper instead advocates understanding LLMs
and their connection to AI through the imagery of Jorge Luis Borges, a master
of 20th century literature, forerunner of magical realism, and precursor to
postmodern literature. This exercise leads to a new perspective that
illuminates the relation between language modelling and artificial
intelligence. | [
0.0224595312,
0.0800446719,
-0.0520195141,
0.0194886755,
-0.0090746796,
-0.0026700085,
-0.0107387565,
0.030692827,
0.0307760425,
-0.0342734382,
0.0356217399,
-0.0024199092,
0.0003097341,
0.005604506,
0.0073166848,
-0.0785300285,
-0.01122496,
-0.0326371789,
-0.0077586495,
-0.0077536823,
-0.0417404175,
0.0222814307,
0.0274586715,
0.01952249,
0.0252356883,
-0.0335241593,
0.00299797,
-0.0211158842,
-0.0413055308,
0.0364392586,
-0.0547434725,
-0.0114427265,
0.051403299,
0.058975637,
0.000001724,
-0.0311959423,
0.0269713029,
-0.033450976,
-0.0098743252,
0.0025431521,
0.0316851884,
0.0356901959,
-0.0105622215,
-0.062424168,
-0.0520640202,
0.0333132669,
0.0142974034,
0.0015471493,
-0.0147431018,
0.0350222923,
-0.0017950274,
-0.0247063842,
0.0593492761,
-0.0010446189,
-0.0069561494,
-0.0079208603,
0.0509279743,
0.0144843087,
0.0913995877,
0.0249049384,
-0.0284826178,
0.0691288784,
0.0199770872,
-0.0031622851,
-0.0394345596,
-0.0008863754,
0.0126288533,
-0.0156613681,
-0.001634779,
0.0012479393,
0.0259296615,
-0.0339561328,
0.0264530387,
0.057703577,
-0.0113897137,
-0.000824274,
-0.0080638556,
0.037729051,
0.0126655996,
0.003308336,
0.0894872472,
-0.0176102817,
0.0271383505,
-0.0011108362,
-0.02523279,
0.0865084603,
0.0118702436,
-0.0110388221,
-0.0100307371,
-0.0258821305,
-0.0139078172,
-0.0711725056,
0.0027218009,
0.0432531089,
-0.0151098697,
0.0053228713,
-0.0638329685,
-0.0044355653,
-0.048925478,
-0.0739967152,
0.0218317956,
0.0079679498,
0.0465365872,
0.0179591216,
0.0633760467,
0.0309343766,
-0.0214692354,
0.0473035015,
-0.0317025036,
0.001923137,
-0.0350698084,
-0.0301339142,
-0.0818920135,
0.0010781694,
0.0247501768,
-0.0152395573,
0.0041235439,
0.0209753532,
0.0100703528,
-0.0141583653,
-0.0612270571,
0.0059590838,
0.0308925733,
-0.0322996601,
-0.0288556255,
-0.0206943247,
-0.0616738126,
0.0026641949,
-0.0177747905,
-0.0564112589,
0.0187259987,
0.0101001319,
-0.0112729054,
-0.0334248841,
0.0178652778,
0.055327978,
0.0485132076,
-0.002102315,
-0.0418172777,
0.002300092,
0.0237727556,
-0.0617899708,
0.0109011214,
-0.0105943475,
0.0119627109,
0.0088169612,
0.0049524577,
-0.052351743,
0.0033862942,
0.0150363063,
-0.0311548952,
0.0272732116,
-0.0695559457,
0.0110108322,
0.0231066644,
0.0057158549,
0.0137556791,
0.0032960966,
0.0657114685,
0.0037346822,
0.0326372385,
-0.0038471536,
0.0905319527,
0.0283202473,
-0.0334204212,
0.0165932197,
-0.094149597,
-0.0115808323,
-0.0082405917,
0.0302851368,
-0.0005992672,
0.0536548384,
0.0248867664,
0.0407755077,
0.0089425948,
0.0731629655,
-0.0251081102,
0.0561768748,
0.0723724142,
-0.0061674677,
0.0547898933,
0.0328866132,
-0.0327071585,
-0.0053103063,
0.0192045216,
0.0069297547,
-0.0178881865,
-0.0013808035,
0.0185442716,
-0.0098385727,
0.0083995778,
-0.0118763139,
-0.0135028465,
-0.0218752287,
0.0443514623,
-0.0134056946,
0.0154973501,
-0.021399904,
0.0045497827,
0.0228668842,
-0.001795316,
-0.0554316938,
0.0298676286,
0.0387897231,
0.0203250293,
-0.0268464684,
0.0428333431,
-0.0061829709,
0.0258754529,
0.0280801691,
-0.009777694,
0.0114847515,
-0.0343223438,
-0.0295956805,
0.0450298376,
0.0175139755,
0.0130716385,
0.0177727565,
-0.1293729693,
0.0187707767,
-0.0296176355,
0.0461879708,
-0.0589453615,
-0.0012710129,
-0.0393914767,
-0.0580682904,
-0.0512069464,
-0.0280561242,
-0.0145889129,
-0.002762568,
-0.055225268,
0.0155931665,
0.0416662022,
-0.0609116219,
-0.0746637732,
0.0413088426,
-0.0204816498,
0.1190311313,
0.0468501523,
-0.0719863772,
0.0327510573,
0.0182900447,
0.0656187534,
-0.0106885638,
0.0859456882,
-0.0383550115,
0.0618897714,
0.0254736599,
0.0606367476,
-0.0526877232,
0.022683192,
-0.0138772586,
0.0022228989,
-0.0310292486,
0.0436514355,
-0.0075044734,
-0.0146069806,
0.0498962626,
-0.0062812851,
-0.023932036,
0.0421591103,
0.0221086536,
0.0190498382,
0.0124324458,
-0.0318565778,
0.0226247292,
-0.0189049449,
-0.0098175341,
-0.0252704266,
-0.0012337827,
-0.0179179721,
0.011467943,
-0.0104160365,
-0.0320310704,
0.0162061639,
0.0123085771,
-0.0061039883,
0.0139589123,
-0.0317634754,
-0.0083550941,
-0.0042610359,
-0.0499649644,
0.0048157745,
0.0205541886,
-0.0257704351,
0.055065643,
0.0544409156,
-0.0270369817,
-0.0416349582,
-0.0364044383,
-0.0469171703,
0.0163527466,
-0.0237976462,
-0.0087566581,
0.0092440341,
-0.0361547433,
-0.0078485878,
0.042369917,
-0.0341041386,
0.0230478067,
0.0467682034,
-0.0043184133,
0.0169970021,
-0.0105055207,
0.0249955487,
0.0003480733,
-0.0436627381,
-0.0471716598,
0.0086822528,
0.0513119288,
0.0109102484,
0.034704648,
0.0141005339,
0.1410607547,
-0.0480278395,
-0.0288953725,
0.0040163221,
-0.0577890389,
-0.0132948365,
0.0780269951,
0.0029962594,
-0.011724744,
0.036342375,
-0.0061351685,
0.0004907907,
-0.0311643276,
-0.0360912196,
0.0052134721,
0.0144446669,
0.0310329366,
0.0488646887,
0.0412775986,
0.0297906604,
-0.0284848139,
0.0048672785,
-0.0447689928,
-0.0253024623,
0.0001324769,
-0.021366911,
0.0042364923,
0.0239292532,
-0.0037162476,
0.0042086313,
0.0330496021,
-0.095198229,
0.0044661607,
0.0823196918,
-0.0343133137,
-0.0519503839,
-0.0417325199,
0.0179786272,
-0.0239649713,
0.0349219665,
-0.0097868219,
-0.0000587858,
-0.0367126912,
0.0432346053,
-0.0065756841,
0.0077107358,
0.0069847461,
-0.0275122654,
-0.0135877104,
-0.045699507,
0.020686103,
-0.0198940262,
0.0177897848,
0.0474547595,
0.0017167276,
-0.0353458151,
-0.0096901683,
-0.0060069943,
-0.037051037,
-0.005917138,
0.0669737235,
0.0120300846,
-0.0008028063,
0.0376666188,
-0.0485297628,
-0.0543335229,
0.0151553359,
0.0535157509,
-0.0354884639,
0.048694104,
-0.0084046805,
0.0023307896,
-0.0251175761,
-0.0432494618,
-0.0158164576,
-0.0183935519,
0.0226678271,
0.0250542257,
-0.0163448043,
-0.0296358522,
0.0031365252,
-0.0609737858,
-0.004271504,
-0.0182532333,
-0.0147443851,
0.0138284983,
0.0163592864,
-0.0002943872,
0.036789313,
0.045588959,
-0.0323135555,
-0.0084492378,
0.0404198766,
0.0695777014,
0.0678778365,
-0.0976980627,
-0.0391564667,
-0.0141256247,
0.067158632,
0.0116818165,
-0.0008403657,
-0.00337076,
0.0348694064,
-0.0039115306,
-0.0542697757,
-0.0192408264,
-0.0081303427,
0.0105847921,
0.0919343382,
0.072538197,
-0.0249436051,
-0.0293366928,
-0.0352745652,
-0.0185690578,
-0.0067231143,
0.0156527888,
0.0189046189,
-0.0502738506,
-0.0283768903,
-0.0632907748,
-0.0122596715,
0.0200339425,
-0.1116439998,
-0.0555042028,
0.0086195618,
0.0059164283,
-0.0371296294,
-0.0382321775,
-0.0405101143,
0.053675063,
0.079151921,
-0.022401588,
0.0554153696,
-0.0442946889,
-0.0256941784,
-0.0134912916,
-0.0062445397,
-0.0103109423,
-0.0281001497,
-0.0039183157,
-0.0048793093,
-0.0509765744,
0.0268271919,
-0.015885273,
-0.0243079271,
-0.0588271059,
0.0408891141,
0.0584722757,
0.0395878516,
0.0079372907,
-0.0034695666,
-0.0591808408,
0.0385708399,
0.0150800571,
-0.0134220971,
0.0612504743,
-0.0178586375,
0.0254738349,
-0.0091843447,
0.0473756641,
-0.0017249151,
0.0029780003,
-0.0148772718,
-0.0241058674,
-0.0443408638,
-0.0476665646,
0.0001864811,
-0.0034956539,
-0.031401448,
-0.0298252124,
-0.0266445074,
0.0062097944,
-0.0393654965,
-0.05546505,
-0.0296720359,
0.0134246303,
0.0427079275,
-0.0023193317,
0.0013633722,
-0.0137461228,
-0.0294611566,
-0.0410104617,
0.0012894073,
-0.0016315255,
0.0042880448,
-0.0136701465,
0.0367035083,
0.0184224248,
0.0061552548,
0.0234838743,
0.0786158144,
-0.0308821108,
0.0448198356,
0.016546011,
0.0209226981,
-0.0020819271,
-0.0232765824,
-0.0181377791,
0.0221353006,
-0.0676267818,
-0.1383486241,
0.0529388897,
0.0163893718,
0.0250146333,
-0.0250189397,
0.0045167343,
-0.0129614789,
-0.0046484745,
-0.000654219,
0.0030618783,
0.0509010404,
0.0113134468,
-0.0326576568,
0.0174338389,
-0.0282529611,
0.0195691362,
0.0281733666,
-0.0917139202,
0.0440484025,
0.071892336,
-0.0149800824,
-0.0215959642,
-0.050761871,
-0.0333799347,
0.0050101983,
0.0229829755,
0.0062407344,
-0.0445508547,
-0.0179790352,
0.0258538499,
0.0086497441,
0.0076602865,
-0.0577546284,
0.0035054768,
0.0573540926,
-0.0013000579,
0.0099710952,
-0.0487981252,
0.0893916041,
-0.0844141617,
-0.0307323374,
-0.0301087238,
-5.465028623e-33,
-0.0364026427,
-0.009113213,
0.0232918188,
0.0008068752,
-0.0509468056,
-0.0155686196,
-0.016066853,
0.0223235972,
-0.0470181517,
0.0302450042,
-0.0181313418,
-0.0433308147,
-0.0106689902,
-0.0299918596,
0.0422734991,
0.0205688421,
0.0255582649,
-0.0026092266,
0.0088260472,
-0.0027887223,
0.0260943566,
0.0053445674,
0.0009974925,
-0.1118644029,
0.0368524753,
-0.0308750067,
-0.0147751048,
0.0062101763,
0.0237605609,
0.0308421403,
-0.0129718957,
0.0389893353,
0.0166146774,
-0.0005530572,
-0.0282165296,
0.0210660044,
0.0477874056,
-0.0184066165,
0.0047375672,
0.0420316607,
0.0692673773,
-0.0618740171,
0.0052367821,
-0.0255765989,
-0.0340433307,
0.0318168737,
0.0382133238,
-0.024195496,
-0.0313370489,
-0.0409097038,
-0.0541207008,
-0.0148052499,
-0.0138903633,
-0.0150816245,
0.0093766348,
-0.0317985788,
-0.011492474,
0.0218597241,
-0.0430327505,
0.0204612371,
0.0016939087,
-0.0175535232,
0.0162288267,
0.0172522888,
0.0468053631,
0.0364021137,
0.1150456816,
0.011811276,
-0.0622944385,
0.0582913011,
0.0423808992,
0.0345717557,
0.0179388802,
0.0272526257,
0.0134964436,
0.0088588661,
0.0022242486,
-0.0250655226,
-0.0431209132,
-0.0010665813,
0.0401393659,
-0.0235285256,
-0.0472447835,
-0.0270089731,
0.0073052468,
-0.0812426358,
-0.0006972111,
0.0203251615,
-0.0582032464,
-0.0361918919,
0.0423363745,
-0.0192183536,
-0.0016905948,
-0.079109557,
-0.0117577976,
0.0064621964,
-0.0236487519,
0.011266469,
0.0188062619,
0.006717083,
0.0141395442,
0.0027999606,
-0.0439114384,
0.0532728992,
0.0295729507,
0.0276776068,
0.0012297418,
-0.0010703877,
-0.0037207415,
-0.030137293,
-0.0039036714,
-0.0233357009,
0.0515857749,
-0.0015137587,
0.0228804983,
0.0196495075,
-0.0004653507,
0.0059789242,
0.0258893501,
0.0240919199,
0.0201815628,
0.0237495024,
-0.0133789517,
0.0318263918,
-0.0466942526,
-0.0114774574,
-0.0787222534,
0.0439405739,
0.078089118,
-0.0795306414,
-0.0308589656,
-0.0452964678,
2.628e-7,
-0.0120704528,
0.0374394916,
0.0265093502,
-0.0023814337,
0.0092473123,
0.0615870617,
-0.0028720314,
0.0331292078,
-0.0362970345,
0.0552542172,
-0.0033568528,
0.0084288428,
-0.0192234758,
0.0333697908,
-0.0498817563,
-0.0273152646,
-0.066071786,
-0.0358470567,
-0.0881660655,
0.0332116671,
0.0274039619,
0.0423261859,
0.0649390221,
-0.0234176386,
-0.0063088452,
-0.0353960358,
-0.0177559182,
-0.0228569154,
0.0219844319,
0.0491624027,
0.0085221957,
0.0497303233,
-0.0040515009,
0.000930656,
0.0186432097,
0.0032355376,
-0.002714233,
0.0334472582,
0.0110932468,
0.0413397476,
0.045757059,
-0.0411840752,
-0.0078308219,
-0.0118382564,
0.0461968109,
-0.0244899951,
-0.0237655453,
-0.0219993796,
0.0028755805,
0.0013731983,
0.0211205892,
-0.0290442389,
-0.0202568006,
0.0267617963,
0.012023069,
-0.012722224,
0.0219390262,
-0.0234424863,
0.0187835302,
0.0447138622,
-0.0311634261,
-0.0506990813,
-0.004731643,
0.0388674103,
0.0612653233,
-0.0553044751,
0.0258542784,
2.059234677e-34,
0.0278850906,
-0.0194578059,
-0.0153747378,
0.02910625,
0.0435420461,
0.0259441417,
0.0131367231,
0.0038432432,
0.0100984462,
-0.0403136089,
-0.0286584701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15739v1 | Experience and Evidence are the eyes of an excellent summarizer! Towards Knowledge Infused Multi-modal Clinical Conversation Summarization | 2023-09-27T15:49:43 | 2023-09-27T15:49:43 | Abhisek Tiwari, Anisha Saha, Sriparna Saha, Pushpak Bhattacharyya, Minakshi Dhar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the advancement of telemedicine, both researchers and medical
practitioners are working hand-in-hand to develop various techniques to
automate various medical operations, such as diagnosis report generation. In
this paper, we first present a multi-modal clinical conversation summary
generation task that takes a clinician-patient interaction (both textual and
visual information) and generates a succinct synopsis of the conversation. We
propose a knowledge-infused, multi-modal, multi-tasking medical domain
identification and clinical conversation summary generation
(MM-CliConSummation) framework. It leverages an adapter to infuse knowledge and
visual features and unify the fused feature vector using a gated mechanism.
Furthermore, we developed a multi-modal, multi-intent clinical conversation
summarization corpus annotated with intent, symptom, and summary. The extensive
set of experiments, both quantitatively and qualitatively, led to the following
findings: (a) critical significance of visuals, (b) more precise and medical
entity preserving summary with additional knowledge infusion, and (c) a
correlation between medical department identification and clinical synopsis
generation. Furthermore, the dataset and source code are available at
https://github.com/NLP-RL/MM-CliConSummation. | [
0.0552085042,
-0.0037051407,
0.0151419993,
-0.0140102319,
-0.0057173921,
0.0345990025,
-0.0142175602,
0.0134234326,
-0.0022001569,
-0.0402626917,
-0.0132358009,
-0.0469284393,
0.0334046856,
0.0599617176,
0.0257224888,
-0.1041566283,
0.0155483717,
0.0370219052,
0.0162358154,
0.0442878567,
0.0270586908,
0.0062746839,
-0.0380853415,
0.0652642772,
-0.0137102064,
0.0186955202,
0.0009221293,
0.0062247333,
0.059373986,
-0.0564864948,
-0.0225953627,
0.0042220443,
0.0044018212,
-0.0369089842,
0.0000018169,
-0.0348666832,
-0.0198367015,
0.0167327132,
0.0019771196,
-0.0838073939,
0.0423662849,
-0.0858260095,
0.0290614367,
0.0112698199,
-0.0207173061,
-0.010940996,
0.0292395186,
0.066047743,
0.0708781257,
0.0672297254,
-0.0374847241,
0.0185187478,
-0.0103169847,
-0.0044596912,
-0.0192593355,
-0.0408756137,
-0.0077124112,
0.0458909646,
0.0314539149,
-0.0030511396,
0.015388581,
0.0349166691,
-0.038898252,
-0.0077753747,
0.0138529986,
0.0528805777,
0.0019097851,
-0.0120313596,
-0.0033317369,
0.0877046958,
0.0238996875,
0.0244984385,
0.0513757057,
0.0221988652,
-0.0014239022,
-0.0191158336,
-0.0650897473,
0.0183930453,
-0.0290918387,
-0.0042507048,
-0.0366795026,
0.0361583233,
-0.0169425216,
-0.0234583318,
0.0098555144,
-0.0782193094,
0.0056161517,
0.0064747036,
-0.0330606885,
0.013054613,
-0.0336903669,
-0.0734431669,
0.0120317265,
0.0393965989,
-0.0596915521,
0.0022874521,
-0.0097093424,
-0.0684954375,
0.0374363959,
-0.0339537933,
-0.0143672619,
0.0064666755,
0.004601527,
0.0339501388,
0.0039620199,
-0.0215261895,
0.0293476861,
-0.0128844129,
-0.0445049368,
-0.0120836096,
-0.0482271314,
-0.0113191456,
-0.0221043788,
0.0265681762,
-0.0198262595,
-0.0137417093,
-0.0598395877,
0.0212183073,
0.0154137071,
0.0247403122,
-0.0136667537,
0.0463321358,
-0.0320170484,
0.0306029245,
0.0070158467,
0.0161436815,
-0.0298414044,
0.0007075359,
0.0139494371,
-0.0315223783,
-0.0070728022,
0.0532119721,
0.0206660051,
0.0200740024,
-0.034140151,
0.0191312358,
-0.0464315377,
-0.0351385325,
0.0181382447,
-0.1015258431,
-0.0437782779,
-0.0073126713,
0.0139407208,
-0.0332581848,
0.0421739109,
0.0183841139,
-0.0123948138,
-0.0298502333,
0.0056252261,
0.0117221298,
-0.0326254405,
0.0355437547,
-0.0617537722,
0.0133662745,
0.0290239342,
0.0311982166,
0.0016885494,
0.0217006095,
0.0079005277,
0.0022458332,
0.0116163185,
0.0033389281,
0.0154554155,
-0.0259186625,
0.0138331139,
-0.0464582741,
0.024333274,
-0.0073145349,
-0.0140406294,
0.0456648171,
-0.0274170842,
0.0797785372,
-0.0192852933,
0.0187324882,
0.0304472297,
0.0613638535,
0.0168246981,
0.0143578332,
0.0345704779,
-0.0002722457,
-0.0132903615,
0.0368075445,
-0.0169378724,
0.0249810368,
0.0080911517,
0.0380440243,
0.0109828832,
0.0108057708,
-0.0405544639,
-0.0280879736,
-0.0199956205,
-0.0288368296,
-0.0231878497,
-0.0290114004,
0.0331656672,
0.0109964395,
-0.0238869879,
0.0673312023,
0.0335251428,
-0.0390506648,
-0.0184848662,
-0.0324616432,
-0.0151157519,
0.0504629388,
0.0500843525,
-0.0397859924,
-0.0604224764,
-0.037622299,
0.0188883413,
0.0327095874,
0.036066588,
-0.0297003537,
0.0168004911,
-0.0421242751,
-0.0155657958,
0.0146493297,
0.0087321457,
-0.0363505334,
-0.0297092702,
-0.0007375933,
0.0261385478,
-0.0134067591,
0.0068320679,
0.0355773307,
-0.017025549,
0.0090177804,
0.0042642155,
-0.0077531035,
-0.0084350985,
0.0627957061,
-0.0171003323,
0.0210897028,
0.0315638185,
-0.0103064487,
-0.0038421187,
0.0585103221,
-0.0528717861,
-0.0505765639,
0.0073090428,
-0.0472821482,
0.008425355,
-0.0360813886,
-0.0135575049,
-0.0640586317,
-0.0129630826,
-0.0633597225,
0.0328132808,
-0.0111410851,
0.0090935593,
0.0803129524,
-0.0038064602,
-0.0032819251,
0.0363815017,
-0.0008320718,
-0.0227741115,
0.0433501862,
-0.0466635004,
-0.0067132795,
-0.0090495627,
0.0094072744,
-0.0158209652,
-0.000742904,
-0.0077200211,
0.0111202328,
0.0022392697,
-0.0299324188,
-0.0216393489,
-0.17605187,
-0.0166417882,
0.0002363948,
-0.0228178874,
0.0471442342,
0.0672726482,
0.0013310964,
-0.0284232553,
-0.0671058819,
0.0099706864,
0.059377823,
0.0050454428,
0.0510478653,
0.0706511587,
0.0222075079,
-0.0188331455,
0.0152854836,
-0.0104124919,
0.0516181588,
0.0382112712,
-0.0547912531,
-0.036617402,
0.0053412202,
-0.0595481768,
-0.0257709958,
0.0020297039,
0.0209359359,
0.0041173105,
0.0043302379,
0.0099021113,
0.0185243301,
0.0405635722,
0.022825798,
0.0357947908,
-0.0084520066,
-0.0259514991,
0.0055009048,
-0.0549579002,
-0.0097330268,
0.0251585972,
-0.0288373232,
0.0256306194,
0.0687448084,
0.0173492189,
0.0173138771,
-0.0115873711,
-0.0367445238,
0.018925216,
0.0204168949,
-0.0557028092,
-0.0001552534,
-0.0178634077,
0.0370202996,
0.0000807537,
-0.0320754498,
0.084422648,
-0.0062256861,
0.0165884998,
-0.0597718805,
-0.0224263482,
-0.0578714535,
0.0406136103,
-0.0194833092,
0.0483856909,
0.0439854115,
-0.0239203181,
-0.0067989514,
0.016389763,
0.0154361716,
-0.0241203625,
0.0936009884,
-0.0420962833,
0.0069148089,
-0.0148544312,
-0.0388449244,
-0.0335639007,
-0.0262094382,
-0.0259293914,
-0.010708455,
0.0160263758,
0.0036054449,
-0.0598219186,
0.0455565564,
0.007110754,
0.0472503901,
0.0225882716,
-0.0158125907,
0.0070531187,
0.0819163695,
0.0443958379,
0.0496820174,
0.0033490979,
-0.0326480903,
0.0337893181,
0.0730366856,
-0.0192594118,
-0.0062628156,
0.0291106198,
-0.0248768665,
-0.0418652743,
-0.0348362885,
-0.0151366843,
0.0058320723,
0.0677938238,
-0.0126396436,
0.0128714256,
0.0886070579,
0.0208347552,
-0.0647884086,
0.0039770706,
0.0129967434,
0.0097936997,
-0.0174161438,
0.0056906557,
-0.0584131479,
-0.0409503467,
-0.009384403,
0.0263467412,
-0.0102525726,
-0.0358155742,
-0.0224677883,
-0.0168447252,
0.0133816125,
-0.0075351885,
-0.0259779058,
-0.0370439477,
-0.0156117221,
-0.0080925943,
0.0124211702,
-0.0242780503,
-0.0159611478,
-0.0238984618,
-0.0189144518,
0.0087511893,
-0.0610768646,
-0.0468741283,
-0.0098953899,
-0.0163049959,
0.0122266887,
0.0390912071,
0.0460626446,
0.0129117323,
0.0202399027,
0.0035101916,
-0.0042164857,
0.0175416488,
0.0128387297,
0.0991559923,
-0.0219527259,
0.0010020825,
-0.0399638712,
0.0439523458,
0.0098530808,
-0.0397156216,
0.0096580302,
0.001417857,
-0.0397684462,
-0.0195959825,
-0.0607485287,
0.0529705249,
0.0148122208,
0.0522771068,
0.0104800835,
0.0257491674,
-0.0107976384,
0.0237212162,
0.041041784,
-0.0145921884,
-0.0089312764,
-0.0157831665,
-0.0158635546,
-0.0205243714,
-0.0804012194,
-0.0294711534,
0.0570071749,
-0.0219129678,
-0.0022926538,
-0.017888546,
0.0035026586,
0.0284920279,
-0.0828519687,
0.0214596372,
0.0267170891,
-0.0011109024,
-0.0266232751,
-0.0348846614,
0.0668540522,
-0.033590883,
0.0117084961,
0.0322228484,
-0.0500314161,
0.0143166222,
-0.0463818759,
0.04898341,
0.0173861384,
0.0534169339,
0.0264383387,
0.0205062851,
0.0297454782,
0.0400179289,
-0.0247205384,
0.0103210267,
-0.0258082692,
0.004144487,
-0.0410532169,
0.0068971799,
-0.0346580893,
0.0351615027,
-0.0259672161,
0.0220422875,
-0.0238778405,
-0.0611567087,
0.0023017675,
0.0200437754,
0.0194415618,
-0.0179404486,
0.0093573872,
-0.0221648701,
-0.0144904489,
-0.0372777581,
0.0057992102,
-0.036723122,
0.0282319561,
-0.0323163122,
0.0043654661,
0.0240607001,
0.0622321218,
-0.0433607809,
-0.0400548354,
-0.0117724817,
0.0061845109,
-0.0266578626,
-0.0498466194,
0.0125475638,
-0.0079160566,
-0.0249226261,
0.0085792709,
-0.0127483625,
0.0110766897,
-0.00482206,
0.0522685014,
-0.0001163887,
0.0065592327,
-0.0046286238,
0.0753572583,
-0.0502019189,
0.0120029878,
-0.0490891002,
0.0398233756,
0.0336462371,
-0.0035560473,
0.036945086,
-0.0354001597,
0.0235984307,
-0.0264980197,
0.0583370253,
-0.0258330144,
-0.0060535767,
0.0132662058,
-0.0177710764,
0.0133452667,
-0.0138722528,
0.1024915874,
-0.0721487626,
0.0162131283,
0.0215915535,
-0.0474021211,
-0.0717205703,
-0.0189619828,
0.0221027415,
0.0150780659,
-0.0274873395,
-0.0144117661,
-0.0636174679,
-0.0212888811,
0.0595637076,
-0.0518683232,
-0.0008424094,
-0.0217950456,
0.0804446265,
0.0252825525,
0.0361839235,
0.0030156223,
-0.0291264802,
0.0202368461,
-0.0305001922,
0.0288252942,
0.0051359874,
-5.087047679e-33,
-0.0220079105,
-0.0571509749,
0.0140168713,
0.00920719,
-0.0166172534,
0.0339225605,
-0.0598485246,
0.0077633434,
0.0255892761,
0.0001425532,
0.0073784222,
-0.0253582038,
0.0051426636,
0.0699466839,
-0.0156809632,
0.0038567774,
0.0372243635,
-0.0045841425,
-0.0163319912,
0.075991109,
0.0055472245,
0.0376538225,
0.0160334874,
-0.0750289187,
-0.0019120416,
-0.0083792247,
0.0142666698,
-0.0002219857,
0.07058274,
0.0524900854,
-0.0450171567,
0.0063642608,
0.0671375543,
0.010025342,
-0.0489213094,
0.0253045559,
-0.0654090121,
-0.021462474,
-0.0023629463,
-0.0442916863,
-0.080297254,
-0.0071659717,
0.0184862241,
-0.0307790991,
0.0304279309,
-0.0352414809,
0.0468372144,
-0.0162916165,
-0.0244651288,
-0.0601524599,
-0.0378626063,
0.0565135926,
-0.0287143234,
-0.0610224977,
-0.0020178398,
0.0406454019,
0.0174732264,
-0.0018255177,
-0.0115149915,
0.0387937203,
-0.0058832811,
-0.0075966422,
0.0097251236,
0.0119001651,
-0.0346501693,
0.0799545795,
0.0292963106,
-0.0112921027,
-0.0857194811,
0.053271126,
-0.0834905878,
0.0584617332,
0.0328593478,
0.0471095331,
-0.0279545523,
-0.0136149619,
-0.046183724,
0.0712972879,
-0.0620409958,
0.0146692842,
0.0000884298,
-0.0387617014,
-0.0301881377,
0.0098797781,
0.0067071673,
0.0052062385,
0.0000188528,
-0.0229820311,
0.0239672065,
0.0321227275,
0.0014141293,
0.0072194878,
0.0029884556,
-0.006320192,
0.0617370829,
-0.0392779596,
0.0107621476,
0.0402700938,
-0.0434220955,
-0.053626202,
-0.013007924,
-0.0250183381,
0.0591882206,
0.0087241763,
0.0218854416,
0.0498781353,
0.0278127827,
-0.0291576143,
-0.0081143416,
0.0047161961,
0.0526902229,
0.0082105603,
-0.0489884391,
0.0370520763,
0.0112199411,
0.0198108368,
-0.0304731969,
0.0524694324,
-0.0206491463,
0.020513501,
-0.0296254922,
-0.058754921,
0.0327366218,
0.0136663793,
-0.0373219773,
0.0044007697,
-0.0260733124,
0.0072768321,
0.0461064912,
-0.0252551865,
0.0044877105,
-0.0093941661,
2.598e-7,
0.0760189295,
0.0160537492,
0.0547203757,
-0.0229141861,
0.0249913093,
0.0242649894,
0.0176741816,
0.0503576212,
0.0022169994,
-0.035876099,
0.0397692397,
-0.0020877009,
0.020975573,
0.0255925227,
-0.0922529846,
-0.0304045081,
-0.05100137,
-0.0565287583,
-0.0140826758,
-0.0172131658,
0.1159503013,
0.0559964292,
-0.0800817162,
-0.0106854653,
0.0139049962,
-0.015242096,
0.0561003126,
-0.0279214606,
-0.0273246821,
0.0416054241,
0.0302779712,
0.0000907019,
-0.0049241977,
0.0429381803,
-0.0176971126,
-0.0398842208,
0.0193710849,
0.059516836,
-0.0236312412,
-0.0046283319,
-0.0019144994,
0.0039770114,
0.0436762124,
-0.0043057562,
0.0470481552,
-0.0738098547,
-0.0449417494,
-0.0186358932,
-0.0233721435,
0.0011859376,
0.0324469842,
-0.0215188358,
-0.0592573993,
0.0784852505,
0.0044475347,
0.0102319038,
-0.029631272,
-0.1102308258,
-0.0371581167,
0.0335822701,
-0.0240472052,
-0.028171286,
0.0474618524,
-0.0812176615,
0.0192466658,
-0.0659979954,
-0.0142192505,
2.098518918e-34,
0.047461234,
0.013505226,
-0.022675829,
0.0212759301,
0.028549917,
-0.0454823337,
-0.020561453,
-0.0055170166,
0.0401456766,
-0.0498819575,
-0.011853097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.01424v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.01424v2 | Identifying and Mitigating Privacy Risks Stemming from Language Models: A Survey | 2023-09-27T15:15:23 | 2024-06-18T09:14:34 | Victoria Smith, Ali Shahin Shamsabadi, Carolyn Ashurst, Adrian Weller | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown greatly enhanced performance in
recent years, attributed to increased size and extensive training data. This
advancement has led to widespread interest and adoption across industries and
the public. However, training data memorization in Machine Learning models
scales with model size, particularly concerning for LLMs. Memorized text
sequences have the potential to be directly leaked from LLMs, posing a serious
threat to data privacy. Various techniques have been developed to attack LLMs
and extract their training data. As these models continue to grow, this issue
becomes increasingly critical. To help researchers and policymakers understand
the state of knowledge around privacy attacks and mitigations, including where
more work is needed, we present the first SoK on data privacy for LLMs. We (i)
identify a taxonomy of salient dimensions where attacks differ on LLMs, (ii)
systematize existing attacks, using our taxonomy of dimensions to highlight key
trends, (iii) survey existing mitigation strategies, highlighting their
strengths and limitations, and (iv) identify key gaps, demonstrating open
problems and areas for concern. | [
0.0345836245,
0.121817939,
-0.0233691204,
0.0562743433,
-0.0514571592,
-0.00683448,
0.0517418012,
0.0096049197,
0.0200102981,
-0.0417190269,
-0.0206130762,
-0.0362299569,
0.0062020742,
0.0181183293,
0.0416096337,
0.0068713329,
0.0270356871,
-0.0549789332,
-0.0099363215,
-0.0380059741,
-0.0362073407,
-0.0027922792,
0.0560742579,
0.0187193472,
0.0077290577,
-0.0135369953,
-0.0130664213,
-0.04287716,
-0.0024269482,
-0.0297431499,
0.0037655914,
0.0499687679,
0.0205051415,
0.0721274391,
0.0000019437,
-0.0214042272,
-0.0537731908,
0.0503656156,
-0.0483025908,
0.0313737057,
0.022516055,
-0.0203962177,
0.0136219431,
0.0046605486,
-0.0206974633,
0.0163904577,
0.0095440587,
0.0282619968,
0.0399728529,
0.0783623978,
-0.0109779509,
-0.0118890936,
0.0299447142,
-0.0266727582,
-0.0079303598,
-0.0309840981,
0.0408363342,
-0.0356130153,
-0.0393704101,
0.0167093035,
0.0281706434,
0.0466113575,
-0.0078706415,
0.0380704105,
-0.0336402282,
0.0233308114,
-0.0133776022,
-0.0073983194,
0.0055953981,
0.0223175287,
0.008470878,
-0.0171473529,
0.0442781933,
0.0242142119,
0.0441675,
0.0177371148,
-0.0053887623,
0.0695676282,
-0.0485107638,
0.0023998693,
0.0045061591,
-0.0422511511,
0.0542749278,
0.0111504365,
0.0029204472,
0.0433708727,
0.0169365648,
-0.0097500663,
-0.0155885611,
-0.0483959988,
0.042411603,
-0.0706568956,
0.0446709916,
-0.0009623275,
0.0502664149,
0.0333668329,
-0.0745912716,
-0.0406837314,
0.0377994888,
-0.0714831352,
0.0303553138,
-0.0155171324,
0.0169765856,
0.0182857364,
0.0161530934,
0.0420025438,
-0.011703874,
0.0234324951,
0.0148762576,
0.0110883368,
-0.0122960275,
-0.0215152986,
0.0284462906,
0.0560265779,
-0.0004861952,
0.0163419396,
-0.0123421922,
0.0516294278,
-0.0064926906,
0.0473938249,
-0.0448887832,
-0.0062619126,
0.0070712757,
-0.0080655785,
-0.0053456272,
-0.0553170703,
0.0255492516,
0.0084131602,
0.0085149799,
-0.0660674497,
-0.0142320441,
-0.027235223,
-0.0184717309,
-0.0013864854,
-0.0258427206,
0.0838918388,
0.0457200333,
-0.0330857784,
-0.0454967432,
-0.1068185866,
0.0046679485,
-0.0339763351,
0.0030510633,
-0.0673242211,
-0.0030336122,
-0.0245371647,
-0.0174604338,
-0.0783122778,
-0.0045397016,
0.0304525923,
-0.062329784,
0.0466828346,
-0.009408297,
-0.0062606712,
0.0115088224,
0.0432506576,
0.0137797557,
0.0243597552,
0.0132944481,
0.0395843647,
0.0625036284,
-0.0249419659,
0.0409455299,
0.0268582534,
0.0350114405,
0.0062870593,
-0.0259721801,
0.0223739352,
0.0292627327,
-0.0625172555,
-0.0235174187,
0.0640655532,
-0.000168362,
-0.0702771991,
0.1025516987,
0.1027614474,
-0.0392322689,
0.0283371881,
-0.0522753671,
-0.0010492083,
0.0150955031,
-0.0005832838,
-0.0614388585,
-0.0435039662,
-0.0727588385,
-0.0318216383,
-0.0101915328,
0.013534477,
-0.0093718115,
-0.0092660757,
0.0000639559,
-0.0766108111,
0.0355415456,
0.0499683134,
0.005019892,
0.0084663387,
0.0417743325,
0.066917412,
0.0090990188,
-0.0528976619,
-0.0110085271,
-0.0540698096,
-0.0110054715,
0.0677611902,
0.0379861481,
-0.0171103291,
0.0021174767,
-0.0467293821,
-0.0177098215,
-0.0187887195,
-0.0008032419,
0.0033038578,
0.0590497553,
-0.0144033199,
-0.020653408,
0.0133316861,
0.0276038367,
0.0095737912,
0.0241824165,
0.0047944128,
0.0239476562,
-0.0199943576,
-0.036021661,
0.0218981579,
-0.041144114,
-0.0399144888,
0.0165947191,
0.0022256305,
0.0188805293,
0.0293427911,
-0.0082957586,
0.021374464,
0.0514178053,
0.0407349728,
0.0113320537,
-0.039426595,
-0.0032369888,
0.0280535817,
0.0076241465,
0.0030106425,
0.0273569766,
0.0404788256,
-0.0203091893,
-0.0003933815,
-0.0057576685,
-0.0267104432,
0.0512976535,
0.0070564477,
0.0261498597,
-0.0222451594,
0.0421002805,
-0.0282664876,
0.0091060754,
-0.0595889501,
-0.0101826601,
-0.038326636,
-0.0269829109,
0.0111289332,
-0.0559961498,
-0.032787066,
0.0313513838,
-0.0092736576,
0.027863618,
0.0163244028,
-0.0348914787,
-0.0233553238,
-0.0022169189,
-0.0150086051,
-0.0116662551,
-0.0008093888,
0.0504513346,
0.0000677763,
0.0002399909,
-0.0364729278,
-0.0477836989,
-0.0423598215,
-0.0445674025,
-0.0405304208,
0.0387970917,
0.0198396146,
-0.0047537657,
-0.0364957675,
0.0030595376,
-0.0231600553,
0.0069325338,
0.0508383512,
-0.0421999171,
-0.0345869958,
-0.0414740145,
0.0465863198,
-0.0352051593,
0.0434672609,
-0.0199770518,
0.0037157813,
0.0020259891,
0.0027003721,
-0.0196594782,
0.046311304,
0.0202496853,
0.0404426083,
0.0571649894,
0.0027657414,
-0.0231445674,
-0.0413117968,
-0.0065601035,
-0.0329324491,
-0.0509854741,
-0.0223854352,
0.034227021,
-0.0019495859,
0.0238651428,
-0.0308507364,
0.0133431535,
0.039287407,
0.0004505139,
-0.035048075,
-0.0183946602,
-0.0228171106,
-0.0273820367,
0.0291521568,
0.0056992383,
-0.0843245089,
0.0662070811,
-0.0364339277,
0.0497829318,
-0.0052178889,
-0.049748797,
0.0233989954,
0.0693621933,
0.0134815369,
0.0378435515,
0.0513673499,
-0.0491514131,
-0.0107406657,
-0.0011714532,
0.0241296887,
-0.0710622966,
0.0329267643,
-0.0141196512,
-0.0406093635,
0.0079200501,
-0.0338266343,
-0.061471954,
-0.061089132,
-0.0138670458,
-0.0027536757,
-0.0024883787,
-0.045762565,
-0.0209101494,
-0.0398066416,
0.0533531271,
0.008161407,
-0.0018295686,
0.0205369256,
-0.0057490119,
0.0111222835,
0.0137201538,
-0.0520048998,
0.0058636088,
-0.0205656718,
0.0003111173,
0.0932249129,
0.0508274473,
0.0245720744,
0.0397730097,
-0.0275605135,
0.0339331478,
-0.0180662312,
-0.0228154175,
0.0452941693,
0.0113504557,
-0.0596676208,
-0.0009868087,
0.063669011,
0.0088792909,
-0.042402558,
0.0043447441,
0.0256370325,
0.0168662705,
-0.0130925756,
-0.014891346,
-0.0743360296,
0.0202635229,
0.0426878519,
0.0743791908,
-0.0388418846,
-0.0252129268,
-0.0337323695,
-0.0775579736,
-0.0124017736,
0.021073278,
-0.0187268071,
-0.0342072994,
-0.0470563918,
-0.0186849516,
0.0289289113,
0.0253882594,
-0.047782816,
-0.0056663672,
-0.0201328993,
0.0233817305,
-0.0439550504,
-0.0426826999,
-0.0181721449,
-0.029259298,
0.0436635353,
0.052315224,
0.0039004772,
-0.0085127028,
-0.0200777706,
0.015138533,
0.0304068998,
-0.0181051809,
0.01212327,
0.0579199195,
-0.0107084392,
-0.0011908107,
-0.0097349212,
0.0730755478,
0.0009203544,
-0.0101254471,
0.0304059684,
0.0334101319,
-0.0508570112,
0.0015722559,
0.0005783799,
-0.0453224704,
0.0126778837,
0.05976687,
-0.0091893496,
-0.0251801144,
0.0197773688,
-0.0604280159,
0.0482131653,
0.0063887564,
0.0023364725,
0.0287237447,
-0.0087253414,
-0.0593424626,
-0.0359716713,
-0.0257253852,
-0.0334420688,
-0.0212024916,
0.0366327874,
0.0266631264,
0.0412515514,
-0.0223661847,
-0.0450326353,
0.014076299,
-0.0520008057,
0.0095551349,
-0.0572705269,
0.0012495688,
-0.0007249422,
0.0149098542,
-0.0064933849,
0.0131948562,
-0.0970264897,
-0.0893264711,
0.0312705636,
0.0365982503,
0.0111732697,
0.050173495,
0.0110462606,
-0.0727986693,
0.0831059292,
0.0394565128,
-0.0282437336,
-0.0045449939,
0.0572088957,
-0.0297343489,
0.0056317663,
0.0243105404,
-0.026764961,
-0.0343825929,
0.0738853142,
-0.0578801632,
-0.0434984788,
-0.033394102,
-0.0120982183,
0.0571429096,
0.0297584254,
-0.0013170361,
0.025416594,
-0.0084780902,
0.0269014016,
-0.026719613,
-0.0127651785,
-0.0064651114,
0.0062164809,
0.0240418296,
0.0006355605,
0.0426334068,
-0.0273882467,
0.0304760076,
0.0252641495,
-0.0268221237,
0.0467223413,
0.0221062247,
0.0333533585,
0.0390449129,
0.0067452341,
-0.0271611847,
0.078724809,
-0.0012917815,
0.039141126,
-0.0350717865,
0.0263709482,
-0.0161285643,
-0.0013303554,
-0.0201176573,
0.0442367531,
-0.041598212,
-0.0614419766,
0.0016039207,
0.0252734683,
-0.0063308217,
0.006616571,
-0.0101928953,
-0.0425185636,
-0.002257294,
-0.0445277318,
-0.0163266081,
-0.0191615857,
-0.0181795321,
-0.0086865388,
-0.0037296792,
-0.034199629,
0.0544687919,
0.1027850136,
0.0252365675,
0.0525333844,
-0.0146550816,
-0.054647807,
-0.0241064001,
-0.0291659255,
0.0431850404,
0.0129184555,
-0.0309196878,
-0.046050258,
-0.0285609625,
-0.0836174786,
-0.0092511354,
-0.0252121352,
0.0105065741,
-0.0051697688,
-0.0072891982,
0.0227150638,
0.0021663029,
0.0067798798,
-0.0875330344,
0.0232128501,
0.0138035184,
-0.0462187454,
0.0224731993,
-5.250024094e-33,
0.0277832448,
-0.0221290607,
-0.0357214175,
0.0251120608,
0.0306949113,
0.0400876887,
0.008761459,
0.0055391598,
-0.0297856871,
-0.0399060212,
-0.03839425,
-0.0067995549,
0.0053854357,
0.0413568988,
-0.0130232377,
-0.0210441612,
0.0202274639,
-0.021876568,
-0.0052720676,
0.0275728349,
0.0676527619,
0.0345643498,
0.0464076474,
-0.0827540457,
0.0599712431,
0.0009176019,
-0.0157240201,
-0.0036159796,
-0.038848754,
0.0525276326,
-0.021171758,
0.0012991293,
0.0059647593,
-0.0216028783,
-0.0136240488,
0.0472061411,
-0.0338988341,
-0.0033849631,
-0.0225448571,
0.0089667486,
0.0635739192,
-0.0713203847,
0.0503834635,
-0.0495732315,
0.0003789932,
0.0142581211,
-0.0138744554,
-0.0325717591,
-0.0518035591,
-0.0120938877,
0.0279178265,
0.0092496891,
-0.008400118,
0.033134494,
0.0843399614,
0.0300301276,
0.0168833323,
-0.012508478,
-0.0619712099,
0.0407477245,
0.0642684326,
0.0153152319,
0.0686766803,
0.0361643359,
0.0390694179,
0.0447524749,
0.049729649,
0.0014916376,
0.0049226005,
0.0056859562,
-0.0059447866,
0.0275195371,
0.0046291696,
0.0076665324,
0.0094245691,
-0.0586520992,
-0.0194011144,
-0.001849764,
-0.0259122178,
-0.0098069999,
0.0546296835,
-0.0192622785,
-0.0751365274,
-0.0179060046,
-0.0505913384,
-0.0134790717,
-0.0233434979,
0.0065415725,
-0.0001630155,
-0.0071276068,
-0.0186592136,
0.0041860342,
0.0183526985,
-0.0563193485,
-0.0493748039,
0.0346695781,
0.0290569514,
-0.0324707292,
-0.0085372953,
-0.0047832597,
-0.0460917465,
0.0020799392,
-0.020450443,
-0.049516432,
0.0159404986,
0.0208519716,
0.0471153744,
0.012413254,
-0.0663588867,
-0.0199529603,
-0.0230884571,
0.0223911088,
0.0591861084,
0.0278810579,
0.0577542298,
-0.0254208967,
0.0256991796,
0.0190141127,
0.0414009467,
0.0057841544,
-0.0363456644,
0.0240824688,
-0.0202274006,
0.0062239948,
0.0155673549,
-0.021894576,
0.0026017835,
0.039579086,
0.1057410836,
0.0135811456,
0.0268368274,
-0.0255236588,
2.654e-7,
-0.0072858753,
0.0076712403,
-0.0058354549,
-0.0211962759,
0.0082866084,
0.0712676421,
-0.0003031025,
0.0583951324,
-0.0097927293,
0.0158736072,
-0.0302166641,
-0.0067206239,
0.0476721786,
0.0275989566,
-0.0537700728,
-0.0216555726,
-0.0421254747,
-0.0125661185,
-0.0699652582,
0.0092313606,
0.0231886972,
0.1049174368,
0.0495094843,
-0.0363271944,
-0.0247993413,
-0.0492900386,
0.0076756538,
-0.056406267,
-0.0163512379,
-0.0188404787,
0.0462439358,
0.0852017924,
0.0095348479,
0.0032920735,
-0.029847309,
0.0199477803,
-0.0630915985,
0.0717851073,
0.0290810242,
-0.0190477688,
-0.0054181456,
-0.0535998158,
-0.0311808735,
-0.0273585748,
0.048471611,
0.0283579715,
-0.0499576926,
-0.0180066843,
0.0372032523,
-0.0881649032,
0.0175195504,
-0.017337298,
0.0211805832,
0.0215759985,
-0.0092305979,
0.0028932358,
0.0233506598,
-0.071073018,
-0.026545424,
-0.0354834571,
-0.0105687408,
-0.0239026565,
0.0049694474,
0.013658735,
-0.0391186811,
-0.0234102439,
0.053959664,
2.528080369e-34,
-0.039449852,
-0.0304929428,
-0.0306823831,
0.0368410163,
0.0166769046,
-0.007159607,
0.0302726272,
0.0203819834,
-0.0053604683,
-0.0607338324,
-0.0244383477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15714v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15714v2 | Integrating LLM, EEG, and Eye-Tracking Biomarker Analysis for Word-Level Neural State Classification in Semantic Inference Reading Comprehension | 2023-09-27T15:12:08 | 2023-10-17T17:17:59 | Yuhong Zhang, Qin Li, Sujal Nahata, Tasnia Jamal, Shih-kuen Cheng, Gert Cauwenberghs, Tzyy-Ping Jung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the recent proliferation of large language models (LLMs), such as
Generative Pre-trained Transformers (GPT), there has been a significant shift
in exploring human and machine comprehension of semantic language meaning. This
shift calls for interdisciplinary research that bridges cognitive science and
natural language processing (NLP). This pilot study aims to provide insights
into individuals' neural states during a semantic relation
reading-comprehension task. We propose jointly analyzing LLMs, eye-gaze, and
electroencephalographic (EEG) data to study how the brain processes words with
varying degrees of relevance to a keyword during reading. We also use a feature
engineering approach to improve the fixation-related EEG data classification
while participants read words with high versus low relevance to the keyword.
The best validation accuracy in this word-level classification is over 60\%
across 12 subjects. Words of high relevance to the inference keyword had
significantly more eye fixations per word: 1.0584 compared to 0.6576 when
excluding no-fixation words, and 1.5126 compared to 1.4026 when including them.
This study represents the first attempt to classify brain states at a word
level using LLM knowledge. It provides valuable insights into human cognitive
abilities and the realm of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI), and offers
guidance for developing potential reading-assisted technologies. | [
0.0184808187,
0.0263418872,
-0.0238741674,
-0.0068813064,
0.0176370777,
0.0356488936,
0.010775106,
0.026973661,
0.0386683643,
-0.0479026586,
-0.021797901,
0.0051952936,
0.031716153,
0.057910867,
0.0346190408,
-0.0209636185,
0.0447052456,
0.0042567318,
-0.0169424731,
0.0147806257,
0.0001619598,
0.0145393023,
-0.0236985236,
0.036944326,
-0.0056253602,
0.0059927613,
-0.0057195099,
-0.0038800556,
0.0224292614,
-0.014124901,
-0.0356176719,
0.0695865303,
-0.0188963283,
-0.0107901553,
0.0000017734,
-0.0669940934,
0.0012015585,
-0.0065332195,
-0.017270321,
-0.0345984735,
-0.0147765381,
-0.0137747694,
0.0154842148,
-0.0173612647,
-0.002961451,
-0.0166082717,
0.0505516082,
0.0569839701,
0.0119070634,
0.0220318791,
-0.0241808146,
-0.0001331119,
0.0732705668,
-0.0106222183,
0.0618332401,
-0.0325830542,
0.0467504933,
-0.0047939853,
-0.0210389346,
-0.0009700806,
-0.0485474877,
0.0376497544,
-0.0209306832,
0.0478085466,
0.0443065986,
0.0645455793,
-0.0025783125,
-0.0046679419,
-0.0003220106,
0.0515035577,
0.0296951011,
-0.0537059233,
-0.0132163148,
0.0254726093,
-0.0297289696,
0.0564235561,
-0.0006585568,
0.0151449423,
-0.0326428302,
0.0415412076,
0.0701057464,
-0.0353150144,
0.0004290438,
-0.0014614953,
-0.0658038184,
0.0732656345,
0.033809185,
-0.0434524007,
0.040265955,
0.0344549753,
-0.020387087,
-0.02611975,
0.0446519665,
-0.0035921531,
0.0214164965,
0.0229506083,
-0.0182402041,
-0.0815535933,
-0.0093186656,
0.0053906925,
-0.0019102093,
0.047385294,
-0.0076508853,
0.0420302376,
-0.0119527215,
0.0189709738,
-0.0196151063,
0.01947142,
-0.0380726494,
0.0132842893,
0.0032383925,
-0.0350579135,
-0.0177863371,
-0.0128665455,
-0.0101189315,
-0.0640642568,
-0.0502235554,
-0.0121037653,
0.0370656252,
-0.0768236443,
-0.0152783068,
0.0415664501,
-0.0285027772,
0.0070895911,
-0.0340147801,
0.0012323627,
-0.0114314463,
0.0262187067,
-0.0358716324,
-0.0453783907,
-0.0081290565,
0.033414837,
-0.0106964232,
-0.0153074982,
-0.0386155844,
0.056711778,
-0.0017811832,
-0.0771647394,
-0.0434573367,
-0.0025956407,
0.0149155827,
0.0128965555,
0.0055346852,
-0.0203131959,
0.0106439125,
0.0496859029,
-0.0068929926,
-0.063718386,
-0.0006333574,
-0.0026413468,
-0.0160482377,
0.0534536839,
-0.0539573468,
0.0012213994,
0.0294326972,
0.0280341879,
0.0138911773,
0.0023442577,
0.0559277199,
-0.0354593955,
0.0011231021,
-0.0358219743,
-0.0046372502,
0.0291222297,
-0.0331775956,
-0.0419249162,
-0.0177833084,
-0.0601563677,
-0.0214063432,
0.0068700709,
0.0170518178,
0.0193610322,
0.0031686421,
-0.051899638,
0.0714949965,
0.0995187163,
-0.01091302,
0.0251540691,
-0.0251271576,
0.0166423712,
0.0238817856,
0.0064456323,
-0.0272897668,
0.0010618992,
-0.0328205973,
-0.0132581452,
0.0021917247,
-0.0214532074,
0.008032308,
-0.0223755985,
0.012792021,
0.0153556122,
0.0145583767,
0.019809965,
0.0757880285,
-0.0241584331,
-0.0558374189,
0.052749224,
0.0264482778,
-0.0260773171,
0.0190269649,
-0.0487646237,
0.0370941758,
0.0378070399,
0.0354684666,
-0.0310344771,
-0.04131376,
0.0266648214,
-0.0253137909,
0.0526392683,
-0.0350908414,
0.0279479735,
0.0031624937,
-0.0267596021,
-0.0099874781,
0.0141912624,
0.0009799572,
-0.0109417709,
-0.0367030166,
0.0022600242,
-0.0059999065,
-0.0162310712,
-0.0370848216,
0.0590619035,
-0.041647464,
-0.0136846695,
-0.0341297798,
0.017527055,
0.0130020976,
-0.0291063897,
-0.0107680708,
0.004769654,
0.015838895,
-0.0055938978,
0.0364856012,
-0.0046744328,
0.0213657394,
0.0537874326,
-0.0100031495,
-0.0483548678,
-0.0144668687,
0.0242652651,
0.0349333435,
-0.018938031,
-0.0210078247,
-0.0692022294,
0.045967035,
-0.0428932235,
0.0121667227,
-0.0006188258,
0.0393809974,
-0.0649503097,
0.022875255,
0.001752098,
0.0227255672,
-0.0121795321,
-0.0138826976,
0.0239886623,
-0.0027324255,
-0.0120328832,
0.0004287152,
0.0024208222,
-0.0425726064,
-0.0258577541,
-0.016459262,
-0.0736679807,
-0.0022537191,
-0.0861767381,
-0.0242887866,
0.0238206107,
0.0323706977,
0.0349165052,
-0.015796436,
-0.0395051204,
0.0199488625,
0.0227061119,
0.0173134785,
0.0072899968,
-0.0027560329,
-0.0016106489,
-0.0247450862,
-0.0010734643,
-0.0039358558,
-0.0142020248,
-0.0534689799,
0.0736956894,
0.0699117556,
0.0039511197,
-0.1078571752,
0.0763527676,
-0.0208397526,
0.0245021805,
-0.002994275,
0.0032104461,
0.0564245731,
-0.0005609898,
0.0499345064,
0.0934235007,
0.0279941205,
0.046030093,
0.0522486605,
-0.0432128832,
-0.0239888839,
-0.0041087633,
-0.0069094556,
0.0372400507,
-0.0342003144,
-0.0046290033,
0.031822335,
0.0556557514,
0.0704996362,
-0.0380298682,
-0.0357994959,
0.037804693,
-0.0050369557,
-0.0509229414,
-0.025512211,
0.0231277272,
-0.0361695923,
0.0800123736,
-0.0155310053,
-0.0619652122,
0.0678148642,
-0.0028607068,
0.0227022674,
-0.0438639633,
0.0410000794,
0.0045490176,
0.0294162985,
0.0026016908,
-0.0026988771,
-0.0408082828,
-0.0375704616,
-0.0245322343,
0.0210135505,
-0.0444001369,
-0.0142420949,
0.0827075168,
-0.0356720574,
-0.0033576894,
0.0417434797,
0.0255517662,
-0.0617299192,
-0.0064840172,
-0.0431608036,
-0.0536829047,
0.0373612046,
0.0324000344,
-0.0643155873,
0.0162483677,
0.0173960365,
-0.0026007486,
0.0024685217,
-0.0519427247,
0.001128369,
0.0405709036,
0.0222664531,
0.0228970014,
0.0233385805,
-0.0195327122,
-0.0442519225,
0.0742415637,
-0.0325553119,
0.0122289238,
-0.0297256503,
0.0212424621,
0.0570138469,
-0.0928828642,
0.0000113449,
-0.0021081259,
-0.0094088707,
-0.068653658,
0.0007138941,
0.1263605654,
0.0425575376,
-0.071727939,
-0.0036924875,
-0.0422997177,
0.0155206155,
0.0067833276,
0.0134646986,
-0.0438729934,
-0.0283139963,
-0.0286673773,
0.0155895939,
0.0074257609,
-0.0270807445,
-0.0189719927,
-0.0062852814,
0.016353393,
-0.030421786,
-0.0460220873,
0.0009162147,
-0.0544808544,
0.0512928143,
0.0228490643,
-0.0050059608,
-0.0025561843,
-0.0156830456,
0.0154202087,
0.0098693399,
0.025537625,
0.0262155086,
-0.0029143614,
-0.0092271678,
0.0107710632,
0.0517773181,
-0.008873567,
-0.0416061617,
-0.0246890876,
0.0021400871,
-0.0400882289,
0.0245583635,
-0.0300460532,
0.0424241088,
-0.0107695377,
-0.0009511855,
-0.075486891,
0.0069763339,
-0.0288045518,
-0.0577167273,
-0.007318744,
0.0469921604,
-0.0278562997,
-0.0279931966,
-0.0014430296,
0.0234392341,
-0.0429112986,
0.0490143746,
0.0423645116,
-0.0803194046,
-0.0302856937,
-0.0156164924,
0.0610645637,
-0.0174180493,
-0.0665865839,
0.0035606807,
0.0186212845,
-0.0163829159,
-0.0335343331,
-0.0308600441,
0.0473615192,
-0.0243389886,
0.0590125583,
0.0249520354,
0.1048346609,
-0.0639542863,
-0.0248810314,
0.0551069342,
0.0147385634,
-0.0266369879,
-0.0545338131,
-0.0456033647,
0.0250036027,
-0.0415842682,
-0.0255318992,
0.0190062206,
-0.0387654155,
-0.0269831661,
0.0663150698,
-0.0063902489,
0.0219205618,
-0.0223857239,
0.0072005522,
-0.0371599793,
0.0187697038,
0.0067684501,
-0.0080977073,
0.073375836,
-0.0352684706,
0.0104443179,
-0.0103831943,
-0.0206149146,
-0.0018132399,
0.0165832918,
0.039472688,
-0.0022389691,
-0.009294522,
-0.0407616608,
-0.0033170544,
0.0283870045,
0.0842281729,
-0.0251249243,
0.0086506233,
-0.0743032023,
-0.0187877249,
0.0116137778,
0.0537126996,
-0.0146671264,
-0.0503002107,
0.020556815,
0.0118186902,
-0.0620618686,
0.0030410031,
-0.04388896,
-0.0468482338,
-0.009332004,
0.0047348826,
-0.058741644,
-0.0331754237,
-0.0196877755,
0.0109232105,
-0.0129936794,
0.0174278487,
-0.0342979059,
0.0359203629,
0.0195055827,
0.0833742321,
0.0238271337,
-0.0176443662,
-0.0263686366,
0.030297745,
-0.0146446088,
-0.0154984761,
0.0721645206,
0.0327063836,
-0.00758179,
-0.0204376932,
0.0380468369,
-0.0141189704,
0.0127287898,
-0.0300574563,
0.0399845764,
-0.0057010693,
0.0243985932,
0.0331859663,
-0.0026540819,
0.0239230599,
-0.0118143139,
0.0564850084,
0.0289414823,
0.0094213719,
0.0308932494,
-0.0530001968,
-0.0258066803,
-0.0261885449,
0.0059908172,
-0.0225890633,
-0.0634493083,
0.0349507928,
-0.0630701408,
-0.0686138645,
0.0370160714,
0.0209995806,
0.0428962,
-0.0304166991,
0.0362189636,
0.0308347046,
-0.0156812947,
-0.0207819082,
-0.0002486568,
-0.0008253517,
-0.0315167494,
-0.0433552004,
-0.0208200943,
-5.90315153e-33,
-0.0065457709,
-0.0747572631,
0.0010318472,
0.0500357933,
-0.0384250693,
0.0233592819,
-0.0390777439,
0.0403551795,
0.0319258906,
0.0070755547,
0.0051648878,
0.0274616573,
-0.0015771319,
0.002362068,
-0.0155195463,
-0.0222139172,
-0.0389985703,
0.0027230345,
-0.0022518691,
-0.0007864053,
0.016960511,
0.0327951759,
0.0692496002,
-0.0437826961,
0.0251317751,
-0.0053712246,
0.0517712831,
-0.0027339021,
-0.0382880047,
0.0431646965,
-0.082043983,
0.0920993388,
0.0538455173,
-0.0004215691,
0.022477515,
0.0290250182,
-0.0366960615,
-0.0527287982,
0.0386105105,
0.0140341306,
-0.0433160439,
-0.0012725155,
0.0756918639,
0.0071901204,
-0.0130559625,
0.0008428189,
0.0824311525,
-0.0091032395,
-0.0188945942,
0.0096774939,
-0.0733059123,
-0.0081284186,
-0.0096859261,
0.0113749625,
-0.0032827531,
0.0200247765,
-0.0233897325,
0.0357993171,
-0.04836227,
-0.015891904,
0.0108920531,
-0.0073525356,
0.0390781835,
0.0398061201,
0.0016476443,
0.0680320784,
0.0316448733,
0.0031121522,
-0.0813026801,
-0.045150619,
0.0736684129,
0.0248793941,
0.0001503315,
-0.0364383124,
0.045959834,
-0.0165021643,
-0.064018704,
0.0286733974,
-0.0096721565,
0.0476494655,
0.0247558802,
-0.056782376,
-0.0288557652,
-0.0142076807,
-0.0249280892,
0.0403872319,
-0.0584179461,
-0.0068159341,
0.0495520942,
-0.0667674989,
-0.0138414102,
-0.0012474018,
0.0130324662,
-0.0357114747,
0.0665397123,
0.0028430792,
-0.0002236379,
0.0129900509,
0.0130280172,
-0.0032508275,
0.0117518194,
-0.0221990086,
0.0042932909,
-0.0320308581,
0.0535855964,
-0.0405610949,
-0.0684230775,
-0.0362330824,
0.004174578,
0.0025858344,
0.0086859763,
-0.0468393117,
0.023892628,
-0.0068573556,
0.0401401222,
0.0068463748,
0.0022004927,
-0.0253133997,
0.0107353777,
0.004632317,
-0.0457988083,
-0.0058436724,
0.0021420685,
0.0428426191,
-0.0103195915,
0.0158568006,
-0.0014547561,
0.0006056999,
-0.0277645662,
-0.0665622726,
-0.0329135321,
0.033787448,
2.744e-7,
0.100035578,
0.0617138296,
0.0107843503,
0.0392547548,
-0.0063474802,
0.0002524899,
0.0306130219,
0.0083603226,
0.0495798923,
-0.0250000525,
-0.0162035469,
0.065543972,
-0.0003457284,
-0.0370957144,
-0.04445149,
-0.0554705001,
0.0546774901,
0.0862287879,
-0.0514977425,
0.0171256457,
0.0975100398,
-0.0111788297,
-0.0170773994,
-0.016263403,
0.0138404667,
-0.0063450402,
0.0646299347,
-0.0410242341,
0.0204856656,
0.0226311348,
0.0458871946,
-0.0138703967,
0.0343577154,
0.0692874268,
0.0196624883,
-0.0114658847,
0.0350565277,
0.0029042016,
-0.0334808379,
0.0046892283,
0.0127111655,
0.0004647376,
0.0065647289,
-0.0356591232,
0.0381901972,
-0.0447162986,
-0.0582295023,
0.0456302129,
-0.042783998,
-0.020599205,
0.0245491285,
-0.0123082055,
-0.0353364721,
-0.0197636988,
0.0167197008,
-0.0200633854,
-0.0110358912,
-0.051612407,
-0.0079724714,
0.0287122838,
-0.0601214953,
0.0100771682,
-0.0200195014,
-0.0294587836,
0.0611564815,
-0.0293545835,
-0.0028230525,
1.882401182e-34,
-0.0416015983,
0.0074215843,
0.033707533,
0.0466783196,
0.0073063537,
-0.0235722717,
0.0234012362,
-0.0233678725,
0.0139577258,
-0.1189264953,
-0.0014431741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15701v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15701v2 | HyPoradise: An Open Baseline for Generative Speech Recognition with Large Language Models | 2023-09-27T14:44:10 | 2023-10-16T05:47:42 | Chen Chen, Yuchen Hu, Chao-Han Huck Yang, Sabato Macro Siniscalchi, Pin-Yu Chen, Eng Siong Chng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Advancements in deep neural networks have allowed automatic speech
recognition (ASR) systems to attain human parity on several publicly available
clean speech datasets. However, even state-of-the-art ASR systems experience
performance degradation when confronted with adverse conditions, as a
well-trained acoustic model is sensitive to variations in the speech domain,
e.g., background noise. Intuitively, humans address this issue by relying on
their linguistic knowledge: the meaning of ambiguous spoken terms is usually
inferred from contextual cues thereby reducing the dependency on the auditory
system. Inspired by this observation, we introduce the first open-source
benchmark to utilize external large language models (LLMs) for ASR error
correction, where N-best decoding hypotheses provide informative elements for
true transcription prediction. This approach is a paradigm shift from the
traditional language model rescoring strategy that can only select one
candidate hypothesis as the output transcription. The proposed benchmark
contains a novel dataset, HyPoradise (HP), encompassing more than 334,000 pairs
of N-best hypotheses and corresponding accurate transcriptions across prevalent
speech domains. Given this dataset, we examine three types of error correction
techniques based on LLMs with varying amounts of labeled
hypotheses-transcription pairs, which gains a significant word error rate (WER)
reduction. Experimental evidence demonstrates the proposed technique achieves a
breakthrough by surpassing the upper bound of traditional re-ranking based
methods. More surprisingly, LLM with reasonable prompt and its generative
capability can even correct those tokens that are missing in N-best list. We
make our results publicly accessible for reproducible pipelines with released
pre-trained models, thus providing a new evaluation paradigm for ASR error
correction with LLMs. | [
-0.0194004755,
0.0964566469,
0.0269868579,
0.0170918815,
0.0126786307,
0.0072281114,
0.0175701436,
-0.001943697,
0.0048042769,
-0.0213481355,
-0.0397015586,
-0.0592036285,
0.0504886881,
0.0003647582,
0.018234089,
0.0083406297,
0.0144908642,
-0.0603037104,
-0.0085966792,
-0.0410682335,
-0.0270352103,
0.0178485103,
-0.0345338434,
0.0587314628,
0.0018669039,
0.0245408192,
0.0219478942,
0.0478161536,
0.0167471934,
-0.0081439335,
0.0041066948,
0.0376155414,
0.0363680199,
0.0753758773,
0.0000020662,
-0.0406280793,
-0.0023065566,
0.0148607353,
-0.0581899732,
0.0125659043,
0.0206442829,
0.0070402743,
-0.042799972,
0.0554451607,
0.0282662157,
-0.0680959001,
0.0626569614,
0.0175853521,
0.0022314717,
0.0555448569,
0.0116898734,
-0.0579844154,
0.0160483327,
-0.0397227108,
-0.0104572251,
-0.0321122743,
0.0210752357,
-0.0254464447,
-0.0410208255,
-0.0441451408,
0.0027691221,
0.0192217808,
0.0145932697,
-0.0136919329,
-0.0100570573,
0.0072390698,
-0.0122547103,
-0.0372052342,
-0.0187695883,
0.0681516603,
-0.0254811924,
-0.0295110792,
0.0066014924,
-0.0131130135,
-0.0262936968,
-0.0179911051,
-0.0063605825,
0.0610858388,
0.0253775008,
0.0129767181,
0.0363599546,
0.0032384112,
0.0578665249,
0.0157837234,
-0.032841906,
0.0385884792,
0.0386422426,
-0.0186654702,
0.0109133739,
-0.0013823606,
-0.0198921822,
-0.0222559869,
0.0533611514,
-0.0073121381,
-0.0404179096,
0.0003363528,
-0.0226910897,
-0.0426349752,
0.0143229282,
-0.0515599325,
0.0017924836,
0.0483352281,
-0.0646577403,
0.0137997288,
-0.0248455666,
0.0717051625,
-0.0169983674,
-0.0048959968,
0.0036404335,
-0.0119178975,
0.0302448329,
0.0155660715,
-0.0208856352,
0.0015792073,
-0.0400510095,
-0.0066257766,
-0.0413099453,
0.0110666035,
-0.0002523709,
0.0228334256,
0.0460265875,
-0.0021189386,
-0.0812942609,
-0.0388239026,
0.0285150278,
0.0129697267,
0.0355880223,
0.0474635474,
0.0127552832,
-0.102536507,
-0.0201881118,
0.0144066755,
0.0340720527,
-0.016671434,
0.0262956563,
0.0766385868,
0.0024732479,
-0.0212227274,
-0.018342562,
0.0197996553,
-0.0303555615,
-0.0391911678,
-0.0289556887,
-0.0648487285,
0.0244751777,
0.0053979526,
0.015073996,
-0.0589635186,
0.0172668789,
-0.0371820889,
0.0051634447,
0.0751048997,
0.0118921557,
0.0169373527,
0.0535270683,
-0.0080487449,
0.0254276413,
0.0412350595,
0.0517115369,
-0.0057258508,
0.0010927537,
-0.0427331552,
0.0286363903,
0.0696644634,
-0.026664786,
-0.0112293176,
-0.0284413695,
-0.0312641785,
0.013029376,
0.0417786464,
0.0691668466,
0.0725381747,
-0.0494554974,
-0.0215937514,
0.0475118123,
0.0270180665,
-0.0030718585,
0.0100915981,
0.0277694631,
-0.0006237841,
-0.0034850545,
-0.027205348,
-0.0248274375,
-0.0096454918,
0.0178021342,
0.0101302275,
0.0794004947,
0.0292203315,
-0.0178690739,
-0.0218181536,
-0.0270142667,
-0.0365127511,
-0.0361148305,
0.0588130802,
0.0705122426,
-0.008431782,
-0.0684027895,
0.0588044748,
0.0250644106,
-0.0665758476,
0.0270753689,
-0.0308343377,
0.0207952727,
0.0854220018,
0.0370194502,
-0.019809071,
-0.0320546478,
-0.0413648859,
-0.0570438355,
0.054872714,
0.0114504872,
0.0238753464,
0.0793179199,
-0.0823477581,
0.0006856482,
0.0625083447,
0.0090703378,
0.0641721264,
-0.006488882,
-0.0167837441,
0.0257009063,
-0.0126507645,
-0.0082083372,
0.0123602273,
-0.0243814494,
-0.0321493298,
0.0406616069,
-0.002989877,
0.0781810507,
0.0227458961,
-0.0704900995,
-0.0054696444,
0.0555894449,
-0.0280691106,
-0.0283758491,
-0.003722223,
-0.0923193544,
-0.0557078868,
0.0469352379,
-0.032136336,
-0.0219139289,
0.0451208577,
-0.0126017751,
-0.0680804029,
0.0094320737,
-0.032409098,
0.0183069203,
-0.0784840286,
0.0411867909,
0.0431321338,
0.0234841909,
0.0069211978,
-0.015964618,
-0.0085530654,
0.0155386152,
0.0028704091,
-0.0055923583,
-0.0323189497,
-0.0825028867,
-0.0199667607,
0.0380808972,
-0.027945932,
0.0317462236,
0.0010508762,
0.0201252811,
-0.0034666157,
-0.007653398,
-0.0936870053,
-0.0103213759,
-0.0558988526,
-0.0095607853,
0.0080388645,
0.0390059873,
-0.0029116936,
-0.0358141363,
-0.0155029157,
-0.0268636234,
0.0064072246,
0.0077729346,
-0.0286747534,
-0.0034430653,
-0.0389016122,
-0.0161763467,
-0.0088957939,
0.0172234569,
0.0242885575,
-0.0188988708,
-0.0065352917,
-0.0759186894,
0.0651405528,
0.0043651103,
0.0492574088,
-0.0009975426,
-0.0340936966,
-0.0125021571,
-0.0083963685,
0.0358242914,
0.0220391639,
-0.0031109424,
-0.0297306422,
0.0281310044,
-0.0076873722,
-0.0565577596,
-0.0134629682,
-0.0216744114,
-0.0342063345,
-0.0003873994,
-0.0254956409,
-0.0690839663,
0.0383269005,
0.0432900526,
0.0236031562,
-0.0397994034,
-0.0276248734,
-0.005329493,
-0.037218634,
-0.0504937656,
-0.0234388933,
-0.0268299226,
0.017409049,
-0.0152416201,
-0.0041452404,
0.0228006057,
-0.0813688561,
-0.0269828513,
-0.0242546592,
-0.0187130924,
-0.0283121318,
-0.0218907353,
0.0059874672,
0.0007235858,
-0.0284086186,
-0.0805762559,
-0.0242385678,
0.0055100559,
-0.0090665724,
-0.0747863874,
0.0322900638,
-0.0477013551,
0.023581747,
-0.0204265974,
-0.0650670603,
-0.0382220224,
-0.0279766731,
-0.0054922225,
0.0169949159,
0.0325985327,
-0.0246406049,
-0.0078615556,
-0.00552959,
-0.0025552083,
0.0958849862,
0.001176601,
0.0267809443,
-0.0187992584,
0.0423267744,
0.0271087941,
0.0265878215,
0.0314471982,
-0.019435687,
0.0114815552,
0.0111488169,
0.0454989113,
0.0189579632,
-0.0371095724,
0.009240428,
0.0601208322,
0.0151250139,
0.0031235763,
0.0176689345,
0.0274395291,
-0.0425957516,
-0.0017857363,
0.1206625849,
-0.0106583508,
-0.0441044867,
-0.0149560599,
-0.0130592287,
0.0022123139,
0.0108271791,
-0.0282871164,
-0.0699217021,
-0.0220691599,
0.0677868575,
0.0499982275,
-0.0089926431,
0.0051547787,
0.0167947989,
-0.113337554,
0.0790321082,
0.0428849794,
-0.0265277773,
-0.0150232855,
-0.0411855988,
-0.0066468352,
-0.0590719655,
0.0558668301,
0.0435851663,
0.0294169318,
-0.0424166992,
0.0446180962,
-0.0298445709,
-0.0896255821,
0.007747273,
-0.0208293628,
0.0576950163,
0.0766208842,
-0.0282738395,
-0.0215939116,
-0.027415771,
0.0406937003,
0.0050430554,
-0.0197262634,
0.0033137519,
0.0048112245,
0.0117025422,
-0.020714514,
0.0409852713,
0.0591681749,
-0.0290958025,
0.006356521,
-0.0166798066,
0.0325487405,
-0.0083220741,
0.0314176381,
0.0303562451,
-0.0069600339,
0.0126296701,
0.0542265885,
0.0293194,
-0.0257093031,
-0.0174635388,
-0.0048874891,
0.0571754165,
-0.0274760425,
0.0312872417,
0.0180998482,
0.0221979842,
-0.0559213609,
-0.0160583463,
-0.0066871359,
-0.0022018955,
-0.0065892804,
0.0199531298,
-0.0012827341,
-0.0173032656,
0.0209236536,
-0.0297489297,
0.0111800591,
0.005190311,
0.0054870243,
-0.0818390623,
0.0269020833,
0.0243371148,
-0.0478978865,
-0.0359315239,
0.0492837541,
-0.0417020395,
-0.0570574813,
0.0485331155,
-0.0080311466,
0.0179595444,
0.0428365581,
-0.0105348723,
-0.0644295365,
0.0331161767,
0.0615320727,
-0.0256514363,
0.0204277113,
0.0026713389,
0.001037429,
-0.0245601181,
0.0295046717,
-0.0720020086,
0.0431425497,
0.012140329,
0.0236028358,
0.0183242057,
-0.065820992,
-0.0037377726,
0.0346779414,
0.0811119676,
-0.0256665945,
0.005162362,
-0.0383584835,
0.0298280567,
-0.003623941,
0.0206436794,
-0.0206964333,
0.0246771052,
0.0583403744,
0.0043122824,
-0.0169970673,
0.0212203804,
-0.0045644604,
-0.0002432214,
-0.0202858988,
0.0358278677,
-0.0132800424,
0.0189376399,
0.0281642228,
-0.0178672429,
-0.0372986346,
0.0429255441,
0.0258840974,
0.0252224877,
-0.0183382146,
-0.0116508752,
-0.016958911,
0.0195237752,
-0.0255090408,
0.0080004642,
-0.0419020243,
-0.0635981411,
-0.0521582179,
0.0352395326,
0.0766446963,
0.0321391709,
0.0653547943,
-0.0014129438,
0.0045169964,
-0.0640688315,
0.0185412783,
0.0024692123,
0.0023323258,
0.0076902187,
0.0078456178,
-0.0178702809,
0.0348763429,
0.0543056577,
0.0406134576,
0.0460885242,
-0.0235880613,
0.0198339503,
-0.0365955755,
-0.0431430079,
-0.0239250623,
-0.0330564715,
-0.0307045411,
-0.0396344177,
0.0137774246,
-0.0786282122,
0.0153496386,
0.0345674008,
0.0476853624,
-0.0176001471,
-0.0017232125,
0.0180276744,
-0.0451909602,
-0.0220975932,
-0.0027192661,
0.0014735525,
-0.0185652487,
-0.0459450036,
-0.0180892292,
-6.974248391e-33,
-0.0266750045,
0.0204662662,
-0.0035518701,
-0.0717197135,
-0.0314408951,
0.0044453372,
-0.022395568,
-0.0027720283,
0.0238528065,
-0.0091114743,
-0.019522205,
0.0128005082,
0.041778069,
0.0269280672,
0.0014037606,
0.0260434281,
0.1091911793,
-0.0206725374,
-0.0136910444,
0.0025416785,
0.059000805,
0.0613815114,
0.0418007672,
-0.0595641173,
-0.0354470238,
0.0049141794,
-0.0318986103,
0.0013211885,
-0.0215631537,
0.0252913535,
0.0059694764,
0.0357622951,
-0.0230285134,
-0.0400272198,
-0.0315608755,
0.0082924515,
-0.0907975882,
0.0182560161,
-0.0206126347,
0.0553207844,
0.0015329858,
-0.0226725303,
0.0662329718,
0.0045437226,
-0.0662856847,
-0.0247048754,
-0.0129142916,
-0.0350571871,
-0.0229663868,
-0.0389687307,
0.0154726552,
0.0453356877,
-0.0280241147,
-0.0056283805,
0.0413747914,
0.0232465863,
-0.0226462819,
0.0114066442,
-0.0794862062,
0.0332729444,
0.0214133579,
0.0285414103,
0.0529560633,
0.0428554825,
-0.0215329733,
0.0342951044,
0.0470743515,
-0.0409646556,
-0.0036371951,
-0.0750996396,
0.0275518559,
0.0293032341,
0.0033107367,
0.0422568955,
0.0429749861,
-0.0461956859,
-0.0779461116,
-0.0107209496,
-0.0196175855,
-0.0122396657,
0.0642136559,
0.0299189202,
-0.0562088788,
-0.0199993774,
-0.0765570924,
-0.0242541954,
-0.0334384739,
0.0195175502,
0.0345041677,
-0.0049795154,
0.0047904132,
-0.011445893,
0.0563453659,
-0.0321525782,
0.0207183026,
0.0419390649,
0.0033002389,
-0.0089335321,
-0.0146962125,
0.0429733023,
-0.0456692167,
-0.0224289633,
0.0312671959,
0.0510685705,
-0.0033687127,
-0.0341541134,
-0.0032089655,
0.0383107513,
-0.0557002053,
0.0146221286,
-0.0158003587,
0.0338757224,
-0.0048007593,
0.0058161826,
0.0494192801,
-0.0103408014,
0.0248903967,
0.0406832397,
0.0012146676,
0.034494631,
0.0058191111,
0.0035254864,
0.0209501944,
0.019834552,
-0.0277665742,
0.011908954,
0.0463528261,
-0.0254284758,
0.0434386469,
0.0023074995,
-0.0054485202,
0.0067622187,
2.953e-7,
-0.0407749265,
0.026645992,
0.0294717178,
-0.0108168516,
0.040348649,
0.0163999721,
0.0052805441,
-0.0065882788,
-0.0077081425,
0.0363898575,
0.0324225239,
-0.0042208596,
0.1046765968,
0.0088877948,
-0.0583753847,
-0.0327869803,
-0.066305697,
0.0387822948,
0.0099650389,
-0.0389158539,
-0.0000975234,
0.0884524509,
-0.0287149977,
-0.0413611718,
-0.0044728452,
-0.0050305622,
0.0367933027,
-0.0255160239,
-0.001353621,
-0.0129566016,
-0.018696826,
0.0345471762,
0.0209247097,
0.0091137197,
-0.0087284138,
0.0279728118,
0.0112723364,
0.0360779613,
-0.0100271609,
-0.0413839482,
0.0025695376,
0.058073096,
0.0125942556,
-0.0487572961,
0.0181954429,
-0.0051149107,
-0.0130275926,
-0.0456055515,
-0.0609992594,
-0.0124705518,
0.0207450576,
-0.0308178682,
0.0368985198,
-0.0061968016,
0.0098088169,
-0.0115304952,
-0.0459363051,
-0.0613028668,
0.005520964,
0.001688708,
-0.0852118656,
-0.0417430475,
0.0022341246,
0.0297505055,
0.020183064,
-0.0149416504,
0.0231491048,
2.454609217e-34,
0.0525504164,
0.0000403134,
0.0219897386,
0.004016995,
0.0290116835,
-0.0292872321,
0.0085830521,
0.0106069511,
-0.0322310552,
-0.0566978082,
-0.0473159328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15686v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15686v1 | Enhancing End-to-End Conversational Speech Translation Through Target Language Context Utilization | 2023-09-27T14:32:30 | 2023-09-27T14:32:30 | Amir Hussein, Brian Yan, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Shinji Watanabe, Sanjeev Khudanpur | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Incorporating longer context has been shown to benefit machine translation,
but the inclusion of context in end-to-end speech translation (E2E-ST) remains
under-studied. To bridge this gap, we introduce target language context in
E2E-ST, enhancing coherence and overcoming memory constraints of extended audio
segments. Additionally, we propose context dropout to ensure robustness to the
absence of context, and further improve performance by adding speaker
information. Our proposed contextual E2E-ST outperforms the isolated
utterance-based E2E-ST approach. Lastly, we demonstrate that in conversational
speech, contextual information primarily contributes to capturing context
style, as well as resolving anaphora and named entities. | [
0.0117504559,
0.0467139259,
0.006137698,
0.0314712301,
-0.0074710846,
-0.0254099965,
0.0350632481,
-0.0383634269,
-0.0794575065,
-0.0071141138,
-0.0426553674,
-0.0223922431,
0.0400527157,
0.0370542295,
0.0226774588,
-0.0740418211,
0.036144007,
-0.0188045185,
-0.0321970731,
0.0139233349,
-0.015078444,
0.0059867697,
0.0068639717,
0.0018382664,
-0.0067589269,
0.0153906075,
-0.0244153831,
0.0704632699,
0.0330375731,
-0.0064725913,
-0.0286811702,
-0.0044491505,
0.0384764671,
0.0227327477,
0.000001914,
-0.057833951,
-0.0372293219,
0.0026088813,
-0.056379009,
-0.0054657641,
0.0220312607,
-0.0346927568,
-0.0307578277,
0.0275492575,
0.019780824,
0.0235899612,
0.0612890981,
0.0243964195,
0.0444060937,
0.0703605413,
-0.0250066724,
-0.0596615002,
0.0152945574,
-0.058365427,
0.0123934867,
-0.0720960423,
-0.0417879,
-0.0274024047,
-0.001093762,
0.0296048019,
-0.0252177473,
0.0864059329,
0.0139885042,
-0.0054827235,
-0.002815044,
0.0115816277,
-0.0518263951,
-0.0021163714,
-0.0204062965,
0.0939203054,
0.032740809,
0.0391044505,
0.00269891,
0.019056445,
-0.0113596702,
-0.0605965964,
-0.0211921763,
0.0089053959,
0.0072466293,
-0.0099722473,
0.0130265886,
0.0944131911,
0.0078777773,
-0.0338412225,
-0.0660600737,
0.0090784393,
0.0285375938,
0.0032467381,
-0.0001511556,
-0.0013272066,
-0.0285632778,
-0.0040937164,
0.070592083,
-0.0086216573,
-0.0420198068,
0.0257612765,
-0.0523673855,
-0.0052850568,
-0.0236127377,
-0.006430537,
-0.0151973488,
0.0748548433,
-0.034513291,
0.0303679369,
0.0069004507,
0.0191996116,
-0.0081284372,
-0.0307002682,
-0.0524130054,
-0.0642519668,
-0.0182554852,
0.0496785939,
-0.0584980436,
-0.0020955368,
-0.0701733604,
-0.0446234047,
-0.0285478551,
0.039160639,
0.0004260653,
0.0121926712,
0.0032840269,
-0.0251354594,
-0.085961625,
-0.0101771904,
0.0327106081,
0.0384978838,
-0.0130709335,
-0.003220316,
0.0202999189,
-0.02660756,
-0.0239523463,
0.0452448241,
0.0218976084,
-0.0342345983,
-0.0103892637,
0.0842683539,
0.0154981995,
-0.051142104,
0.0154602993,
-0.0102188922,
-0.0671662465,
-0.0575041845,
-0.0410493538,
-0.0460167043,
0.0452043191,
-0.0014029159,
-0.0010933587,
0.0031143057,
-0.0172177013,
-0.0218685158,
-0.0059563247,
0.0728296414,
0.0288707484,
0.006329501,
0.0499022268,
0.0168147925,
0.0129491016,
0.0427313149,
0.050142426,
-0.011788873,
0.0293606929,
0.0039094831,
-0.0369957834,
0.0618536994,
0.0276179183,
0.028432209,
-0.022135701,
0.0072334115,
0.0171914697,
0.0245151781,
0.0599381663,
0.0508675501,
-0.0094385957,
-0.0147577235,
0.0469448045,
0.011514904,
0.0139311813,
-0.0013566999,
0.0413170196,
0.0287961122,
-0.0613444038,
0.004261768,
-0.0391150117,
0.0114032384,
0.0123552596,
0.0306638908,
0.0902927518,
0.0420899093,
-0.0272933636,
0.00359705,
0.0151370233,
-0.0173442792,
0.0077375318,
0.0141391857,
-0.0053271982,
-0.0051345187,
-0.0553689525,
0.0561796874,
-0.0161824077,
-0.0589080714,
0.0248254705,
0.0114070959,
-0.0480560549,
0.0676865578,
0.025992509,
0.0149941528,
-0.0330836847,
-0.0279488768,
0.0155782923,
0.0645639449,
0.0104114888,
0.0124587668,
0.1275520176,
-0.0336487815,
-0.0041005206,
0.0042387219,
-0.0024118267,
0.0364466049,
-0.0007515406,
0.0416624658,
0.049548015,
-0.0068175518,
0.014596425,
-0.0282493234,
-0.0182369389,
0.0123541299,
0.0324602425,
0.0325087607,
0.0279954225,
0.0479236655,
-0.0118548274,
-0.0075047654,
0.0037033618,
-0.0264903884,
0.0289495587,
0.0655004084,
-0.1100688279,
-0.0451994725,
0.0001993814,
-0.0371904485,
-0.0089512412,
-0.0315863676,
0.014292866,
-0.0944003388,
-0.0026378371,
-0.0252412613,
0.057435073,
-0.0195362959,
0.0503472947,
0.0353485383,
0.0306689925,
-0.0044559659,
0.0015383122,
0.0147729022,
-0.0462949984,
0.0407436304,
0.0365010165,
-0.0227499232,
-0.065535523,
0.0075116763,
0.0412934907,
0.0339986868,
0.0039961436,
0.0175970681,
-0.0115098124,
-0.0456838645,
-0.0218813363,
-0.0947170183,
0.0327409469,
-0.01395874,
0.0321483649,
0.0363898799,
0.0577051304,
-0.0062600616,
-0.0010544599,
-0.0103433942,
-0.0265902355,
-0.0028019289,
-0.0084109204,
-0.0419691019,
0.0329679176,
-0.0327507444,
-0.0222915448,
0.0288364366,
0.0482813641,
0.0052003353,
0.0047418168,
-0.0362363458,
-0.0412193611,
0.0442522131,
0.0024218261,
-0.000171755,
-0.012021522,
0.0019652094,
-0.0321524926,
0.0007310972,
0.0339204855,
0.010616092,
0.0088842763,
-0.0164984986,
-0.0145563856,
-0.0800424665,
-0.055100508,
0.0196280889,
0.0050483961,
-0.0072660767,
-0.0176934917,
-0.0252619125,
0.0385519117,
0.0377731659,
0.0110315876,
0.024017388,
-0.0333511159,
-0.0501490571,
0.0268295556,
-0.0195716564,
-0.0081721805,
-0.0136059811,
-0.0195695795,
0.0013137141,
-0.0257751178,
-0.0202159695,
0.0596191511,
-0.0843610913,
-0.0349959843,
-0.0377894975,
-0.0160397459,
-0.0179451909,
0.0213732272,
-0.0464628376,
0.0146071268,
-0.0170960519,
-0.0721483231,
-0.0186103731,
0.0238159038,
-0.0022160856,
-0.0064586285,
0.0587600097,
-0.0613291077,
-0.0150553882,
0.0104505764,
-0.0293795131,
-0.0303633492,
0.0265712123,
-0.012517333,
0.0015942522,
0.0174158495,
-0.047149431,
-0.0238124263,
0.0155852865,
0.0099075474,
0.063246794,
-0.0029891697,
0.0107900752,
0.0099820821,
0.0408998094,
-0.0006044224,
0.0652883798,
-0.0207033064,
-0.0218430422,
0.0369344912,
0.0030071237,
0.0398670956,
-0.0146956993,
-0.0052235965,
-0.0273680389,
0.0176466294,
0.0272105318,
-0.0780027956,
0.0135951815,
0.0675847307,
-0.0337358974,
-0.0163226221,
0.1126328632,
-0.009541071,
-0.0251784958,
-0.0344343111,
-0.0142863095,
0.0534099601,
0.0186280441,
0.0152119324,
-0.0699500814,
-0.0677329227,
0.0340032242,
0.0365391634,
0.0394302644,
0.0128799984,
-0.0301716346,
-0.0802518874,
0.0207188446,
0.0465687774,
-0.1199453846,
-0.0343277529,
0.0099747684,
-0.0090388199,
-0.0155203622,
0.0615355521,
-0.0232037921,
0.0058693346,
-0.0216209497,
-0.0098770196,
0.023662556,
-0.0246209707,
0.0120469909,
-0.0322956294,
0.0903879851,
0.059052702,
0.0327995606,
0.0163178016,
0.0601061545,
0.049450174,
-0.05936056,
-0.0022339523,
-0.0114336452,
0.0287396777,
-0.0394670479,
0.0042570676,
0.0395586975,
0.0443101674,
0.017820755,
0.0203762092,
0.0304197185,
0.0257526208,
-0.0083503975,
0.0494888276,
0.030704001,
0.0266804863,
0.0312220994,
0.0802248493,
0.0414531752,
-0.0240705293,
0.0163478255,
-0.0072099315,
0.003035597,
-0.0584139265,
0.0511158146,
-0.0141840996,
-0.0257077869,
-0.0248055495,
-0.0721667483,
-0.0515786894,
-0.0069061592,
0.0309597682,
0.002460001,
-0.0011862956,
-0.0169098899,
0.0183256846,
-0.0266916919,
0.0055176425,
-0.0407485031,
0.0297812074,
-0.0730516985,
0.0166320521,
0.0069735618,
-0.0556837134,
0.0188162811,
0.0662587583,
-0.0578560606,
-0.0664896518,
0.0093167564,
0.0020233835,
0.0171142239,
0.1049968526,
-0.0188259035,
-0.0046118763,
0.0291693285,
-0.0045625209,
-0.0428535081,
0.0261929128,
0.0700468495,
0.0546100624,
-0.0031043475,
0.0586939864,
-0.0334936194,
0.0039016854,
-0.0151461922,
0.0374769829,
-0.0318614952,
-0.0923661664,
-0.0195181016,
-0.0076127765,
0.0232633948,
-0.0223077722,
0.0102844471,
0.0093584321,
0.0611201786,
-0.0298063308,
0.0242376961,
-0.0407671779,
-0.026112359,
0.0132838031,
-0.0107953167,
0.0251635183,
0.0122183515,
-0.0328516215,
-0.0214506015,
-0.0176709909,
0.0026086301,
-0.0126678124,
-0.0048360978,
0.0002905435,
0.0233669616,
0.0003041736,
0.0199212153,
0.0315597504,
0.0317144133,
-0.0647260845,
0.0555295646,
-0.0201975275,
-0.021913968,
-0.0019145458,
0.0247486793,
-0.0348506868,
0.0494110063,
-0.0007597941,
0.0035822245,
0.0178665109,
-0.0192739386,
0.1097192168,
0.0023135028,
0.0256688725,
-0.0288344417,
0.0668986216,
-0.0293139778,
-0.0442294776,
-0.0105444118,
-0.0120491665,
0.0144610526,
0.0533363633,
0.027678404,
-0.0284904391,
-0.001256981,
-0.0226932317,
0.01750529,
-0.0178365596,
-0.0323960446,
-0.0231738389,
-0.0036704643,
-0.0303102192,
-0.0265119262,
-0.0140672559,
-0.0626166314,
0.0151312454,
-0.0332476236,
0.0101811001,
-0.0095190201,
0.016994033,
0.0416707955,
-0.0276574176,
0.0051464038,
0.012229288,
-0.012218968,
0.0208895653,
-0.0020932006,
-0.0187379774,
-6.219139473e-33,
-0.062296655,
0.0003787384,
0.0109862704,
-0.0282317959,
-0.0390548334,
0.0117801744,
-0.0811810493,
-0.0152578102,
0.0006483908,
-0.0339689739,
-0.014785002,
0.0252429172,
0.0357567891,
0.0461100005,
-0.0373470671,
-0.0044113379,
0.0681082532,
0.03147728,
-0.0283315368,
0.0497368351,
0.0530626923,
0.023509765,
0.0474553071,
-0.094819136,
0.0087895365,
0.0177705381,
-0.0151549773,
0.0219761468,
0.0493861176,
0.0005399672,
0.0219849925,
-0.0005711543,
-0.0092016952,
-0.0495049469,
-0.0157299191,
0.0012184944,
-0.1221621409,
0.0214530788,
0.0116926786,
0.0098774433,
0.0047851857,
-0.0508633815,
0.033847969,
-0.0297350287,
0.0398272015,
-0.0283177514,
-0.006083684,
-0.043225076,
-0.0319917239,
-0.0158551894,
-0.069500789,
0.0181278754,
-0.0269566029,
-0.0017260336,
0.042968519,
0.0452887863,
0.0145816384,
-0.0274441075,
-0.0429320671,
0.0399160273,
-0.0309517663,
0.0110433716,
0.0611389503,
0.0277380068,
-0.0187951922,
0.023960907,
0.0406614244,
-0.026405409,
0.0293953624,
-0.0164194386,
0.030532511,
-0.0026505482,
-0.004240734,
0.0212474857,
0.0148972291,
-0.007744079,
-0.0143715562,
0.0179947335,
-0.0098224189,
-0.0216638409,
-0.0135720372,
0.0264310557,
-0.0476141013,
0.0047269166,
-0.0371448956,
-0.02922621,
-0.0255209673,
-0.0258973967,
0.0108747007,
0.0156947989,
-0.0152268354,
0.0037600747,
0.1068731397,
0.0155710606,
0.0148643935,
-0.0021375013,
-0.0180578437,
0.0069827475,
-0.0336712115,
0.022347698,
-0.0211050101,
-0.0120604998,
0.063986443,
0.0253469404,
0.0063988785,
-0.0489476025,
0.0148117393,
0.0433508158,
-0.0460838638,
-0.0026520956,
-0.0413841121,
0.0240615308,
-0.0653648376,
0.0025487472,
0.026659647,
-0.0047648121,
-0.0139716892,
0.0639891401,
-0.0077604866,
0.0041090832,
-0.0254290402,
-0.0513559431,
0.025815744,
0.0279577076,
-0.061338149,
0.0124325771,
0.0270720795,
-0.025173137,
0.0361607373,
-0.041068688,
-0.0227098297,
-0.0224714857,
2.68e-7,
0.0014477654,
0.0182987563,
0.0269793663,
-0.0125377541,
0.0132553894,
0.0112735722,
0.0015498013,
0.0040691495,
0.0041387621,
0.0174313411,
0.0115521709,
0.0073791537,
0.0975688994,
0.0165511519,
-0.0887468383,
-0.0280916169,
-0.0196916144,
0.026606407,
-0.0402012207,
0.0112593072,
0.0384830683,
0.0970269516,
-0.0306772552,
-0.0116565274,
-0.0154963713,
-0.0070316563,
0.0321799852,
-0.0464812294,
-0.0212427154,
-0.0130912848,
-0.0308562852,
0.0083971368,
-0.0499607176,
0.0030269539,
-0.0339859501,
0.0228089448,
0.0264593232,
0.0926579311,
0.0386648215,
-0.0675591081,
-0.0063964403,
0.0205990113,
-0.0320266075,
0.0112615824,
0.0474278815,
-0.0311603341,
-0.0021591033,
0.0060784412,
-0.0361954831,
0.021932967,
-0.0425404832,
-0.0045355693,
-0.0201056302,
0.0084253019,
0.0170497503,
-0.0297021512,
-0.0142983245,
-0.0766997486,
-0.0417983159,
-0.014297097,
-0.0332466252,
-0.0189544186,
-0.0180719234,
-0.0426790118,
0.0218960047,
-0.02434,
0.0123384567,
2.602610155e-34,
0.0463543385,
-0.0099700298,
0.0075098113,
0.0047957203,
0.0135170193,
-0.0368451141,
0.0020124589,
0.0075376248,
0.0119535988,
-0.0283016078,
-0.0543851964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15674v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15674v1 | Speech collage: code-switched audio generation by collaging monolingual corpora | 2023-09-27T14:17:53 | 2023-09-27T14:17:53 | Amir Hussein, Dorsa Zeinali, Ondřej Klejch, Matthew Wiesner, Brian Yan, Shammur Chowdhury, Ahmed Ali, Shinji Watanabe, Sanjeev Khudanpur | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Designing effective automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems for
Code-Switching (CS) often depends on the availability of the transcribed CS
resources. To address data scarcity, this paper introduces Speech Collage, a
method that synthesizes CS data from monolingual corpora by splicing audio
segments. We further improve the smoothness quality of audio generation using
an overlap-add approach. We investigate the impact of generated data on speech
recognition in two scenarios: using in-domain CS text and a zero-shot approach
with synthesized CS text. Empirical results highlight up to 34.4% and 16.2%
relative reductions in Mixed-Error Rate and Word-Error Rate for in-domain and
zero-shot scenarios, respectively. Lastly, we demonstrate that CS augmentation
bolsters the model's code-switching inclination and reduces its monolingual
bias. | [
-0.0291919783,
0.0213066917,
0.0141376564,
0.0269767568,
-0.0125626419,
-0.0073791882,
0.0244368259,
-0.0268748123,
-0.0108366041,
-0.0211984385,
-0.0475982539,
-0.0127929039,
0.0487402603,
0.0383256339,
0.0442970134,
-0.0224866923,
0.0399795696,
-0.0775452033,
-0.0259937663,
0.0005041237,
-0.0078420481,
0.0004097306,
-0.0161910914,
0.0236393381,
0.0050183772,
0.0036278232,
0.003433279,
0.0506498665,
0.0057983482,
-0.008976372,
-0.0250015706,
0.0194690302,
0.0326688364,
0.049707707,
0.0000018235,
-0.0323898494,
-0.0538193546,
0.0063910484,
-0.0506016538,
0.0038476095,
0.0443432108,
-0.0078065456,
-0.0315011032,
0.0472011641,
-0.0084109204,
0.0009860644,
0.0545916781,
-0.0421018265,
0.0339335091,
0.0482433774,
-0.0235785767,
-0.0427127741,
-0.0229484364,
-0.027770279,
-0.0455504693,
-0.0106176157,
-0.0209225416,
-0.0313669518,
0.0336934589,
-0.0551922917,
-0.0252951737,
0.0554243997,
0.0020879058,
-0.0055858688,
-0.015474393,
0.000709662,
-0.085315071,
-0.0179634113,
-0.0250599328,
0.057045199,
-0.0306938607,
-0.0246800799,
0.026709253,
-0.000093591,
-0.0007803083,
-0.0719020218,
-0.0105207479,
0.0124437017,
-0.0115935933,
0.0060761217,
-0.0089294966,
0.0128487311,
0.0368079208,
-0.0486461744,
-0.0446024165,
-0.016416505,
0.007209762,
-0.0408616588,
-0.0043820143,
-0.0111067817,
0.0420507602,
-0.0006418255,
0.0643186346,
-0.0030228915,
-0.0297427122,
0.0068968679,
-0.0622032396,
-0.06582845,
-0.0072236052,
0.0018583103,
0.0228486583,
0.060853418,
-0.029600637,
0.0156046934,
-0.0153120384,
0.0292401146,
0.0305558648,
-0.0134502202,
-0.010017951,
-0.0021581459,
-0.0242788475,
0.0181910284,
-0.0443645418,
0.0196467768,
-0.0267726295,
-0.0010153671,
-0.0553251989,
0.0076615959,
-0.0118363686,
0.0314899124,
0.0062834769,
-0.0215038732,
-0.0262616817,
0.0036993937,
0.0576050878,
0.0071145333,
0.0165801961,
0.0424778871,
0.0296668727,
-0.0823908746,
-0.0227120724,
0.0127700763,
0.0410171524,
-0.0120243244,
0.0252053458,
0.094408609,
-0.0315409712,
-0.0366559401,
-0.0292084683,
-0.0122974534,
-0.0312156864,
-0.0267789774,
-0.0132518895,
-0.0871208757,
0.0384381004,
0.0264001396,
0.0109455856,
-0.0526855774,
-0.0021321678,
-0.013079972,
-0.0034497657,
0.0580464117,
-0.0614425689,
0.0183258355,
0.0258631874,
-0.0143375406,
0.0019826691,
0.0774386898,
0.0912126303,
-0.0373944379,
0.0398857258,
-0.0331252366,
0.0105995331,
0.0630326197,
-0.0005382442,
0.0082864147,
-0.0192289799,
-0.0545736663,
-0.0023954224,
-0.0093273334,
0.0735287368,
0.0456519797,
-0.041983366,
-0.0132227316,
0.0179593246,
0.0139781758,
0.0333818309,
-0.001103685,
0.0550877899,
0.016631417,
-0.0045577534,
0.0377193801,
0.0320845209,
-0.0032968903,
0.0163465645,
0.0268377997,
0.0857483,
0.0465331413,
-0.0215962175,
0.0054420377,
0.0027997298,
-0.042453073,
0.0435936935,
0.0064737364,
0.0001841874,
0.0043936814,
-0.0444619022,
0.0107131181,
0.0028771523,
-0.089129813,
0.0178742558,
-0.0252267756,
-0.0383424461,
0.0868256539,
0.0337356701,
0.0055759973,
-0.0170571804,
-0.0376173742,
-0.0304543804,
0.0504803509,
0.0042155222,
-0.0111503042,
0.0847288594,
-0.0705444887,
0.023905335,
0.0141275981,
-0.0169564392,
0.0712558106,
-0.016261179,
0.0333469175,
0.0225631166,
0.0217638556,
-0.0231895205,
-0.0315527767,
-0.0618483499,
0.0124739297,
0.0332485065,
-0.0056449692,
0.0510292612,
0.0242844336,
-0.0628167763,
0.0295169242,
0.0171035156,
-0.0208062474,
0.011373587,
0.0520069934,
-0.049171526,
-0.045988176,
0.0441743955,
-0.0443508998,
-0.0133734755,
-0.0029599008,
0.0202280153,
-0.09007065,
0.0374822915,
-0.0350995287,
0.0350213498,
-0.0375147983,
0.0764194652,
0.0413284488,
0.0227939431,
0.0033304847,
-0.0256100576,
0.021240674,
0.0007719587,
0.0442437977,
0.0043002167,
0.0266864318,
-0.0574885122,
0.0111200511,
0.0520917214,
-0.0303480085,
-0.010218895,
-0.0095866146,
0.0005536574,
-0.0171730444,
-0.0111973193,
-0.0734343156,
-0.0112361992,
-0.0216165613,
-0.0003225611,
-0.02491148,
0.0149307782,
-0.0172470082,
-0.0327373333,
-0.0097859912,
-0.0106862532,
-0.0058017061,
0.0011504964,
-0.0478907339,
0.0118181007,
-0.0081158979,
-0.043131873,
0.0143422084,
0.0421536155,
-0.0208577719,
-0.0396459624,
-0.0573340543,
-0.0710291713,
0.0319148116,
0.0140821505,
0.034410879,
0.0104301376,
-0.0104733184,
0.0066223014,
0.0192163736,
0.0916714817,
-0.0039410247,
-0.020768756,
-0.0555412509,
0.0479315333,
-0.0428360663,
-0.0270561595,
0.0097225029,
0.0546628982,
0.0154133877,
-0.015359845,
-0.0168677773,
-0.0091514196,
0.021780014,
0.0310330335,
0.037108127,
-0.0430104807,
-0.0571081303,
-0.0037959474,
-0.054021772,
0.0229348857,
-0.0501176789,
-0.0283886474,
0.050885085,
-0.012745617,
-0.0394035503,
0.0243621245,
-0.082515873,
-0.0494197682,
-0.0401353911,
-0.0287675951,
-0.026238244,
-0.0192329027,
-0.0275352914,
0.0051661651,
-0.0358416773,
-0.0503347367,
-0.0380377918,
0.0293094739,
0.0010605098,
-0.0696398914,
0.0408446342,
-0.0497800298,
-0.0027480698,
-0.0100251734,
-0.049807325,
-0.01072603,
0.0158131383,
-0.0255318154,
-0.0083101755,
0.0536366925,
-0.0423018113,
0.0198734701,
0.021878127,
-0.0031442002,
0.11259152,
0.0017706829,
0.0312422253,
-0.0134552382,
0.0262209978,
-0.0009527892,
0.0213953089,
-0.0203637443,
-0.0131723015,
0.0164477825,
-0.0354239568,
0.0495756455,
0.03065845,
-0.0266092252,
-0.0009521102,
0.0376261212,
0.0202480927,
-0.0508594401,
0.0043294844,
0.0463626571,
-0.0337695293,
-0.0073524765,
0.0915756449,
0.0143883657,
-0.0545034856,
-0.0359319821,
-0.0158114396,
0.0481693894,
0.0233367849,
0.011822884,
-0.028319221,
-0.0173655301,
0.0491683558,
0.0635450929,
0.0092028929,
0.0214597881,
-0.0296926778,
-0.1135367751,
0.0474086739,
0.0434060432,
-0.0312644206,
-0.0499972254,
-0.0070032505,
-0.0384029225,
0.0086500878,
0.0258279294,
0.0021784354,
-0.035296116,
-0.0161535759,
0.0494915918,
-0.0605989397,
-0.0546492524,
-0.0389937423,
-0.0023544917,
0.0970105156,
0.088088043,
0.0250459835,
-0.0316949263,
-0.035561461,
0.0300715733,
0.029778786,
0.0078277206,
-0.0118605867,
0.0411776304,
-0.0061817314,
-0.0030908161,
0.0810099915,
0.0092213359,
0.0199111514,
-0.0138620008,
0.0282004979,
0.0173327234,
0.0013710601,
0.0038677196,
0.0148560246,
0.0459557772,
0.012498972,
0.0273277201,
0.041550301,
-0.0361080989,
-0.0090385517,
-0.0009633263,
-0.0155172497,
-0.087345168,
0.0558131374,
0.0209424645,
-0.0123025347,
-0.0666002631,
-0.0521048345,
-0.0107431086,
0.0225099642,
0.0603452176,
0.0255183131,
0.0378858596,
-0.0199041236,
0.0545108207,
-0.0604657009,
-0.0649505332,
0.0009826708,
0.0333356746,
-0.0718929619,
-0.0230001565,
-0.0040734131,
-0.0337442346,
0.0057597407,
0.036458496,
-0.0709280744,
-0.0698460266,
0.0230245963,
-0.0127209965,
0.0209041145,
0.091782704,
-0.0155852167,
-0.0418522209,
0.0029448827,
0.046961233,
-0.0510223582,
0.0488752425,
0.0870428756,
-0.0373086818,
-0.0343015939,
-0.0002729047,
-0.0425444469,
-0.0095029855,
-0.026583571,
-0.0094714975,
-0.0312177259,
0.0034359142,
0.0070622046,
-0.0123404032,
-0.0022593783,
-0.0596368499,
0.040006116,
-0.0226208642,
0.0328313336,
-0.0001106697,
0.0411110744,
-0.0448860563,
-0.0165085308,
0.033574786,
-0.0121574905,
-0.0117752189,
0.021278508,
-0.0596445873,
-0.0182804912,
0.0183533654,
0.031207772,
0.0242626686,
0.0281687118,
0.0304636899,
-0.0072637307,
-0.0033095817,
0.0495846272,
0.0134188337,
0.0092878556,
-0.0320140831,
0.0015256206,
-0.002761004,
0.0097611863,
0.0372407287,
0.0382759348,
-0.0341013372,
-0.0067380723,
-0.000713475,
0.0135757737,
0.0398212709,
0.0058475761,
0.1198778674,
-0.0127554638,
0.0371158384,
-0.0263868589,
0.0189041942,
-0.0329220071,
-0.0297751185,
-0.0340095311,
-0.0107692452,
-0.0146405455,
0.0242417194,
0.0767771751,
0.0101816719,
-0.0139460173,
-0.0191630218,
0.0216341335,
-0.0315517001,
-0.0190859679,
0.0411524959,
-0.0000108963,
-0.0086166691,
-0.0107689453,
-0.0187513735,
-0.0804365128,
0.0640716627,
0.0068364111,
0.0501728207,
-0.0074641937,
0.0154399527,
0.0361328796,
-0.0318315029,
0.0729147196,
-0.0273616835,
-0.0218588002,
0.0569536202,
-0.0411956795,
0.0198530518,
-5.67001794e-33,
-0.0422412641,
0.0042984863,
0.0079945615,
0.0010760162,
-0.014882897,
-0.0475456938,
-0.0551978424,
0.0240948461,
0.0164872296,
-0.0377623588,
-0.0290507805,
0.0139782997,
0.037554197,
-0.0035903803,
0.0171447732,
0.0181686152,
0.0794192851,
0.0007752316,
-0.0007218536,
0.0218966957,
0.0245834403,
0.0498428531,
0.0170612466,
-0.0671564415,
-0.0302549768,
0.0016529247,
-0.0057841656,
-0.0788713247,
0.0525159873,
0.0168524552,
0.0305970144,
0.0177099928,
-0.0082028992,
-0.0052349526,
-0.0273744501,
-0.0061835148,
-0.0572372489,
0.0127070546,
0.0105272066,
0.0387737341,
0.0120094931,
-0.0169338807,
0.0138084246,
-0.0044901189,
-0.0138812717,
-0.0121077131,
0.0146666011,
-0.0352913737,
-0.0261294115,
-0.0285089482,
-0.0559539385,
0.0404944755,
-0.0057157595,
-0.0319227502,
0.0459977984,
0.0978700221,
-0.0263423398,
0.0064480742,
-0.0650166422,
0.0708285719,
0.0314562023,
0.0457668528,
0.0353961848,
0.0120850839,
-0.0280525386,
0.0483453795,
0.0207467619,
-0.0284539443,
0.0368639119,
0.0165986754,
0.051264558,
-0.0032341974,
0.0071268077,
0.0686348304,
0.0695637837,
-0.0543192364,
-0.0086432928,
-0.0264365487,
0.0140460478,
-0.0324637145,
0.0329444185,
0.0319476575,
-0.0148404287,
-0.007554844,
-0.0404454097,
-0.0333862305,
-0.0159885101,
-0.0496322922,
0.0475243516,
0.0235804636,
-0.005256536,
0.0147998836,
0.0764096901,
0.0107508758,
-0.001501889,
-0.0051012472,
-0.0248983242,
0.0088523189,
-0.0001660598,
0.0402606651,
-0.0230277441,
-0.0122266347,
0.0924898908,
0.0260859989,
0.039007064,
-0.0254679825,
0.0433801077,
0.084484227,
-0.0582210906,
-0.0037983849,
0.0064085904,
0.0369578078,
0.0088799326,
0.012644154,
0.01503463,
0.0062004537,
0.0024471765,
0.0165146478,
-0.0333649665,
-0.0095682489,
-0.0386650749,
-0.0443960838,
-0.0240202527,
0.032912977,
-0.0377499498,
-0.0001646035,
0.008531712,
-0.0137428474,
0.024881633,
-0.0414791591,
-0.0184571072,
0.0022633681,
2.681e-7,
-0.0167045463,
-0.0031034595,
0.0027991377,
-0.0291561317,
0.0240098666,
-0.0332521535,
-0.0571211129,
0.0050758766,
0.0285657682,
0.0083067967,
-0.0078596845,
-0.0367786586,
0.0848514065,
0.0299670435,
-0.1000845358,
-0.050010059,
-0.0065795104,
0.0268254858,
-0.0109669175,
0.0058563813,
0.0134968301,
0.0770517886,
-0.0425790213,
-0.0275778603,
0.0273284353,
0.0077804923,
0.0084831547,
0.0150025636,
-0.0023346951,
-0.0469131991,
-0.0631568506,
-0.0006893403,
-0.0263037104,
-0.0060914345,
-0.0590528995,
0.0130664399,
0.0549129769,
0.0257696398,
-0.0012163343,
-0.0365332514,
0.0201937482,
0.0175953638,
-0.0609623678,
0.0050647976,
0.0412580445,
0.0229754001,
0.0239127632,
-0.0269635078,
-0.031812638,
0.0522141084,
-0.0104224114,
-0.030903928,
-0.0092419349,
0.0011684858,
0.0312984996,
0.0193797145,
0.0142183267,
-0.0282246582,
-0.0058948668,
-0.0041523655,
-0.0343256071,
-0.0249067601,
-0.0343106687,
0.0003873172,
0.0364987478,
-0.0339026228,
0.0068577705,
2.364042658e-34,
0.0536461473,
-0.0280562248,
0.0205693208,
-0.0012424501,
-0.0021053832,
-0.0440293215,
-0.0098537412,
0.0451515242,
-0.0055254558,
-0.0096731279,
-0.0483527258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15670v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15670v1 | MONOVAB : An Annotated Corpus for Bangla Multi-label Emotion Detection | 2023-09-27T14:10:57 | 2023-09-27T14:10:57 | Sumit Kumar Banshal, Sajal Das, Shumaiya Akter Shammi, Narayan Ranjan Chakraborty | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In recent years, Sentiment Analysis (SA) and Emotion Recognition (ER) have
been increasingly popular in the Bangla language, which is the seventh most
spoken language throughout the entire world. However, the language is
structurally complicated, which makes this field arduous to extract emotions in
an accurate manner. Several distinct approaches such as the extraction of
positive and negative sentiments as well as multiclass emotions, have been
implemented in this field of study. Nevertheless, the extraction of multiple
sentiments is an almost untouched area in this language. Which involves
identifying several feelings based on a single piece of text. Therefore, this
study demonstrates a thorough method for constructing an annotated corpus based
on scrapped data from Facebook to bridge the gaps in this subject area to
overcome the challenges. To make this annotation more fruitful, the
context-based approach has been used. Bidirectional Encoder Representations
from Transformers (BERT), a well-known methodology of transformers, have been
shown the best results of all methods implemented. Finally, a web application
has been developed to demonstrate the performance of the pre-trained
top-performer model (BERT) for multi-label ER in Bangla. | [
0.0317970067,
0.0088172983,
-0.0052225911,
0.0486977398,
0.0034480365,
0.0368762054,
-0.0244083852,
-0.0120860329,
0.0283640325,
-0.061456833,
-0.0561023429,
-0.0422243029,
-0.0414129905,
0.0058056451,
-0.0468727909,
-0.0674811602,
0.001729599,
0.0582993329,
0.0788189173,
-0.0147289578,
0.0297050495,
0.0367010683,
-0.0263177566,
0.0047577177,
-0.0632669926,
0.003523424,
0.0023699377,
0.0265757032,
0.0060606566,
-0.0157097746,
0.0219121333,
0.057380598,
0.0062037813,
-0.0190322809,
0.0000022135,
-0.0326378085,
-0.0408985242,
0.0047488529,
0.0202631392,
-0.0339058749,
0.0883737877,
0.0028492017,
-0.019252196,
0.0173155591,
-0.02088622,
0.0041142632,
0.0539315231,
0.0831765682,
0.089358218,
0.0691115484,
-0.0480138399,
-0.0673330873,
-0.0372977331,
0.0170296747,
-0.0102213807,
-0.0165437162,
-0.0001262563,
-0.0266155563,
0.0150614772,
-0.0433181562,
-0.0449747182,
0.0006946265,
-0.0093695698,
0.0013184611,
-0.0117562963,
-0.020765556,
-0.0287669133,
-0.0564978793,
-0.0070769168,
0.0351717584,
-0.0144293569,
0.0346003175,
-0.0021648791,
0.0143251112,
0.0029189608,
-0.0257589053,
0.0047136256,
0.0014033098,
-0.0370751694,
0.0090079652,
-0.0211467557,
0.0495248288,
-0.0344396345,
0.0026127226,
0.0072284336,
0.0101019358,
-0.0306750387,
-0.0332057029,
0.015498016,
0.0366605818,
-0.0071538249,
0.0446831286,
0.0553264357,
-0.0314845555,
0.0397424623,
0.0259545241,
-0.0258458816,
-0.0536521673,
-0.009152499,
-0.0936829224,
-0.0404625013,
0.0165752321,
-0.0795346051,
0.0241825487,
0.0103432955,
-0.0101499157,
0.0046222438,
0.0245579407,
-0.027730938,
-0.0219258294,
-0.0412754826,
0.0009691961,
0.0093049435,
0.0519301966,
0.0081014261,
0.0177135691,
-0.1147850305,
0.0111045511,
-0.0371646844,
-0.0273359139,
0.0083131064,
-0.0222122334,
0.0306039881,
-0.0008758955,
0.0084299846,
0.0513161495,
-0.0234516338,
0.0029539636,
-0.0296371281,
-0.071994707,
0.030393023,
0.0241928454,
0.0155246258,
-0.0341578051,
0.006543356,
0.02481227,
-0.0127452658,
-0.0493054613,
-0.0487283133,
0.0180187169,
-0.0456419103,
-0.0307438355,
-0.0183580238,
-0.0327152573,
0.0779816881,
0.0190930385,
-0.0004383721,
0.0164997075,
0.017053863,
-0.0199424084,
-0.0041015018,
0.0624291375,
-0.0213071704,
-0.0323196054,
0.031626571,
0.0093482751,
0.0459118783,
0.0312851742,
0.0093236566,
0.0787620842,
0.0279754624,
-0.0057735979,
0.0295604318,
0.0042339563,
-0.0194153283,
-0.0455491655,
-0.0198583007,
-0.0322392099,
-0.0166313071,
-0.0203945842,
-0.0142546231,
0.0351347104,
-0.0224751383,
0.0213726871,
0.0009106006,
-0.0189564005,
-0.0143558541,
0.0246746354,
-0.0300017167,
0.0178275183,
0.0329542756,
-0.0209630951,
0.0088869426,
0.0424872749,
-0.0247151386,
-0.0456352495,
0.0189358201,
0.0326948278,
-0.0020809693,
-0.0347863697,
-0.0276689455,
-0.0481610708,
-0.0093279192,
-0.0103927413,
0.0889918804,
-0.0057011023,
-0.0550917052,
0.0316005312,
0.0551224649,
-0.100314796,
-0.0190952774,
-0.0306473449,
0.0052606119,
0.0229818895,
0.0042990004,
-0.0237119813,
-0.0194750205,
-0.0395624749,
-0.0398207568,
0.0255695432,
0.0200263895,
-0.0020472172,
-0.0093349712,
-0.0578238331,
0.0302606616,
0.0331657045,
-0.0077847308,
0.0242546313,
-0.0716786683,
0.0411762781,
-0.0214843582,
0.0121792424,
0.0388148166,
0.0114927841,
0.0644820035,
0.0157572124,
-0.0090672979,
0.0232561268,
0.061706014,
0.0543102734,
-0.0118035655,
-0.0525340959,
0.0422793068,
-0.0126882754,
-0.0275839008,
0.0238065328,
-0.0201336201,
-0.061664328,
0.0201847665,
-0.0280059949,
-0.0063001248,
0.0266708173,
-0.0322837643,
-0.0250616334,
0.0037664585,
-0.0067699291,
0.0255546756,
-0.0046955463,
0.0320450068,
-0.0489418954,
0.0397195555,
0.0034414083,
0.0494274311,
0.0142229693,
-0.021383699,
-0.0309396889,
-0.0251345038,
0.0419198908,
0.0047417358,
-0.0626820996,
0.0526669435,
-0.0032954225,
-0.0039759236,
0.0009732271,
0.0144998515,
-0.050465133,
-0.055716373,
-0.103098087,
-0.0334053524,
0.0002338695,
0.0074775261,
-0.0049061445,
0.0200184025,
-0.0186810996,
-0.0074705495,
0.0028126552,
0.0151578318,
-0.0164784081,
-0.0038900706,
0.0097255306,
-0.0029184027,
0.0161192659,
-0.0171899796,
-0.0020754533,
-0.0286759343,
0.0205231085,
0.0401104651,
-0.0810099393,
0.0107536288,
-0.0153234461,
-0.0078871846,
0.003248737,
0.0191650745,
-0.0682924166,
-0.0024754624,
-0.0299233943,
0.0076526226,
0.0304292478,
0.0346963704,
0.0919151902,
-0.0159293097,
0.0147672324,
-0.0121662812,
0.0301963836,
-0.0417000316,
0.0190865565,
-0.0185681619,
0.0039177574,
-0.0267886575,
0.0409048125,
0.0204700474,
0.0249254126,
-0.0339683481,
-0.06579905,
-0.0107491082,
-0.051020015,
-0.0381969325,
-0.0002453441,
-0.0288759694,
-0.0094174473,
0.0416816063,
-0.0082118241,
0.0347726382,
0.026989555,
-0.0249166377,
-0.0718172044,
0.0269884132,
-0.0095397895,
0.0528899208,
-0.0403478481,
0.0114540625,
-0.0170898158,
-0.022786038,
0.0049919505,
-0.0001085968,
-0.0152487066,
-0.0576352477,
-0.0259108208,
0.0126017397,
-0.0054423148,
-0.0001094049,
-0.0410053916,
0.0037744914,
-0.0387329422,
-0.0376638323,
-0.0118263122,
0.0154632479,
0.0114824176,
-0.0097033717,
0.0104805874,
0.0029494464,
-0.0496983789,
0.0140801156,
-0.0137597518,
0.0439735577,
0.0410181768,
0.0156382397,
-0.0359743685,
0.0362489857,
-0.0370159186,
-0.0317049995,
0.0254371222,
-0.0055842991,
0.0004579748,
0.0035617517,
-0.0082468148,
0.0267005768,
0.004533947,
0.0145119466,
-0.0399430431,
0.008850161,
0.0089256251,
0.0182343964,
0.0954670087,
0.0345212631,
-0.0493788533,
-0.0138625782,
-0.0587843917,
-0.0185161997,
-0.0013915374,
0.0261251107,
-0.0486889482,
-0.0431062318,
-0.0144711239,
0.0200049598,
0.0168894548,
-0.0091457628,
0.0276494808,
-0.0773407668,
0.008449127,
-0.0179385189,
-0.0129009094,
-0.0169017073,
-0.0091648446,
-0.0098413564,
-0.021485826,
-0.0067115286,
-0.0293755122,
0.0421685763,
-0.0189386476,
0.0636899471,
0.013806656,
-0.0515265726,
0.0452421717,
-0.0072378442,
0.021143591,
0.001963937,
0.0743508562,
-0.0505317561,
-0.0132642705,
0.0039649587,
-0.0015201441,
-0.0296353269,
-0.0164189953,
0.0486222357,
-0.0507782176,
-0.0399108753,
-0.0196447838,
-0.0179787744,
-0.0471179336,
0.0215054043,
-0.0245902613,
0.0403231159,
-0.0109055825,
-0.0333302356,
-0.0343097039,
-0.0119386967,
0.0161197484,
0.0170792136,
-0.0114309844,
-0.075499557,
0.0047900113,
-0.0037580358,
0.0272072852,
-0.0227903668,
-0.0387498587,
0.0202436391,
-0.0630001873,
-0.0870522633,
-0.0359102041,
-0.0476494841,
0.0143048856,
0.0412702151,
-0.0289132092,
-0.0362855271,
0.0442460328,
0.0261106957,
-0.0359817259,
-0.0096548498,
0.0261779968,
0.0061142137,
-0.0379561633,
-0.0270962957,
0.0653849766,
0.0010702559,
-0.0117319282,
-0.0392842367,
0.0051368079,
0.0006011238,
0.0685238838,
0.0344994552,
0.0067268,
-0.0312670171,
-0.0179076996,
-0.0460471883,
0.0106131835,
0.0779815465,
-0.001481996,
-0.0017652096,
0.048443079,
0.0445922352,
-0.0284224264,
-0.008430725,
-0.0220344588,
0.0609467551,
-0.0150597822,
-0.0199656226,
0.0065520485,
-0.0420806855,
0.0049487152,
0.023235321,
0.0524345636,
-0.0243732668,
-0.0417611301,
-0.0284106787,
-0.0351857841,
0.0206447653,
-0.0202769954,
-0.020805262,
-0.0201348979,
0.0255711395,
0.0062378417,
-0.0342232697,
-0.0280531142,
0.0174132753,
-0.0256633144,
0.0318966694,
0.0883267373,
0.0635074526,
0.0210906789,
-0.0063404962,
0.02030617,
-0.0105840638,
-0.027042482,
0.037910495,
-0.0002181804,
-0.0322144479,
0.0477456003,
0.0060492987,
-0.0172285512,
0.0404528864,
0.0665319264,
0.0314392112,
0.0950528905,
-0.0523709916,
-0.0255115442,
0.035819035,
-0.0070085642,
0.080222398,
-0.0180193782,
0.0161944665,
-0.0138620296,
0.0233531855,
-0.050638888,
-0.0257218517,
0.0397486538,
-0.0224891473,
-0.020821115,
-0.0079772836,
0.0150227025,
-0.0952553749,
0.0310896244,
0.0116340043,
-0.0028143537,
-0.0471070632,
-0.0087562893,
0.0439292639,
-0.0044031707,
0.0404077396,
0.0308707878,
-0.0671624243,
-0.0186745636,
0.0795590132,
-0.0722560585,
0.0208853874,
0.0062869419,
0.0353458971,
0.0421908945,
0.0005308449,
0.0586754903,
-0.065885976,
-0.0003115514,
-0.0273318104,
0.010640135,
0.0154370656,
-6.252195843e-33,
-0.014156566,
-0.0084723243,
-0.0808959901,
-0.0164867099,
-0.0317937769,
-0.0048824335,
0.0066832993,
0.0197437871,
-0.0029133705,
0.037825983,
-0.0102921519,
0.0080962023,
0.0182283167,
0.0265487172,
0.0488259532,
-0.0466521643,
0.0035098575,
0.011183857,
0.0193678625,
0.0038770018,
0.0867509171,
0.0667435601,
0.0930565,
-0.1156276688,
0.0127929561,
-0.018981684,
-0.0716200322,
-0.002644879,
0.0611778386,
0.059148483,
-0.008351217,
0.0578480735,
0.0208464582,
0.0133596193,
0.0274335667,
0.0301371552,
-0.0107175158,
-0.0008166161,
-0.0254081599,
0.0758916512,
-0.0292943623,
-0.0056061139,
0.0222476106,
0.0217296667,
-0.015256376,
0.0295340568,
0.0295244344,
-0.0182591565,
0.0109737795,
-0.0707975924,
-0.0352978781,
0.0318694897,
-0.0120896157,
0.0023404616,
0.0593931973,
0.0692082047,
0.0153221497,
0.0204994399,
-0.0634370521,
0.0088160755,
-0.0189573579,
-0.0145303523,
0.0242851805,
0.0168417953,
0.0051818364,
0.05080029,
0.035932295,
-0.0285172109,
0.0348981358,
0.0305239055,
0.0270527788,
0.0391722657,
-0.0066099642,
0.070822157,
0.0120166689,
-0.0433433391,
-0.0023689501,
0.0162008591,
0.0805211887,
-0.0174920708,
0.0576136,
0.0306360424,
-0.0326153748,
-0.0124290418,
0.05220728,
-0.0206831284,
-0.0094182706,
-0.0099710412,
0.025221616,
-0.0331146196,
-0.0189956035,
0.0216798931,
0.0089204405,
-0.0177044757,
0.0029277967,
0.0109469965,
-0.0606310256,
0.1057833433,
-0.0016746762,
0.0095051192,
-0.0077992231,
-0.0478026979,
-0.0031284515,
0.0380509757,
0.0212982967,
0.0018805302,
0.0395848528,
0.015104265,
-0.0619762428,
0.0013013483,
-0.0098087266,
-0.0030636534,
-0.016384583,
0.0365398154,
-0.0416829363,
-0.0005821498,
-0.0334338024,
0.0372195654,
0.0322413519,
0.0761251673,
0.0068219784,
-0.0237010941,
0.008127653,
-0.010215329,
-0.0259867925,
-0.018938629,
0.0011847428,
-0.0230591819,
0.0008731975,
-0.0312395357,
0.0130232992,
-0.013319077,
2.987e-7,
0.0285564009,
0.0704226568,
0.0053567891,
-0.0950516909,
0.0084778555,
0.0747678876,
-0.0043125334,
0.01381109,
0.0166007988,
0.0094725396,
0.0213041529,
-0.0167111233,
0.011133437,
0.0250640344,
-0.123533234,
-0.0040560514,
-0.0218631998,
-0.0197930839,
-0.0082799597,
0.0767506212,
0.1134073809,
0.096379146,
0.0491038114,
-0.0160662942,
-0.0191715956,
0.0815553665,
0.0466229208,
-0.0229249075,
0.0063582249,
0.0276511945,
-0.0407988653,
0.0048433696,
-0.017397007,
-0.0255545229,
0.008519874,
-0.0177909918,
0.0540722571,
0.0537303947,
-0.0225562323,
-0.0238754153,
0.0628054738,
0.0478408635,
-0.0139073934,
0.0363271162,
0.0354530402,
-0.0340467133,
-0.0832054466,
-0.0265687667,
-0.0198737774,
0.0142715955,
0.0311682243,
-0.0051700417,
-0.044096373,
0.0104678208,
-0.0110086575,
-0.0535691604,
-0.0761886761,
-0.0655206889,
0.0367451608,
0.0117142275,
-0.0238166619,
-0.0150896991,
0.0210965835,
0.0450848266,
0.055772163,
-0.0466747433,
0.0209986884,
2.000864036e-34,
0.018380899,
-0.0030915984,
0.0123888077,
0.0394227952,
0.0059501659,
0.0066809198,
-0.0296703652,
-0.0236006156,
-0.0028580886,
-0.0296919048,
0.0218196418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15656v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15656v1 | Conversational Feedback in Scripted versus Spontaneous Dialogues: A Comparative Analysis | 2023-09-27T13:45:38 | 2023-09-27T13:45:38 | Ildikó Pilán, Laurent Prévot, Hendrik Buschmeier, Pierre Lison | cs.CL | cs.CL | Scripted dialogues such as movie and TV subtitles constitute a widespread
source of training data for conversational NLP models. However, the linguistic
characteristics of those dialogues are notably different from those observed in
corpora of spontaneous interactions. This difference is particularly marked for
communicative feedback and grounding phenomena such as backchannels,
acknowledgments, or clarification requests. Such signals are known to
constitute a key part of the conversation flow and are used by the dialogue
participants to provide feedback to one another on their perception of the
ongoing interaction. This paper presents a quantitative analysis of such
communicative feedback phenomena in both subtitles and spontaneous
conversations. Based on dialogue data in English, French, German, Hungarian,
Italian, Japanese, Norwegian and Chinese, we extract both lexical statistics
and classification outputs obtained with a neural dialogue act tagger. Two main
findings of this empirical study are that (1) conversational feedback is
markedly less frequent in subtitles than in spontaneous dialogues and (2)
subtitles contain a higher proportion of negative feedback. Furthermore, we
show that dialogue responses generated by large language models also follow the
same underlying trends and include comparatively few occurrences of
communicative feedback, except when those models are explicitly fine-tuned on
spontaneous dialogues. | [
0.0952104032,
0.0195861403,
-0.024190288,
0.0291184131,
-0.0183393806,
0.0092577366,
-0.0102151427,
0.0181104653,
0.0240945145,
-0.0649052188,
-0.0597364195,
-0.0542364195,
0.0166708119,
0.0607878752,
0.0139841391,
-0.0459524654,
0.0255987998,
-0.0193444099,
0.0431257673,
-0.0050339545,
0.0200466774,
-0.0033323946,
-0.0230758544,
0.053573817,
-0.0329957828,
-0.0027619679,
-0.0396166891,
-0.0043434226,
-0.0032280334,
0.009658413,
0.0338461548,
0.051975619,
0.011889834,
0.0391306318,
0.0000016457,
-0.0331910811,
0.0661534965,
-0.0553978868,
-0.0083013847,
0.031628903,
0.0289589819,
0.0132850464,
-0.0249331929,
0.0222829171,
-0.0383649617,
-0.0078628194,
0.0357304923,
0.0555901602,
0.0571146347,
0.0531097092,
-0.0275842398,
-0.0209548026,
0.0208234061,
-0.0226981379,
-0.007353167,
-0.0131322667,
-0.0017018,
0.0513701215,
0.0068549146,
0.0182665903,
-0.0329972021,
0.0267044511,
-0.0101007735,
-0.0888790414,
0.016294267,
0.0385684632,
-0.0394758955,
-0.0329919346,
-0.0162773486,
0.0868312046,
0.0521515682,
-0.0046773832,
-0.0254509319,
-0.0203945991,
0.0187356714,
-0.0263737794,
-0.0573457889,
0.0233602617,
0.0423817895,
-0.0086922953,
0.011451751,
0.025803702,
0.0068177469,
-0.0151431076,
0.0244056731,
0.0484459102,
-0.0016999523,
-0.0186962765,
-0.0097467499,
-0.000067024,
-0.0126863802,
-0.1053508744,
-0.0072998507,
0.0085252766,
-0.0167215671,
-0.0072182859,
-0.0131478449,
0.0310104843,
-0.0245824195,
-0.0641654283,
0.0069327326,
0.0195347294,
-0.0294039622,
0.0274247546,
0.0280036628,
0.0595542975,
-0.0090586422,
0.0418049581,
-0.0113340039,
0.0058127032,
-0.0580758415,
-0.0097456574,
-0.0259041023,
0.0476872846,
-0.0458740667,
-0.040363051,
-0.0200037975,
0.0238463134,
-0.0260190647,
0.014933113,
-0.0130908107,
0.0298396219,
0.0044952463,
0.0194186773,
-0.0658129305,
0.0414410383,
-0.0308872089,
-0.003269796,
0.009410983,
-0.0621510148,
-0.0050593233,
0.0439454131,
-0.0126713812,
-0.0088548046,
-0.006590839,
0.0190071426,
-0.0129870307,
-0.0300751701,
0.0140191866,
0.0086691193,
-0.059195511,
-0.0425397865,
-0.0230451804,
-0.001239424,
0.0442872345,
-0.0136358067,
-0.0146745136,
0.0100903818,
0.0194878578,
-0.0141826142,
-0.0189904403,
0.0451337919,
0.0063906941,
0.0269579571,
0.0126950005,
-0.0067982096,
0.004623278,
0.037856929,
0.0458417833,
0.0006184927,
0.0734023824,
-0.003414284,
0.0447490513,
0.0336701907,
-0.0000853689,
0.0009849981,
-0.0146579463,
-0.0097503606,
-0.0060403738,
0.027087763,
0.0427938886,
0.0260067619,
-0.0417659916,
-0.0216260329,
0.0469512232,
0.0719487146,
-0.0371270888,
0.0002021626,
0.0262702107,
0.0502355397,
0.000055838,
0.056411624,
-0.0155861489,
0.0276049543,
0.0058855345,
-0.0210043136,
-0.0044439202,
-0.0686556846,
-0.0439702533,
-0.0630831048,
-0.0105290543,
-0.0041870843,
0.0438932218,
-0.0058242204,
0.0295023117,
0.0261567403,
-0.0316209383,
0.0247507989,
0.0270553399,
-0.04641781,
0.0083424337,
-0.044567138,
0.0048757242,
0.0583521165,
0.0434436053,
0.0258899163,
-0.0225333013,
-0.0319166034,
0.0024248192,
0.0657368675,
0.0602493696,
-0.058883287,
0.0313622914,
-0.0359368026,
0.0271306355,
-0.0157142188,
0.0010883501,
0.0517067946,
-0.0434658155,
-0.031447392,
-0.0200036094,
0.039227996,
-0.0443099812,
-0.0106787644,
-0.0235292409,
-0.0191865712,
0.0226295814,
-0.0238392781,
0.0404769853,
0.0466273837,
-0.0289811362,
-0.0238054395,
0.0330357365,
0.0013352217,
-0.0272361897,
0.0792432129,
-0.0220504645,
-0.0664546043,
-0.0009068203,
0.0365996137,
-0.0016753135,
0.0281013958,
-0.0034839665,
-0.0643918887,
0.0387709886,
-0.0269453023,
0.0542824902,
-0.0496406928,
0.0266263206,
0.0059133,
0.0047755125,
-0.0170820579,
-0.0202892292,
-0.0068954742,
0.0139011173,
0.0164756142,
0.0433630794,
0.0389493071,
-0.027873788,
-0.0227362383,
0.0723607913,
-0.0038861602,
-0.019055292,
0.0562298968,
-0.0102570625,
-0.0252609421,
-0.008626353,
-0.1084345281,
-0.0027708043,
-0.0140514327,
0.0125152702,
0.0262516402,
0.0342028365,
0.0069006449,
-0.0216121338,
-0.046209529,
-0.0002200364,
0.0336393788,
-0.0040909653,
0.0482308008,
0.0484229326,
-0.0183869042,
-0.0427773111,
0.0129606863,
-0.012594657,
0.0413992777,
0.0117149334,
-0.0231954176,
-0.040810369,
-0.0024183092,
-0.0032586469,
0.0533690676,
-0.0476093963,
-0.0962905958,
0.0186569933,
0.0249115191,
-0.0102243219,
0.0582181178,
0.01894252,
0.0396758243,
0.002917883,
-0.0151476059,
-0.0663045123,
0.0308543816,
-0.0237450916,
-0.0520336665,
-0.0596489385,
-0.0213186815,
0.0184001606,
0.0853752345,
0.0332108848,
0.0306591094,
-0.0744066313,
-0.0295798611,
0.0010793313,
-0.0370974168,
-0.0014734298,
-0.0372541398,
-0.0410893038,
0.0780378059,
0.0164797232,
-0.0312776789,
0.0465552807,
-0.0314615443,
-0.0651463419,
-0.0500074513,
-0.0202534441,
-0.0123842927,
0.0542460456,
-0.0218154322,
0.0137107894,
0.0228422303,
-0.0739096552,
-0.0071925283,
-0.0503846668,
0.0186785664,
-0.000473756,
0.0162367597,
0.0038440134,
-0.00612358,
0.0154532883,
-0.0152426008,
-0.0577415377,
-0.0446336754,
-0.0101982169,
0.013858703,
0.026668787,
-0.0521433093,
0.004991231,
0.0388809144,
-0.0070326086,
0.0267234966,
-0.0243148375,
0.0069076777,
-0.0081285732,
0.0555471629,
0.0345161147,
-0.0090478202,
-0.0374391563,
0.0036085905,
0.0592964701,
0.0248347558,
0.0084762834,
0.0385144986,
-0.0285557136,
-0.019594213,
0.0346831679,
0.0046163867,
-0.0207453892,
-0.0385393612,
0.057995107,
-0.0161937568,
-0.0167322084,
0.1390648633,
0.0260835197,
-0.0702325925,
-0.0055110739,
-0.0139965601,
0.0013077125,
0.0350668617,
0.0037053598,
-0.0597272739,
-0.0068591698,
-0.0089534894,
-0.0048577385,
-0.016264258,
-0.0031676535,
0.0053966646,
-0.1235975474,
0.0476495996,
0.0055136331,
-0.0006389223,
-0.01123414,
0.0047026328,
-0.0083088707,
0.0018837007,
0.00565639,
-0.0353972279,
0.0104440497,
-0.0202716552,
0.024770949,
-0.0349839441,
-0.0435228832,
0.040512722,
-0.0122491335,
0.0950423852,
0.0554197095,
0.0630295724,
-0.0057729743,
0.0114470618,
0.0751013011,
-0.0048380103,
0.0168276057,
-0.0145533597,
0.0534917042,
-0.0363314301,
-0.0129780937,
-0.0169607997,
-0.0196816772,
-0.0010120214,
-0.000010559,
0.0119774761,
0.0190845598,
-0.050726857,
-0.0007483541,
-0.0215036832,
0.0790403038,
0.0107883168,
0.0584108979,
0.0207919497,
-0.0613213032,
0.0072502843,
0.0183619522,
0.0083079971,
-0.0137924347,
-0.0080839405,
-0.0069985446,
0.0232349075,
-0.0187346898,
-0.0697268695,
-0.0732283145,
-0.0170456413,
-0.0155057311,
0.0051439479,
-0.006811752,
0.0057481392,
-0.01146637,
0.0327173807,
0.0046293442,
0.0205681734,
-0.0103224032,
-0.0257876497,
-0.0424000472,
0.0655308589,
-0.0234438833,
-0.014458687,
0.0091061704,
-0.0715869144,
-0.0985919982,
-0.0457901843,
0.0396474861,
0.0292405356,
0.0891270787,
-0.0145683205,
-0.0339776278,
-0.0656199455,
-0.0246443823,
-0.0124331992,
0.0231080353,
0.0445097499,
0.0439377241,
-0.0456461981,
0.0159481708,
0.0003828202,
0.0133536942,
-0.0129112359,
0.0400269181,
-0.0390376113,
-0.0931128189,
-0.0125606144,
-0.0078744907,
0.0369604491,
-0.0084667113,
0.0107023222,
-0.0345451981,
0.0045638788,
-0.0261376072,
0.0144868745,
-0.0573954768,
-0.0003702378,
0.0216114596,
-0.0272864662,
-0.0303534567,
-0.0159197543,
-0.1127896383,
0.04327273,
-0.0124094216,
-0.0049337787,
0.0232995432,
-0.0197038706,
-0.010354382,
0.0339911692,
-0.0258065853,
0.0187866371,
0.043203827,
0.015249664,
0.0140368985,
0.1021848544,
0.0235890858,
-0.0479983874,
0.054148484,
0.0448844284,
-0.063297905,
-0.0050916867,
0.0181230791,
0.0327111185,
0.0279557761,
-0.0039816629,
0.0452249795,
-0.025703758,
0.021940846,
-0.0024499753,
0.0713620782,
-0.0102524767,
-0.0453763418,
0.0245280154,
0.0036142115,
-0.0308641922,
0.055006586,
0.0384606719,
-0.0035807495,
0.0054170173,
0.0219679438,
0.0162079018,
-0.0360437557,
-0.0018116405,
0.0266764127,
0.0081824968,
-0.0254671499,
0.0591838844,
-0.0466403216,
-0.0469504595,
0.0013301658,
-0.0209462382,
0.0310534332,
-0.0390323475,
0.0182971731,
0.0424914174,
0.0147929545,
0.0005288657,
-0.0473524258,
0.0086007603,
-0.0474752374,
0.0057468275,
-0.060580723,
-5.4303846e-33,
-0.0334706008,
-0.0229930896,
-0.0311302356,
0.0814271569,
-0.0729059801,
-0.0248239599,
-0.046535708,
0.0126450425,
-0.0104333833,
0.0245953593,
-0.0076348488,
0.0469611622,
0.0094042094,
-0.0025115104,
0.0213036221,
-0.0439421088,
0.0713714734,
-0.0163517129,
-0.0361452922,
0.0541330315,
0.021708142,
0.0095386114,
0.0729094744,
-0.0859335065,
0.0481844135,
-0.0494939424,
-0.0389012359,
0.0277984329,
0.0329919979,
0.0516901761,
-0.017904602,
0.072626926,
0.0099735111,
-0.0120034628,
0.0313648917,
0.0258276463,
-0.0303822607,
-0.0193727966,
0.0396444909,
0.0537403934,
-0.0342240706,
-0.0058915587,
-0.015736809,
-0.0257609896,
-0.0488629937,
0.0233563557,
0.0117219724,
0.0025110603,
-0.0031556603,
0.0060235923,
-0.0424703173,
-0.0187816266,
-0.0205795951,
-0.0584649593,
0.0069752126,
0.0738513693,
0.0084933797,
-0.0505721457,
-0.0423523821,
0.0371188298,
0.0102209691,
0.0214509051,
0.0199352577,
0.0040433649,
0.0202176236,
0.0570288673,
0.0359094702,
0.0401501022,
0.0188410692,
-0.0258671045,
0.0178053863,
-0.0057974863,
0.0063541695,
0.0450376086,
-0.0059049786,
-0.0304201785,
-0.0202403944,
-0.019123381,
0.0258696638,
0.0477410927,
0.0128038777,
-0.0199055187,
-0.0363195501,
-0.0289932359,
-0.0265945792,
-0.0591831021,
0.0033116601,
-0.0618442371,
0.0261097997,
0.0193797499,
0.0408364758,
-0.01847063,
0.0424844213,
-0.0590846352,
0.0096360389,
0.0041411952,
-0.0334465168,
0.0323296003,
-0.0002199627,
0.0085901599,
-0.0090764379,
-0.0095911147,
0.0059065414,
0.0240253098,
0.0324512608,
0.0123642543,
-0.0065539987,
0.0334336869,
-0.0177738275,
-0.0212233569,
-0.0046148207,
0.047991842,
-0.0516501069,
0.0539263859,
-0.026339544,
0.0288449377,
-0.0563978069,
0.0875647292,
-0.024013482,
0.0267280638,
-0.0360603556,
-0.0274840295,
0.0218299385,
0.0106003489,
-0.0730250701,
-0.0049403436,
0.00407551,
0.016243225,
0.0189457927,
-0.0204803813,
-0.0396967046,
-0.0454182774,
2.421e-7,
-0.0262938533,
0.0553490072,
0.0272148848,
0.0062740515,
0.0254396945,
0.0573056713,
-0.022496419,
0.0239334721,
0.0531285107,
-0.0552089699,
-0.0040060217,
-0.0237663016,
0.0316077694,
-0.0182425156,
-0.0990246683,
-0.0110398764,
-0.083043687,
-0.0435979292,
0.0058943625,
-0.014665965,
0.0485951491,
0.0537712835,
0.0161707886,
0.0016800081,
-0.013940542,
-0.017059369,
0.0472207852,
-0.03253562,
-0.0789550543,
0.0226071496,
0.042827744,
-0.0051179328,
-0.003908183,
0.0342092328,
-0.004393403,
0.0274810437,
0.0045723538,
0.0579317957,
-0.0407776348,
-0.0456140153,
-0.0331244096,
0.0101268115,
0.0046727955,
-0.0383478031,
0.0197568815,
-0.035018526,
-0.0369438566,
-0.0451530255,
0.0192100927,
-0.0145216249,
0.0528325178,
-0.0409928598,
-0.0119602438,
0.0208558161,
0.0123335598,
0.0286475029,
-0.0099115623,
-0.0637547001,
-0.0015819779,
-0.0091307834,
-0.0300216302,
-0.0503450558,
0.0118195815,
-0.0014655825,
-0.0044930424,
-0.022245314,
0.010859739,
1.759816062e-34,
0.0576659814,
0.0282432344,
0.0129338382,
0.0642118603,
0.0350299142,
0.0039984835,
0.0076060663,
0.0072810352,
0.0560331605,
-0.0316404104,
-0.0255822614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15649v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15649v2 | Generative Speech Recognition Error Correction with Large Language Models and Task-Activating Prompting | 2023-09-27T13:36:03 | 2023-10-10T09:10:58 | Chao-Han Huck Yang, Yile Gu, Yi-Chieh Liu, Shalini Ghosh, Ivan Bulyko, Andreas Stolcke | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | We explore the ability of large language models (LLMs) to act as speech
recognition post-processors that perform rescoring and error correction. Our
first focus is on instruction prompting to let LLMs perform these task without
fine-tuning, for which we evaluate different prompting schemes, both zero- and
few-shot in-context learning, and a novel task activation prompting method that
combines causal instructions and demonstration to increase its context windows.
Next, we show that rescoring only by in-context learning with frozen LLMs
achieves results that are competitive with rescoring by domain-tuned LMs, using
a pretrained first-pass recognition system and rescoring output on two
out-of-domain tasks (ATIS and WSJ). By combining prompting techniques with
fine-tuning we achieve error rates below the N-best oracle level, showcasing
the generalization power of the LLMs. | [
-0.0271054078,
0.0472850427,
0.0169199184,
0.0360158831,
-0.0071209315,
0.0208725389,
0.0112170884,
-0.0061684693,
0.0211945362,
-0.0408585295,
-0.0477320775,
-0.0603053272,
0.0369641855,
-0.0203926731,
0.033234518,
-0.0127014369,
0.0393183306,
-0.0692740008,
0.0035124638,
-0.0199670121,
-0.0335209221,
0.0001309947,
-0.0215190351,
0.0317108259,
0.0037822884,
-0.0167919304,
0.005344281,
0.0206292123,
0.0120178554,
-0.0216595214,
-0.014056202,
0.0060714008,
0.0402233526,
0.0349993221,
0.0000019579,
-0.0332361832,
0.0114034824,
0.0099873133,
-0.067174077,
0.0196966864,
0.0328681245,
0.0129050352,
-0.0449143425,
0.0281499475,
0.0059050745,
-0.040835131,
0.0635283068,
0.0195178725,
0.0186097287,
0.0729136318,
0.0064540221,
-0.0440833829,
0.0302981082,
-0.0099624284,
-0.0199201778,
-0.0495884344,
0.026076287,
-0.0115261609,
0.0028967266,
-0.0235628914,
-0.0077640712,
0.0397047326,
0.0010823295,
-0.0104417512,
-0.033510901,
0.0071878876,
0.0142222084,
0.0028488208,
-0.0407553315,
0.0420186408,
-0.0052882377,
-0.028641047,
-0.0117326435,
0.0045176782,
-0.0059836223,
-0.0213513523,
0.0020412316,
0.0325089581,
0.0329347961,
0.0038581041,
0.0228825584,
-0.0126354918,
0.053623002,
0.0045847716,
-0.0307033192,
0.0114834467,
0.0220557023,
-0.0265275668,
-0.0150221698,
0.0090511478,
-0.0279727206,
-0.0304817706,
-0.006714989,
0.0214597788,
-0.089143008,
0.0167165231,
-0.0453571603,
-0.0258456059,
-0.0388633981,
0.0155505734,
0.0520345122,
0.0382857136,
-0.0651241317,
0.0181339867,
-0.0193135887,
0.0795131177,
0.0050942311,
0.0203523766,
-0.0205801241,
-0.0127315065,
-0.0140199158,
0.007435679,
-0.0390425809,
0.0022745172,
-0.0472064465,
0.0038538936,
-0.0421673432,
0.0268645324,
-0.0074040946,
0.0348286219,
0.0079010446,
-0.0206792485,
-0.069097057,
-0.0457625762,
-0.0050911787,
0.0256405286,
0.0516777597,
0.0449503027,
0.0169812869,
-0.0642572567,
-0.033872474,
-0.0090598734,
0.0283062942,
0.0000196755,
0.0258144587,
0.0595998913,
0.0005383602,
-0.0633687824,
-0.0639727563,
0.0286386274,
-0.0095574539,
-0.0736620948,
-0.0205122698,
-0.0361666344,
0.0038575693,
0.0152466884,
0.0256953705,
-0.0523776449,
0.0095770946,
-0.0200587809,
-0.0101644946,
0.0945043862,
0.0284001417,
0.0047282642,
0.0163974278,
-0.0289979652,
0.032035131,
0.0756717697,
0.0400514491,
-0.0254113637,
0.0070589921,
-0.0017567399,
0.0380296521,
0.0520606749,
0.001380513,
0.0340072662,
-0.0393298008,
-0.0243299101,
0.0650269166,
0.0067660604,
0.0710172281,
0.0467595868,
-0.033870887,
0.0358218104,
0.0620380901,
0.0359409899,
0.0000779161,
-0.0042635142,
0.0424894616,
-0.0272676051,
-0.0167869423,
-0.0036089232,
-0.0328232944,
-0.0117096975,
-0.0148352301,
0.035771396,
0.0576515682,
0.0263348259,
-0.0515765734,
-0.0201392937,
-0.0016429918,
-0.0204025563,
-0.04141137,
0.0780747309,
0.0724961907,
0.0120983869,
-0.086307466,
-0.0196734834,
0.0073664025,
-0.0550662503,
0.0167382993,
-0.0699109435,
-0.0083783083,
0.0833687633,
0.0519973822,
-0.0334080234,
0.0014934395,
-0.0260497183,
-0.0103252074,
0.0256011263,
0.0250445884,
-0.0099483794,
0.020706255,
-0.0613642745,
0.0053699901,
0.0379894301,
-0.0033973246,
0.0477041267,
-0.0072745956,
-0.0028609652,
0.0148965372,
0.0004454638,
-0.0201799069,
-0.0061646304,
-0.0386938713,
-0.0490973629,
0.0252928603,
0.0163360536,
0.0485883355,
0.0269167796,
-0.0513951704,
-0.0049967398,
0.0110115185,
-0.0206403267,
0.0218449049,
0.0113853868,
-0.0691611618,
-0.0589298718,
0.0296113342,
0.0346251801,
-0.0049549793,
-0.0015243111,
-0.0165407974,
-0.0785272792,
-0.0039645522,
-0.011771176,
0.0454073995,
-0.0746345297,
0.0662434101,
0.0244111493,
-0.017982902,
-0.0197628587,
0.0066783228,
0.0047632544,
0.0027866571,
0.0728308856,
0.0164508894,
-0.0576306581,
-0.0672109351,
-0.0328537747,
0.024779316,
0.0149132656,
0.0262476634,
-0.0365921035,
-0.0129333893,
0.0130020604,
-0.0017480652,
-0.076487191,
0.0005854978,
-0.0486167632,
-0.0025080673,
-0.0007816773,
0.0282029901,
-0.0079960879,
-0.0407434739,
-0.0009114786,
-0.0271758828,
0.0136001036,
0.010902009,
-0.0255880095,
-0.0006182028,
-0.0319716074,
-0.0078782085,
0.0193738118,
0.034887135,
0.0204191823,
-0.0348711573,
-0.0022943954,
-0.1172583178,
0.0720007271,
0.0360596702,
0.0615889877,
-0.0020666397,
-0.0223811734,
-0.017174311,
-0.0149566159,
0.0707184076,
0.0525586568,
-0.0286894199,
-0.0058568302,
0.0238487944,
-0.0229035355,
-0.0514863431,
0.0130605204,
-0.0041679163,
-0.0557955094,
-0.0232257489,
0.0290515386,
-0.0064705806,
0.0458008721,
0.0015572888,
0.0134166824,
-0.0329805166,
-0.0337041132,
-0.0093561634,
-0.0325010456,
-0.029048305,
-0.0462733805,
-0.0429407395,
0.010066539,
-0.0109590702,
-0.039883893,
0.0395396948,
-0.0572408848,
-0.016184736,
-0.0359142311,
-0.0000279808,
0.0185180902,
0.0146138417,
-0.0064748386,
-0.0094015319,
0.0123232184,
-0.0644932538,
-0.0400169864,
0.0049443427,
-0.0094724633,
-0.05087265,
0.0503393263,
-0.0637572855,
0.0326403826,
-0.0236797091,
-0.0560076348,
-0.0448862165,
-0.0031859924,
-0.0345242247,
0.0043947399,
0.0288083889,
-0.0381762199,
-0.0066280379,
0.0367073566,
0.0329638347,
0.0711694285,
0.0169192515,
0.0065908055,
-0.03348203,
0.0232463107,
0.0094488552,
0.0520229638,
0.0098535931,
-0.0188466925,
0.0466454178,
-0.02257316,
0.0845572129,
-0.0208297577,
-0.0495482683,
0.0021822613,
0.0787607655,
-0.0066232337,
-0.0095942691,
0.0525162928,
0.0692649782,
-0.0723559484,
-0.0195805524,
0.0856241137,
-0.0061589773,
-0.0599420182,
-0.042627573,
0.0384424068,
-0.0240246821,
0.0171970557,
0.0099447342,
-0.0731583536,
-0.0217159893,
0.0669832751,
0.018894339,
-0.0090157343,
0.0252436642,
-0.0358891226,
-0.1503306776,
0.0955061466,
0.0514172204,
-0.0167775713,
-0.0511457883,
-0.0225376207,
0.0075821108,
0.0122337434,
0.0421444736,
0.041476842,
-0.0017948431,
-0.0459625386,
0.0430851169,
0.0124414628,
-0.0864026546,
-0.0023278971,
-0.0101621384,
0.0720617995,
0.1134612337,
-0.0091342172,
0.0294996463,
-0.029695373,
0.0291570667,
-0.0219773445,
0.0322400853,
0.0099328775,
0.0112943212,
0.0084140217,
-0.0362366103,
0.023770744,
0.0464545339,
-0.0051092119,
-0.0077808928,
-0.0064256755,
0.0608234406,
-0.0548292696,
0.0412711278,
0.031112209,
-0.0197194126,
0.018879896,
0.0248194356,
0.0207207445,
-0.0223017801,
-0.0252697319,
-0.0133604342,
0.0072454154,
-0.0444422178,
0.0094074598,
0.0013572921,
-0.0339093357,
-0.0230852328,
-0.0213713516,
-0.0047866721,
0.0331272371,
0.0534670837,
0.016290592,
-0.0106454454,
-0.0183919277,
0.03806578,
-0.0103402911,
-0.0207139272,
-0.064543575,
0.0330793709,
-0.1004837379,
-0.0015237234,
0.0464013666,
-0.0405927561,
-0.0055751568,
0.0100520402,
-0.0520434342,
-0.0605111271,
0.0107665891,
0.0202521719,
0.0183348488,
0.0772887245,
-0.0137170712,
-0.0631288514,
0.0655735135,
0.0631789714,
-0.0431151651,
0.0455676652,
0.0322360732,
-0.0024052269,
-0.0234271195,
0.0175215825,
-0.0448443294,
0.0167451911,
0.0197221488,
0.018405458,
0.0119435666,
-0.0587524213,
0.0042112828,
0.020627372,
0.0777426958,
-0.0259197857,
0.0206021685,
-0.0345528685,
0.0474957004,
-0.0109119406,
0.0139160883,
-0.0244215392,
0.0022041304,
0.0164862256,
-0.0135422498,
-0.0051708911,
0.0144269941,
-0.0060428847,
0.0141173135,
-0.0220329054,
0.017722588,
-0.000064994,
0.0090867626,
0.0451652743,
-0.0051925117,
-0.0254762005,
0.0076773539,
0.0606216304,
0.0212433375,
-0.0186159629,
0.0468301624,
0.0037976056,
0.023719728,
-0.0557562374,
0.0075238743,
-0.0646045059,
-0.0491285287,
-0.0390512906,
0.0625505075,
0.1002325639,
0.011446638,
0.0399094634,
-0.0306268334,
-0.0065509514,
-0.0451148115,
0.0328654088,
0.025602242,
-0.0060929689,
0.0116082802,
0.0124079213,
-0.0056207189,
0.0360424519,
0.0600849614,
-0.0125702405,
0.0502894036,
-0.0176332276,
0.022747457,
-0.0324559063,
-0.0749114528,
-0.0151387453,
-0.0488070101,
-0.027829133,
-0.0019222943,
-0.0076995795,
-0.0715836585,
-0.0056314734,
0.0002252506,
0.0192794017,
-0.0539504737,
0.0003225651,
0.0013696317,
-0.0273904875,
0.0104058636,
-0.016158713,
-0.0221088324,
0.0357738733,
-0.0394123159,
-0.0041238344,
-6.079364011e-33,
-0.0386023149,
0.0197419412,
0.0381006673,
-0.0329133123,
-0.0150612639,
0.0011775994,
-0.0199248809,
-0.0058652987,
0.033490397,
-0.0149127822,
-0.0497475788,
-0.0002392866,
0.0524514131,
0.0233426616,
-0.0055078338,
0.0073554679,
0.1331840605,
-0.0317370072,
0.0074106059,
0.0126217324,
0.0324763283,
0.0427417308,
0.0208714381,
-0.0384770744,
0.0160367601,
0.0025700568,
-0.0179741699,
-0.0163894575,
0.0493763722,
0.0056377198,
0.0031012166,
0.0246643946,
-0.0096520027,
-0.0479761474,
-0.0331057906,
0.0272786338,
-0.0961287394,
0.0108175939,
0.0076999376,
0.0335418992,
-0.0334258266,
-0.0316484272,
0.0147636058,
0.0224749632,
-0.046868775,
-0.0030234768,
-0.0144538786,
-0.039670784,
-0.033179421,
-0.0351203457,
-0.0042639519,
0.0062008332,
0.0007917074,
-0.0530057959,
0.0589673817,
0.0073677097,
-0.0348837748,
-0.0036233035,
-0.0591901429,
0.0372133777,
0.0363385305,
0.026268065,
0.0490107909,
0.0752684847,
0.0035136833,
0.0183535777,
0.0168864243,
0.0150434189,
0.0269392747,
-0.0259262696,
0.0064576482,
0.0139381988,
-0.0357676931,
0.0492683239,
0.0335042849,
-0.0474778041,
-0.035280183,
-0.0077462355,
-0.0035435415,
0.0015034243,
0.0611374304,
0.0068826084,
-0.0427926816,
-0.0256784502,
-0.0600529835,
0.0223640595,
-0.0364573561,
-0.007321761,
0.0512240343,
0.0312168691,
0.0188188534,
-0.0358372033,
0.0720261186,
-0.0447561517,
0.0070045893,
-0.0004213318,
-0.0042278422,
0.0040307101,
-0.0332525969,
0.0035700705,
-0.0414380766,
-0.0435039885,
0.0113713657,
0.042258203,
-0.0125446795,
-0.0154586714,
0.0120538492,
0.0638606846,
-0.0713443458,
0.0065280702,
-0.0137730287,
0.04893177,
0.0222296119,
0.0365656726,
0.0422069281,
-0.0089042103,
0.0196833555,
0.0569392666,
-0.0396212302,
-0.029072918,
0.0228930581,
0.0060156439,
-0.0082237935,
0.0181108322,
-0.0478286184,
0.028112622,
0.0046317186,
-0.0102265365,
0.0203341972,
-0.0247560237,
-0.0099394554,
-0.0121895531,
2.841e-7,
-0.0493127182,
0.0178000908,
0.0180216841,
0.0313023068,
0.0123469504,
0.0118861562,
-0.006008253,
-0.0120832892,
0.0325529613,
0.0222861562,
0.049899824,
0.0011603638,
0.0674133226,
0.0082835285,
-0.0878291428,
-0.0007344431,
-0.0264528152,
0.0389047302,
-0.01076183,
-0.0481437556,
-0.0134620117,
0.0722259209,
-0.011396192,
-0.01164845,
0.017585637,
-0.0356307998,
0.0435410142,
-0.0149870887,
-0.0181539766,
0.0016037478,
-0.0009675781,
0.0457243696,
-0.0063200532,
0.0426932164,
-0.0123388786,
0.0120494235,
-0.0145547008,
0.0308984518,
0.0139342062,
-0.0349928364,
-0.0105281202,
0.0303480811,
0.0066800141,
0.0065117902,
0.046304103,
-0.0437386483,
0.0084465174,
-0.0576464199,
-0.0112564964,
-0.0488619395,
-0.020875169,
-0.0111402255,
0.0347297862,
0.0327806771,
0.0114467246,
-0.0016775605,
-0.0162419379,
-0.0638515428,
0.0092432089,
0.0289562531,
-0.047822129,
-0.0537000671,
-0.0073675467,
-0.00028457,
0.0392382592,
-0.0268459953,
0.0063676112,
2.408371193e-34,
0.0626441836,
-0.0273762904,
0.0382478572,
0.059092585,
0.0130426018,
-0.0263423026,
-0.0526456498,
0.0264100395,
0.0410656705,
-0.0612138622,
-0.0454844385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15630v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15630v4 | NLPBench: Evaluating Large Language Models on Solving NLP Problems | 2023-09-27T13:02:06 | 2023-10-19T05:58:31 | Linxin Song, Jieyu Zhang, Lechao Cheng, Pengyuan Zhou, Tianyi Zhou, Irene Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent developments in large language models (LLMs) have shown promise in
enhancing the capabilities of natural language processing (NLP). Despite these
successes, there remains a dearth of research dedicated to the NLP
problem-solving abilities of LLMs. To fill the gap in this area, we present a
unique benchmarking dataset, NLPBench, comprising 378 college-level NLP
questions spanning various NLP topics sourced from Yale University's prior
final exams. NLPBench includes questions with context, in which multiple
sub-questions share the same public information, and diverse question types,
including multiple choice, short answer, and math. Our evaluation, centered on
LLMs such as GPT-3.5/4, PaLM-2, and LLAMA-2, incorporates advanced prompting
strategies like the chain-of-thought (CoT) and tree-of-thought (ToT). Our study
reveals that the effectiveness of the advanced prompting strategies can be
inconsistent, occasionally damaging LLM performance, especially in smaller
models like the LLAMA-2 (13b). Furthermore, our manual assessment illuminated
specific shortcomings in LLMs' scientific problem-solving skills, with
weaknesses in logical decomposition and reasoning notably affecting results. | [
0.0521979891,
0.0507506542,
-0.0191499125,
0.0385635681,
-0.0796882063,
0.0287349112,
0.0020157546,
0.0103238588,
0.0080817491,
-0.0758001879,
0.0053233565,
-0.0110225463,
-0.0149807101,
0.0008415704,
0.0210117493,
-0.0496106111,
0.0322571211,
-0.0483507961,
0.0155074978,
0.0024706866,
-0.0011223534,
0.0031137853,
-0.0195239745,
0.0221861508,
0.0042923852,
-0.0545015596,
0.0112368073,
-0.0250253789,
-0.0088876225,
-0.0634983256,
-0.0129497368,
0.0518507063,
-0.0021355082,
0.028362887,
0.0000022996,
-0.0803331882,
-0.0113336369,
0.018326832,
-0.0573989898,
0.0446835458,
0.0302535687,
0.028192671,
0.0246329829,
0.038015753,
-0.0242502838,
0.0052629127,
-0.0005589507,
0.0595759004,
0.0422854312,
0.0408805497,
0.0126322974,
-0.0433200411,
0.0314159989,
0.0099363038,
0.0182034858,
-0.0570884459,
0.0304398052,
0.0251224078,
0.040072009,
0.024340244,
-0.0254559182,
0.0311088264,
0.0270330366,
0.0229818113,
-0.008023466,
0.0336906686,
-0.0566436015,
-0.0196076687,
-0.0160360318,
0.0658973604,
0.0174622964,
0.0052148341,
-0.0146664781,
-0.0084028421,
-0.0124531137,
0.039204631,
-0.066435039,
0.0324673578,
-0.0204425398,
-0.0089935139,
0.0335042924,
0.0116588427,
0.0069256541,
0.0167433936,
-0.0270909201,
0.0967635661,
0.0128086871,
-0.0463456437,
0.0349058583,
-0.0036349313,
-0.038890522,
-0.0591474324,
0.034802746,
0.0285795033,
-0.0269811507,
0.0329427868,
0.0217846967,
-0.0015868804,
0.0397651419,
-0.010470503,
0.0435895137,
0.0455489159,
-0.0001364445,
0.0417103358,
-0.0141423484,
0.0642022714,
-0.0323134474,
0.0125854425,
-0.0367871821,
0.0030652967,
-0.0823511332,
-0.0446679518,
-0.0046028998,
0.0505016521,
-0.0398380905,
-0.0228892583,
0.0044408538,
-0.0219366383,
-0.0013705525,
-0.0154590355,
-0.0056544319,
0.0081947641,
0.0187855288,
-0.0025088235,
-0.0840362161,
0.0587850325,
-0.0355165116,
0.0225478578,
0.000558736,
-0.0364021063,
-0.0126116751,
0.0014898247,
-0.0213461015,
-0.032411065,
0.0405923538,
0.0594769083,
0.0140354419,
-0.0360779427,
-0.0215840284,
-0.0322603621,
-0.0109110447,
-0.0886767209,
0.0337708518,
-0.0715364441,
0.0304106008,
0.0320515595,
-0.0006292901,
0.0027302667,
0.025843665,
0.0369682871,
0.0027736784,
0.056610439,
0.0182374567,
0.0229991935,
0.0451181158,
0.0198073555,
0.0157298017,
0.0689694285,
0.0232629627,
-0.0043898253,
0.0155089591,
-0.0016368332,
-0.0105048856,
0.0279310439,
-0.0169546418,
-0.0025176902,
0.0225832034,
0.0303711966,
-0.0123365289,
0.0511450358,
-0.0180068091,
0.0623937994,
-0.0095459037,
0.0089823278,
0.0193461236,
0.0971525013,
0.0002669171,
0.0092213945,
0.0232262723,
-0.0001534123,
0.0343709178,
0.0082790591,
-0.0185339749,
0.0059782956,
-0.0492251292,
-0.0101900613,
-0.017684944,
0.0594667159,
-0.0075602126,
-0.0504662022,
-0.0619119294,
0.0538029671,
-0.0243148059,
0.0250038598,
0.0164199602,
-0.0031095047,
-0.0169261433,
0.0628587455,
-0.005673286,
-0.023992613,
-0.0089438204,
-0.035780035,
-0.006199677,
0.018421717,
0.0651332214,
-0.0187199973,
-0.0521832295,
-0.0075513585,
0.0032156876,
0.0496912561,
0.0444528274,
-0.0175115839,
-0.0256290361,
-0.0329492874,
0.0000140674,
-0.0231426917,
0.019540146,
-0.0282347389,
0.0311627649,
-0.0176441669,
-0.0011331224,
-0.0206462443,
-0.0234692674,
0.0356365964,
-0.0717044845,
-0.0492899008,
-0.0324881151,
-0.0024078777,
0.0306835044,
0.0188742075,
0.0069731949,
0.0474898145,
0.0130958082,
-0.0572096929,
-0.0318984799,
-0.0132741183,
-0.0436211489,
-0.0477823801,
0.0628283098,
-0.0413975306,
-0.0600071214,
0.0337698981,
-0.0253526233,
-0.0379372835,
-0.0003813127,
-0.0455459468,
0.0134038506,
-0.0038419042,
0.0202366002,
-0.0082661035,
-0.0251817293,
-0.0432039499,
0.0908458009,
-0.0147549585,
0.0471533909,
0.0369174555,
0.0028120263,
0.017626904,
-0.0143280718,
-0.0154458741,
0.0133670121,
-0.0023091212,
-0.0214923881,
0.0005588564,
0.0385328755,
-0.1036391407,
-0.0329140127,
-0.0535528064,
0.0376154184,
0.0122053465,
0.0459974706,
0.0296113621,
-0.0281654019,
-0.0247527435,
0.0340525024,
-0.036676269,
-0.0157699529,
0.0259837676,
0.017709624,
0.037558455,
0.0019549013,
-0.0095296903,
-0.0338296518,
-0.0104837073,
-0.0594852418,
0.0311871469,
0.0088028442,
-0.016858032,
0.0065420321,
0.063771084,
-0.0191688892,
-0.0157989468,
0.0023213176,
0.0107451715,
0.0275749117,
-0.0052678501,
0.053963922,
0.0561579391,
-0.0359677821,
0.0185226053,
0.0485032238,
-0.0347217582,
-0.0405797586,
0.0250898134,
-0.0023460244,
-0.0087134503,
-0.0190288648,
-0.0447564796,
0.0085330931,
0.0665228441,
-0.0030958725,
-0.0172230192,
-0.0062122419,
0.0270512793,
-0.0525031313,
-0.0065885102,
-0.0381693207,
-0.0310351606,
-0.0126649318,
0.0693586022,
-0.0164857917,
-0.0065273908,
0.0705897287,
-0.0297547579,
0.0010104827,
-0.0999442488,
0.0106556965,
-0.0657052398,
0.089220956,
-0.0151506662,
0.0014087779,
0.0048761428,
-0.0301859677,
-0.0465910956,
0.0035096158,
-0.0037786288,
-0.0302915629,
0.0447072648,
-0.0422295369,
-0.0048360135,
0.0004365569,
-0.0513577051,
-0.0185333714,
-0.0101395277,
-0.0581208244,
0.0273808241,
0.0214617122,
-0.0065974612,
-0.0180701502,
-0.0097855311,
0.047312405,
-0.0210173801,
-0.0132575976,
-0.0373784751,
-0.0284234229,
0.0528546311,
0.031411197,
0.0133416709,
0.0818343237,
-0.0275891609,
0.0510402136,
0.0556883737,
0.0641505122,
0.0259153992,
-0.0021241738,
0.0192719642,
0.0318485647,
-0.0373293348,
-0.0191858262,
0.0173470341,
0.0476377793,
-0.0701855347,
-0.0117147779,
0.1034570709,
0.0665303394,
-0.0102877505,
-0.0031056164,
-0.0555034168,
0.0215140842,
0.0474821888,
0.0289526824,
-0.0693354085,
-0.0417573415,
0.0248687845,
-0.0345213525,
-0.0234585702,
-0.0483286679,
-0.0035661501,
-0.1559040099,
0.0214031041,
-0.0193190202,
-0.0101087205,
0.0129277809,
-0.0609934069,
0.0039520995,
0.0252491497,
0.0026753193,
0.0110513764,
-0.037327867,
0.013353236,
0.0343082435,
-0.0427650809,
-0.0275872387,
0.0745825022,
-0.016896639,
0.0219612103,
0.025936747,
0.0254640672,
-0.0134224035,
-0.0149390977,
0.0622826554,
-0.0339469761,
0.0065260045,
-0.0223077964,
0.0008301054,
0.0049976427,
0.0244223867,
-0.0438100658,
0.0253054537,
-0.0567182414,
0.0004350134,
0.0376762077,
0.1177501753,
0.0042352253,
-0.0115298107,
-0.0356993899,
0.0086501939,
-0.0634635687,
0.0719817281,
0.0365046896,
-0.0044965399,
-0.0360997319,
-0.0292229932,
-0.0137332221,
0.0185796209,
-0.0377330631,
0.0316700414,
0.0181847196,
0.0202402603,
-0.0275410973,
-0.0379409753,
0.073406443,
0.0136483954,
0.0115900822,
0.0338694975,
0.0164118391,
0.0071633072,
-0.0036358272,
0.0341261849,
-0.0318490528,
0.0289762747,
-0.0345468447,
0.0263716541,
0.029768303,
0.0165612455,
-0.0431531221,
0.0401449203,
-0.0890691057,
-0.0523396321,
-0.0263382234,
0.0069062919,
0.027973257,
-0.0385006927,
-0.0065137777,
-0.0518505722,
-0.0254935399,
0.0181046799,
-0.0332216062,
0.0227078535,
-0.0372255333,
0.0140192704,
0.019937044,
0.009093442,
-0.0100138234,
0.0160278827,
-0.0063794451,
0.0876161829,
-0.020829659,
-0.0459053181,
0.0415817313,
0.0750083774,
0.0179391671,
0.0106442086,
-0.0153384255,
-0.0086267646,
0.0032558464,
-0.0215679444,
-0.0266616363,
-0.022784397,
0.0004915276,
0.0312647596,
-0.0091015929,
0.0068930723,
-0.0195551217,
-0.016804114,
0.0540698059,
-0.0196496844,
0.0270424038,
0.0456772223,
-0.0209098253,
0.0129634133,
-0.0334616005,
-0.0056487801,
-0.0301570464,
-0.0210704189,
0.0409954228,
0.0000605762,
0.0806153417,
0.0073636714,
0.0048874859,
-0.0252883118,
-0.0073753688,
-0.0702930242,
-0.0927073807,
0.0268106982,
0.031767983,
0.0189900678,
-0.0039036507,
0.0088757686,
-0.0364396758,
-0.0095579242,
0.0030895176,
-0.0178934,
0.0024229879,
-0.0278878212,
0.0893585086,
0.0394558832,
-0.0012001202,
-0.0202866253,
0.0619995967,
0.0243073478,
0.0291182119,
0.0379792675,
-0.0060544331,
-0.0222373288,
-0.0309738088,
-0.0244976319,
0.0328559354,
-0.0014093578,
0.0290873274,
-0.1253224611,
-0.0565342084,
0.0212015212,
-0.0143043548,
0.0276176259,
-0.0329775997,
0.0248452276,
0.071822919,
0.0013071254,
-0.0467858464,
-0.001897634,
0.0247885343,
-0.0168720875,
-0.0355228931,
-0.0076325987,
-6.879107552e-33,
-0.0187318549,
-0.0516504906,
0.0546796247,
-0.0069200187,
-0.0165824704,
0.0110919243,
-0.0382670872,
0.0260248054,
-0.0324333906,
-0.0007753639,
-0.0348905846,
0.012246958,
-0.00220496,
-0.0038282699,
0.0188563559,
-0.019537136,
0.009534169,
-0.0146297272,
-0.0162299573,
-0.0186373256,
0.0217889789,
0.0107457284,
0.0241873059,
-0.0291668046,
-0.0016656666,
-0.0043107369,
0.0178199764,
0.0201571435,
-0.0520381182,
0.0455833785,
-0.0526241176,
0.0189008918,
0.0436881185,
-0.0737258494,
0.0043275515,
0.0169173088,
-0.0370465554,
-0.0529312342,
0.0683717504,
-0.0342737511,
-0.0333238989,
-0.0355252437,
0.0251247287,
0.0315918773,
-0.0230539124,
-0.0368406288,
0.0216588248,
-0.022878563,
-0.0044161961,
-0.0131687578,
-0.0489128008,
0.0179121997,
-0.0267516673,
-0.0054131965,
-0.0017968022,
0.0448844545,
-0.0330061466,
0.0478894413,
-0.0092837894,
0.004474286,
0.0361869596,
0.0289672725,
0.0486978926,
-0.0254457593,
-0.0009123574,
0.0521247238,
-0.0058892551,
-0.0116555067,
-0.0259560663,
-0.0136311278,
0.0045804381,
0.0674127787,
0.0616289973,
0.023678273,
0.0416247845,
0.0077987937,
-0.0705094263,
0.0067831511,
0.0135051981,
0.0450204276,
0.0155885434,
-0.0039701201,
-0.0162548926,
-0.0125311967,
-0.082116574,
0.0152095445,
-0.0386105888,
0.0056552351,
0.0515863933,
-0.0278258044,
-0.006229334,
-0.0130011868,
0.0203123912,
-0.035081543,
-0.0259376746,
0.0083146943,
-0.0085635185,
0.0538795292,
0.000703883,
0.0657667741,
-0.1005095541,
0.0214579813,
-0.0235525668,
0.0166862682,
0.0310147498,
-0.0066599944,
0.0050064274,
-0.023419952,
-0.0467254668,
-0.0230604727,
-0.0517191142,
0.0064498289,
0.0045605553,
0.0315913223,
0.0353578739,
0.0360910818,
-0.0038912739,
0.0271517206,
0.0179834329,
-0.017949,
-0.0281328186,
0.0167341437,
-0.0227649156,
-0.0068537113,
-0.0024592755,
-0.0102429027,
-0.0341058113,
0.0261650905,
0.0239435583,
-0.055510357,
-0.0082997605,
0.0129878502,
3.011e-7,
0.0524587892,
0.0802500695,
0.0041633477,
-0.0015249016,
0.0143850092,
0.0149968546,
-0.028681092,
-0.0308505315,
0.0431653075,
-0.0468191095,
-0.0424061529,
0.0276615862,
0.0325108469,
0.0422620475,
-0.0666177943,
-0.0084911631,
-0.0433819778,
-0.0165436491,
-0.0829465315,
-0.0042644674,
0.0718278065,
0.0723150745,
-0.0025468294,
-0.0277338978,
-0.0472566858,
-0.0317511037,
0.0389019065,
-0.0276523624,
-0.0172370709,
0.0126064401,
0.0256629046,
0.0117033301,
0.0274822582,
0.0432946272,
0.0085048229,
-0.0021157656,
0.0062089176,
0.0596373677,
0.0289964285,
-0.0088925334,
0.0091366647,
-0.0146588339,
-0.0181284267,
-0.0698274449,
0.07401032,
-0.0572241135,
-0.0452629402,
-0.0074161729,
-0.019979585,
-0.0273430087,
0.0107418401,
-0.003689318,
0.012403422,
0.0213081893,
-0.0176366158,
-0.0221508071,
-0.0146294199,
-0.0708267614,
-0.003717843,
0.0032211083,
-0.0209910534,
-0.0370623507,
-0.0580973551,
-0.0169732645,
0.036010392,
-0.0537206829,
-0.0406711325,
3.171583859e-34,
0.0260537304,
-0.0221989509,
0.0505000241,
0.0431568362,
0.0426516011,
0.0027776328,
-0.0124614304,
0.0120557649,
-0.0265285801,
-0.1196494177,
0.0072128456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.01423v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.01423v1 | An Empirical Study of AI Generated Text Detection Tools | 2023-09-27T12:44:12 | 2023-09-27T12:44:12 | Arslan Akram | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 53, I.2.6; I.2.7 | Since ChatGPT has emerged as a major AIGC model, providing high-quality
responses across a wide range of applications (including software development
and maintenance), it has attracted much interest from many individuals. ChatGPT
has great promise, but there are serious problems that might arise from its
misuse, especially in the realms of education and public safety. Several AIGC
detectors are available, and they have all been tested on genuine text.
However, more study is needed to see how effective they are for multi-domain
ChatGPT material. This study aims to fill this need by creating a multi-domain
dataset for testing the state-of-the-art APIs and tools for detecting
artificially generated information used by universities and other research
institutions. A large dataset consisting of articles, abstracts, stories, news,
and product reviews was created for this study. The second step is to use the
newly created dataset to put six tools through their paces. Six different
artificial intelligence (AI) text identification systems, including "GPTkit,"
"GPTZero," "Originality," "Sapling," "Writer," and "Zylalab," have accuracy
rates between 55.29 and 97.0%. Although all the tools fared well in the
evaluations, originality was particularly effective across the board. | [
0.0791333765,
-0.0059265047,
-0.0109653277,
0.048415605,
-0.0941319242,
0.0078913094,
0.0256070998,
0.0223881695,
0.0614383593,
-0.0604234301,
0.0150986807,
0.0083370619,
-0.0246217567,
0.0641117096,
-0.021510601,
0.0380483381,
0.020647198,
0.0108992672,
0.062041074,
0.0491911806,
0.0250834469,
0.0399465077,
-0.0099060731,
0.053557992,
-0.0171557143,
-0.0612943135,
0.0074479566,
-0.0038857774,
0.0311325397,
-0.0490182415,
0.0137185957,
0.0423648506,
-0.0392913669,
0.11231976,
0.0000019254,
-0.0615934916,
-0.053796649,
0.0018481024,
-0.0141219338,
0.0163398366,
0.0966584682,
0.0310690515,
-0.0488933101,
0.0086044008,
-0.0435708612,
0.024178559,
0.0321735255,
0.0496713147,
0.0253774431,
0.0969455838,
-0.0406213664,
-0.013773351,
0.0386516675,
0.0386851653,
-0.0030337656,
-0.0166873727,
0.0279409755,
0.0068724626,
0.0234749112,
0.0354492217,
0.0515052006,
0.0354580283,
-0.0084546451,
-0.0626331344,
-0.0178115088,
0.0087075979,
-0.0708581805,
-0.0235763658,
-0.0277693253,
-0.0007855576,
-0.0178572685,
-0.057174556,
0.0586899891,
-0.0178936534,
0.0209222436,
0.0225478616,
0.0013994905,
0.016036028,
-0.0751036704,
-0.0086804489,
0.0037484465,
0.0084560784,
-0.0287006814,
0.027454732,
0.0283986107,
0.0274658948,
0.0099056894,
-0.0480716377,
0.016972417,
0.0059280992,
0.0217747912,
-0.0452608429,
0.0321660973,
0.0201540794,
0.0491821542,
-0.0081994878,
-0.0490875244,
-0.0841964632,
0.0126067307,
-0.0643388703,
-0.0320504196,
0.012827212,
-0.0084526828,
0.039330598,
-0.0424649455,
0.067284435,
0.0025625124,
0.0463235453,
0.0054186806,
0.0310843941,
-0.0525593124,
-0.0258662198,
-0.0192097835,
0.0358752944,
-0.006869365,
-0.0410928726,
-0.0399093144,
0.0211487897,
0.022282321,
0.0328499265,
-0.0392942838,
-0.0180390291,
-0.02331765,
-0.0020735806,
0.0295439251,
-0.0143194161,
0.016857408,
0.0219467245,
-0.0091271121,
-0.0390678495,
0.002577388,
0.0720072538,
0.0452127866,
0.0098150978,
-0.0012891022,
0.0634743348,
-0.0224533603,
-0.0503543802,
-0.0360825472,
-0.0479020178,
-0.0340621918,
-0.0193803478,
0.0329572633,
-0.054411225,
-0.0149066299,
0.0084450962,
-0.0114453267,
-0.0355360582,
-0.0122695435,
0.0230221711,
-0.023318477,
0.0160582922,
-0.0425994173,
-0.0050870916,
0.0528373607,
0.0079983156,
-0.0139744813,
0.0277523585,
0.013292267,
0.1049209014,
0.0631101131,
-0.0020490179,
0.0468699001,
0.0298293922,
-0.0048759086,
-0.0079905149,
0.0595345125,
-0.0210573524,
-0.0262251105,
-0.0114091076,
-0.0246739145,
0.0338544622,
-0.0110915853,
-0.0023864396,
0.0587445088,
0.0681846216,
-0.0041996939,
0.0352756493,
0.010476036,
0.0669914186,
0.0304473154,
0.027022047,
0.0162790976,
-0.0157009102,
-0.0469837524,
-0.0051768571,
-0.0275709797,
0.0362751074,
0.0210316163,
-0.0139549654,
-0.0377514251,
-0.0179545954,
-0.0157692526,
-0.0655486286,
0.04629739,
0.0077682794,
-0.0630724281,
-0.0722976178,
-0.013908851,
-0.0262519047,
-0.0244415365,
-0.0782783106,
0.0409180857,
0.0628645569,
0.0806521177,
-0.0287453234,
0.0084241638,
-0.0256159902,
-0.0071954657,
0.0562232547,
0.0191471986,
0.0039137616,
-0.0358951502,
-0.0347039737,
-0.038728606,
-0.0177534297,
-0.0037636645,
0.0463202111,
0.0474588238,
0.0653666407,
0.0269069262,
0.0160553809,
-0.0515775792,
0.0335953198,
-0.0049413829,
-0.0368612558,
-0.0185152125,
-0.0160844568,
0.01246012,
0.0195584241,
-0.0373665914,
0.0180065073,
0.0125137065,
0.0082875565,
-0.0330186747,
0.0084096817,
0.0295524318,
0.0176450368,
0.0151397632,
-0.0717318878,
-0.0030102611,
0.0163440928,
-0.0196748897,
0.0101812389,
0.004466489,
-0.0312147476,
0.0113675976,
-0.0612160936,
0.0052254461,
-0.0283962544,
0.0135382647,
-0.0205709599,
0.0593972206,
0.0339762233,
-0.0106555093,
0.0063888957,
-0.0239872131,
0.0496525802,
-0.0087668346,
-0.0117735406,
-0.0127627701,
-0.049358286,
0.0225504767,
0.0304894112,
0.0270625968,
-0.0123287896,
-0.03586936,
-0.0648889542,
0.0030361661,
-0.0023535094,
0.0270528812,
0.0394571722,
-0.0367991105,
-0.0335971899,
0.0102974838,
-0.0077252463,
-0.0413634665,
0.0141356103,
-0.0162900779,
0.0270051658,
-0.018510893,
0.0223549884,
-0.0048410734,
0.0326110385,
-0.0403133407,
0.0202106647,
0.1000208929,
-0.0970184654,
-0.0648499131,
0.0458398014,
0.0174680445,
-0.0343494751,
-0.0093066944,
-0.044787135,
-0.0214965586,
-0.0034256084,
0.0060708649,
0.0862226486,
0.0285766385,
0.0144327758,
0.0074227699,
0.0363144241,
-0.0250132903,
-0.0021351397,
-0.0336944647,
0.033597406,
0.0337789394,
-0.033831358,
0.0758239403,
0.0069091041,
0.0219159294,
0.0290419012,
0.0034135121,
0.0206405483,
-0.0340630896,
-0.0123666739,
0.0092598228,
-0.0504298806,
-0.0242980551,
0.0146428272,
0.0070967651,
-0.0364170782,
0.0397245623,
-0.0410198756,
0.0099784844,
-0.0956396759,
-0.0051389658,
-0.0083150184,
0.0245976485,
-0.0140996808,
0.0302826688,
0.0355320647,
-0.0124576492,
-0.0055421679,
0.0120458435,
0.0563373901,
-0.0177683253,
-0.0116076097,
-0.0089688282,
0.027963113,
-0.020895483,
0.0069100456,
-0.0325714722,
-0.0400518924,
0.0150084803,
-0.0464056693,
0.0644779727,
-0.0261997078,
-0.02406119,
0.0388510823,
0.0187485404,
0.0858879611,
-0.0338437036,
0.0019198332,
-0.0070008677,
0.0602688491,
0.0204362385,
-0.0623002239,
0.0262960084,
0.0210065115,
-0.0033006603,
0.0720837116,
-0.0143573796,
0.0134214647,
-0.0202281009,
-0.0611465313,
-0.0331625007,
-0.0371456631,
0.0123194344,
-0.0246958416,
0.0109610483,
-0.0351654477,
0.012943998,
0.0695274621,
0.0275453888,
-0.0734606683,
-0.0490823053,
-0.0074125137,
-0.0233738031,
-0.0104392422,
0.0015076291,
-0.0844385028,
-0.0059114238,
0.0191830341,
0.0255333912,
-0.0475676432,
0.0043725264,
-0.0100206081,
-0.0498299599,
0.032407891,
0.0156209227,
-0.0203119572,
-0.0206550229,
-0.0069818366,
-0.0022632566,
0.0234914254,
-0.0477688871,
-0.0616655946,
-0.0091864411,
0.0144726662,
-0.0019554205,
-0.0732926726,
-0.0599242151,
-0.0260625239,
-0.0016317141,
0.0066976747,
0.0758659914,
0.0443059504,
-0.0198578872,
-0.0030389505,
0.0451469272,
-0.0009298641,
-0.0235399362,
-0.0102655385,
0.0789474398,
-0.0138751464,
0.0229830891,
-0.0073597617,
0.0275508184,
-0.0064991228,
0.0034129638,
0.0723048821,
0.042080719,
-0.0171507262,
-0.0302470215,
-0.045617912,
-0.0097616352,
0.0321026482,
0.0526688248,
0.0078155063,
-0.0177947786,
-0.0557887666,
-0.0442036018,
0.0374109,
-0.0461099595,
-0.0191830043,
-0.0107285054,
-0.0345933586,
-0.0586583093,
-0.0872932747,
-0.0093522025,
-0.0204493832,
0.0128317177,
0.0285888389,
-0.0046652304,
-0.0031225423,
0.0231730156,
-0.0672032386,
-0.0533309877,
-0.0218894538,
-0.000942135,
-0.0496788621,
0.0151110534,
-0.00512945,
-0.026371628,
-0.027034631,
0.0500418805,
-0.0285181515,
-0.0370500535,
0.0094059026,
-0.0225324091,
0.0254429057,
-0.0018712668,
-0.0381108895,
0.008295279,
0.0604058169,
0.0496482104,
-0.0147727216,
-0.0231364667,
-0.010627104,
-0.0155754657,
-0.0314788409,
-0.0269413758,
-0.0223100781,
0.0458786227,
0.0032614793,
-0.0579731129,
-0.0108762337,
0.0139391944,
0.0287318435,
0.0526820198,
0.0007607312,
-0.011455074,
0.0379483625,
-0.0258116312,
-0.0116218776,
-0.0013128152,
0.0059424844,
-0.0201922562,
0.0049832244,
0.0404610634,
-0.0057022078,
0.0042976104,
0.041642677,
-0.0264157057,
0.0199003462,
-0.0351540446,
0.0171554293,
0.0015938389,
0.0905986577,
0.0115829753,
-0.0203208141,
0.0001858131,
0.0198816638,
-0.0009187129,
0.0346845277,
-0.0008860856,
0.0499063469,
0.0339377299,
-0.0416344926,
0.059906859,
0.0531656072,
-0.0812051743,
0.0089325765,
-0.0577955768,
0.0481235497,
0.0455206372,
0.0214597601,
0.0464384779,
-0.062663503,
-0.0113291517,
-0.0251648519,
0.0481174588,
0.0264092889,
-0.0295387954,
-0.0654682964,
-0.026629813,
-0.0485816374,
-0.0127910851,
0.0671643689,
-0.0048272703,
0.0102836592,
0.0043131439,
-0.0642767474,
-0.0569453016,
-0.023294393,
0.0152984392,
-0.010195164,
0.0132639389,
-0.0035234452,
-0.0473814458,
-0.0186839458,
0.003456333,
-0.015970638,
0.0389771387,
-0.0091784196,
-0.0078952145,
0.069723174,
-0.0024944425,
-0.0048547303,
-0.0257583726,
0.0004269831,
-0.0623041391,
-0.0196820628,
-0.0095872218,
-5.10818417e-33,
0.0199381988,
-0.0851505101,
-0.0289466064,
0.0541736558,
0.0094287274,
0.0278814621,
-0.0235577784,
-0.0406561568,
0.0071467222,
0.0047614649,
-0.0111125167,
0.0168991145,
0.0105637359,
-0.0257369876,
-0.0146486908,
0.0104866186,
0.003510894,
-0.0120108752,
-0.044973243,
0.0425377376,
0.0433069728,
-0.0040414925,
0.065501377,
-0.091323413,
0.018427154,
-0.0474392511,
-0.0375332013,
-0.0435216017,
-0.0043419232,
0.0638178214,
-0.0184833128,
-0.0088447211,
0.0415900499,
-0.0013886013,
0.0177518651,
0.0522168279,
-0.010645153,
-0.0344979763,
-0.0160363764,
0.0166127477,
0.0240612421,
-0.0597587042,
0.0406230837,
-0.0479968674,
-0.0406486429,
0.0193498954,
0.0621063113,
-0.0096909236,
0.0039661513,
-0.060923446,
-0.0831601247,
0.0375290439,
-0.0039697052,
0.0194326527,
0.0236953534,
0.0468033813,
0.0248927549,
0.0117414827,
-0.0356160328,
-0.0005295589,
0.0215292145,
-0.002672574,
0.0245339163,
-0.019357698,
-0.0336410478,
0.0332327448,
0.0054963846,
0.0018380453,
-0.007282156,
-0.0306057241,
0.0015358528,
-0.0174368788,
0.073826246,
0.0689058453,
0.0295889024,
-0.0509698875,
-0.0210168678,
0.0523781888,
0.0305889174,
-0.0050541284,
0.0346629769,
-0.0294741932,
-0.0659131855,
0.0073783952,
0.0509261973,
-0.0385304913,
-0.0294144917,
-0.0515587442,
0.0496999249,
-0.0038023901,
-0.0383910872,
0.0184861682,
-0.0026583795,
-0.0507724993,
0.023256002,
0.008639751,
-0.0506342538,
0.0340568386,
-0.0043545919,
0.0170680135,
-0.0491857678,
-0.0082375286,
0.0212538056,
0.0271247402,
0.0226332508,
-0.0230058916,
0.0400012545,
0.0176340006,
-0.0612068437,
0.021276474,
0.0104355961,
0.0225230325,
0.0199427698,
-0.0112823285,
-0.0106880395,
-0.038756039,
0.0201941412,
-0.0259805657,
0.0609171502,
0.0360360891,
-0.0547901951,
-0.0296647679,
-0.0321207345,
0.0096783219,
-0.0296940878,
0.0068044378,
-0.007155858,
-0.0001220476,
-0.0148234954,
-0.0555013716,
0.0162035935,
-0.0071080253,
2.549e-7,
0.0377493761,
0.0468332134,
0.0493787974,
-0.0167595539,
0.0156376101,
0.018216189,
0.0200478155,
0.0309521537,
-0.0070031974,
0.0319000222,
-0.0086773038,
-0.0309134088,
0.0499995239,
0.004919026,
-0.0951419398,
0.02457132,
-0.0481433645,
-0.0037218465,
-0.0912585333,
0.0646599606,
0.0822287798,
0.0136087416,
0.0083632693,
-0.0105008632,
0.0046707843,
-0.06970682,
-0.008590051,
0.0169143192,
0.0230870415,
0.0462965779,
0.0419209972,
0.0312688798,
-0.0041134697,
0.0291672666,
-0.013008452,
-0.0085681509,
0.0090261986,
0.0362471305,
0.0120068481,
0.0540597923,
0.011186894,
-0.0309065077,
0.0416451581,
-0.0596989393,
0.0547242537,
0.0102518136,
0.0096756648,
-0.047910247,
-0.0259391833,
-0.0706146732,
-0.0003731026,
-0.0000048222,
-0.0115804747,
0.0173224267,
-0.0267577041,
-0.0053330329,
0.009446783,
-0.0301920231,
0.0276627131,
-0.0324398391,
-0.0024903892,
-0.0168746766,
-0.0405987091,
-0.0003842939,
0.0494784936,
-0.0462579168,
0.039291162,
2.486776896e-34,
0.0348291732,
-0.0483625494,
-0.0138944928,
0.0147666633,
0.0306769852,
0.0154457586,
0.0184593424,
0.0149128838,
-0.0316113867,
0.008078997,
0.0335274674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15609v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15609v1 | Developing automatic verbatim transcripts for international multilingual meetings: an end-to-end solution | 2023-09-27T12:16:15 | 2023-09-27T12:16:15 | Akshat Dewan, Michal Ziemski, Henri Meylan, Lorenzo Concina, Bruno Pouliquen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper presents an end-to-end solution for the creation of fully
automated conference meeting transcripts and their machine translations into
various languages. This tool has been developed at the World Intellectual
Property Organization (WIPO) using in-house developed speech-to-text (S2T) and
machine translation (MT) components. Beyond describing data collection and
fine-tuning, resulting in a highly customized and robust system, this paper
describes the architecture and evolution of the technical components as well as
highlights the business impact and benefits from the user side. We also point
out particular challenges in the evolution and adoption of the system and how
the new approach created a new product and replaced existing established
workflows in conference management documentation. | [
0.0415193737,
0.0150686847,
-0.0123315752,
0.0672246888,
-0.0355007276,
-0.0117200911,
-0.0014923688,
0.0075169834,
0.0092554195,
-0.0143063199,
-0.0465627424,
-0.0045955149,
-0.0034678024,
0.0503653586,
0.0058326102,
-0.0721023679,
0.0276816059,
-0.0032506557,
-0.035497684,
0.0363325104,
0.0482088812,
0.0325323083,
-0.0194798317,
0.0259131771,
0.0205961429,
0.016711235,
-0.0070911874,
-0.0045731599,
0.0200477783,
0.0118682431,
-0.0583326146,
0.0093789306,
0.0233713221,
0.0556150563,
0.0000017906,
-0.0578794628,
-0.0405541398,
0.0258595124,
-0.00705224,
0.037089821,
0.0172058269,
0.0267911553,
-0.0490069352,
0.0547246076,
-0.0244116094,
0.024122607,
0.0378364958,
-0.0169056244,
0.0360304601,
0.0438648276,
-0.0446029603,
0.0018153678,
-0.0033467626,
-0.0206723735,
-0.0336584039,
-0.0193158388,
-0.0201633926,
0.0151949525,
0.0222095549,
-0.0235612206,
0.0700580701,
0.054676339,
-0.0537557825,
-0.050802011,
-0.0397173539,
-0.0105462633,
-0.0846649781,
-0.0498180985,
-0.0400674976,
0.0380820706,
0.0350347571,
0.0260218158,
0.027404679,
-0.0038000389,
0.0157959051,
-0.0521038249,
-0.0501127467,
0.0167165697,
-0.0296399761,
-0.0055176378,
0.0061619841,
0.0563614257,
-0.0552778095,
-0.02580918,
-0.0085054068,
-0.0344960168,
0.0273126028,
-0.0179813076,
-0.0342505835,
0.0114777293,
0.0477913208,
-0.0483498238,
0.0830617249,
0.020086607,
0.0159780588,
0.0189396683,
-0.0005254565,
-0.0594287328,
-0.0061317151,
-0.0542399921,
0.02713985,
0.0453133769,
-0.0136054931,
0.0363003798,
0.0120259989,
0.0088323709,
-0.0189297087,
0.0298176575,
-0.041317258,
-0.0281901546,
-0.0121962177,
0.0301111545,
-0.0319741964,
-0.0155609911,
-0.071165666,
-0.0104513373,
-0.0267185625,
0.0339102782,
0.0364029445,
0.0553511642,
0.0252554975,
-0.0430519395,
-0.0231225435,
-0.0292115193,
-0.0276746247,
0.0235549957,
0.0067791296,
0.0128192883,
-0.0352685899,
-0.0335397199,
0.009791025,
0.0557588488,
0.0459721684,
0.0631035343,
-0.0191445742,
0.0886805281,
-0.0324782319,
-0.0018666385,
0.0024819451,
-0.0373028517,
-0.0303938054,
-0.0204365924,
-0.015318566,
-0.0364622623,
0.0823811516,
0.035120137,
-0.0368517637,
0.0035527186,
0.0214478597,
-0.0094358753,
0.0022041583,
0.0131337354,
-0.0321725383,
0.0058841431,
0.0321683064,
-0.03200607,
-0.0110592553,
0.009150451,
0.0362731367,
0.0252905022,
0.0467304923,
0.0069693695,
0.0229574274,
0.1012011021,
-0.0161314961,
0.0352643505,
0.0063364957,
0.0172969699,
0.0229510032,
-0.0430674963,
0.0040023872,
0.0432977937,
0.0100765098,
0.0678069517,
0.0363949053,
0.0627976879,
-0.0176899973,
0.0021763591,
0.0241768863,
0.0146515565,
-0.0104645435,
-0.0117014442,
0.0556765497,
-0.0054804743,
0.0654057264,
0.0027727073,
0.0543875918,
0.0271743014,
-0.0016933376,
-0.0363374762,
-0.0037607071,
-0.0062008072,
0.0053601665,
0.0091874497,
0.0154095786,
-0.0054233042,
-0.0567880273,
0.0285240486,
-0.0225346852,
-0.0650692582,
-0.0095569603,
-0.0188273005,
-0.0018032568,
0.0586048923,
0.0034814805,
-0.0077377539,
0.0379059948,
-0.0632107705,
-0.0432888791,
0.089204751,
0.0683653355,
-0.0075812265,
0.0167204365,
-0.0392100923,
-0.0194324125,
0.0720766038,
-0.0139405699,
0.0437046066,
-0.0538954698,
0.0301985946,
0.0352391861,
0.0096422322,
-0.0500496998,
-0.0051794071,
-0.0039845486,
-0.0308410525,
-0.0256479848,
0.0015095592,
0.063658528,
0.057287313,
-0.0198173802,
0.0165188778,
0.0251834653,
-0.0309396498,
0.0105036683,
0.0856388509,
0.0059004365,
0.0265044421,
0.0325029455,
-0.027093837,
0.0037938727,
-0.0130449357,
-0.0201328341,
-0.0614659749,
-0.0094263628,
-0.0043421616,
0.0383144319,
-0.0347900726,
0.0602035001,
-0.0058099814,
0.0178468395,
-0.0015884597,
-0.0481878705,
0.0357457921,
-0.03834356,
0.0339195877,
-0.1024935097,
0.0694254637,
-0.0174595416,
0.0053947433,
0.0489942543,
-0.0219759587,
0.0098607726,
0.0504172184,
-0.0137840733,
-0.0211526304,
-0.0163361765,
-0.0878163427,
0.0247504693,
-0.0185754932,
0.0329922438,
0.0256503746,
0.0442512482,
-0.0109485202,
-0.0001619547,
-0.0107719637,
-0.0344703384,
0.0210202578,
-0.0542335398,
0.042451676,
0.0186690409,
-0.0290417671,
-0.0581917837,
0.0066428478,
0.0233730823,
-0.0262883753,
0.0460585766,
-0.0639830455,
-0.1042241082,
0.0416357927,
-0.0085814511,
-0.0015937532,
0.0018255799,
-0.0260943491,
0.0038697226,
-0.0178172048,
0.0495821275,
0.0300317518,
0.0198137052,
-0.0042358171,
-0.0060647377,
-0.0083892047,
-0.0481218994,
-0.0175161436,
-0.0012853459,
-0.0100609213,
0.0054707639,
0.0012888348,
0.0716874823,
-0.0094178263,
0.0238461494,
0.0541062132,
-0.0237366557,
-0.0497534722,
-0.0046316842,
0.0179851688,
0.0200349372,
-0.0708269626,
-0.0441061482,
0.0552005917,
0.0339493826,
-0.0169919189,
-0.009975154,
-0.0876612663,
-0.0195564199,
-0.066810444,
-0.0363716334,
-0.0366709381,
0.0610963069,
-0.0545699932,
0.0228830278,
-0.0174630862,
-0.0552674793,
-0.0101341177,
-0.0549333654,
0.0240840279,
-0.0374065116,
-0.0508405268,
-0.0451883003,
-0.0026324056,
-0.064563103,
-0.0245112535,
-0.007959594,
0.0368695222,
-0.0310361087,
-0.0140043376,
0.0592993498,
-0.0119197452,
-0.0484069213,
0.0802311078,
0.0458713397,
0.0572352521,
0.0303283893,
0.0141753089,
-0.0003496237,
0.0267159063,
-0.0253020506,
-0.0044863671,
-0.0181945581,
0.003831198,
0.0071761217,
-0.0125305206,
0.0158909447,
0.033130955,
0.0318557657,
-0.0521155037,
0.0059509743,
-0.0104305623,
-0.0359693579,
-0.01841731,
0.0487594754,
-0.0402291641,
0.0745520964,
0.073828347,
-0.0046797749,
-0.0618506446,
-0.0535329059,
-0.0402737111,
-0.0238013975,
-0.0202623401,
0.0396505147,
-0.0874174684,
0.0226451028,
0.001321845,
0.0738202557,
-0.0201493762,
0.0228811037,
-0.0112049039,
-0.0353733227,
0.0751419142,
0.0394606777,
-0.0442465097,
-0.0316017084,
-0.0065575484,
-0.0307449158,
-0.0013236671,
0.0099389013,
-0.0041633546,
0.0022165971,
-0.039818719,
0.0128850713,
-0.1158078387,
-0.030273743,
0.0042228252,
-0.0299129747,
0.0361057594,
0.0752981678,
0.0692061409,
0.0227556583,
-0.016579872,
-0.0074005648,
-0.0515620038,
-0.0006580737,
-0.0073453737,
0.0145542799,
0.0053499825,
-0.0289763529,
0.0016025043,
0.0484218113,
0.0177221335,
0.0349729992,
0.0401428305,
0.0404004231,
-0.0142696705,
0.0469972156,
-0.0044854684,
0.0058735665,
0.0342163704,
0.0248167869,
0.0101019535,
-0.0370663367,
-0.0047742971,
-0.0189590063,
-0.002288928,
-0.0744169727,
0.0012817626,
-0.0195053685,
-0.0363373272,
-0.0520377755,
-0.0709784552,
-0.0556980036,
0.0445521325,
0.0148325423,
0.0173991751,
-0.0059058638,
0.0312099066,
0.0353673622,
-0.0180596523,
-0.0112343468,
-0.037520621,
0.0045868517,
-0.0606654808,
-0.0218198411,
0.0113628544,
0.0194915887,
-0.0037709246,
0.0589620918,
-0.0300316289,
-0.0517600365,
-0.0072458833,
0.0110247042,
0.0238293037,
0.0554586016,
0.0220606606,
0.0447627641,
-0.0171860456,
-0.0313013494,
0.0017349886,
-0.041545663,
0.0248041786,
0.0443669297,
-0.0475224331,
-0.012001968,
-0.0415323637,
0.0101590203,
-0.0345338508,
-0.0040192385,
-0.0042626807,
-0.0740062818,
0.0079027852,
0.0644075945,
-0.0426585004,
-0.0209398046,
-0.0283496659,
-0.0252392013,
0.0219545662,
-0.0150002949,
0.0068026897,
-0.0347449891,
0.0006107753,
-0.012683372,
-0.0417091474,
0.025602635,
0.0174585618,
-0.1042579487,
-0.0355434902,
0.0224697199,
0.0674291626,
-0.0048102611,
0.0060621961,
0.0337670371,
-0.0014109167,
-0.0449610129,
0.0328710787,
-0.0004950574,
0.0522508435,
-0.0566434637,
0.0181693323,
-0.0323430374,
0.0111295916,
0.0332878269,
0.0520624854,
-0.0142212557,
-0.0469234884,
-0.03837502,
0.0241002254,
0.056644734,
0.0019132568,
0.0942075998,
-0.0720462948,
0.0228926055,
-0.0116103757,
0.0401873849,
-0.035947144,
0.0067809136,
-0.035759896,
-0.0158168375,
-0.0240753423,
0.014557099,
0.0048040105,
-0.0275764782,
-0.0198872834,
-0.0095567685,
-0.0189447571,
-0.0692757592,
-0.0292456448,
0.0495142974,
-0.0388872847,
-0.0113218464,
-0.0374116786,
-0.0470249243,
0.0227597654,
0.0168122035,
-0.0039978689,
-0.0166017301,
-0.0431351438,
-0.0136523284,
0.0547355451,
0.0012278279,
0.0136165414,
-0.0220706817,
-0.0058693825,
0.0166932289,
-0.0320974253,
-0.0301765222,
-5.633906386e-33,
-0.0266853496,
-0.0152903488,
0.0033129405,
0.0610324293,
-0.0184585396,
-0.0498483218,
-0.0318610556,
-0.0177488811,
-0.0191433858,
-0.0256955791,
-0.0319389217,
-0.0415190049,
0.0494078249,
-0.0093318922,
0.0319826566,
0.045307368,
0.0538578928,
-0.0161083844,
-0.0138207106,
0.0387436673,
0.0418055914,
-0.0035290988,
0.0651687384,
-0.1144399866,
0.0539067611,
-0.0344224833,
-0.0180568025,
-0.0228863582,
0.0926353559,
-0.0057881055,
0.0080428421,
-0.013216286,
-0.0247289706,
-0.0196726825,
-0.0199069567,
0.0333561897,
-0.0435292684,
0.0351180024,
0.0097093647,
0.0506601743,
0.0628404841,
0.001573512,
0.003333173,
-0.0358416289,
-0.001064288,
0.0437559783,
0.0135597801,
-0.0052738111,
-0.0267448016,
-0.0146400128,
-0.0648139268,
0.0203725155,
-0.0296952259,
-0.0184065904,
0.0323056318,
0.0653006658,
0.0153601477,
-0.0536511429,
-0.0787137151,
0.0619543456,
-0.0037755617,
-0.0141278571,
0.0510078557,
-0.0301347375,
-0.0259833597,
-0.0118014971,
-0.0020113804,
0.002278046,
0.0558004119,
0.0056173918,
-0.0044853222,
0.0245075189,
0.0368737541,
0.003827696,
-0.0097400062,
-0.0254756585,
0.001110318,
0.0640530661,
0.0003256089,
-0.001569375,
0.019903481,
0.0303798448,
0.0065669152,
0.0119867241,
-0.007977277,
-0.0048555806,
0.0219510607,
-0.0331169181,
0.0284885876,
0.0037565015,
-0.0032108277,
-0.0124629373,
0.0828672424,
0.0063365172,
-0.0201222897,
-0.0203151964,
-0.0073115691,
0.0223046057,
-0.0226777848,
0.0034729664,
-0.0428356603,
-0.0211956669,
0.0313523076,
0.0289717894,
0.0119901616,
-0.0027652427,
-0.0476314165,
0.0276534203,
-0.0369821079,
0.0499946289,
0.0204290114,
0.038314186,
-0.037108954,
0.0084618488,
-0.0254886374,
-0.020033218,
0.0023266757,
0.0134794246,
-0.0005595338,
-0.0217958596,
-0.0045006811,
-0.023057064,
0.0178889576,
0.0346853174,
-0.0613187887,
0.0378987305,
-0.0087878378,
0.041742526,
0.0580784008,
0.0369169153,
0.0062144506,
-0.0557032488,
2.469e-7,
0.0518411882,
0.0392913334,
0.0312628336,
0.0150181847,
0.0115359016,
0.0124084288,
0.0002030043,
0.0176624954,
0.0038123659,
0.0483165979,
0.0244979374,
-0.0376844332,
0.1033131555,
0.0403593779,
-0.0940729678,
-0.0489027761,
-0.0500984527,
-0.0246138014,
-0.0893622637,
0.0435966961,
0.0543899946,
0.0548844524,
-0.0182047058,
0.0198768079,
-0.0020918851,
-0.045489125,
0.015908828,
-0.0168901943,
-0.007840476,
-0.0032903533,
0.0394075252,
-0.0120270951,
-0.0470089577,
-0.016103955,
-0.0386728011,
0.01915388,
-0.0002300017,
0.0481649451,
0.0046944157,
0.0138325067,
0.0104586072,
-0.0233420283,
-0.0044276235,
-0.0263777506,
-0.0062254802,
0.0060867998,
0.0082077784,
0.0137597462,
-0.0192329381,
0.0071193078,
0.0176376551,
-0.0079500414,
-0.0061237523,
0.0476586856,
0.0012004549,
-0.01663002,
-0.0101399282,
-0.0451783016,
0.0091770366,
-0.0532221943,
-0.0092841741,
-0.0288763773,
-0.0174738541,
-0.0393785089,
0.0106100859,
0.0146521367,
0.0372134112,
2.282017719e-34,
0.0289611537,
-0.0282298513,
-0.0098023228,
0.0515084118,
0.049297493,
-0.0010123793,
0.0509573184,
0.0384471007,
-0.0072541535,
-0.0300400145,
-0.0189281255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15588v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15588v1 | Few-Shot Multi-Label Aspect Category Detection Utilizing Prototypical Network with Sentence-Level Weighting and Label Augmentation | 2023-09-27T11:44:04 | 2023-09-27T11:44:04 | Zeyu Wang, Mizuho Iwaihara | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-label aspect category detection is intended to detect multiple aspect
categories occurring in a given sentence. Since aspect category detection often
suffers from limited datasets and data sparsity, the prototypical network with
attention mechanisms has been applied for few-shot aspect category detection.
Nevertheless, most of the prototypical networks used so far calculate the
prototypes by taking the mean value of all the instances in the support set.
This seems to ignore the variations between instances in multi-label aspect
category detection. Also, several related works utilize label text information
to enhance the attention mechanism. However, the label text information is
often short and limited, and not specific enough to discern categories. In this
paper, we first introduce support set attention along with the augmented label
information to mitigate the noise at word-level for each support set instance.
Moreover, we use a sentence-level attention mechanism that gives different
weights to each instance in the support set in order to compute prototypes by
weighted averaging. Finally, the calculated prototypes are further used in
conjunction with query instances to compute query attention and thereby
eliminate noises from the query set. Experimental results on the Yelp dataset
show that our proposed method is useful and outperforms all baselines in four
different scenarios. | [
0.034739688,
0.0001714417,
-0.0170931015,
0.0333630517,
-0.0098482622,
0.011286878,
0.0393384323,
-0.0039196657,
-0.0374685898,
-0.0360272825,
-0.045636218,
-0.0231446382,
-0.0289580505,
0.0458385274,
0.022622915,
0.0184006281,
0.0515535325,
0.072211504,
0.0318298899,
0.0442473888,
0.0377309807,
0.0303127728,
0.0114155933,
0.0089794016,
-0.0118138036,
-0.0206299014,
0.0072126607,
0.0289386939,
0.0324673317,
-0.0305538084,
0.0569702759,
0.0326950029,
-0.0230474155,
-0.0251664426,
0.0000018695,
-0.0093346983,
-0.027536111,
-0.0163278077,
0.0423320159,
-0.0148334596,
0.0522660092,
0.0086289495,
0.0325611308,
0.0057535465,
0.0009186973,
-0.0356882922,
0.0278626047,
0.087266475,
0.0125969332,
0.0699713603,
-0.0146016413,
-0.0542494953,
-0.0077881366,
0.0036528402,
0.0264192838,
-0.0397591665,
0.0041525788,
-0.0515090674,
-0.0197696276,
0.0512452871,
-0.0050638285,
0.0102464845,
0.0462664701,
-0.0079438984,
0.016583709,
0.0286069419,
-0.0017914703,
0.0128955208,
0.0072706519,
0.0706831068,
-0.0150290327,
-0.0227573477,
-0.0084456336,
-0.0485221073,
0.0317483209,
-0.0418659896,
0.0076032602,
-0.0222385153,
-0.0209042709,
0.0123651186,
0.0137614422,
0.0544483997,
-0.0218103696,
0.0042053596,
0.0180261731,
0.0453341193,
-0.0031418165,
-0.03317241,
-0.0063237017,
0.0586304814,
0.0040736175,
-0.0027251467,
0.0399418771,
0.0094125075,
0.0197160915,
0.0338136666,
-0.0340592004,
-0.0021656773,
-0.002343375,
-0.057929989,
-0.0010604257,
-0.0095351767,
-0.0498820953,
0.0420319997,
0.0260701701,
-0.0122518735,
-0.0004368483,
0.0073593468,
-0.0672082603,
0.0307057705,
-0.0418553464,
0.0349007621,
-0.0634501651,
0.0690119639,
0.0006135747,
-0.0098746251,
-0.0247461647,
0.004423521,
0.0495078862,
-0.0343470238,
0.0273631457,
0.0205711797,
0.0048177605,
0.0028566977,
0.0257864352,
0.0537786782,
-0.063290678,
0.0329324752,
-0.0136034051,
0.019625973,
-0.0185070653,
0.0353143513,
0.0344624557,
-0.0445194244,
-0.014426182,
-0.0079731233,
0.0258554332,
-0.0885731056,
-0.0818267837,
-0.052476503,
-0.0576443449,
-0.0536764376,
-0.0342821144,
-0.0488286279,
0.0213926081,
-0.0147533407,
-0.0028489716,
0.0324075706,
-0.0010889634,
0.0326563306,
-0.0304524787,
0.0369565077,
0.0011247003,
-0.015632743,
-0.0493638553,
0.0189815294,
0.0673864931,
0.0687387511,
-0.0131126214,
0.0471711978,
0.0265338924,
0.0154935978,
-0.0127597488,
-0.0013770175,
0.0128797991,
0.0174252558,
0.0197338313,
-0.015129596,
-0.043828845,
-0.0007855725,
0.0042665112,
-0.0008463077,
-0.0145408977,
-0.0373065993,
0.0717549995,
-0.0339094549,
0.0475583784,
0.0572392419,
0.023071155,
0.0193429831,
-0.0382254422,
0.0207471568,
-0.0323625468,
0.067517519,
-0.0347159766,
-0.0167006273,
0.01538793,
-0.0002653591,
-0.0657536313,
-0.0400150456,
0.0027621554,
0.002520228,
-0.0661406443,
-0.0084033161,
0.0534113869,
0.0150619838,
-0.0220077727,
0.0153946746,
0.0396662951,
-0.0005309125,
-0.0004967289,
-0.000009073,
0.0347967334,
0.0753577128,
0.0054684095,
-0.0334176533,
-0.0033019115,
-0.0271822847,
-0.0168810226,
0.0107168397,
0.0285530239,
0.0071464502,
0.0195331685,
-0.0454509817,
-0.0160620902,
-0.0158705264,
0.0201498661,
-0.0011117694,
0.0029377334,
0.0657699555,
0.0060206745,
-0.0814895406,
0.0381771028,
0.0033259855,
0.0668295547,
-0.0106364563,
0.0285246484,
0.0122921541,
-0.0001361726,
0.0651841015,
0.0196059607,
-0.0004652193,
0.0213414561,
-0.0224646181,
-0.0198926087,
0.0032026728,
-0.0484949276,
-0.0696016774,
0.0201441552,
0.020996999,
-0.0188438352,
-0.0135437595,
-0.0284520797,
-0.0341040865,
0.0039917347,
0.0045744292,
0.0007219118,
-0.0299326237,
0.00159835,
0.0296467151,
0.044571057,
-0.0379800573,
0.0565884262,
-0.0126851583,
0.0625259057,
-0.0392212234,
-0.0108398553,
0.0245046411,
0.0012112284,
-0.0273094922,
-0.0256155971,
-0.018394189,
0.0046801148,
0.0353985839,
0.0163418185,
-0.0665957332,
0.025881175,
-0.0607837886,
0.0104195969,
0.0025499789,
0.0283941515,
0.0333023407,
-0.0179565325,
0.0176319163,
-0.0025761139,
-0.0386248939,
0.0453828648,
-0.0639906973,
0.0369648077,
0.01521427,
0.0151350014,
0.0107730292,
0.0048967651,
-0.0181094781,
-0.0374944322,
0.0371369421,
-0.0039676689,
-0.0627980828,
-0.0669063851,
0.0205429215,
0.014796799,
-0.0231810324,
0.0307072215,
-0.0197564047,
-0.0169143528,
0.0015397188,
-0.0231606513,
0.0573901497,
-0.001336343,
0.0145361526,
0.0208535064,
0.0182350334,
-0.0185748525,
0.0322575532,
-0.0538355261,
0.031258788,
-0.0181790236,
-0.0269704293,
0.0160255022,
0.0617165901,
-0.0042318604,
0.0089298226,
-0.0404649973,
-0.0029148913,
-0.0006179738,
-0.0235125404,
-0.0082944408,
0.0534592196,
-0.0036610938,
-0.000937314,
-0.0339537151,
0.0545666739,
0.0796900243,
0.0158897676,
-0.012471254,
-0.0277393237,
-0.0095299305,
-0.0231573731,
0.0699396878,
0.0000106357,
0.0487996079,
0.0515337065,
-0.0583019108,
-0.0294852443,
-0.0185519177,
-0.0110820793,
0.0051868856,
0.0427192338,
0.0355291218,
-0.0116175227,
0.0019806575,
-0.0261143893,
0.0067535462,
-0.0457001962,
-0.0295862705,
0.0058530858,
-0.0451259948,
-0.0073453258,
-0.0481668226,
0.0040967823,
-0.0146389855,
0.0320305005,
-0.0311864018,
-0.0068467068,
0.0300308559,
0.085048832,
0.0486845598,
-0.0281975046,
-0.0031463732,
-0.0092180949,
0.0508655608,
0.0684022829,
-0.0548154153,
0.0092271306,
0.0087317359,
-0.017850047,
0.0361664928,
-0.0203730669,
-0.0031639324,
-0.0111867748,
0.0461792387,
-0.0395943709,
-0.0545376204,
0.0843840092,
0.035007745,
-0.0728344768,
-0.0135022597,
0.0406075716,
-0.0409123935,
0.0332848132,
0.0221781228,
-0.0739471838,
-0.0348018333,
-0.0484999418,
-0.0033626817,
0.017440252,
-0.0126166251,
-0.0430125967,
-0.0994948298,
0.0144180376,
-0.0113779306,
-0.0958562791,
-0.0411461443,
-0.026872687,
0.0331217572,
-0.0219426397,
0.0073920344,
0.0094961207,
0.0515403636,
-0.0231191441,
-0.0031884525,
0.0639986917,
-0.0023205315,
0.0417449139,
-0.0137229832,
0.0351225138,
-0.0121301236,
0.0202985052,
-0.0201735776,
-0.0234566182,
0.0542214736,
-0.089798592,
-0.0265455656,
0.0036647844,
0.0724267364,
-0.0733884797,
-0.00714444,
0.0010733195,
-0.0157917626,
-0.0637026951,
-0.0128027173,
-0.018118836,
0.063834846,
0.0217116252,
-0.0419162139,
-0.060724508,
-0.010125218,
0.0065905671,
0.0562792271,
0.023986835,
-0.0706845522,
0.0064697382,
0.0020463984,
-0.0617950857,
-0.0799733698,
-0.0244474988,
0.0037181717,
0.0038401587,
-0.0845145881,
-0.0356463008,
-0.0485439412,
0.0044049467,
0.0149577353,
-0.0366116464,
0.0064158831,
0.0141833676,
0.0056419056,
-0.0483482741,
-0.0143735632,
-0.0261460077,
0.0206748303,
-0.0165633895,
0.0162054505,
0.0819100067,
-0.0399743691,
-0.0195891652,
-0.0037239036,
-0.0735124573,
-0.035602238,
-0.0019582256,
-0.0067785848,
-0.0063698548,
0.0065170829,
-0.0617581978,
-0.0391626246,
-0.0095937625,
0.0501519553,
-0.0172090717,
0.0059296843,
0.0187256727,
0.0052306936,
-0.0013890102,
0.0539685488,
-0.0544946529,
0.0641356483,
0.0322236866,
-0.0075369696,
-0.0706353709,
-0.0757232606,
0.0243854802,
0.0003774174,
0.0784870833,
0.0121787228,
-0.0017132366,
-0.0214611776,
0.0364880972,
0.0308790598,
-0.0427767374,
-0.0248757545,
-0.0219868422,
0.0115874112,
-0.0397185422,
-0.0475708395,
0.0219240896,
-0.0110841803,
0.0076589063,
-0.0431982689,
-0.0091573009,
-0.0292029288,
-0.008863627,
-0.0305723995,
0.0199627839,
-0.0365908071,
0.0041278694,
0.0124815777,
0.0266064014,
-0.0067805019,
0.0163020454,
-0.0033760518,
-0.0138138626,
-0.0235744789,
0.0398233682,
-0.0419618525,
0.0785046816,
-0.055542957,
-0.0297665559,
-0.0106003368,
-0.0569751561,
0.0080397967,
0.011581406,
-0.0058233468,
-0.0314163528,
0.0212646034,
-0.0206867009,
-0.0160363298,
0.029117018,
0.0185851268,
-0.0017012665,
-0.0109916143,
0.0372095034,
-0.0311496332,
0.0158544257,
0.0447727032,
-0.0250470918,
0.0111829443,
0.0246699434,
-0.0394450538,
0.0677388161,
-0.011584851,
0.0322669558,
-0.0383281894,
-0.0271838028,
-0.004981135,
-0.0470779836,
0.0345460549,
0.0413526408,
0.0455417447,
0.0247739125,
0.0274512488,
0.0199031662,
-0.0336587504,
-0.0207179654,
0.0094089909,
-0.0036038703,
0.0229055695,
-6.693651277e-33,
-0.0398103483,
-0.0449283533,
-0.0331551172,
-0.0340393148,
-0.0114674671,
0.0284180865,
-0.0252009388,
0.030626744,
-0.0354798622,
0.013934521,
0.031345915,
0.0627821013,
0.0075013451,
0.0112382006,
0.0008827381,
-0.0283225011,
0.02202061,
0.0142502384,
0.018015923,
0.0308547039,
0.0033247084,
0.0361064598,
0.1228634119,
-0.0807368308,
-0.0188181009,
0.0166365579,
-0.0498013869,
-0.0032257773,
-0.0050930013,
0.090105094,
0.0350605026,
0.077482231,
0.0441582538,
-0.0247514211,
0.0118012689,
0.0080591189,
-0.0685956404,
-0.0359386057,
0.0221944842,
0.0222620182,
0.0119490363,
-0.0538144447,
0.0284219999,
0.0094525106,
0.0449528992,
-0.0504797101,
0.0358964652,
-0.0179019831,
-0.0156530477,
-0.0734537914,
0.0086139645,
0.0407574028,
0.0271613952,
-0.0087373974,
0.0168906115,
0.012653443,
0.022973109,
0.0568702519,
-0.0264868084,
0.022741193,
-0.043964766,
0.0305283125,
-0.0199820381,
0.005643894,
-0.0431821644,
0.0401566587,
-0.002210459,
0.0265915822,
-0.001240812,
-0.0444776639,
0.0121799428,
-0.0030264095,
0.0321760289,
0.0188190676,
0.0127730975,
0.0000677412,
-0.0381314196,
-0.0102532106,
0.0116409501,
-0.0134751312,
0.0475167744,
0.0131591652,
-0.0449441969,
-0.0175099205,
0.009008538,
-0.0777974129,
-0.1076506525,
0.0011052678,
0.0113454573,
0.050276462,
-0.0183592923,
0.0521707609,
0.0073197233,
-0.0563991331,
0.0040507405,
0.0186587442,
-0.0156620014,
0.0572838821,
0.0191482678,
0.0320431031,
-0.0976682007,
-0.0162530132,
-0.004841004,
0.0212816335,
-0.0174138919,
0.0009617743,
0.1080089435,
-0.0062223966,
-0.0688772351,
-0.0203575082,
-0.0101677096,
-0.0376706421,
-0.0269735362,
0.0229588505,
0.0036392545,
0.0267107897,
-0.0413568057,
0.1142232716,
0.0417414159,
-0.0047062794,
-0.0355448052,
-0.010653751,
0.0153605817,
0.0579712428,
-0.0153260436,
-0.0139269363,
0.0282684062,
-0.0047589447,
0.0249500908,
-0.0197243802,
-0.0412626378,
0.0259463433,
2.725e-7,
0.0377152637,
-0.0096203778,
-0.0282192808,
0.0064665093,
0.0316899046,
0.0402008034,
0.037386287,
0.0563110858,
-0.0218469016,
-0.0243289713,
0.0416986719,
0.0187553186,
-0.0312751383,
-0.000408761,
-0.0727948844,
0.0423580669,
0.0082867397,
0.0019937095,
-0.0426331088,
0.0114652654,
0.0878718197,
0.0975793898,
0.0485651009,
0.0245297737,
0.0219428353,
-0.0054778997,
0.0043581468,
0.0309828725,
-0.0197671447,
-0.0050432393,
-0.0594622269,
0.0771627054,
-0.0201595239,
-0.0219601989,
-0.0182463583,
0.0055403602,
0.0104617998,
0.0557526164,
-0.0291798953,
-0.057313621,
-0.0003007146,
-0.0054491102,
0.0147116054,
-0.0289364643,
0.0739281923,
-0.0312337354,
-0.0212555677,
-0.0361657888,
0.0005586247,
0.0177482124,
0.0023290662,
0.0277549047,
-0.0330143496,
-0.0051971888,
0.0109285628,
-0.0376291424,
-0.0359277837,
-0.1129512712,
-0.0288370438,
0.0600308441,
0.0135120833,
-0.0314247906,
-0.0205241609,
-0.0216211993,
-0.004342712,
-0.0826263502,
-0.023398634,
2.080339852e-34,
0.0326621942,
0.0122398408,
0.0153668439,
0.0327988714,
-0.0312754661,
-0.0362807028,
-0.0413540304,
-0.0476759784,
0.0269318186,
-0.0175663494,
-0.0078347381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15564v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15564v2 | Jointly Training Large Autoregressive Multimodal Models | 2023-09-27T10:40:23 | 2023-09-28T17:23:11 | Emanuele Aiello, Lili Yu, Yixin Nie, Armen Aghajanyan, Barlas Oguz | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | In recent years, advances in the large-scale pretraining of language and
text-to-image models have revolutionized the field of machine learning. Yet,
integrating these two modalities into a single, robust model capable of
generating seamless multimodal outputs remains a significant challenge. To
address this gap, we present the Joint Autoregressive Mixture (JAM) framework,
a modular approach that systematically fuses existing text and image generation
models. We also introduce a specialized, data-efficient instruction-tuning
strategy, tailored for mixed-modal generation tasks. Our final instruct-tuned
model demonstrates unparalleled performance in generating high-quality
multimodal outputs and represents the first model explicitly designed for this
purpose. | [
0.008529433,
0.0963097811,
0.0279620066,
0.0136188753,
-0.0017560252,
0.0059502763,
0.0283498727,
-0.013558466,
-0.0353588313,
-0.059359353,
-0.0660962537,
-0.0333063342,
-0.000611582,
0.0478475802,
0.0462417118,
-0.0596753024,
0.0194703601,
-0.0424394645,
-0.051583007,
0.0012134484,
0.0247649122,
0.0397174135,
-0.0220188517,
0.0400619879,
-0.0733595267,
-0.0281011313,
-0.0129249925,
0.034153387,
0.0170528721,
-0.0046925624,
-0.0012475152,
0.0603097044,
0.0381955355,
0.0244279355,
0.00000189,
-0.0002331063,
0.012632479,
0.004386873,
0.0495389625,
0.0024418153,
0.0550826862,
-0.0290966574,
-0.0017122618,
0.0008456153,
-0.0075135445,
-0.0003735156,
0.0538181067,
0.026877705,
0.1046756953,
0.0700075179,
-0.0211039409,
-0.0295732152,
-0.0010129506,
-0.0409478061,
0.0381161049,
0.0086945808,
-0.0145984506,
0.0118452003,
-0.0090293465,
0.0028747302,
-0.0400484763,
0.0503881723,
0.0408539996,
-0.01876246,
0.0188367963,
0.0380640812,
0.0261089206,
-0.0206240546,
-0.0356891118,
0.0748086423,
-0.0400469825,
0.0112412544,
-0.0174540151,
-0.0152763743,
-0.0256171394,
-0.001445687,
-0.0117495321,
0.0265925582,
0.0116249826,
0.0203924216,
-0.0503933206,
0.005106213,
0.0025864379,
-0.0147619415,
0.0136419013,
-0.0339212939,
0.0274343193,
0.0267016347,
-0.0343698487,
0.0213947091,
-0.0131803043,
-0.0427095406,
0.008018788,
0.0390455164,
-0.0089605432,
-0.0216208305,
-0.079186894,
-0.0360081084,
-0.0060860319,
0.0069286819,
0.0689863116,
0.0191884637,
-0.0486827344,
0.0356157646,
-0.0250915065,
0.0016871913,
-0.0220786445,
-0.0015509106,
-0.0180242267,
0.0110563803,
-0.0232660994,
-0.0160663016,
-0.0256183259,
-0.0212109294,
-0.0422612242,
-0.0458151996,
-0.0520444661,
0.0172717422,
-0.0028763823,
-0.0070932191,
0.0216208026,
0.0420125164,
-0.0846933201,
-0.0472990498,
-0.0073219729,
0.0225635599,
0.0042144465,
0.0317488983,
0.0258707963,
-0.0182140879,
-0.004527289,
0.0518215671,
0.0030477482,
-0.0091748023,
-0.0108023304,
0.0962420776,
-0.08796978,
-0.0088007748,
-0.0351829268,
-0.0482478403,
-0.0368137434,
-0.0625545606,
0.0345278159,
-0.029291708,
0.0304852538,
-0.0133842137,
0.010473378,
-0.0058342181,
0.003645435,
-0.0139374929,
0.0316028409,
0.0561237596,
0.0162326247,
-0.0063814274,
0.0430968627,
0.0009013144,
0.0004149468,
0.0777477622,
0.034211617,
0.0666518211,
-0.0157932881,
0.018264614,
0.0053680041,
0.031514667,
0.0013123853,
0.015757639,
-0.0319483913,
-0.0401166342,
0.007832055,
0.0156040657,
0.0578787029,
0.0660210699,
-0.0175464824,
-0.0015672004,
0.0777699128,
-0.0313971899,
0.0419677384,
0.0290392861,
0.0942468792,
-0.0081324503,
-0.0010827205,
0.0088042859,
-0.0040086373,
0.0573194958,
-0.0084372927,
0.0166231766,
0.0702303797,
0.0783033818,
-0.0476437658,
-0.0252473541,
0.0483452566,
-0.0414044969,
-0.0101594888,
-0.0337867104,
0.0368048362,
0.0198742021,
-0.0835938379,
-0.0244922359,
0.0096292021,
-0.0224972293,
0.0569195598,
-0.028065376,
-0.0165773854,
0.0424398296,
0.0260914695,
0.0113610169,
0.0143535901,
-0.0178346541,
0.0078229923,
0.0579583459,
-0.0194323231,
0.0091732712,
0.0572049581,
-0.060306631,
-0.0359793976,
-0.0297901593,
0.0178527646,
0.0603063889,
-0.0376441404,
0.0217471123,
0.0379834846,
0.0159877595,
0.0230623297,
0.0431840792,
-0.0107344724,
-0.0131601011,
0.0023197962,
0.008645013,
0.0101512428,
-0.0334553644,
-0.0318018645,
0.0154927121,
-0.0145368716,
-0.05644802,
0.0092258174,
0.0343409888,
-0.0583957471,
-0.0539718755,
-0.015626153,
-0.0346671343,
0.0176025126,
-0.0319723338,
-0.0351886228,
-0.044448711,
0.0119295288,
-0.0313883498,
0.0146345682,
-0.0617016405,
-0.0062763751,
0.0687791407,
0.0029584991,
0.0006083912,
0.0234490763,
-0.0296431649,
-0.0467697084,
0.0175996628,
0.0089833289,
-0.0200361963,
-0.016121313,
-0.0223825779,
-0.0198767893,
0.0149864145,
0.0111468192,
0.0124327727,
0.025837088,
-0.0411022492,
-0.0575404763,
-0.0761050433,
-0.0142893111,
-0.006450491,
-0.0279255621,
0.0039948178,
0.0069660596,
0.011749763,
-0.0094333841,
-0.019475501,
0.0352588519,
0.0412240364,
0.0096375076,
0.0068691247,
0.0102130529,
0.025005715,
-0.0323479027,
-0.0135444067,
0.02793926,
0.0525734089,
0.0101914667,
0.0158630237,
-0.0233938247,
-0.0089682434,
-0.0363311172,
0.0046272008,
-0.0153540792,
-0.035625875,
0.0119654341,
-0.0049474095,
0.0967834592,
0.0519009754,
0.0466707721,
0.0244152602,
-0.0014301715,
-0.0317825824,
-0.0249211937,
0.022647474,
-0.0180084351,
-0.0049370984,
0.0156518444,
-0.0254007224,
-0.0002753763,
0.039433796,
0.0186477695,
0.0370328575,
-0.0732974932,
0.0148597425,
0.0084735658,
-0.0618261583,
-0.03050901,
0.0186308119,
-0.0005497393,
-0.0104847457,
-0.0415029898,
-0.0658749342,
0.0205297489,
-0.0288508777,
-0.0160979684,
0.0245718956,
0.0149967382,
-0.0153086307,
0.0374642201,
0.0248503834,
0.0413070992,
-0.0148517834,
0.0067167305,
-0.0506378971,
0.0316789597,
0.0446774065,
-0.0054186336,
0.0300619453,
-0.0073243654,
0.0172768161,
-0.0152304592,
-0.0244335141,
-0.0311661717,
-0.0459494367,
0.0229984969,
-0.0188537557,
0.0055712364,
-0.0110346852,
-0.0177827571,
0.0231087562,
0.0100134127,
0.0102268867,
-0.012257765,
-0.0248865597,
-0.0270889364,
0.0578324385,
0.0258455966,
-0.0074793715,
-0.0575040504,
-0.0839710236,
0.0071171201,
0.0202031899,
0.0216175616,
-0.0064556659,
-0.0610627122,
0.0374896526,
0.0018659012,
0.0625767037,
-0.0145443315,
0.02792578,
0.0916029364,
-0.0400848351,
-0.000081512,
0.0451513641,
-0.0156319458,
-0.0338098779,
-0.0186113752,
0.0520133264,
0.0717008039,
0.000403755,
0.0140757775,
-0.0775758177,
-0.0516850352,
-0.0133475792,
-0.0139322896,
0.0333813801,
0.0169660561,
-0.0375476666,
-0.0635592937,
0.0527442507,
0.0322218947,
-0.0132460063,
-0.0184341203,
-0.000529449,
-0.0137314256,
0.0004991688,
-0.0207662974,
0.0043461146,
-0.0317386836,
0.0172815267,
0.0333007053,
0.0326931253,
-0.0723821372,
-0.03439698,
-0.014745011,
0.0378867239,
0.043965809,
0.0175229702,
0.0106103504,
-0.0314539745,
0.0470024981,
0.0234915782,
0.0171576627,
-0.0159581993,
0.0318692774,
-0.0307830386,
-0.0115009397,
0.0024696665,
0.0315131657,
0.0076124109,
-0.0112489183,
-0.0029721854,
0.0143575706,
-0.0190379005,
0.0107659651,
-0.0543801971,
0.0254120938,
0.0374602564,
0.017986428,
0.0115930764,
-0.0462308936,
-0.0264554266,
-0.0260877423,
0.0366487764,
-0.0775173679,
-0.0086065531,
-0.0064987745,
-0.017079344,
-0.0256676469,
-0.0622244664,
-0.0094577735,
0.0138094062,
0.0531283729,
-0.0154097974,
-0.0302786212,
-0.0535600223,
0.0006815003,
-0.0365209617,
0.0402617939,
-0.0028181253,
0.0086125238,
-0.0816441923,
-0.0401248336,
0.0046915971,
-0.041767057,
-0.0156345982,
0.0247299336,
-0.098708041,
-0.0574912615,
-0.0312438961,
0.0937160701,
0.0058134831,
0.0398795381,
0.0345662795,
-0.0264639445,
0.0489944033,
0.0665645078,
-0.0142919794,
0.0046735131,
0.0234076083,
0.0096128834,
-0.0232450664,
0.0001358473,
-0.0240112189,
0.047381673,
-0.0032987427,
0.0264185835,
0.0257620905,
-0.0502936356,
0.0128997732,
-0.0342420414,
-0.0144473249,
-0.0726986229,
0.0263242107,
-0.0650047436,
-0.0493600965,
-0.0326810032,
-0.0067756525,
-0.086916104,
0.0077810101,
0.0315799192,
0.0007643193,
-0.0019251257,
0.0287132915,
0.0413218401,
0.0745468363,
-0.02677604,
0.017753195,
0.020167714,
0.0189254731,
-0.0049344259,
0.0204969421,
0.002252707,
0.032636404,
-0.0132782701,
0.0102138156,
-0.0091301063,
0.0648263395,
-0.0034061261,
-0.0041077496,
-0.0259806458,
0.0351992473,
-0.0076894057,
0.0103496118,
-0.0864538625,
0.0525807366,
0.0435680076,
0.0109016532,
0.0568900742,
-0.0243980624,
-0.0167942494,
-0.0232210401,
0.0714755207,
0.0129881762,
-0.01578377,
0.0153379049,
-0.0167782642,
0.0072819204,
-0.0204017218,
0.0789090618,
-0.0005415045,
0.0257237293,
0.0012753926,
0.0225487184,
-0.0591684803,
-0.0158812739,
0.0554822199,
-0.0076339175,
0.0132069401,
0.0275750645,
0.0120958351,
-0.0451031998,
-0.0051455814,
0.0283489171,
-0.0085856793,
0.0386131816,
0.0576034077,
0.0219015181,
0.0001603842,
0.0057838922,
-0.0331592709,
0.0010034151,
0.0278646909,
0.0056013763,
0.025063077,
-6.012460015e-33,
-0.0509476103,
-0.0228034295,
0.0186957009,
-0.0782258585,
-0.0241740886,
0.0180263855,
-0.006660495,
0.0176781751,
0.0295121279,
-0.0144910654,
0.0319816545,
-0.0319448858,
0.003013168,
0.0430176184,
0.0065469178,
0.0586655885,
0.0666018203,
-0.0356349982,
-0.0198073443,
0.0443849452,
0.0302620623,
0.0271181278,
0.0042520724,
-0.0281388275,
-0.0400610305,
0.0192142781,
-0.0716283247,
-0.0101861451,
0.0219045449,
0.0440649763,
-0.0402049609,
0.0096237594,
0.0016542377,
0.0076923561,
-0.0324767046,
0.0229086746,
-0.0472646505,
-0.0025564949,
-0.0222150236,
-0.0269178059,
-0.1069815606,
-0.0113573885,
0.015303093,
-0.0286783539,
-0.0006343803,
-0.0440499038,
0.0543078445,
-0.0103764348,
0.0097971102,
-0.0440963581,
-0.0671847239,
0.0100915907,
-0.0338113308,
-0.058226198,
0.0185238905,
0.058951918,
0.0341127142,
-0.00901559,
-0.0361707434,
0.0405886248,
-0.0082982006,
0.0468082651,
0.0575983711,
0.0746428594,
0.0068883211,
0.0446630009,
0.0109062893,
-0.0112458859,
-0.0307507161,
0.0231353585,
0.0168928448,
0.0752264634,
-0.0100799678,
0.0662872493,
0.0187102742,
0.0062947432,
-0.035116829,
0.059522476,
-0.0054468098,
0.0046317228,
0.0224155784,
0.0070301685,
0.031734053,
0.0265844315,
-0.0323769934,
-0.0301404931,
-0.0235281345,
-0.0257189292,
0.0309670549,
0.064536348,
-0.0224765465,
-0.0308656748,
0.0829564855,
0.0145120332,
-0.0207218602,
-0.0040665334,
-0.0482639261,
0.036756549,
-0.0170326158,
0.0254289657,
-0.0275650322,
-0.0531038232,
0.0977705494,
-0.0013273277,
-0.0020831437,
0.0008082457,
0.0082644057,
0.0534358881,
-0.0509806275,
0.0043075294,
-0.0265100095,
0.0478498265,
0.0137461647,
0.0250842404,
0.0260046851,
-0.0330360681,
-0.0672218725,
0.0335260816,
-0.0235729236,
0.0143244723,
-0.0136628402,
-0.0542371981,
0.0060015814,
0.0304371398,
-0.0233847909,
0.0504157767,
-0.0432344787,
-0.0714736804,
0.0278876089,
-0.0574791655,
-0.0335271098,
0.014081331,
2.424e-7,
0.0209635589,
-0.0022126385,
0.0088856518,
-0.0086469483,
0.0066097011,
0.0346880183,
-0.0309705082,
0.0339360051,
0.0236987118,
-0.0346273147,
0.0143308863,
0.0311133619,
0.0578761585,
0.0158662926,
0.0313735269,
0.0246097296,
-0.0664139763,
0.0315553248,
-0.0429443903,
-0.033313334,
0.0449809171,
0.0620914847,
-0.0304378606,
-0.0244610738,
0.0327070653,
-0.0050140526,
0.1145968586,
0.0039053969,
-0.0456827506,
-0.0137162246,
0.0428608581,
0.0023058103,
-0.0181405451,
-0.0143536786,
-0.0204515308,
-0.0431131795,
0.0346226953,
0.034279108,
-0.0256712697,
-0.059453927,
0.0314570516,
0.0650961623,
-0.0343987979,
-0.0061182901,
0.0552700013,
-0.0452530943,
-0.0111953802,
-0.063663289,
-0.0377442464,
0.0283424743,
0.0472827144,
-0.0514798351,
-0.0752855167,
0.0239094328,
0.0592758991,
0.0121986512,
-0.0358943939,
-0.049711287,
-0.0437157527,
-0.009836291,
-0.0852204561,
-0.0006178397,
-0.0707175806,
-0.0132111069,
0.0213492215,
-0.036808826,
-0.0481082723,
1.956787819e-34,
0.0219208915,
-0.0299070645,
0.0241091195,
-0.0276444647,
0.0201301631,
0.0109562408,
-0.0581240654,
0.0093799271,
-0.0025263561,
-0.062315926,
-0.0570263714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15554v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15554v1 | Direct Models for Simultaneous Translation and Automatic Subtitling: FBK@IWSLT2023 | 2023-09-27T10:24:42 | 2023-09-27T10:24:42 | Sara Papi, Marco Gaido, Matteo Negri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper describes the FBK's participation in the Simultaneous Translation
and Automatic Subtitling tracks of the IWSLT 2023 Evaluation Campaign. Our
submission focused on the use of direct architectures to perform both tasks:
for the simultaneous one, we leveraged the knowledge already acquired by
offline-trained models and directly applied a policy to obtain the real-time
inference; for the subtitling one, we adapted the direct ST model to produce
well-formed subtitles and exploited the same architecture to produce timestamps
needed for the subtitle synchronization with audiovisual content. Our
English-German SimulST system shows a reduced computational-aware latency
compared to the one achieved by the top-ranked systems in the 2021 and 2022
rounds of the task, with gains of up to 3.5 BLEU. Our automatic subtitling
system outperforms the only existing solution based on a direct system by 3.7
and 1.7 SubER in English-German and English-Spanish respectively. | [
0.0377988219,
0.0227674395,
-0.0028964444,
0.0203666072,
-0.0315397158,
0.0206475258,
0.0445984416,
-0.0165343098,
-0.007139686,
0.0089045549,
-0.0409811772,
-0.0594223551,
-0.0191518087,
0.0348104723,
0.0035625619,
-0.0925970301,
0.0396191925,
-0.0284944139,
0.0084335608,
-0.0064182864,
-0.0031534273,
0.0110572847,
-0.029273387,
-0.0177368987,
-0.0301565453,
-0.0104137501,
-0.0124459798,
0.0263111703,
0.0469018854,
-0.0108773699,
-0.0013726903,
0.0129164159,
0.0596073419,
0.087591365,
0.0000016162,
-0.0129650943,
-0.0301649962,
0.0059437174,
0.0061177891,
0.0207950417,
0.0587332919,
-0.0411395207,
-0.0567207113,
0.017434245,
-0.0206787996,
-0.0092405295,
0.063091971,
-0.0117457202,
0.048827704,
0.0388305746,
-0.0401248038,
-0.06185247,
-0.0028438277,
-0.0532958172,
-0.0457613394,
-0.0506618135,
-0.0310776457,
0.0105133532,
-0.0351759978,
-0.0033988822,
-0.0131301265,
0.0835963711,
0.0391687676,
-0.0208838154,
-0.0388414338,
0.0188583303,
-0.0363006219,
-0.031660676,
-0.0340579934,
0.0646979734,
0.0026534121,
0.0135666942,
-0.0028745278,
-0.0098911682,
-0.0235935245,
-0.0560716204,
-0.0877832621,
0.0078586042,
0.012839417,
-0.0199648943,
0.0141560081,
0.0807293877,
0.0238402523,
-0.0079561947,
0.0241091289,
0.0247988775,
0.0471530482,
-0.0143903764,
-0.0139916642,
0.0113758175,
0.0058626309,
-0.0622806959,
0.0371244103,
0.0088427039,
0.0102570876,
0.0131533714,
-0.0625772104,
-0.0332761928,
-0.0590611957,
-0.0626614168,
0.0134358574,
0.0829870775,
-0.0204898715,
0.0757809654,
-0.0140451537,
0.0773838758,
-0.038216766,
0.0073665907,
-0.0347599871,
-0.0200919602,
-0.0120185232,
0.0063238624,
-0.051216267,
0.0097531462,
-0.0841157958,
-0.0405357033,
-0.0388122723,
0.0012467102,
0.0039204839,
0.0133623173,
-0.0115333702,
-0.0171692148,
-0.0597961023,
-0.0219265148,
-0.0051471214,
0.0739108622,
0.0096874209,
-0.0158417523,
-0.0016311903,
-0.0275541805,
-0.027090624,
0.0131865749,
-0.021422388,
-0.0339203179,
0.0069259466,
0.059133485,
-0.0571563877,
-0.0140861385,
-0.009492375,
-0.0219120346,
-0.0310864225,
-0.0286200829,
-0.0244489871,
-0.064794369,
0.0702537596,
-0.003733021,
0.0086211562,
-0.0091051944,
0.0103094764,
-0.0016486025,
0.0300470535,
0.0626230687,
-0.0196699537,
0.0187658388,
-0.0037292289,
0.0101948716,
-0.0049932813,
0.0671995655,
0.0428586192,
0.0351722762,
0.0363883525,
0.0558720306,
-0.0385473557,
0.0978978351,
-0.0113866664,
0.0365377031,
-0.0549185202,
-0.0094189681,
0.0123170866,
0.0357965827,
0.0439317599,
0.0184457023,
0.0004862114,
-0.0058563231,
0.0834828466,
0.0009580266,
-0.0152553916,
0.0307221729,
0.0876889601,
0.0202356931,
0.0094184177,
0.0236012489,
0.032025028,
0.0738314465,
0.0510043949,
0.0310825668,
0.0155771105,
0.0289929379,
-0.0253518336,
-0.0290978327,
-0.0027506032,
-0.0155480718,
-0.0255273636,
0.001128242,
0.0420477614,
0.0144180944,
-0.0562240109,
0.0616335943,
-0.0023207609,
-0.0270738136,
0.0297230203,
-0.0240661949,
-0.0298173819,
0.0951608792,
0.0380953178,
-0.0111731132,
-0.010667487,
-0.0017219818,
0.0596940294,
0.0819240436,
0.0866029039,
-0.0415899716,
0.0202270132,
-0.0401177853,
-0.0277889762,
0.0333360694,
-0.0251319371,
0.0407193713,
-0.027396353,
0.0222015474,
0.0001060497,
0.0508839153,
-0.054631494,
-0.0088064456,
-0.0416953303,
-0.0069488953,
-0.0324575081,
0.0198928881,
0.003234627,
0.0449164659,
-0.0375231542,
-0.0170168318,
-0.0028354428,
-0.037723437,
-0.0063159121,
0.0661233366,
-0.0352550596,
-0.0415397026,
0.0280213282,
-0.0081571564,
0.0119635956,
0.0526883267,
-0.0406729989,
-0.0696150959,
-0.0137521075,
-0.0159946457,
0.0056425058,
-0.0232377052,
0.0204629414,
0.0191734843,
-0.023663979,
-0.0267713349,
-0.0021514823,
-0.008430548,
-0.0142438486,
0.0502980612,
-0.0609164536,
0.0381512158,
-0.0435537137,
-0.0135926455,
0.07564044,
-0.000540762,
-0.0168443583,
0.022879526,
-0.0143449474,
-0.0249540266,
-0.0064748074,
-0.0530922525,
0.0150052868,
-0.0157459099,
0.0410302132,
0.0163536277,
0.0548082888,
-0.0125932349,
-0.0415773652,
0.0130055211,
-0.029161714,
-0.0055453265,
-0.0243160147,
-0.0099959746,
0.0224338491,
-0.0006228991,
-0.0147089558,
-0.0201158877,
-0.007032101,
-0.0028268313,
0.0067626801,
-0.0378316864,
-0.0258893222,
-0.0216204785,
-0.0153327323,
0.0160959121,
0.0022926021,
-0.0472791865,
-0.024490077,
0.0244563557,
-0.0061954297,
0.0216117259,
-0.0174457468,
-0.0197098088,
-0.0102824327,
-0.0046329368,
-0.0129366778,
0.0497701764,
0.0081922552,
-0.0458219163,
-0.0192894675,
0.0103573902,
-0.0396302752,
0.0571943223,
0.0126601793,
0.0223133024,
-0.082668446,
-0.0063680243,
-0.0402489342,
0.0030007609,
-0.0110874632,
-0.0174895748,
-0.0251705721,
0.0287498031,
-0.0242307447,
-0.0546136349,
0.0382577367,
-0.058401484,
-0.0376560763,
-0.0600664169,
-0.0024112922,
-0.0131134009,
0.0567088239,
-0.0139788063,
0.0221812613,
-0.0519839786,
-0.0384237617,
-0.0443752222,
0.0314919092,
0.0334823243,
-0.0236315038,
0.0007302836,
-0.0106281852,
0.0134097273,
-0.0453245938,
-0.0301084295,
-0.0110050151,
-0.024767356,
-0.0463798083,
0.0122004673,
-0.0195685998,
-0.030213397,
-0.0451855324,
0.03687061,
0.0155036505,
0.0848128051,
-0.0195916649,
-0.002605519,
-0.0278136283,
0.0487135611,
0.0400543995,
-0.01441315,
-0.0371797569,
-0.0410962105,
0.0383486412,
-0.0078291753,
0.0724337995,
0.0004296678,
-0.0435312018,
0.00447238,
0.0586630031,
-0.0087322677,
-0.022247633,
-0.0222623274,
0.0301626623,
-0.059523616,
0.0205627661,
0.1507960409,
0.0253727809,
-0.0344621986,
-0.0196521226,
0.0207297746,
0.0070106792,
0.035450764,
0.007032658,
-0.0863955021,
-0.018111106,
0.0078016748,
0.0233476534,
0.0187924113,
0.0365298614,
-0.0374689437,
-0.0530468076,
0.0685845837,
0.0632812008,
-0.0256731473,
0.0048834337,
0.0496062897,
-0.0348259099,
-0.0237413719,
-0.0007017013,
-0.0115669072,
0.0025434056,
0.0032186764,
0.0209680572,
0.008099786,
-0.0470519885,
0.0208724793,
-0.0345466286,
0.0376666524,
0.0667730048,
0.0426574089,
-0.0107526854,
-0.0362039506,
0.0183169339,
-0.0393621475,
0.0113163022,
-0.000228858,
0.0298130196,
-0.0431553721,
-0.0326144695,
-0.0208801832,
-0.0043601342,
0.0292715803,
0.0127515625,
-0.0016375348,
0.050575342,
-0.0084375842,
0.049054835,
-0.0084092049,
0.030570481,
0.0241875835,
0.0511815585,
-0.0101540266,
-0.0109501006,
0.0176702142,
-0.000545981,
-0.0056625144,
-0.0850203559,
0.0065726442,
-0.0049164994,
-0.0514689498,
-0.0483132564,
-0.0467940383,
-0.0265731383,
-0.017458206,
0.0417014211,
0.0173637271,
0.0176704116,
0.0056295446,
-0.0056660771,
-0.0756668746,
-0.0095712254,
0.0104494924,
0.0303819682,
-0.0363644734,
-0.0165417027,
0.0333225019,
-0.0348820426,
-0.0252384935,
0.0575386509,
-0.0537455343,
-0.0691122562,
-0.0174800605,
0.0539287664,
0.0319951251,
0.0799695402,
-0.0359943584,
-0.0291766077,
-0.0095807724,
-0.0131305102,
0.0204919949,
0.0042189318,
0.0216009524,
-0.0303649083,
-0.0439127274,
0.0336981341,
-0.0201990046,
0.0159196258,
-0.0039819018,
0.0592815019,
0.0665139779,
0.0178022142,
-0.0093699964,
0.0004815427,
0.016329525,
-0.038743753,
-0.0280636102,
-0.0277718455,
0.0330252983,
-0.0050500194,
0.0272008423,
-0.0407603458,
0.0077887867,
0.0591595657,
0.0117084095,
-0.0244818442,
0.0440240242,
-0.0029305445,
-0.0677184835,
0.0128145525,
-0.0013802921,
-0.0058760182,
0.0034849797,
0.0028956477,
-0.015298319,
0.0177136008,
0.0404912308,
0.0273915585,
0.0021069811,
-0.01611045,
0.031660445,
0.0269061811,
0.0394010022,
0.0031823188,
0.0543290563,
-0.0187458973,
0.010738316,
-0.0278052036,
0.0174517371,
0.0987485424,
-0.0316916332,
0.0802680328,
-0.0150245875,
-0.0291278157,
-0.003342066,
0.0243938863,
-0.0255893655,
-0.0387156457,
0.0068090707,
-0.0032990247,
-0.0121968845,
0.0557493605,
0.0512180068,
0.0133415079,
-0.0036975567,
0.0368331857,
-0.0375073478,
0.0034114181,
-0.0103107393,
-0.0135349017,
-0.0212075952,
-0.0197898522,
0.0124946414,
-0.037408974,
-0.0527443066,
0.0212580282,
0.0142786996,
-0.0027632266,
-0.0237365533,
0.0320137031,
0.0494377874,
-0.0147122601,
-0.0141875846,
0.007026738,
-0.0332003161,
-0.0228368137,
-0.0343930312,
-0.014983343,
-5.632131757e-33,
-0.0562315434,
0.0067017614,
0.0078255087,
-0.0045347335,
-0.1152909249,
0.0208766963,
-0.0204107985,
-0.0308584496,
0.0082283318,
0.0013835618,
0.0174955875,
0.0220678784,
0.0571576804,
0.010259443,
-0.0001388637,
-0.0117739737,
0.0707744136,
-0.0424108244,
-0.0491200611,
0.0158569645,
0.0217770189,
0.0340216644,
0.0594353341,
-0.0095008314,
-0.00213758,
-0.0200552233,
0.026322972,
0.0079092579,
0.030201152,
0.0521903671,
0.0251579639,
0.0073963157,
-0.0114843994,
-0.0408895612,
-0.0085068159,
0.0170245823,
-0.0958575755,
0.007544572,
0.0345807225,
0.0734193325,
-0.0091334339,
-0.025947582,
0.0079159969,
-0.0184248909,
-0.0218504872,
-0.0248701219,
0.0034335665,
-0.0394756533,
0.0161927845,
-0.0466025062,
-0.0746919587,
0.0103456937,
-0.0097554391,
-0.0164355263,
0.0892672911,
0.0219933614,
0.0378134251,
-0.0261384714,
-0.0629188195,
0.0095474096,
-0.0190357734,
0.0555651747,
0.1163918748,
-0.0236976482,
-0.0199913494,
0.0011434045,
0.0142865125,
-0.0348355807,
0.0356548764,
-0.0004358678,
0.007850552,
0.0137370545,
0.0526262335,
0.001754927,
0.0298814587,
0.0003730103,
-0.0424807742,
0.027639037,
0.0053816768,
-0.0224799514,
0.0254923943,
0.0391733199,
-0.0494237095,
0.0293408502,
-0.0216412246,
-0.0378392413,
0.0042985049,
-0.0838090852,
0.0405138545,
0.0160066262,
0.0496506989,
-0.0223356728,
0.0832082629,
-0.0221782103,
0.0502999909,
-0.0374553464,
-0.0154081406,
0.0430557355,
-0.025716057,
0.0574558191,
-0.0194109436,
0.0045494153,
0.013553842,
0.0545085259,
0.0019533762,
-0.0131490221,
0.0192446709,
0.0688240603,
-0.0086604171,
0.0001267889,
-0.0071883374,
0.0267525278,
-0.0299820974,
0.0475209579,
0.0438896678,
0.0164328832,
-0.0221690834,
0.0376722179,
-0.023092486,
-0.0283080023,
0.0072955969,
0.0075279027,
0.0031800135,
0.0302665923,
-0.0422854237,
0.058085911,
-0.0139418719,
-0.0174949281,
-0.0264780391,
-0.0599501766,
-0.0528470166,
0.0360831842,
2.409e-7,
0.000617187,
0.0239266194,
0.0493968464,
0.0325802565,
0.0306411833,
-0.0083072791,
-0.0575547479,
0.032226745,
-0.0041250582,
0.0364517868,
0.0396817774,
-0.0124329049,
0.0914531723,
-0.0189318936,
-0.0857123733,
-0.0254030358,
-0.0593262613,
0.0176553577,
-0.045108851,
-0.0112792626,
0.0310145449,
0.0623016432,
0.019361075,
-0.0173142906,
0.0356537476,
-0.0148490528,
0.0520135462,
0.0431262217,
-0.0417142175,
-0.0215662811,
0.0291247535,
0.0433879271,
-0.0775427446,
0.02307548,
-0.0335690193,
-0.0021546562,
0.0800279975,
0.0554067418,
-0.0260769855,
-0.009346229,
-0.0081688631,
0.0309381932,
-0.0284002572,
-0.0244630165,
0.0653063133,
-0.0258437358,
-0.0171740931,
0.0144809326,
-0.0430608168,
-0.0026642631,
-0.0152349649,
-0.0231856927,
-0.0108462656,
0.0192008726,
0.0403818637,
0.0138191804,
-0.0177887138,
-0.0188214574,
0.0169911813,
-0.0016827898,
-0.0115156537,
-0.048609253,
-0.0567748733,
0.0315150321,
-0.021336155,
-0.0392896384,
-0.0266282652,
2.082807931e-34,
0.0575847588,
-0.0142706977,
-0.0009276653,
-0.021361798,
-0.0030561045,
-0.0178597271,
-0.0253315121,
0.0072725127,
-0.0219920371,
-0.0410613939,
-0.0466308855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15516v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15516v2 | Teaching Text-to-Image Models to Communicate in Dialog | 2023-09-27T09:33:16 | 2024-02-08T04:06:33 | Xiaowen Sun, Jiazhan Feng, Yuxuan Wang, Yuxuan Lai, Xingyu Shen, Dongyan Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | A picture is worth a thousand words, thus, it is crucial for conversational
agents to understand, perceive, and effectively respond with pictures. However,
we find that directly employing conventional image generation techniques is
inadequate for conversational agents to produce image responses effectively. In
this paper, we focus on the innovative dialog-to-image generation task, where
the model synthesizes a high-resolution image aligned with the given dialog
context as a response. To tackle this problem, we design a tailored fine-tuning
approach on the top of state-of-the-art text-to-image generation models to
fully exploit the structural and semantic features in dialog context during
image generation. Concretely, we linearize the dialog context with specific
indicators to maintain the dialog structure, and employ in-domain data to
alleviate the style mismatch between dialog-to-image and conventional image
generation tasks. Empirical results on PhotoChat and MMDialog Corpus show that
our approach brings consistent and remarkable improvement with 3
state-of-the-art pre-trained text-to-image generation backbones. | [
0.0313600153,
0.0807528645,
0.0097050043,
0.037864726,
-0.010929984,
0.0198131204,
0.0329471081,
0.0161087345,
0.0295228343,
-0.0581156313,
-0.0401117168,
-0.034246929,
-0.0170252547,
0.0757566243,
0.0345738158,
-0.0978016257,
-0.017768763,
-0.0197001956,
0.0080539705,
0.0012183427,
0.0350488946,
0.0297350623,
-0.0206630137,
0.0401767343,
-0.0542414226,
-0.0449700616,
-0.0222222004,
0.0537934341,
0.0036926994,
-0.0157034155,
0.0161434226,
0.0492695533,
0.0292874146,
0.0193707664,
0.0000017719,
-0.0059628771,
0.0228067636,
0.0005633699,
0.0136706661,
-0.0102812508,
0.0560862198,
-0.0204365216,
-0.0308440216,
-0.0105472133,
-0.0429715179,
0.0319840908,
0.0803265944,
0.0852410421,
0.0802257732,
0.0905625448,
-0.0302295797,
-0.0156736746,
0.0039111059,
-0.0458501242,
0.0238609761,
-0.0432893038,
-0.0376853198,
0.0182379913,
-0.0131622786,
0.0270806588,
-0.0171242133,
0.0184787456,
0.0041947803,
-0.0511137396,
-0.0014591784,
0.0439136364,
0.001906217,
-0.0262590013,
-0.0185421724,
0.0898478106,
-0.0079596024,
0.015766304,
-0.0201007761,
-0.0148096206,
0.009147292,
-0.0275828578,
-0.0564565472,
0.0274880622,
0.0024187798,
0.0148330769,
-0.0644601583,
0.0193924718,
-0.0300664511,
0.0069028707,
-0.0040803044,
-0.0526831448,
0.0134568773,
0.0269087385,
-0.0584253334,
0.0366618223,
-0.0268312376,
-0.0709019676,
0.0230385307,
0.0295328218,
-0.0273140203,
0.0084550837,
-0.0464055724,
0.0025471488,
0.0002474142,
-0.017502727,
0.0262632016,
0.0094070518,
-0.0212717876,
0.0128756138,
-0.0066587473,
0.0372359008,
-0.018297907,
0.0134392623,
-0.031193072,
0.0019063753,
-0.0212612581,
-0.0245022271,
-0.0436021835,
-0.0096990988,
-0.05744965,
-0.0583007187,
-0.0299740992,
0.0399792753,
-0.0006058229,
-0.0002560294,
0.0023139368,
0.0396256894,
-0.0773396045,
-0.0053260489,
-0.0268871877,
0.0158804953,
-0.0043302146,
0.0117071914,
0.0293788817,
-0.0395470485,
-0.0075294664,
0.0394328907,
0.0363163687,
-0.0051623941,
-0.0363141783,
0.0478157848,
-0.0665949509,
-0.0204872936,
0.0101600094,
-0.016573105,
-0.0400789008,
-0.0574071258,
0.0172388665,
-0.0190903507,
0.0265212376,
-0.0233938489,
-0.00907443,
-0.0182668325,
0.001157609,
-0.0094320495,
0.0020218631,
0.0595848411,
0.0028245975,
-0.0144660231,
0.0479364768,
0.0149062071,
-0.0160766579,
0.0644202679,
0.0372070558,
0.0661982745,
0.015073224,
-0.0047975071,
-0.003859503,
0.035403274,
0.0260216109,
-0.0090808487,
0.0052299788,
0.0038408167,
-0.0342700668,
0.0229120739,
0.0322404578,
0.0495001264,
-0.0536964312,
0.0090378318,
0.0870570689,
0.0315442123,
0.0387755893,
0.0125849815,
0.0167591162,
0.0322444551,
-0.0049131853,
0.0008065333,
-0.0493909046,
0.0474440567,
0.0335446894,
0.0501309149,
0.0125830146,
0.0450559147,
-0.0584807619,
-0.0188791938,
0.0353171751,
-0.0184256099,
-0.0018514637,
-0.0213759653,
0.0077066072,
0.0582770631,
-0.0684086308,
0.0315601081,
-0.0170838069,
-0.0346035026,
-0.0008884057,
-0.0359383598,
0.0076463753,
0.070218429,
0.0236652736,
0.038446147,
-0.0262186304,
-0.0020536897,
0.0371897481,
0.0931354091,
-0.0125811305,
0.005030097,
0.0519503169,
-0.049099572,
-0.0279334448,
-0.0364141278,
-0.0168714207,
0.0051020402,
-0.0112972232,
0.0096088834,
0.0353164189,
0.0118571669,
0.0060305679,
0.0312702358,
0.0281996205,
-0.0142720416,
0.0061680023,
0.0189501811,
0.0167869665,
0.0022409298,
-0.0243880302,
-0.0024560057,
-0.0141156409,
-0.0102749588,
0.0093623139,
0.0312589183,
-0.088483952,
-0.0798270479,
-0.0087589808,
-0.0428826995,
-0.012640533,
-0.0272116885,
-0.0637190044,
-0.0388132073,
0.0211394522,
-0.0283950586,
0.0099912565,
-0.0674935579,
-0.0055715344,
0.0661894605,
0.0247510951,
0.0143385883,
0.0395941548,
0.0055526374,
-0.0541994758,
0.0270842258,
0.0735190734,
-0.0208726339,
-0.0257797018,
0.0143323382,
-0.0108445417,
-0.0140495365,
0.0228687208,
0.0125657162,
0.0720613673,
-0.0661163777,
-0.0372306965,
-0.0811827183,
-0.0229865182,
0.0036212925,
-0.0240788292,
0.0080304779,
0.0101183215,
0.0112426635,
-0.0253294613,
-0.0665756762,
0.0475876778,
0.0496712029,
-0.0041282768,
0.0489464328,
-0.0109421527,
0.0133192185,
-0.067477569,
0.0100487722,
0.0498314984,
0.0491866507,
0.0171244517,
0.0192219708,
-0.0386066549,
0.007936853,
-0.0336579643,
0.0427213237,
-0.0089805285,
-0.0339415744,
0.038150955,
-0.0071567916,
0.0341085121,
0.0727094486,
0.0754563659,
0.0385199897,
-0.0485220961,
-0.0007735214,
-0.0548489206,
0.0155550577,
-0.020052338,
-0.0076826708,
0.0041263313,
-0.0303151924,
0.0107200276,
0.0420784317,
-0.0099895913,
0.0459287576,
-0.0599108897,
0.0360748954,
0.0427340567,
-0.0475592986,
-0.0222785287,
0.0051648114,
-0.0117368177,
0.0155897029,
-0.0500416122,
-0.0785614029,
0.0291262269,
-0.0262837633,
-0.035932757,
0.0081673134,
0.0126465643,
-0.0121649941,
0.0616354868,
0.0233636443,
0.0454169363,
0.0216722712,
-0.0150748082,
-0.0561638661,
-0.0224689394,
0.0291988403,
-0.0110882754,
0.0458589457,
-0.0233992897,
0.0140575115,
-0.0217015054,
-0.0501887463,
-0.04442738,
0.0006877153,
0.0058774361,
-0.0261162277,
-0.0110158045,
-0.0175462235,
-0.0141122853,
0.0216478352,
-0.0181702394,
0.011528804,
-0.0057524736,
-0.02065452,
-0.0277455132,
0.0736307651,
0.0590108819,
0.0190699827,
-0.0215219297,
-0.0411270671,
0.0637562349,
0.0706983358,
0.0050247777,
-0.0115425996,
-0.0452595875,
-0.0058482918,
-0.0051238947,
0.0697323829,
0.0048074722,
0.0366971791,
0.0785598233,
-0.0293988995,
-0.0266112536,
0.0838470906,
0.0037665926,
-0.0000118355,
-0.0232755765,
0.0271763876,
0.0766893774,
-0.0078817885,
0.0080338893,
-0.0773171559,
-0.0373034999,
-0.0224040672,
-0.0187974628,
0.0124865631,
0.0263549648,
-0.0339115523,
-0.0598374605,
0.0659665763,
0.0223049819,
-0.0105146002,
-0.0106125819,
0.0373599157,
-0.0083024092,
-0.0013814784,
0.0241767075,
-0.0014536608,
-0.0000091253,
0.0137475189,
0.0014288721,
0.0370165035,
-0.0128496615,
-0.0033909087,
-0.0333816074,
0.0240278468,
0.0409500338,
0.044982139,
0.0525808781,
-0.0060064183,
0.023585014,
0.0350290984,
0.0219290908,
-0.009976049,
0.0656646565,
0.0042061764,
-0.0300935693,
-0.0127991438,
0.0280807428,
-0.0078804595,
-0.0061647738,
-0.0103890216,
-0.0284295492,
-0.0255861543,
-0.014163021,
-0.0293491073,
0.0371360332,
0.0469764583,
0.0287661105,
0.0156281311,
-0.027654022,
-0.086206615,
-0.0299276225,
0.032936424,
-0.0802493915,
0.0024120368,
-0.0021763758,
-0.0069347373,
-0.0094482573,
-0.0882632881,
-0.0326484367,
0.0111729,
0.0395780466,
-0.0450193062,
-0.0444142856,
-0.0143624665,
0.006665695,
-0.0202753991,
0.0245628059,
-0.0316173695,
0.0180310681,
-0.0326115154,
-0.0085821487,
0.0057644742,
-0.0561014973,
-0.0051683467,
0.034257248,
-0.0857223868,
-0.0248311739,
-0.0606406294,
0.0868893564,
0.0064642951,
0.0457432009,
0.023728691,
-0.0167322345,
0.0357897691,
0.0447972007,
-0.0105566736,
-0.0149264196,
0.021541236,
0.0437908173,
-0.0164608154,
0.0143349832,
-0.0373014659,
0.0571250953,
-0.0215433147,
0.024058165,
-0.0067047277,
-0.0791051611,
0.0051267543,
-0.0138821332,
-0.0265003908,
-0.0254566036,
0.0038887509,
-0.0133398296,
0.0100369453,
-0.0318239741,
-0.0049853991,
-0.0950168669,
-0.0055034729,
-0.0007864127,
-0.0079202335,
0.0199843887,
-0.0102853747,
-0.0252017658,
0.0698152259,
-0.0211649984,
-0.0159041025,
0.0074741729,
0.0087333154,
0.0079705026,
0.00525762,
-0.0039479188,
0.0567173809,
-0.0098988647,
0.0290188864,
0.005612134,
0.1032605246,
0.002437514,
-0.0282420199,
0.0002051536,
0.0247801356,
-0.0148531226,
-0.0131481914,
-0.0776974261,
0.0210841447,
0.0107380087,
0.0154155707,
0.0589017123,
-0.0279997028,
0.0013600151,
-0.005700619,
0.059283331,
0.0036504904,
-0.0570212081,
0.0396168754,
-0.0309704617,
0.0117427967,
-0.0304766893,
0.0537030958,
0.0076449434,
0.0095997322,
-0.0069425534,
0.0188115854,
-0.0497959107,
-0.0364677943,
0.0137692289,
-0.0206596255,
0.0349194631,
0.0302591361,
-0.0069545065,
-0.0522354618,
-0.0195710249,
0.0175864417,
-0.0220519565,
0.0193261039,
0.0641611293,
0.0140043236,
0.0134269036,
-0.0014486731,
-0.0073705129,
0.0020938774,
-0.0081751263,
-0.0105341356,
-0.0111793764,
-5.509309495e-33,
-0.0467982404,
-0.0557194203,
0.0422723889,
-0.0129914479,
-0.0201197043,
-0.0116398986,
-0.0450147577,
-0.0112445429,
-0.0083025806,
-0.002243622,
0.0055723772,
-0.0065592974,
0.0052198977,
0.0826939046,
-0.0481558517,
0.037685398,
0.0462384038,
-0.0249998998,
-0.0220903866,
0.0521997325,
0.0279522501,
-0.0139573459,
0.0228435248,
-0.0581349321,
-0.0387247205,
-0.0087489728,
-0.0511031821,
0.0035190484,
0.0503581688,
0.040718466,
-0.0149187846,
-0.0056840703,
0.0047456101,
-0.0110850045,
-0.0412424468,
0.0274981949,
-0.0656016991,
-0.0117454203,
-0.0184104815,
0.0154878898,
-0.0578679517,
-0.0084389569,
-0.0006450622,
-0.0358660705,
0.038239412,
-0.0643723011,
0.0317486785,
-0.0163255595,
0.0144330394,
-0.0109202638,
-0.0671954304,
-0.0037766832,
-0.0541063063,
-0.0694427118,
0.006727898,
0.0564245544,
0.0280421413,
-0.003080776,
-0.0320453197,
0.0422091782,
0.0274953395,
-0.0026275727,
0.0643816218,
0.0533420779,
0.0035456619,
0.0251127407,
0.025185179,
0.0210342892,
-0.0353030525,
-0.0315292254,
-0.0136429826,
0.0987296849,
0.0045367004,
0.0830990002,
0.0069659022,
0.0066632507,
-0.0254502874,
0.0544219799,
-0.0114212697,
0.0189983621,
-0.0010695271,
0.0161818676,
0.0190392267,
0.0161834694,
-0.0235131457,
-0.0083974376,
-0.0275079887,
-0.0385908149,
0.023353884,
0.0457025096,
0.0023035395,
-0.0201069675,
0.0637125745,
-0.0235416815,
-0.0214627534,
-0.0151968626,
-0.0480017886,
0.0280786585,
-0.0289572142,
0.0022776041,
-0.0172628202,
-0.055873014,
0.123252742,
0.0323166288,
-0.0175240748,
0.0328214206,
0.0366377048,
-0.0060760849,
-0.0386856496,
0.0009477306,
-0.0324303024,
0.0679648146,
-0.0190347228,
0.0263049845,
-0.0202616658,
-0.0338831469,
-0.0822672546,
0.0479251407,
-0.0390403308,
-0.0187170245,
-0.0278912578,
-0.031834811,
0.0174161065,
0.0273546614,
-0.0603185408,
0.0283897985,
-0.0374163538,
-0.0326175354,
0.0468792021,
-0.0584222116,
-0.0214424562,
0.0051756492,
2.304e-7,
0.0180412252,
0.0017170771,
0.0262427796,
0.0388408713,
0.0324718468,
0.0637496561,
-0.0048590419,
0.0263711661,
0.020342363,
-0.0157004502,
0.0123674031,
0.0279277675,
0.0785759017,
-0.0052992655,
-0.0133917714,
0.0288070831,
-0.0770917684,
-0.0111564109,
-0.0191253889,
-0.0068884837,
0.0589754283,
0.0836621076,
-0.0543318503,
-0.0488539599,
0.0509530753,
-0.0316685997,
0.0955020934,
-0.0327144377,
0.0063326592,
0.0197375324,
0.0095848776,
-0.0144539401,
-0.0065271077,
0.0122781089,
-0.0085344315,
-0.0236591175,
0.0080409199,
0.0455453172,
-0.0190161373,
-0.0518369265,
-0.0116786966,
0.0131741287,
0.009540488,
-0.0579714477,
0.0356699936,
-0.0602346286,
-0.03671626,
-0.0462481007,
-0.0418733284,
0.0054619149,
0.0126070362,
-0.0591622144,
-0.0390717685,
0.0253036339,
0.0565458126,
-0.0051953415,
-0.0163236633,
-0.0695841238,
-0.0493362807,
-0.0292320047,
-0.0364593863,
-0.0198320225,
-0.0678347126,
-0.0080540022,
0.032813482,
0.0281333141,
-0.008927647,
1.520868137e-34,
-0.0029642768,
-0.0103148008,
0.0090428693,
0.0369944759,
0.0185659993,
0.013124086,
0.0192362778,
-0.0149189075,
0.021044882,
-0.0593962707,
-0.017895313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15512v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15512v2 | High-Fidelity Speech Synthesis with Minimal Supervision: All Using Diffusion Models | 2023-09-27T09:27:03 | 2023-12-18T12:52:08 | Chunyu Qiang, Hao Li, Yixin Tian, Yi Zhao, Ying Zhang, Longbiao Wang, Jianwu Dang | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS | Text-to-speech (TTS) methods have shown promising results in voice cloning,
but they require a large number of labeled text-speech pairs.
Minimally-supervised speech synthesis decouples TTS by combining two types of
discrete speech representations(semantic \& acoustic) and using two
sequence-to-sequence tasks to enable training with minimal supervision.
However, existing methods suffer from information redundancy and dimension
explosion in semantic representation, and high-frequency waveform distortion in
discrete acoustic representation. Autoregressive frameworks exhibit typical
instability and uncontrollability issues. And non-autoregressive frameworks
suffer from prosodic averaging caused by duration prediction models. To address
these issues, we propose a minimally-supervised high-fidelity speech synthesis
method, where all modules are constructed based on the diffusion models. The
non-autoregressive framework enhances controllability, and the duration
diffusion model enables diversified prosodic expression. Contrastive
Token-Acoustic Pretraining (CTAP) is used as an intermediate semantic
representation to solve the problems of information redundancy and dimension
explosion in existing semantic coding methods. Mel-spectrogram is used as the
acoustic representation. Both semantic and acoustic representations are
predicted by continuous variable regression tasks to solve the problem of
high-frequency fine-grained waveform distortion. Experimental results show that
our proposed method outperforms the baseline method. We provide audio samples
on our website. | [
-0.0241681524,
0.058945138,
0.019097358,
-0.0409266762,
-0.0017377121,
-0.0390440226,
0.0497295149,
0.0148928612,
-0.0637531355,
0.0016717977,
-0.0522024594,
-0.0385178849,
0.0296673831,
0.0188864637,
0.0410331674,
-0.0884985104,
-0.0008950667,
-0.057469748,
-0.0363451056,
-0.0375545062,
0.0043375883,
-0.0075067719,
-0.0188938789,
0.0321447589,
-0.0739392713,
0.0088735987,
-0.0096181044,
-0.0133915674,
0.0062136366,
-0.0139598381,
-0.0327783413,
0.0162175372,
0.0684799254,
-0.021021897,
0.0000022438,
-0.0254436173,
0.0030124255,
0.0165456589,
-0.0162772853,
-0.003035821,
0.0506513789,
0.0162625629,
-0.0170278568,
0.0186975058,
0.0096877823,
-0.0112928385,
0.0397785492,
0.03323121,
0.0584016629,
0.0331034474,
-0.0230242368,
-0.0805577859,
0.0020909528,
-0.0374958888,
0.0284949187,
0.0355136171,
-0.0323405527,
0.0141856838,
0.0327923074,
-0.0182522703,
-0.0436912887,
0.0553783849,
-0.0111322571,
-0.0022436148,
0.0406313613,
0.0024313813,
0.0128602479,
-0.0569515042,
0.0131862732,
0.0753488019,
0.0068875533,
-0.0015937438,
0.0293663554,
0.0293959733,
-0.027100794,
-0.0307263099,
0.0131762605,
-0.0085034119,
0.025823202,
0.0226239339,
-0.02201147,
0.0268948805,
-0.0097218063,
-0.0679506883,
-0.0188274346,
-0.0355883576,
0.0163565949,
-0.0303280558,
-0.0141739994,
-0.0162220336,
-0.0096760737,
0.020949658,
0.021453239,
-0.0071280701,
-0.0233335551,
-0.0208256934,
-0.0724967346,
-0.0743890032,
-0.0419304185,
0.0035225619,
0.0120411702,
0.0406704731,
-0.0005812159,
-0.0346077755,
-0.0404537916,
0.0325904898,
-0.0143467514,
-0.0106633594,
-0.0566708595,
0.0032908283,
-0.0290629659,
0.0326630324,
-0.0441674516,
0.0672587827,
-0.044943504,
0.0025093837,
-0.0625537783,
0.0071585993,
-0.0302191731,
0.0162825976,
-0.0125551084,
0.0171696935,
-0.0624890998,
-0.0108210435,
-0.0170766916,
0.0092059905,
0.0226371083,
0.0196814835,
0.0167050194,
-0.0120020723,
-0.0210234374,
0.0202996563,
0.0366048962,
0.0326421224,
0.0110021932,
0.0786744505,
-0.0320452154,
0.0249351803,
-0.0230438579,
-0.0554830022,
-0.0339774936,
-0.025562169,
-0.0108037377,
-0.0625685528,
0.0316309556,
-0.0177255943,
-0.0195483863,
-0.0196513087,
-0.0117659885,
-0.022475889,
0.004957539,
0.0278353747,
-0.0183224138,
0.0360825434,
0.041535344,
0.0000632895,
-0.0156155489,
0.0019837127,
0.0644084066,
-0.0159615781,
-0.0500959046,
-0.0318748988,
-0.0128807379,
0.0286352243,
0.0489574671,
0.0359268263,
-0.0662016571,
-0.035827741,
0.0295086782,
0.0369535871,
0.0720209479,
0.0540475436,
-0.0147829093,
0.0087351836,
0.0722219497,
0.0390594862,
0.0257144235,
0.0411928929,
0.1080778912,
0.035816431,
-0.0130745023,
-0.0069067338,
0.0254464,
0.0016167765,
0.035227716,
0.0166712701,
0.0498436615,
0.0123806661,
-0.0537934192,
-0.0160928518,
0.04226036,
-0.0436785594,
-0.0192019232,
-0.0249244571,
0.0242062006,
0.0377131142,
-0.0507466942,
0.070523642,
-0.0269152727,
-0.0750307962,
0.0384551175,
-0.010654008,
0.0113263885,
0.0650866106,
0.0142247975,
-0.0139783509,
0.0261295587,
-0.0518824682,
0.0009413091,
0.0331426859,
-0.0052534537,
0.0105121611,
0.0432870537,
-0.0507772826,
-0.0296047069,
0.0306017194,
-0.0337758027,
0.0076070237,
-0.0448838361,
0.0519074015,
0.0378481336,
-0.0131279426,
0.0134826293,
0.0010020077,
-0.0251673665,
-0.0378575064,
0.0009578685,
-0.008324462,
0.0727643222,
0.0007606721,
-0.0324940421,
0.0405858941,
0.0033134541,
-0.0476897135,
-0.0170630496,
-0.0168140996,
-0.0883308798,
-0.0621172749,
0.0366558619,
-0.0284628384,
0.0397602804,
0.0156754889,
0.0187697299,
-0.0915104821,
0.059785448,
-0.0197793115,
0.0408660136,
-0.0059720366,
0.0269915443,
0.0522202551,
0.0374589488,
0.0320887864,
-0.0092769256,
0.011894295,
-0.0134650497,
0.0558585338,
0.0769202858,
-0.0260813087,
-0.0393912941,
0.006574126,
0.013265579,
-0.0041926727,
0.0377144516,
-0.0221222099,
-0.0246547554,
-0.0108492933,
-0.032898102,
-0.0492518879,
-0.0025113304,
0.0229489841,
-0.0004898299,
0.006349178,
0.0125037441,
0.0124505982,
-0.0038549486,
-0.0441022217,
-0.026566511,
-0.0215505529,
-0.0298754387,
-0.0404342487,
-0.0032008484,
-0.0247820485,
-0.0006672891,
0.0016097947,
0.0388832055,
0.010986276,
-0.0543738678,
-0.0031785236,
-0.0286321212,
0.0261887424,
-0.0028251268,
0.0468132086,
0.0099781388,
-0.021279281,
0.009732116,
0.0050233449,
0.1002011746,
-0.0271501448,
0.0167451482,
-0.0273958184,
0.0317193419,
-0.0203511193,
-0.0322115272,
0.0097781904,
-0.0006086847,
0.0396888219,
-0.0155869657,
0.010636461,
-0.0142931091,
0.0109628625,
0.0749399886,
0.0241083354,
-0.080473125,
-0.0405950174,
0.0062910686,
-0.0492890961,
0.0241779499,
-0.0334650874,
-0.0284201074,
-0.0380082019,
-0.0263877474,
-0.0277644433,
0.0236657001,
-0.0588134676,
-0.053265404,
-0.0329189375,
-0.0561883934,
0.0375373177,
-0.0051532616,
-0.033340387,
0.0224513188,
-0.0263086222,
0.0058321985,
-0.0645643398,
0.0017777479,
-0.0031866855,
-0.0594730191,
0.015140228,
-0.0138124619,
0.0055235797,
-0.0190944523,
0.0167894904,
-0.0074041821,
-0.0827088878,
0.0112517113,
0.0262382925,
0.0078255851,
0.0010362294,
-0.0008688376,
0.0623287819,
0.0334195867,
0.0426239595,
0.0194696449,
0.0043901773,
-0.0227136575,
0.0521170087,
0.0135620991,
0.010058267,
-0.0380109996,
-0.046904549,
0.0519735105,
-0.0043573938,
0.03084407,
0.021241935,
-0.0480489805,
0.0075388993,
-0.01772088,
0.0503687114,
-0.0210805237,
0.0103261666,
0.0562967286,
-0.0369596109,
0.0162772108,
0.0779740065,
-0.0358905569,
-0.0129721425,
0.013606987,
0.0525536239,
0.095900178,
-0.0184854846,
-0.0223150179,
-0.0032630465,
-0.0093578259,
0.0385131277,
0.0422341861,
0.0085742641,
0.0248272941,
-0.0278001614,
-0.0671662614,
0.0289870892,
0.0685680136,
-0.0326451771,
-0.0026640838,
-0.0195430499,
-0.0292091407,
0.0523617305,
-0.0047625666,
0.0292447526,
-0.0288784765,
-0.0086352555,
0.0519812703,
-0.0585254058,
-0.0197424535,
-0.0245376751,
-0.0241917968,
0.0617065355,
0.0563656949,
0.0168243162,
0.0192201808,
-0.0367570296,
0.0512712896,
-0.0266634021,
0.0200588126,
0.0090795839,
0.0351915248,
0.0286082067,
-0.0213089939,
0.0160270706,
0.0625705793,
-0.0144138429,
0.0260710083,
-0.0217505768,
0.0795591623,
-0.0224909913,
-0.0229728129,
0.0045989347,
0.0347570591,
0.0361706056,
0.0357481577,
0.03477953,
-0.0770450011,
-0.0099380929,
0.0253474172,
0.0329829343,
-0.0237499643,
-0.0167195369,
0.0122608272,
-0.0299344845,
-0.0591740683,
-0.0511175022,
0.0063020224,
-0.0090874722,
0.0636973754,
0.0044917879,
0.0151109779,
-0.0114156194,
-0.0314107873,
-0.0300731324,
-0.0131080467,
-0.0175450854,
0.0079001645,
-0.0348579958,
-0.0097566815,
0.0323334895,
-0.0420214385,
-0.0007796261,
-0.0123195155,
-0.0449668244,
-0.0578120723,
-0.014440109,
-0.0136259906,
0.0066062207,
0.0541980527,
0.0028855933,
0.0061818897,
0.1520064175,
0.0206406303,
-0.0132569261,
0.0532160886,
0.0543857366,
-0.0155616151,
0.0087178331,
0.0087816259,
-0.0487196967,
0.0754348487,
-0.0176064633,
0.0238382258,
0.0350257978,
-0.0193096902,
0.0061624874,
0.0096924854,
0.0033080648,
-0.020976454,
0.0856801495,
-0.0222772416,
0.0042742491,
-0.0133337993,
0.0325249396,
-0.0590140633,
0.0195453316,
0.0267554931,
0.0334212966,
0.0137416068,
-0.0176349301,
-0.0091249719,
0.004258811,
0.0482330248,
0.0272488948,
-0.0465162955,
0.0086286301,
0.0328026451,
0.0325057395,
-0.0160160102,
-0.0056523816,
-0.0199454967,
-0.0156952161,
-0.0087451087,
-0.0124059748,
0.0252057482,
0.016764706,
-0.0283617843,
-0.0000221761,
0.0007856342,
-0.022785008,
-0.0177670792,
-0.020613987,
0.0195569135,
0.0281587932,
0.0573410317,
-0.0096110823,
0.0468833558,
-0.0268429834,
0.0234491788,
-0.0497617908,
0.0418392606,
-0.0047166101,
-0.0246719141,
-0.0102144526,
0.0086044539,
0.0427030027,
-0.0111994008,
0.016470572,
-0.062954165,
0.0522818565,
-0.0109647,
-0.0201872867,
-0.0464465134,
-0.0150099648,
0.0042586182,
-0.0489726663,
-0.002143197,
-0.0504456274,
0.0249466728,
-0.0340527929,
-0.0356686562,
-0.0348794684,
0.0799676329,
-0.0471691079,
-0.0370452814,
0.0564444512,
0.0204140339,
-0.03658491,
0.047518529,
-0.0248750094,
0.0222266633,
-6.346536612e-33,
-0.0207119565,
0.0223426782,
0.0059877182,
-0.0283892844,
-0.0823251307,
-0.0103897396,
-0.0508526713,
-0.005479706,
0.0277615692,
-0.0068870406,
-0.0204975847,
0.0004111889,
0.0141907921,
0.0165909752,
-0.0046027135,
0.024279803,
0.0973294079,
-0.0387114882,
0.0025306076,
0.0571049489,
0.0623242073,
0.0405038185,
-0.0121956579,
-0.0648728386,
-0.0463367924,
0.016575953,
0.0140028289,
-0.0560749285,
0.0481006876,
-0.0033608596,
-0.0075060376,
0.0612412728,
-0.0151076727,
-0.0140453093,
-0.06219282,
0.039357949,
-0.0399886332,
-0.0387133919,
-0.0083855921,
-0.0324791186,
-0.0435134023,
-0.0205763951,
0.0660932362,
0.0168711673,
-0.0495062731,
-0.0073708985,
0.0252123978,
-0.0385597795,
-0.0090791453,
-0.0425414145,
-0.0462506674,
0.0183472149,
0.0111237224,
-0.0112679983,
0.0600872599,
0.0732479542,
-0.0232810006,
-0.0187896714,
-0.0491840914,
0.033834707,
-0.0212928131,
0.0555531792,
0.0124588497,
0.0425088517,
0.0429249629,
0.0274763834,
0.0573235825,
-0.0338178538,
0.0170264151,
0.0111022135,
0.0289687999,
0.0547423251,
0.0137210004,
-0.0115496516,
0.0292557701,
-0.0609021597,
0.0057815439,
-0.0084554572,
-0.0267766528,
-0.0212450977,
0.0319209173,
0.0404754132,
-0.0108186575,
-0.0109839281,
-0.088732183,
0.0071502971,
0.0033073416,
-0.0287798401,
0.0559598543,
0.0027367233,
0.0056174002,
-0.0310763363,
0.0654508024,
0.0063105775,
0.0010086205,
-0.0406803675,
-0.0680027157,
0.0221681986,
0.0151207717,
-0.0185283329,
-0.0285020191,
-0.0832376331,
0.0930011123,
0.0328450389,
0.0178263187,
-0.0061048525,
-0.0575166754,
0.0574325845,
-0.0475726314,
-0.0119362529,
0.008073736,
0.0234984942,
0.0155837135,
-0.0420125946,
0.014209968,
-0.0040554334,
0.0062906258,
0.0254506767,
-0.031993933,
-0.0052555394,
0.0534866303,
0.023636153,
0.0370625518,
0.0349284001,
-0.0326991417,
0.0303230155,
-0.031385947,
0.0219112821,
0.0927402526,
-0.0481750779,
-0.0280370526,
0.0262668952,
3.191e-7,
-0.0713815242,
-0.0444368273,
0.0181178339,
-0.0561996885,
0.0458945297,
0.0320949145,
-0.0120424917,
0.0053118379,
-0.0316007771,
-0.0330234356,
0.0209708586,
0.0020301088,
0.0724043474,
0.0119226268,
-0.0738320574,
-0.0430637151,
-0.0419045575,
0.0363859124,
-0.0325414576,
0.0154093951,
0.0353922807,
0.0568449348,
-0.0154118417,
-0.0498296581,
0.0268756133,
-0.0087749874,
0.046032887,
0.0192841608,
0.0135135027,
-0.0103879916,
-0.014204069,
-0.033522442,
-0.0158657394,
0.0117633585,
-0.0592197515,
0.0028300686,
0.0043620546,
0.0312226322,
-0.0112051098,
-0.0443010554,
0.0414163657,
0.0444904156,
-0.0550043471,
0.0459070355,
0.0231316462,
-0.0218794998,
0.0198837724,
0.0095406184,
-0.0661054924,
0.0329204388,
-0.0273176525,
-0.0058227144,
0.0061227484,
-0.0145738591,
0.0229312405,
0.0497985892,
0.002955802,
-0.0142970523,
0.0109349471,
0.0197448712,
-0.0687230527,
-0.0602104217,
-0.0403936431,
0.0396225341,
0.0396015942,
-0.0062187305,
-0.0253729653,
2.689690868e-34,
-0.0030085971,
-0.0536850654,
0.0499244481,
-0.0439692624,
-0.0199252982,
-0.0432202108,
-0.0015919972,
0.0175175332,
0.0268443674,
-0.0227974411,
-0.0655631945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15494v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15494v1 | VideoAdviser: Video Knowledge Distillation for Multimodal Transfer Learning | 2023-09-27T08:44:04 | 2023-09-27T08:44:04 | Yanan Wang, Donghuo Zeng, Shinya Wada, Satoshi Kurihara | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Multimodal transfer learning aims to transform pretrained representations of
diverse modalities into a common domain space for effective multimodal fusion.
However, conventional systems are typically built on the assumption that all
modalities exist, and the lack of modalities always leads to poor inference
performance. Furthermore, extracting pretrained embeddings for all modalities
is computationally inefficient for inference. In this work, to achieve high
efficiency-performance multimodal transfer learning, we propose VideoAdviser, a
video knowledge distillation method to transfer multimodal knowledge of
video-enhanced prompts from a multimodal fundamental model (teacher) to a
specific modal fundamental model (student). With an intuition that the best
learning performance comes with professional advisers and smart students, we
use a CLIP-based teacher model to provide expressive multimodal knowledge
supervision signals to a RoBERTa-based student model via optimizing a
step-distillation objective loss -- first step: the teacher distills multimodal
knowledge of video-enhanced prompts from classification logits to a regression
logit -- second step: the multimodal knowledge is distilled from the regression
logit of the teacher to the student. We evaluate our method in two challenging
multimodal tasks: video-level sentiment analysis (MOSI and MOSEI datasets) and
audio-visual retrieval (VEGAS dataset). The student (requiring only the text
modality as input) achieves an MAE score improvement of up to 12.3% for MOSI
and MOSEI. Our method further enhances the state-of-the-art method by 3.4% mAP
score for VEGAS without additional computations for inference. These results
suggest the strengths of our method for achieving high efficiency-performance
multimodal transfer learning. | [
0.0150869079,
0.0652362183,
-0.0054573626,
0.034083195,
0.0088416664,
-0.0165026411,
0.021759294,
-0.0157252066,
-0.0535207316,
-0.0847049579,
-0.0424302891,
-0.0058691208,
-0.0377396904,
0.02991133,
0.0265001375,
-0.073546201,
0.0334252529,
-0.0069193048,
-0.0089463955,
0.0179224517,
0.0490977652,
0.0099579301,
-0.0415068381,
-0.0030103561,
-0.0773523599,
0.0070268274,
-0.019903753,
0.0143066552,
0.0519823432,
-0.0066226344,
0.0117066391,
0.015570214,
0.0609462261,
-0.053741198,
0.000002292,
-0.0142180743,
-0.0091319056,
-0.0124735441,
0.0279434156,
-0.0139953317,
0.0359251201,
-0.0496578701,
0.0417954177,
0.0193677265,
-0.0340961777,
-0.0109509723,
0.0512182191,
0.0063847862,
0.0773929358,
0.0503040329,
-0.058615081,
-0.0232127104,
0.0251877122,
0.0069231852,
0.0083589433,
-0.0116841337,
-0.0099902283,
0.0269372035,
-0.0191230047,
-0.0062022759,
-0.0736358538,
0.0474378169,
-0.0067785233,
-0.0168565884,
0.0277643185,
-0.0101794396,
0.0172728989,
-0.0219292156,
-0.029616382,
0.0926390067,
0.0033923178,
0.0564412214,
-0.0085552502,
0.0266780723,
0.0294168964,
0.0344387665,
-0.0351287425,
-0.0024726533,
0.0074637732,
0.0207435116,
-0.0675395951,
0.0515502989,
-0.0082873115,
-0.0129377767,
-0.0090347594,
-0.0465824865,
0.0067172572,
0.0180279706,
0.03655155,
0.0161330663,
-0.0107135708,
0.0075443471,
-0.0115380427,
-0.0020178107,
0.0038561509,
-0.0169790294,
-0.0210526269,
-0.0094709126,
-0.0469257869,
0.0177532956,
0.0691892058,
0.0282308292,
-0.0724065155,
0.0482565984,
-0.0054501388,
0.0049300916,
-0.0143587794,
0.0517059863,
-0.0186041482,
-0.0170543045,
-0.1155299693,
0.0088107996,
0.0111267688,
0.0142802689,
-0.0288102385,
-0.0272860117,
-0.0098658251,
-0.023565514,
-0.0765046328,
-0.0202805903,
-0.0313950032,
0.019576963,
0.0206291769,
0.0116622793,
-0.0448784232,
0.1094439402,
-0.0360521227,
0.0578491166,
-0.0006836689,
-0.0281272065,
0.0040208953,
0.022011891,
0.0092829177,
-0.0165915545,
0.0181649625,
0.0535952263,
-0.0739711449,
-0.0341455974,
-0.0356406756,
-0.0292011444,
-0.0416502655,
-0.0437252969,
0.0833505243,
-0.025197519,
0.0755594447,
-0.0298504457,
0.0052096448,
-0.0253062621,
-0.0102415551,
-0.0362084098,
0.0167240351,
0.0905534998,
0.0229793899,
0.0033735496,
0.0130083179,
0.0399893783,
-0.0653289184,
0.0566698276,
-0.0184305534,
0.0543191992,
0.0100809522,
0.0061722803,
0.0124921538,
0.0062420075,
0.016786309,
0.047027342,
-0.0422725528,
-0.02097743,
-0.0146286376,
-0.0059881224,
0.0723939538,
0.0380593762,
-0.0117375739,
0.0077287084,
0.0394414812,
-0.0256764907,
0.0002163499,
-0.0209310018,
0.0257956367,
-0.0002364315,
0.0080041839,
-0.0165469963,
-0.0266219061,
0.0551130883,
-0.0031896434,
-0.0353630781,
0.0430636927,
0.0533338748,
-0.0304733552,
-0.0348780788,
0.0421270281,
-0.0297024287,
-0.0016293627,
0.0306208935,
0.0409451313,
0.0019080166,
-0.0344962515,
0.0224199034,
0.0391638391,
-0.0178052746,
0.042932976,
-0.0307795182,
-0.0100910636,
0.0148801999,
-0.0242061038,
-0.0405301638,
0.0021275238,
-0.0142943757,
0.0527360737,
-0.024221072,
0.0225832351,
-0.0307695493,
0.0650546998,
-0.0526930317,
-0.0826531276,
-0.0133614261,
0.0289004277,
0.0365807228,
-0.0161131006,
0.0310956724,
0.0235528946,
-0.0403221585,
0.0252149869,
0.014067525,
0.0473841578,
-0.0173583832,
-0.0526792109,
0.0414312109,
0.0269349217,
0.0037716692,
-0.0134242065,
-0.0222086739,
-0.0051562558,
-0.0421955846,
-0.0075298203,
-0.0051361439,
-0.0545139723,
-0.0575535409,
0.0510476641,
-0.0866098106,
0.0347582139,
0.0405126363,
-0.045439709,
-0.0348293446,
0.0158352852,
0.0138239833,
-0.0030840198,
-0.0227442011,
-0.0250771325,
0.0382558964,
0.0118931253,
0.0236087199,
-0.0066207149,
-0.0148473252,
-0.0473183021,
0.0238991585,
-0.0105366409,
0.0133994957,
0.0556864589,
-0.0415523387,
-0.0051979842,
-0.0195724964,
0.0319205001,
-0.0086132251,
-0.0444869734,
-0.0429903828,
-0.0198168289,
-0.0896698907,
-0.0163211729,
0.0001099838,
-0.018811075,
-0.0255716778,
-0.0005120685,
0.0223132968,
-0.0390034653,
-0.0313009433,
0.0081024254,
-0.0219737701,
0.0283000711,
-0.0129357213,
0.0462390073,
0.0412929915,
-0.0282155499,
0.0005744832,
0.0083167162,
0.0328538418,
-0.0387258008,
0.0025294055,
0.023011392,
-0.0324824899,
-0.0388599932,
0.049178388,
-0.0315721706,
-0.0204575993,
-0.0047409525,
-0.0457961038,
0.0438033827,
0.018065419,
0.0052756299,
0.0445066467,
0.0259678047,
-0.0255732238,
-0.0245049428,
0.0243572332,
-0.0039892304,
-0.0249432232,
-0.024873402,
0.0062344833,
-0.0298579633,
-0.0211277753,
-0.0007243857,
-0.0091381194,
-0.053372819,
0.0025163756,
0.0311695114,
-0.0390409939,
-0.0345933847,
0.0372932814,
0.026734706,
-0.0040198821,
-0.0172618981,
-0.0277364869,
0.0334748402,
-0.0113843679,
-0.0151391802,
-0.0123653682,
-0.0181515999,
0.0012399452,
0.0573535785,
-0.0322158821,
0.0380711295,
-0.0112860324,
0.0156250689,
-0.0803115517,
-0.0270546172,
0.0409207828,
0.0002786485,
0.0269463137,
-0.0433163606,
-0.0129083768,
-0.0182308313,
-0.0267430916,
-0.0062682959,
-0.0333916247,
-0.024784388,
-0.0043268134,
-0.0354679972,
0.0131038427,
-0.0349377058,
-0.0237513445,
0.0212512426,
-0.000307091,
0.0097710732,
-0.0112273945,
0.0054500489,
0.0466773547,
0.0332165286,
0.0274675842,
-0.069098562,
-0.0535051748,
0.0192228183,
0.0425805189,
-0.0028440638,
-0.0392631851,
-0.0469856299,
0.0296718162,
0.0109826904,
0.0623279549,
0.00115385,
0.0247589462,
0.0610346906,
-0.0287144445,
0.0505913384,
0.0540535599,
-0.0221816618,
-0.0340683721,
-0.0158563405,
0.0593899116,
0.010758209,
0.0226360951,
0.0151062747,
-0.0693725646,
-0.0933893099,
-0.0232489128,
0.0114064887,
0.0609973222,
0.0119131263,
-0.0228406675,
-0.0803003386,
0.0238714088,
0.0080716005,
-0.043463774,
-0.0507264435,
-0.0050630611,
0.0070679146,
-0.01490789,
-0.0190336127,
-0.0451250374,
-0.021068722,
0.0213394836,
0.0247343425,
0.0180390272,
-0.06362506,
0.0135762794,
-0.0223947316,
0.0064284904,
0.0237534232,
0.0118218707,
-0.0182690155,
-0.0621535666,
-0.0135427285,
0.0210099798,
0.0233999901,
0.0042210645,
0.1042249277,
-0.0595295802,
-0.0219250191,
0.031646017,
0.0352428071,
0.0197474286,
-0.0010796897,
0.00689391,
0.0698836297,
-0.0051099402,
-0.0156957265,
-0.0619190596,
0.0111046927,
0.0464915223,
0.0427530706,
-0.0135928029,
-0.0294126458,
-0.0043967431,
0.0298870374,
0.0136482976,
0.0281640515,
0.0022261895,
-0.0055790516,
-0.0237842984,
0.0054925005,
-0.0380661972,
0.0075827953,
0.0261239577,
0.0523233674,
-0.005999458,
-0.0218746886,
-0.0144851273,
0.0337445922,
-0.0591158196,
0.0604551397,
0.0041100676,
0.0206128582,
-0.0398870111,
0.0044419575,
0.04240283,
-0.0300871544,
-0.0130741671,
-0.0260609835,
-0.035249304,
-0.0361084342,
-0.0578742661,
0.075833708,
0.0069977194,
0.0443555489,
0.0521046817,
0.018019028,
0.0625548363,
0.0372177176,
-0.0063430895,
-0.0006730743,
0.0644803122,
-0.0276321005,
-0.0166968219,
0.0046372567,
-0.0247234516,
0.0423227511,
-0.0104905581,
-0.0002816431,
0.0040871105,
-0.0008651394,
-0.005232783,
-0.0255891792,
0.0863268301,
-0.0150000649,
-0.0112332329,
-0.0425992161,
-0.0386618972,
0.0193007551,
0.0196464416,
-0.0966339484,
0.0283018872,
0.0450268649,
0.0212805253,
0.0125923306,
-0.0034828342,
0.0456857234,
-0.0044115563,
-0.0202038549,
-0.0050452696,
0.0262932852,
-0.0291130692,
-0.0121619618,
0.0425185114,
0.0251666829,
0.0223075189,
0.0189647023,
0.0017921276,
-0.016886875,
0.0801617354,
0.0347111076,
-0.0033712059,
-0.0061377729,
0.0437737778,
-0.0067945933,
0.0013324991,
-0.0337490216,
0.0540370755,
0.012717708,
-0.0113707753,
-0.0026195906,
0.0078650462,
-0.0064000259,
-0.0135737285,
0.0731094629,
-0.0210474767,
-0.0056984471,
0.0671223998,
-0.0033888633,
0.0213982742,
0.0072672982,
0.0571023412,
-0.0352998488,
0.038025938,
-0.0499847941,
0.0132961757,
-0.0425279327,
0.0013144485,
0.0977949426,
0.043094039,
0.0186185557,
0.0357278474,
-0.0240296777,
-0.0651390329,
-0.0164722353,
-0.0425002463,
-0.041602049,
0.0235240404,
0.0453486145,
0.010718436,
0.0069518615,
-0.0199793316,
-0.0204028096,
-0.0516635738,
0.0082288105,
0.0119188419,
0.0444723777,
-6.441753858e-33,
-0.008277596,
0.022052113,
-0.0019007709,
0.0036707486,
-0.0358110219,
0.0087943031,
0.009931067,
0.0179338101,
-0.0310865417,
0.036674086,
0.0305838678,
0.0103102783,
0.0014394224,
0.0472611561,
0.0188636743,
-0.0157612972,
0.0566833541,
0.0190329645,
0.0069256695,
0.0120517807,
0.0388508216,
0.0524716899,
0.0490995161,
-0.1051898971,
-0.0160313062,
0.0194197856,
-0.0530472361,
0.0031534836,
0.0211419761,
0.0076449928,
-0.0264023729,
0.0281227045,
0.002339402,
-0.0384732187,
-0.0232862346,
0.0270195343,
-0.0714150593,
-0.0266935453,
0.0056996001,
-0.0031295836,
-0.0707281753,
-0.0034462831,
0.0117535042,
-0.0101506924,
0.0477293395,
-0.0658131614,
0.039397452,
-0.0027636662,
0.0375616886,
-0.0154887633,
-0.0396560766,
-0.0064171478,
-0.0156219946,
-0.0770137459,
0.043825686,
0.0363715477,
0.0453222543,
-0.0434877314,
-0.0365818329,
0.022695424,
-0.0344604999,
0.0058569107,
0.06253317,
0.0217822827,
-0.0627739206,
0.0688768327,
0.0125692338,
-0.0652627945,
-0.0105668139,
-0.0167551395,
0.0249341819,
0.0967087001,
-0.0072301319,
0.0713007972,
0.0549732931,
-0.0279083811,
-0.0398741364,
0.0287987962,
-0.027566839,
0.0229767393,
-0.0335023552,
0.0109977387,
0.0109724114,
-0.0300864354,
-0.0308928806,
-0.0173078496,
-0.0008535619,
-0.0293360241,
0.046679344,
0.0113732871,
-0.0040083351,
0.0003876956,
0.066172801,
-0.0649308339,
0.0115953237,
0.0262879878,
-0.0396595784,
0.0342632234,
-0.0059147589,
-0.0204069689,
-0.0506254509,
-0.0267384965,
0.0760686472,
-0.0234656855,
0.0089257127,
0.0151189547,
0.0428978167,
0.0895145833,
-0.0300310459,
-0.0295170508,
-0.0148296952,
0.0046885717,
0.0105317105,
0.0548752248,
-0.0076401625,
0.0262646731,
-0.06257613,
0.0283347666,
-0.0150780687,
0.0513879023,
-0.0144605152,
-0.0478262119,
0.025138991,
0.0158119705,
-0.0238155648,
0.0059245438,
-0.0458419956,
-0.0988333598,
0.0137497308,
-0.0480016135,
-0.0022801033,
0.0208788756,
3.071e-7,
0.02264628,
-0.0057690325,
-0.019731544,
-0.064918682,
-0.0183395445,
0.0711772367,
-0.0094978819,
0.0475738756,
0.0282714292,
-0.0569826849,
0.0294705741,
0.0488985032,
0.0314933062,
0.0191767067,
-0.0185956433,
-0.0431141406,
0.001835488,
-0.0489310585,
-0.0277900342,
0.0238965899,
0.0854981169,
0.0691176504,
0.0286165327,
-0.0383108854,
0.0157161523,
-0.0134507231,
0.0714806765,
0.0009945174,
0.0119580645,
-0.0263773706,
0.0449758805,
-0.0188379753,
-0.0199055802,
0.0209195856,
-0.0138915796,
-0.0072140787,
0.0383129306,
0.0589641817,
-0.0166571941,
-0.0427654348,
-0.0234103873,
0.0721250772,
-0.0319735855,
0.0254641846,
0.0596599095,
-0.0456387885,
-0.0112717971,
-0.055285491,
-0.0748198777,
-0.0007282365,
0.0065815034,
0.0170709565,
-0.0339298658,
0.0115381926,
0.0122322608,
0.0060612527,
-0.0705117211,
-0.0941780731,
0.0086874031,
0.0013285815,
-0.0192844924,
-0.0256024115,
0.0162047204,
-0.0327749662,
0.0378107168,
-0.038477093,
-0.0493463054,
2.185637284e-34,
0.007946129,
-0.0182791278,
0.0326193795,
-0.0616142601,
0.0044326391,
0.001356622,
-0.084754765,
-0.0195658728,
0.0089379139,
-0.0195069909,
-0.021635564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15476v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15476v1 | Dynamic Multi-Scale Context Aggregation for Conversational Aspect-Based Sentiment Quadruple Analysis | 2023-09-27T08:17:28 | 2023-09-27T08:17:28 | Yuqing Li, Wenyuan Zhang, Binbin Li, Siyu Jia, Zisen Qi, Xingbang Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Conversational aspect-based sentiment quadruple analysis (DiaASQ) aims to
extract the quadruple of target-aspect-opinion-sentiment within a dialogue. In
DiaASQ, a quadruple's elements often cross multiple utterances. This situation
complicates the extraction process, emphasizing the need for an adequate
understanding of conversational context and interactions. However, existing
work independently encodes each utterance, thereby struggling to capture
long-range conversational context and overlooking the deep inter-utterance
dependencies. In this work, we propose a novel Dynamic Multi-scale Context
Aggregation network (DMCA) to address the challenges. Specifically, we first
utilize dialogue structure to generate multi-scale utterance windows for
capturing rich contextual information. After that, we design a Dynamic
Hierarchical Aggregation module (DHA) to integrate progressive cues between
them. In addition, we form a multi-stage loss strategy to improve model
performance and generalization ability. Extensive experimental results show
that the DMCA model outperforms baselines significantly and achieves
state-of-the-art performance. | [
-0.0024340726,
0.1145298555,
0.0195100121,
0.0464803353,
0.0065375408,
0.0235383101,
0.0110036349,
-0.0490867011,
-0.0397357717,
-0.0305377562,
-0.0540279336,
-0.0585530661,
-0.0188125465,
0.0784287676,
0.0036030156,
-0.0353941359,
0.0296803974,
0.0313995518,
-0.0071664974,
-0.0015967481,
0.0315106437,
0.0396275669,
-0.0166871939,
-0.0009936186,
-0.067004241,
-0.0265568197,
-0.0200626832,
0.0169700198,
0.0202604141,
-0.0525705293,
0.0256686546,
0.023431113,
0.0369307548,
0.0204314999,
0.0000019451,
-0.0100792516,
-0.0377723537,
-0.0223912727,
-0.0173563082,
0.014016252,
0.0479560159,
-0.0126767661,
-0.0067333868,
-0.000129918,
-0.0486652963,
-0.020372225,
0.0403462462,
0.075406611,
0.0736533627,
0.0345374867,
-0.0259955563,
-0.0672409087,
0.036235977,
-0.0423511267,
-0.0455373451,
-0.0780509636,
0.0007524183,
0.0406695679,
-0.0486040935,
0.028986292,
0.0309338849,
0.0043387306,
0.0184745863,
-0.0131096449,
-0.0227916762,
0.0319556296,
-0.004153172,
0.0238399375,
-0.0163961202,
0.0883182511,
0.0063996883,
0.0616127066,
-0.0050988495,
-0.0165171102,
0.0196722373,
-0.0842074603,
-0.0300710648,
-0.0232053995,
0.0162175018,
0.0298226681,
-0.0176996645,
0.0663423985,
-0.0147805912,
0.024705518,
-0.0460925661,
0.0127142696,
-0.0315324329,
-0.0158156827,
0.0023553574,
0.0249171685,
-0.0063914466,
0.038372077,
-0.0060570193,
-0.0133643905,
0.0027821285,
0.0366530567,
0.0053559509,
0.0504260957,
0.0173011031,
-0.0361813009,
-0.002155259,
0.0020655692,
-0.0543956533,
0.0492239334,
0.0244909562,
0.008116574,
-0.0282339342,
-0.03071348,
-0.0346496552,
-0.0049346862,
-0.0379446633,
0.0039622397,
-0.0013814447,
0.05796941,
-0.0503474139,
-0.0184556507,
-0.0577714741,
0.0144373719,
-0.0400005765,
-0.019195104,
0.0019183573,
0.0339070335,
-0.0002493676,
0.0010939832,
0.007114199,
0.0593599081,
-0.0362906978,
0.05294374,
0.0078601371,
-0.0445417091,
-0.0157607552,
0.0146778366,
0.0120194256,
-0.007634602,
0.0031601267,
0.0584817603,
-0.0098024067,
-0.0556599237,
0.0226033255,
-0.0317652561,
-0.069123134,
-0.0562214479,
-0.0189869851,
-0.028062528,
0.0954212844,
-0.0648877621,
-0.0283977892,
0.0101300636,
0.0057722782,
-0.0207790472,
0.0022613325,
0.0354898311,
0.0088834111,
-0.0435339808,
-0.001030424,
0.0082480721,
0.0387185812,
0.0763799176,
0.0002465596,
0.0263084508,
0.0090228254,
0.0319958925,
-0.0055761831,
0.0202473216,
0.0283199344,
0.0246929582,
-0.0066488734,
-0.0212720558,
-0.0483738594,
-0.003014219,
0.0389822498,
0.0499399193,
-0.0517341346,
-0.0184518062,
0.0290840417,
0.0358569585,
-0.0248903595,
0.0327583142,
-0.0054441621,
0.0180620179,
-0.0191831086,
0.011216904,
-0.0397144891,
0.0309728608,
0.035101179,
-0.0065856013,
0.0539774448,
0.0383212455,
-0.0419719368,
-0.0502186604,
0.0244444571,
-0.0061403015,
0.0111474721,
-0.0128098512,
0.0099268286,
0.0047481791,
-0.0582609884,
0.0395335928,
0.0396632403,
-0.0395936184,
-0.0420163237,
-0.0171749406,
0.0123621859,
0.0235837344,
0.0043404088,
-0.0222818926,
-0.0322180018,
-0.0124253035,
-0.0328397788,
0.0259858761,
0.0060911071,
-0.0274120923,
0.0723973066,
-0.0386343114,
-0.0189714916,
-0.0240406767,
0.0184688233,
0.0177810676,
-0.0178721212,
-0.0082515357,
-0.0063135931,
0.0548314936,
0.0563695878,
-0.0236505307,
0.0117981406,
-0.0228794217,
0.0323832296,
0.0037018261,
0.0482390486,
0.0472729281,
-0.0115730083,
0.0014873634,
0.0359597877,
-0.0422870219,
-0.061624594,
0.0272572078,
-0.1068842486,
-0.0724042431,
0.0246579051,
0.0121851871,
-0.019229522,
-0.0217166841,
-0.062670961,
-0.0323363543,
0.0167131349,
-0.0292041134,
0.0363798141,
-0.023240963,
-0.0159652047,
0.0375795588,
0.0731689706,
-0.0094527788,
0.0752663389,
-0.0595351197,
-0.0526307598,
-0.0170976855,
0.0114736846,
-0.0277014133,
-0.0028252942,
0.0238476116,
-0.0041402499,
-0.00523957,
0.0408573188,
-0.0005073001,
-0.0028027501,
-0.0522503406,
-0.0533362329,
-0.0938095972,
0.0013783388,
0.0127077214,
0.0333231725,
0.0172304548,
0.0208655894,
0.0025942416,
-0.0084564108,
-0.054626964,
0.0075949291,
0.0115502235,
0.017631216,
0.0331620201,
0.0401823446,
0.0287819728,
-0.0534912236,
-0.0071125175,
-0.013584502,
0.047572691,
-0.0334177241,
-0.0279898867,
0.0103849936,
0.0054864543,
-0.0447767749,
0.0278291497,
-0.0200286899,
-0.0497196503,
-0.0184176043,
-0.0428255722,
-0.0021088733,
0.0318422988,
0.0163564701,
0.0602891222,
-0.0149851507,
-0.0270699728,
-0.0380032584,
0.0538249798,
-0.0542884097,
0.0078999735,
0.0067968885,
0.0319809765,
0.0085978499,
0.068967171,
0.022842437,
0.0455140173,
-0.0021484594,
0.0005485497,
0.0169848371,
-0.0043529286,
-0.0095436042,
-0.0086488156,
-0.0211027283,
0.0277391449,
-0.006338635,
-0.0180365629,
0.0443624072,
0.0123058921,
-0.0191906653,
-0.0514280125,
-0.0019707887,
-0.0411094204,
0.0728243068,
-0.0525537618,
0.0089694476,
0.0026130008,
-0.0157722235,
-0.0084065357,
-0.0504084378,
-0.012579524,
-0.0415154435,
0.0839247555,
-0.0163776334,
-0.0021372389,
-0.0006686068,
-0.0599340871,
-0.0136548942,
0.0108722597,
-0.0314465463,
0.0036987045,
-0.0158551242,
-0.0060959216,
-0.0588952154,
-0.0290365759,
0.0141400481,
0.0064002145,
-0.0026508195,
-0.0044203522,
0.0011060052,
0.1228006482,
0.0408710651,
0.0340276361,
0.0298666488,
-0.0130050573,
0.0478062443,
0.079876259,
0.0185380746,
0.0337442867,
0.0035187143,
0.0062110284,
0.0208383203,
0.077385582,
0.0147176599,
-0.0251464844,
0.0731924251,
-0.0474814288,
0.0111964447,
0.0788818821,
0.0191853903,
-0.0797364563,
-0.0057798498,
0.0116446083,
0.011193268,
-0.0039629876,
-0.0083736461,
-0.0921257362,
-0.046789743,
-0.0356404744,
-0.0026884638,
0.018334521,
-0.0015934426,
-0.0234563798,
-0.0876044184,
0.0082580969,
-0.0036143472,
-0.0229226965,
-0.0162632111,
-0.00942141,
0.0267268587,
-0.0253796075,
0.0398164392,
-0.0426511094,
0.0346593857,
-0.0431738012,
0.0137363579,
-0.0002620612,
-0.0155711789,
0.0685015693,
0.0147974202,
0.0183031205,
0.0324730128,
0.0440440364,
0.0010934493,
-0.005286681,
0.0477587022,
-0.0912345722,
-0.0159139447,
0.0224150103,
0.0555113517,
-0.0363166779,
-0.015050563,
-0.0228833947,
0.0198259708,
-0.0398316495,
0.0012248564,
-0.0291826483,
0.0286378022,
0.0215198882,
0.0162978023,
-0.0421117544,
0.0504938476,
0.0067472877,
0.0538541228,
-0.0015971938,
-0.0394486338,
-0.0043145227,
-0.0084892102,
0.0064170659,
-0.0645848885,
-0.0009828031,
0.0116538238,
0.0193511359,
-0.0107164262,
-0.06671983,
-0.045242656,
-0.0308466908,
0.0270587523,
-0.0756969377,
-0.0311787147,
0.0279782172,
0.0204563178,
-0.0255912691,
0.0185908601,
-0.0002455582,
0.0134717654,
-0.0089424746,
0.0175037831,
0.0907412842,
-0.0023426563,
-0.0120869661,
0.0328600332,
-0.08613123,
-0.0452338085,
-0.0344681665,
0.0328303762,
0.0051215272,
0.0424420685,
0.011473231,
0.0146686928,
0.0030814363,
0.0300627481,
-0.0197303612,
0.0084734624,
0.0670114458,
0.0839620978,
-0.0121729607,
0.0383392982,
-0.0338102765,
0.0778449774,
-0.0236158352,
0.0017063594,
-0.1076186821,
-0.0835419521,
-0.0095789265,
-0.068384558,
0.0184082314,
0.0310062468,
0.0097288629,
-0.0084742773,
0.0138500612,
-0.0000504085,
0.000974055,
-0.065346323,
0.0277003888,
-0.0089048939,
-0.0593411848,
-0.0088566467,
0.0097147264,
0.0272522047,
0.0290716682,
-0.028576022,
0.0016314671,
0.0008788687,
-0.0299005322,
-0.0414537638,
0.0031784552,
-0.0255330801,
0.008446767,
-0.0365204886,
0.0092504974,
-0.022858534,
0.0647057667,
0.0031843497,
-0.0164150205,
-0.0005679457,
0.0579169914,
-0.0286534745,
0.0337556861,
-0.0260432549,
-0.0453266129,
0.0144510269,
0.0158503372,
0.0451382436,
0.0191459209,
0.0083885845,
0.0051450017,
0.0247425623,
-0.0494203269,
-0.0119954767,
0.0381762646,
0.0315479264,
-0.0154247629,
0.0018036648,
0.041367095,
-0.0779623315,
0.0285798628,
0.0214904211,
0.0344012231,
-0.031744916,
-0.0190502517,
0.0097885039,
0.059123151,
0.0240355469,
0.0232540034,
-0.0536189228,
-0.0447619781,
0.0050456612,
-0.0193791594,
-0.0018143293,
0.0004601157,
0.0371583849,
0.0270844772,
0.009660461,
0.0255329274,
-0.0133405253,
-0.0194127243,
-0.0131804543,
0.0038672362,
0.000139132,
-6.415005484e-33,
-0.0261559598,
-0.0166499726,
-0.0271793697,
-0.0055002701,
-0.0584237091,
0.0537875071,
-0.0391386636,
0.0056602494,
-0.0265801381,
0.0200117659,
0.0338131152,
0.0162624363,
-0.0011878624,
0.0559648834,
-0.0065158806,
0.0073058642,
0.0303873587,
-0.000486421,
0.010754047,
0.0783153474,
0.0513350926,
-0.0040579163,
0.056304045,
-0.0998460278,
-0.0217757784,
0.0026802667,
-0.0471232422,
0.0339285396,
0.0244477168,
0.0506536402,
-0.0563961342,
0.0047817933,
0.0233200844,
-0.0362089016,
-0.0159264188,
0.0429849476,
-0.0357726663,
-0.028296994,
-0.0188110024,
-0.0188068599,
-0.0258395076,
-0.0169405881,
-0.0141432397,
0.0075633428,
0.0299394578,
-0.0590228438,
-0.0089891851,
-0.0067509306,
-0.0273540895,
-0.0892659575,
-0.0058368403,
0.0358984992,
-0.0189356655,
-0.0272171721,
0.0072194133,
0.019040551,
0.0550681688,
0.0040930263,
-0.0205891766,
0.0204529129,
-0.0435660109,
-0.0266283564,
-0.0121009275,
-0.0169665962,
0.0063654594,
0.0865857527,
0.0382221378,
0.0038686211,
-0.0165534988,
-0.0342279449,
-0.0146148866,
0.0383874997,
0.0137988096,
0.0660201609,
0.0207637306,
0.0052887443,
-0.0204126649,
0.0066561042,
0.0637861788,
-0.0115434658,
0.0220410023,
0.0359368697,
-0.0240068939,
0.0021070412,
0.0203782972,
0.0227595326,
-0.0350304283,
-0.0094642993,
0.0069562173,
0.0288853645,
-0.0136062037,
0.0347848013,
0.0275497362,
-0.0408728831,
-0.0032019156,
0.0635412633,
-0.0277209133,
0.030256141,
0.0003501915,
-0.0107737454,
-0.0033561469,
-0.0362569839,
0.0021879422,
0.0378703661,
0.0037057674,
0.0039908816,
0.0284961835,
-0.0059271948,
-0.0752864778,
-0.0029368405,
-0.0195524152,
0.0341013148,
-0.027206691,
0.0582497232,
0.0085623367,
0.0022862267,
-0.033519201,
0.0779067352,
0.0056774411,
0.0446610712,
-0.0310737379,
0.0004251225,
0.001807802,
0.048058942,
-0.0118454956,
-0.0328929126,
-0.0216568206,
-0.0568821467,
0.017187763,
-0.0416056924,
-0.025030436,
0.0039413059,
2.652e-7,
-0.009084112,
0.0321364552,
0.0427904241,
-0.020576911,
0.0263059475,
0.0732041746,
0.0065121786,
0.0205669515,
-0.0033733791,
-0.0143997641,
-0.0052991272,
0.0308211111,
0.0343200602,
0.0366334878,
-0.0478989258,
0.0226417705,
-0.0666753054,
-0.0174124986,
-0.0254858732,
0.0078635477,
0.0790131763,
0.1109963581,
0.0112154195,
-0.0328598209,
-0.0157683939,
0.0232185572,
0.0409095548,
0.0301339328,
-0.0265723839,
0.0130915502,
-0.0509457104,
0.0083071906,
-0.0189352799,
-0.0256030466,
-0.0083187204,
0.0543434583,
-0.0002281267,
0.0815771297,
0.0129093835,
-0.1061493903,
0.0268355124,
0.0264957882,
-0.0069746659,
-0.0043241004,
0.0406872183,
-0.0614963584,
-0.030576583,
-0.0696597621,
-0.0339686722,
0.0365400985,
0.0234253388,
0.0204893518,
-0.0106765274,
0.0506456085,
-0.0281653255,
-0.0390393175,
-0.0308768917,
-0.1209610626,
0.0110547105,
0.0229460988,
-0.0157878641,
-0.026808966,
-0.0029423113,
-0.040302217,
0.0119797811,
-0.0511179455,
0.0121721765,
2.117282976e-34,
0.0550622754,
-0.0309646837,
0.0077451379,
0.057454668,
0.0100015597,
-0.027890671,
-0.0429633893,
-0.0089233788,
0.0459179431,
-0.0330503844,
0.029344935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15461v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15461v1 | ChatCounselor: A Large Language Models for Mental Health Support | 2023-09-27T07:57:21 | 2023-09-27T07:57:21 | June M. Liu, Donghao Li, He Cao, Tianhe Ren, Zeyi Liao, Jiamin Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents ChatCounselor, a large language model (LLM) solution
designed to provide mental health support. Unlike generic chatbots,
ChatCounselor is distinguished by its foundation in real conversations between
consulting clients and professional psychologists, enabling it to possess
specialized knowledge and counseling skills in the field of psychology. The
training dataset, Psych8k, was constructed from 260 in-depth interviews, each
spanning an hour. To assess the quality of counseling responses, the counseling
Bench was devised. Leveraging GPT-4 and meticulously crafted prompts based on
seven metrics of psychological counseling assessment, the model underwent
evaluation using a set of real-world counseling questions. Impressively,
ChatCounselor surpasses existing open-source models in the counseling Bench and
approaches the performance level of ChatGPT, showcasing the remarkable
enhancement in model capability attained through high-quality domain-specific
data. | [
0.0880921856,
0.0352213793,
-0.0419014506,
-0.0053615966,
-0.0447197631,
0.0332105607,
0.0415998474,
-0.0026114713,
0.0988509953,
-0.0303743985,
-0.0139584867,
-0.0388556011,
-0.0293979608,
0.0350346677,
-0.011478235,
-0.0854449272,
0.0099608405,
0.0145157734,
0.0611088239,
0.001270726,
0.0304715615,
0.0383090153,
-0.0518170223,
0.0649954677,
-0.031655468,
-0.0401691236,
0.0144412173,
0.0083774235,
0.0082201501,
-0.0589169189,
0.0302666575,
0.0345139205,
-0.0162640791,
0.0031613042,
0.0000021831,
-0.0220204219,
-0.0144699523,
0.009844806,
-0.0148387821,
-0.0483762175,
0.0567349866,
-0.0490901805,
0.00513023,
0.0496704392,
-0.0197849926,
-0.0088668773,
0.0245444328,
0.0697634071,
0.0857833102,
0.0670738891,
-0.0263837278,
0.0017289805,
0.0124160135,
-0.0105288727,
-0.0384002514,
-0.0365144834,
0.013161948,
0.0355848037,
0.0534505211,
0.0006802363,
-0.0114661213,
0.0144423591,
-0.0178403277,
-0.0057385494,
-0.0224972125,
-0.0161383376,
-0.0429388322,
-0.0465213172,
-0.0098115727,
0.0674353838,
0.0458143614,
0.0432430618,
-0.0041901604,
-0.0076961396,
0.0195121467,
-0.0366038047,
-0.0293776188,
0.0289908815,
-0.0040289299,
-0.0156578906,
0.0075932802,
-0.0151777854,
-0.0103122871,
-0.0060719652,
0.0425489843,
0.0368723571,
0.0008523064,
-0.0252119657,
0.0343462974,
-0.0051294365,
-0.044450812,
-0.0678440854,
0.0223633014,
0.057324294,
-0.0706162378,
0.012022824,
-0.0156469624,
-0.0238984451,
0.015906129,
-0.006714826,
-0.0280845296,
0.0627986118,
-0.0399988778,
-0.0065530245,
0.0572457202,
0.0557427779,
0.0316696949,
0.0054542953,
-0.0308309644,
-0.0163131636,
-0.0876715779,
-0.0063562808,
-0.0525246337,
0.0152121326,
-0.0173754226,
-0.0355859622,
-0.0745489001,
0.0460671186,
-0.021254709,
0.0047723157,
0.0028755958,
-0.0252697617,
0.0020609209,
-0.0003630501,
-0.0088639976,
0.0296585225,
-0.0295262132,
0.0008506085,
0.0176860113,
-0.0933152363,
0.0431187004,
0.0222133044,
-0.0352307893,
-0.0361504629,
0.0105508501,
0.0572603717,
0.0276473332,
-0.0284667611,
-0.0204208121,
-0.0293121673,
-0.0509545654,
-0.0565341525,
-0.0134811178,
-0.0296260696,
0.0261710193,
0.009319636,
0.0074619809,
-0.0238186754,
0.0374733061,
-0.0064909211,
-0.0474238731,
0.066378139,
-0.0331679024,
0.0058023422,
0.0360094905,
0.0347081944,
-0.0150021957,
0.0483628139,
-0.024224991,
0.0209969822,
0.0221487619,
-0.0392520241,
0.007179643,
0.0226434059,
-0.0425932296,
-0.0415430814,
0.0049269204,
-0.0063364389,
0.0068266448,
0.0523227379,
-0.014825088,
0.0258858185,
-0.0176613256,
0.0174474735,
0.0522081479,
0.0626019761,
-0.0022060082,
0.0624449998,
0.0061139753,
0.0432029702,
0.0215156339,
-0.0182881132,
-0.061847195,
0.0139933173,
-0.0337454788,
-0.0330379456,
0.0056553599,
0.0047625052,
-0.0340756066,
-0.0451857001,
-0.0266262852,
-0.0387328044,
-0.0192173552,
0.0245776251,
-0.0026484129,
-0.0315615013,
-0.0011525587,
0.0348817445,
0.0366385877,
-0.0051326966,
-0.056315694,
-0.05494247,
0.0180807654,
0.0943047926,
0.0334913954,
-0.0491926447,
-0.0537906475,
-0.0178649239,
0.0049295328,
0.0469565094,
0.03935441,
0.0173913557,
0.0045452681,
-0.0308563989,
-0.0099193742,
0.0194725394,
0.0068570599,
-0.0136745218,
-0.0082863932,
0.0352143832,
-0.0277195107,
0.0265341233,
-0.0163357463,
0.0424846746,
-0.0116004832,
-0.0185927991,
0.0083784806,
-0.02453354,
0.0571917519,
0.0312406551,
-0.0033060729,
0.0030941216,
0.0217198897,
-0.0332340449,
-0.0420417972,
0.0232930593,
-0.0298859254,
-0.0479923673,
0.0404224992,
-0.0004786166,
-0.0219100621,
0.0512800738,
-0.0286880378,
-0.0214234889,
0.0283521935,
-0.0605708025,
0.0595604964,
-0.0086030765,
0.0061606606,
-0.021521179,
0.0295813214,
-0.0170808081,
0.020800706,
0.0020897181,
0.0167122502,
0.0066657914,
0.0070957188,
-0.0393935479,
-0.0333146267,
-0.0230756607,
0.0115801953,
-0.0118837366,
0.0029266004,
0.0062358361,
0.0259287748,
-0.0503548719,
-0.0508224592,
-0.1555315554,
0.0267689656,
-0.0077265454,
-0.0214550849,
0.0226526838,
-0.0141201103,
-0.0197754782,
-0.0250724871,
-0.0661929548,
0.0435343571,
0.0441710278,
0.0308684912,
0.0078079705,
0.0038626229,
-0.0249375291,
-0.0377282426,
-0.0003001237,
-0.0223126505,
-0.0217062365,
-0.0047134538,
-0.0117470063,
-0.046412874,
0.0198288858,
-0.0632163584,
0.0074191731,
-0.0170441289,
-0.0605689809,
0.0145830764,
-0.0083329938,
0.0484664775,
0.0245329011,
0.0304323528,
0.0211581215,
0.0007501703,
0.0114527913,
-0.0438477732,
0.0050323056,
-0.0005458147,
-0.0534015112,
-0.0479737669,
-0.0531805493,
-0.0083738565,
0.0282536354,
0.030904768,
0.0219591595,
-0.0489253178,
-0.0079875058,
-0.0029494669,
0.0221138354,
-0.0085662547,
0.0243303291,
-0.0002313313,
0.0100540156,
0.0093701379,
-0.0241723917,
0.0539630763,
0.002439271,
-0.0158476681,
-0.0519511476,
-0.0699900612,
-0.0400480554,
0.0405678302,
-0.0053117014,
0.0283883289,
0.0246563647,
-0.0213536154,
0.0143192345,
-0.0355287716,
-0.0188371092,
-0.0441464782,
-0.0036145013,
-0.0666662082,
0.0074232896,
0.0354917161,
-0.0128184808,
-0.0624233,
-0.0404877849,
-0.0597437285,
0.0029779717,
0.0310622994,
0.0185288601,
-0.0589884184,
-0.0270924661,
0.0309297182,
0.0321857668,
-0.0223039947,
-0.0281408262,
-0.0005480045,
-0.000392397,
0.0404320322,
0.0021165051,
0.0394148752,
-0.0212837178,
0.0501869582,
0.036375571,
-0.0452344231,
0.0379914865,
-0.0035734097,
0.0044759321,
-0.0037861511,
0.0202007126,
0.0044898563,
0.0104993451,
0.0529386178,
-0.0263130609,
-0.0287155621,
0.1431849748,
0.0184578467,
-0.0517171584,
0.0017617871,
-0.0653365105,
-0.0112927034,
0.019501552,
0.004920315,
-0.0460072309,
-0.0348754004,
-0.0210603327,
0.0267426074,
-0.0307902172,
-0.0152468132,
-0.0002234447,
-0.0658656582,
0.0437500365,
-0.0105796605,
-0.021024365,
-0.0278954003,
-0.0025101425,
0.0036810569,
-0.0074178218,
0.0281220879,
-0.0229570791,
0.0079379901,
-0.0029614742,
0.0096503105,
-0.0762571916,
-0.0310871862,
0.0624010898,
-0.0127667505,
0.1128498837,
0.0444014482,
0.0410318747,
-0.0090749227,
-0.0017176123,
0.0073043844,
0.0659813732,
-0.0197424069,
0.02438193,
0.0673428848,
0.0097934175,
0.0041978592,
-0.0431878977,
0.0450171083,
-0.0611555614,
0.0222573001,
0.0443169996,
0.0695230365,
-0.0247817859,
-0.0030711121,
-0.0143560227,
0.0665343627,
0.0464639775,
0.0509518459,
0.0099260667,
-0.0632604957,
-0.0140726827,
0.0001564325,
0.0042600734,
0.0521730334,
-0.0323455371,
0.0257926304,
-0.0174449012,
0.0279541556,
-0.0510496907,
-0.0546432659,
0.0531022362,
-0.0379620269,
-0.0086457673,
-0.0220899694,
-0.0038286429,
0.0291551668,
-0.0124496901,
0.0419837236,
-0.0231707413,
0.0358532108,
-0.0661599934,
-0.0073190327,
0.0390656367,
-0.0335104652,
0.0075149406,
0.0384851806,
-0.0255893283,
-0.0136197805,
0.0386146158,
0.0326196812,
0.0145188998,
-0.0221783929,
0.001149355,
-0.0407348201,
-0.0127578117,
0.0367828421,
-0.0606268644,
-0.0245570745,
0.0068102172,
0.0790716559,
0.0092628561,
0.0397746004,
-0.0153776994,
0.077038452,
0.0209968686,
0.0121099139,
-0.0109831747,
-0.0408020653,
0.0171732754,
0.0513441004,
-0.0046844473,
0.0076820389,
-0.0203122776,
-0.008514585,
-0.0403588079,
-0.0333984531,
-0.0009153642,
-0.0497676358,
-0.0055901655,
0.032787133,
-0.0212695897,
0.0129280966,
-0.0618468076,
-0.0549379401,
-0.0121433409,
-0.029366944,
-0.0051242514,
-0.0038953715,
-0.0091923401,
0.0058784685,
0.0114885252,
-0.0067876643,
0.0212484859,
-0.0051427661,
0.0357705168,
-0.0261543412,
0.1236168742,
-0.0078578265,
-0.0014138662,
0.0610558279,
0.0251083523,
-0.0337411799,
-0.1224294826,
0.0075536096,
0.0353456661,
0.0426149666,
0.0466853753,
0.0408189595,
-0.0375159048,
0.0105065666,
-0.0235011466,
0.0291701555,
0.0014266034,
-0.0189192276,
0.0208171234,
0.0096050296,
-0.024609305,
-0.0065808608,
0.0335954353,
-0.0282231532,
0.026302075,
0.0314845257,
-0.0261411034,
-0.0492258854,
0.0070095495,
0.0162997693,
0.0381922089,
-0.0252138749,
0.0214331113,
-0.0385484286,
-0.0499264337,
0.0062067821,
-0.0360812955,
-0.0341295265,
-0.0214634128,
0.0379722081,
0.0249482524,
-0.0159912873,
-0.0295630638,
-0.063398838,
0.0476983562,
-0.0302946772,
-0.0162552204,
-0.0263261404,
-5.815151452e-33,
-0.004560655,
-0.0202903673,
0.0147750704,
0.0164442286,
-0.0180935711,
-0.013509552,
-0.0176489539,
0.0277383775,
-0.0161362346,
0.0204325709,
0.0220840573,
0.0770847648,
-0.0025237766,
0.0350970142,
0.0336457081,
0.018947985,
0.0314329304,
-0.0202596784,
-0.0120327808,
0.0388348177,
-0.016717406,
0.0554796122,
0.0506729558,
-0.0997223705,
0.0311259534,
-0.0099414149,
-0.0030432055,
0.0363921039,
0.0222790372,
0.0345830321,
-0.0513130948,
0.0635399595,
0.0417139679,
-0.0127382493,
0.0049642771,
0.0137041714,
-0.0307323169,
-0.0279186219,
0.0052226651,
-0.0023125075,
-0.0527834184,
-0.0061699757,
-0.0135978889,
-0.0510550253,
0.0135793956,
-0.0300078616,
0.0240722336,
-0.0623604506,
0.0198383294,
0.0365813375,
-0.0272712503,
-0.0005013315,
-0.0283284523,
-0.0269097444,
-0.034402892,
0.0750717446,
-0.050601121,
0.0151231056,
-0.0004913018,
0.0021565377,
0.0110590933,
0.0019759585,
-0.0012016634,
-0.0433680452,
-0.0242202282,
0.0506039113,
0.0118084801,
-0.0067374692,
-0.0089245886,
-0.0110641634,
-0.0099955089,
0.03015434,
0.0549924448,
0.0295110624,
-0.0200169552,
-0.0325905979,
-0.031204218,
-0.0064447005,
0.0919523239,
-0.0112805432,
0.0229087416,
0.0006062993,
-0.0127610862,
-0.0076089953,
-0.0319359489,
-0.005111496,
-0.0272149034,
-0.0448198877,
0.0305685811,
-0.0077511095,
0.0035306932,
-0.026201915,
-0.0007427784,
-0.0441345088,
0.0289557595,
0.0082020294,
-0.0155984629,
0.0287265442,
0.0062434697,
0.0337057039,
-0.033653494,
-0.0166659653,
0.0015469072,
-0.0082127005,
0.0468443036,
-0.0189240016,
0.028866753,
-0.008153866,
-0.032314349,
-0.0140940631,
-0.0096172784,
0.0709064975,
-0.0066411057,
0.0190879684,
-0.049903553,
0.0229455642,
-0.0184442326,
0.059820734,
0.0138005363,
0.0160561539,
-0.0644684359,
-0.0382171385,
-0.0145470342,
-0.025439335,
-0.0467061922,
-0.0414269269,
-0.0305374339,
0.0135764284,
0.0496341549,
-0.0266293362,
-0.000095044,
-0.0330235474,
2.76e-7,
0.0137797231,
0.0754214376,
-0.0217798427,
0.016814718,
0.0343067683,
0.014446958,
0.0128531763,
0.0474531129,
0.0388721563,
-0.0361571759,
-0.00880735,
0.0271502975,
0.0568455718,
0.0447188579,
-0.024701722,
-0.0378441475,
-0.0176635366,
-0.0703095049,
-0.0616723634,
0.0300842375,
0.0952920839,
0.0994001552,
0.0098021841,
-0.0349277556,
-0.0102215819,
0.0047176867,
0.042625688,
-0.0431356095,
-0.0252147131,
0.055282075,
0.0402582027,
0.0284032896,
0.0234319605,
0.0278264266,
0.0214276146,
0.0041117072,
-0.0161653254,
0.0997874066,
-0.0296365544,
-0.0264555439,
0.0270079952,
0.0429536141,
-0.0088869734,
-0.0300848186,
0.0414032303,
-0.0928802192,
-0.053785637,
-0.0503627025,
-0.0225535538,
-0.0708812326,
0.0473883078,
-0.0328935757,
-0.0242114365,
0.0574370809,
0.0161737371,
-0.0144345853,
0.0254782811,
-0.040346954,
0.0189663824,
0.0256118104,
-0.0728751272,
-0.022696266,
0.0010027962,
0.0004958478,
-0.013640794,
-0.0580609404,
0.0565418415,
2.155065936e-34,
0.0282295533,
0.0413329527,
0.0294759069,
0.0227493327,
0.0481355451,
0.0333568342,
0.0079544717,
0.0374352075,
-0.0056795646,
-0.0724751428,
-0.0088664833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.15427v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15427v2 | Graph Neural Prompting with Large Language Models | 2023-09-27T06:33:29 | 2023-12-28T21:14:01 | Yijun Tian, Huan Song, Zichen Wang, Haozhu Wang, Ziqing Hu, Fang Wang, Nitesh V. Chawla, Panpan Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable generalization capability
with exceptional performance in various language modeling tasks. However, they
still exhibit inherent limitations in precisely capturing and returning
grounded knowledge. While existing work has explored utilizing knowledge graphs
(KGs) to enhance language modeling via joint training and customized model
architectures, applying this to LLMs is problematic owing to their large number
of parameters and high computational cost. Therefore, how to enhance
pre-trained LLMs using grounded knowledge, e.g., retrieval-augmented
generation, remains an open question. In this work, we propose Graph Neural
Prompting (GNP), a novel plug-and-play method to assist pre-trained LLMs in
learning beneficial knowledge from KGs. GNP encompasses various designs,
including a standard graph neural network encoder, a cross-modality pooling
module, a domain projector, and a self-supervised link prediction objective.
Extensive experiments on multiple datasets demonstrate the superiority of GNP
on both commonsense and biomedical reasoning tasks across different LLM sizes
and settings. Code is available at https://github.com/meettyj/GNP. | [
0.0538927056,
0.0394611284,
0.0113516608,
0.0306091942,
-0.0126013299,
-0.0248085503,
-0.0104077635,
-0.0079930276,
0.0755408034,
-0.0375467204,
-0.0225087684,
0.001376842,
-0.0165313724,
0.0257208571,
0.0391347818,
0.0165645778,
0.0390399396,
0.0006555429,
-0.0090278089,
-0.0257410221,
-0.0179417413,
0.051175978,
-0.0035824799,
0.0191810075,
-0.0087307636,
0.0133666527,
-0.0036660265,
0.0158639438,
-0.0234971195,
-0.0491953902,
-0.0002025828,
0.0516849682,
0.057195127,
0.0314677991,
0.0000019999,
-0.0304423496,
0.0006990494,
-0.0215536542,
-0.0628676414,
-0.0205946136,
0.0165509395,
-0.0045649153,
0.0483933091,
-0.0160230473,
-0.0557542108,
-0.0480566211,
0.0245390031,
0.0383724049,
0.0291448087,
0.0651280805,
0.0023873004,
-0.0145137133,
0.02624451,
-0.0283783004,
0.0171874631,
-0.020232087,
0.0205596257,
0.0467039756,
0.0144621087,
0.0179789402,
-0.0312572755,
0.0423495099,
0.044009015,
-0.0064258636,
0.0503975861,
0.0573038273,
-0.001656645,
0.0081454506,
-0.0115899956,
0.1395795792,
0.0115475655,
-0.0263409745,
-0.002613808,
-0.0025004505,
0.0195641797,
0.0454793461,
-0.0508496724,
-0.0125873759,
0.0087791216,
0.0235003978,
-0.0161471032,
-0.0223910529,
0.0735659599,
-0.0072646574,
0.002938129,
0.0768142045,
0.0206434149,
-0.0059675281,
0.0559562258,
0.0267892182,
-0.013579309,
-0.0375975966,
0.0130125135,
0.0460114107,
-0.0266720038,
0.0247002058,
-0.0087316418,
0.0121098105,
0.023495324,
-0.0025588789,
0.0285422932,
0.0048418287,
-0.0088404212,
0.0242528208,
-0.0547638163,
0.0115908589,
-0.0313900858,
0.0457276441,
-0.0432055928,
-0.0165748671,
-0.0510894842,
-0.0173883997,
-0.0274648611,
0.0304965265,
-0.0457299352,
-0.0364561602,
-0.0583815798,
0.0357534885,
-0.0042417026,
0.0083720768,
0.0572842769,
0.0653899014,
0.0012373595,
-0.0321558267,
-0.0268205702,
0.0651251674,
-0.0216468051,
0.0349828526,
0.0067617432,
-0.0265286919,
-0.0199402161,
0.014791673,
0.0422899649,
-0.0338726044,
0.0242905077,
0.0600647628,
0.0099983122,
-0.0281093232,
-0.0342804268,
-0.0505523682,
-0.0218549371,
-0.0499079116,
0.0566533208,
-0.0698809177,
0.0351041295,
0.0036178292,
-0.022291664,
-0.0599499643,
0.0372793898,
0.0026083393,
-0.0384448022,
0.0487774052,
-0.018598279,
-0.0077123512,
0.0068327952,
-0.0032692836,
-0.0083013298,
0.0347482748,
0.0078568198,
0.0000524806,
0.0301273149,
-0.000854874,
-0.0305163004,
-0.0023389999,
0.0768530443,
-0.0024460608,
0.0090162316,
-0.0063432623,
-0.0270936582,
0.0506125651,
0.0235065967,
0.0380787067,
-0.0337597281,
-0.0038938436,
0.0327298529,
0.0509463735,
0.0303721596,
0.0173939243,
0.0467414223,
0.0091735916,
-0.02691276,
-0.0207995307,
-0.0688951164,
0.032039959,
-0.0460666493,
0.0245647337,
-0.0016241007,
-0.0016685433,
-0.0383499227,
-0.0061318325,
0.0195853375,
-0.0170923378,
0.0679710358,
0.0329875313,
0.0505294204,
0.0306978915,
-0.0443538614,
0.0796669647,
0.0432655253,
-0.0404783711,
0.0377667435,
-0.0220718291,
0.0102651846,
0.0444983654,
0.0407612175,
0.0030118923,
-0.0514524318,
-0.0043432619,
0.003346381,
0.0033611297,
0.0006883633,
-0.0377255529,
-0.0086401505,
-0.0784575939,
-0.0361685269,
-0.0277367812,
-0.0095016072,
0.009164515,
0.0321427658,
0.003437659,
0.0486325137,
-0.0969526619,
0.0094331233,
0.015816398,
-0.0400957577,
-0.0035260385,
0.0064084004,
0.0011015501,
-0.0041398928,
0.0492538922,
0.0243729167,
0.0228995252,
0.0464046374,
-0.0374930874,
-0.0373962149,
0.0196065474,
-0.0814609453,
-0.0764831677,
0.0376597196,
-0.0009435163,
-0.0166842695,
-0.0099112829,
-0.0365877561,
-0.0573134311,
0.0502683185,
-0.0176693089,
0.0670978203,
-0.0435667261,
-0.0322759785,
0.0227736086,
-0.018110387,
-0.0012654293,
0.0676820055,
-0.0039556473,
0.0170167815,
0.0137424795,
0.0192094091,
-0.0026365253,
-0.0470281988,
0.0027641279,
0.0036503042,
0.004776834,
0.0042883279,
0.0199506991,
0.0366895795,
-0.0786495507,
0.0234425049,
-0.1215453073,
-0.0009977602,
-0.0114538968,
-0.0035448077,
-0.0079550482,
0.0207233634,
0.0132694794,
-0.0504854806,
-0.0722377524,
0.0487283431,
0.0206464659,
0.0180837084,
0.0200141743,
-0.0056446195,
0.0117794378,
-0.0153475041,
-0.0319980606,
-0.0045917011,
0.0755252391,
0.0239006635,
0.0011134369,
-0.0172293931,
0.0421363898,
-0.0526428595,
0.0168224815,
-0.0189455803,
0.0076162745,
0.005349542,
-0.0161608737,
0.0555173904,
0.0367848799,
-0.0368240401,
0.0015634056,
0.0541770197,
-0.0137052163,
-0.0628919527,
-0.0108288294,
-0.0825454593,
-0.0200672615,
-0.0156312659,
0.0245713666,
-0.0242477562,
0.0258733705,
0.0210576076,
-0.0267134402,
-0.0636736155,
-0.0223391764,
0.0055752429,
-0.0003008475,
-0.0614831932,
-0.000420322,
0.0008955148,
0.0089546246,
-0.0234263912,
-0.0317832232,
0.0998075977,
-0.0065387217,
-0.0035410137,
-0.003652076,
0.0006469844,
-0.037238393,
0.0609045252,
-0.0086385906,
0.0170877632,
0.0018860492,
-0.0453488305,
-0.0527459942,
0.0184818115,
-0.0234179925,
-0.0442369618,
0.04061912,
-0.0223680958,
0.0359981582,
0.034319263,
-0.0231803805,
-0.0516144373,
-0.0000818627,
-0.0434963517,
0.0224475879,
-0.0409269631,
-0.005079119,
0.0309954099,
-0.0261229444,
0.0066701728,
0.0306884404,
-0.0113902763,
0.0190767311,
-0.0174259767,
0.0334019884,
0.0513042808,
0.0135730645,
0.0064158193,
-0.0332081616,
-0.0170942955,
0.0411790498,
0.009276256,
-0.0181404911,
-0.008764918,
0.0260778125,
-0.002610577,
0.0059252284,
-0.000208174,
0.0083435755,
0.0600756034,
-0.0389614254,
-0.0270934198,
0.1083639935,
0.0201137196,
-0.0615100451,
0.003779476,
-0.0252299756,
0.0190493949,
0.0240812991,
0.01521267,
-0.088474296,
-0.0448350869,
-0.0096555119,
0.0177791473,
0.0475996919,
-0.044472117,
0.0154670356,
-0.1224952117,
-0.00523578,
0.0333844163,
-0.0103128096,
-0.0572649203,
-0.0437898971,
-0.0147966444,
0.0157105401,
0.0056071309,
0.0020011766,
0.0132677676,
0.0107072471,
0.0112906555,
0.0290619135,
-0.071564965,
0.0212680046,
-0.0342360809,
0.044009421,
0.0122121843,
0.0232472345,
0.0236569177,
-0.0423485078,
0.0314542018,
0.0034134036,
-0.0070751263,
-0.0277768709,
0.0512048788,
0.0075132865,
0.0145862605,
-0.0370344594,
0.0581566729,
-0.0928641632,
-0.0212526117,
-0.0249328632,
0.0990931541,
-0.0243844483,
-0.0273044705,
0.01880854,
0.0119209411,
0.0128487833,
0.0479092672,
0.0397283174,
0.0204965677,
0.0044674212,
-0.0202275068,
0.0322130211,
-0.0259784553,
-0.0352382883,
0.0346045047,
0.002233508,
0.0568188727,
-0.0672093853,
-0.0198008269,
0.0389355496,
0.009905573,
0.0043978244,
-0.0031708328,
0.0280215256,
-0.0135427201,
-0.0812924653,
0.0644969419,
-0.0443754047,
-0.0096869366,
-0.031817846,
-0.0190764964,
0.0454282947,
-0.0403608903,
-0.0157900508,
0.0143744722,
-0.0389061421,
-0.0755755752,
-0.0521778949,
0.0338488743,
0.0129973162,
0.0731978565,
-0.0269350819,
-0.0068238624,
0.0549092777,
0.0437335335,
-0.036874868,
-0.004234246,
0.0109003438,
-0.0257794522,
-0.0059255534,
0.0501792096,
-0.0685459822,
-0.0042945868,
0.0287977885,
0.0720536187,
0.005216422,
-0.0644674376,
0.0132495333,
0.0439696498,
0.0267871227,
-0.0086532431,
0.0217783246,
-0.0704487637,
-0.0027096455,
-0.0295544881,
-0.0146829663,
-0.0320199281,
-0.0040924447,
0.0233154781,
-0.0190738067,
0.0112935882,
-0.0579738505,
0.0000483113,
0.079172872,
-0.0264446586,
-0.0219897926,
0.0122727314,
-0.016712036,
0.0527084097,
0.0077986051,
-0.0149035677,
0.0279676188,
0.0067499229,
0.0242610723,
-0.0513927378,
0.051848758,
0.0138858762,
-0.0441853516,
-0.0587520823,
0.0158539135,
-0.0422965251,
-0.0300146341,
-0.0032823063,
0.0306575559,
0.0694300234,
0.000762401,
0.0191196855,
-0.0102498541,
-0.0142131038,
-0.0046367976,
0.0604448169,
-0.0075723045,
-0.0416865237,
0.0507893786,
0.0234052781,
-0.0116750328,
0.0256306343,
0.0483958684,
0.0092514707,
0.0439724438,
0.003218994,
-0.0101358937,
-0.0456647612,
-0.0343262926,
-0.0007919189,
0.0351874083,
-0.0338879339,
0.0407695174,
-0.0478849784,
-0.0978653207,
0.0137602696,
-0.0009631423,
-0.0385635197,
0.0288243815,
0.0553500876,
0.0476807617,
-0.0007190123,
-0.0248728003,
-0.0224736929,
0.0692227483,
-0.0400939733,
-0.01843323,
-0.0140940985,
-6.454307403e-33,
-0.0198688097,
-0.0458339788,
0.0448896214,
-0.0184099395,
-0.044382669,
0.0124759562,
-0.06434457,
-0.0120483516,
-0.0331234559,
0.0120208366,
-0.0004955267,
-0.0008597749,
-0.0128306383,
0.0393738858,
-0.0205663294,
-0.0330258533,
0.0321953073,
0.0121630225,
0.0103516383,
0.0489653423,
0.0547085181,
0.0561078265,
0.0608776882,
-0.0434834436,
0.0283118244,
-0.0049697836,
0.0372912325,
0.0422667451,
-0.001360182,
0.0373436362,
-0.0338819735,
0.0784590989,
0.020930782,
0.0063804025,
0.0073371534,
0.0311441906,
-0.1068425626,
-0.0568754263,
0.0157674253,
-0.0208273921,
-0.0425135121,
-0.037075974,
0.0478726812,
-0.0275536627,
0.0174980033,
-0.0137895979,
0.0139858872,
0.0121695623,
-0.0462671295,
-0.0092717381,
-0.0301952437,
-0.0071653887,
0.0203035194,
-0.0102728195,
-0.0142795742,
0.0225750506,
-0.0027101364,
0.0235476252,
-0.0595070496,
0.0243703909,
-0.0523392074,
0.0050882269,
0.036963746,
0.0195007473,
0.027510386,
0.0596715696,
-0.0390014797,
-0.0349013992,
-0.0627210513,
0.0293445475,
0.0270545781,
0.0333672129,
0.027362965,
0.0277524553,
-0.0255552307,
-0.0227532722,
-0.099484399,
-0.0079279887,
-0.0206314437,
0.0208089557,
-0.0001955346,
0.003695156,
0.0035377687,
-0.044090189,
-0.0507193655,
-0.0179945081,
-0.0193475522,
-0.0485754237,
0.0023138844,
0.0013979133,
-0.028312875,
0.0108075636,
-0.0015323107,
-0.0491440743,
-0.0018575194,
0.0722665489,
0.0179961845,
-0.0115572317,
-0.0092573473,
0.0306706373,
-0.0613623336,
-0.0168410111,
0.0316571631,
-0.046568647,
-0.0043300688,
0.0276578311,
0.0404659249,
0.0111227818,
-0.0307175182,
-0.0142600387,
-0.0635099262,
-0.0058150124,
0.0036726671,
0.0043741046,
0.0269331429,
0.0737820044,
-0.0300535783,
0.0481294021,
0.0347374119,
0.0364972204,
-0.0272594001,
-0.0002154068,
0.0127494577,
0.0367733613,
-0.0534861572,
-0.0054935743,
-0.0303987581,
0.0225482881,
0.0417211987,
-0.0577215552,
-0.0197695605,
-0.0189191978,
2.843e-7,
0.0540469475,
0.0333501808,
0.0259119142,
-0.0096343718,
-0.0087813493,
0.0124914842,
0.0070265001,
0.0121941529,
0.0256635807,
-0.066676572,
0.0321210399,
0.0570073836,
-0.0114721414,
0.0137346704,
-0.0826289803,
0.0341449343,
-0.0486954637,
-0.0516531505,
-0.0136168478,
-0.0001218531,
0.0202354491,
0.0618413836,
0.0242763795,
-0.0217486564,
-0.000623051,
-0.0590195879,
0.0746443421,
-0.0222179741,
-0.028011119,
-0.0322331376,
-0.0028552467,
-0.0051662927,
-0.0190581717,
0.0308271609,
-0.0030633279,
0.02442603,
0.005804929,
0.0485586151,
-0.0113785164,
-0.0248535033,
-0.0155747961,
-0.0167635009,
0.0084977821,
-0.0235511959,
0.0634789392,
-0.0892043337,
-0.0307956077,
-0.0111087449,
-0.0210563727,
-0.0080103856,
0.0099018272,
-0.026532162,
-0.0154941147,
0.002582374,
0.0224118605,
0.0052340841,
0.0080786562,
-0.079574652,
-0.011290512,
0.016492689,
-0.0212225895,
-0.0487406477,
0.0044785528,
-0.0250932388,
-0.0077966768,
-0.0447732843,
0.0200268216,
2.637953505e-34,
0.0084495246,
0.0235010851,
0.008210402,
0.0118049271,
0.0303941891,
-0.0224187933,
-0.0349041335,
0.0082914243,
0.0387248956,
-0.1113766432,
-0.0208775382
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.