id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11354v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11354v2 | Preserving Knowledge in Large Language Model with Model-Agnostic Self-Decompression | 2024-06-17T09:17:40 | 2024-06-19T11:36:30 | Zilun Zhang, Yutao Sun, Tiancheng Zhao, Leigang Sha, Ruochen Xu, Kyusong Lee, Jianwei Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Humans can retain old knowledge while learning new information, but Large
Language Models (LLMs) often suffer from catastrophic forgetting when
post-pretrained or supervised fine-tuned (SFT) on domain-specific data.
Moreover, for Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) which are composed of
the LLM base and visual projector (e.g. LLaVA), a significant decline in
performance on language benchmarks was observed compared to their
single-modality counterparts. To address these challenges, we introduce a novel
model-agnostic self-decompression method, Tree Generation (TG), that
decompresses knowledge within LLMs into the training corpus. This paper focuses
on TG-SFT, which can synthetically generate SFT data for the instruction tuning
steps. By incorporating the dumped corpus during SFT for MLLMs, we
significantly reduce the forgetting problem. | [
-0.01446959,
0.0775409564,
-0.0286249239,
0.0540798008,
-0.0196056459,
0.0109824333,
-0.031077601,
0.0027931156,
-0.034344703,
-0.0520268045,
-0.0713863373,
0.0177756697,
-0.0162744522,
-0.0121538565,
0.0273876078,
-0.0188987199,
0.0590751432,
-0.0593199283,
-0.0518721379,
-0.0198875777,
-0.0074863797,
0.0158923492,
0.0217207111,
-0.0091632232,
-0.0163180009,
-0.058918111,
-0.0405149646,
0.00214516,
-0.0370722972,
-0.0216626469,
-0.0058540381,
0.0300451871,
0.0363788344,
-0.002669269,
0.0000023106,
-0.0258125979,
-0.0166826472,
-0.0118577108,
-0.0441599898,
0.0361107104,
0.0226582736,
-0.0046435315,
-0.0067834109,
0.0028637,
-0.0209538098,
-0.0475154035,
0.0245561823,
0.0306578074,
0.077249065,
0.0763624907,
0.002822923,
-0.054289598,
0.0287502594,
-0.0083241304,
-0.0093675284,
-0.0233077016,
0.0089836083,
0.0058046682,
-0.0632277504,
0.0196464825,
-0.0476247929,
0.0286315121,
0.0228272863,
0.0152590135,
-0.0075307754,
0.0411719568,
0.003018311,
-0.0341488458,
-0.0139469709,
0.0207234882,
-0.0167133845,
-0.0356151685,
-0.0048000775,
-0.0028838608,
0.0142522799,
-0.0158189777,
-0.0407773443,
0.0563377254,
-0.0034652099,
0.0275288429,
0.0180575158,
-0.0674844235,
0.0283521656,
-0.0280270576,
-0.0109208627,
0.0101101631,
0.035371013,
-0.0149188349,
-0.0143981688,
-0.0233607516,
-0.0325941183,
-0.0079824105,
-0.0278787576,
0.035000734,
-0.012395571,
0.0133718504,
-0.0372930579,
-0.0244345795,
-0.0040359884,
-0.0257601067,
0.0737686455,
0.0014299412,
-0.0307236556,
0.0195864625,
-0.0508386679,
0.0388521142,
-0.0033647255,
0.0142837493,
-0.0373676121,
0.0062830178,
-0.0556093976,
-0.0244411454,
-0.0546714291,
0.0330950767,
-0.0379735343,
0.0322409756,
0.0036177419,
0.0291634463,
-0.004057717,
-0.0201550573,
0.0258736275,
-0.0038283365,
-0.0593761206,
-0.0108811567,
0.0123847565,
0.0700512379,
-0.0069115926,
-0.0003449022,
-0.013404944,
-0.0301036295,
-0.0116349589,
0.0404225178,
-0.0009088581,
-0.0195892062,
0.0291131865,
0.0527959652,
-0.0367581993,
-0.0258926228,
-0.0754375383,
-0.0241430104,
-0.0234328583,
-0.0812077895,
0.0630965382,
-0.0422735848,
0.0135758137,
-0.0273519978,
0.0207297113,
-0.0577515513,
-0.0122239087,
0.0062746741,
-0.0024993829,
0.0528323837,
-0.0202414338,
0.0198770314,
0.0299460106,
0.0051224823,
0.0403016955,
0.0774954855,
0.0131366346,
0.030689653,
0.0069169342,
-0.0522667207,
-0.0056919595,
0.0568043813,
0.0301883593,
-0.0015488693,
-0.040207196,
0.0000391749,
0.0067532607,
0.0085678129,
0.0481682383,
0.0289536212,
-0.0300564673,
-0.0072244979,
0.0493459143,
0.0133344093,
0.0644489601,
0.0598874278,
0.0243874043,
-0.0183118116,
0.0051580421,
0.0331009701,
-0.0524255671,
0.0190277267,
-0.0383979976,
0.008619667,
-0.0402724221,
0.0416761264,
-0.0514832921,
-0.0212777574,
0.0025184313,
-0.0268017743,
-0.0122653591,
0.0036413097,
0.0625855476,
0.0540402681,
-0.0211886931,
0.0592296943,
0.0351478048,
-0.0428198501,
0.016565688,
-0.051102411,
-0.0127059827,
0.0218052045,
0.0328846425,
-0.0157877225,
-0.0401822105,
0.02278951,
0.0110087134,
0.0102279391,
0.0114338528,
-0.0275393184,
0.0294650905,
-0.0456804819,
-0.0181048512,
-0.0074707544,
0.0173427425,
0.0107672233,
0.0102920588,
-0.0372220911,
0.0175626203,
-0.0447589979,
-0.0129211815,
0.0579985231,
-0.0621309541,
-0.0429466069,
-0.0051117749,
-0.0072408561,
0.0153426621,
-0.0081205629,
-0.0162260327,
-0.0177603718,
0.0739699528,
-0.0262195487,
0.0171433799,
0.0038132062,
-0.0984755307,
-0.0431779064,
0.0512117222,
-0.0042613358,
-0.0069037215,
0.0481464528,
-0.0360922106,
-0.047610037,
0.0091855153,
-0.0235047936,
0.0429625027,
-0.0689324141,
0.0368749499,
-0.0090926308,
0.0014835095,
-0.0324127637,
0.0587927774,
0.0008161098,
-0.0352328606,
-0.0039132521,
-0.0166756138,
0.0201326255,
-0.0105584189,
-0.0215534531,
0.0326948874,
-0.0026038967,
0.052189786,
0.0065075443,
0.0173363481,
-0.0659089088,
-0.0131502505,
-0.1109243035,
0.0145333605,
-0.0305158254,
0.0008447524,
0.0242621023,
-0.0052258638,
-0.0159633942,
-0.0351109095,
0.0058432366,
0.0534750521,
-0.0065218732,
0.0371078961,
-0.0028146075,
-0.0154380826,
0.0225876085,
-0.0084267715,
-0.0319171399,
0.0169002414,
0.027307732,
-0.0498178974,
-0.0199515633,
-0.0748512521,
0.0705515891,
-0.0168452356,
0.0534474626,
-0.0097654872,
-0.050012134,
0.0018376387,
-0.0440527983,
0.0442511141,
0.0835519284,
0.0082172919,
0.0338953771,
0.0892148167,
-0.0192157533,
-0.0402857959,
0.0192175787,
-0.0339486077,
-0.0718434751,
-0.0333949849,
0.0218493808,
-0.0117795411,
0.0724388957,
0.0011497691,
-0.0035604655,
-0.0416645147,
-0.0317026712,
-0.0299098901,
-0.0213365406,
-0.0221288651,
0.0030682271,
-0.04237739,
0.0002978118,
-0.0096988855,
-0.0664346963,
0.0454068705,
-0.0187045839,
-0.0049602063,
-0.0188049655,
0.0125133405,
-0.0185955744,
0.0749120265,
0.0320836902,
0.0283541474,
0.0215038806,
-0.0143417874,
-0.0754973367,
0.022842763,
0.0393813327,
-0.0140902298,
0.0236166772,
-0.0300999749,
-0.0075083897,
-0.017547857,
-0.0513263755,
-0.0269553829,
-0.0657533482,
0.0100265061,
-0.0095431181,
-0.004237154,
-0.0037885129,
-0.0030840221,
-0.013262731,
0.0284480713,
0.0316774026,
-0.0017244961,
-0.0062200017,
-0.0242520254,
0.0184452441,
0.0337567143,
0.0479686782,
-0.0053677633,
-0.0521577187,
0.0403840467,
0.0464097261,
0.0375284329,
0.0105711566,
-0.0505377166,
0.0269611795,
0.0256726574,
0.0098582665,
-0.0367404036,
0.0355430022,
0.0567918345,
-0.0587906204,
-0.0236323569,
0.098927021,
0.0009063379,
-0.059645541,
-0.0146994451,
-0.0046956465,
0.0690512881,
0.0357240066,
0.0289067104,
-0.0686099455,
-0.0427020304,
0.006339781,
0.027773004,
0.06082277,
-0.0082298722,
0.0109325321,
-0.1179030985,
0.0309219584,
0.0366674624,
-0.0070976359,
-0.0036783125,
-0.0269232914,
-0.0276812166,
0.0261330437,
0.0213251617,
0.0426344201,
-0.04827144,
0.00014413,
0.0288063046,
-0.0250347313,
-0.060377758,
0.0142759718,
-0.0091020847,
0.0536391176,
0.0641067252,
0.0279663112,
0.0148319965,
-0.0028312602,
0.0521195382,
-0.0071669216,
0.0351135768,
-0.0192794502,
0.0410269089,
0.0154757854,
-0.0153796086,
0.0296709575,
0.0304410104,
-0.0179883037,
-0.007810174,
0.0080305338,
0.0849380344,
-0.013855435,
-0.0364726558,
0.0171329658,
-0.0490667708,
-0.0565387793,
0.0537444353,
0.0356454402,
-0.0200025141,
-0.0182150397,
0.0012782904,
0.0394560061,
0.0181306731,
-0.0348365679,
0.0623047836,
-0.0357236117,
-0.0045168148,
-0.0487149917,
-0.01820869,
0.0252189059,
0.0466757827,
0.0048235971,
0.0175313409,
0.0040706024,
-0.0036705984,
-0.0775694922,
0.0374112539,
-0.0725692958,
-0.045866102,
-0.0516522154,
-0.010402428,
0.0587071292,
-0.0136894751,
0.0222368147,
0.0062274383,
-0.0850769654,
-0.0524914302,
0.0378634818,
0.0518460274,
0.0099654896,
0.0743046552,
0.0356072187,
-0.0699464753,
0.0357120968,
0.0458289422,
-0.0559389107,
0.0658542514,
0.0204980504,
-0.05341582,
-0.0109970728,
0.0479376726,
-0.0284448322,
0.0202198382,
0.0423806682,
0.0340947919,
0.0002602929,
0.0118550649,
0.0412256047,
0.0557133295,
0.0524286106,
-0.0490679331,
0.0133840907,
-0.0155410217,
0.0119669959,
-0.0209838301,
-0.0178424139,
-0.0330447033,
0.0156252012,
0.0104988646,
0.0076665385,
0.0349651128,
0.0004364143,
0.0451493151,
0.0181695633,
-0.0397486165,
-0.0136222532,
0.0529302321,
0.0016275008,
0.0312734023,
0.0456029736,
0.0173001122,
0.0189329535,
0.0309052542,
0.0270430073,
-0.027041629,
0.0761004016,
0.0051351399,
0.031335339,
-0.079163149,
0.0186669044,
-0.0047600847,
-0.0827382281,
-0.048433546,
0.0105097219,
0.0902679116,
-0.0059909285,
0.0395779796,
-0.0126485806,
-0.0172734726,
-0.0310253892,
0.015424435,
-0.0090774624,
-0.0050224694,
0.0099296616,
0.0062058615,
-0.0298180338,
0.0048495838,
0.0838314891,
0.0252504312,
0.0617804155,
-0.00397596,
0.0301873777,
-0.0446875617,
-0.0145968944,
-0.0114874458,
0.005118791,
-0.0094950637,
-0.017677119,
-0.0178631432,
-0.0872170031,
-0.0132055013,
0.0129996371,
0.0027831062,
0.0038254424,
0.0498909317,
0.045026619,
-0.0202250853,
-0.0306329224,
-0.0163205955,
0.0110587375,
0.0230477173,
-0.0016360822,
-0.0049755909,
-6.904626799e-33,
-0.0487523638,
0.010849894,
0.0495570041,
-0.0113219488,
-0.0303324461,
0.0045304368,
-0.02862533,
0.0156185599,
0.0113122342,
0.0132581089,
-0.0197705477,
-0.0044035371,
-0.0065004099,
0.0477378853,
0.0205705296,
0.0060571283,
0.0618058741,
-0.0565046519,
-0.023832079,
0.035108529,
0.0463528,
0.02798797,
0.0626162142,
-0.0473428555,
-0.0408442616,
0.0224297009,
-0.005646274,
0.0322429053,
-0.0137151908,
0.0548332036,
-0.0438208096,
0.0502650924,
0.0244862996,
-0.0152222961,
-0.0578836724,
-0.0291179679,
-0.1081886739,
-0.0360844508,
0.0036925985,
0.0058858255,
-0.0558033101,
-0.0112316059,
0.0720759481,
-0.0172576196,
-0.0244051535,
-0.0118698031,
0.0052682697,
-0.0121068554,
-0.0282471608,
-0.0146868117,
-0.0476570949,
-0.0123939365,
0.0085105393,
-0.0339240618,
0.0722251907,
-0.0318911076,
0.0021378607,
-0.0015989776,
-0.0384815522,
0.0137911243,
-0.0029133835,
0.0830430686,
0.0719435588,
0.045513846,
0.0268412884,
0.0635671243,
0.0548808761,
0.0131975925,
0.0102888877,
0.0110243885,
0.0710097179,
0.0534599423,
0.0131576275,
0.0286347643,
0.0286493208,
-0.03198836,
-0.0415856615,
0.0056323949,
-0.0416941866,
0.067816481,
-0.0094730174,
0.0368134826,
0.0241789985,
-0.0375919044,
-0.0651476011,
0.0141122052,
-0.0169840194,
0.0093488395,
0.035023734,
0.0241790432,
-0.0249398593,
-0.020340655,
0.0485868938,
-0.0387208834,
-0.0002464236,
0.0140154231,
-0.0497459769,
0.0294338036,
-0.001362958,
0.0355423838,
-0.0399008766,
-0.038006898,
0.0027779981,
-0.0361478887,
0.0249089319,
0.0149768628,
0.0135290045,
0.0640631244,
-0.0555956885,
-0.0046858042,
-0.0293942913,
-0.0253399685,
0.0257207584,
0.0279736836,
0.0444530435,
0.0146917151,
-0.00714309,
0.02789828,
0.0619858541,
0.001855183,
-0.0581804812,
-0.0031458961,
0.0319156013,
0.0248506162,
0.0248179268,
0.0000193375,
-0.0508010462,
-0.0353670493,
0.054884322,
-0.0623633191,
0.006635793,
0.0199298821,
2.917e-7,
0.0264267679,
0.0460761413,
-0.0050420328,
-0.0334958658,
0.0505348928,
0.0528341196,
-0.0293119643,
-0.0150567275,
0.0157908648,
-0.0355232023,
-0.0049072327,
0.0285957865,
0.0421168581,
0.011640491,
-0.0710249916,
0.0401638076,
-0.0199417267,
0.0012423754,
-0.0534670763,
-0.0304606445,
-0.0122077335,
0.0804210678,
-0.0059879599,
-0.0386222117,
0.0060480898,
-0.0142002515,
0.0667826682,
-0.0262981877,
-0.0203667879,
0.0232133791,
-0.0087186256,
0.0368776321,
-0.0274777468,
0.0055755866,
-0.0262321159,
0.0001476637,
-0.0236436278,
0.0539679565,
-0.0096156355,
-0.0234494861,
0.0263648126,
0.0247015078,
-0.0394157805,
-0.0010454558,
0.0511934347,
-0.0654617473,
-0.0117409155,
-0.0357455201,
-0.0232122,
-0.0107709216,
-0.00180958,
-0.0168491006,
-0.0136444289,
0.0459308177,
-0.0006072978,
0.0051329932,
-0.0490843654,
-0.082491219,
-0.023676157,
0.0066772839,
-0.0649930313,
-0.02251417,
-0.0401568413,
-0.0030296193,
0.0308852103,
-0.056629993,
0.0053673568,
2.697617879e-34,
0.0005563773,
-0.0320574567,
0.0168021172,
0.0402932093,
0.0100779366,
-0.0349370725,
-0.0125355106,
0.0335620157,
-0.0153940897,
-0.0631473437,
-0.0206682254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11353v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11353v1 | $\texttt{MoE-RBench}$: Towards Building Reliable Language Models with Sparse Mixture-of-Experts | 2024-06-17T09:17:05 | 2024-06-17T09:17:05 | Guanjie Chen, Xinyu Zhao, Tianlong Chen, Yu Cheng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) has gained increasing popularity as a promising
framework for scaling up large language models (LLMs). However, the reliability
assessment of MoE lags behind its surging applications. Moreover, when
transferred to new domains such as in fine-tuning MoE models sometimes
underperform their dense counterparts. Motivated by the research gap and
counter-intuitive phenomenon, we propose $\texttt{MoE-RBench}$, the first
comprehensive assessment of SMoE reliability from three aspects: $\textit{(i)}$
safety and hallucination, $\textit{(ii)}$ resilience to adversarial attacks,
and $\textit{(iii)}$ out-of-distribution robustness. Extensive models and
datasets are tested to compare the MoE to dense networks from these reliability
dimensions. Our empirical observations suggest that with appropriate
hyperparameters, training recipes, and inference techniques, we can build the
MoE model more reliably than the dense LLM. In particular, we find that the
robustness of SMoE is sensitive to the basic training settings. We hope that
this study can provide deeper insights into how to adapt the pre-trained MoE
model to other tasks with higher-generation security, quality, and stability.
Codes are available at https://github.com/UNITES-Lab/MoE-RBench | [
0.0146190943,
0.0749390796,
0.0467657447,
0.0306747742,
-0.008140712,
-0.0215178076,
0.0244917907,
-0.0029983509,
-0.0304349381,
-0.0216337759,
-0.0477790125,
-0.0524178222,
0.0187739544,
0.0117213791,
0.0600406565,
-0.0170931853,
0.003978427,
-0.0458950438,
-0.0542357713,
-0.0168685112,
0.0176877379,
0.0031537025,
0.0022523811,
0.0560840368,
-0.0062665301,
0.0038448332,
0.0154771963,
0.0055515105,
0.035422083,
0.015261041,
-0.0095000397,
0.0869297609,
0.0302398689,
0.0793195739,
0.000001943,
-0.0138932439,
-0.0299844164,
0.0261842925,
-0.021902021,
0.0188140944,
0.0086328248,
-0.0261917189,
-0.0359049141,
0.0229753498,
0.0160692204,
-0.0004748893,
0.0468214378,
0.0480325595,
0.0421051979,
0.1245509163,
-0.001598308,
0.0001946183,
0.0821876451,
-0.0509870201,
-0.0248182993,
-0.0510135107,
0.0150021752,
-0.004498018,
-0.0385721475,
0.0218788069,
-0.0050577577,
0.0261624977,
0.033534795,
0.0062751779,
-0.0326601528,
0.0268195365,
-0.0210061185,
-0.0088011688,
-0.0152472928,
0.0478748865,
-0.0744158551,
0.0128964176,
-0.0267078467,
-0.0065427115,
-0.0074380487,
0.0284241904,
-0.0255423766,
0.0013599793,
0.030571945,
0.0163993482,
-0.0352860056,
0.0110000391,
0.073413752,
0.0245370585,
-0.0532468483,
0.0403605551,
0.0257704835,
0.0227893237,
-0.0087806368,
-0.0275935996,
-0.0494316593,
-0.0210369546,
-0.0225198194,
-0.0061828732,
-0.0073333536,
-0.0044436501,
-0.0800973102,
-0.0245933775,
0.0138137378,
-0.0135805113,
0.0433970131,
0.0043349699,
-0.0338532329,
0.0363701768,
-0.0018804579,
0.0254201479,
-0.0095622428,
0.0348887965,
0.0085784746,
-0.0021829174,
-0.0491508059,
0.0044103223,
0.022528911,
0.0113957124,
0.0180126689,
-0.0230362155,
-0.0446940362,
-0.0224606041,
-0.0297015533,
0.0382311083,
-0.0149078975,
-0.0127982367,
-0.0298983417,
-0.0546920523,
0.0214391667,
0.01473221,
-0.0080001215,
0.0098446393,
0.0270794779,
-0.0720949769,
-0.0240677372,
0.0532190949,
-0.0406834893,
-0.036370717,
-0.0179021489,
0.0681606457,
0.0115270289,
-0.0560010597,
-0.016715616,
-0.0160470773,
-0.0541544706,
-0.0582295023,
-0.0078510027,
-0.0845521688,
-0.00146054,
-0.0241705179,
0.0421456844,
-0.0902524218,
0.0152783068,
-0.0150645198,
-0.0427883677,
0.0269244965,
-0.0394425243,
-0.0052652978,
-0.0205166582,
0.0272259656,
-0.0096345199,
0.0679141954,
0.0252711419,
0.0135413287,
0.0487877913,
0.0136430413,
0.0427943803,
0.0280905236,
0.0043779542,
0.0367190354,
-0.0256863888,
0.0040546157,
-0.0008083804,
-0.0261570513,
0.0012040888,
0.0827729702,
-0.0470447354,
-0.057056535,
0.0855974182,
-0.0142699843,
0.0108636245,
0.0366434306,
0.0198012814,
-0.0120640704,
0.0203259513,
0.0108296685,
-0.0425319411,
-0.0039739446,
-0.0691724867,
-0.0075291432,
0.0749632046,
0.048891671,
-0.0522739552,
-0.031185111,
-0.0283865724,
-0.000621532,
-0.0358578116,
0.0064730281,
0.0704299882,
-0.0148613509,
-0.021040149,
0.0160181765,
0.0112513779,
-0.0268745236,
0.0085097151,
-0.0673594251,
-0.0108349351,
0.0272428803,
0.0532285348,
-0.0127987284,
0.025525922,
-0.051021371,
-0.0160483532,
-0.0077980231,
0.0126541993,
0.019105792,
0.0684097186,
-0.0565667264,
-0.0183742139,
-0.01811314,
0.0501382835,
0.0293275509,
0.0346765928,
0.0137570463,
0.0379621983,
-0.0242224447,
-0.0348543674,
0.0284082666,
0.0009745695,
0.0154055282,
0.0182689186,
0.0087325824,
0.0186069608,
0.0181033704,
-0.0667371675,
0.033549659,
0.011309078,
-0.0046248906,
-0.0094386013,
-0.0426487848,
-0.0443958938,
-0.0174563564,
0.0245016813,
-0.0034678075,
0.0069347182,
0.0135430768,
-0.0412199683,
-0.027965581,
0.007589072,
-0.0399480425,
-0.0259852428,
-0.051527258,
0.0013147563,
-0.0244500283,
0.0465220176,
-0.0129369684,
0.0584899858,
-0.048962336,
-0.001292554,
-0.0132303741,
0.0086923679,
0.0364878066,
-0.0483262576,
-0.0765258074,
-0.0199101605,
-0.0180633217,
0.0516364798,
0.0082065286,
-0.0165113788,
-0.0188594982,
-0.0454426333,
-0.044084087,
-0.0103243263,
-0.0825683326,
0.004439292,
0.025654532,
-0.0046912455,
-0.0117126955,
0.0013091022,
0.0163598359,
0.0218812097,
-0.0233251117,
0.0020681459,
-0.0044551375,
-0.0077505726,
-0.0100918971,
-0.0242526121,
-0.0492201969,
0.023994904,
0.0821737051,
-0.0556514375,
-0.0068775471,
-0.0423984081,
0.0461975485,
-0.0225690957,
0.00778407,
-0.0180268288,
-0.0300870221,
0.0298919398,
-0.0039732121,
0.0603347719,
0.052369941,
0.0310898814,
0.0119224237,
0.0686097592,
0.0002998907,
0.0185624845,
-0.0294127185,
-0.0086118011,
-0.0247289259,
-0.0328804404,
-0.0115045859,
-0.0025543079,
0.033881411,
0.014641487,
-0.0433812588,
-0.0335617214,
-0.014684516,
0.0180114023,
-0.0150450291,
-0.0070207561,
0.0032479037,
0.0171828363,
0.0262005571,
-0.0149579505,
-0.0419524424,
0.075327225,
-0.0315947942,
0.0371426232,
-0.0001988838,
-0.071095787,
-0.0001365773,
0.0005673951,
-0.0141041875,
0.0264747161,
0.0019975903,
-0.0026398089,
-0.0666758865,
-0.0561586246,
0.0001864475,
-0.0121295471,
0.0183828138,
-0.0157884806,
0.0150356404,
0.0123605113,
-0.0132721635,
-0.0160766318,
-0.0389744714,
-0.0294924043,
0.0354168639,
-0.0098595321,
-0.036215961,
-0.0472741537,
0.0267144665,
0.0167724881,
0.0361829214,
-0.0280127246,
0.0062418994,
0.0145708201,
0.0488279127,
0.037845429,
0.0097316466,
0.0404157713,
-0.0563107543,
0.0214299485,
0.0536927916,
0.0444678999,
0.0059191831,
-0.0609900802,
-0.0200294275,
0.0112307649,
0.0307484325,
-0.0184752587,
0.0391105376,
0.0686926991,
-0.0276904199,
-0.0067855814,
0.0604293942,
-0.0218615308,
-0.0082506919,
-0.0024799616,
0.0120048895,
0.0867621824,
0.0067052385,
-0.0177393649,
-0.036718782,
-0.0076441835,
0.0208840519,
0.0227014776,
0.019679226,
-0.018770026,
0.018729914,
-0.0703182966,
0.0158764478,
0.0278517175,
-0.0419624858,
-0.0728368834,
-0.0430978537,
-0.0030731487,
-0.0343770124,
0.0558709837,
0.0012156767,
0.0353098772,
-0.0415027812,
0.021283187,
-0.0019032899,
-0.0875130817,
0.0236229785,
-0.0553614199,
0.0526294522,
0.0564406551,
-0.0203748923,
-0.0117104631,
-0.0007862184,
0.0272238459,
-0.0052063242,
-0.0092592239,
0.0519099422,
0.0501322523,
-0.0319610238,
-0.0074691684,
0.0347260498,
0.0385928601,
0.0075008925,
-0.0174313691,
-0.0003201898,
0.0328607671,
-0.0163859092,
-0.0344448574,
-0.023233017,
-0.0233662948,
0.0075034359,
0.0506601185,
0.0166510716,
-0.0140144853,
-0.0113664931,
-0.0383496806,
0.0197564233,
-0.0065111117,
-0.0145831918,
0.0596077517,
0.0370503739,
-0.0587086864,
-0.0282057915,
0.0141872996,
0.0025061122,
0.0599921718,
-0.0163072124,
-0.00937571,
-0.0229725298,
0.0165057257,
0.0037796139,
0.0271230582,
-0.036383234,
0.0263612047,
-0.0585205629,
0.0384922847,
0.0144435083,
-0.0026606538,
-0.0055142879,
-0.016918119,
-0.096196413,
-0.0863057524,
-0.0116761522,
0.0655823499,
0.0210176539,
-0.0043436708,
-0.0420555919,
-0.1118911356,
0.1262658834,
0.0408892483,
-0.0460854433,
-0.0134581383,
0.0644615665,
-0.0697947368,
0.0017049512,
0.044317726,
-0.0424003601,
-0.0065897149,
0.0443174802,
0.0235136859,
-0.0077569443,
-0.0167189203,
-0.0311701801,
-0.0279314891,
0.0197335314,
-0.0369353555,
0.0404529795,
-0.0289338641,
0.0059806216,
-0.0077102492,
-0.0027696732,
-0.0128247896,
0.0496985726,
0.0676205233,
-0.0067651388,
0.0193545073,
-0.004119419,
0.0094072716,
0.0472127311,
-0.0039480804,
-0.009470487,
0.0247301385,
-0.0155309392,
0.0393313542,
0.0042608841,
-0.0259365011,
0.0210518707,
-0.0092115756,
-0.0007932641,
0.0065391944,
0.0373946577,
-0.0122446204,
-0.0245711394,
-0.0109873842,
0.0358310491,
-0.0888565928,
-0.0495479293,
-0.0416838825,
0.0512502976,
0.0669243485,
0.0055839987,
0.0180969108,
-0.0176151302,
0.0017153085,
-0.0682099164,
0.0100696357,
0.0055601723,
0.0001671729,
0.0133427912,
0.0185798034,
0.0023448868,
0.0812186897,
0.1015881076,
0.0411114022,
0.0061011189,
0.0099455481,
-0.0120700449,
-0.0394194461,
-0.0164791346,
0.0072724139,
0.0527874902,
-0.0714924932,
-0.015840508,
-0.0144622838,
-0.0766990706,
-0.0042581595,
-0.0038005784,
0.020391332,
0.0565056019,
-0.0071228454,
0.0382544249,
-0.0273932107,
0.0800799057,
-0.0310188327,
-0.0105724791,
0.0630946457,
0.013553909,
0.0124803819,
-6.474723536e-33,
0.0348247029,
-0.003067581,
-0.0400758609,
-0.0729623213,
0.0208403282,
-0.0088266544,
-0.0226587225,
0.0296261199,
-0.0423347913,
-0.0094633671,
-0.0187242851,
0.0119823562,
-0.0029096396,
0.0516064651,
-0.041583512,
-0.0003480918,
0.0364869684,
-0.0125980591,
-0.0324081853,
0.0078033279,
0.0430500209,
0.0050252909,
0.0392737053,
-0.0769311935,
0.02807514,
0.0247830302,
-0.0478160679,
-0.0048467494,
-0.0105451448,
0.055696331,
0.0035185914,
0.0562336892,
-0.0033613294,
-0.0041293758,
-0.0233678725,
-0.0359376073,
-0.0280711669,
-0.0089888321,
-0.043579217,
-0.0421761572,
-0.0139758149,
-0.0148526728,
0.0536846668,
-0.0136891948,
0.018694805,
-0.0350063704,
0.000505641,
-0.0081794197,
-0.0428431667,
-0.0210210346,
0.001382702,
0.0507372357,
0.0040268819,
-0.0150061175,
0.0083439872,
-0.0206006728,
0.0239387415,
-0.0071499529,
-0.0253362581,
0.0171396714,
-0.0174635649,
0.0449395366,
0.0483137593,
0.0209896378,
-0.0214522537,
0.0589462779,
-0.0051328833,
0.0304529145,
0.002887974,
-0.0199006703,
0.0482206643,
0.0555256568,
0.0745703056,
0.0423524603,
0.0296671037,
-0.0133800767,
-0.1084811985,
0.0142484037,
-0.0116076488,
0.0396538824,
0.0785968527,
0.0412937552,
-0.0413933918,
-0.0099564483,
-0.0278824996,
-0.0437955447,
-0.036437992,
-0.0392678529,
-0.0147404615,
0.0411120132,
-0.0384602398,
-0.0207870211,
0.03472488,
-0.050162416,
-0.0004011602,
0.0290779825,
-0.037614014,
-0.0000521765,
-0.0086409952,
0.0613902062,
-0.0425889343,
-0.0370559655,
0.0295012724,
-0.0135059906,
-0.0227695927,
-0.0262636635,
0.0667069703,
0.0347812362,
-0.0447263867,
-0.0172993075,
-0.0040060948,
0.0110848481,
0.0321645923,
0.0666847453,
0.0226012543,
-0.0109888436,
-0.0026406152,
0.0149645088,
0.0094185397,
0.0052919327,
0.0195661355,
0.0099568581,
0.0074047809,
0.0111897262,
-0.0022857613,
0.0054334351,
-0.0493816398,
-0.0291406605,
0.049657125,
-0.0143358391,
-0.0188697092,
-0.0170573946,
2.638e-7,
0.0134834833,
0.0041725892,
-0.0058098831,
-0.0233659949,
0.0013326739,
0.02786351,
-0.0378104374,
0.0263904165,
-0.0317716487,
-0.0458761342,
0.0091165509,
0.0239866246,
0.0714912936,
0.0396034494,
-0.0455479324,
-0.0171281509,
-0.0643848702,
0.0187726486,
-0.0411322229,
-0.0144234151,
0.0368091017,
0.1535469443,
0.0234522726,
-0.0033694967,
0.001095981,
-0.0604519099,
0.0460507572,
-0.0039959275,
-0.009319935,
0.0104445405,
0.0812737122,
0.0701643676,
0.0126875807,
0.0138087515,
0.0031078439,
0.042744834,
0.0416878834,
0.0662252977,
0.0002375128,
-0.0461830869,
0.0075919102,
-0.0106019741,
0.0024960614,
-0.0430937931,
0.0592562519,
-0.0275231209,
-0.0224130768,
-0.0228445996,
-0.0131284911,
-0.0243535955,
0.0699495077,
-0.0733595416,
-0.0223442446,
0.0097225774,
0.0080560381,
0.0070235152,
0.0031388362,
-0.0543658361,
-0.0157646779,
-0.0150769437,
-0.0483773611,
-0.0707120374,
-0.0091448259,
-0.0110952556,
0.043336872,
-0.0204518065,
0.0112872636,
2.432818032e-34,
0.0598350167,
-0.0257320348,
-0.0275651962,
0.0088848472,
0.0433738716,
-0.037576694,
-0.0321966335,
-0.0266430695,
-0.0175634008,
-0.0622970425,
-0.0461104587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15484v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15484v1 | JobFair: A Framework for Benchmarking Gender Hiring Bias in Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T09:15:57 | 2024-06-17T09:15:57 | Ze Wang, Zekun Wu, Xin Guan, Michael Thaler, Adriano Koshiyama, Skylar Lu, Sachin Beepath, Ediz Ertekin Jr., Maria Perez-Ortiz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | This paper presents a novel framework for benchmarking hierarchical gender
hiring bias in Large Language Models (LLMs) for resume scoring, revealing
significant issues of reverse bias and overdebiasing. Our contributions are
fourfold: First, we introduce a framework using a real, anonymized resume
dataset from the Healthcare, Finance, and Construction industries, meticulously
used to avoid confounding factors. It evaluates gender hiring biases across
hierarchical levels, including Level bias, Spread bias, Taste-based bias, and
Statistical bias. This framework can be generalized to other social traits and
tasks easily. Second, we propose novel statistical and computational hiring
bias metrics based on a counterfactual approach, including Rank After Scoring
(RAS), Rank-based Impact Ratio, Permutation Test-Based Metrics, and Fixed
Effects Model-based Metrics. These metrics, rooted in labor economics, NLP, and
law, enable holistic evaluation of hiring biases. Third, we analyze hiring
biases in ten state-of-the-art LLMs. Six out of ten LLMs show significant
biases against males in healthcare and finance. An industry-effect regression
reveals that the healthcare industry is the most biased against males. GPT-4o
and GPT-3.5 are the most biased models, showing significant bias in all three
industries. Conversely, Gemini-1.5-Pro, Llama3-8b-Instruct, and
Llama3-70b-Instruct are the least biased. The hiring bias of all LLMs, except
for Llama3-8b-Instruct and Claude-3-Sonnet, remains consistent regardless of
random expansion or reduction of resume content. Finally, we offer a
user-friendly demo to facilitate adoption and practical application of the
framework. | [
0.0420847349,
0.0937203243,
-0.0272387508,
-0.0288685802,
-0.0080438983,
0.0138832834,
0.0273873545,
0.0033654717,
0.0307225026,
-0.0520785153,
0.0023254317,
-0.0173353385,
0.0376901738,
0.0085524423,
0.044545684,
0.0122755393,
0.0009174642,
0.0450789072,
0.0214002691,
-0.0403544158,
-0.0034154665,
0.0382690877,
0.0045164246,
0.0804374516,
0.0282971263,
-0.0354577117,
0.0925377384,
0.0191770438,
0.0096578598,
0.0053239767,
0.0559818968,
0.0489945449,
-0.0281588119,
0.0116434731,
0.0000022358,
-0.0551810749,
-0.0029780837,
0.0204705447,
-0.0188555885,
-0.0279132929,
0.0447216667,
0.0178005137,
-0.0188100711,
0.0356312133,
-0.0132354293,
0.0208766833,
0.0083668875,
-0.0303333886,
0.0324004441,
0.0084592765,
0.0047422429,
0.0006095649,
-0.0534466915,
-0.0602938943,
0.0060202996,
-0.0102356281,
0.0415263958,
-0.0592506826,
-0.0265703816,
-0.0198620521,
-0.0243427064,
-0.0233346932,
-0.0499623157,
-0.0453904867,
0.0352302827,
0.0287655387,
-0.0225043055,
-0.006684104,
0.0185910892,
0.018982742,
0.0078295358,
-0.003554953,
0.0000425157,
-0.0444974229,
0.0647758767,
0.0139021333,
-0.0356392972,
0.0303150918,
-0.0287993737,
-0.0435351282,
-0.0306340232,
0.0134154297,
0.0145493215,
0.0195961148,
0.0356285498,
0.0929161757,
0.0015467613,
-0.0438489653,
0.0398829468,
-0.0056766793,
0.0791771859,
-0.0431029946,
0.0421372391,
-0.0173344649,
-0.0309426244,
-0.0072818049,
0.0362997055,
0.0136376638,
0.0539602041,
-0.0551549941,
-0.0273543894,
0.0278411042,
0.0148923574,
0.034621764,
-0.0064195544,
0.0347756259,
-0.0002575743,
-0.0470109992,
-0.0066508548,
-0.0231791865,
-0.0578522384,
-0.0185786989,
0.0023038327,
-0.0250768047,
0.0006675426,
0.0892767087,
-0.0878431946,
-0.0284626987,
-0.0786861107,
0.0159989074,
0.0589883067,
0.0198929813,
-0.0052558356,
0.0341881327,
-0.0293419585,
-0.0164767951,
-0.007075598,
0.0024908804,
-0.0345590562,
-0.033188954,
0.0254337676,
-0.0090583796,
0.0287541468,
-0.0332882442,
0.0199060757,
0.03879622,
0.052631598,
0.0023411354,
0.0324076451,
-0.0275517106,
-0.014380482,
-0.0315958373,
-0.023882417,
-0.0441484228,
0.025021838,
0.0261048209,
0.0174412411,
-0.05215111,
0.0062206052,
0.0209977087,
-0.036066141,
-0.0030621677,
0.0473137759,
0.0096321693,
0.060329169,
0.006800184,
-0.0514379181,
0.0491442569,
0.0330557674,
0.0546262227,
0.0461063385,
-0.0389700346,
0.0265261568,
0.0675352141,
0.0019329088,
0.0078765638,
-0.0177955627,
0.0495926663,
0.0094379913,
0.0147801023,
0.0661361143,
-0.0372659899,
-0.0124969156,
0.0347193331,
0.0242934562,
0.0763918534,
0.0268233977,
0.0199970659,
0.0284241065,
0.022052817,
-0.0253569633,
-0.0285980925,
-0.0440241322,
0.0032723539,
-0.0100897001,
-0.0403525457,
-0.0275630523,
0.0349779241,
-0.0074589276,
-0.0126456134,
-0.0066076885,
0.0444491431,
-0.0288772751,
0.0172759499,
0.0019394857,
0.014325507,
-0.0423428789,
0.034152437,
0.0232987292,
-0.0526920035,
0.004691774,
-0.020456126,
-0.0370321795,
0.0962275118,
0.0292139705,
-0.0308877993,
0.0245466977,
-0.045482412,
-0.029180089,
0.0183297098,
0.0527417287,
-0.0040291143,
0.0000679691,
-0.0268369727,
-0.0172284786,
0.0540592298,
0.0252969172,
0.0325669348,
0.0406936444,
0.0260644928,
0.0101095196,
-0.0457213968,
-0.0606232174,
0.0151292207,
0.0018770728,
-0.0474162996,
0.0313824601,
-0.0071749859,
-0.0055479743,
0.0143344747,
-0.024545908,
0.0094645647,
-0.0369529016,
0.0005112016,
0.0090030814,
0.0000808786,
0.0163204502,
0.0302941054,
-0.0235424433,
-0.0127587235,
-0.0959802121,
0.0168170705,
-0.0169706661,
0.0270291604,
0.0282902513,
0.0235085003,
0.0213418622,
-0.0001801265,
-0.0038218573,
-0.0181180034,
0.0173081364,
-0.0261924416,
0.0440046117,
0.0001712643,
0.0152426613,
-0.0058475761,
-0.0600950494,
-0.0212322474,
-0.1273588538,
-0.0020113892,
-0.0032374794,
-0.0047389572,
-0.0019121112,
0.0143076703,
-0.01385614,
-0.0234599747,
-0.0534607694,
-0.0684735775,
0.0208764225,
0.0147608127,
0.0022711549,
-0.0114852814,
-0.0115389302,
-0.0139699513,
-0.0141432462,
-0.016761288,
-0.0318446569,
0.0256850123,
0.0182343069,
0.0148996329,
-0.0498107523,
-0.0246727485,
-0.0701143965,
-0.0623785742,
-0.0605025254,
0.0343496315,
0.0506104827,
0.032949701,
-0.0395265743,
-0.0112960618,
-0.027122369,
-0.0330341123,
-0.0113620544,
-0.0045632664,
-0.0151278079,
0.0316416807,
0.0031256317,
0.0866207108,
-0.0010780891,
0.009172515,
0.0233024023,
-0.0133487061,
-0.0095352642,
-0.0235693026,
0.0303567536,
0.0445968397,
0.0088956719,
-0.0951789692,
-0.0104770791,
-0.008174126,
0.0157938059,
-0.0365795568,
-0.0109794727,
0.0703033134,
-0.0487961024,
-0.0213830713,
-0.0658204556,
0.0037329781,
-0.0177792963,
0.026972115,
-0.0119210007,
-0.0428198241,
-0.019627139,
-0.0119275218,
0.0393239893,
0.0085575348,
-0.0312578008,
-0.0567470863,
0.0479158238,
-0.0118980017,
0.0072112982,
-0.0124395546,
-0.0024613501,
-0.0482018553,
-0.015935,
0.0304840058,
-0.0463734232,
-0.0378275253,
0.0083315186,
-0.0046697259,
0.0172474477,
-0.0347211435,
-0.0133476257,
-0.0536133945,
-0.0067091309,
0.0230574254,
0.049145706,
-0.0075342376,
-0.0469682179,
-0.0082211783,
-0.005440997,
0.0270605944,
-0.014465862,
-0.0178597625,
-0.0134947263,
0.0003768455,
0.0105026122,
0.0075704469,
0.0091000414,
-0.0288225934,
-0.0211599525,
-0.0084345099,
0.0091495495,
0.0248672348,
0.0219252631,
0.0181281492,
0.0308973659,
-0.0788537264,
-0.0053994348,
-0.0132566188,
-0.0329991169,
-0.0559453256,
0.0544384643,
0.0713306144,
0.0030596703,
-0.0426674262,
0.0182894003,
0.0077839158,
-0.0085419435,
0.056759458,
0.0407521538,
-0.0356095284,
0.036973469,
0.0229165666,
0.0387470722,
-0.0220499951,
-0.0460311621,
-0.0153313791,
-0.1086378694,
0.0667498186,
-0.02579429,
-0.0069629829,
-0.0016826459,
-0.0407482423,
0.0025020137,
-0.0402979553,
-0.0407939218,
0.0081889415,
-0.0216105599,
0.0126668122,
-0.0062606437,
-0.0336853713,
-0.0313376561,
0.0897639692,
-0.0630764738,
0.0097796014,
0.0233139023,
0.07790941,
-0.0355039202,
0.0147713181,
0.0064898124,
0.0153841507,
-0.0134515185,
0.0230112113,
0.0303632915,
-0.0417968705,
-0.0072693704,
-0.0573580936,
-0.0145142432,
0.0088520339,
0.0357623212,
0.0347096436,
0.012129494,
0.0402808152,
-0.0196210146,
-0.0282341167,
-0.0152977658,
-0.021905018,
0.0729936361,
-0.0221797228,
-0.0786774233,
0.0233577266,
-0.0555622354,
0.0201138239,
0.0257433765,
-0.0569586568,
0.0004113963,
0.0092776334,
0.0162649956,
-0.0072763418,
-0.0468560308,
0.0023722188,
0.0067352462,
0.0169746242,
-0.0124937287,
-0.020327406,
-0.0106118424,
-0.0426573902,
0.0018692359,
-0.0177765712,
0.0631442443,
0.0182951614,
-0.0055354261,
-0.0271433368,
-0.0404295251,
-0.0627231374,
-0.0285944249,
-0.0302299801,
0.0029228979,
0.0011806339,
0.0040890039,
0.0206987243,
0.0079846233,
-0.0003295582,
-0.0679017901,
0.0403361432,
0.0462093204,
-0.0294229221,
0.0477660447,
-0.0154127302,
-0.0000256183,
-0.0089376383,
-0.0087102326,
-0.0659827441,
0.0229379069,
0.0363064446,
-0.0054975357,
0.0582752079,
-0.032150507,
-0.0048332117,
0.001409038,
-0.0242132265,
-0.0182357747,
-0.0085948333,
-0.043966461,
0.0205838904,
-0.0246110931,
-0.0411644615,
0.0112937596,
-0.0317107663,
0.0676713884,
0.0272392724,
-0.0151582686,
0.0086675184,
-0.0140809184,
0.0391658954,
-0.0532587916,
0.0636592209,
-0.0244236775,
0.0371373184,
0.0028392188,
-0.0385111608,
-0.0030732353,
-0.0272731669,
-0.0071758279,
0.0334535651,
0.0241410825,
0.0060390406,
-0.0259812213,
0.0293862727,
-0.0093727838,
0.0353108943,
-0.040054813,
-0.0329508893,
0.0062924922,
0.0124669271,
0.0121980244,
-0.0584803969,
0.0532222651,
0.0138757536,
0.0101417722,
0.0075815292,
-0.0327731408,
0.0226595737,
0.0127560543,
0.0179325379,
0.0081665479,
0.0133610107,
0.003532124,
0.0317895263,
0.0853745639,
0.0364981666,
-0.058052253,
-0.018929597,
-0.0037673302,
-0.0149847288,
0.0574494489,
0.0190422125,
-0.011947481,
-0.0103764152,
-0.1197447404,
-0.0558743812,
-0.0011747599,
-0.0006779899,
0.0194680467,
-0.0109882141,
-0.0294613913,
0.0609782748,
-0.0104535865,
-0.0460416898,
-0.0281788092,
-0.0080531193,
-0.0162007678,
-0.0125260698,
-0.049797181,
-6.271159506e-33,
-0.0151457191,
-0.0657708868,
-0.0080149248,
-0.0067118499,
0.0142190605,
0.0152993118,
0.0279981662,
-0.0450431705,
0.02261246,
-0.0160201155,
-0.0518490784,
0.0301272403,
-0.0040388959,
-0.0104430886,
0.0432801694,
0.0479890406,
0.0613386296,
0.0089829229,
-0.0203320533,
-0.0154644698,
-0.066726312,
0.023582736,
0.0343630984,
-0.0338929817,
0.102058202,
-0.0231562499,
-0.0137663558,
0.0014997622,
-0.006865256,
0.038169574,
0.0058887242,
0.0370245725,
0.0155839603,
-0.0420156606,
0.0244142897,
0.0156825278,
-0.0254336651,
-0.0046710512,
0.0272346176,
0.0314246379,
0.0736992955,
-0.0239180513,
0.0169848762,
0.0306830313,
-0.0689298436,
-0.0387094505,
0.0871625766,
0.0216963924,
0.0720018968,
0.0397634879,
-0.0098826084,
0.030139273,
-0.0682398528,
0.0345924087,
0.0011843069,
0.0213847812,
0.0158774555,
0.0825746432,
-0.1118439808,
-0.0027057056,
-0.0602004826,
0.0252193399,
0.0212040171,
-0.0054861498,
0.0134812556,
0.0294985939,
0.0838635936,
0.0772683844,
0.0350504741,
-0.0799443796,
0.0023725347,
0.0017963657,
-0.0114230448,
0.0606822781,
0.081283465,
-0.0235410146,
-0.0436479263,
-0.0301075745,
0.0206067618,
-0.0031300806,
0.0088545373,
-0.0073927776,
-0.061757341,
-0.0394292772,
-0.025735084,
-0.0780132189,
-0.0090993019,
0.0096404236,
0.040306218,
-0.0034169052,
0.0276476499,
0.0009814647,
-0.0410571322,
-0.0408821478,
-0.0525349267,
0.0089355251,
-0.0324926376,
-0.0258837491,
0.0303847883,
-0.0030185333,
-0.0784906819,
0.0535572134,
-0.0207983442,
0.0304433852,
0.0570468232,
0.0494304039,
-0.0269631185,
0.003931087,
-0.084030889,
-0.0175587665,
0.0042218389,
-0.0120959254,
-0.0241460819,
0.025611544,
0.0433900952,
0.0214393009,
0.036841657,
-0.0175631326,
0.0683076456,
0.0422957018,
-0.0141183883,
-0.0592963062,
0.0027745226,
0.0108951619,
0.0152143063,
-0.0087757306,
0.023401333,
-0.0023949661,
0.0328097083,
-0.0341838971,
-0.0046787788,
-0.0454815142,
2.796e-7,
0.0190191679,
0.0660367906,
-0.0430376157,
0.0299839452,
0.034672413,
0.0045908941,
-0.0064031961,
0.0444757193,
0.0890509859,
0.0208549574,
-0.043728698,
-0.0027382895,
0.0024804822,
0.0004485759,
-0.0802303702,
0.0043844976,
-0.08023002,
-0.0257742088,
-0.0113698449,
-0.0059299045,
0.0342323743,
0.0274746716,
0.0632826909,
-0.0061360407,
-0.0413609408,
-0.0011788907,
0.0434913002,
-0.010364335,
0.008257024,
0.0415194929,
0.0223263223,
-0.029127555,
-0.0172732249,
0.06449496,
-0.0114657348,
0.0493104383,
0.0497384705,
0.0264817923,
-0.0443506874,
0.0746359229,
0.0091825472,
-0.0202688556,
-0.0211852491,
-0.0657815859,
0.0242858659,
0.0403924771,
-0.0272256844,
-0.04951014,
-0.0663067251,
0.0106152128,
0.0703722388,
0.0077856001,
-0.0303851496,
-0.0184304751,
0.0221665874,
-0.0031340879,
-0.0416362844,
-0.0132319778,
-0.0001177024,
-0.018082574,
-0.0159086399,
-0.0987870768,
0.0113101387,
0.0322638564,
0.0235983022,
-0.040963918,
0.0155735575,
2.6377331e-34,
0.0346121565,
0.0365847647,
0.0213773046,
-0.0320356824,
0.0588012822,
0.0172272604,
0.0015551399,
0.0031420235,
0.0137442732,
-0.0030997954,
0.0104566133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11345v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11345v1 | Full-ECE: A Metric For Token-level Calibration on Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T09:07:58 | 2024-06-17T09:07:58 | Han Liu, Yupeng Zhang, Bingning Wang, Weipeng Chen, Xiaolin Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) excel in various domains but face challenges in
providing accurate uncertainty estimates, which are crucial for high-stakes
applications. Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently emerged as powerful
tools, demonstrating exceptional performance in language tasks. However,
traditional calibration metrics such as Expected Calibration Error (ECE) and
classwise-ECE (cw-ECE) are inadequate for LLMs due to their vast vocabularies,
data complexity, and distributional focus. To address this, we propose a novel
calibration concept called full calibration and introduce its corresponding
metric, Full-ECE. Full-ECE evaluates the entire predicted probability
distribution, offering a more accurate and robust measure of calibration for
LLMs. | [
-0.0199482851,
0.0870620236,
0.0088344021,
0.0202991217,
-0.0240488034,
0.0056738299,
-0.0094115464,
-0.0153792715,
-0.045878876,
-0.0084997993,
-0.0461654812,
-0.0897166207,
0.0420264564,
0.0306903832,
0.0085392408,
-0.0030998129,
0.0035238487,
-0.0030022925,
0.0035607021,
-0.007943511,
-0.0097136004,
-0.0161011629,
-0.0243671872,
0.0605463907,
-0.0479860492,
-0.0106407721,
0.0259970352,
0.0332874507,
0.0267258938,
-0.0015838328,
0.0433985554,
0.0551765077,
0.0012632878,
0.0839443654,
0.0000017417,
-0.0430857986,
-0.0043952884,
0.0101312539,
-0.0399702825,
0.0273384452,
0.032493595,
-0.0180815663,
-0.0291155558,
0.0079377005,
0.0225847661,
0.008707324,
0.087760143,
0.0023751545,
-0.0286930986,
0.0578232817,
0.0214793906,
-0.0256235227,
0.0575386398,
-0.0193677787,
-0.0244268924,
-0.0576428808,
0.019055862,
-0.0018318335,
-0.0808909312,
-0.0184377171,
-0.0256107394,
0.0244550146,
0.0522031002,
-0.0086503066,
-0.0173656289,
0.0181160029,
-0.0513302386,
-0.0172165781,
-0.0278988201,
0.0253519062,
-0.0075197066,
-0.025532132,
-0.0456257835,
-0.04520173,
-0.0124532823,
-0.027249312,
-0.01164388,
0.0122761736,
0.0542215258,
0.0349003933,
-0.0055871489,
0.0029913613,
0.0869858488,
0.0003205161,
-0.0075000571,
0.0952374265,
0.03150874,
-0.0171922278,
-0.0194507521,
0.0239019729,
-0.0334780142,
-0.0436744355,
0.0308645442,
0.0264874734,
-0.0335185826,
0.0056376699,
-0.0343106687,
-0.0624664687,
0.0145843765,
-0.0187135432,
0.0328676514,
0.0427056625,
-0.0351685248,
0.0341850892,
-0.0167040545,
0.0740458667,
-0.0024993713,
0.0181127507,
-0.0110313874,
-0.038531661,
0.0094846915,
0.0067887986,
-0.0059995279,
-0.0415934213,
-0.0162301511,
-0.0236251112,
-0.0811384469,
0.0007387745,
-0.005453717,
0.0117413402,
0.0462366156,
0.0243820641,
-0.0543302894,
-0.0198795646,
-0.0079580611,
0.0364321768,
-0.0224002227,
0.0223418865,
0.0331118926,
-0.0450993069,
-0.0020752465,
0.0256205127,
-0.0120037561,
-0.0184565391,
0.0240089297,
0.0544119924,
0.0350765027,
-0.0245984774,
0.0138523886,
0.0163782705,
-0.0797153935,
-0.0475937799,
0.0151726585,
-0.0657664016,
0.0069192275,
0.0013531892,
0.0121728163,
-0.0392182358,
-0.0058590639,
-0.0318677165,
0.0049057435,
0.0449788496,
0.0158106461,
0.0056863427,
0.0176402368,
-0.0226764474,
0.0042741853,
0.1008865461,
0.0587792918,
0.0149820074,
0.0546862818,
0.0148096904,
0.0024863374,
0.0660822242,
0.0096901115,
-0.0019708807,
-0.0498722717,
-0.0347819068,
0.0137164574,
0.0410580933,
0.0245697368,
0.0414431207,
-0.0148203811,
-0.0001717079,
0.0489031374,
0.0141021507,
0.0134149324,
-0.0112932073,
0.0168126263,
-0.0601457097,
0.0072788461,
-0.0133017246,
-0.0579332225,
0.0181546807,
-0.0065310681,
0.005405446,
0.0504641794,
0.0023844475,
-0.0004534372,
-0.0425893664,
-0.0253586248,
-0.0175921284,
-0.018174991,
0.0008891943,
0.0384868495,
-0.0486887284,
-0.0051442846,
0.0707298815,
0.0111967111,
-0.0253768619,
0.0459941365,
-0.0335963219,
-0.0124878967,
0.0349819995,
0.0015381858,
-0.0200740229,
-0.0240966808,
0.0256756991,
-0.0010818447,
0.031884063,
0.0429982506,
0.0024329028,
0.048130136,
-0.0275606308,
-0.0280838124,
-0.0252606999,
0.0487393588,
0.0127844168,
0.0216418821,
0.0104506202,
0.0309477597,
-0.1004100218,
-0.0376144014,
0.0340984277,
0.0027259516,
-0.0247422066,
0.0112432893,
0.0254676994,
0.0077831708,
0.0210989714,
-0.0229650177,
0.0005344352,
0.0133172628,
-0.0188329984,
-0.002569268,
-0.0492718853,
-0.0197386499,
0.0253032763,
0.0612178221,
-0.01539787,
-0.0130084939,
0.0269373059,
-0.0402935296,
-0.0437204726,
0.0079804817,
-0.0018870448,
0.0281589162,
-0.0459199511,
0.0238882285,
-0.0687708184,
0.0321048126,
-0.0203225594,
0.0017996461,
-0.0154776806,
0.0381767265,
-0.0127502698,
0.0075701536,
0.0172939114,
-0.0119968066,
-0.0594073646,
-0.042946469,
-0.0032625517,
0.0190479513,
0.043281883,
0.0130554596,
-0.0378587507,
-0.0333154723,
-0.0793963373,
0.0208547805,
-0.0713922456,
0.0326453485,
0.0312456284,
0.0130414199,
-0.0215647966,
0.0026202179,
-0.0334359407,
-0.0066795731,
-0.0100128334,
-0.0011806035,
0.029031001,
-0.0167221315,
-0.0365523212,
-0.0475914143,
-0.040268559,
-0.0199839976,
0.0312034432,
-0.0121557284,
0.0289089996,
-0.0724316761,
0.0452151299,
-0.0069293617,
0.0068903631,
0.0152118877,
-0.0603961833,
0.0163304228,
0.0023034601,
-0.0063120164,
0.0673505738,
-0.0111522116,
-0.0235496238,
0.0321964137,
0.0213989355,
-0.0480456054,
-0.0103617879,
-0.0314553715,
-0.0571333952,
-0.0343305878,
-0.0134972036,
-0.0187854972,
0.057525143,
-0.0243549384,
-0.0189289078,
-0.0260530263,
-0.0117041236,
-0.0246058088,
-0.0239701439,
-0.0091776112,
0.0061882334,
-0.0259921383,
0.0208186693,
-0.0110030007,
-0.0636265576,
0.0564968549,
-0.0626852065,
0.0232967064,
0.0043726764,
-0.0053583398,
-0.0182054304,
0.0176011696,
0.0302850083,
0.0113547435,
-0.0342374295,
-0.0366161093,
-0.0614900067,
-0.0097853001,
0.0000588029,
-0.0240258183,
0.0401263684,
-0.025809072,
-0.0159021597,
-0.0258713067,
-0.0166403521,
-0.0333959796,
-0.0015884188,
-0.0419124514,
0.0551244989,
0.0385224037,
-0.0447167456,
-0.0389964506,
-0.0096554337,
-0.0190920718,
0.0194599051,
-0.0178782102,
0.0147573985,
-0.0165001322,
0.0006158648,
0.0457913876,
0.0176339615,
0.0462806523,
-0.0318290628,
-0.0485588312,
0.0177583341,
0.0147312386,
0.0824302211,
-0.0485300794,
-0.0077115498,
0.0535048991,
0.0019168676,
-0.0032331855,
0.0278565865,
0.071652621,
-0.0263597798,
-0.0030287975,
0.1416083574,
0.0014913258,
-0.0619531907,
-0.0044904421,
-0.0165416785,
0.046252232,
0.0096090641,
-0.0012256472,
-0.0591030121,
-0.0251459256,
0.0171053279,
-0.004499278,
-0.0043041864,
-0.0319924578,
0.0242487192,
-0.0829765722,
-0.0245387219,
0.0067102141,
-0.0608109124,
-0.0727640167,
-0.0322865583,
0.0458115712,
-0.0232648496,
0.0811008215,
0.0095195472,
0.0663864464,
-0.0200786591,
0.0514320731,
-0.0459290966,
-0.0754316077,
0.0158486348,
-0.0916533023,
0.0650435612,
0.0680563524,
0.0034891304,
-0.0457145646,
0.0004262024,
0.0136379236,
-0.041666653,
-0.0441552401,
0.0685264617,
0.0339325331,
-0.0231197383,
-0.0185869969,
0.0542598814,
0.0204289686,
-0.051979661,
0.0071387445,
-0.025678549,
0.0294559021,
0.0281660389,
0.0073867538,
-0.0132885035,
-0.0415862575,
0.0260226633,
0.0547395572,
0.0424539708,
-0.053875789,
-0.0019858906,
-0.0436464548,
0.0300260764,
-0.0424304232,
0.0365309492,
0.0295407735,
0.0107799023,
-0.0290033314,
-0.026471898,
0.016520666,
-0.0103648985,
0.0100991717,
0.0235126484,
-0.0387152359,
-0.0027472966,
-0.0104099121,
-0.0326103978,
0.0221246071,
-0.0129443416,
0.0554951392,
-0.0644198135,
0.0249342136,
-0.0038148938,
0.0328969844,
-0.0288903154,
0.0518009998,
-0.1005682573,
-0.0559238344,
0.0148071731,
0.0131202796,
0.0163442232,
0.0004000391,
-0.0182772148,
-0.089665845,
0.0805649236,
0.0515627861,
-0.0014714254,
0.0077383514,
0.0167108774,
-0.0182028767,
-0.0249252077,
0.0432135127,
-0.0623677522,
-0.0091847042,
0.0395070203,
0.065608643,
0.0209281873,
-0.0821947381,
-0.0093669752,
-0.0173730385,
0.0958690494,
-0.0598773919,
-0.0283582807,
-0.0166946016,
0.0015394402,
0.0045292852,
-0.0233400203,
-0.0006692496,
-0.0188925508,
0.0529128648,
-0.0040988033,
-0.0392024033,
0.0041154213,
0.0409119204,
0.0152757661,
-0.0129357222,
-0.0116847353,
0.0447060876,
0.0014242965,
0.0578542799,
-0.0046463935,
-0.0219570156,
-0.0068954327,
-0.0033468523,
0.0222456548,
0.0088699674,
-0.0035349694,
0.0265812725,
0.0031927291,
-0.0338395201,
-0.0085469205,
-0.0493256301,
-0.0105913496,
-0.0405088477,
0.0752451792,
0.0454396121,
-0.0100133503,
0.012979201,
-0.0132877519,
-0.0389985703,
-0.0614084303,
0.0127761737,
-0.0111801513,
0.0047049737,
0.0420305766,
-0.0077129812,
0.0076885512,
0.0306320544,
0.0240703877,
-0.0076137912,
0.0456623882,
-0.0510237589,
-0.0178770907,
0.0264222603,
-0.0064866426,
-0.0087511465,
0.0018209111,
-0.0357570462,
-0.0091301175,
-0.0242815185,
-0.1054125428,
0.0369853377,
0.0820281804,
0.0067241038,
0.0210493654,
-0.0003820519,
0.0706559718,
-0.045623377,
-0.0085221082,
-0.0192030426,
0.023427505,
0.0012897057,
0.0080496464,
-0.0310203619,
-5.901614939e-33,
-0.0159537829,
-0.0098528061,
-0.0235943384,
0.0025103062,
-0.0288033206,
0.0227454938,
-0.000644468,
0.0288974904,
0.0007499648,
0.0334966034,
0.0007801811,
0.0219297074,
0.0248623881,
0.034290038,
-0.0031276052,
-0.0408799201,
0.0267796963,
-0.0401054211,
-0.0314374343,
-0.0185607579,
0.0202078968,
0.0232904162,
0.0946058035,
-0.032944221,
0.0502228327,
0.032257989,
-0.0024481157,
0.0356849283,
0.019800704,
0.0690674111,
-0.0048482567,
0.0727527514,
-0.015845852,
0.0089185117,
0.0100072855,
-0.0056537418,
-0.025738081,
-0.0222903062,
-0.0033138762,
0.06583675,
-0.0305029005,
-0.0047021424,
0.0684751868,
0.0073040859,
-0.0645594448,
-0.0275667757,
0.0108191809,
-0.024465546,
-0.0101500414,
-0.0341036879,
-0.0135164075,
0.0170311555,
-0.002698221,
-0.0136925587,
0.0024983075,
-0.0137524316,
0.0414670967,
0.0053698951,
-0.0669329166,
-0.0286349449,
-0.011913971,
0.0640112758,
0.0628601983,
0.0651913211,
-0.0094639082,
0.0746062621,
0.0382243879,
-0.0209010895,
-0.0231267828,
-0.005597698,
0.0677960441,
-0.035153199,
0.0340520069,
0.0730954558,
0.0441053845,
0.0023332597,
-0.086842671,
0.0189889874,
-0.0048553227,
0.0026509902,
0.0356457978,
0.0283668432,
-0.0254671033,
-0.007045438,
-0.0615092888,
-0.0700459406,
-0.0368778221,
0.0056860507,
0.001162209,
-0.0155957695,
-0.0098722503,
-0.017944634,
0.0087768566,
-0.0725775063,
-0.0271261614,
0.0210756455,
0.0106262863,
0.0169803649,
-0.0115581034,
0.0598811284,
-0.0161384623,
-0.0133416746,
-0.0083108954,
0.0220755246,
0.0329831727,
-0.0175645836,
0.0525298417,
0.0179910827,
-0.03320916,
0.0058629592,
-0.0327820182,
-0.0292769931,
0.0154748131,
0.052277647,
0.0380218551,
-0.0336875543,
0.0035769446,
-0.0001171353,
0.0109481439,
0.0423383079,
0.0182179678,
-0.0039891303,
0.0179442838,
0.030857591,
-0.0587325878,
-0.0183138419,
0.0033251774,
-0.0259906631,
0.0166296363,
-0.0506054685,
-0.005653243,
-0.009000646,
2.396e-7,
0.1110802516,
0.0125326775,
0.0201371927,
0.0145716127,
0.0289984941,
0.0248883739,
-0.0148497969,
0.022637479,
0.0230501033,
-0.0472527929,
-0.0100780651,
-0.004806601,
0.0314131081,
0.0003566121,
-0.0697182268,
-0.0184015892,
-0.0475371964,
0.0489298813,
0.0271714255,
0.0161024649,
-0.0009294972,
0.1098312438,
0.0291770976,
-0.0358106457,
-0.0052063293,
-0.0363808535,
0.043519076,
-0.046135772,
0.0018804099,
0.0607128739,
0.0455131233,
0.0412904546,
0.0374087431,
0.0439739823,
0.0020171669,
0.0503100157,
0.0376686528,
0.0423278436,
0.0074522393,
0.005692163,
-0.0419325642,
-0.003682662,
0.0195879526,
-0.0695120171,
0.0396706685,
-0.0332403034,
-0.0028188406,
-0.0794469416,
-0.0012423333,
-0.0204134304,
0.0789193586,
-0.0320031345,
-0.0246618055,
0.0173317138,
0.0321877114,
-0.00986588,
-0.0249630883,
-0.070333004,
-0.0503873266,
0.0179172419,
-0.0323070474,
-0.0403289795,
0.0003273922,
-0.0265658274,
0.0197309311,
-0.0667159855,
0.0276540425,
2.042780971e-34,
0.0484369211,
-0.0148827303,
0.0023783897,
0.000626256,
0.0241982266,
-0.0178571753,
0.0226640068,
-0.0349515751,
-0.0088736322,
-0.0531185679,
-0.0197080243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11341v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11341v1 | A Systematic Analysis of Large Language Models as Soft Reasoners: The Case of Syllogistic Inferences | 2024-06-17T08:59:04 | 2024-06-17T08:59:04 | Leonardo Bertolazzi, Albert Gatt, Raffaella Bernardi | cs.CL | cs.CL | The reasoning abilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) are becoming a
central focus of study in NLP. In this paper, we consider the case of
syllogistic reasoning, an area of deductive reasoning studied extensively in
logic and cognitive psychology. Previous research has shown that pre-trained
LLMs exhibit reasoning biases, such as $\textit{content effects}$, avoid
answering that $\textit{no conclusion follows}$, display human-like
difficulties, and struggle with multi-step reasoning. We contribute to this
research line by systematically investigating the effects of chain-of-thought
reasoning, in-context learning (ICL), and supervised fine-tuning (SFT) on
syllogistic reasoning, considering syllogisms with conclusions that support or
violate world knowledge, as well as ones with multiple premises. Crucially, we
go beyond the standard focus on accuracy, with an in-depth analysis of the
conclusions generated by the models. Our results suggest that the behavior of
pre-trained LLMs can be explained by heuristics studied in cognitive science
and that both ICL and SFT improve model performance on valid inferences,
although only the latter mitigates most reasoning biases without harming model
consistency. | [
0.046381861,
0.0523165874,
-0.0105055887,
0.0287195556,
-0.0452952795,
0.064015761,
0.0397681594,
-0.0310485885,
0.0087984307,
-0.0793926343,
-0.019158408,
0.0107940799,
0.0067353584,
-0.0447812602,
0.0396864563,
-0.0292075779,
0.0603348501,
-0.0607003942,
0.022002181,
-0.0361017101,
-0.0142609207,
0.0121941762,
0.0019982124,
0.009879102,
0.0007272974,
-0.0141571304,
0.0060599865,
0.0000100531,
0.0081395097,
-0.0466270782,
-0.0132093448,
0.0496614836,
0.0266293064,
0.0572818592,
0.0000020822,
-0.0728612393,
0.0012438766,
0.0063238721,
-0.0195167046,
0.0262380913,
-0.0234557763,
-0.0460317545,
0.0011974848,
0.009388769,
-0.0086506428,
0.0033850085,
0.0165934749,
0.0660763383,
0.037424542,
0.0652682409,
-0.001987701,
-0.0795178935,
0.0066263317,
-0.0313464291,
-0.0221461169,
-0.0438811369,
0.0524650291,
0.0231150649,
-0.0111454371,
0.0004532874,
-0.0033016873,
0.0286950916,
0.034009058,
0.0204066504,
-0.0761987418,
0.0248585455,
-0.0374569744,
-0.0386048928,
0.0148980794,
0.0236504097,
-0.0037802053,
-0.0483147763,
-0.0171321519,
0.013796228,
0.0051202327,
0.0196921565,
-0.028746875,
0.0617555901,
-0.0166114159,
0.0123405019,
0.0817470402,
-0.015511645,
0.0389745794,
0.0174679253,
-0.0728570372,
0.0861272663,
-0.0144339362,
-0.033828143,
0.0417989679,
0.0241609942,
-0.0616711266,
-0.0773378238,
-0.0183495488,
0.045977354,
-0.047285419,
0.0342318043,
-0.017481776,
0.0197204836,
0.0342156701,
-0.054462675,
0.0114281895,
0.0187329799,
0.0312243514,
0.0718291923,
-0.06885463,
-0.0002691703,
-0.0488818772,
0.0566387288,
0.0158257522,
-0.0322333276,
-0.0249410793,
-0.0217151977,
-0.012621806,
0.0452109836,
0.0035814401,
0.0033632671,
-0.0033733926,
0.0047501046,
-0.0305095594,
0.0387239419,
-0.0164843705,
-0.0039446251,
0.0230027102,
-0.0266331397,
-0.0745283663,
0.0120203495,
-0.057794597,
0.0538740754,
0.010117352,
-0.024838347,
0.000190531,
-0.0357574448,
-0.0162289944,
-0.0230647754,
0.0541474186,
0.026679894,
0.0056724893,
0.0021700934,
-0.0740047544,
-0.0391561277,
-0.05094276,
-0.0819798857,
-0.0200073868,
-0.0741486028,
-0.0191228073,
0.0440758057,
0.0277439971,
-0.0175748616,
0.0160450712,
0.0140137123,
-0.0498913862,
0.0771159604,
-0.0020802594,
0.0123715093,
0.0015065762,
-0.0036047061,
0.0179898124,
0.0752440915,
-0.0079763653,
0.0133089842,
0.0024770119,
0.0071582734,
-0.0211889762,
-0.0054530012,
0.0120759662,
-0.0034363638,
-0.0449937321,
0.0150699364,
-0.0110660987,
0.005453039,
-0.0013164063,
0.066370219,
-0.032260973,
-0.0130469976,
0.0459773764,
0.0273606591,
0.0745218247,
0.0273980498,
0.0460392162,
-0.0530350059,
0.0045913639,
0.0217579696,
-0.0771866888,
0.0063909264,
-0.0344692804,
-0.0236342736,
0.0011302008,
0.0215743221,
-0.0250700917,
-0.0474999882,
-0.0169149898,
0.0005900555,
-0.0048315935,
0.0301196557,
0.0625496954,
0.0343439579,
0.0069464403,
0.0201072134,
0.05622169,
0.0122183478,
-0.0433840714,
-0.0345727243,
0.0196654648,
-0.009569753,
0.0383708626,
-0.01717861,
-0.0194093361,
-0.0158509761,
0.0132945552,
0.0160971135,
0.0603799522,
-0.0055561792,
-0.019641364,
-0.0243029054,
-0.0105966367,
-0.0513738766,
0.0469635203,
0.0071576242,
-0.0113780303,
0.0209545847,
0.0080790706,
0.0112802647,
0.0117772799,
0.0268333275,
-0.0245732982,
-0.0258822832,
-0.0434922613,
0.0254765544,
0.0338083096,
-0.0096611818,
-0.0165186618,
0.0124447802,
0.0076541635,
-0.0263306946,
-0.0074574091,
0.0171971787,
-0.0555048697,
-0.0378775485,
0.0282597598,
-0.0454912446,
-0.0228240415,
-0.0043071844,
-0.0245417506,
-0.0062604728,
0.0052746716,
-0.0187065322,
0.0109383455,
-0.030002987,
0.0240883678,
-0.0368753187,
-0.017331088,
-0.0457415171,
0.0928363428,
0.0196106732,
0.0195739064,
0.0489374697,
0.0257517565,
0.0135542993,
-0.0002199431,
-0.0130855683,
0.0449176095,
0.0030507364,
-0.0192133356,
0.0059491843,
-0.0219984092,
-0.0476079136,
-0.0318465717,
-0.093009904,
0.0039709038,
-0.0219074674,
-0.0059148828,
0.0204989631,
-0.038977202,
0.005511791,
0.0205103271,
-0.0008005362,
0.002252589,
0.0222443845,
0.0397405513,
0.0218668655,
-0.0105374884,
-0.0064530848,
-0.0063550686,
-0.0092198802,
-0.0395485088,
0.055306118,
0.0251259524,
0.0204914697,
-0.0288673509,
0.0705282241,
-0.0625386238,
0.0215111207,
-0.0217102263,
-0.0203045737,
0.0391256139,
0.0108910883,
-0.0091921156,
0.1164877489,
-0.0023595262,
0.0011330736,
0.0775121078,
-0.0059217834,
-0.0326831266,
0.0244136862,
-0.0108079137,
-0.0168714803,
-0.054269962,
-0.0133992974,
-0.0235896595,
0.056281466,
-0.0162994042,
-0.0133775454,
-0.0422354862,
0.0515442006,
-0.020854855,
-0.0039193225,
-0.0027320476,
-0.0301861297,
0.0163785294,
0.0738318413,
0.0055409502,
-0.0054408852,
0.0622413084,
0.0017299254,
0.0321371593,
-0.0522867851,
-0.0131863412,
-0.0614781007,
0.0697233602,
-0.0152813159,
0.014369322,
0.0044628768,
0.0183385573,
-0.0582826138,
-0.040918462,
0.0371940434,
-0.0123225003,
0.0168560725,
-0.029866077,
0.0003334925,
-0.0113757486,
-0.0514770374,
-0.0384725966,
-0.0288583897,
-0.079248853,
-0.0182114597,
0.0070052524,
0.0098664826,
0.0085730422,
0.0067196446,
0.0288351309,
0.0071782577,
-0.0035527812,
-0.0230895206,
-0.0187978894,
0.0045901248,
0.0379893593,
0.0022059523,
0.0695971921,
-0.0317991301,
0.0279953741,
0.0386223868,
0.0312055871,
0.0391300619,
-0.0185829513,
0.0129880058,
0.0025973907,
0.015904123,
-0.0619181171,
0.0035430121,
0.0532828867,
-0.0548944771,
-0.0043117646,
0.1191545576,
0.0259765051,
-0.0427976064,
0.0096790027,
-0.016864026,
0.0182868578,
0.0285730865,
-0.025115924,
-0.0537503511,
-0.0559110381,
0.0307440925,
-0.0335953645,
-0.0408234857,
-0.0397820026,
0.0065685445,
-0.1039030626,
0.0050657317,
0.003614604,
-0.0086162481,
-0.0303648151,
-0.0595581457,
0.0316801891,
0.0026330519,
-0.0216669943,
0.0229814649,
-0.0071410877,
-0.0052327742,
0.0136960642,
0.0197829772,
-0.0360728018,
0.0393342003,
-0.0356820822,
0.031014679,
0.0267596766,
0.0244486313,
0.0003993005,
-0.0357425958,
0.0743866339,
-0.0579847693,
0.0076427762,
-0.0195551757,
-0.0009019769,
-0.0044113309,
-0.0040317019,
-0.0417198427,
0.0443315282,
-0.0000971975,
-0.0235099047,
0.0107474923,
0.0654540136,
0.0070331534,
-0.063780047,
-0.013296999,
0.037667606,
-0.0668202862,
0.0549443774,
0.0116611328,
-0.0244207792,
-0.0420251563,
-0.0308596548,
-0.0308358874,
0.0396131985,
-0.0282983687,
0.0343192071,
0.0308080018,
0.0003613887,
-0.0228058416,
-0.045876991,
0.0347941332,
0.0559776798,
-0.0106428545,
0.0104703186,
-0.0030189315,
0.0201581772,
0.0228298288,
0.042094402,
-0.0306002442,
0.0287170932,
-0.0179772899,
0.0477743447,
0.0173366293,
-0.0154029978,
-0.0151594793,
0.0122984843,
-0.062856108,
-0.0743987933,
-0.0056827627,
0.02453232,
0.0311478451,
0.057290677,
-0.0240360443,
-0.049218826,
0.0314905979,
0.054062169,
0.0033604375,
0.032525491,
0.0330296829,
-0.0051030135,
0.0231979918,
0.0373486169,
-0.0127898334,
0.0099734589,
0.054036539,
0.0349757262,
-0.0336363763,
-0.0062777353,
0.0606273934,
-0.0057263412,
0.0215480346,
0.0221508835,
-0.0474627875,
-0.0008749129,
0.0249783434,
-0.0123362951,
-0.0361965522,
0.0024252259,
0.0046982449,
0.0161477737,
0.0060833287,
-0.0134111419,
-0.0691555217,
0.0165757015,
0.027233446,
0.0175301023,
-0.0039959913,
0.0547045581,
0.0102264723,
0.0249947663,
-0.013609915,
-0.0386871733,
0.0245105866,
-0.0136378156,
0.0463411845,
-0.012922734,
0.0809646696,
0.0746947601,
-0.0168381631,
-0.0448982753,
-0.0234306529,
-0.0797015578,
-0.0554591604,
0.0295378473,
0.0006794661,
0.0592407212,
-0.0367340744,
0.0293648709,
-0.0403414555,
-0.0295548141,
0.0005949467,
0.0127900215,
0.0343472473,
-0.0090785269,
0.0217857566,
0.0196572356,
-0.0270724818,
0.0013229477,
0.0344945937,
-0.0243186615,
0.0357773937,
0.0350774862,
-0.0284082163,
-0.0178037975,
-0.0388554409,
-0.0304166414,
0.0365635678,
0.0022013364,
0.0216653869,
-0.0868906975,
-0.0948931798,
-0.034382347,
0.0031106083,
0.0239928737,
-0.0126892338,
-0.0157131366,
0.0921265706,
0.011413523,
-0.013351256,
-0.0103106899,
-0.0051732175,
0.0128288744,
0.0124984002,
-0.0106949871,
-6.490935072e-33,
-0.0222416781,
-0.0236311052,
0.0048683486,
-0.0050666882,
0.0069812224,
-0.0242123585,
-0.0218012556,
0.0015125908,
-0.0638065785,
0.0510326847,
-0.016600715,
0.0124786766,
-0.002489341,
-0.0017138394,
-0.0393760316,
-0.0055109067,
0.0205556378,
0.0490721241,
-0.0288223755,
-0.0148115586,
0.0398999192,
-0.0123232789,
0.0201553311,
-0.0385763794,
0.0004194752,
0.0055793114,
-0.0022251487,
0.0159019921,
-0.0812623724,
0.002430321,
0.0171182975,
-0.0070770327,
0.0296607967,
-0.0093157478,
0.0357237197,
0.0170473829,
-0.0831272453,
-0.0126831122,
0.0619036853,
-0.0180842876,
-0.0102094561,
-0.0358410589,
0.0383743607,
0.0088398401,
-0.0182518028,
-0.0199899226,
0.0172513593,
-0.029321067,
-0.0016655801,
-0.0420574807,
-0.06408564,
0.0120005971,
-0.0157464147,
-0.0260144398,
-0.0304141268,
0.025771847,
-0.022950856,
0.0243272781,
-0.0155404145,
0.0132452361,
0.0337012075,
-0.0083810445,
0.055893857,
-0.02238339,
-0.0087939119,
0.0562936477,
0.0083147548,
0.0332965851,
-0.0547924228,
-0.0022578996,
0.014690984,
0.048651997,
0.0564496033,
0.0321399271,
0.0435349643,
0.0096862679,
-0.1168955714,
-0.0570441149,
-0.0046946071,
0.0414433964,
0.0598161109,
-0.0034758497,
-0.0043237549,
-0.0279695,
-0.0930225328,
0.0044058342,
-0.0225996934,
0.0039145201,
0.0124393255,
0.0144166276,
-0.0200012717,
-0.0080635846,
-0.0001542914,
-0.0474071018,
-0.0270888638,
0.0459922776,
0.0051361355,
-0.0160405952,
-0.0112951435,
0.0420685522,
-0.0355470031,
0.0016696549,
-0.0055496129,
0.0029914731,
0.0242612734,
0.017860122,
0.0685724542,
-0.0058209938,
-0.0392374396,
-0.0136415455,
-0.0573153719,
0.0159044657,
-0.0148511836,
-0.0365953259,
0.0691466033,
0.029030066,
-0.0076335352,
0.0040431609,
0.0319956914,
-0.0156169478,
-0.0228210967,
0.0340826996,
-0.0232254397,
0.0157539006,
-0.0045018489,
-0.0348354466,
-0.0358490087,
0.007744797,
0.0315328538,
-0.0640953556,
-0.0147835994,
0.0191870965,
2.875e-7,
0.0285483934,
0.0796123594,
-0.0341981277,
0.0179105792,
0.0300814137,
0.0571898147,
-0.0094547905,
-0.0231630336,
0.056879282,
-0.0338135473,
-0.015641069,
0.0545188077,
0.0217177607,
0.0506298989,
-0.0129944151,
0.0112555642,
-0.0468646139,
-0.0288148783,
-0.0476834625,
0.0195576809,
0.0250353534,
0.1015415117,
0.0204102769,
-0.0160573553,
0.0338662714,
-0.0642395169,
0.0599672869,
-0.0126612196,
0.0080906739,
-0.0062694661,
0.0058769872,
-0.0327447169,
0.0208336841,
0.0596994795,
0.0479869694,
0.0220790356,
-0.0297234021,
0.0306964796,
-0.0062247613,
0.010339899,
-0.0263500698,
-0.0361288749,
-0.0052256892,
-0.1160532013,
0.1181267425,
-0.1006096974,
-0.060007304,
-0.0105288047,
0.0044211927,
-0.0438034944,
0.0263985321,
0.0112419948,
-0.0030350047,
0.0049155378,
-0.0100534521,
0.0105367405,
0.0073569082,
-0.0955854505,
-0.0216488559,
0.0449107923,
-0.0147323459,
-0.0499250926,
0.0099805547,
0.0005625312,
0.0742555782,
-0.0586360171,
-0.0009270444,
2.803635301e-34,
0.0330884382,
-0.0212625414,
0.0300907716,
-0.0035723783,
0.0648893043,
0.0155314477,
-0.0206109751,
0.0113209272,
0.036959365,
-0.0858014822,
-0.0068093846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11338v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11338v1 | Fine-grained Controllable Text Generation through In-context Learning with Feedback | 2024-06-17T08:55:48 | 2024-06-17T08:55:48 | Sarubi Thillainathan, Alexander Koller | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a method for rewriting an input sentence to match specific values
of nontrivial linguistic features, such as dependency depth. In contrast to
earlier work, our method uses in-context learning rather than finetuning,
making it applicable in use cases where data is sparse. We show that our model
performs accurate rewrites and matches the state of the art on rewriting
sentences to a specified school grade level. | [
0.02652869,
0.0233152024,
0.0000960407,
0.0190201979,
-0.0487967506,
-0.0082200654,
-0.0129245017,
-0.0381978229,
-0.0183034334,
-0.064029932,
0.0285794698,
0.0145429652,
0.004095715,
0.0555709377,
0.0511887372,
-0.0653642491,
0.0087747453,
0.0128334835,
-0.0197806079,
0.0023315735,
0.0278462954,
0.0263018832,
0.0136084529,
0.0320787504,
-0.0461451858,
-0.00563615,
-0.015650725,
0.0377972201,
0.0020034441,
0.0119570196,
0.0787894949,
0.0380003005,
0.0285268873,
0.0149448682,
0.0000019296,
-0.0197153166,
-0.0400547162,
-0.010244186,
0.0256223325,
0.0213959254,
0.0142864622,
-0.0342494696,
-0.0265212078,
0.020994639,
-0.0295496453,
0.0360260308,
0.0242343247,
0.0232274365,
0.0688847378,
0.0714781955,
-0.0361724347,
-0.0112720281,
-0.0053135813,
-0.0372607931,
0.0355972573,
-0.0081867315,
-0.0064282804,
0.014668256,
0.0132990628,
-0.0117807966,
-0.0353547186,
0.0238221996,
0.0219464004,
-0.0288222823,
0.0203278307,
0.0136168646,
0.0085713901,
0.0230326615,
0.0172639396,
0.0590710975,
-0.0251471978,
-0.0515142493,
0.0348043516,
-0.0268754214,
-0.0036280893,
-0.013944081,
-0.0332115926,
0.0141940275,
-0.0203408133,
0.006949353,
0.0143526765,
-0.0105571877,
-0.0142587079,
0.031387262,
-0.0261239056,
0.0277077593,
0.0169271193,
-0.0367358439,
-0.063021265,
0.0352197029,
0.0103992382,
-0.08083269,
0.0110429749,
0.0050379494,
-0.042077858,
0.0052941241,
-0.1217671409,
-0.0299664158,
0.0141111407,
-0.0363671668,
0.0072988519,
0.0121390056,
0.0008389761,
-0.0022334177,
-0.0073378547,
0.0084973788,
-0.0045229173,
0.0054029566,
-0.0252583995,
0.0373281278,
-0.0401171371,
-0.0112519292,
-0.0824867785,
0.0451397076,
-0.0431829877,
-0.0208172221,
-0.0780219138,
0.026409816,
-0.000226213,
0.023742307,
-0.0347454734,
0.01929814,
-0.0694328398,
-0.0155857401,
0.0391773172,
0.0523344986,
-0.0329747833,
0.0087644318,
0.0463512577,
-0.0057594301,
0.0053777932,
0.0203625802,
0.0576023459,
-0.0077474169,
-0.002499229,
0.0348308198,
-0.0448546149,
-0.0136036752,
-0.0414530709,
-0.0895029902,
-0.0391348824,
-0.0361144729,
-0.0491756424,
-0.0840503275,
-0.0201882254,
0.0050581074,
-0.005802223,
-0.0287009329,
0.019454496,
0.0364927761,
-0.0067947484,
0.0089653842,
0.0001314749,
-0.0316592678,
0.0179605745,
-0.006833849,
0.032172475,
0.0377539992,
0.0536739267,
0.0760192648,
0.0139163285,
0.0097167213,
0.0176627338,
0.0123794237,
0.0208102427,
0.0079335412,
-0.0394139849,
-0.0375740007,
-0.041333925,
0.044262059,
0.0178584177,
0.0380584262,
-0.0181051064,
0.0813414827,
0.0831614956,
0.0067603597,
0.0381982252,
0.0203607772,
0.1026998982,
0.0242856815,
-0.0406679213,
0.0685839579,
-0.0295998305,
0.0224833377,
-0.0164592806,
0.048394002,
0.0266327262,
0.0113298772,
-0.0043895915,
-0.0611760393,
0.0348430648,
-0.0057097115,
-0.0183684751,
-0.0377641916,
0.0313856155,
0.0762234777,
-0.0694331527,
-0.0121247917,
0.0375231579,
-0.0571833402,
0.0335029177,
-0.0013439944,
0.0137430113,
0.0914914608,
0.0661442205,
0.004019883,
-0.0153827928,
-0.0071104644,
0.0294496398,
0.0630005375,
0.022124961,
-0.0128597775,
-0.0130950278,
-0.0426965095,
0.0035475427,
-0.0395941846,
0.035172198,
-0.0027136926,
-0.0158854853,
-0.0110041546,
0.0459324494,
0.019366283,
-0.0558291338,
0.0428482927,
-0.0154788569,
-0.0237193443,
0.0357808024,
0.0343325622,
-0.0165129211,
-0.0230419803,
-0.011591333,
0.0392519124,
-0.0065563708,
-0.0426512882,
-0.034446504,
-0.0259770527,
-0.0659207851,
-0.0662159547,
-0.0243811663,
-0.0648785532,
0.0146036427,
-0.017614793,
-0.0496040955,
-0.06342379,
0.0305481683,
-0.0408585519,
0.0351317301,
-0.0265760217,
0.0172583237,
0.0150251789,
-0.0206842646,
-0.0658849776,
0.0499617122,
0.0423755832,
-0.0025913115,
-0.0003869892,
0.0262891818,
-0.0024897226,
-0.007256703,
-0.0101020541,
-0.0377951674,
-0.0179425534,
0.0008644031,
0.0225525461,
0.0504804552,
-0.0250760093,
-0.0480406471,
-0.0387199596,
-0.0023423946,
-0.0211583301,
-0.0030054401,
0.0630587414,
0.0492650457,
0.0175344329,
-0.0091402465,
-0.0410898179,
0.0143097797,
0.0367477834,
-0.0228405483,
0.0433435887,
0.0162919555,
0.0038753054,
-0.0550838411,
-0.0104658706,
-0.0068692127,
0.00560789,
0.0429659151,
-0.030150082,
-0.0451010242,
0.0547346361,
-0.0369181521,
0.0151057271,
0.0176219624,
-0.0403427929,
0.0024409445,
-0.0203638561,
0.0500232205,
0.0574633367,
0.0230206139,
0.0267069936,
0.0191664919,
-0.0040564705,
-0.0227855314,
0.0251281522,
-0.0337490626,
0.012923588,
-0.0200731251,
-0.0175708439,
0.0296256375,
0.0528140664,
0.0664400086,
-0.0100168148,
-0.0598274544,
0.0274321102,
-0.0068477062,
-0.0010173913,
-0.0131608034,
-0.002973865,
-0.0102438964,
0.0147565361,
-0.025133742,
-0.0538669527,
0.0599220246,
-0.0081508644,
0.0129879378,
-0.0093509303,
-0.0036389842,
-0.0251656063,
0.0442629084,
0.007967419,
0.0184941031,
0.0214200187,
-0.0098966062,
-0.0806295425,
0.0368013047,
0.0554818474,
-0.0018630623,
0.0696190223,
-0.0731209144,
0.0178957582,
-0.0235542022,
-0.0523877777,
-0.0306058396,
-0.0414817631,
0.0060608322,
-0.0225377586,
0.0258770213,
-0.0299307629,
-0.0052243872,
-0.024199307,
0.0315566175,
0.0972730964,
-0.0419193245,
-0.027107574,
-0.0512755513,
0.0230655614,
0.0602770746,
-0.0129517335,
-0.03285864,
-0.0293346439,
0.0216463041,
0.043647524,
-0.020704275,
0.0093580652,
-0.0052241972,
0.0056683836,
0.0069404962,
0.0137926703,
-0.0238446239,
0.0406223051,
0.0320095755,
-0.0826835036,
-0.0875720307,
0.0882191807,
0.0190347619,
-0.0206917878,
0.02507958,
0.0201202128,
0.0827858448,
0.0114435237,
0.0385497697,
-0.0515620112,
-0.0291263741,
0.0209932886,
0.0583047792,
-0.0144422576,
-0.0030793252,
-0.0163962785,
-0.0858877748,
0.0363734849,
0.0196101945,
-0.0137168914,
-0.032268215,
0.0184409097,
-0.0114225214,
0.0435282141,
-0.0227775574,
0.0188674554,
-0.0265531521,
0.0109122451,
0.0017639278,
-0.0118226465,
-0.0489749275,
-0.003630175,
0.0065849377,
0.0225491505,
0.0699352697,
0.0148704909,
0.005759113,
0.0310666878,
0.0338004641,
-0.0161029752,
-0.0100409649,
-0.01607766,
0.061528299,
-0.0000695723,
-0.0193032175,
-0.0094946558,
0.0801111236,
0.0092406198,
0.027254194,
0.0198287349,
0.0266063809,
-0.0241339989,
-0.0008358438,
0.0030449664,
-0.0017079818,
0.0478613675,
0.0418909453,
0.0532273576,
-0.0754306167,
-0.0428081751,
-0.0576252677,
-0.0113513367,
-0.0915550441,
-0.024778774,
-0.0105432561,
-0.0020740984,
0.0008839684,
-0.1281289756,
-0.0075748218,
0.0517994501,
0.0666028634,
0.0095613543,
0.0084491801,
0.0299430899,
-0.0615366958,
-0.0389261469,
-0.017649591,
-0.0161082912,
0.0217444412,
-0.0599013716,
-0.0461415909,
0.0216251947,
-0.0381527878,
-0.0039830366,
0.0506305806,
-0.0735368878,
-0.0747202858,
0.0001243407,
0.0581242107,
0.0170656666,
0.0434480868,
-0.0041737584,
-0.0526415221,
0.0500105657,
0.034890864,
-0.0261771344,
0.0332017988,
0.0262823403,
0.0012016182,
-0.0120672975,
0.0539484322,
-0.0469391011,
0.0120519102,
0.0363266654,
0.0402570963,
0.0175282527,
-0.0159005225,
0.0607340485,
-0.0118250381,
-0.0132212117,
-0.0498665944,
0.0128761223,
-0.0529424548,
0.0123964204,
-0.0525208972,
-0.0266602375,
-0.0661979392,
0.0044645267,
0.0084677413,
0.0189097822,
0.0086253136,
-0.0255973451,
-0.003489679,
0.0579018071,
-0.0389904045,
0.0054947399,
-0.0541799664,
0.0313361622,
0.0667303726,
-0.018165892,
-0.0317904204,
0.021022385,
-0.0217464082,
0.0274484791,
-0.037940681,
0.0320099182,
0.0462243482,
0.0237469487,
-0.0438017212,
0.0150672905,
-0.0380055048,
0.0164208859,
-0.0637069866,
0.0146237798,
0.0397837125,
-0.0133712376,
0.0686753243,
-0.0654681697,
-0.007555929,
0.0030796533,
0.0981199369,
0.0043661371,
-0.050990954,
-0.0170018841,
-0.0042262049,
0.0077517042,
0.0016364491,
0.1016214564,
0.0204123277,
0.0206317939,
0.0137867704,
0.0231839716,
-0.0635301098,
-0.0174551364,
0.0203127228,
0.0325303227,
0.0075506899,
0.0019458819,
-0.0541181304,
-0.0412150957,
0.0085036093,
0.0245185923,
0.0119126355,
-0.0236566421,
0.0511737503,
0.0298366658,
-0.0132356845,
0.0132877426,
-0.0272914153,
0.0305600911,
0.0155028999,
-0.0420254394,
-0.0472209789,
-6.116651426e-33,
-0.054125499,
-0.0425194353,
0.0064412882,
0.0116351638,
-0.0181162972,
0.0277497787,
-0.0567149259,
0.0183298271,
0.0404756702,
0.0261539295,
-0.0119827399,
-0.0234530829,
-0.0066682803,
0.0815118253,
0.0273501538,
0.0339385532,
0.0531399474,
0.0076325987,
-0.025218159,
0.0548196845,
0.0376898535,
0.0255030412,
0.0376269892,
-0.0270579513,
-0.0014071482,
-0.0375332832,
-0.0459075645,
0.0109184338,
-0.0443111956,
0.0087030865,
0.0123418411,
0.0030332725,
0.0264419001,
0.0085948659,
-0.0360251516,
0.0475643389,
-0.0451160297,
-0.0082183974,
-0.0211929902,
-0.0376957133,
-0.0552468337,
-0.0386473127,
0.0442098007,
-0.0325782187,
0.0242953002,
0.007276827,
0.0471134335,
-0.026655307,
-0.002923873,
-0.0545680784,
-0.117056556,
-0.0006998988,
-0.0202668048,
-0.0586200133,
-0.0438430756,
0.0459407046,
0.0041043656,
-0.0085316515,
0.0364180021,
0.0294805653,
0.0141364932,
0.0728032663,
0.030545203,
0.0109295761,
-0.0071224691,
0.0490378104,
-0.0338725112,
0.0496685877,
-0.013908485,
-0.0127900708,
0.020765651,
0.0323243029,
0.0326047428,
0.0775203705,
0.0274677388,
-0.002204071,
-0.0600033328,
0.012629739,
-0.0200291853,
0.0126876803,
0.0164221246,
0.0021036498,
-0.0171534028,
-0.025756631,
-0.010253083,
0.0025693423,
-0.0012091501,
-0.0052133715,
0.0238614343,
0.0469475016,
-0.0576850809,
-0.0327394903,
-0.001445393,
0.0058315671,
-0.0161269363,
0.0074390001,
-0.0475666188,
0.0177722443,
-0.023823835,
-0.0183157381,
-0.0254367962,
-0.0300209131,
0.0159953702,
0.0202032644,
0.0224602818,
0.0337892659,
0.0668051168,
0.0290408302,
-0.0495427847,
0.0337256491,
-0.0449543148,
0.0417409986,
-0.0073999413,
0.0032543552,
0.0147528211,
-0.0397854112,
-0.0162571967,
0.0136142634,
0.0037934526,
-0.0390473306,
-0.0239088386,
-0.0206063893,
-0.0010383059,
0.0228917506,
-0.0579630695,
0.0001115995,
-0.0355611444,
0.009520066,
0.0599372312,
-0.0318459533,
-0.0049158158,
-0.0026908033,
2.687e-7,
0.0064514079,
0.0560973622,
0.0464809723,
-0.0016400791,
0.0098769926,
0.0230186135,
0.0049222708,
0.0327228792,
-0.0078787468,
-0.0002745541,
0.0295658186,
-0.0308184717,
0.0693361238,
-0.02671545,
-0.1037955061,
0.0529844314,
-0.0332866907,
0.008900431,
-0.0352789201,
-0.0482073911,
0.0776739493,
0.0375495814,
0.0087509081,
-0.0069944342,
0.0390779749,
-0.0238380693,
0.0371104516,
0.0170062538,
0.010360701,
0.0120883901,
-0.0069934367,
-0.014520078,
-0.0352347568,
0.0067224526,
-0.0405276977,
-0.0225266572,
-0.0228508431,
0.0566202365,
0.0105806496,
0.028482601,
0.0066319648,
-0.0041505662,
0.0048324307,
-0.0434868075,
0.0172309112,
-0.087053977,
0.0131147876,
-0.0142230643,
0.0105324024,
0.0240328815,
-0.0366788581,
-0.0261669699,
-0.0406909883,
0.0029011294,
0.0244966317,
0.0156544093,
-0.0070999619,
-0.0413874425,
-0.0263779033,
-0.0080925506,
-0.0372375846,
-0.0020638374,
-0.0608919337,
0.0023437063,
0.0131875258,
-0.0351277404,
-0.0035121967,
2.725314776e-34,
0.0281954836,
-0.0305768102,
0.0183671676,
-0.0282677058,
0.0124516934,
0.0116288625,
-0.0006147614,
0.0368566848,
0.0267150141,
-0.0427924991,
-0.0462168939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11328v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11328v1 | Are Large Language Models True Healthcare Jacks-of-All-Trades? Benchmarking Across Health Professions Beyond Physician Exams | 2024-06-17T08:40:36 | 2024-06-17T08:40:36 | Zheheng Luo, Chenhan Yuan, Qianqian Xie, Sophia Ananiadou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated their
potential in delivering accurate answers to questions about world knowledge.
Despite this, existing benchmarks for evaluating LLMs in healthcare
predominantly focus on medical doctors, leaving other critical healthcare
professions underrepresented. To fill this research gap, we introduce the
Examinations for Medical Personnel in Chinese (EMPEC), a pioneering large-scale
healthcare knowledge benchmark in traditional Chinese. EMPEC consists of
157,803 exam questions across 124 subjects and 20 healthcare professions,
including underrepresented occupations like Optometrists and Audiologists. Each
question is tagged with its release time and source, ensuring relevance and
authenticity. We conducted extensive experiments on 17 LLMs, including
proprietary, open-source models, general domain models and medical specific
models, evaluating their performance under various settings. Our findings
reveal that while leading models like GPT-4 achieve over 75\% accuracy, they
still struggle with specialized fields and alternative medicine. Surprisingly,
general-purpose LLMs outperformed medical-specific models, and incorporating
EMPEC's training data significantly enhanced performance. Additionally, the
results on questions released after the models' training cutoff date were
consistent with overall performance trends, suggesting that the models'
performance on the test set can predict their effectiveness in addressing
unseen healthcare-related queries. The transition from traditional to
simplified Chinese characters had a negligible impact on model performance,
indicating robust linguistic versatility. Our study underscores the importance
of expanding benchmarks to cover a broader range of healthcare professions to
better assess the applicability of LLMs in real-world healthcare scenarios. | [
0.0446823612,
0.0673444942,
-0.0084053837,
-0.0390759632,
-0.005520469,
0.0142756198,
0.0329684466,
0.0581734069,
0.028624652,
-0.0177022759,
-0.0005433417,
-0.0612175278,
-0.0062105278,
-0.0072826575,
0.031493891,
-0.0432339497,
0.0138831632,
0.0276692957,
0.0050405078,
-0.01544894,
-0.0173604917,
0.008944395,
-0.0192427412,
0.071999386,
0.0416878983,
-0.0141679747,
0.0382253304,
-0.0020781734,
0.0160125177,
-0.0533705279,
0.0147465346,
0.0443055481,
-0.0297718067,
0.0215233602,
0.0000020632,
-0.0486634374,
-0.0130400807,
0.036308594,
-0.0527577624,
-0.0000133888,
0.0275897346,
-0.0393254273,
-0.0097291032,
0.0482285321,
-0.0311363377,
-0.0564597435,
0.0115304803,
0.02267465,
0.0342045203,
0.0536884665,
-0.0000849732,
0.0130371591,
-0.0015512457,
-0.0367319286,
-0.0244537611,
-0.046501521,
0.0424134098,
0.0073190182,
0.0211078767,
-0.0182244815,
-0.0208775848,
0.0253467988,
-0.001834777,
0.0326531194,
-0.0165038146,
0.045032993,
-0.0443781391,
0.032932356,
0.0130411573,
0.0385459997,
-0.0204067584,
-0.0090079261,
0.0070835999,
-0.0082206577,
-0.0005491263,
0.0209001508,
-0.0507800616,
0.023976963,
-0.0089050522,
-0.0289627519,
0.0072154519,
-0.018323971,
0.036318928,
0.0324992649,
-0.0155561492,
0.00586943,
0.0344670899,
-0.0303029902,
0.036324013,
-0.0094706314,
0.0153323989,
-0.0270027276,
0.0299078263,
0.0383830927,
-0.0392704643,
0.0191411488,
0.0158193,
0.012332458,
0.0735788122,
-0.0418872871,
-0.0195780192,
0.0412048884,
-0.0016578591,
0.0445036516,
-0.0052900976,
0.0317307562,
-0.0192904696,
0.0154189421,
-0.0726153031,
-0.017472852,
-0.0712399483,
-0.0209251046,
0.0024879391,
0.003133392,
0.0030412814,
0.0393142253,
-0.0791640058,
-0.0290859994,
-0.0136998808,
0.022878034,
0.0182464942,
0.0178038981,
-0.0377504677,
0.0015276418,
-0.0425847918,
0.0571908429,
-0.0008173879,
0.0152182253,
-0.0273496155,
-0.02996023,
0.0283645894,
0.0081075747,
0.0078195985,
0.004660707,
0.0160880499,
0.036636021,
-0.0056646634,
0.0015743602,
0.0006212818,
-0.0273217726,
-0.0217212252,
-0.0279341508,
0.0134962359,
-0.0518508404,
0.0050095026,
0.0167782437,
0.0324836224,
-0.051586628,
0.0224904269,
0.0309846513,
-0.042561505,
0.0337043889,
-0.0154479137,
0.0287575051,
0.0444077924,
0.0481156968,
-0.0042579151,
0.0301245302,
0.0038504852,
-0.0479974151,
-0.0002909371,
-0.0556948408,
0.0084108878,
0.0181856286,
0.0031491257,
-0.0185345467,
0.0199093707,
0.0362067781,
0.0627980158,
0.0689825714,
-0.0533543453,
0.0653568357,
-0.0110952035,
-0.0103202015,
0.0304193217,
0.0760835111,
0.0120843332,
-0.0024590259,
0.0081805736,
-0.0209786296,
0.0153882327,
-0.0241527278,
-0.0210550632,
-0.0307023115,
-0.0096154753,
-0.0068610134,
-0.0367595665,
-0.0046243449,
-0.0466193482,
-0.0385763682,
-0.0459686145,
0.000039388,
-0.0316995457,
0.0179959685,
0.042395141,
-0.0442991368,
-0.0107939662,
0.0907520801,
0.040582981,
-0.0395482704,
0.0045996918,
-0.0566250011,
-0.0350112021,
0.0890606493,
0.0501216017,
-0.0311099011,
-0.0409830362,
-0.0231172647,
0.0078137824,
0.0389002301,
0.0543335117,
-0.0318142921,
-0.0179284364,
-0.0422724448,
-0.0072529418,
0.0432318784,
0.0209658369,
-0.0225237682,
0.0261607263,
0.0684704632,
-0.0025961997,
-0.0545704924,
-0.0570527576,
0.0315167718,
-0.1185011566,
-0.0287488457,
-0.0144699672,
-0.0108214924,
0.0103965867,
0.0346778072,
-0.0130707147,
0.0389856994,
0.0062705078,
-0.0330054313,
-0.0167612378,
-0.0067505809,
-0.0286545996,
0.0072570858,
0.0505869389,
-0.04951277,
-0.0116356714,
0.0184896551,
-0.0364580266,
-0.0392598175,
-0.0460330769,
-0.002144031,
0.0291351099,
-0.0386297852,
0.0217199028,
-0.0214867368,
-0.0046121301,
-0.0375541076,
0.0213911496,
-0.0084487684,
0.0441537797,
0.0185087714,
-0.0233715717,
0.0184725393,
-0.0443269312,
-0.0449735783,
0.0215188134,
0.0017331291,
0.0498090088,
-0.0098459451,
0.0311502628,
-0.0448975712,
-0.0213176608,
-0.1389774978,
-0.0165485516,
-0.0091677876,
-0.0145831648,
0.0355572887,
-0.0090774409,
-0.0064058732,
-0.0100186253,
-0.0797958449,
-0.0312518552,
0.01872392,
0.0147098703,
-0.0054247268,
0.0205794107,
0.0141323125,
-0.0256071854,
-0.0179339368,
-0.0579931773,
-0.0008998882,
0.0172239877,
0.0292700343,
0.0108104758,
-0.0025257366,
-0.0334803909,
-0.0241230093,
-0.0057165213,
-0.0334474482,
0.0006095849,
-0.0129358899,
-0.0194697604,
0.0164732989,
-0.0054289554,
-0.0278455541,
0.0288253967,
0.0003083418,
-0.0186089482,
0.0124607543,
0.0018625591,
-0.0357211418,
-0.0043867272,
-0.0632176548,
-0.0162256602,
0.0531599298,
0.0145271271,
-0.0086440034,
-0.0347485393,
-0.0046785655,
-0.0806273073,
-0.0047993301,
-0.0723044872,
0.0514614098,
-0.0302751176,
0.0459239408,
0.0225806106,
-0.0037318489,
0.0643567219,
0.0092424154,
0.0461391248,
-0.0696771741,
-0.0129210278,
-0.0394402519,
0.0335425436,
-0.0381968617,
0.0160916355,
0.0389154628,
-0.0299829729,
-0.0433000363,
0.0304728821,
-0.0267496444,
-0.0973851308,
0.0339483209,
-0.023965558,
0.0101581374,
-0.0086665098,
-0.0532984324,
-0.0524356067,
-0.0320456624,
-0.0263599884,
0.0356762521,
0.0067226347,
0.0150043638,
-0.0222615171,
0.0412285104,
-0.0225204527,
0.0526301265,
0.0243681725,
-0.0003026827,
0.0080031892,
0.0166683383,
0.033475168,
0.0431009717,
-0.0011948956,
-0.0430654585,
0.0571252629,
0.0624296442,
0.0633602589,
0.0087125301,
0.0263989046,
-0.0100068059,
0.0212946944,
-0.0523513071,
-0.0032254695,
0.0266925134,
0.0027403072,
-0.0691023767,
0.026203936,
0.1288613081,
0.0188705437,
-0.0163568538,
0.0101813767,
-0.0144291837,
-0.0332238972,
0.0269706249,
0.0352617279,
-0.0865557715,
-0.0036064822,
-0.0066762585,
0.0512331054,
0.0070954696,
-0.0147515051,
0.0380098373,
-0.0968990847,
0.0363823362,
-0.0055317469,
-0.0481944717,
-0.0023064276,
-0.0124493241,
0.0022829606,
-0.0033514586,
0.027357718,
0.0087679159,
-0.0091078775,
-0.0131822638,
0.0151782669,
-0.0690079033,
-0.0809724852,
0.0867614001,
-0.0212242305,
0.0377578102,
0.0461951122,
0.0249720067,
-0.0358786955,
-0.024367908,
-0.0075191255,
-0.0169679746,
-0.0028692763,
-0.0026657428,
0.0704444796,
0.0236023664,
-0.0000740112,
-0.0228017755,
0.0163355004,
-0.0623795614,
0.018305175,
0.0485545471,
0.0785912201,
-0.0001652197,
-0.0307310894,
-0.0202894695,
0.0255132206,
-0.0090309028,
0.0689020455,
-0.0128525961,
-0.0475145429,
-0.0044051786,
-0.0163339991,
0.0233590659,
0.0123905344,
-0.0345143043,
0.0743816048,
-0.0153964572,
-0.0265375823,
-0.0557017997,
-0.0446483903,
0.0568138547,
-0.0156388916,
0.0241631977,
0.0302868318,
0.041605968,
0.0020897777,
-0.0467485413,
0.0344397724,
-0.0172267705,
0.0251808669,
-0.0647451282,
-0.0424886867,
0.067062743,
0.0077238805,
-0.0193175375,
-0.0099292872,
-0.023168724,
-0.0087467059,
0.0021624335,
0.0277120825,
0.0143057257,
-0.0174523741,
-0.0113688391,
-0.0111412294,
0.0179659519,
0.0079261307,
-0.0554260649,
0.0027411426,
-0.0204554442,
-0.022813499,
-0.0203924831,
-0.0003719972,
-0.0266588125,
-0.0013287799,
0.0395659544,
0.0420966409,
-0.0069997641,
-0.0271350909,
0.0372274257,
0.055932451,
-0.0012211029,
0.0077906698,
0.0057507763,
-0.0261841621,
0.0271105189,
-0.0179132279,
-0.0036970652,
-0.0090610441,
-0.0442302823,
0.064846091,
-0.0078504384,
0.0016780103,
0.0258426163,
-0.0209044423,
-0.0078141419,
-0.0892104805,
0.0316036083,
-0.0026798209,
0.0122496132,
0.0279711261,
-0.0183621272,
-0.0123240827,
0.0006596553,
0.011367457,
0.0470272265,
-0.0006510164,
0.0803694427,
-0.0150634516,
0.0280748121,
0.038047526,
0.0099986186,
-0.0453194082,
-0.1049863249,
0.0027676923,
0.0369040892,
0.0680376813,
0.0002077933,
-0.0082028331,
-0.0115587162,
-0.0072251754,
-0.039200332,
-0.0288893562,
0.0020531809,
0.0201639589,
0.0719616339,
0.0251911618,
0.0026685223,
-0.0144191813,
0.1086269096,
0.0266487561,
0.0632791892,
0.0097043803,
-0.0293498114,
-0.0453098789,
-0.0041574263,
0.0479750037,
0.020105971,
-0.0621115156,
0.0369051509,
-0.0998224169,
-0.0596147925,
0.015107003,
-0.0090384269,
-0.0196393356,
-0.0124266371,
0.0470867641,
0.0545798615,
0.0073881648,
-0.0243767519,
-0.0457812212,
0.0424232185,
-0.0240227282,
0.0029041735,
0.041903384,
-6.18350877e-33,
0.0065562562,
-0.0137604531,
0.0438947342,
-0.0584130287,
0.0295152664,
0.0388487913,
-0.0124762915,
-0.0059591616,
-0.0548549034,
0.0016675156,
-0.0347125866,
0.0256260224,
0.0118574612,
0.0300201308,
0.0360398218,
-0.0354005247,
0.0326640606,
0.005280606,
-0.0024597861,
0.0248318706,
-0.0168699697,
0.0419103429,
0.0529894717,
-0.0436110944,
0.006654141,
-0.0029888165,
0.0460500568,
-0.0072226464,
-0.0334617496,
0.0654418916,
-0.0203792825,
0.047772795,
0.0467975698,
-0.0425362289,
0.0142711857,
-0.039719414,
-0.0750826821,
-0.0007400315,
-0.0011716138,
0.0019959912,
-0.0189684574,
-0.0227570105,
0.0390721373,
-0.0157220382,
-0.033298526,
-0.0402159281,
0.0305996686,
-0.0563934408,
-0.0045103012,
-0.023277903,
-0.0005408549,
0.0333205685,
0.0004164582,
0.0335482396,
-0.0674111396,
0.0332719795,
-0.0416222773,
0.0525162034,
-0.0572460033,
-0.0223831479,
0.0710028484,
0.0477423705,
0.0392788537,
-0.019066859,
-0.013187279,
0.0221778825,
0.0240169913,
0.012979473,
0.0144297592,
-0.0163923167,
0.000700496,
0.0119684404,
0.0352367163,
0.0486581288,
0.0144986678,
-0.0386757962,
-0.1059989184,
0.0460182913,
-0.027686879,
0.0385632031,
0.0219634939,
-0.0096892901,
-0.0576888435,
-0.0300168488,
-0.0459465943,
0.0418969058,
-0.0293230172,
-0.0177350752,
0.0495110676,
0.0094581479,
0.007098231,
0.0049147047,
0.0146499183,
-0.0535303913,
0.0081056925,
-0.0082300948,
0.010052029,
-0.0103622088,
-0.0286940075,
0.0482631251,
-0.0954710916,
0.0127845258,
-0.0263284724,
-0.0245905407,
0.0235749185,
0.0181732122,
-0.0060110637,
-0.0201701391,
-0.0680590197,
-0.0065037259,
0.0138856024,
-0.0339589305,
0.0114516681,
0.0293184016,
0.0451442599,
0.0297462456,
0.036805395,
0.0200914163,
0.0292187966,
-0.0231305957,
-0.0616381727,
-0.0568786003,
-0.0007905119,
-0.0106673818,
-0.0436374433,
0.0161174405,
-0.0196977556,
0.0436772034,
0.037949875,
-0.0274667162,
-0.0116004599,
-0.012121914,
2.726e-7,
0.1036047786,
0.0469560958,
-0.0237031206,
0.008771887,
0.0182065852,
-0.0055322996,
-0.0304194689,
-0.0100433836,
0.0081890663,
0.0127103049,
0.0265291594,
-0.0092386585,
0.0535259508,
0.0221631937,
-0.079822734,
0.0076442291,
-0.0673748553,
-0.0147885922,
-0.0356583223,
-0.0125910537,
0.0256291106,
0.0892763436,
-0.0458526723,
-0.0305451397,
-0.009964807,
-0.0212084595,
0.0651158541,
-0.0378532037,
-0.0226599835,
0.0553340428,
0.0326209851,
0.028931031,
0.0112294201,
0.061383523,
-0.0265669655,
-0.0005256071,
0.0539416336,
0.0957625583,
-0.0363762639,
0.0390629098,
0.0197546799,
-0.0092135528,
0.0036305578,
-0.0860957205,
0.0564864427,
-0.0114330314,
-0.0494933091,
-0.0019501281,
-0.0370285399,
-0.029910218,
0.0628381222,
-0.0146174347,
-0.0391258486,
0.0172630772,
0.0106762471,
0.0194808152,
-0.0150383692,
-0.0133545427,
-0.0241181664,
0.0191863831,
-0.0228794776,
-0.0830202401,
0.0320309512,
-0.0455831327,
-0.0364540145,
-0.0702464804,
-0.0026920342,
2.363897558e-34,
0.0266152564,
0.0169836916,
0.0145346429,
0.0371263511,
0.0163871963,
0.0029956403,
0.0182600543,
0.0011752573,
-0.0035679238,
-0.0505169556,
-0.0265740119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11925v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11925v2 | DocCGen: Document-based Controlled Code Generation | 2024-06-17T08:34:57 | 2024-07-03T09:16:27 | Sameer Pimparkhede, Mehant Kammakomati, Srikanth Tamilselvam, Prince Kumar, Ashok Pon Kumar, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent developments show that Large Language Models (LLMs) produce
state-of-the-art performance on natural language (NL) to code generation for
resource-rich general-purpose languages like C++, Java, and Python. However,
their practical usage for structured domain-specific languages (DSLs) such as
YAML, JSON is limited due to domain-specific schema, grammar, and
customizations generally unseen by LLMs during pre-training. Efforts have been
made to mitigate this challenge via in-context learning through relevant
examples or by fine-tuning. However, it suffers from problems, such as limited
DSL samples and prompt sensitivity but enterprises maintain good documentation
of the DSLs. Therefore, we propose DocCGen, a framework that can leverage such
rich knowledge by breaking the NL-to-Code generation task for structured code
languages into a two-step process. First, it detects the correct libraries
using the library documentation that best matches the NL query. Then, it
utilizes schema rules extracted from the documentation of these libraries to
constrain the decoding. We evaluate our framework for two complex structured
languages, Ansible YAML and Bash command, consisting of two settings:
Out-of-domain (OOD) and In-domain (ID). Our extensive experiments show that
DocCGen consistently improves different-sized language models across all six
evaluation metrics, reducing syntactic and semantic errors in structured code.
We plan to open-source the datasets and code to motivate research in
constrained code generation. | [
0.003239722,
0.0759943947,
-0.0244250111,
0.0211778544,
-0.0149609055,
-0.0016391787,
-0.0224615745,
-0.0087733027,
0.0005701142,
-0.0290398262,
-0.0084691672,
0.0053278059,
0.008253892,
0.0448045209,
0.0371525027,
-0.0229973625,
0.0360194556,
-0.040578559,
-0.0214394797,
0.015658604,
-0.0306405388,
0.0494380109,
0.0241379477,
0.029385129,
0.0327028409,
-0.0455302261,
0.005174573,
0.0518743731,
-0.0300564356,
-0.0362852588,
0.0602391623,
0.0226452686,
0.0251409709,
-0.0001153309,
0.0000023874,
-0.0607118271,
0.0016347286,
0.0008659226,
0.0210921317,
0.0290407129,
0.0260373969,
-0.0543858074,
0.0088337278,
0.0014980893,
-0.0248280112,
-0.0289482567,
0.0284264013,
-0.0489753298,
0.0758461207,
0.0768478587,
0.0061689503,
-0.0287740678,
-0.0181947108,
0.0077522313,
0.0204576142,
0.017869588,
-0.0177755542,
0.0467485078,
0.04858936,
-0.0079546124,
0.0200498663,
0.0094076786,
0.0032029129,
-0.0142015992,
0.0035995408,
0.0176683068,
-0.0346099958,
-0.0205068514,
0.000692194,
0.0427175015,
-0.0383744165,
-0.0217526536,
0.0384499468,
-0.0388347842,
-0.0166173447,
-0.0450451188,
-0.0150147388,
0.0539040603,
0.0045424164,
-0.0147851957,
0.0321039185,
-0.0322986469,
0.0046140258,
-0.0110795423,
-0.0013235975,
0.034886416,
0.0190635044,
0.0013040822,
-0.0451922677,
-0.0115224803,
-0.0046764305,
-0.0489789955,
-0.0326334834,
0.0299404133,
-0.0401443467,
-0.0047739516,
-0.067456238,
-0.0377139747,
0.0467838682,
-0.019804867,
0.0256533939,
0.0271914676,
-0.0025898318,
-0.0047590379,
-0.0191091988,
0.0765442103,
0.0010244319,
-0.0056013674,
-0.0238488037,
0.030294016,
-0.0495259911,
0.003849793,
-0.0498415232,
0.0209342148,
-0.0337635204,
0.0320664756,
-0.0232129283,
0.0508673787,
0.010240294,
0.0630342737,
-0.0190473255,
-0.0273581073,
-0.0406025127,
0.0158017911,
0.0287730265,
-0.0151179302,
0.0123394141,
-0.0563749447,
-0.0176433828,
-0.0413594022,
0.0044496506,
0.0393090285,
-0.0139101585,
-0.0205089338,
0.0147720715,
0.1111018136,
0.0220664553,
0.014036255,
-0.0288587492,
-0.056831453,
0.0506690964,
-0.0333751291,
0.0279047489,
-0.0802084431,
-0.0234660786,
0.0302248411,
-0.0232666358,
-0.0965725705,
-0.0056305085,
-0.0069770981,
0.0017324118,
0.0056249672,
-0.0400931761,
0.014294371,
0.0153691545,
0.0038989969,
-0.018477045,
0.0526541211,
0.0319919176,
0.0038071435,
0.0035572099,
-0.0383715928,
0.0377320126,
0.0246568583,
-0.0063948995,
-0.0045098197,
0.0007806352,
0.042955853,
0.0315450691,
0.0090475604,
0.0596357957,
0.0172854699,
-0.0054760124,
0.0415379107,
0.018791344,
0.0108719645,
-0.003397645,
-0.0125342831,
0.08019045,
0.0588950999,
-0.0098651731,
-0.0146263102,
-0.0416958742,
0.0445035473,
0.0091828154,
0.0253467951,
-0.0271864161,
0.0336522125,
0.0183165707,
-0.0539445356,
-0.0225425363,
-0.0127594322,
-0.0322583392,
-0.0183741469,
0.0061701271,
0.0212111156,
-0.0527345501,
0.0603544936,
0.0189487021,
-0.0515651405,
-0.002266702,
-0.008971421,
0.0296764541,
0.0525469594,
0.0856087953,
-0.0439702235,
-0.0354287811,
-0.0319159068,
0.0103550162,
0.0450230204,
0.0308507215,
-0.0168216527,
0.0350549743,
-0.0188351795,
0.0058485623,
-0.078222543,
0.0085653309,
0.0334530771,
0.0078888843,
-0.0389626138,
0.0332847312,
-0.0377340801,
-0.0631400272,
0.0461485386,
-0.0240848474,
-0.034437824,
0.0330150276,
-0.0134450095,
0.0046893861,
-0.0336614661,
-0.0455128774,
0.0173902567,
0.0143411336,
-0.0132197291,
-0.0120166782,
-0.0426780283,
-0.0480860285,
-0.0112118404,
0.013940719,
-0.030542925,
-0.042544771,
0.0092719076,
-0.0437291265,
-0.0139232613,
0.0769333765,
-0.0239623841,
-0.0015414837,
0.0277326368,
0.0128858397,
-0.0055210451,
0.0055755684,
-0.0122435298,
0.0420269258,
0.0176522024,
0.0070187068,
0.0073438729,
0.0330340788,
0.0197176114,
0.0277180932,
0.0037875033,
0.0036940284,
-0.033103399,
0.0394001789,
0.034913823,
0.0845789611,
-0.0007881542,
-0.0259307604,
-0.0104204277,
0.0224084277,
-0.0331426151,
0.014784079,
0.035077896,
0.0382642932,
-0.0081141181,
-0.0012637094,
-0.0222741533,
-0.0222316831,
0.0121884318,
0.0083540902,
0.0472617149,
-0.0064247265,
-0.0914118811,
-0.035032738,
0.0084659997,
-0.0164750386,
0.0374814048,
-0.0072525255,
0.0145451929,
-0.0676151514,
0.0623949505,
-0.0092186956,
0.0088281278,
-0.0053137923,
-0.022314053,
0.0009980702,
-0.0487702265,
0.0703988597,
0.034359511,
-0.0399255417,
-0.0515200123,
0.0741097331,
-0.008388862,
-0.0494466089,
-0.0059341048,
0.0146719301,
-0.0471985787,
0.0070685651,
-0.0239467211,
0.0595683232,
0.069292821,
-0.0089669228,
-0.0007825284,
-0.0306282975,
0.0129504018,
0.0060314555,
0.0080415821,
0.0145354988,
-0.0273124725,
0.0254525747,
0.0747145414,
0.0106347371,
-0.0849959925,
0.0512055196,
-0.0229241289,
-0.0246134996,
-0.0640331507,
-0.0195118561,
-0.073222734,
0.0793280303,
0.0289977305,
0.0220521521,
0.0278110784,
-0.0393192843,
-0.0350825824,
0.0174871944,
0.0133348219,
0.0069806315,
0.0391630828,
-0.0551189594,
0.0236343443,
-0.0254106335,
-0.0123697743,
-0.0249002762,
0.0138354572,
0.0026172157,
0.0129873827,
0.0587954745,
-0.0063899378,
0.0322861187,
-0.0366920307,
-0.0089116609,
0.058947593,
0.0564576909,
-0.028433647,
-0.0323375873,
-0.023424007,
-0.0306683257,
-0.0519505404,
-0.0473588817,
0.0040843529,
-0.0223491415,
0.002031171,
0.0271900147,
0.000443696,
-0.0563808978,
-0.0037458674,
0.0348563604,
-0.0239894632,
-0.0424780883,
0.0453368463,
0.0381110199,
-0.0617400855,
-0.0464914925,
0.0914048851,
0.0258141216,
-0.0219151657,
0.041115392,
-0.0339718089,
0.081620343,
0.0642745569,
0.0647317544,
-0.0768154711,
-0.0422073565,
-0.0151890507,
0.0539956838,
0.0127237532,
-0.0144878281,
-0.0516697727,
-0.0756806657,
0.0424340367,
0.0126924263,
-0.0032077634,
-0.0584207848,
-0.0333705023,
-0.0455638058,
0.0080661243,
-0.045012705,
0.0329040512,
-0.0171686597,
0.0223625116,
-0.0150184426,
-0.0369286686,
-0.0416240059,
0.0340333544,
-0.0305369142,
0.0332021825,
0.1100541353,
-0.0028751364,
0.0423141867,
-0.0065080491,
0.0381143019,
0.0234139469,
0.0023932678,
-0.014870096,
0.033129245,
0.0184041038,
-0.0253032967,
0.0171509143,
0.0518923625,
-0.0808299035,
-0.0252437852,
0.0277828779,
0.0509271435,
-0.0119521581,
-0.0280226246,
-0.0292238537,
-0.0075688059,
0.050509315,
0.0257673431,
0.0402078852,
-0.0011424001,
-0.0786619857,
-0.0705139413,
-0.0122157009,
-0.0502613485,
0.0378244445,
-0.0154066347,
0.0012326338,
0.002942295,
-0.0835320354,
0.0103583466,
0.0177998133,
0.0052460823,
0.0277465824,
-0.0161381122,
0.0068890466,
-0.0104423538,
-0.0567516163,
0.0097104302,
-0.0280550867,
0.0193938948,
-0.060591571,
-0.052415181,
0.0130240805,
-0.0195629802,
-0.0073311445,
0.0434778035,
-0.0714287981,
-0.0888907611,
-0.0065558376,
0.048112087,
0.017524872,
0.0472103357,
-0.0105037279,
-0.023041917,
-0.0034185958,
0.0545637012,
-0.1041784808,
0.0095329862,
0.0338134356,
0.0214394256,
0.0207442064,
0.0211040247,
-0.0848959535,
0.0022119603,
-0.0064878017,
-0.0034660229,
0.0123366667,
0.0107326536,
0.0426665545,
0.0328541398,
-0.0387455374,
0.0083211102,
-0.0025899573,
-0.016300492,
-0.0086101294,
-0.0109933261,
-0.0337293297,
-0.0426162183,
0.015413736,
-0.0176638681,
-0.0320643261,
0.0547490604,
0.033220686,
-0.0287564993,
0.0619038939,
0.0171322711,
0.0473394468,
-0.0012887843,
0.0384944268,
0.0703398138,
-0.0159283541,
-0.0279293545,
0.044510778,
-0.0534484088,
0.0563776903,
-0.035651207,
0.043358922,
0.0196130387,
0.0358500257,
0.0014996728,
-0.0108009866,
-0.0095767705,
-0.0536434054,
0.010991687,
-0.0238621719,
0.0362123214,
0.0241849851,
0.067321755,
-0.0669884533,
0.0343581066,
-0.0020742875,
0.0649146438,
-0.0158094559,
-0.0523296446,
-0.0034997577,
0.0139511824,
-0.0226785503,
-0.0483965725,
0.1110203713,
0.0478014126,
0.0130773271,
-0.0112124281,
-0.0032605981,
-0.0557574779,
-0.002135443,
0.0617942698,
-0.0179061089,
-0.0407819897,
0.0086676069,
-0.0504777506,
-0.0260276739,
-0.0180652589,
0.0324878246,
0.0109824901,
-0.0239800401,
0.0301761143,
0.0692271143,
0.0151097681,
-0.0230771918,
-0.0239751395,
0.0454988219,
-0.0363544971,
-0.0630168319,
-0.0453641415,
-5.938530971e-33,
-0.0286412556,
0.0018513126,
0.0158283599,
0.0260917377,
0.052127365,
0.0025818411,
-0.0621150248,
-0.0172755439,
0.0245249327,
-0.0371364579,
0.0553122163,
-0.013776077,
-0.0168810897,
-0.0041075433,
0.028788168,
0.0085508535,
0.0424649268,
0.0170260482,
-0.0569509119,
0.0511178523,
0.0062178681,
0.0093409438,
0.0141823879,
-0.0625417754,
-0.0325737409,
-0.0148925222,
0.0468677357,
-0.0198173057,
0.038198974,
0.0100910012,
-0.0085685486,
-0.0197531041,
-0.0094687026,
-0.0017418523,
-0.0598929152,
-0.0290687624,
-0.0218770225,
0.000705541,
0.0005258059,
0.0136409067,
-0.0267588571,
-0.0699465498,
0.048214037,
-0.0077367588,
-0.0023078152,
0.0040918491,
0.0055450057,
0.0379980542,
-0.0003688456,
-0.0653346702,
-0.0941978693,
0.0377955325,
-0.0446693897,
0.0009463422,
-0.0466419421,
0.0316430405,
0.015692614,
0.0511281192,
0.0010594728,
-0.0149258692,
0.008151006,
0.0503911525,
0.0847046003,
-0.0337327123,
-0.02466809,
0.0278026555,
-0.0036532211,
0.0428609662,
-0.0078596985,
0.0689312145,
0.001590476,
0.0390874557,
-0.0108813029,
0.0246094782,
0.0203044433,
-0.0233660843,
-0.0374125913,
0.0195093248,
-0.022815071,
0.0458673276,
0.0172065236,
0.0176013317,
-0.017461244,
-0.0074217655,
-0.0294947196,
0.0019205413,
-0.0125401169,
-0.0276655536,
0.0418920591,
-0.0221289452,
-0.0406646654,
-0.0544586256,
0.0124784401,
-0.000482081,
-0.0199546739,
0.0674335659,
-0.0763707086,
0.0244416501,
-0.0193443615,
0.0211355425,
0.0060300562,
-0.0347943306,
0.0314307883,
-0.02428798,
0.0793429464,
0.0360794477,
0.0240977388,
0.0390318744,
-0.0552365333,
0.0138057312,
-0.069567278,
0.0281839184,
-0.0367438793,
0.0176213291,
0.0004286313,
-0.0263929684,
0.0086880811,
0.015483343,
0.0085710334,
-0.0673413128,
-0.0411565267,
-0.0248168688,
0.0412188806,
0.0319546461,
-0.0469695404,
-0.0285711121,
-0.0587401688,
0.0078268889,
0.0626770556,
0.0009510102,
-0.0356198922,
0.0060702437,
3.155e-7,
0.0113171861,
0.0510444641,
-0.0068304664,
0.0703509971,
-0.0009397352,
0.0400559492,
-0.0087468699,
0.0278598405,
-0.0218493436,
-0.0242843106,
-0.0532018431,
-0.0306852479,
0.0266074184,
0.0361813642,
-0.0594943799,
0.0160446223,
0.0471264943,
0.020334417,
-0.090475291,
-0.0263158362,
0.0213345941,
0.0410982445,
-0.0210915823,
-0.021461552,
-0.0026928775,
-0.04603903,
-0.0100289863,
-0.0040489947,
0.0256914049,
0.0346232392,
-0.0195592549,
0.0262670051,
0.0033943506,
-0.0147691481,
-0.0266787186,
-0.0142778903,
-0.0138878189,
0.0557441376,
0.0284168869,
0.0578894839,
0.0319307931,
-0.0415215865,
-0.0153190624,
-0.0577887632,
0.0296186637,
-0.0329749212,
-0.0194516927,
-0.0214617327,
-0.0431376211,
0.0275387745,
-0.0478260368,
-0.0219438579,
-0.0093461582,
0.0110374661,
-0.009557222,
-0.043938566,
-0.0320644267,
0.0091161756,
-0.043068517,
0.0136957234,
-0.0020131064,
-0.0219131615,
-0.0515952036,
0.0654812679,
0.0129532414,
-0.0166529715,
0.0142427962,
3.48209161e-34,
0.0186839942,
-0.038648691,
0.0077699125,
0.0149937654,
0.0527916402,
-0.0208492987,
-0.0256942324,
0.0345743001,
0.0110431453,
-0.0025921345,
-0.0210531894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11317v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11317v1 | GUICourse: From General Vision Language Models to Versatile GUI Agents | 2024-06-17T08:30:55 | 2024-06-17T08:30:55 | Wentong Chen, Junbo Cui, Jinyi Hu, Yujia Qin, Junjie Fang, Yue Zhao, Chongyi Wang, Jun Liu, Guirong Chen, Yupeng Huo, Yuan Yao, Yankai Lin, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.HC | Utilizing Graphic User Interface (GUI) for human-computer interaction is
essential for accessing a wide range of digital tools. Recent advancements in
Vision Language Models (VLMs) highlight the compelling potential to develop
versatile agents to help humans finish GUI navigation tasks. However, current
VLMs are challenged in terms of fundamental abilities (OCR and grounding) and
GUI knowledge (the functions and control methods of GUI elements), preventing
them from becoming practical GUI agents. To solve these challenges, we
contribute GUICourse, a suite of datasets to train visual-based GUI agents from
general VLMs. First, we introduce the GUIEnv dataset to strengthen the OCR and
grounding capabilities of VLMs. Then, we introduce the GUIAct and GUIChat
datasets to enrich their knowledge of GUI components and interactions.
Experiments demonstrate that our GUI agents have better performance on common
GUI tasks than their baseline VLMs. Even the small-size GUI agent (with 3.1B
parameters) can still work well on single-step and multi-step GUI tasks.
Finally, we analyze the different varieties in the training stage of this agent
by ablation study. Our source codes and datasets are released at
https://github.com/yiye3/GUICourse. | [
0.003595111,
0.0188964047,
-0.0142895626,
0.0499547794,
-0.0230654422,
0.0287545621,
0.0231830217,
0.0186909214,
0.0437886268,
-0.0357020088,
-0.0513520613,
0.0035614406,
0.0195105877,
0.0164007731,
-0.0083405441,
-0.0705694184,
0.0196811892,
-0.0437217243,
-0.057711456,
0.0118820574,
-0.0157121569,
0.0022289276,
-0.0472173057,
0.063788034,
0.0053015319,
-0.0258685295,
-0.049654033,
0.0313468985,
0.0209417883,
-0.0030889248,
-0.0162135772,
0.0243962239,
0.0284705479,
0.0323682763,
0.0000020224,
-0.0047285398,
0.0462622866,
-0.0057232096,
-0.0063004708,
-0.0063763619,
0.0459642559,
-0.0142599689,
-0.002957457,
0.0145153273,
-0.0417256989,
-0.0288771857,
0.0362475738,
0.0590875559,
0.0654100999,
0.0287377257,
0.0001570187,
0.0099493098,
0.0376087017,
0.0091449749,
0.0269993953,
-0.0649966896,
0.0263042189,
0.0071435771,
0.0204397067,
-0.0360791571,
-0.0164927822,
0.0023548254,
0.0384483449,
-0.0050783372,
-0.0441478416,
0.0427076817,
-0.0475201309,
-0.0546922162,
-0.0536304414,
0.0597748756,
-0.0226446036,
0.0057210228,
0.0111586526,
0.0226802081,
0.0287650693,
-0.0107592577,
-0.0456290953,
-0.0112766661,
-0.0454407372,
-0.0274750479,
-0.0520014539,
-0.0204014704,
-0.0086943191,
-0.0146304416,
-0.010258236,
-0.0114261741,
-0.003038744,
-0.0038682716,
0.0083496952,
-0.0238524787,
-0.0398666747,
-0.0204512365,
0.019108152,
0.0445602387,
-0.0229970627,
0.022508854,
-0.0628831759,
0.0133813675,
-0.0163332019,
-0.071956791,
0.0305431169,
0.0111523578,
-0.037882708,
0.0477822907,
-0.0287791081,
0.1054178402,
-0.0133310985,
0.0646466389,
-0.0228582192,
-0.0010180392,
-0.069804877,
-0.0085000601,
-0.0464237891,
-0.0059236069,
-0.0076574152,
-0.0129024461,
-0.0320756733,
0.0284886807,
0.0031974309,
0.0109558096,
0.0226798784,
0.0164338071,
-0.0228182916,
-0.0080209356,
-0.0182846431,
0.0102784969,
-0.0023748383,
0.0299878381,
0.0158992261,
-0.0487415828,
0.0107097831,
0.0079166899,
0.0273485649,
-0.0219549797,
-0.0179974623,
0.0747786164,
-0.0149485674,
-0.0152335456,
-0.0544158183,
0.0179803688,
0.0135490792,
-0.0040459018,
-0.0007992421,
-0.0498239435,
0.0156847965,
-0.0049805925,
0.0094091967,
-0.0416567884,
0.0335954838,
0.0504894815,
0.0157048088,
0.0707351491,
-0.0159340911,
-0.0082231164,
0.0369765684,
-0.0186719112,
-0.0321015157,
0.045116812,
0.0376712196,
0.085883379,
0.0082497373,
-0.0282043424,
0.0511021428,
0.0564593114,
-0.0361090861,
-0.0175268725,
-0.0064896555,
0.0113608427,
0.0243926663,
0.0012139177,
-0.0128924018,
0.0427629501,
-0.0613661222,
-0.027295744,
0.0726861134,
0.0773348808,
0.013784145,
-0.0276219901,
0.001068531,
-0.0000250062,
0.0181049574,
-0.0179118048,
-0.0604656115,
0.0380490124,
-0.0217310507,
-0.0139926318,
-0.0718843117,
0.0168617852,
-0.0428978056,
-0.0702983662,
-0.0258641988,
-0.0071328292,
0.0288498532,
-0.0466101877,
0.0769259408,
0.0228363033,
-0.0551290959,
-0.0552877486,
0.0180407576,
-0.0837136135,
-0.0421498418,
-0.0625712499,
-0.0265233107,
0.0503730103,
0.042459745,
0.0136377281,
-0.0281409882,
-0.0197091289,
0.053926412,
0.0236033369,
0.0185401496,
-0.0233529434,
0.0179474577,
-0.0367193297,
-0.0431914143,
0.0207695141,
-0.021945063,
0.0504937209,
0.0112068783,
-0.0370857418,
-0.0135881752,
-0.0550251119,
-0.0127902459,
0.0618490092,
0.0188711807,
-0.0576814339,
-0.0328760929,
0.0143223368,
0.0150702717,
-0.0129301632,
-0.0200983621,
-0.0332932696,
0.0353417471,
-0.0040173652,
0.0399722904,
0.0043282853,
0.0003446904,
-0.016545536,
0.0600149222,
0.0083223628,
-0.0020798529,
0.0419135727,
-0.013489305,
0.0041882694,
-0.0213434119,
0.0092979828,
0.0246296972,
-0.0239993893,
0.0227717776,
-0.0017283825,
-0.0356812626,
-0.0040680808,
0.0577267073,
-0.0245892201,
-0.0238617547,
0.0229966268,
0.0150247477,
0.0266836751,
-0.0745060667,
0.0156527907,
-0.0165885426,
-0.0312403385,
0.0384190828,
-0.0030597076,
0.0405380689,
-0.0079615908,
-0.0034899951,
-0.0867780745,
-0.0318157822,
-0.0446092784,
-0.0166402142,
0.0034934159,
-0.0137391826,
-0.0183898415,
-0.0344656371,
0.019680487,
0.0472353511,
-0.0330361128,
-0.0151300896,
0.0119279604,
-0.0038124642,
-0.019794751,
-0.0429784544,
-0.014911226,
-0.0106494809,
-0.0059552561,
0.0075610983,
-0.021747265,
-0.0210568868,
0.0482446589,
0.0161022861,
0.0636197105,
-0.0537005365,
-0.0356874317,
0.0063774115,
-0.0063671195,
-0.0267348588,
0.1192886978,
-0.0073013748,
0.055375278,
0.0221755877,
-0.0155272586,
-0.0134522915,
0.0271504223,
-0.0120963184,
-0.0406499356,
-0.0732518137,
0.0362269022,
0.0141169,
0.0693291649,
-0.0314521194,
0.0404504389,
-0.0709514171,
0.0231482312,
-0.0132442797,
-0.0588319786,
-0.0477760956,
0.027584346,
-0.032023482,
0.0043798415,
-0.0674072653,
-0.0535108857,
0.0218158513,
-0.0597653426,
-0.0187546294,
0.0347227529,
-0.0035474282,
0.0002117778,
0.0751568004,
0.0444727577,
-0.0216732733,
0.0200186353,
-0.0243183244,
-0.0373289622,
0.0200900063,
0.0048998981,
-0.016066961,
0.0183540434,
-0.0809882209,
0.0421217307,
-0.0347569287,
-0.0366966315,
-0.0375424176,
0.0653746426,
0.0131399836,
-0.0174466874,
-0.0485136099,
-0.0036640544,
-0.0623311214,
0.0658676252,
0.026401151,
0.0453830846,
-0.019383695,
-0.0196921322,
-0.0292463694,
0.0046449704,
0.0496694967,
0.007786029,
-0.0671497658,
-0.0530434139,
0.0320035443,
0.0458520502,
0.0325978026,
-0.0474298485,
-0.0257923417,
0.0271997824,
0.0239875484,
0.0123123191,
0.0112061175,
0.0274389181,
0.0306523591,
-0.0504431911,
-0.0028463472,
0.0625287816,
0.0312357582,
-0.038382329,
-0.0206142496,
-0.0196935069,
0.0063129356,
0.0317947082,
0.0273523424,
-0.0478290841,
-0.0486674011,
-0.0044577084,
0.0285406131,
0.0576037839,
0.0111093717,
0.0251362883,
-0.0678699538,
0.0543020144,
0.0189454909,
-0.0201559216,
-0.0418827683,
-0.0080666821,
0.0214123297,
-0.0652601272,
-0.0002213585,
0.0579967648,
-0.0177512486,
-0.0120553132,
0.0207827371,
0.0086170435,
-0.0110304505,
0.025038749,
-0.0109955668,
-0.0336135291,
0.078696914,
0.0150675084,
0.022025425,
-0.0392664373,
0.0133652426,
0.02126652,
0.0046747955,
-0.0209561344,
0.0472540334,
-0.01615013,
-0.0247375183,
0.0099482154,
0.0580630228,
-0.0595847704,
-0.0283467975,
0.0225844011,
-0.0050533814,
-0.0108109675,
0.0082639232,
-0.021661222,
-0.0753296092,
-0.0198189616,
0.0116123771,
-0.0218008887,
-0.0168775152,
-0.0678338334,
-0.0533893406,
-0.0240530837,
-0.0271344129,
-0.066067718,
0.0002236398,
0.0010549567,
-0.0512360893,
-0.0634321794,
-0.0674664602,
0.0652380958,
0.0852944776,
-0.0172586255,
-0.0426394194,
0.0004288273,
0.0611234121,
-0.0359729789,
0.0352067277,
-0.0295812096,
0.024319103,
-0.059628956,
-0.0072135176,
0.0001980724,
-0.0431817397,
-0.0211626738,
0.0239638314,
-0.0452705361,
-0.0391935296,
-0.0169257522,
0.0908067524,
0.0239644386,
0.0400729887,
-0.014987818,
-0.0135226306,
0.0297386404,
0.0275744498,
0.0305249766,
0.0106421057,
0.0026851054,
-0.0074172709,
-0.0056214738,
0.0023213897,
-0.0567776076,
-0.0023195401,
-0.01036877,
0.0236464292,
-0.049494464,
-0.0030034494,
0.0323556997,
-0.0263728928,
0.0339343548,
0.0270106588,
0.0435668081,
-0.0177250747,
0.0533064008,
0.0077356212,
0.0082913106,
-0.0701683313,
0.0198747572,
0.003424701,
0.0415562019,
0.0618777387,
-0.0507932492,
0.0111143952,
0.0047279568,
-0.0825345367,
-0.0077872449,
-0.002860507,
0.0216754191,
0.0072542704,
0.0378665738,
0.0000332398,
0.0249240734,
-0.0030360592,
0.0752150863,
0.0050046928,
0.0651675612,
0.0202391818,
0.0009776077,
-0.0070904614,
0.0343429409,
-0.0439626612,
-0.0004782651,
-0.0471750535,
0.0427935272,
0.0562591664,
0.0317956731,
0.031545829,
-0.0353982784,
0.0079443259,
-0.0472022705,
0.0111904703,
0.0519963093,
-0.0344828777,
0.0108628236,
0.0332113914,
0.017913077,
-0.0747631341,
0.0785846338,
0.0353949592,
0.0412849709,
0.0001051055,
-0.0040472723,
-0.0576842129,
-0.0458130315,
0.0537071861,
-0.0034556498,
-0.0074894424,
-0.009545234,
-0.0225148723,
-0.0270252582,
0.0003210108,
0.0370922908,
0.0207268465,
-0.0366849303,
0.0434251875,
0.0367229655,
0.0082035121,
-0.0406787209,
-0.0149999047,
-0.0532857515,
-0.0304646883,
0.0065117124,
-0.023916347,
-4.874800419e-33,
-0.0415925309,
0.0053063319,
0.0688652173,
0.0452254415,
0.0242062882,
-0.0225129034,
0.020727329,
0.0196014997,
-0.0319732428,
-0.0106779383,
0.007002546,
0.0020830524,
0.0242678169,
0.0274492037,
-0.0376306288,
0.0164243188,
0.026733093,
-0.0059390366,
-0.0249625314,
-0.0168259814,
-0.0257965568,
0.0166295357,
0.0112204421,
-0.0598887242,
-0.0217234325,
-0.0029876439,
0.001263164,
-0.0137669174,
0.0017127134,
0.0590178147,
-0.0082146591,
0.0346019752,
0.0156697985,
0.0494977199,
-0.0095502483,
0.0160354506,
-0.0654246956,
0.0076749758,
-0.0345688313,
0.0946292728,
-0.0260673426,
0.0026769829,
0.0167525597,
-0.0014920036,
-0.0257064588,
-0.0090786647,
0.0597668551,
-0.0334164426,
-0.0453127325,
0.0420868099,
-0.0470559783,
0.0123286163,
0.0230051596,
-0.0839189738,
0.0425645523,
0.0350059941,
-0.0121154506,
-0.0169442128,
-0.0445767269,
0.0248663351,
0.0305145178,
0.0406440757,
0.0851179138,
0.0624823943,
0.0524859503,
0.033330705,
0.0078788372,
-0.0064136363,
-0.0438512638,
0.0278341863,
0.0291989297,
0.0739068538,
0.0382839665,
0.0441834591,
0.0120465271,
-0.0057893754,
-0.0337617733,
0.0613772497,
-0.0168924313,
0.1025713682,
-0.012835036,
0.0460214764,
-0.0073418035,
0.0240851026,
-0.0106921475,
-0.0154687464,
0.0012354779,
-0.0175265912,
0.0748319924,
0.0384465195,
0.0099266879,
-0.0883131772,
0.0387454778,
-0.0100731729,
-0.0339581519,
-0.0052820868,
-0.0111323018,
0.0664440617,
-0.0114421016,
-0.0042234873,
-0.0438835882,
-0.0390205532,
0.0386765674,
0.0102854017,
0.046553269,
-0.0115602817,
-0.0159265213,
0.0355835818,
-0.0126669267,
-0.0088541275,
-0.048617661,
-0.0099356258,
0.0222774837,
0.0703543201,
0.0360688791,
-0.0273861252,
-0.0221792068,
0.0516981445,
-0.0496937707,
-0.0870457515,
-0.0258529428,
-0.0634950027,
-0.0178679563,
0.0026686089,
-0.0379711874,
-0.0417072065,
-0.0639882386,
0.056073036,
0.0059446306,
-0.0308499318,
0.0121573759,
0.0234378651,
2.655e-7,
-0.0059589143,
0.0133033423,
0.0400790051,
0.0465290137,
-0.0229920652,
0.0504666232,
-0.0260135606,
0.0436609611,
-0.0102944504,
-0.0685603097,
0.0154840117,
0.0537072234,
0.0412004627,
-0.0110917902,
-0.0314608775,
0.0192466397,
0.0229806527,
-0.0018578959,
-0.0556427911,
0.0057375203,
0.0426643044,
0.058282271,
-0.0264194831,
-0.0031513621,
0.0648495927,
-0.0463994816,
0.0363916866,
-0.0161479861,
0.0336666815,
-0.0247496367,
-0.0102305729,
0.0497264192,
-0.0315908641,
0.0035970574,
0.0127861891,
0.0161675736,
0.0127427615,
0.0275471732,
-0.0838430747,
-0.0073472513,
0.0047351909,
-0.0077048242,
-0.0185288154,
-0.0176179763,
0.0679446235,
-0.043288108,
0.0222341567,
0.0120456945,
-0.0053805872,
0.0190551709,
-0.0317614153,
-0.0148328124,
-0.0177310742,
0.0054907692,
0.0197492521,
-0.0018809673,
-0.0527173132,
-0.0507115498,
0.0016845304,
-0.022939343,
-0.0125355907,
-0.0401948951,
-0.066137068,
0.0304883644,
-0.0138549572,
0.0280089397,
-0.0508838892,
2.154109699e-34,
-0.0113334907,
-0.0098700179,
0.0138172219,
0.0455143116,
0.0325874314,
-0.0085188346,
0.0115902405,
0.0305440407,
0.0031826745,
-0.0284393262,
-0.0140257841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11307v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11307v1 | An Empirical Investigation of Matrix Factorization Methods for Pre-trained Transformers | 2024-06-17T08:14:23 | 2024-06-17T08:14:23 | Ashim Gupta, Sina Mahdipour Saravani, P. Sadayappan, Vivek Srikumar | cs.CL | cs.CL | The increasing size of transformer-based models in NLP makes the question of
compressing them important. In this work, we present a comprehensive analysis
of factorization based model compression techniques. Specifically, we focus on
comparing straightforward low-rank factorization against the recently
introduced Monarch factorization, which exhibits impressive performance
preservation on the GLUE benchmark. To mitigate stability issues associated
with low-rank factorization of the matrices in pre-trained transformers, we
introduce a staged factorization approach wherein layers are factorized one by
one instead of being factorized simultaneously. Through this strategy we
significantly enhance the stability and reliability of the compression process.
Further, we introduce a simple block-wise low-rank factorization method, which
has a close relationship to Monarch factorization. Our experiments lead to the
surprising conclusion that straightforward low-rank factorization consistently
outperforms Monarch factorization across both different compression ratios and
six different text classification tasks. | [
-0.0177969057,
0.0843053535,
0.0053599952,
0.0236176662,
0.0167542361,
0.0071059465,
0.0117120417,
0.0421029665,
-0.0391495042,
-0.0276303478,
-0.0348048136,
-0.0060345726,
-0.0011105124,
0.0050635808,
-0.0158181898,
-0.0199365113,
0.0317815989,
0.0122318622,
-0.0687066019,
0.0322899483,
-0.0067915823,
0.0020866389,
0.0272196308,
0.0482078046,
-0.0178054124,
-0.0219121296,
-0.0253568832,
-0.013996141,
-0.0073715989,
0.0110966535,
-0.0352846049,
0.0726003423,
0.0249995608,
0.0152795669,
0.0000020342,
-0.0038740048,
-0.0297481976,
0.012003962,
-0.041289594,
0.0625050664,
0.0257536322,
-0.0169288367,
0.0258333087,
0.0171232074,
-0.044068817,
-0.0831390172,
0.0316274539,
0.110907048,
0.083421573,
0.0219405089,
-0.0203399081,
-0.0153079731,
0.0150729772,
-0.0196819138,
-0.0553718507,
-0.040945936,
0.0244917981,
-0.0406396128,
-0.0579741187,
0.013858431,
-0.0266870409,
0.0133535946,
0.0167514067,
0.0253263693,
0.0216367468,
0.0299724955,
-0.0164925307,
-0.0301400684,
0.0017757403,
0.071615763,
-0.0331337266,
-0.039217338,
-0.0330351181,
0.0061877756,
0.0078535397,
0.0252393018,
-0.0227595158,
0.042225752,
0.0529569648,
0.0199864637,
0.0092628039,
0.0499757417,
0.0301938932,
-0.0201704819,
-0.031606283,
0.0574580319,
0.0182679147,
-0.0190450996,
0.0104131037,
0.0326884054,
0.019088475,
-0.0367487445,
0.0029302221,
0.0138384476,
-0.0011989877,
-0.016372446,
-0.0469136313,
-0.0136689199,
0.0027464021,
-0.0622651055,
0.0335845537,
0.0204959624,
0.0234985985,
0.018396588,
-0.0214032698,
0.0171587933,
-0.0111537641,
0.0345174633,
-0.0280799195,
0.0232451279,
-0.0200557895,
0.0084745875,
-0.0548145473,
0.0579999685,
-0.0217180941,
-0.0293492433,
-0.0334786437,
0.0028913119,
0.0245710071,
-0.0148940589,
0.0286828559,
0.0186360851,
0.0021636866,
0.0107781803,
0.0020316744,
0.0448672809,
-0.0177266113,
0.0152472183,
-0.0423266739,
-0.0155308563,
-0.0332009196,
0.0013586609,
0.0269616172,
-0.0102679562,
0.0197643694,
-0.0176820178,
-0.0123012541,
-0.0649682879,
-0.02565993,
0.0206945017,
0.0254865289,
-0.0417252593,
-0.0120820124,
-0.0140770683,
0.0537515767,
-0.0131902918,
0.0192874912,
-0.0151583971,
-0.0101337498,
0.0370156728,
-0.0327321291,
0.0581405051,
0.0080951778,
-0.0125051169,
-0.0256486516,
0.0309338197,
0.0294663999,
0.0240281224,
-0.0122298747,
0.0240369514,
0.0152910715,
-0.086675927,
0.0316396095,
0.0218033716,
0.0435929559,
-0.0044854889,
0.0102764443,
-0.0120888725,
-0.0082195206,
-0.0207137894,
0.0094497427,
0.0730551183,
-0.0443163216,
0.004318689,
0.03676318,
0.0405491069,
0.0368872583,
0.1335328221,
0.0097945454,
-0.0062026582,
0.0244450606,
0.0175588634,
-0.0294070821,
0.0102040479,
-0.0327184759,
-0.025003599,
-0.0212965291,
0.0709440112,
-0.0562940277,
-0.0423858464,
0.0106134769,
-0.028708607,
0.0214928668,
-0.0126193305,
0.0240493473,
0.0179755818,
-0.0388030894,
0.0973817259,
0.0019458286,
-0.0954141393,
0.0025960349,
-0.043174684,
-0.0319328308,
-0.0135103306,
0.0452030897,
0.0042989636,
-0.008319471,
-0.0181827135,
-0.0141455578,
-0.0342002213,
0.0286907963,
-0.0171269085,
0.0200090092,
-0.0388996899,
-0.008693194,
0.02872614,
0.0236777682,
-0.0344176479,
0.0079741217,
-0.0121234134,
0.0154550252,
0.0087622683,
0.0127808889,
0.0472337678,
-0.0149504058,
-0.0275517609,
0.0462628007,
-0.0003615102,
0.0171417221,
0.0193577819,
-0.0163048394,
-0.0332511179,
0.071152851,
-0.0337855592,
-0.0423892066,
-0.043065507,
-0.0414894037,
-0.0181968305,
0.0291909855,
-0.0140897688,
0.0413474925,
0.1030967757,
-0.0347079113,
-0.0230108798,
-0.0160317943,
-0.0022360638,
0.0429878533,
-0.0111654121,
0.029281646,
-0.0296418685,
0.0473833792,
-0.0120249121,
0.0446964763,
-0.0174318235,
0.0024959024,
0.0216200035,
-0.0591401272,
0.009955789,
0.0309293196,
-0.0534400865,
0.0051983492,
-0.038634941,
0.0313060768,
0.0245605279,
-0.017592933,
-0.0057138545,
0.0014096488,
-0.048120711,
0.0214444455,
-0.0235003456,
-0.0042661964,
0.0317319483,
0.0227013156,
0.0466832109,
-0.0002301353,
-0.0261949562,
-0.0220852233,
-0.0068305256,
0.0097786915,
-0.0192305762,
-0.0145044522,
0.0064216368,
-0.008895197,
-0.0696884915,
0.0201068316,
0.1023769975,
-0.0492716059,
-0.0092274789,
-0.0541069433,
0.0412887745,
-0.0114812041,
0.0084866211,
-0.006829924,
-0.0383699127,
-0.0338541903,
-0.0102931224,
0.0644261241,
0.0391585752,
0.021360347,
0.0734118447,
0.0762785599,
0.0426355936,
-0.0137929898,
0.002929575,
-0.0532150082,
-0.0093074441,
-0.0271886792,
-0.0049254908,
0.0229954422,
0.0610780604,
-0.0373652615,
-0.0109383762,
-0.0439200327,
-0.0199015643,
-0.0345341638,
-0.0096217217,
-0.0107084746,
-0.0235023145,
-0.0089226021,
-0.0018978976,
0.0329301655,
-0.009687556,
0.0376575105,
-0.036747314,
-0.0069807018,
-0.0118649323,
-0.0435284115,
-0.0316761881,
0.0189241096,
-0.0105229188,
0.0056171059,
-0.0538222045,
0.0004050967,
-0.0149152791,
0.0146517809,
-0.0041350508,
-0.0400687978,
0.0410562567,
0.0482339188,
-0.0154025909,
-0.0529344454,
-0.0481399074,
-0.03298188,
-0.0602294952,
-0.0093621695,
0.0139087681,
0.06278833,
-0.0129375868,
-0.0613636784,
0.0114857731,
-0.0020579824,
0.0289348755,
-0.0040181656,
0.0005992,
0.0091957506,
0.0692814291,
0.0111866593,
0.0237047412,
0.0659242794,
0.00100483,
0.0485384054,
0.0630806312,
0.0035234836,
-0.0194150768,
-0.0412314162,
-0.0204488542,
0.0484464839,
-0.0379995778,
-0.0371478982,
0.0170278661,
-0.0338845029,
-0.0297258254,
0.0068556922,
0.0989699587,
0.0337155201,
-0.0916795805,
0.007116945,
0.0292625371,
0.0557652712,
0.0079019833,
0.0306168571,
-0.0255204346,
-0.0020796061,
0.0130891232,
-0.0299893748,
0.0674078614,
-0.0239102207,
0.000905556,
-0.0793744326,
0.0410320684,
-0.0020616914,
0.0392157435,
-0.0030599469,
-0.0653352439,
0.0025157898,
-0.0471205972,
-0.0112568745,
-0.0024395054,
-0.0318210199,
-0.0039664949,
0.0088091716,
-0.0308812149,
-0.0419678465,
-0.0132742329,
-0.0096880365,
0.0080481637,
-0.0222839545,
0.0074659535,
-0.0094413422,
-0.0836839452,
0.0207195897,
-0.0317288972,
-0.0245886948,
-0.0330039859,
0.0648829713,
-0.0087002488,
0.0087601515,
-0.0124756498,
0.0168944765,
-0.0162911844,
-0.0321278386,
-0.0451606959,
0.0968868732,
0.0029950142,
-0.0613535047,
-0.0032516397,
-0.0083395634,
-0.047290422,
0.0798091888,
0.0261135511,
-0.0389835164,
-0.0498335697,
0.0201974735,
0.0281732399,
-0.0091297403,
-0.1222129911,
0.036955893,
0.0261437334,
-0.0262060817,
-0.0289230254,
-0.0043502715,
0.0112737035,
0.0398719832,
-0.0200443882,
-0.0422186852,
-0.0005631267,
0.0188942701,
-0.0445193909,
0.0120791765,
0.0009839089,
-0.0012648101,
-0.0379213281,
0.0413137339,
0.0426066779,
-0.0096713379,
-0.0097888866,
-0.0219791196,
-0.0656314269,
0.0029590803,
0.0206258316,
0.0424914509,
0.0151230469,
0.0155463349,
0.0129905175,
-0.0663049743,
0.0191968661,
0.0253963284,
-0.050203912,
0.0299725235,
0.0234446004,
-0.0943764448,
-0.0075290943,
0.0142807029,
-0.0191105045,
0.0404407494,
-0.0180850569,
0.032545615,
-0.0174639821,
-0.0292125866,
0.0235930476,
-0.0069778292,
0.0671041682,
-0.008415428,
0.0236786995,
0.011507757,
0.0238998476,
-0.0196877737,
-0.0009733905,
-0.0356650427,
0.0144945327,
0.0353932492,
0.0183951743,
-0.0192242749,
0.0291106161,
0.0276959594,
0.0179714747,
0.0099205123,
-0.0129213836,
0.0001306683,
-0.0554173142,
0.0376918651,
0.0396193117,
-0.0269034132,
-0.0476601422,
0.0331767835,
0.0012836694,
-0.0389904007,
-0.0116443411,
-0.0022671467,
0.0366034843,
-0.0687058717,
0.0428199172,
-0.0531545579,
-0.0417351723,
-0.0282762591,
-0.0368650295,
0.02928227,
-0.0286516268,
0.0374667048,
-0.0053761043,
-0.0330204628,
0.0000121858,
0.0028260241,
0.0143967401,
-0.0207709596,
0.0147767775,
-0.0238530636,
-0.0238858461,
0.0112728253,
0.0917248949,
-0.0075799567,
0.0078250002,
-0.0039416761,
-0.0190778673,
-0.0491065904,
-0.0231155846,
-0.022633994,
0.0409499109,
-0.0083836773,
-0.0370039269,
-0.0512055494,
-0.0546348691,
0.018762935,
-0.0182638559,
0.0036843943,
-0.0188909639,
0.0111866081,
0.0244560763,
0.0387763493,
0.0013659778,
-0.0102106556,
-0.0335366838,
-0.0121504609,
-0.0196879432,
-0.0002751934,
-6.003193446e-33,
0.0107283872,
0.0107274316,
0.0109266797,
0.0319861136,
-0.015062023,
0.0365467072,
0.014299714,
0.0030301877,
-0.0095577594,
0.0059591229,
-0.0547949784,
0.0035155329,
-0.0066671674,
0.0281994231,
-0.0127637703,
-0.0139207263,
0.0889323726,
-0.019138258,
-0.0162057057,
0.0573107712,
-0.0203549992,
0.0281331856,
0.0311639477,
-0.0463711843,
-0.0678158849,
-0.0085756527,
-0.0073786927,
-0.0186779555,
0.0175471026,
0.0316017792,
-0.0585175566,
0.0085172821,
0.0411682874,
-0.0771893114,
0.0008548864,
0.0284630395,
-0.1002231091,
-0.0005628115,
-0.00273672,
0.0133407954,
-0.0530136526,
-0.0133606391,
0.009438877,
0.035633605,
-0.0128524303,
-0.0577290319,
0.014891603,
0.0147241158,
-0.043998912,
-0.1006599069,
-0.0180254485,
0.0033479442,
-0.0166803449,
-0.0105276005,
0.0663557649,
0.0726118758,
-0.0343102515,
0.0462802574,
-0.0902313292,
0.0129925041,
0.0198647212,
0.0419911444,
0.0304820631,
-0.0095600849,
-0.029388871,
0.0228487831,
-0.0150082959,
0.0022370124,
-0.0594985858,
0.0104511715,
0.0382919908,
0.0631408244,
0.0629845783,
0.0368577167,
0.0501235127,
-0.00295603,
-0.0658801273,
0.0290044602,
-0.0103737377,
-0.0072266785,
0.0028519828,
0.012109438,
0.0236454625,
-0.0085179638,
-0.049493812,
0.0281769596,
-0.0225628372,
-0.0270995442,
-0.0002345655,
0.0554185882,
-0.0460919663,
0.0206190888,
0.0469283015,
-0.053992141,
-0.0101773879,
0.054606922,
-0.0228256788,
0.038096711,
0.0081706708,
-0.0317233205,
-0.0420283303,
0.0150270453,
0.0226790346,
-0.0308390316,
0.006259793,
-0.013162367,
0.042341508,
0.043735303,
-0.0761238113,
-0.0186488796,
0.0255956631,
-0.006145535,
0.0432348326,
0.0308003891,
0.0327423066,
0.0247166157,
0.0017451289,
0.047072012,
0.0182932671,
0.0811468363,
-0.0018604986,
0.0188854877,
0.0690517575,
0.0145888599,
0.0347994305,
-0.0080967089,
-0.0730032697,
0.0344671868,
0.0462825336,
-0.0920296833,
-0.0260980465,
-0.0163384154,
2.634e-7,
0.0451722629,
0.0580149479,
-0.0212868825,
-0.0428077616,
0.0191090032,
0.0262853354,
0.0376638733,
0.0134579297,
-0.0075488971,
0.0261788331,
0.0451391675,
-0.0060486277,
0.0070744725,
0.0154501228,
-0.0566034913,
-0.0304447059,
-0.1002668366,
-0.0003201812,
-0.0500637069,
-0.0336234979,
0.0466288999,
0.1318116188,
0.0020484196,
-0.0256615579,
-0.0087966919,
0.0189832859,
0.066586785,
-0.0311599802,
-0.0060988409,
0.0263025295,
0.0414684825,
-0.017348364,
-0.0122738844,
-0.0118922619,
-0.0484050028,
0.0364167951,
-0.000025479,
0.0659450963,
0.0111310855,
-0.0099969078,
0.0303673074,
0.0146580646,
-0.0034955561,
-0.0358944125,
0.0797343925,
-0.0256893169,
-0.010762048,
-0.0287139546,
-0.0570012555,
-0.001382234,
0.0142348744,
0.0020995843,
0.0459649079,
0.0539694391,
0.0043974868,
0.0061676451,
-0.0441030934,
-0.0999508351,
0.0014867811,
-0.009987195,
-0.0255072508,
-0.0076262113,
-0.0230206698,
-0.0725421011,
0.0599390045,
-0.0143610667,
-0.0096352696,
2.551274113e-34,
0.0046713692,
0.0003104678,
0.052592475,
0.0344356745,
-0.0000521882,
-0.0430153124,
0.0451831631,
-0.0085678119,
-0.0124978982,
-0.1054834276,
-0.0015860262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11303v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11303v1 | VideoVista: A Versatile Benchmark for Video Understanding and Reasoning | 2024-06-17T08:09:00 | 2024-06-17T08:09:00 | Yunxin Li, Xinyu Chen, Baotian Hu, Longyue Wang, Haoyuan Shi, Min Zhang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite significant breakthroughs in video analysis driven by the rapid
development of large multimodal models (LMMs), there remains a lack of a
versatile evaluation benchmark to comprehensively assess these models'
performance in video understanding and reasoning. To address this, we present
VideoVista, a video QA benchmark that integrates challenges across diverse
content categories, durations, and abilities. Specifically, VideoVista
comprises 25,000 questions derived from 3,400 videos spanning 14 categories
(e.g., Howto, Film, and Entertainment) with durations ranging from a few
seconds to over 10 minutes. Besides, it encompasses 19 types of understanding
tasks (e.g., anomaly detection, interaction understanding) and 8 reasoning
tasks (e.g., logical reasoning, causal reasoning). To achieve this, we present
an automatic data construction framework, leveraging powerful GPT-4o alongside
advanced analysis tools (e.g., video splitting, object segmenting, and
tracking). We also utilize this framework to construct training data to enhance
the capabilities of video-related LMMs (Video-LMMs). Through a comprehensive
and quantitative evaluation of cutting-edge models, we reveal that: 1)
Video-LMMs face difficulties in fine-grained video tasks involving temporal
location, object tracking, and anomaly detection; 2) Video-LMMs present
inferior logical and relation reasoning abilities; 3) Open-source Video-LMMs'
performance is significantly lower than GPT-4o and Gemini-1.5, lagging by 20
points. This highlights the crucial role VideoVista will play in advancing LMMs
that can accurately understand videos and perform precise reasoning. | [
0.0086765075,
0.0556830429,
-0.0185592305,
0.0766486377,
-0.0158115309,
0.0105306543,
0.02226796,
0.0018843176,
-0.0241116248,
-0.0528574735,
-0.0000152605,
-0.0585748479,
-0.0523007363,
0.0564694665,
0.023566423,
-0.0676668733,
0.0457223095,
-0.0179134272,
0.0131344944,
0.0296874922,
0.0447530523,
-0.0112736393,
-0.0050927079,
0.0146309808,
-0.057739459,
-0.0329802372,
-0.0204579961,
-0.0008007011,
0.0667776987,
-0.0528036021,
-0.0138617158,
0.019394638,
0.0873435512,
0.0112857362,
0.0000019565,
-0.0287883542,
-0.0006063014,
-0.0251622554,
-0.0008300993,
0.0054520196,
-0.0470585749,
-0.0309177991,
0.0109362919,
0.026173478,
-0.0489137396,
0.0120728528,
0.0243767984,
-0.0094800526,
0.0417003147,
0.0601050295,
-0.0350506939,
-0.0520871393,
0.023401035,
-0.0175928455,
0.0653316677,
-0.0484510064,
-0.0105795972,
0.0046380088,
0.020910494,
-0.0178974681,
-0.0796154365,
0.015176639,
0.0423701257,
-0.0007345665,
0.0031933207,
0.0081986198,
-0.0340289585,
-0.0354879722,
-0.0147966649,
0.082997337,
0.0014771423,
0.0390223972,
-0.0144389477,
0.0169800706,
0.0186560191,
-0.0020721729,
-0.0725087523,
0.0144445132,
-0.0104001993,
-0.0055362382,
-0.0200525969,
0.0176506024,
0.0263024587,
-0.0109264562,
0.0152514083,
0.0057811481,
0.0066246395,
0.0104187466,
-0.0275617819,
-0.0100103058,
-0.0230845436,
-0.0308596976,
-0.022738114,
0.0445303693,
-0.0228801053,
-0.0059145172,
-0.0084010055,
0.0432537869,
-0.0267940909,
-0.0139310714,
0.0278788302,
0.0113520604,
-0.0406698324,
0.0706248954,
0.0128265349,
0.0672090501,
-0.0543792285,
0.035329394,
0.0020428046,
0.0056315083,
-0.0841303691,
0.0025383143,
0.0273700561,
-0.001553983,
-0.0433721766,
-0.0077888742,
0.0086399224,
0.0281339362,
-0.0266961288,
0.0130247753,
-0.0431755371,
0.0318225287,
0.0521860048,
-0.0199223831,
-0.0390178338,
0.0204328652,
-0.0873524249,
0.0401011184,
0.0017537207,
-0.0542634912,
-0.0160572622,
0.011713176,
-0.0136196511,
-0.035786774,
0.0316513702,
0.050404653,
-0.0362892151,
-0.0478419885,
-0.0300372317,
0.0012891443,
0.0073914928,
-0.0498945266,
0.0587357655,
-0.0466484278,
0.0375884213,
-0.0145155806,
0.0042485157,
0.0240594912,
-0.0010505072,
-0.0164827108,
-0.0256521832,
0.085062027,
0.0059732422,
0.0236777272,
-0.003749243,
0.0404126272,
0.0055704219,
0.0613339283,
0.015363791,
0.0313951038,
0.0421913229,
-0.0002916853,
0.0507745296,
0.0293243527,
-0.0300787538,
0.0141846258,
-0.0724243596,
0.0371081457,
-0.0307784602,
0.0382360369,
0.0145638715,
-0.0029405595,
-0.0084734512,
-0.0473272055,
0.0482293703,
0.0227120668,
-0.0483109243,
-0.0342063978,
0.0353978835,
-0.0213292856,
-0.0092690429,
0.015578513,
-0.0389376469,
0.1084921882,
0.0130170304,
-0.0210376903,
-0.0000914531,
0.0309702326,
-0.0603035763,
-0.0305834208,
-0.0209824983,
0.0022317783,
-0.007036123,
0.0204449687,
0.0217077471,
-0.0197278224,
-0.0332368501,
-0.0129895248,
-0.0158577859,
0.0170062371,
0.0199766066,
-0.0405996032,
0.046681691,
0.0483973473,
0.0246353224,
-0.0216494594,
-0.0634236559,
-0.0115138926,
0.0426400267,
-0.0063058739,
0.0184942186,
-0.0254200157,
0.0268254634,
-0.0654318035,
-0.0296221636,
-0.0486718602,
0.0326512642,
0.0380166024,
0.0116609316,
0.0010198088,
-0.0051788823,
-0.0548134111,
0.0471132286,
0.0283441897,
0.0449354947,
-0.0130985128,
-0.0175856072,
0.0105876261,
0.0266342517,
0.0051072929,
0.0081381695,
-0.0236468315,
0.00335821,
-0.0151182488,
0.0256858692,
0.0323311426,
-0.0204360746,
-0.0158729311,
0.0348925069,
-0.0651761293,
-0.0329277962,
0.0788602605,
-0.0606466345,
-0.0215699654,
0.0466200747,
0.0145086627,
-0.0430438742,
-0.0799482167,
-0.0304358639,
0.0313366316,
0.01754448,
0.0187310502,
0.0569600239,
-0.0093774125,
-0.0320052467,
0.0006251645,
0.0284656342,
0.0487336032,
-0.01374372,
0.0037877031,
-0.0161221549,
-0.0305590164,
0.0040432015,
-0.0271297619,
-0.0187349785,
-0.0677926093,
-0.0001234318,
-0.0521122441,
0.0519262962,
-0.0233516898,
0.0048747617,
-0.0159240402,
-0.0092657683,
-0.0284604989,
-0.03493613,
-0.0029503501,
0.0015275571,
-0.0024821481,
0.0257481188,
0.0046337065,
0.0248947814,
0.0053547318,
-0.0114365146,
-0.0024224645,
-0.0163160898,
0.0219561178,
0.0034662634,
0.0103915911,
0.0294522624,
-0.0699581429,
-0.0415978543,
0.0345820859,
-0.0509220287,
-0.0282319635,
0.0431928858,
-0.0247721281,
0.0211436469,
0.065152511,
0.0316235498,
0.0443657003,
0.0047423984,
-0.0241253152,
0.019294776,
0.0336456299,
0.0010456357,
-0.0207067356,
-0.0257027484,
-0.0318263546,
-0.0438807756,
0.0086330697,
-0.0518788509,
0.0084887175,
-0.0630673841,
0.0354648158,
0.0467451401,
-0.0265655071,
-0.0470395312,
0.0059619779,
-0.0139332665,
0.0351761989,
-0.0256950837,
-0.0321422555,
0.0365315638,
-0.0050126966,
-0.0041732946,
0.0249849483,
0.0093608312,
-0.0188958235,
0.0905774534,
0.0275087617,
0.0117083127,
-0.0279805847,
-0.0425365604,
-0.0699449256,
-0.0210463814,
0.0315663926,
0.0174584016,
0.0148970783,
-0.0661954507,
-0.0103896027,
0.0147221992,
-0.0164337307,
-0.0540267341,
-0.0332791954,
-0.0402281694,
-0.0167492628,
-0.0803782046,
-0.0026600531,
-0.0118823536,
0.0044611399,
0.013512373,
0.0075657456,
-0.0258099679,
0.021673644,
0.0122112948,
0.0619012676,
0.0752902403,
0.0180837382,
-0.0308766235,
-0.0772919431,
0.0494101532,
0.0474512167,
0.0061861016,
-0.0573414639,
-0.0356298946,
0.0742818341,
-0.0188250747,
0.036393743,
-0.0228522234,
0.024783859,
0.0710301325,
-0.0527640507,
0.0143222166,
0.0861609355,
0.0183955152,
-0.0235453714,
-0.010606654,
0.0044695311,
-0.0123533867,
0.0647117496,
0.0129952598,
-0.069601737,
-0.060271576,
-0.0010578127,
0.0142234862,
0.009055987,
-0.0103207473,
-0.0177187342,
-0.0675582215,
0.1000345945,
-0.0079572303,
-0.0488098301,
-0.0126777738,
-0.0006814821,
0.0227358378,
-0.026573278,
-0.0203669965,
-0.0041026827,
0.011044044,
0.0142161129,
-0.0016043769,
-0.013911048,
-0.0271092393,
0.0762177929,
-0.0484658666,
0.0357035846,
0.0228318423,
0.0006363861,
-0.0250641201,
-0.0591111258,
0.0032107234,
0.0009314499,
0.0278139003,
0.0015309984,
0.0660205111,
-0.0519324541,
-0.0319494195,
-0.0176927168,
0.0579091758,
0.0061929147,
-0.0403042696,
0.0186706353,
0.0981915072,
-0.0196537357,
0.0011845005,
-0.0654915869,
-0.0110387513,
0.0039374442,
0.0301838219,
-0.0130947176,
-0.0043240422,
-0.0203454513,
0.0393293202,
-0.0413632318,
-0.0162341855,
0.0025227868,
-0.0107695302,
0.0301445574,
-0.0140351774,
-0.0258021597,
-0.0192239136,
0.0531647727,
0.0452073179,
-0.0378042534,
-0.0009499109,
-0.0394563228,
0.0442170873,
-0.0728349015,
0.0740032345,
0.0155667374,
-0.0056563755,
-0.0183568001,
0.0258582998,
0.0142658763,
-0.0418378897,
-0.0083678188,
0.0109959012,
-0.0450105481,
-0.0158242602,
-0.0377287753,
0.0730703548,
0.020361362,
0.0786374733,
0.0182257313,
0.0067622745,
-0.0489568971,
0.0057673366,
-0.0034565518,
-0.0039551654,
0.0043965261,
-0.0735696256,
-0.0196899809,
0.0226850472,
-0.0101661291,
0.0370612107,
-0.0177329779,
0.0113282567,
-0.0720282346,
0.0267373547,
-0.0006156635,
-0.0317866765,
0.0655355901,
-0.0129529731,
-0.0154960454,
-0.0363050438,
-0.0020705373,
0.0126527473,
0.0317104869,
-0.0525311492,
0.0163691603,
0.0416503437,
0.0007062177,
-0.0278016441,
-0.0257572047,
-0.0225445349,
-0.0116034709,
-0.0340614095,
-0.0299139041,
-0.0020419543,
-0.0131346956,
-0.020499723,
0.0195222925,
0.0624803901,
0.0149559109,
0.0054756911,
0.0597225428,
0.020317493,
0.0889227688,
0.0210737064,
0.0082533341,
-0.0055649295,
0.0190035831,
-0.0248187967,
-0.0352953933,
0.008423524,
0.0542150699,
0.0400877595,
-0.0397131704,
-0.0473868735,
0.0102956118,
-0.017499879,
0.0056688585,
0.0464771949,
-0.0020572843,
-0.059015248,
0.0565993004,
0.0455072261,
0.0018444059,
-0.0111907236,
0.0685739517,
0.0027893444,
0.0073419134,
0.0016073725,
-0.0000507849,
-0.0304853525,
0.0011808758,
0.0476166606,
0.0388589092,
-0.0073010214,
0.0207169112,
-0.0529912189,
-0.0717329383,
-0.0289012883,
-0.000914984,
-0.0105682369,
0.054451935,
0.0105090812,
0.0563686229,
-0.0143899312,
-0.0543849468,
0.0179092288,
-0.0400298685,
-0.0507076681,
-0.0046228995,
0.0502691083,
-6.248927234e-33,
0.0057690744,
-0.0073644868,
0.0403385982,
-0.0188884772,
-0.0092610652,
0.0003424228,
-0.015419377,
0.0055737728,
-0.0240428653,
0.0196289066,
0.0104166139,
0.0449175127,
0.0060983198,
0.0118869981,
0.0202011093,
-0.0687379465,
0.0105765332,
-0.026964169,
-0.0185720269,
-0.0021525945,
0.027730912,
0.033481475,
0.0554604232,
-0.0655452311,
-0.0243300404,
0.0031703939,
-0.0448611602,
0.0534172878,
-0.0444980934,
0.0587000065,
-0.0063113254,
-0.0446613207,
0.0445576943,
-0.0315431319,
0.003742313,
0.0013399296,
-0.0534621403,
-0.0053576315,
0.0370386094,
0.0019415722,
-0.0818664059,
-0.0116635263,
-0.0060497308,
0.0044849557,
0.0342830718,
-0.0571109243,
0.0394165441,
-0.0371794552,
0.0581174791,
0.0436283238,
-0.0146353636,
-0.0019460679,
-0.0385839678,
-0.0618566237,
0.0303331502,
0.0044851117,
0.0259478316,
-0.0101507269,
-0.035927821,
-0.0005548913,
-0.0463207327,
-0.0234956145,
0.074347347,
-0.0064546629,
-0.029880574,
0.0505963899,
0.0309054367,
-0.0855805054,
-0.0504118279,
0.0059741968,
-0.0088225063,
0.105028525,
0.0337434001,
0.036464911,
0.053476844,
0.002528341,
-0.0804693401,
0.0250924155,
-0.0521597974,
0.0579920895,
-0.0055890735,
0.0152067458,
0.0114215678,
0.0301074982,
-0.0068849865,
0.0019238868,
-0.0377954431,
-0.0178402886,
0.0442572609,
-0.0023206808,
-0.0114914021,
0.0027771066,
0.0591694526,
-0.0382863767,
0.0568789616,
0.0135969864,
-0.0250446387,
0.0322443247,
0.0348441154,
0.0542029031,
-0.027991686,
0.0117298206,
0.0578291193,
-0.0248998944,
0.0009978762,
-0.0038891733,
0.0280155521,
0.0536794141,
0.0070996289,
-0.0083279079,
-0.014551797,
0.0424536504,
-0.0316597074,
0.0302835554,
0.0167949405,
0.0509316027,
-0.0384816527,
0.030503802,
0.0008672566,
0.0069932956,
-0.0352239124,
-0.0226151794,
-0.0417423956,
0.022193877,
-0.0121522136,
0.0127145909,
-0.0351891369,
-0.0847756937,
-0.001750423,
-0.0574309826,
0.0045588445,
0.0351757854,
2.69e-7,
-0.0011108947,
0.0190216042,
0.0018708733,
0.0032166531,
0.0132725984,
0.0613781363,
-0.0305773672,
0.0346629694,
0.0371087827,
-0.068249397,
0.0244376585,
0.0787215158,
0.026920503,
0.0365832187,
0.0148926908,
0.0049973484,
-0.0086783571,
-0.0502721593,
-0.0800761208,
0.0027013945,
0.0319087654,
0.0894028172,
0.0382147282,
-0.0253213905,
0.0433095731,
-0.0299422983,
0.0549251437,
0.0052995184,
-0.0411938801,
-0.0265129991,
0.0119880214,
0.0300014541,
-0.0222765505,
0.0186018199,
-0.0174970366,
-0.0398931354,
0.0150282644,
0.0498015508,
-0.0191049185,
-0.0703879744,
-0.0401351824,
0.0377271436,
-0.0047871829,
-0.0502727441,
0.0915240943,
0.0115896044,
-0.0189150181,
0.0009461911,
-0.0358021297,
-0.0016188702,
-0.0246125143,
0.0215547662,
-0.0118002249,
-0.0035370241,
0.0092215249,
-0.02636916,
-0.0071429475,
-0.099349767,
0.0334174335,
0.0041127321,
-0.0376252495,
0.0204192307,
-0.0120112887,
0.0020668728,
0.0644384921,
-0.0100870961,
-0.0825035796,
1.844531897e-34,
0.0160368718,
-0.0023898694,
0.0201457366,
-0.0370912068,
-0.0007724016,
0.0027777916,
-0.0681629404,
-0.0184118729,
-0.0023048329,
-0.0269589722,
0.0069377678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11301v1 | Optimizing and Testing Instruction-Following: Analyzing the Impact of Fine-Grained Instruction Variants on instruction-tuned LLMs | 2024-06-17T08:08:11 | 2024-06-17T08:08:11 | Jiuding Yang, Weidong Guo, Kaitong Yang, Xiangyang Li, Zhuwei Rao, Yu Xu, Di Niu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The effective alignment of Large Language Models (LLMs) with precise
instructions is essential for their application in diverse real-world
scenarios. Current methods focus on enhancing the diversity and complexity of
training and evaluation samples, yet they fall short in accurately assessing
LLMs' ability to follow similar instruction variants. We introduce an effective
data augmentation technique that decomposes complex instructions into simpler
sub-components, modifies these, and reconstructs them into new variants,
thereby preserves the original instruction's context and complexity while
introducing variability, which is critical for training and evaluating LLMs'
instruction-following precision. We developed the DeMoRecon dataset using this
method to both fine-tune and evaluate LLMs. Our findings show that LLMs
fine-tuned with DeMoRecon will gain significant performance boost on both ours
and commonly used instructions-following benchmarks. | [
0.030131951,
0.0760110915,
-0.0140768532,
0.0379600674,
-0.0254418682,
0.0323441699,
-0.0229057334,
-0.0215577856,
-0.0239538178,
-0.0414602123,
-0.0428638048,
-0.0273057315,
0.0072831307,
-0.0267187208,
0.0482425839,
-0.0226488598,
0.0877151117,
-0.0563850701,
-0.076415129,
0.0182456877,
-0.0032375876,
0.0299109686,
-0.007539934,
0.0283162519,
0.0388503186,
-0.0130371246,
-0.0205457583,
0.0485495478,
0.0155694885,
-0.0209219567,
0.0302278642,
0.0257210117,
0.049065832,
0.0310670696,
0.0000020942,
-0.0148406494,
0.0075424309,
0.0184277464,
-0.059310168,
0.0628873408,
0.021276189,
-0.0299922954,
-0.0195327885,
0.0358523764,
0.0041007563,
0.0130805988,
0.035470061,
-0.0158303026,
0.0675315782,
0.103318505,
0.0114070326,
-0.0199084058,
0.0175236203,
-0.0182327833,
0.0113446983,
-0.0118624484,
0.006345829,
0.0090369331,
0.0122095328,
0.0514516756,
-0.0177323762,
0.0077026635,
0.0155942943,
0.0302819759,
-0.0325006582,
0.0012179539,
-0.0095480429,
0.0095903603,
-0.0212043189,
0.0641042888,
0.0007341793,
-0.0030929302,
-0.0212495942,
-0.0190682318,
-0.0067865136,
-0.0267173983,
-0.0358359292,
0.009115858,
0.0262601078,
0.0196627807,
0.0212588832,
-0.0436025821,
0.0208141189,
-0.0243368112,
-0.0264297742,
0.0651415139,
0.0228337608,
-0.0352067985,
-0.0300131347,
-0.0088840397,
-0.0330129601,
-0.0450124629,
-0.0247680135,
0.0312299989,
-0.0364900678,
0.032076817,
-0.0799795315,
0.0003573695,
0.0318344869,
-0.0097740535,
0.0955758616,
0.0754579604,
-0.0341087095,
0.01048824,
-0.0251043327,
0.0650549307,
-0.0326864347,
0.0417191498,
-0.0366343409,
0.0377869532,
-0.0490275621,
0.0182296522,
-0.0088969925,
0.0339817666,
-0.0501701571,
-0.0022239306,
-0.0427563302,
0.0475640967,
0.0063999533,
0.0364009291,
0.0126922624,
-0.0444803797,
-0.0450975634,
0.0152278887,
0.0034130127,
0.022607632,
-0.0271119606,
0.0230109487,
-0.0008197296,
-0.060614638,
-0.0187556744,
0.0157120228,
-0.0295945983,
-0.0366121642,
0.0265708156,
0.0719980747,
-0.0101470342,
-0.0247960947,
-0.0562342033,
-0.0266165603,
0.0057080546,
-0.0566694587,
-0.0151498998,
-0.0787785202,
0.0326138958,
-0.0072341976,
-0.0039018849,
-0.0186168253,
0.0192224011,
0.0291114394,
-0.0244848933,
0.0499527566,
0.0106884986,
0.0067600999,
-0.0203891955,
0.0033101914,
0.0257965364,
0.0624678619,
0.0222921986,
0.0026012128,
0.0279814042,
-0.0274050161,
-0.0207157433,
0.0501549393,
0.0099820988,
0.0337327532,
-0.0206889417,
0.0214948226,
-0.0016104029,
0.0045293793,
0.0638242364,
0.037775889,
-0.017436048,
-0.0253784917,
0.0428037941,
0.0150170838,
0.0085109929,
-0.0283906981,
0.0633756891,
0.0320223346,
-0.0108965933,
0.0313390046,
-0.0734697282,
0.0129771931,
-0.0091368705,
0.0324545577,
0.0103056813,
0.0295399576,
-0.0328492448,
-0.0205486324,
-0.0154115241,
-0.0108898869,
0.0072133648,
0.0115176663,
0.0212887023,
-0.0250710379,
-0.0675580353,
0.0389607362,
0.0410908721,
-0.0374343432,
-0.0288209449,
-0.051811941,
-0.0287787169,
0.0891059712,
0.0342819579,
-0.0066736415,
-0.0727899149,
0.0143760275,
0.0462182425,
0.0126768043,
0.0331849381,
0.0099782404,
0.0513506234,
-0.0674324632,
-0.0477850176,
-0.0392458327,
0.0042780326,
0.0205376297,
0.0412615538,
-0.0330319367,
0.0193197522,
-0.0074965195,
-0.0499309823,
0.0640558824,
-0.0278334636,
-0.0438390896,
-0.0132734375,
0.0106025673,
0.0254372228,
0.0021056398,
-0.0222620629,
-0.0003162062,
0.0426693633,
-0.0014323387,
0.04052395,
-0.0295383763,
-0.0602063686,
-0.0424765609,
0.0171575695,
-0.014344899,
-0.0185040049,
0.0219526645,
-0.0615907237,
-0.0484882779,
0.0028437274,
-0.0538968407,
0.0268286541,
0.0047939839,
0.0511624143,
-0.0009563216,
0.0130649908,
-0.035095755,
0.0118875587,
-0.0421193726,
0.0052797548,
0.0460871346,
0.0178575218,
-0.0030970355,
-0.0222381074,
-0.009330241,
-0.0457096547,
0.0070499973,
0.0085715316,
-0.007831201,
0.0241236482,
-0.0156614389,
-0.034843713,
-0.0544044785,
0.0455433689,
-0.0273130536,
0.043959517,
0.0450926013,
0.0173789617,
0.0097158123,
-0.0104833888,
-0.0085343188,
-0.0367340595,
-0.0216696281,
0.0281585399,
0.0100082709,
0.019242391,
-0.0746603161,
-0.054133065,
-0.0197825842,
-0.0127184298,
-0.0044712066,
-0.0497697219,
0.0414888784,
-0.0867965519,
0.0154726887,
0.0014795791,
0.0423307046,
-0.0205936693,
-0.0642654374,
0.0169069394,
0.0127923572,
0.0148010571,
0.0544157773,
-0.0318665132,
-0.00772449,
0.0414589234,
0.0010683243,
-0.0812069848,
0.0068338444,
-0.0067990809,
-0.0409066528,
-0.0607487932,
-0.0639752373,
-0.0107532833,
0.0821762905,
-0.0010253779,
0.0154442303,
-0.0464047492,
-0.0571368262,
-0.0048701242,
-0.007931035,
0.0083104577,
-0.0200973395,
-0.0247541722,
0.002301354,
-0.0419333018,
-0.0840256214,
0.058932282,
-0.0487713777,
-0.0122340042,
-0.0311971102,
-0.0212415513,
-0.0292971786,
0.0316133089,
0.0333527885,
0.0059052794,
-0.0269009266,
-0.0356412642,
-0.0513870753,
0.0272061992,
-0.000930925,
-0.023105599,
0.0803430751,
-0.0596562736,
-0.0019384142,
-0.0103450147,
-0.0180264879,
-0.0374226309,
-0.0173620507,
0.0268604867,
0.0121665103,
0.0741061568,
-0.045426067,
-0.0481901243,
-0.009125134,
0.0246390887,
0.0474752374,
-0.0141923297,
-0.0025642198,
-0.0467399172,
-0.0342637561,
0.0395839214,
-0.0168294702,
-0.0111207841,
-0.045385275,
0.0038321752,
0.0302228928,
0.0450136587,
-0.0100043798,
-0.0477970503,
0.0203286167,
0.0549396053,
-0.0197590012,
-0.0266787373,
0.0514465086,
0.0980809629,
-0.0662449673,
-0.0205833223,
0.1050620154,
0.0399122201,
-0.0298465528,
0.0209520739,
0.0033834216,
0.0514914989,
0.0415830277,
0.0490293652,
-0.0888943449,
-0.0330796875,
0.0009953977,
0.0489271134,
0.003172471,
0.0159017984,
-0.0096969912,
-0.1125693545,
0.016127931,
0.0249324962,
-0.0528040379,
-0.0473366454,
-0.029760452,
0.0107777044,
0.0132288532,
0.0658565536,
0.0181732178,
-0.0307132956,
-0.0234150663,
0.0418073535,
-0.0344390683,
-0.0628942251,
0.0359040238,
-0.0301317275,
0.0874094665,
0.090918377,
-0.0316664577,
0.0259965416,
-0.0184404291,
0.0492569953,
-0.0059944983,
0.025609592,
-0.0061709378,
0.0475801677,
-0.0172596946,
-0.0144357672,
0.0224278774,
0.0311112255,
-0.0369857475,
0.0238673873,
0.0199853256,
0.0538705587,
-0.0360312052,
0.0412552916,
-0.0204590354,
-0.0152628403,
0.0012530524,
0.0410111435,
0.0403339081,
-0.0260561705,
-0.004005143,
-0.036402043,
-0.0261475258,
-0.0768671408,
0.0116512431,
0.0474508666,
-0.0624943823,
-0.016267648,
-0.0328017585,
-0.0424989089,
0.0350427628,
0.022200834,
0.0176905617,
-0.0158014484,
0.0211135782,
-0.0398997962,
-0.0404185578,
0.0281800665,
-0.0339452662,
0.0400539339,
-0.1101301908,
-0.0807145536,
0.0015465155,
0.0309237968,
-0.0006546996,
0.0098412093,
-0.1112569422,
-0.0847041234,
0.0112425331,
0.0723547414,
0.0106803291,
0.0671785623,
-0.0063243224,
-0.0347921513,
-0.0164435599,
0.0134398174,
-0.0420286097,
0.038053982,
0.0404282473,
-0.0494440794,
-0.0073458049,
0.0039284742,
-0.0337867513,
0.0431021713,
0.0335465148,
0.0309599247,
-0.037701536,
-0.0218567681,
0.0330890678,
0.008238215,
-0.0032867626,
-0.022824144,
0.0183998235,
0.0126430308,
0.0585488491,
-0.0204660781,
0.0120867416,
-0.0361112766,
-0.0223432258,
0.0317787416,
-0.0197950006,
0.0128490953,
-0.0095997248,
-0.0228433479,
0.0219724998,
-0.0625831932,
0.0433116369,
-0.0082195811,
0.0362584703,
0.0209315028,
0.0204325244,
-0.0173231885,
0.0394284353,
-0.0058549778,
0.0385005549,
-0.0213634819,
0.0596791692,
-0.0016671258,
0.0463635549,
-0.0263061803,
0.038230598,
-0.0287779775,
-0.0167216584,
-0.0485248454,
0.0034810735,
0.0345411338,
-0.016338978,
0.0589963607,
0.0041457941,
0.0184291098,
-0.0144327218,
0.0324520841,
-0.031122569,
-0.0187376849,
0.0119644823,
0.0623117723,
-0.0121772466,
0.0078128781,
0.060683161,
0.0021217428,
0.053059347,
-0.0077280537,
0.0048830537,
-0.0307755619,
-0.0335971825,
0.0451698117,
0.0271099713,
-0.0319306143,
-0.0096651101,
-0.0094355382,
-0.0499900766,
-0.0432803258,
0.0335915759,
0.0184932873,
-0.0282709301,
0.03295701,
0.0152964154,
-0.0089666424,
-0.0406888686,
-0.0311750025,
-0.0332990214,
0.0121834064,
-0.0294106137,
-0.0174013656,
-6.443500937e-33,
-0.0518916287,
0.0136503037,
0.0249392912,
-0.0341232866,
-0.0199087225,
-0.0002790025,
-0.0201597065,
-0.0167709459,
-0.0064473241,
-0.0222325958,
0.0075780875,
0.0250487402,
0.0128777232,
0.0321115479,
0.0353017226,
0.013922398,
0.0512579829,
-0.0032172098,
-0.0264294557,
0.0136531461,
0.0157234855,
0.0015764739,
0.0464896783,
-0.0411495529,
0.0128391692,
-0.0199939106,
0.0085371211,
-0.0067272019,
-0.0152374525,
0.0843460932,
0.0110523533,
0.0112859309,
0.0039054013,
-0.0415870287,
-0.0509732701,
-0.0172892213,
-0.0374202766,
-0.0211455766,
0.0411998779,
0.030473467,
-0.028190393,
-0.0299519747,
0.0273523927,
-0.0239409748,
-0.0137254037,
-0.0098665422,
0.0126493359,
-0.0072737057,
-0.0130883278,
0.0513066947,
-0.0716346875,
0.0187306963,
-0.0195079446,
-0.042432569,
0.0149643151,
0.0140020149,
0.0138246818,
-0.0099139335,
-0.0339291245,
0.0246903468,
0.0569846071,
0.0941211805,
0.08824002,
0.0391828939,
0.0019677442,
0.0211613961,
0.0118205631,
0.0235926695,
0.018631354,
0.0264661368,
0.0321551189,
0.0488898754,
-0.0042438922,
-0.0130747473,
0.0415482931,
0.0013541384,
-0.0332407765,
0.0077948538,
0.021101959,
0.0273241159,
0.0192024037,
0.0168773253,
-0.0665843785,
-0.0028723394,
-0.0040376633,
0.0558139943,
-0.0232460294,
-0.0404897667,
0.048944369,
0.0110891899,
-0.0362590887,
0.0045695375,
0.0488961227,
-0.0181943532,
-0.0111828921,
-0.0203664601,
-0.0309707876,
0.0146521553,
-0.0162419304,
0.0168289822,
-0.0551561266,
-0.0872719884,
0.0475846194,
-0.04592105,
0.0556515418,
0.0000834938,
0.0351509526,
0.0333244428,
-0.0741369277,
-0.0015861859,
-0.0473264158,
0.0228556022,
-0.034741655,
0.0012891742,
0.0368637778,
0.0048554223,
-0.0045642862,
0.0736778304,
-0.0147773027,
-0.0524852239,
-0.0325244479,
-0.0085379211,
0.0140554328,
0.0443949886,
-0.0291843787,
0.0105209015,
-0.0383016653,
-0.0084483046,
-0.0154768657,
-0.0358379632,
-0.0299380403,
0.0273975376,
2.779e-7,
0.0242637489,
0.0427065901,
0.0395195745,
0.0505655147,
-0.0092225485,
-0.0016454597,
-0.0340432301,
-0.00696362,
0.0044465903,
-0.017042635,
0.0272634197,
0.0395434573,
0.0355049744,
0.0056533376,
-0.0301307365,
0.025481794,
-0.0279934239,
0.0268818624,
-0.0672661588,
-0.0009721183,
0.0140049001,
0.1038483307,
-0.0012771264,
0.0093736714,
0.0135531817,
0.0165861174,
0.004241047,
-0.0193099156,
-0.007440391,
0.0321129635,
-0.0197982136,
0.0472031496,
-0.0272222031,
0.0145650692,
-0.0254516322,
0.0077992845,
-0.0513326712,
0.1107217968,
-0.0378728732,
-0.0059659728,
0.007734857,
-0.0218277965,
-0.0240000784,
-0.0079336818,
0.0278193429,
-0.0370004326,
0.0024842201,
-0.0311604068,
-0.0277006142,
-0.0027263644,
-0.0154728554,
-0.0077713961,
0.016883906,
0.0149949118,
0.0438073985,
-0.0374484882,
-0.0346340016,
-0.0604267567,
-0.0100159962,
0.0355442725,
-0.0319431201,
-0.0457684137,
-0.047419671,
0.0150013836,
-0.0042928853,
-0.0399178453,
-0.0438560322,
2.979676371e-34,
0.0211657919,
-0.0169621482,
0.045031786,
0.0352004506,
0.0202342458,
-0.016480606,
-0.0519993715,
0.0533806868,
0.0009233662,
-0.0635369048,
-0.0289040525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11924v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11924v1 | Explainable assessment of financial experts' credibility by classifying social media forecasts and checking the predictions with actual market data | 2024-06-17T08:08:03 | 2024-06-17T08:08:03 | Silvia García-Méndez, Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, Jaime González-Gonzáleza, Francisco J. González-Castaño | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Social media include diverse interaction metrics related to user popularity,
the most evident example being the number of user followers. The latter has
raised concerns about the credibility of the posts by the most popular
creators. However, most existing approaches to assess credibility in social
media strictly consider this problem a binary classification, often based on a
priori information, without checking if actual real-world facts back the users'
comments. In addition, they do not provide automatic explanations of their
predictions to foster their trustworthiness. In this work, we propose a
credibility assessment solution for financial creators in social media that
combines Natural Language Processing and Machine Learning. The reputation of
the contributors is assessed by automatically classifying their forecasts on
asset values by type and verifying these predictions with actual market data to
approximate their probability of success. The outcome of this verification is a
continuous credibility score instead of a binary result, an entirely novel
contribution by this work. Moreover, social media metrics (i.e., user context)
are exploited by calculating their correlation with the credibility rankings,
providing insights on the interest of the end-users in financial posts and
their forecasts (i.e., drop or rise). Finally, the system provides natural
language explanations of its decisions based on a model-agnostic analysis of
relevant features. | [
0.0353929102,
0.0655005425,
0.0038366036,
0.004235514,
0.0041153659,
-0.0412288383,
0.0271230713,
-0.0051009231,
-0.0057162498,
0.0019981463,
0.0111041116,
0.0041305032,
0.0164262541,
0.0740439296,
0.0280375797,
-0.0242764298,
-0.0002340672,
0.0266026184,
0.0656086132,
-0.0152514856,
0.0344156474,
0.0176112037,
-0.0003133026,
0.047526747,
-0.0226130635,
-0.0017875334,
0.014460572,
-0.0189120341,
0.0101644117,
-0.0115339942,
-0.0175280739,
0.0384013057,
-0.0032562776,
0.039182093,
0.0000016894,
-0.0278661456,
-0.0222546253,
-0.0042616711,
-0.0211237315,
-0.0391410813,
0.033139661,
-0.0260376092,
0.0446603037,
0.0209988318,
-0.0927420631,
0.0623710789,
0.0651126727,
0.0398095325,
0.0712587088,
0.0617174096,
-0.0177899133,
-0.0494777597,
0.0254205577,
-0.0363896713,
0.0018955932,
-0.0579173006,
-0.0029406045,
0.0247442387,
-0.0607120283,
0.0256498363,
0.0310513061,
0.0193903893,
-0.0146718146,
-0.0240642447,
0.0764017478,
-0.0126094557,
0.0120982807,
-0.0063818558,
-0.0447954163,
-0.003691542,
0.043371439,
0.0001753123,
0.0154758655,
-0.013729888,
-0.0142844925,
0.0411737189,
-0.0392578654,
0.0246149879,
-0.0238512829,
0.0054626376,
-0.0005650267,
0.0495392643,
0.0349172354,
0.0214865021,
0.0164375585,
0.0442374311,
-0.0444207974,
-0.0216758046,
0.0323337838,
0.0165679473,
-0.0138802426,
-0.0879626274,
0.0060004806,
0.0256801788,
0.0063112546,
0.0104182642,
0.0189645644,
-0.0051575894,
-0.0131422011,
-0.0956498906,
-0.0146366861,
-0.0064883609,
0.0352260433,
0.0478605293,
-0.0250230711,
0.0009576461,
0.0449546911,
-0.0461449809,
0.0627802685,
0.0231684353,
-0.0623632781,
0.0162103269,
-0.0034472938,
0.0209001191,
0.0087286513,
-0.0062737353,
-0.0873089209,
-0.0081143444,
-0.0399769582,
0.0666041225,
0.0318927579,
0.0360424519,
-0.0065982454,
-0.0201110356,
-0.0789585933,
-0.0118853804,
-0.0394011699,
0.0179751236,
-0.0258288216,
-0.0007390752,
0.0535305068,
0.014097156,
0.0051865415,
0.0103720017,
0.0096704504,
0.0536407754,
0.0562153794,
-0.025789775,
-0.0402352512,
-0.0881742463,
0.0092755752,
-0.0026007006,
-0.0693207234,
-0.0388128832,
-0.0333565399,
-0.0137404185,
-0.0164186191,
0.0123619027,
0.0091616474,
0.0146767534,
-0.0237744283,
0.0610570237,
-0.0377266854,
0.0113885542,
0.0041550561,
-0.0134844286,
-0.0403630435,
-0.0066492963,
0.0144429496,
0.0460443087,
0.0763110965,
0.0114403218,
0.0101688448,
-0.000814441,
0.0250730161,
-0.0732758194,
0.0121946018,
0.0174198989,
-0.046871908,
-0.015477377,
-0.0087255519,
0.0170778185,
-0.0014328799,
-0.0021581529,
0.0655989796,
0.0121477833,
0.0181855727,
0.0366597995,
0.0432912596,
0.0242910068,
0.0367500819,
-0.0253943969,
-0.0124753797,
0.0082514761,
-0.0419443808,
-0.0036809454,
0.007806737,
-0.0055809524,
-0.0125044668,
-0.0427501202,
0.0226116758,
-0.0295102187,
0.0014549155,
-0.0173061453,
0.0096832225,
-0.0376034491,
-0.0422313102,
0.0135154389,
0.0129896086,
0.0016124265,
-0.003731885,
-0.0055802464,
0.0487291738,
0.0518115722,
-0.0114781139,
0.0106315641,
0.0658803433,
-0.0246084575,
-0.0047671711,
0.027641749,
0.0313223973,
0.0016405294,
-0.0543196537,
-0.024864044,
-0.0103534227,
0.0114209503,
0.0107357325,
-0.011222804,
0.0391290672,
0.0414385498,
-0.0111229029,
-0.0053253612,
-0.0199472923,
0.0205732491,
0.0215779822,
-0.0107699083,
0.0144581301,
-0.0174084846,
0.0081334785,
0.0490166172,
0.0241231769,
-0.0018432275,
-0.0084231002,
0.0293446593,
-0.0602876097,
0.0240509175,
-0.0192950629,
0.0589410476,
0.0027706232,
-0.0459683165,
-0.0184066296,
0.0015709257,
-0.0327033661,
0.0024087182,
0.0318390876,
-0.0181326568,
0.0154192522,
-0.0573790371,
-0.0766554326,
0.0025760543,
0.0040167733,
0.0012949171,
0.0625294,
-0.0019278198,
0.0167385414,
-0.0471060835,
-0.0359328873,
0.0223405752,
-0.0102094645,
0.0528948121,
-0.0466266088,
-0.0245498642,
0.0669387281,
0.05207932,
-0.0444094129,
-0.0032203025,
-0.0032147474,
-0.0833807811,
-0.0573601276,
-0.0343279578,
0.0011763765,
-0.0054814848,
-0.0343784727,
0.0210069753,
-0.0077907341,
-0.0278812498,
-0.0098743094,
0.0083899973,
-0.00999205,
0.066381447,
-0.0143326027,
0.0045219315,
-0.0235839449,
-0.0194423981,
-0.0163453184,
0.0407045595,
0.1253245175,
-0.0126337595,
-0.0057133613,
-0.0838146359,
-0.0719571412,
-0.0123818126,
-0.0104553243,
0.042788092,
-0.0048073791,
0.0339185186,
-0.0519281961,
-0.0095322821,
0.044084467,
0.0545839146,
-0.0461782701,
0.044326093,
0.0039786799,
-0.0275684875,
-0.0549709164,
-0.0119366609,
-0.0176976509,
0.009139603,
0.0299053621,
0.0195410084,
-0.0026640778,
-0.0054761395,
-0.0463751256,
0.0678922683,
0.0306989662,
0.0255642571,
0.0154745709,
-0.0157355927,
0.0256058946,
0.0883213952,
0.0004411575,
-0.0646745637,
0.0568141043,
-0.0194362253,
0.002804263,
0.0137366299,
-0.0662294105,
-0.0287072975,
-0.0093046241,
0.0107120629,
0.0067824139,
0.0107952338,
0.0236231424,
0.0334615037,
-0.0327241085,
0.0612574108,
-0.0088273007,
-0.0486160368,
0.0002355248,
0.0240643322,
0.0266292542,
0.0253722947,
0.0040389397,
-0.1126830503,
-0.0622990578,
0.0113456734,
0.0119419396,
-0.0749061853,
-0.0357350893,
-0.0165739339,
-0.0118549773,
-0.0529283211,
-0.0305535626,
-0.0541818999,
0.0195688065,
0.0196335129,
0.0187178999,
0.0133996503,
0.0261500962,
-0.0277304053,
0.0104959561,
0.0211204085,
-0.0059389044,
0.0066228504,
-0.0668755397,
-0.0139945531,
-0.0297777709,
-0.0221981257,
0.0207525156,
0.0531898327,
-0.0064058695,
-0.0104279667,
0.054409612,
0.0910758376,
0.030732628,
0.0427691564,
0.0129322987,
0.0090866303,
0.0057451432,
-0.0306641255,
0.0240406394,
-0.072941862,
-0.0042573977,
-0.0461844429,
0.0163962375,
-0.0184723623,
-0.0520347618,
-0.0339114778,
-0.0974953026,
0.0837117508,
-0.0322919823,
0.0050173653,
0.0115018729,
-0.0822891071,
-0.0319034941,
-0.0468630083,
-0.0143707711,
-0.0048755496,
0.0136506772,
0.0429236554,
0.0178489555,
-0.085895434,
-0.0130068948,
0.030747408,
-0.0389494002,
-0.0265666004,
0.0475307778,
0.0226063151,
-0.0295722298,
-0.0472300649,
-0.1135484129,
0.0468925573,
0.0185988396,
0.0176464822,
0.0904448405,
-0.0394822881,
-0.0162903182,
-0.0322546363,
0.0344887972,
-0.0103995325,
0.0403557904,
-0.0127950432,
0.007177284,
-0.0111847222,
-0.0615208223,
-0.0199764762,
0.0662174076,
0.02463031,
0.0551302806,
0.0224945266,
-0.0230193343,
-0.0299835186,
-0.0526339374,
0.0114888642,
-0.0264401641,
-0.0237686858,
-0.0235091373,
0.0365372635,
-0.0498462729,
-0.0926368758,
-0.0175343268,
-0.0387265719,
0.0412002429,
-0.0453051217,
-0.0026382019,
0.0645091385,
0.0069472482,
-0.0376894288,
0.0293901563,
0.000460158,
0.0369684696,
-0.0349667519,
0.0523479432,
0.0423466116,
-0.0285927244,
-0.0325294025,
0.0110680042,
-0.0308104102,
-0.0313840434,
-0.0265338682,
0.0248717852,
0.0294706598,
-0.0175437927,
-0.0188075472,
-0.0254236348,
0.0454380065,
0.0527880751,
-0.0545119457,
-0.0284632985,
0.0591080748,
0.0600982346,
-0.0008148627,
0.0250862464,
-0.0084615573,
0.0270987786,
-0.0388022326,
-0.0465281717,
-0.0724088997,
0.0047842008,
-0.0372059904,
-0.0111097842,
0.0647697076,
0.0290636159,
-0.0289953053,
0.0267411899,
-0.0647820681,
0.0011379197,
-0.0190815665,
-0.009755048,
0.0085448008,
0.0165494047,
0.0071678096,
-0.0273617767,
-0.0137326345,
-0.0200803839,
-0.0351856053,
-0.0202480797,
0.0051194555,
0.0013736553,
0.0361127183,
-0.0323166624,
-0.001067244,
0.0243910737,
-0.0485907421,
0.0413445272,
0.0056344345,
0.0246510822,
-0.0335421339,
-0.0058284793,
0.0043470128,
0.0387986787,
-0.0313620418,
-0.049155768,
-0.0559457131,
-0.0136409719,
0.0475829393,
-0.012172373,
0.0037801357,
0.0005523344,
-0.0328233577,
0.0229984391,
0.0195635241,
0.0209090002,
0.0035782268,
-0.0518097766,
0.0093522817,
-0.0138757555,
-0.0611472204,
-0.0089937402,
0.0456065312,
0.0035624097,
-0.0280811545,
-0.0416687913,
-0.0786031038,
-0.0203835312,
-0.0356329568,
-0.0127500147,
0.0539821088,
0.0414664298,
0.016114518,
-0.0428268202,
-0.0438046083,
0.067770049,
0.0077023013,
0.0102232182,
0.0016395958,
-0.0016378826,
0.0666451827,
0.0117927827,
0.0860562027,
-0.0144969029,
-0.0249788389,
-0.0289882515,
-0.014166859,
-0.0829997137,
-5.783502368e-33,
0.0114622843,
-0.1005198434,
0.0026988445,
0.0113531314,
0.0425272584,
0.0272946525,
-0.0272245891,
-0.0163215175,
0.0087180333,
0.047380019,
0.0149052432,
0.0298492387,
0.0129646007,
0.0048110588,
0.0089975176,
0.0116461022,
0.0177310202,
-0.0134508451,
-0.0119113224,
-0.0062041846,
0.0292820428,
0.0091007622,
0.0239985287,
-0.0897360146,
0.0771704391,
0.0099910991,
-0.0560633764,
0.0057698921,
0.036301434,
0.0339880101,
0.0251151714,
0.0677417293,
0.0257835537,
-0.0647219941,
0.010331613,
0.0045942585,
-0.001144612,
-0.0304636974,
0.0024413858,
-0.0213561505,
-0.0376408473,
0.0715855584,
0.0616391003,
0.0088498406,
-0.0099531179,
0.018861996,
0.0695507899,
0.0144634573,
0.0352265798,
-0.0170432013,
-0.0265096165,
0.043776419,
-0.0116580846,
0.0398194231,
0.0148396231,
0.0524343587,
0.0322657004,
0.0248380583,
-0.0411074124,
0.0107385432,
-0.0374327488,
0.0099969925,
0.013609915,
-0.0305698477,
-0.0539390668,
0.0572459176,
0.0032510404,
0.0096466588,
-0.0288021676,
0.0201399196,
-0.0177185293,
0.0598580912,
0.0898011625,
0.0888544619,
0.0460237823,
-0.0315637775,
-0.0429982953,
0.0464791358,
0.037664216,
-0.0057315328,
-0.0064209187,
-0.0339862779,
-0.039547585,
-0.0052422066,
0.0001948308,
-0.0391531102,
-0.0263668504,
-0.00640094,
-0.0396704227,
0.0091889752,
-0.0151551226,
0.0853732005,
-0.0211881883,
-0.0505726784,
-0.0586358979,
-0.0111364126,
-0.0048168967,
0.0271637794,
0.0161929745,
-0.0001807594,
-0.0144400094,
0.0334915817,
-0.0312299039,
-0.0110604865,
-0.0110318894,
-0.0264354274,
0.0121067176,
0.0254001282,
-0.0093612438,
-0.0190629773,
-0.0026745468,
0.0087412344,
-0.0226070452,
0.0014933986,
0.0000040453,
0.0233417675,
-0.0334411003,
0.0145822698,
-0.0253855418,
0.0545107462,
0.0101030786,
-0.0031816564,
-0.020224303,
0.0004496564,
0.0029837859,
-0.0476333089,
0.0299736373,
0.0018113304,
0.0171393864,
-0.0219139419,
-0.0123187089,
-0.0114931175,
2.51e-7,
0.0108500374,
0.056623064,
-0.0215009246,
-0.0063574817,
0.0335376449,
0.0716528147,
0.0304037575,
0.0100403512,
0.0077763502,
-0.0687291995,
0.0219976623,
0.0302101243,
0.0331916995,
0.0185477082,
-0.0259335078,
-0.0584104545,
-0.0695604235,
0.0077263857,
-0.0628601983,
0.0425576381,
0.0081878779,
0.0103027616,
0.045853544,
-0.0312163848,
-0.0126592778,
-0.0354674235,
0.0434001721,
-0.0127495043,
-0.0050859796,
0.0106097553,
0.0782611519,
-0.0293295179,
0.0062006833,
0.0249652267,
-0.0283298306,
0.0050909375,
0.0062533617,
0.0105832927,
0.019496236,
0.0305205472,
0.0019888189,
-0.0226525925,
0.0122167002,
-0.0118253231,
-0.0011339504,
-0.0543545522,
-0.058823172,
-0.0853401199,
-0.0510167368,
0.0050489674,
0.0452328287,
0.015845526,
-0.0231139343,
0.0206127856,
-0.0051420238,
-0.0171726402,
0.0158060864,
-0.0271334071,
-0.0232364554,
-0.0055124029,
-0.0457732677,
0.0446227752,
0.007114314,
0.0072085829,
0.0402787589,
-0.0397118963,
0.0675038025,
1.713586762e-34,
0.0379993059,
0.0015873538,
-0.0254853349,
-0.0336787254,
0.0830912292,
0.0423178002,
-0.0140826618,
0.0046376581,
0.0437433757,
-0.0062357467,
0.0041652313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11290v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11290v1 | Iterative Utility Judgment Framework via LLMs Inspired by Relevance in Philosophy | 2024-06-17T07:52:42 | 2024-06-17T07:52:42 | Hengran Zhang, Keping Bi, Jiafeng Guo, Xueqi Cheng | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Utility and topical relevance are critical measures in information retrieval
(IR), reflecting system and user perspectives, respectively. While topical
relevance has long been emphasized, utility is a higher standard of relevance
and is more useful for facilitating downstream tasks, e.g., in
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG). When we incorporate utility judgments
into RAG, we realize that the topical relevance, utility, and answering in RAG
are closely related to the three types of relevance that Schutz discussed from
a philosophical perspective. They are topical relevance, interpretational
relevance, and motivational relevance, respectively. Inspired by the dynamic
iterations of the three types of relevance, we propose an Iterative utiliTy
judgmEnt fraMework (ITEM) to promote each step of the cycle of RAG. We
conducted extensive experiments on multi-grade passage retrieval and factoid
question-answering datasets (i.e., TREC DL, WebAP, and NQ). Experimental
results demonstrate significant improvements in utility judgments, ranking of
topical relevance, and answer generation upon representative baselines,
including multiple single-shot utility judging approaches. Our code and
benchmark can be found at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/ITEM-B486/. | [
0.0529933982,
0.0028162075,
0.0135553749,
-0.0126746958,
-0.0182441287,
0.0239387229,
-0.0317439921,
0.0105232773,
-0.0207266044,
-0.0488635376,
-0.0023755678,
0.0010956868,
-0.0310049765,
-0.0224339887,
0.0089790244,
-0.0250031259,
0.0294887293,
0.0120549034,
0.0264430121,
-0.0039246632,
0.0062590116,
0.00507107,
-0.0317476019,
0.0072703739,
0.007630005,
0.0089510959,
-0.0002404266,
0.0207607262,
0.032827843,
-0.0453423858,
0.0323386863,
0.0308157559,
0.0249138214,
-0.0292242821,
0.0000019329,
-0.0914942026,
-0.034587495,
-0.0201205127,
-0.0188877247,
-0.0242302381,
0.0633753911,
0.0906632543,
0.0401940607,
0.0079857074,
-0.0550859571,
0.0469124913,
0.0178574082,
0.0225172006,
0.039387349,
0.0506303832,
0.0250477362,
-0.0115887886,
-0.0105920471,
-0.013926887,
0.0884263888,
-0.051380638,
-0.0139717665,
0.0494522676,
0.0164575446,
0.0630129799,
0.011474736,
0.0214513335,
-0.0029852304,
-0.0153381927,
0.0640853122,
-0.0031105052,
-0.0062569776,
0.0391686186,
0.0230305195,
0.0561452061,
0.0920512825,
0.0096239867,
-0.0062292372,
0.0399662554,
0.0466042161,
0.0294484925,
-0.0598620586,
0.0123397699,
-0.0245974548,
0.0170055274,
0.0227980837,
0.0147019168,
-0.0052253217,
0.0431878269,
0.0154256877,
0.0691073611,
-0.021736877,
-0.0126101607,
0.0011979818,
0.0242130253,
0.0049292552,
-0.0225352366,
-0.0004526989,
0.069414787,
-0.0389416106,
0.010447464,
0.0274835788,
0.0055269701,
0.0393171571,
-0.0206735563,
0.0155217135,
0.0157562438,
0.0221288092,
0.0007335218,
-0.0080120713,
0.0200802796,
-0.0089251725,
-0.0083915852,
-0.0908827484,
0.0244972669,
-0.0492348857,
-0.0347786359,
0.0043659126,
0.0957112536,
-0.0282945,
0.0073722731,
-0.0492452644,
0.0329988599,
0.0283781905,
-0.0331526548,
-0.0418994278,
0.0423451588,
-0.0505670495,
0.0300753079,
-0.0803780705,
0.0225418042,
-0.049574472,
0.0020798868,
0.0072974334,
0.0142687839,
-0.0022839231,
0.0352812409,
-0.0041226936,
-0.0339837708,
0.0349138714,
0.0383957922,
-0.0069819763,
-0.050475385,
-0.0719399229,
-0.0607779361,
0.0120132565,
-0.0299410429,
0.0156547707,
-0.0770640671,
-0.0260033868,
0.0291625299,
-0.0307947006,
-0.0071441275,
0.0172282178,
0.0660462528,
-0.0226226728,
0.0209769942,
0.025288539,
-0.0018739883,
0.0199528169,
0.0138364462,
0.0310953185,
0.043093998,
0.0063553615,
0.0448646024,
0.0475477651,
0.0159543175,
-0.0296333265,
-0.0414688326,
0.0022488057,
0.0262739267,
-0.0281118099,
0.0554893389,
-0.035061352,
0.0136266071,
0.0188918244,
0.0240683295,
-0.0287391413,
0.0223942995,
0.0400860123,
0.0326716676,
0.0516422689,
0.0083344588,
0.0069051157,
0.0151968738,
-0.0055469121,
0.0446787849,
0.0037828404,
0.0785960555,
-0.0608966798,
0.0070638116,
0.0150134182,
0.0017604157,
-0.0315085351,
-0.0706693232,
0.0015839052,
0.0290837716,
-0.0288747605,
0.042518992,
0.0258091986,
0.0320706442,
-0.0316244476,
0.0056589516,
0.0034774302,
-0.0661830157,
0.0164898839,
-0.0515890643,
0.0735234767,
0.0951358229,
0.0893527418,
-0.0432335399,
-0.0382732861,
0.0034861641,
-0.0037111866,
0.0310783423,
0.0271010082,
-0.040082816,
-0.0278550684,
-0.0549336895,
-0.0319081284,
-0.0434131809,
-0.0303000938,
-0.0019818782,
0.0182234086,
0.0178719033,
0.0183597635,
-0.0887108445,
0.0146910641,
0.0341986977,
0.013200298,
-0.0382692665,
0.0265144985,
-0.0028873717,
0.0075301421,
0.0243245717,
0.0093804328,
0.0293732584,
0.0189579204,
-0.0103995148,
-0.0279268976,
-0.0106230946,
-0.0254630353,
-0.0080795819,
0.0289301611,
-0.0233092308,
0.0097098304,
0.0112757506,
-0.0141751803,
-0.012509726,
-0.0095422519,
-0.0500992611,
-0.0177892931,
-0.058347635,
-0.013139952,
0.0099889124,
0.0132758263,
-0.0964906812,
0.0895976946,
-0.008823581,
0.0510989614,
0.0519698337,
0.0021282183,
-0.0116936918,
-0.0379296057,
-0.0168957487,
-0.0144773182,
-0.0070237829,
0.0132431565,
0.0436389111,
0.0413863845,
-0.062341854,
-0.0006807854,
-0.0526025668,
0.017124448,
-0.024501102,
0.0432033837,
0.0034998485,
-0.0049312552,
0.0119731948,
-0.0109085562,
-0.0445794836,
-0.0033217093,
0.0083608953,
0.0306613799,
0.0644126013,
0.028488202,
0.0277703982,
-0.0261907298,
-0.0015525938,
-0.0019216668,
0.0151176704,
0.0201187246,
0.0436458774,
-0.0449953713,
0.0203637648,
-0.0686441287,
-0.0489285178,
0.0149494298,
0.0218476001,
0.030449478,
-0.0033985744,
0.1128673181,
0.0251318514,
0.0480735302,
0.0186738893,
0.016202122,
-0.0205481816,
-0.0877611563,
0.013953845,
-0.0503448956,
0.0011755651,
-0.0074198316,
-0.0574345812,
0.0362521149,
-0.0152690951,
-0.0203972459,
-0.0112610459,
-0.0334244557,
0.042750366,
0.0119295316,
-0.0148696396,
-0.0598321371,
0.036360871,
-0.0012611573,
0.0330681391,
0.007255618,
-0.0343939587,
0.0796237811,
0.0110160355,
0.0001819419,
-0.0652751178,
0.008219894,
-0.0774970353,
0.048555471,
-0.0296160858,
0.0129780052,
-0.0643601045,
-0.023657877,
-0.0237212256,
-0.016281398,
0.0112431925,
-0.0613769107,
0.0675495043,
-0.0467908941,
-0.0066683744,
-0.007115975,
-0.0085844882,
-0.0319725238,
-0.0246861447,
0.0394190885,
-0.0142616583,
-0.0458929352,
0.006572945,
-0.0116016259,
-0.020165734,
0.0529875569,
-0.0341034271,
-0.0296995882,
-0.0555996895,
0.0059129144,
0.0655011684,
0.0618153512,
0.0242017061,
0.0378156193,
0.0266514793,
0.0032827014,
0.0639087185,
0.0371899121,
-0.0249424987,
0.0381925553,
0.0027657694,
0.0712845251,
-0.0704119802,
0.0082639726,
0.0244806111,
0.0072397934,
-0.0228939001,
-0.042660635,
0.0802250281,
0.0332962349,
-0.0354664214,
-0.0119190188,
-0.0711834803,
0.0397093073,
0.0209929552,
0.035226319,
-0.039316766,
-0.0108594252,
0.0105757201,
0.0812606215,
-0.0288349707,
-0.0371438265,
-0.0124743143,
-0.0882569328,
0.020649109,
-0.0236927718,
-0.0008540964,
-0.001433774,
-0.0353172161,
-0.0054225479,
0.0100790197,
-0.0284342486,
0.0670828298,
-0.0449718945,
0.0327979587,
0.0322736874,
0.0481434762,
0.0041875141,
0.0067441305,
0.0069998023,
-0.0117422938,
0.071005173,
0.0118484469,
-0.0121304477,
-0.0418600813,
0.0075595276,
-0.0621475428,
0.0095267585,
-0.0260539278,
0.0258847028,
-0.0237558261,
0.0313222557,
-0.0908293128,
0.0327892341,
-0.0306490082,
-0.0283306278,
0.016688874,
0.0305588916,
-0.0474578701,
0.0070539466,
-0.082011506,
0.0266973283,
-0.0119854631,
0.0842449963,
0.0122690685,
-0.0403109118,
-0.0151775656,
-0.0350217186,
0.0063786949,
-0.0746584386,
-0.0432474799,
0.0101109175,
-0.012444362,
0.0172444452,
-0.0736320317,
-0.0478780866,
-0.0355027393,
0.0163733047,
-0.0230317079,
-0.0002861448,
-0.079457432,
-0.001920631,
-0.0616956018,
0.0074765184,
-0.032855656,
-0.0119098676,
-0.046214018,
-0.0084043937,
0.0516987145,
-0.0931830779,
-0.0093246503,
-0.0149931274,
-0.0093019605,
-0.0117532462,
-0.0273783058,
0.0439575352,
0.0181212444,
-0.0055109994,
0.0088318158,
-0.0057657305,
0.0429402925,
0.0661177114,
-0.0040973024,
0.0245987587,
0.0010351416,
0.0386845917,
-0.0020814918,
0.0029768539,
-0.0559821241,
0.0192295853,
-0.0135369832,
0.0844424516,
0.0140174497,
-0.0478932075,
0.0424081534,
0.0247943327,
-0.0192918591,
0.0112882117,
-0.0058149756,
-0.02650363,
0.0062375949,
0.0186375976,
-0.024361629,
-0.0153567223,
0.0209176708,
-0.0134927006,
-0.0140369013,
-0.016663691,
0.0113863489,
-0.0207059011,
0.0619775765,
-0.013772144,
0.0000037657,
-0.0034855376,
0.0067285253,
-0.0080600586,
-0.0132653108,
-0.0366207287,
-0.0090626758,
-0.0196161605,
0.0433680937,
-0.0015380116,
0.0728151277,
0.0200454183,
-0.0009249367,
0.0284537245,
0.0165372808,
-0.0716806948,
0.0069545191,
-0.0263660178,
-0.001294183,
-0.0174465012,
0.0376867764,
0.045896776,
-0.0137061477,
0.0008040855,
-0.012012518,
0.0122319041,
0.0018896977,
-0.0211369172,
0.0232995898,
0.0320235305,
-0.0080124829,
-0.0328332745,
0.057460729,
-0.0467613265,
-0.0043793758,
-0.0144730425,
-0.0540254377,
-0.0490918569,
-0.1061574072,
-0.0181504395,
0.0170687474,
0.0112152612,
-0.0111849289,
-0.064172402,
-0.008659767,
-0.0140426653,
0.0300158858,
0.033735428,
-0.0315747671,
0.0407085083,
0.0847532675,
-0.0009726616,
-0.0190576706,
-0.0550569333,
0.0313733369,
-0.0917183012,
0.0042303661,
-0.0334832855,
-6.064757759e-33,
-0.0197536256,
-0.0683694556,
0.0328461491,
0.0218804087,
-0.0180342253,
-0.0191620067,
-0.0176657122,
0.0143878348,
-0.0137155913,
-0.0268487576,
0.0004983899,
-0.0036702931,
-0.0022340433,
0.0086423298,
0.0025975443,
-0.0098816538,
0.0324776135,
0.0234376583,
-0.0565073788,
0.0322600231,
0.0543572828,
-0.0021424845,
0.0412419774,
-0.0007611742,
0.0394323319,
-0.0307988599,
0.0160540249,
0.0426031053,
-0.0356800035,
0.0455697589,
0.0043839058,
0.0553837046,
0.0466840491,
-0.0203972552,
0.0117900698,
0.019467758,
-0.0807796195,
-0.0542989448,
0.0191143006,
-0.0249664262,
-0.040525049,
-0.0488721207,
0.0113921026,
-0.0102448622,
-0.016799273,
0.0042340769,
0.0510646477,
-0.0336386897,
-0.0077413693,
-0.0849663541,
-0.0253586527,
0.0177517403,
-0.0195284504,
-0.0184849966,
-0.0498710833,
0.093829222,
0.0145400194,
0.052867163,
-0.0308466349,
0.0632405579,
-0.0500573888,
0.0425628014,
0.029766852,
-0.0208569523,
-0.0250889417,
0.0220546294,
-0.0312253088,
-0.0369527861,
-0.0012558909,
-0.056672357,
-0.0212997105,
0.0152524356,
0.0263816118,
0.0445929728,
0.0352190398,
-0.0048362659,
-0.0450021103,
0.0866361484,
0.024695687,
0.0434701778,
0.033216957,
0.0006849816,
-0.0072574373,
0.0054908376,
-0.0320174396,
0.0446223952,
-0.0499559902,
-0.0501786657,
0.0480638444,
0.0063314806,
-0.0279088356,
-0.0128762731,
0.0221424717,
0.0034855204,
0.0000423755,
0.0432274602,
-0.0310158692,
0.0135866972,
0.0053438898,
-0.0052173752,
-0.0342227146,
0.0029015157,
0.0174682569,
-0.0233334918,
-0.0349964909,
-0.0056318152,
0.0138896843,
0.0104034301,
-0.0218328647,
0.0079556592,
-0.0119433831,
0.0454658195,
-0.0242345016,
-0.0141225988,
-0.0053201714,
0.0069410526,
-0.0059486781,
0.0502287894,
0.012055777,
0.01238761,
-0.0586310402,
-0.0281186588,
0.0041196169,
0.0233228579,
0.0052043903,
0.0382718071,
-0.0110769589,
0.0674746037,
-0.0522623584,
-0.0193275381,
-0.0176429022,
0.0525346063,
2.682e-7,
0.043910142,
-0.0056380113,
0.0100788362,
0.0407348275,
-0.0162513088,
0.0154067725,
0.0092825042,
-0.0041609225,
0.0449017547,
0.0102188429,
0.0255963672,
0.0300117601,
0.0035534909,
0.0394755676,
-0.060758058,
-0.0604786761,
-0.0046325405,
-0.0287169423,
0.0013776124,
0.0028361087,
0.0846850723,
-0.0037720727,
0.0055020582,
-0.0233164579,
-0.0065515498,
-0.0384213403,
0.0457138121,
-0.0322429091,
-0.0034582054,
0.041735325,
0.0476814732,
-0.0220727585,
0.0298579335,
-0.0305098779,
0.032022424,
0.0016820504,
0.0130133387,
0.0206621792,
0.0226259865,
-0.0953475535,
0.0034775436,
-0.0111389766,
0.0417145155,
-0.0329121575,
0.0472975187,
-0.0115495007,
-0.0239424184,
0.0275880937,
-0.0574459434,
0.0085502388,
0.0038298268,
-0.0234902352,
-0.0343459398,
0.0062390543,
0.0039158491,
0.0103918733,
-0.0421051085,
-0.0612397864,
-0.0120996581,
0.0232444927,
-0.0456847064,
-0.0427755453,
-0.0360017084,
0.005195837,
-0.0362280607,
-0.0921368897,
-0.0401653945,
2.409523958e-34,
0.0287605021,
-0.0010137586,
-0.0007984939,
-0.0018381744,
0.0246001408,
0.0308979638,
-0.0325902291,
-0.006783247,
0.0184474736,
-0.0609416664,
-0.0196398832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11289v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11289v1 | A Systematic Survey of Text Summarization: From Statistical Methods to Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T07:52:32 | 2024-06-17T07:52:32 | Haopeng Zhang, Philip S. Yu, Jiawei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text summarization research has undergone several significant transformations
with the advent of deep neural networks, pre-trained language models (PLMs),
and recent large language models (LLMs). This survey thus provides a
comprehensive review of the research progress and evolution in text
summarization through the lens of these paradigm shifts. It is organized into
two main parts: (1) a detailed overview of datasets, evaluation metrics, and
summarization methods before the LLM era, encompassing traditional statistical
methods, deep learning approaches, and PLM fine-tuning techniques, and (2) the
first detailed examination of recent advancements in benchmarking, modeling,
and evaluating summarization in the LLM era. By synthesizing existing
literature and presenting a cohesive overview, this survey also discusses
research trends, open challenges, and proposes promising research directions in
summarization, aiming to guide researchers through the evolving landscape of
summarization research. | [
0.0392970294,
0.0245813448,
0.0280994829,
0.0116938762,
-0.0226325318,
-0.0003212978,
-0.0149055691,
-0.0477165692,
-0.0167334955,
-0.0259838142,
-0.0069316034,
-0.0237665996,
0.0346771479,
-0.009616469,
0.0011121976,
-0.1005281955,
0.0165024735,
-0.0340963155,
0.0005693757,
0.0150122335,
0.0257642511,
0.004677583,
0.0197868291,
0.0349080376,
0.0194786601,
0.0122153824,
-0.0084376726,
0.0088073891,
0.0478785783,
-0.0079591637,
0.0107373241,
-0.0211499296,
0.0294498671,
0.0217449367,
0.0000019139,
-0.0596898645,
-0.0139145209,
-0.0288170408,
-0.0069743115,
0.0459693111,
0.0446005017,
-0.0385126621,
0.0189704113,
0.0070392946,
0.0035546415,
0.0035140421,
-0.0061848024,
0.0497582965,
0.03806182,
0.0424586125,
-0.0179590583,
-0.0443941578,
0.0296393167,
-0.0183668975,
-0.0628034025,
-0.0037793824,
0.01746873,
0.0066447938,
-0.0141371563,
-0.0162130203,
-0.0170630589,
0.0552919246,
0.0125501379,
-0.0006078026,
-0.0298597403,
0.024958374,
-0.0502600931,
-0.0046437755,
0.0150060114,
0.0813372433,
-0.0021087362,
0.0014459623,
0.0192878284,
-0.0083110044,
-0.0159561299,
-0.0098275626,
-0.0681602433,
0.0622105524,
0.0107981926,
0.0508427396,
-0.0066146562,
0.0655055046,
0.0058625671,
0.0538377948,
-0.0514086559,
0.0216018446,
-0.0108480146,
-0.0023841925,
-0.0166031662,
0.0070414427,
-0.0113759218,
-0.030178437,
0.049103044,
0.0402808227,
0.0237802826,
-0.0126016084,
-0.0436230414,
-0.0782608315,
0.026454458,
-0.0263378881,
0.0178075619,
-0.0019688148,
-0.0007481551,
0.0528714433,
-0.0101199588,
0.0102864141,
0.035270106,
0.0156520698,
-0.0528767966,
-0.0198900886,
0.0230367593,
-0.0002434558,
-0.0393712819,
0.0460209399,
-0.0250327513,
-0.0351619273,
-0.0425753109,
-0.0004702405,
0.0463267155,
-0.0178651828,
-0.0129674347,
0.0196666326,
0.0211502835,
-0.0055284249,
0.00615955,
0.0227360055,
-0.0260262992,
-0.0183335096,
0.0041796854,
-0.0095336679,
-0.0037215457,
0.0373884514,
0.0196766555,
0.0128079057,
0.0393681452,
0.0190432388,
-0.0016236149,
-0.0572856888,
-0.0059465985,
-0.0031115932,
-0.0227340739,
-0.0562006123,
-0.0101218,
-0.0768805444,
-0.0037096117,
-0.0366786495,
-0.0033004528,
-0.0244043767,
-0.0154113816,
0.0073174774,
-0.0771738291,
0.0100376504,
-0.0259375367,
0.0196687505,
0.048928462,
0.0135038421,
0.049859833,
0.0314609334,
0.0799359456,
0.0630300939,
0.0541737005,
0.0211682133,
0.0005602213,
0.0538442396,
-0.0039495784,
-0.0072507644,
0.005973964,
-0.0354147591,
-0.0523191914,
-0.0124435648,
0.0024017771,
0.0801393092,
-0.0440284982,
0.008639859,
0.0815100744,
0.0855656341,
-0.0005233283,
0.0121393483,
0.041766502,
0.017130021,
0.0725425258,
0.0375155322,
0.0010415659,
0.0119491117,
-0.0337062888,
0.0603626966,
0.1027249768,
0.0529243425,
-0.0292396545,
-0.0640196279,
0.0194394439,
-0.0152673069,
0.0070180753,
0.0136483088,
0.0480258614,
-0.0098219672,
-0.0662350059,
0.0182328466,
-0.0015759128,
-0.0625933185,
0.018733291,
-0.0130341416,
-0.0033122997,
0.0509817004,
0.0391465016,
-0.0690659583,
-0.0130503448,
0.002369629,
0.0302027278,
0.0253137574,
0.0170291979,
0.0033567727,
0.0221201759,
-0.0686258972,
-0.0162598342,
-0.0175098181,
0.0068360865,
-0.0161502715,
-0.0286415406,
-0.0052954229,
0.029754132,
0.0014246968,
-0.0656679049,
0.0278685875,
-0.0226338413,
-0.0243673697,
-0.0102145886,
-0.002857195,
0.0028532636,
0.0379201844,
-0.0099876234,
0.020661965,
0.0321862623,
-0.0333151147,
0.0183221381,
0.0030732243,
-0.0392232873,
-0.0259894039,
0.0060795196,
-0.0671724007,
-0.0055032885,
0.0325465687,
-0.0359614566,
-0.0505444072,
0.0210654419,
-0.041468326,
0.0028480855,
-0.0358089171,
0.0247631371,
-0.0000887336,
0.0220850389,
-0.0346096307,
0.0469181761,
0.0077837147,
-0.0246033445,
0.0711228773,
-0.0326962583,
0.003134178,
-0.0294052605,
-0.0305841044,
-0.028532505,
-0.0152542023,
0.0012439347,
0.0477573201,
0.0114117796,
-0.0266792923,
-0.0095601305,
-0.0994925126,
0.0253899209,
-0.0309922379,
0.008713129,
0.0324704684,
0.0322017074,
-0.0161584169,
-0.0119785052,
-0.0125596356,
-0.0483390801,
0.0314552598,
-0.014781747,
0.0383651331,
0.0007252552,
0.044233948,
-0.0897820741,
-0.0366134234,
-0.0081752827,
0.0535332412,
-0.008029961,
-0.0614253432,
0.0056575998,
0.0298489202,
-0.0325645357,
-0.0317662917,
0.0009697261,
0.0013292226,
-0.0240928438,
-0.0179064423,
0.071205005,
0.0420252755,
0.0451968499,
0.0127218757,
0.0390516035,
-0.0114958137,
-0.0237816107,
-0.0150514161,
-0.0445881933,
0.0411628261,
0.0084693916,
-0.0312707052,
0.0313933603,
0.0493999943,
0.0117489556,
-0.0069479863,
-0.0134276599,
0.0204423945,
-0.0268125255,
-0.016504623,
-0.0293912794,
-0.0156198777,
-0.0105450293,
0.0223119836,
-0.0237744469,
-0.0155227147,
0.0429190993,
-0.0209059957,
0.0397886075,
-0.0615621693,
-0.0248690452,
-0.0656472594,
0.0404684618,
0.0472528525,
0.0153543884,
-0.0144962166,
-0.0085846866,
-0.0140613504,
-0.0182378404,
0.014598594,
-0.0183510892,
0.0783218741,
-0.0516706705,
0.0230017863,
-0.0406146795,
0.0102062104,
0.0044747209,
-0.0612047538,
-0.0503281951,
0.0198761281,
0.0419391803,
0.0268255956,
-0.0210228767,
0.0240809508,
0.0146001941,
0.0634977147,
-0.0203659441,
-0.0119588235,
-0.0241398457,
0.0677320659,
0.0662361681,
-0.0234854687,
0.0680818856,
-0.0524536222,
0.0113127939,
0.0305215623,
0.0205961764,
-0.018475011,
-0.0060766474,
-0.0334999934,
0.00357799,
-0.0840248168,
0.0374610052,
-0.0094228545,
0.0494670197,
-0.0331336781,
0.0178554878,
0.1148348227,
0.0164265465,
-0.0171227213,
-0.0188439488,
0.0382359065,
0.0097226035,
-0.0326499566,
-0.0217569042,
-0.0366807953,
-0.01446517,
0.0024080544,
-0.0003296799,
0.0087531619,
-0.0341264568,
-0.0132325394,
-0.0440650918,
-0.0083406745,
0.0042546601,
-0.0654913932,
-0.0253034998,
-0.0119505757,
0.0013278632,
-0.0211776923,
0.0150671815,
-0.0031669789,
-0.0550540052,
0.0056536305,
0.0025336507,
-0.1090812758,
0.0141801946,
-0.034213163,
-0.0453833826,
-0.0085415281,
0.061598625,
0.0381729938,
-0.0145480493,
0.0649845898,
0.0533207916,
-0.0409972295,
-0.0182578303,
0.0074446043,
0.1077834889,
-0.0035199311,
0.0045092441,
-0.0357886665,
0.0493515246,
-0.009560124,
0.0070973635,
0.0208649021,
-0.0176197905,
0.0095932297,
-0.0598496757,
-0.0652394071,
0.0676338598,
-0.0543992333,
0.0734623894,
0.0457355715,
-0.0151664605,
-0.0479933582,
-0.0363548584,
-0.0078525785,
-0.0822986439,
-0.0485479981,
-0.0083521791,
-0.0091183055,
0.0142816091,
-0.0511085205,
-0.0715048909,
0.0293750688,
-0.0445375219,
0.0067759412,
0.0211014282,
0.0095975986,
0.0025688272,
-0.0208148621,
0.0062752026,
-0.0243337322,
-0.0054461658,
-0.0421304703,
0.005751085,
0.08062388,
-0.0297967643,
-0.0118319523,
0.0201083254,
-0.0826737657,
-0.0456438959,
-0.0246386006,
0.0498505272,
0.0164414477,
0.0583851188,
0.021797996,
-0.0288555212,
0.0728178844,
0.0137688667,
0.0250724405,
0.0310873445,
0.0179205369,
0.0325997397,
-0.0348448791,
0.0107696848,
-0.0607073046,
0.0411773212,
-0.0144298719,
0.0243299156,
-0.0323284455,
-0.0724334791,
-0.0153131727,
0.0075852936,
0.0213736966,
-0.0147019234,
-0.0161641035,
-0.0447972678,
-0.0315308943,
-0.0103322249,
0.0115876505,
-0.0211311523,
0.0346012488,
-0.0150606306,
0.0276238676,
-0.0413719863,
0.080976285,
0.0228274073,
0.0094774291,
-0.0385869294,
0.0312214307,
-0.01836765,
-0.0200051088,
-0.0621698909,
-0.0201502535,
-0.0447698571,
-0.0070121964,
-0.0390937924,
-0.0137922624,
0.0125859873,
-0.0156714264,
0.0285986811,
0.0154673662,
-0.0222699288,
0.0483120978,
-0.0820956901,
0.0101012429,
-0.058095526,
0.0215328187,
0.0561822504,
-0.0530854017,
0.0796051249,
0.0170645006,
-0.008759453,
-0.0389536209,
0.0182153024,
0.062419802,
0.0233103931,
-0.0709340349,
0.0118679339,
0.0149522135,
0.0322140381,
0.0637528971,
-0.0060262056,
0.0191596709,
0.064076066,
-0.0303923115,
-0.0281864256,
-0.0309797954,
-0.0153395468,
0.0321881212,
0.0028691725,
-0.040829014,
-0.0478407294,
-0.0068878666,
0.0512973517,
0.0276283491,
0.0025218865,
-0.0296327174,
0.0204252545,
0.0010506466,
0.0095433099,
0.0379589945,
-0.0405048095,
-0.0262100995,
-0.0046631997,
0.0075714709,
0.0065770587,
-5.87526109e-33,
-0.0166772828,
0.0089973323,
-0.0421418548,
0.0157257803,
-0.0547639243,
0.0131558962,
-0.0640321225,
-0.0286028534,
-0.0038999736,
0.0002561379,
-0.0043730875,
-0.0072163036,
0.0237331279,
0.0539788082,
-0.0138253653,
0.0256257504,
0.0521189198,
0.0066264803,
-0.0288117714,
0.0351047404,
-0.0175524708,
0.0267655775,
0.0331955813,
-0.0277681202,
0.0193251483,
-0.0193393584,
-0.0010349875,
-0.0141857471,
0.0508582741,
0.0303677544,
-0.0112133836,
0.0081704818,
0.0479156598,
-0.0147847421,
-0.0508352742,
0.0306966417,
-0.0975928605,
-0.037945386,
0.0008115537,
-0.0447174683,
-0.0525538325,
-0.034112379,
0.0557819456,
-0.0038863816,
0.0085136471,
-0.0368550308,
0.0837868303,
-0.02911219,
-0.0243436433,
-0.0839384645,
-0.0299900118,
0.0373077691,
-0.0628883094,
-0.0279695727,
0.036246147,
0.0491604246,
-0.0053232098,
0.0475098751,
-0.0418012217,
0.0608820431,
0.0566030964,
0.0154380416,
0.0206857715,
0.0364069939,
0.0139911585,
0.0520565175,
-0.0195777174,
-0.0029445363,
-0.0531698056,
0.0268983264,
0.0387870818,
-0.011376,
0.0263138209,
0.0296602547,
0.0130712269,
0.0349048972,
-0.0654097348,
0.0874724537,
0.0077232532,
-0.0191015955,
0.037107192,
-0.0098043121,
0.0216742661,
-0.0053404979,
-0.0404973179,
-0.0113085704,
0.0137189636,
0.0084651522,
-0.0220581498,
0.022471929,
-0.0754765645,
-0.027300382,
0.0258111171,
-0.0502641201,
0.0082193408,
0.0185800698,
-0.0013321642,
0.0222658254,
0.0073452429,
-0.0160050727,
-0.0549937971,
0.0152812842,
0.0090437606,
-0.0094487136,
-0.0175895356,
-0.0098678637,
0.043132551,
-0.0008571903,
-0.0070753316,
0.0073130778,
0.045289021,
-0.0031251058,
-0.0225638933,
0.0427282378,
-0.030462496,
0.0100097861,
0.0245753378,
0.0407566242,
-0.0007148746,
-0.0178034808,
0.0091248918,
0.017603958,
0.0364640579,
0.0108215762,
-0.0317409039,
0.0284169391,
-0.016142603,
0.0256323051,
0.0488886349,
-0.0480130427,
-0.0079370048,
-0.0043331385,
2.305e-7,
0.0803543702,
0.0193324126,
0.0952361897,
-0.0273668468,
-0.0281860083,
0.0067183618,
0.0158051755,
0.0149351014,
0.0080364663,
0.0167715028,
0.0660736337,
0.0560600571,
0.0374656171,
-0.020653395,
-0.0975933522,
-0.0249203295,
-0.0658092648,
-0.0310730487,
-0.0293721128,
-0.029864721,
0.036691498,
0.0831238553,
-0.0245268755,
-0.0089104129,
-0.0183707774,
-0.02567783,
0.0210995264,
-0.0371856131,
-0.0161977392,
0.0447239764,
0.0234097596,
0.0116980635,
-0.0413849615,
-0.0347747654,
0.0027751797,
-0.0050371704,
0.0771909133,
0.0510595404,
0.0294221733,
-0.0021039462,
0.008205032,
0.0053794663,
0.0379684046,
0.0120292902,
0.065859139,
-0.0647726357,
-0.0010182686,
-0.0153834205,
-0.019651344,
0.0012256558,
0.0005277265,
-0.0072552986,
-0.042383533,
0.0604833625,
0.0043925587,
-0.0039500818,
-0.012414095,
-0.0938603058,
-0.0150251584,
0.0006271053,
0.0014777137,
-0.010345987,
-0.0136377774,
-0.0233198795,
-0.000568763,
-0.0558004193,
-0.0076657264,
2.035732367e-34,
0.0964710712,
-0.0181997996,
-0.0419626422,
-0.0188686457,
0.007762548,
-0.0312889926,
-0.032518357,
-0.0099444855,
-0.0168231875,
-0.0955688581,
-0.005298411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11288v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11288v1 | MFC-Bench: Benchmarking Multimodal Fact-Checking with Large Vision-Language Models | 2024-06-17T07:51:44 | 2024-06-17T07:51:44 | Shengkang Wang, Hongzhan Lin, Ziyang Luo, Zhen Ye, Guang Chen, Jing Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Large vision-language models (LVLMs) have significantly improved multimodal
reasoning tasks, such as visual question answering and image captioning. These
models embed multimodal facts within their parameters, rather than relying on
external knowledge bases to store factual information explicitly. However, the
content discerned by LVLMs may deviate from actual facts due to inherent bias
or incorrect inference. To address this issue, we introduce MFC-Bench, a
rigorous and comprehensive benchmark designed to evaluate the factual accuracy
of LVLMs across three tasks: Manipulation, Out-of-Context, and Veracity
Classification. Through our evaluation on MFC-Bench, we benchmarked 12 diverse
and representative LVLMs, uncovering that current models still fall short in
multimodal fact-checking and demonstrate insensitivity to various forms of
manipulated content. We hope that MFC-Bench could raise attention to the
trustworthy artificial intelligence potentially assisted by LVLMs in the
future. The MFC-Bench and accompanying resources are publicly accessible at
https://github.com/wskbest/MFC-Bench, contributing to ongoing research in the
multimodal fact-checking field. | [
0.0320325829,
0.0474193878,
0.0132369949,
0.0809087157,
-0.0655478686,
-0.0115765044,
0.023700688,
-0.0042919237,
-0.0067875385,
-0.0811588168,
-0.0145674255,
-0.0371456258,
0.0064949985,
0.0299922116,
0.0189529192,
-0.0241918806,
0.0778783709,
-0.0350216366,
0.0136458278,
0.004829186,
0.0236202832,
0.0094239395,
-0.0325659961,
0.0343948342,
-0.0734093487,
-0.0449692458,
0.0269698165,
0.0104107978,
0.0344867371,
-0.0108970189,
-0.0275195632,
0.0325049646,
0.0462712646,
0.0508826934,
0.0000017405,
-0.0270659011,
0.0251213908,
0.0060859025,
-0.0108010443,
0.0037621125,
0.0126873767,
-0.0425703675,
0.0085211601,
-0.0143196443,
-0.0261342302,
-0.0263400655,
0.0405075587,
0.0471967198,
0.0854994506,
0.0632907897,
-0.0024615314,
-0.0022049954,
0.0062391525,
0.0151540954,
0.0031659813,
-0.0340719037,
0.0057150219,
0.0437561385,
-0.0272343829,
-0.0011709883,
-0.0435277596,
0.0447844006,
0.0280399546,
-0.0294122528,
-0.0250215288,
0.0353386477,
-0.0318152532,
-0.0281306859,
-0.0053875241,
0.0889554024,
0.0052019134,
0.0015432268,
-0.0256616455,
0.001058868,
-0.0012331903,
0.0231793318,
-0.0434173644,
0.0568368845,
-0.0219522621,
-0.0257624742,
-0.0665304214,
-0.0240338296,
0.0268689822,
0.0277941022,
0.0388767049,
0.0253673885,
-0.0061602895,
0.0140069099,
0.0116461106,
-0.0049157371,
-0.0279412754,
-0.0566603877,
-0.0455191396,
0.0191774815,
-0.0151779503,
-0.0028698731,
-0.0419600382,
-0.0121396556,
0.0201606471,
-0.0612699725,
0.0303369127,
0.0004642528,
-0.078328833,
0.0827149078,
-0.0134762162,
0.0537179038,
-0.0476999059,
0.0401679873,
0.0121340351,
-0.0395666547,
-0.0183917657,
0.0230711531,
0.0139588965,
0.0027106721,
-0.0419165008,
-0.0372820348,
-0.0272265542,
-0.0067711226,
-0.0409510359,
0.0543926917,
-0.0233168527,
0.0171382912,
0.0104341134,
-0.0218153428,
-0.0789110139,
0.060943298,
-0.01158664,
0.0267552324,
-0.0064727743,
-0.0624873787,
0.0050233938,
0.0393158793,
-0.0160836689,
-0.0312510058,
0.0199710187,
0.0396903679,
-0.0288593862,
-0.0138375089,
-0.0357906185,
-0.04718633,
-0.046901539,
-0.0877477229,
0.040228188,
-0.0658629462,
0.0363311358,
-0.0327938348,
-0.0190558266,
-0.0053708893,
-0.0034343335,
0.0269561224,
-0.0032593161,
0.1065483317,
0.0112278182,
-0.0173017625,
0.0204736907,
0.0079446817,
-0.0225561466,
0.0496950522,
0.0115721207,
0.0516149327,
0.0735805333,
0.0287541337,
0.0241054408,
0.0097276159,
-0.0012117294,
0.0084552774,
-0.0097130779,
0.012298475,
0.0169912186,
0.0315786079,
0.0229454748,
0.0508266464,
-0.0266075321,
-0.0712894201,
0.1147903129,
-0.0077754613,
-0.0232981071,
-0.0364396237,
0.031474717,
-0.0303127076,
0.0403926969,
0.0063554789,
-0.0651405752,
0.0812566429,
-0.0050513083,
0.0005820915,
0.0125867445,
0.0526908562,
-0.0086455066,
-0.0143717127,
-0.0092606638,
-0.0215221513,
-0.0137886284,
0.0233261883,
0.0169664696,
-0.0139914006,
-0.0309397038,
0.0079797544,
0.0173927099,
-0.0224444922,
-0.0168524217,
-0.0268170945,
0.0153846825,
0.0332529619,
0.0513977669,
-0.0025538749,
-0.0202713683,
-0.0251797941,
0.032164555,
0.0319358073,
0.049829945,
-0.0018542483,
0.0198572259,
-0.0251214914,
-0.0102908853,
-0.0511883833,
0.0002182533,
0.0097285341,
0.0179693121,
-0.0068559116,
-0.0161847007,
-0.0382318236,
0.0324550048,
0.0204131231,
0.0494260117,
0.0113878297,
-0.0276001357,
0.018652549,
0.0267872624,
0.0012102879,
-0.0306373313,
-0.0132617336,
0.014872306,
-0.0063310275,
-0.0156696569,
0.028008271,
-0.0383143835,
-0.0291297529,
0.0558829196,
-0.0640543178,
-0.0438385867,
0.0406850763,
-0.0498224013,
0.0147026898,
-0.0093648629,
-0.0284415856,
-0.0249281917,
-0.0775941461,
-0.0294225328,
0.0096126497,
0.0262046941,
0.0289016962,
0.0621948279,
-0.0426282249,
-0.0297531914,
0.013598498,
0.0083850548,
0.0221300144,
-0.0115501378,
-0.0096135912,
0.0239571091,
0.0120278979,
0.0327332728,
0.0050915899,
-0.0242789555,
-0.0397656895,
0.0164108053,
-0.0940249562,
-0.0210956745,
-0.0090028513,
-0.0366568826,
-0.0121704191,
-0.0358894095,
0.0221475419,
-0.0214999057,
-0.0144306729,
0.0066693174,
0.0054892735,
0.0258746389,
0.0471129753,
0.0039421637,
0.0215827655,
0.0000516266,
0.0153615093,
-0.0119850794,
0.0781031549,
0.0068135019,
0.0007144186,
-0.0116542885,
-0.0443474837,
-0.0767925382,
0.0594842248,
-0.0406964533,
-0.0079942392,
0.0316824988,
0.0122659421,
0.0236800015,
0.0850691721,
0.0335610695,
-0.0020017854,
0.039711602,
0.0070448429,
-0.0103553934,
0.0111623611,
0.0113692582,
-0.0347020142,
-0.010909046,
-0.0401604064,
-0.0140351411,
-0.0098043522,
0.0081119072,
0.0060808011,
-0.0269988049,
0.0464782938,
0.0181349367,
-0.0733733028,
-0.0252576396,
0.0061161704,
-0.0078515243,
0.0337022766,
-0.0392106473,
-0.0444266535,
0.0640086606,
-0.0558510683,
0.0157605186,
0.0295895711,
0.0069611589,
-0.0072378111,
0.0830937251,
0.0187922679,
0.0471321382,
0.0078516919,
0.0400246009,
-0.040475551,
-0.0526547469,
0.0657597259,
-0.0123525942,
0.0554094128,
-0.0690111294,
0.0232627839,
-0.000792267,
-0.0439862162,
-0.0448396988,
-0.0669980049,
-0.0170568191,
-0.0135399923,
-0.0730429366,
-0.0323392041,
-0.0452148765,
-0.0018479271,
0.07777448,
0.015587884,
-0.0010221915,
-0.0054458836,
-0.0014149515,
0.042395819,
0.0490284786,
0.0580268577,
0.0257327128,
-0.0291024223,
-0.0275144558,
0.0790512338,
-0.000491454,
-0.0011189174,
-0.0609364547,
-0.0117958793,
-0.0338202193,
0.0346447304,
0.0268827751,
0.0090975529,
0.0486171432,
-0.0455592573,
0.0264309198,
0.0558379814,
-0.0036914581,
0.0036045909,
-0.0037606016,
0.0412936136,
-0.0237166211,
0.0347431079,
-0.0193405095,
-0.0981543809,
-0.0488988869,
-0.0251121055,
-0.0102987317,
-0.0037941127,
-0.0201051477,
-0.0394903198,
-0.1117675826,
0.0578139052,
-0.0263741333,
0.0051893173,
-0.0592262298,
-0.0195978191,
-0.0099313734,
0.0035299787,
-0.0044560027,
0.006051138,
0.0373034924,
-0.0131442435,
-0.02135369,
0.022577865,
-0.0242709946,
0.0561631918,
-0.0521127656,
0.0044267499,
0.0022216609,
0.0168641265,
-0.0193192754,
-0.0621853434,
0.0054812278,
0.0242690351,
-0.0149715282,
0.0103473673,
0.0706886649,
-0.0469222702,
-0.0331684723,
0.0106170466,
0.0038532524,
0.050082203,
-0.0269683693,
-0.0320268832,
0.048407387,
-0.0060390402,
-0.0176399071,
-0.0386354662,
0.0223498344,
-0.0103392247,
0.0361505374,
0.0042681419,
0.012010389,
-0.0176445004,
-0.016355928,
-0.0383506604,
-0.0196411777,
-0.0193881858,
0.0239642877,
0.0364344604,
0.0104526831,
-0.0700533912,
-0.0084920926,
-0.0128285289,
0.0659869835,
-0.0575702339,
-0.0236135107,
0.013721332,
0.0284473784,
-0.0426363088,
0.0458405837,
-0.036245238,
0.0530311093,
0.0000907124,
0.0419910997,
0.0363001935,
-0.0530333109,
-0.0134695787,
0.0422032177,
-0.063271679,
-0.0255855303,
-0.0445652381,
0.075259015,
0.0123315332,
0.0407014042,
0.0146971149,
0.0042887628,
-0.0114605529,
0.0197459832,
-0.0214330535,
0.0588762201,
0.0169801395,
-0.0234179348,
0.0001096532,
0.0204094648,
-0.0181197822,
0.0055706399,
0.001162046,
0.012405145,
-0.0140314866,
-0.0274919327,
0.0143311778,
0.0388569906,
0.032660421,
-0.0124220941,
0.0028462049,
-0.0188640803,
0.0097385254,
0.0032402801,
-0.0322299711,
-0.0139910663,
0.0324218906,
0.0111265294,
0.009025909,
0.0067107887,
-0.0009602383,
-0.0075703468,
0.0242095888,
0.0110507607,
-0.0160939228,
0.0416776314,
-0.0197649747,
-0.0206857808,
-0.0066230861,
-0.0368728861,
0.0099889236,
-0.0237032268,
0.048170995,
-0.0036174653,
0.084553495,
0.0489690974,
-0.0473082922,
-0.01843247,
-0.0034787585,
-0.0493992716,
0.0237411782,
-0.0109170843,
0.0480249524,
0.0702210739,
0.0377781801,
0.001888029,
-0.0383805297,
-0.0307966899,
-0.0188230798,
0.0029205759,
0.0107055325,
-0.0230009966,
0.0622142889,
0.0191010404,
0.0041085072,
0.0404232703,
0.0264883004,
-0.0079293614,
0.0357515402,
0.0116237449,
-0.0238177814,
-0.0500457026,
-0.0531257018,
-0.0091924267,
-0.0011419898,
0.0053236345,
0.0028019689,
-0.0671436861,
-0.0655537099,
0.0375490412,
0.0509184636,
0.0130793201,
0.0244299155,
0.0180104114,
0.0700631887,
0.0575822443,
-0.0302894209,
-0.0173106622,
-0.0208236948,
-0.0057497183,
0.0292000677,
0.0188122932,
-5.848167047e-33,
-0.0011841339,
-0.0426511653,
0.0238316003,
-0.0256576426,
-0.0095589049,
0.0316592865,
-0.0049714213,
-0.0101199914,
-0.0605900288,
0.0192665327,
0.0311187003,
0.0086607663,
-0.0020099194,
0.0114499889,
-0.0314488821,
-0.0111354832,
0.0196650885,
-0.0131236799,
-0.0613551661,
-0.0232553836,
0.0448000655,
-0.0363665074,
0.0394491889,
-0.0521868914,
0.0277541634,
0.0265870728,
-0.0571869947,
0.0394959114,
-0.0399221145,
0.0708181262,
-0.0248200037,
0.0479143523,
0.0245335605,
-0.016654579,
-0.0002017451,
0.0012424749,
-0.0621151626,
0.0054975413,
0.0658895895,
0.004149369,
-0.0762557462,
0.0252346322,
0.0094791297,
-0.0160461403,
-0.008167576,
-0.0585422702,
0.0176171958,
-0.0143894916,
0.0176285617,
-0.0053487886,
-0.035422653,
0.0068804701,
0.015244782,
-0.0248526949,
-0.0056449031,
0.0171443745,
0.0275187269,
0.0133105246,
-0.0597982481,
0.0110130487,
-0.0500286892,
-0.0292872116,
0.0957990885,
0.0015008688,
-0.0120556327,
0.077026397,
0.0058007664,
-0.0012604381,
-0.057276886,
0.0069534993,
0.0163522158,
0.0557353348,
0.0637695566,
0.1417930722,
-0.001191249,
0.0110670989,
-0.0549095981,
-0.0172547288,
-0.0003226118,
0.049821116,
0.0242626686,
-0.0115609067,
0.0042837304,
0.0129836155,
-0.0638704151,
0.0581184551,
-0.0436488166,
0.0135972146,
0.040206451,
0.0193746686,
0.0047236294,
0.0385070182,
0.0472307205,
-0.0424810573,
0.0159992687,
0.0165253673,
-0.0142064216,
0.0542371087,
0.0126849171,
0.0362109058,
-0.0268772971,
0.0511365235,
0.0594791174,
-0.0155256717,
-0.0020572813,
-0.0005424746,
0.0557507016,
0.0296561811,
-0.0314387195,
0.0207670778,
-0.0294130314,
0.0187181197,
-0.0285761505,
-0.0050371536,
0.0224208515,
-0.0033538183,
-0.0594147593,
-0.0081907427,
-0.0185425151,
0.010910335,
-0.0304792132,
-0.0275512859,
-0.0073768371,
0.0277168471,
-0.0222054794,
0.0276741609,
-0.0417898223,
-0.0343053341,
-0.0081916712,
-0.0734812841,
0.0161944758,
0.0684735775,
2.455e-7,
-0.0033117358,
0.0374433175,
0.009036798,
0.0278431829,
0.0088772243,
0.0613418147,
-0.0246684141,
0.0125110121,
-0.0182864945,
-0.1113452092,
-0.0325320736,
0.0636284351,
0.0326661132,
0.0410100743,
0.0260076579,
0.0217621848,
-0.0233814809,
-0.0611954778,
-0.054194577,
0.0118654631,
0.0295177493,
0.052841235,
0.010694257,
-0.0426539406,
0.0280088317,
-0.0613771789,
0.0625524968,
0.0208579712,
-0.0552705117,
-0.0420948081,
0.0301982127,
-0.0065906951,
0.0013667509,
0.0281520374,
0.0012846087,
-0.0554909222,
0.0103760688,
0.0305490941,
-0.0109268781,
-0.050518807,
-0.0614409894,
-0.0042103869,
-0.0328535587,
-0.0364229754,
0.0686707646,
0.0003961968,
-0.0236927941,
-0.0620982759,
-0.0260251816,
0.0172364358,
0.0418328829,
-0.0165031105,
-0.0432943329,
0.017800292,
0.0293855537,
0.0049101878,
-0.0258180536,
-0.0565734245,
-0.0107907271,
-0.0070775212,
-0.0435634591,
-0.0610859208,
0.0054496019,
-0.0237123985,
0.0610070601,
-0.050302051,
-0.0534585379,
1.859280103e-34,
0.0496196672,
-0.0308988765,
0.0154906427,
-0.0520714112,
0.0254120193,
0.0182033069,
-0.0590981506,
-0.0345985778,
-0.0023073319,
-0.0252226498,
-0.015686946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11285v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11285v1 | Self and Cross-Model Distillation for LLMs: Effective Methods for Refusal Pattern Alignment | 2024-06-17T07:46:45 | 2024-06-17T07:46:45 | Jie Li, Yi Liu, Chongyang Liu, Xiaoning Ren, Ling Shi, Weisong Sun, Yinxing Xue | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) like OpenAI's GPT series, Anthropic's Claude,
and Meta's LLaMa have shown remarkable capabilities in text generation.
However, their susceptibility to toxic prompts presents significant security
challenges. This paper investigates alignment techniques, including Supervised
Fine-Tuning (SFT) and Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF), to
mitigate these risks. We conduct an empirical study on refusal patterns across
nine LLMs, revealing that models with uniform refusal patterns, such as
Claude3, exhibit higher security. Based on these findings, we propose
self-distilling and cross-model distilling methods to enhance LLM security. Our
results show that these methods significantly improve refusal rates and reduce
unsafe content, with cross-model distilling achieving refusal rates close to
Claude3's 94.51%. These findings underscore the potential of distillation-based
alignment in securing LLMs against toxic prompts. | [
0.0382680036,
0.0621730126,
-0.0138966804,
0.0217257701,
-0.0477212444,
-0.0020123741,
0.0098561272,
-0.0076855952,
0.003633718,
-0.0145555194,
-0.0367012173,
-0.0475463122,
-0.0025622288,
0.0435406379,
0.0046598497,
-0.0026419575,
0.0313994251,
-0.0629708767,
0.0197805874,
-0.0157874394,
0.0245980471,
0.0029529841,
-0.0070288274,
0.0464190245,
0.0165394954,
-0.025425503,
-0.0431002714,
0.0174460448,
0.0249493606,
-0.0558492653,
0.0006843834,
0.0832520947,
-0.0020341203,
0.0920368508,
0.0000022533,
-0.0825222805,
-0.0280388687,
0.0067264228,
-0.0240361877,
0.0263238885,
-0.006760281,
-0.0239117965,
-0.0249428824,
0.0428716429,
-0.0247333813,
0.0451320447,
0.0622100607,
0.0573737882,
0.0856138617,
0.0517598391,
0.0129194483,
0.0222092643,
0.0214770529,
-0.0221442003,
0.004150073,
-0.0217819922,
0.0271155946,
-0.0463119671,
0.0190009233,
-0.01846743,
-0.0287584551,
0.0136435069,
0.0173513442,
-0.025401758,
-0.0484304465,
-0.0020493863,
-0.0379846133,
-0.0674513951,
-0.0313316509,
0.0773018003,
-0.0040216255,
-0.0087759765,
-0.0099095348,
-0.0309155472,
0.0247911382,
0.04417786,
-0.0252510104,
0.0493641198,
-0.0071635479,
0.0227411538,
-0.0196946394,
-0.0024288304,
0.0174575485,
0.0220773797,
0.017304305,
0.0469126254,
0.0177652817,
-0.0529122241,
0.0091693942,
-0.0013003038,
0.0186665915,
-0.0703730807,
0.0179606788,
0.0145125967,
-0.0436881557,
0.0070994799,
-0.077665858,
0.0160441604,
0.0579294972,
0.0057065189,
0.0489472151,
0.044628676,
-0.0040488229,
-0.0269618295,
0.0036933105,
0.0334494002,
-0.0258543827,
0.0678595454,
0.0099750943,
0.057781551,
-0.0271663424,
0.0020629754,
-0.0356626958,
0.0358153395,
-0.0415680632,
-0.0129785212,
-0.0521812551,
0.0354346,
-0.0250017159,
0.0163682923,
0.0161241572,
-0.0080311289,
-0.0287414957,
0.0092368312,
-0.0310813654,
-0.0186508391,
-0.0225046203,
-0.0085822716,
0.0403329693,
-0.0645328611,
-0.026886398,
0.0006179062,
-0.0156765357,
-0.0380246565,
-0.0205440577,
0.0864356682,
0.007221892,
-0.0189581942,
-0.057630375,
-0.0604656115,
-0.0418116786,
-0.0518521816,
-0.0093264757,
-0.0489757918,
-0.0178069193,
-0.0391266607,
-0.0302406438,
-0.0735850856,
0.0022900754,
0.0301890243,
-0.0146612069,
0.0592851341,
0.0004848919,
-0.0218324792,
0.0232548509,
0.0333261564,
-0.0162981134,
0.0595724881,
0.0314778648,
0.0686598197,
0.0369400233,
-0.0032555559,
0.0666144565,
0.0236342624,
0.0472673811,
0.0520250872,
-0.0230269544,
-0.007673136,
0.0098285452,
0.0101384325,
0.0324548371,
0.0888666436,
-0.0144170662,
-0.0203779284,
0.1183236614,
0.030048864,
-0.0156240324,
-0.0033447722,
0.0135571994,
0.0158833675,
-0.0266533494,
0.0423257463,
-0.0703899041,
0.0207224116,
-0.054504931,
0.0247004181,
0.0536841676,
0.0659845024,
-0.0031800007,
-0.0306664947,
0.0108839357,
-0.0111424578,
0.0069241049,
0.0082185045,
-0.0092396159,
0.0225688722,
-0.0247863121,
-0.0154763656,
0.0301015545,
-0.04704706,
-0.0214696992,
-0.0860434026,
0.0491254553,
0.0643006712,
0.0607646182,
0.0180411674,
0.0192916542,
-0.0292078108,
-0.0306905471,
0.0575597323,
0.0350518189,
0.0059852777,
0.0089678252,
-0.0498711951,
-0.0567015931,
0.0053897616,
-0.0089965872,
0.0090032881,
0.0167611726,
0.0409106649,
0.0223533921,
-0.0009421066,
-0.0376481935,
0.0467367023,
0.0002250463,
-0.0834490955,
0.0058478513,
0.0351451971,
0.0359238312,
0.0025385653,
-0.0081216637,
0.0228645764,
0.0108398227,
0.0234879851,
0.0165106952,
-0.0622610822,
-0.0453700125,
-0.0148565434,
0.0324410535,
-0.0090469476,
-0.0109112486,
0.0310240649,
-0.0241117459,
-0.027088305,
-0.0040009352,
-0.0153607754,
0.0076359296,
-0.0477972068,
0.0417260602,
0.010379496,
0.0281321537,
-0.0447778255,
0.0269932821,
-0.0144052012,
-0.0285679922,
0.0324358605,
-0.0120718619,
0.0214880127,
-0.0488596037,
-0.0452485234,
0.0160362814,
-0.0133495256,
0.0494732559,
0.0425007865,
0.0377686173,
-0.0325890593,
-0.0213395879,
0.0074936226,
0.0047482187,
-0.0142178144,
0.0147207184,
0.0022469729,
0.0136692571,
-0.0426152833,
-0.0082418937,
-0.0371371992,
-0.0384575762,
0.0105803153,
0.0140579417,
0.0253994744,
-0.0024872327,
-0.0507351048,
-0.043667689,
-0.0023251621,
0.0010774105,
0.0154282292,
-0.0113928178,
0.0248304848,
-0.0412412658,
0.0319557488,
-0.0311166402,
0.0230264813,
0.0363554545,
-0.0486116149,
0.0421111435,
0.0169938989,
-0.012552727,
0.0444213375,
0.0219273586,
0.0254478753,
0.0801080912,
0.0205389597,
-0.0507403873,
0.0083077829,
-0.0018362866,
-0.0189804398,
0.0017871202,
-0.0237897411,
0.0317816883,
0.0524422601,
0.0205210578,
-0.0088987621,
-0.0573323071,
0.0598444268,
0.0201151241,
-0.053640265,
0.013485699,
-0.0179438163,
-0.05908411,
0.0349766202,
-0.0211929884,
-0.0897082165,
0.0905438289,
-0.0605310015,
0.0336411893,
-0.0193297602,
-0.0223748274,
0.0124749439,
0.0404568203,
-0.010969175,
0.0259266254,
0.069791764,
-0.0043825689,
-0.0658774748,
-0.0295444429,
0.0436731577,
-0.0162794217,
0.0165069457,
-0.0412013941,
-0.0129403723,
-0.0244414397,
-0.0464839041,
-0.066115059,
-0.0541311316,
-0.0065717301,
-0.0078935195,
0.0131681645,
-0.0202035122,
-0.002410939,
-0.0131849423,
0.0121751204,
0.0052702674,
-0.0282052942,
-0.0157292932,
-0.0430794656,
0.030534042,
0.0785417035,
0.0039450442,
0.0159227829,
-0.0291439556,
0.0439603031,
0.0506654605,
0.014030939,
0.0114482259,
-0.0036271948,
0.0206339639,
0.0258150641,
-0.0266991761,
0.0016237628,
0.0659028664,
0.0289611965,
-0.0286249928,
-0.0272990447,
0.0594710112,
0.0249589197,
-0.0060599805,
0.0079138232,
-0.0115542505,
0.1109485999,
-0.0097007109,
0.0136888027,
-0.0750366971,
-0.0176698416,
0.0265083946,
0.0762388706,
-0.0278278943,
-0.0046710931,
-0.0319339819,
-0.1259200275,
0.0411059447,
0.0173164345,
-0.0466793664,
-0.035655465,
-0.0046862294,
-0.0120595004,
0.0136368573,
0.0423392281,
0.0035706188,
-0.0067538633,
0.0055312915,
0.0254163891,
-0.0096606975,
-0.0498550683,
-0.0122249648,
-0.0379839465,
0.0479355007,
0.0704728812,
0.0017204051,
0.0178037304,
-0.0543753207,
0.0345014632,
-0.0197924394,
0.0003444373,
0.0031500598,
0.0191685166,
-0.0087964982,
0.000691008,
-0.0282030515,
0.0525901057,
-0.006251331,
-0.0488679297,
0.0272636469,
0.0786291063,
-0.0193715934,
-0.0101764016,
-0.0493503921,
0.0005375139,
0.0511069819,
0.06788674,
0.0468204319,
-0.0576210544,
-0.0359171294,
-0.0499734245,
-0.0217376165,
-0.0628107488,
-0.0055096932,
0.0270563513,
-0.0158377625,
-0.0169364009,
-0.0692368373,
-0.017572483,
-0.014604196,
0.0586921237,
0.0244156327,
-0.0077615683,
0.0066169314,
0.0281044636,
0.0088234395,
-0.0141995503,
-0.0405970551,
0.0161455255,
-0.0954106003,
0.0171437617,
-0.0308862161,
-0.0580446571,
0.0011167222,
0.0261082407,
-0.0563177243,
-0.1030791998,
0.0016956102,
0.0716561973,
0.0372925289,
0.0217141099,
0.0067137592,
-0.0628284067,
0.0890409425,
0.0495000072,
-0.0019451736,
-0.0008424611,
0.0234042369,
-0.0172939487,
-0.0096432278,
0.0147169391,
-0.0252827108,
-0.0103572942,
0.0448509082,
0.0314470232,
-0.024730552,
-0.0371713787,
0.0290251933,
0.0524372049,
-0.0057936246,
-0.0453063399,
0.0269785076,
-0.0374905765,
0.0384119116,
0.0087217288,
0.0035652365,
-0.0235599503,
0.0050622704,
0.0309774987,
-0.0457847342,
0.023138836,
-0.0322367884,
-0.0208755024,
0.035183534,
-0.0242903065,
0.0284566246,
0.0024864958,
0.0682028681,
0.0395618044,
0.001686429,
0.0020502836,
0.0555902421,
-0.0150839482,
0.0266962983,
0.0068068062,
0.0696150288,
0.0103678377,
0.0352424607,
0.0043717423,
0.0541287884,
-0.0602883063,
-0.0518052727,
-0.0305708852,
0.0173947997,
-0.003608312,
0.0194239095,
0.0146810804,
-0.0211122427,
0.0049562925,
-0.0311039444,
0.0278198998,
0.0066585178,
-0.0122354683,
0.027242871,
-0.0027063896,
-0.025827352,
-0.0187958535,
0.0656171739,
-0.009072002,
0.0201182347,
-0.0097587872,
-0.0173700191,
-0.0401670709,
-0.0429042466,
0.0377680883,
0.0097504761,
-0.0364441872,
-0.0555637181,
-0.0715631917,
-0.0681892633,
-0.0384808369,
0.0380924307,
0.009873746,
-0.0063737044,
0.0209500808,
0.0131380726,
-0.0064169676,
0.0015786773,
-0.028531488,
-0.024016086,
0.0129253259,
-0.0378327072,
-0.0088439239,
-6.456588597e-33,
-0.011153358,
-0.0290085487,
-0.004611813,
0.0018573322,
-0.004268399,
-0.0323034152,
-0.0123233125,
0.0056128036,
0.0172299203,
-0.008935798,
-0.0342761874,
-0.0204345174,
0.019901393,
0.0266622715,
0.0004195068,
-0.0111124953,
0.0347657874,
-0.0110235047,
-0.0620690472,
0.0229995921,
0.0336836576,
0.01238521,
-0.0183298048,
-0.0585419796,
0.0297838692,
-0.014297314,
-0.0421822779,
-0.037167836,
-0.0741545781,
0.0901683867,
-0.0172411483,
0.0311481655,
0.0052884934,
-0.0237530693,
-0.0108776558,
0.0721877888,
0.0004812046,
-0.0385583825,
0.000394401,
-0.0263041258,
-0.0155940317,
-0.0721651614,
0.0470751561,
-0.014324706,
-0.0489874221,
0.0340468623,
-0.0110390466,
-0.0111160967,
-0.0271404367,
-0.0253880695,
-0.0653355867,
0.0064235185,
-0.0053395354,
-0.0557052344,
0.0031900692,
-0.0024444619,
0.0048460821,
-0.0147209447,
-0.0204664785,
0.0461407304,
0.0518816635,
0.0230731703,
0.065531753,
0.015754072,
-0.0395075344,
0.0483289137,
-0.0198762603,
-0.028632367,
0.0367675275,
-0.0439575016,
-0.0004789958,
0.0511568934,
0.0011017725,
0.0669421256,
0.0437168069,
-0.0277205985,
-0.0377358422,
0.0632129014,
-0.0056297309,
0.0156982057,
0.0322464146,
-0.017178962,
-0.0190125201,
-0.0034745601,
-0.0290092062,
-0.0201830249,
-0.0282816347,
-0.0288064927,
0.0627239645,
0.0203654431,
-0.0419993661,
-0.0420534983,
0.0212800093,
-0.0392194688,
-0.0364354253,
0.0080275396,
-0.0266997404,
-0.0189223774,
-0.011110981,
-0.013434859,
-0.0392434038,
-0.0186850578,
0.0191212371,
-0.0307201222,
0.0215790682,
0.0089274198,
0.034181457,
0.0450314134,
-0.0940202549,
0.0359098874,
-0.0264897067,
0.0647144392,
0.0453156941,
0.0182229392,
0.0254676994,
-0.0695428252,
0.0055068526,
-0.0120390076,
0.0056508025,
-0.0411882587,
-0.0593913831,
0.0349079631,
-0.0008058622,
0.0360554196,
0.0039896416,
0.0245309155,
0.0072347512,
0.0482702553,
0.0415764935,
-0.04783969,
-0.0043051047,
-0.0141183147,
2.973e-7,
-0.0142972497,
0.0102005489,
0.0516294986,
0.0181194134,
-0.001995089,
0.0573955774,
-0.0202205423,
0.0640286803,
-0.025469128,
-0.0265172347,
0.0112151615,
-0.0119489143,
0.0510042943,
0.027322676,
-0.0478231683,
0.028625695,
-0.0896267593,
0.0316586345,
-0.067083925,
-0.0050630504,
0.0543858632,
0.0842365921,
-0.0128800636,
-0.0389929935,
0.0198862664,
-0.0365216397,
0.0300502367,
0.003235708,
0.016847536,
0.0152829802,
0.0253541898,
-0.0259980094,
-0.0040166476,
0.0047531966,
-0.0365154818,
0.0068395324,
-0.0556647927,
0.0358596779,
0.0163960457,
-0.0424478762,
0.008904079,
-0.0067563485,
0.0090530403,
-0.0552382134,
0.0380278714,
0.0255912133,
-0.0037516218,
-0.0217229128,
0.0297332853,
-0.0612257309,
0.0444579199,
-0.0412067734,
0.0079502258,
0.0145436209,
-0.0025334654,
0.0222369675,
0.0050179833,
-0.0418884903,
-0.0065938542,
-0.0563183911,
-0.0060068928,
-0.0492169075,
-0.0392293707,
-0.0040212502,
0.0073502148,
-0.0495917685,
-0.001890311,
2.998893867e-34,
0.0203045849,
-0.0563948564,
0.0316279009,
0.0098673338,
0.0228676666,
0.0230209436,
-0.0072379406,
0.021397246,
0.0276761055,
-0.0188128427,
-0.0442475565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11278v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11278v1 | Do Not Design, Learn: A Trainable Scoring Function for Uncertainty Estimation in Generative LLMs | 2024-06-17T07:30:40 | 2024-06-17T07:30:40 | Duygu Nur Yaldiz, Yavuz Faruk Bakman, Baturalp Buyukates, Chenyang Tao, Anil Ramakrishna, Dimitrios Dimitriadis, Salman Avestimehr | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we introduce the Learnable Response Scoring Function (LARS) for
Uncertainty Estimation (UE) in generative Large Language Models (LLMs). Current
scoring functions for probability-based UE, such as length-normalized scoring
and semantic contribution-based weighting, are designed to solve specific
aspects of the problem but exhibit limitations, including the inability to
handle biased probabilities and under-performance in low-resource languages
like Turkish. To address these issues, we propose LARS, a scoring function that
leverages supervised data to capture complex dependencies between tokens and
probabilities, thereby producing more reliable and calibrated response scores
in computing the uncertainty of generations. Our extensive experiments across
multiple datasets show that LARS substantially outperforms existing scoring
functions considering various probability-based UE methods. | [
0.0314182565,
0.1248000637,
-0.0054410333,
0.0161744673,
-0.0249590799,
0.0145602012,
-0.0036611042,
-0.0187364779,
-0.0505630746,
-0.0320457071,
-0.0039711879,
-0.1056960523,
0.0048215329,
0.015853852,
0.022045223,
-0.037294697,
0.0326495953,
-0.0409416296,
0.0386887565,
-0.0323851854,
-0.0211182833,
-0.0045453315,
-0.001134606,
0.0485275909,
-0.0597502887,
0.0127695585,
0.0238519385,
0.0241536144,
0.0282301754,
-0.016096171,
0.0222337861,
0.0539301895,
-0.0130054327,
0.0515987948,
0.0000016766,
-0.0671828911,
-0.0149703063,
-0.0051713535,
-0.0120587964,
-0.0082197888,
0.0751166493,
0.0437744707,
-0.042627506,
0.0252556242,
-0.0247563906,
-0.0028175022,
0.0383216366,
-0.0089788698,
0.0020300071,
0.0554964691,
0.018845465,
-0.0564397536,
0.0452024043,
-0.045861531,
0.0550886542,
-0.0475858189,
0.0143732363,
0.0057098176,
-0.0696809515,
-0.0218300633,
-0.0151123581,
0.0426324382,
0.0044790129,
-0.0475328229,
-0.0047546597,
-0.0016989678,
0.0161207952,
-0.0431808084,
0.0316469707,
0.0300971381,
0.0173588488,
-0.0115559679,
-0.0334918573,
-0.0190098099,
0.0111917341,
0.0218311846,
-0.023645224,
0.0435252376,
0.016084332,
0.0267852675,
0.0232676342,
0.0070846905,
0.0286082216,
-0.0135492049,
-0.0063589285,
0.0825851485,
0.0380756818,
0.0142953359,
-0.0225433987,
0.0197873339,
-0.0296080168,
-0.0328672864,
-0.0138181094,
0.0374926738,
-0.0496750511,
0.0334691107,
-0.0375518389,
-0.0237959586,
0.0245404337,
-0.0045935363,
0.0140595026,
0.0117877387,
-0.0004896456,
0.0124042248,
-0.032329794,
0.0233967714,
0.0427069031,
-0.0514077768,
-0.0515205637,
-0.0362082198,
-0.009715789,
0.0036702033,
-0.0073890081,
0.0135106659,
-0.0293194372,
0.0138939964,
-0.0832777768,
0.0266845338,
-0.0155219818,
0.0054262872,
0.033851169,
0.016271824,
-0.0468916893,
-0.020913098,
-0.0510438271,
0.0092429006,
-0.0202920306,
-0.006673113,
-0.0116349533,
-0.0707487091,
0.0186051019,
0.0322525352,
-0.0025389728,
0.0265482217,
0.0005729617,
0.0669621974,
-0.0063892142,
-0.0252839942,
-0.0327556543,
-0.0016883352,
-0.0616188273,
-0.071871452,
-0.0040510022,
-0.0620788485,
-0.0207559895,
0.0109531889,
-0.0091915419,
-0.0644182935,
0.0161304586,
-0.0029834895,
-0.0343985446,
0.0480758473,
0.0203768928,
0.0235995799,
0.0099063246,
-0.0137569625,
0.0004943738,
0.0893275514,
0.0610661991,
-0.0010868892,
0.0444089547,
0.0376458131,
-0.0045375652,
0.0307060182,
0.0105528124,
0.0068837339,
-0.0118264491,
-0.0098828059,
0.0072620255,
0.0274787042,
0.044586502,
0.0509302802,
0.0161817446,
0.0147197554,
0.0732510909,
0.018693706,
-0.0076865936,
-0.0194813851,
0.0447395965,
-0.0160980839,
0.0058881463,
-0.0001294291,
-0.0178839043,
0.0218550414,
-0.007579281,
0.0282961912,
0.0436956771,
0.0329396613,
-0.0086045386,
-0.0876992643,
-0.0209061671,
-0.0151977688,
-0.0311020836,
0.016930975,
0.0628830567,
-0.0121986838,
-0.0220271349,
0.0254515372,
0.0141361579,
-0.0478660166,
0.0489868261,
-0.0704548806,
0.0772683844,
0.0420064777,
0.0361604244,
-0.0163535923,
-0.0192454308,
0.0131329792,
-0.0197603051,
0.03650916,
0.001824746,
-0.03008903,
0.032353092,
-0.0352246165,
-0.0281473193,
0.0249004997,
0.0407945774,
0.0160612427,
0.0198563244,
-0.0146615952,
0.0399766341,
-0.0441722386,
0.0122911641,
0.0219278354,
0.0194663927,
-0.0109048961,
0.0564892329,
-0.029456133,
0.0559831336,
0.0146006029,
-0.0117544532,
0.0388096757,
0.0311319251,
-0.0204370935,
-0.0204466134,
-0.0147129456,
-0.0318906046,
-0.0029168387,
0.0656101033,
0.0028222811,
-0.0305554755,
-0.0322735421,
-0.0527186915,
-0.0581935234,
0.0377736725,
-0.0454883575,
0.0104299011,
-0.0479906425,
0.032824412,
0.0009574147,
-0.0135218976,
-0.0774929002,
0.0755367056,
-0.0174671244,
0.0285943821,
-0.0004693634,
0.0108641787,
0.029165145,
-0.0290493798,
-0.0386406258,
-0.0172349401,
-0.0089289527,
-0.0023368252,
0.042085357,
0.0150631564,
-0.0247047506,
-0.0170962587,
-0.045349516,
0.0034829776,
-0.0257082805,
0.0517731011,
0.0025817985,
-0.0009485847,
-0.0221663378,
-0.0049118819,
-0.0389489271,
0.0221525859,
0.0138963321,
0.0124805542,
0.0245397352,
-0.0153874056,
-0.0075980122,
-0.0589044616,
-0.0167630911,
0.0057092127,
0.0196591653,
0.0094516445,
0.0046527386,
-0.0754850805,
0.0415670834,
-0.0565252975,
0.020641081,
-0.0002524366,
-0.0404110141,
0.0267038438,
-0.010482287,
0.1044877395,
0.0153436614,
0.0246771425,
-0.0175185204,
0.0343134664,
-0.0373623259,
-0.047200948,
-0.0052943532,
-0.0617991574,
-0.0535073839,
-0.0316896848,
-0.0345614478,
-0.0227375161,
0.0480861738,
0.0014984941,
-0.0683572218,
-0.0563460402,
0.0231604632,
-0.018858131,
-0.0184921902,
0.0098433513,
0.0161597021,
-0.022674175,
0.0407312028,
0.0009758453,
-0.0701549128,
0.0591917336,
-0.0525482371,
0.0242940914,
-0.0108550107,
0.0148426462,
-0.0090096444,
0.0550444722,
0.0199418031,
0.0101560913,
0.0031932755,
0.0015099103,
-0.0814757049,
0.0233106837,
0.0554483272,
-0.0453202277,
0.0425856337,
-0.0762782469,
0.0056972648,
0.0024151166,
-0.0039814301,
-0.0463235565,
-0.004254187,
-0.0203564614,
0.0211608801,
0.0590344816,
-0.035027612,
-0.0116306879,
-0.0219069924,
0.0143550709,
-0.005784174,
-0.0303408224,
-0.0102728009,
-0.0057375506,
0.0318632498,
0.0643510073,
0.0005178213,
0.0610910878,
-0.000156681,
-0.014667524,
0.0437863208,
0.0128806951,
0.0220758505,
-0.0156522542,
-0.0183029622,
0.0699302256,
-0.0068398057,
-0.0174362473,
0.0438186601,
0.0758952275,
-0.0173318852,
0.0021088631,
0.124157235,
0.0183913298,
0.0112547344,
-0.0024855777,
-0.0416735746,
0.0609888397,
0.0249169581,
0.0262793228,
-0.0386380106,
-0.0199035816,
0.0146981366,
0.0324351974,
-0.025563471,
-0.0223894864,
0.0226243548,
-0.1329963356,
0.048941303,
-0.0061501767,
-0.0446254313,
-0.0214431081,
-0.0367958248,
0.0159523245,
-0.0245639253,
0.019439565,
0.0136912121,
-0.0026998874,
0.0285175927,
0.03351973,
-0.0581047274,
-0.0801014304,
-0.0225962587,
-0.0464492142,
0.0785737559,
0.0577242337,
0.0061601638,
0.0123090986,
-0.0167406537,
0.0278861057,
-0.0515401922,
-0.0482426472,
-0.0216167253,
0.0135257719,
0.0359526463,
0.0038913121,
-0.0270503424,
0.008491897,
-0.028083574,
-0.0035120165,
-0.026898684,
0.0506848805,
-0.0024869896,
0.0026870253,
-0.0179059859,
-0.0035104095,
0.0182307158,
0.0727329552,
0.0075781122,
-0.0335231349,
-0.0111364489,
-0.0541976653,
0.0284159761,
-0.0487050712,
0.0167287216,
0.001409597,
-0.0146944113,
-0.0419149213,
-0.094933331,
0.0025735546,
-0.0030789534,
-0.013857536,
-0.0171696972,
0.0127849178,
-0.0251915883,
-0.0205841195,
-0.0374380983,
-0.0166253634,
-0.0313960165,
0.0015990817,
-0.0594741739,
0.0038983077,
0.0624951869,
0.0037376466,
-0.0194253121,
0.0420750529,
-0.1050899848,
-0.0835096538,
-0.0039446997,
0.0846529156,
0.0234092455,
-0.0003900804,
-0.0182524361,
-0.0677730441,
0.0939770862,
0.067570284,
-0.0179072656,
0.0017001058,
0.0225615557,
0.0350263566,
-0.0263930038,
0.0337086655,
-0.0445845127,
-0.0050151069,
0.0298845004,
0.0682903379,
-0.0222915392,
-0.0519660935,
-0.0173078496,
0.0086192507,
0.043914739,
-0.0829207376,
-0.0219609626,
-0.0387297347,
0.0264441893,
-0.0270160437,
-0.0210765209,
-0.0343782455,
-0.0019004999,
0.0364391692,
-0.0108563062,
-0.0202775262,
-0.0079322932,
-0.0107513061,
0.0608683228,
-0.0201518685,
-0.0122096697,
0.0383376405,
0.0063574435,
0.0221067499,
0.0018270686,
0.0145124262,
0.0065514566,
0.0070334063,
0.0004021877,
0.0198532194,
0.0137986895,
-0.0179845002,
-0.0024646977,
0.0239507221,
-0.0123987142,
-0.0494872741,
-0.0399183892,
-0.0501047634,
0.0483329594,
0.0674355775,
0.0433025546,
0.0583853573,
-0.0097135967,
-0.007283628,
-0.0462249331,
0.0186244547,
0.0080872681,
-0.0256326925,
0.0688596368,
-0.0089502633,
-0.0213955473,
0.0341054164,
0.0850018188,
0.0059908181,
0.0409402288,
-0.0592651106,
-0.0266124979,
-0.0068061007,
-0.0512395203,
-0.0059189564,
0.0117474925,
-0.0261145607,
0.0101829004,
-0.0537122861,
-0.0851281062,
-0.0082666166,
0.071009621,
0.016224049,
-0.0170272905,
0.0253481306,
0.0411461666,
-0.0167891234,
-0.0179208964,
-0.0743570104,
-0.0135884508,
-0.0219316501,
-0.0032823617,
-0.0285729077,
-6.304770563e-33,
-0.0357061327,
-0.0314455517,
-0.0260214433,
-0.0409220085,
-0.012101748,
-0.0141745256,
-0.0130159687,
0.0365603864,
0.0104872901,
0.0238484554,
0.0004465922,
-0.0057236585,
0.0147100724,
0.044779066,
0.0234786943,
-0.0409608632,
0.0438052453,
-0.0111011481,
0.0169847254,
0.0107156644,
0.0380742438,
-0.0094310753,
0.0535204746,
-0.0271227397,
0.0676915273,
-0.0040995595,
-0.035005182,
0.0652802214,
0.0045379368,
0.0577464402,
-0.0105582327,
0.0696540996,
-0.005412919,
-0.0351204909,
-0.0222214684,
-0.0433469899,
-0.0652106404,
-0.0269516353,
0.0116208009,
0.0159284398,
-0.0083884876,
-0.0161557607,
0.0287922136,
0.0221243296,
-0.054008536,
-0.0107103614,
0.0288161281,
-0.0202454217,
-0.0320128314,
-0.0682853833,
-0.0417655893,
0.0271367431,
0.020435987,
-0.0076415064,
-0.0200166944,
-0.0044808704,
0.0250174589,
-0.0085158898,
-0.0044852435,
-0.0032276444,
-0.011653007,
0.0697745606,
0.0670418069,
0.0248659868,
-0.0073994505,
0.0149793802,
-0.0162035953,
-0.0336035043,
-0.0264940392,
-0.0323060341,
0.0082280347,
0.0052603395,
0.0315256268,
0.0853101164,
-0.0016739817,
0.0090845674,
-0.0894003287,
0.0646327138,
0.0345236883,
0.0612274595,
0.0038125296,
0.0456806459,
0.0034236766,
-0.0131760612,
-0.0489746854,
-0.0548519976,
-0.0095572192,
-0.0171903186,
-0.0113135194,
-0.014349333,
-0.0279199462,
-0.0476434343,
0.0367226303,
-0.0272096172,
-0.0272300113,
-0.0180247258,
-0.0069257715,
0.0092912614,
0.01246153,
0.0542416312,
-0.0105834985,
-0.0103786085,
0.0372208804,
-0.0210771859,
-0.008222606,
0.0110378601,
0.013660416,
0.0079774614,
-0.0842582658,
0.027655296,
-0.0371880755,
0.0343906879,
-0.0234734286,
0.0184418485,
0.0319076851,
-0.0267663114,
0.0082491729,
0.0174802672,
0.0166304652,
0.0460281223,
0.0084411157,
0.0018359802,
-0.0176343955,
-0.0048215785,
-0.0449435823,
0.0113679068,
0.0132292509,
-0.001591321,
0.0142310029,
-0.0053137778,
-0.0244419277,
0.0280647222,
2.432e-7,
0.0799247399,
0.0357411727,
0.0088593094,
0.038187284,
0.0336664021,
0.0243768785,
0.0115723517,
-0.0221301448,
0.0427422449,
0.021928791,
0.0247395337,
-0.0270741899,
0.0471318066,
0.0420085602,
-0.0860145688,
-0.0208779853,
-0.0307956487,
0.0173632875,
0.0157339219,
0.0242616031,
0.0705269352,
0.1131133884,
-0.0090117948,
-0.0078232568,
-0.0032010942,
-0.004661527,
0.0676402301,
-0.0480983257,
-0.0439704582,
0.0346230939,
0.0490601696,
-0.0092418827,
0.0199453682,
0.0165348258,
-0.0296711884,
0.0056969062,
-0.0059829275,
0.0561798774,
0.041720137,
-0.0197290704,
-0.0022013863,
0.0013558152,
0.0451747626,
-0.0647934005,
0.0562112369,
-0.0144788064,
-0.032067854,
-0.0312421694,
-0.0096763829,
-0.0114661725,
0.0162457973,
-0.0296184644,
-0.0477248654,
0.0214013308,
0.0248609073,
0.0202165153,
-0.0362230688,
-0.0465578027,
-0.0294665471,
0.0030234826,
-0.0526541248,
-0.0736567453,
0.0142133348,
0.0143025611,
0.0113952477,
-0.0487307571,
0.0019155992,
2.004688525e-34,
0.0600110479,
-0.0035710856,
-0.0315044001,
-0.0179219414,
0.0458415858,
0.0147996414,
0.0003203099,
0.0281048752,
0.0196315236,
-0.051850494,
-0.020094689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11277v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11277v1 | Small Agent Can Also Rock! Empowering Small Language Models as Hallucination Detector | 2024-06-17T07:30:05 | 2024-06-17T07:30:05 | Xiaoxue Cheng, Junyi Li, Wayne Xin Zhao, Hongzhi Zhang, Fuzheng Zhang, Di Zhang, Kun Gai, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Hallucination detection is a challenging task for large language models
(LLMs), and existing studies heavily rely on powerful closed-source LLMs such
as GPT-4. In this paper, we propose an autonomous LLM-based agent framework,
called HaluAgent, which enables relatively smaller LLMs (e.g. Baichuan2-Chat
7B) to actively select suitable tools for detecting multiple hallucination
types such as text, code, and mathematical expression. In HaluAgent, we
integrate the LLM, multi-functional toolbox, and design a fine-grained
three-stage detection framework along with memory mechanism. To facilitate the
effectiveness of HaluAgent, we leverage existing Chinese and English datasets
to synthesize detection trajectories for fine-tuning, which endows HaluAgent
with the capability for bilingual hallucination detection. Extensive
experiments demonstrate that only using 2K samples for tuning LLMs, HaluAgent
can perform hallucination detection on various types of tasks and datasets,
achieving performance comparable to or even higher than GPT-4 without tool
enhancements on both in-domain and out-of-domain datasets. We release our
dataset and code at https://github.com/RUCAIBox/HaluAgent. | [
-0.0104030902,
0.0438162573,
-0.0125441775,
0.0732159168,
-0.0340835005,
0.0234135706,
-0.0073969779,
0.0211162101,
0.0482767485,
-0.010572765,
-0.0311677605,
-0.0143060898,
-0.0112672681,
-0.0014988042,
0.0341826677,
-0.0259462371,
0.06142525,
-0.0351263657,
0.0000615703,
-0.014203839,
0.0115379719,
-0.0128049627,
-0.0010350889,
0.0601240955,
-0.0027119194,
-0.0522077568,
-0.0114856325,
-0.000444635,
0.0214845166,
-0.0006956372,
-0.0070335018,
0.0625964776,
-0.0061431695,
0.1105045304,
0.0000022782,
-0.0331403092,
-0.0225711986,
-0.0158414021,
0.0127209183,
-0.002558999,
0.0498348586,
-0.0085669402,
-0.0447733253,
-0.0041273716,
-0.0587063357,
-0.0115565592,
0.0503805093,
0.0524606034,
0.0648909509,
0.0799072012,
-0.0048010168,
0.0069481987,
0.0389413498,
0.0168048646,
0.0434682108,
0.0033282868,
0.0304216817,
0.0064291167,
-0.0032381329,
-0.035195183,
-0.0170285385,
0.0235887207,
0.0209612213,
0.0027374143,
-0.0481639244,
0.0123287197,
-0.1133547723,
-0.0152350264,
0.0017515558,
0.042867966,
-0.0640169829,
-0.0553682335,
0.025798114,
0.0107190413,
0.012369358,
-0.0210108273,
-0.0314624906,
0.0172465611,
-0.0273796339,
0.0125375632,
0.0527639091,
-0.020303471,
0.0294036828,
0.0057380144,
-0.0466348007,
0.0495121367,
-0.0062900549,
-0.0247806404,
0.0107835121,
-0.0012684603,
0.0011912583,
-0.0301457718,
0.0375468656,
-0.0032407492,
-0.0411996394,
-0.0150139518,
-0.0604112111,
-0.0144193294,
0.0266968478,
-0.1003988162,
-0.0123230303,
0.0231823288,
-0.0591135733,
0.047108829,
-0.0473594926,
0.0498602241,
-0.0138438847,
0.0865625292,
-0.0075287726,
0.0140436953,
-0.0187664572,
0.0092764134,
-0.0560298637,
0.0100736571,
0.0223710164,
-0.0293924827,
-0.0142674306,
0.0183418989,
-0.0388593078,
0.0337310545,
-0.039861165,
-0.0202623792,
0.0034762856,
-0.0102670286,
0.0237437729,
0.0079828547,
-0.028251227,
-0.0277851354,
0.025148632,
-0.1014252156,
-0.0374234356,
0.0458571911,
-0.0074658422,
-0.0053427042,
0.0025499407,
0.047079552,
0.0520911366,
-0.0055971919,
-0.0229130462,
-0.0097219972,
0.015584413,
-0.0789670348,
0.00466346,
-0.0795276314,
-0.0175353233,
-0.0075074332,
0.0119612878,
-0.0582308248,
0.0369577259,
0.0102846408,
0.0160262194,
0.0743682012,
-0.0279336162,
-0.0278394781,
-0.000022579,
0.0164692923,
-0.0388727859,
0.1031844839,
0.015152703,
0.0328073688,
0.0554900542,
-0.0197508931,
0.05197566,
0.0396895558,
-0.0211186428,
0.0224836301,
-0.0125335101,
-0.0359187685,
0.0140338987,
0.009718122,
-0.0001423063,
0.0516958684,
-0.0124026518,
-0.0213624407,
0.0435048304,
0.0540667884,
-0.0153205656,
-0.0007468798,
-0.0036611662,
0.0387873948,
-0.0023115275,
0.0192061141,
-0.0519821607,
0.0263800882,
-0.0305324681,
-0.0079155043,
0.0261346754,
0.018505929,
-0.0289492775,
-0.0420511626,
-0.0104647018,
-0.0097391298,
0.0351796672,
0.0022347856,
0.039141193,
0.0082992278,
-0.036769107,
0.062938638,
0.0126085551,
-0.0538470447,
-0.0139794843,
-0.071853444,
-0.0020996886,
0.0973393172,
0.0497213155,
-0.0503932275,
0.0260698609,
-0.0221391376,
0.0393827334,
0.0677595437,
0.0125815617,
0.024748195,
0.0018088352,
-0.0747944638,
0.0026716506,
0.007803611,
0.0504623912,
0.0072175842,
0.0017751635,
0.0305589437,
-0.0027617947,
-0.0219946951,
-0.059836641,
0.0316590182,
-0.0125433393,
-0.0168153401,
-0.0269324463,
0.0007562941,
0.0073554497,
-0.0117750242,
-0.0222187564,
0.0270989928,
0.0113054551,
-0.0437593348,
-0.0375287123,
0.0261675008,
-0.0173239447,
-0.0395149589,
0.0564924963,
-0.018730158,
0.0029916479,
0.0339088961,
-0.0244144518,
-0.048146069,
0.027507836,
-0.061004661,
0.0452952497,
-0.0512775555,
0.0469235592,
-0.0253296793,
0.0664498582,
0.0134592773,
0.0642620996,
-0.026477132,
0.002768409,
0.006721566,
0.0303612426,
0.0130870165,
-0.0127528924,
-0.054107219,
0.0063314629,
0.0004120928,
0.0651043877,
-0.024597723,
-0.0134460721,
-0.0367226005,
-0.0099811368,
-0.0584763847,
0.0052298587,
-0.0414713547,
-0.0037145093,
0.0220884737,
-0.0166007113,
-0.007177047,
-0.010737841,
-0.0020763124,
0.0464704409,
-0.016065741,
0.0321111418,
-0.0224760007,
-0.0464108922,
-0.0430262238,
-0.0099933259,
0.0074975295,
-0.0137465885,
0.0072036125,
-0.0195748974,
-0.068267554,
-0.0841611475,
0.0431615375,
-0.0035785001,
0.0325328186,
-0.0085357921,
-0.0437826179,
0.0033966571,
-0.0413064398,
0.0359488763,
0.0890794173,
-0.0264744367,
0.0229304284,
0.0676874295,
-0.0298844483,
-0.0266864542,
-0.0093393754,
0.0204817355,
0.027315272,
-0.0190308206,
-0.0222038198,
-0.0121460725,
0.0486918166,
0.0116488533,
0.0111195901,
-0.0563932844,
0.0039362861,
-0.0284419842,
-0.0327879153,
0.033179123,
0.0178118702,
-0.048168961,
0.025192976,
-0.0122735128,
-0.0528688431,
0.0658939704,
-0.0271303747,
-0.0194571726,
-0.0284149814,
-0.0063519203,
-0.0151526611,
0.042829182,
0.0207549203,
-0.0053564608,
-0.0205032825,
-0.0202390142,
-0.0304353293,
0.0402198806,
-0.0148999505,
-0.0511734672,
0.0256993975,
-0.0370140374,
-0.0022169785,
-0.0007289897,
-0.0227245074,
-0.0409690812,
0.0079753846,
-0.0342498496,
-0.0138114318,
-0.0131922783,
-0.0225411542,
-0.037467014,
0.0393987261,
0.0005097549,
0.0497636683,
-0.0276504792,
0.0009097916,
-0.00638561,
-0.0197124984,
0.0517155454,
-0.0057260864,
0.0448064618,
-0.052501142,
0.0580625795,
0.0844852701,
0.025891969,
0.0208643898,
-0.0032285603,
-0.0272731576,
0.0216589291,
0.0092091644,
-0.0246757418,
0.0006079498,
0.0294334907,
-0.0760082901,
-0.028392408,
0.0885135308,
0.0086251702,
-0.0758245736,
-0.0124974493,
-0.0733378008,
0.051900804,
0.0050289324,
-0.0199219231,
-0.0773337856,
-0.0345055796,
0.0080215922,
-0.0056909346,
-0.019995179,
-0.0005152906,
0.0148490388,
-0.0793273821,
0.0515390784,
0.0493496694,
-0.0248705577,
-0.0249628108,
-0.0189265963,
0.004102129,
-0.0002395343,
0.0256304778,
-0.0180413369,
0.0207257587,
-0.0344255678,
-0.0091830762,
-0.0526513271,
-0.017495051,
0.0206594132,
-0.0407611318,
0.0355804302,
0.077469252,
0.0273456424,
-0.0153636504,
-0.0736892596,
0.0241565779,
0.0013572953,
-0.029171003,
0.0163751934,
0.0550814755,
0.0279189553,
-0.014780012,
0.0157864615,
0.0311607867,
-0.0656532124,
0.0077071292,
0.0368307978,
0.0848214924,
-0.0519414283,
-0.0326306894,
-0.0017900356,
0.0296691507,
-0.0141703123,
0.0832274407,
0.038609419,
-0.0269741267,
-0.0690759197,
-0.0429516099,
0.0297326315,
-0.0605203621,
-0.0545009002,
0.0224979017,
0.0331342556,
-0.0644364506,
-0.0609251149,
-0.0410112627,
0.0260246806,
0.0040439335,
0.0024807751,
0.062424399,
-0.0141339665,
0.0103208274,
-0.0530142337,
-0.0065515549,
-0.0479031987,
0.0334420241,
-0.0463731475,
-0.0137757938,
0.0142796282,
0.003317575,
0.0037390108,
0.0524161719,
-0.1218331531,
-0.0571780466,
0.0413793884,
0.0222331844,
0.0197302289,
0.0409818068,
-0.057140369,
-0.0043111057,
0.0371105969,
0.0263012797,
-0.023373574,
0.0207729861,
0.0519141592,
-0.0316351205,
0.0041389861,
0.0419549569,
-0.017555844,
-0.0207484215,
-0.0066666873,
0.0216917172,
-0.0421004929,
0.0318947136,
0.0213149004,
-0.011607049,
-0.0031400484,
-0.0062765419,
0.0080039809,
-0.0081454711,
0.0127934394,
-0.0107881017,
-0.0082432097,
-0.0387932695,
0.0069739404,
0.041337043,
-0.0389015377,
0.0299691316,
0.0023422565,
-0.0005830996,
-0.0584771372,
-0.0067733368,
0.024209667,
-0.0104650324,
0.0489396863,
0.0558866374,
-0.016990874,
-0.0159813873,
0.0289847739,
0.003152838,
0.0458185449,
-0.0119350944,
0.0642599389,
0.0034420888,
-0.0317908227,
0.0140543515,
0.0404353477,
-0.0359368362,
-0.0772555768,
-0.0145832067,
0.0320418328,
0.0601324141,
0.0137075214,
0.0844976231,
-0.0399182476,
0.0095457016,
-0.0325287916,
0.0018897363,
0.0419865325,
-0.0514920317,
-0.0426961668,
0.0179627594,
-0.0173765086,
-0.042178724,
0.0944540575,
-0.0241450481,
0.040417403,
0.0263027493,
-0.0071159024,
-0.0370779224,
-0.04552586,
-0.0294711236,
-0.0103070671,
-0.0243134312,
-0.025930848,
-0.0521190576,
-0.0535843,
-0.0291880425,
-0.0004152296,
-0.01883821,
-0.0108383661,
-0.0019184551,
0.0452164598,
-0.0278200805,
-0.0191500653,
-0.0230598263,
-0.0066925446,
0.0383734889,
-0.0296446942,
0.0072232476,
-6.178512184e-33,
-0.0027842219,
-0.0324248523,
0.0028661541,
0.0041080243,
0.0251935311,
-0.0282573849,
-0.0415432267,
0.0056503001,
0.0152917095,
0.002125039,
0.0112521006,
0.0502333306,
0.0318319984,
0.0014935007,
0.0219537783,
-0.0132760955,
0.0362484679,
0.0097614871,
-0.0143823503,
0.0442470238,
0.0354952216,
0.0158603303,
0.0624656491,
-0.0498397909,
0.0104049798,
-0.0199524108,
-0.0171448328,
-0.0027731098,
-0.0286112279,
0.0513529815,
-0.026820099,
0.0550239012,
0.0046484978,
-0.0048053181,
-0.0425364859,
-0.0177266505,
-0.0357325487,
-0.0254233237,
-0.0273272321,
0.0789478719,
-0.0136795705,
-0.0392526388,
0.0352943912,
-0.0260520335,
0.005733646,
0.0071186484,
0.0348441079,
-0.0547749959,
-0.0161173157,
0.0425624885,
-0.0533909872,
0.0320613608,
0.0252941065,
-0.0131950136,
0.034614969,
0.0260186419,
-0.0126474956,
-0.0463858396,
-0.0801453367,
0.0346991494,
-0.0052455971,
0.0055409092,
0.0188130997,
0.0060891118,
0.0156551637,
0.0708280727,
0.0967845023,
0.0140627511,
-0.0054841042,
-0.0131485388,
0.0501611233,
0.0419788174,
0.0631043091,
0.0048483526,
0.0294645727,
-0.0215450041,
0.0017060857,
0.0115947416,
0.0214954801,
0.0136219021,
0.0739215612,
0.0131700765,
-0.0665839016,
-0.0384212956,
0.0391507894,
0.0180288795,
-0.0306450184,
-0.0353804417,
0.0394934528,
-0.0020996977,
-0.0138572045,
-0.0416516252,
0.0396342427,
-0.0542006865,
0.0039363843,
0.0240321234,
-0.0185353216,
0.0088786874,
-0.0056662071,
0.0135518685,
-0.0094124228,
-0.0209687147,
0.0256743152,
-0.0074768364,
0.0397186875,
0.0072129644,
0.0191909522,
0.0137013076,
-0.0564970411,
0.003201646,
-0.043535959,
-0.0117942337,
0.0438372605,
0.0144681083,
0.0223390274,
-0.019483842,
0.00105854,
0.0036743325,
0.0220113564,
-0.0132053662,
-0.0356269293,
0.0355167314,
-0.0508875847,
0.0192575697,
-0.0397933796,
-0.0042967531,
-0.0769728646,
0.0128472829,
0.0413583554,
-0.0823073164,
-0.0083171148,
-0.0181636512,
2.93e-7,
-0.012900576,
0.0299912207,
0.0080590388,
0.0090029826,
0.0152276782,
0.0230751,
-0.0341435447,
0.015086188,
-0.0075699263,
-0.0060329959,
-0.0226034615,
0.0312988199,
0.1008358076,
0.057769563,
-0.0979491919,
0.0116843274,
0.0044023907,
0.0069025364,
-0.068427965,
-0.0131068993,
0.0296063274,
0.1028501391,
0.0391022004,
-0.0121050011,
0.0397953503,
-0.0898177177,
0.035685461,
-0.0163846835,
0.0267780684,
0.0258702803,
-0.0167962387,
0.0535859317,
-0.0016348329,
0.0178745296,
0.0168434456,
-0.03199175,
0.0195210949,
0.0523936749,
-0.0076432666,
-0.0214362517,
0.0114226416,
-0.0200210009,
0.008739071,
-0.0528180487,
0.0602842383,
0.0106230564,
-0.0159137733,
0.0108894957,
0.0064871395,
-0.0395840779,
0.0408996418,
-0.0164940692,
-0.0468107462,
0.0197719987,
0.0091960523,
0.0064240242,
-0.0123335635,
-0.0397849604,
-0.0149379419,
-0.0201564766,
-0.0379504114,
-0.035452839,
-0.0385088734,
0.0164797492,
-0.0251411442,
-0.046215903,
0.0124661932,
3.098698388e-34,
0.0410149507,
-0.0159559902,
0.0087066758,
0.0640242845,
0.0439726599,
-0.0107502388,
0.0347642861,
0.0094131259,
-0.0164327323,
-0.0393339843,
-0.0235367678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11275v1 | Self-training Large Language Models through Knowledge Detection | 2024-06-17T07:25:09 | 2024-06-17T07:25:09 | Wei Jie Yeo, Teddy Ferdinan, Przemyslaw Kazienko, Ranjan Satapathy, Erik Cambria | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) often necessitate extensive labeled datasets and
training compute to achieve impressive performance across downstream tasks.
This paper explores a self-training paradigm, where the LLM autonomously
curates its own labels and selectively trains on unknown data samples
identified through a reference-free consistency method. Empirical evaluations
demonstrate significant improvements in reducing hallucination in generation
across multiple subjects. Furthermore, the selective training framework
mitigates catastrophic forgetting in out-of-distribution benchmarks, addressing
a critical limitation in training LLMs. Our findings suggest that such an
approach can substantially reduce the dependency on large labeled datasets,
paving the way for more scalable and cost-effective language model training. | [
-0.0148953181,
0.0629508793,
0.0126307644,
0.0502619259,
-0.0070983879,
0.0232426375,
0.0225816723,
-0.0262903962,
0.0346113034,
-0.062126331,
-0.0477283411,
-0.0257143863,
-0.0368357189,
0.0024558462,
0.0381686762,
0.0258794744,
0.055667378,
-0.0554480813,
-0.0162613038,
-0.0088236574,
-0.0219006184,
0.0310321301,
-0.0210928824,
0.0059775412,
-0.0361449197,
-0.0386965759,
0.0007563268,
-0.0054078475,
-0.034599971,
-0.0462336428,
0.0090843001,
0.0669255555,
0.0317639038,
0.0509968139,
0.0000020654,
-0.0479549319,
-0.0195021648,
-0.0488168485,
-0.0345966555,
0.0084897261,
0.0291622132,
-0.0022545769,
-0.0039816583,
0.0122763822,
-0.0195556059,
-0.0200697612,
0.0236879662,
0.045028314,
0.0569426008,
0.0492618755,
-0.0016051811,
-0.0103996377,
0.0141651724,
-0.0368925445,
0.021217145,
0.0050133457,
0.0374575928,
0.0110599827,
-0.0503744371,
-0.0242655892,
-0.0018719584,
0.0536467917,
0.0088802325,
0.0353344791,
0.0073149661,
0.0646350235,
-0.0642936751,
-0.0221653488,
-0.0128242569,
0.0448014326,
-0.0156881288,
-0.0489939526,
0.0391744748,
-0.0065489742,
-0.0118031669,
-0.0166234449,
-0.0115072625,
0.0464532711,
0.0001649537,
0.0353783481,
0.0287142843,
-0.0158272311,
0.0472405739,
0.0168637708,
-0.0415296331,
0.0590471476,
0.0124634113,
-0.0396670178,
0.0125610819,
0.0014799405,
-0.0264427308,
-0.0437478498,
0.0117663322,
0.0327794366,
-0.0033121437,
0.0316460133,
-0.0776541829,
-0.02526097,
0.0213605296,
-0.0452198386,
0.0228399672,
0.0025362924,
-0.0424267463,
0.0327795483,
-0.0598404109,
0.0349154957,
-0.0101948185,
0.0386137515,
-0.0245796498,
0.0327309407,
-0.0331338868,
-0.0276017357,
-0.0759226754,
0.0441559777,
0.0037379132,
-0.0181045346,
-0.0329183787,
0.0098083625,
-0.0101739429,
-0.0034837893,
-0.0061046337,
-0.0018857374,
-0.0542070158,
-0.0108529264,
0.0110467235,
0.0125767179,
0.0147473663,
0.0040769754,
0.0380326174,
-0.0675179064,
-0.0153061291,
0.0200886093,
0.0124155842,
-0.0094453674,
0.0179506671,
0.0377293639,
-0.019011965,
-0.0494237281,
-0.0841938704,
-0.0409128517,
-0.0352655426,
-0.0868855044,
0.0182935949,
-0.0839027762,
0.0139749739,
0.0182056315,
-0.001491625,
-0.0638106316,
0.0295211691,
0.0044585383,
-0.0027379121,
0.0360822827,
-0.0327197276,
0.0200632643,
0.0488725081,
0.0130593153,
0.0268444717,
0.1089816466,
0.0016085914,
0.0059844521,
0.000832257,
0.0074685086,
0.0382788405,
0.0418065004,
0.0370361097,
0.0017330598,
-0.0621562712,
-0.0279637016,
0.0509979427,
0.0309539288,
0.0394362584,
0.0381535627,
-0.0220722388,
0.0050709797,
0.0729916319,
0.0233857334,
0.0085043395,
-0.0020824885,
0.0446986184,
-0.0099880612,
-0.0020261474,
0.0167746283,
-0.0429948121,
0.0183687694,
0.01684542,
0.0224488359,
0.0225488935,
0.0225018747,
-0.0688879415,
-0.0277452916,
-0.0196888503,
-0.0067784456,
-0.037941277,
0.0165931247,
0.0543011948,
0.0567950495,
-0.0264744107,
0.0873972252,
0.0279109459,
-0.0316484943,
0.0418524258,
-0.0454474315,
0.0377273746,
0.0567523986,
0.0410631746,
-0.0185643677,
-0.0097266976,
-0.0109245414,
0.0619773678,
0.0526454709,
0.0316704102,
0.0058553489,
0.0184149574,
-0.0636590719,
0.000038631,
-0.0207176246,
0.0284135472,
0.0020436407,
0.003105192,
0.0100937355,
0.0187813081,
-0.0452329367,
-0.0422809497,
0.0565737411,
-0.054221753,
-0.0553930402,
-0.0012303854,
-0.0079942523,
0.0160887241,
-0.0236553773,
-0.0094604213,
0.0188221186,
0.0282730535,
-0.0428196415,
-0.0275021717,
0.0122416196,
-0.0802391395,
-0.0314009972,
0.0419826508,
0.0351119973,
-0.007003508,
-0.0121248551,
-0.0162159726,
-0.0541704819,
0.0313520618,
-0.030366227,
0.0247250069,
-0.0686051771,
0.0348530263,
0.0355379209,
0.0322695784,
-0.0006606833,
0.0731591061,
-0.018345302,
-0.0115690781,
-0.0033720233,
0.0382895395,
0.0222163945,
-0.0292522218,
-0.0310213007,
-0.0162300933,
-0.0236012563,
0.021634575,
-0.0251217112,
-0.0021622458,
-0.0540532321,
-0.0189943928,
-0.0568136722,
0.0177289154,
-0.0379833169,
0.0042676283,
0.0238054935,
-0.0087990444,
-0.0038844345,
-0.0319829434,
-0.0256705731,
-0.0000879451,
0.0300731845,
0.0185561925,
-0.00437163,
0.0165626872,
-0.0186261758,
-0.0049109384,
0.0072691264,
-0.0126830172,
0.0302093793,
-0.0145534733,
-0.0069491565,
-0.0866335779,
0.0380423851,
-0.0534358509,
0.0625382215,
0.0100424271,
-0.0159898456,
0.0097209252,
-0.0200799573,
0.0596093126,
0.0433294363,
-0.0020284664,
-0.033865463,
0.0941471085,
-0.0157967079,
-0.0322906077,
-0.005182514,
-0.0296716969,
-0.0105625931,
-0.0054912954,
-0.0054762093,
-0.0074071875,
0.0724982023,
0.017313594,
0.0055925334,
-0.0366723724,
-0.0042452724,
-0.031119924,
-0.0605277009,
-0.041215267,
0.0068201488,
-0.0123424977,
0.0174967535,
-0.0239904411,
-0.0588658452,
0.0367999487,
-0.0563885719,
-0.0116705922,
-0.0205132123,
-0.0030178104,
-0.0010955513,
0.0325847119,
0.0259186868,
0.0341848843,
0.0195613727,
-0.0020315102,
-0.0142335705,
-0.0060866238,
-0.0063836789,
-0.0145876845,
0.0356283709,
-0.0631852522,
0.0324776284,
0.0238021091,
-0.0303956065,
-0.0785681829,
-0.0293232258,
0.0034538526,
-0.0164699554,
-0.0275440309,
0.0101971794,
0.0038767906,
0.036779128,
0.0004030792,
0.1001776978,
-0.008127287,
-0.0201886669,
-0.0378914438,
0.0373268425,
0.0546209961,
-0.0167612974,
0.0204128884,
-0.0402665585,
0.011897576,
0.0318320915,
0.0496232584,
0.0244713072,
-0.0332271121,
0.019626772,
-0.0070124036,
-0.0205090027,
0.0014072104,
0.0303855464,
0.0316701196,
-0.0548781678,
-0.0680374429,
0.1156931892,
0.0217858665,
-0.0498879217,
-0.0080043264,
-0.001743913,
0.0428745374,
0.0390080027,
0.0105660288,
-0.0564118102,
0.0010995282,
-0.0053932811,
0.0187768508,
-0.0123512372,
-0.0173868593,
-0.0134059153,
-0.1028482243,
0.044410944,
0.0305869635,
-0.0587063208,
-0.004920132,
-0.0266818088,
-0.0436953232,
-0.0029675122,
0.0097150588,
0.015233499,
-0.028932767,
-0.0077325962,
0.0467412882,
-0.0203273762,
-0.0592112355,
0.0037624321,
-0.0451410376,
0.0803212374,
0.0517590977,
0.0026622124,
0.0152715528,
-0.0383009352,
0.040752843,
-0.0217613429,
-0.0100150909,
-0.008248968,
0.0606522225,
-0.0008945992,
-0.016807843,
0.0282813106,
0.0249677189,
-0.0635473356,
-0.0148813566,
0.0093755629,
0.068435438,
-0.0157437231,
-0.0372717567,
0.0396378115,
0.0173987728,
0.0198424924,
0.0907050148,
0.0281351581,
0.0003645149,
-0.032441102,
0.0015964789,
0.0420353189,
-0.0477694497,
-0.0083266804,
0.0620691366,
-0.0118436506,
-0.0426763222,
-0.0718997717,
-0.0177056007,
0.0268827621,
0.0613655895,
0.0190826375,
0.0513157211,
-0.0075692846,
-0.0092673106,
-0.059866745,
0.0325990021,
-0.0850319937,
-0.0537232384,
-0.0483203344,
-0.04385693,
0.0436685346,
-0.0283543468,
-0.0031194799,
0.0628785864,
-0.0914310738,
-0.0699305162,
0.0168723762,
0.0539185107,
0.0240392592,
0.0812875256,
-0.0002614909,
-0.0376186632,
0.0338935629,
0.047517471,
-0.0604308434,
0.0366369076,
-0.0010384017,
-0.0290234219,
-0.0027844689,
0.0201207362,
-0.0273996275,
0.0434276797,
0.0282569509,
0.0340185463,
-0.0017156808,
0.0405626707,
0.0488177985,
-0.0213987529,
0.0075664236,
-0.0521936938,
0.0550078191,
-0.0591404513,
-0.0177951809,
0.0088379057,
0.006068063,
-0.0505881272,
0.0224976949,
0.0155538507,
0.00633671,
0.0125366785,
-0.0166033749,
-0.0056450195,
0.0317403376,
-0.0073714871,
-0.0520291254,
-0.0265092533,
0.0247144103,
0.0437128395,
-0.018353276,
-0.0200640708,
0.0284522288,
0.0028045198,
0.0161972921,
-0.0226785429,
0.0564870909,
0.0091329226,
-0.0169548206,
-0.0343417116,
-0.007858796,
-0.0212270208,
-0.054766003,
-0.0574951991,
0.0035626478,
0.066529572,
-0.0132283885,
0.060755983,
-0.0538433194,
-0.0088722482,
-0.0237429738,
0.0189269278,
-0.0108756479,
-0.0297427643,
0.0032139756,
0.0242206026,
-0.0476300009,
-0.0052151396,
0.0724198148,
0.0422439575,
0.0405544788,
0.0155053725,
0.0246818066,
-0.0401664898,
-0.0520413034,
-0.0309819803,
-0.0085885329,
-0.0440912358,
-0.0007454421,
-0.0114006372,
-0.0873605087,
-0.0135855693,
0.002358255,
-0.0031035393,
-0.0058702393,
0.0551935844,
0.0653216019,
-0.0287714396,
-0.0056492784,
-0.0292743668,
0.0162381548,
0.0076992805,
-0.0035133862,
-0.0084458031,
-6.825303706e-33,
-0.0167421848,
-0.0227503218,
0.0640637577,
-0.0426383242,
0.0106831798,
-0.0088604791,
-0.0478626788,
0.0199875608,
0.0303953737,
-0.0025650011,
0.0105920434,
0.0162252355,
0.0239686556,
0.0400191732,
0.0249405671,
0.0104960939,
0.0787907392,
-0.0334755369,
-0.0080272956,
0.0606662519,
0.0479272492,
0.0388541333,
0.0512279905,
-0.0580620579,
-0.0423359647,
-0.0148770455,
-0.0004237892,
0.0144005129,
0.0026088981,
0.045948524,
-0.0663432702,
0.0298885051,
0.0215924606,
-0.0300512481,
-0.0389432795,
-0.0279949587,
-0.0706519559,
0.0034968511,
-0.0293781739,
0.0061554252,
-0.0276660398,
-0.0166346338,
0.043731492,
-0.0184117705,
-0.0210072249,
0.0451634787,
0.0287221,
-0.0299783312,
-0.0336810648,
0.0203811787,
-0.0551823825,
0.0014137933,
0.0265726335,
-0.0134754032,
0.0440580472,
0.0078326361,
-0.0206905343,
-0.021178335,
-0.0744161233,
0.0109995548,
-0.0025945094,
0.0567893386,
0.0624890924,
0.0533012114,
0.0234694425,
0.0599588156,
0.0706142783,
0.0139696011,
0.0251389313,
-0.0057660188,
0.0640951842,
0.0383459777,
0.0171643998,
-0.0020762861,
0.0270569827,
-0.0178004224,
-0.0594888292,
-0.0271700304,
-0.0247738641,
-0.0218388271,
0.0525285415,
-0.0222861953,
-0.01911401,
-0.0230888687,
-0.0143248998,
-0.0130371042,
-0.0347955637,
-0.0137414085,
0.0693696439,
0.0651602075,
0.0073550171,
-0.0340426974,
0.0280656479,
-0.0182235148,
-0.0255556405,
0.015670713,
-0.021803163,
0.0105606401,
-0.0062388717,
0.0349703357,
-0.0609851331,
-0.0474380814,
0.000618425,
0.0237162821,
0.0055523468,
0.0090612844,
0.0299528874,
0.0221617837,
-0.0569944195,
0.0163342953,
-0.0570256338,
0.0301380083,
0.0149008296,
0.0137613807,
0.0408384614,
-0.002122571,
-0.0130232237,
0.0367396586,
0.0017474005,
-0.0508006774,
-0.0109977936,
0.0245132931,
-0.0210337825,
0.0489514694,
-0.0212997552,
0.0028642023,
-0.0414057821,
-0.0148775065,
0.0564671122,
-0.0551798977,
0.0110252388,
0.0088411216,
2.651e-7,
-0.0028991508,
0.003374062,
0.0070327511,
0.0152331572,
0.0288402848,
0.0043648952,
-0.0288483873,
0.008928474,
0.0104175666,
-0.0232247468,
-0.0017189295,
0.0687239617,
0.0612754636,
0.0105463853,
-0.0925609693,
0.0042782105,
-0.0510942414,
0.0358087905,
-0.0585407652,
-0.0594998933,
-0.0387065858,
0.0715117082,
0.0054188054,
-0.0271824133,
0.0216532052,
-0.0588709302,
0.0818339586,
-0.0072851083,
0.0312305633,
0.0427090973,
0.0014162287,
0.0714328736,
-0.0150327981,
0.0374237671,
-0.0186588652,
-0.0010463378,
-0.0228307024,
0.0517420769,
0.0300544463,
-0.0163188651,
0.0164131057,
0.028580185,
-0.0166720729,
-0.0472471975,
0.0479162969,
-0.0887399539,
-0.0036156347,
-0.0065483782,
0.012303113,
-0.0114933895,
-0.0018267767,
-0.0273818541,
-0.0123587027,
0.0259095933,
0.0233502667,
0.0132041946,
-0.0181439333,
-0.0619936846,
-0.0103907883,
0.0399353355,
-0.0679461211,
-0.012794978,
-0.0601334795,
0.0135048246,
0.0026411577,
-0.0785806179,
0.0093029095,
2.620497414e-34,
0.0090973126,
-0.0176524948,
0.0123679517,
0.037879914,
0.0175862238,
-0.0288356803,
-0.0036572865,
0.0270980373,
-0.0286450144,
-0.053467311,
0.0047905492
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11274v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11274v1 | Skip-Layer Attention: Bridging Abstract and Detailed Dependencies in Transformers | 2024-06-17T07:24:38 | 2024-06-17T07:24:38 | Qian Chen, Wen Wang, Qinglin Zhang, Siqi Zheng, Shiliang Zhang, Chong Deng, Hai Yu, Jiaqing Liu, Yukun Ma, Chong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Transformer architecture has significantly advanced deep learning,
particularly in natural language processing, by effectively managing long-range
dependencies. However, as the demand for understanding complex relationships
grows, refining the Transformer's architecture becomes critical. This paper
introduces Skip-Layer Attention (SLA) to enhance Transformer models by enabling
direct attention between non-adjacent layers. This method improves the model's
ability to capture dependencies between high-level abstract features and
low-level details. By facilitating direct attention between these diverse
feature levels, our approach overcomes the limitations of current Transformers,
which often rely on suboptimal intra-layer attention. Our implementation
extends the Transformer's functionality by enabling queries in a given layer to
interact with keys and values from both the current layer and one preceding
layer, thus enhancing the diversity of multi-head attention without additional
computational burden. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our enhanced
Transformer model achieves superior performance in language modeling tasks,
highlighting the effectiveness of our skip-layer attention mechanism. | [
0.0225801617,
0.0825742334,
-0.0048199212,
0.0376509614,
-0.0067488002,
0.0038609414,
0.0045627286,
-0.0366672389,
-0.0065799719,
-0.0121248802,
-0.0206239074,
-0.0565827601,
-0.0036394154,
0.0501929224,
-0.0033721244,
-0.0684392825,
0.0310122948,
0.0190524384,
-0.0213320348,
0.0296190437,
-0.0070825284,
0.0134100365,
0.0267652962,
0.031112276,
-0.0209372044,
-0.0261877123,
-0.0137515152,
0.0055075902,
0.0406140946,
-0.0032995855,
0.0159219243,
0.0465163663,
0.0086112432,
0.0202882942,
0.0000021772,
0.000314773,
-0.0086013209,
-0.0070770341,
-0.0104482099,
-0.0133609008,
-0.0041337991,
-0.0399217159,
0.0144538395,
-0.0118358051,
-0.0250750445,
-0.0164178126,
0.0411255956,
0.0989252701,
0.0542952642,
0.0343020968,
-0.0219603609,
-0.0340871811,
0.0441150963,
-0.0472440459,
0.0000660419,
-0.0607863218,
-0.0118205771,
-0.0625589266,
-0.0256573334,
0.0039849007,
-0.0333195888,
0.0475726053,
0.0609358065,
0.0001605351,
0.0415169299,
0.0410609543,
-0.0476564355,
-0.0208735093,
0.0153939435,
0.1004504487,
-0.0704338923,
-0.0042299484,
-0.0208259206,
-0.0341016278,
-0.0107680149,
-0.0195211731,
-0.0297001489,
-0.0069803037,
0.014799404,
0.0071336217,
-0.0093081649,
0.0280599315,
0.0364874974,
0.0125201782,
-0.0710336566,
0.0320600905,
0.0018825402,
-0.0127676986,
0.0146213025,
0.0071772761,
-0.0043941126,
-0.0257322211,
0.0384067148,
0.0279123355,
-0.0182966515,
-0.001551715,
-0.0381014831,
-0.028793579,
-0.0065558683,
-0.0590764806,
0.0143957734,
0.0278157704,
-0.0654402152,
0.0341132991,
0.00245494,
0.0280297063,
-0.0606374331,
-0.0015116774,
-0.0160757061,
-0.0188222975,
0.0015570482,
-0.0123290028,
-0.059965346,
0.0319961198,
-0.0607683808,
-0.0357599892,
0.0123018166,
0.0193325337,
-0.0247078128,
-0.0449481197,
0.0107652983,
0.0560797006,
-0.0491623394,
-0.0337166078,
0.0283362083,
0.0612535067,
-0.0294719934,
0.0118542397,
0.0117848646,
-0.046917282,
-0.0351711102,
0.0133310324,
0.0349671692,
-0.019840803,
0.0042006336,
0.0471745208,
-0.0037076494,
-0.0430309586,
0.0261514522,
0.0023307032,
0.0095289862,
-0.0530575886,
0.0256025251,
-0.0195676871,
0.0262773186,
-0.0066177621,
-0.0011712571,
-0.0128931627,
0.0232318845,
0.034555234,
-0.0335588604,
0.0540345125,
0.0585057847,
-0.0287081674,
-0.0147693194,
0.0177802462,
0.0231871922,
0.0486872159,
0.0412277803,
0.0200552307,
-0.0208479613,
-0.0069356402,
0.01617462,
0.0042348574,
0.0144766103,
-0.0254470687,
-0.0107920701,
0.0018029964,
-0.0710464194,
0.0064290427,
0.0520355105,
0.0343840197,
0.0024480876,
-0.0338595435,
0.0484245867,
-0.0010968626,
0.0279696621,
0.0633194819,
0.0270796306,
0.0352791212,
-0.0437254794,
0.0165066756,
-0.0761526674,
0.0927982777,
0.0351462662,
-0.0130580338,
-0.0304386225,
0.0359168723,
-0.029228149,
-0.0089029502,
0.013961507,
0.0111576449,
0.0012405799,
0.0374373421,
0.0170815587,
0.0307960548,
-0.0374858491,
0.1374738365,
0.026906006,
-0.033099141,
0.0078173727,
-0.0266624968,
-0.038241744,
0.064559415,
0.0021008586,
-0.0180770438,
-0.0365743823,
-0.0116414195,
0.0391123854,
0.063809,
0.0093647037,
0.0289006811,
0.0454131551,
-0.0489577502,
-0.0281494148,
-0.0169144645,
0.0133850947,
-0.0060196486,
-0.0055055185,
-0.0196354967,
0.0200867709,
-0.0074167377,
0.0103008077,
0.0196168963,
-0.0267637167,
-0.0113267163,
-0.0012201203,
0.0317267329,
0.0034173562,
0.0254078694,
0.0097616268,
0.0193440877,
0.0228779074,
-0.0469827279,
-0.0311491434,
0.0075669843,
-0.0496450476,
0.0120718498,
-0.0196880065,
-0.0541100986,
-0.0239043012,
0.0507100001,
-0.0262646861,
-0.0279537942,
0.0359759182,
-0.0570112206,
0.0556083098,
-0.0129606714,
-0.0005611536,
0.0052507194,
0.059581764,
-0.0183727182,
0.0558183752,
-0.0374275222,
-0.0183842424,
0.0039772168,
-0.0013775948,
-0.0053818519,
-0.000103539,
0.0097234063,
0.0100950096,
-0.0137686012,
0.008947257,
-0.0055297562,
0.0013384345,
-0.0293906573,
-0.0313811935,
-0.0198149923,
-0.0133234598,
-0.0403495915,
0.005407454,
0.0136266146,
0.0581962392,
0.0220103376,
-0.0143025964,
-0.021409316,
0.0141997235,
-0.0183523875,
-0.0000176791,
-0.0146854063,
-0.0144016743,
0.0006643969,
-0.040982645,
-0.027764814,
-0.0079000471,
0.0559355989,
-0.0037583229,
-0.0289250445,
-0.006346507,
-0.0476409271,
0.0026342997,
0.0392339192,
-0.0073650409,
-0.0244282689,
-0.0292663872,
-0.0213269852,
0.0136269843,
0.053655453,
0.0103444597,
0.0317773297,
0.0300789811,
-0.0248093624,
-0.0488793105,
0.0537468754,
-0.0346221849,
0.0512426905,
-0.023668319,
-0.0040487838,
-0.0084042773,
0.0915932581,
-0.0380267315,
-0.0102013256,
-0.055127494,
-0.0093204202,
0.0142281773,
-0.0201858636,
0.0439834297,
0.0121701807,
-0.0233758371,
0.0043307226,
-0.0561007224,
-0.0042788624,
0.0748867393,
0.0060469434,
-0.0248230975,
-0.0470457524,
0.0177873727,
-0.0431332886,
0.0593075901,
0.0163225438,
0.0182138663,
-0.0138104334,
-0.0701135844,
-0.042004589,
0.0515195318,
-0.0176383015,
-0.0065761982,
0.0914218947,
0.0101908762,
0.0102708517,
-0.0079447813,
-0.0259105526,
-0.0466925837,
-0.0180262942,
-0.0475243405,
0.0490419231,
0.033816848,
-0.0208381433,
-0.1019032672,
-0.0003537468,
0.0162030607,
0.0546252467,
0.0092246188,
0.0070915637,
-0.0262442995,
0.0255993996,
0.0445601158,
0.0314789191,
0.0271444544,
-0.0086602718,
0.0364032462,
0.0489628389,
0.0035725089,
-0.0077271825,
-0.0220666993,
-0.0230751261,
0.0479579121,
-0.0175840706,
-0.0107954973,
-0.0149369724,
0.0217809081,
-0.0980138332,
-0.0279408246,
0.0689143986,
0.0088756671,
-0.079417333,
0.0124520436,
-0.01524211,
0.0215703435,
0.0336305089,
0.0377405807,
-0.0559279695,
-0.0368874483,
-0.0006571821,
-0.0202415269,
0.0371654928,
-0.0235717278,
0.0104207173,
-0.0841124728,
0.038147036,
-0.0370848253,
-0.0493328162,
-0.0503229424,
-0.0310269818,
0.0266061313,
-0.0009600958,
0.0285160076,
-0.0074430364,
-0.0033873294,
-0.0587690696,
-0.0045554563,
0.0039973324,
-0.0305025838,
0.0460343212,
-0.0401103012,
-0.024241494,
0.0519061163,
0.026722135,
-0.0119292876,
-0.0256949514,
0.0111526223,
-0.0267465264,
-0.0013296171,
0.004107723,
0.0467370786,
-0.0142407315,
-0.0320270546,
-0.0296900999,
-0.0131472386,
-0.0292570163,
-0.0063097617,
-0.0570278242,
0.0906302705,
-0.0218311325,
-0.0298042558,
-0.0433957912,
0.0060541825,
-0.006536488,
0.0374323651,
0.0451048948,
-0.0410658345,
-0.047814779,
-0.0084240632,
0.0114905117,
-0.083529897,
-0.0256234426,
0.0496820137,
0.0232988857,
-0.0551172756,
-0.0199944861,
-0.0515976399,
-0.0017108239,
0.0019002249,
-0.0129534751,
-0.0329392254,
0.0498251021,
-0.0229624398,
-0.057741832,
0.0515512116,
-0.0023943873,
0.0281028468,
-0.0067038476,
0.0036190902,
0.0448551103,
-0.022810502,
-0.0293821786,
0.0380622372,
-0.0873668417,
-0.0291883349,
0.0221961103,
0.0171750523,
0.0071166544,
0.0556511693,
-0.0475225076,
-0.0726893321,
-0.0000320591,
-0.0008962529,
-0.0470847785,
0.0005480708,
0.0253533479,
-0.0577307492,
-0.0054033161,
0.0535082966,
-0.0440006964,
0.0473211147,
0.0156239904,
0.0475587286,
-0.0144751268,
-0.0270926636,
0.0131407222,
-0.0728499815,
0.0489573441,
0.0308175534,
0.0337353982,
-0.0319628045,
0.0517474003,
0.0120386118,
0.0010420636,
-0.072517246,
0.006175675,
0.0149186496,
0.0022968065,
0.0017787558,
0.023847321,
0.0077622063,
0.0031524678,
-0.0145875318,
0.0477615073,
-0.0079142191,
-0.0272308011,
0.0236822665,
0.0043372894,
-0.0182773713,
-0.0057722102,
0.0158687681,
0.0304512978,
0.0035831595,
0.0053603142,
0.0280040111,
-0.0194645822,
-0.0566354766,
-0.0077215843,
-0.0674941465,
-0.026850272,
-0.0209909454,
-0.0440637022,
0.0389824547,
-0.027833607,
0.0373601653,
0.036168009,
-0.0180620514,
0.012499461,
0.0161379352,
-0.0199892353,
-0.0508713163,
0.0098926499,
0.0258084182,
0.0202907193,
-0.0039216978,
0.0512426831,
-0.0126749147,
0.0065231668,
-0.0173717048,
-0.0122821257,
-0.019248737,
-0.0100341765,
-0.0005304471,
0.0430201218,
-0.0317839719,
0.0466903709,
-0.0478143953,
-0.0679018199,
0.0285744276,
-0.0579369627,
-0.0034127044,
-0.0243977681,
0.0422234721,
0.0405657664,
0.0257365424,
-0.0486446545,
-0.0017563427,
0.0158777982,
-0.0074501503,
-0.0177425481,
0.0007925961,
-6.975638413e-33,
-0.0148721514,
-0.0224746,
-0.0021024863,
0.0082245516,
-0.0631801412,
0.027316194,
-0.0529582612,
-0.0103000049,
-0.0436210558,
0.0369032919,
-0.0256660338,
0.0500009842,
0.0147204809,
0.0420545861,
0.0324739218,
-0.0439059399,
0.0588453263,
0.0293905009,
0.0146575859,
0.0432874411,
-0.001847403,
0.0736329854,
0.0928111002,
-0.032385122,
-0.0222972874,
0.004821145,
0.0167629886,
0.0177460425,
-0.0171311162,
0.0581560917,
-0.0165137462,
0.0286772698,
0.0418696217,
-0.0490179099,
-0.0258427318,
0.0406432413,
-0.10739173,
-0.0150489081,
-0.0177161302,
0.0188854001,
-0.0357625596,
-0.0213442277,
0.0610152483,
0.0243404079,
0.0751673877,
-0.0969384164,
0.0411114395,
-0.0105828196,
-0.0405633636,
-0.0436029583,
-0.0691889152,
0.0294426288,
0.0032927964,
-0.0076971194,
0.0265670829,
0.0653102174,
-0.0057821488,
0.045698721,
-0.0771505386,
-0.02358892,
0.010718287,
0.0333114713,
0.0325166732,
0.0439228155,
-0.0380947031,
0.0366837271,
0.0136305941,
-0.0157009047,
-0.0543472543,
-0.0135483025,
0.0467072353,
0.0564145222,
0.0188765228,
-0.0179591235,
0.0175226275,
0.0364990458,
-0.0640629232,
-0.0493418761,
-0.0304660834,
0.0904277489,
0.0149394264,
0.0137167675,
-0.0144539988,
-0.0083537176,
-0.0294755902,
-0.0081941625,
-0.0512749366,
-0.0043964628,
0.0088021634,
0.0375815108,
-0.0120320916,
0.0579905771,
0.0362499505,
-0.0285536926,
0.0198027827,
0.0281749461,
0.0149741927,
0.015803257,
0.0250487197,
0.030246174,
-0.0202618185,
-0.0008691877,
-0.0114227021,
0.0003242203,
-0.0000294972,
0.0074794386,
0.0504192971,
0.0192577615,
-0.055118937,
-0.0377795026,
-0.0420073122,
-0.0046170834,
-0.0272850338,
0.0760576501,
0.0318538547,
0.0132376049,
-0.0168898571,
0.0894074887,
-0.0031145713,
0.045801919,
-0.0195719227,
0.0529465973,
0.0168207008,
0.0526662469,
-0.0201357342,
-0.0167409424,
-0.0653951839,
-0.0074746027,
0.0457265861,
-0.0872450471,
-0.034003444,
0.0268697441,
2.885e-7,
0.0434222743,
0.0269662496,
0.0078861518,
0.0149890492,
0.0041956562,
0.0077972347,
0.0357796103,
0.0511395596,
-0.0086443089,
0.0068351128,
0.0033747649,
0.0250275955,
0.0232417285,
0.0025924197,
-0.1026129201,
-0.0230324175,
-0.0558122955,
-0.0254253186,
-0.0208985936,
-0.0512084849,
0.0269596465,
0.1319393665,
-0.0083243344,
0.0009394154,
0.0191251189,
0.027913468,
0.0430519171,
-0.0050674616,
0.0150286267,
0.0300826747,
0.0346412361,
0.0148128057,
-0.0278934967,
0.0290683173,
-0.0328121968,
0.0539423488,
0.0183052365,
0.0713690966,
-0.0217378791,
-0.0412329026,
0.0109874746,
-0.0021975911,
0.0015134303,
-0.0511613786,
0.0420560092,
-0.0979519412,
-0.0200111289,
-0.0151589019,
-0.030612411,
0.0232058465,
-0.0092099244,
0.0043229787,
0.0182202924,
-0.0007397891,
0.0160828829,
-0.0443413332,
-0.0221636351,
-0.1077335104,
-0.0360281318,
0.0186697412,
-0.0423820354,
0.0363907255,
-0.0519634038,
-0.0747991651,
0.0538472719,
0.0197800957,
-0.0039002609,
2.636378297e-34,
0.0436605588,
0.0069235992,
-0.0092705954,
0.0388177559,
0.007837859,
-0.0264846925,
-0.0070316065,
0.0221437421,
0.0157001261,
-0.0750166848,
-0.0151213184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11267v1 | Mitigating Large Language Model Hallucination with Faithful Finetuning | 2024-06-17T07:16:07 | 2024-06-17T07:16:07 | Minda Hu, Bowei He, Yufei Wang, Liangyou Li, Chen Ma, Irwin King | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance on
various natural language processing tasks. However, they are prone to
generating fluent yet untruthful responses, known as "hallucinations".
Hallucinations can lead to the spread of misinformation and cause harm in
critical applications. Mitigating hallucinations is challenging as they arise
from factors such as noisy data, model overconfidence, lack of knowledge, and
the generation process itself. Recent efforts have attempted to address this
issue through representation editing and decoding algorithms, reducing
hallucinations without major structural changes or retraining. However, these
approaches either implicitly edit LLMs' behavior in latent space or suppress
the tendency to output unfaithful results during decoding instead of explicitly
modeling on hallucination. In this work, we introduce Faithful Finetuning (F2),
a novel method that explicitly models the process of faithful question
answering through carefully designed loss functions during fine-tuning. We
conduct extensive experiments on popular datasets and demonstrate that F2
achieves significant improvements over vanilla models and baselines. | [
0.0357957222,
0.0909446329,
-0.0144112436,
0.0463589914,
-0.0145814409,
0.0371350646,
-0.036684107,
-0.0198735502,
-0.0274558328,
-0.0478036404,
-0.0115952622,
-0.0101995664,
0.0042148032,
-0.0158725325,
0.0398333371,
-0.0202130675,
0.0766384378,
-0.0468673483,
-0.0074896822,
-0.0321895406,
0.012894067,
0.0227730386,
0.0184842572,
0.0274484511,
0.0274158549,
-0.0508186184,
0.0165895801,
-0.0079603875,
0.0029497882,
0.0128830792,
0.0450841859,
0.0739054978,
0.0143353492,
0.0603283979,
0.0000020234,
-0.0374855883,
-0.0054826322,
0.0040002037,
-0.0326352455,
0.0289576184,
0.0050545544,
-0.0205964819,
0.0140171964,
0.0039959997,
-0.0261345785,
0.0191747695,
0.0466143899,
0.0803919658,
0.081927225,
0.0581971668,
0.0183109939,
-0.0392553657,
0.0258760024,
-0.0011826981,
0.0131995007,
-0.0375099592,
0.0283567496,
0.0311344918,
-0.0344196297,
-0.0100756371,
-0.0290658362,
0.0395385921,
0.0117733357,
0.0297815651,
-0.0005772144,
0.0108651342,
-0.0669099167,
-0.0197420791,
0.0036543044,
0.067181021,
-0.0419641882,
-0.0646173581,
-0.0096374638,
0.0031355084,
0.018340392,
-0.0188049302,
-0.0419306085,
0.0194749665,
-0.0064310678,
0.0051175435,
0.0162404627,
-0.0542160571,
0.0395595878,
0.0380364582,
-0.0263383389,
0.0565547682,
0.0234918464,
-0.0368908383,
0.0047200257,
0.0037753456,
-0.0481428467,
-0.0408386663,
0.0071260505,
0.0212110523,
-0.067266576,
0.0028040714,
-0.0465687253,
-0.0061073801,
0.0346538387,
-0.0501370691,
-0.0082505746,
0.0145473676,
-0.0312985033,
0.0453700721,
-0.0260924324,
0.0310534257,
-0.0331032164,
0.0604370572,
-0.0314805508,
-0.0196862761,
-0.0215530358,
-0.0395191722,
-0.0561175905,
0.0331404209,
-0.0210949276,
-0.0067860829,
0.0000927776,
0.0107022589,
-0.0291824304,
-0.0044269706,
-0.0307962801,
0.0513671972,
-0.0423567481,
-0.0469865613,
-0.0160653517,
0.059714321,
-0.0343875028,
0.0362937897,
0.0202022865,
-0.0854128525,
-0.0431123711,
0.0112324497,
-0.0115991374,
-0.0196821149,
0.0165375732,
0.0205550753,
0.0030640962,
0.0041661444,
-0.0298675299,
-0.0395121388,
-0.0355951078,
-0.0746654123,
-0.0065304874,
-0.0621222369,
0.0489124097,
-0.0004334294,
-0.0053112502,
-0.0716136619,
0.0077005299,
0.0180274416,
-0.0685964525,
0.0805854574,
-0.0221804231,
-0.0012951024,
0.0439210869,
0.0221159235,
0.001393598,
0.061557781,
0.0148554239,
0.0267791096,
0.0213500001,
-0.0158222672,
0.0288317874,
0.0262563862,
0.03074372,
0.0117259296,
-0.0080416081,
0.0270703398,
0.0060616243,
0.0215745475,
0.0524186231,
0.0408620983,
-0.0330686085,
-0.0355464108,
0.0694550797,
-0.0104288468,
-0.0131930215,
0.0302167591,
0.0073935925,
0.0096541699,
0.0014655166,
0.029432619,
-0.0925134718,
0.0265403166,
-0.0364060737,
-0.0006200108,
0.0468308516,
0.0093363533,
-0.0183368791,
-0.0141354473,
0.0211871248,
0.0114081716,
-0.0050072265,
0.0324359871,
-0.0072583836,
0.0408055186,
-0.039818123,
0.0786106288,
0.0432825238,
0.0121150082,
0.0202676803,
-0.0516148023,
0.0245531835,
0.0506247468,
0.051208239,
-0.0050291889,
-0.016838029,
-0.0408776402,
0.0627162009,
0.0218637399,
0.0659893826,
-0.0084921857,
0.0268433578,
-0.027488783,
-0.0026295455,
-0.016852431,
0.0451093391,
-0.0125322053,
-0.0112396264,
0.0083400849,
0.0118973143,
-0.0484663993,
-0.0368080996,
0.0417821296,
-0.0094378218,
-0.0614288598,
-0.0156043656,
-0.0233996566,
0.0142502654,
-0.0235711541,
-0.018504981,
0.0309622381,
-0.0004000379,
-0.0186158679,
-0.031286981,
-0.0212986208,
-0.0272510611,
-0.0180761609,
0.0401015244,
-0.0224755276,
-0.0443164967,
0.0444866307,
-0.0494414456,
-0.0066123237,
-0.00876687,
-0.046132341,
0.0200406052,
-0.0521331988,
0.0192842018,
-0.014405176,
0.0410772562,
-0.0457342863,
0.0502007306,
-0.0353051051,
0.0094845248,
0.0229060072,
-0.0056261308,
-0.0076719192,
-0.010635158,
-0.0045241201,
0.0065357578,
0.0026718914,
0.0267518256,
0.0052356753,
-0.0254392605,
-0.0605680272,
-0.0389967747,
-0.0352330096,
0.0084969718,
-0.0377747416,
0.0102139506,
0.0330166034,
-0.0112066064,
-0.0064923372,
-0.0242889635,
-0.0260823481,
0.0019015551,
0.0256406087,
0.0375696048,
0.0027926599,
-0.0005615752,
-0.009121988,
-0.0173319317,
0.0180365294,
-0.0011710658,
0.0132342856,
-0.0433155969,
-0.0268011801,
-0.1154131666,
-0.0060842005,
-0.0351076946,
0.0205957722,
0.0132201668,
-0.0344727635,
-0.0072111175,
0.0188357402,
0.0230115913,
0.0789880976,
0.0202014949,
0.016053956,
0.048996646,
0.0070051379,
-0.0430746078,
0.0098411422,
-0.0199561361,
-0.0552004613,
-0.0278194658,
-0.0464141667,
0.0093327835,
0.052677203,
0.024006851,
0.0208456423,
-0.0670151711,
0.0505923741,
-0.027669549,
-0.0524919033,
0.0119435145,
0.0002166105,
-0.0210039038,
0.0199272372,
-0.0400220528,
-0.0436218493,
0.0808567777,
-0.0160675123,
0.0153991645,
-0.0220012497,
0.0226738118,
0.0092395423,
0.0131403031,
0.0002546468,
0.0150170596,
0.0124434596,
-0.0179741271,
-0.0761102885,
-0.0298071839,
0.0122285699,
-0.0535649508,
0.0220261719,
-0.0256801601,
-0.0079947896,
0.0104948981,
-0.0238590576,
-0.0541336276,
-0.0733987167,
-0.0301756263,
-0.0100383116,
-0.0323878452,
0.0144188618,
-0.0381471887,
-0.0314509198,
0.0080470592,
0.0032505752,
-0.05260114,
-0.0075665261,
-0.0254219342,
0.0297831055,
0.1282273531,
0.0544840544,
0.0707758889,
-0.0355852433,
0.028784059,
0.0774684921,
-0.0171624459,
0.064277485,
-0.0157858059,
-0.0118016051,
0.0152258286,
-0.0108340299,
0.0039874394,
0.0230880696,
0.0718110204,
-0.0734902173,
-0.0382496603,
0.1012297943,
0.0225249194,
-0.0294378605,
0.020776581,
-0.0483957529,
0.0758821368,
0.0137132751,
0.0125163626,
-0.0629177466,
-0.0493525267,
0.0073051564,
0.045947738,
0.0047159079,
-0.024660185,
0.0129656037,
-0.0837934092,
0.0304001849,
0.036851652,
-0.0277639143,
-0.0602941513,
-0.037360128,
-0.0000208959,
0.0248823129,
0.0757123232,
0.0175206382,
0.0176476575,
-0.0125464965,
0.0177327432,
-0.0231771637,
-0.0522088781,
0.0350918099,
-0.0318930224,
0.0799360499,
0.0795920417,
0.0304155648,
0.0037054273,
-0.0488482565,
0.0373037085,
-0.0229718015,
-0.0162796006,
-0.0063633905,
0.0536669679,
0.004593384,
-0.0124053098,
-0.003450206,
0.0448865965,
-0.0267327726,
-0.0149255376,
-0.0036346209,
0.0709876418,
-0.0366441533,
-0.0343355611,
0.0038971335,
0.0170149971,
0.0122456849,
0.0785338059,
0.0345748439,
-0.0210665297,
-0.0449102782,
-0.03692507,
0.020428624,
-0.0245745387,
-0.0474655628,
0.0707037225,
0.0610866621,
0.0026322405,
-0.0543013215,
-0.0458264686,
0.0276004486,
-0.0200391635,
-0.0071799881,
0.0274994038,
-0.0077483854,
-0.014237849,
-0.0226735398,
0.0589593798,
-0.0779072419,
0.0152071128,
-0.0286004171,
0.0027281486,
0.0051490832,
-0.0048435964,
-0.0005343783,
0.0153001063,
-0.0914292559,
-0.0683499277,
0.0350413956,
0.0436804406,
0.021109676,
0.0612127446,
-0.0303671937,
-0.0924042538,
0.0104540791,
0.0376888961,
-0.035423208,
0.036917571,
0.0277576987,
-0.0304343589,
-0.0038385219,
0.0684343427,
-0.0351930149,
-0.006341707,
0.0352102369,
0.0345334783,
0.0044456329,
-0.0143142417,
0.0638094917,
0.0058739358,
-0.0002536196,
-0.0092263632,
0.0122622568,
-0.0069690077,
0.0129449582,
0.0123755271,
-0.0189184006,
-0.0093702329,
-0.0059426208,
0.0467936881,
-0.038191326,
-0.0007129907,
-0.0171024054,
-0.0066333893,
0.0258291494,
-0.0598907545,
-0.0097115459,
0.0234423205,
0.0014652108,
0.0425090529,
-0.0085165091,
-0.0415261798,
0.029788373,
-0.0078373495,
0.0597688965,
-0.0120615875,
0.0375814028,
0.0208803751,
-0.0133530349,
-0.0434074216,
0.0103550851,
-0.0502710007,
-0.1004565954,
-0.0426740982,
-0.0067697982,
0.0137605788,
0.0029576018,
0.0430519618,
-0.013726267,
-0.0281490739,
-0.0182905644,
-0.0107974317,
0.0220553726,
-0.0028277251,
0.0336073004,
0.022831792,
-0.0273305532,
0.0060948208,
0.065721333,
-0.006756776,
0.065423727,
-0.0018325252,
-0.0156773645,
-0.0379642397,
-0.059537556,
-0.0493885837,
0.0188607126,
-0.02429864,
0.0153111061,
-0.0283990484,
-0.0717772618,
-0.0310262628,
-0.0015722525,
-0.0071607428,
-0.0274686683,
0.000924985,
0.0492140874,
-0.0228077304,
-0.0277287699,
-0.0233021881,
0.0112166982,
0.0533308052,
-0.0049922261,
-0.0115706343,
-6.941249326e-33,
0.0053085084,
-0.0022633413,
0.0081703272,
-0.0366304256,
-0.0337596387,
-0.0276480485,
-0.0228245314,
0.0160721559,
-0.0454696752,
0.0319471546,
-0.0132742617,
0.0238840785,
0.0072691408,
0.0205055866,
0.0076945103,
-0.0411098897,
0.0675179735,
0.0038082551,
-0.0362465382,
0.0213344377,
0.0047074892,
0.0105733518,
0.0439472683,
-0.0538158566,
0.0342022553,
-0.0290067829,
-0.0573649108,
0.0343292281,
-0.0417036191,
0.0297141802,
-0.0361023992,
0.0394403972,
0.0199271664,
-0.026316544,
-0.0374493785,
0.0082269991,
-0.0764714405,
0.0016486609,
0.0111401835,
0.0367783904,
-0.0223400742,
-0.0463992208,
0.0541779324,
-0.0104010124,
0.0169029925,
-0.01684702,
0.001098157,
-0.0574146807,
-0.0152976429,
0.0217234232,
-0.0682333782,
0.0062863086,
0.0037003476,
-0.0356316641,
-0.0100782877,
0.048950363,
-0.0222881716,
0.0279588941,
-0.0605526157,
-0.0349355377,
0.0358218662,
0.0342964381,
0.0443813689,
-0.0051473179,
-0.0084693311,
0.045551341,
0.0426529087,
0.0177806467,
-0.0192616712,
-0.0212677624,
0.0121467011,
0.0262892116,
0.0442115217,
0.0351879336,
0.0651643947,
-0.018762324,
-0.0478701293,
-0.0129862949,
-0.0625512898,
0.0456598811,
0.0376949348,
-0.0006607152,
-0.0110337185,
-0.0281134229,
-0.0580272414,
0.0245622527,
-0.0400653481,
0.0122985886,
0.0409943126,
0.0192352943,
-0.0404580384,
-0.0033452897,
0.0428340808,
-0.0539008714,
0.00923023,
0.0190843698,
-0.005119489,
-0.0070828772,
0.0161324739,
0.0282678641,
0.0016425829,
0.0083546489,
0.0078600263,
-0.0300880875,
0.0380956158,
0.0241243057,
0.0380803496,
-0.0072066872,
-0.0733614936,
0.0085990634,
-0.0366172232,
0.0363261662,
0.0244806688,
0.0139075303,
0.0412178487,
0.0146341268,
-0.0164379347,
0.0029429938,
0.0102922134,
-0.0048420709,
-0.0119822677,
0.0448160544,
-0.0002933465,
0.0164856669,
-0.0318153873,
-0.0196554959,
-0.027442893,
-0.0029689511,
0.0105248699,
-0.0747109577,
-0.0198505577,
0.0113890367,
2.769e-7,
0.0269291811,
0.0500284433,
0.0134367477,
0.0155173857,
0.0227531698,
0.0314396136,
0.0208424293,
0.0260617509,
0.042773962,
-0.0628711209,
-0.0145182647,
0.0333766192,
0.0635614172,
0.0372564122,
-0.0736182779,
0.0056220926,
-0.0531900078,
0.041349452,
-0.0560379736,
-0.036407765,
0.0454792269,
0.110806331,
-0.0079870075,
-0.0312185697,
0.0129057607,
-0.0405444019,
0.0604461804,
0.0143390093,
0.0142441196,
0.0382406674,
0.0123084262,
0.0136223817,
0.0157566871,
0.0330816545,
-0.0205080751,
-0.0138460482,
-0.0096745854,
0.0491762348,
-0.0260003395,
-0.0508647375,
-0.0505728424,
-0.0268418472,
0.0250877719,
-0.0668146312,
0.0770292133,
-0.0830806568,
-0.0256966427,
-0.0386505462,
-0.0315362625,
-0.0005614729,
0.0341919996,
-0.0194750689,
-0.0093401205,
0.0220281631,
0.0264819581,
0.0552534908,
-0.0167474691,
-0.0631994382,
-0.0234123524,
0.0114716133,
-0.0306195989,
-0.037316598,
-0.014430088,
0.0005073039,
0.0250853188,
-0.0721104518,
0.044749476,
2.693768594e-34,
0.0357836522,
-0.0173904188,
0.0554251485,
0.0427478813,
0.0459243134,
0.0142399007,
0.0645291656,
0.0136688873,
0.013491692,
-0.0632072762,
-0.013163575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11263v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11263v1 | The Fall of ROME: Understanding the Collapse of LLMs in Model Editing | 2024-06-17T07:08:29 | 2024-06-17T07:08:29 | Wanli Yang, Fei Sun, Jiajun Tan, Xinyu Ma, Du Su, Dawei Yin, Huawei Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite significant progress in model editing methods, their application in
real-world scenarios remains challenging as they often cause large language
models (LLMs) to collapse. Among them, ROME is particularly concerning, as it
could disrupt LLMs with only a single edit. In this paper, we study the root
causes of such collapse. Through extensive analysis, we identify two primary
factors that contribute to the collapse: i) inconsistent handling of prefixed
and unprefixed keys in the parameter update equation may result in very small
denominators, causing excessively large parameter updates; ii) the subject of
collapse cases is usually the first token, whose unprefixed key distribution
significantly differs from the prefixed key distribution in autoregressive
transformers, causing the aforementioned issue to materialize. To validate our
analysis, we propose a simple yet effective approach: uniformly using prefixed
keys during editing phase and adding prefixes during the testing phase. The
experimental results show that the proposed solution can prevent model collapse
while maintaining the effectiveness of the edits. | [
0.0284964591,
0.0858961269,
-0.0179693736,
0.0035979971,
-0.0223341268,
-0.0183072351,
-0.0259783417,
0.0065964451,
-0.0583774969,
-0.0548562109,
0.0123353833,
-0.0394506566,
0.0336664654,
0.0355862044,
0.0244549587,
-0.0434837602,
0.0966262519,
-0.0642350316,
-0.0309365168,
0.0044667539,
-0.0330459252,
-0.0252791103,
0.0341964364,
0.0339190401,
0.0095796753,
0.0057860571,
-0.0349863209,
0.0061241612,
-0.0051413355,
0.0297131184,
-0.0365392305,
0.0579827912,
-0.0159864482,
0.0259954445,
0.0000020935,
-0.0436296202,
-0.0502384044,
0.0371034741,
-0.0400750786,
0.0956248417,
0.0104035083,
0.0061503481,
-0.072198391,
0.0255285241,
0.0037424089,
-0.0083759595,
0.0411428474,
0.0075670104,
0.0463716872,
0.0560674295,
-0.004772048,
0.0119650047,
0.0056083468,
-0.0121906456,
-0.043689318,
-0.0499962494,
0.0559230857,
0.0006443327,
0.034654282,
0.0030508849,
-0.017984828,
0.0195400678,
0.0005497782,
-0.0531076826,
-0.0347880311,
0.000348217,
-0.0103033949,
-0.0196219403,
0.001368107,
-0.0110741146,
-0.0020877135,
-0.0367810093,
0.0313096158,
-0.0025004772,
-0.01717229,
0.0197919626,
-0.0476667397,
-0.0026272307,
0.0177344866,
0.0045630718,
0.0419826023,
-0.0760392547,
0.0169257168,
-0.0145201674,
-0.0397878364,
0.0560959168,
0.0386893153,
-0.0026750155,
-0.0702747107,
-0.0514194816,
-0.0169682447,
-0.0945650861,
-0.0047127195,
0.0388606228,
-0.043322444,
0.0158869755,
-0.0548792705,
0.010636935,
0.0065182303,
-0.0809995607,
0.0334798284,
0.035461124,
0.0071851523,
0.0093342392,
0.0033053649,
0.0658165812,
-0.0299233887,
-0.0092287324,
0.011159014,
0.043950703,
-0.0194739103,
-0.027276339,
-0.0731435567,
0.0003089683,
-0.0153956087,
0.0296141598,
-0.0097268932,
0.0528283566,
0.0297240466,
0.0335356668,
0.0001303794,
-0.0519091897,
-0.0137475142,
-0.0015791635,
0.0056459429,
0.02718064,
0.0201590154,
-0.0306241997,
-0.0177852809,
-0.0403115749,
-0.0075251111,
-0.0283186547,
-0.0176169239,
-0.0189753361,
-0.0211775564,
0.0761375874,
0.0130859679,
0.0311862603,
-0.0557821766,
-0.0609167852,
-0.0209758282,
-0.0284298044,
-0.0428012833,
-0.0572040416,
-0.0408429615,
0.0176063869,
-0.0242975131,
-0.069177784,
-0.0178555716,
-0.0195703357,
-0.0391273908,
0.0277276803,
-0.053859368,
0.0536790714,
-0.0095159989,
-0.0031765932,
0.0158742238,
0.065386124,
0.0496906154,
-0.0211809725,
0.0696259886,
-0.0147267533,
0.0518117361,
0.0683448315,
-0.0116631584,
0.0877970681,
-0.0386612788,
-0.0052191773,
0.0473561473,
-0.0081288842,
-0.0058071488,
0.0308452323,
0.0063395659,
-0.0083039384,
0.0561261997,
-0.0085091628,
0.0064916126,
0.0661093965,
-0.0095465844,
-0.0090652788,
-0.0128430286,
0.0120584555,
-0.0368462801,
-0.0177311357,
-0.0169321075,
0.0459826887,
-0.0205852631,
0.0330434702,
-0.0115763666,
-0.0324169621,
-0.0432450213,
0.0298769344,
-0.0194960721,
-0.0372382104,
0.0454238951,
0.0147200674,
-0.0297505092,
0.0987828523,
0.0135783236,
-0.0531389564,
-0.0043943324,
-0.0668077618,
-0.0286290105,
0.0432420522,
0.0848275498,
-0.0097482614,
-0.0708771646,
0.0084618991,
-0.0114890477,
0.0003286024,
0.0627438724,
0.0008611079,
-0.0108322175,
-0.0122408578,
-0.0143185928,
0.0262371339,
0.0208958481,
0.0217213724,
-0.0201540813,
0.0085366471,
0.0255054664,
-0.016413413,
-0.0210580323,
-0.0087324856,
-0.0589049831,
-0.0076551931,
-0.0274021868,
0.007731989,
-0.026590066,
0.0130324988,
-0.0315072834,
0.0027721496,
-0.0040182462,
0.0369506106,
0.0016765442,
0.0319028497,
-0.0150839463,
0.0578186475,
0.0758985281,
0.037739493,
0.0006968979,
0.0241478328,
-0.0146893887,
-0.0376969464,
0.0396116488,
-0.0462880321,
0.0840184242,
0.0293812118,
0.0893764868,
-0.0544245839,
-0.0130292168,
-0.0017415526,
-0.0204653684,
-0.0165055692,
-0.0218627974,
-0.0046813064,
0.0202034563,
0.0295039304,
-0.0071461047,
-0.0465691276,
0.0525144041,
0.0034689039,
-0.0022769836,
0.0142192384,
-0.0041937414,
-0.0022010189,
-0.0429158397,
-0.0283696111,
-0.0201455858,
-0.0156044438,
0.0496003143,
0.019713616,
0.0525625944,
-0.0456876531,
0.0138673894,
0.0362972245,
-0.0365224853,
-0.0005814435,
0.0361667983,
0.0186468791,
0.0164629072,
-0.0774690881,
-0.0490322262,
-0.0140653942,
-0.0172271561,
0.0592523105,
-0.0072475458,
-0.0304227509,
-0.0949410349,
0.0494373329,
-0.0259000007,
0.0289225206,
-0.0095659811,
-0.072170265,
-0.0012947709,
-0.0125973281,
0.0682851076,
-0.0221101809,
-0.0457327589,
0.0131658781,
0.0466560498,
-0.0467877872,
-0.021334324,
-0.0270412508,
0.0246476773,
-0.0444362462,
-0.0589378737,
-0.0269336794,
0.0051710014,
0.0924598873,
-0.0513757654,
-0.0513931401,
-0.0303871948,
-0.0036264053,
-0.0119236065,
-0.0056881644,
0.0280200616,
-0.0539649017,
-0.0485114381,
0.0455392823,
-0.0076994677,
-0.0358298421,
0.023878403,
-0.0564257875,
0.0052935779,
-0.0370887071,
0.0173470322,
-0.0401004963,
0.0132525722,
-0.0281387512,
-0.010998413,
0.0235147756,
-0.0294472929,
-0.0366974138,
0.0037803585,
0.0054952255,
-0.0106794499,
0.0740948096,
-0.032130219,
0.0200761836,
-0.0334725901,
-0.0100901742,
-0.015399985,
0.0019588547,
-0.0257040486,
0.0116103841,
0.0726511627,
-0.0294968467,
0.0051930905,
0.0502141453,
0.0064248694,
0.0315816216,
-0.0148223946,
0.0004476287,
-0.0374887846,
-0.0259181224,
0.021666497,
-0.0010821345,
0.022265099,
-0.041359257,
0.0373459756,
0.0281912088,
0.0739942938,
-0.0381307192,
-0.0591328479,
-0.0105851945,
0.0249590445,
-0.0446897596,
-0.0449408181,
0.0071197744,
-0.0132854199,
-0.0299355946,
0.0018230277,
0.0712047592,
0.0253776181,
-0.0262759514,
0.0505136698,
-0.0589725338,
0.0640101954,
0.0458794385,
0.0643895194,
-0.0769282207,
0.0349888876,
0.0582042858,
0.0152075067,
-0.0096564116,
-0.0082666017,
-0.0234769601,
-0.0778227523,
0.0458626747,
0.0250868499,
-0.0257386267,
0.0011646328,
-0.0557641648,
0.0148012368,
0.0001686011,
0.0429562852,
0.0642222613,
-0.02470042,
0.0012399605,
0.0049949228,
-0.0282685105,
-0.039978236,
-0.0247735046,
-0.0296851341,
0.0652131811,
0.01579584,
0.0033984007,
0.0099720601,
0.0255913269,
0.0836498141,
0.0875879377,
0.0182742849,
-0.038531635,
-0.0369930826,
0.0738609135,
-0.0124614956,
0.0312499907,
-0.0265073664,
-0.0150417807,
-0.0325973704,
0.0021240448,
0.0714554414,
-0.0084122373,
0.0030332897,
-0.0020861039,
-0.0424165316,
-0.0039530015,
0.0156713128,
0.0492908768,
-0.003843687,
-0.024392901,
-0.0462215208,
-0.0435006022,
-0.0123847062,
-0.0389464647,
-0.0261971001,
-0.029233234,
-0.0370528512,
-0.0145893432,
-0.0096794497,
0.0042100134,
0.0346190594,
0.0226100851,
0.0104272068,
0.0176725872,
-0.0131960008,
0.0062193759,
-0.0180028211,
-0.0344509929,
0.0139375273,
-0.082775712,
0.023783965,
0.0166294035,
0.0000117939,
-0.0245719738,
-0.0155408885,
-0.0695355907,
-0.1070336699,
0.0536678471,
0.0452826396,
0.0351374932,
0.0304797627,
0.0058008516,
-0.0945103094,
-0.0077437018,
-0.006457286,
0.0042545428,
0.0536318272,
0.0170975551,
-0.0060750879,
0.0031368516,
-0.002738151,
-0.047557883,
-0.0199747942,
0.0010150702,
0.020144647,
-0.0289245695,
-0.0289527457,
-0.0181442145,
0.0650643483,
-0.0156260934,
0.0012298748,
-0.0008990004,
0.0070112618,
0.0623017028,
-0.0589699969,
0.0166028105,
-0.0018823828,
0.0570447072,
-0.0504974313,
0.004883782,
0.0063924463,
-0.0023930571,
-0.0411315747,
0.030354863,
0.0075761625,
0.0344141461,
-0.0197549835,
0.0224147048,
0.086887449,
0.0108941542,
0.017894147,
0.0331071466,
0.0368649699,
0.0098925205,
-0.024068851,
-0.0080454042,
0.0071671968,
-0.0024120898,
-0.046700269,
0.0248516295,
-0.0357872956,
-0.0642610118,
-0.0133431591,
0.0259246435,
0.0314870961,
0.0233831462,
0.0577745736,
-0.0276532434,
0.0007629524,
-0.025224125,
0.0094617158,
0.004216366,
0.0016804625,
-0.0242733452,
0.0021838115,
-0.0096885152,
0.0378016904,
0.0437445305,
0.0265545212,
0.0563379116,
-0.0054259175,
-0.0076869843,
-0.0096603502,
-0.0166029464,
-0.0089350799,
-0.0458958149,
-0.0294791758,
-0.0715515092,
-0.0516670309,
-0.0573110618,
0.0054708938,
0.016277466,
0.0094404509,
-0.0126579078,
-0.0048191575,
0.0487670936,
0.0247640926,
0.035481438,
-0.0146638388,
-0.0267931186,
0.0201193225,
-0.012197121,
0.0328652002,
-5.987093214e-33,
-0.0015853847,
0.017467238,
0.0370743647,
0.0021944479,
-0.0208589286,
-0.0295536201,
-0.0564471222,
0.0122921951,
0.0359777585,
-0.0344958939,
-0.030910233,
-0.0106665138,
0.0221571382,
-0.0310919899,
0.0193643644,
0.0104425419,
0.0596101321,
0.0289779175,
-0.0239779111,
0.019331947,
0.0279559027,
0.015369988,
0.0791499391,
-0.0347417183,
0.0241722353,
-0.0124784475,
0.0073442934,
0.0276789535,
0.0018356612,
0.0587521382,
0.0243841726,
0.0128607443,
-0.0114996303,
-0.0418130755,
-0.0641769469,
-0.0486236103,
-0.0089170355,
-0.0077267219,
0.0209081061,
0.0533502921,
0.035893932,
-0.0639739409,
0.0178626571,
0.0452504419,
-0.0328000821,
-0.001707931,
-0.0002746189,
-0.0098747639,
-0.0158978347,
0.0081473095,
-0.056827344,
0.0281246956,
-0.0004478493,
0.0264136866,
0.0074481098,
0.0055248425,
0.0147113474,
-0.0189554412,
-0.0168451555,
0.0268317703,
0.1182620153,
0.0714206174,
0.0702342466,
0.0059128115,
-0.0003044608,
-0.0048778844,
-0.0185971279,
0.0506833121,
-0.0050355322,
-0.0068205693,
0.0348914862,
0.0333181396,
0.0087167881,
0.005397636,
0.0009958196,
-0.0360604711,
0.0011306808,
0.0227710158,
-0.0144516416,
0.0449435562,
-0.0002057104,
0.0495318733,
-0.0204622895,
0.0062931874,
-0.0570972115,
0.0035546839,
-0.0442074314,
-0.0405860245,
-0.0010104899,
-0.0335301049,
0.0052755456,
0.0075683915,
0.0388680622,
-0.0488962047,
-0.0593006797,
-0.0138396742,
-0.0290724337,
0.0457111709,
-0.0267640073,
0.0123944385,
0.0276584178,
-0.0147704203,
0.011365559,
-0.0054301857,
0.0330971666,
0.0052765859,
-0.0399300084,
0.0752159059,
-0.0659519061,
0.013794804,
0.0057649203,
0.0171308201,
0.0310021397,
0.0003303293,
0.0065931804,
-0.0485206954,
0.0177563205,
0.0123703592,
0.0445394441,
-0.0221782308,
0.0013293177,
0.0655472204,
0.0291847289,
0.0405638292,
0.0064022224,
-0.0034702574,
-0.036156524,
0.0425875336,
0.0659219325,
-0.0563298874,
-0.0457826033,
-0.0017688171,
2.928e-7,
0.011170323,
0.0988473147,
0.0677795857,
-0.0017614448,
0.0052932701,
0.0215328801,
-0.0371576697,
0.0045722025,
0.0134185189,
0.0273766983,
-0.0005344368,
-0.0313376747,
0.0319930129,
0.0222023688,
-0.0259159096,
0.0426449627,
-0.0985036567,
0.0139810881,
-0.0723283365,
-0.0436655618,
-0.0238338541,
0.0348015875,
0.0280531384,
-0.0022547606,
-0.0192795862,
0.0069064987,
-0.0089588976,
-0.0201917905,
-0.0315151215,
0.0533743277,
0.0220359489,
-0.0064149396,
0.0243894532,
-0.0266404599,
-0.0406874493,
0.014682753,
-0.0270095784,
0.0489891022,
-0.0150600486,
0.0147018209,
0.0404205844,
-0.0330148116,
-0.0199258495,
-0.0415623598,
0.0395005047,
-0.0102425544,
0.0071733468,
-0.0665775016,
-0.0345135257,
-0.0116616404,
-0.0339251347,
-0.0200451463,
0.0217311457,
0.0653125271,
0.0013199415,
0.0242334288,
0.0059678177,
-0.0201113094,
-0.0401427187,
0.002725105,
-0.0442892052,
-0.0329343416,
-0.0278363395,
-0.0040827496,
0.010904449,
-0.005621444,
-0.0070389928,
3.101421081e-34,
0.0347349979,
-0.0461070985,
0.0397619531,
0.0509454012,
0.0347442366,
-0.010822216,
0.0020860233,
0.0655096024,
0.0010565656,
-0.0460613035,
-0.0703590214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11260v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11260v1 | Adversarial Style Augmentation via Large Language Model for Robust Fake News Detection | 2024-06-17T07:00:41 | 2024-06-17T07:00:41 | Sungwon Park, Sungwon Han, Meeyoung Cha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The spread of fake news negatively impacts individuals and is regarded as a
significant social challenge that needs to be addressed. A number of
algorithmic and insightful features have been identified for detecting fake
news. However, with the recent LLMs and their advanced generation capabilities,
many of the detectable features (e.g., style-conversion attacks) can be
altered, making it more challenging to distinguish from real news. This study
proposes adversarial style augmentation, AdStyle, to train a fake news detector
that remains robust against various style-conversion attacks. Our model's key
mechanism is the careful use of LLMs to automatically generate a diverse yet
coherent range of style-conversion attack prompts. This improves the generation
of prompts that are particularly difficult for the detector to handle.
Experiments show that our augmentation strategy improves robustness and
detection performance when tested on fake news benchmark datasets. | [
0.052225329,
0.0503917821,
-0.0116502205,
0.0564982779,
-0.0119175566,
0.0062087961,
-0.0001574743,
0.0311075523,
0.0159975365,
-0.0264534596,
-0.0195706263,
-0.0570915639,
-0.0074987258,
0.0431041829,
0.0677892864,
-0.0207955781,
0.0363003835,
0.0028013964,
0.0377557129,
-0.0227576327,
0.0632634386,
0.0338476561,
-0.0038418558,
0.0096340887,
-0.0065100403,
-0.0137323132,
0.0138116777,
0.0542515442,
0.0439257696,
0.0042836689,
0.0125101227,
0.044938717,
0.0110894348,
0.0919313431,
0.0000017895,
-0.0069486382,
0.0040920824,
-0.0086415783,
-0.0020495714,
0.0396641158,
0.0483296476,
-0.0764527619,
-0.0440528952,
0.0112669012,
-0.0202217586,
-0.0319857113,
0.0233264174,
0.0801653042,
0.0948791504,
0.1360892653,
-0.0192188546,
-0.0392657779,
0.0470462926,
-0.0288540758,
0.0169147905,
-0.0363472439,
0.0356795974,
-0.0327374078,
-0.0347879045,
0.0678691566,
0.0332431681,
0.0168648697,
0.0097758761,
-0.0310154222,
-0.0405241363,
-0.0115289558,
-0.0204087719,
0.0092325322,
0.0002480768,
0.0363575146,
-0.0710778087,
-0.035117574,
0.010578759,
-0.0136165665,
0.0523847044,
0.0231293384,
-0.01701634,
0.0025143079,
-0.0099104354,
0.0019297565,
-0.027571667,
-0.0347558483,
0.0487246439,
0.0481824949,
0.0256664902,
-0.0194532573,
0.0084019369,
-0.0259675551,
-0.0270604286,
-0.0274306014,
-0.0348389968,
-0.0307404883,
0.0323028751,
-0.019888917,
-0.006235315,
-0.0104404185,
-0.0928097069,
-0.0503952987,
0.0199279021,
-0.0891776234,
0.0370895863,
-0.0122159831,
-0.0079709757,
-0.0019904464,
-0.0429812744,
0.0287078004,
-0.0466523916,
0.0358834341,
-0.0131633822,
0.0122061223,
0.0049879579,
0.006606387,
-0.0059799752,
-0.0325495154,
0.0095316954,
0.0098043019,
-0.0294222422,
0.0036434452,
-0.0053898487,
0.0414027236,
-0.0151152145,
-0.00644982,
-0.0415145829,
-0.0451205038,
0.0371626914,
0.0247940719,
0.0340331271,
0.0067470148,
0.0089844204,
-0.0374092124,
-0.0200558007,
0.042841427,
-0.0379965194,
-0.0166304726,
-0.0121024381,
0.0239722896,
-0.0162534602,
0.0053859469,
-0.0650218576,
-0.0104103275,
-0.0267804749,
-0.0108530857,
0.0333607681,
-0.0630642921,
-0.0552246347,
-0.0479488,
-0.009579937,
-0.0584803298,
-0.0146092763,
0.0119658997,
-0.0241277739,
0.0431438424,
0.0136390869,
-0.0283487048,
0.0608331934,
0.0291731823,
0.0224087834,
0.0881352872,
0.0042938096,
0.1296901703,
0.0351245254,
-0.0146522978,
0.0010075384,
0.0683576018,
0.0508475825,
0.0392912626,
-0.0313020833,
-0.0425458625,
0.0113244411,
0.0290224012,
0.0290299505,
0.017255662,
0.0069452222,
-0.078916505,
0.0986177176,
-0.0716824979,
0.0061619761,
0.0238904096,
0.0328248702,
0.0316391289,
0.0189464688,
0.0034033563,
-0.0399865024,
-0.0002195062,
-0.0854988024,
0.002985388,
-0.0167716295,
0.0497172512,
-0.0161637906,
0.0110644624,
0.0046557775,
0.0030274324,
0.0093333255,
-0.014747357,
-0.0158773679,
0.0509386286,
-0.0347751454,
-0.0312300939,
-0.0003808096,
0.0016541012,
-0.0060256897,
-0.07707268,
0.0091242222,
0.0537728257,
0.0463019572,
0.0344230421,
0.0384445302,
-0.0330539048,
0.0140983434,
0.0376917049,
0.0320030935,
-0.0174382981,
-0.0241037644,
-0.028260313,
-0.013462442,
-0.0522894934,
0.0018916103,
0.0190748777,
0.0220614746,
0.0347727053,
0.0124956826,
0.0081053665,
-0.0442238338,
0.0155585697,
0.0071083927,
-0.0429038927,
0.0046534454,
0.0258614682,
0.0069554462,
0.0239314139,
-0.0140482765,
-0.0015667854,
0.0132739674,
-0.0391280353,
-0.0232559182,
-0.0323780514,
0.002280788,
-0.0483495854,
-0.0020201101,
-0.0322353728,
-0.0503532775,
0.0736627355,
-0.0388822034,
-0.0043784715,
0.0339737572,
-0.0718365386,
-0.004203523,
-0.0462353416,
-0.0315723754,
-0.0219585299,
0.0390336327,
-0.0078997277,
0.0574105904,
-0.0223791339,
-0.0455875918,
-0.0052785203,
0.0406492688,
-0.0247918386,
-0.011296114,
-0.0161593519,
-0.0117214667,
-0.006002848,
0.00694498,
0.0136752473,
-0.0021610323,
0.0066012093,
-0.0260866936,
-0.0268483516,
-0.0247946363,
-0.0232310686,
0.0113101164,
0.0471162982,
0.0089948177,
-0.0195163675,
0.0033152071,
-0.0602071956,
-0.0232886001,
-0.0250406154,
0.0256642736,
-0.0226855204,
-0.0328301042,
-0.00822856,
-0.0040865084,
0.0023090441,
0.0068498044,
0.0355009064,
0.0104458164,
-0.0485967509,
-0.0303187873,
-0.0251696836,
-0.0009225202,
0.0093587348,
-0.0161954928,
-0.0505474024,
0.0046773921,
-0.010638413,
0.0140716089,
0.0715846941,
0.0941988304,
0.040718101,
0.0061189351,
0.0663563088,
-0.0262766592,
-0.0446250811,
0.004730917,
0.0295732319,
-0.0197544768,
-0.0771083981,
0.0492323637,
0.010130005,
0.0490220003,
0.0230212957,
-0.0096388161,
0.0456665792,
0.0370165147,
-0.047941111,
0.0363351814,
-0.0185491238,
-0.0137305856,
-0.0274082404,
-0.0296497308,
-0.023880586,
0.0766201839,
-0.0411246419,
0.0148926256,
0.028603375,
-0.0309983771,
0.0246732924,
-0.0123366471,
-0.0012135331,
0.0285063032,
0.0106435847,
-0.0224967245,
-0.0039060067,
-0.011310732,
0.0826263726,
-0.0244919248,
0.0165555924,
0.0066543873,
0.0258979425,
0.0133200269,
0.0193974487,
-0.0707573146,
-0.1004779264,
0.0069559338,
-0.0182956252,
0.0068505229,
-0.0420372449,
-0.0475578383,
-0.0213221908,
0.0234876834,
0.0580263212,
-0.0499017723,
0.0048586256,
0.0085720886,
0.0601557158,
0.0370796844,
-0.0169224422,
0.0032839759,
-0.0232750624,
-0.0157502852,
0.0573403984,
-0.0284988675,
0.0375523865,
-0.035374552,
-0.0204503816,
0.0162420776,
0.0222250838,
0.0006683824,
-0.0175567456,
0.0366868153,
-0.0435964577,
0.0013709019,
0.0663906261,
-0.0047484185,
-0.0127903577,
0.0008472442,
0.0303222965,
-0.0008622219,
-0.0026357479,
0.0008778889,
-0.0615907721,
-0.0251151528,
-0.0033705733,
0.0166884065,
-0.0302704796,
0.0148356957,
-0.0137657551,
-0.0582213253,
0.0007424174,
0.030542979,
-0.0402530618,
-0.0153105957,
-0.0151413688,
-0.0006732178,
0.024104096,
0.0219313651,
-0.0238427687,
0.0265718028,
-0.0305628665,
-0.0017339723,
0.0165346339,
-0.0787946135,
-0.0302800573,
0.0055269925,
0.0723546073,
0.0769455582,
0.0347569957,
-0.0307998229,
-0.0875984356,
0.0124757523,
0.0087327138,
-0.0161463935,
-0.0006320938,
0.0558415391,
-0.0202550683,
-0.0120069813,
-0.0200072769,
0.0617665388,
0.0387627222,
0.0107476804,
0.0224744827,
0.0052350238,
0.005323519,
-0.0822258517,
-0.0479523316,
0.0020861954,
0.0347594172,
0.044056423,
0.0312211011,
-0.0420445018,
0.0105468156,
-0.0706285834,
0.0108927032,
-0.0604841299,
-0.0761977881,
0.0187476724,
-0.0239400156,
-0.0288876984,
-0.0689506605,
0.0144925844,
-0.0513150692,
0.0223760046,
-0.0135531975,
-0.0397597849,
-0.0486627221,
-0.0119150467,
-0.0272191558,
-0.0153172333,
-0.0009435452,
0.0677742362,
-0.0075047566,
-0.006310286,
0.0033054696,
-0.0476551354,
-0.0066828751,
0.0529931001,
-0.0730142593,
-0.0547379553,
0.0154002206,
0.0297591928,
0.0074687367,
0.050135415,
-0.03418025,
-0.0768034682,
0.0752009228,
0.0805970281,
0.0264494605,
0.0202340633,
0.0597072467,
-0.0295739006,
0.0350569338,
0.033150021,
0.0101407627,
0.0385062546,
0.0461773574,
-0.0415503979,
-0.0289328862,
0.010923245,
0.0081159361,
0.0235915631,
0.0120002348,
-0.0398132168,
0.0312154982,
0.0162033234,
-0.0265830569,
-0.0317275152,
-0.0130737275,
-0.0048400708,
-0.0007413992,
0.0313676931,
-0.0036606516,
0.0383062921,
0.010923381,
-0.0075172782,
0.0263081715,
-0.0593315139,
-0.0192652382,
0.0062686885,
0.0926910564,
0.000572731,
0.0266456679,
-0.0313546881,
0.065262951,
0.008809519,
0.0175734349,
-0.0062131472,
0.0124012716,
0.037286181,
-0.0312777497,
0.0143311052,
0.0132352747,
-0.0567161143,
0.0247936025,
-0.0609865002,
0.0565315932,
0.012960746,
-0.0160586778,
0.0389332846,
0.003239675,
0.0041946932,
0.0162151214,
-0.0112882107,
-0.0192361232,
-0.0575663075,
-0.0186684541,
0.0062904484,
0.006342872,
0.0119136777,
0.0453162082,
0.0129100289,
0.0191775952,
0.0022132397,
-0.0519345552,
-0.0128336828,
-0.020444015,
0.0212621782,
0.0385216549,
-0.0279983357,
-0.0234460756,
-0.0324167013,
-0.0647880808,
-0.0105462139,
0.0221959557,
0.0179022327,
0.0340516269,
-0.0208472311,
0.0548738316,
-0.00093075,
0.0229412653,
-0.0187950786,
0.0495738536,
0.0209420547,
-0.0586711802,
0.0202435181,
-5.61571157e-33,
0.0240148772,
-0.0384294316,
-0.0557454191,
-0.030574169,
-0.0103992475,
0.029621277,
-0.0304870475,
-0.0321680568,
-0.0200356413,
0.0245893691,
0.0056166006,
0.0096307844,
-0.0205965713,
0.0463629402,
-0.0590896867,
0.0007675872,
0.0634059981,
-0.0154132554,
-0.0440883972,
0.0254331939,
0.0722476169,
-0.0330643132,
0.0512838624,
-0.0412590615,
0.0404644795,
-0.0289798677,
-0.0710934401,
-0.0343107693,
-0.0132648749,
0.0218516774,
0.032447502,
0.041561719,
0.0145949945,
-0.0183350369,
-0.0076876823,
0.0325757302,
-0.0199934989,
-0.0226121396,
0.0248467531,
0.0215237513,
-0.011645833,
0.0012105004,
0.0516372211,
-0.0294976104,
0.0126187652,
-0.0042226654,
0.0013728776,
-0.0389285125,
-0.006704635,
-0.0304627195,
-0.0247977413,
0.0138558988,
0.0019322614,
0.0106998105,
-0.0122613823,
0.0447956994,
0.0230724458,
-0.0109378714,
-0.0718780383,
0.0157375094,
-0.0200163536,
-0.0026105945,
0.0128977839,
-0.0051626945,
-0.0262370445,
0.0437136292,
-0.0179229621,
0.0482259244,
-0.0460589677,
0.0287230853,
0.0485214107,
-0.0029324379,
0.0684355646,
0.1141513661,
0.0314041562,
-0.0481366105,
-0.0255349744,
0.0511982106,
0.0746546015,
-0.0312272292,
0.0080139302,
0.011026415,
-0.0347224958,
0.0201065447,
-0.0135404328,
-0.0606518947,
-0.0098177521,
-0.0390784293,
-0.0111949854,
0.0193322208,
-0.041361127,
0.0389286242,
0.0039350726,
-0.045637846,
-0.0115998937,
0.0051449351,
-0.0451797508,
-0.0082389964,
-0.0084819347,
0.0255990811,
-0.0061453385,
0.0068939347,
0.0849516317,
-0.0095856749,
-0.0206366964,
-0.0149341207,
0.0812431946,
0.0340532251,
-0.0296435654,
-0.0095521491,
-0.0046125436,
0.0506243221,
0.0069328202,
-0.0077881026,
0.0195436627,
-0.0162510071,
-0.0286741257,
-0.0176171567,
-0.0095546627,
-0.0103675285,
-0.0045998618,
0.0087249577,
-0.0371245854,
0.0500970297,
-0.0440777764,
-0.0244122017,
-0.0340222158,
-0.0386948027,
0.0227747615,
-0.1155560091,
0.0038531118,
-0.023755081,
2.566e-7,
-0.0302783214,
0.0291955229,
0.0130285006,
0.021094026,
0.0385035463,
0.052501779,
0.0324134901,
0.0497046374,
-0.0074653211,
-0.0752528235,
-0.0415127352,
0.0168582816,
0.0298058372,
0.0238051675,
-0.0472616926,
0.0302346572,
-0.0815105438,
0.0333211124,
-0.0427691266,
0.0036105763,
-0.0023122844,
0.0733713508,
0.041879829,
-0.0578275286,
0.053398449,
-0.0035686442,
0.0372929201,
0.0464236438,
-0.0079488894,
-0.0111249434,
0.070859395,
-0.0207784902,
0.022512123,
0.0074674236,
-0.0391451716,
-0.016338544,
0.015444749,
0.0402082205,
0.0272577088,
0.0335889347,
-0.0323323384,
-0.0365167595,
0.0275323093,
-0.0552663431,
0.0853740573,
0.0098768454,
-0.0195261128,
-0.0936520174,
-0.0700661466,
-0.023249032,
0.0095040174,
-0.0478403084,
-0.0122006405,
0.0284422785,
0.0209965687,
0.0140118096,
0.0193460584,
-0.0295286197,
-0.018256586,
-0.0239420142,
-0.0417310782,
0.0146268625,
-0.0369526185,
0.0113207903,
0.0227401052,
-0.0167913791,
0.015681861,
2.152675917e-34,
0.0236953776,
-0.0186499823,
-0.005008047,
-0.0261812732,
-0.0120480862,
0.0310667809,
0.0101938862,
0.0072408952,
0.0040474585,
-0.0373060554,
-0.031905964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11258v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11258v1 | Enhancing Biomedical Knowledge Retrieval-Augmented Generation with Self-Rewarding Tree Search and Proximal Policy Optimization | 2024-06-17T06:48:31 | 2024-06-17T06:48:31 | Minda Hu, Licheng Zong, Hongru Wang, Jingyan Zhou, Jingjing Li, Yichen Gao, Kam-Fai Wong, Yu Li, Irwin King | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown great potential in the biomedical
domain with the advancement of retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). However,
existing retrieval-augmented approaches face challenges in addressing diverse
queries and documents, particularly for medical knowledge queries, resulting in
sub-optimal performance. To address these limitations, we propose a novel
plug-and-play LLM-based retrieval method called Self-Rewarding Tree Search
(SeRTS) based on Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) and a self-rewarding paradigm.
By combining the reasoning capabilities of LLMs with the effectiveness of tree
search, SeRTS boosts the zero-shot performance of retrieving high-quality and
informative results for RAG. We further enhance retrieval performance by
fine-tuning LLMs with Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) objectives using the
trajectories collected by SeRTS as feedback. Controlled experiments using the
BioASQ-QA dataset with GPT-3.5-Turbo and LLama2-7b demonstrate that our method
significantly improves the performance of the BM25 retriever and surpasses the
strong baseline of self-reflection in both efficiency and scalability.
Moreover, SeRTS generates higher-quality feedback for PPO training than
self-reflection. Our proposed method effectively adapts LLMs to document
retrieval tasks, enhancing their ability to retrieve highly relevant documents
for RAG in the context of medical knowledge queries. This work presents a
significant step forward in leveraging LLMs for accurate and comprehensive
biomedical question answering. | [
0.066342786,
0.0327180065,
0.0268392209,
-0.0250394531,
-0.0080021583,
-0.026212953,
-0.0448279716,
0.0500700772,
-0.0214168392,
-0.0004831508,
-0.0390598178,
-0.0357332677,
-0.0479072444,
0.0043512927,
0.0046819942,
-0.0206264462,
0.0481804684,
0.0080198944,
0.0426803268,
-0.0292153563,
-0.0057672863,
-0.0005174242,
-0.0066468786,
0.0319703668,
0.0111140469,
-0.0171352811,
0.002023329,
0.0114616854,
0.0207284,
-0.0758856758,
0.0150982812,
0.0109949261,
0.0298473649,
0.0205956865,
0.0000020753,
-0.0443497822,
-0.0406301022,
0.0299532358,
-0.0231081937,
-0.024971839,
0.0306683015,
0.0154749639,
0.0255979262,
0.0262146611,
-0.0248854551,
0.0239889417,
0.025844574,
0.0285716113,
0.0565666445,
0.0708367229,
0.0262059364,
-0.0255040731,
0.0322831869,
-0.0230545234,
0.079521507,
-0.0546576716,
0.0275875106,
0.008255478,
0.0476891212,
0.0250646137,
0.0181856565,
0.0273525864,
-0.000648961,
-0.0063505541,
0.0291065946,
0.0809504911,
-0.0119890803,
0.0088523068,
0.0075724027,
0.0414566994,
0.0193208959,
-0.0225886237,
0.0261599235,
-0.0036516972,
-0.0325871594,
0.0036758645,
-0.0553895198,
0.0344284251,
-0.0433196239,
0.0098226313,
0.0198104959,
0.0033730036,
0.0654590502,
0.0322703421,
-0.0414707474,
0.0493271351,
0.0231069792,
-0.0556921326,
0.0180548653,
-0.0109415725,
-0.006154757,
0.0076712817,
0.0178931206,
0.0645052716,
-0.0584222414,
0.0164896585,
0.0111637842,
-0.0236229915,
0.0610685833,
-0.0022672783,
0.0350980051,
0.0141718388,
-0.0007173147,
0.0268441662,
-0.0136454673,
0.0102415904,
-0.0536706559,
0.0182888247,
-0.0350641906,
-0.0168263875,
-0.0617048405,
-0.0571658872,
-0.0496356152,
0.0675497055,
-0.0389770158,
-0.0206961818,
-0.0606079064,
0.0048041302,
0.0231907442,
-0.0382957272,
0.0203476548,
0.0574508123,
-0.0730749443,
0.0093307719,
-0.0515129417,
0.0236761123,
-0.0270887353,
-0.0063731,
0.0254767276,
0.0034797906,
-0.0239811223,
0.0181860421,
-0.0078452816,
-0.0171150882,
0.0351821408,
0.0661883578,
-0.0118896421,
-0.0279605724,
-0.0028778447,
-0.0571895801,
-0.0245791543,
-0.0526527315,
0.0309614055,
-0.0551342554,
0.0103254272,
-0.0116796913,
-0.0274681393,
0.0019164167,
0.0362978056,
0.0402617157,
-0.0208756495,
0.0295654051,
-0.017001858,
-0.0013308673,
0.042980656,
0.0082705524,
0.0216243751,
0.0447775088,
0.0180560667,
-0.0010838854,
0.0160997342,
0.0298883934,
0.0042408593,
-0.0192750487,
0.0571400002,
-0.0257458352,
0.0110497959,
0.033543922,
-0.0359682292,
0.1044039205,
0.0082273129,
0.0313438885,
-0.0425080396,
0.0160579979,
-0.0013592786,
0.0541688129,
0.0187072251,
-0.0123713585,
0.0352006443,
-0.0226439554,
-0.0165526774,
-0.0364004709,
-0.0069144648,
0.0391192697,
-0.0223203246,
0.0407758392,
0.0163416155,
0.0057059699,
-0.0220903251,
-0.0228764452,
-0.0110497773,
0.0351543538,
-0.0596186519,
0.0287977122,
0.0456457511,
-0.0029211373,
-0.0433114655,
0.0363224708,
0.0164793693,
-0.0257246923,
0.0009329119,
-0.0795476511,
0.0168117862,
0.0589292906,
0.0717974305,
-0.0415008403,
-0.0126314517,
0.0116413962,
-0.0369337946,
0.0297165252,
-0.0010496067,
-0.0134503562,
-0.002205349,
-0.0473975241,
-0.0220582895,
-0.0009230894,
0.0030139191,
-0.0027081075,
0.0343126208,
0.0252990425,
0.031064067,
-0.0275008846,
0.0017215068,
0.0320940353,
-0.0479764193,
-0.041244287,
0.0274360441,
-0.0330646038,
0.0280078258,
0.0271655004,
-0.0254360456,
0.0613937117,
0.0549541004,
-0.0212010387,
-0.0348614156,
-0.0374011695,
-0.0471065231,
-0.04110571,
0.0259950142,
0.0085219489,
0.011102221,
-0.0197150912,
-0.0251465309,
-0.0580196381,
-0.0431319475,
-0.0582829639,
0.0055749984,
-0.0595281385,
-0.0054843025,
0.0311221462,
-0.0203969069,
-0.0735227466,
0.0491453819,
-0.017039096,
0.015530033,
0.0423903391,
-0.0225342941,
0.0319777094,
-0.0921964198,
-0.001093875,
0.0042879633,
0.0011667192,
0.0123585695,
0.0386105366,
0.021725513,
-0.0453525111,
-0.0269264299,
-0.0854363143,
0.0296095442,
0.0064045605,
0.0099834083,
0.0231044646,
0.0299284328,
-0.0095056035,
-0.0166612659,
-0.0355038829,
-0.0130794365,
0.0437921733,
0.0200163703,
0.0495942421,
0.0367708616,
0.0212501623,
-0.0487334803,
-0.0224345569,
-0.0077672969,
-0.0157317091,
-0.0218153615,
0.0499162078,
-0.0016261628,
-0.0061954348,
-0.0508183613,
0.0020368975,
-0.012199278,
-0.0022224826,
0.0534440763,
-0.0590512753,
0.0100688962,
0.0529385172,
0.0090285968,
0.0040133847,
0.0518192463,
0.0001295346,
-0.0698376149,
0.0450704321,
-0.0582632534,
-0.0282433592,
0.0219553467,
-0.0197964255,
0.0365838073,
0.0543156341,
0.0132375499,
-0.0005548105,
-0.0476237275,
0.0106884297,
0.0135738375,
-0.0359264538,
-0.0634778216,
0.045432955,
-0.0259622745,
0.0147199174,
-0.0122278826,
-0.0455988646,
0.1106262058,
-0.0053335875,
0.0205685813,
-0.0655629337,
0.0130090779,
-0.0317486823,
0.0282477718,
-0.0057001123,
0.0139234019,
-0.0258502737,
-0.0028425776,
-0.010750602,
0.0051936568,
0.0226127859,
-0.0644933134,
0.0081354547,
-0.0121419234,
0.0447933078,
0.0253281966,
-0.061844185,
-0.0245755576,
-0.0313493423,
-0.0058897496,
-0.0026757605,
-0.0125853792,
-0.0068359165,
-0.006738978,
0.0137233892,
0.0480293445,
0.0327195711,
-0.0342159644,
-0.0389079824,
-0.0016298098,
0.0204953812,
0.0773018152,
-0.0137876049,
0.0062570595,
-0.0107347751,
0.023458045,
0.0523675829,
0.0478550121,
-0.0154415006,
0.0193240605,
-0.0094411084,
0.0047806194,
-0.0364518836,
-0.0074813487,
0.027363658,
0.022363374,
-0.0715099052,
-0.0548293255,
0.0819116607,
0.0380849689,
-0.0483277217,
-0.0187831186,
-0.0483610891,
0.0441092588,
0.0064170216,
0.0923685208,
-0.0548689961,
-0.0228651799,
-0.0045912554,
0.0764572918,
-0.0349519812,
-0.0253435299,
0.0277795848,
-0.0935620666,
0.0328111798,
-0.0108292354,
-0.0374344997,
-0.0434856154,
-0.0442992039,
-0.0357168242,
0.0137889432,
-0.0245280378,
0.0543901436,
-0.0200399924,
0.0188587103,
0.0177249387,
0.0217164923,
-0.0487648696,
0.0086923428,
-0.0055671073,
0.0098732403,
0.1123569086,
0.0012818305,
0.0113388253,
-0.0061627585,
-0.0133390985,
-0.0285431948,
0.0153792892,
-0.0224850327,
0.0294428691,
-0.0082780384,
0.0064340201,
-0.0715796575,
0.0316476077,
0.0040227412,
-0.0134844854,
-0.0096071064,
0.0868753642,
-0.052721411,
-0.0140080778,
-0.0764738172,
-0.0017599248,
-0.0043477113,
0.0597932115,
-0.0173360985,
0.0159257837,
-0.049645409,
0.0031453448,
0.0471478812,
-0.0342044272,
-0.015522683,
0.0338947475,
-0.0162725281,
0.0497195125,
-0.0600490198,
-0.0508600473,
0.0020595945,
0.018002864,
-0.0396363251,
0.0447347462,
-0.0404757671,
-0.0072599761,
-0.0458493643,
0.0120072272,
-0.024931632,
-0.0179281346,
-0.0365645327,
-0.0036091595,
0.0800703019,
-0.0179589819,
-0.0182256903,
-0.0152285621,
-0.0144169275,
-0.0322764181,
-0.066353716,
0.0785947293,
0.0144030685,
0.0215760898,
0.0028802913,
-0.0399470478,
0.078541033,
0.0692315102,
-0.046607215,
-0.0060718637,
-0.0143633308,
-0.0208855886,
-0.0337277465,
0.0240654983,
-0.0493836813,
0.009674849,
-0.0413939804,
0.0901332647,
0.0204871073,
-0.0123126144,
0.053309273,
0.0285618845,
0.0355855413,
-0.0299082883,
0.0160617344,
-0.0123744113,
0.0246602148,
-0.0427631065,
0.007115257,
-0.0159483701,
0.0123056052,
0.0338121429,
-0.0538094603,
0.0053009856,
-0.0113299191,
-0.0268208031,
0.0234790593,
-0.0246530268,
-0.0036493458,
0.0040513887,
-0.0112752505,
0.0444546863,
-0.0253548194,
-0.0063845022,
0.0058701653,
0.0185747873,
0.0388668664,
-0.0175494533,
0.0629303902,
0.0340022407,
0.0130384257,
-0.0103548765,
0.0001330758,
-0.098082751,
-0.0421438143,
-0.0295365788,
0.0148224616,
0.0504256897,
0.0395862237,
0.0113223027,
-0.018701179,
-0.0198322367,
-0.0162451416,
-0.0056008878,
-0.0069053588,
0.0096128657,
0.0713959485,
0.03023321,
0.0013448538,
-0.0313379355,
0.095616512,
0.043395035,
0.067116484,
-0.02182642,
-0.0331030488,
-0.0272503179,
-0.0345654078,
-0.0029738133,
0.0211739261,
-0.0363901593,
-0.0105959233,
-0.0391603075,
-0.0303146243,
0.0104463464,
0.037559025,
-0.0391779207,
-0.0371704996,
0.0718629658,
0.056957759,
-0.0128546106,
-0.0663506761,
-0.0336371064,
0.0617764778,
-0.0617973432,
-0.0159896761,
0.001021528,
-6.673750893e-33,
-0.0208215602,
-0.0277522877,
0.0766079128,
-0.0176560786,
-0.0469972976,
-0.0161183439,
-0.0628736764,
-0.0195808411,
0.0102032302,
0.0267789401,
-0.0449231081,
0.0132342055,
-0.0016501016,
0.0416033939,
0.0150326509,
0.0018276498,
0.0359762385,
-0.028677661,
-0.0245746598,
0.0330702849,
0.0100070182,
0.0571238436,
0.0139520504,
-0.0336156785,
-0.0252514221,
0.0081390254,
0.0127280951,
0.0415038839,
-0.0273136236,
0.0672763139,
-0.0188157298,
0.0289333854,
0.0176334064,
-0.0182817187,
0.0104302038,
-0.032325238,
-0.0802510679,
-0.0342530534,
-0.019874936,
-0.0697274432,
-0.0569288656,
-0.0472671613,
0.0495501012,
-0.0164535437,
-0.0048848372,
-0.0037260179,
-0.0095182108,
-0.0081999088,
-0.0537457541,
-0.0544199906,
-0.0271751415,
0.0284118988,
0.0322746187,
0.0125797363,
-0.0139321871,
0.0156799573,
-0.0229325034,
0.0535092205,
0.0189381205,
0.0110548455,
0.019248005,
0.0455751903,
0.0181551818,
0.0335458294,
0.0350957364,
0.018800199,
0.0170135349,
-0.017962873,
-0.021597391,
-0.0169800688,
-0.0179776754,
0.0189218447,
0.0234852824,
0.040818356,
0.0260420777,
0.0209905226,
-0.0897368193,
0.0555398762,
-0.0308686048,
0.066767849,
0.0191969424,
0.0051251305,
-0.0227570664,
-0.0075563472,
-0.0384691283,
0.0120943552,
-0.0155959204,
-0.0447871089,
0.0561602265,
0.0326967426,
0.0047123753,
-0.0018888708,
0.0124985566,
-0.0095910197,
-0.0023548095,
0.0148139047,
0.000443134,
-0.0158763994,
-0.0310578384,
0.013474308,
-0.0818397477,
-0.0084235854,
0.0048206984,
-0.034141209,
-0.0080358759,
0.0307941325,
-0.0405050628,
-0.0084225684,
-0.0407078601,
0.0016700079,
-0.0188318845,
0.0304246806,
-0.0257306416,
0.0000123689,
0.0115903616,
0.0256905556,
0.0181752294,
0.0574512407,
0.0248725265,
0.0276377592,
-0.0369853824,
-0.0471923575,
0.0291275512,
0.0081668431,
-0.0088901799,
0.0595954172,
-0.0387974046,
0.0569282062,
-0.0216083415,
-0.0681672394,
-0.0068720719,
0.0406790227,
2.881e-7,
0.0658487231,
0.0513669699,
0.0226373728,
0.0233313479,
0.0247585066,
0.0152982315,
-0.0017136857,
-0.0118699251,
0.0025199209,
-0.0332174189,
0.0352052338,
0.0060622259,
0.0063862377,
0.011358303,
-0.1039407402,
-0.01042936,
-0.0996843651,
-0.0345225148,
-0.0177891441,
-0.0712139979,
0.0251700841,
0.058635857,
-0.044069916,
-0.0330875255,
0.0330114923,
-0.0249453336,
0.0978871956,
0.0106955105,
-0.0098965652,
0.0289994907,
0.0261608399,
0.0106583294,
0.0179362521,
-0.0098190065,
-0.0085924556,
0.0136567298,
-0.0142855775,
0.0685143024,
-0.0176842511,
-0.0544591583,
0.0364862606,
0.0019062874,
0.0358303487,
-0.0461139679,
0.0573152751,
-0.0478397235,
-0.0028601396,
-0.0065711234,
0.0032552299,
-0.0170777086,
0.0398491845,
-0.0500528514,
-0.0391352512,
0.0392351784,
-0.0131360823,
0.0468798764,
0.0003004125,
-0.0855269954,
-0.0035458766,
0.0075089354,
-0.0449887291,
-0.0217425562,
-0.0452351831,
0.0176556185,
-0.0250271801,
-0.0632954389,
-0.0348858647,
2.674781835e-34,
0.02990162,
-0.028233951,
0.0016081856,
0.0199231673,
0.0220340621,
0.0251788218,
-0.0078999996,
0.0282567404,
0.0180018116,
-0.070587568,
-0.0443263128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11256v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11256v1 | Dynamic Data Mixing Maximizes Instruction Tuning for Mixture-of-Experts | 2024-06-17T06:47:03 | 2024-06-17T06:47:03 | Tong Zhu, Daize Dong, Xiaoye Qu, Jiacheng Ruan, Wenliang Chen, Yu Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) models have shown remarkable capability in
instruction tuning, especially when the number of tasks scales. However,
previous methods simply merge all training tasks (e.g. creative writing,
coding, and mathematics) and apply fixed sampling weights, without considering
the importance of different tasks as the model training state changes. In this
way, the most helpful data cannot be effectively distinguished, leading to
suboptimal model performance. To reduce the potential redundancies of datasets,
we make the first attempt and propose a novel dynamic data mixture for MoE
instruction tuning. Specifically, inspired by MoE's token routing preference,
we build dataset-level representations and then capture the subtle differences
among datasets. Finally, we propose to dynamically adjust the sampling weight
of datasets by their inter-redundancies, thus maximizing global performance
under a limited training budget. The experimental results on two MoE models
demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach on both downstream knowledge \&
reasoning tasks and open-ended queries. Code and models are available at
https://github.com/Spico197/MoE-SFT . | [
0.0319048502,
0.0386955626,
-0.022663679,
0.0002297293,
-0.0076740254,
0.0373847187,
0.010079626,
-0.0320450626,
-0.0238716267,
-0.0307700112,
-0.0389523841,
-0.0080080666,
-0.0182795562,
0.0049790237,
0.0256644804,
-0.0731077418,
0.0351861119,
-0.0299977474,
-0.0259981751,
-0.0023623372,
-0.0211384147,
0.016112024,
-0.0317277499,
0.029779736,
0.0144972727,
-0.0252542645,
-0.005877445,
0.0130805261,
0.0077298894,
0.0279431436,
0.0155130941,
0.0672639981,
0.0578654483,
0.0116795134,
0.0000021393,
-0.0076057287,
-0.015083042,
0.0066731577,
-0.023526106,
-0.0514302067,
-0.0033961809,
0.0229297262,
0.0130808884,
0.0325131677,
-0.0144636463,
0.0009736991,
0.0408859141,
0.0256261751,
0.0503261127,
0.1028184891,
0.0173372701,
0.0021385544,
0.041103255,
-0.0182061009,
0.061782036,
0.0108719878,
0.0072887293,
0.0214864872,
-0.0172357131,
0.0149789378,
-0.0351678282,
0.0116221299,
0.0307896826,
0.0441911854,
0.0545663312,
0.0140553471,
-0.0267207716,
0.0445930623,
-0.022010291,
0.0540477075,
-0.0547127575,
0.0110848276,
-0.0054190811,
0.0119348438,
0.0159086045,
0.0015371036,
-0.0415126421,
-0.0064310776,
-0.0306341611,
-0.010105608,
-0.0024787406,
-0.0107620209,
0.0122053474,
0.003182373,
-0.0523121096,
0.0321661606,
-0.0015643581,
-0.0180266555,
-0.0339383893,
-0.0133516667,
-0.0204750784,
-0.0346881747,
0.0007173051,
0.0342895314,
-0.023087604,
0.0059019849,
-0.0474789813,
-0.0368780904,
-0.0359368101,
0.0045625097,
0.0495659113,
0.0610194802,
-0.0139256008,
0.0350084379,
-0.0029819759,
0.0229672771,
0.0027168326,
0.05906526,
-0.0395833813,
0.0143230166,
-0.1187797785,
-0.0115933213,
-0.0323710032,
0.0594360344,
-0.0396221355,
0.0275005326,
-0.0479215197,
0.0602106377,
-0.0364017822,
0.004531878,
0.0241471082,
0.0003906824,
-0.0481995605,
0.0187230259,
-0.033892028,
0.0271799285,
-0.0384741575,
0.0274461005,
0.0207143947,
-0.0128676351,
-0.0064613451,
0.0089172293,
-0.0325672366,
-0.0340914279,
0.0325612724,
0.080864653,
-0.0409681275,
-0.004186118,
-0.0423961617,
-0.0324398242,
0.0311245527,
-0.0609329268,
0.0273656473,
-0.0612229779,
0.079154633,
0.0066956747,
0.0006187185,
-0.0096084019,
-0.0343835689,
0.0103255734,
-0.0192101635,
0.0460550785,
0.0200929064,
-0.0029803948,
0.0159116704,
0.0189964063,
-0.0805130079,
0.0883341506,
0.0291077737,
0.004528272,
0.0125396401,
0.0194419641,
-0.0065853801,
-0.0206796918,
-0.0047450066,
0.0199501067,
-0.0013459935,
0.0309887417,
0.0045518535,
0.0046035484,
0.0406129397,
0.0158746988,
-0.0607563369,
0.0020028125,
0.0253365003,
0.0037334529,
0.0530329607,
0.018685719,
0.0671269372,
0.0314826518,
0.0221505836,
0.0661273077,
-0.0528954268,
0.0500072315,
-0.0216879733,
0.0007245289,
0.0195851717,
0.0545513816,
-0.0501748025,
-0.0435374454,
0.0332269333,
0.0047261752,
-0.0496684834,
0.0435271785,
0.0320884511,
-0.019972505,
-0.0226111859,
0.0175546557,
0.0100606391,
-0.0157429092,
0.0065891938,
-0.0528878905,
-0.0221758056,
0.0757785738,
0.0365500413,
-0.0684744492,
-0.0528256521,
-0.0251902919,
0.0346450396,
-0.0364087559,
0.0104129622,
-0.0242196899,
0.0220675487,
-0.0474926867,
-0.065698944,
-0.0514036939,
0.0152659779,
0.0260431506,
0.0242614653,
-0.0027105934,
0.0110201063,
-0.025824517,
-0.026007697,
0.0242757555,
-0.044486396,
-0.0249298308,
0.0032798431,
0.0262047704,
0.013790003,
-0.0034270696,
-0.0275550243,
0.0150908204,
0.0036211063,
0.0037676347,
-0.02313211,
-0.0098879552,
-0.0599088632,
-0.0381613225,
0.0200548451,
-0.047106199,
-0.0191114414,
-0.0456482209,
-0.0757960156,
-0.0510034785,
0.0161720663,
-0.0142531442,
0.0065764701,
-0.0171128865,
0.0124746216,
0.0048308964,
-0.0506100617,
-0.0153669324,
0.0720965341,
-0.0209198967,
0.0135847861,
0.0174645539,
0.0151532916,
0.0091027115,
-0.0370981544,
0.0208489597,
-0.0396104828,
0.0072452836,
0.0569113269,
-0.0132799381,
-0.0047725816,
-0.0381695963,
-0.0868941098,
-0.0552118346,
0.0136302318,
-0.0316288359,
0.0228028595,
0.0345225744,
-0.0129337115,
-0.0031131841,
0.012733575,
-0.0437405817,
-0.0332918279,
-0.0482963324,
0.0278455783,
-0.0064590033,
0.0139907729,
-0.0020062467,
0.0113213649,
-0.0411001965,
-0.0549215339,
0.0102642793,
-0.02923318,
0.026177749,
-0.030456204,
-0.0213514734,
-0.0473884232,
0.0175158978,
-0.0267255455,
0.0088360636,
0.0099099018,
-0.02994949,
0.0719901919,
0.0848642588,
-0.0168481786,
-0.001908759,
0.0453704558,
-0.0214932766,
-0.0112368567,
0.0417205989,
0.0068745478,
0.0475840941,
-0.0163891092,
-0.0108922143,
-0.0206129029,
0.0361120664,
-0.0173071679,
-0.0274291355,
-0.0674622059,
-0.0017833782,
0.0168747343,
-0.0269157551,
-0.0245507248,
0.0148653165,
0.0317740589,
-0.0043030363,
-0.0542655028,
-0.028366277,
0.0873714387,
0.0400202945,
0.0165671576,
-0.0696023628,
-0.0073683881,
-0.0633830428,
-0.0016772053,
-0.0109567549,
0.014561167,
-0.0445063785,
-0.0156360772,
-0.120283626,
0.0146916229,
0.0315230899,
-0.0254143104,
0.0419461653,
-0.0304783229,
-0.0331774317,
-0.0005878768,
-0.0451848246,
-0.0219133515,
0.0111863613,
0.0329290815,
0.0423802882,
0.03959883,
-0.0548131391,
-0.0618896075,
-0.0194680374,
0.0332831442,
0.0569993705,
-0.0329073034,
-0.0164825395,
-0.0399545617,
0.0000933289,
0.0195884127,
-0.002987829,
-0.0516462177,
-0.0683932081,
0.0056703328,
0.0168608353,
0.0940085202,
-0.0835143924,
0.0011620466,
0.0604866073,
0.0124788256,
-0.0389951617,
-0.0202961992,
0.0487136692,
0.0529569685,
-0.0544647202,
-0.0062059918,
0.0877806917,
0.0231379494,
-0.0390804522,
-0.0164462123,
0.0118153207,
0.0152645595,
0.0440752394,
0.05877221,
-0.0753682852,
-0.0240698103,
-0.0115044946,
0.0329305716,
0.0064969729,
-0.0217066482,
-0.0121083222,
-0.0715716407,
0.0039273128,
0.0249993131,
-0.0712929368,
-0.0248875301,
-0.0275316555,
-0.0392719656,
-0.0168833416,
-0.006652961,
-0.0164034311,
-0.0399179496,
0.0039861416,
0.0450826026,
0.0472703576,
-0.0595027208,
0.0127936685,
-0.032024689,
0.0412255637,
0.0323607177,
-0.0062601911,
0.0219300501,
-0.0235227775,
-0.0103037842,
0.0258816797,
0.0183262229,
0.0031840729,
0.0783868134,
-0.0606185943,
0.0128910989,
0.007044943,
0.0142054241,
-0.0086388858,
0.0200290252,
0.0337064713,
0.0941931382,
-0.0202486087,
0.0230397098,
-0.0519039407,
-0.0437969454,
0.00890233,
0.0568296425,
0.0175743587,
-0.0246639661,
-0.0100002345,
-0.0244511105,
-0.0349385776,
-0.0418633334,
0.056653589,
0.0398958735,
-0.0180335045,
-0.0489840917,
-0.0269346014,
-0.0091742473,
0.061066445,
0.066134952,
0.0138954753,
0.0112793408,
-0.0059084678,
0.0051327879,
-0.083085984,
0.030579336,
-0.0368501954,
0.012525579,
-0.0950115174,
-0.0462999679,
0.0053124214,
-0.0191132873,
-0.0147609226,
-0.0317798816,
-0.1059731692,
-0.0601671971,
-0.0159683861,
0.0733568817,
0.0161906667,
0.0546846427,
0.0014631139,
-0.0645671859,
0.0544220507,
0.0476763621,
-0.0517725721,
-0.0069556893,
0.0491119251,
-0.0426683165,
0.0063941502,
0.0052185976,
-0.05188765,
0.0130240386,
0.0503517613,
-0.0017357402,
-0.0148347439,
0.0646591708,
0.0062628379,
-0.0137698129,
-0.0102924015,
0.034921892,
0.0186961647,
-0.0593324788,
0.0430541113,
0.0067901108,
-0.0080065634,
-0.0284984987,
-0.006156961,
0.0193616711,
-0.0027067617,
0.0051243757,
0.021614641,
0.0359978266,
0.0147810178,
-0.0407272279,
0.0045382907,
-0.004377638,
0.0426968746,
0.0209150221,
-0.0031617344,
-0.0156652331,
0.0025397604,
0.0114008235,
0.0175442025,
0.0002831242,
0.0333256088,
0.0310828146,
0.0353143737,
-0.0185725857,
0.0277600493,
-0.1093206704,
-0.0563105717,
-0.0269854385,
0.0038375894,
0.0454501621,
-0.0200871229,
-0.0150964623,
-0.0038977719,
0.0066728285,
-0.0224141181,
0.0049138917,
-0.0011664389,
-0.0008177701,
-0.0208916944,
0.0610007495,
0.0192503352,
-0.0176943,
0.0881322473,
-0.0299722571,
0.0429829434,
-0.0205524825,
-0.0151737109,
-0.0269902498,
0.0168233402,
0.0410258248,
0.0597170517,
0.0079072071,
0.0238838829,
-0.0397873446,
-0.0510193333,
-0.0016805429,
-0.0172867011,
0.020895591,
0.0140141165,
0.0609634593,
0.0393767916,
-0.0352943912,
-0.0350657217,
-0.0129528176,
-0.0066358494,
0.0421737023,
-0.0181131847,
0.0090959147,
-6.289621379e-33,
0.0006433647,
0.0010156248,
0.0364109986,
-0.0360680819,
0.0183889102,
0.012299573,
-0.010669075,
-0.0134573402,
-0.0278053526,
-0.0116868233,
-0.0344875231,
0.0522138514,
-0.0000104392,
0.0146939242,
0.0425873958,
0.0189313516,
0.0619731881,
-0.0122284489,
-0.0245801471,
0.046674557,
0.0526825972,
0.0042162733,
0.0688606873,
-0.0382328853,
-0.0409249738,
0.0212957505,
0.0239891633,
0.0266796928,
-0.0318632089,
0.06078621,
0.0294070821,
0.0456099734,
0.0202847905,
-0.0225282516,
-0.040801011,
-0.0575622693,
-0.0691996589,
-0.0873953775,
-0.0171383917,
-0.0124081373,
-0.0094558597,
-0.0562539622,
0.0508714803,
0.0008092166,
-0.0052967458,
-0.0681539103,
0.0509755872,
-0.004745204,
-0.01165759,
-0.0264413599,
-0.0292217731,
0.0165381581,
-0.0113368351,
-0.0026989982,
0.0000217986,
0.0260338243,
0.0342052355,
-0.0289645493,
-0.0427581072,
0.0481387712,
0.0261475258,
0.0746726021,
0.0354441851,
0.0439449996,
0.0122481426,
0.0126320738,
0.0387467034,
0.0577672236,
0.0166497026,
0.0200489536,
0.0325094536,
0.0765150264,
0.0133351851,
-0.0354345776,
0.0557883531,
0.0182078015,
-0.0442009047,
0.0245379005,
0.0229008812,
0.0218959749,
0.0193643458,
0.0020359817,
-0.0601508021,
-0.0144483289,
-0.0320029333,
0.0005012468,
-0.026257474,
-0.0192762036,
0.0351028927,
0.0300792679,
-0.0167565029,
-0.0022325867,
0.0235532653,
-0.0414914265,
-0.0093847681,
-0.0043705702,
-0.0236539934,
0.0164786763,
0.0273955427,
0.0263629127,
-0.076377444,
-0.0820450857,
0.0690918192,
-0.0087973895,
0.0129426997,
0.0300278887,
0.0559818111,
0.037521217,
-0.0554298796,
-0.0175639931,
-0.0365470275,
0.002002832,
0.0374098085,
0.038143266,
0.0204903949,
0.0420986526,
-0.0040006805,
0.0064615021,
-0.0084425006,
-0.0354151428,
-0.0324618593,
-0.0169116128,
-0.0139456969,
0.0303008296,
0.0225461088,
0.0174987819,
-0.0545187183,
-0.0561513416,
-0.0070550572,
-0.048655238,
-0.0442709848,
0.017926164,
2.811e-7,
-0.0091815135,
0.0220671128,
0.0164314937,
0.030170951,
-0.0118791098,
-0.0103899417,
-0.0339828245,
0.023525238,
0.0041456814,
-0.0157740787,
0.0404406488,
0.0562762097,
0.0128885778,
0.0143009983,
-0.0845757723,
-0.0015656042,
-0.0036635613,
0.0374979079,
-0.0570294037,
0.0036646463,
0.0209567491,
0.0794904232,
0.0401334129,
-0.0017691066,
0.0235223994,
-0.0163172148,
0.035251271,
0.0365112834,
0.0496694781,
0.0439902805,
0.0341547765,
0.0448503271,
0.0128225228,
0.0451580547,
-0.029835863,
0.0183872543,
-0.0114898086,
0.0426423587,
-0.0503638685,
-0.0164214186,
0.0363253839,
-0.0102378773,
-0.0241662674,
-0.0129547352,
0.0667950064,
-0.0360999517,
-0.0226506367,
0.0261639599,
-0.0054723723,
-0.010919176,
0.0404991396,
0.0118525568,
-0.0149041517,
0.0193976928,
0.0179567188,
0.0005800374,
0.0142449616,
-0.0616541468,
0.0123435007,
0.0320027694,
-0.0348011628,
-0.0661895648,
-0.0361561477,
0.008544907,
0.0451551415,
-0.0481350161,
-0.0307148322,
3.178152393e-34,
0.0446646288,
0.0068992856,
0.0401488319,
0.0237719677,
0.0220816135,
-0.0280612707,
-0.072089985,
-0.000739886,
0.0263866913,
-0.0496926047,
-0.0580861494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15483v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15483v1 | Duplicate Detection with GenAI | 2024-06-17T06:42:13 | 2024-06-17T06:42:13 | Ian Ormesher | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.LG | Customer data is often stored as records in Customer Relations Management
systems (CRMs). Data which is manually entered into such systems by one of more
users over time leads to data replication, partial duplication or fuzzy
duplication. This in turn means that there no longer a single source of truth
for customers, contacts, accounts, etc. Downstream business processes become
increasing complex and contrived without a unique mapping between a record in a
CRM and the target customer. Current methods to detect and de-duplicate records
use traditional Natural Language Processing techniques known as Entity
Matching. In this paper we show how using the latest advancements in Large
Language Models and Generative AI can vastly improve the identification and
repair of duplicated records. On common benchmark datasets we find an
improvement in the accuracy of data de-duplication rates from 30 percent using
NLP techniques to almost 60 percent using our proposed method. | [
0.0519305319,
0.0551424399,
-0.0444577597,
0.0302073881,
-0.029166488,
0.0104937078,
-0.0299320947,
0.0146428114,
0.0273192916,
-0.0321739428,
0.0330294818,
-0.0256544463,
0.0076051308,
0.0271036755,
-0.0054663476,
-0.018738959,
0.0377357304,
0.0480728783,
0.0012667171,
0.0384773165,
0.0026371675,
0.0319907516,
0.0156983379,
0.0286936481,
-0.0343744531,
-0.0268691555,
-0.0000258152,
0.0015239253,
0.0514527187,
-0.0383143164,
-0.0202332921,
0.0250412561,
-0.009802429,
0.0133691262,
0.0000019734,
-0.0676915348,
-0.0562345311,
0.0172441248,
-0.0728555396,
0.0354144648,
-0.0052173096,
-0.0071333121,
-0.0145518435,
0.0437793508,
-0.0405109935,
-0.0041561783,
0.0234952234,
0.071085088,
0.0863975659,
0.0571638979,
-0.051525142,
-0.0616264418,
0.0230965223,
0.0102332123,
-0.0004797473,
-0.0386489592,
0.0488306098,
0.0286764335,
0.0250487328,
-0.0222370476,
0.029203115,
0.0317950845,
-0.0308443233,
-0.0090169497,
-0.035745766,
0.0159262102,
-0.0040268456,
0.0544515587,
-0.0214936063,
0.0405262671,
-0.0330285728,
-0.0192319788,
0.0235064495,
-0.0138440607,
-0.0222089179,
-0.0412901416,
-0.0015578368,
0.0133620771,
-0.0163114499,
0.0297817718,
-0.0408316925,
-0.0366208367,
0.0117409481,
-0.0358023793,
-0.0380879007,
-0.0089812968,
0.0425780714,
-0.0373062938,
-0.0034032976,
-0.0003263324,
0.0020338478,
-0.0550384782,
0.0166419689,
0.0537695847,
-0.0277327392,
-0.0093040681,
-0.0502269417,
-0.0320366658,
0.0270096511,
-0.0437803976,
0.0208205618,
0.0194916259,
0.0369629674,
0.02961329,
-0.0016543713,
0.0456046425,
0.0120175835,
-0.0322269052,
-0.012319372,
-0.0438810512,
-0.0610903203,
-0.0206268486,
-0.0392596237,
0.0357914194,
0.024647411,
-0.0304548051,
-0.0299642514,
0.0020181939,
-0.0108611155,
0.0613151155,
0.0034133901,
-0.0275485497,
0.0103286589,
-0.0075751594,
-0.0524721444,
-0.033118207,
-0.056037154,
0.0122145126,
-0.0488009527,
-0.0531591885,
0.0397775508,
0.0105075585,
0.0215470809,
0.0263338387,
-0.0151457638,
0.0127930781,
0.0505632572,
-0.0092688808,
-0.1346963793,
-0.01935325,
0.0024605237,
-0.0098994905,
-0.064146474,
-0.0218476187,
0.039511282,
-0.0143816471,
-0.0224057827,
-0.0312017314,
0.0050628744,
0.0328012183,
-0.0194390267,
0.0759992674,
-0.0526012219,
0.0647545084,
0.0434729196,
-0.0412803851,
0.0728043541,
-0.0170618165,
0.0222896673,
-0.0481949486,
0.0581902787,
0.0154320803,
0.0678152889,
0.0496388488,
-0.0289306268,
-0.0574329458,
0.0352413952,
0.0147191193,
-0.0337270759,
0.0211523287,
0.0236266665,
0.0710333884,
0.0009451394,
0.0012333692,
0.0482815392,
0.0102175679,
-0.0075084153,
0.0542264469,
0.0197473709,
0.0508218817,
-0.0258874595,
-0.0027743978,
0.0220236201,
0.0001261579,
0.0119533008,
0.0087962979,
-0.010492757,
0.0331167616,
-0.0517631881,
0.0028984575,
-0.0075580636,
-0.0149053354,
-0.0271077938,
-0.0281325225,
-0.0035557889,
0.0467164405,
-0.0100978678,
0.0227339882,
-0.0015204917,
-0.0285504404,
-0.0587592684,
-0.0403275304,
0.002302194,
0.089489691,
0.0529841036,
0.0250292663,
-0.0328489654,
0.0177232902,
-0.0885245427,
0.0531176925,
0.0461877249,
-0.0264975429,
-0.0206518006,
-0.0574635975,
-0.0113020791,
0.0654614195,
-0.0220091995,
0.0062115625,
0.0257740542,
0.0221100431,
0.0486476868,
-0.0108222943,
-0.0041563706,
0.0401175097,
0.0052022906,
-0.0301968288,
-0.0003206316,
0.0434300527,
0.0156311169,
0.0142678581,
-0.0099412035,
0.0088557974,
0.0235745311,
-0.011606304,
-0.0323692001,
0.0088552535,
0.0494930595,
0.0042522964,
0.0271594562,
-0.0254572611,
-0.0428065248,
0.0071539041,
-0.0315094702,
-0.0155065367,
-0.049756974,
-0.018750865,
0.0260067936,
-0.0663553029,
0.0600011162,
0.0145618469,
0.0041374923,
-0.028633615,
0.0814412087,
0.0231665839,
-0.0330185331,
0.0043179509,
-0.0529587902,
0.0546039194,
-0.0700781569,
-0.0172967575,
-0.006912116,
-0.0188597124,
0.0508546233,
0.0078024738,
-0.0316239186,
-0.0142053887,
0.0077431649,
-0.0550064445,
0.0176809635,
0.0376240872,
0.0301767569,
0.0126648322,
0.0540939793,
-0.030142149,
-0.0013306175,
-0.0272784121,
0.0029122182,
0.0503900982,
-0.0288085137,
0.051998876,
0.0039877864,
-0.0615584739,
-0.0404751562,
0.0372605808,
-0.0363817587,
0.010094922,
0.0208707433,
-0.070979923,
-0.09274593,
0.0378061943,
-0.0430565029,
0.0204777811,
0.0069263168,
0.0175302774,
-0.0068986798,
0.0355717801,
0.0757605582,
-0.0106087504,
-0.0175429322,
-0.0420015603,
-0.0035397264,
-0.0001691554,
-0.0309125911,
0.0118688671,
-0.0211887211,
-0.0359388627,
0.0314207226,
-0.0148226423,
0.0658731908,
-0.0383067355,
0.0092560994,
-0.0282372888,
0.0068488149,
-0.0026468523,
0.0070695858,
0.0463744178,
-0.0163769051,
-0.023777524,
-0.0104954587,
0.0304184631,
0.0135811334,
0.023973126,
0.0158676319,
-0.0089843515,
0.0486732461,
-0.047153268,
0.0002734373,
-0.0202874914,
0.0501380786,
-0.0126794623,
0.0293876342,
-0.0018713614,
-0.0396471731,
0.0023717994,
0.0205782503,
0.0378987156,
0.0194997955,
0.0265560746,
-0.0330550745,
0.0516216941,
0.017360026,
-0.025350444,
-0.0793152377,
0.0096128937,
0.0100263245,
0.0002351453,
0.0450369082,
0.0234368779,
-0.061218258,
0.0306688435,
-0.0256346297,
0.0369033739,
0.0062490362,
-0.025375044,
-0.0069124391,
0.0258455575,
0.0163205247,
0.0105464375,
0.0288030375,
0.0215666872,
-0.0092674298,
0.0088436641,
0.0058148974,
0.0280704536,
-0.0414312333,
-0.0172587484,
-0.0286925826,
-0.1006078497,
0.0348530263,
0.0278024357,
-0.0519642122,
-0.0047466611,
0.009726081,
0.084021844,
0.0339948311,
-0.0179292914,
0.003146423,
-0.0080191409,
-0.0502705835,
0.0018896573,
0.0390484147,
-0.0654010624,
0.0078367759,
0.0096344585,
-0.0224599633,
0.0375634953,
-0.0247434285,
-0.0074436227,
-0.1471039206,
0.0231740344,
-0.0109359203,
0.004355615,
-0.086908631,
-0.0245124437,
0.0104140444,
0.0184412897,
0.0130912839,
0.001387164,
-0.0209730361,
-0.0290420167,
-0.0215415936,
-0.0152514456,
-0.0823524296,
-0.027354151,
-0.1000480056,
0.0243160017,
0.0861898437,
0.0799766257,
0.0399482809,
-0.0119281271,
-0.0005478355,
0.0120214317,
0.0138670821,
0.0164788626,
0.0728305951,
-0.0040884218,
-0.0043870015,
-0.0386246517,
-0.0057598702,
-0.0262689441,
-0.0041226433,
0.0393361114,
0.0199916475,
-0.0160078257,
-0.0167672001,
-0.0172676854,
-0.0170421973,
0.0288511384,
0.0799062252,
0.0191562939,
-0.0023702811,
-0.0199250039,
-0.0020103841,
0.0450147055,
0.0276033413,
-0.0262776203,
0.072101824,
-0.0402179845,
-0.0349107012,
-0.0907601938,
-0.0208935719,
0.0331605673,
-0.0073995651,
0.0752908662,
-0.0031874143,
0.0541583337,
-0.0213165767,
-0.0088237058,
-0.0803405344,
-0.0804341957,
0.0367712453,
-0.0711548254,
0.0421450436,
-0.0215381905,
0.0466340072,
-0.0488754325,
-0.0012060418,
-0.0701344386,
-0.0327187926,
-0.033681646,
-0.0143131064,
0.0210071374,
-0.0075696339,
0.0066650226,
-0.0153345671,
-0.0633979887,
0.0471302383,
-0.028764924,
-0.0241186488,
-0.0573857054,
0.0112164533,
0.0003459555,
0.0300090965,
-0.0249611903,
0.024420945,
-0.0228999984,
0.0434366614,
-0.0179929342,
-0.0210798159,
0.0394510366,
0.0647508278,
-0.004454392,
0.0216024928,
0.0418134965,
-0.0546044223,
0.0213227756,
-0.0321723707,
-0.0007810137,
0.0054121092,
-0.0081255166,
0.0193579439,
0.0520347208,
0.0082589416,
-0.0052311872,
-0.0306412969,
0.0047957189,
-0.0293644201,
-0.0377363861,
0.0063271206,
0.0559110418,
-0.0132205784,
-0.0406843163,
0.0027804954,
0.0171949472,
0.0549209528,
0.0490687229,
-0.0282139033,
0.0062599997,
0.0128873345,
0.0254627187,
-0.0528132729,
-0.0060196854,
0.0439006351,
-0.0850089788,
-0.0071532237,
0.0072967662,
0.0553204976,
0.0011173399,
0.0054614595,
-0.0678174272,
-0.0165511798,
-0.0182274301,
0.000075138,
0.0264203083,
-0.0208212901,
-0.0346208885,
-0.0045826347,
-0.0479928702,
-0.0157046132,
0.0811907277,
-0.037286751,
0.0421451516,
-0.06265641,
-0.0389978625,
-0.0621766746,
-0.0039353729,
0.0198752154,
-0.0348727331,
-0.0030435431,
-0.0199548118,
-0.0406589285,
-0.0202338044,
-0.006961335,
0.0325290971,
-0.0015055066,
0.0216717478,
0.0323822871,
0.0155081907,
0.0264411122,
-0.009757393,
-0.0133896768,
0.0014167011,
-0.0207740311,
-0.0252481233,
-0.0390418954,
-5.479416306e-33,
-0.032605391,
-0.0154639259,
0.0146906674,
0.0024942409,
0.017449256,
0.0118811252,
-0.0067368252,
-0.0370977595,
0.0014202822,
-0.0017905111,
-0.0315509737,
0.0219275337,
0.0435131043,
-0.0210437253,
0.0005973779,
0.0226806644,
0.0644163266,
0.0208853837,
-0.0021024554,
-0.0078333979,
0.0034241914,
0.0198780727,
0.0165841449,
-0.076915808,
0.0012155565,
-0.0538216978,
-0.0145381568,
0.032709375,
0.0142120132,
0.060745243,
-0.0444365628,
0.0138830543,
0.0173819158,
-0.0415711626,
0.0225338172,
0.0105151506,
-0.0969008207,
-0.0379195437,
-0.0140796471,
0.0033539711,
0.0487941243,
-0.0030912014,
0.0151440278,
-0.0339721777,
-0.0429235287,
0.0715048686,
0.0622176751,
-0.0216279067,
-0.0065076607,
-0.0451741852,
-0.0876006186,
0.0144213652,
0.0052699917,
0.0331070609,
0.0170156099,
-0.0399952382,
-0.0172347855,
0.0114848539,
-0.1053884327,
0.0375816301,
0.023682138,
-0.0018601021,
0.006174922,
-0.0445392281,
0.010366139,
0.031874381,
-0.0002525103,
-0.0423816405,
0.0090049403,
-0.0089595607,
-0.0321414396,
0.01924452,
-0.0284954384,
0.0347554609,
0.0014817219,
-0.051992029,
-0.04611554,
0.1256932914,
0.0047601904,
0.0154294055,
0.0053625377,
0.007258168,
-0.0617878549,
-0.0188337117,
0.0061326651,
0.0043341499,
-0.038722802,
0.0017376,
0.0622389168,
0.0112497862,
-0.0093855411,
0.01339697,
-0.0109709082,
-0.0421224497,
-0.0905350149,
-0.0113722114,
0.0097384742,
-0.0299695227,
-0.011343522,
0.0071261055,
-0.0121322274,
-0.0445895344,
0.0098729609,
0.0002720859,
0.026665803,
0.0066388072,
0.0259904265,
-0.0060749045,
-0.078411147,
0.0491209589,
0.0348823518,
-0.0355970562,
-0.0189278349,
0.0045741838,
0.0129141342,
0.0152785098,
0.0314860828,
0.011147785,
0.0479093976,
0.0014709311,
-0.0018699388,
0.0259438083,
0.0112049216,
-0.0110254027,
-0.0224645697,
0.0400561951,
-0.0492479876,
-0.0186615922,
0.0506615862,
-0.0308083631,
-0.0180934202,
0.0035483257,
2.662e-7,
0.0294580851,
0.027214678,
0.0264735501,
0.0445798635,
0.018381577,
0.0293841418,
0.0152245583,
-0.0006716357,
-0.0097512174,
0.051064413,
0.0577547997,
-0.0343485251,
0.0218806081,
0.0129999025,
-0.0624707304,
0.0388345756,
-0.0198555402,
-0.041573219,
-0.1145999581,
-0.0006709991,
0.0253509469,
0.0779371709,
0.0143206781,
-0.0007676792,
0.0022787962,
-0.042846702,
0.0038461965,
-0.0306478087,
0.0164472051,
0.0709251016,
0.0641542971,
0.0166768357,
-0.0041997624,
0.0178124309,
-0.0131370304,
0.037601728,
0.0343311392,
0.0286370516,
-0.0102802198,
0.028624557,
0.0169555228,
-0.0476217791,
-0.0074730953,
-0.0411045551,
0.0406891257,
-0.0355170257,
-0.0024094367,
0.0001464427,
-0.0054989778,
0.0041881138,
0.0014333242,
0.0412551202,
-0.0344850607,
0.0187397432,
0.0233238507,
0.0063381242,
-0.0378616229,
-0.0595783629,
0.0444576032,
0.018522637,
-0.0222777333,
0.031922251,
0.0020065669,
-0.0295800697,
0.0461510345,
-0.0100382632,
0.0463198312,
2.192270102e-34,
-0.0175888035,
0.0095126675,
0.0139257368,
0.0198795814,
0.0541380495,
0.0099187372,
-0.0234169923,
0.0527402759,
-0.040037781,
-0.0399317443,
-0.006325217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11250v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11250v1 | Can Machines Resonate with Humans? Evaluating the Emotional and Empathic Comprehension of LMs | 2024-06-17T06:22:20 | 2024-06-17T06:22:20 | Muhammad Arslan Manzoor, Yuxia Wang, Minghan Wang, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Empathy plays a pivotal role in fostering prosocial behavior, often triggered
by the sharing of personal experiences through narratives. However, modeling
empathy using NLP approaches remains challenging due to its deep
interconnection with human interaction dynamics. Previous approaches, which
involve fine-tuning language models (LMs) on human-annotated empathic datasets,
have had limited success. In our pursuit of improving empathy understanding in
LMs, we propose several strategies, including contrastive learning with masked
LMs and supervised fine-tuning with Large Language Models (LLMs). While these
methods show improvements over previous methods, the overall results remain
unsatisfactory. To better understand this trend, we performed an analysis which
reveals a low agreement among annotators. This lack of consensus hinders
training and highlights the subjective nature of the task. We also explore the
cultural impact on annotations. To study this, we meticulously collected story
pairs in Urdu language and find that subjectivity in interpreting empathy among
annotators appears to be independent of cultural background. The insights from
our systematic exploration of LMs' understanding of empathy suggest that there
is considerable room for exploration in both task formulation and modeling. | [
0.0210982114,
0.0426529013,
-0.0368564539,
0.0451106541,
-0.0219567735,
0.060158506,
-0.0219967607,
-0.0471043624,
0.0094139846,
-0.0134097459,
-0.0306437612,
-0.0063063884,
-0.0053832857,
-0.008389499,
0.0104230791,
-0.0689074174,
0.0261301193,
0.0568690598,
0.0397676416,
-0.0086105159,
0.0057998849,
0.0677135438,
-0.0032351702,
0.0549242906,
-0.006895931,
0.0048507578,
0.0047303885,
-0.0046399459,
0.0544701852,
0.00073218,
0.0125002069,
0.0325416625,
0.0315411873,
-0.0005709619,
0.0000020222,
-0.0343375318,
0.0089386217,
-0.0261132382,
0.0264860503,
-0.034774743,
0.0815687627,
-0.0535714142,
0.021044299,
-0.0007825058,
-0.0527911074,
-0.015319977,
0.0150616467,
0.0535897724,
0.0394583307,
0.0721560717,
-0.0310334247,
-0.0195076577,
-0.0194840971,
-0.0060779974,
-0.0192129984,
0.0217073988,
0.0120716924,
-0.009928925,
-0.005719787,
-0.0634519085,
-0.0458844863,
0.0184273161,
0.0111449277,
0.0051597632,
0.0229370072,
0.0253506303,
0.0146855284,
-0.0426341146,
0.0054829316,
0.0871801302,
0.0110319955,
0.0211500302,
0.008649487,
-0.0166537352,
-0.0124569563,
-0.0193395913,
-0.0032683623,
0.0011610199,
0.0044804658,
0.0501900688,
0.0413006507,
0.0215304997,
0.0097761787,
0.0430327021,
0.0376006365,
-0.015049614,
-0.0365132242,
0.0103943953,
-0.0021043564,
0.0070975358,
-0.0309298169,
-0.0222135913,
0.0402608179,
0.0212691631,
-0.0073363115,
-0.0026455366,
-0.0303680152,
0.026881136,
0.0153513979,
-0.0499454364,
0.0341275372,
0.0689068362,
-0.0160973668,
0.0019356329,
0.0046365703,
-0.010379469,
0.0260469243,
0.0172627326,
-0.0415897258,
-0.0068595954,
-0.0380838625,
0.0171296634,
0.0265111476,
0.0140949702,
-0.034036763,
0.0072745392,
-0.0487968512,
0.0141257998,
-0.0097890478,
0.009014097,
-0.065479137,
-0.0154585885,
-0.0223417692,
-0.0112325782,
-0.0212179311,
0.0475356244,
-0.0751547515,
0.0264758002,
-0.0264787842,
-0.0861847773,
0.0190785881,
0.0132454596,
-0.0011400953,
-0.0170457754,
0.0272739492,
0.0334168933,
0.0206854213,
-0.0762239024,
-0.0351516083,
0.0078399535,
0.0111806393,
-0.0495594926,
-0.0167370923,
-0.0275439974,
0.0579818338,
0.0074703335,
0.0303005073,
0.0028716261,
0.0239310842,
0.0003441842,
-0.0474049039,
0.0995047092,
0.0235444997,
0.0106051033,
-0.0010688499,
0.0074208612,
0.0289191231,
0.0287506357,
0.0369366966,
0.0105835907,
0.0396580882,
-0.0097014727,
0.0390368365,
-0.0063399975,
-0.0506825075,
-0.021301752,
0.0050967378,
-0.0285207797,
-0.0240305439,
0.0585194789,
0.0584251694,
0.0316616111,
-0.0185732078,
-0.0370534137,
0.058049947,
0.1168801934,
-0.0256183669,
0.0757558867,
0.0213297252,
0.020985717,
-0.0122183729,
0.0374371633,
-0.0603276752,
0.0331196859,
0.0376305953,
-0.0303842165,
0.0135066146,
0.0112483473,
-0.0246862229,
-0.0278125945,
-0.0220725462,
-0.0284237899,
0.0406021848,
0.0105782496,
0.012176048,
-0.0119810067,
-0.0107953493,
-0.0503866188,
0.0665277615,
-0.0568130128,
0.0297425929,
-0.0319079496,
0.0150566269,
0.0777592435,
0.0159601625,
-0.026217794,
0.0058780271,
-0.0269118939,
-0.0293696485,
0.0242690966,
0.0405034572,
-0.0051106368,
0.054935798,
-0.0408428274,
0.0201817695,
-0.007910626,
0.0010061545,
0.0199231952,
-0.0614699535,
-0.0008564502,
-0.0127967224,
-0.0199097823,
-0.028507961,
0.0485052615,
-0.0624826588,
0.0045423019,
-0.0072414493,
0.0188330077,
0.0124558769,
0.0292413514,
-0.0226110704,
-0.0255524833,
0.022318881,
-0.0198981464,
-0.032548897,
0.080471307,
-0.0541129261,
-0.0361077338,
0.0081537524,
-0.1045159549,
-0.0224438794,
0.0597129762,
-0.0045475122,
-0.0157133061,
0.0301712416,
-0.0262117237,
0.0218565594,
-0.0473261662,
0.0171766225,
-0.0437698923,
0.0168232601,
-0.0054128673,
0.012673663,
-0.0320142359,
0.0135278311,
-0.0367240123,
-0.0125138778,
-0.00197345,
-0.0026134094,
-0.0428382494,
0.0333524123,
0.0292856805,
-0.0094708502,
0.0054781539,
-0.0100627104,
-0.0626063272,
-0.0367530137,
-0.1323343068,
-0.00675837,
-0.0105719576,
-0.0134848934,
-0.0002545225,
-0.0126239611,
-0.0316608772,
0.0052271937,
-0.0609610081,
0.0210190564,
0.0134400791,
0.004033607,
0.056313578,
-0.0017890846,
0.0153112477,
-0.0684471875,
-0.0015073358,
-0.0342689045,
0.0281438995,
0.0157325249,
-0.0078836856,
-0.008144849,
0.0060574836,
-0.0447456017,
0.0092151482,
-0.0251523331,
-0.0752134472,
0.0021449781,
0.0137594724,
-0.0016516028,
0.0580182634,
0.0224578865,
0.068117775,
0.0250814576,
0.0043205507,
-0.036547441,
0.0276656933,
-0.0168519486,
0.01134085,
-0.0493532643,
-0.0633829534,
-0.0455500856,
0.0517509803,
-0.0092221182,
-0.0056582089,
-0.053897202,
-0.0358228721,
0.0104606366,
-0.0403111577,
0.0145816831,
0.0104874559,
-0.0060365773,
0.0044414797,
-0.0217620227,
-0.0476488508,
0.0794143379,
0.0203842688,
-0.0118242633,
-0.0225109514,
-0.008421246,
-0.0283135846,
0.0512833521,
-0.0537766293,
0.0214179885,
-0.0234145708,
-0.0151082706,
-0.0362824164,
-0.0289595928,
-0.0122064995,
-0.0329927355,
-0.0216363855,
-0.0053371959,
-0.048276674,
0.0251052957,
-0.0422911756,
-0.0310953408,
-0.0449917316,
-0.0501151681,
0.0154481279,
0.0425240472,
-0.0147081744,
0.0186453592,
-0.0161020886,
0.0235600565,
-0.0196497943,
-0.0191591363,
-0.023125492,
-0.0365914144,
-0.0152195739,
0.0741303563,
0.0200496875,
0.0512063652,
-0.0314103514,
0.0730345324,
0.0101747671,
0.0434215926,
0.0234231278,
0.0136573957,
0.045320563,
0.0235682521,
0.006882892,
-0.0012026454,
-0.0386699997,
0.0255792867,
-0.02982191,
0.0093069607,
0.1337686479,
-0.0001963691,
-0.0708939135,
0.0336336046,
-0.0427307673,
-0.0497197062,
0.0138625056,
-0.0069872821,
-0.0672772974,
-0.0054379124,
0.0013766153,
0.0344707444,
-0.0308264215,
-0.0493123643,
0.0115059577,
-0.0895599425,
0.0234812554,
-0.0096150879,
0.0135609591,
-0.0521786548,
-0.0363828689,
0.0002146664,
0.0067919679,
0.049999442,
-0.0256301835,
-0.0121806161,
-0.0206531752,
0.0129210213,
0.0163616985,
-0.0338222757,
0.0364625752,
-0.0649514347,
0.055537492,
0.0533430167,
0.0958269462,
-0.0089378813,
-0.0118399737,
-0.0335642174,
0.0097361738,
0.0005383582,
-0.0134515259,
0.0338853076,
-0.0580630675,
-0.0256624818,
-0.0205284953,
0.0712572187,
-0.0283351056,
0.0090051591,
-0.0178908687,
0.0547798462,
-0.0231912434,
-0.0262517575,
0.022988325,
0.0293198507,
0.0064878087,
0.0785499513,
0.0395308472,
-0.077429913,
0.0041362173,
0.0201984737,
-0.0007750699,
0.0091814175,
-0.0380756482,
0.0096287876,
0.0062322281,
-0.0029387316,
-0.0268535167,
-0.0993613154,
0.0102252373,
0.002811525,
0.020872565,
-0.0163386334,
0.018760711,
0.0223314948,
-0.0441945605,
0.0516125038,
-0.0272071306,
0.0339488648,
0.0151014384,
0.0268557891,
0.0476007387,
-0.0491563678,
0.0096538663,
-0.0257708561,
-0.01735208,
-0.0605845116,
0.0123330122,
0.0148200737,
0.0077170176,
0.0504269898,
-0.0061564147,
-0.0803855807,
-0.0037248039,
0.04389745,
-0.0484975725,
0.0252394341,
0.0140012568,
0.0293752141,
-0.0139593789,
0.0251043085,
-0.0119196968,
0.0214857608,
0.0317567475,
0.0054924134,
0.0205280036,
-0.0445907712,
-0.0002072619,
-0.0004975331,
0.0401624553,
-0.014969347,
-0.0268340036,
-0.065337956,
-0.045803003,
-0.009799948,
-0.0062755924,
-0.0317871347,
-0.023313811,
0.0281697139,
0.0601450875,
-0.0453020819,
-0.0777098015,
-0.0658143163,
0.0211247653,
-0.0515923202,
0.0361344032,
-0.0152009968,
-0.0026178528,
-0.0318849422,
0.0411008038,
-0.0061252713,
0.0102358023,
-0.0199713036,
0.0062618656,
-0.0058391066,
0.0488222837,
0.0353168622,
-0.0058341757,
0.0034178621,
0.0214836039,
-0.0010154723,
-0.017978806,
-0.0364155173,
0.0129122026,
0.0933787376,
-0.0359979495,
0.0235777721,
-0.0206003003,
0.026307093,
-0.0171402674,
0.0446648188,
-0.0155111235,
-0.0151421037,
-0.0226721521,
0.0201326627,
-0.0364224538,
0.0421147235,
0.0016492468,
-0.0871258378,
0.0468800366,
0.0199724156,
-0.0189094581,
-0.0230886266,
0.0029118052,
0.0657763183,
0.0038282792,
-0.0118159922,
0.0368916094,
-0.0688148662,
-0.065196313,
0.041443754,
-0.0444626883,
-0.024902761,
-0.03761255,
0.01832835,
0.0436312594,
-0.0127914697,
0.0053436467,
-0.0511804894,
0.0152606815,
-0.0544572286,
-0.030452922,
0.0150998039,
-5.956292691e-33,
-0.0014325636,
0.0019113417,
-0.063943848,
0.0057882359,
-0.0423185714,
0.0179957729,
-0.0237682145,
0.0239815358,
-0.0173331462,
0.0630604923,
-0.0279189236,
0.0390385427,
0.0117540667,
-0.0170042291,
0.005483659,
-0.0135588013,
0.0218633246,
0.0103761144,
-0.0011246837,
0.0205582883,
0.0083005866,
0.0637356341,
0.0628552213,
-0.074240908,
0.0353110842,
-0.0191456862,
-0.0329745598,
0.0215470046,
0.0401953459,
0.0337148011,
-0.055062376,
0.0781842172,
0.0302696824,
-0.0020428416,
0.0096912319,
0.0275244061,
-0.0705514699,
0.012552782,
0.02175905,
0.0119530484,
-0.0535566956,
-0.0588373914,
0.04707966,
-0.0063211382,
-0.0339034088,
0.0083359275,
0.031915538,
-0.0120533248,
0.0510583818,
-0.0192127433,
-0.046333015,
-0.010808832,
-0.0283258073,
-0.0522855185,
0.0108734593,
0.0267457627,
-0.0117738694,
0.0573465675,
-0.0222254489,
-0.0049111769,
-0.0177441593,
0.0003406081,
0.0183124617,
-0.0286824536,
0.0072794589,
0.0913506895,
-0.001524134,
0.0094795749,
0.0112608336,
0.0495132133,
0.0565672666,
0.0123375496,
0.0270454101,
0.0749240369,
-0.0380564667,
-0.0180848222,
-0.0194171481,
0.0292912647,
0.0315535776,
0.0378921293,
0.0530146211,
-0.0003925632,
-0.0292386785,
0.0111101428,
-0.0546286479,
-0.0862597451,
-0.008705019,
-0.0036021527,
-0.0061942972,
-0.0221570618,
-0.0195430778,
-0.0027909991,
0.0023565125,
-0.0441674814,
0.0267021116,
0.0105319619,
-0.0498705171,
0.0150899012,
0.0134675559,
0.0227903444,
-0.0211747903,
-0.0581529588,
-0.0056095864,
-0.0023236843,
0.0663393661,
-0.0020639489,
0.013774843,
0.0134144593,
-0.0341552123,
-0.0047835973,
-0.0303047448,
0.0288192481,
-0.0116959643,
0.004387123,
-0.0066512283,
0.007990391,
-0.0278301276,
-0.0086521134,
0.0244400017,
0.0375000536,
-0.0356560536,
-0.0484474301,
-0.0329177603,
0.0212338138,
-0.0386333428,
-0.0016918308,
0.0073347264,
-0.0163609684,
0.0396900885,
-0.0182751995,
-0.0289362296,
-0.0244635809,
2.648e-7,
-0.0212259423,
0.027516067,
0.0337759182,
-0.0208316036,
-0.0019251022,
0.0606331006,
0.008707447,
0.0856906101,
0.0380707718,
-0.0285659432,
0.0386000536,
0.0296081156,
0.0891539976,
0.0087876758,
-0.0966321006,
0.0499881618,
-0.0482147001,
0.0124770645,
-0.0226758234,
0.0079820696,
0.055490341,
0.0776656717,
0.0491165593,
-0.0037396853,
0.0182831865,
-0.0068139695,
0.0171434246,
-0.0976534113,
-0.026418196,
0.0135297244,
-0.0275881588,
-0.0030922075,
-0.0017273613,
-0.0311724693,
0.0165485218,
0.0451673083,
0.0134782754,
0.1009282917,
0.0045886133,
-0.0719326213,
0.0336189643,
0.0464568399,
-0.0061693303,
-0.037538562,
0.0427720435,
-0.0731076598,
-0.0473931208,
-0.0123368641,
0.0433009528,
-0.0114283878,
0.0362132639,
-0.0182744302,
-0.0370014198,
0.0371166691,
0.0166001469,
-0.0089664012,
-0.0102553125,
-0.0495440327,
0.0222838614,
-0.0116401985,
-0.0310050696,
-0.0685313866,
0.0110042542,
0.009019048,
0.0058065611,
-0.0167789031,
0.0032763493,
1.82275793e-34,
0.0239008293,
-0.0081886882,
0.0070213256,
0.0651680976,
0.0603192747,
0.043781016,
-0.0222018491,
0.0020523614,
0.0668826476,
-0.0574686825,
-0.0030011933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11243v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11243v1 | FamiCom: Further Demystifying Prompts for Language Models with Task-Agnostic Performance Estimation | 2024-06-17T06:14:55 | 2024-06-17T06:14:55 | Bangzheng Li, Ben Zhou, Xingyu Fu, Fei Wang, Dan Roth, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language models have shown impressive in-context-learning capabilities, which
allow them to benefit from input prompts and perform better on downstream end
tasks. Existing works investigate the mechanisms behind this observation, and
propose label-agnostic prompt metrics that can better estimate end-task
performances. One popular approach is using perplexity as a way to measure
models' familiarity with the prompt. While showing consistent improvements on
in-domain tasks, we found that familiarity metrics such as perplexity cannot
accurately estimate performance in complicated situations such as task or
domain transferring scenarios. In this work, we propose a revised measure
called FamiCom, providing a more comprehensive measure for task-agnostic
performance estimation. Specifically, FamiCom combines familiarity with
\textit{complexity} -- the inherent difficulty of end tasks, which is an
important factor missing from current metrics. Experiments show that FamiCom
strongly correlates with end-task performances, producing a 0.85 Spearman's
correlation, versus 0.43 of familiarity-only ones'. We further apply FamiCom to
automatic prompt and demonstration selection, and outperform existing methods
and baselines by more than 7.0% in accuracy. | [
-0.002013087,
0.0195486881,
-0.0310301781,
0.0343478955,
-0.0537107065,
0.0308927149,
0.0399376862,
-0.0213682465,
-0.0012788905,
-0.0044407439,
-0.067327857,
-0.050766658,
0.017579956,
0.0304853078,
0.0287444089,
-0.0481069125,
0.0526094288,
-0.0463206321,
0.0041601034,
0.006771862,
-0.0293957386,
-0.0111077707,
-0.0293839853,
0.0572021455,
-0.0016972158,
-0.038665846,
-0.0172148943,
0.0078387605,
-0.024116829,
-0.0499610007,
0.0192443598,
0.069247447,
0.0044323886,
0.0379953459,
0.0000021252,
-0.073708199,
0.0119333183,
-0.04079118,
-0.0547269918,
0.0179755706,
0.0357051343,
0.0246069506,
-0.0095473444,
0.0357831679,
-0.0266143065,
-0.0510642827,
0.0466621071,
0.0256293062,
0.0024167688,
0.0389735587,
0.0040573217,
0.044756677,
-0.0257147178,
-0.0459690802,
0.0029824032,
-0.0434219651,
-0.0078908466,
-0.0591051355,
0.0166939441,
0.0110415071,
-0.0286144167,
0.0339551121,
0.0441874973,
-0.0034000888,
-0.0350967534,
0.0307068545,
0.0316417031,
-0.0197058395,
-0.0464091338,
0.081651926,
-0.0367730707,
0.0004076102,
-0.0147925774,
-0.0272708535,
0.0497675948,
0.0105640823,
-0.0594807714,
-0.0164144747,
0.0128962891,
-0.0009976407,
-0.012995447,
0.0171031915,
0.0328091644,
-0.0039581298,
-0.0034837706,
0.0777145475,
0.0199781936,
-0.0247581806,
0.0281788446,
-0.0121299047,
-0.0347325057,
-0.0631988198,
-0.006272235,
0.0126346881,
-0.0794150978,
0.0201109033,
-0.0366863087,
-0.0328074284,
0.0197580457,
-0.0005035982,
0.061716903,
0.0539235212,
-0.0592693239,
0.0575934909,
-0.025061693,
0.111633651,
0.02135773,
0.0190744456,
-0.0156676825,
0.0200466644,
-0.0543943159,
0.0011549619,
-0.0302625168,
0.0111315716,
0.0007632356,
-0.0255340226,
-0.0065268767,
0.0541708171,
-0.0206686482,
0.0125852013,
-0.0051753549,
-0.0151963504,
-0.0220452528,
0.0157978367,
-0.0363366306,
0.0469774827,
-0.0447709858,
0.0298463497,
0.0494465083,
-0.0746851489,
-0.0290845204,
-0.0005267431,
0.0022660193,
-0.0407209173,
-0.0153540997,
0.064760156,
-0.0184194017,
-0.0469581895,
0.0046243658,
0.0099671772,
-0.0180351343,
-0.0604858212,
0.0014373939,
-0.039974682,
0.0179634579,
0.0258731078,
0.0033525571,
-0.0345518775,
-0.0158947408,
0.016077226,
0.0113106091,
0.0643243864,
0.0224216282,
0.0249411296,
0.0216425695,
0.0244428758,
-0.0419552363,
0.0648460165,
-0.0048309732,
0.0111940522,
0.0542481318,
-0.0120056635,
0.0258859098,
0.0520182736,
-0.0012241381,
0.0024914297,
-0.0050637904,
-0.0115052788,
0.0695142597,
-0.0080545498,
0.0290346071,
0.0374312811,
-0.0006516212,
0.0195357092,
0.0771588311,
0.0194577798,
-0.0079087373,
-0.0608827509,
0.0602281466,
0.0137317134,
0.0139107322,
0.0411420465,
-0.0933450535,
0.0221519005,
-0.004945016,
0.0111605301,
0.0374573506,
0.0088320496,
-0.0337168835,
-0.0391387157,
-0.0007066479,
-0.014090728,
-0.0035708197,
0.0242157914,
0.0490651317,
0.0374091417,
-0.063147366,
0.0196400452,
0.0136394128,
-0.0497491024,
0.0067206095,
-0.0553643182,
0.0212892648,
0.0342914239,
0.0212247092,
-0.0307030957,
-0.0216995906,
-0.0083097611,
0.0686035007,
0.0348971225,
0.064834021,
-0.0216732956,
0.0412413441,
-0.0144133233,
-0.0382492691,
-0.0198936686,
0.0428668968,
0.0163417347,
0.0154846292,
0.0054396172,
0.0194544364,
-0.0602469891,
-0.0166326463,
0.0286249798,
-0.0274236277,
-0.037985906,
0.0098688295,
0.020554455,
0.0071688271,
-0.0084750317,
0.025004372,
0.0256420542,
0.0182678476,
-0.0315741971,
0.0520132296,
0.0052879723,
-0.0781880543,
-0.0430396982,
0.0281076357,
0.0239692014,
-0.0099315951,
0.0513041057,
-0.0160969794,
-0.0448937118,
0.0078808023,
-0.0264934693,
0.0373935178,
-0.0264674667,
0.0448056981,
-0.0444350801,
0.0092912782,
-0.0258905869,
0.0536669344,
0.0113842217,
0.0513692871,
0.0508791916,
0.0376260094,
0.0133889588,
-0.0254156273,
-0.049143821,
-0.0103629213,
-0.0360089615,
-0.0088204127,
0.0199033562,
-0.0131626222,
-0.0388451889,
-0.0179929566,
-0.078673251,
-0.0065207668,
-0.031145066,
0.0159535185,
0.0137187159,
0.0155139538,
-0.0130911171,
-0.046244178,
-0.0121012051,
-0.0029590805,
0.0005221191,
0.0458493531,
0.0271219965,
0.0146880057,
-0.053884469,
-0.0346622579,
0.0050311764,
-0.0039711557,
0.0462596416,
-0.0121504134,
0.0157393198,
-0.0390476584,
0.0500519313,
-0.0062212646,
-0.0033702599,
-0.0359885842,
0.0015133823,
0.0375527628,
-0.0027195241,
0.0502376147,
0.0406556912,
0.0018474011,
0.0215540435,
0.0545083173,
-0.0280786678,
-0.0543816537,
0.0020147043,
-0.0221905876,
-0.0302694198,
-0.0194173921,
-0.0255080983,
0.0230692737,
0.0708025247,
-0.0089717535,
-0.0104284696,
-0.0515305325,
0.0133522162,
-0.0371506736,
-0.0229318421,
-0.0478660502,
-0.0096931187,
-0.0408723578,
0.0684608892,
-0.0309509337,
-0.0849608779,
0.0798309743,
-0.0342976451,
-0.0118901301,
-0.0404671989,
0.0064951926,
-0.0003879845,
0.0654643103,
-0.0096491631,
-0.0063176109,
0.0334396511,
-0.0654689521,
-0.0630989447,
0.0198208448,
-0.0013998558,
-0.0375696756,
0.0518390313,
-0.0541722104,
-0.0183510613,
0.0090627708,
-0.0364042148,
-0.0529959053,
-0.0216233563,
-0.0003216267,
0.0323988497,
-0.0255745836,
-0.0135287959,
-0.0057850811,
-0.0125339078,
0.0317815058,
0.0454173721,
-0.0153162749,
0.003825916,
-0.016961243,
-0.0153484503,
0.0380251594,
0.0348605961,
0.0065608649,
-0.0492797792,
0.051099401,
-0.0015383983,
0.0718656257,
-0.0027835565,
-0.0113664102,
0.0105055254,
0.0278031304,
-0.0049529485,
-0.0293543357,
0.0860029086,
0.0468951091,
-0.0542091802,
-0.0239580739,
0.1317570359,
0.0209054984,
-0.0518221818,
0.0163158029,
-0.0081446124,
0.0582503863,
0.0493157543,
0.0066210921,
-0.0479878038,
-0.0318036489,
0.0248670038,
0.0128503414,
0.0007233218,
-0.0247618295,
-0.0184279289,
-0.1226943061,
0.0239427574,
-0.0271368418,
-0.0703004152,
-0.0319017656,
-0.0655317456,
0.0424008034,
0.0320374332,
0.0463894308,
0.003019654,
-0.0193167608,
-0.0016950731,
0.027237229,
-0.0083350278,
-0.0949488953,
0.0306763146,
-0.0427369662,
0.0514243022,
0.0591866001,
-0.0036424561,
-0.0026856738,
-0.0456865281,
0.048126962,
-0.0189037714,
0.0039661834,
-0.0108520146,
0.0371751934,
0.0359246619,
-0.0286053848,
0.0207769517,
-0.0011459851,
-0.021341607,
-0.0331502073,
0.0105066579,
0.0701800212,
-0.0065250224,
-0.0095897177,
0.0126607232,
-0.0355965979,
0.0481184423,
0.0980677232,
0.086524047,
-0.0618259683,
-0.0124244718,
-0.0282625016,
0.0079884864,
-0.0214470308,
0.0031529965,
0.0091552213,
0.0094777774,
-0.0398719199,
-0.0333251879,
-0.0271058362,
0.0446361303,
0.0623947866,
0.0378017873,
0.0136509938,
-0.0359148085,
-0.0042120479,
-0.040383447,
0.0456111915,
0.0023246738,
0.0473570079,
-0.1020345315,
0.0127985356,
-0.0010390902,
-0.0179929249,
-0.0227186754,
0.0023487895,
-0.0570882075,
-0.0498231612,
-0.0019063464,
0.0298989285,
0.0253950395,
0.0122498106,
-0.0362620167,
-0.0488651209,
0.0242157876,
0.0209263284,
-0.0209165029,
0.0385174379,
0.0356687084,
-0.0153541574,
-0.017624706,
0.0437351912,
-0.0543269105,
-0.0137187233,
0.04398394,
0.0416758545,
0.0224799849,
-0.0493300594,
0.0150313564,
0.0004745364,
0.0718992949,
-0.010878426,
-0.0214673597,
-0.0447410084,
-0.0196933746,
0.029510837,
-0.0088571208,
-0.054921817,
-0.0115406336,
0.0106093157,
0.0306904241,
0.0125244362,
-0.0030699607,
-0.0150188841,
0.0546185002,
-0.0417941995,
-0.0150188012,
-0.0202168133,
0.0121210711,
0.0185146052,
0.0163503997,
-0.0271755308,
-0.0088449195,
0.0064340183,
0.0275283717,
0.0000623488,
0.0596586727,
0.0291438363,
-0.0010933077,
0.0038078192,
0.0429804623,
-0.052104786,
-0.028077703,
0.0082372548,
0.0062720967,
0.0305437054,
-0.0377197377,
0.0376047455,
-0.007385219,
0.0118482122,
-0.049481947,
-0.0001883529,
0.0297414418,
-0.0502999872,
0.0427074693,
0.0343396142,
0.016584808,
0.0202362575,
0.0848361179,
-0.0279502328,
0.033097256,
-0.000361095,
0.0385858491,
-0.0262547042,
-0.0092542777,
0.0374465249,
0.0341986157,
-0.034190461,
0.0104902331,
-0.0521645844,
-0.0747302249,
0.0050255214,
-0.0026041155,
-0.0277217794,
-0.0150250681,
0.0504359268,
0.0842640251,
-0.0513824858,
-0.0303617232,
-0.0319906995,
-0.0212500021,
0.0153503278,
-0.0157325994,
-0.0265742689,
-6.173698535e-33,
-0.0359810404,
-0.0403882749,
-0.0143297436,
-0.0153563367,
0.0059382943,
0.0086321924,
-0.0794299766,
0.0333407074,
-0.0285085998,
0.0078440411,
-0.0188362896,
-0.008106255,
0.0115905637,
0.0115700206,
0.0110628121,
-0.0193862412,
0.0434844941,
-0.0011598582,
-0.0720950663,
0.0223296825,
0.0058724424,
0.0146331806,
0.0407820567,
-0.0625019968,
0.0522119068,
0.0179057829,
-0.0094929263,
0.0139652593,
0.0098202648,
0.0590810739,
0.0046944791,
0.0470546931,
0.023498388,
-0.0750389323,
-0.0414697193,
0.0514330566,
-0.030372832,
-0.0572990589,
0.0244808737,
0.0128535395,
-0.0330735147,
-0.0312909447,
-0.0038657109,
-0.0308681838,
-0.0269622654,
-0.000817151,
0.0314633101,
-0.0081783738,
-0.0178762749,
0.0351998359,
-0.0428880602,
-0.001937787,
-0.0081311176,
-0.0562170446,
0.0246364027,
0.0732745528,
-0.0164392628,
-0.0229936223,
-0.0244689379,
0.0353320725,
0.0095232185,
0.0479780436,
0.0663883388,
0.0460568517,
-0.0049490123,
0.0649845526,
0.034789443,
0.0255827904,
0.0237108469,
-0.0187115185,
0.0633070096,
0.0251700245,
0.0331256762,
0.0089121768,
0.0234449562,
0.0161716938,
-0.0418134741,
0.0282160044,
0.0324254595,
0.0020817732,
0.0174577869,
-0.0127839902,
-0.0461393595,
-0.0444222055,
-0.0598108023,
0.020351138,
-0.0468204618,
-0.0270073116,
0.061728172,
-0.0089650005,
-0.0206444729,
-0.0402914248,
0.049385298,
-0.0160749685,
-0.0463702865,
0.0162618887,
-0.0095493188,
0.0480774604,
0.029642174,
0.0282140486,
-0.0301217698,
-0.0342048071,
0.0106125027,
0.0171434786,
0.0286171436,
-0.0105090747,
0.0165919606,
0.0422631241,
-0.0761210322,
0.0015520348,
-0.0470333397,
0.003148604,
0.0272365324,
0.009073182,
0.0283528157,
-0.0094450116,
-0.021555759,
0.0341655686,
-0.0081518898,
-0.0832925439,
-0.0486025512,
0.016445104,
-0.0232938025,
0.0152528472,
-0.0496297181,
-0.054914616,
-0.0324926376,
0.0326078311,
0.0245312843,
-0.0147677846,
-0.0242370218,
-0.000204382,
2.789e-7,
0.0217843726,
0.0093577383,
-0.0324880071,
0.0348927826,
0.0209575575,
0.0447598435,
-0.0470382124,
0.011171476,
0.0119997812,
-0.0235119779,
-0.0264456291,
0.0179825276,
0.0688482076,
-0.0070230262,
-0.1089000031,
-0.0147019345,
-0.0380075052,
0.0424147323,
-0.0365348682,
0.0269068554,
0.0202076416,
0.0609002076,
-0.0134057589,
0.0073253075,
-0.0180108212,
-0.0327542424,
0.0135094766,
-0.0505568013,
0.0397457369,
0.0072350483,
0.0012139069,
0.0051194285,
0.0232627206,
0.058808133,
-0.0283390321,
0.0164918434,
0.0290143602,
0.0552794077,
0.0385876223,
-0.0390472598,
-0.01832534,
0.003751881,
0.0161225665,
-0.0659143627,
0.0763158053,
-0.045184087,
0.0002198449,
-0.0092759803,
0.0174443368,
-0.0201232918,
0.0328319296,
-0.0091649964,
-0.0319699645,
0.00678901,
0.0245168321,
-0.0122134183,
-0.0145282885,
-0.0458730012,
-0.0242795683,
-0.0014394139,
-0.0441025123,
-0.0745476857,
-0.0622977577,
0.014752035,
0.0101824142,
-0.0495464019,
0.0250263382,
2.731606196e-34,
0.0137418723,
-0.0232394692,
0.0446369648,
0.0384332091,
0.0010118929,
-0.0242343619,
-0.0072143259,
0.0121942461,
0.0371381305,
-0.0681815296,
-0.01553379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15481v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15481v1 | CSRT: Evaluation and Analysis of LLMs using Code-Switching Red-Teaming Dataset | 2024-06-17T06:08:18 | 2024-06-17T06:08:18 | Haneul Yoo, Yongjin Yang, Hwaran Lee | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent studies in large language models (LLMs) shed light on their
multilingual ability and safety, beyond conventional tasks in language
modeling. Still, current benchmarks reveal their inability to comprehensively
evaluate them and are excessively dependent on manual annotations. In this
paper, we introduce code-switching red-teaming (CSRT), a simple yet effective
red-teaming technique that simultaneously tests multilingual understanding and
safety of LLMs. We release the CSRT dataset, which comprises 315 code-switching
queries combining up to 10 languages and eliciting a wide range of undesirable
behaviors. Through extensive experiments with ten state-of-the-art LLMs, we
demonstrate that CSRT significantly outperforms existing multilingual
red-teaming techniques, achieving 46.7% more attacks than existing methods in
English. We analyze the harmful responses toward the CSRT dataset concerning
various aspects under ablation studies with 16K samples, including but not
limited to scaling laws, unsafe behavior categories, and input conditions for
optimal data generation. Additionally, we validate the extensibility of CSRT,
by generating code-switching attack prompts with monolingual data. | [
-0.0118995458,
0.0699416324,
-0.0234136004,
0.0582070276,
-0.061407689,
0.0049432046,
0.0639737546,
0.0068645556,
0.0093331914,
-0.0410658307,
-0.0306291785,
-0.0402312018,
-0.0127011156,
0.0172627848,
0.0728257149,
0.0330056064,
0.0613127947,
-0.058596693,
-0.049963776,
-0.0138324825,
0.0196996331,
0.0092146602,
0.0147786327,
0.045328062,
0.0050956691,
0.0006266451,
-0.0168853179,
0.0287505817,
0.0044262595,
-0.038576562,
0.0245440993,
0.0547849946,
0.0070458907,
0.0605775453,
0.0000020498,
-0.0436688736,
-0.0493680462,
0.0328616276,
-0.0068427981,
0.051530201,
0.0056933393,
-0.0365529247,
-0.0112982588,
0.0414369218,
-0.0329144858,
0.0035642432,
0.0546531789,
-0.0007780971,
0.0627542883,
0.101108484,
0.0041872277,
-0.0085745286,
-0.0215119757,
-0.0396359563,
-0.0122565459,
-0.0403029732,
0.0469760858,
-0.0174770206,
0.0242007338,
0.0150800394,
-0.0115026794,
-0.0026041248,
0.0032577161,
-0.0076798163,
-0.1042435691,
-0.0089017441,
-0.0547169819,
0.0062344689,
0.0123060606,
0.0319046266,
-0.0523913614,
-0.0197943263,
0.0136122294,
0.0164665207,
-0.0463822894,
-0.0440220498,
-0.0122552123,
0.028215155,
-0.0057914406,
0.0088644857,
0.0094619691,
-0.0024294953,
0.0545820519,
0.0019735096,
-0.0286514033,
0.0464217812,
0.0120627685,
-0.0371660776,
-0.0138707981,
-0.0441584736,
0.0174913127,
-0.0461131409,
-0.0097379778,
-0.0152148241,
-0.0273612123,
0.0307811368,
-0.0513430834,
-0.0661298931,
0.0791468471,
-0.0573574901,
0.022280924,
0.0405296907,
-0.0157198124,
0.0289280713,
-0.0100300862,
0.0311600696,
-0.013638692,
0.0337789617,
0.0027707391,
-0.0232242476,
-0.0275035165,
0.0089290738,
-0.0120570818,
0.0195575207,
0.0261136834,
0.0309702493,
-0.0410770774,
0.0222753286,
-0.0219104774,
0.0308380686,
-0.0156556536,
-0.0545501001,
-0.0125370873,
0.0131983301,
0.0451667942,
-0.0310871005,
-0.0137305865,
-0.0260664318,
-0.018039206,
-0.0870120674,
-0.0233676247,
0.002498602,
-0.0616232604,
-0.0574176647,
0.0057092072,
0.0899120942,
0.0058372431,
-0.0274200533,
-0.0439002402,
-0.0502789393,
-0.0015592063,
-0.0251928363,
-0.0057982332,
-0.0865540206,
0.0157174673,
-0.0043493607,
-0.0047024656,
-0.066474542,
-0.0005676554,
0.0014428662,
-0.0384313948,
0.0853018761,
-0.0214357208,
-0.00624274,
-0.011157129,
0.0211826544,
-0.0108655095,
0.1263676137,
0.0025383909,
-0.0002787097,
0.0617374592,
-0.0097654387,
0.032625705,
0.0801659673,
0.0025023911,
0.0573418178,
-0.027579084,
0.0222594086,
0.0535089262,
-0.0146612367,
0.0062071308,
0.0643686205,
-0.0199394561,
-0.0739950389,
0.0428902879,
0.0277314074,
-0.0189372506,
0.0439803638,
0.0152662518,
0.0191702656,
-0.0161324032,
-0.0111981248,
-0.0467518568,
-0.0093409372,
-0.055032894,
-0.0264676008,
0.0246472657,
0.0348607898,
-0.0240908563,
-0.0139764687,
-0.02956637,
-0.0066964799,
0.0215109456,
0.0119076362,
0.0255754311,
0.0035305072,
-0.0015066551,
0.0448807813,
0.0221706256,
-0.0578418449,
-0.0143590542,
-0.0624481067,
-0.0277256276,
0.0341846719,
0.0572946891,
-0.0470975265,
-0.0176458322,
-0.0183215365,
0.0005847111,
0.0465988405,
0.0259086266,
0.0171838552,
0.0190992523,
-0.0473132618,
-0.0281389691,
-0.0006588992,
0.017959198,
0.0220976099,
0.0309457574,
0.0115512945,
-0.0100297537,
-0.0299821645,
-0.0453641564,
0.0220455714,
-0.0267647654,
-0.0156440474,
0.0175047219,
0.0030603141,
0.0280078035,
-0.006641503,
-0.0441171825,
0.0142949615,
0.0373255573,
0.0029454709,
0.0015307714,
0.0082584647,
0.0299994536,
-0.0043057441,
0.0295036118,
-0.021414781,
-0.0036303585,
0.06356401,
-0.0465620868,
-0.0127184503,
0.0360067971,
-0.0429392494,
0.0107768364,
-0.0160712879,
0.0129896896,
-0.0135228327,
0.0353419743,
-0.0187441483,
-0.0016329356,
-0.0266472567,
0.0220255554,
-0.0135515779,
-0.0129185272,
0.0346816033,
-0.0406597629,
-0.0754134655,
0.0289996583,
-0.0244548023,
0.0567493215,
0.0174458064,
0.0422813259,
-0.0033911578,
-0.0148419552,
-0.0333328098,
0.0089246985,
-0.0344574824,
0.0387143902,
0.033170525,
0.0163213331,
-0.0294593722,
-0.0060062082,
-0.0228359867,
-0.0272743795,
-0.032140132,
0.0544877574,
0.0031276769,
-0.0252671074,
-0.0602383688,
-0.0199080706,
-0.0259468779,
-0.0150477411,
0.0607600361,
-0.0438812859,
-0.0211439878,
-0.0446101204,
0.0267645027,
-0.0200814325,
0.0340016484,
-0.0266196057,
-0.0776800141,
0.0247759242,
-0.0331386924,
-0.0219392478,
0.0338592865,
0.0103813745,
-0.0101029957,
0.095507443,
0.0019441504,
-0.0510798767,
-0.0134759527,
0.0162235666,
-0.0402247123,
-0.041797664,
-0.0622607395,
0.0242000222,
0.0622010417,
0.0013991306,
-0.0155174918,
-0.0353750363,
-0.0433601066,
0.0053152563,
-0.0290181264,
-0.0334370881,
-0.0063452371,
-0.0160527732,
0.024441449,
0.0025439244,
-0.0533116572,
0.0718393996,
-0.0484240279,
0.0114880558,
-0.0567544326,
-0.026385963,
-0.0251223017,
0.041482728,
-0.0161706526,
0.0319635496,
0.0190179534,
-0.0283970181,
-0.0193800703,
-0.032249596,
0.023534067,
-0.0372779928,
0.0557689965,
-0.0489814505,
0.0177291539,
-0.0097477706,
-0.0328186676,
-0.0451833233,
-0.0367225409,
-0.0243438836,
-0.0110645955,
0.039392259,
-0.0303976946,
0.000948125,
0.0138766514,
0.0416623466,
0.0157583095,
-0.0108363144,
-0.0018761297,
0.0121494057,
-0.0176324993,
0.0232840795,
-0.0382543802,
-0.0048694974,
-0.0150279617,
0.0102550695,
0.087532118,
0.0457640961,
-0.0045192903,
-0.0158768035,
-0.000373923,
0.0452027135,
-0.0248390324,
-0.0164980665,
0.0058328263,
0.013568162,
-0.0572761558,
-0.0226613451,
0.061518684,
0.0421373509,
-0.0512227193,
0.007963201,
-0.013823661,
0.0388076976,
0.0268306658,
0.0376323797,
-0.1232396439,
-0.0123964073,
0.0076355119,
0.0551608913,
-0.0155820716,
-0.0348013565,
-0.0322701,
-0.1397387087,
0.0092118969,
0.0155046759,
-0.0511440448,
-0.0199146476,
-0.0398647413,
-0.0012047043,
0.000041118,
0.0509107523,
0.0057763895,
0.0226613637,
-0.0271651149,
0.0325115584,
-0.0496514402,
-0.0439078026,
0.0261676777,
-0.045261845,
0.0490860008,
0.0522730201,
0.0147795528,
-0.0360039398,
-0.0070519033,
0.0341737606,
0.006312531,
-0.0166957807,
-0.0154065816,
0.0328418352,
0.0147485724,
-0.032650128,
0.0440205932,
0.0032779912,
0.004819199,
-0.0024959955,
0.0617238618,
0.0287743993,
-0.033271227,
0.0038111778,
-0.0174244698,
-0.0029028493,
0.0394718572,
0.0607443564,
0.0230927337,
-0.036993213,
-0.0181115679,
-0.0709886849,
-0.0266630333,
-0.0597417839,
-0.0483206697,
0.026176028,
-0.0060575693,
-0.0354105867,
-0.0260807537,
-0.0033135405,
0.0056550237,
0.0113042435,
0.0310759731,
0.026479993,
-0.0279840026,
0.0115155224,
-0.0234189387,
-0.0329975821,
-0.0472428389,
0.0417439155,
-0.0739179701,
0.0249943212,
0.0157455839,
-0.0211385339,
0.0013461998,
0.0245432295,
-0.0701374859,
-0.108188726,
0.0050291391,
0.0645122156,
0.0218834579,
0.0221201759,
-0.0374849625,
-0.0931142196,
0.0162421912,
0.0371779725,
-0.004196133,
0.0043762587,
0.0827982649,
-0.0284031369,
0.0070647122,
0.0371062681,
-0.0600335188,
-0.0029612726,
0.0126173366,
-0.0014160523,
-0.0844111592,
0.0058169891,
0.0009352484,
0.0568473116,
0.0320004262,
-0.0305747185,
0.0007754395,
0.0152200665,
0.026739208,
-0.0385195017,
-0.0243700519,
0.0188482609,
0.0163086113,
0.0036357688,
-0.0230206661,
0.0000047606,
0.0202693511,
-0.0124715446,
-0.0017470424,
-0.007893946,
0.0570918545,
0.0468685143,
0.0382345058,
0.0680762455,
0.0028457073,
-0.0150754666,
0.0357170999,
0.0302969608,
0.0327560753,
-0.0153195038,
0.0153297409,
0.0046321596,
-0.0048343656,
0.021710109,
0.04273431,
-0.0385135971,
-0.0536987931,
0.0490728095,
-0.0102347163,
0.0485707931,
0.0202424899,
0.0782628953,
-0.0089881672,
0.007506819,
-0.0394053496,
0.0186026916,
-0.0005233233,
-0.0320662037,
0.0303032398,
0.0092568919,
-0.0209536068,
0.0430924222,
0.1020007133,
-0.000850197,
0.0325632989,
0.0369748026,
-0.0167926196,
-0.0280544553,
-0.0012423217,
0.0439767875,
0.0195954144,
-0.0341532119,
-0.072769843,
-0.0618429258,
-0.0692292377,
0.0133093074,
0.0056088702,
0.0266243424,
0.021073157,
-0.0057908408,
0.0659801438,
0.0286323335,
0.0498191714,
-0.0666544214,
0.0104951104,
0.0180839039,
-0.0616800599,
0.0416869484,
-6.265841129e-33,
0.0318211466,
-0.0191845279,
-0.0003578326,
0.0023854161,
0.0215337928,
0.0161263514,
-0.0350085758,
0.0026095333,
-0.0414024964,
-0.0223082826,
-0.0054104119,
-0.0012629438,
0.0136999274,
0.0057655913,
0.0035415178,
-0.0253313109,
0.0007752802,
0.0046427501,
0.0015006255,
0.0136232954,
0.081037201,
0.0010333244,
0.056895826,
-0.0802841336,
0.0160627756,
-0.0205525979,
-0.0392317884,
0.0131865796,
-0.0380972922,
0.0543376654,
0.0020278427,
0.0661965236,
-0.006652189,
-0.0277258307,
-0.0126458444,
-0.0108149434,
-0.006952445,
-0.0086941253,
0.0009021099,
-0.0051429253,
0.022269154,
-0.0359386839,
0.0357607007,
0.001515915,
-0.0048523811,
-0.0117888963,
0.0044188467,
-0.0115289045,
-0.0136890067,
-0.0146066984,
-0.0206022784,
0.036658898,
-0.0274187811,
-0.0030254645,
0.0318488218,
0.0390215516,
0.0339059308,
0.003298217,
-0.0712064654,
0.0493614413,
-0.0081984401,
0.0220798478,
0.0764374733,
0.0089391321,
0.0105513204,
0.0359714516,
-0.0044281688,
0.031303186,
0.0273231063,
0.0163786057,
0.0308904033,
0.0383583121,
0.0475868285,
0.0815695375,
0.0083303312,
-0.0388234071,
-0.0865637958,
0.0222618114,
0.0731280521,
0.0082879039,
0.0406735688,
0.0183894634,
-0.0769789517,
-0.0343315788,
0.0044579534,
-0.0196313094,
-0.0298895314,
-0.0463190489,
0.015387563,
-0.0143313147,
-0.0315932296,
0.0024699818,
0.0298759528,
-0.0225844793,
-0.0279903691,
0.0576219819,
-0.0221638884,
-0.0228622947,
-0.0005841313,
0.0362284034,
-0.016917197,
-0.0114266612,
-0.0009733437,
-0.0590880811,
0.0417538881,
-0.0031379601,
0.0360394791,
0.0355197974,
-0.0728988424,
-0.0233819224,
-0.0299017131,
0.0536093079,
0.0045629353,
0.0075493744,
0.017288141,
-0.0156282522,
0.0222174674,
0.0045696222,
0.0541177206,
-0.0330751725,
-0.0389276147,
-0.0065260069,
-0.026880946,
0.0326467119,
-0.0057323715,
0.0203951113,
-0.0020831167,
0.0278542768,
0.0626144782,
-0.0559626184,
-0.0183306932,
-0.000499711,
2.829e-7,
0.0433569886,
0.0173331238,
0.0224066172,
0.0564628839,
0.0021842911,
0.0565560758,
-0.0502981655,
0.0685315579,
0.0169061217,
-0.0054845451,
-0.0347854346,
0.0152256889,
0.0707525238,
0.0867997855,
-0.0648820326,
-0.003915119,
-0.0543942414,
0.0178757291,
-0.0664582029,
-0.0250024088,
0.0318012238,
0.0888490602,
0.0170499589,
-0.0085601509,
-0.0123583497,
-0.0457236804,
0.0060525746,
-0.0244987849,
-0.0211914685,
0.0022453552,
0.0006442544,
0.0173550677,
0.0204639342,
0.040532589,
-0.0373954624,
-0.0303893741,
-0.001096742,
0.0383761078,
0.0258649755,
-0.0336561799,
0.0019517539,
-0.0686793178,
-0.0199264884,
-0.0621226206,
0.0824031159,
0.0405630283,
-0.0000245971,
0.0075645577,
0.0073279198,
-0.0227296203,
0.0425078347,
-0.0611339398,
-0.011210911,
0.0352459252,
0.0235519297,
-0.0118837385,
0.0183883533,
-0.0520844981,
-0.0326954983,
-0.0090465518,
-0.0195904709,
-0.0335849114,
0.0130474688,
0.0396726504,
-0.0243094992,
-0.0104603833,
0.0208678022,
2.826698638e-34,
0.0137005206,
-0.0286037456,
0.0132922754,
0.0090595605,
0.0389225408,
-0.0009699556,
-0.0227523316,
0.0327231325,
-0.0127455359,
-0.0348011032,
-0.0355356745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11239v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11239v1 | Evading AI-Generated Content Detectors using Homoglyphs | 2024-06-17T06:07:32 | 2024-06-17T06:07:32 | Aldan Creo, Shushanta Pudasaini | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The generation of text that is increasingly human-like has been enabled by
the advent of large language models (LLMs). As the detection of AI-generated
content holds significant importance in the fight against issues such as
misinformation and academic cheating, numerous studies have been conducted to
develop reliable LLM detectors. While promising results have been demonstrated
by such detectors on test data, recent research has revealed that they can be
circumvented by employing different techniques. In this article,
homoglyph-based ($a \rightarrow {\alpha}$) attacks that can be used to
circumvent existing LLM detectors are presented. The efficacy of the attacks is
illustrated by analizing how homoglyphs shift the tokenization of the text, and
thus its token loglikelihoods. A comprehensive evaluation is conducted to
assess the effectiveness of homoglyphs on state-of-the-art LLM detectors,
including Binoculars, DetectGPT, OpenAI's detector, and watermarking
techniques, on five different datasets. A significant reduction in the
efficiency of all the studied configurations of detectors and datasets, down to
an accuracy of 0.5 (random guessing), is demonstrated by the proposed approach.
The results show that homoglyph-based attacks can effectively evade existing
LLM detectors, and the implications of these findings are discussed along with
possible defenses against such attacks. | [
0.0563767888,
0.0462478362,
-0.037185654,
0.0562211201,
-0.0605203956,
0.013565734,
0.0462863892,
0.0518992282,
0.0498110354,
-0.0496456251,
0.0065170415,
-0.027254425,
0.0224758945,
0.0596325919,
0.0425106585,
0.0175081454,
0.011751717,
-0.0469158553,
0.0210055206,
-0.01663596,
-0.003138144,
0.0159865972,
0.0377264097,
0.0570863634,
-0.0249415915,
-0.0143826399,
-0.0271515027,
0.0115983523,
-0.0141830398,
-0.0111144986,
-0.0132468306,
0.0453268103,
-0.0350911543,
0.1049736962,
0.000002051,
-0.0484902747,
-0.0348437317,
0.0301806759,
-0.0306260195,
0.0514819063,
0.0654578581,
-0.0478328466,
-0.0442739427,
0.0198089629,
-0.0273137335,
0.027779052,
0.0240619574,
0.0602602176,
0.0437142029,
0.0953136533,
-0.0279503278,
-0.0249634329,
0.0919547155,
-0.0072822352,
0.0028274835,
0.0172236189,
0.0555550009,
0.0023743005,
-0.0231987014,
0.0498341247,
0.0114444755,
0.0300766136,
0.0002005887,
-0.0288048051,
-0.052848421,
0.0111048929,
-0.0066376724,
-0.0109779043,
0.0051675746,
0.0221626796,
-0.0790904313,
-0.0469339751,
0.0441086553,
-0.0151727991,
0.0178603865,
0.0297288503,
0.0035311831,
0.0595102645,
-0.0071292762,
0.0130866757,
0.0425468981,
-0.0365471914,
0.0250032675,
0.0203106888,
-0.0272812303,
0.0063539175,
0.022793822,
-0.0297798645,
-0.0141789168,
-0.0328032635,
-0.0095797023,
-0.060763251,
0.0145494826,
0.0202714168,
0.0437020995,
0.0027445008,
-0.0916364789,
-0.0468658656,
0.0149449324,
-0.0567101389,
0.006333977,
0.0195776671,
-0.0140564842,
0.0299579073,
-0.0722028315,
0.0778954849,
-0.0628752634,
0.0443726704,
0.0253918972,
0.0024829046,
0.0106804427,
-0.0341088772,
-0.0425460041,
0.0284673907,
0.0100865057,
-0.0315173455,
-0.0226595867,
0.0448032655,
0.0021311082,
0.0448899418,
-0.0475124866,
-0.0392782055,
0.006789309,
0.0038847299,
0.0281110555,
-0.0239795614,
0.0291185752,
-0.0088770706,
-0.0093052583,
-0.0774369985,
0.0038450644,
0.0792397931,
0.012872383,
0.0154868318,
0.0074471575,
0.0759163573,
0.0124842664,
-0.0417886041,
-0.0021444492,
-0.0633454919,
-0.0422112197,
-0.005931546,
0.0269772615,
-0.0667997971,
-0.0280101132,
-0.0268639065,
-0.0050021876,
-0.0457147807,
0.0213308856,
0.0147210537,
-0.0381032638,
0.0400046743,
-0.041155085,
-0.0204753559,
0.035376206,
-0.0019429054,
-0.0260338783,
0.0577386096,
0.0327740051,
0.0907613561,
0.0619866364,
-0.0000828063,
0.0302698836,
0.0855917111,
0.01596223,
0.043690268,
0.0133391414,
-0.0473185144,
0.0025544376,
0.0017534345,
-0.0122858929,
0.0846881643,
0.0060459119,
-0.0433812737,
0.0686021745,
0.0980890393,
-0.0429810807,
-0.0035747059,
0.0099077625,
0.0307900496,
0.0358763225,
0.0382812731,
-0.0156523418,
-0.0407705046,
-0.0656064227,
-0.0362542383,
0.0077434834,
0.0095239067,
0.0125558106,
-0.0191130098,
-0.0175186191,
-0.0486690514,
0.0020785802,
-0.0323366486,
0.0414891243,
-0.0010155719,
-0.0320193134,
-0.0368241072,
0.0055210697,
-0.0190856457,
0.011131783,
-0.0870560184,
0.0332735591,
0.0421214662,
0.0744038373,
0.0161492266,
0.0628648847,
-0.0211947504,
-0.0238735564,
0.0615511201,
-0.028313892,
0.0336334445,
-0.0503974557,
-0.0321129039,
0.0135900043,
-0.0157425646,
0.0056050918,
-0.002592023,
0.0183436759,
0.0584804527,
0.0236778185,
0.0240212791,
-0.0413375311,
0.0251714233,
0.0039257235,
-0.0157515761,
-0.0201719534,
0.0171542242,
0.0263835136,
0.0030055821,
-0.0301645212,
0.0392180383,
0.0435532145,
-0.0390563272,
-0.0422092415,
-0.0126129668,
0.0314600393,
0.0257012714,
0.0392232276,
-0.059787143,
0.0147616034,
0.0338703729,
0.0258180425,
-0.0025242602,
0.0077999425,
-0.0711829439,
0.0605580322,
-0.0245237257,
0.0276622083,
-0.0212372802,
0.0518382229,
-0.0264909603,
0.0323592499,
-0.020301519,
-0.0010942742,
-0.0081648706,
0.0049746823,
0.0326383486,
-0.0140965991,
-0.0267061871,
0.0292974878,
-0.0010889095,
-0.0118380189,
-0.0033899294,
-0.0053458759,
0.0194341708,
-0.0533987731,
-0.0651973933,
-0.0213791765,
-0.0153396698,
-0.0043374202,
0.033219561,
-0.0383442454,
-0.0234599207,
0.0042216871,
-0.0444303453,
-0.0018870758,
0.0197189655,
0.0114487708,
0.0301451366,
-0.0318057351,
-0.0221182331,
0.0109761152,
-0.0023945102,
-0.0295078624,
0.0644937754,
0.0455138013,
-0.0679546967,
-0.0496742614,
0.038452439,
-0.0104833301,
0.0134199616,
-0.0259207785,
-0.0519344956,
0.0075174705,
-0.0392614976,
-0.0070124464,
0.0561173819,
0.0346144587,
0.0477084182,
0.0314305425,
0.0546618924,
-0.0265708361,
-0.0424380265,
0.0100562284,
0.0223568343,
-0.0336516015,
-0.0631818771,
0.0513255671,
-0.006216519,
0.0259277113,
0.0171114914,
-0.0336278118,
0.045645766,
-0.0258646216,
-0.0250402875,
0.0079207309,
-0.0439790301,
-0.0347833671,
0.0012335712,
-0.001055719,
-0.0685466528,
0.0323381014,
-0.0632296056,
0.0327482745,
0.0062810453,
-0.0073867254,
-0.0105128856,
0.0101386188,
0.003726491,
0.036843922,
0.0160842668,
-0.0175434668,
-0.0093546286,
0.041369956,
0.015331924,
-0.0349739268,
0.0086677186,
0.0019638313,
-0.0016753234,
0.0012191737,
0.01634074,
-0.03567468,
-0.0434692241,
-0.021024514,
-0.0195809174,
0.0594756752,
-0.0640612617,
-0.0052111456,
-0.0000579341,
0.0123715149,
0.0015325262,
-0.0368071795,
0.013087593,
-0.0153532699,
0.0819633678,
0.0406338088,
-0.0659073517,
0.0357232727,
-0.0354007035,
0.0109189767,
0.0983640403,
0.0045648445,
0.0151125966,
0.0060791285,
-0.037876498,
0.0247756671,
0.0252975412,
-0.0260820482,
-0.0019382951,
0.0048463605,
-0.0254729576,
0.0280295629,
0.0845858082,
0.0237495881,
-0.0379106812,
0.0040237508,
0.0058555515,
0.0084399935,
-0.0187632591,
-0.0470476225,
-0.122254923,
-0.0040537734,
0.0261410438,
0.0104870852,
-0.0397887379,
-0.0149869537,
0.0065398347,
-0.0921799242,
0.0095222406,
0.0383839458,
-0.0230115093,
-0.0337614305,
-0.0075129727,
-0.0153930495,
0.0374177508,
-0.0318619348,
-0.0515579581,
0.018062992,
0.0000136365,
0.0124414368,
-0.0378541537,
-0.0120203774,
-0.0262397286,
-0.0279357824,
0.0393656716,
0.0244745929,
0.0242562238,
-0.0374520756,
-0.0323679708,
0.0286763851,
-0.0003806725,
-0.0008200231,
-0.0029403337,
0.050777711,
-0.0174802337,
-0.0366760977,
-0.0087380009,
0.0263494793,
-0.030783603,
-0.0042152177,
0.0164816435,
0.0460080951,
-0.0171353538,
-0.0436196215,
-0.0163017809,
-0.0329304263,
0.0096377209,
0.0707339197,
-0.0109690707,
-0.0515869521,
-0.0522254333,
-0.0591196083,
0.0439473279,
-0.0137443561,
-0.0590839423,
0.005671056,
0.0285470262,
-0.0537386052,
-0.0700147673,
0.0015444288,
-0.0236783326,
0.0118669933,
0.0239053369,
0.0144526362,
0.0203822404,
0.0066422699,
-0.031531658,
-0.0546293408,
-0.0521812215,
0.0328015946,
-0.0765126571,
0.0177134201,
-0.0044070096,
-0.0355664603,
0.0038108034,
0.0330012627,
-0.0828149319,
-0.0599442013,
0.0300827175,
0.0048927064,
0.0208897907,
0.0051815752,
-0.0326052122,
-0.0461025499,
0.046676904,
0.0082309479,
-0.0212406646,
0.0347009562,
0.0375454873,
-0.0050619836,
-0.004558499,
0.0174808521,
-0.0285347402,
-0.0015345854,
0.023700403,
-0.0462601185,
-0.0440730378,
-0.0559161268,
0.0243759658,
0.0716434419,
-0.0164700951,
-0.0276838187,
0.0358939096,
0.0164455548,
0.0134344567,
-0.0356480815,
-0.0010780471,
-0.0058211274,
0.0088794827,
0.0088119004,
-0.0022243643,
0.0217825323,
0.0085916817,
-0.0078612389,
0.0008885222,
-0.0213374253,
0.0072819311,
-0.0177312382,
0.063595131,
0.0333165899,
-0.0032191805,
0.0081391297,
0.0498181954,
0.0052841506,
0.0196488872,
-0.010021152,
0.0248192474,
-0.0010456934,
-0.0372190364,
0.0149056027,
0.0344640091,
-0.0684080124,
-0.0225381348,
-0.0236526709,
0.0356460772,
0.0404870249,
0.0249212421,
-0.0025503554,
-0.0543018319,
-0.0013150596,
-0.0247614235,
-0.0055481396,
0.0032142776,
-0.0344900787,
-0.004367657,
-0.0050970009,
-0.0186847672,
0.0170013532,
0.0691063181,
0.047112029,
0.0475592129,
0.0250511356,
-0.0322503746,
-0.0157476775,
-0.0154976891,
0.0257463977,
0.0160693247,
-0.0315992907,
-0.0130563686,
-0.0449272729,
-0.0713396817,
0.0079924958,
-0.0124087622,
0.0339372754,
0.0071421475,
-0.0375900641,
0.0284543838,
-0.0032740009,
0.0107198777,
-0.0634037629,
0.0434682965,
-0.0009593879,
-0.0172201283,
0.0251584314,
-5.566200115e-33,
0.0303111356,
-0.0858033821,
-0.0572984889,
0.0022261997,
0.0328911953,
0.0276301075,
-0.0089910962,
-0.0154580781,
-0.014421328,
-0.0077609681,
0.0055380026,
0.0063674161,
-0.0004823935,
0.0063910829,
-0.0307435133,
-0.0124498382,
0.0165104233,
-0.0055553606,
-0.0142278401,
0.0206263773,
0.0576797612,
-0.0330464989,
-0.0095171537,
-0.0687530562,
0.0287655015,
-0.0390006565,
-0.0626322404,
-0.038842544,
-0.0623629391,
0.0709049702,
-0.0096528362,
0.045414865,
0.0243057534,
0.0535351261,
-0.005870468,
0.0483963676,
0.0059386366,
-0.0105190836,
0.0065027294,
0.0309136733,
0.0137037914,
-0.094335489,
0.0225531124,
-0.0376691148,
-0.0331788324,
0.0338453129,
0.0144053744,
-0.0173776299,
-0.0151088638,
-0.0143528273,
-0.0377953425,
0.0120530147,
-0.0087531479,
0.0409686193,
0.0129851103,
0.0058621448,
0.0520112924,
0.0057817441,
-0.0598824359,
0.0619920082,
0.0351411179,
-0.0244725309,
0.0040364787,
0.0044040526,
-0.0119334068,
0.0511393696,
0.0364085734,
0.0040582106,
-0.0207646806,
-0.0419806018,
0.0338489749,
-0.0127563979,
0.0708490238,
0.034903951,
0.0379197523,
-0.061529927,
-0.0451189019,
0.0146591179,
0.0131640378,
-0.0031447941,
0.0281317122,
-0.0219003316,
-0.0875120312,
0.0002412642,
-0.0085404981,
-0.0282484554,
-0.0195544064,
-0.0177124217,
0.0187477469,
0.0161040667,
-0.0591898486,
0.0271121357,
0.004790165,
-0.0765306652,
0.0128711481,
0.0352563523,
-0.0312488079,
0.0366175734,
-0.0006097847,
0.0303927772,
-0.0033295311,
-0.0179249812,
0.0488842204,
-0.0474515334,
0.0371592082,
0.0075300187,
0.0191048943,
0.023586357,
-0.0803862736,
-0.0123927388,
0.0062778094,
0.0172214732,
0.0566984117,
-0.0300158113,
0.0354881175,
-0.0342866443,
0.0075679659,
-0.0322196335,
0.0222269967,
0.0160719641,
-0.0465621911,
0.0310647599,
-0.0408794433,
0.003126231,
-0.0272298437,
0.0067504351,
-0.0149450153,
0.0504476391,
0.0469763726,
-0.0812743679,
-0.0104820458,
-0.0228538923,
2.726e-7,
0.0212857183,
0.0513139218,
0.0548737757,
-0.0030854191,
0.0494443178,
0.0402066745,
-0.0129414527,
0.0173405763,
-0.0179272443,
0.0123136519,
-0.0292926375,
-0.0059781112,
0.0446834639,
-0.0174857825,
-0.0658515245,
0.0398892872,
-0.0284567475,
-0.0226334073,
-0.0946401805,
0.0351473615,
0.0489149317,
0.0756530538,
0.0025213372,
-0.02368645,
-0.01585095,
-0.0533805639,
0.0298203062,
0.0129721221,
0.00037478,
-0.0137935448,
0.0079330262,
0.0194249302,
0.0016141939,
0.0471093059,
-0.0266128518,
-0.0147481365,
0.0311886109,
0.0438861884,
0.0147035923,
0.0330072753,
-0.0236337986,
-0.0607230216,
-0.0019865078,
-0.0614910424,
0.0848593563,
0.0650633946,
-0.0257706568,
-0.0559442602,
-0.0149682174,
-0.0562926792,
0.0107750408,
-0.0486690067,
-0.0191015583,
0.0196536705,
0.0127512561,
0.009267319,
0.0343306772,
-0.0483500436,
0.0090569668,
-0.0635773242,
-0.0206984524,
-0.0160340685,
-0.0500282757,
0.0327203572,
0.0454729721,
-0.0379968546,
0.0253868289,
2.903987392e-34,
0.0027045929,
-0.050894741,
-0.0026954287,
0.0305632409,
0.0226519741,
0.0120959645,
0.03758315,
0.0302873906,
0.0183043312,
-0.0489790216,
-0.0048931106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11238v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11238v1 | What Kinds of Tokens Benefit from Distant Text? An Analysis on Long Context Language Modeling | 2024-06-17T06:07:29 | 2024-06-17T06:07:29 | Yutong Hu, Quzhe Huang, Kangcheng Luo, Yansong Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | As the context length that large language models can handle continues to
increase, these models demonstrate an enhanced ability to utilize distant
information for tasks such as language modeling. This capability contrasts with
human reading and writing habits, where it is uncommon to remember and use
particularly distant information, except in cases of foreshadowing. In this
paper, we aim to explore which kinds of words benefit more from long contexts
in language models. By analyzing the changes in token probabilities with
increasing context length, we find that content words (e.g., nouns, adjectives)
and the initial tokens of words benefit the most. Frequent patterns in the
context (N-grams) also significantly impact predictions. Additionally, the
model's prior knowledge plays a crucial role in influencing predictions,
especially for rare tokens. We also observe that language models become more
confident with longer contexts, resulting in sharper probability distributions.
This overconfidence may contribute to the increasing probabilities of tokens
with distant contextual information. We hope that our analysis will help the
community better understand long-text language modeling and contribute to the
design of more reliable long-context models. | [
0.0524304062,
0.0232466478,
-0.0231292639,
0.0438102446,
-0.0711047351,
-0.0210418776,
0.0332631245,
0.0193981566,
-0.0476790145,
-0.0662682578,
0.0153552629,
-0.1003482714,
0.0442567728,
0.0547208935,
0.0495038219,
-0.0489966646,
0.020203812,
-0.051028382,
0.0023481695,
0.0082951216,
0.0104947696,
-0.0158751383,
0.0221836977,
0.0591891967,
-0.0519540533,
0.0050037052,
-0.0068141827,
-0.0075888326,
-0.0458169617,
-0.0239718612,
-0.0001760051,
0.052826643,
-0.0083232448,
0.0075499201,
0.000001712,
-0.0595192835,
-0.0036745691,
-0.0049980707,
0.0233273022,
0.0211332366,
0.0730561614,
0.0068365792,
0.008516972,
0.0085164309,
-0.0005899699,
0.0039308229,
0.0486094505,
0.058584854,
-0.0616284125,
0.0500387102,
-0.0148674967,
-0.0080876723,
0.0190712009,
-0.0317070037,
0.0462262481,
-0.0448058471,
0.0414555259,
-0.0362032019,
0.0010768578,
0.0006133318,
-0.0406494513,
0.0209841486,
0.0083702682,
0.0153315431,
0.0073747626,
0.0655268431,
0.0003665886,
-0.0082970532,
-0.0002623309,
0.0149956876,
-0.0012999024,
-0.044795569,
0.0096603017,
-0.0102390442,
-0.0134903565,
0.0045965966,
-0.0379690975,
0.0143615231,
-0.0018526152,
0.0191334244,
0.0629900545,
0.0156383272,
0.0229469128,
0.0400480367,
-0.0493701287,
0.0838309377,
0.0317835249,
-0.0383456759,
-0.0458825156,
-0.0127750318,
-0.0360117629,
-0.0858789757,
0.017761793,
0.0114961909,
0.0157606583,
0.0370617658,
-0.0260607731,
-0.0093807299,
0.0444715507,
-0.037857838,
-0.020845646,
0.0167476069,
-0.0319388583,
0.0373714045,
-0.0416061282,
0.0204619337,
0.0345410518,
-0.0356729589,
-0.0195707623,
-0.0108651128,
-0.0069060554,
-0.0156327635,
-0.0466048829,
0.0169590078,
-0.0477872677,
-0.0505283549,
-0.0599313863,
-0.0044552698,
0.0323280692,
-0.0489573404,
0.0151367253,
0.0300950371,
-0.0395525992,
-0.0088252667,
-0.021395795,
-0.0224521495,
-0.0431226753,
0.0458231755,
-0.0044860803,
-0.0324650928,
0.0003364014,
0.0067391507,
0.0060357344,
-0.0442598276,
-0.0241315402,
0.0716484413,
0.0183754936,
-0.0439319946,
-0.0106480969,
-0.03101434,
-0.0845571831,
-0.032465484,
-0.0287510864,
-0.084288545,
-0.0127364416,
0.0371706188,
0.0021316274,
-0.0366278999,
-0.0040600733,
0.000819319,
-0.0530471131,
0.0469548665,
0.0107322242,
0.0230863113,
0.021883348,
0.0085717067,
0.0097389407,
0.063588649,
0.0241431762,
0.0352071002,
0.0510889962,
0.000217188,
0.0217226073,
0.0398691148,
-0.0024200701,
0.0056444374,
-0.0508407056,
0.0038721324,
0.0259582605,
0.0072973319,
0.0275443457,
0.0644554645,
-0.0123635605,
0.0046413252,
0.0539780185,
0.0842677653,
0.0191301927,
0.0076833041,
0.0527214259,
-0.0091612907,
-0.0229514223,
0.0297505315,
-0.0508550704,
-0.0119073903,
0.0150542054,
0.0269989166,
0.0376857668,
0.0309891589,
-0.0010140191,
-0.0263800398,
-0.0458141305,
-0.0086382665,
0.0182819143,
-0.0380620249,
0.0491784588,
-0.0161716994,
-0.0385854952,
0.0437808186,
0.0353899412,
-0.0337959267,
0.0233243313,
-0.0445650481,
0.0351478904,
0.0612252913,
0.0148380538,
-0.0137320869,
0.0088956896,
0.0222583376,
0.0242396109,
0.0389658622,
0.0016715827,
0.0201198738,
0.0324724577,
-0.0051130173,
0.0071596699,
0.0088718198,
0.0423343778,
0.0343621783,
0.0430686772,
0.0382002592,
0.0200631972,
-0.042676542,
-0.0020225379,
0.0362603776,
-0.0419095717,
-0.0019016373,
-0.0217601582,
-0.0057767811,
0.0236712638,
-0.0093353596,
-0.003018948,
0.0484381206,
0.0112914862,
-0.0237134639,
-0.0218075067,
0.0156446006,
-0.0852079093,
0.0131910993,
0.0486361422,
0.0276422165,
0.0656929463,
-0.0555775538,
0.017530486,
-0.0285123978,
0.0220309272,
-0.029634811,
0.1011133194,
-0.0278070811,
0.0447099581,
-0.0272322632,
0.0187306143,
-0.0360108167,
0.0653249398,
-0.0109158847,
0.0483801179,
-0.0013097331,
0.022104159,
0.0032902739,
-0.024173731,
-0.0243341699,
-0.0064577027,
-0.0126779024,
-0.0132128671,
0.0407051817,
-0.0334693864,
-0.0379398875,
-0.045684699,
-0.1149548814,
-0.0159375425,
-0.002385631,
0.0015089132,
0.0004327298,
0.0032459756,
-0.0524079539,
0.0119730514,
-0.010271946,
-0.0268982202,
-0.0078551285,
0.0509816743,
0.0216379073,
0.0128116151,
-0.0407606959,
-0.0608697012,
-0.0095944786,
-0.0144445207,
0.0608919375,
-0.0011410938,
-0.0481868424,
-0.0477195159,
0.0631860197,
-0.0347978584,
0.0042460766,
-0.0190502852,
-0.051608175,
-0.0163176488,
-0.0205203071,
0.0973450467,
0.0252035186,
0.0261240359,
0.0193644427,
0.0278749857,
-0.0399039239,
-0.0113556013,
-0.0387998074,
-0.0325862616,
0.0039071916,
-0.037791986,
-0.0232840087,
-0.0273007657,
0.0786090493,
0.0381237008,
-0.0186260846,
-0.0213721916,
0.0277023856,
-0.0593006499,
-0.036264345,
0.0146494247,
-0.0250302013,
-0.0457795039,
0.0500941426,
-0.016575845,
-0.0623676702,
0.0697821006,
-0.0485825986,
0.0444694646,
-0.0248286892,
-0.0111530023,
-0.044743713,
0.0636667758,
0.0079659875,
0.0049697142,
-0.0199019108,
-0.0481462069,
-0.0296040643,
-0.0106547093,
-0.0086689154,
-0.0177299008,
0.0484700054,
-0.0158635974,
-0.0067580142,
0.0287508368,
-0.0216898359,
-0.0168640167,
-0.0624550693,
-0.0362718105,
-0.0011871664,
0.0470103137,
0.0038807611,
0.0112489602,
0.0483999439,
-0.0077795954,
0.03321198,
-0.0505441912,
0.0214828309,
-0.008402288,
0.0348803587,
0.0554513782,
-0.0539921746,
0.0094087264,
-0.0379179977,
0.0006140604,
0.0292329174,
0.0247650705,
0.011879853,
-0.0197215583,
-0.0245031938,
-0.0014365829,
-0.0278943181,
-0.0702043921,
0.0361117013,
0.0609401651,
-0.0614123195,
-0.0181555729,
0.1262415349,
0.0195970517,
-0.0305115264,
0.0421442464,
-0.0157242175,
0.052637931,
0.0023264727,
-0.005062684,
-0.0543201528,
-0.0318668596,
0.0244096983,
-0.0352323987,
-0.0210949481,
-0.0373560004,
-0.0043070428,
-0.0893373266,
-0.0136540961,
0.0028644204,
-0.0640718639,
-0.0063676136,
-0.037758749,
0.0043656696,
0.0141261863,
0.0117771458,
0.018677203,
-0.0321126953,
0.0178498887,
0.0233116876,
-0.0296985768,
-0.0329940617,
0.0198887419,
-0.0508518852,
0.0407461114,
0.0302891638,
0.0351446457,
-0.0232273769,
0.0150604285,
0.051856719,
-0.013855095,
0.0366925597,
0.0110296747,
0.0252040606,
-0.0067046201,
0.0272387806,
-0.0095978798,
0.0080794375,
-0.0043420736,
-0.038201984,
0.0234206375,
0.0467147902,
0.0030542267,
-0.0440641977,
-0.0345680639,
-0.0034603644,
0.0274782032,
0.0881499648,
0.0417683721,
-0.0423606336,
-0.0614559427,
-0.0099123856,
0.0123302704,
0.0060518892,
0.0287149791,
-0.0518855713,
-0.0178537946,
-0.016358206,
-0.0752304569,
-0.0396136791,
0.0383157171,
0.0432681255,
0.0259895027,
0.0532425605,
-0.0421844609,
0.0059874123,
-0.0294410009,
0.0112286769,
-0.0006307795,
0.027737394,
-0.0608959496,
0.0316023491,
0.0492743924,
-0.0329575576,
-0.0149674136,
0.0180928037,
-0.1119420528,
-0.0721524209,
0.035529267,
-0.0114349974,
0.0330842063,
0.0341090523,
0.0092446869,
-0.0618286282,
0.0588356592,
0.0250124447,
-0.0393440053,
0.0404021814,
0.0008400271,
0.0290280674,
0.0258016884,
0.0362404548,
-0.0392680615,
0.0264650118,
0.0183630232,
0.0348226428,
0.0007376943,
-0.0286611281,
-0.0216253065,
-0.0220570471,
0.0449431241,
-0.0461993068,
-0.029820988,
-0.02475572,
0.0032979439,
-0.0461940654,
0.0116749844,
0.0024124861,
0.0314012095,
0.0324299894,
0.0332522653,
-0.0243085343,
-0.0071964166,
-0.0251992419,
0.0501842983,
-0.0239242148,
-0.0077956286,
0.0023432628,
-0.0256728251,
0.0494167283,
0.0231335238,
-0.0291646123,
-0.0242941696,
-0.0434295274,
0.0168342236,
-0.0208442397,
0.030862296,
-0.0049022906,
-0.0258172452,
-0.0443121269,
0.0128721911,
-0.0716231912,
0.0287126619,
-0.0196441822,
0.0231288578,
0.0285878126,
-0.0541659594,
0.0296013169,
-0.03878529,
0.0094001051,
-0.0244756546,
0.0384165272,
0.0132323401,
-0.0322914496,
0.0241164099,
0.0233901814,
-0.0499193817,
0.0154769979,
0.1031843647,
0.0574680641,
0.0166232157,
0.0365271941,
-0.0227297619,
0.0133941798,
0.0184944104,
0.0068334471,
0.0570196658,
-0.0138191748,
0.0069984281,
-0.0862003118,
-0.061065048,
0.030853672,
-0.0253328215,
0.0022832917,
-0.0256839339,
0.0142755108,
0.0830447823,
0.0042645102,
0.0127653806,
-0.0389094763,
0.0161032435,
0.012749169,
-0.0089199115,
-0.0305730905,
-6.095491793e-33,
-0.0153426779,
-0.0354529358,
0.0012222826,
0.0058578555,
-0.0374771729,
0.0287332181,
-0.0319034681,
0.0176031888,
0.0263033323,
0.015370761,
-0.0354031362,
0.0139442831,
0.0178721845,
0.0231644288,
0.0087858224,
-0.0064596664,
0.0266964063,
0.0082397088,
0.0050241877,
0.0040225456,
0.0541004613,
0.0364853442,
0.0406207256,
-0.0250882469,
0.0362559669,
-0.0045627858,
-0.002795127,
0.0101068597,
0.033238437,
0.062965937,
-0.0458153486,
0.0351569355,
0.0497670099,
-0.0266129225,
-0.0339755304,
0.0354912281,
-0.0373952128,
-0.013962918,
0.0708252639,
-0.031765569,
0.0094100805,
-0.0455702841,
0.0363419354,
0.0063062767,
-0.0364299938,
-0.0017871797,
0.0461647436,
-0.0285042115,
-0.0446005799,
-0.0166134629,
-0.0675912797,
0.0321388394,
0.0204138141,
0.0125719523,
-0.0018214583,
-0.0305813476,
0.0165580157,
0.0225137211,
-0.0236693267,
0.0286691468,
0.0081060994,
0.0774009749,
0.0397080518,
0.0319819003,
0.01722393,
0.0743388012,
0.058890827,
0.0044205314,
-0.0308174826,
-0.0330251604,
0.0418134816,
0.0170251206,
0.0151798809,
0.0346559212,
0.0692278221,
-0.0460521691,
-0.0287378505,
-0.0330390558,
0.0132649075,
0.0071891025,
0.0764982179,
-0.0019132516,
-0.0628140941,
-0.0641110316,
-0.0424129479,
-0.0201778375,
-0.0227707867,
-0.035169553,
0.0377175324,
0.0164584424,
0.0106570069,
-0.0083894599,
0.0328994952,
-0.0218911283,
-0.0409626886,
0.0350384489,
-0.0101272762,
0.0128219584,
-0.0083365934,
0.0424238145,
-0.0437126718,
-0.0081544397,
-0.0076348768,
0.0080236346,
-0.0084514245,
-0.0099951364,
0.009230365,
0.0101454761,
-0.088931933,
-0.0091442959,
-0.0391200222,
-0.0270564072,
0.0140866442,
-0.0023420278,
0.0440597087,
0.0211377628,
-0.0093604261,
0.0655416325,
0.0303882025,
-0.0052780807,
0.0014584534,
-0.022465026,
-0.0070382995,
0.0222681835,
-0.0366307721,
-0.0280447677,
-0.0262371488,
0.0284394398,
0.056561172,
-0.0415284671,
-0.0212051123,
0.0189780463,
2.447e-7,
0.038820181,
0.0657779202,
0.0350361243,
-0.0407701321,
0.0476849079,
0.0021664628,
0.0099416543,
0.0119670695,
0.0052927458,
0.0126291374,
-0.0307904184,
-0.0071716313,
0.0171964597,
0.0084451586,
-0.0913511515,
0.0155238686,
-0.0904652923,
0.0147401225,
-0.0578451715,
0.0060052825,
0.021409465,
0.114755109,
0.0104702255,
0.0013635141,
-0.0457875803,
-0.0801053047,
0.0338736996,
-0.0509857908,
-0.0185989402,
0.028441174,
-0.0028052828,
0.0071191457,
0.046253074,
0.0005731793,
-0.0043107504,
0.0233459249,
0.038435664,
0.0408438183,
-0.0082454029,
-0.011251404,
0.0089314822,
-0.0264971834,
-0.0288425963,
-0.0670959353,
0.0787486807,
-0.0355512202,
-0.008940246,
-0.035875421,
-0.0070319311,
0.0014120904,
-0.0229685474,
-0.0028301426,
-0.0139904115,
0.0255749952,
0.008723706,
0.0042678774,
-0.0101390863,
-0.0685661137,
-0.0550728887,
0.0087875174,
-0.0344157331,
-0.0582245588,
-0.0251763593,
-0.0077230255,
0.0449772999,
-0.0857294053,
0.0048337397,
2.540449004e-34,
0.0545759723,
0.006421098,
-0.0161950607,
0.0061787977,
0.0346194915,
-0.0281504486,
0.0399850495,
0.0335294306,
0.0121964132,
-0.0680295527,
-0.0352202803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11234v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11234v1 | MiniConGTS: A Near Ultimate Minimalist Contrastive Grid Tagging Scheme for Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction | 2024-06-17T06:01:11 | 2024-06-17T06:01:11 | Qiao Sun, Liujia Yang, Minghao Ma, Nanyang Ye, Qinying Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction (ASTE) aims to co-extract the sentiment
triplets in a given corpus. Existing approaches within the
pretraining-finetuning paradigm tend to either meticulously craft complex
tagging schemes and classification heads, or incorporate external semantic
augmentation to enhance performance. In this study, we, for the first time,
re-evaluate the redundancy in tagging schemes and the internal enhancement in
pretrained representations. We propose a method to improve and utilize
pretrained representations by integrating a minimalist tagging scheme and a
novel token-level contrastive learning strategy. The proposed approach
demonstrates comparable or superior performance compared to state-of-the-art
techniques while featuring a more compact design and reduced computational
overhead. Additionally, we are the first to formally evaluate GPT-4's
performance in few-shot learning and Chain-of-Thought scenarios for this task.
The results demonstrate that the pretraining-finetuning paradigm remains highly
effective even in the era of large language models. | [
0.022043556,
0.0294537935,
0.0061269999,
0.0412437022,
-0.0407573432,
0.0345973223,
0.0062996405,
0.0077944268,
-0.0176698733,
-0.0483093448,
-0.068674095,
0.0026511669,
-0.0420705117,
0.0301153492,
-0.0108469706,
-0.0336957909,
0.0514057577,
0.0374772884,
0.0167336054,
-0.0057538962,
0.0207387693,
0.0211519599,
-0.0010163639,
-0.0076729632,
-0.0183148086,
-0.0142620327,
0.0237973928,
-0.0182820968,
0.031648837,
-0.0555476435,
0.0338275358,
0.0291116089,
-0.0125418883,
0.0296516903,
0.0000021679,
-0.0071952036,
-0.0546565428,
-0.0086850831,
0.0844445527,
-0.0037660399,
0.0607827343,
-0.0128868371,
0.0138008567,
-0.0134705417,
-0.0700604171,
-0.0559017621,
0.002333319,
0.1296829581,
0.0415783785,
0.058219526,
-0.0329093412,
-0.0490122922,
-0.0060937572,
-0.0166209936,
-0.0055944687,
-0.0218604673,
-0.0037482691,
-0.0090119382,
-0.017443141,
0.0709280893,
0.0031025223,
0.0032203286,
0.0117013017,
0.0498964898,
-0.0041746739,
0.0540059544,
0.0065654018,
0.0490495637,
-0.0212432109,
0.033604946,
0.0337254889,
-0.0029560491,
-0.0041344292,
-0.0315685384,
-0.0055152732,
-0.0611407571,
-0.0072292248,
-0.0325243361,
-0.0216605812,
0.0429960378,
0.0391183235,
0.0321941264,
-0.0155556686,
0.0208687186,
-0.0156358872,
0.041476056,
-0.00997697,
-0.0504746847,
0.0084923431,
0.0760718808,
0.0050187414,
-0.0151654929,
0.0018479223,
-0.0182424411,
0.0250064544,
0.0071131303,
-0.0178148039,
-0.0358250067,
0.01743095,
-0.0078537269,
0.0001644658,
0.0121571748,
-0.0239146706,
0.0528487228,
-0.0092427563,
-0.0307503752,
-0.0067231553,
0.0080859391,
-0.0397687815,
0.0317758135,
-0.0598475859,
0.0086564487,
-0.050933972,
0.0836641714,
-0.0374194197,
0.0094780643,
-0.0254308973,
-0.0241155885,
0.0055932608,
-0.0243305024,
0.0207598116,
-0.0111973453,
0.003542217,
0.001520517,
0.0015543242,
0.0574900024,
-0.0809281915,
0.0110314433,
-0.017920265,
-0.0185172781,
-0.0280792359,
0.0099384161,
-0.0016533913,
-0.0551276542,
0.0200160388,
0.0042050737,
0.0174937602,
-0.0851875097,
-0.0331631973,
-0.0082359156,
-0.041714225,
-0.0549134053,
0.0025649292,
-0.0597518086,
0.0127161434,
-0.0055498583,
0.0135486471,
-0.00501777,
-0.0148991877,
-0.0129527748,
-0.0174374133,
0.0742519721,
-0.0749625713,
-0.0666387528,
-0.0402649902,
0.0147055928,
0.0354769044,
0.054596711,
0.0171297248,
0.0496136956,
0.0154168438,
0.0113605997,
-0.0256882235,
-0.0069592334,
0.0118450234,
-0.006512058,
0.0101481574,
-0.0202987455,
-0.0195645299,
-0.0470766388,
0.030027533,
0.0469394587,
-0.0197700188,
-0.0100421263,
0.0400698259,
0.0027629724,
-0.00787389,
0.0824934095,
0.0406096689,
0.0055971141,
0.0037523075,
0.0430618785,
-0.0277028531,
0.0354200192,
0.0123514859,
0.0039752736,
0.0278679039,
0.0428935587,
-0.0220250953,
-0.0561652072,
0.0089576803,
-0.0221379902,
-0.0102781188,
-0.0251695234,
0.0640631691,
0.0192315467,
-0.0538473539,
-0.0306142662,
0.069744572,
-0.0446557961,
-0.0400697328,
-0.0354871191,
0.0088217454,
0.0674836189,
0.0038934366,
-0.0198084898,
-0.0401505418,
-0.0089197084,
-0.0284472387,
-0.00220657,
0.0601262413,
0.0130014466,
-0.0049353363,
-0.0368325002,
0.0020841323,
-0.0346422382,
0.0196187422,
0.0185150262,
0.0012303028,
0.0269314777,
-0.012693448,
-0.0056178677,
0.0420514271,
0.0039980686,
0.0350799523,
-0.0464616753,
0.0272927675,
-0.0128045641,
0.0097675379,
0.0683899671,
-0.0226335116,
-0.0229037702,
0.0252265371,
-0.0329860523,
-0.0116871223,
-0.0001438521,
-0.0682059601,
-0.0817496181,
0.0141137987,
0.0296250116,
-0.0178179145,
-0.0031022741,
-0.0503784418,
-0.0266563594,
0.0043672719,
0.0103376983,
0.0546243005,
-0.0429534353,
-0.017366223,
0.0424226783,
0.0016567108,
-0.0168221295,
0.0710322633,
-0.0083205467,
-0.0038168202,
-0.0692137927,
-0.0003169055,
0.0235635098,
0.0216351617,
-0.0337145291,
0.0090553341,
0.0112987477,
0.0015278917,
0.0110287275,
0.039262142,
-0.0505023338,
-0.0141178984,
-0.1060279757,
0.0080773057,
0.0095017087,
0.0438167602,
-0.0004052209,
-0.0084827766,
0.0105393743,
0.0229763109,
-0.0423139669,
0.0190805085,
-0.0377834365,
0.0152930422,
0.0199466199,
0.0274518635,
0.0247258805,
-0.0154259522,
-0.0012750325,
-0.0365880132,
0.0149568552,
-0.006851648,
-0.0504323393,
-0.0025139619,
0.0399054699,
-0.0151425079,
0.0139212217,
0.0156847592,
-0.0304937698,
0.0016642313,
-0.0435044281,
0.0158393048,
-0.0014607438,
-0.0167087968,
0.039501939,
0.0101505239,
-0.002621352,
-0.033760421,
0.0455173552,
-0.0489381142,
-0.0026175759,
0.0041427226,
0.0192137528,
-0.0038003766,
0.0709126517,
-0.0062560695,
0.0044503808,
-0.0673941597,
0.0327363499,
-0.0174243115,
0.0048692194,
0.0404121093,
0.0523618162,
-0.0064094127,
0.0025309157,
-0.0161219314,
0.0129260784,
0.0705461353,
0.0088768899,
0.0001847381,
-0.0684133247,
-0.0039986405,
-0.0247357804,
0.0749735609,
-0.0378559232,
-0.003734238,
0.0485946722,
0.0010461502,
-0.0053561884,
-0.062187966,
-0.0170894451,
-0.011069891,
0.045731999,
0.0196572449,
0.0134640513,
0.0007519607,
-0.0573886596,
0.0378353819,
-0.0453740507,
-0.0603808947,
0.0258696862,
-0.0034278387,
-0.0048551382,
0.0540569648,
-0.0004155937,
-0.0256417114,
0.0329106562,
-0.0384770818,
-0.0270442963,
0.0125046391,
0.074562341,
0.0333923697,
-0.0604729056,
0.0143459048,
-0.0027600313,
0.0177165922,
0.073349975,
-0.0104931677,
0.003149722,
-0.0381323434,
0.0085849538,
0.0269076303,
-0.0047686277,
-0.0070039826,
-0.0668556616,
0.0428214408,
-0.0697486624,
-0.0446699969,
0.1080383062,
0.0444007106,
-0.0636299178,
-0.0123012196,
0.0479178354,
0.0016442908,
0.0192246512,
-0.008088313,
-0.0608339123,
-0.0465159789,
-0.0271562561,
0.0213581137,
0.0138877658,
-0.0299534686,
-0.0075725913,
-0.0993244871,
0.0128396656,
-0.0191637855,
-0.0236996673,
-0.0408723503,
-0.0244420245,
-0.0092706392,
-0.0125213386,
-0.0388479903,
-0.0316259004,
-0.0034956913,
0.039468132,
-0.0171512663,
0.0177653152,
-0.0147075756,
0.0513607971,
-0.0025195375,
0.0154916495,
0.0365928821,
0.0247163102,
-0.0104787108,
-0.0367403999,
0.0501664765,
-0.0856360123,
0.0007096234,
-0.0602359325,
0.0673026145,
-0.0639884546,
-0.023849098,
0.0073692831,
-0.0323873982,
-0.0328527465,
-0.008239462,
-0.0133241564,
0.0530788675,
-0.014200368,
0.0070431582,
-0.0021555815,
0.0220847297,
0.0137526942,
0.0590685196,
0.0071838275,
-0.0557906926,
-0.0108115878,
0.014317506,
-0.007760074,
-0.0868726447,
-0.0324974842,
-0.0310306102,
-0.010831831,
-0.0321649611,
-0.0546941087,
-0.0712724179,
0.0179549512,
0.0455015488,
-0.0456591845,
0.0028850413,
-0.036927212,
0.0215268042,
-0.0568141229,
0.0122756604,
-0.003942789,
-0.0127957137,
0.0120573333,
-0.0274447892,
0.1161592603,
-0.0160688497,
-0.0268113799,
-0.0100445589,
-0.0382272713,
-0.0235614013,
-0.0073513538,
0.0662825555,
0.0049019712,
0.0106832897,
0.0054567456,
0.0289845262,
-0.0400812291,
0.0701528043,
-0.0118192844,
0.00285648,
0.0513400733,
0.0504960492,
0.0172595289,
0.0295076072,
0.0010519404,
0.0570392646,
0.0255548917,
0.015641382,
-0.0534701645,
0.0040648044,
0.028204646,
-0.010891106,
0.1046691537,
0.000008356,
0.0007501772,
-0.0177454241,
0.0065955794,
-0.0334106646,
-0.0143608497,
-0.0476379097,
-0.020382138,
-0.0042324145,
-0.0045104935,
-0.0819527134,
0.0584983192,
0.0076025883,
0.054429695,
-0.0268263556,
0.0199920982,
-0.014279183,
-0.0206035133,
-0.0492992923,
0.0039263158,
-0.033218801,
-0.0358689725,
0.0279988982,
-0.0160433315,
-0.0380994119,
0.0429006778,
0.037573196,
0.0011455215,
-0.0200138912,
0.0681500509,
-0.0288987029,
0.0360847265,
-0.0413220301,
-0.0209299326,
0.0035432358,
-0.0303697232,
0.0585513301,
-0.0271338951,
-0.0285437945,
0.0154467057,
0.0096408883,
-0.0169239808,
0.0199860241,
0.0098050945,
0.0190564003,
-0.0205868427,
-0.0245363638,
0.0329528004,
-0.1031162515,
0.0320638344,
0.0780570284,
-0.0080181537,
-0.0303093642,
0.0078146169,
-0.0217427649,
0.0200304855,
0.0319723226,
0.0200335141,
-0.0791010186,
-0.033121489,
0.011988448,
0.0041289935,
-0.0053742742,
0.024082737,
0.0453693047,
0.0464911833,
0.0335286409,
0.0091832103,
-0.0317794122,
-0.0418479331,
0.0213803574,
-0.0198004507,
-0.0030600845,
-6.8537132e-33,
-0.0330184996,
0.000900885,
-0.0004266611,
0.0153033761,
-0.0421612263,
0.0111018894,
-0.0150540974,
0.0043915589,
-0.01368823,
0.0315922275,
0.0078966301,
0.0077156699,
-0.0002097545,
0.0206654742,
0.0055298377,
0.0322145224,
0.0446604751,
-0.0145879528,
0.0133202858,
0.0393176898,
0.0123308776,
0.0426408313,
0.0939299166,
-0.0975939631,
-0.0081507778,
0.0131781427,
-0.0488143489,
-0.0033131898,
0.0292066876,
0.0447039157,
-0.0160634797,
0.016931273,
0.0449922457,
-0.042911943,
0.0167998187,
-0.014886668,
-0.0997467786,
-0.059438955,
0.0037697826,
-0.0202097371,
-0.001551315,
-0.044842042,
-0.0198928826,
-0.0019752644,
-0.0050114794,
-0.0354086347,
-0.0069436273,
-0.0190689862,
0.0245867521,
-0.0925861821,
-0.0440023728,
0.0420439653,
0.0281169675,
0.0031231986,
0.0635410696,
0.0029198234,
0.0304742977,
0.0570555404,
-0.0283254143,
0.0033328137,
0.0131382942,
0.0206558947,
-0.0216816664,
-0.0315354206,
0.0005559731,
0.0564222969,
0.0183156896,
0.0192687269,
0.0004326652,
0.0276176389,
0.0032243885,
0.003191096,
0.0149034206,
0.0455629118,
0.0531153195,
-0.0186394472,
-0.0345594436,
0.0161799304,
0.0083886897,
-0.0108596524,
0.0100664916,
0.0033150427,
-0.0417412966,
0.0189134143,
0.0375596695,
-0.0782229602,
-0.0364451706,
-0.0376667678,
0.0056997403,
0.0116294604,
-0.0269358698,
0.0573862605,
-0.002454849,
-0.0275898632,
0.0019316103,
0.0107950596,
-0.0401327685,
0.039263919,
-0.0013956481,
0.0174643006,
-0.0330431238,
-0.0388371684,
-0.0142088989,
0.0374156013,
0.0153215146,
-0.0106665269,
0.0996766612,
-0.008771657,
-0.1166790053,
-0.0075761965,
0.0030821853,
0.0329169445,
-0.0180626735,
0.031575419,
0.0121122831,
0.0388059169,
-0.0068383315,
0.1048136279,
0.0508470759,
0.0228033848,
-0.0196989086,
0.0126889301,
0.0170685705,
0.0241986867,
0.0367939472,
-0.0152077153,
0.0258561373,
0.0054724552,
-0.0071204966,
-0.0272261519,
-0.0347698256,
0.0327699929,
2.932e-7,
0.0404219739,
0.0304348879,
-0.0016578924,
-0.0062539736,
-0.0034999847,
0.0736840665,
0.0201359112,
0.0192427821,
-0.0138895987,
-0.0108096134,
0.0255601592,
0.0355614461,
0.0007187786,
0.0264436472,
-0.0668332875,
0.0751853287,
0.0115324091,
-0.0305056628,
-0.0311952811,
0.0107751768,
0.1379566938,
0.0775411353,
0.0300657395,
0.0027732817,
0.0068541961,
0.0047138622,
0.0418114923,
-0.0084273061,
-0.0117725534,
0.0105122393,
-0.0434305593,
0.0043838569,
-0.0513556637,
-0.0057075433,
-0.0189502742,
0.0084107323,
-0.0280260295,
0.0546190999,
0.0038507986,
-0.065119192,
0.0336222239,
0.0106944004,
0.0163548999,
-0.0222000703,
0.0726440921,
-0.0538584106,
-0.0251504593,
-0.0416125581,
-0.0365433544,
0.0359059572,
0.0199503861,
0.0061058155,
-0.0415583588,
0.0291504059,
-0.0217747465,
-0.0031051706,
-0.0666172579,
-0.0950104818,
0.02251238,
0.0615633838,
0.0220218189,
-0.0589573197,
0.017254347,
0.0019610852,
0.0008963594,
-0.0560153425,
-0.0066605685,
2.694366673e-34,
0.042828314,
-0.0467460603,
0.0338745825,
0.0467596948,
-0.010759118,
0.0075627877,
-0.0232330319,
-0.0384813882,
0.0231263526,
-0.0286245272,
0.0092512574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11233v1 | Probing the Decision Boundaries of In-context Learning in Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T06:00:24 | 2024-06-17T06:00:24 | Siyan Zhao, Tung Nguyen, Aditya Grover | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In-context learning is a key paradigm in large language models (LLMs) that
enables them to generalize to new tasks and domains by simply prompting these
models with a few exemplars without explicit parameter updates. Many attempts
have been made to understand in-context learning in LLMs as a function of model
scale, pretraining data, and other factors. In this work, we propose a new
mechanism to probe and understand in-context learning from the lens of decision
boundaries for in-context binary classification. Decision boundaries are
straightforward to visualize and provide important information about the
qualitative behavior of the inductive biases of standard classifiers. To our
surprise, we find that the decision boundaries learned by current LLMs in
simple binary classification tasks are often irregular and non-smooth,
regardless of linear separability in the underlying task. This paper
investigates the factors influencing these decision boundaries and explores
methods to enhance their generalizability. We assess various approaches,
including training-free and fine-tuning methods for LLMs, the impact of model
architecture, and the effectiveness of active prompting techniques for
smoothing decision boundaries in a data-efficient manner. Our findings provide
a deeper understanding of in-context learning dynamics and offer practical
improvements for enhancing robustness and generalizability of in-context
learning. | [
0.0133804427,
0.0237746164,
-0.0068141799,
0.0542946383,
-0.0280097034,
0.0362486877,
0.0008844303,
-0.0151804471,
0.0023439503,
-0.0765955299,
-0.0379496887,
-0.0719726011,
-0.0003649833,
0.0124520268,
0.0168192014,
-0.0308173373,
0.0311396103,
-0.0429635271,
0.0039911764,
-0.0131092928,
-0.031066414,
-0.0172961634,
0.0039473078,
0.0284678452,
-0.0067618787,
-0.0234868973,
-0.0033269294,
0.0085289441,
-0.0148305492,
-0.0194879938,
0.0347325429,
0.0355401412,
0.0501615331,
0.0736204162,
0.0000020011,
-0.0824353397,
-0.0084639741,
-0.0263592415,
-0.0464693159,
0.0040244348,
0.0286733862,
-0.0283250716,
-0.0224866029,
0.0184324272,
-0.033906199,
-0.023917906,
0.0639080256,
0.0352214873,
0.0104074022,
0.0785544887,
-0.0217419565,
-0.0169672929,
0.002328695,
-0.0437647812,
-0.0089232894,
-0.0370044,
0.0501217321,
-0.046768222,
-0.041163899,
-0.0169539154,
-0.0541012324,
-0.0023727999,
0.0079308497,
0.0351486951,
0.0022753736,
0.0465847962,
-0.0260240491,
-0.0257392321,
-0.0178485941,
0.0519532226,
-0.0373111889,
-0.0264575835,
-0.0221923534,
-0.0226019546,
0.0181351826,
0.0198557675,
-0.0393447094,
0.0244858768,
-0.0026600601,
0.0398066267,
0.0145775639,
0.0077672563,
0.0543803647,
0.0267754234,
-0.0674201921,
0.037955042,
-0.0001847946,
-0.0541910678,
0.0539783873,
0.0488425456,
-0.016110247,
-0.0289030652,
-0.0153753813,
0.0320802853,
-0.0504445769,
0.0298668295,
-0.0249285791,
0.0299046282,
0.0131177697,
-0.0252009481,
0.0442529358,
0.0111856917,
-0.034694124,
0.0558104888,
-0.0084397681,
0.0053166873,
-0.0091839302,
0.0255647451,
-0.0299658068,
0.0262147859,
-0.0107002864,
0.0009997353,
-0.0318748839,
-0.0224558059,
-0.011308087,
-0.0150192659,
-0.0367562026,
0.0338882171,
-0.0272811055,
0.0243706312,
0.0043725795,
-0.0198264737,
-0.0318693221,
0.0203740839,
0.0008591197,
0.0126014212,
-0.0181402862,
0.028485924,
-0.0043735779,
-0.0328387208,
-0.0187897049,
0.0058573345,
0.0148382522,
-0.036024332,
0.0112771727,
0.0558428168,
-0.0141014345,
-0.0542147532,
-0.0355484262,
0.0232615136,
-0.0136448527,
-0.0689556748,
0.0177102815,
-0.0236058887,
-0.0104841599,
0.0262899548,
0.0167328548,
-0.0032037415,
0.0027909279,
-0.0074469852,
-0.0037172046,
0.0929421782,
-0.0123115629,
0.0108728865,
0.040066734,
-0.0173575971,
0.009260973,
0.1043512151,
-0.0059299394,
-0.0011793831,
0.0436075665,
-0.0117950495,
0.0052993782,
0.0507522114,
0.0195304919,
0.017801214,
-0.0743018538,
-0.0099059194,
0.0478783213,
0.0268734973,
0.0330510102,
-0.0001828208,
-0.0289667919,
0.0054759607,
0.0563874952,
0.0404865369,
0.0321137235,
0.0162225384,
-0.0002027701,
0.0064440276,
0.0070935837,
0.0323872268,
-0.0631297305,
-0.052942168,
-0.0069072312,
0.0103443852,
0.0026000296,
0.0299396962,
-0.014400796,
-0.0334335193,
-0.0093667619,
0.0005546242,
0.0188122168,
0.0418360941,
0.0813301653,
0.0200814195,
-0.0206983201,
0.0308377817,
0.0478535183,
-0.0128029194,
-0.0049840081,
-0.0522115268,
0.0230753552,
0.0153794698,
0.0078852335,
-0.0744578764,
0.0103113689,
-0.0156140961,
0.0757885128,
0.0067579262,
0.0395249426,
-0.0306726806,
0.0153574226,
-0.0579999946,
-0.0320422091,
0.0026130315,
0.0332331322,
-0.0194007177,
0.0298101455,
-0.0020437625,
-0.0001106475,
-0.0220395047,
-0.0096111754,
0.0550493151,
0.0049001086,
-0.0364713222,
0.0153242555,
0.037213508,
0.0269235875,
-0.0069819493,
-0.0177335292,
-0.0183540508,
0.0315112919,
-0.0334493108,
0.0218613036,
0.0086574918,
-0.0437891819,
-0.0270246975,
0.0433897711,
0.0291349664,
-0.0122441296,
-0.0214571878,
-0.0388856009,
-0.0222738404,
-0.0109563405,
-0.0217940956,
0.0668763518,
-0.0355694182,
0.0285306033,
-0.0399562679,
0.0304714087,
-0.0664424896,
0.0793370306,
0.0205172487,
-0.0024854694,
0.0248520691,
0.015978599,
-0.0050138277,
-0.0038798407,
-0.009431622,
0.0292185005,
-0.0110737979,
0.0300028231,
-0.0199475996,
-0.01284217,
-0.0399682336,
-0.0099444343,
-0.1034850404,
-0.0244133528,
-0.0514861047,
-0.0121037634,
0.0004847481,
-0.0073420792,
-0.0200476684,
-0.0369297713,
-0.0058525489,
-0.0174280405,
-0.0202458818,
0.0512542203,
0.0183955934,
0.00527253,
-0.0142388586,
-0.0192980841,
-0.025769271,
-0.001805483,
0.0764332488,
-0.0160156973,
-0.008071295,
-0.0947089121,
0.0202246942,
0.0252116434,
0.0417842418,
-0.0242151953,
0.0341274478,
0.0165241677,
-0.0388939939,
0.0365547575,
0.1055931821,
0.0156015046,
0.091135703,
0.0814655349,
0.0012159699,
-0.0462095588,
0.010128282,
-0.0115374085,
-0.0088977525,
-0.0197046418,
0.0302958861,
0.0048699984,
0.079653576,
-0.0344808362,
-0.0155878635,
-0.0218664221,
-0.0005004157,
-0.0284722522,
-0.0149695687,
-0.0812383294,
0.0140243201,
-0.0405039005,
0.0580512322,
-0.0038440477,
-0.0899337009,
0.0414983034,
0.0075712185,
0.0042338264,
-0.0460187048,
-0.0368190557,
-0.0405772664,
0.0610686615,
-0.0029098496,
0.0024484147,
0.0175426994,
-0.0428611226,
-0.0724756271,
0.0011727321,
0.001190659,
-0.0208226796,
0.0866295174,
-0.0419549458,
0.0153399538,
-0.0195093099,
-0.025550399,
-0.0538136475,
-0.0147040188,
-0.0299060158,
-0.0047675734,
-0.0216985121,
-0.006719206,
0.0147453919,
0.0226543713,
-0.0255429205,
0.0652186349,
-0.007922993,
-0.00234026,
-0.019157324,
0.034198124,
0.0375885218,
0.0284335278,
0.0096533289,
-0.0500949919,
0.0098225186,
0.0191342067,
0.0229877308,
-0.0024717099,
-0.0312098563,
0.0267209578,
0.0596308075,
-0.0358350165,
-0.0102442969,
0.0296560656,
0.0536554828,
-0.0685860813,
-0.0276306458,
0.0988477841,
0.0256966483,
-0.0861387774,
0.003057159,
-0.0114202267,
-0.0004905878,
0.0468417369,
0.0134631749,
-0.0498314425,
-0.0417737365,
0.0132257268,
-0.0213043559,
-0.0036409269,
0.0039385222,
0.0012322256,
-0.1142052561,
0.0452589802,
0.0129490653,
-0.0458203368,
-0.015611426,
-0.0303213615,
0.013333872,
-0.0059980103,
0.0303741526,
-0.0161764957,
-0.0418673679,
-0.0308568794,
0.0239537489,
0.0188508946,
-0.0871653184,
-0.0051684403,
-0.0650240704,
0.025399683,
0.0437939949,
0.0164144896,
-0.0138229029,
0.0072731348,
0.0870283395,
-0.0175306275,
0.0155515019,
-0.0251718275,
0.0383784212,
0.0098704761,
0.0027124803,
0.0197143685,
0.0187582467,
-0.0041489634,
-0.0306544695,
0.0234948453,
0.0904923603,
-0.0208510999,
-0.0290176459,
0.0033449735,
-0.020848535,
0.0498170815,
0.0580491051,
0.0191855747,
-0.0771598667,
-0.0382563956,
-0.0275450181,
0.0193813629,
0.0420263261,
-0.0044641593,
0.013028115,
-0.029112462,
-0.0524524748,
-0.0358723737,
0.0138230985,
0.0405703485,
0.0342405997,
0.0199463721,
0.0175321512,
-0.0023618955,
0.0189998597,
-0.0432853289,
0.043194633,
-0.0347898602,
0.0347223692,
-0.0367843844,
-0.0083760032,
0.0385275409,
-0.0326381512,
-0.013624602,
0.043251738,
-0.0546344258,
-0.0813964382,
0.0075602918,
-0.0099003548,
0.0266110767,
0.0763724148,
0.003758332,
-0.0746197924,
0.0815686211,
0.0194311608,
0.0274877101,
0.0090203239,
0.0380621403,
0.008747655,
-0.0325302444,
0.0273213834,
-0.0358500071,
-0.0064770202,
0.0361442007,
0.0084741591,
-0.0690788627,
-0.0062367143,
0.0089789238,
-0.0701106265,
0.0738120526,
-0.0228428207,
-0.041643966,
-0.0447703898,
0.0255249236,
0.0249499008,
-0.016835738,
-0.0211535301,
-0.035178218,
0.0380293131,
0.0057590348,
-0.0111283101,
0.0083681764,
0.0098398784,
0.0298779756,
-0.0430859998,
-0.0048349421,
-0.0076213344,
0.0465977192,
0.0600579642,
0.0197388716,
-0.0176560357,
0.0250387453,
0.022877356,
0.0174567606,
0.0038018029,
0.0641032085,
0.0304820947,
0.0169093721,
-0.0475298725,
0.0060793059,
-0.0669097379,
-0.0061868797,
-0.0304960888,
0.0344886631,
0.0653943121,
-0.0498447642,
-0.0024424961,
-0.0027725659,
-0.0455373153,
-0.0123575302,
0.0084401667,
0.0022204157,
-0.0371283814,
0.0447340757,
0.0260409079,
-0.0321053863,
0.0421347134,
0.0622848049,
0.0337640941,
0.0479019918,
-0.0092386231,
0.0042716675,
-0.0308770742,
-0.0201319847,
0.0633465499,
0.0117409984,
-0.0256610401,
0.0079615852,
-0.0644764379,
-0.0628235787,
0.0070166844,
-0.0443333983,
-0.0017492069,
-0.0381205268,
0.0093514472,
0.0813102201,
-0.0068842908,
-0.0069025559,
-0.0273694918,
0.000176759,
0.0097834188,
-0.0023473278,
-0.0590573885,
-6.473415064e-33,
0.0120482063,
0.0063896305,
-0.0028597491,
-0.0133028934,
-0.0078004133,
0.0008536752,
0.0052864533,
0.005513798,
-0.0179293063,
0.0109656993,
-0.025146693,
0.0005265864,
0.0271371976,
0.0153886182,
0.0033007758,
-0.0520371534,
0.0628095865,
-0.0104394518,
-0.0093084211,
0.019465236,
0.0064807143,
0.0279528499,
0.0383348688,
-0.0660328344,
0.0149170496,
0.0160722677,
-0.0188878197,
0.0358796604,
-0.0224604998,
0.029882554,
-0.0204167254,
0.0625405833,
0.0373349637,
-0.0335773937,
-0.0084513314,
0.0539365858,
-0.0598057061,
-0.0084135262,
-0.0147569291,
0.0336886235,
0.0174231566,
-0.0374096073,
0.0563959368,
0.0043021734,
-0.0176426116,
-0.0396750569,
0.0211464688,
-0.0274179578,
-0.063141413,
-0.0635709539,
-0.0777922571,
0.0215560365,
0.0089293038,
-0.0237641726,
0.0231271554,
0.0173913296,
0.0148771321,
0.0041436106,
-0.0427003615,
0.0281239748,
0.0487925448,
0.0154710729,
0.0242512077,
0.059483923,
-0.0067627435,
0.047630243,
0.0099207964,
0.0243696794,
0.0212006476,
-0.0480208956,
0.0528940372,
0.0242339335,
-0.0026927881,
0.0193042811,
0.0735253319,
-0.0159497708,
-0.0710121393,
-0.0163866747,
0.0321722552,
-0.005622338,
0.0294265002,
0.017833462,
-0.0454703718,
-0.0519323908,
-0.0291865207,
-0.027379483,
-0.0421365537,
0.0042249328,
0.0360147916,
0.0253608115,
-0.0061847758,
0.0217317995,
0.0072454703,
-0.0481927954,
-0.0283540282,
-0.0032716694,
-0.0021016202,
0.019431442,
0.0141066071,
-0.0162220765,
-0.0389351174,
-0.0640437454,
-0.0131545579,
-0.0133665754,
0.0173138753,
-0.0037038357,
0.0543615781,
0.0114701241,
-0.0622691326,
-0.0109573612,
-0.0212649908,
0.006865032,
0.0252375118,
0.0928527564,
0.0543048084,
-0.0002472249,
0.0088688806,
0.0648711622,
0.0312660411,
-0.0142751392,
-0.0181808192,
-0.0006137687,
-0.026636783,
0.027508961,
-0.0182535797,
-0.0196048114,
-0.0170492772,
-0.0204008296,
0.0684875622,
-0.0662746951,
-0.0164914634,
-0.0188065656,
2.724e-7,
0.0284565371,
0.0632089674,
-0.0125617804,
-0.0006479151,
0.0306329988,
0.0357544236,
-0.0234793592,
0.0003860834,
0.0229109507,
-0.0099387923,
0.0112831295,
0.0142219048,
0.0585771985,
0.0293312948,
-0.1028758511,
-0.0223604236,
-0.0414596573,
0.0345373116,
-0.0505309775,
0.0121537941,
0.0039532608,
0.100158453,
-0.0091491621,
-0.0372315459,
0.0073191957,
-0.0502233207,
0.0690030158,
-0.062041387,
0.0591230206,
0.0186699796,
-0.019901678,
0.0055217794,
-0.0029609066,
0.0364545472,
-0.0168389603,
0.0473387279,
-0.0104527362,
0.0618019663,
0.0038765725,
0.0222199429,
-0.0223104097,
0.0017591091,
0.0069121839,
-0.0656145513,
0.0752579793,
-0.1004746258,
-0.0103730289,
-0.065620482,
0.0516967177,
-0.0579811148,
0.0296420492,
-0.031165434,
0.0041799271,
0.0023696222,
0.0116648274,
-0.0144982301,
-0.0105709974,
-0.0974024385,
-0.0358579084,
0.0218223315,
-0.0473434031,
-0.0406125896,
-0.0259890147,
0.016983496,
0.0317838714,
-0.0619664416,
0.0375464037,
2.670823036e-34,
0.0381831788,
-0.0170017146,
0.0278834328,
0.0439931825,
0.0096426671,
-0.0182043388,
-0.0168839097,
0.0273154657,
0.0428204089,
-0.0549241789,
0.0268505141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11231v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11231v1 | Enabling robots to follow abstract instructions and complete complex dynamic tasks | 2024-06-17T05:55:35 | 2024-06-17T05:55:35 | Ruaridh Mon-Williams, Gen Li, Ran Long, Wenqian Du, Chris Lucas | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Completing complex tasks in unpredictable settings like home kitchens
challenges robotic systems. These challenges include interpreting high-level
human commands, such as "make me a hot beverage" and performing actions like
pouring a precise amount of water into a moving mug. To address these
challenges, we present a novel framework that combines Large Language Models
(LLMs), a curated Knowledge Base, and Integrated Force and Visual Feedback
(IFVF). Our approach interprets abstract instructions, performs long-horizon
tasks, and handles various uncertainties. It utilises GPT-4 to analyse the
user's query and surroundings, then generates code that accesses a curated
database of functions during execution. It translates abstract instructions
into actionable steps. Each step involves generating custom code by employing
retrieval-augmented generalisation to pull IFVF-relevant examples from the
Knowledge Base. IFVF allows the robot to respond to noise and disturbances
during execution. We use coffee making and plate decoration to demonstrate our
approach, including components ranging from pouring to drawer opening, each
benefiting from distinct feedback types and methods. This novel advancement
marks significant progress toward a scalable, efficient robotic framework for
completing complex tasks in uncertain environments. Our findings are
illustrated in an accompanying video and supported by an open-source GitHub
repository (released upon paper acceptance). | [
0.0062583475,
0.0479413942,
-0.0053102323,
-0.0110467719,
-0.0336907059,
0.0019689933,
-0.0429853164,
0.0080812257,
0.0214622207,
-0.0284489244,
-0.0049781282,
-0.0266491268,
-0.0300431028,
0.032941822,
-0.0006953503,
-0.0468068235,
0.0374438316,
-0.0333903469,
0.0136318672,
0.007107887,
-0.0206585061,
-0.0073085348,
-0.0208570324,
0.0548903383,
-0.0282962453,
-0.009136294,
-0.0540711544,
0.0012151845,
0.0098917633,
-0.0150183635,
-0.0191512089,
0.0726305321,
0.0394265316,
0.0676742941,
0.0000020792,
-0.0361298658,
0.0094497083,
0.0043712892,
-0.0014422343,
-0.0669556111,
-0.0107244635,
-0.0391447581,
-0.0055781868,
0.0070185969,
-0.0314935669,
-0.0401229598,
0.0450438336,
0.0372237042,
-0.0142325722,
0.0130230123,
0.0119332857,
-0.0620714389,
-0.006785173,
0.0181609374,
0.0411511511,
-0.0226034373,
0.0205106772,
0.0314851664,
0.0857548341,
0.0146988118,
-0.0071963063,
0.0212547686,
0.0344269685,
-0.0219803955,
-0.0307391565,
0.038021341,
-0.0486667305,
-0.0190230906,
-0.0038567202,
0.0217485391,
-0.0104417987,
0.0035713199,
0.0145203779,
0.0042185555,
-0.0051206076,
0.0160794966,
-0.0448727347,
-0.0109029543,
-0.0052036163,
-0.0138957696,
-0.0951507837,
-0.0260316301,
0.0173905157,
0.0001441553,
0.0205856394,
0.1118469387,
-0.0045458339,
-0.0038141403,
0.0193677209,
-0.0023046166,
0.0009627623,
-0.0309444256,
0.0064372658,
0.0608751103,
-0.0385811999,
0.0271384194,
-0.0358737111,
0.0544375964,
-0.018524915,
-0.0178670753,
-0.0230254177,
0.0582942739,
-0.0279082488,
0.0213953517,
-0.0217327699,
0.0625442043,
-0.0811329484,
0.0302805435,
-0.0668380857,
0.0255259443,
-0.0968038291,
-0.024654353,
-0.0291138403,
0.0071730907,
-0.0616370291,
-0.0255266242,
-0.0050263731,
0.0466374978,
-0.0305129159,
0.0168735795,
-0.0092242956,
0.038765654,
-0.0133709516,
-0.0117425444,
-0.0499540865,
-0.0043705995,
-0.0085752271,
0.0369224623,
-0.0016516626,
0.0056562289,
-0.0053550298,
-0.0012363157,
-0.0149959503,
0.0223801658,
-0.0107878158,
0.0800054222,
-0.0293123256,
0.0122594554,
0.0018670203,
-0.0325467959,
0.0168876052,
-0.0611409284,
0.0306741353,
-0.0495964698,
0.0050409129,
-0.0157146696,
-0.0066302111,
0.0092570009,
0.0247284025,
0.001026405,
0.0049785455,
0.076485306,
0.0363240354,
0.0150333503,
0.015989054,
0.0166206416,
-0.029778963,
0.0256001242,
0.0232056715,
0.0413357578,
-0.0166364778,
0.0165243726,
0.0603406355,
0.0182183497,
-0.0702802241,
-0.0045394949,
0.0014280942,
-0.0041282042,
-0.0065001673,
0.0324311964,
-0.0123102143,
0.015746139,
-0.0005197147,
0.0714513734,
0.059475746,
0.0349128656,
-0.0607193001,
0.0164732467,
0.0316438004,
-0.0024851905,
-0.0147984419,
-0.0108110541,
-0.0276345797,
0.0160021018,
-0.0653060228,
0.0055547482,
-0.0561344698,
-0.0362142958,
-0.0254304409,
-0.0142811649,
-0.0006258184,
0.021812791,
0.0827635154,
0.0101931114,
0.0839446709,
-0.0077598048,
-0.0430732481,
-0.0234750099,
-0.0469662435,
-0.0253878552,
-0.0384445079,
-0.0486303903,
0.0381460115,
0.1234987676,
-0.0118971914,
-0.0610934384,
-0.0158729814,
0.0119308811,
0.0143787563,
-0.0096532768,
-0.0084270937,
-0.0137351733,
0.0053658709,
0.0284100492,
-0.0375104807,
0.0056350357,
0.0360994823,
0.0628632978,
0.007695185,
-0.0095713045,
0.0075860908,
0.0195692685,
-0.0095154271,
0.0119315013,
0.0565638728,
-0.028974114,
0.0031737133,
0.0212227907,
0.0061974064,
0.0294705704,
0.0005587439,
-0.0062967427,
0.0381180868,
-0.002113421,
-0.01950977,
0.0635978207,
-0.0039322451,
0.029697476,
0.0152548114,
0.013988819,
-0.0393074714,
-0.0039286572,
-0.0229256563,
-0.035567876,
0.0197495073,
0.0085134357,
0.0491978079,
0.0115897181,
-0.0069887391,
0.0028230236,
-0.0550836585,
-0.015673168,
0.0453794263,
-0.0213955641,
0.0092880558,
-0.0124992309,
0.0514522307,
-0.010810188,
-0.0155715309,
-0.0071424735,
-0.0004454622,
0.0168472677,
0.0625175759,
0.0312909558,
0.0670805871,
-0.0167478789,
-0.0118542332,
-0.1033432186,
-0.0196775924,
-0.010105703,
-0.045128081,
0.0005355417,
0.0208441895,
-0.0084043546,
-0.0250444803,
0.0599308871,
0.0501561761,
-0.0277927034,
0.0132596912,
0.0083717359,
0.0551456064,
-0.0465624258,
-0.0180658139,
0.0105099818,
-0.0085273143,
-0.0330378264,
0.016445484,
0.0110807428,
-0.049927257,
0.0229929965,
0.0078583239,
0.0582753234,
-0.0222687405,
-0.0231245719,
0.0396696962,
-0.047482349,
0.0051348717,
0.0565138236,
-0.0918248221,
0.0095500313,
0.062082801,
-0.0479652397,
-0.0330298394,
0.0225908384,
-0.035681136,
-0.0455174856,
-0.0018972815,
0.0169672575,
0.0081013488,
0.0122079011,
-0.0043762643,
0.0129386475,
-0.0626574382,
-0.0355036743,
-0.0219875835,
-0.0527076125,
-0.0628671795,
0.0117905503,
-0.0627686158,
0.0584809035,
-0.0075898627,
-0.0498394109,
0.0286755972,
-0.0035960283,
0.025591664,
0.0461710393,
-0.0285816211,
0.0076805507,
0.1292644739,
0.0276194327,
-0.0089993011,
0.0299008638,
-0.0192482453,
-0.0143867601,
0.0556301288,
-0.0147024924,
-0.0241733007,
0.058283776,
-0.1376291066,
0.0099519258,
0.018622363,
-0.0560772829,
-0.0221351497,
0.026326295,
-0.0092857666,
0.0170782935,
-0.0290921964,
-0.0464634709,
-0.0297020525,
0.0121390438,
0.0283923764,
0.0447893217,
-0.0141058993,
-0.0156871937,
-0.0485320427,
-0.026639875,
0.036693465,
0.0255812537,
-0.0884188414,
0.0041230517,
-0.0525449142,
0.0180330742,
0.0668743178,
-0.0309425388,
-0.0669046491,
0.0343003459,
0.0466800742,
0.0328391492,
-0.0007044166,
0.0153548922,
0.0520032458,
-0.0576036945,
-0.0331692286,
0.0634869263,
-0.0038742477,
-0.0161199998,
-0.0067108846,
-0.0107819811,
-0.003334831,
0.0251171291,
0.0518465862,
-0.0621850081,
-0.0232482441,
0.0218671057,
0.0091000646,
-0.013072921,
-0.0274409764,
-0.0077123651,
-0.1126112193,
0.0719682351,
0.0121067818,
-0.0732718557,
-0.1107300222,
0.0070232395,
0.0227215067,
-0.0250764973,
0.0021958449,
0.0260709692,
0.018097939,
-0.0068808109,
0.0124160321,
0.0184959248,
-0.0593518317,
0.0019506192,
-0.0194790121,
-0.0192373842,
0.0791080371,
0.0030833834,
-0.0075187981,
0.0271774624,
0.0192690101,
0.0400114171,
0.0133563969,
-0.0247120541,
-0.0445555449,
0.006538006,
0.0036688515,
0.0005204759,
0.0295248535,
-0.0252315402,
-0.051706031,
0.001777551,
0.0753902644,
-0.0193042606,
-0.0071063139,
-0.0266807955,
-0.0756666586,
0.0589219481,
0.0400805511,
-0.0319494084,
-0.0038799939,
-0.0488292687,
-0.0688911825,
-0.0633290559,
0.0235713236,
-0.0086557344,
-0.0070285094,
-0.04364397,
-0.0353567787,
-0.0179137178,
-0.0069655525,
0.0637748539,
0.037747249,
0.0072099483,
-0.0394235514,
0.0225146282,
0.0633589923,
-0.0232902169,
-0.005608432,
-0.0210528765,
0.019749945,
-0.0058766007,
-0.0156517886,
0.0422169119,
-0.0307562239,
-0.0175632499,
0.0322292149,
-0.0076060635,
-0.0434344299,
0.0135653075,
0.1200617254,
0.026614178,
0.0327616185,
-0.0170336906,
-0.0059833219,
0.0182090048,
0.0114402436,
-0.0482205041,
0.023406947,
-0.008746204,
0.0191681236,
0.0180861577,
0.0065845768,
-0.0914318189,
0.0052818288,
-0.0457031913,
0.023700662,
-0.0386197306,
-0.0128067257,
0.0462725759,
-0.0342788659,
0.0355253853,
0.0025723241,
-0.0076180683,
-0.0328915641,
0.0284964815,
0.0040130732,
-0.0284314975,
-0.0677193552,
0.0455014519,
0.0275713336,
-0.0307074282,
0.0252609663,
-0.014983098,
0.0120155346,
0.0360031277,
-0.0472144112,
-0.0391856991,
-0.0190328695,
0.0510929562,
0.0609821901,
0.0331374705,
-0.0028355669,
0.042063307,
-0.0348742679,
0.0338939019,
0.02307068,
0.0355110243,
0.0106381653,
-0.0013883115,
-0.0558242798,
0.0165351927,
-0.0599601045,
-0.0936015844,
0.0045697689,
0.0208952315,
0.0628450066,
-0.0423079208,
0.031106839,
-0.0884015113,
-0.0040254514,
-0.0398984626,
0.0314380527,
0.0408062413,
0.0176850557,
0.0018189766,
0.0378225558,
0.0264723673,
-0.0168022029,
0.0505820885,
-0.0602800436,
0.0349823274,
0.0022161824,
-0.0377171598,
-0.0438322574,
-0.0306949411,
0.0514460877,
0.0144134499,
-0.0077477796,
-0.0439851023,
-0.0328010991,
-0.0110584358,
-0.0676582605,
0.0419521518,
0.0079325605,
-0.0187197998,
0.0678576976,
0.041213531,
-0.035954304,
-0.0590895936,
-0.0143181132,
-0.0369279422,
-0.0071821972,
0.01980808,
-0.0382896513,
-5.800611689e-33,
-0.0232032612,
-0.0394701995,
0.0274693128,
0.0010031452,
0.0018310855,
-0.0454144105,
-0.0024009643,
-0.0055269408,
0.0477594137,
0.0263121724,
0.0223788023,
-0.0072684712,
0.0027548124,
-0.0049925046,
0.0854893103,
-0.0429476313,
0.038847439,
0.0010280616,
-0.0064154691,
0.0075988509,
0.0392801538,
0.0213175509,
-0.0112824459,
-0.0556159988,
0.0243943781,
0.0145357912,
-0.0157218017,
0.0390516557,
-0.0128914565,
-0.0023597404,
-0.0238820706,
0.0376313105,
-0.0116339102,
-0.0070873592,
-0.0250899233,
0.0471356325,
-0.0411552154,
-0.0241266116,
-0.0129768299,
0.0338700488,
-0.0587641709,
-0.0131487465,
0.0350485332,
0.0285046846,
-0.0338633657,
0.0337865353,
0.0051687136,
-0.0002921176,
0.0334019251,
-0.0064895935,
-0.022627566,
0.003998626,
0.019944571,
-0.0428798161,
0.0170733761,
0.0219028108,
0.0227648504,
-0.0311035868,
-0.0147795267,
-0.0090216072,
-0.0102183176,
0.0026135871,
0.05783654,
0.0017490794,
0.0324976109,
0.0118136872,
0.010089295,
-0.0409153439,
0.0062801884,
-0.0151914908,
-0.026761936,
0.0931723788,
-0.0215336159,
-0.0107929371,
0.0643459335,
0.0244697034,
-0.0234017763,
-0.0082206493,
-0.0669132397,
0.0974059924,
-0.0071850559,
0.044249095,
0.002216408,
0.0177596007,
0.0188632887,
0.0075575975,
-0.0084554246,
-0.0341700874,
0.0232708156,
0.0244969577,
0.0088928938,
-0.0631509274,
0.0001512351,
0.0195716266,
0.0059704944,
-0.0263609849,
-0.0201159772,
0.0348820798,
0.0080290558,
0.0188792776,
-0.009647076,
-0.039440006,
-0.0029912191,
-0.0087714884,
-0.0191585701,
0.0210838597,
-0.0569991805,
0.0939428136,
0.0149620892,
0.0202932619,
-0.045505736,
-0.0008274926,
0.0317735262,
0.0012895584,
0.0617198162,
-0.0036008623,
0.0087252883,
0.050230775,
-0.0356091559,
-0.0262860525,
-0.0187777132,
0.0037991954,
0.0026924231,
-0.0378801376,
-0.0145002045,
-0.0303598028,
-0.0289044306,
0.0120657329,
0.0189705845,
-0.0394281857,
-0.00340092,
0.0307797231,
2.99e-7,
0.0286747776,
0.0221112352,
-0.0029422157,
0.0499181896,
-0.00542511,
0.0203616582,
-0.0015196542,
0.0564829521,
-0.0150090419,
-0.0252431054,
0.0289951265,
0.0189191997,
-0.0014003681,
-0.0061842096,
-0.0853124931,
-0.0035103993,
0.0319878235,
-0.0285279378,
-0.0191229675,
-0.0030673372,
0.0312953666,
0.0216701124,
0.0220979266,
0.0336508229,
0.0193240196,
-0.0394899733,
0.0270053707,
-0.0475468524,
0.0622060634,
-0.0348374173,
-0.0057973284,
0.0375057571,
0.0019654846,
-0.0210520364,
0.0079472773,
-0.0189520884,
-0.0196304265,
0.0557180606,
-0.0365836881,
-0.0009156025,
0.006086715,
0.0208063927,
0.0107361833,
-0.041735705,
0.0425838493,
-0.0809658244,
0.0605020337,
0.0527743883,
0.0249531362,
-0.0381838568,
-0.042415157,
0.0192896985,
0.0256964099,
-0.0075047379,
-0.0111514935,
-0.0002898649,
-0.0381020159,
-0.042397853,
0.0171070099,
0.0045193336,
-0.0738693848,
-0.0297750477,
0.0203792043,
-0.0232767649,
-0.0605366156,
-0.0197188351,
-0.0415175371,
2.343059625e-34,
0.0299306531,
0.0226229224,
0.0079013845,
0.0540378094,
0.0208931472,
0.0146239921,
-0.0569666475,
0.0406124853,
0.0693740025,
-0.0237379223,
-0.0441316664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11230v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11230v1 | Multimodal Needle in a Haystack: Benchmarking Long-Context Capability of Multimodal Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T05:54:06 | 2024-06-17T05:54:06 | Hengyi Wang, Haizhou Shi, Shiwei Tan, Weiyi Qin, Wenyuan Wang, Tunyu Zhang, Akshay Nambi, Tanuja Ganu, Hao Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have shown significant promise in
various applications, leading to broad interest from researchers and
practitioners alike. However, a comprehensive evaluation of their long-context
capabilities remains underexplored. To address these gaps, we introduce the
MultiModal Needle-in-a-haystack (MMNeedle) benchmark, specifically designed to
assess the long-context capabilities of MLLMs. Besides multi-image input, we
employ image stitching to further increase the input context length, and
develop a protocol to automatically generate labels for sub-image level
retrieval. Essentially, MMNeedle evaluates MLLMs by stress-testing their
capability to locate a target sub-image (needle) within a set of images
(haystack) based on textual instructions and descriptions of image contents.
This setup necessitates an advanced understanding of extensive visual contexts
and effective information retrieval within long-context image inputs. With this
benchmark, we evaluate state-of-the-art MLLMs, encompassing both API-based and
open-source models. The findings reveal that GPT-4o consistently surpasses
other models in long-context scenarios, but suffers from hallucination problems
in negative samples, i.e., when needles are not in the haystacks. Our
comprehensive long-context evaluation of MLLMs also sheds lights on the
considerable performance gap between API-based and open-source models. All the
code, data, and instructions required to reproduce the main results are
available at https://github.com/Wang-ML-Lab/multimodal-needle-in-a-haystack. | [
0.0158685111,
0.0408947691,
0.0052841841,
0.0621149354,
-0.0611645989,
0.0070133302,
0.0422396362,
0.0177052431,
0.012526283,
-0.0847208276,
-0.0302204564,
-0.0502897985,
-0.0075921617,
0.0009034554,
0.0314403884,
-0.0646453202,
0.0095894104,
-0.0548200905,
-0.0461072363,
0.0014548326,
0.0001971035,
-0.0120329764,
0.0128227305,
0.033009395,
-0.0535825752,
-0.0188104529,
-0.0267296471,
0.0481415093,
-0.0012828407,
-0.0146134906,
-0.0180828217,
0.0318053178,
0.0452469662,
0.0335260332,
0.000001862,
-0.0305564348,
-0.0172783583,
0.012758214,
0.0339380614,
-0.0105705606,
0.0759037137,
-0.0334096327,
0.0015577385,
-0.024023341,
0.0038107159,
-0.0245021842,
0.0721877217,
0.0437413268,
0.0420064479,
0.0412196741,
-0.028206395,
-0.0509482995,
0.0211796165,
-0.0044336398,
0.0305199195,
-0.0579147562,
0.0262038168,
0.0148101905,
0.0298387501,
0.0043868581,
-0.0400401503,
0.0661174282,
0.0392065048,
0.0159373749,
-0.0315635763,
0.0502244346,
-0.0428388193,
-0.0267477352,
-0.014779849,
0.0583580285,
-0.0318322778,
-0.0037178774,
-0.0236918684,
0.0118988305,
-0.0175326467,
0.0094797267,
-0.0695586503,
0.0485879779,
-0.0204764437,
0.0146636311,
-0.0429890044,
0.0111368466,
0.0249837805,
0.0060545094,
-0.02087483,
0.0146147404,
0.0462904423,
-0.0215877164,
-0.0098567232,
-0.0105414754,
-0.0290571898,
-0.029577855,
0.0065803337,
0.0102443583,
0.0018344079,
0.0099772494,
-0.0263274424,
-0.0265463684,
0.0211131964,
-0.0314489417,
-0.0005240551,
0.0080355527,
-0.0784966797,
0.10886617,
-0.0267574303,
0.038509097,
-0.0431202501,
0.0067414627,
-0.0222967584,
-0.057145685,
-0.0303675979,
-0.0118497061,
-0.0360194966,
-0.005748509,
-0.0446284413,
-0.0688820481,
0.0106584346,
0.008573764,
-0.0050330292,
-0.0083916578,
-0.0542147644,
-0.0210786089,
-0.0325047113,
-0.026448587,
0.025466051,
0.0483200289,
0.0016417808,
-0.0255802348,
-0.0089500342,
-0.0379603915,
0.018480422,
0.052878771,
0.0202357769,
-0.0486534238,
-0.0031574126,
0.0782581568,
-0.0135059794,
-0.0585773475,
-0.0172543637,
-0.0293295998,
-0.0707498193,
-0.0580354892,
0.0186735261,
-0.0705168471,
0.0211173091,
-0.0002586543,
0.0243324749,
-0.0100227203,
-0.0011160163,
0.0241528824,
-0.0385633335,
0.1016952321,
0.0153477713,
-0.0010898624,
0.0290920977,
0.0349845849,
0.0201286692,
0.0911422595,
-0.0126011195,
0.0867559016,
0.0712964684,
-0.0022039479,
0.0206039324,
0.06282603,
-0.0265752058,
0.0043047331,
-0.0373784378,
0.003766377,
0.0396813564,
0.0430230536,
-0.0015063328,
0.071304284,
-0.0430556275,
-0.030544322,
0.0747360066,
0.0742488876,
0.0177427027,
-0.0327261053,
0.0321183503,
-0.0100320121,
-0.0352008753,
-0.0032985534,
-0.0641881004,
0.049372863,
-0.0237868503,
0.0118340086,
0.068494752,
0.025673613,
-0.0290359538,
0.0176564623,
-0.0307208523,
-0.018018201,
-0.0154422624,
0.0223722402,
0.0620561615,
-0.039765615,
-0.0444797017,
0.0076583251,
0.0144586377,
-0.0468126945,
-0.0102832029,
-0.0340265445,
-0.0051277345,
0.071264945,
0.0440378599,
-0.0103561431,
0.0011142007,
0.0126233529,
0.0636649132,
0.0531229377,
-0.0116453106,
0.0027923656,
0.0410636924,
-0.0510604903,
-0.0384452716,
0.0107624838,
-0.0170145277,
-0.0072022742,
0.0429176912,
0.0376153141,
0.0365525484,
-0.0311039072,
0.0366915055,
0.0385509767,
0.0135706207,
0.0047525298,
-0.045198217,
0.0241917074,
-0.008721102,
-0.0015791012,
-0.0200828761,
-0.0012106624,
0.039765086,
-0.0331213363,
0.0151381791,
-0.0083222501,
-0.0327742063,
-0.0177562162,
0.030574441,
-0.0565295927,
0.000838589,
0.0258679278,
-0.0169162285,
-0.0245739352,
-0.0063781571,
-0.0114840949,
0.035391923,
-0.0449856818,
-0.0100467307,
0.0122369453,
0.0218053497,
-0.0508204214,
0.0340398587,
-0.0082135685,
0.0104555739,
-0.0104441391,
0.0177758187,
0.0038451152,
-0.0474224314,
-0.0335461013,
0.0428942069,
0.0092565119,
0.0258578267,
0.0154310539,
0.0050525395,
-0.0483662635,
-0.0363142453,
-0.1321997344,
-0.0092514288,
-0.0479756519,
-0.0473759472,
-0.0025654954,
0.0030387519,
0.0000333119,
-0.0420308411,
-0.0019782039,
0.0316908993,
-0.007897459,
0.0629913062,
-0.0208662245,
0.0239090994,
-0.0202730875,
-0.0269722342,
-0.0427027903,
0.0240133088,
0.0747134611,
-0.0114552872,
-0.0567141809,
-0.0335516743,
-0.0289918352,
-0.0261246078,
0.0255481675,
-0.0282751266,
0.0033123319,
0.0221981797,
-0.0633920357,
0.0539442413,
0.0500005372,
0.0196780469,
0.0100818891,
0.0038505807,
-0.0166160595,
-0.0185060203,
0.003767492,
0.0006590149,
-0.0475043766,
-0.0109410146,
-0.0119042359,
-0.0366160013,
0.0148494076,
-0.0081455987,
0.0210498851,
-0.0520919263,
-0.0085103652,
-0.0154398568,
-0.0267693717,
-0.066977717,
0.0317110233,
-0.0053372416,
0.0337801129,
-0.045852866,
-0.0771118701,
0.0291343722,
-0.0378085338,
-0.0300068669,
0.0359672159,
0.0074821962,
-0.0074777789,
0.1277836859,
0.0239093546,
0.0439295582,
-0.0238603204,
0.0005061125,
-0.0051342016,
0.0170703791,
-0.0222742595,
-0.0123112276,
0.0596817993,
-0.0302413236,
0.0313022472,
-0.0115129622,
-0.0328203179,
-0.0001334836,
-0.0309689417,
-0.0247044768,
-0.0161558408,
-0.0614152066,
-0.0022137256,
-0.0127218915,
0.0654570162,
0.0215847194,
0.0436069071,
0.0044818837,
-0.0115088997,
-0.0086542973,
0.0216417685,
0.0549125522,
-0.0078899637,
-0.0180988163,
-0.0319552608,
-0.0153428679,
0.0456961431,
0.0330905616,
0.0037750083,
-0.0433676317,
0.03044568,
0.0349716432,
0.0445614271,
-0.0343113504,
0.0365288593,
0.0530469492,
-0.0420222357,
0.0017761691,
0.0611315966,
0.0152183445,
-0.0799913034,
-0.0392952114,
-0.0007503259,
0.045211181,
0.0213204343,
0.0010334513,
-0.0636543334,
-0.0637336522,
0.0032784082,
0.0054578851,
0.0466682389,
0.0023660972,
-0.0031317524,
-0.0943622068,
0.070997633,
0.0105995815,
-0.0422057472,
-0.0377049483,
-0.015399958,
0.0043455786,
0.0187624432,
0.0135042872,
0.0346363857,
-0.0175059456,
-0.0264366139,
-0.0297271255,
0.0241091177,
-0.0272238832,
0.0390402898,
-0.0463415086,
0.0053807343,
0.0395523719,
0.0097493371,
0.003237264,
-0.0423426665,
0.0645154491,
-0.0127042262,
-0.0088928211,
-0.0017018723,
0.048679769,
-0.0423757732,
-0.0196004976,
-0.0046086051,
0.004334752,
-0.0117678205,
-0.0240378957,
-0.0296750218,
0.0586676039,
0.0102719227,
0.0082397265,
-0.0418652333,
-0.0024374241,
0.0027363377,
0.0691818446,
0.0173851866,
-0.0217534285,
-0.0294464547,
-0.007244091,
0.0243790634,
-0.0015939568,
-0.0026644694,
0.0266280659,
-0.0072993757,
-0.0017496969,
-0.0462824404,
-0.0114762718,
0.0198440254,
0.0562342666,
-0.0255617294,
0.0269518699,
-0.0499047078,
0.0204709042,
-0.0735155046,
0.0484624319,
-0.0432301983,
0.0319001786,
-0.0517130271,
0.030851081,
0.0390288644,
-0.0315745212,
0.0156495012,
0.0592244156,
-0.0945108309,
-0.0415564403,
-0.014478188,
0.0334548652,
0.0194546543,
0.0254132953,
0.0138162542,
-0.0718335062,
0.0040643122,
0.0143912071,
0.0047675911,
0.0371471085,
0.004534394,
0.0116280634,
-0.0057250927,
0.042417977,
-0.0708898455,
0.0034556531,
-0.0013254448,
0.0198154505,
-0.0014507679,
-0.0191203207,
-0.003131333,
-0.0048869215,
0.0478934646,
-0.0466925912,
-0.0130471941,
0.0009649457,
-0.0039633759,
-0.0150631405,
-0.0239173863,
-0.0461185724,
-0.0024953275,
0.0151047837,
0.0007596868,
0.0227071531,
0.0145269139,
0.0163889881,
0.0300978813,
-0.0440499634,
0.0092589976,
0.0087570501,
-0.0448869839,
0.0245771743,
0.0177379251,
-0.0121139986,
-0.0106414938,
-0.0309489872,
0.0392086133,
-0.0400323682,
0.0760999247,
0.0273628999,
-0.0315477923,
-0.0460802428,
0.0507858507,
-0.0328849629,
-0.0242344216,
-0.0191276036,
0.0276251938,
0.0859907717,
-0.0090714209,
0.0470979623,
-0.0271803252,
-0.0225187149,
-0.0466621034,
0.0391578078,
0.0069410196,
-0.0440756567,
0.0356091447,
0.0410159305,
0.0033454366,
0.0427649766,
0.0580075867,
0.0232555903,
0.0192381628,
0.0246189199,
0.0068380125,
-0.0194278769,
-0.0110945627,
0.0365860313,
0.0287907552,
-0.0084692147,
0.003615781,
-0.0137731973,
-0.0598458573,
-0.0112613756,
0.0071433401,
-0.0309564862,
0.0226623081,
0.0412141308,
0.0927007571,
0.0210276805,
-0.0188336037,
-0.0229795165,
-0.0138281994,
0.0303020068,
-0.0003057177,
0.0132386172,
-6.365199054e-33,
-0.0221735165,
-0.0312738232,
0.0391122438,
-0.0234576091,
-0.0234090239,
0.0231067017,
-0.0191972665,
0.0231277477,
0.0035760636,
-0.0044509084,
0.0133407107,
-0.0206641592,
0.009366421,
0.0488838032,
-0.022781102,
-0.0008445373,
0.0125813643,
0.0086640259,
0.0059404727,
0.000576302,
0.0148189431,
0.0162459221,
0.0220589917,
-0.0388532504,
-0.0070860777,
-0.0064282012,
0.0062392778,
0.014840248,
0.0187506415,
0.0568608157,
-0.0363014378,
0.0365743265,
0.0262207165,
-0.0253996793,
-0.0173564777,
0.0330189094,
-0.0519712307,
0.0281920526,
-0.0153305857,
0.020240169,
-0.0482472703,
-0.0123549802,
0.0561321601,
-0.0381635316,
-0.0046642111,
-0.0270127989,
0.0207067914,
-0.0123510947,
-0.0479080118,
0.0247189924,
-0.0501047149,
0.0279634036,
0.0245553441,
-0.0223628413,
0.0694363862,
0.0178280715,
0.0276961811,
0.048961889,
-0.0429860204,
0.0140398433,
-0.034813229,
0.0212025419,
0.0722912997,
0.047610309,
0.0274687558,
0.0737838,
0.0601359196,
-0.0198612902,
-0.0017294824,
-0.0320270099,
0.0333948806,
0.0356086269,
0.0260511003,
0.0661018789,
0.0304431599,
0.0299921501,
-0.0210127197,
-0.0228264462,
-0.0523907728,
0.0172593389,
0.0431641489,
0.0461638011,
-0.0267285481,
-0.0070977616,
-0.0388325006,
0.0008096734,
-0.046624016,
0.0004105422,
0.0604943112,
0.0430841558,
-0.002289325,
0.035363093,
0.1028821319,
-0.0241248943,
-0.0130750658,
-0.011863458,
-0.0177576579,
0.0568576492,
0.0037816202,
0.0298921019,
-0.0204200745,
-0.022054689,
0.0327487923,
0.0093230605,
0.0061573549,
-0.0163193904,
0.0161556881,
0.0272497591,
-0.0778190717,
0.0011926241,
-0.0354908779,
-0.0159786865,
-0.0094903419,
-0.0268750507,
0.0528460145,
-0.0132057676,
-0.0153761422,
0.0475064591,
0.0255402457,
-0.008515913,
-0.0107182395,
-0.0719783753,
-0.0243505538,
-0.0260225199,
-0.005571858,
0.0353599973,
-0.0450233594,
-0.0292989668,
0.0406602472,
-0.0460193977,
-0.0140696028,
0.054202687,
2.579e-7,
0.0322859474,
0.0449651368,
0.0232410412,
-0.0128091583,
0.0367125757,
0.0186055284,
-0.0192247108,
0.0151172085,
-0.012879503,
-0.0520295203,
-0.0343641229,
0.0339991897,
0.0432056077,
0.0010462705,
-0.0386912152,
0.0235334281,
-0.0089889476,
0.0009915299,
-0.0790965706,
0.0123555269,
0.0619714297,
0.0978920832,
-0.0163421687,
-0.023575088,
0.0392767303,
-0.0898224115,
0.0828726143,
-0.042875465,
-0.0041499278,
-0.0368634798,
-0.0125085963,
0.0425843447,
-0.0000448958,
0.0077015432,
0.0266558863,
-0.0413914844,
0.0625039861,
0.0525039025,
-0.0208885577,
-0.0511840209,
0.0064720931,
0.0021086645,
-0.0609615408,
-0.0797917694,
0.0972725898,
-0.0279880725,
-0.0035605179,
-0.0164611321,
-0.0158149004,
-0.0203364976,
0.0100496188,
-0.0109129446,
-0.0421488285,
0.0120672034,
0.0320108831,
-0.0121952826,
-0.024135977,
-0.103980802,
-0.0154150277,
-0.0139040295,
-0.0577764027,
-0.0041354978,
-0.0641929656,
-0.0269044656,
0.0297634136,
-0.0562466867,
-0.052628044,
2.329218638e-34,
0.0457553156,
-0.0126509955,
0.0128227286,
-0.0171284154,
0.0226527303,
-0.0270179752,
-0.0561595708,
0.0156957284,
-0.0411627553,
-0.0661833957,
-0.0112186801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11228v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11228v1 | ComperDial: Commonsense Persona-grounded Dialogue Dataset and Benchmark | 2024-06-17T05:51:04 | 2024-06-17T05:51:04 | Hiromi Wakaki, Yuki Mitsufuji, Yoshinori Maeda, Yukiko Nishimura, Silin Gao, Mengjie Zhao, Keiichi Yamada, Antoine Bosselut | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose a new benchmark, ComperDial, which facilitates the training and
evaluation of evaluation metrics for open-domain dialogue systems. ComperDial
consists of human-scored responses for 10,395 dialogue turns in 1,485
conversations collected from 99 dialogue agents submitted to the Commonsense
Persona-grounded Dialogue (CPD) challenge. As a result, for any dialogue, our
benchmark includes multiple diverse responses with variety of characteristics
to ensure more robust evaluation of learned dialogue metrics. In addition to
single-turn response scores, ComperDial also contains dialogue-level
human-annotated scores, enabling joint assessment of multi-turn model responses
throughout a dialogue. Finally, building off ComperDial, we devise a new
automatic evaluation metric to measure the general similarity of
model-generated dialogues to human conversations. Our experimental results
demonstrate that our novel metric, CPDScore is more correlated with human
judgments than existing metrics. We release both ComperDial and CPDScore to the
community to accelerate development of automatic evaluation metrics for
open-domain dialogue systems. | [
0.0214325208,
0.0536400825,
0.0020038239,
0.0384601764,
-0.0222312361,
0.0090461662,
-0.0116495229,
-0.0129874535,
0.0126706967,
-0.0303845201,
-0.0876785889,
-0.0173950773,
0.0076290946,
0.0266659837,
0.0006204494,
-0.0455370955,
0.0287227612,
0.0058234711,
-0.0185108464,
0.0263711661,
-0.0091261771,
0.0223098956,
-0.0561033897,
0.0858001933,
-0.0200057738,
-0.0419183858,
-0.0067836316,
0.014420433,
0.0620525815,
-0.0093865683,
0.0061171702,
0.0530668758,
0.0124478992,
0.0325203203,
0.0000015208,
-0.0318883359,
0.0440546423,
-0.0087886555,
-0.031738136,
-0.0051578959,
0.0330355279,
0.0252500903,
0.0023157944,
0.0169877484,
-0.0535260364,
-0.014392484,
0.011812414,
0.0646923631,
0.0827316418,
0.0652714148,
-0.0034817155,
-0.039766714,
-0.003235352,
-0.0078474479,
-0.0559462085,
-0.0916408077,
-0.0210112501,
0.0314614139,
-0.0211624149,
-0.0213926192,
0.0173734706,
-0.0118206525,
0.0413228013,
-0.0578803942,
0.0127060013,
0.0341759622,
-0.0576408133,
0.0004882222,
-0.0170558002,
0.1478957385,
0.0594466515,
0.0257259272,
-0.0205029715,
-0.0005313762,
0.0243198872,
-0.0564582087,
-0.0288040917,
-0.0242334306,
0.0295670927,
-0.0000310027,
-0.0502860248,
0.0305577498,
-0.0074114855,
0.0215223581,
0.0008425913,
0.0404182151,
0.0039353189,
-0.0032508601,
0.0289950464,
-0.0110431174,
0.0036868928,
-0.0137660373,
-0.0001358384,
0.0241582002,
-0.0582343191,
-0.0029511694,
-0.0425158031,
0.0376286432,
0.0263050701,
-0.0448551923,
0.0387679487,
0.0319038816,
-0.0155616915,
0.0556410775,
0.0139031494,
0.0832305253,
-0.0075132465,
0.0073974617,
-0.0088350354,
-0.0048007793,
-0.0684609786,
0.0254023969,
-0.0353939496,
0.0145817818,
-0.0513745174,
-0.0256497636,
-0.0346991383,
0.0181257389,
-0.0173118841,
0.0150654223,
0.0280393139,
0.0392566696,
-0.0194401592,
0.005586653,
-0.0353565961,
0.0749267042,
-0.0670153871,
0.0164260641,
0.0476932153,
-0.0556518547,
-0.0163377896,
0.0357524529,
0.0109924972,
-0.0042832517,
-0.025031345,
0.0297127571,
-0.015648935,
-0.0443501584,
0.0175510123,
-0.020116007,
-0.0260275025,
-0.0695548132,
-0.0567422025,
-0.0111152465,
0.0439609177,
-0.0124487216,
-0.0139239021,
-0.0135066947,
0.0270889904,
-0.0023742146,
0.0148913786,
0.0508673936,
0.0495058373,
-0.0081390906,
0.0037520688,
0.021529125,
-0.0270358603,
0.0521647781,
0.0200461652,
-0.0020774109,
0.0483628362,
-0.0090185255,
0.0261766426,
0.0219284762,
0.0241286177,
-0.0016304319,
0.0389513485,
0.0537292212,
-0.0020177679,
0.0491204336,
0.0424211994,
0.0284498148,
-0.0553170443,
-0.0489676222,
0.0618515648,
0.0584220402,
-0.0342783444,
0.0201729555,
0.0459877774,
0.0201039892,
0.022924589,
0.0128883105,
-0.0447219461,
0.0293062683,
-0.0105865384,
-0.0276444089,
0.0171697475,
-0.01085738,
-0.0351973623,
-0.0225349981,
0.0228048507,
-0.0048744823,
0.0135290194,
-0.03424244,
0.0056685628,
0.0061936663,
-0.0588336885,
0.0641300827,
-0.0261301305,
-0.0661830977,
-0.0071213753,
-0.0307968855,
-0.0124927023,
0.0399168283,
0.0382030234,
0.0065092533,
-0.0444034301,
-0.0292545017,
-0.023288304,
0.0584168322,
0.0495317318,
-0.0478213951,
0.0686358735,
-0.045937907,
0.0050810943,
-0.0196351893,
-0.0110160084,
0.0411399528,
0.0068185339,
-0.0220943876,
0.0216063429,
-0.0230790116,
0.028170662,
-0.0064507551,
-0.0147855952,
-0.0091827633,
0.0215619542,
0.0029612996,
0.0351883806,
0.0382531621,
-0.0195894353,
0.0026813538,
0.0385825932,
0.0124947485,
-0.0206338186,
0.0232169852,
-0.0497136265,
-0.0619497783,
0.0293179825,
-0.0208399408,
-0.0365382694,
0.0524422452,
-0.0125488834,
-0.0325138904,
0.0259014405,
-0.0397149846,
0.0406421758,
-0.0531011857,
0.0053716684,
0.0271429587,
0.0172874052,
0.0005138798,
0.0460681506,
-0.0198029093,
0.0134579884,
0.0330084674,
0.0197787005,
0.030327728,
-0.0628651232,
0.0164234564,
-0.0215048939,
-0.0224790387,
0.0255195387,
0.0113831824,
0.0230112355,
-0.0686135367,
-0.0422157422,
-0.1181774288,
-0.0209696572,
-0.0173935425,
-0.0044636894,
0.0121080885,
0.0008560197,
0.0090460554,
-0.0212192331,
-0.0442366786,
-0.0231124628,
0.0507480204,
0.0071266163,
0.0308096372,
0.0166443158,
-0.0168764219,
-0.0395383388,
0.0221854113,
0.0227266457,
0.0415638909,
-0.0388425775,
0.0900267735,
-0.0108110802,
-0.0127422754,
-0.0417025685,
0.0253672153,
-0.0200092196,
-0.0580107681,
0.0427245721,
0.0353815928,
0.0156236757,
0.0694280192,
0.0216572881,
0.0402340852,
-0.0386122614,
-0.0186623409,
-0.055724822,
0.0177080892,
-0.0280125029,
-0.0135280332,
-0.0578547269,
0.0132117653,
0.0339506418,
0.0071242205,
0.0102140522,
0.0258686896,
-0.0592138879,
-0.0096904561,
0.0076093157,
-0.0662540868,
-0.0081044976,
0.0191073585,
-0.0379497074,
0.0193167403,
-0.0327361934,
-0.0234889891,
0.0706334487,
-0.0329053514,
-0.0246640109,
-0.0356212519,
0.0062680673,
-0.0244204551,
0.0367108919,
-0.0542380251,
0.0080945184,
-0.0486836545,
-0.0321106054,
-0.0308174696,
-0.0210973844,
0.0268994905,
-0.0486180149,
0.0427723043,
-0.0137951244,
0.005208475,
0.0028890085,
-0.0582445636,
-0.059815336,
-0.0197321326,
-0.0076040155,
0.0124161653,
0.0063799405,
-0.047451105,
-0.0431982353,
-0.0094659254,
-0.0151576977,
0.0071505182,
-0.0065155849,
0.0126081808,
0.0009771273,
0.0264276396,
0.0166752469,
0.0451962203,
0.0155559024,
0.0062956344,
0.0759359226,
0.0325424485,
0.0386488587,
-0.0042482838,
-0.0055998624,
0.0000542485,
0.0079084709,
0.002506275,
0.0062774247,
0.0065377206,
0.0614027567,
-0.0031154784,
-0.0423118323,
0.1182641685,
0.0246327519,
-0.02584281,
-0.0053279875,
-0.0255696122,
0.0324164294,
0.016084753,
-0.00784091,
-0.0403014161,
-0.0316625312,
-0.0092078298,
0.0290752854,
0.002448045,
-0.0585838035,
0.0099609531,
-0.0947914645,
0.0162512027,
-0.0271637756,
-0.0804068148,
-0.0600785688,
-0.0256978516,
0.0183826089,
-0.0368568003,
0.0159387197,
0.0018357583,
0.0388835259,
-0.0202679802,
0.0005262542,
0.0048760548,
-0.040264938,
0.0532689989,
-0.0172316208,
0.0693957508,
0.0732044652,
0.0802417621,
0.0562398024,
-0.0634792373,
-0.028238697,
-0.0088914521,
-0.0105885807,
0.00303532,
0.0350964516,
-0.0145361377,
-0.0080480939,
-0.0249578692,
0.0351080634,
-0.0529270694,
-0.0242662337,
-0.0123430947,
0.022297008,
-0.0345766805,
0.0308417417,
-0.0085051907,
0.0583921559,
0.03665125,
0.0835817754,
0.0344820954,
-0.0084143607,
-0.0268492512,
-0.0096921381,
-0.016655717,
-0.0594346821,
-0.0154626155,
-0.0171384457,
0.0069483691,
0.0050474498,
-0.0829036906,
-0.04869093,
-0.0006822732,
0.0462070182,
-0.0400742106,
-0.0449054651,
-0.0023552573,
0.0326492712,
-0.013565097,
0.0345977582,
-0.027593527,
0.0259832684,
-0.0868049115,
0.0013831825,
0.0541658998,
0.0109876981,
-0.020724168,
0.0403015427,
-0.0574510582,
-0.0300889648,
-0.0281227212,
0.0468871184,
0.0172530487,
0.028651176,
-0.0098860795,
-0.0027275172,
-0.0137324408,
-0.0035201351,
-0.0560639277,
-0.0168482699,
0.0708700642,
0.0378563739,
-0.0314538293,
0.0554553382,
-0.0097264154,
0.012409525,
-0.0037413961,
0.0508914143,
-0.030647764,
-0.1085695028,
-0.0047942293,
-0.009031781,
0.0499943011,
0.0119799552,
-0.0142108984,
0.0081361737,
0.0041470071,
-0.0310104601,
-0.0192436744,
-0.059559349,
-0.0162334777,
0.0199194774,
-0.0203180909,
-0.0094707664,
0.0160490535,
-0.0556436069,
0.0706688687,
-0.0190934427,
-0.0344808213,
0.067200236,
0.017186705,
-0.0253083315,
-0.01746062,
-0.0358508267,
-0.0179662481,
-0.006884329,
0.030028712,
0.0187316313,
0.097626619,
0.0182651971,
-0.0087139811,
0.0501821153,
0.0382338576,
-0.0559475385,
0.0334848501,
-0.0395869501,
0.0465132669,
0.012753631,
0.045427803,
0.0418459103,
-0.0160056297,
0.0036466685,
0.0020198189,
0.0513676964,
-0.0201734863,
-0.0166413374,
0.0377841443,
0.0199144874,
-0.0021158038,
0.0219709892,
0.0497865789,
-0.0286970325,
0.0218296573,
-0.0198457707,
-0.0132056326,
-0.0554753914,
-0.0527863428,
0.0067648604,
0.0150441434,
0.0187103301,
0.0287433043,
-0.0726672933,
-0.0332408175,
0.0072336043,
0.0651260912,
0.004019584,
0.0231850855,
0.0372852497,
0.0340927728,
-0.0246221889,
-0.0261847675,
-0.0362981781,
0.0087324101,
-0.0427430049,
-0.007341045,
-0.0508403331,
-5.340428793e-33,
-0.0590690635,
-0.031892661,
0.0044312337,
-0.00293303,
-0.0747884735,
-0.0309169404,
-0.021269748,
0.0180303939,
-0.017764328,
0.0315270312,
-0.0039973292,
0.0294705369,
0.0000241962,
0.0202968568,
-0.0464351736,
-0.0534324683,
0.0293672103,
-0.0022137417,
-0.0446904078,
0.0544835478,
0.0129207354,
-0.0077144266,
0.0404146947,
-0.0916005,
0.028963523,
-0.0063850265,
-0.015627522,
0.0367464721,
0.0109630171,
0.0660649985,
-0.0215793345,
0.0373088866,
0.0048085861,
-0.046153903,
0.0176119898,
0.0269404724,
-0.045605801,
-0.0112791946,
0.0206254106,
0.0175021403,
-0.0140499491,
0.0142704109,
-0.0211416148,
0.0005088398,
-0.015988484,
-0.0058127358,
-0.0017961321,
-0.021951234,
-0.000689618,
0.003072592,
-0.0410963893,
0.012915073,
-0.0270377472,
-0.0782878473,
-0.0526915267,
0.0699409321,
-0.0003255206,
-0.0162400305,
-0.0374087133,
0.0170014575,
-0.0463311672,
-0.0120979557,
0.0214410778,
0.0307423994,
0.0035734989,
0.045040261,
-0.0015234075,
-0.0082995249,
-0.0290837809,
-0.0451820083,
0.0140442206,
0.053313978,
0.0433185957,
0.1048124433,
-0.0416001379,
0.0280392077,
-0.0271164048,
0.0555925928,
0.0119657191,
0.0351955444,
-0.003995839,
-0.0039048239,
-0.0188440997,
0.0162771028,
-0.0506867431,
-0.0306346398,
-0.0223875977,
0.0012457198,
0.0281821359,
-0.0077050123,
-0.0383823775,
-0.005200875,
0.0471822135,
-0.0315214843,
-0.0016419815,
0.0479340181,
0.0059896819,
0.0020675336,
0.0021289582,
0.0012610755,
-0.0303978138,
-0.0033690995,
0.077655755,
0.0410089605,
0.0353000537,
-0.0056465035,
0.0186515469,
-0.013162829,
-0.0313863195,
-0.0101046618,
-0.0123540722,
0.0552120209,
-0.0642961115,
0.0544745289,
-0.0051234365,
-0.0163445454,
-0.0331860296,
0.0852895379,
-0.0286103506,
0.0186888352,
-0.0187454838,
-0.0237991884,
0.0583472662,
0.0162784681,
-0.039880164,
0.0101916557,
-0.0137675898,
-0.0368660651,
0.0067512305,
-0.0210738946,
-0.0103003792,
0.020794522,
2.171e-7,
-0.0202322882,
0.002515547,
0.0559589043,
0.0040955623,
0.0119503513,
0.0682957247,
-0.0105811404,
0.0424268134,
0.0176173244,
-0.0289954562,
0.0263609979,
0.0035751245,
0.0678976774,
0.0046080509,
-0.095454827,
-0.0177356862,
-0.0705835819,
-0.0312275551,
-0.0163193736,
-0.0418794602,
0.0687137693,
0.0480082557,
0.0258201398,
0.0088686589,
0.0118504036,
0.0291590299,
0.041319564,
-0.0239302497,
-0.0153967701,
-0.0257761031,
0.0512124859,
-0.0132891452,
0.0107884994,
0.0381410047,
-0.0015961721,
0.0412711762,
0.0382222086,
0.052386567,
-0.0161832366,
-0.0995061919,
-0.0134027246,
-0.031099122,
0.0214552823,
-0.0366626345,
0.0389896743,
-0.0375974737,
-0.0137954373,
-0.0318672843,
-0.0460475795,
0.00304431,
0.0563631132,
-0.0350434259,
-0.039831467,
0.0338704959,
0.0333698578,
-0.0224692579,
0.0218142159,
-0.0721000656,
0.0024986223,
-0.0133704394,
-0.0325269923,
-0.0517759509,
0.0013240565,
-0.0333223417,
-0.0016653648,
-0.0360855199,
-0.0011934993,
1.5116552e-34,
0.0217857435,
-0.0027306795,
0.0269936305,
0.0101348581,
0.0533761047,
-0.0006168855,
-0.0008605219,
-0.0273435134,
0.051129654,
-0.0655031577,
0.0304387547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11218v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11218v1 | Building another Spanish dictionary, this time with GPT-4 | 2024-06-17T05:25:56 | 2024-06-17T05:25:56 | Miguel Ortega-Martín, Óscar García-Sierra, Alfonso Ardoiz, Juan Carlos Armenteros, Ignacio Garrido, Jorge Álvarez, Camilo Torrón, Iñigo Galdeano, Ignacio Arranz, Oleg Vorontsov, Adrián Alonso | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present the "Spanish Built Factual Freectianary 2.0" (Spanish-BFF-2) as
the second iteration of an AI-generated Spanish dictionary. Previously, we
developed the inaugural version of this unique free dictionary employing GPT-3.
In this study, we aim to improve the dictionary by using GPT-4-turbo instead.
Furthermore, we explore improvements made to the initial version and compare
the performance of both models. | [
-0.0059900144,
0.0379524156,
-0.0140476432,
0.0664496124,
-0.0393759571,
-0.0025087853,
-0.0612085424,
0.0100333253,
-0.0039401408,
0.0027808459,
-0.0099455463,
-0.0028697848,
0.0178581402,
0.0134869982,
-0.0211224239,
-0.0297692325,
0.0284594689,
-0.016075829,
-0.0151419947,
-0.040970169,
-0.0074647246,
0.0584725142,
-0.0319490172,
0.0315986872,
-0.0637473911,
-0.0020612022,
-0.0136243803,
-0.0540274195,
0.006431316,
-0.0182399154,
-0.034204945,
0.0531256087,
-0.0507123023,
0.1058214158,
0.000001786,
-0.0594710819,
-0.0633647367,
0.0075461958,
-0.0061435685,
-0.0229530968,
0.0453907177,
-0.0031476996,
-0.0233915653,
0.0191980861,
-0.0737474188,
-0.0628445745,
0.066896148,
-0.0108327866,
0.017361315,
0.0239257962,
-0.0088725314,
-0.0955415294,
0.0134376017,
-0.0308605619,
0.0027700257,
-0.0315914117,
-0.0257144123,
-0.021983441,
-0.0038837432,
-0.0215207096,
0.0036949916,
0.0285806488,
0.0212467313,
-0.0094955517,
-0.0205473974,
0.0018179248,
-0.0732344389,
-0.0207194034,
0.0021039995,
0.0316803195,
0.0084049925,
-0.0448934324,
-0.0153807374,
0.0018382684,
-0.0028396193,
0.0020000853,
-0.0064306017,
0.0404804759,
-0.0222106483,
0.0189101808,
0.0714309365,
-0.0167313311,
0.0267151147,
0.0140514877,
-0.0232026801,
0.0779405534,
0.0305493046,
-0.0401339307,
0.047838375,
0.0171915572,
-0.0051502408,
-0.0389145091,
0.0132693723,
-0.0030702639,
0.0170327947,
0.0187950153,
-0.025538737,
-0.0262853708,
0.0056424122,
-0.0967148095,
-0.0083576888,
0.0169135425,
-0.0054948092,
0.0032389185,
0.0031004613,
0.0174724888,
0.0250176284,
0.0068805353,
-0.0543534197,
-0.0160022434,
-0.0551786609,
0.0006895949,
-0.0921599269,
0.0374987274,
-0.0424351133,
0.0231702067,
-0.0104668988,
-0.0202307589,
0.0033436464,
-0.0181084871,
0.0502649099,
-0.0146715268,
-0.0417262726,
0.0380251892,
-0.0264941808,
-0.0234548096,
-0.0451578759,
-0.0474037826,
-0.0288050082,
-0.090277575,
0.0143012749,
0.0037986112,
-0.0006074716,
-0.0379823744,
0.0469307043,
-0.0146993399,
-0.0041421778,
-0.0412609763,
-0.0150094293,
-0.017079059,
-0.0173148438,
-0.1124967933,
-0.0308372509,
-0.0890541822,
0.0250217132,
-0.0016519213,
0.0122559881,
-0.0460552275,
0.0108188884,
0.0046246937,
-0.0094903968,
0.0805628374,
-0.0853031799,
-0.0222719368,
0.0194859318,
-0.016371429,
-0.0000802767,
0.0832565203,
0.0335743204,
0.0308903996,
0.0430161245,
-0.0032515631,
-0.0195995886,
0.0201797709,
-0.0191929806,
-0.0027609062,
-0.0169808716,
-0.0177360568,
-0.0129040144,
0.042727083,
-0.0024937694,
0.0615014471,
0.0124947075,
0.092941992,
0.0272225104,
0.0122433351,
0.047556147,
0.0303665511,
0.0579924807,
0.015726015,
0.0582524836,
-0.0101299034,
-0.0317298435,
-0.0332940482,
-0.0151752327,
0.0227852426,
-0.0330086425,
0.0393818691,
0.0018596542,
-0.0425873697,
0.0226263311,
-0.0093323654,
0.0319182687,
-0.0468382426,
0.0472282954,
0.0201023798,
-0.0350580923,
0.0178439599,
-0.0059362431,
-0.0439921059,
-0.005905685,
-0.0421198048,
0.0375151411,
0.0400482304,
0.0608905964,
0.0065753968,
-0.0433185436,
0.0274967328,
-0.0280382186,
0.0743065551,
0.0044912435,
-0.0237890668,
-0.0132577028,
-0.0784575567,
-0.0128866257,
0.0188049451,
0.0322457068,
0.0295493174,
0.0248045772,
0.0455754586,
0.0182387438,
-0.0098790014,
-0.0098415893,
-0.0038855434,
0.0227354225,
-0.0451199673,
0.0055848304,
-0.0032889501,
-0.013743896,
0.0810244307,
-0.0236230828,
-0.0066095651,
0.0485744365,
0.0007408033,
0.0112102823,
0.0043321666,
0.0069091138,
0.011000854,
0.064996101,
-0.031706199,
0.0214937255,
0.012101803,
0.0070435531,
-0.0422892496,
0.00141704,
-0.039161332,
0.1050605848,
-0.0694859028,
0.0393819064,
-0.0090070479,
0.0292076413,
0.0091491621,
0.0646441355,
-0.0253821984,
0.0168856308,
-0.015107451,
0.0114760948,
0.0291167516,
-0.0295863301,
-0.0096202372,
0.093486771,
0.0039838268,
0.0165786576,
0.0368582793,
0.0599323101,
0.0118533503,
-0.0090971626,
-0.0646757558,
-0.0037374566,
-0.0124968924,
-0.0049564941,
0.0061165905,
-0.002021523,
-0.0239414964,
0.01776742,
-0.0166854523,
0.0316224694,
0.0235201083,
-0.0132489083,
0.0000382756,
0.0018902958,
-0.0276577622,
-0.0281843636,
0.0146032711,
0.0183521006,
-0.0152517594,
0.0386583246,
-0.0547421388,
-0.0281741079,
-0.0239590798,
-0.0423796326,
0.0508388951,
0.04561764,
-0.062231414,
0.0395220704,
-0.0147930281,
0.0624333695,
0.0148682147,
-0.0088899955,
0.0116161918,
0.0662622154,
-0.0235078763,
0.0036246115,
0.0207244549,
0.0073284614,
-0.059100382,
-0.023610251,
-0.0327382199,
0.0193840507,
0.0329061188,
0.0343106426,
-0.0058632488,
-0.0773445964,
0.0140762627,
-0.028916521,
-0.0496868826,
0.0232713316,
0.0444876663,
-0.03174996,
0.042345129,
-0.012423411,
-0.0430880152,
0.0254093111,
-0.055896055,
0.0196373612,
-0.0800807998,
0.0096520381,
-0.0166411307,
0.0458414108,
0.0082159042,
0.0278376974,
-0.0006934531,
0.0114513645,
0.029619677,
0.0034828191,
0.0383012183,
-0.0671513453,
0.0769151002,
-0.0726181194,
0.0178585108,
0.0013494848,
-0.01394579,
-0.0323065147,
0.0195874665,
-0.01765614,
-0.0178559832,
0.0767869577,
-0.055708576,
0.0392338261,
0.0210073795,
0.0005839493,
0.0795401931,
-0.001280508,
-0.0029449165,
-0.0015578797,
-0.0250020009,
0.0147125795,
-0.0024178186,
0.0075836633,
0.0063856137,
-0.0019850158,
0.0007551828,
0.0137248822,
0.0147572663,
-0.0314807445,
0.0036303925,
0.0194151979,
-0.0033937013,
-0.0550967306,
-0.0221479367,
-0.0396718644,
-0.0025168702,
-0.002131931,
0.0839698762,
0.035206493,
-0.0594928376,
-0.0164972581,
-0.0247110929,
-0.0010880709,
0.0227097999,
0.0314858817,
-0.0773176104,
0.0062573403,
0.0047026468,
0.0295048654,
0.0062444904,
-0.0104670096,
-0.0357599072,
-0.1509814858,
0.0371485353,
-0.0022459247,
0.0064383438,
-0.0681374446,
-0.0231886841,
-0.0329969265,
-0.064999789,
-0.0554482713,
0.0155649576,
0.00767517,
0.020541627,
0.0189230535,
0.0214204434,
-0.0170740988,
-0.018342372,
-0.0405187421,
-0.0189208835,
0.0740173906,
0.04360459,
-0.0468317233,
-0.0220083036,
-0.0226254649,
-0.025958648,
-0.0358128659,
-0.0261955224,
0.0066828318,
0.0542079024,
-0.0062488308,
0.0011486657,
-0.0197170824,
-0.0163521748,
0.0030771804,
0.0452460758,
0.0849787891,
-0.0140612787,
0.0247086268,
-0.0082312152,
-0.034567751,
0.0053641326,
0.0320170932,
0.0023245499,
0.0085709607,
0.002394163,
-0.0300124288,
-0.0011990756,
-0.0666599795,
-0.0084435418,
0.0200893153,
-0.0674976483,
-0.0703986809,
-0.0647345036,
-0.0428083315,
0.024360802,
0.0619203821,
0.0314652547,
0.0265137982,
-0.0250042863,
0.0134894243,
-0.032972727,
-0.0124618057,
0.0168318804,
0.0059512937,
-0.0528348275,
-0.0673149303,
-0.0055733593,
-0.0204746109,
0.0016141547,
0.0563573726,
-0.0078929793,
-0.0176650006,
0.0516925827,
0.0639219433,
0.0342889056,
-0.0004104254,
-0.0444523804,
-0.0073584286,
0.0132354349,
0.0259815045,
0.0018404933,
0.0255045239,
0.0256524701,
-0.0193320028,
-0.0121943858,
0.0239636824,
0.0276310313,
-0.0128867263,
-0.0663803369,
0.0475160703,
-0.0046666209,
-0.0410746187,
0.0603783578,
0.0476638973,
0.0420110822,
-0.0813443288,
0.0006425293,
-0.0266869199,
-0.0315535553,
-0.053301461,
-0.0141766649,
-0.0042953016,
0.0323634669,
0.0321657583,
-0.0246166214,
-0.0116984416,
-0.006235837,
-0.0382252261,
-0.0140533298,
0.0316845365,
0.0034059663,
0.0245345011,
0.0158253051,
0.0217940584,
0.0128273126,
0.0079985047,
0.0262065995,
-0.0040973858,
0.0189676285,
-0.03309815,
0.0135367392,
-0.0160403959,
-0.0294559803,
0.0159666296,
0.052032508,
0.0437455028,
-0.0070911949,
-0.0629809946,
0.0339705795,
0.0825924575,
-0.0290068053,
0.0565027148,
-0.0455042869,
-0.0068119555,
-0.0081243664,
0.0145202968,
0.039611619,
-0.0071734106,
-0.00246412,
-0.0107876929,
0.0076466086,
-0.0452215672,
0.075019829,
-0.0005167449,
0.04135729,
-0.0101852445,
0.0081047947,
-0.0238654837,
-0.0401361212,
-0.0466264077,
-0.0296666604,
-0.0340181105,
-0.0235099625,
-0.0798635855,
-0.0495226122,
0.0025024356,
0.0118717151,
0.0464801863,
0.0103783049,
0.0637956783,
0.0812924877,
-0.0221723989,
-0.0278754607,
-0.0303027947,
0.0158676784,
-0.0346412212,
-0.0134187043,
0.0004314271,
-5.530549576e-33,
-0.0269366205,
-0.0335434526,
0.0166923571,
0.0023706513,
-0.0135504939,
-0.0055089025,
-0.0181477014,
-0.0085719181,
0.019366201,
0.0155967269,
-0.0465250053,
-0.0005220641,
0.0400373861,
-0.0316199213,
0.0297809523,
0.0349603482,
0.0067652864,
-0.0041491222,
-0.0086260922,
-0.0139554087,
0.0205118656,
0.0057106246,
0.1145764291,
-0.0689117536,
0.0112778218,
0.0188873727,
-0.0333901867,
0.040680021,
-0.0019200699,
0.0526113808,
-0.0093994709,
0.0563973039,
0.0243096519,
-0.0377806388,
0.0040840902,
-0.0484885089,
-0.0122941146,
-0.064764902,
0.0477244556,
0.0223654117,
0.0155341355,
-0.0450887382,
-0.0248439852,
-0.0164487213,
-0.06131991,
0.0323173851,
0.0158559643,
-0.0389376916,
0.0025605105,
0.0289594345,
-0.0179118179,
0.0411382169,
0.060655646,
-0.0010340894,
0.0439084731,
-0.0059480998,
-0.0306340195,
-0.069976069,
0.0005856467,
0.0226633139,
0.0480667539,
0.0649812147,
0.076121524,
0.0064713764,
-0.0120100873,
-0.0063820956,
0.0407516472,
-0.0500679426,
-0.0188743118,
0.0216131192,
0.0009811738,
0.0353781879,
0.0488448367,
0.1191839352,
0.0810656101,
-0.0337000675,
-0.0068157287,
0.0323954299,
-0.0128043341,
0.0176727343,
-0.041908931,
-0.0218002424,
-0.0489798784,
0.0041548717,
-0.0485903956,
-0.0111795906,
-0.004011495,
-0.0408876725,
0.0232390352,
-0.0044589941,
-0.0258598533,
0.0092617515,
-0.0135590574,
0.013822576,
0.0334309451,
0.0152733419,
-0.0322645977,
0.0267725047,
-0.0169759691,
0.0439924039,
-0.0036620232,
-0.0086218743,
-0.0173179414,
0.0534480326,
0.0127988039,
0.0145158274,
-0.0220175013,
0.0586927049,
-0.0260902215,
0.0318167545,
-0.0281584244,
0.0391621925,
-0.0057377545,
0.0166066121,
0.0033605008,
0.004299181,
0.0032556001,
0.012795032,
0.0569122322,
0.040559981,
-0.028511649,
-0.0549208336,
0.0258366596,
0.0330007821,
0.0037135023,
0.0202449057,
-0.0356547162,
-0.0317003466,
0.025298493,
-0.0448604897,
-0.0245781522,
-0.0136621865,
2.465e-7,
0.0274956357,
0.0158500373,
0.0319085084,
0.0940852612,
-0.0324918255,
-0.0108856289,
0.0084341299,
0.0302039906,
-0.087908566,
0.0092105493,
-0.0160466414,
0.0156439971,
0.0410714336,
0.0732230619,
-0.0398614109,
-0.0275336858,
-0.0072837966,
-0.0034778127,
-0.077629596,
-0.0083915805,
0.0190256741,
0.0790336877,
0.0421655737,
-0.0358303562,
-0.0301725492,
-0.0022173119,
0.0038516284,
0.0274662226,
-0.0140253138,
0.0221547261,
0.0498190187,
0.0254272874,
-0.02885212,
-0.0024554017,
-0.0257302281,
-0.0228782222,
0.0254100356,
0.0283120349,
-0.0123350453,
0.0446132869,
0.079982169,
-0.0667364672,
-0.0201997869,
-0.0135878855,
0.0409754738,
0.0501311831,
0.0359051526,
0.0217016842,
-0.0080788322,
0.0333405435,
-0.0224588867,
-0.0491103455,
-0.0538931303,
0.0162030738,
0.0322473347,
-0.0150431888,
-0.0166581403,
-0.0087447008,
-0.0140210791,
0.031411469,
-0.0003464665,
-0.0263101757,
-0.0260196757,
-0.0005717788,
-0.0223467667,
-0.0010071852,
0.0318527557,
1.875473456e-34,
0.0032112247,
-0.0168111492,
0.0135444039,
-0.0393771753,
0.0418004356,
0.0021862073,
0.0376660638,
0.0020663852,
-0.0213969145,
-0.0099623278,
-0.0238168612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11217v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11217v2 | WeatherQA: Can Multimodal Language Models Reason about Severe Weather? | 2024-06-17T05:23:18 | 2024-06-24T03:55:30 | Chengqian Ma, Zhanxiang Hua, Alexandra Anderson-Frey, Vikram Iyer, Xin Liu, Lianhui Qin | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, physics.ao-ph | Severe convective weather events, such as hail, tornadoes, and thunderstorms,
often occur quickly yet cause significant damage, costing billions of dollars
every year. This highlights the importance of forecasting severe weather
threats hours in advance to better prepare meteorologists and residents in
at-risk areas. Can modern large foundation models perform such forecasting?
Existing weather benchmarks typically focus only on predicting time-series
changes in certain weather parameters (e.g., temperature, moisture) with
text-only features. In this work, we introduce WeatherQA, the first multimodal
dataset designed for machines to reason about complex combinations of weather
parameters (a.k.a., ingredients) and predict severe weather in real-world
scenarios. The dataset includes over 8,000 (multi-images, text) pairs for
diverse severe weather events. Each pair contains rich information crucial for
forecasting -- the images describe the ingredients capturing environmental
instability, surface observations, and radar reflectivity, and the text
contains forecast analyses written by human experts. With WeatherQA, we
evaluate state-of-the-art vision language models, including GPT4, Claude3.5,
Gemini-1.5, and a fine-tuned Llama3-based VLM, by designing two challenging
tasks: (1) multi-choice QA for predicting affected area and (2) classification
of the development potential of severe convection. These tasks require deep
understanding of domain knowledge (e.g., atmospheric dynamics) and complex
reasoning over multimodal data (e.g., interactions between weather parameters).
We show a substantial gap between the strongest VLM, GPT4o, and human
reasoning. Our comprehensive case study with meteorologists further reveals the
weaknesses of the models, suggesting that better training and data integration
are necessary to bridge this gap. WeatherQA link:
https://github.com/chengqianma/WeatherQA. | [
-0.015435541,
0.0987403169,
0.0095422901,
0.0584216081,
-0.0003371834,
0.0398059525,
-0.004460827,
-0.0501363873,
-0.0005585508,
-0.0254428517,
-0.0152686853,
-0.0499122404,
-0.0191793647,
0.0475633964,
0.0148927765,
-0.13773489,
0.0047687241,
-0.0475159958,
-0.0241672583,
-0.0007019537,
0.0329768173,
-0.00181234,
-0.0112734726,
0.0242036283,
-0.0152777592,
-0.0065460294,
-0.0469623208,
-0.0096435845,
0.0447235294,
-0.0346222632,
-0.0202343836,
0.0147951553,
0.066707164,
-0.0038465101,
0.0000020691,
-0.0280248281,
0.0277420338,
-0.0163609218,
-0.0019851343,
-0.0214529987,
0.0342500992,
-0.048837021,
0.0104107251,
0.0252057202,
-0.076424025,
-0.0026952389,
0.0850690752,
0.0424370915,
0.0927013084,
0.0497380756,
-0.0102558602,
-0.0487493463,
0.045407448,
0.0050017419,
0.0260521062,
-0.012907696,
0.0036550595,
-0.0093767513,
0.0145525886,
-0.0277057644,
-0.0025924905,
0.0275128987,
0.0459350906,
0.0178253353,
-0.0198551677,
0.0641739741,
-0.0264932755,
-0.0473800041,
-0.0588050857,
0.056763541,
0.0053720875,
0.0061547025,
-0.0179516971,
-0.0000210985,
0.0034315023,
0.0095942235,
-0.0427287072,
-0.0215631537,
-0.0349910855,
0.022018984,
-0.0358289145,
-0.0081267999,
0.0344782062,
0.0303576626,
-0.0302961376,
0.0906027928,
-0.0024651135,
0.02059591,
-0.0139903761,
-0.0131676532,
-0.0151499063,
-0.0426248685,
-0.036754936,
0.0041936422,
-0.0544837713,
0.00565862,
-0.0508346409,
0.0129227517,
-0.0423470847,
-0.0532305688,
0.0435762554,
0.0378516763,
-0.020451542,
0.0337236524,
-0.0125064496,
0.0170063693,
0.0013411146,
-0.0040550558,
-0.0003028039,
-0.0544785932,
-0.0595890619,
-0.0251302179,
-0.0073706289,
-0.0314514786,
-0.0363941751,
-0.0015531651,
-0.0225577261,
0.0159450918,
-0.0064301137,
0.0214482415,
0.0073908051,
0.0284262691,
-0.0249255933,
-0.0398670435,
-0.0559703149,
-0.0169263687,
-0.0218886826,
0.0308125,
0.0177700967,
-0.0773679614,
0.0331029631,
0.020594202,
-0.004967527,
-0.0010614535,
0.006667098,
0.0928474888,
-0.0215057377,
-0.0003762635,
-0.0382898748,
-0.0095477132,
0.0188461393,
-0.0672271773,
0.0061944742,
-0.0375917852,
-0.0135918604,
0.0101604946,
-0.0052850423,
-0.0473003611,
0.0242951307,
-0.0047580707,
-0.0108628813,
0.1196106076,
-0.043784827,
-0.0174910929,
0.0219087042,
0.0130075999,
0.0006802669,
0.0572509207,
0.0265501626,
0.079449147,
0.0088003995,
-0.0193292685,
0.0349543318,
-0.0031008455,
-0.0321137607,
0.0118936375,
-0.0718867183,
0.0181709025,
-0.0345179439,
0.0351131558,
0.0146638863,
-0.005011701,
-0.0114409281,
-0.024648007,
0.0575432889,
-0.0035055059,
-0.0036126971,
0.0076296208,
0.0694998726,
0.001923338,
-0.0018486903,
-0.0141473832,
-0.0603156984,
0.0967411473,
-0.0439319387,
0.0195833128,
0.011878564,
0.0461302102,
-0.0227272492,
-0.078053847,
-0.0369824767,
-0.0044533843,
-0.0409358628,
-0.0142539982,
0.0310217608,
-0.0500304885,
-0.014614311,
-0.0291416124,
0.011160804,
0.009719396,
-0.0229289811,
0.0011733961,
0.0015652608,
0.0889461637,
-0.0373089164,
-0.0042565134,
-0.0267963428,
0.0146632828,
0.021691028,
0.0164376441,
0.0369995125,
0.0298314858,
0.0232239384,
-0.0597703494,
-0.0399456359,
0.0010458217,
0.0222015083,
0.0266843121,
-0.036238905,
0.0000422392,
-0.0052985996,
0.0197394677,
-0.0096961483,
0.0169466529,
0.0235424973,
-0.0494821817,
-0.0350900292,
0.0204460267,
0.0482071824,
-0.0611567199,
0.0317825712,
0.002410321,
0.0182663314,
-0.0334691405,
-0.0434406362,
0.0799370781,
-0.05149002,
0.0033299651,
0.0062570632,
-0.021849703,
0.0107762469,
0.0248326492,
-0.0708044842,
-0.0330112055,
0.0647573546,
0.0052098227,
-0.0160175841,
-0.0444938578,
-0.0392236337,
0.0535840951,
0.0193402655,
0.017086884,
0.0417449512,
-0.0280593317,
-0.0515148416,
-0.0175694209,
0.0323577784,
-0.0019386312,
-0.0051385523,
0.0369174816,
-0.0041428488,
0.0296769924,
0.0139506776,
-0.0404037423,
-0.0115668848,
-0.0303232726,
0.0138089657,
-0.0448940843,
-0.0041669281,
-0.021753855,
0.0259835944,
0.0097902128,
-0.0283727739,
-0.0192391705,
-0.0189442933,
-0.0058064172,
0.0490359962,
-0.0159180854,
-0.0034012492,
0.0343506262,
-0.0058944738,
-0.0003682546,
-0.0020006271,
0.0077057877,
0.0141672334,
0.0656402633,
0.0565553643,
-0.0424376875,
-0.025499355,
-0.0303468872,
-0.0689096227,
0.0375485383,
-0.0148956608,
-0.0168746822,
0.0177623518,
-0.0581138395,
0.0130731957,
-0.0000811785,
0.0100676538,
0.0342633761,
0.0226134062,
-0.0081400052,
-0.0403443873,
0.034530703,
-0.0173094887,
-0.0254288744,
-0.0268971473,
-0.0057459977,
-0.0455405153,
0.0304007828,
-0.0122681726,
0.0297717433,
-0.0116998879,
0.0786277652,
0.0139792236,
-0.0074707912,
-0.0656416938,
-0.0031075047,
0.0073447064,
0.0495376475,
-0.0099823521,
-0.0895515904,
0.0375204794,
-0.005739891,
0.0062546683,
-0.0259153228,
-0.0242838245,
-0.0241458062,
0.0569285192,
-0.021246694,
0.0323205926,
0.003144637,
0.0299877636,
-0.0375834778,
-0.064522557,
0.00393384,
0.0148651684,
-0.0029889178,
-0.0715814829,
0.0102790799,
0.0026832195,
-0.0127249788,
-0.0373854265,
0.0149198947,
-0.0878682956,
-0.0074938606,
-0.0324838795,
-0.0284926239,
-0.0315846652,
0.0067391219,
0.0018858691,
0.0171946622,
0.0101208482,
-0.0272824317,
-0.0158694424,
0.0420743972,
0.0456055999,
0.0441027135,
0.0255865436,
-0.0482267216,
0.0159794148,
0.0029054345,
0.0540998429,
-0.0248669311,
-0.0934894308,
0.0684290752,
-0.0022222723,
0.0252352636,
-0.0307017639,
0.0349725224,
0.0482202098,
-0.0651181266,
0.0420732498,
0.0662633181,
0.0195212886,
-0.0054961503,
-0.0141558703,
-0.0272261444,
0.0065862355,
0.0174524393,
-0.0027647188,
-0.019470863,
-0.0711712465,
0.0205730051,
0.0112416716,
0.0325024948,
-0.0327345096,
-0.0195626654,
-0.0272561628,
0.0966852009,
0.0026426944,
-0.004717669,
-0.0377026871,
-0.0608265847,
-0.0034244624,
-0.0401459299,
-0.0348083489,
-0.0504363291,
0.0137889264,
0.0222952701,
0.0201556422,
-0.0151362419,
-0.0410339348,
0.013416349,
-0.0471473858,
-0.0304588284,
0.0330773555,
-0.0002743707,
-0.0068363859,
-0.0784196332,
-0.0160289351,
-0.0070072389,
0.0383144841,
-0.0141652254,
0.0318752266,
-0.0007251819,
-0.0199502278,
-0.0364727862,
0.0719476566,
-0.0311526805,
-0.0066065807,
0.0247297678,
0.0581813529,
-0.0466431528,
-0.018605534,
-0.0373268984,
-0.0054866369,
0.0356740281,
0.0369075872,
-0.0102449032,
-0.0124628311,
-0.0638062805,
-0.0531156138,
-0.0065742326,
-0.0464501604,
-0.041101858,
-0.0038249707,
0.0588856973,
-0.0270222519,
-0.0232072622,
-0.017236989,
0.0428579003,
0.0411240123,
-0.0290686339,
-0.0345971398,
0.0103893802,
-0.0172398183,
-0.0534333475,
0.0610530637,
0.0239872225,
0.0159869809,
-0.0111275185,
0.0332750194,
0.0311768781,
-0.0437769778,
-0.0088874474,
0.028529061,
-0.0766202956,
0.0154804802,
0.012278826,
0.0588745251,
0.0201257337,
0.008625132,
0.0283649974,
-0.0100483112,
0.0114652421,
0.0486026369,
0.0031932811,
0.0138048911,
0.005589928,
-0.0190377161,
0.0179322641,
0.016002113,
0.0036558108,
0.0513008684,
-0.0288431663,
-0.0125705842,
-0.0284573324,
0.0057319491,
0.0031561416,
-0.0237274077,
0.0502666086,
-0.0108794048,
-0.0710443258,
-0.0337095521,
0.0066485466,
0.0310057364,
-0.0044594863,
-0.0458791368,
0.0619578138,
0.0115907304,
0.0512540229,
-0.0102643818,
-0.0193497445,
0.0264354087,
-0.0063388711,
-0.0086761201,
0.022918677,
0.0767292082,
-0.0048305094,
0.0104690511,
0.0013171973,
0.0179988686,
0.0074030976,
-0.0068986863,
0.0205474962,
-0.005294688,
0.038845595,
0.0093061589,
0.0246666595,
-0.0109418239,
0.0319427662,
-0.0565229021,
-0.0819763094,
-0.0480322354,
0.0393007472,
0.0222644228,
0.0462250225,
0.00100427,
-0.070282191,
0.0014955357,
-0.0212315843,
0.0349161588,
0.0394528843,
-0.0202529989,
0.0731874555,
0.0111285681,
-0.0444771983,
-0.0205739923,
0.0288628861,
0.0075324769,
0.06957791,
0.0144970305,
-0.0170804113,
-0.0341453254,
-0.0249203779,
0.0238485485,
0.0082656378,
0.0081583532,
0.007089477,
-0.0690526515,
-0.0290596187,
0.0228982773,
0.005393235,
-0.0724408329,
-0.0243809,
0.023905715,
0.0527973473,
0.0024805432,
0.0293458048,
0.0024002902,
0.0049401829,
-0.0470650457,
0.0289858952,
0.0176919904,
-6.257656749e-33,
-0.0261453446,
-0.0058310032,
0.0479336195,
-0.0196472872,
0.0175442658,
0.0394016951,
0.000713786,
-0.0202763826,
-0.0100015337,
0.0183183998,
0.0334608965,
-0.0233737379,
0.0058565573,
0.0046040015,
0.0676984563,
0.0103711877,
0.0243503861,
-0.0335666649,
-0.0112933591,
-0.0305174906,
0.0596697815,
0.0039812657,
0.0234562252,
-0.0681336299,
-0.0155062377,
0.006481091,
-0.0564078353,
-0.0106080454,
-0.0278964229,
0.0521328673,
-0.0379783846,
0.0330952927,
0.0049571143,
-0.0336386673,
-0.0575642474,
0.0348179787,
-0.0363880731,
-0.043342784,
-0.0184737723,
-0.0395915657,
-0.0905765072,
0.0002165991,
0.0113748042,
0.0432167724,
0.0104231564,
-0.0260616727,
0.040336214,
-0.0295606237,
0.0088196127,
-0.0186158791,
0.0087456079,
0.0502073839,
-0.0170788411,
-0.0159998201,
0.028803356,
0.0126405628,
0.0006160978,
0.045922935,
-0.0364684947,
0.0097722169,
0.0073205004,
0.0047939727,
0.0833616927,
0.0302639436,
0.0169018507,
0.0863432437,
0.0217584986,
-0.1026804969,
-0.04110929,
-0.0100172963,
0.0241835248,
0.0881560817,
0.0477040559,
0.1120242774,
0.0308984891,
0.0004177968,
-0.0340933539,
0.0233291239,
-0.0293816291,
0.0752048194,
0.0050716954,
0.0069742482,
0.0087353047,
-0.0144328289,
-0.0292479936,
-0.0175448935,
-0.0352057926,
0.0127809402,
0.0552388057,
-0.0308207553,
0.0559754223,
0.0883890241,
0.0135207828,
0.0179038402,
-0.0089605991,
0.0240589008,
0.0242100377,
0.0062535363,
0.0346572585,
0.0474492349,
-0.0623489805,
0.0000172675,
0.0183374416,
0.0210392047,
0.0067949751,
0.0143600022,
0.023816919,
0.0652289093,
-0.0322962925,
-0.025993051,
-0.0253104363,
0.0128052589,
-0.0027235108,
0.0298418608,
0.0402993411,
-0.0099249678,
-0.0267915409,
0.014197927,
-0.0372344106,
0.0000353866,
0.0026591884,
-0.0502646416,
-0.0045466139,
0.0485881232,
0.0124829039,
0.0257391594,
-0.0334475897,
-0.1096104831,
0.0109337829,
-0.0273093991,
0.0023793546,
0.0447074547,
2.71e-7,
0.0218637716,
0.0558534451,
0.0087908581,
0.0007086353,
-0.0237283036,
0.0780981109,
-0.0246444456,
0.0236263573,
0.0072395327,
-0.0048728995,
0.0162669197,
0.0369927026,
0.0563687682,
0.0588405617,
-0.0031548277,
0.0146265589,
-0.0333622657,
-0.0265497733,
-0.0603073314,
-0.0119975293,
0.0982644334,
0.0926158279,
0.0393065736,
-0.0004610819,
0.0751868635,
-0.0094553912,
0.0470537879,
-0.0201055072,
-0.0058993604,
-0.0252305772,
0.0002813022,
0.0113495085,
0.0052293194,
0.0335919783,
-0.0200256854,
-0.0396744162,
0.0277450923,
0.0329214409,
-0.0276076868,
-0.0458245166,
-0.0067614364,
0.007476158,
-0.0198619757,
-0.0521972738,
0.0474972092,
-0.0469497517,
-0.0283574611,
0.0223920513,
-0.0469522104,
0.0402282029,
-0.0017276207,
-0.0072250548,
0.0015181374,
-0.0035961394,
-0.016320724,
-0.0254122019,
-0.0363359898,
-0.0639458895,
-0.006659138,
-0.0115692718,
-0.0135556199,
-0.0129997144,
-0.0760909319,
-0.0317203999,
0.0920384824,
-0.0356321484,
-0.0391210988,
1.998957531e-34,
0.0162594859,
0.0270454865,
-0.0277649797,
-0.0302604735,
-0.0227813628,
-0.0034182037,
0.0107704895,
0.0178773124,
0.0075668572,
-0.0314089768,
0.0037145759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11214v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11214v1 | Global Data Constraints: Ethical and Effectiveness Challenges in Large Language Model | 2024-06-17T05:13:25 | 2024-06-17T05:13:25 | Jin Yang, Zhiqiang Wang, Yanbin Lin, Zunduo Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | The efficacy and ethical integrity of large language models (LLMs) are
profoundly influenced by the diversity and quality of their training datasets.
However, the global landscape of data accessibility presents significant
challenges, particularly in regions with stringent data privacy laws or limited
open-source information. This paper examines the multifaceted challenges
associated with acquiring high-quality training data for LLMs, focusing on data
scarcity, bias, and low-quality content across various linguistic contexts. We
highlight the technical and ethical implications of relying on publicly
available but potentially biased or irrelevant data sources, which can lead to
the generation of biased or hallucinatory content by LLMs. Through a series of
evaluations using GPT-4 and GPT-4o, we demonstrate how these data constraints
adversely affect model performance and ethical alignment. We propose and
validate several mitigation strategies designed to enhance data quality and
model robustness, including advanced data filtering techniques and ethical data
collection practices. Our findings underscore the need for a proactive approach
in developing LLMs that considers both the effectiveness and ethical
implications of data constraints, aiming to foster the creation of more
reliable and universally applicable AI systems. | [
0.0559506826,
0.1591949463,
-0.0435089581,
0.0629560947,
-0.0540048108,
0.0040079746,
0.0501462519,
-0.0126296123,
0.0190525167,
-0.0273004565,
-0.0293740742,
-0.0582879335,
0.0156915858,
0.003643746,
-0.0023384073,
-0.0198999289,
0.0422521755,
-0.0091137104,
0.0139175672,
-0.0452120453,
-0.002145865,
0.0389110371,
0.0464748554,
0.0265440457,
-0.0253646355,
0.0109381638,
0.0366881564,
-0.0361989178,
0.0015858175,
-0.0025474203,
0.002899905,
0.0475468785,
0.0090879323,
0.0957315713,
0.0000018444,
-0.0696415082,
-0.0231052935,
0.0304711834,
-0.0102387862,
0.002025252,
0.0542482249,
-0.0382004231,
-0.0011172361,
-0.006706228,
-0.0484654866,
0.0216603577,
0.0696116462,
0.0102295689,
0.0679532737,
0.0740851685,
-0.0006099737,
-0.0074658706,
0.0379888825,
-0.0114557873,
-0.0278535392,
-0.0078106695,
0.0619157366,
0.0049223588,
-0.0254776329,
0.0142407566,
-0.0144951819,
0.0614472479,
0.0290089045,
0.0177902542,
-0.0448012128,
-0.0161842648,
-0.0743755549,
-0.0580794774,
0.0325796865,
0.065913707,
0.0327654779,
-0.0297726933,
0.0129583338,
-0.0090984823,
0.003838347,
-0.0060512726,
-0.0005460057,
0.0868217126,
-0.0118997423,
0.0569890812,
0.0200990438,
-0.0137940533,
0.0435902029,
0.0587335452,
0.0106574604,
0.0400224775,
-0.0023300801,
-0.0575882383,
0.0041658683,
0.0183334518,
-0.0107144332,
-0.0111297555,
0.0140280444,
-0.0121872416,
-0.0104448767,
0.0500270613,
-0.0399585404,
-0.0063151363,
0.0440541431,
-0.0345307179,
0.0019189232,
0.0293187406,
0.0010724312,
-0.0052619204,
0.0458834618,
0.0181148443,
-0.0175665431,
0.0640052781,
-0.0307599045,
-0.0352622829,
0.0088564772,
0.0024663249,
0.015526955,
0.0212466922,
-0.037068259,
0.0457338244,
-0.0253743883,
0.0068006269,
-0.0548827313,
0.0192843582,
0.0003249203,
-0.0090857334,
-0.0137051437,
-0.0081225075,
-0.0408118255,
-0.0328742079,
0.0011485496,
0.0277198236,
-0.0306949653,
-0.0807235539,
0.0175641309,
0.0053401189,
-0.032922525,
-0.026647998,
0.0252862908,
0.0739535913,
0.0372872539,
-0.0212833509,
-0.0526953116,
-0.0177495386,
-0.0234920233,
-0.0851443633,
0.0045579351,
-0.0142109152,
0.0397812314,
-0.0213703625,
-0.0232236683,
-0.0823264942,
0.0031670767,
0.0225151274,
-0.0574170463,
0.0405111872,
-0.0352498032,
0.01903685,
0.028480446,
0.029006958,
0.0049558515,
0.0818210542,
0.0348266587,
0.0067198342,
0.0577593893,
-0.007713146,
0.0069820927,
0.019249253,
0.05124842,
0.0413362086,
-0.0497777015,
0.0326440707,
-0.0187191814,
0.0137242898,
0.0197364371,
0.1056211963,
-0.0054551386,
-0.0390841104,
0.0993537232,
0.0371217653,
-0.0311519764,
0.0268894304,
0.0015088121,
0.0041072113,
-0.0041164681,
-0.0146648185,
-0.0785364956,
-0.0332927927,
0.0016967286,
-0.0257881489,
-0.016569268,
0.0717588067,
0.004801936,
-0.0362072289,
-0.0075949631,
-0.0257685278,
0.0365747474,
0.0518235639,
0.0153755955,
-0.0343438163,
0.007639613,
0.0176415015,
0.0444150008,
-0.0475350171,
0.0009657341,
-0.0408545397,
0.0423675664,
0.0433553308,
0.0210557338,
0.0017116951,
0.0054845465,
-0.03058419,
0.0046321321,
0.0574292988,
0.0130682802,
-0.0132495388,
0.0342322774,
-0.0417592376,
-0.0408423208,
0.0085780201,
0.0010896436,
0.0015646361,
0.0242754966,
0.0357551575,
0.0201759227,
-0.0306911245,
-0.066825904,
0.0448756628,
-0.0186158065,
-0.0191008635,
-0.0270437133,
0.0011924007,
0.0305853095,
0.0276385453,
-0.0205555521,
-0.0298981313,
0.0036119372,
0.0226714835,
0.0228190869,
-0.0194173753,
-0.0406787656,
0.0551935509,
0.0224530101,
-0.0645484179,
0.0041741272,
0.0546881035,
-0.0276969094,
0.008032836,
-0.0070203296,
-0.0163010489,
0.017236989,
-0.0558966063,
-0.0045463415,
-0.0636587739,
0.0280028507,
-0.0251849331,
0.0457977392,
-0.0418906659,
0.0099481056,
0.0212823115,
-0.012179167,
0.0418280102,
-0.037679933,
-0.0403769314,
0.0540116243,
0.0031163914,
0.0510096848,
0.0404774025,
0.0201952234,
-0.011934163,
-0.0022029534,
-0.0533255935,
-0.0207067616,
-0.0078829098,
0.0041366918,
-0.0239253212,
-0.0131934863,
-0.0422966443,
0.009349254,
-0.0425851271,
-0.052695442,
0.0102385404,
0.0392304063,
-0.0027943328,
-0.0152299693,
-0.0198798086,
-0.0010453972,
-0.0190554019,
0.0106065953,
0.0231688786,
0.0139039801,
-0.0163124409,
-0.0377243757,
0.0084093716,
-0.0689756051,
0.0409325138,
0.0022602282,
-0.0149644101,
0.0107111447,
0.0369382985,
-0.0398680307,
0.0301830713,
0.0009827104,
0.0039323308,
0.0760448501,
0.029986307,
-0.0381151587,
-0.0280210786,
0.0116455499,
0.0027608946,
-0.019425571,
-0.0390309058,
0.0105530936,
0.0008388761,
0.0186793115,
-0.0371337086,
-0.0420744084,
0.0587352328,
-0.0692430884,
-0.0717272386,
0.0037540616,
-0.0491731949,
-0.0377649032,
0.0220189206,
-0.0210018996,
-0.0740106702,
0.0705771595,
-0.0061263782,
0.0407251269,
-0.0189299434,
-0.0110019315,
-0.0259416942,
0.0369339697,
0.0130530205,
0.0502645411,
0.019803483,
-0.0103316261,
-0.0442845784,
0.0086645326,
0.0608853661,
-0.0554949269,
0.0527229421,
-0.0386162475,
0.0161403921,
-0.014837102,
-0.0579516627,
-0.0615822636,
-0.0320130698,
0.0067728194,
-0.0018238728,
0.0416029282,
-0.0002443228,
-0.0109419888,
-0.0190666635,
0.041670654,
0.0236853659,
-0.0025524434,
0.0216742884,
0.0045150435,
-0.0413612984,
0.0382532291,
-0.0257321559,
0.0620798394,
-0.0036180238,
0.0075034369,
0.0209064782,
0.0077804215,
0.0066900356,
0.0322035141,
0.0162318591,
0.0309138447,
0.0080617182,
-0.0039953133,
0.0093268715,
0.0308643598,
-0.0541801453,
0.0143276183,
0.0859842896,
-0.0033920039,
-0.0619203486,
0.0033060205,
-0.0003903483,
-0.031523075,
0.008194821,
-0.0072448091,
-0.1045848653,
0.0159017425,
0.0061993338,
0.0489015877,
-0.087031208,
-0.0501501188,
-0.0253482126,
-0.1013946906,
0.0276987497,
0.0264421217,
-0.0420390777,
-0.0397517122,
-0.0402229317,
-0.0230156425,
-0.0547891408,
0.0852600783,
-0.0188390706,
-0.00308241,
-0.0307271145,
0.0127655668,
-0.0106037334,
-0.0670279264,
0.0076140356,
-0.0395245068,
0.0735035613,
0.0519422777,
0.0325028114,
-0.0467477776,
-0.0380338952,
0.000883765,
0.0029273354,
-0.052680064,
0.0007006724,
0.0236539841,
-0.0066774124,
-0.0220614057,
-0.0453113355,
0.0315485559,
-0.0011623201,
-0.0145071996,
-0.0086286375,
0.0770682469,
-0.0196370631,
-0.0277247727,
-0.0080835521,
-0.0287305303,
0.0289895386,
0.0885476619,
-0.0166078079,
-0.0381936245,
0.0093475692,
-0.0190805104,
-0.0103223613,
-0.0119995307,
-0.009079339,
0.0633121058,
-0.0266704932,
-0.0300561693,
-0.0403215028,
-0.0646160096,
-0.0162303392,
-0.0238861665,
0.0398627855,
-0.0032668463,
0.0439395383,
-0.0195492674,
0.00094113,
0.0445151776,
-0.0582048669,
0.0015595341,
-0.0269262474,
-0.0170462206,
-0.0132056773,
-0.0280576274,
0.0233808607,
0.0245871469,
-0.0204958133,
-0.0686796829,
0.0554670431,
0.0314823873,
0.0226282012,
0.0537451021,
0.0156310555,
-0.0400715247,
0.0366985053,
0.0412611291,
-0.0303412583,
0.0069380281,
0.0380900279,
-0.0133037614,
0.0015450415,
0.0309760123,
-0.0378147885,
0.0086517744,
0.0314882547,
-0.0147915399,
-0.046029456,
0.0114557818,
0.0446425006,
0.0391136073,
-0.0025290197,
-0.0620071851,
-0.025629662,
-0.0668736175,
-0.0251746587,
-0.0351550281,
-0.0242119022,
-0.0265034679,
0.013619598,
0.0492240153,
0.0233575925,
-0.0131965755,
-0.0165472887,
-0.025863139,
-0.0041480274,
-0.0511592627,
0.0251068808,
-0.0051134918,
0.0492420904,
0.0160857588,
0.0181541275,
-0.0331343971,
0.0592840128,
-0.0299010575,
0.048815459,
-0.00081878,
0.0397129133,
0.0271307379,
0.0115251848,
0.0259213708,
0.0289664324,
-0.0402741022,
-0.0367498249,
-0.0388902724,
-0.0057436363,
0.0184471514,
0.0025876684,
0.0332253985,
-0.0128515912,
0.0101921838,
-0.0076975203,
-0.0122433603,
0.0302340481,
-0.0484549925,
0.0061881146,
-0.0010703407,
-0.0478777178,
0.0331143029,
0.0652838647,
0.026133325,
0.0608184673,
-0.0131205274,
-0.0162068438,
0.0137654943,
-0.0606992282,
0.0131019792,
-0.0405160226,
-0.0581228174,
-0.028014984,
-0.0619161464,
-0.0863880068,
-0.0544470996,
-0.0031396353,
-0.0147026712,
-0.0267458055,
0.0082735708,
0.0386107899,
-0.0005459529,
-0.0130939214,
-0.0515577123,
-0.035723269,
-0.0042258352,
-0.0218289848,
0.0167846903,
-6.056661174e-33,
0.0193719827,
0.0005935421,
-0.0025108694,
-0.0308749303,
-0.0288742837,
0.0041190805,
0.0134866107,
-0.0069804126,
-0.0715238973,
0.0010296362,
0.002824595,
0.0095249079,
0.0034233867,
0.0305746477,
0.0002652294,
-0.0394680873,
0.0110707916,
0.0053316574,
-0.015132335,
0.0301592704,
0.0321750268,
-0.0125038316,
0.0632966235,
-0.0810491741,
0.0960680097,
-0.0107767992,
-0.0297638215,
0.0266144145,
-0.04482219,
0.0553483777,
-0.0162941702,
0.0865085647,
0.0337086581,
-0.0184036773,
0.0035144158,
-0.0015946822,
-0.0134700416,
-0.0050612935,
0.0307581555,
0.0127376178,
0.022552941,
-0.0402205177,
0.0456653275,
-0.0329713635,
-0.0268430728,
0.0274495389,
0.0035427499,
-0.0344804265,
-0.020747615,
-0.0075102509,
-0.0387947597,
0.0141495373,
-0.0146416686,
0.041055996,
0.0194392465,
0.0326519571,
0.0060176561,
0.0115837166,
-0.0318250991,
0.0145592829,
0.0441654474,
-0.0368209071,
0.0749881715,
-0.0064276624,
0.031822212,
0.0672918856,
0.0305678546,
-0.0004930194,
-0.0116147567,
-0.0427371673,
0.0266211722,
0.0239366796,
0.0247137696,
0.0822050422,
-0.005175435,
-0.0604126453,
-0.0581250452,
-0.026697889,
-0.0210204571,
0.0261982549,
0.00448384,
-0.0376582369,
-0.0666278675,
-0.0368072912,
-0.0259528719,
-0.0524639711,
-0.0263324305,
-0.0001723076,
0.0375915244,
0.0031727832,
-0.0220925845,
0.0225804467,
0.0279449616,
-0.0650909021,
-0.0137305642,
0.0253057498,
0.0164042823,
-0.0384536982,
0.0149804251,
0.0314439088,
-0.0519102477,
-0.0295280311,
-0.0041583576,
-0.018983027,
0.0249255411,
0.0069480338,
0.0327130705,
0.0305475555,
-0.026079556,
0.0194888599,
-0.0214067772,
0.0503201224,
0.0268406589,
-0.0047768778,
0.0340445079,
0.0066486117,
0.0150991706,
0.0251765214,
0.0717139393,
0.0253465828,
-0.0420740508,
-0.0049091214,
-0.0181767382,
0.005773684,
-0.022279609,
-0.0249559171,
-0.0006251667,
0.0294652879,
0.0668059066,
-0.0479782932,
-0.0030830484,
0.0001026632,
2.618e-7,
0.0275128353,
0.0241731424,
-0.0242943969,
0.0276735462,
-0.0340984873,
0.0216258168,
0.0086288461,
0.0406918302,
-0.0206936281,
-0.0154409846,
0.006087312,
0.0076096212,
0.05648534,
0.0885007754,
-0.0458955728,
-0.0061091376,
-0.0535458736,
-0.0103990296,
-0.0797117352,
0.0399807766,
0.0125724059,
0.0887816101,
0.0193647314,
-0.0306623466,
-0.0283089373,
-0.0449160561,
0.0381852165,
-0.0712564886,
0.0061906273,
0.0100207226,
0.0547115542,
0.022250928,
0.0354334116,
-0.003907023,
0.0059501627,
0.0352178141,
-0.0071799331,
0.0581943691,
0.0000530975,
-0.0154477851,
-0.016395852,
-0.0581314899,
-0.0197932199,
-0.0826896131,
0.0703610405,
0.0242006183,
-0.0331559218,
-0.0226507112,
0.0238562543,
-0.0519294962,
0.0349910408,
-0.0439990498,
-0.0061002225,
-0.0018513555,
0.0162807442,
-0.0047577918,
0.0190536398,
-0.0344288833,
0.0122201685,
-0.0521112829,
-0.0103934826,
-0.062360391,
0.0134471925,
0.0077595385,
0.0040503927,
-0.0296829082,
0.0621405393,
2.377968593e-34,
0.0045301258,
-0.0501413643,
0.0257698782,
-0.0038571151,
0.0302061234,
0.0372300558,
0.0119808353,
-0.0108615328,
-0.0227946322,
-0.0277686715,
-0.0086660692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11201v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11201v2 | Fine-Tuning or Fine-Failing? Debunking Performance Myths in Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T04:35:17 | 2024-06-30T14:42:52 | Scott Barnett, Zac Brannelly, Stefanus Kurniawan, Sheng Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have the unique capability to understand and
generate human-like text from input queries. When fine-tuned, these models show
enhanced performance on domain-specific queries. OpenAI highlights the process
of fine-tuning, stating: "To fine-tune a model, you are required to provide at
least 10 examples. We typically see clear improvements from fine-tuning on 50
to 100 training examples, but the right number varies greatly based on the
exact use case." This study extends this concept to the integration of LLMs
within Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) pipelines, which aim to improve
accuracy and relevance by leveraging external corpus data for information
retrieval. However, RAG's promise of delivering optimal responses often falls
short in complex query scenarios. This study aims to specifically examine the
effects of fine-tuning LLMs on their ability to extract and integrate
contextual data to enhance the performance of RAG systems across multiple
domains. We evaluate the impact of fine-tuning on the LLMs' capacity for data
extraction and contextual understanding by comparing the accuracy and
completeness of fine-tuned models against baseline performances across datasets
from multiple domains. Our findings indicate that fine-tuning resulted in a
decline in performance compared to the baseline models, contrary to the
improvements observed in standalone LLM applications as suggested by OpenAI.
This study highlights the need for vigorous investigation and validation of
fine-tuned models for domain-specific tasks. | [
0.0516934432,
0.0399417542,
-0.0141233234,
0.0114123793,
-0.0130067402,
0.0119232275,
0.013915197,
-0.0071001933,
-0.0289994739,
-0.0826001465,
-0.0376404971,
-0.0251350254,
-0.0160339065,
0.0141322399,
0.0335528404,
-0.0191423185,
0.0512138195,
-0.0086399922,
-0.022936238,
0.0198074896,
-0.0390435122,
0.0268355142,
0.0211502369,
0.0460366048,
0.0240634196,
0.0147525957,
-0.00510538,
0.0387480855,
0.0095024435,
-0.0000872034,
0.0292252004,
0.0235459637,
0.0345860757,
0.0532615036,
0.0000018488,
-0.0734521598,
0.0140454806,
0.028898973,
-0.0092242323,
0.0334602073,
0.049297601,
0.0138669666,
0.0218842532,
0.0406773686,
-0.0287142433,
-0.0102449292,
0.0208682343,
0.0390775539,
0.0317365155,
0.0914142132,
0.0110365003,
-0.029289918,
0.0248271096,
-0.0419709533,
0.0145389335,
-0.0615194365,
0.0158500094,
-0.0039211758,
0.0389102176,
0.0196056105,
0.0162332281,
0.0306720212,
0.0141636385,
-0.0047108009,
0.0177962873,
0.0477480479,
-0.0669230595,
-0.0195176844,
0.0209896769,
0.0641188547,
0.005457323,
-0.0059758094,
-0.0068418402,
-0.0076489341,
-0.0064594159,
0.0158681013,
-0.0346765444,
0.0196954366,
-0.0022628433,
0.0232166536,
-0.0104750078,
-0.0134169534,
0.0413236432,
0.0376659557,
-0.0522651225,
0.0444297642,
0.0199056864,
-0.025184799,
-0.0038668124,
0.0197235011,
-0.0225114301,
-0.024364911,
-0.0129296575,
0.0378298834,
-0.0310670901,
0.0204556212,
-0.0330246054,
-0.0372468121,
0.0434407033,
-0.0145996306,
0.0325348526,
0.0519762784,
-0.035048876,
0.027886942,
-0.0474529751,
0.02665204,
-0.0217299256,
0.0020460107,
-0.0678827912,
-0.0366868712,
-0.0466797315,
-0.0221562907,
-0.0360115059,
0.0359346718,
-0.0736150369,
-0.0377322696,
-0.0350626968,
0.0260381531,
0.0319725052,
-0.0170602892,
0.021740986,
0.0220532883,
-0.0762176886,
0.0080936719,
-0.0483657345,
0.0208834019,
-0.0316801928,
0.030922072,
0.0419655368,
-0.09081579,
-0.0075249653,
0.0105972085,
0.0024831411,
-0.0382128954,
0.000281282,
0.0229488686,
-0.0135823777,
-0.0378084108,
-0.06003711,
-0.0426060334,
-0.0163976699,
-0.073222056,
-0.0053370525,
-0.0448310636,
0.0222812742,
0.0223452281,
-0.0178243555,
-0.0341053978,
0.0128188366,
0.0366887301,
-0.0252069347,
0.0340147242,
-0.0007292829,
0.021317564,
0.0546001084,
0.0112009179,
0.042294994,
0.0875006393,
0.0245185867,
0.041946549,
0.0254035816,
0.018219905,
-0.023156831,
0.0119555295,
0.0271326117,
0.0272730943,
-0.0351013839,
0.0202449411,
-0.0101605821,
0.0496151187,
0.0470660329,
0.0528505519,
-0.0340270475,
0.0305710062,
0.0253986809,
-0.0006554805,
0.0748713017,
-0.0070564384,
0.0786172226,
0.0078760283,
-0.0096664028,
-0.0087107792,
-0.0337520838,
0.0084268348,
0.0055535706,
0.0447673239,
0.0501769669,
0.0429902375,
-0.0375226848,
-0.0336696692,
-0.0109821437,
0.0148264701,
-0.0492026545,
0.0195732377,
0.0564842112,
0.030767411,
-0.0341371633,
0.0255817212,
0.0268359631,
-0.0505080856,
0.0464954972,
-0.0601629615,
0.0100212684,
0.0758368894,
0.0772649497,
-0.0055280598,
-0.003394417,
0.0267938003,
-0.0011577196,
0.0317291208,
0.0623600185,
-0.0136326309,
0.0058517852,
-0.06305556,
-0.0475534387,
-0.0424406081,
0.0214703362,
0.009736198,
0.0408259183,
0.0034167692,
0.0684134439,
-0.0597557351,
-0.0385647453,
0.0500537455,
-0.0703658089,
-0.0566352643,
0.0194849521,
0.0002865753,
0.0017665777,
0.0066120727,
-0.0160662755,
0.0275787804,
0.0313541926,
-0.019392062,
-0.0091182636,
-0.0212672669,
-0.0092922105,
-0.0049884873,
0.006423559,
0.0148255741,
0.0234962609,
0.0085543497,
-0.0453861095,
-0.042426154,
-0.0108386045,
-0.0137554305,
0.0216100421,
-0.0863621011,
-0.0006531665,
0.0212938935,
0.015887646,
-0.0685321465,
0.0696378052,
0.0233620405,
0.0134509131,
0.022434812,
0.0399498791,
0.0223128516,
-0.0489061102,
-0.0076894402,
-0.0132687492,
0.0080749383,
0.0096079689,
0.0135849165,
-0.0120310988,
-0.0732611939,
0.0027375936,
-0.0975775719,
0.0084028775,
-0.0215727258,
0.0099110054,
0.0179408044,
0.0438853391,
-0.0154509991,
-0.0079569556,
-0.0260731131,
-0.0182674136,
0.0302895345,
0.0374237821,
0.0184462108,
0.0450760759,
-0.0055100704,
-0.0395675302,
0.0020515933,
0.0069200825,
0.0416412391,
-0.0070778313,
0.0078325942,
-0.0429086164,
0.0646239296,
-0.0417125188,
0.0166352112,
-0.0083246799,
-0.0101341549,
-0.0000873261,
-0.0330448411,
0.0280238334,
0.0375245139,
0.0055391421,
0.0105417212,
0.0262766797,
-0.0105725909,
-0.0860518292,
0.0253291056,
-0.0450929292,
-0.0517996736,
-0.0093444297,
-0.0106075015,
0.0228044204,
0.0110354936,
0.0070772143,
-0.0094750198,
-0.0305224806,
0.0172474552,
-0.0077415672,
-0.0366445631,
-0.0315311551,
0.0031907896,
-0.010734912,
0.0635132715,
-0.0228192098,
-0.0554525219,
0.0589844882,
-0.020961361,
0.0132538006,
-0.0357041992,
0.0090763913,
-0.0556073748,
0.0382925384,
-0.0231967289,
0.0341419093,
-0.0166734233,
-0.0258869696,
-0.0380968191,
0.0040946817,
-0.0094802706,
-0.0353319049,
0.0683999881,
-0.0306603722,
0.0281305332,
-0.0094159087,
-0.0399314165,
-0.0675269887,
-0.0237054117,
-0.0022854481,
0.0285985135,
0.0095132608,
-0.0132730706,
-0.0545302741,
-0.0081860572,
0.0124661895,
0.0249548033,
-0.029719092,
-0.0451153666,
-0.0103611695,
0.0377761573,
0.0590320975,
0.0049174665,
0.0159192327,
-0.0101360427,
0.0111008389,
0.0197936222,
0.0407697149,
-0.0249931272,
-0.024029268,
-0.0127270333,
0.0326073058,
-0.0426257513,
-0.0106440615,
0.0398233421,
0.0353487097,
-0.0463795811,
-0.0779117048,
0.0915748775,
0.0233186949,
-0.013450643,
-0.0007314057,
0.0091793854,
0.0474788658,
0.0279190913,
0.0619384125,
-0.0743351504,
-0.0230968948,
0.0118747735,
0.0750180334,
-0.0086759804,
0.0120877326,
-0.0100784209,
-0.1727714092,
0.0555678383,
-0.0028073955,
-0.0434226505,
-0.0175084341,
-0.0350188762,
0.0058267163,
0.006180448,
0.0528949536,
0.0428526662,
-0.0204562452,
-0.0065197083,
0.0312159676,
0.0593523532,
-0.1223434806,
-0.0026437936,
-0.0292708389,
0.0215233918,
0.0804783478,
0.0107886074,
0.0232248083,
-0.0170927867,
0.0471833721,
-0.0540886745,
0.068687968,
-0.0177207422,
0.0486896709,
0.0030040236,
0.0052644531,
-0.0187423415,
0.0049772034,
-0.0243562423,
-0.006018457,
-0.037873406,
0.0412265807,
-0.0345825404,
0.0184995271,
-0.0507889129,
-0.0281394441,
-0.020308435,
0.0825095102,
0.0246486496,
0.0006938881,
-0.0239297189,
0.0014044867,
-0.013249753,
-0.0647541732,
-0.0101616085,
0.0331556797,
-0.0293893944,
-0.0313721448,
-0.0459741242,
-0.0540913455,
0.0087877875,
0.0302551165,
-0.0070067556,
0.023562368,
-0.0258337781,
0.0086695086,
-0.0360763259,
0.0394576825,
-0.0572920442,
-0.002126534,
-0.0339114368,
-0.0100190938,
0.0432600193,
-0.0605228655,
-0.0195819382,
-0.0034157389,
-0.0711874068,
-0.0657591671,
0.0007047082,
0.023626497,
0.0270969234,
0.0220830813,
-0.0101942336,
-0.0571550764,
0.0263351183,
0.0717795789,
-0.0544681251,
0.0152649591,
-0.0282772779,
-0.0227508079,
-0.0138989985,
0.0186741594,
-0.0784139633,
0.022228254,
0.0001571381,
0.0532224141,
0.0172521938,
-0.0489489958,
0.0359269232,
0.0316073634,
0.0450145565,
-0.0219587348,
-0.0140832495,
-0.0326149501,
0.0169245843,
-0.019361414,
-0.0191150066,
-0.0283865295,
-0.0152297029,
0.0274738539,
0.0035575503,
-0.0087158466,
0.0100299362,
-0.016635621,
0.0774010792,
-0.070731692,
-0.0284942649,
-0.0037324601,
0.0220102705,
0.0352877825,
0.0004810076,
-0.035205029,
0.0298580527,
0.0010384154,
0.0515488088,
-0.0467770323,
0.0292148292,
0.0075343461,
0.0273451228,
-0.019270625,
0.0187554359,
-0.0806401819,
-0.0295403376,
-0.0405957103,
-0.0109365173,
0.019132603,
-0.0215562955,
0.0422329009,
-0.0059437556,
-0.0065061287,
-0.029818546,
-0.0096006943,
0.0204310101,
-0.0167952459,
0.0179749578,
0.0213737767,
-0.0223677568,
0.0013023359,
0.0711969137,
-0.0266636573,
0.0633948892,
-0.040942803,
-0.020847667,
-0.0120416302,
-0.0368769392,
0.0160411112,
0.0387699045,
-0.0324002206,
-0.025687268,
-0.0556801334,
-0.0475146286,
-0.0167169515,
-0.0118129142,
0.006899246,
-0.0202675983,
0.0440627746,
0.0860877931,
0.0156819467,
-0.0127134016,
-0.0642528161,
-0.007298422,
-0.0613102876,
-0.0085826982,
-0.0018174775,
-6.740048039e-33,
-0.0452751145,
-0.0187303182,
0.0504877493,
-0.0377888232,
-0.0352144465,
-0.0151704699,
-0.0377607867,
-0.0339435004,
-0.0350716636,
-0.0297411066,
-0.0140093854,
0.0176522229,
0.0203468688,
0.0276885256,
0.0053351214,
-0.0001991411,
0.0582920946,
0.0190899484,
-0.0257807579,
0.0268847216,
0.0690931529,
0.0358062051,
0.0023858785,
-0.0557680018,
-0.0031389878,
-0.0187966023,
-0.0237396937,
0.017299762,
-0.0188533254,
0.0820847824,
-0.0036597881,
0.0658249408,
0.0334501751,
-0.0322205424,
-0.0102562616,
-0.0060406025,
-0.0698469058,
-0.010448576,
0.015159769,
-0.0161221437,
-0.0082755387,
-0.0385526232,
0.0668244213,
-0.0163766742,
-0.0180950686,
0.0052459235,
0.0383152403,
-0.0302614588,
-0.0373849235,
-0.0659436658,
-0.080521673,
0.0156830493,
0.0412108526,
-0.0107528381,
-0.0006614793,
0.0389158651,
-0.0014305842,
0.0670243576,
-0.0388203301,
0.0222920999,
0.0059264097,
0.064876616,
0.069891572,
0.0303935967,
-0.014695189,
0.0303124916,
0.0179101545,
-0.0015620358,
-0.0002946949,
-0.0164478552,
0.0508629642,
0.0553051345,
0.0050942404,
0.0663824752,
0.0261810292,
-0.0215746798,
-0.0681112483,
0.0627047345,
-0.0429550633,
0.0390993282,
0.0311566312,
0.0078297853,
-0.0468767881,
-0.017071791,
-0.053253565,
0.0181748569,
-0.0508866049,
-0.0055022482,
0.0591205619,
0.0481991656,
-0.0151032927,
-0.0069098994,
0.0316070803,
-0.0213798899,
0.0140523566,
0.0178465396,
-0.0392697528,
-0.0075595821,
-0.0270061605,
-0.0012617223,
-0.0450048968,
-0.0560793281,
0.0390106067,
0.0180559903,
-0.0206585657,
0.0021336561,
0.0176347811,
0.0251278188,
-0.055053141,
0.0118457722,
-0.0468877144,
0.0262471437,
-0.0048114285,
0.0243809205,
0.0232498925,
0.0138094733,
-0.012678422,
0.0517134145,
0.0252726581,
0.0006348759,
-0.0232392624,
-0.0365195088,
0.0404632911,
-0.0022298798,
-0.0191586092,
0.0390859246,
-0.0102987317,
0.0306947082,
0.0454474874,
-0.0215491075,
-0.0357876085,
0.0489549451,
2.689e-7,
0.0666301399,
0.0237634834,
0.0220350251,
0.0346655548,
-0.0021059173,
0.0214625113,
0.0045767184,
0.0041531064,
0.0423130207,
0.0116955722,
0.0179898441,
0.0261123311,
0.0381172672,
0.0177642852,
-0.0539035872,
0.0128884241,
-0.0303174201,
-0.0005950382,
-0.0583861731,
-0.0070084683,
0.0321147889,
0.0696472302,
-0.0243183523,
-0.0312665477,
0.0144771375,
-0.0581879318,
0.0798645169,
0.0016052657,
-0.0240464341,
0.0398533717,
0.0160713848,
0.0609478354,
0.0152148474,
-0.0104225902,
-0.030821437,
0.0199705642,
-0.0035061443,
0.0442898646,
0.012361967,
-0.0427658409,
-0.0000649231,
-0.0126288561,
0.0271132216,
-0.064114213,
0.061456766,
-0.0441698506,
-0.0014665222,
-0.0042354437,
-0.0145329144,
0.0078841448,
0.0094772056,
-0.0365709364,
0.0016198315,
0.0063394844,
0.0090402989,
0.0080230357,
-0.0355412513,
-0.0992593095,
-0.0004100272,
-0.0011178593,
-0.0563151203,
-0.0491761491,
-0.0450355373,
0.0095295738,
0.0068492703,
-0.0511042438,
-0.0144617241,
2.703174156e-34,
0.0275623351,
0.0049300781,
0.0042378404,
0.00748188,
0.0223218109,
0.0127322562,
-0.0185519531,
0.0245245751,
0.0041171154,
-0.1086947694,
-0.0358900204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11200v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11200v2 | AvaTaR: Optimizing LLM Agents for Tool-Assisted Knowledge Retrieval | 2024-06-17T04:20:02 | 2024-06-18T01:39:57 | Shirley Wu, Shiyu Zhao, Qian Huang, Kexin Huang, Michihiro Yasunaga, Kaidi Cao, Vassilis N. Ioannidis, Karthik Subbian, Jure Leskovec, James Zou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large language model (LLM) agents have demonstrated impressive capability in
utilizing external tools and knowledge to boost accuracy and reduce
hallucinations. However, developing the prompting techniques that make LLM
agents able to effectively use external tools and knowledge is a heuristic and
laborious task. Here, we introduce AvaTaR, a novel and automatic framework that
optimizes an LLM agent to effectively use the provided tools and improve its
performance on a given task/domain. During optimization, we design a comparator
module to iteratively provide insightful and holistic prompts to the LLM agent
via reasoning between positive and negative examples sampled from training
data. We demonstrate AvaTaR on four complex multimodal retrieval datasets
featuring textual, visual, and relational information. We find AvaTaR
consistently outperforms state-of-the-art approaches across all four
challenging tasks and exhibits strong generalization ability when applied to
novel cases, achieving an average relative improvement of 14% on the Hit@1
metric. Code and dataset are available at https://github.com/zou-group/avatar. | [
0.0367155112,
0.0024372521,
-0.018656522,
0.0370808393,
-0.021102123,
0.0073506217,
-0.0127638225,
0.0292682834,
0.0564260557,
-0.05219993,
-0.0542626716,
-0.0318667069,
-0.0630875677,
-0.0009589785,
0.018725954,
-0.0549021438,
0.0438878238,
-0.0123215774,
0.0129538942,
0.002563087,
0.0090856925,
-0.0024036649,
-0.0185867287,
0.0398354195,
-0.0350467041,
-0.017655598,
0.0100796064,
0.0262035523,
0.0015661565,
-0.0442336015,
0.0164264422,
0.0338047929,
0.0277229194,
0.0222591963,
0.0000021534,
-0.0507993177,
-0.0150304325,
-0.0207902137,
-0.0118827727,
-0.0566145703,
0.0744784251,
0.0035869291,
0.0434523299,
0.0042872336,
-0.060211353,
-0.0139108105,
0.0320200697,
0.0485670008,
0.071826838,
0.0707162544,
-0.0052858614,
0.0080738058,
0.0115439994,
0.0066950587,
0.0297199991,
-0.0140348151,
0.0213822145,
0.0215973016,
0.0312118735,
0.0117585286,
-0.0134664504,
0.0739548132,
-0.014341387,
0.0125996014,
0.0440967008,
0.0072278958,
-0.05962063,
-0.0449242666,
0.0062939771,
0.0834496096,
0.0182574019,
-0.006224276,
0.0002513201,
0.0116578965,
0.0137478467,
0.0465876907,
-0.0634180456,
0.0207254905,
-0.0318897776,
-0.0026444988,
-0.037238203,
-0.0167887826,
0.0382115543,
0.0126864966,
-0.0253798291,
0.0331433974,
-0.0041314191,
-0.0293089505,
0.0561390854,
-0.015199556,
-0.0047463854,
-0.0257872231,
0.0076144706,
0.041414842,
-0.0637678653,
0.0044799605,
-0.0016316033,
-0.0277717132,
0.0358594395,
-0.066878967,
0.0199735053,
0.0170963444,
-0.0673326626,
0.0743944719,
-0.0382882431,
0.0154651115,
-0.0040432708,
0.069661513,
-0.0208349265,
-0.0215508975,
-0.0470574088,
-0.0193342026,
-0.029755624,
0.0101868454,
0.000914668,
-0.0474013835,
0.0053438982,
0.0380969346,
-0.0314024091,
0.0312081072,
-0.0134831844,
0.0140229808,
0.0165713467,
-0.0130604915,
-0.0691156462,
0.0152337048,
-0.0303219203,
-0.0017091525,
-0.0015537948,
-0.0288166311,
0.0136583652,
0.0260051172,
-0.0065945582,
-0.0210837945,
0.0190217048,
0.095825389,
-0.0077349474,
-0.0394561961,
-0.0244559087,
-0.0303320568,
0.0289926101,
-0.0437248796,
0.0138687184,
-0.0459030047,
0.0126131307,
0.0088849319,
-0.0114374245,
-0.0602030046,
0.0328615829,
0.0230910983,
-0.0238214824,
0.0827848613,
-0.0256837104,
0.0092054866,
0.0514846668,
0.0303327888,
-0.0473858714,
0.0644566268,
-0.0292013716,
0.057693284,
0.0792687759,
-0.0038816279,
0.0367703065,
0.0336213522,
-0.0174550228,
-0.0047234255,
-0.0245281216,
0.0251490623,
0.0098206056,
0.0288026091,
-0.008917707,
0.0460289493,
-0.0295855794,
-0.0286436379,
0.0477258936,
0.0358973742,
0.0296735577,
-0.0364534855,
-0.0002725973,
0.0074788821,
-0.0180210229,
-0.0220990572,
-0.060162548,
0.0653018579,
-0.0441721044,
-0.012334343,
0.0490623377,
0.0176572539,
-0.0256780908,
-0.0248219706,
-0.0228708033,
0.0130108539,
0.0120938262,
0.056543041,
0.0347452499,
-0.0229257699,
-0.0490372144,
0.0280405879,
0.0258181058,
-0.0288702566,
-0.0312128495,
-0.0520294122,
0.0330050215,
0.0904439837,
0.0714654699,
-0.0636659488,
-0.018194614,
-0.0072964584,
0.0307962168,
0.0476263613,
-0.0220784638,
-0.0145187741,
-0.0093954001,
-0.0688331947,
-0.0529277474,
0.0212297328,
-0.0037907294,
-0.0054630209,
0.0122078955,
0.0095961643,
0.0316644572,
-0.0456719175,
-0.0192623306,
0.0553836487,
0.010742099,
-0.0489445664,
-0.0327083394,
0.0293206852,
0.0077451495,
-0.006610828,
-0.0118119875,
0.0088578966,
0.0407156609,
-0.0377806276,
-0.0547311045,
-0.0040815794,
0.0030810023,
-0.0058433753,
0.0399443097,
-0.0124103399,
0.0429259799,
-0.0061727106,
-0.0096964389,
-0.0071250387,
0.0040444741,
-0.0038004443,
0.041246023,
-0.063186802,
0.0176635925,
0.0079606557,
0.0240300409,
-0.0458547026,
0.0652552322,
-0.0060835676,
-0.0013986028,
0.0230160933,
0.0111795254,
-0.0105251484,
-0.0226518996,
-0.03039876,
0.0131557649,
0.0301736593,
0.045348689,
0.0165912844,
-0.0210319981,
-0.0611573271,
-0.009653192,
-0.1090336144,
0.0015515323,
-0.0112542361,
-0.029240936,
-0.0253039096,
-0.0304935034,
-0.0122903716,
-0.0392136946,
-0.0177372303,
0.0366210341,
0.0033141142,
0.060275957,
0.0136343166,
-0.0005913866,
-0.0182612073,
-0.0414088815,
-0.0091358563,
0.0159774739,
0.0381800048,
-0.0192565136,
-0.0238303673,
-0.0422719531,
0.0545039624,
-0.0771016553,
0.0419097878,
-0.0279484,
-0.0017491697,
0.0240131989,
-0.0715186968,
0.0063455338,
0.0773370713,
0.024076961,
-0.0022160579,
0.0606444925,
-0.008894857,
-0.0909347609,
0.0073124319,
0.0033668205,
-0.0149931908,
0.0158357639,
-0.020734746,
0.002016491,
0.0008196753,
0.0163538903,
0.0203598998,
-0.0542201623,
0.0103742164,
0.021376919,
-0.0457801782,
-0.0489052758,
0.0254339967,
0.0149336737,
0.0529408529,
-0.0275397655,
-0.0441222936,
0.0696090832,
-0.0086398078,
-0.0110394852,
0.031068746,
-0.0118879909,
-0.031983044,
0.0835862532,
-0.0006849057,
0.014428311,
-0.04262463,
0.0041314238,
-0.0523363873,
-0.0335491113,
0.0198344402,
-0.0599430725,
0.046065446,
-0.0106269326,
0.0230205376,
0.0107502714,
-0.0276048351,
-0.0724907517,
-0.0381643586,
-0.0093062334,
-0.0284071453,
-0.0544783957,
0.0238485914,
-0.0390570462,
0.0125881089,
0.0265531726,
0.0054086493,
0.0092070354,
-0.0295467637,
0.0053832154,
-0.0062946095,
0.0472190641,
0.0090213111,
0.003713975,
-0.0395738035,
0.0341876075,
0.0543640889,
0.0258826334,
-0.0417836346,
-0.0240048189,
-0.0301240198,
0.0242133215,
-0.0257307049,
0.0056495918,
-0.0042389343,
0.0201032683,
-0.0517842844,
0.0350159295,
0.1012184769,
0.0279197283,
-0.0781642422,
-0.0320543759,
-0.0597615466,
0.010992663,
0.0608624965,
0.0396005735,
-0.0832917243,
-0.0510947816,
-0.0020336094,
0.0388138592,
0.0080233347,
-0.0193269458,
0.0188732408,
-0.0969766825,
0.0471405201,
0.0048289057,
0.0239373837,
-0.00778194,
-0.0224918853,
0.0117341662,
-0.0204607937,
-0.0056913546,
0.0443075076,
-0.0231805891,
-0.0144476192,
-0.0139110042,
0.0324470848,
-0.0098963687,
0.0189903975,
-0.0558076464,
0.0266594738,
0.0795435831,
0.0031048688,
0.0023073386,
-0.0650426745,
0.0170330014,
0.0286009684,
0.0154993488,
-0.0271886867,
0.0645069703,
-0.0277810302,
-0.010984215,
-0.0159074254,
0.011635961,
-0.026847966,
0.008994489,
0.0177790746,
0.0761612952,
-0.0466520451,
0.0153311575,
-0.0439682752,
0.0091273021,
-0.0066556525,
0.0734743699,
-0.0100282598,
-0.0100003714,
-0.0038565581,
-0.0155478269,
0.0202318449,
0.0211966801,
-0.0360008366,
0.0291994214,
-0.009916597,
0.0365824886,
-0.0953635722,
-0.0326428041,
0.0375049487,
0.0361886583,
0.0231576972,
0.0234098956,
-0.056617219,
0.0164443161,
-0.0610688329,
0.0461348481,
-0.0240384787,
0.0104026143,
-0.0341740213,
0.0124822762,
0.0352833048,
-0.0522472076,
-0.0003379948,
0.024240762,
-0.0349529572,
-0.0356505848,
-0.0193728823,
0.0415508673,
0.017839279,
0.0265820846,
0.0141641079,
-0.0432696231,
0.0263077989,
0.068155624,
-0.0099110538,
-0.0114405993,
-0.0032206213,
0.0062044007,
-0.007531222,
0.0337739028,
-0.08468353,
-0.0015816611,
-0.0263644084,
0.0396830738,
-0.0155020105,
-0.0342403725,
0.0224780701,
0.0398363173,
0.0010234668,
-0.0069387057,
-0.0138722295,
-0.0434156694,
0.0128178485,
0.0077233477,
-0.0310758073,
-0.0332705341,
0.0372467339,
-0.0017950011,
-0.0353946015,
0.0280343834,
0.0084232604,
-0.0039251549,
0.0294207092,
-0.0464440733,
-0.0047276649,
-0.0256459713,
-0.0146418465,
0.0168045815,
0.0179346409,
-0.0244084615,
0.0660591871,
0.0177076031,
0.0613270514,
-0.0318167768,
0.1094330698,
0.0102730105,
-0.0196094234,
-0.0454463102,
0.0279870722,
-0.0228726882,
-0.08028391,
0.0238624457,
0.0549568236,
0.0639041662,
-0.0048850449,
0.0297378805,
-0.0345355831,
-0.0034907348,
-0.0179273151,
-0.0160283502,
0.0159920696,
-0.0244393181,
0.0170841105,
0.0424883664,
0.0010297194,
-0.002026258,
0.0597279444,
-0.0666950941,
0.0377108827,
-0.0287893917,
-0.0490974449,
-0.0430745445,
-0.0285378639,
0.0498992056,
0.0190460086,
-0.0212488491,
-0.005715616,
-0.0284010693,
-0.0561258271,
-0.0153743867,
-0.0084177991,
-0.0711357296,
-0.0113579342,
0.0353439339,
0.0839232132,
0.0292954184,
-0.0263329837,
-0.039518062,
-0.0163406152,
-0.028710736,
0.0019606999,
0.0173084512,
-6.542877964e-33,
-0.0279231947,
-0.0172696486,
0.0491601974,
-0.0272968486,
-0.0063516605,
-0.025024483,
0.0046308241,
0.013975692,
-0.0160964075,
-0.0106286192,
-0.0112521993,
0.0001866993,
0.0048940568,
-0.002016006,
0.0226988923,
-0.0016351178,
0.0230097435,
0.0144094704,
-0.0097055361,
-0.0107915625,
0.0537703298,
0.0572477467,
0.0087526515,
-0.0731297731,
0.0245484076,
0.010873341,
0.0133901797,
0.0372477546,
0.0014676937,
0.0510091521,
-0.0390648358,
0.0558125079,
0.0257315207,
0.000033312,
-0.0050782682,
-0.0201611929,
-0.0595223978,
-0.0292403214,
0.0038195269,
0.0102389371,
-0.0328002237,
-0.0142780272,
0.05727835,
-0.0368607342,
-0.0053031477,
0.0112062152,
0.0588180088,
-0.042151548,
-0.0362021104,
0.0103860963,
-0.0349467099,
0.0167340823,
0.0149088474,
-0.0353718288,
0.0339122266,
0.0586075149,
0.0035766738,
0.0289195478,
-0.085320048,
0.0320364423,
-0.0418697037,
0.0057726582,
0.060425289,
0.0418898873,
-0.001005951,
0.0979066268,
0.0420600399,
-0.0213654321,
-0.0380424783,
-0.0365171432,
0.0276043732,
0.0549103618,
0.0041320059,
0.0626985207,
-0.0146590425,
-0.0127745504,
-0.016485475,
0.040668752,
-0.0036265892,
0.0551489703,
0.0694216713,
0.0409195572,
-0.0467289872,
-0.0084343152,
-0.0256787278,
0.0133317541,
-0.0550763346,
-0.059744332,
0.0548029281,
0.0280454755,
0.0137536097,
-0.0286091976,
0.0343721434,
-0.0199932512,
0.0034684474,
0.0075444388,
-0.0285988245,
0.0004075934,
-0.0164893977,
0.006590242,
-0.0039263684,
-0.0099010905,
0.0387977026,
-0.0284247268,
-0.0056483485,
0.0184482951,
-0.008325994,
-0.0037888852,
-0.073721543,
-0.0107085807,
-0.0340282246,
0.0081960605,
-0.0174752306,
-0.006163653,
0.0095407758,
0.0115446215,
-0.0131897312,
0.052296333,
0.0145012429,
-0.0115778167,
-0.0366913006,
-0.0451426432,
0.0059150923,
-0.0253083874,
-0.0240787491,
0.0345188677,
-0.0309060011,
-0.0181662608,
0.0132744778,
-0.0609455444,
0.0033281795,
0.00658932,
2.888e-7,
0.0135682328,
0.0600186363,
-0.0275010988,
0.052878838,
-0.0150843356,
0.0373096131,
-0.0332246609,
0.0105232336,
0.0232023038,
-0.0630836636,
0.0228360221,
0.0635470748,
0.0301673915,
0.0426899195,
-0.0612197742,
-0.0341958404,
0.0097413119,
-0.0483057164,
-0.0744136572,
-0.0183144417,
0.077928327,
0.0701003149,
0.0045030029,
-0.0366932936,
0.0104891844,
-0.1120683104,
0.0802616924,
-0.0354223177,
-0.0215983503,
0.0002474037,
0.0294408202,
0.0506791584,
0.0126266871,
0.0250124447,
0.033677686,
-0.0104209185,
0.0259610191,
0.0409432873,
-0.0196842551,
-0.0661444589,
-0.0014475625,
0.0300224554,
-0.0047981967,
-0.0481930077,
0.0744868144,
-0.0093417233,
-0.0166091435,
-0.0034300222,
-0.0227503255,
-0.0131081147,
0.0284548681,
-0.0458588824,
-0.0436089933,
0.0182559043,
0.0077714566,
0.0013362039,
-0.0370133258,
-0.093723461,
-0.0069368151,
0.0049535828,
-0.0340418704,
-0.029360136,
-0.0209784713,
0.0068694879,
-0.0391001999,
-0.0443022102,
-0.0091084857,
2.651855792e-34,
0.0432836711,
0.0411660448,
0.0089164311,
0.0436585955,
0.0404920727,
0.0065781088,
-0.005784452,
0.0152997011,
-0.0115291243,
-0.1022386104,
-0.0098579563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11194v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11194v1 | In-Context Editing: Learning Knowledge from Self-Induced Distributions | 2024-06-17T04:00:04 | 2024-06-17T04:00:04 | Siyuan Qi, Bangcheng Yang, Kailin Jiang, Xiaobo Wang, Jiaqi Li, Yifan Zhong, Yaodong Yang, Zilong Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | The existing fine-tuning paradigm for language models is brittle in knowledge
editing scenarios, where the model must incorporate new information without
extensive retraining. This brittleness often results in overfitting, reduced
performance, and unnatural language generation. To address this, we propose
Consistent In-Context Editing (ICE), a novel approach that leverages the
model's in-context learning capability to tune toward a contextual distribution
rather than a one-hot target. ICE introduces a straightforward optimization
framework that includes both a target and a procedure, enhancing the robustness
and effectiveness of gradient-based tuning methods. We provide analytical
insights into ICE across four critical aspects of knowledge editing: accuracy,
locality, generalization, and linguistic quality, showing its advantages.
Experimental results across four datasets confirm the effectiveness of ICE and
demonstrate its potential for continual editing, ensuring that updated
information is incorporated while preserving the integrity of the model. | [
0.0585531257,
0.047360111,
0.0004469168,
0.0381176583,
-0.0153517053,
-0.0240862221,
-0.0249990076,
-0.0487079434,
-0.0611410812,
-0.0526689216,
-0.0529022589,
-0.009289599,
0.0101385536,
0.0131348753,
0.0399119779,
-0.0441554859,
0.0430686511,
0.0100637851,
-0.0127915218,
0.0183139853,
0.0081631802,
0.0000741262,
0.0124331787,
0.0170995183,
-0.0472245179,
-0.0242565367,
-0.004190092,
0.0602241345,
0.0247189309,
0.0077986782,
0.0482400469,
0.074125573,
0.0050415494,
0.0014736309,
0.0000021483,
-0.0403393321,
-0.0384210944,
-0.0145178018,
-0.0077430541,
0.018480571,
0.0364496149,
-0.0419411063,
-0.0632964298,
-0.0118058622,
-0.0408347286,
0.0488503762,
0.0645692125,
-0.0007461176,
0.0658419356,
0.078444697,
-0.0106833735,
0.009238814,
-0.0149896555,
-0.0554012433,
-0.0014700074,
-0.025976643,
0.0252171364,
0.0021135428,
-0.06372419,
0.003567402,
-0.041847121,
0.0512206852,
0.0239113234,
-0.0286376998,
0.0489735529,
0.0058845091,
-0.0590309426,
-0.0097746002,
-0.0263965614,
0.0709089115,
-0.0171811786,
-0.0256661288,
-0.0008226385,
-0.0134967482,
0.0258028153,
-0.0186457466,
0.0005147149,
-0.0087575596,
0.0345434994,
0.0255020745,
-0.0194990244,
-0.0442759544,
0.0476748049,
0.0273786224,
0.0011503085,
0.0588192791,
0.035570614,
-0.013251612,
-0.0580018833,
-0.0073286262,
-0.0620050505,
-0.0777493119,
-0.0034813292,
0.0183936078,
-0.033013843,
0.0262885075,
-0.0872244611,
-0.007129862,
0.0079372087,
-0.0264746267,
0.0355840772,
0.0467876084,
0.0128661981,
0.0449056961,
0.0229711737,
0.0004975325,
0.0290529206,
-0.0004317616,
-0.0242564846,
0.0221442804,
-0.0430629291,
-0.0140859056,
-0.0568355918,
-0.0030137836,
-0.0612725094,
-0.0012163522,
-0.0590227954,
0.0491456278,
-0.0075702746,
0.0029002123,
0.0127385743,
0.0242341645,
-0.070989728,
-0.0058210907,
0.0049805138,
0.0085922386,
-0.021540625,
0.0033877918,
0.031957604,
0.0116492175,
-0.0271239169,
0.0014358938,
0.0217478033,
-0.03021558,
0.0088145118,
0.0314841047,
-0.0295571964,
-0.0210627001,
-0.0264027305,
-0.0534067005,
-0.0577199645,
-0.0678361803,
-0.0505792424,
-0.0447215177,
0.0258482751,
-0.0215626117,
-0.0392053798,
-0.0792981982,
-0.0027795441,
0.0022096608,
-0.0217630584,
0.0676820874,
-0.0316401385,
0.0104266759,
0.0644660518,
0.016282212,
0.0070613055,
0.0763337687,
0.0432464369,
-0.0062391283,
0.0597993769,
0.0308900513,
-0.0054171984,
0.0301837269,
0.0426405482,
0.0219828766,
-0.046787791,
-0.0037082033,
-0.0095887342,
0.0382197201,
0.0559528135,
0.025863599,
-0.0288399607,
0.0127205644,
0.0921094716,
-0.0117829069,
0.0658799708,
0.0257985238,
0.0233252551,
-0.0136579201,
-0.0169219617,
-0.0108949058,
-0.0684211105,
0.0202467293,
0.0065208077,
0.0260299239,
0.0066660712,
0.011913538,
-0.0158839785,
-0.0391571112,
0.0015150065,
-0.0026093691,
0.00315719,
-0.0253330898,
0.0027538256,
0.0504272208,
-0.041243773,
0.0337149538,
0.0324514434,
-0.0185010601,
0.0103132091,
-0.0170994978,
0.0000784656,
0.072876431,
0.071061641,
-0.0030887211,
-0.0403221026,
-0.0196555201,
0.0119641256,
0.0386381857,
0.0360613875,
-0.031023996,
0.0105937459,
-0.0390496925,
-0.0349057131,
-0.0543598682,
0.0418264568,
-0.0150367981,
0.0320483297,
0.0173380617,
0.0459148847,
-0.0437927917,
-0.0046694814,
0.0294246096,
-0.0328736492,
-0.0098098116,
0.0058914339,
0.0116825001,
-0.004884568,
-0.0148887355,
-0.0268423595,
-0.0110770278,
-0.0094831875,
0.00347447,
-0.0042307251,
0.0109068993,
-0.0669016838,
-0.0368581377,
0.0414696336,
0.0063774614,
-0.0123688532,
-0.0330930166,
-0.0317428373,
-0.0323233195,
0.018550057,
-0.0191249084,
0.0665801987,
-0.0640738904,
0.0284448992,
0.0047295061,
-0.0011541336,
-0.0303642265,
0.0573702157,
0.0038549211,
-0.0509647578,
0.0253342818,
0.0417362005,
-0.0080280025,
-0.0367810726,
0.0218302552,
-0.0160525236,
-0.0003353024,
0.0073288074,
0.0100551713,
0.0368775688,
-0.0461601429,
-0.0412244983,
-0.0675708055,
0.0198824499,
-0.0523892343,
-0.0030182151,
0.0657932386,
0.035116192,
-0.0302991718,
-0.0102313077,
0.0077191116,
-0.0065366388,
-0.0286953878,
0.0076528373,
0.0434557684,
0.0382062718,
0.0133199571,
-0.0613509491,
0.0197757725,
0.0184788238,
0.0303249881,
0.0094861863,
0.0052407254,
-0.0403960645,
0.0372119136,
-0.0513135456,
0.0195678081,
0.0105963266,
-0.0261917189,
-0.0362462215,
0.0217240658,
0.1144843772,
0.0552908033,
0.0105664767,
0.0157725699,
0.0428477302,
-0.0200328734,
-0.0239087176,
0.0314323045,
-0.0218707733,
-0.0161682609,
0.0080508143,
0.011158091,
0.0136766657,
0.0612018034,
0.0248633493,
-0.0406047553,
-0.045864597,
0.0471153818,
-0.0052868095,
-0.0565645099,
-0.0413923524,
0.006220676,
-0.0225182138,
0.0121264597,
-0.0549603291,
-0.0579652227,
0.075719066,
-0.0001692168,
0.0383076742,
-0.040659491,
0.0028490988,
-0.009953104,
0.0112957414,
-0.0401355587,
0.0325354338,
-0.0201394446,
0.0108467247,
-0.0767445937,
-0.0198577996,
0.0458546951,
-0.0014174598,
0.0340260603,
-0.063621521,
0.0009629088,
0.0133683402,
-0.0315965451,
-0.0379628725,
-0.0345465839,
0.0196883772,
0.0214666501,
0.0230111256,
-0.0346490853,
-0.0012045678,
0.0091328649,
0.0058333501,
0.1065945029,
-0.0299307108,
-0.032800924,
-0.0202761311,
0.0028275957,
0.068648994,
0.0168918148,
0.0068507958,
-0.0046206932,
0.0104569085,
0.0371909291,
0.0190850999,
-0.0252266768,
0.0051042549,
0.0097305188,
-0.025353441,
-0.0502097905,
-0.0179860778,
0.0189868528,
0.0776697174,
-0.0501180924,
-0.0571156256,
0.1143447533,
0.0359524898,
-0.0391247086,
0.0372850224,
-0.0157444868,
0.0279376078,
0.0418255627,
0.026339341,
-0.0861520693,
-0.0396694168,
0.0140892044,
0.0459874831,
0.021982722,
-0.029217951,
-0.0236828811,
-0.0553598404,
0.0284476262,
0.0243023187,
-0.0461990871,
-0.0422463901,
-0.0190394428,
0.0251614302,
-0.0127683673,
0.0412728377,
0.0269307233,
-0.0060024671,
0.0260436684,
-0.0219655726,
0.0176746566,
-0.0991588607,
0.0017890201,
-0.0426484272,
0.0448441729,
0.0746008605,
0.0146159185,
0.0457425751,
0.0077376175,
0.042700313,
-0.0283731595,
0.0112780435,
-0.0229168814,
0.0193644632,
-0.0266456436,
0.0094788279,
0.013074371,
0.0456376337,
-0.0245263185,
-0.0338296443,
0.0065807374,
0.0479623489,
-0.011447263,
0.0222281739,
0.0003204619,
-0.0328896306,
0.0580231547,
0.0644393861,
0.0426388495,
-0.0328614339,
0.0051726121,
-0.045373708,
0.0066782078,
-0.0463199541,
0.0039580408,
-0.0093575669,
-0.0044992766,
-0.0143101634,
-0.1025712192,
-0.0411683545,
0.0171853881,
0.0414925739,
0.0253307726,
0.0030444036,
-0.0322608165,
-0.0198925938,
-0.0561584122,
0.0027959454,
-0.0469607748,
-0.0110366661,
-0.0473602936,
-0.0319191441,
0.0419431925,
-0.0520793386,
-0.0062204981,
0.0443325788,
-0.0425980128,
-0.0696668252,
0.0069727837,
0.0554286242,
0.0188726354,
0.097566314,
-0.022756638,
-0.0422574729,
0.0670201555,
0.0401492454,
-0.0127910711,
0.0570907779,
0.0153727503,
-0.0016975398,
-0.0011210276,
0.0519105829,
-0.0453599729,
0.0082860747,
0.0451295003,
0.0640525743,
-0.0194606166,
-0.05139241,
0.0363765024,
-0.0346379206,
-0.0146881687,
-0.0222779159,
-0.030263165,
-0.0517456718,
0.0449451506,
-0.032849852,
-0.0189835113,
-0.0334391743,
0.0124204447,
0.0118731959,
-0.0024934853,
-0.0178572331,
0.0206375588,
-0.0116831902,
0.0400405824,
-0.0415014066,
-0.0350599699,
-0.007743658,
0.0048986604,
0.0301115233,
0.0209655669,
0.0110769104,
0.0421484038,
-0.0237626024,
0.0056715086,
-0.0332543142,
0.023547614,
0.0295906961,
-0.0262215734,
-0.0454805605,
0.0450920686,
-0.0552752167,
0.0323112905,
-0.0574107543,
0.0094395559,
0.0632140413,
-0.002979113,
0.0439467989,
-0.0397661589,
-0.0423219837,
-0.0160042848,
0.0490828566,
0.0197646394,
-0.0248111282,
0.0039579589,
0.0079386858,
-0.0190725289,
0.0286056381,
0.0602215603,
-0.0054241358,
0.1023977548,
-0.0362625346,
-0.0060842116,
-0.0587085113,
-0.0003919385,
-0.0036567326,
0.0154601093,
-0.0281706862,
0.0101483306,
-0.0073805433,
-0.083753556,
-0.0046661487,
0.0254916772,
-0.0318981148,
0.0427685864,
0.0461273864,
0.0646634102,
-0.0330900513,
-0.0127686057,
-0.0282603614,
-0.0051910221,
0.0144844381,
0.0041360529,
-0.0149369044,
-6.544771244e-33,
-0.0227128938,
-0.005909143,
0.0165917184,
0.0028730619,
-0.0226371773,
-0.0150918616,
-0.057137005,
0.0010049621,
-0.0011007196,
-0.0027073119,
-0.0258343183,
0.0194462985,
-0.0048965625,
0.0347192921,
-0.0140841678,
0.0206892341,
0.0720055997,
0.011435993,
-0.0417224877,
0.0215345174,
0.0136626177,
0.042440854,
0.0654843226,
-0.0328251123,
0.0176309962,
0.0217726007,
-0.0422553979,
0.0381891653,
-0.0262295287,
0.0450071581,
-0.0138035053,
0.0357400589,
0.0037887394,
-0.0131688379,
-0.0369743556,
-0.0509869456,
-0.0485414863,
-0.0226269979,
-0.009246584,
0.0128822578,
-0.0309946537,
-0.0743258819,
0.0605451427,
-0.0193373337,
-0.0311714318,
-0.0058807014,
0.0269367844,
-0.0338961631,
-0.0210979208,
-0.041820623,
-0.0810499787,
0.0174888447,
-0.0028050183,
-0.0435814075,
-0.0189954247,
-0.0386545397,
0.0267738588,
-0.0310625508,
-0.0758264586,
-0.0009460059,
0.0057197567,
0.0563430116,
0.0782305077,
0.0151211061,
-0.005785686,
0.0212109406,
-0.0079734921,
0.0163045768,
0.0188344792,
-0.0390713364,
0.0311877895,
0.0122229811,
-0.0046975794,
0.0723661184,
0.0062563298,
-0.0213509742,
-0.0656791255,
0.0080147367,
-0.0470710769,
0.0056856042,
-0.0100456802,
0.0467481166,
0.0052221548,
-0.0021112249,
-0.0588655248,
-0.0064142994,
-0.0281593855,
-0.0173843578,
0.0374399461,
0.0582910851,
-0.0300669,
0.0225483831,
-0.0119644729,
-0.0106724007,
0.0067259148,
0.0288028121,
-0.0267980862,
0.0062357513,
0.0057669668,
-0.0073164986,
-0.0387781039,
0.0242243484,
0.0354404859,
0.0296499152,
-0.0133186039,
0.0012492427,
0.0557417497,
0.0543095283,
-0.0531254821,
0.0203787293,
-0.0069052866,
0.0572216436,
-0.00808076,
-0.0146185113,
0.0023834109,
-0.0069718445,
-0.0252201222,
0.0235589053,
0.0573084578,
0.0072715282,
-0.008510056,
0.03843119,
0.0016294841,
0.0340246484,
-0.018464461,
0.0079852631,
0.0090436656,
-0.010270129,
0.035341382,
-0.0570832454,
-0.0249658152,
-0.0111253709,
2.738e-7,
0.0761720464,
0.0564823896,
0.0132119711,
-0.0129978359,
0.0287314355,
0.0196098667,
-0.0133586694,
0.0074603502,
-0.0004640415,
-0.0101606511,
0.0375977233,
0.0387253575,
0.0104347169,
-0.003390095,
-0.0696671382,
0.0450032465,
-0.0536988899,
0.0480620749,
-0.0275058188,
-0.0401627384,
0.0007503592,
0.0693086013,
0.0252004564,
-0.0169283282,
-0.011510795,
-0.0361391567,
0.0747196525,
-0.0260552298,
0.0131331552,
0.0471402965,
-0.0102103474,
0.0307994764,
-0.0043421965,
0.0183740221,
-0.072107695,
0.0073023601,
-0.0228220336,
0.0806984305,
-0.0274609253,
0.0061613573,
-0.0026875858,
0.040931493,
0.0097229648,
-0.0669848472,
0.0550872944,
-0.0751991272,
0.0103122229,
-0.0265591294,
-0.0013353967,
0.032977134,
0.0106794713,
-0.0488711409,
-0.0360257067,
0.0157391783,
0.035514731,
0.0846549198,
-0.0416727103,
-0.0568908863,
-0.0423006974,
0.0136823896,
-0.0279459711,
-0.0288699344,
-0.0589950383,
-0.0297740474,
0.0366667025,
-0.0720180571,
0.0090531139,
2.709232773e-34,
0.0229491983,
0.0145496782,
0.0256207585,
0.0074543729,
0.0174738355,
0.0104337651,
0.0083634946,
-0.0064831339,
0.0219148565,
-0.0613403209,
-0.0344989859
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11193v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11193v1 | MMNeuron: Discovering Neuron-Level Domain-Specific Interpretation in Multimodal Large Language Model | 2024-06-17T03:59:44 | 2024-06-17T03:59:44 | Jiahao Huo, Yibo Yan, Boren Hu, Yutao Yue, Xuming Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Projecting visual features into word embedding space has become a significant
fusion strategy adopted by Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs). However,
its internal mechanisms have yet to be explored. Inspired by multilingual
research, we identify domain-specific neurons in multimodal large language
models. Specifically, we investigate the distribution of domain-specific
neurons and the mechanism of how MLLMs process features from diverse domains.
Furthermore, we propose a three-stage framework for language model modules in
MLLMs when handling projected image features, and verify this hypothesis using
logit lens. Extensive experiments indicate that while current MLLMs exhibit
Visual Question Answering (VQA) capability, they may not fully utilize
domain-specific information. Manipulating domain-specific neurons properly will
result in a 10\% change of accuracy at most, shedding light on the development
of cross-domain, all-encompassing MLLMs in the future. Our code will be
released upon paper notification. | [
0.043035455,
0.0353107005,
-0.0248603243,
0.090530552,
-0.020228805,
0.0005991472,
0.0429165438,
-0.0171946753,
-0.0131097063,
-0.0591330864,
-0.0539086126,
-0.045686055,
0.0249603447,
0.0549136922,
0.0681895763,
-0.0310280751,
0.0278034229,
-0.0361582376,
-0.0551680066,
-0.0267960522,
0.0149931004,
0.0148392962,
-0.007962184,
0.0582485683,
-0.0057529947,
-0.0367948376,
-0.0184104256,
-0.0033060666,
-0.0144116553,
0.027815327,
-0.025668839,
0.0190081522,
0.0566349067,
0.0018631683,
0.0000019127,
-0.0321692675,
0.02380923,
-0.0069339019,
0.027387239,
0.0141011868,
0.0323370285,
-0.050686717,
0.0067945686,
-0.0075079119,
-0.0270443521,
-0.0658077002,
0.0837581158,
0.0352281779,
0.0435285829,
0.0341656022,
-0.0094698817,
-0.0345037542,
0.00296282,
-0.0170608554,
0.0062362948,
-0.0348741263,
0.0072027831,
0.0338239186,
-0.0071704094,
-0.0147910221,
-0.0670032054,
0.0614762753,
0.0328846313,
-0.0050002872,
-0.0203248598,
0.0456206724,
0.0313646607,
-0.0493234545,
-0.011127485,
0.047636874,
-0.018672578,
-0.0165593736,
-0.0348536931,
0.0114682727,
0.0061544552,
0.01869414,
-0.0326713882,
0.0436737202,
0.0002981294,
0.0142824287,
-0.0133337462,
-0.0442928188,
0.0253005177,
0.002142139,
-0.0279333498,
0.0276701227,
0.041564472,
0.0343711264,
-0.0335477665,
0.0279432908,
-0.0423691757,
-0.0468911752,
-0.0025299785,
0.0403876938,
0.0225039143,
0.0166239124,
-0.0212224573,
-0.0251935236,
-0.013672201,
-0.0152870761,
0.0459423624,
0.0197059195,
-0.0333181769,
0.048448965,
-0.0043896297,
0.0421181135,
-0.0460911542,
0.0040329685,
-0.028902771,
-0.0479004644,
-0.019525487,
-0.0438819341,
-0.003954778,
-0.0017073147,
-0.0442983881,
-0.0656206012,
-0.0060046148,
0.0398605205,
0.013869076,
-0.0473881513,
-0.0198140126,
0.0292679965,
-0.0060157948,
-0.0140890619,
-0.0241033379,
0.0888957381,
-0.0167152118,
0.0129405167,
-0.0250908639,
-0.030795034,
-0.0101216994,
0.0539636761,
-0.0051849158,
-0.0587872826,
-0.0013755783,
0.1019200534,
-0.0240657218,
-0.0540656336,
-0.0204925761,
-0.0196477063,
-0.0501816981,
-0.0197237041,
0.0768896267,
-0.070575133,
0.015159091,
0.011890972,
-0.0124673834,
-0.0206764881,
-0.0009620205,
-0.002267421,
-0.0096719489,
0.0999358892,
-0.0214394592,
0.0050398228,
0.047150705,
0.0114516271,
-0.0044834614,
0.0517726578,
0.0067839306,
0.0276907608,
0.025508156,
-0.0082906419,
0.0128372628,
0.0798965618,
0.0022888221,
-0.0132758571,
-0.0554035045,
-0.0169544388,
0.0190290865,
0.0119338613,
0.054691609,
0.0141843073,
-0.0249953121,
-0.0387439243,
0.078577511,
0.0555826686,
0.0234299209,
-0.018012315,
0.0354806073,
-0.0231655706,
0.0135635836,
-0.0005804065,
-0.0496112891,
0.0737429112,
0.0018029895,
0.0031783753,
0.0089077735,
0.0743943229,
-0.0200569518,
-0.0194066968,
-0.0058330521,
-0.0137020415,
-0.0239080321,
0.0314390846,
0.0705107301,
0.0236435495,
0.0029822071,
0.0238129031,
0.0187237393,
-0.0049366551,
0.0022932922,
-0.0494881049,
0.0189183559,
0.0008123692,
0.0296003502,
-0.0055170348,
-0.0169501863,
0.0086033614,
0.0296641216,
0.0642286986,
0.0051459586,
-0.0079676379,
0.0428022221,
-0.0332039371,
-0.0226211026,
-0.0385898091,
-0.0057028267,
0.0203799699,
-0.0067065242,
-0.013879898,
-0.000694625,
-0.0467176326,
0.0235829279,
0.0242490135,
-0.0052937963,
0.0141245602,
-0.020307282,
0.0279520433,
-0.0222759675,
-0.0195285827,
-0.0244864821,
0.0234460365,
0.0073638107,
-0.0572617762,
0.0112994667,
0.0016947832,
-0.0213395488,
-0.0384359471,
0.0628571212,
-0.0519485399,
-0.0072734826,
0.0023745187,
-0.0074011493,
0.006106196,
0.0234450884,
-0.0457448661,
0.0202779733,
-0.0812510848,
-0.0193263758,
0.012889442,
0.0395586304,
-0.0450657792,
0.0434505716,
-0.0026682615,
-0.0038961987,
0.0141416229,
0.0019786912,
0.0303977765,
0.0044674329,
-0.0486837402,
0.0520548187,
-0.0080038207,
0.042016048,
-0.0063407831,
-0.0174802318,
-0.0146786571,
-0.0021621017,
-0.0757265389,
-0.0372530185,
-0.0082688397,
-0.027483413,
0.0234433785,
0.0163148865,
0.0165023766,
-0.0198721047,
-0.0317717083,
0.019060893,
0.0252898261,
0.0486722626,
0.0192746613,
-0.0068584564,
0.0081760744,
-0.0260888059,
-0.0408413038,
-0.020705102,
0.0924140289,
-0.0097107068,
-0.0201029107,
-0.0537515618,
-0.0137080159,
-0.051282227,
0.0315728262,
-0.0062790122,
-0.0364938751,
0.0327832811,
-0.0444125906,
0.0375704803,
0.0858161971,
-0.0158121828,
0.0221940093,
0.052478686,
-0.0286420994,
-0.0278568827,
-0.0133943753,
0.0051298751,
-0.0133626033,
-0.0434006006,
0.0135221211,
-0.0296493042,
0.0690809265,
0.0112615479,
-0.0344824605,
-0.0370576493,
0.0314434022,
-0.0187639594,
-0.0624679998,
-0.060107898,
0.0295751542,
-0.0045685135,
0.0483269729,
-0.0238064975,
-0.0559800044,
0.0487866215,
-0.0269188322,
-0.0204477198,
-0.0096263597,
-0.0137872305,
-0.0207272358,
0.073834911,
0.0371790528,
0.0446437709,
-0.0052356077,
-0.0135604888,
-0.0618672408,
0.0119277444,
-0.0141253797,
-0.0135727078,
0.0872631148,
-0.0325595476,
-0.0297072548,
-0.0169176217,
-0.006309927,
-0.0176822636,
-0.0217216685,
-0.0380866714,
-0.0041150297,
-0.0557565615,
-0.0078102164,
-0.0311671328,
0.0050451062,
0.0411064625,
0.0071839504,
-0.0369073376,
0.007768936,
-0.0300023798,
0.0468243808,
0.0658614337,
0.0638787746,
-0.0093879532,
-0.029399246,
-0.0146549745,
0.0422564372,
-0.0150624998,
0.0042806594,
-0.0654066429,
0.0317540243,
0.033282239,
0.0497577824,
-0.0285562184,
0.0146681657,
0.0466605909,
-0.0391161479,
0.0116042895,
0.0778373554,
0.0142172119,
-0.0584819354,
-0.0193213932,
-0.0269185435,
0.0242101047,
0.0398440771,
0.0418243296,
-0.0696917921,
-0.0560297631,
-0.0296591222,
-0.0312606134,
0.0464789532,
0.0261868145,
-0.0153865227,
-0.1149836481,
0.0359569639,
-0.0090206657,
-0.0050702328,
-0.0372907743,
0.0273150261,
-0.0196438655,
0.0371286273,
0.016948482,
-0.0093942471,
0.0035259563,
-0.0025313566,
-0.0125489514,
0.0627722219,
-0.025965564,
0.0209713932,
-0.0497603342,
0.0193524007,
0.0810046792,
0.0246815402,
-0.0236756392,
-0.0269382223,
0.0312334877,
0.0049494789,
0.0073168259,
0.0008746502,
0.0712322593,
-0.0064784726,
-0.0328793116,
0.0034431836,
0.0074012051,
-0.0055706194,
-0.0271952152,
-0.0202005003,
0.0730094984,
-0.0208219122,
-0.0161418542,
-0.0184583999,
0.0215822794,
-0.0275115408,
0.0421831943,
0.0518883839,
-0.0716521591,
-0.0225801188,
-0.0110750487,
-0.0258943811,
0.0137327341,
-0.0606516786,
0.0149386423,
0.0463661999,
-0.003443412,
-0.0374338701,
-0.0265370179,
0.0365597717,
0.0343016014,
0.0014761685,
-0.022478953,
-0.0145349335,
-0.010531785,
-0.0578573756,
0.0759475455,
-0.024978688,
0.0355590805,
-0.051623635,
0.0410636663,
0.0460345447,
-0.071545966,
-0.0190382041,
0.0195279103,
-0.0697086304,
-0.069127284,
-0.0432061963,
0.019646354,
0.0160686262,
0.0079611121,
-0.0171910729,
-0.0548605658,
0.0057661301,
0.0212563891,
0.0207009949,
0.0578346364,
-0.0043233172,
-0.0328239091,
-0.0132488338,
0.0169614255,
-0.0305455774,
0.0095025627,
0.0292682853,
0.0169308912,
0.0306813587,
-0.0417114086,
0.0074315425,
-0.0002460663,
0.045272626,
-0.0054590949,
-0.0017320479,
-0.0371206626,
-0.0211176593,
0.0174791049,
-0.0030882065,
-0.0691742823,
-0.0019275153,
0.0301840603,
0.0211853385,
0.0114440611,
-0.0116320783,
0.024109751,
0.0146998977,
-0.0319122374,
-0.0096804267,
0.0243286472,
-0.0464803092,
-0.0168290231,
0.0194690283,
0.0015808525,
0.0144438921,
-0.0256902296,
0.0366322808,
-0.0169618875,
0.0748590156,
0.0194207244,
-0.038274236,
-0.0447183587,
0.0520341359,
-0.0235336144,
-0.0589178316,
0.0121599818,
0.0336657539,
0.0735279024,
-0.0151736168,
0.0500834212,
-0.0151676992,
-0.0092615252,
-0.0154598085,
0.0134598389,
0.00264175,
-0.0114135947,
0.1042728797,
0.0150773451,
-0.0067339842,
-0.0494178794,
0.0540164001,
0.0415790416,
0.0085166562,
0.0016140314,
0.0204524547,
-0.0034554768,
-0.0482524037,
0.0429000072,
-0.017594127,
-0.0380143523,
0.030032495,
-0.0351058245,
-0.1013259292,
-0.0031428752,
0.0351422355,
-0.058502771,
0.0132660251,
0.0064183054,
0.074190706,
0.0488336943,
-0.0381588079,
-0.0283676144,
0.0085648838,
0.0197070725,
-0.0030849052,
0.0168927275,
-6.000742908e-33,
-0.033076331,
-0.0269900598,
0.0290971957,
-0.0169913378,
-0.0043675392,
0.0153452419,
-0.0230097845,
0.0203580745,
-0.034782026,
0.0120170685,
0.0175344478,
0.0062277606,
-0.0040217694,
0.0380893461,
0.011209134,
-0.0047095427,
-0.0267910417,
0.003655388,
0.0088453814,
-0.0343470648,
0.0087823952,
0.0060918536,
0.070494324,
-0.036258202,
0.0093790861,
0.0409754999,
-0.0078844801,
0.033288639,
-0.031382259,
0.090779148,
-0.049139332,
0.0321603641,
0.0401560292,
-0.025024984,
-0.0265974738,
0.0274036918,
-0.0561814122,
-0.0049612327,
0.050423719,
0.0138909714,
-0.0517879277,
-0.0071006217,
0.0605642237,
-0.040193703,
0.0241982155,
-0.0409381986,
0.0441953242,
-0.0183502566,
-0.008242703,
0.0370170064,
-0.0890368372,
-0.0038766779,
0.0246490706,
0.0009656114,
0.0220280737,
0.0323348939,
0.0244862717,
0.0363061279,
-0.0507603139,
0.0157402325,
-0.0407123603,
0.0585097671,
0.0746915489,
0.0625627935,
0.0174522381,
0.0644443929,
0.0351004973,
-0.0441682413,
-0.0295181721,
-0.0210385676,
0.0456506759,
0.0206227023,
0.0541469678,
0.0667509958,
-0.005507905,
0.0240748953,
-0.0194786619,
-0.0204532072,
-0.0519546494,
0.0286147334,
0.027904341,
-0.0151408827,
0.0400063768,
-0.004385842,
-0.0380574614,
0.0069132601,
-0.0559222028,
-0.0137663968,
0.0519069657,
-0.0152026573,
0.0009407647,
0.0354021862,
0.0762889087,
-0.0565528125,
-0.0152434055,
0.0234994143,
-0.0020234529,
0.048120331,
0.0159403253,
0.043053627,
-0.0141650001,
0.0187186468,
0.0038985508,
-0.0281910114,
-0.0022104131,
0.0364098623,
-0.0048748348,
0.0028435215,
-0.0251188353,
-0.0076707122,
-0.054157339,
-0.0416204035,
0.0070539457,
0.0769471899,
0.0177022945,
0.0034943952,
-0.0518484265,
0.002494348,
0.0234919861,
-0.0329906605,
-0.0320843123,
-0.0123121785,
-0.0036232513,
0.0383494534,
-0.0632347167,
0.0010143253,
-0.0627028644,
-0.01869178,
0.0369092077,
-0.0586130694,
-0.0132884709,
0.0292447321,
2.638e-7,
0.0720013902,
0.0048426655,
-0.0065370505,
0.0372339003,
0.0216130167,
0.0621015429,
-0.0215328224,
0.03561984,
0.0285468735,
-0.0636419803,
-0.0332633108,
0.0548426397,
0.0184588563,
-0.0128146382,
-0.0358074158,
0.0305279475,
0.0068135587,
0.0093285246,
-0.0435819887,
0.0077772993,
0.0221815687,
0.1130136922,
-0.0191584267,
-0.0400302261,
0.0395398512,
-0.0869225636,
0.0889491811,
-0.0097486125,
-0.0224481579,
-0.0206107628,
-0.0071716313,
-0.00766704,
0.0002663787,
-0.0112438258,
0.0152608026,
0.0002062296,
0.0394685753,
0.0358987227,
-0.0319012515,
-0.0135698933,
-0.0244675986,
-0.0180340447,
-0.0367155522,
-0.0542176068,
0.0696897134,
-0.043739073,
-0.0320323184,
-0.0447802134,
0.0401224531,
-0.026724983,
0.0265090689,
-0.0478615649,
0.0001972177,
0.0081625711,
0.02680072,
-0.0271967556,
-0.0175970141,
-0.0676168874,
-0.0306928866,
-0.0237811599,
-0.0705484822,
-0.0052605378,
-0.0529191718,
-0.028977938,
0.0537130535,
-0.0404173136,
-0.0407942384,
2.213071301e-34,
0.0001444968,
-0.0073896782,
0.0124915,
0.0216950513,
0.0399219058,
-0.0225037131,
-0.0334100276,
-0.0216853116,
-0.0204459205,
-0.0954911932,
-0.0309882089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11192v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11192v1 | Beyond Boundaries: Learning a Universal Entity Taxonomy across Datasets and Languages for Open Named Entity Recognition | 2024-06-17T03:57:35 | 2024-06-17T03:57:35 | Yuming Yang, Wantong Zhao, Caishuang Huang, Junjie Ye, Xiao Wang, Huiyuan Zheng, Yang Nan, Yuran Wang, Xueying Xu, Kaixin Huang, Yunke Zhang, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Open Named Entity Recognition (NER), which involves identifying arbitrary
types of entities from arbitrary domains, remains challenging for Large
Language Models (LLMs). Recent studies suggest that fine-tuning LLMs on
extensive NER data can boost their performance. However, training directly on
existing datasets faces issues due to inconsistent entity definitions and
redundant data, limiting LLMs to dataset-specific learning and hindering
out-of-domain generalization. To address this, we present B2NERD, a cohesive
and efficient dataset for Open NER, normalized from 54 existing English or
Chinese datasets using a two-step approach. First, we detect inconsistent
entity definitions across datasets and clarify them by distinguishable label
names to construct a universal taxonomy of 400+ entity types. Second, we
address redundancy using a data pruning strategy that selects fewer samples
with greater category and semantic diversity. Comprehensive evaluation shows
that B2NERD significantly improves LLMs' generalization on Open NER. Our B2NER
models, trained on B2NERD, outperform GPT-4 by 6.8-12.0 F1 points and surpass
previous methods in 3 out-of-domain benchmarks across 15 datasets and 6
languages. | [
0.0326466672,
0.0816315114,
0.0377493203,
0.0469106138,
0.014272579,
0.0456180274,
0.0119271791,
0.0197213814,
0.0023957579,
-0.0514970347,
-0.0293408185,
-0.0705155507,
0.0023496342,
0.00901841,
-0.0054546567,
-0.0158321671,
0.0244924258,
0.0070903678,
0.0006856062,
-0.002123792,
-0.0313667208,
0.0274644326,
0.0126345409,
0.0053317943,
0.0194245465,
0.0047330679,
0.0047637457,
0.0213794839,
0.0489404686,
-0.0478219911,
0.0283168294,
0.0386777073,
0.0091224611,
0.0970475972,
0.0000019313,
-0.0871169418,
-0.0646029711,
0.0135847032,
-0.0204560906,
0.0080750408,
0.008590444,
-0.0283687189,
-0.0071556526,
0.0038412691,
0.0121709602,
-0.1089463606,
0.0601994582,
0.0847849324,
0.016526388,
0.0813996494,
0.0003781039,
-0.047992982,
0.0113663068,
-0.0284998734,
-0.0254434198,
-0.0263526123,
0.0585179105,
-0.0192675963,
-0.0297683477,
0.0053588799,
-0.0072541274,
-0.0163544212,
-0.0143004525,
0.0519991852,
-0.0070702955,
0.0519364849,
-0.0262525082,
0.0080557624,
0.0237155184,
0.1002396792,
-0.0155577557,
0.0029879506,
0.0315065943,
-0.0128072482,
-0.0231742915,
-0.0211075004,
-0.0134535283,
0.0447977185,
-0.0485354178,
0.0291080624,
0.0075864629,
-0.0210967716,
0.0597582795,
0.0100073349,
-0.047659494,
0.0217118673,
0.0260963924,
-0.0462458506,
0.0122069241,
0.0179120097,
-0.0618339591,
-0.0426714458,
-0.0099526066,
0.0142659787,
0.0033610994,
0.0359449238,
-0.0375946797,
0.0164317023,
0.0207007732,
-0.0374205746,
-0.0070391293,
0.0100550679,
-0.024268873,
0.0456124172,
-0.0219301898,
-0.0032475707,
-0.0086842375,
0.0267109517,
0.0157806855,
-0.049242232,
-0.0721948519,
0.0034730243,
-0.0156927332,
0.0393666252,
-0.0041171629,
-0.0037124469,
-0.0304941498,
-0.0034456516,
-0.013117074,
0.0330192931,
0.0403764211,
-0.0329010151,
0.0043612844,
-0.0162614267,
-0.0583964065,
0.002791235,
0.0016906769,
0.0032212019,
-0.0327906385,
-0.0719724819,
0.0044447561,
-0.0251040664,
0.0109813195,
-0.0488386005,
0.0155083118,
0.042039685,
0.0389713049,
-0.0752580166,
-0.0876666009,
0.0120849833,
0.0048418888,
-0.0618788525,
-0.0064469166,
-0.035316322,
0.0202957503,
-0.0002609169,
0.0164681077,
-0.0815741718,
0.0243032798,
-0.0058041695,
-0.0564094707,
0.0740791634,
-0.0759925619,
-0.0051507684,
0.0281965584,
-0.0076226941,
0.037361782,
0.0574020967,
0.0185969695,
-0.0604613833,
0.0615040399,
0.0199733246,
0.0072231754,
0.025473468,
0.0131106982,
0.0050060754,
0.0287450887,
0.021738667,
0.0312632956,
0.0305867139,
0.0355477445,
0.0402923711,
-0.00641071,
-0.0233877525,
0.0243098121,
-0.0214866456,
-0.0017524912,
0.0044376687,
0.0310045034,
0.0057716379,
0.0007182223,
-0.0149783101,
-0.0483086631,
-0.0329689085,
0.0095748231,
0.0191845987,
0.0156298466,
0.0587139092,
-0.0374416299,
0.0094762724,
-0.0414814577,
-0.0099340873,
-0.0079843635,
0.0170306619,
0.075147137,
0.0085764406,
-0.033789847,
0.0947174728,
0.0415525623,
-0.0205284767,
0.0029122154,
-0.0152569348,
0.0358204991,
0.0333975703,
0.0274126995,
-0.0424173623,
-0.0227073133,
-0.05724838,
-0.0197712649,
0.0705651864,
0.0365162417,
-0.0144571671,
0.0380019061,
-0.0494114421,
-0.0063873967,
0.0077221687,
0.0368759744,
0.0239598993,
0.0327832513,
0.0493515991,
0.0429916605,
-0.0595569424,
-0.0494040586,
0.044556506,
-0.023204647,
-0.0353081748,
0.0226965677,
0.0304942727,
0.0006322444,
0.043919012,
-0.03577796,
-0.0352545083,
0.0098223286,
-0.0030260417,
-0.024223702,
-0.053404972,
0.0008046703,
-0.0090648886,
0.0466501489,
0.008504807,
-0.0449193567,
0.0246135723,
-0.0635287985,
-0.037471991,
-0.0305759795,
0.0483814776,
0.021001691,
-0.066228807,
0.0414627045,
-0.0122583006,
0.0273799784,
0.0029313629,
0.068317309,
-0.0155531978,
0.0408898145,
0.0133625129,
-0.0092937127,
0.026788827,
-0.0268042907,
-0.0678600818,
0.0284884479,
-0.0210396592,
0.0212055519,
0.0069503975,
0.0252439398,
-0.0499323793,
0.0003385137,
-0.0798328072,
0.0193797499,
-0.0240844339,
0.0450251028,
0.0115971118,
0.0400741585,
-0.0255791396,
0.0092856335,
0.0187966824,
-0.0313739851,
-0.0209824033,
-0.0007699664,
0.0334179886,
-0.0264907256,
-0.034688592,
0.0309013426,
0.0095491679,
-0.0186941884,
0.0285359714,
-0.0237904433,
-0.0249782391,
-0.0873183757,
0.0449756645,
-0.0606107414,
0.0204712506,
0.0058858143,
0.0369761437,
-0.0237745252,
0.0356017277,
-0.0095981602,
0.0299637951,
-0.0231096782,
-0.0095104659,
0.0173875969,
-0.0095875869,
-0.0381912775,
0.0166021101,
0.004059149,
-0.0082529383,
0.0004014118,
-0.0317673124,
0.0142605426,
0.0635890141,
-0.0276707187,
-0.0150549784,
-0.035707958,
0.007033919,
-0.0230971612,
0.0176351033,
-0.0228524525,
0.0239018183,
-0.014497648,
0.0128739234,
-0.0251278542,
0.0033468637,
0.0508326627,
-0.0549060106,
0.0139403772,
-0.01114232,
0.0134035489,
-0.0713365749,
0.0238408856,
-0.019594444,
0.0026726068,
0.062744379,
-0.0639948845,
-0.0199857075,
0.0411093719,
-0.0063343588,
-0.0204072911,
0.0632690415,
-0.0194782075,
0.0260482095,
-0.0228439365,
-0.026501976,
-0.0313303135,
0.0231065601,
-0.0320906527,
0.0357770361,
-0.0293299239,
-0.0211301707,
-0.0171649028,
0.0397650786,
-0.0248903409,
0.0357627124,
0.0168810934,
-0.0088895978,
-0.0182736386,
0.0246697161,
0.0313322842,
0.0182758626,
0.024808215,
-0.0158470627,
-0.0100262016,
-0.0162307695,
-0.0227180347,
-0.0158308502,
0.0205741767,
-0.0171389971,
0.0192062203,
-0.0651471019,
0.0048737363,
-0.0211981479,
0.0334337465,
-0.0010521769,
-0.0154283661,
0.1079105288,
0.0028383743,
-0.0170741994,
-0.0289399996,
0.0067631281,
0.0212684404,
0.0238318555,
-0.0109197078,
-0.1133030131,
-0.0469834544,
0.0194669832,
0.0015261922,
0.0224767122,
-0.0629935265,
-0.0097890291,
-0.1486897916,
0.0089821145,
-0.0101104071,
-0.089283742,
-0.0137605323,
-0.0357554257,
0.0246332809,
-0.0620101541,
0.0357103422,
-0.0236432776,
-0.0149763692,
-0.0014362755,
0.0036883317,
0.0134025654,
-0.0807399601,
0.0301782507,
-0.0677764937,
0.041519586,
0.014049842,
0.0181144457,
-0.0069525517,
-0.0000777841,
0.0237247776,
-0.0501585118,
-0.0609333254,
-0.0176962707,
0.0465645976,
-0.0474042073,
-0.0078705102,
-0.0121224513,
-0.0004623519,
-0.0365755819,
0.013049637,
0.013274122,
0.0715080872,
0.0197322723,
-0.0103954189,
0.0181678068,
-0.0603404418,
0.0078077023,
0.0787139535,
-0.0091954945,
-0.0194628853,
-0.0144170113,
0.0144285699,
-0.0350213833,
-0.0135449423,
0.0244603995,
0.0467782021,
-0.0459093116,
-0.0651164651,
-0.0193105098,
-0.0552124828,
0.0348529406,
-0.0088742403,
0.0128645739,
0.0232919119,
0.0063148197,
0.0235967562,
-0.0548183806,
0.0382805616,
-0.044852633,
0.0226252731,
-0.0611329749,
0.0016873474,
0.011018578,
0.0011558738,
-0.0422830693,
0.0332250744,
-0.0697706938,
-0.056290783,
-0.0074715735,
-0.0146507993,
0.0109245293,
0.051295273,
-0.0079512633,
-0.0090428842,
0.0276488177,
0.0404980853,
-0.0424183086,
-0.0088151395,
0.0131115783,
0.0301567186,
-0.0015697536,
0.0434048697,
-0.0540783517,
-0.000938394,
0.0515957847,
0.0422973707,
-0.0067959656,
-0.018059222,
0.0099395318,
0.0438419543,
0.05195437,
-0.013254582,
-0.0201613437,
-0.076949425,
0.0213189069,
0.0348412879,
0.002650192,
-0.0325605869,
0.0140301529,
0.0546893962,
-0.0098853819,
-0.0232343264,
0.0732350051,
-0.000867429,
0.0300471317,
-0.0458075032,
-0.0172772389,
0.0079633528,
0.0728786662,
0.0241914019,
-0.0501552299,
-0.0159285124,
0.0380448774,
0.0363749675,
0.0177714955,
-0.018925216,
0.0306662749,
0.0020829008,
0.0422758013,
-0.0009121646,
-0.003299399,
-0.0055863834,
-0.0252441391,
-0.0301613845,
0.0455704741,
0.0585130081,
0.019543102,
0.0478395484,
-0.012691915,
-0.0117403688,
-0.018509943,
0.0155970454,
-0.010629449,
-0.0038650879,
0.0237404704,
0.0017077884,
-0.0353786536,
-0.009122517,
0.0632198825,
0.0077451468,
0.0478192307,
-0.0111445514,
-0.0087742042,
-0.0331769325,
-0.0065375832,
0.0259018522,
-0.0217490979,
-0.0320577472,
0.0049410863,
-0.0378705934,
-0.060502369,
0.0134672634,
-0.031048676,
-0.0163177587,
0.0323040262,
0.002086651,
0.0194922611,
0.0094688982,
-0.0298302975,
-0.0197433885,
-0.0384333655,
0.0048618363,
-0.038695775,
-0.0051480979,
-6.401432198e-33,
-0.0108091757,
0.0058105998,
0.0066349143,
-0.0596631542,
-0.0290455092,
0.0071184714,
0.0057704975,
-0.0257609021,
-0.0226175506,
-0.0362577438,
0.0032706002,
0.0236048214,
0.0322575159,
0.0284224432,
-0.0088491989,
-0.0409100689,
0.0463018678,
0.0350357518,
-0.0201674532,
0.0163111314,
0.0669872314,
0.0489502028,
0.0985208452,
-0.0791510344,
0.0685933158,
-0.0059053292,
-0.0242659841,
0.0167267546,
0.0647296831,
0.0585683845,
-0.0462562703,
0.0595401227,
0.0292781238,
-0.0444020256,
-0.0006896227,
-0.0205327328,
-0.1604975313,
0.0115831224,
-0.0298185255,
0.0354085937,
0.0013390408,
-0.0212514363,
0.0142696127,
0.007500628,
0.031631384,
-0.0176885761,
0.0228914451,
-0.004417452,
0.0058976253,
0.0077427714,
-0.0355635583,
0.0657598972,
0.0250786841,
0.0424300209,
0.023793146,
-0.0066327155,
0.0163585506,
-0.0085069975,
-0.0742996186,
-0.0088306824,
0.0473160259,
-0.0450452603,
0.0307959076,
0.0248048082,
0.000865934,
0.0309506338,
0.000380897,
-0.0157850087,
-0.0378943942,
-0.0297505837,
0.0110394545,
0.0265100487,
-0.0331456959,
0.0675091371,
0.0351180062,
-0.0429338962,
-0.0855072066,
0.0318314098,
-0.0229119286,
-0.0195109267,
-0.0054403609,
-0.0319557264,
-0.0313618816,
-0.0055068396,
-0.0079829767,
-0.0147757856,
-0.0602850989,
-0.0093543306,
0.0440918021,
0.0151228672,
-0.0406241678,
0.0110105816,
0.029895369,
-0.0405831821,
-0.0761276186,
0.0238841698,
0.0340084545,
-0.0100859683,
0.0063398848,
-0.0095687909,
-0.066553928,
-0.0691033527,
0.0168836284,
-0.0108517157,
0.0053051417,
0.0061293957,
0.0563695394,
-0.0074095796,
-0.0611589327,
0.0199889634,
-0.0054109162,
0.0207732562,
-0.0218629111,
0.0466153361,
0.0094039189,
0.0036929396,
0.0153716216,
0.0312688686,
0.0902732834,
-0.005272876,
-0.0242414698,
0.0182713028,
0.0106893806,
0.0256783534,
0.0001065606,
0.0089988383,
0.0248113461,
-0.0281030852,
0.0269800462,
-0.0444347188,
-0.004432444,
-0.0044898954,
2.656e-7,
0.0252205711,
-0.0181096513,
-0.0057301172,
0.0324968025,
-0.0368229933,
0.0265443679,
0.0043770531,
0.0682548359,
-0.0549039096,
-0.0007298723,
0.0142115066,
-0.0139670074,
0.0440455228,
0.0197028518,
-0.0988964364,
-0.0020485404,
-0.0150155229,
0.0115235252,
-0.0618335903,
0.015872078,
0.0122429058,
0.0991081968,
0.0099140853,
-0.030174166,
-0.0207239892,
-0.0172382686,
0.0528641678,
-0.0149623984,
0.0261854101,
0.044781018,
0.0169159211,
0.0779194236,
-0.0084309559,
0.0223522857,
0.002279934,
0.0448509008,
0.0276572946,
0.0420290083,
0.0197356064,
0.0329884812,
-0.0111623481,
-0.0508044325,
0.0077045769,
-0.0676677823,
0.0762303472,
-0.0208301079,
-0.0259195678,
0.0296720006,
0.010944345,
-0.0235333983,
0.0598872826,
0.0004958935,
-0.0017722894,
0.0354667343,
0.018038502,
-0.0273146667,
-0.0053238175,
-0.0765631944,
0.0334903635,
0.0050803092,
-0.0057773902,
-0.0202880595,
0.0174874552,
-0.007099513,
0.0193366725,
-0.0518795028,
0.0294414163,
2.366449896e-34,
-0.0020499204,
0.0093841413,
-0.0454923287,
0.0146101462,
0.0512038656,
-0.0388920791,
-0.0276687052,
-0.0007432103,
-0.0425636247,
-0.0407996774,
0.0149806933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11191v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11191v2 | A Survey on Human Preference Learning for Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T03:52:51 | 2024-06-18T08:18:33 | Ruili Jiang, Kehai Chen, Xuefeng Bai, Zhixuan He, Juntao Li, Muyun Yang, Tiejun Zhao, Liqiang Nie, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recent surge of versatile large language models (LLMs) largely depends on
aligning increasingly capable foundation models with human intentions by
preference learning, enhancing LLMs with excellent applicability and
effectiveness in a wide range of contexts. Despite the numerous related studies
conducted, a perspective on how human preferences are introduced into LLMs
remains limited, which may prevent a deeper comprehension of the relationships
between human preferences and LLMs as well as the realization of their
limitations. In this survey, we review the progress in exploring human
preference learning for LLMs from a preference-centered perspective, covering
the sources and formats of preference feedback, the modeling and usage of
preference signals, as well as the evaluation of the aligned LLMs. We first
categorize the human feedback according to data sources and formats. We then
summarize techniques for human preferences modeling and compare the advantages
and disadvantages of different schools of models. Moreover, we present various
preference usage methods sorted by the objectives to utilize human preference
signals. Finally, we summarize some prevailing approaches to evaluate LLMs in
terms of alignment with human intentions and discuss our outlooks on the human
intention alignment for LLMs. | [
0.0626254827,
0.0662793219,
-0.026795717,
0.0018611029,
-0.0384492092,
-0.0023627577,
-0.0333821252,
-0.0300355777,
0.0066953814,
-0.014723938,
-0.0405069925,
-0.0682680085,
0.0034209485,
-0.0260253642,
-0.0049637607,
-0.078466922,
0.0239711665,
-0.0306777861,
-0.0096985204,
-0.0071646478,
0.023863947,
0.0293452181,
0.025334632,
0.0346618369,
0.0321349129,
-0.0012734702,
0.015558687,
-0.0222680978,
0.0001010541,
-0.0402955376,
0.0079925479,
0.0582125448,
0.0404935814,
-0.0135627445,
0.0000023864,
-0.0726147965,
-0.0092750527,
-0.0340475477,
-0.028301904,
0.0252899583,
0.083976917,
0.0588969998,
-0.0157047436,
-0.0133038703,
-0.0297498219,
0.0336875878,
0.038885083,
-0.0029155917,
-0.0049110716,
-0.0008620537,
-0.0012196016,
-0.025259899,
-0.0439590327,
-0.0164465159,
-0.0049527269,
0.0141603919,
0.0380646698,
-0.0569405667,
0.0440647267,
0.0215925053,
0.0217401888,
-0.0208358411,
-0.0147514055,
0.0115725519,
0.0083675915,
0.0195512027,
0.0078044366,
-0.0293080118,
-0.0216292776,
0.0668851286,
0.0289055333,
-0.0348767228,
-0.0007217563,
-0.0153968986,
-0.0081404699,
0.0404432081,
-0.0351207815,
-0.0261531025,
0.0077897487,
0.0303105246,
0.0242918022,
0.011331195,
0.0129706478,
0.0570925325,
-0.0340227447,
0.0966377109,
0.0158955976,
-0.0144575061,
0.0382561907,
-0.0024104393,
-0.011754686,
-0.0591058172,
0.0244741049,
-0.0253824405,
-0.0618388057,
0.0200680289,
-0.0287348442,
0.023132449,
0.0311351232,
-0.0682508871,
0.0539166369,
0.0461558178,
-0.0236257445,
0.0182821061,
0.0339216962,
0.0538908131,
-0.0210650526,
-0.030053135,
-0.0448257625,
0.0312643833,
-0.0101611931,
0.0122403428,
0.0150005352,
0.0192903075,
-0.0237435549,
-0.0105645601,
-0.0447317921,
0.0463580638,
0.0036879694,
0.0254801922,
0.0102205062,
0.0136575289,
-0.022858046,
-0.0165229458,
-0.0825639293,
0.058145225,
-0.0399331488,
0.0149733173,
0.0181194954,
-0.0024687266,
0.0610018186,
-0.0015770727,
-0.0270180292,
-0.0359178782,
0.0006328066,
0.0433273204,
0.0064410577,
0.0004684671,
-0.0082626138,
0.0020943542,
-0.0235917363,
-0.0363712125,
-0.01991334,
-0.0811955407,
0.0158864204,
0.0183680579,
0.0034143361,
-0.0372159891,
-0.0037847271,
0.01668928,
-0.0425927676,
0.040781308,
0.0039516101,
0.0080681443,
0.0008836241,
-0.0216624327,
-0.0103257122,
0.0589903928,
0.0097416528,
0.0877451375,
0.0438978225,
-0.0082631577,
-0.036082454,
0.0288927183,
-0.0247931648,
0.0164023042,
-0.0752915516,
0.0263202898,
-0.0163925327,
0.0365476869,
0.0392079204,
0.059504047,
-0.0304994248,
-0.0301129203,
0.0982027948,
0.0536197759,
0.0032192317,
-0.0090433927,
0.0159985498,
0.057499066,
-0.0132678142,
0.029620098,
-0.0039687734,
0.0157508608,
-0.0198171362,
0.0020154298,
0.0009793247,
0.0254878737,
-0.0105788689,
-0.0425708815,
-0.0000735308,
-0.0186838396,
0.0374732725,
0.0488586538,
0.0755682364,
-0.0375816822,
-0.0126652811,
-0.0139259892,
0.062375512,
-0.0313695036,
0.0282441899,
-0.0392571576,
0.0705150291,
0.1425719857,
0.0240265168,
-0.0145195695,
0.0148904761,
-0.020306753,
-0.043132551,
0.0147575652,
0.0621495061,
-0.0319388099,
-0.0341005623,
-0.0436963402,
0.0074499943,
0.0471834242,
-0.0175938085,
0.0319193415,
-0.0103794718,
-0.0405136757,
-0.0244868007,
-0.0265868995,
-0.0197695307,
-0.0075194645,
0.0013683449,
0.0183350816,
0.0164376851,
0.023045117,
0.0400878862,
0.0319507532,
0.016109651,
0.0060220421,
0.0109881004,
0.014051022,
-0.0002519667,
0.0322985165,
-0.0463193282,
0.0349220373,
0.0210403595,
0.0061954213,
-0.0067358944,
0.0296230111,
0.0222324543,
-0.0057246326,
-0.0211938154,
-0.0082707815,
0.0598227605,
-0.0321475752,
0.0297665969,
-0.0166766308,
-0.0368025117,
-0.0698273033,
0.040259175,
-0.0074823545,
-0.0187273361,
0.0272813942,
-0.0116740586,
0.0039074491,
-0.0430082418,
-0.0392896719,
0.0510542765,
0.0219986793,
0.0275084637,
0.0664323643,
-0.0108494805,
-0.0578464121,
-0.0169207752,
-0.0881594718,
-0.0056674555,
0.0070407996,
0.0065512052,
-0.0103271939,
-0.0030553353,
-0.0118268002,
0.0028866569,
-0.0338048339,
-0.0158880819,
-0.0327951126,
0.0232598241,
-0.0161427073,
-0.0105335731,
-0.0029376973,
-0.0543316938,
-0.0063174982,
0.000395754,
0.0047294968,
-0.0049052988,
-0.001419561,
-0.0348208137,
0.00506286,
-0.0172328874,
-0.002208743,
-0.0113042705,
-0.0283119939,
0.0316911787,
-0.0225462671,
0.0453127101,
0.0459509045,
0.0285623018,
0.021668151,
0.0870964378,
0.0035646509,
-0.0866670012,
-0.0211985391,
-0.0637757853,
0.0005285422,
-0.0427412726,
-0.0136822201,
0.00825937,
0.0452160239,
0.0054828483,
0.0003093814,
-0.0431676283,
0.0064009083,
-0.0324614458,
-0.021435855,
-0.0334914923,
-0.0110602593,
-0.0446882918,
0.0784332678,
0.0241761338,
-0.0404492989,
0.0864253938,
0.0035109664,
0.0266023967,
-0.052403193,
-0.0003720868,
-0.0158216543,
-0.0042666188,
-0.0264913607,
0.0282282624,
0.0228137337,
-0.0014444293,
-0.0522542074,
-0.0300348736,
0.0232596286,
-0.0362018682,
0.0433286577,
-0.0739397183,
0.0025288488,
0.0368121341,
-0.045729816,
-0.0343449041,
-0.0556734577,
-0.0599129125,
-0.0112710046,
0.0326466896,
-0.0194303263,
0.0248852205,
0.0051201582,
0.0197532848,
-0.0139569212,
0.0256772656,
-0.0096371127,
-0.0007588099,
-0.0023706665,
0.0776038691,
0.0186242405,
-0.0004493138,
-0.0140269892,
-0.0217126589,
0.0251719616,
0.0375901572,
0.0045959842,
-0.0112225953,
0.034948118,
0.0832770318,
-0.0012170812,
-0.037036147,
0.0731647909,
0.0029112075,
-0.012923752,
0.0377961844,
0.0946094841,
0.0447229445,
-0.0766244531,
0.0217358116,
-0.0235284958,
0.0486351512,
0.01664792,
0.03513759,
-0.050985314,
-0.0068541812,
0.0126080178,
0.0357824005,
-0.0135751618,
-0.0053508109,
0.0138159273,
-0.118398428,
0.0126372818,
0.0128260339,
-0.0411506295,
0.0537901707,
-0.0539565347,
0.0373144336,
-0.0268006958,
-0.0054160361,
-0.0195314121,
0.0021107253,
-0.0256667174,
0.0160148144,
-0.016541196,
-0.0736571103,
0.0188206527,
-0.0418907329,
0.0671189502,
0.0814313367,
0.023307085,
-0.0051027597,
-0.052574724,
-0.0239856318,
0.0195965115,
-0.0015141076,
-0.0206200369,
-0.0100438036,
-0.0028000828,
0.01800422,
-0.057520818,
0.0386923775,
-0.0001459312,
-0.0151959555,
0.0026827871,
0.0664265677,
-0.0192564409,
0.0064961156,
-0.0109057557,
-0.0103059569,
0.0277704503,
0.0406284556,
0.0047262083,
-0.126867786,
0.0245200396,
-0.0494519547,
-0.0376289748,
-0.0104888836,
-0.0512944497,
-0.0059311581,
-0.0029075861,
-0.0320105553,
-0.0669484735,
-0.0161433388,
0.0050266813,
0.0277104881,
0.0353435762,
0.0301512945,
0.0537145808,
-0.0169150084,
0.013460651,
0.0227020439,
-0.0103804162,
0.037145488,
-0.0871027783,
-0.0507037416,
0.029906923,
-0.0518378466,
0.0082293516,
-0.0277251396,
0.0040759193,
-0.0854694694,
-0.0091794813,
0.0514976978,
0.0245363582,
0.0445022546,
0.0002881711,
-0.0878929272,
-0.0023158572,
0.0155637581,
0.0000019838,
-0.0119689535,
0.0182401892,
0.0296551809,
-0.0139563652,
0.0245604888,
-0.0070253187,
0.0125657665,
0.0085439235,
0.0018046387,
-0.0364046618,
-0.0505465977,
0.0515353531,
-0.002115278,
0.0055495217,
-0.0474848263,
-0.0187930185,
-0.039343603,
-0.0188993029,
-0.0266619381,
-0.0326565579,
-0.0098387031,
-0.060413707,
0.0471693277,
-0.0131877307,
-0.0112577779,
-0.0448518731,
-0.0223451648,
0.0201835614,
-0.0187964514,
0.0276980102,
0.0150321266,
0.0416474491,
0.0557694286,
0.0313153602,
-0.0092733977,
-0.0232445449,
-0.0150987301,
0.0627395064,
0.0168054905,
0.0708108842,
0.0045218305,
-0.0546435341,
0.01752479,
0.0255808774,
0.0098190485,
-0.0658633932,
-0.0249935482,
-0.0221101958,
0.0351698697,
-0.066910699,
0.0580659658,
-0.0261220336,
-0.0051374035,
-0.03081806,
0.0338076353,
-0.0269337036,
-0.0156962406,
0.0074617607,
0.0239670165,
-0.0437938496,
0.0236147959,
0.0396921523,
-0.0001137795,
-0.0181710403,
-0.0362247229,
-0.0156725124,
-0.0412188992,
0.0010425849,
-0.0033369644,
0.0312629193,
-0.0564262867,
-0.0082079889,
-0.0911848396,
-0.0474154167,
-0.0018761264,
-0.0014903856,
-0.0057778689,
-0.0376311317,
0.0666671023,
0.0501597747,
-0.0437789857,
0.0247702841,
-0.0583256409,
-0.01456773,
-0.0622486174,
-0.0170933753,
-0.0597087108,
-6.495356401e-33,
-0.0058371136,
-0.0049080499,
0.0150659764,
-0.0380731001,
-0.0092901075,
-0.0567948669,
0.0156606045,
0.025789028,
-0.0004351402,
-0.0247081593,
-0.0119375968,
-0.0596160069,
0.012012532,
-0.0255126897,
0.033596117,
0.0006920716,
0.0451636389,
0.0072594075,
-0.0357985049,
-0.0122960657,
0.0500912331,
-0.0105368951,
0.0237923395,
-0.0860348195,
0.0131964283,
0.0190741364,
-0.01071872,
-0.0028728293,
0.0101474551,
0.0862600133,
-0.0190509632,
0.0288979225,
-0.0179999806,
-0.0373373702,
-0.0285136253,
0.04589241,
-0.0038031256,
-0.0113883438,
0.0568597279,
0.0191661548,
0.040041592,
-0.0236946326,
0.0081495075,
0.0012545919,
-0.0402498245,
0.0619315244,
0.0288498905,
-0.0281353779,
-0.0277538784,
0.0627765954,
-0.0457301512,
0.003236183,
0.0013346223,
0.0039317184,
0.0256938487,
0.0595741197,
-0.0368320383,
0.0323526114,
-0.0416756682,
0.079782933,
0.0133576216,
-0.0015779921,
0.0644644722,
0.0016393001,
0.0306465589,
0.0639601424,
0.0268237945,
-0.0023303758,
0.0427881069,
-0.026949659,
0.0314841717,
0.0434549712,
0.0121936006,
0.0528473817,
0.0070416238,
-0.0432432033,
0.0137987202,
0.0382717438,
0.0474414565,
-0.0130253835,
0.0603868552,
0.0615670457,
-0.0584681816,
-0.0458046794,
-0.0196343213,
-0.0122646764,
-0.0428700335,
-0.0467298701,
0.0311749801,
-0.0195524823,
-0.0327118337,
-0.0105717722,
0.0360791683,
-0.0403039157,
-0.0632304922,
0.0106647573,
-0.0465994217,
0.0410741493,
0.0131369559,
-0.0100736236,
-0.0845840722,
0.0063141054,
-0.0202090796,
-0.0349475369,
-0.0164239071,
0.0291595235,
-0.0220817309,
0.0157205332,
-0.0286710598,
0.0036186539,
-0.0127128279,
-0.0515652634,
0.0211924147,
-0.03134102,
0.0687272549,
0.0081696035,
-0.0167285334,
0.0592369065,
-0.0007675771,
-0.0411065444,
-0.0301379878,
-0.043599911,
-0.0031931652,
0.026459882,
-0.0056375507,
-0.0057557561,
-0.0204727463,
0.0162544157,
0.0245527942,
0.00621517,
-0.0133529371,
-0.0187583454,
2.969e-7,
0.0011533364,
0.0690595284,
-0.0266052186,
-0.0055491584,
-0.0335858427,
0.0501228571,
-0.0050332313,
-0.015638262,
0.0510108657,
0.006937657,
0.0210428741,
-0.0166529547,
0.0629461631,
0.029985873,
-0.1044950038,
0.0071184551,
0.0036709607,
0.0115881227,
-0.0405552238,
0.0062631438,
0.0614479855,
0.05401925,
0.0298230983,
0.0088008028,
0.0093997149,
0.0474126935,
0.0561022237,
-0.1070626006,
-0.0180472359,
-0.0132479118,
-0.0093597043,
-0.0047642533,
-0.02810831,
-0.011284058,
-0.0039196834,
0.0029624903,
-0.0070327758,
0.053590402,
0.0003787764,
-0.0599551313,
-0.0046691126,
0.0065950397,
0.0059370245,
-0.071831353,
0.0416786335,
-0.0367821902,
-0.0181742702,
-0.0076229656,
-0.0004797306,
-0.0131179327,
-0.0155110927,
-0.0382139981,
-0.0158282164,
-0.0140515948,
0.0148846367,
0.0169736762,
-0.0146155274,
-0.0255396385,
0.0085971151,
0.0308916848,
-0.0465483293,
-0.0615519956,
-0.033088211,
0.0414593183,
-0.032688871,
-0.0181805398,
0.0220558345,
2.408701801e-34,
0.0293052495,
0.0302138031,
0.008896132,
0.0162323918,
0.036924284,
0.0234673042,
0.0217979085,
0.0405718572,
0.0707069561,
-0.0850494131,
-0.0139455302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11190v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11190v1 | Aligning Large Language Models from Self-Reference AI Feedback with one General Principle | 2024-06-17T03:51:46 | 2024-06-17T03:51:46 | Rong Bao, Rui Zheng, Shihan Dou, Xiao Wang, Enyu Zhou, Bo Wang, Qi Zhang, Liang Ding, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In aligning large language models (LLMs), utilizing feedback from existing
advanced AI rather than humans is an important method to scale supervisory
signals. However, it is highly challenging for AI to understand human
intentions and societal values, and provide accurate preference feedback based
on these. Current AI feedback methods rely on powerful LLMs, carefully designed
specific principles to describe human intentions, and are easily influenced by
position bias. To address these issues, we propose a self-reference-based AI
feedback framework that enables a 13B Llama2-Chat to provide high-quality
feedback under simple and general principles such as ``best for humanity``.
Specifically, we allow the AI to first respond to the user's instructions, then
generate criticism of other answers based on its own response as a reference,
and finally determine which answer better fits human preferences according to
the criticism. Additionally, we use a self-consistency method to further reduce
the impact of position bias, and employ semantic perplexity to calculate the
preference strength differences between different answers. Experimental results
show that our method enables 13B and 70B Llama2-Chat annotators to provide
high-quality preference feedback, and the policy models trained based on these
preference data achieve significant advantages in benchmark datasets through
reinforcement learning. | [
0.0771001577,
0.057421308,
-0.0101914098,
0.0222113691,
-0.0256260503,
-0.0035926732,
-0.0293695685,
-0.0125714727,
0.035570804,
-0.0407062918,
-0.0553661734,
-0.0373089947,
-0.021837987,
-0.0030871772,
-0.0165509712,
-0.0293939169,
0.040262606,
-0.0216583256,
0.0617618784,
-0.0227220617,
0.042215161,
0.0100437552,
0.0042921305,
0.0296399444,
-0.0065534636,
-0.0087107327,
0.0037683789,
-0.0151493363,
0.0172684174,
-0.0444971733,
0.0331381261,
0.0542764626,
-0.0040118755,
0.0314320773,
0.0000020691,
-0.0508285314,
0.0143153202,
-0.0145609509,
-0.017052561,
0.0238421019,
0.0577037223,
0.019855449,
-0.0195723418,
0.0142560545,
-0.0520011708,
0.0320615284,
0.0644761473,
0.0495788008,
0.1069344208,
0.0605715662,
0.0207413025,
-0.012090357,
-0.0060785939,
-0.0342454053,
0.0204373915,
-0.0290411301,
0.0255195834,
0.010587885,
0.0119546242,
0.0389527492,
-0.0171371866,
0.0067991568,
0.0134377247,
-0.0355792493,
-0.0116499271,
0.0184519757,
-0.014416947,
-0.0253315773,
-0.0271029621,
0.086902231,
0.0348541699,
-0.0281836037,
-0.0027356034,
-0.0201232322,
0.0157621466,
-0.028912412,
-0.0435510799,
0.0017028842,
0.0263374429,
0.0315653682,
0.0251871347,
0.0111598531,
0.0264529269,
0.0273577776,
-0.0073751076,
0.0661963224,
-0.0300630815,
-0.0471158363,
0.0048968191,
0.0132027678,
-0.0152781904,
-0.0668742806,
-0.0076593584,
0.0301693659,
-0.0717991367,
0.0215426311,
-0.0290453732,
0.0161283556,
0.0445697643,
-0.0751387179,
0.0501280613,
0.0546750203,
-0.0106785465,
0.0328669921,
0.0435334519,
0.082933709,
-0.0368667543,
0.0348287374,
-0.0454244837,
0.0010765996,
-0.0182432644,
-0.0167952366,
0.007305955,
0.0429168195,
0.0044636033,
-0.0059915083,
-0.07162828,
0.0195476916,
-0.0716282576,
0.0437865667,
0.027106503,
0.0392575264,
-0.0333941095,
0.008307416,
-0.081306912,
0.0627102032,
-0.0452553518,
0.0186379682,
0.0212083627,
-0.041014038,
0.0058829612,
0.0177942924,
-0.026584655,
-0.0077040778,
0.0231340118,
0.0969443768,
0.0091783199,
0.0058678752,
0.0154477963,
-0.0065219523,
-0.0586392134,
-0.0612272061,
-0.0243568942,
-0.0490361527,
0.0622863024,
-0.0204564445,
-0.0360279195,
-0.0459266566,
0.0436031036,
0.0359350406,
-0.0163733531,
0.0602040477,
-0.0055801151,
0.0043405588,
0.0176447239,
-0.0068690097,
-0.0196545143,
0.0494436026,
0.0355224833,
0.0448547453,
0.0544732548,
0.0158762336,
-0.0004391856,
0.0264680069,
0.0191061385,
-0.0111918095,
-0.0213706512,
0.0348894596,
-0.0518542714,
0.0438801646,
0.0361287594,
0.0686760172,
-0.0112461587,
-0.0371231884,
0.0648564547,
0.0494877063,
-0.0285029374,
0.0091527756,
0.0123636145,
0.0486808047,
0.0096526425,
0.0165455509,
-0.0474260077,
0.0611723438,
0.0026293478,
-0.0178784169,
0.0523609035,
0.0010622788,
-0.0202186443,
-0.0866416991,
0.0117012523,
-0.0135557791,
0.0234410837,
0.0398986489,
0.0345355198,
-0.0215209629,
-0.0162457097,
-0.0012651103,
0.0482189804,
-0.0284966622,
-0.0055407858,
-0.0568274632,
0.0582706481,
0.111845389,
0.0349315666,
-0.015458337,
-0.0414909869,
-0.0162747465,
-0.0195469745,
0.0511992648,
0.0740638152,
-0.0349172764,
-0.0457181893,
-0.0333316773,
-0.0280549265,
-0.0107989907,
0.0002518459,
0.0185769871,
0.0260458346,
-0.0209550392,
-0.0093167871,
0.0138096474,
-0.0380336083,
0.0316994302,
0.0343402214,
-0.0260573495,
0.0129627381,
0.000748934,
0.062488649,
0.0262855552,
-0.020443378,
0.0075807753,
0.0127900317,
-0.0142915202,
-0.0339275301,
0.0035276352,
-0.0714236423,
0.0001478224,
0.0635908246,
0.008184108,
-0.0262113754,
0.0539427772,
-0.0441285968,
-0.0185903776,
-0.0004645521,
-0.0171049163,
0.0063911714,
-0.0284688175,
-0.0045642843,
-0.0208402462,
-0.0110436128,
-0.0544657409,
0.0359794684,
-0.0054369792,
-0.0211195201,
-0.0221388303,
0.0035543402,
0.0272437986,
-0.0279079042,
-0.0461403839,
0.0038623449,
0.0179408062,
0.0371801592,
0.0677792132,
0.0384837314,
-0.0255911611,
-0.0202638693,
-0.0869676098,
-0.028806949,
-0.016544044,
0.0023457699,
0.0198214054,
-0.0007905061,
0.0140079986,
-0.0381488763,
-0.0519118682,
-0.0129701085,
0.0218180381,
0.0258572474,
0.051206667,
0.0124140708,
-0.0176361408,
-0.0899981707,
-0.0066984724,
-0.0260793902,
-0.0207140576,
0.026855981,
0.011497994,
-0.0414300188,
-0.0247817542,
-0.0460910797,
0.0402674749,
-0.0109867426,
-0.0648413971,
0.045617111,
0.0082847783,
-0.0030092432,
0.0711805522,
0.0301729124,
0.0361332223,
0.0856662616,
0.0418417417,
-0.0970787778,
0.0105438624,
-0.029157294,
-0.0140238637,
-0.0251275916,
-0.0132293282,
0.0143784322,
0.0568079166,
0.0088615417,
-0.0030422262,
-0.0694933459,
0.0181003455,
-0.0071599032,
-0.0377219059,
-0.0201864336,
-0.0332874581,
-0.0266069472,
0.0442675576,
-0.0117442971,
-0.055743698,
0.1080698222,
-0.0133360112,
0.0185101461,
-0.0348589197,
-0.0111748651,
-0.0453128442,
0.0287501477,
-0.0123590045,
0.0387005433,
-0.0174690261,
0.0239881743,
-0.0590613522,
-0.0342572927,
0.0285866074,
-0.0518416949,
0.0337655917,
-0.0518597215,
0.0181789435,
0.0183862429,
-0.0815334246,
-0.0632870421,
-0.0504389405,
-0.0549565479,
-0.008078848,
0.0046882345,
-0.0265724361,
0.0160330217,
-0.012506376,
0.0358118825,
-0.0033792648,
-0.011805743,
-0.0014530943,
-0.00953467,
-0.0201407969,
0.0785684437,
0.0182875246,
0.0125101088,
-0.0032296244,
-0.0016192198,
0.0492596254,
0.0132301152,
0.0161134284,
-0.0249509476,
-0.0116677042,
0.0289573371,
-0.0138755282,
0.0088503622,
0.0251223017,
0.0270764753,
-0.0194874108,
0.0006497061,
0.1175306961,
0.0348762646,
-0.0644443259,
0.017547138,
-0.0236924607,
0.0078285467,
0.0172369685,
0.0575327389,
-0.0915515572,
-0.0284452792,
-0.023356529,
0.0351770818,
0.0016939379,
0.0052643553,
0.0013861713,
-0.1277121007,
0.0016127815,
-0.011725083,
-0.0221740566,
-0.0183540192,
-0.0237298701,
0.0169571545,
-0.0280351322,
0.0164361969,
-0.0138597265,
0.0271898024,
-0.0194286183,
0.0027414917,
0.0071614892,
-0.0000463153,
0.0462280028,
-0.0427904874,
0.0925546288,
0.0993918926,
0.0470127948,
0.0166591872,
-0.0118529024,
0.0217407197,
0.0004943499,
-0.0191814005,
-0.0013048042,
0.0086184843,
-0.0160775967,
-0.0137876924,
-0.0256730448,
0.032839857,
-0.0003701861,
0.0073764217,
0.0057891873,
0.0480121113,
-0.006510119,
-0.0013708584,
-0.0374115445,
0.0371090658,
0.021689808,
0.0702723116,
0.0041766572,
-0.0962038115,
-0.037199419,
-0.0375705212,
-0.0411249846,
-0.0196294468,
-0.0516956709,
-0.0175878163,
-0.0016532446,
0.0045726006,
-0.0798593536,
-0.0564612225,
-0.039203044,
-0.0255756378,
0.0097431457,
-0.0352984928,
0.0254526921,
0.0029060217,
0.0290174875,
-0.0128647489,
-0.0379975848,
0.0208377503,
-0.0385495014,
0.0029943103,
0.0269559845,
-0.0195010863,
-0.0265907086,
0.0017553526,
-0.0250969436,
-0.067997694,
-0.0003092843,
0.0864810795,
0.0151321581,
0.0479707867,
-0.0149631295,
-0.0393121205,
0.0180575401,
0.0460456274,
-0.0377418324,
0.0097223427,
0.0190083608,
0.0559376292,
0.0065172305,
0.0424399339,
-0.043761231,
0.0307189748,
0.0061840829,
0.0286364332,
-0.0311093926,
-0.0543007031,
0.0456778146,
0.0028267533,
-0.0148750963,
-0.0025971895,
0.0129157249,
-0.0102736354,
0.0114278821,
-0.022748705,
-0.0527267456,
-0.0218050536,
-0.0313709415,
0.0075494968,
-0.0578730069,
-0.0084383097,
-0.0209878068,
-0.0203281865,
0.0235558692,
-0.0057942495,
0.0019394805,
0.0223887302,
0.0315047503,
-0.0170063972,
0.0004638604,
-0.0046116863,
0.007787188,
0.0277252551,
0.0261374749,
0.0068081766,
0.0484145656,
0.0277804229,
-0.044497665,
0.0033509275,
0.037136592,
-0.0426992066,
-0.0496684574,
-0.0126199713,
0.0066569126,
0.0494652353,
0.0082934303,
0.0533346683,
-0.0188236721,
-0.0073237689,
-0.0011968263,
0.0135575989,
-0.0212564189,
-0.0054490753,
0.0312885977,
0.0139884362,
-0.0136567727,
0.0051350226,
0.0383852422,
-0.0101020904,
0.0168480221,
0.0100400029,
0.0028385413,
-0.032626152,
-0.033100754,
-0.0180790406,
0.0208012983,
-0.0222272668,
-0.0275483746,
-0.037272919,
-0.0453930683,
0.0013506998,
0.0403577648,
-0.0198074989,
-0.0094197737,
0.0370392017,
0.0408244953,
-0.0163333453,
-0.0205327999,
-0.0308782738,
-0.0245469343,
-0.0657322332,
-0.0172865,
-0.0486015454,
-6.419694972e-33,
-0.0158612281,
-0.0467169695,
0.023110263,
-0.0039416114,
-0.0162175987,
-0.048742231,
-0.0021661855,
0.008071078,
-0.0313520059,
0.0181236528,
-0.0166319609,
0.016305659,
0.0068740956,
-0.000290955,
0.0341777168,
-0.0379195437,
0.0382782817,
-0.0370275564,
-0.0447872654,
0.0273093283,
0.0238292273,
-0.0297405124,
0.0229730122,
-0.0859362334,
0.0462470725,
0.0213296134,
-0.0292445887,
0.0318758711,
-0.0324468277,
0.0847503543,
-0.0231350325,
0.0790110454,
0.0067317109,
-0.0137101142,
0.0023728339,
0.0448341593,
-0.0342233442,
-0.0508527718,
0.0268731155,
-0.0212789383,
-0.0135314865,
-0.0205560774,
0.0325078145,
-0.0170242302,
-0.0427745879,
0.0432094932,
0.0254655685,
-0.0113462228,
0.0194570292,
0.0405369699,
-0.0506732576,
-0.0127024353,
-0.0355925187,
-0.0205625426,
-0.0131613389,
0.0610115752,
0.003736933,
0.02373356,
-0.0391950384,
0.0433923043,
0.0092501352,
0.0062666568,
0.0565628484,
-0.016016392,
0.0210713428,
0.0609722808,
0.0170103014,
0.0111570274,
-0.0236727074,
-0.0599657372,
-0.0192393996,
0.0256980751,
0.035386771,
0.0772055835,
0.0097959898,
-0.0139695751,
-0.075954318,
0.0156441554,
0.0281433705,
0.0471604317,
0.044721432,
0.0212519951,
-0.0711708367,
-0.0233065728,
-0.0385567695,
-0.0138839167,
-0.0472362489,
-0.0679679438,
0.0321451686,
0.0283628795,
-0.0357129686,
-0.01864787,
-0.0038833392,
-0.0783000886,
-0.0388703756,
0.0152895078,
-0.0446013287,
0.0161934551,
0.0283004344,
-0.00953467,
-0.0593867041,
0.0063814409,
-0.014962337,
-0.0157174505,
-0.0079606138,
0.0155163454,
0.021836549,
0.0095998878,
-0.0533928797,
0.0048872088,
-0.0258748028,
-0.0042955,
-0.0229162052,
-0.0599627048,
0.0249743909,
0.011962452,
-0.0171677303,
0.0565775596,
0.0138835218,
0.0106684789,
-0.0157313645,
-0.0264515597,
-0.002618256,
0.0083272187,
-0.0326772034,
0.015442118,
-0.0339065604,
0.0372358672,
-0.039260149,
-0.0581969358,
-0.0136183985,
-0.0157652888,
2.697e-7,
0.0210586898,
0.0550519973,
0.0261807106,
0.0268232711,
0.0036831468,
0.0597670972,
0.0188463163,
0.0356220566,
0.0064881891,
0.0062264763,
0.0317216888,
0.0422383845,
0.0203842819,
0.0194074363,
-0.0541019626,
0.0098713981,
-0.0890617073,
-0.0146146817,
-0.0400623642,
-0.0068087899,
0.0654280558,
0.080444172,
0.0333468989,
-0.0067654839,
-0.0183894243,
0.0306172483,
0.0707031712,
-0.0515951663,
-0.0018154536,
0.0259134304,
0.0083392067,
-0.0102967592,
-0.0129046021,
-0.003604688,
0.026731452,
0.0051836288,
-0.0175192542,
0.08582028,
0.0062934635,
-0.0701012313,
-0.0161756277,
0.0248771403,
0.0213291533,
-0.0539416745,
0.0641086623,
-0.0579577722,
-0.0317307897,
-0.0722219124,
0.0149673205,
-0.0116914827,
0.0283549409,
-0.0232578889,
-0.023627013,
-0.0042320048,
0.0105699291,
0.029105844,
-0.0105664954,
-0.0451350994,
-0.0244456697,
-0.0081098303,
-0.0148608256,
-0.0235558506,
-0.039436616,
0.0331390053,
0.0000386895,
-0.0493232086,
0.0415799804,
2.143695553e-34,
0.0209618844,
-0.033455696,
0.0176755525,
0.0053489371,
0.0206723977,
0.0519287959,
0.0108055277,
0.0198083445,
0.0631276518,
-0.056485299,
-0.02618099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11177v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11177v1 | TIFG: Text-Informed Feature Generation with Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T03:29:14 | 2024-06-17T03:29:14 | Xinhao Zhang, Jinghan Zhang, Fengran Mo, Yuzhong Chen, Kunpeng Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Textual information of data is of vital importance for data mining and
feature engineering. However, existing methods focus on learning the data
structures and overlook the textual information along with the data.
Consequently, they waste this valuable resource and miss out on the deeper data
relationships embedded within the texts. In this paper, we introduce
Text-Informed Feature Generation (TIFG), a novel LLM-based text-informed
feature generation framework. TIFG utilizes the textual information to generate
features by retrieving possible relevant features within external knowledge
with Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) technology. In this approach, the
TIFG can generate new explainable features to enrich the feature space and
further mine feature relationships. We design the TIFG to be an automated
framework that continuously optimizes the feature generation process, adapts to
new data inputs, and improves downstream task performance over iterations. A
broad range of experiments in various downstream tasks showcases that our
approach can generate high-quality and meaningful features, and is
significantly superior to existing methods. | [
0.0285330024,
0.0287665408,
-0.024719853,
0.0491083153,
-0.004900659,
-0.0123930303,
-0.003883169,
0.0031303496,
0.0304914173,
-0.0658418611,
0.0114631811,
0.0064186626,
-0.0151538206,
0.0465966538,
-0.0074189338,
-0.0109276148,
0.0280112922,
-0.0184360854,
-0.0083641605,
0.0298699085,
-0.0084147146,
0.0354822241,
0.0279403385,
0.0183000844,
-0.0247117169,
0.0353778787,
-0.042733591,
-0.0049390248,
0.0077120308,
0.0064357389,
-0.0222309548,
0.015480387,
0.0270608608,
-0.0102965143,
0.0000022752,
-0.0541658886,
-0.0410406627,
0.0068143741,
-0.0168183763,
-0.0243443474,
0.0527429469,
0.0293107182,
0.0095126675,
0.0237063169,
-0.0227569826,
0.0248734187,
0.027197456,
0.0825637653,
0.0286327302,
0.0634048581,
-0.0222767498,
-0.021181019,
-0.0020297971,
0.0120621054,
0.0875258744,
0.0029482418,
-0.0115388148,
-0.0012207138,
0.0167236235,
0.0187678412,
0.0234586801,
0.0337314494,
-0.0104507729,
-0.0137737105,
0.0621747561,
0.0227559656,
-0.010665603,
-0.0043043992,
0.0109501136,
0.0651217923,
-0.007774008,
-0.0296976902,
0.0326602831,
-0.0147286728,
-0.0051750368,
0.0552445538,
-0.0149518894,
0.0081690056,
-0.0166132841,
0.028280003,
-0.0046052597,
-0.0260412004,
0.0150569025,
-0.0022651546,
-0.03890571,
0.0168332476,
-0.0037176891,
0.0199661516,
-0.0266407337,
-0.0140198274,
-0.0394522697,
-0.0274554808,
0.0014675691,
0.0461739786,
-0.0028945548,
0.028317133,
-0.0109460065,
-0.0585368834,
0.0274147056,
-0.0481134392,
-0.0172815844,
0.0193048064,
-0.067691572,
0.0103280731,
-0.0717772916,
0.0275698099,
0.0057906061,
-0.0310171507,
-0.0515122674,
0.0064724027,
-0.0931486785,
-0.0432523899,
-0.0080683576,
0.0499672219,
-0.0036368696,
0.0048512397,
-0.0025125328,
0.0265903417,
0.0062530171,
0.0277028233,
0.0022907541,
0.0402889811,
-0.0355709381,
0.0062370347,
-0.0462619625,
-0.0483426191,
0.0087624462,
-0.0094732624,
-0.031559892,
-0.0286673009,
0.0253353082,
0.0232687667,
0.035807386,
-0.0055513498,
0.0243624393,
0.0675890818,
-0.0213648044,
-0.0498122014,
-0.0663378686,
-0.0986407027,
-0.0021721772,
-0.033713717,
-0.0138333123,
-0.0741830021,
-0.0066691437,
0.0111068748,
-0.0472595468,
-0.0458002873,
0.0492849126,
0.0248631667,
-0.0293029342,
0.0535910316,
-0.0473334864,
0.0148021178,
0.0168546923,
-0.003126953,
0.0431623869,
0.0340547487,
0.0507266447,
0.0664148331,
0.0334758535,
0.0112469001,
-0.0000098964,
0.0212796368,
0.0066280537,
-0.0197097361,
-0.023472907,
0.010179502,
-0.0108089792,
-0.0173311252,
0.0100721987,
0.0001555302,
0.0184426606,
0.0281438846,
0.0332585573,
0.0468782075,
0.0395384282,
0.0689276904,
0.0253544524,
0.0348342657,
-0.0267030112,
-0.0124071445,
0.01824685,
0.0284934081,
-0.0489648543,
0.0188541058,
-0.0078408075,
0.0534564853,
-0.0104181487,
-0.0627860725,
-0.0073918761,
-0.0246037114,
0.0245088562,
0.026478963,
0.0804288313,
0.0229477603,
-0.0132365162,
0.0615402199,
0.0137949977,
-0.0864689723,
-0.033651188,
-0.04430243,
0.0414626822,
0.116108872,
0.0680998862,
-0.0454158783,
-0.0226517282,
0.0185343288,
-0.0072430721,
0.0192375835,
-0.0204176512,
-0.0127582382,
-0.0117208771,
-0.0375112854,
-0.0404513292,
-0.0041497489,
-0.0089583946,
0.0252371859,
-0.0297863875,
-0.0039626583,
0.0439847559,
-0.0196611341,
-0.0751383305,
0.0293097347,
-0.0445319377,
-0.01364021,
0.0600370392,
0.0256801657,
-0.0264095254,
0.0225253422,
-0.0304045137,
0.021259075,
0.0691825971,
-0.0662015378,
-0.0258342549,
0.0407770574,
0.0322797596,
-0.0150288064,
0.0217076875,
0.0004509539,
0.0350767709,
-0.0470988192,
-0.0234948583,
-0.0372284725,
0.0088380454,
-0.0545404479,
0.0331465937,
-0.0605971217,
0.0148472851,
-0.0117183113,
-0.0221103281,
-0.065347977,
0.0827317387,
0.0195678454,
-0.0072674048,
0.0048260526,
-0.0247369464,
0.0524499528,
-0.0068036402,
0.0370711125,
0.0142725445,
-0.0066454867,
0.0048777754,
0.0422828794,
0.0187842362,
-0.011341312,
-0.0197121222,
-0.0854693502,
0.0319035389,
0.0023785033,
-0.004153403,
0.0203332473,
0.0034492656,
0.0087862415,
-0.0213403199,
-0.0581858233,
-0.0133303562,
0.0347466879,
-0.0295498911,
0.0442560576,
0.0295976251,
-0.0293536987,
-0.0059783086,
0.0205529425,
-0.0055173668,
0.0550931096,
0.0351239368,
-0.0357307829,
-0.0703182146,
0.071452938,
-0.0372594893,
0.008929044,
-0.0356687009,
0.007174009,
-0.0175821222,
-0.0348585397,
-0.0035192089,
-0.017130401,
0.0130061647,
0.010591819,
0.0715114996,
-0.0233898871,
-0.0633469597,
0.0264121722,
-0.0348445624,
0.0248994213,
0.0211240202,
-0.0442850031,
0.0070569571,
-0.0110357422,
0.0209520943,
-0.0347215571,
-0.0335460193,
0.0162562951,
0.0339609869,
-0.0267753694,
-0.0554655753,
-0.0107686324,
0.0286228303,
0.060400676,
-0.0286815297,
-0.0747130364,
0.0319372378,
-0.039879404,
0.0286250729,
-0.0489008054,
-0.0159957092,
-0.0667247549,
0.0962300301,
0.0144638577,
0.0402058847,
-0.0183588695,
-0.0153058935,
-0.0224938784,
0.0322516151,
0.0236474313,
-0.0592614971,
0.0867220834,
-0.0347748026,
0.0247655381,
0.0356349684,
-0.0040679979,
-0.0638591796,
-0.0341042764,
0.027930174,
-0.0199059956,
0.0030154376,
-0.0318555422,
-0.010848769,
-0.0171070416,
0.0476633757,
0.0108564217,
0.0098929629,
-0.023139406,
-0.012988491,
0.0262114238,
0.048988685,
0.0108104916,
-0.0058830422,
0.0002085978,
0.0044916482,
0.0345921181,
-0.0257917903,
-0.0422175899,
-0.0112734865,
0.0088460352,
0.0008969498,
-0.0329865813,
-0.0051542507,
0.0075447266,
0.0153776286,
-0.0585702509,
-0.007897798,
0.0706025213,
0.0617851689,
-0.0148043856,
0.011144802,
-0.0262632426,
0.0393735953,
0.0228213128,
0.0517534092,
-0.062977396,
-0.0287678912,
-0.0011792228,
0.0160808414,
-0.0319507606,
-0.0123067396,
-0.0319173485,
-0.1047768891,
0.0523188002,
0.0080384482,
0.0063102841,
-0.0473629199,
-0.0619868487,
-0.0226368662,
0.0130703449,
-0.0263657141,
0.0127106132,
-0.0266759694,
0.0136551978,
0.0041468623,
-0.0502834283,
-0.0479256138,
0.0017981717,
-0.0077296956,
-0.0389725454,
0.1112388596,
0.0274178274,
0.0104864379,
-0.0164443068,
-0.0358979069,
0.0366919897,
0.0669879541,
-0.0398147516,
0.0745049044,
0.0430832505,
-0.0093364837,
-0.0228640623,
0.0346631743,
-0.0147538856,
-0.0286616944,
0.0002956941,
0.0641961619,
-0.0446866527,
0.012603051,
-0.0147723109,
-0.0386510119,
0.0315733105,
0.0387079827,
-0.0194586441,
-0.0432337858,
-0.0086290585,
-0.0353638083,
-0.0173941627,
-0.0221839715,
-0.0632572323,
0.0155569632,
-0.0391684994,
-0.040022932,
-0.0849376693,
-0.0067173932,
0.0493745208,
0.0007544467,
0.0274813492,
0.0365342833,
-0.0373433791,
-0.0142332306,
-0.0989819095,
0.0275973231,
-0.0020058688,
0.0105426423,
0.0120614339,
-0.014401434,
0.0346709453,
-0.134208262,
-0.016139796,
0.0224575512,
-0.0484422408,
-0.0605643429,
-0.040559344,
0.0129870605,
0.0142520191,
0.0356571414,
0.0053585162,
-0.0237849709,
0.0802595839,
0.0725645944,
-0.0624216497,
-0.0110249612,
-0.0203634966,
-0.0152358934,
0.0108501529,
0.0277133249,
-0.062997885,
-0.0128791062,
0.003624826,
-0.0048395279,
-0.0047212322,
-0.027511809,
0.0320687629,
0.0544455796,
0.0212722719,
0.0068738027,
-0.0157224964,
-0.0629620031,
0.0247147586,
-0.0080248425,
-0.017423749,
-0.058684241,
0.0674968287,
-0.0302963443,
-0.0297359452,
0.0285960473,
-0.0091026695,
-0.0209902022,
0.0294232853,
0.0034746258,
0.0219108649,
-0.0538745858,
0.0437017977,
0.037039157,
0.0129821077,
0.0114241121,
0.0322455987,
0.0119355842,
0.0336781032,
-0.0236221887,
0.0307348762,
-0.0026565804,
-0.0051523135,
-0.0714523643,
0.0094480906,
-0.0164009407,
-0.0449528359,
-0.0746989548,
-0.0039524892,
0.044219248,
-0.0197729636,
0.0606001578,
-0.0469918624,
-0.009880919,
-0.023117749,
0.0524747223,
0.0209863037,
-0.0106140617,
-0.0217386801,
-0.0119705889,
-0.0595788658,
-0.0405017324,
0.076228112,
0.0095922332,
0.0182870552,
-0.016428167,
-0.0656830966,
-0.0402655378,
-0.0005865096,
0.0529523157,
0.0043179463,
-0.0269123465,
0.0017125093,
-0.0269301105,
-0.0305109974,
0.042151235,
-0.0226813164,
-0.0204827767,
-0.0101553053,
0.0339314379,
0.0591663755,
0.0189540163,
0.0114672659,
-0.0626208186,
-0.0073890355,
-0.068260543,
-0.0233163163,
0.0136917019,
-6.212789599e-33,
-0.0223067421,
-0.1005551368,
0.0301172473,
0.0100800935,
0.0100013111,
-0.0235452913,
-0.0325025134,
0.0229916889,
0.024048835,
-0.0078377593,
0.0001669417,
-0.0182687249,
0.0016107411,
-0.0108199902,
0.0269970428,
-0.0036293482,
0.0362622701,
0.0318493918,
0.0142092695,
0.0522729903,
0.0867075697,
0.0397369191,
0.0426079407,
-0.0997917876,
-0.007086853,
-0.0074738408,
-0.0029333602,
0.0232672896,
0.0204094909,
0.0546891354,
-0.0187515076,
0.0368472151,
0.0226148609,
-0.0264009759,
-0.0245435014,
-0.0151700405,
-0.031347122,
-0.0352252498,
-0.0130268428,
-0.0085445829,
0.0005684111,
-0.0569284074,
0.0298668053,
-0.0251403507,
-0.0011767696,
0.0149975149,
0.0797933564,
-0.0467075482,
-0.0025157304,
-0.0384602137,
-0.041314844,
0.0492747575,
-0.0107323062,
0.0034564617,
0.0359839387,
0.0317990556,
0.0162954722,
0.0340321176,
-0.0455007106,
0.0233556293,
0.031350784,
0.0326800756,
0.0703891516,
0.0091734128,
0.0335876159,
0.0813003182,
0.013569654,
-0.0093404595,
-0.0516493395,
0.0250155907,
-0.0117959082,
0.1218767911,
0.0174236428,
0.0433516204,
0.0368174575,
-0.0197705943,
-0.0776488036,
0.0698169619,
-0.0192141384,
0.0024444058,
0.0304490812,
0.00138256,
-0.0120263426,
-0.0148643143,
-0.0304636303,
0.0422801115,
-0.0463768281,
-0.0618257038,
0.0157653615,
0.0279244538,
-0.0171296913,
-0.0029220907,
0.0044913059,
-0.0201402102,
0.0043174531,
0.0387270339,
-0.0509664789,
0.0074113542,
-0.0080301333,
-0.0359866433,
0.001742084,
-0.0245584901,
0.0137892514,
-0.0370432213,
0.0122022312,
0.0165285636,
0.0148765696,
0.0162356123,
-0.035812173,
0.0278655142,
-0.0099057117,
0.0039993618,
-0.0187095124,
0.0061584297,
-0.0090705324,
-0.0058521051,
-0.0201083813,
0.0528159142,
0.0173201449,
0.0118275806,
-0.0286959242,
-0.0105832051,
0.0115999049,
0.0037625039,
-0.0058242553,
0.0134893432,
-0.0086395619,
-0.0174800139,
0.0622933768,
-0.0214101095,
0.0034745829,
0.0243954472,
2.93e-7,
0.0297867171,
0.0372348465,
-0.0038139569,
0.013199605,
-0.011298974,
0.0460005552,
-0.001872999,
-0.0137572307,
0.0155343823,
-0.0089179715,
0.043335598,
0.0160940289,
0.0496428236,
0.06920138,
-0.0922715217,
0.0055886046,
0.0210225061,
-0.0480327643,
-0.0649595261,
-0.0139334165,
0.0537778474,
0.0615203492,
-0.0290972814,
-0.0248156041,
0.0322741345,
-0.0580549836,
0.0399990492,
-0.0449817888,
-0.0173257794,
0.0314959176,
0.0493279845,
0.0109119201,
-0.0276988484,
-0.0063123084,
-0.0456688255,
0.0311165601,
-0.020807853,
0.0223982465,
-0.002176028,
-0.0224150624,
0.0213735104,
-0.0027230887,
0.0094124405,
0.0046909554,
0.0688401908,
0.0099844532,
-0.0034845527,
-0.0251286123,
0.0316799283,
-0.0135088423,
-0.0373612083,
-0.0236378908,
0.0133069884,
0.0293412637,
-0.0007168052,
-0.0316745974,
-0.0066440562,
-0.0700009614,
-0.0328648351,
0.0447021648,
-0.0578221343,
-0.0126699256,
-0.0351919495,
0.0392514989,
0.0147192199,
-0.0297254641,
0.0266737323,
3.226483119e-34,
0.0046988726,
0.0086421613,
-0.0389106087,
0.0445409827,
0.050101161,
-0.0104579441,
-0.0113978758,
0.0144694727,
0.0191461369,
-0.0843787789,
-0.006297613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11176v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11176v1 | Watch Every Step! LLM Agent Learning via Iterative Step-Level Process Refinement | 2024-06-17T03:29:13 | 2024-06-17T03:29:13 | Weimin Xiong, Yifan Song, Xiutian Zhao, Wenhao Wu, Xun Wang, Ke Wang, Cheng Li, Wei Peng, Sujian Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language model agents have exhibited exceptional performance across a
range of complex interactive tasks. Recent approaches have utilized tuning with
expert trajectories to enhance agent performance, yet they primarily
concentrate on outcome rewards, which may lead to errors or suboptimal actions
due to the absence of process supervision signals. In this paper, we introduce
the Iterative step-level Process Refinement (IPR) framework, which provides
detailed step-by-step guidance to enhance agent training. Specifically, we
adopt the Monte Carlo method to estimate step-level rewards. During each
iteration, the agent explores along the expert trajectory and generates new
actions. These actions are then evaluated against the corresponding step of
expert trajectory using step-level rewards. Such comparison helps identify
discrepancies, yielding contrastive action pairs that serve as training data
for the agent. Our experiments on three complex agent tasks demonstrate that
our framework outperforms a variety of strong baselines. Moreover, our
analytical findings highlight the effectiveness of IPR in augmenting action
efficiency and its applicability to diverse models. | [
0.0052988189,
-0.000809672,
-0.0095534669,
-0.0115453107,
-0.0238314774,
0.0218429863,
-0.0326340795,
-0.008616358,
-0.009311595,
-0.0068203765,
-0.044484634,
0.0157245118,
-0.0430656336,
0.0409289449,
-0.0040975735,
-0.0541378334,
0.0325126462,
-0.0519783869,
0.0502587296,
-0.0106287133,
-0.0271427389,
-0.0196712203,
-0.0413195789,
0.0672469214,
0.0013118054,
0.0066895182,
-0.0276809912,
0.0151809631,
0.0435883738,
-0.07615529,
0.007596212,
0.0177884866,
0.064929992,
0.0342742838,
0.0000021614,
-0.0496978983,
0.0184067581,
-0.0235504936,
-0.0456421785,
-0.0367760658,
0.0335246325,
0.017098343,
-0.0219867565,
0.0116086164,
-0.0302535221,
0.0089664096,
-0.006214723,
0.0660476387,
0.0536794774,
0.0715456605,
0.0129951742,
-0.0064460123,
-0.0129456175,
-0.0038024578,
-0.009666889,
-0.0606255308,
-0.0068581561,
0.0007797901,
0.0189075228,
0.0005682243,
-0.0183664355,
-0.0112202531,
0.0354982987,
-0.03196989,
0.0088222502,
0.0565937534,
0.045770511,
-0.0173617844,
-0.027734682,
0.035660509,
-0.0248876382,
0.0092806602,
-0.0200429838,
-0.0231878888,
0.0144558921,
-0.0263114963,
-0.0309413318,
0.0125751365,
0.0006158652,
0.0390608981,
0.0038436514,
-0.0273960195,
0.0410871767,
-0.0060159881,
-0.0186710674,
0.0849597603,
-0.0244379304,
-0.0441392697,
0.0423018336,
0.0170403644,
0.0216870178,
-0.0392837971,
-0.021580901,
0.0352868922,
-0.0619401261,
0.0239690971,
0.007930072,
0.0258445069,
-0.0289357603,
-0.0031096295,
0.0830938146,
0.0268953927,
0.0314957313,
0.0394764245,
-0.0255990401,
0.0227953997,
0.0136361029,
0.0340724513,
-0.0365033448,
0.0281844568,
-0.0702356994,
0.0156600364,
-0.0295176897,
0.0233311336,
-0.0183832999,
-0.0082192877,
-0.0308773406,
0.0326394066,
0.000232931,
0.0481445231,
0.0148041872,
-0.0153321838,
-0.0362410843,
0.0192247014,
-0.0621630028,
0.0093813958,
-0.0514437109,
0.0411826372,
0.0342036746,
0.0074993684,
-0.0117704524,
-0.0065868944,
-0.0190935526,
0.005489212,
0.0099300779,
0.0770799667,
-0.0289859474,
-0.0426289402,
-0.0567814112,
-0.0014043803,
0.0652099699,
-0.0643678308,
0.0211610291,
-0.033585988,
0.0115225315,
-0.0438913107,
-0.0145562859,
-0.0153873349,
-0.0012610662,
-0.0415280536,
-0.0111732744,
0.0570944846,
0.0133717274,
0.0027694367,
0.0162152741,
0.0004880197,
-0.0193157848,
0.0585565902,
0.0491277389,
0.0113148056,
-0.0010914744,
0.0031012623,
0.0507952906,
0.0405349061,
-0.0125231482,
0.0419264436,
0.0284673478,
-0.0246174727,
0.0016900214,
0.0441322625,
0.0804594457,
-0.0277402643,
-0.0678460076,
0.0708988979,
0.066448167,
0.0503130518,
0.0135076521,
-0.030316731,
0.0540094078,
0.0307574291,
0.0128720701,
-0.0132915992,
-0.0832205564,
0.0300922971,
0.0051248358,
0.0166686941,
-0.054194469,
-0.0052314396,
-0.0384832472,
-0.0414557271,
0.0317570642,
0.0253133252,
0.037809141,
0.0238963887,
0.0299357995,
-0.0001139397,
-0.0722639337,
-0.0049462081,
0.0349798687,
-0.0374025702,
0.0086950231,
-0.0605406277,
0.034925472,
0.1104662195,
0.0418407843,
-0.0280645844,
-0.0098667024,
-0.0293299258,
0.0109868646,
0.0331197046,
-0.0179310963,
-0.0211805943,
0.0304187965,
-0.0216512829,
-0.0754210055,
-0.029595796,
0.0191554297,
0.0473602116,
0.0245989524,
-0.0232354403,
-0.0266038589,
-0.0085350387,
-0.0390216522,
0.0408316962,
-0.0194367673,
-0.0413179286,
0.015663797,
-0.0124265105,
0.0331164747,
-0.0077810171,
-0.0145144947,
-0.0133311776,
0.0333484784,
0.0112693943,
-0.0012281513,
0.0316707678,
-0.0116013028,
-0.036394231,
0.0253321845,
0.0093741221,
-0.0077342433,
-0.0100389663,
-0.0352505855,
-0.0278735552,
0.0102920085,
-0.0187499952,
0.0117198182,
0.007384134,
0.0551686957,
-0.0117586059,
-0.001258536,
-0.0323390961,
0.0350504592,
-0.0199201014,
-0.032465823,
0.0189690795,
0.0183320567,
-0.0237273574,
-0.0563351884,
0.0341951288,
-0.0063592484,
0.0271141361,
0.0145322289,
0.0326545238,
0.0235240478,
-0.0487950109,
-0.0445552282,
-0.0666441396,
-0.0286439303,
-0.0082740132,
0.0185329877,
0.0153803807,
-0.0294309929,
-0.0218714327,
-0.0141498987,
0.0042348057,
0.0143339923,
0.0315967947,
0.014102703,
0.0039746929,
0.0072894911,
-0.077692464,
-0.045261655,
0.01907067,
0.0079168631,
-0.028511012,
-0.0070162578,
0.0289810859,
-0.0737909004,
0.0133774085,
-0.0012728942,
0.0247063302,
-0.0401342213,
-0.0445970856,
0.0622785464,
-0.0206557177,
0.0077074049,
0.0877743214,
-0.0184846986,
0.0547733568,
0.0418642014,
-0.0257529188,
-0.0677414909,
0.0477688648,
-0.0180741139,
-0.0157502554,
-0.0921601728,
-0.009643686,
0.0214880053,
0.0775966197,
-0.0179624762,
0.0613247678,
-0.0333253667,
-0.0246390291,
-0.0095475465,
-0.0776204765,
-0.0030927099,
0.0014976936,
-0.0405675732,
0.0252696797,
-0.0318629742,
-0.0331422687,
0.0655893981,
0.0108451117,
-0.0228365194,
-0.0436393395,
-0.0343995541,
0.0186825637,
0.0644070432,
-0.0022199419,
0.0010206543,
-0.0626132563,
-0.0289080106,
-0.0414826423,
-0.0223508161,
0.0628199279,
0.0098266415,
0.0515286885,
-0.0695830509,
-0.0214545988,
0.0077033341,
-0.0445468798,
-0.0443620309,
-0.0012911037,
-0.0134378253,
0.0128634423,
-0.0180976447,
-0.0338443406,
-0.023832228,
-0.0060587497,
0.0594953895,
0.0283714719,
0.0119996918,
-0.0419631936,
-0.0372714996,
-0.047728423,
0.0298625045,
0.0124317463,
0.0051633301,
-0.0539067201,
0.0733472854,
0.0208402053,
0.0643241927,
-0.0374100357,
-0.0256179739,
0.0195588004,
0.0198009945,
-0.0585019328,
0.0174725112,
0.0629783273,
0.0661799908,
-0.0730123892,
-0.0238791686,
0.1053134054,
0.0103080813,
-0.0308699012,
0.0263480525,
-0.0231340546,
0.0279316213,
0.0104879988,
0.0377521515,
-0.015953429,
-0.0133524807,
0.0168509278,
0.0381576531,
-0.0153670274,
-0.0227498151,
0.0316750035,
-0.0873517469,
0.0606412888,
0.016828103,
-0.0238373298,
-0.0062535857,
-0.0469737835,
-0.0051786467,
-0.0124860732,
0.0291893631,
0.044827573,
0.0063652201,
-0.0305664223,
0.0202883892,
0.0116686039,
-0.0602491125,
0.0193165783,
-0.0563001074,
0.0278374236,
0.0831293836,
-0.0036811333,
-0.0006156908,
0.0116452044,
0.0399926752,
0.0205945652,
0.0512655564,
0.0103574907,
0.0260677394,
-0.0075943857,
0.0077903708,
0.0038663438,
0.037612807,
-0.0123856897,
-0.0375967585,
0.0045224824,
0.0670319051,
-0.0643015206,
-0.021668924,
0.0130976951,
-0.0156852361,
0.0159444176,
0.0425281376,
-0.0067246705,
-0.0420961045,
-0.0510789156,
-0.0385299362,
-0.0311657544,
-0.0195932072,
-0.0193222165,
0.0073184646,
-0.0226705428,
0.0130239185,
-0.0278534293,
-0.097219713,
0.0470402613,
0.0383614451,
-0.0015355026,
-0.0077796858,
-0.0116131585,
0.0143477833,
-0.0063029164,
0.0135458196,
-0.0350677632,
0.036540702,
-0.0382632352,
-0.0367590375,
-0.0213433523,
-0.022598153,
0.006544766,
-0.0118458588,
-0.0774468854,
-0.0449636914,
-0.0160702448,
0.0813837871,
0.0169101637,
0.0889378116,
-0.0087977899,
-0.0327032879,
0.0346767455,
-0.045951061,
-0.0147326048,
0.0320830941,
0.0535334125,
0.0532182679,
-0.0149546051,
0.020792529,
-0.044069279,
0.0112952348,
0.0217061192,
0.0528161786,
-0.0358176008,
-0.0618292913,
0.0191030204,
-0.0385685563,
0.0283551533,
-0.0201194528,
0.0054793665,
-0.036926575,
0.0247786157,
-0.0206609536,
0.0014739244,
-0.0405383557,
-0.0112088285,
0.047218401,
0.0032893149,
0.0219231304,
0.0139398007,
-0.0123065263,
-0.0204881653,
-0.0278331377,
0.0180107225,
-0.0032860446,
0.0000822588,
0.0108545553,
0.0201683771,
-0.0104096197,
0.014723504,
0.027393844,
0.024134418,
0.0409399644,
0.0836741626,
0.0160842743,
0.0153841404,
-0.0233120471,
0.014936923,
-0.063323833,
-0.0220112856,
0.0053336602,
0.0422219075,
0.0877800509,
0.0173701122,
0.0586283319,
-0.0666939914,
0.0309322141,
0.0089135254,
-0.0041817129,
-0.0094242459,
-0.0259778369,
0.0303610768,
0.0363296755,
0.006282609,
-0.0166959744,
0.060277909,
0.0041899118,
0.085047327,
-0.0531847849,
0.0232871622,
-0.0427929536,
-0.053286083,
-0.0050369357,
0.0155562656,
-0.0203886498,
-0.0077463803,
-0.0245805159,
-0.0345568247,
-0.0513080247,
0.010298009,
-0.0212675445,
-0.072141856,
0.0501675196,
0.0349506289,
-0.0359047614,
-0.0513023324,
-0.0360208377,
-0.080785431,
0.0248696841,
-0.0061974735,
-0.0617814511,
-5.926175424e-33,
-0.0192166604,
-0.0122600133,
0.0617681965,
0.0213716291,
-0.0385635085,
-0.0445344225,
-0.0507192574,
0.0096238535,
0.0114652319,
0.0532467254,
-0.0326342434,
0.0202297345,
0.0193626657,
-0.0160201229,
0.0173742138,
0.0053472049,
0.0802879557,
-0.0172511861,
-0.0737929866,
-0.0098059187,
-0.0069551738,
0.0089839157,
0.0635159612,
-0.0557516925,
-0.0074250721,
0.0269368235,
-0.0503777005,
0.0559927486,
0.0093631381,
0.0303331092,
0.0289688706,
-0.017149888,
0.0133778593,
-0.0494882576,
-0.0243215356,
-0.0572189689,
-0.0664318427,
-0.0271831788,
-0.0077078645,
0.0041429852,
-0.0620370246,
-0.0250123572,
0.0256634988,
0.0029943543,
-0.0591453724,
0.0275948551,
0.0054238373,
-0.0084216138,
-0.0196121633,
0.0079376185,
-0.0754987448,
0.0152576249,
-0.001272822,
-0.0286293887,
0.0235929918,
0.000420041,
-0.0323053822,
-0.0852819681,
-0.0448280722,
0.0137385409,
0.0292284526,
0.0261015501,
0.0596813448,
0.0539470129,
0.0317747779,
0.0170364343,
0.0458666645,
0.0417337418,
-0.0118411947,
-0.0054411213,
0.0412401929,
0.0267435443,
0.0058118459,
0.0102472473,
-0.0420222543,
0.0371842124,
-0.0184536483,
0.0399162546,
0.0546050705,
0.1045914963,
-0.0121351071,
0.0461993553,
-0.0108150346,
-0.0242697336,
-0.0658469945,
0.0274004415,
0.0182928909,
-0.052921012,
0.0408397131,
0.0513273552,
0.0288946182,
-0.0700099692,
0.0184797533,
0.0049503772,
-0.0126206158,
-0.0083652278,
-0.0283609163,
0.0342143439,
0.0087714233,
-0.0190813616,
-0.0803248733,
-0.0543562435,
0.0300840996,
-0.0189164914,
0.0019399163,
0.0206358228,
-0.0200630631,
0.0501252487,
-0.0326161943,
0.0316917934,
-0.0308018588,
0.0291481558,
0.0283927377,
0.0276715774,
0.0307370033,
-0.0304559525,
-0.0059492127,
0.0208868366,
-0.0134874508,
-0.0240818746,
-0.0024350884,
0.0490910858,
0.002944475,
0.0246288087,
-0.0293261074,
0.0091449628,
-0.0659647584,
0.0174178276,
0.0031675317,
-0.0510345474,
-0.0119811473,
0.0180232879,
2.892e-7,
-0.0390250906,
0.024259327,
-0.0011583325,
0.055270806,
0.038240172,
0.0514996089,
-0.0469606258,
-0.0154234627,
0.0040204148,
-0.0175820831,
0.0429434218,
0.0534802265,
0.0239163265,
-0.0135763343,
-0.0593156479,
-0.0724791735,
-0.029844081,
0.0034461778,
-0.0324573927,
-0.0471498445,
-0.0131560592,
0.0774370283,
0.0222616512,
-0.0076287501,
0.0256761257,
-0.042213019,
0.0607353412,
-0.0259324685,
-0.0102633527,
0.0347793214,
-0.0059130434,
0.006692518,
-0.0028364202,
0.010994127,
-0.0161680896,
0.0229986385,
-0.06962502,
0.0898007527,
-0.028651258,
-0.0078671053,
-0.0149069866,
0.002912357,
0.0266540349,
-0.0164052024,
0.024236219,
-0.0483355559,
-0.0218050815,
0.0045107286,
0.0069103446,
-0.0215190984,
-0.0024649363,
-0.0127657782,
-0.0336659364,
0.0307562388,
0.0070781778,
0.0311567448,
-0.0232946854,
-0.0513200872,
-0.0099780569,
-0.0021359965,
-0.0120502999,
-0.060171511,
-0.0183766913,
0.0255808029,
-0.0183745325,
-0.0345831253,
-0.0036715944,
2.683423555e-34,
0.0277770218,
-0.0234791655,
0.0323413387,
0.035407044,
0.020671308,
0.0255373456,
-0.0360494964,
0.0320313387,
0.0550558306,
-0.0383932814,
0.0022864474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11173v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11173v2 | BSRBF-KAN: A combination of B-splines and Radial Basic Functions in Kolmogorov-Arnold Networks | 2024-06-17T03:26:02 | 2024-06-19T23:01:14 | Hoang-Thang Ta | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we introduce BSRBF-KAN, a Kolmogorov Arnold Network (KAN) that
combines Bsplines and radial basis functions (RBFs) to fit input vectors in
data training. We perform experiments with BSRBF-KAN, MLP, and other popular
KANs, including EfficientKAN, FastKAN, FasterKAN, and GottliebKAN over the
MNIST and Fashion-MNIST datasets. BSRBF-KAN shows stability in 5 training
sessions with a competitive average accuracy of 97.55% on MNIST and 89.33% on
FashionMNIST and obtains convergence better than other networks. We expect
BSRBF-KAN to open many combinations of mathematical functions to design KANs.
Our repo is publicly available at: https://github.com/hoangthangta/BSRBF-KAN. | [
-0.0487310439,
0.0830269903,
-0.0170327555,
0.0370926224,
-0.0117084868,
-0.0606128052,
0.0008489455,
0.0115554128,
-0.0449375287,
0.0481348448,
-0.038691327,
-0.0401050895,
-0.0087854834,
0.0531051755,
0.0007280958,
-0.0390122719,
-0.0524264574,
-0.007246681,
0.0020868611,
-0.0247165505,
0.0328012295,
-0.0330119506,
-0.0397703499,
0.0481517725,
-0.0876123384,
0.0239845067,
0.012383352,
-0.0215490051,
0.0588537827,
-0.0590412505,
0.036293745,
0.022928901,
0.0197339505,
0.0049872668,
0.0000023159,
-0.0163171738,
0.0337414443,
0.040407598,
0.0107237268,
-0.00075078,
0.0023715899,
0.0226303264,
-0.0157112665,
-0.0129812015,
-0.0513942055,
-0.0220307969,
0.0619974323,
0.0783980414,
0.037240427,
0.0630071089,
-0.0099367676,
-0.092728354,
0.0215427838,
-0.0593665875,
0.0133688562,
-0.0152338622,
0.0182428863,
0.0005316497,
-0.0183985867,
-0.0305503495,
-0.0160935558,
0.0739340633,
0.0441576801,
0.0012519478,
0.0832098201,
0.0487272292,
-0.0049355659,
0.0236736443,
0.0236921404,
0.0850127637,
-0.0349157788,
-0.0242009517,
0.0009654916,
0.0070660431,
-0.0100463089,
0.013248018,
-0.0125161055,
-0.0015408448,
-0.0209933519,
0.0047815475,
-0.087889351,
0.037202742,
0.0311780069,
-0.0159702748,
0.0179306138,
0.0268148351,
-0.0301163942,
-0.0323960334,
0.047418192,
-0.020780487,
-0.0398316979,
-0.0113736335,
0.0102185216,
-0.010002601,
0.0245881062,
0.0040830341,
-0.0255023986,
0.0311872791,
0.0025554996,
-0.0378296785,
0.100208208,
0.0149832359,
0.0326788276,
0.0086963009,
-0.0903892666,
0.068485193,
-0.0574163534,
0.001741984,
0.0212365575,
0.0545363761,
-0.045507323,
0.0307374336,
-0.0080842348,
0.0224399846,
0.0038522379,
-0.0278353244,
-0.0556996539,
-0.006432273,
-0.0096026054,
-0.0184044503,
0.0487082601,
0.0463376381,
-0.0132862367,
0.0124338223,
-0.0849989355,
-0.0095803402,
-0.0216855314,
0.0033410669,
-0.0029715321,
0.0484120771,
0.0159301888,
-0.032408949,
0.010616255,
0.0027792051,
0.0346445814,
-0.0057972106,
0.0022989537,
0.0174808428,
-0.0594105162,
0.0227494966,
-0.0266810618,
-0.0129003152,
0.033128608,
-0.0437739268,
0.0202929098,
-0.0454461351,
0.0140604358,
0.0158917326,
0.0298894774,
-0.0246434994,
-0.0224466827,
0.0262905303,
0.0199156012,
-0.0222348627,
0.0252008382,
-0.0171945803,
-0.0411363393,
0.036652904,
0.0280021168,
0.0084967213,
-0.0445604809,
-0.014289123,
-0.0380843394,
-0.007758345,
0.0166136418,
-0.0489718691,
-0.0416017585,
-0.07522057,
-0.0707618743,
0.0650623813,
0.0577284954,
-0.0175523795,
-0.064876087,
0.0058642263,
0.0202548429,
0.0215738676,
0.02465811,
0.0955964923,
0.0444667153,
-0.0297295563,
0.0210722815,
-0.009942933,
-0.0349863432,
0.0666658357,
-0.016807301,
0.0155644575,
-0.0218439642,
-0.0175441001,
-0.0337704234,
-0.0322860666,
0.0654717982,
-0.0145060457,
-0.0107853524,
-0.0458848402,
0.0365894884,
-0.0354990996,
-0.0178886782,
-0.0491832308,
0.0023622042,
-0.0291677658,
-0.0451308712,
0.005802297,
-0.055306159,
-0.0077305962,
-0.0016161669,
-0.0142528797,
-0.0144660631,
0.0120474901,
-0.0064314734,
-0.0052671214,
0.0149840713,
0.0175862703,
0.0113910055,
-0.0508105606,
0.0049739992,
0.0705651045,
0.02671922,
0.0747979805,
-0.0018940395,
0.0051866462,
-0.0176049359,
0.0239006132,
-0.0508696474,
-0.0075399284,
-0.0590582974,
0.0313625112,
0.0197627321,
0.0305891428,
0.04562594,
-0.0262536127,
-0.0183868557,
-0.0190216433,
0.0254650917,
-0.0643737018,
-0.0065159472,
-0.0040533692,
-0.0390111655,
-0.0067243511,
0.0382281914,
-0.0217590891,
0.0290347748,
0.0287084561,
-0.0039078831,
-0.0678526685,
0.005698496,
-0.0121768713,
-0.0211076364,
-0.0580651388,
0.0119633935,
-0.0044213645,
-0.0307056904,
-0.0201506913,
0.0192104746,
-0.0157340504,
0.0309868418,
-0.0210879743,
-0.0083946185,
-0.0113922199,
-0.0444942452,
-0.0432453156,
-0.0185655616,
-0.0166949462,
0.0108528221,
-0.010220076,
0.0006764713,
0.0313979797,
-0.0219174623,
-0.0579067133,
0.0080783255,
-0.0063728979,
-0.0213643443,
0.0237998366,
-0.0288473051,
-0.0056837751,
0.0021855831,
-0.0026774474,
0.0888575912,
-0.0002543678,
-0.0658533275,
0.00741687,
0.009042711,
-0.032189548,
-0.0156028215,
-0.0357100554,
0.0125193512,
0.0113805002,
-0.000385355,
0.0244677234,
0.0070171515,
-0.0015614877,
-0.0133112138,
0.0508639626,
-0.037900459,
-0.0455921888,
-0.0382349379,
-0.0376147851,
-0.0645059869,
0.0705995187,
0.0195675883,
-0.049219273,
-0.0023173804,
0.0482582301,
-0.0275007598,
0.0568600595,
-0.0291218292,
0.0564491972,
-0.0384984128,
-0.0232329182,
0.0032375325,
0.0640214682,
-0.0253501125,
0.0092338584,
-0.0224953629,
-0.0279235542,
0.0448296368,
-0.0348524787,
-0.0544845313,
-0.0172131453,
-0.0048362906,
-0.0186821949,
-0.0137145305,
-0.0390081331,
0.0271456838,
-0.0536406338,
0.0080879144,
0.0114895161,
0.006293436,
0.0046673231,
-0.0641627982,
0.0586851686,
0.0217366274,
-0.0467504971,
0.0097457916,
0.0200736895,
0.0136907641,
0.0331454873,
-0.0100490553,
0.0020993943,
-0.0144069931,
0.0059651765,
0.0158478916,
-0.0430170186,
-0.0686887652,
-0.0047582434,
-0.0053660292,
-0.0093680918,
0.004089938,
-0.0371695235,
-0.0177026,
0.0048167352,
-0.0025361779,
0.0400798135,
-0.0600550696,
0.005520294,
-0.0237296503,
0.0174965542,
0.0129282614,
-0.0178693514,
0.0038274825,
0.0065332879,
0.0155949034,
-0.0325301848,
-0.046387285,
0.0317252539,
-0.0694736242,
-0.0061557409,
-0.0566829629,
-0.020105252,
-0.020521177,
-0.0053304867,
0.0314808115,
-0.0058403867,
-0.0414910428,
0.0449100733,
0.0107940892,
-0.0734513402,
-0.0454148985,
0.0055806637,
0.0834184289,
0.0110009378,
0.023684945,
0.0413466543,
0.0190366898,
-0.0018583369,
0.0323927999,
-0.0244169571,
-0.0039388291,
0.0518748015,
-0.0727646276,
0.0150019117,
0.0382951312,
-0.1300305575,
-0.0429934524,
-0.0160955228,
-0.0249307044,
-0.0064399913,
-0.000501306,
0.016558975,
-0.0201089755,
-0.0113063743,
0.0615614913,
-0.0242680423,
-0.0293403286,
0.0047794357,
-0.0563840419,
-0.0197100025,
0.0290000346,
0.0019506409,
-0.031888783,
-0.0494792499,
0.0192486513,
0.0145654101,
0.0354468562,
0.0017438454,
0.0112356022,
0.045663368,
-0.028437335,
0.0395792201,
0.0930362195,
-0.0419089645,
0.0587453097,
-0.002660115,
0.0202009957,
-0.0060827946,
0.0123904636,
-0.002648866,
-0.0033651371,
-0.0123260515,
-0.0012075804,
-0.0180505756,
-0.0217338707,
-0.0128682237,
-0.0000575886,
0.0370044336,
-0.0419074334,
-0.0703245848,
-0.0269863643,
-0.0482141413,
-0.0427689739,
-0.0496326573,
0.0105183059,
-0.0262751654,
0.0711429939,
0.0031260429,
-0.068050839,
0.0199421719,
0.0163525417,
0.0144558223,
0.0180567279,
0.0109890634,
-0.0227313414,
-0.0293571204,
0.0535668246,
0.033443369,
-0.0085114231,
-0.0127415815,
-0.0211285707,
-0.0303836875,
0.0064713713,
-0.0053577609,
0.0940412283,
0.002220137,
0.0426212102,
-0.0507227965,
-0.0253155567,
0.0667807534,
0.0080788443,
0.0864601582,
0.0060356394,
0.0470381789,
-0.0390025266,
-0.008439905,
0.023151949,
0.0046325186,
0.0611980818,
0.0057627526,
0.0076124407,
-0.0251689348,
0.0649997145,
-0.0042977519,
0.0220689569,
0.0687790439,
0.0443373211,
-0.0122696748,
-0.0710790977,
0.0126278643,
0.0311461668,
0.0305543095,
-0.0343046449,
0.0425552428,
0.0569482259,
0.0451630056,
-0.0118192881,
-0.0768558681,
0.0876337439,
0.0171560291,
0.0229775663,
-0.0130287251,
0.0765822902,
0.0764091313,
-0.0215297192,
0.0157246366,
-0.0045599621,
-0.0063210637,
0.0047429441,
0.0262951795,
0.0140102729,
0.0781793222,
-0.016399296,
0.0053410749,
-0.0103316754,
-0.009551405,
-0.0667141303,
0.0086529162,
-0.0841663107,
0.0283126291,
0.0581143275,
-0.0029549082,
0.0109266983,
-0.015702419,
0.0082847737,
-0.0174015909,
0.0037712185,
0.0187265966,
0.0576233938,
0.058801949,
0.0161598716,
0.0121946102,
-0.010088495,
0.0208112244,
0.0198657364,
-0.003183132,
-0.0066141766,
0.051339563,
-0.0394589975,
-0.0107055306,
0.0221627783,
0.0471787155,
-0.0236752704,
-0.0113370959,
0.0158859883,
-0.0128693637,
0.081064932,
-0.0091130817,
0.0310624912,
0.0050510573,
0.0562057123,
0.0027147692,
-0.0269763153,
0.0639455914,
-0.0133095421,
-0.0406496748,
-0.0322587267,
0.0143386917,
-0.0526278056,
-5.948906178e-33,
0.0060717897,
0.0311088283,
-0.001456873,
-0.0306858029,
-0.0324108638,
0.0244541615,
0.0233406126,
-0.0025181652,
-0.0078538349,
0.0012273872,
-0.0315415189,
-0.019611964,
0.0008261495,
0.0272117741,
0.0041877842,
-0.0104018273,
0.0036589298,
-0.0004975957,
0.0433074124,
0.0144767156,
0.0439918861,
0.0124817016,
0.0025738575,
-0.0644854158,
-0.0742411762,
0.0500488356,
-0.0441075563,
0.029052034,
-0.0422627628,
0.013793922,
-0.040501453,
-0.0081710089,
-0.0169702694,
0.050661426,
-0.0117059126,
-0.0441160798,
-0.047055345,
-0.0118332757,
-0.0402398407,
0.0010130092,
-0.0361717492,
0.0009100426,
0.0668578669,
-0.0329462066,
0.0007682757,
-0.003122956,
0.0288317576,
-0.0250755567,
-0.0420207046,
0.0060987319,
0.0528259836,
-0.0066792746,
0.015898101,
0.0101789813,
0.0292435884,
0.0145781087,
-0.0200086404,
-0.0316262729,
-0.0538225099,
-0.0034639202,
0.0221641678,
0.0288524255,
-0.0231072828,
0.0345431007,
0.0669881031,
0.0361781418,
0.0368808247,
-0.0379982516,
0.0154579552,
-0.034500327,
0.017622374,
0.0331306644,
0.0830182284,
-0.0009199273,
0.0565393865,
0.0025116354,
-0.050815817,
0.0258206017,
0.0165766925,
0.0346982442,
-0.0010719872,
0.0010601808,
-0.0384948663,
0.0434272252,
-0.016159771,
-0.0996492207,
-0.0407429039,
-0.0136023518,
0.0096447123,
0.018021265,
0.0075204936,
0.0150652798,
-0.0256530344,
-0.0252488945,
0.0441190638,
-0.0240339283,
0.0188685767,
0.0400993563,
0.0422443151,
-0.0079719955,
-0.029994918,
-0.0155187435,
-0.0406003967,
0.0092458371,
0.0139213018,
0.0028217894,
0.0396019854,
-0.006928551,
0.0098918686,
-0.0357793085,
-0.0451757573,
0.0456726849,
0.0255135074,
0.0337312557,
0.0421449468,
-0.0267727878,
0.0157984216,
0.091596283,
-0.0152192665,
0.0542333163,
0.0033537676,
-0.002265359,
0.0012341358,
0.0538769327,
-0.0000088509,
0.0045026396,
-0.0102173109,
-0.0215886142,
-0.0290634818,
-0.0969114155,
-0.0113566983,
0.0082625337,
3.023e-7,
-0.0068185898,
-0.0161289163,
-0.0157360565,
-0.0093698688,
0.0452367626,
-0.0234619901,
-0.0341661088,
0.0073087565,
-0.0112339184,
-0.0313165262,
0.0440208726,
0.0095131192,
0.0245977733,
-0.0114545133,
-0.0973032713,
-0.1033543795,
-0.0678000599,
-0.0033194742,
0.0081840577,
-0.0229285639,
0.0147347804,
0.0568128899,
0.0139058335,
-0.0032099253,
0.0823564678,
-0.0114807077,
0.02861505,
0.0287879296,
0.0639718175,
-0.0186067224,
-0.0220261328,
-0.0270512439,
-0.026860334,
0.029586792,
0.0041220221,
0.0942191333,
0.0033706015,
0.0363150313,
0.0253667627,
-0.0262495223,
0.0613592565,
0.0957545862,
0.0222531278,
-0.0011807684,
0.0371606536,
-0.0310001951,
0.0204956811,
0.0135271102,
-0.0481522195,
0.0051122224,
0.0467790402,
-0.0150933154,
-0.0094058933,
-0.0035405348,
0.0070005003,
-0.030074317,
0.0101316394,
-0.0319659486,
0.0159921963,
0.0546606742,
-0.0500649847,
-0.0113373781,
-0.0612415336,
0.04479919,
0.035048984,
0.0177588686,
-0.054267399,
2.653338017e-34,
0.0294357501,
-0.0296227075,
0.033447884,
0.0214446764,
0.0211436171,
0.016991064,
-0.0514627323,
-0.0028799102,
0.0094951307,
-0.0592164211,
-0.0176740531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11172v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11172v1 | Enhancing Criminal Case Matching through Diverse Legal Factors | 2024-06-17T03:23:11 | 2024-06-17T03:23:11 | Jie Zhao, Ziyu Guan, Wei Zhao, Yue Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Criminal case matching endeavors to determine the relevance between different
criminal cases. Conventional methods predict the relevance solely based on
instance-level semantic features and neglect the diverse legal factors (LFs),
which are associated with diverse court judgments. Consequently,
comprehensively representing a criminal case remains a challenge for these
approaches. Moreover, extracting and utilizing these LFs for criminal case
matching face two challenges: (1) the manual annotations of LFs rely heavily on
specialized legal knowledge; (2) overlaps among LFs may potentially harm the
model's performance. In this paper, we propose a two-stage framework named
Diverse Legal Factor-enhanced Criminal Case Matching (DLF-CCM). Firstly,
DLF-CCM employs a multi-task learning framework to pre-train an LF extraction
network on a large-scale legal judgment prediction dataset. In stage two,
DLF-CCM introduces an LF de-redundancy module to learn shared LF and exclusive
LFs. Moreover, an entropy-weighted fusion strategy is introduced to dynamically
fuse the multiple relevance generated by all LFs. Experimental results validate
the effectiveness of DLF-CCM and show its significant improvements over
competitive baselines. Code: https://github.com/jiezhao6/DLF-CCM. | [
0.035320323,
0.0477746464,
-0.0077366508,
-0.0000897674,
-0.0830792412,
0.0414180793,
0.0086510628,
0.0102564804,
-0.0119049083,
-0.0752240121,
-0.0371337011,
-0.0195241868,
-0.0306419283,
0.0042977957,
-0.046871312,
-0.0512734354,
0.071453169,
0.0392760672,
0.0378201455,
0.0319778509,
0.0201338716,
0.0320509784,
0.0186897144,
0.0358733572,
-0.0306542665,
0.006532907,
-0.005826653,
-0.0000697673,
0.0550871156,
0.0101208389,
-0.0076616472,
0.0676536113,
0.0238736626,
0.0028417499,
0.0000017587,
-0.0828782395,
-0.0194918644,
-0.0338685624,
-0.0009312097,
-0.0256484114,
0.0136592751,
0.0287009515,
-0.0089967698,
-0.0249257851,
-0.032759726,
-0.0218586307,
0.0080599384,
0.0677465126,
0.0391767658,
0.0513300486,
-0.0059812479,
-0.0437007025,
0.0362605751,
-0.0436371416,
0.0028542855,
-0.0588853508,
0.0354516581,
0.0077274442,
0.0070070545,
-0.0492045879,
0.0275978055,
-0.0200927611,
0.0305741243,
0.019445857,
-0.0150279757,
-0.0021281198,
-0.0219610184,
0.0143365376,
0.0052388762,
0.0751076341,
-0.010491753,
-0.0481675342,
-0.0093114171,
-0.0092292484,
0.040095076,
0.0078923125,
-0.0305834003,
0.0522628427,
-0.0415253304,
0.0476403125,
0.0278136302,
0.024887722,
-0.0097625013,
0.0187047068,
-0.0320659056,
0.0492892452,
0.0170165915,
-0.0285840575,
0.0016888145,
0.0161895826,
0.0037014349,
-0.0354356132,
0.0413994603,
0.0034981591,
-0.0314102471,
-0.0055127977,
-0.0570951477,
-0.0433069579,
0.0553507768,
-0.0699323788,
-0.0021612477,
-0.0011739542,
-0.0188750327,
0.068402648,
-0.0236755833,
-0.0094190426,
0.0109382858,
0.0034493399,
-0.0418724902,
-0.0741964653,
-0.068120122,
0.0082106963,
0.0064572091,
0.0739166141,
-0.031778302,
0.0289874487,
-0.0249852147,
0.0097480472,
-0.0738953352,
0.0061491947,
0.0256543346,
0.0033614906,
-0.013731055,
-0.0099026049,
-0.0482712314,
-0.0335499384,
-0.0373325385,
0.0589151941,
-0.0329433829,
0.0158710666,
-0.0073635662,
-0.0030994276,
0.0131815448,
-0.0285010803,
0.0176668782,
0.1069382429,
-0.0118999202,
-0.0385116041,
-0.0486199968,
-0.046761103,
0.0059933048,
-0.0419821814,
-0.045166783,
-0.0513059571,
0.0202380102,
-0.0401426367,
-0.0203523114,
-0.0478876941,
0.000428715,
0.037376482,
-0.0434955209,
0.0711875707,
0.0248531904,
-0.0287246071,
-0.0354987271,
0.0263034031,
0.0246825162,
-0.0134377507,
-0.0113965664,
0.0334191397,
0.0072214613,
0.0030293316,
0.0137491319,
0.0250986088,
0.010311407,
0.0029568863,
0.0004034474,
0.0218576789,
0.0307428669,
-0.0078090453,
0.0503653735,
-0.0037609329,
0.0178320631,
-0.0194384139,
0.0025803612,
0.0248080958,
0.0506562255,
0.0428391285,
0.0071138297,
-0.0055496329,
0.0031152861,
0.0220512077,
-0.0594916008,
0.0308399275,
-0.0414004289,
0.0047873091,
-0.0535265058,
0.0353579223,
-0.0350767858,
-0.0047219228,
0.0181847792,
0.0073052319,
0.0164280348,
0.0239481684,
0.0175324157,
0.0251054,
0.0020611787,
0.0350086056,
0.064595826,
-0.0261649638,
-0.017841557,
-0.0604789704,
0.0006933177,
0.0460874029,
0.0279843751,
-0.0403326862,
-0.0439271964,
0.0167432614,
-0.0455976129,
0.0138823437,
0.0101647815,
-0.0071772276,
0.0086156493,
-0.0430491716,
-0.0706982017,
0.0204164647,
0.0149132404,
0.0460241586,
-0.0031853975,
0.0190134365,
0.044160109,
-0.0157310236,
0.0159377009,
0.0269327238,
0.010892353,
-0.0189747959,
0.029240815,
0.0178867094,
0.0555081815,
0.0153970262,
-0.0081048375,
-0.007596896,
0.003286683,
0.0193097107,
-0.0116276573,
0.0172797721,
-0.0035230974,
-0.023332566,
0.0581879877,
-0.0212195162,
-0.00580442,
-0.0130132372,
-0.057684198,
-0.0147591801,
0.0021689478,
0.0194596518,
-0.0025452487,
-0.0477023497,
-0.0023419575,
0.0086705042,
-0.021710543,
-0.0320770182,
0.0577629022,
0.0209720694,
-0.0640172809,
-0.03254015,
-0.0483689494,
0.0221056566,
-0.019832097,
0.0070240996,
-0.0531673394,
-0.0547381006,
0.0336444117,
-0.0039051708,
-0.0073889005,
-0.0474275239,
-0.017321201,
-0.0400528498,
0.0208351165,
-0.0246477146,
-0.0119148437,
0.0011250929,
0.0119674793,
-0.0024015962,
-0.0400692448,
-0.0199441388,
-0.0335705727,
0.0147447586,
0.0071122348,
0.0057083173,
0.0048946487,
0.0074319225,
-0.0211248249,
-0.03079441,
-0.0259488598,
0.0444381759,
-0.0276200771,
-0.0057296776,
-0.0178503767,
0.0926242843,
-0.0281952303,
-0.0042261253,
-0.038130708,
0.0560345575,
-0.023273116,
0.0050260914,
-0.0355235934,
-0.0163988471,
0.0429417938,
-0.0355249308,
0.0400680341,
-0.0358088352,
-0.066999644,
0.0188182928,
0.0067416392,
0.0484922603,
-0.0097420821,
-0.0065477332,
0.0141030662,
0.0089406222,
0.0098518841,
-0.0107683158,
-0.0235566199,
-0.0290272702,
0.0283690952,
-0.0452731997,
-0.0467914641,
-0.0364325941,
0.0247857459,
-0.0068974686,
-0.0201470032,
-0.0477677993,
0.0855522975,
0.0213645734,
0.086005263,
-0.048914317,
-0.0254122056,
-0.0595713556,
0.0849459991,
-0.0011174977,
-0.0206657238,
-0.0090668648,
-0.0363331735,
0.0209916048,
-0.0275223367,
0.061164353,
-0.0308219474,
0.1113010421,
0.0115422653,
0.0202622041,
-0.0238112696,
-0.0492095985,
-0.0410302207,
-0.0701448172,
0.0127115194,
0.0031807453,
-0.0258441884,
0.0252100695,
-0.0532656163,
0.0095710419,
-0.0212863982,
-0.0014748808,
0.0188565478,
-0.0052836817,
-0.0380259119,
0.0360099971,
0.0385712609,
-0.0022054538,
-0.0144643076,
0.0066398685,
-0.0258587375,
0.0095046433,
0.0152245909,
-0.0262268297,
0.0237271097,
0.0287486278,
0.0339977331,
-0.087804988,
0.0084433267,
0.0272538457,
-0.016385857,
-0.0292744469,
0.0576791726,
0.0683480129,
0.0184760951,
-0.0457088649,
-0.0206977315,
-0.000393368,
-0.0181960594,
0.0187420174,
0.0194795299,
-0.0457787663,
-0.0110538844,
0.0305818897,
-0.0272248574,
-0.0068179443,
-0.0411186367,
-0.0046339878,
-0.0612018667,
0.0570726469,
0.0378339961,
-0.0103984447,
-0.0439323857,
-0.0453303792,
0.0137306424,
-0.0447441377,
-0.0082444586,
-0.0163905658,
-0.0413107835,
-0.015993014,
-0.0073910891,
-0.0264985543,
0.0041503762,
0.0531408899,
-0.0604546592,
0.0271264054,
0.028145805,
0.0216155313,
-0.0334625728,
0.0063842069,
-0.0171526447,
-0.0017644505,
0.0138229961,
-0.0040769945,
0.0518612973,
-0.0104931882,
0.0171869881,
-0.0795657486,
0.0222057495,
0.0191911738,
-0.0611442514,
0.0446158983,
0.0409902595,
-0.057613343,
0.0130176283,
-0.0327904373,
-0.0381297432,
-0.0130253565,
0.0546901897,
-0.011000907,
0.0060039381,
0.004651858,
0.0203202646,
-0.0336695947,
-0.0395831168,
0.0015968023,
0.0133115435,
-0.0517596789,
0.005882489,
0.0194238946,
-0.0101577165,
-0.0133810109,
0.0089544598,
0.0106787244,
0.0319962539,
0.0040252982,
-0.0155873084,
-0.0776822716,
0.0579886101,
-0.0521672517,
0.0298564769,
0.0220421627,
0.0628920421,
0.0033984473,
-0.02298172,
-0.038578257,
0.0206146408,
-0.0155942151,
0.0227843691,
-0.0085144518,
-0.0219233055,
0.0063831494,
0.0106021771,
-0.046359539,
-0.0275596492,
0.0475817882,
0.0408627428,
0.005102207,
-0.0152686778,
0.0537798926,
-0.0619778,
-0.0233060755,
0.0015878797,
-0.0135466279,
0.0509065241,
0.0327574015,
-0.0005128033,
-0.0273633637,
-0.0497834869,
0.025599245,
0.0439969972,
0.0880552754,
-0.0005851943,
-0.0015815343,
-0.0612847768,
0.0167853478,
0.0072633778,
-0.002280572,
-0.0114821456,
0.0060464162,
0.0211067293,
0.0212473162,
-0.036931131,
0.0656576827,
0.0107130827,
0.0077514108,
-0.079553321,
-0.0082500027,
0.0382238962,
0.0030197999,
-0.0219182689,
-0.0450281985,
-0.0024699853,
0.0052289385,
0.0157235749,
0.0280913133,
-0.0260816477,
0.0162093043,
0.0001918722,
0.036752902,
-0.0336342566,
0.0166656133,
-0.0532104112,
0.0361753032,
-0.0288907625,
0.0165876318,
0.1015568227,
-0.0149339708,
-0.0108538307,
-0.0004776728,
-0.0039369105,
-0.0019544363,
0.0189138092,
-0.011424196,
-0.0031559865,
0.0229190383,
0.0277292505,
-0.0081361914,
0.0131369978,
0.0283855982,
-0.0248088464,
0.0462474599,
-0.028141614,
-0.0443121865,
-0.0282254983,
-0.0427545011,
0.0044670599,
0.0601956099,
-0.0447601043,
-0.0811701268,
-0.0705819651,
-0.0046173055,
0.0113848234,
-0.0202042721,
-0.0318785906,
0.0422090404,
0.0042803525,
0.043664217,
0.0276641063,
-0.0255955383,
-0.0093409391,
-0.0015901872,
0.0195955765,
-0.0152776111,
0.0165968109,
-5.484570482e-33,
-0.0169683993,
-0.0236495025,
-0.0064047612,
0.0243596118,
-0.0251656603,
-0.0109728985,
0.0482217893,
-0.0512807332,
-0.037098337,
-0.0105103403,
-0.0035927198,
0.0131355282,
0.0178001188,
-0.0160120632,
0.0338129178,
-0.0229804497,
0.0130141228,
0.0313888937,
0.0263132453,
0.0269458722,
0.0243301876,
0.0177933071,
0.027519552,
-0.0991262943,
0.0250429232,
0.0301530268,
-0.0136558935,
-0.0136642139,
-0.0329314582,
0.0576363057,
0.0071388357,
0.0342114978,
0.0516041555,
-0.0814717785,
-0.0322688483,
0.019144075,
-0.0854442045,
-0.0187955238,
0.005723842,
-0.0367626697,
0.0450587794,
-0.0301104933,
-0.0112740928,
0.0120046642,
0.0005351012,
-0.0120352237,
0.0541586094,
-0.0480976738,
-0.0279966015,
-0.0694213957,
-0.0579322875,
0.0455862768,
0.0056857015,
0.0417117439,
0.014602134,
-0.0044326205,
0.0303522665,
0.0362309664,
-0.0737685636,
0.0189733729,
-0.0577820726,
0.0058218441,
0.0243553463,
-0.0335452631,
-0.0547088273,
0.0617713965,
-0.0360630937,
-0.0372740813,
-0.0480585061,
-0.0200329814,
0.0100094182,
0.1039772779,
0.0229170155,
0.0778824687,
0.0542392842,
-0.0398894437,
-0.1071845368,
0.0199735351,
0.0534018017,
0.0348854624,
-0.0104780169,
-0.0125215063,
-0.048831258,
0.014535523,
-0.0381760783,
0.0232135076,
-0.0123294434,
0.0069241091,
0.0164812151,
0.0039454666,
0.0649959594,
0.0178942624,
-0.0011654469,
-0.0395439193,
0.0393504947,
0.0581170693,
-0.0088246651,
-0.0054684617,
-0.0043972475,
0.0215129741,
-0.0038734798,
-0.0664274171,
0.0440231301,
-0.0514465384,
-0.0093356771,
-0.0273529999,
0.0803655982,
-0.0321477763,
-0.0314456485,
0.0058492669,
0.0304176174,
0.0119559476,
-0.0047140066,
0.0167983025,
0.0126177268,
0.0428357869,
0.0375818722,
-0.0052486286,
0.0263294484,
0.011443371,
-0.0253929738,
-0.0186369494,
0.006922191,
0.010409642,
0.0598293766,
-0.0009114288,
-0.0039088102,
-0.0186890457,
0.0138340201,
0.008967747,
0.0052227736,
0.0664215833,
2.573e-7,
0.0340051167,
-0.0071316026,
-0.0293702427,
0.0140313096,
-0.020612238,
0.0509205349,
0.0146736316,
0.066275388,
0.0337920077,
0.0039153881,
0.0200110357,
0.0363211706,
0.049608089,
0.0668082908,
-0.0135475071,
-0.0540910251,
-0.0334998593,
-0.0449701734,
-0.0622897483,
0.0364198163,
0.033292938,
0.1101193279,
0.0555423908,
-0.0275453534,
0.0197247732,
-0.0236428808,
0.0235519875,
-0.0214613453,
-0.0275055207,
0.0138376709,
0.0482862853,
-0.0199689884,
-0.0098854899,
0.0973295718,
-0.0155295441,
0.0815958902,
0.0017987629,
0.0277404413,
0.0045786682,
-0.0114783663,
-0.0466443077,
-0.0360819101,
0.0303731021,
-0.0142646143,
0.083988905,
0.0003053087,
0.0015765182,
-0.0294067506,
-0.0339338332,
0.0180740468,
0.0267775469,
0.0536079593,
0.0025772939,
-0.0197122917,
0.0420389473,
0.0117551871,
-0.0294244215,
-0.0961561352,
0.0076799761,
0.0658028722,
-0.0242074095,
0.0177462399,
0.0152306948,
-0.0257483982,
0.1243948787,
-0.1000210866,
0.0249351021,
2.224561759e-34,
0.0140563259,
0.0038333202,
0.0166790765,
-0.0288101546,
0.0055734017,
0.0447582565,
-0.1038256958,
0.0201561823,
-0.0207052808,
-0.0711515173,
0.0413766317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11171v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11171v2 | SUGARCREPE++ Dataset: Vision-Language Model Sensitivity to Semantic and Lexical Alterations | 2024-06-17T03:22:20 | 2024-06-19T00:03:42 | Sri Harsha Dumpala, Aman Jaiswal, Chandramouli Sastry, Evangelos Milios, Sageev Oore, Hassan Sajjad | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T45, 68T50, I.2.7; I.2.10 | Despite their remarkable successes, state-of-the-art large language models
(LLMs), including vision-and-language models (VLMs) and unimodal language
models (ULMs), fail to understand precise semantics. For example, semantically
equivalent sentences expressed using different lexical compositions elicit
diverging representations. The degree of this divergence and its impact on
encoded semantics is not very well understood. In this paper, we introduce the
SUGARCREPE++ dataset to analyze the sensitivity of VLMs and ULMs to lexical and
semantic alterations. Each sample in SUGARCREPE++ dataset consists of an image
and a corresponding triplet of captions: a pair of semantically equivalent but
lexically different positive captions and one hard negative caption. This poses
a 3-way semantic (in)equivalence problem to the language models. We
comprehensively evaluate VLMs and ULMs that differ in architecture,
pre-training objectives and datasets to benchmark the performance of
SUGARCREPE++ dataset. Experimental results highlight the difficulties of VLMs
in distinguishing between lexical and semantic variations, particularly in
object attributes and spatial relations. Although VLMs with larger pre-training
datasets, model sizes, and multiple pre-training objectives achieve better
performance on SUGARCREPE++, there is a significant opportunity for
improvement. We show that all the models which achieve better performance on
compositionality datasets need not perform equally well on SUGARCREPE++,
signifying that compositionality alone may not be sufficient for understanding
semantic and lexical alterations. Given the importance of the property that the
SUGARCREPE++ dataset targets, it serves as a new challenge to the
vision-and-language community. | [
0.0347685888,
0.1112745106,
-0.0233312324,
0.0642849803,
-0.0412562527,
0.0227367636,
-0.013605441,
0.000873022,
-0.0579665899,
-0.1002051905,
-0.0397846699,
-0.024645878,
0.04633075,
0.0479111299,
0.02580023,
-0.0572135784,
0.0637227371,
-0.0159560964,
-0.0713526681,
-0.0014838477,
0.009877109,
0.0056030145,
0.0042435401,
0.0228855032,
0.0034772465,
-0.0127867553,
-0.0020423862,
0.0541583598,
-0.0080232788,
-0.0107544931,
-0.0225920025,
0.0670391917,
0.0310207196,
0.0316117108,
0.0000019581,
-0.0338161774,
0.0152722914,
0.0028868958,
0.0206844267,
0.0168290418,
0.0832254738,
-0.0553170964,
0.0074236938,
-0.0172554273,
-0.0154276378,
-0.0390390642,
0.0929631665,
0.0361392424,
0.0400168113,
0.0510241129,
-0.0306225829,
-0.0499861762,
-0.0042323307,
-0.0287565868,
0.0073079872,
0.0123202717,
0.0477974042,
0.0327347629,
-0.0430822223,
-0.0050975569,
-0.0654307157,
0.0316514596,
-0.0091758529,
0.0240206867,
-0.0140013481,
0.0271954089,
-0.0536732487,
-0.0447509326,
-0.0077257939,
0.0768303722,
-0.0284153745,
-0.025360601,
-0.0173532367,
-0.00157799,
-0.001635702,
-0.0321822017,
0.0035659443,
0.0369315371,
0.0383359455,
0.0397637486,
-0.0547621697,
-0.0115056038,
0.0169811547,
0.0219543353,
-0.0190009139,
-0.0262851547,
0.0430030636,
-0.0059022536,
-0.0153582757,
0.0211084448,
-0.0298020095,
-0.0352648534,
-0.0253732018,
0.0021850565,
0.0172938276,
0.0114114089,
-0.072287783,
-0.0225604251,
0.00167015,
-0.0666115731,
0.0695038885,
0.0186110102,
-0.0686060637,
0.0603049695,
-0.0273880959,
0.0499354638,
0.0137170656,
0.0798453242,
-0.046077989,
-0.0032264986,
-0.030248927,
-0.0055309678,
-0.032100372,
0.0271519218,
-0.0492320731,
-0.0434640683,
-0.0179475304,
0.0089881271,
-0.0282688849,
-0.007487189,
-0.0214528553,
0.0064824871,
-0.0286262911,
0.0128628537,
-0.0249843076,
0.0120328795,
0.0476996787,
0.0197003726,
-0.0360769033,
-0.0518004708,
-0.0009091606,
0.0317957439,
0.0062903594,
-0.0062491521,
0.0022331341,
0.091296643,
-0.0043718149,
-0.0587192662,
0.0024611957,
0.0006081458,
-0.0247010738,
-0.0447233245,
0.0007818042,
-0.0671657398,
0.0316750966,
-0.0259925891,
0.002399693,
-0.0742617771,
0.0106908921,
-0.0012355255,
-0.0441272743,
0.1249430776,
-0.0182735492,
0.0067127626,
-0.0395461507,
-0.0156067424,
0.0079208901,
0.0830431059,
0.0104483487,
-0.0055459007,
0.0334916562,
0.0172309056,
0.0041130753,
0.0237166081,
0.0049794209,
0.0472374111,
-0.0773083046,
-0.0066686068,
0.016211316,
0.0259624384,
0.0307027698,
0.058731731,
-0.0204654057,
-0.0555160306,
0.0732303187,
0.0098341471,
-0.011444441,
-0.0098362472,
0.0166778304,
0.0075316564,
-0.0056546065,
-0.0033823994,
-0.0751506314,
0.00656306,
-0.0032912339,
-0.0030386646,
-0.0172332488,
0.0129979914,
-0.0449770428,
-0.0175912827,
-0.0329650231,
-0.0303602852,
0.0256995149,
-0.021501204,
0.0335186422,
0.0304268096,
-0.013011043,
0.0723249838,
0.0392037295,
-0.0364698991,
-0.0268547982,
-0.0515043773,
0.021451924,
0.0493774638,
0.0322742611,
-0.007144528,
-0.0280301254,
0.0153292157,
-0.0132318372,
0.0782626867,
0.0019831907,
0.0149487974,
0.0528085679,
-0.0333316438,
-0.0190447271,
-0.0292523969,
0.0115628866,
0.0097275674,
0.0102393329,
-0.0260408632,
0.0184245966,
-0.0208116788,
-0.0170397982,
0.0623972453,
0.040905647,
0.0224878807,
-0.0215762276,
-0.0000526857,
0.0092084082,
-0.0281421822,
-0.0303391274,
0.0004605702,
-0.0023696141,
-0.0077150883,
-0.0315164588,
0.0400896184,
-0.049037829,
-0.0653630123,
0.0511662103,
-0.0379932672,
0.0000761922,
0.0258490089,
-0.0440047942,
0.0008798676,
0.0336038433,
-0.052115757,
0.0307972003,
-0.0594240949,
0.0310062785,
-0.0265091285,
0.042279996,
-0.0185027514,
0.0314295888,
-0.0313907675,
-0.0392825343,
-0.0115880603,
0.0049387058,
0.0181496236,
-0.0197318494,
-0.0430397354,
0.0098730884,
-0.0012853146,
0.0165599659,
-0.0197520517,
0.0185279604,
-0.0222473647,
-0.0207806081,
-0.0413299575,
-0.0272287503,
-0.0278720763,
-0.0272366852,
0.0379785113,
0.0159241576,
0.0059057409,
-0.0347469039,
0.0084559135,
0.0299933087,
-0.0077533578,
0.0463068262,
0.0347655341,
-0.0027490461,
0.0184725113,
-0.0247074384,
-0.0207840018,
0.0104598682,
0.0806545317,
-0.0173402876,
-0.0304220598,
-0.0526317656,
0.0202118941,
-0.0399673395,
0.0276690442,
0.0179035254,
-0.0391194187,
-0.0255943481,
-0.003407913,
0.0171670578,
0.075420931,
-0.0046803104,
0.0323185511,
0.0589845665,
-0.0039485027,
-0.0335176438,
-0.0348683149,
-0.0127750821,
-0.0410839356,
-0.0213242583,
-0.031821169,
-0.042831026,
0.0355899259,
-0.0297745354,
0.0031292504,
-0.071299471,
0.0505853742,
-0.0265826862,
-0.0588191561,
-0.0204780903,
0.0127407489,
-0.0193403699,
0.0069798464,
-0.0610646158,
-0.051867485,
0.0128131341,
-0.0439282097,
-0.0023347875,
-0.034066461,
0.0363281704,
-0.0259219985,
0.0832676589,
0.0508424155,
0.0409039743,
-0.0196791831,
0.0003547134,
-0.0519568622,
-0.0429362208,
-0.0017870936,
-0.0071373889,
0.0451330394,
-0.0560250841,
0.0240696985,
-0.0365270004,
-0.0185146816,
-0.0075204722,
-0.0215337183,
0.0064623882,
0.0070358571,
-0.0642909333,
-0.0135666486,
-0.0190184992,
0.0348816812,
-0.0180517826,
0.0219070408,
-0.008348872,
-0.0029800464,
-0.0321554318,
0.0144901583,
0.0668701306,
0.0291443467,
-0.005813512,
-0.0095952991,
-0.0065028127,
0.0305029508,
-0.0229937863,
0.0253904443,
-0.0575829968,
0.0320817046,
0.018420862,
0.0234268643,
0.0149365813,
0.0005833341,
0.0416142419,
-0.0298178308,
-0.0204945058,
0.0557562672,
0.032247968,
-0.0434580557,
0.0112152118,
0.0137464451,
-0.0006714467,
0.044837743,
-0.0166682731,
-0.0820552409,
-0.0491286442,
-0.0040668156,
-0.0312041845,
0.0115355663,
0.0066157943,
-0.0457488447,
-0.1014978811,
0.0079420861,
0.0153099149,
-0.0620802864,
-0.0304927621,
0.0346482396,
0.0084416335,
-0.0301774163,
0.0211911444,
-0.0188322682,
-0.0152542908,
0.0021686356,
-0.0057494794,
0.008368969,
-0.0509947799,
0.0146179674,
-0.0477722548,
0.0269465297,
0.0777710229,
0.0100562135,
-0.0196846817,
-0.0252416097,
0.0534773655,
-0.0107114315,
0.0004241068,
-0.0059742345,
0.0830512717,
-0.0153108891,
-0.0320301987,
0.0289894212,
0.0038725629,
-0.0275094528,
-0.0239990782,
-0.0334083922,
-0.0072900178,
0.0015281701,
-0.0008807483,
-0.0591760203,
0.0108375652,
-0.0224269256,
0.0544705093,
0.0388845354,
-0.0235968027,
-0.017189879,
0.0117092347,
-0.0268669575,
-0.0467173532,
-0.0060224063,
0.0415575132,
0.016717175,
-0.0097104656,
-0.072622031,
-0.0370214246,
-0.0034496412,
0.0209690239,
0.0141340811,
-0.0174887367,
0.0002754969,
0.0041294969,
-0.0652083308,
0.0536637791,
-0.0431221165,
0.0236727819,
-0.0201008115,
-0.0244011488,
0.0450063609,
-0.0073160697,
-0.0136901047,
-0.0224961098,
-0.0888302922,
-0.0405309461,
0.0022726876,
0.0520204715,
0.018002199,
0.0515736751,
-0.0069257799,
-0.0173130911,
0.0240168385,
0.0593944862,
0.0233674496,
0.0788662285,
0.0243939143,
-0.0255232193,
-0.003503979,
0.0423500091,
-0.0253532063,
0.0313807689,
0.0577013716,
0.0153254624,
0.0284953974,
-0.0399933532,
0.0088420007,
-0.0035400025,
0.0365627147,
-0.0045002536,
0.0293151047,
0.001486156,
0.0099338079,
0.0001470203,
-0.0061895107,
-0.0635715798,
-0.0110334484,
0.0163805466,
0.0277341455,
-0.022475468,
-0.0059136581,
-0.0415982418,
0.0394634828,
-0.009999604,
-0.0075308247,
0.0326329209,
-0.0261336863,
0.0019430699,
0.0495092683,
-0.0148644252,
0.0192026589,
-0.0528144054,
-0.0077109118,
-0.0316421501,
0.0225846991,
0.0196647141,
-0.0041366997,
-0.060804531,
0.0748989359,
-0.0019966338,
0.0084533496,
-0.0435501784,
0.0215080939,
0.0376833305,
-0.0150168426,
0.0167861637,
-0.0074069477,
-0.008450577,
-0.0372943692,
0.0208094325,
0.0035745646,
-0.0358971022,
0.0789484307,
0.0020545544,
-0.013705696,
0.009616958,
0.0622184351,
-0.0109432079,
0.0512634143,
0.0061886064,
0.0073134145,
0.0035356071,
-0.0320476331,
0.0448503569,
-0.0039773402,
-0.0086982036,
0.0198174603,
-0.0178450942,
-0.0624649897,
-0.0149086658,
0.0020445664,
0.0215106104,
0.0520001985,
0.0333790332,
0.0271584783,
0.0207235292,
-0.0054092249,
-0.0120268799,
-0.0566939302,
-0.01126674,
0.0202880222,
0.0167340357,
-5.789848936e-33,
-0.0367839709,
0.0146079017,
-0.0040901909,
0.0110266097,
-0.0335440524,
0.0242138207,
-0.0068243658,
0.0030430441,
-0.014286912,
-0.007346801,
0.0427824482,
0.0131275877,
0.0131849181,
0.041341275,
-0.0262668487,
-0.002440681,
0.0615289472,
0.008002351,
-0.00145667,
-0.0185198188,
0.0189198032,
-0.0079895211,
0.0527142882,
-0.054647211,
-0.0198346805,
0.0173503049,
-0.0125271464,
0.0086321225,
0.0141722718,
0.0659870729,
-0.0277586151,
0.0571052954,
0.0260748919,
0.0124938088,
-0.0688200668,
-0.0312175751,
-0.0547559299,
-0.0033486448,
0.0372703373,
0.058932472,
-0.0433023721,
-0.0146483295,
0.0417353287,
-0.0310467072,
-0.0200378671,
-0.041174408,
0.0342077762,
-0.0359697789,
-0.0030192882,
0.0019198549,
-0.0774824321,
0.0034250154,
0.0132361464,
-0.0125838835,
0.0369406082,
-0.0052886689,
0.0117893564,
0.0314614102,
-0.033796262,
0.025154002,
0.013456678,
0.0281593185,
0.0541977063,
0.0510743484,
0.0241811443,
0.0612815246,
0.0365529209,
-0.0218870882,
0.0190293416,
-0.0128361629,
0.0561337434,
0.0541736893,
0.060085725,
0.0761694759,
0.033762008,
-0.0161017831,
-0.0220163185,
-0.0133072874,
-0.0899772123,
0.0101365289,
0.0574363694,
0.0225239638,
-0.0010179622,
0.0055547855,
-0.0707486421,
-0.0032976391,
-0.052873224,
-0.0276952852,
0.0677763894,
0.0115145277,
-0.0112908045,
0.0626898259,
0.0552517287,
-0.0665788576,
-0.0293682013,
-0.0184477512,
-0.0329078324,
0.0455319732,
-0.0043000989,
0.0302335098,
-0.0141920811,
-0.050916668,
0.072022371,
0.0294302534,
0.0103565389,
0.0084476359,
0.0581517667,
0.0164358839,
-0.0454051346,
-0.0076017966,
-0.0056311921,
-0.0302409865,
-0.0430995263,
0.0078473901,
0.0203651618,
0.0535263643,
-0.0484629273,
0.0403265469,
0.0224234536,
-0.0107224667,
-0.0213067736,
-0.024076879,
0.0035981922,
0.0462733172,
-0.0218501687,
0.0037214274,
-0.0317782797,
-0.0380694047,
0.0357345194,
-0.0394761413,
-0.0123083219,
0.0314944424,
2.59e-7,
0.0531898364,
0.0309277251,
0.0261394549,
-0.0084346328,
0.0317915641,
0.0354781896,
-0.0362521112,
0.0334106348,
-0.0334438011,
0.0111285774,
-0.0037075514,
0.0481848866,
0.0296392925,
-0.0207813773,
-0.0105448579,
0.0975223482,
-0.0510209091,
0.0005382381,
-0.0756354704,
0.0036885729,
0.0908399448,
0.1079511866,
-0.017123403,
-0.0251752045,
0.0196706727,
-0.0351665094,
0.0794111267,
-0.0521163642,
-0.0000554903,
-0.017961964,
-0.0139570041,
0.0518397056,
0.0144959046,
0.0321952812,
-0.002899775,
-0.0242454875,
0.0351863988,
-0.0004564335,
-0.0574906431,
-0.0019687994,
-0.0319065191,
0.017389955,
-0.0343154594,
-0.0592054315,
0.0884757265,
-0.0741038397,
-0.0292307045,
-0.048778493,
-0.0124231931,
0.0201951973,
0.05397553,
-0.018853087,
-0.0213992689,
0.022013478,
0.0657938719,
0.0092804888,
-0.0656638592,
-0.0958073437,
-0.0126140006,
-0.0160647333,
-0.0139099825,
-0.0030069828,
-0.0604148917,
0.0251568165,
0.0545488335,
-0.0696882755,
-0.024962483,
2.231974031e-34,
0.0055850279,
0.0070708878,
0.0220059287,
-0.0207941495,
-0.0017587534,
-0.0136215426,
0.0138032995,
0.0189085342,
-0.0488692783,
-0.0484732985,
0.0171464048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15480v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15480v1 | On Giant's Shoulders: Effortless Weak to Strong by Dynamic Logits Fusion | 2024-06-17T03:07:41 | 2024-06-17T03:07:41 | Chenghao Fan, Zhenyi Lu, Wei Wei, Jie Tian, Xiaoye Qu, Dangyang Chen, Yu Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Efficient fine-tuning of large language models for task-specific applications
is imperative, yet the vast number of parameters in these models makes their
training increasingly challenging. Despite numerous proposals for effective
methods, a substantial memory overhead remains for gradient computations during
updates. \thm{Can we fine-tune a series of task-specific small models and
transfer their knowledge directly to a much larger model without additional
training?} In this paper, we explore weak-to-strong specialization using logit
arithmetic, facilitating a direct answer to this question. Existing
weak-to-strong methods often employ a static knowledge transfer ratio and a
single small model for transferring complex knowledge, which leads to
suboptimal performance. % To address this, To surmount these limitations, we
propose a dynamic logit fusion approach that works with a series of
task-specific small models, each specialized in a different task. This method
adaptively allocates weights among these models at each decoding step, learning
the weights through Kullback-Leibler divergence constrained optimization
problems. We conduct extensive experiments across various benchmarks in both
single-task and multi-task settings, achieving leading results. By transferring
expertise from the 7B model to the 13B model, our method closes the performance
gap by 96.4\% in single-task scenarios and by 86.3\% in multi-task scenarios
compared to full fine-tuning of the 13B model. Notably, we achieve surpassing
performance on unseen tasks. Moreover, we further demonstrate that our method
can effortlessly integrate in-context learning for single tasks and task
arithmetic for multi-task scenarios. (Our implementation is available in
https://github.com/Facico/Dynamic-Logit-Fusion.) | [
0.0134106744,
0.059540119,
0.0210992061,
0.0050301119,
-0.0015547695,
0.0272104573,
-0.0190067794,
-0.0413572118,
-0.0334543325,
-0.0261407234,
-0.055174876,
-0.0429591537,
0.0282739308,
0.0082098506,
0.0283634923,
-0.0107084867,
0.0246344153,
-0.0354633778,
-0.0302919634,
-0.0094326735,
-0.0052515771,
0.028422229,
-0.0143709332,
0.0471277721,
0.0412640683,
-0.0058902204,
-0.0008212593,
0.0139983101,
0.0254642237,
0.0221576132,
0.0346959457,
0.0290773176,
0.0387068912,
-0.001304069,
0.0000020132,
-0.007001203,
-0.009049044,
0.0023313968,
-0.0270493496,
0.0035317973,
0.0334435962,
-0.0600307845,
-0.0235514026,
0.0223926287,
-0.0301197916,
-0.0552056953,
0.0584780648,
0.0114363022,
0.0686212927,
0.0669740364,
-0.0050575347,
-0.0334703438,
0.0200266317,
-0.0476259254,
-0.0241873171,
-0.0562005825,
0.0132837901,
-0.0044320612,
-0.0268249623,
-0.0267593451,
0.0083726803,
0.0452233143,
0.00834978,
0.0284720007,
-0.0035438226,
0.0285140425,
-0.0158301983,
0.0117185144,
-0.0313106515,
0.0341945365,
-0.048749432,
-0.0222484879,
0.0152427657,
0.0053667426,
-0.0217751265,
-0.0553602092,
-0.0266508088,
-0.003314029,
0.0010142305,
0.0081048068,
0.0363105424,
-0.0099731535,
0.0402648412,
0.0170264412,
-0.0268155187,
0.0064185252,
0.0344603434,
-0.0100117177,
-0.0165218934,
0.0025873524,
-0.0318201706,
-0.023014199,
-0.0043196683,
0.0267137699,
-0.0108505916,
-0.0016369782,
-0.0432444066,
-0.0663384497,
-0.0429054275,
0.0023718113,
0.057904318,
0.0565229617,
0.0160679687,
0.0489104986,
-0.0130953193,
0.0145026408,
-0.0242741033,
0.0090862066,
-0.0318168513,
-0.0044664526,
-0.0735244378,
-0.0066296333,
-0.0366645679,
0.0159801319,
-0.0283744577,
-0.0053818752,
-0.0104001826,
0.0081318645,
-0.0146917123,
-0.0307960082,
0.0481024757,
0.0046575754,
-0.0555591844,
-0.0046454528,
0.0665929914,
0.0601654612,
0.0079566212,
0.0172597449,
0.0161063503,
-0.0304643437,
-0.007260364,
0.0109530641,
-0.009656094,
-0.048741471,
-0.0052126404,
0.0368920937,
-0.0635789335,
-0.0107244737,
-0.0441360548,
0.0086957728,
-0.0243484769,
-0.0702049285,
-0.0238546412,
-0.0411394276,
0.028397426,
-0.0091475416,
0.0136208255,
-0.024808798,
-0.0101854196,
-0.0309109371,
-0.0210613608,
0.1033531502,
0.0161376074,
0.0053863525,
0.0324387886,
0.0137197813,
-0.0282212775,
0.0936813131,
-0.0009047413,
0.0288539119,
-0.0100308331,
0.0176710747,
-0.0430464037,
0.0628371686,
0.00239495,
0.0439182036,
-0.0079710344,
-0.0267639589,
-0.0062870355,
-0.0374424569,
0.0519807041,
0.0185182355,
-0.0537091605,
0.0341894738,
0.0841645449,
0.0011785941,
0.0681628436,
0.0307185892,
0.0203754045,
0.0029157628,
-0.0060994453,
-0.0201777313,
-0.0352940373,
-0.0007896147,
-0.0173452869,
-0.0129542891,
0.011677485,
0.0599934533,
-0.0260815397,
0.0077538467,
0.0311442111,
-0.0324767679,
0.023445826,
0.0206678063,
0.0873985365,
0.0231384467,
-0.0422372445,
0.0582628511,
0.0236139856,
-0.0386459604,
0.0113828266,
-0.0357701816,
-0.0069411728,
0.0316704288,
0.0181782097,
0.0079149026,
-0.0396972112,
0.0082598105,
0.0000414301,
-0.0091020297,
0.0419933088,
-0.0184182283,
0.039944306,
-0.065281719,
-0.0388023183,
-0.0020558997,
0.0233457536,
0.0411052145,
0.0059456369,
0.0222700555,
0.0201887861,
-0.0136115458,
0.0212590303,
-0.0128771141,
-0.0362841152,
-0.019600695,
0.0213741064,
0.0189587753,
0.0090653747,
0.0007043559,
-0.0098974835,
0.0272361021,
0.0064837746,
-0.0692500547,
-0.0168670416,
0.0203789435,
-0.04360139,
-0.0074727861,
0.0462081656,
0.0103098378,
0.0268826652,
0.0353142135,
-0.024116803,
-0.0656237379,
0.057812497,
-0.0143937236,
0.0488840751,
-0.0300642792,
0.0053642141,
0.0120221553,
-0.008662113,
-0.0372555554,
0.0533222444,
0.0013072747,
-0.0210327078,
0.0039841142,
0.0134946071,
-0.0221154578,
-0.0209876336,
-0.01332743,
0.0199526362,
-0.0119038066,
0.0538122319,
0.0186911095,
-0.0000748445,
0.01053965,
-0.0411092192,
-0.0979486629,
0.0222780369,
-0.0387265831,
0.0489684381,
0.0310727116,
0.0335215628,
0.0196465049,
0.0182846375,
-0.0384716578,
-0.0039600469,
-0.0393976457,
0.0213718489,
-0.0504694954,
0.0518602654,
0.0098791309,
-0.0077182804,
-0.023494903,
0.00587038,
-0.001004656,
-0.0139454594,
0.0068201185,
-0.0735826939,
0.0142060183,
0.0307522267,
0.0334343016,
-0.00672823,
-0.024055453,
0.0066308477,
-0.0277677812,
0.0894830003,
0.0627997443,
-0.0306039285,
0.0055011632,
0.022625722,
-0.0269686021,
-0.0517336577,
0.0163522791,
0.0004345758,
-0.0527594872,
-0.0628329962,
0.0066828798,
-0.03120091,
0.0834663287,
-0.0124973655,
-0.0157076288,
-0.1011046171,
-0.0359405838,
-0.0031039249,
-0.0463753864,
-0.0112768365,
0.0186930392,
-0.0078461021,
0.0149018914,
-0.0483051352,
-0.0065590045,
0.0511089526,
-0.0202931706,
-0.0081154061,
-0.0560969524,
-0.0412426963,
-0.0287421588,
0.0371657982,
-0.0401673168,
0.0041239616,
0.000800983,
-0.0240296833,
-0.0778219849,
0.0266205575,
0.0289057177,
-0.0239473879,
0.0744797811,
-0.0294416193,
0.0034647994,
-0.0352163427,
-0.0614580475,
-0.0063736737,
0.0074234358,
-0.0195441507,
0.0380122401,
0.0159596857,
-0.0488258451,
-0.0519073308,
0.0111756381,
-0.0117687806,
0.0629069433,
-0.0229179692,
-0.0028650388,
-0.0343878306,
0.0198449921,
0.0580949374,
0.0263201091,
-0.02330954,
-0.0216058269,
-0.0007665501,
0.0343581811,
0.100713037,
0.0097908378,
-0.0563787743,
0.0010776579,
0.0613503158,
0.0191396773,
-0.0336919464,
0.0191859361,
0.0462553427,
-0.062067572,
-0.0306446441,
0.0788653865,
-0.0062666652,
-0.081158109,
-0.0200864319,
-0.0141018638,
0.0451569632,
0.010572942,
0.0032046293,
-0.045896899,
-0.0599596873,
0.0157122165,
0.0523746461,
0.0277003832,
-0.0058638924,
-0.0087356381,
-0.1300797164,
0.0017873243,
0.047121767,
0.0248753075,
-0.0122743836,
-0.0321916193,
-0.0124223465,
-0.0388801955,
0.0096094394,
-0.0059974208,
0.0240116995,
-0.0031520298,
0.0392166264,
0.0361654311,
-0.0718508065,
0.0279636048,
-0.0210724398,
0.0430986062,
0.0764774978,
0.0088559631,
0.0047048619,
0.0067131161,
0.0510738045,
-0.0232898034,
-0.022728188,
0.0135294488,
0.0074371598,
-0.0126778362,
-0.0197492093,
0.0442962497,
0.0361044034,
-0.0493433736,
-0.0042914217,
0.0228688587,
0.055899065,
0.0003299076,
0.0141101331,
0.0025976663,
-0.0478843562,
0.0221624468,
0.0564354882,
0.0028672633,
-0.0518651232,
-0.0347168036,
-0.0005302656,
-0.0021335061,
-0.0221120436,
-0.0006812453,
0.0244445745,
0.0132767307,
-0.0749035403,
-0.0651139766,
0.0005212181,
0.0125333639,
0.0595286228,
0.0026054613,
0.0202283245,
0.0252720956,
-0.0004918107,
-0.0992455259,
0.0249525234,
-0.0397259109,
0.0301120318,
-0.0486733317,
0.0028266071,
0.0494061336,
-0.0069917534,
-0.0037291544,
0.0382375568,
-0.1184726581,
-0.1007484049,
-0.0155628836,
0.0179735553,
0.0193262603,
0.0565484688,
-0.0609776936,
-0.0532600507,
-0.0018088705,
0.0053223758,
-0.0323346853,
0.0371973179,
0.0441834852,
-0.0464686751,
-0.0180195421,
0.0321686342,
-0.0787648708,
-0.016534986,
0.047835093,
0.0437822901,
-0.0332850218,
-0.0180037003,
0.0023726819,
-0.0031354232,
0.0222517755,
-0.0159780066,
-0.0137196872,
0.001064505,
0.0061964481,
0.0347897001,
0.0275214072,
-0.0573705398,
-0.0259050224,
0.0599927343,
0.0130415056,
0.0318056457,
0.0435905866,
0.0720091611,
0.0347379074,
-0.0733617395,
0.0080233412,
0.0036055034,
0.041818466,
0.0285279136,
-0.0170273595,
-0.0288271122,
0.0207329281,
0.0282049123,
0.0015230164,
-0.0433869772,
-0.0037977705,
0.033371944,
-0.005009253,
-0.0295074414,
0.0478881523,
-0.0510373339,
-0.0426121466,
-0.0277789179,
-0.0057381694,
0.0569500662,
-0.0020982092,
0.073811613,
-0.0257757213,
-0.0127740763,
-0.0381396115,
-0.0056933416,
-0.0176930968,
0.0119293258,
0.0074967174,
0.0296867937,
0.0173552316,
0.0375007614,
0.0619528778,
0.0211082306,
0.0589843802,
-0.0015402121,
0.0044663814,
-0.0187409464,
-0.0414289013,
0.0248191748,
0.0379965454,
-0.0159236547,
0.0368740559,
0.0005688783,
-0.0710587949,
0.0152887162,
-0.0377671756,
-0.0136508644,
0.0038482752,
0.0447098576,
0.0399948396,
-0.0444751047,
-0.0284132063,
-0.0200351533,
-0.0335513093,
0.0286921468,
0.0080204839,
0.0106369108,
-6.474334154e-33,
0.0018187204,
0.0390715823,
-0.0033525098,
-0.0429170951,
-0.0215292796,
0.0032827077,
-0.0101321535,
-0.010856837,
-0.0126853818,
-0.0163649116,
-0.0253548939,
0.0122716827,
0.0269440953,
0.0433236696,
0.005475909,
0.0081387311,
0.0634637401,
0.0002093455,
-0.0085497154,
0.0335399061,
0.0182821788,
0.0478529595,
0.0463498905,
-0.073872745,
-0.0068717524,
0.005998495,
-0.048141595,
0.0031343501,
-0.0140931327,
0.0504321344,
-0.0008881859,
0.0303010885,
0.0117350137,
-0.0739673302,
-0.0490431711,
0.0069627417,
-0.1178973913,
0.0071316431,
0.0317322202,
0.0027482421,
-0.0264656078,
-0.0291920118,
0.0161224976,
0.0271281675,
0.024451945,
-0.0594832525,
0.0096548134,
-0.0608291067,
-0.0129219154,
-0.0315513536,
-0.0371115766,
0.0030012839,
0.0003143892,
-0.0167576522,
0.0512632206,
-0.0178194698,
-0.0309853964,
-0.0369143933,
-0.0447598286,
0.0104277115,
-0.0032281864,
0.0706532225,
0.072304897,
0.0628602058,
-0.0138336141,
-0.0059126979,
0.0253545195,
-0.0031672353,
0.0058269608,
-0.0573430434,
0.0474350527,
0.0468145944,
0.0132844811,
0.0170627888,
0.0393217914,
-0.0032980873,
-0.0646550655,
-0.0129519179,
0.0642811731,
0.0376388729,
0.0393125638,
0.047593046,
-0.0267277639,
-0.0171906557,
-0.0532948487,
0.0040788911,
-0.0378741883,
-0.0082077691,
0.0380864181,
0.0588115975,
-0.0168145858,
0.0051441756,
0.0442141257,
-0.0508505367,
0.0454037338,
0.050530158,
0.0040251347,
0.0099258712,
-0.0206392054,
0.0391274579,
-0.0289566685,
-0.0474570207,
0.036254283,
0.0209386107,
0.0033085053,
0.0004455993,
0.0006392719,
0.0362975784,
-0.0452544317,
-0.0396316163,
-0.0366809405,
0.0323973633,
0.0084114373,
0.0915806144,
0.0336598977,
-0.0158490874,
0.0018592323,
0.0373049416,
0.0067295362,
0.0235110503,
-0.0022149868,
0.0045940015,
0.0397444591,
0.0164280664,
-0.0108313356,
-0.003388471,
-0.0244205073,
-0.0601107851,
0.0311680734,
-0.0054485071,
-0.022102192,
0.0048422818,
2.729e-7,
0.0091251619,
-0.0160084851,
-0.016942041,
-0.0116675459,
0.0057659997,
0.0447315909,
-0.0334375314,
0.0126733771,
0.0036252358,
-0.0160269272,
0.0080307052,
0.0347350203,
0.0617975183,
-0.010445999,
-0.0774098411,
-0.0010165183,
-0.0322899967,
0.0534079894,
-0.0187540017,
-0.0220019706,
-0.0040028584,
0.1237015128,
0.0090903407,
-0.0188617744,
0.015900325,
-0.0470062643,
0.0467586815,
-0.0071371496,
-0.0067866486,
0.0247201007,
0.0448858961,
0.0353876762,
-0.0259603243,
0.0024693804,
-0.0320581794,
0.0142989,
0.0265233032,
0.0766487643,
-0.029628817,
-0.0340129398,
0.0214850567,
0.0107134255,
-0.0104731647,
0.021050863,
0.0577594824,
-0.07988666,
-0.0321508162,
-0.0360556208,
-0.0135779111,
0.0040863464,
-0.020349266,
-0.0180093683,
0.0073266281,
-0.0012139956,
0.0312380102,
0.0143009797,
-0.0264544617,
-0.1197474599,
0.012555738,
0.0623454861,
-0.0494579338,
-0.0380560383,
-0.0368423387,
0.0165796615,
0.0502726771,
-0.08646705,
0.0116167022,
2.811631647e-34,
0.0154359974,
0.0142489802,
0.0131419124,
0.043595016,
0.0193980858,
-0.0338299274,
-0.078696683,
0.0323680565,
0.0267835278,
-0.0827705786,
-0.0269866828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11162v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11162v2 | How Good are LLMs at Relation Extraction under Low-Resource Scenario? Comprehensive Evaluation | 2024-06-17T03:02:04 | 2024-06-26T01:43:15 | Dawulie Jinensibieke, Mieradilijiang Maimaiti, Wentao Xiao, Yuanhang Zheng, Xiaobo Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Relation Extraction (RE) serves as a crucial technology for transforming
unstructured text into structured information, especially within the framework
of Knowledge Graph development. Its importance is emphasized by its essential
role in various downstream tasks. Besides the conventional RE methods which are
based on neural networks and pre-trained language models, large language models
(LLMs) are also utilized in the research field of RE. However, on low-resource
languages (LRLs), both conventional RE methods and LLM-based methods perform
poorly on RE due to the data scarcity issues. To this end, this paper
constructs low-resource relation extraction datasets in 10 LRLs in three
regions (Central Asia, Southeast Asia and Middle East). The corpora are
constructed by translating the original publicly available English RE datasets
(NYT10, FewRel and CrossRE) using an effective multilingual machine
translation. Then, we use the language perplexity (PPL) to filter out the
low-quality data from the translated datasets. Finally, we conduct an empirical
study and validate the performance of several open-source LLMs on these
generated LRL RE datasets. | [
0.0650430098,
0.0413223021,
-0.0038853891,
0.0944304019,
-0.0589552447,
0.0371075012,
0.0024454293,
0.0039176592,
0.0121573908,
-0.0202741958,
-0.0120195197,
-0.0422083177,
-0.0128662437,
-0.0493717343,
-0.0075081792,
-0.0311341844,
0.0188615751,
-0.0023214156,
0.0371431634,
0.0178777501,
-0.0131237693,
0.0256271679,
-0.0009050415,
-0.0520469882,
-0.0055321963,
0.0016612365,
0.0137585504,
-0.0175688583,
0.0129327886,
-0.0626642406,
-0.012499244,
0.0157218874,
-0.0145323994,
0.0149186235,
0.0000019665,
-0.0693355948,
-0.0420668125,
-0.0093893381,
-0.0077340757,
-0.0132671865,
0.0341566652,
-0.0452076606,
0.0025702531,
0.0123381736,
-0.0637738332,
-0.0500468388,
0.0238792636,
0.0579066724,
0.0317905731,
0.0737726018,
-0.0195315238,
-0.072158888,
0.0170976538,
-0.0185940247,
-0.0132677658,
-0.0148009211,
0.0412382111,
0.0246349685,
-0.0240948126,
0.0071634427,
0.0042334041,
0.0228595305,
0.0117122959,
-0.0182538517,
-0.0160503164,
0.004592224,
-0.0630140081,
-0.0287300218,
0.0119649563,
0.0998194963,
-0.0112334266,
0.0310119092,
0.0478279106,
0.0292366277,
-0.0214901511,
0.0415434949,
-0.0070055937,
0.0111695332,
-0.0454044417,
0.0501545966,
0.0301409792,
-0.0083888639,
0.0402858667,
-0.003216339,
-0.0463998057,
0.0585147887,
0.0028181167,
-0.051017791,
0.0233024862,
-0.0030426753,
0.0062229764,
-0.0139955115,
0.0140512865,
0.0209057201,
0.0274186507,
0.0526299626,
-0.0093258154,
-0.0190288275,
-0.0002209347,
-0.0663735643,
-0.0225599874,
0.0031507616,
-0.004643213,
0.0385404937,
-0.0628820211,
-0.005243381,
0.008993336,
0.0020813348,
-0.0234503951,
-0.0176882204,
-0.0237207953,
0.0348303132,
-0.0047479318,
0.0659161136,
-0.0538702235,
0.0350434482,
-0.0525956564,
0.0245533604,
0.0146987466,
0.0339698568,
0.0076082642,
-0.0243153702,
0.0052556158,
-0.018984301,
-0.04067434,
0.0010491512,
0.0339953229,
-0.0149543826,
-0.0593821071,
-0.0492260829,
0.0210541487,
0.0000343221,
0.0623082966,
-0.024518529,
0.0085737808,
0.0895490497,
0.0063374839,
-0.0276739579,
-0.0664691105,
-0.0104841273,
0.0401515923,
-0.0306689274,
0.022873912,
-0.0505156368,
0.0832247585,
0.038199015,
-0.0311002266,
-0.0347386859,
0.0488921665,
-0.0215990823,
-0.092914395,
0.0432052463,
-0.0415234789,
0.037626598,
-0.0012053353,
-0.004423392,
0.0617985688,
0.0578658506,
0.0608356968,
-0.0043149595,
0.0848975778,
-0.0098271454,
-0.0179912858,
0.0346259587,
0.0052361703,
-0.0045276461,
-0.0135452552,
0.0132218134,
-0.0220070295,
-0.002795968,
0.0278094076,
0.0445591286,
-0.0311194099,
0.0079215653,
0.0502870008,
0.0287631545,
0.0426523797,
0.0716090128,
0.0182797536,
0.0107728923,
0.0159026384,
0.0173596367,
-0.0220495258,
-0.037261866,
0.0013249778,
0.0423901081,
-0.0131162433,
0.0469232611,
-0.004556166,
-0.0281427931,
-0.0136705106,
-0.0302076768,
0.0130695747,
-0.0070598209,
0.1210969314,
-0.0131387468,
-0.022916602,
0.0622269958,
0.0572306439,
-0.0094811069,
0.0205453821,
0.0079188524,
-0.0190223623,
0.0239789858,
0.0434554368,
-0.0293745231,
-0.0101437904,
0.0042154491,
-0.0046275137,
0.0277996212,
0.0127480878,
-0.0151968962,
0.0340149701,
-0.0371254943,
-0.042116195,
0.056321688,
-0.0092389621,
-0.0085484404,
0.0580601506,
0.0448006801,
0.0369051918,
-0.0454306863,
-0.0260526612,
0.0404551476,
-0.0498888455,
-0.010948644,
0.0132988542,
0.025706619,
0.0191911645,
0.0421163626,
-0.0231412929,
-0.0095523363,
0.0525424145,
-0.0585259795,
0.0152758444,
0.0146120517,
-0.0432078168,
-0.0325948261,
0.0290914327,
0.0002833178,
-0.015938608,
-0.0114130769,
-0.032441251,
-0.0164847318,
0.022605041,
0.0479503348,
0.1044202149,
-0.0260980278,
0.0425808318,
-0.0008887735,
0.0142505663,
-0.029991731,
0.0680626258,
-0.0168649293,
0.0019012601,
0.0023783871,
-0.0745880529,
0.0041055041,
0.0026288996,
-0.0014183921,
0.0162492245,
0.0108203301,
-0.022428181,
0.0061067017,
0.0296002161,
-0.046354197,
-0.0190437939,
-0.0377311371,
-0.0000717832,
0.0169677138,
0.0874342769,
-0.0050084242,
0.032847032,
-0.0058846525,
-0.001837154,
-0.0030058699,
0.0120841265,
-0.0091593266,
-0.0095181363,
0.0586212762,
0.0128003545,
0.0009806453,
-0.0343283676,
-0.0063435989,
0.0170624517,
0.0459017269,
0.0376392081,
-0.044828821,
0.0123664057,
0.0826411098,
-0.0429718979,
0.0353529453,
-0.0134001216,
-0.0309010688,
-0.0382081084,
-0.0101072695,
0.0110731889,
-0.0334785432,
-0.016257735,
0.0086801471,
0.0134435827,
-0.0207719207,
-0.0236667767,
0.0046970909,
-0.0303144362,
-0.0043329629,
-0.0323476717,
-0.0350338034,
-0.0040945313,
-0.0064426591,
0.002233302,
0.0190831348,
0.0408873968,
-0.0103506399,
0.0085793193,
0.0333716534,
-0.0218258575,
0.0639894679,
0.0129916947,
0.0475460701,
-0.0393075943,
-0.0135167418,
0.0386243053,
-0.0024379443,
0.0184063539,
-0.01367079,
-0.0016728778,
-0.0762248039,
0.0422314629,
-0.0133515541,
-0.0044954978,
-0.0376737118,
-0.0276437066,
-0.0197498202,
-0.031415455,
0.0178769194,
-0.026027495,
0.0310705658,
-0.0667616725,
0.0104642045,
-0.0447099507,
0.0101886895,
-0.0617635883,
-0.0434908494,
-0.016390387,
-0.0018402386,
0.0335253216,
0.0077504665,
0.0169574711,
0.064466171,
0.0382415541,
0.0089060478,
-0.0042304783,
0.0125759812,
0.0047668917,
0.0754828975,
0.0386294574,
-0.0367805324,
0.0116393156,
0.0051222555,
0.0507360362,
0.031114351,
-0.0196909942,
-0.0557072274,
-0.0069635157,
-0.023404818,
0.0145349503,
-0.0274894312,
-0.0008953382,
-0.0319375917,
-0.0372449867,
-0.0563175343,
0.000991361,
0.1094575971,
0.002554486,
-0.0386185162,
0.0072826678,
0.006657077,
-0.0220774114,
0.016423557,
0.0125444056,
-0.0936229452,
0.0218749791,
-0.0171900485,
-0.0137669304,
0.0065306616,
-0.0691521466,
-0.00781566,
-0.1371822953,
-0.0104766274,
-0.0039110039,
-0.0722287148,
-0.0467789993,
-0.0319707952,
-0.0071632559,
0.0127797807,
-0.0045907176,
0.0009029512,
-0.0521765426,
0.0071705165,
0.0209499002,
-0.0429676697,
-0.0745242387,
-0.0330762565,
-0.0426210612,
0.0155903082,
0.0106595717,
0.0319685116,
-0.0605800152,
0.0143225286,
0.0233314987,
-0.0071020876,
-0.0285103954,
-0.0416742042,
0.0147034302,
-0.0018239847,
-0.0378109626,
-0.0237728879,
-0.0401272438,
-0.0783073977,
0.0411116667,
0.032464806,
0.0568615794,
-0.0049769292,
-0.0161215123,
0.0261821095,
-0.0446666516,
-0.0036904402,
0.0407217294,
-0.020582661,
-0.0197995659,
-0.0151804686,
0.0427975617,
-0.0151349772,
-0.0441890284,
0.0168529768,
0.0068177204,
-0.0834729597,
0.0154196937,
-0.0524886921,
-0.0635857955,
0.0266928747,
-0.000419961,
0.0043515484,
0.0589751005,
0.0792755038,
0.0212886576,
-0.0556207374,
-0.0138790626,
-0.0189485773,
-0.0545357205,
-0.043294955,
-0.0146794897,
-0.0079970984,
-0.0464581959,
0.0242436118,
-0.0610719882,
-0.044341132,
-0.0317246243,
-0.0028038828,
-0.0144564407,
0.0136231435,
0.0330616944,
0.0133239115,
-0.0035383853,
0.0357973613,
0.0621097349,
-0.0529837012,
0.0007767972,
-0.0033606414,
0.030340258,
0.0077486634,
0.0403449461,
-0.0294773746,
0.0129586421,
0.035740383,
0.006711842,
-0.0622788034,
-0.0495467409,
-0.0001352285,
0.0533376522,
0.0451191105,
-0.0059881252,
0.0036758143,
-0.0617195405,
0.0314763561,
-0.0564488322,
0.0193961598,
-0.0428475402,
0.0271247365,
-0.0070592575,
0.0236087181,
-0.0260775425,
-0.0262276344,
0.0167464688,
0.0097902305,
0.0040176711,
0.0121655911,
-0.0314138196,
0.0012998605,
0.0213773157,
-0.0084099201,
-0.0036948868,
0.0075681596,
-0.000265866,
0.0081065549,
-0.027157763,
-0.0007389808,
-0.0180544276,
-0.0300709605,
0.029697584,
0.0350098498,
0.016510861,
0.0094182836,
-0.0075525101,
0.0248409901,
0.086088106,
-0.0116617065,
0.059528213,
-0.0071408995,
0.0092337364,
-0.0016670447,
0.0502332486,
-0.0190135315,
0.0132921683,
0.0037315642,
-0.0073082261,
-0.0630929694,
0.0667572618,
0.0695575699,
0.0061837612,
-0.00818507,
0.0490376428,
-0.0459403284,
-0.0133777913,
0.0053815739,
0.0065004551,
-0.0125182699,
-0.0420733355,
-0.0155653637,
-0.0539458282,
-0.0819929764,
-0.0010996971,
-0.0104409978,
-0.0437145308,
-0.0138907311,
-0.0114967199,
0.0635055825,
0.0414047576,
-0.0031570215,
-0.075351797,
0.0404853635,
-0.0567132346,
-0.0262176879,
0.0132229095,
-6.516587298e-33,
-0.0088800276,
-0.0508737788,
0.0363720953,
-0.0160695538,
-0.0179553106,
0.0336689167,
-0.0315635204,
-0.0009543284,
-0.0412057713,
0.01428439,
-0.0316462293,
-0.0076020239,
0.0281231832,
0.0029584549,
0.0182517935,
-0.0033211943,
-0.0063585462,
0.0079778545,
0.0521882176,
0.0091578644,
0.0430447571,
0.0547343493,
0.0969769582,
-0.1133035272,
0.0088812318,
-0.0556847304,
0.028755676,
0.0246177651,
0.0655120686,
0.0321682505,
-0.0307221655,
0.0347505584,
0.0427775495,
-0.0138608962,
0.0299109127,
-0.0407682694,
-0.1230475381,
-0.0063596,
-0.0047665448,
-0.0012248824,
-0.0310892425,
-0.0087868143,
0.0366791897,
0.0127937989,
0.0295664947,
0.0355092175,
0.0401969478,
-0.0333785787,
-0.0503452532,
-0.0616566725,
-0.0519149676,
0.0550935529,
0.0579710901,
0.0184083804,
0.0416841134,
0.031009201,
-0.0210779384,
0.005929661,
-0.0626064762,
-0.0368162058,
-0.0022264007,
0.0068285065,
0.0504744053,
0.0250075702,
0.0136897387,
0.0224694312,
-0.0055680876,
-0.0206000358,
0.0296454299,
0.0083990162,
0.0228993706,
0.0360684916,
-0.0699226186,
0.0488586985,
0.004666796,
-0.033153452,
-0.1137604043,
0.0033088909,
0.0350690782,
0.0345201194,
-0.0116028059,
-0.0291279629,
-0.0466180369,
-0.0222362299,
0.0437816121,
-0.0125659192,
-0.0002672027,
-0.0538666584,
-0.0036677218,
0.0000125387,
-0.0155042717,
0.0185461007,
-0.0079074465,
-0.0292433798,
-0.0228350516,
0.0162690002,
-0.0074315909,
-0.0176963042,
-0.0249483846,
-0.0005148511,
-0.0634037182,
-0.0709380209,
-0.0626916587,
0.0002677823,
0.0073303813,
0.0208564103,
0.017793078,
-0.0193297062,
-0.0554493181,
-0.0056564352,
-0.0419668145,
0.0194088519,
-0.0100653134,
0.0366681479,
-0.0179606751,
-0.0056461017,
-0.0050471588,
0.020079609,
0.080990389,
0.0023579404,
-0.0105902217,
0.0537629649,
0.0226526763,
-0.0049090688,
0.0366865247,
0.0053475159,
-0.0123809362,
0.0564968921,
0.0186124947,
-0.0391164459,
0.0043379776,
-0.0028134133,
2.902e-7,
0.0370215289,
0.0286727976,
0.0247968081,
0.0106128957,
0.0171720516,
0.006710812,
0.0000472215,
0.0263875164,
-0.0248551369,
0.0181748644,
0.0335494876,
-0.0087284427,
0.0324397348,
0.04766519,
-0.0784349442,
-0.0509066544,
-0.0615827404,
-0.0536105037,
-0.0485004783,
-0.0069634989,
0.0536601469,
0.0486861169,
0.0315041505,
0.011933852,
-0.0875361115,
-0.0392374694,
0.0309277214,
-0.0555312298,
-0.0313628241,
0.0348865613,
0.0467845351,
0.0354158506,
-0.0274986532,
0.0307791792,
-0.0058348645,
0.0518601239,
0.0032579028,
0.0662838742,
0.0046251565,
-0.0055553624,
0.0181448925,
-0.0474933162,
0.0009660768,
-0.0266021937,
0.0763567984,
-0.0299224574,
-0.0156887881,
0.0452927426,
0.0093330909,
0.0154010653,
-0.01918534,
0.0045160647,
0.0127211511,
0.0250834581,
0.0283518415,
-0.0606455952,
-0.0490150899,
-0.029141115,
0.033056356,
0.0329077728,
0.0105379391,
-0.0447044335,
0.0204050243,
-0.0093271062,
0.0003850123,
0.0245364774,
0.023518445,
2.328432297e-34,
0.002628844,
-0.0061845174,
-0.0243746303,
0.0258680508,
0.034108378,
-0.0223595481,
-0.0477735363,
0.0156239346,
-0.0463673584,
-0.0486807525,
0.0374359637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15479v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15479v1 | Twin-Merging: Dynamic Integration of Modular Expertise in Model Merging | 2024-06-17T02:31:55 | 2024-06-17T02:31:55 | Zhenyi Lu, Chenghao Fan, Wei Wei, Xiaoye Qu, Dangyang Chen, Yu Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In the era of large language models, model merging is a promising way to
combine multiple task-specific models into a single multitask model without
extra training. However, two challenges remain: (a) interference between
different models and (b) heterogeneous data during testing. Traditional model
merging methods often show significant performance gaps compared to fine-tuned
models due to these issues. Additionally, a one-size-fits-all model lacks
flexibility for diverse test data, leading to performance degradation. We show
that both shared and exclusive task-specific knowledge are crucial for merging
performance, but directly merging exclusive knowledge hinders overall
performance. In view of this, we propose Twin-Merging, a method that
encompasses two principal stages: (1) modularizing knowledge into shared and
exclusive components, with compression to reduce redundancy and enhance
efficiency; (2) dynamically merging shared and task-specific knowledge based on
the input. This approach narrows the performance gap between merged and
fine-tuned models and improves adaptability to heterogeneous data. Extensive
experiments on $12$ datasets for both discriminative and generative tasks
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method, showing an average improvement of
$28.34\%$ in absolute normalized score for discriminative tasks and even
surpassing the fine-tuned upper bound on the generative tasks. (Our
implementation is available in https://github.com/LZY-the-boys/Twin-Mergin.) | [
-0.0305080824,
0.0628291219,
-0.0115642371,
0.0039200978,
-0.0316291451,
0.0426375568,
0.0415415764,
-0.0233697742,
-0.0214908365,
-0.0267338399,
-0.0520105027,
-0.0123684574,
0.0354678519,
0.0158128254,
0.0447087064,
-0.0159654543,
0.060764309,
-0.0109293144,
-0.0333357453,
-0.005937329,
-0.0309164692,
0.0238536522,
-0.003443735,
0.0422169268,
0.0144650107,
0.0040043634,
0.0089097088,
0.0083529064,
0.0528478138,
0.072347939,
0.0050775749,
0.0706641302,
0.0105537884,
0.0778611079,
0.0000018208,
-0.0246863551,
0.0056839692,
0.015477011,
-0.0122275902,
-0.0074459338,
0.0470981486,
0.0080126552,
-0.0055690436,
0.0133984797,
-0.0278152637,
-0.0490591899,
0.056414485,
0.0433613658,
0.0366744213,
0.0329402201,
-0.0117106428,
-0.0245455448,
0.0572324023,
-0.0447851717,
-0.0189872775,
-0.0055909823,
0.0652349368,
0.0332330428,
-0.0051831612,
-0.0430676043,
0.0069008349,
0.0386397876,
0.0144292945,
0.0006722241,
0.014730989,
0.0412983336,
-0.0128127057,
-0.0359468348,
0.0157552809,
0.0308207646,
-0.0697354451,
-0.0228114724,
0.0220956355,
0.0041081365,
0.010019104,
0.0149934003,
-0.0627907589,
-0.0238508787,
-0.0065720323,
0.0123870224,
0.0009820667,
-0.0635231286,
0.0248144958,
-0.004361074,
-0.0288908575,
0.0209798161,
0.0446811132,
-0.0065159332,
-0.0075202412,
0.0106043778,
-0.0308001209,
-0.0525546223,
-0.013448786,
-0.014368359,
-0.0133422185,
-0.0151812993,
-0.0937845781,
-0.0797553733,
0.01767952,
0.0082103247,
0.0548676439,
0.0276454203,
-0.027272895,
0.0490981154,
-0.0580366105,
0.0575238951,
-0.0141364522,
0.04995092,
-0.0812075213,
-0.0263561569,
-0.0885972232,
-0.0020195064,
0.0174249355,
-0.0159869362,
-0.0283069182,
-0.0326373875,
-0.0213232599,
0.0076155532,
-0.026458228,
0.0013404759,
0.0539666936,
-0.021841865,
-0.0317822173,
0.0128269503,
0.0416451842,
0.0430878066,
-0.0189157855,
0.0570605099,
0.0221815445,
-0.0140211983,
-0.0241150279,
0.0062346309,
0.013181109,
-0.0306902789,
-0.0070999484,
0.0299957022,
-0.0608935952,
0.0208638962,
-0.0054234727,
-0.0321474597,
-0.010898767,
-0.0580727942,
0.0295061991,
-0.0386387184,
0.089549534,
-0.0381807126,
-0.00589346,
-0.0221376941,
-0.0379126146,
-0.0255652089,
-0.006506735,
0.0916379318,
-0.020991059,
0.0244224109,
0.0351266377,
0.0202822313,
-0.0268859044,
0.0752547532,
-0.0054120831,
-0.0008457558,
-0.0151921557,
-0.0002582739,
-0.0022525892,
0.0320748575,
0.0173643231,
0.0153453434,
0.0202696901,
-0.0488366745,
0.05714304,
-0.0390667506,
0.0440821201,
0.0300533939,
-0.0558331497,
-0.0025470706,
0.0692784712,
-0.0021363581,
0.0390224569,
0.0159212388,
0.0372422151,
0.0114388363,
0.0135780247,
0.0392048396,
-0.0404227301,
0.0083543295,
-0.0376311764,
0.0299063716,
0.0236542914,
0.0926668048,
-0.0521659032,
-0.0277126003,
-0.0277184155,
-0.0237934645,
0.0197408814,
0.0214219876,
0.0638739839,
-0.0073663616,
-0.0350736566,
0.0310021192,
0.0418941006,
-0.0435528345,
0.015671473,
-0.0497364551,
-0.0061941962,
0.0378671698,
-0.0104103517,
-0.0053969384,
-0.0641142726,
0.019483475,
-0.016159663,
-0.0247435197,
0.0219747107,
-0.0169160683,
0.0436755233,
-0.0729805082,
-0.0756305382,
-0.0089296484,
0.0172604173,
0.0273862593,
0.0186892059,
-0.0261830259,
0.0333473869,
-0.0195911545,
0.0151707279,
0.0294562113,
-0.0645747334,
0.021249149,
-0.0195543766,
-0.0008947937,
0.029754417,
-0.008461277,
-0.0176009685,
0.0056309868,
0.0294902883,
-0.0218030252,
-0.037092153,
0.0446698666,
-0.0158771127,
-0.0466154888,
0.0224455036,
0.0001792414,
-0.0197881367,
0.0623287149,
-0.0331628621,
-0.0773413181,
-0.0270458609,
0.0038739943,
0.0039631254,
-0.0315379389,
0.020027576,
0.0117526548,
0.0105186142,
0.0044205026,
0.064349778,
-0.0019710076,
-0.0048416606,
0.0005480237,
-0.0365781151,
-0.0050032022,
-0.0237342846,
-0.0324027091,
-0.0042057228,
-0.0297839381,
0.0140326517,
-0.0109947044,
-0.0307291504,
-0.0432513133,
-0.0378819555,
-0.1054235101,
-0.0002238723,
-0.0106301103,
0.0350026898,
0.0141793909,
-0.0146606304,
0.0004316389,
0.0182123985,
-0.0014544774,
-0.0024740556,
0.0016360971,
0.0317451879,
-0.0196521208,
0.005978391,
-0.0172728729,
-0.0227882341,
-0.0433397889,
-0.0193053968,
0.0318218805,
-0.0111519387,
-0.0165187437,
-0.0272447262,
0.0153864659,
-0.0376965292,
0.0303091705,
-0.0140033355,
-0.0095345611,
-0.0061706328,
-0.0248157885,
0.0855265632,
0.0711168647,
-0.0503596812,
-0.0499383695,
0.0717826784,
-0.0438258685,
-0.0169296432,
0.0136928409,
0.0243863668,
0.0082381498,
-0.0276406761,
-0.0210040808,
-0.0462742299,
0.0730593726,
-0.0011962657,
-0.0424185246,
-0.0654947311,
-0.0321265087,
-0.033032503,
-0.016934488,
0.0039494359,
-0.0295585766,
-0.0108966324,
0.0209591184,
-0.0591815412,
-0.0421239734,
0.0593615584,
-0.0228458494,
-0.0349431969,
-0.0314455181,
-0.0152604161,
-0.0087108258,
0.0616045818,
-0.0101628266,
-0.0029777398,
0.0031051172,
-0.0251356103,
-0.0905908197,
0.0116165765,
0.0386647917,
-0.0153497439,
0.0660309047,
-0.0626051053,
0.0379116423,
-0.0403439179,
-0.0384330601,
-0.0135669094,
0.0147357555,
-0.0093229385,
0.0407134145,
0.0204805937,
-0.0368657112,
-0.0741608143,
-0.0068288702,
-0.0017222178,
0.0528075732,
-0.0010141409,
0.0045716935,
-0.0076112067,
0.0419259369,
0.0319095105,
0.0184179246,
-0.0205052905,
-0.0422010273,
0.0066372477,
0.0387131087,
0.084193103,
0.0320358798,
-0.0283971056,
-0.023592893,
0.0504096523,
-0.0102689285,
-0.0229537878,
-0.0051401989,
0.030092584,
-0.0270494465,
0.0192748662,
0.0947663337,
-0.0066218735,
0.0049796943,
-0.0467843376,
0.0001192636,
0.0517053492,
0.0126506789,
0.022556141,
-0.038537655,
-0.0281193573,
0.0361668058,
-0.0285852179,
0.0429012515,
0.0083013689,
-0.0073859426,
-0.1005222872,
0.0060394518,
0.0433393084,
-0.0020676695,
0.0081677595,
0.0066242926,
0.0132746184,
-0.0399157703,
0.0115168644,
-0.0159229711,
-0.0043357494,
-0.0225274228,
0.009610896,
0.006553547,
-0.0562993698,
0.0186963975,
-0.0391090959,
0.0360105857,
0.0286170375,
0.0121918116,
0.0320908614,
-0.0338306241,
0.0524317175,
0.0152067328,
-0.0168811008,
0.0060190177,
0.0270535704,
-0.0071289591,
0.0063411458,
0.0226360355,
0.0262276847,
-0.0283117518,
-0.0302367266,
-0.0349886417,
0.0403911695,
0.0250604227,
-0.0019738199,
-0.0138792181,
-0.0020382793,
-0.0239624791,
0.0754400492,
0.0079381149,
-0.0084114848,
0.0116290124,
0.0391744971,
-0.0354198888,
-0.0107314792,
0.0036427542,
0.0274907406,
-0.0269837901,
-0.0461776108,
-0.0542179644,
-0.0149976211,
0.0526164658,
0.0418217108,
0.0088815307,
0.0185794644,
-0.0195721388,
-0.0058133309,
-0.0644660741,
0.0517207757,
-0.0230352897,
0.01393284,
-0.0290910564,
-0.0106847417,
0.0199895855,
-0.0101960907,
-0.0431838818,
0.0326410867,
-0.1436088383,
-0.0772370398,
-0.0261118151,
0.0288094692,
0.0192347858,
0.0490243547,
-0.0183459874,
-0.0418168753,
0.0056299353,
-0.0005846044,
-0.0275702775,
0.034586627,
0.0407001749,
-0.0408039205,
0.0080495486,
0.0191758145,
-0.0562170893,
0.0203900766,
-0.0059870547,
-0.0106106503,
-0.0437536724,
-0.004643098,
-0.0169087444,
-0.0024841167,
0.0444422215,
-0.0258976482,
0.010850287,
-0.065860644,
0.0204752702,
-0.0029565699,
-0.0079334192,
-0.0516354144,
-0.0084263785,
0.0496661514,
0.0071830945,
0.0369404927,
0.0891091153,
0.0544642843,
0.002191595,
-0.079472512,
-0.0444143862,
-0.023940064,
-0.0096291956,
0.002182256,
0.0046160989,
-0.0086643873,
-0.0158100836,
0.0071905581,
0.0030133326,
-0.0361326635,
0.0165634677,
0.0042137769,
0.0235388279,
-0.0088076768,
0.0435653664,
-0.0664758384,
-0.0562576428,
-0.0191431884,
0.0150070507,
0.0515549481,
-0.0083332062,
0.0955440179,
-0.0065354169,
-0.0246163942,
-0.045473244,
0.007754005,
-0.0212979224,
0.0118998922,
0.0090600876,
0.0057562259,
0.0193016119,
-0.0373766273,
0.081024766,
-0.0176567156,
0.0331546254,
-0.0420186222,
0.0179372784,
-0.0328330882,
-0.0529365204,
0.0598873124,
0.0025449793,
-0.0415847003,
-0.0413503125,
-0.0142520694,
-0.0441825837,
0.0103638005,
0.0203345735,
-0.0242451727,
0.0406153947,
0.0323611535,
0.0332213603,
-0.0492811576,
-0.0357100032,
0.0225606076,
-0.0638282374,
0.0227728058,
-0.000128168,
0.0359507911,
-6.074751665e-33,
-0.0497224741,
0.0167816449,
0.0186347291,
-0.0528710485,
-0.0179617181,
0.0110325944,
0.0136193018,
-0.0028619259,
-0.0308572985,
-0.014473849,
0.0035341692,
0.0150165763,
0.0312257241,
0.0211094506,
0.0167724136,
0.0011190549,
0.0746482685,
0.0314592086,
0.0058026048,
0.0104656545,
0.0104847513,
0.0198793467,
0.0376997776,
-0.0399174914,
0.0035331866,
0.0185709521,
-0.0306100193,
0.0084073665,
-0.0274651516,
0.0734502301,
-0.0026109933,
0.0077229897,
0.0166801084,
-0.0348313451,
-0.0681124702,
0.0140216844,
-0.0883888826,
-0.0151698748,
0.0247233603,
0.0051414599,
-0.0281823296,
-0.008488887,
0.0469417349,
0.0125741148,
0.0355777442,
-0.0792514458,
0.0441193543,
-0.0268909018,
-0.0246116258,
-0.0312225558,
-0.0704694465,
0.0025057623,
0.0040506516,
-0.0402271785,
0.0793245137,
0.0280197989,
0.0456436016,
-0.038712468,
-0.0625847429,
0.0285982713,
0.0058870018,
0.0664206371,
0.0936984941,
0.0336490385,
-0.0000640895,
0.042597048,
0.0230204519,
-0.0072007854,
0.0107183792,
-0.0205475837,
0.0462713353,
0.0805157349,
0.0306639299,
0.024480531,
0.0069778129,
0.0238468125,
-0.0278820861,
0.0728241131,
0.0373691507,
0.0141532077,
-0.0280044153,
0.0601477213,
-0.0032194273,
-0.0074019805,
-0.0433889255,
0.0279231835,
-0.04700258,
0.0374832451,
0.022016596,
0.0397552028,
-0.0244971011,
0.0087876674,
0.0343657434,
-0.0435784385,
0.0317006893,
0.0207160991,
-0.0368796252,
0.0373662896,
-0.0183733758,
0.0025631057,
-0.035280358,
-0.0631371662,
0.0653347373,
0.0374894403,
0.0023305048,
0.0061640632,
0.0413274765,
0.0112958802,
-0.0546563752,
0.0185128208,
-0.0280526262,
-0.0017525605,
0.0332166031,
0.0341855176,
0.0812293962,
0.0208030641,
0.0124927973,
-0.0125562064,
0.0398440138,
-0.0098532643,
-0.0257633161,
0.0436842442,
0.0196031258,
0.0086453902,
0.0368177928,
0.0228815563,
-0.0150915943,
-0.0721376687,
0.0635596812,
0.01143617,
-0.0330598317,
0.0475978293,
2.5e-7,
0.0155277634,
-0.0123147527,
0.0065400922,
-0.0232985727,
0.0067451526,
0.0310503226,
-0.0400335006,
0.0178068988,
0.0096649155,
-0.0152915139,
0.0106256306,
0.0309370141,
0.0732065663,
0.0197792742,
-0.0490831472,
-0.0344831906,
-0.0072653424,
0.0270666387,
-0.0474076048,
-0.0007457865,
0.0298189707,
0.0721051246,
0.0264577754,
-0.0120536657,
0.006617636,
-0.0359595604,
0.070199132,
-0.0205708351,
0.0116079766,
0.0368881114,
0.012273306,
0.0031526037,
0.0004443809,
0.0627571121,
-0.0320336632,
0.0037247483,
0.0241712779,
0.0738772824,
-0.0241338164,
-0.0065390626,
-0.0144067248,
0.0216033682,
-0.0178062692,
-0.0350598358,
0.0743272081,
-0.0371028334,
-0.0111278519,
-0.0248599239,
-0.022098517,
0.0138733583,
0.0279428978,
0.0016450329,
0.0091987606,
0.0390142649,
0.0223882087,
0.0053748358,
-0.0446491353,
-0.0812443122,
-0.012490523,
0.0348194279,
-0.1136867851,
-0.0398907214,
-0.0233655982,
-0.0417389795,
0.0411198251,
-0.0838762969,
-0.0282475967,
2.383727138e-34,
-0.0144219529,
-0.0035149239,
0.0481605977,
0.0292932726,
-0.0137223192,
-0.0440204628,
-0.0620672181,
0.0166922025,
-0.0229175147,
-0.0515486486,
-0.02609968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11149v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11149v1 | GoldCoin: Grounding Large Language Models in Privacy Laws via Contextual Integrity Theory | 2024-06-17T02:27:32 | 2024-06-17T02:27:32 | Wei Fan, Haoran Li, Zheye Deng, Weiqi Wang, Yangqiu Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR | Privacy issues arise prominently during the inappropriate transmission of
information between entities. Existing research primarily studies privacy by
exploring various privacy attacks, defenses, and evaluations within narrowly
predefined patterns, while neglecting that privacy is not an isolated,
context-free concept limited to traditionally sensitive data (e.g., social
security numbers), but intertwined with intricate social contexts that
complicate the identification and analysis of potential privacy violations. The
advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) offers unprecedented opportunities for
incorporating the nuanced scenarios outlined in privacy laws to tackle these
complex privacy issues. However, the scarcity of open-source relevant case
studies restricts the efficiency of LLMs in aligning with specific legal
statutes. To address this challenge, we introduce a novel framework, GoldCoin,
designed to efficiently ground LLMs in privacy laws for judicial assessing
privacy violations. Our framework leverages the theory of contextual integrity
as a bridge, creating numerous synthetic scenarios grounded in relevant privacy
statutes (e.g., HIPAA), to assist LLMs in comprehending the complex contexts
for identifying privacy risks in the real world. Extensive experimental results
demonstrate that GoldCoin markedly enhances LLMs' capabilities in recognizing
privacy risks across real court cases, surpassing the baselines on different
judicial tasks. | [
0.0419558696,
0.1109048426,
-0.0309372135,
0.0080137197,
-0.0934011266,
0.0043691113,
0.0266377348,
0.0022560337,
-0.0010166768,
-0.0644302443,
0.0035045235,
-0.0340371095,
0.0025020419,
0.0094817337,
-0.0068903523,
-0.0073621362,
0.0189199559,
-0.0008079497,
0.0414643139,
-0.0003041301,
-0.0052342569,
-0.0081033539,
0.0384394079,
0.0111550689,
-0.0013816599,
-0.0180915333,
0.0052996823,
-0.0003856986,
-0.0225164443,
-0.0247087255,
0.0026114234,
0.068343848,
0.0101529183,
0.0530848056,
0.0000018441,
-0.0915208459,
-0.015001419,
0.0445535071,
-0.0254909694,
0.0583895259,
0.0062086694,
-0.0445683226,
-0.0095834201,
-0.024191482,
-0.0233754739,
0.0494710803,
0.0117719639,
0.025768267,
0.0257415138,
0.0652835369,
-0.0270971619,
-0.0472201146,
0.0502551422,
-0.0107791014,
0.0084824292,
-0.0634834021,
0.0577530004,
-0.0049688504,
0.0172511209,
-0.0101487124,
0.0781212002,
0.0270046517,
0.0301188231,
-0.0244459752,
-0.0371924862,
-0.0232474487,
-0.008540595,
0.0213108696,
-0.0115012797,
0.0552540869,
0.0882155374,
0.0037516064,
0.0044242991,
0.0057152547,
0.0639239326,
0.0208816081,
-0.0113514448,
0.0707442984,
-0.0376936309,
0.0089735389,
0.0051492145,
0.0288817231,
0.0519425161,
0.0494894274,
-0.0051635262,
0.0503259152,
-0.0164252408,
-0.0533396453,
-0.0391917862,
-0.0294749141,
0.0281101335,
-0.0250643697,
0.0507097766,
0.0087781865,
0.0060152351,
0.0421290845,
-0.0512413718,
0.0069845645,
0.089319855,
-0.0791239515,
0.0043164566,
0.0037642224,
0.0154545391,
0.0326495692,
0.0077643916,
0.0084753809,
-0.0093109552,
-0.0020550392,
0.023194002,
-0.0163402148,
0.012911655,
-0.0173751097,
0.0142914578,
0.0391114205,
-0.0743228868,
0.0358641893,
-0.0259026792,
0.0062803579,
-0.0644414052,
0.0512044057,
-0.0376910344,
-0.0287968386,
0.0108581344,
-0.045725733,
-0.0327467211,
-0.1019300595,
-0.0146178715,
0.0678182393,
0.0126439352,
-0.0237638466,
0.0216947291,
-0.0153732616,
-0.0326904841,
-0.007624961,
-0.0395865887,
0.1167206392,
0.0501398407,
-0.0187986679,
-0.0414802916,
-0.082389228,
-0.0297322739,
-0.0307746679,
-0.0454751588,
-0.056586843,
-0.021445699,
-0.0135826003,
-0.024006281,
-0.0784244835,
-0.0175122023,
0.0043711392,
-0.0297048613,
0.0497994497,
-0.0055070966,
-0.0242297016,
-0.0449597165,
0.0713727325,
0.0395273641,
-0.0154067362,
-0.0088682882,
0.0145040778,
0.0454310142,
-0.0095483912,
0.044984322,
0.0080890283,
-0.0135341072,
0.0198279377,
-0.000205822,
0.0110782962,
0.016553117,
-0.0102072898,
-0.0299186595,
0.0318805389,
0.0072460803,
-0.0018005358,
0.0977542326,
0.0918980241,
-0.0167139322,
0.0253583696,
-0.0429102555,
-0.002407732,
-0.0130459266,
0.0010473159,
-0.0670944899,
0.0026199231,
-0.068263799,
-0.0405695178,
-0.0737530813,
-0.000408783,
-0.0329121314,
-0.0343280956,
0.0048117074,
-0.0189280547,
0.0330404826,
0.0125769768,
-0.0250831023,
0.0216894392,
0.0408855341,
0.0103847878,
0.0057237991,
-0.0465037972,
-0.0235875472,
-0.0382725038,
-0.0056100418,
0.0885998085,
0.0321741141,
-0.0115291979,
0.0237186644,
-0.0413947664,
0.0000128137,
0.0109393084,
0.0136743411,
-0.0017913438,
0.0113598444,
-0.0243920684,
-0.0241216701,
-0.0021170594,
0.0379624292,
0.0075384127,
0.0127345994,
-0.0355189443,
0.0255958568,
-0.0185898431,
0.0328404456,
0.0099411905,
-0.0187858902,
-0.0133841084,
0.0006660128,
0.0109902862,
0.0202424247,
0.0428040475,
0.0349268168,
0.0038571861,
0.0153966164,
0.0341118127,
-0.0031236364,
-0.0054745595,
0.0219926815,
0.0768737793,
0.0074746893,
-0.0390951373,
0.0054490711,
-0.0096712941,
-0.0215026326,
0.0175409038,
-0.002359733,
-0.0116668763,
0.0523178056,
-0.0444708019,
0.0158543829,
-0.0283324793,
0.0054904521,
-0.0217911974,
0.0258113723,
-0.0481989048,
-0.0409144573,
-0.0372314751,
-0.0097557278,
0.0368974619,
-0.0058302819,
-0.0164836999,
-0.0143859265,
-0.0356411338,
0.0603097975,
0.0282383747,
-0.0370926373,
-0.013541582,
-0.0307774562,
-0.0097168647,
0.0133509496,
0.0021856369,
0.0213259142,
0.0029123437,
0.0269974563,
-0.0039597251,
-0.0235169902,
0.0181883723,
-0.074346073,
-0.0432395004,
0.0329915248,
0.0226289481,
0.0313611738,
-0.0579216853,
0.0342822373,
-0.0189429037,
-0.0393657796,
0.0295220874,
0.0089355893,
-0.0156812817,
-0.011559017,
0.0318550058,
-0.0093247928,
-0.014767427,
0.0057997992,
0.0079796556,
-0.026164202,
0.0342921764,
-0.0345786028,
-0.0260180645,
0.0294809397,
0.0766292959,
0.0157118179,
0.0153957177,
-0.004255868,
-0.0475698262,
0.0078358026,
-0.0021126792,
-0.0338255912,
-0.0248638857,
0.0339983292,
-0.009879726,
-0.0021721697,
0.0079982486,
-0.0252297018,
0.0358298793,
-0.0123193357,
-0.0285662096,
-0.0209655073,
-0.0627050772,
-0.0098104365,
0.0583921149,
-0.007717588,
-0.0468570925,
0.0513399467,
-0.0071285339,
0.1008165181,
0.0018162718,
-0.0237681847,
-0.0150431078,
0.0780139267,
-0.0261910539,
0.0158668961,
0.0545157939,
-0.0603473559,
0.0311808921,
-0.0210523196,
0.0783801153,
-0.0504277609,
0.0880422518,
-0.0312847719,
-0.0112802405,
0.0183465946,
-0.0651477799,
-0.0233814362,
-0.0552370399,
0.0045562889,
0.0559572577,
-0.007496425,
-0.0090938369,
-0.0046522911,
-0.0365269631,
0.010367495,
-0.003195364,
0.0206198357,
0.0009170327,
-0.0330567174,
-0.0003759703,
-0.0563096553,
-0.0687060356,
0.0301390234,
-0.0080759693,
0.0273536257,
0.032508906,
0.0207608789,
0.0396786667,
0.0174799617,
0.0148961628,
-0.0125314053,
-0.0266257524,
0.0048473957,
0.0299703367,
0.0241211019,
-0.0389070846,
0.0072217882,
0.0610469505,
0.0374157578,
-0.0216642451,
0.0186772272,
-0.0013580514,
-0.0398665853,
0.0033770811,
-0.0077999872,
-0.1031623036,
0.0245889109,
0.0061580651,
-0.0053414605,
-0.0823815539,
-0.0421116576,
-0.0099922679,
-0.0430278331,
0.0572159551,
0.0346095935,
0.0064563197,
-0.049586501,
-0.0338256583,
0.0297075342,
0.003310516,
0.0449215025,
-0.0508890413,
-0.009377379,
-0.0423889421,
-0.0076530995,
-0.0463071652,
-0.0488720126,
0.0289781895,
-0.0417664163,
0.0288010854,
0.0546372123,
0.030446168,
-0.0477301702,
-0.0171930213,
0.0067537376,
-0.0049699149,
-0.0326516554,
0.0445907749,
0.0140021415,
0.0294014756,
0.0337434001,
-0.0572370254,
0.069926843,
0.0022887876,
-0.0589089952,
0.015234855,
0.0260363445,
-0.0622400753,
0.0039650206,
0.0048642829,
-0.0436484404,
0.0433638804,
0.0229489151,
0.0045768018,
0.0017210779,
-0.0257185102,
-0.0340046175,
0.0194176119,
0.0079817567,
0.0267076734,
0.0126232551,
0.0172236804,
-0.0226235744,
-0.0166392084,
0.0269604027,
-0.0431455225,
-0.0082976921,
0.0516752638,
0.0100222928,
0.0376234055,
-0.0333003029,
-0.0409928262,
-0.0104760006,
-0.0539794303,
0.0453549288,
0.0150734521,
0.0360750556,
-0.0161393322,
0.0412025154,
0.0206562299,
0.0370678566,
0.0085823983,
-0.0215585008,
0.0137954904,
-0.0138976444,
0.0258405115,
0.0047503957,
-0.0615471154,
-0.0539091304,
0.0073434529,
0.0468083285,
-0.0343562998,
-0.0229733232,
0.0850970969,
-0.0424289517,
-0.0151732424,
-0.0043842243,
0.0188912284,
-0.0143191982,
0.020847911,
-0.0013006229,
-0.0649137795,
-0.0257955752,
0.041776523,
0.0324908942,
-0.0110196508,
0.0222860891,
0.0231223255,
0.0029493633,
-0.0306557789,
-0.0219101459,
-0.0166204777,
0.0174774304,
-0.0469024703,
0.0298841447,
0.0015999574,
0.0086517911,
0.035903018,
-0.0148680862,
-0.0114826728,
-0.0465643629,
0.0608326271,
0.0119128143,
0.0365955383,
0.0282578282,
-0.0370073542,
-0.0021632302,
0.0631269738,
-0.0043955212,
0.047716286,
-0.028732866,
0.0327307992,
-0.0023820475,
0.0221570376,
-0.0450481474,
0.0254345294,
-0.0703156739,
0.0093034068,
0.0321566053,
0.0344279669,
-0.0010218543,
0.0223259367,
-0.0230188239,
-0.0190634709,
-0.0118082846,
-0.003586221,
0.0179739147,
-0.0147906635,
-0.0546674356,
0.0094325999,
0.0268342998,
-0.0246075448,
0.0539752692,
0.019260725,
-0.0354317985,
0.0311142039,
-0.0594900437,
-0.0254852604,
-0.0091296956,
-0.0364466645,
0.0395647697,
0.0567651726,
-0.0507575385,
-0.05352173,
-0.1087589338,
-0.0328822732,
-0.0476310626,
-0.013480586,
-0.0009823628,
0.0021813367,
-0.0258666798,
0.0512985587,
0.0269001238,
-0.028619742,
-0.0739466846,
-0.0100721037,
-0.0075748172,
-0.008306507,
0.0035423134,
-5.047546661e-33,
0.0067355721,
-0.0574703217,
-0.0232414939,
0.0313442871,
0.0146479402,
0.0265042614,
-0.0194488429,
-0.002276757,
-0.0213696938,
0.002268377,
-0.0166599881,
0.0280403383,
-0.000937217,
0.0001394535,
-0.0243651439,
-0.0019733568,
0.007697132,
0.0154007766,
0.0238639396,
0.0270014144,
0.001525205,
-0.0001456168,
-0.0093491497,
-0.0941578969,
0.0965174511,
0.035135325,
-0.0730469078,
-0.0076517905,
-0.077513285,
0.0476224758,
-0.0245408602,
0.0196553003,
0.0183368083,
-0.0236528665,
0.0251301546,
0.0731224045,
-0.0384956971,
0.001325946,
-0.0014390821,
-0.0427870452,
0.0544931702,
-0.0488285236,
-0.0101895714,
-0.023072863,
-0.0270804707,
0.010639105,
0.0001555044,
-0.0438428111,
-0.0437110551,
-0.0450133719,
-0.0611758232,
0.036848709,
-0.0322250575,
0.0501866862,
0.0157236494,
-0.0025366987,
-0.0119927609,
0.0116622066,
-0.0131431781,
0.0301178023,
0.0243231934,
-0.0685221031,
0.0203497764,
-0.0065057934,
0.0103511,
0.0692977384,
0.0069127572,
0.0111843422,
-0.0239357892,
-0.0014936087,
0.0205948278,
0.0570204593,
0.0174243506,
0.0663790703,
-0.0494208001,
-0.0548054315,
-0.0481096506,
0.0019013685,
-0.024771044,
-0.011127905,
0.059650749,
-0.0164831225,
-0.0790043399,
-0.0230442397,
-0.0538926013,
-0.0141989812,
-0.0214112941,
0.0168946553,
-0.0189764537,
-0.0113475081,
-0.0409306288,
0.0278402623,
-0.027129719,
-0.0652746484,
-0.0307796653,
0.0249107964,
0.0482458025,
-0.0185936764,
-0.0190794356,
0.0315239392,
-0.0235169083,
-0.0745725036,
0.0100042708,
0.0054237526,
0.0406338759,
-0.0051839319,
0.0609612688,
-0.0022587476,
-0.0489485078,
-0.0256451908,
0.0054594637,
0.039583303,
0.037594717,
-0.0237771012,
0.0048324973,
0.024134377,
0.0346106403,
0.0513612777,
0.0215862393,
0.0116820065,
-0.0455796607,
0.0246172156,
-0.0517032184,
0.0240402911,
0.0118825128,
-0.0200167727,
-0.0057879989,
0.0175153147,
0.1216308847,
0.0094309775,
0.0054900898,
0.0170077626,
2.653e-7,
0.06922324,
-0.0368692316,
-0.0217682943,
-0.0083384737,
0.0134951724,
0.0664218739,
0.0070185452,
0.0487541035,
0.0045155985,
-0.0388875753,
0.0067702318,
-0.0143967923,
0.0507537872,
0.0300230905,
-0.0120901149,
-0.0122747794,
-0.0120220296,
-0.0313508585,
-0.0472690091,
0.0620808154,
0.0429093055,
0.0300406124,
0.0438560359,
-0.0219619758,
-0.027391281,
-0.0149554117,
0.0292348284,
-0.0569953024,
-0.0128404349,
-0.0151928272,
-0.0089755123,
0.0380887873,
0.0254757348,
0.0451633334,
-0.0056792838,
0.0195862781,
-0.0336878225,
0.0780254453,
0.0252891649,
0.0475531071,
-0.0493521467,
-0.0696090832,
0.0143893557,
-0.0577883348,
0.0304082185,
0.0079428321,
-0.0572478548,
-0.0422395132,
-0.0041941772,
-0.0545644984,
0.0043127504,
0.0253953114,
-0.0324607119,
-0.0295802057,
-0.0026402869,
0.0318227559,
0.001443136,
-0.0646847412,
0.0147018973,
0.0027377887,
0.0191676579,
0.0044899932,
0.0398177952,
0.0025813973,
0.0439593643,
-0.0509287007,
0.078430742,
2.265026315e-34,
0.0010896689,
-0.0345475152,
0.0270725992,
0.0268956367,
0.0337235071,
0.0396900289,
0.0369998403,
0.0113499677,
0.0140808877,
-0.0419343039,
0.0411818959
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11139v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11139v1 | Breaking Boundaries: Investigating the Effects of Model Editing on Cross-linguistic Performance | 2024-06-17T01:54:27 | 2024-06-17T01:54:27 | Somnath Banerjee, Avik Halder, Rajarshi Mandal, Sayan Layek, Ian Soboroff, Rima Hazra, Animesh Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL | The integration of pretrained language models (PLMs) like BERT and GPT has
revolutionized NLP, particularly for English, but it has also created
linguistic imbalances. This paper strategically identifies the need for
linguistic equity by examining several knowledge editing techniques in
multilingual contexts. We evaluate the performance of models such as Mistral,
TowerInstruct, OpenHathi, Tamil-Llama, and Kan-Llama across languages including
English, German, French, Italian, Spanish, Hindi, Tamil, and Kannada. Our
research identifies significant discrepancies in normal and merged models
concerning cross-lingual consistency. We employ strategies like 'each language
for itself' (ELFI) and 'each language for others' (ELFO) to stress-test these
models. Our findings demonstrate the potential for LLMs to overcome linguistic
barriers, laying the groundwork for future research in achieving linguistic
inclusivity in AI technologies. | [
0.0427392498,
0.0415909216,
-0.0467111021,
0.0497141369,
-0.0314809158,
-0.0205364097,
-0.0008302539,
-0.0218198039,
0.0066755028,
-0.0527149178,
-0.0857564956,
-0.0228710324,
0.0214506779,
0.008266896,
0.0158791114,
-0.0694693029,
0.0438171811,
-0.012462995,
-0.0161470473,
-0.0153216505,
0.0009840272,
0.0115359602,
0.0169397499,
0.0536619425,
-0.0095651429,
0.0036722887,
0.0001941941,
0.0128810564,
0.0060124872,
0.0069903159,
0.010089823,
0.0666843802,
-0.0159197282,
0.0502612144,
0.0000021003,
-0.0547109917,
-0.0123508554,
0.0053549083,
0.0001147114,
0.0214046221,
0.0040573464,
-0.0160187092,
-0.0403186344,
0.0086810347,
-0.0241033398,
0.04354918,
0.0676522329,
0.0338045023,
0.0546455495,
0.0602377914,
-0.0167344641,
0.0254546441,
0.0425888039,
-0.0106221382,
-0.0092354706,
0.0071873828,
-0.001124411,
-0.0061529428,
-0.0080832094,
-0.0276311785,
-0.0049819136,
0.0668692514,
0.0431664698,
-0.0260148253,
-0.0264952704,
0.0062785512,
-0.0505218655,
-0.0391381904,
0.0025966282,
0.0372633114,
-0.020687867,
-0.0217226073,
-0.0420148782,
0.0101969754,
0.0086314809,
-0.003264423,
-0.0318854153,
0.0374954566,
0.0130708246,
0.0181349255,
0.0719664171,
-0.0364356749,
0.0307568181,
0.0009373715,
0.0058217994,
0.0925655439,
0.0544205382,
-0.0676579997,
-0.0023943519,
0.0311927516,
0.0019219117,
-0.079625763,
0.0035430084,
0.0182821583,
-0.0263852999,
0.0265201144,
-0.0480894484,
-0.0239950884,
0.0160961654,
-0.0668612048,
0.0335810855,
0.0524511524,
-0.0318654031,
0.0321251974,
0.0080865435,
0.0549286008,
0.0111600244,
0.0326931365,
-0.0204724371,
-0.0189248081,
-0.033242166,
-0.0349989459,
-0.0500763245,
0.0166090317,
-0.0510608926,
0.0348327346,
-0.0441971682,
0.0331766009,
-0.0176413432,
0.0167178493,
0.0550144725,
-0.0465172455,
-0.0251543187,
-0.0216910746,
-0.0143256495,
0.0246768612,
-0.0160576049,
0.0135730347,
-0.0269767214,
-0.0934821665,
0.0114937089,
-0.0124325976,
-0.081844002,
-0.070675239,
0.0075554308,
0.0417626724,
-0.0180064701,
-0.0310894251,
-0.0576571077,
-0.0037439479,
0.0080300327,
-0.06721735,
-0.0039205658,
-0.0679731071,
0.0450498834,
0.0053520086,
0.0126503268,
-0.0664400309,
0.0014253522,
-0.0112507669,
-0.028597435,
0.068262808,
-0.0244246386,
0.0241924953,
0.0737601966,
0.020039821,
-0.0138456877,
0.0884508938,
0.0408873893,
-0.0424106605,
0.0751770213,
-0.0073330314,
0.0171984006,
0.0723902881,
-0.0179538839,
0.0215437766,
-0.0409735031,
0.0138769858,
-0.0066576172,
0.0141691165,
0.0167371351,
0.0376007259,
0.0095932325,
0.0265605655,
0.0596514158,
0.0446398333,
0.014186223,
0.0471240878,
0.0176509041,
-0.0625027493,
0.0106268516,
0.0363026671,
-0.0464864559,
-0.0037734665,
-0.011795871,
0.0099297781,
-0.0051249764,
0.033711601,
-0.0264859032,
-0.037173368,
-0.034616705,
-0.0014846472,
0.0383660905,
-0.0206940807,
0.0213988386,
0.0115712751,
-0.0070431894,
0.0569162145,
0.0342286639,
-0.0654677674,
0.0259343274,
-0.0588423386,
-0.027205782,
0.0456770025,
0.0305161551,
-0.0502788648,
-0.0329240821,
0.0025636971,
-0.0389320403,
0.0468722284,
0.0779981539,
-0.0025878779,
0.0064763906,
-0.0201987792,
-0.0173769072,
-0.0239273887,
0.0269594584,
0.0415116772,
0.0184809938,
0.0580530986,
-0.0118611632,
-0.0679830611,
-0.0466740094,
0.0264212973,
-0.0607192069,
-0.0033924938,
-0.0187381096,
0.0035601584,
-0.0025646971,
0.0144538404,
-0.0629930422,
-0.0105098113,
-0.0043667187,
-0.0268290993,
-0.0256950762,
0.0397722237,
-0.0117532406,
0.0007484826,
0.0575215332,
-0.0384834744,
-0.0242950972,
0.0117923589,
0.0012752869,
-0.0356294699,
0.0167072453,
0.0070719612,
0.057184644,
-0.0445715673,
0.0548593998,
-0.0201093797,
-0.0201360341,
-0.023601735,
0.0204853173,
0.0063339882,
-0.0012676024,
0.0200836901,
-0.0180490538,
0.0362094156,
-0.0493843704,
-0.0338503979,
0.0943321437,
0.0273486003,
0.0040171235,
0.0206477456,
0.0321769975,
-0.0253574047,
-0.0305299778,
-0.1384465545,
-0.0063429028,
-0.0303716343,
0.0121435681,
0.0168600585,
0.0413307808,
-0.0419098139,
0.003914135,
-0.0075005856,
-0.0641659871,
0.0316276439,
0.0660503507,
0.0293923169,
-0.0020681259,
-0.0056298766,
-0.0435816646,
-0.011052303,
-0.0023314855,
0.0341374762,
0.0060456586,
-0.04275278,
-0.0320826769,
0.0085531091,
-0.0584008917,
0.0250914842,
0.005492453,
-0.0443969518,
-0.0140951304,
0.0238910131,
0.0701101497,
0.0510755405,
-0.0489944927,
0.0219882336,
0.0595610254,
-0.0383981988,
-0.0122767584,
0.0158765912,
0.0651258901,
-0.0378584005,
-0.0040894127,
-0.0308830589,
0.0373352095,
0.0805779174,
-0.0131819136,
-0.0502008572,
-0.0475574397,
-0.0007714452,
-0.0661146417,
-0.0279113129,
-0.0291635804,
-0.011275433,
-0.0063474504,
0.0631490797,
-0.0316637456,
-0.0369110368,
0.0728476718,
-0.037492495,
0.0179860257,
-0.060720928,
-0.0087939585,
-0.0367127359,
0.0302774664,
-0.0423798934,
0.042046573,
-0.0192846339,
-0.0238514394,
-0.0729987547,
0.0013702362,
0.0196246561,
-0.0043181698,
0.0196574889,
-0.0747588053,
0.0051712547,
-0.026188435,
-0.0492364764,
-0.030658666,
0.0075493278,
-0.011649129,
0.052268438,
0.0427009389,
-0.018702032,
-0.0063153962,
0.009685535,
0.0285177715,
0.0583625622,
-0.0094007524,
0.0000878751,
0.0096194586,
-0.0107193505,
0.0255486798,
0.0158764664,
0.0297468286,
-0.0215775538,
0.0452487133,
-0.010315598,
0.0265087392,
-0.057107687,
0.0164734107,
0.0138626136,
0.0087704509,
-0.0913626179,
-0.051014889,
-0.0285293479,
0.0639514402,
-0.0291028544,
0.0158925615,
0.110480316,
0.0338435285,
-0.0258217994,
-0.0082654171,
-0.0907600373,
0.0201620683,
0.0421560444,
0.0497887284,
-0.0785910189,
0.0038050788,
0.0404779054,
-0.0235764831,
-0.0078569427,
-0.0189541299,
-0.0104901372,
-0.1093935445,
0.0017003434,
-0.0084642814,
-0.0443154499,
-0.0420960672,
-0.0170852579,
-0.0194382071,
0.0090294378,
0.0566116311,
0.0057280478,
-0.0141142746,
0.0048836633,
-0.0144328978,
-0.0099845584,
-0.0481502041,
0.0034946809,
-0.0435498692,
0.0140111428,
0.0446352996,
0.0165383704,
-0.0356727988,
-0.0340189151,
0.0635218769,
0.0037986138,
0.0090872506,
-0.0226415377,
-0.0136790276,
0.0114564504,
-0.0185360797,
0.0144165633,
-0.0107057849,
0.0194910113,
-0.0140674915,
0.0312085878,
0.08390259,
0.0009110646,
0.0069359755,
-0.0009405469,
-0.0508420058,
-0.0118906628,
0.0613824464,
0.0323911123,
-0.0350626186,
-0.0129726501,
-0.0535310879,
-0.0103820739,
0.0221478473,
-0.0247218721,
0.0411951989,
-0.0618369803,
-0.0072032935,
-0.0333359763,
-0.1129258126,
0.0302680414,
-0.0065960642,
0.082759589,
0.0090740984,
-0.0059953532,
-0.0262640659,
0.0062116073,
0.0158057008,
-0.0298011284,
0.0194059014,
-0.0659398064,
-0.021896638,
-0.0124231782,
-0.0387544669,
-0.0135158543,
-0.0222383942,
0.0172350686,
-0.0695429742,
0.0045487797,
0.0526360609,
0.0281820931,
0.0176130626,
0.008181626,
-0.0631374195,
-0.0029310239,
-0.0033373875,
0.0053269453,
0.0307289083,
0.0321082883,
0.0045751426,
0.0055553503,
0.0494376868,
-0.0418188348,
-0.0122971805,
0.0067814421,
0.0354973488,
-0.0030298783,
-0.0446682721,
0.0114362305,
0.0350672938,
0.0073167346,
-0.0501959622,
0.0059105661,
-0.0726595595,
0.036436297,
-0.0427446105,
-0.0115023293,
-0.0155731998,
-0.0006410374,
0.0137286698,
0.0085467501,
-0.00496272,
0.02701094,
-0.0274530221,
-0.0018906567,
-0.0277132671,
0.0281205084,
0.0056422777,
0.0437831357,
0.0212917048,
0.0323097594,
0.005034199,
0.0498728156,
0.0048183328,
0.0219572615,
-0.0091663478,
0.0335373506,
-0.0001792837,
0.002588579,
-0.0070685348,
0.0395121425,
-0.0048482884,
-0.0634206459,
0.0081531908,
0.0437504314,
0.0967555344,
-0.0134768924,
0.0533736572,
-0.0350703038,
-0.0211523082,
-0.0130476598,
0.0142751122,
0.053844355,
-0.0069530834,
0.0241744984,
-0.0175282471,
-0.0203393456,
-0.0022348829,
0.0672212541,
-0.0059688515,
0.0868167281,
-0.0225709714,
-0.0132971387,
-0.0165874492,
-0.0314092748,
0.0465390198,
-0.0292782038,
-0.0313947648,
-0.0097648343,
-0.0582871735,
-0.0778948441,
0.0121190622,
0.0219536219,
-0.0069571212,
0.0074625192,
-0.0036866784,
0.0868205503,
-0.0028817623,
-0.0028315838,
-0.0136436718,
-0.0208784547,
-0.0089505501,
-0.0066707497,
0.0179442894,
-6.189566239e-33,
-0.0406343341,
0.0234254226,
0.0187643468,
-0.0093897358,
-0.0088034878,
0.0011288857,
-0.0309362207,
0.0163317807,
-0.0035309556,
0.0276810098,
-0.0525793433,
0.0125177698,
0.0117620789,
-0.0290787723,
0.0318736844,
0.0090865707,
0.0539967865,
0.0437179618,
-0.017190855,
-0.0316949226,
-0.0278033465,
0.0220825505,
0.111904256,
-0.0411495641,
0.0645879507,
-0.0053039086,
0.0027963531,
0.022399148,
-0.0370752886,
0.0406773873,
-0.015929427,
0.0447861776,
0.0289867576,
-0.0329032168,
-0.0075667179,
-0.0314279683,
-0.0206381474,
-0.0377640426,
0.0428940468,
0.0693983138,
-0.006619195,
-0.0545360781,
0.0362414457,
0.0018214569,
-0.0796537548,
0.0143979238,
0.0184009075,
-0.0028148063,
0.0497952662,
0.0062048691,
-0.0832357034,
0.0106858211,
-0.0139392475,
-0.0047156811,
0.0294037089,
-0.002570505,
0.0032256295,
-0.0535963401,
-0.0689189658,
-0.0020212845,
0.0573217906,
0.0470154956,
0.0936818346,
-0.0232280567,
-0.0264937878,
0.008782723,
0.0203752089,
0.0040011853,
0.0140438154,
-0.0006051236,
0.0155061884,
0.013515722,
0.0048365975,
0.0329120569,
-0.0135745965,
-0.0152701978,
-0.0379074626,
0.0270099901,
-0.0140809594,
0.0193862263,
-0.0358618647,
0.0203800295,
-0.0206335206,
-0.0275455751,
-0.0274806358,
-0.0386882313,
-0.0316009298,
-0.031603653,
0.0478053801,
-0.0260811485,
0.0313156322,
0.00034653,
0.0258949064,
-0.0236731879,
-0.0371629074,
0.0084630307,
-0.0264572967,
0.0116497865,
-0.0025475819,
0.031878598,
-0.0215976909,
0.0136648742,
-0.0175088923,
0.0234282762,
0.0082241334,
0.0038254808,
0.0182020012,
0.021541737,
-0.0591443591,
0.0162790231,
-0.0212919563,
0.0409929119,
0.0103181666,
0.0367654525,
0.0300821364,
0.0109453266,
-0.0050220257,
0.01723882,
0.0624336936,
-0.011749913,
-0.0711847246,
0.0361055583,
0.0007939836,
0.0231256038,
-0.000168731,
0.0178014264,
-0.0269186832,
0.0172787886,
0.0150646223,
-0.0447970815,
-0.0303599294,
-0.0239673276,
2.87e-7,
0.0416229032,
0.0649445727,
0.025259465,
-0.0038057177,
-0.0047091846,
0.0297768936,
-0.0620862655,
0.0085340664,
0.0032485893,
0.0212022066,
-0.0295471959,
0.0384100862,
0.0250683371,
0.0458749719,
-0.0460998341,
-0.0131806973,
-0.0729954615,
0.0318905413,
-0.0761198848,
0.0109031517,
0.0110493014,
0.0379967578,
0.008073099,
-0.0150600746,
-0.0529076047,
-0.0216908902,
0.0451758578,
-0.0332411453,
-0.0223407187,
0.0357807428,
0.0466440096,
0.0279916823,
0.0169912279,
0.0245807376,
-0.0129701775,
0.0228560939,
0.0110503361,
0.0395540372,
-0.0389497615,
0.0271815211,
0.0338145308,
0.0062174704,
-0.0345954448,
-0.0703169107,
0.0555844754,
0.0487386771,
-0.0049372721,
-0.012399585,
-0.0003318985,
-0.0107087009,
0.0842614993,
-0.0517357029,
-0.0075004948,
0.0386252478,
0.0252740011,
0.0061190925,
-0.0345997177,
-0.0070328596,
-0.0633418038,
-0.0010118029,
-0.0036076023,
-0.0282813068,
-0.0259403903,
0.0027454023,
-0.0154704293,
-0.04907782,
0.0168659016,
2.583234932e-34,
0.0130382394,
0.0132853733,
0.0549452342,
0.0436488912,
0.0585593656,
-0.0156040797,
-0.000634783,
-0.0114418743,
-0.0298066679,
-0.0249325652,
-0.0273908135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11132v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11132v1 | RePrompt: Planning by Automatic Prompt Engineering for Large Language Models Agents | 2024-06-17T01:23:11 | 2024-06-17T01:23:11 | Weizhe Chen, Sven Koenig, Bistra Dilkina | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this past year, large language models (LLMs) have had remarkable success
in domains outside the traditional natural language processing, and people are
starting to explore the usage of LLMs in more general and close to application
domains like code generation, travel planning, and robot controls. Connecting
these LLMs with great capacity and external tools, people are building the
so-called LLM agents, which are supposed to help people do all kinds of work in
everyday life. In all these domains, the prompt to the LLMs has been shown to
make a big difference in what the LLM would generate and thus affect the
performance of the LLM agents. Therefore, automatic prompt engineering has
become an important question for many researchers and users of LLMs. In this
paper, we propose a novel method, \textsc{RePrompt}, which does "gradient
descent" to optimize the step-by-step instructions in the prompt of the LLM
agents based on the chat history obtained from interactions with LLM agents. By
optimizing the prompt, the LLM will learn how to plan in specific domains. We
have used experiments in PDDL generation and travel planning to show that our
method could generally improve the performance for different reasoning tasks
when using the updated prompt as the initial prompt. | [
0.0378164351,
0.0338189378,
-0.0252020266,
0.029093422,
-0.0449062474,
-0.0158795398,
0.0022277783,
-0.0140879992,
0.0438330546,
-0.0232234132,
-0.0106285987,
-0.0217993222,
-0.006326268,
0.0251046922,
0.0016705297,
-0.0511335395,
0.0259475484,
-0.0531328134,
-0.0058743376,
-0.0057176938,
-0.0281827301,
-0.0127011584,
-0.0189805031,
0.0722491294,
0.0090509132,
-0.0233670603,
-0.0648803562,
0.0122660575,
0.0116632683,
-0.0285237823,
-0.0025283687,
0.0293876678,
0.0279806275,
0.0202384312,
0.0000022013,
-0.0597825013,
-0.0193931386,
-0.0402231179,
-0.0502310656,
-0.0302920435,
0.0184812285,
0.0260810163,
-0.0232145097,
0.0387893915,
-0.066451408,
0.0104252724,
0.0083394218,
0.0282168891,
0.082818687,
0.098678261,
0.0249261111,
-0.0207423083,
-0.0006413948,
0.0102973878,
0.0226155967,
-0.0718745887,
0.0183635764,
0.0004044726,
0.0387834832,
0.0205192827,
-0.0148059092,
0.0151199559,
0.0254233498,
-0.0405066833,
-0.0166048408,
0.0302647334,
0.0179019887,
-0.0428338535,
-0.04006055,
0.0795206949,
-0.0068762056,
0.0151064033,
0.0339705087,
-0.0020718793,
0.0193303749,
-0.0202198029,
-0.0228025895,
0.0270584598,
-0.0177495666,
0.0048906039,
-0.0078913961,
-0.0335794762,
-0.0086020669,
-0.0103844367,
-0.030111067,
0.1038258895,
-0.0110234031,
-0.0194144603,
-0.0060676984,
-0.0248496234,
0.0458876193,
-0.0829632431,
0.01404035,
0.0914647505,
-0.0886159092,
0.0235963184,
0.0038879158,
0.00908003,
-0.0050772694,
0.0144898724,
0.0351760797,
0.0519325212,
-0.0046447529,
0.0277583767,
-0.011887325,
0.0860481262,
-0.0012288683,
-0.0195430368,
-0.0338488892,
0.0293098483,
-0.0738579184,
0.0177503042,
-0.08616703,
0.027234111,
-0.0316093862,
0.0037184719,
-0.0222378317,
0.0827509686,
0.0087078782,
0.0440016463,
0.0096441992,
-0.0046336721,
-0.0313452296,
-0.0278974641,
-0.0697241277,
-0.0208423603,
-0.0519968681,
-0.0266378578,
0.0249532554,
-0.0346397869,
0.0134671852,
-0.005834986,
0.0149026858,
0.0012438751,
-0.0396775641,
0.0983780846,
-0.0048924675,
-0.0013893703,
-0.0346295536,
-0.068225868,
0.0170896593,
-0.0604870804,
-0.0065146685,
-0.0618879087,
0.0256843958,
-0.022781644,
-0.0278007463,
-0.0530966744,
-0.0057791416,
0.0123863313,
0.0017127465,
0.0626085699,
-0.0173495188,
0.0283994917,
0.0271961745,
0.0018426507,
-0.0538848378,
0.0427390225,
0.015623386,
0.0628114939,
0.0088029588,
0.0237313937,
0.0314326361,
0.0427445434,
-0.0082317973,
0.0017177154,
0.0100888032,
0.0149663985,
0.0188897979,
0.0433937199,
0.0018790843,
0.0275433064,
-0.0421205871,
0.0260950588,
0.0224718936,
0.0432540551,
0.0266883262,
-0.0081842607,
0.0776321441,
0.0491632856,
-0.0308340192,
0.0014740505,
-0.0564205833,
0.0045324476,
-0.0248002671,
-0.0011354997,
-0.0181531943,
0.0127955154,
-0.0283440761,
-0.0504008867,
0.0254528224,
-0.0079431916,
0.0141589986,
-0.0037752241,
0.011398714,
0.0116649158,
-0.0574263595,
0.0065512881,
0.0023137874,
-0.0244153012,
-0.0296213049,
-0.0652300194,
0.0354734957,
0.0842146352,
0.0322634205,
-0.0282371361,
-0.0403262004,
-0.0115763741,
0.0251231305,
0.0186040066,
0.0401261561,
-0.0240344349,
-0.018579118,
-0.0393811576,
-0.0325346775,
0.0031786354,
-0.0020275791,
0.039074216,
0.0287433397,
-0.0154986456,
0.0106307929,
0.0271822494,
-0.0070729586,
0.0275065955,
-0.0411804728,
-0.0319416374,
0.0119632091,
0.0263584238,
0.028314393,
0.0042207846,
0.0019208244,
0.010861991,
0.0188905969,
-0.0180216469,
-0.0317479037,
-0.0039256988,
-0.03815699,
-0.0709147826,
0.0519798771,
0.0051545934,
-0.0285501555,
0.003320701,
-0.0388561934,
-0.0444383249,
-0.0045728753,
-0.0270389188,
0.0343510322,
-0.0059318375,
0.0488244891,
0.0186953247,
-0.0365427062,
-0.0402944759,
0.0702869222,
0.0157862622,
-0.0192081574,
0.0727561563,
0.0763709992,
0.0112492479,
-0.0519639514,
0.009381935,
0.0155738499,
-0.0026358273,
0.0237152558,
0.0466140769,
0.0496118926,
-0.0359972864,
-0.0438095964,
-0.0684756562,
0.0112197362,
-0.0292496495,
-0.0059104217,
0.0008520791,
0.0045589777,
-0.01669202,
-0.0450235605,
-0.0475881919,
0.0446106568,
0.0038608976,
0.0129785743,
0.0426944159,
0.0172912125,
-0.0762366503,
-0.034753982,
0.0093360189,
-0.0086334674,
-0.0161441807,
0.0220666155,
-0.0135413054,
-0.099998273,
0.0428319648,
-0.0314489342,
0.0268322546,
-0.0098674949,
-0.0257889461,
0.0247759093,
-0.0276349559,
0.0506093763,
0.0528334714,
0.0096667651,
0.0112157324,
0.0368393399,
-0.0162737574,
-0.0838667005,
0.0421448834,
-0.0396451838,
-0.0495507345,
-0.0416095667,
-0.0307847392,
0.0265315082,
0.0537148528,
-0.006147413,
0.0122457249,
-0.0419843346,
0.0061900248,
0.0199417695,
-0.0007884214,
-0.0231869016,
-0.0061136298,
-0.0361724086,
0.0913855359,
0.0065361117,
-0.0700332746,
0.0903493613,
-0.0161557794,
-0.0061453581,
-0.0331140384,
-0.0235594008,
-0.0234032515,
0.0702908263,
0.0021204585,
0.0345001817,
0.0126448469,
-0.0474652313,
-0.0248790458,
-0.0037334252,
0.0047108983,
-0.0093030976,
0.0232012141,
-0.0588023439,
0.0190008506,
-0.008994801,
-0.064662233,
-0.0747888982,
-0.0471564457,
-0.0348104239,
0.0046973526,
-0.0252077077,
-0.026971003,
-0.0216101967,
-0.0139059704,
0.0173508655,
0.032673426,
-0.0118276291,
-0.0286081955,
-0.0426487327,
-0.0324719399,
0.0348717868,
0.0464115106,
-0.0271435082,
-0.0164680369,
0.0579762273,
0.0026204877,
0.0224914849,
-0.0082507841,
-0.0345680341,
0.0165517405,
0.0084729036,
-0.0322116986,
0.0016452231,
0.0754283592,
0.0373355336,
-0.0391137563,
-0.0260238219,
0.1096214801,
0.0397271365,
-0.0652180016,
0.0035531658,
-0.0274657123,
0.0283812936,
0.0220252499,
0.0538045689,
-0.0614298172,
-0.0484088883,
0.0218718015,
0.0097620711,
-0.0178496279,
-0.0444440171,
-0.0240274481,
-0.1188141927,
0.0384590253,
-0.0164236985,
-0.019502975,
0.012161958,
-0.0334028676,
-0.0276299883,
0.0196349341,
0.0143968305,
0.0375561565,
-0.0069843414,
-0.016629491,
-0.0006876987,
-0.0463844873,
-0.0246891063,
0.0100681754,
-0.0097619789,
0.0580188036,
0.0945960656,
0.027096549,
0.0315927267,
-0.0257870592,
0.0489723273,
0.0574087836,
0.0457810126,
-0.019002961,
0.002595867,
0.003021094,
-0.0134816617,
-0.0078255422,
0.0254309494,
-0.0640794858,
-0.0100738937,
0.0683096498,
0.0806133226,
-0.043279279,
0.0142595703,
-0.015149327,
0.0213065147,
0.0354492776,
0.052138228,
0.0085879294,
-0.0335292034,
-0.0481949858,
-0.0690035224,
-0.0346232727,
0.0026375835,
-0.0187049918,
0.0035502657,
-0.0265974905,
0.0275252555,
-0.0694282204,
-0.0405818783,
0.0407502986,
0.0534241423,
0.0199504048,
-0.0160758197,
0.019962566,
0.027133679,
-0.0070695952,
-0.0005342355,
-0.0558292829,
0.0232780781,
-0.069134742,
0.0010725147,
0.0215939805,
-0.04161622,
0.0003212104,
0.0014214814,
-0.0519462563,
-0.0788897797,
-0.0212267134,
0.0467697643,
0.0279152002,
0.0474408157,
-0.020821793,
-0.0199346747,
0.0042469096,
0.0066937017,
-0.0130585656,
0.0054973643,
0.0013666176,
0.0681206062,
-0.0059808344,
0.0406857282,
-0.0548581481,
0.0124331973,
-0.0136855571,
0.0441107713,
-0.0317891575,
-0.0476666689,
0.0405803882,
0.0408981778,
-0.0141840493,
0.0011941702,
-0.0441337973,
-0.0158992819,
0.0274613015,
-0.0219534226,
-0.0346340835,
-0.0525157303,
0.0320323296,
-0.0062342975,
-0.0385839492,
0.0702007413,
-0.0228706859,
-0.0320854746,
0.0191607736,
0.0056642229,
-0.0004939359,
0.0025503782,
0.0389159732,
0.0665969178,
0.0016378302,
-0.0218499806,
0.0267436616,
0.0261791125,
0.031172866,
0.012283925,
0.0712985024,
0.0353316739,
0.003260229,
-0.0386319384,
-0.0022005609,
-0.0719806179,
-0.1220543534,
0.0487924777,
0.044322364,
0.0714447871,
0.045653142,
-0.0032263685,
-0.0517921075,
0.0219507832,
-0.0146434568,
0.0305201001,
0.0328326449,
-0.0408520699,
0.0488801897,
0.0147658531,
-0.0103985472,
-0.0142910974,
0.0646708831,
-0.0206318311,
0.0375196487,
-0.0162402056,
-0.0121668419,
-0.0602763928,
-0.0155082801,
0.0214497373,
0.0085137403,
-0.018074017,
-0.0137832183,
-0.0409345962,
-0.0291939545,
-0.0304151047,
0.0251851771,
-0.013816868,
-0.0278122071,
0.0695271194,
0.0382695943,
0.008306344,
-0.0239026919,
-0.0448309332,
0.001528113,
-0.0199876111,
-0.030935863,
-0.0232668296,
-5.699452686e-33,
-0.0259990357,
-0.0478390604,
0.0694439113,
0.0041011502,
-0.0280983225,
-0.0118499715,
-0.0516850613,
0.0252727438,
-0.0053615882,
0.0024210813,
-0.0250765532,
-0.0002749201,
0.019642124,
-0.0011634476,
-0.002073627,
-0.0161167402,
0.0524596125,
0.003917723,
-0.0372780152,
0.017766254,
0.0095521817,
0.0336867012,
-0.0220366064,
-0.0170636829,
0.0014491979,
-0.0125134084,
-0.0128013194,
0.0735097229,
0.0243187789,
0.0499383695,
-0.017902771,
0.0068399264,
0.011736162,
-0.0398897417,
-0.0437185429,
0.0544522218,
-0.03195557,
-0.0545953959,
0.0056474335,
0.0137966434,
-0.0594860539,
-0.0262078382,
0.0010929778,
-0.0154227884,
-0.032695733,
0.041801542,
0.0291554704,
0.003402004,
-0.0323148742,
0.0407913812,
-0.0514556281,
0.011382632,
0.0016247932,
-0.0459388494,
0.0347527713,
0.0184662957,
0.0008276673,
-0.0162325632,
0.0045368248,
0.0084956102,
0.0109229377,
0.0083825774,
0.034866035,
0.0111446874,
0.0053173611,
0.0442035533,
0.0566448718,
0.045157019,
-0.0261179209,
-0.014893163,
-0.0122151952,
0.0473076962,
-0.0308131054,
0.0372659005,
-0.0136461575,
0.0038140195,
-0.0419556946,
0.033108294,
0.0461351648,
0.0333474688,
0.02760466,
0.0068843425,
-0.0203406196,
-0.0089238891,
-0.0515845641,
0.0434030853,
-0.0126081388,
-0.0393520445,
0.0329091176,
0.0312414505,
0.0117454119,
-0.0724148527,
0.0383676589,
-0.0300955866,
-0.0265752561,
0.0161913112,
-0.0209451839,
0.0030273511,
-0.0116146049,
0.0382712223,
-0.0223744195,
-0.0398989767,
-0.0123605756,
-0.0185554866,
0.031300839,
0.0427107289,
-0.0068881758,
0.0360455438,
-0.0469142161,
0.0091587324,
-0.0691496953,
0.0085444544,
-0.0080838921,
0.0275442768,
0.0336447023,
-0.0185755994,
-0.0222990587,
0.0652626455,
-0.0056436812,
-0.0563814268,
-0.0196562782,
0.0084640998,
0.0250902884,
0.0243355297,
-0.0475598797,
-0.0073223175,
-0.0336824656,
0.0748086572,
0.0375342667,
-0.0325783566,
-0.004196581,
0.0077667693,
2.889e-7,
-0.037697766,
0.0328790434,
0.0222111903,
0.0582777262,
0.012910828,
0.0439580157,
-0.0211415552,
0.0067233886,
-0.0041054585,
-0.0133666052,
0.0144408327,
0.0288949683,
0.0287983865,
0.0227059834,
-0.110622853,
-0.0033017274,
-0.0148261292,
-0.0251294337,
-0.0811533406,
0.0024934378,
0.0735333562,
0.0622022152,
-0.0125525156,
-0.0024903887,
0.0216769092,
-0.0209365562,
0.0222873278,
-0.0246658269,
-0.0011510338,
0.0217887349,
0.0239768531,
0.0120350914,
0.0062907347,
-0.0006044234,
0.0158971176,
-0.0015737665,
-0.030843854,
0.0798584968,
0.0026092764,
-0.0126488078,
0.0276853088,
-0.0409481749,
0.0048832945,
-0.0252909362,
0.0299562197,
-0.0130319363,
-0.000185208,
-0.0230193809,
0.0226129889,
-0.0461410247,
-0.0036739632,
-0.0287840068,
0.0031445448,
0.007355175,
0.0048826337,
0.0021535587,
0.0030922885,
-0.0894118473,
0.015241812,
0.0040731984,
-0.038381137,
-0.047289934,
-0.0335398428,
0.0368596278,
0.0215500649,
-0.0494033247,
0.0207701195,
2.639691033e-34,
0.0173772611,
0.0030448614,
0.0052549485,
0.0599994995,
0.0547367185,
0.0197105054,
0.00795276,
0.0375360548,
0.0527615212,
-0.0734211281,
-0.0468157902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11131v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11131v2 | Are Large Language Models a Good Replacement of Taxonomies? | 2024-06-17T01:21:50 | 2024-06-20T08:01:14 | Yushi Sun, Hao Xin, Kai Sun, Yifan Ethan Xu, Xiao Yang, Xin Luna Dong, Nan Tang, Lei Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB | Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate an impressive ability to internalize
knowledge and answer natural language questions. Although previous studies
validate that LLMs perform well on general knowledge while presenting poor
performance on long-tail nuanced knowledge, the community is still doubtful
about whether the traditional knowledge graphs should be replaced by LLMs. In
this paper, we ask if the schema of knowledge graph (i.e., taxonomy) is made
obsolete by LLMs. Intuitively, LLMs should perform well on common taxonomies
and at taxonomy levels that are common to people. Unfortunately, there lacks a
comprehensive benchmark that evaluates the LLMs over a wide range of taxonomies
from common to specialized domains and at levels from root to leaf so that we
can draw a confident conclusion. To narrow the research gap, we constructed a
novel taxonomy hierarchical structure discovery benchmark named TaxoGlimpse to
evaluate the performance of LLMs over taxonomies. TaxoGlimpse covers ten
representative taxonomies from common to specialized domains with in-depth
experiments of different levels of entities in this taxonomy from root to leaf.
Our comprehensive experiments of eighteen state-of-the-art LLMs under three
prompting settings validate that LLMs can still not well capture the knowledge
of specialized taxonomies and leaf-level entities. | [
0.0720889792,
0.0304484554,
-0.0235788543,
0.0760558173,
-0.0155132478,
-0.0038426537,
-0.0198583286,
0.0247031767,
0.0312722512,
-0.070593819,
-0.0512002818,
-0.0213742554,
-0.0380025767,
0.0164172631,
0.0051906966,
-0.0371749997,
0.029802084,
-0.0259647425,
0.0120383035,
-0.0393709205,
0.0039990321,
0.0273135472,
0.0139782215,
0.0260264352,
-0.0013646738,
-0.0401129164,
-0.004451443,
-0.001151723,
-0.0116023347,
-0.0481976308,
0.0232695378,
0.0245130882,
0.0405498557,
0.081736967,
0.0000019955,
-0.0560649671,
0.0121949054,
-0.0106317904,
-0.052940499,
0.0324119888,
0.0115485294,
0.0300195571,
0.0322431549,
-0.0032050214,
-0.0328241624,
-0.0313687958,
0.0090632755,
-0.0012341061,
-0.0133349709,
0.0178925116,
0.0092367977,
-0.0764636472,
0.010696847,
-0.0294571854,
-0.0095463498,
-0.0589445233,
0.022666458,
0.0487780161,
0.0114321494,
0.0362352915,
-0.0253227931,
0.0004393083,
-0.0017406117,
-0.020085223,
0.0241413135,
0.0678876638,
0.0074134441,
-0.0125785163,
0.0188075416,
0.0832459554,
0.0157572217,
-0.0011103043,
0.0034758125,
0.0223879889,
-0.0084397607,
0.0440404341,
-0.0556148924,
0.0222263839,
-0.0395040512,
0.0032895268,
0.0598124042,
-0.0192199983,
0.0366674028,
0.0142880529,
-0.0251425933,
0.0917016268,
0.0256408639,
-0.0169180669,
0.0319712423,
0.0022968543,
-0.0286995526,
-0.093042545,
-0.0219073873,
0.0426766835,
-0.0373318382,
0.0554859713,
-0.0085085575,
0.0335792676,
0.0426220857,
-0.0708210692,
-0.0131271472,
0.0127266115,
0.0265176892,
0.0785286203,
-0.0056418534,
0.0369922668,
-0.0317829251,
-0.0031945738,
-0.0336084664,
-0.0463200696,
-0.0852202177,
-0.0204925574,
-0.0153476968,
0.0511613712,
-0.0126854777,
-0.0254867412,
-0.0165394917,
0.0308022071,
0.0069629592,
-0.0029102671,
0.002802656,
0.0039364756,
0.0081407325,
-0.0104298983,
-0.0670549124,
0.0235905182,
-0.0580584966,
0.0327182338,
0.0058639483,
-0.0156292822,
0.045745451,
0.0252401289,
0.0233160798,
-0.0188432615,
0.0261604767,
0.0259924196,
0.0205078684,
-0.0314652659,
-0.0367981046,
-0.0411815159,
-0.0280817673,
-0.0458029732,
0.0411518812,
-0.0776792765,
0.0154843489,
0.0303510688,
0.0128250932,
-0.009412623,
0.0213089529,
0.0122638391,
-0.037364237,
0.0243072547,
-0.0224838573,
0.0320274718,
0.0466432869,
0.0334122367,
-0.0175827201,
0.0490544736,
-0.0006385668,
0.0051325071,
0.0582562685,
-0.0252404567,
-0.0234184731,
0.0212024134,
-0.0183551311,
0.0116865803,
-0.0080745444,
0.0542021058,
-0.0373587459,
0.0333941951,
0.0559897311,
0.0675247759,
-0.0002440508,
-0.009533111,
0.0462170951,
0.0938327909,
0.0177163724,
0.0178450979,
0.0231498685,
0.0096737668,
0.0289565362,
-0.0087146591,
0.0038390341,
0.0095559657,
-0.0465148278,
-0.0031616283,
-0.0000141621,
-0.0031274376,
-0.0478110276,
-0.000202588,
-0.0465180166,
0.0060504982,
-0.007692873,
0.0056951242,
0.0550420657,
-0.0187366586,
0.0280200131,
0.0552387647,
0.0447994173,
-0.0137577187,
0.0143111497,
-0.0579059273,
0.0574544817,
0.052022282,
0.0455085747,
-0.0194573551,
-0.0380267762,
0.0280754622,
0.0132387849,
0.0420505516,
0.0412002206,
-0.0556860343,
-0.0275171641,
-0.0049828445,
-0.0240324941,
-0.0169191286,
0.0192815661,
0.0094789546,
0.0416994318,
0.0203853976,
0.0012453437,
-0.102620244,
0.0061475397,
0.0202967711,
-0.0558869801,
0.0025042025,
-0.00894411,
-0.0153945116,
0.0091506075,
0.0187261049,
-0.0223351885,
0.0057227458,
0.0398045443,
-0.0175927076,
-0.0373337753,
-0.0157857314,
-0.0342895165,
-0.0382876694,
0.0425988287,
0.0141136795,
-0.0276496187,
0.0117507819,
0.0010484917,
-0.0095501291,
-0.0097561283,
-0.0155837974,
0.063251622,
-0.0499156825,
0.0169534162,
-0.0444569439,
-0.0364024453,
-0.0161538161,
0.0943566784,
-0.0060804691,
0.0595430769,
-0.0243402217,
-0.0171761382,
0.0134524256,
-0.0067510051,
-0.0271350108,
0.0132270819,
-0.0045103477,
0.0318049639,
0.037642993,
-0.0037005681,
-0.0721875802,
-0.0053146612,
-0.1022770181,
0.0260241814,
-0.0026908654,
0.0320904292,
0.0144652799,
-0.0194474198,
0.0124232229,
0.0111755952,
-0.0608684905,
0.0411246531,
-0.0022002403,
0.0332528614,
0.0031736162,
0.0038208019,
-0.0342496224,
-0.0383774713,
-0.0084079662,
-0.0111931041,
0.0479095243,
0.0026851892,
0.0082322452,
0.0028992041,
0.035520535,
-0.0592896193,
0.0036012039,
-0.0316927359,
-0.0103896447,
0.0127301617,
-0.0133906649,
0.0165601969,
0.0196122024,
-0.0089685749,
-0.0032729029,
0.0497630127,
0.0126597648,
-0.0411598682,
-0.0113346959,
-0.0126388278,
-0.0279233418,
-0.0582086928,
-0.0174844973,
0.0076031927,
0.096876204,
-0.0257722642,
-0.0118949814,
-0.0305322483,
0.0315562338,
-0.0503542349,
0.009602231,
-0.064512141,
-0.0050127357,
0.0127330786,
0.0568928309,
-0.02002104,
-0.0468697101,
0.0499577373,
-0.0061155632,
-0.0080731921,
-0.0021087439,
-0.0108549306,
-0.0528294668,
0.0868138671,
-0.0097456109,
0.0301614404,
0.0395246148,
-0.0340592936,
-0.0380639546,
0.0403584614,
-0.0053650606,
-0.0386467129,
0.0500509217,
-0.0277097728,
0.0182971284,
0.0048793559,
-0.0361249,
-0.040761482,
0.0089745428,
-0.0346406251,
0.0530114248,
0.0376325026,
-0.0322273821,
0.0095069939,
-0.0222591925,
0.0075357705,
-0.0074479235,
0.018939646,
-0.044980973,
0.0095734969,
0.0610988885,
0.0530363917,
0.0026128064,
0.0066976869,
-0.0160342772,
0.065296106,
0.0420853756,
0.0062456527,
-0.0012982559,
-0.0083749928,
-0.0405231565,
0.0103689702,
-0.0355457962,
-0.0467867404,
0.0107233236,
-0.001399233,
-0.0356882587,
0.0039610779,
0.1204085201,
0.0474763624,
-0.0279285628,
0.0142210741,
-0.0539713241,
0.0336366631,
0.0710474551,
0.004150534,
-0.0724729523,
-0.0024452789,
-0.0082011409,
0.0041304594,
0.0128376698,
-0.0618974194,
0.0171374381,
-0.1167125627,
0.0088560339,
-0.0215520766,
-0.0320114568,
0.0107092429,
-0.042325072,
-0.0046101809,
0.0463243835,
-0.0211815927,
0.0077896612,
-0.0217969585,
-0.0029753121,
0.0281137731,
-0.0684821978,
-0.0380168185,
0.0986887366,
-0.0487822779,
0.0111364583,
0.0272614509,
0.0516782701,
-0.0229038242,
0.014646641,
0.0438463725,
-0.0216315575,
0.0097159836,
0.0044145002,
0.0185579956,
-0.0010042408,
0.0051781344,
-0.027801495,
-0.0222134683,
-0.0324866064,
0.0413087234,
0.0251176618,
0.1109720543,
0.0147283915,
-0.0301062446,
-0.0105833067,
-0.0238137543,
-0.0136333695,
0.0889828354,
0.0133781815,
-0.0172380973,
0.0101536959,
-0.0118870055,
-0.0028016146,
0.020765299,
-0.0427049734,
0.055972226,
0.0122311339,
0.0056309318,
-0.064427644,
-0.0247300323,
0.0681478679,
-0.0005765125,
-0.0002501263,
0.0487226844,
-0.0195145905,
-0.016893236,
-0.0475536808,
0.0131689496,
-0.0505520254,
-0.002904251,
-0.0538196564,
-0.031963136,
0.0376886651,
0.0222667903,
-0.0345039032,
-0.0222939365,
-0.036831893,
-0.0679646507,
-0.022567302,
-0.0130332727,
0.0178058855,
0.0215119198,
0.0046448465,
-0.06030472,
0.0348410308,
-0.0192791037,
-0.0391887687,
0.0249339882,
-0.012159599,
0.0211629067,
-0.0070100133,
0.0555722415,
-0.08539249,
0.0015084443,
0.0255543794,
0.0544222482,
-0.0140313283,
-0.0668790862,
0.0133639146,
0.0382212996,
-0.0075238547,
0.0047124517,
0.0105417091,
-0.0262422841,
-0.0105975932,
-0.0310489982,
-0.0170412455,
-0.0168926716,
-0.0390473492,
0.0561357699,
-0.0082887597,
0.0001549236,
0.0153650325,
0.0080401758,
0.0550790355,
-0.0409049131,
-0.0243217889,
0.0108833872,
-0.0127154524,
0.0403203741,
0.0075482382,
-0.0279161446,
-0.0355682485,
-0.0080670845,
0.0326382928,
-0.0267323349,
0.0740994737,
-0.0023193506,
-0.031909842,
-0.0205787513,
-0.0204975698,
-0.0170930475,
-0.0976364538,
0.0306996293,
0.0374275371,
0.0689125434,
0.0012796557,
0.0078456448,
-0.0629070029,
-0.0170075595,
-0.0408148691,
0.0155990338,
-0.0255171955,
-0.074510254,
0.0727349818,
0.0204351414,
-0.035358917,
-0.0064876112,
0.1030075848,
0.0799366236,
0.0501186103,
-0.0065955655,
-0.0243988298,
-0.0111232474,
0.0054336716,
0.0029831885,
0.0142803863,
-0.0323596559,
0.0446153283,
-0.0756475776,
-0.0653408319,
-0.0110092396,
-0.0192946978,
-0.0017471995,
-0.0065279291,
0.0437232591,
0.0669542402,
0.0089317774,
-0.042223677,
-0.0573061556,
0.0197596606,
-0.0640254766,
0.0198990721,
-0.0159659535,
-6.413972519e-33,
-0.0052856477,
-0.0438223742,
0.0272056721,
0.0034693968,
0.0019576843,
0.0258653685,
-0.0462322719,
0.0435605198,
-0.0414340086,
0.0396511108,
0.0007260706,
0.0062904432,
-0.0263509583,
-0.0132368542,
0.0311668757,
0.0009613944,
0.0241101142,
-0.0254324637,
-0.0029518849,
0.027046131,
0.0409891419,
0.0161897503,
0.0473811626,
-0.0286482535,
0.0026322133,
0.0048051961,
0.0413904041,
0.0475197211,
-0.0237588752,
0.0728181973,
-0.0330550447,
0.0427905396,
0.0482849553,
-0.0071352879,
0.0091590034,
0.011997248,
-0.0745023116,
-0.017591387,
0.0200374313,
-0.0173668843,
-0.0247326922,
-0.0364386365,
0.0184017401,
0.0212160479,
0.0105890073,
-0.0352855176,
0.0341224335,
-0.0059946985,
-0.0336111784,
-0.0568203032,
-0.0530804358,
0.0228158459,
0.0160812382,
-0.0006224905,
0.003195904,
0.020659266,
0.005848106,
0.0349961631,
-0.0222322326,
0.0237934384,
-0.0018627465,
0.0040387353,
0.038954217,
0.0141580449,
0.0099626174,
0.0720447972,
0.0260820705,
0.0543563776,
-0.0062371511,
-0.0073136929,
0.020687446,
0.0408538468,
0.0165454876,
0.0012651277,
0.0124999257,
0.0099308444,
-0.07407327,
0.0227496251,
-0.0296951197,
0.0172438771,
0.0301178861,
0.0369480923,
-0.0335211307,
-0.0394685231,
-0.0593471453,
0.0552628264,
-0.0529307947,
-0.0211718623,
0.0295023024,
-0.0087069673,
0.0355973169,
-0.0296256486,
0.0226726383,
-0.0526407845,
-0.0418466888,
0.0150664793,
0.0063808104,
0.0352496728,
-0.0232424345,
0.044688873,
-0.095801875,
-0.036030259,
0.0030761769,
-0.0224192459,
0.0148670711,
0.0332322381,
0.0053790957,
-0.0160707198,
-0.0427587554,
-0.0048849639,
-0.0392524749,
-0.0419420265,
-0.0111784171,
0.0040425425,
0.040059112,
0.0172366165,
0.0151910298,
0.0454160608,
0.0662558079,
-0.0095260153,
-0.0419727564,
0.0208851919,
-0.0073590474,
-0.013736017,
-0.011443398,
0.0023853383,
-0.0361945964,
-0.0075186859,
0.0344440453,
-0.0029786804,
-0.0315738656,
-0.0407082103,
2.77e-7,
0.063820444,
0.051744163,
-0.0383678861,
0.0296802223,
0.0421269648,
0.0301184282,
-0.011664209,
0.0155199394,
-0.0176756009,
-0.0410417393,
-0.0314444825,
-0.008170479,
0.0356282853,
0.034809202,
-0.0871374905,
-0.0013374398,
-0.0405580476,
0.0007991247,
-0.0556266308,
-0.0046067322,
0.0096057467,
0.0406220518,
0.0032423544,
-0.0078263497,
-0.0328879915,
-0.0706738532,
0.0806454718,
-0.0143678151,
-0.0049701692,
0.0433854684,
0.0277779195,
0.0500009507,
-0.0027264273,
0.0398743562,
-0.0035200943,
0.0331721865,
-0.0100976005,
0.0372088999,
-0.0238421261,
0.0058031618,
0.0101179676,
-0.0472205803,
-0.0052092848,
-0.1107469201,
0.0594917685,
-0.0518846139,
-0.0259257499,
-0.0047460557,
0.0134113636,
0.0069421977,
-0.0183552727,
-0.0458350442,
-0.0112581663,
-0.0099679027,
-0.018629035,
-0.0068804794,
0.0005475429,
-0.0661789551,
0.0147278402,
0.0439912863,
-0.0617344268,
-0.08401867,
-0.0367874578,
0.0177550353,
-0.0204085857,
-0.0130052511,
0.0322198682,
2.549549213e-34,
0.0018275378,
0.0232606567,
-0.0080071837,
0.0430754162,
0.0470091216,
-0.027955737,
-0.0169385206,
-0.0083734747,
-0.0047610109,
-0.0978605375,
0.0120351743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11130v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11130v1 | Dynamic Order Template Prediction for Generative Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis | 2024-06-17T01:21:28 | 2024-06-17T01:21:28 | Yonghyun Jun, Hwanhee Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aspect-based sentiment analysis (ABSA) assesses sentiments towards specific
aspects within texts, resulting in detailed sentiment tuples. Previous ABSA
models often use static templates to predict all of the elements in the tuples,
and these models often fail to accurately capture dependencies between
elements. Multi-view prompting method improves the performance of ABSA by
predicting tuples with various templates and then ensembling the results.
However, this method suffers from inefficiencies and out-of-distribution
errors. In this paper, we propose a Dynamic Order Template (DOT) method for
ABSA, which dynamically generates necessary views for each instance based on
instance-level entropy. Ensuring the diverse and relevant view generation, our
proposed method improves F1-scores on ASQP and ACOS datasets while
significantly reducing inference time. | [
0.0320015475,
0.0591700822,
0.0217181463,
0.0090562841,
0.0116455033,
0.0366096981,
0.0018289024,
-0.0185606834,
-0.0122353714,
-0.0377372093,
-0.0182409026,
-0.0466023386,
-0.0105775222,
0.0470189787,
-0.012933461,
-0.0459608361,
0.0144299185,
0.0130758742,
0.005996109,
-0.0261247512,
-0.0054125343,
0.0352592915,
-0.0008692265,
-0.0221476611,
-0.0119968634,
-0.037909586,
-0.0030486064,
0.0365043841,
0.0570683628,
-0.0138654374,
-0.0145526435,
0.04432109,
-0.0263900589,
-0.0330341458,
0.0000023051,
0.0045318413,
-0.0356142148,
0.0128096109,
0.0651305914,
0.008181137,
0.0833561942,
-0.0071431231,
0.0288068112,
0.037707936,
-0.0603258349,
-0.0287428256,
0.0123424856,
0.1016205326,
0.0439784713,
0.0589068644,
-0.0338982828,
-0.0376443975,
-0.003510325,
-0.035768684,
0.0052195583,
-0.0210832432,
-0.0065101371,
-0.0683867484,
-0.047307495,
0.0459141694,
0.0187876485,
0.0088528385,
0.0327730589,
0.00966202,
-0.0050631799,
0.0098118288,
0.0573715344,
0.0211444106,
-0.0189069025,
0.0275798962,
0.0285974555,
0.000192818,
-0.0019718949,
-0.0330513529,
-0.005367938,
0.0577614829,
-0.0076795123,
-0.0114658941,
-0.0122431312,
0.0522502512,
0.0575184189,
0.0517134219,
-0.0145523036,
0.0007894112,
-0.0059817187,
-0.0099331252,
-0.0079580834,
-0.0379393362,
-0.022035256,
0.0590591282,
0.0094437972,
-0.0240254197,
-0.0219999738,
-0.0547639243,
-0.0087280404,
0.0230900217,
0.0075509544,
0.0329700597,
0.0013341582,
-0.0676504597,
0.0255722497,
-0.0069827982,
-0.0039483616,
-0.0110843303,
0.0226880796,
-0.0189420283,
0.0154954698,
-0.0432022698,
-0.0412204824,
0.0465234444,
-0.0525593907,
-0.0042656492,
0.0421347469,
0.0492655449,
-0.0446727872,
-0.0121805165,
-0.0696729124,
0.0117309168,
-0.0269085094,
-0.0112925023,
0.0407793596,
0.0202335529,
0.0238660164,
0.026807189,
0.0026712292,
0.0043007289,
-0.0349176861,
0.0180474166,
-0.0371079817,
0.0187794045,
0.0099465614,
0.0108435825,
-0.0052536731,
0.0017422168,
-0.0158415865,
0.0035703031,
0.0334872827,
-0.052989617,
0.0118582388,
-0.0220696069,
0.0048421919,
-0.0300814062,
-0.004274697,
-0.0630878136,
0.0032778829,
0.019864345,
0.0079398928,
-2.563e-7,
0.0142040532,
0.0122192185,
-0.0328374244,
0.015153829,
0.005445431,
-0.0214354414,
-0.0779623911,
0.0102794142,
0.1055106893,
0.046017129,
-0.0355954915,
0.0403164439,
0.0116422353,
0.015062659,
0.0044994876,
-0.0161161479,
-0.0169752315,
0.0489543267,
-0.0304366685,
-0.0142773399,
-0.0455292873,
-0.0570860244,
0.0103450529,
0.018950548,
0.0100226821,
-0.0420972407,
0.0031829388,
-0.0498056561,
-0.0178548414,
0.0682594255,
0.0000171969,
0.0012131059,
-0.0185272302,
0.0228102487,
0.0183864664,
0.0223240219,
0.0007243908,
-0.0190566313,
0.0627677515,
0.0207401272,
-0.017237857,
-0.0669355616,
-0.0172329433,
0.0034305286,
-0.0536760539,
0.0119721806,
0.0172847677,
0.0191729255,
-0.0303265359,
-0.0230183229,
0.0645005777,
-0.0413260274,
-0.066465348,
0.0082507506,
0.0345660672,
0.0925473496,
0.026477607,
-0.0278790183,
-0.0452376902,
0.0018337576,
-0.0936692357,
0.0129302451,
0.0148580279,
-0.0123313013,
0.0125741586,
-0.0129040862,
-0.0052882833,
0.0048032305,
0.0086774714,
0.0390872397,
-0.0256337468,
0.0290906392,
-0.0086188009,
0.0056672441,
-0.0238318276,
-0.0159265567,
0.010227439,
-0.0024491735,
0.066155076,
0.0039134547,
0.049230881,
0.0906898975,
-0.0212936755,
-0.0086600855,
0.0512227491,
-0.062284831,
-0.0495537221,
0.0512191541,
-0.0536390617,
-0.0744305253,
-0.0323315077,
-0.0101476489,
-0.0139058847,
-0.0396575108,
-0.0444582365,
-0.0181645993,
-0.0074856458,
0.0141351409,
0.0220664069,
-0.0218424462,
-0.0280750263,
0.0506654605,
0.0095011797,
-0.0131353606,
0.0803803802,
-0.0582373254,
0.0314443335,
0.0198199246,
-0.0459100939,
0.013508358,
0.0189051796,
-0.0002419429,
-0.0067840307,
0.0039282972,
-0.0113189667,
0.0294216499,
0.0216813292,
0.0013760566,
-0.0272525642,
-0.0983215868,
-0.0373384766,
0.0121864304,
-0.0025016423,
0.0296106543,
-0.0088426266,
-0.00628606,
0.0203340258,
-0.0442851447,
-0.0078179324,
-0.0167956501,
0.0257203002,
-0.0083098458,
0.0096356878,
0.0276788771,
0.0042197546,
-0.0084169684,
-0.0348666981,
0.0585171208,
0.0289650708,
-0.0008425847,
-0.0410622843,
0.0722801238,
-0.0287767835,
0.0008237538,
0.0020317789,
-0.0264103021,
-0.0227344912,
-0.0313793868,
0.0229042508,
0.0055996277,
0.0286471099,
0.037064597,
0.0419014879,
0.0143824676,
-0.0227189697,
0.0212956984,
-0.068231523,
0.0707969815,
0.0155537548,
-0.0658558533,
0.0048404112,
0.0379341356,
0.0270102881,
-0.0155429626,
-0.0694167316,
0.0184242371,
-0.0219787881,
-0.018097166,
-0.0237352848,
0.0302540716,
0.0112093771,
0.0361362919,
0.0354127623,
-0.0157333929,
0.0357727036,
0.0081667611,
0.03589027,
-0.055897627,
0.0411560871,
-0.0385472476,
0.0472422242,
0.0071452758,
0.0323071927,
0.0092899948,
0.0420253091,
-0.0091255084,
-0.0042979727,
-0.0217769258,
-0.0092912484,
0.0148425838,
0.0322401151,
0.0052534975,
0.0278367493,
-0.0710032061,
-0.0002567325,
-0.0463482179,
0.0192875303,
0.0103501724,
0.0087946476,
-0.0295971017,
0.0029995861,
-0.0163390078,
-0.0204207245,
-0.024178192,
-0.0040127211,
-0.0489034615,
0.0205684546,
0.0658086762,
0.0575385094,
-0.0797237903,
0.013059604,
-0.0326607376,
0.0044282638,
0.0539812669,
0.0277978182,
0.0171893854,
-0.0084380107,
-0.030511437,
0.0510215349,
0.0491864309,
-0.0332542732,
-0.0448183082,
0.0402748324,
-0.0194015075,
-0.0134230126,
0.1039066315,
0.0409713611,
-0.0658715218,
-0.0010284174,
0.0095734177,
0.0573412403,
0.0488086902,
0.0232889373,
-0.0748173669,
0.001561468,
-0.0310589131,
0.057212539,
-0.0153534971,
-0.0128252879,
0.0195008982,
-0.1008359492,
0.0230690613,
-0.0376636311,
0.0068616197,
-0.0285268929,
-0.063886039,
0.0212335028,
-0.0190534759,
-0.0719324052,
-0.0346256532,
-0.0078152455,
0.0285068806,
0.022989355,
-0.0294167306,
-0.0088474806,
0.0357104726,
0.0316192172,
0.0133024352,
0.0408662446,
0.0408794992,
-0.025860915,
-0.0185045768,
-0.0303732734,
-0.035409756,
0.0260092933,
-0.0437408537,
0.049421601,
-0.0373340808,
-0.010944088,
-0.0108352378,
0.0155461077,
-0.0518237315,
0.0075753145,
-0.0230790395,
0.0274337083,
-0.0073560826,
-0.0133224996,
-0.0354145691,
0.0000909046,
0.0133754881,
0.0400162265,
-0.0033218449,
-0.0640170127,
-0.0064434116,
-0.0147146564,
0.0136862863,
-0.0438326262,
-0.0149265621,
-0.027098719,
-0.0306536164,
-0.0888505131,
-0.1040517613,
-0.0248050746,
-0.0241960399,
0.0825664178,
-0.022929281,
-0.0021561235,
-0.0062712301,
-0.0129678994,
-0.0323602445,
-0.0217212457,
0.0521272868,
0.001382291,
-0.0109851323,
-0.0544051751,
0.0888042822,
-0.0351453796,
-0.0427781604,
0.0053984048,
-0.0166549347,
-0.0469057709,
0.0206937883,
0.0467075519,
0.0062787379,
0.0106872497,
0.0060187592,
0.0387527496,
0.0698773488,
0.0930439383,
0.0093264999,
0.0056602419,
0.0516864173,
0.0420323126,
0.0232194401,
0.0256233104,
0.0001466737,
0.041648183,
0.0092577413,
-0.0286892559,
-0.0298182238,
-0.055486884,
-0.0001118651,
0.0038204512,
0.0465804525,
0.0051705418,
-0.0509203859,
-0.0337370746,
0.0093546947,
-0.0211517774,
-0.0282052085,
-0.0399656817,
0.0510517694,
-0.0051254383,
0.0024826708,
-0.0765253231,
0.0421654582,
-0.0067027034,
0.0391420349,
-0.0879963487,
0.0456179231,
-0.0064695165,
-0.019261077,
-0.0192515831,
-0.0094570965,
0.0007534274,
-0.0170811899,
-0.0072612776,
0.0077180867,
-0.0163922478,
0.0611687377,
0.0221953392,
0.0427399427,
-0.0198376887,
0.0413858071,
-0.0294710174,
0.0094084935,
-0.0457960255,
-0.0005760907,
-0.0327173136,
-0.0140937483,
0.0611763149,
-0.043738123,
0.0234600734,
0.0113841193,
0.0305065345,
-0.001909375,
-0.0084914351,
0.0299623366,
0.0195365213,
-0.0098032281,
-0.0284466427,
0.079425633,
-0.0949473158,
0.0497743152,
0.0457821749,
-0.0071984264,
-0.0426215231,
0.0004355355,
0.0290167052,
-0.0027017694,
0.0227643345,
0.0515409969,
-0.0523975119,
-0.0422877632,
0.0092966501,
-0.0411803573,
0.0402440615,
-0.0043010945,
0.0175022092,
0.0500503816,
0.0456746407,
0.0611631721,
-0.0715290233,
-0.0376102142,
-0.0290606655,
-0.0515404195,
0.0153556718,
-7.501700788e-33,
-0.0065354668,
-0.0063352971,
-0.0545034111,
-0.0107771121,
-0.0160826109,
0.0240284298,
0.0107328817,
0.0257720817,
0.0427588038,
0.0216434505,
-0.0041484558,
0.0246099811,
-0.0048949714,
0.0380958244,
0.0499160029,
0.0088018635,
0.03374945,
-0.0101275202,
0.005011606,
0.0669454336,
0.0959486663,
-0.0094903149,
0.0218195673,
-0.0979247466,
0.0185993984,
0.0120613752,
-0.0401332974,
-0.010119807,
-0.0085871276,
0.0136768296,
-0.0069206073,
0.0105579467,
0.0485723354,
-0.0373197608,
0.0114063742,
-0.0174000487,
-0.0067256088,
-0.0548077859,
0.0182445496,
-0.0260374714,
-0.027471967,
-0.0242700018,
-0.0219697896,
0.017389698,
-0.0009844161,
-0.032767415,
-0.0027062998,
-0.0155008202,
0.0044126944,
-0.1557810158,
0.0065062237,
0.0386439823,
-0.0129738236,
-0.0297494177,
-0.0091867484,
0.0556378849,
0.0119284661,
0.0062714941,
-0.0052636131,
0.0470953658,
0.012936363,
0.0396996811,
-0.0208297968,
-0.0420085452,
0.0259070843,
0.0383099653,
-0.0101706823,
-0.0099943234,
-0.027668925,
0.0119648958,
-0.0279182792,
0.0429019779,
-0.0132751325,
0.0118773011,
0.0393741131,
-0.0152517362,
-0.0274228081,
0.0483043827,
0.0568186454,
-0.0196878593,
0.0958918855,
-0.0108883306,
-0.0424793474,
-0.0291149449,
0.0092481924,
-0.0319021009,
-0.0294210203,
-0.0081721097,
-0.0037593977,
0.0353099331,
-0.0656312257,
0.0000075036,
-0.0164374784,
-0.0297568589,
-0.0137386303,
0.0487760529,
-0.0561694652,
0.0316289701,
-0.0008510901,
-0.0165509842,
-0.0523554049,
-0.0113082854,
-0.0050126244,
0.0158220567,
-0.0120022148,
-0.0009081283,
0.0659658685,
-0.0023265977,
-0.0986714661,
-0.0282119401,
0.0070627066,
0.0439853035,
-0.0132399704,
0.0253512356,
0.0189158134,
-0.0019225277,
-0.0045572324,
0.0686328784,
0.0165045857,
0.0420216173,
-0.0262955502,
0.0550018549,
-0.0096579669,
0.0263566524,
-0.004578732,
-0.0298516843,
0.0231239591,
-0.0682885721,
0.0009474813,
-0.0284083076,
-0.0488614403,
0.039371267,
3.072e-7,
0.0223528054,
0.0682955235,
-0.0195488073,
0.0498833656,
0.0261654854,
0.0603805557,
0.0240750164,
0.0269530881,
-0.0001374964,
0.0085011534,
0.0386498272,
0.0011021834,
0.0137605099,
0.0375015959,
-0.0564454459,
0.0611250289,
-0.0234960467,
-0.021959031,
-0.0120509798,
-0.0165021922,
0.0494896844,
0.0640740767,
-0.0095673995,
-0.0001553098,
0.0263432451,
0.089772746,
0.0312217921,
-0.0086325901,
-0.0096706823,
-0.0313399136,
-0.0114572784,
-0.0416377485,
0.0066868393,
-0.0364946425,
-0.0073801395,
-0.0045287204,
-0.0161094069,
0.0136281336,
0.0252561439,
-0.0662209317,
0.059257891,
0.0076882523,
0.013192445,
-0.0460692644,
0.0459713042,
-0.0300421715,
-0.0436489433,
-0.0702796057,
-0.0319954678,
0.0641359985,
-0.0018659583,
0.0306507815,
-0.0263675153,
0.0576739684,
-0.0332197696,
-0.0577756874,
-0.0296442099,
-0.0375197493,
-0.0103020286,
-0.0019638366,
0.0024041117,
-0.005197865,
0.0253272709,
0.0123147005,
-0.0324248597,
-0.0513041131,
-0.0125248563,
3.004278871e-34,
0.07913398,
0.0164772216,
-0.0340109132,
0.0396457426,
0.0129688522,
-0.040006008,
-0.0788940266,
-0.0034645144,
0.0297080483,
-0.0543040112,
-0.0076767225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11116v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11116v1 | Grammaticality Representation in ChatGPT as Compared to Linguists and Laypeople | 2024-06-17T00:23:16 | 2024-06-17T00:23:16 | Zhuang Qiu, Xufeng Duan, Zhenguang G. Cai | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional performance across
various linguistic tasks. However, it remains uncertain whether LLMs have
developed human-like fine-grained grammatical intuition. This preregistered
study (https://osf.io/t5nes) presents the first large-scale investigation of
ChatGPT's grammatical intuition, building upon a previous study that collected
laypeople's grammatical judgments on 148 linguistic phenomena that linguists
judged to be grammatical, ungrammatical, or marginally grammatical (Sprouse,
Schutze, & Almeida, 2013). Our primary focus was to compare ChatGPT with both
laypeople and linguists in the judgement of these linguistic constructions. In
Experiment 1, ChatGPT assigned ratings to sentences based on a given reference
sentence. Experiment 2 involved rating sentences on a 7-point scale, and
Experiment 3 asked ChatGPT to choose the more grammatical sentence from a pair.
Overall, our findings demonstrate convergence rates ranging from 73% to 95%
between ChatGPT and linguists, with an overall point-estimate of 89%.
Significant correlations were also found between ChatGPT and laypeople across
all tasks, though the correlation strength varied by task. We attribute these
results to the psychometric nature of the judgment tasks and the differences in
language processing styles between humans and LLMs. | [
0.0368558392,
0.0483690761,
-0.0464588217,
0.0141807673,
-0.0678511634,
0.0302267447,
-0.0110419011,
-0.0049971729,
0.0258445982,
-0.0353112295,
-0.0819600895,
-0.0252642557,
-0.0013523824,
-0.0066709169,
0.0580031201,
-0.0294063427,
0.0180690028,
-0.0067561604,
0.0296924543,
-0.002564409,
0.0185954385,
0.0193548109,
-0.0162321143,
0.0568594523,
0.0003886153,
-0.0387705155,
0.0123123135,
-0.0318936892,
-0.0085249376,
-0.0140733076,
0.0269261058,
0.0470210984,
-0.0106897885,
0.0371873789,
0.0000020433,
-0.0464125089,
0.0738114044,
-0.0233943127,
-0.0082541471,
0.0826641545,
0.0465278327,
0.0329651237,
-0.0210969448,
-0.0208968017,
-0.0525299907,
-0.0001814409,
0.0186129157,
0.0488847643,
0.0039156107,
0.0352089256,
-0.0127224866,
-0.0275255963,
0.0163024012,
-0.0141183715,
0.0009004861,
-0.0192627646,
0.0023681256,
0.0200624242,
-0.0046190582,
0.005774084,
-0.0059604621,
0.02272496,
0.0332600921,
-0.0026694322,
-0.0361071676,
0.0481069088,
-0.0583310537,
-0.0448272303,
0.0057586511,
0.0238579493,
0.0293786861,
-0.0344055146,
-0.0141025083,
0.0081236903,
0.0233562514,
0.0055823415,
-0.0624444,
0.0393448286,
0.0024410696,
0.0337234139,
0.0303086359,
-0.033097811,
-0.0032250602,
0.0316951089,
0.0238969363,
0.0632957295,
0.0002314394,
-0.0154908216,
0.0232592039,
0.0469890535,
-0.0708289072,
-0.0716144666,
0.0001342557,
-0.0260849018,
-0.0336329378,
-0.004866702,
0.0107794553,
0.0095723644,
0.0084655667,
-0.0569131598,
0.0243800581,
0.0299695674,
-0.0403968319,
0.0322317891,
-0.0110430755,
0.0491042659,
-0.003371797,
0.0408464707,
-0.0150464736,
0.0218766425,
-0.0724877268,
-0.0326407291,
0.0049811099,
0.0050207903,
0.0008872838,
-0.0068463595,
-0.0686219856,
-0.0115846284,
-0.0082810903,
-0.0529960096,
0.0089367367,
0.0320626274,
0.0051807784,
0.0166292153,
-0.0459434725,
0.0192528088,
-0.0390623547,
0.0491857454,
-0.0071993023,
-0.0765632465,
0.0049417554,
0.028144639,
-0.0203352086,
-0.031936083,
-0.0280946009,
0.0069498266,
-0.0128934719,
-0.0159977097,
0.0155288754,
-0.0298290662,
-0.0403077826,
-0.0517480783,
-0.010582448,
-0.0396781191,
-0.0067607816,
0.0440861993,
-0.0153450966,
-0.014436313,
-0.0157888178,
0.0197543725,
-0.0232422072,
0.0203501321,
0.0434549414,
0.0504840463,
-0.0236842427,
-0.0062473896,
-0.0216386318,
0.0326479003,
0.0297183655,
-0.0058095334,
-0.0049949042,
-0.0171050411,
-0.0270832945,
0.0245033484,
-0.0627559498,
-0.0291916914,
-0.0198304616,
-0.0039056917,
-0.0242633969,
0.0371395387,
0.0382164866,
0.0860612988,
-0.0349711627,
-0.0004253592,
0.0932921246,
0.0529330187,
0.0206701513,
0.0684326291,
0.0470213518,
0.0362684391,
0.0353184454,
0.0381049663,
-0.053093534,
0.0300250538,
-0.0397289768,
-0.0202311743,
-0.012453625,
0.0386305749,
-0.0059780972,
-0.0272556301,
-0.0210372545,
0.0206935387,
0.0109858019,
-0.0355625153,
0.0101108328,
-0.0006083496,
0.0040843268,
0.0170199648,
0.0421894714,
-0.047198303,
-0.010882807,
-0.0624250099,
0.0160928927,
0.0215813797,
-0.0012872287,
0.047628928,
0.0020801178,
0.0284000821,
0.0085360389,
0.0372873358,
0.0504467413,
0.0213178564,
-0.0292394869,
-0.006929419,
0.0218523722,
-0.0246849116,
0.0208445154,
-0.0170628726,
-0.0234255996,
0.0243761167,
-0.007118274,
-0.0436278582,
-0.0106318407,
0.0187948737,
-0.0299055763,
0.0137531944,
-0.046230223,
-0.0137024028,
0.0179638881,
-0.0196122844,
0.0021279887,
0.0455618612,
0.0028285924,
-0.008572788,
-0.0149624432,
0.0552493706,
-0.0627438277,
-0.0464828052,
0.0122914743,
-0.018607093,
-0.0364410579,
0.022919368,
0.0174018629,
-0.0152404271,
0.0317084417,
-0.0594398044,
0.0463397689,
-0.0494023599,
0.0088302642,
-0.0151238889,
0.0229847524,
-0.0367822237,
0.0502665453,
0.0274504181,
0.0301521607,
-0.0215741638,
-0.0152380811,
0.0158686303,
-0.0045358352,
-0.0326916091,
-0.0105166389,
0.0099145267,
0.004415377,
0.0213679262,
0.0277000275,
-0.0660199896,
-0.040399041,
-0.1226564795,
-0.0126409512,
0.0132265408,
0.0241809562,
0.0292752143,
-0.0450903289,
-0.01608257,
0.0281953737,
-0.0263437722,
0.0229310282,
-0.0035822231,
0.0382969044,
0.0459762588,
-0.0459333733,
-0.0066363271,
-0.0197095815,
0.0114840027,
-0.0411937647,
0.0122978725,
0.0298982915,
0.0094832238,
-0.0144467615,
0.0405243821,
-0.0464784503,
-0.0387883298,
0.0232690182,
-0.0893100947,
0.0428174324,
0.0148534384,
0.0552416071,
0.0625544712,
0.0013532909,
0.033908084,
0.0495194234,
-0.0184812117,
-0.0380753428,
-0.0287340768,
-0.0238857735,
-0.0253716409,
-0.029829992,
-0.0285651535,
-0.0253960676,
0.0911510363,
0.033936955,
-0.0067062806,
-0.0353337936,
0.0648247972,
-0.0537653752,
-0.0020164144,
-0.0051841871,
0.0088102333,
-0.0515275113,
0.0545894094,
-0.0059123021,
-0.0288175233,
0.074552618,
0.014087799,
-0.0417228453,
-0.0270903241,
-0.0003473739,
-0.0340390615,
0.0693796203,
0.0028021038,
-0.0080429949,
0.0105115743,
-0.0229791682,
-0.0744884014,
0.0094079915,
0.0178352688,
0.0002751688,
0.0040961937,
-0.0491803102,
-0.0201065354,
0.0135753844,
-0.0494733378,
-0.0062528793,
-0.0485381447,
-0.0620255172,
0.0043893042,
0.0399738364,
0.0043841368,
-0.0004964719,
-0.0150494352,
0.0338536724,
-0.0131689925,
-0.0363668837,
-0.005014244,
-0.0192153454,
0.0283708833,
0.0355504379,
0.0192599278,
0.0198977273,
-0.010739848,
-0.0012678839,
0.0902790427,
-0.0385450833,
0.057085529,
-0.0226497389,
0.0253286213,
0.0280544516,
0.0440608785,
-0.0782544091,
0.0165184624,
0.0690297037,
-0.0395692475,
0.0084999204,
0.1152096689,
0.0313580781,
-0.0296584647,
0.0445024036,
-0.0420150496,
0.0468446799,
0.0072081732,
-0.0166971292,
-0.0373790227,
-0.0348510854,
0.0181086101,
-0.0491918772,
-0.0354904048,
-0.0236253385,
0.0072696381,
-0.0910963342,
0.043659661,
0.0088634398,
0.0075723082,
0.0375134498,
-0.026221253,
0.0356527902,
0.0061929808,
0.0410943814,
0.0292323735,
-0.0131592797,
0.0256586317,
0.0282056425,
-0.0629903227,
-0.0510959551,
0.0556949191,
-0.027141558,
0.047724206,
0.0236826763,
0.0513785295,
-0.0293632988,
-0.0522428863,
0.0736109093,
0.0282698814,
0.0253714155,
0.008482933,
-0.0005941419,
0.0244079232,
-0.0071251132,
-0.0908201858,
0.0220025089,
-0.031699378,
-0.01519226,
-0.0023133592,
0.101793088,
-0.0095056817,
-0.0518498309,
0.0081789857,
0.0372995101,
-0.0360987559,
0.0760549679,
0.0619780123,
-0.0710867867,
-0.0241176132,
-0.0011426281,
-0.0016842668,
0.0222436003,
-0.0786901414,
0.044719968,
0.0347907059,
-0.0512608215,
-0.0662643462,
-0.0532416999,
0.0210744236,
-0.0427726209,
-0.0073298742,
-0.0203865729,
0.01710218,
-0.0237299558,
0.0231175758,
0.0488778017,
0.0063251369,
-0.001847778,
-0.0558581427,
0.0059325565,
0.0495579727,
-0.0117318453,
-0.0375420898,
0.002683728,
-0.0373633318,
-0.0588261038,
0.036638923,
-0.0028331934,
0.0162351578,
-0.0353427865,
0.0092346715,
-0.0614489503,
-0.0440852307,
0.0643655881,
-0.0694601163,
0.0602144375,
-0.0085611856,
0.0133240828,
0.0479802601,
0.0541021228,
0.0203002449,
0.0376712903,
0.0310164299,
0.0371615775,
0.0002545416,
-0.032397639,
0.0530759282,
0.0397410877,
0.0678374916,
-0.0034721051,
0.0147624025,
-0.0281849056,
-0.0524615385,
-0.026580127,
-0.0018775163,
-0.0413439423,
-0.0401118211,
0.0390302241,
0.0346927196,
-0.0362247825,
-0.0261441488,
-0.0284591578,
0.0387915038,
-0.0079005603,
-0.0024082775,
-0.0172479246,
-0.0076360134,
0.0168666467,
0.0147895617,
-0.0197552163,
-0.0204585716,
-0.0527071506,
0.0083846403,
-0.0141973086,
0.0400454104,
0.0234418437,
0.0045122369,
0.0054705804,
-0.0030911753,
-0.028844839,
-0.0348700956,
0.052983474,
-0.0045497809,
0.0464547351,
-0.0287997108,
0.0672710314,
-0.0634222254,
0.0045831916,
-0.0421649851,
0.0367211811,
-0.0300208107,
-0.0059385565,
0.01617085,
0.002292183,
-0.0413559899,
-0.0314903483,
0.0591803715,
-0.0251647867,
-0.0186053477,
0.0169094708,
-0.0401647761,
-0.0068492065,
-0.0259282496,
-0.013337383,
-0.0280738454,
0.0079662856,
0.0401185825,
-0.072618708,
-0.0655112267,
-0.0507373437,
0.0041191885,
0.0020968369,
-0.0548623838,
0.0190034583,
0.0685689226,
-0.0329434201,
-0.0287868828,
-0.0184833743,
0.003344621,
0.002079583,
0.001639209,
-0.0533929653,
-6.469928988e-33,
-0.0093518207,
-0.0097734332,
-0.0069771912,
0.0102957459,
-0.0283539128,
-0.0272395331,
-0.0470676683,
0.0577485152,
-0.0005135676,
0.0655640885,
-0.0329288244,
0.0081106387,
0.0069077741,
0.0051899096,
0.0540313981,
0.0073141968,
0.0014736337,
-0.0230798051,
0.0065092309,
-0.0184135437,
0.0138559183,
-0.0045159506,
0.0872603804,
-0.0538007431,
0.0220833458,
0.0023239909,
0.0173168071,
-0.0051367432,
-0.0438945517,
0.0401423126,
-0.0096190246,
0.056720756,
0.0416571312,
0.0158730987,
-0.0071980692,
0.015836332,
0.0045000864,
-0.046088282,
0.0725750998,
0.0261064209,
-0.0208165403,
-0.0279740486,
0.0306158941,
-0.0383671299,
-0.0542813726,
0.006316823,
0.037597198,
-0.0077669271,
0.0221218355,
0.0306110866,
-0.0312846452,
0.0058625792,
-0.0184942018,
-0.0191097427,
-0.0090250485,
0.0068957293,
-0.0613902695,
-0.0392663367,
-0.0312891752,
0.0123826247,
-0.0067321043,
0.0362229645,
0.0370896868,
-0.0296586938,
0.029049525,
0.0765083358,
0.0536591224,
0.0166724194,
-0.0475630015,
0.0056694201,
0.0536728948,
0.0297515392,
0.0074186237,
0.0282836948,
0.0223506559,
-0.0149082923,
-0.0344393738,
-0.0475441851,
0.0584770329,
0.0431283712,
0.0490832776,
0.0226266868,
-0.0113023911,
-0.0523071624,
-0.0215438493,
-0.019520659,
-0.0352090783,
-0.040838629,
0.032015916,
-0.0593559295,
0.0378208309,
-0.0525256097,
0.0091025252,
-0.0148894228,
-0.0130058639,
-0.0236307178,
-0.0703245029,
0.0413362421,
0.0133770742,
0.0508232564,
-0.0571616814,
-0.0010971283,
-0.0203256309,
0.029040968,
0.0328551084,
0.0328490026,
0.0229871497,
-0.0037314203,
-0.0139301261,
-0.0155781489,
-0.0480326749,
-0.0383626521,
-0.0032201693,
-0.0287995674,
0.0449342206,
0.0189066939,
-0.0259507596,
-0.0102239819,
-0.0136986431,
0.0014757385,
-0.0599364042,
-0.0110694226,
-0.0217175316,
0.0139788585,
-0.0207431801,
-0.0224022828,
-0.030836679,
-0.0193017535,
0.0637406185,
-0.0136049474,
-0.0237599164,
-0.0018501639,
2.865e-7,
0.0425515547,
0.0819049329,
-0.0440101922,
0.0099215554,
0.043301709,
0.0248944983,
-0.0252322536,
-0.000388559,
0.0394749194,
-0.0057122526,
-0.0212366972,
0.0298768841,
0.0536966883,
0.0134894941,
-0.083183907,
0.0203687232,
-0.0784252733,
0.000873189,
-0.0102155907,
0.0106321964,
0.0678770244,
0.032127995,
0.0273920391,
0.0039481129,
-0.0156617425,
-0.0503873937,
0.0691324025,
-0.0466262437,
-0.0264438298,
0.0146143399,
0.0213958416,
-0.0038167511,
0.0414462909,
0.0484542102,
0.0394559279,
-0.0216089655,
0.026145963,
0.0664231926,
0.0086995512,
0.0429367572,
0.0046713464,
0.0021917468,
-0.0067242975,
-0.0842146352,
0.0666114986,
-0.1057453752,
-0.0713970438,
0.0193327256,
-0.0060948394,
-0.0343759134,
0.0263032243,
-0.0004107344,
-0.0379804336,
0.0180427916,
0.0399334915,
-0.0178935565,
-0.0215176195,
-0.0377188399,
-0.0262549017,
0.03194521,
-0.0454577319,
-0.0583228245,
-0.0248389281,
0.0137397088,
0.0214681514,
-0.0352110751,
-0.0121209882,
2.416326673e-34,
0.0237552766,
0.0106579568,
0.0753913298,
-0.0149653135,
0.0613017939,
0.0206118673,
0.0602786876,
0.0257261936,
0.0232264437,
-0.0493580624,
-0.0204212349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11115v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11115v1 | Text Grafting: Near-Distribution Weak Supervision for Minority Classes in Text Classification | 2024-06-17T00:23:08 | 2024-06-17T00:23:08 | Letian Peng, Yi Gu, Chengyu Dong, Zihan Wang, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL | For extremely weak-supervised text classification, pioneer research generates
pseudo labels by mining texts similar to the class names from the raw corpus,
which may end up with very limited or even no samples for the minority classes.
Recent works have started to generate the relevant texts by prompting LLMs
using the class names or definitions; however, there is a high risk that LLMs
cannot generate in-distribution (i.e., similar to the corpus where the text
classifier will be applied) data, leading to ungeneralizable classifiers. In
this paper, we combine the advantages of these two approaches and propose to
bridge the gap via a novel framework, \emph{text grafting}, which aims to
obtain clean and near-distribution weak supervision for minority classes.
Specifically, we first use LLM-based logits to mine masked templates from the
raw corpus, which have a high potential for data synthesis into the target
minority class. Then, the templates are filled by state-of-the-art LLMs to
synthesize near-distribution texts falling into minority classes. Text grafting
shows significant improvement over direct mining or synthesis on minority
classes. We also use analysis and case studies to comprehend the property of
text grafting. | [
0.0267965198,
0.0111423247,
0.0107901376,
0.0172315259,
-0.0179574359,
0.0213913415,
-0.0010796516,
0.0511072241,
0.0184785146,
-0.0429265685,
-0.019011436,
-0.0304050092,
-0.0370286591,
-0.0182468779,
0.0043617701,
-0.0192555208,
-0.0224265363,
0.0000356548,
-0.0434163064,
-0.0063535324,
-0.0135301417,
0.0034082395,
0.0381217822,
-0.0032990507,
-0.0098683927,
0.0006499882,
0.0140578812,
-0.006513597,
0.0094557665,
0.0047182725,
0.049742125,
0.0090969829,
-0.0119792586,
0.0323361456,
0.0000018775,
-0.0398529544,
-0.0452517197,
0.0078813415,
-0.0056926813,
-0.0284429733,
0.0615770891,
-0.047055319,
0.0038518133,
0.0187103264,
-0.0289407913,
-0.006406696,
0.016018739,
0.0784511194,
0.0341969281,
0.0434775278,
-0.0121830208,
-0.0031383778,
-0.0320407897,
-0.0024653478,
0.0496688299,
0.0007528214,
0.0389573872,
-0.0102640055,
0.0090580117,
0.0187474433,
0.0125904083,
0.0257740058,
0.0219284091,
-0.0067195999,
0.0351966135,
0.0458943434,
-0.0822524875,
-0.0059199263,
0.019509092,
0.0351475216,
-0.0336877406,
-0.0625816062,
0.0371374674,
-0.0168290883,
0.0250292066,
-0.0035235302,
-0.0209134649,
0.0309313741,
-0.0181753114,
0.0488280877,
0.0349983461,
0.0178558212,
0.0229926463,
0.0057072667,
0.0115481326,
0.0094303731,
-0.0189597346,
-0.0381453149,
-0.004438126,
0.0367982276,
-0.0490355603,
-0.0047979145,
0.0034275081,
0.0079794032,
0.043151591,
-0.0043782177,
-0.0676578358,
-0.0506931245,
0.038960956,
0.0072408132,
-0.0129629131,
-0.0097988835,
-0.040875379,
0.0455879457,
-0.0441909693,
-0.0685526729,
0.0203790683,
0.0606250018,
-0.0162430592,
-0.0345087014,
-0.050285928,
-0.0136175221,
0.0029994459,
0.0632268861,
-0.0101336939,
0.0560806617,
-0.0418023169,
0.0184490215,
-0.0207010917,
0.0067836088,
-0.0055745174,
-0.005703507,
-0.0399611965,
0.0246913172,
0.0011917338,
-0.0622945651,
0.0139329517,
0.0206658579,
-0.0385557003,
-0.0101086712,
-0.0010766231,
0.0668257847,
0.0147227105,
-0.0362289101,
0.0284515973,
0.0226714443,
-0.0258827228,
-0.0679096058,
-0.0912119895,
-0.0167063531,
-0.0455230996,
-0.0147954989,
-0.0061133276,
-0.0517570078,
-0.0169993732,
-0.0055724005,
0.0082463631,
0.0107532497,
0.0005737809,
-0.0059246067,
-0.0156292897,
0.0669970065,
-0.0204603747,
-0.0127133736,
0.0237058811,
0.0297837574,
0.0064803911,
0.037846107,
-0.0068250564,
0.0181862358,
0.0384262577,
-0.0089006824,
0.0633242577,
0.0192276333,
0.0268270597,
0.0430616923,
-0.0103900423,
-0.0382712781,
0.03730556,
-0.0599150322,
0.0282004513,
0.0075359247,
0.01251511,
-0.025925722,
0.0372611843,
0.0063103852,
0.0154252807,
0.0291800201,
0.0024072274,
-0.0017648791,
-0.0320416018,
0.0305520184,
0.0062046181,
-0.0172215365,
-0.0431209467,
-0.0263157357,
-0.0312626734,
0.0229738653,
-0.0297026429,
-0.0598452911,
-0.0088085635,
-0.0119001651,
-0.0215713549,
-0.011439885,
0.0785684884,
0.0356726237,
0.0256321244,
0.0157449879,
0.0416547507,
-0.0164345168,
0.0270856712,
-0.0420617498,
0.0173315201,
-0.0163385086,
0.0229127891,
-0.104300037,
0.0050766743,
-0.0078095724,
0.02232714,
0.0264655724,
-0.0164509416,
-0.0057078991,
0.0077051884,
-0.0664775893,
-0.028690435,
0.0250359103,
0.0317004733,
0.0188471992,
-0.0338837728,
0.0092730178,
0.0240340084,
-0.0662181601,
-0.0444812924,
0.0682830587,
0.0196348391,
-0.0361181051,
0.0540640168,
0.0231775306,
0.0122888759,
0.0086621791,
-0.0180021394,
-0.0355061255,
0.036551211,
-0.0400597714,
-0.0908729434,
-0.0334727429,
-0.0047914488,
-0.047129903,
0.0227351971,
-0.0687422752,
-0.0084601259,
0.0131223258,
-0.0345583297,
-0.0532312728,
-0.00229895,
0.0016181117,
0.0514067151,
-0.049340006,
0.0257558804,
0.0247660484,
0.0036795321,
-0.058683116,
0.0809360296,
0.0199401509,
0.0555725135,
0.0197910834,
-0.0687298253,
0.0223860685,
0.0019115261,
0.0073512155,
0.0234094299,
-0.0300161112,
0.0351780877,
0.0402848162,
0.0362544581,
-0.0099862516,
-0.0549392067,
-0.0329837911,
-0.0121791419,
-0.0280466545,
0.0108649274,
0.0248978641,
-0.0003119691,
-0.013712625,
-0.0027975535,
-0.0353766903,
-0.0589862317,
-0.0265421439,
-0.0099443449,
0.0383320302,
0.0071493103,
0.0190892331,
0.0493298434,
0.0169116165,
0.0109076435,
0.0224335827,
0.0059897504,
-0.0259403121,
-0.0558654815,
0.0494798906,
0.019919727,
0.0029458257,
-0.0134207839,
-0.0003808342,
-0.0202030595,
0.0035181148,
0.0288589709,
-0.006328796,
-0.0019247491,
0.0065705436,
0.0563088544,
0.0245594624,
-0.0404892676,
-0.0110674184,
-0.0244566221,
0.0113164354,
0.0064292788,
-0.0262009799,
0.0180391669,
0.0194285475,
0.0171096418,
-0.0466883555,
-0.0527072512,
-0.0392354429,
-0.009111681,
0.0026159275,
-0.0309949797,
0.0368162468,
-0.0112807974,
-0.0109788105,
0.0010542796,
-0.0275603738,
0.0418490022,
-0.0277827103,
0.0068250108,
-0.0309797693,
-0.0818100274,
-0.0592317842,
-0.0032921843,
0.0089132981,
-0.0120444,
0.0368317999,
-0.0130115598,
-0.0472551882,
0.0167512372,
0.0045020706,
-0.0156772174,
0.0162116252,
-0.0104428958,
0.0168945976,
-0.0210734587,
-0.0246961452,
-0.0280868467,
-0.1057170182,
0.0396891907,
0.0086604916,
0.0179675166,
0.009723464,
-0.0288985856,
0.020264728,
-0.0126981931,
0.0673362613,
0.0158282965,
-0.0334749185,
-0.017974887,
0.0332361236,
0.0066227964,
-0.035631936,
-0.0291434862,
-0.0315644518,
-0.0173342675,
0.0511097163,
0.0412170328,
0.0108806286,
0.0110725202,
-0.0112571465,
0.022906946,
0.004023246,
-0.0171401706,
-0.0338219106,
0.0082856994,
0.0038198831,
0.0042410656,
0.0716978461,
0.0340170003,
-0.0585609041,
-0.0062418198,
-0.0078576747,
0.0668588653,
0.0342939869,
-0.0094610164,
-0.0853413865,
-0.0030551257,
0.0236468948,
0.0720994473,
-0.0423204191,
-0.0315071903,
0.0218481869,
-0.0960706025,
0.0338544473,
0.0339133218,
-0.0365249999,
-0.006879678,
-0.0472956523,
-0.0069060861,
-0.0028894765,
-0.0460918248,
-0.0468481928,
0.0035431325,
0.0072267298,
0.047979638,
-0.037341889,
-0.0638350025,
-0.0162256174,
-0.0074482579,
0.0257259719,
-0.0088007022,
0.0306730121,
-0.0298196226,
-0.0103415782,
0.0888747424,
-0.0834853649,
-0.0468062125,
-0.0283974931,
0.0917065069,
-0.01003135,
-0.0256985296,
0.0110941054,
0.0648675412,
-0.04177415,
-0.0102074388,
0.0263107568,
0.083634764,
-0.0413207747,
-0.0356316753,
-0.032387089,
-0.0484930202,
0.0480190106,
0.0589366704,
0.0098402379,
-0.0535729751,
0.0050405315,
0.0009222054,
0.0129767181,
0.0259591695,
-0.0222045239,
0.0733241886,
-0.0672558025,
-0.0478987806,
-0.0466150679,
-0.0101712123,
0.0219639353,
0.0905412734,
0.011756653,
0.0064765369,
-0.0327026919,
-0.0425357968,
-0.0226660557,
0.0149822487,
-0.0655086413,
0.0004584642,
-0.0223384891,
-0.0448503047,
0.0524438918,
-0.0593494549,
-0.0183625165,
-0.022298567,
-0.0160773061,
-0.0410668887,
-0.0000878763,
-0.0082666427,
0.0231907889,
0.0280401912,
-0.0096743908,
-0.0591683164,
0.0766001344,
0.142705664,
0.0297335219,
-0.0031778403,
0.0161270443,
-0.0536735095,
-0.023083454,
0.0031286513,
-0.0515250005,
0.0426929072,
0.0715386569,
-0.0319755785,
-0.0565004274,
0.0448263809,
0.0160282794,
0.0216252469,
0.0321441405,
-0.0336962938,
-0.0072085243,
-0.018848205,
0.0367323831,
0.0460510962,
-0.0336387642,
-0.0183747821,
0.0145603418,
0.038224183,
0.0011854206,
-0.0366806723,
0.0391423218,
-0.0203246865,
0.1034824103,
-0.0604966991,
0.0018292952,
-0.0020704241,
0.0225810781,
-0.0014149436,
-0.0076633315,
-0.0006759432,
0.0155281536,
0.0451903194,
0.0503652282,
0.0146332951,
0.0012369482,
0.0467614159,
0.0415714793,
-0.0131943161,
-0.0141731109,
-0.0852138922,
0.0561295748,
-0.0337999575,
0.027725419,
0.0322564542,
-0.05534219,
-0.003816684,
-0.0324609354,
-0.0394835211,
-0.0078380257,
0.0225834139,
0.0454288162,
-0.009651768,
0.0298992731,
0.0007047774,
-0.0336691029,
0.0276379213,
0.0465377159,
0.0412930287,
0.0441832952,
-0.0170847196,
-0.0422813781,
-0.0491738394,
0.0054560942,
0.0787854791,
0.0108709857,
0.0214980599,
-0.017459685,
-0.0598299876,
-0.0361498669,
0.0368586518,
-0.0303139351,
-0.0089249788,
0.0066567212,
0.0024986765,
0.0364750363,
-0.0034739405,
0.0146268476,
-0.0308658853,
0.0043305289,
0.0635629967,
0.0022230048,
0.0198162943,
-6.384245736e-33,
0.0080678593,
-0.0625874177,
-0.050988242,
0.0248830561,
0.0305981711,
0.0164974984,
0.0427712351,
-0.029063113,
0.0601944067,
-0.0052571688,
-0.0230409857,
0.0043720282,
0.0144499922,
0.0462755077,
-0.0137335472,
-0.0124911442,
0.0345419049,
0.022879282,
-0.0308399443,
0.0307858828,
0.0225236006,
0.0246683452,
0.0265644081,
-0.1392144263,
0.0415128842,
-0.0021466068,
-0.010163052,
-0.0260072686,
-0.0018032664,
0.0205037631,
-0.0052456334,
0.058361277,
0.0540704727,
-0.0119566359,
0.0087712985,
0.0072512268,
-0.0369513854,
-0.0255867802,
-0.037388172,
-0.004812934,
0.0182037894,
-0.0357502475,
0.039088998,
0.0094937682,
0.0050994768,
0.0163600426,
0.0762881711,
-0.047006119,
-0.0100372648,
-0.0631785393,
0.0026343665,
0.0508983955,
-0.0019467331,
0.014312733,
0.0237935018,
0.0097796796,
0.0237798486,
0.0484670103,
-0.0492705926,
-0.0028095304,
0.0191554911,
0.0174124707,
0.0014871807,
0.0446857139,
-0.0210293159,
0.0478966609,
-0.0104916301,
0.0503443703,
-0.0177174378,
-0.0491588451,
0.022919558,
0.009268946,
0.0087323841,
0.0535670221,
0.0449219495,
-0.0248359982,
-0.0520806909,
0.0626294613,
0.0222593565,
-0.0689593032,
0.01801656,
0.024403384,
-0.0540589914,
-0.0426837914,
-0.012351336,
-0.0407354347,
-0.0134965219,
0.0444594026,
0.001145188,
0.0384491645,
-0.0704663768,
0.0230514351,
-0.017476676,
-0.0099531543,
-0.0766384229,
-0.0307983253,
0.0016461689,
0.0245650541,
-0.0228781123,
-0.0604839511,
-0.0345315337,
-0.0624887832,
0.0565796793,
0.0053103678,
0.0258040819,
-0.0181270055,
0.0907596722,
0.0246394109,
-0.0933421627,
0.0030955116,
-0.0014787125,
0.0450466983,
0.0172686782,
0.0393943712,
-0.0009652135,
-0.0120275505,
0.0136552621,
0.0316805355,
0.0553944744,
0.0063627162,
-0.0014490875,
0.0286396649,
-0.0215831883,
-0.0109829586,
-0.014506299,
0.0020639582,
0.0527291782,
0.0077636521,
0.0852008611,
-0.0544973426,
0.0113683427,
-0.0813989043,
2.616e-7,
0.0294906348,
-0.0185566843,
-0.0163400732,
-0.0641887933,
-0.0134414695,
0.0650266632,
-0.024429936,
0.0174624976,
-0.0356372967,
-0.0548466742,
0.0098623196,
-0.0284409709,
0.0409874506,
0.0131036872,
-0.0973822847,
0.0351506472,
-0.0085259182,
-0.039215859,
-0.0284613241,
0.0133559164,
0.0478905328,
0.0914799944,
0.0350526795,
-0.051636599,
-0.0068744044,
-0.066912137,
0.0249159373,
-0.0154760471,
-0.0007195141,
0.0188870672,
0.0654497966,
0.0338652097,
0.0064429813,
0.0277236868,
-0.012173201,
0.0030098062,
0.0250264611,
0.0370256491,
-0.0129279466,
0.0444831327,
-0.0002803554,
0.0272092633,
0.003403574,
0.0181565862,
0.0621537752,
-0.0368973613,
-0.0055275536,
-0.0309909545,
-0.0061485502,
-0.0234577786,
0.0074629555,
-0.0093407547,
0.0003948827,
0.0352238528,
0.0022154427,
0.0043915785,
-0.0276984107,
-0.0880559012,
0.0113236178,
0.0025097791,
-0.0449654944,
-0.0102726845,
0.0050136158,
0.0946850702,
0.0236183759,
-0.0657535195,
0.0111498153,
2.808189423e-34,
0.033859212,
0.0107773561,
-0.0277850218,
0.0098716691,
-0.0041096932,
-0.0011518609,
0.0342857987,
0.0215009879,
-0.0029363979,
-0.0229903813,
0.0250895955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11109v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11109v2 | Investigating Annotator Bias in Large Language Models for Hate Speech Detection | 2024-06-17T00:18:31 | 2024-06-18T06:21:16 | Amit Das, Zheng Zhang, Fatemeh Jamshidi, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha, Nilanjana Raychawdhary, Mary Sandage, Lauramarie Pope, Gerry Dozier, Cheryl Seals | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Data annotation, the practice of assigning descriptive labels to raw data, is
pivotal in optimizing the performance of machine learning models. However, it
is a resource-intensive process susceptible to biases introduced by annotators.
The emergence of sophisticated Large Language Models (LLMs), like ChatGPT
presents a unique opportunity to modernize and streamline this complex
procedure. While existing research extensively evaluates the efficacy of LLMs,
as annotators, this paper delves into the biases present in LLMs, specifically
GPT 3.5 and GPT 4o when annotating hate speech data. Our research contributes
to understanding biases in four key categories: gender, race, religion, and
disability. Specifically targeting highly vulnerable groups within these
categories, we analyze annotator biases. Furthermore, we conduct a
comprehensive examination of potential factors contributing to these biases by
scrutinizing the annotated data. We introduce our custom hate speech detection
dataset, HateSpeechCorpus, to conduct this research. Additionally, we perform
the same experiments on the ETHOS (Mollas et al., 2022) dataset also for
comparative analysis. This paper serves as a crucial resource, guiding
researchers and practitioners in harnessing the potential of LLMs for
dataannotation, thereby fostering advancements in this critical field. The
HateSpeechCorpus dataset is available here:
https://github.com/AmitDasRup123/HateSpeechCorpus | [
0.0358194597,
0.0630355403,
-0.0388304181,
0.0432282463,
0.0140803754,
0.0672787949,
0.0530896671,
-0.0021710934,
0.0218408648,
-0.0961689129,
-0.0192036219,
-0.0056468942,
0.0020523886,
-0.0084702261,
-0.0062802113,
-0.0485068001,
0.0423363224,
0.0318806879,
0.0453710258,
-0.0145627102,
0.0608934127,
0.0148209669,
0.0125736678,
0.0588566549,
-0.0594173372,
0.0113719609,
0.0632644519,
-0.0071599344,
0.0204942767,
-0.018680891,
0.0430692919,
0.0665615499,
0.0018385298,
0.0955317765,
0.0000018337,
-0.0442292802,
0.0169113353,
0.0231346488,
-0.0107639125,
-0.0243337732,
0.0616924688,
-0.0360593423,
-0.0193439703,
0.0294244327,
-0.0156983808,
-0.0097022103,
0.0738511086,
0.0374869518,
0.059059836,
0.0464915186,
-0.0083578276,
-0.0279577449,
0.0028554529,
0.0081295623,
0.0134428898,
0.026482217,
0.0526559651,
-0.015444085,
-0.0667315274,
-0.0000332652,
-0.0135249048,
0.0090776514,
0.0156098874,
0.0435467325,
0.0087124817,
-0.020279808,
-0.0643800497,
-0.0306488536,
0.0172067769,
0.032473512,
-0.0108615188,
0.0039717755,
0.0041753696,
0.0031714181,
-0.0085058156,
-0.0265405606,
-0.018822955,
0.0091551226,
-0.0129075367,
0.0075499355,
-0.0055228416,
0.0230037235,
0.0472437926,
0.0551927797,
0.0262030084,
0.051668901,
-0.0101278145,
-0.0388058424,
0.0114548421,
-0.0047419253,
-0.0199709516,
-0.0093826875,
0.0084077418,
-0.0276197009,
0.0104652923,
0.0067042173,
-0.0387522317,
-0.0332750194,
0.017277617,
-0.0864375234,
0.0118923457,
0.043945536,
-0.0385446213,
-0.0034824363,
0.0026005888,
0.0352778211,
0.0118831536,
0.0182951484,
0.0054919771,
-0.0032807498,
-0.0082916971,
0.0062102512,
0.0096290531,
-0.024592828,
0.0022003527,
0.0605636127,
-0.0558683984,
-0.0011310244,
-0.0491335541,
-0.0196429733,
-0.0145004503,
-0.0233329367,
-0.0123729352,
0.0180562492,
-0.0199227873,
-0.0101771615,
-0.0263197701,
0.0192137975,
-0.0420241579,
-0.0994985327,
0.0209824443,
0.0493987538,
-0.0306623578,
-0.0418375358,
0.0175548419,
0.0526345,
0.0466358811,
-0.0229998492,
-0.0316705331,
-0.0171639081,
-0.0286558475,
-0.0553609468,
-0.0099546565,
-0.0514800884,
0.0188959595,
0.0168128461,
-0.0159262866,
-0.062562786,
0.0004993723,
0.0260303114,
-0.0483689345,
0.0902059674,
-0.0055445991,
-0.0265376009,
0.0544289798,
0.0251448639,
-0.0220260415,
0.0694396123,
0.0402904116,
0.0097955968,
0.0391695201,
-0.0243146159,
0.0096220644,
0.0653856397,
0.0290086661,
0.0316468701,
-0.0352986678,
0.0124805802,
-0.032588806,
-0.0288777668,
0.0357716195,
0.0335967429,
0.0011136894,
-0.0462279171,
0.0421205349,
0.0922880098,
-0.0313399509,
0.0207262095,
0.0266553722,
0.0210637618,
-0.0128955226,
-0.0361071788,
-0.0688834786,
-0.0372511558,
-0.0239663646,
-0.0566662401,
0.0218661856,
0.0477427058,
-0.0115404166,
-0.0431047902,
-0.0543957502,
0.0068192426,
0.0521525629,
-0.0109216738,
0.0056692534,
0.0013414135,
0.0197858792,
0.0052251904,
0.0450836793,
-0.0165963974,
-0.0016486722,
-0.0641875416,
-0.0039537637,
0.0519474447,
-0.0090069948,
-0.0128006423,
0.0018282398,
-0.0649692789,
-0.0184572507,
0.0366363898,
0.0125138955,
0.0055792839,
-0.0371923931,
-0.0399397984,
-0.0287260991,
0.0458005331,
0.0287414137,
0.0232147779,
0.0637746006,
-0.0008310265,
0.0235265791,
-0.0043749786,
-0.0734026805,
0.0357429273,
0.0333201177,
-0.0382692218,
-0.0125385458,
-0.0031878373,
0.0620655008,
0.0214642771,
-0.0311946943,
-0.0496975482,
-0.031221848,
0.0078972047,
-0.004599377,
0.012137224,
-0.0246216971,
-0.0034103922,
0.0112157101,
-0.0486400463,
-0.0336111784,
0.0515821129,
-0.0072772955,
0.0150457509,
0.0397261418,
-0.033964321,
-0.0106197083,
-0.0242364723,
-0.03454943,
-0.0501545779,
0.0456918515,
-0.0331083201,
0.0476612784,
-0.0164070539,
-0.0123604629,
0.0154539607,
-0.0376696773,
0.0406600647,
0.0041502942,
-0.0640950799,
-0.0223579332,
-0.0049424702,
0.0384998992,
0.0048693772,
-0.011837895,
-0.0037906962,
0.0182662141,
-0.1005418375,
0.0014982657,
-0.0319597237,
-0.0271578357,
-0.0131997429,
0.0008892374,
-0.0325225443,
-0.0069334381,
-0.0118222041,
-0.0525640883,
0.0385873429,
0.0486723483,
-0.0154498722,
-0.0498277396,
-0.0273759589,
-0.0240772534,
-0.0251795948,
-0.0253858026,
0.0189411175,
0.0357897542,
-0.0793270916,
0.0212703887,
-0.0292671025,
-0.0331964977,
0.0068910122,
-0.0164346993,
-0.0197822955,
0.0304226391,
0.0604841523,
-0.0173625667,
0.0250478759,
0.0367207341,
0.0821972638,
0.0329531766,
-0.0020521639,
-0.0219582189,
-0.0100186076,
-0.013923794,
0.0155291464,
-0.0165559482,
-0.0782948956,
-0.0202443115,
0.0757197812,
0.0319702774,
-0.0234163553,
-0.0673746839,
0.0249917638,
-0.0809186548,
-0.0366233587,
-0.032959234,
-0.0506117158,
-0.036842443,
-0.0157584883,
-0.0281835943,
-0.0836087689,
0.0511416234,
-0.0061154957,
0.0220167171,
-0.0253018942,
-0.0158973001,
-0.03259442,
0.0430454947,
0.0180709623,
0.0276447553,
-0.0275159571,
0.0075407638,
0.0173782501,
-0.0031035859,
0.0273211747,
-0.0352619402,
-0.0026422516,
-0.0121154832,
0.0224108361,
-0.0071181455,
-0.0298989303,
-0.0530037284,
-0.0465719998,
-0.0507979542,
-0.0234993342,
0.0258526057,
-0.0152238077,
-0.01253286,
0.0343328044,
0.0189454593,
0.0186909698,
0.0003758545,
0.0134626124,
0.0228075124,
-0.0577133633,
0.0012803753,
-0.0125612505,
0.0234891213,
0.0060995035,
-0.0381788798,
0.0362575501,
-0.0076639643,
0.0300670117,
0.0037356564,
0.0101731969,
0.0322488844,
0.0198144577,
-0.005050641,
-0.0143609531,
0.0267928652,
-0.029177554,
0.0229267031,
0.0951829329,
0.0152451964,
-0.0421779528,
0.0024459851,
0.009109892,
0.0330742821,
0.0143211652,
-0.0275090709,
-0.1158407554,
-0.004848511,
-0.0005843411,
0.0436220095,
-0.0961038694,
-0.0468505397,
0.0017922459,
-0.0715181306,
0.0363158695,
-0.0099731348,
-0.0718318,
-0.005868284,
-0.0229257531,
0.0282527115,
-0.0330128111,
0.0611477159,
-0.0459259525,
0.0299596898,
-0.0037924068,
0.0480950326,
-0.1033904403,
-0.0371180885,
0.0188185014,
-0.0261298344,
0.0676012859,
0.0346211493,
0.0239508282,
-0.0356774926,
0.0065866071,
0.0591237694,
0.00258231,
-0.0355392694,
-0.0479654782,
0.0523803979,
-0.0227090381,
-0.0472281575,
-0.0211125519,
0.0568150952,
-0.0006087805,
0.0145225823,
0.0207091719,
0.0260173343,
0.0235445034,
0.0242209584,
-0.045745004,
0.0136291161,
-0.0083581917,
0.0953408629,
0.0196519233,
-0.0462766849,
0.0250007603,
-0.0776662827,
-0.0151468134,
0.0121079674,
-0.1086937636,
0.0212792568,
-0.0338330269,
-0.0404979922,
-0.0030351987,
-0.0447057597,
0.0409341119,
-0.0204343386,
0.0276079606,
-0.0059212632,
-0.0251005962,
0.0065524322,
-0.0479583777,
0.0410014763,
-0.0104517611,
0.0323822089,
0.0063014925,
-0.0223047026,
-0.0266940966,
-0.0055902,
-0.0439155623,
0.0396277271,
-0.0506599024,
-0.0287614241,
0.0957234576,
0.0349209048,
0.0173195694,
0.0246790014,
0.0061118631,
-0.0890454575,
0.041819334,
0.063717328,
0.0016583961,
0.0016995522,
0.0278926194,
-0.0112828063,
0.0002309775,
0.0072091022,
-0.0061506559,
0.0659565553,
0.0331796817,
-0.0504665114,
-0.0588337742,
0.0133145591,
-0.0149297239,
0.0039987881,
0.0561856814,
-0.0225701164,
-0.0474688187,
-0.0381209292,
-0.0193166807,
0.0048785349,
-0.0579333194,
-0.0214517768,
-0.0112062423,
0.0077628717,
-0.0017087727,
-0.06413728,
-0.030490851,
-0.0439146347,
0.0094261048,
-0.0397781543,
0.0493639,
0.0420908704,
0.0272687934,
0.0038644727,
0.0063031497,
-0.0144135915,
0.0509343632,
0.0049087307,
0.0003983132,
0.0264090449,
0.010055596,
0.0128403883,
0.01431455,
0.0407378338,
-0.0145194829,
0.0207619052,
-0.0189741664,
-0.0454838425,
0.0095663089,
-0.0270131025,
-0.014751642,
0.0365274735,
0.0023388045,
-0.022624597,
-0.0195209123,
-0.0253022835,
0.0092557613,
-0.0148079488,
0.024442235,
0.015916938,
-0.0419710614,
0.0155994911,
0.028400166,
0.03967252,
0.0547903702,
0.0207636729,
-0.0646340549,
-0.0236833859,
-0.0071697501,
0.0170311555,
-0.0017748721,
0.002826253,
0.0100479675,
-0.0674913675,
-0.0430100821,
-0.0301041789,
-0.0455704443,
0.0302445255,
-0.0043878043,
0.0078353183,
0.0561740287,
-0.046042826,
-0.0243342966,
0.0014989671,
-0.0117710037,
-0.0089080995,
-0.0485492162,
0.0157743301,
-5.634159117e-33,
-0.0215764549,
-0.0339484215,
-0.0158322733,
-0.0002766117,
0.0065150568,
-0.0063373614,
0.0511697717,
0.0184345972,
-0.0053758002,
0.0166210923,
0.02564965,
0.0185135454,
0.0188700296,
0.0066986554,
0.011036355,
-0.0436213501,
0.0298140161,
-0.0068462589,
-0.0184866227,
-0.0100724604,
0.0087871235,
-0.008631533,
0.0342707783,
-0.0824467242,
0.08904697,
-0.0128638111,
-0.0241133496,
0.0072704572,
0.0032992084,
0.0746860355,
-0.035792321,
0.0938531905,
0.0273123588,
-0.0078475149,
0.0087402072,
0.0563113056,
-0.0310492199,
0.0064302627,
0.0308090709,
0.0487603024,
0.0311781075,
-0.0182685181,
0.0243821405,
0.0043078824,
-0.0746735856,
-0.0063349563,
0.0455786362,
-0.047607664,
0.0237667635,
-0.0034146346,
-0.0671293065,
0.0615295134,
-0.029749861,
0.0171324406,
0.0085638752,
0.0141242994,
0.0238898061,
0.0178571194,
-0.0428515077,
0.0045566447,
0.0076567857,
-0.0132816974,
0.0107587157,
0.0299906898,
0.0133936061,
0.0623832271,
0.0405522585,
0.0270033181,
-0.0141916163,
-0.0279428642,
0.0337272696,
-0.0021015136,
0.0399658866,
0.0688510463,
0.022096172,
-0.0320356116,
-0.0388875529,
-0.0124344677,
0.043816898,
-0.0151155666,
0.036694169,
-0.0355397612,
-0.0939591825,
-0.0496623889,
-0.0426703803,
-0.0624875836,
-0.0167857725,
-0.0148630263,
0.0349360369,
-0.0136724133,
-0.0247027222,
0.0420115516,
0.0228478983,
-0.0197521411,
-0.0076366011,
0.0139001021,
-0.0234652366,
-0.0103744408,
0.0197118446,
0.0374149941,
-0.042066019,
0.0025863629,
0.0103239343,
-0.0079654455,
0.0518040732,
-0.0177482944,
0.0782430992,
0.0182725936,
-0.079814814,
0.0129058287,
0.0043466268,
0.0602404848,
-0.0371190943,
0.0274528656,
0.0345344394,
0.0287420414,
0.0048727933,
-0.0109507432,
0.0459366925,
0.0037080224,
-0.0192639269,
-0.0031087287,
-0.0493519232,
-0.0112668928,
0.0094038406,
-0.0073960195,
0.0311081428,
-0.0086049354,
0.0308930241,
-0.0780253634,
0.0273566525,
-0.0619196258,
2.43e-7,
0.0126234898,
0.0558213815,
-0.0119413687,
-0.0092991674,
0.019214645,
0.0291227531,
0.051275868,
0.0183094703,
0.0258835535,
0.0060208603,
-0.0233870037,
0.0550231971,
0.0225567464,
0.0535685942,
-0.007902585,
-0.0187088996,
-0.0794961229,
0.0164473038,
-0.0503321849,
0.0193237234,
-0.016743673,
0.1068628207,
0.0566022731,
-0.029453611,
-0.0204828549,
-0.0054693534,
0.0223160088,
-0.0668737218,
-0.0189739149,
0.0122405533,
0.0732026771,
0.0421914868,
0.039789129,
0.0260684621,
0.0118009113,
0.0187544711,
0.0310017951,
0.049292177,
0.0273515955,
0.0211866796,
-0.0144024855,
0.0024753204,
-0.023242075,
-0.0625925809,
0.0541628674,
0.010134412,
-0.0307248216,
-0.064279303,
-0.016033845,
-0.0226329453,
0.0451322012,
-0.0136666559,
0.0021958896,
-0.0146681601,
0.0372670256,
-0.0266802069,
-0.0027305498,
-0.0663102046,
-0.0152419051,
-0.0163010508,
-0.0401414037,
-0.063441202,
-0.0188863259,
0.0029126718,
0.0247409474,
0.0217767004,
0.0421555489,
1.997351787e-34,
0.0355051346,
-0.0107153021,
0.0096428003,
-0.0310077835,
0.0304232538,
0.0452209488,
0.0286844149,
-0.0071872748,
0.0295361783,
-0.0203508642,
0.0056968825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11107v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11107v1 | Exploring Safety-Utility Trade-Offs in Personalized Language Models | 2024-06-17T00:17:11 | 2024-06-17T00:17:11 | Anvesh Rao Vijjini, Somnath Basu Roy Chowdhury, Snigdha Chaturvedi | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) become increasingly integrated into daily
applications, it is essential to ensure they operate fairly across diverse user
demographics. In this work, we show that LLMs suffer from personalization bias,
where their performance is impacted when they are personalized to a user's
identity. We quantify personalization bias by evaluating the performance of
LLMs along two axes - safety and utility. We measure safety by examining how
benign LLM responses are to unsafe prompts with and without personalization. We
measure utility by evaluating the LLM's performance on various tasks, including
general knowledge, mathematical abilities, programming, and reasoning skills.
We find that various LLMs, ranging from open-source models like Llama (Touvron
et al., 2023) and Mistral (Jiang et al., 2023) to API-based ones like GPT-3.5
and GPT-4o (Ouyang et al., 2022), exhibit significant variance in performance
in terms of safety-utility trade-offs depending on the user's identity.
Finally, we discuss several strategies to mitigate personalization bias using
preference tuning and prompt-based defenses. | [
0.0260799062,
0.0685425177,
-0.0298690256,
0.036301598,
-0.0221676212,
-0.0157031082,
0.0532293692,
-0.0119520063,
0.0580362529,
-0.0052079763,
-0.0108482381,
-0.028279189,
-0.0044071358,
0.0023494416,
0.0163008999,
-0.0569452457,
0.0508644804,
-0.0750352666,
0.044043418,
-0.0298443586,
-0.0013255964,
0.0153077208,
-0.0016581111,
0.0651655719,
0.0352186747,
-0.0424545296,
0.0341938846,
-0.0129450634,
0.0050007585,
-0.033366181,
0.0218280964,
0.0647588894,
-0.0215544868,
0.0342512727,
0.0000023894,
-0.0715903491,
-0.0031527085,
0.0043946058,
-0.0355983116,
0.0361075923,
0.0632039085,
0.0615559556,
-0.0156617183,
0.057450261,
-0.0390577391,
0.0086667417,
0.0349940993,
-0.0236965753,
0.0313785858,
0.026033612,
0.0048583103,
0.0281276554,
0.0005340626,
-0.0098696528,
0.0171025153,
-0.0368962474,
0.0038095184,
-0.0601823218,
-0.005816468,
-0.0016844479,
0.0076179262,
0.026379697,
0.0031973657,
0.0071574915,
-0.0157964565,
0.0264857002,
-0.031130204,
-0.0129521871,
-0.0163815804,
0.0565406457,
-0.0163853765,
-0.0140582239,
0.023593314,
-0.0094981706,
0.026994098,
0.0207024552,
-0.0285480469,
0.0251763556,
-0.0243079122,
-0.0261170343,
0.0105787087,
0.0095587112,
0.0268432274,
0.0275665484,
0.0076413886,
0.1106503457,
0.020197548,
-0.0095685441,
-0.0095248651,
-0.0200823005,
-0.002115451,
-0.0745906308,
0.0379434302,
0.007197246,
-0.0397870168,
0.0018565094,
-0.0612623468,
-0.0297770966,
0.0212530661,
-0.0381367058,
0.0217880644,
0.0775594711,
0.0108591393,
0.0057099643,
0.0114442091,
0.0230617579,
0.0104528945,
0.0115499105,
0.0305004865,
0.0301799793,
-0.0065157595,
-0.0199337527,
-0.0096600335,
0.0222370028,
0.0071658138,
0.0522578731,
-0.0383190177,
0.0676497892,
0.0002391797,
0.0275591444,
-0.0069125672,
-0.0090349792,
-0.0088403588,
-0.0341023579,
-0.0390429869,
-0.0185359586,
-0.0440402739,
-0.0080730338,
0.008607612,
-0.0646517873,
0.0057042893,
-0.0137986327,
-0.0059556835,
-0.0426360779,
0.0013978621,
0.0871005878,
0.0149025125,
-0.018523626,
-0.0428472869,
-0.0719043761,
0.0082672471,
-0.0256300066,
-0.0405928157,
-0.0964136198,
0.0130083598,
0.05074054,
-0.0064775404,
-0.0847565606,
-0.01495363,
0.04645174,
-0.0359939411,
0.0294558443,
-0.0028299659,
0.0040131821,
0.0229394659,
0.0246930774,
-0.0239036158,
0.0344138518,
0.0289001968,
0.0206962712,
0.0436940715,
-0.0369324163,
0.0357340463,
0.0483098887,
-0.0213640146,
0.0102195097,
0.0216278527,
0.0038696188,
0.0235728472,
-0.0182541721,
0.006132721,
0.0453341939,
-0.0023812384,
-0.0085622445,
0.0986194983,
0.0869451463,
-0.0314965807,
-0.006667708,
0.0008503934,
0.0286776815,
0.0122464774,
-0.020472059,
-0.0797313973,
0.0054293135,
-0.0671387464,
-0.0070964368,
0.0103207575,
0.0345645249,
-0.0101045212,
-0.0123274429,
-0.0088376682,
-0.0203689095,
0.0207527671,
0.0417139046,
0.0032806816,
-0.0244458709,
-0.0064148186,
0.0628046021,
0.0133093093,
-0.0665338561,
-0.0203669034,
-0.0617938451,
0.0151312593,
0.1052679494,
0.0392085537,
0.0026824679,
-0.0001392386,
-0.025128359,
-0.0228453781,
0.0340417549,
0.0530971661,
0.0091096116,
0.0299457815,
-0.0491063967,
-0.0150348172,
0.0477358066,
0.0055160387,
0.0287704077,
0.0531961247,
0.0198535286,
0.0096118283,
-0.0269971583,
-0.0138928043,
-0.0070855352,
-0.0365044102,
-0.0742573887,
0.0003640821,
0.0153875994,
-0.0099070529,
0.0067985863,
0.0236890092,
0.0086682346,
0.0030743615,
0.0191161465,
0.0229508579,
-0.0066557722,
-0.0526048206,
0.0544692986,
0.0386769846,
0.0195741728,
-0.0152786346,
0.0368262455,
0.0008050929,
-0.0111896284,
0.0403023884,
0.0028007715,
0.0266141873,
0.0080155944,
0.021972077,
-0.0134149306,
-0.0065501025,
-0.028235564,
0.045546256,
-0.0206972864,
0.0068822033,
0.0106428033,
0.0005190879,
-0.0077774473,
-0.0791309401,
-0.0643086508,
-0.0072687375,
-0.0270298421,
0.0615911409,
0.0122189075,
0.0116383489,
-0.0204153508,
-0.0035246154,
-0.0597446784,
0.0110574346,
-0.0189314652,
0.0459303409,
0.0228248779,
0.0295934249,
-0.0415222012,
-0.0287680496,
-0.0280792657,
-0.0377969407,
-0.0050920579,
0.0358409844,
0.0065915398,
-0.0144621218,
-0.0332407542,
-0.0336598828,
-0.0155226532,
-0.0299764108,
0.0003377497,
-0.0308457837,
0.0148241147,
-0.0313233882,
-0.0038659428,
-0.0216067303,
0.0276482143,
-0.0168327522,
0.01330317,
0.0263107345,
-0.0046039145,
0.0510863513,
0.055074919,
-0.0016125136,
-0.0109994682,
0.0583619289,
-0.0006540139,
-0.0732254758,
-0.0073467181,
0.0170811974,
-0.0322742499,
0.0107702138,
-0.058286842,
0.0089305295,
0.0635742471,
0.0094230603,
-0.0054521342,
-0.0492268428,
0.0416917317,
-0.0249530263,
-0.011488704,
-0.0272409935,
0.003053373,
-0.0307851806,
0.0577591695,
0.0073107989,
-0.0714225695,
0.0806676745,
-0.0105099566,
0.0215108991,
-0.0050940146,
-0.0280734487,
0.0108538195,
0.0336932689,
-0.0203909203,
0.0121070445,
0.0390781872,
-0.0387040786,
-0.0455711409,
-0.0219099168,
0.028729232,
-0.054534819,
0.03757184,
-0.0419823937,
-0.0180596355,
-0.0067485734,
-0.0479495935,
-0.0189203918,
-0.0622593164,
-0.0411259197,
-0.0256994162,
0.0227585621,
-0.0301881004,
0.0262321159,
-0.0212630033,
0.0372260995,
0.0379357412,
-0.0398693867,
-0.0086525101,
-0.0156350359,
-0.0332522281,
0.0205137916,
-0.0251031946,
0.0061762468,
-0.0350407027,
0.0109128496,
0.0399743505,
0.08710742,
-0.0328454114,
0.0127454363,
-0.0231755786,
0.064361617,
-0.0473635457,
-0.0561628826,
0.0880665332,
0.0543242991,
-0.065983437,
0.0100196032,
0.0822307765,
0.0150937205,
-0.0570907034,
-0.0002939015,
-0.0479793251,
0.058627177,
0.01473819,
0.0407413207,
-0.0769476667,
-0.0119004957,
0.0180544704,
0.0859854147,
-0.0117849782,
-0.0330318101,
-0.0009853819,
-0.0900185108,
-0.0034765848,
0.0074234661,
-0.0386971608,
0.037581794,
-0.0293499511,
-0.0097759981,
0.001314105,
0.0436817668,
-0.002838145,
-0.0334095694,
0.0067896405,
0.0097882422,
-0.0647594705,
-0.0542729162,
0.0295239333,
-0.0246854685,
0.0458000451,
0.0624281131,
-0.027685307,
-0.0222868212,
-0.0644388124,
0.0357214473,
0.027545115,
-0.022242438,
-0.0162352454,
0.018815523,
-0.0125639485,
0.0099826837,
-0.0481446311,
0.0145917851,
-0.0164601933,
-0.0161887538,
0.0297476593,
0.0334453024,
-0.0108526107,
-0.0017166469,
-0.0148121333,
-0.0259188265,
0.0147630069,
0.0734295771,
-0.0002669257,
-0.0800058842,
-0.0321800783,
-0.0959645659,
-0.0176051818,
-0.033505816,
-0.0572012775,
-0.0055612437,
0.0272035245,
-0.0810687095,
-0.0284708999,
-0.031036986,
0.0067509459,
0.0055113896,
0.0164861456,
0.0003664324,
0.0031392069,
0.0125311324,
-0.0112267369,
0.0443326943,
-0.0789737031,
0.0489962921,
-0.1008941382,
0.0454068482,
-0.0230941027,
-0.0345785692,
0.0007128252,
0.0139056062,
-0.0442234948,
-0.0840732306,
0.012209449,
0.0768415183,
0.0354225226,
0.0187848937,
-0.023049159,
-0.1062677354,
0.0374442302,
0.0556138791,
-0.0292645339,
0.0056595029,
0.0324620418,
-0.0142608397,
0.0156258568,
0.0164178964,
-0.0409562103,
-0.0304047652,
0.0218667798,
0.0109775243,
-0.0286058579,
-0.044503089,
-0.0046789725,
0.0679071695,
0.0385864042,
-0.0154661005,
0.0484543405,
-0.0014646491,
0.0015487894,
-0.0040985337,
-0.0242620166,
0.0071024769,
-0.0197073966,
-0.0040339152,
-0.0092988182,
0.0203196276,
-0.0355739668,
-0.0280570574,
0.017599605,
-0.0364002548,
0.0463842489,
-0.0128506171,
0.0609805211,
0.0614314601,
-0.0005297003,
-0.0338537507,
0.0341238827,
-0.0031237083,
0.0455702692,
-0.0117483577,
0.0561700426,
-0.0390127748,
0.0035999066,
0.005674758,
0.0482670143,
-0.0342972167,
-0.0909138918,
0.0227176994,
0.0417500809,
-0.0020319761,
0.0047971644,
0.0314497203,
-0.0267821066,
0.0240337923,
-0.0472603366,
-0.0286962129,
0.0385354534,
-0.0383576788,
0.0054620486,
0.0004004191,
-0.0109281158,
-0.0275727846,
0.0929765105,
0.0123070292,
0.028412547,
-0.0233260412,
-0.0227508042,
-0.0414823033,
-0.0105197132,
0.0053693289,
0.0726519227,
-0.0649684146,
-0.0529003143,
-0.0931871608,
-0.071324721,
-0.0248881672,
0.0286048651,
0.0118899252,
-0.0270261336,
0.0222909432,
0.0428664833,
-0.0215195604,
-0.0320002995,
-0.0315294564,
0.0107971095,
-0.0117130484,
-0.0233364832,
-0.0132098868,
-6.557108792e-33,
-0.0123402542,
-0.0067896084,
-0.0084465379,
0.0202132035,
0.0539665706,
-0.0410906896,
-0.0230257306,
0.058472693,
-0.0236454327,
-0.0500007868,
-0.0367005318,
-0.0110274507,
0.0283041131,
0.0008713171,
0.023409484,
-0.0026414555,
0.0146366209,
0.0137966918,
-0.0492133573,
0.0258566309,
0.032693807,
-0.0141006233,
0.0351420641,
-0.0800099596,
0.0694868192,
-0.0283984523,
0.0105699133,
-0.0221088845,
-0.0417272113,
0.0550921708,
0.0026328878,
0.0525829494,
-0.0065751639,
-0.0263728369,
-0.0246093906,
0.0445803553,
-0.0246221647,
-0.0382114612,
0.0403652005,
-0.0031985911,
0.000166261,
-0.1050216407,
0.035549324,
-0.0105565302,
-0.0737886801,
0.0205098279,
0.0272631701,
0.0030666864,
-0.0137608955,
0.0066361506,
-0.0108256163,
0.0111950412,
0.0117342807,
0.0005428943,
-0.0029398287,
0.0311238598,
-0.0139661543,
-0.00213899,
-0.0353114307,
0.0512868129,
0.0184367914,
0.0089223525,
0.0783870146,
0.0093708802,
-0.0132925343,
0.021418428,
0.011739091,
0.0164478458,
0.0057645962,
-0.0389604159,
0.0275985859,
0.0021128336,
0.023535464,
0.0393973924,
0.0018410281,
-0.0437474996,
-0.0170843862,
0.0410714932,
0.0478105135,
-0.0167110469,
0.0508783609,
-0.0054061967,
-0.0749452934,
-0.0395692214,
-0.0315442868,
-0.0149626266,
-0.0403500982,
-0.0281632356,
0.0502710417,
-0.0159078743,
-0.033221025,
-0.0503354631,
0.0110362107,
-0.0218748823,
-0.0438559353,
-0.0173439961,
-0.0149201425,
0.0010462657,
-0.0006337772,
0.0315600745,
-0.0282184295,
0.0096007641,
-0.0287348647,
-0.0408531316,
0.0354662724,
0.0314391293,
-0.0201378427,
0.0243588369,
-0.1001260951,
0.0005080216,
-0.0158081204,
0.0518762022,
0.0307296123,
0.0173713528,
0.0701903626,
-0.0197338723,
0.0224913433,
0.0268092882,
0.0270004608,
-0.0286292769,
-0.0487801284,
-0.0097271148,
-0.0251905043,
-0.0027013698,
-0.0057051401,
0.0094742225,
-0.0107977372,
0.0455080904,
0.0335848257,
-0.0020663533,
-0.017103076,
-0.0478481986,
2.983e-7,
0.0032052777,
0.0566534735,
-0.0233644713,
0.0205833353,
-0.0025967194,
0.0766361654,
-0.0068847281,
0.0640994236,
0.028704267,
0.002925114,
-0.0419024453,
0.0166901704,
0.0312967189,
0.0406999588,
-0.0673239902,
0.002099405,
-0.0368066542,
0.071566388,
-0.0641369745,
0.0160463434,
0.0451483391,
0.0345185772,
0.027090976,
0.0027516582,
-0.0128604956,
-0.0335783698,
0.0198166985,
-0.0419340841,
-0.005034613,
-0.0109764021,
0.0360176302,
0.0397326313,
0.023800211,
0.0401717536,
-0.0081115188,
-0.0005462104,
-0.0324622281,
0.0961394385,
0.0080310898,
0.0196901839,
0.0241082795,
-0.0591107272,
-0.0051891734,
-0.065650925,
0.0581641272,
0.0332105607,
-0.0050014406,
0.0044558393,
-0.0006024475,
-0.0318605453,
0.0102013415,
-0.0210517775,
-0.0280283317,
0.0050609079,
0.0132921152,
-0.0038764542,
-0.0172140747,
-0.0323554613,
-0.0421255417,
0.0015025367,
0.0042947424,
-0.0792285651,
-0.0414660536,
0.0559551008,
-0.000615617,
-0.0433183424,
0.0286978036,
2.891373786e-34,
-0.0016688789,
0.025556175,
0.0270520765,
-0.027878331,
0.0364871994,
0.0399355255,
0.0229327753,
0.0245656855,
0.0413918346,
-0.0146957086,
-0.024422735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11106v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11106v1 | From Intentions to Techniques: A Comprehensive Taxonomy and Challenges in Text Watermarking for Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T00:09:31 | 2024-06-17T00:09:31 | Harsh Nishant Lalai, Aashish Anantha Ramakrishnan, Raj Sanjay Shah, Dongwon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the rapid growth of Large Language Models (LLMs), safeguarding textual
content against unauthorized use is crucial. Text watermarking offers a vital
solution, protecting both - LLM-generated and plain text sources. This paper
presents a unified overview of different perspectives behind designing
watermarking techniques, through a comprehensive survey of the research
literature. Our work has two key advantages, (1) we analyze research based on
the specific intentions behind different watermarking techniques, evaluation
datasets used, watermarking addition, and removal methods to construct a
cohesive taxonomy. (2) We highlight the gaps and open challenges in text
watermarking to promote research in protecting text authorship. This extensive
coverage and detailed analysis sets our work apart, offering valuable insights
into the evolving landscape of text watermarking in language models. | [
0.0597089678,
0.0416339301,
-0.0118701514,
0.0395463035,
-0.0597871952,
-0.0166334193,
0.0631303862,
0.0577853136,
0.0249383338,
-0.0123135466,
-0.003535683,
-0.0085468004,
0.0393275805,
0.0023213271,
0.0384609438,
-0.0068692137,
-0.015059947,
-0.0266269073,
0.016975062,
-0.0210358761,
0.0194771066,
0.0276858788,
0.0631093904,
0.0301309098,
-0.0106914239,
-0.0318386592,
0.0351067111,
-0.0039056665,
-0.0029307373,
0.0040860544,
-0.0320996717,
0.0501423292,
-0.0074934559,
0.0929124579,
0.0000018423,
-0.0328278877,
-0.0270155314,
0.0416206308,
-0.0161052309,
0.0711679384,
0.0580334216,
0.0216662697,
-0.0474568903,
0.0247158762,
-0.0094172554,
0.0579861179,
0.0296382047,
0.0500846617,
0.0837102756,
0.0387681164,
-0.0294891894,
-0.0068931752,
0.0253138114,
0.0096619464,
0.0226395931,
0.0001799445,
0.0236732643,
0.0190237407,
-0.0310041383,
0.0510567464,
0.0408096053,
0.087167874,
-0.011150239,
-0.0609269403,
-0.0262317993,
-0.0093377614,
-0.0136490054,
0.0119421855,
0.0426965952,
-0.0172676016,
-0.0169535521,
-0.0313939713,
0.0148909343,
0.0082906112,
0.0057843816,
0.0608860888,
-0.0024257002,
0.051958032,
0.0067482982,
0.0090886103,
0.0017306485,
0.0029660151,
0.0275566876,
0.0230215956,
0.0283948611,
0.025273649,
0.0272072069,
-0.0133098606,
-0.0440366641,
-0.0339803398,
-0.0101113794,
-0.0752868354,
0.0742797107,
-0.0022236502,
0.0673578084,
0.0100203156,
-0.0916576385,
-0.0740598813,
0.012841708,
-0.0488058701,
0.0442550555,
0.0096543841,
-0.0007048095,
0.0391447805,
-0.0556950569,
0.061728958,
-0.019505702,
0.0151695758,
0.0532312281,
-0.017050555,
0.0121302372,
-0.0437278487,
-0.0260598473,
0.0079076951,
0.0083002597,
0.0235174038,
-0.0186915081,
0.0402963273,
0.0098120086,
0.0477705784,
-0.0025561887,
-0.0549883321,
0.0117348759,
-0.0162155554,
0.0575274266,
-0.052678559,
0.0353813656,
0.0115436139,
-0.0273073986,
-0.0207997486,
0.0261658169,
0.0157934055,
0.021686893,
0.0043880166,
-0.0043371031,
0.0653367341,
0.0381966308,
-0.0144385872,
-0.0146907838,
-0.0492825136,
0.0045614056,
0.0247969944,
-0.0171726719,
-0.045992624,
-0.0464109927,
-0.0236984137,
0.0168404896,
-0.0944114849,
0.0016971849,
0.0179948844,
-0.0227435641,
0.0130863255,
-0.0317456797,
-0.0132397972,
0.0332650952,
0.0050136,
-0.0230786558,
0.0063967444,
0.0500383861,
0.0610096753,
0.0683567002,
-0.0137343248,
0.0338854603,
0.0597142614,
-0.0273997653,
0.0185568072,
-0.0022893883,
-0.0293096974,
0.0559394695,
-0.0320360325,
-0.017154146,
0.0370920487,
0.007750974,
-0.0358180888,
0.0927417427,
0.067066811,
-0.037507575,
-0.006027597,
-0.0281915236,
0.0157023445,
0.0454901643,
-0.0446441397,
0.0009088123,
-0.0069829989,
-0.0302414075,
-0.0471543446,
-0.0370149389,
-0.0017612894,
0.0229047779,
0.0012467242,
-0.0359508209,
-0.0131996842,
0.0355913714,
0.0127380593,
0.0025671173,
0.0567554794,
-0.0187339522,
0.0079344753,
-0.0385227762,
-0.0405788384,
0.0334478058,
-0.0573677942,
0.0096521359,
0.0745118707,
0.0855485499,
0.0139731821,
0.072146751,
-0.0133430865,
-0.0200154576,
0.0302130282,
-0.051569555,
-0.0122555653,
0.0176945515,
-0.0243867207,
-0.0360663831,
-0.0495392308,
-0.0036746818,
0.0262749419,
0.0132592805,
0.0183122754,
0.0430758148,
-0.0456465967,
-0.0275590848,
0.0129142776,
-0.0015285094,
-0.0219060797,
-0.01763306,
-0.0151916891,
-0.008477048,
0.0296336878,
-0.0326032937,
0.0234095529,
-0.0062202942,
0.013962375,
-0.0196372867,
-0.0242177602,
0.0445053689,
0.0344401188,
0.0381191894,
-0.0361594111,
0.0074494253,
0.0304082707,
0.0145664942,
0.0044806143,
0.0094299521,
-0.0496872403,
0.0255439691,
-0.0430296063,
0.0090507409,
-0.0457624756,
0.0227304529,
-0.0241940804,
-0.0060315202,
0.0041762935,
0.006110576,
0.023261467,
0.0064272555,
0.0317849852,
0.0213118885,
-0.0534050353,
-0.020882206,
-0.0307450481,
0.012128449,
0.0013033245,
0.0122949481,
0.0144410003,
-0.0293404851,
-0.0261615049,
-0.0046955273,
-0.004048517,
0.0291991755,
0.017564591,
0.00177334,
0.0019857218,
0.0107197333,
-0.0424513444,
-0.0924125984,
-0.0100147408,
0.013488343,
0.0368901901,
-0.0379680432,
-0.0280988943,
-0.0011227116,
0.0147117246,
0.0404024646,
0.0451621711,
-0.0003925925,
-0.058430668,
-0.0412904583,
0.0486742184,
-0.0316325352,
-0.0121603189,
-0.0103090489,
-0.0061962493,
-0.0220388174,
-0.0192890763,
-0.0128458841,
0.0282268822,
0.0040560607,
-0.0143092694,
0.0217834394,
-0.0027243576,
-0.0214911234,
-0.0533434711,
-0.0155569846,
-0.0057717711,
0.0110624824,
-0.0520468839,
0.0587257333,
-0.0195029769,
0.0017479202,
-0.0105969291,
-0.0217844918,
0.0359039903,
-0.0297892075,
-0.0178026035,
-0.0015439669,
-0.0555100292,
-0.023473125,
-0.0026685556,
-0.0175505243,
-0.0271958802,
-0.0060304212,
-0.0488801375,
-0.0027137683,
0.0037477501,
-0.0023637477,
0.0063654114,
0.0520415716,
-0.0078135179,
0.0283921733,
0.0299564116,
-0.031998653,
0.0099425372,
0.0033573031,
0.0821894631,
-0.0354424752,
-0.0326789692,
-0.0027850829,
-0.0261318423,
0.0186983086,
0.0286726598,
0.0071014287,
-0.0553849861,
0.0034483864,
-0.0047615217,
0.0253975056,
-0.0070398087,
0.0235649627,
-0.0170914903,
0.0526132844,
0.0033681039,
-0.0059280815,
0.005264062,
-0.0388564169,
0.0574613102,
-0.0409315303,
-0.0912109241,
-0.033229813,
-0.0089566531,
-0.0231143851,
0.0540093109,
0.0176141635,
-0.0329352729,
0.053363353,
-0.005274985,
0.045916751,
0.0005853501,
-0.0616814755,
0.0107245669,
0.0443450175,
-0.0434403941,
0.0365486071,
0.0880956575,
0.0357407816,
-0.0062541692,
-0.0139839612,
-0.0211588442,
-0.0065731304,
0.0070640612,
-0.0136465542,
-0.0702100024,
0.0206135567,
0.0463584177,
0.022064615,
-0.0384886228,
0.003593209,
-0.0309206136,
-0.038776461,
0.0027421222,
0.0121194618,
-0.0325601101,
0.0166542698,
-0.0582465753,
-0.0299458448,
0.0543760583,
-0.0541197732,
-0.0616070852,
0.0306682363,
-0.0076087462,
0.0268876571,
-0.0608655252,
-0.0255423058,
-0.0201303139,
-0.0355531424,
0.0101162251,
0.0554344878,
0.0351073146,
-0.0225329027,
-0.0422590598,
0.008126772,
-0.0043583936,
-0.0198117662,
0.0000389776,
0.0494044609,
-0.0001021721,
-0.0254997946,
-0.0300110597,
0.020477578,
0.0519717075,
-0.0587575771,
0.0036278695,
0.0439190529,
0.0085050659,
0.0029819121,
0.0052597225,
-0.0542792566,
0.042451147,
0.0429413617,
0.0044425442,
-0.0505956113,
-0.0065681683,
-0.0835492387,
0.0516296104,
-0.0299109593,
-0.0523128584,
-0.019784091,
-0.0523390099,
-0.0597392768,
-0.0473393127,
0.0101552643,
-0.0462018847,
-0.0229100157,
0.0808608457,
0.0552756041,
0.0215512067,
-0.0420652404,
-0.0043101362,
-0.0462298915,
-0.1145580858,
0.0556087047,
-0.0147813717,
0.0148451412,
-0.0235614311,
-0.0244006962,
0.0172903799,
0.0054105143,
-0.0635992661,
-0.0563378185,
0.0202514417,
0.0012565142,
0.020613391,
-0.0321594663,
-0.0295394212,
-0.1144081131,
0.0482414812,
0.0069013885,
0.0001014112,
0.0214505699,
0.0505085923,
-0.0352176987,
-0.0034702378,
0.0245391969,
-0.0591775328,
-0.012918937,
0.0841473714,
-0.0600071922,
-0.0276633687,
0.0231266264,
-0.0062721325,
0.0553728566,
-0.0098145315,
-0.0380158648,
0.0437496528,
-0.0014272605,
-0.0035034132,
-0.0538811609,
-0.0381120853,
-0.0036637322,
0.0303987898,
0.0444916897,
0.0039233058,
0.0164645091,
0.0353209898,
0.0002118739,
0.0001888412,
0.0003800348,
0.0377596207,
0.0022580628,
0.0563476533,
0.0315295979,
0.028532574,
-0.0095953951,
0.0436459817,
0.0159437656,
0.0017201203,
0.0176511221,
-0.004345065,
0.0147042591,
0.0079080621,
0.0035202608,
0.0296319015,
-0.0643753633,
-0.0228500068,
-0.0085309297,
0.0162872747,
0.0147706801,
0.0096445587,
0.0428995341,
-0.04102052,
-0.0104410639,
-0.0292917434,
0.0093209716,
-0.004726415,
-0.0558323413,
-0.0532385893,
-0.0305732209,
-0.0290339757,
0.0238995999,
0.0250140913,
0.0187898166,
0.0475409366,
0.0064126602,
-0.0602270663,
-0.0325610712,
-0.0099201631,
0.0564039387,
-0.0004452498,
-0.0347648896,
-0.0438846424,
-0.059870705,
-0.044703424,
0.0246369373,
-0.0108863469,
-0.0032393869,
-0.0066184201,
-0.0391586348,
0.0195479803,
0.0035018304,
0.0016037257,
-0.0647307858,
0.0339909531,
0.0126709891,
-0.0491431691,
0.0106107714,
-4.605336707e-33,
0.0256264862,
-0.0413453542,
-0.034661103,
0.0067839124,
0.0428298526,
0.0601192974,
-0.0124530494,
-0.0228268672,
-0.0017082627,
0.0037082853,
-0.0380359329,
-0.0103131188,
-0.0021073131,
-0.0089082383,
-0.0417263992,
0.0336432792,
0.0330960788,
0.0120015889,
-0.0285234172,
0.0084356694,
0.057274729,
-0.0398044698,
0.027418904,
-0.0814651623,
0.0835450143,
-0.0454781651,
-0.0851602629,
-0.0329985246,
-0.0154466284,
0.0384122878,
-0.0197019894,
-0.0174842831,
-0.021434281,
-0.0048168767,
-0.0314639285,
0.0531937554,
-0.0083457427,
-0.0350433365,
0.0127081769,
0.0590244792,
0.0478578135,
-0.0719506815,
0.0063749189,
-0.0268169306,
-0.0138983196,
0.0415407009,
0.0197968166,
0.0114390003,
-0.0276768375,
-0.0211539697,
-0.0045585055,
0.0078764278,
-0.0149357906,
0.0362818502,
0.0587940067,
0.0228794459,
0.046185609,
-0.0022879827,
-0.0900547653,
0.0402779318,
-0.007138344,
-0.0325582214,
0.0099214474,
0.0260606762,
0.0215194169,
0.0299739596,
-0.0322998241,
0.0228053872,
0.035647139,
-0.0003940189,
0.0157297179,
0.0112329377,
0.0819185525,
0.061179515,
0.0381456167,
-0.0232214779,
0.0234102849,
0.0344005115,
-0.0575523376,
-0.0433289297,
0.0451776981,
0.0108866291,
-0.0328081921,
-0.0387464762,
-0.0607567355,
-0.0676448494,
-0.0005698649,
-0.0140343308,
0.0061959904,
-0.0376777537,
-0.0403126813,
-0.0086770942,
0.0200679824,
-0.0615592673,
-0.0727440938,
0.0226573199,
-0.0301962625,
0.0709421188,
0.0046471902,
0.0297710691,
0.0303529855,
0.0241989475,
0.0384615324,
-0.0529246666,
0.0127690714,
-0.0193749629,
0.060482163,
0.0162871201,
-0.0770945102,
-0.0099683851,
0.0076898211,
0.0308651533,
0.0304708853,
0.0207034051,
0.0120008737,
-0.0471890271,
0.0187837929,
-0.0712292269,
0.040737424,
-0.0253188536,
-0.0124397371,
0.0038575311,
-0.0165329017,
-0.0229508262,
0.0035672903,
0.0105686188,
-0.0003300399,
0.0361267403,
0.0720888451,
0.0043643545,
-0.0238394681,
-0.0339738801,
2.421e-7,
0.0576965846,
0.0116043184,
0.0213683825,
0.0031169094,
0.0311365314,
0.0561617427,
0.0179055333,
0.0107547548,
-0.024335824,
0.0217956286,
-0.0275186673,
-0.0197183602,
0.0741576254,
-0.0161816664,
-0.0537029132,
0.0137429591,
-0.0233820304,
-0.0012724353,
-0.0315296464,
0.0263300631,
0.0338549316,
0.0286978465,
0.0535370782,
-0.0415588282,
-0.0425751843,
-0.0620995536,
0.0357343294,
-0.0366654731,
0.0073695024,
-0.0126078511,
-0.0019103866,
0.0123440167,
0.0440494791,
-0.0215034056,
-0.0364215225,
-0.0153200394,
0.0093817236,
0.0441395752,
0.0153798554,
0.0604486875,
-0.0270404611,
-0.0417679176,
0.0052651381,
-0.0579748973,
0.0580377765,
0.1287710369,
-0.0307568945,
-0.0547790043,
-0.0411010757,
-0.0548401996,
0.0424658544,
-0.0225130189,
-0.0270030759,
0.0111182965,
-0.0055334,
0.0189856458,
-0.0507100821,
-0.0460005291,
-0.0545237102,
-0.0617690235,
-0.0089648049,
0.0103048524,
-0.0329345576,
0.0373722948,
0.0607472062,
-0.0522550866,
0.0438923836,
2.268488972e-34,
-0.0147369439,
-0.0769514143,
-0.0053389571,
0.0423540846,
0.0343760215,
0.0252020601,
0.014036037,
0.0386340022,
-0.0071556447,
-0.0237248,
0.0002990707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11102v1 | Grading Massive Open Online Courses Using Large Language Models | 2024-06-16T23:42:11 | 2024-06-16T23:42:11 | Shahriar Golchin, Nikhil Garuda, Christopher Impey, Matthew Wenger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Massive open online courses (MOOCs) offer free education globally to anyone
with a computer and internet access. Despite this democratization of learning,
the massive enrollment in these courses makes it impractical for one instructor
to assess every student's writing assignment. As a result, peer grading, often
guided by a straightforward rubric, is the method of choice. While convenient,
peer grading often falls short in terms of reliability and validity. In this
study, we explore the feasibility of using large language models (LLMs) to
replace peer grading in MOOCs. Specifically, we use two LLMs, GPT-4 and
GPT-3.5, across three MOOCs: Introductory Astronomy, Astrobiology, and the
History and Philosophy of Astronomy. To instruct LLMs, we use three different
prompts based on the zero-shot chain-of-thought (ZCoT) prompting technique: (1)
ZCoT with instructor-provided correct answers, (2) ZCoT with both
instructor-provided correct answers and rubrics, and (3) ZCoT with
instructor-provided correct answers and LLM-generated rubrics. Tested on 18
settings, our results show that ZCoT, when augmented with instructor-provided
correct answers and rubrics, produces grades that are more aligned with those
assigned by instructors compared to peer grading. Finally, our findings
indicate a promising potential for automated grading systems in MOOCs,
especially in subjects with well-defined rubrics, to improve the learning
experience for millions of online learners worldwide. | [
0.0746937692,
0.0014827799,
-0.0167364087,
-0.0104914922,
-0.0368684418,
0.0091337701,
0.0380170569,
0.0090411073,
0.0496372692,
-0.0688222796,
-0.0266118478,
-0.0237581395,
-0.0253534392,
0.0301366132,
-0.0225031897,
-0.0467481017,
-0.0143820439,
-0.0294731129,
0.0039590369,
-0.0050582257,
0.0289710946,
-0.0013894208,
-0.0258340333,
0.0099246232,
0.0537569858,
-0.0470450036,
0.0044805892,
-0.0275641531,
0.0014966029,
-0.0215756707,
0.0285510998,
0.0794378519,
-0.0342176557,
0.0614416301,
0.0000020729,
-0.0848806873,
-0.0281200465,
-0.0080084624,
-0.0149159459,
0.0657633767,
0.0045093372,
0.062759161,
0.0017019986,
0.0184155852,
-0.0289621502,
-0.0236953609,
0.0291363616,
-0.0186816435,
0.0454327129,
0.0287197307,
0.0166314654,
-0.0157362092,
0.004852613,
0.0107191093,
0.0196007919,
0.0204796065,
0.0178367831,
0.0630025044,
-0.0142233614,
0.0480600148,
-0.0507469103,
-0.0070969691,
0.0053816135,
-0.0446029715,
0.0469621159,
0.0096207941,
-0.0261141006,
0.0151382787,
0.000897776,
0.0249453261,
0.0172843691,
0.0138258198,
-0.0214133989,
-0.0162870754,
0.0100778136,
0.0498786159,
-0.0832828134,
0.0523873009,
-0.0159029271,
-0.0241324808,
0.0095377322,
-0.010935368,
-0.0119325537,
0.0555866361,
0.0353477113,
0.058849819,
0.015543961,
-0.0482112244,
-0.0128987264,
0.0511298068,
0.0255261343,
-0.0336881168,
0.0240672603,
0.041007854,
-0.0216466412,
-0.0164420512,
0.0179710817,
0.0061081494,
0.0350684077,
-0.0053920792,
0.0766203105,
0.0301179327,
0.0230992772,
0.0365622677,
-0.0043890649,
0.0802764669,
0.0516293123,
-0.0067580924,
-0.0070068385,
0.0467051305,
-0.0679895729,
0.0065543111,
0.0341812633,
0.0517059267,
0.0573529452,
0.0266788471,
-0.0869796649,
-0.0179953612,
-0.0404593274,
0.0322835296,
-0.0148480264,
-0.0378598534,
0.0193537567,
0.0269298181,
-0.0427394956,
0.0850928724,
-0.0068371203,
0.0115718953,
-0.0109204222,
-0.0117783397,
0.0187029969,
0.0168314744,
0.0229803734,
0.0172697362,
0.0009214096,
0.0139508825,
-0.0011351708,
0.0020211204,
0.0382959917,
-0.0671461299,
-0.017577935,
-0.030019125,
-0.0102249794,
-0.0766591951,
-0.0290408153,
0.0272502974,
0.0120078558,
0.037941929,
0.0234499015,
0.0242619645,
0.0136139486,
-0.0250941571,
0.0162593126,
-0.0166633353,
0.037928544,
0.0240666866,
-0.0155300619,
-0.0154823028,
0.0168331545,
0.0064289733,
0.0234219413,
-0.0469228327,
0.0573860854,
0.0214273501,
-0.0184276775,
0.0148949157,
0.0491817668,
0.0193563066,
0.0649478212,
0.0546422563,
-0.0452588275,
0.0264929496,
0.0045836745,
0.0698630139,
0.0603577867,
0.0425605923,
-0.0054118237,
0.0171607044,
0.0105094956,
-0.0189917516,
0.0290258583,
0.0320783257,
-0.0041314065,
0.0353828333,
-0.0277542155,
0.0027747566,
0.045569852,
0.0259076748,
-0.0007687948,
-0.0799825042,
-0.0360448658,
0.0221360084,
-0.0377361625,
0.0387158878,
0.0416497365,
-0.0474648923,
0.0057089343,
-0.024798099,
0.005590498,
-0.0890884995,
0.0639372841,
-0.0371254571,
0.0537650287,
0.0552321374,
0.0684510618,
0.0024480231,
-0.033517316,
-0.0352749079,
0.0506832711,
0.0730062947,
0.0795613453,
-0.0347287543,
-0.0654863939,
-0.0325206369,
-0.0538304523,
-0.0056641679,
-0.0202069748,
-0.0284691583,
-0.0000728155,
0.0150456149,
-0.0034991307,
0.017388124,
-0.103615962,
0.0070466558,
-0.0195699912,
-0.0551143438,
-0.0261373781,
-0.0015876055,
0.0209394302,
0.0297809802,
0.0072604651,
-0.0058932547,
-0.0024157749,
-0.0171220731,
-0.0329674222,
-0.0680450499,
-0.0109107122,
0.0204095952,
0.0615122318,
-0.0642715171,
-0.0004826265,
0.0033914961,
-0.0304721054,
-0.029310124,
0.0114056803,
0.0048652906,
-0.0056490949,
0.0075515462,
0.0009147917,
-0.0530544296,
-0.0159540195,
-0.0244508404,
-0.0041493201,
0.0052295607,
0.1092119589,
-0.0029655711,
-0.0215874426,
0.022705717,
0.0079734614,
-0.0432157107,
-0.0250215288,
0.0056150965,
0.0191519894,
0.0404874198,
0.0218511112,
-0.0608973354,
-0.0595610663,
-0.0334414355,
0.0000900079,
0.0257035811,
-0.0083649494,
0.0341017768,
-0.0640713498,
0.0006486658,
0.0370150246,
-0.0407696515,
0.0017559006,
0.0078728357,
-0.003320216,
0.0205719285,
-0.0119820507,
-0.0307824612,
-0.0140404515,
-0.0269006956,
-0.0429090783,
0.0090566743,
0.0910133868,
0.0339830071,
-0.0198378451,
0.0444521829,
-0.0493138283,
-0.0558325797,
0.0316453539,
-0.0364144258,
0.014320679,
-0.0246861875,
0.0463264659,
0.0526217259,
0.0199118573,
0.0005264967,
0.0830757245,
-0.0406155959,
-0.0201910008,
-0.0355659686,
-0.0203843471,
-0.0504767522,
0.0070646922,
-0.0789946094,
-0.0210806001,
0.022170607,
0.0242877807,
-0.0574175157,
-0.0123062143,
0.0004815789,
-0.0983199254,
0.0193492286,
-0.010903839,
-0.0082013495,
-0.0045942049,
-0.0070184497,
0.0139447423,
-0.0199690238,
0.0841479525,
-0.0037207648,
-0.0017196303,
-0.045877073,
0.0295944568,
-0.0234148093,
-0.000512881,
0.0033467258,
0.0162208863,
-0.0134955449,
0.0046996279,
-0.0115043875,
-0.0028065357,
0.0234440509,
-0.0632912591,
-0.0171358176,
-0.0312960558,
-0.0288520325,
-0.0189216025,
0.0096060745,
0.0149730537,
0.0215738211,
-0.0056497795,
-0.00329207,
-0.0395928249,
-0.0076863174,
0.0249080807,
-0.0197367221,
0.0190348662,
0.0129328258,
-0.0626919866,
-0.0311111659,
0.0036113397,
0.001303775,
0.0016268782,
-0.0291383993,
-0.0033036277,
-0.0592236631,
0.0247576404,
0.0752591267,
0.0768811405,
-0.0211196486,
0.0317123495,
-0.021923786,
0.046881143,
-0.0361924581,
0.0128420638,
0.0331787579,
0.0174755789,
-0.0714660659,
-0.0193542875,
0.1213232055,
0.0083514918,
-0.0505933538,
-0.0469194539,
-0.0534521118,
0.0150794322,
0.0326087475,
0.013885906,
-0.0756332651,
0.003173002,
-0.0241634212,
0.0339788906,
-0.0299532767,
-0.0415731929,
0.0214330759,
-0.0804224461,
0.0319742896,
0.0209701657,
-0.0140437586,
0.0094565544,
-0.0464573503,
0.007048178,
0.0182321407,
-0.0449061282,
0.0287499409,
0.0064278832,
0.0120427273,
0.0275886655,
-0.0299115628,
0.0287800971,
0.0527064204,
-0.0324771479,
0.031398233,
-0.0025623296,
0.0188879576,
-0.042895522,
-0.0637148693,
0.0319966227,
-0.0079502147,
-0.0383633301,
0.0029034554,
0.0182597339,
-0.0098120123,
0.0283514913,
-0.0471810475,
0.0582376681,
-0.0286290161,
0.0067670494,
0.0481058285,
0.1037360653,
0.0207515247,
-0.0568288974,
-0.0346756466,
0.0115933418,
0.002643487,
0.0466703847,
0.0215279441,
-0.1002044827,
-0.0126124239,
-0.0570547655,
0.0049121957,
-0.0102379518,
-0.0205222052,
0.0248895679,
0.0234323032,
-0.018168794,
0.0087704165,
-0.0462333597,
0.009735168,
0.0121960025,
0.0565927625,
0.0445275009,
0.0327487253,
0.01706223,
0.005030897,
0.0283826776,
-0.0464766584,
0.0113089317,
-0.0803455338,
-0.0148011306,
-0.0204966646,
-0.0087539842,
-0.022520965,
0.0076740156,
-0.0369752944,
-0.0252479166,
-0.0125438487,
0.0262742043,
0.0156029435,
-0.0612992309,
0.0579996556,
-0.0421135314,
0.0064519765,
-0.0289233401,
0.0036160825,
0.0217849053,
-0.0174210705,
0.0049245809,
0.0171897747,
-0.0248277672,
-0.0206417721,
-0.0109357629,
0.0332312137,
0.0281446818,
-0.0177414566,
-0.0268603768,
0.0379688442,
0.0183499437,
0.0293087699,
-0.0091820406,
-0.0022206348,
-0.0159175713,
0.0291694365,
-0.0213427134,
-0.0367560014,
0.0181315653,
-0.0379683487,
0.0616826937,
0.0117261475,
0.0329452641,
0.0310514849,
-0.0501817614,
0.0376432687,
-0.0235905759,
0.0284489617,
0.0186181273,
0.0173470639,
0.0433754101,
-0.026812477,
-0.054543633,
-0.0472799763,
0.0053169136,
0.0345315598,
-0.0040764813,
0.1144357398,
0.0028176683,
0.0082811918,
0.070678778,
-0.0058014146,
-0.0639527887,
-0.0115220929,
-0.0167742688,
0.0197961964,
-0.0002535923,
0.035150148,
0.034880653,
-0.0368871987,
0.0153654488,
-0.0349626578,
0.0173526537,
-0.036879614,
-0.0555370189,
0.025330523,
0.0060042627,
0.0182095077,
0.0292184241,
0.0338332392,
-0.0189414937,
0.0238712654,
-0.0161892958,
-0.0148140714,
-0.0352211446,
-0.0063181734,
0.0049882545,
0.0315576531,
0.0001163073,
-0.039293088,
-0.0717713162,
-0.0224137623,
0.0057038656,
0.0387274995,
0.0375047065,
-0.0424054712,
0.0152236922,
0.0412104838,
-0.054107029,
-0.0405070148,
-0.0362809636,
0.0591993965,
-0.0117081953,
-0.0433183126,
-0.0106684873,
-5.862918767e-33,
-0.0054128491,
-0.0445566848,
0.0114882654,
0.0593304671,
0.0154017815,
0.0158174485,
-0.008689397,
0.0244268104,
0.0139371548,
0.0101918383,
0.0011940821,
-0.023047274,
-0.0076066339,
0.0537101366,
0.0748170689,
0.0285563078,
0.0240784958,
-0.0208892692,
-0.032874085,
0.0273769125,
0.0164336953,
-0.0143575575,
0.042423483,
-0.0342029259,
0.0792089403,
-0.047586672,
0.006584642,
-0.0116166137,
-0.067832768,
0.021140784,
-0.0255213361,
0.0556215756,
0.0103901485,
-0.0120192217,
-0.0020876729,
0.0029847487,
-0.0087243244,
-0.0288940128,
-0.0041715652,
0.0158807579,
-0.0023086134,
-0.0439425372,
0.0212450437,
0.0210727155,
-0.067321986,
-0.0430646166,
0.0368044302,
-0.004397314,
0.016955398,
0.0137394434,
-0.0445774235,
-0.0014998184,
-0.0359163582,
-0.0187733304,
-0.0283394363,
0.0457008258,
0.0024575838,
0.0177995954,
-0.011226492,
0.0873357877,
-0.0070758737,
0.0686387271,
0.0657558143,
0.009867589,
-0.0470311679,
0.0381958894,
-0.018657675,
0.0197566357,
0.0054171127,
-0.021987997,
0.0196134094,
-0.0491507277,
0.0779503658,
0.07840994,
0.0200889315,
-0.0070765298,
-0.0785544813,
0.0212281905,
0.0448914617,
-0.0273912661,
0.0254925042,
-0.0449756905,
-0.041619774,
-0.0283557586,
-0.0286641922,
-0.0497579724,
-0.0206240714,
-0.0068954858,
0.0191780217,
-0.0361141972,
0.0026458325,
-0.0451399647,
0.0399141684,
-0.0288663507,
-0.0680525005,
-0.0189642366,
-0.0227203034,
0.0814604685,
-0.0256896447,
0.0091279484,
-0.0694258213,
0.0149944499,
-0.0252948422,
-0.0249062646,
0.0110743716,
0.0300394557,
0.0119482009,
0.0196624231,
-0.0235282481,
-0.01223573,
-0.0410408862,
-0.0597093292,
0.0443637669,
-0.0200491082,
0.0035527945,
0.0247688629,
0.0150574613,
0.06891343,
0.031358026,
-0.0042580464,
-0.0047195274,
-0.0561352484,
-0.012848855,
-0.0414128788,
-0.0146639189,
-0.0222727694,
-0.0288400035,
-0.0021802352,
-0.0031257956,
-0.0324259996,
-0.0051142345,
-0.0011529607,
2.723e-7,
0.0255140141,
0.0694677234,
-0.0112760086,
-0.0554747395,
0.0025255745,
0.0296433605,
-0.0041371887,
-0.0068739862,
0.0692249164,
0.004543981,
-0.0122727035,
-0.0117944218,
0.0389209762,
0.0155814253,
-0.0702350438,
-0.0713632926,
-0.0057562413,
-0.0286343526,
-0.0615601502,
0.0207090061,
0.0699955001,
-0.0283697341,
0.0558447465,
-0.0269471537,
-0.0508868471,
-0.0246158186,
0.0289205257,
0.0124144126,
0.002046692,
0.0547277331,
-0.0249504391,
-0.0279492103,
0.0129730534,
0.0623763986,
0.0236229002,
-0.0304062851,
0.0210909117,
0.0493381396,
0.0287486706,
0.0236889143,
0.0353745222,
0.0116113462,
0.0278535765,
-0.083315894,
0.0190940164,
0.0153419292,
0.0116008092,
-0.0151860099,
-0.0380331129,
-0.0385027491,
0.0343339927,
-0.0468999259,
-0.0063426672,
0.0074531981,
-0.0214131102,
0.0050474615,
0.0000271066,
0.0295078531,
-0.0308694504,
-0.0277021993,
-0.0117705893,
-0.0832232013,
-0.031192435,
-0.0283554122,
0.0244553126,
-0.0427113287,
-0.0290912669,
2.468481658e-34,
0.0021007357,
-0.0423641168,
0.0714749917,
-0.011682705,
0.0087050963,
0.0089708827,
-0.0122032361,
0.0138228042,
0.0096721593,
-0.0176868569,
-0.0417513102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15477v1 | CrisisSense-LLM: Instruction Fine-Tuned Large Language Model for Multi-label Social Media Text Classification in Disaster Informatics | 2024-06-16T23:01:10 | 2024-06-16T23:01:10 | Kai Yin, Chengkai Liu, Ali Mostafavi, Xia Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the field of crisis/disaster informatics, social media is increasingly
being used for improving situational awareness to inform response and relief
efforts. Efficient and accurate text classification tools have been a focal
area of investigation in crisis informatics. However, current methods mostly
rely on single-label text classification models, which fails to capture
different insights embedded in dynamic and multifaceted disaster-related social
media data. This study introduces a novel approach to disaster text
classification by enhancing a pre-trained Large Language Model (LLM) through
instruction fine-tuning targeted for multi-label classification of
disaster-related tweets. Our methodology involves creating a comprehensive
instruction dataset from disaster-related tweets, which is then used to
fine-tune an open-source LLM, thereby embedding it with disaster-specific
knowledge. This fine-tuned model can classify multiple aspects of
disaster-related information simultaneously, such as the type of event,
informativeness, and involvement of human aid, significantly improving the
utility of social media data for situational awareness in disasters. The
results demonstrate that this approach enhances the categorization of critical
information from social media posts, thereby facilitating a more effective
deployment for situational awareness during emergencies. This research paves
the way for more advanced, adaptable, and robust disaster management tools,
leveraging the capabilities of LLMs to improve real-time situational awareness
and response strategies in disaster scenarios. | [
0.0273515359,
0.0240333918,
-0.0029697041,
0.0043084207,
0.0120120887,
0.0475978404,
0.0090313721,
-0.0128954053,
0.0220640693,
-0.0961885452,
0.0357152596,
-0.0338025652,
-0.0635548383,
0.0220520198,
-0.000538499,
-0.0474191643,
0.0320932828,
-0.0034587407,
0.0595464297,
0.007673054,
0.0137400702,
0.0341628306,
-0.0046186768,
0.0275896117,
0.0008316044,
0.0270561948,
-0.0279930476,
0.0155296167,
0.0358447209,
-0.056427259,
0.0366075374,
0.0419907793,
0.0687906817,
0.0311214421,
0.0000017883,
-0.0152290724,
-0.031926997,
-0.0517536886,
0.0064164782,
-0.0298521984,
0.0180479884,
-0.0720281899,
0.0047829654,
0.0304380152,
-0.0441888757,
-0.0331064612,
0.0506816059,
0.0649283603,
0.0741075277,
0.0846541673,
-0.0068152747,
-0.061627578,
0.0409433991,
0.0274312217,
-0.0056208535,
-0.02426962,
0.0219451971,
0.0001794864,
0.0074248244,
0.0356977582,
0.0476879738,
0.0379825048,
-0.0046550231,
0.0468785465,
0.0125515815,
0.0273183342,
-0.0278055109,
-0.0063509946,
-0.0214802455,
0.0485009365,
-0.0169135537,
-0.0182680935,
0.0200716164,
-0.005182371,
0.0018839984,
-0.0009048957,
0.003205173,
-0.0166494269,
-0.0271840598,
0.0316520445,
0.0020741737,
0.0364350751,
0.021006478,
0.0485295169,
0.0065072682,
0.0160371885,
-0.0440696515,
-0.0318855084,
-0.0188215002,
0.0094866725,
-0.0468661003,
-0.0123619707,
0.0171748176,
0.0416053236,
-0.0475472733,
0.0003415889,
-0.0236165952,
-0.0262087546,
0.0169949066,
-0.1274473667,
-0.0246971846,
0.0023858773,
0.0023788351,
0.0252825804,
0.0273913518,
-0.0332969576,
0.0316447206,
0.0298513174,
-0.0095020598,
-0.0145367431,
-0.1146684289,
0.0065248068,
-0.0258788224,
0.0303335693,
0.0267986637,
0.0252284501,
-0.0379681513,
-0.0012472662,
0.0157313608,
-0.0348949321,
0.0104658836,
-0.0183487087,
-0.0218661483,
-0.022068575,
0.0032748296,
0.0084977215,
-0.0369643606,
0.051820185,
-0.0313545503,
-0.0151351662,
0.0478837974,
0.0057570231,
0.0248448625,
0.0001060784,
-0.0119352564,
0.0241428521,
-0.0390540473,
-0.0339832418,
-0.0805269033,
-0.0002873323,
0.0003643236,
-0.0007878941,
0.001494718,
-0.0591121502,
0.0201451648,
0.0269030966,
-0.0133482376,
0.0024088216,
0.0200839844,
-0.0384721272,
-0.0469528325,
0.0406586081,
-0.0642811358,
0.0438582525,
0.0505484156,
0.0050120298,
0.0691037327,
0.0756789222,
0.0336665623,
0.0526234396,
0.0767266899,
-0.046098832,
0.0123816421,
0.0003112158,
-0.054475408,
0.027422972,
-0.0407832414,
0.0001469481,
-0.0158750918,
0.01486851,
0.0020916774,
-0.0421885438,
0.0180697814,
0.0406764708,
0.0578326434,
0.0114840278,
0.0252415668,
0.014414967,
0.0269384496,
0.0874214992,
-0.0302006789,
-0.0359843411,
0.0075518922,
0.0138499085,
-0.0322860852,
0.0006333281,
0.0616112985,
0.0605867356,
-0.0529354922,
-0.0290350635,
-0.0325527936,
-0.0065348232,
-0.0276463609,
-0.0177853834,
0.0120505216,
-0.0340358317,
-0.0212695841,
0.0127472263,
0.0539823472,
-0.0170322265,
0.0223952029,
-0.0458864644,
-0.0323434919,
0.0858020037,
-0.0097089522,
-0.06503319,
-0.0207995418,
-0.0398692116,
0.0923551247,
0.0181660373,
0.0132092442,
0.0486963093,
-0.0010940394,
-0.0505913533,
-0.0374963991,
0.0051745237,
0.0233807862,
-0.005825629,
0.0015680622,
0.0349190012,
-0.0181345269,
0.0142109971,
-0.0696983337,
0.0388338715,
0.0319043621,
-0.0619414337,
-0.0289981924,
0.0332938619,
-0.0030931407,
0.011484216,
0.0236619823,
-0.0339726731,
0.0437814258,
-0.0174255148,
-0.0771098062,
-0.0070820153,
-0.0210486464,
0.0332836211,
0.0171150025,
-0.0070317881,
-0.0138818733,
0.0041748933,
-0.0799775794,
-0.005175624,
0.0325317606,
0.0073815486,
0.0005694901,
-0.0385266468,
-0.0053970586,
-0.0170887113,
-0.0184904933,
-0.0144664701,
0.0855711475,
0.0031657538,
0.0076855598,
-0.0900909975,
-0.024559373,
-0.0004448765,
0.030546343,
0.0062122326,
0.0034597374,
-0.026908299,
0.0666319728,
-0.0038435345,
0.0118153989,
-0.0278729796,
-0.0582533889,
-0.053499788,
0.0028254383,
-0.031555701,
0.0208987556,
0.0295655075,
-0.0109602762,
-0.0254387185,
0.0193038899,
0.0037034976,
0.0158042628,
-0.0001225291,
0.0172262676,
0.0135992942,
-0.0117647471,
0.0398798622,
-0.0170477722,
0.0022325043,
-0.0074159256,
0.0256253369,
0.0363233276,
-0.0792658329,
-0.041136831,
-0.0036094796,
-0.0360200778,
-0.0134601938,
0.0277411435,
-0.0995712653,
0.0089295693,
-0.0154447872,
0.0016708028,
-0.0518664904,
0.0491840243,
0.0568912402,
0.0094653619,
0.0158331208,
-0.003229439,
0.0142683927,
-0.0644081533,
-0.0873094052,
-0.0631304607,
-0.0022070818,
-0.0439508446,
0.0412118621,
-0.0192684494,
0.0192661155,
-0.0217787363,
-0.0464458503,
-0.0140976412,
0.0051658517,
-0.0479079969,
-0.0011301871,
-0.0007649863,
-0.0144529007,
-0.0024670721,
-0.0171808861,
0.0185055379,
0.0435093828,
0.0305961482,
-0.0480501167,
-0.0744612888,
-0.0659202412,
0.0443817936,
-0.0308785625,
0.0202318504,
0.0324096978,
-0.0008949403,
-0.0001353516,
-0.0221795831,
-0.0139796352,
-0.0265799034,
-0.0199298784,
-0.022232011,
0.0095159952,
0.0129749216,
-0.0031830973,
-0.0100394925,
-0.0522774123,
-0.0338628367,
-0.0120996311,
-0.0043208576,
0.0195450746,
-0.0678658411,
0.0225035083,
0.0601786673,
0.0180743262,
0.024774326,
-0.0296797771,
-0.0233028494,
0.0491242781,
-0.0086278236,
-0.0020878867,
-0.0027867178,
-0.0185917038,
0.0249469522,
0.0221384522,
0.0118453093,
-0.0431811251,
-0.01848289,
-0.0048441603,
0.0296727084,
-0.0295012519,
0.0114890849,
0.0159783382,
0.0438797176,
-0.0145479254,
0.0110067353,
0.0929975957,
0.0463328734,
-0.0744938701,
0.0097417347,
-0.0148398792,
-0.0084106633,
0.0335197933,
0.0082908869,
-0.0003970605,
-0.0366042331,
-0.0321950167,
0.005166498,
0.0046489304,
-0.0377055481,
0.0213780608,
-0.0321862288,
0.0184255596,
0.0076385788,
-0.0257911608,
-0.0095099304,
-0.0746535808,
0.0168441907,
0.0097894873,
-0.0165463649,
-0.042364236,
-0.0226745903,
-0.0123965675,
0.0330829397,
-0.0362083018,
-0.0825247988,
0.0004019741,
-0.0367614217,
0.0356148556,
0.0123368166,
0.0306431483,
-0.0321129039,
0.0172742065,
0.063219361,
-0.0159087572,
0.008009335,
-0.0059155049,
0.0431177467,
-0.0028354509,
0.0028806035,
-0.0040067197,
-0.0020040988,
-0.0798005387,
0.0028477223,
0.012011095,
0.0763266608,
-0.0096477987,
-0.0121403672,
-0.0320521854,
0.0071763815,
0.0768637285,
0.0280080419,
-0.0055017006,
-0.0506343395,
0.0054758862,
-0.0303500295,
0.0289538447,
-0.0274373963,
-0.0357948728,
0.0344262682,
-0.0485094748,
-0.0910393372,
-0.0262017362,
-0.0322330147,
0.0269768387,
-0.0122443624,
-0.0488273725,
-0.0040671071,
0.0395476967,
-0.0220447406,
-0.0249063913,
0.0346456431,
-0.0194788352,
0.0201127045,
-0.0467636064,
-0.0328284502,
0.013080542,
0.0091437893,
-0.0164925568,
0.0219935626,
-0.0468400531,
-0.0378600918,
0.0409564637,
-0.0238972548,
0.0154146869,
-0.0574611202,
0.0022290042,
-0.0588860735,
0.0221099872,
0.0902505219,
-0.0506693907,
-0.0362577699,
0.0076860925,
-0.0033337297,
0.0058435672,
0.0378811322,
-0.010795013,
0.0748058408,
0.0041596098,
0.0131265083,
-0.0849757344,
-0.0142630152,
-0.0307700578,
-0.0215288885,
0.0793931186,
0.0046102572,
-0.1120294631,
-0.0212856345,
-0.029204648,
0.0199225787,
-0.0223609321,
0.0201262962,
0.0448634736,
0.0199975707,
-0.0020102679,
-0.0229679942,
0.0309982225,
0.0178127643,
0.0060247234,
-0.0258755386,
0.0097981729,
0.0420647003,
0.0523886047,
-0.0043696123,
0.0057762046,
-0.0139506189,
0.030027315,
0.0341893323,
-0.0475359447,
-0.0068382039,
0.0121284863,
0.0037911453,
0.0218471158,
-0.0123031307,
0.0279856119,
-0.0255861022,
-0.0401904434,
-0.0303232893,
-0.0100121088,
0.0841219425,
0.0359617695,
-0.0009513791,
-0.0017920581,
-0.0145527404,
-0.0103204735,
0.0407634154,
-0.0100205438,
-0.0417209938,
0.0195625667,
0.0142190754,
-0.0495767109,
0.0467840433,
0.0452051498,
0.0268823691,
-0.0005563512,
0.0401315801,
-0.0289595965,
0.0026214796,
-0.0112868017,
-0.0009067947,
0.0639270544,
-0.0087304357,
0.0501035191,
-0.0373596475,
-0.0093963454,
0.0516004339,
-0.0545730107,
-0.0435206965,
0.0019602168,
0.0208807476,
0.0532542877,
-0.0019722697,
0.0340021141,
-0.0463336706,
-0.0092515098,
0.001717173,
-0.0041685915,
0.0057569658,
-6.400816533e-33,
0.0267150197,
-0.0615653507,
-0.0025620118,
-0.0416099206,
0.0032752175,
0.0267484747,
0.0127777243,
0.0221009832,
0.0000937649,
-0.0110811442,
0.0189467482,
0.0168121476,
0.0048822206,
-0.0092908712,
0.0427795574,
-0.0126769375,
-0.0025037345,
-0.0028808496,
0.0107331034,
0.0249610953,
0.0595705509,
0.0098930029,
0.0416902229,
-0.0990412682,
0.0033778572,
-0.0153107354,
-0.0141610792,
-0.0056306622,
0.0608295612,
0.0417451747,
-0.0394010656,
0.0803210586,
0.0544022173,
-0.0217496175,
0.0130097326,
0.0583638102,
0.0130579378,
-0.0096867634,
-0.0028522101,
-0.0418515392,
-0.0062404149,
-0.037352927,
-0.0040727626,
0.0448639728,
0.0040020603,
-0.0250722393,
0.0445839949,
0.0063996576,
0.0042750477,
-0.0263137817,
-0.07716389,
0.0319861509,
-0.0235296916,
0.0004897342,
-0.0044375742,
0.0268471017,
0.0114886202,
0.0576178171,
-0.0547645614,
0.0094866287,
-0.025352329,
0.0088368515,
0.0145169077,
-0.0203574374,
-0.0627564117,
0.0538050421,
-0.0504528992,
0.0123704812,
-0.0279795602,
-0.0089768572,
-0.0141770346,
0.0333268493,
0.038689971,
0.1220268011,
0.0188676082,
-0.0520840585,
-0.0745101944,
0.0044188546,
-0.0140454611,
0.0123029407,
0.0410616621,
0.017225394,
-0.0217951257,
0.004308573,
0.0039696516,
0.006754783,
-0.0473884493,
0.0175649561,
-0.0228297878,
0.0144636007,
0.0022566849,
0.0886274353,
0.0183011275,
0.0257098358,
-0.0178124961,
0.0202825665,
0.0115548521,
0.0601938702,
-0.0006782546,
0.0483191311,
-0.0676738992,
-0.028051421,
0.0236296095,
-0.0081005702,
0.0106162308,
-0.0129126655,
0.0413710587,
0.0226528551,
-0.0248018652,
0.0242863093,
0.0056411382,
0.0067045782,
-0.028824769,
-0.0174702182,
-0.0038024394,
0.0200466849,
0.0293531008,
0.0101202726,
0.054265935,
-0.0297030266,
0.0440399051,
-0.0419944488,
-0.0514437221,
0.0150574101,
0.018024385,
0.011408153,
-0.052300632,
-0.0196800847,
-0.014350391,
-0.0281170253,
-0.013225548,
0.0015289538,
2.554e-7,
0.056629464,
0.0863626972,
-0.012460202,
-0.0166048389,
0.0032675404,
0.0507766455,
0.0232646354,
0.0360195301,
0.0134088295,
-0.0309698619,
0.0101865409,
0.0684528723,
0.0574162677,
0.0428069457,
-0.0274432339,
-0.0116447145,
-0.0459808186,
0.0358690508,
-0.1027356684,
0.0196000542,
0.0976072401,
0.060844522,
0.0343871266,
-0.0017600174,
-0.0475014485,
-0.0492579415,
0.0286253504,
-0.0485811345,
-0.0299168732,
0.046090357,
0.0193894673,
0.0413416587,
-0.0337793231,
0.0237319451,
-0.0313002728,
-0.0430466235,
0.0274649598,
0.0435907952,
-0.0185059607,
-0.0087998761,
-0.0035504408,
-0.0207751729,
-0.0234694146,
-0.0463829897,
0.0467665009,
-0.0656830519,
-0.0275446512,
0.0488490351,
-0.0393552557,
0.0191578101,
0.0171891954,
-0.0483968966,
-0.0529982224,
0.0307346247,
0.000653863,
-0.0185594615,
-0.0387465805,
-0.0664583445,
0.0289582554,
0.0484543517,
-0.0222564675,
-0.0104303109,
-0.014589848,
0.0158135239,
0.077402994,
-0.0375098623,
0.0848175436,
1.867239371e-34,
0.0087980824,
0.0063704355,
-0.0341362469,
-0.0308253877,
0.0194288511,
0.0225084256,
-0.0482167415,
-0.0064938189,
-0.0090608895,
-0.0491302349,
0.0468527414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11097v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11097v2 | InstructCMP: Length Control in Sentence Compression through Instruction-based Large Language Models | 2024-06-16T23:00:47 | 2024-06-18T18:35:52 | Juseon-Do, Jingun Kwon, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Manabu Okumura | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Extractive summarization can produce faithful summaries but often requires
additional constraints such as a desired summary length. Traditional sentence
compression models do not typically consider the constraints because of their
restricted model abilities, which require model modifications for coping with
them. To bridge this gap, we propose Instruction-based Compression
(InstructCMP), an approach to the sentence compression task that can consider
the length constraint through instructions by leveraging the zero-shot
task-solving abilities of Large Language Models (LLMs). For this purpose, we
created new evaluation datasets by transforming traditional sentence
compression datasets into an instruction format. By using the datasets, we
first reveal that the current LLMs still face challenges in accurately
controlling the length for a compressed text. To address this issue, we propose
an approach named "length priming," that incorporates additional length
information into the instructions without external resources. While the length
priming effectively works in a zero-shot setting, a training dataset with the
instructions would further improve the ability of length control. Thus, we
additionally created a training dataset in an instruction format to fine-tune
the model on it. Experimental results and analysis show that applying the
length priming significantly improves performances of InstructCMP in both
zero-shot and fine-tuning settings without the need of any model modifications. | [
0.0247896798,
0.054407049,
0.0052181361,
0.0068992102,
-0.0414693616,
0.0090356143,
0.0229610987,
0.0184041131,
-0.0449384004,
-0.019881906,
0.0024837148,
0.0017591973,
0.0272642709,
-0.0314727426,
0.0384803005,
-0.0304393787,
-0.0041928287,
-0.0088712573,
-0.0177257322,
0.0174526908,
0.0336991698,
-0.0038055435,
0.0388590507,
0.020941779,
0.0054024132,
-0.0193965323,
-0.0132244965,
0.0192836262,
0.0135082239,
-0.002735706,
0.0059039276,
0.0242976286,
0.0484639257,
-0.0181666482,
0.0000018881,
-0.0310922042,
-0.0379409268,
0.0054229163,
-0.058306627,
0.0399693809,
0.0665972009,
-0.0572636351,
0.0321704671,
0.0333758183,
-0.0095818397,
-0.0169350971,
0.0235870853,
0.0595161244,
0.0802219808,
0.1010428667,
-0.0184745621,
-0.0312496144,
-0.0118266279,
-0.0659220219,
-0.0164229833,
-0.0172224734,
0.0294508059,
0.0050970106,
0.0093276268,
0.0116402535,
-0.0459652878,
0.0307725053,
0.0444702245,
0.0146917617,
-0.0058929869,
0.0116537223,
-0.0370799191,
-0.0097850561,
0.0025598456,
0.0503325872,
-0.0037664503,
-0.0168843362,
0.0112342928,
0.0184595156,
0.0171830263,
-0.0366999321,
-0.0886673555,
0.068330884,
0.0232056137,
0.0309636109,
-0.0196967032,
0.0435981639,
-0.014165842,
-0.0027128689,
-0.0344487727,
0.0209850017,
0.0008266793,
-0.0468053743,
-0.0191076286,
-0.0125413639,
-0.02151726,
-0.0472423919,
-0.0186560918,
0.033856459,
-0.0180882905,
-0.0082121938,
-0.0802596211,
-0.0661875382,
0.016791502,
-0.0018684382,
0.076664269,
0.0239862408,
0.0365360193,
0.0487060547,
-0.0382326841,
0.0936507881,
0.0249092784,
-0.0052496111,
-0.0608923733,
0.0015478916,
-0.0470372885,
0.0205032658,
-0.0358456932,
0.0237616766,
-0.0427618325,
-0.0102275815,
-0.0335897356,
0.0165889896,
0.0212060977,
0.0133831101,
0.0290766042,
-0.0242043119,
-0.0283115879,
-0.0270796269,
0.0219385251,
0.038312804,
-0.0431712009,
0.0048232041,
0.0082366709,
-0.0017243441,
-0.0605378412,
0.031410601,
0.0246161968,
-0.0111741852,
0.0401943624,
0.0313748196,
-0.0288789459,
-0.0390336514,
0.0068310834,
-0.0393400118,
-0.0139153274,
-0.0579462871,
-0.0114963707,
-0.0649414286,
0.0337335244,
-0.0257652868,
0.0046198433,
-0.0158747323,
0.0015172842,
0.0052854004,
-0.0555553995,
0.0323422477,
0.0199110191,
0.0346365012,
-0.004677156,
-0.0007629876,
0.076041922,
0.0734452307,
0.0428275913,
0.0549476556,
0.027859401,
0.0046076602,
-0.0036714666,
0.0436791442,
0.0446223244,
0.0299853124,
-0.019737551,
-0.0036238011,
-0.0069599617,
-0.0071733836,
0.0390024073,
0.0768219233,
-0.0477570444,
0.0148844952,
0.0563867763,
0.0355509371,
0.027733935,
0.0214296542,
0.0409301817,
0.0232186988,
-0.0047960621,
0.0439806059,
-0.0143907219,
0.0139053734,
-0.0392335355,
0.0620594732,
0.100277558,
0.0195053499,
-0.037687216,
-0.0505231656,
-0.0140401525,
-0.0221408568,
0.0285962839,
0.0183315556,
-0.0052802642,
0.0042186347,
-0.0445845574,
0.026392648,
-0.0069638244,
-0.0637051538,
-0.0141749103,
-0.0148563897,
-0.0131833013,
0.0391673967,
0.0554317385,
-0.0028018835,
-0.0221466031,
-0.0268117543,
0.0249530561,
0.0297010001,
0.0020083764,
-0.0239451826,
0.0030806786,
-0.0680777133,
-0.0247411057,
-0.0234107636,
0.0075085675,
-0.0356997438,
0.0315676741,
-0.015407023,
0.0357348472,
-0.0082957195,
-0.0432010852,
0.0344227031,
-0.0320614502,
-0.0553634875,
0.0076388321,
-0.0083695604,
0.0312846862,
-0.0129377162,
-0.0352940932,
0.0050315182,
0.0212204214,
-0.0690911114,
-0.0168254673,
-0.039064873,
-0.038248539,
-0.0684398636,
0.0496997833,
-0.068771787,
0.0138119468,
0.0336262546,
-0.047700014,
-0.042473983,
-0.0043126144,
-0.0578830652,
0.0120453192,
-0.0244879313,
0.0247894488,
0.0104785897,
0.010756176,
-0.035407953,
0.0252267122,
-0.0130368778,
-0.0066494741,
0.0419083275,
-0.0511836149,
-0.0133846309,
-0.0249460079,
-0.0169225298,
-0.0100183254,
0.005855727,
-0.0163643118,
0.0614875741,
0.0438061617,
-0.0083372546,
-0.0374002717,
-0.1062870473,
0.047833275,
-0.0084059341,
0.0106240772,
0.0301110353,
0.0089094006,
-0.0167544596,
0.0094333105,
-0.0439234413,
-0.0311359335,
0.0116545269,
0.0031227395,
0.0170908626,
0.0092132045,
0.0163441636,
-0.0416799076,
-0.0401917025,
0.0169266462,
0.0468863994,
-0.0337808542,
-0.0214794129,
-0.0224161446,
0.0785355046,
-0.0060953326,
-0.017474534,
0.016491117,
-0.0472940765,
-0.042641975,
-0.0132796345,
0.0690455511,
0.0688340664,
0.0059731337,
0.0274164472,
0.0555317514,
-0.0182963479,
-0.0206058063,
0.0294493269,
-0.0492503121,
-0.01823112,
-0.0091465134,
-0.0493038222,
-0.002912963,
0.0797333345,
-0.0072370577,
0.0024098158,
-0.0594086088,
-0.0075840568,
-0.0134062227,
-0.0083666146,
-0.0151311895,
-0.0162376687,
0.0149129322,
0.0028501076,
-0.0426536053,
-0.0314708054,
0.0573988743,
-0.039747335,
-0.0098047769,
-0.0442977846,
-0.0108706197,
-0.072164923,
0.050146848,
0.0180121493,
0.0189111382,
0.0345331095,
0.0381105207,
-0.04481408,
-0.0003274782,
0.0325707346,
-0.0230657086,
0.0095918635,
-0.0215166193,
-0.0067308191,
-0.054576844,
-0.0171624608,
-0.0062299315,
-0.0587990172,
0.0133282496,
0.0248672422,
0.0544182509,
0.0095323604,
-0.0487307273,
0.0177879427,
0.0368011706,
0.0433423258,
-0.0408426784,
0.0131347151,
-0.0162489321,
0.0182285421,
0.077408202,
0.0015541728,
0.0046017766,
-0.0597328022,
0.0345539227,
0.0237961262,
0.0204115622,
0.0226600487,
0.0221840423,
0.013801652,
0.0134505378,
-0.0218518078,
0.0141871301,
0.0353354737,
0.0699860901,
-0.0500266403,
-0.0179946944,
0.1177223176,
0.0418519937,
-0.0324278474,
-0.0145553146,
0.0180806872,
0.0373811647,
0.0085578701,
0.0274134725,
-0.0747086927,
-0.0318345167,
0.0318584256,
0.0001571907,
-0.0103943376,
-0.0060128351,
-0.0468019694,
-0.1208144948,
0.0189779773,
0.0468554385,
0.0010853966,
-0.022923179,
-0.0184942819,
0.0097358488,
-0.0047276425,
0.015610571,
0.0176682174,
-0.0531438068,
0.0060847658,
0.0068360926,
-0.0423154533,
-0.0308982618,
-0.0118481293,
0.0055039525,
0.0449197739,
0.0450041182,
0.0082445266,
0.0116572324,
0.0251172725,
0.0208858773,
0.0019135061,
-0.0217995569,
-0.024628479,
0.0538181663,
-0.011510429,
0.0183844119,
-0.0001990195,
0.0683988854,
0.0107991649,
0.0180012938,
0.030039547,
0.0395841338,
0.0303409565,
-0.0242755543,
-0.0494069122,
-0.0076985457,
-0.0250874441,
0.0890702382,
0.0609126501,
-0.0115272831,
-0.0451449752,
-0.0094257155,
-0.0562469512,
-0.0808559135,
-0.0180214755,
0.0018649725,
-0.0389856584,
0.0131342066,
-0.056155704,
-0.0264488142,
0.0519447923,
-0.0157870445,
0.0018239297,
-0.0425453037,
-0.0187071227,
0.0150055764,
-0.0659570247,
-0.0325286724,
-0.0466120429,
-0.008246813,
-0.0713220462,
0.0105301449,
0.0040641511,
-0.004710238,
0.0058572232,
0.027811097,
-0.1104983389,
-0.0630944818,
-0.0619044043,
0.0471747518,
0.0172888972,
0.0803786367,
0.0184474047,
-0.0341894105,
0.0664920136,
0.0202824157,
-0.0459274314,
0.057721056,
0.0332376808,
-0.0316727795,
0.0194067117,
0.0423318259,
-0.0351938233,
0.0603943393,
0.0129502183,
0.044488959,
-0.0424334668,
-0.031136442,
0.0342238694,
0.0356525257,
0.0096701169,
-0.0053900117,
0.0080804825,
0.0070103663,
-0.0009916273,
-0.0413975194,
-0.0097149201,
-0.033117,
0.0257219747,
0.00247939,
0.0209415313,
0.0199286491,
0.0413762257,
-0.0117203658,
-0.0017916737,
-0.0437653512,
0.0191907529,
-0.0530297123,
-0.0742881745,
-0.0144890333,
0.0192034375,
-0.0342040621,
-0.0173996314,
-0.0140514486,
-0.001006021,
-0.0025244283,
0.0065027885,
0.0262668896,
0.0634915456,
-0.0423706695,
0.0383515805,
-0.0342288204,
0.0528414287,
-0.0385823585,
0.0263887923,
0.0561227277,
-0.0421423614,
0.0357545391,
-0.0054116622,
-0.000537439,
-0.0278199855,
0.0076061608,
-0.0046068965,
0.0050873077,
-0.0171631705,
0.0290087871,
-0.0086878454,
-0.0063901986,
0.1031760201,
0.0114824558,
0.0219497792,
0.0124263987,
-0.0043283105,
-0.0485224798,
-0.0224206187,
-0.0151003748,
0.0053182603,
0.0129738441,
-0.0056325095,
-0.02015936,
-0.0334118232,
0.0084838346,
0.0111204311,
0.0197024327,
-0.014016876,
0.0342557281,
0.0024740268,
-0.02177082,
-0.0130154565,
-0.021140337,
-0.0227940474,
0.005661888,
-0.0352656618,
0.0005410117,
-5.788918091e-33,
-0.0342230611,
0.0207539797,
0.0258569084,
-0.0194233153,
-0.0560631342,
0.0316373818,
-0.0422514379,
-0.0059167817,
0.0213950928,
0.0055437386,
-0.0388866886,
-0.013714578,
0.0000769933,
0.0343105383,
0.0070610479,
0.0325014554,
0.0717261285,
-0.0182331037,
-0.0414379053,
0.0146236718,
0.0043220599,
0.0087677445,
0.0052373554,
0.025970716,
-0.0052333986,
-0.0226435922,
-0.0347862393,
-0.0049563036,
0.0528931916,
0.053274978,
-0.0081415474,
0.0048195757,
0.0264638085,
-0.0775284916,
-0.0519754924,
0.0521072969,
-0.0744019747,
-0.0245263875,
0.0525504388,
-0.0523749068,
-0.0436216667,
-0.0941995084,
0.0183753651,
-0.0197348539,
-0.0044244775,
-0.0668581501,
0.0164743941,
-0.0664202273,
-0.0120008625,
-0.059396252,
-0.0195922889,
-0.0069285403,
-0.0379154906,
-0.0639989674,
0.0760531574,
0.0528172292,
-0.0208248459,
-0.0016619255,
0.00268362,
0.0457184464,
0.0400987007,
0.0916768759,
0.0249935016,
-0.0006850898,
0.0131464163,
0.0115749789,
-0.0462935418,
-0.0263333339,
-0.029288413,
0.0227607954,
0.0079163592,
-0.004591566,
0.0449769311,
0.0298479572,
0.063540861,
0.0017214959,
-0.0609449558,
0.0344910733,
0.0138646085,
0.0393497497,
0.0319455303,
0.0171878356,
-0.0034501769,
-0.016708836,
-0.0254073832,
0.0247195885,
0.0006891638,
-0.015242395,
0.0127318986,
0.0477196649,
-0.0152743608,
-0.0163012836,
0.0694087669,
-0.0370130949,
0.033064805,
0.0291574337,
-0.0230669342,
0.0324387923,
0.0112779634,
-0.0081432303,
-0.0725543424,
0.0282953959,
0.0468432307,
-0.0238456205,
0.001282739,
0.0019119056,
0.0650273114,
0.0237791743,
-0.0384721197,
-0.0132020861,
-0.0035403734,
0.0156612191,
-0.0163890887,
0.0122087486,
0.0037305055,
0.053729713,
-0.0026500414,
0.0219892375,
-0.0086639384,
-0.0348130427,
-0.0135636758,
-0.001951301,
0.0296718776,
0.0299632959,
-0.0148183797,
0.0242525656,
-0.0454932041,
0.0143962717,
0.0166846234,
-0.0338428877,
-0.0211263355,
0.0177365541,
2.483e-7,
-0.0086086644,
0.0536650829,
0.057570789,
-0.0061324569,
-0.0015903335,
-0.0008867437,
-0.021317739,
0.0246334746,
0.002610889,
-0.0151416874,
0.0589688458,
0.050375402,
0.0682922453,
0.0021532881,
-0.0976891294,
0.0162960589,
-0.0414457507,
-0.0136891268,
-0.0564708486,
-0.0324525461,
0.0668223426,
0.1066200957,
0.0112361135,
0.0302181449,
-0.0116277141,
-0.0027942788,
0.0288715456,
-0.0251345485,
-0.0418843776,
0.0133155854,
0.0010070233,
0.0063614417,
-0.0430519879,
0.0004409725,
-0.0080650523,
0.0129110944,
0.0056633065,
0.088169083,
0.0229116082,
0.0020396747,
0.0081839422,
-0.0151287206,
-0.0477190278,
0.0152226556,
0.079766877,
-0.0598206706,
-0.0061344025,
-0.0274774395,
-0.007744519,
0.0136824679,
-0.0064773434,
-0.0157853924,
-0.0026798751,
0.0374093093,
0.027263049,
0.0123517942,
-0.0036788299,
-0.0704720318,
-0.0175454263,
0.0306418687,
-0.0206433237,
-0.0055151954,
-0.0347272456,
0.0132357487,
-0.0011727872,
-0.0924182534,
-0.020682903,
2.742208145e-34,
0.0526237637,
-0.0095610917,
0.0142371962,
-0.0089310696,
0.0122292032,
-0.0656852424,
-0.0627630278,
0.0273964442,
0.0091929017,
-0.1155196056,
-0.0263515674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11096v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11096v2 | The Potential and Challenges of Evaluating Attitudes, Opinions, and Values in Large Language Models | 2024-06-16T22:59:18 | 2024-07-01T10:04:09 | Bolei Ma, Xinpeng Wang, Tiancheng Hu, Anna-Carolina Haensch, Michael A. Hedderich, Barbara Plank, Frauke Kreuter | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) have sparked wide interest in
validating and comprehending the human-like cognitive-behavioral traits LLMs
may have. These cognitive-behavioral traits include typically Attitudes,
Opinions, Values (AOV). However, measuring AOV embedded within LLMs remains
opaque, and different evaluation methods may yield different results. This has
led to a lack of clarity on how different studies are related to each other and
how they can be interpreted. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing an
overview of recent works on the evaluation of AOV in LLMs. Moreover, we survey
related approaches in different stages of the evaluation pipeline in these
works. By doing so, we address the potential and challenges with respect to
understanding the model, human-AI alignment, and downstream application in
social sciences. Finally, we provide practical insights into evaluation
methods, model enhancement, and interdisciplinary collaboration, thereby
contributing to the evolving landscape of evaluating AOV in LLMs. | [
0.0357358381,
0.0773490667,
-0.0110243801,
0.0289171692,
-0.045273561,
0.0310406927,
-0.0063451915,
-0.035317339,
0.0403090678,
-0.0298486371,
-0.0715223998,
-0.0499983281,
-0.0133532397,
0.0235018246,
-0.0212928075,
-0.0064377566,
0.0402803011,
0.0073002386,
0.0776864886,
-0.0106205847,
0.0154993739,
0.0357169919,
0.0126472907,
0.0252711568,
0.0206752941,
0.0033833508,
0.0180590041,
-0.0399195626,
0.0484680384,
-0.026429899,
-0.0213465877,
0.0225647315,
-0.005870373,
0.0038407622,
0.0000020849,
-0.0712144375,
0.0055419635,
-0.0204496514,
0.0202553812,
0.0289230254,
0.0910735428,
0.0359928235,
-0.0077591338,
0.0125532383,
-0.0561262965,
0.0185955409,
0.0017057775,
0.005812909,
0.0286747981,
0.0300111547,
-0.0054536923,
-0.0115493434,
-0.025132576,
0.0096380422,
-0.0242200922,
-0.0125087891,
0.0409682952,
0.0168317426,
-0.0431711338,
0.0110873831,
0.0187482294,
0.026026696,
-0.0003853478,
-0.0054429821,
0.0015187431,
-0.023826275,
-0.0192260295,
-0.0475705862,
0.0100944005,
0.0443022773,
0.0587346926,
0.0050370912,
-0.0178146958,
-0.0084198844,
0.0261363108,
0.0287823547,
-0.0236184467,
0.0262258984,
0.027823627,
0.0197645966,
0.0365605392,
0.046567034,
0.0010700757,
0.0477974452,
-0.0344494879,
0.0872367918,
-0.020411592,
-0.0208286978,
0.0207101237,
0.0029243936,
-0.0443399809,
-0.0340791419,
0.0168166645,
0.0362202711,
-0.0159578379,
0.0279544909,
-0.0118765077,
0.0222763699,
0.0390500315,
-0.0930861756,
0.0705826506,
0.0310097616,
-0.0133356573,
0.0371965058,
0.0240203254,
0.0645550862,
0.0235504825,
-0.0053242934,
-0.0217401162,
0.0104093645,
-0.0465493724,
0.0070507699,
0.0145946546,
0.0221224166,
0.0296197124,
-0.0045089624,
-0.037085209,
0.0024473418,
-0.0376939103,
0.0022054764,
-0.0087569831,
-0.0098845446,
0.0472705252,
-0.0130677437,
-0.0804232284,
0.0417023934,
-0.0445709489,
0.0300764386,
-0.0288596693,
-0.0295603946,
0.0750394091,
0.0126818232,
-0.021015415,
-0.0310805123,
0.0132092601,
0.0542891882,
0.0138424234,
-0.0055103945,
-0.0194146875,
-0.0051112673,
-0.0341521837,
-0.0956134051,
-0.0250253286,
-0.0454286076,
0.0020141662,
0.0310394708,
0.002922581,
-0.0648101345,
-0.0073303371,
0.0258467644,
-0.0422188826,
0.0169829875,
0.025295753,
0.0300842859,
-0.0021928509,
0.0145048285,
0.0227160174,
0.0439667851,
0.0231928863,
0.0254642311,
0.0383527316,
-0.0093125217,
-0.0184013117,
0.0223769192,
0.0026089633,
-0.0100181857,
-0.0554096475,
0.0404657312,
-0.0355886333,
0.0144490665,
0.0229081139,
0.1171542704,
0.0066851294,
-0.0262427591,
0.0794525445,
0.0527751558,
-0.045749791,
0.0101769157,
0.0304622799,
0.0140747279,
0.050450597,
-0.0200803336,
-0.0276138578,
0.0301676393,
-0.022978723,
-0.0097240219,
0.0256857239,
0.0487830751,
-0.0064662481,
-0.0606028251,
-0.0278144293,
0.0169260409,
0.0569257364,
0.0189629141,
0.0214814693,
-0.0597893782,
0.0077244351,
-0.0542031117,
-0.0031262059,
-0.0704924315,
0.0075736837,
-0.0809366181,
0.0346182585,
0.0697897002,
0.0219971947,
0.0302943159,
0.0034163932,
0.0049864524,
-0.0474760979,
0.037659131,
0.0682760701,
-0.0379911028,
-0.0528152287,
-0.0255722404,
0.0310163721,
0.0167259611,
0.0051250998,
-0.0105432589,
0.0079346029,
0.0414287113,
-0.0198037457,
-0.0370380878,
-0.0419220291,
0.0021149495,
-0.0496638417,
-0.0034259669,
-0.0553928018,
0.0357917249,
0.0507564172,
0.0507819317,
0.0130323358,
0.0302725881,
0.0062315683,
0.0161014646,
-0.0160205886,
0.0196425971,
-0.0257479269,
0.0408199281,
0.0371817984,
0.0018994396,
-0.0033440983,
0.0254157856,
0.0286842268,
0.0144717153,
-0.0015534511,
-0.012393252,
0.0224003717,
-0.0394412503,
0.0265733656,
-0.074454695,
-0.0131354155,
-0.0402307771,
0.0434984714,
-0.0302446503,
-0.0049818917,
0.0145822763,
-0.0569803044,
0.0498609543,
-0.0072570825,
-0.0537764803,
-0.0212526154,
0.0218840707,
0.0145899123,
0.0458322391,
-0.0005816339,
-0.0463746265,
-0.0318177678,
-0.0824268609,
-0.047998134,
0.006822424,
0.0310435575,
0.0119058993,
-0.0400113054,
-0.0219068453,
0.0580117293,
-0.0542167351,
-0.0115674352,
0.0185315385,
0.0428677276,
0.0279406067,
-0.0196630824,
-0.0130725037,
-0.0446004383,
0.0071434816,
-0.0246038176,
0.0095564453,
0.0112504084,
-0.0043717725,
-0.0269300863,
0.0344252288,
-0.0766227767,
-0.0120062903,
-0.0077146343,
-0.0683793798,
0.019640835,
0.017622117,
0.0510638915,
0.0674276277,
0.0187076665,
0.0499062687,
0.0540766828,
0.0024186145,
-0.058987692,
-0.0316661969,
-0.0337984487,
0.002899552,
-0.0319221988,
-0.0633630902,
-0.009153109,
0.0720060244,
0.0062073688,
-0.0079255458,
-0.0469571576,
0.0373180434,
-0.0668948218,
-0.0453290492,
-0.0298185404,
-0.0155346273,
-0.0091440091,
0.0591168627,
0.0157459956,
-0.0502078608,
0.0860615969,
0.0048146429,
0.043098513,
-0.0385068171,
-0.0319306217,
-0.0481776819,
0.0493718795,
-0.0152897956,
0.0123072769,
0.0016364475,
0.0403440185,
-0.0369840972,
-0.0341981165,
-0.0396516509,
-0.05700076,
0.0320068561,
-0.0143104345,
-0.0119026871,
0.0415521897,
-0.005343887,
0.004851996,
-0.0175354686,
-0.0630710721,
0.011545158,
0.0562447086,
-0.0390522219,
-0.0077145305,
0.0101154372,
0.0393438786,
-0.0741136298,
0.0023662748,
-0.0131477546,
0.0137295583,
-0.0094764428,
0.0762150958,
0.0196816511,
0.0716929361,
-0.0173739512,
0.0086330455,
0.0278403703,
0.0170122404,
0.0034385119,
-0.0123068588,
-0.0145550193,
0.046280168,
0.0051069628,
-0.0130199157,
0.0210722387,
0.0489025712,
-0.0012021231,
0.0105379419,
0.1160623804,
0.0494126193,
-0.0418695286,
0.0125232842,
-0.0281848386,
0.0379816443,
0.0200856104,
0.0114672724,
-0.0475832336,
-0.0089158127,
-0.0181883331,
-0.0079312362,
-0.0560794212,
-0.0311952122,
0.0088137211,
-0.1044825986,
-0.0002185361,
-0.0089615081,
-0.0199753437,
-0.0313445218,
-0.0167647675,
0.0354140326,
-0.0355185531,
0.0138146533,
-0.0110363979,
-0.0061387201,
-0.007665548,
0.0035170068,
-0.0317279026,
-0.0483719073,
0.068352066,
-0.025126731,
0.0908945203,
0.0557085834,
0.0580586642,
-0.0039688107,
-0.0874678791,
-0.0034831788,
0.0118169272,
-0.0066700438,
0.0116075585,
0.0102743302,
-0.045769427,
0.0187543109,
-0.0554753877,
-0.0117862225,
-0.0164987352,
-0.0097468058,
-0.0142010218,
0.0779972151,
-0.0114170164,
-0.0256290827,
-0.0407864898,
0.0240326431,
0.0175771192,
0.1086947769,
0.0105681792,
-0.0842314139,
0.0224729534,
-0.0208642446,
-0.0304225646,
0.0013708235,
-0.0799997002,
0.0104024457,
0.0073461472,
0.0050226259,
-0.0484238975,
-0.0659947693,
0.0094757155,
-0.0166763347,
-0.0076462384,
-0.0367440134,
0.0267355684,
0.0010962541,
-0.0348623469,
0.016084522,
-0.0209724847,
0.049206268,
-0.0442816056,
-0.002091568,
0.0429366603,
-0.0241597407,
-0.0262058806,
-0.0083704302,
-0.0141265588,
-0.0457218774,
0.0447096378,
0.0235779081,
0.0208482426,
-0.0367095806,
0.0041893097,
-0.0459241718,
0.0221260302,
0.0160192419,
-0.0156325009,
0.0317035466,
-0.0042272406,
0.0899965763,
0.0059761466,
0.0398647822,
0.0171992555,
0.0225809235,
0.0172356423,
-0.0180729814,
-0.040849492,
-0.056222789,
0.0056911092,
0.0249535367,
0.0091036521,
0.0059910095,
-0.0033114266,
-0.0221856665,
-0.067976959,
-0.0280429423,
-0.0454989783,
-0.033827614,
-0.051328823,
0.0300476346,
0.0152366497,
-0.0625575185,
-0.0075309761,
-0.0153292492,
0.0145267127,
-0.0185619351,
0.0383610129,
0.0021875324,
0.0351200216,
0.0060280636,
0.0007000163,
-0.0288658701,
0.0060905349,
-0.0503974333,
0.0210559834,
0.012445841,
0.0771431997,
0.009818498,
-0.0138444491,
0.013235745,
0.0431937017,
-0.0172821339,
-0.0220237523,
-0.0010821976,
0.0251655634,
-0.0139932269,
-0.0104809431,
0.0485934354,
-0.0312430598,
0.0067420709,
-0.0439597704,
0.0065984111,
-0.0186603088,
-0.0495388918,
0.0469673015,
0.00905996,
-0.0250763055,
-0.0015734013,
0.0220746528,
-0.022472769,
0.0072147949,
-0.0143802511,
-0.0495202839,
-0.0252114236,
0.0015128885,
0.0098899528,
-0.0248783641,
-0.0357432403,
0.0098189535,
-0.1092512906,
-0.0592532232,
-0.018082289,
0.0337647013,
0.0059192493,
-0.0420616046,
0.0050308676,
0.07148882,
-0.0322506465,
0.0102755222,
-0.0429807641,
-0.0244094878,
-0.0948404595,
0.0035805556,
-0.0415465645,
-6.467253269e-33,
-0.0232620779,
-0.0405632965,
0.0145089561,
-0.0287443809,
-0.0310936421,
-0.0425680913,
-0.0030973451,
0.0558067523,
-0.0565095879,
0.0278077833,
0.0069456031,
-0.0126585551,
-0.0016358582,
-0.0213971678,
0.0241445992,
-0.0225730576,
0.0075704153,
-0.0259520728,
-0.0292836372,
-0.0203927755,
0.0272541028,
-0.0553242527,
0.0145938098,
-0.085126929,
0.0645247325,
0.0198749434,
-0.0239201188,
0.0098309051,
-0.0140919322,
0.0653237253,
-0.0348821692,
0.0432094783,
0.031959191,
-0.0056960508,
0.0137041574,
0.0409171544,
-0.0092673404,
-0.0173603892,
0.0446091667,
-0.0014756175,
-0.008880049,
-0.0310207158,
-0.0074125752,
-0.010253245,
-0.0955230296,
0.0209012274,
0.0400137156,
-0.0348030739,
0.0493071601,
0.0068308925,
-0.0526659228,
0.000521864,
-0.0097431093,
0.0066294703,
0.0012726104,
0.0211088527,
-0.0285457,
0.048206374,
-0.0598376952,
0.0512215942,
0.0034589132,
-0.0110253952,
0.064394623,
-0.0171843469,
0.0058490331,
0.0761742145,
0.0104662329,
0.0203846712,
-0.0404122807,
0.001998096,
0.068500258,
-0.0054542022,
0.0341051146,
0.0490324013,
-0.0285851248,
-0.0171744302,
-0.0042767646,
0.0088496599,
0.0475398488,
0.0175095219,
0.0476373322,
0.0213230066,
-0.041690819,
-0.0183881335,
-0.0297730099,
-0.0483667664,
-0.0383530855,
-0.0274427161,
0.0362195857,
-0.0374897309,
-0.0253048986,
-0.012922735,
0.0547279939,
-0.0262730177,
-0.0262548067,
0.0404466577,
-0.0351493172,
0.0603950545,
0.0132065536,
0.029233573,
-0.112588428,
0.0284111407,
-0.0412227623,
0.0307991542,
0.0215576608,
0.018607799,
-0.003211396,
0.0255798437,
-0.0529931709,
-0.0223322194,
0.007408632,
-0.0115645174,
-0.0064943307,
-0.0214538965,
0.0250633713,
0.0044054841,
0.0054443404,
0.0279294625,
-0.0113430303,
-0.0046731094,
-0.0118981712,
-0.004579701,
-0.0018089716,
0.004830929,
-0.0385768674,
0.0017291843,
-0.0274122581,
-0.0021629108,
-0.016822163,
0.0023307968,
0.0032463712,
-0.0022892144,
2.719e-7,
0.0365392119,
0.0854297206,
-0.0305068195,
0.0502511933,
-0.0123558659,
0.0454572439,
-0.0162233189,
-0.0333645493,
0.0610841066,
-0.0139165362,
0.0219240803,
0.032568071,
0.0491443537,
0.0257086474,
-0.0439111516,
0.017966792,
-0.013871612,
0.002271978,
-0.0031301156,
0.0504313558,
0.0485591143,
0.0356655344,
0.0268061403,
0.0248222854,
-0.0177383106,
0.0059400173,
0.0373382233,
-0.0552625097,
-0.0109155085,
0.0298967045,
-0.0020389582,
-0.0105065452,
0.008130135,
0.0114042955,
0.0270889159,
0.0038979256,
0.0218358226,
0.0754670873,
0.0105997995,
-0.0196231771,
0.0000312427,
0.001897083,
-0.010825525,
-0.0738128871,
0.0591463707,
-0.0636747554,
-0.0564979911,
-0.0571967065,
-0.0075535448,
-0.0073603638,
0.0338593498,
-0.0033992149,
-0.029109234,
0.0009844166,
0.0416263118,
-0.0140153635,
-0.0186945591,
-0.037311174,
0.0102799209,
-0.0327871032,
-0.0128920982,
-0.0999649391,
-0.0234096795,
0.0178924184,
-0.0005860053,
-0.071993351,
0.0026668839,
2.21114046e-34,
0.0527803153,
-0.0159029458,
0.0083374493,
-0.0174245685,
0.0750295296,
0.0361564085,
-0.0147171132,
0.019646531,
0.0414268039,
-0.0893800482,
0.0213318951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11093v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11093v1 | RAEmoLLM: Retrieval Augmented LLMs for Cross-Domain Misinformation Detection Using In-Context Learning based on Emotional Information | 2024-06-16T22:49:11 | 2024-06-16T22:49:11 | Zhiwei Liu, Kailai Yang, Qianqian Xie, Christine de Kock, Sophia Ananiadou, Eduard Hovy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Misinformation is prevalent in various fields such as education, politics,
health, etc., causing significant harm to society. However, current methods for
cross-domain misinformation detection rely on time and resources consuming
fine-tuning and complex model structures. With the outstanding performance of
LLMs, many studies have employed them for misinformation detection.
Unfortunately, they focus on in-domain tasks and do not incorporate significant
sentiment and emotion features (which we jointly call affect). In this paper,
we propose RAEmoLLM, the first retrieval augmented (RAG) LLMs framework to
address cross-domain misinformation detection using in-context learning based
on affective information. It accomplishes this by applying an emotion-aware LLM
to construct a retrieval database of affective embeddings. This database is
used by our retrieval module to obtain source-domain samples, which are
subsequently used for the inference module's in-context few-shot learning to
detect target domain misinformation. We evaluate our framework on three
misinformation benchmarks. Results show that RAEmoLLM achieves significant
improvements compared to the zero-shot method on three datasets, with the
highest increases of 20.69%, 23.94%, and 39.11% respectively. This work will be
released on https://github.com/lzw108/RAEmoLLM. | [
0.0108212344,
-0.0056864363,
-0.0069762934,
0.0596109219,
-0.0016018626,
0.0140121225,
-0.0136359613,
-0.0027379356,
0.0340503938,
-0.049964264,
-0.0637242869,
-0.030197138,
-0.0215182416,
-0.0161463562,
0.0038483797,
-0.0262050722,
0.0622249506,
0.0617387444,
0.0406255461,
0.0050254175,
0.0238556787,
0.0122512812,
0.0042277002,
0.0241026729,
-0.0332271345,
-0.0431166217,
0.019015871,
0.0365650766,
0.0772822127,
-0.0483366959,
0.0686774924,
-0.0019372355,
0.0624514371,
0.0473977663,
0.0000019644,
0.0012095632,
-0.0282393005,
0.0126784686,
-0.0189040024,
-0.0277377758,
0.0771721378,
-0.0526569076,
-0.0033575995,
0.0275914539,
-0.0075506764,
-0.0037809098,
0.0317078717,
0.0873424411,
0.0782504901,
0.117770575,
-0.0086451583,
-0.0202922951,
-0.0165309366,
-0.0172201097,
0.049668923,
-0.0462265834,
0.0531236604,
-0.0332911685,
-0.0213401001,
0.0270000417,
0.0021427292,
0.0026537252,
-0.026281843,
0.0198369212,
-0.0171604939,
-0.0244751777,
0.0072783767,
-0.022928305,
-0.0176141169,
0.0698061734,
0.0132723339,
-0.0061497549,
-0.0021512073,
-0.0035599845,
0.0229575466,
0.0216444228,
-0.0156842172,
-0.005493985,
-0.028723957,
0.038631238,
-0.0241047926,
0.0009355029,
0.0570973158,
0.0381939486,
0.0318706036,
0.0379308127,
-0.0362582691,
-0.0439969338,
0.0023155492,
0.0057091075,
0.0276900735,
-0.0007520224,
-0.021326093,
0.0025783912,
0.0113015566,
0.007106889,
-0.0438747592,
-0.0152145028,
0.0232224707,
-0.0760887265,
-0.0121120699,
0.0303783491,
-0.0263738967,
0.0360532403,
0.0273932014,
0.0010043317,
-0.0080834031,
0.0194942318,
-0.0110596837,
-0.0245191958,
-0.020916108,
0.0360761732,
0.023935521,
0.0341390222,
-0.0437402129,
0.0173436888,
-0.0794285759,
-0.0138609549,
-0.0665603355,
-0.000801009,
-0.0345876254,
0.0147042572,
-0.0188664123,
-0.0009457972,
-0.0236885231,
0.0323341824,
-0.0004118239,
0.0334424041,
-0.0120886294,
-0.0427316092,
-0.0256428104,
0.0219332278,
-0.046038866,
0.0025365415,
-0.0038704686,
0.0659484789,
0.0470786951,
-0.0262385476,
-0.0757990107,
-0.0398054793,
-0.0215540845,
-0.0371732041,
0.0473590381,
-0.023891056,
-0.0220940001,
-0.0458749123,
0.0039274329,
-0.0515367463,
-0.0054861787,
0.0063842176,
-0.0485008024,
0.0657584891,
-0.0110022994,
-0.033372663,
0.0402392298,
0.0572150648,
-0.0045174859,
0.0900854692,
-0.0063708308,
0.0792219192,
0.0606123395,
0.0403767154,
0.0240517668,
-0.0472703576,
0.0861539245,
0.0234621391,
0.0195822995,
-0.0180967189,
-0.0429677516,
-0.0010193273,
0.0119994264,
0.0113076428,
-0.0306162201,
-0.0449329391,
0.0140025811,
-0.0181645881,
-0.000469161,
-0.015150819,
0.0028396538,
0.0397695713,
-0.0258130617,
-0.0147385141,
-0.0428438373,
0.0383308753,
-0.076967068,
-0.0324104354,
0.0379761793,
0.0249762796,
-0.0283808708,
-0.0247726738,
-0.0265705436,
-0.0206649788,
-0.0257402118,
0.0144524192,
0.0187820606,
-0.022627363,
-0.0464302823,
0.0507742018,
0.0561731495,
-0.0227022246,
-0.0356031917,
-0.0236835256,
0.0102675389,
0.0556081906,
0.0334727764,
-0.0561460331,
-0.0202489272,
-0.0385169201,
0.0260382239,
0.0219581369,
0.0316739045,
-0.0110509526,
0.0052318173,
-0.0232305806,
-0.0295068771,
-0.0516851433,
0.0297697615,
0.0147240041,
0.0184050296,
0.0422155336,
0.0196552239,
-0.040843267,
0.0263425075,
0.0155197782,
-0.0415695943,
-0.0108828777,
-0.0140522458,
0.052592963,
0.0421519466,
0.0066973134,
-0.018523572,
-0.0105765378,
0.0472935997,
0.0073801773,
-0.0452660583,
-0.0484158285,
0.0095288549,
-0.0525786057,
0.0369612575,
-0.0165027156,
-0.0078752963,
-0.0022170851,
-0.0636683628,
0.0640583336,
0.0462031104,
-0.0051988289,
0.0134175168,
-0.0405865498,
-0.0359317474,
-0.0238135904,
0.0406878181,
-0.0001997335,
0.05153488,
-0.0365206376,
-0.0208637118,
0.0135981888,
-0.0314422213,
0.0047423448,
-0.0021267342,
-0.0029237228,
-0.0454148129,
0.002957436,
0.0065528704,
0.0159638245,
-0.0440491363,
-0.01489776,
-0.0166949686,
-0.0299597587,
-0.0235824622,
-0.0075550326,
-0.004391823,
-0.0138948252,
-0.0222723633,
-0.010168639,
0.0065026516,
0.0058996701,
0.002827704,
-0.0004686392,
0.0257812049,
0.013583729,
-0.0199957639,
0.0359274819,
-0.0332524031,
0.0314759165,
-0.003788569,
0.0185742415,
-0.0284789391,
-0.065263629,
-0.0466440022,
0.0204017702,
-0.0606065392,
0.0344696566,
-0.034353096,
-0.023143582,
-0.0040737754,
0.0370890722,
-0.0063619106,
0.035006389,
0.0211941972,
0.0861425921,
0.020876294,
0.0126820346,
-0.0399653129,
0.014745024,
-0.0259031039,
0.0303853843,
-0.0321398154,
-0.0117389774,
0.0051683025,
0.0293618031,
0.0177307557,
-0.0081048803,
-0.0234270878,
0.0324400514,
0.0199151132,
-0.0409119427,
-0.0129970433,
-0.018537892,
0.0098847896,
0.0100848526,
-0.0329360627,
-0.0558101498,
0.0858191475,
-0.0012063704,
0.052312132,
-0.0218036231,
-0.0130526451,
-0.0097294729,
-0.0142079154,
-0.0728247762,
0.0211318582,
0.030965928,
0.0248786062,
-0.0229129381,
-0.0441142358,
0.0325360633,
-0.0541495569,
0.0091461232,
-0.0141300056,
0.0234644599,
0.0097805075,
-0.0589107759,
-0.0534431301,
-0.0564432703,
-0.0150969746,
-0.0280421674,
-0.0443020612,
-0.0095096966,
-0.0895185694,
-0.0732838586,
0.04431054,
-0.044954963,
0.0163759012,
-0.0277163144,
0.0602028556,
0.0026932179,
0.0216891244,
-0.0338476039,
0.0703261495,
-0.0310745277,
0.0222061817,
0.0656011924,
-0.0187128354,
-0.0082938895,
-0.0018986901,
-0.0401961915,
0.0166390538,
0.0052326121,
-0.0133473873,
-0.0109484773,
0.0208561197,
-0.0413070023,
0.0259457156,
0.0953172743,
-0.0007964505,
-0.0068170489,
-0.0141537404,
-0.0118746487,
-0.041783724,
0.030280089,
0.0062400051,
-0.0598930977,
-0.0475387722,
0.0007830616,
0.0400665142,
-0.0185923334,
-0.0064436584,
0.0076801875,
-0.0894314796,
0.0312749259,
0.0219842121,
0.0236521773,
-0.0731726289,
-0.038957037,
0.0129763233,
0.0190421939,
-0.0060241688,
-0.0245328099,
0.017751513,
-0.0239824317,
-0.0203857385,
-0.0193377491,
-0.0873099491,
0.0005721518,
0.0079873698,
0.0451193005,
0.0386743061,
0.0577398352,
0.0139319738,
-0.0620985925,
0.0220191739,
0.0169502962,
-0.0231787451,
-0.0429333746,
0.1022366211,
-0.0616966411,
-0.0219198763,
-0.0321360901,
0.0157332625,
-0.0027733904,
-0.0097198738,
-0.0554113872,
0.0780356973,
-0.041377183,
-0.0100763096,
-0.0840699449,
0.0275552515,
0.06657058,
0.0684771091,
-0.0305840019,
0.0174769405,
0.0025872646,
-0.0455542393,
0.0078313509,
0.014450849,
-0.0268310774,
0.0187407434,
-0.0225291438,
-0.0057232175,
-0.0260759275,
-0.0311393011,
-0.0150875784,
0.0065581352,
-0.0313766487,
-0.0185174458,
-0.0189180411,
0.003542142,
-0.0540151186,
-0.0133746499,
-0.0351764485,
0.051797621,
-0.0028322127,
0.0139394216,
0.0479519926,
-0.0116831604,
-0.0075146127,
-0.0084439237,
-0.0331844948,
-0.0672413334,
-0.0278263111,
0.0282727033,
0.00626546,
0.0461458415,
-0.0024183174,
0.010949959,
0.0971512496,
0.067449227,
-0.0118769724,
0.0147206187,
0.0461011343,
0.0322947614,
-0.0020161669,
0.0336181298,
-0.0578446575,
0.0407993123,
0.0288949702,
-0.0171124097,
-0.0420389026,
-0.0080445139,
0.0058342754,
-0.0100699048,
0.0899459571,
0.0108271716,
-0.026182266,
-0.0304276496,
-0.0270114839,
-0.0241657421,
-0.0282864366,
-0.0117647136,
-0.0050048856,
0.0122960499,
-0.033536125,
-0.0197135527,
0.0336443782,
-0.0023649496,
0.0402398594,
0.0036039995,
0.0196759775,
0.0179003682,
0.0379040018,
0.004226529,
0.0121879131,
-0.0184198748,
0.0098658567,
0.0082650613,
0.0061899861,
-0.0090590836,
0.0219400208,
-0.0103896149,
0.0013215047,
0.0034028622,
-0.026389135,
0.001855021,
0.0234493315,
-0.0456654243,
0.029179221,
0.0355370604,
0.0177721865,
0.0001570169,
-0.0064187339,
-0.024302775,
-0.0288012978,
-0.0120068062,
-0.027097214,
-0.0172373597,
0.0538075343,
0.0071382094,
-0.0340147465,
0.0248744544,
0.0534172542,
-0.0255877934,
0.0768562183,
-0.0212490261,
-0.0646011159,
-0.0346383862,
0.0011278786,
0.0600174367,
0.0148518421,
0.0046442966,
0.0224748272,
-0.0908811763,
-0.0460097529,
0.0790563822,
-0.012477315,
-0.0345624201,
-0.0012951128,
-0.0124518881,
0.080482848,
0.0288682766,
0.0426689014,
-0.0519572794,
-0.0033543308,
-0.0551359206,
-0.0438377187,
0.0176357869,
-6.248376956e-33,
-0.0221916772,
-0.0348303542,
-0.0281559918,
-0.0061736847,
-0.02178487,
0.0391021259,
0.0026182798,
-0.0115791066,
-0.0382647701,
0.0649198219,
0.0471457168,
0.0482971556,
-0.0231435429,
-0.0050936071,
-0.0464093834,
-0.0392232202,
0.055380933,
0.0023518743,
0.0062895864,
-0.0022138895,
0.0627206191,
0.0473837145,
0.0438918658,
-0.0873897672,
0.04262444,
-0.0067762351,
-0.0162553936,
0.0276576262,
0.0127679994,
0.0407787263,
0.0136389202,
0.0877887905,
0.0239306819,
-0.0136457998,
0.0023381172,
0.0180414915,
-0.0291420165,
-0.0313954502,
-0.0114945015,
-0.0378979221,
-0.0043130694,
-0.0164158102,
0.0335652977,
0.0265661944,
-0.026341239,
-0.0244596656,
0.007868181,
-0.0405877717,
0.0059788879,
-0.0463655815,
-0.0496900156,
0.0099610789,
0.0188989937,
-0.0030748816,
-0.0031697906,
0.0855507404,
0.0574922711,
0.0871954858,
-0.10281872,
-0.00045156,
-0.0666948184,
-0.0014577145,
0.0135373855,
-0.0411101468,
-0.0121033536,
0.1011705548,
0.0163670089,
0.0203850474,
-0.0461045429,
0.0146272723,
-0.0033058922,
0.0228245035,
0.0394929461,
0.1367208064,
-0.0032649874,
-0.0618719347,
-0.094922848,
0.0411625765,
0.0242451243,
0.0254636463,
0.0241267513,
0.0087710274,
-0.0334703624,
0.008664621,
0.0044609103,
0.0168019794,
-0.030018229,
-0.012019624,
0.0228269678,
0.0386625938,
-0.0046121245,
0.0218719635,
-0.0184628926,
-0.0585528053,
0.0038822019,
0.0634654239,
0.0036015261,
-0.0145965479,
0.0263533201,
0.0044958093,
-0.0364767164,
-0.0062449477,
0.0270988774,
-0.0015207235,
-0.0004031269,
-0.0277066622,
0.0447106138,
0.0017973135,
-0.0611687377,
-0.0070240782,
-0.0140942587,
0.0509337895,
-0.0040495815,
-0.0048385691,
-0.0118574975,
0.011719618,
0.001043144,
0.0013512186,
-0.0156845842,
0.0231836978,
0.0252733417,
-0.0200411417,
-0.0242269132,
0.0446399115,
-0.0381258503,
-0.0157124884,
0.0028793481,
0.0033418254,
-0.0006210305,
-0.089265056,
-0.0033679837,
-0.0108857369,
2.874e-7,
0.0031593814,
0.0407863632,
0.0065787127,
-0.0219686292,
0.0236957204,
0.0778482407,
-0.025150124,
0.012397496,
0.0226309169,
-0.0878033638,
-0.0051138173,
0.0408063196,
0.0339865945,
0.0392841101,
-0.0757542625,
0.0323695466,
0.020734163,
-0.0024987173,
0.0118274046,
0.0131471418,
0.0407381468,
0.07483951,
0.0397825465,
-0.0184995756,
-0.0047968039,
0.0293720849,
0.0744404718,
0.005956436,
-0.0272349343,
-0.0041177673,
0.015921114,
0.0103539154,
0.0053474847,
-0.0296562482,
-0.0277073514,
-0.0026024773,
-0.0253918841,
0.0149923135,
0.0112249004,
-0.0686845481,
-0.0111535611,
0.0030914249,
0.0143277692,
0.0194699932,
0.0381213352,
-0.0698024035,
-0.0232154168,
-0.0683840364,
-0.0451867506,
0.0096547576,
0.0442075394,
0.0028509533,
-0.047051765,
-0.0066718073,
0.0076761437,
0.0172525644,
-0.0005415009,
-0.0690484345,
0.0293093473,
0.0212376937,
-0.045386754,
-0.0220573191,
0.0119208787,
0.0001775428,
0.0438229144,
-0.0201085806,
0.0211424455,
2.200673739e-34,
0.0471409746,
-0.0450055301,
-0.0177152287,
-0.000900358,
0.0063361567,
0.0102955019,
-0.0802926347,
-0.053964071,
0.0354328789,
0.0108767329,
0.0384322889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11087v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11087v2 | MemDPT: Differential Privacy for Memory Efficient Language Models | 2024-06-16T22:11:41 | 2024-06-20T05:43:50 | Yanming Liu, Xinyue Peng, Jiannan Cao, Yuwei Zhang, Chen Ma, Songhang Deng, Mengchen Fu, Xuhong Zhang, Sheng Cheng, Xun Wang, Jianwei Yin, Tianyu Du | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models have consistently demonstrated remarkable performance
across a wide spectrum of applications. Nonetheless, the deployment of these
models can inadvertently expose user privacy to potential risks. The
substantial memory demands of these models during training represent a
significant resource consumption challenge. The sheer size of these models
imposes a considerable burden on memory resources, which is a matter of
significant concern in practice. In this paper, we present an innovative
training framework MemDPT that not only reduces the memory cost of large
language models but also places a strong emphasis on safeguarding user data
privacy. MemDPT provides edge network and reverse network designs to
accommodate various differential privacy memory-efficient fine-tuning schemes.
Our approach not only achieves $2 \sim 3 \times$ memory optimization but also
provides robust privacy protection, ensuring that user data remains secure and
confidential. Extensive experiments have demonstrated that MemDPT can
effectively provide differential privacy efficient fine-tuning across various
task scenarios. | [
0.0374329612,
0.0856670216,
-0.0246974006,
0.0557843819,
-0.0354786627,
-0.0354600549,
0.0706604719,
-0.0414299145,
0.0286019761,
-0.0116569428,
-0.0352310166,
-0.0561247356,
-0.0255299769,
0.0321006402,
0.028598981,
-0.0119434716,
0.0424894243,
-0.0590817258,
-0.0067704907,
-0.0302023068,
-0.0339051299,
0.0037289825,
0.0465914756,
0.0046488936,
0.0180213023,
-0.0189232528,
-0.0319234654,
0.0222325679,
0.0069891848,
-0.0108085601,
0.0295911655,
0.0572425574,
0.0299441107,
0.0625908673,
0.000002063,
0.0115873376,
-0.020931514,
0.0308391657,
-0.0412823819,
0.0352267362,
0.0268335342,
-0.0072528655,
0.0140685011,
0.012373385,
-0.0091276467,
-0.0108516626,
0.0598957501,
0.0218404569,
0.0751755163,
0.0744693726,
0.0028512634,
-0.0341245309,
-0.0074993926,
-0.0626410693,
-0.0147506325,
-0.0513798557,
0.0103872977,
-0.0683252215,
-0.0588380881,
0.0027578147,
0.0072191101,
0.0220524482,
0.0253668446,
0.0422354601,
-0.0094544338,
0.0419629551,
-0.0120762242,
-0.0235485341,
-0.0218500476,
0.0292386319,
-0.0164669845,
-0.0161037538,
0.0429971032,
0.0228270069,
0.012056225,
-0.0104656117,
0.0225545932,
0.0422913246,
-0.0280544311,
-0.007469085,
-0.0110345595,
0.0096264975,
0.0271653514,
0.0293927323,
-0.0000806277,
0.0185358822,
0.0263041127,
0.0125831151,
-0.030431563,
-0.0355684943,
-0.0011826849,
-0.0559877828,
0.0654536411,
-0.0172454845,
0.0396102518,
0.0130110215,
-0.0775026903,
-0.0747402757,
0.0136634801,
-0.054117348,
0.0257749893,
0.0000245409,
0.0288156904,
0.0080440501,
-0.0153939612,
0.0496152341,
-0.0276246872,
0.0124519132,
0.0238627587,
0.0161265135,
0.0218341276,
0.0054556304,
-0.037855871,
0.0591716766,
-0.0643413961,
-0.0168530717,
-0.027683394,
0.044667799,
-0.015257325,
0.0205997564,
0.0105556278,
0.0096988194,
-0.0369312055,
-0.011618508,
0.0352527797,
-0.046654582,
-0.0078392597,
-0.0114401067,
0.0287212096,
-0.0521225482,
-0.0145179257,
-0.0283864886,
-0.0289020408,
-0.0210045129,
-0.0117634097,
0.1014635488,
0.0255304351,
-0.0129716173,
-0.0177079961,
-0.0618491955,
0.0333685428,
-0.0585833751,
0.0077339825,
-0.0661998242,
0.0059649092,
-0.0235615391,
-0.0103100007,
-0.0620767176,
-0.0020558354,
0.0276653804,
-0.0535647459,
0.0426366143,
-0.0077014077,
-0.0204303954,
0.0328371301,
0.0444863066,
0.0181258637,
0.0210042223,
0.0333918333,
0.0277808197,
0.0745172501,
-0.0008736378,
-0.0177916437,
-0.004618051,
0.0717949569,
0.0396642201,
-0.0156511012,
0.0190864541,
0.0178596657,
-0.0230949651,
-0.0053471159,
0.0601611696,
-0.0240830258,
-0.0782586485,
0.0692948252,
0.0623893514,
-0.0157493968,
0.024284279,
-0.0632760376,
0.0324662812,
-0.0291480236,
-0.0286769737,
-0.0737732574,
0.0114960782,
-0.0333736837,
-0.0263312086,
0.0157096013,
0.034947332,
-0.0196047574,
0.0220011249,
0.0154323867,
-0.0483606085,
0.040487811,
0.032957416,
-0.006559853,
-0.0028530159,
0.0156024229,
0.0795661211,
-0.0071959817,
-0.0583295673,
-0.036195457,
-0.0565152802,
-0.0399768241,
0.0780903026,
-0.0021377746,
0.0127752237,
-0.014925126,
-0.0178641155,
0.006533511,
0.0257898346,
0.0056935046,
0.0227919407,
0.0752066597,
-0.0405282527,
-0.0245208256,
-0.0062507363,
0.0288128667,
0.024045106,
0.0247494709,
-0.0068012094,
0.0295628197,
-0.0250769239,
-0.0305162575,
0.0296094716,
-0.0168180708,
-0.0048462576,
0.0533092991,
0.0154882278,
-0.0080625201,
0.0038695326,
-0.0210678689,
0.0000603511,
0.0129523836,
0.0370528623,
0.0307865106,
-0.0405363999,
-0.0600306913,
0.0174348988,
-0.0069920002,
-0.0193985365,
0.0568456873,
0.066918321,
-0.0138810109,
-0.0569886751,
0.0049618175,
-0.0085452246,
0.0475743972,
-0.0091132773,
0.0191589333,
-0.0112909004,
0.0318093114,
-0.0161473006,
0.0021760589,
-0.0527572483,
-0.0154418861,
-0.0454881638,
0.0143002048,
0.0197749045,
-0.0315426923,
-0.0385810286,
-0.0069229989,
0.01822659,
0.0434768423,
0.0029837193,
0.0224981103,
-0.0016388781,
-0.0146359866,
-0.0544045977,
0.0309261065,
-0.0503269583,
0.0470605008,
0.034442842,
0.015941998,
-0.014452084,
-0.0566991307,
-0.052720964,
0.0051798788,
-0.0581436083,
0.0381513648,
-0.0173843615,
0.0440173335,
-0.0246379357,
0.0051261303,
-0.0482649803,
0.0260138102,
0.0324324816,
-0.0706173256,
-0.0451640002,
0.0027721785,
0.0401316732,
0.001174479,
0.0687833801,
-0.0247175973,
-0.0325825922,
-0.0056717442,
0.0184873454,
-0.0047267247,
0.0495495684,
0.0056607611,
0.0000923883,
0.0438510068,
0.0083320597,
-0.0442394465,
-0.0052079009,
-0.0125174588,
-0.0161121748,
-0.0293303058,
0.0058033136,
-0.0156306121,
0.0270614699,
-0.0140949814,
-0.0535034798,
-0.0346283615,
0.0014038729,
0.0062019732,
-0.0364690199,
-0.0107414937,
-0.0296352971,
0.0067573432,
0.0180253536,
-0.0219382998,
-0.0541415513,
0.0779652521,
-0.0175777096,
0.0058752364,
-0.0042780074,
-0.0331646614,
0.009422984,
0.0595178232,
0.0114414068,
0.0567743182,
0.0337458514,
-0.0498473868,
-0.0337311998,
0.0174343307,
0.0336901881,
-0.0380597413,
0.0069427979,
-0.0249405392,
-0.0298644397,
-0.0112692043,
-0.0637987703,
-0.0264350809,
-0.0704982728,
0.0170473922,
0.0145817278,
-0.0085323565,
-0.0603639334,
0.0202423315,
0.0172487367,
-0.0069810329,
0.0545762032,
-0.0227799751,
0.0387275144,
-0.0047180848,
-0.0296620633,
0.0324371122,
-0.0544359945,
0.0065421155,
-0.0401653685,
0.0064012385,
0.0749194548,
0.0822598562,
0.0023114786,
0.0311339237,
-0.0235374086,
0.0481887683,
-0.0157005042,
-0.0484842807,
0.0335330293,
0.0514379628,
-0.0570475534,
-0.0168377683,
0.0535656102,
-0.0112601668,
-0.0938279629,
-0.0196749344,
0.0399736315,
0.0394656248,
0.0114521552,
0.0139915161,
-0.0804958865,
0.0112332981,
0.0184857305,
0.0515914932,
-0.0039868378,
-0.0292985197,
-0.0502135493,
-0.069957763,
-0.0483770967,
0.0166669954,
-0.0298281498,
0.0015962746,
-0.0298943184,
-0.0116016846,
0.0160596333,
0.0103932247,
-0.0391340889,
0.0195030402,
-0.0360438749,
0.0080954507,
0.0159298927,
-0.030841127,
0.0056788968,
-0.0453657024,
0.04417032,
0.044550363,
-0.0150070703,
0.0039100884,
-0.0404661447,
0.0514672399,
0.005974852,
-0.0263572354,
0.009351328,
0.0361202657,
-0.0358612947,
-0.0178027619,
0.0046515446,
0.0359930061,
0.022996787,
-0.0018032426,
0.0042186356,
0.0209199823,
-0.0159238502,
-0.0026888843,
0.0099791344,
-0.0220692549,
0.0333482288,
0.0354117453,
-0.0134983966,
-0.040658623,
0.0006740303,
-0.0329308026,
0.0275756977,
-0.0303049218,
0.0264071207,
0.0279819835,
0.0143604018,
-0.0853955001,
-0.0055575846,
0.0266761221,
-0.0179338455,
0.0313227326,
0.0342233367,
-0.0015054859,
0.0458845943,
-0.0087355776,
-0.0533416569,
0.0151876006,
-0.0681815743,
0.0116555728,
-0.0544857644,
-0.0042747189,
0.0109622907,
0.0414450839,
-0.0199470464,
0.0271712262,
-0.0835547447,
-0.1091442257,
0.0314719155,
0.0566522442,
0.0173312407,
0.0588800535,
-0.0137236686,
-0.0862711444,
0.0534805544,
0.0318190679,
-0.0808793381,
0.0112679359,
0.0692016184,
-0.0608608238,
0.0071748919,
0.0312718637,
-0.030221045,
-0.0325293094,
0.0860033557,
-0.0313423276,
-0.0403444357,
-0.0692736953,
-0.0324689597,
0.0162527822,
0.0266749468,
-0.0203257464,
0.0562427714,
-0.0406875201,
0.0677152202,
-0.0232620258,
0.0054385867,
-0.0138742244,
0.001216436,
0.0311450269,
-0.0140548982,
0.0204138923,
-0.0296745934,
0.0780306458,
-0.0123609426,
-0.0533512235,
0.0141508942,
-0.0007581972,
0.0232121162,
0.0388939045,
0.019002527,
-0.049018316,
0.0505341217,
0.0262251068,
0.0366943292,
-0.0471692793,
0.0197844878,
0.0033340098,
-0.0165864546,
-0.019292511,
0.0649398416,
-0.0327439904,
-0.0533178523,
-0.0152947484,
0.0177170672,
0.0133105321,
0.0275369585,
-0.0135173257,
-0.044497855,
0.0098494757,
-0.0337410532,
-0.0046968553,
-0.0044960254,
-0.0514581054,
-0.0126115093,
-0.006591294,
0.0051707593,
0.033500649,
0.0645595193,
0.0503720045,
0.0259685423,
0.00397941,
-0.0175218564,
-0.034033861,
-0.0049787206,
-0.0018519552,
0.0610732473,
-0.0223782994,
-0.010955926,
-0.0293011405,
-0.0780003294,
-0.0210092794,
-0.0083089676,
0.0290667433,
0.0007764364,
0.0100796511,
0.0181272235,
0.0051754075,
-0.0196040329,
-0.0696198344,
-0.0163517203,
0.0278097931,
0.0190106798,
-0.0021402852,
-5.78200545e-33,
-0.0208207201,
0.0001287797,
-0.0064166244,
-0.015697604,
0.012968584,
0.0255516022,
-0.0078393715,
-0.0004746442,
-0.0447109193,
-0.0353006981,
-0.0558210574,
0.0300635342,
0.0292008743,
0.0314505957,
-0.0271462817,
0.0235586446,
0.0556912385,
-0.0319534615,
-0.0045178533,
0.0639182031,
0.043397937,
0.0404964425,
0.0439889804,
-0.0686662272,
0.0223233625,
-0.0111002708,
-0.0274240635,
0.0113766734,
-0.0579132736,
0.0212773196,
-0.0228160881,
-0.0050372495,
-0.0153676094,
-0.0269780215,
-0.0386118926,
0.0357881188,
-0.0556394123,
0.0043870048,
-0.0050742133,
0.0038049913,
0.021834299,
-0.0748631582,
0.031107273,
-0.0220029876,
0.0196997393,
0.0042584338,
-0.0296489969,
0.0255160797,
-0.026962908,
-0.0287295543,
0.0463127643,
0.0031271465,
0.0294759274,
0.0084572937,
0.0660872459,
-0.0455033667,
-0.0257016961,
-0.0685802624,
-0.0642624125,
0.0095922891,
0.0215965379,
0.0281220935,
0.0530479066,
0.0350584276,
0.0284089148,
0.0334583558,
0.061715208,
0.063889429,
0.0152001306,
0.0011462761,
0.034952227,
0.0298438203,
0.0139392456,
-0.0276329201,
0.0118735153,
-0.06692563,
-0.0279481281,
-0.0465845242,
-0.0412635393,
-0.0029800008,
0.0627084076,
-0.003582095,
-0.0625601783,
-0.017498374,
-0.0566098802,
-0.0106993234,
-0.038431704,
0.0108751627,
-0.0021219265,
0.0277324095,
-0.0274437163,
-0.0064954264,
0.0458265096,
-0.0490021035,
-0.003025962,
0.0292002335,
0.0576947927,
-0.0151632261,
-0.0098676793,
0.0349744074,
-0.0327827856,
-0.0328138061,
-0.0197202042,
-0.0148556037,
0.0090288464,
-0.0029247422,
0.0384356044,
0.0044261091,
-0.0807723328,
-0.0022354077,
-0.0463833921,
0.0489040613,
0.0549937896,
0.0597686321,
0.0296647083,
-0.0273111276,
-0.0007483567,
0.0258757658,
0.0182157811,
-0.0080753863,
-0.0195299052,
0.0178477764,
0.0066657886,
0.0199259501,
0.0291698817,
0.0058009266,
-0.0070786364,
0.0459201112,
0.0874290317,
0.0173132066,
0.0138851516,
-0.0015019872,
2.71e-7,
-0.0437175706,
-0.0015660959,
0.0027628287,
-0.0013074386,
0.009821455,
0.043895971,
0.0318853855,
0.0588124394,
-0.0084600989,
0.0228720121,
-0.0257240497,
0.0218294226,
0.024094969,
0.0174081586,
-0.0623166896,
-0.0142954057,
-0.0438065119,
0.0416165888,
-0.0405297428,
-0.0112184174,
0.0049056653,
0.0942854285,
0.0319458395,
-0.0040636766,
-0.0231064614,
-0.0309935324,
0.0310754497,
-0.050292816,
-0.0091301491,
-0.0184910577,
0.023424916,
0.1093410626,
-0.0358516201,
0.0070479088,
-0.0291003548,
0.0419612117,
-0.071915783,
0.1095950603,
-0.0054470319,
-0.0013446712,
0.0316757485,
-0.0615836829,
-0.0600962937,
-0.0099502113,
0.0371072069,
0.0063622394,
-0.0217344407,
-0.0226162858,
0.0501524061,
-0.0734030604,
0.0221532676,
-0.0202290118,
0.0237457994,
0.015200831,
0.0077369874,
-0.0065137111,
0.0219425242,
-0.0929037333,
-0.0337458365,
-0.0008532277,
-0.009672367,
-0.0266936924,
-0.0204181466,
0.0118455337,
-0.0039545679,
-0.0182809979,
0.041470319,
2.27606563e-34,
0.0060862559,
-0.0159298982,
-0.0186989177,
0.0373160802,
0.0067925346,
0.0002699877,
0.0504437461,
0.0108742854,
0.0231740829,
-0.0563064553,
-0.0497037284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11085v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11085v1 | Multiple Sources are Better Than One: Incorporating External Knowledge in Low-Resource Glossing | 2024-06-16T22:01:15 | 2024-06-16T22:01:15 | Changbing Yang, Garrett Nicolai, Miikka Silfverberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we address the data scarcity problem in automatic data-driven
glossing for low-resource languages by coordinating multiple sources of
linguistic expertise. We supplement models with translations at both the token
and sentence level as well as leverage the extensive linguistic capability of
modern LLMs. Our enhancements lead to an average absolute improvement of
5%-points in word-level accuracy over the previous state of the art on a
typologically diverse dataset spanning six low-resource languages. The
improvements are particularly noticeable for the lowest-resourced language
Gitksan, where we achieve a 10%-point improvement. Furthermore, in a simulated
ultra-low resource setting for the same six languages, training on fewer than
100 glossed sentences, we establish an average 10%-point improvement in
word-level accuracy over the previous state-of-the-art system. | [
0.0379589014,
0.0250018463,
-0.008005132,
0.0819687173,
-0.0326760821,
-0.0089291828,
-0.0101539176,
0.0221369416,
0.0174730383,
-0.0414586887,
-0.0134603074,
-0.007127604,
0.0140375569,
-0.0305052735,
0.0508274846,
-0.057332132,
0.0582069643,
-0.0242043138,
0.0017027248,
-0.0203366522,
0.0131412446,
0.0261367746,
0.0081610959,
0.0130505459,
-0.0685379207,
0.0310591236,
0.0263936892,
0.0099869054,
-0.001021199,
0.0180770028,
0.0107706729,
0.0449398533,
-0.0289806593,
0.0215944853,
0.0000020072,
-0.0651590303,
-0.0311146025,
-0.0174330305,
0.0037438262,
0.0075315316,
0.1013994515,
-0.048464302,
0.022200752,
0.0024723862,
-0.0368218049,
0.0115377307,
0.0374113955,
-0.0164445937,
0.0428046137,
0.0459744185,
-0.0028786291,
-0.0500363708,
0.0239692256,
-0.008734474,
-0.006462229,
-0.0262924433,
-0.0073803067,
0.026436625,
-0.0021440869,
-0.0491135418,
-0.0236274023,
0.0766837746,
-0.0242345165,
0.0041429568,
0.0142111359,
0.0138111264,
-0.0419142656,
-0.0119377188,
-0.0017681425,
0.0719210654,
-0.0350795276,
-0.0275683384,
-0.0220040027,
-0.0073068053,
0.016022006,
-0.0011303426,
-0.0314379297,
0.0182875395,
-0.005675877,
0.0304248109,
0.0291903336,
-0.0203458816,
0.0285532121,
0.0396622308,
-0.0397310667,
0.0342037342,
0.0217947867,
0.0037208907,
0.0113184843,
0.0135774892,
-0.0268061627,
-0.0049076756,
-0.050916668,
0.0095647145,
-0.006126821,
0.0362811387,
-0.0202130005,
-0.0821434781,
0.0377149619,
-0.0119540635,
-0.0124077071,
0.0217593703,
-0.0271736979,
0.0320958197,
-0.0495946743,
-0.0239171721,
0.0272557437,
0.0419017076,
-0.0429559276,
-0.0691221133,
-0.0090718977,
0.004731331,
-0.0608074516,
0.0322887748,
-0.0789275691,
0.0045304727,
-0.0194043741,
-0.0081508746,
0.0264709275,
0.003342336,
-0.0023551821,
0.0115469201,
-0.0311008468,
-0.0249094721,
-0.0172782838,
-0.0051345732,
-0.0317149423,
0.0176407918,
-0.0259890258,
-0.0749921724,
-0.0098288339,
0.0152051719,
0.0060603349,
-0.0140760345,
-0.0006805283,
0.1006188542,
0.002540943,
-0.0167969614,
-0.0921196416,
-0.0146684945,
-0.027491102,
-0.0348485485,
-0.0631622002,
-0.1001065001,
0.0144303571,
0.0179862268,
0.0180819277,
-0.0304804388,
0.0152083635,
-0.0061656218,
-0.0647572502,
0.0920198336,
-0.1163527369,
-0.0003442289,
-0.002033497,
-0.0023462414,
0.0133757098,
0.0900927782,
0.0406896472,
-0.0439171642,
0.07192,
0.0259970371,
0.0099479547,
0.0300176665,
-0.0130742844,
-0.007564533,
-0.0188197009,
-0.014136537,
-0.0040903925,
0.04659421,
0.0827578753,
0.0990874767,
-0.0516979881,
-0.0034831811,
0.0388968177,
0.0361542553,
0.0243052933,
0.0462557413,
0.0251847524,
0.0204228573,
-0.0127859274,
0.0056630853,
-0.0044732173,
-0.0173659511,
0.0037965318,
0.0272423159,
0.0027543295,
0.0327417217,
-0.001060489,
-0.0299875028,
-0.0210681204,
-0.0302501768,
0.0169194937,
-0.0317777209,
0.0345337987,
0.0238740053,
-0.0043977019,
0.0693137273,
0.0693735108,
-0.0261681415,
0.0275506247,
-0.0181439146,
-0.0205913242,
0.0868619159,
0.0456785597,
0.0060887695,
-0.0573217273,
0.0036347797,
0.0294020474,
0.029625589,
-0.0008870708,
-0.022861585,
0.0173666757,
-0.0816235393,
0.0172402356,
0.0014243494,
0.005762517,
0.0154838981,
0.0377686322,
0.0468589067,
0.0248033497,
-0.0598955415,
-0.0630838722,
0.0125054084,
-0.0062516513,
0.0076922989,
0.0282225125,
-0.0092223864,
-0.0032083211,
0.0017672111,
-0.0225648601,
0.0153781008,
-0.0022499035,
-0.0445684716,
-0.0011982535,
0.0088147772,
0.0179235935,
-0.0284223948,
0.0347930081,
-0.015526589,
0.0068626795,
-0.0297612529,
-0.0104597798,
-0.0362149477,
0.0085070748,
-0.0360513702,
0.1310396045,
-0.0519995689,
0.0194767732,
0.0263736974,
0.0097700981,
-0.0534815229,
0.0516784266,
0.0062183128,
0.0381507501,
-0.0041893916,
0.0081148725,
0.0283229351,
-0.0363606624,
-0.0023160623,
-0.0006865262,
0.0378899351,
0.0123790661,
-0.0062405062,
0.02063125,
-0.064540863,
-0.036318291,
-0.1008384973,
-0.0199197978,
-0.0105884718,
-0.0033841969,
0.0045273965,
0.048934631,
-0.0185212567,
-0.0146783879,
0.0079963449,
0.0151722925,
0.0337218568,
-0.0026473573,
0.0651757121,
0.0218180176,
-0.0286351927,
-0.039178554,
0.0315199755,
0.0348331928,
-0.0155971823,
0.0126666129,
-0.078460753,
0.000604098,
-0.0108316569,
-0.0544729307,
0.0125007173,
-0.0025493966,
-0.049812559,
-0.0323111862,
-0.0282356534,
0.0245791022,
-0.0218444653,
-0.0077761272,
-0.0548105426,
0.0404538885,
-0.0650669038,
-0.0575865321,
-0.0070550493,
0.0091966866,
-0.0581731349,
-0.0384312049,
0.0305486321,
-0.0063468325,
-0.0029355611,
0.0380396806,
-0.0223292504,
-0.0019473189,
0.0200112462,
-0.044937063,
-0.0179548524,
0.0034309025,
0.0400632359,
-0.0245710835,
0.0360870324,
-0.0242241025,
-0.0465153754,
0.0524743386,
-0.012957762,
-0.0237782616,
-0.0056335162,
-0.0173495486,
-0.0447519235,
0.0308782998,
-0.040492747,
0.0228710584,
-0.0534082316,
-0.0566058308,
-0.0166472495,
-0.0097729666,
0.0353346504,
-0.0148798004,
0.0586917326,
-0.0969228595,
0.0418795012,
0.0073113926,
-0.0191549584,
-0.0149707021,
-0.0660198778,
-0.0094242105,
-0.0137607958,
0.0523716286,
-0.0180948116,
0.0142952474,
-0.0162613932,
0.0075479755,
0.0344518274,
0.0047181426,
-0.0127276834,
0.004576812,
0.0646077245,
0.0151543301,
0.000124678,
-0.0104773901,
0.0133626359,
0.0143267922,
0.0178081393,
-0.008098823,
-0.0573510118,
-0.0104519194,
-0.0012258058,
0.0280247312,
-0.0406272635,
-0.0235641841,
-0.0150621058,
-0.0111490469,
-0.0080782808,
0.0059255641,
0.1010804325,
0.017456783,
-0.0586141013,
0.0151849193,
-0.0261985883,
0.0364006832,
0.0237079971,
-0.0023782677,
-0.1337756217,
-0.0127137918,
-0.0104325674,
0.0303806886,
0.0258895718,
-0.034367945,
0.0009705805,
-0.1142764539,
0.0273408387,
0.0145710232,
-0.0021023548,
-0.0097567867,
-0.009112061,
-0.0057345871,
-0.0422209166,
0.0245718937,
-0.0136563992,
-0.0246054456,
0.0077746203,
-0.0010190085,
-0.0357223935,
-0.0533560626,
-0.0178288873,
-0.0368328206,
0.0517142266,
0.002156897,
0.0245792009,
-0.0320549719,
0.0133902747,
0.0502568521,
-0.0122471917,
-0.0160257965,
-0.0457712412,
0.0535172075,
-0.0013418777,
-0.0151048331,
0.0112412162,
-0.0082145389,
-0.0058428212,
0.0128536494,
-0.0057121385,
0.0331638418,
0.0062619983,
0.0239573512,
0.0409577563,
-0.0433542877,
0.0284605287,
0.0329541527,
0.0034850424,
0.0221379455,
0.0165450182,
-0.0029857266,
-0.0325665921,
-0.0256275367,
-0.0494639985,
0.0193288047,
-0.0322035737,
-0.0367519408,
-0.0637838542,
-0.0564565957,
0.0640566796,
0.0463294685,
0.0313240029,
0.0621895082,
-0.0508832969,
0.0077936444,
-0.0228703395,
0.0233561881,
-0.0245302487,
-0.0188396219,
-0.0499590747,
-0.045416031,
0.0417353995,
-0.0014077403,
0.0063443892,
0.0695855543,
-0.0128615052,
-0.0620576479,
0.0060835085,
0.0305421017,
0.0213906635,
0.0630969331,
-0.0432867594,
-0.014851206,
0.0264544841,
0.0199316312,
-0.048018761,
0.0358614177,
0.0241656918,
0.0514943637,
0.0272485167,
0.0824324563,
-0.0244824383,
-0.0092803771,
-0.0096382415,
0.0346057788,
-0.0703569502,
-0.0607996322,
0.0192869492,
0.0473463275,
0.0153517677,
-0.062362019,
0.01130288,
-0.0425655507,
0.0087888492,
-0.0213024784,
-0.0388443694,
-0.0191820338,
0.0252037626,
0.0382871069,
-0.029768981,
-0.028590342,
-0.0379186757,
-0.0101183159,
-0.0229702219,
0.009913398,
-0.0058213025,
-0.0090858275,
-0.0453702435,
0.0137051642,
0.0284076072,
-0.0322965421,
0.0015893023,
-0.0233756918,
0.023902202,
-0.0323347151,
-0.0452156514,
0.0067191208,
-0.0191157758,
-0.0243824143,
0.019729672,
0.0097237695,
-0.0461819097,
-0.0205822233,
0.017250469,
0.0709009394,
-0.0014640932,
0.0916204154,
-0.0432056226,
-0.0120986588,
-0.0120829437,
0.034967564,
0.0030126467,
-0.0358646214,
-0.0213711038,
-0.0035453443,
-0.0386074819,
-0.0021312237,
0.0862198398,
-0.0097378716,
0.0380021296,
-0.0013858727,
-0.0120735047,
-0.0326586179,
-0.026741039,
-0.0005536827,
0.0169454888,
0.0139861237,
0.0140807647,
-0.0482859239,
-0.0542918779,
0.0153035084,
0.0141786244,
-0.0232924446,
0.0141950957,
0.0408137664,
0.0418431312,
0.0378685333,
0.0166086983,
-0.0550116263,
0.0006936964,
0.0199656691,
-0.0318182893,
-0.0186335016,
-6.340953748e-33,
-0.0434586331,
-0.0397235304,
0.0144656794,
-0.0002514224,
-0.0117206797,
0.0257157534,
-0.0018055692,
0.0347399451,
-0.012256748,
0.0066837356,
0.0016743628,
0.0088198874,
0.032157179,
-0.011096919,
0.0787827,
0.0212771446,
-0.0121194366,
0.0326141641,
0.0343845375,
0.004934412,
0.0330007374,
0.0308331233,
0.1056857929,
-0.0328993276,
0.0496937931,
0.0042890795,
0.0042924429,
0.0221854895,
0.0424824432,
0.0082010105,
-0.0128359972,
0.0690454841,
0.0190169401,
0.0400673412,
-0.0163973719,
-0.0698589757,
-0.086695686,
-0.0302399006,
0.0901445895,
-0.0003801711,
0.009533097,
-0.0342025273,
0.0348906517,
-0.0262126196,
-0.0125620179,
0.0645030439,
0.0271435119,
-0.0325135551,
-0.0183872674,
-0.0044200993,
-0.0613644235,
0.05372978,
-0.0087056272,
0.0178759489,
0.0429673344,
-0.0025816374,
0.0051652724,
-0.0167931914,
-0.0115713822,
0.0119664799,
-0.0096756127,
0.0529219471,
0.0578369759,
-0.0053524696,
-0.0467714258,
0.0595093928,
-0.0173496902,
-0.0416044258,
0.0106788157,
0.0308030937,
0.0183494445,
0.0402525775,
-0.0080335503,
0.0651725307,
-0.0167365391,
-0.0419113263,
-0.0190974232,
0.0105496673,
0.0336515941,
0.054681886,
-0.0351040028,
-0.0152880438,
-0.0384563506,
-0.0422003679,
-0.0082764858,
0.0028697418,
-0.0096439701,
-0.0299302787,
0.0230259188,
0.0102836434,
0.0289801396,
0.0280721486,
-0.0169779714,
0.0025170955,
-0.0134787774,
0.0007226436,
0.0310168602,
0.0103947474,
-0.0266503673,
0.0182113443,
-0.0350713357,
-0.0256645307,
-0.0324311852,
0.0376781635,
-0.000638029,
-0.0121756746,
0.0299201831,
0.0073515577,
-0.0552644692,
0.0104939975,
-0.0216333773,
0.0007348525,
-0.0357796811,
-0.024381265,
0.0165048894,
0.0162836351,
-0.0141785117,
0.0182219669,
0.0222183373,
-0.018818453,
0.0129858237,
-0.0148267485,
0.0079959156,
-0.0046726265,
-0.0191503074,
0.0200461652,
0.0046659913,
-0.0110956198,
0.0146177579,
0.0072355708,
0.0037443964,
-0.0174635537,
2.824e-7,
0.0955889001,
0.0461423099,
0.009944207,
0.0271290746,
-0.044440534,
-0.0643028095,
-0.0237117466,
-0.0023024471,
-0.0472789258,
-0.007870513,
0.0090409787,
0.0259760693,
0.0128689222,
0.0496166646,
-0.1236976385,
0.0115011809,
0.0025915026,
0.0056369686,
-0.06440752,
-0.0173112471,
0.0414249003,
0.0622551143,
0.0196021497,
-0.0079168128,
-0.0396911353,
-0.0979225188,
0.0427349731,
-0.0563150868,
-0.0436090082,
0.0445986539,
0.1090906039,
0.0658752695,
0.0151179144,
-0.0064025372,
-0.0221682619,
0.0137713198,
-0.006118048,
0.026670916,
-0.0169655941,
-0.0200741347,
0.0221534893,
-0.053044349,
-0.0223246776,
-0.0322460383,
0.0359543972,
0.0076074982,
0.0282407738,
0.0368348174,
0.0304080974,
0.0457716212,
0.0107027031,
-0.0420854352,
-0.0539493673,
0.0137694338,
0.0637653694,
-0.0308162812,
-0.0470360927,
-0.068995744,
-0.0137963071,
0.0495838299,
0.008339162,
-0.0391926952,
0.0336654708,
0.0014579316,
-0.0089414725,
-0.0475203134,
0.0309781395,
2.169686147e-34,
0.065693669,
0.0011609413,
0.029325733,
0.0720638856,
0.0551044121,
-0.0129286647,
0.018382065,
0.0161982104,
-0.0333314463,
-0.0429569446,
-0.0069127954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15476v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15476v1 | Self-Regulated Data-Free Knowledge Amalgamation for Text Classification | 2024-06-16T21:13:30 | 2024-06-16T21:13:30 | Prashanth Vijayaraghavan, Hongzhi Wang, Luyao Shi, Tyler Baldwin, David Beymer, Ehsan Degan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, there has been a growing availability of pre-trained text models on
various model repositories. These models greatly reduce the cost of training
new models from scratch as they can be fine-tuned for specific tasks or trained
on large datasets. However, these datasets may not be publicly accessible due
to the privacy, security, or intellectual property issues. In this paper, we
aim to develop a lightweight student network that can learn from multiple
teacher models without accessing their original training data. Hence, we
investigate Data-Free Knowledge Amalgamation (DFKA), a knowledge-transfer task
that combines insights from multiple pre-trained teacher models and transfers
them effectively to a compact student network. To accomplish this, we propose
STRATANET, a modeling framework comprising: (a) a steerable data generator that
produces text data tailored to each teacher and (b) an amalgamation module that
implements a self-regulative strategy using confidence estimates from the
teachers' different layers to selectively integrate their knowledge and train a
versatile student. We evaluate our method on three benchmark text
classification datasets with varying labels or domains. Empirically, we
demonstrate that the student model learned using our STRATANET outperforms
several baselines significantly under data-driven and data-free constraints. | [
-0.0008394414,
0.0641618297,
0.0046943328,
0.0256247465,
-0.0011735003,
-0.0028731043,
0.085961096,
-0.0541656613,
0.0193300284,
-0.0549303554,
-0.0419168994,
0.0360281393,
-0.0334367268,
0.0373494811,
0.0163399968,
-0.0481786989,
0.0069712996,
-0.0058438568,
-0.0300292876,
0.0184859727,
-0.0222747829,
0.0026598582,
0.0120908655,
-0.0025171561,
0.015179201,
0.0116601801,
-0.0326370485,
0.009205563,
0.0536125675,
0.0293822587,
0.0446111374,
0.0590913743,
0.0268955994,
0.0387588218,
0.0000019112,
-0.0254985094,
-0.0696197748,
0.0215558764,
-0.0433261245,
0.008217277,
0.0586278401,
0.0267620329,
0.0238407757,
0.0071959659,
-0.0533982366,
-0.006837361,
0.024871856,
0.0644284487,
0.1022065356,
0.0403415971,
-0.0070523401,
-0.0226747766,
0.0262926854,
-0.0490949452,
0.0149690099,
-0.032590773,
0.0709878206,
-0.0088698249,
-0.0435883626,
0.0537795164,
0.004037186,
0.0408350751,
0.0284118559,
-0.0053951498,
0.0488143116,
0.0168697797,
0.0047527184,
0.0003811598,
-0.0180128627,
0.0720346645,
0.0028252886,
-0.0238544457,
0.0200662259,
-0.0285515655,
0.0513942838,
0.0336673744,
-0.0291613471,
-0.0119870473,
-0.0125843147,
0.0004206328,
-0.038726747,
0.0588062219,
0.013760793,
-0.0052759978,
-0.0189043023,
-0.0199160911,
-0.0150721846,
-0.0148485694,
0.0160688311,
0.0186095778,
0.0259468425,
-0.0454972163,
-0.0115055544,
0.0170786865,
0.0884697214,
0.0116528887,
-0.0767947361,
-0.0437623076,
-0.0012492921,
0.0032189789,
0.0018198537,
-0.0260321163,
-0.0048027579,
0.0758606568,
-0.0269466117,
-0.0083160801,
-0.0070034345,
0.0418109149,
-0.0158395544,
0.0205458868,
-0.0967686474,
0.004170964,
-0.0187132191,
0.0511130393,
0.0042269425,
0.0081046317,
-0.0292845629,
-0.0055370103,
-0.0495251492,
0.0066607292,
0.0150123416,
0.0193668287,
-0.0137176896,
0.0116314972,
-0.0142583409,
0.0144897802,
-0.0029052994,
0.0274720155,
0.0265620537,
0.0033273315,
-0.0141639942,
-0.0089016808,
0.0063323281,
0.009111817,
-0.0127594629,
0.0041368506,
-0.0192610901,
-0.0147557948,
-0.0618723668,
-0.0698201284,
-0.0033495466,
-0.0410269313,
0.0041666203,
-0.0658591315,
0.0602651909,
-0.0317725837,
-0.026129825,
-0.0460038297,
-0.0008962519,
0.0203923173,
-0.0249610953,
0.0769788325,
-0.0175880492,
-0.0310896803,
0.0400334708,
0.0643556565,
-0.0361541174,
0.0284750313,
-0.0168199036,
0.0496667884,
0.0218369383,
0.0133298663,
0.0254738275,
-0.014409638,
0.0803933665,
0.0266136341,
0.0199630596,
-0.003039127,
0.0130917486,
-0.0221055038,
-0.0293167699,
0.0139676556,
-0.0404185653,
-0.010304912,
0.0252480749,
0.004143205,
0.0199253522,
0.0379930846,
0.0246394519,
0.0307235736,
0.0285088178,
0.0067283642,
-0.0305431262,
-0.0114264302,
-0.0451533571,
-0.0357190296,
0.0232083108,
0.0279593561,
-0.0235561896,
-0.0917440578,
0.0187273882,
-0.0529236086,
-0.0048553571,
0.0114301639,
0.0738577023,
0.0330447927,
-0.0167199075,
-0.0068539423,
0.0111696543,
-0.0746634007,
0.0204288401,
-0.0478125364,
0.003464239,
0.0222201385,
0.0189604107,
-0.0739402622,
-0.017211128,
-0.0325416587,
0.0546379425,
-0.0170537829,
0.0423986055,
-0.02461005,
0.0122382566,
-0.0676916018,
-0.0778468251,
0.0098253675,
0.0326570608,
0.0521963984,
0.007565028,
0.0111473007,
0.0550686717,
0.0024459483,
-0.0360224247,
0.0413188115,
-0.0613063574,
-0.0458221063,
-0.014418304,
0.0127135906,
0.0138082234,
0.0225488879,
-0.027561726,
-0.0250441134,
0.0226438623,
-0.0228052586,
-0.0720530376,
-0.037281666,
-0.0402798764,
-0.0275396612,
-0.0026702434,
-0.0334247425,
0.0221143272,
-0.0101849604,
-0.0424020067,
-0.0708322078,
0.0089676268,
0.0485276207,
0.0183110181,
-0.023164466,
-0.0288539138,
0.0298396479,
0.0022867378,
-0.0075883111,
0.0663193911,
0.0409195162,
-0.0168454088,
-0.0088403821,
-0.0190789606,
0.049115818,
0.0082781911,
-0.0290149283,
-0.0742940903,
-0.0091528399,
0.0316631086,
-0.0005596019,
-0.0146195255,
-0.0393494889,
-0.0254649445,
-0.0425415672,
0.0061609237,
0.0059708622,
-0.0084206443,
0.0022455605,
-0.0046328395,
0.0061456244,
-0.0142969154,
-0.0465532392,
-0.0268276446,
-0.0519254021,
-0.0191634186,
0.0093372948,
0.019552039,
0.016068073,
-0.0097134113,
-0.0352591462,
-0.0252089109,
0.0602190234,
0.0332339779,
-0.0010508703,
-0.0277123414,
0.0283764079,
-0.0362512209,
0.0651860833,
-0.0130189834,
-0.0260854401,
-0.0285934415,
-0.041699335,
-0.02226891,
0.0627591014,
-0.0342364684,
0.0006753703,
0.0517706126,
-0.0186539609,
-0.0493694209,
0.0315069035,
-0.0264621321,
0.0215889271,
0.0113477837,
0.0208394174,
-0.0069910455,
0.0215691049,
0.0093146497,
-0.0868491381,
-0.0709278062,
0.028185226,
-0.0051066517,
-0.0131109087,
-0.0679441541,
-0.001420089,
0.0479542129,
0.0193995256,
-0.0016995543,
-0.0203870721,
0.0665039495,
-0.0170466006,
0.0094171362,
0.0012899203,
-0.0411401168,
-0.0555239618,
0.0420262516,
0.003973403,
0.0271770172,
0.0647933707,
0.0204702858,
-0.0476883873,
0.0038973985,
0.0732223317,
-0.048765745,
0.018799087,
-0.0207343642,
0.021947667,
-0.0122047653,
-0.03977203,
-0.0382307023,
-0.0328790024,
-0.0013351395,
0.0000972733,
-0.0042242827,
-0.0478994995,
-0.0489440113,
-0.0331406444,
0.0316463038,
0.0541564673,
-0.0241538957,
-0.0344688408,
-0.0000828173,
0.0395136699,
-0.0090782531,
-0.0290917456,
-0.0471769981,
-0.0216833372,
0.0136401784,
0.0670806691,
0.0281191636,
0.0024362304,
-0.0106916763,
-0.0154126817,
0.0115589676,
-0.0308196563,
0.0047378405,
-0.0105241686,
0.0069533759,
-0.0474179685,
0.0030025223,
0.0633059368,
0.0223877821,
-0.0337999538,
-0.072798267,
0.0114916181,
0.0327408761,
0.0163586345,
0.0384983681,
-0.0636555851,
-0.0180285014,
-0.0030496565,
0.0305454712,
0.0289437491,
-0.0316329375,
-0.0311955065,
-0.0835460275,
-0.0111737531,
0.0464131534,
-0.0549715608,
-0.0022156385,
-0.0335445963,
-0.0281260535,
-0.0241089948,
-0.0601904579,
-0.0367222279,
-0.0102912011,
-0.0004577856,
0.0274788365,
-0.0236588102,
-0.0335332416,
-0.0269995444,
-0.0106023466,
0.0471526645,
0.0092279874,
-0.0126449624,
-0.0118113812,
-0.0513563789,
-0.0134802125,
-0.0070340107,
-0.0395177267,
0.0155338384,
0.112533085,
-0.018229235,
0.0037049779,
0.0300909597,
0.0710572004,
-0.0629662126,
0.0016639428,
0.0315005146,
0.0709882751,
0.0453447811,
-0.0147903459,
-0.0558415689,
-0.0108460793,
0.0285480246,
0.0648396239,
-0.0023248314,
-0.0450959653,
0.0218646917,
0.0048272968,
0.0017120728,
-0.0182503629,
-0.0148088774,
0.0737494081,
-0.0340905562,
-0.0438903347,
-0.0396182649,
-0.0125697525,
0.0125498185,
0.0399570838,
0.0357913859,
0.0115663689,
0.0312631764,
-0.0161774661,
-0.042473048,
0.011811858,
-0.0213495456,
0.0007453962,
-0.0340681039,
0.0002066948,
0.0391469188,
-0.0343961716,
-0.041652564,
-0.0016459703,
-0.0759656429,
-0.0675949827,
0.012008532,
0.0318228267,
0.0160495844,
0.0254485477,
-0.0081044789,
-0.033429686,
0.1036967188,
0.058226604,
-0.014905124,
-0.0287166573,
0.070931904,
-0.0451748706,
-0.0022585383,
0.0108522456,
-0.0667506233,
0.0422515646,
0.0067162015,
-0.080532141,
-0.0736352429,
-0.0082175806,
-0.0355530828,
-0.0120279389,
0.0414607339,
0.0234805495,
-0.0199807622,
-0.0691047236,
0.0261608977,
0.0126379877,
-0.0233696476,
-0.0595534071,
0.0273506753,
0.0486642532,
-0.0065673059,
-0.0083729299,
0.0108683109,
0.0736571178,
0.0111021698,
-0.0311971996,
-0.0179849174,
0.0090025812,
0.0189088583,
0.0362324975,
-0.0135067301,
-0.0206645709,
0.0038888366,
0.0101078628,
0.0091281505,
-0.01299119,
0.0203406923,
0.0338431224,
0.0480384827,
0.030831296,
0.0166837517,
-0.0973512307,
-0.0164067801,
-0.0317779258,
-0.0115983784,
0.0188932717,
0.0303551201,
0.0254821293,
-0.0054116827,
-0.025942428,
-0.0091934912,
-0.0028247957,
0.0009439205,
0.0130710555,
0.0352562927,
0.0132057322,
0.0070071607,
0.0227659214,
0.0469105951,
0.0212589484,
0.0396287702,
0.000086366,
-0.0181663614,
-0.0440284312,
0.003453413,
0.0651618093,
0.0330224633,
-0.0148789845,
-0.0295083001,
-0.0030407782,
-0.063120693,
0.0500517264,
0.0229595583,
-0.0217116531,
0.0458795391,
0.0291802417,
0.0136531284,
-0.0092966277,
0.0134798791,
-0.0128320418,
0.0009454184,
0.0072421231,
-0.0202851277,
0.053931959,
-6.095817626e-33,
-0.0126962354,
-0.0044057765,
-0.0026047695,
0.0148815755,
0.0093167927,
0.0349514857,
0.0172169022,
-0.0061384034,
0.0076274658,
0.0192210879,
-0.0086984877,
0.0271953102,
-0.0010483091,
0.0701505691,
-0.0000308376,
0.00233333,
0.0519428588,
0.0139172273,
0.0189644024,
0.0628526881,
0.0447735116,
0.0279595722,
0.0091259927,
-0.1004991531,
0.0364283621,
-0.0225353409,
-0.0153869363,
0.0226299278,
-0.0548175275,
0.0411321297,
-0.0030193161,
0.0385476463,
0.0251529329,
-0.0219179988,
-0.0086205397,
0.0390148163,
-0.087982513,
-0.0784573331,
-0.0542620905,
-0.0228770543,
-0.0108933803,
-0.0165868625,
0.0562076457,
0.006164378,
0.0725404248,
-0.0601274185,
0.0728696063,
0.0202461742,
-0.0118178781,
-0.0768783391,
0.0153543781,
0.0231983755,
-0.0022646869,
-0.0329907574,
0.0498862416,
-0.000677672,
0.0380900055,
-0.009731628,
-0.0853365213,
0.0217973255,
0.0461300947,
0.0168420915,
0.0162239484,
0.0296063758,
-0.0302997958,
0.049970977,
0.0072783879,
0.0024909435,
-0.0552246943,
-0.0229450744,
0.0129903769,
0.0702270418,
0.0473333262,
0.0486438833,
0.0277764723,
-0.0146673312,
-0.0586209372,
0.0416095629,
-0.0124343904,
-0.0522057675,
-0.0338033587,
0.0042322497,
-0.0378766134,
-0.010510725,
-0.0512567423,
-0.0322417356,
-0.0182412881,
0.0148155848,
0.0100963423,
0.0290277805,
-0.0337006934,
0.0193101969,
-0.0044687856,
-0.0645933598,
-0.0406677574,
0.0146393348,
0.0335583352,
-0.0047807256,
-0.0264137238,
-0.0044253436,
-0.0681627095,
-0.0283716172,
0.0433389433,
0.0069168932,
0.0052573662,
0.0142766209,
0.0924621075,
0.0282915942,
-0.0740084872,
-0.0265482794,
0.0033968403,
0.0168563724,
0.0476131439,
0.0158364605,
0.0301185753,
0.0358538926,
-0.0085571148,
0.0162500646,
0.0462206565,
0.005155304,
-0.0205277801,
0.0213362519,
0.0162228588,
-0.0204455052,
0.0136442753,
-0.0516123548,
-0.0073342817,
0.0036424086,
0.072173737,
-0.0593877546,
0.0197785869,
0.0215361938,
2.615e-7,
0.0187013689,
-0.0224870965,
-0.0136076296,
-0.0483790971,
0.0061253733,
0.0577247813,
-0.0006343149,
0.0400800183,
-0.0190923382,
-0.0181719214,
0.0065127476,
0.0460613035,
0.031187905,
0.0481486171,
-0.077828221,
-0.0415263847,
0.0016249595,
0.0141727086,
-0.0352121554,
-0.0083127515,
0.0841927603,
0.0364392474,
0.0895428509,
-0.0084833736,
-0.0104901204,
-0.0174099747,
0.0436599366,
-0.0017181619,
0.0213589743,
0.0377004147,
0.0641779378,
0.0416546017,
-0.0486811921,
0.0452975594,
-0.0486573279,
0.0266906638,
-0.0105437087,
0.0439883284,
0.0071782488,
0.0053496435,
0.0076260003,
-0.0016098183,
-0.0223096404,
0.0079002324,
0.0706438795,
-0.0811385959,
0.0113196429,
0.0420816801,
-0.0003153044,
-0.0398913026,
0.0266341269,
0.0537762977,
0.0216927659,
0.0235086866,
-0.0022516067,
-0.0010501273,
-0.0117033385,
-0.1178485081,
0.0255394019,
-0.0326013118,
-0.0224005487,
-0.0081134588,
-0.0119495029,
-0.0053579397,
0.0089481818,
-0.0596460626,
0.0455011502,
2.148436561e-34,
0.0022472534,
-0.0113449814,
0.0177352987,
-0.0410594903,
-0.0037457545,
-0.0219417047,
-0.0001207638,
0.0046844375,
0.0171541441,
-0.0418708399,
-0.0181188211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11073v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11073v1 | Exploring the Limitations of Detecting Machine-Generated Text | 2024-06-16T21:02:02 | 2024-06-16T21:02:02 | Jad Doughman, Osama Mohammed Afzal, Hawau Olamide Toyin, Shady Shehata, Preslav Nakov, Zeerak Talat | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent improvements in the quality of the generations by large language
models have spurred research into identifying machine-generated text. Systems
proposed for the task often achieve high performance. However, humans and
machines can produce text in different styles and in different domains, and it
remains unclear whether machine generated-text detection models favour
particular styles or domains. In this paper, we critically examine the
classification performance for detecting machine-generated text by evaluating
on texts with varying writing styles. We find that classifiers are highly
sensitive to stylistic changes and differences in text complexity, and in some
cases degrade entirely to random classifiers. We further find that detection
systems are particularly susceptible to misclassify easy-to-read texts while
they have high performance for complex texts. | [
0.0491025075,
0.0361864492,
-0.0276337676,
0.0385597683,
-0.0404445753,
0.0304005966,
0.0177179128,
0.0552621968,
0.0072734142,
-0.0598476306,
0.008447865,
-0.0421011262,
0.0222444274,
0.0316325054,
-0.0041948296,
-0.0106949331,
-0.0022615853,
-0.0075025489,
0.0037536148,
0.0387902036,
0.0320969857,
0.0256717689,
0.0128129078,
0.0139437551,
-0.006353314,
-0.0255242158,
0.0135970293,
0.0344120562,
0.0021392892,
-0.0023783578,
0.0296602659,
0.0721666664,
-0.0279358644,
0.105230391,
0.0000015301,
-0.022588402,
-0.0018789661,
-0.0176876187,
-0.0226245001,
0.0213457029,
0.0905500874,
-0.0325398929,
-0.0411945544,
0.027364986,
0.0050381632,
-0.0037028436,
0.0147741586,
0.0459131114,
0.0000321417,
0.0836660862,
-0.0283714011,
-0.0022084895,
0.0246240348,
0.0215872508,
0.0111227427,
0.0017614167,
0.0134112416,
-0.0521199293,
-0.0093634222,
0.0053401561,
0.0339627862,
0.0146404887,
-0.0108174514,
-0.0413653888,
-0.0010199187,
0.0232796315,
-0.0166825447,
0.0021246278,
-0.0256006345,
0.0086955987,
-0.0118341567,
-0.0561284795,
0.0462783352,
-0.0280192178,
0.025407685,
0.0217633191,
0.0405451357,
0.0451835468,
-0.0734135136,
-0.0066351094,
-0.0032154601,
0.0161324721,
0.0081979539,
0.0547877252,
0.0183628723,
0.0180905089,
0.0009580693,
-0.048302412,
-0.0200631265,
0.0369706713,
0.0177770685,
-0.0453637876,
0.0555832461,
0.0148975886,
0.0081058219,
-0.0235930271,
-0.1000687256,
-0.0694006979,
0.021521749,
-0.039457228,
0.0444416031,
-0.0286206771,
0.0108429464,
0.0108975191,
-0.0587016493,
0.0404343791,
-0.0158554185,
-0.0182572305,
0.0049560089,
0.0395229459,
-0.0217841994,
-0.0201135799,
-0.0021986142,
-0.0236178748,
0.0051218984,
-0.0156904962,
-0.0246363971,
0.0577797443,
0.0136966435,
0.0033016084,
-0.052440498,
-0.0333299004,
-0.0196942259,
0.0152528705,
-0.0005105702,
-0.0213021934,
0.021957282,
0.0236950908,
-0.0090540433,
-0.0432439074,
0.0106201917,
0.0730583742,
0.0439870209,
0.0111168744,
0.0166418944,
0.0270841792,
-0.0363369137,
-0.046680253,
-0.0565085635,
-0.039524056,
-0.0342365913,
-0.0303367116,
0.0080077685,
-0.0451422296,
-0.0581993088,
0.0047810068,
-0.0223157108,
0.00033693,
-0.0128244292,
0.0448258892,
-0.0162391923,
0.0342235789,
-0.0061875819,
-0.006934708,
0.074496679,
-0.0175755359,
0.0167557336,
0.0323465131,
0.0103245154,
0.0815370753,
0.0429764092,
0.0024338304,
0.0721751973,
0.0593106225,
-0.0302775074,
-0.0053315489,
0.0053639975,
-0.0551358312,
-0.0269278847,
0.0127395736,
0.0261835866,
0.0410792194,
0.028174486,
0.0039190315,
0.0866021737,
0.0090081329,
0.0299227443,
0.006143935,
0.0528485253,
0.0568814687,
0.0223501138,
0.059820883,
-0.0011762925,
-0.0525342599,
-0.0553302541,
0.001884995,
-0.0041392944,
-0.0190753397,
0.005980453,
-0.0300109815,
-0.0253354348,
-0.0206564348,
-0.0043719276,
-0.054794956,
0.0709151775,
0.0214213412,
-0.0496024787,
-0.0686870441,
-0.0171084385,
-0.0332255699,
-0.001951831,
-0.0575149618,
0.0603735149,
0.0727428347,
0.0426113941,
-0.0049095396,
0.0717770681,
-0.0098675452,
0.0189453252,
0.059554588,
0.0222451501,
-0.0103860367,
-0.0057750447,
-0.0233167522,
-0.0157820918,
0.0303665586,
0.0263823457,
-0.0141624073,
0.0268438365,
0.0114550637,
0.0178676397,
-0.0154456319,
-0.0686036274,
0.0793433264,
0.0101188319,
-0.0237442572,
0.0156922229,
0.0315718018,
-0.0119089521,
-0.0011859826,
-0.0437349342,
0.0080093583,
-0.0175470617,
-0.0382525884,
-0.0199156981,
-0.0240831655,
-0.0032447092,
-0.0144404471,
-0.0205808561,
-0.0174981523,
-0.0556762591,
0.0055104322,
-0.0030117489,
-0.008259831,
-0.0057889414,
-0.0853477046,
-0.0064444947,
-0.0899379402,
0.0345515497,
-0.0486178771,
0.0113266949,
-0.0337417386,
0.0696304291,
0.0097957039,
-0.0122521473,
0.0113438899,
-0.0237180665,
0.0363166593,
-0.0120724496,
0.0152970403,
-0.0393044911,
-0.0346603021,
0.0216922183,
0.0170767866,
0.0156481899,
-0.0179839674,
-0.0467399657,
-0.0518972091,
-0.0066529126,
-0.0494886898,
0.0214765817,
0.0241036844,
-0.0243800618,
-0.0142235663,
-0.0049054865,
-0.004175033,
-0.0039032709,
0.0336045809,
0.0150563447,
0.055791121,
-0.041537717,
0.0370940976,
-0.0027854089,
-0.0076199169,
-0.0007378139,
0.0453820154,
0.072190173,
-0.0263618492,
-0.0816885009,
0.0345911272,
0.02231819,
-0.0277991816,
0.0238582008,
-0.0274039544,
-0.0141224042,
-0.0118503682,
0.0329318307,
0.0823342949,
0.0544429645,
0.0287440754,
0.0099380007,
0.070875138,
0.0136297522,
-0.0232594721,
0.0026353304,
0.0355845802,
-0.0013720568,
-0.0707802102,
0.0524510518,
0.0459281392,
-0.0050200988,
0.0075279148,
0.0119061051,
0.027053399,
0.0004276821,
-0.0184632745,
0.0000235992,
-0.0163571108,
-0.0235674884,
0.0505085923,
-0.0270807371,
-0.0804577321,
0.0376329757,
-0.0279831029,
0.0161131881,
-0.0162608586,
-0.0335694589,
-0.0122630214,
-0.0016756968,
0.0241327882,
0.0352475718,
0.0276185516,
-0.0320151374,
-0.0278913341,
0.0495462008,
0.04947339,
-0.0130949477,
0.029240191,
-0.0218309499,
0.0053751096,
-0.0029593259,
-0.0199388359,
-0.0580891259,
-0.0389248803,
0.0033996464,
-0.0280733407,
0.0503996983,
-0.0359202251,
-0.0097808298,
0.0105246687,
-0.0045048399,
0.0668819919,
-0.0236332957,
-0.0248179846,
-0.0193800498,
0.0874609798,
0.0129053574,
-0.0406058691,
0.0117125819,
-0.0545578375,
-0.0159898866,
0.0334286653,
-0.0240517799,
0.0222449545,
-0.0031157748,
-0.0140471533,
0.01423671,
-0.0221840218,
-0.0375373811,
0.0258877352,
0.0213854909,
-0.0599403121,
-0.010193903,
0.093150124,
0.0229784418,
-0.0364678316,
-0.0168568157,
0.0018232209,
0.0291474294,
-0.0047149858,
0.0180007219,
-0.0293918774,
-0.018911371,
0.0273230094,
0.0287702363,
-0.0600673705,
0.0234541483,
0.0079259975,
-0.0737651363,
0.036824815,
-0.0012313224,
-0.0488821343,
-0.0273080673,
-0.0204034355,
-0.0133448336,
0.0179208685,
-0.0485500768,
-0.0139282318,
-0.0452647954,
-0.0050840164,
-0.0008372372,
-0.063312538,
-0.0489564724,
-0.0572807305,
-0.0296581499,
-0.0012528269,
0.0699977875,
0.0442936011,
-0.0390084349,
-0.0425843671,
0.0309222434,
-0.0335846506,
0.007615041,
-0.0269627497,
0.0706524104,
0.0080364356,
-0.0028768617,
-0.0648544133,
0.0166482795,
0.0116546927,
0.0142935822,
0.0229093507,
0.0151630035,
-0.0217824839,
-0.085135825,
-0.0381495878,
-0.0056821732,
0.0212119836,
0.0441649333,
0.0301970895,
-0.0666190609,
-0.0942033604,
-0.0494157858,
0.0325590335,
-0.0796707645,
-0.0191290081,
0.0047099409,
-0.0173295829,
-0.0428598411,
-0.0975297391,
-0.0188015532,
-0.0363227427,
0.0108513916,
0.0131847989,
-0.0017189007,
-0.0113444747,
0.0023249923,
-0.0823476464,
-0.0427648388,
-0.0021933634,
0.0212567803,
-0.067975536,
-0.0283383001,
-0.0156674068,
-0.0468022563,
-0.0028489751,
0.0196783077,
-0.0540309809,
-0.0228479858,
-0.0016786664,
-0.0103399465,
0.0176723674,
-0.0076314067,
-0.0116512105,
-0.0565573722,
0.0938175172,
0.0407078713,
0.004569666,
0.006459787,
0.0100718709,
-0.0351266116,
-0.0494245254,
0.0138643654,
-0.0189681537,
0.0334071703,
0.0228575896,
-0.0666192472,
-0.0216498058,
-0.0072048847,
0.0032984277,
-0.0068177213,
0.0084525142,
-0.0252507962,
-0.0197216962,
-0.0243500602,
-0.0440534167,
0.0269082189,
-0.0119714038,
-0.0344463848,
-0.0162385963,
0.0166090727,
0.0370585322,
-0.0323490351,
0.0503696501,
-0.0062497882,
0.05878428,
-0.018331917,
0.0052520912,
0.0132306926,
0.0976443067,
0.0003960806,
0.0030443962,
0.0025323685,
0.0517069995,
0.0078188796,
0.0290926527,
0.0162201785,
0.0471161455,
-0.005638611,
0.0051541529,
0.0008792335,
0.0129036102,
-0.0675936118,
0.0390737616,
-0.0420114435,
0.0184649769,
0.0538595319,
-0.0484162867,
0.0289406516,
-0.0382250436,
-0.0069577689,
-0.0524655394,
0.021703817,
0.0251874719,
-0.0173116159,
-0.0526270568,
-0.0086074928,
-0.0377806835,
-0.0014991496,
0.0750954002,
0.0506828614,
0.0178030282,
0.0051708906,
-0.0451131016,
-0.0312960558,
-0.0072431294,
0.0372508056,
0.0005994671,
0.0020292799,
0.0155703351,
-0.0279448703,
-0.0292125065,
0.0762590915,
-0.0273097381,
0.0492719077,
-0.0062418259,
-0.0151464427,
0.0563901328,
-0.0142168896,
0.0008369365,
-0.0746712089,
0.0263206791,
-0.0206661094,
0.0120987957,
-0.0238075405,
-4.863613754e-33,
0.0103001222,
-0.0824896619,
-0.0524053909,
0.0198175143,
0.0155088454,
0.025967529,
-0.0296820626,
-0.0177882425,
0.0227540545,
0.0303205345,
-0.0233633183,
0.0127852075,
0.0131965484,
0.0179761108,
0.0052451147,
0.0025104694,
0.066152662,
-0.0281045996,
-0.0493414924,
0.0183272921,
0.0307419579,
0.0101084094,
0.0101824785,
-0.0660746992,
0.0104367454,
-0.0561936907,
-0.0239595324,
-0.0062884842,
0.0027540692,
0.0460605547,
-0.017058026,
0.0355576538,
0.0533774979,
0.0005305283,
-0.0121529503,
0.0687409416,
-0.0207761247,
0.0097799776,
-0.0627305061,
0.0260550287,
-0.0131940125,
-0.0718328208,
0.0463927537,
-0.0293758493,
-0.0209611077,
0.014938849,
0.0837193504,
-0.0302418005,
-0.0011551613,
-0.0599412769,
-0.0577421077,
0.0461547971,
0.0251812562,
-0.0089491755,
0.0362035297,
0.048011858,
0.0217490364,
0.0024151269,
-0.0473307148,
0.0252736323,
0.0061595854,
0.0092397351,
-0.0002266221,
0.0446454398,
-0.0367863066,
0.0297884587,
0.02590294,
0.0567668192,
-0.0353163444,
0.0071240463,
0.0255755559,
-0.014270436,
0.0594469979,
0.0739946365,
0.0432305336,
-0.0341296159,
-0.0340182409,
0.0620749518,
0.0051542153,
-0.0382520892,
0.016279988,
-0.0207425486,
-0.0495901592,
-0.0090645291,
0.0067894217,
-0.0687247068,
-0.0214186739,
0.0220399052,
0.0086823367,
0.0290845502,
-0.0097202631,
-0.0112386681,
0.0056442018,
-0.0362597182,
-0.0312784202,
-0.0044527934,
-0.0293903667,
0.0325112045,
0.0015767396,
-0.0116831865,
-0.0045260438,
-0.0161253605,
0.0412363559,
0.0259683169,
0.0208152831,
-0.0007229561,
0.0641286746,
0.0109606767,
-0.0659080371,
0.0238549784,
0.0187614486,
0.0126436204,
0.0261874236,
0.0318937115,
0.0165744256,
-0.0637835637,
0.0220870096,
0.0048392075,
0.0259514824,
0.0273240879,
-0.0408742651,
-0.0390640385,
-0.0313923284,
0.0160278939,
-0.0253414381,
-0.0094496598,
-0.0349083096,
0.0255294591,
0.0012158479,
-0.0512992851,
0.036989063,
-0.0648882687,
1.991e-7,
0.0352533497,
0.0516858958,
0.0443390571,
-0.0004161003,
0.0449442342,
0.0517459065,
0.0128454948,
0.0117197428,
-0.0341411792,
0.0446608029,
0.013299101,
-0.0281016566,
0.0920073166,
-0.0142082833,
-0.0752366632,
0.0113060838,
-0.0576540381,
0.0568338446,
-0.0479869433,
0.0175247453,
0.0902544558,
0.0360357575,
-0.0261174683,
-0.0478792712,
0.0397039875,
-0.0842341557,
0.0639109686,
-0.0108575402,
0.0556302667,
0.0108177373,
0.0464960821,
0.0079401052,
0.0034834868,
0.030971121,
-0.038972225,
-0.0169051997,
0.0176674463,
0.0629311278,
0.0157291498,
0.0530013777,
0.0062567671,
0.014520647,
0.0182143115,
-0.0153418863,
0.0661962032,
0.016686514,
0.004233269,
-0.0479517579,
-0.003117783,
-0.0689811632,
0.0174625311,
-0.0141354641,
-0.0166794527,
0.0338152014,
0.0027353861,
-0.015642941,
-0.005983572,
-0.0527616218,
-0.0232945774,
-0.0227657966,
-0.0330993533,
0.0180697609,
-0.0642886683,
0.0262900591,
0.0708249584,
-0.042520348,
0.0353750512,
1.774880413e-34,
0.0301095061,
-0.0170203391,
-0.0167250857,
0.0088254418,
-0.0086103836,
0.0267312657,
0.0319919698,
0.0059844563,
-0.011087046,
-0.0387158692,
0.0513419546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11069v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11069v1 | WildVision: Evaluating Vision-Language Models in the Wild with Human Preferences | 2024-06-16T20:53:25 | 2024-06-16T20:53:25 | Yujie Lu, Dongfu Jiang, Wenhu Chen, William Yang Wang, Yejin Choi, Bill Yuchen Lin | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent breakthroughs in vision-language models (VLMs) emphasize the necessity
of benchmarking human preferences in real-world multimodal interactions. To
address this gap, we launched WildVision-Arena (WV-Arena), an online platform
that collects human preferences to evaluate VLMs. We curated WV-Bench by
selecting 500 high-quality samples from 8,000 user submissions in WV-Arena.
WV-Bench uses GPT-4 as the judge to compare each VLM with Claude-3-Sonnet,
achieving a Spearman correlation of 0.94 with the WV-Arena Elo. This
significantly outperforms other benchmarks like MMVet, MMMU, and MMStar.
Our comprehensive analysis of 20K real-world interactions reveals important
insights into the failure cases of top-performing VLMs. For example, we find
that although GPT-4V surpasses many other models like Reka-Flash, Opus, and
Yi-VL-Plus in simple visual recognition and reasoning tasks, it still faces
challenges with subtle contextual cues, spatial reasoning, visual imagination,
and expert domain knowledge. Additionally, current VLMs exhibit issues with
hallucinations and safety when intentionally provoked. We are releasing our
chat and feedback data to further advance research in the field of VLMs. | [
0.0085423291,
0.0526365638,
-0.0069069508,
0.0471398011,
-0.0541696511,
0.0124766994,
0.0031937945,
0.0023302149,
0.0335297994,
-0.0415528975,
-0.059708178,
-0.0532890297,
0.0340136923,
0.0612691939,
0.0071994737,
-0.0564269125,
-0.0094375741,
-0.0626676083,
-0.0222389027,
0.022261763,
-0.0083928565,
-0.0012414529,
-0.0438060276,
0.0536595657,
-0.0017089029,
-0.0072495514,
-0.0073332391,
0.0134460106,
0.0333705433,
-0.0349512734,
-0.042396985,
0.0557104573,
0.0135435471,
-0.0046578017,
0.0000022415,
-0.0448903441,
0.0548011623,
-0.0305567365,
0.048320137,
-0.014798617,
0.0281458795,
0.014175592,
0.0029826968,
-0.0021990305,
-0.0458219275,
-0.0153881377,
0.0730106011,
0.0259312261,
0.0264067557,
0.0200642403,
-0.0092264852,
-0.0160065126,
0.0200601164,
-0.0157148652,
0.0305074621,
-0.0150600737,
0.0497557558,
-0.0062224325,
0.0110341329,
-0.0413333774,
-0.0353153981,
0.0087836981,
0.0280334204,
0.0036576991,
0.0141468542,
0.0347116552,
-0.082946822,
-0.0597937256,
-0.0257345811,
0.0876651406,
-0.0216278676,
-0.0327275731,
0.0211875513,
0.0173938852,
-0.0077496525,
0.0088300519,
-0.0341051221,
0.0190844443,
-0.0183664821,
0.0048988946,
-0.0576090813,
0.0303260274,
0.0139949108,
-0.0196624398,
0.0096505219,
0.02692274,
0.0263328459,
0.0279631168,
0.0414104499,
-0.0043472033,
-0.0408094898,
-0.0776842833,
0.0089906175,
-0.0393343233,
-0.0464047752,
-0.0161437467,
-0.0616624244,
0.0189884137,
-0.0105892885,
-0.0391794741,
0.0653601587,
0.0207974631,
-0.0543916039,
0.057992667,
0.0016524788,
0.0557036176,
-0.0115604391,
0.0346275344,
-0.0026010424,
0.0190488957,
-0.0217666794,
0.00277945,
-0.0039066449,
-0.0416829772,
-0.0559514575,
-0.0528788529,
-0.02968481,
-0.0039807376,
-0.0431548804,
0.0104604829,
0.0072890655,
0.0357391089,
0.0187378265,
-0.0163544063,
-0.0438556597,
-0.0000454282,
0.0037350857,
0.0080551403,
0.002478312,
-0.0879299939,
0.0232496988,
0.0474358201,
-0.0167490896,
-0.013835934,
-0.0305532105,
0.1073801816,
0.0150818639,
-0.0366165861,
0.0226175506,
0.0052011744,
-0.0138031198,
-0.0516579561,
0.0290001724,
-0.061642278,
0.0219630785,
-0.0326854363,
-0.0089781992,
-0.0283953249,
0.029052183,
0.002008595,
-0.0109124472,
0.0948962718,
-0.0118014114,
0.0030220081,
-0.0326597467,
0.0221997947,
0.0097631849,
0.0493313856,
0.0263961479,
0.0408109128,
0.01876943,
-0.0118515696,
0.0803183839,
0.0314423963,
-0.0393811092,
-0.0062952922,
-0.0548305809,
0.0043269871,
-0.0063279155,
0.0689073727,
-0.0039445814,
0.0705713108,
-0.0258941278,
-0.0752763003,
0.0984883755,
0.0710435137,
-0.0019032022,
-0.0545787103,
0.0158689711,
-0.0146413362,
0.0282971393,
-0.0351334549,
-0.0523000769,
0.0609803051,
-0.017690897,
-0.0203495715,
-0.0081428587,
0.0108862538,
-0.0156231141,
-0.0347333401,
-0.0366837122,
-0.0103831897,
0.0083519584,
0.0330073908,
0.0407322422,
-0.0132740242,
-0.0377201885,
-0.0294411145,
0.008413245,
-0.0422727764,
-0.0091939569,
-0.0508757122,
0.0111556742,
0.0966227278,
0.0392496549,
0.01232515,
0.0042617158,
-0.0073721409,
0.0311443731,
0.0600086376,
0.0376180299,
0.0356099717,
0.04752912,
-0.0383562669,
-0.0257947408,
0.0059292288,
0.0151721556,
0.0263756923,
-0.0192805305,
-0.0184803084,
-0.0055098399,
-0.0506168082,
0.0003488467,
0.0336421169,
-0.0005130445,
0.0007969072,
-0.0423250422,
0.0056832801,
0.0088386005,
0.0127698267,
-0.0067710117,
0.0237610675,
0.0267121512,
-0.0158341285,
0.0298262648,
0.0568965077,
-0.0328592435,
0.0183973406,
0.0415868834,
-0.0806641355,
0.0143918926,
0.0458508171,
0.0009494738,
0.0049698036,
0.0042711319,
-0.0176345985,
0.013614702,
-0.0314806812,
0.0078445282,
0.0240944605,
-0.0112478537,
-0.0071505387,
0.060056977,
-0.0316062756,
-0.009651334,
0.0059922095,
-0.0129556768,
0.0064264378,
-0.0316506438,
-0.0226821061,
0.019497769,
-0.0045059584,
0.0191855039,
-0.0053745992,
-0.0168615244,
-0.0794587806,
0.015819082,
-0.0822925866,
-0.0304739419,
-0.0330514759,
-0.0389761701,
0.0098458594,
-0.0346063152,
-0.030614743,
-0.0314533971,
-0.0299953148,
0.0380999558,
-0.0173971076,
0.0206786059,
-0.0061287759,
-0.0239612926,
-0.0245540012,
-0.0233074278,
-0.0121086687,
0.0204579718,
0.0552189574,
0.0181768704,
-0.0038395792,
-0.0083027864,
0.0226631872,
-0.0525012873,
0.039359346,
-0.0434683412,
-0.021395022,
0.0363812372,
-0.0287805423,
0.0097472444,
0.068028219,
0.0361319445,
-0.0049615591,
0.052820079,
-0.0170594845,
-0.0033460904,
-0.0470052809,
0.0175975095,
-0.0351134799,
-0.0109388251,
0.0134763736,
0.0099072661,
0.0421701893,
0.0093678134,
0.033186812,
-0.0893478766,
0.0524394475,
0.025305843,
-0.0842611268,
-0.0176966507,
-0.0019016225,
-0.0289815068,
0.0730945617,
-0.0255929772,
-0.0675076023,
0.0553597286,
-0.0303119645,
-0.0077947672,
0.0270288922,
0.0305713695,
0.0065689394,
0.056694027,
0.0467653312,
0.0070349425,
-0.0241959412,
0.0036506178,
-0.0437692702,
-0.0433534496,
-0.0114380633,
-0.0376866125,
0.0543535352,
-0.0718390197,
0.0018406047,
-0.0009297788,
-0.0052487594,
-0.0370666534,
-0.0010498329,
-0.0553655997,
-0.0207735524,
-0.0294448026,
-0.0021573873,
-0.0137351817,
0.0276067797,
0.0106314439,
0.0249508955,
0.0090907821,
-0.0291826278,
-0.002535654,
0.0034595227,
0.0748755112,
0.0275777038,
-0.0015094025,
-0.0379927419,
-0.0135214543,
0.095499143,
0.0312045943,
0.001571694,
-0.069852896,
0.0529890321,
0.003608563,
0.0346294865,
0.0086035943,
0.0458627902,
0.0588993765,
-0.0327090286,
0.0302750301,
0.0575880781,
0.0152768213,
-0.0522443131,
0.0055413465,
-0.0133583955,
0.0450731739,
0.0269731246,
-0.0155622829,
-0.0933613256,
-0.0454333387,
-0.0010781564,
0.0273700152,
0.016440304,
-0.0395595916,
0.0081145531,
-0.0817108154,
0.0458214171,
0.017118955,
-0.023007134,
-0.0059137987,
0.0045032604,
0.0391178988,
-0.0446408205,
-0.0091449823,
0.0046604536,
-0.0088337185,
-0.0037834954,
-0.0192506872,
0.0160635058,
-0.0193880834,
0.0752086937,
-0.0440960042,
0.0285599977,
0.0763270035,
0.0108767189,
0.0146470275,
-0.0924811661,
0.002925287,
0.0204927903,
0.0236468129,
0.0021133542,
0.0426548049,
-0.0246566348,
-0.0123982178,
-0.0179290622,
0.0523966514,
-0.0341418125,
-0.0492887832,
0.0006166225,
0.0055240332,
-0.0247702859,
-0.0232223645,
-0.0361660533,
0.029513834,
-0.0092929583,
0.049809251,
0.0299401078,
-0.0589696765,
-0.0443425663,
-0.0014322901,
0.029492544,
-0.0172293186,
-0.0934476703,
-0.019043304,
0.0897102132,
-0.0388759971,
-0.0765078366,
-0.0133819021,
0.0306419954,
0.0569863245,
-0.0121674854,
-0.003799865,
-0.0267143603,
0.0205833092,
-0.0173207205,
0.0994716063,
0.0055724219,
0.0149111357,
-0.0436087176,
0.0170337874,
0.0016981425,
-0.0648955107,
0.0040496648,
0.0420946032,
-0.0587495565,
-0.0501364656,
0.0026586992,
0.0725157782,
0.0335560441,
0.0378846824,
-0.0000391005,
-0.0247333348,
0.0116900215,
0.0615864918,
0.0260977279,
0.0356727354,
-0.0096813319,
-0.0035940579,
0.0052370424,
0.013776266,
-0.0093907015,
0.0017913652,
0.0208038762,
0.0220645685,
0.0340484157,
-0.0265510883,
0.0172684398,
-0.0169090088,
0.0653840154,
-0.0395374298,
0.0004427773,
-0.0057232017,
-0.0043522362,
-0.0254572239,
0.0180229247,
-0.0757340044,
-0.001119911,
0.0146477837,
0.0155304233,
0.0039404822,
-0.0294232368,
-0.0355862379,
-0.0230506063,
-0.0367224365,
-0.0282294694,
0.0375592671,
-0.057647299,
0.0220002644,
0.0096942168,
-0.0128869778,
0.0130638406,
-0.0373126231,
0.0600974485,
0.02646029,
0.0628325343,
0.0007110672,
-0.0369976386,
0.0251140688,
0.0681011006,
-0.0351195522,
-0.0897834376,
-0.004150976,
0.0471883379,
0.0574926287,
0.0004162436,
0.0274337027,
-0.0376381278,
0.0177796874,
-0.0492628627,
0.0485460088,
0.019219758,
-0.0238861665,
0.0103365202,
0.0310240965,
-0.0282218717,
-0.0072000488,
0.034140382,
-0.0017393085,
0.0004791605,
-0.0108774947,
0.0076321,
-0.0288741868,
-0.0104729217,
0.0160357542,
0.0144086992,
-0.0373384655,
-0.020683866,
-0.0589518473,
-0.0526518971,
-0.0318018161,
0.0475926921,
0.0054632528,
0.0074903467,
0.0684153587,
0.0456195399,
0.0020495111,
-0.0088605499,
0.0046859733,
-0.048013337,
0.0093566626,
-0.0105986921,
0.0078898184,
-6.417377044e-33,
0.0013433913,
-0.0155790383,
0.0291495528,
-0.0131265,
-0.0015455538,
-0.0259039067,
-0.0227177832,
0.033484634,
-0.0124881864,
-0.0135486554,
0.0262856446,
-0.0140113672,
-0.0007454237,
0.0120494021,
0.0106940689,
-0.0275770687,
0.0017570135,
0.0043765469,
-0.0449417494,
-0.0126345484,
0.0094391778,
-0.031058602,
0.0231177863,
-0.0832796916,
-0.0012883567,
0.0421682559,
-0.0222938042,
0.0050303452,
-0.0331600532,
0.070351392,
-0.0368001089,
0.020552922,
0.005506305,
0.0256896503,
-0.0289836284,
0.0108607886,
0.0044016195,
0.0143175013,
0.0112230005,
0.0241773315,
-0.1009786502,
0.0259968415,
0.0644043759,
-0.0066226977,
-0.0237386655,
-0.0375930741,
0.0276455842,
-0.0306286067,
-0.0233666729,
0.0320942551,
-0.036819797,
-0.0002971267,
0.0197120663,
-0.0541896373,
0.0377036147,
0.0565751269,
-0.025328774,
0.0144351516,
-0.0538537577,
0.0440791138,
-0.0333252959,
-0.0295023192,
0.1122254133,
0.0190964583,
0.0356585272,
0.0964682177,
0.0758209452,
-0.0287403855,
-0.0198628157,
-0.0375121571,
0.0198629107,
0.1028965488,
0.0448363721,
0.0524529181,
0.0034502787,
0.0104681831,
-0.0141848261,
-0.0036166988,
-0.0435532033,
0.0361980759,
0.0474852845,
0.0219462011,
-0.0486087054,
0.0213205423,
-0.013233861,
0.0048494348,
-0.0654725134,
-0.027126113,
0.0610037744,
0.0034799799,
0.00029603,
0.0047829058,
0.0512258299,
-0.034835536,
0.0175281037,
-0.0023513937,
-0.0253303722,
0.0553892069,
-0.0055740932,
0.000836311,
-0.0168767553,
0.0192089025,
0.0532513857,
0.0076512857,
0.0243465845,
0.006634654,
-0.0364742354,
-0.0030217918,
-0.0342810526,
0.00285852,
-0.0316071138,
0.0109970793,
0.0370824039,
0.0324096531,
0.0851244628,
-0.027018087,
-0.0435040258,
0.0038802123,
-0.0282818247,
-0.0354616493,
-0.0369827189,
0.0004226145,
-0.0185346231,
0.0117646977,
0.0027454833,
0.0004621515,
-0.0583446249,
-0.0495321862,
0.0174531341,
-0.0114892414,
-0.0147763221,
0.0061032656,
3.008e-7,
-0.0170723107,
0.0390696041,
-0.0047129444,
-0.0069721951,
0.0122422315,
0.0560562424,
-0.0008406299,
0.0612587593,
0.0170218349,
-0.0538807139,
-0.019888198,
0.0199511554,
0.0723865479,
0.0083660297,
-0.0248772353,
-0.0102377571,
0.0148147829,
0.0070365747,
-0.0520655513,
-0.0200661551,
0.0626612976,
0.0172988046,
0.0072084125,
0.0003368195,
0.0605070703,
-0.0396850668,
0.0658537745,
-0.0687512457,
-0.0094370469,
-0.0410089903,
0.0172077175,
0.0162915159,
-0.0093614114,
0.0358101875,
-0.0189108755,
-0.0455399007,
0.0260172039,
0.0345665812,
-0.0513983741,
-0.0718906298,
-0.0223938767,
0.0221046451,
-0.0048456602,
-0.0719394013,
0.0776434168,
-0.029260546,
-0.0121057685,
-0.0037477606,
-0.033542458,
-0.0248336531,
0.0237077549,
-0.0144196376,
-0.027556967,
-0.0001558527,
0.0253147837,
0.0038858668,
-0.0447972715,
-0.0544057637,
-0.008536404,
-0.0167888869,
-0.0509812683,
-0.0423142947,
-0.0437782556,
0.0376807526,
-0.0111410627,
-0.015232686,
-0.0637108162,
2.395338129e-34,
0.0134992357,
0.0252477787,
0.0398544632,
-0.0346443318,
0.0020351685,
-0.0001502283,
0.0238453858,
0.030328989,
-0.0002168481,
-0.0529468432,
-0.0051479591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11065v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11065v1 | Can LLMs Understand the Implication of Emphasized Sentences in Dialogue? | 2024-06-16T20:41:44 | 2024-06-16T20:41:44 | Guan-Ting Lin, Hung-yi Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emphasis is a crucial component in human communication, which indicates the
speaker's intention and implication beyond pure text in dialogue. While Large
Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized natural language processing, their
ability to understand emphasis in dialogue remains unclear. This paper
introduces Emphasized-Talk, a benchmark with emphasis-annotated dialogue
samples capturing the implications of emphasis. We evaluate various LLMs, both
open-source and commercial, to measure their performance in understanding
emphasis. Additionally, we propose an automatic evaluation pipeline using
GPT-4, which achieves a high correlation with human rating. Our findings reveal
that although commercial LLMs generally perform better, there is still
significant room for improvement in comprehending emphasized sentences. | [
0.0461987965,
0.0461264811,
-0.007825736,
0.0209860411,
-0.0203543697,
-0.0057705087,
-0.0278798677,
-0.0169793889,
-0.01340272,
-0.0339125954,
-0.0666815564,
-0.0309080742,
-0.0108640734,
0.0073540355,
0.0313005894,
-0.0726258978,
0.0335378051,
-0.0133018391,
0.0341711082,
0.0198795069,
0.0303771552,
0.0317866094,
-0.0011727258,
0.0616312176,
-0.000849951,
-0.0128868846,
-0.0002163273,
0.0436289907,
0.0404892601,
-0.0264462363,
-0.0087786969,
0.0307102073,
0.0035368323,
0.0003568062,
0.0000015982,
-0.0249081757,
0.0175353587,
-0.0522489958,
-0.0136285434,
0.0863086805,
0.0628102347,
-0.0175706167,
-0.0264770389,
0.0126277553,
-0.0402825586,
0.0003270065,
0.0130264387,
0.0679878518,
0.0480641834,
0.0549876913,
-0.0120412828,
0.002079481,
0.0130610522,
-0.0307689328,
-0.0467389673,
-0.047725372,
0.021619061,
0.017261479,
0.0133886719,
0.0461411141,
0.0238240305,
0.0396861173,
-0.0074551809,
0.0169431642,
-0.0065128133,
0.0345134735,
-0.0365552641,
0.0150366575,
-0.0340825841,
0.0731628463,
-0.0445692912,
0.0204721615,
-0.0012005833,
-0.0591082126,
-0.0057528848,
-0.0572371893,
-0.0279811136,
0.0054922597,
0.010914593,
0.0522429943,
0.0595409386,
0.0177204739,
-0.0052307784,
0.0540618785,
0.0279151183,
0.0561836138,
0.0002455501,
-0.0162893776,
0.0257723033,
-0.0022626393,
-0.0842421502,
-0.0473036729,
0.0389553085,
0.0053822557,
0.0049650483,
0.0194590613,
-0.0277109127,
-0.0110089788,
0.0296067409,
-0.033058688,
0.0080702845,
0.0140903071,
-0.0663482919,
0.0669391006,
0.0057620439,
0.0306134615,
-0.0144688962,
0.0041782046,
-0.0026340513,
-0.023072036,
-0.0142799467,
0.0076059247,
-0.0385708436,
0.0148681365,
-0.0331185274,
-0.0436936952,
-0.0209436398,
0.016249802,
0.0077292109,
0.0033181473,
0.0172753818,
-0.0011812862,
-0.0078781825,
-0.0210155919,
0.0040602735,
0.0625859648,
-0.032574892,
0.0354259238,
-0.0115962205,
-0.0560027733,
-0.01019888,
0.0529107526,
0.0044407225,
-0.0102394428,
0.0071579563,
-0.0208593234,
0.0209887493,
-0.048366867,
-0.0291536413,
-0.0101610534,
-0.0481503531,
-0.0483538918,
-0.0567036793,
-0.0245091431,
0.0102368742,
0.0030433396,
0.0012657278,
-0.0165371485,
0.0375709385,
0.0031652881,
-0.0216349289,
0.0202446189,
-0.0140344147,
0.0137270931,
0.0230514184,
0.0151798651,
-0.0343184583,
0.0185266919,
0.0374187045,
0.0274835508,
0.0268700067,
-0.0015429157,
0.0126343882,
0.0626417994,
-0.0215822533,
0.0064394348,
0.0044511519,
0.0118632335,
-0.0619727708,
0.0282679815,
0.0214272626,
0.0895792618,
-0.0436958224,
-0.0271698032,
0.0755453035,
0.0657800734,
-0.0416100211,
-0.0071519203,
0.0174416024,
0.0595811903,
0.0294636041,
0.0190080553,
-0.0268827211,
-0.0255112499,
0.0113049131,
-0.0248813853,
0.0384402536,
-0.0128701422,
-0.0324151143,
-0.0271445382,
-0.0238896124,
-0.0250189845,
-0.0125730056,
-0.0268640295,
0.0235135481,
-0.01287656,
-0.0542080514,
0.0516517833,
0.0168440994,
-0.0091644758,
-0.0189257115,
-0.0240863599,
0.0152836721,
0.0367722884,
0.0129929576,
-0.0282536726,
0.0105093513,
-0.0459740646,
0.0030763585,
0.0633694977,
0.0074023777,
-0.0050687185,
0.0284536146,
-0.0362782292,
0.0299057513,
-0.0357569642,
0.0372130685,
0.0074064508,
0.0016058723,
0.0037149247,
0.0087271109,
-0.0150062013,
-0.0091551142,
0.0053361859,
0.0550726727,
-0.0138057843,
0.0127855111,
-0.0335757956,
0.0309041683,
0.0297486968,
-0.0212015938,
0.0089300256,
0.0118381726,
-0.0270270687,
-0.0214552823,
0.0060647177,
-0.0585044026,
-0.024742702,
0.0162598249,
-0.0555857196,
-0.0470259972,
0.0220073145,
-0.0390664637,
-0.0512308702,
-0.0050661294,
-0.0526712425,
0.0579419956,
-0.0436799861,
-0.0135269025,
0.0292945411,
0.0480222031,
-0.026477335,
0.0375368074,
-0.0147969667,
-0.0208629221,
0.0113147805,
0.0189868547,
0.0168652292,
-0.0656175166,
0.0072328891,
-0.0237179659,
0.0253027584,
0.0018596796,
-0.0172087234,
-0.0125837559,
-0.0362042151,
-0.0579932667,
-0.1167687029,
0.002852289,
-0.0222754367,
0.0223836452,
0.0547698401,
-0.0170845371,
-0.0150661953,
-0.0068584359,
-0.0337274708,
-0.0242181532,
-0.0087195104,
-0.0141869448,
0.0307770558,
0.0054751686,
0.0228888635,
-0.0476033837,
0.0129569247,
-0.0067410874,
0.0204497296,
0.0164275095,
-0.0066017704,
-0.0475793183,
-0.0308052357,
-0.0043129805,
0.0088143703,
0.0173256323,
-0.0554881692,
-0.0014156242,
0.00759171,
0.0028266418,
0.0682266876,
0.0236929189,
0.0151938787,
0.027096495,
-0.0364298485,
-0.0542105995,
0.0073149358,
-0.0093930904,
0.0173646584,
-0.0261556637,
-0.0018555946,
-0.0011419846,
0.0545949526,
0.0309287347,
0.0585641339,
-0.0543196425,
-0.0338483602,
-0.0110981399,
-0.0232841857,
0.0154079273,
-0.0136585133,
-0.0575769283,
0.0223430526,
-0.0031912003,
-0.0235366281,
0.0658944622,
-0.050986778,
-0.0359773114,
-0.0220109075,
-0.0231176335,
-0.0370171182,
0.0024743143,
-0.0355026871,
-0.0099404436,
0.0057404791,
-0.0579040647,
0.0162511766,
0.0087491516,
-0.0361487456,
-0.0397079848,
0.0252726693,
-0.0223804656,
-0.0306412373,
0.020788908,
-0.0489577353,
-0.0198792648,
-0.089502804,
-0.0762429684,
0.0222212877,
0.0462769754,
-0.0035913344,
0.0058839312,
0.0216397345,
-0.0046610152,
0.0229080133,
-0.0071461643,
0.0218329281,
-0.0244128332,
0.0280701984,
0.0757417083,
-0.0007808484,
-0.0034581565,
-0.0057746805,
0.013433571,
0.0397930183,
0.0086379517,
-0.0107625481,
-0.0566126257,
0.0112408735,
0.0220900439,
-0.0147006949,
-0.0331007242,
-0.0031167914,
0.0558680072,
-0.0107195536,
0.046031408,
0.1310391277,
0.0185798537,
-0.0061488971,
0.0265373252,
-0.0412115976,
0.0553995892,
-0.007423386,
-0.006166433,
-0.1447837949,
-0.0685184151,
-0.0088493731,
0.0307659321,
-0.0108111473,
-0.0173012037,
0.0064867777,
-0.1039354429,
0.0548641384,
0.0005103002,
-0.0505076982,
0.0495699383,
-0.0140166562,
0.0401504561,
-0.0466013923,
0.0341205709,
0.0028287352,
-0.000539754,
-0.0099737281,
0.0185323879,
-0.0467894301,
-0.0523690544,
0.0577255934,
-0.0249396544,
0.0467131697,
-0.0085299602,
0.0441055261,
0.0185095165,
-0.0352749527,
0.0377586409,
-0.0360587463,
0.0051051695,
-0.0275685564,
0.0309355762,
-0.0444127768,
-0.042865105,
-0.0400954112,
0.0339513496,
-0.0168084279,
0.0067779715,
0.0078834742,
0.0614896007,
-0.0333809145,
0.0240478348,
0.0019641784,
0.0103235552,
0.0252870396,
0.0860251561,
0.040580824,
-0.0556328706,
-0.0347507,
0.003737201,
-0.0202093124,
0.0168305617,
-0.0357564129,
0.0021742524,
0.0230428036,
0.0087124715,
-0.075122349,
-0.0594293401,
0.0176416859,
-0.034641102,
-0.0211706683,
-0.0073436424,
-0.0004368429,
-0.0051765502,
0.0333071873,
0.0554464795,
-0.0005128176,
0.0136766108,
-0.0789961666,
-0.0090872506,
0.0325114727,
-0.0093063917,
-0.0320942514,
0.0840278789,
-0.0409884788,
-0.0645321459,
0.0127361612,
0.0322631858,
0.02470842,
0.0137967821,
-0.0250238404,
-0.0360675342,
-0.0320835449,
-0.0305720568,
-0.0384933986,
0.0342129543,
0.0556670725,
-0.0034973023,
-0.0060556158,
0.0565060712,
0.0089967744,
0.0552106202,
0.011658702,
0.0475450121,
-0.0794543996,
-0.125006631,
-0.0232621487,
0.0157076158,
0.0980066359,
0.0090928134,
-0.0270526335,
-0.0061665955,
0.022582937,
-0.0027546617,
0.0050840983,
-0.0725110769,
0.0086440342,
0.0208845325,
-0.0422357284,
-0.0572278053,
-0.0106341746,
-0.0517541766,
0.0350741819,
-0.0146386782,
0.026929725,
0.0078537939,
-0.0146699855,
-0.0362244956,
-0.013537501,
-0.0512892082,
0.0379780047,
-0.0097499257,
0.039822679,
0.0133379726,
0.0615759976,
0.0006376853,
-0.0337267257,
0.0702389702,
0.0276066419,
-0.0537036285,
-0.0206012987,
0.0011478518,
-0.0062479703,
0.0550073497,
-0.020898968,
0.112903893,
-0.0303470679,
0.0089294817,
-0.0313305967,
0.0586857237,
-0.0337955095,
-0.0274525844,
0.0393317528,
0.0247844681,
-0.0315160826,
0.068162702,
0.0366189033,
-0.0310472567,
0.0269345976,
0.0333385952,
0.019372832,
-0.0338259228,
-0.0085448641,
0.0254406165,
0.0188675802,
-0.0153928576,
0.041174449,
-0.0328977406,
-0.0360272489,
0.028363172,
0.0138085373,
-0.001126009,
-0.0398617908,
0.0386817157,
0.0140772155,
-0.0274202786,
-0.0080025392,
-0.0358220227,
-0.0143631864,
-0.0019572263,
-0.0007842089,
-0.0375130996,
-6.512667024e-33,
-0.0158170108,
0.0164244678,
-0.0232189391,
0.0365989543,
-0.0317495503,
0.0526703596,
-0.0481712557,
0.0309544504,
-0.0007024526,
0.0166517682,
-0.0064983019,
0.0342374407,
0.0238515064,
0.0077446951,
-0.0030148108,
-0.0135015203,
0.0161154158,
-0.000259192,
-0.0222450607,
0.0242355186,
0.0109407622,
0.006790956,
0.0531333797,
-0.0975012332,
-0.0089749238,
0.0067743002,
-0.035626173,
0.0019911267,
0.0093231238,
0.0551544428,
-0.0290560815,
0.0635370612,
0.0026641423,
-0.0946145207,
-0.0112307929,
0.0256115757,
-0.0371230468,
0.0060203183,
0.0563960001,
0.0006728118,
-0.0641581342,
-0.007188316,
0.0193147343,
0.0021333951,
-0.0003393163,
0.0089349914,
0.0159979407,
-0.0386181436,
0.0289639737,
0.0078211892,
-0.0298930593,
0.0659115165,
-0.0395381041,
-0.000882055,
0.018883327,
0.0186248925,
-0.0063619283,
0.0053179841,
-0.0024701101,
-0.0132319424,
0.0145943621,
0.0172233321,
0.0121495361,
-0.0065331953,
-0.015033233,
0.0426859967,
-0.0216905437,
-0.0412233397,
0.0101487106,
-0.015965376,
0.0143775456,
0.0535718091,
0.0556796193,
0.0147564588,
-0.0027972122,
0.0489281192,
-0.0498313494,
-0.0216396656,
0.0436759964,
0.0360907204,
0.0043918653,
0.0185246132,
-0.0304928012,
0.0258306898,
-0.020854542,
-0.0076254955,
-0.024139883,
-0.0143971387,
0.0164229497,
-0.0001959627,
0.0008732101,
0.0949822068,
0.0540721454,
-0.0108761415,
-0.0079307593,
0.0175401978,
-0.0237878151,
0.0108068353,
-0.0113628032,
0.0271243248,
-0.077914618,
0.0027212033,
0.0162758902,
0.0230820142,
0.0421574973,
0.0184374209,
0.0141670667,
-0.0067195683,
-0.046788808,
0.0113980044,
0.0131384879,
0.0060782442,
-0.0959735289,
-0.0000524757,
0.0399027616,
0.008041962,
-0.0171074942,
0.074971661,
-0.0362275466,
0.024712095,
-0.0114842467,
-0.0535237938,
0.0328288712,
0.0348264016,
-0.0487606823,
0.0286120623,
0.0470439643,
-0.0248539057,
-0.0039699329,
-0.0295913555,
-0.0079120975,
0.0262211971,
2.398e-7,
0.0490676537,
0.0646004602,
0.0201296508,
0.018566668,
0.0056725102,
0.0256252084,
-0.0231166463,
0.0400849618,
0.0374008752,
-0.0314430892,
0.0110951466,
0.0213310868,
0.0810346231,
0.005123415,
-0.1028318852,
-0.0031191329,
-0.1117160246,
-0.0027081363,
-0.0403283946,
0.0038534983,
0.0827888325,
0.0996584073,
0.0116689801,
0.0163762867,
-0.0094519695,
-0.0188375972,
0.0475792401,
-0.0243473258,
0.0244087484,
0.0045120153,
0.0587554201,
0.0307636056,
-0.0222404171,
0.0279963948,
0.0079237549,
0.0265808795,
0.0410810001,
0.1099746004,
-0.0124540143,
-0.0674371645,
0.0070867497,
-0.0100569148,
-0.0242910758,
-0.0850670263,
0.0737637654,
-0.0472132489,
-0.0331215933,
-0.0104737021,
-0.0363336205,
-0.0375688858,
0.0067695403,
-0.0151669988,
-0.0125714252,
-0.0051907119,
0.0212371647,
-0.042961739,
-0.0410641804,
-0.0625240579,
-0.0183759592,
0.0038992111,
-0.0154921748,
0.0014596692,
-0.0080589438,
0.0343249217,
-0.0228011459,
-0.0787514895,
-0.0131809236,
1.547023575e-34,
0.0312466044,
-0.0266182665,
0.0287390109,
0.0419907421,
0.0424816348,
0.037410643,
-0.021290388,
-0.0169175174,
0.019750813,
-0.0854899585,
0.0046966327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11050v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11050v1 | A Peek into Token Bias: Large Language Models Are Not Yet Genuine Reasoners | 2024-06-16T19:22:53 | 2024-06-16T19:22:53 | Bowen Jiang, Yangxinyu Xie, Zhuoqun Hao, Xiaomeng Wang, Tanwi Mallick, Weijie J. Su, Camillo J. Taylor, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study introduces a hypothesis-testing framework to assess whether large
language models (LLMs) possess genuine reasoning abilities or primarily depend
on token bias. We go beyond evaluating LLMs on accuracy; rather, we aim to
investigate their token bias in solving logical reasoning tasks. Specifically,
we develop carefully controlled synthetic datasets, featuring conjunction
fallacy and syllogistic problems. Our framework outlines a list of hypotheses
where token biases are readily identifiable, with all null hypotheses assuming
genuine reasoning capabilities of LLMs. The findings in this study suggest,
with statistical guarantee, that most LLMs still struggle with logical
reasoning. While they may perform well on classic problems, their success
largely depends on recognizing superficial patterns with strong token bias,
thereby raising concerns about their actual reasoning and generalization
abilities. | [
0.0470117964,
0.0800759494,
-0.0120271854,
0.0395038351,
-0.0550156608,
0.0290138721,
0.0641199425,
0.0080019375,
0.0077558481,
-0.0610383376,
0.0053110695,
-0.0016922529,
-0.0141326142,
0.0001915292,
0.0444270186,
-0.0194637664,
0.0637484863,
-0.040936444,
0.061053317,
-0.022914445,
-0.0361594968,
0.0233120378,
-0.0104249148,
0.0404722728,
-0.0262840912,
-0.0195035134,
0.0144819263,
-0.0108277742,
-0.0106648253,
-0.0107021248,
-0.0375844873,
0.0325854197,
0.0139862765,
0.0423653238,
0.0000019199,
-0.0744322538,
0.0324374624,
-0.0169185158,
-0.0434749946,
0.0279661901,
0.0229281522,
0.0175196156,
-0.0103583001,
0.0339125842,
-0.016391689,
-0.0251775812,
0.0196421072,
0.0862474814,
0.0167541932,
0.0553250983,
0.0051309527,
-0.0309591312,
0.0176858306,
-0.0023627742,
0.0340133272,
-0.0283353161,
0.0454699993,
0.0316109844,
-0.0162422899,
-0.0452756397,
-0.0189796407,
0.0117441444,
0.0425993763,
-0.0023073256,
-0.0426145904,
0.0270197336,
-0.0664367974,
-0.0202351492,
0.0193937365,
0.0153286504,
0.0020876224,
-0.0435268022,
-0.0156100877,
-0.0008619137,
0.0199405141,
0.0232861992,
-0.0394833237,
0.0641052052,
-0.01157605,
-0.0016613472,
0.0656880513,
-0.0509368703,
0.0500894487,
0.0200910904,
-0.0630552694,
0.1156600863,
0.0096870931,
-0.0242704265,
0.0309162848,
-0.0005743694,
-0.0442320518,
-0.0817026421,
-0.0166455135,
0.0199358016,
-0.0478859916,
0.0340221487,
-0.0160391629,
0.0362169929,
0.0286442582,
-0.0294126924,
-0.0158420876,
0.0371561721,
0.0040532392,
0.0576123446,
-0.0530705303,
0.0385834835,
-0.0211417545,
0.068919532,
-0.0158513803,
-0.0230406895,
-0.0312269423,
-0.048946701,
0.003945495,
0.033164531,
-0.0109574934,
-0.0076525928,
-0.0414151251,
0.0017389978,
-0.0122701908,
0.0152598899,
-0.0147708151,
0.0126111852,
0.0243797265,
-0.0295557976,
-0.0748400018,
0.0086494638,
-0.0451190136,
0.0743081644,
0.0051242961,
-0.0747593269,
0.0076760463,
0.0031964511,
0.0046686237,
-0.0408565924,
0.0223655403,
0.0401416719,
-0.0042890627,
-0.0189002566,
-0.0502329394,
-0.0051836055,
-0.0274094176,
-0.0684617981,
-0.014735911,
-0.0641379505,
0.0068493476,
0.0233091339,
0.0079823891,
-0.0192017611,
0.0046213493,
0.020505419,
-0.0382598154,
0.0566640347,
0.0134627549,
0.0337812193,
0.02667615,
0.0034797092,
-0.0217642318,
0.0584652126,
0.0177406203,
-0.0018420526,
0.0131503036,
-0.0172249321,
-0.011967144,
0.011303734,
-0.0026997125,
-0.0128146354,
-0.0408607386,
0.0268730856,
0.0030514484,
0.0362474583,
0.0417806692,
0.0851284564,
-0.0256065261,
0.0047302102,
0.0378118232,
0.0689578354,
0.0307201985,
0.0091619063,
0.0467587747,
-0.0543954596,
0.0095775565,
-0.0029134317,
-0.0896927416,
-0.0103472266,
0.0000854517,
-0.009837646,
0.0133517701,
0.010973664,
-0.0213041455,
-0.0584532619,
-0.0310553573,
0.0239699092,
-0.0211277697,
0.0153745655,
0.0411292762,
-0.0087604802,
-0.0100572072,
0.0554939657,
0.0164436419,
-0.0405611806,
-0.0083613489,
-0.0821349546,
0.0585789979,
0.0191421639,
0.0341580436,
-0.002190267,
-0.0065381448,
0.0000392517,
0.0390287936,
0.0169836953,
0.0632857531,
0.0001267734,
0.0031377594,
-0.022876896,
0.0026819305,
-0.0371654071,
0.045954477,
-0.0197599102,
-0.0140538923,
0.0243298113,
0.0015594156,
-0.0700910166,
0.0142490035,
0.0471451841,
-0.0306643769,
-0.0030751142,
-0.0336134247,
0.0041036056,
0.023498686,
-0.0166661888,
-0.007615556,
0.0340502448,
0.0056043309,
-0.0248789992,
-0.013119258,
0.0152330389,
-0.0417042971,
-0.0194562934,
0.0514202639,
-0.0549232438,
-0.0338607654,
-0.0012252955,
-0.02861204,
-0.0288930032,
0.0167920366,
-0.0352962092,
0.0673525259,
-0.0280878283,
0.0443920754,
-0.035079658,
-0.0231404677,
-0.0213919114,
0.0997325405,
-0.0066259094,
0.0379544012,
0.0001627778,
0.0040429877,
0.0213838238,
-0.0461423509,
-0.003919024,
0.0076261656,
-0.0053254706,
-0.0144367758,
-0.0107506616,
-0.0319108404,
-0.0577048324,
-0.0436165743,
-0.0869823694,
-0.0072979773,
-0.0111642387,
0.0024616562,
0.0121228993,
-0.0402115323,
-0.0201319661,
0.0172422323,
-0.0258385595,
-0.031453725,
0.0227551237,
0.0436301827,
0.0347053483,
-0.0172298811,
-0.0286559928,
-0.0244763922,
-0.0097558834,
-0.0584070981,
0.0241012964,
0.0257562697,
0.0525669195,
-0.031554684,
0.0423758216,
-0.0371065401,
-0.0172057971,
-0.021749597,
-0.0174066033,
0.0432369299,
0.0123955719,
-0.0035791162,
0.1087226868,
0.0109663745,
0.0109673059,
0.0599613525,
-0.0152160944,
-0.0510171801,
0.0140147358,
-0.0005799625,
0.0056513683,
-0.0564491674,
-0.0698850304,
-0.0069665397,
0.0396704152,
0.0047252667,
0.0080476645,
-0.0346445441,
0.0546225607,
-0.0273677222,
-0.0337252095,
-0.0116418581,
-0.0239136722,
-0.0108946161,
0.0633433983,
-0.0187783893,
-0.0333085656,
0.0417276211,
-0.0086489068,
0.0146493511,
-0.0223613791,
0.0112905148,
-0.0504425056,
0.0589135513,
-0.0217726808,
-0.0082101757,
-0.0127062323,
-0.0385203622,
-0.0620181747,
-0.0397744775,
-0.0063196816,
-0.0209491253,
0.0508684553,
-0.0353743657,
-0.0025152036,
0.0037424783,
-0.0542643853,
-0.0452436581,
-0.0377301127,
-0.0797881633,
-0.0071518472,
0.0001367654,
-0.0187188294,
-0.0290957522,
-0.016041249,
0.0167115778,
-0.0088221459,
0.0033873587,
-0.0104560535,
-0.0069077029,
-0.0159807317,
0.0443797037,
0.0379911624,
0.0561652593,
-0.0286089294,
0.0284971148,
0.0419565588,
0.0362300873,
0.0341536403,
-0.0226614997,
0.0052843485,
0.0114849694,
-0.0078321062,
-0.0115100238,
0.0071102818,
0.0584368445,
-0.0328993425,
0.0032382698,
0.1387802958,
0.0430151671,
0.0177281089,
0.01739439,
-0.0488014147,
0.0262374394,
0.0400711522,
-0.0090928841,
-0.0568378046,
-0.0376988612,
0.0461776443,
-0.0122638624,
-0.0514228009,
-0.0229863301,
-0.005135294,
-0.1253470331,
0.0361682512,
0.0027886,
-0.0232417583,
-0.0020414153,
-0.0330770947,
0.0130819473,
-0.0187399238,
0.0556650497,
0.0226579923,
-0.0088742031,
-0.011447167,
0.007687557,
-0.0214622784,
-0.0414023176,
0.0519969687,
-0.0436647832,
0.0524019599,
0.0256102476,
0.0452103913,
-0.0249773767,
-0.0460437164,
0.0822273865,
0.0073932814,
0.00734659,
-0.0184983425,
0.017361626,
-0.006642737,
-0.0029577545,
-0.0414253511,
0.0363749489,
-0.016262494,
-0.024639599,
0.0264680348,
0.0779492185,
-0.0083587905,
-0.0630343631,
-0.0200107992,
0.005188304,
-0.0625148267,
0.078404896,
0.0307795219,
-0.0183621608,
-0.0503619201,
-0.0364305153,
-0.0416135304,
-0.0126896501,
-0.0199959464,
0.0225844439,
0.0385630801,
-0.0115584573,
-0.0337075144,
-0.0286376551,
0.0593349859,
0.0291930977,
-0.0199945346,
-0.0026578521,
-0.0363884196,
-0.0151652535,
0.00606811,
0.036300417,
-0.0362789445,
0.023925893,
-0.0673287436,
0.0460047685,
-0.0233144555,
-0.0198755357,
-0.0297843684,
-0.0305324029,
-0.0499689691,
-0.0526201166,
0.0263215657,
0.0121862516,
0.0326685645,
0.0135475285,
-0.0074482067,
-0.0426862314,
0.0172644164,
0.0472138822,
-0.0170761049,
0.0247643329,
0.0261458848,
-0.0150771327,
0.0240173265,
0.030205043,
-0.0235705227,
0.0064517343,
0.0510400981,
0.0468714312,
-0.0118582975,
0.0309263635,
0.0448269323,
0.0321773328,
0.0250825603,
0.026796652,
0.019806806,
-0.0284536984,
0.0238947496,
-0.024793556,
-0.0283390079,
0.0091403211,
0.0087312004,
0.0217450634,
-0.0005404669,
-0.0182501003,
-0.058388073,
-0.0533802211,
0.0443406291,
0.0100774635,
0.0344317183,
0.0034086944,
0.025293665,
0.0289237835,
-0.0267069209,
-0.0211680625,
-0.001842252,
-0.0228849333,
0.0486104377,
0.032644894,
0.0452256538,
0.0284597129,
-0.0019388025,
-0.0300999638,
-0.0367397927,
-0.0759541169,
-0.0773085207,
0.0707220808,
0.0046543917,
0.0340652354,
-0.0355163887,
0.0085751498,
-0.0282329395,
-0.0091157341,
-0.0128719322,
-0.0103799403,
0.0445217639,
-0.0278240573,
0.0593975075,
0.0038834289,
-0.0342435725,
-0.0298788287,
0.029627027,
-0.0064064702,
0.0634423941,
-0.0151913529,
-0.0123711014,
-0.0147838416,
-0.0366474278,
-0.001927676,
-0.0074473904,
-0.0155697009,
-0.0085144853,
-0.0892598331,
-0.091731891,
-0.0094172871,
0.0186312273,
-0.0045586983,
-0.022209486,
-0.0392368697,
0.0818596557,
0.0085016191,
-0.040511325,
-0.0147561524,
0.0163097866,
-0.0056036548,
0.0047501721,
-0.0302727018,
-6.037488127e-33,
-0.0100296596,
-0.0242581684,
0.0171363354,
-0.0582211912,
0.0104698837,
-0.0059605357,
-0.0252819136,
0.0251292586,
-0.054277584,
0.0435377397,
-0.0242807791,
0.0348279551,
0.0250268765,
-0.0026187035,
0.0057158051,
-0.0137078855,
0.0216735359,
0.0321038552,
-0.032671392,
-0.0186384581,
0.0369797051,
-0.0231370162,
0.0102231195,
-0.0237552878,
0.0284753852,
0.0198733695,
-0.0031149811,
0.0278369542,
-0.0615536533,
0.0464992188,
0.0121649019,
0.0181431677,
0.029738823,
-0.0000590049,
0.0130842589,
0.0393183939,
-0.0302655268,
-0.028958369,
0.0800957158,
-0.0028199491,
-0.0017029571,
-0.0546178743,
0.0303263832,
0.0236258823,
-0.0628050491,
-0.0059673204,
0.0095704747,
-0.0255699083,
0.0081800222,
0.0176658593,
-0.0397509634,
0.016994359,
-0.0152918268,
0.0298487246,
-0.067464076,
0.0130180754,
-0.0159046445,
0.0271661114,
-0.0287380796,
0.0363995433,
0.0073255389,
-0.0067481976,
0.0625764951,
-0.0001704575,
0.00307033,
0.0939495638,
0.058330968,
0.0117556537,
-0.0493167043,
0.0105375275,
0.0306237936,
0.0470703505,
0.0640791655,
0.0207348801,
0.0497802272,
-0.0179169662,
-0.0724511892,
-0.0465347134,
0.0206068456,
0.0539067239,
0.0694620088,
-0.0045484104,
-0.0448440984,
-0.0156366471,
-0.0744489133,
0.0320352763,
-0.0367851853,
-0.0129218195,
0.0476001911,
-0.0088813733,
0.007988262,
-0.0532169752,
0.0202019121,
-0.0347488485,
-0.0209896341,
0.0197649654,
-0.0068247863,
-0.0009428322,
-0.0285817068,
0.0459110029,
-0.0612393357,
-0.0253532343,
0.0077514895,
0.0074976902,
0.0324862599,
0.0072287507,
0.0242708884,
-0.0184278563,
-0.0706373602,
-0.0113489907,
-0.0528041758,
-0.0228419919,
-0.0137566421,
-0.0265229847,
0.0602746569,
0.0263928697,
0.0053504547,
-0.0154020032,
-0.0141487615,
-0.0391162261,
-0.0399774462,
0.0460085161,
-0.0253621321,
0.0368721336,
-0.0102163106,
-0.0224766843,
-0.0247597992,
0.0157867204,
0.0207253937,
-0.0534209348,
-0.0098819062,
0.0165998433,
2.532e-7,
0.0432663821,
0.0622960217,
-0.0050531919,
0.0391837619,
0.011372746,
0.0304740388,
-0.0143590113,
-0.0276983846,
0.052583497,
-0.0043731495,
-0.0277979448,
0.0453512482,
0.0283231102,
0.0278059635,
-0.0524525195,
0.0387211703,
-0.0688068271,
-0.017821433,
-0.0593190156,
0.0429473929,
0.0535925217,
0.0955003053,
0.0259751938,
-0.0254981834,
-0.0070629111,
-0.0752381384,
0.0251181424,
-0.0278500654,
0.0017236518,
0.0115954643,
0.0170873851,
0.0009935574,
0.0434497446,
0.0727162659,
0.0173239149,
0.009573563,
-0.0183503777,
0.0435658097,
-0.0011037677,
0.0016384851,
-0.0514020175,
-0.0364089832,
-0.0081990864,
-0.0852383524,
0.1057923809,
-0.0453566425,
-0.0406397656,
-0.0278075058,
-0.0037886868,
-0.0112456605,
0.0182117335,
-0.0027827688,
0.0026894321,
0.0144941099,
0.0287936535,
-0.0056961044,
0.0196477026,
-0.076614894,
-0.0119728176,
0.0094993506,
-0.0435323231,
-0.073983781,
-0.0181394834,
0.044710055,
0.0499668531,
-0.0349430256,
-0.0109993769,
2.199257406e-34,
0.0403216369,
0.0066368487,
0.0259195063,
0.0150272707,
0.0716231167,
0.0226573572,
0.0015476771,
0.020921262,
0.0147272013,
-0.0653180405,
0.0027358017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11049v1 | Reconsidering Sentence-Level Sign Language Translation | 2024-06-16T19:19:54 | 2024-06-16T19:19:54 | Garrett Tanzer, Maximus Shengelia, Ken Harrenstien, David Uthus | cs.CL | cs.CL | Historically, sign language machine translation has been posed as a
sentence-level task: datasets consisting of continuous narratives are chopped
up and presented to the model as isolated clips. In this work, we explore the
limitations of this task framing. First, we survey a number of linguistic
phenomena in sign languages that depend on discourse-level context. Then as a
case study, we perform the first human baseline for sign language translation
that actually substitutes a human into the machine learning task framing,
rather than provide the human with the entire document as context. This human
baseline -- for ASL to English translation on the How2Sign dataset -- shows
that for 33% of sentences in our sample, our fluent Deaf signer annotators were
only able to understand key parts of the clip in light of additional
discourse-level context. These results underscore the importance of
understanding and sanity checking examples when adapting machine learning to
new domains. | [
-0.0232184064,
0.034747906,
-0.019566413,
0.0144356536,
-0.0354609266,
0.0342456959,
0.0530166104,
-0.0312405378,
0.0129146576,
-0.0415300578,
-0.0203799736,
-0.0122070955,
0.057589028,
0.0255522989,
0.0241885092,
-0.0972511098,
0.0323632173,
-0.0362680145,
-0.0298652425,
-0.0149646346,
0.0068738181,
0.0095419334,
-0.0396543555,
0.0511973388,
-0.0503287576,
-0.0275291819,
-0.0030227499,
0.0312243104,
0.0185826179,
-0.005850804,
-0.0434501953,
0.0207568463,
0.0421768799,
0.0070286943,
0.0000019208,
-0.0291803293,
0.0301813707,
-0.0124724675,
-0.0058424524,
-0.0222128611,
0.0227543581,
-0.1057820767,
-0.0158657357,
0.0198379476,
-0.0392841585,
-0.0336369537,
0.011864434,
0.0851198435,
0.033995416,
0.021479303,
-0.0265885312,
0.0122310463,
0.0104824826,
-0.0343510583,
-0.0069013797,
-0.0344993696,
0.0016887902,
-0.0046041738,
0.0149109047,
-0.0129305907,
-0.0365717076,
0.0863902867,
0.0302768815,
-0.0355754308,
-0.0640613213,
0.0100388015,
-0.0499207638,
0.0038289987,
0.0004791939,
0.0458392724,
0.0430328809,
0.0115290368,
0.0093351202,
-0.0207674988,
0.0246743113,
-0.009728523,
-0.0195596423,
0.0518269949,
-0.0186529886,
0.0087986961,
0.0076012844,
0.01093545,
0.0267083421,
-0.033877831,
-0.014556882,
0.0262671579,
-0.0193047412,
-0.0081388419,
0.0111219576,
0.0028860867,
-0.0061846427,
-0.0327179246,
0.0490018874,
-0.0265110694,
-0.0225844793,
0.0117594628,
-0.0608668923,
0.0017557769,
-0.013582252,
-0.0655393302,
-0.023789227,
0.0571166389,
-0.0252681784,
0.0312304869,
0.0743936673,
0.0258258358,
-0.0248359535,
0.0330416337,
-0.0446596369,
0.0408816412,
-0.0199347585,
-0.0040362854,
-0.0563862287,
-0.0419026874,
-0.0587176979,
-0.0073675616,
-0.0011162515,
0.0238958038,
0.0271178931,
-0.0250429977,
0.0095126359,
0.0124048647,
-0.0348582752,
0.0019488042,
0.0197164454,
0.0363846608,
-0.0244340487,
0.0398705453,
0.003810941,
-0.0819629654,
-0.0035402821,
0.0315613672,
-0.0128399236,
-0.0158140864,
-0.0382915288,
0.0709829405,
-0.008579839,
-0.0030340147,
0.0127171222,
-0.0219614636,
-0.029330587,
-0.0391069502,
-0.0104176523,
-0.0037590049,
0.026209794,
-0.0055038463,
0.016007578,
-0.0842814893,
-0.0051579219,
0.0087017389,
0.0037418762,
0.0833007097,
0.017785266,
0.0003400377,
0.0257887281,
0.0010001754,
-0.0530048944,
0.0570006818,
0.0455416404,
-0.0034014154,
0.0253922995,
-0.0051981113,
-0.0176227894,
0.0716601759,
-0.0104016308,
0.0048185783,
0.0068127476,
-0.0189352725,
-0.0138945319,
0.0379401259,
-0.0036771591,
0.0493586175,
-0.0049419119,
0.022117177,
0.0355385542,
0.0818789154,
-0.0020001503,
-0.0122900195,
0.040009629,
0.0201549213,
-0.000419776,
0.0316461362,
-0.030577112,
-0.0250418354,
0.0447952375,
-0.0372537933,
-0.0385236703,
-0.0084950868,
-0.0238826554,
-0.0408776514,
0.0093444269,
-0.012580405,
0.0197168346,
-0.0154605564,
0.0400482416,
0.0562459826,
-0.0246796124,
-0.0172645282,
-0.0043394403,
-0.04741944,
0.0103967385,
-0.0151071502,
-0.0654355809,
0.0112652769,
0.0314670466,
-0.0007710375,
-0.0164619647,
-0.0157150049,
0.0360448137,
0.0287748184,
0.0171129704,
0.0029284016,
0.0190853067,
-0.0117779225,
-0.019380901,
0.0380460247,
0.0093813604,
0.0152589586,
-0.0715802535,
0.0331556164,
0.003741259,
-0.0265778434,
-0.0375375673,
0.054752402,
-0.0383410491,
-0.0359880999,
0.035850849,
0.0088136345,
0.0357781723,
0.0391023085,
-0.0141724581,
-0.0106840432,
0.0284144562,
-0.0395516939,
0.0054153008,
0.1148864701,
-0.0881418511,
-0.0589211658,
-0.0019282451,
-0.0895800367,
-0.0443423726,
-0.0134080937,
-0.000877637,
-0.0493589193,
0.0182460696,
-0.0263296161,
0.0003045216,
-0.0293443631,
0.0071156695,
0.0117440661,
-0.0076850238,
-0.0358497724,
0.0163656324,
0.005549069,
-0.0647389442,
-0.03115445,
-0.0590786152,
0.0319826268,
-0.064303726,
0.0093969153,
0.0488970354,
-0.0024243901,
0.0282143932,
0.0508477837,
0.0337944441,
-0.0222395323,
0.0106666889,
-0.125423342,
-0.0204587989,
-0.0224856269,
0.0249996427,
0.021329131,
0.010679666,
-0.0024838133,
-0.0345484801,
-0.0220031217,
-0.0590589643,
0.0134569388,
-0.0434957035,
0.0072265835,
0.0099493228,
0.0146299386,
-0.0045708804,
-0.0001394547,
-0.0468372628,
0.0387595333,
0.0554047562,
-0.0686416253,
-0.0501705557,
0.0178751945,
0.0481947884,
0.011111916,
-0.0315933786,
0.0248208977,
0.0604079962,
0.0241367519,
-0.0038761334,
0.0127162337,
-0.0291040502,
0.0771053359,
0.0192938019,
-0.0075214058,
-0.0278987028,
0.0095017105,
0.0110904146,
0.0499079749,
-0.0605042577,
-0.0169631764,
0.0351148061,
0.0702021942,
0.0394263826,
0.0112957889,
-0.0738611296,
-0.0029013352,
-0.0414289683,
-0.0604434758,
-0.0322724171,
-0.0036862565,
-0.043058008,
0.0187735595,
0.0010649014,
-0.0299991574,
0.0495725162,
-0.0392087884,
-0.0188926272,
-0.0172225181,
0.0254416727,
-0.0221346878,
0.0914940238,
-0.013344083,
0.005337175,
-0.0212675333,
-0.0330480747,
-0.0255071521,
0.0508252196,
0.0126941493,
0.0042377207,
0.0186450407,
-0.0617419668,
-0.0050742184,
-0.0242044013,
-0.0182157625,
-0.0312137771,
0.0101326816,
-0.0477284379,
-0.0039899615,
0.0149286138,
-0.0325571671,
-0.0761260167,
-0.035035871,
0.0263900533,
0.0749653056,
0.0046278648,
-0.0031099168,
-0.0319829434,
-0.0136934053,
0.001280596,
0.0099514201,
-0.0179959815,
-0.0678899139,
0.0339733623,
0.0327460542,
0.00901544,
0.0177386068,
-0.0139308982,
-0.0170967188,
0.0366631187,
0.019843407,
-0.019851936,
0.0112597123,
0.0720976666,
-0.0446360298,
-0.0073107071,
0.0805590376,
0.0138835749,
-0.0316098854,
0.0234370604,
-0.0235611387,
0.0091885608,
-0.0153790554,
0.0056097843,
-0.0919691175,
-0.0580991469,
0.0289596058,
0.0669269338,
0.0281730853,
-0.0102522699,
-0.0287440531,
-0.0251469463,
0.0465467274,
0.0210427307,
-0.0918052644,
-0.006776053,
0.0186168253,
0.0025650926,
0.0178390592,
0.0813936219,
0.0060475706,
-0.0196029842,
-0.0082531758,
0.0197850987,
-0.0042967778,
-0.0783411339,
-0.0117345015,
-0.0039759004,
0.0565666482,
0.0499573275,
0.0401806645,
0.0183492322,
-0.0201110598,
0.041357141,
0.0087037589,
0.0372745246,
-0.0041706031,
0.036961332,
0.004099661,
-0.0236255191,
-0.0137121342,
0.0774512216,
-0.0929942057,
-0.0041708737,
0.0582560934,
0.0509167276,
-0.0701184198,
0.0025113833,
0.0121127786,
-0.0313943923,
-0.0092494199,
0.0492906421,
0.0498684496,
-0.0706131086,
-0.0147196418,
-0.0397943594,
0.0129465461,
0.0159685202,
-0.025737213,
0.0171507057,
-0.0547276139,
-0.0262747463,
-0.0624573566,
-0.0667038336,
0.0342707075,
0.0694901273,
0.0314905494,
0.0185837392,
0.0780780315,
-0.0000470604,
-0.0195106808,
0.0533732586,
-0.0289037786,
0.0432058461,
-0.040660277,
-0.0036899203,
-0.0169621315,
-0.0482778996,
0.0012426855,
0.0415895432,
-0.0443829037,
-0.0625749975,
0.027181033,
0.009361133,
0.0196842477,
0.0442932993,
0.0094946027,
-0.0425155908,
-0.0212583784,
0.0405001454,
0.0023985947,
0.0384133533,
0.0346463509,
-0.0296541844,
-0.0207936671,
0.0214465018,
0.0233491007,
0.0106900083,
-0.046499081,
0.0062198672,
-0.0725090131,
0.0096694119,
-0.0042928364,
0.0239856876,
0.0386167876,
-0.0240124874,
-0.0445384905,
-0.0294235498,
0.0118297879,
-0.0337064043,
-0.0047044116,
-0.0791458413,
-0.0179879572,
0.0215491895,
-0.0006641152,
-0.0000226423,
0.0140504949,
-0.051883135,
0.0553599298,
0.0052286554,
0.066371128,
0.0195517521,
0.0529416464,
-0.021214718,
0.0345952697,
0.0270077791,
0.0667618066,
-0.0195869766,
0.0481129587,
-0.0002380978,
0.0207992755,
0.0455400869,
0.0193424523,
0.0583104752,
0.0172546357,
-0.0004506866,
-0.0237349011,
0.0179599989,
0.0292536579,
0.0023115519,
0.0353970006,
0.0788067803,
-0.0105519919,
0.0316274352,
-0.0165917687,
0.0331992954,
0.022167407,
-0.0328209959,
0.0149356397,
-0.0110435626,
-0.0137597211,
0.0225564521,
0.0315824896,
-0.0686562732,
0.0236669555,
-0.0246190038,
0.0072507779,
-0.0320446156,
-0.0316195041,
-0.004851127,
-0.0299084987,
-0.0141660208,
-0.0011567264,
-0.0443264917,
-0.0430195481,
0.0034254957,
0.0162692517,
0.0085218856,
-0.0017812976,
0.0095832199,
-0.0052423035,
-0.0145026771,
-0.0055200472,
-0.0236522295,
-0.0285223424,
-0.0271239262,
-0.0405157469,
-0.0340975709,
-5.499308242e-33,
-0.0595651269,
-0.0583238602,
-0.0013379036,
0.0141946683,
-0.0148267541,
0.0368108004,
-0.0567709096,
0.0175455008,
0.0266849343,
0.0581656955,
-0.0123078134,
-0.0065867971,
0.0105132842,
-0.0018922554,
-0.0012843634,
-0.010553265,
0.041651357,
-0.0165574905,
-0.0269019641,
0.025938509,
0.0274452213,
-0.0002213137,
0.051004909,
-0.1107005104,
0.0631532148,
-0.0366733819,
-0.0540134124,
0.0237934478,
0.0011577659,
0.000793318,
-0.008818306,
-0.0084940912,
0.0133149531,
0.0188540295,
-0.0185601562,
0.0466137305,
-0.0811167583,
0.0039515896,
0.0281087756,
0.103783913,
-0.0679594949,
0.0008567411,
0.0211177785,
-0.0181976929,
-0.0569226183,
0.0334357098,
0.0281923227,
-0.0207645763,
0.0114884209,
-0.0211691372,
-0.0315427408,
0.025579568,
-0.0352869816,
-0.0252314731,
0.0267777126,
0.052012682,
-0.0259000026,
-0.0661711767,
-0.0124051962,
0.035136804,
-0.0054363143,
-0.0095568141,
0.0687966794,
-0.0441365615,
0.0075792666,
0.0475906581,
0.0277802944,
-0.0263782516,
-0.0296137705,
-0.0487854481,
0.0729204565,
-0.0086927991,
-0.0127875404,
0.0663798973,
0.0322862826,
-0.0079835877,
-0.0107059479,
0.0159195606,
0.028362371,
0.0507256575,
-0.0215535481,
0.0177532546,
-0.0313074514,
-0.0190110821,
-0.0893531591,
-0.0132875657,
0.0221947264,
-0.0069278996,
0.0208141953,
-0.0114416732,
-0.011274307,
-0.0100307828,
0.0540693849,
-0.0324248262,
0.0069134333,
0.0006220719,
-0.0224508923,
0.0021248078,
-0.0026111593,
0.02012977,
-0.0236277301,
-0.0163414758,
0.0701618195,
0.0018813034,
0.077698715,
-0.0131179597,
0.0541103333,
0.0494508706,
-0.0175572149,
0.0081037143,
-0.014222811,
0.0444909967,
-0.0070807366,
0.0033708918,
0.062542446,
-0.0088067204,
-0.0347424261,
0.0578035712,
0.0067178938,
-0.0310346596,
-0.04212166,
0.0521041006,
-0.0283417366,
0.0289274771,
-0.0721508041,
-0.0217501428,
0.0346751176,
-0.0142023591,
0.0840679929,
-0.0806871802,
-0.0017790755,
0.0168443527,
2.533e-7,
0.0263881069,
0.0713268444,
0.0472075492,
0.0199151989,
0.0383623838,
0.0497953482,
-0.0172719397,
0.0276131779,
-0.0197386239,
0.0514656417,
0.0190736651,
-0.0005094277,
0.0705010742,
0.0165609866,
-0.0695355609,
0.0132133421,
-0.0319289491,
0.0170649216,
-0.0254573338,
0.0223634243,
0.0467395447,
0.0379458107,
-0.034523651,
-0.0220097266,
0.0202548262,
-0.0794693381,
0.0552726388,
-0.0458483547,
0.0298393629,
-0.0230186712,
0.0349586569,
-0.032238625,
-0.0279179122,
0.0070100385,
0.0035522161,
-0.018115459,
0.0136416955,
0.0408476666,
-0.0290775504,
0.0119866217,
-0.0083598765,
0.0384783261,
-0.0396217182,
0.0152065558,
0.0320779532,
-0.0541695207,
-0.0282752849,
-0.0531903058,
0.0196915958,
-0.0023542987,
0.0081956899,
0.0345071442,
0.0398893468,
0.0236102417,
0.0314975716,
-0.0375538357,
-0.0061027217,
-0.0370150954,
-0.0241418816,
-0.0192523431,
-0.021525085,
0.0206643473,
-0.0000706359,
0.0163844209,
-0.026717294,
-0.0617176145,
-0.01755156,
1.769433764e-34,
0.0291305017,
-0.0019271739,
0.0186304282,
-0.0012405048,
0.0062511116,
-0.0301204808,
0.0464742221,
0.0388973653,
0.0298251677,
-0.0168710127,
-0.0240862537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11044v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11044v1 | Evaluating the Performance of Large Language Models via Debates | 2024-06-16T19:02:31 | 2024-06-16T19:02:31 | Behrad Moniri, Hamed Hassani, Edgar Dobriban | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) are rapidly evolving and impacting various
fields, necessitating the development of effective methods to evaluate and
compare their performance. Most current approaches for performance evaluation
are either based on fixed, domain-specific questions that lack the flexibility
required in many real-world applications where tasks are not always from a
single domain, or rely on human input, making them unscalable. We propose an
automated benchmarking framework based on debates between LLMs, judged by
another LLM. This method assesses not only domain knowledge, but also skills
such as problem definition and inconsistency recognition. We evaluate the
performance of various state-of-the-art LLMs using the debate framework and
achieve rankings that align closely with popular rankings based on human input,
eliminating the need for costly human crowdsourcing. | [
0.001565913,
0.0913244411,
-0.0178111978,
0.0803549811,
-0.0709603876,
-0.0038707624,
0.0067426697,
-0.0149501115,
-0.0171548873,
-0.0717144012,
-0.0088078789,
-0.0631158352,
0.0001038444,
0.0102837868,
0.0222039204,
-0.0309892818,
0.0219803099,
-0.0567928404,
0.0135521973,
0.0004996234,
0.0217251163,
-0.0269929413,
0.0002365105,
0.0380347259,
0.0277483128,
-0.0043719918,
0.0008802503,
-0.0177927352,
0.0175204407,
-0.025246812,
0.0073507116,
0.0480531715,
-0.0074843084,
0.0698000267,
0.0000020209,
-0.0622967035,
-0.0212714039,
0.013774504,
-0.0260280389,
0.044017002,
0.0620073862,
0.0452405363,
-0.0257077832,
0.0196816958,
-0.0444818735,
0.0109993713,
0.0173385069,
-0.0098749474,
0.0797664896,
0.039735347,
0.013058573,
-0.024516182,
-0.0053721205,
-0.0210846327,
-0.0541635789,
-0.0507700145,
0.0073978761,
0.0336038955,
0.0233194288,
0.0083860001,
-0.0024886827,
0.0312149022,
0.0111511452,
-0.0382677689,
-0.0077977125,
-0.015789276,
-0.0822826996,
0.0012742974,
0.00691933,
0.0639354289,
0.0102094458,
-0.0187511984,
0.0137749845,
-0.0094710477,
-0.0097160637,
0.0322029963,
-0.0357564352,
0.001367847,
0.0155404964,
0.0181115847,
0.0127952378,
0.0100721354,
0.0396059863,
0.030592192,
-0.0062015709,
0.0846966207,
0.0164405536,
-0.0188293383,
0.0129769556,
-0.004442465,
-0.011601259,
-0.072910957,
0.0144182099,
0.0156754963,
-0.0570490584,
0.031132929,
-0.0052463594,
-0.0329785347,
0.0252189748,
-0.0645480976,
0.0520968661,
0.0022311313,
0.0082026739,
0.0809735954,
0.0148759373,
0.0747231841,
-0.012981358,
-0.0086570112,
-0.0364622921,
-0.0198457912,
-0.0462563038,
0.0035979371,
-0.0193464607,
0.0036818266,
-0.0156797003,
0.0106024239,
-0.0164232682,
-0.0058045941,
-0.0642860383,
0.0243356824,
0.0131391836,
-0.0266121011,
0.0041978569,
-0.0310868453,
-0.0407063253,
0.0286167897,
-0.0127171911,
0.001671156,
-0.0064936886,
-0.0559336543,
0.0207373891,
0.0289084557,
-0.0533833615,
-0.0201868061,
-0.0029381565,
0.0683952495,
0.0062936717,
0.0189209133,
0.0054576183,
-0.0092959953,
-0.0260903016,
-0.0756882206,
-0.02204106,
-0.1131092086,
0.0001742555,
0.0028636395,
0.0008591126,
-0.0480220839,
0.0071950871,
-0.0111942971,
0.0265492834,
0.0620528013,
-0.0213334393,
0.0056340001,
0.0769356489,
0.0165051725,
-0.0328278877,
0.0851133317,
0.0120290136,
-0.0171373039,
0.0352075286,
0.0167624597,
-0.010081715,
0.050898511,
-0.0058607878,
0.0207012501,
-0.0243172795,
0.038809672,
0.0162638854,
0.0551960506,
-0.0244543198,
0.0770703629,
-0.0231212657,
-0.0344575755,
0.0430578962,
0.0459157862,
0.0136716207,
-0.0209422782,
0.022235211,
0.0044769025,
0.0496922769,
-0.0066681555,
0.0089748269,
-0.017293239,
-0.0030400825,
-0.0133953169,
0.0198420715,
0.0067348024,
0.0137746083,
-0.0602714196,
-0.0363062024,
0.0203490444,
-0.0010170114,
0.0180001985,
0.0409495533,
-0.0241566654,
-0.0185322687,
0.0411159694,
-0.0098808827,
-0.0182738807,
-0.0160468761,
-0.0307767969,
-0.0027815653,
0.0290202256,
0.038480971,
-0.0341840461,
-0.0545746833,
0.0007395177,
0.0411966853,
0.0454875194,
0.0813963711,
-0.0261192378,
-0.0164390579,
-0.025143778,
-0.0133051379,
-0.0142834783,
0.0210939273,
0.0107272752,
0.0279223174,
0.0006311946,
0.0187964477,
-0.0431085154,
-0.0653730929,
0.0142937331,
-0.0309118479,
0.0151510295,
-0.0103062978,
-0.0078575835,
0.0435152948,
-0.0005429046,
-0.039683789,
0.029148804,
0.0107802423,
-0.0385363139,
-0.0027034131,
0.0056357631,
-0.0062524644,
0.0157300904,
0.0713152736,
-0.0422436856,
-0.0391231403,
0.0409181565,
-0.0430599488,
-0.0139601929,
0.027554052,
-0.0378750786,
-0.0206259601,
-0.0112516554,
0.0400738716,
-0.0461288765,
-0.0473401323,
-0.0554767922,
0.0519748069,
0.018332269,
0.0479965247,
0.0188636705,
0.0388437025,
0.0494325757,
-0.0376145802,
-0.0673786029,
0.0425929986,
0.0134418737,
0.0373707004,
0.0383872725,
-0.0102481022,
-0.0622594841,
-0.0320865996,
-0.088288404,
0.0035157579,
-0.0025007972,
0.0456391051,
0.014265989,
-0.0608665571,
0.0119432528,
0.0138942888,
-0.0255066399,
-0.033672072,
0.0143084107,
-0.0045900503,
0.0531372614,
0.0218212511,
-0.0165643338,
-0.070633918,
0.0013616083,
-0.0161868911,
0.0548436083,
0.010016568,
0.0278052744,
-0.0374764241,
0.0231461823,
-0.0495242476,
0.0161334518,
-0.0052968939,
-0.0215098001,
0.0375345498,
0.0083228182,
0.0290376991,
0.0231819171,
0.0039031408,
0.0217784103,
0.0638709366,
-0.0405443572,
-0.0598213039,
-0.030085478,
0.0295635369,
-0.0051408731,
-0.0372078903,
-0.0205864329,
0.0106925191,
0.0822048187,
-0.014907998,
-0.011969124,
-0.0116691161,
0.0649243072,
-0.0793560669,
0.0055481978,
-0.0709986463,
-0.0242954995,
-0.0282251518,
0.0732867867,
-0.021771457,
-0.0437355936,
0.0778564438,
-0.0459324643,
0.0265819374,
-0.0556168817,
-0.0112013603,
-0.0630809292,
0.0374604613,
-0.015414984,
0.0154223023,
-0.0052113016,
-0.0122781098,
-0.0606233329,
0.0016023107,
0.0619485006,
-0.0595249943,
0.0755541697,
-0.0927282125,
0.0316689163,
-0.0073581217,
-0.0345802903,
-0.0179732107,
-0.0177972168,
-0.0463864058,
0.0257770158,
0.0676364601,
-0.009116469,
-0.0206784252,
0.0138096698,
-0.0064809429,
-0.0011749762,
0.016903149,
-0.0087789586,
0.0112470007,
0.0449651629,
-0.0013354891,
0.039183259,
0.030676052,
-0.0304776765,
0.0247900933,
0.0533535741,
0.0451025069,
-0.0043192762,
-0.065815568,
-0.0148733407,
0.0048247459,
-0.0478837788,
-0.0057573151,
-0.0086123282,
0.0368167274,
-0.0540323406,
0.0115668299,
0.1160597578,
0.0512560271,
0.000629229,
-0.023559384,
-0.0472901389,
0.0321448036,
0.0391485766,
0.0240534525,
-0.0811986104,
-0.0187856574,
-0.0120322593,
0.0196546502,
0.0013862561,
-0.0240527783,
-0.0078320103,
-0.1260490119,
0.0274782777,
0.0109528359,
-0.0243913848,
0.0246577524,
-0.0334590599,
0.0173437521,
-0.0249230862,
-0.00263102,
0.009887306,
0.0105214892,
0.0022939108,
0.0124939186,
-0.0372683071,
-0.0670689195,
0.0533358566,
-0.0356803611,
0.059537489,
0.0400563031,
0.0476937629,
-0.010762061,
-0.0279269479,
0.0458551869,
-0.0131138861,
-0.0363301001,
0.0021397467,
0.0133652939,
0.0150725227,
-0.0260053538,
-0.0164135247,
-0.0378105678,
-0.0065141427,
-0.0093137352,
0.0137493061,
0.0657933876,
-0.0048403386,
0.0017846033,
0.005882659,
-0.0083767073,
-0.004955661,
0.0679219142,
0.0397743322,
-0.023204552,
-0.0444700345,
-0.0486096181,
-0.0188490283,
-0.0102625461,
-0.054294914,
-0.0133959381,
0.0286207907,
0.005639208,
-0.0585333705,
-0.006091902,
0.0121595431,
0.018432172,
0.0003415693,
0.0184687879,
0.0368130803,
0.0020201609,
-0.0385589749,
0.0312227327,
-0.0164246652,
0.0412152857,
-0.0725716576,
-0.0000424717,
0.0358132087,
0.0370213762,
-0.0509795658,
0.0625577047,
-0.0959625542,
-0.0738743097,
-0.0064422218,
0.0389577188,
0.0253274441,
-0.0017762631,
-0.0331405252,
-0.0547992513,
-0.01412756,
0.026887456,
-0.0034510437,
0.0014525085,
0.0184409954,
-0.0214906018,
-0.01520951,
0.02508072,
-0.0249411762,
0.009590094,
-0.0178354885,
0.0269396659,
-0.041779127,
-0.0477066301,
0.0190053266,
0.0377475508,
0.0325732753,
-0.0069760699,
-0.0281915478,
0.0010521164,
-0.0046131872,
-0.0411615372,
-0.0646945387,
-0.029637767,
-0.0178629439,
-0.0000684526,
-0.0327465646,
0.0105791632,
0.0381909013,
-0.0080787279,
0.048606921,
-0.000190088,
0.044771973,
0.0325536542,
0.0334783718,
0.0239653103,
-0.0124397501,
0.011186176,
-0.0033671812,
-0.0143728368,
0.0669285357,
-0.0194449257,
0.0268979818,
0.0165836737,
0.0007156494,
0.0334374532,
0.0236632768,
-0.0479438491,
-0.1016649157,
-0.0095833195,
0.0128913159,
0.0517736748,
0.0188293681,
0.0476365797,
-0.0165315531,
-0.0245747026,
-0.0321507864,
0.0121339951,
0.0065759728,
-0.0092637436,
0.0399713852,
0.0362893045,
-0.0079634516,
0.0297361948,
0.073667936,
0.0195910651,
-0.0169100054,
0.0184528865,
-0.0183121618,
-0.0304327104,
-0.0416657068,
-0.025679823,
-0.000312329,
-0.0223955084,
-0.015177073,
-0.0873931721,
-0.0539305434,
-0.0017343892,
0.0466036387,
0.0080410969,
0.0195704754,
0.0437166765,
0.0734872296,
0.0006022737,
0.028561499,
-0.0460621007,
0.0137047507,
-0.0145704253,
-0.0127551267,
-0.0124999918,
-6.177283792e-33,
-0.0381786153,
-0.0702733025,
0.0113714347,
-0.0487495884,
-0.0230836961,
0.0070519294,
-0.0361390188,
0.0374909826,
-0.0217879396,
0.0178982001,
0.0274113789,
0.0193631444,
0.0076123388,
-0.0210578106,
0.0145512568,
-0.0286226757,
0.0304123443,
0.0008738745,
-0.0232946444,
-0.0104265856,
0.001639929,
-0.0272192601,
0.0107136797,
-0.0597839169,
0.0438062549,
0.0025852579,
-0.0122248624,
0.0202351399,
0.0006416166,
0.0703435689,
-0.0074608102,
0.0375536531,
0.0080465246,
-0.0768295303,
-0.0041788667,
-0.0414443836,
0.0024461504,
-0.0158262961,
0.0221864879,
-0.0052163266,
-0.0212336015,
-0.003539742,
0.0474077687,
0.0370494947,
-0.032961648,
0.0061621615,
0.0224610642,
-0.0159646422,
0.0166162327,
0.0235157888,
-0.0486035384,
0.0597973168,
-0.0365308039,
-0.0022610449,
0.0203618854,
0.002544516,
-0.0088560563,
0.0384420305,
-0.0632221475,
0.0190666392,
0.0230284184,
0.0368158668,
0.0898310617,
-0.030424891,
-0.0168440696,
0.0659999624,
-0.0277546551,
0.0221166946,
0.013939688,
-0.0354346633,
-0.0033775712,
0.0559373014,
0.0717793331,
0.0701604933,
0.0286772531,
0.0306439064,
-0.0636873543,
0.0302088074,
0.0022152383,
0.0481256843,
-0.005609042,
0.0243634675,
-0.0250223484,
-0.0089133419,
-0.0631891415,
-0.0007222781,
-0.0352249816,
-0.0253716297,
0.0336689539,
-0.0358306281,
-0.0267955028,
-0.0095971245,
0.0208216831,
-0.0665372014,
-0.0522277057,
0.0105126305,
-0.0236751698,
0.032135509,
0.0151633089,
0.0552341044,
-0.0541516766,
0.0174925774,
-0.0290037096,
0.0618570819,
0.0495615341,
-0.0220367964,
-0.0295301676,
-0.0250660758,
-0.0537112616,
0.0204941574,
-0.0420553535,
-0.0164372232,
-0.0355224647,
0.0559766144,
0.017174013,
-0.0087494114,
-0.0007036013,
0.0610164553,
-0.0054132757,
-0.0214242823,
-0.0267392341,
0.0083836429,
-0.003618439,
0.0018771845,
-0.0098300045,
0.0078808218,
-0.0227888357,
0.0457903109,
0.0312134866,
0.012505006,
-0.0095443446,
-0.0237809215,
2.629e-7,
0.0765927732,
0.0620246455,
-0.00451509,
0.0340520777,
0.0170945562,
0.0388103537,
-0.0579064488,
-0.0094153695,
0.0127983103,
-0.0021046831,
-0.0404389799,
0.0221964289,
0.081565991,
0.0647395775,
-0.0614028722,
-0.0259079635,
-0.0690100268,
-0.0104275681,
-0.049501285,
-0.0241618603,
0.0506048836,
0.0602658205,
0.0042986744,
0.0199726019,
-0.0439731069,
-0.0346593522,
0.0731365532,
-0.0216688514,
-0.0243405178,
0.0446459651,
0.0230774619,
-0.0000731248,
0.0017089663,
0.0152772861,
-0.0124287792,
0.0054431804,
0.0299480762,
0.0534891412,
0.0273467228,
0.0057705725,
-0.0289368015,
-0.0173332654,
-0.0084024314,
-0.0805148408,
0.0407149233,
-0.0442239195,
-0.0352126211,
-0.0589975491,
-0.0290369131,
-0.0378646255,
0.0529625788,
-0.0212579593,
-0.0343142338,
0.018267516,
-0.0040520276,
-0.0197344497,
-0.0070937639,
-0.0373436734,
-0.0419831499,
0.0168322641,
-0.0362595618,
-0.0635390654,
-0.0178768262,
0.0001268705,
0.0052634957,
-0.0396657959,
0.0324376188,
2.165097357e-34,
0.0649686158,
0.0168286841,
0.0203978177,
0.0384690128,
0.0492967628,
0.0257312078,
-0.0494076274,
-0.0094102714,
-0.0071973242,
-0.0428094715,
0.0387748703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11036v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11036v1 | garak: A Framework for Security Probing Large Language Models | 2024-06-16T18:18:43 | 2024-06-16T18:18:43 | Leon Derczynski, Erick Galinkin, Jeffrey Martin, Subho Majumdar, Nanna Inie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR | As Large Language Models (LLMs) are deployed and integrated into thousands of
applications, the need for scalable evaluation of how models respond to
adversarial attacks grows rapidly. However, LLM security is a moving target:
models produce unpredictable output, are constantly updated, and the potential
adversary is highly diverse: anyone with access to the internet and a decent
command of natural language. Further, what constitutes a security weak in one
context may not be an issue in a different context; one-fits-all guardrails
remain theoretical. In this paper, we argue that it is time to rethink what
constitutes ``LLM security'', and pursue a holistic approach to LLM security
evaluation, where exploration and discovery of issues are central. To this end,
this paper introduces garak (Generative AI Red-teaming and Assessment Kit), a
framework which can be used to discover and identify vulnerabilities in a
target LLM or dialog system. garak probes an LLM in a structured fashion to
discover potential vulnerabilities. The outputs of the framework describe a
target model's weaknesses, contribute to an informed discussion of what
composes vulnerabilities in unique contexts, and can inform alignment and
policy discussions for LLM deployment. | [
0.0349807627,
0.084405534,
-0.0058891252,
0.0532280989,
-0.0643858314,
-0.0251009762,
0.035979595,
-0.0275192447,
0.047908593,
-0.0672492757,
-0.0056536999,
-0.0166123211,
-0.0087004965,
0.0621237271,
0.048121687,
-0.0200879499,
0.0472306907,
-0.0781938061,
-0.0093974564,
-0.0004474251,
0.0016485873,
-0.0008698385,
-0.020626504,
0.0609883219,
0.0115581779,
-0.0247423947,
-0.0418463349,
-0.0090843746,
0.0219213609,
-0.0268011969,
-0.032077726,
0.0331977122,
-0.0235377774,
0.0633332431,
0.0000020924,
-0.0671326891,
-0.0246701818,
0.0331438631,
-0.0288910456,
0.0445299968,
0.0240971372,
-0.0142155821,
-0.0338438563,
0.0419997238,
-0.0213904139,
0.0127975149,
0.0250453576,
0.0330838822,
0.0862078443,
0.0875940546,
-0.0001008284,
-0.0294781942,
0.0468547083,
-0.0224592928,
-0.0190279279,
-0.0942372456,
0.0196159314,
-0.0269527137,
-0.0020234769,
0.0298777819,
0.0311990269,
0.0169912633,
0.0341811404,
-0.0264685173,
-0.0567924082,
0.0147691881,
-0.0434815399,
-0.0087963063,
-0.0281611066,
0.0508495644,
-0.0198573377,
0.0121620065,
-0.0140777063,
0.0033867403,
0.0215734504,
0.0052618645,
-0.0007705776,
0.0207397863,
-0.0018274935,
-0.0149885546,
0.0281518605,
-0.0383518562,
0.0441113189,
0.0168566667,
-0.0222782474,
0.0665754452,
0.0147992373,
-0.0086001167,
-0.0265729744,
-0.0501637533,
0.0106486594,
-0.0578908138,
0.0009133526,
0.0237958748,
-0.0340186059,
0.0297182612,
-0.0711933225,
-0.0303847827,
0.0631349608,
-0.0219934024,
0.0312120672,
0.0224520471,
-0.0128502762,
0.0345009752,
0.0161258001,
0.0555913523,
-0.0201589782,
0.014516348,
0.0183742382,
-0.0224267524,
-0.0428628922,
-0.0267993808,
-0.002565389,
0.0113900695,
0.0048778919,
-0.0065200026,
-0.0288473032,
0.0482298434,
-0.0284674689,
0.053488344,
-0.0245715864,
-0.0148728145,
0.0067835404,
-0.0040320079,
-0.0035773411,
-0.0224808063,
-0.0221229363,
-0.0052896603,
-0.0041778241,
-0.0931758136,
-0.0237487424,
0.0300985388,
-0.0714174584,
-0.0415069871,
-0.0187633093,
0.1279397458,
0.0248653162,
0.0013683866,
-0.0491257533,
-0.0790666938,
-0.0244819634,
-0.0221835598,
0.0019982045,
-0.0641541928,
-0.0291487537,
-0.0142224394,
-0.0107810441,
-0.0493966937,
0.005448028,
-0.0038648325,
-0.0083946716,
0.0805401877,
0.0189014152,
-0.0145028541,
0.0160027742,
0.0380387679,
0.0251619499,
0.0671841949,
0.00144467,
0.0313707106,
0.0267940126,
0.0028550511,
0.0548728295,
0.0452769436,
-0.0101871593,
0.0350924395,
-0.0118741589,
0.0300941113,
0.0063818744,
-0.0213023089,
-0.0426583961,
0.0654681846,
0.0105084674,
-0.0589889884,
0.0948186144,
0.0531668961,
-0.0478192605,
0.0158959627,
0.0136101721,
-0.0045745187,
0.0075237239,
-0.0164047293,
-0.0451253504,
0.0044097658,
-0.0751065835,
-0.0417988487,
-0.0118008014,
0.0452078059,
-0.0061141951,
-0.021723073,
-0.0074123302,
0.0066020573,
0.017961923,
0.000253032,
0.0207332186,
0.0399660878,
-0.0024501048,
-0.0100042243,
-0.0171535052,
-0.0267837998,
-0.0375590622,
-0.124476403,
-0.0380219556,
0.0459202155,
0.0818527564,
-0.0420593433,
-0.0419297069,
-0.0202779286,
-0.0356478505,
0.0493285842,
0.0313083939,
0.0107359998,
0.0053073764,
-0.0221904237,
-0.0083861677,
-0.0229306053,
0.0325663611,
0.0320760608,
-0.0085826553,
0.0105558923,
-0.0032167442,
0.0060728542,
-0.0370833352,
0.0281621069,
0.0337569341,
-0.0318200588,
0.0185858272,
0.0138452128,
0.0474986844,
0.027170606,
-0.0189186744,
0.0480450764,
0.0466095395,
0.0046285698,
-0.0012788958,
-0.0060730027,
0.0120437639,
0.0355560258,
0.0296522193,
-0.0053577237,
0.0081259273,
0.0389860943,
-0.060054671,
-0.0026981076,
0.0740164146,
-0.0465149097,
-0.0158713758,
-0.0161348674,
0.0181590542,
-0.0097708488,
0.0247695222,
-0.0432933792,
0.0389684699,
-0.0073880176,
-0.0508138314,
-0.0188683346,
0.0327214897,
0.0267390814,
-0.0566076152,
-0.0489924215,
0.0281552486,
-0.036373198,
0.0376038589,
-0.003266382,
0.0034059135,
-0.0277558528,
-0.0126972962,
-0.041903872,
-0.0079992553,
-0.0179572254,
0.046159707,
0.0329967737,
-0.0031163946,
-0.0118638994,
-0.0144583713,
-0.0012896574,
-0.0202462375,
0.0076075555,
0.0316629335,
0.0268494505,
-0.0087249903,
-0.0525759198,
-0.0411327966,
0.0052543781,
-0.0264911111,
0.0587894693,
0.0126815885,
-0.0069913222,
-0.0113330204,
0.0178667828,
-0.0260848813,
0.0234136358,
-0.0069905529,
-0.0709549859,
0.0428312048,
0.026735371,
-0.0020137175,
0.0311115067,
0.029500626,
0.0487058349,
0.0579110943,
0.0054143635,
-0.0254050009,
-0.0166142378,
0.0377378911,
-0.0415006056,
-0.0311833378,
-0.0089218132,
0.0432888232,
0.0575782359,
0.0306936856,
-0.0172849223,
-0.0195310358,
0.0545649566,
-0.015052693,
-0.0268079452,
-0.019793056,
-0.0581394993,
0.00428598,
0.0339922421,
0.002810589,
-0.0599037446,
0.0799960271,
-0.0605873764,
0.0145931067,
-0.0597171783,
-0.0700314417,
-0.0206430517,
0.0783897266,
-0.034315072,
0.0226206146,
0.0435536206,
-0.0123307845,
-0.0566980354,
-0.0394993983,
0.0210424401,
-0.0133857047,
0.0346593484,
-0.0338854119,
-0.0007183105,
0.0016102368,
-0.029541757,
-0.0620531142,
-0.0208660327,
-0.0414039642,
0.0195872039,
0.008795199,
-0.0233032983,
-0.0289096478,
-0.005175991,
0.0354929194,
-0.0024389678,
0.0142427012,
-0.0249664541,
-0.0196365938,
0.0046812254,
0.0201515909,
-0.0484151319,
0.0032645706,
-0.0007902462,
0.0526091158,
0.064801082,
0.0266800523,
0.0082024625,
-0.0365285203,
-0.0306622237,
-0.0045485152,
-0.004702616,
0.0105165159,
0.0101497676,
0.015720902,
-0.0693333596,
-0.0004955743,
0.0553047247,
0.0309108775,
-0.0035108828,
0.0204620175,
-0.0369884074,
0.0049062348,
0.0061783101,
0.031179186,
-0.0897877142,
-0.0007288824,
0.0248025805,
0.039532654,
-0.0377559997,
-0.00837404,
-0.0134709636,
-0.1275281757,
0.0193706583,
-0.0067569534,
-0.0309019499,
-0.0108185643,
-0.0171279237,
-0.0235240273,
0.0144665251,
0.0363771059,
-0.0004137391,
0.0129941618,
0.0013617317,
-0.0092529496,
-0.0680447742,
-0.0355737843,
0.0142525798,
-0.0284840111,
0.0714795962,
0.0719731152,
0.0192317255,
-0.0118121132,
-0.0029325045,
0.0696337,
-0.0032319655,
0.0044581257,
0.0181706734,
0.0428839773,
0.0231621917,
-0.0228458904,
-0.0002473966,
0.0271105915,
0.0069414708,
-0.0324184,
0.0545928106,
0.0386552773,
-0.0583158024,
0.0060320934,
-0.0331515372,
-0.0072248448,
0.0578134432,
0.0699033961,
0.0309123043,
-0.0412948653,
-0.0394769199,
-0.0729207247,
0.0123384241,
-0.04383903,
-0.0682559088,
0.0263837818,
0.0320559181,
-0.0335250758,
-0.0640605092,
-0.0162922144,
-0.0340669528,
0.0123788463,
0.0339077786,
-0.0268173888,
-0.0304506067,
0.0323658772,
0.0029580314,
-0.0105702057,
-0.0299458075,
0.0461237393,
-0.0406204723,
0.0165165979,
0.0044108117,
-0.0246923901,
-0.025017675,
0.0364576355,
-0.0540465117,
-0.0875862688,
0.0087877763,
0.053293556,
0.0238321722,
-0.0305065718,
-0.0649613738,
-0.0633829683,
0.0864972323,
0.022702707,
-0.0343720168,
-0.0091896784,
0.0784447044,
-0.0174599513,
0.0094164563,
0.0288096312,
-0.0315283202,
-0.0142362649,
0.0256651379,
-0.0112407301,
-0.0451321118,
-0.0421216227,
-0.0107734008,
0.0515283234,
0.0268521924,
0.009883916,
0.0081737144,
0.0069802934,
0.0162964389,
-0.0141402809,
-0.0323471129,
0.0048564281,
0.0154401939,
0.0182277597,
-0.0249089543,
0.0511872619,
0.0005678681,
-0.0167992059,
0.0277997386,
0.0016688035,
0.0367749371,
0.0623853467,
0.0323901549,
0.0323354676,
-0.0046187527,
-0.0014360521,
0.049328763,
-0.0309318453,
0.038151633,
0.0198575109,
0.0399505086,
-0.0221455749,
-0.0092663262,
0.0017942477,
0.0482739694,
-0.0616261028,
-0.0872187018,
0.0501585156,
0.073106885,
0.0217933189,
0.0561571121,
0.0230200309,
-0.0063034813,
0.0113047296,
-0.0278564394,
-0.018760372,
0.0234104823,
-0.0454116389,
0.0230885837,
0.0084367832,
-0.0176641345,
0.0147582144,
0.0630468279,
-0.0076071597,
0.0622647256,
0.0007434657,
-0.0215312056,
-0.0235387422,
-0.0498285182,
0.0031249314,
0.006536887,
-0.0449977219,
-0.0307382327,
-0.0673126578,
-0.0898754001,
-0.0196090676,
0.0324101858,
0.0152111948,
0.031362474,
-0.0076455027,
0.0506465584,
0.0304746442,
0.0437601544,
-0.0793520957,
0.0149863381,
-0.0304552633,
-0.0535966121,
0.0230660327,
-5.828041482e-33,
0.0128841605,
-0.0504341051,
-0.0197814405,
-0.0119554093,
0.0114361839,
0.0254745204,
-0.0249420907,
0.0166588072,
-0.0554501899,
-0.0118154362,
0.0091728419,
0.0035529351,
0.0061710379,
0.0177721735,
-0.0198964607,
-0.021522807,
0.0146495067,
-0.0067720697,
-0.0247272961,
0.0225785263,
0.0611618049,
-0.0263238251,
0.0053964518,
-0.0927704051,
0.0415145308,
0.0105439909,
-0.0401047431,
0.0233315714,
-0.0540084131,
0.0716611743,
-0.0150924372,
0.0340022035,
-0.0047262637,
-0.0417466387,
0.0043370728,
0.0291772876,
0.0233886354,
-0.0178472679,
0.0006382036,
-0.0126892272,
0.0024604383,
-0.051499337,
0.0051630456,
-0.0237619467,
0.0088364687,
0.0004623084,
-0.0014129381,
-0.017088782,
0.0279944316,
-0.0182111226,
-0.0288161635,
0.0184443146,
-0.0489800908,
0.0005326397,
-0.0158222187,
0.0145827159,
0.0445263721,
0.0002648203,
-0.02531505,
0.0324462764,
0.0111012924,
-0.0124267936,
0.0867444053,
0.0172940921,
-0.0104026143,
0.0501585156,
-0.0214177053,
-0.0042649335,
-0.0192377567,
-0.0136285219,
-0.0189783387,
0.0435984395,
0.0586068705,
0.0583219416,
-0.0095030656,
-0.0080264779,
-0.0774283484,
0.0273891073,
0.0283012241,
0.0634890944,
0.0474018455,
0.0109614478,
-0.0515434816,
0.0021223493,
-0.0142455874,
-0.0364024751,
-0.0532389134,
-0.0270117186,
0.0039844909,
-0.0038901751,
-0.0478304401,
-0.0090893703,
0.0249450635,
-0.0285189319,
-0.0007020814,
0.0530554727,
-0.0012908475,
-0.0199734904,
-0.0116156759,
0.0032997001,
0.0265729316,
0.0053755068,
0.024081355,
-0.0249210168,
0.0448609926,
-0.0154718338,
0.0226481482,
0.0255178045,
-0.0528106801,
-0.0076929806,
-0.0298617147,
0.0679301694,
0.0118497489,
0.0556467101,
0.0154268341,
-0.0276907925,
-0.0039868597,
0.0293034911,
0.0411305577,
-0.0125628375,
-0.0376192108,
0.0444478653,
-0.040457461,
-0.000902718,
-0.0254459977,
-0.0039504711,
0.0020533488,
0.0246489905,
0.0433719754,
-0.0269101206,
-0.0070945635,
-0.0381952599,
2.842e-7,
0.0137258563,
0.0036427651,
0.0271516386,
0.0256630704,
0.0354038626,
0.0804267377,
-0.009320301,
0.065517351,
-0.016683111,
-0.0151130082,
-0.0248858035,
0.016660355,
0.0565173961,
0.0553081296,
-0.0237895064,
-0.0000745819,
-0.0998554528,
-0.0084196599,
-0.0843690559,
0.0070872209,
0.0448982418,
0.0967120975,
0.0133772669,
-0.0294454489,
-0.0236707646,
-0.0874131992,
-0.0088713504,
-0.0054871272,
-0.0139613077,
0.0094043734,
0.0372481458,
0.0535772778,
0.0167779252,
0.0352576301,
-0.0168817081,
-0.0200194102,
-0.0501156636,
0.0365120359,
0.0212450549,
-0.0177147649,
-0.0291172657,
-0.0405735224,
0.0154186692,
-0.071801506,
0.0797219574,
-0.0128566725,
-0.0261115022,
-0.0394126177,
0.0236086417,
-0.0446165241,
0.0439817607,
-0.0483911075,
-0.0028602632,
-0.0044042245,
-0.0176815037,
-0.0241651069,
0.0370460637,
-0.0449152179,
-0.0337615237,
-0.0282439422,
-0.0178543739,
-0.0101501606,
-0.0004053475,
0.0139760608,
0.0134664243,
-0.0129069844,
0.018458277,
2.654641851e-34,
0.0055486378,
-0.0227947738,
-0.014440815,
0.002569071,
0.0425979309,
0.0359718427,
-0.0302534923,
0.0004004529,
0.0009457663,
-0.0254959483,
-0.0260025486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11035v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11035v1 | Scaling Synthetic Logical Reasoning Datasets with Context-Sensitive Declarative Grammars | 2024-06-16T18:10:49 | 2024-06-16T18:10:49 | Damien Sileo | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Logical reasoning remains a challenge for natural language processing, but it
can be improved by training language models to mimic theorem provers on
procedurally generated problems. Previous work used domain-specific proof
generation algorithms, which biases reasoning toward specific proof traces and
limits auditability and extensibility. We present a simpler and more general
declarative framework with flexible context-sensitive rules binding multiple
languages (specifically, simplified English and the TPTP theorem-proving
language). We construct first-order logic problems by selecting up to 32
premises and one hypothesis. We demonstrate that using semantic constraints
during generation and careful English verbalization of predicates enhances
logical reasoning without hurting natural English tasks. We use relatively
small DeBERTa-v3 models to achieve state-of-the-art accuracy on the FOLIO
human-authored logic dataset, surpassing GPT-4 in accuracy with or without an
external solver by 12%. | [
0.0182851739,
0.064463459,
0.0017746713,
0.0345295705,
-0.0632517785,
0.003560574,
0.0391859263,
-0.0524754338,
0.0199261121,
-0.0251033828,
0.0323288515,
0.0231143218,
-0.0271537304,
0.0399984159,
0.0424683392,
-0.0287454482,
0.0304262862,
-0.0259037595,
0.0011906006,
-0.0239585452,
0.0258010421,
0.0175181031,
-0.0072729634,
0.0154645508,
-0.0739895627,
-0.0311850868,
-0.0099976594,
-0.0121279061,
0.009422604,
-0.0327206142,
-0.0102005815,
0.065487586,
0.0450039133,
0.0290037822,
0.0000020212,
-0.0431988053,
-0.0064262962,
0.0150011787,
-0.0369299836,
-0.0279866587,
0.0033221571,
-0.0076523041,
0.0116505055,
0.020348873,
-0.0849184245,
-0.0058436533,
0.0225457903,
0.0369736105,
0.0761130452,
0.0833022147,
-0.0098409001,
-0.0746499673,
0.0063477671,
-0.0134839518,
-0.003046196,
-0.0188136697,
0.0007696189,
0.0243256819,
0.0313318707,
-0.0459163003,
0.0418945402,
-0.0005074979,
0.0674284846,
-0.0169122461,
-0.0412990451,
0.0121640256,
-0.0656822771,
-0.0035779984,
0.0036620772,
0.0601576492,
0.0286875181,
-0.0793649927,
-0.0284763034,
0.0248869527,
-0.0074283155,
-0.0148399249,
0.000123558,
0.079302609,
-0.0490489677,
0.0041991929,
0.0710879192,
-0.0261676461,
0.0128353145,
-0.0121376058,
-0.0195687674,
0.0854097903,
-0.0025832925,
-0.0466602072,
0.0106120044,
0.0157266501,
-0.0528284535,
-0.0649154261,
0.0264250357,
0.0116811981,
-0.0414821617,
0.0152990539,
-0.0697229505,
0.0011029306,
0.0143516799,
-0.0104380799,
-0.0067662122,
0.0537911057,
0.0294961724,
0.0164240319,
-0.0346501656,
0.0317382962,
-0.0024461304,
0.0751126856,
-0.0018383552,
-0.0240705777,
-0.0475139618,
0.0035600213,
-0.0384093635,
0.0361048318,
-0.0453996286,
0.0593590401,
-0.0416946411,
-0.0056901765,
-0.0277856328,
0.0539620705,
-0.0008946654,
-0.019856438,
-0.0258930363,
-0.0372077823,
-0.0264445264,
-0.0364111252,
-0.0542534925,
0.019216517,
0.0171977282,
-0.0561141334,
-0.0206429902,
-0.0117732799,
-0.0187810045,
0.009670442,
0.0265360735,
0.058758691,
0.0017495509,
0.0338192731,
-0.0620222837,
-0.0697856843,
0.0330115184,
-0.0608420521,
-0.0146244904,
-0.0846470818,
0.0139883328,
-0.0051966901,
-0.0362706482,
-0.0403866358,
-0.0126593933,
0.0540592894,
0.0500605442,
0.0790640712,
-0.0372070819,
-0.0099570239,
-0.0189197026,
-0.0111546963,
-0.0154128997,
0.0623939037,
0.0227877609,
0.0062222048,
0.0217791703,
0.0318047293,
-0.0080720251,
0.0067520859,
0.0267723966,
-0.0237843636,
-0.0315714628,
0.0293019675,
-0.0010219028,
0.0329714417,
0.0081084548,
0.0428952537,
-0.028687885,
-0.0082172733,
-0.0047397674,
0.0252218992,
0.016197145,
0.0000613984,
0.0559789576,
-0.0081222113,
0.0087766144,
0.0058632591,
-0.0794653445,
-0.0080874711,
-0.0114662033,
-0.0041415449,
-0.0478008203,
0.0210908353,
0.0007114751,
-0.0628152564,
-0.0166063774,
0.0297492798,
-0.021103194,
0.0202074274,
0.0106222304,
0.0386330709,
0.0136019122,
0.0554254912,
0.0281270724,
-0.0826098993,
-0.0412082598,
-0.0039149439,
0.060902901,
0.0166439433,
0.05171353,
-0.0407412723,
-0.0107873008,
-0.0292274542,
0.0471556745,
0.0485609435,
0.0231683683,
-0.0195592307,
0.0063546021,
-0.0170593187,
0.0031083161,
-0.0322976336,
0.0201392416,
0.0069716112,
0.0503310114,
0.0037134211,
0.01516697,
-0.0355584919,
0.0239939578,
0.0327446237,
-0.034897361,
-0.011223481,
0.0200159587,
0.0038801255,
0.0353023596,
-0.0026816186,
-0.0116343228,
0.0155946491,
-0.0051115593,
-0.0376927778,
-0.0057691676,
0.03230327,
-0.0177948959,
-0.0719246119,
0.0581527539,
-0.0756856352,
-0.0588616394,
0.0002470495,
-0.0745716244,
-0.0047131572,
0.0261835642,
-0.0317519829,
-0.0141885607,
-0.0487759225,
-0.0354955867,
0.0397079326,
-0.0173118077,
-0.0098138554,
0.0787882581,
0.0265683513,
-0.0076139322,
0.0099896053,
0.0042655966,
0.0305677671,
-0.0464855954,
0.0518695824,
-0.0128582995,
0.0020825332,
0.0090112556,
0.0184676126,
0.0435504615,
-0.0146670211,
0.0011011345,
-0.0550671332,
0.0222945381,
-0.0294988826,
0.0378430337,
0.0337709598,
-0.0339813791,
-0.0061497646,
0.0013735418,
-0.0596300699,
-0.0369923562,
0.0160638262,
-0.0197971724,
0.0439958498,
-0.0246469174,
-0.0092796534,
-0.0071884277,
-0.0083083445,
-0.0367840417,
0.0218114611,
0.025533203,
0.0412635393,
0.0001270455,
0.0144018549,
-0.0115424348,
0.0531707108,
0.0126423575,
0.0027691924,
0.0344388485,
-0.0180509817,
0.0057563153,
0.0686804727,
-0.0307254437,
0.00740337,
0.0348533504,
-0.0237147491,
-0.0128269494,
0.0404647812,
-0.0089217657,
0.0465175956,
-0.0220223721,
-0.0344136618,
0.009066062,
0.0091043711,
-0.0206351578,
-0.0236675404,
-0.0283380561,
0.0741777718,
-0.0120395273,
-0.0053577106,
-0.0032934942,
0.0003157482,
0.002671899,
0.0652410015,
-0.0083296187,
-0.0053641344,
0.0829008892,
-0.0019341523,
-0.0026769862,
-0.0858107805,
0.0126037309,
-0.0593030527,
0.0543969385,
0.0072202324,
0.0044313185,
0.0323273875,
0.0161454808,
-0.0207815487,
-0.0365575254,
0.0861669183,
-0.0064421017,
0.0305542145,
-0.0649579167,
0.0175162051,
-0.0155510167,
-0.0638691112,
-0.0640338883,
0.0002024332,
-0.0522958823,
0.0071072155,
-0.0364535861,
-0.0082821595,
-0.0279044881,
-0.0345032848,
0.0011540895,
0.021422958,
0.0075627221,
-0.0139666358,
-0.0199750531,
-0.0179409925,
-0.0158517305,
0.0247458704,
-0.0142432088,
-0.0096978238,
0.0026309511,
0.0419704206,
0.0110851442,
0.0002532189,
-0.0065687164,
0.0603857078,
-0.0116812512,
-0.0058417669,
-0.0061915303,
0.0143383127,
0.0144738061,
-0.0841002092,
-0.0096619567,
0.1020301729,
0.0404738113,
0.0293945875,
0.0009792439,
-0.0294595901,
0.0435059257,
0.0086239856,
0.0426007956,
-0.1119962409,
-0.0749760866,
0.0247685462,
-0.0087822238,
-0.0222389214,
-0.0334094241,
-0.0200166702,
-0.1260135323,
0.0587378182,
-0.0026179305,
-0.0067339092,
0.0068600685,
-0.0536104552,
0.0037835371,
-0.0370807685,
-0.0258705467,
-0.0036022086,
-0.0057498082,
0.0295153055,
0.0011852634,
-0.0282425079,
-0.0267731845,
0.0528079346,
-0.031008102,
0.0010486133,
0.0198456813,
0.0101349736,
0.0033131063,
-0.0680857152,
0.0043464629,
0.0371173844,
-0.0150406091,
-0.0161967687,
-0.0026876724,
-0.0018642042,
0.0042774426,
-0.0435841568,
0.0691303834,
-0.0446488969,
-0.0431510732,
0.0357942246,
0.0548069254,
0.0041711712,
-0.0101113142,
-0.0388796963,
0.0377436355,
-0.0232289825,
0.037602894,
0.0180020183,
0.0185508281,
-0.0595566891,
-0.0768350884,
-0.0123718204,
-0.0646785945,
-0.0043913634,
0.0226668566,
-0.0029125921,
-0.049616795,
-0.0446686968,
-0.0139301522,
0.07338503,
0.0503392443,
-0.0063661644,
-0.0493387133,
0.029590033,
-0.0014781294,
-0.0564656183,
0.0490715504,
-0.0414361283,
0.0346468017,
-0.0256440565,
0.029496016,
-0.0188570358,
-0.0091241039,
-0.0278999023,
0.085035339,
-0.0295474697,
-0.0810965374,
-0.0094286837,
0.0278348681,
0.0184300132,
0.0446720496,
-0.0205792524,
-0.0189555269,
-0.003985506,
0.0379504263,
-0.0039670179,
-0.0221137553,
0.0682213008,
-0.0381133966,
0.0159140844,
0.031631697,
0.0105370646,
0.0303634889,
0.0276854839,
0.0591295883,
-0.0235165525,
0.0207729414,
0.066885516,
0.0629803538,
-0.0002222264,
0.0052980348,
-0.0012563348,
-0.0264075194,
0.0129456883,
-0.0690138116,
-0.0205141976,
-0.0477853417,
0.0403916538,
-0.0258743744,
-0.0124966288,
0.0030415668,
-0.0458209291,
-0.044733867,
-0.0105038332,
0.0169042442,
0.0262348987,
0.0280136224,
0.0309550129,
0.0288411453,
-0.0623209998,
-0.017575305,
-0.0375951752,
-0.0174853839,
0.0461717956,
-0.0281895269,
0.0194093939,
0.0636233389,
0.0179672018,
-0.0461478159,
-0.0164507646,
-0.0404474139,
-0.0005804211,
0.0143779088,
-0.0233664215,
0.0598616973,
0.0315240249,
0.0068171704,
-0.0579298213,
-0.0017992465,
0.0294982232,
0.0575359128,
0.0179637689,
-0.0476605669,
0.0281410553,
0.007172985,
-0.0300727319,
-0.062342979,
0.0559783801,
-0.0018680131,
0.0277352761,
0.0063284831,
-0.0147865769,
-0.0525351167,
-0.0433870889,
-0.0264541917,
0.0054296078,
0.0199625939,
-0.0075744134,
-0.0715422109,
-0.0899387076,
0.0168597605,
0.0431553088,
-0.0034553939,
0.0256533325,
0.0421838127,
0.0458176434,
0.0316198207,
-0.0650131628,
0.0030324848,
0.009552639,
-0.00481191,
-0.0527110025,
0.0102953631,
-5.875006889e-33,
-0.0189600158,
-0.0173554663,
0.0459802225,
-0.0160926599,
0.0231059622,
-0.0428016186,
-0.0726881921,
0.0018076872,
0.0019691139,
0.0676538274,
-0.0239024665,
0.0408877842,
0.0156672765,
0.0227458626,
-0.045248501,
-0.0001442153,
0.0204021353,
0.011568293,
-0.0258807838,
0.0234225541,
0.0517747179,
-0.0196436234,
0.028787626,
-0.0294257924,
-0.006879624,
0.0234087519,
-0.0233755242,
0.0457113162,
-0.0756472871,
0.0113027589,
0.0044152802,
0.0398912095,
-0.0107993465,
-0.0264150631,
-0.0057292338,
0.0101784812,
-0.0499980226,
-0.0296033192,
0.0438220836,
-0.0229801498,
-0.0212390665,
-0.0390217416,
0.0174367465,
0.0037183587,
-0.0077508036,
-0.0072722761,
0.0178408176,
-0.0070610777,
0.0216377359,
-0.035975609,
-0.0401650369,
0.0361862853,
-0.008823188,
-0.0055074291,
0.0034592943,
0.0218693372,
-0.0055413502,
-0.063230738,
-0.0209124852,
0.0261719413,
0.0217639301,
-0.0138262659,
0.0447398685,
-0.0580613241,
-0.0077618673,
0.0304689631,
0.0026184903,
-0.0055361399,
-0.0448636301,
0.0824287832,
-0.006020546,
0.0750272572,
0.0500981957,
0.0682974234,
0.0359303989,
0.0128141511,
-0.0977787822,
0.0162289906,
-0.0111416429,
0.0407765135,
0.0210031122,
-0.0480017923,
-0.040170081,
-0.0116449893,
-0.033637654,
0.0893875062,
-0.0046426528,
0.0120274425,
0.0282485373,
-0.0136551429,
-0.0159746353,
-0.0445483848,
-0.0148483338,
-0.0206617266,
-0.005909726,
0.02101909,
-0.0020891032,
-0.0367057845,
-0.0000048981,
0.0375248305,
-0.0264406353,
0.0103021413,
0.0216189306,
0.027487712,
0.0241569299,
0.0090518426,
0.0343167596,
0.0236272737,
-0.0217768792,
0.0215210561,
-0.0447995253,
0.0554867014,
-0.0076598939,
0.0345474854,
0.0322136246,
0.030015951,
-0.0016456407,
-0.0175558981,
-0.0275367796,
-0.0406838693,
-0.0427634493,
0.0604993999,
0.0308418125,
0.0367908403,
0.0129177775,
-0.0290239006,
-0.0420570821,
0.0019853832,
0.0365779735,
-0.0396466739,
0.0065066302,
0.0186222438,
2.745e-7,
-0.0026136434,
0.0226292703,
0.0336011909,
0.0986017734,
-0.0081775133,
0.0460463949,
0.0137662664,
0.0132094007,
0.0074099638,
-0.0404906385,
-0.021751646,
0.0421130098,
0.0352951102,
0.0673868805,
-0.0657294467,
-0.00334931,
0.0054984526,
-0.0419774391,
-0.0402232967,
0.0147277163,
0.0842738748,
0.0680260509,
0.0236391649,
-0.0307026841,
0.0282495264,
-0.0349000618,
0.0323837548,
0.0309814848,
0.0014816632,
-0.0123971477,
0.0597826615,
-0.0123010268,
0.0211187638,
0.0615997314,
-0.017454518,
0.0013617096,
-0.0496808551,
0.0344672427,
0.0008464805,
0.0308486745,
-0.033793807,
-0.0667468682,
-0.0079387072,
-0.0344654433,
0.0474675037,
-0.0504118018,
-0.0262469649,
0.0589893609,
-0.0065104566,
-0.0461761095,
-0.0269087441,
0.0027733722,
-0.0111587681,
0.0029281564,
0.0426152274,
-0.0317001902,
0.0213081073,
-0.0499961823,
-0.0150249964,
0.0196141955,
-0.0321486928,
0.002034815,
0.0247457549,
0.0391139388,
0.0401587375,
-0.0372950025,
0.0018574717,
2.780442706e-34,
0.0480671525,
-0.0015920385,
0.0143476147,
-0.0130983144,
0.073238492,
0.0144985318,
0.0176537316,
-0.013032251,
0.0113592623,
-0.0641892329,
-0.0289782844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11030v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11030v1 | FoodieQA: A Multimodal Dataset for Fine-Grained Understanding of Chinese Food Culture | 2024-06-16T17:59:32 | 2024-06-16T17:59:32 | Wenyan Li, Xinyu Zhang, Jiaang Li, Qiwei Peng, Raphael Tang, Li Zhou, Weijia Zhang, Guimin Hu, Yifei Yuan, Anders Søgaard, Daniel Hershcovich, Desmond Elliott | cs.CL | cs.CL | Food is a rich and varied dimension of cultural heritage, crucial to both
individuals and social groups. To bridge the gap in the literature on the
often-overlooked regional diversity in this domain, we introduce FoodieQA, a
manually curated, fine-grained image-text dataset capturing the intricate
features of food cultures across various regions in China. We evaluate
vision-language Models (VLMs) and large language models (LLMs) on newly
collected, unseen food images and corresponding questions. FoodieQA comprises
three multiple-choice question-answering tasks where models need to answer
questions based on multiple images, a single image, and text-only descriptions,
respectively. While LLMs excel at text-based question answering, surpassing
human accuracy, the open-sourced VLMs still fall short by 41\% on multi-image
and 21\% on single-image VQA tasks, although closed-weights models perform
closer to human levels (within 10\%). Our findings highlight that understanding
food and its cultural implications remains a challenging and under-explored
direction. | [
0.0228766445,
0.0937571377,
-0.0198230874,
0.0369359702,
0.0125521887,
0.050939139,
0.0138339428,
0.0104776137,
0.0267238282,
-0.0456187017,
-0.0093741193,
-0.0407371819,
0.0066062016,
0.0071611051,
0.0279947296,
-0.0598953366,
0.0279968306,
0.0067080585,
-0.0061346265,
0.017650431,
0.0044331388,
0.007229961,
0.0350882709,
0.0098439232,
-0.0397682525,
-0.0245190635,
-0.0049890741,
0.0176181085,
0.0212020073,
-0.0356163383,
0.0103713907,
0.0447731391,
0.0145580675,
0.0166295432,
0.0000016886,
0.0013058272,
0.0339226611,
0.0005655552,
0.0036545435,
0.0591110662,
0.0223293379,
0.0016688744,
0.0212713927,
-0.0138726318,
-0.0309728794,
-0.0252606794,
0.0811173916,
0.0654381365,
0.0251814499,
0.0249612313,
-0.0002732435,
-0.0931428969,
-0.0525202006,
0.0012523141,
0.0373978764,
0.0033566433,
0.030310506,
0.0373158641,
-0.0228600055,
0.0034002331,
-0.0488378741,
0.0439049713,
0.0394640043,
0.0202913303,
-0.0589527264,
0.0451272354,
-0.0456148423,
-0.0489994399,
0.0264880508,
0.1108542755,
0.003004876,
0.0049148989,
-0.0233493131,
0.0056358646,
-0.0511535034,
-0.0109186629,
-0.043168731,
0.0188881736,
-0.0169152133,
0.0289945584,
-0.0642108992,
-0.0371216498,
0.026904596,
0.0495982803,
0.0187594909,
0.0618114881,
0.0118127298,
0.028752733,
-0.0365973525,
0.0108316634,
-0.0419027545,
-0.036971081,
-0.0162613038,
0.0632812679,
0.0010688847,
0.025689723,
0.0428967327,
0.0254500601,
0.0150894327,
-0.0190772694,
0.0040584295,
0.0300432686,
-0.1030334011,
0.0283599366,
-0.002861541,
0.0386013389,
-0.0187804885,
0.0273382999,
-0.0531696305,
-0.0228536353,
-0.041742526,
-0.0121541061,
0.0030182779,
-0.0084982421,
-0.045440957,
-0.0230398159,
-0.0035134801,
0.0049417503,
-0.0000122463,
-0.0210210569,
-0.0000550172,
0.0670239925,
-0.0156298615,
0.0186492261,
-0.052799698,
0.0856518522,
-0.0288945213,
0.0207935739,
-0.0247230623,
-0.0132599361,
-0.0013217147,
0.0035278851,
0.003714367,
-0.0030649221,
0.0135546178,
0.0304308608,
-0.033263877,
-0.0281311292,
-0.0270510223,
-0.0116851544,
-0.0550710708,
-0.0714007318,
0.0334235951,
-0.0763534978,
0.0149611197,
0.0100119347,
0.0388321094,
-0.028317187,
0.0238262266,
0.067358613,
-0.0369896069,
0.061883755,
0.0855184421,
0.0046554231,
0.0382188596,
0.0185958687,
0.0120954439,
0.0592773519,
0.01687623,
0.0500086062,
0.0482266881,
-0.0036338465,
-0.0148951365,
0.0066824458,
-0.0351190306,
0.0207801927,
-0.0660082623,
0.0333736874,
0.0284394585,
0.0198359415,
0.009720834,
0.0602834821,
-0.0010156168,
-0.0208439697,
0.1075138822,
0.0670953542,
-0.0117403995,
-0.0064206207,
0.0303981155,
0.0088322619,
0.0237877164,
0.018362755,
-0.0236713085,
0.052819442,
-0.0203555375,
-0.0036650025,
-0.0156428851,
0.0452407524,
-0.0487430803,
-0.0457550362,
-0.0276905745,
0.0064554131,
0.0575672053,
0.0431435406,
0.0539692231,
-0.0199025031,
-0.0081301937,
-0.0326112323,
0.0181839876,
-0.032635767,
-0.0083352029,
0.0026518705,
0.0892472193,
0.0438102186,
0.0161990412,
-0.0022630654,
0.0587832332,
0.0399075262,
0.0651765093,
0.0460848548,
0.0084023448,
-0.0145342536,
0.0269843116,
-0.0293457564,
-0.0464597233,
-0.0130991163,
0.0092663625,
-0.0260796789,
0.0338625386,
0.0242921598,
0.0256897435,
-0.0010232595,
-0.0211577863,
0.0182333551,
0.0076286853,
-0.00992967,
0.0037110702,
0.0078504309,
-0.0419325791,
0.0202023704,
-0.0056937444,
0.0197583344,
-0.012139949,
-0.0309306625,
0.0032591182,
0.0248168856,
-0.0020939591,
-0.0210402086,
0.0278339721,
-0.0832675919,
-0.0309354346,
0.0192372818,
-0.0492974557,
-0.0198580455,
-0.0102485539,
-0.030787671,
-0.0301485527,
-0.0631173104,
-0.0468308032,
0.0061530685,
0.0585087575,
-0.0279770251,
0.0635075048,
-0.0135529274,
0.0062695849,
-0.0319154747,
-0.0263972357,
0.0139789432,
-0.028385222,
-0.0093655409,
-0.0201501213,
0.041120097,
0.0332266018,
-0.0062616626,
0.0577604994,
-0.0476317219,
0.0170378797,
-0.103437379,
0.0016623329,
-0.0365262441,
-0.0424438752,
-0.0140669206,
-0.0024263614,
0.01334773,
-0.0377602763,
-0.0444015861,
0.0540090501,
-0.0289491266,
0.0375614166,
0.0121389301,
-0.0118762413,
0.0501678474,
-0.0147052808,
-0.0031368549,
0.0163165499,
0.0728190243,
-0.0125811622,
-0.0286662057,
-0.0135331172,
-0.0911123678,
-0.0757625476,
0.0166776702,
0.0084944433,
-0.0403603353,
-0.024777595,
0.0101304194,
0.0020289684,
0.0585550554,
-0.0061021401,
-0.0071640778,
0.0248663146,
-0.0049989941,
-0.0372821093,
-0.019032592,
0.0038977424,
0.0183611009,
0.003214207,
-0.0785354748,
-0.0438998677,
0.0352913849,
0.031832125,
0.0194821171,
-0.0223503076,
0.0375983641,
-0.0120823868,
-0.0444620699,
-0.0748913586,
0.0416470245,
-0.0010691934,
0.0596563369,
-0.0419176482,
-0.0691707879,
0.0485874265,
-0.010473799,
-0.0039186678,
0.0242524669,
-0.0087372223,
-0.0505312309,
0.075493142,
0.0330060422,
0.0408457518,
0.0213790722,
0.0182649381,
-0.0649614781,
0.0096935229,
-0.010733719,
-0.0597060807,
0.073078908,
-0.0570980385,
-0.0269857645,
-0.0196281858,
-0.0058772597,
-0.0401952639,
-0.0084633697,
-0.0456330478,
0.0181813594,
-0.0051623373,
0.012417946,
-0.030568203,
0.054816708,
0.0270190071,
-0.0273449197,
0.0022127267,
-0.0012911606,
0.0022996147,
0.0533891059,
0.0859771743,
0.0453548208,
-0.0123284319,
-0.0208067,
0.0222647674,
0.0375001617,
0.0061373999,
-0.0126810949,
0.0120683312,
0.0569626912,
0.0247472115,
0.0405366756,
-0.0147580523,
0.0005551282,
0.0395468138,
-0.0214327239,
-0.0213308148,
0.0827764571,
0.0336923786,
-0.0448814332,
0.0130790714,
0.0196166765,
-0.0181976259,
0.0402280614,
0.0375538953,
-0.1218742728,
-0.0171997268,
-0.0389537103,
-0.0167822465,
-0.0233032182,
-0.003511403,
-0.0283849388,
-0.0856866315,
0.0458802544,
-0.0057536005,
-0.0797290355,
-0.0471949019,
-0.0062086484,
-0.0165827144,
-0.0162731539,
0.0456305742,
-0.0384342074,
-0.0178098846,
0.0018982587,
0.0047350135,
0.002603566,
0.0011333901,
0.055386398,
-0.06318032,
-0.0053083664,
0.0557047501,
0.0279599372,
-0.0120259421,
-0.0699791387,
0.016684657,
-0.0086011374,
0.0120260278,
-0.0064949282,
0.0494134501,
0.0185006447,
-0.0378820747,
-0.0147343501,
0.0171771552,
-0.0097400118,
-0.0205187965,
0.0155319106,
0.0503243729,
0.0082391798,
-0.0351031236,
0.0016485259,
-0.0108744362,
0.0167575311,
0.0497674607,
0.0268251114,
-0.0418563448,
-0.0376266837,
-0.0205101296,
-0.0816428512,
-0.0153045366,
-0.0390346125,
0.078433156,
-0.0340735205,
-0.0004016641,
-0.0718885958,
-0.004905202,
0.030177556,
0.0318227634,
-0.0053157988,
-0.0018248397,
-0.0041305586,
0.0357405245,
-0.0579565465,
0.0692331791,
-0.0279283077,
0.0132056177,
-0.0208436251,
-0.0393717997,
0.0362699777,
-0.0570676811,
0.002540448,
0.031271141,
-0.1287129372,
-0.0238941386,
-0.019181164,
0.0556552485,
0.0066436133,
0.0112075284,
0.0293219145,
-0.0687098205,
0.0328590386,
0.0076532653,
0.0176493879,
-0.0063387458,
-0.051905632,
-0.0324586444,
0.0242876131,
0.0084640812,
-0.0417959057,
0.0254414082,
0.0135856438,
0.0169188362,
-0.0366631746,
-0.0374782383,
0.0175273623,
-0.0177956391,
0.021414917,
-0.0006082377,
-0.0218702666,
-0.0341996029,
0.0073709195,
-0.0018623202,
-0.0166273452,
-0.0484310277,
-0.0364708602,
0.0421130545,
-0.0087892618,
-0.0278808214,
-0.0102862865,
-0.0043948134,
0.0268901475,
-0.0761056617,
-0.0104566561,
0.025302656,
-0.003608698,
-0.0356617235,
0.0041781985,
-0.0126522537,
0.0506260358,
-0.043008659,
0.0289038289,
-0.0009391649,
0.0945806652,
-0.0053344881,
0.0108412812,
-0.0411503352,
0.0043743891,
-0.0197612196,
-0.0628793016,
0.0003658242,
-0.0101880068,
0.0618168004,
-0.0662591904,
0.0123777874,
0.0122769307,
-0.0209332388,
-0.043709483,
0.0483820811,
0.003425583,
-0.0337941013,
0.0809796825,
0.0192641653,
0.0028131655,
0.0227373168,
0.0964965448,
0.0053170077,
0.0189991109,
0.047879912,
-0.0207276735,
0.0036702731,
-0.0045749098,
0.042355489,
-0.0147658093,
-0.0197847206,
0.0238538813,
-0.0411555097,
-0.0656669289,
-0.0181690697,
0.0105179287,
-0.017195778,
0.0275735557,
0.0190007053,
0.0349166133,
0.0191741064,
-0.040548034,
-0.034504801,
0.0141289439,
-0.042590782,
-0.0198163446,
0.0181110483,
-6.424538743e-33,
0.0014817081,
-0.0715908483,
0.0366815142,
-0.0098648211,
0.0078241257,
0.0187770333,
-0.0249511041,
-0.0137407389,
-0.0423915908,
0.0127780009,
0.0295800641,
-0.0035590632,
0.0105453394,
0.0481424108,
0.0060904729,
-0.0234476291,
-0.0219339635,
0.0078018853,
0.005369694,
-0.0181488618,
0.0143841431,
0.0043043299,
0.0306254476,
-0.0110752787,
0.0006834904,
0.0069639869,
0.0157844871,
0.0126872882,
0.0050768084,
0.0791524872,
-0.0685439408,
0.0552235842,
0.0411221832,
-0.0124257542,
-0.0219416209,
0.0048597562,
-0.0826188773,
-0.0105023095,
-0.0206216034,
0.0183348227,
-0.071397759,
-0.0032692708,
0.0158296768,
-0.0225339849,
0.0428148508,
0.005162911,
0.0741945058,
-0.0273797847,
0.0022944189,
0.0059670354,
-0.0179736018,
0.0123055456,
-0.0103381267,
0.0188410804,
0.0013104406,
0.0586298816,
0.0175097957,
0.0552324243,
-0.0193466656,
0.0135453865,
0.0090146381,
-0.0016647516,
0.054945942,
0.0600785203,
0.0267159641,
0.0187855083,
0.0333422199,
-0.0290099587,
-0.0238973256,
-0.0448499322,
-0.0035793132,
0.0466515347,
0.0305895247,
0.0580374785,
0.0165552273,
-0.0143894833,
-0.0537176169,
0.0227979422,
-0.0232673474,
0.0008389204,
-0.029166637,
0.0056617749,
0.0412577689,
0.014812679,
-0.0372369885,
0.0040462222,
-0.0568215773,
-0.0053831851,
0.0192107968,
0.0094261756,
-0.0184417143,
0.0202532709,
0.0533656515,
-0.0074240635,
0.0042547239,
-0.0183953624,
0.0139522795,
-0.0331082977,
0.0153890345,
0.0175072867,
-0.0812214762,
-0.0183197353,
0.0277935155,
0.0116379559,
-0.0038681438,
-0.0044661649,
0.0199383404,
0.0143603068,
-0.033763919,
-0.0162301101,
-0.0279656928,
-0.0592880771,
0.0015099891,
0.0200867765,
0.0214956738,
0.0034214586,
-0.0364099741,
0.0183735248,
0.0048012803,
-0.0278824903,
-0.0152020678,
-0.0636238232,
0.0137133664,
-0.0181216523,
-0.027785657,
0.0233966243,
-0.0209863707,
-0.0122055551,
0.0323993266,
-0.0440536775,
0.0129784681,
0.051298935,
2.386e-7,
0.0760775805,
0.0180365071,
0.0024409313,
0.0303434897,
-0.0095267203,
0.0008994603,
0.0075524384,
0.0342197791,
-0.0291520432,
-0.0250697695,
0.0158319008,
0.0451109968,
0.053078223,
0.0348147601,
-0.0134989806,
0.0284681078,
-0.0446726158,
0.0198991727,
-0.0486568362,
-0.012728313,
0.0071925945,
0.0820776075,
-0.0201385282,
-0.0253755804,
0.0044499268,
-0.0310425665,
0.0910159945,
-0.0551173091,
0.0101103326,
-0.0287967976,
-0.0030413058,
0.0035670365,
0.0274616964,
-0.0345941074,
-0.0057625924,
-0.0378688574,
0.0765983462,
0.0300428346,
-0.014196882,
-0.0473157465,
-0.0360230729,
0.0122400848,
-0.0048377709,
-0.0991297364,
0.0919851884,
-0.0365645848,
-0.0127116311,
0.039649915,
0.0246121828,
0.0027353161,
0.0380921811,
-0.0198693629,
0.0219466649,
0.0187868979,
0.0147341164,
-0.0276246145,
0.013098604,
-0.0533636548,
-0.0253227279,
-0.0420279913,
-0.0344807357,
-0.0421527326,
-0.0022373493,
-0.0506205633,
-0.0426705889,
-0.0032777367,
-0.0471849032,
1.626299534e-34,
0.0254530869,
-0.00760188,
-0.0188406426,
-0.0102002481,
0.0200669952,
-0.0234155618,
-0.0415251143,
-0.0367675684,
-0.0027753804,
-0.0834267586,
-0.0095582623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11029v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11029v1 | Curating Stopwords in Marathi: A TF-IDF Approach for Improved Text Analysis and Information Retrieval | 2024-06-16T17:59:05 | 2024-06-16T17:59:05 | Rohan Chavan, Gaurav Patil, Vishal Madle, Raviraj Joshi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Stopwords are commonly used words in a language that are often considered to
be of little value in determining the meaning or significance of a document.
These words occur frequently in most texts and don't provide much useful
information for tasks like sentiment analysis and text classification. English,
which is a high-resource language, takes advantage of the availability of
stopwords, whereas low-resource Indian languages like Marathi are very limited,
standardized, and can be used in available packages, but the number of
available words in those packages is low. Our work targets the curation of
stopwords in the Marathi language using the MahaCorpus, with 24.8 million
sentences. We make use of the TF-IDF approach coupled with human evaluation to
curate a strong stopword list of 400 words. We apply the stop word removal to
the text classification task and show its efficacy. The work also presents a
simple recipe for stopword curation in a low-resource language. The stopwords
are integrated into the mahaNLP library and publicly available on
https://github.com/l3cube-pune/MarathiNLP . | [
0.0844258964,
0.0539899394,
-0.0149164042,
0.0407893807,
-0.0300270021,
-0.0063820677,
0.0218587536,
0.059507139,
-0.0149376001,
-0.0427921824,
0.0169058945,
0.0075998777,
-0.0013310334,
0.039832253,
-0.0373001508,
-0.0412960686,
0.0261537358,
0.0213189293,
0.0074937078,
0.0181402396,
0.0692338422,
0.0227506608,
-0.0047678067,
0.0378730185,
-0.0127283344,
0.0154595822,
0.0351228341,
-0.0190492179,
0.0044990778,
-0.0064210529,
0.0014678162,
0.0436926745,
-0.0320897922,
0.0293924082,
0.0000016828,
-0.0709918737,
-0.0744936541,
-0.0373149775,
0.0357372239,
-0.0389137007,
0.0960829705,
-0.007315374,
-0.020589117,
0.0224582478,
-0.0068033151,
0.0702781379,
0.0509543307,
0.0286647715,
0.0093024774,
0.0835135132,
-0.0075997952,
-0.0187832396,
-0.006083074,
0.0339239985,
-0.0012304157,
0.0248058904,
-0.0162349697,
-0.057698112,
0.0227534771,
-0.0527789257,
-0.0208688062,
0.0118731093,
-0.0577821657,
-0.0166005325,
0.0417315513,
0.0152057642,
-0.0834333748,
-0.0158947371,
0.0735502243,
0.0230183043,
-0.0245325994,
-0.0505076088,
0.0122567229,
-0.0045354874,
-0.0575769916,
0.0024967524,
-0.0329964124,
0.0053820619,
-0.049337171,
0.0693125725,
0.0005529391,
0.0191018675,
-0.0105238594,
0.0321623906,
0.0097887442,
0.0102383262,
0.0151407113,
-0.0369598381,
0.0252228677,
-0.0231071282,
-0.0387218148,
-0.0384686738,
0.0294333417,
0.0095944004,
-0.0372665077,
0.0111344075,
-0.0086975135,
-0.0394518599,
0.0555490218,
-0.0558729395,
-0.0469312407,
0.0024874976,
-0.0024026632,
-0.0297260694,
-0.0093605062,
-0.0102593945,
0.0356649309,
-0.0266398042,
-0.0169063192,
-0.0454056598,
-0.0088409372,
-0.0243023559,
0.0074118073,
0.0226120297,
-0.0130085414,
0.0156609751,
-0.0846751928,
-0.0024301328,
-0.0167458188,
-0.0258235279,
-0.0149056735,
0.0050747897,
-0.0134746833,
-0.0184681304,
0.0108276037,
-0.0021931736,
-0.0657070652,
0.0224508867,
-0.0301624499,
-0.0367588326,
0.0345095135,
-0.0043362863,
0.0300323274,
-0.0165932197,
0.0037235902,
-0.017929133,
-0.0101369796,
-0.0628955141,
-0.0580652133,
0.0037839229,
-0.0209926926,
-0.0456033051,
-0.0696518645,
-0.0411171839,
-0.017168643,
0.0227019992,
0.0207868405,
-0.0324925184,
0.0261041727,
0.040802177,
-0.029824283,
0.0734484643,
-0.008347353,
-0.0403948948,
0.0484626256,
0.0163972266,
0.0551698506,
0.0170912128,
0.0185067654,
0.0447169505,
0.0834418461,
-0.0072659198,
0.0294326339,
0.0228210259,
-0.021811828,
-0.0299055297,
-0.0837946683,
0.0077056061,
-0.0623498634,
0.0026462595,
0.0002850186,
0.0353083462,
0.0190266389,
0.0143245794,
0.0045179408,
0.0453954302,
0.0435467809,
0.0195100717,
-0.0136823989,
0.030213723,
-0.0205570944,
-0.0059727412,
0.0196800996,
-0.0319122337,
-0.0852866247,
-0.005120487,
0.0236935411,
-0.0031750896,
-0.0047739591,
-0.0261181276,
-0.0112130558,
-0.0226546247,
0.0023942969,
-0.0303037576,
0.0749876574,
0.0127878552,
-0.0411365964,
-0.0578734726,
0.0488712192,
-0.08742854,
0.0408040583,
-0.013820135,
0.04808053,
0.0568165258,
0.0660054237,
-0.054717958,
0.0285201613,
0.0131060677,
0.0116115063,
0.0248824116,
0.0080956137,
-0.0136403032,
-0.0739376992,
-0.0545411743,
-0.0038557374,
0.0718341768,
-0.0072418377,
-0.025488317,
0.0196103062,
0.0604998395,
0.006890832,
0.0106322709,
-0.0282082316,
0.0298272539,
0.0514339358,
-0.0064244727,
0.0112350062,
0.0004266847,
0.0358713381,
0.0060077575,
-0.0287000407,
-0.0130906673,
0.0293475091,
0.0237545315,
-0.0331470147,
0.0186585523,
0.0697153881,
0.007747109,
-0.0242416114,
-0.0454069078,
0.0233528111,
0.0604878403,
0.023888493,
-0.0325253196,
0.0170804411,
-0.0033504909,
0.0423148423,
-0.0613326095,
0.0446632318,
-0.0192288961,
0.0280188043,
-0.0472865179,
0.0579623766,
0.0173299778,
0.0343125165,
-0.0285347328,
-0.0443843454,
0.0289474148,
-0.0562194958,
-0.0380522832,
0.0529505312,
0.0127708735,
0.0164677594,
0.0614070334,
0.0243472047,
-0.0386198424,
-0.0561412498,
-0.1695822328,
0.0065096659,
0.0068375664,
0.0194814615,
-0.0443664677,
0.0563264936,
-0.0191755481,
0.0085599348,
0.0414680168,
0.0025623399,
0.0865377262,
0.0027919998,
0.0715625733,
-0.0218695216,
0.0000259265,
-0.0295858625,
-0.0250163916,
-0.0073889396,
0.0491015799,
-0.0004944339,
-0.0912555605,
0.0308715291,
0.0161980987,
-0.0253330469,
0.0288060121,
0.0066376789,
-0.0363770835,
-0.0153496731,
-0.001578066,
-0.0018439817,
0.0196749475,
0.0321183093,
0.0405666903,
-0.0176607855,
-0.0163758714,
-0.0224987809,
-0.0119673377,
0.0040747449,
0.0563491471,
0.0137383128,
-0.0188502707,
0.0453792773,
0.020721592,
-0.0097606443,
-0.002451448,
-0.0176747367,
-0.0233815052,
-0.0453936905,
0.0146965813,
-0.0229366366,
0.014980915,
-0.0467140637,
0.0362524278,
0.0084247766,
-0.0594485551,
0.0197570287,
-0.0209767967,
0.0117822038,
-0.1071276888,
0.0040892968,
-0.0583809316,
0.0110360915,
-0.0535469279,
0.0139756985,
0.007492159,
-0.0285819527,
-0.0058516948,
0.0235903952,
-0.017486088,
-0.0281600561,
-0.0007836313,
-0.0566845238,
0.0020979268,
-0.0215989053,
-0.003114016,
-0.0038545104,
-0.0777140781,
-0.0089298105,
-0.0199863315,
0.0470244475,
-0.0068018795,
-0.0140432566,
0.0439051837,
-0.0178271029,
-0.0329510346,
-0.0165645462,
-0.0015909267,
0.0416524261,
0.0195107441,
0.0587171279,
-0.010227629,
-0.0066339029,
0.0378964022,
0.0105446875,
0.0258247759,
0.0446989052,
-0.0182686877,
0.0560453385,
0.0014499334,
0.0127369566,
-0.0712518096,
-0.0311748087,
-0.0392255075,
0.012871475,
0.0238962043,
-0.0238667149,
0.0974118188,
0.0596728809,
-0.0279049128,
-0.0261710081,
0.0142530873,
-0.0248565935,
-0.0058370088,
0.0161024574,
-0.0294341706,
-0.0190371461,
0.026554741,
-0.0082020555,
-0.0266582631,
-0.0114773046,
0.0046994723,
-0.0899127945,
0.0003938941,
-0.017526919,
-0.0174119081,
0.0072632204,
-0.001151774,
-0.042716343,
0.0103353653,
-0.0376800075,
0.003658649,
-0.0463512652,
0.0123817809,
0.0413953178,
-0.0066182958,
-0.0008293614,
0.0024105723,
0.0043940814,
-0.0113267368,
0.0510055795,
0.0424421094,
-0.0528523326,
-0.0438187644,
0.0334708244,
-0.0631759167,
-0.0494062975,
-0.0476296805,
0.0500801802,
-0.0220185574,
-0.0128845489,
-0.0057725357,
0.0251648724,
-0.0003647978,
-0.0021302651,
0.0155920116,
0.0293114129,
0.0164495036,
-0.0272656959,
-0.0277631152,
0.0241097547,
-0.0065458152,
0.0036987858,
-0.0217979085,
-0.0586035922,
-0.0225678086,
0.0008217947,
-0.0269482359,
-0.0451405384,
-0.0273568854,
-0.0340423808,
-0.0084960172,
-0.0273683742,
-0.0514858104,
-0.0779025033,
0.0652189776,
0.0580857918,
0.0212838575,
0.0487277023,
-0.0482889973,
0.0333358236,
-0.0367289782,
-0.0241325777,
0.0009380659,
0.0246587358,
-0.0833846927,
0.0075955987,
0.0035239458,
-0.0114627788,
-0.0267356578,
-0.0592010617,
0.033878807,
-0.0161746424,
0.0208632052,
0.0014902564,
0.0253799763,
-0.0448033512,
-0.0362538546,
-0.0777413324,
0.036839243,
-0.0007073923,
-0.0443635173,
-0.0245953538,
0.0099640032,
0.0125606442,
-0.0085563501,
0.0259239338,
-0.0341468342,
0.0190397743,
-0.0296209268,
-0.00604562,
0.0068790028,
0.0073380028,
0.0166226216,
0.0062763887,
0.0304422118,
-0.0483256653,
-0.0129823638,
-0.0483311787,
0.0027953524,
0.0229540449,
-0.0282592829,
0.0019120718,
0.0146045713,
0.034477625,
0.0208023731,
-0.04961472,
0.0425442718,
-0.0519995764,
-0.0050661904,
-0.0002752521,
0.0557405539,
0.0806363449,
0.0936840922,
-0.0041041011,
0.0049015498,
0.0129441265,
-0.0328912362,
0.0024852655,
0.0101777501,
-0.0168396495,
0.0319562033,
0.0056843259,
0.0208270401,
0.000954047,
0.0387060642,
0.0253132824,
0.0607215054,
-0.0491101816,
0.0565383881,
0.0121135795,
-0.0177461337,
0.0007730096,
-0.0159624051,
-0.0055751386,
-0.0215364173,
0.0035158636,
0.0069786878,
0.0271324981,
0.0152334012,
0.0049385182,
-0.046723485,
-0.0054193274,
0.0278638359,
0.0099239014,
-0.0081203254,
0.0350598171,
-0.0707269311,
-0.0369266421,
0.0115969973,
-0.0028681532,
0.0389895476,
0.0288547594,
0.0028492168,
-0.0951763242,
-0.0004085357,
0.04408741,
-0.0374467634,
0.0451817773,
-0.0239910036,
0.0049875644,
0.050597731,
0.0197870936,
0.0500167795,
-0.0654791892,
0.0114921462,
-0.0118182749,
-0.0525597408,
0.0156523865,
-5.078701302e-33,
0.0182441492,
-0.0203833058,
-0.0129477372,
0.0196047314,
-0.0041780784,
-0.011909877,
-0.0056930226,
0.0007923481,
0.0161024053,
0.0336692892,
-0.037762586,
0.0031585735,
0.0319548883,
-0.0185400583,
0.0384323671,
0.0362171084,
0.0107515985,
0.0251856297,
-0.0205447115,
0.0011617267,
0.0753625184,
0.0581449419,
0.0414479636,
-0.00094966,
0.0465960242,
-0.0399172567,
-0.0386607684,
0.0085042473,
0.0254770312,
0.0461265966,
-0.0428462438,
0.0266173538,
0.026020132,
0.0152341714,
0.01462927,
0.0407338813,
-0.0517785139,
-0.0016869854,
-0.000438367,
0.0476530865,
0.0113488184,
-0.0051368205,
0.0141276475,
-0.0160243493,
-0.029217897,
0.0653292835,
0.0478278436,
0.0080942698,
-0.0498001873,
-0.0548317097,
-0.086444132,
0.0515991338,
0.0228517167,
-0.0011294454,
0.0408304557,
0.013306981,
0.0126883127,
0.045506116,
0.0250890348,
-0.0147049362,
0.0379421823,
0.0409786776,
0.0182373449,
-0.039378304,
-0.0543971397,
0.0244036485,
0.0006683398,
-0.0692823082,
0.0688243732,
0.0170054715,
0.0228429623,
0.0280986,
-0.0059498707,
0.0417902991,
0.0527914874,
-0.1060188338,
-0.0117325094,
0.0343659632,
-0.0056530866,
0.0596351624,
-0.0025825088,
-0.011895977,
-0.0682801902,
-0.0228355434,
0.0714481771,
-0.0253925677,
-0.0370159261,
0.0036518271,
0.0560016632,
-0.0012684836,
-0.0542776249,
0.0180750601,
-0.0034921868,
-0.0113729378,
0.0033062908,
0.0183566678,
-0.0163770467,
0.011554148,
0.0137696462,
-0.0213048216,
-0.0274302252,
-0.0374054797,
-0.031148959,
0.0254135802,
-0.0157324579,
-0.0526677594,
0.033144474,
-0.0196732767,
-0.0729085654,
0.0122076264,
-0.0130507192,
0.0674618781,
-0.0142495707,
0.0765204877,
-0.0420294032,
-0.0062733321,
-0.004640894,
-0.0292830542,
0.0286394861,
0.0042847479,
-0.0486487783,
-0.0006326855,
0.0049383203,
-0.04172967,
-0.0050946143,
-0.0001155445,
0.0073471521,
0.067732133,
0.0012878769,
-0.0110136941,
0.0151795177,
0.0198288746,
2.37e-7,
0.0115720201,
0.0635644197,
0.042984765,
-0.0666004941,
-0.0159206036,
0.0119924759,
-0.0452423804,
0.0079350537,
-0.0268724039,
0.0881828144,
0.028369341,
-0.0423872955,
0.0359225795,
0.0440896712,
-0.1142635271,
-0.043417573,
-0.0338583365,
-0.0092871226,
-0.0241765846,
-0.0241643097,
-0.0050866315,
0.064112097,
0.0219264869,
-0.0239938274,
-0.0220867079,
-0.0323034897,
0.0309981834,
-0.0061684945,
0.0136807235,
0.0233438909,
0.0321677476,
-0.0688307658,
-0.0205079596,
-0.0423495695,
-0.0073025413,
0.0333051011,
0.0510522164,
0.0628677532,
-0.0127247432,
0.0052429251,
0.0251972955,
0.0100767603,
0.0162722953,
-0.033012487,
0.0485525429,
0.0745481178,
0.0205546282,
0.0312968865,
0.0053512091,
-0.0408682488,
0.0443323478,
-0.0245992579,
-0.0448953845,
0.0208171755,
0.0205431134,
-0.0196052622,
-0.0363158919,
-0.0693982616,
0.0123773413,
-0.0006887053,
-0.0112591218,
-0.0270953774,
-0.0027669393,
0.0198997911,
0.0194147024,
0.0052306433,
0.0176580176,
1.910901639e-34,
0.062241137,
0.0260328632,
-0.0122684026,
-0.0141019858,
0.0295717232,
-0.0051635508,
0.0216356367,
0.0308146663,
0.0226830989,
-0.025029216,
0.0077554421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11028v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11028v1 | Universal Cross-Lingual Text Classification | 2024-06-16T17:58:29 | 2024-06-16T17:58:29 | Riya Savant, Anushka Shelke, Sakshi Todmal, Sanskruti Kanphade, Ananya Joshi, Raviraj Joshi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Text classification, an integral task in natural language processing,
involves the automatic categorization of text into predefined classes. Creating
supervised labeled datasets for low-resource languages poses a considerable
challenge. Unlocking the language potential of low-resource languages requires
robust datasets with supervised labels. However, such datasets are scarce, and
the label space is often limited. In our pursuit to address this gap, we aim to
optimize existing labels/datasets in different languages. This research
proposes a novel perspective on Universal Cross-Lingual Text Classification,
leveraging a unified model across languages. Our approach involves blending
supervised data from different languages during training to create a universal
model. The supervised data for a target classification task might come from
different languages covering different labels. The primary goal is to enhance
label and language coverage, aiming for a label set that represents a union of
labels from various languages. We propose the usage of a strong multilingual
SBERT as our base model, making our novel training strategy feasible. This
strategy contributes to the adaptability and effectiveness of the model in
cross-lingual language transfer scenarios, where it can categorize text in
languages not encountered during training. Thus, the paper delves into the
intricacies of cross-lingual text classification, with a particular focus on
its application for low-resource languages, exploring methodologies and
implications for the development of a robust and adaptable universal
cross-lingual model. | [
-0.0002989751,
0.0117582893,
-0.0084475381,
0.0320040807,
-0.0226574149,
0.0429501422,
0.0401718877,
-0.0061647543,
0.0519694015,
-0.0508043282,
-0.0358314365,
-0.0337411501,
-0.0092203841,
-0.009810132,
0.0033063982,
-0.0462100431,
0.052771382,
-0.0194948409,
-0.0294009317,
-0.0280905012,
-0.018171357,
0.0233830716,
0.0355594605,
-0.0166452769,
-0.0146157527,
0.0111350287,
0.0239959583,
-0.0164059922,
0.0213948674,
0.005875234,
0.0300853606,
0.0270989928,
0.0202144682,
0.0384342857,
0.0000018136,
-0.0444009453,
-0.0282499883,
-0.0081170769,
0.0335038975,
-0.0276819058,
0.0611756146,
-0.040438816,
-0.0089692436,
0.0173585098,
0.0140973981,
-0.0360324755,
0.0805661157,
0.0515520386,
0.0348573923,
0.0544658713,
-0.0216569975,
-0.0398878306,
0.0156474579,
-0.0166079327,
0.0389268361,
-0.0418595225,
0.042303931,
0.0056350413,
-0.0161614399,
0.0297883097,
-0.0047721737,
0.0298347045,
0.0106634293,
0.0231501162,
-0.0061473241,
0.0025347669,
-0.0475313291,
-0.0187008902,
0.0034219006,
0.0270190164,
-0.0532270521,
-0.0613628551,
-0.018582575,
0.0008944464,
-0.005237421,
-0.0117622679,
-0.0303304587,
0.0142571786,
-0.0226627979,
0.0213050507,
0.0668908805,
0.032970041,
0.0312101524,
0.007512012,
-0.0145415924,
0.0271512996,
0.015584561,
-0.0193920434,
0.0339548104,
0.0347076468,
0.0218578093,
-0.0308082793,
-0.00620822,
0.0012511181,
0.019673394,
0.0101788491,
-0.0391977727,
-0.0448109657,
0.0255416185,
-0.0359524526,
-0.0297002327,
0.0017649271,
-0.0488266386,
0.0557379201,
-0.0427734479,
-0.0074382415,
-0.0091711683,
0.000583197,
-0.0168229844,
-0.051397752,
-0.0916184187,
-0.0021367203,
-0.0384397879,
0.0010990768,
-0.0070091779,
0.0402338803,
-0.0548725165,
0.0129112108,
-0.0003128841,
-0.0333773829,
0.0204048418,
-0.0488884076,
-0.0266588721,
0.0106047839,
-0.0059855371,
0.0379571803,
-0.0080557475,
0.0124939987,
-0.0535243116,
-0.0301758125,
0.0343981944,
0.0230913479,
-0.0098349499,
-0.0604864843,
0.0534860268,
0.0585494451,
-0.0372851044,
-0.0468103439,
-0.091028221,
0.0182679277,
-0.0270098206,
-0.0532759354,
0.003547309,
-0.0744212195,
0.0464329533,
0.0126115205,
0.0350150131,
-0.0088065313,
-0.0046004388,
-0.00429053,
-0.039590206,
0.0793684125,
-0.0156128025,
-0.008219908,
0.0567838773,
-0.0149907488,
0.0182397999,
0.069276616,
-0.020489268,
0.0014888727,
0.0816408023,
-0.0109974453,
-0.0086002573,
0.0468829125,
-0.0015940814,
0.029354021,
-0.0039119902,
0.0017083932,
0.0524064228,
-0.0498960353,
-0.0083524203,
-0.0260518473,
-0.0015705241,
0.0192848835,
0.0508910492,
0.0006685808,
0.0130183036,
0.061536029,
0.0176070593,
-0.0166733041,
-0.0420340635,
-0.0278891325,
0.0253791958,
-0.0030688725,
-0.0211169589,
-0.0058996361,
0.017661659,
0.050494425,
-0.0566100962,
-0.0441940203,
-0.0155987181,
-0.0402718745,
0.0007702871,
0.0127641018,
0.090477936,
0.0245977379,
0.0014432844,
0.059883859,
0.077759333,
-0.0698434785,
0.0214382783,
-0.0000975188,
0.0136744604,
-0.0160352811,
-0.0185615662,
-0.0553388856,
0.0481576584,
-0.010788898,
0.077369526,
0.0001451337,
0.0544644222,
-0.0213372596,
0.0258368701,
-0.0371929221,
-0.0233653989,
0.0010455474,
0.0184604824,
0.0664314106,
-0.0294647142,
0.0513997152,
0.0046161059,
-0.0422783941,
-0.0554718189,
0.0264664479,
-0.0379330888,
-0.0198650043,
0.0405967832,
0.0306003075,
0.0151418131,
0.011825446,
-0.0235888138,
-0.0374618247,
0.027411988,
-0.0634724498,
-0.0221547354,
-0.0203487873,
0.0278644357,
-0.0332758687,
0.015671039,
-0.0450096242,
-0.0056740232,
0.016257694,
-0.0179441385,
-0.0425027497,
0.0032376063,
0.0015847498,
0.0024144449,
-0.0416218936,
0.0192062948,
-0.0305813365,
0.0093943831,
-0.0207750816,
0.0847048834,
0.0596035831,
0.0440298095,
-0.0236814804,
-0.0518282764,
0.0847824588,
-0.0202163029,
-0.0465810411,
0.0633258596,
-0.018533852,
0.014520824,
0.0591497384,
0.0449326672,
0.0078585446,
-0.0234433133,
-0.0941930488,
0.0001248878,
-0.0222920105,
0.0101409657,
-0.0091322018,
0.0267208107,
0.0056517972,
-0.0194319263,
-0.0611821339,
0.0006059411,
0.0025143004,
0.0410877727,
0.0084596332,
-0.0182524212,
0.0225996021,
0.0256978832,
-0.0002125513,
0.0304392204,
0.0495003276,
-0.0070680529,
-0.0492844172,
-0.0515933707,
0.0295905992,
-0.0528702997,
0.0238781422,
-0.014091081,
-0.0278515089,
-0.0366736762,
0.0195639506,
-0.0198249612,
0.0182400886,
-0.0227139872,
-0.0434829183,
0.0694479346,
0.0132146804,
-0.0088145304,
0.0331172645,
-0.0228123553,
-0.0078211399,
-0.0285884235,
-0.036359109,
0.0024835833,
0.0709727481,
-0.0188362151,
-0.0364144258,
-0.0535805747,
-0.0461302325,
-0.0411395729,
0.0120840957,
-0.0639130324,
0.030584598,
0.0206168368,
0.0672670454,
-0.0092211086,
-0.0242676716,
0.0488707721,
-0.0201010928,
-0.0019058824,
-0.0717749819,
-0.044118382,
-0.0793738738,
0.0315488577,
-0.0116259642,
0.0488799997,
-0.0124872969,
0.0112715755,
-0.0460831337,
-0.0097961668,
0.0254033767,
-0.0024225765,
-0.0088963788,
-0.0122544682,
0.0054607671,
-0.0260015819,
-0.0476855449,
-0.0083824098,
-0.0042925798,
-0.0119935963,
-0.0008288547,
-0.0185764451,
0.0165214799,
-0.064926967,
0.0184881687,
0.0328235812,
0.0524678975,
-0.0144105125,
-0.0074422816,
0.0069182054,
0.0268909894,
-0.0014860004,
-0.0667273104,
-0.0502983741,
-0.0150383795,
-0.0009107576,
-0.0036121712,
0.0090722023,
-0.0057615475,
0.0278514419,
0.0234852042,
0.0559388436,
0.0048801964,
-0.0428133421,
-0.0401131995,
0.0133629134,
-0.0008734231,
-0.014915565,
0.0520740636,
0.0136146769,
-0.0451974347,
-0.0420496464,
-0.0431480035,
0.0253330115,
0.0316410325,
0.0341644138,
-0.0559430122,
-0.0228631962,
-0.0126272067,
-0.0024875335,
0.0036553114,
0.0170184411,
-0.0085884975,
-0.0972621515,
0.0020859689,
0.0339739621,
-0.102364637,
-0.0284598917,
-0.0650945678,
-0.0119299721,
-0.049593661,
0.0037783093,
-0.0654192641,
0.0123486621,
-0.0248542111,
0.019722674,
-0.013095798,
-0.0450105444,
0.0184579771,
-0.0185206719,
-0.0089276955,
0.012134498,
0.0621257983,
-0.0345094204,
-0.011928793,
0.0586447194,
-0.0471962839,
-0.0452715792,
-0.0270848665,
0.0454621278,
0.000247465,
-0.0203819741,
0.0437638797,
-0.0162143372,
-0.0375830159,
-0.0074273851,
0.0365022048,
0.0975182801,
0.0503124259,
0.0010830716,
-0.0007075532,
-0.0355730765,
0.0397506617,
0.0559416041,
-0.0279919934,
-0.05869231,
-0.0036637068,
0.0042978674,
-0.0204973668,
-0.0229087826,
-0.0356969498,
0.0669808984,
-0.0896971151,
-0.10884431,
-0.0338765532,
-0.0479412004,
0.0033141833,
0.0110347029,
0.0341066159,
0.0307092257,
-0.0177022777,
0.0069883117,
-0.0234733429,
0.0269612893,
-0.0204388984,
0.0252469052,
-0.0313768722,
-0.0077887564,
0.0140453465,
-0.0708626434,
0.0033656368,
-0.0176504236,
-0.022070501,
-0.0558880419,
-0.011799952,
0.0116338227,
0.017835388,
0.0337681323,
-0.0004776555,
-0.0692808628,
0.0755565315,
0.0396741889,
-0.0156168016,
-0.019302588,
0.0589657426,
-0.0062429071,
-0.0088554779,
0.032688126,
-0.0698187724,
0.0352880172,
0.0202713385,
-0.0181952063,
-0.042609293,
-0.0116071114,
0.0102813439,
-0.0123250363,
0.0210236516,
-0.048358649,
-0.0501392372,
-0.0546392016,
0.0265070442,
0.0100666294,
-0.0374285132,
-0.016257545,
0.0145677635,
0.0562295131,
-0.00722874,
-0.00613948,
0.0406204276,
-0.0083036907,
0.024141388,
0.0020986577,
-0.0121150455,
0.0388758369,
0.0807156563,
-0.0104758237,
0.0384052098,
-0.0038347449,
-0.0237117913,
0.0054533402,
0.0109501639,
-0.0365243107,
0.0218755454,
-0.0012564815,
0.0190958492,
0.0035285745,
-0.0031623659,
-0.0371548198,
-0.0021576649,
0.0014350654,
-0.0017462835,
0.0607900135,
-0.0413139686,
0.0512942895,
-0.0210485291,
-0.0470541231,
-0.0216504522,
0.024670573,
0.0200844221,
-0.0253472961,
0.0064058015,
-0.0038986311,
-0.02840757,
0.0144869257,
0.0633273125,
0.0264943317,
0.0110323168,
0.0116988402,
-0.0215332936,
-0.0128699699,
0.0253150929,
0.0582407266,
0.0046412703,
-0.0174968876,
-0.014850039,
-0.0300331023,
-0.0627052933,
0.0400300883,
-0.0215236638,
-0.0204445459,
0.0215093866,
0.0005069736,
0.0973354802,
0.018432226,
0.032363005,
-0.0547463931,
0.0053873197,
0.0183242727,
0.0209993757,
-0.0023223308,
-5.4046736e-33,
0.0129820993,
0.0110957483,
-0.0150336754,
0.0104225026,
0.0293492079,
0.0022542235,
0.0202256162,
-0.0032560015,
0.0014675257,
0.0095050689,
0.008630964,
-0.0014077366,
0.0270805992,
0.0340198092,
0.0067326338,
0.0071412986,
0.0172798634,
0.0154100433,
-0.0108937491,
0.032005541,
0.0507385172,
0.0143577494,
0.0844147801,
-0.1002488881,
0.0601451583,
0.000233062,
0.0123508992,
0.02038428,
0.0656864792,
0.0520141572,
-0.0165700261,
0.0752177089,
0.0405709334,
0.0008978567,
0.0352889858,
0.0389184318,
-0.0626535267,
-0.0476329029,
-0.0011501051,
0.0452021211,
0.0081340317,
-0.0352802835,
-0.0346546546,
-0.026089333,
0.0401025154,
-0.0110899899,
0.0733077899,
-0.0309314243,
-0.0216971524,
-0.0474014245,
-0.0398293212,
0.0250856113,
0.0228158645,
-0.006153692,
0.0538071692,
0.0832526833,
0.0316540487,
0.0138938595,
-0.038301643,
0.0331723653,
-0.0393747762,
0.017335318,
0.0411554426,
-0.0040232106,
-0.0236302353,
0.0190750659,
0.0230527613,
0.0251910929,
0.0526471809,
-0.0190043207,
0.0111113666,
-0.0070119086,
0.0363769792,
0.118762739,
0.0245351773,
-0.040450681,
-0.0996599868,
0.0337055698,
0.0332128592,
-0.0259376802,
-0.0035355603,
-0.0005273436,
-0.0078404788,
-0.0315166153,
-0.0407078974,
-0.061162699,
-0.0300564189,
0.0010991165,
-0.0067418101,
0.0164403766,
-0.0102091236,
0.0036593203,
0.0280940086,
-0.0184598584,
-0.0746471137,
0.0231042057,
-0.0027358937,
0.0043848902,
0.0066792034,
0.0251137614,
-0.0278072245,
-0.0723132491,
-0.0132956225,
0.0020873598,
0.0211495832,
-0.0156669635,
0.1016765162,
0.0212993678,
-0.0619522259,
0.0160540044,
-0.0232339613,
0.0089502633,
0.0105470456,
0.0853391215,
0.0020133064,
0.0258500185,
0.012598143,
0.0498657674,
0.0516151451,
-0.0230542962,
-0.0035428682,
-0.0418762453,
-0.0204599779,
0.0274615344,
-0.0124059068,
-0.0269587003,
-0.0207268819,
0.004634128,
0.0433545969,
-0.0434414297,
-0.0000966191,
-0.0234591514,
2.547e-7,
0.0414628796,
-0.002255101,
-0.0416125506,
-0.018429745,
0.0036298234,
0.0472921841,
-0.045419544,
0.0448558964,
-0.0230250079,
-0.0178562198,
-0.0057406644,
-0.0109584453,
0.0706956983,
0.0477167033,
-0.0781318247,
-0.0176929384,
-0.0139589403,
0.0115061989,
-0.0414918251,
0.0150277549,
0.0410588123,
0.1013126522,
0.0088164927,
-0.0382026546,
-0.0498429351,
-0.048949562,
0.0868480802,
-0.0432199128,
-0.028587807,
0.0050750114,
-0.0041486099,
0.0338135883,
-0.0276053715,
0.0249613356,
-0.0441229567,
0.0205938332,
0.0407291912,
0.0237736255,
-0.0138788158,
0.0019504939,
0.0258881394,
0.0128332963,
-0.0537126847,
-0.0302104764,
0.06980405,
-0.0391894281,
-0.0024559479,
0.0116335377,
0.0086781038,
0.0090385182,
0.0847777948,
-0.0033727989,
-0.0404610783,
0.0397090837,
0.0290197432,
-0.0071167056,
-0.0377153121,
-0.0555375926,
-0.0061032949,
0.035264466,
-0.0173378121,
0.0110067846,
0.0014923681,
0.0390289314,
0.0305642318,
-0.0580021553,
0.0687335432,
2.012388931e-34,
0.0141545488,
-0.0184207931,
-0.0142357508,
-0.0451278351,
-0.0010998005,
-0.0582387485,
-0.0170102082,
0.0199664216,
-0.0162410922,
0.0089153331,
0.0141638452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11025v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11025v1 | Large Language Models for Dysfluency Detection in Stuttered Speech | 2024-06-16T17:51:22 | 2024-06-16T17:51:22 | Dominik Wagner, Sebastian P. Bayerl, Ilja Baumann, Korbinian Riedhammer, Elmar Nöth, Tobias Bocklet | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Accurately detecting dysfluencies in spoken language can help to improve the
performance of automatic speech and language processing components and support
the development of more inclusive speech and language technologies. Inspired by
the recent trend towards the deployment of large language models (LLMs) as
universal learners and processors of non-lexical inputs, such as audio and
video, we approach the task of multi-label dysfluency detection as a language
modeling problem. We present hypotheses candidates generated with an automatic
speech recognition system and acoustic representations extracted from an audio
encoder model to an LLM, and finetune the system to predict dysfluency labels
on three datasets containing English and German stuttered speech. The
experimental results show that our system effectively combines acoustic and
lexical information and achieves competitive results on the multi-label
stuttering detection task. | [
0.0064585474,
0.0469005927,
-0.0339795351,
0.0487688631,
0.0021354968,
0.0123988176,
0.0141212773,
-0.0034553073,
-0.0247947183,
-0.0632653907,
0.0180839673,
-0.0664015859,
0.0073462003,
0.0207140725,
0.0186022446,
-0.0674112588,
0.0432954133,
-0.0952792466,
0.055132173,
-0.0323727913,
0.0209587086,
-0.0007342251,
-0.0261742789,
0.0246814173,
-0.049051702,
0.0160330981,
0.0078791715,
0.0466061123,
-0.0044970564,
-0.0114420606,
0.0078351237,
0.0405510925,
0.007433197,
0.0136932591,
0.000002029,
-0.0193636157,
-0.0003451205,
-0.0433029607,
0.0152447941,
0.0114914514,
0.0638706908,
0.0177984815,
-0.0435860269,
0.0196459945,
-0.0001187868,
0.0176253468,
0.0412807986,
-0.0015204928,
0.0131699769,
0.0294761453,
-0.0051781144,
-0.0608628951,
0.0233791806,
0.0249625649,
-0.0093865236,
-0.0289875939,
0.0223263092,
-0.009309439,
0.0556243882,
-0.0445340015,
-0.0337164849,
0.0666729063,
-0.0188211687,
-0.0052919197,
-0.0008257002,
-0.0291912202,
-0.0937995315,
-0.0485043265,
-0.0120674958,
0.0642924011,
-0.0644279346,
-0.0046518878,
0.022637438,
0.0006943306,
0.0061033801,
0.0026823592,
0.0184277762,
-0.0381171294,
0.031095231,
-0.003268203,
0.0320980512,
0.0090324627,
0.0225135889,
0.0102028782,
-0.024139449,
0.0607233793,
0.0141544808,
-0.0345421769,
-0.0199825354,
-0.0008540308,
-0.0165399108,
-0.012125928,
0.0450404249,
0.0036396196,
-0.0556026213,
0.0076726163,
-0.0242005698,
-0.0811513513,
-0.0022228262,
-0.0105284471,
-0.0325531512,
0.0141348746,
-0.0775883496,
0.0031326669,
-0.0207781456,
0.0735782981,
-0.0097157955,
0.0054938076,
-0.0296390783,
0.0031781185,
-0.0113096498,
0.0186966807,
-0.0476206355,
0.0204883367,
0.0086713303,
0.0040703323,
-0.0580484495,
-0.0072476738,
-0.0293948967,
-0.0188640542,
-0.0363892056,
-0.0101034809,
-0.0135511803,
-0.0028072018,
-0.0332275294,
0.0564955622,
0.0186990555,
0.0371100418,
-0.0035976092,
-0.0671358481,
0.0220058411,
-0.0016039897,
0.0176112317,
-0.0117430538,
0.0494764298,
0.0440713167,
0.0271531828,
-0.0518251918,
-0.0428154729,
-0.0188643187,
-0.0698954016,
-0.017265236,
-0.0497471057,
-0.0776926503,
-0.0110218646,
0.0258859657,
0.035559807,
-0.0607937723,
-0.0081122629,
-0.0216431469,
0.0125465281,
0.0826580003,
-0.067483522,
0.0558212213,
0.056145139,
-0.0027815765,
0.0166183636,
0.0725857913,
0.0328546166,
-0.0426678061,
0.0505513214,
-0.0118563706,
0.0625964776,
0.0678833649,
-0.0086845411,
0.0204390008,
-0.0601103157,
-0.0704849809,
0.0042348714,
-0.0119735571,
0.0606608167,
0.0520025231,
0.0092439465,
-0.010732186,
0.0558840334,
0.0451289639,
0.0166336987,
-0.0271926727,
0.0137122506,
0.0322985202,
-0.0258252937,
0.0173525251,
0.0316634513,
-0.0215375908,
0.0141925672,
0.0233772192,
0.0600121319,
0.0653120205,
-0.0320222005,
-0.0006480285,
-0.0025240169,
-0.0477297604,
0.0051421444,
0.0262912959,
0.0452599488,
-0.0104781333,
-0.0205625892,
0.0704704225,
0.0387278832,
-0.0097864792,
0.0445645154,
-0.0444981754,
-0.0494872741,
0.0959413052,
0.0329395905,
-0.023767991,
0.0157697741,
-0.0663940161,
-0.0037272577,
0.0187379234,
0.0068474542,
-0.0011158825,
0.0188131779,
-0.0636379793,
-0.0092448816,
0.0553308874,
0.0143997762,
0.017452985,
-0.0433851629,
0.0538789816,
0.0221112892,
-0.0202391203,
-0.0230577327,
-0.0077443495,
-0.0068497816,
0.0048421049,
0.0036016095,
0.0091804862,
0.0581398532,
0.0272802487,
-0.0360928401,
-0.0105902469,
0.0079354616,
-0.0191315319,
-0.0090954946,
0.0005117593,
-0.0473025851,
-0.0145922769,
0.0661922693,
0.0278627686,
-0.0008315248,
0.0147911767,
-0.0055893497,
-0.0855676383,
-0.00961826,
-0.0581668653,
-0.002932654,
-0.0431424715,
0.0682878345,
-0.0167648122,
0.0461119227,
0.0057928101,
0.0057374765,
0.0055650715,
0.0216437597,
0.0180562716,
-0.0049050534,
-0.0239646118,
-0.0807486549,
-0.06209426,
0.0416638814,
-0.0336751901,
0.0395289101,
-0.0185804404,
-0.0339653343,
-0.0225490108,
-0.0417231657,
-0.0095401565,
-0.026119655,
-0.035507299,
-0.0242398754,
-0.0516373999,
0.0025173214,
-0.0183617249,
-0.0436914489,
-0.0084201666,
-0.0392113626,
0.0391952246,
0.0101918411,
-0.0215620622,
0.019936353,
-0.0968007743,
-0.0061937138,
0.0108756023,
0.0217803624,
-0.025925722,
-0.0155143011,
-0.0818212181,
-0.0558338277,
0.0197484922,
-0.0139406202,
0.0378334969,
0.0268546809,
-0.0433669239,
-0.0232196841,
0.0104387924,
0.0383175276,
-0.005826816,
0.0153604671,
-0.0053741573,
0.0256166533,
-0.0596165843,
-0.0055114361,
-0.0027838489,
-0.0016979974,
0.0389353037,
-0.0448719487,
0.0170629881,
-0.0473774932,
0.0307404976,
0.005284817,
0.0229284428,
-0.0299048256,
-0.0371707194,
-0.0461623371,
-0.0009495183,
-0.0175402835,
-0.0690624192,
-0.0337881111,
0.0461380631,
0.0203925725,
-0.0429084115,
0.0677288547,
-0.05393143,
-0.0357483216,
-0.0123647805,
-0.0449449345,
0.0026972413,
-0.0228803903,
-0.0283164121,
0.0192122739,
-0.0177467316,
-0.0613766052,
-0.0252368711,
0.001877922,
-0.003288741,
-0.0709485784,
0.0078584719,
-0.0402915627,
0.0028553379,
0.0211434569,
-0.0576971769,
-0.0225317124,
-0.0266364887,
-0.0483188629,
0.0021096049,
0.0136512537,
-0.0072069941,
-0.0381984822,
0.0440836847,
-0.0437933877,
0.0486826934,
0.0077145454,
0.0325670317,
-0.0097680138,
0.0467833951,
0.0388875045,
0.0160477795,
-0.014074116,
-0.0415553972,
0.0428318605,
-0.0406571142,
0.0297464728,
0.0290955584,
-0.0277513098,
0.0068396116,
0.0356612802,
-0.0105229123,
-0.0464126989,
0.0287941378,
0.0448464192,
-0.0596209727,
-0.0008075022,
0.1136372313,
-0.0173596386,
-0.0495314449,
0.0010572582,
-0.016919747,
0.0344072841,
0.0294857062,
-0.0052280314,
-0.0762873366,
-0.0540002398,
0.0374955572,
0.0358273797,
-0.0184264313,
0.0251775365,
0.0332737081,
-0.0793013647,
0.0195526257,
0.0238755047,
-0.0176783502,
-0.0197149478,
0.0229014605,
-0.0068163839,
0.0377456024,
0.0593801811,
-0.0155667383,
0.0015973086,
-0.0022738592,
0.0394927636,
-0.0276059937,
-0.1016532183,
0.0242588185,
-0.0179374162,
0.1310000867,
0.0371749923,
0.0004938656,
-0.0296674483,
-0.0691877604,
0.0801934898,
-0.0121257473,
-0.0122098289,
0.0069198129,
-0.0014676779,
0.0034706097,
-0.0440225564,
0.0218269136,
0.0213361699,
-0.0001893046,
0.0395855904,
-0.0218465049,
0.0327258445,
-0.023387773,
0.0103019141,
-0.0128792496,
-0.0035597743,
0.0158682577,
0.0490247197,
0.020471001,
-0.063052848,
-0.0116173802,
0.0156451538,
0.0042551439,
0.0363998264,
-0.0181658659,
0.0069553675,
0.0204838458,
-0.0168604236,
-0.0124134971,
0.0134785762,
0.0136815775,
-0.0346634686,
0.0243216176,
0.0597647689,
-0.0001515469,
0.0249223839,
-0.0292095542,
0.0155975604,
0.0253302567,
0.0531519018,
-0.1148810983,
0.0016576352,
0.0056367125,
-0.0154112717,
-0.0273495093,
0.0113610877,
-0.0494544059,
-0.0648360252,
0.060050372,
0.0076225051,
0.01689036,
0.0192955062,
-0.0377591439,
-0.078919448,
0.066895932,
0.0704949573,
-0.0919989645,
0.0330648795,
0.0226801839,
-0.0459805056,
-0.0249628779,
0.0378947295,
-0.0342013836,
0.0511662625,
-0.0483245663,
0.0136637026,
-0.0197812691,
-0.0751877427,
-0.0300886165,
0.0122646894,
0.0518316887,
-0.0350948982,
-0.0050803516,
-0.0202941447,
0.013819376,
0.0439031608,
0.0239588711,
-0.0305797942,
0.0237451121,
0.0194097683,
-0.0419012085,
-0.0056400793,
-0.0647210181,
-0.0521538742,
-0.023581082,
0.0406152532,
0.0327579416,
0.0229944494,
-0.0069312784,
0.0198635459,
0.0082995091,
0.0508549027,
0.0506918728,
0.0363426581,
0.0364618041,
0.004337471,
0.038378451,
0.0021500385,
0.0006754264,
0.0220452026,
0.025054764,
0.0047680964,
0.0043319655,
-0.0325287692,
-0.0016208778,
0.0264888592,
0.0018172425,
0.0598859228,
0.0207434017,
0.0058723348,
-0.0402786955,
0.0047614565,
-0.0004567048,
-0.0009075223,
0.0467455722,
0.009556761,
-0.0404852331,
0.0357149467,
0.0349998698,
0.0101879789,
-0.016322853,
-0.000787978,
0.0109537132,
0.0013564213,
-0.010011144,
-0.0350046828,
0.0184308086,
-0.0323860943,
0.04074746,
-0.0329996832,
-0.0794302002,
0.0147923781,
-0.015183459,
0.031706173,
-0.0182780195,
0.0070711509,
0.0064428514,
-0.0338096283,
0.026408378,
-0.0141622145,
-0.0879006311,
-0.0052967872,
-0.0198624209,
0.0466530211,
-6.077909704e-33,
-0.0459121205,
-0.0487193838,
-0.0308576338,
-0.0302740075,
-0.0130013311,
0.0177834425,
-0.0029959988,
0.0351827517,
-0.0118328733,
0.021808384,
0.0177049246,
0.0266255997,
0.0338087603,
-0.0085800439,
-0.0010734072,
-0.0251100343,
0.0741091669,
-0.0134105599,
0.0337233655,
0.0260821767,
0.0427479595,
0.0397128314,
0.0108296946,
-0.0381220467,
0.0035989226,
-0.0302752759,
-0.008581928,
-0.0169617478,
0.0677284151,
0.0420649797,
-0.0086589642,
0.071808435,
-0.0012495026,
0.0049861907,
-0.0041464525,
0.0167576931,
-0.0625695288,
0.0398269109,
-0.012323251,
0.0445878617,
0.0640668049,
-0.0153380893,
0.0428280644,
0.01494944,
-0.0073272483,
0.0448974036,
0.0489400215,
-0.0624967441,
-0.0121515132,
-0.0459633172,
-0.0069972645,
0.0458690301,
-0.0121052871,
-0.040021576,
0.086467348,
0.0684377328,
-0.0207062736,
0.0029547114,
-0.0187790245,
0.0077286167,
0.0067710504,
0.0551899299,
0.0472677201,
0.0018534209,
-0.0250103585,
0.0498821363,
0.0092490613,
-0.0239138156,
0.0630251169,
-0.0321887285,
0.0437538661,
0.0385423005,
0.0404827371,
-0.0035754433,
0.0325297602,
-0.0507795699,
0.0112839462,
-0.0136569506,
0.0042933025,
0.0123946508,
0.0491123796,
0.0263265632,
-0.0538570844,
-0.0317763425,
-0.0421860665,
-0.0031148265,
-0.0159888621,
0.0027108185,
0.0653886646,
-0.012094263,
0.0081491256,
0.0052653886,
0.0657349229,
-0.0335091688,
-0.0367590524,
-0.0452887788,
-0.0664420575,
0.0114953192,
0.0102333305,
0.0358767211,
0.0093415007,
-0.0507499389,
0.0537224263,
0.0566058792,
0.0022736781,
-0.0350085162,
-0.0193806887,
0.0239908174,
-0.0748383999,
0.0334990919,
0.0352034345,
0.0243316703,
-0.0201694183,
0.0213250443,
0.0347174965,
0.0004584383,
-0.0240419526,
0.0467331558,
0.0006224786,
-0.0130244028,
-0.0038231574,
0.0059658079,
-0.0277699847,
0.0619349107,
-0.0505462028,
0.0168865919,
-0.0038344804,
-0.011111496,
0.0253859963,
-0.0367123038,
-0.0060343877,
-0.0203627553,
2.77e-7,
0.0002963912,
0.0308367945,
-0.0064962464,
-0.0249256752,
0.033290796,
0.0162626021,
-0.0394673422,
-0.0359580033,
0.0252595507,
-0.0101725552,
0.0041613895,
0.0007415646,
0.0917051658,
0.0123007651,
-0.0610766858,
0.0058697984,
-0.0550169535,
0.0376145728,
-0.0435441285,
-0.0017556588,
0.0107679674,
0.0682948604,
-0.0222391393,
-0.065832518,
0.035821721,
-0.0384421833,
0.0166315716,
-0.0125259245,
0.0238121673,
-0.0107753836,
0.0282222144,
0.0113391839,
0.0031855495,
0.0430993699,
-0.0299874078,
0.0302497353,
0.0178339519,
0.036286857,
-0.0108434688,
-0.0208846778,
0.0168480612,
0.0268500615,
-0.0450984091,
-0.0205477104,
0.0468581505,
0.0196250305,
-0.0070875376,
-0.024689965,
-0.0496271551,
-0.054389853,
0.0617688671,
-0.0257107038,
-0.0057536517,
0.0057816552,
0.0238203797,
-0.0018831595,
-0.0432593934,
-0.0560592972,
0.0085353712,
0.0267395172,
-0.0319092609,
0.0192252677,
-0.0072149937,
-0.0156651791,
-0.0054622232,
-0.0354151502,
0.0121721188,
2.367847862e-34,
0.0865048468,
-0.0390433408,
-0.0005811179,
0.0379996076,
0.0181711242,
-0.0284085851,
-0.0312348139,
0.0181301292,
-0.0292852931,
-0.0294138435,
0.0046397513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11020v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11020v1 | RUPBench: Benchmarking Reasoning Under Perturbations for Robustness Evaluation in Large Language Models | 2024-06-16T17:26:44 | 2024-06-16T17:26:44 | Yuqing Wang, Yun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the increasing use of large language models (LLMs), ensuring reliable
performance in diverse, real-world environments is essential. Despite their
remarkable achievements, LLMs often struggle with adversarial inputs,
significantly impacting their effectiveness in practical applications. To
systematically understand the robustness of LLMs, we present RUPBench, a
comprehensive benchmark designed to evaluate LLM robustness across diverse
reasoning tasks. Our benchmark incorporates 15 reasoning datasets, categorized
into commonsense, arithmetic, logical, and knowledge-intensive reasoning, and
introduces nine types of textual perturbations at lexical, syntactic, and
semantic levels. By examining the performance of state-of-the-art LLMs such as
GPT-4o, Llama3, Phi-3, and Gemma on both original and perturbed datasets, we
provide a detailed analysis of their robustness and error patterns. Our
findings highlight that larger models tend to exhibit greater robustness to
perturbations. Additionally, common error types are identified through manual
inspection, revealing specific challenges faced by LLMs in different reasoning
contexts. This work provides insights into areas where LLMs need further
improvement to handle diverse and noisy inputs effectively. | [
0.0135861412,
0.08637923,
-0.0087913638,
0.0575843342,
-0.0519923046,
-0.001243318,
-0.0050124205,
-0.0010418176,
0.029018838,
-0.0511208661,
-0.0063098292,
-0.0118551962,
0.0094743781,
-0.0040595662,
0.0324482583,
-0.0306680463,
0.0524713881,
-0.0627988726,
-0.0099687697,
-0.007615509,
-0.0092105344,
-0.0015556789,
0.0066068955,
0.0163313001,
-0.0057332837,
-0.0280335993,
0.016537182,
0.0110841999,
0.02106902,
-0.0092591867,
0.0011673779,
0.0564851239,
0.0069341152,
0.0784864724,
0.0000020814,
-0.0298652463,
0.0124361524,
0.0171605777,
-0.0376485363,
0.0481919758,
0.0236338135,
-0.0215156469,
-0.0099365246,
0.0112030348,
-0.0288793091,
-0.0068545793,
0.0112595987,
0.0546082072,
0.0561176389,
0.0908435583,
-0.0069364868,
-0.0357663594,
0.0237557516,
-0.0470009297,
-0.0104867136,
-0.0767726898,
0.0426175594,
0.028645793,
0.0157811288,
0.0161991585,
-0.0082033304,
0.0179644413,
0.0503728352,
0.0145396767,
-0.0778016374,
0.0327007994,
-0.0477580018,
-0.0025923417,
0.0136671783,
0.0898927525,
-0.0261427611,
-0.0220210832,
-0.0292765647,
-0.0021111413,
-0.0015332056,
0.0115770344,
-0.0201121513,
0.0065049063,
-0.0079332478,
0.0102338847,
0.0164597929,
-0.0228374507,
0.0655882657,
0.0419889055,
-0.0560860448,
0.0862544551,
0.0375694707,
-0.0212705117,
0.0132436315,
-0.0208089147,
-0.0798234567,
-0.0439315811,
0.0071712197,
0.0285043921,
-0.0338711962,
0.0233513061,
-0.0546973124,
-0.0203232393,
0.0350573882,
-0.0515066311,
0.0279816221,
0.0307951402,
-0.0174660031,
0.0799651369,
-0.0361872129,
0.080121316,
-0.0379944593,
0.0617264099,
0.0074961018,
-0.006915465,
-0.0355469361,
-0.0102251442,
0.0113587901,
0.0148668829,
-0.0478724614,
-0.0016451536,
-0.0472363271,
0.0122054489,
-0.0199196227,
0.0442094095,
-0.0009566263,
-0.0058409991,
0.0082386639,
-0.0370078608,
-0.0255425703,
-0.0084332209,
-0.0472191311,
0.0397183634,
0.0062225517,
-0.0740636438,
-0.0233123526,
0.0068659531,
-0.0358190946,
-0.0601328835,
0.0239002388,
0.0820247903,
0.0128191989,
-0.0402862243,
-0.0364701338,
-0.0051942705,
-0.0203037504,
-0.0967664793,
-0.0140710147,
-0.0395654179,
0.0283707753,
0.0011805457,
-0.0244205389,
-0.0685259849,
0.0162602793,
0.015743129,
-0.0343452059,
0.0968264043,
0.0271784905,
-0.0183919277,
-0.0163387414,
0.0212364718,
-0.0191446822,
0.0669905841,
0.0308420546,
-0.0108050089,
0.0427475199,
0.0183417778,
-0.0229024123,
0.0312714241,
0.02785936,
0.0114482446,
-0.0303294621,
0.0311536472,
0.0063287225,
0.0246036835,
-0.0244513303,
0.0764382258,
-0.0363248251,
-0.053686332,
0.0699058026,
0.0311154332,
-0.0199740138,
0.011544425,
-0.0017944637,
-0.0494440645,
0.0185745358,
-0.0093167294,
-0.1128476709,
-0.0175986197,
-0.0708590597,
-0.0161321387,
0.0021492736,
0.0327159949,
-0.0255732592,
-0.0380527452,
-0.049315989,
-0.0051748352,
0.0219140053,
0.0113802701,
0.0490660295,
-0.0056740157,
-0.029372232,
0.0196456593,
0.0027648399,
-0.0320901573,
-0.0135282613,
-0.0528789833,
0.0187846255,
0.0234538577,
0.069027774,
-0.0558970943,
-0.0145506049,
0.0067420625,
0.012946384,
0.0326097347,
0.0384844877,
0.0174825564,
0.023053214,
-0.0478592627,
0.0161336716,
-0.0245350581,
0.0332170464,
0.0194085818,
0.0436320715,
-0.0007058911,
0.0110420864,
-0.060547702,
0.0080381045,
0.0374262296,
-0.0432258062,
-0.0311373472,
-0.0114745339,
-0.0107401246,
0.012503678,
-0.0046834792,
-0.0002486241,
0.0192163661,
0.0221013576,
-0.0248823427,
-0.0058577382,
0.019133389,
-0.0274966583,
-0.0548284389,
0.0572466739,
0.0051805242,
-0.0490668528,
0.0698823333,
-0.0552602448,
-0.013148183,
0.0420090109,
-0.0171673354,
0.0093414634,
-0.0349349529,
0.0104089221,
0.0069356579,
0.0527967289,
-0.0185057819,
0.0878499523,
-0.031761758,
0.0125830416,
-0.0176184904,
0.0480103306,
0.0289070196,
-0.0185491126,
-0.0416561775,
0.0222004149,
-0.012983704,
-0.0012662358,
-0.0248226356,
-0.0127123063,
-0.0325330496,
-0.0296755284,
-0.026064299,
-0.0077647436,
-0.0373633541,
0.0276288204,
0.0193540547,
-0.0203296915,
0.0011943816,
0.0162339546,
-0.0121580474,
0.0040146112,
0.0323145501,
0.0447616838,
0.0355347432,
-0.0075126556,
-0.001608229,
-0.0388428643,
-0.0264626611,
-0.0284255147,
0.0695348158,
0.0016437938,
0.0374479368,
-0.0273366142,
-0.0017016777,
-0.0550403781,
0.0469570681,
-0.0353097543,
-0.0280050877,
0.0149557097,
-0.0075548068,
0.0457516611,
0.078719154,
-0.0361848027,
0.0221654996,
0.0572577156,
-0.0110965194,
-0.0207094587,
0.0130762719,
-0.008399561,
-0.0146061294,
-0.0194397494,
-0.0141736539,
-0.0406114794,
0.0383667089,
-0.0084823882,
-0.0250493195,
-0.0575352684,
0.0405941457,
-0.0161083676,
-0.0120919822,
-0.0120740142,
-0.008346105,
-0.0007807671,
0.0473131724,
-0.0391843133,
-0.0277525801,
0.0706079155,
-0.0122994753,
0.009374789,
-0.0244074017,
0.001322015,
-0.0389189087,
0.0761421099,
0.0019648708,
0.0000766124,
-0.0201679263,
0.0046657645,
-0.0378548726,
-0.0637856573,
0.0333590247,
-0.0381858498,
0.0678524226,
-0.0607342795,
0.0322885327,
-0.0077623324,
-0.0550540797,
-0.0405357033,
-0.0332894921,
-0.0305490438,
0.0317845084,
-0.0076106437,
-0.0287824217,
-0.0262476075,
0.0065737455,
-0.0040635085,
0.0375320092,
-0.0147730503,
-0.0004643263,
-0.0195800923,
0.0153432051,
0.0253704507,
0.000505027,
0.0425419435,
-0.0374892689,
0.0221738052,
0.0668131188,
0.0192737747,
-0.0048396802,
-0.0547954068,
0.0186346583,
-0.0063527543,
-0.0061962749,
-0.0054910015,
0.0048133647,
0.0430652983,
-0.0574905202,
-0.0227175094,
0.082187444,
0.0323433615,
-0.0017046639,
0.0263810251,
-0.0306116696,
0.0438488834,
0.0217925515,
0.0168272872,
-0.0654172897,
-0.0507439002,
0.0360894576,
0.0066606458,
0.0270709582,
-0.0643642619,
0.0039153378,
-0.1110836193,
0.0160817411,
0.0012384291,
-0.0344277993,
-0.0710540339,
-0.0510593206,
0.0183731448,
-0.0244324394,
0.0268649142,
0.0262735952,
0.0289881695,
-0.0148182753,
-0.0139148384,
-0.0045443522,
-0.0756175816,
0.0516769513,
-0.0307845566,
0.0368225798,
0.0568296425,
0.0272623897,
0.0010522949,
-0.0538820475,
0.0657047555,
-0.0000950118,
-0.0194408465,
0.0016023006,
0.029950846,
0.0116906548,
-0.000039248,
-0.0055035022,
0.0333617814,
-0.044632487,
-0.0378177762,
-0.0050466,
0.0712276399,
0.0031286248,
-0.0193722919,
-0.0167493392,
0.0059204497,
-0.0110707851,
0.0729269683,
0.0145798782,
0.0191597249,
-0.086366713,
-0.0517969653,
-0.0385302715,
-0.0452733003,
-0.0054484224,
0.0253282432,
0.0506377257,
-0.0019588405,
-0.0428853445,
-0.0188737083,
0.0090762069,
0.0140901683,
-0.0081224022,
-0.0094277645,
-0.0191680435,
-0.0030158614,
-0.0186711941,
0.0232095253,
-0.0312116053,
0.054140266,
-0.024187848,
0.0344807543,
0.0189476181,
0.0026008205,
-0.0289936922,
0.0125629632,
-0.0929879919,
-0.0965982601,
-0.006883834,
0.0327874906,
0.0277211051,
0.0321588702,
-0.0382134728,
-0.0452312343,
0.0226227958,
0.0191115085,
-0.012927101,
0.0279032476,
0.0617137849,
-0.0235459469,
0.0271680299,
0.054181546,
-0.0372073241,
0.0058842171,
0.014143385,
0.0443798266,
-0.0220552068,
-0.0024903656,
0.0118360622,
0.0289719999,
0.0078466814,
0.0165171847,
-0.0019246507,
0.0037257466,
0.0218357705,
-0.0442632847,
-0.0152179971,
-0.0120429415,
0.0310187954,
0.0484628081,
-0.0249832403,
-0.0132542634,
-0.0223161057,
0.0174236652,
0.0408450961,
-0.0065180878,
0.0144226393,
0.0167455133,
0.0130430544,
0.0323713347,
-0.0223229174,
-0.0159493983,
0.027011903,
-0.0361401811,
0.0622722432,
-0.0328938887,
0.0385137759,
0.0408441946,
-0.0189877544,
-0.027178837,
-0.0028073238,
-0.0761778802,
-0.036750637,
0.0378956571,
0.0145189939,
0.0537432171,
0.003033109,
0.0073166722,
-0.044569917,
-0.0277425572,
-0.0267049428,
0.0068443883,
0.0361601003,
-0.0218000002,
0.0507187992,
0.0257975999,
0.0018801301,
0.0283795595,
0.0579469875,
-0.0005865904,
0.0602621473,
0.0366373323,
0.0072209709,
-0.0438641049,
-0.060864266,
-0.0216893423,
0.0008949225,
-0.0309762452,
0.023504192,
-0.0661815256,
-0.105138585,
0.0053865206,
0.0239993948,
-0.0028721332,
0.0077130748,
-0.0258971062,
0.0704303309,
0.0182318222,
-0.0008174933,
-0.0126999989,
0.0035864615,
-0.0484463647,
-0.0033594917,
-0.0280256364,
-6.322807789e-33,
-0.0203922577,
-0.0285005998,
0.0152794439,
-0.060271062,
-0.0029096033,
-0.0205472987,
-0.0556280911,
0.0040966319,
-0.037143115,
0.0179349389,
-0.019914303,
0.0333496965,
-0.0138022956,
0.0315220281,
-0.0371043272,
-0.0547792725,
0.0098581845,
0.0155472243,
-0.0275850967,
0.0021183516,
0.0231359452,
-0.0046451287,
0.0279908702,
-0.0547952801,
0.0253426507,
0.0204174146,
-0.0245975181,
0.0259735007,
-0.0865283981,
0.0475985594,
-0.0058569903,
0.021062512,
0.0011609512,
0.0081466651,
0.0130522074,
-0.0019845809,
-0.0673536956,
-0.0245577767,
0.0349530801,
-0.0093083968,
-0.0339617431,
-0.0146142831,
0.0224399567,
0.0085489172,
-0.0099124508,
-0.0241668224,
-0.0079616867,
-0.0302877724,
-0.0126731908,
0.0140617229,
-0.0189547054,
0.057714384,
-0.0164423604,
0.0012273184,
-0.0111477235,
0.0377638079,
0.0093680788,
0.0392589793,
-0.0497786924,
-0.0092975637,
0.0285661183,
0.0106558995,
0.0388376527,
-0.002562593,
-0.000949375,
0.0470235907,
-0.0102465488,
0.0069847116,
-0.0485081971,
-0.0023059228,
0.0199524201,
0.0597772077,
0.0880685672,
0.071899347,
0.021814106,
0.0027190875,
-0.0997484401,
-0.0246260874,
0.0208115857,
0.049302958,
0.0502163582,
0.0114377989,
-0.0629561245,
-0.0032156436,
-0.0446456969,
-0.0043742904,
-0.0592706725,
-0.0126261059,
0.02929754,
-0.00679455,
-0.0184214972,
0.0019293375,
-0.0124760885,
-0.040994551,
-0.0143487612,
0.0586688221,
-0.006349171,
-0.0247578118,
-0.0001519848,
0.0655790567,
-0.0161731336,
-0.012195576,
0.011154023,
-0.0114143295,
0.0200683512,
-0.0008056188,
0.036710836,
0.026815448,
-0.0475034975,
-0.0217181966,
-0.0302235708,
0.0313593373,
0.0102596739,
0.0447863974,
0.0547726303,
0.0131720351,
0.0080539137,
0.0200438239,
0.0255223345,
0.0221742261,
-0.022603333,
0.0204704106,
0.009144959,
0.0247635599,
-0.0087140929,
-0.0195438731,
-0.0337952413,
-0.0055337292,
0.0197222903,
-0.0589248948,
0.0034593744,
0.0192689095,
2.718e-7,
0.0440840609,
0.0886583477,
0.0136767197,
0.0309889894,
0.0117504634,
0.0264803115,
-0.0365404263,
0.0050964379,
-0.0159011036,
-0.0195327774,
-0.0245202743,
0.0499479622,
0.0605673864,
0.0512813739,
-0.0255182777,
-0.0034480211,
-0.0529094189,
-0.0145385135,
-0.0446271375,
0.0003075842,
0.0753511414,
0.1113916859,
0.0304509029,
-0.0079405708,
0.0143632647,
-0.0859045163,
0.0591899864,
-0.0302935354,
-0.0001874127,
-0.0131237609,
0.031994734,
0.0163065214,
0.0244917572,
0.0438343845,
0.0019700716,
0.0119495634,
-0.003694454,
0.0853278711,
-0.0128698498,
-0.0436647534,
-0.0559472293,
-0.0404047593,
-0.0051735025,
-0.081606634,
0.1055581644,
-0.0229593813,
-0.0449127443,
0.003323698,
-0.0122609641,
-0.0220994297,
0.0500185601,
-0.0102391085,
-0.032224495,
-0.0085977418,
0.0189374443,
-0.00975913,
-0.0098867929,
-0.1042881086,
-0.0238613524,
0.0012321385,
-0.0447930582,
-0.0335071273,
-0.0240087938,
0.0117950281,
0.0487342589,
-0.0397258624,
-0.0138676465,
2.897590131e-34,
0.0667359382,
-0.0182596464,
0.0135757644,
0.0028919859,
0.0591687709,
0.0047814329,
0.0318458267,
0.0009669641,
0.0191667955,
-0.0922972038,
-0.0128435446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11016v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11016v1 | Optimized Speculative Sampling for GPU Hardware Accelerators | 2024-06-16T17:19:23 | 2024-06-16T17:19:23 | Dominik Wagner, Seanie Lee, Ilja Baumann, Philipp Seeberger, Korbinian Riedhammer, Tobias Bocklet | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In this work, we optimize speculative sampling for parallel hardware
accelerators to improve sampling speed. We notice that substantial portions of
the intermediate matrices necessary for speculative sampling can be computed
concurrently. This allows us to distribute the workload across multiple GPU
threads, enabling simultaneous operations on matrix segments within thread
blocks. Additionally, we use fast on-chip memory to store intermediate results,
thereby minimizing the frequency of slow read and write operations across
different types of memory. This results in profiling time improvements ranging
from 6% to 13% relative to the baseline implementation, without compromising
accuracy. To further accelerate speculative sampling, probability distributions
parameterized by softmax are approximated by sigmoid. This approximation
approach results in significantly greater relative improvements in profiling
time, ranging from 37% to 94%, with a slight decline in accuracy. We conduct
extensive experiments on both automatic speech recognition and summarization
tasks to validate the effectiveness of our optimization methods. | [
0.0334339067,
-0.0003913826,
-0.037142396,
0.001472109,
-0.0022952517,
-0.0085705006,
0.0376296565,
-0.0196159147,
-0.0408604182,
-0.0164708998,
0.0008864217,
-0.0813823193,
0.0164408572,
0.0021554774,
-0.0119146081,
-0.0563730933,
-0.0068997457,
-0.0615727976,
-0.0161085445,
-0.0389187112,
-0.0013290052,
0.0348286889,
0.0012870999,
-0.0061362535,
-0.0240121912,
0.0191139858,
-0.0152155515,
-0.0106229037,
0.0316881947,
0.0149022117,
-0.0325040668,
0.0044194167,
0.0240985751,
-0.0207007658,
0.0000021995,
0.0026691486,
-0.0014471939,
-0.0062152767,
0.0531552993,
0.03917633,
0.0575959571,
-0.0055874875,
-0.0037139128,
-0.0162925944,
0.0148730949,
-0.0009796843,
0.0229089018,
-0.0270692781,
-0.0538963415,
-0.0262982864,
0.0121918842,
0.0264646355,
0.0341774225,
-0.0229862537,
0.0052908058,
-0.0648268163,
-0.0023588568,
-0.0241885185,
0.012897783,
-0.0546544567,
0.0362251662,
0.0295452699,
0.0181682743,
-0.0140985074,
0.0142550049,
0.0478629693,
-0.0103707118,
0.0149279973,
-0.0069421469,
0.02857548,
-0.0742878839,
0.0062408396,
0.0137999784,
-0.0318645127,
-0.0270920377,
-0.0111921988,
-0.0216448233,
0.071607478,
-0.0346041508,
-0.0223809835,
0.0181270614,
0.0259158779,
0.0188800935,
-0.007221214,
0.0275034457,
0.0429267101,
0.0244044755,
0.0461868197,
-0.0281961411,
0.0551437028,
-0.0012473239,
-0.0278694108,
0.053636644,
-0.025981931,
-0.0526593663,
0.0203510392,
-0.0853056461,
-0.066645585,
-0.0157873519,
-0.0240796544,
0.059218701,
0.0094697801,
0.0272973217,
0.0127760796,
-0.0114205386,
-0.0449149795,
-0.0149872936,
0.0008768034,
-0.0161093231,
-0.0049842279,
0.0370521247,
0.0201824717,
-0.0251724869,
0.0526691414,
-0.071512796,
-0.0292788353,
-0.0402754284,
0.0125556057,
-0.0284156799,
-0.0434863567,
-0.0495155454,
0.0375413112,
-0.0790905654,
0.0380344614,
0.0072856685,
-0.0373417139,
-0.0832602531,
0.0349909961,
-0.0141841359,
-0.046963647,
-0.0052733468,
-0.0103028957,
0.0210434515,
-0.0356037617,
-0.0090758326,
0.0170354098,
-0.0391075164,
-0.0869120136,
-0.031203419,
-0.0187310297,
-0.0029749516,
-0.029846726,
0.0024789949,
-0.0650181323,
0.0766838714,
0.005147337,
0.033466544,
0.0563581139,
0.019180214,
0.0395286717,
0.0096854186,
0.0429541878,
0.0074814288,
-0.0713136494,
0.0512591824,
0.0037341926,
0.0318097882,
0.0686200336,
0.0152478581,
0.0846317038,
0.0203500092,
0.026283985,
0.0114464201,
0.0037922829,
0.0052966797,
0.0133856898,
-0.0013034611,
0.0054462994,
-0.0057002213,
0.0310990699,
0.0597782396,
0.0734245181,
-0.056101758,
-0.0339991376,
0.0261143632,
0.0602561124,
-0.1012372449,
0.0190842841,
0.0288109332,
-0.0469250977,
0.0210546777,
0.010925022,
0.0068312935,
0.0368258432,
0.0380162001,
0.0205154475,
0.0642958581,
0.0644860938,
-0.0014600224,
0.0284207612,
0.0198858641,
0.006441847,
-0.0050129108,
0.0013870812,
0.0721301958,
-0.0107503971,
-0.0113784559,
0.0108545059,
0.0455029383,
-0.0250712223,
-0.0421476588,
-0.0203182567,
0.0080375103,
0.0297957528,
0.0083258161,
-0.022139689,
0.0074897259,
-0.0132838385,
-0.0830926374,
-0.0273840316,
0.0214079283,
-0.0193520114,
0.0422770754,
-0.0317469947,
-0.0069607282,
-0.0198207162,
-0.0372604989,
0.0791678801,
0.0292070322,
0.0180996675,
0.0065156003,
0.0113682924,
-0.0350980982,
-0.0258146282,
0.0122462995,
-0.0030373186,
0.0876215473,
-0.0387304947,
0.0586094297,
0.0143834967,
-0.0139740109,
-0.015843235,
0.0333076008,
-0.0513941795,
0.0207947437,
-0.0314358547,
-0.0405219235,
0.009857825,
0.0104899397,
-0.0527082048,
0.0180707108,
0.0072043655,
-0.0220923517,
-0.0636330321,
0.0506477132,
-0.0198530257,
-0.0212071259,
-0.0388484038,
0.0216223933,
0.0151713463,
0.0516988598,
-0.0118417498,
0.028451845,
-0.0282774158,
-0.0099533685,
0.0506786406,
-0.0012864339,
-0.0018505375,
-0.064324066,
-0.0310037564,
-0.0315768607,
0.0432305783,
-0.0232498497,
0.0279332884,
-0.0482798256,
0.0080858879,
0.0547264032,
-0.113155365,
0.0302877482,
-0.0213587414,
-0.0095085222,
0.0209073126,
0.0283888541,
0.006979154,
-0.012326045,
0.0248723775,
-0.0003249026,
-0.0568695813,
0.007245007,
-0.0280970503,
0.033297386,
-0.0010499813,
0.0033914831,
-0.0497717112,
0.0129437242,
0.0307871457,
-0.0114064217,
-0.0542550609,
0.0032263405,
-0.0143118305,
0.0371729173,
0.0017861963,
-0.03764401,
0.0434309803,
-0.0048494004,
-0.0143075529,
0.0322564468,
0.045965828,
0.0079610804,
0.0234692879,
0.0110559668,
-0.0004179926,
0.0299563445,
0.0404598378,
-0.0072521092,
0.0356102623,
0.0067887716,
-0.0153477313,
-0.0273751728,
0.0447961949,
0.0215955768,
-0.0412920378,
0.019504834,
-0.0305327773,
0.002770866,
-0.0545176417,
-0.0160600711,
-0.0130069479,
-0.0316312872,
0.01197071,
0.0074073877,
-0.0186738912,
0.0000738591,
-0.0514440648,
0.0438080952,
-0.039535109,
-0.020146586,
0.0037718525,
0.0359767973,
0.0289313905,
-0.0031413829,
-0.0687369183,
-0.0034845967,
0.0509235896,
0.0014068442,
0.0002052857,
-0.0424646251,
0.0382059291,
0.0007436305,
0.0208821632,
-0.0200135559,
-0.0347344242,
0.0270832311,
-0.0237190053,
-0.0393136777,
-0.0085106278,
0.0783706978,
-0.0191055406,
0.0094829621,
0.0277202353,
-0.0143617,
0.0689810663,
-0.034423694,
-0.0285899676,
-0.0092251049,
0.000093666,
0.0696268156,
-0.0328180455,
0.0010624452,
-0.022000527,
-0.0336212739,
0.0377348624,
0.0750727504,
0.0156280175,
-0.0762015358,
-0.0399593674,
0.0199809875,
-0.0075068213,
-0.0266545042,
0.0552572012,
0.0305545069,
-0.0284078009,
-0.0043566418,
0.0340499058,
0.0221921802,
-0.0474314392,
0.0139551265,
0.0932805687,
0.0069608777,
0.0130348159,
0.0327138603,
-0.064184323,
-0.0246226415,
0.0351531208,
0.0167511217,
-0.036796663,
-0.0175162666,
0.0375668928,
-0.0938801095,
0.0497585312,
-0.0478082076,
-0.0169778597,
-0.0301376246,
-0.0282826647,
0.0261633303,
0.0160538778,
0.0348288529,
-0.0248737168,
-0.0064236927,
-0.0002781749,
0.0065365313,
0.0145910988,
0.0690345317,
-0.0024326129,
-0.0178826507,
0.0051946831,
0.0059085707,
0.0173256751,
-0.0222246218,
0.0305092316,
-0.0053151227,
-0.0030255655,
0.0212614294,
0.0020568024,
0.0457616188,
-0.0045613549,
0.011073675,
0.0019087851,
0.012472325,
-0.0054047769,
-0.0038705836,
0.0090530831,
0.0453287028,
-0.0172902793,
-0.0316604823,
-0.016546702,
0.0014343053,
0.0161631871,
-0.0028533405,
0.0080653178,
-0.0485890061,
-0.0401207618,
-0.0591991767,
-0.0346974581,
-0.0855755508,
0.0277926959,
-0.047244966,
0.0200010631,
0.0073691779,
-0.007406842,
-0.0181868263,
0.0443236381,
0.0403711684,
-0.0194904841,
-0.0013237044,
0.0082486048,
-0.0036826613,
-0.0682097226,
-0.0032622525,
-0.0511679687,
0.0418740548,
0.0391558073,
-0.0037202672,
0.011264557,
-0.0156201189,
-0.0272948984,
0.0899129137,
-0.121049583,
-0.0241076946,
-0.0064463937,
0.0306395944,
0.0041337255,
0.0396645851,
0.0153666651,
-0.0396312773,
0.0377168618,
0.0551167578,
-0.0467013195,
0.056827765,
-0.0209839642,
-0.0611759312,
-0.0154144419,
0.0063038394,
-0.0021776024,
-0.0039473134,
0.0018681469,
-0.0090775853,
0.0014199947,
-0.0725615174,
-0.0581143796,
-0.0112966411,
0.059406735,
-0.0124134542,
0.0134447571,
-0.0018679197,
0.01158062,
0.0302528776,
0.00785485,
-0.0177225471,
-0.0340427384,
0.0171336513,
-0.0153427627,
-0.0386794358,
-0.0032766273,
0.0431296453,
0.0013710007,
-0.0331264734,
-0.0706194937,
0.0057903058,
-0.0165986121,
-0.0154703557,
-0.0300198533,
-0.0143582243,
-0.0123151634,
0.0507087111,
0.0727329925,
0.0137527036,
0.0174095146,
0.0055073574,
0.0120332837,
0.0193536244,
-0.0325650685,
-0.0520876162,
-0.032711491,
-0.0870543122,
-0.0002729326,
0.0237638038,
-0.0300824046,
0.0280892029,
-0.0161170103,
0.0018346772,
-0.0121650137,
-0.0051330528,
-0.022884924,
-0.0065386058,
0.0203716084,
0.0083421702,
0.0277227648,
0.0474607497,
0.0367434546,
-0.0343948267,
0.0132493116,
0.0378423147,
-0.0170093868,
-0.0230111871,
-0.028554989,
-0.0586928055,
0.0700486377,
-0.0010852253,
-0.0479433648,
0.0262701362,
-0.004555671,
0.0708168596,
0.008475434,
-0.0223713797,
-0.0167919453,
0.0600571521,
0.0194433164,
-0.0120437499,
-0.0052513634,
-0.0210006312,
0.0352757797,
0.0244628489,
0.0207225755,
0.0116877006,
-6.127481403e-33,
-0.0193236079,
-0.0000201333,
-0.0056266729,
0.015808912,
0.0037964131,
0.0135259489,
-0.004688377,
0.0256175306,
0.0582099669,
0.011148626,
-0.0310709383,
-0.0064318879,
0.033739958,
0.0203820169,
0.0016152663,
0.0164670795,
0.0400093086,
-0.0181215703,
-0.009078796,
0.0856722668,
0.028515758,
0.0671984553,
0.0438405238,
-0.0337768942,
-0.0495930724,
-0.007323571,
0.0320546851,
-0.070407331,
0.0108790267,
0.0317953229,
-0.0476839095,
0.0342527293,
-0.0145279253,
-0.0607312806,
-0.0369353369,
0.0081232674,
-0.0882299691,
-0.0386805832,
0.046200823,
0.015000199,
-0.0111741377,
-0.005019621,
-0.03598205,
0.0590290464,
0.033937607,
-0.0287675448,
0.0001733398,
0.0025916575,
-0.0617142729,
-0.0881681889,
0.020194035,
0.0018757817,
0.0242661629,
0.0826665759,
0.0748946071,
-0.037159428,
-0.0488602705,
0.007834712,
-0.0245378762,
-0.0050393883,
0.0260811262,
0.0465333462,
0.0382236466,
0.0386895873,
0.0226147529,
0.0768995062,
0.0412712581,
-0.008645515,
-0.0013552979,
0.0182390567,
0.0063689365,
-0.0305319931,
-0.0667258203,
0.060520567,
0.0757751912,
0.024013482,
-0.0537679233,
0.0126658948,
0.0948152617,
-0.0420592763,
0.1010446623,
-0.0273091141,
-0.0080492338,
-0.04782952,
-0.0483925454,
0.0186881963,
-0.0204382353,
0.0207008012,
0.0022891855,
0.052435495,
-0.0486478433,
0.0661407262,
0.0319325216,
-0.0075605228,
0.0289089717,
-0.0262914412,
-0.0010232897,
0.0337775275,
0.0231577512,
-0.0294606034,
-0.02944839,
-0.0454020724,
-0.0193569548,
-0.0491644591,
0.0157380272,
-0.0288883373,
0.0138936136,
0.0092123458,
-0.0406067781,
-0.0001913255,
-0.0096565336,
0.0567591935,
0.0043199128,
0.0645653531,
0.0358766243,
-0.00115916,
-0.0113753667,
0.0731363222,
-0.0296417046,
0.0139357923,
-0.0344496556,
-0.0005873311,
0.0022214088,
-0.0172912776,
-0.0450168252,
0.0149492892,
-0.0185824633,
-0.0297824219,
0.008319675,
-0.0931541249,
-0.0499393716,
0.0314030536,
2.868e-7,
0.0082891379,
0.0167308021,
0.0249008629,
0.0184467603,
0.016480444,
0.0053802994,
0.0692220405,
0.0127680935,
0.0352054797,
-0.0126983365,
0.0163807869,
0.0188296214,
-0.0240448639,
0.03012955,
-0.0937449113,
-0.0025347518,
0.0171203297,
0.0294439234,
-0.0320752561,
-0.0345237143,
-0.0760641396,
0.095138073,
0.0033918782,
-0.0315666012,
0.0657008663,
-0.022984229,
0.0216217712,
0.009600156,
-0.0056251083,
0.0229783878,
0.0078605628,
0.0483994856,
-0.041553732,
0.058455646,
0.0188073032,
0.0193552598,
-0.0033108848,
0.0428083465,
0.0027038122,
-0.0552222095,
0.0532959737,
-0.0263099782,
0.0055811275,
-0.017399054,
0.0390311852,
0.0102962842,
0.0091202864,
-0.0523100644,
-0.0137918508,
-0.021598408,
-0.0162908398,
-0.0052795047,
0.0962991193,
0.0351219252,
0.0079630241,
-0.0031810661,
-0.0311509464,
-0.0312781408,
0.0123453829,
0.0216892157,
-0.062841557,
-0.0506250933,
-0.0560525656,
-0.0274803173,
0.0232442636,
-0.0630805418,
-0.0109282201,
2.200879451e-34,
0.0379254185,
0.0468471237,
-0.0436299369,
-0.0124771185,
-0.0101534035,
-0.0279945061,
-0.0193133689,
-0.0191426184,
0.0033509911,
-0.0745403394,
-0.0753057003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11012v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11012v3 | Connecting the Dots: Evaluating Abstract Reasoning Capabilities of LLMs Using the New York Times Connections Word Game | 2024-06-16T17:10:32 | 2024-06-22T15:40:14 | Prisha Samadarshi, Mariam Mustafa, Anushka Kulkarni, Raven Rothkopf, Tuhin Chakrabarty, Smaranda Muresan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The New York Times Connections game has emerged as a popular and challenging
pursuit for word puzzle enthusiasts. We collect 200 Connections games to
evaluate the performance of state-of-the-art large language models (LLMs)
against expert and novice human players. Our results show that even the
best-performing LLM, GPT-4o, which has otherwise shown impressive reasoning
abilities on a wide variety of benchmarks, can only fully solve 8% of the
games. Compared to GPT-4o, novice and expert players perform better, with
expert human players significantly outperforming GPT-4o. To deepen our
understanding we create a taxonomy of the knowledge types required to
successfully categorize words in the Connections game, revealing that LLMs
struggle with associative, encyclopedic, and linguistic knowledge. Our findings
establish the New York Times Connections game as a challenging benchmark for
evaluating abstract reasoning capabilities in humans and AI systems. | [
0.0390601978,
0.0567981079,
-0.0404798463,
0.0923131332,
-0.0443879962,
0.0051356084,
-0.0082404604,
0.0236715209,
0.004524515,
-0.0106255589,
-0.0223162286,
-0.0454109535,
0.0138830915,
0.0297235418,
0.0433982909,
-0.0094531532,
0.0405631289,
-0.0595582724,
0.0241828039,
-0.0075764973,
-0.0439743549,
0.0040467712,
-0.0354107618,
0.0227451287,
0.0148420827,
-0.0034803473,
-0.0024762899,
-0.0236833133,
-0.0086080274,
-0.0539260656,
-0.0436756127,
0.0421329215,
0.0321867093,
0.0402975045,
0.0000022301,
-0.0548448116,
0.0173514169,
-0.0274707042,
-0.0396646708,
0.0022478295,
-0.025010081,
0.0039306702,
0.0098040607,
0.0021351834,
-0.0388225913,
0.0138543928,
0.0422931425,
0.0267695319,
0.0601466224,
0.0637586787,
0.0070686177,
-0.0112273088,
0.069595933,
-0.0257190857,
0.0403153263,
-0.0792469829,
0.0025815207,
0.0658895671,
0.0459199883,
-0.0178550724,
-0.0181211885,
0.0155366194,
0.0293396823,
0.0263138767,
-0.0207625814,
0.0442334004,
-0.0140805831,
0.0097411377,
0.0076315724,
0.0743917376,
0.0058369315,
0.0092779836,
-0.0068417331,
0.0173938926,
-0.0099265818,
0.0318382643,
-0.0300000403,
0.0404794179,
-0.0115798069,
0.0059598275,
0.0256660189,
0.0085321832,
0.0432538092,
0.0567523837,
-0.0291188061,
0.1179044396,
-0.0151470965,
-0.0055611543,
0.0306701604,
-0.006998051,
-0.0440815575,
-0.0836007148,
-0.022586396,
0.0370082706,
-0.030437462,
0.040769808,
-0.0136321466,
0.0153466305,
0.0305241924,
-0.0144797824,
0.0013115718,
0.0334676392,
0.0618655682,
0.0739093572,
0.0117700249,
0.0475087948,
-0.0197422691,
0.0410583504,
-0.0248665866,
-0.0098299989,
-0.0317379199,
-0.0425186194,
-0.0022850994,
0.0672528669,
-0.0263404511,
-0.0306354593,
-0.0188942533,
-0.0066072638,
-0.0144136427,
0.0281792488,
-0.0052937618,
-0.0187742505,
0.0071274829,
-0.0664236844,
-0.0777984858,
-0.0218219887,
-0.0592834763,
0.0212454163,
0.0041346308,
-0.0455612242,
-0.0196747594,
-0.027550526,
-0.0109348213,
-0.0465850905,
0.0438233465,
0.0622484125,
-0.0217020437,
-0.0321703553,
0.0240483135,
-0.0140505275,
-0.0010182339,
-0.1210661754,
0.0123865074,
-0.0716460571,
0.0335848629,
0.0148322554,
0.0021476164,
-0.0458553806,
0.0109470524,
0.0045477999,
-0.0416537337,
0.0945997387,
-0.0078061214,
0.0199171696,
0.0374560431,
0.0381308012,
-0.0023318997,
0.0591597967,
0.040302448,
0.0218852647,
0.0145057989,
-0.0048459368,
0.0250826068,
0.0305051487,
-0.0069250423,
-0.0090427808,
0.0019223846,
0.016622914,
-0.0392715931,
0.0585792847,
-0.0141111817,
0.0626806244,
-0.02397798,
-0.0118242139,
0.0615427122,
0.1059985831,
-0.0081921062,
0.0346178636,
0.0278997552,
-0.0244805608,
0.0357422903,
-0.0259829033,
-0.0436033458,
0.0457988195,
-0.0259854086,
0.0190084074,
-0.0143802855,
0.0259657092,
-0.0100362469,
-0.0431720465,
-0.0426442325,
0.0194020066,
0.0330284722,
0.0126222475,
0.0522765256,
-0.0253859181,
-0.033842396,
0.0319793001,
0.0045880266,
-0.0160274953,
-0.007341323,
-0.0804481581,
0.0332595557,
0.057540562,
0.0654404983,
-0.010293453,
-0.0513854288,
0.0106528271,
0.0178884808,
0.0780473799,
0.0432305336,
0.0253714453,
-0.0122881886,
-0.0326410197,
0.0061229561,
-0.0267480277,
0.0123256287,
0.0326921158,
0.0284249652,
0.0299507305,
-0.0098762047,
-0.0639441162,
0.0307356045,
0.0109903365,
-0.045405861,
-0.0382967219,
-0.0536555238,
0.0126198744,
0.0231114794,
0.0075174994,
0.007020399,
0.0191541519,
0.0199760161,
-0.0283908304,
-0.0402310565,
-0.0073111597,
-0.0378321186,
0.0347562619,
0.0197421815,
-0.0530380309,
-0.0295859035,
0.043638669,
0.0053628697,
-0.0133069959,
0.0345343016,
-0.0173946805,
0.0677437186,
-0.0252854824,
0.0244713854,
-0.0058984957,
-0.0246669762,
-0.0043440736,
0.10862232,
-0.0168118179,
0.0236626435,
-0.0186903588,
-0.0238176715,
0.0156441461,
-0.0713636354,
-0.0091624605,
0.0398050398,
-0.013604573,
-0.0151211675,
-0.0194918513,
-0.0019460714,
-0.0689582378,
-0.0195335075,
-0.0540885516,
-0.0023168942,
0.0246507861,
0.0204762109,
-0.0051337918,
-0.039125137,
-0.0187533535,
0.0338070169,
-0.0036665397,
0.0087054484,
0.0171426255,
0.0101031084,
0.0287952553,
0.0230649039,
-0.0417866707,
-0.0143071115,
-0.0151368175,
-0.0296073444,
0.026236726,
0.0034292631,
0.0183341466,
-0.0277620237,
0.0097336983,
-0.0640291944,
-0.0021154918,
-0.02824389,
-0.0318765007,
0.0280065201,
-0.0127543742,
-0.0127386926,
0.0620350763,
-0.007428342,
0.0225663148,
0.045611918,
-0.0542924739,
-0.0318574682,
0.0277890898,
0.0126201883,
-0.0179234184,
-0.0527936332,
-0.0697416738,
-0.0173849259,
0.0938423574,
0.0085120816,
0.0139043899,
-0.0348998941,
0.0629274026,
-0.0066841301,
-0.0086111296,
-0.0720101446,
-0.0404125601,
-0.006272845,
0.027651025,
-0.048674494,
-0.0178530794,
0.0677446574,
-0.0253714472,
0.020427892,
-0.0308754761,
0.0022790879,
-0.0305989925,
0.1092749909,
-0.0050525237,
0.0140951592,
-0.0381690897,
-0.0325809754,
-0.0704165772,
-0.0410983153,
0.0264031906,
-0.0480001979,
0.0506248884,
-0.0750588402,
0.0118104536,
0.0095788622,
-0.0486178808,
-0.0182693861,
0.0112429075,
-0.0803001747,
0.003549464,
0.073667258,
-0.0269688219,
-0.0272982214,
0.0128816403,
0.0491421893,
-0.0339525826,
0.0090723494,
-0.0140093016,
-0.0046647629,
0.0256693233,
0.0584684312,
0.0475849546,
0.0302063599,
-0.0567044169,
0.0309081897,
0.0331862755,
0.0174577385,
-0.0270551294,
0.0090611232,
0.0226426087,
0.0236667506,
-0.0188000947,
-0.0255288463,
0.0255834218,
0.0087063927,
-0.0579712912,
-0.016356755,
0.1014765576,
0.0570664071,
-0.0144036366,
0.0029247871,
0.0021937378,
0.0113965124,
0.0230157953,
0.0304474477,
-0.0762674212,
-0.0329438597,
0.0242322255,
-0.0321200714,
0.0139039168,
-0.0599903166,
-0.0233924519,
-0.1205296442,
0.0115891537,
0.0105470112,
-0.0554341376,
-0.0226963703,
-0.0118898349,
-0.0155773386,
-0.0101634664,
0.0069858832,
0.0216868371,
-0.0037313621,
-0.0067032129,
-0.0188847855,
-0.0167682245,
0.0050012507,
0.0597222187,
-0.0125448648,
0.0692486092,
0.0191163942,
0.0466322079,
-0.0596404634,
-0.0708890036,
0.0676412061,
0.0039860234,
-0.0057457737,
-0.0006045135,
0.0372557938,
-0.0031501991,
0.0119641777,
-0.0201271474,
0.0043937289,
-0.0266287047,
-0.0389715768,
-0.0057895151,
0.0770434663,
0.0023223138,
-0.0314256921,
0.0027636434,
-0.0060739662,
-0.0294125546,
0.085863173,
-0.0042330902,
0.0030020727,
-0.0385179594,
-0.0074417987,
0.0067057256,
-0.0314316899,
-0.0380377956,
0.0003711277,
0.0251902547,
0.018969398,
-0.0604562387,
-0.0235812236,
0.0084455889,
0.0048542232,
-0.0081832642,
0.0220755842,
-0.0175857451,
0.0164898187,
-0.0269558877,
0.0366405807,
-0.0197032075,
0.0178533699,
-0.0562751442,
-0.0201512128,
-0.0033197328,
-0.0707679689,
-0.0455722064,
0.0302124284,
-0.037571121,
-0.028315004,
-0.0041747275,
-0.0031186419,
0.0352376029,
-0.0067322399,
0.0160668287,
-0.0305637624,
-0.0045145964,
0.0034922743,
-0.0261600297,
0.0114549864,
-0.010953973,
0.0362320617,
0.0213571563,
0.0317103267,
-0.0341675542,
0.0157652274,
0.0245329123,
0.0709650889,
-0.0300668161,
0.0300407726,
0.0091880066,
0.0350125283,
0.019839948,
0.0000342884,
-0.0029391136,
-0.0076934882,
0.0153862424,
-0.0334464237,
-0.0213659946,
-0.0119365836,
-0.0391170643,
0.0212126207,
-0.0140609667,
0.0198578443,
0.0073618311,
0.0471829548,
0.0193388443,
0.0066279024,
-0.0073670922,
0.0046057552,
-0.0253922027,
0.0049040518,
-0.0034280233,
0.0196585525,
0.0359706655,
-0.0268930309,
0.0657624602,
-0.0088244602,
0.0313139148,
0.026297953,
-0.0452248119,
-0.0345443115,
0.0224003009,
-0.0423645303,
-0.0905734524,
0.0347035043,
0.0257995706,
0.078230612,
-0.0109335864,
-0.0131000374,
-0.0490703322,
0.0077567212,
0.0227040909,
-0.0343226604,
0.0008399917,
-0.04003397,
0.0380680226,
0.0485657156,
0.0031057922,
-0.0068785399,
0.0528416857,
0.0013616432,
0.0200657658,
-0.0055296058,
-0.031073058,
-0.0222748015,
-0.0055961828,
0.0026855653,
0.0331886038,
-0.0253885631,
0.030121224,
-0.0857869461,
-0.0784741193,
-0.028194584,
0.0563588403,
0.0088950051,
0.0268755797,
0.0287767537,
0.0815489143,
0.0016030532,
-0.0537843555,
-0.0186760072,
0.0116092488,
-0.035964217,
-0.0119246664,
-0.0029895972,
-7.055039383e-33,
-0.0291387811,
-0.0623688549,
0.0546845868,
-0.0179113112,
-0.0030749016,
0.0019557271,
-0.0478892513,
0.0266967025,
-0.045241788,
0.0080461912,
-0.0237352625,
0.0165291131,
-0.006931616,
-0.0142709594,
-0.0057239803,
-0.0169172585,
-0.0299952663,
0.031903185,
-0.0324811228,
-0.0285948254,
0.015794633,
-0.0361551121,
0.0356885791,
-0.0341287851,
0.0116423648,
0.0070345472,
-0.0119982036,
0.0233686194,
-0.0404583253,
0.0414410643,
-0.0145453615,
-0.0160432607,
0.0382372774,
-0.0076895831,
0.0312469192,
0.0063833403,
-0.041128464,
-0.0253271684,
0.0441743508,
-0.0540310778,
-0.0301238373,
-0.0378891155,
0.0520238094,
0.0144271618,
-0.0355490409,
-0.0066523873,
0.0283009317,
-0.0161837805,
0.0211925097,
0.0237519983,
-0.0242072083,
0.0027014427,
-0.0364450105,
0.0088479687,
0.0075854496,
-0.0370843671,
-0.0105467141,
-0.0105610574,
-0.0568774343,
0.0648222864,
0.0358653925,
-0.0092857704,
0.0878313705,
-0.0147555145,
0.0081672724,
0.0534181744,
0.0243871678,
-0.0032127327,
-0.0426016003,
0.0046236757,
0.0353219733,
0.0798454434,
0.0470953062,
0.0165826008,
0.0264819469,
-0.0099937525,
-0.0462165102,
-0.0002696408,
0.0073182471,
0.0659143925,
0.031986434,
0.0177353192,
-0.0777244642,
0.000867681,
-0.0315606631,
0.0602528006,
-0.0419368409,
-0.0389052331,
0.0326264054,
-0.0185019299,
0.007360572,
-0.0461048074,
0.0186932497,
-0.0322886035,
-0.0227732733,
0.010436316,
0.0293644108,
0.0126574039,
-0.0089454986,
0.0027139825,
-0.0604055785,
-0.0355897732,
-0.0289333463,
0.0299637243,
0.0133161722,
0.0100181913,
-0.0197449829,
0.0066954419,
-0.0342651457,
-0.0119945323,
-0.0485051014,
0.0071501709,
0.0167860966,
-0.0366923399,
0.0278827138,
-0.007091491,
0.0043805982,
0.0052187908,
0.0126662133,
-0.0116710132,
-0.0266655851,
0.0519593842,
-0.0421202295,
-0.0055115679,
0.0059466208,
0.0081344545,
-0.0362338498,
0.0214384682,
0.0196067505,
-0.0292995237,
-0.0098828943,
0.0067146691,
3.085e-7,
0.0310258381,
0.0893996209,
-0.0383330993,
0.0673528686,
-0.0049773064,
-0.0006217065,
-0.0512575693,
-0.0500752814,
0.0057505821,
-0.0270259734,
0.0189280435,
0.0839715973,
0.0410684198,
0.0599988736,
-0.080382809,
0.0326269753,
-0.0383743122,
-0.004851752,
-0.066197753,
0.0043436498,
0.0538029559,
0.024834862,
0.0323056839,
-0.0008316867,
-0.026821956,
-0.0883840248,
0.0156040508,
-0.0567816347,
0.0101175215,
0.022130264,
0.0026522013,
0.0285023469,
0.001943689,
0.037460383,
-0.0054125767,
0.0212318394,
0.0232701711,
0.0309582241,
-0.0267674085,
-0.029701177,
-0.0375999808,
-0.039719265,
-0.0040584719,
-0.0879781693,
0.0783677846,
-0.0341032408,
-0.0418346711,
0.0259778704,
-0.0217381492,
-0.0288261287,
-0.0018928137,
-0.0220035557,
-0.0365504511,
-0.0084639154,
0.0110390177,
-0.023558965,
0.0165656954,
-0.0506014414,
0.0072706477,
0.0327701643,
-0.0552551635,
-0.0489245467,
-0.0503715202,
-0.0043625953,
0.0095412182,
-0.0551717319,
-0.0315190405,
2.707644938e-34,
0.0271323118,
-0.0065219938,
0.0278997477,
0.0292204544,
0.0800878406,
0.0282377824,
-0.0086801741,
0.0108740088,
0.0147223426,
-0.0881371126,
0.0110916616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11011v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11011v2 | Data Shapley in One Training Run | 2024-06-16T17:09:24 | 2024-06-29T23:05:32 | Jiachen T. Wang, Prateek Mittal, Dawn Song, Ruoxi Jia | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Data Shapley provides a principled framework for attributing data's
contribution within machine learning contexts. However, existing approaches
require re-training models on different data subsets, which is computationally
intensive, foreclosing their application to large-scale models. Furthermore,
they produce the same attribution score for any models produced by running the
learning algorithm, meaning they cannot perform targeted attribution towards a
specific model obtained from a single run of the algorithm. This paper
introduces In-Run Data Shapley, which addresses these limitations by offering
scalable data attribution for a target model of interest. In its most efficient
implementation, our technique incurs negligible additional runtime compared to
standard model training. This dramatic efficiency improvement makes it possible
to perform data attribution for the foundation model pretraining stage for the
first time. We present several case studies that offer fresh insights into
pretraining data's contribution and discuss their implications for copyright in
generative AI and pretraining data curation. | [
0.0056668525,
0.1379715651,
-0.0146809705,
0.0124122277,
-0.0253917687,
0.0218508393,
0.0787975267,
-0.0287881605,
-0.0446518771,
0.0067941728,
-0.0114144646,
0.0151954116,
-0.0284249224,
0.0543584675,
0.0255996138,
-0.0296958182,
-0.0116553735,
0.0372034125,
-0.0365596302,
-0.022173468,
-0.0253951941,
-0.0109702786,
0.0309896152,
0.0226212293,
-0.0527608097,
-0.0142697478,
0.0141395675,
0.0182733759,
0.0328589343,
0.0047549657,
-0.0110829966,
0.0594490282,
0.0055279508,
0.0491019301,
0.0000021513,
-0.0115764234,
-0.0248939265,
0.0476265848,
-0.0305574611,
0.0316397287,
0.0459180176,
0.0243528243,
0.0174709782,
-0.0220470242,
-0.0369001627,
0.0458418801,
0.0520766154,
0.0292264931,
0.0657373965,
0.0175428372,
-0.0278533436,
-0.0128134834,
0.0046660332,
-0.0189382806,
0.0359070189,
-0.0007055149,
-0.0225409474,
0.0135525819,
-0.0575058609,
-0.0571076199,
-0.001380093,
0.0832012147,
0.0500228107,
0.02491864,
0.067699343,
0.0199356321,
-0.0039220876,
-0.0075575514,
0.009811189,
0.056729801,
-0.0496759303,
-0.049350623,
0.0118105365,
-0.0276663098,
0.0309526399,
-0.0147421444,
-0.037943352,
0.0489434749,
0.0357857421,
0.0101934643,
-0.0221869797,
0.0046837083,
0.0473456718,
-0.0057678851,
-0.008822713,
-0.0356134698,
0.0113323545,
0.0054535959,
-0.0018629669,
0.0224309545,
-0.0239844099,
-0.0471499674,
-0.003788797,
-0.0043986184,
-0.0053407508,
-0.0244485792,
-0.0930860192,
0.0007591755,
0.0012048819,
-0.0073922453,
0.0838205665,
-0.0182729624,
-0.0173210762,
0.0296976883,
-0.0248618852,
-0.0242800619,
-0.0270912815,
0.0450036488,
-0.0140663292,
0.003349849,
-0.0517733656,
-0.0113610551,
-0.0223790482,
0.0203897674,
-0.0065288213,
-0.0130780917,
-0.027033573,
0.0320286676,
-0.0541565716,
-0.0200157911,
0.0101301139,
0.0524427518,
-0.0174932424,
0.0312295854,
0.0212096199,
-0.0620146394,
-0.0508069023,
0.0565813035,
0.0285522379,
-0.0718893334,
-0.0421602018,
-0.0044768481,
-0.0090342639,
-0.0046528988,
0.0688489303,
0.0280060321,
0.0246664304,
-0.013862228,
0.0028047028,
-0.0574239045,
0.0500515215,
-0.0393240005,
-0.0070216502,
-0.0339918509,
0.012987107,
-0.0180669539,
0.0288726091,
-0.0293283947,
-0.0395568423,
-0.0049447236,
-0.036422722,
0.0774782971,
0.0107445698,
0.0202204399,
-0.0437188521,
0.0159260426,
-0.0144067388,
0.0013961694,
0.0364172347,
0.0571183376,
-0.0012772322,
-0.0168371256,
0.0294526275,
-0.0138153816,
0.0915743113,
0.023954872,
-0.0007882604,
-0.0043968013,
-0.0196512043,
-0.0479326285,
0.0013130151,
0.0010274379,
-0.0431180187,
0.0111136138,
0.0634829178,
0.0467617139,
0.0196828749,
0.0735682324,
0.0155041898,
-0.0197575018,
0.0006035924,
-0.0584236421,
-0.0421936773,
0.0385882407,
-0.008500698,
-0.0195527896,
-0.0696942657,
0.0498707667,
-0.0255010817,
-0.0182275157,
0.0475456119,
-0.0103653679,
-0.0219465792,
0.0532470904,
0.0169935264,
0.0517688096,
0.0287822336,
0.0201329999,
0.0088651283,
-0.0691670552,
0.0142072923,
-0.0512500778,
0.0022948002,
0.0285630375,
0.0457415804,
-0.0264754165,
0.0371969081,
-0.0257385373,
-0.0059969244,
-0.0161271486,
0.0055570332,
-0.029677188,
0.0473717339,
0.0075730705,
-0.0545327254,
-0.0607108772,
0.0096401135,
0.0360873826,
0.0082845874,
0.006882377,
-0.0096858284,
-0.0057976623,
-0.0408723429,
0.0203443877,
-0.0399686769,
-0.0374862775,
0.0119236754,
-0.0078228274,
0.0476895906,
0.0222636703,
-0.0679928735,
-0.0228531361,
0.0247392021,
0.0046077627,
-0.019228531,
0.0260930452,
-0.0151894484,
0.044547718,
-0.0078708474,
-0.0446617901,
0.01497092,
0.0070552859,
-0.0412004888,
-0.0112938667,
0.0045915693,
0.0128972577,
0.0057614599,
-0.0395829305,
0.0090969186,
-0.0296503901,
0.0360294059,
-0.0006491415,
0.0302510466,
-0.0073589394,
-0.0392390899,
0.0182764567,
0.0055433949,
0.063278608,
0.0020501872,
-0.0107989162,
-0.0030975635,
-0.0271689538,
0.026930159,
0.0054370989,
-0.0353322849,
-0.0060859681,
0.0232901555,
0.0034862785,
0.0093561132,
-0.0146894418,
-0.0005526686,
0.0061211139,
0.015888473,
-0.0127301114,
-0.0449721105,
-0.0275043156,
-0.0246911943,
0.0088813026,
-0.0110443719,
-0.0137026953,
0.0189036615,
0.0142943403,
0.0054907058,
-0.0170707442,
0.0308886338,
0.0243270732,
0.040012408,
0.0431093462,
-0.030084895,
0.0127403429,
-0.0072794422,
0.0101019219,
-0.0009457277,
-0.0046494263,
0.0057370365,
0.0018950307,
-0.0354014821,
0.0674348548,
-0.0270264,
0.0260793008,
0.0330027975,
0.0002180707,
-0.0301377587,
-0.0130007453,
-0.0205488373,
-0.0184189025,
-0.015137692,
-0.0155813703,
0.0114898933,
0.0008514009,
-0.0171304084,
-0.0429600291,
-0.0395965017,
0.0715005621,
0.0234421156,
-0.0817662925,
-0.0263855122,
0.025884036,
0.0082466714,
0.0086642196,
-0.0325900279,
-0.093665868,
0.0261455495,
-0.016754806,
0.0164047554,
0.0358776115,
-0.0016383979,
-0.0024103317,
0.0663149804,
0.0027364013,
0.0219714884,
-0.0138509031,
-0.0037960596,
-0.0373888686,
0.0417754352,
0.074536711,
-0.0272363406,
-0.0538515188,
-0.0159596745,
-0.0023540754,
0.0039656525,
-0.0451143011,
-0.0211422835,
-0.0259163789,
0.0407168008,
0.0320647918,
-0.0060826973,
-0.0302719604,
0.0086845923,
-0.0448458716,
0.0176174156,
0.0221993532,
0.0118747298,
-0.0037161177,
-0.001307281,
-0.0210141838,
0.0125644356,
-0.0148667591,
0.0155418133,
-0.0027534692,
-0.0300333891,
0.0299139991,
0.0643617809,
0.0192489214,
-0.0258559026,
0.0379189067,
0.0040087244,
-0.0061991201,
0.0205683261,
0.01530114,
0.0356518924,
-0.014469062,
-0.0032900525,
0.0587822944,
0.0103672221,
-0.0217457358,
-0.0033979195,
0.0077120052,
0.0250079371,
0.0352133922,
0.0013842138,
-0.1069793776,
-0.0006791023,
-0.0135492906,
0.0413010381,
-0.0224128515,
-0.0356307216,
0.0224699136,
-0.0499586239,
0.0493442863,
0.0123866796,
-0.0214255862,
-0.0067338459,
-0.0075965729,
-0.0257084295,
-0.0659413636,
-0.0670523494,
-0.0582380891,
-0.0070220251,
0.0320844874,
0.0305493996,
0.0763969421,
-0.0259040836,
-0.0018027187,
-0.0662579089,
0.010997735,
0.1154298484,
0.0136055481,
-0.0012815102,
0.0076993401,
-0.0514308177,
0.019453058,
0.0122218207,
-0.000217659,
0.0713176355,
-0.0050206818,
-0.0160440784,
-0.0044703698,
0.042132929,
-0.0035251188,
-0.0079807648,
-0.0031950811,
0.048126284,
0.0118472325,
-0.0137736602,
-0.0236997232,
-0.0863035396,
0.0363785699,
0.059935715,
0.0438951664,
-0.0225340035,
-0.0488163307,
-0.0356883444,
0.0009879681,
-0.0322835892,
-0.0377432816,
0.0005195382,
-0.0355248116,
-0.0536094308,
-0.0648793504,
-0.0255800635,
-0.0320338942,
0.0637494847,
0.0100884521,
-0.041757673,
-0.0099732541,
-0.0367006063,
-0.0818479508,
0.0086822864,
-0.0393412672,
0.0048624496,
-0.0066287005,
-0.0587502569,
0.0125116464,
-0.0233980846,
-0.0330422521,
0.0109018227,
-0.0743862838,
-0.0088196928,
0.041471649,
0.0820456818,
0.0255451333,
0.0454226024,
-0.0123453075,
-0.047000505,
0.1514784098,
0.0723436996,
-0.0096078906,
0.0147758229,
0.0488658063,
-0.0916277766,
0.0039114407,
-0.0036845526,
-0.0260790978,
0.0521270186,
0.0940585881,
-0.0180193111,
-0.006551893,
0.0471894108,
0.004388331,
0.0196796004,
0.023071751,
-0.0251238216,
-0.0108321914,
0.0023934315,
-0.0018581847,
0.0373725221,
-0.0087898746,
-0.0844198838,
-0.0037711458,
0.0518877655,
0.0127042048,
-0.0158314724,
0.0486328229,
0.0428762212,
0.0419935323,
-0.0930798128,
-0.0142688034,
0.0206226129,
0.0447759852,
0.0131987091,
0.0212875605,
0.0314476602,
0.0126159573,
0.00811157,
0.0297843311,
0.0022957977,
-0.0092642726,
0.0290501323,
0.0355483778,
-0.0056593991,
0.0589689836,
-0.0896598771,
-0.0563387796,
-0.0626486838,
0.0024981189,
0.0359384567,
0.0223436486,
0.0292201471,
-0.0349606015,
-0.0116208773,
-0.0020131138,
0.0422328115,
-0.024454914,
-0.0503523163,
-0.0612651035,
-0.02600177,
-0.0217261929,
-0.0171325002,
0.0543689132,
0.0204834472,
0.0790748894,
-0.084101215,
-0.032356564,
-0.0163504053,
-0.0639631152,
0.0356165692,
-0.0225330219,
0.0075927321,
0.0109544033,
-0.0138423732,
-0.0822159797,
-0.0327180736,
0.0165247004,
0.0473663099,
0.0039308588,
-0.0036819447,
0.0218091626,
-0.0423723795,
-0.0331328623,
-0.0117749926,
-0.0105355196,
-0.0065202564,
-0.0309703723,
0.0144162672,
-6.358685346e-33,
0.0103072878,
0.0168938376,
-0.0095755272,
0.0216695759,
-0.0207285192,
-0.0030225073,
-0.0101843383,
-0.0326834694,
0.0200946461,
-0.003006055,
-0.0417188033,
0.0315328762,
0.0063485857,
0.0107259257,
0.0243831649,
-0.0439951792,
0.0685904548,
0.0108449329,
-0.0351340622,
0.0963415802,
0.0076954397,
0.0185089912,
0.0376875773,
-0.0593511686,
-0.0034246473,
-0.0281739477,
-0.0314836279,
-0.0220897868,
-0.0470118411,
0.0196897443,
0.0028539607,
-0.0117358062,
0.0028260478,
-0.0563907549,
-0.0306246225,
-0.026723709,
-0.0786409751,
0.0010168401,
-0.0289133508,
-0.0090180682,
-0.0209391005,
-0.0078867702,
0.030760698,
0.0006620659,
-0.001862675,
-0.0336419009,
0.0218039677,
-0.0206308495,
0.0052615334,
-0.0751037747,
-0.0444944911,
-0.016852662,
-0.0474906079,
0.0124306176,
0.0594257303,
-0.0556251928,
0.0044135852,
0.007992818,
-0.0461621135,
0.0211398154,
0.0251605492,
-0.0546213351,
0.0664538816,
0.0456144996,
0.0725153163,
0.0546672381,
0.0265623406,
-0.0166889895,
0.0091531044,
0.0220792051,
0.003231196,
0.0825942829,
0.0300495364,
0.0686029121,
0.0900087729,
-0.0201952979,
-0.0444339141,
0.0368962549,
0.0146597214,
-0.0159476716,
0.0070873047,
0.0022730071,
-0.0050157108,
0.004835017,
-0.0654325783,
-0.0799315199,
-0.0150136659,
-0.0219895896,
0.0304275118,
0.0249289274,
-0.041506622,
0.0716308504,
0.0338160843,
-0.0740188956,
-0.0019126905,
0.012041959,
-0.0019307788,
0.0295142066,
0.0180061832,
-0.0226074681,
-0.0283489935,
-0.0206612833,
0.0478763841,
-0.0152413528,
0.0650688335,
-0.0022043209,
0.0830784887,
0.051236663,
-0.012892141,
0.0143209165,
-0.0249692053,
0.0240055975,
0.0463350639,
-0.0112667084,
0.0083424496,
0.0348637737,
0.0011372463,
-0.0164705515,
0.0059720441,
0.0448802672,
-0.0451981127,
-0.004859475,
-0.0268043503,
-0.0105238007,
-0.0317564569,
-0.0168182924,
-0.0357911587,
-0.040542338,
0.0533794388,
-0.0654014573,
-0.0385506749,
-0.0159847979,
2.859e-7,
-0.0004517044,
-0.011056439,
-0.0085821068,
-0.012210561,
0.0043010386,
0.0247178636,
-0.0019136701,
0.0787913054,
-0.0021443984,
0.0034594808,
0.0153576499,
0.0229335055,
0.045989193,
-0.0131299505,
-0.0247675087,
-0.0701219067,
-0.0483796969,
0.0185908806,
-0.0332710408,
0.0092303501,
-0.0318325236,
0.0442465544,
0.0643278807,
-0.0521034375,
0.072068952,
0.0055563571,
0.0339281596,
-0.0429393537,
0.0430601984,
0.0185244735,
0.0316361301,
0.0207414683,
-0.0088049034,
-0.0043295166,
-0.0361265801,
0.0143130096,
-0.0118353684,
0.0245019086,
0.0087083196,
0.0064452207,
-0.0608264655,
-0.0469329543,
0.0541104786,
-0.0171512254,
0.0263603982,
0.0105604092,
-0.0208898727,
-0.0350209698,
-0.0364077613,
-0.0438778698,
0.0144898072,
-0.0005082544,
0.084353976,
0.0002287761,
-0.0086800605,
0.0185851119,
-0.0062247645,
-0.0746746212,
-0.0039019962,
-0.053081952,
-0.0297646411,
-0.0226734057,
-0.0161435641,
-0.0228059776,
0.0420877747,
-0.0632259101,
0.0284404997,
2.481238986e-34,
-0.011021696,
-0.0006365143,
0.057745479,
0.0152982259,
0.0224586725,
0.0104127415,
0.0293341316,
-0.0366951562,
0.018737128,
-0.0152072953,
-0.026347613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11911v1 | A Notion of Complexity for Theory of Mind via Discrete World Models | 2024-06-16T16:46:55 | 2024-06-16T16:46:55 | X. Angelo Huang, Emanuele La Malfa, Samuele Marro, Andrea Asperti, Anthony Cohn, Michael Wooldridge | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Theory of Mind (ToM) can be used to assess the capabilities of Large Language
Models (LLMs) in complex scenarios where social reasoning is required. While
the research community has proposed many ToM benchmarks, their hardness varies
greatly, and their complexity is not well defined. This work proposes a
framework to measure the complexity of ToM tasks. We quantify a problem's
complexity as the number of states necessary to solve it correctly. Our
complexity measure also accounts for spurious states of a ToM problem designed
to make it apparently harder. We use our method to assess the complexity of
five widely adopted ToM benchmarks. On top of this framework, we design a
prompting technique that augments the information available to a model with a
description of how the environment changes with the agents' interactions. We
name this technique Discrete World Models (DWM) and show how it elicits
superior performance on ToM tasks. | [
0.0557419546,
0.0283577815,
-0.03351634,
0.0257174857,
-0.0864675194,
0.0114680659,
0.0045691351,
0.0145846792,
0.0595329776,
-0.0091900276,
0.0063821208,
-0.0611685179,
0.048885446,
0.0138295144,
0.0385328233,
-0.0341686457,
0.0229843687,
-0.0765871778,
0.0007155183,
-0.0303865466,
-0.0668917894,
-0.0140315238,
-0.0084634488,
0.0136444662,
0.0276211854,
0.0190009121,
-0.0351422615,
-0.0073776706,
0.044903364,
-0.0354923196,
-0.0641952008,
0.016948618,
0.0183985513,
0.0330864824,
0.000002179,
-0.0851745903,
-0.0086316913,
0.0169071537,
-0.0236960351,
-0.0096093956,
0.003892926,
0.0072080358,
0.0264029689,
0.0268757194,
-0.0351259634,
-0.0049569965,
0.030475378,
0.0597992018,
0.0034507436,
0.0502112247,
-0.0098967561,
0.0088066394,
0.0118353786,
-0.0225835964,
0.0264983196,
-0.0928888917,
0.0552579835,
-0.0191638414,
0.0658568665,
-0.0324728973,
-0.0147501742,
0.0207288004,
0.0004400611,
0.0281435605,
-0.0261393748,
0.0100173932,
0.003893265,
0.0004885764,
-0.0039038623,
0.0743047222,
0.0987854227,
0.025196366,
-0.0024946257,
0.0060618697,
0.0256572217,
0.0417391211,
0.0251969658,
0.0367938057,
-0.0089737615,
-0.0017505592,
0.0120815299,
0.0478222184,
0.0134186707,
0.0065608867,
-0.0356000476,
0.1040460616,
-0.0116477003,
-0.0074474341,
0.0046351049,
-0.0181577746,
-0.0318883583,
-0.071239017,
-0.0494388007,
0.0122098178,
-0.0481687523,
0.0067547401,
-0.0139788687,
0.0461692177,
-0.0112992274,
-0.020589361,
0.0814750344,
0.0392217226,
0.0367491096,
0.0649248958,
0.0146795148,
0.056455154,
0.0007230732,
-0.0256192572,
-0.0279893596,
0.005792981,
-0.0679293051,
0.0247402731,
-0.0495619886,
0.0388451628,
0.0081964107,
-0.0252513159,
0.0190567728,
-0.0073255943,
-0.0439011417,
0.0206257738,
-0.0282256752,
-0.0320302919,
0.0179331135,
-0.0125344321,
-0.0485301055,
0.0072367857,
-0.0680769309,
0.0193273295,
0.0069686845,
-0.0606301501,
0.0052339099,
-0.0389846079,
0.0330765359,
0.0220989436,
-0.015668802,
0.0664532185,
0.0303535871,
-0.0425170846,
-0.0079136519,
-0.0296847783,
-0.0125116026,
-0.0763712898,
-0.0062488299,
-0.0308994018,
0.0104637425,
-0.0012243604,
-0.0216234196,
0.0005516707,
0.0175784454,
-0.041808717,
-0.0588126667,
0.0668513402,
0.0106189726,
0.0264570266,
-0.0021051697,
0.0193372313,
0.0101622725,
0.0351990834,
0.0102186892,
-0.0243830979,
0.0204778649,
0.0348739363,
0.0440697111,
0.0298505649,
-0.0162096117,
0.0175937433,
-0.0138178617,
0.0083896639,
0.0340410098,
0.029742917,
-0.0374711417,
0.0663009733,
-0.0175670497,
0.0140200043,
0.0294149946,
0.0536460653,
-0.0084050484,
-0.0142980758,
0.0205417741,
0.0512172021,
0.021332914,
0.0335058942,
-0.0418900251,
0.0418355763,
-0.0579852797,
-0.0274509471,
0.0316940807,
0.0019616929,
-0.0499332584,
-0.0196928214,
-0.0098588774,
0.0155680589,
0.0708110407,
0.0110815465,
0.0266848318,
-0.0233804546,
-0.0327737704,
0.0240329243,
0.0204253476,
-0.0210441072,
-0.04683052,
-0.0769530162,
0.019202387,
0.0390170328,
0.0428466387,
-0.0366744027,
0.0030878901,
-0.0062409095,
0.0067876587,
0.0476062484,
0.0645577759,
0.0090099499,
-0.0069864383,
-0.0154527063,
-0.0272402409,
-0.0335648619,
0.0225333311,
0.0295822453,
-0.0049734227,
-0.0098730205,
-0.0130024143,
-0.0168199856,
0.00639618,
-0.0151286339,
0.0034223555,
-0.0206807107,
-0.0659061745,
0.0384740047,
0.0378888398,
0.0074289478,
-0.0067824181,
0.0195447821,
-0.0169337671,
-0.0289840475,
0.0048898314,
0.020830499,
-0.0124343652,
0.0135032497,
0.0348863155,
-0.0120315002,
-0.0031872208,
0.0607808642,
0.000910179,
-0.0245991293,
0.0402151123,
-0.0316584408,
0.0527342707,
0.0180547126,
0.0314361192,
-0.0562926345,
-0.0190106314,
0.0074794977,
0.0583161749,
-0.0198904816,
0.0247245692,
0.00161464,
-0.0425080024,
0.0447058082,
-0.0053938879,
-0.0140197659,
-0.0117512895,
-0.0062038917,
-0.0105008585,
0.0375974774,
-0.0118390508,
-0.033881098,
-0.0541763045,
-0.0804543495,
-0.0590203777,
0.0165879522,
-0.0182214454,
-0.0233075265,
0.0047154538,
-0.0099315122,
0.0241192281,
-0.0518398657,
0.0578966215,
0.0242670141,
0.0134195685,
0.0247507729,
0.0332474895,
-0.0881993398,
-0.0318230763,
0.0289831664,
-0.026804734,
0.0294050798,
0.0128152892,
-0.0538529046,
-0.0392342508,
0.0577919893,
-0.0564672388,
0.0507867448,
-0.0512222499,
-0.023366157,
0.0344351493,
0.0039917585,
0.0396616682,
0.0769244507,
-0.0345260054,
0.0044202153,
0.062277019,
-0.0141533893,
-0.0183186885,
0.0082615204,
0.0222001802,
-0.021612836,
-0.0430422463,
-0.0784501731,
0.0015352803,
0.0581625253,
0.0067772977,
-0.0169147961,
-0.0600812547,
0.0292865094,
-0.0409810208,
-0.0333395451,
-0.0068937731,
-0.0190424658,
0.0039575417,
0.0602460392,
-0.0222564433,
-0.0222419947,
0.0561832748,
-0.0349089392,
0.0173837971,
-0.0103036705,
0.0290656947,
-0.0277282856,
0.0939121693,
0.035510473,
0.0495604575,
0.0508291572,
0.0088292789,
-0.0597856678,
-0.0541965179,
-0.0096116476,
-0.0004784754,
-0.034244366,
-0.0734932497,
0.0110304989,
-0.0139511218,
-0.0243900791,
-0.009866355,
0.0193995684,
-0.06202792,
0.0191379413,
-0.0063364636,
-0.0128173865,
-0.0133735221,
0.0009702063,
0.0497739539,
-0.0013756298,
-0.0035459073,
-0.0188945662,
-0.0239949003,
-0.0173364338,
0.0153220799,
0.0319071971,
0.0301384218,
-0.0366551392,
0.0450880378,
0.0264306478,
0.0381304845,
0.0830879211,
0.0123203974,
0.0068870373,
0.0303314924,
0.0255742632,
-0.0299859736,
0.0523714498,
0.0635755807,
-0.0075207297,
0.0032365702,
0.0923040062,
0.0252205152,
-0.0101138419,
0.0060246927,
-0.0453575328,
-0.0283091422,
0.0225662775,
0.0181951765,
-0.029966535,
-0.0011820975,
0.0252059307,
-0.0368036777,
-0.0462548807,
-0.0725267977,
-0.0049455781,
-0.076747939,
-0.0007595208,
0.0041206661,
0.0100978538,
-0.0210133474,
-0.0034217527,
0.0280281734,
0.0522213578,
-0.0385459065,
0.0060335342,
0.0267013479,
-0.0068328413,
-0.0187098496,
-0.0050769076,
-0.0330917574,
0.0798839033,
-0.0118552363,
0.1057348177,
0.0574731268,
0.0477702841,
-0.0043099006,
-0.0806656033,
0.0202243328,
0.0722607821,
0.0042915815,
-0.0009441004,
-0.0048447545,
0.0195169449,
-0.0082417624,
-0.0216931291,
0.0173783135,
-0.0075689945,
0.0244584512,
-0.0058435109,
0.0407080986,
0.0186504833,
-0.0226905961,
0.0372020081,
0.009173301,
-0.0013603988,
0.0800893083,
0.0288284849,
-0.0395504981,
0.0282563027,
-0.0216646288,
-0.0302169248,
0.0084503181,
-0.0363638066,
0.0076067965,
0.024151329,
-0.0280544534,
-0.0280525032,
-0.0108669056,
0.0387760065,
0.0470713452,
0.0188632067,
-0.0230234154,
0.0629005432,
0.0166077521,
-0.0165189374,
-0.0120945489,
-0.0719785988,
0.0443559848,
-0.0289274044,
-0.026663715,
0.0139276534,
-0.0266560707,
-0.0080539463,
-0.0170345344,
-0.0383011289,
-0.0506806299,
0.0025193072,
0.0094225099,
0.0316258967,
-0.0008705626,
-0.0111435857,
-0.0244575664,
0.002491799,
-0.0651627779,
-0.0440770909,
0.0857293531,
0.0234436542,
0.0527720042,
0.0221667979,
0.0643666312,
-0.0109071396,
-0.0017044478,
0.0114427079,
0.0285556335,
-0.020621324,
-0.0186094642,
0.0022294498,
0.0327590294,
-0.0167595856,
0.0187124796,
-0.0099081667,
-0.0018182236,
-0.0380034521,
-0.0312222056,
-0.0244964063,
-0.0807780325,
-0.0141481385,
0.0300759133,
0.0517945215,
0.0186236016,
-0.0648296997,
-0.0087449057,
-0.0120179569,
0.0286194496,
0.004304463,
0.003364502,
0.0212576687,
0.0436751321,
0.0052746618,
-0.0253671296,
-0.0070163296,
-0.0473336615,
0.0152130723,
0.0217913669,
0.0925428048,
0.033718124,
-0.0196919981,
-0.0428763442,
0.0273956098,
-0.0494255424,
-0.1039963961,
0.0751665905,
0.0541289449,
0.0035472703,
0.0085134674,
-0.0286114793,
-0.054401841,
0.0200260263,
0.0126119955,
-0.003412181,
0.0152085675,
-0.0599132739,
0.0026067661,
0.0310983825,
0.0007321872,
0.0329486802,
0.0423431061,
0.0008125157,
0.0327422544,
0.0086918147,
0.0186419617,
-0.0443476476,
0.0265837722,
-0.0121605946,
0.0756201297,
-0.0095318211,
0.0645512789,
-0.1101821363,
-0.0271276236,
0.019662682,
0.0262916815,
-0.004884298,
-0.0067941397,
0.0365176052,
0.0402887985,
0.0036706117,
-0.0282735024,
-0.0185860507,
-0.0476405583,
-0.0181001462,
-0.0020822813,
0.0027052243,
-6.514119495e-33,
-0.060882736,
-0.0341812149,
0.0043174261,
-0.0181770138,
-0.0259693898,
-0.0150654251,
-0.0688875094,
0.0399789736,
-0.0244979113,
-0.0103064021,
-0.0062681451,
0.0021569664,
-0.0108843017,
-0.0099561876,
-0.0346909761,
0.0015716702,
0.0080979532,
-0.0166596696,
-0.0519642271,
-0.0314626284,
0.0015960984,
-0.0411561504,
-0.0088196844,
-0.0527227893,
0.0487074926,
0.0286571085,
-0.0105256578,
0.0231997538,
-0.0265650284,
-0.0322813094,
-0.0325152352,
0.0214829184,
0.0179207101,
-0.0318204649,
0.0079707969,
0.0167568438,
-0.0338250734,
-0.0463236086,
0.0591106601,
-0.0265354775,
0.0063968939,
-0.0420544781,
-0.0265843812,
-0.0037786749,
-0.0284567028,
0.0184513647,
0.007167106,
-0.0182860531,
0.000167045,
0.066045925,
-0.0587876737,
-0.0164347235,
-0.0121535826,
-0.0335371867,
0.0087346258,
0.0042783492,
-0.0052096602,
-0.0458011478,
-0.0308121461,
0.0302556772,
0.061438296,
-0.0095816497,
0.009347721,
-0.0369048454,
0.0493852422,
0.0554977134,
0.057356637,
0.0132652689,
-0.0280605052,
-0.0263822097,
0.0088987667,
0.0650820881,
0.0172852296,
0.0395023301,
-0.0182393473,
-0.0199959651,
-0.0362346657,
-0.0076469649,
-0.0030522994,
0.0263760667,
0.0441047251,
-0.0100789284,
-0.0691391528,
-0.059676934,
-0.0332352147,
-0.0020550455,
-0.0246702675,
0.0366390981,
0.020926103,
-0.0006658528,
-0.0357026272,
-0.0882666484,
0.0292439107,
-0.0519622862,
-0.0034603185,
-0.0214112829,
0.0178936962,
0.0390014909,
-0.0040562144,
0.0066222278,
-0.0403737947,
-0.0315267891,
-0.0307916682,
0.0221947301,
0.0313255005,
0.0079861209,
-0.0496653579,
0.019199444,
-0.0548256561,
-0.0015431548,
-0.0330529958,
0.0095592802,
0.0071440558,
-0.0076960768,
0.0161819328,
-0.0207903422,
-0.0089595793,
-0.0460157469,
-0.0377902873,
-0.0790426731,
-0.0254342668,
0.0716977865,
-0.0372460634,
0.015991563,
-0.0216999575,
-0.0318104066,
-0.0375929438,
0.0195327234,
0.0684232563,
0.0274979323,
-0.0215251911,
-0.0092944568,
2.969e-7,
-0.0490726195,
0.0386405401,
-0.012164264,
0.0072647328,
0.0256901588,
0.0758957118,
-0.0323452801,
0.013928595,
0.0145365745,
-0.0321384892,
0.0024735255,
0.0612055473,
0.0295083355,
-0.0019162699,
-0.0509993806,
0.0058670482,
0.043224901,
-0.0311975386,
-0.0028797996,
0.0232667346,
0.0129600856,
0.0124204895,
0.0411046445,
0.0352752507,
-0.0096729705,
-0.0461054035,
0.0236018654,
-0.083030872,
0.0272391494,
0.0008873059,
0.0160708427,
-0.01617378,
0.0008174769,
0.0227249973,
0.0505935848,
0.0461732075,
-0.0325489901,
0.0208922122,
0.0058619631,
-0.005365368,
-0.0274645053,
-0.0299973208,
-0.0296062604,
-0.0344059728,
0.0354972929,
-0.0496548265,
-0.0705665424,
0.0254370626,
0.0550658293,
0.0023499851,
-0.0235292949,
0.0623860024,
-0.0212763455,
-0.0089697568,
0.0031469085,
-0.0330606587,
0.0432034135,
-0.043931555,
0.029325366,
-0.0662822649,
0.0167022347,
-0.1058058664,
-0.0275847092,
-0.0069442028,
0.002703513,
-0.0659162328,
0.0086949952,
2.77059266e-34,
0.0307587627,
-0.004324934,
0.0478774272,
-0.0189478528,
0.0584992878,
-0.0260447506,
-0.0658308938,
0.0107489983,
0.0502312258,
-0.1123625562,
0.0016499786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10999v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10999v1 | Not All Bias is Bad: Balancing Rational Deviations and Cognitive Biases in Large Language Model Reasoning | 2024-06-16T16:25:22 | 2024-06-16T16:25:22 | Liman Wang, Hanyang Zhong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper investigates the nuanced role of biases in the decision-making
processes of large language models (LLMs). While conventional research
typically aims to eliminate all biases, our study reveals that not all biases
are detrimental. By examining rational deviations, involving heuristic
shortcuts that enhance decision-making efficiency, we highlight their potential
benefits when properly balanced. We introduce the concepts of heuristic
moderation and an abstention option, allowing LLMs to abstain from answering
when uncertain, thereby reducing error rates and improving decision accuracy.
Using our newly developed BRD (Balance Rational Deviations) dataset, our
findings demonstrate that appropriately scaled bias inspection enhances model
performance and aligns LLM decision-making more closely with human reasoning.
This balance improves the reliability and trustworthiness of LLMs and suggests
new strategies for future enhancements. Our work offers a fresh perspective on
leveraging biases constructively to enhance the practical applications of LLMs,
from conversational agents to decision support systems and beyond. | [
0.051302623,
0.069477804,
-0.0154401632,
0.0302567985,
-0.0391608812,
0.0138020664,
0.0187051427,
-0.0038716604,
0.0406010523,
-0.0474772789,
-0.0235839654,
-0.0607401617,
-0.0013162869,
-0.0007402966,
0.0010762678,
-0.0346958935,
0.0302616786,
-0.0616192259,
0.1028269082,
-0.0542111248,
-0.0080818255,
0.0183592159,
-0.0102443397,
0.0419704318,
0.0024116701,
-0.0095674926,
0.0169055648,
-0.0033643984,
0.0052046608,
-0.0218841527,
-0.0124716451,
0.0432203151,
-0.0125576146,
0.0402450971,
0.0000021827,
-0.0891183764,
0.0037105731,
-0.0158865694,
-0.0742166117,
0.0149417548,
0.0325987488,
0.0387967378,
0.0007257884,
0.0391957276,
-0.039772369,
0.0330867544,
0.0343878232,
0.0286021791,
0.0162683856,
0.0293672327,
0.0032841007,
0.0096824495,
-0.037679486,
-0.0016175783,
0.002499654,
-0.0640999004,
0.0264098924,
0.0271020439,
-0.0216058102,
0.0081765987,
-0.0094703063,
0.0101364497,
-0.0019115891,
-0.0137314843,
-0.0243110601,
0.037867561,
0.0095182089,
-0.0707479119,
-0.0137673495,
0.0510444567,
0.0264258459,
-0.0199065395,
-0.0143587403,
-0.0352679342,
0.0275452696,
0.0045864247,
-0.0501598753,
0.0483525284,
-0.0084211398,
0.0055815028,
-0.0068455688,
0.0018635701,
0.0369011685,
0.0338781886,
-0.0447153673,
0.0757643357,
-0.0120922923,
-0.021375386,
0.0302664451,
0.0033838055,
0.006020877,
-0.0905557051,
-0.0225765705,
0.0530899055,
-0.0770877078,
0.0150701487,
-0.0196765885,
0.041261375,
0.021212155,
-0.0394587442,
0.0051278481,
0.0419721305,
0.0441496558,
0.0510893688,
0.0228666086,
0.0049348879,
-0.0042479075,
-0.0158136953,
-0.0124978144,
-0.0058739716,
-0.0019716551,
-0.0248658881,
-0.0184208937,
0.0065127704,
-0.0254887883,
-0.0153820673,
-0.0196731482,
0.0152577097,
-0.0263103079,
0.0270384755,
0.0134694995,
0.0147939557,
0.0129936459,
-0.0300057959,
-0.0988264084,
0.0260363463,
-0.0563708581,
0.0639988258,
0.0003201496,
-0.0847577676,
-0.0024199653,
0.0134779895,
-0.0122295404,
-0.0369549058,
0.0066501056,
0.0522217676,
-0.0110283839,
-0.0109359277,
-0.0332346708,
-0.0295445137,
-0.019985063,
-0.1053725854,
-0.0257385392,
-0.0571863614,
0.0119131459,
0.0387096852,
-0.0201371666,
-0.0439008437,
0.0060009779,
0.0064378888,
-0.0609831475,
0.068747811,
-0.0049593518,
0.0418426506,
0.0184598956,
0.0016128999,
-0.0311949179,
0.0861150846,
0.0474351123,
0.0139839482,
0.0412897356,
-0.0256922208,
0.0209643506,
0.0022669155,
0.0006051256,
0.0208708737,
-0.039848946,
0.04272414,
-0.0204758421,
0.0007670703,
0.0296604466,
0.0674205199,
-0.0426750258,
0.0082869176,
0.094863385,
0.0428097472,
-0.0224869177,
0.0128978547,
-0.0007762689,
0.0304230861,
-0.0040724524,
-0.0256209951,
-0.0632886365,
0.0271270517,
-0.0325496569,
-0.0129248397,
0.0266224165,
0.0282762796,
-0.0299917888,
-0.0417833775,
-0.0065255794,
0.0178665388,
0.044859387,
0.0560769923,
0.0152199967,
-0.0394118056,
-0.009831992,
0.0723799318,
0.0045189708,
-0.0335913673,
-0.0371905118,
-0.0580818392,
0.062523298,
0.0517130308,
0.0145843476,
-0.0003076043,
-0.0119859241,
0.0011949223,
0.015698038,
0.0091792019,
0.103049539,
-0.0050254147,
-0.0062433975,
-0.0658648387,
-0.0287752226,
0.0132994354,
0.0216977093,
-0.005483666,
0.0212516896,
0.0208143387,
-0.0033667921,
-0.0540563203,
-0.008250745,
-0.007354483,
0.0078883749,
-0.021749815,
-0.0264388956,
-0.000140902,
0.0423964076,
-0.0090347556,
0.0106239878,
0.0244115815,
-0.0037469168,
0.043243736,
-0.0496882312,
0.0116710616,
-0.0254422016,
0.0175393112,
0.0454255678,
0.0101400241,
-0.044463139,
-0.0203808807,
-0.0171436146,
-0.0273332968,
0.0174636561,
-0.0255377404,
0.0087429481,
-0.0156702213,
0.0340568163,
-0.0333931707,
0.0081562391,
-0.0316342935,
0.0485793352,
-0.0008808496,
-0.0106467325,
0.0181554612,
-0.0082789324,
0.0103482716,
-0.0504974909,
0.0018998026,
0.0277298186,
0.0164032187,
0.0116406325,
0.0270734783,
0.0041299718,
-0.0481844693,
-0.0312089603,
-0.0795880184,
-0.0182098821,
0.0042473688,
0.0064760647,
-0.0150271859,
-0.0087441336,
-0.0186019242,
-0.0009230272,
-0.0214251988,
0.0003761804,
0.0357185118,
0.0444069952,
0.0186626855,
-0.0191877913,
-0.033912167,
-0.0261040684,
-0.0075303684,
-0.0104595609,
0.0157184005,
0.0331736021,
0.0295112263,
-0.0511139929,
0.0099855093,
-0.0423185825,
0.0147223882,
-0.0000396126,
-0.0276473593,
0.017858211,
0.0094752274,
-0.0149117196,
0.0737891719,
0.0036561319,
-0.0014349745,
0.0546626486,
-0.0097467601,
-0.083040297,
0.0186967831,
-0.0030909604,
-0.0180903412,
-0.0548686907,
-0.0310268942,
-0.031476099,
0.0502203107,
0.0049347035,
0.0010018976,
-0.0563508533,
0.0662091896,
-0.001816893,
-0.0512246229,
-0.0045446851,
-0.0359065831,
0.0108651575,
0.1020508111,
0.0096966764,
-0.0394632295,
0.0737678111,
-0.0102332067,
0.0155578526,
-0.0263876691,
0.0177454893,
-0.0277178306,
0.0339648128,
-0.0387094207,
0.0084058903,
0.0076171635,
-0.0017798168,
-0.0469179414,
-0.0560302697,
0.0068125632,
-0.0368727259,
0.0401662998,
-0.0623976365,
0.0011214314,
-0.0137828328,
-0.0467692912,
-0.040520478,
-0.0264060572,
-0.0924791172,
-0.0013812407,
0.0496602394,
-0.0242264327,
-0.0507011004,
-0.0008044694,
0.0217749644,
-0.004207301,
-0.0193671156,
-0.0134792216,
0.0028740021,
-0.0166616552,
0.0416809916,
0.0508344769,
0.0945271328,
-0.008593047,
0.0578718893,
0.0572326258,
0.0152857462,
0.0112949535,
-0.0052364431,
-0.0091861682,
0.0430329591,
0.0025060819,
0.0047245696,
0.0554604754,
0.0695729256,
-0.0179849658,
-0.0000427022,
0.1222593784,
0.0300161541,
-0.04019944,
0.003148044,
-0.0578228123,
0.0633349419,
0.0344235003,
-0.0008827743,
-0.0631567016,
-0.0476101376,
0.0373163968,
0.0168131422,
-0.035381604,
-0.0429635011,
0.0039576036,
-0.1405166686,
0.0473366678,
0.0106408726,
0.0278902017,
-0.0119311335,
-0.0456503443,
0.0060361698,
-0.0353885069,
0.0355801173,
0.0318800621,
0.0065286891,
-0.0224200375,
0.0037278591,
-0.0366874412,
-0.0557434894,
0.0368539244,
-0.0137826875,
0.0400217026,
0.0129021099,
0.0367011987,
0.002493494,
-0.0206524488,
0.0393676311,
0.0029208895,
-0.0124333836,
-0.0114733912,
0.0275969077,
0.0144943036,
0.0004205029,
-0.0391424559,
0.0416358151,
0.0048335674,
-0.0104296105,
0.0229354203,
0.0762643889,
-0.0220689159,
-0.0310577936,
-0.0205325224,
0.0180976037,
0.0242539328,
0.0879536942,
0.01266558,
-0.0533597767,
-0.0436287783,
-0.0322712995,
-0.0377111323,
-0.0077157388,
-0.019775698,
0.0223460142,
0.0334046409,
0.0143695893,
-0.0196908247,
-0.0468947664,
0.0363295265,
0.0082699964,
-0.0027147152,
-0.0371581018,
0.01231803,
0.0120024197,
0.02637114,
0.0338538326,
-0.0517196245,
0.0446840227,
-0.0158510171,
0.0464974381,
-0.0223041624,
-0.040773429,
-0.0036444203,
0.0145024918,
-0.0394127257,
-0.0681176707,
-0.0067469655,
0.0552097969,
0.0400384627,
0.0163045339,
-0.0266480688,
-0.0794976279,
0.0064821509,
0.0114603378,
-0.0277549326,
0.0103000086,
0.0342294089,
0.0305051245,
-0.000022836,
0.0542350784,
-0.0282528084,
0.0081216358,
0.0111073973,
0.0516711846,
-0.0433034077,
-0.0601299405,
0.0124425292,
0.0120337149,
-0.0007696192,
0.002146607,
0.0319145992,
-0.0102541773,
0.0254377406,
-0.0132164815,
-0.0353626199,
-0.0059987181,
-0.0214912109,
0.0202248972,
-0.0228934828,
0.0078947982,
-0.0277127717,
-0.0257296618,
-0.0104636122,
0.0130999284,
0.0317321829,
0.0204331689,
-0.0025116468,
0.0515337996,
-0.0288351271,
-0.015189196,
0.0192282181,
-0.0066229017,
0.0249994267,
0.0351775102,
0.0733597949,
0.0320371687,
-0.0300784074,
-0.0291554816,
-0.0277192332,
-0.0499777198,
-0.1181606576,
0.049560409,
0.0186862331,
0.0244025979,
-0.0250820387,
0.037778981,
-0.0393786617,
-0.0032444391,
-0.0079862652,
-0.0182838161,
0.0314239822,
-0.0110851564,
0.0593986623,
0.0342511982,
-0.0496421829,
0.0025838544,
0.0520358197,
-0.0298547074,
0.039980296,
-0.0503582694,
-0.0475937575,
-0.0227521919,
-0.0655040443,
-0.0141234798,
-0.0024911927,
-0.0223352369,
-0.0163788237,
-0.0989722088,
-0.0706721842,
-0.0182033423,
-0.0036017168,
0.0030420914,
-0.0514706001,
-0.0057163243,
0.064481996,
0.0025002905,
-0.0257610604,
-0.0232860446,
0.0041128737,
-0.0553329811,
0.0328912698,
-0.0823472887,
-6.85475939e-33,
0.0052344608,
-0.0340942293,
0.0116009274,
-0.0527358875,
-0.0000953959,
-0.0441398472,
-0.0133760758,
0.0210522003,
-0.0392350256,
0.0230300333,
-0.0342580937,
0.0312121678,
0.0249832775,
0.0030997037,
0.0215358529,
-0.0215979572,
0.0366215371,
0.0266143419,
-0.0546247326,
-0.0264853816,
0.0023186104,
-0.0270301644,
-0.0052378802,
-0.0519870743,
0.0276140738,
0.0068456475,
-0.0130538493,
0.0522851571,
-0.0401633643,
0.0532816984,
-0.0004424357,
0.0374084078,
0.0026912026,
-0.0244421829,
-0.0089429468,
0.0542185791,
-0.017433282,
-0.0095395874,
0.0472904593,
0.0042693214,
0.0456551313,
-0.0202759933,
0.0028415539,
0.0285308827,
-0.0709862038,
0.0173137058,
-0.0099358605,
-0.04782461,
0.0049000676,
0.0353702158,
-0.0269202068,
0.025273351,
-0.0283632688,
0.004990614,
-0.0148388138,
0.0702037588,
-0.0205348507,
0.0310469866,
-0.0352245122,
0.0322069861,
0.0469606891,
-0.0229592994,
0.0566723868,
0.0046847025,
-0.012385414,
0.0466689803,
0.0282019861,
0.0130570559,
-0.0470037125,
-0.042861823,
-0.0064635244,
0.0340670682,
0.0321452245,
0.0587802231,
-0.011181091,
-0.0116341868,
-0.0630957931,
-0.0085471375,
0.0042059473,
0.0896154195,
0.0727125481,
0.0245358292,
-0.0635948032,
-0.0451587066,
-0.0678284913,
0.0085918726,
-0.0545513146,
-0.0053867139,
0.0383520797,
-0.0044771093,
0.0009562108,
-0.0174765382,
0.0345401801,
-0.0357219689,
-0.0256135277,
0.0364367515,
0.006235661,
0.0048915814,
-0.0040506204,
0.0323082767,
-0.0490305834,
0.0013329493,
-0.001726122,
-0.0029229466,
-0.0064073899,
0.0366860144,
-0.023683466,
0.0042572119,
-0.0356578194,
-0.0057714074,
-0.0313259587,
0.0273858197,
-0.0067144544,
0.0127629954,
0.052513998,
-0.0013543341,
-0.0045332946,
0.0172348805,
-0.0212695319,
-0.0091773011,
-0.0155888945,
-0.0157047175,
-0.0149305016,
0.0301486384,
-0.0266027339,
-0.01405749,
-0.0209372137,
-0.0145670194,
-0.009199989,
-0.0376395546,
-0.0301608574,
0.0059155212,
2.887e-7,
0.0077991141,
0.0569035411,
-0.0284670349,
0.0364294127,
0.0105098234,
0.0717590749,
-0.0197559427,
-0.0181794893,
0.0372624099,
0.0015142058,
0.0156951509,
0.0547740832,
0.0485519618,
0.051611729,
-0.0261596888,
-0.031783931,
-0.0651894063,
0.0094638718,
-0.0169903878,
0.0008465502,
0.0467248484,
0.066680178,
0.0042945328,
0.000976812,
-0.0032534874,
-0.0304129869,
0.0383967608,
-0.0640145019,
0.0132877585,
0.0446062051,
0.056034334,
-0.0156188179,
0.0267019887,
0.0546263121,
0.0327344239,
0.0264515691,
-0.0451960303,
0.0761878043,
-0.0020183176,
-0.0271948911,
-0.0382648744,
-0.0386064127,
0.0228665415,
-0.0954388231,
0.083447285,
-0.0387624055,
-0.0532662347,
-0.0403894037,
0.0130136106,
-0.0369001143,
0.019493239,
-0.0069670524,
-0.0109822974,
-0.0018831289,
0.0009101381,
0.0153418919,
0.0148748234,
-0.0644301251,
-0.0219993666,
0.0209945757,
-0.0341392122,
-0.0876994357,
0.0072586769,
0.0323527269,
0.0393195972,
-0.0324704275,
0.0296717118,
2.479622911e-34,
0.0677772313,
0.0105807194,
0.0121827656,
0.0252135005,
0.0773854479,
0.0165619068,
0.0061798906,
0.0072387387,
0.06359905,
-0.0776231959,
-0.0032513365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10996v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10996v1 | THEANINE: Revisiting Memory Management in Long-term Conversations with Timeline-augmented Response Generation | 2024-06-16T16:17:46 | 2024-06-16T16:17:46 | Seo Hyun Kim, Kai Tzu-iunn Ong, Taeyoon Kwon, Namyoung Kim, Keummin Ka, SeongHyeon Bae, Yohan Jo, Seung-won Hwang, Dongha Lee, Jinyoung Yeo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are capable of processing lengthy dialogue
histories during prolonged interaction with users without additional memory
modules; however, their responses tend to overlook or incorrectly recall
information from the past. In this paper, we revisit memory-augmented response
generation in the era of LLMs. While prior work focuses on getting rid of
outdated memories, we argue that such memories can provide contextual cues that
help dialogue systems understand the development of past events and, therefore,
benefit response generation. We present Theanine, a framework that augments
LLMs' response generation with memory timelines -- series of memories that
demonstrate the development and causality of relevant past events. Along with
Theanine, we introduce TeaFarm, a counterfactual-driven question-answering
pipeline addressing the limitation of G-Eval in long-term conversations.
Supplementary videos of our methods and the TeaBag dataset for TeaFarm
evaluation are in https://theanine-693b0.web.app/. | [
0.0562253371,
0.0645132959,
-0.0296936166,
0.0165598113,
-0.0461360738,
-0.0067211823,
0.0067946357,
-0.0112187099,
0.0295560546,
-0.0399228595,
0.0137058888,
-0.0405189693,
-0.0076962821,
0.0569647364,
-0.0290013459,
-0.0534244105,
0.0518972054,
-0.0083641503,
0.0269253198,
0.0059769088,
-0.0004057248,
-0.0074260668,
-0.0162216816,
0.022826409,
-0.0261754617,
-0.0306595657,
-0.0478161611,
-0.0110180508,
0.0130416593,
-0.0488516465,
0.0111899935,
0.0285663176,
-0.010135483,
0.0342300683,
0.0000020461,
-0.0351629891,
-0.0000549979,
-0.0326103643,
-0.0286051035,
0.0289226566,
-0.0151909012,
0.0530626215,
-0.0009690415,
0.0112888683,
-0.0679552779,
-0.0205101166,
0.0135851521,
0.0449540429,
0.0820498765,
0.0586257428,
-0.0069345646,
-0.0196310636,
0.0323591977,
-0.0220834743,
0.045777306,
-0.0433350466,
-0.0100237606,
-0.0164444689,
0.0256867371,
0.0087897973,
-0.0178826656,
0.0344933234,
0.0520385541,
-0.0137761096,
0.0110776732,
0.0511483923,
-0.0035989359,
0.0089147696,
-0.0331994146,
0.0733566657,
0.0718423352,
-0.0129237259,
-0.0020730037,
0.0142480666,
0.0050278939,
-0.0063124378,
-0.0673017055,
-0.012532034,
-0.0109258732,
-0.0195690133,
-0.0118348459,
-0.006167091,
-0.002423886,
0.0285860896,
-0.013560418,
0.0614682436,
0.0176878721,
-0.0040429845,
-0.0626111627,
-0.0249863695,
0.0240540374,
-0.0660177767,
0.0171809327,
0.0597966537,
-0.0518939607,
0.0006889168,
-0.0117436787,
0.0348879248,
0.0298033394,
-0.0377787836,
-0.0179225896,
0.0226586387,
-0.022256067,
0.02446343,
-0.0235323925,
0.0681752339,
-0.0339788608,
-0.0666951537,
-0.0329977274,
-0.0068199914,
-0.041777283,
-0.0271286108,
-0.0391227491,
0.0093493294,
-0.0563029833,
-0.0057679997,
-0.0092175705,
0.0573320128,
0.0040057683,
-0.0069957888,
-0.0241883751,
0.0484715253,
-0.0183984879,
0.0021342845,
-0.0676201954,
0.029735731,
-0.0705179051,
-0.0025629043,
0.0367698446,
-0.0787676871,
-0.0470734276,
0.0101325493,
0.0089849168,
-0.0229356568,
-0.0231806636,
0.0519631654,
-0.0244316198,
0.0141010629,
-0.0177976992,
-0.0424171686,
-0.0491084866,
-0.0744426996,
0.0198223889,
-0.0380493104,
0.0141515285,
0.0121238185,
-0.0341463797,
-0.009596074,
0.0291919392,
0.0290741809,
-0.0366499871,
0.0260242615,
0.0438118204,
0.0052121058,
0.0346527696,
0.0219590515,
0.0098355059,
0.0092610065,
0.0579885542,
0.0139546338,
0.0130047547,
-0.0077257589,
0.0281694718,
0.0054028905,
0.0384334214,
-0.0273175314,
-0.0359306373,
0.0263601765,
0.0213932432,
0.0300571099,
0.01422452,
0.0368955322,
-0.0128260758,
-0.029623149,
0.0533780977,
0.0126966648,
-0.0342046544,
-0.003790624,
0.0372084789,
-0.0310847051,
-0.0110504748,
0.0539358221,
-0.0351545177,
0.0464406163,
-0.0049679708,
-0.000793961,
0.0163293574,
0.0205181539,
-0.0280590598,
-0.0263714176,
0.027676126,
0.0094526801,
0.0154451253,
0.0312004592,
-0.0009622464,
0.0200590249,
-0.0593181029,
0.0606114715,
-0.0272206739,
-0.0453372598,
-0.0108485427,
-0.0546836816,
0.0405066982,
0.0920352638,
0.0672358945,
0.009336221,
-0.0439815782,
-0.0116225472,
-0.015884975,
0.0256350208,
0.0399244092,
-0.0260131042,
0.0353718922,
-0.0304320306,
0.0005360555,
-0.0056498088,
0.0006213231,
0.0343335681,
0.0317298844,
0.0135634756,
0.0216065515,
0.0304376483,
0.037805669,
0.0051549333,
-0.050919421,
-0.0362932421,
0.0094462931,
-0.0207254179,
0.0136964191,
0.0155684622,
0.013319023,
0.0191615745,
0.0519126654,
-0.0370443612,
-0.0143955424,
0.0517269783,
-0.1039511189,
-0.0623747818,
0.0163798518,
0.0236825962,
0.0087497048,
0.0084994826,
-0.0230052508,
-0.0848561004,
0.0366857052,
-0.014538113,
0.0750319585,
-0.0442782231,
0.0154434945,
0.0346999355,
0.0139211183,
-0.0520723537,
0.0596011803,
-0.016034117,
-0.0133650471,
0.0174328517,
0.0376693457,
0.0125473561,
-0.0369971655,
0.0028987189,
0.0459772386,
-0.000333119,
-0.0141283469,
0.0442704782,
-0.0064060544,
-0.0956797078,
-0.0211701468,
-0.1276277602,
0.0366270803,
-0.0168673582,
-0.0062969532,
0.0102938795,
0.0285276398,
-0.0092383614,
-0.0447949693,
-0.0485214517,
0.0359975249,
0.0504703708,
0.0026230633,
0.0179018863,
0.0406043157,
-0.0078683272,
-0.0561106242,
0.004761321,
-0.001611435,
0.0533841439,
-0.0022222081,
-0.036822401,
0.0048509524,
-0.0144334845,
-0.0313317552,
0.0480445214,
-0.0195527822,
-0.0285365488,
0.0123127149,
-0.0149689326,
0.0772000998,
0.0578123033,
0.0423357226,
0.0048278784,
-0.0150494175,
-0.0688929558,
-0.0747663304,
0.0498234704,
-0.0457048528,
-0.0301144905,
-0.0170403887,
-0.015715437,
-0.0283432771,
0.0649274886,
0.00238365,
0.0084819579,
-0.0235506911,
0.0043606684,
0.0266768597,
-0.0164014902,
0.0096215904,
-0.0225425754,
-0.0498659126,
0.0109260594,
-0.0332395248,
-0.0551888347,
0.0489909463,
-0.0128168482,
-0.019354973,
-0.026055498,
0.0243606344,
-0.0194605459,
0.1217454746,
0.0234992187,
0.0007060244,
0.0072597764,
-0.0157275014,
-0.040867582,
-0.0205446128,
0.0012801054,
-0.0473825224,
0.0159472357,
-0.0584021844,
0.0132209975,
0.0012589551,
-0.0054819207,
-0.0995532647,
-0.0314033739,
-0.0129231913,
-0.0074059698,
-0.0497206524,
0.0003706226,
-0.0515884086,
-0.0001404927,
0.0143349404,
0.0503618084,
-0.0291991532,
0.0008532371,
-0.0097783823,
0.0804511309,
0.0640906692,
-0.00298451,
0.0189494696,
0.0045345072,
0.0784068108,
0.0520155318,
0.0737995207,
0.0051334212,
0.013039331,
-0.0189266764,
-0.003612974,
-0.0036026516,
-0.0057086847,
0.0308367983,
0.0317149982,
-0.0626131594,
-0.0469315872,
0.1003838256,
0.0541993901,
-0.0230667852,
-0.0067173275,
-0.0151017131,
0.0568839535,
0.0255343113,
-0.0000629614,
-0.05423503,
-0.0202510953,
0.0006393621,
-0.0124394419,
-0.0287556481,
-0.0388431922,
-0.0273438562,
-0.1205701903,
-0.0010970042,
0.0059175156,
-0.0337827578,
0.0282428972,
-0.0132183712,
-0.0113601498,
0.0517797023,
0.0427274518,
0.021964293,
0.0045020226,
0.0007854207,
0.0057996009,
-0.0308018159,
-0.0194634572,
0.0295192823,
0.0108319819,
0.0790988803,
0.0556127168,
0.0425759405,
0.0319604203,
0.007439666,
0.0356940329,
-0.0276473332,
0.0199191812,
-0.0216010176,
0.0583444983,
0.0185729526,
0.0041442164,
-0.002808982,
0.0220814366,
-0.0120047061,
-0.0363732465,
0.042539984,
0.0586364493,
-0.0689271614,
0.0095867896,
-0.0015757276,
0.031511005,
0.0361645743,
0.0675540045,
0.033723373,
-0.0452745296,
-0.0597517975,
0.00324123,
0.0107435733,
-0.073562406,
0.0191762671,
-0.016037697,
0.0543402024,
0.004410394,
-0.0836770982,
-0.0845957175,
-0.0061699296,
-0.0067341304,
-0.0235633161,
0.0009799791,
-0.0362476334,
-0.0124599319,
-0.0436222963,
0.0262565184,
-0.0197201576,
0.0038103387,
-0.0292661395,
-0.01179488,
0.0312425848,
-0.0145608718,
0.0083850306,
0.0773474425,
-0.0952997208,
-0.0336211435,
0.0259628687,
0.0578401275,
0.0247157235,
0.0656309202,
0.0151719013,
-0.0011937276,
0.0091793323,
0.0186989568,
-0.0497680232,
0.0002729779,
0.0162828974,
0.0298735127,
-0.0281593185,
0.0235499032,
-0.022408545,
0.0161355771,
-0.0046922318,
0.075782381,
-0.0262701251,
-0.0438129231,
0.0113246646,
-0.0480948649,
0.0414125882,
-0.0016045233,
-0.0052922294,
-0.0013200744,
0.0256166756,
-0.0438742377,
0.004642209,
-0.0335402973,
0.0053335303,
-0.0089265481,
-0.0260157082,
0.0097354101,
-0.0439242572,
-0.0273911804,
0.0446808226,
-0.0198180694,
-0.0165007692,
0.0417183414,
-0.02835311,
0.0088805687,
0.0035094696,
-0.0175404586,
-0.0148148304,
0.0272558555,
0.0352317244,
-0.0145983743,
0.0949097872,
0.0005467153,
-0.0199889466,
0.0017441799,
-0.0062333909,
-0.1146414503,
-0.0264429543,
0.0145593043,
0.027582204,
0.0599305183,
-0.0129766297,
0.0475490429,
-0.0105492333,
0.0158637725,
-0.0291296374,
0.016500283,
0.0280741006,
-0.0356165357,
0.0025295482,
0.0093625579,
-0.0367663354,
0.0491921827,
0.0487511382,
-0.0284112953,
0.0619001016,
0.0184921324,
0.0046377662,
-0.0311975498,
-0.0735684633,
-0.0180157516,
0.002297522,
-0.0073700259,
0.0001533782,
-0.0600439198,
-0.032642018,
0.0156646241,
0.0022615739,
0.0040688184,
-0.0212400705,
0.0248579886,
0.031000061,
0.0218397193,
-0.0417980812,
-0.0412681773,
0.0552444384,
-0.0347804055,
-0.029080689,
-0.0812755898,
-6.287443041e-33,
-0.0404972471,
-0.0477553457,
0.0370072313,
-0.0290729515,
-0.0671740398,
0.00137328,
-0.0685889199,
-0.0004343324,
-0.0231053289,
-0.0079341745,
-0.0357579812,
0.0300081279,
0.0075529534,
0.0374641269,
0.0090679564,
-0.0434012562,
0.0588000268,
-0.0078984285,
-0.0155699924,
0.0857454985,
0.055373922,
0.0494017527,
0.0040673246,
-0.0346781053,
0.0267841723,
-0.0177901238,
0.0171399489,
0.0346505791,
-0.0010872084,
0.0667533129,
-0.0492819622,
0.0260388609,
0.0185825992,
-0.0414261296,
-0.012138851,
0.0371779427,
-0.0832224116,
-0.0107713984,
0.028849503,
-0.0117501272,
-0.0309473462,
-0.0438594893,
-0.0027911591,
-0.0191208031,
0.0146522596,
0.0029641029,
0.0083423657,
-0.0109480722,
-0.0257950015,
-0.0052087968,
-0.0348133668,
-0.0004851868,
-0.0103356075,
-0.0249470286,
-0.0429506153,
0.0511045419,
0.0382212177,
-0.0123816561,
-0.0350982174,
-0.0070522386,
-0.0308712106,
0.0021724924,
0.0370199606,
0.0469733402,
0.0064974385,
0.0565155223,
0.0251286291,
0.0122566726,
-0.0200371202,
-0.0102091916,
0.0012419204,
-0.01270176,
0.0146523453,
0.0090973582,
0.0204073731,
-0.0119528258,
-0.0334253423,
0.0175339393,
0.0131558971,
0.0618650913,
0.0227481145,
-0.008814442,
0.003452182,
-0.0126588121,
-0.023819847,
0.04910836,
-0.0166711435,
-0.0091051552,
0.034881141,
0.0171287302,
0.0005759383,
-0.0380394645,
0.0541667417,
-0.0289679263,
0.0127267651,
0.0561156049,
-0.035291668,
0.0023220428,
0.0057039848,
0.0646114945,
-0.0304605309,
0.042275928,
0.0401613563,
0.0108136134,
-0.000492977,
0.0248690695,
-0.0023075426,
0.0155995293,
-0.0627600998,
0.0073573589,
-0.037240494,
0.0663789958,
-0.0481849164,
-0.0224306174,
0.0149534186,
0.019328,
-0.0200983174,
0.0470845588,
0.0058957208,
0.0064766281,
-0.0285756681,
-0.0508868657,
0.016676819,
0.0058830376,
-0.0217459965,
0.0191270486,
-0.0216056351,
0.0441004597,
-0.0015721306,
-0.0250289068,
0.0111629115,
0.0171354376,
2.621e-7,
-0.0187445302,
0.013747042,
0.0669496879,
0.0206737164,
0.0404804163,
0.01106402,
0.0163320825,
0.0054642078,
0.0287517682,
0.0001882866,
0.0017255639,
0.0366645977,
0.0508159287,
0.0312369652,
-0.0290276855,
-0.0192024205,
-0.0856111944,
-0.0450508222,
-0.0474743806,
-0.0251546931,
0.0889713541,
0.0524194203,
0.0313608386,
-0.0100438483,
-0.0134916632,
-0.0074536172,
0.0664429292,
-0.0513149984,
-0.0334801637,
0.0108213304,
0.0160172824,
-0.0061016134,
-0.0036311061,
0.0077828891,
-0.0154840555,
0.0036754976,
-0.0627574697,
0.0396402031,
0.0122081432,
-0.0942562222,
-0.0287359059,
0.0024964123,
0.0119444607,
-0.0453489684,
0.0708002895,
-0.0313049331,
-0.0108541362,
-0.0117236022,
-0.0031260396,
0.0084511442,
-0.0085600745,
0.0045005507,
-0.0364398584,
0.0317699723,
-0.0074063037,
0.0172497183,
0.0315562822,
-0.0849919543,
-0.0394357592,
0.0221933685,
-0.0582279302,
-0.0472944789,
-0.0279540215,
-0.0050819423,
-0.0084057115,
-0.042311281,
0.0040221871,
2.344185758e-34,
0.0269694421,
0.0021733514,
0.0018880384,
0.0314048529,
0.0278477874,
-0.0071631186,
0.0185774136,
0.0151184164,
0.0625657439,
-0.0734346882,
-0.0259556416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10993v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10993v1 | CoSTA: Code-Switched Speech Translation using Aligned Speech-Text Interleaving | 2024-06-16T16:10:51 | 2024-06-16T16:10:51 | Bhavani Shankar, Preethi Jyothi, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Code-switching is a widely prevalent linguistic phenomenon in multilingual
societies like India. Building speech-to-text models for code-switched speech
is challenging due to limited availability of datasets. In this work, we focus
on the problem of spoken translation (ST) of code-switched speech in Indian
languages to English text. We present a new end-to-end model architecture COSTA
that scaffolds on pretrained automatic speech recognition (ASR) and machine
translation (MT) modules (that are more widely available for many languages).
Speech and ASR text representations are fused using an aligned interleaving
scheme and are fed further as input to a pretrained MT module; the whole
pipeline is then trained end-to-end for spoken translation using synthetically
created ST data. We also release a new evaluation benchmark for code-switched
Bengali-English, Hindi-English, Marathi-English and Telugu- English speech to
English text. COSTA significantly outperforms many competitive cascaded and
end-to-end multimodal baselines by up to 3.5 BLEU points. | [
-0.0013039488,
0.0129207727,
-0.0013000628,
0.018956434,
-0.0434024557,
0.0111149875,
0.0259639975,
-0.0078379847,
-0.0202095173,
-0.0248179417,
-0.0840178728,
0.0034924068,
0.0399616361,
0.0547896624,
0.031145867,
-0.0289936177,
0.0362708755,
-0.0352846868,
-0.0300835129,
0.0068552038,
0.045690272,
0.0329230763,
-0.0387466662,
-0.0005244751,
-0.0264143962,
-0.0198122002,
0.0201120917,
0.0364775211,
0.0206641648,
-0.0301593449,
0.0033751035,
-0.004893844,
0.0238114744,
0.0517378971,
0.0000018559,
-0.0055621658,
-0.0348568857,
-0.0053535067,
-0.0265782997,
-0.0022952484,
0.0558318309,
-0.0269565657,
0.0135108531,
0.0549121946,
-0.0082113612,
0.0042021084,
0.0806122422,
-0.0311940685,
0.037452165,
0.1093121693,
-0.0388178043,
-0.0685710087,
0.0093602212,
-0.0192169454,
-0.0578105748,
-0.0480694957,
-0.0244596414,
-0.0310903024,
-0.0137421014,
-0.005338293,
-0.0281139966,
0.0561519228,
-0.0047373702,
-0.0107003702,
0.0264996625,
-0.0358614288,
-0.0335322358,
-0.0225844458,
-0.0153187262,
0.078990072,
-0.0552621968,
-0.0109103918,
0.0302908681,
-0.0363077037,
-0.0565247871,
-0.0855852216,
0.0111549003,
-0.0056254272,
-0.0238544736,
0.0127233882,
0.0213050973,
0.0868884921,
0.0216834452,
-0.0390631407,
-0.0294171385,
-0.0478172265,
0.0231378507,
-0.0176400486,
-0.0175445098,
-0.0332359448,
0.0246406682,
0.0184478313,
0.0715855211,
-0.0111212656,
-0.0308676995,
0.0190863814,
-0.0313295163,
-0.0618576482,
-0.0267694443,
-0.0339711457,
0.0423050784,
0.0670615733,
-0.0355976745,
0.0045999326,
-0.0095791034,
0.07359308,
-0.0407202877,
0.0282594059,
-0.0226309747,
0.0016987213,
0.0072933384,
0.0050845328,
-0.0086423876,
-0.037661057,
-0.0428599603,
-0.011954275,
-0.0159116052,
0.028904099,
0.005956667,
0.0005547713,
0.0368101485,
-0.0406463929,
-0.0298423972,
-0.0404748954,
0.0426321328,
0.0444995947,
0.0066295564,
0.0188626852,
0.0251450967,
-0.0668300092,
0.0013711586,
0.0326787159,
-0.0043672635,
-0.0169398244,
-0.0202072188,
0.0533289462,
-0.0475883745,
-0.0307814945,
-0.0467166454,
0.0467801392,
-0.0337714776,
-0.0533095226,
-0.0179395713,
-0.0422767624,
0.0744196177,
0.0174598265,
0.0307484865,
-0.0542254485,
-0.0113026602,
-0.0147223426,
0.0144783771,
0.0785008967,
-0.0276722349,
0.0038467855,
0.0400223993,
-0.0067772856,
0.0117529454,
0.071344234,
0.0566220582,
-0.0041257632,
0.0206785854,
-0.0361311436,
0.0077156392,
0.0740304142,
-0.0021697825,
0.0156673584,
-0.0069433809,
0.0097321589,
0.0383616984,
0.0365010276,
0.0291371029,
0.0328654982,
-0.0147574553,
0.015067162,
-0.0047497479,
0.0079066232,
0.0260040183,
0.0444934927,
0.0333406776,
0.0186999217,
0.0047602444,
0.0049278629,
0.0244053882,
0.0116251847,
0.0032632379,
-0.027496146,
0.0781055167,
0.0289145596,
-0.0333597921,
0.0237157214,
-0.0115025314,
-0.0416987389,
0.0227942858,
-0.0298950151,
0.0111551192,
0.0225849953,
-0.0602897927,
0.016168369,
-0.0082293823,
-0.0647912249,
0.0534090772,
-0.0341813341,
-0.0494970195,
0.0433262326,
0.0068561761,
-0.0299517512,
0.0282695256,
-0.0276969969,
-0.016536409,
0.0332216471,
0.0187606737,
0.023075683,
0.0546353199,
-0.0710906908,
0.0467198715,
0.0307334922,
-0.0279112607,
0.040441364,
-0.0273310412,
0.0311051849,
0.0041683,
0.0259753224,
-0.0249867328,
0.0139634218,
-0.0387712754,
0.0222114548,
0.0233862698,
-0.0024216569,
0.0578104481,
-0.0265596788,
-0.034069892,
0.0108972201,
0.011708186,
-0.0086874804,
0.0047712727,
0.0384226851,
-0.0451517776,
-0.0458827876,
0.0082602091,
-0.0552333146,
0.0360205062,
0.0317094103,
-0.0025860542,
-0.0786808655,
0.0171982739,
-0.0243133232,
0.0220351983,
-0.0058309198,
0.0741627514,
0.0230186693,
-0.0007344275,
-0.0101432558,
-0.0156416278,
0.0163552444,
-0.0075420402,
0.0020316984,
0.0123646613,
0.0448859781,
-0.0311553348,
0.0372833833,
0.0558631197,
0.0120920753,
0.0308340751,
0.0080413809,
-0.0098428018,
-0.0179395229,
-0.0376119018,
-0.0943381265,
-0.0043705301,
-0.0127341831,
0.0195443574,
0.015138383,
0.0457027406,
-0.0022382794,
-0.0223867837,
-0.0172998905,
0.0071329325,
0.02646471,
0.0010172946,
-0.0325465091,
-0.0202637352,
0.0199537408,
-0.0150797758,
0.0009246865,
0.0240032859,
0.0409091786,
-0.0404720716,
-0.0355848707,
-0.0730338991,
0.0056224684,
0.0322444737,
0.0086901942,
-0.0245246887,
-0.0707636327,
-0.0058761225,
-0.0155746825,
0.033467412,
0.007801834,
0.0119392732,
-0.0585797317,
-0.0180599876,
-0.0311237201,
-0.0416323207,
-0.031044988,
0.0519491658,
-0.0144280046,
-0.0369991325,
-0.0013402008,
0.0164757911,
0.0498909205,
0.0186161697,
0.0493078865,
-0.0617367886,
-0.0832255185,
0.0003358599,
0.0083212741,
0.0106974794,
0.0018109016,
-0.041331958,
0.0587529019,
-0.0435429439,
-0.0406978391,
-0.0024442063,
-0.0786679462,
-0.0271443315,
-0.0957542285,
0.0049702046,
-0.0299748313,
-0.0018674136,
-0.0336304978,
-0.0008305903,
-0.0364599712,
-0.0410493724,
-0.0265264865,
0.0303009097,
-0.0210695509,
-0.059096802,
-0.0018039363,
-0.0650691316,
0.0356272273,
-0.0401749387,
-0.043282304,
-0.0031364199,
-0.0485030077,
-0.024027016,
-0.0168653894,
0.0687694773,
-0.041849073,
0.023768723,
0.0496385619,
-0.0207497776,
0.0824298635,
0.0129950205,
0.0367770754,
0.0023084525,
0.0365811847,
-0.0051447656,
-0.0052199648,
-0.0210379567,
-0.0109073976,
0.0345373191,
-0.0409354083,
0.0400543548,
0.0188053288,
-0.0476039276,
-0.0020396218,
0.0363548025,
0.0250955746,
-0.0281399917,
-0.0160187148,
0.0352196991,
0.0048390129,
-0.0108660487,
0.0683073848,
0.0064933705,
-0.0625282824,
-0.0467639938,
-0.0145914508,
0.0425224602,
0.0211983472,
0.0188606679,
-0.0814977735,
-0.0233438816,
0.0412805527,
0.0061704605,
0.0168008879,
0.0280483514,
-0.0574352741,
-0.0461324044,
-0.0223129895,
0.0452420115,
-0.0440752506,
-0.0572369359,
0.0176904928,
-0.0468294807,
0.003641254,
0.0049057938,
0.0328313708,
-0.0342287868,
-0.0496525951,
0.0495080352,
-0.0281906668,
0.0030813327,
-0.0272029508,
0.0047198813,
0.0650140792,
0.0726058334,
-0.0063463575,
-0.0047637201,
-0.0346571691,
0.0369970463,
-0.0191549025,
-0.0143682258,
-0.0130276792,
0.0205385908,
-0.0324085876,
-0.0109673487,
0.0445782803,
0.016082732,
-0.0135092614,
-0.0024392942,
0.0112606622,
0.0330805108,
0.001268985,
0.036499802,
0.0316004492,
0.0109802354,
0.0188959483,
0.0091880234,
0.0190027095,
-0.0611103922,
0.0152075738,
0.0005943456,
0.0299432147,
-0.0349301957,
-0.003910454,
0.0204898994,
-0.0371195748,
-0.0258724745,
-0.0192248356,
0.0095770303,
0.0059177754,
0.0562063009,
0.0235762838,
0.0264631622,
0.0005479295,
0.0030765499,
-0.0132122878,
-0.0234183818,
-0.0512699597,
0.0596909672,
-0.1035490781,
-0.0057676076,
0.0207997393,
-0.0509014241,
-0.0050441884,
-0.006129601,
-0.0631888956,
-0.0481148437,
0.0293902718,
0.0212533288,
0.0212962367,
0.0375955328,
-0.048756741,
-0.0250787325,
0.0138741061,
-0.0464947373,
-0.0682179853,
0.0047089104,
0.0655282065,
0.0041796514,
-0.0155821349,
0.0152516617,
-0.0171118714,
-0.0179014355,
-0.0181724224,
0.0015151289,
-0.0105120325,
-0.0302821193,
0.004306192,
-0.0048696944,
0.028110167,
-0.0682065785,
-0.0205172617,
-0.0153865656,
0.045524437,
0.0318254195,
0.0102118598,
-0.0275542904,
-0.0250010248,
0.0813294202,
0.0105260061,
-0.0153857199,
0.0243035089,
-0.0196387842,
-0.0209584925,
0.024746282,
0.0567526668,
0.0284896363,
0.0851579383,
0.0304084867,
0.0313500948,
-0.0154625764,
0.0380031653,
0.0046064076,
0.0172683876,
-0.0302167051,
0.0641448498,
-0.0008291287,
-0.0046968386,
0.0431777649,
0.0664670542,
0.0129536567,
0.0077980678,
0.0037043679,
-0.0263297539,
0.0449285097,
0.0325827785,
0.1133401915,
0.0474476553,
0.0234041363,
-0.0350340083,
0.0513379946,
-0.0577639192,
0.0112367962,
-0.0015783623,
-0.0301439986,
-0.0165727939,
0.04568097,
0.0293861404,
-0.0068980879,
-0.0098540979,
-0.0086838966,
0.0293214656,
-0.0136410268,
-0.0194376241,
-0.0060621463,
0.0052403621,
0.0206579845,
-0.0518910885,
-0.0074308878,
-0.0405717231,
0.0316409096,
-0.021377245,
0.0332392342,
-0.0302162208,
-0.0006951569,
0.0406768061,
-0.010744499,
0.0317861326,
-0.0326392315,
-0.0246621314,
0.0636150762,
-0.0395528264,
0.0063080271,
-5.897784664e-33,
-0.0247071534,
0.0552107878,
-0.0037214756,
-0.0141160013,
-0.0637290552,
-0.0058358107,
-0.0125294235,
-0.028623784,
0.0028157814,
-0.0390178449,
-0.028377926,
0.0192532074,
0.0162132327,
-0.0064107119,
0.0019007971,
0.0154268062,
0.0561071932,
-0.0062271194,
-0.012135881,
0.0436094031,
0.0337894745,
0.0217914972,
0.0368699208,
-0.0283992849,
-0.0527082533,
-0.0344139896,
-0.0321800262,
-0.0113744643,
-0.0324682258,
0.0071712863,
-0.0081851576,
0.0077078091,
0.0073972414,
0.011074258,
-0.0170083866,
0.0375210494,
-0.0717631802,
0.0711482763,
0.0188095458,
0.0955866426,
-0.0213468857,
-0.0558516644,
0.0229581427,
-0.036499396,
-0.0103065055,
0.0005229167,
-0.0222038254,
-0.0070780828,
0.0060870992,
0.0030700236,
-0.0798039585,
0.0461781211,
-0.0283454079,
-0.0103705972,
0.0461472608,
0.0851577893,
-0.0069727409,
-0.0143192736,
-0.079716824,
0.0008557659,
-0.0122254146,
0.0400404595,
0.0359883271,
0.0510878526,
-0.0499502085,
0.00893493,
0.0801391974,
-0.063654691,
0.0734852031,
0.0221992582,
0.0392663814,
-0.0117724324,
0.0004125497,
0.0118075348,
0.0315429009,
-0.0815727711,
-0.0086337607,
-0.0327075794,
0.0127193527,
-0.0022422383,
0.0257180724,
0.0492853113,
0.0005099065,
-0.0259847064,
-0.0310078803,
-0.0521960668,
-0.0136625897,
-0.0332744569,
0.0566802472,
-0.0012336724,
0.0120327566,
0.0061990577,
0.0986441299,
0.0026861092,
0.0134745073,
-0.012891422,
-0.0190983862,
0.0524685569,
-0.013204298,
0.1034023538,
-0.0608438067,
-0.0625438616,
0.0534815826,
0.0301953629,
0.0220251195,
-0.048662737,
0.0215806738,
0.0442010611,
-0.0536219962,
-0.001907671,
-0.0082835071,
0.0267235227,
-0.0072199116,
0.0278573018,
0.005498739,
0.007922451,
-0.0088732159,
0.0241829492,
-0.0282218922,
-0.0015888835,
-0.0232880842,
-0.0485381521,
0.0206051189,
0.0646436065,
-0.0320493951,
0.0293074474,
-0.0339209028,
0.0211740695,
0.0251258407,
-0.0383049175,
-0.0068930257,
0.0377634764,
2.64e-7,
-0.006171579,
0.0322983786,
0.0456557982,
-0.0597040914,
-0.0040437416,
-0.0165108666,
-0.0624849498,
-0.0047457581,
0.0200356189,
0.042559009,
-0.0134947188,
-0.0008349512,
0.1188046485,
0.0135906767,
-0.0551768579,
-0.045341704,
-0.0280261338,
0.0329951458,
-0.0332441367,
-0.0326741599,
0.0250314604,
0.0657982752,
-0.0164325032,
0.0029858889,
0.0243311934,
0.0255266353,
0.0336731449,
0.0074204099,
0.0158398878,
-0.0171090718,
-0.0647429302,
-0.0049704285,
-0.0729691684,
0.0043261587,
-0.0221705865,
0.0176116358,
0.0434775539,
0.0699797049,
-0.0319277756,
-0.0251922123,
0.0187345091,
0.0268137194,
-0.0597334951,
-0.0059454204,
0.0686333552,
0.0302807484,
0.0114996284,
-0.0290005803,
-0.0692954659,
0.0315099023,
0.0251518786,
-0.0209025294,
-0.0080030775,
0.0288551077,
0.0480992086,
-0.0178153161,
-0.0401346758,
-0.041774042,
-0.01647643,
0.0031202491,
-0.0245786607,
-0.0315890312,
-0.0508289821,
0.0293184686,
0.0184354056,
-0.0225896016,
0.0040902104,
1.946859713e-34,
0.0506821238,
-0.0277918763,
0.0360397212,
-0.0144139435,
0.0388804562,
-0.048773367,
0.0128341997,
0.0299862642,
0.0068215723,
-0.0493621789,
-0.0366771035
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10991v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10991v1 | Adaptive Query Rewriting: Aligning Rewriters through Marginal Probability of Conversational Answers | 2024-06-16T16:09:05 | 2024-06-16T16:09:05 | Tianhua Zhang, Kun Li, Hongyin Luo, Xixin Wu, James Glass, Helen Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Query rewriting is a crucial technique for passage retrieval in open-domain
conversational question answering (CQA). It decontexualizes conversational
queries into self-contained questions suitable for off-the-shelf retrievers.
Existing methods attempt to incorporate retriever's preference during the
training of rewriting models. However, these approaches typically rely on
extensive annotations such as in-domain rewrites and/or relevant passage
labels, limiting the models' generalization and adaptation capabilities. In
this paper, we introduce AdaQR ($\textbf{Ada}$ptive $\textbf{Q}$uery
$\textbf{R}$ewriting), a framework for training query rewriting models with
limited rewrite annotations from seed datasets and completely no passage label.
Our approach begins by fine-tuning compact large language models using only
~$10\%$ of rewrite annotations from the seed dataset training split. The models
are then utilized to generate rewrite candidates for each query instance. A
novel approach is then proposed to assess retriever's preference for these
candidates by the probability of answers conditioned on the conversational
query by marginalizing the Top-$K$ passages. This serves as the reward for
optimizing the rewriter further using Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), a
process free of rewrite and retrieval annotations. Experimental results on four
open-domain CQA datasets demonstrate that AdaQR not only enhances the in-domain
capabilities of the rewriter with limited annotation requirement, but also
adapts effectively to out-of-domain datasets. | [
0.0523412749,
0.0354577787,
-0.0013030212,
0.0084843766,
-0.030241048,
0.0152988499,
-0.0176746268,
-0.0162563473,
-0.0014742017,
-0.0515808687,
-0.0224572495,
-0.0153356167,
-0.0427933186,
0.0134907188,
0.0118456976,
-0.0341065452,
-0.0062568286,
-0.0087459274,
0.0260982588,
0.0047704782,
0.0222862102,
0.0119902715,
0.0042396989,
0.036482919,
0.0518727824,
-0.011446082,
-0.014804027,
0.0300359894,
-0.0188687351,
0.0157764833,
0.068863973,
0.0598110296,
0.0263360199,
0.0230481755,
0.0000017321,
-0.0708786771,
-0.0591100305,
0.0041298335,
-0.0415528491,
0.0029405213,
0.0218727328,
0.0595554709,
0.0507570282,
0.0330985524,
-0.0450669155,
0.0236815866,
0.0476910919,
0.0516289137,
0.0509640723,
0.0824101418,
0.0109373583,
-0.0436833575,
-0.0006036928,
-0.0281088594,
0.0518235192,
-0.0531553514,
0.0294900294,
0.0123694735,
-0.0046848999,
0.0339064524,
0.0021285228,
0.0104493462,
0.0140629727,
-0.0205508582,
0.0281486195,
-0.0032810089,
-0.0447027162,
0.0395432413,
0.0162903536,
0.1047016531,
0.0200852826,
-0.023970427,
0.0051716282,
0.0066113556,
0.0146999201,
0.0230990387,
-0.0622603595,
-0.0009788593,
-0.0053045317,
-0.0074081644,
-0.0238844156,
0.0305088107,
-0.0014249155,
0.0078866314,
-0.0338723436,
0.0618662387,
0.0098455492,
-0.0308553614,
-0.0015354597,
0.0123065514,
-0.025902465,
-0.0485213287,
0.0284195039,
0.0094392337,
-0.0287347157,
0.0421886742,
-0.0423984304,
-0.01074237,
0.0146722291,
-0.0421408191,
0.0231437534,
0.0208441336,
0.0139187584,
0.042601902,
-0.001540467,
0.0366661884,
-0.0032732673,
0.005568577,
-0.0901034921,
-0.0081282733,
-0.0363112837,
-0.0143585308,
-0.0667573512,
0.0466495566,
-0.0729987398,
0.0172763281,
-0.0350140855,
0.0496045016,
0.0622852892,
-0.0575412214,
0.0069054007,
0.0517605208,
-0.072914578,
-0.0202068184,
-0.0569077656,
0.0449122638,
-0.0021473535,
0.0210530851,
0.0205876585,
-0.0590627417,
-0.0145226615,
-0.004372485,
0.0292821415,
-0.0619375296,
-0.0215124693,
0.0355439559,
-0.0431552567,
-0.0293601882,
-0.0168882031,
-0.0328371637,
0.0021870874,
-0.0009292762,
-0.01488763,
-0.0366514064,
0.0393513478,
0.0101740668,
-0.0399925932,
-0.039818041,
0.0080339937,
0.0626345649,
-0.0084197652,
0.0328960977,
0.0545342416,
-0.0042313682,
0.045900777,
0.0065102759,
0.0153006986,
0.0805105418,
0.0229722485,
0.0054955459,
0.0760208741,
0.0092899706,
0.0519637689,
-0.0102377469,
0.0104971714,
0.0264720973,
-0.002148224,
0.087995939,
0.0403661542,
0.0250692107,
0.0320941061,
0.0096778842,
-0.0492220931,
-0.0575920679,
0.0603770874,
0.0118396934,
0.030095825,
-0.011470275,
0.0082486747,
0.0327424295,
-0.0041914345,
0.0327848978,
-0.0328419432,
0.0399827212,
0.0028618113,
0.0346215367,
0.0496097654,
0.0121793095,
-0.0344109274,
-0.0603370555,
0.0499379076,
0.0221564453,
-0.0126500716,
0.0466364734,
0.0030491436,
0.0362591185,
-0.0581390932,
-0.0002325966,
0.0074570617,
-0.0484328344,
0.0090467762,
-0.0512163527,
0.0065525929,
0.0240754485,
0.071311377,
-0.0424517281,
-0.0240730755,
-0.0305813178,
-0.0070510432,
-0.0130696148,
0.0592007786,
-0.0343521535,
0.0268724766,
-0.044939734,
-0.029298678,
-0.0248902328,
0.0008609977,
0.0326914899,
0.0449714437,
-0.0025503633,
0.0327842794,
-0.0858399272,
-0.0035424863,
0.0346571766,
-0.0013502568,
-0.0478234738,
0.0710838437,
-0.0084713567,
0.0293388199,
0.0067707542,
0.003592944,
0.030776402,
0.0202070549,
-0.0020140831,
-0.0481368676,
-0.0070854207,
-0.0432627052,
-0.0523472466,
0.032908313,
-0.032194756,
0.0058345767,
0.0121343238,
-0.0380718261,
-0.0320439823,
-0.0069225468,
-0.0400721729,
0.0423335396,
-0.0660741553,
0.0006428133,
0.0173211154,
-0.0188777894,
-0.1006324813,
0.038161736,
0.0453358106,
0.0126629332,
0.0046224701,
-0.042163074,
0.0065832338,
-0.0542926788,
-0.0018446547,
-0.0280919094,
-0.0153745487,
0.0195081905,
0.0423304178,
-0.0067970948,
-0.0647381842,
-0.0164213497,
-0.0995404273,
0.0131713431,
-0.0222376026,
0.0246505216,
0.0312801339,
0.0532732345,
-0.0057414277,
-0.0353135131,
-0.0603146441,
-0.0486534871,
-0.0039060123,
0.0488266423,
0.0427815057,
0.0450364053,
-0.0150157176,
-0.0192686077,
-0.024444852,
0.0160783734,
0.029878255,
-0.0143756084,
0.0194998961,
-0.0331116021,
0.019257104,
-0.0491844937,
0.0249072183,
-0.0193510391,
0.001469375,
-0.0433329083,
-0.0280437786,
0.0342313647,
0.0824420378,
0.029906068,
-0.0530341491,
0.0041268677,
-0.0045520975,
-0.0522790179,
0.0297029242,
-0.0560779199,
-0.0545479916,
-0.0169851091,
-0.0401084945,
0.0400695391,
0.0243548322,
0.0014571039,
-0.024335267,
-0.0040682852,
-0.0090999585,
0.0048286058,
-0.0182346441,
-0.0667805523,
0.0165555067,
0.0113187749,
0.0515292957,
0.0056214049,
-0.0295968577,
0.0937282071,
0.012445691,
-0.0334642641,
-0.0972023457,
-0.0123678092,
-0.0755144283,
0.0412490144,
-0.0206364356,
0.0209209137,
0.0477322303,
-0.0301957484,
-0.0591736212,
-0.0309691988,
0.0202437453,
-0.0564047731,
0.0503246486,
-0.0515251458,
0.0223584324,
-0.0011713223,
-0.0633730069,
-0.0421272852,
-0.0714027807,
0.0079599591,
-0.0127104474,
-0.0228941757,
-0.0077147209,
-0.0428465903,
0.0193379913,
0.0245894864,
0.0474370457,
-0.0448232517,
-0.0054623401,
-0.0020542091,
0.0728250146,
0.1001997441,
0.0483409092,
-0.021479724,
-0.0156266186,
0.0149790328,
0.0400211066,
0.0504752696,
-0.0452901982,
0.040274363,
-0.0218670554,
0.0154718067,
-0.058538802,
-0.0030767689,
0.0222225767,
0.0477284566,
-0.0256036669,
-0.0337509997,
0.0669535697,
0.033218123,
-0.024522122,
-0.0293632187,
-0.0091885058,
0.050664179,
0.0102733541,
0.070391506,
-0.0809356645,
-0.0476616472,
-0.0004921153,
0.0529196672,
-0.0030642783,
-0.0259998888,
-0.0041567753,
-0.1070982739,
0.0228472613,
-0.0348233357,
-0.0501402766,
-0.0101999063,
-0.0454528779,
-0.0018184221,
-0.0279564019,
0.0025929713,
0.0375477225,
-0.0285351723,
0.0194446016,
0.0060497322,
0.0230786763,
0.0090610683,
0.0090464531,
-0.0104874102,
-0.0080997217,
0.0619791858,
0.0006976918,
0.0218547061,
0.0139632542,
0.005214531,
-0.078008838,
-0.0188496634,
0.0159007758,
0.0394909084,
-0.0082033565,
0.0239179041,
-0.0238865614,
0.0343307853,
-0.0134203928,
0.0145644443,
0.023745127,
0.0208812822,
-0.0174690913,
0.0157601852,
-0.0187898204,
0.0143982321,
0.0072089229,
0.0591626763,
0.017550664,
-0.0074743894,
-0.0468869843,
-0.0407932028,
0.0111301383,
-0.0658930391,
0.0011914111,
-0.0134096351,
0.0034505075,
0.0418970175,
-0.0782178938,
-0.0283494778,
0.0204134341,
0.0321079791,
-0.0008304393,
0.0186562464,
-0.0099053532,
0.0143755926,
-0.0515064187,
0.007435584,
-0.0652121827,
0.0113138231,
-0.0248552226,
-0.0146663245,
0.0258873105,
-0.0499412343,
-0.0314989239,
-0.0022556572,
-0.0456305444,
-0.0465951674,
-0.0160755068,
0.0386752486,
0.0234682038,
0.012471688,
-0.0149234869,
-0.0341618545,
-0.0004695893,
0.0282254163,
-0.0306149051,
0.0050159958,
0.0196328834,
0.0480861701,
-0.0049245083,
0.0383908637,
-0.0510597639,
-0.0378041565,
-0.0105043817,
0.0352695584,
-0.0096043488,
-0.0781012401,
0.0542828664,
-0.0048703104,
-0.0231039952,
0.0528460033,
0.0070984801,
-0.0332492255,
0.0838438869,
-0.0112882368,
-0.0273309816,
-0.0236688815,
0.0209578164,
0.0355057493,
-0.0271184202,
0.001609592,
0.0110217985,
-0.0465884283,
0.0292493105,
-0.0615829863,
-0.0176649503,
0.035259217,
-0.0200695265,
0.0273868106,
-0.0042776451,
-0.0090578618,
0.0132723274,
0.0517823286,
0.0954450741,
0.0246040262,
0.0365665592,
0.0268239547,
-0.00679952,
-0.0225041527,
0.0094504273,
-0.1035441533,
-0.0176962484,
-0.0319725648,
0.0295100398,
-0.0195889864,
0.009456683,
0.0162213463,
0.0071512181,
-0.0104968948,
-0.0260702502,
0.0235123225,
0.0119667947,
0.0075659328,
0.0446966514,
0.0156366546,
-0.0240574107,
0.0466724671,
0.0922366753,
0.0027501034,
0.0439687744,
-0.0050958302,
-0.0081777116,
-0.0251768027,
-0.0381153412,
0.0281658955,
0.0418572538,
-0.0097020594,
-0.0248069204,
-0.0191809572,
-0.022900831,
-0.0009647063,
-0.0297749732,
-0.0102219405,
-0.0262669958,
0.0465866476,
0.0709166378,
0.0126548624,
-0.0538751148,
-0.0546560027,
0.0283029247,
-0.0343679152,
-0.032670863,
-0.035396222,
-5.993501128e-33,
-0.0010232261,
0.0099052582,
0.0156031819,
-0.0181596857,
-0.0344382077,
-0.0146958428,
-0.0198028218,
-0.0239338577,
-0.0270646904,
-0.0271849502,
-0.033566732,
0.0141794579,
0.0088225221,
0.0378661491,
-0.0312372856,
-0.025877472,
0.0241555348,
-0.0110793542,
-0.0470810719,
0.0258517377,
0.0144948009,
0.0193833727,
0.0123429401,
-0.0297568236,
0.0134068271,
-0.0484319925,
-0.0090411985,
0.0522229262,
0.0077087847,
0.0578810982,
0.0018515147,
-0.005111651,
0.0237842686,
-0.0476280563,
0.010382249,
0.0315811336,
-0.0670136288,
0.0084490497,
0.000732257,
0.0018038979,
-0.0076823509,
-0.0165821016,
0.0223140586,
-0.0155545156,
0.0477644876,
-0.0196312685,
0.0179350879,
-0.0088349786,
-0.0151891951,
0.0118284468,
0.00038821,
0.0175893214,
-0.0249098651,
-0.0500602797,
-0.0417282693,
0.0775664523,
0.0180712547,
0.0278484207,
0.0109021123,
0.03921175,
0.013958361,
0.0534579009,
-0.004109683,
0.0120664183,
0.0029636256,
0.009642981,
0.0234219581,
0.0105517786,
0.0173779801,
-0.0583710372,
-0.0269851852,
0.0015405379,
-0.00828896,
0.0505399406,
0.0116536347,
0.0462085977,
-0.04871995,
0.0834204927,
0.0268108975,
-0.0210232157,
0.0060728425,
0.0261619482,
-0.0387637094,
-0.0492789708,
-0.0496275611,
0.0397937112,
-0.0456953682,
0.0032383555,
0.0388228595,
0.0327517018,
-0.0309727862,
0.0115065351,
0.0319350995,
-0.0384010859,
-0.0114317695,
0.0111742122,
0.0064823283,
0.0119148092,
0.0053255935,
0.0106560905,
-0.020970853,
0.0344601274,
0.0531538241,
-0.0117746266,
-0.0558014847,
-0.0145667633,
0.0160615034,
0.0185586922,
-0.0516266115,
0.0077535952,
-0.0047500911,
0.0205570161,
-0.0208440963,
0.0615947731,
0.0005032397,
0.0537779331,
-0.009043552,
0.0594298504,
0.0193483494,
0.0079593938,
-0.0814700574,
-0.051829502,
0.0236599687,
-0.0025355199,
-0.0017897259,
0.0234924983,
0.0149615072,
0.0097921537,
-0.050509192,
-0.0256768633,
-0.0171329156,
0.026613852,
2.56e-7,
0.057646405,
0.0171069037,
0.0406784452,
0.0260350518,
-0.0149260294,
0.0532115661,
0.0363247246,
0.0083826166,
0.0728800967,
-0.0034242256,
0.0340984203,
-0.0085223271,
0.0325735174,
-0.0098106619,
-0.121598281,
-0.0223961119,
-0.038832359,
-0.0421138033,
-0.0168438535,
-0.074322015,
0.0167890228,
0.0916755721,
-0.0149709471,
-0.0032935305,
-0.0175504815,
-0.0321425013,
0.035046462,
-0.0161838215,
-0.0279837884,
0.0351521894,
-0.0108504221,
-0.0037440532,
0.0229591206,
-0.0116963638,
-0.0143992212,
0.0279874392,
0.031203514,
0.0758042857,
0.0157328099,
-0.0708111152,
-0.019220544,
0.0029262831,
0.0072064134,
-0.0633549169,
0.0606684722,
-0.0253472365,
-0.0096143978,
0.0282898657,
-0.0226433016,
-0.0226234384,
0.0256131552,
-0.0225504395,
-0.0234908108,
0.0170493238,
0.0054311519,
0.0311432835,
0.0040499046,
-0.0490140431,
-0.0109711494,
-0.0080903228,
-0.0372302681,
-0.0300877485,
-0.0206997208,
0.012935305,
-0.0260120947,
-0.0357930586,
0.0044677709,
2.387067195e-34,
0.0415350534,
0.0262792278,
-0.0009595,
0.0434237979,
0.0434089042,
-0.0129240612,
0.0221053828,
-0.0034372902,
0.0426164977,
-0.1318976432,
-0.0339620486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15474v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15474v1 | WundtGPT: Shaping Large Language Models To Be An Empathetic, Proactive Psychologist | 2024-06-16T16:06:38 | 2024-06-16T16:06:38 | Chenyu Ren, Yazhou Zhang, Daihai He, Jing Qin | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | Large language models (LLMs) are raging over the medical domain, and their
momentum has carried over into the mental health domain, leading to the
emergence of few mental health LLMs. Although such mental health LLMs could
provide reasonable suggestions for psychological counseling, how to develop an
authentic and effective doctor-patient relationship (DPR) through LLMs is still
an important problem. To fill this gap, we dissect DPR into two key attributes,
i.e., the psychologist's empathy and proactive guidance. We thus present
WundtGPT, an empathetic and proactive mental health large language model that
is acquired by fine-tuning it with instruction and real conversation between
psychologists and patients. It is designed to assist psychologists in diagnosis
and help patients who are reluctant to communicate face-to-face understand
their psychological conditions. Its uniqueness lies in that it could not only
pose purposeful questions to guide patients in detailing their symptoms but
also offer warm emotional reassurance. In particular, WundtGPT incorporates
Collection of Questions, Chain of Psychodiagnosis, and Empathy Constraints into
a comprehensive prompt for eliciting LLMs' questions and diagnoses.
Additionally, WundtGPT proposes a reward model to promote alignment with
empathetic mental health professionals, which encompasses two key factors:
cognitive empathy and emotional empathy. We offer a comprehensive evaluation of
our proposed model. Based on these outcomes, we further conduct the manual
evaluation based on proactivity, effectiveness, professionalism and coherence.
We notice that WundtGPT can offer professional and effective consultation. The
model is available at huggingface. | [
0.1034193933,
-0.0063235909,
-0.0218298659,
0.019405961,
-0.0334901512,
0.0419619977,
-0.0140214413,
0.00245355,
0.056312006,
0.0280441865,
-0.0044764481,
-0.0150599191,
-0.0399114527,
0.0198521614,
-0.0063472376,
-0.1165870503,
-0.0017182875,
0.0193069559,
0.0882475078,
0.010263239,
0.0268415622,
0.0281287841,
-0.0525505841,
0.0309378896,
0.0186046306,
-0.0243521277,
0.0066155209,
0.000485139,
0.0323652588,
-0.0532272868,
-0.0082182633,
0.0310191568,
0.0065582218,
-0.0331872925,
0.0000024241,
-0.0460766293,
-0.0032118089,
-0.015061615,
-0.0034144139,
-0.0617990419,
0.0419125967,
-0.0697515905,
0.0091380822,
0.0208562072,
-0.014194075,
-0.034600243,
0.0230097156,
0.0870091468,
0.0599373803,
0.0228574909,
-0.0152434213,
-0.0168271046,
0.0095746825,
-0.0135122379,
-0.0242461711,
0.0021879112,
0.0101620033,
0.0195436962,
0.0492560007,
-0.0310556013,
-0.0214005467,
0.0348930061,
-0.0091299778,
-0.0056446362,
0.0142656965,
0.0013389522,
0.0332261622,
-0.0560663678,
0.0147669315,
0.0680702478,
0.0575989671,
0.0567927398,
0.0417961217,
-0.0261327773,
0.0207081083,
-0.0134328036,
-0.0184479561,
0.0272503123,
-0.0129282596,
-0.0171630252,
0.0535718314,
0.0186488256,
-0.0059511187,
0.0164820012,
0.0383937433,
0.0117257033,
-0.0182378255,
-0.0175042246,
0.015123995,
-0.016553551,
-0.0643346384,
-0.0631847829,
0.0191197358,
0.0568325669,
-0.0776815712,
0.0263458919,
-0.0006281427,
-0.0179168805,
0.0311293099,
-0.0064884066,
0.0080748741,
0.0478771552,
0.0082053421,
-0.0056954389,
0.0720849708,
0.0206060912,
-0.0062332065,
0.0218616258,
-0.0438136868,
0.0292599034,
-0.0503201745,
-0.0189444013,
-0.0416735746,
-0.0091661373,
0.0188253727,
-0.02349177,
-0.0553967208,
0.0126788868,
-0.0246944781,
0.0153238531,
-0.0196483098,
-0.0378217846,
0.0000780407,
0.0166324042,
-0.0210077912,
0.0300534461,
-0.0518142879,
-0.019497579,
0.0173212048,
-0.0181443263,
0.0219876114,
0.0064780461,
-0.0283929575,
-0.0070283343,
0.0159511119,
0.00600495,
0.0081127631,
-0.0174822491,
-0.0155826388,
-0.0253581181,
-0.0436395705,
-0.0125257298,
0.0087961815,
-0.0264501609,
0.0329506099,
0.0076717534,
0.0057501686,
-0.0049065412,
0.0265263654,
-0.0133102899,
-0.0584842339,
0.0587177426,
-0.0300299004,
0.0229755845,
0.01416633,
0.0477733575,
0.0067940336,
0.0173239037,
-0.0122101838,
-0.0133247636,
0.0099411141,
-0.0378446616,
0.0233281143,
-0.0144874202,
-0.0033995141,
-0.0238604508,
0.013330102,
-0.0258458517,
0.0049437555,
0.0915876627,
-0.0134759294,
0.0240122266,
-0.0275706016,
0.036760956,
0.0285807494,
0.0916949883,
0.0195443388,
0.0425703004,
0.0066617974,
0.0202939361,
0.0064095706,
0.0085567283,
-0.0337521397,
0.0144149158,
-0.0080191847,
-0.0223589186,
-0.0216905959,
-0.0282279514,
-0.032135535,
-0.0335012302,
-0.0315090008,
-0.0154756587,
0.0018336438,
0.0328769088,
-0.0440956652,
-0.0240166541,
0.0203336477,
0.0199876074,
0.0335968174,
-0.0186280031,
-0.0227465052,
-0.054370977,
0.0181665812,
0.1174437106,
0.0363232531,
-0.0272357557,
-0.020117972,
-0.0173875671,
-0.0147589026,
0.0356374532,
0.0250344984,
-0.0077163107,
0.0009914394,
-0.0171095338,
-0.0020939442,
0.0071934541,
0.005702503,
-0.0332293585,
-0.0664366633,
0.0296811108,
-0.0324728303,
0.0105629107,
-0.0113484608,
0.0463357791,
-0.0787201002,
-0.025297083,
-0.0349093825,
-0.0035778177,
0.0350328945,
0.0349954814,
-0.0013597755,
0.0387294069,
0.0033906987,
-0.0287970006,
-0.0182950441,
0.057380762,
-0.0470968112,
0.0017390618,
-0.0005436175,
-0.0070173903,
0.0124334795,
0.0034917479,
-0.0041557578,
-0.0096927956,
0.016417494,
-0.0512014218,
0.0471764319,
-0.0012767371,
0.0267639998,
-0.0117039066,
0.0053848247,
-0.0313306339,
-0.0122708278,
-0.0056703803,
0.0352839492,
0.0005893086,
-0.0387496278,
-0.0473876894,
-0.0251436923,
-0.0219379999,
0.0352196731,
-0.0031979664,
-0.0245792773,
-0.0249451771,
0.0312264543,
-0.0487014726,
-0.068749316,
-0.1313436478,
-0.0016547049,
-0.0022448937,
-0.0229204632,
0.0411531292,
-0.0156308394,
-0.0366943665,
0.0170729216,
-0.0412251279,
0.0446558408,
0.0659902766,
0.0070646922,
0.0120140249,
0.0335979834,
-0.0100298915,
-0.0323321074,
-0.016300641,
-0.0373342559,
-0.006897754,
-0.0115017518,
-0.0169624519,
-0.0423395559,
-0.0248857345,
-0.0786285549,
-0.0282480791,
-0.0094945896,
-0.0811497644,
0.0177724846,
0.0069329864,
0.0471168235,
0.028613165,
0.0038206398,
0.0583751053,
0.0035564993,
-0.0145705324,
-0.0629330352,
0.0147740804,
-0.0007689604,
-0.0377954282,
-0.0400741063,
-0.0534495264,
-0.0003012618,
0.0673541352,
0.0311838668,
0.0297896266,
-0.0525404774,
-0.0161542781,
-0.0002329342,
0.0201531425,
-0.0001850345,
-0.0327027403,
0.0095049534,
-0.0115916105,
0.0214187689,
-0.0173405707,
0.0774327815,
0.0179944187,
-0.0155691439,
-0.0677234009,
-0.0399693698,
-0.0091175186,
0.0603531264,
-0.0302701592,
0.0367479697,
0.0323394388,
-0.0224720798,
0.0154292472,
-0.0463081263,
-0.0189743694,
-0.0366116986,
-0.0052311113,
-0.0423859246,
-0.0250435565,
0.0068688034,
0.0123155704,
-0.0368521772,
-0.0053868177,
-0.0552417524,
0.0050760945,
0.0139727881,
0.0357233696,
-0.0344483294,
-0.0142467096,
0.0738990456,
0.0658494234,
-0.0034341887,
-0.0351439342,
-0.0184804089,
-0.0557002351,
0.0390022434,
-0.0101833483,
0.0491741002,
-0.0282422602,
0.0695700347,
0.0341682471,
-0.0177906286,
0.0349584147,
0.0628807992,
0.0093149953,
0.0141719719,
0.0138125848,
-0.0066551371,
0.0108938962,
0.0151660908,
-0.012030785,
-0.044703465,
0.1413919032,
0.0259267092,
-0.0650646165,
0.0335562788,
-0.0808747634,
-0.0394273996,
-0.0131114936,
-0.0155571084,
-0.0335824713,
-0.0071032881,
-0.0554404929,
0.024309855,
-0.0477257222,
-0.0102655282,
0.0146625359,
0.0022877238,
0.0376546979,
-0.0092575038,
0.0529286228,
-0.0070932875,
0.0108186994,
0.0033798611,
0.0496832281,
0.0040143514,
-0.0110279918,
0.0161268543,
0.0018994957,
0.0199704356,
-0.0465398841,
-0.0372584015,
0.0638993084,
-0.0165470708,
0.0717116073,
0.0287020151,
0.0546199307,
0.0047006584,
-0.0532886013,
-0.0551455095,
0.026457822,
0.0021214574,
0.0081688967,
0.0180206858,
-0.0112376958,
0.0286383815,
-0.0669460371,
0.0686785579,
-0.0615178682,
0.0023718867,
0.0242823102,
0.0923581645,
-0.0356791802,
-0.0302947015,
-0.0133319879,
0.0602508672,
0.0389706045,
0.0466721803,
0.0011327794,
-0.0450302176,
0.0295528006,
0.0603742637,
0.0226610731,
0.066770494,
-0.0340014175,
0.0247390196,
-0.0074586198,
0.0041748043,
-0.028282756,
-0.0449954197,
0.0333285816,
0.0017905377,
0.0020705727,
-0.0355406813,
-0.0066630766,
0.0113921855,
-0.0522157922,
0.0532230884,
0.0420887098,
0.0459470823,
-0.0473751202,
0.0164298434,
0.054341089,
-0.0156836789,
0.0066056424,
0.0041555064,
0.0147101441,
-0.0243932288,
0.0489497371,
0.0302569233,
0.0160128344,
-0.0229409803,
0.0160291903,
-0.055880852,
-0.0601007342,
0.006647462,
-0.0502456613,
-0.0045294911,
-0.0251339544,
0.0602860488,
0.0100478418,
0.0374843329,
0.0034813131,
0.0454812944,
0.0431908444,
0.0297236312,
0.013164036,
-0.0375785604,
0.0132542867,
0.0583668761,
0.0008222166,
-0.0079626739,
-0.0145190414,
-0.0153830303,
-0.0626961067,
-0.0108292829,
-0.0133987423,
-0.0389187597,
0.0063330797,
0.0060209674,
-0.0028657736,
-0.0026139719,
-0.0982982293,
-0.0633790866,
-0.0559197068,
-0.0235531908,
0.019549055,
-0.0401662737,
-0.0461818464,
-0.0283923578,
0.012873468,
-0.0136250332,
0.0097833313,
-0.0251752194,
0.0075194715,
-0.0010180642,
0.1424157321,
0.020572152,
-0.018837614,
0.0209035855,
0.02220672,
0.0021298013,
-0.1324715912,
0.0016950584,
0.0262420662,
0.0514559671,
0.0351478346,
0.0092586949,
-0.0579600744,
0.0323619694,
0.0068475665,
0.0109973438,
-0.0190918799,
-0.0534636788,
0.0513091274,
0.0173298959,
-0.0107261213,
-0.0559233651,
-0.0240020286,
-0.0722516924,
0.007633091,
0.0066305753,
0.0120405275,
-0.0304887425,
-0.0098314947,
0.036663413,
-0.0117516192,
-0.0674858466,
0.0381496623,
-0.070195049,
-0.0381950736,
0.0006300498,
-0.0304423813,
-0.0447691642,
-0.0615958124,
0.0204771571,
0.0311314687,
-0.0053931242,
-0.0428221524,
-0.0206280388,
0.0943942666,
-0.0497126691,
-0.006095028,
-0.0074941311,
-5.765515468e-33,
-0.0052116197,
-0.020789735,
0.0191859584,
-0.0276744273,
-0.0557750948,
-0.0155156618,
-0.0309677254,
0.0344231799,
-0.0162923764,
0.0269818865,
0.0121255582,
0.0553613156,
-0.0015698596,
-0.0034425135,
0.0146117052,
-0.0006295313,
0.0131335473,
0.013573057,
-0.0437013358,
0.0134715466,
-0.0427625328,
0.0496941395,
0.0391733013,
-0.0517879426,
0.041940745,
-0.020194713,
-0.0192520935,
0.0599992648,
0.0076957969,
0.0263547674,
-0.0305711459,
0.0324780457,
0.0473927371,
0.0172357168,
0.0259913038,
0.0237464793,
-0.0201395825,
-0.026701875,
0.0541637279,
-0.0242570359,
-0.0932562426,
-0.0254721418,
-0.0036688596,
-0.0209531132,
-0.0225252509,
-0.0127267474,
-0.0071748965,
-0.0463997759,
0.0277023297,
0.0128086647,
-0.0274917148,
-0.0268669352,
-0.0146865342,
-0.0002240934,
-0.016448522,
0.0124818366,
-0.0588820577,
0.0235448033,
-0.0139612276,
-0.0163420159,
0.0318076536,
0.0002124917,
0.0131583866,
-0.0331276432,
-0.0242414288,
0.0461517796,
-0.0318485685,
0.0127592292,
0.0021719907,
0.0349656865,
0.0050902637,
0.0100582177,
0.0508777499,
0.0119397594,
-0.0480242521,
-0.0242996905,
-0.0062716091,
-0.0254249778,
0.0444506258,
0.0147989383,
0.044786118,
-0.0044710841,
-0.0182934608,
-0.0345948301,
-0.066085659,
-0.0030262547,
-0.0087550441,
-0.0374362469,
0.0191489551,
-0.0131740319,
-0.0049420749,
-0.0405321568,
-0.0212023091,
-0.0029363143,
0.0100956513,
-0.0244162139,
0.0004931432,
0.0528558381,
-0.005033595,
0.0156136919,
-0.0253067352,
-0.0201276541,
-0.0470619798,
-0.0253805071,
0.0756879523,
0.0169967432,
0.0031105599,
-0.0102420235,
-0.0068781464,
-0.0069121527,
0.0153922746,
0.0562364496,
0.0127598708,
-0.0025309355,
-0.0485218056,
0.0038898834,
-0.0199586134,
0.0299837198,
0.0317983106,
-0.0497141965,
-0.0676450506,
-0.0178818461,
-0.0188204739,
0.0091167493,
-0.052372057,
-0.0239683259,
-0.0209228322,
0.0261779521,
0.0888229162,
-0.0107530113,
-0.006377107,
-0.0102661224,
3.163e-7,
-0.0223768707,
0.0491708517,
-0.018487744,
0.0077436958,
0.0212805513,
0.0324020945,
0.0031883046,
0.0775453821,
0.0399494134,
-0.035744179,
0.0085914815,
0.0168552697,
0.0382045582,
0.0385159962,
-0.0208138339,
0.0095175533,
-0.0308370572,
-0.0257466659,
-0.0498090126,
0.0134330913,
0.0766235963,
0.0303920135,
0.0111296214,
0.0001652553,
0.0151915625,
0.0374063365,
0.0203214437,
-0.0570511557,
-0.0009876168,
0.0730698928,
0.0491225757,
-0.0212502945,
0.0379571021,
0.0284523256,
0.0329407752,
-0.0038939079,
-0.0091212075,
0.112901397,
-0.0574817136,
0.0202136859,
0.0140907075,
0.0250993446,
0.0116529986,
-0.0645515993,
-0.019308012,
-0.122815989,
-0.0562400632,
0.0226630885,
0.0032688077,
-0.0584759563,
0.0364606567,
-0.0205292366,
-0.0369853675,
0.0689468458,
0.0237870328,
0.0104039442,
0.0240438972,
-0.0198674556,
0.0294814203,
0.0077741342,
-0.0122701386,
-0.0331787802,
0.0013479894,
0.0083020478,
-0.0143710999,
-0.0739315897,
0.033619076,
2.461379101e-34,
0.0041117454,
0.0585710295,
0.0346920863,
0.0079758475,
0.0370507762,
0.0411951058,
0.0045634243,
0.0536794253,
0.0050397217,
-0.0562369116,
-0.0196616594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10985v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10985v1 | Taking a Deep Breath: Enhancing Language Modeling of Large Language Models with Sentinel Tokens | 2024-06-16T15:50:10 | 2024-06-16T15:50:10 | Weiyao Luo, Suncong Zheng, Heming Xia, Weikang Wang, Yan Lei, Tianyu Liu, Shuang Chen, Zhifang Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown promising efficacy across various
tasks, becoming powerful tools in numerous aspects of human life. However,
Transformer-based LLMs suffer a performance degradation when modeling long-term
contexts due to they discard some information to reduce computational overhead.
In this work, we propose a simple yet effective method to enable LLMs to take a
deep breath, encouraging them to summarize information contained within
discrete text chunks. Specifically, we segment the text into multiple chunks
and insert special token <SR> at the end of each chunk. We then modify the
attention mask to integrate the chunk's information into the corresponding <SR>
token. This facilitates LLMs to interpret information not only from historical
individual tokens but also from the <SR> token, aggregating the chunk's
semantic information. Experiments on language modeling and out-of-domain
downstream tasks validate the superiority of our approach. | [
0.0126440115,
0.0541704074,
-0.0133033469,
0.0058702962,
-0.0241399482,
0.0020586234,
0.0068134484,
-0.0235340856,
-0.005712464,
-0.0556027107,
0.003078622,
-0.060977485,
0.0012994908,
0.0536212847,
0.0424695909,
-0.0731734931,
0.0574805476,
-0.0480625182,
-0.0112016704,
0.0181331802,
-0.0053092698,
0.0082479268,
0.0419992395,
0.0553469062,
-0.0181971323,
-0.0129942913,
-0.0116849691,
-0.0085627837,
0.0212446954,
-0.0236599762,
-0.0128439628,
0.0250450466,
0.0267365742,
0.0288519152,
0.0000021466,
-0.0195721891,
-0.0082245516,
-0.0043208315,
-0.0191733409,
0.0239950363,
0.0695820898,
-0.0087686665,
-0.0140644023,
0.026171295,
-0.0119398255,
0.0054068975,
0.0344849564,
0.0269561689,
0.0531430095,
0.0505386963,
-0.0118958596,
0.0027682325,
0.0306014195,
-0.0366060771,
-0.0025446825,
-0.0271605067,
0.0413762145,
-0.0470363982,
-0.0060953014,
-0.0045633721,
-0.0244993288,
0.066109471,
0.0398582481,
-0.0123545742,
0.0361473896,
0.052167248,
-0.0432024114,
-0.0118729956,
-0.019495979,
0.0323769785,
-0.0564941242,
-0.0224037208,
0.0090407822,
0.0047503146,
-0.0164863821,
-0.0384054184,
-0.0862442851,
0.0347121209,
0.0195100307,
0.0308147576,
0.0141242109,
0.0109671028,
0.0127802286,
-0.0074146814,
-0.0983457267,
0.0518442988,
0.0072931838,
-0.0144570041,
-0.0383547284,
-0.0277018957,
-0.007849928,
-0.0762046203,
0.0362123623,
0.0589113608,
-0.018357154,
0.0309882816,
-0.0325447395,
-0.0444076695,
0.0255434234,
-0.015566675,
-0.0180768073,
0.0237250738,
-0.0512575284,
0.065870896,
-0.0369300395,
0.0339074321,
-0.0192441307,
0.0241985023,
-0.0529287346,
-0.0275111683,
-0.0222617835,
-0.0263762157,
-0.043024756,
0.0331062898,
-0.0605716296,
-0.0423998088,
-0.0342810228,
0.0551873595,
0.0079184165,
-0.0258047543,
0.0091542182,
0.0122672096,
-0.0088939294,
-0.0029606398,
0.0026062694,
0.0352604836,
-0.0069164978,
-0.0140608614,
0.0164139476,
-0.0637478828,
-0.018047452,
0.0358542092,
-0.0158473477,
-0.0199681912,
-0.0364034176,
0.0860795751,
-0.0009885249,
-0.029346412,
-0.0166410506,
-0.0149494372,
-0.0542061962,
-0.0395513177,
-0.001779414,
-0.059353929,
0.0358065255,
0.0074894098,
-0.0009008744,
-0.0551048368,
0.020821631,
0.0276802257,
-0.036377687,
0.0288649332,
-0.0031562785,
0.0148044042,
-0.0012941697,
0.0020832326,
0.0381243825,
0.0756572634,
0.0452689752,
0.04524168,
0.0101625742,
-0.0014249684,
-0.022718152,
0.065687336,
0.0088995844,
0.0185928307,
-0.0356448852,
-0.0093886619,
-0.0010145705,
0.0188342649,
0.0492128208,
0.0877658203,
-0.006240759,
0.0036357571,
0.0730689168,
0.0886746347,
-0.0132665467,
0.0266622249,
0.0310299788,
0.0087030875,
-0.014623615,
0.0049251211,
-0.0550370514,
0.0311889015,
0.0235650484,
0.0161560904,
0.0350816213,
0.060686633,
-0.0245326404,
-0.0332659148,
-0.0143960277,
-0.0039145364,
0.0134878196,
0.0308220312,
0.0635010079,
-0.0150114503,
-0.0370799936,
0.1012232304,
0.032491073,
-0.0532269999,
0.027446311,
-0.036408592,
0.0040850258,
0.0697108582,
0.0378589034,
-0.0251142848,
-0.0153864147,
-0.020293178,
0.0266523622,
0.0406159833,
-0.0055659269,
0.0237752236,
-0.0136455512,
-0.0416826792,
-0.0129890116,
0.0024288243,
-0.0076287161,
-0.0085988641,
0.0066460422,
-0.0143514192,
0.0299137924,
0.0159989893,
-0.0298177395,
0.0468733646,
-0.0484670289,
-0.0243417397,
-0.0064678178,
-0.0091046747,
0.0238757506,
-0.0011774752,
0.0168954004,
0.0252641756,
0.0424483232,
-0.0557675473,
-0.0197863374,
0.0265316851,
-0.0563548654,
0.0115511799,
0.037842378,
-0.0124471011,
-0.0043098927,
0.0214144234,
-0.0208729636,
-0.0445067175,
-0.0024380654,
-0.0627898127,
0.0688201562,
-0.0148126781,
0.0366694219,
-0.004154087,
0.0485028327,
-0.0531441718,
0.0482101068,
-0.0150300879,
-0.0137498379,
0.0116151255,
-0.0114302961,
-0.0102108391,
-0.0329128839,
-0.0243839566,
-0.0193188898,
-0.0055121831,
-0.0033339227,
0.0174993742,
-0.0174192097,
-0.0422341675,
-0.0331164598,
-0.098408103,
0.0040494762,
-0.0183423888,
0.0161196701,
0.0177296828,
0.030925421,
-0.0135149481,
-0.0023918864,
-0.0393805578,
-0.0214038119,
-0.0178174172,
0.0189183839,
0.0101148011,
-0.0193304829,
-0.0184951629,
-0.0451068282,
-0.0175845306,
-0.0295779072,
0.0663796663,
-0.0063899388,
-0.0517453887,
-0.0595496781,
0.0199075006,
-0.0161262508,
0.0085078171,
-0.0282964092,
-0.0265562255,
-0.0082568638,
-0.0130095258,
0.1103109345,
0.0702698007,
0.0453454182,
0.0286201593,
0.0500770621,
-0.0151090464,
-0.0289313737,
0.0147842029,
-0.0370520204,
0.0021889403,
-0.0177560095,
-0.0291240159,
0.0269462392,
0.0631868094,
-0.0036847158,
-0.0003818881,
-0.019445153,
0.0038176337,
-0.0394888446,
-0.024017375,
-0.027393207,
-0.0079014143,
-0.0662422851,
0.0232698061,
-0.0222857092,
-0.0466581583,
0.0534740351,
-0.0318909064,
-0.0054554814,
-0.0174644534,
-0.0075620827,
-0.0495609082,
0.0600558668,
0.0159329027,
0.013080027,
0.006460906,
-0.0208771881,
-0.02414288,
0.0005383075,
-0.0549419671,
-0.0272261258,
0.0922962874,
-0.017596852,
-0.0036891864,
0.001079464,
-0.0039651715,
-0.0485084876,
-0.0365159214,
-0.0636888221,
0.0340377986,
0.0417077765,
-0.0135401292,
-0.0718023106,
0.0415123254,
0.0617071502,
0.0278933812,
-0.0368873626,
-0.0111018447,
-0.0274027251,
0.0202265754,
0.0769414231,
-0.0088732233,
0.0322011188,
-0.0478623137,
0.028715685,
0.078463912,
0.0514531694,
0.03438434,
-0.0225143973,
-0.0327470675,
0.0261523128,
-0.0299154837,
0.0135525949,
0.0125203673,
0.0555991158,
-0.0767905042,
-0.0076092109,
0.1213582754,
0.0280926563,
-0.0322898142,
0.0306699928,
-0.0153516531,
0.0193792433,
0.0164386872,
0.0140995812,
-0.0487805232,
-0.0229961462,
0.0188782569,
-0.0200634394,
0.0128852064,
-0.0033735109,
-0.0022544283,
-0.0781364515,
0.0386319607,
0.0112342406,
-0.0614142679,
0.0160972867,
-0.0413082317,
0.0173745379,
0.0018151707,
0.0458904132,
0.0113822315,
-0.0252940897,
-0.038439814,
0.017258808,
-0.0351880975,
0.0014590552,
0.0143477395,
-0.0361044779,
0.0340866335,
0.0357429236,
0.0202566385,
0.0048382408,
-0.0408385098,
0.0527707748,
-0.026522655,
0.0168352872,
0.0087836003,
0.0510357358,
-0.0157615207,
-0.0189337153,
-0.0282543991,
0.0112806018,
-0.0412874073,
-0.0260607544,
-0.0062195519,
0.0855471939,
0.0046488647,
-0.0132898614,
-0.0344149433,
0.0056680953,
-0.0172320958,
0.0689550042,
0.0541850477,
-0.0539559126,
-0.034127783,
-0.0292488672,
-0.037112657,
-0.0340306871,
-0.052088961,
0.0064047631,
-0.0210009515,
-0.0543011017,
-0.0382965989,
-0.0141609302,
0.0531308278,
0.0120678889,
-0.0036605294,
0.0128169097,
0.0447323434,
-0.0124896048,
-0.0437048785,
0.0383273959,
-0.0626204237,
0.0365020521,
-0.0407530032,
0.0050267894,
0.0406730697,
0.0011549887,
-0.0072150701,
0.0354932062,
-0.1302721053,
-0.0576662943,
0.0435206257,
0.0251721758,
0.0235183965,
0.0130558871,
-0.0272164661,
-0.0456199124,
0.0848646164,
0.0379016437,
-0.0697317868,
0.0158974025,
-0.0129131451,
0.0209636576,
0.0060141026,
0.0334966108,
-0.0539292134,
0.0066319583,
0.0113320062,
0.0246644188,
-0.0152029321,
-0.016899379,
-0.0063277176,
0.0035649936,
0.0275813304,
-0.0171210356,
0.0005205564,
0.0101957256,
0.0114067104,
-0.0288736578,
0.0096421288,
-0.0213814378,
0.0207955595,
-0.0092938552,
-0.001582927,
0.000947207,
0.047813125,
-0.0244721193,
-0.0192417689,
-0.0449510403,
0.0157581121,
-0.043202024,
0.0080893012,
0.0297627337,
0.0075294711,
-0.0190882646,
-0.0443554781,
-0.0374413878,
-0.0032918463,
-0.0062959525,
0.0142085347,
0.0154683376,
0.0000277409,
-0.0321931168,
0.0441237427,
-0.0845936835,
-0.0395876467,
-0.0134224072,
0.0154141774,
0.045945134,
-0.0072462489,
0.0537949428,
-0.0027535101,
-0.0168734156,
-0.0302863978,
0.0098239221,
-0.0054182098,
-0.0317539163,
0.0027318578,
0.0346802175,
-0.0270982757,
-0.0047543137,
0.0634578392,
0.0188820045,
0.0024975741,
0.0276833363,
-0.0134979179,
-0.0212299414,
-0.009992158,
-0.0163100846,
0.0291340463,
-0.0375435539,
-0.0272577405,
-0.0579094589,
-0.0789313018,
0.0332337804,
0.0069811,
0.0049343817,
-0.0326772667,
0.0281506404,
0.0244290382,
0.0014742145,
-0.0362475477,
-0.0240646154,
0.0335879475,
0.0115861008,
-0.0197206549,
-0.0130028492,
-6.813027871e-33,
-0.0142760836,
-0.0398317054,
0.0297528096,
0.0111033041,
-0.0648939833,
0.0189210195,
-0.0517204888,
-0.0203549732,
0.0295305327,
-0.0064473446,
-0.0256167799,
0.0083288187,
0.0172593687,
0.0417672284,
0.0138806459,
-0.007414544,
0.0537660308,
0.0056456979,
-0.0038732493,
0.0322867557,
0.040026363,
0.0317321382,
0.0426406674,
-0.0323636979,
0.0067877048,
0.0079096304,
0.0089346869,
0.0113277668,
0.0248870719,
0.0682261661,
-0.0385787152,
0.046008639,
0.020922929,
-0.0425876677,
-0.0496415198,
0.0589709617,
-0.0654965118,
0.0124798408,
0.047905758,
-0.0121299885,
-0.0341711752,
-0.0451384448,
0.0642849877,
0.0030947821,
0.0307052322,
-0.0312667824,
0.0448968224,
-0.0317659415,
-0.0576401129,
-0.0528702103,
-0.070884943,
0.0351852179,
-0.0022536444,
-0.0099817403,
-0.0032517973,
0.0201206896,
-0.0017368561,
0.0590799153,
-0.015703015,
-0.001520962,
0.0214494988,
0.0634537786,
0.0622510798,
0.0511715785,
0.0174928792,
0.0607573837,
0.03257294,
-0.0000982811,
-0.0604169145,
-0.0234349873,
0.0612562485,
0.0052394159,
0.0340608694,
-0.0062088035,
0.0134093212,
-0.010303678,
-0.0554236248,
0.0040167468,
0.006349368,
0.0587590784,
0.0634567589,
0.0338094942,
0.0278926119,
-0.0059051793,
-0.0218826868,
0.0175749362,
-0.0278778411,
-0.0043167314,
0.011484663,
0.0150976432,
-0.021397518,
-0.0002869184,
0.0394650735,
-0.0350388438,
0.0139561379,
0.0015887069,
0.0207956396,
0.0252701174,
-0.0023383284,
0.0199205931,
-0.042701669,
-0.0071011479,
0.013188811,
0.0200110786,
0.0075495425,
-0.0000343652,
0.0410451442,
0.0181922,
-0.0728639662,
-0.0182276834,
-0.0378486514,
0.0078646354,
-0.0012555358,
0.0007809349,
0.036328584,
0.0086627426,
-0.0030799157,
0.0448196307,
0.0046682917,
-0.0313820653,
-0.0296795983,
0.0276749674,
0.0129866777,
0.0347716361,
-0.04481766,
-0.0023847341,
-0.0538834371,
0.0457229838,
0.0645301118,
-0.0787734687,
-0.024767179,
0.0162529666,
2.787e-7,
0.0420576818,
0.0591965355,
0.0589512587,
0.0071068108,
0.0328760296,
-0.0088063469,
0.0214733817,
0.0177730303,
0.0271399431,
0.0100893825,
-0.0143976035,
0.0319297947,
0.0516664162,
0.0212034099,
-0.123808004,
-0.0034966101,
-0.0860953405,
-0.0091064023,
-0.0537278764,
-0.0013488139,
0.056146279,
0.123724781,
0.0096261026,
-0.0069970046,
0.0092949346,
-0.0209668092,
0.0413893051,
-0.0308158882,
-0.0248067845,
0.0276024584,
-0.0012036507,
0.0069583538,
-0.0066672475,
-0.0160701498,
-0.0078054387,
0.0050053303,
0.0101897055,
0.0856654271,
-0.0255638231,
-0.0224968381,
0.000440101,
-0.0125201633,
-0.0115418667,
-0.0684092641,
0.0570753664,
-0.0770585611,
0.0007230105,
-0.0548316464,
-0.0186868589,
0.0174272563,
-0.0163077861,
0.0058470611,
-0.0447200723,
0.0613553748,
0.0131761096,
-0.0107855331,
-0.0050993222,
-0.107770443,
-0.056516543,
-0.0130395954,
-0.0635566637,
-0.0319957472,
-0.0505486764,
-0.0265352745,
0.024032427,
-0.05686187,
-0.0119742583,
2.897605054e-34,
0.0553008132,
0.0100282282,
-0.0198978465,
0.0281943679,
0.0246876478,
-0.0253051016,
0.0048387875,
0.0328129083,
0.0215704478,
-0.1046732813,
-0.0377405658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10984v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10984v1 | Revisiting Cosine Similarity via Normalized ICA-transformed Embeddings | 2024-06-16T15:44:37 | 2024-06-16T15:44:37 | Hiroaki Yamagiwa, Momose Oyama, Hidetoshi Shimodaira | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cosine similarity is widely used to measure the similarity between two
embeddings, while interpretations based on angle and correlation coefficient
are common. In this study, we focus on the interpretable axes of embeddings
transformed by Independent Component Analysis (ICA), and propose a novel
interpretation of cosine similarity as the sum of semantic similarities over
axes. To investigate this, we first show experimentally that unnormalized
embeddings contain norm-derived artifacts. We then demonstrate that normalized
ICA-transformed embeddings exhibit sparsity, with a few large values in each
axis and across embeddings, thereby enhancing interpretability by delineating
clear semantic contributions. Finally, to validate our interpretation, we
perform retrieval experiments using ideal embeddings with and without specific
semantic components. | [
-0.028750008,
0.0253690947,
-0.0145807043,
0.047248967,
-0.0168194622,
0.0465786047,
0.0432742499,
0.0325558744,
-0.0119690364,
-0.0045067738,
-0.0626547635,
-0.0045490661,
0.0146708358,
-0.009414617,
-0.0014449704,
-0.0342796296,
0.0398561917,
0.0353977792,
-0.0175243244,
-0.022698855,
-0.0079632271,
-0.0475122295,
0.0312073044,
0.0270737037,
-0.0283708535,
-0.0190850478,
0.0286073927,
-0.0451896787,
0.0153792771,
-0.0313255414,
-0.0492097624,
0.0251244046,
0.0621808805,
0.0051945504,
0.000001837,
-0.0294288844,
-0.0324569717,
-0.0120420568,
0.0345215648,
0.0256094467,
-0.0052516414,
-0.0436690003,
0.037883535,
-0.0510746241,
-0.0203445535,
-0.0292323735,
0.0273976289,
0.0663826615,
0.0048723966,
0.032856863,
-0.0228308272,
-0.0495291762,
-0.0411312096,
-0.0344023854,
0.0473331846,
0.0154108843,
-0.0014716442,
0.0141710052,
-0.0468031652,
0.0688484907,
-0.0522890501,
0.0177202448,
-0.0086068716,
0.0250412151,
0.0362821482,
0.0608758964,
0.0030093668,
0.0146378977,
0.0358647108,
0.0738492832,
0.0013603724,
-0.0094373599,
0.020954879,
0.01295364,
-0.0227619167,
0.0782257989,
-0.0876589715,
-0.0369272716,
0.0468673185,
0.046767626,
-0.0024095322,
0.0477920137,
0.0071418379,
-0.0382404327,
-0.0134472558,
0.0077691968,
0.0253954343,
-0.0276810974,
-0.0224528313,
-0.0164395161,
0.007373292,
0.0501059853,
-0.0054984814,
-0.0148773883,
0.0436733812,
-0.0050856275,
0.0318270996,
0.0026231476,
0.0176000167,
-0.0439385325,
0.0314642116,
0.0248956699,
-0.0174763445,
0.0585791282,
-0.0422574952,
0.0579236522,
-0.0231325459,
0.0638636723,
-0.0165637285,
0.0151786078,
-0.0521707535,
-0.0164023917,
0.0197389591,
0.0221594088,
0.0070925569,
-0.0124894921,
0.0108988099,
0.0237268358,
-0.0564935133,
-0.0011192732,
-0.0314199999,
0.0516610146,
0.0054909093,
0.0161411986,
-0.0109025696,
0.0227808021,
-0.0354987755,
-0.00274684,
-0.061785996,
0.004790165,
-0.0127895093,
0.0489368774,
0.038625136,
-0.0240596756,
0.0016250057,
0.0401345864,
-0.0045331586,
-0.0215977728,
0.0455774516,
-0.0346132107,
0.012633957,
0.0117099071,
0.0410708189,
-0.0600281209,
0.0534452684,
0.018813774,
0.0015033197,
-0.0719502047,
-0.0255251545,
0.0133710532,
-0.0654640719,
0.0713310987,
0.0265958998,
-0.0001892721,
-0.0136081241,
0.0228013918,
0.0128444517,
0.0303616077,
-0.0159219634,
-0.0219248645,
0.0700535029,
-0.0092020575,
-0.0191348288,
-0.0254600421,
-0.0049236268,
0.0040092687,
-0.049954012,
0.0052119647,
0.0313604064,
0.0124643678,
0.033700496,
0.0290943254,
-0.0296424795,
-0.0595095679,
-0.0096779345,
0.0943383425,
0.0104357861,
-0.0117920646,
0.0167999621,
0.0299459025,
-0.0112882312,
0.0483145304,
-0.0434216261,
0.0283938423,
0.0505966134,
-0.0167153738,
0.0332890823,
-0.0209301673,
-0.0386939384,
-0.0187647827,
0.0002134227,
-0.0225366279,
-0.0209163763,
-0.0502246059,
0.016882306,
-0.051616624,
0.0412862077,
-0.0300253965,
0.0485741347,
-0.0595678352,
-0.0021075369,
0.0396148376,
0.0367936529,
0.0090663191,
0.0308851525,
-0.0497752763,
0.0155254388,
0.0446474068,
-0.0239610039,
-0.0177965611,
-0.0032351438,
-0.0302583799,
-0.0069668908,
-0.0319474414,
-0.0476112813,
-0.0046935873,
0.0423141345,
0.0346122347,
-0.0590433963,
0.007736302,
0.0500736982,
-0.0304901581,
0.0037087698,
0.0105207264,
-0.0375677161,
-0.0142025491,
0.0118921446,
0.0278217811,
-0.0381528959,
0.034078151,
-0.0030238219,
0.0123602496,
0.046681907,
-0.0712581947,
-0.0348982923,
0.0155560188,
-0.0302254632,
0.0008521612,
0.0250654966,
-0.1123114675,
0.0059515955,
0.0141941449,
0.0167528745,
-0.0349389166,
0.0514358953,
-0.0231042765,
0.0028531984,
-0.0004099693,
-0.022064833,
-0.0369271934,
0.0277911685,
-0.0453126952,
0.0521697402,
0.0119328024,
0.039150849,
0.0190985724,
-0.0275480859,
0.0746746883,
-0.0040149577,
-0.0061987825,
0.0198918693,
0.0198510736,
-0.0026667162,
0.0236455202,
-0.0208224766,
-0.0140270339,
0.0090332907,
-0.0395971648,
-0.015891498,
-0.0140842358,
0.007607155,
0.0335098803,
-0.0222320054,
0.0025157412,
-0.0299113281,
-0.0463131256,
-0.0013224954,
-0.0448479243,
0.0360883549,
0.042495627,
-0.0362158492,
-0.0140699372,
-0.0597855411,
-0.0283688102,
-0.0468023084,
0.0738338009,
0.0211327411,
0.0098646283,
0.0090276506,
0.0225816853,
-0.0564595759,
-0.0179620851,
-0.0284404662,
0.0274045896,
0.0418521091,
-0.0367426202,
0.0182768889,
0.0101583339,
-0.0086635938,
0.0237480123,
0.0640766099,
-0.0093213711,
-0.046151109,
-0.0340550169,
-0.0594635643,
0.0781956911,
-0.0100181242,
-0.0329164192,
0.0134872859,
0.0016642916,
0.0344377905,
-0.0265097152,
-0.0529585555,
0.0330218524,
-0.0250210129,
0.0060182493,
-0.0937414616,
-0.0063539394,
0.0083608702,
0.0013660321,
0.0076948744,
-0.0217954107,
0.0070515252,
-0.0197811071,
0.0279623587,
-0.0254874639,
0.0001050543,
-0.0613922663,
0.0659587309,
-0.020196015,
0.0086932732,
-0.0301335417,
-0.0141329505,
0.0085116141,
0.0567128658,
0.0243105423,
-0.0308264978,
0.0330520421,
0.027478274,
-0.0193309747,
-0.0032026391,
0.0008190708,
-0.0174456611,
-0.0376406796,
0.0143903913,
0.0006323433,
0.0387112089,
-0.0147731854,
-0.0168646723,
-0.0188990738,
0.0231076106,
-0.0170565583,
0.0009012381,
-0.0054359823,
-0.0161095392,
0.0530281663,
0.0202415362,
0.0126986215,
-0.0108479839,
0.0168480631,
0.0012463467,
0.0264758132,
0.0108510833,
-0.0308455713,
-0.0266449023,
0.0310387686,
-0.0274619218,
0.0298525672,
-0.0287849791,
-0.0612072609,
0.0166392345,
0.0280365665,
-0.0218208004,
0.0740614459,
0.0375097692,
-0.0970363542,
0.0159091279,
-0.0326056629,
0.0014381361,
0.0421723388,
-0.0090983482,
-0.0202952065,
-0.0185507555,
-0.0123043563,
0.0190742798,
0.0183841642,
-0.0390317068,
-0.0056031658,
-0.0609965287,
0.007261862,
-0.02470758,
0.0222238339,
-0.0977032334,
-0.1123364866,
0.0231465809,
0.0034224347,
-0.017034376,
-0.0358108394,
-0.0241740867,
0.02274625,
0.0061439248,
-0.0495891608,
-0.0402221493,
-0.0269979239,
-0.0062036114,
0.0085691866,
-0.0312693231,
0.0490129218,
-0.0149599826,
-0.0649055168,
-0.0135512836,
-0.0646704882,
0.0243972018,
-0.0058827419,
0.0544574037,
0.0246269219,
-0.0363024101,
-0.0173674617,
-0.0033321267,
0.0024337466,
-0.0042392295,
-0.0461311713,
0.0911626667,
-0.0351990834,
-0.0148872603,
-0.043306224,
-0.036811851,
-0.0123828268,
0.0638042614,
0.0616742782,
0.0053356108,
0.008026802,
0.0008000192,
0.0607175529,
0.0714720413,
-0.0213425942,
-0.0243222434,
-0.0070843827,
-0.0258211028,
-0.0782156661,
-0.0323610045,
-0.0227249786,
0.0435932763,
-0.0103762541,
-0.008045299,
-0.0443647951,
-0.0523031764,
-0.0271734428,
0.0288372748,
-0.026664691,
-0.0143153323,
0.0266492851,
0.040122617,
0.0034790281,
-0.0105408262,
-0.0616391264,
-0.0651515946,
0.0056722471,
-0.0571451187,
-0.0073115914,
-0.0403526016,
0.0068339789,
0.0207574293,
0.0002702296,
-0.0172226056,
0.0559217371,
0.0477619059,
-0.008599963,
0.0336725116,
0.0205317196,
-0.0467283018,
0.0154129444,
0.042407129,
-0.0285251718,
0.0271468069,
-0.0107775209,
0.032762453,
0.0084634246,
-0.0132538872,
0.0184537638,
0.0198742095,
0.0688066408,
0.043576058,
0.0270070843,
-0.0150513481,
-0.0450032614,
-0.0511242934,
0.0057759751,
0.0210074354,
-0.026280107,
0.0154786212,
-0.0061778845,
-0.0367773511,
0.0746723488,
-0.0029796844,
0.035929963,
-0.0520034619,
0.011505899,
-0.0154033937,
0.0006965924,
-0.0815467909,
0.0158494711,
-0.0198815558,
-0.0031138055,
-0.0388786606,
-0.0048604975,
-0.0304847118,
-0.0292770937,
0.0093119191,
0.0074818623,
-0.068736203,
0.0334192701,
-0.0486881286,
-0.0012198711,
0.0622493774,
-0.0372231454,
0.0069329957,
-0.0317663252,
0.0487145185,
0.000477316,
0.0067561343,
-0.0023361766,
-0.0208757129,
0.005902471,
0.0030423438,
0.0657254606,
-0.0011251892,
-0.0032392335,
0.0311845429,
0.0928216353,
-0.072227031,
0.0175692514,
-0.087145485,
-0.0187697299,
-0.0033279776,
0.047663644,
0.086423263,
0.0502138734,
-0.0391761847,
-0.0107986154,
-0.0349848159,
-0.0119467694,
0.0272962283,
0.0053598168,
-0.0165130198,
0.0545422211,
0.0307094995,
0.0476602502,
0.0032671841,
0.0173029061,
0.0232508518,
-0.0058065797,
-0.0654722676,
-0.0363498703,
-0.0381947123,
-6.309515152e-33,
0.0246011708,
0.0123628406,
-0.0368697271,
0.0155040389,
-0.0379291177,
0.0360303447,
-0.0233753845,
0.0212136935,
-0.0238419771,
0.041535832,
-0.00225604,
0.0041696099,
-0.0112291314,
-0.0127069652,
0.0179928076,
-0.019466877,
0.016915448,
0.0294752792,
-0.0247465633,
0.0303965043,
0.1096623018,
0.0147467032,
0.0511840098,
-0.1460812688,
0.0151530607,
0.0137960706,
0.04541751,
0.005598709,
0.0737753436,
0.0398068763,
-0.053032089,
0.0595597066,
0.0366544276,
-0.0063423901,
-0.0193749219,
0.0152708841,
-0.0261380561,
-0.0626284182,
-0.0111531429,
-0.0216296073,
-0.011938435,
-0.0475557297,
0.041813232,
-0.0288167875,
-0.0241733324,
-0.0408589244,
0.0777509734,
0.0312104747,
-0.0152644571,
0.0346563384,
-0.0209858343,
0.019168349,
-0.0410420038,
0.033976119,
0.0294908676,
0.0378954411,
0.0067565152,
0.0463153422,
-0.0339289345,
0.0342736058,
-0.0983192027,
0.020385785,
0.0046227365,
-0.0435123481,
0.0304827318,
0.0970897451,
0.0481705181,
-0.0351501219,
-0.0145588294,
-0.0433446653,
0.0482128039,
0.013718647,
0.0247092117,
0.0180024356,
0.0322217643,
-0.0126948599,
-0.0564547107,
0.0449001268,
-0.0384177752,
0.019911984,
0.0065007797,
0.0177704766,
-0.0802374408,
-0.0059000007,
-0.0250403024,
-0.005685071,
-0.0290082004,
-0.0372769609,
0.0160503816,
-0.0080376826,
-0.0311026629,
0.0568980873,
0.012670964,
-0.013146366,
-0.0094738351,
0.0485375784,
0.0113526694,
0.0272319075,
0.0189795271,
-0.0788491145,
-0.0021365657,
-0.0290021971,
0.0358999744,
-0.0508985855,
0.0448911488,
-0.0312388055,
0.0498792082,
0.0081774341,
-0.055195041,
-0.0422167778,
0.0214602463,
-0.115490295,
-0.0223681983,
-0.049268309,
0.0135275722,
0.0411412306,
-0.0169701446,
0.0302541889,
0.0489602871,
0.0675022081,
-0.034212444,
-0.0490855649,
-0.0068155904,
0.0218855031,
-0.0002461939,
-0.0045354213,
-0.0342529826,
-0.0099821351,
0.0341296829,
-0.0603424981,
-0.0002673321,
-0.0108357156,
2.622e-7,
0.0112393834,
0.0452223755,
0.0307957828,
-0.0127441017,
0.0439268015,
0.031123573,
-0.0039513595,
0.0469293296,
-0.0251503214,
0.0014255034,
-0.0050582644,
0.024446724,
-0.0255734231,
0.0320519954,
0.0253948141,
0.0537984185,
-0.0234282594,
-0.0319049396,
-0.0309542343,
0.0058750347,
0.0598419458,
0.0697241053,
0.0087299151,
0.011883311,
0.020027535,
-0.0265263077,
0.047330521,
-0.0377863459,
0.0255512446,
-0.0358638428,
0.0074304631,
-0.0173354726,
0.0695095584,
0.009006747,
0.01738571,
0.0299539361,
0.0594158806,
-0.002753034,
-0.0152499992,
0.0365005583,
0.009434009,
0.00675243,
0.0028103325,
-0.0428065397,
0.1013599411,
-0.028814584,
-0.0339386985,
-0.0323861837,
-0.0330234021,
0.0708792135,
0.0257587861,
0.0572115853,
-0.0344423056,
-0.0002421194,
0.0126123633,
0.0096803484,
0.0213280898,
-0.0311366301,
0.0233156923,
-0.0023916077,
-0.0428140499,
-0.0102528241,
-0.0332202278,
0.0016669427,
0.0563669391,
0.0168945119,
0.0075742798,
2.352454167e-34,
-0.0120517313,
0.0249956641,
0.0165753402,
-0.0294362959,
-0.0000921445,
-0.0562581085,
-0.008207906,
-0.0113456454,
0.0128042847,
-0.0748094991,
0.0190752931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10977v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10977v1 | Toward Optimal LLM Alignments Using Two-Player Games | 2024-06-16T15:24:50 | 2024-06-16T15:24:50 | Rui Zheng, Hongyi Guo, Zhihan Liu, Xiaoying Zhang, Yuanshun Yao, Xiaojun Xu, Zhaoran Wang, Zhiheng Xi, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang, Hang Li, Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68 | The standard Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) framework
primarily focuses on optimizing the performance of large language models using
pre-collected prompts. However, collecting prompts that provide comprehensive
coverage is both tedious and challenging, and often fails to include scenarios
that LLMs need to improve on the most. In this paper, we investigate alignment
through the lens of two-agent games, involving iterative interactions between
an adversarial and a defensive agent. The adversarial agent's task at each step
is to generate prompts that expose the weakness of the defensive agent. In
return, the defensive agent seeks to improve its responses to these newly
identified prompts it struggled with, based on feedback from the reward model.
We theoretically demonstrate that this iterative reinforcement learning
optimization converges to a Nash Equilibrium for the game induced by the
agents. Experimental results in safety scenarios demonstrate that learning in
such a competitive environment not only fully trains agents but also leads to
policies with enhanced generalization capabilities for both adversarial and
defensive agents. | [
0.0296514686,
0.0320751294,
-0.0184437092,
0.0213666167,
-0.0498125777,
0.0025973797,
-0.0412925519,
-0.009290969,
0.0046198466,
-0.0134149129,
-0.0327204615,
-0.0374331325,
0.0036089201,
-0.0433015302,
0.0477956608,
-0.0225690417,
0.0639887601,
-0.0293958858,
0.0054264856,
-0.0099042151,
0.0181004182,
-0.0348532423,
-0.0319492109,
0.0026983302,
0.0162071791,
0.0071016224,
-0.0438640155,
0.0302419513,
0.052136004,
-0.026115993,
0.0243667532,
-0.0070821354,
0.0166745037,
0.066407986,
0.0000016803,
-0.0559287183,
-0.0267187133,
-0.018512167,
-0.0200089421,
-0.0239057671,
0.0160449948,
-0.0471116975,
-0.0373920798,
0.0209592003,
-0.0456255227,
0.0275948979,
0.0397252142,
0.0275021549,
0.0770635605,
0.1180816814,
0.0266153105,
-0.0002480984,
0.0411055051,
-0.0271261204,
-0.0243817978,
-0.0899996981,
0.0136172445,
-0.0167518463,
-0.024952963,
-0.0316812173,
-0.0129995067,
0.0181990732,
0.0081225261,
0.007972368,
-0.0348135903,
0.0302896611,
0.0037644184,
0.0085870279,
-0.0263159852,
0.0622224137,
-0.0288737323,
-0.0175563563,
0.0153399464,
-0.028516762,
0.0306777712,
-0.0060863011,
0.0036165689,
-0.0107760997,
0.0062825945,
0.0377605706,
0.0067045344,
-0.0374005809,
0.0553228408,
0.009657193,
0.0069604316,
0.0645516589,
0.001230737,
-0.0423685834,
0.0184472986,
0.0099925147,
-0.0019258129,
-0.0635557324,
-0.0577915162,
0.0438143238,
-0.0764980763,
0.0380650498,
-0.0579138249,
-0.0106840283,
0.0197295286,
-0.0142927282,
0.0296763275,
0.0262934435,
0.0142790014,
0.0373488516,
-0.0058825468,
0.0506556258,
-0.0321995728,
0.0679487213,
-0.0191396102,
0.0199808013,
-0.0097586755,
-0.0162271298,
-0.0006246939,
0.0205246247,
0.0188527908,
0.0237494949,
-0.044817213,
0.0412724391,
-0.0257272776,
0.1047869176,
-0.0270795058,
-0.0070716459,
-0.0264022592,
-0.0149312178,
-0.0473957434,
-0.0159231164,
-0.0279886406,
0.0024375138,
0.0220814981,
-0.0439638011,
-0.0353185162,
0.0174608305,
-0.0611040927,
-0.0402661301,
-0.0020008353,
0.1116105914,
-0.0289930217,
-0.0089608822,
-0.0275630299,
-0.0016501239,
-0.0045986846,
-0.0663230494,
-0.0024174899,
-0.0380155854,
0.0280229915,
-0.0261631943,
-0.0469413884,
-0.0749014094,
-0.0036706694,
-0.0186732598,
-0.0070331688,
0.1242855713,
0.0093302177,
-0.0011273483,
0.0323528722,
-0.0166098401,
-0.006199819,
0.0735668913,
0.0333702974,
0.0123673314,
0.0153638618,
-0.0005787945,
0.0136208255,
0.06975995,
0.0390598476,
0.0440637395,
0.0103579452,
0.0001798903,
0.0293878634,
0.0922863558,
0.0200635958,
-0.004071048,
-0.0083556874,
-0.0372382663,
0.0677382573,
0.0442885906,
-0.0002006817,
-0.0167167746,
0.0038541455,
0.0208260249,
-0.0283231195,
0.0487162732,
-0.0612662137,
0.0195380226,
-0.0640318617,
-0.0020287277,
0.0006978134,
0.0030458204,
-0.0309379846,
-0.0390332453,
-0.0149461105,
-0.0119351363,
0.0209418293,
0.0237091314,
0.0253737941,
0.0014051691,
-0.0726206526,
0.0179893635,
0.0229796935,
-0.0129538365,
-0.0079393517,
-0.0608421564,
0.0232658219,
0.0406106412,
0.0440281108,
-0.0640464574,
-0.0591027439,
-0.01372883,
-0.0195823722,
0.0534875654,
0.0355340131,
-0.0046035619,
0.0131304776,
-0.0393387228,
-0.0348578617,
-0.0264336821,
-0.0117048761,
0.0348214619,
0.0156996585,
-0.0285418499,
-0.0330765508,
0.0295749288,
-0.0422763936,
0.0607945696,
-0.0034017407,
-0.0543350242,
-0.0281285271,
0.0509206168,
0.0567006581,
-0.0042549567,
-0.0062511279,
0.0161109287,
0.0420731567,
-0.0196271297,
0.0095684007,
-0.0051788888,
0.0053805513,
-0.0173414703,
0.0663622171,
-0.010514711,
-0.0321904942,
0.0424432904,
-0.0494497642,
-0.0319063365,
0.0006235606,
-0.028270876,
0.0074456478,
0.0120043587,
0.0271959398,
-0.0093571479,
-0.0200554319,
-0.0692466199,
0.060103111,
-0.0042636599,
-0.0146576986,
-0.0110164061,
0.0124419928,
-0.0045691794,
-0.0704188421,
-0.0057134647,
0.0299918111,
-0.0054299301,
0.0202097502,
0.0434192717,
-0.012251433,
-0.0319736488,
-0.0301730391,
-0.0078136912,
0.0086917961,
-0.0167167764,
0.0295641478,
0.0391004458,
-0.0516031571,
-0.0083656106,
0.0022834663,
-0.0501709133,
0.0075041326,
0.0263279434,
0.0004779004,
0.0677118674,
0.0116676921,
-0.0386764482,
-0.0719931349,
0.0083912406,
-0.0248959493,
-0.0052880533,
-0.0151509102,
-0.0033380305,
-0.0803688094,
0.021105146,
-0.0176861919,
0.0537802987,
-0.0344836563,
-0.0598369651,
0.0541073196,
0.0099165523,
-0.0135081876,
0.1083781421,
-0.0015262002,
0.0415265188,
0.0527818911,
0.0333265401,
-0.0875443444,
0.0299777463,
-0.0089145862,
-0.0652030781,
-0.0946983546,
-0.0365400016,
0.0278773531,
0.0926612392,
0.0066299136,
0.0124864839,
-0.0436022766,
0.0131303156,
0.0478548035,
-0.0431310534,
-0.0206491668,
-0.0240615141,
-0.0442405567,
0.0137518737,
-0.0527636036,
-0.0401710682,
0.0936550498,
-0.0205439571,
0.0139085036,
-0.016633993,
-0.0250987019,
-0.0003312763,
0.045177307,
0.0100433184,
0.0161413606,
-0.0142901819,
-0.0306495689,
-0.1025250331,
-0.0658955052,
0.0602902509,
-0.0267883483,
0.0551523007,
-0.0223635975,
0.0001736658,
-0.0257433951,
-0.0346628502,
-0.066171661,
-0.0379111022,
-0.020337835,
0.0016378162,
-0.0190239269,
-0.0117808348,
-0.0516609102,
-0.0139046945,
0.0305272769,
-0.0102136619,
0.0043696258,
0.0120577626,
-0.0481305942,
-0.0014989979,
0.0512913428,
0.032959342,
-0.0010112301,
-0.0421392731,
0.035382811,
0.0384702086,
0.0267282855,
0.0155490711,
-0.0065474245,
-0.0346381031,
0.0430855379,
-0.0692467988,
0.0062488611,
0.0169415232,
0.0343556739,
-0.0127230762,
0.0052021015,
0.0575439148,
0.019833928,
-0.0139185516,
0.0115036285,
-0.0142273298,
0.0450160205,
0.0114335679,
0.0277670752,
-0.0339965709,
-0.019209424,
0.0009215979,
0.0352579057,
0.008314399,
-0.0062949872,
-0.003420989,
-0.1251499355,
-0.0316844359,
0.0313554779,
-0.0366354212,
-0.0179574192,
0.0155746965,
-0.0093504563,
-0.0306150429,
0.0608429164,
0.036566034,
0.0291498415,
-0.0163763575,
0.0176011473,
0.0412621945,
-0.0022264987,
-0.0411533043,
-0.053290464,
0.0756424591,
0.1231724918,
0.0395522527,
-0.015705822,
-0.0329843163,
0.0229638442,
0.0246541351,
0.0042931074,
0.0464097597,
0.0204909164,
-0.0288225655,
0.0027757376,
0.0243581552,
0.053102091,
0.0092151305,
0.0087409792,
0.0180650894,
0.0187056828,
-0.0043988442,
0.033848621,
0.0099589368,
0.0115623958,
0.0185982008,
0.058525674,
0.0012930548,
-0.0339708626,
-0.0391433947,
-0.0375038534,
0.0022784197,
-0.0475859232,
-0.0444044434,
0.0348865055,
-0.0090200379,
0.0158506725,
-0.0485817231,
-0.0566023923,
-0.023590941,
0.0296956692,
0.0177467875,
-0.010931246,
-0.0331630819,
0.0099575706,
-0.0150506292,
-0.009689251,
-0.0155690713,
0.0249147899,
-0.0371119417,
-0.0149781452,
0.0013605929,
-0.057804849,
-0.0065126484,
-0.0027023586,
-0.0512540936,
-0.0977279618,
-0.0144267892,
0.0421818532,
0.0157763436,
0.0832469687,
-0.0239479188,
-0.0297377929,
0.0572426058,
0.0151600568,
-0.0090705594,
0.0136105791,
0.0386269093,
0.0042163413,
0.0044616363,
0.0578948893,
-0.0550642721,
-0.0430043079,
0.0765990391,
0.0314906947,
-0.04467934,
-0.0322247036,
0.0428159125,
0.0108823404,
0.0493340641,
-0.045002643,
-0.0238440055,
0.0237297863,
0.0284971092,
0.0219701659,
-0.0247214325,
0.003303899,
-0.0192029458,
0.0248353686,
-0.0224979557,
0.0380624495,
-0.0067893253,
0.0105125131,
0.0244268216,
-0.0161536615,
0.0094721215,
0.0137331774,
0.0236746389,
0.0263107121,
0.0337566398,
0.0122801503,
0.0754806474,
0.01882842,
0.0263615474,
0.0474973209,
0.0396385342,
0.0504135266,
0.0306944214,
-0.0134594152,
0.0071961954,
-0.0494699441,
-0.0496541895,
0.0075233988,
0.0291130058,
0.0819831863,
0.0181161985,
0.0211190134,
-0.0147469416,
-0.0069725914,
0.0235505421,
-0.0163149145,
-0.0414786227,
-0.0089568608,
0.0624558032,
0.0232601296,
-0.0158770476,
-0.0017737027,
0.0684050322,
0.0120783532,
0.070946157,
-0.0390736945,
0.0322335996,
-0.0383880846,
-0.0528482981,
0.0493854173,
0.0012872203,
-0.0404361151,
-0.0028978926,
-0.0142426984,
-0.0519274622,
-0.0314847454,
0.0657259449,
-0.0204557851,
0.0014728594,
0.031735383,
0.0359698273,
-0.0140263988,
0.0043356088,
-0.0163730774,
0.0166458134,
0.0020311889,
-0.0584963374,
0.0028524373,
-5.574625104e-33,
-0.0340678841,
-0.0409155115,
0.0310895834,
-0.0065138545,
-0.029186951,
-0.0337682031,
0.0015772015,
-0.0089972476,
-0.02702008,
-0.0065440703,
-0.0103017492,
0.0074318829,
0.0122418879,
-0.0056715859,
-0.0029440757,
-0.0561720915,
-0.0056898594,
-0.0217961781,
-0.0503491499,
-0.0313490666,
-0.0158441532,
0.0266940668,
0.04956384,
-0.0253369398,
0.0590046048,
-0.0072812913,
-0.046024248,
0.0467287898,
-0.0416511968,
0.0629619509,
0.0266679749,
-0.0095684007,
-0.0078870552,
-0.0299436133,
0.0151726594,
0.0124366051,
-0.0315652229,
-0.0171128884,
0.0338834897,
0.0243555494,
-0.0588375032,
-0.0534779653,
0.0615045354,
-0.0242892019,
-0.0393205956,
0.0179946553,
0.0137900524,
-0.0091296434,
-0.0325657725,
-0.0003347704,
-0.0538706183,
0.0039369031,
-0.0151861589,
-0.0250366498,
0.0124112796,
-0.0027281083,
0.0140818972,
0.0067120777,
-0.0608063415,
0.0220295247,
0.003422423,
0.0172439069,
0.0909917578,
0.0467919149,
0.0076712985,
0.0635292605,
-0.0070934533,
-0.0272124428,
-0.0223736595,
-0.0509767421,
0.0007237614,
0.0019305105,
0.0433372594,
0.0667293891,
-0.0106988,
-0.0133427298,
-0.0740895495,
0.0323841795,
0.0229408611,
0.0469490029,
-0.0069916006,
0.0497640334,
-0.037859343,
0.0083823483,
-0.0453994721,
-0.0126729002,
0.0000700777,
-0.0531000607,
-0.0004077959,
0.0040967371,
0.0034072802,
-0.0542236902,
-0.012779776,
-0.0373499915,
-0.0018511617,
-0.0072924271,
-0.0026967044,
-0.0094040288,
-0.0232927594,
0.0176964942,
-0.0591986217,
-0.0400324576,
-0.0404930897,
-0.0166278258,
0.0282289237,
0.0305437446,
0.0272272527,
0.0280562099,
-0.0460804328,
0.0198748335,
-0.0245279148,
0.0251125712,
0.0122301914,
-0.0221211836,
0.0667822808,
-0.0298102424,
-0.0006604796,
0.0223405771,
0.0132248495,
-0.058451049,
0.0021078209,
0.024074411,
-0.0348905399,
0.0271590166,
-0.0369687006,
0.0272523463,
-0.0039622518,
0.0525812805,
0.0034508863,
-0.0581058972,
-0.0110790068,
-0.0373315811,
2.464e-7,
-0.0000628904,
0.0213307869,
0.0343690962,
0.0395309776,
0.0088677378,
0.0681208372,
-0.0620269366,
0.0625486299,
-0.0356782489,
-0.0438240096,
0.0431573503,
0.0240181182,
0.0429220349,
0.0125922253,
-0.0462198704,
0.0240889676,
-0.0902122259,
0.0356799997,
-0.0232806578,
0.0113668358,
0.0178698339,
0.0849058479,
0.0192785095,
-0.0119009791,
-0.001446333,
-0.0387494005,
0.0438383408,
-0.0508582629,
-0.0039843563,
0.0359114334,
0.0378080048,
-0.0093409829,
-0.0295969564,
0.0106491521,
0.006091577,
0.0260124188,
-0.029181106,
0.043781817,
-0.0116070993,
-0.0525674373,
-0.0487976037,
-0.0021020405,
0.0102847945,
-0.0254888758,
0.04272056,
-0.037645068,
-0.0498350523,
-0.0115686515,
0.0148836039,
-0.0215150248,
0.0034276131,
-0.0105324788,
-0.0026488944,
0.016874142,
0.0057540224,
0.0171490163,
0.0070646717,
-0.0523340106,
-0.0387579761,
0.0199209843,
-0.0128135532,
-0.0308715422,
-0.0018697873,
0.0441334583,
0.0133494241,
-0.0512187444,
-0.0321650133,
1.827939748e-34,
-0.0062133991,
-0.0368389077,
0.0138640944,
0.0236733127,
0.0119872224,
0.0084291054,
-0.0346962996,
0.0279838964,
0.0649432316,
-0.0038797769,
-0.0068026483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10976v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10976v1 | Promoting Data and Model Privacy in Federated Learning through Quantized LoRA | 2024-06-16T15:23:07 | 2024-06-16T15:23:07 | JianHao Zhu, Changze Lv, Xiaohua Wang, Muling Wu, Wenhao Liu, Tianlong Li, Zixuan Ling, Cenyuan Zhang, Xiaoqing Zheng, Xuanjing Huang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | Conventional federated learning primarily aims to secure the privacy of data
distributed across multiple edge devices, with the global model dispatched to
edge devices for parameter updates during the learning process. However, the
development of large language models (LLMs) requires substantial data and
computational resources, rendering them valuable intellectual properties for
their developers and owners. To establish a mechanism that protects both data
and model privacy in a federated learning context, we introduce a method that
just needs to distribute a quantized version of the model's parameters during
training. This method enables accurate gradient estimations for parameter
updates while preventing clients from accessing a model whose performance is
comparable to the centrally hosted one. Moreover, we combine this quantization
strategy with LoRA, a popular and parameter-efficient fine-tuning method, to
significantly reduce communication costs in federated learning. The proposed
framework, named \textsc{FedLPP}, successfully ensures both data and model
privacy in the federated learning context. Additionally, the learned central
model exhibits good generalization and can be trained in a resource-efficient
manner. | [
-0.0044257352,
0.1122978255,
-0.0143990945,
0.0481860936,
-0.0284766406,
-0.0303375721,
0.1111607403,
-0.0127933295,
0.0166113582,
-0.0111040156,
-0.0523331128,
-0.0179215241,
0.0009067269,
0.0250490271,
0.0213812832,
-0.00466986,
0.0283050202,
-0.0295468215,
-0.0065105888,
-0.0380697399,
-0.0360848643,
0.0136650298,
0.0327826105,
0.0073588318,
0.0236023013,
-0.070600383,
-0.0205987114,
0.0050749606,
0.0111474562,
0.0171577968,
0.0564952828,
0.0464882143,
0.0209137574,
0.0770260245,
0.0000019392,
0.0148795033,
-0.0775123537,
0.0415471382,
-0.0382974781,
0.0347255096,
0.0051997872,
-0.0014046429,
-0.0114201028,
0.030047724,
-0.0444845706,
-0.033732675,
0.0330266282,
-0.0010912368,
0.05024755,
0.0616363958,
0.0049429885,
-0.0152062792,
-0.0124583198,
-0.0260880664,
-0.0889759883,
-0.0455892459,
-0.0238734093,
-0.0249221046,
-0.05167339,
-0.0008507838,
-0.0203958657,
0.0338378176,
0.0325508229,
0.0393485278,
0.0078540826,
0.0015525247,
-0.0364239328,
-0.0328944772,
-0.0479860641,
0.0395291932,
-0.0203437153,
-0.0071766293,
0.0316778645,
0.0065924418,
-0.0163750481,
-0.0057381112,
-0.0075265854,
0.0392809734,
-0.0148092303,
0.036911577,
-0.0211385731,
-0.0264246576,
0.0068848543,
0.0137728406,
0.0300257225,
0.0784080401,
0.008760062,
0.0314072371,
-0.0548985451,
-0.0232955143,
-0.0290027075,
-0.0790569559,
0.0570997521,
0.0233340468,
0.0254243705,
-0.0239611641,
-0.0812107399,
-0.0446973331,
-0.0024645079,
0.0228851605,
0.0306563508,
-0.0309467241,
0.0148086566,
0.0341676325,
-0.0121487398,
0.0115830917,
-0.0412167013,
0.0404393338,
0.0301299505,
0.0359514877,
-0.0137351165,
-0.0002557955,
0.0064636045,
0.0730213895,
-0.0587873869,
-0.0106682135,
-0.0117415367,
0.0221965648,
-0.0203803126,
0.0359359533,
-0.0227083098,
0.0151798809,
-0.0143724969,
-0.028673429,
0.032828331,
-0.0110419206,
0.0047788001,
0.0158707555,
0.0291419663,
-0.0508109145,
-0.0261051059,
-0.0138443355,
-0.0194472298,
0.0152879506,
-0.0198130347,
0.0602662861,
0.0405409597,
-0.0118377991,
0.0170072205,
-0.0865849927,
0.0581810921,
-0.0578401461,
-0.0137258619,
-0.0473907106,
-0.0182000585,
-0.0272193421,
0.0109524922,
-0.043427337,
-0.0175607298,
-0.0079350406,
0.0048952983,
0.0333501659,
-0.0335135534,
-0.0265155099,
-0.0043820394,
0.035131298,
0.004945335,
0.0588459261,
0.0213054642,
0.0201900024,
0.0645700097,
0.0113859987,
0.0029150071,
0.0061105648,
0.0621609166,
0.0220223963,
-0.0022803168,
0.0054208566,
-0.0068443343,
-0.00915433,
-0.0296962354,
0.0234348346,
-0.0291182529,
-0.0414263941,
0.0662108511,
0.0689210221,
0.0430666655,
-0.0033568421,
-0.088580519,
0.0379504301,
0.0052805454,
0.0065515018,
-0.0499240197,
0.0166928247,
-0.0278135408,
-0.0509621426,
0.0077207452,
0.0869707912,
-0.0263727773,
-0.0294539779,
0.0082582179,
-0.0583198667,
-0.0347461365,
0.0498373248,
-0.0101345722,
0.0270826351,
0.0360771716,
0.0653037354,
0.0108492626,
-0.0330089517,
-0.0177495535,
-0.0447071865,
0.0200842228,
0.0491937585,
0.0533155091,
0.0002816322,
-0.0163042806,
-0.032640148,
0.0190694574,
0.0166573264,
-0.0337944254,
0.0047473037,
0.1032802016,
-0.0243552756,
-0.0570892319,
0.0147405872,
0.0152904578,
-0.0091237891,
-0.0037094771,
0.0142020965,
-0.0231911447,
-0.0076936069,
0.0041440427,
0.0164258834,
0.0327836163,
-0.0556248166,
0.036546465,
0.0321274474,
0.0056677032,
0.0168267526,
-0.0057938742,
-0.0185823031,
0.0019505032,
0.0378067158,
0.0114353923,
-0.0483757742,
0.0150980828,
0.0122131435,
-0.017603429,
-0.0053390223,
0.0347960889,
0.0312360395,
-0.0479275249,
0.0016587131,
-0.0036577419,
0.0111384401,
0.0485848635,
0.0326577909,
0.0065170168,
-0.0023213658,
0.0689068884,
-0.0153568201,
-0.0358647071,
-0.0299771652,
-0.0345373042,
-0.0232218597,
-0.0003740777,
0.0281136725,
-0.040409904,
0.0335019976,
0.0162556749,
0.0354507007,
0.0203539971,
-0.0176622439,
0.0286303815,
0.0216837805,
0.0207012817,
0.0119210742,
0.0000739299,
-0.0513183698,
0.049274873,
0.0368981026,
0.0271403734,
-0.0247425195,
-0.0625391752,
-0.0220759809,
0.0070511317,
-0.0589758195,
0.0239535104,
-0.0103300093,
0.0015282591,
-0.0502503663,
-0.0051648896,
-0.0380699188,
0.0311816148,
0.0482386127,
-0.0386961773,
-0.0134969437,
-0.0706049204,
-0.0107840803,
-0.0586742945,
0.0283486433,
0.0073951627,
0.0132626919,
0.0337703899,
0.0322421119,
-0.0453849398,
0.0694168136,
-0.0129182683,
0.0074383328,
0.0699124485,
0.0055988058,
-0.0467660613,
-0.0061569214,
-0.0226130355,
-0.0588517562,
-0.0459077843,
0.0457989015,
0.0292352121,
0.0195903145,
-0.0232505593,
-0.0572201945,
-0.0050985054,
0.0725554079,
-0.0152334226,
-0.0382818468,
-0.0465552807,
0.0314218886,
0.0240227096,
0.0570790209,
0.0199145805,
-0.0581954569,
0.0657076985,
-0.0221856553,
0.025702009,
-0.0034685079,
-0.0622982457,
-0.0385576151,
0.0429631546,
-0.0411849618,
0.0534910001,
0.0012561212,
-0.0530618019,
-0.018035762,
0.0076147891,
0.0569982342,
-0.0401056968,
-0.0529288165,
-0.0295987464,
-0.0416990854,
-0.0098329745,
-0.0470935777,
0.0195651501,
-0.0376211219,
0.006657341,
0.0010800095,
-0.0611629039,
-0.0166977812,
0.0586159118,
0.0131656807,
0.0076138098,
0.0152116939,
-0.0421691649,
0.0137731237,
-0.0305905621,
-0.0028751034,
0.0054296772,
-0.0541339628,
-0.0110550197,
-0.0106198918,
-0.0023160002,
0.070848003,
0.0769322067,
0.0085186707,
0.0227146801,
-0.0288139805,
0.0435767435,
0.0137618203,
-0.0114058172,
-0.0030280033,
0.0857928395,
-0.0243691541,
0.0027857043,
0.0259086024,
-0.0200363584,
-0.0731141046,
-0.026752919,
-0.0034037111,
0.0699831769,
-0.0064100497,
0.0068560564,
-0.0962653458,
0.0109402817,
0.0287973937,
0.0613056645,
0.0122065069,
-0.0178559963,
-0.0638028681,
-0.0461192131,
-0.0109618967,
0.029090479,
0.0186702199,
-0.024308756,
-0.0223503932,
0.0044596819,
0.0056668757,
0.0288819689,
-0.0442968421,
0.0049346872,
0.0020144039,
0.0153179662,
0.0090805423,
-0.0168691408,
-0.0343845114,
-0.0333429165,
0.0372408703,
0.0093366876,
0.0061880867,
0.0223258808,
-0.0285206605,
-0.0213376489,
0.0500019528,
-0.0295322463,
-0.0076584979,
-0.0022763491,
-0.0251384489,
-0.0264954045,
0.0212939829,
0.0337071829,
0.0451641716,
-0.0060667256,
0.0213249419,
0.0303447731,
0.0018874391,
0.0148283783,
0.0084506916,
-0.0389943607,
0.0543835126,
0.0085723661,
0.0027992718,
-0.0061468021,
-0.0260729641,
-0.0044372631,
0.0292258952,
0.0317127258,
0.0034386197,
0.0219825637,
-0.0102035934,
-0.0426572114,
-0.028446367,
0.0243809167,
0.0054692468,
0.0434395671,
0.0276503284,
0.0235623717,
0.0569636971,
0.0005240326,
-0.0372261032,
0.0168633629,
-0.0641946271,
0.0228682552,
-0.0377888344,
-0.0241578799,
-0.0032554655,
0.0036031744,
-0.0319420695,
0.0235047098,
-0.088435851,
-0.0843541399,
0.0176178962,
0.031304244,
0.0223085284,
0.0381632447,
-0.0218561143,
-0.0707973614,
0.1169442087,
0.0527422428,
-0.0650532991,
0.0380250439,
0.0667939931,
-0.0713980719,
0.0059562074,
0.0305584259,
-0.0557367019,
0.0043149912,
0.071317859,
-0.0326018929,
-0.0261552241,
-0.0694156215,
-0.0233412925,
0.0177996531,
0.0610331595,
-0.0046118698,
0.0246260464,
-0.0179074705,
0.0530209988,
-0.0064302627,
0.0336015038,
-0.0385088585,
0.013395207,
0.0046386286,
-0.0241783839,
0.0254354309,
-0.005927518,
0.0792144164,
-0.026801765,
-0.0000607303,
0.0033933055,
-0.0025197582,
-0.0102830073,
0.0544731505,
0.0179681871,
-0.0211811438,
0.066474475,
0.0078777112,
0.0442066006,
-0.0161807444,
0.0114376647,
-0.0164610129,
0.0129119074,
-0.0141611276,
0.0710304976,
-0.0472942069,
-0.1487600356,
-0.0253159124,
0.0243733507,
-0.0005887891,
0.0740986913,
-0.0121118277,
-0.0336240679,
0.0008490242,
0.0052358126,
0.009494218,
-0.0420240834,
-0.055640433,
-0.0173001122,
-0.0159342308,
0.0330497399,
0.0446545668,
0.0622372739,
0.0531880632,
0.0128555307,
-0.0412643589,
-0.0055492357,
-0.049522236,
-0.0240224618,
0.0139123667,
0.0266908742,
-0.011632503,
-0.0180726163,
0.0257920176,
-0.0632933229,
-0.0111802612,
-0.0093142949,
0.0042387685,
-0.0079550156,
-0.0180345792,
0.0079027228,
0.0016365042,
-0.0383160636,
-0.0865990371,
-0.0111963861,
0.0182590876,
0.0125522083,
0.0075593102,
-5.824948095e-33,
-0.0139046665,
-0.0090412879,
-0.0121835265,
0.0306426007,
0.0182993319,
0.0553151034,
0.0177068058,
-0.0186753739,
0.0211331937,
-0.0343044922,
-0.0542055331,
0.042961292,
0.0346458852,
0.0350412689,
-0.0281397887,
-0.0282245297,
0.0396277532,
-0.0459248014,
-0.0198834762,
0.0531314313,
0.0393369459,
0.0346089117,
0.040184781,
-0.0240979455,
0.0157226007,
-0.0106440512,
-0.0407200232,
0.0129088536,
-0.0679722056,
0.0321351364,
-0.0432005152,
-0.0096969614,
-0.0187508557,
-0.0136378203,
-0.0379404798,
0.003809012,
-0.0358800367,
-0.0111479871,
-0.0290958211,
0.0219997279,
-0.018033104,
-0.0366364457,
0.0475772806,
-0.0345775411,
0.0102419714,
-0.0224672575,
-0.0113695152,
0.0455226563,
-0.036989674,
-0.0466835685,
0.0312720239,
-0.0042479276,
0.0358530656,
0.0348914154,
0.0740460902,
-0.0240740571,
-0.0055700191,
-0.0604174212,
-0.0569848828,
0.01417532,
0.0148720257,
-0.0003942491,
0.0370819122,
0.0360303186,
0.0122577846,
0.0364831537,
0.0738212094,
0.0087395189,
-0.024021754,
0.029059222,
-0.021426009,
0.0337179415,
-0.0033812583,
0.0298276562,
0.0091051012,
-0.0256050453,
-0.0115836468,
-0.0339911282,
-0.0091134394,
-0.0227048527,
0.0137397805,
0.015014532,
-0.0257312208,
-0.0013028991,
-0.0386191681,
-0.0483252332,
-0.0155339176,
0.0005012289,
-0.017158825,
0.0284528397,
-0.0279973429,
-0.0263359267,
0.0222732201,
-0.0397625864,
-0.0294604357,
-0.0082956273,
0.0898298994,
0.0032755404,
0.0131718433,
0.0130894519,
-0.0218907651,
0.0010840365,
-0.0281608421,
-0.0225144755,
0.0218482129,
0.0016680796,
0.068967931,
0.042714566,
-0.0538184196,
-0.013091255,
-0.0376346596,
0.0302272066,
0.0432698429,
0.0004697799,
0.0444527529,
-0.0450649112,
0.0156353377,
0.0148035511,
0.0134231132,
0.0397179052,
-0.020008821,
0.0217289068,
-0.0118104154,
0.0264953915,
0.0044233561,
-0.0070398939,
-0.0280913711,
0.0320208296,
0.0737835914,
-0.0166684128,
0.0191458985,
-0.0355008841,
2.656e-7,
-0.0413929559,
-0.0046736929,
-0.0160662681,
-0.0512496568,
0.0231435094,
0.0142694963,
0.0132740457,
0.0782113224,
-0.0121898362,
0.0175103582,
-0.0419797525,
0.0094349058,
0.0375288427,
0.0103959544,
-0.0543412678,
-0.0249206349,
-0.0290928148,
0.0366388448,
-0.0578345023,
-0.0465793908,
-0.0315616094,
0.056830354,
0.0495611541,
-0.0343066268,
0.021899974,
0.0045347647,
0.0120275021,
-0.0158551224,
-0.0241802279,
-0.024129374,
0.0590009242,
0.0883963779,
-0.0100881811,
-0.0502297245,
-0.0104101179,
0.0171661172,
-0.0765902922,
0.0712043494,
0.0224995185,
0.0324404165,
-0.0297438446,
-0.0530552939,
-0.0627233014,
0.0229294505,
0.0438402072,
0.0062141973,
-0.0143798832,
-0.0637590215,
0.0486342609,
-0.1084824055,
0.0485425405,
-0.0044278391,
0.0345682018,
0.0165425949,
-0.0109627582,
-0.017082911,
-0.0127311889,
-0.0772817284,
-0.0179913975,
-0.0270105992,
0.007614058,
-0.0397077277,
-0.0208253618,
0.0155484779,
-0.002600203,
-0.0006197288,
0.0411548465,
2.112634722e-34,
-0.0078017781,
-0.0325067304,
0.0245696343,
0.0089992685,
-0.0029280984,
-0.0351394713,
0.0352075323,
-0.0190046225,
0.0255359486,
-0.0301899128,
-0.0103258649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10974v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10974v1 | Towards Supporting Legal Argumentation with NLP: Is More Data Really All You Need? | 2024-06-16T15:15:44 | 2024-06-16T15:15:44 | T. Y. S. S Santosh, Kevin D. Ashley, Katie Atkinson, Matthias Grabmair | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Modeling legal reasoning and argumentation justifying decisions in cases has
always been central to AI & Law, yet contemporary developments in legal NLP
have increasingly focused on statistically classifying legal conclusions from
text. While conceptually simpler, these approaches often fall short in
providing usable justifications connecting to appropriate legal concepts. This
paper reviews both traditional symbolic works in AI & Law and recent advances
in legal NLP, and distills possibilities of integrating expert-informed
knowledge to strike a balance between scalability and explanation in symbolic
vs. data-driven approaches. We identify open challenges and discuss the
potential of modern NLP models and methods that integrate | [
0.0283518471,
0.0669137537,
-0.0045228098,
0.0154038593,
-0.0515405498,
0.0232691187,
0.0211273208,
0.0163729675,
-0.0094612148,
-0.0867041722,
0.0403120853,
0.0187865328,
-0.0181415305,
0.0012608012,
-0.0077693863,
-0.0764766932,
-0.0051541268,
0.0180098787,
0.0963663384,
-0.0068958909,
0.0431434661,
0.0434010327,
-0.0102518769,
0.0215459876,
-0.0323066041,
-0.0090696719,
-0.0001894118,
-0.020488197,
-0.0123152323,
-0.0102986703,
-0.0445936956,
0.0531811193,
0.0408922322,
-0.0015522247,
0.0000017372,
-0.0582046397,
0.0248524323,
0.0033883969,
-0.0315395147,
0.0031399312,
0.0063699074,
-0.0807157233,
0.0057814885,
-0.0166003052,
-0.0367919505,
0.0556573346,
0.0345784537,
0.0355409011,
0.0198934581,
0.0729022473,
-0.0073873755,
-0.0612934679,
0.0472108535,
-0.015298672,
-0.0153982006,
0.0063333511,
-0.0080043469,
0.045939479,
0.0409275554,
-0.0219177715,
0.0477782898,
0.0129119502,
0.0390201695,
-0.0457745828,
-0.0132136336,
-0.0029323287,
-0.0205859914,
-0.006152919,
-0.0125031397,
0.0339217819,
0.0531359725,
-0.068945244,
-0.0072320015,
-0.0188670512,
0.0340650417,
0.0511504672,
-0.0235279743,
0.092695497,
-0.0081806658,
0.0298960526,
0.0661147088,
0.0619357377,
0.0343700498,
0.0484809913,
-0.0290433429,
0.045333609,
-0.0340537354,
-0.0314948037,
0.0247403532,
-0.0025350312,
-0.008763806,
-0.0448641181,
0.0227273423,
0.0786343813,
0.0076788813,
0.0479439832,
-0.0200727824,
-0.0161014386,
0.0518595539,
-0.0562100001,
0.0524819344,
0.0091260336,
-0.0104336413,
0.0620181225,
-0.0425365157,
-0.0239160247,
0.0012379364,
0.0411125422,
0.0250014048,
-0.0498267673,
-0.0582072176,
-0.0498367064,
-0.0186436586,
0.0322187655,
-0.0855132714,
-0.0024946406,
0.0391402245,
-0.0077870791,
-0.0596481338,
0.0203669779,
0.0165687855,
0.0209137462,
0.023604922,
-0.0486055426,
-0.071418196,
-0.0705207586,
-0.0759541243,
0.0390802734,
0.0164742656,
-0.0101174973,
0.0271852054,
0.0023980571,
-0.0182047319,
-0.0015361299,
0.0026475689,
0.1105632558,
0.0109330183,
0.0057818615,
-0.0077402615,
-0.087499842,
-0.0224487185,
-0.0607978404,
-0.0473442338,
-0.047150325,
0.0241377801,
-0.0122577455,
-0.0037378175,
-0.0710395947,
0.0119189341,
0.0462814085,
0.0062965984,
0.0724608749,
-0.0576166883,
-0.0201915838,
-0.0515613072,
-0.003059333,
0.0090644481,
-0.0008910225,
0.0136565985,
-0.0248593893,
0.0127488319,
-0.0192543026,
0.0248824432,
-0.0285919309,
0.0130662117,
0.0168068893,
-0.0149122467,
0.014138788,
-0.0562998541,
0.0246741604,
-0.0121444389,
0.0407512859,
0.0007851768,
-0.0144676995,
-0.001479881,
0.0846699998,
0.0024492934,
0.0522975847,
0.03419213,
-0.0109875705,
0.0447104126,
-0.0073859622,
-0.0669672415,
0.0302026011,
-0.025683511,
-0.0119595025,
-0.0860657319,
0.0154780056,
0.0124138156,
-0.073409453,
-0.0046440437,
0.0109785032,
0.0072378251,
0.0072350935,
-0.0026540267,
0.0013358815,
0.0431176275,
0.0117341271,
0.0308273733,
-0.0272858422,
-0.0462430939,
-0.0072854636,
0.001310279,
0.0265491251,
0.0194731373,
-0.0324079245,
0.0106273219,
-0.0150422547,
-0.0144494297,
0.0499799699,
0.0269110911,
-0.0205084626,
-0.0198200922,
-0.0077730487,
-0.0207505468,
-0.006527863,
0.0473320186,
-0.0011342347,
-0.0050433362,
-0.021174673,
0.0326218233,
-0.0530780219,
-0.0172246732,
0.0424462631,
0.0022159969,
-0.0180699024,
-0.0003537893,
0.0098152375,
0.0381658673,
0.0616831109,
0.011486413,
0.0113385394,
0.0200044122,
-0.0024611398,
-0.0187002495,
0.044714801,
0.0163405165,
0.0092709158,
0.0633920953,
-0.0262423363,
-0.0231799539,
-0.0169964675,
-0.0394167304,
-0.0161134452,
-0.0294185299,
-0.0312532522,
0.0120369373,
-0.0305330548,
-0.0418618284,
0.0110300062,
-0.0258745011,
-0.0169438887,
0.0460235588,
0.0264630355,
-0.0468458347,
0.0195990652,
-0.0029674852,
0.0459907092,
-0.0147830863,
0.0139310276,
-0.0154067809,
-0.0112405205,
0.010406306,
0.022711562,
-0.0148702916,
-0.0151940016,
0.0037869357,
-0.034481395,
0.0052269087,
-0.0168703496,
-0.0039671347,
0.0135274883,
-0.0511989519,
0.0101459194,
-0.0055290926,
-0.0026302955,
-0.0220812391,
-0.0253000408,
-0.0125014558,
0.0468837321,
-0.0340625085,
-0.0217503123,
0.003052708,
-0.0253625773,
-0.0510470048,
0.0247391965,
0.0397317037,
-0.0083177257,
-0.0137210973,
0.0077944081,
-0.0210349001,
-0.0006299431,
-0.0144621413,
0.0285704918,
-0.0096058855,
0.0194755048,
-0.0538633056,
0.0263621211,
0.0249621216,
0.0167149864,
0.0145744123,
0.0298669655,
-0.0538305007,
-0.0096519738,
0.0071168593,
0.048511453,
-0.0427926891,
-0.014807825,
0.0181427207,
-0.0012065856,
-0.0158859193,
0.0091614258,
-0.0392444246,
0.0304350648,
-0.0061343368,
-0.0057160743,
-0.0134818628,
-0.0233796258,
-0.0122503629,
0.0664171353,
0.0222210959,
-0.0662088543,
0.0526149385,
0.0149598066,
0.0733335018,
-0.0433457345,
-0.0524609052,
-0.04935316,
0.0942869931,
-0.0230499599,
0.0098812701,
-0.0018721324,
-0.0110758571,
0.0302085523,
-0.0344134979,
0.050756488,
-0.0038482829,
0.0826702416,
-0.0473950729,
0.0576378442,
0.0065949885,
-0.0372204371,
0.0022363139,
-0.0277056918,
-0.049645707,
0.0381350815,
0.012133657,
-0.015540258,
0.0033124138,
-0.0226358902,
0.0126016969,
-0.0174696036,
0.0386541672,
-0.0120283207,
-0.0340608284,
0.0073669082,
-0.0221794304,
0.0021034705,
0.0208957251,
0.0252018627,
0.0061259838,
0.0072619058,
-0.0024220613,
-0.0037927937,
-0.0252437349,
0.0052981297,
-0.0245847926,
-0.0615608506,
-0.0097021135,
0.0347337276,
0.0184229091,
-0.0501146652,
0.0447032191,
0.0793845281,
0.0116268918,
0.0012202084,
0.0024169942,
0.0058265436,
-0.0225643236,
0.010146264,
0.0325283147,
-0.098173812,
-0.0049260515,
-0.0024757267,
-0.0343346521,
-0.0617780723,
-0.0213208254,
-0.0066013024,
-0.0775026008,
0.0616046675,
0.006892798,
0.0012691675,
-0.0287470371,
-0.0362956487,
-0.0045340732,
-0.0300995391,
-0.0125484793,
-0.0233414844,
-0.0288940854,
0.0130276103,
0.0429958813,
-0.046136979,
0.0129347267,
0.017928265,
-0.026661193,
0.067298755,
-0.0001817442,
0.057570383,
-0.033536531,
-0.0300598647,
-0.0068958993,
0.0012481483,
0.0305200629,
0.0126867462,
0.0251379032,
0.0132864146,
0.0281571615,
-0.0419492759,
0.0362300985,
-0.0380967148,
-0.0585783161,
0.0278201122,
0.0600791276,
-0.0609292015,
-0.0150546068,
-0.0460093804,
-0.0105173411,
-0.0326806828,
0.0517098196,
0.0094681792,
0.0416322276,
-0.0490305126,
-0.0436485372,
-0.0338229276,
-0.0377974138,
-0.0490833893,
-0.0109555507,
0.0183947813,
-0.0157714617,
-0.0186052416,
-0.0529865772,
-0.002366489,
0.0602138527,
0.0216018222,
0.0136580961,
0.0016892038,
-0.0210615378,
-0.0364326686,
0.0244148169,
-0.0377639644,
0.008484032,
0.0531671271,
0.0112168528,
-0.0228016358,
-0.0009217244,
0.0026701249,
-0.0246971156,
0.0363537595,
-0.0134138474,
-0.0271490496,
0.0064983093,
0.0224437509,
0.000288807,
-0.0381378643,
-0.0657729506,
0.0415638462,
0.0378511809,
-0.0090638129,
-0.030707743,
0.066342324,
-0.0130226454,
-0.0017501814,
0.0088440739,
0.0183100011,
0.0076403017,
-0.005857816,
0.0383755602,
-0.0645970553,
0.046728421,
0.0631412864,
0.0397196822,
-0.0071958387,
-0.0076309349,
-0.0545112714,
-0.0037047619,
-0.0395420268,
-0.0297223534,
-0.0274359342,
-0.0123200323,
0.0205931813,
0.0038933977,
-0.0177377313,
-0.0433719605,
0.017784873,
-0.024703091,
-0.0084367776,
-0.0060538794,
0.0419019572,
0.0524669364,
0.0017964086,
-0.0221698247,
-0.0219396278,
-0.0007779092,
0.0243723951,
-0.0412180647,
0.049397368,
-0.0032391828,
0.0311268046,
0.032029368,
-0.0204449315,
-0.0276746508,
-0.0009861011,
-0.0621994287,
-0.0534935929,
0.0228573922,
-0.0012564036,
0.0298104044,
-0.0095635038,
0.0006564992,
-0.0290816221,
-0.0078748325,
0.0294096041,
0.0449497961,
0.0332223736,
-0.0302462671,
0.0310066435,
0.0144262351,
-0.0199890938,
-0.0162311997,
-0.0124427872,
-0.0523418561,
0.028953759,
-0.0073687518,
-0.0084821954,
0.0044935234,
-0.0322097167,
-0.0123150134,
0.0375403054,
-0.016816996,
-0.0375329852,
-0.0956951454,
-0.0385546982,
-0.0351802073,
0.0134513211,
0.0080165137,
0.0278940815,
-0.0064751343,
0.0541437566,
0.0294962637,
-0.0102085955,
-0.0489501283,
0.0284423195,
-0.0228464995,
0.0092746159,
-0.0264727864,
-5.334140265e-33,
0.0005268891,
-0.048992373,
0.0150754116,
-0.010013002,
0.0096240565,
-0.0191430673,
-0.0207672045,
-0.0110502094,
-0.0355355665,
0.0770829171,
-0.0080183689,
0.0347801968,
0.0183486771,
-0.0292452089,
0.0192363206,
-0.0168039445,
-0.0269857105,
0.0314986408,
0.0006815416,
-0.0112868827,
0.0123705445,
-0.0453638621,
-0.0016034017,
-0.103354983,
0.0812957138,
0.0950886831,
-0.0207234509,
-0.0317373089,
-0.0707249343,
0.0371968895,
-0.0182963572,
0.0604582243,
0.0199780967,
-0.0238357913,
0.0180426203,
0.0394494981,
-0.058385171,
0.0123309717,
0.0305080414,
-0.0484831147,
-0.0079764593,
-0.036818739,
0.0097430125,
0.0177681614,
-0.0180072319,
0.0017184817,
0.0493401363,
-0.0482950471,
-0.0033142385,
-0.0825930163,
-0.0775516778,
0.0494738109,
-0.0419723578,
0.0418754108,
0.0199208967,
-0.0036012605,
-0.0013934135,
0.0198271424,
-0.0359622128,
-0.0159714911,
-0.009248239,
-0.0524703972,
0.0532223023,
-0.0924307257,
-0.0296410117,
0.0609862469,
0.0045879707,
-0.0017426681,
-0.0561908707,
0.0250888765,
0.010558771,
0.075992398,
0.065469712,
0.0336866826,
0.049621962,
0.0063294373,
-0.0482082143,
-0.0312485565,
0.0401566587,
0.0234589204,
0.0075370008,
-0.0138614159,
-0.0526586846,
0.0067774388,
-0.044427786,
-0.0686307102,
-0.0036729677,
-0.0119285053,
-0.0119130258,
0.0047544562,
0.0139672859,
0.0123434104,
-0.0443279967,
-0.0472193994,
0.0177175719,
0.0117016481,
0.0339286327,
-0.011338911,
-0.0164579451,
0.0122231236,
-0.0185877997,
-0.0330851115,
0.0123251947,
-0.0002943329,
0.0493991859,
-0.0087480443,
0.0591374449,
-0.018166991,
-0.0239002611,
-0.0149257723,
-0.0246960372,
-0.0112499781,
0.0308143813,
-0.0220491942,
0.0231125709,
0.0750408918,
0.031830404,
0.0302818753,
-0.0003130833,
-0.0197400004,
0.0043901443,
0.0094743622,
-0.0221769102,
-0.036176756,
0.0095111234,
-0.0083286399,
-0.0012776395,
0.0187438335,
0.0374448188,
0.0025303084,
0.0136042545,
0.0393937379,
2.37e-7,
0.0941183269,
0.0377359614,
0.0097564664,
-0.004008533,
-0.0286226999,
0.0137590207,
0.0271281376,
0.0050819032,
0.0116151199,
-0.0524987131,
-0.0018842452,
0.042480085,
0.0377922095,
0.0518392473,
-0.0218325704,
-0.0341939032,
-0.0250422452,
-0.0647324547,
-0.0509512909,
0.0733853355,
0.0845058113,
0.0603414588,
0.0428672545,
-0.0039619892,
-0.009868688,
-0.0216126535,
0.0235343762,
-0.0324507952,
0.0381349809,
-0.0269442853,
0.1003690511,
-0.0679326877,
0.031470146,
0.0376221724,
-0.0032576516,
0.0362006612,
-0.0610471666,
0.0419113971,
-0.0323843397,
0.048240196,
-0.0546675995,
-0.0850553364,
0.0376192108,
-0.0149338422,
0.051983241,
-0.0249389615,
-0.0318652391,
-0.0000783244,
-0.0642620176,
-0.0279345121,
-0.0024655617,
0.0326273255,
-0.0136131318,
-0.0157645922,
0.0109800156,
-0.0213048272,
0.0228322223,
-0.1167239249,
-0.0165312905,
0.0609139986,
0.0137005942,
0.0539908633,
0.0212018285,
-0.014769013,
0.0941893831,
-0.076667808,
0.0119694639,
1.769225068e-34,
0.0123283286,
0.0121637173,
0.0398217663,
0.0579233058,
0.0666339248,
0.0561999939,
-0.0228295811,
0.0029470667,
0.0374193639,
-0.0530194268,
0.0424217433
] |
Subsets and Splits